ads_id
stringlengths
4
8
arxiv_id
stringlengths
8
25
title
stringlengths
6
260
abstract
stringlengths
23
5.96k
embed
sequencelengths
1.54k
1.54k
umap_x
float32
2.23
17.3
umap_y
float32
-2.64
17.2
date
date32
cites
int64
0
10k
bibcode
stringlengths
19
19
keywords
sequencelengths
1
20
ads_keywords
sequencelengths
1
44
read_count
int64
0
633
doi
sequencelengths
1
3
authors
sequencelengths
1
1.38k
aff
sequencelengths
1
1.38k
cite_bibcodes
sequencelengths
1
10k
ref_bibcodes
sequencelengths
1
1.11k
29059620
2403.06859
Radial Tully-Fisher relation and the local variance of Hubble parameter
Utilizing the well-established Radial Tully-Fisher (RTF) relation observed in a 'large' (843) sample of local galaxies, we report the maximum allowed variance in the Hubble parameter, H<SUB>0</SUB>. We estimate the total intrinsic scatter in the magnitude of the RTF relation(s) implementing a cosmological model-independent cosmographic expansion. We find that the maximum allowed local 'radial' variation in our baseline analysis, using 4 RTF relations in the galaxy sample is $\Delta H_0/H_0\lesssim 3 \%$ at a $95\%$ C.L. significance. Which is implied form a constraint of $\Delta H_0/H_0= 0.54^{+1.32}_{-1.37} \%$ estimated at D<SUB>L</SUB> ~ 10 [Mpc]. Using only one 'best-constrained' radial bin we report a conservative $95\%$ C.L. limit of $\Delta H_0/H_0\lesssim 4 \%$. Through our estimate of maximum variation, we propose a novel method to validate several late-time/local modifications put forth to alleviate the H<SUB>0</SUB> tension. We find that within the range of the current galaxy sample redshift distribution 10 [Mpc] ≤ D<SUB>L</SUB> ≤ 140 [Mpc], it is highly unlikely to obtain a variation of $\Delta H_0/H_0\sim 9\%$, necessary to alleviate the H<SUB>0</SUB>-tension. However, we also elaborate on the possible alternative inferences when the innermost radial bin is included in the analysis. Alongside the primary analysis of fitting the individual RTF relations independently, we propose and perform a joint analysis of the RTF relations useful to create a pseudo-standardizable sample of galaxies. We also test for the spatial variation of H<SUB>0</SUB>, finding that the current samples' galaxies distributed only in the southern hemisphere support the null hypothesis of isotropy, within the allowed noise levels.
[ 0.016272714361548424, -0.013198146596550941, 0.05359247326850891, 0.002130950801074505, -0.032095491886138916, -0.010279806330800056, -0.014497963711619377, -0.035819970071315765, -0.012835697270929813, 0.03359528258442879, -0.028920939192175865, 0.03841960430145264, -0.05354247987270355, 0.013960539363324642, 0.018272433429956436, 0.05061789229512215, 0.005561719182878733, 0.00846131145954132, -0.021371997892856598, 0.039644431322813034, -0.006542831193655729, -0.025183962658047676, 0.0028449129313230515, 0.01383555680513382, -0.002118452452123165, -0.0318705253303051, 0.014210504479706287, 0.030045781284570694, 0.03591995686292648, -0.06424097716808319, 0.0015138499438762665, -0.02232186496257782, -0.01853489689528942, -0.014560455456376076, -0.04949304834008217, 0.11168431490659714, 0.003540127770975232, 0.03469512611627579, 0.008361325599253178, -0.013798062689602375, -0.021421991288661957, -0.001449015224352479, -0.013210644945502281, -0.004093175288289785, 0.007236483972519636, -0.03247043862938881, 0.0008451938047073781, -0.040144361555576324, 0.010798483155667782, -0.03347029909491539, -0.06574077159166336, -0.014260496944189072, 0.002830852521583438, -0.04391883313655853, -0.012335767969489098, 0.014985395595431328, 0.021384496241807938, 0.0048836893402040005, 0.018409915268421173, -0.005458608269691467, -0.022059401497244835, -0.019572250545024872, -0.005039917305111885, -0.023709170520305634, 0.013785564340651035, 0.029520854353904724, -0.011485886760056019, -0.027821093797683716, 0.03559499979019165, 0.04846819490194321, -0.023034265264868736, 0.012398258782923222, 0.015597810037434101, 0.004939931444823742, 0.032170481979846954, -0.020547114312648773, 0.01117968000471592, -0.0014255810528993607, -0.019809717312455177, -0.017697514966130257, 0.013748069293797016, 0.00801762379705906, -0.010548518970608711, -0.009004984982311726, -0.023171745240688324, -0.0017435051267966628, 0.03544502332806587, -0.012367012910544872, -0.02550891786813736, 0.005274259485304356, 0.037444740533828735, -0.03559499979019165, -0.01116093248128891, -0.01920980215072632, 0.0030933155212551355, -0.06784047186374664, -0.009079975076019764, -0.02654627151787281, 0.053942423313856125, 0.017110098153352737, 0.0170351080596447, 0.059691619127988815, 0.023234236985445023, -0.039619434624910355, 0.05304254963994026, 0.04336890950798988, 0.005458608269691467, 0.013460610061883926, 0.02657126821577549, 0.03179553523659706, 0.047543324530124664, 0.00212782621383667, -0.03766971081495285, 0.001576341106556356, -0.030170762911438942, -0.02183443307876587, -0.08513804525136948, 0.02440907247364521, -0.06479090452194214, 0.008929995819926262, 0.016097739338874817, -0.04021935164928436, 0.0518927127122879, 0.01542283408343792, 0.04474371671676636, -0.04564359039068222, -0.002360606100410223, -0.012292023748159409, -0.033645275980234146, 0.023159246891736984, 0.009629897773265839, 0.011354655027389526, 0.02500898763537407, 0.01084847655147314, -0.0456685870885849, 0.00651783449575305, 0.025746384635567665, -0.03232046216726303, 0.009811121970415115, -0.0025168340653181076, -0.018884848803281784, -0.0003454592952039093, 0.013335627503693104, -0.012935683131217957, 0.05259261280298233, 0.024734025821089745, -0.0424940325319767, 0.009073725901544094, 0.0217344481498003, 0.03671984374523163, -0.030920658260583878, 0.007286476902663708, -0.02440907247364521, -0.03359528258442879, 0.002830852521583438, -0.033795252442359924, 0.021097037941217422, 0.029495857656002045, -0.029395872727036476, -0.012485746294260025, -0.04511866346001625, 0.013860553503036499, -0.006817792542278767, -0.006842789240181446, 0.021946918219327927, 0.02064710110425949, -0.0007444267394021153, -0.027896082028746605, -0.08383822441101074, -0.05689201131463051, 0.017772505059838295, -0.007973880507051945, -0.01904732547700405, -0.059691619127988815, 0.05404241010546684, 0.04529364034533501, 0.00637722946703434, -0.0030355111230164766, -0.013735570944845676, 0.01696011796593666, -0.029920797795057297, 0.043843843042850494, 0.001406833645887673, -0.021471984684467316, -0.051842719316482544, 0.010242311283946037, 0.0003481932799331844, -0.011992066167294979, 0.01863488368690014, -0.04524364694952965, 0.012516992166638374, 0.03621991351246834, 0.014060525223612785, 0.029345879331231117, -0.03229546546936035, -0.015797780826687813, -0.001466981484554708, 0.039669428020715714, -0.02504648268222809, -0.01699761301279068, 0.015010392293334007, 0.0031479953322559595, 0.02767111361026764, -0.0744895413517952, -0.057091981172561646, -0.008405069820582867, 0.00799887627363205, 0.016085240989923477, -0.029045920819044113, -0.011404648423194885, 0.00043548570829443634, 0.02450905740261078, 0.004505617078393698, 0.02769611030817032, 0.0023387339897453785, 0.007099003065377474, -0.02807105891406536, 0.01459794957190752, 0.050717879086732864, 0.03594495356082916, -0.04634349048137665, 0.04674343764781952, 0.034295182675123215, 0.022146889939904213, -0.007611431181430817, -0.009836118668317795, 0.029095914214849472, -0.0074052102863788605, 0.0011420270893722773, 0.0002534800150897354, 0.04239404574036598, 0.00770516786724329, -0.03574497997760773, 0.023134252056479454, 0.0021293885074555874, 0.005749192554503679, 0.0001648206089157611, 0.0002642206964083016, -0.035819970071315765, -0.07983878999948502, -0.01541033573448658, 0.023696672171354294, 0.0019262919668108225, 0.013673080131411552, -0.03619491681456566, -0.015197865664958954, 0.007049010135233402, 0.011785845272243023, 0.04666844755411148, -0.04091925546526909, 0.012173290364444256, -0.010767238214612007, -0.015210364013910294, -0.08833759278059006, -0.05359247326850891, 0.01693512126803398, -0.04206909239292145, 0.028920939192175865, -0.03194551542401314, 0.01797247678041458, -0.04369386285543442, -0.029920797795057297, -0.03781968727707863, -0.01004858873784542, 0.004764955956488848, 0.03334531560540199, 0.020534615963697433, 0.008180101402103901, -0.0489681251347065, -0.0008959679398685694, 0.0008631600649096072, 0.028570987284183502, 0.0035807471722364426, -0.04191911220550537, -0.017272574827075005, 0.03304535895586014, 0.009804872795939445, 0.022721808403730392, 0.005005546845495701, -0.06254121661186218, 0.007867645472288132, 0.018672378733754158, 0.00018932888633571565, -0.007430206518620253, 0.008630038239061832, -0.00010584451229078695, -0.017385058104991913, 0.028895942494273186, -0.002691809553653002, -0.011617118492722511, 0.07823901623487473, -0.05359247326850891, 0.029545851051807404, -0.029420867562294006, -0.042694006115198135, -0.0020434630569070578, 0.031620558351278305, -0.03139559179544449, -0.024159107357263565, -0.004918059334158897, 0.007623929530382156, 0.023021766915917397, 0.05529223382472992, 0.018809858709573746, -0.0043775103986263275, 0.010704746469855309, 0.04666844755411148, -0.0017950604669749737, -0.02062210440635681, 0.06834040582180023, -0.01010483130812645, 0.04829321801662445, -0.04199410229921341, 0.04999297857284546, -0.04101923853158951, -0.006942775100469589, -0.01918480545282364, 0.050792865455150604, 0.0185598935931921, -0.005992908496409655, -0.030595703050494194, -0.08208847045898438, 0.004199410323053598, 0.01352310087531805, 0.023571690544486046, -0.057641904801130295, 0.0036213663406670094, -0.014372981153428555, 0.007586434483528137, 0.03936947137117386, 0.002357481513172388, 0.0011545253219082952, 0.06094144284725189, -0.01808496005833149, -0.039544448256492615, -0.04396882653236389, -0.013198146596550941, 0.06964021921157837, -0.030620699748396873, -0.01006733626127243, -0.011285915039479733, 0.0009381495183333755, 0.013498104177415371, -0.02169695310294628, 0.014535458758473396, 0.019759725779294968, 0.03831961750984192, 0.021996911615133286, 0.04831821471452713, 0.024571549147367477, -0.016810139641165733, 0.015497823245823383, 0.025458924472332, -0.015635304152965546, 0.03674484044313431, -0.006799045018851757, 0.0393194779753685, -0.04904311150312424, -0.025296447798609734, -0.03764471411705017, 0.016597669571638107, -0.006039776839315891, 0.03611992672085762, -0.04726836085319519, 0.03354528918862343, 0.016560174524784088, -0.008267588913440704, 0.013635585084557533, -0.018772363662719727, -0.05219266936182976, 0.015035388991236687, 0.006405350286513567, -0.028545990586280823, 0.00034995086025446653, -0.06539081782102585, -0.003088628873229027, 0.02874596230685711, 0.006961522623896599, 0.016797641292214394, -0.007248981855809689, 0.02333422377705574, 0.008055118843913078, 0.006355357356369495, -0.029395872727036476, 0.02809605374932289, 0.013285634107887745, -0.002130950801074505, -0.02279679849743843, -0.06124139949679375, 0.00731772230938077, -0.03037073463201523, 0.009679890237748623, 0.004811824299395084, 0.037494733929634094, 0.00045696707093156874, -0.02544642612338066, 0.03179553523659706, 0.08328830450773239, 0.04244403913617134, 0.06994017958641052, -0.020609606057405472, -0.041094228625297546, -0.05244263634085655, -0.017160089686512947, -0.04294396936893463, 0.039569444954395294, -0.023184243589639664, 0.07368965446949005, 0.024834012612700462, 0.015522819943726063, 0.013323129154741764, -0.05259261280298233, 0.02340921200811863, -0.025746384635567665, 0.016672657802700996, 0.04674343764781952, 0.012529490515589714, 0.026921220123767853, -0.0329703688621521, 0.04291897267103195, -0.017859991639852524, 0.006586574949324131, -0.000857692037243396, -0.016822637990117073, -0.019797218963503838, 0.02862098067998886, 0.013085662387311459, 0.024309085682034492, -0.014785423874855042, -0.0372447706758976, 0.0032839139457792044, 0.06764049828052521, 0.031195620074868202, 0.011692107655107975, -0.05414239689707756, 0.0058148084208369255, 0.048143237829208374, 0.0382196344435215, 0.05474231392145157, -0.006949024274945259, 0.06779047846794128, 0.006755301263183355, 0.0015583749627694488, -0.06589074432849884, 0.03984440490603447, 0.011242170818150043, 0.05379244685173035, 0.022659318521618843, 0.026846230030059814, 0.021421991288661957, -0.012429504655301571, 0.0045899804681539536, 0.0020965805742889643, -0.005774189252406359, -0.036819830536842346, -0.014110518619418144, 0.029845809563994408, -0.053842440247535706, 0.026696251705288887, -0.01641019620001316, 0.016160231083631516, 0.013723072595894337, -0.02709619514644146, 0.00801137462258339, -0.040594298392534256, 0.00929244514554739, -0.0073614660650491714, -0.009954852052032948, -0.0489681251347065, -0.01802246831357479, 0.011229673400521278, -0.03606993332505226, 0.05614211782813072, -0.0058304313570261, -0.005243013612926006, -0.021322006359696388, -0.008180101402103901, -0.03454514965415001, 0.043268922716379166, -0.01459794957190752, 0.07283977419137955, -0.01276695728302002, 0.0027105568442493677, -0.01087347324937582, 0.0573919415473938, 0.025596406310796738, -0.0037838437128812075, 0.03879455104470253, -0.016672657802700996, 0.010729743167757988, -0.030595703050494194, -0.04424378648400307, -0.03437017276883125, -0.012679469771683216, 0.03879455104470253, 0.011842086911201477, 0.004939931444823742, 0.011610869318246841, 0.002263744594529271, 0.01639769785106182, 0.0518927127122879, -0.00729897478595376, 0.04369386285543442, 0.035370033234357834, 0.012217034585773945, 0.0477432943880558, -0.005111782345920801, -0.058641765266656876, -0.0444437600672245, 0.04256902262568474, -0.043818846344947815, 0.07363966107368469, 0.002609008690342307, 0.005427362862974405, 0.013410616666078568, 0.007067757658660412, -0.020934559404850006, 0.017072603106498718, 0.005908545106649399, -0.03277039900422096, -0.008173852227628231, -0.027796097099781036, -0.015760287642478943, 0.038444600999355316, -0.011298413388431072, -0.006164759397506714, -0.001554469228722155, -0.11538379639387131, -0.02972082607448101, -0.020022187381982803, 0.01164836436510086, -0.011279665865004063, -0.016222720965743065, 0.0012779455864802003, 0.0015052573289722204, -0.03524504974484444, -0.014173009432852268, -0.016972616314888, 0.0034088962711393833, -0.0286959707736969, 0.010992206633090973, -0.008161353878676891, 0.0004237686225678772, 0.022096896544098854, 0.023096757009625435, 0.00701151555404067, -0.0055992137640714645, 0.02769611030817032, 0.05194270610809326, 0.01277945563197136, 0.04624350741505623, -0.021434489637613297, -0.010692248120903969, 0.023146750405430794, -0.026696251705288887, 0.0029464613180607557, 0.03574497997760773, -0.0027230551932007074, 0.016060244292020798, 0.005064913537353277, -0.0042244065552949905, 0.016685156151652336, 0.01354809757322073, 0.030070777982473373, -0.016160231083631516, -0.033720266073942184, -0.01643519289791584, -0.004127545282244682, -0.03859458118677139, 0.01797247678041458, -0.006799045018851757, 0.01594776101410389, 0.008617539890110493, -0.03147058188915253, 0.003537003183737397, 0.01602274924516678, 0.02977081947028637, 0.009348686784505844, 0.034820109605789185, -0.038544587790966034, -0.016360202804207802, 0.019784722477197647, 0.019997192546725273, 0.014972897246479988, -0.008355076424777508, -0.03452015295624733, 0.00224812189117074, 0.016360202804207802, -0.021609464660286903, 0.007342719007283449, 0.004855568055063486, 0.015685297548770905, 0.014073023572564125, 0.030920658260583878, -0.03542002663016319, 0.022446848452091217, 0.006374104879796505, 0.035345036536455154, -0.005574217066168785, 0.010748490691184998, -0.004905560985207558, -0.010804732330143452, 0.0006362387794069946, -0.0270462017506361, -0.039619434624910355, -0.005855427589267492, 0.012267027050256729, 0.0049118101596832275, -0.020572111010551453, -0.02437157742679119, -0.013773065991699696, 0.014472967945039272, 0.00044993680785410106, -0.023059261962771416, -0.020297149196267128, 0.034820109605789185, -0.016610167920589447, -0.005636708345264196, 0.03621991351246834, 0.014435472898185253, -0.02872096747159958, -0.003343280404806137, -0.01918480545282364, -0.03144558519124985, 0.02288428694009781, 0.0004733710375148803, 0.004155666567385197, -0.007123999763280153, 0.026671255007386208, -0.0030667567625641823, 0.0029870804864913225, -0.01688512973487377, 0.021534476429224014, -0.02487150765955448, 0.007280227728188038, 0.016585171222686768, -0.0009811122436076403, 0.022109394893050194, -0.038469597697257996, -0.05644207447767258, 0.05854177847504616, 0.03132060170173645, 0.037469737231731415, -0.032195478677749634, -0.008417568169534206, -0.014048026874661446, 0.013685578480362892, 0.006005406845360994, -0.047543324530124664, -0.02493399940431118, 0.010517273098230362, -0.015835275873541832, -0.0005592964589595795, 0.04731835424900055, 0.014497963711619377, -0.01117968000471592, 0.018697373569011688, 0.012923184782266617, -0.03189552202820778, -0.008342578075826168, 0.011904578655958176, 0.017772505059838295, -0.010267307981848717, -0.01692262291908264, -0.0025777630507946014, -0.006380354054272175, 0.005136778578162193, 0.012523241341114044, 0.0164226945489645, 0.0202096626162529, 0.04389383643865585, -0.0028745962772518396, 0.009554908610880375, 0.009661143645644188, -0.015685297548770905, -0.007936385460197926, 0.010504774749279022, -0.029320882633328438, -0.03599494695663452, 0.019522259011864662, 0.013698076829314232, 0.00731772230938077, -0.003124561160802841, -0.03194551542401314, -0.031170623376965523, 0.04414379969239235, 0.01431049033999443, 0.005174273159354925, -0.011760848574340343, 0.0075426907278597355, -0.013173149898648262, -0.000055900352890603244, 0.02079707942903042, -0.01514787320047617, -0.002894905861467123, -0.00821759644895792, -0.030670693144202232, -0.010617258958518505, 0.021434489637613297, -0.05239264294505119, 0.045968543738126755, 0.02013467252254486, -0.012935683131217957, -0.03347029909491539, -0.026346299797296524, -0.017110098153352737, -0.004180662799626589, -0.003346404992043972, 0.03666985034942627, -0.02223437838256359, 0.030595703050494194, 0.018172448500990868, -0.00731772230938077, -0.009948602877557278, -0.0013177837245166302, -0.01192332524806261, 0.033245332539081573, 0.004024434834718704, -0.03971942141652107, -0.00878001656383276, -0.00022457783052232116, -0.03457014635205269, -0.030620699748396873, 0.01813495345413685, 0.03826962411403656, -0.023571690544486046, -0.01593526266515255, 0.006305364426225424, -0.027221176773309708, -0.006114766467362642, 0.016747647896409035, 0.009173711761832237, 0.008848757483065128, -0.017360061407089233, 0.012998174875974655, 0.01744754984974861, 0.020497120916843414, 0.017085101455450058, 0.002343420870602131, 0.04564359039068222, 0.03339530900120735, -0.007767659146338701, 0.011885831132531166, 0.00014324160292744637, 0.014397977851331234, 0.01306066568940878, 0.033195339143276215, -0.02647128328680992, -0.026721248403191566, 0.015560314990580082, 0.013023171573877335, 0.010161072947084904, 0.005164899863302708, -0.008755020797252655, 0.02495899423956871, 0.005946040153503418, 0.019847212359309196, -0.001481823157519102, 0.015485325828194618, 0.04999297857284546, 0.028795955702662468, 0.03861957788467407, 0.007992628030478954, 0.005880424287170172, -0.022484341636300087, -0.0057835630141198635, -0.05349248647689819, -0.009342437610030174, 0.0076176803559064865, -0.035819970071315765, 0.014960398897528648, 0.03019575960934162, 0.006730305030941963, 0.0030964401084929705, 0.02872096747159958, 0.0033932735677808523, 0.01116718165576458, -0.01512287650257349, -0.0016341455047950149, -0.0061053927056491375, -0.014735430479049683, -0.010929714888334274, 0.011504634283483028, -0.012004564516246319, -0.018272433429956436, -0.008730024099349976, -0.01812245510518551, -0.006955273449420929, 0.01706010475754738, 0.018272433429956436, -0.012160792015492916, 0.019947199150919914, -0.006058524362742901, 0.003073005937039852, -0.014247999526560307, 0.05369246006011963, 0.0050961594097316265, -0.09748630970716476, 0.04834321141242981, 0.02489650435745716, 0.011310911737382412, 0.04899311810731888, 0.027421148493885994, 0.0018013095250353217, 0.033820249140262604, 0.002888656919822097, 0.015272854827344418, -0.024009129032492638, -0.001209205249324441, -0.02929588593542576, 0.0037588472478091717, -0.00045306136598810554, -0.03274540230631828, -0.012554487213492393, 0.013085662387311459, -0.00960490107536316, 0.006055399775505066, -0.027721107006072998, 0.038544587790966034, 0.02277180179953575, 0.006861536297947168, 0.01908482052385807, 0.001712259603664279, -0.014660441316664219, -0.027871085330843925, 0.01587277092039585, -0.016635164618492126, -0.014085521921515465, -0.00074716069502756, -0.03229546546936035, 0.05294256657361984, -0.011229673400521278, -0.05204269289970398, -0.013635585084557533, 0.027221176773309708, -0.04096924513578415, 0.026446286588907242, -0.006567827891558409, -0.04396882653236389, 0.017072603106498718, 0.011342157609760761, 0.03224547207355499, 0.0029167779721319675, 0.0008756582974456251, 0.021434489637613297, 0.0070052663795650005, 0.0015794656937941909, -0.0004300177388358861, 0.028321022167801857, 0.010042339563369751, 0.00771141704171896, -0.002758987480774522, -0.008436315692961216, 0.018697373569011688, 0.007555189076811075, -0.027471141889691353, -0.0017325691878795624, -0.01808496005833149, -0.01005483791232109, 0.01243575382977724, -0.02752113528549671, -0.0540924035012722, -0.007186490576714277, -0.04926808178424835, 0.018409915268421173, -0.007498946972191334, -0.01601025089621544, -0.0015724354889243841, 0.017410054802894592, 0.011823339387774467, 0.0042275311425328255, -0.0045931050553917885, -0.00019206287106499076, -0.0038932033348828554, 0.005011796019971371, -0.04671844094991684, -0.006405350286513567, 0.004627475049346685, -0.03789467737078667, 0.012198287062346935, -0.007455203216522932, -0.010542269796133041, 0.0270462017506361, 0.007780157495290041, -0.017272574827075005, -0.030545709654688835, 0.014922904781997204, 0.0036088682245463133, 0.01243575382977724, 0.02543392777442932, 0.008242592215538025, 0.0012896626722067595, -0.020034685730934143, 0.019972195848822594, -0.04084426537156105, -0.006661564577370882, -0.012685718946158886, -0.024759022518992424, -0.007280227728188038, -0.00691777840256691, -0.03991939499974251, 0.009054978378117085, -0.0024746523704379797, 0.015810279175639153, -0.013335627503693104, 0.01603524759411812, 0.03137059509754181, 0.0052805086597800255, 0.025308946147561073, -0.016060244292020798, -0.0063209873624145985, 0.04559359699487686, 0.010304803028702736, -0.008954992517828941, -0.023709170520305634, 0.008311333134770393, 0.017135092988610268, 0.031245611608028412, 0.004211908672004938, 0.01354809757322073, -0.011585872620344162, -0.01800996996462345, 0.0028292902279645205, -0.014910406433045864, -0.014285493642091751, -0.02450905740261078, 0.03279539570212364, 0.014785423874855042, -0.012235782109200954, 0.014810420572757721, 0.009948602877557278, 0.0007952008163556457, -0.008055118843913078, 0.016172729432582855, 0.02917090430855751, -0.008417568169534206, 0.01696011796593666, -0.007461452390998602, 0.0302207563072443, -0.011479637585580349, 0.01511037815362215, 0.00542423827573657, 0.02814604714512825, -0.014897908084094524, -0.02495899423956871, 0.03811964765191078, 0.013173149898648262, 0.007792655844241381, -0.001670078025199473, -0.006955273449420929, 0.0005182866007089615, -0.010592262260615826, -0.005777313839644194, 0.04639348387718201, 0.0013373121619224548, -0.037469737231731415, 0.03384524583816528, 0.0031964262016117573, 0.04131919890642166, -0.00139746000058949, -0.020572111010551453, 0.028970930725336075, 0.0006647504051215947, -0.005014920607209206, 0.008923746645450592, 0.00769891869276762, 0.00932994019240141, -0.01276695728302002, -0.06819042563438416, -0.0014552643988281488, 0.004858692642301321, 0.014897908084094524, 0.020309647545218468, -0.03571998327970505, 0.01584777422249317, 0.02489650435745716, 0.018859852105379105, 0.022184384986758232, -0.02172194980084896, -0.00183099287096411, -0.006730305030941963, 0.026446286588907242, -0.007217736449092627, -0.02919589914381504, 0.00291521567851305, 0.034295182675123215, 0.01542283408343792, -0.021884426474571228, 0.035894960165023804, -0.0001184403954539448, 0.045893553644418716, 0.019772224128246307, 0.005111782345920801, -0.044393766671419144, 0.009761129505932331, -0.004855568055063486, -0.0013529349816963077, -0.013623086735606194, 0.005121155641973019, -0.004427503328770399, -0.036944810301065445, 0.01166711188852787, -0.00439000828191638, -0.00480245053768158, -0.02025965414941311, -0.014098020270466805, -0.026796236634254456, 0.017859991639852524, 0.017385058104991913, 0.02397163398563862, -0.010186069644987583, 0.05844179168343544, -0.04336890950798988, 0.04951804503798485, -0.018209943547844887, -0.054942283779382706, -0.02022216096520424, 0.02754613198339939, -0.054992277175188065, 0.025721387937664986, 0.03129560500383377, -0.0009069038787856698, 0.04821822792291641, 0.004464997909963131, -0.0037900926545262337, 0.01854739524424076, -0.009073725901544094, -0.00463684881106019, -0.008148855529725552, -0.004893062636256218, -0.0018934841500595212, -0.04471872001886368, -0.030570706352591515, 0.004168164450675249, 0.0046243504621088505, -0.03027074970304966, -0.0011349968845024705, 0.036969806998968124, -0.038444600999355316, -0.00439000828191638, -0.004133794456720352, -0.012798203155398369, 0.0073614660650491714, 0.01224827952682972, -0.04309394955635071, 0.004608727991580963, -0.016735149547457695, -0.001963786780834198, -0.001576341106556356, -0.013685578480362892, 0.010342298075556755, -0.00932369101792574, 0.01863488368690014, -0.015660300850868225, 0.021621963009238243, 0.013748069293797016, 0.00112406094558537, -0.025358939543366432, -0.01087347324937582, -0.015572813339531422, -0.0044868700206279755, 0.01542283408343792, -0.002630880568176508, -0.026321303099393845, -0.006492838263511658, 0.018947338685393333, -0.00928619597107172, 0.005102408584207296, -0.017884988337755203, 0.039519451558589935, 0.017210083082318306, -0.029370876029133797, -0.00311518763191998, 0.02599634975194931, 0.018859852105379105, -0.005752317141741514, 0.07378964126110077, -0.030995646491646767, -0.03289537876844406, -0.01858489029109478, -0.017235079780220985, 0.0017481920076534152, -0.01968473568558693, 0.003643238451331854, -0.024121612310409546, 0.023509198799729347, 0.0233217254281044, -0.03224547207355499, -0.025646397843956947, 0.01751004159450531, 0.016572672873735428, 0.018859852105379105, -0.025921359658241272, 0.020534615963697433, 0.0003425300237722695, -0.026896223425865173, 0.004499368369579315, -0.004746208433061838, -0.026371296495199203, 0.01542283408343792, -0.060241539031267166, -0.001470106071792543, 0.013423115015029907, -0.02227187156677246, -0.010654754005372524, -0.03202050179243088, -0.012973178178071976, 0.04174413904547691, -0.010261058807373047, 0.013485605828464031, -0.0003868597268592566, 0.01403552945703268, -0.011542129330337048, -0.023996630683541298, 0.006283492781221867, -0.00480245053768158, 0.025921359658241272, -0.02383415214717388, 0.012410757131874561, 0.020022187381982803, 0.0007674703374505043, -0.030620699748396873, -0.007024013437330723, -0.011717104353010654, 0.0008920622058212757, 0.0014294867869466543, 0.01652267947793007, -0.016872631385922432, 0.04309394955635071, 0.034270185977220535, -0.02335922047495842, -0.0074364556930959225, 0.014085521921515465, 0.04351888969540596, -0.0035713734105229378, 0.02702120505273342, 0.018759865313768387, 0.014897908084094524, 0.007049010135233402, -0.031595561653375626, -0.0006655315519310534, -0.01164211519062519, 0.02124701626598835, -0.019747227430343628, 0.009561157785356045, -0.03596995025873184, -0.0038775803986936808, 0.07298974692821503, -0.025646397843956947, -0.001191238989122212, 0.019384777173399925, 0.013423115015029907, 0.019359780475497246, 0.010479778051376343, 0.017122594639658928, 0.029320882633328438, -0.0016919499030336738, -0.00932369101792574, 0.00310893845744431, -0.03811964765191078, 0.024746524170041084, 0.019572250545024872, 0.0007276321994140744, -0.011898329481482506, 0.019759725779294968, -0.014272995293140411, 0.019872209057211876, 0.019484763965010643, -0.017360061407089233, -0.014960398897528648, 0.013910546898841858, 0.0028839700389653444, -0.00897998921573162, 0.004608727991580963, -0.0019169183215126395, 0.00439625745639205, 0.016835136339068413, -0.01009233295917511, 0.018447410315275192, -0.0130356689915061, -0.002412161324173212, -0.03941946476697922, -0.017422553151845932, 0.022496839985251427, 0.026671255007386208, 0.02178444154560566, -0.024196602404117584, 0.036994803696870804, -0.016560174524784088, 0.005905420519411564, -0.001882548094727099, -0.033795252442359924, 0.006436596158891916, -0.022146889939904213, 0.03499508649110794, 0.019947199150919914, -0.0028324148152023554, 0.006830290891230106, -0.01909731887280941, -0.005114906933158636, 0.0054929787293076515, -0.008717525750398636, 0.01962224394083023, 0.058091841638088226, 0.019284792244434357, 0.0292458925396204, 0.00661782082170248, 0.007180241867899895, -0.02068459615111351, -0.026846230030059814, 0.02814604714512825, -0.002252808539196849, -0.0415191687643528, -0.005852303002029657, 0.03299536556005478, -0.037519730627536774, -0.027821093797683716, -0.004768080543726683, -0.011485886760056019, -0.014985395595431328, -0.007105252239853144, -0.028895942494273186, 0.00409629987552762, -0.05514225736260414, 0.039494454860687256, -0.01963474228978157, 0.011273416690528393, 0.007161494344472885, -0.010236062109470367, -0.018934840336441994, 0.025283949449658394, -0.034845106303691864, 0.0018778613302856684, 0.03781968727707863, 0.0024480936117470264, -0.027171185240149498, 0.030695689842104912, -0.012073304504156113, 0.003836961230263114, 0.0016997612547129393, 0.004843069706112146, 0.007136497646570206, 0.002833977108821273, 0.01907232217490673, 0.008742522448301315, 0.015372841618955135, 0.027346160262823105, -0.0068240417167544365, 0.015610307455062866, 0.015635304152965546, -0.009923606179654598, 0.018997332081198692, 0.005299255717545748, 0.014210504479706287, -0.04449375346302986, 0.01593526266515255, -0.017884988337755203, 0.026446286588907242, 0.021471984684467316, 0.027396153658628464, 0.021934419870376587, -0.0008709714165888727, 0.015210364013910294, 0.005446110386401415, -0.0034026470966637135, -0.006849038414657116, -0.022396855056285858, 0.031670551747083664, -0.01114843413233757, 0.027846090495586395, 0.006805294193327427, -0.03084566816687584, -0.017934981733560562, -0.009454921819269657, -0.00318861473351717, 0.0014255810528993607, 0.006499087437987328, -0.021409492939710617, 0.01812245510518551, 0.019822215661406517, 0.016285212710499763, 0.0340702161192894, 0.002215313958004117, 0.0026168199256062508, -0.03172054514288902, 0.029620841145515442, -0.02819604054093361, 0.03829462081193924, -0.019297290593385696, -0.0015661863144487143, -0.03726976737380028, 0.0025480797048658133, -0.01908482052385807, 0.0015599371399730444, 0.014435472898185253, 0.02819604054093361, -0.005011796019971371, -0.03766971081495285, 0.00621787691488862, 0.006039776839315891, 0.0058179330080747604, -0.0164226945489645, 0.0014951025368645787, -0.05159275606274605, -0.028795955702662468, -0.008448813110589981, 0.03564499318599701, -0.004208784084767103, -0.00030679284827783704, -0.011548378504812717, 0.03981940820813179, 0.0540924035012722, -0.04844319820404053, 0.004018185660243034, -0.01509787980467081, -0.01514787320047617, 0.008423817344009876, -0.009748631156980991, -0.05624210089445114, 0.012342017143964767, -0.01271696388721466, -0.016122736036777496, -0.04826822131872177, 0.004918059334158897, -0.01915980875492096, -0.01746004819869995, 0.025921359658241272, 0.006730305030941963, -0.05754191800951958, -0.005349248647689819, 0.02819604054093361, -0.0005206300411373377, -0.0023277981672436, 0.006264745257794857, 0.015647802501916885, 0.03444516286253929, -0.025396432727575302, 0.007105252239853144, 0.009723634459078312, 0.03469512611627579, 0.024209100753068924, 0.012104550376534462, 0.06334110349416733, 0.010785985738039017, -0.01593526266515255, -0.01692262291908264, 0.0005952289211563766, 0.015685297548770905, -0.0164226945489645, 0.029595844447612762, -0.01117343083024025, 0.0006374104996211827, -0.012591981329023838, -0.004830571822822094, 0.015710294246673584, -0.005289881955832243, 0.01277320645749569, 0.0013138779904693365, -0.028396012261509895, 0.006014780141413212, 0.0031229988671839237, 0.009011234156787395, 0.004971176851540804, -0.012935683131217957, 0.03302036225795746, -0.011535880155861378, -0.010504774749279022, 0.02812105044722557, 0.01954725570976734, -0.027471141889691353, 0.014510462060570717, 0.011842086911201477, -0.015485325828194618, 0.02063460275530815, 0.01699761301279068, -0.0001604266872163862, 0.02018466591835022, -0.02612133137881756, -0.0445687398314476, 0.00929869432002306, -0.023259233683347702, -0.0013998034410178661, 0.011092192493379116, -0.036894820630550385, 0.02168445475399494, -0.04096924513578415, -0.0031026892829686403, -0.0012138920137658715, -0.022571830078959465, 0.014135515317320824, -0.010623508132994175, 0.008748771622776985, 0.04709338769316673, 0.039569444954395294, 0.016260216012597084, -0.022459346801042557, -0.00771141704171896, -0.0318705253303051, -0.008630038239061832, 0.009473669342696667, -0.024696532636880875, 0.007173992693424225, -0.037394747138023376, 0.013223143294453621, -0.051292795687913895, -0.00847380980849266, 0.046968404203653336, 0.011573375202715397, -0.00020114362996537238, 0.004530613776296377, -0.006064773537218571, 0.022584328427910805, 0.012554487213492393, 0.006830290891230106, -0.005627334583550692, -0.012054556980729103, 0.0003899842849932611, 0.017897486686706543, -0.012660722248256207, 0.019572250545024872, -0.006936525925993919, 0.02127201296389103, 0.01649768278002739, 0.007473950274288654, -0.0372447706758976, 0.013223143294453621, -0.0013833994744345546, 0.02494649589061737, 0.009654894471168518, 0.03469512611627579, -0.027896082028746605, -0.03884454444050789, 0.015522819943726063, -0.008486308157444, 0.005614836700260639, 0.017884988337755203, 0.02817104384303093, 0.014735430479049683, 0.01591026596724987, 0.011723353527486324, -0.01543533243238926, -0.009048729203641415, 0.004015061073005199, 0.006492838263511658, 0.007936385460197926, 0.006599073298275471, -0.007642676588147879, 0.0001059421556419693, 0.017635023221373558, -0.03134559839963913, -0.006164759397506714, -0.0037807191256433725, -0.005164899863302708, -0.018884848803281784, -0.0004979769582860172, -0.010717244818806648, -0.013360624201595783, 0.01962224394083023, 0.017272574827075005, 0.022946776822209358, 0.020409634336829185, -0.020922061055898666, 0.033145345747470856, -0.014085521921515465, 0.03444516286253929, 0.007123999763280153, -0.006949024274945259, -0.004718087613582611, -0.001721633248962462, 0.017122594639658928, 0.009929855354130268, 0.03941946476697922, -0.008086364716291428, 0.00163102091755718, 0.0012709152651950717, 0.004761831369251013, 0.018734868615865707, 0.04734335094690323, -0.011348406784236431, 0.03027074970304966, 0.018384918570518494, -0.00008470490138279274, -0.00015583749336656183, 0.020022187381982803, 0.014522960409522057, -0.013498104177415371, -0.03816964104771614, 0.009348686784505844, -0.0074677010998129845, 0.004833696410059929, -0.03439516946673393, -0.01649768278002739, -0.0007018545875325799, 0.007117750588804483, -0.03487010300159454, -0.0033995225094258785, -0.016122736036777496, -0.011754599399864674, 0.02439657412469387, -0.007217736449092627, -0.021471984684467316, 0.026921220123767853, -0.004611852578818798, 0.014460469596087933, -0.011317160911858082, -0.0023199866991490126, -0.008061368018388748, 0.0006284273695200682, 0.011335908435285091, -0.0132481399923563, 0.010017342865467072, 0.0027496139518916607, 0.015360343270003796, 0.011879581958055496, 0.022521836683154106, -0.00008514429646311328, -0.01654767617583275, 0.03666985034942627, 0.01918480545282364, -0.009029981680214405, 0.006774048786610365, -0.015035388991236687, -0.0307706780731678, -0.0004487651167437434, -0.0035838717594742775, 0.01357309427112341, -0.010617258958518505, 0.009379932656884193, 0.0011521819978952408, -0.006295990664511919, -0.02448406256735325, 0.004221282433718443, 0.020297149196267128, -0.007923887111246586, 0.021484483033418655, 0.007092753890901804 ]
11.629413
1.611449
2024-06-01
0
2024MNRAS.tmp.1442H
[ "local galaxies", "H<SUB>0</SUB", "maximum variation", "RTF", "galaxies", "the current galaxy sample redshift distribution", "the individual RTF relations", "\\Delta H_0/", "bin", "the RTF relations" ]
[ "(cosmology:) dark matter", "cosmological parameters", "galaxies: distances and redshifts", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
10
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1467", "10.48550/arXiv.2403.06859" ]
[ "Haridasu, Balakrishna S.", "Salucci, Paolo", "Sharma, Gauri" ]
[ "SISSA-International School for Advanced Studies, Via Bonomea 265, 34136 Trieste, Italy; INFN, Sezione di Trieste, Via Valerio 2, I-34127 Trieste, Italy; IFPU, Institute for Fundamental Physics of the Universe, via Beirut 2, 34151 Trieste, Italy", "SISSA-International School for Advanced Studies, Via Bonomea 265, 34136 Trieste, Italy; INFN, Sezione di Trieste, Via Valerio 2, I-34127 Trieste, Italy", "SISSA-International School for Advanced Studies, Via Bonomea 265, 34136 Trieste, Italy; INFN, Sezione di Trieste, Via Valerio 2, I-34127 Trieste, Italy; IFPU, Institute for Fundamental Physics of the Universe, via Beirut 2, 34151 Trieste, Italy; University of Strasbourg, CNRS UMR 7550, Observatoire astronomique de Strasbourg, F-67000 Strasbourg, France; University of Strasbourg Institute for Advanced Study, 5 allée du Général Rouvillois, F-67083 Strasbourg, France; Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of the Western Cape, Cape Town 7535, South Africa" ]
null
[ "1992ApJS...81..413M", "1993MNRAS.262..392S", "1996MNRAS.281...27P", "1997AJ....114.2402C", "2000ApJ...537L...9S", "2007MNRAS.377..507Y", "2008IAUS..244...53S", "2013ApJ...775...62K", "2014MNRAS.437.2146W", "2014PhRvD..89d3007M", "2016ApJ...826...56R", "2016PhRvD..94j3523K", "2017AAS...23031405H", "2017MNRAS.465.4703K", "2017MNRAS.465.4914B", "2017PhLB..774..317S", "2017PhRvD..96d3520Z", "2018ApJ...853..119A", "2018ApJ...853..126R", "2018ApJ...855..136R", "2018JCAP...10..015H", "2019A&ARv..27....2S", "2019ApJ...875..145K", "2019ApJ...882...34F", "2019ApJ...886...61Y", "2019MNRAS.482.3497Z", "2019MNRAS.484L..64S", "2019MNRAS.488.5127F", "2019MNRAS.490.1743C", "2019NatAs...3..891V", "2019PhRvD..99j3526K", "2019PhRvD..99l1302V", "2019PhRvD.100d3537D", "2019Sci...365.1134J", "2020AJ....160...71S", "2020ApJ...889....5H", "2020ApJ...891L...1P", "2020ApJ...896....3K", "2020ApJ...900..160L", "2020ApJ...901..153D", "2020JCAP...06..005B", "2020MNRAS.494.6072S", "2020MNRAS.495.2630C", "2020MNRAS.496.3402D", "2020MNRAS.497.1757H", "2020MNRAS.498.1420W", "2020NatRP...2...10R", "2020PhRvD.101d3533K", "2020PhRvD.101f3528A", "2020PhRvD.101j3517B", "2020PhRvD.101l3505K", "2020PhRvD.102b3007D", "2021A&ARv..29....9S", "2021ApJ...908L...5S", "2021ApJ...908L...6R", "2021ApJ...911...65B", "2021ApJ...919...16F", "2021CmPhy...4..123J", "2021JCAP...08..027B", "2021MNRAS.503.1753S", "2021MNRAS.505.3135A", "2021PhRvD.103c5025A", "2021PhRvD.103d1303N", "2021PhRvD.103f3539H", "2021PhRvD.103h3517A", "2021PhRvD.103j3509K", "2021PhRvD.103j3533B", "2021PhRvD.103j3537N", "2021PhRvD.104b1303M", "2022ApJS..262...33S", "2022JHEAp..34...49A", "2022MNRAS.511.6160K", "2022PhRvD.105b3526D", "2022PhRvD.105f3538A", "2023ApJ...946L..49L", "2023ApJ...959...83L", "2023MNRAS.520.5110P", "2023MNRAS.521.4963D", "2023PhRvL.130p1003L", "2023Univ....9...94H", "2023Univ....9..393V", "2024A&A...682A..37T", "2024PhRvD.109b3525G", "2024PhRvD.109b3527A" ]
28584849
2310.16884
Atomic hydrogen shows its true colours: correlations between H I and galaxy colour in simulations
Intensity mapping experiments are beginning to measure the spatial distribution of neutral atomic hydrogen H I to constrain cosmological parameters and the large-scale distribution of matter. However, models of the behaviour of H I as a tracer of matter are complicated by galaxy evolution. In this work, we examine the clustering of H I in relation to galaxy colour, stellar mass, and H I mass in IllustrisTNG at z = 0, 0.5, and 1. We compare the H I-red and H I-blue galaxy cross-power spectra, finding that H I-red has an amplitude 1.5 times greater than H I-blue at large scales. The cross-power spectra intersect at ≈3 Mpc in real space and ≈10 Mpc in redshift space, consistent with z ≈ 0 observations. We show that H I clustering increases with galaxy H I mass and depends weakly on detection limits in the range M<SUB>H I</SUB> ≤ 10<SUP>8</SUP> M<SUB>⊙</SUB>. In terms of M<SUB>⋆</SUB>, we find massive blue galaxies cluster more than less massive ones. Massive red galaxies, however, cluster the weakest amongst red galaxies. These opposing trends arise from central-satellite compositions. Despite these M<SUB>⋆</SUB> trends, we find that the cross-power spectra are largely insensitive to detection limits in galaxy surveys. Counter-intuitively, all auto and cross-power spectra for red and blue galaxies and H I decrease with time at all scales. We demonstrate that processes associated with quenching contribute to this trend. The complex interplay between H I and galaxies underscores the importance of understanding baryonic effects when interpreting the large-scale clustering of H I, blue, and red galaxies at z ≤ 1.
[ 0.009469454176723957, 0.020392950624227524, 0.03290983662009239, 0.014564663171768188, 0.023373739793896675, 0.014189034700393677, 0.01635798253118992, -0.0003040615702047944, -0.023373739793896675, 0.006682538893073797, -0.013740705326199532, 0.011456646025180817, -0.05733775720000267, -0.0013661944540217519, 0.042239945381879807, 0.014601013623178005, -0.022937526926398277, 0.032425157725811005, -0.035163603723049164, 0.03945302963256836, -0.00008368319686269388, -0.031237687915563583, -0.021531950682401657, 0.0409797765314579, -0.06325086206197739, -0.004795312415808439, 0.010893204249441624, 0.015909653156995773, 0.05743469297885895, -0.022489195689558983, 0.009736028499901295, -0.013243907131254673, -0.04456641525030136, -0.031237687915563583, -0.0473775640130043, 0.07997235655784607, -0.0023507026489824057, 0.02903238870203495, -0.027384474873542786, 0.013146971352398396, 0.003417000640183687, 0.025082239881157875, 0.006049424409866333, -0.043063901364803314, -0.0033291522413492203, -0.026875559240579605, -0.005885844584554434, -0.04362128674983978, -0.032425157725811005, 0.011420294642448425, -0.06630435585975647, -0.0010329763172194362, -0.034557752311229706, -0.041682563722133636, -0.025130707770586014, 0.011262773536145687, -0.00889995414763689, 0.03620566800236702, -0.03480009362101555, -0.018878323957324028, -0.01235936488956213, 0.005080062430351973, 0.013159087859094143, 0.010711449198424816, 0.0030110804364085197, 0.03782934695482254, -0.012698641046881676, -0.021422898396849632, 0.04192490130662918, 0.0065795439295470715, 0.00975420419126749, -0.0013275714591145515, -0.015146279707551003, 0.01972651481628418, 0.026657452806830406, -0.0013972442829981446, -0.045923519879579544, -0.009729970246553421, -0.02903238870203495, -0.001148088020272553, -0.007748836651444435, 0.03644800931215286, 0.0038047456182539463, -0.019605344161391258, -0.007112693041563034, 0.001785746426321566, 0.015255332924425602, -0.02164100483059883, -0.058646395802497864, -0.005519304424524307, -0.0014275368303060532, 0.00781548023223877, -0.01415268424898386, -0.03450928255915642, -0.02706943079829216, -0.056126054376363754, 0.031916242092847824, -0.029129326343536377, 0.014249620027840137, 0.021459249779582024, 0.03579368814826012, 0.047838009893894196, 0.01724252477288246, -0.05869486555457115, 0.045148029923439026, -0.02173794060945511, 0.0031443675979971886, 0.005764673929661512, 0.013801290653645992, -0.005504158325493336, 0.06247537583112717, 0.029832113534212112, -0.016830546781420708, 0.01916913129389286, -0.053605712950229645, 0.01959322765469551, -0.08564312756061554, 0.0018281559459865093, -0.011390002444386482, -0.004428772255778313, 0.020611057057976723, -0.02194393053650856, 0.032982539385557175, 0.012698641046881676, 0.010275236330926418, -0.05651380121707916, 0.04131904989480972, -0.03254632651805878, -0.034048836678266525, 0.020332366228103638, 0.019435705617070198, -0.011923152022063732, -0.004689288325607777, -0.008003294467926025, -0.040834371000528336, -0.008857544511556625, 0.011595992371439934, -0.0009269523434340954, -0.02886275015771389, -0.02198028191924095, -0.006646187510341406, 0.0030095658730715513, 0.046989817172288895, 0.02109573781490326, 0.030922645702958107, -0.0023461587261408567, -0.0431366041302681, 0.022222621366381645, 0.051812395453453064, 0.012159433215856552, 0.037296198308467865, -0.008009352721273899, -0.03194047510623932, -0.04437253996729851, -0.001096590654924512, -0.00671283109113574, 0.02385842055082321, -0.010172241367399693, -0.03552711382508278, 0.0011321844067424536, -0.011238539591431618, 0.016685141250491142, -0.03916222229599953, -0.002028086921200156, -0.039428796619176865, 0.03879871219396591, 0.009905667044222355, -0.03375802934169769, -0.07318682223558426, -0.024270398542284966, -0.034775856882333755, -0.014382907189428806, -0.02156830206513405, -0.04546307399868965, 0.04303966835141182, 0.044421009719371796, 0.004150080494582653, -0.023579727858304977, -0.0033715618774294853, 0.012953098863363266, 0.010475167073309422, 0.036908455193042755, -0.016576088964939117, -0.021168440580368042, -0.024815665557980537, 0.0011427868157625198, -0.04888007417321205, 0.026608984917402267, -0.031480029225349426, -0.003877447685226798, 0.028402304276823997, 0.045656945556402206, 0.0025506336241960526, 0.052927158772945404, -0.001417691819369793, -0.01852693036198616, 0.00017768479301594198, 0.025591153651475906, -0.05559290573000908, 0.030365262180566788, 0.0559321828186512, 0.015643078833818436, 0.02869311347603798, -0.04473605379462242, -0.07061801850795746, -0.021507717669010162, 0.05409039556980133, 0.005201232619583607, -0.012722874991595745, -0.019060079008340836, 0.005013418849557638, -0.01913277991116047, -0.0009383120341226459, 0.012407832778990269, -0.01020253449678421, -0.026948262006044388, -0.07061801850795746, 0.026608984917402267, 0.03189200535416603, 0.05060069262981415, -0.05438120290637016, 0.04972826689481735, 0.038483668118715286, 0.005876756738871336, -0.02881428226828575, 0.007209629286080599, 0.048346925526857376, -0.038435198366642, 0.01656397245824337, -0.001622166601009667, 0.01839364320039749, 0.013486247509717941, -0.008954480290412903, -0.0020068821031600237, 0.0166487917304039, 0.01406786497682333, 0.0007300506695173681, -0.00026714251725934446, 0.004971009213477373, -0.055738311260938644, -0.03392766788601875, 0.004028910305351019, 0.052539415657520294, 0.003789599286392331, -0.01746063120663166, -0.004343952983617783, -0.00015913060633465648, -0.002635452663525939, 0.03307947516441345, -0.04221571236848831, -0.001422993023879826, -0.007451969664543867, -0.011729279533028603, -0.05481741577386856, -0.02925049513578415, 0.013219673186540604, -0.00862126238644123, 0.04330624267458916, -0.03426694497466087, 0.015764247626066208, -0.026827091351151466, -0.026584750041365623, -0.0427003912627697, 0.000002260108885820955, -0.001454800134524703, 0.051424648612737656, 0.011505113914608955, 0.002394626848399639, -0.0849645733833313, 0.0046105277724564075, 0.0012707728892564774, -0.01355894934386015, 0.07498014718294144, -0.06494724750518799, -0.056126054376363754, 0.052490945905447006, 0.007664017844945192, 0.034727390855550766, 0.03816862404346466, 0.009208938106894493, -0.00511338422074914, -0.015109929256141186, 0.04039815813302994, 0.030728772282600403, -0.013462013565003872, 0.014819120056927204, -0.008590970188379288, 0.02673015557229519, 0.006240267306566238, -0.010305528528988361, 0.0802631676197052, -0.04691711813211441, 0.009099884890019894, 0.007966943085193634, -0.03351568803191185, 0.001850875443778932, 0.01763026975095272, 0.023046579211950302, -0.05530209839344025, 0.011002257466316223, 0.03060760162770748, -0.010135890915989876, 0.0452692024409771, -0.007973001338541508, -0.02451273985207081, 0.006749182473868132, 0.061069801449775696, 0.03487279638648033, 0.02018696255981922, 0.05370264872908592, 0.0033715618774294853, -0.005537480115890503, 0.007312623783946037, 0.02595466561615467, -0.03167390078306198, -0.026608984917402267, -0.0061887698248028755, 0.05956729128956795, 0.013316608965396881, 0.0002446124271955341, -0.04478451982140541, -0.02561538852751255, -0.008227459155023098, 0.008784842677414417, 0.03324911370873451, -0.03402460366487503, -0.007149043958634138, -0.030631836503744125, -0.039041049778461456, 0.01116583775728941, -0.00977843813598156, 0.037247732281684875, 0.0392833910882473, 0.016067173331975937, 0.004658995661884546, -0.04665054380893707, 0.0019220629474148154, 0.07919687032699585, -0.06242690607905388, -0.005876756738871336, -0.02673015557229519, 0.011135544627904892, 0.01541285403072834, -0.004940716549754143, -0.011184013448655605, 0.017581801861524582, 0.027699517086148262, 0.02185911126434803, -0.03465468809008598, 0.0005884330021217465, -0.010881087742745876, 0.0069188205525279045, 0.025251878425478935, -0.050019074231386185, 0.05588371306657791, -0.016370099037885666, 0.014273853972554207, -0.05656226724386215, -0.022864824160933495, 0.0058919028379023075, -0.026318175718188286, 0.019266068935394287, 0.03356415778398514, 0.01199585385620594, 0.005110354628413916, 0.0007433036807924509, -0.019908269867300987, 0.014673716388642788, -0.02808726206421852, -0.012280603870749474, 0.007954826578497887, -0.0200657919049263, -0.03368532657623291, -0.017060769721865654, -0.03666611388325691, 0.019702281802892685, 0.031649667769670486, 0.014298087917268276, 0.013740705326199532, 0.0025157970376312733, 0.047668371349573135, -0.0004710493085440248, 0.025469984859228134, -0.044929925352334976, 0.010426699183881283, -0.017145588994026184, -0.00423792889341712, -0.018841972574591637, -0.11128275096416473, 0.004849839024245739, 0.01733946055173874, 0.004168256185948849, 0.005646533332765102, 0.011117369867861271, -0.009826906025409698, -0.04047086089849472, 0.005479923915117979, 0.03770817816257477, 0.030389495193958282, 0.07498014718294144, -0.014540428295731544, -0.05098843574523926, -0.043233539909124374, -0.06664363294839859, 0.0019190337043255568, 0.006470490712672472, -0.010238884948194027, 0.06325086206197739, 0.03312794491648674, 0.0019887066446244717, 0.039210688322782516, -0.015994472429156303, 0.012819811701774597, -0.01378917321562767, -0.028450772166252136, 0.008784842677414417, -0.05476894974708557, 0.0042591337114572525, -0.005734381731599569, 0.03484855964779854, 0.020223312079906464, 0.001678207772783935, 0.001096590654924512, 0.003910769708454609, -0.05006754398345947, 0.02011425979435444, 0.04803188145160675, 0.009881433099508286, -0.0027914594393223524, -0.014164800755679607, -0.0050376527942717075, 0.06543193012475967, 0.029565539211034775, 0.03698115795850754, -0.011238539591431618, -0.018793504685163498, 0.05268482118844986, -0.0006111523834988475, 0.026269707828760147, 0.016879014670848846, 0.05413886159658432, -0.02651204913854599, -0.012856162153184414, -0.058549460023641586, 0.032037410885095596, 0.004404538311064243, 0.04582658410072327, 0.016236811876296997, 0.021107856184244156, -0.04095553979277611, 0.00702181551605463, 0.0019266067538410425, -0.027142133563756943, 0.021798526868224144, -0.03492126241326332, -0.02441580407321453, -0.005482953507453203, -0.012171550653874874, -0.020041557028889656, -0.05520516261458397, -0.023373739793896675, 0.012165492400527, -0.0008474343339912593, 0.041391752660274506, -0.02532457932829857, 0.05006754398345947, -0.013946694321930408, -0.02886275015771389, 0.024355217814445496, 0.015655195340514183, -0.0096087995916605, -0.05884026736021042, 0.05113384127616882, -0.014940290711820126, 0.006973347160965204, -0.019750749692320824, 0.010075305588543415, -0.0020417184568941593, 0.05695001408457756, -0.0015123561024665833, 0.06581967324018478, -0.049970608204603195, -0.012831928208470345, 0.007609491236507893, 0.038410965353250504, 0.025857729837298393, -0.03608449548482895, -0.0005195174016989768, 0.005788908340036869, -0.013025800697505474, -0.04068896546959877, -0.03380649536848068, 0.01955687627196312, -0.011602050624787807, 0.026827091351151466, 0.005092179402709007, -0.01839364320039749, -0.01199585385620594, -0.00707634212449193, 0.021846994757652283, 0.03480009362101555, -0.02331315353512764, 0.04507533088326454, -0.043185073882341385, 0.006209974642843008, 0.009269523434340954, 0.0012366937007755041, -0.030704539269208908, -0.028571942821145058, 0.03804745525121689, -0.025469984859228134, 0.03043796494603157, 0.014770652167499065, 0.012001912109553814, -0.01114160381257534, -0.016042940318584442, 0.01052363496273756, 0.02600313350558281, 0.015000876039266586, 0.0085364431142807, -0.010135890915989876, -0.025469984859228134, -0.006809767335653305, -0.00898477341979742, 0.02245284616947174, -0.014358673244714737, 0.00900900736451149, -0.07677346467971802, -0.01541285403072834, -0.024585440754890442, -0.00900900736451149, -0.059276480227708817, -0.006930937524884939, -0.0023264687042683363, -0.04030122235417366, -0.027166368439793587, -0.0061917994171381, -0.022307440638542175, 0.014770652167499065, -0.007833655923604965, 0.010893204249441624, 0.020598940551280975, -0.011177954263985157, 0.01815130189061165, 0.023494908586144447, 0.043354712426662445, -0.023846304044127464, 0.03278866782784462, 0.048783138394355774, 0.0542357973754406, 0.03581792116165161, -0.00928769912570715, 0.02450062334537506, 0.02395535632967949, -0.009433102793991566, 0.008021470159292221, 0.03678728640079498, -0.008142639882862568, 0.009148352779448032, 0.009414928033947945, 0.001195041462779045, -0.028063027188181877, -0.02027178183197975, 0.04236111417412758, 0.015534024685621262, -0.024536972865462303, 0.015109929256141186, -0.03334604948759079, -0.02314351499080658, 0.013304492458701134, -0.007355033420026302, 0.0025778969284147024, 0.03765971213579178, -0.02532457932829857, 0.004256104584783316, 0.0024567265063524246, -0.003886535530909896, 0.019072195515036583, 0.03734466806054115, -0.01994462125003338, -0.029953282326459885, 0.014831237494945526, 0.007821539416909218, 0.005788908340036869, -0.012904630042612553, -0.004658995661884546, -0.042627688497304916, -0.01613987609744072, 0.005395105108618736, -0.0268997922539711, -0.008554618805646896, -0.022271089255809784, 0.0027914594393223524, -0.010408523492515087, -0.017569685354828835, 0.00969361886382103, 0.03678728640079498, 0.010935613885521889, -0.002467328915372491, 0.008021470159292221, 0.01108101848512888, 0.014722184278070927, -0.0482499897480011, -0.042627688497304916, -0.02612430416047573, 0.025930430740118027, -0.01742427982389927, -0.013195439241826534, -0.018114950507879257, 0.030728772282600403, 0.008548560552299023, 0.0050315940752625465, -0.02390688844025135, -0.02728753723204136, 0.016454918310046196, -0.004895277786999941, 0.01916913129389286, -0.011874683201313019, 0.01771508902311325, 0.0006546979420818388, -0.009905667044222355, 0.014334439300000668, -0.030874177813529968, -0.028111495077610016, 0.03307947516441345, 0.014395024627447128, 0.008197166956961155, -0.0422641783952713, 0.00029894968611188233, -0.017533333972096443, 0.0345819853246212, -0.0170728862285614, 0.033830732107162476, -0.02096245065331459, 0.008827252313494682, -0.007621608208864927, -0.017048653215169907, 0.05675613880157471, -0.013801290653645992, -0.01613987609744072, 0.031116517260670662, -0.001682751695625484, 0.035381708294153214, -0.04037392511963844, 0.016891131177544594, -0.0026718038134276867, -0.006597719620913267, -0.008269868791103363, -0.019072195515036583, -0.022549781948328018, 0.012347247451543808, -0.0029671562369912863, 0.021507717669010162, 0.04422713816165924, 0.024476388469338417, -0.006985464133322239, 0.019096430391073227, 0.007342916447669268, -0.03581792116165161, -0.011923152022063732, -0.010978023521602154, 0.017230408266186714, -0.011602050624787807, 0.029832113534212112, 0.002655142918229103, -0.014552545733749866, 0.0035018199123442173, 0.02365243062376976, -0.008851486258208752, 0.02736023999750614, 0.039210688322782516, -0.0011511172633618116, 0.05995503440499306, 0.01882985606789589, -0.0018281559459865093, 0.004504503682255745, 0.019459940493106842, 0.011814098805189133, -0.047450266778469086, -0.009166528470814228, 0.00534663675352931, -0.001036762841977179, -0.010529694147408009, -0.05404192581772804, 0.0049467748031020164, 0.02706943079829216, 0.022695185616612434, 0.026415111497044563, -0.0025263994466513395, -0.0035078783985227346, 0.002170461928471923, -0.0043015433475375175, 0.010729624889791012, 0.012601705268025398, 0.03005021996796131, -0.01074174139648676, -0.012038263492286205, -0.011371826753020287, -0.016382215544581413, -0.044929925352334976, 0.024330984801054, 0.023325271904468536, 0.017569685354828835, -0.04919511824846268, 0.012468417175114155, -0.0021719764918088913, -0.01600658893585205, 0.020817046985030174, 0.030171388760209084, -0.020344482734799385, 0.03293406963348389, 0.038919880986213684, -0.013995162211358547, 0.0401315838098526, 0.020477769896388054, 0.0007966943085193634, 0.03526053950190544, 0.02224685624241829, -0.03436388075351715, -0.004434830974787474, 0.005379958543926477, -0.01994462125003338, -0.026366643607616425, 0.00457720598205924, 0.03979230672121048, -0.047959182411432266, -0.024003824219107628, 0.00429245550185442, -0.013861875049769878, 0.011977678164839745, 0.006003985181450844, 0.020138494670391083, -0.0066280122846364975, -0.031480029225349426, 0.020986685529351234, 0.043354712426662445, 0.021665239706635475, -0.017872611060738564, -0.00983902346342802, 0.02578502707183361, 0.022561898455023766, 0.0034624396357685328, 0.018926791846752167, -0.017315227538347244, 0.007155102677643299, 0.012419949285686016, 0.013050034642219543, -0.0028384127654135227, 0.0015350754838436842, -0.024864133447408676, -0.007494379300624132, 0.008906012400984764, -0.007367150392383337, 0.004634761717170477, 0.04585081711411476, -0.008978715166449547, 0.018199769780039787, -0.01404363103210926, 0.03269173204898834, -0.0009307389263994992, 0.03392766788601875, 0.06770993024110794, -0.00024745234986767173, 0.035454411059617996, -0.02779645286500454, -0.019011611118912697, -0.03962266817688942, -0.018539046868681908, 0.0140920989215374, -0.04645666852593422, -0.011959502473473549, 0.009214996360242367, 0.055350564420223236, -0.012407832778990269, 0.0341457724571228, -0.009324049577116966, 0.01583695039153099, -0.02271942049264908, -0.0166487917304039, 0.00039986177580431104, -0.004240958485752344, -0.028063027188181877, 0.003671458223834634, -0.02505800500512123, -0.02958977222442627, 0.018551163375377655, -0.005304227117449045, -0.015679428353905678, 0.006997581105679274, -0.01395881175994873, -0.036181434988975525, 0.023204101249575615, -0.008197166956961155, 0.004880131222307682, -0.033491455018520355, -0.0013677091337740421, 0.00883936882019043, -0.10284929722547531, -0.011420294642448425, 0.021119972690939903, 0.008269868791103363, 0.04546307399868965, 0.037296198308467865, 0.007773071061819792, 0.029832113534212112, -0.005791937466710806, 0.003832008922472596, 0.007058166433125734, -0.03918645530939102, -0.014491960406303406, 0.034436583518981934, -0.0028247812297195196, 0.0047407858073711395, 0.0005641989409923553, 0.016757844015955925, -0.022428611293435097, -0.004552971571683884, 0.002933834446594119, 0.006755240727216005, 0.03266749531030655, 0.005713176913559437, 0.008360746316611767, -0.0019553848542273045, -0.035502880811691284, -0.04039815813302994, 0.02253766544163227, -0.02903238870203495, -0.005585948005318642, -0.0004286397306714207, -0.0035805804654955864, 0.07507707923650742, -0.015146279707551003, -0.011129486374557018, 0.0015691545559093356, 0.022319559007883072, -0.02908085659146309, 0.011171896010637283, -0.049073945730924606, -0.023422207683324814, 0.014649481512606144, 0.005710147321224213, 0.037465836852788925, -0.0032049529254436493, -0.01423750352114439, 0.034557752311229706, 0.02451273985207081, 0.027045197784900665, -0.02779645286500454, 0.029735175892710686, 0.014661598950624466, 0.049679797142744064, 0.023979591205716133, 0.026633217930793762, 0.03189200535416603, -0.01530380081385374, -0.01815130189061165, -0.01903584413230419, -0.02745717577636242, -0.0020750402472913265, 0.000048231435357593, -0.03446081653237343, -0.028886985033750534, -0.02245284616947174, -0.03749007359147072, 0.033830732107162476, 0.004019822925329208, -0.02881428226828575, 0.031407326459884644, 0.02915355935692787, -0.00027490497450344265, 0.03252209350466728, 0.022210504859685898, 0.004789253696799278, -0.014285971410572529, -0.0075186132453382015, -0.023628197610378265, 0.051473118364810944, -0.015328035689890385, -0.02378571778535843, 0.01094773132354021, 0.009317991323769093, 0.0014192063827067614, 0.017654504626989365, 0.018369408324360847, -0.025033771991729736, -0.003626019461080432, 0.004480269737541676, -0.01605505682528019, 0.011050726287066936, 0.03300677239894867, 0.019532643258571625, -0.001961443340405822, -0.0031958650797605515, 0.009881433099508286, -0.017557566985487938, 0.04904971271753311, -0.02062317542731762, -0.021507717669010162, -0.025373047217726707, 0.017945311963558197, -0.02317986637353897, 0.002193181309849024, -0.027893388643860817, 0.0006781746633350849, 0.001394215039908886, 0.010584220290184021, 0.022222621366381645, 0.013849758543074131, 0.028063027188181877, 0.014661598950624466, 0.0036502534057945013, 0.03833826258778572, 0.01009348127990961, -0.03424270823597908, -0.030680304393172264, -0.012940981425344944, -0.024658143520355225, 0.024561207741498947, -0.011202188208699226, -0.05098843574523926, -0.036229901015758514, 0.013037918135523796, 0.012407832778990269, -0.002078069606795907, 0.02224685624241829, -0.030922645702958107, 0.006234208587557077, -0.017448514699935913, -0.020477769896388054, 0.0281841978430748, -0.02001732401549816, -0.025251878425478935, -0.03433964401483536, 0.006737065501511097, 0.03923492506146431, -0.0019054020522162318, 0.004892248194664717, 0.017642386257648468, 0.009505805559456348, -0.009960194118320942, -0.008627320639789104, 0.0004771078238263726, -0.009651209227740765, 0.016830546781420708, -0.0268997922539711, 0.03509090095758438, 0.014322321861982346, 0.0007705669850111008, 0.0328856036067009, 0.0023022345267236233, 0.01703653484582901, -0.02019907906651497, 0.013886108994483948, 0.026051601395010948, -0.028717346489429474, 0.02387053705751896, 0.04136751964688301, 0.02617277204990387, -0.0062826769426465034, -0.008639438077807426, -0.013328726403415203, 0.02808726206421852, 0.039937712252140045, 0.0016948686679825187, -0.003250391688197851, 0.010559986345469952, -0.0010208592284470797, -0.008790900930762291, -0.05486588552594185, -0.008790900930762291, 0.017181940376758575, -0.015946002677083015, 0.02617277204990387, 0.02673015557229519, 0.03254632651805878, 0.01630951464176178, -0.001543405931442976, -0.01695171557366848, -0.005080062430351973, -0.01626104675233364, -0.007718544453382492, 0.01627316325902939, 0.007348975166678429, -0.021956047043204308, 0.01116583775728941, 0.019447823986411095, 0.01715770550072193, 0.007282331585884094, 0.020780695602297783, -0.0026612014044076204, 0.0439847968518734, 0.03031679429113865, 0.01351048145443201, -0.009851140901446342, 0.03509090095758438, -0.030583368614315987, 0.03778088092803955, -0.005046740639954805, 0.007688251789659262, -0.0025763821322470903, -0.0452449657022953, 0.013631652109324932, -0.006110009271651506, 0.009439161978662014, -0.01938723772764206, -0.023410091176629066, -0.01895102486014366, 0.019823450595140457, 0.007409560028463602, 0.04512379691004753, 0.02561538852751255, 0.044760286808013916, -0.02488836646080017, 0.012710758484899998, -0.008251693099737167, -0.014976641163229942, -0.031189220026135445, 0.005049769766628742, -0.04793494567275047, -0.003207982052117586, 0.037853583693504333, -0.008318336680531502, 0.013764939270913601, 0.005010389257222414, -0.005958546418696642, -0.00020788269466720521, -0.009130177088081837, 0.02825690060853958, -0.0019038873724639416, -0.009808731265366077, -0.020502004772424698, -0.02288905903697014, 0.017787791788578033, 0.01133547630161047, 0.011147662065923214, -0.004337894730269909, -0.0006671936134807765, 0.057919375598430634, 0.026051601395010948, -0.021192675456404686, 0.025857729837298393, -0.008554618805646896, -0.02010214328765869, 0.031746603548526764, -0.0007868492393754423, 0.03700539097189903, -0.007306565530598164, -0.02903238870203495, 0.024585440754890442, -0.015570376068353653, 0.0009231657604686916, -0.01815130189061165, 0.010535752400755882, -0.02942013368010521, 0.0358663909137249, 0.032085880637168884, -0.011541465297341347, 0.009360400959849358, -0.00013716849207412452, -0.029638240113854408, -0.033321816474199295, 0.02639087848365307, -0.024270398542284966, -0.03409730643033981, 0.006034277845174074, 0.0033321816008538008, -0.029565539211034775, -0.002936863573268056, -0.04255498945713043, 0.05127924680709839, 0.005228495690971613, -0.0034897029399871826, 0.033539921045303345, -0.017993779852986336, -0.006827943027019501, 0.024221930652856827, 0.004807429388165474, -0.02549421787261963, 0.006161506753414869, -0.05118230730295181, -0.0031231630127876997, -0.0069612301886081696, 0.033491455018520355, 0.007991177029907703, -0.03465468809008598, 0.004652937408536673, 0.008700023405253887, 0.023422207683324814, 0.0013866418739780784, 0.04631126672029495, -0.014334439300000668, 0.023458559066057205, 0.003626019461080432, 0.000976177747361362, 0.016551854088902473, -0.002334041753783822, -0.012395715340971947, -0.006640129256993532, 0.0038744183257222176, 0.008990831673145294, -0.007997236214578152, -0.023725133389234543, -0.002524884883314371, 0.00007142417598515749, -0.006834001280367374, -0.02416134625673294, -0.00813052337616682, 0.007336858194321394, 0.0007008941029198468, -0.008627320639789104, 0.02373724989593029, -0.001008742256090045, -0.028765814378857613, 0.031528495252132416, 0.013243907131254673, 0.008172933012247086, -0.004477240145206451, -0.024815665557980537, -0.005628357641398907, 0.029395900666713715, 0.004465123172849417, -0.005782849621027708, -0.016709376126527786, 0.01796954683959484, -0.013268141075968742, 0.03290983662009239, 0.04005888104438782, -0.0019266067538410425, 0.03380649536848068, 0.017230408266186714, 0.00426822155714035, -0.02126537635922432, 0.03906528651714325, 0.01977498270571232, 0.0006251626764424145, 0.03104381449520588, 0.006458373740315437, 0.002700581680983305, 0.010123773477971554, -0.02253766544163227, -0.0027717691846191883, 0.015194747596979141, -0.007197512313723564, 0.004898306913673878, 0.009075650945305824, -0.04051932692527771, 0.012662289664149284, 0.06194222718477249, -0.03232821822166443, 0.01009348127990961, -0.00702181551605463, 0.012226076796650887, -0.009160470217466354, 0.021253259852528572, 0.04691711813211441, 0.007421677000820637, -0.018502695485949516, -0.004758961033076048, -0.011511173099279404, -0.012819811701774597, 0.018030131235718727, 0.018708685413002968, 0.005322402808815241, -0.00685217697173357, 0.03685998544096947, 0.01240177359431982, 0.0028565884567797184, 0.00000797546272224281, -0.0023249539081007242, -0.03407306969165802, 0.015946002677083015, -0.015194747596979141, -0.0341457724571228, 0.013086386024951935, -0.008142639882862568, -0.027505643665790558, 0.021422898396849632, -0.006288735195994377, -0.014164800755679607, -0.006985464133322239, -0.012371481396257877, -0.01592176966369152, 0.0006312212208285928, -0.010844736360013485, 0.025736559182405472, 0.02702096290886402, 0.001450256328098476, 0.04829845577478409, 0.002905056579038501, 0.011868624947965145, -0.022598249837756157, -0.0072641558945178986, 0.012674407102167606, -0.007506496272981167, 0.023385856300592422, 0.011305183172225952, -0.014298087917268276, -0.0409797765314579, -0.012650173157453537, 0.008427389897406101, -0.0018857117975130677, 0.0140920989215374, 0.02442792057991028, 0.031092284247279167, 0.025712324306368828, 0.026633217930793762, -0.018648099154233932, -0.009929900988936424, -0.030025985091924667, -0.03625413402915001, -0.006379613187164068, 0.02164100483059883, -0.01981133408844471, 0.0022386200726032257, 0.011129486374557018, -0.014431375078856945, -0.019617462530732155, -0.03509090095758438, 0.01977498270571232, -0.020635291934013367, 0.008930246345698833, -0.012232135981321335, 0.01342566218227148, -0.019738631322979927, 0.03211011365056038, 0.004892248194664717, 0.0026384820230305195, 0.00005419528315542266, -0.015267450362443924, -0.02864464372396469, 0.035720985382795334, -0.0350181981921196, 0.030413730069994926, 0.022440727800130844, -0.00015960392192937434, 0.005407222080975771, 0.02151983417570591, -0.0002446124271955341, -0.012565353885293007, 0.004861955996602774, 0.01652762107551098, 0.01630951464176178, -0.02915355935692787, -0.01404363103210926, -0.004652937408536673, 0.030753007158637047, 0.016757844015955925, 0.015049343928694725, 0.05234554409980774, 0.037805113941431046, -0.017618153244256973, 0.015546142123639584, 0.02190757915377617, 0.013195439241826534, -0.03654494509100914, -0.013861875049769878, -0.032812900841236115, 0.03727196529507637, 0.02280423976480961, -0.001626710407435894, 0.030025985091924667, -0.01176562998443842, 0.018429992720484734, -0.006555309984833002, -0.041343286633491516, -0.03128615766763687, -0.015134163200855255, 0.030534900724887848, -0.011311241425573826, 0.013207555748522282, -0.01669725961983204, -0.0017175881657749414, 0.0002909979084506631, 0.0066219535656273365, -0.01406786497682333, -0.008421331644058228, 0.017387928441166878, -0.03223128244280815, 0.008718199096620083, 0.01840575970709324, 0.012468417175114155, 0.005413280334323645, 0.020429302006959915, 0.003992559388279915, -0.02198028191924095, 0.02852347493171692, 0.010105597786605358, 0.017872611060738564, 0.0011912549380213022, -0.020586824044585228, -0.03431541100144386, 0.05055222287774086, 0.0041773440316319466, -0.009566389955580235, 0.01630951464176178, 0.005567772313952446, -0.00845162384212017, -0.01144452951848507, -0.0015797569649294019, -0.0004373488191049546, 0.0316011980175972, -0.008500092662870884, -0.013134853914380074, -0.03402460366487503, 0.017642386257648468, 0.003816862590610981, 0.020950334146618843, 0.023167749866843224, 0.01426173746585846, -0.014431375078856945, -0.00911806058138609, 0.0439605638384819, -0.0008709111134521663, 0.001366951735690236, -0.035333242267370224, -0.033491455018520355, 0.0034563811495900154, -0.014685832895338535, -0.018551163375377655, 0.00813052337616682, -0.020889749750494957, -0.02556692063808441, -0.018454227596521378, 0.007627666462212801, -0.006094863172620535, -0.02566385641694069, 0.02920202724635601, -0.019496291875839233, -0.06921244412660599, 0.029735175892710686, 0.024755079299211502, -0.004961921367794275, -0.0059282537549734116, 0.011480879969894886, 0.01005712989717722, 0.03906528651714325, -0.01176562998443842, 0.0027687400579452515, 0.013195439241826534, 0.021083621308207512, -0.004792282823473215, -0.0038047456182539463, 0.023834185674786568, 0.003374591236934066, 0.011832273565232754, 0.015000876039266586, 0.012286662124097347, -0.04299120232462883, -0.057919375598430634, 0.008275927044451237, -0.01017830055207014, -0.006222091615200043, 0.011705045588314533, 0.035624049603939056, 0.010620571672916412, -0.004225811921060085, -0.007252038922160864, -0.018635982647538185, -0.014273853972554207, -0.024282516911625862, 0.008148699067533016, -0.013437779620289803, 0.037805113941431046, 0.0087545495480299, 0.01400727964937687, -0.020138494670391083, 0.0008163845050148666, 0.03988924250006676, -0.013050034642219543, -0.02442792057991028, -0.00017863143875729293, 0.01626104675233364, 0.026415111497044563, 0.035284772515296936, -0.003510907758027315, 0.010856853798031807, -0.003435176331549883, -0.011862566694617271, -0.0431366041302681, -0.0033291522413492203, -0.02236802689731121, 0.008209283463656902, 0.022404376417398453, -0.02992904931306839, 0.013474131003022194, -0.029177794232964516, -0.0005172454402782023, -0.017448514699935913, -0.03845943510532379, 0.025300346314907074, -0.004095553886145353, 0.005307256709784269, 0.01784837618470192, 0.002849015174433589, -0.002406743820756674, -0.005628357641398907, -0.0075670816004276276, -0.009893549606204033, 0.03782934695482254, -0.024755079299211502, 0.010432757437229156, -0.019011611118912697, -0.01600658893585205, 0.060730524361133575, -0.03882294520735741, 0.00432274816557765, 0.017787791788578033, -0.004816517233848572, 0.029638240113854408, 0.019060079008340836, 0.004861955996602774, 0.038483668118715286, 0.00460143992677331, -0.018175536766648293, 0.013183321803808212, -0.013486247509717941, -0.016285279765725136, -0.012868279591202736, -0.009451278485357761, -0.023422207683324814, -0.013292375020682812, 0.054623544216156006, 0.016515502706170082, -0.009469454176723957, -0.029953282326459885, 0.02113208919763565, -0.0038047456182539463, 0.013389311730861664, -0.04488145560026169, 0.009420986287295818, -0.001682751695625484, -0.016212578862905502, -0.022089334204792976, 0.009929900988936424, 0.0057252938859164715, -0.015194747596979141, 0.030389495193958282, 0.03392766788601875, 0.014382907189428806, 0.001325299497693777, -0.009015065617859364, 0.02101092040538788, -0.030195623636245728, -0.005728323012590408, -0.0013184836134314537, 0.03206164389848709, -0.006549251265823841, 0.008009352721273899, 0.006640129256993532, -0.019193366169929504, -0.008354688063263893, 0.02488836646080017, 0.0008216857095248997, -0.02001732401549816, 0.009439161978662014, 0.0021083622705191374, -0.01052363496273756, 0.021338079124689102, 0.027529878541827202, -0.020041557028889656, 0.00997231062501669, 0.023373739793896675, 0.024730846285820007, -0.020562589168548584, 0.05481741577386856, 0.03334604948759079, 0.012710758484899998, 0.004552971571683884, 0.009911725297570229, 0.021313844248652458, -0.00006460834993049502, 0.03431541100144386, -0.008318336680531502, 0.016600321978330612, 0.03576945513486862, 0.010390347801148891, 0.02561538852751255, 0.010984081774950027, 0.00006943622429389507, 0.0028808224014937878, 0.02515494078397751, 0.011044667102396488, -0.011904976330697536, -0.024355217814445496, 0.014516194351017475, -0.02416134625673294, -0.026100069284439087, 0.02395535632967949, -0.017194056883454323, 0.008251693099737167, -0.02101092040538788, -0.01097196526825428, 0.029517069458961487, 0.0021644034422934055, -0.00958456564694643, -0.03310370817780495, 0.0010344908805564046, 0.014613131061196327, 0.004628702998161316, -0.02881428226828575, 0.004410596564412117, 0.031746603548526764, 0.015049343928694725, 0.00898477341979742, -0.01969016343355179, 0.0005339063936844468, -0.029105091467499733, -0.014419258572161198, 0.01114160381257534, 0.00906959269195795, 0.018793504685163498, -0.037974752485752106, 0.007112693041563034, 0.020986685529351234, 0.0017539391992613673, -0.00021413053036667407, -0.007112693041563034, 0.037853583693504333, 0.027772217988967896, 0.023119281977415085, 0.016491269692778587, -0.022780004888772964, -0.05190933123230934, 0.023204101249575615, 0.0452692024409771, 0.009742087684571743, -0.00494374567642808, 0.0266816858202219, -0.023022346198558807, -0.012553236447274685, -0.007845773361623287, 0.037247732281684875, -0.006979405879974365, -0.028790049254894257, -0.03126192092895508, -0.021677356213331223 ]
12.853137
3.468104
2024-06-01
0
2024MNRAS.531..450O
[ "galaxy H", "galaxy cross-power spectra", "H I", "massive blue galaxies", "Massive red galaxies", "red galaxies", "galaxies", "galaxy evolution", "galaxy surveys", "large scales" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
40
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1102", "10.48550/arXiv.2310.16884" ]
[ "Osinga, Calvin K.", "Diemer, Benedikt", "Villaescusa-Navarro, Francisco", "D'Onghia, Elena", "Timbie, Peter" ]
[ "Department of Astronomy, University of Maryland - College Park, 4296 Stadium Dr, 20742, College Park, MD, USA;", "Department of Astronomy, University of Maryland - College Park, 4296 Stadium Dr, 20742, College Park, MD, USA;", "Center for Computational Astrophysics, Flatiron Institute, 162 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10010, USA", "Department of Astronomy, University of Wisconsin - Madison, 475 North Charter Street, Madison, WI 53706, USA; Department of Physics, University of Wisconsin - Madison, 1150 University Avenue, Madison, WI 53706, USA", "Department of Physics, University of Wisconsin - Madison, 1150 University Avenue, Madison, WI 53706, USA" ]
null
[ "1959ApJ...129..243S", "1970A&A.....5...84Z", "1972ApJ...176....1G", "1972MNRAS.156P...1J", "1978MNRAS.183..341W", "1980ApJ...237..692L", "1980FCPh....5..287T", "1985ApJ...292..371D", "1985ApJ...292..404G", "1987MNRAS.227....1K", "1996ApJ...461L..65F", "1996MNRAS.283.1388M", "1996Natur.379..613M", "1996PASA...13..243S", "1998ApJ...495..139M", "1998ApJ...498..541K", "1998ApJ...499...20J", "1999MNRAS.308..947A", "2000AJ....120.1579Y", "2000MNRAS.318.1144P", "2000Sci...287..109J", "2001MNRAS.328..726S", "2001MNRAS.328.1039C", "2002AJ....123..485S", "2002AJ....124.2440S", "2002ApJ...575..587B", "2003ApJ...584..210G", "2003MNRAS.339..289S", "2004ApJ...608..752B", "2004ApJ...609...35K", "2004ApJ...615L.101B", "2005AJ....130.2598G", "2005ApJ...621...22Z", "2005ApJ...630....1Z", "2005ApJ...631...41T", "2005ApJ...633..560E", "2005MNRAS.363L..66G", "2006ApJ...652...71W", "2006MNRAS.368...37L", "2007ApJ...654..702M", "2007ApJ...655L..69W", "2007ApJ...660L..43N", "2007ApJ...667..760Z", "2007ApJ...670..156D", "2007CSE.....9...90H", "2007MNRAS.378..301B", "2008AJ....136.2782L", "2008AJ....136.2846B", "2008ApJ...681..232L", "2008ApJ...689..865K", "2009ApJ...693..216K", "2009ApJ...699L...9S", "2009ApJ...703.1416F", "2009IEEEP..97.1482D", "2009MNRAS.393.1302W", "2010ARA&A..48..391S", "2010MNRAS.401.1552D", "2010Natur.466..463C", "2011AJ....142..170H", "2011ApJ...728...88G", "2011ApJ...736...59Z", "2011ApJ...738...22W", "2011MNRAS.413..101G", "2011piim.book.....D", "2012MNRAS.424.1471L", "2013ApJ...763L..20M", "2013ApJ...767..122G", "2013ApJ...776...43P", "2013MNRAS.428.3306W", "2013MNRAS.429.3604B", "2013MNRAS.430.1447K", "2013MNRAS.431.2261R", "2013MNRAS.436.2747K", "2013MNRAS.436.3031V", "2014ApJ...783..118R", "2014ApJ...784..128S", "2014ApJ...790...10S", "2014ApJ...795...37G", "2014MNRAS.441.2398G", "2014SPIE.9145E..22B", "2015ApJ...807..152S", "2015PhRvD..92j3516O", "2016A&A...594A..13P", "2016MNRAS.456.1115B", "2016MNRAS.461.2135H", "2016MNRAS.461.2630M", "2016SPIE.9906E..5XN", "2017ApJ...838...87C", "2017ApJ...846...61G", "2017MNRAS.466.3460V", "2017MNRAS.469.2626H", "2017MNRAS.470..771T", "2017MNRAS.471.1671D", "2017RMxAA..53..385F", "2018ApJ...866..135V", "2018ApJS..238...33D", "2018ApJS..239...35D", "2018JCAP...05..004O", "2018MNRAS.473.4077P", "2018MNRAS.475..624N", "2018MNRAS.475..648P", "2018MNRAS.475..676S", "2018MNRAS.476.3382A", "2018MNRAS.477.1206N", "2018MNRAS.479.4056W", "2018MNRAS.480.5113M", "2018arXiv181009572C", "2018ascl.soft11008V", "2019ComAC...6....2N", "2019MNRAS.483.5334S", "2019MNRAS.485.4817D", "2019MNRAS.486.2827D", "2019MNRAS.487.1529D", "2019PhRvD.100f4044L", "2020ApJ...890...63W", "2020ApJ...895...34Z", "2020MNRAS.493.5506H", "2020MNRAS.497..146D", "2020MNRAS.499..768Z", "2020Natur.585..357H", "2020moco.book.....D", "2021ApJS..257...21B", "2021JOSS....6.3021W", "2021MNRAS.500.4004D", "2021MNRAS.506.3455W", "2021MNRAS.506.4760D", "2021SCPMA..6489811W", "2022ApJ...929...94A", "2022ApJ...933...10Z", "2022ApJ...937..113Q", "2022ApJ...940..176V", "2022ApJ...941...48L", "2022MNRAS.510.3495W", "2023A&A...671A...3J", "2023ApJ...957L..19S", "2023MNRAS.518.6262C", "2023MNRAS.519.1913A", "2023MNRAS.521.5645G", "2023MNRAS.523.5538Z", "2023PASA...40...17W", "2023RAA....23g5003J", "2023arXiv230111943P" ]
29071289
2402.17822
Galaxy cluster virial-shock sources in eROSITA catalogs
Context. Virial shocks around galaxy clusters and groups are being mapped, thus tracing accretion onto large-scale structure. <BR /> Aims: Following the recent identification of discrete ROSAT and radio sources associated with the virial shocks of MCXC clusters and groups, we examined the eROSITA-DE Early Data Release (EDR) to see whether it shows virial-shock X-ray sources within its 140 deg<SUP>2</SUP> field. <BR /> Methods: EDR catalog sources were stacked and radially binned around EDR catalog clusters and groups. The properties of the excess virial-shock sources were inferred statistically by comparing the virial-shock region to the field. <BR /> Results: We find an excess of X-ray sources narrowly localized at the 2.0 &lt; r/R<SUB>500</SUB> &lt; 2.25 normalized radii, just inside the anticipated virial shocks, of the resolved 532 clusters, for samples of both extended sources (3σ for 534 sources) and bright sources (3.5σ for 5820 sources; 4σ excluding the low cluster-mass quartile). The excess sources are on average extended (∼100 kpc), luminous (L<SUB>X</SUB> ≃ 10<SUP>43 − 44</SUP> erg s<SUP>−1</SUP>), and hot (keV scales), consistent with infalling gaseous halos crossing the virial shock. The results agree with the stacked ROSAT-MCXC signal, showing the higher L<SUB>X</SUB> expected at EDR redshifts and a possible dependence on host mass. <BR /> Conclusions: Localized virial-shock spikes in the distributions of discrete radio, X-ray, and possibly also γ-ray sources are new powerful probes of accretion from the cosmic web. We expect that data from future all-sky catalogs will allow us to place strong constraints on virial shock physics.
[ -0.025605589151382446, 0.0097318971529603, 0.0012568520614877343, 0.012543193064630032, 0.007648751605302095, 0.030240429565310478, -0.009877527132630348, 0.007832372561097145, -0.014892271719872952, -0.011340160854160786, -0.011517450213432312, 0.009776218794286251, -0.03274780139327049, -0.024351904168725014, 0.019742390140891075, 0.048425208777189255, -0.028670156374573708, 0.03041771799325943, -0.04510737583041191, 0.0385730117559433, 0.005755559075623751, -0.031684067100286484, 0.003913020249456167, -0.015234186314046383, -0.037281334400177, -0.014373068697750568, 0.010105470195412636, 0.02727717161178589, 0.07400546967983246, -0.032342568039894104, -0.0005445303395390511, -0.03378620743751526, 0.01831141486763954, -0.020172949880361557, -0.07902021706104279, 0.07005446404218674, -0.01544946525245905, 0.02471914514899254, -0.040447209030389786, -0.010542361065745354, 0.04558858647942543, 0.0017808041302487254, -0.040345899760723114, 0.014955589547753334, -0.04672830179333687, -0.05252818390727043, -0.04655101150274277, -0.07304304838180542, 0.017374316230416298, -0.02070481702685356, -0.03667348623275757, 0.009402645751833916, 0.002937931101769209, 0.022895600646734238, -0.04318252205848694, -0.013423305936157703, -0.0037958831526339054, 0.027910346165299416, -0.006819292902946472, -0.02877146378159523, -0.002073647454380989, 0.01001049391925335, 0.02960725501179695, -0.023440131917595863, 0.035077884793281555, 0.019147206097841263, -0.01347396057099104, 0.03049369901418686, 0.03740796819329262, 0.0018092970130965114, 0.016386564821004868, 0.010187783278524876, -0.02621343731880188, 0.005207862704992294, 0.04477812349796295, -0.03001248650252819, -0.01215695682913065, 0.0033874851651489735, -0.013562604784965515, -0.03568573296070099, 0.039864685386419296, 0.0018409558106213808, -0.03685077279806137, -0.02350344881415367, -0.03115220181643963, -0.01566474512219429, 0.003985835704952478, 0.0033494948875159025, -0.03999132290482521, 0.027885019779205322, -0.013435970060527325, 0.033355649560689926, 0.01739964447915554, -0.04082711413502693, -0.03403947874903679, -0.010877943597733974, 0.013499286957085133, -0.0310762207955122, 0.053541261702775955, 0.018995244055986404, -0.027885019779205322, -0.004948261193931103, 0.02449120208621025, -0.06119001284241676, 0.030645661056041718, 0.0030044144950807095, -0.015981333330273628, 0.02671997807919979, 0.03989001363515854, -0.02441522106528282, 0.05607396364212036, 0.0026498367078602314, -0.01798216439783573, 0.010922265239059925, 0.01600665971636772, -0.003510954324156046, -0.01591801457107067, -0.0006023075548000634, -0.056428540498018265, 0.026264091953635216, 0.00554661126807332, 0.04584185779094696, 0.019007908180356026, 0.013714566826820374, 0.019223187118768692, -0.004805796779692173, 0.012004994787275791, -0.03512853756546974, -0.022490369156003, -0.01463900227099657, 0.03963674232363701, 0.000905440014321357, 0.045461952686309814, -0.02127467468380928, -0.059721048921346664, 0.00787036307156086, 0.025504281744360924, -0.01938781328499317, -0.04561391472816467, 0.005160374566912651, -0.005150876939296722, -0.021287336945533752, 0.008370570838451385, 0.00748412637040019, -0.003169039962813258, -0.017374316230416298, -0.0276064220815897, 0.006901605520397425, 0.03254518657922745, 0.014385731890797615, -0.008585850708186626, 0.005758725106716156, -0.0019470126135274768, -0.030139122158288956, 0.009301338344812393, -0.0387502983212471, 0.002808130346238613, 0.016538526862859726, -0.013790547847747803, -0.02480779029428959, -0.021148039028048515, 0.014436385594308376, 0.003298840718343854, -0.006673662457615137, -0.006711652968078852, 0.019311832264065742, -0.029227349907159805, 0.0025437797885388136, -0.08327515423297882, -0.011644084937870502, -0.030316410586237907, -0.033684901893138885, 0.014398395083844662, -0.038952913135290146, 0.00706623075529933, 0.03576171398162842, 0.025782879441976547, 0.00819961354136467, 0.0012932595564052463, -0.015031570568680763, -0.010327081196010113, 0.0316334143280983, 0.06417860090732574, -0.035229846835136414, -0.01937514916062355, -0.02942996472120285, -0.018741974607110023, 0.0034856274724006653, -0.030544353649020195, -0.047209516167640686, -0.019932342693209648, 0.03155743330717087, -0.008357907645404339, 0.08302187919616699, -0.021730558946728706, -0.04789334163069725, -0.04260000213980675, 0.010371403768658638, -0.01937514916062355, 0.0037135703023523092, 0.06503971666097641, 0.05501022934913635, 0.04123234376311302, -0.061038050800561905, -0.027733057737350464, -0.05804946646094322, 0.03687610104680061, 0.03125350922346115, 0.008294589817523956, 0.029809869825839996, 0.035888347774744034, -0.04135897755622864, -0.0024598841555416584, 0.0007871154230087996, -0.014119798317551613, 0.008186950348317623, 0.0038813615683466196, 0.03766123950481415, 0.025415636599063873, 0.017374316230416298, 0.0015338660450652242, 0.037458620965480804, 0.03568573296070099, 0.00944063626229763, -0.012346909381449223, 0.051641739904880524, 0.03626825287938118, -0.05293341353535652, 0.026238763704895973, -0.022123128175735474, 0.02283228375017643, 0.026238763704895973, 0.016462545841932297, -0.05663115531206131, -0.02323751524090767, -0.0025089553091675043, 0.009535612538456917, 0.023440131917595863, 0.007401813752949238, -0.018729310482740402, 0.004011162556707859, 0.0013209609314799309, 0.00696492288261652, 0.01401849091053009, -0.004406896885484457, 0.007718401029706001, -0.006971254944801331, -0.020096968859434128, 0.013043400831520557, -0.004713986534625292, 0.04667764902114868, -0.017032403498888016, 0.0021939508151263, -0.007287842221558094, -0.007579102646559477, -0.018273424357175827, -0.05637788400053978, 0.019223187118768692, -0.07152342796325684, 0.018779965117573738, 0.011238853447139263, -0.03999132290482521, -0.02636539936065674, 0.03611629083752632, -0.01277113612741232, 0.028898099437355995, 0.013891855254769325, 0.03059500642120838, -0.02374405600130558, 0.006616676691919565, -0.01828608848154545, -0.015132877975702286, 0.05658050253987312, -0.03956076130270958, -0.05121117830276489, 0.06843353807926178, 0.017944173887372017, -0.0029315995052456856, 0.018931927159428596, -0.007547443732619286, 0.009326664730906487, -0.006287425756454468, 0.0034792956430464983, -0.011004578322172165, -0.0310762207955122, 0.004960924852639437, -0.009358324110507965, -0.00289519177749753, -0.009586267173290253, -0.0024028983898460865, 0.04700689762830734, -0.047943998128175735, 0.0003571501583792269, -0.016791796311736107, -0.02737847901880741, -0.033431630581617355, 0.036546848714351654, 0.019071225076913834, -0.04989417642354965, -0.00021607091184705496, 0.05237622186541557, 0.02958192676305771, 0.044651489704847336, 0.02103406749665737, -0.041257672011852264, 0.0010558189824223518, 0.08170487731695175, -0.004416394513100386, -0.005796715617179871, 0.035255175083875656, 0.019818371161818504, -0.016133293509483337, 0.024377230554819107, 0.012587515637278557, -0.035812366753816605, -0.009700237773358822, -0.02119869366288185, 0.028543520718812943, 0.05495957285165787, -0.022047147154808044, -0.015880024060606956, -0.01153644546866417, 0.0001346485805697739, -0.022123128175735474, -0.007648751605302095, -0.06686326116323471, 0.014563021250069141, -0.003650252940133214, 0.023110881447792053, -0.03419144079089165, 0.02851819433271885, 0.06027824431657791, 0.02993650548160076, -0.013587931171059608, 0.005293341353535652, -0.06139263138175011, 0.026998573914170265, 0.015094887465238571, -0.01961575634777546, -0.04032057151198387, 0.0012228188570588827, -0.012517865747213364, 0.010915934108197689, -0.004296090919524431, 0.014727646484971046, 0.0672684907913208, 0.02366807498037815, 0.023275505751371384, 0.021249346435070038, 0.003745228983461857, -0.03723067790269852, 0.0014768802793696523, -0.021616587415337563, 0.04510737583041191, 0.04146028682589531, -0.0003575459122657776, -0.013828538358211517, -0.014119798317551613, -0.025580262765288353, 0.014601011760532856, -0.006068980786949396, 0.007661415264010429, 0.035255175083875656, 0.04049786180257797, 0.00768674211576581, 0.019261177629232407, -0.03246920555830002, 0.06894007325172424, -0.015094887465238571, -0.05830273777246475, 0.0292526762932539, 0.009972503408789635, -0.03056968003511429, 0.028416885063052177, -0.056276578456163406, 0.0031025565695017576, 0.05501022934913635, -0.0008310419507324696, 0.037053391337394714, 0.03766123950481415, 0.039611417800188065, -0.003161125350743532, -0.03887693211436272, -0.04320785030722618, 0.03517919406294823, -0.015120214782655239, -0.04102972894906998, -0.008117301389575005, -0.08094506710767746, 0.016044650226831436, -0.025922177359461784, 0.022617004811763763, -0.004834289662539959, -0.001290885149501264, -0.030974911525845528, -0.0006268430734053254, 0.00510972086340189, 0.062101785093545914, 0.028239596635103226, 0.050071462988853455, -0.02669464983046055, -0.035812366753816605, -0.05941712483763695, -0.044398218393325806, 0.010928597301244736, 0.041333653032779694, -0.04556325823068619, 0.03001248650252819, 0.006749643478542566, -0.021705232560634613, 0.026568016037344933, -0.025934841483831406, 0.018893936648964882, -0.027505114674568176, 0.015778716653585434, 0.07582901418209076, -0.04303056001663208, 0.03806646913290024, -0.051970988512039185, 0.07937479764223099, -0.041662901639938354, -0.014816290698945522, -0.041840191930532455, 0.03718002513051033, -0.029531273990869522, 0.0034571345895528793, 0.03685077279806137, -0.003146878909319639, -0.002766974037513137, -0.023427467793226242, 0.007509453222155571, 0.015386148355901241, 0.03472330793738365, 0.0012805960141122341, -0.008300921879708767, 0.020464209839701653, 0.06174720823764801, -0.020502200350165367, -0.00548012787476182, -0.01624726504087448, 0.009510286152362823, 0.02679595910012722, -0.010365071706473827, -0.015588764101266861, 0.002985419239848852, -0.02274363860487938, 0.018172116950154305, -0.019223187118768692, 0.047766707837581635, -0.01682978682219982, 0.003567940089851618, -0.023136207833886147, -0.029708562418818474, -0.005641587544232607, -0.032519858330488205, -0.033583592623472214, 0.041738882660865784, -0.00038544516428373754, 0.02449120208621025, -0.009168371558189392, -0.02037556655704975, 0.017538942396640778, -0.037889182567596436, -0.009541944600641727, -0.013144709169864655, 0.020489536225795746, -0.02796100080013275, 0.00026197609258815646, 0.035812366753816605, 0.004622176289558411, 0.007249851711094379, -0.039282165467739105, -0.009782550856471062, 0.021477289497852325, -0.010358739644289017, -0.0186406672000885, -0.015056896954774857, -0.03766123950481415, 0.05480761080980301, 0.015880024060606956, 0.011644084937870502, 0.03229191526770592, 0.011682075448334217, 0.020058978348970413, 0.053794533014297485, 0.011561771854758263, -0.01722235418856144, 0.016715815290808678, 0.016538526862859726, -0.005451634991914034, -0.017956838011741638, 0.013993163593113422, 0.0016874108696356416, -0.013094055466353893, 0.03811712563037872, -0.02844221331179142, 0.013651248998939991, 0.032342568039894104, 0.006135464180260897, 0.013777883723378181, 0.06671129912137985, 0.03188668563961983, 0.013651248998939991, -0.009978835470974445, 0.03791450709104538, 0.04910903796553612, -0.022300416603684425, 0.00932033360004425, 0.018032819032669067, -0.0038813615683466196, -0.009453300386667252, 0.016272593289613724, -0.005540279671549797, 0.007211861200630665, 0.004593683406710625, 0.0030867273453623056, -0.0270492285490036, 0.03049369901418686, -0.0183747336268425, 0.00673698028549552, 0.017703568562865257, -0.03026575595140457, -0.0014634253457188606, 0.024047980085015297, -0.003352660685777664, -0.021793877705931664, -0.04895707592368126, -0.06478644907474518, -0.03725600615143776, 0.012049316428601742, -0.020172949880361557, -0.01567740924656391, 0.012479875236749649, 0.03733198717236519, 0.01088427472859621, -0.03636956214904785, -0.03231724351644516, 0.019489120692014694, 0.004641171544790268, 0.008028656244277954, 0.00123152497690171, 0.03059500642120838, -0.012676159851253033, 0.014119798317551613, 0.018425386399030685, 0.06412794440984726, -0.012555856257677078, -0.008503537625074387, 0.028391558676958084, 0.01484161801636219, 0.0007954258471727371, 0.003390651196241379, 0.0058695306070148945, -0.002489960053935647, 0.003021826734766364, 0.0024028983898460865, -0.012758472934365273, -0.028796790167689323, 0.020666826516389847, -0.011302170343697071, -0.012258264236152172, 0.004910270683467388, -0.007218192797154188, 0.02639072574675083, -0.02054019086062908, -0.010998246259987354, 0.007902021519839764, 0.001029700506478548, -0.007826040498912334, 0.004441721364855766, -0.013942509889602661, -0.024757135659456253, 0.013258680701255798, 0.0017159037524834275, 0.010384066961705685, -0.023630084469914436, -0.031101547181606293, 0.004220110364258289, -0.013056064955890179, -0.04634839668869972, -0.006888941861689091, 0.017437634989619255, 0.0310762207955122, 0.048678480088710785, -0.040345899760723114, -0.008978419005870819, 0.008737812750041485, -0.03462199866771698, 0.028467539697885513, 0.0020815622992813587, 0.013891855254769325, -0.015284840017557144, 0.0012513117399066687, 0.022566350176930428, -0.028062308207154274, 0.008972086943686008, 0.05308537557721138, -0.0025722726713865995, -0.0007966130506247282, -0.03791450709104538, -0.015411474741995335, 0.0035141203552484512, -0.030291084200143814, -0.04829857498407364, 0.032519858330488205, 0.04617110639810562, -0.0047361478209495544, -0.0202869214117527, -0.025858860462903976, 0.014740309678018093, 0.0017918847734108567, 0.004672829993069172, 0.0017095720395445824, -0.0004606346774380654, 0.0338115356862545, 0.02785969153046608, 0.026593342423439026, -0.006160791032016277, 0.005192033480852842, -0.01862800307571888, -0.0500967912375927, -0.017209691926836967, 0.003170622978359461, 0.002037239959463477, 0.024047980085015297, 0.02554227225482464, 0.0047361478209495544, -0.04667764902114868, 0.031278837472200394, 0.009010077454149723, 0.007610761094838381, -0.01928650587797165, 0.0117453932762146, 0.02447853796184063, -0.015183532610535622, 0.00915570743381977, -0.024035315960645676, 0.028138289228081703, -0.027834365144371986, 0.003700906876474619, 0.012251933105289936, 0.04082711413502693, 0.022110464051365852, -0.01582937128841877, 0.044068966060876846, 0.021629251539707184, 0.016753805801272392, 0.01546212937682867, -0.031456124037504196, 0.04320785030722618, -0.03231724351644516, 0.011859364807605743, 0.020388228818774223, 0.002475713612511754, 0.032849110662937164, 0.017842866480350494, 0.03723067790269852, 0.0066483356058597565, -0.010605677962303162, 0.009510286152362823, 0.019413139671087265, -0.010605677962303162, 0.012061980552971363, -0.0319879911839962, 0.0039288499392569065, 0.04016860947012901, 0.00027661825879476964, 0.012163287959992886, -0.05713769420981407, 0.0628615990281105, 0.028822118416428566, -0.023098217323422432, 0.03330499678850174, -0.002022993518039584, 0.015968669205904007, -0.01207464374601841, 0.002879362553358078, 0.005815710872411728, -0.017361653968691826, 0.011226189322769642, 0.016196612268686295, -0.014335078187286854, -0.030189774930477142, 0.029961831867694855, -0.02555493637919426, 0.002057818230241537, 0.004270764067769051, -0.008148959837853909, -0.004685493651777506, 0.028796790167689323, -0.006401397287845612, -0.00397633807733655, 0.0383957214653492, 0.010890606790781021, 0.008592181839048862, -0.032925091683864594, -0.029075387865304947, -0.026086801663041115, 0.013663912191987038, -0.034419383853673935, 0.035229846835136414, 0.024693818762898445, 0.02167990617454052, -0.003922517877072096, -0.024136623367667198, -0.008224940858781338, 0.009871195070445538, 0.012321582064032555, 0.06336813420057297, -0.004172622226178646, 0.04738680273294449, 0.031050892546772957, -0.01714637316763401, 0.006068980786949396, -0.018362069502472878, 0.012308918870985508, 0.002991751069203019, 0.016601843759417534, -0.0159053523093462, -0.02208513766527176, -0.028543520718812943, 0.006195615511387587, -0.06108870729804039, -0.005166706629097462, 0.04376504197716713, -0.020160285755991936, 0.03176004812121391, -0.0034761298447847366, -0.029404638335108757, -0.0011333829024806619, 0.016348574310541153, -0.006217776797711849, -0.004286593291908503, -0.03479928895831108, 0.0026371730491518974, 0.017121046781539917, -0.002271514618769288, 0.01937514916062355, 0.01529750321060419, 0.021059393882751465, 0.03662282973527908, -0.015170868486166, 0.029303330928087234, 0.029708562418818474, 0.027885019779205322, -0.008478211238980293, 0.04417027533054352, 0.014816290698945522, -0.006509037222713232, -0.00043174606980755925, 0.01986902579665184, 0.010162455961108208, 0.01380321104079485, -0.0155381103977561, 0.04244804009795189, -0.007186534348875284, 0.011112217791378498, 0.0042992569506168365, -0.013043400831520557, 0.02851819433271885, 0.027023902162909508, -0.016538526862859726, -0.005343995522707701, 0.03814245015382767, 0.019641082733869553, 0.0118783600628376, -0.04143495857715607, 0.0008397481287829578, -0.015196195803582668, -0.015842033550143242, 0.01575339026749134, 0.02851819433271885, 0.0032291915267705917, -0.028974080458283424, 0.0008215443231165409, 0.019083889201283455, 0.016551189124584198, -0.010694323107600212, -0.03431807458400726, 0.0038465370889753103, -0.0009648001287132502, -0.024541856721043587, -0.017273008823394775, -0.013372652232646942, -0.015842033550143242, 0.021148039028048515, -0.02416195161640644, -0.039535436779260635, -0.004628507886081934, -0.023794708773493767, -0.0028540354687720537, -0.04211878776550293, -0.040447209030389786, -0.007629756350070238, -0.0017174866516143084, 0.03340630233287811, -0.011549108661711216, -0.10657598823308945, -0.009295006282627583, 0.018412724137306213, 0.023971999064087868, 0.031101547181606293, 0.03925683721899986, 0.03766123950481415, 0.01614595763385296, -0.004049153067171574, -0.020147623494267464, 0.009630588814616203, -0.022047147154808044, -0.010903269983828068, -0.02061617188155651, 0.008972086943686008, -0.045132700353860855, -0.021705232560634613, 0.03667348623275757, 0.001415145699866116, -0.009257015772163868, 0.004805796779692173, -0.00635074358433485, 0.020818788558244705, 0.00476464070379734, -0.01026376336812973, 0.021540608257055283, -0.002469381783157587, 0.004216944333165884, 0.01985636167228222, 0.004273930098861456, -0.004216944333165884, 0.025086386129260063, -0.014512366615235806, 0.043081216514110565, -0.0036407553125172853, -0.01969173736870289, -0.010111802257597446, 0.03543246164917946, -0.023440131917595863, -0.0049292659386992455, 0.030139122158288956, -0.007471462711691856, 0.012479875236749649, 0.024427885189652443, 0.018729310482740402, 0.015348157845437527, -0.026593342423439026, 0.025491617619991302, 0.020730143412947655, 0.046297743916511536, 0.02687194012105465, -0.004384735599160194, 0.005084394011646509, 0.04135897755622864, -0.0012726814020425081, 0.05718835070729256, -0.013284008018672466, -0.0010138711659237742, -0.0022461877670139074, -0.007826040498912334, -0.015398811548948288, -0.004261266440153122, 0.0045335316099226475, -0.05516219139099121, -0.03191201016306877, -0.024009989574551582, -0.0533892996609211, 0.037281334400177, -0.008725148625671864, -0.0026625001337379217, 0.023592093959450722, 0.03535648062825203, -0.014512366615235806, -0.004128299653530121, 0.017121046781539917, 0.003900356823578477, 0.036065638065338135, -0.018577348440885544, -0.03725600615143776, 0.031962666660547256, 0.009668579325079918, -0.02531432919204235, 0.00910505373030901, -0.008921433240175247, -0.011821374297142029, 0.018083473667502403, -0.006119634490460157, -0.010365071706473827, 0.011466795578598976, -0.012251933105289936, 0.004498707130551338, -0.03991534188389778, 0.02687194012105465, -0.0034128122497349977, -0.0030455708038061857, 0.024516528472304344, 0.004296090919524431, -0.06321617215871811, -0.004460716620087624, -0.004147294908761978, 0.028138289228081703, -0.017842866480350494, -0.009579935111105442, -0.0603288970887661, -0.00911138579249382, 0.014385731890797615, -0.007433472201228142, 0.021717896685004234, 0.0028413720428943634, 0.0200209878385067, 0.031962666660547256, 0.0709155797958374, -0.006983918137848377, 0.026238763704895973, 0.03940879926085472, 0.010156123898923397, -0.009579935111105442, -0.015702735632658005, -0.00727517856284976, -0.013613258488476276, 0.002779637463390827, 0.028568847104907036, -0.02636539936065674, -0.01936248503625393, 0.017665578052401543, -0.004805796779692173, 0.00045074132503941655, -0.044474199414253235, -0.0184633769094944, 0.0191978607326746, 0.014866944402456284, 0.010415725409984589, -0.0001470152783440426, -0.005571938585489988, -0.01936248503625393, 0.03173472359776497, -0.004907104652374983, 0.04541129618883133, 0.011713733896613121, 0.031937338411808014, -0.013018074445426464, -0.008687158115208149, 0.03887693211436272, -0.02497241459786892, -0.023110881447792053, -0.005524450447410345, -0.02176854945719242, -0.012992747128009796, 0.025529608130455017, 0.0022604342084378004, -0.0010423640487715602, 0.036901429295539856, 0.01705772988498211, 0.006125966552644968, 0.0026830784045159817, 0.01707039400935173, 0.007756391540169716, 0.007712069433182478, -0.033684901893138885, 0.017095720395445824, 0.07233389467000961, 0.0385730117559433, 0.015487455762922764, -0.012169620022177696, 0.013663912191987038, 0.003849702887237072, -0.006717985030263662, 0.017121046781539917, -0.003593267174437642, -0.00856685545295477, -0.012163287959992886, -0.03148145228624344, 0.019223187118768692, 0.05268014594912529, -0.030848277732729912, 0.013651248998939991, -0.04903305694460869, 0.0007063856464810669, -0.012834453955292702, 0.0012544776545837522, -0.012112634256482124, 0.01096025574952364, 0.007395481690764427, -0.03497657552361488, 0.030468372628092766, 0.004486043471843004, -0.01021944172680378, -0.017412306740880013, 0.00506856432184577, 0.006015160586684942, -0.02811296284198761, 0.04548727720975876, 0.01463900227099657, 0.005198365077376366, -0.006585018243640661, 0.019109215587377548, -0.0194637943059206, 0.005315502639859915, -0.019159870222210884, -0.014727646484971046, -0.04434756562113762, 0.0061006392352283, 0.025681570172309875, -0.0028635330963879824, -0.04280261695384979, -0.020084304735064507, -0.018235433846712112, 0.003232357557862997, 0.007294173818081617, -0.025289002805948257, 0.002469381783157587, 0.005524450447410345, 0.004353076685220003, 0.0233134962618351, 0.03295041620731354, -0.02200915664434433, 0.01268882304430008, -0.016627170145511627, -0.019324496388435364, -0.016855113208293915, -0.005021076183766127, -0.06255767494440079, 0.0044733802787959576, 0.08758074045181274, -0.013195362873375416, 0.03322901576757431, -0.0037040726747363806, -0.028315577656030655, -0.03715469688177109, 0.006474212743341923, 0.024263259023427963, -0.013271343894302845, -0.01814679056406021, -0.000852411612868309, -0.027885019779205322, -0.044803451746702194, -0.02661866880953312, 0.010770304128527641, -0.002766974037513137, -0.004365740343928337, 0.0031532105058431625, -0.008110969327390194, 0.00013316457625478506, 0.0008587433258071542, -0.013917182572185993, 0.006787633989006281, 0.04277729243040085, -0.003621760057285428, 0.021072058007121086, 0.03520451858639717, -0.030063141137361526, -0.016437217593193054, -0.01227725949138403, 0.01861533895134926, -0.027733057737350464, 0.04817194119095802, -0.013423305936157703, 0.005201531108468771, 0.013334661722183228, 0.018425386399030685, 0.026264091953635216, -0.02621343731880188, -0.004026991780847311, -0.010479043237864971, 0.04087776690721512, -0.01001049391925335, -0.03188668563961983, 0.006888941861689091, 0.011067896150052547, 0.019109215587377548, 0.008712485432624817, -0.04219476878643036, -0.003339997259899974, -0.01970439963042736, -0.021869858726859093, 0.0011959089897572994, 0.005739729851484299, -0.017678240314126015, -0.037281334400177, 0.04260000213980675, 0.007503121625632048, -0.018362069502472878, -0.04475279524922371, 0.01606997661292553, -0.004422726109623909, 0.0270492285490036, -0.0003403314622119069, -0.03183602914214134, 0.04037122800946236, -0.00469815731048584, 0.004007996525615454, 0.035913676023483276, -0.03229191526770592, -0.009377319365739822, 0.010953924618661404, -0.024921759963035583, 0.019919680431485176, 0.013866528868675232, 0.01952711120247841, -0.017121046781539917, 0.007351159583777189, 0.0032070304732769728, -0.002198699628934264, -0.00444805296137929, -0.013157372362911701, -0.0023316661827266216, -0.03593900427222252, -0.003954176791012287, -0.014854281209409237, -0.004353076685220003, -0.005625758320093155, -0.03388751670718193, -0.015132877975702286, 0.004812128841876984, -0.008174287155270576, -0.03978870436549187, -0.01491759903728962, 0.01888127252459526, -0.015436802059412003, -0.010991915129125118, -0.05047669634222984, 0.010814625769853592, -0.0013447050005197525, 0.016107967123389244, -0.018362069502472878, 0.019894352182745934, 0.003352660685777664, 0.019603092223405838, -0.0008144211024045944, 0.020882105454802513, 0.008338912390172482, 0.015512783080339432, -0.016373900696635246, -0.01125151664018631, 0.016348574310541153, 0.030873604118824005, 0.0076170931570231915, 0.0024867940228432417, -0.010048484429717064, 0.005233190022408962, -0.009712901897728443, 0.006106971297413111, -0.008098306134343147, -0.016057312488555908, 0.03431807458400726, -0.022389061748981476, 0.00541997654363513, -0.02546629123389721, -0.01075764000415802, -0.012707818299531937, 0.06539429724216461, 0.0026830784045159817, -0.0013265012530609965, 0.0017238184809684753, 0.007357491180300713, -0.02233840711414814, -0.005606763064861298, 0.016943758353590965, 0.019248515367507935, -0.026922592893242836, -0.003529949579387903, 0.014525030739605427, -0.008471879176795483, 0.019159870222210884, -0.008224940858781338, -0.01537348423153162, -0.008718817494809628, 0.02606147527694702, -0.02654268778860569, -0.02292092889547348, 0.001973922597244382, -0.014879608526825905, -0.003723067929968238, 0.0008144211024045944, -0.012581183575093746, -0.016209274530410767, 0.03229191526770592, -0.05242687463760376, 0.0332796685397625, 0.002795466920360923, -0.00861750915646553, -0.009541944600641727, 0.004587351344525814, -0.0007661415147595108, -0.029455292969942093, -0.020096968859434128, 0.006170288659632206, 0.00849720649421215, 0.00799699779599905, 0.012137961573898792, 0.005302838981151581, 0.006445719860494137, 0.0030044144950807095, -0.014664328657090664, -0.022287754341959953, 0.02669464983046055, -0.019932342693209648, 0.031025566160678864, -0.015183532610535622, -0.013765220530331135, -0.020426219329237938, 0.012676159851253033, 0.017766885459423065, -0.012809126637876034, -0.013043400831520557, -0.004625341854989529, 0.02003365196287632, 0.015208858996629715, 0.04095374792814255, -0.005992999766021967, -0.01747562550008297, -0.019096553325653076, -0.017526278272271156, 0.03378620743751526, 0.0488051138818264, 0.005758725106716156, 0.022034483030438423, -0.006496373564004898, 0.0036629163660109043, -0.010871611535549164, -0.014575684443116188, -0.009877527132630348, 0.008965755812823772, -0.03484994173049927, -0.01831141486763954, -0.013068728148937225, 0.01895725354552269, 0.055111534893512726, -0.008915101177990437, 0.051312487572431564, -0.03287443518638611, -0.00260551436804235, -0.030189774930477142, 0.02102140337228775, -0.050502024590969086, 0.02333882451057434, 0.0506286583840847, -0.038623664528131485, -0.04077645763754845, 0.020920095965266228, 0.002214528853073716, -0.006996581796556711, -0.008478211238980293, 0.03279845416545868, 0.02983519807457924, 0.020261595025658607, -0.002222443697974086, 0.002489960053935647, 0.011783383786678314, -0.014854281209409237, 0.0050907256081700325, 0.00952928140759468, 0.0491596944630146, -0.022477706894278526, 0.00714854383841157, -0.0089087700471282, 0.01813412643969059, -0.03735731542110443, 0.0015085389604791999, -0.005992999766021967, 0.04016860947012901, 0.014373068697750568, -0.00305031961761415, 0.0062810941599309444, -0.006534364074468613, 0.021831868216395378, -0.0005156417610123754, -0.015411474741995335, -0.007496790029108524, 0.02537764608860016, -0.010941260494291782, 0.010200446471571922, -0.0064425538294017315, -0.025339655578136444, -0.011618757620453835, -0.006572354584932327, 0.023212188854813576, -0.005188867449760437, 0.035888347774744034, 0.011985999532043934, -0.002002415480092168, 0.00980787817388773, 0.03826908767223358, 0.006698989775031805, 0.008598513901233673, 0.010858948342502117, 0.01096658781170845, -0.00513504771515727, 0.05490892007946968, 0.018425386399030685, -0.015018906444311142, -0.02811296284198761, -0.04791866987943649, -0.029885850846767426, -0.0043879016302526, -0.0502740815281868, -0.016348574310541153, -0.005416810512542725, 0.02793567255139351, 0.003564774291589856, -0.01227725949138403, 0.004957758821547031, -0.0074271406047046185, 0.029860524460673332, 0.011359156109392643, -0.022617004811763763, -0.028163615614175797, -0.003545779036357999, -0.001769723603501916, -0.01904589869081974, -0.020261595025658607, -0.006274762563407421, 0.0028255425859242678, -0.0007139046210795641, 0.041333653032779694, -0.033583592623472214, 0.004115636460483074, 0.024275923147797585, -0.024845780804753304, 0.02844221331179142, -0.045132700353860855, -0.021806539967656136, 0.02859417535364628, -0.015588764101266861, -0.04130832478404045, 0.005936014000326395, 0.03393816947937012, -0.0022952586878091097, -0.016703151166439056, 0.007762723136693239, -0.021224020048975945, -0.05072996765375137, 0.013790547847747803, 0.03634423390030861, 0.0030677320901304483, 0.0167284794151783, -0.01567740924656391, 0.015474792569875717, -0.019679073244333267, -0.029556600376963615, 0.019489120692014694, -0.0038402052596211433, 0.03642021492123604, 0.035660404711961746, 0.010434720665216446, 0.04796932265162468, -0.024263259023427963, -0.005499123129993677, -0.0013114633038640022, 0.013321998529136181, -0.03586302325129509, -0.024769799783825874, 0.00012376588711049408, -0.018362069502472878, -0.006996581796556711, 0.020996076986193657, 0.002322168555110693, 0.004353076685220003, 0.018995244055986404, 0.011688407510519028, -0.01096025574952364, -0.0004827957891393453, 0.006290591787546873, -0.0036312576849013567, -0.012169620022177696, 0.026669323444366455, -0.010314418002963066, 0.004429057706147432, 0.000866658054292202, -0.002732149325311184, 0.027150535956025124, 0.011777051724493504, 0.00034923548810184, -0.004685493651777506, 0.039180856198072433, 0.028796790167689323, 0.016525862738490105, 0.016867777332663536, -0.01429708767682314, 0.005397815257310867, 0.0054611326195299625, -0.01821010746061802, -0.0006565231597051024, -0.00911138579249382, 0.006122800521552563, 0.024123961105942726, -0.024098632857203484, -0.014740309678018093, -0.03231724351644516, 0.0024234766606241465, 0.02266765758395195, -0.00568907568231225, 0.005597265437245369, 0.013663912191987038, -0.006882610265165567, 0.04227074980735779, 0.016196612268686295, -0.004425892140716314, -0.029075387865304947, -0.031785376369953156, -0.014259097166359425, 0.027429133653640747, -0.026669323444366455, -0.03859833627939224, 0.007591766305267811, -0.045867182314395905, 0.002029325347393751, -0.05237622186541557, 0.012840785086154938, -0.01298008393496275, -0.020806124433875084, -0.004280261695384979, 0.018729310482740402, 0.007040903903543949, 0.017956838011741638, -0.012758472934365273, -0.03241854906082153, 0.01788085699081421, -0.01771623082458973, 0.012169620022177696, -0.009370987303555012, -0.037281334400177, 0.0087758032605052, -0.008167955093085766, -0.023060226812958717, 0.04006730392575264, 0.014854281209409237, -0.04938763752579689, -0.0014832119923084974, -0.009776218794286251, -0.04639904946088791, 0.005578270182013512, 0.016791796311736107, -0.010770304128527641, -0.029911179095506668, 0.004463882651180029, -0.017500951886177063, 0.025668907910585403, 0.02661866880953312, 0.0037388973869383335, 0.008275594562292099, 0.041105709969997406, -0.02389601804316044, -0.02793567255139351, -0.020324911922216415, -0.00034132078872062266, -0.02051486447453499, -0.03576171398162842, 0.010390399023890495, -0.031101547181606293, 0.028492866083979607, -0.00090939732035622, -0.015588764101266861, 0.009896522387862206, 0.00174123072065413, 0.004755143076181412, -0.0009070229134522378, -0.05784685164690018, -0.01034607645124197, -0.008870779536664486, 0.02589685097336769, -0.01208097580820322, 0.0023664908949285746, 0.023098217323422432, 0.011694738641381264, -0.0026150119956582785, -0.002980670426040888, 0.04032057151198387, 0.026264091953635216, 0.007325832732021809, -0.03414078801870346, 0.012859780341386795, 0.017361653968691826, 0.012055648490786552, 0.05202164128422737, -0.0371040441095829, -0.015943342819809914, 0.024250594899058342, 0.04888109490275383, 0.02473180927336216, 0.031608086079359055, -0.03406480699777603, 0.02694792114198208, 0.01937514916062355, -0.029531273990869522, -0.011194530874490738, 0.0016399227315559983, 0.03100023977458477, -0.02785969153046608, -0.011333828791975975, 0.010612010024487972, -0.020134959369897842, 0.0015045816544443369, -0.012454548850655556, -0.02826492302119732, -0.005644753575325012, 0.015424138866364956, -0.02671997807919979, -0.026669323444366455, -0.013625921681523323, -0.01199866272509098, -0.009383650496602058, 0.00915570743381977, -0.008579518646001816, 0.03940879926085472, 0.0056479196064174175, -0.0053091710433363914, 0.010295422747731209, 0.008750475943088531, 0.005100223235785961, -0.011276843957602978, 0.00915570743381977, -0.008237604051828384, -0.005492791533470154, -0.0027432299684733152, 0.009712901897728443, -0.02563091740012169, 0.0013668661704286933, -0.014651665464043617, -0.03373555466532707, 0.021743223071098328, 0.004318252205848694, -0.00910505373030901, 0.02414928749203682, -0.04391700401902199, -0.051388468593358994, 0.013448633253574371, 0.02176854945719242, 0.008351575583219528, -0.0183747336268425, 0.05070463940501213, 0.0010890606790781021, 0.012441884726285934, -0.016044650226831436, 0.005030573811382055, -0.0044892095029354095, 0.007737396284937859, 0.00011575227108551189, 0.009446968324482441 ]
13.371157
5.447751
2024-06-01
1
2024A&A...686L..16I
[ "EDR catalog sources", "X-ray sources", "virial shock physics", "EDR catalog clusters", "bright sources", "virial-shock X-ray sources", "MCXC clusters", "galaxy clusters", "EDR redshifts", "Localized virial-shock spikes" ]
[ "shock waves", "methods: statistical", "catalogs", "large-scale structure of Universe", "X-rays: galaxies: clusters", "Astrophysics - High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
8
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202449819", "10.48550/arXiv.2402.17822" ]
[ "Ilani, Gideon", "Hou, Kuan-Chou", "Nadler, Gil", "Keshet, Uri" ]
[ "Physics Department, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, PO Box 653, Be'er-Sheva, 84105, Israel", "Physics Department, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, PO Box 653, Be'er-Sheva, 84105, Israel", "Physics Department, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, PO Box 653, Be'er-Sheva, 84105, Israel", "Physics Department, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, PO Box 653, Be'er-Sheva, 84105, Israel" ]
[ "2024arXiv240413111K" ]
[ "2011A&A...534A.109P", "2017ApJ...845...24K", "2018ApJ...869...53K", "2019A&A...622A.136H", "2020ApJ...895...72K", "2021ApJ...920..104P", "2022A&A...661A...1B", "2022A&A...661A...2L", "2022A&A...661A...7B", "2022MNRAS.514.1645A", "2023MNRAS.521.5786H", "2024arXiv240216946I" ]
28997956
2310.11422
A Full Accounting of the Visible Mass in SDSS MaNGA Disk Galaxies
We present a study of the ratio of visible mass to total mass in spiral galaxies to better understand the relative amount of dark matter present in galaxies of different masses and evolutionary stages. Using the velocities of the Hα emission line measured in spectroscopic observations from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) MaNGA Data Release 17 (DR 17), we evaluate the rotational velocity of over 5500 disk galaxies at their 90% elliptical Petrosian radii, R <SUB>90</SUB>. We compare this to the velocity expected from the total visible mass, which we compute from the stellar, H I, H<SUB>2</SUB>, and heavy metals and dust masses. H<SUB>2</SUB> mass measurements are available for only a small subset of galaxies observed in SDSS MaNGA DR17, so we derive a parameterization of the H<SUB>2</SUB> mass as a function of absolute magnitude in the r band using galaxies observed as part of SDSS DR7. With these parameterizations, we calculate the fraction of visible mass within R <SUB>90</SUB> that corresponds to the observed velocity. Based on statistically analyzing the likelihood of this fraction, we conclude that the null hypothesis (no dark matter) cannot be excluded at a confidence level better than 95% within the visible extent of the disk galaxies. We also find that when all mass components are included, the ratio of visible to total mass within the visible extent of star-forming disk galaxies increases with galaxy luminosity.
[ 0.02638610266149044, 0.007874967530369759, 0.016368724405765533, 0.0011361493961885571, 0.0038820260670036077, 0.017874833196401596, -0.033858273178339005, 0.010606979951262474, 0.017045889049768448, 0.026549557223916054, -0.022825146093964577, 0.004369468428194523, -0.021097207441926003, -0.000005102228442410706, 0.030262291431427002, 0.05468694865703583, -0.03285419940948486, 0.01726771891117096, -0.039065442979335785, 0.030682601034641266, 0.010647843591868877, 0.013158025220036507, -0.003368314355611801, 0.00824857596307993, -0.04959653317928314, -0.0026298537850379944, 0.02119060978293419, 0.015072769485414028, 0.017045889049768448, -0.025171874091029167, -0.02720337174832821, -0.029445022344589233, -0.0455101877450943, -0.07056531310081482, -0.03920554369688034, 0.08550965040922165, -0.032760798931121826, 0.004532922059297562, -0.026339402422308922, -0.01071205735206604, -0.04471627250313759, 0.019030684605240822, -0.022801795974373817, 0.021494165062904358, 0.007927506230771542, 0.006503123324364424, 0.020700247958302498, -0.0564148873090744, 0.019287539646029472, -0.017874833196401596, -0.08761119842529297, -0.005755906458944082, 0.038271524012088776, 0.015528104268014431, -0.0009332916233688593, 0.007326229941099882, -0.014605758711695671, 0.013134675100445747, -0.03476894274353981, -0.01936926692724228, -0.013123000040650368, -0.025919092819094658, 0.016006790101528168, -0.002933410694822669, -0.006970134098082781, -0.01126079447567463, -0.024214502424001694, -0.0019614447373896837, 0.03455878794193268, 0.012235679663717747, 0.00981306191533804, -0.014290526509284973, 0.026759712025523186, 0.006368857808411121, 0.008055933751165867, -0.010904698632657528, 0.0020198212005198, -0.017302745953202248, -0.047915294766426086, 0.005609965417534113, 0.014804238453507423, 0.008371165953576565, 0.0015761610120534897, 0.013940268196165562, -0.04544013738632202, 0.007945018820464611, 0.038248173892498016, -0.002936329459771514, -0.04810209944844246, -0.008330303244292736, 0.032503943890333176, -0.0031669160816818476, -0.014664134941995144, -0.013368180021643639, -0.004900692962110043, -0.037267450243234634, -0.0010821513133123517, -0.03133641555905342, 0.06598860770463943, 0.017699703574180603, 0.004351955838501453, 0.0434553436934948, 0.03579636663198471, -0.017092591151595116, 0.015855012461543083, -0.020805325359106064, 0.03642683103680611, 0.02848765067756176, 0.0274368766695261, -0.006123677361756563, 0.06542819738388062, -0.004092181101441383, -0.011914609931409359, 0.012749391607940197, -0.023303832858800888, 0.009848087094724178, -0.027226721867918968, 0.03792126476764679, -0.036216676235198975, -0.029631827026605606, -0.0034354471135884523, -0.010542766191065311, -0.004220609087496996, -0.04361879453063011, 0.05221179127693176, 0.007921668700873852, -0.023350533097982407, -0.014944341033697128, -0.03789791464805603, 0.07827098667621613, 0.006503123324364424, -0.010221695527434349, 0.03897203877568245, -0.03708064556121826, -0.02643280290067196, 0.024868318811058998, 0.026969866827130318, 0.004308173432946205, 0.015002717263996601, 0.05599457770586014, -0.006234592292457819, -0.011967148631811142, 0.0034879858139902353, 0.05277220532298088, -0.006438909564167261, -0.005142955109477043, -0.042754825204610825, 0.017337771132588387, -0.014477330259978771, 0.006345507223159075, -0.035189252346754074, -0.01775808073580265, 0.002813739236444235, -0.002105926163494587, 0.004200177267193794, 0.0019059872720390558, 0.045346736907958984, 0.015189521946012974, -0.0015469727804884315, -0.02374749258160591, -0.025288628414273262, 0.005230519454926252, 0.007343742530792952, -0.006812517996877432, -0.024961719289422035, 0.03978930786252022, -0.015189521946012974, -0.024121100082993507, -0.06085148826241493, -0.04936302825808525, -0.016894111409783363, 0.02687646448612213, -0.002415320836007595, -0.0748618096113205, 0.014582407660782337, 0.018446920439600945, 0.04735488072037697, -0.033858273178339005, 0.021634269505739212, 0.00028093610308133066, -0.009118382818996906, 0.036450181156396866, 0.03612327575683594, -0.0350024476647377, -0.043525394052267075, 0.016111867502331734, 0.0019847953226417303, 0.045089878141880035, 0.011663591489195824, 0.004877342842519283, 0.025802338495850563, 0.007921668700873852, 0.02561553567647934, 0.015446377918124199, -0.06304644048213959, -0.013765139505267143, 0.0038557567168027163, 0.0292348675429821, -0.012550911866128445, 0.0292348675429821, 0.039836008101701736, -0.024004347622394562, 0.044599518179893494, -0.11647246032953262, -0.0784577950835228, -0.004956150893121958, 0.022614991292357445, -0.0032603181898593903, 0.005002851597964764, 0.011739480309188366, 0.016298672184348106, 0.01722101867198944, -0.022661693394184113, -0.00476642744615674, -0.017127616330981255, 0.01438392885029316, -0.0419142059981823, 0.035119201987981796, 0.0910203754901886, 0.04959653317928314, -0.02900136262178421, 0.02094542793929577, 0.030635898932814598, 0.011132366955280304, 0.02269671857357025, 0.017115941271185875, 0.0730871707201004, -0.01591338776051998, 0.01826011762022972, 0.02324545569717884, 0.039298947900533676, 0.005014527123421431, -0.05860983952879906, 0.028861260041594505, 0.02349063567817211, -0.012515885755419731, -0.0010281532304361463, 0.03005213662981987, -0.029701879248023033, 0.02269671857357025, -0.00966712087392807, 0.04684117063879967, 0.02507847361266613, 0.03525930643081665, -0.01727939397096634, 0.023152053356170654, 0.0026079625822603703, -0.0020694411359727383, 0.010122456587851048, 0.01859869994223118, 0.015061094425618649, -0.029118115082383156, -0.010303422808647156, -0.02144746482372284, -0.03266739472746849, 0.032270438969135284, -0.08083954453468323, 0.06318654119968414, -0.01461743377149105, 0.039836008101701736, -0.05496715381741524, 0.031710024923086166, -0.027530279010534286, 0.012317406013607979, -0.030916105955839157, 0.04679447039961815, 0.004007535520941019, -0.009702146984636784, -0.0429416298866272, 0.008131823502480984, -0.008412029594182968, -0.010904698632657528, 0.033811572939157486, -0.03528265655040741, -0.02904806286096573, 0.012854469008743763, -0.023852569982409477, 0.04135379567742348, 0.029468372464179993, -0.008569645695388317, 0.02615259774029255, -0.01370676327496767, 0.023875920102000237, 0.03364811837673187, -0.0256388857960701, 0.03502580150961876, 0.022579966112971306, 0.033064354211091995, -0.008347815833985806, -0.04205431044101715, 0.07915830612182617, -0.03525930643081665, 0.04084008187055588, -0.02507847361266613, -0.021295687183737755, -0.0023467286955565214, 0.013403206132352352, 0.01802661083638668, -0.0017323177307844162, 0.04434266313910484, 0.017302745953202248, 0.014337227679789066, 0.015819987282156944, 0.028137393295764923, -0.020256588235497475, 0.023630740121006966, 0.0324338898062706, 0.015352975577116013, -0.0392288975417614, 0.03404507786035538, -0.015831662341952324, 0.01824844256043434, 0.017874833196401596, 0.03780451416969299, -0.05095086246728897, -0.023934297263622284, -0.03712734952569008, 0.076402947306633, 0.017606301233172417, -0.029725229367613792, -0.01649715192615986, 0.005288895685225725, -0.049549832940101624, 0.0021073855459690094, 0.005989411845803261, -0.05618138238787651, -0.02199620194733143, -0.04492642730474472, -0.03577301651239395, -0.04266142472624779, 0.019240839406847954, 0.01369508821517229, 0.0748618096113205, 0.00555158918723464, 0.010122456587851048, -0.029912034049630165, 0.014932665973901749, 0.032013580203056335, -0.04212436079978943, 0.01161105278879404, 0.017302745953202248, -0.013975294306874275, 0.013963619247078896, -0.017898183315992355, -0.005023283418267965, 0.01267933938652277, -0.03166332468390465, 0.02510182373225689, 0.03432528302073479, 0.0073028793558478355, 0.0028735750820487738, 0.0058434708043932915, 0.044809672981500626, -0.02349063567817211, 0.07262016087770462, -0.025942442938685417, 0.024237854406237602, -0.0882183164358139, 0.016357049345970154, -0.0031727536115795374, -0.00516630569472909, -0.026222648099064827, 0.029678527265787125, 0.00510209146887064, 0.03946240246295929, 0.05781592056155205, -0.01987130381166935, -0.008884877897799015, 0.04574369639158249, -0.0360298715531826, -0.004074668046087027, 0.0110915033146739, -0.0012426861794665456, 0.00966712087392807, -0.0502503477036953, -0.01266766432672739, 0.020501768216490746, -0.006281293462961912, -0.005954386200755835, -0.012445834465324879, 0.03887863829731941, -0.0021394926588982344, 0.0029261137824505568, -0.04520663246512413, -0.013905243016779423, 0.05118436738848686, 0.02243986167013645, -0.034371986985206604, -0.04992343857884407, 0.0017512900521978736, -0.00016819681331980973, 0.026035845279693604, 0.009229298681020737, 0.01409204676747322, -0.03528265655040741, -0.03612327575683594, 0.009468641132116318, 0.04581374675035477, 0.003023894038051367, 0.02009313367307186, -0.016275322064757347, -0.029211517423391342, -0.056554991751909256, -0.024961719289422035, -0.0034792295191437006, -0.0002931586350314319, -0.016100192442536354, 0.02374749258160591, 0.0015717827482149005, 0.0033099381253123283, 0.03710399568080902, -0.0019249595934525132, 0.02042004093527794, -0.022369811311364174, 0.00034150155261158943, 0.05207169055938721, -0.01476921234279871, 0.061832211911678314, -0.027576979249715805, 0.03845832869410515, -0.009048331528902054, 0.019415969029068947, 0.011050639674067497, -0.008966605179011822, -0.024167802184820175, 0.011360034346580505, 0.03981265798211098, 0.06379365921020508, -0.027810486033558846, -0.014675810001790524, -0.03416183218359947, 0.07009830325841904, 0.028604403138160706, 0.022906873375177383, -0.001830098102800548, -0.04630410671234131, 0.014734186232089996, -0.04415585845708847, 0.04214771091938019, -0.02270839363336563, 0.059683963656425476, -0.023700790479779243, 0.014652459882199764, -0.04618735611438751, 0.026783062145113945, -0.02095710299909115, 0.030425744131207466, 0.04315178468823433, 0.02328048087656498, -0.046607665717601776, -0.011132366955280304, -0.008511269465088844, -0.02430790476500988, -0.015446377918124199, -0.030262291431427002, -0.032013580203056335, 0.009439453482627869, -0.01803828775882721, 0.011832882650196552, -0.04597720131278038, 0.01321640145033598, 0.028137393295764923, -0.03876188397407532, -0.008312789723277092, -0.04945642873644829, -0.001882636803202331, -0.013239752501249313, -0.0003394948726054281, 0.02718002162873745, -0.0037039783783257008, 0.03502580150961876, -0.06823025643825531, 0.04098018631339073, -0.00103034230414778, -0.021237310022115707, 0.01266766432672739, -0.059450458735227585, -0.005323921795934439, 0.04438936337828636, 0.007232827600091696, 0.0548737533390522, -0.02664295770227909, -0.028581053018569946, -0.021902799606323242, 0.04359544441103935, 0.05646159127354622, -0.0006187891121953726, 0.019019009545445442, -0.018120013177394867, -0.005922278854995966, -0.0475650355219841, -0.055807773023843765, 0.05664839223027229, -0.010029054246842861, 0.0037039783783257008, -0.02037334069609642, 0.00011976269888691604, -0.0365435853600502, -0.03785121440887451, 0.02040836587548256, 0.02792723849415779, -0.016333697363734245, 0.02559218369424343, -0.0092935124412179, 0.019415969029068947, 0.044599518179893494, -0.007186126429587603, -0.05249200016260147, -0.028674455359578133, 0.033321212977170944, -0.012924520298838615, 0.04210101068019867, 0.004203096032142639, -0.013064623810350895, -0.005189655814319849, 0.00917092151939869, 0.00876228790730238, 0.012854469008743763, 0.015761610120534897, 0.013835190795361996, -0.014407278969883919, 0.008849851787090302, -0.005180899519473314, 0.007203639484941959, 0.006538149435073137, -0.02582569047808647, -0.01475753728300333, -0.08476243913173676, -0.026783062145113945, 0.01479256246238947, -0.026783062145113945, -0.021587567403912544, 0.044786322861909866, 0.006958459038287401, -0.003470472991466522, -0.02741352654993534, -0.04392235353589058, -0.006841706112027168, -0.0035989009775221348, -0.000266342016402632, 0.027343474328517914, -0.00764146214351058, -0.004716807510703802, 0.005951466970145702, 0.04733153060078621, 0.017337771132588387, 0.00072715018177405, 0.024471359327435493, 0.024868318811058998, -0.002443049568682909, 0.0017571275820955634, 0.004751833621412516, -0.007022672798484564, 0.029374970123171806, -0.02512517385184765, 0.013041272759437561, -0.014150422997772694, -0.00543191796168685, 0.006736628711223602, 0.012422483414411545, -0.016567204147577286, 0.010280072689056396, -0.002958220662549138, 0.039088793098926544, 0.01125495694577694, -0.043782249093055725, -0.012107251212000847, -0.05123107135295868, -0.021389087662100792, 0.04263807460665703, -0.011914609931409359, 0.01072956994175911, 0.044786322861909866, -0.03869183361530304, 0.005116685759276152, -0.02250991389155388, -0.023362208157777786, 0.008452893234789371, -0.012364107184112072, -0.03446538746356964, -0.024634812027215958, -0.034605491906404495, 0.021762697026133537, -0.0015674046007916331, -0.03981265798211098, 0.018902257084846497, 0.007466332986950874, 0.012188978493213654, 0.019450994208455086, -0.004591298755258322, 0.033297859132289886, -0.03761770948767662, 0.0055282386019825935, 0.016263647004961967, 0.007822428829967976, -0.022673368453979492, 0.010227533988654613, 0.01161689031869173, -0.024681514129042625, -0.008201874792575836, -0.001650590798817575, 0.035422757267951965, -0.007437144871801138, -0.04805539920926094, -0.0022562453523278236, 0.027623681351542473, -0.00023113378847483546, -0.03628673031926155, -0.017886508256196976, 0.018703777343034744, -0.022159656509757042, 0.03535270690917969, -0.01802661083638668, -0.03782786428928375, -0.012959546409547329, 0.006853381637483835, -0.01650882698595524, 0.027343474328517914, -0.0022898116149008274, -0.008073447272181511, -0.02981863170862198, -0.0037798676639795303, 0.024214502424001694, -0.01597176492214203, 0.01475753728300333, -0.02767038159072399, 0.004419088363647461, -0.02746022678911686, 0.004556272644549608, -0.0434553436934948, -0.003438366111367941, 0.00021033722441643476, 0.042778175324201584, -0.028674455359578133, 0.0059047662653028965, -0.016251971945166588, -0.03185012936592102, 0.04359544441103935, -0.029328269883990288, -0.02767038159072399, 0.03581971675157547, -0.0014243825571611524, 0.017909858375787735, -0.023572362959384918, -0.0064680976793169975, -0.00023277562286239117, 0.0011587701737880707, 0.021377412602305412, -0.05440674349665642, -0.007810753304511309, 0.011523487977683544, -0.031523220241069794, -0.019988056272268295, 0.02252158895134926, 0.01882052980363369, -0.009900625795125961, 0.01856367476284504, -0.027366824448108673, -0.04828890413045883, 0.00965544581413269, 0.004664268810302019, 0.005682935938239098, 0.015738260000944138, -0.011459274217486382, -0.02351398766040802, 0.012831117957830429, 0.0022971087601035833, 0.03425523266196251, 0.002818117383867502, 0.019789576530456543, 0.044996477663517, 0.007985882461071014, 0.007880805060267448, 0.014407278969883919, -0.013893567025661469, 0.0020139834377914667, 0.03343796357512474, 0.013613360933959484, -0.05053055286407471, -0.0010923671070486307, 0.020279938355088234, -0.0009843709412962198, 0.009176759980618954, 0.0003108539676759392, -0.012901169247925282, 0.010828809812664986, 0.013006246648728848, 0.005542832892388105, -0.013321478851139545, 0.009270161390304565, 0.01161689031869173, -0.027763783931732178, 0.022836821153759956, 0.0009617501054890454, -0.02374749258160591, 0.01803828775882721, 0.007022672798484564, -0.01674233190715313, 0.04466956853866577, -0.04511323198676109, -0.01908906176686287, 0.0022124629467725754, 0.006228754762560129, 0.0012733337935060263, -0.01528292428702116, -0.0032136172521859407, -0.01854032278060913, -0.009923976846039295, 0.009713822044432163, 0.016322022303938866, 0.024681514129042625, 0.040373072028160095, -0.03976595774292946, -0.024891668930649757, 0.00824857596307993, -0.02979527972638607, -0.013648387044668198, -0.004696376156061888, -0.034885697066783905, -0.015621506609022617, -0.0032194547820836306, -0.02066522277891636, -0.0559011772274971, 0.000012975052413821686, 0.04856910929083824, -0.01475753728300333, -0.01649715192615986, 0.0274368766695261, -0.019264189526438713, -0.029421672224998474, 0.016006790101528168, 0.023724142462015152, -0.01910073682665825, -0.02088705264031887, 0.013368180021643639, 0.03061254881322384, 0.010017379187047482, 0.01720934361219406, 0.0016812384128570557, 0.044996477663517, 0.027880536392331123, 0.010023216716945171, 0.018435245379805565, -0.02876785770058632, 0.0054260799661278725, -0.02063019573688507, 0.02818409353494644, -0.011149879544973373, -0.005180899519473314, 0.011686941608786583, 0.005963142495602369, 0.007927506230771542, 0.00877396296709776, 0.0312897153198719, 0.007437144871801138, -0.032293789088726044, 0.0314064659178257, -0.017851483076810837, -0.0017439929069951177, 0.019474344328045845, 0.0355161614716053, -0.0017410741420462728, -0.0011303117498755455, 0.008055933751165867, -0.02246321365237236, 0.010414337739348412, -0.006380533333867788, -0.0029494641348719597, 0.002190571976825595, -0.004868586082011461, -0.002517479471862316, 0.01281944289803505, 0.041143640875816345, -0.02222970686852932, 0.04569699242711067, 0.018096663057804108, 0.038014668971300125, 0.007232827600091696, 0.002818117383867502, 0.009223460219800472, -0.025405380874872208, -0.028674455359578133, 0.0123057309538126, -0.02354901283979416, -0.005023283418267965, 0.021225634962320328, 0.041377145797014236, -0.0025466675870120525, 0.03292425349354744, 0.004588379990309477, -0.05407983437180519, -0.0007640002877451479, 0.0026386103127151728, -0.0006009113858453929, 0.013905243016779423, 0.0030092999804764986, 0.023595713078975677, -0.06673582643270493, -0.0055282386019825935, 0.022813471034169197, -0.011062314733862877, 0.027366824448108673, 0.05361282452940941, -0.009357726201415062, 0.023852569982409477, 0.04373554885387421, -0.008581320755183697, 0.02692316472530365, -0.008855689316987991, -0.00900163035839796, 0.04336193948984146, 0.014640784822404385, 0.024728214368224144, -0.01884387992322445, 0.014710836112499237, -0.02380586788058281, -0.003987103700637817, -0.01748954877257347, 0.025568833574652672, 0.0051225232891738415, -0.021610919386148453, -0.008505431935191154, -0.03845832869410515, -0.008978280238807201, -0.001962904119864106, 0.03969590738415718, -0.024728214368224144, 0.010426012799143791, -0.014559057541191578, -0.021751021966338158, 0.040069516748189926, -0.022276408970355988, -0.007151100784540176, 0.0019118249183520675, -0.004684700630605221, -0.037991318851709366, 0.00041337742004543543, -0.00516630569472909, -0.010898861102759838, 0.051324471831321716, 0.028160743415355682, 0.04051317647099495, 0.043478693813085556, 0.020069783553481102, 0.010945562273263931, 0.039625853300094604, 0.009421939961612225, -0.021085532382130623, -0.008949091657996178, 0.02505512163043022, 0.000907751964405179, -0.00704602338373661, -0.007005160208791494, 0.011173230595886707, -0.016578879207372665, -0.0006972323171794415, -0.018937282264232635, -0.05534076318144798, 0.0018228009575977921, 0.002359863370656967, -0.02304697595536709, -0.04728483036160469, -0.03290090337395668, -0.015609831549227238, 0.01747787371277809, 0.010945562273263931, -0.009275998920202255, -0.0013893566792830825, 0.004687619395554066, 0.00014913329505361617, 0.03367146849632263, 0.006444747094064951, -0.018400220200419426, -0.039579153060913086, -0.003858675714582205, -0.02853435091674328, -0.002298568142578006, 0.01215395238250494, -0.0314064659178257, 0.006438909564167261, -0.02010480873286724, 0.009188435040414333, 0.03133641555905342, -0.017034213989973068, 0.01021002046763897, -0.0256388857960701, 0.009182597510516644, 0.012457509525120258, 0.002495588269084692, 0.005140036344528198, 0.03222373500466347, -0.020980454981327057, -0.018622050061821938, 0.028581053018569946, -0.024634812027215958, 0.019404293969273567, -0.007495521102100611, -0.016100192442536354, 0.00005436296123662032, -0.017559600993990898, -0.030892755836248398, 0.0019687418825924397, -0.05650829151272774, -0.007623949088156223, -0.006777492351830006, 0.00859883427619934, 0.0023919702507555485, 0.02304697595536709, 0.03156992048025131, -0.012644314207136631, 0.007226990070194006, 0.03367146849632263, 0.02904806286096573, -0.023362208157777786, 0.01939261704683304, 0.009200110100209713, -0.035142552107572556, -0.0015513510443270206, 0.009556205943226814, -0.028907960280776024, -0.001394464634358883, 0.004903612192720175, -0.007594760973006487, -0.027086619287729263, -0.021844424307346344, -0.021213959902524948, 0.02979527972638607, 0.004147638566792011, 0.047424934804439545, 0.04261472448706627, 0.005653747823089361, -0.017968235537409782, 0.004737239331007004, -0.007682325318455696, 0.025919092819094658, 0.013823515735566616, 0.00047795622958801687, -0.018657075241208076, 0.0051633864641189575, 0.0076589747332036495, 0.007232827600091696, 0.00876228790730238, 0.014360577799379826, 0.010005703195929527, -0.016333697363734245, 0.06720283627510071, 0.003128971438854933, -0.0043402803130447865, 0.033321212977170944, -0.009562043473124504, 0.0221830066293478, -0.005218844395130873, -0.003943321295082569, 0.011867908760905266, -0.012177303433418274, -0.02484496682882309, 0.030519146472215652, 0.034862346947193146, 0.025662235915660858, 0.01033261138945818, -0.0196144487708807, 0.016578879207372665, 0.013286453671753407, -0.002622556872665882, 0.029655177146196365, -0.019976381212472916, -0.007437144871801138, -0.015014393255114555, -0.033881623297929764, -0.01438392885029316, 0.01265598926693201, -0.0073554180562496185, 0.01369508821517229, -0.00051517115207389, -0.023117028176784515, 0.011336684226989746, -0.011517650447785854, -0.03110291063785553, -0.024004347622394562, -0.009632094763219357, 0.010326772928237915, 0.034068427979946136, -0.01907738484442234, -0.00809679739177227, 0.007752377074211836, 0.015236223116517067, 0.02164594456553459, -0.02296524867415428, 0.023362208157777786, 0.009597069583833218, 0.0339750275015831, 0.0553874634206295, 0.010151644237339497, -0.017979910597205162, 0.02636275254189968, 0.0032719934824854136, 0.039579153060913086, -0.016555529087781906, -0.013414881192147732, 0.018481947481632233, -0.014874289743602276, 0.0066257137805223465, 0.004001697525382042, 0.014489006251096725, -0.0016593473264947534, -0.0412837415933609, -0.001973120030015707, 0.019953031092882156, 0.0056858547031879425, 0.03056584857404232, -0.002933410694822669, 0.05202498659491539, -0.04312843456864357, 0.05221179127693176, -0.009608744643628597, -0.002650285605341196, -0.022323109209537506, 0.03206028416752815, -0.014547382481396198, 0.012375782243907452, 0.06757644563913345, -0.01018667034804821, 0.03794461488723755, -0.010163319297134876, 0.00018625699158292264, -0.03187347948551178, 0.015061094425618649, 0.033578068017959595, -0.010029054246842861, 0.0027874698862433434, -0.02771708369255066, -0.05515395849943161, -0.018236765637993813, -0.0018432327779009938, -0.009608744643628597, -0.005469862371683121, -0.019450994208455086, -0.00109674537088722, -0.0007880805060267448, 0.0053677037358284, -0.016053492203354836, -0.001471813302487135, -0.018878906965255737, 0.004328605253249407, -0.040256317704916, -0.009381076321005821, 0.010776271112263203, -0.01908906176686287, -0.022813471034169197, -0.03535270690917969, 0.012352432124316692, -0.01177450641989708, 0.021610919386148453, -0.02402769960463047, 0.012550911866128445, 0.021120557561516762, -0.018400220200419426, 0.008377003483474255, -0.02016318589448929, -0.018388545140624046, -0.0026386103127151728, 0.02799728885293007, 0.010939724743366241, -0.01804996281862259, 0.010414337739348412, -0.00020705355564132333, -0.013438232243061066, -0.024868318811058998, -0.01905403472483158, 0.02243986167013645, 0.008931579068303108, -0.01058362890034914, 0.009427777491509914, 0.028394248336553574, -0.008394517004489899, -0.007081049028784037, 0.02142411470413208, -0.012901169247925282, -0.045066528022289276, 0.012737715616822243, -0.015411351807415485, 0.016251971945166588, 0.03453543782234192, 0.011266632005572319, -0.000036918470868840814, 0.025778988376259804, -0.021505841985344887, -0.005674179643392563, 0.019159112125635147, 0.02825414575636387, 0.019801251590251923, 0.010396825149655342, -0.01696416176855564, -0.019988056272268295, -0.013006246648728848, -0.004670106805860996, 0.018423570320010185, -0.005183818284422159, 0.019497694447636604, 0.01773473061621189, -0.050343748182058334, 0.02250991389155388, -0.03446538746356964, 0.004486221354454756, -0.011657753959298134, -0.029374970123171806, -0.017898183315992355, 0.03579636663198471, -0.029374970123171806, -0.0055895340628921986, 0.00811430998146534, -0.030892755836248398, -0.025685586035251617, -0.010606979951262474, 0.029188167303800583, -0.01214227732270956, 0.000044990822061663494, -0.0077231889590620995, -0.0017746405210345984, -0.009900625795125961, -0.0020431717857718468, -0.02065354585647583, 0.009182597510516644, -0.017921533435583115, -0.003455878933891654, 0.03558621183037758, 0.02356068789958954, -0.003683546558022499, 0.04048982635140419, 0.01334482990205288, -0.0012426861794665456, -0.015014393255114555, -0.000258497690083459, 0.001885555568151176, 0.0021176014561206102, 0.029468372464179993, -0.0029348700772970915, -0.008341978304088116, -0.006987647153437138, -0.054266639053821564, 0.017828132957220078, 0.011955472640693188, -0.00041447195690125227, -0.0000036827257190452656, 0.0021365738939493895, -0.04644421115517616, -0.015388001687824726, 0.05697530135512352, -0.004170989152044058, 0.02774043381214142, -0.034628842025995255, 0.01936926692724228, -0.008055933751165867, -0.000998964998871088, 0.012772741727530956, 0.011062314733862877, 0.0053677037358284, 0.011570189148187637, -0.023140378296375275, -0.02582569047808647, 0.015317949466407299, 0.030215589329600334, -0.00009358456009067595, 0.00917092151939869, 0.03369481861591339, -0.010595304891467094, 0.003925808239728212, -0.03537605702877045, -0.009322700090706348, -0.023642415180802345, 0.04149389639496803, -0.018937282264232635, -0.01475753728300333, 0.011470949277281761, 0.012025524862110615, -0.01697583869099617, 0.0211555827409029, 0.0048627485521137714, 0.02095710299909115, 0.023093678057193756, 0.021272335201501846, -0.010396825149655342, -0.036963894963264465, 0.008155173622071743, 0.01617024466395378, 0.02718002162873745, -0.0015031906077638268, 0.0355161614716053, 0.00913005881011486, 0.03236383944749832, 0.0022416512947529554, 0.02426120452582836, -0.01855199784040451, -0.00917092151939869, 0.027506928890943527, 0.02720337174832821, -0.01669563166797161, -0.02114390768110752, 0.006368857808411121, 0.021809397265315056, 0.016602229326963425, 0.015574805438518524, 0.02767038159072399, 0.010782108642160892, 0.0312897153198719, 0.011821207590401173, -0.015761610120534897, -0.0034179342910647392, -0.021389087662100792, -0.041470546275377274, 0.04004616290330887, 0.034909047186374664, 0.007483846042305231, -0.018225090578198433, -0.018458597362041473, 0.0011624187463894486, -0.01281944289803505, -0.020128158852458, 0.007682325318455696, -0.023128703236579895, -0.015808310359716415, -0.002110304543748498, -0.01563318260014057, -0.017617978155612946, -0.002225597621873021, -0.009719659574329853, 0.0006034653633832932, -0.0256388857960701, -0.008838176727294922, -0.008557970635592937, 0.05716210603713989, -0.03843497857451439, -0.027296774089336395, 0.003990022465586662, -0.01426717545837164, -0.028300845995545387, 0.015352975577116013, -0.022930223494768143, 0.014407278969883919, 0.0024970476515591145, 0.022895198315382004, 0.019731201231479645, 0.0037565170787274837, -0.023105353116989136, 0.01124911941587925, 0.02774043381214142, 0.004597136285156012, -0.04107358679175377, 0.03126636520028114, 0.01543470285832882, -0.016345374286174774, 0.014512356370687485, 0.039859361946582794, -0.032293789088726044, -0.041680701076984406, -0.006345507223159075, -0.0382014736533165, 0.02454140968620777, 0.02844095043838024, 0.012796091847121716, 0.0059456294402480125, -0.0005487375310622156, 0.01830681785941124, -0.00009768914605956525, 0.02119060978293419, -0.029701879248023033, -0.017944885417819023, 0.04677111655473709, 0.015037743374705315, 0.02164594456553459, -0.006006924901157618, -0.02636275254189968, -0.022019552066922188, -0.029118115082383156, 0.02015151083469391, 0.011068153195083141, 0.0007654596702195704, -0.036193326115608215, 0.012002173811197281, -0.012037199921905994, 0.028931310400366783, -0.013496608473360538, -0.0004816047439817339, 0.023724142462015152, -0.03712734952569008, 0.016357049345970154, 0.006170378532260656, 0.016800709068775177, -0.018481947481632233, -0.006975971627980471, -0.008826501667499542, 0.013426556251943111, 0.002988868160173297, -0.014278851449489594, 0.007682325318455696, 0.009462803602218628, -0.0002052292984444648, -0.043011683970689774, 0.0012974139535799623, 0.007588923443108797, -0.0018811773043125868, -0.021832749247550964, -0.03455878794193268, -0.03474559262394905, -0.027763783931732178, -0.025148523971438408, 0.003666033735498786, 0.006123677361756563, 0.022801795974373817, 0.0025743963196873665, 0.01318137627094984, 0.06668912619352341, -0.01802661083638668, -0.016111867502331734, -0.00555742671713233, -0.04072333127260208, 0.023910945281386375, -0.016870761290192604, -0.031990230083465576, 0.014185449108481407, -0.0164738018065691, -0.0464208610355854, -0.027366824448108673, 0.016859084367752075, 0.007781565189361572, -0.039836008101701736, 0.0382014736533165, 0.011523487977683544, -0.02430790476500988, -0.007267853710800409, -0.02692316472530365, -0.0022562453523278236, 0.020209886133670807, -0.006170378532260656, 0.032573994249105453, 0.013963619247078896, 0.012924520298838615, 0.0235256627202034, -0.0007147452561184764, 0.028861260041594505, 0.020490093156695366, -0.005820120219141245, 0.05305241048336029, 0.02089872770011425, -0.022299759089946747, 0.0024269961286336184, -0.007915831170976162, 0.020560145378112793, -0.047681789845228195, -0.0009719659574329853, -0.009923976846039295, -0.0003477040445432067, 0.026596257463097572, -0.0132047263905406, 0.0055399141274392605, 0.011412573046982288, 0.023058651015162468, -0.024961719289422035, -0.005250951275229454, 0.012889494188129902, 0.01750122383236885, 0.04945642873644829, 0.039625853300094604, -0.01719766855239868, 0.010350123979151249, 0.02116725780069828, -0.008575483225286007, 0.012562586925923824, 0.01213060226291418, -0.004211852326989174, -0.007699838373810053, -0.04371219873428345, 0.013613360933959484, 0.009713822044432163, -0.016905786469578743, 0.023829219862818718, 0.009065844118595123, -0.028557702898979187, -0.01747787371277809, 0.0023919702507555485, -0.003137727966532111, -0.017407823354005814, 0.013765139505267143, -0.027226721867918968, 0.022556615993380547, -0.005125442054122686, 0.007530547212809324, -0.023093678057193756, -0.004322767723351717, 0.03369481861591339, 0.019696174189448357, -0.003038488095626235, 0.01017499528825283, 0.02741352654993534, 0.004818966146558523, -0.0455101877450943, -0.007734864018857479, -0.018983984366059303, 0.017454523593187332, -0.026969866827130318, -0.013263102620840073, 0.005598290357738733, 0.000734447268769145, 0.030215589329600334, -0.027857186272740364, -0.0020942508708685637, 0.03677709028124809, -0.018143365159630775, -0.005977736320346594, 0.0312897153198719, -0.012737715616822243, 0.02061852067708969, 0.001835935632698238, -0.023455610498785973, -0.003158159554004669, 0.011733642779290676, -0.021073855459690094, -0.011932122521102428, -0.02479826658964157, 0.00307643273845315, -0.016263647004961967, 0.009100870229303837, 0.006327994633466005, 0.0014747320674359798, -0.028394248336553574, 0.01564485765993595, 0.02015151083469391, 0.013403206132352352, -0.0009019143762998283, 0.02243986167013645, -0.003450041403993964, -0.025498783215880394, 0.026806412264704704, -0.012002173811197281, -0.019275864586234093, -0.01773473061621189, 0.044576168060302734, 0.0012463347520679235, 0.013975294306874275, 0.0024970476515591145, -0.03292425349354744, -0.017594626173377037, -0.03320445865392685, -0.02844095043838024, -0.04777519032359123, 0.0026488262228667736, 0.0014667053474113345, -0.019264189526438713, 0.007402119226753712, -0.026456154882907867, -0.016286997124552727, -0.007758214604109526, -0.010478551499545574, -0.010677031241357327, -0.04044312238693237, 0.001307629863731563, -0.025218576192855835, 0.0046000550501048565, 0.0339750275015831, -0.010747082531452179, 0.020268263295292854, -0.018400220200419426, 0.028581053018569946, -0.045603591948747635, 0.038528379052877426, 0.018622050061821938, 0.014710836112499237, -0.030635898932814598, -0.005577858537435532, 0.030168889090418816, 0.026292700320482254, 0.020595170557498932, -0.002860440406948328, 0.0032865875400602818, 0.02015151083469391, 0.02296524867415428, 0.002186193596571684, 0.0055924528278410435, -0.040256317704916, 0.017711378633975983, 0.015866687521338463, -0.0003030096413567662, -0.0031873479019850492, -0.019532721489667892, 0.02741352654993534, 0.017069239169359207, -0.025241926312446594, 0.01280776783823967, -0.004637999460101128, -0.004562110640108585, -0.05249200016260147, -0.027320124208927155, -0.024985071271657944, 0.009462803602218628, -0.023362208157777786, -0.016800709068775177, -0.05917024984955788, 0.0007800537277944386, 0.012632638216018677, -0.046887870877981186, -0.05258540064096451, 0.02505512163043022, -0.017045889049768448, 0.0180149357765913, 0.0028896285220980644, 0.02247488871216774, -0.020583495497703552, -0.026596257463097572, -0.013123000040650368, -0.02484496682882309, 0.012095576152205467, 0.010420175269246101, -0.000956642150413245, 0.02197285182774067, -0.015201197005808353, 0.02349063567817211, -0.01807331293821335, 0.019497694447636604, 0.04156395047903061, 0.018446920439600945, -0.023373883217573166, -0.025031771510839462, -0.01880885474383831, 0.024704864248633385, 0.012492535635828972, 0.044786322861909866, -0.0040892623364925385, -0.01618191972374916, 0.006497285794466734, 0.00529181445017457, 0.006462260149419308, 0.004886099137365818, 0.0017760999035090208, 0.003347882768139243, 0.002726174658164382, -0.022042904049158096 ]
10.795051
6.153192
2024-06-01
0
2024ApJ...967..135R
[ "visible mass", "spiral galaxies", "galaxies", "galaxy luminosity", "SDSS MaNGA DR17", "SDSS MaNGA", "mass", "dark matter", "H I", "MaNGA Data Release" ]
[ "Disk galaxies", "Late-type galaxies", "Galaxy dynamics", "Galaxy masses", "Galaxy dark matter halos", "Galaxy rotation curves", "Dark matter", "391", "907", "591", "607", "1880", "619", "353", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
7
[ "10.3847/1538-4357/ad36c2", "10.48550/arXiv.2310.11422" ]
[ "Ravi, Nitya", "Douglass, Kelly A.", "Demina, Regina" ]
[ "Department of Physics &amp; Astronomy, University of Rochester, 500 Joseph C. Wilson Blvd., Rochester, NY 14627, USA", "Department of Physics &amp; Astronomy, University of Rochester, 500 Joseph C. Wilson Blvd., Rochester, NY 14627, USA", "Department of Physics &amp; Astronomy, University of Rochester, 500 Joseph C. Wilson Blvd., Rochester, NY 14627, USA" ]
null
[ "1970ApJ...159..379R", "1970ApJ...160..811F", "1974ApJ...193L...1O", "1980ApJ...238..471R", "1982ApJ...261..439R", "1985ApJ...289...81R", "1985ApJ...294..494C", "1989A&A...223...47B", "1990A&A...232L..15D", "1992A&A...253..335K", "1992ApJS...81..413M", "1996AJ....111.1748F", "1996MNRAS.281...27P", "1998AJ....116.3040G", "2001ASPC..238..269L", "2001ApJ...546..176S", "2002AJ....124.1810S", "2003A&A...410...83H", "2005AJ....129.2562B", "2005ApJ...635L..29P", "2005Natur.435..629S", "2006ApJ...640..751C", "2006JPhG...33....1Y", "2006agna.book.....O", "2007ApJS..173..342M", "2008AJ....136.2648D", "2008ApJ...680.1083R", "2008Natur.454.1096S", "2009ApJS..182..543A", "2010A&A...518L..72P", "2010ApJ...710..903M", "2010CQGra..27w3001B", "2010JKAS...43..191C", "2011AJ....142...31B", "2011ARA&A..49..155P", "2011ApJS..192...18K", "2011MNRAS.416.1936T", "2013AJ....146...32S", "2013MNRAS.431.1383T", "2013pss5.book..985S", "2015AJ....149...77D", "2015AJ....150...19L", "2015ApJ...798....7B", "2016MNRAS.457.3678P", "2016MNRAS.460.2143W", "2016PASJ...68....2S", "2016RMxAA..52..171S", "2017AJ....154...86W", "2017ApJS..233...22S", "2017MNRAS.464.1903K", "2017MNRAS.465.4703K", "2017PASJ...69R...1S", "2018ARNPS..68..429B", "2018ApJ...852...74B", "2018ApJ...861...49H", "2018NatAs...2..957C", "2018Natur.555..629V", "2018RMxAA..54..217S", "2019A&A...623A...5D", "2019A&ARv..27....2S", "2019AJ....158...74C", "2019AJ....158..231W", "2019ApJ...886..153D", "2019ApJS..240...23A", "2019MNRAS.488.3143B", "2019MNRAS.490.5451D", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020ApJ...890...63W", "2021ApJ...922..249Y", "2021MNRAS.503.1345S", "2021MNRAS.507.5820D", "2022ApJ...925..127D", "2022ApJS..259...35A", "2022MNRAS.509.4024D", "2022MNRAS.510.3119W", "2022PhRvD.105i2007T", "2023EPJC...83..503A", "2023EPJC...83..933T", "2023MNRAS.523.1885S" ]
28832041
2312.03904
Cosmological parameters estimated from peculiar velocity-density comparisons: calibrating 2M++
Cosmological parameters can be measured by comparing peculiar velocities with those predicted from a galaxy density field. Previous work has tested the accuracy of this approach with N-body simulations, but generally on idealized mock galaxy surveys. However, systematic biases may arise solely due to survey selection effects such as flux-limited samples, edge-effects, and complications due to the obscuration of the Galactic plane. In this work, we explore the impact of each of these effects individually as well as collectively using the semi-analytic models from numerical simulations to generate mock catalogues that mimic the 2M++ density field. We find the reconstruction and analysis methods used for our 2M++ mocks produce a value of fσ<SUB>8</SUB> that is biased high by a factor 1.04 ± 0.01 compared to the true value. Moreover, a cosmic volume matching that of 2M++ has a cosmic variance uncertainty in fσ<SUB>8</SUB> of $\sim 5~{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$. The systematic bias is a function of distance: it is unbiased close to the origin but is biased slightly high for distances in the range 100-180 h<SUP>-1</SUP> Mpc. Correcting for this small bias, we find that recent peculiar velocity samples yield $f\sigma _8^{\textrm {lin}} = 0.362\pm 0.023$, a value that is in tension with the extrapolations from cosmic microwave background measurements. The predicted peculiar velocities from 2M++ have an error of 170 km s<SUP>-1</SUP> that slowly increases with distance, exceeding 200 km s<SUP>-1</SUP> only at distances of 180-200 h<SUP>-1</SUP>Mpc. Finally, the residual bulk flow speeds found in previous work are shown to be not in conflict with those expected in the Λ cold dark matter model.
[ 0.025470834225416183, 0.04106868803501129, 0.01598598062992096, -0.012171420268714428, -0.034834396094083786, 0.02593173459172249, -0.022329431027173996, -0.03255414962768555, 0.005100231152027845, 0.010831168852746487, -0.027338694781064987, -0.0011658971197903156, -0.04650246351957321, -0.011182908900082111, 0.040923140943050385, 0.029352104291319847, -0.04366428777575493, 0.029546167701482773, -0.03131699562072754, -0.0351254940032959, -0.02500993385910988, 0.008417503908276558, -0.0004821264883503318, 0.003214176744222641, -0.05564770847558975, -0.06011116877198219, 0.005964420270174742, 0.006792222149670124, 0.038036443293094635, -0.06860144436359406, -0.018969707190990448, -0.03301505371928215, -0.03318485617637634, -0.025592124089598656, -0.09557627141475677, 0.10993696749210358, -0.011073748581111431, 0.012383677065372467, -0.03502846136689186, -0.014469859190285206, -0.028575848788022995, 0.031729381531476974, -0.037114642560482025, 0.011158650740981102, -0.011000974103808403, -0.01539166085422039, 0.007544218562543392, -0.024379227310419083, -0.017550617456436157, -0.02241433411836624, -0.045920275151729584, 0.014069603756070137, 0.0014046861324459314, -0.038254767656326294, 0.02658669836819172, 0.008229505270719528, 0.0102247204631567, -0.014457730576395988, -0.010018527507781982, -0.01318418886512518, -0.02277820184826851, -0.03857012093067169, -0.013754250481724739, -0.05181495472788811, 0.01003672182559967, -0.006919576320797205, 0.026829278096556664, -0.012747545726597309, 0.007701895199716091, 0.03012835793197155, -0.012316967360675335, 0.01750210113823414, -0.008187053725123405, 0.02539806067943573, 0.0204494409263134, -0.02257201075553894, 0.04475589469075203, 0.002472793450579047, -0.03878844156861305, -0.004339138511568308, 0.00651325611397624, -0.002396987285465002, 0.007744346279650927, -0.03170512244105339, -0.039079535752534866, 0.014287924394011497, 0.023287618532776833, 0.002965532708913088, -0.04742426797747612, 0.020037055015563965, 0.010151946917176247, -0.035489361733198166, -0.0077200885862112045, 0.007538153789937496, -0.00325662805698812, -0.038909729570150375, 0.010085237212479115, -0.04912232235074043, 0.06302212178707123, 0.004096559248864651, 0.0020073442719876766, 0.06219734996557236, 0.02539806067943573, -0.030322421342134476, 0.08907514065504074, 0.007228865288197994, 0.008599438704550266, -0.04441628232598305, -0.007544218562543392, -0.0025652768090367317, 0.0477638766169548, 0.017211006954312325, -0.024767354130744934, 0.0028624364640563726, -0.03350020945072174, 0.013378252275288105, -0.07835313677787781, 0.05249417573213577, -0.024888643994927406, 0.004390686750411987, -0.004615072626620531, -0.027775337919592857, 0.04550788924098015, 0.013548057526350021, 0.010255042463541031, -0.020243247970938683, -0.007774668745696545, -0.04388260841369629, -0.0323115736246109, 0.014967147260904312, 0.013802765868604183, -0.02893971838057041, 0.04186920076608658, 0.02741146832704544, -0.01636197790503502, 0.02143188752233982, 0.016822880133986473, -0.025034191086888313, 0.028648624196648598, 0.02049795724451542, -0.03432498127222061, 0.02876991406083107, 0.015791917219758034, 0.024621805176138878, 0.007738281972706318, 0.0030337581411004066, -0.011352714151144028, -0.007744346279650927, 0.019758090376853943, 0.027362952008843422, -0.0329422801733017, 0.010922135785222054, -0.03279672935605049, -0.04427073523402214, -0.022741815075278282, -0.008823824115097523, 0.019224414601922035, 0.01898183487355709, 0.011649874038994312, -0.031147191300988197, -0.0193578340113163, 0.0028336301911622286, -0.027217404916882515, 0.013244833797216415, 0.016349850222468376, 0.005260940175503492, -0.05545364320278168, -0.01985512115061283, -0.047933682799339294, -0.04822477698326111, -0.016725847497582436, 0.03252989426255226, -0.013244833797216415, -0.058704208582639694, 0.050116896629333496, 0.032772473990917206, -0.008957243524491787, -0.04841884225606918, -0.030152615159749985, 0.009794142097234726, -0.020946728065609932, 0.017768938094377518, 0.06316766887903214, 0.0054731969721615314, -0.0319962203502655, 0.005154811777174473, 0.011019167490303516, 0.0272416640073061, 0.008902662433683872, -0.027484241873025894, 0.006992350332438946, 0.03958895429968834, 0.050116896629333496, 0.020024927332997322, -0.06331321597099304, -0.040098369121551514, -0.005794614553451538, 0.041796423494815826, -0.03830328211188316, 0.009587949141860008, 0.02453690394759178, 0.026247087866067886, 0.017283780500292778, -0.0644775927066803, -0.031025901436805725, -0.025422317907214165, 0.02908526547253132, 0.013099285773932934, -0.03379130735993385, 0.03565916791558266, 0.00728951022028923, -0.0043148803524672985, 0.03713890165090561, 0.014566890895366669, -0.03854586184024811, 0.002571341348811984, -0.04866142198443413, 0.02719314768910408, 0.040098369121551514, 0.03835179656744003, -0.03442201390862465, 0.06297360360622406, 0.02556786499917507, 0.02463393472135067, 0.011510390788316727, 0.014178764075040817, 0.061372581869363785, -0.03823050856590271, -0.028406044468283653, -0.013390380889177322, 0.02272968739271164, 0.02093460038304329, -0.024621805176138878, 0.010594653896987438, 0.0000177433539647609, 0.0077200885862112045, 0.0017981196288019419, 0.06350728124380112, -0.0127232875674963, -0.008957243524491787, -0.00127126753795892, 0.013062899000942707, -0.01929718814790249, -0.013778507709503174, -0.018520934507250786, 0.01258986908942461, -0.021516790613532066, 0.01756274700164795, 0.060887422412633896, -0.024937158450484276, 0.03604729473590851, 0.004891006741672754, -0.01729590818285942, -0.020970987156033516, -0.015403790399432182, -0.004963780287653208, -0.03648393601179123, 0.039079535752534866, -0.013511670753359795, 0.0028912429697811604, -0.06942621618509293, 0.0070833177305758, -0.03873992711305618, 0.017259521409869194, -0.038909729570150375, 0.029230814427137375, 0.007738281972706318, -0.019588284194469452, -0.014627535827457905, 0.00563087360933423, -0.00659209443256259, 0.023299748077988625, 0.019758090376853943, -0.016762234270572662, -0.05162088945508003, 0.028963977470993996, -0.0437128022313118, 0.051523856818675995, 0.03386408090591431, -0.01702907122671604, -0.007392606232315302, -0.010570395737886429, 0.002910952316597104, 0.00875105056911707, 0.012292709201574326, -0.0028791138902306557, 0.015185468830168247, 0.024561161175370216, 0.005106295924633741, -0.022487107664346695, 0.035974521189928055, -0.030201131477952003, -0.0269263107329607, 0.012783932499587536, -0.011540713720023632, -0.0066891261376440525, 0.042499907314777374, -0.01473669707775116, -0.015585724264383316, 0.02680502086877823, 0.046842075884342194, 0.0007648830651305616, 0.024718837812542915, 0.006743706297129393, 0.0014964115107432008, 0.010746265761554241, 0.05831608176231384, 0.04596878960728645, -0.02098311483860016, 0.02908526547253132, -0.006428353488445282, 0.05661802366375923, -0.04383409023284912, 0.007265252061188221, 0.022147497162222862, -0.013487412594258785, -0.04487718269228935, 0.035489361733198166, 0.04987431690096855, -0.025543607771396637, -0.07966306805610657, -0.037721093744039536, -0.01139516569674015, 0.018799901008605957, 0.01930931769311428, -0.0401226282119751, -0.021383371204137802, -0.018205581232905388, 0.023457424715161324, -0.00308682257309556, -0.01128600537776947, 0.004175397567451, 0.03638690710067749, -0.01248070877045393, 0.0018875707173720002, -0.06015968322753906, 0.020461570471525192, 0.06923215091228485, -0.032990794628858566, -0.008605503477156162, -0.015573595650494099, 0.025034191086888313, 0.01995215378701687, -0.02457329072058201, 0.022014077752828598, -0.011431552469730377, 0.03425220772624016, 0.04128700867295265, 0.07345303148031235, -0.01103736087679863, 0.0005711985868401825, 0.007980861701071262, 0.031462542712688446, 0.00482732942327857, 0.04938916116952896, -0.03471310809254646, 0.022487107664346695, -0.05171792209148407, 0.002638050587847829, -0.011540713720023632, 0.02321484498679638, -0.002111956709995866, 0.04594453424215317, 0.03638690710067749, -0.009472724050283432, 0.0051639084704220295, -0.006464740261435509, 0.017174620181322098, -0.054677389562129974, -0.01372999232262373, -0.017271650955080986, 0.02789662778377533, -0.03342743590474129, 0.029327845200896263, -0.021286340430378914, 0.009339305572211742, 0.027071857824921608, 0.01984299160540104, 0.016543913632631302, -0.0016647009178996086, 0.04172364994883537, 0.013754250481724739, 0.00880563072860241, -0.03578045591711998, 0.014203022234141827, 0.02436709776520729, -0.01915164105594158, -0.05564770847558975, -0.07340452075004578, 0.011564971879124641, -0.01729590818285942, 0.005782485939562321, -0.01346315536648035, 0.02903675101697445, 0.0014259119052439928, -0.012135032564401627, 0.042281582951545715, 0.04659949615597725, 0.05312488228082657, 0.05045650899410248, 0.008957243524491787, -0.041020169854164124, -0.04388260841369629, -0.009630400687456131, -0.019175898283720016, 0.025058448314666748, -0.004366428591310978, 0.03692058101296425, 0.008284085430204868, 0.004721201024949551, 0.019758090376853943, -0.02496141754090786, 0.020473698154091835, -0.0068771252408623695, 0.008775308728218079, 0.008211311884224415, -0.019054610282182693, 0.07912939041852951, 0.01915164105594158, 0.03687206283211708, 0.007471444550901651, -0.01723526418209076, -0.005330681800842285, -0.0010809942614287138, -0.043373189866542816, -0.021346984431147575, 0.01750210113823414, 0.051087215542793274, -0.018302613869309425, -0.04436776787042618, -0.045168276876211166, 0.029400618746876717, 0.012771803885698318, -0.034834396094083786, -0.054143715649843216, -0.029715972021222115, 0.010461235418915749, -0.025373801589012146, 0.021516790613532066, -0.004045011010020971, 0.026295604184269905, -0.0020907309371978045, -0.02636837773025036, -0.031122932210564613, 0.05215456336736679, -0.014093860983848572, 0.02500993385910988, -0.006889253854751587, 0.026125798001885414, -0.02197769097983837, -0.018969707190990448, -0.026683731004595757, -0.03468884900212288, 0.005834033712744713, -0.0297402311116457, -0.021771498024463654, 0.00422997772693634, -0.007811055518686771, 0.042499907314777374, -0.058655690401792526, -0.01871499791741371, 0.0125656109303236, -0.024488387629389763, -0.01696842722594738, -0.023590844124555588, 0.03769683465361595, -0.0010506719117984176, 0.014118119142949581, 0.00433610612526536, 0.027751080691814423, 0.02240220457315445, -0.07650953531265259, 0.046842075884342194, 0.01049155741930008, -0.008635825477540493, -0.015076307579874992, -0.03922508284449577, 0.012759675271809101, 0.0530763678252697, 0.007616992108523846, 0.06345876306295395, -0.012086517177522182, 0.031777895987033844, 0.02794514410197735, 0.04361576959490776, 0.02441561408340931, -0.00008542394789401442, 0.03039519488811493, -0.020655633881688118, 0.003814560594037175, -0.04172364994883537, -0.031947702169418335, 0.018945448100566864, -0.011425488628447056, 0.027775337919592857, -0.011007038876414299, -0.005879517644643784, 0.014045345596969128, -0.020485827699303627, 0.01599811017513275, 0.040098369121551514, -0.050165414810180664, 0.034882914274930954, 0.005618744529783726, 0.0027608564123511314, 0.03941914811730385, -0.05846162885427475, -0.029546167701482773, -0.01745358482003212, 0.016701590269804, -0.029667457565665245, 0.06258548051118851, 0.020861824974417686, -0.011510390788316727, 0.02758127450942993, 0.010291430167853832, 0.004963780287653208, 0.04599304869771004, 0.04633266106247902, -0.009818400256335735, 0.03381556272506714, -0.012759675271809101, -0.02491290122270584, 0.012529224157333374, -0.004554427694529295, -0.038473088294267654, -0.040219660848379135, -0.12303625792264938, -0.008065763860940933, -0.0025531479623168707, 0.028139207512140274, -0.014190892688930035, 0.014688180759549141, -0.027654048055410385, -0.005697582848370075, -0.015318887308239937, 0.005054747685790062, 0.018520934507250786, 0.002883662236854434, -0.0014948953175917268, 0.014433472417294979, -0.0251312218606472, 0.008411440066993237, 0.0053155203349888325, 0.032432861626148224, 0.051038701087236404, 0.03398536890745163, 0.020255377516150475, 0.020679891109466553, 0.023372521623969078, 0.01077052392065525, 0.00859337393194437, 0.003629593877121806, 0.018351130187511444, -0.029352104291319847, 0.02186853066086769, 0.006822544615715742, -0.030201131477952003, 0.02561638131737709, 0.007604863028973341, 0.0020346343517303467, -0.02881842851638794, -0.022935878485441208, 0.03529529646039009, -0.002309052273631096, -0.052009016275405884, -0.007156091276556253, -0.04485292360186577, 0.006422288715839386, 0.044125188142061234, -0.03291802108287811, -0.0033506276085972786, 0.013924055732786655, -0.014421343803405762, -0.012965867295861244, -0.002571341348811984, 0.01487011555582285, -0.021613821387290955, -0.018508804962038994, -0.021080147475004196, -0.017987260594964027, 0.022826718166470528, 0.03141402825713158, 0.011880324222147465, -0.048152003437280655, 0.008848082274198532, 0.03126848116517067, -0.0192001573741436, 0.022474978119134903, 0.0019391188398003578, 0.0013576863566413522, -0.01315993070602417, 0.008199182339012623, -0.00456958869472146, -0.001314476947300136, 0.033039309084415436, 0.03328188881278038, 0.019648928195238113, 0.002970081055536866, -0.0348101407289505, 0.017380811274051666, 0.02925507165491581, -0.01740507036447525, -0.01071594376116991, -0.02143188752233982, 0.022984394803643227, 0.008738921955227852, -0.016835007816553116, -0.028042174875736237, -0.008732857182621956, -0.02299652434885502, 0.010916071943938732, -0.02207472175359726, -0.04422222077846527, -0.013814895413815975, -0.0013758798595517874, -0.0017056361539289355, -0.02539806067943573, 0.006458675488829613, -0.029546167701482773, -0.02469458058476448, -0.034397754818201065, 0.017308037728071213, 0.005679389461874962, 0.06491424143314362, -0.03180215507745743, 0.02289949171245098, -0.007604863028973341, -0.031680867075920105, -0.019758090376853943, 0.03786664083600044, -0.027047598734498024, 0.02648966759443283, 0.004721201024949551, 0.01604662463068962, 0.024512644857168198, -0.0066891261376440525, 0.03628987446427345, -0.053804103285074234, 0.0003896431007888168, 0.03138976916670799, 0.012529224157333374, 0.02964319847524166, -0.04444054141640663, -0.01103736087679863, -0.016774363815784454, 0.033306147903203964, -0.00010338050196878612, -0.024864384904503822, -0.014967147260904312, -0.0181085504591465, -0.028478818014264107, -0.009551562368869781, 0.033572982996702194, 0.03551362082362175, -0.017574874684214592, 0.00573700200766325, 0.016992684453725815, -0.03595026209950447, 0.006561771966516972, -0.012796062044799328, -0.007052995264530182, -0.0030640806071460247, -0.02158956415951252, -0.008356858976185322, 0.0190424807369709, 0.003811528440564871, 0.0243549682199955, -0.01789022795855999, 0.0227903313934803, 0.029715972021222115, 0.029400618746876717, 0.011868195608258247, 0.05225159600377083, -0.01762339100241661, 0.005831001792103052, 0.015537208877503872, -0.020740536972880363, -0.024840127676725388, 0.02915804088115692, -0.0008960275445133448, 0.021140791475772858, -0.02675650455057621, -0.013960442505776882, -0.0032596602104604244, 0.018011517822742462, -0.02376064844429493, -0.0030944030731916428, 0.007519960403442383, 0.014942889101803303, 0.004387654364109039, -0.034276463091373444, 0.028260497376322746, 0.02436709776520729, -0.007410799618810415, -0.024670321494340897, -0.014663922600448132, -0.009205887094140053, 0.014384957030415535, -0.019879378378391266, 0.014773083850741386, 0.00807182863354683, 0.01963680051267147, -0.02424580790102482, -0.02252349443733692, -0.022499237209558487, -0.027508500963449478, -0.011073748581111431, 0.020206861197948456, 0.006731577683240175, 0.021941304206848145, 0.042063262313604355, -0.024233678355813026, -0.003523465245962143, -0.010600718669593334, -0.020303893834352493, -0.0063434503972530365, 0.012905222363770008, -0.04060778766870499, -0.019551897421479225, 0.0014918631641194224, -0.007198542822152376, -0.04444054141640663, 0.03379130735993385, 0.02055860124528408, -0.026465408504009247, -0.01637410745024681, 0.040656302124261856, -0.01745358482003212, -0.021601693704724312, 0.028406044468283653, 0.019333574920892715, -0.026610957458615303, -0.014069603756070137, 0.00884201843291521, 0.01832687109708786, -0.0017117006937041879, -0.0013667831663042307, 0.0007974797044880688, 0.053270429372787476, -0.007598798722028732, 0.022972267121076584, 0.009830528870224953, 0.018084291368722916, 0.019115254282951355, 0.024342840537428856, 0.010606782510876656, -0.018229840323328972, 0.00037391335354186594, -0.0048152003437280655, 0.01198948547244072, 0.00937569234520197, 0.006786157842725515, -0.0019512478029355407, 0.011243553832173347, -0.02872139774262905, 0.024342840537428856, -0.005118424538522959, 0.014348569326102734, 0.024597547948360443, 0.022208141162991524, 0.0369933545589447, -0.006064484361559153, 0.025495091453194618, -0.015052049420773983, 0.021068017929792404, -0.02995855174958706, 0.0019648929592221975, 0.0437128022313118, -0.025810444727540016, -0.010218655690550804, 0.00555809959769249, 0.040923140943050385, 0.004775781184434891, 0.07151240110397339, 0.0006610287819057703, 0.009181628935039043, -0.02714463137090206, -0.016847137361764908, 0.01979447714984417, -0.00225750426761806, -0.027751080691814423, 0.019830863922834396, -0.03221454098820686, -0.013451025821268559, 0.009939689189195633, -0.008932985365390778, -0.021929174661636353, 0.004530169535428286, 0.025325285270810127, -0.01318418886512518, 0.0020770858973264694, -0.04650246351957321, -0.0016116367187350988, -0.010515815578401089, 0.0181085504591465, 0.013305478729307652, -0.11604996770620346, 0.00005780211358796805, 0.025955991819500923, 0.0005003199330531061, 0.014081732369959354, 0.02436709776520729, 0.016119398176670074, 0.04143255576491356, -0.023408908396959305, -0.016543913632631302, 0.028624365106225014, -0.009345370344817638, -0.025252511724829674, 0.03500420227646828, 0.006428353488445282, -0.034446269273757935, -0.027605531737208366, 0.023469554260373116, -0.01318418886512518, -0.023190587759017944, -0.009224080480635166, 0.05137830972671509, -0.013341865502297878, 0.002627437701448798, -0.01773255132138729, -0.011031297035515308, -0.012316967360675335, 0.0007281171274371445, 0.03095312789082527, -0.06738854944705963, -0.013802765868604183, -0.003866108600050211, -0.0036993352696299553, 0.032166022807359695, -0.012711158953607082, -0.0027926950715482235, -0.01973383128643036, 0.006901382934302092, -0.03252989426255226, 0.0027775338385254145, -0.009879045188426971, -0.03255414962768555, 0.005279133561998606, 0.04038946330547333, 0.032990794628858566, 0.018993964418768883, 0.0012682352680712938, -0.01081904023885727, 0.004833393730223179, -0.021456144750118256, 0.024063874036073685, 0.009357498958706856, 0.016446880996227264, 0.004533201921731234, 0.0002471277257427573, 0.03827902302145958, 0.018314741551876068, 0.007265252061188221, 0.001554024056531489, -0.015294629149138927, -0.027969401329755783, 0.01806003414094448, -0.00037903027259744704, -0.0033657888416200876, -0.06714596599340439, -0.008453890681266785, -0.04186920076608658, 0.026077281683683395, 0.01668946072459221, -0.014918630942702293, -0.0014183312887325883, 0.05035947635769844, 0.012189613655209541, 0.00013427146768663079, -0.01599811017513275, 0.004642362706363201, -0.006986286025494337, -0.023348264396190643, -0.03767257556319237, 0.026441151276230812, -0.027387211099267006, -0.01751423068344593, 0.006810416001826525, -0.03551362082362175, 0.00371146434918046, 0.029230814427137375, 0.005300359334796667, 0.002457632217556238, 0.016277074813842773, 0.032772473990917206, 0.03437349572777748, -0.00006344018765958026, 0.04414944350719452, 0.007077252957969904, -0.033524468541145325, -0.004587782546877861, 0.0182662270963192, -0.02376064844429493, -0.011977355927228928, -0.013717863708734512, -0.00791415199637413, -0.010164075531065464, -0.020752664655447006, -0.019830863922834396, 0.0308318380266428, 0.023093555122613907, -0.014627535827457905, -0.011668067425489426, 0.013608702458441257, -0.000655722338706255, 0.025980250909924507, 0.018302613869309425, -0.03284524753689766, 0.04997134953737259, 0.045483630150556564, -0.014506245963275433, -0.008581245318055153, 0.004833393730223179, 0.018084291368722916, 0.027557015419006348, -0.014906502328813076, 0.007744346279650927, -0.04150532931089401, -0.02925507165491581, -0.012917350977659225, 0.008375052362680435, -0.002383342245593667, -0.00505778007209301, -0.006222160998731852, 0.03786664083600044, -0.01996428146958351, 0.011213230900466442, 0.015949593856930733, 0.0009475756669417024, -0.004605975933372974, 0.012905222363770008, -0.006664867978543043, 0.005633905995637178, 0.007119704503566027, 0.026295604184269905, -0.004533201921731234, -0.017113974317908287, 0.013414639048278332, -0.01487011555582285, 0.0359017476439476, 0.0192001573741436, 0.005412552040070295, -0.03138976916670799, 0.039079535752534866, 0.01427579578012228, 0.015440177172422409, -0.0019709572661668062, 0.014203022234141827, -0.00325662805698812, -0.01126174721866846, -0.029715972021222115, 0.003468885086476803, 0.005706679541617632, -0.008878405205905437, 0.020534344017505646, -0.011692325584590435, 0.035974521189928055, -0.004687846172600985, -0.017259521409869194, 0.02446412853896618, -0.017283780500292778, -0.006670932751148939, 0.008029377087950706, -0.014008958823978901, 0.011898517608642578, -0.001512330723926425, -0.061857737600803375, 0.04053501412272453, 0.026441151276230812, 0.015052049420773983, 0.0045089442282915115, -0.02446412853896618, -0.008757115341722965, 0.04216029495000839, 0.0021513758692890406, -0.009612207300961018, -0.04104442894458771, -0.003429465927183628, 0.014773083850741386, 0.049510449171066284, 0.009642530232667923, -0.023748520761728287, -0.0006189564010128379, 0.013632960617542267, 0.025082707405090332, -0.0044998470693826675, 0.036678001284599304, -0.008957243524491787, 0.06981433928012848, 0.04524105414748192, 0.015488692559301853, -0.04672078788280487, 0.034834396094083786, -0.021128663793206215, 0.00023367215180769563, -0.004417976830154657, -0.04921935498714447, -0.006146354600787163, -0.0401226282119751, -0.016895653679966927, 0.006955963559448719, -0.0009771400364115834, 0.021055888384580612, -0.0075624119490385056, -0.03713890165090561, 0.0025440510362386703, 0.037648316472768784, 0.03255414962768555, 0.024076001718640327, 0.017053330317139626, -0.05409519746899605, 0.05273675546050072, 0.01778106763958931, -0.005794614553451538, -0.013560187071561813, 0.04713317006826401, -0.023675747215747833, -0.018023647367954254, 0.07282232493162155, -0.013256962411105633, 0.008629760704934597, -0.015343145467340946, -0.017053330317139626, -0.015682756900787354, 0.01740507036447525, -0.002309052273631096, -0.01865435391664505, -0.024646064266562462, -0.026610957458615303, -0.024391354992985725, -0.010606782510876656, -0.013742120936512947, -0.004615072626620531, -0.0036932709626853466, -0.01473669707775116, 0.027823854237794876, -0.019770218059420586, -0.003383982228115201, -0.0070044794119894505, 0.01952763833105564, -0.0013675411464646459, 0.007453251164406538, -0.007071188651025295, -0.002954920055344701, 0.0008399310754612088, -0.02610154077410698, 0.004196622874587774, -0.02952190861105919, 0.007404735311865807, 0.005024425219744444, 0.009066403843462467, -0.030007068067789078, 0.011013103649020195, 0.017878100275993347, 0.000620472535956651, -0.008138537406921387, -0.0032081122044473886, -0.04703614115715027, -0.021844271570444107, 0.015743400901556015, -0.018727127462625504, -0.030467968434095383, 0.005200295243412256, 0.03226305544376373, -0.016519654542207718, -0.035149749368429184, -0.027969401329755783, 0.0272416640073061, 0.00004832635750062764, 0.010376332327723503, -0.01598598062992096, 0.016628814861178398, -0.018666481599211693, -0.02697482518851757, 0.029376361519098282, -0.02175937034189701, -0.03323337435722351, -0.028430301696062088, -0.007841378450393677, -0.008265892043709755, 0.02121356502175331, -0.0024257937911897898, 0.0006837705732323229, 0.024888643994927406, 0.009224080480635166, -0.0073744128458201885, 0.03267544135451317, 0.021395500749349594, -0.0044998470693826675, 0.03752702847123146, -0.014348569326102734, -0.0021604725625365973, 0.031511060893535614, -0.01198948547244072, -0.018993964418768883, -0.0020300860051065683, -0.004196622874587774, 0.0055065518245100975, -0.009048210456967354, -0.007962667383253574, 0.005955323576927185, -0.0127232875674963, 0.0005742308567278087, -0.02860010787844658, -0.017320167273283005, 0.020740536972880363, -0.030225388705730438, 0.0141666354611516, 0.0009786561131477356, 0.006864996161311865, 0.004721201024949551, -0.03383982181549072, 0.00328391813673079, 0.006610287819057703, -0.010455170646309853, -0.008793502114713192, -0.028478818014264107, -0.013778507709503174, -0.017599133774638176, -0.017162490636110306, -0.021189307793974876, -0.022001948207616806, -0.009988205507397652, 0.006128161214292049, 0.0033566919155418873, 0.017720423638820648, 0.034616075456142426, 0.028842687606811523, -0.018423903733491898, -0.019830863922834396, 0.0268535353243351, 0.020376667380332947, 0.023942584171891212, 0.027047598734498024, 0.008029377087950706, 0.0075017670169472694, -0.018351130187511444, -0.015840433537960052, -0.012128968723118305, 0.0012212354922667146, 0.016022367402911186, 0.010182268917560577, 0.008447826839983463, -0.02772682160139084, -0.008520600385963917, 0.05986858904361725, -0.010679556988179684, 0.03160809352993965, -0.01723526418209076, 0.014239409007132053, -0.022268785163760185, 0.0014206054620444775, 0.015076307579874992, 0.021177178248763084, 0.0007095446344465017, 0.011880324222147465, 0.007798926904797554, 0.006440482102334499, 0.03134125471115112, 0.013778507709503174, -0.008090022020041943, 0.0005022151162847877, 0.013778507709503174, 0.004584750160574913, 0.013353994116187096, -0.01315993070602417, 0.015561466105282307, -0.005597518756985664, 0.009145242162048817, 0.0016889588441699743, -0.04475589469075203, 0.013123543933033943, -0.02741146832704544, -0.0006526901270262897, 0.014469859190285206, 0.004857651889324188, 0.0014062023255974054, -0.010655298829078674, 0.0019466994563117623, -0.0004483927914407104, -0.014857986010611057, 0.005946226883679628, 0.01587682031095028, 0.014894373714923859, -0.0033051439095288515, 0.03616858273744583, -0.03138976916670799, 0.00840537529438734, -0.0437128022313118, -0.009533368982374668, 0.016083011403679848, -0.00454229861497879, 0.004354299511760473, 0.01217748410999775, -0.01631346344947815, 0.0025910509284585714, -0.0019724734593182802, 0.010552202351391315, -0.025106964632868767, 0.006152419373393059, 0.014967147260904312, 0.00859337393194437, 0.04960748180747032, 0.022196011617779732, -0.008817760273814201, 0.009060339070856571, -0.026635214686393738, -0.050165414810180664, 0.019066737964749336, 0.023784907534718513, -0.017441457137465477, -0.009503046981990337, 0.007338026072829962, -0.006270676851272583, -0.005230617709457874, -0.0063737728632986546, 0.010782652534544468, -0.0003144055954180658, -0.02893971838057041, -0.009066403843462467, -0.021286340430378914, -0.020958857610821724, -0.001958828419446945, -0.01425153762102127, -0.01305077038705349, -0.020024927332997322, 0.015500822104513645, -0.0043209451250731945, 0.006676997058093548, -0.028672881424427032, -0.01773255132138729, -0.013269091956317425, 0.006288870237767696, -0.025203997269272804, 0.02399110049009323, -0.042548421770334244, 0.009230145253241062, 0.004572621081024408, 0.012868835590779781, 0.018884804099798203, 0.007738281972706318, -0.002926113549619913, 0.0037053998094052076, 0.0241972915828228, -0.00867221225053072, -0.041529588401317596, -0.006683061830699444, 0.001155284233391285, -0.009339305572211742, 0.03628987446427345, 0.0068407380022108555, -0.004842490889132023, -0.07558773458003998, 0.0012485256884247065, -0.004020752850919962, 0.027096115052700043, 0.03454330191016197, 0.044076669961214066, -0.014967147260904312, 0.0023333101999014616, 0.02806643210351467, 0.016034496948122978, 0.038812700659036636, -0.010631040669977665, 0.01734442450106144, 0.011201102286577225, 0.022960137575864792, 0.0015350725734606385, -0.002011892618611455, -0.02881842851638794, -0.01806003414094448, -0.021844271570444107, 0.02534954436123371, -0.04533808305859566, 0.04545937478542328, -0.026683731004595757, 0.008963307365775108, -0.003696303116157651, 0.0035719810985028744, 0.015464434400200844, 0.002583470195531845, 0.012832448817789555, -0.019345704466104507, -0.0011583165032789111, -0.0014092344790697098, -0.0010938813211396337, -0.0012341225519776344, -0.030201131477952003, 0.005382229574024677, -0.0268535353243351, -0.022960137575864792, -0.002287826733663678, -0.023736391216516495, 0.01675010472536087, -0.0036629484966397285, -0.004066236782819033, 0.009872980415821075, 0.013523799367249012, -0.002541018882766366, -0.021128663793206215, -0.007447186857461929, -0.034397754818201065, -0.04507124796509743, -0.002941274782642722, 0.0329422801733017, 0.004029849544167519, 0.007999055087566376, -0.005749131087213755, 0.011928840540349483, 0.03337892144918442, -0.013899797573685646, 0.012365483678877354, -0.025640638545155525, -0.04509550333023071, 0.00288214604370296, -0.00524577870965004, -0.03039519488811493, 0.013438897207379341, -0.023069297894835472, -0.03556213527917862, 0.001714732963591814, 0.027969401329755783, 0.007756475359201431, -0.036896321922540665, 0.027605531737208366, 0.010291430167853832, -0.038254767656326294, -0.022984394803643227, -0.016022367402911186, 0.017259521409869194, -0.0283332709223032, 0.019976411014795303, 0.002994338981807232, 0.012844577431678772, -0.028963977470993996, -0.004687846172600985, -0.004872812889516354, -0.015537208877503872, 0.028915461152791977, 0.0254465751349926, 0.03941914811730385, 0.0053428104147315025, -0.048637162894010544, -0.025082707405090332, 0.016944168135523796, -0.03219028189778328, -0.03857012093067169, 0.029715972021222115, -0.016774363815784454, -0.005976549349725246, 0.025713413953781128, 0.005018360912799835, 0.013002254068851471, 0.011789357289671898, -0.00037846172926947474, -0.005097198765724897, -0.0003869899082928896, -0.0030201131012290716, 0.018520934507250786, 0.003471917239949107, 0.010734137147665024, 0.000614029006101191, 0.010800846852362156, -0.00508507015183568, 0.008811695501208305, 0.030201131477952003, -0.005324617028236389, 0.00020789810514543205, 0.014397085644304752, -0.0038448830600827932, 0.02262052707374096, 0.01425153762102127, -0.008296214044094086, 0.003623529337346554, 0.0516694039106369, -0.016022367402911186, -0.001911828643642366, 0.01625281758606434, -0.011995550245046616, -0.023045040667057037, -0.013851282186806202, -0.02174724079668522, 0.02410026080906391, -0.02141975797712803, 0.012371547520160675, 0.003811528440564871, -0.005418616812676191, 0.03056500107049942, 0.04150532931089401, 0.004912232048809528, 0.05137830972671509, 0.033912595361471176, 0.014603277668356895, -0.03716316074132919, 0.006440482102334499, -0.04623562842607498, 0.025373801589012146, -0.02241433411836624, 0.006883189547806978, 0.009321112185716629, -0.045920275151729584, 0.012941609136760235, -0.038473088294267654, -0.011504326947033405, 0.026683731004595757, 0.002227181801572442, 0.01947912387549877, 0.03197196125984192, -0.005482293665409088, 0.019175898283720016, 0.019430607557296753, -0.02376064844429493, -0.02675650455057621, -0.015585724264383316, -0.03638690710067749, 0.023518070578575134, -0.038691408932209015, 0.015015662647783756, 0.014651793986558914, 0.03163234889507294, -0.007010543718934059, 0.001426669885404408, -0.04936490207910538, 0.005791582632809877, -0.015743400901556015, 0.023845551535487175, 0.014130248688161373, 0.02207472175359726, 0.021298468112945557, -0.022960137575864792, 0.00131144467741251, -0.029182298108935356, 0.008854147046804428, -0.03136551380157471, 0.03616858273744583, 0.013608702458441257, 0.005840098485350609, 0.019127383828163147, -0.01183180883526802, -0.02174724079668522, -0.0038782376796007156, -0.013742120936512947, -0.0009005758911371231, 0.004966812673956156, -0.006707319524139166, 0.019867250695824623, -0.037332963198423386, -0.021395500749349594, -0.0034324980806559324, 0.025252511724829674, -0.0003896431007888168, 0.01870287023484707, 0.017089717090129852, -0.0070348018780350685, 0.014651793986558914, 0.0005416342755779624, 0.02610154077410698, -0.0015115727437660098, 0.020158344879746437, -0.020510084927082062, 0.018969707190990448, -0.030589258298277855, 0.03311208263039589, 0.0416751354932785, 0.03306356817483902, -0.03801218792796135, 0.007398670539259911, 0.033087827265262604, 0.014093860983848572, 0.011176844127476215, -0.0044755893759429455, 0.014833728782832623, -0.009897238574922085, 0.014506245963275433, 0.0026319860480725765, 0.027557015419006348, -0.0444890558719635, -0.007659443654119968, 0.009363563731312752, -0.0014660890446975827, -0.014057474210858345, -0.010151946917176247, 0.016713717952370644, -0.009412079118192196, -0.020037055015563965, 0.017198877409100533, -0.022111110389232635, 0.0034597881603986025, -0.006549642886966467, -0.01946699433028698, 0.006210031919181347, -0.017720423638820648, -0.028745654970407486, 0.003908560145646334, -0.017963001504540443, 0.01552507933229208, -0.024027487263083458, -0.028406044468283653, 0.015076307579874992, 0.008787437342107296, 0.006731577683240175, 0.011692325584590435, -0.005555067677050829, 0.017538487911224365, -0.008229505270719528, -0.02588321827352047, -0.009387821890413761, -0.006355579476803541, -0.019988540560007095, 0.01139516569674015, 0.046259887516498566, 0.006743706297129393, -0.024500517174601555, -0.02658669836819172, -0.011922775767743587, 0.0190424807369709, 0.03471310809254646, 0.005712744314223528, -0.008423568680882454, -0.05817053094506264, -0.022705428302288055, -0.0011674131965264678, -0.019333574920892715, 0.006792222149670124, 0.005221521016210318, 0.022377947345376015, 0.009527305141091347, -0.006288870237767696, -0.0269263107329607, -0.004190558567643166, 0.014676052145659924, -0.014530504122376442, 0.003614432644098997, 0.016083011403679848 ]
11.746182
2.702045
2024-06-01
3
2024MNRAS.531..788H
[ "recent peculiar velocity samples", "peculiar velocities", "selection effects", "Previous work", "previous work", "idealized mock galaxy surveys", "cosmic microwave background measurements", "systematic biases", "distance", "distances" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
15
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1042", "10.48550/arXiv.2312.03904" ]
[ "Hollinger, Amber M.", "Hudson, Michael J." ]
[ "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Waterloo, 200 University Ave W, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada; Waterloo Centre for Astrophysics, University of Waterloo, 200 University Ave W, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Waterloo, 200 University Ave W, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada; Waterloo Centre for Astrophysics, University of Waterloo, 200 University Ave W, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada; Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics, 31 Caroline St. North, Waterloo, ON N2L 2Y5, Canada&lt;IDsystem=\"ORCID\"&gt;0000-0002-1437-3786" ]
[ "2024MNRAS.531...84B", "2024arXiv240204767A", "2024arXiv240402278L" ]
[ "1975ApJ...196..313S", "1976ApJ...203..297S", "1979ApJ...229....1A", "1979ApJ...233..433D", "1982ApJ...254..437D", "1982ApJ...257..423H", "1988ApJ...326...19L", "1989ApJ...344....1G", "1989MNRAS.241..325L", "1991ApJ...372..380Y", "1995PhR...261..271S", "2000MNRAS.319..573P", "2001MNRAS.327..265H", "2002ApJ...569..101M", "2003MNRAS.341.1311S", "2004ApJ...609...35K", "2004ApJ...614..533T", "2005ApJ...635...11P", "2005PhRvD..72d3529L", "2006ApJ...637....1P", "2007ApJ...661L.123N", "2007PhDT.........3W", "2009ApJS..182..543A", "2009MNRAS.399..683J", "2010ApJ...710..903M", "2010ApJ...717..379B", "2010JCAP...02..021J", "2011MNRAS.413.2906D", "2011MNRAS.416.2840L", "2012ApJ...751L..30H", "2012ApJ...761..152T", "2012ApJS..199...26H", "2012MNRAS.420..447T", "2013ApJ...762..109B", "2013ApJ...763...18B", "2013MNRAS.432.2433H", "2014MNRAS.440.2997V", "2014MNRAS.444.3926J", "2014MNRAS.445.4267K", "2014PhRvD..90l4030B", "2015MNRAS.450..317C", "2015MNRAS.451.1247S", "2015MNRAS.454.3328V", "2016ApJ...826...56R", "2016ApJS..222...22C", "2016MNRAS.457.4340K", "2016MNRAS.458.2725J", "2016MNRAS.459.1468M", "2016MNRAS.461L..11H", "2017ApJ...847..128H", "2017JCAP...05..015H", "2017MNRAS.464.2517H", "2017MNRAS.470..445N", "2017MNRAS.471..839A", "2018ApJ...855..136R", "2018ApJ...859..101S", "2018MNRAS.474.5206K", "2018MNRAS.479....2C", "2019MNRAS.486..440D", "2019MNRAS.487.5209H", "2019MNRAS.487.5235Q", "2020A&A...641A...1P", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020A&A...641A...8P", "2020MNRAS.494.3275A", "2020MNRAS.497.1275S", "2020MNRAS.498.2703B", "2021A&A...645A.104A", "2021A&A...646A.140H", "2021MNRAS.502.1401M", "2021MNRAS.502.2087T", "2021MNRAS.502.3723H", "2021MNRAS.507.1557L", "2021PhRvD.103h3533A", "2022ApJ...934L...7R", "2022ApJ...935...83K", "2022ApJ...938..110B", "2022ApJ...938..112P", "2022MNRAS.516.5355A", "2022PhRvD.105b3520A", "2023ApJ...944...94T", "2023PhRvD.108l2005P", "2023PhRvD.108l3519D", "2023PhRvL.131k1001N", "2024ApJ...962..113M" ]
29031195
2403.14758
Modelling of surface brightness fluctuation measurements. Methodology, uncertainty, and recommendations
<BR /> Aims: The goal of this work is to scrutinise the surface brightness fluctuation (SBF) calculation methodology. We analysed the SBF derivation procedure, measured the accuracy of the fitted SBF under controlled conditions, retrieved the uncertainty associated with the variability of a system that is inherently stochastic, and studied the SBF reliability under a wide range of conditions. Additionally, we address the possibility of an SBF gradient detection. We also examine the problems related with biased measurements of the SBF and low luminosity sources. All of this information allows us to put forward guidelines to ensure a valid SBF retrieval. <BR /> Methods: To perform all the experiments described above, we carried out Monte Carlo simulations of mock galaxies as an ideal laboratory. Knowing its underlying properties, we attempted to retrieve SBFs under different conditions. The uncertainty was evaluated through the accuracy, the precision, and the standard deviation of the fitting. <BR /> Results: We demonstrate how the usual mathematical approximations taken in the SBF theoretical derivation have a negligible impact on the results and how modelling the instrumental noise reduces the uncertainty. We conducted various studies where we varied the size of the mask applied over the image, the surface and fluctuation brightness of the galaxy, its size and profile, its point spread function, and the sky background. It is worth highlighting that we find a strong correlation between having a high number of pixels within the studied mask and retrieving a low uncertainty result. We address how the standard deviation of the fitting underestimates the actual uncertainty of the measurement. Lastly, we find that, when studying SBF gradients, the result is a pixel-weighted average of all the SBFs present within the studied region. Retrieving an SBF gradient requires high-quality data and a sufficient difference in the fluctuation value through the different radii. We show how the SBF uncertainty can be obtained and we present a collection of qualitative recommendations for a safe SBF retrieval. <BR /> Conclusions: Our main findings are as follows. It is important to model the instrumental noise, rather than fitting it. The target galaxies must be observed under appropriate observational conditions. In a traditional SBF derivation, one should avoid pixels with fluxes lower than ten times the SBF estimate to prevent biased results. The uncertainty associated with the intrinsic variability of the system can be obtained using sets of Monte Carlo mock galaxy simulations. We offer our computational implementation in the form of a simple code designed to estimate the uncertainty of the SBF measurement. This code can be used to predict the quality of future observations or to evaluate the reliability of those already conducted.
[ 0.0036931713111698627, 0.01417543925344944, 0.02649819850921631, 0.008471135050058365, -0.03824808821082115, -0.007916550152003765, -0.01037866435945034, 0.001138118328526616, -0.01729574240744114, 0.04256288334727287, 0.01808800734579563, -0.0008669201633892953, -0.08844108879566193, -0.010238494724035263, 0.03985699638724327, 0.08137165009975433, -0.024560198187828064, 0.026376312598586082, -0.037077974528074265, -0.012883438728749752, 0.010287249460816383, -0.03193435072898865, 0.003863812889903784, 0.027960840612649918, -0.06742779910564423, -0.09248773008584976, 0.03588348627090454, 0.0036413692869246006, 0.035005901008844376, -0.04639013111591339, -0.005006501916795969, -0.022085895761847496, -0.05202130228281021, -0.02744891680777073, -0.03317759931087494, 0.08688093721866608, -0.022597819566726685, 0.013675703667104244, -0.020379479974508286, -0.03091050311923027, -0.002733312314376235, 0.008788040839135647, -0.02297566831111908, 0.03371389955282211, -0.004372690338641405, -0.03459148481488228, -0.015004269778728485, -0.07503353804349899, 0.01254215557128191, 0.008257833309471607, -0.05358145385980606, -0.002562670735642314, 0.009964249096810818, -0.03871126100420952, 0.023853253573179245, -0.003854671260342002, -0.01930687576532364, 0.014370458200573921, -0.000495165295433253, -0.013517250306904316, 0.004988218657672405, -0.013212533667683601, 0.011920533142983913, 0.010780890472233295, -0.01450453419238329, -0.016296271234750748, 0.027229519560933113, -0.00323609565384686, 0.005893228575587273, 0.025961896404623985, 0.022658763453364372, 0.02061106450855732, 0.03961322084069252, -0.0012767646694555879, -0.0034981523640453815, 0.0015342505648732185, 0.06455127149820328, 0.005046115256845951, -0.0073863426223397255, -0.01306626945734024, -0.0018145903013646603, 0.005914558656513691, 0.02201276272535324, -0.02468208409845829, -0.07498478144407272, 0.005058303941041231, -0.017222611233592033, -0.021878687664866447, -0.05075367912650108, 0.008891644887626171, -0.003385406918823719, -0.005231992341578007, -0.02262219786643982, 0.03156869113445282, -0.005643360782414675, -0.04799903556704521, -0.01035428699105978, -0.04439118504524231, 0.04814530164003372, 0.0022046281956136227, 0.035322804003953934, 0.0344695970416069, 0.024413933977484703, -0.09068381041288376, 0.07844636589288712, -0.016345025971531868, 0.01734449714422226, -0.0031507748644798994, 0.009440135210752487, 0.047121450304985046, 0.05504409596323967, -0.018782760947942734, -0.007953116670250893, 0.02141551673412323, -0.002747024642303586, 0.014443590305745602, -0.07727625221014023, 0.015028647147119045, 0.018831515684723854, -0.002881100168451667, -0.001770406379364431, -0.018929025158286095, 0.013456307351589203, 0.031081143766641617, 0.04344046860933304, -0.022744083777070045, 0.06347866356372833, -0.033104464411735535, -0.04397677257657051, -0.017673591151833534, 0.060797154903411865, -0.05153375491499901, 0.018929025158286095, -0.01658879965543747, -0.01189006119966507, -0.011755985207855701, -0.011682853102684021, 0.003418925916776061, 0.013407552614808083, 0.02458457462489605, -0.01684476062655449, 0.010409136302769184, -0.004771869629621506, 0.018941214308142662, 0.02091578207910061, 0.000596864614635706, -0.036322277039289474, 0.04175842925906181, 0.0016576610505580902, 0.03303133323788643, -0.019440950825810432, -0.009056191891431808, -0.059480778872966766, -0.014760496094822884, 0.016515666618943214, -0.033811409026384354, 0.036371033638715744, 0.03922318294644356, -0.01805143989622593, 0.005186284892261028, -0.01824645884335041, 0.028472766280174255, -0.024157971143722534, -0.013029702939093113, 0.012200872413814068, 0.008660060353577137, -0.04180718585848808, -0.0075569842010736465, -0.020672008395195007, 0.0006962785846553743, 0.004771869629621506, -0.001064224517904222, 0.025693746283650398, -0.06708651781082153, -0.009744852781295776, 0.04331858083605766, 0.030642351135611534, -0.01638159155845642, 0.0016911799320951104, -0.015540571883320808, -0.008257833309471607, -0.010177550837397575, 0.04855971783399582, -0.013785401359200478, 0.022902537137269974, -0.01644253544509411, -0.016856949776411057, 0.01961159147322178, 0.015504006296396255, -0.025596236810088158, 0.012249627150595188, -0.008422380313277245, 0.008428474888205528, 0.02740016207098961, -0.04273352399468422, -0.021452084183692932, -0.0033396994695067406, 0.002104071667417884, -0.03683420270681381, 0.013188156299293041, 0.03834559768438339, 0.003927803598344326, 0.04568318650126457, -0.00041441526263952255, -0.017856420949101448, -0.03715110942721367, 0.018380535766482353, -0.0000658950739307329, -0.023341329768300056, -0.025937519967556, -0.0034920580219477415, -0.0050247847102582455, 0.02120831049978733, -0.004269086755812168, -0.07127942144870758, 0.029667256399989128, -0.02644944377243519, 0.045268770307302475, 0.011445173993706703, 0.001518252887763083, -0.0018328733276575804, 0.02623004838824272, 0.05714055150747299, 0.02126925252377987, 0.024852726608514786, 0.02016008272767067, 0.06108968332409859, -0.0380043163895607, 0.010817456990480423, -0.06557512283325195, 0.027205143123865128, 0.028935935348272324, 0.015394307672977448, 0.010506645776331425, 0.013200344517827034, -0.007282738573849201, 0.007203512359410524, 0.025864386931061745, 0.00571953970938921, -0.03715110942721367, 0.014187628403306007, 0.0581156462430954, -0.01649129018187523, -0.03361639007925987, -0.015942798927426338, 0.010299437679350376, -0.021854309365153313, -0.006697681732475758, 0.022987857460975647, 0.001988279167562723, 0.023548537865281105, -0.03156869113445282, -0.03856499493122101, -0.03612725809216499, -0.03125178441405296, -0.030739860609173775, -0.040588315576314926, 0.01749076135456562, -0.018660875037312508, 0.0005130674107931554, -0.07483851909637451, -0.07498478144407272, -0.05046115070581436, -0.02045261114835739, -0.06167474016547203, 0.016150007024407387, -0.009982531890273094, 0.01412668451666832, -0.0009171984856948256, 0.018734006211161613, -0.024304235354065895, 0.023853253573179245, 0.05411775782704353, -0.00650875736027956, -0.02136676199734211, 0.0020111328922212124, -0.018173327669501305, 0.0622110441327095, -0.024255480617284775, -0.0049486057832837105, 0.015345552936196327, 0.002094930037856102, 0.015699025243520737, -0.002702840603888035, -0.0009644296369515359, 0.016503477469086647, 0.01739325188100338, -0.009568116627633572, 0.004662171471863985, -0.038686882704496384, 0.0353715606033802, -0.0034920580219477415, 0.016978837549686432, 0.019879743456840515, -0.014614231884479523, -0.02735140733420849, 0.033445749431848526, 0.003836388234049082, 0.00024815398501232266, 0.027717066928744316, 0.023146310821175575, 0.015357742086052895, 0.03212936967611313, 0.012712797150015831, -0.017271365970373154, -0.015504006296396255, 0.02156178094446659, 0.03076423890888691, -0.03461586311459541, 0.013212533667683601, 0.03132491931319237, 0.016113439574837685, -0.011877872049808502, 0.046975187957286835, -0.013517250306904316, -0.03322635218501091, 0.015516194514930248, -0.007928739301860332, 0.0321781262755394, -0.016759440302848816, -0.03629789873957634, -0.031739331781864166, 0.011640192940831184, 0.01143907941877842, 0.00816641841083765, -0.062162287533283234, -0.0024392602499574423, 0.011682853102684021, 0.009196361526846886, 0.011085608042776585, 0.028521521016955376, 0.020745139569044113, 0.03685858100652695, -0.032251257449388504, -0.051875039935112, -0.04894975572824478, 0.016503477469086647, 0.07805632799863815, -0.019733479246497154, -0.03917443007230759, -0.010086135938763618, -0.0420265831053257, -0.015369930304586887, -0.0037845864426344633, 0.04373299703001976, -0.006831757258623838, 0.01914842240512371, -0.004698737524449825, 0.0907813161611557, 0.0029968926683068275, 0.0035103410482406616, 0.02649819850921631, 0.03934507071971893, -0.025498727336525917, 0.0130906468257308, -0.0067403423599898815, 0.020074762403964996, -0.022634385153651237, -0.029691634699702263, -0.049632322043180466, 0.03232438862323761, 0.008550361730158329, 0.03347012773156166, -0.0014816868351772428, -0.009714380837976933, 0.031788088381290436, 0.015443062409758568, -0.008154229260981083, -0.019928498193621635, -0.01824645884335041, -0.00643562525510788, 0.030983634293079376, -0.034810882061719894, -0.005299030337482691, -0.07561859488487244, 0.008257833309471607, 0.04870598018169403, -0.016661930829286575, -0.01850242167711258, 0.07361964881420135, 0.05957828834652901, 0.03534718230366707, -0.06128470227122307, -0.02839963324368, 0.02413359470665455, 0.0011160263093188405, 0.02498680166900158, -0.02487710304558277, -0.051094964146614075, 0.03215374797582626, -0.058944474905729294, 0.023341329768300056, 0.014918949455022812, 0.014967704191803932, 0.03417706862092018, 0.015918420627713203, -0.0016942271031439304, 0.09253648668527603, 0.04831594228744507, 0.05133873596787453, -0.00351338810287416, 0.011640192940831184, -0.03132491931319237, -0.031739331781864166, -0.05050990730524063, 0.028789671137928963, -0.008129851892590523, 0.02016008272767067, 0.034957144409418106, 0.027960840612649918, -0.018941214308142662, -0.051289983093738556, 0.05640922859311104, -0.06108968332409859, 0.023743556812405586, 0.04497624188661575, 0.00014321703929454088, 0.05626296624541283, -0.018319591879844666, 0.01663755439221859, 0.006917078047990799, -0.05172877386212349, 0.006277172360569239, -0.013736646622419357, -0.04036892205476761, 0.03990574926137924, -0.023085366934537888, 0.004741398151963949, 0.0003224287647753954, -0.05143624544143677, -0.01674725115299225, 0.01643034629523754, -0.022280914708971977, -0.0017292695119976997, -0.0531914159655571, 0.003108114469796419, 0.05011986941099167, -0.03222687914967537, 0.009013531729578972, -0.013444118201732635, 0.032397523522377014, -0.02488929219543934, -0.06440500915050507, -0.0016668025637045503, 0.013334420509636402, 0.027619557455182076, 0.011323287151753902, 0.01914842240512371, 0.014870194718241692, -0.02413359470665455, -0.009342625737190247, -0.022280914708971977, -0.005009549204260111, -0.00987283419817686, -0.016125628724694252, -0.0062131816521286964, 0.03615163639187813, -0.060992173850536346, 0.0536789633333683, -0.03156869113445282, 0.030398577451705933, 0.012798118405044079, -0.006030351389199495, 0.03100801259279251, 0.01649129018187523, 0.05216756835579872, -0.02488929219543934, 0.0004582183319143951, -0.025718122720718384, 0.030349822714924812, 0.008330965414643288, -0.0402226559817791, 0.051143717020750046, 0.017173856496810913, 0.014992081560194492, -0.023158499971032143, -0.017161667346954346, -0.06030960753560066, 0.022232159972190857, 0.012371513992547989, 0.02131800726056099, 0.002378316828981042, 0.021025478839874268, 0.027156388387084007, 0.0384918637573719, 0.06328364461660385, 0.04656077176332474, 0.03573722019791603, -0.03256816416978836, -0.0020111328922212124, -0.027253897860646248, -0.05387398228049278, 0.0384187325835228, -0.011640192940831184, 0.028643406927585602, -0.028228992596268654, -0.009019626304507256, 0.0047231148928403854, -0.004476293921470642, 0.015418685041368008, 0.08302931487560272, 0.0049486057832837105, 0.006264983676373959, 0.048486582934856415, 0.03624914586544037, 0.004829765763133764, -0.04263601452112198, -0.024608952924609184, -0.03388454020023346, -0.01602811925113201, -0.007697153836488724, 0.02981352061033249, 0.02749767154455185, 0.019014347344636917, 0.016710685566067696, 0.022256536409258842, -0.02754642628133297, 0.024864915758371353, 0.014016986824572086, -0.019916309043765068, -0.002728741616010666, -0.03763865679502487, -0.00929996557533741, 0.015845289453864098, 0.012048513628542423, -0.024706462398171425, -0.030691105872392654, -0.05845692753791809, -0.01138423103839159, -0.007288833148777485, 0.03261691704392433, -0.02452363260090351, -0.03437208756804466, -0.009153701364994049, -0.005652502179145813, -0.025669367983937263, -0.017283553257584572, -0.016210949048399925, -0.04000325873494148, 0.008276116102933884, 0.021903064101934433, -0.028326502069830894, 0.025449972599744797, 0.012213061563670635, -0.0044336337596178055, -0.002303661312907934, -0.003226954024285078, 0.010579777881503105, 0.014833628199994564, -0.007672776468098164, 0.01679600588977337, -0.015235855244100094, 0.022987857460975647, 0.034055184572935104, 0.0009697621571831405, 0.03020355850458145, 0.015723401680588722, -0.019026534631848335, -0.0015586279332637787, -0.0038150581531226635, 0.011707230471074581, 0.007093814201653004, 0.0036048032343387604, 0.02488929219543934, -0.021854309365153313, -0.025303708389401436, -0.006813474465161562, -0.008684437721967697, -0.004555520601570606, 0.02282940410077572, -0.03293382376432419, 0.030934879556298256, 0.0026997935492545366, -0.01604030840098858, 0.009452324360609055, -0.0026373264845460653, -0.014309515245258808, -0.046926431357860565, 0.0021497791167348623, 0.007496040780097246, -0.01900215819478035, -0.008873362094163895, -0.02644944377243519, -0.011024664156138897, -0.03839435428380966, -0.016576610505580902, 0.02296348102390766, 0.0021482554730027914, 0.018868083134293556, -0.010488362051546574, -0.011213589459657669, -0.017064157873392105, -0.01683257333934307, 0.032348766922950745, 0.01996506378054619, 0.022597819566726685, 0.00007198941602837294, 0.02754642628133297, -0.011122173629701138, 0.038028694689273834, 0.01703977957367897, -0.0028247274458408356, -0.007343681994825602, -0.026961369439959526, -0.013175967149436474, -0.006917078047990799, 0.022451555356383324, -0.017673591151833534, -0.006137002259492874, 0.020038196817040443, -0.02221997082233429, 0.018563365563750267, -0.00864787120372057, -0.02774144522845745, -0.01599155366420746, 0.015540571883320808, 0.006313738413155079, -0.016600986942648888, 0.029228463768959045, 0.0008334012818522751, -0.017832044512033463, -0.0048937564715743065, 0.030642351135611534, -0.026254424825310707, 0.05309390649199486, 0.0036931713111698627, 0.0032878974452614784, -0.030447332188487053, -0.003677935339510441, -0.011402513831853867, -0.01845366694033146, 0.008983059786260128, 0.015747779980301857, -0.03076423890888691, 0.004872426390647888, 0.01723479852080345, -0.0033579824957996607, 0.01256653293967247, -0.015394307672977448, -0.01647910103201866, 0.02896031364798546, 0.010921061038970947, 0.01452891156077385, -0.05558039993047714, -0.009111041203141212, -0.007611833047121763, -0.009574211202561855, 0.01301751472055912, -0.030983634293079376, -0.04775526374578476, -0.04936416819691658, -0.01607687398791313, 0.019416572526097298, 0.006978021468967199, 0.01292000524699688, 0.002867387840524316, 0.009141513146460056, 0.011420796625316143, 0.0160890631377697, -0.003915614914149046, -0.01779547892510891, 0.02130581997334957, -0.00982407946139574, -0.03332386165857315, -0.0028399634175002575, 0.009671720676124096, -0.0007118952926248312, -0.006679398939013481, 0.03615163639187813, 0.04170967638492584, 0.017454195767641068, -0.023390084505081177, -0.011676759459078312, 0.03086174838244915, -0.025937519967556, 0.017405441030859947, 0.035566579550504684, -0.05353270098567009, 0.009568116627633572, 0.05036364123225212, -0.021976197138428688, 0.0071730404160916805, -0.034250203520059586, -0.015174911357462406, -0.027229519560933113, 0.043806128203868866, 0.01457766629755497, -0.01699102483689785, 0.004781011026352644, -0.031081143766641617, 0.010311626829206944, 0.017210422083735466, 0.007563078310340643, -0.005582417361438274, 0.009885022416710854, -0.0005831523449160159, 0.0036230862606316805, 0.000969000393524766, -0.006910983938723803, -0.06113843992352486, 0.013322231359779835, 0.006176615599542856, 0.047779642045497894, -0.01980661042034626, -0.03593223914504051, -0.005631172098219395, -0.024145781993865967, 0.021183932200074196, 0.014065741561353207, -0.041539035737514496, 0.022439366206526756, 0.022232159972190857, -0.03337261825799942, -0.001367417979054153, 0.013346608728170395, -0.003595661837607622, 0.026156915351748466, 0.03198310732841492, 0.016418157145380974, -0.006813474465161562, -0.022341856732964516, 0.008312682621181011, -0.015126156620681286, -0.002737883012741804, 0.027180764824151993, -0.04595133662223816, -0.014467967674136162, 0.009391380473971367, -0.025596236810088158, 0.015235855244100094, 0.016905704513192177, 0.03563971072435379, 0.005402633920311928, -0.023694802075624466, 0.009434041567146778, -0.0012973330449312925, -0.006971927359700203, 0.004841954447329044, 0.002552005695179105, 0.02090359292924404, 0.0024575432762503624, 0.006630644202232361, -0.004262992180883884, 0.0007027537794783711, -0.008708815090358257, -0.0031568692065775394, 0.004253850784152746, -0.011500023305416107, -0.008318777196109295, -0.03166620060801506, 0.02025759220123291, 0.009239022620022297, 0.02323163114488125, -0.02976476587355137, 0.0393206924200058, 0.0018572506960481405, -0.0028765294700860977, -0.0025261046830564737, -0.0008433045586571097, 0.029374727979302406, 0.025498727336525917, 0.015589326620101929, 0.013407552614808083, -0.020147893577814102, -0.020745139569044113, 0.02473083883523941, -0.03283631429076195, 0.0014245524071156979, 0.038126204162836075, -0.019830988720059395, 0.01919717714190483, 0.006182709708809853, 0.015918420627713203, -0.005573275499045849, 0.01563808135688305, 0.016308458521962166, 0.019891932606697083, -0.015662459656596184, -0.007301021832972765, 0.03805306926369667, -0.000602958956733346, -0.010147078894078732, 0.013724458403885365, 0.022683139890432358, 0.007514323573559523, 0.02035510167479515, -0.028814049437642097, 0.002366128144785762, 0.005844473838806152, -0.01885589398443699, -0.0060547287575900555, 0.014187628403306007, -0.007843418046832085, -0.004561614710837603, -0.03015480376780033, 0.03649291768670082, -0.020988913252949715, -0.09375535696744919, 0.008739286102354527, 0.025596236810088158, 0.03156869113445282, -0.007355870679020882, -0.0026799868792295456, -0.0075021348893642426, 0.023182876408100128, 0.006892700679600239, 0.004829765763133764, 0.009123229421675205, -0.006048634182661772, 0.010610248893499374, 0.05168002098798752, 0.011798646301031113, -0.034957144409418106, -0.0032818031031638384, 0.015150533989071846, -0.004095397889614105, -0.0060273041017353535, 0.007989682257175446, 0.043513599783182144, -0.008684437721967697, 0.006021209992468357, 0.021500838920474052, 0.01814894936978817, -0.026961369439959526, -0.0008989154594019055, 0.007928739301860332, -0.01462642103433609, -0.003967416472733021, 0.02508431114256382, -0.0029450906440615654, 0.005686020944267511, -0.002093406394124031, 0.00354995415546, -0.009641248732805252, 0.0622110441327095, -0.01578434556722641, 0.015418685041368008, -0.005975502077490091, -0.008440664038062096, 0.03317759931087494, 0.020696384832262993, 0.046219490468502045, 0.014187628403306007, 0.022280914708971977, 0.03215374797582626, 0.030032917857170105, -0.00995205994695425, -0.01628408208489418, -0.01042741909623146, -0.01135985367000103, -0.002550482051447034, 0.01023240014910698, -0.0026479915250092745, 0.01410230714827776, 0.003760209074243903, -0.035469070076942444, -0.010147078894078732, -0.04324544966220856, 0.025011179968714714, 0.006146143656224012, -0.018929025158286095, -0.025961896404623985, -0.047974660992622375, -0.02944786101579666, 0.018161138519644737, -0.009732663631439209, -0.03724861890077591, -0.05163126438856125, 0.007337587885558605, 0.02835087850689888, 0.02262219786643982, 0.004436681047081947, 0.02096453681588173, -0.011493928730487823, -0.038321223109960556, -0.03836997598409653, -0.009635154157876968, 0.007343681994825602, -0.02126925252377987, 0.019087478518486023, -0.027985218912363052, -0.007221795152872801, 0.032397523522377014, 0.02584001049399376, 0.007355870679020882, 0.004199001472443342, 0.043416090309619904, 0.03483526036143303, -0.014565477147698402, 0.04014952480792999, -0.001791736576706171, -0.01105513609945774, -0.009330437518656254, 0.025449972599744797, -0.02820461429655552, 0.03186121955513954, -0.013907288201153278, -0.013882910832762718, 0.009598588570952415, -0.018307402729988098, -0.056067947298288345, 0.006959738675504923, -0.03602974861860275, -0.02141551673412323, -0.00046735984506085515, -0.018368346616625786, -0.004823671653866768, 0.028082728385925293, 0.05026613175868988, -0.002108642365783453, 0.016954459249973297, 0.022744083777070045, 0.018782760947942734, 0.005186284892261028, 0.01158534362912178, -0.013444118201732635, 0.008617399260401726, 0.047682132571935654, 0.004787105601280928, -0.030886124819517136, 0.0187949500977993, -0.015479628928005695, -0.030081672593951225, -0.011085608042776585, -0.0290578231215477, -0.043659865856170654, 0.035103410482406616, -0.006106530781835318, 0.02117174305021763, -0.010244588367640972, -0.0037815391551703215, 0.005835332442075014, -0.015077401883900166, 0.0015555807622149587, -0.0041045392863452435, 0.048632849007844925, 0.03780929744243622, -0.005338643677532673, 0.027327029034495354, 0.01306626945734024, 0.03361639007925987, -0.025206198915839195, 0.008056719787418842, 0.008148135617375374, -0.03590786084532738, 0.04329420626163483, 0.03056921996176243, 0.010695570148527622, 0.02532808482646942, -0.013614759780466557, 0.04770650714635849, -0.011615815572440624, -0.00177802424877882, 0.01668630912899971, -0.022805027663707733, -0.03283631429076195, 0.022597819566726685, 0.011024664156138897, 0.0496566966176033, -0.01914842240512371, -0.02698574587702751, -0.007879984565079212, 0.004037501756101847, -0.019770044833421707, 0.027912085875868797, -0.0042751808650791645, 0.0027561660390347242, -0.02608378417789936, -0.052655115723609924, 0.06630644202232361, 0.0014816868351772428, 0.006661115679889917, 0.01562589220702648, -0.031788088381290436, 0.011859589256346226, 0.025059934705495834, 0.005597652867436409, 0.017856420949101448, -0.023999517783522606, 0.008788040839135647, -0.0070694368332624435, 0.03520091995596886, -0.026863859966397285, -0.034152694046497345, -0.006941455416381359, 0.003418925916776061, -0.0013956043403595686, -0.006207087077200413, 0.007739814464002848, 0.021403329446911812, 0.024255480617284775, 0.031349293887615204, 0.014187628403306007, -0.03581035137176514, 0.04699956625699997, -0.016820384189486504, -0.0011221206514164805, -0.05177753046154976, -0.014431402087211609, -0.016296271234750748, -0.004890709184110165, -0.009842362254858017, -0.0009217692422680557, -0.0025200103409588337, -0.008062814362347126, -0.021988386288285255, -0.024413933977484703, -0.02688823640346527, 0.019794423133134842, 0.024950236082077026, -0.0076605877839028835, 0.009708286263048649, -0.03995450586080551, 0.021939631551504135, -0.008507701568305492, -0.04480560123920441, -0.01964815892279148, 0.015967175364494324, -0.05519036203622818, -0.019111856818199158, 0.028033973649144173, 0.00541786989197135, 0.020489176735281944, 0.011000286787748337, -0.037272993475198746, -0.00712428567931056, -0.01424857135862112, 0.01292000524699688, 0.007837323471903801, 0.01961159147322178, -0.031495559960603714, -0.02282940410077572, 0.026473822072148323, -0.032495032995939255, -0.007806851994246244, -0.009622965939342976, -0.0009895687690004706, 0.04565880820155144, 0.002056840341538191, 0.010153173469007015, -0.012304476462304592, 0.0047078789211809635, 0.008123758248984814, -0.003836388234049082, 0.0019867555238306522, -0.005497096572071314, -0.000026305655410396867, -0.01254215557128191, 0.01753951609134674, 0.0024788735900074244, 0.002108642365783453, 0.010226305574178696, 0.016369402408599854, -0.01914842240512371, 0.03685858100652695, 0.021988386288285255, 0.00032585684675723314, 0.009220738895237446, -0.01000081468373537, -0.006667210254818201, -0.022585630416870117, 0.016564421355724335, -0.0012310571037232876, -0.024803971871733665, -0.01256653293967247, -0.03378703072667122, 0.0013841773616150022, 0.004799294285476208, -0.03520091995596886, 0.0016942271031439304, -0.010336004197597504, -0.038906279951334, -0.021854309365153313, -0.010969815775752068, -0.013943854719400406, -0.0036413692869246006, 0.011402513831853867, -0.021476460620760918, 0.005905417259782553, -0.000160738272825256, -0.010799174197018147, -0.0352984294295311, -0.0130906468257308, -0.028935935348272324, 0.008282210677862167, 0.0380043163895607, 0.0006772337364964187, 0.0001746409834595397, 0.015552761033177376, 0.007593550253659487, -0.002702840603888035, -0.007538700941950083, -0.010518833994865417, 0.025620613247156143, 0.007697153836488724, 0.007380248047411442, 0.018965592607855797, -0.0375899001955986, -0.023816687986254692, 0.013931665569543839, 0.027765821665525436, 0.0031203031539916992, -0.015491817146539688, -0.00023729844542685896, -0.006222323048859835, -0.04609760269522667, -0.001541106728836894, 0.014845817349851131, -0.0022305292077362537, -0.012932193465530872, -0.006332021206617355, 0.0020446516573429108, -0.028180237859487534, -0.01261528767645359, -0.0014093165518715978, 0.015967175364494324, -0.0130906468257308, 0.01763702556490898, -0.0016530902357771993, 0.014016986824572086, 0.027107633650302887, -0.00876975804567337, -0.0230244230479002, -0.020196648314595222, 0.0011586867040023208, -0.028643406927585602, 0.028765294700860977, 0.013651326298713684, 0.02085483819246292, 0.0023463217075914145, -0.022207781672477722, -0.024560198187828064, -0.007922644726932049, 0.04122212901711464, 0.020269781351089478, 0.059188250452280045, 0.03971073031425476, -0.013639137148857117, 0.01995287463068962, -0.0022000574972480536, -0.00867224857211113, -0.004220332019031048, 0.01268841978162527, 0.004305652808398008, -0.023694802075624466, -0.022792838513851166, 0.011719419620931149, 0.06460002809762955, 0.005716492887586355, 0.014333892613649368, -0.05197254940867424, 0.05050990730524063, -0.033201973885297775, 0.00014416927297133952, -0.009281682781875134, 0.043854884803295135, 0.01729574240744114, 0.007441191468387842, 0.02006257325410843, -0.02623004838824272, 0.030544841662049294, 0.03181246668100357, 0.007477757520973682, 0.0012531490065157413, 0.020026007667183876, -0.028984690085053444, 0.015260232612490654, -0.013761023990809917, 0.011999758891761303, -0.010323815047740936, -0.012846873141825199, -0.015248043462634087, 0.010866211727261543, -0.0036535579711198807, 0.017734535038471222, 0.015223666094243526, -0.0020735999569296837, 0.0023402273654937744, 0.026254424825310707, -0.021732423454523087, -0.009171984158456326, -0.02849714271724224, -0.03520091995596886, 0.00014493106573354453, 0.02779019996523857, 0.038638126105070114, -0.001076413202099502, 0.008184701204299927, -0.00802015420049429, 0.008312682621181011, -0.013943854719400406, -0.00937309768050909, 0.013310043141245842, 0.028838425874710083, 0.03780929744243622, -0.014821439981460571, 0.0062527949921786785, 0.024548009037971497, -0.0011129791382700205, 0.0015494864201173186, -0.01723479852080345, -0.02654695324599743, 0.01859993115067482, -0.015199288725852966, 0.021330196410417557, 0.012481212615966797, 0.0034829163923859596, 0.0008387338020838797, -0.010433513671159744, -0.022134650498628616, 0.02342665009200573, 0.03210499510169029, -0.0032848503906279802, 0.01713728904724121, 0.025596236810088158, 0.008062814362347126, 0.0013118070783093572, -0.020379479974508286, 0.009354814887046814, -0.011640192940831184, -0.014212005771696568, 0.003415878629311919, -0.00575610576197505, -0.02061106450855732, 0.03702922165393829, -0.01568683609366417, -0.013590382412075996, -0.006606266833841801, 0.0012371514458209276, -0.0052502756007015705, -0.0013818920124322176, -0.04032016545534134, -0.009891116991639137, -0.021854309365153313, 0.0005842950195074081, -0.06128470227122307, 0.024950236082077026, -0.02649819850921631, 0.02382887713611126, 0.0208060834556818, 0.005789624992758036, 0.002297566970810294, 0.016125628724694252, 0.002568765077739954, -0.02117174305021763, 0.03744363784790039, -0.008934305049479008, 0.007764191832393408, 0.0006372396019287407, 0.007429002784192562, -0.01985536515712738, 0.004896803759038448, 0.013505062088370323, -0.008848984725773335, -0.03734612837433815, 0.03161744773387909, 0.018478045240044594, 0.04478122293949127, 0.0016820384189486504, 0.004241662099957466, -0.015857478603720665, 0.018612120300531387, 0.0010924107627943158, 0.021829932928085327, 0.013956042937934399, -0.013870722614228725, -0.0252793300896883, 0.028935935348272324, 0.005588511470705271, 0.015479628928005695, -0.03678544610738754, -0.031154276803135872, -0.021427705883979797, -0.015235855244100094, -0.008318777196109295, 0.0027759727090597153, -0.0063563985750079155, -0.04387926310300827, 0.00967781525105238, 0.008306588046252728, 0.04061269387602806, -0.006216228939592838, -0.003882095916196704, 0.015272420831024647, 0.0019090526038780808, -0.00712428567931056, -0.02407265082001686, -0.0037632561288774014, -0.04909601807594299, -0.009921588934957981, -0.04207533597946167, -0.009464512579143047, -0.02041604556143284, -0.007849512621760368, -0.023816687986254692, -0.001957807457074523, 0.009171984158456326, -0.010969815775752068, -0.013163778930902481, 0.006344209890812635, 0.001524347229860723, -0.006231464445590973, 0.008318777196109295, 0.006935361307114363, -0.023390084505081177, 0.004869379103183746, 0.02156178094446659, 0.0007469377596862614, 0.01674725115299225, -0.014285137876868248, 0.021098611876368523, 0.03273880481719971, -0.028838425874710083, -0.022536875680088997, 0.011500023305416107, -0.009159795939922333, -0.003949133679270744, -0.039978884160518646, -0.050948698073625565, 0.011737702414393425, -0.007508229464292526, -0.027985218912363052, -0.015662459656596184, 0.016466911882162094, 0.0032848503906279802, -0.021708045154809952, 0.0044183977879583836, -0.001048988662660122, -0.04100273177027702, 0.014992081560194492, -0.03685858100652695, -0.0393206924200058, -0.012749363668262959, -0.012761551886796951, 0.012822495773434639, 0.0018542035249993205, -0.0362003892660141, 0.012761551886796951, -0.03941820189356804, 0.022098083049058914, 0.0000047701319090265315, 0.014236383140087128, 0.01623532734811306, 0.027156388387084007, -0.029374727979302406, -0.04982734099030495, 0.008788040839135647, -0.004019218496978283, -0.011554872617125511, 0.01184130646288395, -0.015174911357462406, -0.00515276612713933, 0.023402273654937744, -0.02332914061844349, 0.0027622603811323643, 0.01829521358013153, 0.04955918714404106, 0.015504006296396255, 0.005911511834710836, -0.04192907363176346, 0.006874417886137962, -0.003540812758728862, 0.009214645251631737, -0.01694227010011673, -0.0021726328413933516, 0.016405967995524406, 0.025596236810088158, 0.021025478839874268, 0.01030553225427866, -0.019111856818199158, 0.01774672418832779, -0.011530495248734951, 0.02598627470433712, 0.029691634699702263, 0.00643562525510788, 0.024803971871733665, -0.011372041888535023, 0.00514057744294405, -0.039808239787817, -0.016820384189486504, 0.009415757842361927, 0.020550120621919632, -0.00547881331294775, -0.03195872902870178, 0.020074762403964996, -0.025693746283650398, 0.008666153997182846, 0.005746964365243912, -0.011774268932640553, -0.013675703667104244, -0.0019654252100735903, 0.02679072692990303, 0.0656726285815239, 0.0241701602935791, 0.015040836296975613, -0.010396947152912617, 0.0020583639852702618, -0.022841593250632286, 0.01417543925344944, 0.0017003214452415705, -0.01935563050210476, 0.03866250440478325, -0.043416090309619904, 0.052947644144296646, -0.031081143766641617, -0.005280747078359127, 0.00978141836822033, -0.013809778727591038, 0.01184130646288395, 0.031203031539916992, 0.0023569867480546236, -0.00816641841083765, 0.0001950189471244812, -0.016003742814064026, -0.007745908573269844, -0.025059934705495834, -0.030130427330732346, 0.02698574587702751, -0.027205143123865128, -0.006429530680179596, -0.026303179562091827, 0.03473775088787079, 0.010171456262469292, 0.01845366694033146, -0.02603502944111824, 0.009050097316503525, 0.028619030490517616, 0.03237314522266388, -0.014614231884479523, 0.007380248047411442, 0.01643034629523754, 0.012700608931481838, 0.024645518511533737, 0.009123229421675205, 0.00046812163782306015, -0.046268243342638016, 0.015126156620681286, 0.037077974528074265, 0.0021878688130527735, 0.020988913252949715, -0.013553816825151443, 0.0023493687622249126, -0.027180764824151993, -0.003385406918823719, -0.006350304465740919, 0.019014347344636917, -0.011018570512533188, 0.009592493996024132, -0.015004269778728485, -0.0230244230479002, 0.004832813050597906, 0.022707518190145493, 0.03232438862323761, -0.02030634693801403, 0.002885670866817236, 0.007392436731606722, -0.018892459571361542, 0.042197223752737045, 0.02769269049167633, 0.005372162442654371, 0.04014952480792999, 0.021342385560274124, 0.038223713636398315, -0.024694273248314857, 0.029789144173264503, 0.00580486049875617, 0.041904695332050323, -0.012712797150015831, 0.00811766367405653, 0.032690051943063736, -0.018721818923950195, 0.019489705562591553, -0.0012196301249787211, -0.0160890631377697, -0.02202495187520981, 0.018660875037312508, -0.006024256814271212, 0.020099138841032982, -0.0487547367811203, 0.007721531204879284, 0.024718651548027992, 0.004071020521223545, 0.008538173511624336, -0.0009331961045973003, 0.0648437961935997, -0.015174911357462406, -0.013712269254028797, 0.04166091978549957, -0.03025231324136257, 0.021781178191304207, -0.04207533597946167, -0.027132010087370872, 0.00864787120372057, -0.0017262223409488797, -0.010555400513112545, -2.2615722627961077e-7, -0.021135177463293076, 0.02117174305021763, -0.0057256342843174934, -0.016722874715924263, 0.006612360943108797, 0.02944786101579666, 0.005521473940461874, 0.03715110942721367, 0.0044458224438130856, 0.036517295986413956, 0.016150007024407387, -0.04056394100189209, 0.01864868588745594, -0.02136676199734211, -0.020281970500946045, 0.00705115357413888, 0.030179182067513466, 0.010147078894078732, -0.02835087850689888, -0.02458457462489605, 0.004869379103183746, 0.018941214308142662, 0.008312682621181011, 0.0036626996006816626, 0.011707230471074581, -0.016454722732305527, -0.015894044190645218, 0.01301751472055912, 0.02453581988811493, 0.018307402729988098, 0.003048694459721446, 0.043513599783182144, -0.0012790500186383724, 0.025352463126182556, -0.0045768506824970245, 0.02407265082001686, 0.018685251474380493, 0.004183765966445208, 0.002903953893110156, 0.0003692790342029184 ]
9.807181
6.803658
2024-06-01
0
2024A&A...686A..62R
[ "SBF gradients", "SBF", "Monte Carlo mock galaxy simulations", "mock galaxies", "biased results", "Monte Carlo simulations", "the SBF uncertainty", "the SBF theoretical derivation", "the SBF derivation procedure", "Monte Carlo" ]
[ "methods: data analysis", "galaxies: stellar content", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
13
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202347559", "10.48550/arXiv.2403.14758" ]
[ "Rodríguez-Beltrán, P.", "Cerviño, M.", "Vazdekis, A.", "Beasley, M. A." ]
[ "Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias (IAC), 38200, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain ; Departamento de Astrofísica, Universidad de La Laguna, 38205, Tenerife, Spain", "Centro de Astrobiología (CSIC/INTA), ESAC Campus, Camino Bajo del Castillo s/n, 28692, Villanueva de la Cañada, Spain", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias (IAC), 38200, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Departamento de Astrofísica, Universidad de La Laguna, 38205, Tenerife, Spain", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias (IAC), 38200, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Departamento de Astrofísica, Universidad de La Laguna, 38205, Tenerife, Spain; Centre for Astrophysics and Supercomputing, Swinburne University, John Street, Hawthorn, VIC, 3122, Australia" ]
null
[ "1953MNRAS.113..134D", "1987ApJS...64..581D", "1988AJ.....96..807T", "1990AJ....100.1416T", "1991MNRAS.253..710V", "1993A&A...275..433B", "1993MNRAS.265.1013C", "1994ApJS...95..107W", "1996ApJ...468..519J", "1998AJ....116.2873J", "1998ApJ...505..111J", "1999A&A...352..447C", "1999ApJ...515...79P", "2000AJ....119..166J", "2001MNRAS.320..193B", "2001dge..conf...45G", "2003ApJ...583..712J", "2004A&A...413..145C", "2004AJ....127..771J", "2004MmSAI..75..198R", "2005ApJ...634..239C", "2005ApJS..156..113M", "2006A&A...451..475C", "2007ApJ...668..130C", "2007IAUS..241..199R", "2007MNRAS.377..759S", "2008A&A...491..693C", "2009ApJS..182..216K", "2009ApJS..182..543A", "2010ApJ...724..657B", "2012ApJS..200....4F", "2013A&A...558A..33A", "2013MNRAS.435..623V", "2013NewAR..57..123C", "2015ApJ...808...91J", "2017PhDT.......448M", "2018AJ....156..123A", "2018ApJ...856..126C", "2018ApJ...868...96C", "2018MNRAS.475.3700M", "2019ApJ...879...13C", "2020MNRAS.493.5131V", "2020Natur.585..357H", "2021ApJ...908...24G", "2021ApJ...923..152K", "2021MNRAS.507.3005R", "2022ApJ...935..167A", "2023arXiv230703116C" ]
28584816
2311.05704
The case for hot-mode accretion in Abell 2029
Radiative cooling and active galactic nucleus heating are thought to form a feedback loop that regulates the evolution of low-redshift cool-core galaxy clusters. Numerical simulations suggest that the formation of multiphase gas in the cluster core imposes a floor on the ratio of cooling time (t<SUB>cool</SUB>) to free-fall time (t<SUB>ff</SUB>) at min(t<SUB>cool</SUB>/t<SUB>ff</SUB>) ≈ 10. Observations of galaxy clusters show evidence for such a floor, and usually the cluster cores with min(t<SUB>cool</SUB>/t<SUB>ff</SUB>) ≲ 30 contain abundant multiphase gas. However, there are important outliers. One of them is Abell 2029 (A2029), a massive galaxy cluster (M<SUB>200</SUB> ≳ 10<SUP>15</SUP> M<SUB>⊙</SUB>) with min(t<SUB>cool</SUB>/t<SUB>ff</SUB>) ~ 20, but little apparent multiphase gas. In this paper, we present high-resolution 3D hydrodynamic adaptive mesh refinement simulations of a cluster similar to A2029 and study how it evolves over a period of 1-2 Gyr. Those simulations suggest that A2029 self-regulates without producing multiphase gas because the mass of its central black hole (${\sim} 5 \times 10^{10} \, \mathrm{ M}_\odot$) is great enough for Bondi accretion of hot ambient gas to produce enough feedback energy to compensate for radiative cooling.
[ -0.005728060845285654, 0.016188960522413254, 0.02351885475218296, 0.015784552320837975, 0.016580730676651, 0.05393792316317558, 0.02509857527911663, 0.00787331908941269, -0.010691537521779537, 0.021850671619176865, 0.003427990013733506, 0.007601607590913773, -0.07602871209383011, 0.0034564249217510223, 0.0017803432419896126, -0.0021657946053892374, -0.015127388760447502, -0.015253766439855099, -0.01508947554975748, 0.044788192957639694, -0.0987766683101654, -0.028232736513018608, 0.029622890055179596, 0.029572337865829468, -0.0659690648317337, -0.0005777822225354612, 0.030381154268980026, 0.008239814080297947, -0.007557375356554985, -0.01357294525951147, 0.0515873022377491, -0.007412041071802378, -0.012290213257074356, -0.011203366331756115, -0.06187443062663078, 0.05636437237262726, 0.013244363479316235, -0.019512688741087914, -0.026362350210547447, -0.03040643036365509, -0.020687999203801155, -0.0038576736114919186, -0.03215043991804123, 0.017237892374396324, 0.00942776259034872, -0.03409665450453758, -0.007633201777935028, -0.03199878707528114, 0.01315589901059866, 0.024112829938530922, -0.02509857527911663, 0.03086138889193535, -0.023493580520153046, -0.032757051289081573, -0.04458598792552948, 0.028965726494789124, 0.0070139518938958645, 0.03409665450453758, 0.02906682901084423, 0.009010717272758484, -0.007551056332886219, -0.015974117442965508, 0.01780659146606922, -0.013914164155721664, 0.001085266936570406, -0.033110909163951874, 0.014874633401632309, -0.0016950384015217423, 0.017768679186701775, 0.045369528234004974, -0.028333839029073715, -0.044838741421699524, 0.006334673147648573, -0.03846931457519531, 0.010110201314091682, -0.00878323707729578, 0.0021263016387820244, -0.06738448888063431, -0.019335759803652763, 0.01417955756187439, 0.010950611904263496, 0.025882115587592125, 0.04033970460295677, -0.0036775856278836727, 0.03349004313349724, -0.03144272416830063, 0.011456121690571308, 0.027979981154203415, -0.10726923495531082, -0.015026286244392395, 0.02866242080926895, 0.017351632937788963, -0.004578025545924902, 0.004407415632158518, -0.009642604738473892, -0.040289152413606644, 0.05489839240908623, -0.036725305020809174, 0.06258214265108109, 0.04271560162305832, -0.04276615008711815, -0.0036712668370455503, 0.01079895906150341, -0.04597613960504532, 0.06248104199767113, -0.0060187289491295815, -0.062127187848091125, 0.034526336938142776, 0.01943686231970787, 0.005004549399018288, 0.054645638912916183, 0.005674350541085005, -0.025781013071537018, -0.015367506071925163, -0.06986148655414581, -0.013117985799908638, -0.04066828265786171, 0.0555555559694767, -0.06935597956180573, 0.016618642956018448, -0.009478313848376274, -0.03184713423252106, 0.011355020105838776, 0.007532099727541208, -0.010975887067615986, -0.04984329268336296, 0.02934485860168934, -0.04524315148591995, -0.07006369531154633, 0.032883428037166595, 0.0012100647436454892, -0.045546457171440125, 0.005990294273942709, -0.0133581031113863, -0.04279142618179321, -0.04172985628247261, 0.01558234728872776, -0.0007239062106236815, 0.019285209476947784, -0.011866848915815353, -0.00452115572988987, 0.02403700351715088, -0.0007965732947923243, 0.04544535279273987, 0.013193812221288681, 0.07208573818206787, -0.04306945577263832, 0.034172479063272476, -0.00004502198862610385, 0.008669497445225716, -0.01674502156674862, 0.005314174573868513, -0.009996461682021618, -0.011045394465327263, -0.002162635326385498, -0.009503589011728764, -0.022672126069664955, 0.026640379801392555, -0.008732685819268227, -0.037028610706329346, -0.022128703072667122, -0.015784552320837975, -0.05242139473557472, -0.021092407405376434, 0.0046127792447805405, 0.028409665450453758, -0.044257406145334244, 0.007930189371109009, -0.07228793948888779, -0.019386310130357742, 0.01627742312848568, -0.04900920018553734, -0.019474774599075317, 0.004935042001307011, 0.014356485567986965, 0.043903548270463943, 0.004931882489472628, -0.04263977333903313, -0.0006358368555083871, 0.06334041059017181, 0.005990294273942709, 0.015443332493305206, 0.030305327847599983, -0.025781013071537018, -0.05247194319963455, 0.01785714365541935, -0.011279192753136158, -0.004644373897463083, -0.005873395130038261, -0.02427712082862854, -0.033237285912036896, 0.033414214849472046, -0.012839955277740955, 0.015203215181827545, -0.009806894697248936, -0.012966332957148552, 0.008423061110079288, -0.020574258640408516, 0.014482863247394562, 0.02772722765803337, 0.03278232738375664, 0.02311444655060768, 0.013901527039706707, -0.059599634259939194, 0.007696390617638826, -0.008410423994064331, 0.019007178023457527, 0.015961479395627975, -0.02339247800409794, -0.023784248158335686, 0.03809018433094025, 0.01310534868389368, -0.01268830243498087, 0.010129157453775406, -0.01599939353764057, -0.020586896687746048, -0.06167222559452057, 0.05108179152011871, 0.016669195145368576, 0.016075219959020615, 0.004502199124544859, 0.017756041139364243, -0.0009209761628881097, 0.0541401281952858, 0.019234657287597656, -0.007829086855053902, 0.01832474023103714, -0.03278232738375664, 0.030204225331544876, 0.053887370973825455, 0.004214690066874027, 0.020687999203801155, -0.02158528007566929, -0.0458497628569603, 0.010963249020278454, -0.01029976736754179, -0.018640683963894844, 0.051663126796483994, 0.03232736885547638, -0.013282276690006256, -0.05110706761479378, 0.019803356379270554, -0.021041857078671455, 0.018071984872221947, -0.019462136551737785, 0.009743706323206425, -0.01979071833193302, 0.0030551764648407698, 0.033110909163951874, -0.0031183650717139244, 0.00779117364436388, -0.015076837502419949, -0.008884339593350887, -0.01716206595301628, -0.018071984872221947, -0.020763825625181198, 0.02537660486996174, 0.03063390962779522, -0.024365585297346115, -0.03548680618405342, -0.05550500378012657, -0.05070265755057335, -0.026589829474687576, 0.027979981154203415, 0.018918713554739952, 0.055757761001586914, 0.019007178023457527, -0.020877566188573837, -0.05636437237262726, 0.008353553712368011, -0.011772065423429012, -0.03144272416830063, 0.0153422299772501, -0.04635527357459068, -0.01704832725226879, 0.048630066215991974, 0.03902537748217583, 0.025477707386016846, -0.002713957102969289, -0.02858659438788891, -0.004142023157328367, -0.03227681666612625, 0.05007077008485794, 0.004957158118486404, -0.010666262358427048, 0.010369274765253067, -0.001138977357186377, 0.013345465995371342, -0.00035306718200445175, -0.03675058111548424, 0.0627843514084816, -0.020561622455716133, 0.004224168602377176, 0.042108986526727676, -0.05595996230840683, -0.01814781129360199, -0.019992923364043236, 0.0074436357244849205, -0.052775248885154724, -0.01634061336517334, 0.008378828875720501, 0.008321959525346756, 0.023796886205673218, 0.016542816534638405, -0.013294914737343788, 0.017996158450841904, 0.05282580107450485, 0.011241279542446136, 0.014103730209171772, 0.06521079689264297, 0.0176802147179842, 0.026817308738827705, 0.009238196536898613, 0.01925993338227272, -0.04855424165725708, -0.017414821311831474, 0.010135476477444172, 0.04731574282050133, 0.05975129082798958, -0.03682640939950943, -0.03278232738375664, -0.04516732320189476, -0.010520928539335728, -0.01211328525096178, 0.014116368256509304, 0.0016223713755607605, 0.03518350049853325, -0.012372358702123165, -0.027701951563358307, -0.017768679186701775, 0.0367758572101593, -0.0005513218929991126, 0.07623091340065002, 0.013080072589218616, -0.012593518942594528, -0.06318875402212143, 0.03851986676454544, 0.035739559680223465, -0.03596704080700874, -0.014053179882466793, -0.011462440714240074, 0.002202128292992711, -0.031543828547000885, 0.0043473863042891026, 0.027449196204543114, -0.008524163626134396, 0.012473460286855698, 0.015127388760447502, 0.05057628080248833, 0.009231877513229847, -0.021345162764191628, 0.016580730676651, 0.017768679186701775, 0.004183095879852772, 0.06945708394050598, -0.01722525618970394, -0.0075952885672450066, -0.045950863510370255, -0.04261449724435806, 0.03028005175292492, 0.041982609778642654, 0.023202911019325256, 0.04284197837114334, 0.025705186650156975, 0.000732989574316889, 0.03144272416830063, -0.051915884017944336, 0.041350722312927246, -0.023025983944535255, -0.005453189834952354, 0.016327975317835808, 0.051031239330768585, -0.05070265755057335, -0.016416439786553383, -0.08386411517858505, 0.023531492799520493, 0.045015670359134674, -0.013016884215176105, 0.0306844599545002, -0.02590738981962204, 0.040112223476171494, -0.010261854156851768, 0.033692244440317154, -0.02497219666838646, -0.01382569968700409, 0.011260236613452435, -0.031240520998835564, -0.013610858470201492, -0.09291274845600128, 0.01570872589945793, 0.012536649592220783, -0.004012485966086388, 0.011601455509662628, 0.014343847520649433, 0.017490647733211517, -0.016492266207933426, -0.012479779310524464, 0.07203518599271774, -0.011234961450099945, 0.05474673956632614, 0.024024365469813347, -0.012599837966263294, -0.009023354388773441, -0.01703568920493126, 0.034046102315187454, 0.0006891523953527212, -0.006382064428180456, 0.0476190485060215, 0.022899605333805084, -0.03639672324061394, 0.03477909043431282, 0.0035132949706166983, 0.008277727290987968, -0.016151046380400658, -0.010773682966828346, 0.04049135744571686, -0.08902031928300858, 0.06789000332355499, -0.04334748908877373, 0.04943888261914253, -0.012877868488430977, 0.004382140468806028, 0.0310383178293705, -0.02281114086508751, -0.04392882436513901, -0.009724750183522701, 0.04026387631893158, 0.015026286244392395, -0.04319583624601364, -0.03700333461165428, 0.014937822706997395, 0.03639672324061394, -0.009225558489561081, 0.03546153008937836, -0.0007432577549479902, 0.041805680841207504, 0.02519967593252659, -0.06152057275176048, 0.0035448893904685974, -0.016656557098031044, 0.004050399176776409, 0.037609949707984924, -0.03063390962779522, -0.04339803755283356, 0.003769209375604987, 0.05408957600593567, -0.00042020523687824607, -0.014192194677889347, -0.00021168233070056885, -0.020561622455716133, -0.02246992290019989, 0.007904913276433945, -0.0006492644897662103, 0.010242898017168045, -0.030128398910164833, -0.029673440381884575, 0.06111616641283035, -0.013901527039706707, 0.03184713423252106, -0.060256797820329666, -0.007310939021408558, 0.005813365802168846, -0.029092103242874146, 0.0055384947918355465, -0.06607016175985336, 0.012220705859363079, 0.020801739767193794, 0.04165402799844742, -0.00757001293823123, -0.022634213790297508, 0.008707410655915737, -0.03809018433094025, -0.007348852697759867, -0.020119300112128258, 0.03576483577489853, 0.002666565589606762, -0.026564553380012512, 0.03022950142621994, 0.05595996230840683, 0.009851126931607723, 0.05904357507824898, -0.0038608331233263016, -0.009408806450664997, 0.010040693916380405, 0.027853604406118393, 0.006189338862895966, -0.02276059053838253, 0.010792640037834644, 0.0019604312255978584, -0.013926802203059196, 0.008107117377221584, 0.003901905845850706, 0.06531190127134323, -0.012978971004486084, 0.02166110649704933, 0.006353629752993584, -0.04418157786130905, -0.01278308592736721, 0.023556768894195557, 0.03445051237940788, 0.05429178103804588, 0.04711353778839111, 0.020789101719856262, -0.025136487558484077, -0.00577861163765192, 0.009263471700251102, -0.01855221949517727, -0.003431149525567889, 0.006318875588476658, -0.0009383530705235898, -0.025174401700496674, 0.008088161237537861, 0.005390000995248556, -0.00995222944766283, -0.008625265210866928, 0.006780153606086969, -0.013168537057936192, 0.020220402628183365, 0.014836720190942287, -0.01885552518069744, -0.003658629022538662, -0.009339298121631145, 0.006457890849560499, 0.013914164155721664, 0.00910549983382225, -0.0018198362085968256, -0.0225331112742424, -0.10110200941562653, -0.017187342047691345, 0.005655393935739994, 0.02059953473508358, -0.024188656359910965, 0.009370892308652401, 0.01199322659522295, -0.04552118107676506, -0.0030456981621682644, -0.02830856293439865, 0.0009983823401853442, -0.03220099210739136, -0.0555555559694767, 0.024125467985868454, 0.000632282521110028, -0.010009098798036575, -0.00034220662200823426, 0.022305632010102272, 0.023822162300348282, 0.004050399176776409, 0.019980285316705704, 0.037559397518634796, 0.06152057275176048, 0.020435243844985962, -0.0017045167041942477, 0.013926802203059196, 0.022267717868089676, -0.005886032711714506, -0.03821656107902527, -0.005898670293390751, -0.011778384447097778, 0.01808462291955948, 0.0027724066749215126, -0.033009808510541916, 0.0034943383652716875, -0.028055807575583458, 0.003980891779065132, -0.0013111666776239872, -0.06157112494111061, -0.00965524185448885, -0.02177484519779682, -0.0400363951921463, 0.015001011081039906, -0.028434941545128822, -0.014015266671776772, 0.0018498508725315332, 0.01549388375133276, 0.012934738770127296, -0.007260388229042292, -0.029370134696364403, 0.016466990113258362, 0.024959558621048927, -0.018716510385274887, -0.011380295269191265, -0.018539581447839737, -0.0060187289491295815, -0.001685560098849237, -0.03851986676454544, 0.009471994824707508, -0.0029840890783816576, 0.019588515162467957, 0.001966750016435981, -0.0021736931521445513, -0.01669446937739849, -0.01426802109926939, 0.032529573887586594, 0.013383379206061363, -0.02364523336291313, 0.002511753002181649, -0.00007636953523615375, 0.033818621188402176, 0.029951471835374832, 0.013560307212173939, -0.01529167965054512, 0.01035663764923811, -0.03424830734729767, -0.03634617477655411, -0.012934738770127296, 0.01441967487335205, -0.00449272058904171, 0.01079895906150341, 0.008265089243650436, 0.026766758412122726, 0.0015568130183964968, -0.03131634742021561, 0.010539884679019451, -0.025224952027201653, -0.0008182944147847593, -0.016327975317835808, 0.013029521331191063, -0.029142655432224274, 0.012568243779242039, -0.013408654369413853, -0.013345465995371342, 0.02013193815946579, 0.01680820994079113, -0.0232787374407053, 0.029900919646024704, 0.022381458431482315, -0.05065210908651352, 0.0010070707648992538, -0.005317334085702896, -0.01977808028459549, 0.01674502156674862, -0.020751187577843666, 0.003898746334016323, -0.011531948111951351, 0.0005722531932406127, 0.024997472763061523, 0.02281114086508751, 0.03561318293213844, -0.0004273139638826251, -0.025490345433354378, 0.014558689668774605, 0.03437468409538269, 0.03273177519440651, -0.0548478402197361, 0.021951774135231972, 0.019398948177695274, -0.002900363877415657, -0.03902537748217583, -0.008081842213869095, -0.019070366397500038, 0.004979274235665798, -0.026589829474687576, 0.02631179802119732, 0.02853604219853878, 0.013054797425866127, -0.024428773671388626, -0.008107117377221584, -0.03978364169597626, -0.03996057063341141, 0.02300070784986019, 0.004849737044423819, -0.003535411087796092, 0.005895511247217655, 0.025300778448581696, -0.02351885475218296, -0.0032794964499771595, -0.010495652444660664, 0.005813365802168846, -0.015961479395627975, 0.024352947250008583, 0.05067738518118858, 0.00488765025511384, 0.01079895906150341, 0.042740873992443085, 0.009825851768255234, -0.024529876187443733, -0.003838717006146908, -0.0014667690265923738, -0.03356586769223213, 0.008833788335323334, -0.011512991972267628, 0.02006874978542328, -0.00009132749983109534, 0.00936457421630621, 0.011203366331756115, -0.010805277153849602, -0.0082903653383255, 0.013181175105273724, 0.02858659438788891, 0.007803811691701412, 0.014154281467199326, -0.005415276624262333, 0.03523405268788338, 0.013989990577101707, -0.012378677725791931, -0.014861995354294777, 0.007607926614582539, -0.0023158679250627756, 0.00985744595527649, -0.04079466313123703, 0.027348093688488007, 0.01995500922203064, 0.018046708777546883, -0.021724294871091843, -0.009320341981947422, 0.0006776993977837265, 0.0041925739496946335, 0.000051390230510151014, 0.007898594252765179, -0.03670002892613411, 0.02584420144557953, 0.02042260579764843, -0.01779395341873169, 0.01769285276532173, -0.00968683697283268, -0.020447881892323494, -0.005336290691047907, 0.013813062570989132, -0.030027298256754875, -0.01529167965054512, 0.01950005069375038, -0.001969909528270364, -0.04228591546416283, 0.02490900829434395, 0.00875796191394329, -0.025288140401244164, 0.00399668887257576, 0.03470326587557793, -0.03803963214159012, -0.016795571893453598, 0.004284197930246592, 0.01621423475444317, 0.024479323998093605, -0.025957942008972168, 0.006299918983131647, 0.04698716104030609, 0.005841800477355719, -0.022318270057439804, -0.022103426977992058, 0.019639065489172935, -0.016024669632315636, -0.01727580651640892, -0.007740622851997614, -0.0014580806018784642, 0.055808309465646744, 0.0241633802652359, 0.05894247442483902, 0.020574258640408516, 0.01785714365541935, 0.004969795700162649, -0.02008138783276081, 0.010640987195074558, 0.03093721531331539, 0.006495804060250521, -0.009907997213304043, 0.027044788002967834, 0.01774340309202671, 0.0025133327580988407, 0.015961479395627975, 0.008707410655915737, 0.05292690172791481, 0.023316651582717896, -0.009693155065178871, 0.040238600224256516, -0.008107117377221584, 0.01792033202946186, -0.025578809902071953, -0.0069381254725158215, 0.03546153008937836, -0.035335153341293335, -0.004799186252057552, 0.011045394465327263, -0.0007886746898293495, -0.04430795833468437, 0.012530330568552017, 0.015898291021585464, 0.0022226646542549133, -0.006296759471297264, 0.005491103045642376, 0.011847891844809055, 0.021673744544386864, -0.04306945577263832, 0.009528864175081253, -0.02166110649704933, -0.047416843473911285, 0.011740471236407757, 0.054999493062496185, 0.02216661535203457, -0.021686380729079247, 0.014217470772564411, -0.007601607590913773, 0.013711960054934025, 0.010362956672906876, 0.03017895109951496, 0.00960469152778387, 0.015064199455082417, 0.014331210404634476, -0.1186937615275383, -0.006132469046860933, -0.0007100836373865604, 0.025313416495919228, -0.0077848550863564014, 0.015266403555870056, -0.023253463208675385, 0.023999089375138283, 0.01971489191055298, -0.016896674409508705, 0.005519538186490536, -0.0020789101254194975, 0.0011239700252190232, 0.028611868619918823, -0.010110201314091682, -0.007399403490126133, 0.025465069338679314, 0.023190274834632874, 0.014053179882466793, 0.026463450863957405, -0.014091093093156815, -0.006306238006800413, 0.006994995288550854, 0.011190729215741158, 0.0032242063898593187, -0.009212920442223549, -0.0020315186120569706, 0.01570872589945793, 0.006571630947291851, 0.024403497576713562, 0.016479628160595894, -0.030911939218640327, 0.02696896158158779, 0.053078554570674896, -0.010255535133183002, -0.019120918586850166, -0.009143413044512272, 0.035335153341293335, 0.008024971932172775, 0.012062733992934227, 0.0004514046886470169, -0.014091093093156815, 0.035335153341293335, 0.014621878042817116, 0.0324537456035614, -0.0069002122618258, 0.007841724902391434, -0.015910929068922997, 0.01313062384724617, -0.01762966252863407, 0.009320341981947422, 0.012441866099834442, 0.020978666841983795, -0.007867000065743923, 0.009092861786484718, 0.02200232446193695, -0.00027862293063662946, -0.011885805055499077, -0.0068686180748045444, -0.014748255722224712, 0.018754422664642334, 0.019007178023457527, 0.0061166719533503056, -0.03786270320415497, -0.012530330568552017, -0.022330906242132187, -0.011159135028719902, 0.018160449340939522, -0.02380952425301075, -0.03237792104482651, -0.011778384447097778, 0.008953846991062164, 0.00022293782967608422, 0.0023743174970149994, -0.03232736885547638, -0.012524011544883251, -0.02853604219853878, 0.005923945922404528, -0.04516732320189476, 0.014621878042817116, -0.03232736885547638, -0.030532807111740112, -0.012245981022715569, -0.023897988721728325, -0.0064420937560498714, -0.01514002587646246, 0.01310534868389368, -0.02410019189119339, 0.02317763678729534, -0.012858912348747253, -0.0028055808506906033, 0.006148266140371561, 0.028637144714593887, -0.010002780705690384, 0.0004308683273848146, 0.029572337865829468, 0.011898443102836609, -0.022899605333805084, -0.013269638642668724, -0.008391466923058033, 0.009263471700251102, -0.016643919050693512, -0.0016476468881592155, -0.013433929532766342, 0.0028434940613806248, -0.031088868156075478, 0.0009659981005825102, 0.000015772506230860017, 0.017756041139364243, -0.006887574680149555, 0.05403902381658554, 0.014583964832127094, -0.024782631546258926, 0.03116469457745552, 0.053078554570674896, -0.0031183650717139244, -0.02364523336291313, 0.014495501294732094, -0.0037249771412461996, -0.020094024017453194, 0.020852290093898773, -0.00933297909796238, -0.04281670227646828, -0.0065337177366018295, -0.024289758875966072, 0.019992923364043236, -0.01967697963118553, 0.0028308562468737364, -0.001713995006866753, 0.051915884017944336, -0.041350722312927246, -0.013054797425866127, 0.009503589011728764, 0.008814831264317036, -0.0027281746733933687, -0.009806894697248936, -0.015304316766560078, 0.045192599296569824, -0.012012182734906673, 0.0432969368994236, -0.011336063034832478, -0.012625114060938358, 0.0000023418099317495944, -0.03525932505726814, -0.02037205547094345, 0.002821377944201231, 0.009054948575794697, -0.04127489775419235, 0.024833181872963905, 0.03343949094414711, 0.0027392327319830656, -0.024428773671388626, 0.0019857066217809916, 0.046481650322675705, -0.01555707212537527, 0.011538267135620117, -0.011102264747023582, 0.006385223940014839, 0.0037344556767493486, 0.029622890055179596, 0.05636437237262726, 0.06723283976316452, -0.004214690066874027, -0.018817612901329994, 0.0021184030920267105, -0.012410271912813187, -0.03816600888967514, -0.026640379801392555, 0.013623496517539024, -0.0182109996676445, 0.0012140140170231462, -0.0021468380000442266, -0.006429456174373627, -0.029395410791039467, 0.0038008037954568863, 0.014356485567986965, 0.003143640700727701, -0.0011539846891537309, -0.004745475482195616, 0.02982509322464466, 0.0006085867062211037, -0.006685370579361916, 0.013749873265624046, -0.009516227059066296, 0.02059953473508358, -0.0056016831658780575, -0.026640379801392555, 0.03892427310347557, -0.03523405268788338, 0.005810206290334463, -0.014192194677889347, 0.027322819456458092, 0.009768981486558914, 0.04279142618179321, -0.013648771680891514, 0.05105651542544365, -0.033161461353302, 0.03303508087992668, -0.0031499594915658236, -0.007867000065743923, -0.02755029872059822, -0.02701951190829277, 0.0023885350674390793, -0.04708826169371605, 0.010287129320204258, -0.005225710105150938, 0.0003038984432350844, -0.013585583306849003, -0.020687999203801155, -0.01838792860507965, -0.015241128392517567, -0.014798806980252266, 0.013876250945031643, 0.017136791720986366, 0.04638054966926575, -0.014773531816899776, 0.01714942790567875, -0.009813213720917702, -0.028156910091638565, -0.01727580651640892, 0.03624507039785385, -0.059498533606529236, -0.005791249684989452, 0.048630066215991974, 0.007614245172590017, 0.05419067665934563, -0.011778384447097778, -0.009263471700251102, -0.026640379801392555, 0.005800727754831314, 0.042740873992443085, 0.008707410655915737, 0.017718126997351646, -0.011715196073055267, -0.025187037885189056, -0.02269740216434002, -0.02463097684085369, 0.025781013071537018, 0.005364725366234779, 0.022191891446709633, 0.014533414505422115, 0.033818621188402176, 0.02689313516020775, -0.014899908564984798, -0.0025670432951301336, 0.0033616418950259686, 0.012441866099834442, -0.00488765025511384, -0.015253766439855099, -0.027272267267107964, -0.009958548471331596, -0.00910549983382225, -0.016542816534638405, 0.014457588084042072, -0.012498736381530762, 0.017073601484298706, -0.024732079356908798, 0.021256698295474052, 0.00843569915741682, -0.027449196204543114, -0.0034153524320572615, -0.014318572357296944, -0.020498432219028473, -0.01762966252863407, -0.003914543427526951, 0.018173087388277054, -0.04529369994997978, 0.01216383557766676, 0.016820847988128662, -0.029193205758929253, -0.0020978667307645082, -0.0306844599545002, 0.03227681666612625, 0.000521307229064405, -0.014369123615324497, -0.003661788534373045, 0.0029588136821985245, -0.0033047720789909363, -0.020169852301478386, -0.0037028612568974495, -0.024782631546258926, -0.00040480296593159437, -0.03543625399470329, -0.01798352040350437, 0.03543625399470329, 0.044029925018548965, 0.0005663292249664664, -0.028106359764933586, 0.01593620516359806, 0.0038861085195094347, -0.022886967286467552, 0.024466687813401222, 0.00538368197157979, 0.0108242342248559, 0.0027897837571799755, -0.010255535133183002, -0.003911383915692568, 0.05070265755057335, -0.023594681173563004, -0.05176423117518425, -0.010413506999611855, -0.015544434078037739, 0.034399960190057755, -0.00008816806075628847, -0.02666565589606762, 0.008833788335323334, 0.001168202143162489, -0.009503589011728764, -0.023607319220900536, -0.020966028794646263, -0.0060218884609639645, -0.0041988929733633995, -0.005064578726887703, 0.004969795700162649, -0.0074373167008161545, -0.018640683963894844, -0.0007061343640089035, 0.0006188548868522048, 0.012991608120501041, -0.00956677831709385, -0.015683449804782867, 0.0029840890783816576, 0.002066272310912609, 0.020687999203801155, -0.03750884532928467, -0.029496511444449425, -0.005724901333451271, -0.010160752572119236, -0.0016902992501854897, 0.030355878174304962, 0.0075131431221961975, 0.03427358344197273, 0.011974269524216652, 0.008397785946726799, 0.0046854461543262005, 0.061015065759420395, -0.007841724902391434, 0.05454453453421593, 0.0102744922041893, 0.01797088235616684, -0.02339247800409794, -0.0016042045317590237, -0.020005561411380768, 0.026564553380012512, -0.013850975781679153, -0.003968254197388887, 0.014596602879464626, -0.03659892827272415, 0.010129157453775406, -0.03927813097834587, 0.06955818086862564, -0.01989182084798813, -0.0035417298786342144, -0.04713881388306618, 0.022495197132229805, -0.016757657751441002, 0.003709180047735572, 0.05100596323609352, -0.021926498040556908, -0.02211606502532959, 0.0005343399243429303, 0.017591750249266624, -0.023847436532378197, -0.0023822160437703133, 0.03164492920041084, 0.01108962669968605, -0.030330603942275047, 0.03167020529508591, 0.010577797889709473, 0.018893439322710037, -0.006094555836170912, 0.007108735386282206, 0.019297845661640167, 0.009541502222418785, 0.021560003980994225, -0.009029673412442207, 0.03045698069036007, -0.016770295798778534, -0.01146875973790884, 0.030735012143850327, -0.004527474287897348, -0.02661510556936264, -0.022722676396369934, 0.02818218618631363, -0.006830704864114523, -0.014407036826014519, -0.028561318293213844, 0.0016365888295695186, -0.003112046280875802, 0.007898594252765179, 0.010413506999611855, 0.004473763983696699, 0.00014592653315048665, -0.027398645877838135, 0.017073601484298706, 0.010811596177518368, -0.007146648596972227, 0.01426802109926939, 0.010584116913378239, 0.01283363625407219, -0.00878323707729578, -0.017591750249266624, -0.00300462543964386, 0.0027724066749215126, 0.0221792533993721, 0.02159791812300682, 0.010464058257639408, 0.0310383178293705, 0.027221716940402985, 0.006590587552636862, 0.012448185123503208, -0.015974117442965508, -0.045142047107219696, 0.021863309666514397, 0.0011934776557609439, -0.010590435937047005, 0.018703872337937355, 0.025465069338679314, -0.018628045916557312, -0.009547821246087551, -0.032529573887586594, 0.0031025679782032967, 0.0017282124608755112, 0.013016884215176105, 0.007797492668032646, -0.010893741622567177, -0.021673744544386864, 0.007949145510792732, -0.020498432219028473, -0.022672126069664955, -0.006615862715989351, -0.01564553566277027, -0.00015836681996006519, 0.021926498040556908, -0.0006184599478729069, -0.001854590023867786, 0.006647457368671894, -0.0030820316169410944, -0.019803356379270554, 0.03768577426671982, -0.003961935173720121, -0.015203215181827545, 0.026766758412122726, 0.005402638576924801, 0.018640683963894844, -0.003535411087796092, -0.04097159206867218, 0.026160145178437233, 0.007607926614582539, 0.009124456904828548, -0.009598372504115105, 0.0021436784882098436, 0.02083965204656124, -0.020460519939661026, 0.002634971169754863, 0.014091093093156815, -0.003421671222895384, -0.025490345433354378, 0.006666413974016905, -0.006170382257550955, 0.0310383178293705, 0.015241128392517567, -0.0008775338646955788, -0.0182109996676445, -0.04137599840760231, 0.03824183717370033, 0.01610049605369568, 0.016820847988128662, -0.016909310594201088, -0.010255535133183002, 0.0065337177366018295, 0.02621069736778736, -0.007797492668032646, -0.04458598792552948, 0.012220705859363079, -0.05014659836888313, -0.004875012673437595, 0.011399251408874989, -0.005355247296392918, -0.007980739697813988, -0.024946920573711395, 0.00742467911913991, 0.027221716940402985, -0.017490647733211517, 0.028030533343553543, -0.02679203264415264, 0.0035922809038311243, -0.009244515560567379, 0.06147002428770065, 0.011487715877592564, -0.010830553248524666, 0.015215853229165077, -0.006647457368671894, -0.012839955277740955, 0.028081083670258522, -0.007032908499240875, 0.02456778846681118, 0.018160449340939522, 0.02200232446193695, 0.006369426846504211, -0.022684764117002487, 0.00024189446412492543, -0.023607319220900536, 0.01744009740650654, -0.02368314564228058, 0.00021879107225686312, -0.01761702634394169, -0.029572337865829468, -0.010937973856925964, 0.00237115821801126, 0.0064515722915530205, 0.006239889655262232, -0.022394096478819847, -0.010754726827144623, 0.03538570553064346, -0.024125467985868454, -0.006006091367453337, 0.0036997017450630665, -0.00722247501835227, -0.007064503151923418, 0.010634668171405792, 0.012555605731904507, 0.01491254661232233, -0.041628751903772354, -0.040061671286821365, -0.009490950964391232, 0.032706499099731445, 0.001426486182026565, -0.052724700421094894, 0.04468708857893944, 0.005873395130038261, -0.023657871410250664, 0.0225331112742424, 0.006167222745716572, -0.0026460292283445597, -0.04372661933302879, -0.02222980558872223, 0.007506824564188719, 0.026741482317447662, -0.015418056398630142, 0.0005252565606497228, 0.002260577864944935, 0.014975735917687416, 0.006126150023192167, 0.009193964302539825, 0.00925083365291357, 0.014141644351184368, -0.03530987724661827, -0.00172505306545645, 0.020447881892323494, -0.01901981607079506, -0.04842786490917206, 0.008265089243650436, -0.0357142873108387, -0.014091093093156815, 0.0004506148397922516, -0.013497118838131428, 0.0205489844083786, 0.013206450268626213, -0.01925993338227272, 0.002151577267795801, 0.004366342909634113, -0.032655950635671616, 0.006132469046860933, 0.005510059650987387, 0.042740873992443085, -0.01511475071310997, 0.013320189900696278, -0.009667879901826382, 0.0003501051978673786, 0.04314528405666351, 0.006874936632812023, 0.0011350280838087201, -0.009611009620130062, 0.02298806980252266, 0.028611868619918823, 0.019866544753313065, 0.007456273306161165, 0.016846122220158577, 0.023796886205673218, -0.0021752729080617428, -0.02876352332532406, 0.011285511776804924, 0.01587301678955555, -0.006138787604868412, -0.005560610443353653, -0.02916792966425419, 0.009301384910941124, -0.04127489775419235, 0.007007633335888386, -0.01079895906150341, 0.005225710105150938, 0.0276008490473032, -0.007949145510792732, 0.007386765908449888, 0.02387271262705326, 0.01967697963118553, 0.02206551469862461, -0.02782832831144333, -0.0031025679782032967, -0.00890329573303461, 0.04600141569972038, -0.003712339559569955, -0.011323424987494946, -0.007089778780937195, -0.005497422069311142, -0.003083611372858286, -0.04562228173017502, 0.002238461747765541, 0.027348093688488007, 0.04529369994997978, 0.028611868619918823, -0.0055321757681667805, 0.03621979430317879, 0.008972803130745888, 0.013143261894583702, -0.02316499873995781, 0.0073614902794361115, 0.016125770285725594, -0.024239206686615944, -0.01924729533493519, -0.004258922301232815, 0.0022984910756349564, 0.005769133567810059, 0.02603376843035221, -0.0033047720789909363, 0.01163936872035265, -0.006173541769385338, 0.01639116369187832, -0.029041552916169167, 0.00290352338925004, 0.005225710105150938, 0.034349408000707626, -0.005737539380788803, -0.04615306854248047, -0.040643010288476944, -0.010862147435545921, -0.005551132373511791, -0.03151855245232582, 0.020763825625181198, 0.051031239330768585, -0.007418360095471144, 0.0019888661336153746, 0.00796810258179903, -0.0061040339060127735, -0.0010283970041200519, -0.018173087388277054, -0.020801739767193794, 0.026412900537252426, -0.02543979324400425, 0.007803811691701412, 0.02153472788631916, -0.03149327635765076, 0.0030314805917441845, 0.006037685554474592, 0.012189111672341824, -0.022672126069664955, 0.008669497445225716, 0.013711960054934025, -0.011506672948598862, 0.020397331565618515, -0.00018601190822664648, -0.006792791653424501, 0.03131634742021561, -0.0001444455556338653, -0.0005540864076465368, -0.008878020569682121, 0.05965018644928932, -0.027853604406118393, 0.029092103242874146, 0.014091093093156815, -0.001020498457364738, -0.017199980095028877, -0.013838337734341621, 0.012176473625004292, -0.005307855550199747, 0.019651703536510468, 0.042108986526727676, 0.0276008490473032, 0.006887574680149555, 0.02135780081152916, -0.0306844599545002, 0.013850975781679153, -0.010716813616454601, -0.0059523810632526875, -0.006887574680149555, 0.012334445491433144, 0.017402183264493942, -0.03126579895615578, -0.011525629088282585, 0.01925993338227272, -0.03985946998000145, -0.004375821445137262, -0.02427712082862854, -0.01538014318794012, 0.026766758412122726, -0.014596602879464626, 0.01838792860507965, 0.0027518703136593103, 0.021560003980994225, -0.004821302369236946, 0.001196637051180005, -0.016416439786553383, -0.0075952885672450066, 0.024479323998093605, -0.011753109283745289, 0.025604084134101868, 0.00004541692032944411, -0.0003189057460986078, 0.023721059784293175, -0.0017566474853083491, 0.010110201314091682, 0.020877566188573837, -0.011190729215741158, -0.008505206555128098, 0.03217571601271629, 0.03141745179891586, -0.01353503204882145, -0.02287433110177517, -0.00837251078337431, -0.0008412003517150879, 0.021686380729079247, -0.010261854156851768, 0.02375897206366062, -0.033768072724342346, -0.03508239984512329, -0.006195657886564732, 0.038014356046915054, 0.008536800742149353, -0.0019272570498287678, 0.011405570432543755, -0.021458901464939117, -0.0205489844083786, -0.009617328643798828, 0.022267717868089676, 0.01464715413749218, -0.01714942790567875, 0.022482559084892273, 0.007083459757268429 ]
14.045527
5.341404
2024-06-01
1
2024MNRAS.531..259P
[ "multiphase gas", "galaxy clusters", "abundant multiphase gas", "little apparent multiphase gas", "hot ambient gas", "SUB", "enough feedback energy", "Numerical simulations", "high-resolution 3D hydrodynamic adaptive mesh refinement simulations", "important outliers" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
8
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1203", "10.48550/arXiv.2311.05704" ]
[ "Prasad, Deovrat", "Voit, G. Mark", "O'Shea, Brian W." ]
[ "School of Physics and Astronomy, Cardiff University, Cardiff, CF24 3AA, UK; Department of Physics and Astronomy, Michigan State University, East Lansing 48824, MI, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, Michigan State University, East Lansing 48824, MI, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, Michigan State University, East Lansing 48824, MI, USA; Department of Computational Mathematics, Science, and Engineering, Michigan State University, Lansing 48824, MI, USA" ]
[ "2024OJAp....7...49S" ]
[ "1980A&A....88...23P", "1990ApJ...356..359H", "1992ApJ...399L.113C", "1993ApJS...88..253S", "1994ARA&A..32..277F", "1997ApJ...490..493N", "2001MNRAS.328..762E", "2003ApJ...590..207P", "2003ApJ...591..891B", "2004ApJ...607..800B", "2005ApJ...632..821P", "2006ApJ...652..216R", "2009ApJS..182...12C", "2009MNRAS.398...53B", "2011ApJ...727...39M", "2012ApJ...746...94G", "2012MNRAS.419.3319M", "2012MNRAS.420.3174S", "2013MNRAS.432.3401G", "2014ApJ...780....9W", "2014ApJS..211...19B", "2015ApJ...803L..21V", "2015ApJ...808L..30V", "2015ApJ...811...73L", "2015ApJ...811..108P", "2015MNRAS.449..316N", "2015MNRAS.451..588R", "2015Natur.519..203V", "2016A&A...585A.153B", "2016ApJ...818..181Y", "2016Natur.534..218T", "2017ApJ...841..133M", "2017ApJ...843...76A", "2017ApJ...851...66H", "2017MNRAS.471.1531P", "2017MNRAS.471.2321D", "2018ApJ...858...45M", "2018ApJ...862...39B", "2018ApJ...863...62P", "2019ApJ...885...63M", "2019JOSS....4.1636B", "2020ApJ...897...57M", "2020ApJ...905...50P", "2020MNRAS.495..594P", "2022ApJ...932...18P", "2022MNRAS.515.4838N", "2022PhR...973....1D", "2023MNRAS.522.4374B" ]
29097422
2406.15344
Elucidating galaxy population properties using a model-free analysis of quadruply imaged quasar lenses from large surveys
The population of strong lensing galaxies is a sub-set of intermediate-redshift massive galaxies, whose population-level properties are not yet well understood. In the near future, thousands of multiply imaged systems are expected to be discovered by wide-field surveys like Rubin Observatory's Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST) and Euclid. With the soon-to-be robust population of quadruply lensed quasars, or quads, in mind, we introduce a novel technique to elucidate the empirical distribution of the galaxy population properties. Our re-imagining of the prevailing strong lensing analysis does not fit mass models to individual lenses, but instead starts with parametric models of many galaxy populations, which include generally ignored mass distribution complexities and exclude external shear for now. We construct many mock galaxy populations with different properties and obtain populations of quads from each of them. The mock 'observed' population of quads is then compared to those from the mocks using a model-free analysis based on a 3D sub-space of directly observable quad image properties. The distance between two quad populations in the space of image properties is measured by a metric η, and the distance between their parent galaxy populations in the space of galaxy properties is measured by ζ. We find a well defined relation between η and ζ. The discovered relation between the space of image properties and the space of galaxy properties allows for the observed galaxy population properties to be estimated from the properties of their quads, which will be conducted in a future paper.
[ 0.009569494985044003, 0.009991678409278393, 0.038057710975408554, 0.004873467143625021, -0.009177904576063156, 0.02604077383875847, -0.026261044666171074, -0.012157663702964783, -0.02249198406934738, 0.014207395724952221, -0.024963900446891785, -0.005344599951058626, 0.002051261719316244, -0.02031376212835312, 0.03206147998571396, -0.0036375094205141068, -0.013656721450388432, 0.002360251033678651, -0.006210382096469402, 0.02821899764239788, -0.016691548749804497, -0.014085023663938046, 0.027215545997023582, -0.02016691491007805, -0.024474412202835083, -0.024878239259123802, -0.0383269302546978, -0.02552681230008602, 0.036956362426280975, -0.00865782331675291, 0.016483517363667488, -0.017254460602998734, -0.06598301231861115, -0.019873222336173058, -0.05208154767751694, 0.09549915790557861, 0.02338530123233795, 0.057906460016965866, -0.017389070242643356, 0.025453388690948486, 0.0028313836082816124, -0.004093345254659653, -0.03215937688946724, -0.0034570107236504555, 0.021182604134082794, 0.0019916053861379623, -0.0016336670378223062, -0.03563474491238594, -0.02927139587700367, -0.009985560551285744, -0.048018794506788254, -0.006785530596971512, -0.01578599587082863, -0.026554737240076065, -0.017046427354216576, -0.037347953766584396, -0.036858465522527695, 0.0013124403776600957, -0.024180719628930092, 0.014574511907994747, 0.010640250518918037, 0.01396265160292387, 0.06343767791986465, -0.005115152336657047, -0.031131451949477196, 0.00960620678961277, 0.0020053721964359283, 0.005889155436307192, -0.004956068471074104, 0.002891039941459894, -0.021317213773727417, 0.017144326120615005, 0.01682615838944912, 0.020791012793779373, 0.01632443256676197, 0.00020153148216195405, 0.0251352209597826, 0.009324750863015652, -0.054137397557497025, -0.013607772998511791, 0.04319733753800392, 0.021867888048291206, -0.0015954257687553763, 0.010010034777224064, -0.007183239795267582, 0.016361145302653313, 0.02299370989203453, -0.03389706090092659, -0.05947282165288925, 0.03470471501350403, 0.028781907632946968, -0.008021488785743713, 0.01582270674407482, -0.041386231780052185, -0.0024765045382082462, -0.005788198206573725, 0.04674612730741501, -0.04469027742743492, 0.05085782706737518, 0.034411024302244186, 0.036809515208005905, 0.0418267697095871, -0.002043613465502858, -0.07175897806882858, 0.040945690125226974, 0.011362246237695217, 0.03343204781413078, -0.02403387241065502, -0.0011464732233434916, 0.025110745802521706, -0.0026111139450222254, -0.001904415199533105, 0.00860887486487627, 0.0026677108835428953, -0.013436452485620975, -0.019995594397187233, -0.017389070242643356, -0.004894882440567017, -0.015859419479966164, -0.017193274572491646, -0.020595217123627663, 0.015039525926113129, 0.027288969606161118, 0.03115592710673809, 0.04395604506134987, -0.034117329865694046, -0.024180719628930092, -0.06524877995252609, -0.04486159607768059, 0.026358941569924355, 0.04185124486684799, -0.020387185737490654, -0.008296825923025608, 0.017951982095837593, -0.05604640394449234, -0.007415746804326773, 0.008192809298634529, -0.028341369703412056, -0.007305611856281757, -0.006387821398675442, -0.006375584285706282, 0.0044268094934523106, 0.019628478214144707, 0.02682395465672016, 0.03211043030023575, 0.04219388589262962, -0.03311387822031975, 0.012714456766843796, 0.004344208166003227, 0.01946939527988434, -0.011215399019420147, -0.03166988864541054, -0.028341369703412056, -0.026603685691952705, -0.02990773133933544, -0.01707090251147747, 0.010878875851631165, 0.003166377078741789, 0.00596257857978344, -0.028684010729193687, 0.02484152838587761, -0.02249198406934738, 0.012524779886007309, 0.0019564232788980007, -0.041728872805833817, 0.04608531668782234, -0.03343204781413078, -0.01671602390706539, -0.08590518683195114, -0.05829804763197899, -0.039403803646564484, 0.01872292533516884, 0.010010034777224064, -0.05864069238305092, 0.016287721693515778, 0.032967034727334976, -0.009728578850626945, -0.0171810369938612, -0.005953400861471891, -0.012702220119535923, -0.0029109253082424402, 0.0066753956489264965, -0.01261655893176794, -0.01311828475445509, -0.04444553330540657, 0.027949778363108635, -0.018588315695524216, 0.04300154373049736, 0.015994029119610786, 0.0028206759598106146, -0.0049774837680161, 0.07503854483366013, -0.0023984923027455807, 0.057710662484169006, -0.003169436240568757, -0.03977091982960701, 0.022210529074072838, 0.03937932848930359, -0.025893928483128548, -0.019750850275158882, 0.03308940678834915, 0.04106806218624115, 0.028488215059041977, -0.05614430084824562, 0.005093737039715052, -0.056829582899808884, 0.05340316519141197, -0.023311877623200417, -0.031890157610177994, 0.006614209618419409, 0.019028855487704277, 0.028561638668179512, 0.017095377668738365, 0.027117649093270302, 0.01139895711094141, -0.01871068775653839, -0.025355489924550056, 0.03795981407165527, 0.021574193611741066, 0.030837759375572205, -0.024829290807247162, 0.036858465522527695, 0.05609535053372383, 0.02826794609427452, 0.032820187509059906, -0.005047847516834736, 0.05550796538591385, -0.007550355978310108, 0.006993563380092382, -0.01811106503009796, -0.0004753389803227037, 0.015651386231184006, -0.019971121102571487, -0.014672409743070602, 0.007134290877729654, -0.026407890021800995, 0.00040459263254888356, 0.02638341672718525, -0.007458576932549477, -0.07699649780988693, -0.006626447197049856, 0.009024939499795437, 0.006901784334331751, -0.024657970294356346, 0.02279791422188282, 0.03399495780467987, -0.002049732021987438, 0.0283658429980278, 0.02120707742869854, -0.006029883399605751, -0.009649037383496761, 0.0019518343033269048, 0.005775961093604565, -0.01851489208638668, -0.0159328430891037, 0.04473922401666641, -0.027509238570928574, 0.043882619589567184, -0.018600553274154663, 0.0013460926711559296, -0.032428596168756485, -0.0125676104798913, -0.028047675266861916, 0.005595462396740913, -0.012898014858365059, 0.049095671623945236, 0.023275164887309074, -0.012836828827857971, -0.02687290497124195, 0.0064612445421516895, -0.01945715770125389, -0.01702195405960083, 0.011851733550429344, -0.048948824405670166, -0.040994640439748764, 0.030397219583392143, -0.01199246197938919, 0.010762622579932213, 0.04185124486684799, -0.007024156395345926, 0.013583298772573471, -0.01956729218363762, 0.022026970982551575, 0.028243470937013626, 0.013522112742066383, 0.007623779121786356, -0.017756186425685883, -0.01721774972975254, -0.03727452829480171, 0.011117502115666866, 0.06329082697629929, -0.04858170822262764, 0.0026157028041779995, -0.022332901135087013, -0.032477546483278275, 0.0038455419708043337, -0.007421865593641996, -0.02370346710085869, -0.031376197934150696, 0.04089674353599548, 0.04892434924840927, 0.01475806999951601, -0.0028726840391755104, 0.006516312249004841, -0.060451798141002655, -0.0196529533714056, 0.05257103592157364, 0.008192809298634529, -0.009722460061311722, 0.02101128362119198, -0.0018294622423127294, -0.012726694345474243, -0.018441470339894295, 0.030788810923695564, -0.04938936233520508, -0.011184806004166603, -0.037054259330034256, 0.03972196951508522, 0.019334785640239716, -0.04637901112437248, -0.028243470937013626, -0.04491054639220238, -0.0031158984638750553, -0.00027571956161409616, -0.026554737240076065, -0.039501700550317764, -0.020986808463931084, -0.026995277032256126, -0.034973934292793274, -0.04290364310145378, 0.031327247619628906, -0.01722998544573784, 0.013668959029018879, 0.01197410561144352, -0.02897770330309868, -0.0711715891957283, 0.006718226242810488, 0.048899874091148376, 0.011845615692436695, -0.0027487825136631727, -0.02653026208281517, 0.049511734396219254, 0.02310384437441826, -0.017707237973809242, 0.013644484803080559, 0.011435668915510178, 0.029442718252539635, 0.039550650864839554, 0.019542818889021873, -0.007807337213307619, 0.0049774837680161, -0.02932034619152546, 0.04309944063425064, -0.013999363407492638, 0.060549695044755936, -0.02990773133933544, 0.017682762816548347, -0.05345211550593376, -0.04410289227962494, 0.021733278408646584, -0.007599304895848036, -0.033383097499608994, 0.032232802361249924, 0.000017328075045952573, -0.07102474570274353, 0.005840206518769264, 0.016483517363667488, 0.01122151780873537, -0.04216941073536873, -0.022785676643252373, -0.004631782416254282, 0.034827087074518204, -0.017499204725027084, -0.002719718962907791, -0.039991188794374466, 0.004815340507775545, 0.02469468116760254, 0.010676962323486805, -0.008186690509319305, 0.006748819258064032, 0.001242076396010816, 0.004145353566855192, 0.03066643886268139, -0.04787195101380348, 0.03379916399717331, 0.03871852159500122, -0.01931031048297882, -0.024963900446891785, -0.0557527095079422, -0.0030868351459503174, -0.011074671521782875, 0.0014309883117675781, 0.05046623572707176, 0.001073814812116325, 0.05105362460017204, -0.03766611963510513, 0.02070535346865654, 0.07498960196971893, 0.028047675266861916, 0.021121418103575706, -0.009820357896387577, -0.04026040807366371, -0.0024902713485062122, -0.04574267566204071, -0.018992144614458084, 0.0022195233032107353, 0.013852517120540142, 0.007709439843893051, 0.0238992627710104, 0.02478034235537052, 0.04434763640165329, -0.04796984791755676, 0.017560390755534172, 0.004867348819971085, 0.02349543571472168, 0.010456692427396774, -0.0042983186431229115, 0.01451332587748766, 0.008504858240485191, 0.04383367300033569, 0.051298368722200394, -0.006852835416793823, 0.028096625581383705, 0.007770625874400139, -0.004971364978700876, 0.031376197934150696, -0.0038486013654619455, 0.02763161063194275, -0.017841845750808716, -0.0159328430891037, -0.018196726217865944, 0.030103527009487152, 0.048018794506788254, -0.028145574033260345, -0.0012711398303508759, -0.03644239902496338, 0.015957316383719444, -0.032820187509059906, 0.0008971401839517057, -0.021537482738494873, 0.019175702705979347, -0.010083457455039024, -0.03274676203727722, -0.03306493163108826, 0.03786191716790199, -0.00145240337587893, 0.04838591068983078, -0.003163317684084177, 0.02145182155072689, -0.03617317974567413, -0.032379645854234695, 0.06701093912124634, 0.03375021368265152, -0.0189064834266901, -0.014672409743070602, -0.03318730369210243, -0.03957512602210045, -0.03788638859987259, 0.023776890709996223, -0.04633006080985069, -0.032428596168756485, -0.016263246536254883, -0.008578281849622726, 0.03717663139104843, 0.0036497467663139105, 0.02922244742512703, 0.007507525850087404, 0.0243887510150671, -0.006467363331466913, -0.00925744604319334, 0.017682762816548347, -0.029834307730197906, 0.04077437147498131, -0.02797425352036953, -0.006969088688492775, -0.007146528456360102, -0.02240632474422455, -0.03509630635380745, 0.012494186870753765, 0.02946719154715538, 0.028684010729193687, 0.00014063226990401745, -0.004169827792793512, 0.028341369703412056, -0.02753371372818947, 0.010732029564678669, 0.010475048795342445, 0.014378717169165611, -0.0049530090764164925, -0.020350473001599312, -0.045228712260723114, -0.005445556715130806, 0.045620303601026535, -0.011778310872614384, 0.03375021368265152, 0.002068087924271822, -0.034411024302244186, -0.021072469651699066, 0.001866173930466175, 0.03105802834033966, 0.10768741369247437, -0.05795540660619736, -0.014439903199672699, 0.0010952299926429987, 0.020191390067338943, 0.022235004231333733, -0.02240632474422455, -0.015161897987127304, -0.01607968844473362, 0.04473922401666641, -0.009147311560809612, 0.05599745362997055, -0.020974570885300636, -0.006011527497321367, -0.002035965211689472, 0.03120487555861473, -0.0293692946434021, 0.010676962323486805, 0.02608972229063511, 0.005087618250399828, 0.02802320197224617, -0.03876746818423271, -0.03370126709342003, -0.00126655085477978, 0.026309993118047714, 0.013485400937497616, -0.04121490940451622, -0.10944957286119461, -0.005197753198444843, -0.013252894394099712, -0.008382486179471016, -0.03742137551307678, -0.01827014796435833, 0.00923297181725502, -0.002332717413082719, -0.04290364310145378, 0.005206931382417679, -0.02657921053469181, 0.009086125530302525, -0.04006461426615715, -0.011037959717214108, 0.03649134933948517, -0.02537996508181095, 0.015125186182558537, 0.006638684310019016, 0.025722606107592583, -0.007568711880594492, -0.015418879687786102, 0.024853765964508057, 0.01955505460500717, 0.05913018062710762, 0.004717443138360977, 0.002471915679052472, 0.03925695642828941, 0.0025346314068883657, 0.016251008957624435, 0.021892361342906952, 0.03866957128047943, 0.023165030404925346, -0.015247558243572712, -0.02031376212835312, 0.0015525955241173506, -0.019971121102571487, 0.014439903199672699, 0.0025621650274842978, -0.026554737240076065, 0.009514427743852139, -0.028830857947468758, 0.01388922892510891, 0.029197974130511284, -0.060500744730234146, -0.011105264537036419, 0.03756822273135185, -0.036613721400499344, -0.0004856641171500087, 0.016140874475240707, -0.010034509003162384, 0.03250201791524887, -0.021415110677480698, -0.035708166658878326, -0.02195354737341404, -0.016703786328434944, -0.015761520713567734, 0.012151545844972134, -0.05981546267867088, -0.0015059411525726318, -0.007795100100338459, 0.015737047418951988, 0.01254313625395298, 0.01981203630566597, 0.004720502067357302, -0.025624709203839302, -0.008847500197589397, 0.0015640679048374295, 0.030299322679638863, -0.0022072859574109316, 0.0477740503847599, 0.0034264177083969116, -0.02623656950891018, -0.030274847522377968, -0.018784111365675926, 0.006644802633672953, -0.019432682543992996, -0.034973934292793274, -0.023507673293352127, 0.005127389449626207, -0.018784111365675926, 0.01050564181059599, 0.007519762963056564, -0.023605570197105408, -0.014574511907994747, 0.03071538731455803, -0.0149293914437294, 0.002552987076342106, -0.0066753956489264965, 0.000264820788288489, 0.012628796510398388, -0.01901661790907383, 0.029051126912236214, -0.01219437550753355, -0.007948065176606178, -0.014280819334089756, -0.00881078839302063, 0.0013239127583801746, 0.05031939223408699, 0.030030103400349617, -0.046868499368429184, -0.03967302292585373, 0.005255879834294319, -0.01672826148569584, -0.014501089230179787, -0.057906460016965866, 0.04483712464570999, -0.006803886499255896, -0.014966103248298168, 0.0293692946434021, -0.013473163358867168, 0.022320663556456566, 0.015908367931842804, -0.0013399741146713495, 0.047309037297964096, 0.02011796645820141, 0.026995277032256126, -0.039844341576099396, 0.01817225106060505, 0.014574511907994747, -0.00863334909081459, -0.010083457455039024, -0.02980983443558216, -0.0038761349860578775, 0.02011796645820141, -0.04309944063425064, 0.013681196607649326, 0.0026661811862140894, 0.030250372365117073, 0.012157663702964783, 0.034313127398490906, -0.011105264537036419, -0.006810005288571119, 0.01115421298891306, -0.026701582595705986, 0.0032673340756446123, 0.010114050470292568, -0.019971121102571487, -0.005044788122177124, 0.002060439670458436, 0.026212094351649284, 0.021329449489712715, -0.0044268094934523106, 0.006400058511644602, 0.047064293175935745, -0.011833378113806248, 0.038106661289930344, 0.03920800983905792, -0.026652634143829346, -0.0061644925735890865, 0.0036681024357676506, -0.010891113430261612, -0.02812109887599945, 0.010077339597046375, -0.008535451255738735, -0.009985560551285744, 0.0014508736785501242, -0.011093026958405972, -0.027166597545146942, 0.01627548411488533, 0.0031908515375107527, -0.009214616380631924, -0.00868229754269123, 0.009820357896387577, 0.01135000865906477, 0.007568711880594492, 0.038449302315711975, -0.010383269749581814, -0.0055250986479222775, -0.028879806399345398, -0.012237206101417542, 0.008333537727594376, -0.0015556548023596406, -0.013693433254957199, 0.0231405571103096, 0.01682615838944912, 0.0011105265002697706, -0.03715215623378754, -0.00418206537142396, 0.000737674068659544, -0.023911500349640846, -0.005307888146489859, 0.02055850625038147, 0.0021950488444417715, 0.07440221309661865, 0.030274847522377968, -0.009269683621823788, -0.014427665621042252, 0.006687633227556944, -0.0179275069385767, -0.0298587828874588, -0.0098264766857028, -0.03340757265686989, 0.00043097909656353295, -0.01721774972975254, -0.03678504005074501, -0.06730463355779648, 0.010793215595185757, 0.01552901417016983, -0.04038278013467789, 0.01603073999285698, 0.018588315695524216, -0.02254093438386917, -0.005182456690818071, 0.02677500620484352, 0.020839961245656013, 0.009869306348264217, -0.024914951995015144, 0.009202378802001476, 0.000832894816994667, -0.015859419479966164, -0.0011181747540831566, -0.009961085394024849, 0.03289360925555229, -0.00723218871280551, -0.005782079882919788, 0.0028711543418467045, 0.01475806999951601, 0.032967034727334976, 0.02892875485122204, 0.024609021842479706, 0.009649037383496761, 0.012463593855500221, -0.023581095039844513, -0.020827725529670715, 0.009226853027939796, -0.003166377078741789, -0.009765290655195713, 0.015161897987127304, -0.029981154948472977, 0.009612325578927994, -0.0009858598932623863, 0.03896326571702957, 0.002907866146415472, 0.06255659461021423, 0.041777823120355606, 0.029932206496596336, -0.0010095695033669472, -0.0006592794670723379, 0.0038547199219465256, -0.017058664932847023, 0.0102058295160532, 0.03193910792469978, -0.03920800983905792, -0.0189064834266901, 0.03778849169611931, 0.015382167883217335, 0.024058347567915916, 0.033383097499608994, 0.01875963620841503, 0.013583298772573471, -0.016642600297927856, 0.012096477672457695, 0.024560071527957916, -0.015333219431340694, -0.0076482538133859634, 0.030886707827448845, -0.051151521503925323, -0.0077155581675469875, 0.0008650174713693559, 0.00010009652032749727, -0.03578159213066101, 0.018588315695524216, -0.00838860496878624, 0.009918255731463432, 0.015088475309312344, 0.0022470569238066673, 0.03893879055976868, -0.013326317071914673, 0.04515529051423073, -0.02229619026184082, -0.10621894896030426, 0.02961403876543045, 0.025722606107592583, 0.02245527319610119, 0.019885459914803505, 0.05589955672621727, 0.026750532910227776, 0.009912136942148209, -0.03360336646437645, -0.03313835337758064, 0.02026481367647648, -0.03294255957007408, 0.020436134189367294, 0.03299150615930557, 0.005831028800457716, -0.026212094351649284, -0.026309993118047714, -0.006155314389616251, -0.01466017309576273, 0.015369930304586887, -0.005164100788533688, 0.0328691340982914, 0.000736144429538399, 0.00960620678961277, 0.017805134877562523, -0.005616877693682909, -0.016899581998586655, -0.005913629662245512, 0.028194522485136986, -0.01583494432270527, -0.022418562322854996, -0.03240412101149559, -0.013473163358867168, 0.03793533891439438, -0.014329767785966396, -0.03255096822977066, 0.01757262833416462, 0.008890329860150814, -0.054333195090293884, 0.004457402508705854, -0.0328691340982914, -0.030446168035268784, 0.015223084017634392, 0.018992144614458084, 0.04510634019970894, 0.010542352683842182, 0.0018585256766527891, 0.031890157610177994, 0.003561026882380247, 0.029393767938017845, 0.01341197732836008, 0.0040413374081254005, 0.010138525627553463, 0.005867740139365196, -0.03795981407165527, 0.04251205548644066, 0.02608972229063511, -0.00628380523994565, -0.013999363407492638, -0.016299959272146225, -0.04946278780698776, 0.027166597545146942, 0.016556939110159874, -0.013044861145317554, -0.05247313901782036, -0.005944222677499056, -0.02966298721730709, 0.025869453325867653, 0.005883036646991968, -0.01885753497481346, 0.005356837064027786, 0.048704080283641815, 0.04569372534751892, 0.026212094351649284, -0.017597101628780365, -0.023422012105584145, 0.006754937581717968, -0.009973322972655296, -0.015994029119610786, -0.01647127978503704, -0.0042983186431229115, -0.012910252436995506, -0.007146528456360102, -0.02473139390349388, 0.005528158042579889, 0.04021145775914192, -0.01251866202801466, 0.004047455731779337, 0.02200249582529068, 0.03991776704788208, 0.004509410355240107, -0.005418023094534874, 0.01470912154763937, 0.010126288048923016, -0.012096477672457695, -0.01812330260872841, -0.006008468102663755, -0.03259991854429245, -0.0015388285974040627, 0.002326598856598139, -0.02474362961947918, -0.0013981007505208254, -0.002309772651642561, -0.040700946003198624, 0.009104480966925621, -0.03587948903441429, 0.04305049031972885, 0.034117329865694046, 0.0073178489692509174, -0.00783793069422245, 0.03644239902496338, -0.010958418250083923, -0.012494186870753765, 0.03330967575311661, 0.026114197447896004, 0.014048312790691853, 0.007372916676104069, -0.004793925676494837, 0.03480261564254761, 0.02743581496179104, 0.03230622410774231, -0.011288822628557682, -0.017450256273150444, -0.013424214906990528, 0.010260897688567638, -0.029785359278321266, 0.015161897987127304, 0.0216476172208786, -0.011533566750586033, 0.03729900345206261, -0.015688098967075348, -0.012579848058521748, 0.0159328430891037, -0.014427665621042252, -0.013044861145317554, 0.013424214906990528, 0.005867740139365196, 0.013693433254957199, 0.017609339207410812, 0.024058347567915916, -0.005421082489192486, 0.016838395968079567, 0.03274676203727722, 0.019848749041557312, 0.00209715124219656, 0.010940061882138252, 0.014745833352208138, -0.03563474491238594, -0.004451283719390631, 0.01871068775653839, 0.024009397253394127, 0.012102596461772919, 0.005635233595967293, 0.021733278408646584, -0.0059778750874102116, 0.009336988441646099, 0.020631929859519005, -0.022577645257115364, -0.011606989428400993, 0.011912919580936432, -0.0023893145844340324, 0.021268263459205627, -0.016556939110159874, -0.017511442303657532, 0.016091926023364067, 0.021733278408646584, 0.004313615150749683, 0.0016061333008110523, -0.01410949882119894, -0.03639345243573189, 0.006650921422988176, -0.05634009465575218, -0.005470030941069126, 0.022528696805238724, -0.0070058004930615425, 0.0448126494884491, -0.012555372901260853, -0.01179666630923748, 0.015247558243572712, 0.002294476144015789, 0.00747693283483386, 0.00010889201075769961, -0.02682395465672016, 0.04226731136441231, 0.02180670201778412, 0.0004914003075100482, -0.012292273342609406, 0.003613034961745143, 0.045424509793519974, -0.005858562421053648, -0.018306860700249672, 0.031474094837903976, 0.005999290384352207, 0.04743140935897827, 0.03379916399717331, 0.01742578111588955, 0.008272351697087288, 0.03918353468179703, -0.003215325763449073, -0.0028788025956600904, -0.06637460738420486, -0.015112949535250664, -0.03250201791524887, -0.020093493163585663, -0.0016076628817245364, -0.013546586968004704, 0.007746151182800531, -0.02463349513709545, -0.03539000079035759, -0.03316282853484154, 0.009398174472153187, -0.012316747568547726, 0.017401307821273804, 0.010872757993638515, 0.04400499165058136, -0.04324628785252571, 0.014892679639160633, -0.035463422536849976, -0.03862062096595764, -0.046819549053907394, 0.01572480984032154, -0.03612423315644264, -0.034411024302244186, 0.08370248973369598, -0.03174331411719322, -0.0030807165894657373, 0.019824273884296417, -0.024963900446891785, -0.05350106582045555, 0.008321300148963928, 0.04052962735295296, -0.008315181359648705, 0.009135073982179165, -0.010866639204323292, -0.032085955142974854, -0.004179005976766348, 0.003811889560893178, -0.03448444604873657, -0.0049652461893856525, 0.026358941569924355, 0.006400058511644602, -0.004445164930075407, -0.013375266455113888, -0.028439266607165337, -0.0026462958194315434, -0.00724442582577467, 0.028341369703412056, -0.012555372901260853, -0.0015969553496688604, 0.020631929859519005, 0.0036191537510603666, 0.004016862716525793, -0.023483198136091232, -0.013546586968004704, -0.016495753079652786, -0.013448689132928848, -0.037005312740802765, 0.018930958583950996, 0.02011796645820141, -0.01261655893176794, 0.0036833989433944225, 0.010640250518918037, -0.03193910792469978, -0.017805134877562523, 0.023874789476394653, -0.0009093773551285267, -0.020864436402916908, 0.04026040807366371, 0.009789764881134033, -0.020595217123627663, -0.02016691491007805, -0.017646051943302155, 0.027313442900776863, -0.0008871974423527718, -0.014782545156776905, 0.012702220119535923, 0.008529332466423512, -0.01711985096335411, -0.011460143141448498, 0.05056413635611534, -0.05687853321433067, -0.010407743975520134, -0.024021634832024574, -0.003527374705299735, -0.019187938421964645, 0.03365231677889824, 0.0074341027066111565, -0.00469296844676137, 0.01946939527988434, -0.005246702115982771, 0.005099855829030275, 0.04782300069928169, 0.02318950556218624, -0.004582833498716354, 0.015088475309312344, -0.003961795475333929, -0.02537996508181095, 0.0004164474084973335, 0.03301598131656647, -0.03414180502295494, -0.006871191319078207, -0.0000169934646692127, 0.0020390243735164404, -0.02463349513709545, 0.00863334909081459, -0.04606084153056145, -0.005182456690818071, -0.009520546533167362, -0.02250422164797783, -0.015541251748800278, 0.03509630635380745, -0.00072467204881832, 0.009520546533167362, 0.011894564144313335, -0.008572163060307503, -0.01045057363808155, -0.00965515524148941, 0.00372622930444777, 0.006473482120782137, -0.014317531138658524, -0.046917445957660675, -0.0034570107236504555, -0.002921632956713438, -0.02469468116760254, -0.027484765276312828, 0.013497638516128063, 0.0021996377035975456, -0.008101030252873898, 0.026163145899772644, 0.0403338298201561, 0.009477715939283371, 0.035757116973400116, 0.022724492475390434, -0.023825839161872864, -0.037005312740802765, 0.0013017328456044197, 0.03157199174165726, -0.01911451667547226, 0.012922489084303379, -0.004279962740838528, -0.00843755342066288, 0.0053507182747125626, -0.001268080435693264, -0.018037641420960426, 0.0022700016852468252, 0.003557967720553279, 0.011808903887867928, 0.007831811904907227, -0.01737683266401291, 0.02159866876900196, 0.060011256486177444, -0.024560071527957916, -0.01885753497481346, -0.042291782796382904, 0.005613818299025297, 0.0149293914437294, 0.012677744962275028, 0.026309993118047714, 0.02628551796078682, -0.03166988864541054, -0.0017132088541984558, -0.01583494432270527, -0.04493502154946327, 0.022859100252389908, 0.026163145899772644, 0.008253995329141617, -0.01236569695174694, 0.007293374743312597, -0.01647127978503704, -0.004904060158878565, 0.0036833989433944225, 0.0070608677342534065, -0.022418562322854996, 0.028341369703412056, -0.016764972358942032, -0.02922244742512703, 0.0153087442740798, 0.008327418938279152, -0.01177219208329916, 0.026995277032256126, -0.018441470339894295, -0.012898014858365059, -0.01776842400431633, -0.02299370989203453, -0.0008734305738471448, 0.003138843225315213, 0.005087618250399828, -0.004090286325663328, 0.028757434338331223, -0.014978339895606041, 0.028047675266861916, 0.006626447197049856, -0.012414645403623581, -0.010921706445515156, -0.007568711880594492, 0.016348907724022865, 0.035316575318574905, 0.029197974130511284, -0.00004801669274456799, -0.004399275407195091, -0.04048067703843117, -0.0019350082147866488, 0.006277686450630426, 0.00469296844676137, 0.016936292871832848, 0.0010914058657363057, 0.019334785640239716, 0.03568369150161743, -0.0008665471686981618, 0.012224968522787094, -0.018208961933851242, 0.018429232761263847, -0.05492058023810387, 0.02140287309885025, 0.026114197447896004, -0.017560390755534172, 0.004962187260389328, 0.025624709203839302, -0.019273599609732628, -0.003163317684084177, 0.008706771768629551, -0.001232898561283946, -0.019701901823282242, 0.0141829214990139, -0.032820187509059906, 0.011692650616168976, 0.006724344566464424, 0.0017973396461457014, -0.034313127398490906, -0.007917472161352634, -0.007330086547881365, -0.01415844727307558, 0.004432927817106247, 0.0457916259765625, -0.008676178753376007, -0.011711006052792072, 0.01391370315104723, 0.023360826075077057, -0.030935656279325485, 0.0393303819000721, -0.03866957128047943, 0.0037017548456788063, 0.03543894737958908, 0.02011796645820141, -0.005503683350980282, 0.002312832046300173, -0.01596955396234989, 0.006109424866735935, -0.0006577498279511929, 0.007923590950667858, -0.03355441987514496, 0.02846374176442623, 0.0003061213647015393, 0.010854401625692844, 0.05604640394449234, 0.029197974130511284, -0.03514525666832924, -0.024706918746232986, 0.02378912828862667, 0.0013743912568315864, 0.016312194988131523, 0.018429232761263847, -0.011625345796346664, -0.015859419479966164, -0.0011625345796346664, 0.03788638859987259, -0.020986808463931084, -0.04165545105934143, -0.013766856864094734, -0.02826794609427452, 0.01866173930466175, 0.023177267983555794, -0.012286154553294182, -0.017058664932847023, -0.006840598303824663, -0.0318656861782074, 0.020130204036831856, -0.01000391598790884, -0.007360679563134909, 0.029393767938017845, -0.0338481105864048, 0.017597101628780365, 0.00500195799395442, 0.011166450567543507, 0.02448664978146553, 0.023715704679489136, 0.002308242954313755, -0.041582025587558746, 0.0442986860871315, 0.013240656815469265, 0.011753836646676064, 0.012922489084303379, -0.0073178489692509174, -0.002985878149047494, -0.01333855465054512, -0.027142122387886047, 0.015541251748800278, -0.015345456078648567, 0.006161433178931475, -0.00878631416708231, -0.0032061480451375246, -0.003766000038012862, 0.01781737245619297, -0.01935926079750061, 0.026114197447896004, 0.02763161063194275, -0.008137742057442665, 0.02772950939834118, -0.03081328421831131, -0.0007831811672076583, -0.01906556636095047, 0.02323845401406288, -0.02080325037240982, 0.01872292533516884, 0.060109157115221024, -0.020729826763272285, -0.02403387241065502, -0.02210039459168911, -0.04848381131887436, 0.011827259324491024, -0.003371350234374404, -0.028781907632946968, -0.0019640715327113867, -0.038694046437740326, -0.023862551897764206, -0.02036271058022976, -0.0031158984638750553, -0.02537996508181095, -0.0051946938037872314, 0.017939744517207146, -0.009043294936418533, -0.016165349632501602, 0.025722606107592583, 0.017903031781315804, -0.019701901823282242, -0.0013514464953914285, 0.0031021316535770893, 0.013791331090033054, -0.015749284997582436, -0.0058218506164848804, 0.007109816651791334, -0.014256345108151436, 0.0266281608492136, 0.0006699870573356748, 0.020619692280888557, 0.04067647457122803, 0.028390318155288696, -0.04493502154946327, 0.00040612227167002857, 0.005314006935805082, -0.010114050470292568, -0.04762720689177513, -0.007697202730923891, -0.0463055856525898, -0.014244107529520988, -0.006950732786208391, 0.030348271131515503, 0.03891431540250778, 0.002721248660236597, 0.0049805426970124245, 0.011239874176681042, -0.025575760751962662, -0.028439266607165337, 0.0647103488445282, 0.0003657777269836515, 0.024902714416384697, 0.006767174694687128, 0.04858170822262764, -0.043980520218610764, 0.01687510684132576, 0.057612765580415726, -0.005583225283771753, -0.0023969628382474184, 0.0318412110209465, 0.01737683266401291, -0.013326317071914673, 0.024572309106588364, -0.011490736156702042, -0.003118957858532667, 0.02378912828862667, -0.024303091689944267, -0.053892653435468674, 0.012702220119535923, -0.030250372365117073, -0.025918401777744293, 0.03250201791524887, -0.006161433178931475, -0.025000611320137978, -0.02010572887957096, 0.024217430502176285, 0.014366479590535164, -0.026554737240076065, 0.019530581310391426, 0.01827014796435833, 0.004237132612615824, 0.03321177884936333, 0.026799481362104416, 0.015002814121544361, -0.00003248117718612775, 0.020277051255106926, -0.006528549361974001, 0.0231527928262949, -0.008890329860150814, -0.019922170788049698, 0.0092084975913167, 0.009153430350124836, 0.04055410251021385, -0.03996671363711357, -0.04305049031972885, 0.03149856999516487, -0.005999290384352207, 0.00460424879565835, 0.010395506396889687, 0.02459678426384926, -0.008706771768629551, 0.0216476172208786, -0.01396265160292387, 0.01960400491952896, -0.020986808463931084, 0.011888445354998112, -0.013265131041407585, -0.04770062863826752, 0.0076604909263551235, 0.024523360654711723, 0.015015051700174809, 0.024229668080806732, -0.017633814364671707, -0.0025483982171863317, 0.01721774972975254, 0.01632443256676197, 0.011484617367386818, 0.002101740101352334, 0.020570743829011917, -0.014427665621042252, -0.019004380330443382, 0.005610758904367685, -0.0013514464953914285, 0.004166768863797188, -0.013583298772573471, 0.013546586968004704, -0.003983210772275925, 0.018686214461922646, 0.007727795746177435, -0.01239017117768526, -0.01555348839610815, -0.008113267831504345, 0.0010684611042961478, -0.02459678426384926, -0.010462811216711998, -0.016251008957624435, 0.004983602091670036, 0.04165545105934143, -0.0149293914437294, 0.0204116590321064, 0.0005984758608974516, 0.024768104776740074, -0.032134901732206345, -0.02180670201778412, -0.011582515202462673, -0.01796421781182289, 0.01663036271929741, -0.016446804627776146, -0.027802931144833565, 0.024021634832024574, -0.014354242943227291, -0.010615776292979717, 0.0025866394862532616, 0.016752734780311584, 0.010444455780088902, 0.026554737240076065, -0.023275164887309074, 0.041484128683805466, 0.0418267697095871, 0.010725910775363445, 0.02851269021630287, 0.009037177078425884, 0.030128000304102898, -0.018331333994865417, 0.024560071527957916, -0.00557710649445653, -0.01935926079750061, -0.030299322679638863, -0.004439046606421471, 0.00042753739398904145, -0.004931594245135784, 0.012114834040403366, -0.0009835654636844993, 0.007544237654656172, -0.02961403876543045, -0.015272033400833607, 0.009355343878269196, -0.026505788788199425, 0.005913629662245512, 0.0015801292611286044, -0.022173818200826645, 0.015186372213065624, 0.011490736156702042, 0.011741599068045616, -0.001052399748004973, -0.02772950939834118, 0.03157199174165726, 0.006332754157483578, -0.02623656950891018, 0.006932377349585295, 0.07141633331775665, -0.010566827841103077, 0.02010572887957096, 0.0011763013899326324, -0.010683081112802029, 0.034019432961940765, -0.011680413037538528, -0.0011105265002697706, 0.01022418588399887, 0.006320517044514418, -0.00586162181571126, 0.02075430192053318, 0.012800117023289204, -0.02846374176442623, -0.014244107529520988, -0.023874789476394653, 0.04101911559700966, 0.03264886513352394, 0.017413543537259102, 0.002323539461940527, -0.042536526918411255, -0.06108813360333443, 0.03761717304587364, -0.005277295131236315, 0.004689909052103758, -0.035463422536849976, 0.014696883969008923, 0.005769842769950628, 0.0017743948847055435, 0.002095621544867754, -0.0031755550298839808, -0.0013231479097157717, -0.007874642498791218, -0.0013675077352672815, 0.00029273692052811384 ]
12.876492
3.960351
2024-06-01
0
2024MNRAS.tmp.1534M
[ "many galaxy populations", "many mock galaxy populations", "galaxy properties", "strong lensing galaxies", "populations", "image properties", "different properties", "the observed galaxy population properties", "the galaxy population properties", "quads" ]
[ "gravitational lensing: strong", "galaxies: fundamental parameters", "dark matter", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
6
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1536", "10.48550/arXiv.2406.15344" ]
[ "Miller, John H.", "Williams, Liliya L. R." ]
[ "Minnesota Institute for Astrophysics, University of Minnesota, 116 Church Street, Minneapolis, MN 55455, USA", "Minnesota Institute for Astrophysics, University of Minnesota, 116 Church Street, Minneapolis, MN 55455, USA" ]
null
[ "1965TrAlm...5...87E", "1985ApJ...289L...1F", "1995MNRAS.272..363K", "1997ApJ...482..604K", "1998MNRAS.295..587M", "1999ApJ...523..617F", "2000ApJ...540L..65W", "2001PASA...18..207W", "2001astro.ph..2341K", "2002ApJ...572...25D", "2002ApJ...574..719M", "2003AJ....125.2769S", "2003MNRAS.345....1M", "2004MNRAS.349.1039N", "2004MNRAS.350..949B", "2005ApJ...619..749M", "2005ApJ...623L...5F", "2005ApJ...635...35K", "2005tyad.confE..12D", "2006A&A...451..865C", "2006ApJ...653..936S", "2006MNRAS.365.1243D", "2006MNRAS.373...65G", "2007Ap&SS.312..203M", "2008ApJ...682..964B", "2008ApJ...685..725W", "2008MNRAS.389.1311J", "2008MNRAS.391.1685S", "2009ApJ...699.1720K", "2010MNRAS.405.2579O", "2011ApJ...726...84W", "2011arXiv1110.3193L", "2011ascl.soft02003K", "2012A&A...538A..99S", "2012ApJ...753....4A", "2012MNRAS.420.2944W", "2012arXiv1211.0310L", "2015ApJ...799..149J", "2015MNRAS.446..493P", "2015MNRAS.447.3189X", "2015MNRAS.449.3441S", "2015MNRAS.454..862W", "2015aska.confE..84M", "2016MNRAS.458..242T", "2017MNRAS.472.1129P", "2017Natur.548..555H", "2018MNRAS.475.1987G", "2018MNRAS.475.2438H", "2018MNRAS.477.5460S", "2018MNRAS.479.4108M", "2018MNRAS.481..164S", "2018PDU....22..189B", "2019A&A...631A.161H", "2019MNRAS.483.5649S", "2019MNRAS.484.4563D", "2019MNRAS.487.5721G", "2019MNRAS.489.2049N", "2020A&A...635A..86W", "2020A&A...643A.165B", "2020MNRAS.494.3998G", "2020OJAp....3E..10W", "2020RNAAS...4..190W", "2021JOSS....6.2825N", "2021MNRAS.504.1340G", "2021MNRAS.504.4583D", "2021MNRAS.507.2432G", "2021OJAp....4E..12B", "2022AJ....164..120F", "2022MNRAS.512.5862H", "2022RAA....22b5014C", "2023A&A...678A...4S", "2023MNRAS.518.1260S", "2023MNRAS.522.1863P", "2023MNRAS.522.5442G", "2023MNRAS.525.5423L", "2023NatAs...7..736A", "2023arXiv230611781V", "2023arXiv230916529R", "2024SSRv..220...23L" ]
29059278
2309.16297
The Relation between the Cool-core Radius and the Host Galaxy Clusters: Thermodynamic Properties and Cluster Mass
We present a detailed study of cool-core systems in a sample of four galaxy clusters (RXCJ1504.1-0248, A3112, A4059, and A478) using archival X-ray data from the Chandra X-ray Observatory. Cool cores are frequently observed at the centers of galaxy clusters and are considered to be formed by radiative cooling of the intracluster medium (ICM). Cool cores are characterized by a significant drop in the ICM temperature toward the cluster center. We extract and analyze X-ray spectra of the ICM to measure the radial profiles of the ICM thermodynamic properties, including temperature, density, pressure, entropy, and radiative cooling time. We define the cool-core radius as the turnover radius in the ICM temperature profile and investigate the relation between the cool-core radius and the properties of the host galaxy clusters. In our sample, we observe that the radiative cooling time of the ICM at the cool-core radius exceeds 10 Gyr, with RXCJ1504.1-0248 exhibiting a radiative cooling time of Gyr at its cool-core radius. These results indicate that not only radiative cooling but also additional mechanisms, such as gas sloshing, may play an important role in determining the size of cool cores. Additionally, we might find that the best-fit relation between the cool-core radius and the cluster mass (M <SUB>500</SUB>) is consistent with a linear relation. Our findings may suggest that cool cores are linked to the evolution of their host galaxy clusters.
[ 0.03867768868803978, 0.012867769226431847, 0.0022438017185777426, -0.0009553202544339001, 0.03714049607515335, 0.03867768868803978, 0.03428925573825836, -0.03976859524846077, 0.011690082959830761, 0.004506198689341545, 0.001892045489512384, -0.0031503101345151663, -0.05876033380627632, -0.0038398762699216604, -0.0008174070389941335, -0.0046332646161317825, -0.040462810546159744, -0.01493801735341549, -0.027669422328472137, 0.06218181923031807, -0.061785124242305756, -0.02248760312795639, 0.023107439279556274, 0.018545454367995262, -0.01267562061548233, -0.006619834806770086, -0.002584710717201233, 0.04187603294849396, 0.03909917548298836, -0.03396694362163544, -0.013276860117912292, 0.00027834452339448035, -0.040834713727235794, -0.03443801775574684, -0.04026446491479874, 0.049561984837055206, 0.0091239670291543, 0.009260331280529499, -0.0018130165990442038, -0.0055010332725942135, -0.022425619885325432, 0.02161983586847782, -0.03260330855846405, 0.03287603333592415, -0.000950671499595046, -0.03002479486167431, 0.006706611718982458, -0.022004133090376854, 0.021049587056040764, 0.03647107630968094, -0.04636363685131073, 0.04762810096144676, -0.01242148783057928, -0.015012397430837154, -0.057024795562028885, 0.02250000089406967, 0.0031503101345151663, 0.025140495970845222, 0.01845867745578289, 0.0032727273646742105, 0.006898760329931974, -0.022177686914801598, 0.03587603569030762, -0.02541322447359562, 0.009582645259797573, -0.01325206644833088, 0.012440082617104053, -0.004772727377712727, 0.032479338347911835, 0.022946281358599663, 0.004896694328635931, -0.004682851489633322, 0.007233471143990755, -0.050132233649492264, 0.017380164936184883, -0.014888430014252663, 0.01527272816747427, -0.05955372005701065, -0.0011838843347504735, 0.0028403927572071552, 0.004667355678975582, 0.045148760080337524, 0.04309090971946716, -0.022152893245220184, 0.02526446431875229, -0.00534607470035553, 0.02145867794752121, 0.034314051270484924, -0.038479339331388474, 0.015632232651114464, 0.008355372585356236, 0.02885950542986393, 0.02300826460123062, -0.0010320248547941446, 0.011107438243925571, -0.028512397781014442, 0.016115702688694, -0.010530992411077023, 0.061190083622932434, 0.06436363607645035, -0.04554545506834984, 0.014491735957562923, 0.020900826901197433, -0.03488430008292198, 0.07080992311239243, 0.014231405220925808, -0.03766115754842758, 0.03617355599999428, -0.0027939050924032927, -0.03339669480919838, 0.03463636338710785, 0.006787190213799477, -0.043388430029153824, 0.03942148759961128, -0.05642975494265556, -0.0006372675998136401, -0.058561984449625015, 0.01153512392193079, -0.07993388921022415, 0.008002066053450108, 0.013636363670229912, 0.0021601240150630474, -0.00715909106656909, 0.004465909209102392, -0.007679752539843321, -0.06084297597408295, 0.04031405225396156, -0.05152066424489021, -0.02161983586847782, 0.011336777359247208, 0.010053719393908978, -0.08013223111629486, 0.03661983460187912, 0.00004447798346518539, -0.03756198287010193, -0.04080991819500923, 0.02073967084288597, -0.04175206646323204, -0.013710744678974152, 0.0020779960323125124, -0.013574380427598953, -0.006232438143342733, 0.03919835016131401, 0.02638016641139984, 0.016884298995137215, 0.06114049628376961, -0.03912396728992462, 0.03272727504372597, 0.009818182326853275, 0.0026265496853739023, 0.004782024770975113, -0.017541322857141495, -0.0058450414799153805, -0.0335206612944603, -0.01707024872303009, -0.018706612288951874, 0.03319834917783737, 0.023553719744086266, -0.010685950517654419, -0.045297522097826004, -0.008002066053450108, -0.014243802055716515, -0.0388016551733017, -0.020702479407191277, 0.016648760065436363, 0.0006372675998136401, -0.040388431400060654, 0.035776861011981964, -0.09178512543439865, -0.008188016712665558, 0.012929752469062805, -0.016066115349531174, -0.023256199434399605, 0.002363119972869754, 0.01676033064723015, 0.06381818652153015, 0.00423037214204669, -0.027272727340459824, 0.002665289444848895, 0.05771901085972786, -0.021991735324263573, -0.0084297526627779, 0.03260330855846405, 0.001317148795351386, -0.049264464527368546, 0.005305785220116377, 0.0009677169728092849, -0.021495869383215904, 0.012179752811789513, 0.012037190608680248, -0.01583057828247547, 0.020392563194036484, -0.008485537022352219, 0.02761983498930931, -0.0003771306946873665, -0.02078925631940365, -0.019388429820537567, -0.016239669173955917, 0.006257231812924147, 0.0243099182844162, -0.0008910124306567013, 0.03230578452348709, 0.015347108244895935, -0.007022727280855179, 0.008752066642045975, -0.015520662069320679, 0.03114049695432186, 0.030644629150629044, -0.06401652842760086, -0.0208884309977293, 0.0157438013702631, -0.005814049858599901, 0.013809917494654655, 0.046760331839323044, 0.0011311983689665794, 0.005017562303692102, -0.035578515380620956, 0.06570248305797577, 0.03210743889212608, -0.008380165323615074, 0.015632232651114464, 0.07170248031616211, 0.03934710845351219, 0.043165288865566254, 0.038206614553928375, 0.010487603954970837, -0.012433884665369987, -0.040289256721735, 0.026702480390667915, 0.008479339070618153, 0.012508264742791653, 0.0012551653198897839, -0.014615703374147415, -0.05360330641269684, -0.013871901668608189, 0.0013489152770489454, -0.010128099471330643, 0.03319834917783737, 0.03267768770456314, -0.03860330581665039, -0.07824793457984924, -0.007865702733397484, -0.02848760411143303, 0.007766528986394405, -0.01845867745578289, 0.00019912190327886492, -0.009384297765791416, 0.001064566196873784, 0.01596694253385067, 0.008708678185939789, 0.028958678245544434, -0.0335206612944603, -0.008745867758989334, -0.04175206646323204, -0.01098966971039772, 0.014194215647876263, 0.01090909168124199, 0.0314876027405262, -0.001103305839933455, -0.03654545545578003, -0.052413225173950195, -0.048595041036605835, -0.02057851292192936, 0.01678512431681156, 0.008212810382246971, 0.03540496155619621, 0.0058419425040483475, -0.004481405019760132, -0.03404132276773453, -0.019685950130224228, -0.008590909652411938, -0.04715702682733536, 0.06153719127178192, -0.04415702447295189, -0.0329752080142498, 0.03478512540459633, 0.010667355731129646, 0.0367685966193676, -0.017640495672822, -0.007369834929704666, -0.0032169423066079617, -0.019946280866861343, 0.03840496018528938, 0.016351239755749702, -0.054396696388721466, 0.018037190660834312, 0.003777892794460058, 0.03203305974602699, 0.0006636105827055871, -0.0400165319442749, 0.0616859532892704, -0.01617768593132496, -0.013599174097180367, 0.014033058658242226, -0.0501074381172657, -0.03942148759961128, -0.03741322457790375, -0.029504133388400078, -0.04118181765079498, -0.012464876286685467, -0.01590495929121971, 0.028983471915125847, 0.02593388594686985, -0.014727273024618626, -0.012359504587948322, 0.023987604305148125, 0.02908264473080635, 0.017826447263360023, 0.012650826945900917, 0.061487603932619095, 0.009861570782959461, 0.0056838844902813435, 0.004155992064625025, 0.04304132238030434, -0.03480991721153259, -0.012805785983800888, 0.0022871901746839285, 0.05236363783478737, 0.04534710943698883, 0.008665289729833603, -0.027719009667634964, -0.06014876067638397, -0.004469008184969425, -0.00827479362487793, 0.010921487584710121, -0.01962396688759327, 0.001325671561062336, -0.014380165375769138, 0.004878099542111158, -0.04747933894395828, 0.02841322496533394, -0.022078512236475945, 0.07680992037057877, 0.033223140984773636, -0.016946282237768173, -0.062380168586969376, 0.021855372935533524, 0.026355372741818428, -0.053801655769348145, -0.02329338900744915, -0.01325206644833088, -0.009613636881113052, -0.01230371929705143, 0.019066115841269493, 0.04842149093747139, 0.0314876027405262, 0.015867769718170166, 0.011559917591512203, 0.013363637030124664, -0.010450413450598717, -0.02212809957563877, 0.015867769718170166, -0.013859504833817482, 0.0014883781550452113, 0.040834713727235794, -0.04547107592225075, 0.00809504184871912, -0.05642975494265556, -0.03272727504372597, 0.03642148897051811, -0.0004993543261662126, 0.016004132106900215, 0.03126446530222893, 0.016685951501131058, 0.02638016641139984, 0.0009328512824140489, -0.05652892589569092, 0.028239671140909195, 0.0178760327398777, -0.0025351240765303373, 0.015595042146742344, 0.013214876875281334, -0.033074382692575455, -0.052264463156461716, -0.02615702524781227, 0.04147934168577194, 0.05444628372788429, -0.014020661823451519, 0.016090909019112587, 0.015644628554582596, 0.0539008267223835, -0.013338843360543251, 0.02638016641139984, 0.0004125775012653321, 0.03235537186264992, -0.00784090906381607, -0.010084711015224457, -0.007599173579365015, -0.06788429617881775, 0.03741322457790375, -0.03200826421380043, 0.004041322506964207, 0.012533058412373066, -0.008150827139616013, -0.007983471266925335, 0.008621901273727417, 0.02761983498930931, 0.05940496176481247, -0.011894628405570984, 0.06436363607645035, 0.014256198890507221, 0.004434917587786913, 0.015260331332683563, -0.012867769226431847, 0.021508265286684036, 0.029553720727562904, -0.010010330937802792, 0.05152066424489021, 0.026826446875929832, -0.017690083011984825, 0.014665289781987667, -0.014231405220925808, 0.0005640495801344514, 0.01175826508551836, 0.00846074428409338, 0.009657025337219238, -0.06421487778425217, 0.04358677938580513, -0.05127272754907608, 0.05583471432328224, -0.020553719252347946, -0.009657025337219238, -0.019028926268219948, -0.02044214867055416, -0.018148761242628098, -0.013078512623906136, 0.02908264473080635, -0.025004133582115173, -0.03414049744606018, -0.04762810096144676, 0.025983471423387527, 0.06247933954000473, 0.005308884661644697, 0.042818184942007065, -0.024285124614834785, 0.0032851239666342735, 0.03456198424100876, -0.01866942271590233, 0.00238171499222517, -0.015880165621638298, 0.014789256267249584, 0.04326446354389191, -0.00511053716763854, -0.03151239827275276, 0.013214876875281334, 0.028363637626171112, 0.041206613183021545, -0.014702479355037212, 0.007004132494330406, -0.029429752379655838, 0.0157438013702631, -0.022685950621962547, 0.008119834586977959, 0.034760329872369766, -0.0124586783349514, -0.007128099445253611, 0.017256198450922966, 0.0023383265361189842, 0.00419628107920289, -0.03024793416261673, -0.0066942148841917515, 0.010785124264657497, -0.044057853519916534, 0.013053719885647297, -0.0526115708053112, 0.017789257690310478, -0.00020222108287271112, 0.04162809997797012, 0.0029023762326687574, -0.030520662665367126, 0.020330579951405525, -0.04048760607838631, -0.02153305895626545, -0.035057853907346725, -0.003750000149011612, -0.02042975276708603, -0.004366735462099314, 0.006619834806770086, 0.056082647293806076, 0.0054762400686740875, 0.06029752269387245, 0.0020563018042594194, 0.0018610537517815828, 0.01062396727502346, 0.033446282148361206, 0.002350723138079047, -0.033595044165849686, 0.032181818038225174, 0.034462809562683105, -0.0081260334700346, -0.027644628658890724, 0.0027892563957720995, 0.03689256310462952, -0.012192148715257645, 0.029504133388400078, -0.02013223245739937, -0.013066115789115429, 0.00715909106656909, -0.02387603372335434, 0.05107438191771507, 0.036595042794942856, 0.05623140558600426, 0.018260331824421883, -0.019289257004857063, -0.003514462849125266, 0.0480743832886219, -0.04671074450016022, 0.02717355452477932, -0.01897933892905712, -0.011640496551990509, -0.009539256803691387, 0.05429752171039581, 0.01881818287074566, -0.00165650830604136, 0.0038739670999348164, -0.008212810382246971, -0.01795041374862194, 0.009142561815679073, 0.000047819281462579966, -0.016425620764493942, 0.028586776927113533, -0.027719009667634964, 0.0019989670254290104, 0.0020826447289437056, -0.002682334743440151, 0.007816116325557232, -0.011776859872043133, -0.10333884507417679, -0.036793388426303864, 0.014888430014252663, -0.023466942831873894, -0.05132231488823891, 0.005838843062520027, 0.021210744976997375, -0.02285950444638729, -0.04299173876643181, -0.014219008386135101, 0.0019865704234689474, -0.03485950455069542, -0.05970248207449913, 0.020702479407191277, -0.012365702539682388, -0.00940909143537283, -0.02205372042953968, 0.040834713727235794, 0.06203306093811989, 0.003653925843536854, 0.005107438191771507, 0.036223143339157104, 0.04576859623193741, 0.029975207522511482, -0.041727274656295776, 0.011280992068350315, 0.007921488024294376, -0.012055785395205021, -0.0015759298112243414, -0.01612810045480728, -0.01759091019630432, 0.02672727406024933, -0.010617769323289394, -0.043611571192741394, 0.02080165408551693, -0.00824380200356245, 0.03205785155296326, -0.0016317149857059121, -0.024632232263684273, -0.015111571177840233, -0.024557851254940033, -0.001513171591795981, -0.011652893386781216, -0.04162809997797012, -0.027867769822478294, -0.012266529724001884, -0.014305785298347473, 0.02307024784386158, -0.030595041811466217, -0.04636363685131073, 0.03136363625526428, 0.01671074517071247, 0.0005760589265264571, -0.0050206612795591354, 0.009824380278587341, 0.011993802152574062, 0.004915289580821991, -0.01654958724975586, -0.01270661223679781, -0.009570248425006866, 0.02578512392938137, 0.010716942138969898, 0.0018796487711369991, 0.0005466167349368334, 0.0016828513471409678, 0.03674380108714104, -0.004004132468253374, -0.01728099212050438, -0.003635330591350794, -0.010227273218333721, 0.0308429766446352, 0.013227272778749466, 0.011950413696467876, -0.01538429781794548, 0.004239669535309076, -0.02717355452477932, -0.03374380245804787, 0.014243802055716515, 0.00900619849562645, 0.008851240389049053, 0.01527272816747427, -0.007462810259312391, 0.017640495672822, 0.017008265480399132, -0.029727274551987648, -0.00039223916246555746, -0.031611572951078415, 0.03260330855846405, 0.005352273117750883, -0.025685951113700867, -0.04249586910009384, 0.01123760361224413, -0.02395041473209858, -0.013338843360543251, 0.0037561985664069653, -0.008305785246193409, -0.00857231393456459, 0.03632231429219246, 0.00534607470035553, -0.016004132106900215, -0.03451239690184593, -0.007183884736150503, 0.023938016965985298, 0.03404132276773453, -0.027223141863942146, 0.023020662367343903, 0.004549587145447731, 0.005621900781989098, 0.014479339122772217, 0.015557851642370224, 0.03173553943634033, -0.005237603560090065, -0.01605371944606304, 0.04946281015872955, 0.03411570191383362, -0.007072314154356718, -0.03838016837835312, 0.024260330945253372, 0.008665289729833603, 0.021359505131840706, -0.01172107458114624, 0.02438429743051529, -0.017702480778098106, -0.010921487584710121, 0.01175826508551836, 0.021657025441527367, 0.024520661681890488, 0.02893388457596302, -0.02811570279300213, 0.021991735324263573, -0.0013481405330821872, -0.07284297794103622, 0.049909092485904694, 0.0006849173805676401, 0.00864669494330883, 0.007834711112082005, 0.004084710963070393, -0.006390496157109737, 0.009799587540328503, -0.011857438832521439, 0.024334711953997612, -0.006092975381761789, 0.06257851421833038, 0.02900826558470726, 0.010283058509230614, 0.02396281063556671, 0.04388429969549179, 0.002642045496031642, -0.006396694574505091, 0.010971074923872948, 0.00401342986151576, -0.03188429772853851, 0.0009553202544339001, 0.004568181931972504, 0.011702479794621468, -0.008671487681567669, 0.010952480137348175, 0.0006020144792273641, -0.021929752081632614, 0.012917355634272099, 0.031611572951078415, 0.020169422030448914, 0.00020435175974853337, 0.006892562378197908, 0.025760332122445107, 0.02761983498930931, -0.01483884360641241, -0.025884298607707024, -0.04162809997797012, -0.035057853907346725, -0.011429752223193645, 0.02535124123096466, -0.011280992068350315, 0.039818182587623596, 0.013896694406867027, 0.014119835570454597, -0.019388429820537567, -0.012805785983800888, 0.009179752320051193, -0.02593388594686985, -0.013326446525752544, 0.02015702612698078, -0.03862810134887695, 0.01883057877421379, 0.04212396964430809, -0.035280991345644, 0.005274793598800898, -0.011820248328149319, -0.009935950860381126, 0.002468491904437542, 0.021595042198896408, -0.04985950514674187, -0.02080165408551693, 0.0071714879013597965, -0.01197520736604929, -0.030719010159373283, -0.01193801686167717, 0.04876859486103058, 0.008212810382246971, -0.002045454690232873, 0.011863636784255505, -0.02987603470683098, -0.0154214883223176, -0.010239670053124428, -0.01720661297440529, 0.028611570596694946, -0.0367685966193676, -0.018260331824421883, 0.034016530960798264, 0.014714876189827919, -0.0036880166735500097, -0.019747935235500336, 0.031462810933589935, 0.007940082810819149, -0.03327272832393646, 0.009904959239065647, -0.019946280866861343, 0.03076859563589096, 0.013363637030124664, 0.06451240181922913, -0.013871901668608189, 0.014814049936830997, 0.006588843185454607, -0.01993388496339321, 0.009929751977324486, 0.013165289536118507, -0.008045454509556293, 0.02732231467962265, -0.01744215004146099, 0.024657025933265686, -0.00624173553660512, 0.005900826770812273, 0.01230991818010807, 0.04323967173695564, 0.029280992224812508, -0.0055258264765143394, 0.04195041581988335, -0.013214876875281334, 0.028884299099445343, -0.024409091100096703, -0.023256199434399605, 0.008590909652411938, -0.03604958951473236, -0.009626033715903759, 0.022239670157432556, -0.0002634297707118094, -0.035925619304180145, 0.00024270403082482517, 0.02535124123096466, -0.01728099212050438, -0.009365702979266644, -0.011194215156137943, 0.00794628169387579, 0.047206614166498184, -0.04708264768123627, -0.019971074536442757, -0.039446283131837845, -0.00846074428409338, -0.003213843097910285, 0.05568595230579376, -0.0002795067266561091, 0.0059845042414963245, -0.01209297589957714, -0.006334710866212845, 0.002981405006721616, -0.011578512378036976, 0.01728099212050438, 0.016822313889861107, 0.031685952097177505, 0.02087603323161602, -0.10462810099124908, 0.003728305920958519, 0.005603305995464325, 0.02563636377453804, 0.0011606405023485422, 0.019239669665694237, -0.013289256952702999, 0.0011366219259798527, 0.023417355492711067, -0.01847107522189617, -0.022252066060900688, -0.0023879134096205235, -0.010592975653707981, 0.021334711462259293, -0.004134297836571932, 0.0025816117413342, 0.026925621554255486, 0.025884298607707024, 0.008200413547456264, 0.030421487987041473, 0.02235124073922634, 0.009669422172009945, 0.0018734504701569676, 0.015000000596046448, 0.01859504170715809, -0.020764462649822235, -0.03419008478522301, -0.005714876111596823, -0.00202376046217978, 0.009471074678003788, 0.005597107578068972, -0.016933884471654892, 0.0035175620578229427, 0.030570248141884804, -0.011095041409134865, -0.0073760333471000195, 0.0033935951068997383, 0.02247520722448826, 0.01881818287074566, -0.018855372443795204, 0.017157025635242462, -0.014814049936830997, 0.032776862382888794, 0.020256198942661285, 0.037090908735990524, -0.01123760361224413, 0.014528926461935043, 0.028884299099445343, -0.006192149128764868, -0.018260331824421883, 0.01490082684904337, 0.0001550555316498503, 0.027669422328472137, -0.003043388482183218, 0.008566115982830524, 0.03171074390411377, -0.024123968556523323, -0.0032386365346610546, 0.007165289483964443, -0.03354545682668686, 0.002894628094509244, 0.019239669665694237, 0.01705785095691681, -0.02205372042953968, -0.03319834917783737, -0.006099173799157143, -0.01830991730093956, -0.010196281597018242, -0.016499999910593033, -0.006750000175088644, 0.018520662561058998, 0.015210743993520737, 0.019809918478131294, -0.0002477401867508888, -0.03485950455069542, 0.00312086776830256, -0.03994214907288551, -0.01465289294719696, -0.050652895122766495, 0.007363636512309313, -0.047057852149009705, -0.03969421610236168, 0.024210745468735695, -0.009353306144475937, -0.009167355485260487, -0.008157025091350079, -0.005733471363782883, -0.004469008184969425, -0.028438016772270203, -0.013475206680595875, 0.04894214868545532, -0.009440083056688309, 0.036000002175569534, 0.00031766531174071133, -0.01874380186200142, 0.051024794578552246, 0.01809917390346527, -0.040760330855846405, -0.011349174194037914, 0.022028926759958267, 0.003247933927923441, -0.028363637626171112, 0.01699586771428585, -0.01388429757207632, -0.0018331612227484584, -0.03830578550696373, 0.0007844783249311149, 0.026578513905405998, 0.0005683109629899263, 0.004506198689341545, 0.05737190321087837, 0.04314049705862999, -0.039818182587623596, 0.04532231390476227, 0.050727274268865585, -0.024173554033041, 0.01992148905992508, 0.009576446376740932, 0.031016530469059944, -0.022797521203756332, 0.02878512442111969, 0.027123967185616493, -0.007233471143990755, -0.029479339718818665, 0.012105372734367847, -0.028685951605439186, -0.019983472302556038, 0.004605371970683336, -0.009464876726269722, 0.009018595330417156, -0.027074381709098816, 0.009018595330417156, -0.0015278926584869623, 0.013363637030124664, 0.003074380336329341, 0.012694215402007103, -0.003622933989390731, 0.032479338347911835, -0.03634710982441902, 0.01589256338775158, -0.015954546630382538, -0.000017348109395243227, 0.039446283131837845, -0.022834710776805878, -0.0025738636031746864, -0.0022530993446707726, -0.026330579072237015, -0.03317355364561081, 0.027495868504047394, 0.018111571669578552, -0.011485537514090538, -0.011956611648201942, 0.018694216385483742, 0.02299586869776249, -0.013227272778749466, 0.03456198424100876, -0.020677685737609863, 0.017045455053448677, 0.02556198462843895, 0.003979338798671961, 0.019797520712018013, 0.041652895510196686, -0.01420661248266697, -0.008634298108518124, 0.016425620764493942, -0.009334711357951164, -0.02365289255976677, -0.007803719490766525, 0.015285124070942402, -0.03964462876319885, -0.00642768619582057, -0.010010330937802792, 0.018508264794945717, -0.003929752390831709, 0.00977479387074709, 0.012892561964690685, -0.003657024819403887, 0.0032665289472788572, 0.001176911173388362, 0.0021306818816810846, -0.022165289148688316, 0.030818182975053787, -0.010648760944604874, -0.006139462813735008, 0.015185951255261898, 0.00033935951068997383, -0.030421487987041473, 0.005928719416260719, -0.04066115990281105, 0.017454545944929123, -0.011435951106250286, 0.0075371903367340565, 0.011051652953028679, 0.03671900928020477, 0.012347107753157616, -0.0016255165683105588, -0.0032169423066079617, 0.010252066887915134, -0.011956611648201942, 0.013314049690961838, -0.0036663224454969168, 0.007859504781663418, 0.0180123969912529, 0.003802685998380184, 0.012694215402007103, -0.001923037227243185, -0.020863637328147888, -0.020392563194036484, -0.037685953080654144, -0.009533057920634747, 0.01823553815484047, 0.005466942209750414, -0.00421487633138895, 0.022078512236475945, 0.058859504759311676, -0.03699173778295517, -0.0010451963171362877, 0.014665289781987667, -0.0033811985049396753, -0.018570248037576675, 0.017045455053448677, -0.03989256173372269, -0.02095041424036026, 0.06014876067638397, 0.0023011364974081516, 0.05276033282279968, 0.011119835078716278, -0.0022608472499996424, -0.03552892804145813, 0.01626446284353733, 0.0249173566699028, 0.01860743947327137, 0.015000000596046448, -0.010121901519596577, -0.025165289640426636, -0.02300826460123062, 0.005507231689989567, 0.025239670649170876, 0.012477273121476173, 0.017466941848397255, 0.005721074528992176, -0.0055227275006473064, -0.002508781151846051, -0.0037314051296561956, -0.02342975325882435, 0.005783058237284422, 0.03803306072950363, 0.00010314437531633303, 0.012793389149010181, -0.021867768839001656, -0.01720661297440529, -0.03225620090961456, 0.0057985540479421616, 0.011950413696467876, -0.013797520659863949, 0.024111570790410042, -0.016896694898605347, 0.017380164936184883, 0.012768595479428768, 0.0029101241379976273, -0.02247520722448826, -0.005262396764010191, -0.005417355336248875, -0.03339669480919838, 0.014256198890507221, 0.022723142057657242, -0.012570247985422611, 0.0036880166735500097, 0.009055785834789276, -0.008138430304825306, 0.02461983636021614, -0.01699586771428585, 0.021793389692902565, -0.005590909160673618, -0.0005458419327624142, -0.024632232263684273, -0.0051353308372199535, 0.016735536977648735, -0.013301653787493706, 0.006880165543407202, -0.0367685966193676, 0.008888429962098598, -0.024954546242952347, 0.03238016739487648, 0.019760331138968468, 0.016425620764493942, -0.026752067729830742, -0.031958676874637604, 0.012966942973434925, -0.012495867908000946, -0.014727273024618626, 0.008944215252995491, -0.011820248328149319, 0.011126033030450344, 0.007760331034660339, -0.0064896694384515285, -0.004183884244412184, 0.018508264794945717, -0.013561983592808247, -0.042595043778419495, 0.0091239670291543, -0.017479339614510536, 0.038702480494976044, 0.00511053716763854, -0.019103307276964188, -0.007611570414155722, -0.012192148715257645, 0.0002099690173054114, -0.010487603954970837, -0.022871902212500572, -0.017776859924197197, -0.015446281060576439, -0.0035516531206667423, 0.010295454412698746, 0.004183884244412184, -0.034239672124385834, -0.03076859563589096, 0.012681818567216396, -0.002050103386864066, -0.023690083995461464, -0.031685952097177505, 0.024495868012309074, 0.012632232159376144, 0.02093801647424698, -0.009254132397472858, -0.01281818188726902, 0.01300413254648447, 0.004376033321022987, -0.0011095041409134865, 0.020107438787817955, -0.02695041336119175, 0.002838843036442995, 0.008150827139616013, -0.016363637521862984, 0.022809918969869614, 0.06084297597408295, 0.02702479436993599, 0.04048760607838631, -0.0006074380362406373, 0.029256198555231094, 0.009830579161643982, -0.010369835421442986, -0.02930578589439392, -0.018570248037576675, -0.002113636350259185, -0.007400826551020145, 0.013078512623906136, -0.025512397289276123, 0.0003519499150570482, -0.016140496358275414, 0.062380168586969376, 0.014962810091674328, -0.004537190310657024, -0.018644629046320915, 0.02900826558470726, 0.014913223683834076, -0.026181818917393684, 0.050355374813079834, -0.015644628554582596, -0.02600826509296894, 0.011014463379979134, -0.011962810531258583, 0.024000000208616257, -0.003226239699870348, -0.0053212810307741165, 0.02424793504178524, -0.015793388709425926, 0.01223553717136383, -0.01413223147392273, 0.0010436467127874494, -0.001090134377591312, -0.04321487620472908, 0.03719008341431618, 0.01172727346420288, 0.007283058017492294, 0.008950413204729557, 0.037834711372852325, -0.02250000089406967, -0.03976859524846077, -0.006855372339487076, 0.007450413424521685, -0.009601240046322346, 0.002423553727567196, -0.015495868399739265, 0.012291322462260723, -0.02072727307677269, -0.03406611829996109, 0.01808677799999714, 0.005194215103983879, 0.028586776927113533, 0.00952066108584404, 0.02080165408551693, 0.02652892656624317, -0.010090908966958523, -0.019450413063168526, 0.02484297566115856, 0.0157438013702631, 0.008851240389049053, -0.009365702979266644, 0.007667355705052614, -0.028760330751538277, -0.02335537225008011, -0.006502066273242235, 0.016871901229023933, 0.014280992560088634, 0.009911157190799713, 0.030297521501779556, 0.05400000140070915, 0.022090910002589226, 0.022289257496595383, -0.008163223043084145, -0.015409091487526894, -0.017764464020729065, 0.03163636475801468, -0.0068491739220917225, -0.015855371952056885, 0.004143595229834318, -0.012446281500160694, 0.00662603322416544, -0.008882232010364532, -0.016351239755749702, 0.008119834586977959, 0.005783058237284422, 0.020305786281824112, -0.02930578589439392, -0.004800620023161173, -0.030223142355680466, 0.0022918388713151217, -0.014491735957562923, -0.02556198462843895, 0.008721075020730495, -0.02461983636021614, 0.0009653925662860274, 0.04847107455134392, -0.022177686914801598, -0.00312086776830256, 0.0063719009049236774, -0.012619835324585438, -0.00218956614844501, 0.06014876067638397, -0.010927686467766762, 0.012024793773889542, 0.00679338863119483, 0.014814049936830997, 0.01656198315322399, 0.0055103306658566, -0.0032324381172657013, -0.011064049787819386, 0.01999586820602417, 0.014727273024618626, -0.0025444214697927237, -0.01043801661580801, 0.013983471319079399, -0.019078513607382774, 0.004112603608518839, -0.015942148864269257, 0.00047339877346530557, -0.017082644626498222, 0.0027241737116128206, -0.00016173812036868185, 0.016946282237768173, 0.02160743810236454, -0.0032510331366211176, -0.02791735716164112, -0.02908264473080635, 0.00882644671946764, -0.00587603310123086, 0.009464876726269722, -0.04462810233235359, -0.008082645013928413, 0.0020748968236148357, -0.0075123971328139305, 0.00587603310123086, -0.03647107630968094, 0.025028927251696587, -0.04160330817103386, -0.012185950763523579, -0.010859504342079163, 0.016301654279232025, 0.007270661182701588, -0.010481405071914196, 0.008931818418204784, 0.008268595673143864, -0.011783057823777199, 0.0202809926122427, -0.005169421434402466, -0.00922314077615738, 0.0025614670012146235, 0.09312397241592407, 0.02205372042953968, -0.02366529032588005, 0.005442149005830288, -0.03495867922902107, -0.008051653392612934, 0.07006611675024033, -0.023615702986717224, 0.02315702475607395, -0.008584710769355297, -0.0019633264746516943, 0.0073760333471000195, -0.043760333210229874, 0.005172520875930786, 0.024706613272428513, 0.016301654279232025, -0.04254545643925667, -0.009700413793325424, -0.03728925809264183, -0.0377851240336895, -0.02739669568836689, 0.01729338988661766, -0.016363637521862984, 0.006582644768059254, 0.0066942148841917515, -0.02957851253449917, 0.03495867922902107, -0.03741322457790375, -0.010283058509230614, 0.024644628167152405, -0.006601240020245314, 0.001783574465662241, 0.006396694574505091, 0.01197520736604929, 0.03171074390411377, -0.037537191063165665, -0.044578514993190765, -0.00827479362487793, 0.019871901720762253, -0.019140496850013733, -0.040983472019433975, 0.042966943234205246, -0.022177686914801598, -0.036669421941041946, 0.00839256215840578, 0.005380165297538042, 0.0008972107898443937, 0.005721074528992176, 0.0014504132559522986, 0.005064049735665321, 0.030272727832198143, -0.007066115736961365, -0.0077231405302882195, 0.04452892765402794, 0.024570249021053314, 0.018520662561058998, 0.010227273218333721, 0.020330579951405525, 0.006725206971168518, -0.014342975802719593, -0.007289256434887648, -0.007016529329121113, -0.004828512668609619, -0.05075206607580185, 0.02652892656624317, -0.045371901243925095, 0.016797522082924843, -0.035107437521219254, 0.010066116228699684, 0.02345454692840576, 0.003567148931324482, -0.012904958799481392, 0.019909091293811798, 0.000745351251680404, 0.0073760333471000195, -0.010617769323289394, -0.010314050130546093, 0.04140495881438255, -0.009092975407838821, 0.0021678719203919172, -0.015991736203432083, -0.005250000394880772, 0.040239669382572174, 0.011126033030450344, -0.002838843036442995, -0.0035485539119690657, 0.012099173851311207, 0.0337190106511116, 0.019574381411075592, 0.0013047520769760013, -0.020318182185292244, 0.009105372242629528, -0.013140495866537094, -0.018198348581790924, -0.013276860117912292, 0.013822314329445362, 0.013500000350177288, -0.0015759298112243414, -0.024136364459991455, -0.018347108736634254, -0.028760330751538277, 0.03411570191383362, 0.014876033179461956, -0.013822314329445362, 0.02623140625655651, -0.03572727367281914, 0.015260331332683563, 0.02900826558470726, 0.016574380919337273, 0.00531198363751173, -0.027942148968577385, -0.04561983793973923, 0.013648760505020618, 0.03374380245804787, -0.02585950493812561, -0.00587913254275918, -0.004713843110948801, -0.04418182000517845, -0.014925620518624783, -0.04943801835179329, 0.010828512720763683, 0.02900826558470726, 0.04006611555814743, 0.010431818664073944, -0.0008251550025306642, 0.033892564475536346, 0.041652895510196686, -0.002127582672983408, -0.03354545682668686, 0.007964876480400562, -0.007636364083737135, -0.02717355452477932, -0.011807851493358612, -0.0075371903367340565, -0.02497933991253376, 0.010345041751861572, 0.00985537189990282, 0.0011180269066244364, -0.01557024847716093, -0.004989669658243656, 0.005367768928408623, -0.04876859486103058, -0.006557851564139128, 0.00882644671946764, 0.03520661219954491, -0.028239671140909195, -0.03523140773177147, -0.006012396886944771, 0.019586777314543724, 0.019958678632974625, -0.005271694157272577, 0.01083471067249775, 0.046760331839323044, -0.009979339316487312, -0.004844008479267359, 0.0006113119889050722, -0.014045454561710358, 0.001704545458778739, -0.05280992016196251, -0.013376033864915371, 0.01948760449886322, -0.03833058103919029, 0.019822314381599426, 0.017925620079040527, -0.03183471038937569, -0.006331611890345812, 0.00955785159021616, -0.0070103309117257595, -0.000250839366344735, 0.002838843036442995, -0.03312396630644798, -0.023318182677030563, 0.0038491736631840467, -0.011225206777453423, 0.006337810307741165, 0.004329545423388481, -0.01483884360641241, 0.011795454658567905, -0.0030154960695654154, 0.05246281251311302, -0.014033058658242226, 0.025066116824746132, 0.01117562036961317, 0.0068491739220917225, -0.020975207909941673, -0.019376033917069435, 0.06158677861094475, -0.012471075169742107, 0.04886776953935623, 0.04048760607838631, -0.007407024968415499, 0.01230371929705143, 0.04212396964430809, -0.05070248246192932, -0.011318182572722435, -0.02381405048072338, -0.037760332226753235, 0.003833677852526307, 0.0021663224324584007, 0.015991736203432083, -0.024061983451247215, -0.009619834832847118, 0.026206612586975098, 0.0033997935242950916, -0.015210743993520737, -0.009167355485260487, -0.0354793407022953, 0.0375123992562294, 0.020962810143828392, 0.006601240020245314, -0.03200826421380043, -0.00013655734073836356, 0.0018780992832034826, -0.010704546235501766, 0.008373967371881008, 0.008008264936506748, 0.04227272793650627, -0.00218956614844501, 0.0007081611547619104, -0.02615702524781227, -0.011404959484934807, 0.03272727504372597, 0.009644628502428532, 0.03912396728992462, 0.03213223069906235, 0.009266529232263565, -0.017677687108516693, -0.021260330453515053, 0.029553720727562904, -0.02908264473080635, -0.006384297739714384, 0.00022701447596773505, 0.010028925724327564, 0.020342975854873657, -0.006514463108032942, 0.03357024863362312, -0.03612396866083145, -0.038504134863615036, -0.009793388657271862, 0.05712397024035454, -0.0006361053674481809, 0.003622933989390731, 0.035702481865882874, -0.01641322299838066, -0.00694214878603816, -0.004323347471654415, -0.009111570194363594, 0.013276860117912292, -0.01962396688759327, 0.03133884444832802, 0.00659504160284996 ]
13.7665
5.052316
2024-06-01
0
2024ApJ...968...45N
[ "Cool cores", "cool cores", "galaxy clusters", "Chandra X-ray", "archival X-ray data", "X-ray spectra", "cooling time", "cool-core systems", "ICM", "radiative cooling" ]
[ "Galaxy clusters", "Intracluster medium", "X-ray astronomy", "584", "858", "1810", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies", "Astrophysics - High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena" ]
19
[ "10.3847/1538-4357/ad4298", "10.48550/arXiv.2309.16297" ]
[ "Ng, FanLam", "Ueda, Shutaro" ]
[ "Academia Sinica Institute of Astronomy and Astrophysics (ASIAA), No. 1, Section 4, Roosevelt Road, Taipei 106216, Taiwan; Yuanpei College, Peking University, Yi He Yuan Road 5, Hai Dian District, Beijing 100871, People's Republic of China", "Academia Sinica Institute of Astronomy and Astrophysics (ASIAA), No. 1, Section 4, Roosevelt Road, Taipei 106216, Taiwan; Institute of Astronomy, National Tsing Hua University, Hsinchu 300044, Taiwan" ]
null
[ "1976A&A....49..137C", "1978A&A....70..677C", "1989GeCoA..53..197A", "1994ARA&A..32..277F", "1996ASPC..101...17A", "1998ApJ...496..728H", "2000MNRAS.318.1041E", "2001A&A...365L..87T", "2001A&A...365L.104P", "2001ApJ...556L..91S", "2001ApJ...560..194M", "2001MNRAS.328L..37A", "2002ApJ...567..716R", "2002MNRAS.335L...7V", "2003ApJ...587..619S", "2003ApJ...595..142T", "2003SPIE.4851...28G", "2004A&A...413..415K", "2004A&A...423...33P", "2004ApJ...606..185C", "2004ApJ...607..800B", "2005ApJ...628..655V", "2005ApJ...630..191S", "2005ApJ...633..148B", "2005MNRAS.359.1481B", "2005MNRAS.364..909V", "2006ApJ...640..691V", "2006ApJ...650..102A", "2006ApJ...652..216R", "2006MNRAS.372.1496S", "2006PhR...427....1P", "2006SPIE.6270E..1VF", "2007A&A...466..805C", "2007MNRAS.380.1554R", "2007arXiv0705.3289M", "2008A&A...483...35S", "2008ApJ...679.1181R", "2008ApJ...681.1035O", "2009ApJ...692.1033V", "2009ApJ...697.1597H", "2010A&A...513A..37H", "2010A&A...517A..92A", "2010A&A...521A..64S", "2010ApJ...717..908Z", "2010ApJ...722...55N", "2010CAMCS...5...65G", "2011A&A...525L..10G", "2011A&A...534A.109P", "2011ApJ...734...95M", "2011MNRAS.411..349G", "2011MNRAS.413..313H", "2011Sci...331.1576S", "2012ApJ...747...32B", "2012ApJ...753..120K", "2012ApJ...756..128F", "2013A&A...558A..33A", "2013ApJ...768..177S", "2013PASJ...65...47O", "2013PASP..125..306F", "2013SSRv..177..247G", "2013arXiv1306.2307N", "2014A&A...569A..67G", "2015A&A...575A..37M", "2015ApJ...805...35H", "2016A&A...585A.130H", "2016A&A...594A.116H", "2016ApJ...818..181Y", "2016ApJS..227...31S", "2016MNRAS.463.1057C", "2017AN....338..153B", "2017ApJ...836..110E", "2017ApJ...837...34U", "2017MNRAS.472.1482O", "2018AJ....156..123A", "2018ApJ...858...45M", "2018ApJ...865...53Z", "2018ApJ...866...48U", "2018MNRAS.481..749S", "2018MNRAS.481.1809B", "2018PASJ...70....9H", "2018SPIE10699E..22T", "2019ApJ...885...63M", "2019MNRAS.484.2807L", "2020ApJ...892..100U", "2020ApJ...895..143N", "2020MNRAS.498.5620S", "2020PASJ...72...33K", "2021ApJ...922...81U", "2022ApJ...934..169U", "2023A&A...674A.102W", "2023MNRAS.520.5157Z", "2023MNRAS.522.4991K" ]
28151191
2307.02545
Increasing the power of weak lensing data with multipole-based intrinsic alignment estimators
It has long been known that galaxy shapes align coherently with the large-scale density field. Characterizing this effect is essential to interpreting measurements of weak gravitational lensing, the deflection of light from distant galaxies by matter overdensities along the line of sight, as it also produces coherent galaxy alignments that we wish to interpret in terms of a cosmological model. Existing direct measurements of intrinsic alignments using galaxy samples with high-quality shape and redshift measurements typically use well-understood but sub-optimal projected estimators, which do not make good use of the information in the data when comparing those estimators to theoretical models. We demonstrate a more optimal estimator, based on a multipole expansion of the correlation functions or power spectra, for direct measurements of galaxy intrinsic alignments. We show that even using the lowest order multipole alone increases the significance of inferred model parameters using simulated and real data, without any additional modelling complexity. We apply this estimator to measurements of parameters of the non-linear alignment model using data from the Sloan Digital Sky survey, demonstrating consistent results with a factor of ~2 greater precision in parameter fits to intrinsic alignments models. This result is functionally equivalent to quadrupling the survey area, but without the attendant costs - thereby demonstrating the value in using this new estimator in current and future intrinsic alignments measurements using spectroscopic galaxy samples.
[ 0.004315453115850687, 0.009036920964717865, 0.043775856494903564, 0.01739715039730072, 0.003031275002285838, 0.04109369218349457, -0.031472355127334595, -0.026452526450157166, -0.05428304523229599, 0.022281639277935028, -0.002952840179204941, 0.017606310546398163, -0.011245399713516235, -0.040158625692129135, 0.02672320418059826, -0.008969251997768879, 0.01339851226657629, 0.00015917654673103243, -0.004549219273030758, 0.06166514754295349, 0.0013818369479849935, -0.008354077115654945, 0.014641165733337402, 0.012771033681929111, -0.014764200896024704, -0.03914973884820938, 0.021285057067871094, 0.012580329552292824, 0.05792488157749176, -0.041708867996931076, -0.022712262347340584, -0.015686962753534317, -0.029848292469978333, -0.047491513192653656, -0.08066175132989883, 0.09793587028980255, -0.009264536201953888, 0.030955608934164047, -0.04212718829512596, -0.02236776426434517, 0.004290845710784197, -0.0011849809670820832, -0.012586480937898159, -0.010230360552668571, 0.0166835468262434, -0.04697476699948311, -0.02308136783540249, -0.03265349194407463, -0.01895969547331333, -0.016425173729658127, -0.07583878189325333, 0.017864683642983437, -0.011306917294859886, -0.028691763058304787, -0.01667124405503273, -0.023733453825116158, 0.01956256665289402, 0.010273423045873642, 0.006185585167258978, 0.01595764048397541, 0.019181158393621445, -0.00006497786671388894, 0.02883940562605858, 0.018492162227630615, -0.05920444428920746, -0.005453526973724365, -0.03454823046922684, 0.004472322762012482, 0.024139469489455223, 0.03954344987869263, 0.02667398937046528, 0.007074513006955385, -0.0074928319081664085, 0.01523173414170742, 0.01893508806824684, -0.019353406503796577, -0.012506508268415928, 0.06565148383378983, -0.022663049399852753, 0.02536981925368309, 0.012894068844616413, 0.001101163332350552, 0.04867265000939369, -0.014801111072301865, -0.020054705440998077, 0.021555732935667038, -0.013287780806422234, -0.02014083042740822, -0.07126187533140182, 0.05861387774348259, 0.02023925818502903, -0.032874953001737595, 0.006563917733728886, -0.044514067471027374, -0.01300480030477047, -0.00325735192745924, 0.02309367060661316, -0.019907064735889435, 0.058367807418107986, 0.03548329696059227, 0.03307180851697922, 0.042373258620500565, 0.01672045700252056, -0.050296712666749954, 0.06136986240744591, 0.008514022454619408, 0.03787017613649368, -0.023007547482848167, 0.0008389449794776738, 0.03191528096795082, 0.04040469601750374, 0.016954224556684494, -0.026944667100906372, -0.021149717271327972, 0.004333908203989267, -0.04116751253604889, -0.06442113220691681, 0.035040371119976044, -0.04006019979715347, -0.004392349626868963, 0.0053181881085038185, 0.010322636924684048, 0.06875196099281311, 0.038682207465171814, 0.041659653186798096, -0.02901165559887886, 0.023388955742120743, -0.0522160567343235, -0.053840119391679764, -0.0005344332894310355, -0.012881765142083168, -0.009018465876579285, 0.02027617022395134, 0.012088189832866192, -0.0713110938668251, -0.014776504598557949, -0.009953532367944717, -0.011460711248219013, 0.020091617479920387, -0.007978820241987705, -0.006265557836741209, 0.001243422506377101, 0.040257055312395096, 0.005896452814340591, 0.011288462206721306, 0.02906086854636669, -0.00651470385491848, -0.01588382013142109, 0.0013526161201298237, 0.00867396779358387, -0.0252221766859293, -0.0074190110899508, -0.025492854416370392, -0.024250200018286705, -0.045965880155563354, -0.01336160209029913, -0.026575561612844467, -0.022835297510027885, 0.007640474010258913, -0.03850995749235153, 0.019390316680073738, 0.02396721951663494, -0.02172798290848732, 0.06028715521097183, -0.022872207686305046, 0.02972525730729103, -0.035064976662397385, -0.017889291048049927, -0.057531170547008514, -0.03969109430909157, -0.0035864703822880983, 0.035015761852264404, -0.013829135335981846, -0.06097615137696266, 0.03895288333296776, 0.02615724317729473, 0.011140819638967514, -0.014345881529152393, -0.04476013779640198, -0.012082037515938282, -0.016117585822939873, -0.00790499895811081, 0.053101908415555954, 0.030094362795352936, -0.03998637944459915, 0.023007547482848167, -0.015108698979020119, 0.055365752428770065, 0.03331787884235382, 0.0017163383308798075, -0.032899562269449234, 0.035188011825084686, 0.019845547154545784, 0.04183190315961838, -0.07032681256532669, -0.040823016315698624, 0.02677241712808609, 0.035138797014951706, -0.03742725029587746, -0.01819687709212303, 0.029454581439495087, 0.0027944326866418123, 0.030192790552973747, -0.04387428238987923, -0.03565554693341255, -0.04724544286727905, 0.02608342096209526, -0.0005386626580730081, -0.04212718829512596, 0.002762136049568653, 0.013964473269879818, 0.0020023947581648827, 0.04035548120737076, 0.014542737975716591, -0.021974053233861923, 0.0023330512922257185, -0.02610802836716175, -0.02684623934328556, 0.048918720334768295, 0.0417826883494854, -0.025566674768924713, 0.028494907543063164, 0.024114862084388733, 0.02529599703848362, -0.019279586151242256, -0.02755984105169773, 0.04653184115886688, -0.05556260794401169, 0.006736166775226593, -0.040158625692129135, 0.006717711687088013, -0.005631927400827408, -0.001497182296589017, 0.006686952896416187, 0.010421065613627434, 0.009282991290092468, -0.0028267293237149715, 0.006797684356570244, 0.01375531405210495, -0.05511968210339546, -0.0026637078262865543, 0.01953795924782753, -0.017532488331198692, -0.023745756596326828, -0.02385648898780346, 0.03472048044204712, -0.024754643440246582, 0.015022574923932552, 0.029085475951433182, 0.020829826593399048, 0.03203831613063812, 0.043062254786491394, -0.04576902464032173, -0.04832815006375313, -0.035064976662397385, 0.028519514948129654, -0.015428589656949043, -0.007468224968761206, -0.025911172851920128, 0.01085783913731575, -0.024090254679322243, -0.012906372547149658, -0.03528644144535065, 0.022195516154170036, -0.022810690104961395, 0.03235820680856705, 0.018947390839457512, 0.020583756268024445, -0.04845118522644043, 0.0020839055068790913, 0.027043094858527184, 0.0003070108068641275, 0.01946413889527321, -0.021518822759389877, -0.0187259279191494, 0.010605617426335812, -0.04335753619670868, 0.032874953001737595, 0.05915523320436478, -0.012746427208185196, -0.02241697907447815, -0.022675352171063423, 0.03034043312072754, 0.010242664255201817, -0.003998637665063143, -0.00020089310419280082, -0.010365699417889118, -0.01304171048104763, -0.021875623613595963, -0.021863320842385292, 0.018504464998841286, -0.04766376316547394, 0.010673287324607372, 0.0003444980247877538, -0.035852402448654175, -0.009276839904487133, -0.00829871091991663, 0.004429260268807411, -0.009855104610323906, 0.02827344462275505, 0.032062921673059464, 0.0054258438758552074, 0.009916621260344982, -0.013324690982699394, -0.015084091573953629, 0.009319901466369629, 0.01339851226657629, 0.021543430164456367, 0.003451131982728839, 0.04803286865353584, 0.0023653479292988777, 0.016191406175494194, -0.009239928796887398, 0.03267809748649597, -0.02970065176486969, -0.016105283051729202, -0.013952169567346573, -0.005216684192419052, -0.00790499895811081, -0.008040337823331356, -0.05762959644198418, -0.07017917186021805, -0.027682876214385033, -0.041610438376665115, 0.014604255557060242, -0.03166921064257622, -0.015576232224702835, -0.015034877695143223, -0.0334901288151741, -0.006019487977027893, 0.024397842586040497, 0.004189342260360718, 0.0035372565034776926, -0.006471641361713409, -0.04047851637005806, -0.019882457330822945, 0.014308971352875233, 0.011128516867756844, -0.0018470630748197436, 0.014345881529152393, -0.043431356549263, -0.010341092012822628, 0.02249079942703247, -0.005555030424147844, 0.037378035485744476, 0.017741648480296135, 0.01604376547038555, 0.02026386559009552, 0.040257055312395096, 0.021949445828795433, -0.02610802836716175, 0.0028651778120547533, 0.037279605865478516, -0.002994364593178034, 0.051822345703840256, -0.01675736904144287, -0.004007865209132433, -0.07278750836849213, -0.009252232499420643, -0.0060010324232280254, -0.007302127778530121, -0.02674781158566475, 0.026920059695839882, 0.05885994806885719, -0.009836648590862751, 0.0066931042820215225, -0.002011622302234173, 0.009953532367944717, -0.03927277401089668, 0.0031127857510000467, -0.010691742412745953, 0.03710735961794853, -0.054578330367803574, 0.011743691749870777, -0.03181685134768486, -0.005358174443244934, 0.029429974034428596, 0.02812580205500126, 0.0253452118486166, -0.002792894607409835, 0.03112785704433918, 0.0027329151052981615, -0.009129197336733341, -0.03531104698777199, 0.048967935144901276, 0.0036941261496394873, -0.023573508486151695, -0.011306917294859886, -0.056842174381017685, 0.01336160209029913, -0.01946413889527321, 0.012561874464154243, 0.024791553616523743, 0.015662357211112976, 0.022798387333750725, -0.01893508806824684, 0.03117707185447216, 0.06565148383378983, 0.024213289842009544, 0.03280113264918327, -0.01963638700544834, -0.02829805202782154, -0.041536618024110794, -0.0448339581489563, -0.03250584751367569, -0.005801100749522448, -0.029971327632665634, 0.03619689866900444, 0.05147784575819969, 0.03609847277402878, 0.04783600941300392, -0.04119212180376053, 0.04478474333882332, -0.04982917755842209, 0.020103920251131058, 0.01154683530330658, -0.02238006889820099, 0.031546175479888916, 0.0011565290624275804, 0.030635716393589973, 0.031570784747600555, -0.019131943583488464, 0.01375531405210495, -0.0009250694420188665, -0.02022695541381836, 0.00724061019718647, -0.00290824007242918, 0.020731398835778236, -0.01749557815492153, -0.06757082790136337, -0.016929617151618004, 0.0677676796913147, 0.05339719355106354, -0.030807966366410255, -0.0074251629412174225, -0.02181410789489746, 0.027092309668660164, 0.0012218913761898875, 0.0119405472651124, 0.0017424833495169878, 0.008224890567362309, -0.006748470012098551, -0.040970657020807266, -0.08061254024505615, 0.03536026179790497, -0.009682855568826199, -0.01886126585304737, 0.026231063529849052, -0.012857158668339252, -0.017815468832850456, -0.035089585930109024, 0.024926893413066864, 0.022626137360930443, 0.0015333237824961543, -0.0015187134267762303, -0.0017301797633990645, -0.006197888404130936, -0.057580385357141495, 0.059056803584098816, -0.0231797955930233, -0.011559139005839825, -0.01583460532128811, -0.03890366852283478, 0.038017816841602325, -0.035704758018255234, 0.07116344571113586, -0.011848270893096924, -0.012543419376015663, -0.006723863072693348, 0.015416286885738373, -0.0009243005188181996, -0.052511341869831085, 0.03742725029587746, -0.001699421089142561, 0.010027352720499039, 0.011245399713516235, -0.015330161899328232, -0.05275741219520569, 0.02618185058236122, -0.005164394620805979, 0.042299434542655945, -0.021887928247451782, -0.004678406286984682, 0.04261932522058487, -0.005345871206372976, 0.03673825412988663, -0.0009596730815246701, 0.015686962753534317, -0.0030620337929576635, -0.007658929098397493, 0.0027529082726687193, -0.03846074268221855, 0.04931243136525154, -0.011762146838009357, 0.014727290719747543, -0.014001384377479553, 0.00828025583177805, 0.010267271660268307, 0.010427216999232769, 0.04247168451547623, 0.09139040112495422, -0.012598784640431404, 0.028691763058304787, 0.042988430708646774, 0.016092978417873383, 0.044514067471027374, -0.04766376316547394, -0.03351473808288574, -0.048967935144901276, 0.04133976250886917, -0.03462205082178116, 0.059696584939956665, -0.00306972349062562, 0.00038909821887500584, 0.007382100448012352, 0.05698981508612633, -0.0158592127263546, 0.017889291048049927, 0.03536026179790497, -0.007505135610699654, 0.027141522616147995, -0.04104447737336159, -0.021174324676394463, 0.017630916088819504, 0.005228987894952297, -0.00401709321886301, -0.05088727921247482, -0.11279849708080292, -0.03031582571566105, -0.011706780642271042, 0.023413561284542084, -0.020103920251131058, 0.006736166775226593, -0.0002643330371938646, -0.020017795264720917, -0.024988410994410515, 0.019722511991858482, -0.011891333386301994, -0.03262888267636299, -0.022097088396549225, 0.007369797211140394, 0.00706220930442214, 0.0015148685779422522, 0.012217376381158829, 0.02309367060661316, 0.017630916088819504, -0.00523513974621892, -0.005348946899175644, 0.03636914864182472, 0.017926201224327087, 0.03203831613063812, -0.03117707185447216, 0.0009965836070477962, 0.010187298990786076, -0.03122628480195999, 0.012217376381158829, -0.0005117487162351608, 0.00596104608848691, 0.02544363960623741, 0.020473025739192963, -0.021838713437318802, -0.02091595157980919, -0.019870154559612274, 0.02832265943288803, 0.008052641525864601, -0.020017795264720917, -0.006145598832517862, -0.02454548329114914, 0.0056473067961633205, 0.032161351293325424, -0.02470543049275875, -0.0022161679808050394, -0.0028282671701163054, -0.038854457437992096, 0.009332205168902874, 0.017704738304018974, 0.004626116249710321, 0.004312376957386732, 0.002269995864480734, -0.0522160567343235, -0.03122628480195999, -0.013509243726730347, 0.002250002697110176, 0.007640474010258913, -0.050985708832740784, -0.012463446706533432, -0.02824883721768856, 0.014555041678249836, 0.028544122353196144, 0.021149717271327972, -0.02038690075278282, -0.01968560181558132, -0.005985653027892113, 0.006391668692231178, -0.003174303099513054, 0.01800002157688141, -0.012518811970949173, 0.02386879175901413, 0.017003437504172325, -0.015342465601861477, 0.00867396779358387, 0.018590589985251427, 0.0032081378158181906, -0.03971569985151291, 0.004739923868328333, 0.01019345037639141, 0.016289835795760155, 0.030192790552973747, -0.013779920525848866, 0.014284364879131317, -0.006403972394764423, 0.005192077253013849, 0.004770682659000158, -0.038042426109313965, -0.016498994082212448, -0.019894760102033615, 0.008089551702141762, 0.006576220970600843, 0.04722083732485771, -0.005167470313608646, 0.017138777300715446, -0.0007739671273157, 0.05133020505309105, 0.002668321831151843, 0.04515384882688522, 0.011386889964342117, -0.004069382790476084, -0.05064120888710022, -0.02393030934035778, -0.014099812135100365, -0.014702683314681053, -0.0320875309407711, 0.030512681230902672, -0.0037464159540832043, -0.0044477153569459915, 0.02383188158273697, 0.028002768754959106, 0.021912535652518272, 0.003214289667084813, -0.030217397958040237, 0.006090233102440834, 0.0004360052989795804, 0.027904339134693146, -0.048943325877189636, -0.00217464379966259, -0.010636376217007637, 0.004647647496312857, 0.00469070952385664, -0.037894781678915024, -0.009812042117118835, 0.003475738922134042, -0.011719084344804287, 0.02025156281888485, 0.030561896041035652, 0.021863320842385292, -0.011448407545685768, -0.010218057781457901, 0.022121693938970566, -0.011479166336357594, -0.043948106467723846, -0.03331787884235382, -0.017913896590471268, -0.02257692441344261, -0.029233118519186974, -0.01882435567677021, 0.0014618097338825464, 0.007068361155688763, 0.02891322784125805, -0.008852369152009487, -0.005419692024588585, 0.0155393211171031, 0.02091595157980919, 0.0052843536250293255, 0.015686962753534317, -0.03954344987869263, -0.012180466204881668, -0.008040337823331356, -0.027166130021214485, -0.04584284499287605, -0.023647328838706017, -0.014284364879131317, 0.004653799347579479, -0.009787434712052345, -0.01550241094082594, 0.002293064957484603, 0.012992496602237225, 0.02669859677553177, 0.02180180326104164, 0.010962419211864471, 0.0069760847836732864, 0.00029720645397901535, -0.011835968121886253, 0.027018487453460693, 0.008378684520721436, -0.009215322323143482, -0.009935077279806137, 0.01946413889527321, 0.01333699468523264, 0.00706220930442214, -0.009221473708748817, 0.029110083356499672, 0.009319901466369629, -0.001963946269825101, -0.04136436805129051, -0.026329491287469864, -0.009707462042570114, -0.03134931996464729, 0.00946139171719551, 0.022970635443925858, -0.011368434876203537, 0.045916665345430374, 0.0071667893789708614, -0.02468082308769226, -0.018418340012431145, 0.013263174332678318, -0.009898166172206402, 0.0005517351091839373, 0.009633640758693218, -0.02393030934035778, -0.02378266677260399, -0.006410123780369759, -0.02689545229077339, -0.05787566676735878, 0.027190737426280975, 0.026427919045090675, -0.029306938871741295, -0.037156570702791214, 0.01801232434809208, -0.0273875929415226, -0.013373905792832375, 0.003088178811594844, 0.0036941261496394873, 0.010919356718659401, -0.017840076237916946, 0.0027129219379276037, 0.029946720227599144, 0.024250200018286705, -0.012531115673482418, -0.013841438107192516, 0.045227669179439545, 0.003854071721434593, 0.011934395879507065, 0.014591951854526997, 0.001788621419109404, 0.02386879175901413, 0.009209170006215572, 0.025763530284166336, 0.0018655182793736458, 0.010273423045873642, 0.028667157515883446, 0.013804527930915356, 0.00984280090779066, -0.004278542473912239, 0.008187979459762573, 0.03678746894001961, -0.025013016536831856, -0.00041870350833050907, -0.022133998572826385, 0.027362985536456108, 0.010027352720499039, 0.016966527327895164, 0.03619689866900444, 0.017729343846440315, 0.0036602914333343506, 0.002265382092446089, -0.0014564269222319126, -0.01820918172597885, -0.015096395276486874, 0.00018407190509606153, -0.010002746246755123, 0.029110083356499672, 0.03415451943874359, 0.05300348252058029, 0.0033127176575362682, 0.016831189393997192, 0.007880392484366894, 0.004992145579308271, 0.0066254353150725365, -0.010181146673858166, -0.003186606802046299, -0.0038725268095731735, -0.017926201224327087, 0.030734146013855934, -0.02529599703848362, -0.0016502070939168334, 0.026427919045090675, -0.012162010185420513, -0.02960222214460373, 0.053249552845954895, 0.007339038420468569, -0.018984301015734673, 0.009086135774850845, -0.011183882132172585, 0.034425195306539536, -0.0052843536250293255, 0.050395138561725616, -0.02017774060368538, -0.1031525507569313, -0.011737539432942867, 0.02977447211742401, 0.04121672734618187, -0.007252913899719715, 0.025197569280862808, 0.028470300137996674, 0.03841152787208557, -0.02970065176486969, -0.028790192678570747, -0.0022115542087703943, -0.025960387662053108, 0.014358185231685638, 0.04320989549160004, 0.03548329696059227, -0.024324020370841026, -0.03843613713979721, 0.029380759224295616, 0.004998297430574894, 0.010728652589023113, -0.0014102887362241745, 0.008981555700302124, 0.005035207606852055, 0.00014120189007371664, 0.013484637252986431, -0.003174303099513054, -0.025197569280862808, -0.01011347770690918, 0.02250310219824314, 0.002265382092446089, -0.005287429317831993, -0.011140819638967514, -0.004072458948940039, 0.030266612768173218, -0.008372532203793526, -0.033563949167728424, 0.01875053532421589, 0.02249079942703247, -0.03988794982433319, 0.025837352499365807, -0.02234315685927868, -0.031447749584913254, 0.024237897247076035, 0.02020234800875187, 0.023659631609916687, 0.015699267387390137, 0.020091617479920387, 0.008237194269895554, 0.010950115509331226, 0.023438168689608574, -0.00010736726835602894, -0.0001008310355246067, -0.013853741809725761, 0.007136030588299036, -0.0002131966029992327, -0.00666849734261632, 0.019291888922452927, 0.02834726683795452, -0.025542067363858223, -0.0012218913761898875, -0.0362953282892704, 0.015219430439174175, 0.015711570158600807, -0.007049906067550182, -0.06579912453889847, -0.0035803187638521194, -0.03130010515451431, 0.020632971078157425, 0.010242664255201817, -0.04180729761719704, -0.02454548329114914, 0.03563093766570091, -0.002005470683798194, -0.020128527656197548, 0.009215322323143482, 0.0067300149239599705, 0.003832540474832058, 0.001035801018588245, -0.04695015773177147, 0.05566103756427765, 0.021149717271327972, -0.003008205909281969, 0.04293921962380409, 0.02023925818502903, -0.00704375421628356, 0.04077380150556564, -0.025185266509652138, -0.01873823255300522, -0.03890366852283478, 0.03494194149971008, 0.024877678602933884, -0.009522909298539162, 0.00868012011051178, -0.02319209836423397, 0.007812722586095333, 0.003737188410013914, 0.032112136483192444, -0.02600960060954094, 0.015034877695143223, -0.016129890456795692, -0.009965836070477962, -0.016486691311001778, -0.010808625258505344, -0.048131294548511505, 0.0012680295621976256, -0.029233118519186974, 0.014616559259593487, 0.005115180276334286, -0.001596379210241139, 0.044538673013448715, 0.000007755771548545454, 0.00863705761730671, -0.01371840387582779, -0.005382781848311424, 0.04207797348499298, -0.014801111072301865, -0.035877007991075516, -0.003927892539650202, 0.029306938871741295, 0.012598784640431404, 0.03614768385887146, -0.035803187638521194, -0.04537530988454819, -0.01417363341897726, 0.017876986414194107, -0.03695971518754959, 0.002934384858235717, -0.004195493645966053, -0.011651415377855301, 0.007825026288628578, 0.013263174332678318, -0.009436785243451595, 0.03041425347328186, -0.02239237166941166, -0.019119640812277794, -0.0025914248544722795, 0.031570784747600555, 0.02615724317729473, -0.00130878493655473, 0.018418340012431145, 0.0037833265960216522, 0.019082730636000633, 0.03038964793086052, 0.007289824075996876, 0.019697904586791992, 0.008101855404675007, -0.010008897632360458, -0.04965692758560181, 0.04141358286142349, 0.01085783913731575, 0.0076712328009307384, 0.011823664419353008, -0.018602892756462097, 0.004579978063702583, -0.03277652710676193, 0.012426535598933697, 0.010402609594166279, 0.01119618583470583, -0.0022761477157473564, -0.004616888705641031, -0.0026252595707774162, 0.02251540683209896, -0.03034043312072754, 0.012438839301466942, -0.01600685529410839, -0.004066307097673416, -0.02020234800875187, 0.004666102584451437, 0.002608342096209526, -0.03321945294737816, 0.008975404314696789, -0.06574990600347519, 0.008790851570665836, 0.005348946899175644, -0.001859366544522345, -0.005352023057639599, -0.04264393448829651, 0.00018214948067907244, -0.005364326294511557, 0.03784556686878204, -0.0004133207257837057, -0.0017686282517388463, 0.002179257571697235, 0.011872878298163414, 0.024779250845313072, -0.009725917130708694, -0.02536981925368309, -0.019722511991858482, 0.035803187638521194, 0.00938141904771328, -0.016216013580560684, 0.048844899982213974, -0.010980874300003052, 0.030881786718964577, 0.01941492408514023, 0.007941910065710545, -0.02888862043619156, 0.04938625171780586, -0.010740956291556358, 0.009485999122262001, -0.06314156949520111, -0.0375748910009861, -0.011602201499044895, -0.025591282173991203, -0.01019345037639141, 0.007277520839124918, -0.01309092529118061, -0.032235171645879745, -0.03703353926539421, -0.04180729761719704, 0.012746427208185196, -0.013238566927611828, 0.03983873501420021, 0.007542045786976814, 0.031595390290021896, -0.058958377689123154, 0.03828849643468857, -0.00002946111635537818, -0.05118256434798241, -0.03390844911336899, 0.03841152787208557, -0.03836231678724289, -0.032284386456012726, 0.052462127059698105, -0.002914391690865159, 0.04798365384340286, 0.014370488934218884, -0.043800462037324905, 0.00290824007242918, 0.014641165733337402, -0.017963111400604248, 0.009479847736656666, -0.008686271496117115, -0.000037511257687583566, -0.04631037637591362, -0.014665773138403893, 0.010581010952591896, -0.00012889839126728475, 0.010556403547525406, -0.007622018922120333, 0.014468916691839695, -0.003737188410013914, -0.007874240167438984, 0.024102557450532913, 0.001431050943210721, 0.01375531405210495, 0.02238006889820099, 0.00724061019718647, 0.01375531405210495, -0.00015494720719289035, -0.013078621588647366, 0.004389273934066296, -0.03267809748649597, 0.000661697646137327, -0.00936911627650261, 0.011110060848295689, -0.043136075139045715, 0.041487403213977814, 0.03260427713394165, 0.009270687587559223, -0.01658511906862259, 0.026575561612844467, -0.026255670934915543, -0.018541375175118446, 0.02684623934328556, 0.004281618166714907, -0.014161329716444016, 0.007745053619146347, 0.010593314655125141, -0.008329469710588455, 0.02238006889820099, -0.04035548120737076, 0.03538486734032631, -0.007517438847571611, -0.006323999259620905, 0.007960365153849125, 0.024963803589344025, -0.002263844246044755, -0.005238215439021587, 0.029528401792049408, -0.02169107273221016, -0.03240742161870003, 0.0011711395345628262, 0.006102536339312792, -0.006853050086647272, 0.01966099441051483, -0.0029159297700971365, 0.00544122327119112, 0.04498159885406494, -0.0071667893789708614, -0.00829871091991663, 0.04589205980300903, 0.017704738304018974, -0.007400555536150932, 0.017126472666859627, -0.02463160827755928, -0.015219430439174175, 0.003229669062420726, -0.0003921740863006562, 0.00942448154091835, 0.007148333825170994, -0.01047027949243784, 0.00236227223649621, -0.014284364879131317, 0.006717711687088013, -0.024139469489455223, -0.0180246289819479, -0.02102668210864067, -0.007252913899719715, -0.019390316680073738, -0.004798365291208029, -0.022982940077781677, 0.00595181854441762, 0.004186266101896763, -0.009258384816348553, -0.011466862633824348, -0.008846216835081577, 0.017815468832850456, 0.026280278339982033, -0.0004367742803879082, -0.007560501340776682, 0.014924146234989166, 0.011146971955895424, -0.00010544484393903986, -0.01594533771276474, -0.02244158461689949, -0.012549570761620998, 0.015096395276486874, 0.008747789077460766, 0.03253045678138733, 0.02233085408806801, 0.0419057235121727, 0.025566674768924713, -0.038165461272001266, -0.05157627537846565, 0.034252945333719254, 0.009978138841688633, 0.00865551270544529, 0.03307180851697922, 0.0018378354143351316, 0.042348649352788925, -0.003681822679936886, -0.008815458044409752, -0.009707462042570114, -0.02097746916115284, 0.030783358961343765, -0.02023925818502903, -0.003952499479055405, -0.04126594215631485, 0.008126461878418922, 0.05738352611660957, -0.013533851131796837, 0.018996605649590492, 0.0215926431119442, 0.02180180326104164, 0.00946139171719551, 0.00775120547041297, -0.011190034449100494, 0.02249079942703247, -0.0043800463899970055, -0.003761795349419117, 0.016412870958447456, 0.015182520262897015, 0.021198932081460953, 0.04466170817613602, 0.010353395715355873, -0.00371873308904469, 0.0333670936524868, 0.00005200151645112783, 0.016806581988930702, -0.0126726059243083, -0.003854071721434593, -0.019144248217344284, 0.00973822083324194, -0.018258394673466682, -0.02977447211742401, -0.006367061752825975, 0.01304171048104763, -0.027116915211081505, 0.017852379009127617, -0.011528380215168, 0.0047799102030694485, -0.010328789241611958, 0.01090090163052082, -0.02824883721768856, -0.013743010349571705, -0.022786082699894905, 0.022281639277935028, -0.003143544541671872, -0.008993859402835369, 0.021481912583112717, -0.0018916632980108261, 0.017557095736265182, -0.04249629005789757, -0.008876975625753403, 0.007295975927263498, 0.011909788474440575, 0.02028847299516201, 0.004764530807733536, -0.004235479980707169, -0.02667398937046528, -0.005964122246950865, -0.00245608645491302, -0.023598114028573036, -0.0031804549507796764, 0.022220121696591377, 0.016818884760141373, 0.031472355127334595, 0.00898770708590746, -0.03164460510015488, 0.0026821631472557783, 0.0003837154363282025, -0.02257692441344261, 0.006717711687088013, 0.0312016773968935, -0.01818457432091236, 0.03319484367966652, 0.003875602735206485, 0.0014956443337723613, 0.013226263225078583, -0.0058718458749353886, 0.009282991290092468, -0.03969109430909157, 0.005207456648349762, -0.010974722914397717, -0.005078270100057125, -0.035877007991075516, -0.0026237214915454388, -0.04402192682027817, -0.044440243393182755, 0.010242664255201817, -0.01742175780236721, 0.02257692441344261, 0.001624062075279653, -0.03887906298041344, 0.02541903220117092, 0.00946139171719551, -0.0028497984167188406, -0.06540541350841522, 0.03752567619085312, -0.02234315685927868, 0.008169524371623993, 0.02682163193821907, 0.0031835308764129877, 0.030020542442798615, -0.00418011425063014, 0.011165427044034004, -0.003924816846847534, 0.026206456124782562, -0.0030143577605485916, -0.005259746685624123, 0.02972525730729103, 0.0012065120972692966, -0.011005481705069542, 0.019759422168135643, 0.009375267662107944, -0.007560501340776682, -0.022060176357626915, 0.007954212836921215, -0.014530434273183346, 0.040896836668252945, 0.020054705440998077, 0.04293921962380409, 0.007585108280181885, -0.010414913296699524, 0.015256340615451336, 0.02103898674249649, -0.022736869752407074, -0.0023607341572642326, -0.03540947660803795, 0.03486812114715576, 0.014247453771531582, -0.007351341657340527, -0.00979973841458559, -0.014370488934218884, -0.037328820675611496, 0.021334270015358925, -0.013127835467457771, 0.00378640228882432, 0.017815468832850456, -0.040626160800457, 0.02315518818795681, 0.021998658776283264, 0.012869461439549923, -0.01163296028971672, 0.009990442544221878, 0.006111763883382082, -0.019427228718996048, 0.029553009197115898, 0.026575561612844467, 0.003595698159188032, -0.003568015294149518, -0.030069755390286446, 0.006397820543497801, 0.016855796799063683, -0.008870824240148067, -0.003998637665063143, 0.008163372986018658, -0.015317858196794987, -0.016437476500868797, -0.008618602529168129, -0.025148356333374977, -0.00686535332351923, -0.01819687709212303, 0.0026806253008544445, 0.0030235853046178818, -0.021481912583112717, -0.0090738320723176, -0.012771033681929111, -0.001158835948444903, -0.010593314655125141, -0.011915940791368484, -0.01375531405210495, 0.0006982236518524587, 0.03759950026869774, -0.04936164617538452, -0.027018487453460693, -0.025960387662053108, -0.043160680681467056, -0.0060010324232280254, 0.0024483967572450638, -0.03609847277402878, 0.007757357321679592, -0.026231063529849052, -0.022638441994786263, -0.03385923430323601, -0.007345189806073904, -0.014911843463778496, -0.02181410789489746, 0.015674659982323647, -0.004312376957386732, -0.04476013779640198, 0.03125089034438133, -0.013115531764924526, -0.020719096064567566, 0.020792916417121887, -0.020103920251131058, 0.0003546868683770299, 0.035926222801208496, -0.012389625422656536, 0.0013579989317804575, -0.022133998572826385, 0.004985993728041649, 0.02107589691877365, 0.017089562490582466, 0.05088727921247482, 0.020128527656197548, -0.04584284499287605, 0.011306917294859886, 0.010722501203417778, -0.005847238935530186, -0.02238006889820099, -0.005813403986394405, -0.017237205058336258, 0.01481341477483511, 0.014690379612147808, 0.03774714097380638, 0.018664410337805748, -0.007160637527704239, 0.027067702263593674, 0.008901583030819893, -0.03240742161870003, 0.017175687476992607, 0.01587151549756527, -0.004217024892568588, 0.051773130893707275, -0.021912535652518272, 0.01958717405796051, -0.018418340012431145, 0.009565971791744232, 0.02822423167526722, -0.0009373729699291289, 0.01090090163052082, 0.005339719355106354, 0.0069883884862065315, 0.013017104007303715, 0.026501741260290146, 0.012328107841312885, -0.006065625697374344, -0.0061548263765871525, -0.02098977193236351, -0.07145873457193375, 0.004819896537810564, -0.0063301511108875275, -0.020879041403532028, 0.025689709931612015, -0.025000713765621185, -0.004121672827750444, -0.016339048743247986, 0.017040349543094635, -0.004650723189115524, -0.02957761660218239, 0.043825071305036545, -0.004241631831973791, 0.0008074172656051815, 0.0682598203420639, 0.03912513330578804, 0.020485328510403633, 0.004333908203989267, 0.008329469710588455, -0.0378209613263607, 0.006797684356570244, -0.011694477871060371, 0.0002897089871112257, 0.01887357048690319, -0.028519514948129654, 0.0312016773968935, -0.009301446378231049, -0.029429974034428596, 0.03115246444940567, 0.00724061019718647, 0.05157627537846565, 0.01309092529118061, 0.002811349928379059, -0.03125089034438133, 0.00008083784632617608, 0.01270951610058546, 0.03179224580526352, -0.013115531764924526, -0.03917434811592102, 0.00253298319876194, -0.026452526450157166, -0.014948753640055656, -0.003092792583629489, 0.05206841602921486, 0.014235150068998337, -0.025861958041787148, -0.006969933398067951, -0.0006024870672263205, -0.01194669958204031, 0.03631993383169174, 0.007628170307725668, 0.03255506232380867, -0.0057211280800402164, -0.007855785079300404, 0.037230394780635834, 0.00032239017309620976, -0.007019147276878357, -0.024262502789497375, 0.017003437504172325, 0.022293943911790848, 0.00176093855407089, -0.00686535332351923, -0.004810668993741274, -0.00010400303290225565, -0.0126726059243083, -0.0008235655841417611, -0.0005013676709495485, 0.013410815969109535, -0.016511298716068268, 0.026378706097602844, -0.003875602735206485, -0.033736199140548706, 0.022835297510027885, 0.010039656423032284, 0.008975404314696789, -0.002905164146795869, 0.023622721433639526, -0.01163296028971672, -0.009479847736656666, 0.03474508598446846, 0.025185266509652138, -0.032259780913591385, 0.035040371119976044, 0.01808614656329155, -0.0027344529516994953, -0.03201371058821678, 0.01514560915529728, 0.015342465601861477, 0.027043094858527184, -0.040109410881996155, 0.013386208564043045, 0.028740977868437767, -0.017987718805670738, 0.025615889579057693, 0.00436774268746376, 0.012758729979395866, 0.0009427557233721018, 0.019673297181725502, 0.03240742161870003, 0.015157912857830524, -0.024004129692912102, 0.009504454210400581, 0.006723863072693348, -0.0019470290280878544, 0.014345881529152393, 0.0017594005912542343, -0.009196867235004902, 0.02182641066610813, -0.02468082308769226, 0.006619283463805914, -0.035852402448654175, -0.024041039869189262, -0.009904318489134312, -0.02233085408806801, 0.0016302138101309538, -0.013410815969109535, 0.009652096778154373, 0.007179092615842819, -0.02379497140645981, 0.02982368692755699, -0.012371170334517956, -0.021481912583112717, -0.010654831305146217, 0.019082730636000633, 0.009996594861149788, 0.0018209181725978851, -0.00014658467262052, 0.01823378913104534, -0.013115531764924526, -0.019894760102033615, 0.00635475805029273, -0.010894750244915485, -0.012469598092138767, -0.020756006240844727, 0.014665773138403893, 0.008704726584255695, -0.01558853592723608, -0.0002012775803450495, 0.005453526973724365, 0.04628577083349228, 0.035827793180942535, -0.003380386857315898, 0.021248145028948784, -0.03280113264918327, -0.02748602069914341, -0.003875602735206485, 0.04357900097966194, 0.04033087566494942, -0.01406290102750063, 0.03275191783905029, 0.006216343957930803, 0.0006343992426991463, -0.0013926024548709393, 0.011534531600773335, 0.00944293662905693, -0.029848292469978333, -0.014751897193491459, -0.013189353048801422 ]
12.124188
4.033286
2024-06-01
6
2024MNRAS.530.3515S
[ "intrinsic alignments models", "coherent galaxy alignments", "intrinsic alignments", "galaxy intrinsic alignments", "direct measurements", "galaxy shapes", "inferred model parameters", "Existing direct measurements", "galaxy samples", "spectroscopic galaxy samples" ]
[ "gravitational lensing: weak", "methods: statistical", "large-scale structure of Universe", "cosmology: observations", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
26
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1034", "10.48550/arXiv.2307.02545" ]
[ "Singh, Sukhdeep", "Shakir, Ali", "Jagvaral, Yesukhei", "Mandelbaum, Rachel" ]
[ "McWilliams Center for Cosmology and Astrophysics, Department of Physics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA", "McWilliams Center for Cosmology and Astrophysics, Department of Physics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA", "McWilliams Center for Cosmology and Astrophysics, Department of Physics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA", "McWilliams Center for Cosmology and Astrophysics, Department of Physics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA" ]
[ "2024OJAp....7E..14L", "2024OJAp....7E..36G", "2024OJAp....7E..45V", "2024PhRvD.109j3501O", "2024arXiv240302314J", "2024arXiv240619669I" ]
[ "1985ApJ...292..371D", "1987MNRAS.227....1K", "1993ApJ...412...64L", "1996AJ....111.1748F", "1998AJ....116.3040G", "2000AJ....120.1579Y", "2001AJ....122.2129H", "2001AJ....122.2267E", "2001ASPC..238..269L", "2001MNRAS.320L...7C", "2001MNRAS.328..726S", "2002AJ....123.2121S", "2002AJ....123.2945R", "2002AJ....124.1810S", "2003AJ....125.1559P", "2003MNRAS.341.1311S", "2004AN....325..583I", "2004PhRvD..70f3526H", "2006AJ....131.2332G", "2006AN....327..821T", "2006MNRAS.367..611M", "2007A&A...464..399H", "2007MNRAS.381.1197H", "2007NJPh....9..444B", "2008ApJ...674.1217P", "2009ApJ...694..214O", "2009ApJS..182..543A", "2010MNRAS.401..791S", "2010PhRvD..81f3531B", "2011A&A...527A..26J", "2011ApJS..193...29A", "2011MNRAS.410..844M", "2011arXiv1110.3193L", "2012AJ....144..144B", "2012ApJ...761..152T", "2012ApJS..203...21A", "2012MNRAS.425.2610R", "2013AJ....145...10D", "2013AJ....146...32S", "2013MNRAS.432.1544M", "2013MNRAS.435...64K", "2013PhR...530...87W", "2015JCAP...08..015B", "2015MNRAS.447..437M", "2015MNRAS.450.2195S", "2015PhR...558....1T", "2015RPPh...78h6901K", "2015SSRv..193....1J", "2016A&A...594A..13P", "2016MNRAS.455.1553R", "2016MNRAS.457.2301S", "2017MNRAS.464.1640S", "2017MNRAS.464.2120S", "2017MNRAS.465.3291W", "2017MNRAS.470.2617A", "2017MNRAS.471.3827S", "2018MNRAS.473.4077P", "2018MNRAS.475..624N", "2018MNRAS.475..648P", "2018MNRAS.475..676S", "2018MNRAS.477.1206N", "2018MNRAS.480.5113M", "2018MNRAS.481.3170M", "2019A&A...624A..30J", "2019ApJ...873..111I", "2019ComAC...6....2N", "2019JCAP...01..016L", "2019JCAP...03..007V", "2019MNRAS.482..785S", "2019MNRAS.483..276Y", "2019arXiv190205569A", "2020JCAP...01..025V", "2020MNRAS.494..694O", "2021A&A...654A..76F", "2021MNRAS.501..833K", "2021MNRAS.501.2983F", "2021MNRAS.501.4167S", "2022A&A...664A.170V", "2022MNRAS.509.1764J", "2022MNRAS.514.1021J", "2022PhRvD.105b3514A", "2022PhRvD.105b3515S", "2023JCAP...10..005B", "2023MNRAS.524.2195S", "2023PhRvD.108h3533K", "2023PhRvD.108l3518L", "2023PhRvD.108l3519D" ]
28584778
2308.11007
Mitigating bias in deep learning: training unbiased models on biased data for the morphological classification of galaxies
Galaxy morphologies and their relation with physical properties have been a relevant subject of study in the past. Most galaxy morphology catalogues have been labelled by human annotators or by machine learning models trained on human-labelled data. Human-generated labels have been shown to contain biases in terms of the observational properties of the data, such as image resolution. These biases are independent of the annotators, that is, are present even in catalogues labelled by experts. In this work, we demonstrate that training deep learning models on biased galaxy data produces biased models, meaning that the biases in the training data are transferred to the predictions of the new models. We also propose a method to train deep learning models that considers this inherent labelling bias, to obtain a de-biased model even when training on biased data. We show that models trained using our deep de-biasing method are capable of reducing the bias of human-labelled data sets.
[ -0.0028033077251166105, 0.03066866658627987, -0.010204097256064415, -0.007965960539877415, -0.00754877645522356, 0.004698958247900009, 0.004811710678040981, -0.05186612904071808, -0.037095557898283005, 0.007994148880243301, -0.00875522755086422, -0.012346393428742886, -0.016112325713038445, -0.028188113123178482, 0.010221010074019432, 0.014950974844396114, 0.03328452259302139, 0.0004925872781313956, -0.01531178317964077, 0.020396918058395386, 0.016428032889962196, 0.0400947704911232, 0.04897966608405113, 0.006071719340980053, -0.02277599461376667, 0.0019872619304805994, 0.00726689537987113, 0.004899093881249428, 0.03968886286020279, 0.020723899826407433, 0.016326555982232094, -0.021524442359805107, -0.03998202085494995, 0.007379647810012102, -0.018728181719779968, 0.07924242317676544, 0.004357882309705019, 0.023272106423974037, -0.02710568904876709, -0.01576279290020466, -0.029180334880948067, -0.019900808110833168, -0.004033719189465046, 0.04151545464992523, -0.021513167768716812, -0.008089988492429256, -0.014443589374423027, -0.01714964769780636, -0.017183473333716393, 0.04839335381984711, -0.06196874752640724, 0.009764362126588821, -0.005685542244464159, -0.0073007214814424515, -0.018310997635126114, 0.015526012517511845, -0.029270537197589874, -0.013237138278782368, -0.010897524654865265, -0.00647199060767889, -0.015593663789331913, -0.043793052434921265, 0.033104121685028076, 0.020543497055768967, -0.024174125865101814, -0.04920516908168793, -0.06620824337005615, -0.01567259058356285, -0.02674488164484501, -0.03612588718533516, 0.030803969129920006, -0.04253022372722626, -0.0031260617543011904, 0.03738871216773987, -0.03231485188007355, -0.03928295522928238, 0.020746450871229172, 0.07554414123296738, -0.004975202027708292, 0.008811604231595993, 0.033961039036512375, 0.014240634627640247, 0.018536502495408058, -0.02126511186361313, -0.03493070974946022, 0.02557225525379181, 0.017093271017074585, 0.015841718763113022, -0.05903718248009682, -0.0027398846577852964, 0.0027286093682050705, -0.02237008698284626, -0.03883194550871849, 0.04640891030430794, 0.013789624907076359, 0.02742139622569084, 0.026158569380640984, -0.0731537938117981, 0.046905018389225006, 0.01454506628215313, -0.00548540661111474, 0.05461728945374489, 0.046544212847948074, -0.025256549939513206, 0.03256290778517723, -0.06769657135009766, 0.029360737651586533, -0.010147720575332642, 0.01029993686825037, 0.04128994792699814, 0.014477415010333061, -0.016473133116960526, -0.013034183531999588, 0.0028399524744600058, 0.01022664736956358, -0.0509641095995903, -0.030803969129920006, 0.05763905495405197, -0.00685534905642271, -0.030871622264385223, -0.049340471625328064, -0.013022908009588718, 0.039440806955099106, -0.01296653226017952, 0.011478199623525143, -0.03608078509569168, 0.012087062932550907, -0.04359009861946106, -0.047310929745435715, -0.03466010466217995, -0.0014742383500561118, 0.005603796802461147, 0.01761193387210369, -0.017375152558088303, -0.056782133877277374, -0.01846885122358799, -0.040658533573150635, 0.004219760652631521, -0.02904503233730793, -0.010824235156178474, 0.013056733645498753, -0.033555131405591965, -0.009583958424627781, 0.041425250470638275, 0.014669094234704971, -0.03145793452858925, -0.003145793452858925, 0.026970386505126953, -0.029202885925769806, 0.05497809499502182, -0.024174125865101814, -0.005789838265627623, 0.00549668213352561, -0.014657818712294102, -0.009454293176531792, 0.01077913399785757, 0.021546993404626846, -0.018333548679947853, -0.0014150432543829083, -0.01959637552499771, 0.0032670022919774055, 0.023632913827896118, 0.0031429745722562075, 0.0020605509635061026, -0.026925286278128624, 0.03542682155966759, -0.03621608763933182, -0.018333548679947853, -0.03139028325676918, -0.06404339522123337, -0.023091701790690422, 0.053219158202409744, 0.004369157366454601, -0.07779919356107712, -0.02559480629861355, 0.06859859079122543, -0.00038934830809012055, -0.037027906626462936, -0.004473453387618065, -0.019585100933909416, -0.031638339161872864, 0.049340471625328064, -0.02143424190580845, 0.006522729527205229, -0.06453950703144073, -0.004121101927012205, -0.009657247923314571, 0.03188639506697655, 0.005096410866826773, 0.027782203629612923, -0.04431171342730522, 0.01099336426705122, 0.02320445515215397, 0.025662457570433617, -0.03292371705174446, -0.030758868902921677, 0.04839335381984711, 0.04162820428609848, -0.02784985490143299, -0.015176479704678059, 0.06557682901620865, 0.02191907726228237, 0.015999572351574898, -0.03062356635928154, -0.01705944538116455, -0.022381361573934555, 0.0017208843491971493, -0.05137001723051071, -0.014454863965511322, 0.005226076114922762, 0.029721546918153763, 0.011929209344089031, 0.008501535281538963, 0.0486188568174839, -0.029744096100330353, -0.004986477084457874, -0.04088404029607773, -0.010711482726037502, 0.027646901085972786, 0.032066795974969864, -0.009256976656615734, -0.010784772224724293, 0.038674090057611465, 0.0035798903554677963, -0.03380318358540535, -0.05191122740507126, 0.030894171446561813, -0.04041047766804695, 0.0033684794325381517, -0.009251338429749012, 0.03621608763933182, -0.002397398930042982, -0.008208378218114376, 0.006810247898101807, 0.053174056112766266, -0.02392606995999813, -0.0017321595223620534, -0.002418540185317397, 0.013676872476935387, -0.02234753593802452, -0.019483624026179314, 0.04514608159661293, -0.05069350078701973, 0.016236353665590286, -0.017363877967000008, 0.041154645383358, -0.011624777689576149, -0.020115038380026817, 0.04667951539158821, -0.004273317754268646, 0.02230243571102619, 0.0069850143045187, 0.0037997576873749495, -0.04672461748123169, -0.014398488216102123, 0.02098323218524456, -0.04523628205060959, -0.011839007027447224, 0.007272533141076565, -0.01731877587735653, -0.03571997582912445, 0.011201956309378147, -0.03459245339035988, 0.059127386659383774, -0.02217840775847435, 0.015830444172024727, -0.025301650166511536, -0.029924500733613968, -0.008287305012345314, 0.04174095764756203, -0.02318190410733223, -0.018750732764601707, 0.01200813613831997, -0.012301292270421982, -0.02352016232907772, 0.0550231970846653, -0.0206900741904974, 0.04681481793522835, 0.024444730952382088, -0.04843845218420029, -0.0023734390269964933, 0.03504346311092377, 0.06404339522123337, 0.0037095556035637856, -0.03382573649287224, 0.027985159307718277, -0.011218869127333164, -0.026113467290997505, -0.021896526217460632, -0.028052810579538345, 0.04007222130894661, -0.046160854399204254, 0.0004488957056310028, 0.017713410779833794, 0.016608435660600662, -0.022618141025304794, 0.02277599461376667, 0.0270831398665905, -0.028729325160384178, -0.03677985072135925, 0.02352016232907772, -0.02712824009358883, -0.0022522301878780127, -0.015469636768102646, -0.02303532510995865, -0.02559480629861355, -0.03017255663871765, 0.022144582122564316, 0.07274787873029709, 0.0022057199385017157, -0.012887605465948582, 0.009989866986870766, 0.016382930800318718, 0.012470421381294727, -0.007644616067409515, -0.011241419240832329, -0.003489688504487276, -0.01882965862751007, 0.009420467540621758, -0.029608793556690216, -0.08469964563846588, -0.019415972754359245, -0.03139028325676918, -0.030127454549074173, -0.03542682155966759, -0.03256290778517723, -0.03585527837276459, -0.010395776480436325, -0.0018153145210817456, -0.013270963914692402, -0.007627703249454498, 0.01315821148455143, 0.012436595745384693, -0.0027906231116503477, 0.0018322273390367627, -0.041898809373378754, -0.0027624350041151047, 0.052001431584358215, -0.0016955150058493018, -0.040658533573150635, -0.05506829917430878, -0.044559769332408905, 0.011106116697192192, 0.0032219013664871454, -0.0011282291961833835, 0.00266800494864583, 0.025346750393509865, 0.072928287088871, 0.0349758118391037, -0.018006566911935806, -0.017735959962010384, -0.024828089401125908, 0.029608793556690216, -0.0027849855832755566, -0.019540000706911087, 0.007340184412896633, -0.028954830020666122, -0.018006566911935806, 0.029338188469409943, -0.007723542861640453, -0.0006250714068301022, -0.03190894424915314, 0.04007222130894661, 0.02859402261674404, -0.0013671234482899308, 0.011545850895345211, -0.012323843315243721, 0.009691073559224606, 0.047265827655792236, -0.002810354810208082, 0.021017057821154594, 0.006804610602557659, -0.05448198318481445, 0.0027159247547388077, -0.03813287988305092, 0.008867979981005192, 0.03062356635928154, 0.014499965123832226, -0.04090658947825432, 0.015165205113589764, 0.015041177161037922, -0.006691858172416687, -0.009826376102864742, -0.019697854295372963, 0.017239850014448166, 0.014984800480306149, -0.009127311408519745, -0.03148048371076584, -0.049340471625328064, 0.021095983684062958, -0.008777778595685959, -0.01928067021071911, -0.03761421889066696, 0.03468265384435654, 0.017747236415743828, -0.018074218183755875, -0.0058687650598585606, 0.014556341804564, 0.02002483606338501, 0.06941040605306625, -0.011433098465204239, -0.029947051778435707, 0.0008435292984358966, -0.014116606675088406, 0.008659387938678265, 0.04631870612502098, 0.026474276557564735, 0.04045557975769043, 0.01567259058356285, 0.030443161725997925, 0.07730308175086975, -0.04239492118358612, 0.018987512215971947, 0.006302861962467432, -0.02232498489320278, -0.011579676531255245, -0.023768216371536255, 0.03659944608807564, 0.004481909796595573, 0.05763905495405197, 0.03323942422866821, -0.021501893177628517, 0.01607850007712841, -0.03964376077055931, 0.017003070563077927, 0.01672118902206421, -0.004276136867702007, 0.028819527477025986, -0.005017484072595835, -0.05290345102548599, -0.045394137501716614, 0.03659944608807564, 0.01897623762488365, -0.05263284593820572, -0.02358781360089779, -0.0036785488482564688, 0.015142654068768024, -0.029721546918153763, -0.007154142949730158, -0.01691286824643612, 0.007328909356147051, -0.013473917730152607, -0.03962121158838272, -0.011213230900466442, 0.05845087021589279, -0.016326555982232094, -0.017262401059269905, 0.03502091020345688, -0.021862700581550598, -0.06562192738056183, -0.008958182297647, -0.005479769315570593, 0.02179504930973053, -0.009730536490678787, 0.02433197945356369, -0.009025833569467068, -0.00714850565418601, -0.02899993024766445, 0.05696253851056099, -0.07757368683815002, 0.02356526255607605, -0.02439963072538376, -0.0008914490463212132, -0.0014375937171280384, -0.012323843315243721, 0.04672461748123169, -0.004527010954916477, -0.0005461446708068252, 0.0008343681693077087, -0.011478199623525143, 0.023249555379152298, -0.03486305847764015, 0.04133505001664162, -0.02352016232907772, 0.010841147974133492, -0.001937932800501585, -0.009364090859889984, -0.055609509348869324, 0.03021765686571598, 0.017217298969626427, 0.02394862100481987, -0.003281096462160349, -0.007441661786288023, -0.028007708489894867, 0.006235210690647364, 0.04000457003712654, -0.012921431101858616, 0.02292257361114025, -0.021862700581550598, -0.010457789525389671, -0.005017484072595835, -0.04313908889889717, 0.04462742060422897, -0.008591736666858196, 0.00714850565418601, -0.016585886478424072, -0.027015486732125282, -0.03062356635928154, 0.03254035860300064, 0.020036110654473305, 0.026429174467921257, -0.023655464872717857, 0.018728181719779968, 0.02284364588558674, -0.03461500257253647, 0.016552060842514038, 0.0010408461093902588, -0.00903147179633379, -0.010350675322115421, 0.017972741276025772, 0.011348534375429153, 0.02990194968879223, 0.007097766734659672, 0.035832729190588, 0.014082781039178371, 0.021107258275151253, -0.03249525651335716, 0.06923000514507294, -0.0016898773610591888, 0.014567616395652294, 0.0016673268983140588, -0.01136544719338417, -0.0306010153144598, 0.0086368378251791, -0.004794797860085964, -0.01751045510172844, -0.06201384961605072, -0.05795476213097572, -0.01921301707625389, 0.018356099724769592, 0.045416686683893204, -0.0024622317869216204, 0.0354042686522007, 0.0069850143045187, -0.05105431005358696, -0.054166279733181, 0.025188898667693138, -0.02174994722008705, -0.02361036278307438, 0.01010825764387846, -0.0006250714068301022, 0.016585886478424072, 0.006009705830365419, 0.029924500733613968, -0.008490259759128094, 0.012481696903705597, -0.00019555503968149424, -0.038651540875434875, 0.041898809373378754, 0.014443589374423027, 0.02674488164484501, -0.025279099121689796, 0.03208934888243675, -0.03341982513666153, 0.00022832371178083122, -0.003932241816073656, 0.01667608693242073, 0.024061372503638268, -0.010339399799704552, -0.019246842712163925, 0.01435338705778122, -0.018559053540229797, -0.008276030421257019, 0.025008494034409523, -0.002104242565110326, -0.014793121255934238, -0.014770571142435074, -0.05723314359784126, 0.0184463020414114, 0.012357668951153755, -0.0186605304479599, -0.0259105134755373, 0.05141511932015419, -0.028052810579538345, -0.017239850014448166, 0.031277529895305634, 0.011297795921564102, -0.01889731176197529, 0.011450011283159256, -0.02000228501856327, -0.034795407205820084, -0.045754946768283844, 0.0024171306286007166, -0.022279884666204453, -0.029766647145152092, 0.01493970025330782, 0.0024805539287626743, -0.013992579653859138, -0.0025031045079231262, -0.020487120375037193, 0.027308644726872444, -0.04762663692235947, 0.0028921004850417376, -0.0286842230707407, -0.02160337008535862, -0.023407408967614174, 0.0041577466763556, 0.03998202085494995, 0.00007980759255588055, 0.010835510678589344, 0.003751837881281972, 0.008681938983500004, -0.03172853961586952, -0.039102550595998764, 0.03193149343132973, 0.013958754017949104, -0.025301650166511536, -0.0010246379533782601, -0.038290731608867645, -0.0009499394218437374, -0.021569544449448586, -0.001802629791200161, -0.0015094734262675047, -0.018559053540229797, -0.012143438681960106, -0.0133273396641016, 0.029924500733613968, 0.010711482726037502, 0.051640622317790985, -0.010260473005473614, 0.0006860282155685127, -0.0038279457949101925, -0.002594715915620327, -0.003951973281800747, 0.05606051906943321, -0.0037264686543494463, -0.00793213490396738, -0.028030259534716606, -0.03698280453681946, -0.04753643274307251, -0.026226220652461052, -0.02241518720984459, 0.03414144366979599, -0.020520946010947227, -0.000712806882802397, 0.028165562078356743, -0.01784871332347393, -0.00039111007936298847, -0.01767958514392376, -0.016946693882346153, -0.026181118562817574, 0.004267680458724499, -0.007379647810012102, -0.03416399285197258, 0.008811604231595993, -0.0031316992826759815, 0.027240991592407227, -0.017882538959383965, -0.027737103402614594, -0.03405123949050903, -0.056376226246356964, -0.029744096100330353, -0.024061372503638268, -0.007712267804890871, 0.02322700433433056, 0.020757727324962616, -0.0004594662459567189, -0.002817401895299554, 0.0025129702407866716, 0.03229230269789696, -0.05213673412799835, -0.015706416219472885, -0.017950190231204033, -0.020780276507139206, -0.018750732764601707, 0.026835083961486816, 0.0002075349766528234, 0.033555131405591965, -0.001978805521503091, 0.02100578136742115, 0.024670235812664032, -0.012729751877486706, -0.001125410431995988, 0.003123242873698473, -0.03783972188830376, -0.04083893820643425, 0.0008569186320528388, -0.05899208411574364, -0.030014703050255775, -0.008360594511032104, -0.008473346941173077, 0.04636380821466446, -0.021975452080368996, -0.024873191490769386, 0.00900892075151205, 0.004033719189465046, 0.021039607003331184, 0.01672118902206421, -0.0025975345633924007, 0.003785663517192006, 0.02478298917412758, 0.011404910124838352, -0.025436952710151672, 0.00876650307327509, -0.0017011526506394148, 0.043364591896533966, -0.01714964769780636, 0.03256290778517723, -0.013857276178896427, -0.03684750199317932, 0.010587455704808235, 0.014962250366806984, -0.0025101513601839542, -0.03213444724678993, 0.008856705389916897, 0.008084351196885109, -0.024647686630487442, 0.013575395569205284, 0.02117491140961647, -0.03889959678053856, -0.009719260968267918, 0.044988229870796204, -0.0010084297973662615, -0.011726254597306252, 0.016608435660600662, -0.042620427906513214, -0.002085920423269272, 0.038741741329431534, -0.00121561239939183, -0.010852423496544361, -0.04352244734764099, -0.005164062138646841, -0.055925216525793076, -0.0006670012371614575, 0.013654322363436222, -0.03571997582912445, -0.03768187016248703, 0.014184258878231049, -0.03172853961586952, -0.03371298313140869, 0.00667494535446167, -0.005992793012410402, 0.005071041639894247, -0.027308644726872444, -0.02062242291867733, 0.0035714339464902878, -0.025797760114073753, -0.014860773459076881, 0.00269760238006711, 0.01868308149278164, -0.030939273536205292, 0.01959637552499771, 0.034795407205820084, 0.006302861962467432, -0.00201826891861856, 0.014015129767358303, 0.020126312971115112, 0.025053594261407852, -0.00920059997588396, -0.03190894424915314, -0.001654642284847796, 0.006686220411211252, 0.010649468749761581, -0.013237138278782368, 0.02017141319811344, -0.029631344601511955, 0.038358382880687714, -0.004828623961657286, -0.0059476918540894985, 0.01731877587735653, 0.05926268920302391, 0.04079383611679077, 0.0008942678687162697, 0.018130594864487648, -0.022809820249676704, -0.039869267493486404, -0.010452152229845524, 0.023768216371536255, 0.014454863965511322, -0.017984015867114067, -0.011681154370307922, -0.013755799271166325, 0.03405123949050903, 0.016179976984858513, 0.024512382224202156, -0.025053594261407852, 0.05150531977415085, -0.02832341566681862, 0.016766289249062538, 0.039125099778175354, -0.005750374868512154, 0.006827161181718111, 0.038741741329431534, -0.027150791138410568, -0.01509755291044712, 0.012290017679333687, -0.06129223480820656, -0.027646901085972786, 0.005958966910839081, -0.015413260087370872, -0.00795468594878912, 0.027624350041151047, 0.002273371210321784, -0.019968459382653236, -0.008935632184147835, 0.035539571195840836, -0.02217840775847435, -0.06810247898101807, -0.017307501286268234, 0.048077646642923355, 0.016833940520882607, 0.024038823321461678, -0.022663243114948273, 0.03136773034930229, 0.04469507187604904, 0.02019396424293518, -0.0030020340345799923, -0.011951759457588196, -0.03763676807284355, -0.024895740672945976, 0.04090658947825432, 0.0386064387857914, -0.0503326952457428, -0.032382503151893616, -0.039801616221666336, -0.009144224226474762, 0.0056235287338495255, -0.01959637552499771, -0.001209974754601717, -0.004380432888865471, -0.024174125865101814, 0.00324163306504488, -0.016687363386154175, -0.007063941098749638, 0.009910940192639828, -0.002777938498184085, -0.0034868696238845587, -0.028075359761714935, 0.0038053952157497406, 0.0011380950454622507, 0.02627132087945938, -0.011038465425372124, 0.027601800858974457, 0.013462643139064312, 0.02627132087945938, -0.04431171342730522, -0.012707201763987541, -0.017995290458202362, -0.0100236926227808, 0.015469636768102646, -0.039125099778175354, 0.02949604205787182, 0.038358382880687714, 0.034795407205820084, -0.014218084514141083, -0.01010825764387846, 0.0029794834554195404, 0.024129025638103485, 0.0020661887247115374, -0.012244916521012783, -0.0026059909723699093, -0.020013559609651566, -0.008101264014840126, 0.01429701130837202, -0.01180518139153719, -0.019607651978731155, 0.03267566114664078, -0.02703803777694702, 0.03894469514489174, -0.007712267804890871, 0.01928067021071911, -0.0458451472222805, -0.017905090004205704, -0.036373939365148544, 0.060976527631282806, -0.016179976984858513, -0.05939799174666405, -0.02318190410733223, 0.03765931725502014, 0.015187755227088928, 0.030398061498999596, -0.007712267804890871, -0.028887178748846054, -0.006686220411211252, 0.029586242511868477, -0.006218297872692347, 0.006212660111486912, 0.007554414216428995, 0.0003780730767175555, 0.019156642258167267, 0.012459145858883858, -0.0014728289097547531, 0.033938489854335785, -0.0027398846577852964, 0.00260740052908659, -0.021422965452075005, 0.04667951539158821, 0.03220209851861, 0.009172411635518074, 0.0007490991265513003, -0.023429960012435913, 0.018773283809423447, -0.0033233785070478916, -0.0021126989740878344, -0.0034727754537016153, 0.0036080784630030394, -0.015706416219472885, -0.007808107417076826, -0.011230144649744034, -0.05024249106645584, 0.004225397948175669, 0.016811391338706017, -0.028526369482278824, -0.008834154345095158, -0.0119404848664999, -0.0009182277717627585, 0.0019590738229453564, 0.014037679880857468, 0.04952087625861168, -0.03287861496210098, -0.024467281997203827, 0.011021552607417107, -0.009623421356081963, -0.011827732436358929, 0.006488903425633907, 0.047716837376356125, 0.01949489861726761, 0.03621608763933182, -0.005654535256326199, -0.06431400030851364, -0.00548540661111474, -0.007424748968333006, -0.03362278267741203, 0.00875522755086422, -0.016597161069512367, -0.00983201339840889, 0.043432243168354034, 0.011737530119717121, -0.003190894378349185, 0.05236223712563515, -0.006939913611859083, -0.007571327034384012, 0.03447970002889633, 0.004828623961657286, 0.013834726065397263, 0.007949047721922398, 0.015537288039922714, -0.011850282549858093, -0.008174552582204342, 0.012594449333846569, -0.007452937308698893, -0.007030115462839603, -0.02433197945356369, 0.026136018335819244, -0.05155042186379433, 0.019348321482539177, 0.03308156877756119, -0.0066580320708453655, 0.019528724253177643, 0.011703704483807087, 0.026587028056383133, 0.006624206434935331, 0.009245701134204865, -0.0030189468525350094, -0.03254035860300064, 0.0030443163122981787, 0.031638339161872864, -0.01510882843285799, 0.01722857542335987, -0.038651540875434875, -0.010339399799704552, 0.02945093996822834, 0.004820167552679777, -0.004543923772871494, 0.02667723037302494, -0.02023906446993351, -0.020227789878845215, -0.03571997582912445, -0.05610562115907669, 0.024422181770205498, 0.009662885218858719, -0.02243773825466633, 0.03698280453681946, -0.013428817503154278, 0.014172983355820179, -0.00016956911713350564, 0.023768216371536255, 0.015368158929049969, -0.00933026522397995, -0.0015010170172899961, 0.014499965123832226, 0.004400164354592562, 0.0015489368233829737, -0.04762663692235947, -0.03096182271838188, -0.001374875195324421, 0.010677657090127468, -0.04275573045015335, 0.013631771318614483, 0.015785343945026398, 0.06602783501148224, 0.05497809499502182, -0.007723542861640453, -0.028954830020666122, 0.016552060842514038, 0.015165205113589764, -0.048528656363487244, -0.08447413891553879, -0.0005123189766891301, -0.046183403581380844, -0.04318419098854065, 0.026158569380640984, 0.007599515374749899, 0.006742596626281738, 0.021783772855997086, -0.04640891030430794, -0.009747449308633804, -0.0286842230707407, 0.00558688398450613, 0.023768216371536255, 0.029157783836126328, 0.0479874424636364, 0.025346750393509865, 0.047716837376356125, 0.002928745001554489, -0.012436595745384693, -0.03761421889066696, -0.02232498489320278, -0.020701350644230843, -0.01334989070892334, 0.052452441304922104, -0.018547778949141502, 0.0077968318946659565, 0.032405056059360504, -0.004070363473147154, -0.007982873357832432, -0.000960509933065623, 0.011444373987615108, -0.0035629775375127792, 0.026587028056383133, -0.03136773034930229, -0.005242988932877779, 0.019201742485165596, -0.03407379239797592, 0.011433098465204239, 0.017431529238820076, -0.004033719189465046, 0.0279400572180748, -0.006060444284230471, -0.016134876757860184, -0.03445715084671974, 0.0028808251954615116, 0.006849711295217276, 0.014094056561589241, -0.004504460375756025, 0.0035686150658875704, -0.006900450214743614, 0.009285164065659046, -0.008230929262936115, -0.008929993957281113, -0.020757727324962616, 0.019731679931282997, -0.013372440822422504, 0.00377438822761178, 0.03495325893163681, 0.02507614530622959, -0.00032257771817967296, 0.00580675108358264, 0.02902248129248619, -0.04117719456553459, -0.04083893820643425, 0.019179191440343857, -0.004061907064169645, -0.007543139159679413, 0.02394862100481987, -0.002335385186597705, -0.006584743037819862, -0.011737530119717121, 0.006020980887115002, -0.0006867328775115311, -0.0037321061827242374, -0.015526012517511845, 0.027759654447436333, -0.00007126307173166424, 0.008225291036069393, -0.0033402913250029087, -0.007114679552614689, -0.03026275895535946, -0.04034282639622688, -0.029247986152768135, 0.007041390519589186, 0.001870281295850873, 0.01629272848367691, -0.008851067163050175, 0.019325770437717438, 0.01846885122358799, 0.0005239465390332043, -0.018006566911935806, 0.021569544449448586, 0.00309505476616323, -0.007323271594941616, -0.005211981944739819, -0.01334989070892334, 0.023429960012435913, 0.002968208398669958, 0.01155712641775608, -0.016957968473434448, -0.004631306976079941, -0.0062577612698078156, 0.03098437376320362, 0.019912082701921463, 0.02629387192428112, -0.014432313852012157, -0.017093271017074585, -0.024467281997203827, -0.01040705107152462, 0.007069578859955072, -0.02550460398197174, -0.008163277991116047, 0.013755799271166325, -0.0005095001542940736, -0.013846000656485558, -0.011793906800448895, -0.0251663476228714, -0.012053237296640873, 0.013485193252563477, -0.032066795974969864, 0.025256549939513206, 0.0001983738475246355, 0.02469278685748577, -0.013575395569205284, -0.008039250038564205, -0.02624877169728279, -0.013372440822422504, -0.0015686685219407082, 0.025188898667693138, 0.025775210931897163, 0.025436952710151672, 0.04749133437871933, 0.02100578136742115, -0.004360700957477093, 0.0031768004409968853, 0.02315935306251049, -0.0381779819726944, -0.01607850007712841, -0.011771355755627155, 0.0002274428406963125, 0.028481269255280495, 0.0026835084427148104, -0.02863912284374237, 0.02002483606338501, -0.006353600881993771, -0.013767074793577194, -0.024196676909923553, 0.026857635006308556, -0.009600871242582798, 0.015052452683448792, 0.04988168552517891, -0.010959538631141186, -0.033104121685028076, -0.037501465529203415, -0.02191907726228237, -0.015999572351574898, 0.01149511244148016, 0.017352601513266563, 0.023317206650972366, -0.008715764619410038, -0.000015437395632034168, 0.019246842712163925, -0.004267680458724499, 0.023858418688178062, 0.05371527001261711, -0.011455649510025978, 0.007255620323121548, 0.00222545163705945, -0.012165989726781845, 0.010897524654865265, 0.020520946010947227, 0.01435338705778122, -0.026925286278128624, 0.014026405289769173, -0.005358560476452112, 0.0040957327000796795, 0.0238809697329998, 0.0033797547221183777, -0.004202847834676504, 0.014522516168653965, -0.014872048050165176, -0.01904388889670372, -0.026992937549948692, 0.012267466634511948, -0.039463359862565994, -0.004924463573843241, -0.006133733317255974, 0.032405056059360504, 0.004636944737285376, -0.021400416269898415, 0.04016242176294327, 0.014838222414255142, 0.027398845180869102, 0.0012501428136602044, 0.0024791446048766375, 0.021738672628998756, -0.021017057821154594, 0.014026405289769173, 0.005558696109801531, -0.032450154423713684, -0.0004228217003401369, 0.0033121032174676657, -0.006962463725358248, -0.01693541742861271, 0.00461157551035285, 0.019912082701921463, -0.01590937189757824, 0.018649255856871605, 0.02437707968056202, 0.014015129767358303, 0.016811391338706017, 0.02821066416800022, -0.015447085723280907, 0.0377495214343071, 0.0027751196175813675, -0.031164778396487236, -0.0027553881518542767, -0.0040421755984425545, 0.021445516496896744, 0.046905018389225006, -0.011106116697192192, 0.021490616723895073, 0.01219981536269188, -0.04282338172197342, 0.010232284665107727, 0.04108699411153793, -0.013225862756371498, -0.0032444517128169537, 0.006094269920140505, -0.010570541955530643, -0.013056733645498753, 0.0031655251514166594, -0.015841718763113022, 0.013891101814806461, -0.03734361380338669, 0.008168915286660194, 0.003207807196304202, -0.013755799271166325, -0.03811032697558403, 0.04645400866866112, 0.0010211144108325243, 0.01878455840051174, 0.046160854399204254, 0.00648326613008976, 0.014612717553973198, 0.005003389902412891, -0.012684650719165802, -0.012256191112101078, 0.01595447212457657, 0.011517662554979324, 0.013597945682704449, 0.011044102720916271, -0.04165075719356537, -0.012616999447345734, -0.0026905552949756384, 0.01532305870205164, -0.03802012652158737, -0.010142083279788494, 0.02262941747903824, 0.01823207177221775, 0.04110954329371452, 0.030826520174741745, 0.0041380152106285095, -0.0036475418601185083, 0.004837080370634794, 0.03287861496210098, 0.017262401059269905, 0.014984800480306149, 0.007576964795589447, -0.024106474593281746, 0.02181760035455227, 0.0341188907623291, 0.016709912568330765, -0.005034396890550852, -0.03680239990353584, -0.008992007933557034, -0.016608435660600662, -0.021614644676446915, 0.018773283809423447, -0.009657247923314571, -0.0388093926012516, 0.0239937212318182, 0.021208737045526505, 0.019652752205729485, 0.0018900129944086075, -0.000585255678743124, -0.01372197363525629, -0.038358382880687714, 0.004417077172547579, -0.005919503513723612, 0.014477415010333061, 0.01176008116453886, 0.014375938102602959, -0.001711018499918282, 0.029202885925769806, -0.022043105214834213, 0.026226220652461052, -0.020938130095601082, -0.04866395890712738, 0.008484622463583946, -0.013440092094242573, -0.020160138607025146, -0.02356526255607605, -0.013361165300011635, 0.006889174692332745, 0.020036110654473305, -0.00945993047207594, -0.020250340923666954, -0.018863486126065254, -0.005564333405345678, 0.0071654184721410275, 0.012053237296640873, -0.02311425283551216, -0.015582389198243618, 0.052001431584358215, -0.017476629465818405, 0.005491044372320175, 0.02940583974123001, 0.00393506046384573, 0.004456540569663048, -0.009781274944543839, -0.011393635533750057, 0.04758153483271599, 0.0002670823596417904, -0.03427674621343613, -0.05227203667163849, 0.03851623833179474, -0.004614394158124924, 0.0008075894438661635, 0.03366788104176521, 0.017950190231204033, -0.011861558072268963, 0.0004696844262070954, 0.011021552607417107, -0.04311653599143028, 0.0016222258564084768, 0.0024692786391824484, 0.025008494034409523, -0.006550917401909828, -0.01130343321710825, -0.006488903425633907, -0.043747950345277786, 0.01944979839026928, 0.002061960520222783, -0.010102619417011738, 0.05727824568748474, 0.05303875356912613, -0.026496825739741325, -0.009482481516897678, 0.017747236415743828, -0.02062242291867733, -0.004208485130220652, 0.026136018335819244, -0.0000794552470324561, -0.0005884268321096897, -0.006466353312134743, 0.04253022372722626, 0.020182689651846886, 0.015999572351574898, 0.0139136528596282, 0.007531863637268543, -0.04476272314786911, -0.007706630043685436, 0.009178049862384796, -0.020115038380026817, 0.014477415010333061, -0.0016800115117803216, -0.0027342468965798616, -0.041898809373378754, 0.00824220385402441, 0.03955356031656265, -0.021095983684062958, 0.006556555163115263, 0.02509869635105133, -0.011450011283159256, 0.03341982513666153, 0.0119968606159091, 0.011134305037558079, 0.05100920796394348, 0.061066728085279465, -0.02545950375497341, -0.019156642258167267, 0.029563693329691887, 0.00022110050485935062, -0.012177265249192715, 0.02789495699107647, -0.009685435332357883, 0.024489833042025566, 0.006336687598377466, 0.004005530849099159, 0.0068327984772622585, -0.0022085385862737894, 0.03256290778517723, 0.030330410227179527, -0.02514379657804966, 0.021287662908434868, 0.004704596009105444, -0.007520588580518961, -0.0038166705053299665, -0.009335903450846672, -0.01624762825667858, 0.025617357343435287, 0.01003496814519167, 0.0055417828261852264, -0.0028582746163010597, -0.0058687650598585606, 0.011737530119717121, 0.0011740349000319839, -0.019348321482539177, -0.015075002796947956, -0.005192250479012728, -0.004397345706820488, 0.04099678993225098, 0.021998003125190735, -0.021885251626372337, 0.032810963690280914, -0.0029202885925769806, 0.024061372503638268, -0.0068722618743777275, -0.04843845218420029, -0.004115464631468058, -0.0060829948633909225, -0.0083154933527112, -0.012132164090871811, 0.021873975172638893, 0.015447085723280907, -0.018367374315857887, 0.014139157719910145, -0.002556661842390895, -0.019945908337831497, 0.015537288039922714, -0.010102619417011738, 0.024512382224202156, -0.020994506776332855, 0.010711482726037502, 0.006838436238467693, 0.011134305037558079, -0.0024805539287626743, -0.020949404686689377, 0.05308385565876961, 0.02390351891517639, -0.0015996753936633468, 0.023384857922792435, -0.003949154634028673, 0.021062158048152924, -0.0018857847899198532, 0.008016698993742466, 0.0007667166646569967, -0.002147934166714549, 0.011106116697192192, 0.024512382224202156, -0.0381779819726944, 0.005104867275804281, 0.009662885218858719, 0.03526896610856056, 0.02712824009358883, 0.014567616395652294, 0.0034586815163493156, -0.0035911656450480223, 0.013958754017949104, 0.002761025680229068, 0.03898979723453522, -0.03687005117535591, 0.0368926040828228, 0.01492842473089695, 0.0239937212318182, -0.021332763135433197, 0.02174994722008705, 0.0172736756503582, -0.0045805685222148895, -0.019844431430101395, 0.016371656209230423, -0.005350104067474604, 0.0092231510207057, 0.023407408967614174, -0.009989866986870766, -0.013902377337217331, 0.01968657784163952, 0.05466238781809807, 0.009606508538126945, 0.02066752500832081, -0.02784985490143299, 0.030781419947743416, 0.03813287988305092, 0.012673375196754932, 0.013947478495538235, -0.003994255792349577, 0.0012346393195912242, 0.02940583974123001, 0.0050062090158462524, -0.028954830020666122, -0.009375366382300854, -0.00638178875669837, -0.016800114884972572, -0.009381003677845001, 0.01684521697461605, -0.008197103627026081, 0.013676872476935387, -0.011117392219603062, 0.0007152733742259443, -0.0007413473795168102, 0.01313566043972969, 0.005606615450233221, 0.0077573684975504875, 0.04077128693461418, 0.016518233343958855, 0.026451725512742996, -0.013631771318614483, -0.0025200173258781433, -0.04780703783035278, -0.03576507791876793, 0.008681938983500004, 0.0019745773170143366, 0.02554970607161522, -0.002985121216624975, 0.03064611740410328, 0.0012430957285687327, -0.002073235809803009, -0.02279854565858841, 0.003134518163278699, 0.02430942840874195, 0.008338043466210365, -0.007520588580518961, 0.00629158690571785, -0.002815992571413517, -0.04004967212677002, 0.010649468749761581, 0.011974310502409935, 0.020103761926293373, -0.01878455840051174, 0.024422181770205498, -0.0027243811637163162, -0.02220095694065094, -0.03621608763933182, 0.01296653226017952, 0.02145679108798504, 0.006325412541627884, 0.018457576632499695, -0.020351817831397057 ]
11.55918
4.686302
2024-06-01
0
2024MNRAS.531...52M
[ "deep learning models", "machine learning models", "biased models", "biased galaxy data", "biased data", "biases", "models", "Most galaxy morphology catalogues", "physical properties", "a de-biased model" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
10
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1088", "10.48550/arXiv.2308.11007" ]
[ "Medina-Rosales, Esteban", "Cabrera-Vives, Guillermo", "Miller, Christopher J." ]
[ "Department of Computer Science, Universidad de Concepción, Edmundo Larenas 219, 4070409, Concepción, Chile; Data Science Unit, Universidad de Concepción, Edmundo Larenas 310, 4070415, Concepción, Chile;", "Department of Computer Science, Universidad de Concepción, Edmundo Larenas 219, 4070409, Concepción, Chile; Data Science Unit, Universidad de Concepción, Edmundo Larenas 310, 4070415, Concepción, Chile; Millennium Nucleus on Young Exoplanets and their Moons (YEMS), Chile; Millenium Institute of Astrophysics (MAS), Av. Vicuña Mackenna 4860, 8331150, Macul, Santiago, Chile;", "Department of Astronomy and Department of Physics, University of Michigan, 1085 S. University, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA;" ]
null
[ "1926ApJ....64..321H", "1959HDP....53..275D", "1968adga.book.....S", "1980ApJ...236..351D", "2005ApJ...625..621B", "2007AJ....134..579F", "2007MNRAS.382.1415S", "2008MNRAS.389.1179L", "2009MNRAS.393.1324B", "2010ApJS..186..427N", "2010arXiv1005.0390G", "2011A&A...525A.157H", "2011ApJS..196...11S", "2011MNRAS.410..166L", "2013ApJ...774...47L", "2013MNRAS.435.2835W", "2015ApJ...809...95H", "2015ApJS..221...11K", "2015MNRAS.450.1441D", "2015MNRAS.454.1886S", "2016MNRAS.461.3663H", "2017MNRAS.464.4176W", "2017MNRAS.464.4420S", "2018AJ....156..284C", "2019Ap&SS.364...55Z" ]
29071518
2309.01443
THE THREE HUNDRED: Contrasting cluster galaxy density in hydrodynamical and dark matter simulations
Cluster number counts at visible and IR wavelengths will be a key cosmological probe in the next decade thanks to the Euclid satellite mission. For this purpose, the performance of cluster detection algorithms, which at these wavelengths are sensitive to the spatial distributions of the cluster galaxy members and their luminosity functions, need to be accurately characterized. Using THE THREE HUNDRED hydrodynamical and dark-matter-only simulations, we studied a complete sample of massive clusters beyond 7 (5) × 10<SUP>14</SUP> M<SUB>⊙</SUB> at redshift 0 (1) on a (1.48 Gpc)<SUP>3</SUP> volume. We find that the mass resolution of the current hydrodynamical simulations (1.5 × 10<SUP>9</SUP> M<SUB>⊙</SUB>) is not enough to characterize the luminosity function of the sample in the perspective of Euclid data. Nevertheless, these simulations are still useful to characterize the spatial distribution of the cluster substructures assuming a common relative mass threshold for the different flavours and resolutions. By comparing with the dark-matter-only version of these simulations, we demonstrate that baryonic physics preserves significantly low-mass subhalos (galaxies), as has also been observed in previous studies with less statistics. Furthermore, by comparing the hydro simulations with higher resolution dark-matter-only simulations of the same objects and taking the same limit in subhalo mass, we find galaxy density profiles that are significantly more cuspy towards the centre of the clusters, where the low-mass substructures tend to concentrate. We conclude that using a dark-matter-only simulation may lead to some biases on the spatial distribution and density of galaxy cluster members. Based on the preliminary analysis of few high-resolution hydro simulations we conclude that a mass resolution of 1.8 × 10<SUP>8</SUP>h<SUP>−1</SUP> M<SUB>⊙</SUB> will be needed for THE THREE HUNDRED simulations to approach the expected magnitude limits for the Euclid survey. These simulations are currently under way.
[ 0.01786784641444683, 0.014986751601099968, 0.029695503413677216, -0.0009137685410678387, 0.02290976420044899, 0.015820752829313278, -0.009287741966545582, 0.018032120540738106, 0.011214790865778923, 0.03823769837617874, -0.004962939769029617, -0.01120215468108654, -0.07435248047113419, -0.030200958251953125, 0.025576042011380196, 0.055751726031303406, -0.014873024076223373, 0.017766756936907768, -0.019599031656980515, 0.020470941439270973, 0.010216516442596912, -0.01889139413833618, 0.010791472159326077, -0.02157030813395977, -0.049964264035224915, -0.009053968824446201, 0.0234152190387249, 0.0016379912849515676, 0.051581721752882004, -0.018246939405798912, 0.032601870596408844, -0.014809842221438885, -0.021582944318652153, -0.014721387065947056, -0.06611356139183044, 0.05175862833857536, -0.01856284774839878, 0.03151514008641243, -0.026359496638178825, 0.01958639547228813, -0.009913243353366852, 0.013432476669549942, -0.03662024065852165, -0.013242930173873901, -0.03295569121837616, -0.039551883935928345, -0.029139501973986626, -0.023301491513848305, 0.008093603886663914, 0.0038098697550594807, -0.03123714216053486, 0.03826297074556351, -0.014089568518102169, -0.0057527138851583, -0.039728790521621704, -0.0170843917876482, 0.004144733771681786, 0.0031006527133286, -0.003721415065228939, 0.016326207667589188, -0.00398993818089366, -0.009256151504814625, 0.020167669281363487, -0.020331941545009613, -0.015985025092959404, 0.02878568321466446, 0.026814406737685204, 0.0026678566355258226, 0.025234859436750412, 0.04152315855026245, -0.012990202754735947, -0.012617429718375206, -0.001821218873374164, -0.013748385943472385, 0.012598474510014057, -0.00350659666582942, -0.0033675963059067726, 0.002562026958912611, -0.06303028017282486, 0.04523825645446777, -0.014734024181962013, 0.011701291427016258, 0.006722556427121162, -0.0007645012228749692, -0.0037845971528440714, -0.016578935086727142, -0.014329659752547741, -0.02323831059038639, -0.06560810655355453, 0.01422856841236353, 0.015429024584591389, -0.018348028883337975, 0.00874437764286995, -0.02600567787885666, -0.03803551569581032, -0.05489245429635048, 0.037555333226919174, -0.02092585153877735, 0.01166338287293911, 0.033713873475790024, -0.0005935151712037623, 0.03169205039739609, 0.014443387277424335, -0.05565063655376434, 0.045187707990407944, -0.016073480248451233, -0.02272021770477295, -0.0004067336267326027, 0.02939222939312458, 0.05640881881117821, 0.012630065903067589, 0.015719661489129066, -0.039324428886175156, -0.0143043864518404, -0.0216208528727293, -0.004049960989505053, -0.038995880633592606, 0.026132041588425636, -0.06606301665306091, 0.02568976953625679, -0.021140670403838158, 0.0237437654286623, 0.018221665173768997, 0.01731184683740139, 0.030302049592137337, -0.0460217110812664, 0.05650990828871727, -0.04154843091964722, -0.0320458710193634, 0.05863282084465027, 0.021140670403838158, -0.0096036521717906, -0.006735192611813545, 0.005026121623814106, -0.015669116750359535, -0.010747244581580162, -0.009483606554567814, -0.019510576501488686, 0.019194668158888817, -0.031590960919857025, 0.011789746582508087, 0.014140114188194275, 0.013609386049211025, 0.0517333559691906, 0.00867487769573927, 0.04013315588235855, -0.02050885185599327, 0.02184830792248249, -0.014127477072179317, 0.016856936737895012, 0.0027452544309198856, -0.018272211775183678, -0.01651575416326523, -0.06434446573257446, -0.005143008194863796, -0.03161623328924179, 0.014127477072179317, 0.03169205039739609, -0.022416945546865463, -0.026233132928609848, -0.028482409194111824, 0.0017848892603069544, -0.05661100149154663, 0.0031875278800725937, -0.026738589629530907, 0.004296370781958103, -0.027193497866392136, 0.004432211630046368, -0.09871543198823929, 0.009717379696667194, -0.007385966368019581, 0.018310120329260826, 0.006526692304760218, -0.03394132852554321, 0.008194695226848125, 0.0418517030775547, 0.014354932121932507, -0.02989768423140049, -0.027319861575961113, 0.008725423365831375, 0.011600201018154621, 0.02916477434337139, 0.02800222672522068, -0.033385325223207474, -0.06934847682714462, -0.012674293480813503, -0.02207576297223568, 0.03396660089492798, -0.015151024796068668, -0.022252673283219337, 0.003585573984310031, 0.003952029161155224, 0.005348349455744028, 0.038338787853717804, -0.009433060884475708, -0.028356045484542847, 0.0015100479358807206, 0.04134624823927879, -0.008295786567032337, 0.008940241299569607, 0.03763115033507347, 0.031262412667274475, 0.056863728910684586, -0.04437898099422455, -0.02018030546605587, -0.047234803438186646, 0.04804353415966034, -0.007316466420888901, -0.0055884406901896, 0.005228303838521242, -0.0029948230367153883, -0.003285459941253066, 0.003064323216676712, 0.017463482916355133, -0.05600445345044136, 0.012680611573159695, -0.03333478048443794, 0.012832247652113438, 0.046855710446834564, 0.07010665535926819, -0.008529559709131718, 0.04915553331375122, 0.03624115139245987, 0.0029521752148866653, -0.008087285794317722, -0.022088399156928062, 0.025449678301811218, -0.035887330770492554, 0.008017785847187042, 0.008276831358671188, 0.05148062855005264, 0.010248107835650444, -0.03548296540975571, 0.029139501973986626, -0.02007921412587166, -0.006112850736826658, 0.03975406289100647, 0.013230293989181519, -0.005152485799044371, -0.03444678336381912, -0.027648407965898514, -0.0028653000481426716, -0.018348028883337975, -0.02517167665064335, -0.005765350069850683, 0.004280575085431337, -0.037833333015441895, 0.003042209427803755, 0.020483579486608505, -0.015985025092959404, 0.036165330559015274, -0.018992485478520393, -0.018777666613459587, -0.05863282084465027, -0.040840793401002884, 0.021128034219145775, -0.0029521752148866653, 0.038338787853717804, -0.01670530065894127, 0.008226285688579082, -0.040992431342601776, -0.023301491513848305, -0.030150411650538445, -0.0018670257413759828, -0.026688043028116226, 0.023579493165016174, 0.009199287742376328, 0.026359496638178825, -0.06869138032197952, 0.024514585733413696, -0.0153658427298069, -0.011145290918648243, 0.06186773627996445, -0.011960337869822979, -0.07040993124246597, 0.018575483933091164, 0.01601029932498932, 0.04387352615594864, 0.016490481793880463, -0.034598421305418015, -0.030074594542384148, -0.002757890848442912, 0.010582971386611462, 0.021785126999020576, -0.00930669717490673, 0.043898798525333405, 0.010608244687318802, 0.011277972720563412, 0.0046723028644919395, -0.023427855223417282, 0.08249031752347946, -0.052415721118450165, -0.023301491513848305, 0.0007881944766268134, -0.052415721118450165, -0.014215932227671146, -0.02120385318994522, 0.021254397928714752, -0.011890836991369724, 0.003626642283052206, 0.0327787809073925, 0.02299821935594082, 0.004804985132068396, -0.015075205825269222, -0.04319116100668907, 0.044505346566438675, 0.02994823083281517, 0.041169337928295135, 0.012377338483929634, 0.023402582854032516, 0.04490970820188522, 0.042053885757923126, -0.009275105781853199, 0.0523146316409111, -0.03161623328924179, -0.044227343052625656, -0.017893120646476746, 0.007038466166704893, 0.014342295937240124, -0.03128768876194954, -0.023895401507616043, -0.058430641889572144, -0.029468048363924026, -0.006558283232152462, -0.014910933561623096, -0.017526663839817047, -0.03045368567109108, -0.017299210652709007, 0.007278557401150465, -0.05989646166563034, 0.022846583276987076, 0.06469828635454178, 0.059037186205387115, -0.020862670615315437, -0.008927605114877224, -0.05752082169055939, 0.014746660366654396, 0.007948285900056362, -0.017248664051294327, -0.011423291638493538, 0.005721122957766056, 0.02699131704866886, -0.020673124119639397, 0.001345774857327342, 0.04624916613101959, 0.04900389909744263, 0.02504531294107437, 0.013988477177917957, 0.05276954174041748, -0.019144121557474136, -0.00153295136988163, -0.003108550561591983, 0.007802966982126236, -0.0029600730631500483, 0.05777354910969734, -0.0006097055156715214, -0.0008742798236198723, -0.03813660889863968, -0.015669116750359535, 0.022833945229649544, -0.012156201526522636, -0.011328518390655518, 0.04240770637989044, -0.0018496507545933127, 0.007992512546479702, 0.038667336106300354, -0.05939100682735443, 0.007120602298527956, -0.02934168465435505, 0.0021323899272829294, 0.008883378468453884, -0.008965514600276947, -0.007714512292295694, -0.02666277065873146, -0.060048095881938934, -0.0007076375186443329, 0.023945948109030724, 0.011625473387539387, 0.007840876467525959, -0.0007510751020163298, 0.028760410845279694, 0.007594466675072908, 0.04710844159126282, -0.06287864595651627, -0.006125487387180328, 0.021696671843528748, -0.009483606554567814, -0.036316968500614166, -0.08845468610525131, -0.003151198383420706, -0.002956913784146309, 0.024047039449214935, 0.040385883301496506, 0.0174887552857399, -0.012522656470537186, -0.03591260313987732, 0.00693105673417449, 0.06778156757354736, 0.0363675132393837, 0.04708316549658775, -0.017008572816848755, -0.03384023532271385, -0.038995880633592606, -0.026586951687932014, 0.010128062218427658, 0.012844884768128395, -0.013141839765012264, 0.030984412878751755, 0.03207114338874817, -0.005086144432425499, 0.018550211563706398, 0.010380789637565613, 0.011808700859546661, -0.030908595770597458, 0.012743793427944183, 0.05067190155386925, -0.0523146316409111, 0.07091538608074188, -0.02527276799082756, 0.04677989333868027, -0.027698954567313194, 0.004356393590569496, -0.02050885185599327, -0.002939538797363639, -0.026713315397500992, 0.03576096519827843, -0.019270485267043114, -0.0010030129924416542, -0.010785154066979885, -0.038161881268024445, -0.045794256031513214, 0.061160098761320114, 0.05989646166563034, 0.03712569549679756, -0.005550531670451164, -0.012762747704982758, 0.0296702291816473, -0.023528946563601494, 0.0057274410501122475, -0.007487057708203793, 0.005411531310528517, 0.007183784153312445, -0.02021821402013302, -0.09254887700080872, 0.006406646687537432, 0.01333138532936573, 0.03262714296579361, 0.036544423550367355, 0.01795630156993866, -0.00490607600659132, -0.01096838153898716, -0.014632932841777802, -0.024059675633907318, 0.019877031445503235, -0.04298897832632065, -0.0213302168995142, 0.04207915812730789, -0.07076375186443329, 0.025816133245825768, -0.050899356603622437, -0.016313571482896805, 0.041118793189525604, -0.007537602912634611, 0.012086701579391956, -0.04875117167830467, 0.0599975511431694, 0.0034276191145181656, 0.003936233464628458, 0.00041344668716192245, -0.020622579380869865, 0.022088399156928062, -0.07288666069507599, 0.04902917146682739, -0.0022634922061115503, 0.03310732543468475, -0.022480126470327377, -0.0065077380277216434, 0.010747244581580162, 0.047841351479291916, 0.026688043028116226, 0.024186039343476295, -0.04569316655397415, -0.03323369100689888, 0.0237437654286623, 0.02615731582045555, 0.02082476019859314, -0.014544477686285973, -0.007771376054733992, -0.0037340514827519655, -0.01007119845598936, -0.03725206106901169, -0.008062013424932957, 0.05691427364945412, -0.013103930279612541, 0.01846175640821457, -0.006255010142922401, -0.0593404583632946, -0.004738644231110811, -0.018992485478520393, 0.030908595770597458, 0.03763115033507347, -0.036999333649873734, 0.007019511424005032, -0.0041952794417738914, 0.02193676307797432, 0.0029348002281039953, -0.05084880813956261, -0.04804353415966034, -0.02828022837638855, 0.02287185564637184, -0.028254954144358635, 0.0503433533012867, 0.04933244362473488, 0.005733759142458439, 0.0018117416184395552, 0.03222277760505676, 0.004324802663177252, 0.027471499517560005, 0.019548486918210983, -0.003926756326109171, 0.020167669281363487, 0.0013307691551744938, -0.0033170508686453104, 0.02989768423140049, 0.00011935459770029411, -0.036038968712091446, -0.02961968444287777, -0.10938054323196411, -0.034598421305418015, 0.012579520232975483, 0.016086116433143616, -0.012111973948776722, -0.002963232109323144, 0.025057949125766754, -0.017071755602955818, -0.009452015161514282, -0.0047923484817147255, 0.0074744210578501225, 0.02643531560897827, 0.0048902807757258415, 0.020862670615315437, 0.0077018761076033115, 0.02021821402013302, 0.0010756722185760736, 0.01233311090618372, 0.03255132585763931, -0.009944834746420383, 0.010772517882287502, 0.046350255608558655, 0.005291485693305731, 0.0009919560980051756, -0.003116448177024722, 0.00411946140229702, 0.007025829516351223, -0.003970983903855085, -0.01873975805938244, 0.01684430055320263, -0.001329189632087946, 0.014670842327177525, -0.009407787583768368, 0.0032570280600339174, 0.018120575696229935, -0.010361835360527039, 0.05256735906004906, 0.0003984409850090742, -0.04071442782878876, 0.0075123305432498455, -0.030933868139982224, -0.025841405615210533, 0.008655923418700695, -0.036999333649873734, 0.011214790865778923, 0.01213092915713787, -0.047234803438186646, 0.0202687606215477, -0.012838566675782204, -0.0307316854596138, 0.013887385837733746, 0.01455711480230093, -0.029215320944786072, -0.011322200298309326, 0.001506888773292303, 0.013179748319089413, 0.01726130023598671, -0.06656847149133682, 0.011025245301425457, 0.017577210441231728, 0.03176787123084068, 0.01203615590929985, -0.021165942773222923, -0.019775941967964172, 0.0049250307492911816, 0.0073796482756733894, -0.007221693638712168, -0.01224465575069189, 0.003942552022635937, 0.019839122891426086, 0.036215875297784805, 0.0028052772395312786, -0.017577210441231728, 0.02628367953002453, 0.03227332606911659, -0.022290581837296486, -0.060149189084768295, -0.03295569121837616, 0.01929575763642788, 0.027623135596513748, -0.02600567787885666, -0.00003420708526391536, 0.010336562059819698, -0.01224465575069189, 0.0024925267789512873, 0.0013544624671339989, -0.015719661489129066, 0.012314156629145145, 0.010532425716519356, 0.03401714563369751, -0.03330950811505318, 0.05201135575771332, -0.01383684016764164, -0.005180917680263519, -0.044682253152132034, 0.01790575683116913, -0.003721415065228939, 0.04076497629284859, -0.009970107115805149, -0.01819639280438423, -0.035988420248031616, -0.020622579380869865, -0.00422371132299304, 0.013849477283656597, -0.024691494181752205, 0.027648407965898514, -0.0035192330833524466, -0.005455758888274431, 0.020748943090438843, -0.0059422594495117664, 0.0384146086871624, -0.030807504430413246, 0.007771376054733992, 0.019093576818704605, 0.04842262342572212, 0.02683967910706997, -0.04041115567088127, -0.016995936632156372, 0.010974699631333351, 0.013457749038934708, -0.007385966368019581, -0.055701181292533875, -0.027648407965898514, -0.0030011411290615797, -0.021582944318652153, 0.022467490285634995, 0.046577710658311844, 0.0310602318495512, -0.004299529828131199, -0.010962063446640968, 0.011398018337786198, -0.06095791608095169, -0.002912686439231038, -0.004887121729552746, 0.011998246423900127, 0.021393397822976112, -0.01302811224013567, -0.01791839301586151, -0.004489075392484665, -0.0019981281366199255, 0.004744962323457003, -0.02282130904495716, 0.03940024599432945, 0.039273880422115326, 0.003888847306370735, 0.022050490602850914, 0.05226408317685127, -0.0188787579536438, 0.01611138880252838, 0.016351481899619102, -0.02683967910706997, -0.03856624290347099, 0.021532397717237473, -0.016541026532649994, 0.010140698403120041, -0.011094745248556137, -0.010469243861734867, -0.004369029775261879, 0.00800514966249466, 0.015744933858513832, 0.015985025092959404, 0.011157927103340626, 0.01750139147043228, 0.0032333347480744123, -0.04025952145457268, 0.021317580714821815, 0.03229859843850136, 0.006008600816130638, -0.011423291638493538, -0.02230321802198887, 0.009275105781853199, 0.044960252940654755, -0.0559033639729023, 0.0003101837355643511, 0.03985515609383583, 0.002749993000179529, -0.021785126999020576, 0.007828240282833576, 0.0026457428466528654, -0.014582387171685696, 0.009464651346206665, 0.048018258064985275, 0.032424960285425186, 0.03202059864997864, 0.030200958251953125, -0.032475508749485016, -0.017324483022093773, 0.004656507633626461, -0.014089568518102169, -0.025929860770702362, 0.020534124225378036, -0.023895401507616043, -0.02711768075823784, 0.01990230567753315, 0.0010353936813771725, -0.06090737134218216, 0.008314740844070911, 0.03356223553419113, -0.012964930385351181, 0.04207915812730789, 0.016124026849865913, -0.007581830490380526, -0.005481031723320484, 0.012383656576275826, 0.0096036521717906, 0.00543680414557457, -0.024413494393229485, 0.014481295831501484, 0.0015629627741873264, 0.0033833917696028948, -0.000664594816043973, 0.009344605728983879, 0.02694077044725418, -0.011309564113616943, -0.00096194475190714, 0.01726130023598671, -0.02638477087020874, 0.02244221791625023, -0.005506304558366537, 0.03664551302790642, -0.004012051969766617, 0.0082136495038867, 0.0015684912214055657, -0.0106651084497571, 0.010361835360527039, 0.010999972000718117, -0.0059801689349114895, 0.03500278294086456, -0.029594412073493004, 0.01363465841859579, 0.012825929559767246, 0.024325039237737656, 0.000493608764372766, 0.0725833922624588, 0.051076263189315796, 0.0012739055091515183, 0.03634224086999893, -0.03050423040986061, -0.003500278340652585, -0.05433645099401474, -0.012352065183222294, 0.03485114872455597, -0.04448007047176361, -0.029821867123246193, 0.012074065394699574, 0.02146921679377556, 0.0026109928730875254, 0.012459474615752697, -0.015037297271192074, 0.007398603018373251, -0.019775941967964172, -0.010848335921764374, 0.022884491831064224, -0.012977566570043564, -0.019371576607227325, 0.01985175907611847, -0.021456580609083176, -0.01017860695719719, 0.005522099789232016, 0.012295201420783997, -0.008687513880431652, 0.028912046924233437, -0.010450289584696293, -0.013129202648997307, 0.01805739291012287, 0.0006219470524229109, 0.040335338562726974, -0.010696698911488056, 0.02656167931854725, 0.0328545980155468, -0.10806635767221451, 0.012788021005690098, 0.024704130366444588, 0.008845468983054161, 0.0010014334693551064, 0.01277538388967514, 0.011240063235163689, 0.036165330559015274, 0.0028668795712292194, -0.01355884037911892, 0.021317580714821815, -0.058986641466617584, 0.02203785441815853, 0.05039389804005623, 0.029088955372571945, -0.028861502185463905, -0.010930472053587437, 0.0006440607248805463, -0.004880803171545267, 0.01180238276720047, -0.01103788148611784, 0.006640419829636812, 0.024009129032492638, 0.013040748424828053, -0.005221985746175051, -0.020395124331116676, -0.033764418214559555, -0.014493932947516441, 0.04235715791583061, -0.03740369528532028, -0.007126920856535435, 0.013849477283656597, -0.03778278827667236, 0.022366398945450783, -0.0013900022022426128, -0.023086674511432648, -0.013672567903995514, 0.036771878600120544, -0.03745424374938011, -0.015454297885298729, -0.032702963799238205, -0.01647784560918808, 0.027623135596513748, 0.000553631572984159, 0.025298040360212326, 0.009489924646914005, 0.011777110397815704, 0.00032321500475518405, -0.01081042643636465, 0.034648966044187546, 0.006589874159544706, 0.028684591874480247, 0.015707025304436684, 0.023819584399461746, 0.010469243861734867, 0.04031006619334221, 0.0016150878509506583, 0.01971275918185711, -0.03176787123084068, -0.023819584399461746, -0.022202126681804657, 0.02318776398897171, 0.0009035014663822949, -0.053527723997831345, -0.048574261367321014, -0.031136050820350647, -0.06303028017282486, 0.06110955402255058, 0.0251337680965662, 0.00015894201351329684, 0.011101063340902328, 0.043620798736810684, -0.006570919882506132, 0.02699131704866886, 0.0296702291816473, -0.01901775784790516, -0.007101648021489382, 0.007626057602465153, -0.00930669717490673, 0.018727121874690056, -0.007335421163588762, -0.023111946880817413, 0.004217393230646849, -0.0064224423840641975, -0.01971275918185711, 0.019194668158888817, 0.011151609010994434, -0.01216883771121502, 0.000010149829904548824, -0.01981385052204132, -0.004700734745711088, 0.03303150832653046, 0.017994210124015808, 0.016680026426911354, -0.009186651557683945, -0.0025320155546069145, 0.04680516570806503, -0.045516256242990494, 0.012927020899951458, 0.006021237000823021, -0.021633489057421684, -0.013925295323133469, 0.02448931150138378, -0.030605321750044823, 0.021090125665068626, -0.03290514275431633, 0.012630065903067589, -0.021974671632051468, 0.031186595559120178, 0.011120017617940903, 0.03411823883652687, 0.025715041905641556, 0.006811011116951704, 0.031540416181087494, 0.03750478848814964, 0.032879870384931564, -0.019194668158888817, 0.00034118237090297043, 0.008889696560800076, -0.03750478848814964, 0.023225674405694008, 0.0031527779065072536, -0.043014250695705414, -0.02272021770477295, 0.0033138918224722147, 0.03507860377430916, -0.015997663140296936, -0.015113115310668945, 0.004928189795464277, 0.026485860347747803, -0.03027677722275257, 0.015997663140296936, 0.018689211457967758, 0.004533302970230579, -0.0001583496923558414, -0.008384240791201591, -0.020395124331116676, 0.029468048363924026, -0.002307719551026821, 0.020799487829208374, -0.013217657804489136, -0.013255567289888859, -0.0009287742432206869, -0.011113699525594711, 0.019005121663212776, 0.02148185297846794, 0.001277064555324614, -0.028937319293618202, 0.0034086646046489477, 0.03356223553419113, -0.00801146775484085, 0.018992485478520393, 0.013975840993225574, 0.021254397928714752, -0.0077271489426493645, -0.03068114072084427, 0.022138945758342743, -0.020028669387102127, 0.013849477283656597, 0.019106213003396988, 0.05827900394797325, 0.018575483933091164, -0.000396071671275422, 0.011303246021270752, 0.0053546675480902195, 0.003933074418455362, -0.015934480354189873, 0.0036771877203136683, 0.00212923064827919, -0.013748385943472385, 0.032323870807886124, -0.05317390337586403, -0.009761606343090534, -0.0064477152191102505, -0.013609386049211025, 0.028532955795526505, 0.028254954144358635, 0.006653056014329195, -0.0011799223721027374, 0.004568052943795919, -0.028684591874480247, -0.005913827568292618, -0.0028226522263139486, -0.016048207879066467, 0.024603039026260376, 0.008314740844070911, -0.012825929559767246, 0.018272211775183678, 0.007784012705087662, 0.046072255820035934, 0.011486473493278027, 0.0307316854596138, -0.000455304718343541, 0.01064615324139595, 0.03576096519827843, 0.009786879643797874, -0.02878568321466446, 0.005774827674031258, -0.009692106395959854, 0.017804665490984917, -0.029518593102693558, 0.00429321127012372, -0.021090125665068626, -0.03545769304037094, -0.005879077594727278, 0.007101648021489382, 0.021545035764575005, -0.0067920563742518425, -0.03386550769209862, -0.030251502990722656, -0.000038945730921113864, -0.008870741352438927, 0.03869260847568512, 0.022518036887049675, 0.05388154089450836, -0.05453863367438316, 0.030327321961522102, -0.022783400490880013, 0.0015195251908153296, -0.027926409617066383, 0.022518036887049675, -0.013053384609520435, -0.0113411545753479, 0.0390717014670372, -0.0006203674711287022, 0.035103876143693924, 0.035103876143693924, -0.02203785441815853, -0.02555076777935028, 0.001508468296378851, 0.03801024332642555, -0.026688043028116226, 0.01762775518000126, -0.013520930893719196, -0.046451348811388016, -0.03189423307776451, -0.018967213109135628, 0.0033486417960375547, 0.010431335307657719, -0.0025162200909107924, 0.060654643923044205, 0.0007601574761793017, -0.006261328235268593, 0.008485332131385803, 0.0025304360315203667, 0.027547316625714302, 0.022467490285634995, -0.027597863227128983, 0.02531067654490471, -0.015037297271192074, -0.036822423338890076, 0.0039551882073283195, -0.016364118084311485, -0.0021924127358943224, -0.013798931613564491, 0.010058561339974403, -0.013672567903995514, 0.04842262342572212, 0.03267768770456314, 0.0013149736914783716, 0.004144733771681786, -0.00568321393802762, -0.03854097053408623, -0.0012304679257795215, 0.035381875932216644, -0.005351508501917124, -0.04978735372424126, 0.015681752935051918, 0.0037593243177980185, -0.05610554665327072, 0.008062013424932957, -0.011018927209079266, 0.030933868139982224, -0.004760757554322481, -0.00560107734054327, 0.0013062861980870366, -0.01592184416949749, -0.019106213003396988, -0.0058601233176887035, 0.006596192717552185, -0.013015476055443287, 0.014582387171685696, -0.02009185031056404, -0.0008932343916967511, 0.00422371132299304, 0.014481295831501484, -0.027623135596513748, -0.009262469597160816, 0.025348586961627007, -0.008725423365831375, 0.008636968210339546, 0.015163660980761051, 0.016326207667589188, 0.015593297779560089, 0.015353206545114517, -0.01689484529197216, 0.016098752617836, 0.0032570280600339174, 0.002896890975534916, -0.0106651084497571, -0.004334279801696539, 0.011713927611708641, -0.0033012554049491882, -0.0012636383762583137, -0.02082476019859314, 0.0007929331040941179, -0.03197005018591881, 0.0010843597119674087, -0.03808606043457985, -0.01499938778579235, 0.02318776398897171, -0.011467518284916878, 0.02143130823969841, -0.005989646073430777, -0.017804665490984917, -0.03050423040986061, 0.017943665385246277, 0.015542752109467983, -0.011562291532754898, -0.009666834026575089, -0.0474875308573246, 0.0029584935400635004, 0.017071755602955818, -0.02532331459224224, -0.024868404492735863, -0.01795630156993866, 0.008327377028763294, 0.01386211346834898, -0.006867874879390001, 0.022277945652604103, -0.008643286302685738, 0.025955133140087128, 0.013141839765012264, -0.02485576830804348, -0.02600567787885666, 0.037428971379995346, 0.004049960989505053, -0.006185510195791721, 0.014506569132208824, 0.023402582854032516, 0.005228303838521242, 0.028179137036204338, -0.0101154251024127, 0.0077018761076033115, -0.009098196402192116, 0.011025245301425457, -0.0122383376583457, -0.020016033202409744, -0.032980963587760925, 0.0033518008422106504, 0.06368737667798996, -0.021267034113407135, -0.019801214337348938, -0.032424960285425186, 0.015176297165453434, -0.022796036675572395, 0.0007352795801125467, 0.01614929921925068, 0.010008016601204872, -0.02304876409471035, 0.006735192611813545, 0.0018085824558511376, 0.007575512398034334, 0.037833333015441895, 0.038212426006793976, 0.013798931613564491, -0.015113115310668945, 0.023667948320508003, -0.039602428674697876, -0.014089568518102169, -0.025664495304226875, -0.007663967087864876, 0.006722556427121162, 0.00794196780771017, 0.021443944424390793, -0.006055986974388361, 0.017425574362277985, 0.0014444966800510883, 0.007758739870041609, 0.014013749547302723, -0.007600785233080387, 0.008365286514163017, -0.0026267883367836475, 0.013571476563811302, -0.019561123102903366, -0.029796592891216278, -0.012655338272452354, -0.00471968948841095, 0.007101648021489382, -0.00768292136490345, 0.02249276451766491, 0.015201570466160774, 0.012952293269336224, 0.003484482876956463, -0.012282565236091614, 0.03500278294086456, 0.005149326752871275, 0.018916666507720947, -0.0008059644023887813, 0.006570919882506132, -0.029366957023739815, -0.0005477082449942827, 0.006735192611813545, -0.0008703309576958418, -0.005120894871652126, 0.015896571800112724, 0.04028479382395744, 0.024375585839152336, 0.04159897565841675, 0.016541026532649994, 0.003405505558475852, -0.012655338272452354, -0.05762191116809845, 0.0349775105714798, 0.022808672860264778, -0.017097027972340584, -0.009799515828490257, 0.01930839568376541, -0.03040314093232155, 0.000613259500823915, -0.000791748461779207, 0.011555973440408707, -0.01439284160733223, 0.004842894151806831, 0.009053968824446201, -0.01731184683740139, -0.017109664157032967, 0.031363505870103836, -0.017160208895802498, 0.0035634604282677174, -0.022063126787543297, -0.007493375800549984, -0.0018117416184395552, 0.024881040677428246, -0.003099073190242052, 0.0029142661951482296, 0.04384825378656387, -0.006368737667798996, -0.02120385318994522, 0.04794244095683098, -0.02337731048464775, -0.021140670403838158, 0.01402638666331768, 0.02355422079563141, 0.013066020794212818, -0.009584696963429451, -0.03356223553419113, 0.00483657605946064, -0.0059201461263000965, -0.031818415969610214, -0.028431864455342293, -0.004476439207792282, 0.03659496828913689, -0.004012051969766617, 0.00555369071662426, 0.00275947037152946, -0.0073543754406273365, -0.0489533506333828, 0.00277684535831213, -0.020572032779455185, 0.01875239424407482, 0.008106240071356297, 0.028482409194111824, 0.030605321750044823, 0.013925295323133469, 0.02419867552816868, -0.010620880872011185, -0.011537018232047558, -0.02193676307797432, -0.009679470211267471, 0.021582944318652153, 0.0174887552857399, -0.006570919882506132, -0.004763916600495577, -0.0019396849675104022, -0.01286383904516697, -0.012257292866706848, -0.01013438031077385, 0.00691842008382082, 0.026915498077869415, -0.048068806529045105, 0.022151581943035126, 0.019232576712965965, 0.04043642804026604, 0.02435031160712242, 0.021026942878961563, -0.0010322346352040768, -0.014506569132208824, 0.03156568855047226, -0.00009936344576999545, 0.019321031868457794, -0.006261328235268593, -0.010842017829418182, -0.024426130577921867, 0.004947144538164139, 0.006055986974388361, -0.012213065288960934, -0.0030848572496324778, 0.014076932333409786, -0.00858642254024744, -0.018082665279507637, 0.008415832184255123, 0.0113411545753479, -0.0016221958212554455, 0.010077516548335552, -0.006220260169357061, -0.015858661383390427, 0.028179137036204338, 0.0070700570940971375, -0.005904350429773331, 0.013659930787980556, 0.04794244095683098, 0.012206747196614742, 0.01156860962510109, 0.03457314521074295, 0.02077421545982361, 0.004087870474904776, -0.028305500745773315, -0.04180115833878517, 0.013786295428872108, 0.010728290304541588, -0.012459474615752697, 0.02378167398273945, -0.027749499306082726, -0.018727121874690056, -0.04399988800287247, 0.031489867717027664, 0.010930472053587437, -0.0433175228536129, 0.023756401613354683, 0.004612280055880547, -0.04738644137978554, 0.03823769837617874, 0.014809842221438885, 0.020900579169392586, -0.0026030950248241425, -0.0013157634530216455, 0.010026970878243446, 0.036215875297784805, -0.007348057348281145, 0.022833945229649544, 0.00027543367468751967, 0.009452015161514282, 0.0022445376962423325, 0.025234859436750412, 0.014089568518102169, 0.004520666319876909, -0.016490481793880463, -0.00021876739629078656, 0.005983327981084585, -0.005509463604539633, -0.04071442782878876, -0.010216516442596912, -0.018828213214874268, 0.0071648298762738705, 0.0045080301351845264, 0.029644956812262535, 0.0349016934633255, 0.02661222405731678, -0.004943985491991043, 0.006466669496148825, -0.0041352566331624985, -0.028937319293618202, 0.050292808562517166, 0.0013552522286772728, 0.03341060131788254, -0.014595023356378078, 0.013078657910227776, -0.007499693892896175, 0.004151052329689264, 0.026637498289346695, 0.009527833200991154, -0.010406062006950378, 0.02189885452389717, -0.0016332525992766023, -0.0032570280600339174, 0.03406769037246704, -0.003961506299674511, 0.0071521932259202, 0.021684035658836365, -0.0035634604282677174, -0.0411946140229702, 0.003024834441021085, -0.0053199175745248795, -0.010791472159326077, -0.010709335096180439, -0.02216421812772751, 0.03828824311494827, -0.015846025198698044, -0.02699131704866886, 0.011574927717447281, -0.01809530146420002, 0.02888677455484867, 0.000024754479454713874, -0.014317023567855358, 0.014974115416407585, 0.03341060131788254, -0.004097347613424063, 0.000834791106171906, 0.002588879084214568, -0.017893120646476746, 0.04852371662855148, -0.013761022128164768, 0.018070029094815254, 0.006747829262167215, 0.011126336641609669, 0.026081496849656105, -0.037049878388643265, -0.015277388505637646, 0.012554247863590717, -0.0050703492015600204, 0.03341060131788254, 0.028532955795526505, 0.00769555801525712, 0.030580049380660057, 0.01791839301586151, -0.026182588189840317, 0.03282932564616203, -0.01113265473395586, -0.012579520232975483, 0.017665665596723557, -0.019245212897658348, 0.012857520952820778, -0.01721075549721718, 0.025929860770702362, 0.04480861872434616, 0.010241789743304253, -0.024287130683660507, 0.017577210441231728, -0.018765030428767204, 0.01050715334713459, -0.0016585254343226552, 0.005266212858259678, -0.02364267408847809, -0.03583678603172302, 0.03272823616862297, -0.005048235412687063, -0.014039022848010063, -0.021924126893281937, 0.019219940528273582, 0.018032120540738106, 0.021873580291867256, 0.001065405085682869, -0.011486473493278027, 0.008706469088792801, -0.034497328102588654, -0.03169205039739609, -0.008643286302685738, 0.00882019568234682, -0.027875863015651703, 0.007910376414656639, -0.005989646073430777, -0.01625039055943489, 0.028659319505095482, -0.003601369448006153, 0.010147016495466232, 0.011391700245440006, -0.00807464960962534, -0.01764039136469364, -0.00560107734054327, 0.003901483491063118, 0.02433767542243004, -0.011537018232047558, 0.03919806331396103, -0.025613950565457344, 0.026410043239593506, -0.024742040783166885, 0.050292808562517166, -0.004849212244153023, 0.010330243967473507, -0.015378479845821857, -0.00033585139317438006, 0.01583338901400566, 0.020003395155072212, 0.036493878811597824, 0.006526692304760218, 0.013179748319089413, 0.022884491831064224, -0.007935648784041405, 0.006125487387180328, 0.023111946880817413, -0.022050490602850914, -0.007663967087864876, 0.0006874982500448823, 0.04382298141717911, -0.013255567289888859, -0.002154503483325243, 0.013369294814765453, 0.015542752109467983, -0.014784569852054119, -0.0005038758390583098, -0.02828022837638855, -0.0023456288035959005, -0.029316410422325134, -0.008409513160586357, 0.008561150170862675, -0.015934480354189873, -0.01745084673166275, -0.004501712042838335, 0.014076932333409786, 0.03396660089492798, -0.007246966473758221, -0.009325651451945305, 0.0006764414138160646, 0.03401714563369751, 0.0037245741114020348, 0.01860075816512108, 0.015542752109467983, 0.003046948229894042, -0.0013039169134572148, -0.011208472773432732, -0.008851787075400352, -0.016680026426911354, 0.025007404386997223, 0.0127311572432518, 0.016920117661356926, 0.031590960919857025, -0.035432420670986176, -0.034320417791604996, -0.0125668840482831, 0.005977009888738394, 0.02327621914446354, 0.02138076163828373, 0.017526663839817047, -0.014013749547302723, -0.027850590646266937, 0.009161378256976604, 0.010848335921764374, 0.004128938540816307, -0.015037297271192074, 0.016970664262771606, -0.00003615684181568213, 0.028709864243865013, -0.011884518899023533, -0.0010361834429204464, -0.0019286280730739236, -0.021962035447359085, 0.023162491619586945, 0.0023551061749458313 ]
12.143025
4.559571
2024-06-01
2
2024A&A...686A.257J
[ "galaxy cluster members", "cluster detection algorithms", "massive clusters", "Cluster number", "few high-resolution hydro simulations", "galaxies", "resolutions", "IR wavelengths", "Euclid data", "the cluster galaxy members" ]
[ "methods: numerical", "galaxies: clusters: general", "galaxies: luminosity function", "mass function", "large-scale structure of Universe", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
12
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202347448", "10.48550/arXiv.2309.01443" ]
[ "Jiménez Muñoz, A.", "Macías-Pérez, J. F.", "Yepes, G.", "De Petris, M.", "Ferragamo, A.", "Cui, W.", "Gómez, J. S." ]
[ "Univ. Grenoble Alpes, CNRS, Grenoble INP, LPSC-IN2P3, 53, avenue des Martyrs, 38000, Grenoble, France; Departamento de Física Teórica and CIAFF, Módulo 8, Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, 28049, Madrid, Spain", "Univ. Grenoble Alpes, CNRS, Grenoble INP, LPSC-IN2P3, 53, avenue des Martyrs, 38000, Grenoble, France", "Departamento de Física Teórica and CIAFF, Módulo 8, Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, 28049, Madrid, Spain", "I.N.A.F. - Osservatorio Astronomico di Roma, Via Frascati 33, 00040, Monteporzio Catone, Roma, Italy", "I.N.A.F. - Osservatorio Astronomico di Roma, Via Frascati 33, 00040, Monteporzio Catone, Roma, Italy", "Departamento de Física Teórica and CIAFF, Módulo 8, Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, 28049, Madrid, Spain", "Departamento de Física Teórica and CIAFF, Módulo 8, Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, 28049, Madrid, Spain" ]
[ "2024ApJ...966..227C", "2024EPJWC.29300025M" ]
[ "1965TrAlm...5...87E", "1974ApJ...187..425P", "1999A&A...350..381D", "2000ApJ...536..571B", "2003PASP..115..763C", "2004MNRAS.349.1039N", "2008ApJ...688..709T", "2009ApJS..182..608K", "2009MNRAS.399..497D", "2011ARA&A..49..409A", "2011arXiv1110.3193L", "2012ApJ...746..125H", "2013ApJ...762..109B", "2013MNRAS.430.2427R", "2013MNRAS.431.1366S", "2013PASP..125..306F", "2014A&A...571A..20P", "2014ApJ...785..104R", "2015ApJS..216...27B", "2015MNRAS.450...53H", "2016A&A...594A..24P", "2016ApJ...832...95D", "2016MNRAS.457.4340K", "2016MNRAS.459.1764S", "2016MNRAS.462.3265D", "2017A&A...608A..65B", "2017MNRAS.466.2217S", "2018A&A...620A...5A", "2018A&A...620A..10P", "2018ApJS..235...33D", "2018MNRAS.480.2898C", "2019A&A...627A..23E", "2019ApJ...878...55B", "2019MNRAS.485..498M", "2019MNRAS.486.2827D", "2019SSRv..215...25P", "2020PhRvD.102b3509A", "2021ApJ...921..112B", "2021ApJS..253....3H", "2021MNRAS.500.2316C", "2021MNRAS.502.1191H", "2022A&A...661A...2L", "2022MNRAS.514..977C", "2023MNRAS.518..111D" ]
28151207
2310.18177
Reinterpreting fundamental plane correlations with machine learning
This work explores the relationships between galaxy sizes and related observable galaxy properties in a large volume cosmological hydrodynamical simulation. The objectives of this work are to develop a better understanding of both the correlations between galaxy properties and the influence of environment on galaxy physics in order to build an improved model for the galaxy sizes, building off of the fundamental plane. With an accurate intrinsic galaxy size predictor, the residuals in the observed galaxy sizes can potentially be used for multiple cosmological applications, including making measurements of galaxy velocities in spectroscopic samples, estimating the rate of cosmic expansion, and constraining the uncertainties in the photometric redshifts of galaxies. Using projection pursuit regression, the model accurately predicts intrinsic galaxy sizes and have residuals which have limited correlation with galaxy properties. The model decreases the spatial correlation of galaxy size residuals by a factor of ~5 at small scales compared to the baseline correlation when the mean size is used as a predictor.
[ 0.008329048752784729, 0.037822622805833817, 0.05936829373240471, -0.009040885604918003, -0.021343886852264404, 0.0018944941693916917, -0.0022434061393141747, -0.045064300298690796, -0.022386420518159866, 0.0497276708483696, -0.02378767356276512, -0.003951533697545528, -0.0703989565372467, -0.05098319426178932, 0.008833499625325203, 0.025939997285604477, 0.00640652934089303, 0.036455001682043076, -0.021949229761958122, 0.03885394707322121, -0.001098582404665649, -0.018743161112070084, 0.009181010536849499, -0.007807782385498285, -0.025670956820249557, -0.03349555283784866, 0.0013445023214444518, 0.048472147434949875, 0.09084603935480118, -0.027374880388379097, -0.014505771920084953, -0.01638905704021454, -0.07129576057195663, -0.0017459613736718893, -0.060758333653211594, 0.06259678304195404, 0.0041645243763923645, 0.04118563234806061, -0.03676888346672058, 0.03524431958794594, 0.01346324011683464, 0.011613585986196995, -0.026141777634620667, -0.021960439160466194, -0.010627103969454765, 0.007202440872788429, -0.022296739742159843, -0.02227431908249855, -0.004268216900527477, 0.02923574484884739, -0.05053479224443436, -0.0009640621719881892, -0.02281240001320839, -0.020323775708675385, -0.010851304046809673, -0.01530168391764164, 0.003957138862460852, -0.031455330550670624, -0.05412200093269348, 0.02876492403447628, 0.012555227614939213, -0.029549626633524895, -0.0014741183258593082, -0.0014348832191899419, -0.04318101704120636, 0.013508080504834652, 0.0094276312738657, -0.00654104957357049, -0.005750742740929127, 0.010408508591353893, 0.015604354441165924, -0.030760308727622032, -0.0038394336588680744, 0.019236402586102486, -0.004789483267813921, -0.020402245223522186, 0.01782394014298916, 0.019830534234642982, -0.0734032467007637, -0.013620180077850819, 0.015043853782117367, -0.012700958177447319, 0.01749884895980358, 0.02589515782892704, -0.066094309091568, -0.02629871852695942, -0.006328058894723654, -0.032150350511074066, -0.025110455229878426, 0.022375209257006645, 0.0407148115336895, -0.015469834208488464, -0.006782065145671368, -0.004060831386595964, 0.02425849437713623, -0.05165579542517662, 0.02008836530148983, -0.09299837052822113, 0.06582526862621307, 0.03277811408042908, -0.02219584956765175, 0.03313683345913887, 0.00484833586961031, -0.05035543069243431, 0.018418071791529655, -0.0236979927867651, 0.01619848608970642, -0.03681372106075287, 0.009926477447152138, 0.01932608336210251, 0.022016489878296852, 0.02036861516535282, -0.009948897175490856, 0.009057700634002686, -0.018272340297698975, -0.024774154648184776, -0.06564590334892273, 0.010447743348777294, -0.038360703736543655, -0.0008575668907724321, 0.03165711089968681, 0.01570524461567402, 0.004764260724186897, 0.0029846690595149994, 0.03239697217941284, 0.009450051002204418, 0.007308936212211847, -0.02609693817794323, -0.036118701100349426, 0.04208243265748024, -0.008200133219361305, 0.011097924783825874, -0.016411475837230682, -0.0158509761095047, -0.03452687710523605, -0.0415443517267704, -0.04031125083565712, -0.007168810814619064, 0.0124319177120924, -0.03584966063499451, -0.0015231621218845248, 0.01987537369132042, 0.0385400652885437, -0.010111442767083645, -0.011792946606874466, -0.004783878102898598, 0.03735180199146271, 0.04217211529612541, -0.0241912342607975, 0.022251900285482407, 0.012969998642802238, 0.00011805557733168826, -0.035356417298316956, -0.04248599335551262, 0.0059917583130300045, -0.002780086128041148, 0.02336169220507145, -0.0023835315369069576, 0.004982856102287769, -0.029616886749863625, -0.018597431480884552, 0.012801848351955414, -0.035289157181978226, 0.045602381229400635, -0.004240192007273436, -0.007163206115365028, -0.048337627202272415, 0.016848668456077576, -0.06546654552221298, -0.05425652116537094, -0.010980219580233097, 0.033248934894800186, -0.007090340834110975, -0.0417012944817543, 0.05322519689798355, 0.049099911004304886, -0.006910980213433504, 0.009618201293051243, -0.017599739134311676, -0.01886647194623947, -0.01007781270891428, 0.02916848473250866, -0.019662383943796158, -0.07062315940856934, 0.000024631402993691154, 0.03970590978860855, -0.027419721707701683, 0.029123645275831223, 0.031522590667009354, -0.03046884760260582, -0.0050276960246264935, 0.03333861380815506, 0.004052423872053623, 0.03354039415717125, -0.033517975360155106, -0.0071295760571956635, 0.0016590836457908154, 0.04981734976172447, -0.008295418694615364, 0.02569337747991085, 0.039593808352947235, 0.0022111774887889624, 0.011568745598196983, -0.021612927317619324, -0.03546851873397827, -0.042463574558496475, 0.005986153148114681, 0.003803001018241048, -0.055736243724823, -0.021500827744603157, 0.009679856710135937, -0.006529839709401131, 0.015525884926319122, -0.004960435908287764, -0.011658426374197006, -0.028047483414411545, -0.051341913640499115, -0.0016100398497655988, 0.04084933176636696, 0.03490801900625229, -0.026276297867298126, 0.039997369050979614, 0.03773294389247894, 0.008015167899429798, -0.011972306296229362, -0.03349555283784866, 0.05909925326704979, -0.10322190821170807, -0.008429938927292824, -0.05927861109375954, -0.0006712002214044333, 0.0015455821994692087, -0.028114743530750275, 0.026253879070281982, 0.005397627130150795, -0.03190373256802559, 0.01606396585702896, 0.0073145413771271706, -0.011058690026402473, -0.029347846284508705, -0.018900102004408836, 0.0477098673582077, -0.04744082689285278, -0.0004158218507654965, -0.005568579770624638, 0.019494233652949333, -0.020267724990844727, -0.004461589735001326, 0.02097395621240139, 0.011871416121721268, 0.008480384014546871, -0.03968348726630211, -0.030917249619960785, -0.006950215436518192, -0.03524431958794594, -0.008564459159970284, -0.04149951413273811, 0.010571053251624107, 0.01583976484835148, 0.010610288940370083, -0.028720084577798843, -0.025603696703910828, -0.023384112864732742, 0.020245304331183434, -0.006372899282723665, 0.01090174913406372, 0.03349555283784866, -0.0013038660399615765, -0.03927992656826973, 0.0056330375373363495, 0.017947249114513397, -0.03995252773165703, -0.003780580824241042, -0.06053413450717926, -0.04008704796433449, 0.04149951413273811, -0.03860732540488243, 0.05779888853430748, 0.04140983149409294, -0.04555753991007805, 0.02336169220507145, -0.007465876638889313, 0.017790310084819794, 0.02856314368546009, 0.02528981678187847, 0.04549027979373932, -0.019382134079933167, -0.0002002040419029072, -0.01961754448711872, 0.0006295129423961043, 0.04324827715754509, -0.022655460983514786, -0.03194857016205788, -0.003682493232190609, -0.032352130860090256, -0.01756610907614231, -0.007802177220582962, 0.00751632172614336, 0.00868216436356306, 0.019998684525489807, 0.013698650524020195, 0.02616419829428196, -0.035423677414655685, -0.006585889495909214, -0.0797705352306366, 0.0015960272867232561, 0.03102934919297695, 0.03141048923134804, 0.008020772598683834, 0.03701550140976906, 0.009309926070272923, 0.01578371599316597, 0.008553248830139637, 0.032621171325445175, -0.010447743348777294, -0.04295681416988373, -0.009976922534406185, 0.01373228058218956, 0.05587076395750046, -0.0057731629349291325, -0.061924178153276443, -0.054749760776758194, -0.021568087860941887, -0.02916848473250866, 0.013272669166326523, -0.028271682560443878, 0.0019000992178916931, 0.007465876638889313, -0.06448006629943848, 0.002998681738972664, 0.0006449267384596169, 0.03490801900625229, 0.029751406982541084, 0.00007601798279210925, -0.02029014565050602, -0.0643903836607933, -0.024168813601136208, 0.02172502875328064, 0.026141777634620667, 0.014124631881713867, -0.028787344694137573, 0.016702936962246895, 0.01178173627704382, -0.0022532150615006685, 0.057843729853630066, 0.009887241758406162, 0.006972635630518198, 0.07232708483934402, 0.033585235476493835, -0.0028641612734645605, 0.022375209257006645, 0.03448203578591347, 0.00796472281217575, -0.030693048611283302, 0.03544609993696213, -0.010133862495422363, 0.003337784903123975, -0.06089285388588905, -0.0069558206014335155, -0.005358391907066107, 0.0006417739205062389, -0.014191891998052597, 0.032890211790800095, 0.0012239946518093348, -0.012319817207753658, 0.03277811408042908, -0.0283613633364439, 0.026119358837604523, -0.01632179692387581, 0.016086386516690254, 0.015458624809980392, 0.020996376872062683, -0.03847280517220497, -0.006109463516622782, -0.08434423059225082, -0.012510388158261776, -0.009113750420510769, 0.02405671402812004, -0.016377845779061317, 0.02528981678187847, 0.0386970080435276, 0.05228355526924133, -0.024303333833813667, -0.02930300496518612, 0.028540723025798798, -0.012521597556769848, 0.008216948248445988, -0.0066027045249938965, -0.049099911004304886, 0.0028487476520240307, -0.010133862495422363, 0.011081109754741192, 0.010974614880979061, 0.010150677524507046, 0.0002191209641750902, -0.0017669801600277424, 0.07421036809682846, 0.045198820531368256, 0.024348175153136253, 0.06102737784385681, -0.02937026508152485, -0.0490550696849823, -0.032015830278396606, -0.04093901067972183, -0.03903330862522125, 0.02910122461616993, -0.004315859638154507, 0.012790638953447342, 0.013788330368697643, -0.01968480460345745, 0.04353973641991615, -0.04105111211538315, 0.01872074231505394, -0.03510979935526848, 0.044862519949674606, 0.03452687710523605, -0.01988658495247364, 0.027038579806685448, 0.0013704255688935518, 0.08927664160728455, -0.010879329405725002, -0.012600068002939224, -0.014886912889778614, -0.004500824958086014, -0.01823871023952961, 0.02663501910865307, 0.01708407886326313, 0.030042866244912148, -0.04878602921962738, -0.04338279739022255, -0.03791230544447899, 0.04100627079606056, 0.02372041344642639, -0.017095288261771202, -0.020447084680199623, -0.015133533626794815, 0.013642600737512112, 0.004262612201273441, 0.0021369110327214003, -0.01471876259893179, 0.04132015258073807, 0.0029146065935492516, 0.0031360045541077852, -0.06353842467069626, 0.08250578492879868, -0.0002538019616622478, 0.01001055259257555, 0.022902080789208412, -0.013821960426867008, -0.036455001682043076, -0.015806134790182114, 0.014886912889778614, -0.024886256083846092, 0.014012531377375126, -0.004484009929001331, -0.01633300632238388, 0.03649984300136566, -0.02793538197875023, 0.052911318838596344, -0.003648863174021244, 0.02528981678187847, 0.030894828960299492, -0.03190373256802559, 0.016680516302585602, 0.004607320297509432, 0.03746390342712402, 0.04360699653625488, -0.008200133219361305, -0.012779428623616695, 0.013239039108157158, 0.023585893213748932, -0.0507141537964344, 0.049010228365659714, -0.02479657530784607, 0.0004897379549220204, -0.011557536199688911, -0.05779888853430748, -0.0393696092069149, 0.006754040252417326, -0.011770525947213173, 0.019225193187594414, 0.002998681738972664, 0.02315991185605526, 0.04031125083565712, -0.02439301460981369, 0.049503471702337265, -0.03970590978860855, -0.010189912281930447, -0.017039237543940544, 0.00799274817109108, 0.0023204751778393984, -0.03434751555323601, 0.02876492403447628, -0.009029675275087357, 0.009791957214474678, 0.01314935926347971, -0.021635347977280617, -0.0017095288494601846, 0.014427302405238152, 0.03134322911500931, 0.0990966185927391, 0.010817673988640308, 0.023473791778087616, 0.02275635115802288, 0.008446753956377506, 0.01144543569535017, 0.0012590258847922087, -0.046095624566078186, -0.024684475734829903, 0.012958789244294167, -0.020727336406707764, 0.048337627202272415, 0.008811079896986485, -0.014292782172560692, 0.02062644623219967, -0.0002793748280964792, -0.043562158942222595, 0.0008295418228954077, 0.048606667667627335, 0.005722717847675085, 0.002139713615179062, 0.01106429472565651, -0.004789483267813921, -0.003859051037579775, 0.02090669609606266, -0.01164721604436636, -0.040199149399995804, -0.07259612530469894, -0.018911311402916908, 0.02034619450569153, -0.011815366335213184, -0.013564130291342735, 0.013407190330326557, -0.02234157919883728, -0.023541051894426346, -0.03468381613492966, 0.012196507304906845, -0.012801848351955414, -0.006653149612247944, -0.012936368584632874, 0.014326412230730057, 0.007359381299465895, 0.005066931247711182, 0.006871745456010103, 0.02315991185605526, 0.05035543069243431, -0.012050776742398739, -0.0035479729995131493, 0.02800264209508896, 0.006159908603876829, 0.06093769520521164, -0.025939997285604477, 0.013698650524020195, 0.033921536058187485, 0.004604517947882414, 0.0014979395782575011, -0.009679856710135937, 0.04392087832093239, -0.01879921182990074, -0.005375206936150789, -0.000529323355294764, 0.0056330375373363495, 0.003651665523648262, 0.021702608093619347, 0.01770062930881977, 0.0016562811797484756, 0.013564130291342735, -0.05856117233633995, 0.0006309142336249352, 0.02499835565686226, -0.0008996045216917992, -0.004753050394356251, 0.00008171057561412454, -0.029078803956508636, 0.012017146684229374, -0.010195517912507057, 0.005504122469574213, 0.006978240329772234, 0.0223527904599905, -0.03040158748626709, -0.015447414480149746, 0.010358063504099846, 0.024886256083846092, -0.00928750541061163, -0.030894828960299492, -0.007079130969941616, -0.015525884926319122, 0.01626574620604515, 0.031858891248703, 0.028473462909460068, -0.004369107075035572, -0.03934718668460846, -0.002564293099567294, -0.002464804332703352, -0.010083417408168316, 0.01789120025932789, 0.02739730104804039, 0.02863040380179882, -0.012600068002939224, 0.011008244939148426, 0.019146721810102463, 0.008626114577054977, 0.012331027537584305, -0.007286516018211842, 0.01503264345228672, 0.0008925982401706278, -0.012151666916906834, 0.0037217282224446535, -0.027711180970072746, -0.011479065753519535, -0.007572371978312731, 0.013821960426867008, 0.0028753713704645634, -0.03452687710523605, -0.036029018461704254, -0.0295272059738636, 0.042732615023851395, -0.013911641202867031, 0.04517640173435211, -0.030020447447896004, 0.02097395621240139, -0.0176894199103117, -0.006451369263231754, 0.0010726592736318707, 0.03080514818429947, -0.004809100646525621, -0.010464558377861977, -0.028383783996105194, -0.012600068002939224, 0.0069894506596028805, 0.0031528195831924677, -0.024146392941474915, 0.02506561577320099, 0.0020920708775520325, -0.01366502046585083, 0.036387741565704346, -0.0038702611345797777, 0.03481833636760712, -0.01294757891446352, -0.017588529735803604, 0.03219519183039665, 0.02679196000099182, -0.0065970998257398605, -0.02221827022731304, 0.004531652666628361, 0.009685461409389973, 0.01789120025932789, 0.0271955206990242, -0.003909496124833822, -0.0115126958116889, -0.029773825779557228, -0.03156743198633194, 0.008037587627768517, 0.023541051894426346, 0.01845170184969902, 0.025177715346217155, 0.030558528378605843, -0.003116386942565441, -0.014023741707205772, -0.009915267117321491, -0.0445486381649971, 0.015694035217165947, -0.012510388158261776, -0.06591494381427765, -0.023406531661748886, -0.017476428300142288, -0.00003792141433223151, 0.03797956556081772, 0.02363073267042637, 0.011905046179890633, 0.02439301460981369, -0.010156282223761082, -0.008536433801054955, 0.014057371765375137, -0.030648209154605865, -0.0022083749063313007, -0.007813387550413609, -0.036925822496414185, -0.02007715404033661, 0.018160240724682808, -0.0005037505179643631, 0.0202789343893528, -0.03551336005330086, 0.0034022426698356867, 0.004803495481610298, 0.00993768684566021, -0.01795846037566662, -0.017162548378109932, -0.007202440872788429, 0.002617540769279003, 0.00870458409190178, -0.04262051358819008, 0.011092320084571838, 0.008396308869123459, -0.016489947214722633, -0.016310585662722588, 0.025020776316523552, 0.012824269011616707, 0.02097395621240139, -0.023339271545410156, 0.010621498338878155, -0.005697495304048061, -0.010470163077116013, -0.021198157221078873, -0.027957802638411522, -0.017252229154109955, -0.028854604810476303, 0.00614869873970747, 0.013026049360632896, -0.05618464574217796, 0.0253570768982172, 0.03441477566957474, -0.015402574092149734, -0.013407190330326557, -0.017106497660279274, -0.017723049968481064, 0.016994398087263107, 0.0022434061393141747, -0.012712168507277966, 0.00705671077594161, -0.03647742047905922, -0.01072238851338625, -0.04318101704120636, 0.014079791493713856, 0.029549626633524895, -0.018888892605900764, 0.006025388371199369, 0.019090672954916954, -0.045333340764045715, 0.017790310084819794, 0.020727336406707764, 0.017532479017972946, 0.006019783206284046, -0.012656117789447308, 0.037889882922172546, 0.004498022608458996, 0.0003853446105495095, -0.001467111986130476, -0.02499835565686226, 0.03889878839254379, -0.030917249619960785, 0.002923014108091593, 0.014292782172560692, -0.0033517975825816393, -0.012375867925584316, -0.003074349369853735, 0.022386420518159866, 0.00700066052377224, 0.008525224402546883, -0.01743158884346485, -0.0058516329154372215, 0.006518629379570484, -0.0032761297188699245, 0.005974943283945322, 0.021500827744603157, -0.015043853782117367, -0.011400595307350159, -0.008329048752784729, 0.011736895889043808, 0.02726278081536293, 0.05026575177907944, 0.01740916818380356, 0.025401916354894638, 0.01905704289674759, -0.0042542046867311, -0.022789981216192245, 0.0046297404915094376, -0.027980221435427666, 0.014819652773439884, -0.002251813653856516, -0.03463897854089737, 0.03484075888991356, 0.008766239508986473, -0.02999802678823471, -0.009612596593797207, -0.010016157291829586, 0.02896670438349247, 0.001858061645179987, -0.015604354441165924, 0.038091663271188736, 0.0193485040217638, -0.03230729326605797, 0.02082822658121586, -0.0035563805140554905, -0.0063841091468930244, 0.01045334804803133, 0.002478816779330373, -0.00798714254051447, 0.016097595915198326, -0.007875042967498302, -0.012185296975076199, 0.01948302425444126, -0.004753050394356251, 0.029123645275831223, 0.005153809208422899, 0.030289487913250923, -0.02034619450569153, -0.09389516711235046, -0.0018804817227646708, 0.04309133440256119, 0.03811408579349518, 0.0020514344796538353, 0.018675900995731354, -0.0070959459990262985, 0.01478602271527052, -0.01864227093756199, -0.021949229761958122, 0.02342895232141018, -0.07246160507202148, 0.014606662094593048, 0.03174678981304169, 0.0445486381649971, -0.03916782885789871, -0.020032314583659172, -0.014685132540762424, 0.018563801422715187, -0.0022658263333141804, 0.005574184935539961, 0.01688229851424694, -0.03506495803594589, 0.0024956318084150553, -0.0025825095362961292, -0.006939005572348833, -0.024639634415507317, 0.01072799414396286, 0.0362083800137043, -0.0072080460377037525, 0.009691067039966583, 0.0014713157434016466, 0.009691067039966583, 0.01817145012319088, -0.021915599703788757, -0.004175734240561724, 0.0022770364303141832, 0.0453781820833683, -0.02062644623219967, 0.0005594503018073738, -0.039459288120269775, -0.0096742520108819, 0.011636005714535713, 0.0026021271478384733, 0.04945863038301468, 0.0325314924120903, 0.026321139186620712, 0.05582592263817787, 0.0027198323514312506, 0.05389780178666115, -0.0015806135488674045, 0.039324767887592316, 0.0042542046867311, 0.017330698668956757, -0.00046276385546661913, 0.03710518404841423, 0.03129839152097702, 0.000058896421251120046, -0.00798714254051447, -0.006372899282723665, -0.009253875352442265, 0.010705573484301567, 0.012073196470737457, -0.006199143826961517, -0.08264030516147614, -0.015189583413302898, -0.03874184563755989, 0.01804814115166664, -0.0248638354241848, -0.033316195011138916, -0.016613256186246872, 0.0513867549598217, 0.033450715243816376, 0.011703265830874443, -0.027778441086411476, -0.016725357621908188, -0.002249011304229498, 0.00480069313198328, -0.04203759506344795, 0.03224003314971924, 0.022509729489684105, -0.018205080181360245, -0.0036656782031059265, 0.0013409992679953575, -0.019213981926441193, 0.02699374035000801, -0.0037609634455293417, -0.014528192579746246, -0.026679858565330505, 0.018418071791529655, 0.024639634415507317, 0.005335971713066101, 0.021781079471111298, -0.016545996069908142, -0.029280586168169975, 0.012353447265923023, 0.0473959855735302, -0.041095953434705734, 0.04125289246439934, -0.026074517518281937, -0.010475768707692623, -0.004346687346696854, -0.019359713420271873, -0.01144543569535017, -0.002379327779635787, -0.02472931519150734, 0.029549626633524895, 0.004649357870221138, 0.013922850601375103, -0.0034582926891744137, -0.0019953844603151083, 0.013250249437987804, -0.018541380763053894, 0.013855590485036373, 0.04118563234806061, 0.00778536219149828, -0.0017151337815448642, 0.006782065145671368, 0.008536433801054955, -0.0035591828636825085, 0.02793538197875023, -0.03203825280070305, -0.00973590649664402, 0.014595452696084976, 0.00744906160980463, -0.0016492749564349651, -0.0094276312738657, 0.006232773885130882, -0.015660405158996582, 0.0620586983859539, -0.014483352191746235, 0.014034951105713844, 0.007942303083837032, -0.015694035217165947, -0.016557207331061363, 0.032352130860090256, 0.010778439231216908, 0.01873195171356201, 0.031589850783348083, 0.005369601771235466, 0.01795846037566662, 0.0011350150452926755, 0.019583914428949356, -0.014561822637915611, 0.033652495592832565, 0.03376459702849388, 0.001402654335834086, -0.03885394707322121, 0.024751735851168633, 0.02281240001320839, 0.0028417413122951984, 0.02446027472615242, -0.036925822496414185, -0.016826247796416283, -0.010974614880979061, -0.004531652666628361, -0.012757008895277977, 0.03053610771894455, -0.007667656987905502, -0.010447743348777294, 0.02234157919883728, 0.05820244923233986, -0.03161226958036423, -0.013956480659544468, -0.029392685741186142, 0.021209366619586945, -0.021769868209958076, 0.02076096646487713, -0.012387077324092388, -0.017812728881835938, 0.0022728326730430126, -0.016624467447400093, 0.00013907437096349895, 0.0022952526342123747, -0.007611606735736132, -0.004907188471406698, -0.015043853782117367, -0.009259480983018875, 0.029751406982541084, 0.014191891998052597, 0.013676230795681477, -0.023182332515716553, 0.0260296780616045, 0.01039169356226921, 0.028473462909460068, -0.018765581771731377, -0.022251900285482407, -0.010604683309793472, -0.004399934783577919, 0.014023741707205772, -0.02240883931517601, 0.02542433701455593, -0.00705671077594161, 0.02923574484884739, 0.023967033252120018, 0.010711179114878178, -0.021030006930232048, 0.0348631776869297, 0.011114739812910557, -0.010066602379083633, -0.03564788028597832, -0.04277745634317398, 0.0052743167616426945, -0.024953516200184822, -0.00042913376819342375, 0.004329872317612171, -0.015189583413302898, 0.006776459980756044, -0.048875708132982254, -0.029459945857524872, 0.01332871988415718, 0.020099574699997902, 0.027643920853734016, 0.0290339644998312, 0.04284471645951271, -0.03750874474644661, 0.015963075682520866, -0.0062383790500462055, -0.03883152827620506, -0.03907814621925354, 0.04658886417746544, -0.0218595489859581, -0.01288031879812479, 0.049907032400369644, -0.013709860853850842, 0.05057963356375694, 0.006529839709401131, 0.00006944960477994755, -0.00028743204893544316, -0.006557864602655172, -0.04118563234806061, 0.022789981216192245, 0.005307946819812059, -0.02282361127436161, -0.02972898632287979, -0.02219584956765175, -0.0009059101575985551, 0.004397132433950901, 0.007292121183127165, 0.0009801766136661172, 0.033854275941848755, -0.0189337320625782, -0.017375538125634193, -0.025670956820249557, 0.028406202793121338, -0.00043859222205355763, 0.023384112864732742, -0.02815958298742771, 0.028473462909460068, 0.005473294761031866, 0.002043026965111494, 0.016960768029093742, -0.0315450094640255, -0.008216948248445988, 0.010447743348777294, 0.02166897803544998, -0.02466205507516861, 0.038024403154850006, 0.01939334347844124, 0.006653149612247944, 0.003845038590952754, 0.012174087576568127, -0.03107418864965439, -0.039257507771253586, 0.0413874126970768, -0.014203101396560669, -0.011501485481858253, 0.0013795336708426476, 0.03244181349873543, -0.009758327156305313, -0.000934635812882334, -0.004035608842968941, 0.02015562541782856, 0.011792946606874466, 0.005481702275574207, 0.02213979884982109, -0.0067708552815020084, 0.0040215966291725636, -0.04111837223172188, 0.0005261705373413861, -0.041858233511447906, 0.016164856031537056, -0.02663501910865307, 0.015155953355133533, -0.02515529654920101, -0.011680846102535725, 0.0014685132773593068, 0.007622817065566778, 0.0036544681061059237, -0.0032985499128699303, -0.028652824461460114, 0.017050448805093765, 0.02522255666553974, -0.006305639166384935, 0.020794596523046494, -0.017521269619464874, 0.014191891998052597, -0.009786351583898067, 0.0021242997609078884, -0.0011203018948435783, -0.013418399728834629, -0.032083090394735336, -0.008362678810954094, -0.010638313367962837, 0.01980811357498169, -0.00693340040743351, -0.007572371978312731, -0.014528192579746246, 0.002953841583803296, -0.010621498338878155, 0.011591166257858276, -0.02656775899231434, 0.014752392657101154, 0.0005685584619641304, 0.0196063332259655, -0.02446027472615242, 0.005481702275574207, 0.007701287046074867, -0.02082822658121586, -0.008401913568377495, -0.013653810136020184, 0.004130894318223, 0.016108805313706398, -0.012073196470737457, -0.008564459159970284, -0.03860732540488243, -0.0045568752102553844, 0.012521597556769848, 0.020738545805215836, 0.00812726840376854, 0.00369650567881763, 0.027509400621056557, 0.005509727168828249, -0.026814380660653114, -0.04475041851401329, 0.010733598843216896, 0.0038954836782068014, 0.004231784492731094, 0.053942639380693436, -0.004399934783577919, -0.0004063633969053626, 0.01110352948307991, -0.017644578590989113, 0.0038394336588680744, -0.0019925818778574467, 0.02282361127436161, -0.01079525426030159, 0.0008736813324503601, -0.03804682567715645, 0.03656710311770439, 0.05479460209608078, 0.016019126400351524, -0.026971319690346718, -0.007320146542042494, -0.008581274189054966, 0.006513024680316448, 0.031388070434331894, 0.015279264189302921, 0.012734588235616684, -0.02030135504901409, 0.008519618771970272, 0.01920277252793312, 0.00021614329307340086, 0.03721728175878525, 0.056812405586242676, -0.00812726840376854, -0.0014601057628169656, 0.004977250937372446, -0.04360699653625488, 0.0031051768455654383, 0.0077068922109901905, -0.007796572521328926, -0.017028028145432472, 0.002805308671668172, 0.007107155863195658, 0.004982856102287769, 0.016557207331061363, 0.006759644951671362, 0.007818992249667645, 0.04640950262546539, 0.002303660148754716, 0.01968480460345745, -0.030894828960299492, 0.03694824129343033, -0.003920706454664469, 0.0021677385084331036, 0.00785262230783701, 0.024482695385813713, 0.012622487731277943, -0.005484504625201225, 0.03286779299378395, 0.009657436981797218, 0.023944612592458725, -0.024101553484797478, -0.025469176471233368, 0.012061987072229385, 0.027217941358685493, 0.02030135504901409, 0.01164721604436636, -0.030042866244912148, -0.001988378120586276, 0.012005936354398727, -0.02643323875963688, 0.0005279221222735941, 0.0031247944571077824, 0.021881969645619392, 0.017454009503126144, 0.04501945897936821, 0.019976263865828514, -0.005733927711844444, -0.0007412629202008247, -0.019303662702441216, -0.011456645093858242, 0.015828555449843407, 0.02137751691043377, -0.013227829709649086, 0.018956152722239494, 0.03006528690457344, -0.011019454337656498, 0.0016142436070367694, -0.01728585921227932, 0.01721859909594059, -0.024975934997200966, 0.0029930765740573406, 0.011187604628503323, -0.004301846958696842, -0.050041552633047104, 0.01980811357498169, -0.007572371978312731, -0.023653153330087662, -0.0008057205704972148, -0.045535121113061905, -0.02363073267042637, 0.006557864602655172, -0.03129839152097702, 0.007269700989127159, 0.01870953105390072, 0.023339271545410156, -0.04618530347943306, 0.06578042358160019, -0.0241912342607975, 0.010621498338878155, 0.024639634415507317, 0.004486812278628349, 0.014124631881713867, -0.0057115075178444386, -0.01653478667140007, -0.025446755811572075, 0.0021004783920943737, -0.013900430873036385, -0.027038579806685448, 0.032352130860090256, 0.008244973607361317, 0.0018804817227646708, 0.016355426982045174, 0.020178044214844704, 0.002181751187890768, -0.03759842365980148, 0.010509398765861988, -0.00857006385922432, 0.022700300440192223, 0.00595812825486064, 0.05389780178666115, 0.033361032605171204, 0.014539401978254318, 0.04575932025909424, 0.03468381613492966, -0.017532479017972946, -0.011260470375418663, -0.02336169220507145, 0.01339598000049591, 0.017924830317497253, -0.01083448901772499, -0.03721728175878525, -0.05075899139046669, -0.01743158884346485, 0.02192680910229683, -0.04015430808067322, 0.0067708552815020084, 0.013900430873036385, -0.03683614358305931, -0.00194634054787457, -0.004562480375170708, -0.00030459740082733333, -0.009719091467559338, 0.017532479017972946, 0.0008008161676116288, -0.025536436587572098, -0.010576658882200718, -0.02159050852060318, 0.019628753885626793, -0.021086057648062706, -0.021287837997078896, -0.033652495592832565, 0.011041874997317791, 0.0017739864997565746, 0.009567756205797195, 0.0124319177120924, 0.01554830465465784, -0.027643920853734016, -0.01314935926347971, 0.0013227829476818442, -0.0066027045249938965, 0.002162133576348424, 0.0012758409138768911, -0.001541378442198038, -0.04183581471443176, -0.005812398158013821, -0.005218266509473324, -0.01927003264427185, 0.012005936354398727, 0.054346200078725815, -0.005557369906455278, 0.032083090394735336, 0.05116255581378937, -0.007213651202619076, -0.02459479495882988, -0.015144743956625462, -0.02479657530784607, -0.02179228886961937, -0.015727665275335312, -0.048337627202272415, -0.002410155488178134, 0.0008582675363868475, -0.02923574484884739, -0.033159252256155014, 0.018552592024207115, -0.010397298261523247, 0.0009871828369796276, 0.03250907361507416, -0.025917578488588333, -0.03717244416475296, 0.0009920871816575527, -0.003150017000734806, -0.02800264209508896, -0.004876360762864351, 0.003391032572835684, 0.002642763312906027, 0.0423738956451416, -0.028338942676782608, -0.00406363420188427, -0.022576989606022835, 0.027240360155701637, 0.02091790735721588, -0.003388229990378022, 0.04466073960065842, 0.03753116354346275, -0.033159252256155014, -0.02542433701455593, 0.0002783238887786865, 0.010879329405725002, -0.012375867925584316, 0.02896670438349247, -0.014326412230730057, 0.012375867925584316, 0.005369601771235466, 0.016545996069908142, 0.01483086310327053, 0.012532807886600494, 0.024975934997200966, 0.012779428623616695, -0.004593307618051767, -0.010531818494200706, 0.013922850601375103, 0.013978901319205761, 0.015581934712827206, -0.00966864638030529, -0.019796904176473618, -0.03862974792718887, -0.0023499014787375927, 0.016725357621908188, 0.013575340621173382, 0.007970327511429787, 0.0038282235618680716, -0.00013767312339041382, 0.0030042866710573435, 0.03862974792718887, -0.00291180401109159, 0.016960768029093742, 0.029123645275831223, -0.028114743530750275, -0.050176072865724564, -0.007045500911772251, -0.045400600880384445, -0.019382134079933167, 0.008659744635224342, -0.02383251301944256, 0.024415435269474983, -0.010245962999761105, 0.028025062754750252, -0.021949229761958122, -0.013227829709649086, 0.022644249722361565, 0.0038506435230374336, 0.011613585986196995, 0.024437854066491127, 0.025850318372249603, -0.0011013849871233106, 0.0022728326730430126, 0.0177678894251585, -0.01191625650972128, 0.04017673060297966, -0.011266075074672699, 0.008497199043631554, 0.005605012644082308, -0.015492254868149757, 0.04046818986535072, -0.021680187433958054, -0.022106168791651726, 0.03416815772652626, -0.001848252839408815, 0.028585564345121384, 0.029818667098879814, 0.011053084395825863, 0.01458424236625433, 0.03190373256802559, -0.009259480983018875, -0.005369601771235466, -0.0068493252620100975, -0.012218927033245564, 0.046768225729465485, -0.036320481449365616, -0.015525884926319122, -0.004108474124222994, 0.016209695488214493, 0.009259480983018875, 0.0018328391015529633, -0.013317509554326534, 0.02336169220507145, -0.028338942676782608, 0.04031125083565712, -0.028518304228782654, -0.009506100788712502, 0.011602375656366348, -0.023473791778087616, 0.039459288120269775, 0.01749884895980358, -0.0038954836782068014, -0.015794925391674042, 0.02268909104168415, 0.03804682567715645, 0.016007915139198303, 0.0020150020718574524, -0.0200211051851511, 0.03374217450618744, -0.008755029179155827, -0.007303331047296524, 0.016489947214722633, 0.005649852566421032, 0.0014138644328340888, 0.009713486768305302, 0.024684475734829903, -0.010716783814132214, -0.04347247630357742, -0.01045895367860794, 0.0010257172398269176, 0.023339271545410156, 0.02699374035000801, -0.04349489510059357, 0.010772833600640297, 0.016635676845908165, 0.019639963284134865, -0.006092648487538099, 0.050041552633047104, -0.02050313539803028, -0.014214311726391315, -0.02090669609606266, 0.02813716232776642, 0.004750248044729233, 0.04398813843727112, 0.0008288412354886532, 0.019729644060134888, 0.01431520190089941, 0.027150681242346764, 0.05528784170746803, -0.00816650316119194, 0.01873195171356201, 0.014427302405238152, 0.010290803387761116, 0.011069899424910545, 0.017184969037771225, -0.04360699653625488, 0.03226245194673538, 0.02856314368546009, -0.006070228759199381, -0.0032312897965312004, 0.023473791778087616, 0.005204254295676947, 0.0004025099624413997, 0.0056638652458786964, -0.005288329441100359, -0.026814380660653114, 0.010128257796168327, -0.023204751312732697, -0.01346324011683464, 0.048068586736917496, -0.007527531590312719, -0.0003263168327976018, -0.022038908675312996, -0.012902738526463509, 0.020929116755723953, -0.0011034868657588959, -0.0038142111152410507, -0.0007398616289719939, 0.03347313404083252, 0.010974614880979061, 0.01728585921227932, -0.007364986464381218, -0.006070228759199381, -0.030020447447896004, -0.017454009503126144, 0.026836799457669258, 0.001390043064020574, -0.0072584911249578, 0.0018174252472817898, 0.0223527904599905, 0.004809100646525621, -0.0008869932498782873, -0.005703100003302097, -0.008317838422954082, 0.03306957334280014, 0.018395651131868362, -0.01113155484199524, 0.0012835478410124779, -0.03654468059539795, -0.04856183007359505, -0.018294760957360268, -0.007555556949228048, 0.024639634415507317, -0.0027324436232447624, 0.033450715243816376, 0.006625124718993902, 0.016030335798859596, -0.0147636029869318, -0.03459413722157478, -0.02739730104804039, -0.023249592632055283, 0.0038198160473257303, -0.027016161009669304 ]
11.750046
6.079476
2024-06-01
0
2024MNRAS.530.3752S
[ "galaxy sizes", "galaxy size residuals", "intrinsic galaxy sizes", "galaxy properties", "observable galaxy properties", "galaxy velocities", "galaxy physics", "galaxies", "an accurate intrinsic galaxy size predictor", "limited correlation" ]
[ "gravitational lensing: weak", "methods: statistical", "large-scale structure of Universe", "cosmology: observations", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
8
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae768", "10.48550/arXiv.2310.18177" ]
[ "Schafer, Chad", "Singh, Sukhdeep", "Jagvaral, Yesukhei" ]
[ "Department of Statistics &amp; Data Science, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA; McWilliams Center for Cosmology, Department of Physics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA; NSF AI Planning Institute, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA", "McWilliams Center for Cosmology, Department of Physics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA; NSF AI Planning Institute, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA", "McWilliams Center for Cosmology, Department of Physics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA; NSF AI Planning Institute, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA" ]
null
[ "1985ApJ...292..371D", "1987ApJ...313...42D", "1987ApJ...313...59D", "1990smod.conf.....W", "1995PhR...261..271S", "2001MNRAS.328..726S", "2002MNRAS.330..443B", "2006ApJ...648L..17B", "2010MNRAS.401..791S", "2015MNRAS.454..478J", "2016MNRAS.462.2668T", "2017MNRAS.464.2120S", "2017MNRAS.465.3291W", "2017MNRAS.472.3936B", "2018MNRAS.473.4077P", "2018MNRAS.475..624N", "2018MNRAS.475..648P", "2018MNRAS.475..676S", "2018MNRAS.477.1206N", "2018MNRAS.480.5113M", "2019ComAC...6....2N", "2020ApJ...895..139D", "2021MNRAS.501.4167S", "2022MNRAS.509.1764J", "2022MNRAS.516.2406J" ]
28998437
null
Estimation of stellar mass and star formation rate based on galaxy images
It is crucial for a deeper understanding of the formation and evolution of galaxies in the Universe to study stellar mass (M<SUB>*</SUB>) and star formation rate (SFR). Traditionally, astronomers infer the properties of galaxies from spectra, which are highly informative, but expensive and hard to be obtained. Fortunately, modern sky surveys obtained a vast amount of high-spatial-resolution photometric images. The photometric images are obtained relatively economically than spectra, and it is very helpful for related studies if M<SUB>*</SUB> and SFR can be estimated from photometric images. Therefore, this paper conducted some preliminary researches and explorations on this regard. We constructed a deep learning model named Galaxy Efficient Network (GalEffNet) for estimating integrated M<SUB>*</SUB> and specific star formation rate (sSFR) from Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument galaxy images. The GalEffNet primarily consists of a general feature extraction module and a parameter feature extractor. The research results indicate that the proposed GalEffNet exhibits good performance in estimating M<SUB>*</SUB> and sSFR, with σ reaching 0.218 and 0.410 dex. To further assess the robustness of the network, prediction uncertainty was performed. The results show that our model maintains good consistency within a reasonable bias range. We also compared the performance of various network architectures and further tested the proposed scheme using image sets with various resolutions and wavelength bands. Furthermore, we conducted applicability analysis on galaxies of various sizes, redshifts, and morphological types. The results indicate that our model performs well across galaxies with various characteristics and indicate its potentials of broad applicability.
[ 0.04461386427283287, 0.0015133199049159884, -0.0050292713567614555, -0.01572604663670063, 0.006943968590348959, 0.014659489504992962, -0.0017714494606480002, 0.04014340043067932, -0.027685103937983513, 0.0374656617641449, -0.021989233791828156, -0.01572604663670063, -0.056958697736263275, -0.030998239293694496, 0.04851701110601425, 0.019867464900016785, -0.01753011718392372, 0.025733530521392822, 0.02004900760948658, 0.013252541422843933, 0.010251430794596672, 0.00007880397606641054, -0.02117229625582695, 0.004918644204735756, -0.031043624505400658, -0.03764720261096954, -0.01281003374606371, 0.0391676127910614, 0.022511165589094162, -0.03045361302793026, -0.01442121621221304, -0.012299447320401669, -0.059772592037916183, -0.020820559933781624, -0.03238249570131302, 0.102571040391922, -0.03172440454363823, 0.003338664537295699, -0.05478019639849663, -0.011312315240502357, -0.021989233791828156, 0.020741134881973267, 0.004192477557808161, 0.01799531653523445, -0.01633874885737896, -0.06426575034856796, -0.01753011718392372, -0.033222123980522156, 0.028297806158661842, -0.0008006271091289818, -0.051194749772548676, 0.001728900708258152, -0.011232890188694, -0.053055550903081894, -0.004495992790907621, -0.005091676488518715, -0.032564036548137665, -0.022987712174654007, -0.025756223127245903, 0.040914952754974365, -0.0005417884094640613, -0.01146549079567194, 0.017541462555527687, 0.024871207773685455, -0.03442483767867088, 0.010813075117766857, -0.0009764955611899495, 0.02439466118812561, -0.0011637103743851185, 0.0174393467605114, -0.02496197819709778, -0.023486953228712082, 0.03855491057038307, -0.026527775451540947, 0.007834657095372677, -0.018471864983439445, 0.006790793035179377, 0.02080921269953251, -0.018154166638851166, -0.010506724007427692, 0.03136132284998894, -0.01540834829211235, -0.00428608525544405, -0.0044165682047605515, -0.04547618702054024, -0.006195109337568283, -0.03365328535437584, -0.060135677456855774, -0.06040798872709274, 0.027390098199248314, -0.021875770762562752, 0.006631943862885237, 0.010461337864398956, 0.021104218438267708, 0.014194289222359657, 0.006909929681569338, -0.0022295585367828608, -0.04942471906542778, 0.051194749772548676, 0.0308166965842247, 0.03567293658852577, 0.043116144835948944, 0.016100475564599037, -0.07415977120399475, 0.03315404802560806, -0.025597374886274338, 0.0246442798525095, -0.0031996718607842922, 0.01767762005329132, -0.0017430835869163275, 0.018891679123044014, -0.01712164841592312, -0.0050292713567614555, 0.02786664478480816, 0.013127731159329414, -0.041527654975652695, -0.06467422097921371, 0.01018335297703743, -0.016735872253775597, -0.0015218297485262156, -0.021739613264799118, 0.03469714894890785, 0.03138401359319687, 0.0292282085865736, 0.055370207875967026, -0.015499119646847248, 0.02036670595407486, -0.020843252539634705, -0.020309973508119583, 0.01790454611182213, 0.048290081322193146, -0.02475774474442005, 0.029682062566280365, -0.03154286369681358, -0.03755643218755722, -0.023350795730948448, -0.023282717913389206, -0.0197313092648983, -0.03333558887243271, -0.007397822570055723, -0.01555585116147995, 0.03201941028237343, -0.010240084491670132, 0.05096781998872757, -0.031225165352225304, 0.008237453177571297, -0.03108900971710682, 0.009496898390352726, -0.019379572942852974, 0.02532506175339222, 0.004992395639419556, -0.0059852018021047115, -0.011879632249474525, -0.06553654372692108, -0.007318398449569941, -0.06072568520903587, -0.03297250345349312, 0.008078604005277157, 0.005457596387714148, -0.00706310523673892, -0.004617966245859861, 0.05074089393019676, -0.019867464900016785, 0.04332038015127182, -0.016713179647922516, 0.05940951034426689, -0.052828624844551086, -0.006229148246347904, -0.04801777005195618, -0.042503442615270615, -0.02085459791123867, 0.03501484915614128, 0.02197788842022419, -0.05369094759225845, 0.026777395978569984, -0.0084246676415205, -0.025574682280421257, 0.01716703362762928, -0.029114743694663048, -0.020423436537384987, -0.031905945390462875, 0.02729932777583599, -0.009559303522109985, -0.03333558887243271, -0.02562006749212742, 0.0018905862234532833, -0.007800618186593056, 0.047926999628543854, 0.02925090119242668, -0.02369118668138981, 0.009207566268742085, 0.018381092697381973, -0.01282138004899025, 0.018573980778455734, -0.0263462346047163, 0.0031230838503688574, 0.009496898390352726, 0.021285759285092354, -0.01792723871767521, 0.017541462555527687, 0.029908988624811172, 0.049288559705019, 0.015975667163729668, -0.02786664478480816, 0.019481690600514412, -0.05809333175420761, -0.01619124785065651, -0.027730489149689674, -0.015521812252700329, 0.01731453649699688, 0.02507544308900833, 0.03821451961994171, 0.006473094690591097, -0.0022295585367828608, -0.054734811186790466, 0.03167901933193207, -0.023963499814271927, 0.017178378999233246, 0.023112522438168526, 0.018256284296512604, -0.027821259573101997, -0.0067056952975690365, 0.05800256133079529, -0.01606643758714199, 0.02986360341310501, -0.025166213512420654, 0.017915893346071243, -0.058819498866796494, 0.006796466186642647, -0.0550525076687336, 0.004096033982932568, 0.020457476377487183, -0.019152645021677017, -0.002050853567197919, -0.010693938471376896, -0.03660333901643753, -0.001937389955855906, 0.012061174027621746, 0.022091351449489594, -0.037420276552438736, -0.017064915969967842, 0.04661082103848457, -0.01619124785065651, 0.008061584085226059, -0.029341671615839005, 0.027798566967248917, 0.006921275984495878, -0.023895421996712685, 0.02661854587495327, 0.017246458679437637, 0.021285759285092354, -0.021875770762562752, -0.034152526408433914, -0.04661082103848457, -0.011811554431915283, -0.001998376566916704, -0.022545205429196358, 0.009394780732691288, -0.04629312455654144, 0.0010474103037267923, -0.03912222757935524, 0.020400743931531906, -0.02891051024198532, 0.0058717383071780205, -0.023089829832315445, 0.0194363035261631, -0.024803129956126213, 0.015465080738067627, -0.028365883976221085, 0.018721483647823334, 0.015238153748214245, -0.03442483767867088, 0.032564036548137665, -0.01538565568625927, -0.022726746276021004, 0.04427347332239151, -0.004666188266128302, 0.05046858265995979, 0.02119498886168003, -0.03047630749642849, -0.0221707746386528, -0.03156555816531181, 0.0446365550160408, 0.02471235953271389, -0.01799531653523445, 0.02104748599231243, 0.01797262392938137, -0.04838085174560547, -0.04779084399342537, -0.012753302231431007, 0.06449267268180847, -0.052783239632844925, 0.017473384737968445, 0.029046665877103806, -0.02119498886168003, -0.05718562379479408, 0.018551288172602654, 0.03878183662891388, 0.011652705259621143, 0.033812135457992554, 0.046701591461896896, -0.007675808388739824, -0.013910629786550999, 0.03403906151652336, -0.07706443220376968, -0.004541378002613783, 0.017030877992510796, 0.010342201218008995, -0.007607730105519295, 0.0051711006090044975, 0.013740434311330318, 0.009286990389227867, 0.04334307089447975, -0.00429175840690732, -0.04395577684044838, -0.0012339160311967134, -0.00425488268956542, -0.018369747325778008, 0.0374656617641449, -0.011601646430790424, -0.023260025307536125, -0.04105110839009285, -0.001971428981050849, -0.005315766669809818, 0.003937184810638428, -0.04674697667360306, -0.02630084753036499, -0.013297926634550095, -0.05105859413743019, 0.000827574694994837, 0.030567077919840813, 0.019470343366265297, 0.030589770525693893, -0.0177003126591444, 0.000026570856789476238, -0.013377351686358452, -0.014659489504992962, 0.01765492744743824, 0.013331965543329716, -0.0263462346047163, -0.020525554195046425, -0.027458176016807556, 0.010835767723619938, 0.024326583370566368, 0.0630403459072113, 0.016815297305583954, 0.018233589828014374, 0.03937184810638428, 0.07098279148340225, 0.006297226529568434, 0.015816817060112953, 0.008055911399424076, 0.012866765260696411, -0.04050648212432861, 0.006836178246885538, -0.025166213512420654, 0.00006834405212430283, -0.04756391420960426, 0.015476427040994167, -0.009099775925278664, -0.017915893346071243, -0.019186684861779213, 0.04706467688083649, -0.005117205437272787, -0.028070880100131035, -0.018766868859529495, -0.018528595566749573, 0.04992395639419556, -0.037057191133499146, -0.04815392568707466, -0.026845473796129227, 0.006166743580251932, -0.0250527486205101, -0.012730608694255352, -0.0538724884390831, -0.009394780732691288, -0.019958237186074257, 0.016293363645672798, -0.036421794444322586, 0.05464404076337814, 0.039939165115356445, 0.021796345710754395, -0.021206336095929146, -0.07706443220376968, 0.006444728933274746, 0.004972539376467466, 0.015794124454259872, -0.021263066679239273, -0.05559713393449783, 0.030703233554959297, -0.038713760673999786, -0.031905945390462875, -0.032269030809402466, -0.015465080738067627, 0.026232769712805748, -0.010103927925229073, 0.0391676127910614, 0.05777563527226448, 0.004535704851150513, 0.04207228124141693, -0.020185163244605064, -0.0365806445479393, -0.012310793623328209, -0.04368346184492111, -0.01890302635729313, 0.008282838389277458, -0.010501050390303135, 0.03909953683614731, 0.038691066205501556, 0.0016849335515871644, 0.05478019639849663, -0.061724163591861725, 0.01104000210762024, -0.03553678095340729, -0.037737973034381866, 0.0087196733802557, -0.016713179647922516, 0.05909181013703346, -0.0501054972410202, 0.05273785442113876, 0.03183786943554878, -0.03043092042207718, 0.0037301138509064913, 0.015714699402451515, 0.007199261337518692, -0.02341887541115284, 0.024576202034950256, 0.02161480486392975, -0.03555947169661522, -0.03555947169661522, -0.025824300944805145, 0.023963499814271927, 0.04774545878171921, 0.01928880251944065, -0.01232213992625475, -0.0292282085865736, 0.027390098199248314, -0.016179900616407394, -0.011754822917282581, 0.024803129956126213, 0.04783622920513153, -0.04354730620980263, -0.018505902960896492, -0.04136880487203598, 0.031633634120225906, -0.030703233554959297, -0.00697233434766531, 0.06707964092493057, 0.022965019568800926, -0.01931149512529373, 0.005327112972736359, -0.02000362239778042, 0.01767762005329132, 0.030067838728427887, -0.04238997772336006, -0.06063491478562355, 0.010546435602009296, -0.023668494075536728, 0.024167733266949654, -0.03147478401660919, -0.00025972514413297176, -0.025846993550658226, 0.008106970228254795, 0.041822660714387894, 0.004478973336517811, 0.035718321800231934, -0.021240374073386192, -0.0023373488802462816, -0.0027954578399658203, -0.007846003398299217, 0.03440214693546295, -0.03181517496705055, 0.030930161476135254, -0.008969292975962162, 0.015805471688508987, 0.016940105706453323, -0.02080921269953251, -0.03265480697154999, 0.048653166741132736, 0.026777395978569984, 0.02242039516568184, 0.01284407265484333, -0.01865340583026409, -0.017269151285290718, -0.005392354913055897, 0.022068658843636513, 0.0005928470054641366, 0.025733530521392822, -0.014965840615332127, -0.004252046346664429, -0.00036006944719702005, -0.040052630007267, 0.04883470758795738, -0.008691307157278061, -0.011068368330597878, -0.04579388350248337, -0.05046858265995979, -0.032246336340904236, 0.009723825380206108, 0.02886512503027916, 0.056595612317323685, -0.0194363035261631, 0.019799387082457542, 0.023350795730948448, -0.005026435013860464, -0.002301891567185521, -0.024281198158860207, -0.02954590506851673, -0.026119306683540344, -0.015192767605185509, -0.018676098436117172, 0.06344880908727646, 0.031656328588724136, 0.033244818449020386, 0.03297250345349312, 0.03074861876666546, -0.05464404076337814, 0.015476427040994167, -0.0003061742754653096, 0.017938585951924324, 0.023804649710655212, -0.026777395978569984, -0.0020054681226611137, 0.012027135118842125, 0.02598315104842186, -0.018846293911337852, -0.03619486838579178, -0.08877387642860413, -0.02788933739066124, -0.02083190530538559, 0.015022573061287403, -0.03201941028237343, 0.03555947169661522, 0.008192067965865135, -0.02314656227827072, -0.03950800374150276, -0.011505203321576118, 0.003443618305027485, -0.028297806158661842, 0.020275933668017387, 0.025597374886274338, -0.01841513253748417, 0.010030176490545273, 0.014148903079330921, -0.007386476267129183, 0.005888757761567831, -0.0018225080566480756, -0.006308572832494974, 0.011238563805818558, -0.02532506175339222, 0.036739494651556015, -0.013842551968991756, 0.03580909222364426, -0.0034748208709061146, -0.0417545810341835, 0.05155783146619797, -0.005341296084225178, -0.010892500169575214, 0.007891389541327953, -0.026096614077687263, 0.004964029882103205, 0.008804770186543465, 0.002670648042112589, 0.008799097500741482, -0.0219098087400198, -0.009911039844155312, -0.0012183147482573986, -0.037964899092912674, -0.04622504487633705, 0.00875371228903532, -0.0014239674201235175, -0.009054390713572502, 0.036399103701114655, -0.04683775082230568, -0.007193588186055422, 0.006240494549274445, -0.0354006253182888, 0.016928760334849358, 0.013717741705477238, -0.019005142152309418, -0.01316177099943161, -0.007278685923665762, 0.0012984484201297164, 0.002161480486392975, -0.032564036548137665, -0.022352317348122597, 0.004183968063443899, -0.022011926397681236, 0.013366005383431911, -0.022817518562078476, 0.012707916088402271, 0.0028578629717230797, -0.005131388548761606, -0.028070880100131035, -0.008504092693328857, -0.00824312586337328, 0.0015998359303921461, -0.006688675843179226, -0.009218912571668625, 0.02024189569056034, 0.011913671158254147, 0.014319098554551601, -0.04009801521897316, -0.03841875493526459, 0.0041953143663704395, 0.00580649683251977, 0.004921481013298035, -0.0019544095266610384, -0.0339936763048172, 0.011567607522010803, -0.005630628205835819, 0.010449991561472416, -0.02691355161368847, -0.03633102402091026, -0.0009304010309278965, 0.019935544580221176, 0.02761702612042427, 0.013615624979138374, 0.03841875493526459, 0.013127731159329414, -0.004226516932249069, -0.01701953075826168, 0.01572604663670063, -0.005633464548736811, 0.06639886647462845, -0.007017720025032759, -0.026868166401982307, -0.029613982886075974, -0.03213287517428398, -0.047336988151073456, -0.005661830771714449, -0.02004900760948658, 0.046973906457424164, -0.028797045350074768, -0.02000362239778042, -0.011323661543428898, 0.020400743931531906, 0.01956111378967762, -0.027004322037100792, -0.014693528413772583, 0.011130773462355137, 0.007817638106644154, 0.011420105583965778, -0.03696642071008682, -0.01860802061855793, -0.00013801775639876723, -0.011266929097473621, -0.011442798189818859, -0.05555174872279167, -0.004583926871418953, -0.0021373694762587547, -0.006336938589811325, 0.01026845071464777, 0.01395601499825716, 0.019629191607236862, 0.023328103125095367, -0.009468532167375088, 0.03172440454363823, -0.05164860188961029, 0.01282138004899025, -0.004856239538639784, 0.0544624999165535, 0.008946600370109081, -0.004947010427713394, -0.008799097500741482, 0.004935664124786854, -0.007448881398886442, 0.028819739818572998, -0.015033919364213943, 0.006717041600495577, 0.035128310322761536, 0.008980639278888702, -0.04450039938092232, 0.010330854915082455, -0.04454578459262848, -0.028138957917690277, 0.00032886696862988174, -0.0677604228258133, -0.02625546231865883, 0.009530937299132347, -0.01318446360528469, 0.034515608102083206, 0.005046290811151266, -0.005242015700787306, 0.0007243937579914927, 0.014636796899139881, 0.016928760334849358, 0.003106064395979047, 0.0292282085865736, -0.0019785205367952585, 0.020945370197296143, 0.004615129437297583, 0.032200951129198074, 0.015635276213288307, -0.007959467358887196, 0.005091676488518715, 0.02263597585260868, 0.02161480486392975, -0.014648143202066422, -0.03789682313799858, 0.029750140383839607, 0.03365328535437584, -0.02952321246266365, 0.0010679755359888077, -0.013320619240403175, -0.007687154691666365, -0.037692587822675705, 0.008855829015374184, 0.008799097500741482, -0.03567293658852577, 0.017348574474453926, 0.028320498764514923, -0.006677329074591398, 0.0015870712231844664, 0.03197402507066727, -0.012730608694255352, 0.01841513253748417, 0.0033613573759794235, 0.010115274228155613, -0.025393139570951462, -0.06903121620416641, 0.006637617014348507, -0.07248050719499588, -0.01395601499825716, 0.013036960735917091, -0.04801777005195618, 0.010557781904935837, 0.01826762966811657, -0.013592932373285294, -0.020627671852707863, 0.010506724007427692, -0.017257804051041603, -0.005939816124737263, -0.0532824769616127, -0.017382614314556122, -0.022794825956225395, -0.007999179884791374, -0.011664051562547684, -0.005956835579127073, -0.00713118351995945, -0.010665572248399258, 0.005338459741324186, -0.004351326730102301, 0.0051086959429085255, -0.025529297068715096, -0.016429521143436432, 0.01621394045650959, -0.004059158265590668, -0.009445839561522007, -0.016440866515040398, -0.011578953824937344, 0.00721628125756979, 0.006132704205811024, 0.011505203321576118, 0.015238153748214245, -0.030317457392811775, 0.016769910231232643, 0.005176773760467768, 0.03274557739496231, 0.012741954997181892, 0.03558216616511345, 0.0414595790207386, 0.04438693821430206, 0.031202472746372223, -0.01863071322441101, -0.013785820454359055, -0.015079304575920105, 0.009366415441036224, 0.010614514350891113, -0.003412415971979499, -0.010750669986009598, 0.01281003374606371, 0.029023973271250725, 0.006580885499715805, 0.029908988624811172, 0.02369118668138981, 0.015011225827038288, -0.020593632012605667, -0.027458176016807556, 0.025801608338952065, -0.024530816823244095, -0.032586727291345596, 0.03567293658852577, -0.003965550567954779, 0.0015743066323921084, 0.006098665297031403, -0.026051228865981102, 0.002689085900783539, -0.009190546348690987, -0.04268498346209526, -0.006773773115128279, 0.04143688455224037, -0.03276827186346054, 0.009474205784499645, -0.015760086476802826, 0.03521908074617386, -0.025188906118273735, -0.06866813451051712, 0.024893900379538536, 0.026414312422275543, 0.011000290513038635, 0.018551288172602654, -0.0002061845298158005, -0.010359221138060093, 0.03338097408413887, -0.021580765023827553, 0.009139488451182842, 0.018131474032998085, -0.042843833565711975, 0.004671861417591572, 0.04357000067830086, 0.04168650507926941, -0.03841875493526459, -0.008407648652791977, 0.00413858238607645, -0.02664123848080635, 0.008447360247373581, -0.03074861876666546, 0.015453734435141087, 0.0014218399301171303, -0.01619124785065651, 0.011425778269767761, -0.01443256251513958, -0.04422808811068535, -0.043751541525125504, 0.026232769712805748, 0.013604278676211834, -0.016350096091628075, -0.03823721408843994, 0.02754894644021988, 0.01298022922128439, -0.008038891479372978, 0.019992275163531303, -0.007482920307666063, 0.020309973508119583, -0.023827342316508293, 0.012719262391328812, -0.026732010766863823, -0.016940105706453323, 0.018199551850557327, -0.0015643785009160638, 0.032200951129198074, -0.019322840496897697, 0.0026139162946492434, 0.008878521621227264, 0.005704379640519619, 0.011618666350841522, -0.020083045586943626, 0.007857349701225758, -0.03635371848940849, 0.015147382393479347, -0.01442121621221304, -0.0039315116591751575, 0.013672356493771076, 0.003443618305027485, -0.022511165589094162, -0.009763537906110287, -0.05219322815537453, 0.01760954037308693, -0.017110301181674004, -0.00577529426664114, -0.05686792731285095, -0.009701132774353027, -0.035446010529994965, 0.005752601660788059, 0.005400864407420158, -0.01780242845416069, -0.01848321035504341, 0.027798566967248917, 0.012276754714548588, 0.0011438543442636728, 0.015340270474553108, -0.030317457392811775, -0.03751104697585106, 0.02920551411807537, -0.060816455632448196, 0.02891051024198532, -0.018063396215438843, -0.0250527486205101, 0.03360790014266968, -0.001894841087050736, -0.02888781763613224, 0.05396325886249542, 0.009116794914007187, 0.021603457629680634, -0.014409869909286499, 0.03810105472803116, 0.01284407265484333, -0.006892910227179527, 0.022352317348122597, 0.021558072417974472, -0.008702653460204601, -0.010937885381281376, 0.010540762916207314, -0.005398028064519167, 0.019572461023926735, 0.010716631077229977, 0.006456075236201286, -0.007613403256982565, -0.030998239293694496, -0.004575417377054691, 0.006648963317275047, -0.03778335824608803, -0.013649663887917995, 0.006524153519421816, 0.03442483767867088, 0.0004669733752962202, 0.04232190176844597, 0.017110301181674004, -0.004901624750345945, -0.008084277622401714, 0.00968411285430193, 0.0027245432138442993, -0.006597904954105616, -0.031860560178756714, -0.008356589823961258, -8.947442324824806e-7, 0.018982449546456337, 0.0013317782431840897, -0.01665644720196724, 0.022772131487727165, -0.00568452337756753, -0.01621394045650959, -0.012775994837284088, 0.0031401035375893116, -0.021206336095929146, 0.0385776050388813, 0.0040109362453222275, -0.04227651655673981, 0.034787919372320175, -0.016599716618657112, -0.04942471906542778, -0.010949231684207916, 0.028615504503250122, 0.03753373771905899, -0.0015218297485262156, 0.01318446360528469, -0.01443256251513958, 0.014682182110846043, 0.0292282085865736, 0.03583178669214249, -0.0009311101748608053, 0.006915602833032608, 0.012412911280989647, -0.018210897222161293, 0.03294981271028519, 0.021773653104901314, -0.007942447438836098, 0.0032790962141007185, -0.0014977187383919954, 0.026845473796129227, 0.000864450354129076, -0.02920551411807537, -0.019674576818943024, 0.0037357870023697615, -0.025869686156511307, 0.008492745459079742, 0.020786520093679428, 0.01777973584830761, -0.011232890188694, -0.014795645140111446, -0.03410714119672775, 0.013036960735917091, 0.0010842859046533704, 0.02818434312939644, 0.00428041210398078, -0.02661854587495327, -0.03388021141290665, -0.04947010427713394, 0.024916592985391617, 0.027208557352423668, -0.023555031046271324, 0.009366415441036224, 0.01860802061855793, 0.032609421759843826, -0.0017388287233188748, 0.01646355912089348, -0.013434083200991154, -0.010432972572743893, 0.016418173909187317, 0.015692006796598434, 0.00565899396315217, -0.014511986635625362, -0.029092051088809967, -0.01589624211192131, 0.048607781529426575, 0.033199433237314224, -0.038691066205501556, 0.032586727291345596, 0.0031599595677107573, 0.032200951129198074, 0.054371729493141174, 0.012140599079430103, -0.052783239632844925, 0.030022451654076576, -0.02759433351457119, -0.019822079688310623, -0.048244696110486984, -0.051467061042785645, -0.016123168170452118, -0.029908988624811172, -0.0027642555069178343, -0.004669024609029293, 0.005559713579714298, 0.006558192428201437, -0.024326583370566368, -0.019209377467632294, -0.007482920307666063, -0.012639838270843029, 0.023305410519242287, 0.01960649900138378, 0.04531733691692352, -0.03882722184062004, 0.033834826201200485, 0.009286990389227867, -0.03406175598502159, -0.030635155737400055, 0.02185307815670967, -0.022999059408903122, 0.012095212936401367, 0.0409376434981823, 0.01633874885737896, 0.044795405119657516, 0.022545205429196358, -0.017711658030748367, 0.0015218297485262156, 0.017723005264997482, 0.01905052736401558, -0.0200263150036335, -0.010603168047964573, -0.040551867336034775, -0.041255343705415726, 0.018857641145586967, 0.0001427158567821607, 0.013570238836109638, 0.006892910227179527, 0.03344905003905296, 0.02466697432100773, -0.003798191901296377, -0.004056321457028389, 0.0019317168043926358, 0.02185307815670967, 0.00968411285430193, 0.007392149418592453, -0.004362673033028841, 0.026868166401982307, -0.0014920455869287252, -0.017791083082556725, 0.007193588186055422, -0.006024913862347603, -0.0071538761258125305, 0.03987108916044235, 0.019356880336999893, -0.03496946394443512, 0.023963499814271927, 0.043184224516153336, -0.0010906682582572103, 0.014954494312405586, 0.030589770525693893, -0.03047630749642849, -0.018551288172602654, 0.0285247340798378, 0.007857349701225758, -0.011664051562547684, -0.018392439931631088, 0.005505818407982588, -0.00706877838820219, 0.02763971872627735, -0.03043092042207718, 0.010302489623427391, -0.0028138956986367702, -0.001456588157452643, 0.0317017138004303, -0.0008516857051290572, -0.01860802061855793, 0.0388726070523262, 0.005154081154614687, -0.04127803444862366, -0.029114743694663048, 0.01682664267718792, 0.008617555722594261, -0.016350096091628075, 0.04012070596218109, -0.04561234265565872, 0.014636796899139881, 0.04513579607009888, -0.01462545059621334, -0.04847162216901779, 0.026051228865981102, 0.008373608812689781, -0.038668375462293625, 0.008123989216983318, -0.02070709504187107, 0.01153924223035574, -0.009071409702301025, 0.02723124995827675, -0.03601332753896713, 0.0063482848927378654, -0.02148999460041523, 0.010347874835133553, -0.016077782958745956, -0.004589600022882223, -0.016270671039819717, -0.025506604462862015, -0.03998455032706261, -0.02170557528734207, 0.018982449546456337, -0.0055653867311775684, -0.00411588978022337, 0.0011239981977269053, 0.009179200045764446, 0.011641358956694603, 6.011130153638078e-7, 0.0030152935069054365, -0.02503005601465702, 0.0047229197807610035, -0.0016906067030504346, -0.008555150590837002, -0.0021728267893195152, 0.016055090352892876, 0.004691717214882374, -0.036694109439849854, -0.0461115837097168, 0.0017473384505137801, -0.03982570394873619, 0.03272288292646408, 0.03848683089017868, 0.0443415492773056, 0.021569419652223587, -0.0017005348345264792, -0.0021359510719776154, 0.0036932381335645914, 0.007545325439423323, -0.0015388492029160261, -0.016611061990261078, 0.02210269682109356, 0.014489294029772282, -0.02791202999651432, 0.010949231684207916, -0.04393308237195015, 0.033857520669698715, -0.03884991630911827, -0.011278275400400162, -0.0006396506796590984, 0.006762426812201738, -0.02891051024198532, 0.03692103549838066, 0.047700073570013046, 0.00440805871039629, 0.015623928979039192, -0.029931681230664253, 0.007301378529518843, -0.013706395402550697, -0.02273809351027012, 0.015090650878846645, 0.029409749433398247, -0.0044676270335912704, -0.0005985201569274068, 0.03712527081370354, 0.0030635155271738768, 0.002494779648259282, 0.0501054972410202, -0.0017487568547949195, -0.01648625172674656, 0.005426393821835518, -0.015465080738067627, 0.018868986517190933, -0.0016352932434529066, 0.04397846758365631, -0.002823823830112815, 0.015351616777479649, -0.02369118668138981, 0.00705175893381238, 0.005681686569005251, 0.012004442512989044, -0.004235026426613331, -0.0001253417576663196, 0.015294885262846947, 0.0003684019320644438, -0.002272107405588031, 0.021274413913488388, 0.0007123383111320436, -0.04041571170091629, -0.007670135237276554, 0.0455215722322464, 0.014829684980213642, 0.03274557739496231, 0.03108900971710682, 0.006149723660200834, 0.022862903773784637, -0.03183786943554878, 0.019039181992411613, 0.00043364346493035555, 0.02282886393368244, 0.034515608102083206, 0.022772131487727165, 0.020355358719825745, -0.01977669447660446, -0.011578953824937344, -0.018959756940603256, -0.0161458607763052, -0.00713685667142272, 0.04320691525936127, 0.0017827958799898624, 0.03018130175769329, 0.017711658030748367, -0.01780242845416069, -0.008061584085226059, -0.013706395402550697, 0.0010190444299951196, 0.06326726824045181, 0.010608840733766556, -0.00005438271909952164, -0.018891679123044014, -0.027072399854660034, 0.021671535447239876, -0.002428119769319892, -0.0006435510003939271, -0.011142119765281677, -0.010041522793471813, -0.029772832989692688, -0.01521546021103859, 0.021671535447239876, -0.00843601394444704, 0.004910134710371494, -0.035151004791259766, -0.03782874345779419, -0.040574561804533005, -0.014341791160404682, -0.03015860915184021, 0.013683702796697617, -0.005996548105031252, 0.01001315750181675, -0.0010112437885254622, 0.030952854081988335, -0.01410351786762476, 0.027957415208220482, -0.04141419008374214, -0.027117785066366196, 0.0027458176482468843, 0.026505082845687866, 0.019402265548706055, 0.013059653341770172, 0.0037074212450534105, 0.015328924171626568, -0.01131798792630434, -0.007953793741762638, 0.0003960586618632078, 0.019232070073485374, 0.0016040907939895988, 0.012946189381182194, 0.02471235953271389, -0.0023316757287830114, -0.012333487160503864, -0.033585209399461746, 0.011698090471327305, 0.01680395007133484, 0.007176568731665611, 0.029704755172133446, 0.006773773115128279, 0.0022522511426359415, 0.005968182347714901, 0.03106631711125374, 0.00996209867298603, 0.004796671215444803, -0.013785820454359055, -0.030408227816224098, 0.02913743630051613, 0.04801777005195618, 0.016849335283041, -0.026482390239834785, -0.019629191607236862, -0.00831687729805708, -0.017393959686160088, -0.04270767793059349, -0.014829684980213642, -0.0058206794783473015, -0.028320498764514923, 0.025506604462862015, -0.02473505213856697, 0.025937765836715698, 0.012594453059136868, -0.004433587659150362, -0.012083866633474827, -0.0403476357460022, -0.014716221019625664, 0.00843601394444704, -0.0024352113250643015, -0.004042138811200857, -0.03664872422814369, -0.017030877992510796, 0.004861912690103054, -0.0013445429503917694, -0.0207297895103693, -0.0009679858339950442, -0.01284407265484333, 0.01775704324245453, -0.0458165779709816, -0.010489704087376595, -0.004961193073540926, 0.02763971872627735, 0.006212128791958094, -0.005392354913055897, 0.008175048045814037, 0.009105448611080647, -0.02981821820139885, -0.012367526069283485, -0.020775174722075462, 0.021648842841386795, -0.0171443410217762, 0.022284239530563354, 0.024462739005684853, -0.010262777097523212, -0.03585447743535042, 0.009786230511963367, -0.012004442512989044, -0.011482509784400463, 0.0169968381524086, -0.02063901722431183, 0.021773653104901314, -0.0032734230626374483, -0.03138401359319687, -0.05096781998872757, 0.017473384737968445, 0.004093197174370289, -0.0017388287233188748, 0.01018335297703743, -0.0010927957482635975, -0.01606643758714199, 0.013978707604110241, 0.008078604005277157, -0.014353137463331223, 0.016645101830363274, 0.012106559239327908, 0.012049827724695206, 0.007409169338643551, -0.0012679550563916564, 0.017008185386657715, -0.03113439492881298, 0.012889457866549492, 0.001655149389989674, -0.000056155586207751185, 0.06476499140262604, 0.01106269471347332, -0.01775704324245453, 0.004147092346101999, -0.00585471885278821, -0.022306932136416435, -0.011890978552401066, -0.007800618186593056, -0.023555031046271324, -0.0046803709119558334, 0.008861502632498741, 0.01025710441172123, 0.015090650878846645, 0.007965140044689178, 0.0440465472638607, 0.011266929097473621, -0.02698162943124771, -0.015714699402451515, 0.015147382393479347, -0.007982159964740276, -0.0036705455277115107, -0.011811554431915283, 0.01860802061855793, 0.00011036101932404563, -0.016202593222260475, 0.03585447743535042, 0.0036308332346379757, 0.012469642795622349, 0.000007955743967613671, -0.008623229339718819, -0.00996209867298603, 0.02337348833680153, 0.020207855850458145, 0.01797262392938137, -0.0024025903549045324, 0.017008185386657715, -0.03238249570131302, 0.004564071074128151, 0.0003481912426650524, -0.027798566967248917, 0.03422060236334801, -0.00831687729805708, -0.005454759579151869, 0.016009705141186714, -0.004842056427150965, 0.021092871204018593, -0.007675808388739824, -0.00421233382076025, 0.018937064334750175, -0.003310298779979348, 0.07275281846523285, 0.04329768568277359, 0.044750019907951355, -0.046043504029512405, 0.006858870852738619, -0.035423316061496735, 0.02134249173104763, 0.003111737547442317, -0.00014484330313280225, 0.02602853626012802, -0.03201941028237343, 0.04549887776374817, -0.019107259809970856, -0.02568814530968666, 0.029114743694663048, -0.017870508134365082, 0.020400743931531906, 0.000588592083659023, -0.009519590996205807, -0.021092871204018593, 0.01284407265484333, 0.004368346184492111, 0.00970680546015501, 0.006717041600495577, -0.013615624979138374, 0.024825822561979294, -0.021240374073386192, -0.0010169169399887323, -0.006603578105568886, 0.027163172140717506, 0.011556261219084263, 0.00015840573178138584, 0.004734266083687544, 0.004666188266128302, -0.022114044055342674, 0.02473505213856697, 0.020616324618458748, 0.017847815528512, -0.032836347818374634, 0.010569129139184952, 0.030862081795930862, 0.010915192775428295, 0.024213118478655815, -0.03912222757935524, 0.012798687443137169, 0.010710958391427994, 0.013400044292211533, 0.006070299539715052, -0.03950800374150276, 0.0035116965882480145, -0.02144460938870907, -0.0022026109509170055, 0.0014445326523855329, 0.011925018392503262, -0.018993796780705452, -0.010455665178596973, -0.02371387928724289, -0.004805180709809065, 0.025574682280421257, 0.04461386427283287, 0.008935254067182541, -0.001728900708258152, -0.04661082103848457, 0.035468701273202896, 0.00986565463244915, 0.03755643218755722, 0.01897110417485237, -0.008209086954593658, 0.03753373771905899, 0.03971223905682564, 0.022533858194947243, -0.020105740055441856, 0.04191343113780022, -0.003676218679174781, 0.016100475564599037, -0.01318446360528469, 0.01445525512099266, 0.038373369723558426, 0.00566466711461544, 0.04465924948453903, 0.02263597585260868, 0.0034237622749060392, -0.02854742668569088, 0.04459116980433464, 0.006875890307128429, 0.008776404894888401, -0.021263066679239273, 0.01114779245108366, 0.03714796155691147, 0.004955519922077656, 0.0030776984058320522, -0.01155058853328228, 0.04327499493956566, -0.00013695404049940407, -0.036058712750673294, -0.00688723661005497, -0.011590300127863884, -0.006773773115128279, -0.03503753989934921, -0.024576202034950256, -0.016452213749289513, 0.013025614432990551, -0.0018593837739899755, -0.00428041210398078, -0.030067838728427887, 0.03973492980003357, -0.008918234147131443, 0.021081525832414627, -0.030249379575252533, -0.0005729908589273691, 0.01172078400850296, 0.018846293911337852, -0.0024025903549045324, 0.013853898271918297, -0.027095092460513115, -0.031270552426576614, 0.010762016288936138, 0.010228738188743591, 0.010654225945472717, 0.020820559933781624, 0.01249233540147543, 0.011437124572694302, -0.026550468057394028, -0.023112522438168526, -0.02925090119242668, 0.02729932777583599, 0.027662411332130432, 0.014909109100699425, 0.0024025903549045324, -0.031588248908519745, -0.012900804169476032, 0.010143640451133251, 0.01877821609377861, 0.013797166757285595, -0.018131474032998085, 0.021875770762562752, -0.002074964577332139, 0.02225019969046116, 0.006524153519421816, -0.003869106760248542, 0.002327420748770237, 0.0028493532445281744, 0.026709316298365593, 0.00441940501332283 ]
11.766704
4.605306
2024-06-01
0
2024MNRAS.531.2011Z
[ "Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument galaxy images", "various network architectures", "various resolutions", "star formation rate", "various sizes", "specific star formation rate", "galaxies", "various characteristics", "photometric images", "image sets" ]
[ "None" ]
9
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1271" ]
[ "Zhong, Jing", "Deng, Zhijie", "Li, Xiangru", "Wang, Lili", "Yang, Haifeng", "Li, Hui", "Zhao, Xirong" ]
[ "School of Artificial Intelligence, South China Normal University, Foshan 528225, Peoples Republic of China", "School of Computer Science, South China Normal University, No. 55 West of Yat-sen Avenue, Guangzhou 510631, Peoples Republic of China", "School of Computer Science, South China Normal University, No. 55 West of Yat-sen Avenue, Guangzhou 510631, Peoples Republic of China", "School of Computer and Information, Dezhou University, Dezhou 253023, Peoples Republic of China", "School of Computer Science and Technology, Taiyuan University of Science and Technology, Taiyuan 030024, Peoples Republic of China", "School of Computer Science, South China Normal University, No. 55 West of Yat-sen Avenue, Guangzhou 510631, Peoples Republic of China", "School of Artificial Intelligence, South China Normal University, Foshan 528225, Peoples Republic of China" ]
null
[ "1999ApJ...527...54B", "2000AJ....120.1579Y", "2003MNRAS.341...33K", "2003MNRAS.344.1000B", "2004MNRAS.351.1151B", "2006A&A...457..841I", "2007ApJS..173..267S", "2008MNRAS.388.1595D", "2009AJ....137.4377Y", "2009ApJ...703.1672K", "2010ApJ...714.1256C", "2011A&A...533A.119E", "2011ApJ...737...67M", "2011ApJ...741..124H", "2011arXiv1110.3193L", "2012arXiv1211.0310L", "2015A&A...575A..74S", "2015ApJ...798....7B", "2015ApJ...801L..29R", "2015ApJ...806..110D", "2015MNRAS.447.2857B", "2015RAA....15.1095L", "2016A&A...589A...2J", "2017ApJ...837..170L", "2018AAS...23122504N", "2018MNRAS.480.4379C", "2019A&A...621A..26P", "2019A&A...622A.103B", "2019A&A...622A.137B", "2019AJ....157..168D", "2019ApJ...876...82N", "2019ApJS..243...27B", "2019MNRAS.484.4683W", "2019MNRAS.490.3952B", "2019MNRAS.490.5285P", "2020MNRAS.493.4808S", "2021ApJ...909..120S", "2021MNRAS.500..531A", "2021arXiv211101154B", "2022ApJ...927..204E", "2022MLS&T...3c5007C", "2022MNRAS.512.1696H", "2022MNRAS.515.2951S", "2022PhRvD.105h3518F", "2023AJ....165...35F", "2023MNRAS.518..513L" ]
28997647
null
Characterising galaxy clusters' completeness function in Planck with hydrodynamical simulations
Galaxy cluster number counts are an important probe with which to constrain cosmological parameters. One of the main ingredients of the analysis, along with accurate estimates of cluster masses, is the selection function, and in particular the completeness associated with the cluster sample under consideration. Incorrectly characterising this function can lead to biases in cosmological constraints. In this work, we want to study the completeness of the Planck cluster catalogue, estimating the probability of cluster detection in a realistic setting using hydrodynamical simulations. In particular, we probe the case in which the cluster model assumed in the detection method differs from the shapes and profiles of true galaxy clusters. We created around 9000 images of the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect from galaxy clusters from the IllustrisTNG simulation, and used a Monte Carlo injection method to estimate the completeness function. We studied the impact of having different cluster pressure profiles and complex cluster morphologies on the detection process. We find that the cluster profile has a significant effect on completeness, with clusters with steeper profiles producing a higher completeness than ones with flatter profiles. We also show that cluster morphology has a small impact on completeness, finding that elliptical clusters have a slightly lower probability of detection with respect to spherically symmetric ones. Finally, we investigate the impact of a different completeness function on a cosmological analysis with cluster number counts, showing a shift in the constraints on Ω<SUB>m</SUB> and σ<SUB>8</SUB> that lies in the same direction as the shift driven by the mass bias.
[ 0.03868726268410683, 0.005698902532458305, -0.008868446573615074, -0.0011838716454803944, 0.01572846807539463, 0.018590472638607025, 0.03386704623699188, 0.012069371528923512, 0.006044100504368544, 0.033716414123773575, 0.010707409121096134, 0.01782476156949997, -0.024113638326525688, -0.021841607987880707, -0.03484615311026573, 0.030502935871481895, -0.008391445502638817, 0.03057825192809105, -0.0003754026547539979, -0.01643141731619835, -0.005516889039427042, -0.004399703349918127, -0.0008677018340677023, -0.02516806125640869, -0.05211859941482544, -0.026360562071204185, 0.017598813399672508, 0.019795527681708336, 0.06276324391365051, -0.007406062912195921, 0.026486089453101158, -0.014046413823962212, -0.03406788781285286, -0.0010230408515781164, -0.03266199305653572, 0.06823620200157166, 0.0207118708640337, 0.06100587174296379, -0.03836089372634888, -0.011686515994369984, 0.013594518415629864, 0.04812685400247574, -0.03517252206802368, 0.010506566613912582, -0.004267900716513395, -0.029523830860853195, 0.01698373444378376, -0.0369298942387104, -0.014448098838329315, 0.012276490218937397, -0.055030811578035355, 0.031482044607400894, -0.003784623695537448, -0.04180032014846802, -0.009910316206514835, 0.014636388048529625, -0.029297882691025734, 0.013720044866204262, -0.027866879478096962, 0.014962757006287575, -0.008416551165282726, -0.025243377313017845, 0.034971680492162704, 0.00856718234717846, -0.01595441624522209, -0.006596417166292667, 0.012546372599899769, -0.026787351816892624, -0.026084404438734055, 0.02298389934003353, 0.020824844017624855, 0.02615972049534321, -0.017234787344932556, -0.0008724090876057744, 0.006866299081593752, 0.0029279054142534733, 0.0029106454458087683, -0.005623586475849152, -0.015464863739907742, 0.030327199026942253, 0.01198150310665369, 0.020172106102108955, 0.03085441142320633, -0.032184991985559464, -0.021992240101099014, -0.012797425501048565, -0.01100867334753275, -0.017598813399672508, -0.10423719882965088, -0.0046884142793715, -0.016356101259589195, -0.007224049419164658, -0.0028729874175041914, 0.01365728210657835, -0.0037030314560979605, -0.04016847535967827, 0.035523995757102966, -0.034042783081531525, 0.021841607987880707, 0.034921467304229736, 0.0021872990764677525, 0.05073780566453934, 0.013782808557152748, -0.08319895714521408, 0.0843035876750946, 0.0059844753704965115, -0.032134782522916794, 0.02298389934003353, 0.007155010011047125, 0.029574040323495865, 0.04079610854387283, -0.02200479246675968, -0.08109010756015778, 0.04714774712920189, -0.013707492500543594, 0.009885210543870926, -0.04551590606570244, 0.024778928607702255, -0.029473619535565376, 0.014711704105138779, -0.0302518829703331, -0.017925182357430458, 0.034419361501932144, 0.04551590606570244, 0.01505062635987997, -0.032134782522916794, 0.030000830069184303, -0.056888602674007416, -0.06020250543951988, 0.01763647235929966, -0.003260550554841757, -0.011786936782300472, -0.0020209765061736107, -0.01523891557008028, -0.04300537332892418, -0.016782891005277634, -0.005064993631094694, -0.023247506469488144, -0.023423243314027786, -0.018640683963894844, -0.014749362133443356, 0.026134613901376724, 0.008611117489635944, 0.05472954735159874, -0.021716082468628883, -0.016883311793208122, -0.027189036831259727, 0.024088533595204353, 0.007581799756735563, 0.002984392223879695, 0.029398303478956223, -0.010851765051484108, -0.016971182078123093, -0.0220173466950655, 0.001212115166708827, -0.016958627849817276, -0.00802741851657629, 0.025193165987730026, -0.012477332726120949, -0.03886299952864647, -0.003998018801212311, -0.0174481812864542, -0.03773326054215431, -0.011812042444944382, -0.016807997599244118, -0.024766376242041588, -0.013243044726550579, 0.024364691227674484, -0.05764176324009895, -0.003944669850170612, 0.018552815541625023, 0.028745565563440323, -0.02150268666446209, -0.05118970200419426, 0.017485840246081352, 0.015376994386315346, 0.01491254661232233, -0.014548519626259804, -0.04589248448610306, 0.009044183418154716, -0.019331078976392746, 0.012772319838404655, 0.04747411608695984, -0.005780494771897793, -0.040745899081230164, -0.014322572387754917, 0.019481711089611053, -0.0013886367669329047, -0.021741187199950218, -0.03652820736169815, 0.02019721269607544, 0.0009273269097320735, 0.025193165987730026, 0.031657781451940536, -0.033992573618888855, -0.05016038566827774, -0.007669668644666672, 0.07642052322626114, -0.022368820384144783, 0.03537336364388466, -0.0015832028584554791, 0.026084404438734055, 0.06567545980215073, -0.02169097773730755, -0.01758626103401184, -0.006721943616867065, 0.03446957468986511, 0.0005527088069356978, -0.010832935571670532, -0.007519036531448364, -0.00289181643165648, -0.010424974374473095, 0.007368404883891344, -0.011586095206439495, -0.004336940124630928, 0.017159471288323402, -0.04275432229042053, 0.002946734195575118, 0.009778513573110104, 0.052419859915971756, 0.014385335147380829, 0.054980602115392685, 0.05161649361252785, 0.009765961207449436, 0.006960443686693907, 0.004566025920212269, 0.06657925248146057, -0.05598481371998787, 0.021854162216186523, -0.012697004713118076, -0.0018154268618673086, 0.027766458690166473, -0.020159553736448288, 0.02447766438126564, -0.03113056905567646, -0.034595098346471786, 0.01833941973745823, 0.04910596087574959, -0.003671649843454361, -0.055683549493551254, -0.024276822805404663, 0.017184576019644737, -0.020636554807424545, 0.0015204396331682801, -0.004405979532748461, 0.006251219194382429, -0.02884598635137081, -0.01083921268582344, 0.030728884041309357, 0.0038191433995962143, 0.06160840019583702, 0.014021309092640877, 0.009878934361040592, -0.03745710477232933, -0.03898852691054344, -0.0025748619809746742, -0.02131439745426178, 0.02293368987739086, 0.0025387732312083244, 0.03931489586830139, -0.020159553736448288, -0.01815113052725792, -0.04448658600449562, 0.0007602198165841401, -0.05048675462603569, 0.04001784324645996, 0.024490218609571457, -0.019469158723950386, -0.0626126155257225, 0.012144687585532665, -0.001959782326593995, -0.020536134019494057, 0.0414237417280674, -0.03484615311026573, -0.04825238138437271, 0.03632736578583717, 0.0024257993791252375, 0.041900742799043655, 0.043683215975761414, -0.029247671365737915, -0.018226446583867073, -0.0062010083347558975, -0.018414735794067383, 0.02708861604332924, 0.00918853934854269, 0.014761915430426598, 0.05553291738033295, -0.009671815671026707, 0.00048092336510308087, -0.017536049708724022, 0.06713156402111053, -0.030402515083551407, -0.019908500835299492, 0.0013360725715756416, -0.05392618104815483, -0.025707824155688286, -0.0001571042521391064, -0.010632093995809555, -0.0233604796230793, 0.022670084610581398, -0.0070985229685902596, -0.0012772319605574012, 0.014523414894938469, -0.029297882691025734, -0.011648857966065407, 0.0013705923920497298, 0.010312001220881939, 0.013192834332585335, 0.003998018801212311, 0.04453679919242859, 0.022230740636587143, 0.04132331907749176, -0.029071934521198273, 0.03494657576084137, -0.03700520843267441, -0.020134449005126953, -0.02248179353773594, 0.007581799756735563, 0.027666037902235985, -0.0007747337804175913, -0.05377554893493652, -0.04350747913122177, -0.023561321198940277, 0.027013299986720085, -0.012596582993865013, 0.00814039260149002, -0.0368545763194561, 0.012627964839339256, -0.01749839261174202, -0.03015146218240261, 0.01007350068539381, 0.02867024950683117, 0.054930392652750015, -0.002783549949526787, -0.0022328023333102465, -0.07034504413604736, 0.015841443091630936, 0.0665290355682373, -0.007117351982742548, -0.04328153282403946, -0.0154523104429245, -0.0036590970121324062, -0.01674523390829563, -0.001297630020417273, 0.04950764775276184, -0.01567825861275196, 0.03248625621199608, 0.04277942702174187, 0.03615162894129753, -0.03826047480106354, 0.0019158479990437627, 0.015075731091201305, 0.02461574412882328, 0.04825238138437271, 0.05161649361252785, 0.013481545262038708, 0.01629333756864071, -0.04877959191799164, 0.018063262104988098, 0.009251302108168602, 0.02721414342522621, -0.012753491289913654, 0.009150881320238113, 0.02759072184562683, -0.009044183418154716, 0.03642778843641281, -0.05603502318263054, -0.01417194027453661, -0.04877959191799164, -0.018916841596364975, 0.0009602776262909174, -0.008586011826992035, -0.02932298742234707, -0.025858456268906593, -0.08550864458084106, 0.00916343368589878, -0.003269965061917901, 0.015100836753845215, 0.03283772990107536, 0.02042315900325775, 0.034971680492162704, -0.006753324996680021, 0.00005501590567291714, -0.031808413565158844, 0.006470890250056982, 0.006175903137773275, 0.009063012897968292, -0.015753574669361115, -0.10614519566297531, 0.0031177641358226538, -0.02102568745613098, -0.020310185849666595, 0.05769197270274162, -0.002504253527149558, 0.017623918130993843, -0.0019017262384295464, -0.018929393962025642, 0.0756673663854599, 0.04654522240161896, 0.02791709080338478, -0.02061145007610321, -0.01472425740212202, -0.058093659579753876, 0.010575606487691402, -0.019017262384295464, 0.007958379574120045, 0.004399703349918127, 0.00918853934854269, 0.02308432199060917, 0.01643141731619835, 0.05608523637056351, 0.003189941868185997, 0.022908583283424377, -0.057240080088377, 0.01291667576879263, 0.036176733672618866, -0.050838228315114975, 0.06165860965847969, -0.03123098984360695, 0.05196796730160713, -0.00827847234904766, -0.027766458690166473, -0.014159387908875942, 0.00399174215272069, -0.048051539808511734, -0.021339502185583115, 0.02671203576028347, -0.000037535362935159355, -0.0008261211914941669, -0.05422744154930115, -0.0078014712780714035, 0.06803535670042038, 0.02471616491675377, 0.03381683677434921, 0.011598647572100163, -0.03931489586830139, 0.0637674555182457, -0.023536216467618942, 0.011222068220376968, 0.0019943020306527615, 0.024678507819771767, -0.005811876617372036, -0.024502770975232124, -0.06642861664295197, 0.02754051238298416, -0.020209765061736107, 0.030402515083551407, -0.01168023981153965, 0.043582797050476074, 0.017335208132863045, -0.03379173204302788, -0.03336494043469429, -0.020485922694206238, 0.007180115208029747, -0.026486089453101158, 0.009483526460826397, 0.01987084373831749, -0.05377554893493652, 0.05392618104815483, -0.06497251242399216, -0.008077629841864109, 0.02516806125640869, -0.025343798100948334, 0.014385335147380829, -0.01395854540169239, 0.08334958553314209, -0.02010934427380562, -0.031482044607400894, 0.001423156587406993, 0.024766376242041588, 0.006790983024984598, -0.06241177022457123, 0.0671817734837532, -0.0020915851928293705, 0.03243604302406311, -0.027666037902235985, -0.016494181007146835, 0.014222150668501854, 0.0279673021286726, 0.01189363468438387, 0.026912879198789597, -0.03140672668814659, 0.036829471588134766, 0.03133141249418259, 0.024904455989599228, 0.049156174063682556, -0.0027568754740059376, 0.024816587567329407, 0.007713602855801582, 0.013782808557152748, -0.03381683677434921, -0.016017179936170578, 0.038134947419166565, -0.012389464303851128, 0.029097039252519608, 0.0003671649901662022, -0.004807664547115564, 0.004148650448769331, 0.015402100048959255, 0.039214473217725754, 0.015063178725540638, -0.036503102630376816, 0.042879849672317505, -0.016318444162607193, -0.003370386315509677, 0.007845405489206314, -0.02108844928443432, -0.03512231260538101, -0.012370635755360126, -0.0019440915202721953, -0.02964935638010502, 0.04531506076455116, 0.020812291651964188, 0.015602942556142807, 0.0035304324701428413, 0.020950371399521828, 0.010964739136397839, 0.036879681050777435, 0.021239081397652626, -0.01978297531604767, 0.028745565563440323, -0.0005405484116636217, -0.002683128695935011, 0.021891819313168526, -0.013945993036031723, -0.024364691227674484, -0.0362018384039402, -0.11006162315607071, -0.042603690177202225, 0.0064269560389220715, 0.02471616491675377, -0.028494512662291527, 0.008498143404722214, -0.0037626565899699926, -0.038837894797325134, -0.01226393785327673, -0.023234952241182327, -0.010136263445019722, -0.009106947109103203, 0.02867024950683117, -0.0022469242103397846, 0.0032479979563504457, -0.00501478323712945, 0.0006527377408929169, 0.003022050252184272, 0.026235036551952362, 0.026561405509710312, -0.002620365470647812, 0.0459929034113884, 0.004766868427395821, 0.020774634554982185, -0.02708861604332924, 0.02726435288786888, -0.002683128695935011, -0.028092827647924423, 0.014774467796087265, -0.009803618304431438, -0.008265919052064419, -0.0017338346224278212, -0.011040054261684418, -0.024929560720920563, -0.01870344579219818, -0.03542357310652733, 0.04591758921742439, -0.006828641053289175, -0.0355491004884243, 0.025532087311148643, -0.023850033059716225, 0.011303660459816456, 0.01554017886519432, -0.0526709146797657, 0.00615393603220582, -0.011535883881151676, -0.03956595063209534, 0.0041015781462192535, -0.0024917006958276033, -0.00285572768189013, -0.009012801572680473, -0.006608969531953335, -0.023398136720061302, -0.006533653475344181, 0.00844793301075697, -0.017008839175105095, 0.013079860247671604, -0.055733758956193924, 0.010186474770307541, 0.02428937517106533, 0.008554629981517792, -0.005648692138493061, 0.004719796124845743, -0.002171608153730631, -0.03258667513728142, 0.013230491429567337, 0.0019284007139503956, -0.02540656179189682, 0.019569579511880875, 0.007832853123545647, 0.017761997878551483, -0.02513040229678154, -0.0012191759888082743, 0.025293586775660515, 0.02708861604332924, -0.030452726408839226, -0.05166670307517052, -0.02275795303285122, 0.016067391261458397, -0.008560906164348125, 0.008297300897538662, -0.008221984840929508, 0.011454291641712189, -0.017008839175105095, -0.011542160995304585, -0.012646793387830257, -0.014146835543215275, 0.03386704623699188, -0.025318693369627, 0.017510944977402687, -0.04438616707921028, 0.040921635925769806, 0.00038010990829207003, -0.0011407219571992755, -0.004518953617662191, -0.010211579501628876, -0.006244942545890808, 0.047624748200178146, 0.00523445475846529, 0.002093154238536954, -0.04205137491226196, 0.00025536795146763325, 0.002996944822371006, 0.013468991965055466, 0.0035021889489144087, 0.007412339095026255, 0.019393842667341232, 0.017473287880420685, 0.020586343482136726, -0.001056776149198413, 0.06843703985214233, -0.018351972103118896, -0.012979438528418541, 0.010136263445019722, 0.039540842175483704, 0.026410773396492004, -0.042603690177202225, 0.0012317287037149072, 0.00996052660048008, 0.026084404438734055, -0.007380957715213299, -0.020912712439894676, 0.004782559350132942, -0.01077017281204462, -0.035574205219745636, 0.023711953312158585, 0.011190686374902725, 0.01916789449751377, -0.000725307734683156, -0.011623753234744072, 0.019255762919783592, -0.03901363164186478, 0.025858456268906593, -0.02023486979305744, -0.0013486251700669527, 0.03733157739043236, -0.031431831419467926, -0.03798431530594826, -0.011341318488121033, -0.006979272700846195, 0.019946159794926643, -0.023900242522358894, 0.027389880269765854, -0.016117600724101067, 0.00909439381211996, 0.015138494782149792, 0.03793410584330559, -0.025444218888878822, 0.04044463485479355, -0.003499050857499242, -0.04900554195046425, -0.03123098984360695, 0.02332282066345215, -0.022042451426386833, 0.020724423229694366, -0.030703779309988022, 0.0046068220399320126, 0.002102568745613098, 0.012966886162757874, 0.019582131877541542, 0.004842184484004974, 0.003859939519315958, 0.0009665539837442338, 0.013745150528848171, -0.018879184499382973, 0.022770505398511887, 0.003044017357751727, -0.014485756866633892, 0.013682386837899685, -0.01782476156949997, 0.0010536379413679242, -0.005077546462416649, -0.010600712150335312, 0.009853829629719257, 0.02079973928630352, -0.01638120599091053, -0.029197461903095245, -0.012734661810100079, -0.006276324391365051, -0.035950787365436554, 0.004901809152215719, 0.029799988493323326, -0.0008190603111870587, 0.03871236741542816, 0.05068759620189667, -0.04436106234788895, -0.028770670294761658, 0.023988110944628716, 0.01007350068539381, -0.02327261120080948, 0.00041423740913160145, -0.014510861597955227, -0.007186391390860081, 0.01260913535952568, -0.019695106893777847, -0.06386787444353104, 0.011855976656079292, 0.026460982859134674, -0.021063344553112984, -0.011410357430577278, -0.000060703823692165315, 0.0009445868199691176, -0.008542077615857124, 0.0004130605957470834, -0.007173838559538126, 0.0012905691983178258, -0.016506733372807503, 0.023511111736297607, 0.02605929970741272, 0.023711953312158585, 0.006508548278361559, 0.0034519783221185207, 0.01865323632955551, 0.019105130806565285, -0.0066152457147836685, 0.03253646567463875, -0.00926385447382927, 0.01577867940068245, -0.011171857826411724, 0.029021723195910454, -0.019192999228835106, 0.02169097773730755, -0.001006565522402525, 0.0021104139741510153, 0.010456356219947338, 0.0120066087692976, -0.009238749742507935, 0.026636721566319466, 0.015615494921803474, 0.020674211904406548, -0.020824844017624855, 0.02726435288786888, 0.0362018384039402, 0.054980602115392685, 0.057240080088377, 0.012075647711753845, 0.023021558299660683, -0.025619955733418465, -0.0025356351397931576, -0.01707160286605358, -0.010600712150335312, 0.03411810100078583, -0.0335155725479126, 0.00490808580070734, -0.0010630524484440684, 0.031431831419467926, 0.015100836753845215, 0.019255762919783592, 0.020222317427396774, 0.017536049708724022, -0.029097039252519608, -0.02196713536977768, 0.0246659554541111, 0.0015243622474372387, 0.007337023038417101, 0.007161286193877459, -0.023900242522358894, -0.012991991825401783, 0.017247339710593224, 0.017385419458150864, -0.015715915709733963, 0.031858623027801514, 0.009690645150840282, -0.0007896400638855994, -0.002436782931908965, -0.017460733652114868, 0.003323313780128956, 0.018904289230704308, -0.0005456479266285896, 0.004500124603509903, -0.10996120423078537, -0.005592205096036196, 0.03951573744416237, 0.013418781571090221, 0.019582131877541542, -0.011931292712688446, 0.002461888361722231, 0.018176235258579254, 0.0071989442221820354, 0.017812209203839302, 0.021992240101099014, -0.01179321389645338, 0.0015149478567764163, 0.03544868156313896, 0.015477416105568409, -0.01596696861088276, -0.006790983024984598, -0.01861557736992836, -0.02377471700310707, -0.0015141632175073028, 0.009056735783815384, -0.007883063517510891, 0.016456522047519684, 0.0260090883821249, 0.005319185089319944, -0.013130070641636848, -0.032084569334983826, -0.01591675914824009, 0.04453679919242859, -0.011291107162833214, -0.008171774446964264, -0.000883392640389502, -0.014899994246661663, 0.023724505677819252, -0.004779421258717775, 0.014121729880571365, 0.0007912091678008437, -0.008322406560182571, -0.049482543021440506, -0.010676028206944466, -0.01425980869680643, -0.0414990559220314, 0.05653712898492813, -0.010017014108598232, 0.04099695011973381, -0.02280816249549389, 0.01291667576879263, -0.007224049419164658, 0.0025607403367757797, 0.017711786553263664, 0.014146835543215275, 0.00916343368589878, -0.020310185849666595, 0.022594768553972244, 0.00868015643209219, 0.010173921473324299, -0.004079611040651798, 0.007412339095026255, -0.005494921933859587, 0.005604757461696863, -0.024904455989599228, 0.016582049429416656, 0.03504699468612671, -0.026787351816892624, -0.04709753766655922, -0.017347760498523712, -0.0758180022239685, 0.07742473483085632, -0.011623753234744072, 0.005557685159146786, -0.0017856142949312925, 0.01861557736992836, -0.015841443091630936, 0.03103014826774597, 0.007192667573690414, 0.018929393962025642, 0.00516541488468647, -0.032034359872341156, -0.049633175134658813, 0.02643587812781334, -0.02573293074965477, -0.013908335007727146, 0.0200591329485178, 0.007537865545600653, -0.042327530682086945, 0.02069931849837303, 0.007173838559538126, -0.03379173204302788, -0.0052815270610153675, 0.002885540248826146, 0.008127840235829353, -0.0017181438161060214, 0.035197626799345016, 0.01102750189602375, -0.012270214036107063, -0.009759684093296528, 0.004493848420679569, -0.031205885112285614, 0.007023206911981106, 0.006022133398801088, 0.004239656962454319, -0.006376745644956827, 0.001779337995685637, -0.02423916570842266, -0.018816420808434486, -0.03462020680308342, 0.02559485100209713, 0.0033390044700354338, -0.0005338798509910703, 0.03923958167433739, 0.056838393211364746, 0.025205718353390694, -0.03484615311026573, 0.013757702894508839, 0.04290495440363884, 0.027942195534706116, -0.017473287880420685, 0.0023630361538380384, 0.02061145007610321, -0.009979356080293655, 0.03652820736169815, 0.023209847509860992, -0.012828807346522808, 0.008742920123040676, 0.0034645311534404755, 0.018954500555992126, -0.00498026330024004, -0.001724420115351677, 0.002770997118204832, 0.047449011355638504, -0.034971680492162704, -0.006640351377427578, 0.03487125784158707, -0.002712941262871027, 0.009502355009317398, -0.008962591178715229, 0.008924933150410652, 0.02721414342522621, 0.0065587591379880905, 0.00018730905139818788, -0.0016820549499243498, -0.01727244444191456, -0.007217773236334324, 0.0025513258296996355, 0.02499232441186905, 0.014184493571519852, -0.0023787268437445164, 0.003461392829194665, 0.0007974854670464993, -0.006790983024984598, -0.01913023740053177, 0.022632425650954247, 0.022921137511730194, 0.01930597424507141, -0.027163932099938393, -0.021389713510870934, 0.01713436469435692, -0.009320341981947422, 0.01693352311849594, 0.038411106914281845, 0.03783368319272995, 0.03936510533094406, -0.02159055508673191, -0.0070985229685902596, 0.017573708668351173, 0.006533653475344181, -0.034092992544174194, 0.013142623007297516, 0.0021621936466544867, -0.01641886495053768, 0.01098356768488884, -0.08520738035440445, 0.018929393962025642, 0.0007476671598851681, -0.0065587591379880905, 0.014197045937180519, 0.010424974374473095, 0.019858289510011673, 0.019343631342053413, 0.00846676155924797, -0.03210967406630516, -0.021301845088601112, 0.015791231766343117, -0.004556611645966768, 0.03891321271657944, 0.0018938808934763074, -0.005573376081883907, 0.005447849631309509, 0.0037281366530805826, 0.01655694469809532, 0.01665736548602581, 0.02098802849650383, -0.006015856750309467, 0.011579818092286587, 0.00436204532161355, 0.02536890283226967, -0.0598510280251503, 0.014360230416059494, -0.01758626103401184, 0.005805599968880415, -0.02688777446746826, -0.007073417771607637, -0.01963234320282936, -0.027189036831259727, -0.0028698493260890245, 0.014975310303270817, 0.006565035320818424, -0.004107854329049587, -0.055583130568265915, -0.045490797609090805, -0.0011995624518021941, 0.00798348430544138, 0.028871092945337296, 0.04993443563580513, 0.03283772990107536, -0.04757453873753548, 0.021239081397652626, 0.01605483703315258, -0.013318360783159733, -0.01949426345527172, 0.02676224708557129, -0.01000446081161499, -0.017950287088751793, 0.0526709146797657, 0.02423916570842266, 0.020046580582857132, 0.002607812872156501, -0.03778347373008728, -0.0069667198695242405, 0.004402841441333294, 0.01725989207625389, 0.012088201008737087, -0.00523445475846529, -0.008234537206590176, -0.05103906989097595, -0.04343216493725777, -0.03672904893755913, 0.005683211609721184, 0.0018436702666804194, -0.015515074133872986, 0.04559122025966644, 0.008297300897538662, 0.013255597092211246, 0.022255847230553627, 0.02791709080338478, -0.01005467213690281, 0.024741271510720253, 0.010801554657518864, 0.02578314021229744, -0.012358082458376884, -0.009954250417649746, 0.007161286193877459, -0.01077017281204462, -0.007644562982022762, -0.0014686599606648088, 0.008768024854362011, -0.023234952241182327, 0.032461151480674744, 0.002215542597696185, -0.0194063950330019, 0.005231316201388836, -0.00757552357390523, -0.03833578899502754, -0.02927277609705925, 0.03364109992980957, -0.012031713500618935, -0.016858207061886787, 0.015502520836889744, -0.030076146125793457, -0.050788018852472305, 0.0139836510643363, -0.017649024724960327, 0.0005856595234945416, 0.0012733093462884426, -0.022306056693196297, -0.01945660635828972, -0.010305725038051605, 0.015012968331575394, -0.002692543203011155, -0.0027819809038192034, -0.014422993175685406, -0.00035931955790147185, 0.0002265360817546025, -0.004587993025779724, 0.009722026064991951, 0.037507314234972, -0.017109259963035583, -0.013092412613332272, 0.01259030681103468, -0.009753407910466194, 0.0010387316578999162, 0.00918853934854269, 0.014422993175685406, 0.002695681294426322, 0.004261624068021774, -0.03271220251917839, 0.023536216467618942, 0.005971922539174557, -0.0052815270610153675, -0.005975060630589724, -0.01763647235929966, -0.011228344403207302, 0.018628131598234177, 0.012816254049539566, 0.00618845596909523, 0.02155289798974991, -0.005488645751029253, -0.010851765051484108, -0.03298836201429367, -0.030176566913723946, 0.008742920123040676, -0.014761915430426598, -0.0020147000905126333, -0.00362457730807364, -0.0100295664742589, -0.026310352608561516, -0.008586011826992035, -0.008159222081303596, 0.0207118708640337, -0.009602776728570461, -0.037507314234972, 0.0018734828336164355, 0.00344256404787302, -0.03675415739417076, -0.018904289230704308, -0.01902981474995613, 0.01482467819005251, 0.02769114263355732, 0.026260141283273697, 0.013820466585457325, 0.03494657576084137, 0.008811959065496922, 0.03898852691054344, -0.014247256331145763, -0.009935421869158745, 0.05588439106941223, -0.033942364156246185, 0.01805070973932743, 0.000742959906347096, 0.02671203576028347, -0.024163849651813507, 0.016833102330565453, -0.03015146218240261, 0.0011603354942053556, 0.0007715956307947636, 0.02676224708557129, -0.024214059114456177, -0.02038550190627575, -0.01196267455816269, -0.004365183413028717, 0.05352449417114258, -0.007173838559538126, -0.02246924117207527, -0.03188372775912285, 0.03462020680308342, -0.03316409885883331, 0.031758200377225876, 0.008366340771317482, 0.027013299986720085, -0.0051560006104409695, -0.004973987117409706, -0.00380972889252007, 0.0006798043614253402, 0.02069931849837303, 0.015038073062896729, 0.008736643940210342, -0.011604923754930496, 0.016958627849817276, -0.015276573598384857, -0.004782559350132942, -0.027490301057696342, 0.007406062912195921, 0.0021245358511805534, 0.018025603145360947, 0.0076759448274970055, -0.024578087031841278, 0.013694940134882927, 0.0106823043897748, -0.02154034562408924, 0.03763284161686897, -0.01963234320282936, 0.0014663062756881118, -0.02736477367579937, -0.0006413619266822934, -0.02191692404448986, -0.017435628920793533, -0.029699567705392838, 0.021050792187452316, 0.012176069431006908, -0.003436287632212043, 0.00482963165268302, 0.01302964985370636, 0.021942030638456345, -0.027013299986720085, -0.0348963625729084, -0.003164836671203375, -0.01182459481060505, 0.03233562409877777, 0.020736975595355034, 0.013054754585027695, -0.015891652554273605, -0.02884598635137081, -0.011943845078349113, -0.014573625288903713, -0.024628296494483948, 0.008655051700770855, 0.01196267455816269, 0.04775027558207512, 0.009464696981012821, -0.005403915420174599, -0.00296713225543499, 0.005727145820856094, -0.025858456268906593, 0.00611941609531641, 0.03831068426370621, 0.009257578290998936, -0.0012552648549899459, -0.004120407160371542, 0.033615995198488235, -0.007475102320313454, -0.0229964517056942, 0.016544390469789505, 0.000587228627409786, -0.03331473097205162, -0.010864317417144775, 0.01137897651642561, -0.014297466725111008, 0.03298836201429367, -0.0015973245026543736, -0.024590639397501945, -0.0014121730346232653, -0.018741104751825333, 0.01884152553975582, 0.028770670294761658, -0.0005401561502367258, 0.014372782781720161, 0.012991991825401783, 0.018314315006136894, -0.050562068819999695, 0.03793410584330559, -0.03765794634819031, 0.010971015319228172, 0.006809812039136887, 0.03798431530594826, 0.03768305107951164, -0.008178050629794598, 0.012904123403131962, 0.0007049096748232841, 0.005585928913205862, -0.031532254070043564, -0.024163849651813507, -0.007016930729150772, 0.02260732091963291, 0.019054921343922615, -0.02317219041287899, -0.007023206911981106, -0.03499678522348404, -0.012163517065346241, -0.004007433075457811, -0.03233562409877777, 0.030226778239011765, 0.01605483703315258, 0.007054588757455349, 0.009860105812549591, -0.03015146218240261, 0.026812458410859108, -0.029624251648783684, 0.006954167503863573, -0.02102568745613098, -0.02964935638010502, 0.023988110944628716, 0.006715666968375444, -0.008906104601919651, -0.018753657117486, 0.0015478985151275992, -0.022632425650954247, -0.00019083949155174196, -0.0018452394288033247, 0.014548519626259804, 0.042930059134960175, -0.031858623027801514, 0.02373705804347992, 0.014548519626259804, -0.008221984840929508, 0.011291107162833214, 0.00809645839035511, 0.006411265581846237, -0.02210521511733532, 0.03123098984360695, 0.03863705322146416, -0.006822364404797554, 0.006131968926638365, -0.036277156323194504, -0.011761832050979137, 0.004346354864537716, -0.0003175427846144885, -0.026460982859134674, -0.02141481824219227, -0.008184326812624931, -0.003295070258900523, -0.018929393962025642, 0.0008998680277727544, -0.008993973024189472, 0.02997572533786297, -0.00010493229638086632, -0.012740938924252987, -0.013996203429996967, -0.008334958925843239, -0.01065719872713089, -0.00041149152093566954, 0.048930224031209946, 0.02504253387451172, -0.0007147164433263242, 0.005648692138493061, 0.020787186920642853, 0.004685276187956333, -0.0002959679113700986, -0.019192999228835106, -0.03477083891630173, 0.007883063517510891, 0.007757537066936493, -0.039716579020023346, 0.03951573744416237, -0.05713965743780136, -0.01377025619149208, -0.0335908867418766, 0.029624251648783684, 0.0032982085831463337, -0.03896342217922211, 0.024440007284283638, 0.012690727598965168, -0.042879849672317505, 0.00746882613748312, -0.00289181643165648, -0.01818878762423992, -0.009627881459891796, -0.010293171741068363, 0.00651482492685318, -0.007537865545600653, -0.00012513421825133264, 0.0133309131488204, -0.0040262620896101, 0.011623753234744072, -0.0066842855885624886, 0.01847749948501587, 0.023209847509860992, 0.010789001360535622, -0.05447849631309509, -0.005645553581416607, 0.018866630271077156, -0.026360562071204185, -0.03298836201429367, 0.025092745199799538, -0.01713436469435692, 0.002035098150372505, -0.00783912930637598, 0.016920970752835274, 0.018414735794067383, 0.013720044866204262, -0.002808655146509409, 0.011297384276986122, -0.00014504193677566946, -0.014084071852266788, 0.005454125814139843, -0.03592568263411522, 0.05098886042833328, 0.029624251648783684, 0.004518953617662191, -0.019519368186593056, 0.004261624068021774, 0.02708861604332924, -0.00030028290348127484, -0.0014435546472668648, 0.002984392223879695, -0.016682470217347145, 0.027515405789017677, 0.024138743057847023, -0.03223520144820213, 0.0012733093462884426, 0.007581799756735563, -0.0026062435936182737, -0.049532752484083176, 0.008341235108673573, 0.007299365475773811, -0.018163682892918587, 0.01274721510708332, -0.025707824155688286, 0.019895948469638824, -0.023423243314027786, -0.0161050483584404, -0.010362211614847183, -0.029850197955965996, 0.02187926694750786, 0.0011022795224562287, 0.011190686374902725, 0.03336494043469429, 0.028092827647924423, -0.015853995457291603, 0.005874639842659235, -0.02098802849650383, -0.007663391996175051, 0.027791565284132957, -0.02010934427380562, 0.007751260418444872, 0.014674046076834202, -0.03238583356142044, 0.03597589209675789, -0.02387513779103756, -0.015552732162177563, 0.00816549826413393, -0.044461481273174286, 0.039440423250198364, 0.03615162894129753, -0.0023159636184573174, 0.052972178906202316, 0.029699567705392838, -0.019582131877541542, 0.0005483938730321825, -0.013142623007297516, -0.014372782781720161, 0.030904620885849, -0.012019161134958267, 0.010274343192577362, -0.0046884142793715, 0.029523830860853195, 0.04667074978351593, 0.00003773149728658609, -0.015703363344073296, 0.014548519626259804, -0.007732431869953871, 0.01968255266547203, -0.00933289434760809, 0.009627881459891796, -0.01619291678071022, -0.02912214584648609, 0.01330580748617649, 0.006715666968375444, 0.011975226923823357, -0.03173309564590454, 0.016117600724101067, 0.004999092314392328, 0.01889173686504364, 0.014460651203989983, 0.013945993036031723, 0.006213561166077852, -0.025619955733418465, 0.005554547067731619, 0.0014247256331145763, 0.0056612445041537285, -0.02373705804347992, -0.006828641053289175, -0.0022579077631235123, -0.025155508890748024, 0.013255597092211246, 0.008090182207524776, 0.025243377313017845, 0.01051284372806549, -0.024327034130692482, -0.0025591712910681963, -0.009213644079864025, 0.01165513414889574, 0.05764176324009895, -0.009753407910466194, 0.027465196326375008, -0.025469323620200157, 0.0260090883821249, -0.04988422617316246, 0.04654522240161896, -0.001975473016500473, 0.021251633763313293, 0.00030106742633506656, 0.004117268603295088, -0.007048312108963728, 0.00574911292642355, 0.017021391540765762, -0.006960443686693907, -0.0034896363504230976, -0.002336361678317189, -0.006715666968375444, -0.031657781451940536, 0.012395740486681461, -0.03336494043469429, -0.015000415034592152, 0.025067640468478203, 0.03396746888756752, 0.008347511291503906, -0.00724915461614728, 0.024025769904255867, 0.014887441881000996, -0.009872658178210258, 0.018251551315188408, -0.01801305077970028, -0.019042368978261948, 0.002625072607770562, -0.035800155252218246, 0.02167842537164688, -0.031858623027801514, -0.020774634554982185, -0.027339668944478035, 0.034645311534404755, -0.008811959065496922, -0.03444446995854378, -0.005108927842229605, 0.021101003512740135, 0.04114758223295212, -0.007048312108963728, 0.017109259963035583, 0.003759518265724182, 0.013356017880141735, 0.019155342131853104, -0.04205137491226196, 0.009470973163843155, -0.008924933150410652, 0.023373031988739967, 0.010971015319228172, 0.011705344542860985, -0.014598730951547623, -0.03168288618326187, -0.021276740357279778, -0.020310185849666595, 0.011918740347027779, 0.025067640468478203, 0.016029732301831245, 0.0022202497348189354, -0.04975869879126549, -0.03745710477232933, -0.006703114602714777, 0.006034685764461756, 0.01277859602123499, -0.004635065793991089, 0.03258667513728142, -0.024728717282414436, 0.020875055342912674, -0.013694940134882927, -0.006128830835223198, 0.02949872426688671, -0.012722109444439411, 0.01661970652639866, -0.022745398804545403 ]
12.436516
4.274282
2024-06-01
1
2024A&A...686A..15G
[ "cluster detection", "galaxy clusters", "cluster number counts", "cluster morphology", "different cluster pressure profiles", "clusters", "cluster masses", "elliptical clusters", "true galaxy clusters", "complex cluster morphologies" ]
[ "methods: numerical", "methods: statistical", "galaxies: clusters: general", "large-scale structure of Universe" ]
4
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202347678" ]
[ "Gallo, S.", "Douspis, M.", "Soubrié, E.", "Salvati, L." ]
[ "Université Paris-Saclay, CNRS, Institut d'Astrophysique Spatiale, 91405, Orsay, France", "Université Paris-Saclay, CNRS, Institut d'Astrophysique Spatiale, 91405, Orsay, France", "Université Paris-Saclay, CNRS, Institut d'Astrophysique Spatiale, 91405, Orsay, France; Institute of Applied Computing &amp; Community Code (IAC), UIB, Spain", "Université Paris-Saclay, CNRS, Institut d'Astrophysique Spatiale, 91405, Orsay, France" ]
[ "2024MNRAS.532..381P" ]
[ "1970Ap&SS...7....3S", "1972CoASP...4..173S", "1980ARA&A..18..537S", "1985ApJ...292..371D", "1992A&A...262L..21O", "1997ApJ...489L...1H", "1997ApJ...490..493N", "1997MNRAS.286..696S", "2002ApJ...580..610H", "2002PhRvD..66j3511L", "2005A&A...429..417M", "2005ApJ...622..759G", "2006A&A...459..341M", "2007ApJ...668....1N", "2008arXiv0807.3004S", "2010A&A...517A..92A", "2010ApJ...708..645R", "2010MNRAS.401..791S", "2011A&A...536A...8P", "2011ARA&A..49..409A", "2012ARA&A..50..353K", "2013A&A...550A.131P", "2013A&A...558A..33A", "2013SSRv..177..155L", "2014A&A...571A...7P", "2014A&A...571A..13P", "2014A&A...571A..16P", "2014A&A...571A..20P", "2014A&A...571A..29P", "2015ApJS..216...27B", "2016A&A...592A...1P", "2016A&A...594A...8P", "2016A&A...594A..13P", "2016A&A...594A..22P", "2016A&A...594A..24P", "2016A&A...594A..26P", "2016A&A...594A..27P", "2017MNRAS.470.2617A", "2018A&A...620A..10P", "2018AJ....156..123A", "2018MNRAS.475..624N", "2018MNRAS.475..648P", "2018MNRAS.475..676S", "2018MNRAS.477.1206N", "2018MNRAS.480.5113M", "2019A&A...632A..47A", "2019ApJ...878...55B", "2019ComAC...6....2N", "2020A&A...635A.195G", "2020MNRAS.499.2303V", "2020Natur.585..357H", "2020PhRvD.102b3509A", "2021A&A...651A..73P", "2021ApJS..253....3H", "2021PhRvD.103d3522C", "2022A&A...661A...2L", "2022A&A...664A.198G", "2022ApJ...935..167A", "2023ApJS..265...55T", "2023MNRAS.522.4766Z" ]
29163305
2406.20096
Galaxy zoo DESI: large-scale bars as a secular mechanism for triggering AGN
Despite the evidence that supermassive black holes (SMBHs) co-evolve with their host galaxy, and that most of the growth of these SMBHs occurs via merger-free processes, the underlying mechanisms which drive this secular co-evolution are poorly understood. We investigate the role that both strong and weak large-scale galactic bars play in mediating this relationship. Using 72,940 disc galaxies in a volume-limited sample from Galaxy Zoo DESI, we analyse the active galactic nucleus (AGN) fraction in strongly barred, weakly barred, and unbarred galaxies up to z = 0.1 over a range of stellar masses and colours. After controlling for stellar mass and colour, we find that the optically selected AGN fraction is 31.6 ± 0.9 per cent in strongly barred galaxies, 23.3 ± 0.8 per cent in weakly barred galaxies, and 14.2 ± 0.6 per cent in unbarred disc galaxies. These are highly statistically robust results, strengthening the tantalising results in earlier works. Strongly barred galaxies have a higher fraction of AGNs than weakly barred galaxies, which in turn have a higher fraction than unbarred galaxies. Thus, while bars are not required in order to grow a SMBH in a disc galaxy, large-scale galactic bars appear to facilitate AGN fuelling, and the presence of a strong bar makes a disc galaxy more than twice as likely to host an AGN than an unbarred galaxy at all galaxy stellar masses and colours.
[ 0.014410712756216526, 0.017463108524680138, 0.023276036605238914, 0.023859761655330658, 0.028018804267048836, 0.0772462859749794, 0.0063601708970963955, -0.005399456713348627, -0.05769149586558342, 0.019287249073386192, -0.007472896948456764, 0.010804994031786919, -0.03745569288730621, 0.02396921068429947, 0.004052632953971624, 0.004143840167671442, -0.02707025036215782, 0.006974298506975174, 0.016526715829968452, 0.013705378398299217, 0.0006566906813532114, 0.04115261882543564, 0.03876907378435135, 0.05365406349301338, -0.061291132122278214, -0.021135712042450905, 0.002087121130898595, 0.06557178497314453, 0.02118435502052307, 0.004523869138211012, 0.013851309195160866, -0.011710984632372856, -0.052000176161527634, 0.010221268981695175, -0.07568968087434769, 0.08532115072011948, 0.017840096727013588, -0.029575403779745102, 0.01292707771062851, -0.02923489734530449, 0.010732028633356094, -0.025440683588385582, -0.03436681255698204, 0.00007956864283187315, 0.008135668002068996, 0.014155332930386066, -0.03237241879105568, -0.059394024312496185, 0.02770261839032173, -0.02005338855087757, -0.08347268402576447, -0.022181551903486252, 0.026048731058835983, -0.022485576570034027, 0.009333521127700806, 0.008360645733773708, -0.025124499574303627, -0.02069791778922081, -0.022765276953577995, -0.012671698816120625, -0.012768985703587532, -0.010780672542750835, 0.011309673078358173, 0.001021518837660551, -0.05005442351102829, -0.028505241498351097, -0.03852585330605507, -0.000735736801289022, 0.03638552874326706, 0.008682910352945328, -0.006101751234382391, -0.04754927009344101, 0.020174996927380562, 0.018606236204504967, 0.02570822462439537, 0.000975155271589756, 0.010920523665845394, -0.002017195802181959, -0.002026316476985812, -0.004067834001034498, 0.01854543201625347, 0.022291000932455063, -0.028067447245121002, -0.0035114712081849575, -0.0179495457559824, 0.010975247249007225, 0.01804683357477188, 0.0041712019592523575, -0.05953995883464813, 0.024759672582149506, 0.06829583644866943, -0.020406056195497513, -0.021853206679224968, -0.024540774524211884, 0.028772782534360886, -0.004250247962772846, 0.057496920228004456, -0.04878968745470047, 0.06926871091127396, 0.014374230057001114, -0.02923489734530449, 0.044338785111904144, 0.015140368603169918, -0.11178334802389145, 0.057399630546569824, -0.036799002438783646, 0.013316228054463863, -0.009935487061738968, 0.007326965685933828, -0.009388244710862637, 0.06031825765967369, 0.02282608300447464, 0.000598546233959496, 0.028067447245121002, -0.05696183815598488, -0.03390469774603844, -0.018034672364592552, 0.03704221919178963, 0.021865367889404297, 0.00784988608211279, 0.010616499930620193, -0.02182888612151146, -0.006913493853062391, 0.019275087863206863, 0.04477657750248909, -0.0014121890999376774, -0.03110768273472786, -0.03726111724972725, -0.028432276099920273, -0.013632412999868393, 0.04319565370678902, -0.007138471119105816, -0.0011385679244995117, 0.012051490135490894, -0.026024408638477325, 0.004703243263065815, -0.028626849874854088, -0.002096241805702448, -0.02672974392771721, 0.0404229611158371, -0.015724094584584236, 0.010130061767995358, 0.026875674724578857, -0.004000948742032051, -0.0077708400785923, 0.01454448327422142, -0.04363344982266426, -0.012337272986769676, -0.018508948385715485, 0.004280650522559881, -0.02033309079706669, 0.02297201380133629, -0.03285885602235794, -0.045846741646528244, -0.04908154904842377, -0.003228729357942939, -0.03799077495932579, 0.004855255130678415, -0.017499592155218124, -0.04543326795101166, -0.008415370248258114, 0.015140368603169918, -0.00579772749915719, 0.04416853189468384, 0.002354661701247096, 0.0503949299454689, -0.009734831750392914, -0.011145500466227531, -0.05710776895284653, -0.03879339620471001, 0.003763810731470585, 0.011710984632372856, -0.01179611124098301, 0.000400170887587592, 0.0009584340150468051, 0.005794687662273645, 0.004897817969322205, -0.028407953679561615, -0.015371426939964294, -0.018265729770064354, 0.0047974903136491776, 0.04197956249117851, -0.01430126465857029, -0.06630144268274307, -0.0423930324614048, 0.0457008071243763, -0.007472896948456764, 0.05428643152117729, 0.018265729770064354, -0.0426848940551281, -0.0038398164324462414, 0.01568761095404625, 0.03431817144155502, 0.023981371894478798, 0.011230627074837685, -0.03122929111123085, 0.03261563926935196, 0.015517357736825943, -0.029307862743735313, 0.041079651564359665, 0.02884574793279171, 0.03283453360199928, 0.015748415142297745, -0.05083272606134415, -0.05696183815598488, -0.06386925280094147, 0.042855147272348404, -0.011492087505757809, 0.0328831784427166, 0.026754066348075867, 0.03662874922156334, -0.001811979920603335, -0.007162793073803186, -0.015322783030569553, -0.01770632714033127, -0.020102031528949738, -0.05919945240020752, 0.022874725982546806, 0.05243796855211258, 0.012191341258585453, 0.004578593652695417, 0.02457725815474987, 0.0011416081106290221, 0.02107490785419941, 0.019664239138364792, 0.012659537605941296, 0.038939327001571655, -0.008068783208727837, 0.0343911349773407, 0.019226444885134697, 0.022473415359854698, 0.0336371585726738, -0.0029231857042759657, -0.043828025460243225, -0.003979667089879513, 0.02081952802836895, 0.013559446670114994, 0.04978688433766365, 0.010452327318489552, -0.04801138862967491, -0.02733779139816761, 0.022765276953577995, 0.020783044397830963, 0.013121653348207474, -0.04336590692400932, 0.021877529099583626, 0.007290482986718416, 0.006004463415592909, 0.0011750507401302457, 0.006016624625772238, -0.01347432006150484, -0.025927122682332993, -0.006767562590539455, 0.007448574993759394, -0.03084014169871807, -0.028286343440413475, -0.04275786131620407, 0.02519746497273445, -0.04249032214283943, -0.022303162142634392, -0.01769416593015194, -0.030669888481497765, -0.03358851373195648, -0.015359265729784966, -0.0436091274023056, 0.022145070135593414, 0.016709130257368088, -0.040447283536195755, -0.03295614570379257, 0.04577377438545227, 0.016478072851896286, -0.011309673078358173, 0.02748372219502926, -0.05881030112504959, -0.023008497431874275, -0.007673552725464106, 0.012398077175021172, 0.024540774524211884, 0.0076188282109797, -0.06348010152578354, -0.005685239098966122, -0.004967743530869484, 0.060026396065950394, 0.027021607384085655, 0.027118893340229988, 0.003876299364492297, -0.019883135333657265, -0.011400880292057991, 0.0046789213083684444, 0.019603433087468147, 0.07442494481801987, -0.03738272562623024, -0.0045147486962378025, 0.02231532335281372, -0.0035266722552478313, -0.007679632864892483, 0.035193756222724915, 0.01906835287809372, -0.032421063631772995, 0.021026263013482094, 0.028067447245121002, 0.03976627066731453, 0.02434620074927807, -0.014191815629601479, -0.026437880471348763, -0.004916059784591198, 0.026024408638477325, 0.05584303289651871, -0.02670542150735855, 0.03648281842470169, 0.017268532887101173, -0.05170831084251404, -0.017098279669880867, 0.027532365173101425, -0.07530053704977036, -0.029940232634544373, -0.026559490710496902, 0.025878477841615677, 0.022351805120706558, -0.04416853189468384, -0.05409185588359833, 0.012574410997331142, -0.07510595768690109, -0.006250722799450159, 0.02935650758445263, -0.054481007158756256, -0.004101276863366365, 0.02658381313085556, -0.011273190379142761, -0.03147251158952713, 0.023774635046720505, -0.0006091870600357652, 0.025173144415020943, 0.05204881727695465, -0.0046789213083684444, -0.08065135031938553, 0.02207210473716259, 0.04416853189468384, -0.033418260514736176, 0.02959972620010376, 0.03701789677143097, 0.008737634867429733, 0.011273190379142761, -0.028140412643551826, 0.021512700244784355, -0.0026176420506089926, 0.037698909640312195, 0.05365406349301338, 0.026437880471348763, -0.013814826495945454, 0.009114624001085758, -0.0041195182129740715, 0.033807411789894104, -0.0227044727653265, 0.04594402760267258, -0.023859761655330658, 0.012075812555849552, -0.05452965199947357, -0.01642942801117897, 0.0010283594019711018, 0.005293048918247223, -0.01655103825032711, 0.023555738851428032, 0.023932727053761482, -0.009400405921041965, 0.017487430945038795, -0.0011522489367052913, -0.011218465864658356, 0.014580965973436832, -0.01695234887301922, -0.0005183600005693734, 0.03239674121141434, -0.0036847644951194525, -0.015079564414918423, -0.02068575657904148, 0.02857820689678192, 0.012051490135490894, 0.032421063631772995, 0.01228254847228527, -0.002401785459369421, 0.0198344923555851, -0.027897194027900696, 0.029040321707725525, -0.025416363030672073, 0.00042297266190871596, -0.002012635348364711, -0.030061841011047363, -0.022424772381782532, -0.0760301873087883, 0.024686705321073532, 0.03332097455859184, 0.0005544628365896642, 0.02057630941271782, -0.020539825782179832, -0.02809176966547966, -0.025440683588385582, 0.016769934445619583, 0.035801805555820465, 0.00485829496756196, 0.08123507350683212, -0.060512833297252655, -0.05277847498655319, -0.0378691628575325, -0.06610686331987381, 0.0027590130921453238, -0.013206779956817627, -0.0017238131258636713, 0.02306930162012577, 0.018156282603740692, -0.024115141481161118, 0.06542585045099258, 0.008099185302853584, 0.02106274664402008, -0.021269481629133224, -0.00802621990442276, 0.03436681255698204, -0.05754556506872177, 0.013425677083432674, 0.0055697099305689335, 0.04818164184689522, 0.009698349051177502, -0.010859718546271324, 0.05302169546484947, -0.017377981916069984, -0.020174996927380562, -0.010361120104789734, -0.025635259225964546, 0.04820596054196358, 0.008166070096194744, -0.018776489421725273, -0.01904403045773506, 0.06401517987251282, -0.007855966687202454, -0.010136142373085022, -0.018375178799033165, -0.014143171720206738, -0.0017450947780162096, -0.008068783208727837, -0.0020749601535499096, -0.04224710166454315, 0.07335478067398071, -0.031180648133158684, -0.018910260871052742, -0.02507585659623146, 0.01881297305226326, 0.026656778529286385, 0.030159128829836845, 0.026510847732424736, 0.0276053324341774, -0.04725740849971771, -0.014471517875790596, -0.03738272562623024, 0.014860667288303375, -0.020260123535990715, -0.04499547556042671, -0.02420026808977127, -0.0006019664579071105, -0.005362974014133215, 0.01040368340909481, -0.05710776895284653, 0.02044253796339035, 0.009984130971133709, -0.014082367531955242, 0.008366726338863373, -0.02244909293949604, -0.03132657706737518, -0.00454515079036355, 0.013304066844284534, 0.0011666901409626007, 0.027799906209111214, 0.014398551546037197, -0.04864375665783882, -0.008287680335342884, 0.007922851480543613, 0.0014767940156161785, -0.028553884476423264, -0.011534650810062885, 0.0024139464367181063, 0.03451274335384369, 0.004590754397213459, 0.018740007653832436, -0.014447195455431938, -0.017900902777910233, 0.02472318895161152, -0.005539307836443186, 0.03638552874326706, 0.005296088755130768, 0.034926217049360275, -0.011194144375622272, -0.015249817632138729, -0.024370521306991577, -0.029697012156248093, 0.09169348329305649, -0.011565052904188633, 0.007278321776539087, 0.006956057157367468, -0.028894390910863876, -0.03536400943994522, 0.006633792072534561, 0.0276053324341774, 0.06508534401655197, -0.01918996125459671, -0.011346155777573586, -0.020150676369667053, 0.011388719081878662, 0.02105058543384075, 0.0005468622548505664, -0.008074863813817501, 0.01679425686597824, 0.014848506078124046, -0.0469169020652771, -0.007108069024980068, 0.0008482254925183952, -0.015517357736825943, -0.025246109813451767, 0.01757255755364895, -0.003806373802945018, 0.014605287462472916, 0.01424045953899622, -0.020272284746170044, -0.0010785232298076153, -0.04830325022339821, -0.00101163808722049, 0.0191656406968832, 0.027191858738660812, 0.0012647376861423254, -0.02285040356218815, -0.10234646499156952, -0.058129288256168365, -0.01422829832881689, -0.043828025460243225, -0.034415457397699356, 0.05516202002763748, -0.01918996125459671, -0.02660813368856907, -0.032785892486572266, -0.022132908925414085, -0.004423541482537985, -0.02908896654844284, -0.014106689020991325, 0.0015976433642208576, 0.011376558803021908, 0.004447863437235355, -0.032299455255270004, 0.013060848228633404, 0.0122947096824646, -0.010944845154881477, -0.006250722799450159, 0.024431327357888222, 0.035704515874385834, 0.03397766500711441, 0.01115766167640686, 0.03850153461098671, 0.04450903832912445, -0.02407865971326828, -0.002786375116556883, 0.021415414288640022, 0.0008269438403658569, -0.004481305833905935, -0.009990211576223373, -0.008062702603638172, 0.00783772487193346, -0.01154073141515255, 0.020479021593928337, -0.023750314489006996, -0.03852585330605507, 0.0016356463311240077, 0.01230078935623169, -0.043317265808582306, 0.05204881727695465, 0.008105265907943249, 0.0014653931139037013, 0.050346288830041885, -0.0019366295309737325, 0.015760576352477074, -0.006530424114316702, -0.03923118859529495, 0.021232999861240387, 0.0028669412713497877, -0.04292811453342438, -0.031423866748809814, -0.050881367176771164, -0.024625901132822037, 0.011340075172483921, -0.007801242172718048, 0.011437362991273403, 0.022619346156716347, 0.03998516872525215, 0.034561388194561005, 0.003478028578683734, 0.016636164858937263, -0.04514140635728836, 0.0029672691598534584, -0.011248868890106678, -0.016855061054229736, 0.009813877753913403, 0.0038945407141000032, 0.01780361495912075, 0.0109022818505764, 0.01253792829811573, -0.002198089612647891, -0.03704221919178963, -0.01631998084485531, -0.020418217405676842, -0.008214714005589485, -0.011948122642934322, 0.009382164105772972, -0.011948122642934322, 0.005676118191331625, 0.01499443780630827, 0.011315753683447838, 0.0007562583778053522, -0.008166070096194744, -0.02283824421465397, -0.013462159782648087, -0.016721291467547417, -0.008001897484064102, -0.009339600801467896, 0.005779486149549484, -0.004317133221775293, -0.005761244799941778, 0.02782422862946987, -0.02522178739309311, -0.0038428567349910736, 0.017086118459701538, 0.02306930162012577, -0.014459356665611267, -0.027435079216957092, 0.006329768802970648, -0.043098367750644684, -0.015116047114133835, -0.02159782685339451, -0.00342026399448514, -0.006171676330268383, -0.02972133457660675, -0.01932373270392418, -0.006323688197880983, 0.03621527552604675, -0.026243306696414948, -0.016283497214317322, 0.04664936289191246, -0.01329190656542778, 0.0051227957010269165, -0.031180648133158684, -0.015529518947005272, 0.024638062343001366, -0.016733452677726746, -0.013437837362289429, -0.03426952660083771, -0.00971051026135683, -0.018131960183382034, -0.008007978089153767, 0.0032226487528532743, -0.01882513426244259, 0.004280650522559881, 0.006664194632321596, 0.009442969225347042, -0.004137759562581778, -0.06712838262319565, 0.04903290793299675, -0.01104213297367096, 0.006016624625772238, 0.006609470117837191, -0.0155416801571846, -0.012756825424730778, -0.004843093920499086, -0.011370478197932243, 0.02857820689678192, 0.00357227586209774, -0.0037394887767732143, 0.090817891061306, 0.01191163994371891, -0.011650179512798786, 0.026754066348075867, 0.00005904705903958529, -0.00310711981728673, -0.00423200661316514, 0.015079564414918423, -0.03246970847249031, -0.0006471899687312543, 0.02884574793279171, 0.03210487961769104, 0.003772931406274438, -0.00520792230963707, 0.031204968690872192, 0.02170727588236332, 0.028018804267048836, 0.018338695168495178, 0.01718340627849102, -0.02921057492494583, 0.008001897484064102, -0.008372806943953037, 0.02962404675781727, 0.009911165572702885, -0.02406649850308895, -0.003654362168163061, 0.021123550832271576, 0.013997240923345089, -0.04356048256158829, -0.054626937955617905, 0.018776489421725273, -0.0020932017359882593, 0.04015542194247246, -0.019031869247555733, -0.003102559596300125, -0.020491182804107666, -0.0010070777498185635, 0.0058129290118813515, -0.015334944240748882, -0.05846979469060898, 0.04939773306250572, 0.04348751902580261, -0.01566328853368759, 0.017232051119208336, 0.0010504011297598481, -0.036069344729185104, -0.011175902560353279, 0.02133028768002987, 0.004146880004554987, 0.0051744794473052025, -0.02258286438882351, -0.03407495096325874, -0.05696183815598488, -0.013510803692042828, 0.026146018877625465, -0.0304753128439188, -0.017341498285531998, 0.04611428081989288, -0.021768080070614815, -0.034293849021196365, 0.0026830071583390236, 0.015140368603169918, 0.0012822189601138234, -0.010117901489138603, -0.03011048585176468, 0.03246970847249031, 0.0008337844046764076, -0.0259514432400465, -0.03397766500711441, 0.02409082092344761, 0.013097330927848816, -0.01298788283020258, 0.0029915908817201853, 0.021232999861240387, 0.014617448672652245, -0.012288629077374935, 0.0002931926283054054, -0.05564845725893974, 0.007539782207459211, 0.008378886617720127, 0.0012829790357500315, 0.009430808015167713, 0.0016432468546554446, 0.0038610980845987797, 0.02758101001381874, 0.006664194632321596, 0.013571607880294323, -0.019858812913298607, 0.02146405726671219, 0.01298788283020258, 0.018752168864011765, -0.0011659300653263927, 0.004922139924019575, 0.01158937532454729, -0.026364915072917938, 0.00896261166781187, -0.018034672364592552, -0.011583294719457626, 0.025124499574303627, 0.011017810553312302, 0.0036209195386618376, 0.02872413769364357, 0.006402734201401472, -0.027921516448259354, 0.03509647026658058, 0.025756869465112686, 0.010713786818087101, -0.018350856378674507, 0.014775540679693222, -0.02660813368856907, -0.027410756796598434, -0.02168295346200466, -0.020795205608010292, 0.007667472120374441, -0.03074285387992859, 0.022595025599002838, 0.03896364942193031, -0.009819958359003067, -0.0015702812233939767, -0.015152529813349247, -0.03271292522549629, 0.011625858023762703, 0.01906835287809372, 0.010063176974654198, -0.006469619460403919, 0.032664280384778976, -0.016988832503557205, -0.11470197886228561, 0.0033077753614634275, 0.025173144415020943, 0.02857820689678192, 0.002409385982900858, 0.01756039634346962, 0.0336371585726738, 0.04137151315808296, 0.033685799688100815, 0.0191656406968832, -0.010798913426697254, 0.001702531473711133, -0.01908051408827305, 0.04392531141638756, 0.0035479539074003696, -0.018496789038181305, -0.04377938061952591, 0.0089747728779912, 0.00014564624871127307, 0.004840053617954254, -0.001130967284552753, 0.027191858738660812, -0.013206779956817627, 0.00014574125816579908, 0.022412611171603203, -0.005727802403271198, -0.02685135416686535, 0.03864746540784836, 0.005177519749850035, 0.009096382185816765, 0.01028815470635891, -0.02736211195588112, -0.027945837005972862, 0.027799906209111214, -0.018533270806074142, -0.05783742666244507, 0.022667990997433662, 0.0049099791795015335, -0.025635259225964546, -0.0027559727896004915, -0.021573506295681, -0.03122929111123085, -0.01347432006150484, -0.021755920723080635, 0.011972444131970406, -0.001500355894677341, 0.020126353949308395, 0.01430126465857029, -0.004055673256516457, -0.005980141926556826, 0.002889743074774742, 0.0056700375862419605, 0.025002891197800636, 0.012586572207510471, -0.020260123535990715, -0.03237241879105568, 0.007381690200418234, -0.013364871963858604, -0.02908896654844284, -0.009953728877007961, -0.023908406496047974, 0.01417965441942215, 0.004605955444276333, -0.03478028625249863, -0.006615550722926855, -0.01566328853368759, -0.008926128968596458, -0.01880081184208393, -0.002081040758639574, -0.0245894193649292, -0.002942947205156088, 0.010993489064276218, -0.0027529324870556593, 0.0026890875305980444, -0.005697399843484163, 0.026291949674487114, -0.034682996571063995, 0.0038124544080346823, -0.06591229140758514, -0.011777869425714016, 0.00019086974498350173, -0.030499635264277458, 0.024248912930488586, -0.004745806567370892, 0.023251716047525406, -0.014872828498482704, 0.032031912356615067, 0.013778343796730042, -0.03609366714954376, 0.027872871607542038, 0.01956695131957531, -0.004222886171191931, 0.007819483987987041, 0.05015171319246292, 0.02084384858608246, 0.024820476770401, 0.01807115599513054, -0.013960758224129677, 0.007187115028500557, -0.0016827699728310108, -0.014945793896913528, -0.016976671293377876, 0.005238324403762817, -0.022400449961423874, 0.022595025599002838, -0.02996455319225788, -0.005767325405031443, 0.02709457278251648, 0.01236159447580576, 0.01374186109751463, 0.057253699749708176, 0.045092761516571045, -0.0033989823423326015, 0.0003082038019783795, 0.04504411667585373, -0.00964970514178276, -0.023251716047525406, 0.02573254704475403, -0.014191815629601479, -0.01216701976954937, -0.014386391267180443, -0.028943035751581192, -0.0058311703614890575, 0.005761244799941778, 0.020466860383749008, -0.011929880827665329, -0.008713312447071075, -0.0010891640558838844, -0.02585415542125702, 0.023409808054566383, -0.017000991851091385, -0.011333995498716831, 0.019639916718006134, -0.033175040036439896, -0.009753072634339333, -0.008993014693260193, -0.02168295346200466, 0.0358990915119648, -0.011534650810062885, 0.006639872677624226, 0.0044873864389956, -0.00991724617779255, -0.025805512443184853, 0.04480089992284775, -0.001277658622711897, 0.009619303047657013, -0.04881400987505913, -0.023482773452997208, 0.04054456949234009, -0.013145974837243557, 0.017256371676921844, -0.00820255372673273, -0.01128535158932209, 0.025294752791523933, 0.02809176966547966, 0.015955151990056038, 0.032275132834911346, 0.00154519930947572, -0.004000948742032051, 0.041809309273958206, 0.01883729360997677, 0.03263996168971062, -0.010294235311448574, -0.029040321707725525, -0.012464962899684906, 0.024735350161790848, -0.012173100374639034, -0.013073009438812733, 0.002163127064704895, -0.026997284963726997, -0.022862564772367477, -0.053605418652296066, 0.00840928964316845, 0.003505390603095293, -0.030280737206339836, -0.010926603339612484, 0.010871879756450653, -0.005332571920007467, -0.0008246636716648936, 0.05156238004565239, 0.007472896948456764, -0.030013198032975197, -0.03074285387992859, 0.019104834645986557, 0.0043019321747124195, 0.012610893696546555, -0.002400265308097005, 0.019104834645986557, 0.049470700323581696, -0.019408859312534332, -0.007995817810297012, 0.024285394698381424, 0.021780241280794144, 0.038209669291973114, -0.02372599206864834, 0.02972133457660675, 0.0021281642839312553, 0.029551081359386444, 0.025294752791523933, -0.0008581062429584563, -0.03509647026658058, -0.06299366056919098, 0.011625858023762703, 0.010519212111830711, 0.0052991290576756, 0.01804683357477188, 0.02134244702756405, -0.022363966330885887, -0.05122187361121178, -0.009619303047657013, 0.005372094921767712, 0.015760576352477074, 0.02030876837670803, -0.00032967544393613935, 0.04591970518231392, -0.007673552725464106, 0.01443503424525261, -0.01717124506831169, -0.037066541612148285, -0.03132657706737518, 0.026121696457266808, -0.052875760942697525, 0.011291432194411755, 0.006469619460403919, -0.005347772967070341, 0.023738153278827667, -0.0034385055769234896, -0.02130596525967121, 0.005916296970099211, -0.009205831214785576, 0.0075945062562823296, -0.0003598877810873091, 0.0013969878200441599, 0.002658685203641653, -0.031010394915938377, 0.003952305298298597, 0.004399219527840614, 0.02171943709254265, -0.028189057484269142, 0.006682435981929302, 0.024261074140667915, -0.022242357954382896, -0.011741386726498604, -0.015103885903954506, -0.02159782685339451, -0.02748372219502926, -0.00244738906621933, -0.010646902024745941, 0.009363923221826553, -0.02860252931714058, -0.0006042466848157346, -0.007156712468713522, -0.014216138049960136, 0.003985747694969177, -0.006311527453362942, 0.022996336221694946, -0.012829790823161602, 0.01292707771062851, 0.025902800261974335, -0.010835397057235241, 0.015407909639179707, -0.008403209038078785, -0.01054353453218937, -0.04241735488176346, 0.008901807479560375, 0.0358990915119648, -0.01807115599513054, 0.01618620939552784, 0.011382638476788998, 0.0005533227231353521, 0.024686705321073532, -0.001720772823318839, -0.0028122172225266695, 0.03896364942193031, -0.005581871140748262, -0.000607286870945245, 0.002228492172434926, -0.0038945407141000032, 0.0014114290243014693, 0.025416363030672073, -0.0007247159373946488, -0.005414658226072788, -0.012574410997331142, 0.005317370407283306, 0.010719867423176765, 0.023409808054566383, -0.020369572564959526, -0.003645241493359208, -0.014058045111596584, -0.04227142408490181, 0.004083035048097372, 0.020162837579846382, 0.038915004581213, -0.004149920307099819, 0.017013153061270714, -0.023507095873355865, -0.02923489734530449, 0.015748415142297745, -0.0074120922945439816, 0.009625383652746677, -0.02998887561261654, -0.01680641807615757, 0.011127259582281113, -0.03161844238638878, 0.019870974123477936, -0.047330375760793686, 0.0065729874186217785, -0.038452889770269394, 0.00044577440712600946, 0.019469663500785828, -0.016015956178307533, -0.0032712926622480154, -0.035801805555820465, 0.013522963970899582, -0.003450666554272175, -0.02682703174650669, 0.01906835287809372, 0.003845897037535906, -0.0009766754228621721, -0.01843598298728466, 0.013182457536458969, -0.013413515873253345, 0.023555738851428032, -0.013875631615519524, -0.02456509694457054, -0.01970072090625763, 0.008232955820858479, -0.024625901132822037, 0.032299455255270004, 0.04548191279172897, 0.01028815470635891, 0.03086446411907673, -0.0006384492735378444, -0.004298891872167587, -0.02621898427605629, 0.04380370303988457, -0.003864138387143612, 0.017146924510598183, 0.006597309373319149, 0.01757255755364895, -0.019129157066345215, -0.02484479919075966, -0.036069344729185104, 0.010701626539230347, 0.013875631615519524, 0.01841166242957115, -0.006694596726447344, -0.002807656768709421, -0.02433403953909874, -0.004314092919230461, 0.06844176352024078, -0.036166634410619736, -0.00895653199404478, -0.00555450888350606, 0.03572883829474449, 0.002927746158093214, 0.02056414820253849, -0.002696688286960125, 0.01769416593015194, 0.014812023378908634, -0.014216138049960136, -0.0025218746159225702, -0.014422873966395855, -0.002641964005306363, 0.017232051119208336, 0.002711889334022999, 0.0021296844352036715, 0.01430126465857029, -0.00435969652608037, 0.024248912930488586, -0.014520160853862762, 0.0005263406201265752, -0.019019708037376404, 0.010573936626315117, -0.006199038587510586, -0.006658114027231932, 0.045822419226169586, 0.02446780912578106, -0.031302258372306824, 0.014641770161688328, 0.01347432006150484, 0.004472185391932726, -0.012817629612982273, 0.016624003648757935, -0.016368623822927475, -0.025367718189954758, -0.013000044040381908, 0.02043037675321102, 0.031302258372306824, 0.013997240923345089, 0.029137609526515007, 0.011935961432754993, 0.019980423152446747, 0.007381690200418234, 0.005125836003571749, -0.016149727627635002, 0.01242847926914692, 0.04905722662806511, 0.01867920160293579, -0.008518737740814686, -0.023628704249858856, -0.0017587757902219892, 0.00241242628544569, -0.013109492138028145, 0.0038337360601872206, 0.01920212246477604, -0.0005092393257655203, 0.024479970335960388, 0.0198344923555851, -0.04626021161675453, -0.00802621990442276, 0.0149336326867342, 0.004694122355431318, 0.02996455319225788, 0.02372599206864834, -0.00447826599702239, -0.0034172239247709513, -0.008841002359986305, 0.029940232634544373, -0.01580922119319439, -0.01443503424525261, 0.013413515873253345, -0.006761481985449791, 0.014447195455431938, -0.008506576530635357, -0.02384760230779648, -0.01944534108042717, -0.0017238131258636713, -0.012647376395761967, -0.013839148916304111, -0.003137522377073765, -0.013364871963858604, -0.024042176082730293, 0.036166634410619736, -0.026778386905789375, -0.03361283615231514, 0.011753547936677933, 0.025246109813451767, -0.026924319565296173, 0.024163786321878433, -0.010835397057235241, 0.004463064484298229, -0.003146643051877618, 0.01730501651763916, 0.028553884476423264, 0.00169341079890728, 0.005362974014133215, 0.04229574650526047, 0.020150676369667053, 0.007551942951977253, -0.008129587396979332, 0.047719523310661316, -0.0010101180523633957, -0.048108674585819244, 0.008986934088170528, 0.014812023378908634, -0.011759627610445023, -0.02709457278251648, 0.03784484043717384, -0.02080736681818962, 0.05253525823354721, 0.026048731058835983, 0.003915822133421898, -0.027921516448259354, 0.00946121010929346, 0.05141644924879074, 0.01178395003080368, -0.028189057484269142, -0.007667472120374441, -0.03835560008883476, 0.01918996125459671, 0.0155416801571846, 0.01981016993522644, -0.014033723622560501, -0.024017853662371635, -0.013085170648992062, -0.0010549614671617746, -0.009990211576223373, -0.0011294472496956587, 0.01593082956969738, -0.023531416431069374, 0.001003277488052845, 0.002199609763920307, 0.007126310374587774, 0.014702575281262398, -0.00410431670024991, 0.014386391267180443, -0.01768200471997261, 0.043463196605443954, 0.0283593088388443, 0.00839712843298912, -0.015724094584584236, -0.04205252602696419, -0.03383173048496246, 0.034439779818058014, -0.003274332731962204, 0.007138471119105816, -0.004280650522559881, 0.007478977553546429, 0.018496789038181305, 0.01417965441942215, -0.00011638398427749053, 0.022230196744203568, -0.016210531815886497, 0.010440166108310223, 0.015395748429000378, -0.009625383652746677, -0.004764047916978598, -0.03156979754567146, -0.005749084055423737, -0.0030584761407226324, 0.0191656406968832, -0.01348648127168417, -0.003359459340572357, 0.01967639848589897, 0.002190489089116454, -0.003044795012101531, -0.010428004898130894, -0.00884708296507597, 0.019275087863206863, -0.021366769447922707, -0.013437837362289429, -0.009868602268397808, -0.03704221919178963, -0.03699357807636261, -0.03208055719733238, 0.022023459896445274, -0.02008987031877041, -0.03312639892101288, 0.022132908925414085, 0.020162837579846382, -0.03074285387992859, -0.008640347048640251, -0.027678297832608223, -0.024248912930488586, -0.003008312312886119, -0.00966186635196209, 0.015176852233707905, 0.015030920505523682, 0.0059831817634403706, -0.010190866887569427, -0.011820432730019093, 0.01203932985663414, 0.009400405921041965, 0.0020278366282582283, 0.05443236231803894, -0.007022942416369915, -0.0351451151072979, 0.012197421863675117, 0.012501445598900318, -0.024759672582149506, -0.04830325022339821, 0.03918254375457764, 0.00026716061984188855, 0.0072114369831979275, -0.007783000823110342, 0.004718444310128689, -0.00004296706902096048, -0.017536073923110962, 0.004067834001034498, 0.032421063631772995, -0.030548278242349625, 0.010379360988736153, 0.012805468402802944, -0.006268964149057865, 0.019408859312534332, -0.022777438163757324, 0.00592541741207242, -0.012385915964841843, 0.0004643958527594805, 0.037942130118608475, -0.01668480783700943, 0.009874682873487473, 0.013462159782648087, -0.025537971407175064, -0.016867222264409065, 0.015638967975974083, -0.03959601745009422, 0.02634059451520443, 0.01769416593015194, 0.00940648652613163, -0.03451274335384369, 0.0008900287211872637, -0.013608090579509735, -0.0027286107651889324, 0.014641770161688328, -0.024820476770401, 0.0022877766750752926, -0.027118893340229988, 0.022753117606043816, -0.0025157942436635494, -0.007132390514016151, -0.0028122172225266695, 0.02972133457660675, 0.00809310469776392, 0.023993533104658127, 0.001362025155685842, -0.011942042037844658, -0.05846979469060898, -0.02933218516409397, 0.017232051119208336, 0.035947736352682114, -0.00511367479339242, 0.011279270984232426, -0.011370478197932243, 0.0015064362669363618, 0.012398077175021172, -0.028553884476423264, -0.062750443816185, 0.003791172755882144, -0.02646220289170742, 0.02495424635708332, 0.02396921068429947, 0.019092673435807228, 0.017900902777910233, 0.02407865971326828, -0.026364915072917938, 0.007284402381628752, -0.0035236321855336428, -0.008688990958034992, -0.023774635046720505, -0.022473415359854698, 0.015772737562656403, -0.015614645555615425, -0.028651172295212746, -0.0025218746159225702, -0.009114624001085758, 0.014775540679693222, -0.00684052798897028, 0.003177045378834009, 0.04599267244338989, 0.016964510083198547, 0.021160034462809563, -0.00025347957853227854, -0.03062124364078045, 0.005259606055915356, -0.008603864349424839, -0.013109492138028145, -0.00017101320554502308, 0.01743878610432148, 0.02332468144595623, 0.005128875840455294, -0.006293286103755236, -0.03872042894363403, 0.029769979417324066, -0.005308249965310097, 0.0008565861498937011, 0.0021661673672497272, 0.018217086791992188, -0.009485532529652119, -0.0023683428298681974, 0.04840053617954254, -0.003277373034507036, -0.014532322064042091, 0.013413515873253345, -0.002575078746303916, -0.02243693172931671, 0.014070206321775913, 0.033150721341371536, -0.02271663397550583, 0.013583769090473652, 0.0244434867054224, 0.0053052096627652645, 0.023908406496047974, 0.015225495211780071, 0.030329382047057152, 0.0009280316298827529, 0.05428643152117729, -0.011261029168963432, 0.00010764331091195345, -0.031642764806747437, -0.017353659495711327, -0.008567381650209427, 0.01666048727929592, 0.022181551903486252, 0.0027833348140120506, -0.013194618746638298, 0.026024408638477325, 0.017840096727013588, 0.008768036961555481, -0.0002895823563449085, -0.029648369178175926, 0.019335893914103508, 0.029429472982883453, -0.009819958359003067, 0.023543577641248703, 0.005253525450825691, 0.01967639848589897, -0.014386391267180443, -0.02573254704475403, 0.009965889155864716, 0.007035103160887957, 0.032542672008275986, -0.030280737206339836, -0.02321523241698742, 0.013206779956817627, -0.014812023378908634, 0.011279270984232426, -0.006797964684665203, -0.02344628982245922, -0.013571607880294323, -0.02107490785419941, -0.030694210901856422, 0.020114192739129066, 0.026146018877625465, -0.01110901776701212, 0.0356072299182415, -0.016259174793958664, 0.0419309176504612, 0.00016075241728685796, -0.00796541478484869, -0.010063176974654198, -0.02522178739309311, -0.0030311141163110733, -0.014447195455431938, -0.006907413247972727, 0.01303652673959732, 0.02857820689678192, 0.0007889409316703677, -0.010683384723961353, 0.009376084432005882, 0.01498227659612894, -0.02694864012300968, -0.01368105597794056, -0.011212386190891266, -0.0446549691259861, 0.00953417643904686, 0.031642764806747437, 0.030888784676790237, -0.0200655497610569, 0.020977620035409927, 0.023932727053761482, 0.003505390603095293, -0.009637543931603432, -0.012756825424730778, -0.004420501179993153, -0.03473164141178131, -0.02269231155514717, -0.009978050366044044 ]
10.613056
6.879557
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.tmp.1590G
[ "unbarred disc galaxies", "weakly barred galaxies", "unbarred galaxies", "AGN fraction", "bars", "AGN fuelling", "stellar masses", "supermassive black holes", "stellar mass", "Galaxy Zoo DESI" ]
[ "galaxies: active", "galaxies: bar", "galaxies: disc", "galaxies: Seyfert", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies", "Astrophysics - High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena" ]
36
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1620", "10.48550/arXiv.2406.20096" ]
[ "Garland, Izzy L.", "Walmsley, Mike", "Silcock, Maddie S.", "Potts, Leah M.", "Smith, Josh", "Simmons, Brooke D.", "Lintott, Chris J.", "Smethurst, Rebecca J.", "Dawson, James M.", "Keel, William C.", "Kruk, Sandor", "Mantha, Kameswara Bharadwaj", "Masters, Karen L.", "O'Ryan, David", "Popp, Jürgen J.", "Thorne, Matthew R." ]
[ "Physics Department, Lancaster University, Lancaster, LA1 4YB, UK", "Dunlap Institute for Astronomy and Astrophysics, University of Toronto, 50 St. George Street, Toronto, ON M5S 3H4, Canada; Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, Department of Physics &amp; Astronomy, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester, M13 9PL, UK", "Physics Department, Lancaster University, Lancaster, LA1 4YB, UK; Centre for Astrophysics Research, University of Hertfordshire, College Lane, Hatfield, AL10 9AB, UK", "Physics Department, Lancaster University, Lancaster, LA1 4YB, UK", "Physics Department, Lancaster University, Lancaster, LA1 4YB, UK", "Physics Department, Lancaster University, Lancaster, LA1 4YB, UK", "Oxford Astrophysics, Department of Physics, University of Oxford, Denys Wilkinson Building, Keble Road, Oxford, OX1 3RH, UK", "Oxford Astrophysics, Department of Physics, University of Oxford, Denys Wilkinson Building, Keble Road, Oxford, OX1 3RH, UK", "South African Radio Astronomy Observatory (SARAO), Black River Park North, 2 Fir St, Cape Town, South Africa, 7925; Department of Physics and Electronics, Rhodes University, PO Box 94, Makhanda 6140, South Africa", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Alabama, 206 Gallalee Hall, 514 University Blvd. Tuscaloosa, AL 35487-0324, USA", "European Space Agency (ESA), European Space Astronomy Centre (ESAC), Camino Bajo del Castillo s/n, 28692, Villaneuva de la Cañada, Madrid, Spain", "School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota, 55455, USA; Minnesota Institute for Astrophysics, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota, 55455, USA", "Departments of Physics and Astronomy, Haverford College, Lancaster Avenue, Ardmore, PA, 19041 USA", "Physics Department, Lancaster University, Lancaster, LA1 4YB, UK", "School of Physical Sciences, The Open University, Milton Keynes, MK7 6AA, UK", "Physics Department, Lancaster University, Lancaster, LA1 4YB, UK" ]
null
[ "1981PASP...93....5B", "1987ApJS...63..295V", "1991ApJ...376..380C", "1993A&A...268...65F", "1996ApJ...471..173S", "2000AJ....120.1579Y", "2000ApJ...529...93K", "2001ApJ...556..121K", "2002ApJ...567...97L", "2002MNRAS.329..502M", "2003MNRAS.341.1179A", "2003MNRAS.346.1055K", "2004ApJ...600..595R", "2004MNRAS.351.1151B", "2005AJ....129.2562B", "2005ASPC..347...29T", "2006ApJS..166....1H", "2006MNRAS.372..961K", "2007ApJ...671.1388D", "2007ApJS..173..267S", "2007CSE.....9...90H", "2007MNRAS.382.1415S", "2010ApJS..186..427N", "2011ApJ...743L..13C", "2011MNRAS.411.2026M", "2011PASA...28..128C", "2012ASSL..378...83C", "2012ApJ...746...90A", "2012ApJ...756...26M", "2012ApJS..198....4O", "2012MNRAS.424.2180M", "2013A&A...558A..33A", "2013ARA&A..51..511K", "2013ApJ...771....8L", "2013ApJ...779..162C", "2013ApJS..208...19H", "2014ARA&A..52..589H", "2015MNRAS.448.3442G", "2016MNRAS.457.2703R", "2017ApJ...843..135G", "2018A&A...618A.149A", "2018AJ....156..123A", "2018ApJS..234...23A", "2018MNRAS.476.2801M", "2019A&A...621A..83S", "2019MNRAS.487.1808M", "2020MNRAS.494.5713M", "2020Natur.585..357H", "2021MNRAS.507.3985S", "2021MNRAS.507.4389G", "2022A&A...661A.105S", "2022A&A...668L...3L", "2022ApJ...935..167A", "2022MNRAS.509.3966W", "2023ApJ...949...91Z", "2023JOSS....8.5312W", "2023MNRAS.521.1775G", "2023MNRAS.522..211G", "2023gbdd.confE..32M" ]
29184351
2403.04901
PHANGS-HST Catalogs for ∼100,000 Star Clusters and Compact Associations in 38 Galaxies. I. Observed Properties
We present the largest catalog to date of star clusters and compact associations in nearby galaxies. We have performed a V-band-selected census of clusters across the 38 spiral galaxies of the PHANGS–Hubble Space Telescope (HST) Treasury Survey, and measured integrated, aperture-corrected near-ultraviolet-U-B-V-I photometry. This work has resulted in uniform catalogs that contain ∼20,000 clusters and compact associations, which have passed human inspection and morphological classification, and a larger sample of ∼100,000 classified by neural network models. Here, we report on the observed properties of these samples, and demonstrate that tremendous insight can be gained from just the observed properties of clusters, even in the absence of their transformation into physical quantities. In particular, we show the utility of the UBVI color–color diagram, and the three principal features revealed by the PHANGS-HST cluster sample: the young cluster locus, the middle-age plume, and the old globular cluster clump. We present an atlas of maps of the 2D spatial distribution of clusters and compact associations in the context of the molecular clouds from PHANGS–Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array. We explore new ways of understanding this large data set in a multiscale context by bringing together once-separate techniques for the characterization of clusters (color–color diagrams and spatial distributions) and their parent galaxies (galaxy morphology and location relative to the galaxy main sequence). A companion paper presents the physical properties: ages, masses, and dust reddenings derived using improved spectral energy distribution fitting techniques.
[ -0.017166951671242714, 0.010426188819110394, -0.005376560613512993, 0.004615698475390673, -0.007180636283010244, 0.002028470393270254, 0.00007277043914655223, -0.0170480664819479, -0.017166951671242714, -0.008113881573081017, -0.015942439436912537, -0.024323809891939163, -0.023860160261392593, -0.02259998209774494, 0.025441326200962067, 0.04027813673019409, -0.026606397703289986, 0.02164890430867672, 0.007043918594717979, 0.03183732554316521, -0.010723400861024857, -0.017273947596549988, -0.022231439128518105, 0.012328344397246838, -0.09120834618806839, -0.026986828073859215, -0.019294988363981247, 0.01885511353611946, 0.027058158069849014, 0.013362640514969826, -0.02267131395637989, -0.02141113579273224, -0.003489266149699688, -0.004068829119205475, -0.022683201357722282, 0.1074717715382576, -0.014765480533242226, 0.05825350433588028, -0.03140933811664581, 0.0060393428429961205, -0.01140698790550232, 0.03894662857055664, 0.02460913360118866, -0.02696305140852928, 0.008779635652899742, -0.004612726625055075, -0.0062473914586007595, -0.04959869757294655, -0.02896031364798546, 0.03897040709853172, -0.0538785494863987, 0.012161904945969582, -0.030077829957008362, -0.029079198837280273, -0.020436281338334084, 0.024276256561279297, -0.0025604793336242437, 0.005968012381345034, -0.01595432683825493, -0.03069603070616722, -0.01846279390156269, -0.0008619141299277544, 0.021209031343460083, 0.0224454328417778, 0.012684998102486134, 0.010099255479872227, -0.021292250603437424, 0.02040061540901661, 0.023634279146790504, -0.00007388498488580808, -0.013850067742168903, 0.01868867501616478, -0.04253694787621498, -0.03138556331396103, 0.012120295315980911, 0.000199874906684272, -0.041633423417806625, 0.0011398071656003594, -0.031956207007169724, -0.004045051988214254, -0.01582355424761772, 0.007959331385791302, 0.01070556789636612, 0.00783450249582529, -0.016929181292653084, -0.017654377967119217, 0.04020680859684944, 0.02320629358291626, -0.06662298738956451, 0.00332877179607749, 0.02836589142680168, 0.017880259081721306, 0.0018219081684947014, -0.031670887023210526, -0.014991361647844315, -0.038447313010692596, 0.010984946973621845, -0.056351348757743835, 0.055970918387174606, 0.014741703867912292, 0.03091002255678177, 0.028627436608076096, -0.0005390678416006267, -0.07427916675806046, 0.036973144859075546, -0.009914983995258808, -0.007412461563944817, 0.052832361310720444, 0.009296784177422523, 0.04027813673019409, -0.001708967611193657, -0.010337024927139282, -0.02570287324488163, 0.08060383051633835, -0.020364949479699135, 0.03678292781114578, -0.04206140711903572, 0.021779678761959076, 0.012898990884423256, -0.0006642682710662484, 0.007697784807533026, -0.024942010641098022, 0.026202188804745674, 0.008393260650336742, 0.013469637371599674, 0.003944000229239464, 0.019604088738560677, -0.044748201966285706, -0.0283421128988266, 0.02095937356352806, 0.007144970819354057, -0.027628805488348007, 0.026511289179325104, 0.030957577750086784, -0.019604088738560677, -0.03504721075296402, -0.02437136508524418, -0.016952959820628166, -0.013814402744174004, -0.023895826190710068, 0.010616404004395008, -0.013279421254992485, 0.04726855829358101, 0.021327916532754898, 0.014147279784083366, -0.01744038611650467, -0.028793875128030777, 0.044130001217126846, -0.02282586321234703, 0.019508980214595795, -0.014004617929458618, -0.030505815520882607, -0.01939009502530098, -0.03737735003232956, -0.009320560842752457, -0.00782855786383152, -0.015193465165793896, 0.009677215479314327, -0.04912316054105759, -0.03635494410991669, -0.022457320243120193, -0.01884322613477707, -0.026677727699279785, 0.003863752819597721, -0.006223614327609539, 0.01226890180259943, -0.03183732554316521, -0.010592627339065075, -0.09030482172966003, -0.025583988055586815, -0.01939009502530098, -0.027224598452448845, 0.04596082866191864, -0.05240437760949135, -0.004526535049080849, 0.03480944037437439, 0.008755858987569809, -0.005430059041827917, -0.043820902705192566, -0.041942525655031204, -0.01667952351272106, 0.03100513108074665, 0.03868508338928223, -0.04626992717385292, -0.04065857082605362, -0.000784639036282897, 0.004250128287822008, 0.03497587889432907, 0.013540968298912048, -0.004208518657833338, 0.011615036055445671, 0.004630559124052525, -0.004395761992782354, 0.06486349552869797, -0.0013515704777091742, -0.01619209721684456, -0.029697399586439133, 0.03200376406311989, -0.013029763475060463, -0.019663529470562935, -0.010854173451662064, 0.016762742772698402, 0.03706825152039528, -0.04850495979189873, -0.053545672446489334, -0.072947658598423, 0.041490763425827026, 0.008535921573638916, 0.009760434739291668, -0.005537054967135191, 0.020923707634210587, -0.017000513151288033, -0.02789035253226757, 0.0322653092443943, -0.021981781348586082, -0.016227763146162033, -0.03659271076321602, 0.03576051816344261, 0.050597332417964935, 0.022302770987153053, -0.002764069475233555, 0.04555661976337433, 0.05188128724694252, 0.010301359929144382, 0.004978296812623739, -0.00961777288466692, 0.023111186921596527, -0.05454430356621742, 0.033763255923986435, -0.018950222060084343, 0.03233664110302925, 0.036188505589962006, -0.01713128574192524, -0.03343037888407707, -0.004966408479958773, 0.014040283858776093, 0.006024482659995556, 0.05311768501996994, -0.02024606615304947, -0.020519500598311424, -0.02912675216794014, -0.0065505472011864185, 0.004785109311342239, 0.03980259969830513, 0.023860160261392593, 0.025132225826382637, 0.008203044533729553, -0.023194406181573868, 0.05202394723892212, 0.04336914047598839, 0.0352136492729187, 0.005040711723268032, -0.025845535099506378, -0.0467216894030571, -0.02366994507610798, 0.0041550202295184135, -0.01203707605600357, 0.03545141965150833, 0.009837709367275238, 0.02703438140451908, -0.012601778842508793, 0.003834031755104661, -0.05644645914435387, -0.012090574949979782, -0.039136845618486404, 0.04177608713507652, 0.02078104577958584, 0.018106140196323395, -0.04964625462889671, 0.004728639032691717, 0.00116878526750952, 0.006925033871084452, 0.06681320816278458, -0.025916865095496178, -0.022290881723165512, 0.022326547652482986, -0.010134921409189701, 0.019223656505346298, 0.03756756708025932, -0.02289719507098198, 0.009962538257241249, 0.03247930109500885, 0.004886161535978317, 0.0397074930369854, 0.03231286257505417, 0.03892285376787186, 0.014634707011282444, -0.0016777603887021542, -0.025346219539642334, 0.008197100833058357, 0.07518269121646881, 0.004276877269148827, 0.01948520354926586, -0.018902668729424477, -0.04819586127996445, -0.011549648828804493, 0.01720261760056019, 0.01790403574705124, 0.0005687890225090086, 0.009861486032605171, -0.01961597613990307, -0.0023910687305033207, 0.014896254055202007, 0.01814180612564087, -0.003637871937826276, 0.0072876326739788055, 0.011692310683429241, 0.025583988055586815, -0.03511854261159897, 0.05102531611919403, 0.039921484887599945, -0.021197142079472542, 0.01595432683825493, 0.02187478542327881, -0.02016284689307213, -0.0339534729719162, -0.024942010641098022, 0.013873845338821411, -0.00026879090000875294, 0.004259044770151377, -0.037496235221624374, -0.0367591492831707, -0.0002572739322204143, 0.000602968386374414, 0.003798366291448474, -0.03939839079976082, -0.0063722203485667706, -0.02865121327340603, 0.02361050248146057, -0.008981739170849323, 0.029459629207849503, 0.0069547551684081554, 0.04325025528669357, -0.01604943536221981, 0.014325606636703014, -0.055638041347265244, 0.040539685636758804, 0.010646125301718712, -0.02275453321635723, 0.003159360960125923, -0.01222134754061699, -0.029792508110404015, 0.011579370126128197, -0.027367258444428444, 0.04137187823653221, 0.039992816746234894, 0.0058996533043682575, 0.04527129605412483, 0.01698862388730049, -0.008042550645768642, 0.020685939118266106, -0.006592156831175089, 0.023539172485470772, 0.02663017436861992, 0.032431747764348984, -0.01908099465072155, -0.0070260860957205296, -0.039683714509010315, 0.027153266593813896, 0.039445944130420685, 0.017178839072585106, -0.04355935752391815, 0.03752001374959946, 0.010628292337059975, 0.02016284689307213, 0.04874273017048836, -0.0406823456287384, 0.0009540497558191419, -0.03542764112353325, -0.036497604101896286, 0.005694577470421791, -0.01257800217717886, 0.007662119343876839, -0.06681320816278458, -0.03504721075296402, 0.016073212027549744, 0.040848784148693085, -0.0037775614764541388, 0.020697826519608498, -0.005468696355819702, 0.0340961329638958, -0.012625555507838726, 0.02470424212515354, -0.02617841213941574, 0.0411103293299675, -0.0018783783307299018, -0.010895783081650734, -0.002538188360631466, -0.06942866742610931, 0.017571158707141876, -0.01382629107683897, 0.014670372940599918, 0.00016448814130853862, 0.014230499044060707, 0.009635604918003082, -0.0590619221329689, 0.003093974431976676, 0.03566541150212288, 0.0005899653770029545, 0.053783439099788666, -0.003468461334705353, -0.02929319068789482, -0.04137187823653221, -0.026891719549894333, -0.030196715146303177, 0.023170629516243935, -0.02172023616731167, 0.05882415175437927, 0.04075367748737335, -0.05968012288212776, 0.018557902425527573, -0.053307902067899704, 0.03433390334248543, -0.02522733435034752, -0.0046454197727143764, 0.051595963537693024, -0.03528498113155365, 0.06638521701097488, -0.04969380795955658, 0.054877180606126785, 0.02258809469640255, -0.014717926271259785, 0.02867499180138111, -0.009564274922013283, -0.045841943472623825, 0.029863838106393814, 0.035784296691417694, -0.0019690280314534903, -0.012637443840503693, -0.02632107399404049, 0.0008203044417314231, 0.0356416329741478, -0.005557859782129526, 0.019901299849152565, 0.025750426575541496, -0.05392610281705856, 0.05811084434390068, 0.03343037888407707, 0.02556021139025688, -0.011930080130696297, 0.03148066997528076, -0.005364672280848026, -0.01877189427614212, -0.06139206141233444, -0.0008054438512772322, -0.030957577750086784, 0.04867139831185341, 0.06709852814674377, 0.041395653039216995, -0.022778309881687164, -0.006229558493942022, -0.03045826219022274, -0.02065027318894863, 0.013588521629571915, -0.02577420324087143, 0.00892229750752449, -0.004901022184640169, -0.05849127471446991, 0.023872049525380135, -0.0620102621614933, 0.03721091151237488, 0.03169466182589531, -0.04888539016246796, 0.027557475492358208, -0.012209459207952023, 0.006806149613112211, -0.05430653318762779, -0.011638812720775604, 0.04332158714532852, -0.014801145531237125, 0.030244268476963043, -0.06462572515010834, -0.0005268078530207276, 0.019342541694641113, 0.0034030748065561056, -0.002529272111132741, -0.02881765179336071, -0.0034773775842040777, 0.049028053879737854, 0.0053825052455067635, 0.06329421699047089, -0.03435767814517021, -0.03288350999355316, 0.0423705093562603, 0.02236221358180046, 0.011430764570832253, -0.02010340429842472, 0.04346424713730812, 0.01720261760056019, 0.03036315366625786, -0.055638041347265244, 0.0042412118054926395, 0.011965746060013771, -0.010711511597037315, 0.000879746803548187, 0.012459116987884045, -0.03771022707223892, -0.013766848482191563, -0.008333818055689335, 0.011716087348759174, 0.06686075776815414, 0.0022588095162063837, 0.0325506329536438, 0.004654336255043745, 0.04336914047598839, 0.03925573080778122, 0.005109070334583521, -0.03659271076321602, -0.012375897727906704, 0.00939189177006483, -0.007751282770186663, 0.04648391902446747, 0.005584609229117632, 0.012007355690002441, 0.02305174432694912, -0.0028680935502052307, -0.0006490361993201077, -0.00022773852106183767, 0.014896254055202007, -0.006782372482120991, -0.010152753442525864, -0.015193465165793896, -0.00904118176549673, -0.014242387376725674, 0.01745227538049221, -0.008500256575644016, -0.026202188804745674, -0.12392541766166687, -0.02227899432182312, -0.00561135821044445, -0.032289087772369385, -0.030339377000927925, 0.024490248411893845, -0.01526479609310627, -0.04301248490810394, -0.015752224251627922, -0.018284467980265617, -0.016144543886184692, -0.017178839072585106, 0.004039107821881771, -0.030244268476963043, 0.003967776894569397, -0.031433116644620895, 0.013219979591667652, 0.03133800998330116, 0.009796099737286568, 0.02406226471066475, 0.03778155893087387, 0.0322653092443943, 0.039541054517030716, 0.04959869757294655, -0.01916421391069889, 0.02430003322660923, 0.011424819938838482, -0.007572955917567015, -0.010414300486445427, 0.001772868214175105, 0.01117516215890646, 0.011751753278076649, 0.011050333268940449, -0.006996364798396826, 0.011264326050877571, -0.0140997264534235, 0.03193243220448494, 0.05240437760949135, -0.01760682463645935, 0.03319260850548744, -0.019722972065210342, -0.04004037007689476, 0.010693679563701153, -0.007156859152019024, -0.0038013383746147156, -0.006562435533851385, -0.030648477375507355, 0.0011271756375208497, -0.008369483053684235, -0.04565172642469406, -0.0032723015174269676, 0.0018679759232327342, -0.012637443840503693, -0.020127180963754654, -0.019187990576028824, 0.018367687240242958, 0.023265736177563667, 0.0030880302656441927, 0.007941498421132565, -0.02212444320321083, -0.04665035754442215, 0.002529272111132741, -0.03939839079976082, 0.02617841213941574, -0.036878034472465515, 0.010580739006400108, -0.013992729596793652, 0.007977163419127464, -0.024347588419914246, 0.027010604739189148, -0.010230029001832008, -0.03288350999355316, 0.001118259271606803, -0.005444919690489769, -0.0065505472011864185, -0.021541908383369446, -0.05516250431537628, -0.04743499681353569, 0.00502585107460618, -0.03350171074271202, -0.03190865367650986, -0.01588299684226513, 0.01878378354012966, 0.006419774144887924, -0.009510776028037071, -0.0004948576097376645, -0.03989770635962486, 0.01861734502017498, 0.008244654163718224, -0.007263855542987585, -0.03217020258307457, -0.0027284040115773678, -0.009498887695372105, 0.0034357679542154074, -0.01821313612163067, -0.005477612838149071, -0.01562145072966814, 0.0283421128988266, 0.017939701676368713, 0.00037801620783284307, -0.05606602877378464, -0.02836589142680168, -0.03162332996726036, 0.001422158326022327, -0.013838179409503937, 0.0437733493745327, -0.02142302319407463, -0.013505302369594574, 0.006580268498510122, -0.01200141105800867, 0.03730602189898491, -0.008440813980996609, 0.018189359456300735, 0.03278840333223343, 0.0395648293197155, 0.03445278853178024, -0.031433116644620895, 0.037734005600214005, -0.018795672804117203, 0.009796099737286568, -0.0017862427048385143, -0.0425131693482399, -0.009154122322797775, -0.017547382041811943, -0.03178976848721504, 0.012043020687997341, 0.008310040459036827, 0.017178839072585106, -0.01916421391069889, -0.021197142079472542, -0.017024289816617966, -0.022528652101755142, 0.02359861321747303, -0.009338393807411194, 0.013992729596793652, 0.03350171074271202, -0.020448168739676476, -0.022088779136538506, -0.014587153680622578, -0.01885511353611946, 0.04398734122514725, -0.018498459830880165, 0.018938332796096802, 0.05844372138381004, 0.0016079156193882227, 0.045770611613988876, 0.030410706996917725, -0.025108449161052704, 0.023967156186699867, -0.013540968298912048, -0.027153266593813896, -0.02149435505270958, 0.0032633852679282427, -0.001014235196635127, 0.04058723896741867, -0.029697399586439133, -0.00046885156189091504, 0.014765480533242226, 0.014706037938594818, 0.001136834966018796, 0.0185222364962101, 0.018272578716278076, -0.0027997347060590982, 0.015716558322310448, 0.0011509525356814265, 0.01534801535308361, -0.0033406601287424564, 0.0001101541129173711, -0.008072271943092346, -0.01839146390557289, -0.00747784785926342, -0.013208090327680111, -0.036973144859075546, 0.017583047971129417, -0.0074659595265984535, 0.022849639877676964, -0.04565172642469406, -0.02594064362347126, 0.03435767814517021, -0.021613240242004395, -0.017975367605686188, 0.015871107578277588, 0.015086469240486622, 0.029935168102383614, 0.04783920571208, -0.03592695668339729, 0.013231867924332619, 0.006806149613112211, 0.00465136393904686, -0.007394628599286079, 0.010117088444530964, -0.025583988055586815, -0.024799348786473274, -0.026463735848665237, 0.015050803311169147, -0.02741481363773346, -0.007525401655584574, 0.011977634392678738, -0.037591345608234406, 0.006271168123930693, -0.012673109769821167, -0.012910879217088223, 0.0016153459437191486, -0.005590553395450115, 0.0012044506147503853, -0.0005316375172697008, -0.04757766053080559, 0.016929181292653084, 0.02063838578760624, -0.0028770097997039557, -0.0016376368002966046, -0.02984006144106388, 0.02446647174656391, -0.007525401655584574, -0.007745338603854179, -0.015550119802355766, 0.012096518650650978, 0.001839740783907473, -0.0005487272283062339, 0.013921398669481277, -0.009320560842752457, -0.00045696308370679617, 0.002368777757510543, -0.010723400861024857, 0.008678583428263664, -0.009849597699940205, -0.002682336140424013, 0.02734348177909851, -0.05473451688885689, 0.021090146154165268, -0.005010990425944328, 0.007899888791143894, 0.00502585107460618, 0.056208688765764236, 0.02437136508524418, 0.00006650113209616393, 0.026915498077869415, -0.010158698074519634, 0.019758637994527817, -0.025583988055586815, -0.014658484607934952, -0.00020823399245273322, -0.03138556331396103, -0.012791994027793407, 0.027533696964383125, 0.003718119114637375, -0.017273947596549988, -0.013695518486201763, 0.015407457947731018, 0.011288102716207504, -0.05497228726744652, 0.002529272111132741, 0.011930080130696297, -0.006229558493942022, -0.028698768466711044, 0.028318336233496666, 0.0002554163511376828, 0.0076442863792181015, 0.017428498715162277, -0.007364907301962376, -0.03164710849523544, 0.0013909511035308242, -0.01714317500591278, -0.027985459193587303, 0.04874273017048836, -0.00259763072244823, 0.025964420288801193, -0.016227763146162033, 0.008250598795711994, 0.01853412576019764, -0.0991973951458931, 0.014420715160667896, 0.018664898350834846, 0.04092011600732803, -0.019354430958628654, 0.011074109934270382, -0.0008173323585651815, 0.048029422760009766, 0.012863324955105782, 0.008595364168286324, 0.01878378354012966, -0.03635494410991669, -0.012084630317986012, 0.0395648293197155, 0.008315985091030598, -0.0028621493838727474, -0.009059014730155468, -0.006562435533851385, -0.02211255580186844, 0.004193658009171486, -0.004134215414524078, 0.03440523520112038, -0.009326505474746227, 0.006752651184797287, 0.007941498421132565, 0.0038399759214371443, -0.000002255210347357206, 0.0005973956431262195, 0.03457167372107506, -0.023622391745448112, -0.03642627224326134, -0.0020938569214195013, -0.02328951470553875, 0.021458689123392105, -0.004936687182635069, -0.018248802050948143, -0.015276684425771236, 0.060393430292606354, -0.034690555185079575, 0.006054203491657972, -0.008827188983559608, -0.02836589142680168, 0.013077317737042904, 0.009362170472741127, 0.06862024962902069, 0.04244184121489525, 0.007697784807533026, 0.02803301438689232, 0.012197570875287056, 0.04788675904273987, 0.016608193516731262, 0.0010573308682069182, 0.01278010569512844, 0.023860160261392593, 0.02235032431781292, -0.0177494864910841, 0.002594658639281988, -0.005290369503200054, -0.02002018503844738, 0.0141710564494133, -0.0425131693482399, 0.026820389553904533, 0.036568935960531235, -0.003958860877901316, -0.05811084434390068, -0.026439959183335304, -0.062343139201402664, 0.02896031364798546, 0.016845962032675743, 0.0053349509835243225, 0.020139068365097046, 0.012744440697133541, 0.014587153680622578, 0.018367687240242958, 0.049979131668806076, 0.02414548397064209, -0.011888470500707626, 0.011846860870718956, -0.04049213230609894, -0.003203942906111479, 0.010818508453667164, -0.026820389553904533, 0.018736230209469795, -0.022706978023052216, -0.02710571326315403, -0.0009629661217331886, 0.0020626496989279985, -0.005064488388597965, -0.006092841271311045, 0.01673896610736847, -0.00003338988244649954, 0.029007868841290474, 0.012851436622440815, 0.006479216273874044, 0.02867499180138111, 0.015098357573151588, 0.019841857254505157, -0.02577420324087143, 0.0020329284016042948, 0.013588521629571915, -0.0022231440525501966, -0.004428455140441656, -0.0007928123814053833, -0.032835956662893295, -0.007180636283010244, -0.052451930940151215, 0.02594064362347126, -0.001649525249376893, 0.008084160275757313, 0.02929319068789482, 0.009504832327365875, 0.05535271763801575, 0.002888898365199566, -0.03756756708025932, 0.0014615388354286551, 0.01421861071139574, 0.004039107821881771, -0.0054568080231547356, -0.0066872648894786835, -0.01382629107683897, 0.05311768501996994, -0.010503463447093964, -0.0364738292992115, 0.024799348786473274, 0.01401650719344616, 0.005641079042106867, -0.020852377638220787, -0.004600838292390108, -0.03637871891260147, 0.031956207007169724, 0.009249229915440083, 0.010800675489008427, 0.031100239604711533, 0.001356771681457758, 0.015585784800350666, -0.0039380560629069805, 0.0007214815705083311, 0.022231439128518105, 0.012155961245298386, 0.00537061644718051, -0.006681320257484913, -0.004345235880464315, -0.0011197453131899238, 0.01961597613990307, -0.0005747332470491529, 0.017868371680378914, 0.00826248712837696, -0.010372690856456757, 0.010877950116991997, 0.022029336541891098, -0.001107113785110414, 0.03364437073469162, -0.016013769432902336, 0.018320133909583092, -0.029269414022564888, -0.005670800339430571, -0.010699623264372349, -0.03497587889432907, -0.015455011278390884, 0.01005170214921236, 0.0239909328520298, 0.0003631556173786521, 0.0282707829028368, -0.03250307962298393, -0.01666763611137867, 0.0367591492831707, -0.03683048114180565, 0.013897622004151344, 0.015359903685748577, 0.024276256561279297, -0.010711511597037315, -0.0509302094578743, 0.03250307962298393, 0.033216387033462524, -0.034167464822530746, 0.027248375117778778, 0.0312191229313612, 0.019211769104003906, 0.04486708715558052, 0.011811195872724056, -0.019901299849152565, -0.0031504447106271982, 0.013362640514969826, 0.0015068636275827885, 0.030648477375507355, 0.008494311943650246, -0.030077829957008362, -0.0055073341354727745, 0.032360415905714035, 0.002587228314951062, 0.00008507687016390264, 0.021220920607447624, -0.011389154940843582, 0.029958946630358696, 0.013933287933468819, 0.02501334249973297, -0.02772391401231289, -0.021791566163301468, -0.0155738964676857, 0.02867499180138111, -0.010206252336502075, -0.03060092404484749, -0.024395141750574112, -0.020971262827515602, 0.016536861658096313, -0.011068166233599186, 0.006574324332177639, -0.028389668092131615, -0.03354926407337189, -0.010562906041741371, 0.009516720660030842, -0.008773691020905972, 0.021898562088608742, 0.025108449161052704, 0.057682860642671585, -0.03271707147359848, 0.048029422760009766, -0.03238419443368912, -0.027391036972403526, -0.02125658467411995, 0.015871107578277588, -0.020899930968880653, -0.036331165581941605, 0.04527129605412483, 0.00896390713751316, 0.019687307998538017, -0.00930272787809372, -0.03892285376787186, -0.03483321890234947, 0.004657308105379343, 0.03343037888407707, 0.002205311320722103, 0.009849597699940205, 0.005403310060501099, -0.022552428767085075, -0.03262196481227875, -0.014741703867912292, -0.00021399247634690255, -0.00285174697637558, -0.019568422809243202, 0.044272664934396744, 0.006651599425822496, 0.019223656505346298, -0.002637754427269101, -0.011537760496139526, -0.014824923127889633, -0.007620509713888168, -0.006384108681231737, 0.02570287324488163, 0.029697399586439133, -0.0018278523348271847, -0.018474683165550232, -0.004464120604097843, -0.0059828730300068855, -0.011620979756116867, 0.020995039492845535, -0.003908334765583277, 0.036568935960531235, 0.029412075877189636, -0.009035238064825535, 0.007144970819354057, -0.011068166233599186, -0.0069547551684081554, -0.02055516466498375, 0.023408398032188416, -0.004250128287822008, -0.0436306856572628, -0.010414300486445427, -0.018272578716278076, -0.02857988327741623, -0.013968952931463718, -0.0366164892911911, -0.01105627790093422, -0.03518987447023392, -0.04004037007689476, 0.00040049286326393485, -0.016715189442038536, 0.02789035253226757, 0.013612299226224422, 0.029958946630358696, -0.02648751251399517, 0.011383210308849812, -0.005798601545393467, 0.017000513151288033, 0.007394628599286079, 0.028912760317325592, -0.021518131718039513, -0.013101094402372837, 0.025346219539642334, -0.018676787614822388, -0.015062692575156689, 0.006395997013896704, 0.022849639877676964, -0.02444269508123398, -0.00708552822470665, -0.01931876502931118, 0.006312777753919363, 0.0001542714744573459, 0.008975795470178127, -0.011311879381537437, -0.01924743317067623, 0.007495680823922157, 0.021993670612573624, -0.008779635652899742, -0.005337923299521208, -0.023967156186699867, -0.003203942906111479, -0.051928840577602386, -0.009207620285451412, -0.010687734931707382, 0.026439959183335304, 0.0022989329881966114, -0.020436281338334084, -0.010039813816547394, -0.04626992717385292, 0.02351539395749569, -0.01830824464559555, -0.004817802459001541, -0.012423451989889145, -0.01714317500591278, -0.035094764083623886, 0.008862854912877083, 0.014159168116748333, 0.02383638359606266, -0.02734348177909851, -0.01374307181686163, 0.019199879840016365, 0.005186345428228378, 0.008904464542865753, 0.015443122945725918, -0.00848836824297905, 0.04581816494464874, 0.018355797976255417, -0.017892148345708847, -0.01878378354012966, 0.01039052288979292, -0.03331149369478226, -0.008375427685678005, 0.028318336233496666, 0.0018858086550608277, 0.023788830265402794, -0.012589890509843826, -0.04472442716360092, 0.004898049868643284, -0.004785109311342239, -0.009879318997263908, 0.030434483662247658, -0.003438740037381649, -0.026820389553904533, -0.006407885812222958, 0.058538828045129776, -0.00899362750351429, 0.005813462194055319, -0.015562008135020733, 0.01798725500702858, -0.0069012572057545185, 0.048314742743968964, 0.012554224580526352, 0.013291310518980026, -0.027367258444428444, 0.012375897727906704, -0.02397904545068741, -0.014896254055202007, 0.02009151503443718, 0.04736366495490074, -0.01278010569512844, -0.009891207329928875, -0.016156431287527084, -0.010610460303723812, -0.026915498077869415, -0.020769158378243446, -0.0031771936919540167, -0.012447228655219078, 0.02430003322660923, 0.007073639892041683, 0.007567011285573244, 0.013148648664355278, -0.01744038611650467, -0.01492003072053194, 0.014432603493332863, 0.012482893653213978, 0.010325136594474316, -0.013338863849639893, 0.01305354107171297, -0.026606397703289986, -0.02601197361946106, 0.01331508718430996, 0.014004617929458618, 0.02078104577958584, -0.00817926786839962, 0.032907284796237946, 0.019330652430653572, 0.016085101291537285, 0.000095757917733863, 0.005343867465853691, 0.009154122322797775, 0.02446647174656391, 0.04745877534151077, 0.008345706388354301, -0.017345277592539787, -0.031956207007169724, -0.009962538257241249, 0.001062532071955502, -0.002618435537442565, -0.013219979591667652, 0.014884364791214466, 0.02298041433095932, -0.00047776789870113134, 0.031742215156555176, -0.004184741526842117, 0.008898519910871983, -0.029150530695915222, -0.007388684432953596, 0.001188847003504634, 0.02117336541414261, -0.005094209685921669, 0.00332877179607749, 0.00896390713751316, 0.012482893653213978, 0.006497049238532782, -0.01861734502017498, 0.005742131266742945, -0.03880396857857704, -0.0035279036965221167, 0.007923665456473827, -0.012161904945969582, -0.016013769432902336, 0.028484774753451347, -0.010901727713644505, 0.0063306107185781, -0.02734348177909851, -0.0010090339928865433, -0.017178839072585106, 0.04306004196405411, -0.04370201751589775, 0.006401941180229187, 0.01348152570426464, -0.012019244022667408, -0.021446801722049713, 0.038661304861307144, -0.008422981016337872, -0.023860160261392593, -0.0025025231298059225, 0.017238281667232513, -0.010176531039178371, 0.015050803311169147, -0.028770098462700844, -0.003518987214192748, 0.03397724777460098, 0.0156095614656806, -0.00790583249181509, 0.034381456673145294, 0.020353062078356743, 0.00131962017621845, 0.013386418111622334, -0.0031207234133034945, -0.006000705529004335, 0.009076847694814205, -0.015169688500463963, -0.02960229106247425, 0.034167464822530746, 0.04308381676673889, 0.024193037301301956, 0.005358728114515543, -0.007561067119240761, 0.04182364046573639, 0.026463735848665237, 0.013101094402372837, -0.04519996419548988, -0.0282707829028368, 0.03202753886580467, 0.0003130011318717152, 0.016144543886184692, -0.029174307361245155, 0.013778737746179104, -0.03792422264814377, 0.011829027906060219, -0.014254276640713215, 0.01035485789179802, 0.01074123289436102, -0.027557475492358208, 0.004256072454154491, 0.039541054517030716, 0.02929319068789482, 0.03599828854203224, 0.003079113783314824, -0.01931876502931118, -0.006823982112109661, 0.05016934499144554, 0.020828600972890854, 0.007983108051121235, 0.009278951212763786, -0.015443122945725918, -0.0075551229529082775, 0.004374957177788019, 0.019045330584049225, -0.01759493723511696, -0.00930272787809372, 0.0026481568347662687, -0.008387316018342972, -0.025845535099506378, 0.007121193688362837, 0.008845021948218346, 0.020899930968880653, -0.008387316018342972, 0.004785109311342239, -0.011680422350764275, 0.041395653039216995, 0.01448015682399273, -0.0004941145307384431, 0.011472374200820923, 0.018902668729424477, 0.006681320257484913, -0.018985887989401817, 0.032360415905714035, -0.006782372482120991, -0.04313137009739876, -0.02953096106648445, 0.006895313039422035, 0.032740846276283264, 0.012482893653213978, -0.036973144859075546, 0.015205353498458862, -0.0016510112909600139, -0.0044670929200947285, -0.014931919053196907, 0.017666267231106758, 0.02468046545982361, -0.02031739614903927, 0.010265693999826908, -0.028223229572176933, -0.048172082751989365, 0.03863753005862236, -0.005123930983245373, -0.023265736177563667, -0.021672680974006653, -0.016013769432902336, -0.005076376721262932, 0.023408398032188416, -0.004538423847407103, 0.02306363359093666, 0.0012111379764974117, 0.013219979591667652, 0.011103831231594086, 0.03300239518284798, 0.04527129605412483, 0.006146339233964682, -0.01814180612564087, 0.016548750922083855, -0.008553754538297653, -0.02936452254652977, -0.015859220176935196, 0.009861486032605171, -0.018724340945482254, 0.025369996204972267, -0.02376505173742771, 0.016929181292653084, 0.0050347670912742615, -0.0013798056170344353, 0.009950649924576283, 0.032193977385759354, -0.027462366968393326, -0.016952959820628166, 0.01036080252379179, -0.03832842782139778, 0.01698862388730049, -0.015906773507595062, 0.020769158378243446, -0.020364949479699135, 0.029626067727804184, 0.05996544659137726, 0.0018219081684947014, 0.006705097388476133, -0.0008210475207306445, -0.0015722502721473575, 0.017868371680378914, 0.027010604739189148, -0.009944705292582512, 0.018284467980265617, 0.016263427212834358, -0.041229214519262314, -0.05578070506453514, 0.030006499961018562, -0.007412461563944817, -0.021934228017926216, 0.043274033814668655, 0.005754019599407911, 0.023693721741437912, -0.020281730219721794, 0.005272536538541317, -0.011799306608736515, -0.020210400223731995, 0.021399246528744698, -0.015597673133015633, -0.0018858086550608277, 0.015407457947731018, -0.00747784785926342, 0.032217755913734436, -0.04874273017048836, -0.026582621037960052, -0.01031919289380312, 0.06714608520269394, -0.029744952917099, -0.015704669058322906, 0.02236221358180046, 0.019413871690630913, 0.025750426575541496, -0.03233664110302925, -0.004737555515021086, 0.00023479729134123772, -0.01961597613990307, 0.01805858686566353, 0.005858043674379587, 0.004547339864075184, 0.029578514397144318, 0.008660750463604927, -0.026511289179325104, 0.026582621037960052, -0.014289941638708115, -0.023004190996289253, -0.02049572393298149, -0.02406226471066475, -0.015050803311169147, -0.0021711320150643587, -0.002096829004585743, 0.0109076714143157, -0.002853232901543379, 0.00517742894589901, 0.020198510959744453, -0.0021428968757390976, 0.028912760317325592, -0.028936536982655525, 0.031100239604711533, -0.024347588419914246, -0.0017461191164329648, 0.026606397703289986, 0.010420244187116623, 0.012025187723338604, -0.0074184057302773, 0.049884021282196045, 0.009368115104734898, -0.008821245282888412, -0.008940129540860653, 0.007275743875652552, 0.016881627961993217, -0.008417037315666676, 0.0016762743471190333, -0.011787418276071548, 0.011858749203383923, 0.0184509065002203, 0.021934228017926216, -0.01839146390557289, -0.019806191325187683, 0.0028770097997039557, -0.0060750083066523075, 0.008107936941087246, -0.008767747320234776, -0.006996364798396826, -0.01149020716547966, -0.009486999362707138, 0.027628805488348007, 0.020911820232868195, 0.00016077299369499087, 0.029412075877189636, 0.023087410256266594, 0.02312307432293892, -0.014492045156657696, 0.07375606894493103, 0.009980371221899986, 0.005828322842717171, 0.023931492120027542, 0.009944705292582512, 0.02103070355951786, 0.038756415247917175, 0.03678292781114578, 0.008696416392922401, 0.006205781828612089, 0.02274264395236969, 0.017785152420401573, 0.01650119759142399, 0.014004617929458618, -0.027391036972403526, 0.018557902425527573, 0.043036263436079025, -0.017178839072585106, -0.0032871621660888195, 0.015383681282401085, 0.03849486634135246, -0.005019906908273697, -0.010539129376411438, 0.0534505620598793, -0.03483321890234947, -0.004755388014018536, -0.019675418734550476, -0.014575265347957611, 0.01784459501504898, 0.0026050610467791557, -0.01675085537135601, -0.015086469240486622, -0.016703302040696144, 0.010241917334496975, -0.017428498715162277, -0.02446647174656391, 0.00015872965741436929, 0.032978616654872894, -0.006669431924819946, 0.02624974213540554, 0.002902272855862975, 0.006841814611107111, -0.02275453321635723, -0.014194834046065807, 0.008066327311098576, -0.0203411728143692, 0.009451334364712238, -0.013861957006156445, 0.020424392074346542, -0.0070795840583741665, 0.029079198837280273, -0.017583047971129417, -0.020852377638220787, 0.011900358833372593, -0.012280790135264397, 0.001992804929614067, 0.025298666208982468, -0.01854601316154003, -0.047862984240055084, 0.01312487106770277, 0.02087615430355072, 0.005016934592276812, -0.028175674378871918, 0.026416180655360222, 0.006627822294831276, 0.01868867501616478, 0.002859177067875862, 0.011757696978747845, 0.04058723896741867, -0.02610708214342594, 0.03899418190121651, -0.013754960149526596 ]
10.18503
8.311474
2024-07-01
2
2024ApJS..273...14M
[ "star clusters", "clusters", "compact associations", "color diagrams", "improved spectral energy distribution fitting techniques", "spatial distributions", "galaxy morphology", "nearby galaxies", "color", "the old globular cluster clump" ]
[ "Star formation", "Star clusters", "Galaxy evolution", "1569", "1567", "594", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
82
[ "10.3847/1538-4365/ad3cd3", "10.48550/arXiv.2403.04901" ]
[ "Maschmann, Daniel", "Lee, Janice C.", "Thilker, David A.", "Whitmore, Bradley C.", "Deger, Sinan", "Boquien, Médéric", "Chandar, Rupali", "Dale, Daniel A.", "Wofford, Aida", "Hannon, Stephen", "Larson, Kirsten L.", "Leroy, Adam K.", "Schinnerer, Eva", "Rosolowsky, Erik", "Úbeda, Leonardo", "Barnes, Ashley T.", "Emsellem, Eric", "Grasha, Kathryn", "Groves, Brent", "Indebetouw, Rémy", "Kim, Hwihyun", "Klessen, Ralf S.", "Kreckel, Kathryn", "Levy, Rebecca C.", "Pinna, Francesca", "Rodríguez, M. Jimena", "Tian, Qiushi", "Williams, Thomas G." ]
[ "Steward Observatory, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721, USA", "Steward Observatory, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721, USA; Space Telescope Science Institute, 3700 San Martin Drive, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA; Gemini Observatory/NSF's NOIRLab, 950 N. Cherry Avenue, Tucson, AZ 85719, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, The Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA", "Space Telescope Science Institute, 3700 San Martin Drive, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA", "Institute of Astronomy, University of Cambridge, Madingley Road, Cambridge CB3 0HA, UK; Kavli Institute for Cosmology Cambridge, Madingley Road, Cambridge CB3 0HA, UK", "Université Côte d'Azur, Observatoire de la Côte d'Azur, CNRS, Laboratoire Lagrange, 06000, Nice, France", "University of Toledo, 2801 W. Bancroft Street, Mail Stop 111, Toledo, OH 43606, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Wyoming, Laramie, WY 82071, USA", "Instituto de Astronomía, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Unidad Académica en Ensenada, Km 103 Carr. Tijuana-Ensenada, Ensenada, B.C., C.P. 22860, Mexico; Department of Astronomy and Astrophysics, University of California, San Diego, 9500 Gilman Drive, La Jolla, CA 92093, USA", "Max-Planck-Institut für Astronomie, Königstuhl 17, D-69117, Heidelberg, Germany", "AURA for the European Space Agency (ESA), Space Telescope Science Institute, 3700 San Martin Drive, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA", "Department of Astronomy, The Ohio State University, 140 W. 18th Avenue, Columbus, OH 43210, USA", "Max-Planck-Institut für Astronomie, Königstuhl 17, D-69117, Heidelberg, Germany", "Department of Physics, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB T6G 2E1, Canada", "Space Telescope Science Institute, 3700 San Martin Drive, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA", "European Southern Observatory, Karl-Schwarzschild Straße 2, D-85748 Garching bei München, Germany", "European Southern Observatory, Karl-Schwarzschild Straße 2, D-85748 Garching bei München, Germany; Univ Lyon, Univ Lyon 1, ENS de Lyon, CNRS, Centre de Recherche Astrophysique de Lyon UMR5574, F-69230 Saint-Genis-Laval, France", "Research School of Astronomy and Astrophysics, Australian National University, Canberra, ACT 2611, Australia; ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D), Australia", "International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research, University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Highway, Crawley, WA 6009, Australia", "University of Virginia Astronomy Department, 530 McCormick Road, Charlottesville, VA 22904, USA; National Radio Astronomy Observatory, 520 Edgemont Road, Charlottesville, VA 22903-2475, USA", "Gemini Observatory/NSF's NOIRLab, 950 N. Cherry Avenue, Tucson, AZ 85719, USA", "Universität Heidelberg, Zentrum für Astronomie, Institut für Theoretische Astrophysik, Albert-Ueberle-Str 2, D-69120 Heidelberg, Germany; Universität Heidelberg, Interdisziplinäres Zentrum für Wissenschaftliches Rechnen, Im Neuenheimer Feld 205, D-69120 Heidelberg, Germany", "Astronomisches Rechen-Institut, Zentrum für Astronomie der Universität Heidelberg, Mönchhofstraße 12-14, D-69120 Heidelberg, Germany", "Steward Observatory, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721, USA", "Max-Planck-Institut für Astronomie, Königstuhl 17, D-69117, Heidelberg, Germany; Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias, C/ Vía Láctea s/n, E-38205, La Laguna, Spain; Departamento de Astrofísica, Universidad de La Laguna, Av. del Astrofísico Francisco Sánchez s/n, E-38206, La Laguna, Spain", "Steward Observatory, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721, USA; Instituto de Astrofísica de La Plata, CONICET–UNLP, Paseo del Bosque S/N, B1900FWA La Plata, Argentina", "Astronomy Department and Van Vleck Observatory, Wesleyan University, 96 Foss Hill Drive, Middletown, CT 06459, USA", "Sub-department of Astrophysics, Department of Physics, University of Oxford, Keble Road, Oxford OX1 3RH, UK" ]
[ "2024ApJ...966..130R", "2024ApJ...967..133S" ]
[ "1968AJ.....73..569V", "1980ApJ...239..803S", "1983AJ.....88..483K", "1986ApJ...301L..13K", "1987ApJ...314....3E", "1987PASP...99..191S", "1989ApJ...345..245C", "1991ApJ...375..569A", "1992MNRAS.259..345A", "1993A&A...272...37E", "1993RPPh...56..173S", "1994ApJ...420...87Z", "1995A&A...298...87G", "1996ApJ...462..147S", "1996MNRAS.281..687B", "1998MNRAS.300..872M", "1999A&A...345...59L", "2001AJ....121.1336H", "2002AJ....124..777E", "2003ARA&A..41...57L", "2003MNRAS.344.1000B", "2004A&A...419...35V", "2005ApJ...621..695V", "2005MNRAS.360.1413B", "2006ARA&A..44..193B", "2007ApJ...660L..43N", "2007ApJ...667L.145S", "2007ApJ...671L.113L", "2007ApJS..173..267S", "2007PASJ...59..117K", "2008AJ....136.1623C", "2008ApJ...679..404M", "2009A&A...507.1793N", "2009ApJ...706..599L", "2010A&A...521A..22F", "2010AJ....140...75W", "2010ARA&A..48..431P", "2010ApJ...719..966C", "2010ApJ...721..193P", "2010ApJS..190..233M", "2010MNRAS.409..396D", "2011A&A...529A..25S", "2011A&A...529A..41N", "2011MNRAS.410L...6G", "2012ARA&A..50..531K", "2012ApJ...750...60F", "2012ApJ...751..122P", "2012ApJ...752...96F", "2012MNRAS.419.2606B", "2013A&A...550A..20D", "2014ApJ...787...17C", "2014MNRAS.439.3775G", "2014arXiv1409.1556S", "2015AJ....149...51C", "2015ApJ...806...35J", "2015ApJ...812..147K", "2015ApJ...815...93G", "2015ApJS..217...32B", "2015MNRAS.449.1106H", "2015arXiv151203385H", "2016A&A...587A..68B", "2016ApJS..227....2S", "2016MNRAS.457.4296W", "2016ascl.soft08013D", "2017A&A...597A..85B", "2017ApJ...840..113G", "2017ApJ...841...92R", "2017ApJ...841..131A", "2018MNRAS.473..996M", "2018MNRAS.475.5659W", "2018MNRAS.476..875C", "2018NewAR..81....1R", "2019A&A...622A.103B", "2019ARA&A..57..227K", "2019ApJS..244...24L", "2019MNRAS.483.4707G", "2019MNRAS.484.4897C", "2019MNRAS.488.5409C", "2019Msngr.177...36S", "2020ApJ...897..122L", "2020ApJ...903...50E", "2020MNRAS.491.4573R", "2020MNRAS.493.3178W", "2020MNRAS.495..663W", "2020MNRAS.497.5024S", "2020MNRAS.499.4455T", "2020NewAR..9001549W", "2020SSRv..216...69A", "2021A&A...656A.133Q", "2021ApJ...907..100P", "2021ApJ...912....4L", "2021ApJ...918...76C", "2021ApJ...923..278L", "2021ApJS..257...43L", "2021MNRAS.501.3621A", "2021MNRAS.502.1366T", "2021MNRAS.506.5294W", "2021MNRAS.508.5935B", "2022A&A...659A.191E", "2022A&A...662L...6B", "2022ARA&A..60...73S", "2022ApJ...935...19L", "2022ApJ...935..166L", "2022ApJS..258...10L", "2022MNRAS.509..522O", "2022MNRAS.509.4094T", "2022MNRAS.510...32D", "2022MNRAS.516.4612T", "2023A&A...676A..67W", "2023A&A...678A.153E", "2023ApJ...944L..13T", "2023ApJ...944L..14W", "2023ApJ...944L..15S", "2023ApJ...944L..17L", "2023ApJ...944L..22B", "2023ApJ...944L..24W", "2023ApJ...944L..26R", "2023ApJ...944L..55L", "2023MNRAS.519.3749C", "2023MNRAS.520...63W", "2023MNRAS.520.4902G", "2023MNRAS.522.2369S", "2023MNRAS.523.2918S", "2023MNRAS.523.6061L", "2023MNRAS.525.5262C", "2023MNRAS.526.2991H", "2023arXiv230105912T", "2024AJ....167...95F", "2024ApJ...967..133S", "2024ApJS..271....2H", "2024ApJS..273...13W" ]
29184546
2407.02173
A study of two FRBs with low polarization fractions localized with the MeerTRAP transient buffer system
Localisation of fast radio bursts (FRBs) to arcsecond and sub-arcsecond precision maximizes their potential as cosmological probes. To that end, FRB detection instruments are deploying triggered complex-voltage capture systems to localize FRBs, identify their host galaxy and measure a redshift. Here, we report the discovery and localisation of two FRBs (20220717A and 20220905A) that were captured by the transient buffer system deployed by the MeerTRAP instrument at the MeerKAT telescope in South Africa. We were able to localize the FRBs to precision of ~1 arc-second that allowed us to unambiguously identify the host galaxy for FRB 20220717A (posterior probability~0.97). FRB 20220905A lies in a crowded region of the sky with a tentative identification of a host galaxy but the faintness and the difficulty in obtaining an optical spectrum preclude a conclusive association. The bursts show low linear polarization fractions (10-17%) that conform to the large diversity in the polarization fraction observed in apparently non-repeating FRBs akin to single pulses from neutron stars. We also show that the host galaxy of FRB 20220717A contributes roughly 15% of the total dispersion measure (DM), indicating that it is located in a plasma-rich part of the host galaxy which can explain the large rotation measure. The scattering in FRB 20220717A can be mostly attributed to the host galaxy and the intervening medium and is consistent with what is seen in the wider FRB population.
[ -0.06234431266784668, 0.01778077520430088, 0.003936817403882742, -0.005403049755841494, -0.04369557648897171, 0.033924829214811325, -0.006116016767919064, -0.006001322064548731, -0.015846464782953262, 0.05207758769392967, 0.006559296045452356, 0.02502204105257988, -0.011140883900225163, -0.018735531717538834, 0.02898985706269741, -0.024538462981581688, -0.017855172976851463, 0.01909511536359787, -0.0601620115339756, 0.0319657176733017, 0.011047887615859509, -0.03156893700361252, -0.01129587646573782, -0.0042716022580862045, -0.018599137663841248, -0.054805461317300797, 0.005018667317926884, 0.0011174982646480203, -0.03283367678523064, 0.002182298805564642, 0.01095489226281643, -0.045332297682762146, -0.05071365088224411, -0.028419483453035355, -0.058376494795084, 0.05877327546477318, -0.013316982425749302, -0.048159368336200714, -0.01624324731528759, 0.025195632129907608, 0.012591616250574589, -0.0006703439285047352, -0.024439267814159393, -0.015288491733372211, -0.012058441527187824, 0.013862557709217072, -0.0403229296207428, 0.000907482928596437, -0.02812189608812332, -0.005065165460109711, -0.03132094815373421, -0.001109748613089323, -0.044885918498039246, 0.04451393708586693, -0.031940918415784836, 0.009349166415631771, 0.011593462899327278, 0.03997574746608734, 0.00878499262034893, 0.006652291864156723, -0.026931552216410637, -0.0022179472725838423, 0.030601782724261284, 0.0037105281371623278, -0.0044420943595469, 0.03137054666876793, -0.018723132088780403, 0.015201695263385773, 0.03536316007375717, 0.03248649463057518, 0.008983383886516094, 0.010458915494382381, 0.03603272885084152, -0.022752946242690086, 0.04528270289301872, 0.00004075826655025594, 0.03950456902384758, 0.03990134969353676, -0.021636996418237686, -0.05287114903330803, -0.009795546531677246, -0.044191550463438034, -0.03243689611554146, -0.03662790358066559, -0.016292845830321312, -0.03561114892363548, 0.00845640804618597, -0.030229799449443817, -0.027973104268312454, 0.007817837409675121, 0.010074533522129059, -0.005809130612760782, -0.0054340483620762825, 0.05237517133355141, -0.034148018807172775, -0.0579301156103611, 0.03228810429573059, -0.05138321965932846, 0.07667804509401321, -0.003189752111211419, 0.0282954890280962, 0.005722334608435631, 0.014432931318879128, -0.05554942414164543, 0.06784965842962265, -0.026509972289204597, 0.0013887356035411358, 0.008183620870113373, 0.03139534592628479, 0.006726688239723444, 0.048208966851234436, -0.0004219679394736886, -0.03620632365345955, 0.02832028828561306, -0.0018320151139050722, -0.005083764437586069, -0.03856221213936806, -0.02898985706269741, 0.0208310354501009, 0.030899368226528168, -0.014222141355276108, 0.034569598734378815, 0.013850158080458641, 0.029981810599565506, 0.008896587416529655, -0.008815991692245007, -0.012579216621816158, 0.0026224784087389708, -0.03935577720403671, -0.008313815109431744, 0.03883500024676323, -0.032139312475919724, -0.007036673836410046, 0.03206491470336914, -0.020905431360006332, -0.019429899752140045, 0.009516558609902859, -0.042480431497097015, -0.029808219522237778, 0.008041027002036572, -0.007824037224054337, 0.017879972234368324, 0.04372037574648857, 0.02349691092967987, 0.013527773320674896, 0.0014042349066585302, -0.0588228739798069, 0.036975085735321045, 0.0421084500849247, -0.0057409340515732765, -0.029188247397542, -0.03836382180452347, -0.014259339310228825, -0.04996968433260918, -0.0017452191095799208, -0.023992888629436493, 0.05311913788318634, -0.002628678223118186, 0.004891573451459408, -0.017024410888552666, -0.030849769711494446, 0.0011329974513500929, -0.02680755779147148, 0.021029425784945488, 0.021674195304512978, -0.006918879225850105, -0.01603245735168457, -0.018276752904057503, -0.06968477368354797, -0.017693979665637016, 0.009001982398331165, -0.020322658121585846, -0.03382563218474388, 0.017272399738430977, -0.018735531717538834, 0.015747269615530968, 0.006472500041127205, -0.02214537374675274, 0.012108039110898972, -0.0042034052312374115, -0.042282041162252426, -0.02658436819911003, 0.04629945382475853, 0.01458172407001257, 0.016119252890348434, -0.024501264095306396, 0.02680755779147148, 0.012015042826533318, 0.030998563393950462, -0.017817974090576172, 0.013316982425749302, 0.04215804487466812, 0.016826020553708076, 0.014036149717867374, -0.00263022817671299, -0.021401409059762955, -0.004950470756739378, -0.01339137926697731, -0.023782098665833473, -0.08104264736175537, -0.013912155292928219, -0.02308773063123226, 0.03174252808094025, -0.014941307716071606, -0.0391077883541584, -0.03320566192269325, 0.054805461317300797, 0.007197866216301918, -0.0017049210146069527, -0.013068994507193565, 0.058922071009874344, -0.0022876940201967955, 0.01647883653640747, 0.014110546559095383, -0.027551522478461266, -0.014544526115059853, -0.03915738686919212, 0.041835661977529526, 0.018586738035082817, -0.03397442400455475, -0.01129587646573782, 0.01646643690764904, 0.007259863428771496, 0.008487407118082047, -0.017842773348093033, 0.033453650772571564, 0.026410775259137154, 0.0070242746733129025, 0.07727321982383728, -0.01296979933977127, -0.004063911736011505, 0.03444560244679451, 0.030576983466744423, -0.0333048552274704, 0.04285241290926933, -0.008915186859667301, -0.0008757094037719071, -0.0032269505318254232, -0.012380826286971569, -0.055003851652145386, -0.029064252972602844, 0.021760990843176842, 0.021760990843176842, -0.021872585639357567, 0.007061472628265619, -0.013465776108205318, -0.009249971248209476, -0.015548879280686378, 0.0610547699034214, -0.0007180042448453605, 0.054111093282699585, 0.0235093105584383, -0.02720433846116066, -0.0368758924305439, 0.0019451598636806011, 0.02060784585773945, -0.02943623624742031, 0.012108039110898972, -0.046671438962221146, -0.012058441527187824, -0.02305053174495697, -0.029709022492170334, -0.03583433851599693, 0.009851343929767609, -0.048208966851234436, 0.018251953646540642, 0.016181251034140587, -0.0068506826646625996, -0.02280254289507866, 0.018599137663841248, -0.005592140834778547, -0.026212384924292564, 0.017830373719334602, -0.0570373572409153, -0.036999884992837906, 0.04168686643242836, 0.03843821957707405, -0.009039181284606457, 0.023211725056171417, -0.031916119158267975, 0.0032641487196087837, 0.019367901608347893, 0.02104182541370392, -0.047117818146944046, -0.018723132088780403, -0.013056594878435135, 0.008388211019337177, 0.0064972988329827785, 0.01642923802137375, 0.015152097679674625, 0.028469080105423927, -0.023137327283620834, -0.00997533742338419, -0.03206491470336914, -0.04260442405939102, -0.030328994616866112, 0.07925713062286377, 0.007662844844162464, -0.03846301883459091, -0.05316873639822006, 0.03814063221216202, 0.006825883872807026, 0.023199325427412987, 0.017656782642006874, -0.029461035504937172, 0.01621844805777073, 0.027080345898866653, 0.029312241822481155, 0.017433591187000275, 0.06536976993083954, -0.015734869986772537, 0.01624324731528759, -0.017433591187000275, -0.026013994589447975, -0.03305686637759209, -0.030800173059105873, 0.0030518085695803165, 0.027353132143616676, 0.053218334913253784, -0.05852528661489487, -0.003487338311970234, -0.054557472467422485, 0.022938936948776245, 0.009032981470227242, 0.010682105086743832, -0.026708362624049187, 0.014594123698771, -0.02767551690340042, 0.023608505725860596, 0.010787500068545341, 0.03427201136946678, 0.008983383886516094, 0.021327011287212372, -0.028221093118190765, -0.014556925743818283, -0.021649396046996117, 0.010985891334712505, -0.00006088311783969402, -0.017644383013248444, -0.008946185000240803, 0.008605200797319412, 0.007594648282974958, 0.017396394163370132, 0.037421464920043945, -0.021165819838643074, 0.05262316018342972, 0.05510304495692253, -0.012337428517639637, 0.014470129273831844, -0.017669180408120155, -0.0012531168758869171, -0.011736055836081505, 0.005136461928486824, -0.011016889475286007, 0.009950539097189903, -0.036355115473270416, 0.05887247249484062, 0.0212774146348238, -0.0333048552274704, -0.0033478448167443275, 0.00910737831145525, 0.031023362651467323, 0.010911494493484497, 0.013899755664169788, -0.027303535491228104, -0.0110850865021348, -0.036107126623392105, 0.0034563399385660887, -0.0020195564720779657, -0.05287114903330803, -0.0071358694694936275, -0.0191075149923563, -0.001721970154903829, 0.0006955302669666708, -0.003025459824129939, -0.008394410833716393, 0.054954253137111664, 0.018710732460021973, 0.028816264122724533, 0.019033117219805717, 0.02262895181775093, -0.028890661895275116, -0.011853850446641445, -0.0683952271938324, -0.01626804657280445, 0.02960982732474804, 0.008617600426077843, -0.04342278838157654, -0.0719662681221962, 0.016292845830321312, -0.061749137938022614, 0.024860847741365433, 0.05021767318248749, -0.022740546613931656, -0.024960042908787727, 0.006292708218097687, 0.055847011506557465, 0.038512613624334335, 0.017669180408120155, 0.03506557643413544, -0.0038562212139368057, -0.010682105086743832, -0.021413806825876236, 0.003065757919102907, 0.0029107651207596064, 0.03620632365345955, -0.02983301691710949, 0.029039453715085983, 0.03980215638875961, -0.01087429653853178, 0.018983520567417145, -0.06522097438573837, 0.02653476968407631, -0.0021141020115464926, 0.030403390526771545, 0.0701807513833046, -0.06675850600004196, 0.005536343436688185, -0.04605146497488022, 0.022492557764053345, 0.0579301156103611, -0.0027356231585144997, 0.00548364594578743, 0.04369557648897171, -0.02437726967036724, 0.012436623685061932, 0.027303535491228104, -0.023769699037075043, 0.03352804481983185, -0.010713103227317333, -0.006441501434892416, -0.02499724179506302, 0.02060784585773945, -0.03556155040860176, 0.01558607816696167, 0.03119695372879505, 0.010310121811926365, -0.011903448030352592, -0.04853134974837303, 0.03685109317302704, -0.0029603627044707537, 0.0077124424278736115, 0.02192218415439129, -0.024315273389220238, 0.03263528645038605, 0.04691942408680916, 0.024972442537546158, 0.055896610021591187, 0.06403063237667084, 0.03114735707640648, -0.009020581841468811, -0.03734707087278366, -0.0004208055033814162, -0.018251953646540642, -0.04171166568994522, -0.012436623685061932, 0.005353451706469059, -0.019801883026957512, 0.046894628554582596, -0.014346134848892689, 0.039826955646276474, 0.01975228451192379, -0.05232557654380798, 0.0006393453804776073, 0.00399881461635232, 0.01580926775932312, 0.008121623657643795, 0.008921386674046516, -0.0014491828624159098, 0.042703621089458466, 0.014668520539999008, -0.03707428276538849, 0.008741594851016998, 0.0300810057669878, -0.014842112548649311, -0.004640485160052776, -0.019181910902261734, -0.01598285883665085, 0.048407357186079025, 0.018549541011452675, -0.000560686516109854, 0.0032052514143288136, 0.013986552134156227, -0.000046473625843646005, -0.02722913771867752, 0.023831695318222046, 0.031097758561372757, 0.10142730176448822, -0.031916119158267975, -0.016404440626502037, -0.03645431250333786, -0.000042889420001301914, 0.03734707087278366, -0.012132837437093258, 0.016106853261590004, -0.04104209691286087, -0.0038562212139368057, 0.00856180302798748, 0.048605747520923615, 0.012709410861134529, 0.023447314277291298, 0.008084425702691078, 0.042257241904735565, 0.032808881253004074, 0.024290474131703377, 0.07950511574745178, -0.06536976993083954, -0.014296537265181541, -0.007458254229277372, 0.031271349638700485, 0.03429681062698364, 0.03640471398830414, -0.01624324731528759, 0.032387297600507736, -0.00012021630391245708, 0.020248262211680412, -0.014184942469000816, 0.0592692531645298, -0.006221411749720573, 0.0072846622206270695, 0.0643778145313263, -0.04543149471282959, 0.002290793927386403, 0.025294827297329903, 0.0020753538701683283, -0.01128347683697939, -0.006732888054102659, -0.0673040822148323, -0.04987048730254173, -0.04766339063644409, 0.028146695345640182, 0.007235064636915922, -0.016751624643802643, 0.02983301691710949, -0.030428189784288406, -0.006246210541576147, -0.02527002803981304, 0.0030130604282021523, -0.04627465456724167, 0.009076379239559174, 0.004618785809725523, -0.013453376479446888, -0.017507988959550858, -0.01480491366237402, 0.01954149454832077, 0.03288327530026436, -0.020682241767644882, 0.01884712651371956, 0.042877212166786194, 0.021153420209884644, 0.01754518784582615, 0.036776695400476456, 0.037198275327682495, 0.006199712865054607, 0.03489198163151741, 0.009888541884720325, 0.023360516875982285, -0.026832357048988342, 0.036305516958236694, -0.013887356035411358, -0.026460373774170876, 0.021810589358210564, 0.00493497122079134, 0.012585416436195374, 0.006221411749720573, -0.014842112548649311, 0.0040608118288218975, -0.0162060484290123, -0.013527773320674896, 0.006838283035904169, 0.020074669271707535, -0.02943623624742031, 0.007836436852812767, -0.0021683494560420513, 0.0319657176733017, 0.018041163682937622, -0.06125316023826599, -0.02457566186785698, 0.03320566192269325, -0.028816264122724533, -0.015648074448108673, 0.03714867681264877, 0.0014484078856185079, 0.02876666747033596, 0.010068333707749844, -0.03928137943148613, -0.013800560496747494, -0.014544526115059853, -0.01735919527709484, -0.030428189784288406, 0.001038451911881566, 0.0027480225544422865, 0.034321609884500504, 0.029560230672359467, -0.0019141612574458122, -0.008227018639445305, 0.018958721309900284, 0.020955028012394905, -0.03511517122387886, -0.0064539010636508465, -0.006416702643036842, -0.0309737641364336, -0.02762592025101185, -0.0238936934620142, -0.009262370876967907, 0.008357212878763676, 0.005499145016074181, -0.017706379294395447, -0.01993827521800995, -0.013366580940783024, 0.0010957992635667324, 0.0075698490254580975, -0.03181692585349083, -0.007042873650789261, 0.0033881429117172956, -0.014780115336179733, -0.007960431277751923, -0.023645704612135887, 0.031097758561372757, 0.024910446256399155, -0.020297858864068985, -0.027477126568555832, 0.032164108008146286, -0.022033778950572014, -0.008537004701793194, 0.02499724179506302, -0.0014817313058301806, -0.012759008444845676, 0.013974152505397797, -0.012387026101350784, 0.025084037333726883, -0.01558607816696167, -0.008202220313251019, 0.01437093410640955, -0.03206491470336914, 0.01823955401778221, -0.00033439701655879617, 0.07757080346345901, -0.029957011342048645, -0.038958992809057236, 0.008741594851016998, 0.03997574746608734, 0.010843297466635704, -0.036131925880908966, 0.0058153304271399975, -0.03117215633392334, -0.0009276320342905819, 0.012387026101350784, -0.01239322591573, -0.02498484216630459, -0.03313126415014267, -0.009801745414733887, 0.016776422038674355, 0.022083377465605736, 0.016602830961346626, -0.003874820424243808, 0.031221752986311913, 0.028245890513062477, -0.00956615712493658, 0.04302600771188736, 0.01973988488316536, 0.04151327535510063, -0.011438470333814621, 0.013812960125505924, -0.028196293860673904, 0.012808606028556824, 0.014891710132360458, 0.013763362541794777, -0.02173619344830513, 0.05202798917889595, 0.06735368072986603, -0.04915132373571396, 0.04607626423239708, 0.04101729765534401, -0.0039926148019731045, -0.025542816147208214, 0.024935243651270866, -0.02104182541370392, 0.000642057741060853, 0.027725115418434143, 0.004253002814948559, 0.0005664987256750464, -0.034123219549655914, -0.04892813414335251, -0.00976454745978117, 0.012461422942578793, 0.0014026849530637264, -0.020471451804041862, -0.008977184072136879, 0.012690812349319458, -0.008506005629897118, -0.022455358877778053, 0.02174859307706356, 0.04786178097128868, 0.016528433188796043, -0.03620632365345955, -0.007055273279547691, -0.011370273306965828, -0.004352198448032141, -0.029089052230119705, 0.0337512344121933, 0.009082579053938389, -0.021847788244485855, -0.050837643444538116, 0.011934447102248669, -0.005151961464434862, 0.02283974178135395, -0.003930618055164814, 0.04042212665081024, 0.013006997294723988, 0.04498511552810669, 0.032362502068281174, 0.01141367107629776, -0.008109224028885365, -0.006714289076626301, -0.01041551772505045, 0.015511681325733662, 0.029237845912575722, 0.012343628332018852, -0.016354842111468315, 0.019677888602018356, 0.010607708245515823, 0.00016158001380972564, -0.02257935330271721, 0.011599662713706493, -0.013267384842038155, 0.036727096885442734, 0.038512613624334335, -0.00046846579061821103, 0.010427916422486305, 0.02437726967036724, -0.027353132143616676, 0.01690041646361351, -0.010254324413836002, -0.01711120642721653, 0.005124062765389681, 0.0017669181106612086, -0.00867959763854742, -0.0010741002624854445, 0.027129942551255226, 0.04491071775555611, -0.008630000054836273, -0.002262895228341222, -0.0197150856256485, -0.0002375264884904027, 0.03278408199548721, 0.01261641550809145, -0.05247436836361885, -0.00003533351991791278, -0.021141020581126213, -0.006937478668987751, 0.009708750061690807, 0.027576321735978127, -0.007631846237927675, 0.05202798917889595, -0.016776422038674355, 0.03114735707640648, 0.010241925716400146, -0.02438966929912567, 0.01502810325473547, 0.013453376479446888, 0.010750302113592625, 0.024960042908787727, -0.0061222161166369915, -0.027179541066288948, 0.02894025854766369, -0.08163781464099884, 0.0022039979230612516, -0.027526725083589554, 0.0029572630301117897, 0.0011376473121345043, -0.006522097624838352, -0.00636090524494648, -0.005691336467862129, 0.029957011342048645, 0.02106662467122078, -0.017631983384490013, 0.01690041646361351, -0.022914137691259384, -0.01217003632336855, -0.018549541011452675, -0.03027939610183239, 0.01392455492168665, -0.01249862089753151, -0.0333048552274704, 0.042926810681819916, 0.029089052230119705, -0.02279014326632023, -0.001681672059930861, -0.012492421083152294, 0.016330042853951454, -0.029287442564964294, 0.010818498209118843, -0.04151327535510063, -0.012436623685061932, 0.02063264325261116, 0.005864928010851145, -0.08952385187149048, 0.005678936839103699, 0.042058851569890976, 0.040273334830999374, -0.010799899697303772, -0.007222665473818779, 0.03685109317302704, 0.045977070927619934, -0.03273448348045349, 0.007439655251801014, 0.02807229943573475, -0.004376997239887714, -0.027774712070822716, 0.0035028376150876284, 0.003657830413430929, 0.009349166415631771, -0.03486718237400055, 0.013788160867989063, 0.010892895050346851, 0.022095775231719017, 0.0034067421220242977, 0.003912018612027168, -0.020893031731247902, 0.03489198163151741, -0.008171221241354942, 0.06085637956857681, -0.07082551717758179, -0.027749914675951004, 0.012430423870682716, -0.0008098374819383025, 0.015548879280686378, -0.005083764437586069, 0.0036857291124761105, 0.03119695372879505, -0.01084949728101492, -0.0014189592329785228, -0.012808606028556824, 0.027997901663184166, -0.0006571695557795465, 0.011791853234171867, -0.018611537292599678, -0.019206710159778595, 0.022244568914175034, -0.0019622091203927994, 0.04979609325528145, -0.003719827625900507, -0.04592747241258621, -0.013416178524494171, 0.02239336259663105, 0.003341645235195756, 0.009001982398331165, -0.01911991462111473, -0.00299446121789515, 0.0334288515150547, -0.020062269642949104, -0.014184942469000816, 0.05004408210515976, -0.013490574434399605, 0.02106662467122078, 0.003679529530927539, -0.007693843450397253, 0.00422200420871377, 0.03288327530026436, -0.03380083292722702, -0.033676840364933014, 0.01730959862470627, -0.04540669545531273, 0.022046178579330444, 0.0002720124030020088, -0.05470626428723335, -0.027749914675951004, 0.008877988904714584, -0.01867353543639183, 0.003862421028316021, 0.01950429566204548, -0.00003022359851456713, 0.0027061745058745146, -0.0073094614781439304, -0.04982089251279831, -0.00814022310078144, 0.006565495859831572, -0.015164497308433056, -0.008524605073034763, -0.030403390526771545, -0.020235862582921982, 0.004491691943258047, 0.03117215633392334, 0.0014871560269966722, 0.017817974090576172, -0.008437808603048325, 0.015610876493155956, -0.0023512409534305334, -0.021463405340909958, 0.026187585666775703, 0.011630660854279995, 0.023546509444713593, -0.011667859740555286, 0.023397715762257576, 0.00670188944786787, 0.00411660922691226, -0.004361497703939676, -0.014085747301578522, -0.029064252972602844, -0.037198275327682495, 0.03027939610183239, -0.03228810429573059, -0.006277209147810936, 0.005120962858200073, 0.030006609857082367, -0.021798189729452133, 0.03469359129667282, 0.042877212166786194, 0.019219109788537025, 0.03382563218474388, 0.033230461180210114, 0.0044141956605017185, -0.019169511273503304, -0.00824561808258295, -0.02725393697619438, 0.01075650192797184, -0.005920725408941507, 0.0009563057101331651, -0.019367901608347893, -0.023583706468343735, 0.009572356007993221, -0.01755758561193943, 0.00007313723472179845, 0.03315606340765953, -0.020483851432800293, 0.007290862035006285, 0.01337897963821888, 0.0398765504360199, 0.02065744251012802, 0.005034166853874922, 0.013738563284277916, -0.02411688305437565, 0.0072846622206270695, 0.02219497226178646, 0.0004932646406814456, 0.040050145238637924, -0.031940918415784836, -0.008704396896064281, 0.017086409032344818, 0.020049870014190674, -0.01755758561193943, 0.009851343929767609, -0.026633964851498604, 0.024240877479314804, -0.015610876493155956, -0.0034997377078980207, 0.007793039083480835, -0.004572288133203983, -0.042455632239580154, 0.024650057777762413, 0.012300229631364346, 0.022269368171691895, -0.004969069734215736, 0.014866910874843597, -0.04240603372454643, 0.049944885075092316, 0.014556925743818283, 0.01868593320250511, -0.02812189608812332, -0.0027325234841555357, 0.03422241285443306, -0.0037942242342978716, -0.039851754903793335, 0.003974015824496746, -0.020359857007861137, -0.013688965700566769, -0.01624324731528759, -0.06522097438573837, 0.057582929730415344, 0.01755758561193943, -0.027278736233711243, -0.032089713960886, -0.008518405258655548, -0.005663437768816948, -0.0009330567554570735, 0.029535431414842606, 0.024687256664037704, -0.008840790018439293, 0.0034315409138798714, -0.0034377407282590866, -0.0018490643706172705, 0.008710596710443497, -0.03665270283818245, -0.0077806394547224045, -0.002414788119494915, 0.0009656052570790052, 0.007898434065282345, 0.0412156917154789, 0.023856494575738907, 0.035412758588790894, -0.001650673453696072, 0.013664166443049908, -0.03905818983912468, 0.035685546696186066, -0.05158160999417305, -0.019901078194379807, -0.04042212665081024, 0.0030626580119132996, -0.0063330065459012985, -0.01780557446181774, -0.012982198037207127, -0.00820841919630766, 0.046398650854825974, -0.02478645183146, -0.03928137943148613, -0.02042185328900814, 0.005685136653482914, 0.004500991199165583, -0.031048161908984184, -0.024228477850556374, 0.059170059859752655, -0.024017687886953354, 0.02569160982966423, -0.02152540162205696, -0.03600792959332466, -0.005914526060223579, -0.014854511246085167, -0.02938663773238659, 0.0017498688539490104, 0.034767989069223404, 0.026658764109015465, 0.001436783466488123, -0.025282427668571472, -0.02062024362385273, -0.0024442367721349, -0.01950429566204548, 0.004358397796750069, -0.025195632129907608, -0.0004897773033007979, -0.0016274246154353023, -0.042505230754613876, 0.02807229943573475, 0.011562463827431202, 0.005037266761064529, -0.00011653522233245894, -0.020136667415499687, -0.02527002803981304, 0.00487607391551137, -0.008177421055734158, -0.0021265014074742794, -0.008481207303702831, -0.005189159419387579, 0.022207370027899742, 0.008698197081685066, 0.008741594851016998, 0.010359720326960087, -0.02128981426358223, -0.005592140834778547, -0.010886695235967636, -0.004541289526969194, -0.018611537292599678, -0.006209012120962143, -0.04319959878921509, 0.024290474131703377, 0.033949628472328186, -0.01032872125506401, -0.022318964824080467, -0.026013994589447975, -0.014023750089108944, -0.008059626445174217, -0.02455086261034012, 0.0009617304312996566, -0.026385977864265442, 0.00876639410853386, -0.01909511536359787, -0.028270689770579338, -0.024315273389220238, -0.031916119158267975, 0.015065302141010761, -0.03233770281076431, -0.005384450312703848, -0.04890333488583565, 0.002800720278173685, -0.019467098638415337, -0.001732819713652134, 0.021649396046996117, 0.01261641550809145, -0.036330316215753555, -0.03328005596995354, -0.019690288230776787, -0.027154741808772087, 0.02084343321621418, -0.0009594055591151118, -0.0552518405020237, 0.016999611631035805, -0.009677751921117306, 0.014246939681470394, 0.002791420556604862, 0.036553505808115005, 0.0007765140035189688, 0.01687561720609665, -0.01502810325473547, 0.002010256750509143, 0.03137054666876793, 0.03256089240312576, -0.026881953701376915, 0.005638638511300087, 0.00581223051995039, 0.014296537265181541, 0.003933717496693134, -0.018586738035082817, -0.02564201131463051, -0.03308166563510895, -0.015003304928541183, 0.01371376495808363, 0.0033695439342409372, -0.009355366230010986, -0.017507988959550858, -0.025170832872390747, -0.03154413774609566, -0.014023750089108944, -0.022219769656658173, 0.00269067520275712, -0.0071420688182115555, 0.02478645183146, 0.0008330863784067333, -0.015300891362130642, -0.0001340687886113301, 0.03228810429573059, -0.004491691943258047, 0.004634285345673561, -0.009522758424282074, -0.024848448112607002, 0.00943596288561821, -0.0062431106343865395, 0.03469359129667282, -0.0011337724281474948, 0.01406094804406166, -0.009962938725948334, 0.019256306812167168, 0.017396394163370132, 0.0012910901568830013, 0.054557472467422485, 0.02150060422718525, 0.011835251934826374, 0.036528706550598145, -0.012442823499441147, 0.01957869343459606, -0.01644163765013218, 0.0022551454603672028, 0.0031417044810950756, 0.017086409032344818, 0.020979827269911766, 0.010055934078991413, -0.002484534867107868, 0.013068994507193565, 0.06125316023826599, -0.012610215693712234, 0.023162126541137695, -0.0044358945451676846, 0.005759533029049635, 0.0024922844022512436, -0.015648074448108673, 0.03908298909664154, 0.02851867862045765, 0.0038655209355056286, 0.0025635811034590006, 0.033949628472328186, 0.04186046123504639, 0.00558904092758894, 0.02941143698990345, 0.014854511246085167, 0.0034067421220242977, -0.0028704670257866383, 0.017879972234368324, 0.008109224028885365, -0.010613908059895039, -0.004528889898210764, 0.027055546641349792, 0.01337897963821888, -0.012337428517639637, -0.00717926723882556, 0.012994597665965557, -0.02591479942202568, -0.026931552216410637, -0.025146035477519035, -0.00460638664662838, 0.029585029929876328, -0.012108039110898972, -0.011692658066749573, -0.010663505643606186, 0.01641683839261532, -0.025158433243632317, 0.01383775845170021, 0.027377931401133537, -0.00889038760215044, 0.016950014978647232, 0.01713600568473339, -0.006429102271795273, -0.01711120642721653, -0.028270689770579338, 0.012151436880230904, -0.024873247370123863, -0.022938936948776245, -0.0010376769350841641, 0.0071420688182115555, 0.005068264901638031, -0.00719166686758399, 0.015176896937191486, -0.021884985268115997, -0.018537141382694244, -0.005833929870277643, 0.013279784470796585, -0.0010059033520519733, 0.02834508568048477, 0.00407011155039072, -0.014494928531348705, -0.014184942469000816, 0.01820235699415207, -0.04570428282022476, -0.00019480659102555364, -0.02834508568048477, -0.017210401594638824, -0.03047778829932213, 0.025418821722269058, -0.041810862720012665, -0.02812189608812332, 0.006298908032476902, 0.003862421028316021, -0.0057626329362392426, -0.018165158107876778, -0.021847788244485855, 0.0028255190700292587, 0.014643721282482147, -0.009584755636751652, -0.012194834649562836, -0.04272842034697533, 0.012349828146398067, 0.02631158009171486, 0.027477126568555832, -0.04806017130613327, 0.018524741753935814, 0.006069518625736237, -0.008623800240457058, -0.00011149796046083793, 0.0033075467217713594, -0.006602693814784288, -0.0030983064789325, 0.011537665501236916, 0.025815604254603386, 0.00487607391551137, 0.02478645183146, -0.026013994589447975, -0.02725393697619438, 0.03315606340765953, -0.013428578153252602, -0.0014484078856185079, 0.024092083796858788, 0.0010663506109267473, 0.008413010276854038, 0.010378318838775158, 0.014333736151456833, -0.020149067044258118, -0.0438939668238163, 0.0056200395338237286, 0.011469468474388123, 0.0072102658450603485, 0.011612062342464924, 0.003741526510566473, -0.005303854122757912, -0.02328612096607685, 0.030452989041805267, 0.025542816147208214, 0.006615093443542719, 0.006103617139160633, -0.03189132362604141, 0.0382150299847126, -0.008400610648095608, 0.024302873760461807, -0.04059571772813797, 0.006695689633488655, -0.028394684195518494, 0.006267909426242113, 0.005269755609333515, 0.006745287217199802, 0.022951336577534676, 0.010347320698201656, 0.02478645183146, 0.027477126568555832, 0.013887356035411358, 0.009801745414733887, 0.019454699009656906, 0.01129587646573782, -0.032089713960886, 0.045555487275123596, 0.014594123698771, 0.007768239825963974, -0.017867572605609894, -0.02285214141011238, -0.028816264122724533, 0.027824310585856438, -0.007768239825963974, -0.0032486494164913893, -0.017817974090576172, 0.029709022492170334, -0.001804116414859891, -0.03380083292722702, -0.01482971291989088, -0.002252045553177595, 0.010824698023498058, 0.01602005772292614, 0.026038793846964836, -0.02787390910089016, -0.00016264559235423803, -0.018822327256202698, -0.019405100494623184, -0.01186005026102066, 0.006379504222422838, -0.00035493355244398117, -0.00810302421450615, 0.041141293942928314, -0.026857156306505203, 0.016144052147865295, 0.00964675284922123, -0.010514712892472744, -0.01888432539999485, -0.01690041646361351, -0.04890333488583565, -0.027973104268312454, -0.004702481906861067, -0.0398765504360199, -0.011264878325164318, 0.011915847659111023, -0.004491691943258047, -0.06517138332128525, 0.018809927627444267, -0.020124267786741257, -0.03184172511100769, 0.025084037333726883, 0.0050806645303964615, 0.0278491098433733, 0.04724181070923805, -0.003524536732584238, 0.015003304928541183, 0.01583406701683998, -0.024885646998882294, 0.020310258492827415, -0.01642923802137375, 0.02369530126452446, 0.022653751075267792, 0.029758621007204056, 0.026261983439326286, -0.020781436935067177, 0.018772730603814125, -0.027278736233711243, 0.026857156306505203, 0.010248125530779362, 0.01753278821706772, 0.012467621825635433, 0.026460373774170876, 0.019367901608347893, -0.0008020878303796053, -0.009590955451130867, 0.00024043260782491416, -0.017408793792128563, -0.027501925826072693, -0.018549541011452675, -0.020769037306308746, -0.007749640848487616, -0.0010462015634402633, 0.02257935330271721, -0.029758621007204056, -0.0027480225544422865, 0.04429074749350548, -0.03625591844320297, -0.00260852905921638, 0.01692521572113037, -0.0076814438216388226, 0.011140883900225163, -0.016776422038674355, 0.011953046545386314, 0.00833861343562603, 0.006565495859831572, 0.0009439062559977174, -0.014668520539999008, -0.0013406878570094705, -0.0018180657643824816, -0.03233770281076431, 0.022083377465605736, 0.02110382169485092, 0.01670202612876892, -0.031469739973545074, -0.009243771433830261, -0.0004909397684969008, -0.03890939801931381, 0.032585691660642624, 0.02593959867954254, 0.01361456885933876, -0.009931939654052258, -0.012783807702362537, -0.009373965673148632, 0.01650363579392433, 0.04151327535510063, 0.024240877479314804, -0.04057091847062111, -0.037644654512405396, -0.012982198037207127, -0.008506005629897118, -0.031940918415784836, -0.012610215693712234, 0.03144494444131851, -0.020818635821342468, 0.015945661813020706, -0.03647910803556442, -0.0041290088556706905, -0.00071335444226861, -0.00900818221271038, -0.026435574516654015, 0.019020719453692436, 0.014618922956287861, 0.002875116653740406, 0.0177683774381876, 0.014184942469000816, 0.018561940640211105, 0.011618261225521564, 0.020149067044258118, 0.01796676777303219, -0.0011570213828235865, -0.005251156631857157, 0.0001513117313152179, -0.004476192407310009, -0.00670188944786787, -0.0071420688182115555, -0.04669623449444771, -0.01227543130517006, 0.025344425812363625, -0.004513390827924013, -0.021339410915970802, -0.013664166443049908, -0.0028890660032629967, -0.04019893705844879, 0.0013375880662351847, 0.03139534592628479, 0.004649784415960312, -0.00791703350841999, 0.005310053937137127, -0.00923137180507183, 0.003089006757363677, 0.006615093443542719, -0.03561114892363548, 0.028394684195518494, 0.02062024362385273, 0.004975269548594952, 0.0009353816276416183, -0.03819023072719574, -0.008685797452926636, -0.01086189690977335, 0.01818995736539364, -0.016627630218863487, -0.026832357048988342, -0.013639368116855621, 0.020322658121585846, -0.021339410915970802, 0.006813484244048595, 0.010465115308761597, -0.01021092664450407, -0.011103685013949871, 0.013044195249676704, -0.023819295689463615, 0.015660474076867104, 0.04364597797393799, 0.0035090374294668436, 0.041562873870134354, 0.013440976850688457, 0.000012702145795628894, 0.00876639410853386, -0.02502204105257988, 0.02347211167216301, 0.002038155449554324, -0.011953046545386314, 0.028568275272846222, -0.00593002513051033, 0.009597155265510082, -0.016974814236164093, 0.02215777337551117, -0.0004064686654601246, 0.009584755636751652, 0.01184765063226223, -0.016776422038674355, 0.014135344885289669, -0.014990905299782753, 0.015883663669228554, -0.013639368116855621, 0.023868894204497337, 0.0162060484290123, -0.053218334913253784, -0.0036516308318823576, -0.020731838420033455, -0.0033478448167443275, -0.02504683844745159, -0.00876639410853386, 0.013986552134156227, -0.032808881253004074, -0.011128484271466732, 0.005421648733317852, -0.03913258761167526, 0.006633692421019077, 0.004218904301524162, -0.031296148896217346, 0.01862393692135811, 0.01775597780942917, 0.0154868820682168, 0.01779317483305931, 0.02283974178135395, 0.024749252945184708, 0.019479496404528618, -0.03801663964986801, 0.023571306839585304, -0.029113851487636566, 0.028816264122724533, 0.012690812349319458, 0.014656120911240578, -0.006571695674210787, 0.021438606083393097, -0.01908271573483944, -0.03888459876179695, -0.0017049210146069527, 0.007830237038433552, -0.00833861343562603, -0.0025744307786226273, -0.011884849518537521, -0.029039453715085983, -0.02148820459842682, 0.01711120642721653, 0.01862393692135811, -0.019851479679346085, 0.024724453687667847, 0.01206464134156704, 0.018326351419091225, -0.00024256376491393894, -0.022256968542933464, -0.024922845885157585, -0.02063264325261116, 0.00978934671729803, 0.004073211457580328 ]
6.37459
3.198073
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.tmp.1616R
[ "FRB 20220717A", "FRB detection instruments", "FRB 20220905A", "FRB", "FRBs", "low linear polarization fractions", "20220717A", "~1 arc-second", "fast radio bursts", "a host galaxy" ]
[ "radio continuum: transients", "stars: neutron", "techniques: interferometric", "Astrophysics - High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena" ]
21
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1652", "10.48550/arXiv.2407.02173" ]
[ "Rajwade, K. M.", "Driessen, L. N.", "Barr, E. D.", "Pastor-Marazuela, I.", "Berezina, M.", "Jankowski, F.", "Muller, A.", "Kahinga, L.", "Stappers, B. W.", "Bezuidenhout, M. C.", "Caleb, M.", "Deller, A.", "Fong, W.", "Gordon, A.", "Kramer, M.", "Malenta, M.", "Morello, V.", "Prochaska, J. X.", "Sanidas, S.", "Surnis, M.", "Tejos, N.", "Wagner, S." ]
[ "Astrophysics, University of Oxford, Denys Wilkinson Building, Keble Road, Oxford OX1 3RH, UK; ASTRON, 4 Oude Hoogeveensedijk, Dwingeloo 7991 PD, The Netherlands;", "Sydney Institute for Astrophysics, School of Physics, University of Sydney, NSW, Sydney 2006, Australia;", "Max-Planck-Institut für Radioastronomie, Auf dem Hügel 69, D-53121 Bonn, Germany;", "Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9PL", "Max-Planck-Institut für Radioastronomie, Auf dem Hügel 69, D-53121 Bonn, Germany; Landessternwarte, Universität Heidelberg, Königstuhl 12, D-69117 Heidelberg, Germany", "Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9PL; LPC2E, Université d'Orléans, CNRS, 3A Avenue de la Recherche Scientifique, 45071 Orléans, France;", "Maria Mitchell Observatory, Nantucket, MA 02554, USA", "University of California, Santa Cruz, 1156 High St., Santa Cruz, CA 95064, USA", "Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9PL", "Department of Mathematical Sciences, University of South Africa, Cnr Christiaan de Wet Rd and Pioneer Avenue, Florida Park, 1709, Roodepoort, South Africa; Centre for Space Research, North-West University, Potchefstroom 2531, South Africa;", "Sydney Institute for Astrophysics, School of Physics, University of Sydney, NSW, Sydney 2006, Australia;", "Centre for Astrophysics and Supercomputing, Swinburne University of Technology, Hawthorn, VIC 3122, Australia;", "Center for Interdisciplinary Exploration and Research in Astrophysics (CIERA), Department of Physics and Astronomy, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208, USA", "Center for Interdisciplinary Exploration and Research in Astrophysics (CIERA), Department of Physics and Astronomy, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208, USA;", "Max-Planck-Institut für Radioastronomie, Auf dem Hügel 69, D-53121 Bonn, Germany;", "Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9PL", "SKA Observatory, Jodrell Bank, Lower Withington, Macclesfield, SK119FT, UK;", "University of California, Santa Cruz, 1156 High St., Santa Cruz, CA 95064, USA", "Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9PL", "Department of Physics, IISER Bhopal, Bhauri Bypass Road, Bhopal, 462066, India;", "Instituto de Física, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Valparaíso, Casilla 4059, Valparaíso, Chile;", "Landessternwarte, Universität Heidelberg, Königstuhl 12, D-69117 Heidelberg, Germany" ]
null
[ "1977ApJ...216..433R", "1994ApJ...435...22K", "2003A&A...410..253L", "2004SPIE.5492..331C", "2007ASPC..376..127M", "2007PASP..119..318D", "2007Sci...318..777L", "2009ARA&A..47...27K", "2009MNRAS.392L..60K", "2011MNRAS.414.2528P", "2011PASP..123..275D", "2011arXiv1107.4264C", "2011ivoa.spec.0711S", "2012MNRAS.422.1527M", "2014A&C.....7...12S", "2016SPIE.9908E..2SG", "2016mks..confE...1J", "2017ApJ...834L...7T", "2017arXiv171008155P", "2018ApJ...863...48C", "2018NatAs...2..922B", "2019MNRAS.484.5500C", "2020A&C....3200384B", "2020JOSS....5.2308P", "2020Natur.581..391M", "2020Natur.587...54C", "2020Natur.587...59B", "2020PASA...37...28B", "2020SPIE11447E..0JR", "2021ApJ...911...95A", "2021ApJS..253...48V", "2021JAI....1050013C", "2021PASA...38...58H", "2022A&A...657A..43H", "2022ASPC..532..273J", "2022ApJ...927...35C", "2022JATIS...8a1006V", "2022MNRAS.511.6033P", "2022MNRAS.512.5037D", "2022MNRAS.514.1961R", "2022MNRAS.516.4862J", "2022Natur.602..585K", "2022PASP..134k4501C", "2022ascl.soft08003J", "2023AJ....165...78D", "2023ApJ...946...58C", "2023ApJ...948...67B", "2023ApJ...949L...3R", "2023ApJ...951...82M", "2023MNRAS.524.2064C", "2023MNRAS.524.4275J", "2023MNRAS.526.3273C", "2023PASA...40...34D", "2024ApJ...964..131S", "2024ApJ...965...57B", "2024ApJ...968...50P", "2024MNRAS.527.3659D" ]
29163017
2405.00103
A 3D view on the local gravitational instability of cold gas discs in star-forming galaxies at 0 ≲ z ≲ 5
Local gravitational instability (LGI) is considered crucial for regulating star formation and gas turbulence in galaxy discs, especially at high redshift. Instability criteria usually assume infinitesimally thin discs or rely on approximations to include the stabilising effect of the gas disc thickness. We test a new 3D instability criterion for rotating gas discs that are vertically stratified in an external potential. This criterion reads Q<SUB>3D</SUB> &lt; 1, where Q<SUB>3D</SUB> is the 3D analogue of the Toomre parameter Q. The advantage of Q<SUB>3D</SUB> is that it allows us to study LGI in and above the galaxy midplane in a rigorous and self-consistent way. We apply the criterion to a sample of 44 star-forming galaxies at 0 ≲ z ≲ 5 hosting rotating discs of cold gas. The sample is representative of galaxies on the main sequence at z ≈ 0 and includes massive star-forming and starburst galaxies at 1 ≲ z ≲ 5. For each galaxy, we first apply the Toomre criterion for infinitesimally thin discs, finding ten unstable systems. We then obtain maps of Q<SUB>3D</SUB> from a 3D model of the gas disc derived in the combined potential of dark matter, stars and the gas itself. According to the 3D criterion, two galaxies with Q &lt; 1 show no evidence of instability and the unstable regions that are 20% smaller than those where Q &lt; 1. No unstable disc is found at 0 ≲ z ≲ 1, while ≈60% of the systems at 2 ≲ z ≲ 5 are locally unstable. In these latter, a relatively small fraction of the total gas (≈30%) is potentially affected by the instability. Our results disfavour LGI as the main regulator of star formation and turbulence in moderately star-forming galaxies in the present-day Universe. LGI likely becomes important at high redshift, but the input by other mechanisms seems required in a significant portion of the disc. We also estimate the expected mass of clumps in the unstable regions, offering testable predictions for observations.
[ -0.01223649550229311, 0.06004178524017334, 0.022282347083091736, 0.00724597554653883, 0.00010866127558983862, 0.007589478511363268, 0.010765263810753822, -0.026883995160460472, -0.0436573252081871, 0.013001276180148125, -0.02107684500515461, 0.006581652909517288, -0.06470824778079987, -0.01486785989254713, 0.00852277036756277, 0.020143551751971245, -0.00908015388995409, -0.009974557906389236, -0.017239976674318314, 0.06019733473658562, 0.035594720393419266, -0.006510359700769186, -0.019456544890999794, 0.032820768654346466, -0.05454573407769203, -0.04671644791960716, 0.04741641879081726, -0.0014679905725643039, 0.017512187361717224, -0.02066204883158207, 0.08233709633350372, -0.02786913700401783, -0.018665840849280357, -0.03974268585443497, -0.04658682644367218, 0.08695170283317566, 0.0035419727209955454, 0.0040280623361468315, 0.013221636414527893, -0.021024994552135468, -0.04477209225296974, 0.04124632105231285, -0.019715793430805206, -0.04347585141658783, -0.0034382736776024103, -0.01154300756752491, 0.041012998670339584, -0.01795290783047676, -0.018419554457068443, -0.035465095192193985, -0.02869872935116291, 0.002519564237445593, 0.014828972518444061, -0.006617299746721983, 0.013662357814610004, 0.0012589719844982028, -0.0030331991147249937, 0.02523777075111866, 0.016799256205558777, 0.007699659094214439, -0.015023408457636833, -0.009157927706837654, 0.038031648844480515, -0.021297205239534378, -0.01808253303170204, -0.005408556666225195, -0.03341703861951828, -0.001399938017129898, 0.03357258811593056, 0.031006034463644028, -0.05770855396986008, -0.04684607312083244, -0.012929982505738735, -0.02696176804602146, 0.027843210846185684, 0.0005735856830142438, 0.013163305819034576, -0.02377302199602127, -0.03759092837572098, -0.03377998620271683, 0.051694005727767944, 0.004400731064379215, 0.014816010370850563, 0.015995588153600693, -0.02614513784646988, 0.019741717725992203, 0.014478988014161587, -0.009456062689423561, -0.04899783059954643, 0.022165685892105103, 0.0039794533513486385, -0.007472817320376635, -0.006601096596568823, 0.008723687380552292, 0.00733023090288043, -0.04754604399204254, 0.07388561964035034, -0.010972661897540092, 0.020843520760536194, 0.007083945441991091, -0.04674237594008446, 0.02613217569887638, 0.02316378988325596, -0.06263426691293716, 0.056464165449142456, -0.01257999800145626, -0.019715793430805206, 0.043579552322626114, 0.01167911197990179, -0.022074948996305466, 0.04417582228779793, 0.037746477872133255, -0.04332030192017555, 0.04096115007996559, -0.048842281103134155, 0.008082049898803234, -0.044901713728904724, 0.010168993845582008, -0.06953025609254837, -0.020986108109354973, 0.0197546798735857, -0.043086979538202286, 0.012936464510858059, 0.011517082341015339, 0.04026117920875549, -0.04472023993730545, 0.01656593382358551, -0.01511414535343647, -0.053068019449710846, 0.03022829070687294, 0.03113565780222416, 0.010745820589363575, 0.017499225214123726, -0.024926673620939255, -0.031991176307201385, -0.00395028805360198, 0.006089081987738609, 0.013779019005596638, -0.011368014849722385, 0.03098011016845703, -0.01399938017129898, 0.01852325350046158, 0.010875443927943707, -0.0021306925918906927, 0.030487539246678352, 0.0017499225214123726, -0.03022829070687294, 0.008529252372682095, 0.015995588153600693, 0.027402490377426147, -0.005505774635821581, -0.021102769300341606, -0.025691455230116844, -0.04951632395386696, -0.025341469794511795, -0.019715793430805206, 0.015088221058249474, 0.009002379141747952, 0.014258627779781818, -0.0402352549135685, -0.0211416557431221, 0.019650980830192566, -0.024719275534152985, -0.006546006537973881, -0.020415762439370155, 0.052523598074913025, 0.009553280659019947, -0.025211846455931664, -0.066522978246212, -0.02495259791612625, 0.013597546145319939, -0.035335473716259, -0.022826766595244408, -0.05413093790411949, 0.006140931975096464, 0.020299101248383522, -0.005129865370690823, -0.009721791371703148, 0.005136346444487572, -0.004815527703613043, 0.03357258811593056, 0.022697143256664276, 0.0035160479601472616, -0.03974268585443497, -0.028802428394556046, 0.07917427271604538, -0.03914641588926315, -0.020843520760536194, -0.0023737375158816576, -0.020402800291776657, -0.05019037052989006, 0.037124283611774445, -0.00013387716899160296, 0.040598202496767044, -0.02322860062122345, -0.04220553860068321, 0.05838260054588318, 0.025548867881298065, 0.03852422162890434, 0.04044265300035477, 0.03634653985500336, 0.03855014592409134, 0.02177681401371956, -0.06533043831586838, -0.04342400282621384, -0.0083153722807765, -0.013804944232106209, 0.003159582382068038, -0.04334622994065285, 0.014466025866568089, 0.00991622731089592, -0.017654772847890854, -0.024563727900385857, 0.036009516566991806, 0.010318061336874962, 0.012936464510858059, -0.015347468666732311, 0.042672183364629745, 0.07746323943138123, 0.04065005108714104, 0.005943255499005318, 0.02453780174255371, 0.008931086398661137, 0.045238737016916275, 0.022761955857276917, -0.0053145792335271835, 0.04414989799261093, -0.013124418444931507, 0.05750115588307381, 0.026313649490475655, 0.010071775875985622, 0.005515496712177992, -0.02593773975968361, -0.005337263457477093, 0.03193932771682739, -0.008503327146172523, -0.021686077117919922, 0.029657945036888123, -0.025756265968084335, -0.014414176344871521, -0.01466046180576086, 0.047260869294404984, -0.026054400950670242, -0.04560168460011482, -0.012560554780066013, -0.00032243941677734256, 0.002790154190734029, 0.022087911143898964, -0.02869872935116291, -0.0027966354973614216, 0.013571620918810368, -0.05579012259840965, -0.019663944840431213, -0.017512187361717224, -0.028880203142762184, 0.0061603751964867115, -0.015995588153600693, -0.011886510998010635, -0.004433136899024248, -0.01442713849246502, -0.025211846455931664, -0.045446135103702545, -0.035879891365766525, 0.026598822325468063, -0.024252628907561302, 0.04837563633918762, 0.01774550974369049, -0.005136346444487572, -0.029294999316334724, 0.016177061945199966, -0.0162937231361866, -0.05791595205664635, 0.0019200538517907262, -0.013649395667016506, -0.03958713635802269, 0.011899473145604134, 0.016449270769953728, 0.025069260969758034, -0.01494563464075327, 0.03416885808110237, -0.007265418767929077, 0.003415589453652501, 0.0402352549135685, 0.04062412679195404, -0.02753211371600628, 0.01615113578736782, -0.01331237331032753, 0.00039980869041755795, 0.00554466200992465, -0.007226531859487295, 0.0824926421046257, -0.0162807609885931, 0.02342303656041622, 0.05184955522418022, -0.025898853316903114, -0.017304789274930954, -0.014608612284064293, -0.002848485019057989, -0.05047554150223732, -0.0026281243190169334, 0.03183562681078911, 0.009371806867420673, -0.009605130180716515, 0.006439066492021084, -0.03543917089700699, 0.004083152394741774, 0.0790187194943428, 0.006004826631397009, -0.025600718334317207, 0.04824601113796234, -0.0018131141550838947, 0.005703451111912727, 0.007777433376759291, 0.020000966265797615, -0.07507815957069397, -0.006779329385608435, -0.029424622654914856, 0.05187547951936722, -0.010894888080656528, -0.018315855413675308, -0.03634653985500336, 0.004400731064379215, 0.02169903926551342, 0.007887613959610462, 0.004410452675074339, -0.01621594838798046, 0.022411970421671867, -0.011128210462629795, -0.03925011307001114, -0.003548454027622938, 0.01892508752644062, 0.0002981349534820765, 0.01760292425751686, 0.013882718980312347, -0.01858806610107422, -0.070670947432518, 0.036216914653778076, 0.06398235261440277, -0.040727827697992325, 0.02648216113448143, -0.023124901577830315, 0.051616232842206955, 0.042049989104270935, 0.015036371536552906, -0.0029473232571035624, 0.023967457935214043, 0.015606716275215149, -0.015127107501029968, 0.06901175528764725, 0.009034785442054272, -0.015191920101642609, -0.02099907025694847, 0.011983728967607021, -0.0054701282642781734, 0.019430620595812798, 0.0068052541464567184, -0.005590029992163181, -0.022995278239250183, 0.018626952543854713, 0.011147654615342617, -0.007440411020070314, -0.0022975835017859936, -0.01420677825808525, 0.01704554073512554, -0.03235412389039993, 0.01946950890123844, -0.02453780174255371, -0.022347157821059227, -0.013176267966628075, -0.02073982171714306, 0.025626642629504204, 0.04902375489473343, -0.005100700072944164, 0.027817286550998688, -0.006503878626972437, -0.014647499658167362, -0.000024557650249334984, 0.04752011597156525, 0.024097081273794174, 0.010700452141463757, 0.022995278239250183, -0.009345882572233677, 0.020558347925543785, -0.023604510352015495, -0.019093599170446396, 0.0002626909117680043, -0.029476473107933998, -0.018108457326889038, -0.09737346321344376, 0.018393630161881447, 0.017291827127337456, 0.010739339515566826, -0.014297515153884888, 0.0029764885548502207, -0.013027200475335121, -0.07150053977966309, -0.003525769803673029, 0.04596463218331337, 0.03370220959186554, 0.023397112265229225, -0.00832185335457325, -0.028517255559563637, -0.07336711883544922, -0.06175282225012779, -0.013636433519423008, -0.01594373770058155, 0.015088221058249474, 0.04650904983282089, -0.007628365885466337, -0.0194046963006258, 0.0443832203745842, -0.03873161971569061, 0.02815430797636509, -0.014271589927375317, -0.002291102195158601, -0.017628848552703857, 0.00042370808660052717, -0.01753811165690422, 0.016721481457352638, 0.05905664339661598, -0.015917813405394554, 0.017525149509310722, 0.012061502784490585, -0.03696873411536217, -0.03287261724472046, 0.02343599870800972, 0.005330782383680344, 0.02308601513504982, -0.0004617850936483592, -0.07787803560495377, -0.0011998311383649707, 0.035724345594644547, 0.02239900827407837, -0.00485117407515645, -0.012152239680290222, -0.029969044029712677, 0.006403420120477676, -0.07585590332746506, -0.0029878306668251753, -0.033598512411117554, 0.03292446956038475, 0.011257834732532501, 0.02107684500515461, -0.04194629192352295, 0.0395352877676487, 0.03867976740002632, 0.03385775908827782, -0.0035160479601472616, 0.00688302842900157, -0.05052739381790161, -0.023047126829624176, 0.037953875958919525, 0.04762381687760353, -0.019456544890999794, -0.03349481150507927, -0.03424663096666336, 0.05579012259840965, -0.04342400282621384, -0.00040365688619203866, -0.01913248561322689, -0.011212466284632683, 0.013753094710409641, 0.007816320285201073, 0.00990974623709917, -0.04964594915509224, 0.0044785053469240665, 0.013299411162734032, 0.0005991054349578917, 0.0032600408885627985, -0.02259344421327114, 0.0004816337605006993, -0.0818185955286026, 0.03821312263607979, -0.015541904605925083, -0.0017564037116244435, 0.0038141829427331686, -0.0190676748752594, -0.02619698829948902, 0.019923191517591476, -0.009203296154737473, 0.04972372204065323, -0.0028598271310329437, -0.0036813183687627316, -0.022437894716858864, 0.038653843104839325, 0.029087601229548454, -0.028335781767964363, 0.007479298394173384, -0.036709483712911606, -0.05449388176202774, -0.00034816167317330837, -0.029865344986319542, 0.0610269270837307, -0.013817906379699707, 0.017836246639490128, -0.01863991469144821, -0.020467612892389297, -0.025678493082523346, -0.017641810700297356, 0.041635192930698395, 0.05817520245909691, 0.01878250204026699, 0.02053242363035679, 0.012748509645462036, 0.032691143453121185, -0.02906167507171631, -0.012106871232390404, -0.034505877643823624, 0.005949736572802067, -0.003830385860055685, -0.02120646834373474, 0.01809549517929554, 0.02322860062122345, -0.020480575039982796, 0.007446892559528351, -0.008931086398661137, -0.006095563527196646, 0.030669013038277626, 0.015515979379415512, 0.010940256528556347, 0.03168007731437683, -0.007045058533549309, 0.006474713329225779, -0.0270395427942276, -0.0023510532919317484, -0.01494563464075327, -0.015101183205842972, -0.0929144024848938, -0.02510814741253853, -0.02134905382990837, -0.0053145792335271835, -0.02973571978509426, -0.008341297507286072, 0.029269075021147728, -0.02350081130862236, -0.04404619708657265, -0.024524839594960213, -0.026676597073674202, -0.028595030307769775, -0.04500541463494301, 0.03295039385557175, 0.02799876034259796, 0.005975661333650351, 0.009306995198130608, 0.020752783864736557, 0.016734443604946136, -0.03365036100149155, 0.0026977972593158484, 0.024589652195572853, 0.029217224568128586, 0.020856482908129692, -0.03175785392522812, -0.004238700959831476, 0.032405972480773926, 0.021310167387127876, -0.01327348593622446, 0.03152453154325485, -0.0036391906905919313, -0.010868962854146957, 0.014517875388264656, 0.0002952994254883379, -0.030669013038277626, -0.04212776571512222, 0.018212156370282173, 0.006915434263646603, -0.03963898494839668, -0.004005378112196922, -0.0004427465901244432, -0.005846037529408932, 0.04949039965867996, -0.01643630862236023, -0.024926673620939255, 0.041298169642686844, -0.017914021387696266, -0.0066205402836203575, -0.02711731754243374, -0.005658082664012909, 0.001025649020448327, 0.024382254108786583, -0.018678802996873856, -0.03460957854986191, -0.039820458739995956, 0.011705037206411362, -0.0014566484605893493, -0.011290241032838821, 0.0012346674920991063, -0.01133560948073864, 0.028620954602956772, 0.0225286316126585, 0.0027869136538356543, 0.010097701102495193, -0.005940014496445656, -0.015230806544423103, 0.003914641682058573, -0.03577619418501854, -0.01788809709250927, 0.019534319639205933, 0.044823940843343735, -0.013467921875417233, 0.009579204954206944, -0.031083809211850166, 0.022658254951238632, -0.031783778220415115, -0.02010466530919075, -0.0381353497505188, 0.012106871232390404, 0.004737752955406904, 0.00178070820402354, -0.011970765888690948, 0.0031984695233404636, 0.003282724879682064, 0.031861551105976105, -0.024589652195572853, -0.04837563633918762, -0.03595766797661781, -0.040805600583553314, 0.03440218046307564, -0.001939497422426939, 0.0367354117333889, -0.0166437067091465, -0.0070061711594462395, 0.013597546145319939, 0.010428241454064846, -0.0006505498895421624, 0.015632640570402145, 0.0029392216820269823, 0.0032875859178602695, -0.022710105404257774, -0.012320750392973423, -0.02233419567346573, -0.01178929302841425, -0.02828393317759037, -0.003512807423248887, -0.00883386842906475, 0.01602151244878769, -0.008509808219969273, -0.013208674266934395, 0.03958713635802269, 0.0015457648551091552, -0.009644017554819584, 0.040183406323194504, -0.005090978462249041, 0.01760292425751686, -0.04147964343428612, 0.041972216218709946, 0.006510359700769186, -0.029632020741701126, -0.0042775883339345455, 0.005366429220885038, -0.005019685253500938, -0.0043748063035309315, -0.018212156370282173, 0.01844547875225544, 0.016877030953764915, 0.01747330091893673, 0.014025304466485977, 0.0032260145526379347, -0.004439617972820997, -0.03725390508770943, 0.02364339679479599, 0.0011171959340572357, -0.02960609644651413, 0.02973571978509426, 0.012035578489303589, -0.015269693918526173, -0.0004358603328000754, 0.016047436743974686, -0.003512807423248887, 0.009520874358713627, 0.014790086075663567, 0.06501933932304382, -0.01469934917986393, -0.007751508615911007, -0.02300824038684368, -0.022723067551851273, 0.04145371913909912, -0.018004758283495903, -0.048920053988695145, -0.01600855030119419, -0.014025304466485977, 0.019573207944631577, -0.0031644431874156, -0.014958596788346767, -0.02378598414361477, -0.007686696480959654, 0.017499225214123726, -0.005278932861983776, 0.017991796135902405, -0.0011795774335041642, 0.02182866260409355, -0.007051539607346058, 0.017499225214123726, 0.003914641682058573, 0.006497397553175688, 0.0002687670348677784, -0.005596511531621218, -0.00921625830233097, 0.025600718334317207, -0.0014841934898868203, -0.047312717884778976, 0.020571311935782433, 0.004857655148953199, -0.00395028805360198, -0.037487227469682693, -0.02147867903113365, -0.018393630161881447, 0.023319337517023087, -0.0063224053010344505, 0.022515669465065002, -0.03634653985500336, 0.020221326500177383, -0.000022139862267067656, -0.012942945584654808, 0.0007919209310784936, -0.01063564047217369, -0.002916537458077073, 0.02440817840397358, -0.0059691802598536015, 0.00124357920140028, 0.010927293449640274, 0.0009640776552259922, -0.03139490634202957, -0.019223222509026527, 0.00778391445055604, 0.04215369001030922, -0.030124591663479805, -0.023565623909235, 0.00046948151430115104, -0.03022829070687294, -0.06024918332695961, -0.008535733446478844, 0.002770710736513138, 0.02593773975968361, 0.009060709737241268, 0.010629158467054367, 0.03860199451446533, 0.0015959941083565354, -0.03735760599374771, 0.003678077831864357, 0.058952946215867996, 0.005593270994722843, -0.009559761732816696, 0.0037558521144092083, 0.05750115588307381, 0.005745579022914171, 0.010726376436650753, 0.034557729959487915, 0.018315855413675308, 0.02246382087469101, -0.011828179471194744, -0.00679229199886322, 0.010804151184856892, 0.019443582743406296, 0.007725583855062723, 0.01926211081445217, -0.019650980830192566, 0.02898390218615532, -0.006947840563952923, 0.014893785119056702, 0.0007011842099018395, 0.048842281103134155, 0.0005715603474527597, 0.009689386002719402, 0.012664253823459148, -0.02163422666490078, 0.02225642092525959, -0.06579708307981491, -0.008762574754655361, 0.056671563535928726, 0.009099597111344337, 0.0015830317279323936, 0.03204302489757538, 0.044694315642118454, -0.027506189420819283, 0.01817326992750168, -0.002673492766916752, -0.00877553690224886, 0.011115248315036297, 0.015451167710125446, -0.006474713329225779, -0.016384460031986237, -0.016889993101358414, 0.010648602619767189, -0.006954321637749672, -0.019793568179011345, 0.01348088402301073, 0.020545385777950287, -0.00045206330833025277, -0.0018325577257201076, -0.006442307494580746, -0.031654153019189835, 0.011452270671725273, -0.009034785442054272, 0.03383183479309082, -0.04145371913909912, 0.049957048147916794, -0.03022829070687294, -0.09182555973529816, -0.017252938821911812, -0.021193506196141243, 0.035179924219846725, -0.00442017475143075, 0.047183096408843994, 0.02911352552473545, 0.018289931118488312, 0.014466025866568089, -0.01879546418786049, -0.025185922160744667, -0.051953256130218506, -0.0034188299905508757, 0.007187644485384226, 0.03225042298436165, -0.00922273937612772, 0.00863295141607523, 0.009391251020133495, -0.0017483022529631853, -0.0022748992778360844, -0.0015611577546223998, 0.006192781496793032, -0.003665115451440215, 0.014932672493159771, 0.010953218676149845, -0.008334816433489323, -0.009391251020133495, -0.0068700662814080715, 0.02919130027294159, 0.00010805366036947817, 0.014193816110491753, -0.03479105234146118, -0.0025244252756237984, 0.024006344377994537, -0.010408798232674599, -0.06258241087198257, 0.009520874358713627, 0.036631710827350616, -0.058330751955509186, 0.02696176804602146, 0.0033021685667335987, -0.010791189037263393, 0.04547205939888954, 0.02149164117872715, 0.02716916799545288, -0.03427255526185036, 0.021608302369713783, 0.01685110479593277, 0.034842900931835175, -0.0064099011942744255, 0.003956769127398729, 0.022100873291492462, 0.0011180060682818294, -0.01698072999715805, -0.022411970421671867, 0.02773951180279255, 0.01968986913561821, -0.02906167507171631, -0.006633502431213856, 0.003878994844853878, -0.012366118840873241, -0.014401214197278023, -0.021180544048547745, -0.02260640636086464, -0.036631710827350616, -0.013623470440506935, -0.047883063554763794, 0.015930775552988052, -0.033805910497903824, -0.03818719834089279, 0.00505857216194272, 0.029424622654914856, 0.019534319639205933, 0.05361244082450867, -0.02538035809993744, -0.0037331681232899427, -0.05843444913625717, 0.01683814264833927, -0.06092322617769241, 0.0162937231361866, -0.023876721039414406, -0.015347468666732311, 0.008470920845866203, -0.022165685892105103, 0.024628538638353348, 0.016902955248951912, 0.003200089791789651, -0.025885891169309616, 0.0038401077035814524, 0.0008846830460242927, 0.014919709414243698, 0.016877030953764915, 0.03263929486274719, 0.014673423953354359, 0.0003378322580829263, 0.012100390158593655, 0.016254834830760956, -0.026987694203853607, -0.028957976028323174, 0.0097023481503129, -0.002522805007174611, -0.02316378988325596, -0.00966994185000658, -0.021880513057112694, 0.00949495006352663, -0.034142933785915375, 0.0017288585659116507, -0.019910229369997978, 0.015840038657188416, -0.0038530700840055943, 0.021387942135334015, -0.017356637865304947, -0.01466046180576086, 0.04373510181903839, 0.05630861595273018, 0.008989416994154453, -0.0007611352484673262, 0.048142313957214355, 0.03152453154325485, -0.009410694241523743, 0.005071534775197506, -0.03925011307001114, -0.04969779774546623, 0.005632157903164625, 0.005184955429285765, -0.006993209011852741, 0.013092013075947762, -0.008581101894378662, -0.02573034167289734, 0.0034577171318233013, -0.005356707144528627, -0.01580115221440792, 0.009844934567809105, -0.01015603169798851, 0.019288035109639168, -0.059523288160562515, -0.006746923550963402, 0.0631009116768837, 0.009397732093930244, 0.03849829360842705, -0.006954321637749672, 0.008969972841441631, 0.02989126928150654, 0.009170889854431152, -0.006124728824943304, 0.0020075500942766666, 0.017641810700297356, -0.07093019038438797, 0.029787570238113403, -0.00859406404197216, 0.030383840203285217, 0.004024821799248457, -0.0039632502011954784, 0.015503017231822014, -0.012910539284348488, -0.02619698829948902, 0.02885427698493004, 0.01060971524566412, -0.012994795106351376, 0.033391114324331284, 0.044123973697423935, 0.02058427408337593, -0.014129003509879112, -0.025354431942105293, 0.02544516883790493, 0.013441997580230236, -0.015827076509594917, 0.010052332654595375, -0.013908643275499344, -0.004079911857843399, -0.0402093306183815, -0.052860621362924576, 0.022969353944063187, 0.0021987452637404203, -0.01057082787156105, 0.00839314702898264, 0.027480265125632286, 0.018069570884108543, -0.003859551390632987, 0.006001586094498634, -0.019093599170446396, 0.01996207982301712, -0.03528362140059471, 0.023098977282643318, 0.010525459423661232, -0.002072361996397376, -0.011374495923519135, 0.021193506196141243, -0.005807150155305862, 0.044072121381759644, -0.011530044488608837, 0.018471404910087585, -0.02509518526494503, 0.016799256205558777, 0.003960009664297104, 0.0298134945333004, 0.008153342641890049, 0.027195092290639877, 0.01914544776082039, -0.00987733993679285, 0.013247561641037464, 0.012139277532696724, -0.0014777122996747494, -0.012055021710693836, 0.009721791371703148, -0.015191920101642609, 0.01747330091893673, -0.03292446956038475, -0.035802118480205536, -0.04663867503404617, 0.014517875388264656, 0.011828179471194744, 0.028128383681178093, -0.0022878616582602262, 0.05490867793560028, -0.019249146804213524, 0.044616542756557465, -0.020687973126769066, -0.0630490630865097, -0.027350639924407005, 0.027480265125632286, -0.057241909205913544, -0.007479298394173384, 0.00248715840280056, -0.008509808219969273, 0.024434102699160576, -0.01787513494491577, 0.002880890853703022, 0.009235702455043793, 0.017252938821911812, 0.016514083370566368, 0.036502085626125336, -0.008710725232958794, -0.015295619145035744, -0.06398235261440277, -0.0007149567827582359, 0.017680699005723, 0.005904368124902248, -0.0023785983212292194, 0.04140187054872513, 0.028828352689743042, -0.019028786569833755, 0.02578219212591648, -0.000488520017825067, -0.019054710865020752, 0.0008960251579992473, 0.023591548204421997, -0.024861861020326614, -0.012301307171583176, -0.007265418767929077, -0.03043568879365921, 0.029087601229548454, -0.0235785860568285, -0.011154135689139366, -0.010447685606777668, 0.025911815464496613, 0.009786603972315788, 0.008043162524700165, 0.0034317923709750175, -0.01615113578736782, 0.009631055407226086, 0.013571620918810368, -0.008120936341583729, -0.017512187361717224, -0.017654772847890854, 0.01607336290180683, -0.005126624833792448, 0.04650904983282089, 0.004809046164155006, -0.003642431227490306, 0.018704727292060852, -0.027013618499040604, 0.03725390508770943, 0.0035841006319969893, -0.011186541989445686, -0.006947840563952923, 0.027091393247246742, 0.0026718724984675646, 0.01857510395348072, 0.005962698720395565, -0.048971906304359436, -0.014466025866568089, -0.013182749971747398, -0.015269693918526173, 0.0311875082552433, -0.016591858118772507, -0.009274588897824287, 0.011672630906105042, 0.002986210398375988, -0.006614058744162321, -0.006993209011852741, 0.03554287180304527, 0.02136201784014702, 0.0003402627189643681, 0.008691282011568546, -0.03002089262008667, -0.0034382736776024103, 0.022230496630072594, 0.014504913240671158, -0.01678629405796528, 0.013390148058533669, 0.02155645191669464, 0.009747716598212719, -0.018756575882434845, -0.021647188812494278, -0.027920985594391823, -0.0360354408621788, -0.0034479955211281776, -0.04484986513853073, -0.006332126911729574, 0.004319716244935989, 0.040313027799129486, -0.00247905682772398, 0.01105691771954298, 0.010784707963466644, 0.024291517212986946, -0.015930775552988052, 0.007958906702697277, 0.012333713471889496, -0.02032502554357052, -0.02732471562922001, -0.017512187361717224, 0.007621884811669588, -0.0064585101790726185, -0.05187547951936722, -0.023747095838189125, 0.0028355226386338472, -0.00589140597730875, 0.04083152487874031, 0.02295638993382454, 0.012437412515282631, 0.042049989104270935, 0.015243769623339176, -0.032405972480773926, -0.02932092361152172, 0.014738236553966999, 0.015904851257801056, 0.017849208787083626, -0.0010961319785565138, 0.004796084016561508, 0.0003475540434010327, 0.0024774365592747927, -0.0083153722807765, 0.016902955248951912, -0.01397345494478941, 0.024771125987172127, -0.015101183205842972, -0.027635812759399414, -0.0028549660928547382, -0.05083848908543587, 0.08155935257673264, -0.02820615842938423, -0.006231668405234814, -0.011737443506717682, 0.01573633961379528, -0.006947840563952923, 0.013908643275499344, 0.018328817561268806, -0.03030606545507908, 0.00333781517110765, 0.0007481728680431843, 0.013124418444931507, 0.01084951963275671, 0.024939635768532753, 0.02836170606315136, -0.022645292803645134, -0.020013928413391113, 0.03805757313966751, -0.011154135689139366, -0.007524666842073202, 0.009397732093930244, -0.025341469794511795, -0.017006654292345047, 0.02372117154300213, 0.00440397160127759, -0.03756500408053398, 0.015243769623339176, 0.015256731770932674, -0.00974123552441597, 0.027221016585826874, -0.02197124995291233, 0.016825180500745773, -0.0052108801901340485, 0.010084738954901695, -0.01996207982301712, 0.012968869879841805, -0.01648815907537937, 0.027402490377426147, 0.0012929983204230666, 0.021932361647486687, 0.027506189420819283, 0.03489474952220917, -0.0067728483118116856, 0.006633502431213856, -0.01310497522354126, -0.010804151184856892, -0.012093909084796906, 0.022424932569265366, -0.011549488641321659, 0.005654842127114534, -0.02869872935116291, -0.026883995160460472, 0.045109111815690994, 0.009747716598212719, 0.005680766887962818, 0.009151446633040905, 0.015619678422808647, 0.016902955248951912, 0.011102286167442799, -0.030124591663479805, -0.0457572340965271, 0.0024288275744765997, -0.06263426691293716, 0.030539387837052345, 0.002798255765810609, 0.022100873291492462, 0.02051946148276329, 0.021932361647486687, -0.01265129167586565, -0.01011714432388544, 0.029994968324899673, 0.02633957378566265, -0.004847933538258076, 0.038576070219278336, -0.019741717725992203, -0.0026864551473408937, -0.02890612743794918, 0.034765128046274185, -0.047805290669202805, -0.013338298536837101, -0.01154300756752491, -0.008950529620051384, 0.0267025213688612, 0.025743303820490837, -0.022995278239250183, 0.008918123319745064, 0.017486263066530228, -0.01760292425751686, -0.01559375412762165, 0.03113565780222416, -0.010065294802188873, 0.005638638976961374, 0.030409764498472214, 0.0004476074827834964, 0.002459613373503089, -0.0039794533513486385, -0.025004448369145393, 0.02337118797004223, 0.01379198208451271, 0.02773951180279255, 0.00921625830233097, 0.010013445280492306, 0.0190676748752594, -0.014141966588795185, 0.016345571726560593, 0.013740132562816143, -0.002381838858127594, -0.023565623909235, -0.021789776161313057, -0.01594373770058155, 0.032483745366334915, 0.026676597073674202, 0.002133933361619711, 0.02211383543908596, -0.013934568502008915, 0.030331989750266075, 0.015230806544423103, -0.013364222832024097, 0.0055641052313148975, -0.03077271208167076, 0.006367773748934269, 0.01331237331032753, -0.001933016232214868, 0.02329341322183609, -0.0032875859178602695, -0.04720902070403099, -0.021737925708293915, 0.024654462933540344, 0.02155645191669464, -0.015503017231822014, -0.01399938017129898, -0.01397345494478941, -0.0037720552645623684, 0.00852277036756277, -0.002242493210360408, -0.02011762745678425, 0.0034836421255022287, -0.01892508752644062, 0.024926673620939255, -0.004452580586075783, 0.0008579480927437544, -0.005152549594640732, -0.019171373918652534, -0.03971675783395767, 0.020700935274362564, 0.001184438238851726, 0.0039632502011954784, 0.030669013038277626, 0.020986108109354973, -0.01781032234430313, -0.03554287180304527, -0.010972661897540092, -0.007485779467970133, -0.004115558695048094, -0.002791774459183216, 0.011763367801904678, -0.02147867903113365, -0.015995588153600693, 0.0011876788921654224, 0.012975350953638554, -0.007757989689707756, 0.012729065492749214, -0.010104182176291943, -0.002929499838501215, 0.03160230442881584, -0.012942945584654808, -0.02593773975968361, 0.01331237331032753, -0.017149239778518677, -0.023682285100221634, -0.014323439449071884, -0.007271900307387114, -0.012871651910245419, -0.022165685892105103, -0.03909456357359886, -0.013377184979617596, -0.02619698829948902, -0.00973475445061922, -0.008535733446478844, 0.029865344986319542, 0.01933988370001316, -0.03984638303518295, 0.017317751422524452, -0.030539387837052345, -0.016617782413959503, 0.009319957345724106, -0.025341469794511795, 0.01678629405796528, 0.045316509902477264, -0.013506809249520302, 0.01358458399772644, -0.02849133126437664, -0.0036132659297436476, 0.00020122082787565887, 0.0054117972031235695, 0.027817286550998688, -0.005346985533833504, -0.01622891053557396, 0.018562141805887222, 0.012145758606493473, -0.03730575367808342, -0.04529058560729027, 0.028932051733136177, -0.034713275730609894, -0.018108457326889038, 0.012061502784490585, 0.007615403272211552, 0.018419554457068443, 0.00001099397923098877, -0.0042775883339345455, 0.012528148479759693, -0.00003055781780858524, -0.016721481457352638, 0.02557479403913021, 0.012547592632472515, -0.006455269642174244, -0.006435825955122709, 0.007913538254797459, -0.011640225537121296, -0.0090088602155447, 0.04033895581960678, -0.0013983177486807108, -0.012178163975477219, 0.006115006748586893, 0.012106871232390404, -0.009929189458489418, 0.048557110130786896, 0.0010094459867104888, 0.030072743073105812, 0.003357258625328541, -0.0048641362227499485, -0.04684607312083244, -0.008892199024558067, -0.023345261812210083, 0.020700935274362564, 0.019715793430805206, -0.02147867903113365, 0.010512497276067734, -0.024524839594960213, -0.025069260969758034, 0.005541421473026276, 0.0035776193253695965, 0.015088221058249474, -0.007809839211404324, 0.022061986848711967, 0.023487849161028862, -0.0029068156145513058, 0.014077153988182545, -0.018808426335453987, -0.017084429040551186, 0.005146068520843983, 0.03160230442881584, 0.04285365715622902, 0.005249767564237118, -0.0067080361768603325, -0.02232123352587223, -0.01494563464075327, -0.04189443960785866, 0.0008020478417165577, 0.0007400714093819261, -0.02468038909137249, 0.015632640570402145, 0.01580115221440792, 0.010862481780350208, 0.015230806544423103, 0.00880146212875843, -0.03243189677596092, -0.002508222358301282, -0.017564037814736366, -0.016112249344587326, -0.018004758283495903, -0.012541111558675766, 0.014543800614774227, 0.012722584418952465, 0.016514083370566368, 0.004779880866408348, -0.0017564037116244435, -0.0015068777138367295, 0.01838066801428795, -0.009138484485447407, 0.013740132562816143, -0.00372668681666255, 0.03222449868917465, -0.01586596481502056, -0.015217844396829605, -0.019158409908413887, -0.043994348496198654, -0.012839246541261673, -0.013701245188713074, 0.02675436995923519, 0.026041438803076744, 0.001980004832148552, -0.004744234494864941, -0.0325874462723732, -0.017706623300909996, -0.010700452141463757, 0.006818216759711504, -0.005930292885750532, -0.0029829698614776134, -0.015347468666732311, -0.008069086819887161, 0.021050918847322464, -0.020402800291776657, 0.0024887786712497473, 0.014816010370850563, -0.011808736249804497, -0.01102451141923666, -0.005327541846781969, 0.006254352629184723, 0.008697763085365295, -0.0022635571658611298, -0.007945944555103779, -0.007200607098639011, 0.0001495738106314093, -0.013947530649602413, 0.02191939949989319, -0.009624573402106762, 0.05636046826839447, -0.00807556789368391, 0.00904126651585102, -0.03562064468860626, -0.003947047516703606, 0.016669632866978645, -0.016812218353152275, 0.02732471562922001, 0.0339873842895031, 0.007278381381183863, 0.004494708497077227, -0.017732547596096992, -0.0074663362465798855, 0.022541593760252, -0.04982742294669151, -0.01670851930975914, -0.005116903223097324, -0.03297631815075874, 0.004838211461901665, 0.016902955248951912, 0.01043472345918417, -0.027506189420819283, -0.048349712044000626, 0.006960802711546421, -0.015165994875133038, 0.007135794963687658, -0.006533043924719095, -0.026508085429668427, -0.01348088402301073, 0.006837659981101751, -0.00542800035327673, -0.0346873514354229, -0.00998752098530531, 0.039898231625556946, 0.020091703161597252, -0.02453780174255371, -0.012735547497868538, 0.024576690047979355, -0.0429832823574543, 0.016164099797606468, -0.03499845042824745, -0.0017823284724727273, -0.007654290646314621, -0.016527045518159866, 0.010441204532980919, -0.002064260421320796, -0.013390148058533669, -0.005755300633609295, 0.009345882572233677, 0.01857510395348072, -0.023280451074242592, -0.0031190747395157814, 0.01775847189128399, 0.008730169385671616, 0.000786655000410974, -0.0022538353223353624, 0.0010985624976456165, -0.002347812755033374, -0.030072743073105812, 0.03367628529667854, 0.024848898872733116, 0.020143551751971245, 0.0071682012639939785, 0.029865344986319542, -0.0067663672380149364, -0.004290550947189331, -0.020610198378562927, 0.01873065158724785, 0.02579515427350998, -0.005223842803388834, 0.023254524916410446, -0.009319957345724106 ]
11.264778
7.78936
2024-07-01
4
2024A&A...687A.115B
[ "galaxy discs", "gas discs", "≲ z ≲", "Instability criteria", "galaxies", "discs", "gas turbulence", "star formation", "cold gas", "stars" ]
[ "instabilities", "ISM: kinematics and dynamics", "ISM: structure", "galaxies: high-redshift", "galaxies: irregular", "galaxies: spiral", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
60
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202449925", "10.48550/arXiv.2405.00103" ]
[ "Bacchini, C.", "Nipoti, C.", "Iorio, G.", "Roman-Oliveira, F.", "Rizzo, F.", "Mancera Piña, P. E.", "Marasco, A.", "Zanella, A.", "Lelli, F." ]
[ "DARK, Niels Bohr Institute, University of Copenhagen, Jagtvej 155, 2200, Copenhagen, Denmark ; INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova, vicolo dell'Osservatorio 5, 35122, Padova, Italy", "Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia \"Augusto Righi\", Università di Bologna, Via Gobetti 93/2, 40129, Bologna, Italy", "INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova, vicolo dell'Osservatorio 5, 35122, Padova, Italy; Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia \"Galileo Galilei\", Università di Padova, Vicolo dell'Osservatorio 3, 35122, Padova, Italy; INFN - Padova, Via Marzolo 8, 35131, Padova, Italy", "Kapteyn Astronomical Institute, University of Groningen, Landleven 12, 9747 AD, Groningen, The Netherlands", "Cosmic Dawn Center (DAWN), University of Copenhagen, Jagtvej 155, 2200, Copenhagen, Denmark; Niels Bohr Institute, University of Copenhagen, Jagtvej 128, 2200, Copenhagen, Denmark", "Leiden Observatory, Leiden University, PO Box 9513, 2300 RA, Leiden, The Netherlands", "INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova, vicolo dell'Osservatorio 5, 35122, Padova, Italy", "INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova, vicolo dell'Osservatorio 5, 35122, Padova, Italy", "INAF - Arcetri Astrophysical Observatory, Largo Enrico Fermi 5, 50125, Firenze, Italy" ]
[ "2024arXiv240406537M", "2024arXiv240506025R", "2024arXiv240513123N", "2024arXiv240706261R" ]
[ "1948AnAp...11..247D", "1959ApJ...129..243S", "1960AnAp...23..979S", "1961hhs..book.....C", "1963BAAA....6...41S", "1964ApJ...139.1217T", "1964ApJ...140..646L", "1965MNRAS.130...97G", "1966PNAS...55..229L", "1970ApJ...161...67V", "1970ApJ...162..453V", "1973ApJ...186..467O", "1973MNRAS.163..163W", "1974ApJ...193..309R", "1975SvA....19..189G", "1978ApJ...221...51L", "1981A&A....95..105V", "1981MNRAS.194..809L", "1982A&A...106..274B", "1984ApJ...276..114J", "1985ApJ...295..305V", "1987PhDT.......209B", "1989A&A...223...47B", "1989ApJ...344..685K", "1991MNRAS.249..523B", "1992MNRAS.256..307R", "1994A&A...286..799R", "1996ApJ...462..563N", "1996ApJS..107....1A", "1997A&A...321..111P", "1997A&A...326..554C", "1997ApJ...481..703S", "1998ApJ...493..595H", "1998ApJ...498..541K", "1998ApJ...499..112B", "1999A&A...352..447C", "1999MNRAS.309..481L", "2000A&A...353..873M", "2001A&A...368..107F", "2001ApJ...547..792D", "2001ApJ...555..301M", "2002ApJ...577..197W", "2002ApJ...581.1080K", "2002MNRAS.330..591B", "2003ApJ...599.1157K", "2003MNRAS.346.1215B", "2004ARA&A..42..211E", "2004ApJ...600L.139C", "2004RvMP...76..125M", "2005A&A...440..775K", "2005ApJ...625..763L", "2005ApJ...627..632E", "2005MNRAS.356..107R", "2005MNRAS.362..197T", "2007ApJ...670..237B", "2008A&A...486..741B", "2008A&A...490..555B", "2008ARep...52..257A", "2008ApJ...673..864J", "2008ApJ...687...59G", "2008MNRAS.383..809B", "2008gady.book.....B", "2009A&A...493..899P", "2009ApJ...692...12E", "2009ApJ...693.1346K", "2009ApJ...703..785D", "2009MNRAS.392..945V", "2009MNRAS.395.1905C", "2009MNRAS.397L..64A", "2010A&A...512A..17B", "2010A&A...515A..62O", "2010ApJ...716.1191W", "2010ApJ...721..975O", "2010ApJ...724..895K", "2010MNRAS.404.2151C", "2010MNRAS.404L..60R", "2010MNRAS.407..705W", "2010MNRAS.407.1223R", "2011ApJ...733..101G", "2011ApJ...737...10E", "2011ApJ...743...25K", "2011MNRAS.414.2446M", "2011MNRAS.415..687B", "2011MNRAS.416.1191R", "2012ApJ...745...11G", "2012ApJ...754...98B", "2012ApJ...760...11H", "2012MNRAS.421..818C", "2012MNRAS.422..600G", "2013A&A...554A.103P", "2013ARA&A..51..105C", "2013ARA&A..51..207B", "2013ApJ...773...88S", "2013ApJ...776....1K", "2013ApJ...777....5S", "2013MNRAS.433.1389R", "2013MNRAS.433.1970F", "2013PASA...30...56G", "2014A&A...565A..59D", "2014A&A...566A..71L", "2014ARA&A..52..291C", "2014ApJ...785...75G", "2014MNRAS.437.1070G", "2014MNRAS.442.1230R", "2014MNRAS.443.3675M", "2014MNRAS.445.1412Z", "2014Msngr.156...38B", "2014Natur.506..171P", "2015ApJ...798L..45V", "2015ApJ...799..209W", "2015ApJ...800...39G", "2015ApJ...801...25L", "2015ApJ...805..145E", "2015ApJ...806L..17S", "2015ApJ...809L..21M", "2015ApJ...814L..30E", "2015MNRAS.448.1007B", "2015MNRAS.449.2156A", "2015MNRAS.449.2883G", "2015MNRAS.450.2327Z", "2015MNRAS.451.3021D", "2015MNRAS.451.3107R", "2015MNRAS.453.2490T", "2015Natur.521...54Z", "2016ARA&A..54..271K", "2016ApJ...819L...2B", "2016ApJ...821...72S", "2016ApJ...827...34O", "2016ApJ...830...14S", "2016ApJ...831...78M", "2016ApJ...833..103H", "2016MNRAS.456.2052I", "2016MNRAS.457.1888S", "2016MNRAS.459.2573R", "2016MNRAS.460.2360R", "2016MNRAS.462.3628R", "2017A&A...604A.117C", "2017A&A...605A..55A", "2017A&A...607A.106M", "2017ApJ...836L..22D", "2017MNRAS.464...32P", "2017MNRAS.464..491F", "2017MNRAS.464..635M", "2017MNRAS.465...76M", "2017MNRAS.465..952O", "2017MNRAS.466.4159I", "2017MNRAS.467.2019R", "2017MNRAS.468.4792T", "2017MNRAS.469..286R", "2017MNRAS.472.3761N", "2017Natur.543..397G", "2018A&A...609A.130L", "2018A&A...619A..15G", "2018A&A...620A..60C", "2018ApJ...853..108G", "2018ApJ...859...12G", "2018ApJS..238...21F", "2018MNRAS.474.5076J", "2018MNRAS.475.4891M", "2018MNRAS.476.3591M", "2018MNRAS.477.2716K", "2018MNRAS.477.5554W", "2018MNRAS.481.1976Z", "2018MNRAS.481.5606R", "2018NatAs...2...76C", "2018Natur.560..613T", "2019A&A...622A..64B", "2019A&A...631A..91G", "2019A&A...632A.127B", "2019ApJ...870...46F", "2019ApJ...870...80L", "2019ApJ...871...17U", "2019ApJ...876..130H", "2019ApJ...880...48U", "2019ApJ...882..107R", "2019ApJS..244...40L", "2019MNRAS.483.1496S", "2019MNRAS.484...81P", "2019MNRAS.485.1036M", "2019MNRAS.489.2792Z", "2019NatAs...3.1115D", "2019igfe.book.....C", "2020A&A...641A..70B", "2020A&A...643A.141M", "2020A&A...644A.125B", "2020ApJ...893..135M", "2020MNRAS.491.4843R", "2020MNRAS.495.2867P", "2020MNRAS.495L...1I", "2020MNRAS.499.2063P", "2020Natur.581..269N", "2020Natur.584..201R", "2021A&A...645A.133R", "2021A&A...647A.194F", "2021ApJ...909...12G", "2021ApJ...909...84U", "2021ApJ...915...92T", "2021ApJ...922..147H", "2021ApJ...923..220D", "2021MNRAS.500..118Z", "2021MNRAS.500.3083C", "2021MNRAS.503.4878S", "2021MNRAS.507.3952R", "2021MNRAS.508..352R", "2021Sci...371..713L", "2022A&A...663A.152L", "2022ARA&A..60..247W", "2022ApJ...927...21W", "2022ApJ...928..143E", "2022ApJ...928..169F", "2022ApJ...929...92V", "2022ApJ...929L...3S", "2022ApJ...930..128R", "2022ApJ...936..137O", "2022ApJ...937...88M", "2022ApJ...939..101K", "2022ApJ...939L...1V", "2022ApJS..261...31B", "2022MNRAS.512.1781A", "2022MNRAS.512.3230M", "2022MNRAS.514.3329M", "2022MNRAS.514.4008S", "2022MNRAS.516.3532M", "2022MNRAS.517..962D", "2022MNRAS.517.5930S", "2023A&A...670A..92M", "2023A&A...672A.106L", "2023A&A...679A.129R", "2023ApJ...942...98L", "2023ApJ...945L..19S", "2023IAUS..373...93E", "2023MNRAS.518.5154N", "2023MNRAS.519.1526P", "2023MNRAS.519.6222D", "2023MNRAS.520.2180C", "2023MNRAS.521.1045R", "2023MNRAS.522.2543A", "2023MNRAS.523.4654T", "2023MNRAS.524.3913P", "2023MNRAS.525.4270W", "2023Natur.618..708S", "2024A&A...685A..48H", "2024A&A...685A..80Z", "2024A&A...686A..63G", "2024A&A...687A..35R", "2024ApJ...960...25K", "2024ApJ...967...11C", "2024MNRAS.527.2691Z", "2024MNRAS.52710201E", "2024MNRAS.529.2162M", "2024arXiv240208911N", "2024arXiv240217004H", "2024arXiv240218543F" ]
29162990
2404.10823
The CAVITY project: The spatially resolved stellar population properties of galaxies in voids
The Universe is shaped as a web-like structure, formed by clusters, filaments, and walls that leave large low number-density volumes in between named voids. Galaxies in voids have been found to be of a later type, bluer, less massive, and to have a slower evolution than galaxies in denser environments (filaments and walls). However, the effect of the void environment on their stellar population properties is still unclear. We aim to address this question using 118 optical integral field unit datacubes from the Calar Alto Void Integral-field Treasury surveY (CAVITY), observed with the PMAS/PPaK spectrograph at the 3.5 m telescope at the Calar Alto Observatory (Almería, Spain). We fitted their spectra from 3750 Å to 7000 Å with the non-parametric full spectral fitting code STARLIGHT to estimate their stellar population properties: stellar mass, stellar mass surface density, age, star formation rate (SFR), and specific star formation rate (sSFR). We analysed the results through the global properties, assessing the behaviour of the whole galaxy, and the spatially resolved information, by obtaining the radial profiles from the 2D maps up to the 2 half-light radius of each stellar population property. The results were examined with respect to their morphological type and stellar mass. Then, we compared them with a control sample of galaxies in filaments and walls, selected from the CALIFA survey and analysed following the same procedure. To make a fair comparison between the samples, we selected a twin filament galaxy for each void galaxy of the same morphological type and closest stellar mass, to match the void galaxy sample as much as possible in morphology and mass. Key findings from our global and spatially resolved analysis include void galaxies having a slightly higher half-light radius (HLR), lower stellar mass surface density, and younger ages across all morphological types, and slightly elevated SFR and sSFR (only significant enough for Sas). Many of these differences appear in the outer parts of spiral galaxies (HLR &gt; 1), where discs are younger and exhibit a higher sSFR compared to galaxies in filaments and walls, indicative of less evolved discs. This trend is also found for early-type spirals, suggesting a slower transition from star-forming to quiescent states in voids. Our analysis indicates that void galaxies, influenced by their surroundings, undergo a more gradual evolution, especially in their outer regions, with a more pronounced effect for low-mass galaxies. We find that below a certain mass threshold, environmental processes play a more influential role in galactic evolution.
[ 0.009046655148267746, 0.022792058065533638, 0.0325278639793396, -0.004626700188964605, 0.024007467553019524, 0.0086018405854702, 0.010299654677510262, -0.029620904475450516, 0.0016242003766819835, 0.02791682630777359, -0.016928020864725113, -0.016965610906481743, -0.03761504217982292, -0.0035898431669920683, 0.028543325141072273, 0.028192486613988876, -0.009209545329213142, 0.02386963739991188, 0.007937750779092312, 0.015825381502509117, 0.012229274027049541, -0.023443618789315224, -0.03776540234684944, 0.06445428729057312, -0.07352600246667862, -0.029169825837016106, -0.013582512736320496, 0.07964064180850983, 0.004811517428606749, 0.012367104180157185, 0.008514130488038063, -0.025536127388477325, -0.01429672259837389, -0.00895894505083561, -0.08009172230958939, 0.08811091631650925, 0.042927756905555725, 0.03079872392117977, 0.0018168491078540683, -0.01775500178337097, -0.013582512736320496, 0.0036806855350732803, 0.014472142793238163, -0.004795854911208153, 0.009046655148267746, 0.004764529876410961, -0.0029351511038839817, -0.011834578588604927, 0.003235870972275734, 0.019396429881453514, -0.047313254326581955, 0.008025460876524448, 0.03488350287079811, -0.031500402837991714, 0.00023630785290151834, 0.006872701458632946, -0.02616262622177601, -0.04250174015760422, -0.026112506166100502, -0.002863103523850441, -0.013018663041293621, 0.018155960366129875, 0.02754092589020729, -0.009222075343132019, 0.023142898455262184, 0.0035083983093500137, -0.03723914176225662, 0.03358038142323494, 0.028493205085396767, 0.052225012332201004, -0.010337244719266891, -0.010168089531362057, 0.007248601410537958, 0.032803524285554886, -0.01645188219845295, -0.010807119309902191, 0.039143700152635574, -0.03686324134469032, -0.028418025001883507, 0.031575582921504974, 0.006039456930011511, 0.004507665056735277, -0.019609440118074417, 0.041273798793554306, 0.005723074544221163, 0.0023368438705801964, -0.0010932419681921601, -0.022090379148721695, -0.023218078538775444, 0.03443242236971855, 0.02507251687347889, -0.0005685484502464533, -0.04024634137749672, -0.009021595120429993, 0.014998402446508408, -0.019083179533481598, 0.008883765898644924, -0.03919382020831108, 0.04067235812544823, 0.0029743071645498276, -0.007962810806930065, 0.05242549255490303, 0.02716502547264099, -0.021050389856100082, 0.03300400450825691, -0.004125500563532114, -0.003285990795120597, -0.013757932931184769, -0.01705332100391388, -0.012266864068806171, 0.022453749552369118, 0.0230802483856678, -0.01630152203142643, 0.013833113014698029, -0.03237750381231308, 0.012943483889102936, -0.0651058480143547, 0.0074365511536598206, -0.002927319845184684, 0.0029210548382252455, 0.0011715544387698174, 0.01775500178337097, 0.017228741198778152, 0.016389232128858566, 0.040070921182632446, -0.019095709547400475, 0.027064787223935127, -0.04513303562998772, -0.06686004251241684, 0.005782592110335827, 0.034156762063503265, -0.009228340350091457, 0.02049906924366951, -0.032026663422584534, -0.07427780330181122, 0.04237644001841545, -0.016840310767292976, -0.007599441334605217, 0.009529059752821922, 0.024045057594776154, -0.027440685778856277, -0.011953613720834255, 0.023406028747558594, 0.02356891892850399, 0.04666169732809067, 0.011533859185874462, -0.02578672766685486, 0.029445484280586243, -0.010036525316536427, 0.02155158855021, -0.0018246803665533662, 0.023130368441343307, -0.0003545596555341035, -0.05014503374695778, -0.022203149273991585, -0.03829165920615196, 0.031951483339071274, 0.011941083706915379, -0.008858705870807171, -0.0028834647964686155, -0.03728926181793213, -0.0332796648144722, -0.005525727290660143, -0.0016946815885603428, -0.009303520433604717, -0.03601120039820671, 0.003965742886066437, 0.007756066042929888, -0.08866223692893982, -0.05084671452641487, 0.013845643028616905, -0.003586710663512349, -0.021651828661561012, -0.03473314270377159, 0.0007674621301703155, 0.016664892435073853, -0.008050520904362202, -0.07192216068506241, -0.0031293658539652824, -0.017567051574587822, 0.009936285205185413, 0.04538363590836525, 0.02079978957772255, -0.04388003796339035, -0.021263400092720985, 0.011508799158036709, -0.009040390141308308, 0.05212477222084999, -0.011233139783143997, 0.006941616535186768, -0.009084245190024376, 0.0028991273138672113, -0.0013242637505754828, 0.030046924948692322, -0.057086650282144547, -0.022904828190803528, 0.013720342889428139, 0.02200266905128956, -0.0347832627594471, 0.02177712880074978, 0.018669690936803818, 0.0001299007999477908, -0.012241804040968418, -0.05603413283824921, -0.006299454253166914, -0.034231942147016525, 0.030071984976530075, 0.033104244619607925, -0.02117568999528885, -0.002335277618840337, 0.03470808267593384, 0.021651828661561012, -0.01015555951744318, 0.02319301851093769, -0.030147165060043335, -0.009184485301375389, -0.025573717430233955, 0.05513197183609009, 0.0764329582452774, 0.023330848664045334, 0.021914958953857422, 0.06340176612138748, 0.01986004039645195, 0.035359643399715424, 0.032427623867988586, 0.019659560173749924, 0.010832179337739944, -0.01806825026869774, 0.012103973887860775, -0.01656465232372284, 0.04410557821393013, 0.04370461776852608, -0.06896508485078812, 0.007029326632618904, -0.02202772907912731, -0.03518422320485115, -0.009829780086874962, 0.061396967619657516, -0.0088962959125638, -0.023806987330317497, -0.03721408173441887, 0.00045460383989848197, -0.01788030005991459, 0.045659296214580536, -0.027340445667505264, 0.05119755491614342, -0.01208517886698246, -0.03240256384015083, 0.04598507657647133, -0.002011063974350691, 0.04623567685484886, -0.039218880236148834, -0.0036180356983095407, 0.0014033593470230699, -0.024608908221125603, 0.008608105592429638, -0.03576060011982918, 0.053077053278684616, -0.018870171159505844, -0.035058923065662384, -0.026262866333127022, -0.02383204735815525, -0.017629701644182205, 0.0268643070012331, -0.004147428087890148, 0.04673687741160393, 0.02708984538912773, -0.006684751715511084, -0.015436952002346516, 0.0008081846171990037, -0.016013331711292267, -0.045960016548633575, -0.008006665855646133, -0.04167475923895836, -0.042100779712200165, 0.03623674064874649, -0.03350520133972168, 0.023481208831071854, 0.03137510269880295, -0.004407425411045551, -0.028718745335936546, 0.034758202731609344, 0.029395364224910736, -0.008069315925240517, -0.006039456930011511, 0.03601120039820671, -0.0067411367781460285, 0.03743962198495865, -0.011026394553482533, -0.003567915642634034, 0.059342049062252045, -0.040070921182632446, 0.016013331711292267, 0.027866706252098083, -0.024345777928829193, -0.0019468477694317698, 0.021914958953857422, 0.018055720254778862, -0.043378837406635284, 0.03358038142323494, 0.029846444725990295, -0.009171955287456512, 0.02957078441977501, 0.0351591631770134, -0.015549722127616405, -0.022353509441018105, 0.014083713293075562, 0.025962145999073982, -0.03132498264312744, 0.030698483809828758, 0.03819141909480095, 0.018018130213022232, 0.003749600611627102, 0.03049800544977188, -0.054881371557712555, -0.02656358666718006, -0.015424421988427639, 0.028367904946208, 0.03160064294934273, -0.0559840127825737, -0.037038661539554596, -0.03185124322772026, 0.017529461532831192, 0.02754092589020729, 0.018519330769777298, -0.05182405561208725, 0.030247405171394348, -0.0166398324072361, -0.06059505045413971, 0.0005528859910555184, -0.017028260976076126, 0.0002821206289809197, 0.033630501478910446, -0.02428312785923481, -0.01795548014342785, -0.022942418232560158, 0.03185124322772026, 0.05778833106160164, 0.021914958953857422, -0.00041544760460965335, -0.019684620201587677, -0.008933885022997856, 0.007762331049889326, 0.03435724228620529, -0.01765476167201996, 0.023243138566613197, 0.037264201790094376, 0.034006401896476746, 0.06194828823208809, -0.014359372667968273, -0.013757932931184769, 0.009892430156469345, 0.03245268389582634, -0.026187686249613762, 0.03207678347826004, -0.05698641017079353, 0.04192535951733589, -0.0703684464097023, -0.012749268673360348, 0.02196507900953293, 0.03686324134469032, -0.03042282536625862, 0.023368438705801964, 0.04575953632593155, -0.0019264864968135953, 0.018456680700182915, -0.004626700188964605, 0.011013864539563656, -0.010901094414293766, -0.059492409229278564, -0.011634099297225475, 0.011377234011888504, -0.011189284734427929, 0.007668355945497751, -0.021539058536291122, -0.03643722087144852, 0.0018810653127729893, 0.030247405171394348, -0.020185818895697594, -0.0003138371976092458, 0.013219143263995647, 0.02068701945245266, 0.008445215411484241, -0.05703653022646904, 0.030999204143881798, 0.02383204735815525, -0.046185556799173355, -0.002651660004630685, -0.09958838671445847, 0.034307122230529785, 0.009077980183064938, 0.0016351641388610005, 0.006286924239248037, 0.04320341721177101, 0.026363106444478035, -0.06174780800938606, 0.01463503297418356, 0.04846601560711861, 0.018268730491399765, 0.039218880236148834, -0.006362104322761297, -0.01463503297418356, -0.023744337260723114, -0.023669157177209854, -0.046110376715660095, 0.02616262622177601, 0.02330578863620758, -0.0015498035354539752, 0.03443242236971855, -0.01884511113166809, 0.04132391884922981, -0.025498537346720695, 0.029069585725665092, -0.02814236655831337, -0.02106291987001896, 0.021338578313589096, -0.04107331857085228, 0.043754737824201584, -0.004589110147207975, 0.07523008435964584, -0.0021786526776850224, -0.01641429215669632, 0.0000620626233285293, -0.03124980442225933, -0.017516931518912315, 0.02806718647480011, -0.007893895730376244, 0.05287657305598259, -0.045408695936203, -0.07823728024959564, -0.02829272486269474, 0.027215145528316498, -0.014121302403509617, -0.021413758397102356, -0.017141031101346016, -0.07041856646537781, -0.010080380365252495, -0.02586190775036812, 0.004015862941741943, -0.04242656007409096, 0.017905360087752342, -0.023894697427749634, 0.002463710028678179, -0.0077498010359704494, 0.009259665384888649, 0.025122636929154396, 0.042777396738529205, 0.027365505695343018, 0.027039727196097374, -0.020925089716911316, 0.03638710081577301, -0.005011997651308775, 0.011082779616117477, 0.010919889435172081, -0.021075449883937836, -0.009992670267820358, -0.009353640489280224, -0.012636498548090458, -0.002206845209002495, -0.05538257211446762, -0.025912027806043625, -0.027290325611829758, -0.00561030488461256, 0.029019465669989586, -0.0025059988256543875, 0.0306233037263155, -0.0034112907014787197, 0.008200881071388721, 0.008739670738577843, -0.02588696777820587, 0.0291197057813406, -0.043153297156095505, 0.0054787397384643555, -0.018419090658426285, 0.017667291685938835, 0.003171654650941491, -0.0472881942987442, -0.018456680700182915, 0.05513197183609009, 0.04222607985138893, 0.057086650282144547, -0.01006158534437418, -0.0158880315721035, 0.0005575847462750971, 0.029971744865179062, 0.030046924948692322, -0.0253356471657753, 0.006816316395998001, 0.004144295584410429, -0.002783224917948246, -0.01686537079513073, -0.03307918459177017, 0.04643615707755089, -0.01227312907576561, 0.020887499675154686, -0.03834177926182747, -0.036963481456041336, 0.010970009490847588, -0.009591709822416306, 0.024233007803559303, 0.08610611408948898, 0.002462143776938319, 0.06024421006441116, 0.0005219525774009526, 0.02068701945245266, 0.010706879198551178, -0.03152546286582947, -0.018456680700182915, 0.007392696104943752, -0.018193550407886505, -0.009428820572793484, 0.047463614493608475, 0.01933377981185913, -0.004015862941741943, 0.01727886125445366, 0.010049055330455303, -0.023669157177209854, 0.011251933872699738, 0.016702482476830482, -0.035284463316202164, -0.007862570695579052, -0.027290325611829758, -0.018832581117749214, 0.005766929592937231, -0.0005462294211611152, 0.008733405731618404, -0.040346577763557434, -0.11266970634460449, -0.005237537436187267, -0.023844577372074127, -0.00457344762980938, -0.015649961307644844, 0.024721678346395493, 0.010080380365252495, -0.03147534281015396, -0.0202359389513731, -0.018782461062073708, -0.011997468769550323, 0.008645695634186268, -0.003962610382586718, 0.002994668437168002, -0.0019108239794149995, -0.016915490850806236, 0.013820583000779152, 0.013933353126049042, 0.05929192900657654, -0.010337244719266891, 0.0014119736151769757, 0.04463183879852295, 0.01746681146323681, 0.06851400434970856, -0.013519863598048687, 0.006362104322761297, 0.009334845468401909, -0.022015199065208435, 0.022766998037695885, -0.019834980368614197, -0.004777059890329838, 0.0026203349698334932, 0.01667742244899273, -0.029996804893016815, -0.011239403858780861, 0.0408477783203125, 0.05137297511100769, 0.029320186004042625, -0.048065055161714554, -0.003859238000586629, 0.0006727040163241327, -0.03728926181793213, 0.032502803951501846, -0.037940822541713715, 0.009027860127389431, 0.03197654336690903, -0.05347801372408867, 0.006553186569362879, -0.033780861645936966, -0.012956013903021812, 0.028192486613988876, -0.006929086521267891, -0.003021294716745615, -0.021376168355345726, -0.043754737824201584, -0.001343058655038476, 0.0012342043919488788, -0.021877368912100792, -0.0062117441557347775, 0.03613650053739548, -0.007248601410537958, 0.014108773320913315, -0.006615836638957262, 0.006020661909133196, -0.008100640960037708, 0.0054975347593426704, -0.012279394082725048, 0.02181471884250641, -0.02326819859445095, 0.020561719313263893, 0.021977609023451805, -0.029520664364099503, -0.007179686333984137, -0.00890256091952324, 0.02522287704050541, -0.020135700702667236, -0.007561851292848587, -0.006709811743348837, 0.03997068107128143, -0.011120369657874107, -0.012041323818266392, -0.009785925038158894, 0.007449081167578697, -0.028693685308098793, -0.0006041806191205978, -0.023092778399586678, -0.02588696777820587, 0.0032640632707625628, -0.006878966465592384, 0.012392163276672363, -0.006371501833200455, -0.013331913389265537, -0.012611438520252705, -0.015524662099778652, 0.023468678817152977, -0.005062117241322994, 0.022240739315748215, 0.05678592994809151, -0.012078913860023022, -0.008532925508916378, -0.02125087007880211, -0.00573247205466032, -0.011201814748346806, -0.007411491125822067, -0.02678912691771984, 0.035058923065662384, -0.000059566416894085705, -0.027891766279935837, -0.007398961111903191, 0.011408559046685696, 0.01727886125445366, -0.01667742244899273, -0.014309252612292767, 0.040346577763557434, 0.02196507900953293, 0.0332796648144722, -0.03034764528274536, 0.00006441200093831867, 0.02552359737455845, 0.00669728172942996, 0.010299654677510262, -0.04896721616387367, -0.0008183651953004301, 0.025022396817803383, -0.019509200006723404, -0.010437484830617905, 0.007311251480132341, 0.02586190775036812, -0.021000269800424576, 0.0018810653127729893, 0.0051435623317956924, -0.03500880300998688, 0.01509864255785942, 0.003417555708438158, -0.012423488311469555, 0.008069315925240517, 0.0030087647028267384, -0.021351108327507973, -0.015549722127616405, 0.008695815689861774, 0.017003200948238373, -0.017115971073508263, 0.03230232372879982, 0.06565716862678528, 0.00437610037624836, 0.007104506250470877, 0.01577526144683361, -0.01422154251486063, -0.016138631850481033, 0.02274193800985813, -0.03616156056523323, -0.02140122838318348, 0.012811918742954731, 0.005604039877653122, 0.02428312785923481, -0.00763703091070056, 0.003859238000586629, -0.01978486031293869, 0.01780512183904648, 0.022992538288235664, 0.009128100238740444, 0.004181885160505772, -0.0025435886345803738, 0.011189284734427929, 0.0028349109925329685, 0.02232844941318035, 0.027791526168584824, -0.024671558290719986, -0.0010055319871753454, 0.014584912918508053, 0.012429753318428993, 0.00557271484285593, -0.05047081410884857, 0.01724127121269703, -0.01821861043572426, 0.008589310571551323, 0.007561851292848587, -0.00190925772767514, 0.008495335467159748, -0.023844577372074127, 0.001821547863073647, 0.00003573005960788578, -0.02225326932966709, 0.026187686249613762, 0.025122636929154396, -0.039143700152635574, 0.008520395494997501, -0.006484271492809057, 0.006402826867997646, 0.008777260780334473, -0.012066383846104145, -0.004620435182005167, -0.009754600003361702, 0.01189722865819931, -0.001289806212298572, -0.04019622132182121, -0.004977540113031864, 0.03856731951236725, -0.0465363971889019, -0.005099707283079624, 0.012116503901779652, 0.013833113014698029, -0.0031622571405023336, 0.009804720059037209, 0.01100133452564478, -0.03841695934534073, -0.019797390326857567, 0.026964547112584114, 0.023142898455262184, -0.011966143734753132, -0.01963450014591217, -0.015549722127616405, 0.04267715662717819, -0.00991122517734766, -0.022153029218316078, 0.01064423006027937, 0.008733405731618404, -0.008313651196658611, -0.006446681916713715, 0.031725943088531494, -0.01414636243134737, -0.006249334197491407, 0.029219945892691612, 0.013908293098211288, 0.01053145993500948, 0.029169825837016106, 0.003091776045039296, 0.027565985918045044, -0.04598507657647133, 0.03849213942885399, 0.0037057455629110336, 0.03693842142820358, 0.005005732644349337, 0.0589912086725235, 0.023255668580532074, 0.02866862528026104, 0.009428820572793484, -0.014234072528779507, 0.025135166943073273, -0.02072460949420929, 0.004034657962620258, 0.04185017943382263, -0.028793925419449806, -0.033104244619607925, -0.014209012500941753, 0.0056197019293904305, 0.014898162335157394, -0.006409091874957085, 0.007336311507970095, 0.032653164118528366, -0.056735809892416, -0.027340445667505264, 0.002980572171509266, 0.01754199154675007, -0.007054386660456657, 0.024420958012342453, 0.00449826754629612, -0.016013331711292267, -0.002817682223394513, 0.04114849865436554, -0.02746574580669403, 0.0009522795444354415, 0.015837911516427994, -0.01343215350061655, 0.011596509255468845, -0.028192486613988876, 0.013294323347508907, -0.019809920340776443, 0.009767130017280579, 0.005644761957228184, -0.10535218566656113, 0.035735540091991425, 0.013808052986860275, 0.00658451160416007, -0.012467343360185623, 0.05272621288895607, 0.026187686249613762, 0.014472142793238163, 0.03358038142323494, 0.01810584031045437, 0.02281711809337139, -0.03390616178512573, -0.0013963112141937017, 0.007605706341564655, 0.029846444725990295, -0.016502002254128456, 0.012511198408901691, -0.014973342418670654, -0.005378499627113342, -0.01103265956044197, -0.01278059370815754, 0.011383499018847942, 0.007499201223254204, 0.00222564022988081, 0.004394895397126675, -0.05052093416452408, -0.009384965524077415, -0.022115439176559448, 0.011627834290266037, -0.0036838180385529995, -0.021338578313589096, -0.02057424932718277, -0.029295125976204872, 0.007398961111903191, -0.01467262301594019, -0.01989763043820858, -0.015449482016265392, 0.019158359616994858, -0.04520821571350098, 0.031049324199557304, -0.019120769575238228, -0.04054705798625946, 0.03162570297718048, 0.04819035530090332, 0.03836683928966522, 0.0011778194457292557, 0.029620904475450516, 0.031350042670965195, 0.009447615593671799, 0.026262866333127022, -0.007599441334605217, -0.030974144116044044, 0.021050389856100082, -0.01142735406756401, -0.019496669992804527, 0.020486539229750633, -0.012843243777751923, -0.006343309301882982, -0.013382033444941044, 0.00546307722106576, -0.014534792862832546, 0.02240362949669361, 0.009980140253901482, -0.008664490655064583, -0.0741775631904602, -0.049819253385066986, -0.023243138566613197, 0.0008348108385689557, -0.01281818374991417, -0.04480725899338722, -0.01425913255661726, 0.04628579691052437, 0.03217702358961105, 0.03616156056523323, 0.015599842183291912, -0.009447615593671799, -0.015449482016265392, -0.001067398814484477, -0.0521748922765255, 0.013895763084292412, -0.009930020198225975, -0.02285470813512802, 0.016063451766967773, -0.019546790048480034, -0.0003531891852617264, 0.010312184691429138, -0.009159425273537636, 0.006355839315801859, -0.01660224236547947, 0.016689952462911606, 0.021940018981695175, -0.0018278128700330853, 0.02435830794274807, 0.011045189574360847, -0.044757138937711716, -0.005666689481586218, -0.011627834290266037, -0.025586247444152832, -0.008507865481078625, -0.0234561488032341, -0.03373074159026146, -0.033254604786634445, -0.029395364224910736, -0.039995741099119186, 0.0023321451153606176, -0.008395095355808735, -0.005951746832579374, 0.023656627163290977, 0.026287926360964775, 0.03145028278231621, 0.03270328417420387, 0.015487072058022022, -0.014710212126374245, 0.03849213942885399, 0.02221567928791046, 0.0008449914748780429, -0.00290382606908679, -0.015010932460427284, -0.002142628887668252, -0.010907359421253204, -0.008595575578510761, 0.004460677970200777, 0.01066302414983511, -0.023055188357830048, 0.006258731707930565, -0.0017134766094386578, 0.018632100895047188, -0.014685153029859066, -0.0043917628936469555, 0.02210290916264057, -0.014998402446508408, 0.014985872432589531, 0.015837911516427994, -0.003809118177741766, 0.03240256384015083, -0.022691817954182625, 0.001455828663893044, 0.039294060319662094, 0.01596321165561676, 0.01585044153034687, -0.007517996244132519, -0.02229085937142372, 0.012880833819508553, 0.011045189574360847, 0.026037326082587242, -0.0050026001408696175, 0.02240362949669361, -0.004679952748119831, 0.02095014974474907, 0.002101906342431903, 0.01339456345885992, 0.019697150215506554, -0.024771798402071, 0.011151694692671299, -0.015913091599941254, -0.024195417761802673, -0.002078412799164653, -0.0325278639793396, 0.02240362949669361, 0.0168277807533741, 0.01002399530261755, 0.04200053960084915, -0.010970009490847588, -0.03220208361744881, -0.0024840713012963533, 0.022466279566287994, -0.008219676092267036, 0.016502002254128456, -0.00794401578605175, -0.00236033764667809, -0.04377979785203934, -0.05528233200311661, 0.027866706252098083, 0.004109838046133518, -0.007962810806930065, 0.02776646614074707, -0.0196720901876688, -0.03586084023118019, 0.019170889630913734, 0.033480141311883926, -0.009466410614550114, -0.019684620201587677, 0.002065882785245776, -0.01150253415107727, 0.02541082724928856, -0.0033329783473163843, 0.006064516957849264, -0.0011754700681194663, 0.0264884065836668, -0.030523065477609634, -0.025736607611179352, 0.051473215222358704, 0.019045589491724968, 0.025962145999073982, 0.021313520148396492, 0.010669289156794548, 0.005911024287343025, 0.024646498262882233, -0.0010055319871753454, -0.00012471259105950594, 0.015537192113697529, -0.04721301794052124, -0.005879699718207121, -0.00754932127892971, -0.019434019923210144, 0.00006406938337022439, -0.02371927723288536, 0.03072354383766651, -0.03982032090425491, -0.02739056572318077, 0.011527594178915024, 0.0074553461745381355, 0.04129885882139206, 0.00511536980047822, 0.04355425760149956, 0.0005419222288765013, 0.042476680129766464, -0.025736607611179352, -0.02776646614074707, -0.03480832278728485, 0.02601226605474949, -0.058139171451330185, -0.02889416553080082, 0.03851719945669174, 0.0120099987834692, 0.041574519127607346, 0.006797521375119686, -0.01208517886698246, -0.004557785112410784, -0.005481872241944075, -0.00886497087776661, 0.024558788165450096, 0.005773194599896669, -0.026062386110424995, -0.03455772250890732, -0.004557785112410784, 0.0020893763285130262, 0.01783018186688423, 0.009930020198225975, 0.0069792065769433975, 0.028643565252423286, 0.00627752672880888, 0.017529461532831192, -0.0022585312835872173, -0.005544522311538458, -0.01712850108742714, -0.004344775341451168, -0.029846444725990295, 0.00921581033617258, 0.012129033915698528, -0.040296461433172226, 0.010769529268145561, -0.025736607611179352, 0.003398760687559843, 0.0036838180385529995, 0.013908293098211288, -0.01263023354113102, 0.026037326082587242, 0.002988403430208564, -0.0044951350428164005, 0.004589110147207975, -0.018594510853290558, -0.050721414387226105, -0.016276462003588676, -0.0007784258341416717, 0.019722210243344307, -0.02601226605474949, 0.01675260066986084, 0.008063050918281078, -0.02151399850845337, -0.019496669992804527, -0.042401500046253204, 0.06224900856614113, 0.005055852234363556, -0.017153561115264893, 0.0031184020917862654, -0.016176221892237663, -0.015035992488265038, 0.01425913255661726, 0.03693842142820358, -0.02428312785923481, -0.006415356881916523, 0.022265799343585968, 0.007517996244132519, -0.0025216611102223396, 0.024872036650776863, 0.0019029928371310234, -0.005763797089457512, -0.001735404133796692, -0.016163691878318787, -0.022904828190803528, 0.01422154251486063, 0.01925859972834587, 0.0031027395743876696, 0.017491871491074562, -0.033104244619607925, -0.0071984813548624516, 0.005162357352674007, 0.007304986473172903, -0.009691949933767319, -0.021501468494534492, -0.026814186945557594, 0.016013331711292267, -0.009566649794578552, 0.025097576901316643, -0.029445484280586243, 0.002617202466353774, -0.027265265583992004, -0.03255292400717735, 0.019208479672670364, 0.041499339044094086, -0.015111172571778297, -0.012811918742954731, 0.014171422459185123, -0.019647030159831047, -0.021902428939938545, -0.01997281052172184, 0.01724127121269703, 0.001429985510185361, -0.020073050633072853, -0.02136363834142685, -0.014948282390832901, 0.051172494888305664, -0.03774034231901169, -0.025623837485909462, 0.008664490655064583, 0.014810452237725258, -0.0021520263981074095, 0.043002936989068985, 0.021651828661561012, 0.03230232372879982, 0.015086112543940544, 0.03315436467528343, -0.0053878971375525, -0.010894829407334328, 0.007292456459254026, 0.01165289431810379, -0.007912690751254559, 0.020210878923535347, 0.033555321395397186, -0.03463290259242058, -0.014008533209562302, -0.023167958483099937, 0.010694349184632301, -0.011114104650914669, 0.008514130488038063, 0.008802320808172226, -0.020210878923535347, -0.020636899396777153, 0.013231673277914524, 0.06014396995306015, -0.0006801437120884657, 0.02143881842494011, -0.0589912086725235, 0.02957078441977501, -0.03728926181793213, -0.007123301271349192, -0.004044055473059416, 0.010180619545280933, -0.015599842183291912, -0.009485205635428429, 0.002682984806597233, -0.021526528522372246, 0.006747401785105467, 0.06239936873316765, 0.004579712636768818, 0.016401762142777443, 0.031074384227395058, -0.0038529729936271906, 0.0018826315645128489, -0.008626900613307953, -0.012768063694238663, 0.009059185162186623, 0.020361239090561867, -0.033555321395397186, -0.00048123006126843393, 0.006402826867997646, -0.0014088411116972566, -0.01876993104815483, 0.003884298028424382, 0.004980672616511583, -0.010901094414293766, -0.023481208831071854, -0.0035083983093500137, -0.015148762613534927, -0.017667291685938835, 0.014747802168130875, 0.005791989620774984, 0.03072354383766651, 0.011634099297225475, 0.016815250739455223, 0.0002719400217756629, 0.01997281052172184, -0.0050213951617479324, 0.00464549520984292, 0.04297787696123123, 0.016890430822968483, 0.044531598687171936, 0.025360707193613052, 0.0012741436948999763, -0.028869105502963066, -0.00816955603659153, 0.010938684456050396, -0.001252216286957264, -0.013231673277914524, 0.006571981590241194, 0.0022115439642220736, 0.015399361960589886, -0.004852239973843098, -0.04280245676636696, -0.02979632467031479, -0.034006401896476746, -0.03503386303782463, 0.04393015801906586, 0.018368970602750778, -0.009529059752821922, 0.012248069047927856, 0.022353509441018105, -0.02601226605474949, 0.015374301932752132, -0.000041285351471742615, 0.012968542985618114, -0.01531165186315775, 0.024483608081936836, -0.020336179062724113, 0.00011874127085320652, -0.006158492062240839, 0.004047187976539135, -0.028718745335936546, -0.018080780282616615, -0.031951483339071274, -0.05583365261554718, -0.005334644578397274, 0.022190619260072708, -0.0009068583021871746, -0.005250067450106144, 0.018118370324373245, 0.02068701945245266, -0.03320448473095894, 0.010550254955887794, -0.036186620593070984, -0.0011715544387698174, 0.00577006209641695, 0.018093310296535492, -0.009015330113470554, 0.02806718647480011, -0.004676820244640112, 0.009829780086874962, 0.011815783567726612, -0.015399361960589886, -0.010330979712307453, 0.014910692349076271, 0.034081581979990005, 0.009623034857213497, 0.01023073960095644, -0.007348841056227684, -0.014497202821075916, -0.0574876107275486, 0.023255668580532074, -0.006120902020484209, 0.04726313427090645, 0.04154945909976959, -0.00001374138992105145, -0.0010313751408830285, 0.035810720175504684, 0.05247561261057854, 0.0022303389851003885, -0.0031403296161442995, -0.013682752847671509, -0.03608638048171997, 0.015386831946671009, 0.017065851017832756, 0.00025177455972880125, -0.041348978877067566, -0.01959691010415554, -0.019158359616994858, 0.0187323410063982, -0.02368168719112873, 0.005149827338755131, -0.00665969168767333, -0.028693685308098793, 0.018231140449643135, 0.0005121635040268302, 0.046862177550792694, -0.002429252490401268, -0.009021595120429993, -0.013808052986860275, -0.022265799343585968, 0.03864249959588051, 0.010970009490847588, 0.017491871491074562, -0.02177712880074978, -0.01585044153034687, -0.010832179337739944, 0.005926686804741621, -0.028242604807019234, -0.008670755662024021, -0.0018309453735128045, 0.03019728511571884, 0.017404161393642426, -0.02866862528026104, -0.008758465759456158, 0.0037402031011879444, 0.021075449883937836, 0.010913624428212643, -0.007054386660456657, -0.037038661539554596, -0.0003512313705869019, -0.004836577456444502, -0.005525727290660143, -0.006540656555444002, 0.009378700517117977, 0.000599873426835984, 0.023330848664045334, 0.02806718647480011, -0.009936285205185413, -0.010280859656631947, -0.019772330299019814, -0.006872701458632946, 0.008075580932199955, -0.015361771918833256, -0.055482812225818634, 0.004435617942363024, -0.01259264349937439, -0.05247561261057854, -0.007643295917659998, 0.015198882669210434, 0.004438750445842743, -0.06044469028711319, 0.0011668556835502386, -0.014973342418670654, -0.0077310060150921345, 0.00976086501032114, 0.005284524988383055, -0.016965610906481743, -0.002786357421427965, -0.012774328701198101, 0.015487072058022022, 0.02432071790099144, -0.0018654027953743935, 0.01907064951956272, -0.016238871961832047, 0.01780512183904648, 0.012811918742954731, 0.014033593237400055, 0.04295281693339348, 0.004175620619207621, -0.04393015801906586, -0.009748334996402264, -0.0020752802956849337, -0.01652706228196621, -0.02240362949669361, 0.014810452237725258, -0.04443135857582092, -0.0066221016459167, 0.014234072528779507, -0.012573848478496075, 0.034081581979990005, -0.026463346555829048, 0.030673423781991005, -0.007950280793011189, -0.0132442032918334, 0.000890412658918649, 0.01197240874171257, 0.03751480206847191, 0.008745935745537281, -0.024032527580857277, 0.039143700152635574, -0.0166398324072361, -0.007373901084065437, 0.0544804111123085, 0.0032108109444379807, -0.009879900142550468, -0.01172807440161705, -0.00433851033449173, 0.016502002254128456, 0.019960280507802963, -0.021839778870344162, 0.007480406202375889, 0.0192961897701025, -0.02896934561431408, -0.02957078441977501, -0.005992469377815723, -0.027791526168584824, -0.009090510196983814, 0.026914427056908607, -0.004730072803795338, 0.025122636929154396, -0.017867770045995712, 0.028844045475125313, 0.014873102307319641, -0.014885632321238518, 0.022980008274316788, -0.014234072528779507, -0.007367636077105999, 0.027565985918045044, 0.03240256384015083, 0.009378700517117977, -0.031074384227395058, -0.004911757539957762, -0.008113170973956585, 0.029470544308423996, 0.009040390141308308, -0.003896828042343259, 0.002546721138060093, -0.021238340064883232, 0.014209012500941753, -0.021163159981369972, -0.0026015399489551783, -0.010537724941968918, -0.014434552751481533, 0.019346309825778008, 0.037189021706581116, 0.006048854440450668, 0.01648947224020958, -0.0038498404901474714, -0.04327859729528427, -0.01320661325007677, -0.0028317784890532494, -0.003884298028424382, -0.018080780282616615, -0.027941886335611343, 0.026463346555829048, -0.0022428687661886215, -0.023518798872828484, -0.009591709822416306, 0.011941083706915379, -0.02292988821864128, 0.03448254242539406, 0.014246602542698383, 0.010186884552240372, 0.012529993429780006, 0.05127273499965668, -0.019170889630913734, -0.0014840210787951946, 0.0031137033365666866, -0.016088511794805527, -0.021614238619804382, 0.00596740934997797, 0.016552122309803963, 0.026112506166100502, -0.0005701147019863129, -0.008965210057795048, -0.011139164678752422, 0.0005333078443072736, 0.0034300857223570347, -0.029696084558963776, -0.009153160266578197, 0.0040189954452216625, -0.016840310767292976, -0.008501600474119186, 0.006709811743348837, -0.019546790048480034, 0.02095014974474907, 0.022340979427099228, -0.011740604415535927, -0.027565985918045044, -0.027114905416965485, 0.022792058065533638, -0.028342844918370247, 0.019158359616994858, -0.01060664001852274, -0.02323060855269432, 0.018569450825452805, -0.004927420057356358, 0.034983742982149124, -0.021150629967451096, 0.028844045475125313, 0.0019703414291143417, 0.005823314655572176, -0.02544841729104519, 0.044681958854198456, 0.023355908691883087, 0.008883765898644924, 0.016326582059264183, -0.0175795815885067, 0.0002482504933141172, 0.02806718647480011, 0.02499733678996563, 0.009735804982483387, -0.017040790989995003, -0.02285470813512802, -0.0196720901876688, 0.00794401578605175, -0.029295125976204872, -0.024909626692533493, -0.0002474673674441874, 0.007173421327024698, -0.022315919399261475, -0.031575582921504974, 0.036737941205501556, -0.02277952805161476, 0.004203812684863806, -0.036036260426044464, -0.03954466059803963, 0.005250067450106144, -0.00020713645790237933, -0.01705332100391388, -0.007223541382700205, -0.04305305704474449, 0.024182887747883797, -0.005359704606235027, -0.049067456275224686, 0.006665956694632769, 0.020524129271507263, -0.002191182691603899, 0.050270333886146545, 0.000032940177334239706, 0.01448467280715704, -0.014284192584455013, -0.04448147863149643, 0.05167369544506073, -0.04636097699403763, 0.028017066419124603, -0.01775500178337097, 0.027340445667505264, 0.031500402837991714, -0.013532393611967564, -0.000348882022080943, -0.01509864255785942, -0.00014810844731982797, 0.01746681146323681, 0.021188220009207726, 0.00032675874535925686, -0.02128846012055874, -0.06415356695652008, 0.031425222754478455, 0.011997468769550323, 0.013407093472778797, 0.011396029032766819, 0.02904452569782734, 0.030046924948692322, -0.006954146549105644, -0.009447615593671799, 0.005907891783863306, 0.013231673277914524, -0.022453749552369118, 0.0058327121660113335, -0.025423357263207436 ]
11.18969
2.773028
2024-07-01
2
2024A&A...687A..98C
[ "void galaxies", "spiral galaxies", "Galaxies", "galaxies", "stellar mass", "stellar mass, stellar mass surface density", "star formation rate", "specific star formation rate", "mass", "the void galaxy sample" ]
[ "techniques: spectroscopic", "galaxies: evolution", "galaxies: fundamental parameters", "galaxies: star formation", "galaxies: stellar content", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
75
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202449414", "10.48550/arXiv.2404.10823" ]
[ "Conrado, Ana M.", "González Delgado, Rosa M.", "García-Benito, Rubén", "Pérez, Isabel", "Verley, Simon", "Ruiz-Lara, Tomás", "Sánchez-Menguiano, Laura", "Duarte Puertas, Salvador", "Jiménez, Andoni", "Domínguez-Gómez, Jesús", "Espada, Daniel", "Argudo-Fernández, María", "Alcázar-Laynez, Manuel", "Blázquez-Calero, Guillermo", "Bidaran, Bahar", "Zurita, Almudena", "Peletier, Reynier", "Torres-Ríos, Gloria", "Florido, Estrella", "Rodríguez Martínez, Mónica", "del Moral-Castro, Ignacio", "van de Weygaert, Rien", "Falcón-Barroso, Jesús", "Lugo-Aranda, Alejandra Z.", "Sánchez, Sebastián F.", "van der Hulst, Thijs", "Courtois, Hélène M.", "Ferré-Mateu, Anna", "Sánchez-Blázquez, Patricia", "Román, Javier", "Aceituno, Jesús" ]
[ "Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucía (CSIC), PO Box 3004, 18008, Granada, Spain", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucía (CSIC), PO Box 3004, 18008, Granada, Spain", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucía (CSIC), PO Box 3004, 18008, Granada, Spain", "Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Facultad de Ciencias (Edificio Mecenas), Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain; Instituto Carlos I de Física Teórica y Computacional, Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain", "Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Facultad de Ciencias (Edificio Mecenas), Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain; Instituto Carlos I de Física Teórica y Computacional, Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain", "Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Facultad de Ciencias (Edificio Mecenas), Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain; Instituto Carlos I de Física Teórica y Computacional, Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain", "Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Facultad de Ciencias (Edificio Mecenas), Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain; Instituto Carlos I de Física Teórica y Computacional, Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain", "Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Facultad de Ciencias (Edificio Mecenas), Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain; Instituto Carlos I de Física Teórica y Computacional, Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain; Département de Physique, de Génie Physique et d'Optique, Université Laval, and Centre de Recherche en Astrophysique du Québec (CRAQ), Québec, QC, G1V 0A6, Canada", "Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Facultad de Ciencias (Edificio Mecenas), Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain", "Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Facultad de Ciencias (Edificio Mecenas), Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain", "Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Facultad de Ciencias (Edificio Mecenas), Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain; Instituto Carlos I de Física Teórica y Computacional, Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain", "Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Facultad de Ciencias (Edificio Mecenas), Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain; Instituto Carlos I de Física Teórica y Computacional, Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain", "Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Facultad de Ciencias (Edificio Mecenas), Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucía (CSIC), PO Box 3004, 18008, Granada, Spain", "Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Facultad de Ciencias (Edificio Mecenas), Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain", "Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Facultad de Ciencias (Edificio Mecenas), Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain; Instituto Carlos I de Física Teórica y Computacional, Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain", "Kapteyn Astronomical Institute, University of Groningen, PO Box 800, 9700 AV, Groningen, The Netherlands", "Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Facultad de Ciencias (Edificio Mecenas), Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain", "Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Facultad de Ciencias (Edificio Mecenas), Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain; Instituto Carlos I de Física Teórica y Computacional, Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain", "Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Facultad de Ciencias (Edificio Mecenas), Universidad de Granada, 18071, Granada, Spain", "Kapteyn Astronomical Institute, University of Groningen, PO Box 800, 9700 AV, Groningen, The Netherlands; Departamento de Astrofísica, Universidad de La Laguna, Avda. Astrofísico Fco. Sánchez s/n, 38200, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Instituto de Astrofísica, Facultad de Física, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Campus San Joaquín, Av. Vicuña Mackenna 4860, Macul, 7820436, Santiago, Chile", "Kapteyn Astronomical Institute, University of Groningen, PO Box 800, 9700 AV, Groningen, The Netherlands", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias, Vía Láctea s/n, 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Departamento de Astrofísica, Universidad de La Laguna, Avda. Astrofísico Fco. Sánchez s/n, 38200, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain", "Instituto de Astronomía, Universidad Nacional Autonóma de México, A.P. 70-264, 04510, Ciudad de México, Mexico", "Instituto de Astronomía, Universidad Nacional Autonóma de México, A.P. 70-264, 04510, Ciudad de México, Mexico", "Kapteyn Astronomical Institute, University of Groningen, PO Box 800, 9700 AV, Groningen, The Netherlands", "Université Claude Bernard Lyon 1, IUF, IP2I Lyon, 69622, Villeurbanne, France", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias, Vía Láctea s/n, 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Departamento de Astrofísica, Universidad de La Laguna, Avda. Astrofísico Fco. Sánchez s/n, 38200, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Centre for Astrophysics and Supercomputing, Swinburne University of Technology, Hawthorn, VIC, 3122, Australia", "Departamento de Física de la Tierra y Astrofísica &amp; IPARCOS, UCM, 28040, Madrid, Spain", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias, Vía Láctea s/n, 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Departamento de Astrofísica, Universidad de La Laguna, Avda. Astrofísico Fco. Sánchez s/n, 38200, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucía (CSIC), PO Box 3004, 18008, Granada, Spain; Centro Astronómico Hispano en Andalucía, Observatorio de Calar Alto, Sierra de los Filabres, 04550, Gérgal, Almería, Spain" ]
[ "2024arXiv240504217P", "2024arXiv240513471M" ]
[ "1963ApJS....8...31D", "1972ApJ...176....1G", "1980ApJ...236..351D", "1989ApJ...345..245C", "1989ApJS...70....1A", "1992A&AS...96..269S", "1993A&AS..101..415C", "1993A&AS..102..339S", "2000A&AS..141..371G", "2003MNRAS.341...54K", "2003MNRAS.342..345C", "2004AN....325..151V", "2004ApJ...613..866K", "2004ApJ...613..898T", "2004ApJ...615L.101B", "2004ApJ...617...50R", "2004MNRAS.351.1151B", "2005ApJ...624..571R", "2005ApJ...629..143B", "2005MNRAS.357..945G", "2005MNRAS.358..363C", "2005MNRAS.362...41G", "2005MNRAS.363....2K", "2005Natur.433..604D", "2005Natur.435..629S", "2005PASP..117..620R", "2006ApJ...645..986R", "2006MNRAS.368....2D", "2006MNRAS.369..529F", "2006MNRAS.372..933N", "2006MNRAS.372.1710P", "2006MNRAS.373..469B", "2007ApJ...660L..43N", "2007ApJS..173..267S", "2007ApJS..173..315S", "2007MNRAS.381..263A", "2008ApJ...684L..79R", "2008MNRAS.391L..29S", "2009ApJ...696L...6S", "2009ApJ...699L.178N", "2010ApJ...721..193P", "2010ApJ...725.2312O", "2010MNRAS.404.1639V", "2010MNRAS.404.1775T", "2011AJ....141..204K", "2011ApJ...742..125G", "2011AstBu..66..255P", "2011MNRAS.413..813C", "2011MNRAS.413.1687C", "2011MNRAS.414..350S", "2012A&A...538A...8S", "2012A&A...544A.101C", "2012AJ....144...16K", "2012ARA&A..50..455F", "2012ApJ...757....4P", "2012MNRAS.421..872C", "2012MNRAS.421..926P", "2012MNRAS.425.2049H", "2012MNRAS.426.3041H", "2012NJPh...14e5023M", "2013A&A...558A..33A", "2013AJ....145..120B", "2013ApJ...764L...1P", "2013MNRAS.429.1286C", "2014A&A...561A.130C", "2014A&A...562A..47G", "2014A&A...569A...1W", "2014AJ....148...77M", "2014ApJS..214...15S", "2014MNRAS.437.1534S", "2014MNRAS.441.2923C", "2014MNRAS.445.4045R", "2015A&A...575A..74S", "2015A&A...581A.103G", "2015ApJ...798....7B", "2015ApJ...798...52V", "2015ApJ...801L..29R", "2015ApJ...806...96L", "2015ApJ...806..101H", "2015ApJ...810..108M", "2015ApJ...812..117A", "2015MNRAS.446..521S", "2015MNRAS.449.1177V", "2015MNRAS.449.3347O", "2015MNRAS.450.1937C", "2015MNRAS.452..616D", "2016A&A...588A..68G", "2016A&A...590A..44G", "2016A&A...594A..36S", "2016A&C....16...17T", "2016ApJ...831..118M", "2016MNRAS.458..394B", "2016MNRAS.462.2559B", "2016MNRAS.463..670P", "2017A&A...599A..71D", "2017A&A...602A.100T", "2017A&A...607A.110L", "2017A&A...607A.128G", "2017A&A...608A..27G", "2017MNRAS.464..121S", "2017MNRAS.465.2342C", "2017MNRAS.466.4731G", "2017MNRAS.470.4434P", "2017MNRAS.471.3727D", "2018A&A...615A..27L", "2018MNRAS.473.4077P", "2018MNRAS.475.5194M", "2018MNRAS.476.3661D", "2018MNRAS.479.3842K", "2019ApJ...878..161J", "2019ComAC...6....2N", "2019MNRAS.483..370B", "2019MNRAS.485.3794D", "2019MNRAS.486.4880A", "2019MNRAS.488.3929C", "2020A&A...638A..60A", "2020A&A...639L...9D", "2020ARA&A..58...99S", "2020ApJ...889..156C", "2020MNRAS.491.5795H", "2020MNRAS.493..830P", "2020MNRAS.493..899H", "2021ApJ...906...97F", "2021ApJ...914....7G", "2021MNRAS.502.4457G", "2021MNRAS.502.5508P", "2021MNRAS.506.4760D", "2021MNRAS.507..944P", "2021MNRAS.508..157M", "2022A&A...658A.124D", "2022A&A...666A..84G", "2022A&A...666A.160R", "2022A&A...666A.186D", "2022ApJ...926..117S", "2022MNRAS.511.4900S", "2022MNRAS.517..712R", "2023A&A...669A..11P", "2023A&A...671A.160G", "2023A&A...680A.111D", "2023MNRAS.518.6325S", "2023MNRAS.524.5768P", "2023MNRAS.525.4329B", "2023Natur.619..269D", "2024ApJ...966..154P", "2024MNRAS.52711066P", "2024MNRAS.528..542K", "2024MNRAS.528.2822R" ]
29184214
2402.08455
The SRG/eROSITA All-Sky Survey. Dark Energy Survey year 3 weak gravitational lensing by eRASS1 selected galaxy clusters
Context. Number counts of galaxy clusters across redshift are a powerful cosmological probe if a precise and accurate reconstruction of the underlying mass distribution is performed - a challenge called mass calibration. With the advent of wide and deep photometric surveys, weak gravitational lensing (WL) by clusters has become the method of choice for this measurement. <BR /> Aims: We measured and validated the WL signature in the shape of galaxies observed in the first three years of the Dark Energy Survey (DES Y3) caused by galaxy clusters and groups selected in the first all-sky survey performed by SRG (Spectrum Roentgen Gamma)/eROSITA (eRASS1). These data were then used to determine the scaling between the X-ray photon count rate of the clusters and their halo mass and redshift. <BR /> Methods: We empirically determined the degree of cluster member contamination in our background source sample. The individual cluster shear profiles were then analyzed with a Bayesian population model that self-consistently accounts for the lens sample selection and contamination and includes marginalization over a host of instrumental and astrophysical systematics. To quantify the accuracy of the mass extraction of that model, we performed mass measurements on mock cluster catalogs with realistic synthetic shear profiles. This allowed us to establish that hydrodynamical modeling uncertainties at low lens redshifts (z &lt; 0.6) are the dominant systematic limitation. At high lens redshift, the uncertainties of the sources' photometric redshift calibration dominate. <BR /> Results: With regard to the X-ray count rate to halo mass relation, we determined its amplitude, its mass trend, the redshift evolution of the mass trend, the deviation from self-similar redshift evolution, and the intrinsic scatter around this relation. <BR /> Conclusions: The mass calibration analysis performed here sets the stage for a joint analysis with the number counts of eRASS1 clusters to constrain a host of cosmological parameters. We demonstrate that WL mass calibration of galaxy clusters can be performed successfully with source galaxies whose calibration was performed primarily for cosmic shear experiments, opening the way for the cluster cosmological exploitation of future optical and NIR surveys like Euclid and LSST.
[ 0.03538819029927254, 0.007779822684824467, 0.03441798314452171, 0.014650079421699047, 0.01740303263068199, 0.005163304042071104, -0.0034775747917592525, 0.015826452523469925, -0.041063882410526276, 0.02498275227844715, -0.02799038402736187, 0.012406483292579651, -0.05835776776075363, -0.016469212248921394, 0.03674647584557533, 0.05404036119580269, -0.02235107310116291, 0.03177417814731598, -0.05753309279680252, 0.03805625066161156, -0.0004373497504275292, -0.01321902871131897, 0.007373549975454807, -0.012564141303300858, -0.05796968564391136, -0.03504861891269684, 0.03776519000530243, -0.025031261146068573, 0.04965018481016159, -0.01102394238114357, -0.016299426555633545, -0.025249557569622993, -0.05374929681420326, -0.023066598922014236, -0.05607778578996658, 0.07727674394845963, 0.010350863449275494, 0.029785260558128357, -0.048510197550058365, -0.016299426555633545, -0.009574700146913528, 0.016214532777667046, -0.04120941087603569, 0.029736749827861786, -0.01095724105834961, -0.03230779245495796, -0.03065844438970089, -0.030900996178388596, 0.0017766859382390976, -0.010587350465357304, -0.0330839529633522, 0.017839625477790833, 0.002048039808869362, -0.0083134351298213, -0.04814637079834938, -0.007616100832819939, 0.028790801763534546, 0.023272767663002014, -0.005430110264569521, 0.0023087821900844574, 0.03264736384153366, 0.00001551473542349413, 0.0388324111700058, -0.008004182949662209, -0.03383586183190346, 0.0015538422157987952, 0.03538819029927254, -0.004805541597306728, 0.01968301273882389, 0.0555441752076149, 0.026704862713813782, 0.018543023616075516, -0.0028545218519866467, 0.025007005780935287, -0.0063305809162557125, 0.006379090715199709, -0.010284162126481533, 0.019015997648239136, -0.03902645409107208, 0.046788085252046585, -0.014007319696247578, -0.02178107760846615, -0.014371145516633987, 0.005712075624614954, -0.014164977706968784, -0.024364246055483818, 0.016299426555633545, -0.026074230670928955, -0.03126482293009758, 0.07402656227350235, 0.0038595926016569138, 0.0066762156784534454, 0.04593915492296219, -0.005272452253848314, -0.03708604723215103, -0.037013281136751175, 0.011642447672784328, -0.013134135864675045, 0.05360376834869385, 0.03065844438970089, 0.05476801097393036, 0.032623108476400375, 0.021029170602560043, -0.1072075366973877, 0.03652817755937576, -0.014480293728411198, -0.022120648995041847, -0.012376164086163044, 0.009041087701916695, 0.0036867749877274036, 0.03980261832475662, 0.007258338388055563, -0.058503296226263046, -0.00014979418483562768, 0.0065306853502988815, -0.03555797412991524, -0.056562889367341995, 0.018967486917972565, -0.05224548280239105, -0.007895034737884998, -0.018009411171078682, -0.005208782386034727, 0.04370768740773201, 0.01338881440460682, 0.025249557569622993, -0.06325729936361313, -0.004074856638908386, -0.018676426261663437, -0.041015371680259705, 0.015644539147615433, 0.050838686525821686, -0.01693005859851837, 0.02881505712866783, -0.008119394071400166, -0.03424819931387901, -0.030779719352722168, -0.006627705879509449, -0.02898484282195568, -0.015232201665639877, 0.0166268702596426, 0.0017630424117669463, 0.01993769034743309, 0.015705175697803497, 0.045502565801143646, 0.012588395737111568, -0.0005760585772804916, -0.021247467026114464, 0.029300158843398094, 0.016554104164242744, 0.007355358451604843, 0.011211919598281384, -0.014310508035123348, -0.02638954669237137, -0.019137272611260414, 0.0036898069083690643, -0.06932107359170914, 0.014067957177758217, 0.03575201332569122, -0.005760585889220238, -0.021429380401968956, 0.0038292736280709505, 0.00035492031020112336, -0.04630298167467117, -0.03027036227285862, -0.04496895149350166, 0.009223001077771187, 0.0006931652314960957, 0.02643805742263794, -0.08368009328842163, 0.0009664140525273979, -0.027626557275652885, 0.05190591141581535, 0.015050288289785385, -0.06316027790307999, -0.023466806858778, 0.03892943263053894, 0.030173342674970627, -0.00934427697211504, -0.019003869965672493, -0.009253320284187794, -0.013291793875396252, 0.004869210999459028, -0.00200862530618906, -0.024279354140162468, -0.05830925703048706, 0.022193415090441704, -0.0012877940898761153, 0.04948040097951889, -0.0007268949993886054, -0.018931103870272636, 0.027238475158810616, 0.033908627927303314, 0.009204809553921223, 0.03458777070045471, -0.020774491131305695, -0.042397912591695786, 0.006097125355154276, 0.05447695031762123, -0.03398139402270317, 0.011988081969320774, -0.00016296394460368901, 0.021477889269590378, 0.06121986731886864, -0.054622482508420944, -0.025346577167510986, -0.037061791867017746, 0.022630006074905396, 0.004253738094121218, -0.01791238971054554, -0.00044038164196535945, 0.029979301616549492, 0.0005957658286206424, 0.020337900146842003, 0.002081390703096986, -0.015838580206036568, 0.008919812738895416, -0.05670842155814171, -0.0019646629225462675, 0.04935912415385246, 0.02660784311592579, -0.006955149583518505, 0.054331421852111816, 0.045793626457452774, 0.012345844879746437, 0.002799947978928685, -0.006955149583518505, 0.027747832238674164, -0.034126922488212585, 0.0334235243499279, -0.032744381576776505, 0.04268897324800491, 0.039899636059999466, -0.01847025752067566, 0.024182332679629326, -0.02458254247903824, -0.03419968858361244, -0.0067307897843420506, 0.03660094365477562, 0.004963199608027935, -0.04050601273775101, -0.021453633904457092, 0.006142603699117899, 0.010751072317361832, -0.0018918976420536637, 0.006342708133161068, 0.016517721116542816, -0.010126503184437752, -0.016784528270363808, 0.034612026065588, -0.002290590899065137, 0.005775745492428541, 0.013995192013680935, -0.031677160412073135, -0.04698212444782257, -0.02638954669237137, 0.02704443410038948, -0.00004104891195311211, 0.02631678245961666, -0.01980428770184517, 0.025128282606601715, -0.030221853405237198, -0.025346577167510986, -0.021817460656166077, 0.03754689171910286, 0.00029390357667580247, 0.010423628613352776, 0.008616623468697071, 0.006742917466908693, -0.05535013601183891, 0.007494825404137373, -0.02192660979926586, 0.016736017540097237, 0.04880125820636749, -0.025370832532644272, -0.04785531014204025, 0.025807425379753113, 0.022423839196562767, -0.003462415188550949, 0.011745531111955643, -0.02269064448773861, -0.00888949353247881, -0.009138108231127262, 0.0032562469132244587, 0.01338881440460682, -0.004375013522803783, 0.01597198285162449, -0.005921275820583105, -0.013837534002959728, -0.004520543850958347, -0.012515630573034286, 0.046400003135204315, -0.07329890877008438, -0.01027203444391489, -0.006888447795063257, -0.03327799588441849, -0.009501934982836246, 0.016990697011351585, 0.020920023322105408, -0.06175348162651062, 0.02820867858827114, 0.025855934247374535, 0.0472731851041317, 0.02002258412539959, -0.01691793091595173, -0.044508107006549835, 0.005360376555472612, 0.04244642332196236, -0.030343128368258476, 0.004526607692241669, 0.039899636059999466, 0.0069612134248018265, 0.044508107006549835, -0.00952012650668621, 0.016723889857530594, -0.011351386085152626, -0.03347203508019447, -0.024643180891871452, 0.05607778578996658, 0.04957742244005203, -0.0383230559527874, -0.05709649994969368, -0.030682699754834175, -0.03786220774054527, -0.01998620107769966, 0.004244642332196236, -0.05093570798635483, -0.004378045443445444, -0.03233204782009125, -0.014565186575055122, -0.029809515923261642, 0.0000028601593839994166, 0.05146931856870651, 0.06655599176883698, -0.030779719352722168, 0.01912514492869377, -0.07266827672719955, 0.037619657814502716, 0.02544359862804413, -0.0020146891474723816, -0.020725982263684273, 0.0011528751347213984, -0.03992389142513275, -0.0035715631674975157, -0.002877261023968458, 0.033957138657569885, 0.046788085252046585, 0.01606900244951248, 0.01310988049954176, 0.02407318539917469, 0.009877888485789299, -0.01669963449239731, 0.00919268187135458, 0.024509776383638382, -0.0021526399068534374, 0.036625199019908905, -0.02631678245961666, -0.013279666192829609, -0.058454785495996475, -0.03170141205191612, 0.014953267760574818, 0.004193100146949291, 0.019064506515860558, 0.0213566143065691, 0.0342724546790123, -0.01263690646737814, 0.023018088191747665, -0.030124831944704056, 0.01190318912267685, -0.030027812346816063, -0.02660784311592579, 0.0021662835497409105, -0.009677784517407417, -0.018579404801130295, -0.03842007741332054, -0.04509022831916809, 0.020568324252963066, 0.04142770916223526, 0.009271511808037758, 0.026171252131462097, 0.025079771876335144, 0.03458777070045471, 0.012364036403596401, 0.024509776383638382, -0.05530162528157234, -0.0068399375304579735, 0.03298693522810936, -0.03638264909386635, -0.013849660754203796, -0.09687486290931702, -0.0036200734321027994, -0.04555107653141022, 0.012394355610013008, 0.0018691584700718522, -0.0018494512187317014, 0.013946681283414364, -0.026413802057504654, -0.0018085207557305694, 0.043174076825380325, 0.048946790397167206, 0.047345951199531555, 0.0013332724338397384, -0.03630988299846649, -0.05709649994969368, -0.04921359568834305, -0.0028742291033267975, 0.0009338213130831718, -0.06757470220327377, 0.022229798138141632, 0.012721799314022064, -0.000594249926507473, 0.028742291033267975, -0.016081130132079124, 0.008743963204324245, -0.030852485448122025, 0.008198223076760769, 0.03686774894595146, -0.035800524055957794, 0.047782544046640396, -0.01636006310582161, 0.030682699754834175, 0.009332149289548397, 0.004823732655495405, -0.013073498383164406, 0.01904025301337242, -0.008489284664392471, 0.04055452346801758, 0.006718662101775408, 0.01813068613409996, -0.012879457324743271, 0.0018039729911834002, -0.027966128662228584, 0.04380470886826515, 0.0665074810385704, -0.0076828026212751865, -0.013485834933817387, 0.01619027741253376, 0.02803889289498329, -0.01410433929413557, 0.03245332092046738, -0.002134448615834117, 0.02604997530579567, 0.03213800489902496, -0.053894829005002975, -0.08435923606157303, 0.003962676506489515, 0.013206901028752327, 0.005211814306676388, 0.025564873591065407, 0.013303921557962894, 0.004614532459527254, 0.0002793126041069627, -0.04775828868150711, 0.02221767045557499, -0.004083952400833368, -0.04244642332196236, -0.04147621989250183, -0.024424884468317032, -0.06107433885335922, 0.056902460753917694, -0.05292462557554245, -0.01669963449239731, 0.03958432003855705, -0.018094303086400032, 0.027626557275652885, 0.016942186281085014, 0.02937292493879795, -0.015159436501562595, 0.006627705879509449, 0.019197911024093628, 0.007221955340355635, 0.009944590739905834, -0.025952955707907677, 0.018094303086400032, -0.021247467026114464, 0.007913226261734962, -0.009144172072410583, -0.04703063517808914, -0.004083952400833368, 0.05030507594347, 0.037231575697660446, 0.05365227907896042, -0.020046839490532875, -0.033011190593242645, -0.003741348860785365, 0.05748458206653595, 0.010411500930786133, -0.010041610337793827, 0.018955359235405922, 0.002799947978928685, 0.005796968471258879, -0.033738840371370316, 0.009950654581189156, 0.02993079088628292, -0.011557554826140404, -0.01765771210193634, 0.0060455831699073315, 0.008822792209684849, 0.012964350171387196, -0.023648720234632492, 0.026292527094483376, 0.07519080489873886, -0.036843493580818176, 0.025152537971735, 0.014698589220643044, 0.017681967467069626, 0.0033168846275657415, -0.03475755453109741, -0.01246712077409029, -0.017803242430090904, 0.0053785680793225765, -0.011824360117316246, 0.058066707104444504, 0.02105342596769333, 0.01091479416936636, -0.003495766082778573, 0.016760272905230522, -0.02360021136701107, 0.02755379118025303, 0.011308939196169376, -0.002249660436064005, 0.030415892601013184, -0.03344777971506119, -0.017075588926672935, 0.016638997942209244, -0.0033866181038320065, -0.0014863827964290977, -0.027456771582365036, -0.10041610896587372, -0.0039444854483008385, 0.005575640592724085, -0.012564141303300858, -0.03614009544253349, 0.00042105335160158575, 0.01229127123951912, -0.024012546986341476, -0.014007319696247578, -0.016736017540097237, -0.01397093664854765, -0.014140722341835499, 0.02115044556558132, 0.018373237922787666, 0.03288991376757622, -0.005960690323263407, -0.007597909774631262, -0.005205750465393066, 0.016093257814645767, 0.0018297439673915505, 0.00511479377746582, 0.0594249926507473, 0.017900262027978897, 0.030294617637991905, -0.014164977706968784, 0.02803889289498329, -0.0015030581271275878, -0.0276023019105196, 0.012194250710308552, 0.013825406320393085, -0.029421433806419373, 0.022144904360175133, -0.01997407339513302, -0.012758181430399418, 0.007573654409497976, 0.005633246619254351, 0.033180974423885345, -0.00549074774608016, -0.03633413836359978, 0.010684370994567871, -0.00871970783919096, -0.017342396080493927, 0.0298822820186615, -0.04164600372314453, 0.006427600979804993, -0.023842761293053627, -0.03638264909386635, 0.02333340421319008, -0.017669839784502983, -0.009920335374772549, 0.018931103870272636, 0.025758914649486542, -0.028257189318537712, -0.013097752816975117, 0.008070884272456169, -0.009429169818758965, 0.02876654639840126, -0.0780043974518776, -0.012430737726390362, 0.009605019353330135, -0.013437324203550816, 0.0065670679323375225, -0.003031887346878648, 0.011939572170376778, -0.0023997388780117035, 0.012891585007309914, 0.010381181724369526, 0.006391218397766352, 0.006748981308192015, 0.006627705879509449, 0.028960587456822395, 0.015668794512748718, -0.00638515455648303, 0.02144150622189045, 0.03204098343849182, -0.01808217540383339, -0.06248113512992859, -0.009289702400565147, 0.05239101126790047, -0.00975661352276802, -0.01363136526197195, -0.006718662101775408, 0.018567277118563652, -0.008804600685834885, -0.02178107760846615, 0.00449932087212801, -0.022460220381617546, 0.038468584418296814, 0.0213566143065691, 0.00762216467410326, -0.03131333366036415, 0.04327109456062317, -0.019949818029999733, -0.005584736354649067, 0.011060324497520924, -0.003347203601151705, -0.026898903772234917, 0.06830235570669174, 0.013619237579405308, -0.02709294483065605, -0.03793497383594513, -0.022581497207283974, 0.006094093434512615, 0.010484266094863415, -0.021950863301753998, 0.014637951739132404, -0.027068689465522766, -0.016432829201221466, 0.03958432003855705, 0.005763617809861898, 0.0476127564907074, -0.01779111474752426, 0.0028332986403256655, 0.027505282312631607, 0.013267538510262966, 0.02118682861328125, -0.060395196080207825, 0.05860031768679619, -0.006194145884364843, 0.020168114453554153, -0.0028939363546669483, -0.047685522586107254, 0.0051329853013157845, -0.009016833268105984, -0.007543335668742657, 0.045405544340610504, 0.013352431356906891, 0.020859384909272194, -0.010932985693216324, -0.019743649289011955, 0.013279666192829609, -0.009332149289548397, 0.006852065213024616, -0.005387663841247559, 0.004332567099481821, 0.005706011783331633, 0.010945113375782967, 0.0003782279381994158, 0.003820178098976612, -0.015729431062936783, -0.007773758843541145, -0.005548353772610426, -0.0002582788874860853, 0.004317407496273518, 0.01153936330229044, 0.035897545516490936, 0.026898903772234917, -0.006433664821088314, 0.010320544242858887, 0.027747832238674164, -0.016311554238200188, -0.01998620107769966, 0.019755776971578598, -0.025079771876335144, 0.0008860690868459642, -0.004241610411554575, -0.027359750121831894, -0.003902039024978876, 0.010472138412296772, 0.03303544223308563, -0.004265865311026573, 0.014359017834067345, 0.009653529152274132, 0.010878412052989006, -0.021562783047556877, 0.02226618118584156, 0.015329222194850445, 0.009805123321712017, 0.014540931209921837, 0.002204182092100382, 0.013510090298950672, 0.00923512876033783, -0.034563515335321426, 0.028960587456822395, 0.004371981602162123, 0.011587873101234436, -0.01825196109712124, -0.02170831337571144, -0.010199269279837608, -0.030900996178388596, -0.0169664416462183, 0.06471260637044907, 0.020641088485717773, 0.03558222949504852, 0.01645708456635475, -0.034684792160987854, -0.00992639921605587, -0.00014136174286250025, -0.006342708133161068, -0.009871824644505978, 0.02149001695215702, -0.01657835952937603, 0.014055829495191574, -0.01825196109712124, -0.01872493512928486, -0.061947520822286606, -0.007076425012201071, 0.030682699754834175, -0.014783482067286968, -0.009326085448265076, 0.0042628333903849125, -0.008089075796306133, -0.014249870553612709, 0.0005499085527844727, 0.01541411504149437, -0.00037405910552479327, -0.02699592523276806, 0.008428646251559258, -0.004475065506994724, -0.005054156295955181, 0.0031410353258252144, -0.0028954523149877787, 0.0254921093583107, 0.02544359862804413, 0.009720230475068092, -0.0015129117527976632, 0.008665134198963642, 0.026122741401195526, -0.016178151592612267, 0.04698212444782257, 0.015947727486491203, 0.016372190788388252, -0.005872765555977821, 0.0062093050219118595, 0.009028960019350052, 0.012612651102244854, -0.013279666192829609, 0.022763410583138466, -0.015693048015236855, -0.0033350761514157057, -0.025977211073040962, 0.029906535521149635, -0.014468166045844555, 0.030634189024567604, 0.03531542420387268, 0.007343231234699488, 0.020483430474996567, 0.005357345100492239, 0.022314690053462982, -0.065828338265419, -0.011690957471728325, 0.010563095100224018, -0.04586639255285263, -0.010908730328083038, 0.02854824997484684, 0.012091166339814663, 0.021126190200448036, 0.026001466438174248, 0.018955359235405922, 0.013582855463027954, -0.029809515923261642, -0.007270465604960918, 0.002220857422798872, 0.01636006310582161, -0.02037428319454193, 0.03272012621164322, -0.020653216168284416, -0.00528457947075367, 0.011982019059360027, 0.009671720676124096, -0.02803889289498329, 0.03259885311126709, 0.014468166045844555, -0.019185783341526985, 0.003941453527659178, 0.009404914453625679, 0.0069975960068404675, -0.01263690646737814, 0.053894829005002975, -0.013922426849603653, -0.09755400568246841, 0.018530895933508873, 0.01834898255765438, 0.01091479416936636, 0.007306848186999559, 0.028742291033267975, -0.006573131773620844, 0.01524432934820652, -0.009671720676124096, -0.010799583047628403, 0.01740303263068199, -0.02373361401259899, 0.00009294629853684455, 0.046351492404937744, -0.008240669965744019, -0.06573131680488586, -0.04421704262495041, 0.023187873885035515, -0.012818819843232632, 0.010799583047628403, 0.023102981969714165, 0.004238578490912914, 0.020556196570396423, 0.0027120232116431, 0.028912076726555824, -0.032186515629291534, -0.018870467320084572, -0.014431783929467201, 0.0509842187166214, 0.024606797844171524, 0.015159436501562595, 0.005875797476619482, -0.033908627927303314, 0.02024088054895401, -0.019391952082514763, -0.0038141142576932907, -0.0011612128000706434, 0.037619657814502716, -0.021587038412690163, -0.016166023910045624, -0.026244016364216805, -0.010290225967764854, 0.02738400548696518, 0.022933196276426315, 0.031143546104431152, 0.01933131366968155, -0.012194250710308552, 0.0147713553160429, 0.010544904507696629, 0.048946790397167206, 0.006048615090548992, 0.0015333769842982292, 0.016566231846809387, -0.0008254313142970204, -0.001257475232705474, 0.028790801763534546, 0.014989650808274746, 0.014359017834067345, 0.005897020921111107, -0.0024861476849764585, -0.02888782136142254, 0.01760920137166977, -0.006488238926976919, -0.039511553943157196, -0.05360376834869385, -0.011357449926435947, -0.03922049328684807, 0.03284140303730965, 0.027456771582365036, -0.026462312787771225, 0.003110716352239251, 0.026947414502501488, 0.009726294316351414, 0.009908207692205906, 0.013413069769740105, -0.025516362860798836, 0.0073614222928881645, 0.01184255164116621, -0.027141455560922623, 0.022630006074905396, 0.0023391011636704206, 0.0008618139545433223, 0.01156361773610115, -0.0065670679323375225, -0.020398538559675217, 0.03339926898479462, -0.018409619107842445, -0.020568324252963066, -0.01782749779522419, 0.007919290103018284, -0.010550967417657375, -0.0044204918667674065, 0.02677762880921364, 0.010684370994567871, 0.02748102694749832, 0.006157763302326202, 0.043513648211956024, -0.05011103302240372, -0.004453842528164387, 0.012339781038463116, -0.02032577246427536, -0.01718473806977272, -0.01868855394423008, -0.03686774894595146, -0.011145217344164848, -0.024728072807192802, 0.024703817442059517, 0.02772357687354088, 0.009938526898622513, 0.012673288583755493, 0.032623108476400375, 0.03170141205191612, -0.02410956844687462, 0.062238581478595734, 0.023648720234632492, 0.010405437089502811, -0.008543858304619789, -0.008064820431172848, 0.040239207446575165, -0.015899216756224632, 0.0076828026212751865, -0.011163408868014812, -0.03065844438970089, -0.022460220381617546, 0.004162781406193972, -0.04509022831916809, 0.010817773640155792, -0.0116060646250844, -0.02738400548696518, 0.025152537971735, -0.002295138780027628, 0.0017675902927294374, 0.03320522978901863, 0.002283011097460985, -0.027893362566828728, 0.02230256237089634, 0.023442553356289864, 0.05748458206653595, 0.003413905156776309, 0.013594983145594597, 0.0015417146496474743, 0.002355776494368911, 0.016772400587797165, 0.004999582190066576, -0.02075023762881756, 0.011502980254590511, 0.0010664663277566433, -0.006160795222967863, 0.022157032042741776, 0.030246106907725334, -0.024182332679629326, 0.006748981308192015, -0.022108521312475204, 0.02221767045557499, 0.004829796496778727, 0.014637951739132404, -0.009307893924415112, -0.022108521312475204, -0.0009580763871781528, 0.0075251441448926926, 0.028621016070246696, 0.03109503537416458, 0.013704130426049232, 0.01513518113642931, -0.018409619107842445, 0.01774260401725769, -0.028087403625249863, -0.007676738779991865, -0.03725583106279373, -0.040239207446575165, 0.008646942675113678, -0.07184360176324844, 0.007543335668742657, 0.018227705731987953, -0.02424297109246254, 0.01885833963751793, -0.01726962998509407, 0.019064506515860558, -0.003835337469354272, 0.010781391523778439, -0.008040565066039562, 0.01743941567838192, 0.003231991780921817, -0.0206774715334177, 0.0541858896613121, 0.03805625066161156, 0.001951019512489438, -0.010308416560292244, -0.002615002915263176, 0.016396446153521538, -0.002658965066075325, 0.05952201038599014, -0.010514585301280022, 0.0292031392455101, 0.024303609505295753, 0.020616833120584488, -0.02665635384619236, 0.020058967173099518, -0.02704443410038948, -0.007349294610321522, -0.019658757373690605, 0.0040718247182667255, -0.03264736384153366, -0.02631678245961666, -0.014164977706968784, -0.012552013620734215, 0.009659592993557453, -0.03466053679585457, -0.031070781871676445, -0.03048865869641304, -0.0019282803405076265, -0.011017878539860249, 0.03233204782009125, 0.03630988299846649, 0.052002932876348495, -0.05830925703048706, 0.02213277667760849, -0.047006379812955856, 0.009423105977475643, -0.06878745555877686, -0.014710716903209686, -0.038177523761987686, -0.006797491572797298, 0.04690936207771301, -0.01872493512928486, 0.00724621070548892, 0.013170518912374973, -0.04147621989250183, -0.04074856638908386, 0.012345844879746437, 0.041912809014320374, -0.010672243312001228, -0.008871302008628845, -0.004041505977511406, -0.04402300342917442, -0.02115044556558132, -0.02398829162120819, -0.02182958833873272, -0.014880502596497536, 0.003332044230774045, 0.03669796511530876, 0.006700471043586731, 0.00456602219492197, 0.03441798314452171, -0.01622666046023369, 0.023964038118720055, 0.014856248162686825, -0.012673288583755493, 0.004005122929811478, -0.008119394071400166, -0.004632723983377218, -0.0017524308059364557, -0.01033267192542553, -0.000012411788702593185, -0.013607109896838665, 0.0048207007348537445, -0.014310508035123348, 0.03611584007740021, 0.027966128662228584, 0.007064297329634428, 0.002819655230268836, 0.006670152302831411, -0.0384928397834301, 0.0005218635778874159, 0.02837846428155899, 0.004159749485552311, -0.029955046251416206, 0.018094303086400032, -0.01460156962275505, -0.026583587750792503, 0.017597073689103127, -0.0506446473300457, 0.02282404713332653, 0.0010748039931058884, -0.003977836109697819, 0.009465551935136318, 0.014298380352556705, -0.02837846428155899, 0.011472661979496479, 0.00824673380702734, -0.0064033460803329945, -0.04300428926944733, -0.02588018961250782, -0.0005798484198749065, -0.003968740347772837, 0.015147308818995953, -0.008434710092842579, -0.030003556981682777, 0.04409576952457428, -0.016857292503118515, -0.009532253257930279, 0.05675692856311798, 0.0048570833168923855, 0.013400942087173462, -0.008877365849912167, -0.01693005859851837, 0.019185783341526985, -0.0020556196104735136, 0.03837156668305397, 0.009107789024710655, -0.015389859676361084, -0.0011089127510786057, 0.0021208052057772875, 0.014055829495191574, -0.007670674938708544, -0.004232514649629593, -0.0147713553160429, -0.022326817736029625, -0.025613384321331978, -0.030779719352722168, 0.008331626653671265, -0.011545427143573761, 0.0005813643801957369, 0.004796445835381746, -0.006894511636346579, -0.032283537089824677, -0.0002779861679300666, 0.0386626273393631, 0.03160439431667328, -0.00015746864664833993, -0.05263356491923332, -0.009429169818758965, 0.01787600666284561, 0.014710716903209686, -0.015499007888138294, 0.008962258696556091, -0.027747832238674164, -0.006276006810367107, 0.008319498971104622, 0.03759540244936943, 0.01774260401725769, 0.01632368192076683, -0.007798014208674431, -0.0020055933855473995, -0.014456038363277912, 0.033350761979818344, 0.00019034567230846733, -0.008768217638134956, 0.005915211979299784, 0.017281757667660713, -0.023660847917199135, 0.0125762689858675, -0.010581286624073982, -0.018543023616075516, 0.002590747782960534, 0.0072340830229222775, 0.003935389686375856, -0.0016235756920650601, -0.025783170014619827, 0.01748792640864849, 0.05753309279680252, -0.01095724105834961, 0.012412546202540398, 0.0007666884921491146, 0.014577314257621765, -0.025176791474223137, -0.0019601150415837765, -0.0007621406693942845, 0.011405959725379944, -0.04227663576602936, -0.012806692160665989, 0.007579718250781298, -0.012855201959609985, 0.018324727192521095, 0.012376164086163044, 0.004080920480191708, -0.01739090494811535, 0.024437012150883675, -0.016372190788388252, 0.018106430768966675, -0.03689200431108475, 0.013231156393885612, -0.014844120480120182, -0.009041087701916695, -0.016736017540097237, -0.005848510656505823, 0.0038868794217705727, 0.011945636011660099, -0.008804600685834885, 0.019670885056257248, -0.0023148460313677788, -0.014189232140779495, 0.00841651950031519, 0.0030409828759729862, -0.03216226026415825, -0.0548650324344635, -0.024267226457595825, 0.02096853218972683, 0.013425197452306747, 0.012867329642176628, 0.02363659255206585, -0.0023694199044257402, 0.00504809245467186, 0.001016440219245851, -0.04838892072439194, 0.011975955218076706, 0.00006305378337856382, 0.016736017540097237, -0.019707268103957176, 0.015110926702618599, -0.024861475452780724, -0.01958599127829075, 0.012406483292579651, 0.0004892708384431899, -0.01701495237648487, 0.009568636305630207, 0.013012859970331192, 0.02105342596769333, 0.03189545497298241, 0.00015206809621304274, 0.00041953742038458586, -0.006748981308192015, -0.033520545810461044, 0.03269587457180023, 0.048558708280324936, -0.012964350171387196, 0.012454993091523647, 0.008307371288537979, -0.007700993679463863, -0.015450498089194298, -0.044120024889707565, 0.0019570833537727594, -0.016032619401812553, 0.010926921851933002, -0.02020449750125408, -0.02002258412539959, 0.0023951909970492125, 0.018276216462254524, -0.03027036227285862, -0.006561004091054201, -0.033520545810461044, 0.011387769132852554, 0.007228019181638956, 0.0298822820186615, -0.014249870553612709, 0.010896602645516396, 0.025686148554086685, 0.012903712689876556, -0.03597031161189079, 0.029688240960240364, -0.01674814522266388, -0.0029197074472904205, 0.010308416560292244, 0.038686882704496384, 0.009404914453625679, 0.014116466976702213, -0.010763199999928474, 0.01108457986265421, 0.009247256442904472, -0.027917617931962013, 0.0013908783439546824, 0.025079771876335144, 0.042737483978271484, 0.02209639549255371, 0.03548520803451538, 0.01535347755998373, -0.005951594561338425, -0.04448385164141655, -0.0298822820186615, -0.015499007888138294, 0.022969577461481094, -0.0018433874938637018, 0.0023330373223870993, 0.004556926432996988, -0.009956717491149902, 0.01524432934820652, 0.012988605536520481, 0.012000209651887417, -0.024218715727329254, -0.01912514492869377, 0.023588083684444427, 0.029906535521149635, 0.0012938579311594367, -0.013776895590126514, -0.014516676776111126, -0.019864926114678383, 0.01679665595293045, -0.037910718470811844, 0.021198956295847893, 0.03909922018647194, -0.01449242141097784, -0.004375013522803783, 0.027189966291189194, 0.00876215472817421, 0.017863880842924118, 0.0038080504164099693, -0.0027635651640594006, -0.01563241146504879, 0.046060431748628616, 0.022193415090441704, 0.0023300054017454386, -0.009532253257930279, -0.03621286153793335, -0.025176791474223137, -0.0000902933970792219, -0.018288344144821167, -0.017512181773781776, -0.00007603404810652137, 0.005954626481980085, -0.0001489414571551606, -0.009459488093852997, -0.017900262027978897, -0.006042551249265671, 0.015110926702618599, 0.02532232366502285, -0.008495348505675793, -0.012552013620734215, 0.004490225110203028, -0.0027726609259843826, 0.004002091474831104, -0.019149400293827057, 0.010120440274477005, -0.004469001665711403, 0.029300158843398094, 0.04926210641860962, -0.02230256237089634, -0.0022390487138181925, -0.01649346761405468, -0.018761318176984787, 0.02898484282195568, 0.004829796496778727, -0.014055829495191574, 0.027699321508407593, -0.030900996178388596, -0.03126482293009758, -0.015656666830182076, -0.005872765555977821, -0.023066598922014236, -0.04103962704539299, 0.03048865869641304, -0.0053330897353589535, -0.038905177265405655, 0.013813278637826443, 0.0068399375304579735, -0.009847570210695267, 0.00484495609998703, -0.023478934541344643, 0.02660784311592579, 0.00676110852509737, 0.000967172032687813, 0.02687464840710163, -0.009477679617702961, -0.0021935703698545694, 0.0029773132409900427, 0.01865217089653015, 0.025734659284353256, 0.004223418887704611, -0.0418642982840538, 0.001143021509051323, 0.01993769034743309, -0.015280712395906448, -0.04785531014204025, -0.02265426144003868, -0.005272452253848314, 0.011781914159655571, 0.02467956207692623, 0.015583900734782219, 0.026001466438174248, 0.021841716021299362, 0.012830947525799274, 0.02441275678575039, -0.017027078196406364, -0.016736017540097237, 0.04150047525763512, 0.01263690646737814, 0.01693005859851837, 0.0028696812223643064, 0.0021010979544371367, 0.00250888685695827, 0.008713643997907639, 0.04116090387105942, 0.005436174105852842, -0.006858129054307938, -0.010247779078781605, 0.011830423958599567, 0.016978569328784943, 0.03509712591767311, -0.011399895884096622, 0.023418297991156578, 0.03354480117559433, -0.019307058304548264, -0.018070047721266747, 0.0028590697329491377, -0.00724621070548892, -0.009350340813398361, 0.01649346761405468, -0.034442238509655, -0.00556654529646039, -0.028912076726555824, -0.026632098481059074, 0.012600523419678211, -0.009774805046617985, 0.014916885644197464, -0.006239624228328466, -0.009568636305630207, 0.03825028985738754, 0.04392598196864128, 0.005484683904796839, -0.011315003037452698, -0.003241087542846799, -0.02415807731449604, 0.022278307005763054, -0.03514563664793968, -0.022811919450759888, -0.025564873591065407, -0.012479248456656933, 0.058842867612838745, -0.03439372777938843, 0.0006836905959062278, 0.02256936952471733, -0.0037352852523326874, 0.030246106907725334, 0.04749148339033127, 0.003192577278241515, 0.015826452523469925, 0.005745426286011934, -0.008125457912683487, 0.0172211192548275, 0.01679665595293045, -0.02842697501182556, -0.008192159235477448, -0.0335933119058609, 0.01363136526197195, -0.005545321851968765, 0.01223063375800848, 0.0808665007352829, -0.026510823518037796, -0.031798433512449265, 0.02604997530579567, 0.010714690200984478, -0.006482175085693598, -0.005924307741224766, 0.010356927290558815, -0.008058756589889526, -0.024267226457595825, 0.01921003870666027, 0.011248301714658737, 0.00583638297393918, -0.018785573542118073, 0.018324727192521095, -0.010435756295919418, 0.016893675550818443, -0.016178151592612267, 0.001036905450746417, -0.0059364354237914085, -0.006991532165557146, -0.02324851229786873, -0.014892630279064178, 0.01804579235613346, -0.025904444977641106, 0.014953267760574818, -0.00666408846154809, -0.044677890837192535, 0.01924641989171505, -0.011042133904993534, 0.0073250397108495235, -0.026801884174346924, -0.020046839490532875, 0.01602049171924591, -0.024400629103183746, 0.007579718250781298, 0.043683432042598724, -0.014650079421699047, 0.01993769034743309, 0.02480083890259266, 0.020956404507160187, -0.04213110730051994, 0.025298068299889565, 0.006151699461042881, 0.03155588358640671, -0.024036802351474762, 0.0258316807448864, -0.0014249869855120778, -0.005360376555472612, 0.019440460950136185, 0.003704966278746724, 0.012794564478099346, 0.00418703630566597, 0.031143546104431152, -0.002430057618767023, -0.0034563515800982714, -0.039244748651981354, 0.020810874179005623, 0.01074500847607851, -0.03383586183190346, -0.0064033460803329945, -0.0022875589784234762, 0.01369200274348259, -0.011515107937157154, -0.014577314257621765, 0.024958496913313866, -0.02329702116549015, -0.008822792209684849, -0.003441191976889968, -0.010247779078781605, 0.009592891670763493, -0.016044747084379196, 0.0032441194634884596, -0.013704130426049232, -0.006779300048947334, -0.01971939578652382, -0.021890226751565933, -0.02772357687354088, -0.0019479875918477774, 0.04176728054881096, 0.018288344144821167, -0.006742917466908693, 0.020689599215984344, -0.0027120232116431, 0.0006518557784147561, -0.01748792640864849, 0.0035230531357228756, -0.012673288583755493, 0.010326608084142208, -0.01657835952937603, -0.01294009480625391, 0.015511135570704937, -0.03354480117559433, -0.0013370623346418142, -0.03235630318522453, 0.025249557569622993, 0.03691625967621803, -0.007610036991536617, 0.02393978275358677, -0.024170204997062683, -0.0216112919151783, 0.02110193483531475, 0.01598411053419113, -0.0013082593213766813, -0.003956613130867481, 0.029858026653528214, 0.010842029005289078, 0.028960587456822395, -0.012406483292579651, 0.01657835952937603, -0.011933508329093456, 0.02264213375747204, -0.01085415668785572, -0.017863880842924118 ]
12.76255
4.407759
2024-07-01
3
2024A&A...687A.178G
[ "galaxy clusters", "eRASS1 clusters", "cluster member contamination", "clusters", "mock cluster catalogs", "mass calibration", "low lens redshifts", "high lens redshift", "WL mass calibration", "mass measurements" ]
[ "gravitational lensing: weak", "large-scale structure of Universe", "X-rays: galaxies: clusters", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
38
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202348615", "10.48550/arXiv.2402.08455" ]
[ "Grandis, S.", "Ghirardini, V.", "Bocquet, S.", "Garrel, C.", "Mohr, J. J.", "Liu, A.", "Kluge, M.", "Kimmig, L.", "Reiprich, T. H.", "Alarcon, A.", "Amon, A.", "Artis, E.", "Bahar, Y. E.", "Balzer, F.", "Bechtol, K.", "Becker, M. R.", "Bernstein, G.", "Bulbul, E.", "Campos, A.", "Carnero Rosell, A.", "Carrasco Kind, M.", "Cawthon, R.", "Chang, C.", "Chen, R.", "Chiu, I.", "Choi, A.", "Clerc, N.", "Comparat, J.", "Cordero, J.", "Davis, C.", "Derose, J.", "Diehl, H. T.", "Dodelson, S.", "Doux, C.", "Drlica-Wagner, A.", "Eckert, K.", "Elvin-Poole, J.", "Everett, S.", "Ferte, A.", "Gatti, M.", "Giannini, G.", "Giles, P.", "Gruen, D.", "Gruendl, R. A.", "Harrison, I.", "Hartley, W. G.", "Herner, K.", "Huff, E. M.", "Kleinebreil, F.", "Kuropatkin, N.", "Leget, P. F.", "Maccrann, N.", "Mccullough, J.", "Merloni, A.", "Myles, J.", "Nandra, K.", "Navarro-Alsina, A.", "Okabe, N.", "Pacaud, F.", "Pandey, S.", "Prat, J.", "Predehl, P.", "Ramos, M.", "Raveri, M.", "Rollins, R. P.", "Roodman, A.", "Ross, A. J.", "Rykoff, E. S.", "Sanchez, C.", "Sanders, J.", "Schrabback, T.", "Secco, L. F.", "Seppi, R.", "Sevilla-Noarbe, I.", "Sheldon, E.", "Shin, T.", "Troxel, M.", "Tutusaus, I.", "Varga, T. N.", "Wu, H.", "Yanny, B.", "Yin, B.", "Zhang, X.", "Zhang, Y.", "Alves, O.", "Bhargava, S.", "Brooks, D.", "Burke, D. L.", "Carretero, J.", "Costanzi, M.", "da Costa, L. N.", "Pereira, M. E. S.", "De Vicente, J.", "Desai, S.", "Doel, P.", "Ferrero, I.", "Flaugher, B.", "Friedel, D.", "Frieman, J.", "García-Bellido, J.", "Gutierrez, G.", "Hinton, S. R.", "Hollowood, D. L.", "Honscheid, K.", "James, D. J.", "Jeffrey, N.", "Lahav, O.", "Lee, S.", "Marshall, J. L.", "Menanteau, F.", "Ogando, R. L. C.", "Pieres, A.", "Plazas Malagón, A. A.", "Romer, A. K.", "Sanchez, E.", "Schubnell, M.", "Smith, M.", "Suchyta, E.", "Swanson, M. E. C.", "Tarle, G.", "Weaverdyck, N.", "Weller, J." ]
[ "Universität Innsbruck, Institut für Astro- und Teilchenphysik, Technikerstr. 25/8, 6020, Innsbruck, Austria", "Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse 1, 85748, Garching, Germany", "Faculty of Physics, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Scheinerstr. 1, 81679, Munich, Germany", "Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse 1, 85748, Garching, Germany", "Faculty of Physics, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Scheinerstr. 1, 81679, Munich, Germany; Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse 1, 85748, Garching, Germany", "Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse 1, 85748, Garching, Germany", "Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse 1, 85748, Garching, Germany", "Faculty of Physics, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Scheinerstr. 1, 81679, Munich, Germany", "Argelander-Institut für Astronomie (AIfA), Universität Bonn, Auf dem Hügel 71, 53121, Bonn, Germany", "Linköpings Universitet, Institutionen för Systemteknik, Linköpings Universitet, Linköping, 581 83, Sweden", "Kavli Institute for Cosmology, University of Cambridge, Madingley Road, Cambridge, CB3 0HA, UK; Institute of Astronomy, University of Cambridge, Madingley Road, Cambridge, CB3 0HA, UK", "Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse 1, 85748, Garching, Germany", "Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse 1, 85748, Garching, Germany", "Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse 1, 85748, Garching, Germany; Faculty of Physics, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Scheinerstr. 1, 81679, Munich, Germany", "Physics Department, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, WI, 53706, USA", "Argonne National Laboratory, 9700 South Cass Avenue, Lemont, IL, 60439, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, 19104, USA", "Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse 1, 85748, Garching, Germany", "Department of Physics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA, 15312, USA", "Instituto de Astrofisica de Canarias, 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Laboratório Interinstitucional de e-Astronomia - LIneA, Rua Gal. José Cristino 77, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, 20921-400, Brazil; Universidad de La Laguna, Dpto. Astrofísica, 38206, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain", "Center for Astrophysical Surveys, National Center for Supercomputing Applications, 1205 West Clark St., Urbana, IL, 61801, USA; Department of Astronomy, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 1002 W. Green Street, Urbana, IL, 61801, USA", "Physics Department, William Jewell College, Liberty, MO, 64068, USA", "Department of Astronomy and Astrophysics, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, 60637, USA; Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, 60637, USA", "Department of Physics, Duke University Durham, Durham, NC, 27708, USA", "Department of Physics, National Cheng Kung University, 70101, Tainan, Taiwan", "NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, 8800 Greenbelt Rd, Greenbelt, MD, 20771, USA", "IRAP, Université de Toulouse, CNRS, UPS, CNES, Toulouse, France", "Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse 1, 85748, Garching, Germany", "Jodrell Bank Center for Astrophysics, School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester, M13 9PL, UK", "School of Mathematics and Physics, University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD 4072, Australia", "Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 1 Cyclotron Road, Berkeley, CA, 94720, USA", "Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, PO Box 500, Batavia, IL, 60510, USA", "Department of Physics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA, 15312, USA; NSF AI Planning Institute for Physics of the Future, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA, 15213, USA", "Universidad de La Laguna, Dpto. Astrofísica, 38206, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Université Grenoble Alpes, CNRS, LPSC-IN2P3, 38000, Grenoble, France", "Department of Astronomy and Astrophysics, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, 60637, USA; Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, 60637, USA; Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, PO Box 500, Batavia, IL, 60510, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, 19104, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Waterloo, 200 University Ave W, Waterloo, ON, N2L 3G1, Canada", "Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, 4800 Oak Grove Dr., Pasadena, CA, 91109, USA", "SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory, Menlo Park, CA, 94025, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, 19104, USA", "Institut de Física d'Altes Energies (IFAE), The Barcelona Institute of Science and Technology, Campus UAB, 08193, Bellaterra (Barcelona), Spain", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Sussex, Pevensey Building, Brighton, BN1 9QH, UK", "Faculty of Physics, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Scheinerstr. 1, 81679, Munich, Germany", "Center for Astrophysical Surveys, National Center for Supercomputing Applications, 1205 West Clark St., Urbana, IL, 61801, USA; Department of Astronomy, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 1002 W. Green Street, Urbana, IL, 61801, USA", "School of Physics and Astronomy, Cardiff University, Cardiff, CF24 3AA, UK", "Department of Astronomy, University of Geneva, ch. d'Écogia 16, 1290, Versoix, Switzerland", "Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, PO Box 500, Batavia, IL, 60510, USA", "Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, 4800 Oak Grove Dr., Pasadena, CA, 91109, USA", "Universität Innsbruck, Institut für Astro- und Teilchenphysik, Technikerstr. 25/8, 6020, Innsbruck, Austria", "Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, PO Box 500, Batavia, IL, 60510, USA", "Kavli Institute for Particle Astrophysics &amp; Cosmology, Stanford University, PO Box 2450, Stanford, CA, 94305, USA", "Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, CB3 0WA, UK", "Kavli Institute for Particle Astrophysics &amp; Cosmology, Stanford University, PO Box 2450, Stanford, CA, 94305, USA", "Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse 1, 85748, Garching, Germany", "Faculty of Physics, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Scheinerstr. 1, 81679, Munich, Germany; Kavli Institute for Particle Astrophysics &amp; Cosmology, Stanford University, PO Box 2450, Stanford, CA, 94305, USA; Department of Physics, Stanford University, 382 Via Pueblo Mall, Stanford, CA, 94305, USA", "Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse 1, 85748, Garching, Germany", "Instituto de Física Gleb Wataghin, Universidade Estadual de Campinas, 13083-859, Campinas, SP, Brazil", "Physics Program, Graduate School of Advanced Science and Engineering, Hiroshima University, 1-3-1 Kagamiyama, Higashi-Hiroshima, Hiroshima, 739-8526, Japan; Hiroshima Astrophysical Science Center, Hiroshima University, 1-3-1 Kagamiyama, Higashi-Hiroshima, Hiroshima, 739-8526, Japan; Core Research for Energetic Universe, Hiroshima University, 1-3-1, Kagamiyama, Higashi-Hiroshima, Hiroshima, 739-8526, Japan", "Argelander-Institut für Astronomie (AIfA), Universität Bonn, Auf dem Hügel 71, 53121, Bonn, Germany", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, 19104, USA", "Department of Astronomy and Astrophysics, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, 60637, USA; Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, 60637, USA", "Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse 1, 85748, Garching, Germany", "Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse 1, 85748, Garching, Germany", "Department of Physics, University of Genova and INFN, Via Dodecaneso 33, 16146, Genova, Italy", "Jodrell Bank Center for Astrophysics, School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester, M13 9PL, UK", "SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory, Menlo Park, CA, 94025, USA; Kavli Institute for Particle Astrophysics &amp; Cosmology, Stanford University, PO Box 2450, Stanford, CA, 94305, USA", "Center for Cosmology and Astro-Particle Physics, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, 43210, USA", "SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory, Menlo Park, CA, 94025, USA; Kavli Institute for Particle Astrophysics &amp; Cosmology, Stanford University, PO Box 2450, Stanford, CA, 94305, USA", "Centro de Investigaciones Energéticas, Medioambientales y Tecnológicas (CIEMAT), Madrid, Spain", "Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse 1, 85748, Garching, Germany", "Universität Innsbruck, Institut für Astro- und Teilchenphysik, Technikerstr. 25/8, 6020, Innsbruck, Austria", "Department of Astronomy and Astrophysics, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, 60637, USA; Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, 60637, USA", "Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse 1, 85748, Garching, Germany", "Centro de Investigaciones Energéticas, Medioambientales y Tecnológicas (CIEMAT), Madrid, Spain", "Brookhaven National Laboratory, Bldg 510, Upton, NY, 11973, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, Stony Brook University, Stony Brook, NY, 11794, USA", "Department of Physics, Duke University Durham, Durham, NC, 27708, USA", "Département de Physique Théorique and Center for Astroparticle Physics (CAP), University of Geneva, 24 quai Ernest Ansermet, 1211, Genève, Switzerland; Institut de Recherche en Astrophysique et Planétologie (IRAP), Université de Toulouse, CNRS, UPS, CNES, 14 Av. Edouard Belin, 31400, Toulouse, France", "Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse 1, 85748, Garching, Germany; Faculty of Physics, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Scheinerstr. 1, 81679, Munich, Germany", "Department of Physics, Boise State University, Boise, ID, 83725, USA", "Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, 4800 Oak Grove Dr., Pasadena, CA, 91109, USA", "McWilliams Center for Cosmology, Department of Physics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA, 15213, USA", "Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse 1, 85748, Garching, Germany", "Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, 48109, USA", "Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, 48109, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Sussex, Pevensey Building, Brighton, BN1 9QH, UK", "Department of Physics &amp; Astronomy, University College London, Gower Street, London, WC1E 6BT, UK", "SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory, Menlo Park, CA, 94025, USA; Kavli Institute for Particle Astrophysics &amp; Cosmology, Stanford University, PO Box 2450, Stanford, CA, 94305, USA", "Institut de Física d'Altes Energies (IFAE), The Barcelona Institute of Science and Technology, Campus UAB, 08193, Bellaterra (Barcelona), Spain", "Astronomy Unit, Department of Physics, University of Trieste, Via Tiepolo 11, 34131, Trieste, Italy; INAF-Osservatorio Astronomico di Trieste, Via G. B. Tiepolo 11, 34143, Trieste, Italy; Institute for Fundamental Physics of the Universe, Via Beirut 2, 34014, Trieste, Italy", "Laboratório Interinstitucional de e-Astronomia - LIneA, Rua Gal. José Cristino 77, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, 20921-400, Brazil", "Hamburger Sternwarte, Universität Hamburg, Gojenbergsweg 112, 21029, Hamburg, Germany", "Centro de Investigaciones Energéticas, Medioambientales y Tecnológicas (CIEMAT), Madrid, Spain", "Department of Physics, IIT Hyderabad, Kandi, Telangana, 502285, India", "Department of Physics &amp; Astronomy, University College London, Gower Street, London, WC1E 6BT, UK", "Institute of Theoretical Astrophysics, University of Oslo, PO Box 1029 Blindern, 0315, Oslo, Norway", "Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, PO Box 500, Batavia, IL, 60510, USA", "Center for Astrophysical Surveys, National Center for Supercomputing Applications, 1205 West Clark St., Urbana, IL, 61801, USA", "Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, 60637, USA; Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, PO Box 500, Batavia, IL, 60510, USA", "Core Research for Energetic Universe, Hiroshima University, 1-3-1, Kagamiyama, Higashi-Hiroshima, Hiroshima, 739-8526, Japan; Instituto de Fisica Teorica UAM/CSIC, Universidad Autonoma de Madrid, 28049, Madrid, Spain", "Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, PO Box 500, Batavia, IL, 60510, USA", "School of Mathematics and Physics, University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD 4072, Australia", "Santa Cruz Institute for Particle Physics, Santa Cruz, CA, 95064, USA", "Center for Cosmology and Astro-Particle Physics, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, 43210, USA; Department of Physics, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, 43210, USA; Center for Astrophysics | Harvard &amp; Smithsonian, 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA, 02138, USA", "Center for Astrophysics | Harvard &amp; Smithsonian, 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA, 02138, USA", "Department of Physics &amp; Astronomy, University College London, Gower Street, London, WC1E 6BT, UK", "Department of Physics &amp; Astronomy, University College London, Gower Street, London, WC1E 6BT, UK", "Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, 4800 Oak Grove Dr., Pasadena, CA, 91109, USA", "George P. and Cynthia Woods Mitchell Institute for Fundamental Physics and Astronomy, and Department of Physics and Astronomy, Texas A&amp;M University, College Station, TX, 77843, USA", "Center for Astrophysical Surveys, National Center for Supercomputing Applications, 1205 West Clark St., Urbana, IL, 61801, USA; Department of Astronomy, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 1002 W. Green Street, Urbana, IL, 61801, USA", "Observatório Nacional, Rua Gal. José Cristino 77, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, 20921-400, Brazil", "Laboratório Interinstitucional de e-Astronomia - LIneA, Rua Gal. José Cristino 77, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, 20921-400, Brazil; Observatório Nacional, Rua Gal. José Cristino 77, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, 20921-400, Brazil", "SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory, Menlo Park, CA, 94025, USA; Kavli Institute for Particle Astrophysics &amp; Cosmology, Stanford University, PO Box 2450, Stanford, CA, 94305, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Sussex, Pevensey Building, Brighton, BN1 9QH, UK", "Centro de Investigaciones Energéticas, Medioambientales y Tecnológicas (CIEMAT), Madrid, Spain", "Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, 48109, USA", "School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Southampton, Southampton, SO17 1BJ, UK", "Computer Science and Mathematics Division, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, TN, 37831, USA", "Center for Astrophysical Surveys, National Center for Supercomputing Applications, 1205 West Clark St., Urbana, IL, 61801, USA", "Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, 48109, USA", "Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 1 Cyclotron Road, Berkeley, CA, 94720, USA; Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, 48109, USA", "Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics, Giessenbachstrasse 1, 85748, Garching, Germany; Faculty of Physics, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Scheinerstr. 1, 81679, Munich, Germany" ]
[ "2024A&A...685A.106B", "2024arXiv240417345L", "2024arXiv240614754K" ]
[ "1920RSPTA.220..291D", "1996ApJ...462..563N", "1997ApJ...491...38M", "2000ApJ...536..571B", "2001ApJ...553..545H", "2003MNRAS.338...14P", "2004ApJ...613...41M", "2006glsw.conf..269S", "2008ApJ...688..729W", "2011ARA&A..49..409A", "2011ApJ...735L..36S", "2011ApJ...740...25B", "2011ApJS..192...18K", "2011MNRAS.414.1851O", "2012ApJ...761...22S", "2012MNRAS.421.1073B", "2012MNRAS.426.2046A", "2012MNRAS.427.1298H", "2014ApJ...785..104R", "2014MNRAS.442.1507G", "2015AJ....150..150F", "2015MNRAS.446.2205M", "2015MNRAS.453...38R", "2015MNRAS.454.2305S", "2016ApJS..224....1R", "2016MNRAS.459.3078D", "2016MNRAS.463.3582M", "2017ApJ...841...24S", "2017MNRAS.467.4015H", "2017MNRAS.468.1917R", "2017arXiv170202600H", "2018ARA&A..56..435W", "2018ApJ...859...55C", "2018MNRAS.475..624N", "2018MNRAS.475..648P", "2018MNRAS.475..676S", "2018MNRAS.477.1206N", "2018MNRAS.480.5113M", "2019AJ....157..168D", "2019ApJ...872L..30A", "2019ApJ...874..165Z", "2019ApJ...878...55B", "2019ComAC...6....2N", "2019MNRAS.482.1352M", "2019MNRAS.483.2871D", "2019MNRAS.484.1598B", "2019MNRAS.487.2005C", "2019MNRAS.488.2041G", "2019MNRAS.489.2511V", "2020A&A...640A.117H", "2020A&ARv..28....7U", "2020ApJS..247...25B", "2020MNRAS.496.4468S", "2020MNRAS.498..771G", "2020PhRvD.102b3509A", "2021A&A...647A...1P", "2021A&A...656A.132S", "2021ApJS..254...24S", "2021JOSS....6.3001B", "2021MNRAS.500.2316C", "2021MNRAS.500.5056R", "2021MNRAS.501.1282J", "2021MNRAS.504.1253G", "2021MNRAS.504.4312G", "2021MNRAS.505.3923S", "2021MNRAS.505.4249M", "2021MNRAS.507.5671G", "2021MNRAS.507.5758S", "2021MNRAS.508.3125F", "2022A&A...661A..11C", "2022A&A...665A..78S", "2022A&A...668A..18Z", "2022MNRAS.509.3371M", "2022MNRAS.511.2170C", "2022MNRAS.515.4471W", "2022PhRvD.105b3520A", "2022PhRvD.105h3528P", "2023A&A...673A.122C", "2023A&ARv..31....2H", "2023ApJ...949...92K", "2023MNRAS.521.5064S", "2023MNRAS.522.1601C", "2023arXiv230613187S", "2023arXiv231012213B", "2024A&A...682A..34M", "2024A&A...685A.106B", "2024MNRAS.527..895P", "2024arXiv240208456K", "2024arXiv240208458G" ]
29097412
2406.07605
Unveiling the (in)consistencies among the galaxy stellar mass function, star formation histories, satellite abundances, and intracluster light from a semi-empirical perspective
In a hierarchical, dark matter-dominated Universe, stellar mass functions (SMFs), galaxy merger rates, star formation histories (SFHs), satellite abundances, and intracluster light (ICL), should all be intimately connected observables. However, the systematics affecting observations still prevent universal and uniform measurements of, for example, the SMF and the SFHs, inevitably preventing theoretical models to compare with multiple data sets robustly and simultaneously. We here present our holistic semi-empirical model DECODE (Discrete statistical sEmi-empiriCal mODEl) that converts via abundance matching dark matter merger trees into galaxy assembly histories, using different SMFs in input and predicting all other observables in output in a fully data-driven and self-consistent fashion with minimal assumptions. We find that: (1) weakly evolving or nearly constant SMFs below the knee ($M_\star \lesssim 10^{11} \, \mathrm{M}_\odot$) are the best suited to generate SFHs aligned with those inferred from MaNGA, SDSS, GAMA, and, more recently, JWST; (2) the evolution of satellites after infall only affects the satellite abundances and SFHs of massive central galaxies but not their merger histories; (3) the resulting SFR-$M_\star$ relation is lower in normalization by a factor of $\sim 2$ with respect to observations, with a flattening at high masses more pronounced in the presence of mergers; (4) the latest data on ICL can be reproduced if mass-loss from mergers is included in the models. Our findings are pivotal in acting as pathfinder to test the self-consistency of the high-quality data from, e.g. JWST and Euclid.
[ 0.008412014693021774, 0.04377784579992294, -0.002306672977283597, 0.0012614864390343428, 0.02366984449326992, 0.0432220958173275, 0.0496637299656868, -0.01658404804766178, -0.0022972000297158957, 0.04814805090427399, -0.001420159125700593, 0.009952954947948456, -0.08725254982709885, -0.051836200058460236, 0.021977337077260017, 0.01304746512323618, 0.0011691248510032892, 0.026802245527505875, -0.008254132233560085, 0.03930659219622612, 0.023985611274838448, 0.022659391164779663, 0.0115254707634449, 0.008500429801642895, -0.04708707705140114, -0.010173991322517395, -0.017379779368638992, 0.017809221521019936, 0.030768271535634995, -0.032132383435964584, 0.02294989675283432, -0.001965645467862487, -0.047920700162649155, 0.016495633870363235, -0.06077870354056358, 0.08801039308309555, -0.03033882938325405, 0.013287447392940521, -0.03645206615328789, 0.030566180124878883, -0.03134928271174431, -0.0065111019648611546, -0.04349996894598007, 0.03655311092734337, -0.028621060773730278, -0.010736055672168732, -0.03619945049285889, -0.029454683884978294, 0.01831444725394249, -0.005279613193124533, -0.053149789571762085, -0.011209704913198948, 0.04380310699343681, -0.0241119172424078, -0.01885756477713585, 0.003467114409431815, 0.00429442198947072, 0.014487359672784805, -0.009889801032841206, -0.0019309110939502716, -0.004774386994540691, -0.017809221521019936, -0.015055738389492035, -0.011354957707226276, -0.023935087025165558, -0.016318803653120995, 0.0217373538762331, 0.026423325762152672, 0.004253372550010681, 0.02634754218161106, -0.03139980509877205, -0.0024535043630748987, 0.01246645487844944, -0.008734096772968769, 0.012921158224344254, -0.031197713688015938, -0.006624777801334858, 0.00950456690043211, -0.05997034162282944, 0.018794411793351173, -0.0001549228618387133, 0.010736055672168732, -0.008576213382184505, -0.04349996894598007, -0.023556169122457504, 0.0033818574156612158, 0.007148949895054102, 0.02500869333744049, -0.07270204275846481, 0.03794248402118683, 0.03521426022052765, -0.016773506999015808, -0.031930290162563324, -0.0227983295917511, 0.02897471934556961, -0.04880484566092491, -0.022545715793967247, -0.06896336376667023, 0.029202070087194443, 0.00846253801137209, 0.04488934203982353, 0.020777424797415733, 0.01203069742769003, -0.07032747566699982, 0.0379677452147007, -0.017973419278860092, -0.015270459465682507, -0.0341532863676548, -0.04049387574195862, 0.007647860329598188, 0.038776107132434845, -0.031980812549591064, -0.048072267323732376, 0.009649818763136864, -0.015308352187275887, -0.023821411654353142, -0.09760969132184982, 0.059414591640233994, 0.0021803665440529585, 0.006280592177063227, 0.02907576411962509, -0.011487578973174095, 0.041352760046720505, 0.03458273038268089, 0.03556792065501213, -0.03971077501773834, 0.01841549202799797, -0.010502387769520283, -0.06052609160542488, -0.009081440046429634, 0.049158502370119095, -0.0260191448032856, 0.04092331603169441, -0.03516373783349991, -0.06173863261938095, -0.01566201075911522, -0.0377151295542717, 0.0010791313834488392, 0.005061734467744827, 0.026979075744748116, -0.03023778460919857, 0.026650678366422653, 0.033521752804517746, 0.013540060259401798, 0.009233007207512856, 0.009921378456056118, -0.015257828868925571, -0.0021251074504107237, -0.026044407859444618, -0.009277215227484703, 0.012125426903367043, -0.028469491750001907, -0.022495193406939507, -0.027054859325289726, 0.011702300049364567, -0.03925606980919838, -0.01016136072576046, -0.003186082234606147, 0.03268812969326973, -0.04956268519163132, -0.008412014693021774, 0.029606251046061516, -0.04963846877217293, 0.011866498738527298, -0.0329660065472126, 0.014878909103572369, -0.012643284164369106, 0.014310530386865139, -0.04749125614762306, -0.019994324073195457, -0.019691187888383865, 0.0027566400822252035, -0.012504346668720245, -0.05880832299590111, -0.025349721312522888, 0.016495633870363235, -0.011506524868309498, -0.053149789571762085, -0.033471230417490005, -0.026928553357720375, 0.023290924727916718, 0.04625345394015312, -0.019337529316544533, -0.02480660378932953, -0.04832487925887108, -0.004079700913280249, -0.010584487579762936, 0.06436581164598465, 0.04453568160533905, -0.006498470902442932, -0.003249235451221466, 0.04324735701084137, 0.0494111143052578, 0.03276391327381134, 0.01076763216406107, -0.01007294561713934, 0.031197713688015938, 0.02617071382701397, -0.01645774208009243, 0.03129876032471657, 0.029454683884978294, 0.016748245805501938, 0.02867158316075802, -0.030566180124878883, -0.051684632897377014, -0.005134360399097204, -0.0038681374862790108, -0.02176261506974697, 0.01244119368493557, 0.030616704374551773, 0.04365153610706329, 0.0009725603158585727, 0.020259568467736244, 0.017430301755666733, -0.016811398789286613, 0.01314850989729166, -0.05597905442118645, 0.000015615631127730012, 0.03531530499458313, 0.03033882938325405, -0.0036186822690069675, 0.014866278506815434, 0.04685972258448601, 0.007060535252094269, -0.0061353398486971855, -0.005045945756137371, 0.023265663534402847, -0.038725581020116806, -0.0061637586914002895, -0.0042154802940785885, 0.045419830828905106, 0.02867158316075802, -0.04165589436888695, 0.03165241703391075, -0.01583883911371231, -0.019337529316544533, -0.018087094649672508, 0.010502387769520283, 0.020726902410387993, 0.0038744527846574783, -0.04317157343029976, 0.042464256286621094, 0.0028782100416719913, 0.024895017966628075, -0.01183492224663496, 0.033471230417490005, -0.016003036871552467, -0.0030313567258417606, 0.010477126576006413, 0.0006816605455242097, 0.07558182626962662, -0.04377784579992294, -0.030768271535634995, -0.012226472608745098, -0.028595799580216408, -0.016836659982800484, -0.019173331558704376, 0.038523491472005844, 0.0025198152288794518, 0.014853647910058498, -0.062041766941547394, -0.01237803976982832, -0.018529167398810387, 0.03925606980919838, -0.028242141008377075, 0.01960277371108532, 0.001304904348216951, -0.01506836898624897, -0.006220596842467785, 0.0227983295917511, 0.0183902308344841, 0.014032655395567417, 0.052088815718889236, -0.01655878685414791, -0.045268259942531586, -0.04324735701084137, -0.017367148771882057, 0.039837080985307693, 0.013881088234484196, -0.03253656253218651, -0.005930091720074415, -0.058505184948444366, 0.049209024757146835, 0.023758258670568466, -0.017266102135181427, 0.0336480587720871, 0.01447472907602787, 0.03665415570139885, -0.01566201075911522, -0.0358457937836647, 0.03011147677898407, -0.02998517081141472, 0.003037672024220228, -0.030414612963795662, -0.01895861141383648, -0.043828368186950684, -0.01697559840977192, 0.050472091883420944, -0.03142506629228592, 0.03430485352873802, 0.053200311958789825, -0.008386753499507904, -0.009258268401026726, 0.01011083833873272, -0.01692507602274418, -0.02879788912832737, 0.026701200753450394, -0.000897565798368305, -0.0022324679885059595, 0.04718812182545662, 0.017960788682103157, -0.027206426486372948, -0.0070036971010267735, 0.037310950458049774, -0.01509363017976284, -0.0630522221326828, -0.013375861570239067, 0.003833403345197439, 0.016596678644418716, -0.03842244669795036, -0.03781617432832718, -0.042742129415273666, -0.049335330724716187, -0.022343626245856285, 0.0018488118657842278, -0.03953394293785095, -0.020764794200658798, -0.048021744936704636, -0.05138149857521057, 0.007578392047435045, 0.02738325670361519, 0.01660930924117565, 0.07820900529623032, 0.008689889684319496, -0.015977775678038597, -0.04946163669228554, 0.02438979223370552, 0.041100144386291504, 0.004013390280306339, 0.02230573445558548, -0.0009749285527504981, -0.03438063710927963, -0.011197074316442013, -0.004679657053202391, -0.007010012399405241, 0.02212890423834324, -0.01158862467855215, 0.02047428861260414, 0.06290065497159958, -0.019249115139245987, 0.012340147979557514, -0.008001518435776234, 0.041504327207803726, -0.001975118415430188, 0.057040028274059296, -0.00426916079595685, 0.011967543512582779, -0.05370553582906723, 0.006132182199507952, -0.02235625684261322, -0.018680736422538757, 0.0018267082050442696, 0.038927674293518066, -0.01898387260735035, -0.02215416543185711, 0.03243551775813103, -0.04208533838391304, 0.06638671457767487, -0.020878469571471214, -0.03299126774072647, -0.008273078128695488, -0.005244878586381674, -0.024895017966628075, 0.009011970832943916, -0.0549180805683136, 0.014689450152218342, 0.003394488012418151, 0.018705997616052628, 0.005418550223112106, 0.019514359533786774, 0.037386734038591385, -0.0028782100416719913, 0.0052354056388139725, -0.042742129415273666, 0.023455122485756874, 0.014209484681487083, -0.010439234785735607, -0.022040490061044693, -0.06411319226026535, -0.017064012587070465, -0.0030597758013755083, 0.010060315020382404, 0.008715150877833366, 0.030566180124878883, -0.01583883911371231, -0.037386734038591385, 0.02364458329975605, 0.034709036350250244, 0.03175346180796623, 0.02094162255525589, -0.0122454185038805, -0.01787237450480461, -0.0250844769179821, -0.0527961291372776, 0.0015756740467622876, 0.0051627797074615955, 0.007919419556856155, 0.027837960049510002, 0.02012063004076481, -0.005709055345505476, 0.04026652127504349, -0.01722821034491062, 0.05410971865057945, -0.035896316170692444, 0.0018614425789564848, 0.045141953974962234, -0.024604512378573418, 0.027863221243023872, 0.0021787877194583416, 0.047844912856817245, -0.01913543976843357, -0.03385015204548836, 0.03392593562602997, -0.06315326690673828, -0.04087279364466667, -0.0030218837782740593, 0.01566201075911522, 0.003197134006768465, -0.0057785240933299065, -0.0580504834651947, -0.05112888291478157, 0.0701759085059166, 0.06264804303646088, 0.031955551356077194, 0.009769810363650322, 0.008456222712993622, 0.034759558737277985, -0.0191101785749197, 0.023290924727916718, -0.020600594580173492, 0.05916197970509529, -0.0022814117837697268, -0.035340566188097, -0.022495193406939507, 0.02161104790866375, -0.01172124594449997, 0.007022642996162176, 0.03705833479762077, 0.00689002126455307, -0.030793532729148865, 0.03933185338973999, -0.020739533007144928, 0.005077522713690996, 0.014285269193351269, -0.01309798751026392, -0.014133701100945473, 0.01436105277389288, -0.02882315032184124, 0.04241373389959335, -0.05365501344203949, 0.011146551929414272, 0.02637280337512493, 0.013464276678860188, 0.0025987569242715836, -0.025046585127711296, 0.024768710136413574, -0.02176261506974697, 0.03688150644302368, 0.019969062879681587, 0.017329256981611252, 0.037310950458049774, -0.07982572913169861, 0.0341532863676548, 0.025198154151439667, 0.018794411793351173, -0.005746947135776281, -0.010205567814409733, -0.009618242271244526, 0.0654267817735672, 0.036174189299345016, 0.04054439812898636, -0.015901992097496986, 0.010300297290086746, 0.02547602728009224, -0.01895861141383648, 0.06178915500640869, -0.03789195790886879, 0.014260007068514824, 0.01054659578949213, 0.006788976024836302, -0.011948597617447376, -0.04324735701084137, 0.04721338301897049, -0.012889581732451916, 0.023227771744132042, -0.019375422969460487, -0.021674200892448425, -0.012769590131938457, -0.03824561834335327, 0.035593181848526, 0.07750169187784195, -0.01689981482923031, 0.0013514799065887928, 0.031955551356077194, 0.0247055571526289, 0.011607570573687553, -0.03971077501773834, -0.029858864843845367, -0.028292663395404816, 0.003915502689778805, -0.007786797825247049, 0.04973951354622841, 0.005308032035827637, 0.009062494151294231, 0.009188800118863583, 0.01980486512184143, -0.018402861431241035, 0.03427959233522415, 0.005434338469058275, -0.0065111019648611546, -0.00426916079595685, -0.030566180124878883, 0.014550512656569481, 0.02577916346490383, 0.032258689403533936, -0.008216239511966705, -0.002815056825056672, -0.09639714658260345, -0.026852767914533615, -0.003798668971285224, 0.020107999444007874, 0.015598856844007969, 0.029479945078492165, -0.008386753499507904, -0.011411795392632484, -0.010287666693329811, 0.002098267199471593, 0.012889581732451916, 0.00785626657307148, -0.014272638596594334, 0.04829961806535721, 0.00839938409626484, 0.017834482714533806, 0.0025245517026633024, 0.015560965053737164, 0.029833603650331497, -0.01844075322151184, 0.001807762193493545, 0.012087535113096237, -0.006277434527873993, 0.01591462269425392, -0.026625417172908783, 0.011815976351499557, -0.007420508656650782, -0.017013490200042725, 0.039862342178821564, -0.006896336562931538, -0.01777132973074913, 0.003552371170371771, 0.011815976351499557, -0.021825768053531647, -0.004445990081876516, -0.00379551132209599, 0.048981674015522, -0.012883266434073448, -0.03018726035952568, -0.037336211651563644, -0.011853868141770363, -0.014853647910058498, 0.016748245805501938, -0.0014564722077921033, -0.010565541684627533, 0.012093850411474705, -0.0029918858781456947, -0.021497372537851334, 0.00013676629168912768, -0.023063572123646736, 0.011923336423933506, 0.021232128143310547, -0.033445969223976135, -0.012839059345424175, -0.03003569319844246, 0.010129784233868122, -0.012775905430316925, -0.07371249049901962, -0.001466734567657113, 0.01562411803752184, 0.03801826760172844, 0.02500869333744049, -0.017480824142694473, 0.020107999444007874, -0.022987788543105125, 0.028444230556488037, -0.0033755421172827482, 0.009908747859299183, 0.032233428210020065, 0.005001738667488098, -0.007748905569314957, -0.004913324024528265, -0.013451646082103252, 0.012005436234176159, 0.007357355672866106, -0.014853647910058498, -0.034936387091875076, 0.0033155465498566628, 0.01139916479587555, 0.005870095919817686, -0.021800506860017776, -0.023657213896512985, 0.016937706619501114, -0.030970361083745956, 0.02140895649790764, -0.021257389336824417, -0.029757818207144737, -0.014777864329516888, -0.001651457860134542, -0.0016988228308036923, -0.014537882059812546, 0.04430833086371422, -0.013060095719993114, -0.004502827767282724, 0.01695033721625805, 0.006852129474282265, -0.0003280022647231817, 0.047642823308706284, -0.006650038994848728, 0.002696644514799118, -0.0011754401493817568, -0.00605324050411582, -0.015333613380789757, -0.0130095724016428, -0.03124823607504368, 0.019021764397621155, -0.013110618107020855, -0.004869116935878992, 0.003482902655377984, 0.022672021761536598, 0.009321422316133976, -0.03268812969326973, -0.010628694668412209, 0.030995622277259827, 0.014449466951191425, 0.03033882938325405, -0.03150084987282753, 0.013603213243186474, 0.015447288751602173, -0.0011549153132364154, 0.013325339183211327, -0.03902871906757355, -0.020070107653737068, -0.006542678456753492, -0.02032272145152092, 0.005093310959637165, 0.020550072193145752, 0.00975086446851492, -0.013489537872374058, -0.011386534199118614, 0.003223974257707596, -0.035871054977178574, 0.013439015485346317, -0.01086867693811655, 0.01506836898624897, -0.010830785147845745, -0.006315326783806086, 0.0053869737312197685, 0.0052069867961108685, -0.013249555602669716, 0.02289937436580658, 0.021080560982227325, 0.041074883192777634, 0.06623514741659164, -0.005696424748748541, 0.032309211790561676, 0.033471230417490005, -0.012011751532554626, -0.027105381712317467, 0.023341447114944458, -0.035997360944747925, -0.02771165408194065, 0.023341447114944458, -0.020209046080708504, 0.007900473661720753, -0.01764502190053463, -0.009131962433457375, 0.006896336562931538, 0.02624649740755558, 0.006220596842467785, -0.008639366365969181, 0.014626296237111092, 0.03137454390525818, 0.010912884026765823, -0.021004775539040565, 0.02166157029569149, 0.0013380597811192274, 0.017935527488589287, -0.0015662009827792645, -0.01290221232920885, 0.0070794811472296715, -0.0046386076137423515, -0.02905050292611122, 0.016104083508253098, -0.008317285217344761, 0.009788756258785725, 0.010559226386249065, -0.013502168469130993, -0.008209924213588238, -0.03635102137923241, 0.03546687588095665, 0.008468853309750557, -0.03905398026108742, 0.03518899902701378, 0.054412852972745895, -0.03407750278711319, 0.03425433114171028, -0.03001043200492859, -0.009675079956650734, -0.009763495065271854, 0.01655878685414791, -0.020853208377957344, -0.00916985422372818, -0.018529167398810387, 0.0026034933980554342, -0.07704698294401169, 0.006972120609134436, 0.031980812549591064, -0.032258689403533936, -0.005109099205583334, 0.031930290162563324, -0.021674200892448425, -0.02869684435427189, -0.010698162950575352, 0.02156052552163601, -0.01764502190053463, -0.020701641216874123, 0.001766712637618184, 0.010066630318760872, -0.009359314106404781, -0.018630214035511017, -0.013817934319376945, 0.045116692781448364, 0.005165937356650829, 0.02738325670361519, -0.011759137734770775, 0.01084341574460268, -0.003129244316369295, -0.014537882059812546, 0.007306832820177078, -0.022293103858828545, 0.0010246617021039128, 0.002905050292611122, 0.01314850989729166, 0.010571856983006, 0.02109319157898426, -0.007717329077422619, 0.036300498992204666, -0.021206866949796677, -0.0021061613224446774, -0.0036660470068454742, 0.014878909103572369, 0.028469491750001907, 0.03283969685435295, 0.01378004252910614, 0.022558346390724182, 0.02540024369955063, -0.026625417172908783, 0.010268720798194408, -0.01950172893702984, -0.014512620866298676, 0.04016547650098801, -0.013451646082103252, -0.03170293942093849, 0.010028738528490067, 0.0007941523217596114, 0.02374562807381153, 0.021989967674016953, 0.01700085960328579, 0.023581430315971375, -0.005898515228182077, -0.05360449105501175, 0.0026113875210285187, 0.006403741426765919, -0.002382457023486495, 0.025918100029230118, -0.010155045427381992, -0.016495633870363235, -0.0015867258189246058, -0.015573595650494099, -0.020802685990929604, 0.008986709639430046, -0.0130095724016428, -0.023366708308458328, 0.034810081124305725, -0.029505206272006035, 0.03768986836075783, -0.009384575299918652, 0.0004247057077009231, -0.005617483053356409, -0.1213553175330162, -0.0057595777325332165, 0.051785677671432495, 0.025122368708252907, -0.0048912204802036285, 0.021623678505420685, 0.009662449359893799, 0.037411995232105255, 0.009510882198810577, -0.011127605102956295, 0.0028434759005904198, -0.024895017966628075, -0.007174211088567972, 0.05744421109557152, 0.01836496964097023, -0.04380310699343681, -0.04829961806535721, 0.021623678505420685, -0.008721466176211834, -0.008014149032533169, -0.003950236830860376, 0.038498230278491974, 0.031980812549591064, 0.008860403671860695, 0.019413314759731293, -0.03291548416018486, -0.05643375962972641, 0.008778303861618042, 0.01916070096194744, 0.0069594900123775005, 0.009725603275001049, 0.015422027558088303, -0.024377161636948586, 0.028115835040807724, -0.0034892179537564516, -0.004224953707307577, 0.013476907275617123, 0.02364458329975605, -0.02773691527545452, -0.024920279160141945, -0.0065553090535104275, -0.012914842925965786, 0.026903292164206505, 0.01836496964097023, 0.027939004823565483, -0.01282642874866724, -0.00345764122903347, 0.010881307534873486, -0.011032875627279282, 0.004468093626201153, -0.03033882938325405, 0.00392813328653574, -0.01513152290135622, 0.02644858881831169, 0.008077302947640419, 0.001145442365668714, -0.00022794381948187947, 0.00783100537955761, -0.019931171089410782, -0.00042628456139937043, -0.021573156118392944, 0.0008352019358426332, 0.019969062879681587, -0.02354353852570057, -0.029176808893680573, -0.02089110016822815, -0.012914842925965786, 0.02116897515952587, -0.009207746013998985, -0.015598856844007969, -0.0019814337138086557, 0.0261454526335001, 0.021270019933581352, 0.008519375696778297, 0.006542678456753492, 0.02116897515952587, -0.04026652127504349, 0.024010872468352318, -0.029277853667736053, -0.0041870614513754845, 0.010628694668412209, -0.0496637299656868, 0.025513919070363045, -0.024036133661866188, 0.005746947135776281, 0.022217318415641785, 0.013325339183211327, 0.0025750743225216866, -0.007729959674179554, 0.050699442625045776, 0.018895456567406654, 0.011354957707226276, -0.007963626645505428, 0.015952514484524727, 0.002579811029136181, 0.004578611813485622, 0.02547602728009224, -0.02022167667746544, 0.03011147677898407, -0.000976507377345115, -0.012182265520095825, -0.012043328024446964, -0.008310969918966293, -0.04572296515107155, 0.019122809171676636, 0.0047585987485945225, -0.0250844769179821, 0.02423822320997715, 0.015826208516955376, 0.03685624524950981, 0.03503743186593056, 0.04435885325074196, -0.011373903602361679, -0.006593200843781233, 0.024970801547169685, -0.030692487955093384, -0.03923080861568451, 0.002804005052894354, -0.0013270080089569092, -0.017657652497291565, -0.007767851930111647, -0.0032397625036537647, -0.0449146032333374, -0.0003195160534232855, -0.010489757172763348, 0.008696204982697964, 0.00447440892457962, 0.014626296237111092, -0.01591462269425392, 0.014904171228408813, -0.017859743908047676, 0.014651557430624962, 0.020082738250494003, 0.0197038184851408, -0.0027455883100628853, -0.02537498250603676, -0.00329975807107985, 0.05014369264245033, -0.003836560994386673, 0.007515238597989082, 0.01287695113569498, 0.005301716737449169, -0.03647732734680176, 0.009081440046429634, 0.023808781057596207, -0.005026999861001968, -0.0204237662255764, 0.002199312439188361, 0.006580570247024298, 0.027080120518803596, 0.003416591789573431, 0.026852767914533615, -0.030995622277259827, -0.002827687421813607, 0.003353438340127468, -0.008235186338424683, -0.001132811768911779, -0.04759230092167854, 0.005642744246870279, 0.022141534835100174, 0.03842244669795036, 0.03516373783349991, -0.0011596519034355879, -0.04307052865624428, 0.014171592891216278, -0.009662449359893799, -0.00636900682002306, 0.009510882198810577, 0.026953814551234245, -0.005522753112018108, -0.01076763216406107, -0.07699646055698395, 0.041302237659692764, -0.015219937078654766, -0.006375322118401527, 0.012359093874692917, -0.002841897075995803, -0.023834042251110077, 0.006021664012223482, 0.02748430147767067, -0.02624649740755558, -0.00883514154702425, 0.0032681815791875124, 0.011714930646121502, 0.05506964772939682, 0.018756520003080368, 0.00053680274868384, -0.012775905430316925, 0.03407750278711319, 0.010552911087870598, 0.0047112335450947285, 0.01158862467855215, 0.004016547929495573, 0.03779091313481331, 0.000025705352527438663, 0.014209484681487083, -0.03266286849975586, 0.02596862241625786, -0.008620420470833778, -0.0008249395177699625, -0.0525435172021389, -0.016647201031446457, -0.02289937436580658, -0.02433926798403263, -0.005266982596367598, -0.01309798751026392, -0.0031923975329846144, 0.009586665779352188, -0.033294402062892914, -0.0003992470446974039, -0.0023366708774119616, -0.02537498250603676, 0.04478829726576805, 0.015750424936413765, 0.02418770082294941, -0.05117940530180931, 0.039938125759363174, -0.02225521020591259, -0.011285488493740559, -0.013843195512890816, 0.014942063018679619, -0.018251294270157814, 0.0024456102401018143, 0.04625345394015312, 0.0021014248486608267, 0.011677038855850697, -0.01367899775505066, 0.003407118609175086, -0.02884841151535511, -0.0035555288195610046, 0.017215579748153687, -0.029277853667736053, 0.010338190011680126, -0.02998517081141472, -0.025918100029230118, 0.012775905430316925, -0.001766712637618184, 0.0059869298711419106, -0.003103983122855425, 0.009182484820485115, 0.026574894785881042, -0.02892419509589672, -0.021573156118392944, -0.023227771744132042, 0.008645682595670223, -0.00039845763240009546, -0.001139916479587555, 0.0022624656558036804, 0.006138497497886419, -0.00014525251754093915, -0.032208167016506195, 0.033420708030462265, -0.003997601568698883, -0.008014149032533169, 0.01710190437734127, 0.030515657737851143, -0.006084816996008158, 0.03763934597373009, 0.04082227125763893, 0.0009615084854885936, 0.020057477056980133, -0.0005573275848291814, -0.029126286506652832, -0.028065310791134834, -0.0038397186435759068, 0.0014320003101602197, -0.06820552796125412, 0.02052481099963188, 0.022760437801480293, -0.03438063710927963, 0.019539620727300644, -0.009011970832943916, 0.007887843064963818, -0.005257509648799896, -0.021623678505420685, -0.00033865938894450665, -0.01513152290135622, -0.006324799731373787, -0.01084341574460268, 0.001728820614516735, -0.016217758879065514, -0.021371064707636833, -0.009176169522106647, -0.007388932164758444, 0.04168115556240082, 0.012864320538938046, 0.00623322743922472, -0.01235277857631445, 0.04617766663432121, -0.028292663395404816, 0.000017576836398802698, -0.0028197932988405228, 0.025791794061660767, 0.007938365451991558, -0.004171273205429316, -0.04102436080574989, -0.029555728659033775, -0.011733876541256905, -0.003744988702237606, -0.031197713688015938, -0.05416024103760719, -0.009315107017755508, 0.00019380159210413694, -0.034784819930791855, -0.010950776748359203, -0.04163063317537308, -0.0024440314155071974, -0.03789195790886879, -0.010249774903059006, 0.01985538750886917, -0.0011154445819556713, -0.010104523040354252, -0.00013301656872499734, 0.012485400773584843, 0.004528088960796595, -0.021282650530338287, 0.0020256410352885723, 0.0260191448032856, 0.0010475547751411796, -0.019640665501356125, -0.004136539064347744, -0.017417671158909798, 0.04183272272348404, -0.011771769262850285, -0.03324387967586517, -0.02408665604889393, 0.021181605756282806, -0.014967324212193489, 0.026903292164206505, 0.0358457937836647, 0.012864320538938046, 0.019514359533786774, 0.028040049597620964, -0.004013390280306339, -0.01317377109080553, 0.027181165292859077, -0.019893279299139977, -0.017480824142694473, 0.017556607723236084, 0.0014762076316401362, -0.018844934180378914, -0.004929112270474434, -0.05234142765402794, 0.010268720798194408, -0.0014959429390728474, 0.011140236631035805, -0.006119551602751017, 0.004600715357810259, -0.029277853667736053, 0.011569678783416748, 0.058505184948444366, -0.023682475090026855, -0.0031497692689299583, -0.01846601441502571, 0.029707295820116997, -0.016192497685551643, -0.023909825831651688, 0.0047870175912976265, 0.011159182526171207, 0.0003911555395461619, 0.00039964175084605813, 0.012580130249261856, 0.028343185782432556, 0.007729959674179554, 0.023429861292243004, -0.006084816996008158, 0.0071552651934325695, 0.022810960188508034, -0.010224513709545135, 0.004992265719920397, 0.004884905181825161, 0.0014927852898836136, 0.00026149398763664067, 0.014815756119787693, -0.022621499374508858, -0.011437056586146355, 0.0027566400822252035, 0.012037012726068497, -0.01950172893702984, 0.013918980024755001, 0.0059395646676421165, -0.0011857026256620884, -0.014752603136003017, -0.019981693476438522, -0.022242579609155655, -0.016167236492037773, 0.009113016538321972, 0.022583607584238052, 0.010849731042981148, -0.02606966905295849, 0.031879767775535583, -0.007281571626663208, 0.022735176607966423, -0.028242141008377075, 0.0012417511316016316, -0.00009354577923659235, -0.01883230358362198, 0.01687455363571644, -0.0034008033107966185, 0.013552690856158733, -0.030844055116176605, -0.012744328938424587, 0.03799300640821457, -0.027181165292859077, -0.00691528245806694, -0.007199472282081842, -0.0051154145039618015, 0.043853629380464554, 0.013691628351807594, -0.015447288751602173, -0.016937706619501114, -0.02406139485538006, -0.02446557581424713, 0.05496860295534134, 0.040039170533418655, 0.02547602728009224, 0.0038049842696636915, 0.005102783907204866, 0.024591881781816483, 0.03031356818974018, -0.029656773433089256, 0.00939089059829712, -0.012971680611371994, 0.005551171954721212, -0.009517197497189045, 0.008917241357266903, -0.044005196541547775, 0.015207306481897831, -0.016066191717982292, -0.011815976351499557, -0.01980486512184143, -0.011942282319068909, -0.0068647600710392, 0.03529004380106926, -0.022558346390724182, -0.01174650713801384, 0.01183492224663496, 0.004742810502648354, -0.012472770176827908, 0.012371724471449852, -0.016748245805501938, -0.023947719484567642, 0.013325339183211327, 0.02771165408194065, 0.030540918931365013, 0.00374814635142684, -0.007092111743986607, 0.010167676024138927, 0.014133701100945473, 0.011986490339040756, -0.029429422691464424, 0.02874736674129963, 0.021573156118392944, 0.003943921532481909, -0.03003569319844246, -0.0015069948276504874, -0.0391550250351429, -0.025071846321225166, 0.005772208329290152, -0.008797249756753445, 0.015396766364574432, 0.019173331558704376, 0.024996062740683556, 0.0018519695149734616, 0.02366984449326992, 0.03645206615328789, 0.02034798264503479, -0.035896316170692444, -0.01952699013054371, -0.03905398026108742, 0.009207746013998985, 0.04312105104327202, -0.00101597816683352, -0.03031356818974018, -0.02905050292611122, -0.01792289689183235, -0.045268259942531586, -0.013186401687562466, 0.012996941804885864, 0.01957751251757145, -0.06274908781051636, 0.00759102264419198, 0.008980394341051579, 0.008077302947640419, 0.006725823041051626, 0.006324799731373787, 0.018503906205296516, -0.0261454526335001, 0.01108971331268549, 0.018579691648483276, -0.005683794151991606, 0.004070227965712547, -0.02446557581424713, -0.02408665604889393, 0.014158962294459343, 0.00939089059829712, -0.021320542320609093, 0.013666367158293724, -0.009795071557164192, 0.001624617725610733, -0.023303555324673653, 0.019236484542489052, 0.024541359394788742, -0.0030060955323278904, 0.0018803884740918875, -0.02099214494228363, -0.01441157516092062, -0.014209484681487083, -0.008607789874076843, 0.013691628351807594, -0.013489537872374058, 0.02230573445558548, -0.023707736283540726, 0.024566620588302612, 0.029530467465519905, 0.010022423230111599, -0.03299126774072647, 0.002971361158415675, 0.00017031645984388888, -0.02874736674129963, 0.003887083614245057, -0.021181605756282806, 0.038750845938920975, -0.03531530499458313, -0.02629701979458332, -0.029151547700166702, 0.007167895790189505, -0.007767851930111647, -0.022065751254558563, 0.013944241218268871, 0.041125405579805374, -0.03776565194129944, 0.02892419509589672, 0.00609744805842638, -0.011973859742283821, -0.008550952188670635, 0.0029839917551726103, 0.014651557430624962, 0.02359406091272831, -0.0034039609599858522, 0.0068647600710392, -0.004335471894592047, -0.005844834726303816, 0.006460579112172127, 0.04688498377799988, 0.0377151295542717, -0.0015677798073738813, -0.02867158316075802, -0.02119423635303974, 0.00413338141515851, -0.005841677077114582, -0.009005655534565449, 0.0122454185038805, -0.029732557013630867, 0.013514799065887928, 0.021307911723852158, 0.026979075744748116, 0.009649818763136864, 0.053048744797706604, 0.04314631223678589, -0.001911965082399547, -0.00790678896009922, -0.003956552129238844, 0.011197074316442013, 0.03799300640821457, 0.034709036350250244, -0.020954253152012825, 0.026423325762152672, 0.012011751532554626, -0.0006623198860324919, 0.017986049875617027, -0.006113236304372549, 0.001407528412528336, -0.012946419417858124, -0.042691607028245926, 0.02884841151535511, 0.03137454390525818, -0.01653352566063404, 0.054614946246147156, 0.025324460119009018, 0.01720294915139675, -0.047920700162649155, -0.007218418177217245, 0.011992805637419224, 0.002961888210847974, 0.014777864329516888, -0.020625857636332512, 0.04281791299581528, -0.03175346180796623, 0.0001222607825184241, 0.022242579609155655, -0.02485712617635727, 0.014664188027381897, 0.008544636890292168, -0.018301816657185555, 0.05628219246864319, 0.029631512239575386, 0.03289021924138069, -0.025488657876849174, -0.012472770176827908, -0.017607130110263824, 0.010994983837008476, 0.012769590131938457, -0.007433139253407717, -0.005349081475287676, 0.004894378129392862, 0.049057457596063614, -0.024149809032678604, -0.005472230724990368, 0.03412802517414093, 0.009548773989081383, 0.015283090062439442, 0.026524372398853302, 0.014714711345732212, -0.005898515228182077, 0.01314850989729166, -0.01859232224524021, -0.02315198816359043, -0.01859232224524021, -0.01513152290135622, 0.00437967898324132, -0.04938585311174393, 0.009630872868001461, -0.013161140494048595, 0.0499163419008255, 0.0026492795441299677, -0.003833403345197439, -0.01578831672668457, 0.029176808893680573, -0.003760776948183775, 0.028014788404107094, 0.02143421769142151, 0.03960973024368286, 0.010881307534873486, -0.0004108909342903644, 0.014638926833868027, 0.007010012399405241, 0.0006595569429919124, -0.03129876032471657, 0.025463396683335304, 0.018529167398810387, 0.004856486339122057, 0.007553130853921175, -0.015573595650494099, 0.003025041427463293, -0.020625857636332512, -0.0046386076137423515, -0.03294074535369873, 0.03496164828538895, -0.01178439985960722, 0.014563143253326416, -0.030692487955093384, -0.01947646774351597, 0.002957151737064123, 0.024528728798031807, 0.007944680750370026, -0.0017793432343751192, -0.018794411793351173, 0.04016547650098801, -0.016179867088794708, 0.030616704374551773, 0.04375258460640907, 0.004332314245402813, 0.019337529316544533, 0.0020335351582616568, 0.03670467808842659, -0.019388053566217422, 0.041327498853206635, 0.015080999583005905, 0.03710886090993881, -0.011935967020690441, 0.020057477056980133, 0.01375478133559227, 0.002714011585339904, 0.03549213707447052, -0.010249774903059006, 0.0020224833860993385, -0.002136159222573042, 0.01115286722779274, -0.007054219953715801, 0.008790934458374977, -0.03134928271174431, -0.017329256981611252, 0.037336211651563644, 0.008393068797886372, -0.01436105277389288, -0.014954693615436554, 0.028520014137029648, -0.004029178526252508, -0.011765453964471817, -0.0053111896850168705, -0.007628914434462786, -0.020284829661250114, -0.011121289804577827, -0.042464256286621094, 0.001034134766086936, 0.0032129224855452776, -0.004146012011915445, -0.018743889406323433, -0.02426348440349102, 0.02572864107787609, -0.00458492711186409, -0.020701641216874123, -0.04741547256708145, -0.013577952049672604, -0.03379962965846062, 0.021926814690232277, -0.00025359983555972576, -0.0004929901915602386, -0.012996941804885864, -0.02617071382701397, -0.014209484681487083, -0.016811398789286613, -0.002357195597141981, -0.009296161122620106, -0.0071552651934325695, 0.04332314059138298, -0.03806878998875618, -0.020360613241791725, 0.01323692500591278, 0.02158578671514988, 0.03268812969326973, 0.0009204588714055717, -0.005930091720074415, -0.001872494351118803, -0.01625565066933632, 0.036249976605176926, 0.029151547700166702, 0.0031229290179908276, -0.0006891600205563009, 0.006485840305685997, 0.003719727275893092, 0.00812782533466816, 0.008734096772968769, -0.014424205757677555, 0.006305853836238384, -0.004749125801026821, 0.0021314227487891912, 0.007281571626663208 ]
11.642798
6.152861
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.532..177F
[ "dark matter merger trees", "merger rates", "satellite abundances", "mergers", "galaxy assembly histories", "theoretical models", "star formation histories", "multiple data sets", "different SMFs", "SFHs" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
34
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1492", "10.48550/arXiv.2406.07605" ]
[ "Fu, Hao", "Shankar, Francesco", "Ayromlou, Mohammadreza", "Koutsouridou, Ioanna", "Cattaneo, Andrea", "Bertemes, Caroline", "Bellstedt, Sabine", "Martín-Navarro, Ignacio", "Leja, Joel", "Allevato, Viola", "Bernardi, Mariangela", "Boco, Lumen", "Dimauro, Paola", "Gruppioni, Carlotta", "Lapi, Andrea", "Menci, Nicola", "Rodríguez, Iván Muñoz", "Puglisi, Annagrazia", "Alonso-Tetilla, Alba V." ]
[ "School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Southampton, Highfield SO17 1BJ, Southampton, UK", "School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Southampton, Highfield SO17 1BJ, Southampton, UK", "Zentrum für Astronomie, Institut für theoretische Astrophysik, Universität Heidelberg, Albert-Ueberle-Str 2, D-69120 Heidelberg, Germany", "Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia, Universita degli Studi di Firenze, Via G. Sansone 1, I-50019 Sesto Fiorentino, Italy; INAF/Osservatorio Astrofisico di Arcetri, Largo E. Fermi 5, I-50125 Firenze, Italy", "Observatoire de Paris/LERMA, PSL University, 61 av. de l'Observatoire, D-75014 Paris, France", "Zentrum für Astronomie, Institut für theoretische Astrophysik, Universität Heidelberg, Albert-Ueberle-Str 2, D-69120 Heidelberg, Germany", "ICRAR, The University of Western Australia, 7 Fairway, Crawley, WA 6009, Australia", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias, Vía Láctea s/n, E-38205 La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Departamento de Astrofísica, Universidad de La Laguna, E-38205 La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain", "Department of Astronomy &amp; Astrophysics, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA 16802, USA", "INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Capodimonte, Via Moiariello 16, I-30131 Napoli, Italy", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA", "SISSA, Via Bonomea 265, I-34135 Trieste, Italy", "INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Roma, via di Frascati 33, I-00078 Monte Porzio Catone, Italy", "INAF - Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio di Bologna via Gobetti 93/3, I-40129 Bologna, Italy", "SISSA, Via Bonomea 265, I-34135 Trieste, Italy", "INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Roma, via di Frascati 33, I-00078 Monte Porzio Catone, Italy", "School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Southampton, Highfield SO17 1BJ, Southampton, UK; Institute for Astronomy and Astrophysics, National Observatory of Athens, V. Paulou &amp; I. Metaxa 11532, Greece", "School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Southampton, Highfield SO17 1BJ, Southampton, UK", "School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Southampton, Highfield SO17 1BJ, Southampton, UK" ]
null
[ "1972ApJ...176....1G", "1977Natur.266..501C", "1980ApJ...237..692L", "1985ApJ...292..371D", "1998Natur.396..549G", "2000ApJ...533..682C", "2001MNRAS.322..231K", "2001MNRAS.328..726S", "2002MNRAS.336.1188K", "2003MNRAS.343...75H", "2003MNRAS.344.1000B", "2003PASP..115..763C", "2004ApJ...600..580G", "2004ApJ...607L..83M", "2004ApJ...612..168P", "2004ApJ...617..879L", "2005ApJ...631L..41M", "2005MNRAS.364.1069D", "2006ApJ...642..797P", "2006ApJ...643...14S", "2006MNRAS.366..499D", "2006MNRAS.368....2D", "2006SSRv..123..485G", "2007ApJ...666...20P", "2007ApJ...671..153Y", "2008ApJ...675.1095J", "2008ApJ...682..355B", "2008ApJS..175..356H", "2008MNRAS.383..119D", "2008MNRAS.384....2G", "2008MNRAS.388.1433D", "2009ApJ...707..250M", "2009ApJS..182..543A", "2010ApJ...709.1018V", "2010ApJ...710..903M", "2010ApJ...715..202H", "2010ApJ...724..915H", "2010ApJ...725.2312O", "2010MNRAS.401..791S", "2010MNRAS.404.1639V", "2010MNRAS.404.2087B", "2010MNRAS.405.1544D", "2010MNRAS.405.2717N", "2010MNRAS.406..936P", "2011A&A...533A...5C", "2011AJ....142...31B", "2011ApJ...732...48R", "2011ApJ...734...48L", "2011ApJ...735L..34G", "2011MNRAS.413..101G", "2011MNRAS.413..971D", "2011MNRAS.418.1392P", "2012ApJ...745..149L", "2012ApJ...752...41Y", "2012ApJ...759...43T", "2012MNRAS.425..641L", "2012MNRAS.425.2058B", "2012SPIE.8442E..0ZA", "2013ApJ...767...50M", "2013ApJ...772..119L", "2013MNRAS.428.3121M", "2013MNRAS.432..176P", "2013MNRAS.432..336W", "2013MNRAS.436..697B", "2014ARA&A..52..415M", "2014ApJ...783...85T", "2014ApJ...788...11L", "2014ApJ...795..104W", "2014ApJS..210....3M", "2014ApJS..214...15S", "2014MNRAS.437..816C", "2014MNRAS.437.3787C", "2014MNRAS.439.3189S", "2014MNRAS.440..889S", "2014MNRAS.441..599B", "2014MNRAS.443...19R", "2014MNRAS.444.1518V", "2015ApJ...798....7B", "2015ApJ...798..115L", "2015ApJ...801...80L", "2015ApJ...802...73S", "2015ApJ...810...74A", "2015MNRAS.446.3943M", "2015MNRAS.449...49R", "2015MNRAS.449.2353B", "2015MNRAS.451.2663H", "2015MNRAS.451.2968F", "2015MNRAS.452.2087L", "2015MNRAS.452.4347K", "2016A&A...590A.103M", "2016ApJ...817..118T", "2016ApJ...833..109S", "2016MNRAS.455.2440M", "2016MNRAS.455.4122B", "2016MNRAS.458.2371R", "2016MNRAS.462.2001B", "2016MNRAS.463.1916F", "2017A&A...605A..70D", "2017AJ....154...28B", "2017ApJ...844...48P", "2017ApJ...847...13L", "2017MNRAS.465.3291W", "2017MNRAS.466..798C", "2017MNRAS.467..490F", "2017MNRAS.467.2217B", "2017MNRAS.467.4101G", "2017MNRAS.470..651R", "2017MNRAS.471.1401C", "2017MNRAS.471.4170T", "2018A&A...615A.146P", "2018A&A...620A.152F", "2018ARA&A..56..435W", "2018ApJ...857...22L", "2018MNRAS.473.4077P", "2018MNRAS.474..917M", "2018MNRAS.475..624N", "2018MNRAS.475..648P", "2018MNRAS.475..676S", "2018MNRAS.476.3137R", "2018MNRAS.477.1206N", "2018MNRAS.477.1822M", "2018MNRAS.479..932C", "2018MNRAS.480.4379C", "2018MNRAS.480.5113M", "2019A&A...630A.145T", "2019AJ....158..231W", "2019ApJ...876....3L", "2019ApJ...877..140L", "2019ComAC...6....2N", "2019MNRAS.482.1557S", "2019MNRAS.482.2838M", "2019MNRAS.483.2506G", "2019MNRAS.484..595M", "2019MNRAS.485.2589M", "2019MNRAS.485.4817D", "2019MNRAS.488.3143B", "2019MNRAS.490.5375K", "2019MNRAS.490.5693B", "2019asrc.confE...6W", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020A&A...643A...8G", "2020ApJ...892....7K", "2020ApJ...893..111L", "2020ApJ...893..139S", "2020ApJ...897..102C", "2020ApJ...901..128C", "2020MNRAS.491..634G", "2020MNRAS.495..905R", "2020MNRAS.496.3235B", "2020MNRAS.497...81D", "2020MNRAS.497..279C", "2020MNRAS.498.5581B", "2021ApJ...909...23T", "2021ApJ...923...28F", "2021ApJ...923L..29X", "2021ApJS..252...27K", "2021Galax...9...60C", "2021MNRAS.501.3215O", "2021MNRAS.502..621J", "2021MNRAS.502.1051A", "2021MNRAS.502.2419F", "2021MNRAS.503.6059P", "2021MNRAS.505..136H", "2021MNRAS.505..492A", "2021MNRAS.505..540T", "2021MNRAS.506.4760D", "2022A&A...659A.160B", "2022ApJ...936..165L", "2022MNRAS.509.5918H", "2022MNRAS.513..256D", "2022MNRAS.513..439D", "2022MNRAS.516.2891W", "2022MNRAS.516.3206F", "2022MNRAS.516.4194K", "2022NatAs...6..308M", "2023A&A...677A.184W", "2023ApJ...948L..18N", "2023ApJ...954...97B", "2023ApJ...958...72C", "2023ApJ...959....5L", "2023MNRAS.519.1526P", "2023MNRAS.519.2199E", "2023MNRAS.520.5651C", "2023MNRAS.522..449B", "2023MNRAS.522.5946E", "2023MNRAS.524.2312E", "2023MNRAS.524.3502R", "2023MNRAS.524.5486A", "2023MNRAS.526.5735T", "2023arXiv230607320L", "2024A&A...686A.184D", "2024ApJ...969..142C", "2024MNRAS.527.9505A", "2024MNRAS.528..771B", "2024arXiv240306575K", "2024arXiv240308872W" ]
29059617
2310.16895
SPICE: the connection between cosmic reionization and stellar feedback in the first galaxies
We present SPICE, a new suite of radiation-hydrodynamic, cosmological simulations targeting the epoch of reionization. The goal of these simulations is to systematically probe a variety of stellar feedback models, including 'bursty' and 'smooth' forms of supernova energy injection, as well as poorly explored physical scenarios such as hypernova explosions and radiation pressure on dust. We show that even subtle differences in the behaviour of supernova feedback drive profound differences in reionization histories, with burstier forms of feedback causing earlier reionization. However, we also find that some global galaxy properties, such as the dust-attenuated luminosity functions and star formation main sequence, remain degenerate between models. In particular, we show that stellar feedback and its strength determine the morphological mix of galaxies emerging by $z \, = \, 5$ and that the reionization history is inextricably connected to intrinsic properties such as galaxy kinematics and morphology. While star-forming, massive discs are prevalent if supernova feedback is 'smooth', 'bursty' feedback preferentially generates dispersion-dominated systems. Different modes of feedback produce different strengths of outflows, altering the interstellar/circumgalactic medium in different ways, and in turn strongly affecting the escape of Lyman continuum (LyC) photons. We establish a correlation between galaxy morphology and LyC escape fraction, revealing that dispersion-dominated systems have escape fractions 10-50 times higher than their rotation-dominated counterparts at all redshifts. At the same intrinsic luminosity, dispersion-dominated systems should thus preferentially generate large H II regions as compared to their rotation-dominated counterparts. Since dispersion-dominated systems are more prevalent if stellar feedback is more explosive, reionization occurs earlier in our simulation with burstier feedback. We argue that statistical samples of post-reionization galaxy morphologies (using both stellar and gaseous components) probed with telescopes such as JWST, ALMA, and MUSE can constrain stellar feedback at z &gt; 5 and models of cosmic reionization.
[ 0.019962375983595848, 0.0254634078592062, -0.008277558721601963, -0.03667354956269264, -0.0030236172024160624, 0.04234364628791809, 0.0036998670548200607, 0.003953460603952408, -0.02651679702103138, 0.01576182432472706, -0.02438400872051716, 0.03813008964061737, -0.04543878883123398, -0.017569491639733315, 0.011405213735997677, 0.002592833014205098, -0.015059564262628555, 0.01379809807986021, -0.012705693952739239, 0.02671186998486519, -0.05305960401892662, -0.027206052094697952, -0.008648195303976536, -0.005959451664239168, -0.05644085258245468, -0.03261604905128479, -0.013616031035780907, 0.04611503705382347, 0.03417662903666496, -0.008570166304707527, 0.01936415396630764, -0.012699192389845848, -0.020586606115102768, -0.030223166570067406, -0.0854155570268631, 0.05001647770404816, -0.007308700121939182, -0.024305980652570724, -0.0241889376193285, -0.008960310369729996, -0.012796727940440178, -0.015904875472187996, -0.04569888487458229, 0.011743338778614998, 0.0003791713388636708, 0.006977078039199114, -0.04364412650465965, -0.03584124147891998, 0.0269719660282135, 0.008225538767874241, -0.054412104189395905, 0.03178374469280243, -0.0052409362979233265, -0.04866398125886917, -0.009643062949180603, -0.010735466144979, -0.006307330448180437, 0.003100020345300436, -0.05368383601307869, -0.008466128259897232, 0.01096305064857006, 0.002974849194288254, 0.023213576525449753, -0.016568120568990707, -0.020144442096352577, 0.0094609959051013, -0.005718863103538752, 0.01872691884636879, 0.053137633949518204, 0.043670136481523514, -0.015332665294408798, -0.036309413611888885, 0.002379879355430603, -0.008186524733901024, 0.010364829562604427, -0.024331990629434586, -0.01147674024105072, -0.022901460528373718, -0.029989080503582954, -0.027830282226204872, 0.0034040077589452267, 0.006827522534877062, -0.008440118283033371, -0.03706369549036026, -0.002470912877470255, -0.006658460013568401, 0.029546916484832764, 0.007835394702851772, -0.07912123203277588, 0.006017973646521568, 0.039716675877571106, 0.014643410220742226, -0.050198547542095184, -0.011145117692649364, -0.015631776303052902, -0.06169479340314865, 0.04616705700755119, -0.05326768010854721, 0.07610411942005157, 0.04840388521552086, 0.015137593261897564, 0.005887925624847412, 0.0038136590737849474, -0.039066433906555176, 0.043436046689748764, 0.005943195894360542, 0.003677108557894826, -0.00020208247588016093, -0.036959655582904816, 0.005081627517938614, 0.03685561567544937, -0.007555791642516851, -0.006076495163142681, -0.013707064092159271, -0.0796414241194725, -0.028714608401060104, -0.06887345016002655, -0.06283921748399734, -0.04741551727056503, 0.002895194571465254, -0.010052714496850967, 0.012491115368902683, 0.01665915548801422, 0.049548305571079254, 0.05056267976760864, -0.055504508316516876, 0.017829587683081627, -0.06544017791748047, -0.0035828237887471914, 0.039924751967191696, 0.042863838374614716, -0.014643410220742226, -0.0145263671875, -0.04054898023605347, -0.05017253756523132, 0.02065163105726242, -0.013915141113102436, -0.019091052934527397, -0.01559276133775711, -0.016477087512612343, -0.0016743686283007264, 0.014487352222204208, 0.00851814728230238, -0.01240658387541771, 0.01706230454146862, -0.02357771061360836, -0.03828614577651024, -0.020053409039974213, -0.006925058551132679, 0.030041098594665527, -0.02148393727838993, -0.00468498095870018, -0.024344995617866516, -0.038234125822782516, -0.022992495447397232, -0.005523791071027517, 0.004233064129948616, -0.00864169280976057, 0.013980165123939514, -0.03641345351934433, -0.02545040287077427, 0.03953460603952408, -0.04824782535433769, -0.02550242282450199, -0.025567445904016495, -0.044944606721401215, -0.022017134353518486, 0.04127725213766098, -0.08021363615989685, -0.03311023488640785, -0.004870299249887466, -0.025931579992175102, -0.012445597909390926, -0.022667374461889267, 0.05175912380218506, 0.03459278121590614, 0.009532522410154343, -0.041173212230205536, 0.007692342158406973, 0.021145813167095184, 0.025125283747911453, 0.05383989214897156, -0.03136758878827095, -0.03893638402223587, -0.023850811645388603, 0.012348062358796597, -0.05243537202477455, 0.02568448893725872, 0.02000138908624649, -0.054828256368637085, -0.019000019878149033, -0.015059564262628555, -0.009135875850915909, 0.06164277344942093, -0.03680359944701195, -0.047883693128824234, 0.005982210393995047, 0.025970594957470894, -0.04314994439482689, -0.021197831258177757, 0.039872732013463974, 0.047441527247428894, 0.024527061730623245, -0.05789739266037941, -0.00334548600949347, -0.02611364796757698, 0.007763868663460016, -0.0019295879174023867, -0.026841918006539345, 0.014617400243878365, 0.06715681403875351, -0.007763868663460016, 0.007120130583643913, -0.0016223493730649352, -0.06606440991163254, -0.03740181773900986, -0.039690665900707245, 0.039274509996175766, 0.01547571737319231, 0.01831076480448246, 0.006664962507784367, -0.028948696330189705, 0.028714608401060104, 0.016073938459157944, 0.05001647770404816, 0.016698168590664864, 0.027284080162644386, -0.01199042983353138, -0.017946630716323853, -0.010819997638463974, -0.0061057559214532375, 0.03753186762332916, -0.029000714421272278, 0.0017442695097997785, -0.006404866464436054, -0.029781002551317215, -0.012647172436118126, -0.00737372413277626, 0.033578407019376755, -0.047441527247428894, -0.015540741384029388, 0.018804946914315224, -0.019715284928679466, 0.010501380078494549, 0.028740618377923965, 0.04835186526179314, -0.013980165123939514, 0.0078093851916491985, 0.004444391932338476, -0.014279276132583618, 0.03201783075928688, -0.04715542122721672, 0.01685422658920288, -0.05560854449868202, 0.0047044879756867886, -0.03727177157998085, -0.04174542427062988, 0.037791963666677475, -0.030587300658226013, 0.018583865836262703, -0.022030139341950417, -0.08245046436786652, -0.01556675136089325, 0.0391184538602829, -0.02543739788234234, 0.030639320611953735, 0.020742664113640785, -0.02629571594297886, -0.01745244860649109, 0.017998650670051575, 0.006873039528727531, -0.002836673054844141, 0.053943932056427, -0.017972640693187714, -0.01126216072589159, 0.01746545359492302, 0.020963745191693306, 0.021939106285572052, 0.009233411401510239, 0.02863658033311367, 0.03383850306272507, -0.031705714762210846, 0.016750188544392586, -0.0017117573879659176, -0.0715264230966568, 0.027752254158258438, 0.002430272987112403, -0.022589346393942833, 0.014292280189692974, -0.06549219787120819, -0.013446968048810959, -0.05430806428194046, -0.029000714421272278, 0.012348062358796597, -0.015176607295870781, -0.017374418675899506, 0.05217527598142624, 0.015085573308169842, -0.05225330591201782, -0.005673346109688282, 0.05514037236571312, -0.016945261508226395, 0.018154706805944443, -0.008895286358892918, 0.0025830792728811502, 0.004148532636463642, 0.024748142808675766, 0.02231624536216259, 0.01643807254731655, 0.04109518229961395, 0.02863658033311367, 0.0013484357623383403, -0.00210677832365036, 0.013642040081322193, -0.041979510337114334, -0.017127327620983124, 0.023070523515343666, 0.01200343482196331, 0.04504864290356636, -0.007549289148300886, -0.031497638672590256, -0.028766628354787827, 0.01724437065422535, -0.010481872595846653, 0.03134157881140709, -0.04171941429376602, 0.028584560379385948, -0.012673182412981987, -0.01959824003279209, 0.009298435412347317, -0.008017461746931076, -0.021405909210443497, 0.04169340431690216, -0.009363459423184395, -0.03937854990363121, -0.043696142733097076, -0.011613290756940842, 0.05493229627609253, 0.01012424100190401, 0.011236151680350304, -0.026165667921304703, 0.004278580658137798, -0.0258665569126606, -0.01978030800819397, 0.009688579477369785, 0.0055465493351221085, 0.034202635288238525, -0.003631591796875, 0.02991105057299137, 0.02777826227247715, 0.00800445768982172, 0.017543481662869453, 0.007997955195605755, 0.008440118283033371, 0.09857641905546188, -0.025307349860668182, 0.03370845317840576, -0.055712584406137466, 0.006024475675076246, -0.0016060933703556657, -0.006118760909885168, -0.0075883036479353905, 0.009747100993990898, 0.007438748609274626, -0.026191677898168564, 0.017959635704755783, -0.01642506942152977, 0.04403426870703697, -0.02334362454712391, -0.03826013579964638, 0.03732379153370857, 0.047051385045051575, -0.024475043639540672, 0.020755669102072716, -0.054412104189395905, 0.017361413687467575, 0.019039034843444824, -0.000985926715657115, -0.009005827829241753, 0.0022417032159864902, 0.0328761450946331, 0.007757366169244051, 0.008771740831434727, -0.04249970242381096, 0.005858664400875568, -0.0013451845152303576, -0.010189265012741089, -0.031471628695726395, -0.07698844373226166, 0.03534705936908722, -0.0046329619362950325, -0.0090578468516469, 0.016073938459157944, 0.020287495106458664, 0.06294325739145279, -0.018557855859398842, -0.01790761575102806, 0.05805344879627228, 0.024253960698843002, 0.0426037423312664, -0.004298088140785694, -0.0316016748547554, -0.027023984119296074, -0.0395866259932518, -0.000579526589717716, 0.00893430132418871, 0.021119803190231323, -0.001991360681131482, 0.037167731672525406, -0.00969508197158575, 0.032121866941452026, -0.032512012869119644, 0.030561290681362152, -0.013733074069023132, 0.008433615788817406, -0.0006640578503720462, -0.023434657603502274, 0.021158818155527115, 0.008797750808298588, 0.11069689691066742, -0.004824782721698284, -0.004808526486158371, 0.013524997048079967, -0.03412460908293724, -0.013850117102265358, 0.022147182375192642, -0.01284224446862936, -0.023070523515343666, 0.00012832085485570133, -0.028064368292689323, -0.02780427224934101, 0.034228645265102386, 0.03446273133158684, 0.019507206976413727, -0.031471628695726395, 0.03513898327946663, 0.03339633718132973, -0.04049696400761604, 0.03391652926802635, -0.03667354956269264, 0.030561290681362152, 0.016698168590664864, -0.030041098594665527, -0.019052039831876755, 0.03404657915234566, -0.0041062673553824425, 0.021340884268283844, -0.02235526032745838, 0.028948696330189705, -0.03508696332573891, 0.010358327068388462, 0.055504508316516876, 0.018011655658483505, -0.008219036273658276, -0.04361811652779579, -0.0012858500704169273, 0.036517493426799774, -0.012926775962114334, 0.032512012869119644, -0.033214271068573, 0.02944287844002247, -0.00018491207447368652, 0.026035619899630547, -0.0020580103155225515, -0.020326510071754456, 0.01659413054585457, 0.0162039864808321, 0.013980165123939514, -0.018687903881072998, 0.0039892238564789295, 0.011359697207808495, -0.03810407966375351, -0.017543481662869453, -0.009565033949911594, -0.03560715541243553, -0.02398085966706276, -0.01702328957617283, 0.04273378849029541, 0.07704046368598938, 0.01935114897787571, 0.026347734034061432, -0.0018304262775927782, -0.0014191493391990662, 0.042629748582839966, 0.01940316893160343, 0.019624250009655952, -0.061954889446496964, -0.013941151089966297, -0.04645316302776337, -0.014500357210636139, 0.01746545359492302, -0.011437726207077503, 0.017543481662869453, -0.014188242144882679, 0.01747845858335495, -0.020729659125208855, -0.029598936438560486, 0.028506532311439514, 0.0045256721787154675, 0.025840546935796738, 0.05680498853325844, -0.003677108557894826, -0.012497617863118649, -0.018570860847830772, 0.04018484801054001, 0.01807667873799801, -0.023018505424261093, -0.02508626878261566, 0.003381249262019992, -0.02803836017847061, -0.014760453253984451, 0.013746079057455063, 0.00599521491676569, -0.00799145270138979, -0.003885185346007347, 0.02866259030997753, -0.032746098935604095, 0.007711849175393581, 0.002573325764387846, -0.018440812826156616, 0.028922686353325844, 0.011860381811857224, 0.0005356353940442204, 0.01547571737319231, 0.03950859606266022, -0.01170432474464178, -0.010052714496850967, -0.11631497740745544, -0.018180716782808304, -0.021939106285572052, 0.0007286754553206265, -0.030197156593203545, -0.005153154022991657, 0.005855413619428873, -0.025307349860668182, -0.011561271734535694, 0.0006364226574078202, -0.0039892238564789295, -0.016125958412885666, -0.015202617272734642, 0.02907874435186386, 0.02463109977543354, -0.040314894169569016, 0.015319660305976868, 0.004454145673662424, 0.03456677123904228, -0.0001368552475469187, -0.01871391385793686, 0.02798634022474289, 0.03352638706564903, 0.030873406678438187, -0.009922666475176811, 0.008219036273658276, -0.00583915738388896, -0.004405377432703972, 0.019078047946095467, -0.010468867607414722, -0.012900765985250473, -0.005439259577542543, 0.025996604934334755, -0.03136758878827095, -0.014253266155719757, -0.02607463300228119, 0.06211094930768013, 0.0014736069133505225, -0.021978119388222694, 0.017998650670051575, -0.02988504245877266, 0.004174542147666216, 0.01577482745051384, -0.03594528138637543, -0.025372374802827835, 0.031445618718862534, 0.004242817405611277, 0.00023205448815133423, -0.009727594442665577, -0.03173172473907471, 0.00820603221654892, -0.00684702955186367, -0.020053409039974213, 0.007932931184768677, -0.01662014052271843, 0.0007778498693369329, 0.014448338188230991, -0.06658460199832916, -0.02234225533902645, 0.002401011995971203, 0.005988712422549725, 0.029104752466082573, 0.0035308045335114002, -0.017998650670051575, 0.0021311624441295862, 0.02191309630870819, 0.036933645606040955, -0.027856292203068733, 0.029963070526719093, 0.04226561635732651, 0.0091423774138093, 0.004655720200389624, 0.0014085829025134444, -0.014487352222204208, 0.006518658250570297, -0.03430667519569397, -0.014175237156450748, -0.02485218271613121, 0.049990471452474594, 0.03279811888933182, -0.0193901639431715, 0.002251456957310438, 0.0014028933364897966, 0.010143747553229332, 0.007666332647204399, 0.021600980311632156, 0.02360372059047222, -0.03329230099916458, -0.00741924112662673, 0.02738811820745468, -0.028688600286841393, 0.023694753646850586, -0.010793987661600113, -0.019468192011117935, -0.014448338188230991, -0.0006156962481327355, 0.0254634078592062, 0.051681093871593475, 0.0025749513879418373, -0.004148532636463642, -0.030899416655302048, 0.0254634078592062, -0.01833677478134632, 0.027076004073023796, -0.025177301838994026, 0.01619098149240017, 0.01769953966140747, -0.039482586085796356, -0.002092147944495082, 0.012061956338584423, 0.018466822803020477, -0.034410715103149414, -0.016802208498120308, 0.026815908029675484, 0.026659850031137466, 0.030613310635089874, -0.03594528138637543, 0.021340884268283844, 0.03329230099916458, -0.012686187401413918, 0.019910356029868126, 0.005588815081864595, -0.025359369814395905, -0.05331970006227493, -0.0025944586377590895, 0.02926081046462059, 0.025346364825963974, 0.010833002626895905, 0.03760989382863045, 0.01954622194170952, -0.006034229416400194, -0.028740618377923965, -0.04140729829668999, 0.018466822803020477, -0.006453634239733219, -0.023109538480639458, -0.0014565380988642573, 0.0012777220690622926, 0.008784745819866657, -0.011938410811126232, 0.011912400834262371, 0.02188708633184433, 0.045776914805173874, 0.03617936745285988, -0.01051438506692648, 0.04057499021291733, 0.00041371534462086856, -0.018037663772702217, -0.02840249426662922, -0.019442183896899223, -0.04699936509132385, -0.012796727940440178, 0.02186107635498047, -0.011483242735266685, 0.002105152700096369, -0.012224516831338406, -0.013102340511977673, 0.014240261167287827, 0.022472303360700607, 0.009083855897188187, -0.015553746372461319, -0.003696615807712078, 0.012445597909390926, 0.005036110524088144, 0.016295021399855614, 0.009194397367537022, 0.007568796630948782, 0.01808968372642994, -0.031055474653840065, -0.01231554988771677, -0.03173172473907471, 0.001710131880827248, -0.035243019461631775, 0.046245086938142776, 0.01659413054585457, 0.016932256519794464, -0.05321566015481949, 0.006167528685182333, 0.011873386800289154, -0.021991124376654625, -0.004437889438122511, 0.020911727100610733, 0.014630405232310295, 0.016789203509688377, 0.02649078704416752, 0.0028448011726140976, -0.0017816582694649696, 0.004603700712323189, -0.008375094272196293, 0.0003671825397759676, -0.0052669458091259, -0.01919509284198284, -0.02718004211783409, -0.01728338561952114, -0.007692342158406973, -0.0303272046148777, 0.01833677478134632, 0.022199202328920364, -0.0657522901892662, -0.01525463629513979, -0.0023912584874778986, -0.04067903012037277, 0.022368263453245163, -0.00841410830616951, 0.0017166342586278915, 0.015241631306707859, 0.006996585056185722, 0.02105477824807167, 0.03584124147891998, 0.013511992059648037, -0.014396319165825844, 0.01409720815718174, 0.030275186523795128, -0.0029862283263355494, -0.017634514719247818, 0.03667354956269264, 0.02863658033311367, 0.004499662667512894, -0.008394601754844189, 0.005523791071027517, 0.011457232758402824, -0.022589346393942833, -0.02884465642273426, 0.004828033968806267, 0.011203639209270477, 0.02759619615972042, 0.012178999371826649, 0.02650379203259945, -0.018050668761134148, 0.016360044479370117, -0.02718004211783409, 0.016984274610877037, 0.021145813167095184, 0.03373446315526962, 0.02822042629122734, 0.0021929352078586817, 0.02104177512228489, -0.014344300143420696, 0.03095143474638462, -0.026659850031137466, 0.025320354849100113, 0.027856292203068733, -0.01197742484509945, -0.014461343176662922, -0.0023359879851341248, -0.012699192389845848, -0.0046394639648497105, 0.025723503902554512, -0.001690624631009996, 0.008167017251253128, -0.021965116262435913, -0.039898741990327835, 0.02041754312813282, -0.0065576727502048016, -0.03425465524196625, 0.01810268871486187, -0.02403287962079048, -0.03339633718132973, 0.0073997341096401215, -0.0025521928910166025, 0.0039892238564789295, 0.0059171863831579685, -0.03282412886619568, -0.029520906507968903, 0.0090578468516469, 0.0064113689586520195, -0.015293650329113007, -0.01314785797148943, 0.03352638706564903, -0.023200571537017822, -0.08962911367416382, 0.027622206136584282, 0.00831657275557518, 0.006125262938439846, 0.006502402480691671, 0.040080808103084564, 0.02166600525379181, 0.024878190830349922, -0.017127327620983124, -0.01814170368015766, 0.0042948368936777115, -0.0032544524874538183, -0.03508696332573891, 0.003100020345300436, 0.0021084039472043514, -0.03532104939222336, 0.018232736736536026, 0.002553818514570594, -0.004457396920770407, -0.023889826610684395, 0.012126980349421501, 0.004301339387893677, 0.0006238242494873703, 0.013264901004731655, 0.0055367955937981606, -0.0008924547582864761, -0.03139359876513481, 0.018908986821770668, 0.01547571737319231, 0.02191309630870819, 0.004606951959431171, 0.0067559960298240185, 0.021405909210443497, 0.02294047549366951, 0.01894799992442131, -0.018687903881072998, -0.007438748609274626, 0.02018345706164837, -0.016047928482294083, 0.009278927929699421, -0.007685839664191008, -0.023486677557229996, 0.0013728197664022446, 0.011359697207808495, 0.03199182078242302, -0.008492137305438519, 0.014812473207712173, 0.03839018568396568, 0.021327879279851913, 0.033604416996240616, 0.019923361018300056, 0.021809058263897896, -0.015046559274196625, 0.009174889884889126, -0.015904875472187996, 0.06793709844350815, -0.003742132568731904, -0.0022628360893577337, -0.016737183555960655, 0.01316736452281475, -0.03285013884305954, 0.013941151089966297, 0.019858337938785553, -0.04593297094106674, -0.03867628797888756, -0.013941151089966297, -0.008888783864676952, 0.00632033497095108, -0.019234105944633484, -0.01556675136089325, 0.006931561045348644, 0.055036332458257675, 0.016099948436021805, -0.0006258562207221985, 0.001206195680424571, 0.0106509355828166, -0.028272446244955063, -0.027284080162644386, -0.05259143188595772, 0.018570860847830772, 0.011996932327747345, -0.031055474653840065, -0.02545040287077427, -0.006011471152305603, 0.0003188209084328264, 0.026399753987789154, 0.011652304790914059, -0.006216296926140785, 0.0059562004171311855, 0.002435149624943733, 0.02255033142864704, -0.03285013884305954, 0.04699936509132385, -0.04231763631105423, -0.03917047381401062, -0.006027726922184229, -0.006899049039930105, -0.0263347290456295, 0.01127516571432352, -0.00840760674327612, 0.008368591777980328, 0.008862774819135666, -0.037765953689813614, -0.01221801433712244, 0.051681093871593475, -0.003270708490163088, 0.004512667190283537, 0.003197556361556053, 0.024553071707487106, 0.04887205734848976, 0.031913790851831436, -0.007003087550401688, -0.00008702043123776093, 0.033994559198617935, 0.030665330588817596, -0.013141355477273464, -0.03459278121590614, -0.007679337169975042, 0.011886391788721085, -0.022407278418540955, 0.016060933470726013, 0.003829915076494217, -0.05256542190909386, -0.0030561292078346014, -0.012523626908659935, 0.002314855344593525, -0.02970297448337078, 0.0007806947105564177, -0.024943215772509575, 0.03370845317840576, -0.024527061730623245, -0.018674898892641068, 0.021718023344874382, -0.009630057960748672, -0.019299130886793137, -0.020664634183049202, -0.003683611052110791, 0.04681729897856712, -0.009630057960748672, 0.012497617863118649, 0.002287219977006316, -0.0352950394153595, -0.016125958412885666, 0.008212534710764885, -0.018271751701831818, 0.0015118086012080312, 0.009961680509150028, -0.02796033024787903, 0.021561967208981514, 0.037974029779434204, -0.02065163105726242, -0.026568816974759102, -0.030821386724710464, 0.035711195319890976, 0.012920273467898369, 0.005328718572854996, 0.006385358981788158, -0.005286453291773796, -0.0210677832365036, 0.012335057370364666, 0.05238335579633713, 0.041823454201221466, -0.02148393727838993, -0.02144492231309414, -0.01345997303724289, 0.0019393415423110127, -0.016958264634013176, 0.016269011422991753, -0.015488722361624241, -0.05290354788303375, -0.02649078704416752, -0.04861196130514145, -0.003322727745398879, 0.006170779932290316, -0.028350474312901497, -0.004509415943175554, -0.01578783243894577, -0.002453031251206994, 0.04130326211452484, 0.0070941210724413395, -0.00808898825198412, 0.041823454201221466, 0.007471260614693165, 0.0038981903344392776, 0.04679128900170326, -0.00024099528673104942, -0.026269705966114998, 0.02965095452964306, -0.002974849194288254, 0.000877824320923537, -0.004564686678349972, 0.023512687534093857, -0.020677639171481133, 0.01981932297348976, 0.013511992059648037, 0.027076004073023796, -0.013967160135507584, 0.017400428652763367, 0.0042200591415166855, -0.022043144330382347, -0.040314894169569016, 0.007698844652622938, 0.009025334380567074, -0.005777384620159864, -0.01602192036807537, 0.013316920027136803, -0.0063365912064909935, 0.0006782818818464875, -0.026438768953084946, -0.024670114740729332, 0.007711849175393581, -0.02612665295600891, 0.014227256178855896, 0.03480085730552673, 0.03300619497895241, -0.03183576092123985, 0.028454512357711792, -0.019117062911391258, -0.06190286949276924, -0.00831657275557518, 0.05259143188595772, -0.06975777447223663, -0.03599730134010315, 0.06793709844350815, -0.010462365113198757, 0.015514732338488102, -0.014994540251791477, -0.0003490977396722883, -0.01914307288825512, 0.02357771061360836, 0.012198506854474545, -0.014227256178855896, -0.023083528503775597, -0.022667374461889267, -0.010605418123304844, -0.025424392893910408, -0.017400428652763367, -0.007295695599168539, -0.00019608807633630931, 0.023031508550047874, 0.03454076126217842, -0.003257703734561801, -0.013928146101534367, -0.03277210891246796, 0.011229649186134338, -0.023473672568798065, 0.013811103068292141, -0.01442232821136713, 0.019845332950353622, 0.00015331445320043713, -0.014383314177393913, 0.046843308955430984, -0.0059171863831579685, -0.02590557187795639, 0.015670789405703545, 0.0038559245876967907, -0.007698844652622938, 0.026997974142432213, -0.006866537034511566, -0.003303220495581627, -0.02421494759619236, 0.001788160647265613, -0.022641364485025406, -0.016789203509688377, 0.002375002484768629, -0.004457396920770407, -0.02819441631436348, 0.03180975094437599, 0.01808968372642994, -0.055452488362789154, 0.020885717123746872, -0.01664615049958229, 0.06814517825841904, 0.00026151849306188524, -0.024579081684350967, 0.003998977597802877, -0.011860381811857224, 0.0019751046784222126, -0.02547641284763813, 0.012035947293043137, 0.001843431033194065, 0.01808968372642994, -0.03719374164938927, -0.023434657603502274, 0.004291585646569729, -0.002586330519989133, 0.001241958816535771, -0.0005750562413595617, 0.022485308349132538, 0.020079419016838074, -0.006414620205760002, 0.04543878883123398, 0.0006404866580851376, -0.01854485087096691, -0.0052669458091259, -0.010267293080687523, -0.014812473207712173, 0.012647172436118126, 0.026256700977683067, -0.028792638331651688, -0.020937735214829445, -0.015930885449051857, 0.021379899233579636, -0.0023782537318766117, -0.013219384476542473, -0.01685422658920288, -0.03095143474638462, -0.03266806900501251, -0.016347039490938187, -0.01703629456460476, 0.0026172169018536806, 0.000300939311273396, -0.020326510071754456, -0.005081627517938614, -0.007770370692014694, -0.04819580540060997, 0.018635885789990425, 0.00589442765340209, 0.015020549297332764, -0.015449708327651024, -0.005572558846324682, -0.003966465592384338, 0.0319398008286953, 0.0012370820622891188, -0.03602331131696701, -0.01832376979291439, 0.023642735555768013, -0.007477762643247843, 0.013017809949815273, 0.016125958412885666, 0.013446968048810959, 0.016555117443203926, 0.0067885080352425575, -0.029598936438560486, -0.008791248314082623, 0.04083508625626564, -0.014578386209905148, 0.010163255035877228, 0.031913790851831436, 0.026412758976221085, -0.02148393727838993, -0.016073938459157944, -0.02842850424349308, -0.003631591796875, 0.028974704444408417, 0.003917697351425886, -0.020365525037050247, -0.02375977858901024, -0.03867628797888756, -0.006528411991894245, 0.06861335039138794, -0.01789461076259613, 0.010475370101630688, -0.03300619497895241, -0.005065371282398701, -0.011762846261262894, -0.022654369473457336, 0.04106917232275009, 0.0037778958212584257, -0.018453817814588547, 0.025593455880880356, 0.0019620999228209257, 0.012393578886985779, 0.0017800326459109783, 0.05867768079042435, -0.012510621920228004, -0.027440138161182404, 0.024969225749373436, 0.007841897197067738, -0.010117738507688046, -0.00008234682900365442, 0.00583915738388896, 0.0010802116012200713, 0.03742782771587372, -0.020365525037050247, -0.005221429280936718, -0.0028269195463508368, -0.021965116262435913, 0.01706230454146862, -0.0004303777532186359, -0.0007120130467228591, -0.0024367752484977245, -0.008576668798923492, 0.036751579493284225, 0.00252780900336802, 0.03324028104543686, 0.02655581198632717, 0.009675574488937855, 0.016269011422991753, 0.024774152785539627, 0.026412758976221085, -0.01766052469611168, 0.00873272679746151, -0.00020045688143000007, 0.02208215929567814, 0.0467652790248394, -0.02819441631436348, 0.02294047549366951, 0.008180022239685059, 0.017543481662869453, -0.02213417738676071, -0.020716654136776924, 0.03248600289225578, -0.003247949993237853, 0.02105477824807167, -0.00990966148674488, 0.018674898892641068, 0.038624271750450134, 0.03794801980257034, -0.021835068240761757, -0.03786999359726906, -0.01578783243894577, -0.038650281727313995, 0.03339633718132973, 0.030171146616339684, -0.004148532636463642, 0.017634514719247818, 0.04130326211452484, -0.004652468953281641, 0.006795010529458523, 0.015904875472187996, -0.002079143188893795, -0.027700234204530716, 0.022485308349132538, -0.00405749911442399, 0.02798634022474289, -0.0258665569126606, 0.03810407966375351, 0.006645455490797758, -0.025346364825963974, -0.012907268479466438, -0.007308700121939182, -0.017621509730815887, 0.03389052301645279, -0.017595501616597176, 0.02632172591984272, 0.02417593263089657, -0.01703629456460476, -0.005806645378470421, 0.015956895425915718, -0.0239548496901989, -0.022212207317352295, 0.005318965297192335, 0.008875778876245022, 0.02438400872051716, -0.020339515060186386, -0.021392904222011566, 0.0019490951672196388, 0.007328207604587078, -0.022589346393942833, -0.015670789405703545, 0.01829775981605053, 0.0233826395124197, -0.033604416996240616, -0.01724437065422535, -0.014617400243878365, -0.003755137324333191, -0.04062701016664505, 0.02044355310499668, 0.02166600525379181, 0.009291932918131351, 0.000017678406948107295, 0.041121192276477814, 0.01166530977934599, -0.001050950842909515, 0.044476430863142014, -0.006135016679763794, -0.019416173920035362, -0.016295021399855614, -0.017855597659945488, -0.0025310602504760027, -0.01158728078007698, 0.011086596176028252, -0.02801235020160675, -0.03076936863362789, -0.03513898327946663, -0.013050321489572525, -0.012926775962114334, -0.0032593291252851486, 0.02002739906311035, -0.020703649148344994, 0.011392208747565746, 0.013746079057455063, 0.009103363379836082, 0.008310070261359215, -0.012549636885523796, -0.0009973059641197324, -0.008700214326381683, 0.039014413952827454, 0.013720069080591202, -0.010774481110274792, -0.01876593381166458, -0.04481455683708191, -0.05074474960565567, 0.029052734375, -0.016034923493862152, 0.004340353421866894, -0.006814517546445131, 0.012725201435387135, -0.018453817814588547, 0.0033276043832302094, 0.0006234178435988724, 0.02000138908624649, 0.014786463230848312, 0.00924641638994217, 0.0038884365931153297, -0.025645475834608078, -0.011938410811126232, -0.028922686353325844, 0.016581125557422638, -0.005436008330434561, -0.0023522439878433943, -0.012048951350152493, 0.008680706843733788, 0.018245741724967957, 0.01451336219906807, -0.003976218868046999, -0.006886044051498175, -0.01663314551115036, 0.003621838055551052, -0.021093793213367462, -0.032928165048360825, 0.016802208498120308, -0.04543878883123398, 0.002366874599829316, -0.010449361056089401, -0.015085573308169842, -0.006769001018255949, -0.0365695096552372, 0.012393578886985779, 0.009870646521449089, -0.044502440840005875, 0.012699192389845848, 0.032512012869119644, -0.0050848787650465965, -0.024969225749373436, -0.028922686353325844, 0.015059564262628555, 0.027934320271015167, -0.03909244388341904, 0.009981187991797924, -0.024761147797107697, 0.018258746713399887, 0.031679704785346985, 0.02671186998486519, 0.05623277649283409, 0.01240658387541771, -0.023005500435829163, -0.027830282226204872, 0.014786463230848312, -0.03789599984884262, 0.004873550496995449, 0.004324097651988268, -0.027700234204530716, -0.02422795072197914, 0.018063673749566078, 0.005982210393995047, 0.01199042983353138, 0.015696799382567406, 0.016919251531362534, -0.0010769603541120887, -0.02671186998486519, -0.02087271213531494, 0.0014996165409684181, 0.04210955649614334, 0.03115951269865036, 0.014929516240954399, 0.013212881982326508, -0.003322727745398879, -0.004818280227482319, 0.03430667519569397, 0.015371679328382015, -0.0009257795754820108, 0.03854624181985855, -0.015644779428839684, -0.013967160135507584, 0.0014996165409684181, 0.022056149318814278, -0.005016603507101536, -0.01263416837900877, -0.01976730301976204, -0.016347039490938187, 0.022381268441677094, 0.014019180089235306, -0.006801513023674488, 0.014344300143420696, -0.0057351188734173775, 0.003100020345300436, -0.04973037540912628, 0.007009590044617653, -0.0056115733459591866, -0.013193374499678612, -0.009955178014934063, 0.009005827829241753, -0.002597709884867072, 0.05178513377904892, 0.0090578468516469, 0.006619445513933897, -0.02777826227247715, 0.00030337771750055254, -0.01723136566579342, 0.04320196062326431, -0.005403496325016022, 0.0006526786601170897, -0.015345669351518154, -0.027310090139508247, 0.028246436268091202, -0.03766191378235817, -0.002503424882888794, 0.02400686964392662, -0.002939085941761732, 0.00631058169528842, 0.038624271750450134, 0.032954175025224686, 0.009552028961479664, -0.006089499685913324, -0.014240261167287827, 0.010585911571979523, 0.007484265137463808, -0.006723484024405479, 0.010442858561873436, -0.036075327545404434, -0.02759619615972042, -0.01875292882323265, 0.03602331131696701, 0.01707530952990055, 0.03454076126217842, -0.001043635536916554, 0.03859826177358627, -0.015228626318275928, 0.02018345706164837, -0.0034722827840596437, 0.013024312444031239, -0.004967835266143084, -0.0006213858141563833, 0.025411387905478477, 0.010455863550305367, 0.028168408200144768, -0.010241284035146236, 0.007581801153719425, 0.033162251114845276, 0.018258746713399887, 0.009129373356699944, -0.022823432460427284, -0.016164973378181458, -0.008147510699927807, -0.019728289917111397, -0.029156772419810295, 0.003298343624919653, -0.02923480048775673, 0.04484056681394577, -0.013037316501140594, -0.006996585056185722, 0.019481196999549866, 0.04772763326764107, 0.021509947255253792, -0.041797444224357605, 0.008973315358161926, 0.009376464411616325, -0.008082486689090729, 0.01305682398378849, 0.01485148724168539, -0.004135528113692999, 0.030613310635089874, -0.014799468219280243, 0.0004506977566052228, -0.004463899414986372, 0.06237104535102844, -0.016919251531362534, 0.017738554626703262, 0.0004218433459755033, 0.031705714762210846, -0.003839668584987521, 0.013342930004000664, 0.006349596194922924, -0.005140149034559727, 0.006323586218059063, 0.0075883036479353905, 0.037349797785282135, -0.009213903918862343, -0.007679337169975042, -0.013746079057455063, 0.004993845243006945, 0.029208792373538017, 0.0034820365253835917, -0.009428483434021473, 0.0011704324278980494, 0.009096860885620117, 0.0008046723087318242, -0.029338840395212173, -0.009929168969392776, -0.01559276133775711, 0.025996604934334755, 0.005689602345228195, -0.022563336417078972, 0.02507326379418373, -0.019273120909929276, 0.02144492231309414, -0.014058194123208523, -0.0012346436269581318, 0.004512667190283537, 0.0050848787650465965, -0.0028464265633374453, 0.01975429803133011, 0.01893499679863453, 0.0015589509857818484, 0.008030466735363007, -0.03324028104543686, 0.020144442096352577, 0.0303272046148777, -0.00013665204460266978, -0.005175912287086248, 0.0041452813893556595, 0.0038689293432980776, 0.018674898892641068, -0.010059216991066933, 0.03141960874199867, -0.0233826395124197, -0.009181392379105091, -0.0032268171198666096, 0.011957918293774128, 0.019078047946095467, 0.010000694543123245, -0.01980631798505783, -0.015865862369537354, -0.01876593381166458, 0.011158122681081295, 0.0013841988984495401, 0.01792062073945999, 0.0032837132457643747, 0.026165667921304703, -0.03331831097602844, 0.00737372413277626, 0.002888692310079932, 0.020664634183049202, -0.017309395596385002, -0.02463109977543354, 0.03826013579964638, -0.021314874291419983 ]
13.337981
5.561089
2024-07-01
6
2024MNRAS.531.3406B
[ "stellar feedback models", "stellar feedback", "supernova feedback", "supernova feedback drive profound differences", "feedback", "burstier feedback", "galaxy morphology", "post-reionization galaxy morphologies", "reionization histories", "galaxy kinematics" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
67
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1125", "10.48550/arXiv.2310.16895" ]
[ "Bhagwat, Aniket", "Costa, Tiago", "Ciardi, Benedetta", "Pakmor, Rüdiger", "Garaldi, Enrico" ]
[ "Max Planck Institut für Astrophysik, Karl Schwarzschild Straße 1, D-85741 Garching, Germany", "Max Planck Institut für Astrophysik, Karl Schwarzschild Straße 1, D-85741 Garching, Germany; School of Mathematics, Statistics and Physics, Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne, NE1 7RU, UK", "Max Planck Institut für Astrophysik, Karl Schwarzschild Straße 1, D-85741 Garching, Germany", "Max Planck Institut für Astrophysik, Karl Schwarzschild Straße 1, D-85741 Garching, Germany", "Max Planck Institut für Astrophysik, Karl Schwarzschild Straße 1, D-85741 Garching, Germany" ]
[ "2024ApJ...968...13L", "2024MNRAS.528.7543H", "2024MNRAS.530.3765G", "2024arXiv240413045L", "2024arXiv240417630Z", "2024arXiv240601277B" ]
[ "1971ApJ...165L...9H", "1972ApJ...178..623T", "1977ApJ...218..148M", "1977egsp.conf..401T", "1981MNRAS.194..809L", "1984JQSRT..31..149L", "1985Natur.317...44C", "1986ApJ...303...39D", "1987ApJ...319..730S", "1987ApJ...321L.107S", "1987MNRAS.224..801H", "1992MNRAS.256P..43E", "1994ShWav...4...25T", "1995ApJ...440..634R", "1996ApJ...461...20H", "1996ApJ...471..115B", "1997MNRAS.292...27H", "1998A&A...334..814B", "1998ApJ...500...95T", "1998ApJ...500..342B", "1998PASP..110..761F", "1999ApJ...514..648M", "2000ApJ...539..505G", "2000ApJ...542..535G", "2001ASPC..240..135B", "2001NewA....6..437G", "2002A&A...385..337T", "2002ApJ...572L..23S", "2003A&A...410..611S", "2003MNRAS.339..289S", "2003MNRAS.342..299C", "2003PASP..115..763C", "2004ApJ...607L..17P", "2004ApJ...615L..45H", "2004BaltA..13..365K", "2004MNRAS.352..376A", "2005ApJ...618..569M", "2005ApJ...630..250K", "2005ApJ...630..675K", "2005MNRAS.363.1299O", "2006A&A...450..283S", "2006AJ....132..117F", "2006ApJ...645..986R", "2006ApJ...653.1145K", "2006MNRAS.372..839N", "2007ApJ...654..304K", "2007CSE.....9...90H", "2007MNRAS.376.1465K", "2008A&A...477...79D", "2008AJ....136.2846B", "2008ApJ...685...40W", "2008MNRAS.390..920O", "2009A&A...506..647T", "2009ApJ...693..984W", "2009ApJ...694L.158B", "2009ApJ...703..785D", "2009ApJ...704.1640L", "2009MNRAS.397..802H", "2010ApJ...721..975O", "2010Natur.468...49R", "2011A&A...528A.106S", "2011ApJ...729..133M", "2011ApJ...731...41O", "2011ApJ...743L..29H", "2011JCoPh.230.4756G", "2011MNRAS.410.1391A", "2011MNRAS.415.3237M", "2012ARA&A..50..531K", "2012ApJ...744...83O", "2012ApJ...745...50W", "2012ApJ...761..156F", "2012MNRAS.422.1384F", "2012MNRAS.427..311W", "2013ApJ...767...59P", "2013ApJ...768...71R", "2013ApJ...777...39Z", "2013MNRAS.428..154H", "2013MNRAS.428.2966P", "2013MNRAS.428.3058S", "2013MNRAS.433.1970F", "2013MNRAS.436.2188R", "2014A&A...563A..11C", "2014ARA&A..52..415M", "2014ApJ...788..121K", "2014ApJ...793...29G", "2014ApJ...797...97S", "2014ApJS..214...15S", "2014MNRAS.439..725I", "2014MNRAS.439.2146C", "2014MNRAS.440.3349R", "2014MNRAS.442.2780R", "2014MNRAS.445..581H", "2014nmat.book.....S", "2015A&A...573A..10M", "2015A&A...578A...7V", "2015ARA&A..53...51S", "2015ApJ...802...99K", "2015ApJ...802L..19R", "2015ApJ...803...34B", "2015ApJ...807L..12O", "2015ApJ...810...71F", "2015MNRAS.447..499M", "2015MNRAS.448.3248G", "2015MNRAS.449..147T", "2015MNRAS.449.4380R", "2015MNRAS.451...34R", "2015MNRAS.451.2900K", "2015MNRAS.452.4347K", "2015MNRAS.454..238W", "2015MNRAS.454.3464S", "2016A&A...594A..13P", "2016ApJ...821...38S", "2016ApJ...824...79A", "2016ApJ...833...66G", "2016ApJ...833..229L", "2016MNRAS.456L..69M", "2016MNRAS.459.2311M", "2016MNRAS.459.3614M", "2016MNRAS.461.1100R", "2016MNRAS.462.1164H", "2016MNRAS.462L...1A", "2016MNRAS.463.1462O", "2016MNRAS.463.3948D", "2017A&A...597A..13V", "2017ApJ...834...25K", "2017ApJ...841..101L", "2017MNRAS.464..469S", "2017MNRAS.465.1682H", "2017MNRAS.466...11R", "2017MNRAS.466..960P", "2017MNRAS.466.1903G", "2017MNRAS.466.3293P", "2017MNRAS.466.4239G", "2017MNRAS.466.4826K", "2017MNRAS.469..416L", "2017MNRAS.470..224T", "2017PASA...34...58E", "2018A&A...619A.136M", "2018ApJ...856....2M", "2018ApJ...859...68K", "2018ApJ...861....4S", "2018ApJ...861...92D", "2018ApJ...866..120I", "2018ApJ...868...92T", "2018ApJS..237...14O", "2018MNRAS.473.4077P", "2018MNRAS.473.4197C", "2018MNRAS.473.5698D", "2018MNRAS.475.4617K", "2018MNRAS.475.5688B", "2018MNRAS.477.1578H", "2018MNRAS.478.5607T", "2018MNRAS.479...75S", "2018MNRAS.479..994R", "2018MNRAS.479.2079C", "2018MNRAS.479.3206N", "2018MNRAS.480.1666S", "2018MNRAS.480.2628F", "2018MNRAS.481.3325F", "2018PhRvL.121i1101D", "2019A&A...622A.142D", "2019A&A...629A.134G", "2019ApJ...874..154D", "2019ApJ...878...12H", "2019ApJ...885...57W", "2019FrASS...6....7K", "2019MNRAS.482.4062H", "2019MNRAS.483.1029K", "2019MNRAS.483.3363H", "2019MNRAS.484.5094G", "2019MNRAS.485.3947M", "2019MNRAS.485L..24K", "2019MNRAS.486.4724O", "2019MNRAS.486.5482G", "2019MNRAS.488.1035K", "2019MNRAS.488.3143B", "2019MNRAS.489.2669M", "2019MNRAS.489.5181C", "2019MNRAS.490.3177W", "2019MNRAS.490.3196P", "2019PhRvD..99h3524U", "2020A&A...634A.134G", "2020A&A...635A.154M", "2020A&A...642A.139P", "2020ApJ...889L..22C", "2020ApJ...893...69L", "2020ApJ...896...23W", "2020ApJ...897L..14Y", "2020ApJ...902L..39B", "2020ApJ...904..144J", "2020MNRAS.491.1656A", "2020MNRAS.491.1736K", "2020MNRAS.492...79M", "2020MNRAS.492.1385K", "2020MNRAS.494.3328A", "2020MNRAS.495.4475M", "2020MNRAS.496.4087O", "2020MNRAS.496.4987G", "2020MNRAS.496.5528M", "2020MNRAS.498.2554C", "2020MNRAS.498.6083E", "2020MNRAS.499.5175Y", "2020MNRAS.499.5732K", "2020Natur.584..201R", "2021A&A...649A.152K", "2021A&A...651A.109D", "2021A&A...653A.154T", "2021ApJ...922...29S", "2021ApJ...922L...3L", "2021MNRAS.500..663M", "2021MNRAS.501.1352G", "2021MNRAS.501.5782C", "2021MNRAS.502.5726G", "2021MNRAS.503..406R", "2021MNRAS.503..426H", "2021MNRAS.503.3568K", "2021MNRAS.506..781D", "2021MNRAS.506.3882S", "2021MNRAS.507.1254K", "2022A&A...658L..11S", "2022A&A...659A..26B", "2022A&A...667A.110S", "2022ApJ...924...71A", "2022ApJ...932...76Z", "2022ApJS..259...20H", "2022LRCA....8....3G", "2022MNRAS.511.3895F", "2022MNRAS.511.4005K", "2022MNRAS.512..199K", "2022MNRAS.512..348K", "2022MNRAS.512.3243S", "2022MNRAS.512.4909G", "2022MNRAS.513.1513M", "2022MNRAS.513.2904T", "2022MNRAS.513.5000F", "2022MNRAS.514...55B", "2022MNRAS.514..280B", "2022MNRAS.514.5355K", "2022MNRAS.515.2386R", "2022MNRAS.515.4929G", "2022MNRAS.516.2112K", "2022MNRAS.516.3389L", "2022MNRAS.517.1098S", "2022MNRAS.517.1313M", "2023A&A...670A..92M", "2023A&A...670L..11J", "2023A&A...677L...4P", "2023A&A...678A..68S", "2023ApJ...942L..26L", "2023ApJ...942L..28T", "2023ApJ...943L...5M", "2023ApJ...943L..27F", "2023ApJ...946L..15K", "2023ApJ...947L..27D", "2023ApJ...948L..13J", "2023ApJ...949L..18P", "2023ApJ...949L..25F", "2023ApJ...951L..22A", "2023ApJ...952...74T", "2023ApJ...954L..46L", "2023ApJ...955L..35S", "2023ApJ...957...16S", "2023ApJ...959..125G", "2023ApJS..265....5H", "2023JOSS....8.5407G", "2023MNRAS.518..270K", "2023MNRAS.518.6011D", "2023MNRAS.518.6142A", "2023MNRAS.520.2757Y", "2023MNRAS.521.5160M", "2023MNRAS.522.3986F", "2023MNRAS.523.1009B", "2023MNRAS.523.1036B", "2023MNRAS.523.5468S", "2023MNRAS.523L..40A", "2023MNRAS.524.2312E", "2023MNRAS.524.5486A", "2023MNRAS.525.3254S", "2023MNRAS.525.3806M", "2023MNRAS.525.4093G", "2023MNRAS.526.1408S", "2023MNRAS.526.2665S", "2023MNRAS.526.3250S", "2023NatAs...7..611R", "2023NatAs...7..731B", "2023NatAs...7.1517H", "2023Natur.622..707A", "2023arXiv230504662L", "2023arXiv230602470L", "2023arXiv230605295E", "2023arXiv230609142S", "2023arXiv230706336L", "2023arXiv230801230M", "2024A&A...684A..84S", "2024A&A...684A..87D", "2024A&A...685A..48H", "2024A&A...686A.128C", "2024ApJ...960..104S", "2024ApJ...961...51V", "2024ApJ...962..124H", "2024ApJ...964..146F", "2024ApJ...964..150D", "2024ApJ...965..169A", "2024ApJ...967...73J", "2024ApJ...967..172S", "2024ApJ...970...19Z", "2024MNRAS.527.5004M", "2024MNRAS.527.6139S", "2024MNRAS.52711372A", "2024MNRAS.529..855W", "2024MNRAS.529.3495B", "2024Sci...384..890H" ]
29163036
2309.11545
Galaxy archaeology for wet mergers: Globular cluster age distributions in the Milky Way and nearby galaxies
Context. Identifying past wet merger activity in galaxies has been a longstanding issue in extragalactic formation history studies. Gaia's 6D kinematic measurements in our Milky Way (MW) have vastly extended the possibilities for Galactic archaeology, leading to the discovery of a multitude of early mergers in the MW's past. As recent work has established a link between younger globular clusters (GCs; less than about 10-11 Gyr old) and wet galaxy merger events, the MW provides an ideal laboratory for testing which GC properties can be used to trace extragalactic galaxy formation histories. <BR /> Aims: To test the hypothesis that GCs trace wet mergers, we relate the measured GC age distributions of the MW and three nearby galaxies, M 31, NGC 1407, and NGC 3115, to their merger histories and interpret the connection with wet mergers through an empirical model for GC formation. <BR /> Methods: The GC ages of observed galaxies are taken from a variety of studies to analyze their age distributions side-by-side with the model. For the MW, we additionally cross-match the GCs with their associated progenitor host galaxies to disentangle the connection to the GC age distribution. For the modeled GCs, we take galaxies with similar GC age distributions as observed to compare their accretion histories with those inferred through observations. <BR /> Results: We find that the MW GC age distribution is bimodal, mainly caused by younger GCs (10-11 Gyr old associated with Gaia-Sausage/Enceladus (GSE) and in part by unassociated high-energy GCs. The GSE GC age distribution also appears to be bimodal. We propose that the older GSE GCs (12-13 Gyr old) were accreted together with GSE, while the younger ones formed as a result of the merger. For the nearby galaxies, we find that clear peaks in the GC age distributions coincide with active early gas-rich merger phases. Even small signatures in the GC age distributions agree well with the expected wet formation histories of the galaxies inferred through other observed tracers. From the models, we predict that the involved cold gas mass can be estimated from the number of GCs found in the formation burst. <BR /> Conclusions: Multimodal GC age distributions can trace massive wet mergers as a result of GCs being formed through them. From the laboratory of our own MW and nearby galaxies we conclude that the ages of younger GC populations of galaxies can be used to infer the wet merger history of a galaxy.
[ 0.0053233802318573, 0.04240471124649048, 0.027401570230722427, 0.029485339298844337, -0.018858114257454872, 0.028782067820429802, 0.030370941385626793, -0.005691295489668846, -0.025682460516691208, 0.03167329728603363, 0.006642015650868416, -0.024132655933499336, -0.03276727721095085, -0.014078468084335327, 0.010327682830393314, 0.008002977818250656, -0.008243913762271404, 0.0062057264149188995, -0.035085469484329224, 0.0011582828592509031, 0.03013651818037033, 0.05563664808869362, -0.024341033771634102, 0.03430405631661415, -0.0514691099524498, -0.02074653096497059, 0.007664364762604237, 0.03847159445285797, 0.02487500011920929, -0.010542571544647217, 0.007436452433466911, 0.007963906973600388, -0.05053141340613365, -0.0047438316978514194, -0.07788088917732239, 0.11023140698671341, 0.0005750715499743819, 0.01599293202161789, -0.04691086336970329, 0.007019698619842529, 0.013492408208549023, 0.0069415573962032795, -0.044827092438936234, 0.01672225072979927, 0.009227192029356956, -0.006355497054755688, -0.029563480988144875, 0.001404916518367827, -0.005873625632375479, -0.002419126220047474, -0.04110235348343849, 0.016735274344682693, 0.01495104655623436, -0.026242472231388092, -0.024575456976890564, -0.021892603486776352, 0.0014513129135593772, -0.0007061211508698761, -0.03193376958370209, 0.0068764397874474525, -0.003041001269593835, -0.0034707786981016397, 0.015589200891554356, -0.0186757855117321, 0.005694551393389702, -0.02328612469136715, 0.044436387717723846, 0.026620157063007355, 0.012658900581300259, 0.014169633388519287, -0.007410405669361353, -0.006296891253441572, 0.015263612382113934, -0.02646387368440628, -0.0002043070999206975, 0.015237565152347088, 0.003662876086309552, -0.03026675246655941, -0.04391544312238693, -0.0022319124545902014, 0.01433893945068121, -0.01752971112728119, -0.015511060133576393, 0.012313775718212128, -0.029381150379776955, 0.013609619811177254, 0.017191099002957344, -0.0016784112667664886, -0.03565850853919983, 0.0667848140001297, 0.037898559123277664, 0.0068764397874474525, -0.029172774404287338, -0.002648666501045227, -0.009181609377264977, -0.06418010592460632, -0.020993977785110474, -0.060012564063072205, 0.027401570230722427, 0.034772906452417374, -0.0005429196753539145, 0.007983442395925522, 0.023715902119874954, -0.023312171921133995, 0.05912696197628975, -0.06016884744167328, -0.04607735574245453, -0.00583455478772521, -0.023221006616950035, 0.0002859078231267631, 0.024067537859082222, 0.044254057109355927, -0.03940929099917412, 0.06688900291919708, -0.013147283345460892, 0.03867997229099274, -0.05626177787780762, 0.023950327187776566, -0.032194238156080246, 0.005652225110679865, -0.030475130304694176, -0.030891884118318558, 0.01621433161199093, -0.008126701228320599, 0.02187957987189293, 0.02474476397037506, -0.006153631955385208, 0.009552781470119953, -0.041388873010873795, 0.013609619811177254, 0.02229633368551731, 0.000027853120627696626, 0.037039004266262054, 0.0031419338192790747, -0.039721857756376266, -0.032689135521650314, -0.01831112429499626, -0.035371989011764526, -0.02800065279006958, 0.04256099462509155, 0.0056685046292841434, 0.009930464439094067, 0.05506361275911331, 0.015979908406734467, 0.03597107157111168, 0.027792276814579964, -0.04670248553156853, 0.02872997336089611, -0.013121236115694046, 0.01604502648115158, -0.017933441326022148, -0.011076537892222404, -0.00540152145549655, -0.04667643830180168, -0.013264495879411697, -0.02831321954727173, -0.040294893085956573, -0.0007280983845703304, -0.02964162267744541, -0.08142329752445221, -0.08491361141204834, 0.017204122617840767, -0.04618154466152191, 0.040711648762226105, -0.011291426606476307, 0.03571059927344322, -0.059699997305870056, 0.018115771934390068, -0.0606376938521862, -0.014560339972376823, 0.007455987855792046, -0.016839463263750076, -0.03873206675052643, -0.01241796463727951, -0.02302565425634384, -0.0040731183253228664, -0.022674018517136574, -0.05626177787780762, -0.009096956811845303, -0.05003651604056358, 0.00365962041541934, 0.02615130878984928, -0.003913579508662224, -0.037039004266262054, -0.07418219745159149, 0.03576269373297691, -0.026607133448123932, 0.036544110625982285, -0.0027821578551083803, -0.010939789935946465, -0.007716459222137928, 0.03271518275141716, 0.03802879527211189, 0.03430405631661415, -0.00297913933172822, -0.04618154466152191, 0.025070352479815483, -0.013713808730244637, -0.003799623576924205, -0.0005941999261267483, 0.006371776573359966, -0.005609898362308741, -0.002295402344316244, -0.02958952821791172, -0.02383311465382576, -0.037533897906541824, 0.04943743348121643, -0.010295123793184757, -0.030292799696326256, 0.018858114257454872, 0.04982813820242882, -0.009683016687631607, -0.02165818028151989, 0.03050117753446102, -0.040529318153858185, -0.03883625566959381, -0.045973166823387146, 0.009057885967195034, 0.07037931680679321, 0.03156910836696625, 0.014885928481817245, 0.014924999326467514, -0.0025623852852731943, 0.03344450145959854, 0.007827159017324448, 0.009096956811845303, -0.0009140911279246211, -0.04256099462509155, 0.00376055296510458, 0.0053233802318573, 0.02202283963561058, 0.029485339298844337, -0.040893979370594025, -0.016552943736314774, 0.006824345327913761, -0.000940138241276145, 0.029381150379776955, 0.04081583768129349, 0.040346987545490265, 0.010972348973155022, -0.007267146371304989, 0.0545426681637764, -0.019131610170006752, -0.00004726127735921182, -0.007306217215955257, 0.019808834418654442, -0.004874067381024361, -0.037533897906541824, 0.0008257750887423754, 0.010347218252718449, 0.004691737238317728, -0.018011583015322685, -0.007690411992371082, 0.0014553827932104468, -0.008856020867824554, 0.0019698133692145348, -0.020056281238794327, 0.04430615156888962, -0.060377221554517746, 0.0053917537443339825, -0.001929114805534482, -0.037039004266262054, -0.021306544542312622, 0.035267800092697144, -0.02138468436896801, 0.03716924041509628, 0.020043259486556053, -0.027583898976445198, -0.03334031254053116, -0.015367800369858742, -0.01866276189684868, -0.05428219586610794, 0.04149306192994118, -0.03633573278784752, -0.04136282578110695, 0.042482852935791016, -0.020460013300180435, 0.030683506280183792, 0.002507035154849291, -0.02396335080265999, 0.0033275196328759193, -0.01055559515953064, 0.04852578416466713, -0.005795483943074942, -0.013362172059714794, 0.043837301433086395, -0.016253402456641197, 0.01657899096608162, 0.021098166704177856, -0.008139724843204021, 0.0468587689101696, -0.04446243494749069, 0.020017212256789207, 0.004919649567455053, -0.0009018814889714122, -0.03076164796948433, 0.007989954203367233, 0.02165818028151989, -0.015927813947200775, 0.02781832404434681, 0.04110235348343849, 0.005740134045481682, -0.004115445073693991, 0.0007342032040469348, -0.009188121184706688, 0.011903533712029457, 0.02306472510099411, -0.029511386528611183, -0.011877486482262611, 0.06642015278339386, 0.010907230898737907, -0.026932721957564354, 0.039435338228940964, 0.02111119031906128, -0.019405104219913483, -0.02423684485256672, -0.05277146399021149, 0.04386334866285324, 0.030188610777258873, -0.011590967886149883, -0.027714135125279427, -0.04170143976807594, -0.025708507746458054, 0.0023002861998975277, -0.004252192098647356, -0.03787251189351082, -0.010015117935836315, -0.06418010592460632, -0.01085513737052679, 0.009005791507661343, 0.014807787723839283, 0.010073723271489143, 0.01957441121339798, 0.0018721367232501507, 0.011317473836243153, -0.03393939509987831, 0.05092211812734604, 0.0386018306016922, -0.015602224506437778, 0.018558572977781296, -0.03094397857785225, -0.006541083101183176, 0.03050117753446102, -0.04844764247536659, 0.03044908307492733, 0.03138677775859833, 0.04386334866285324, 0.07298403233289719, 0.039982330054044724, -0.04756204038858414, 0.005639201495796442, 0.012658900581300259, 0.015328729525208473, -0.012437500059604645, 0.01076397206634283, -0.03344450145959854, 0.02301263064146042, -0.035554319620132446, 0.04149306192994118, 0.04073769599199295, -0.0024028467014431953, -0.010373265482485294, 0.013414266519248486, 0.007735994644463062, -0.003952650353312492, 0.03284541890025139, -0.04589502513408661, 0.020512105897068977, -0.027792276814579964, 0.0011786321410909295, -0.028287172317504883, 0.007019698619842529, -0.03711714595556259, 0.0246535986661911, -0.06256517767906189, -0.03693481534719467, 0.0004505337856244296, 0.01911858655512333, 0.017230169847607613, 0.0030361174140125513, 0.038627877831459045, 0.004493128042668104, -0.008895091712474823, -0.0294071976095438, 0.02520058862864971, -0.010842113755643368, -0.05071374028921127, -0.016018979251384735, -0.1176287904381752, 0.00933138094842434, -0.03847159445285797, 0.021553991362452507, 0.007768553216010332, 0.0012372381752356887, -0.04159725084900856, -0.03209005296230316, 0.05225052312016487, -0.003379613859578967, 0.03326217085123062, 0.02025163546204567, -0.04894253611564636, -0.015602224506437778, -0.0373515710234642, -0.04047722369432449, 0.024627551436424255, 0.02229633368551731, 0.019561387598514557, 0.05766832455992699, 0.010073723271489143, -0.026333637535572052, 0.05089607089757919, 0.028469501063227654, 0.03094397857785225, -0.02202283963561058, 0.009839299134910107, 0.00019077480828855187, -0.0637112557888031, 0.026476897299289703, -0.01130445022135973, 0.025408964604139328, 0.006475965026766062, -0.01630549691617489, -0.00018955384439323097, -0.014885928481817245, -0.027219239622354507, 0.0231168195605278, 0.000696760427672416, 0.0237419493496418, 0.015602224506437778, -0.08741413056850433, -0.09444685280323029, 0.051990050822496414, 0.026906674727797508, -0.0032558899838477373, 0.026932721957564354, 0.005736878141760826, 0.050323035567998886, -0.031100260093808174, 0.005476406775414944, -0.03300170227885246, 0.0002726807724684477, 0.0015205006347969174, 0.006681086029857397, 0.010099770501255989, 0.03021465800702572, 0.022361451759934425, 0.04920300841331482, 0.023364266380667686, -0.017555758357048035, -0.03891439735889435, 0.030423035845160484, 0.00994348805397749, 0.013147283345460892, -0.0010793275432661176, -0.04172748699784279, 0.012737041339278221, 0.0024468014016747475, -0.006345729343593121, 0.04342054948210716, -0.05107840150594711, -0.00804204773157835, 0.0073583112098276615, -0.026125261560082436, 0.014781740494072437, -0.03602316603064537, 0.012737041339278221, -0.011473756283521652, -0.0023833115119487047, 0.02958952821791172, 0.018141819164156914, 0.047145284712314606, -0.05464685708284378, 0.013271007686853409, -0.0024126144126057625, 0.011740739457309246, -0.02116328477859497, -0.04370706528425217, 0.0004834996652789414, 0.05751204118132591, 0.025474082678556442, 0.05193795636296272, 0.016005955636501312, 0.01525058876723051, 0.018949279561638832, 0.014195680618286133, 0.00007976930646691471, -0.05928324535489082, -0.014898952096700668, 0.018858114257454872, -0.014938022941350937, -0.032558899372816086, -0.009793717414140701, 0.00003830757850664668, -0.013804973103106022, 0.024341033771634102, -0.009839299134910107, 0.002404474653303623, -0.03310588747262955, -0.007182493340224028, 0.02958952821791172, 0.04956766963005066, 0.009722087532281876, 0.07548455148935318, 0.00924021564424038, 0.021684227511286736, 0.00802251324057579, -0.04980209097266197, -0.049411386251449585, -0.0068308571353554726, -0.006573641672730446, 0.008458802476525307, 0.035502225160598755, -0.00593548733741045, 0.002269355347380042, 0.014221726916730404, 0.021736321970820427, 0.009051374159753323, 0.021319568157196045, 0.018206937238574028, -0.025982001796364784, 0.0010956069454550743, -0.019730692729353905, -0.009324869140982628, -0.0018005071906372905, -0.0205251295119524, -0.029511386528611183, -0.014859882183372974, -0.07277565449476242, -0.03328821808099747, -0.007762041874229908, 0.01853252574801445, 0.0023507524747401476, 0.017112957313656807, -0.0021749346051365137, -0.04599921405315399, -0.028599737212061882, -0.004926161374896765, -0.01943115144968033, 0.014208703301846981, -0.011486779898405075, 0.03328821808099747, 0.015029188245534897, -0.007325752172619104, -0.003249378176406026, 0.007664364762604237, 0.04339450225234032, -0.022999607026576996, -0.005609898362308741, 0.0306314118206501, 0.05110444873571396, 0.03800274804234505, -0.030527224764227867, -0.003809391288086772, 0.02180144004523754, -0.02958952821791172, 0.005772693082690239, -0.00659317709505558, -0.0031337940599769354, 0.02505732886493206, -0.009005791507661343, -0.02831321954727173, 0.0007830415270291269, 0.005772693082690239, 0.027115050703287125, 0.017933441326022148, -0.0324547104537487, -0.014026373624801636, -0.001868880819529295, -0.02016047015786171, -0.0004843136412091553, -0.028209030628204346, -0.0073583112098276615, -0.0028391359373927116, -0.04602526128292084, 0.01648782752454281, -0.013336124829947948, -0.03253285214304924, 0.03209005296230316, 0.0022774951066821814, -0.0373515710234642, -0.03357473760843277, 0.01613618992269039, 0.003578223055228591, -0.027531806379556656, -0.0428735576570034, -0.014521269127726555, -0.00854345504194498, 0.021853532642126083, 0.05097421258687973, 0.0077750650234520435, -0.015706412494182587, -0.033366359770298004, 0.009090445004403591, 0.021723298355937004, 0.012509129010140896, -0.013297054916620255, 0.024210797622799873, 0.03388730436563492, -0.031204449012875557, -0.0016816671704873443, -0.0015538735315203667, 0.03138677775859833, -0.026424802839756012, -0.02315588854253292, -0.0007016442832536995, 0.01707388646900654, 0.0026047120336443186, -0.019405104219913483, -0.04331636056303978, -0.0014179401332512498, 0.003431708086282015, 0.013492408208549023, -0.029250916093587875, -0.01712598092854023, 0.003329147584736347, -0.004522431176155806, -0.021228402853012085, -0.017503663897514343, 0.006993651855736971, -0.012724017724394798, 0.026359684765338898, 0.02088979072868824, 0.030110470950603485, -0.011141655035316944, 0.05316217243671417, -0.008107165805995464, 0.017451569437980652, -0.007944371551275253, -0.0009311845060437918, -0.008061583153903484, 0.012346334755420685, -0.05225052312016487, 0.01848043128848076, 0.005147561896592379, -0.019834881648421288, -0.009683016687631607, 0.0039005561266094446, 0.00863462034612894, -0.027583898976445198, -0.03451243415474892, -0.0007789716473780572, 0.02279122918844223, -0.011219796724617481, -0.006244796793907881, 0.0222051702439785, 0.020499082282185555, -0.0027154122944921255, -0.0028244846034795046, -0.04586897790431976, -0.002492383820936084, -0.046415966004133224, -0.04370706528425217, 0.0028733229264616966, -0.02428893931210041, 0.03784646466374397, -0.050635602325201035, -0.0072931936010718346, 0.014078468084335327, -0.02935510315001011, 0.021280497312545776, -0.010744436644017696, -0.01663108542561531, -0.006033163983374834, -0.007162957917898893, -0.024393128231167793, 0.0008021699031814933, -0.003994977101683617, 0.007488546893000603, -0.023481478914618492, 0.0168524868786335, 0.0704314112663269, 0.007455987855792046, 0.03344450145959854, 0.039174869656562805, 0.00005479052197188139, -0.009051374159753323, -0.0009010675712488592, -0.019313938915729523, -0.0006332705961540341, 0.02527873031795025, 0.012170516885817051, -0.0009018814889714122, -0.007820647209882736, 0.026906674727797508, -0.014013350009918213, -0.013147283345460892, 0.01871485635638237, -0.023077748715877533, 0.010125817731022835, -0.009976047091186047, 0.016683179885149002, 0.016370614990592003, 0.027115050703287125, 0.027557851746678352, 0.01848043128848076, -0.019926046952605247, -0.00042896351078525186, 0.006218750029802322, -0.03099607303738594, -0.04550431668758392, 0.02039489522576332, 0.008523919619619846, -0.004834996536374092, 0.012606806121766567, -0.005746645852923393, -0.019196726381778717, -0.016344567760825157, 0.027896465733647346, 0.008953697048127651, -0.044748950749635696, 0.025721531361341476, 0.03802879527211189, -0.020473036915063858, 0.00456475792452693, 0.01821996085345745, -0.021046072244644165, -0.016839463263750076, 0.008549966849386692, -0.04896858334541321, 0.026125261560082436, 0.007175981532782316, -0.026515968143939972, -0.06668062508106232, 0.013531479053199291, 0.016657132655382156, -0.03156910836696625, 0.02990209311246872, 0.026802485808730125, -0.021410731598734856, -0.037273429334163666, 0.013987303711473942, 0.0012616573367267847, -0.012802159413695335, -0.014755693264305592, -0.007670876570045948, 0.04250890016555786, -0.016071073710918427, -0.0246535986661911, 0.005082444287836552, 0.02768808789551258, 0.012053304351866245, 0.01957441121339798, -0.01525058876723051, 0.005873625632375479, 0.009018815122544765, 0.006974116433411837, 0.010477453470230103, -0.023312171921133995, 0.011480268090963364, -0.013909162022173405, 0.02147584967315197, 0.011525850743055344, 0.008595549501478672, -0.012509129010140896, 0.03612735494971275, -0.029198821634054184, -0.005837810691446066, -0.016995744779706, 0.013492408208549023, 0.02302565425634384, 0.04602526128292084, 0.029876045882701874, 0.021124213933944702, 0.01479476410895586, 0.003998233005404472, 0.026698296889662743, -0.009429057128727436, -0.0071043516509234905, 0.02527873031795025, -0.06391963362693787, -0.01812879554927349, -0.01216400507837534, 0.04302984103560448, -0.022713087499141693, -0.009643945842981339, 0.020876767113804817, 0.04394149035215378, -0.009520222432911396, -0.0009840927086770535, 0.031881675124168396, 0.023859161883592606, -0.0062480526976287365, -0.02628154307603836, 0.001793995383195579, -0.01717807538807392, -0.0022530758287757635, -0.005264773964881897, -0.022465640679001808, -0.0018102747853845358, -0.011773298494517803, -0.022778205573558807, 0.010412336327135563, -0.016422709450125694, 0.03818507865071297, -0.017633900046348572, 0.027948560193181038, -0.02247866429388523, -0.09324868768453598, 0.0074038938619196415, 0.023351242765784264, 0.007364823017269373, -0.0269587691873312, 0.010184423997998238, -0.021449802443385124, -0.0016865510260686278, -0.020316753536462784, -0.023937303572893143, -0.014417081139981747, -0.04540012776851654, 0.016461780294775963, 0.0032672856468707323, 0.012457034550607204, -0.01030814740806818, -0.03964371606707573, 0.015445942059159279, 0.035319894552230835, 0.045556411147117615, -0.009324869140982628, 0.01889718510210514, 0.022778205573558807, -0.005023838020861149, 0.008712761104106903, -0.04112840071320534, -0.01289332378655672, -0.005775948986411095, 0.026255495846271515, 0.010210471227765083, 0.00583455478772521, 0.01071838941425085, 0.015706412494182587, 0.04141492024064064, -0.03870601952075958, -0.0013943348312750459, 0.004691737238317728, 0.04217028617858887, -0.01952231675386429, -0.02120235562324524, -0.0014496849616989493, -0.02423684485256672, 0.042743321508169174, 0.035814788192510605, 0.0205251295119524, -0.002896114019677043, 0.03578874096274376, 0.021671203896403313, -0.005310356616973877, 0.0133231021463871, -0.003942882642149925, 0.007657852955162525, 0.018792996183037758, 0.007898788899183273, -0.007560176309198141, 0.021814461797475815, -0.005508965812623501, -0.010640248656272888, -0.010275588370859623, -0.000756587425712496, -0.013362172059714794, -0.004812205210328102, 0.008328566327691078, -0.00998907070606947, -0.07798507809638977, -0.023676831275224686, 0.010470941662788391, 0.011538874357938766, -0.015354776754975319, -0.04086793214082718, -0.029250916093587875, 0.007416917476803064, 0.015367800369858742, 0.0057857162319123745, 0.027193192392587662, 0.025265706703066826, -0.04498337581753731, 0.03914882242679596, -0.04219633340835571, 0.04407172650098801, -0.06391963362693787, 0.004024279769510031, 0.0074690114706754684, -0.019379056990146637, 0.007749018259346485, -0.0004773948749061674, 0.013166818767786026, -0.03959162160754204, -0.004558246117085218, 0.003148445626720786, 0.0045126634649932384, -0.012886812910437584, 0.017451569437980652, 0.00041329453233629465, -0.0055122217163443565, 0.008510896004736423, 0.005124770570546389, -0.058918584138154984, 0.03138677775859833, 0.015211517922580242, -0.010314659215509892, -0.012873789295554161, -0.012880301102995872, -0.03271518275141716, 0.020017212256789207, -0.040034424513578415, 0.01604502648115158, 0.022257262840867043, -0.0019812090322375298, 0.0078141363337636, 0.016748297959566116, 0.06423220038414001, -0.05730366334319115, 0.006055955309420824, 0.04428010433912277, -0.029823951423168182, -0.017738088965415955, 0.013609619811177254, -0.009500687010586262, -0.03401753678917885, -0.013349148444831371, 0.02854764275252819, -0.04844764247536659, 0.009669993072748184, 0.02523965947329998, -0.025526177138090134, -0.0019730692729353905, 0.018285077065229416, -0.006088514346629381, 0.03742971271276474, -0.010842113755643368, -0.00029994884971529245, 0.012105398811399937, 0.025070352479815483, -0.018376242369413376, -0.027974607422947884, -0.02211400493979454, 0.02383311465382576, 0.0022986582480371, 0.03130863606929779, -0.00759924715384841, -0.015823625028133392, -0.0009531617979519069, 0.003467522794380784, -0.00933138094842434, -0.010015117935836315, -0.0004953022580593824, 0.012313775718212128, 0.038810208439826965, -0.009858834557235241, -0.0016686435556039214, -0.022908441722393036, -0.009298821911215782, -0.014586387202143669, -0.019899999722838402, 0.01957441121339798, 0.008452290669083595, 0.010002094320952892, -0.006091770250350237, 0.013101701624691486, 0.05475104600191116, 0.02800065279006958, 0.00540152145549655, -0.027740182355046272, 0.008986256085336208, 0.033704973757267, -0.024354057386517525, 0.01314077153801918, -0.02529175393283367, -0.016188284382224083, -0.04300379380583763, -0.046415966004133224, 0.052719369530677795, 0.005616410169750452, -0.018063677474856377, 0.04399358481168747, -0.017998559400439262, -0.04852578416466713, 0.003920091316103935, 0.04172748699784279, -0.015966884791851044, -0.0005905370344407856, -0.00571083091199398, -0.02034280076622963, 0.028782067820429802, -0.0023149377666413784, -0.03138677775859833, -0.01717807538807392, 0.02586478926241398, 0.02714109793305397, -0.005587107036262751, 0.04670248553156853, -0.013518455438315868, 0.028651831671595573, 0.014364986680448055, -0.01286727748811245, -0.0290946327149868, 0.021957721561193466, -0.020460013300180435, -0.0032282148022204638, -0.01424777414649725, -0.06053350493311882, -0.005642457399517298, -0.0413367785513401, 0.010412336327135563, -0.004359636455774307, -0.00752110593020916, -0.0056001306511461735, -0.05772041529417038, -0.020720483735203743, 0.01884509064257145, 0.004014512524008751, 0.009819763712584972, 0.015172447077929974, 0.01736040599644184, -0.007429941091686487, 0.011727715842425823, -0.008282983675599098, -0.002199353650212288, -0.05159934237599373, -0.0012722390238195658, -0.05029698833823204, -0.044827092438936234, 0.032011911273002625, 0.0031663530971854925, 0.030162565410137177, -0.01911858655512333, -0.007254122756421566, -0.014938022941350937, 0.012795647606253624, 0.0068764397874474525, 0.0018509734654799104, -0.03076164796948433, -0.04537408426403999, -0.03198586404323578, 0.0005889090825803578, 0.010093258693814278, 0.012658900581300259, -0.00867369119077921, 0.02509639970958233, 0.020147446542978287, -0.007332263980060816, -0.0021179565228521824, 0.004737319890409708, -0.02370287850499153, -0.00646945321932435, 0.0021570271346718073, -0.011310962028801441, -0.003200539853423834, 0.002026791451498866, 0.0018851603381335735, 0.004939184989780188, 0.01984790526330471, -0.0186757855117321, -0.0031826323829591274, 0.015302683226764202, -0.016956675797700882, 0.026398755609989166, 0.013166818767786026, -0.000347973225871101, 0.01051001250743866, 0.004753599409013987, -0.023898232728242874, -0.03469476476311684, -0.0033633343409746885, 0.0001924027455970645, -0.04654620215296745, -0.003998233005404472, 0.012307263910770416, -0.043290313333272934, 0.022856347262859344, 0.011128631420433521, 0.013336124829947948, 0.0024126144126057625, -0.022400522604584694, -0.051547251641750336, -0.014208703301846981, 0.009904417209327221, -0.011232820339500904, -0.0003276239149272442, -0.04183167591691017, -0.013492408208549023, -0.017594829201698303, 0.005619666073471308, 0.01988697610795498, 0.015927813947200775, -0.0327933244407177, -0.02460150420665741, 0.0306314118206501, -0.02156701497733593, -0.015966884791851044, 0.039852093905210495, -0.0013389847008511424, 0.007762041874229908, -0.011682133190333843, -0.035502225160598755, 0.02043396607041359, -0.0020853974856436253, 0.0012657272163778543, -0.016253402456641197, -0.017568781971931458, 0.014312892220914364, -0.000439545139670372, -0.03589292988181114, -0.01228121668100357, -0.02169725112617016, -0.016331544145941734, -0.015328729525208473, -0.008706249296665192, 0.0225177351385355, 0.0010768856154754758, -0.00006537216540891677, 0.016149213537573814, 0.0027316915802657604, -0.005873625632375479, -0.001280378783121705, -0.0020805136300623417, 0.002598200226202607, -0.01314077153801918, -0.025083376094698906, -0.02206191048026085, -0.008914627134799957, 0.026880627498030663, 0.0186757855117321, -0.004675458185374737, -0.03755994513630867, -0.01433893945068121, -0.01650085113942623, 0.011910045519471169, 0.0013397986767813563, 0.0156282726675272, 0.006993651855736971, 0.008706249296665192, -0.03946138545870781, -0.0011411894811317325, 0.0373515710234642, -0.026307590305805206, 0.022100981324911118, 0.019470222294330597, 0.007560176309198141, 0.02823507785797119, 0.009409521706402302, -0.04289960488677025, 0.009780693799257278, 0.0031549574341624975, -0.02501825802028179, -0.01176027487963438, -0.020199541002511978, -0.00002187551035603974, 0.01640968583524227, 0.07261937111616135, 0.004183818586170673, -0.012137957848608494, -0.034095678478479385, -0.0012885184260085225, -0.012587270699441433, -0.018285077065229416, 0.018519502133131027, -0.002051210729405284, -0.025070352479815483, 0.021007001399993896, 0.00828949548304081, 0.014729646034538746, 0.033731020987033844, 0.035267800092697144, -0.014664527960121632, -0.02474476397037506, -0.0016409684903919697, 0.010939789935946465, -0.0015709669096395373, -0.0032168193720281124, -0.02520058862864971, -0.013290543109178543, 0.027896465733647346, -0.042300522327423096, 0.0004940812941640615, 0.04730156809091568, -0.014977093786001205, 0.0057433899492025375, -0.012548199854791164, -0.008641132153570652, 0.01504221186041832, -0.016930628567934036, -0.002746343147009611, 0.002308425959199667, -0.017907394096255302, -0.017829254269599915, 0.003809391288086772, 0.05105235427618027, 0.0033991490490734577, 0.036179449409246445, 0.005007558967918158, 0.012899835593998432, -0.0193009153008461, -0.004265215713530779, 0.01277611218392849, 0.03558036684989929, 0.013700785115361214, -0.026385731995105743, -0.02324705384671688, -0.036049213260412216, -0.01384404394775629, 0.00752110593020916, 0.012020745314657688, -0.00894718524068594, 0.023533573374152184, 0.008576014079153538, 0.0471973791718483, 0.03630968555808067, -0.008686714805662632, 0.01257424708455801, -0.0034382198937237263, -0.008517407812178135, 0.013557525351643562, 0.015276635996997356, 0.007267146371304989, -0.002186330035328865, 0.01812879554927349, 0.004118700977414846, -0.01803763024508953, -0.0072931936010718346, -0.005408033262938261, 0.013153795152902603, 0.029016491025686264, -0.0024647086393088102, -0.0040503269992768764, -0.029459292069077492, 0.023624736815690994, -0.011245843954384327, -0.015602224506437778, -0.005482918582856655, -0.0281829833984375, 0.002272611251100898, 0.06454475969076157, -0.02564338967204094, -0.006954581011086702, 0.006785274483263493, 0.012912859208881855, -0.02085071988403797, 0.04373311251401901, -0.019405104219913483, -0.013570548966526985, -0.01975673995912075, -0.008374148979783058, -0.003408916760236025, 0.016279449686408043, -0.021580038592219353, 0.014508245512843132, 0.009643945842981339, -0.013264495879411697, -0.002419126220047474, 0.016344567760825157, 0.007462499663233757, -0.012724017724394798, 0.010503500699996948, -0.013375195674598217, -0.02102002501487732, -0.009910929016768932, -0.019509293138980865, 0.039253007620573044, 0.018337171524763107, 0.04388939589262009, -0.023572642356157303, 0.009064397774636745, -0.01372683234512806, 0.052667275071144104, 0.06147120147943497, -0.014208703301846981, -0.011154678650200367, -0.03386125713586807, 0.013205889612436295, 0.04662434384226799, -0.0327933244407177, -0.0010435127187520266, -0.007371334824711084, -0.02964162267744541, -0.034278009086847305, -0.03620549663901329, -0.016618061810731888, -0.02193167433142662, -0.06407591700553894, 0.006238284986466169, -0.00048146472545340657, 0.011838415637612343, 0.013049607165157795, 0.003444731468334794, 0.012991000898182392, -0.02401544339954853, 0.028573689982295036, 0.004268471617251635, 0.003249378176406026, 0.003185888286679983, -0.01889718510210514, -0.024223821237683296, 0.022322380915284157, -0.001758180558681488, -0.017047839239239693, -0.0037800881545990705, -0.0010614200728014112, 0.010125817731022835, -0.027427617460489273, 0.004558246117085218, 0.017685994505882263, 0.014573363587260246, -0.03021465800702572, 0.00755366450175643, -0.02600804902613163, -0.007866229861974716, -0.01667015627026558, -0.013817996717989445, -0.016240378841757774, 0.004063350614160299, -0.015589200891554356, 0.028339266777038574, 0.06048141047358513, -0.005583851132541895, -0.004291262943297625, 0.01590176671743393, 0.007097840309143066, -0.01821996085345745, 0.02836531400680542, -0.0278704185038805, 0.017881346866488457, -0.00588013743981719, -0.06334659457206726, -0.01282169483602047, 0.006179679185152054, 0.009624410420656204, -0.027193192392587662, 0.014977093786001205, 0.002282378962263465, -0.032506804913282394, 0.04865602031350136, 0.013101701624691486, -0.03094397857785225, -0.032689135521650314, -0.008211354725062847, 0.00295634800568223, 0.02039489522576332, -0.02831321954727173, 0.004548478405922651, -0.017998559400439262, 0.024809882044792175, 0.005551292560994625, 0.034330103546381, 0.03946138545870781, 0.000019522622096701525, -0.020186517387628555, -0.007280169986188412, 0.021449802443385124, -0.020629318431019783, -0.022413546219468117, -0.011857951059937477, -0.012743553146719933, 0.0011070026084780693, 0.025474082678556442, 0.007573199924081564, 0.016058050096035004, 0.009891393594443798, 0.020603271201252937, -0.007768553216010332, -0.0029937908984720707, 0.0049977912567555904, 0.017685994505882263, 0.0054666390642523766, 0.023898232728242874, -0.00994348805397749, 0.0016613178886473179, -0.011942604556679726, 0.004086141940206289, 0.018089724704623222, -0.023038677871227264, 0.005310356616973877, -0.0011004908010363579, -0.024184750393033028, 0.003858229611068964, 0.011753763072192669, -0.004261959809809923, 0.01789437048137188, 0.03810693696141243, 0.004092653747648001, -0.056886907666921616, 0.007130398880690336, -0.008198331110179424, -0.005815019365400076, 0.010776995681226254, -0.025982001796364784, 0.02646387368440628, -0.029485339298844337, 0.01871485635638237, 0.03365287929773331, 0.008048559539020061, 0.03763808682560921, 0.017842277884483337, 0.008094142191112041, 0.007338775787502527, 0.03044908307492733, -0.02233540453016758, -0.03294960781931877, -0.014508245512843132, -0.015003141015768051, 0.02995418757200241, 0.0115584097802639, -0.0035326406359672546, -0.015055235475301743, -0.012313775718212128, 0.009767670184373856, -0.029016491025686264, -0.002480988157913089, -0.011350031942129135, -0.026568062603473663, 0.0023263334296643734, 0.009305333718657494, 0.026216425001621246, 0.029303008690476418, 0.02092885971069336, -0.034590575844049454, -0.02392427995800972, 0.0032819369807839394, -0.023585665971040726, 0.006251308601349592, -0.02111119031906128, -0.012945418246090412, 0.016696203500032425, 0.015224541537463665, 0.0032330986578017473, -0.016058050096035004, -0.009956511668860912, 0.010021629743278027, 0.010868160985410213, 0.015146399848163128, 0.0035033375024795532, 0.05102630704641342, -0.0022644714917987585, -0.005613154266029596, 0.005798739846795797, 0.0017614364624023438, -0.03995628282427788, 0.0076122707687318325, 0.025838742032647133, 0.04092002660036087, 0.011890510097146034, -0.001024791388772428, -0.021892603486776352, 0.003441475797444582, 0.006283867638558149, -0.02428893931210041, -0.0028244846034795046, 0.014846858568489552, -0.011571432463824749, 0.018115771934390068, 0.012216099537909031, -0.033236123621463776, -0.023416360840201378, 0.0024874999653548002, 0.0018981838366016746, -0.011356543749570847, 0.02650294452905655, 0.023403337225317955, 0.007162957917898893, -0.006049443501979113, 0.022192146629095078, 0.0005970488418824971, -0.0031647251453250647, 0.011779810301959515, 0.032923560589551926, -0.009630922228097916, 0.04136282578110695, -0.0017484129639342427, 0.02423684485256672, 0.007709947414696217, 0.01220958773046732, 0.03076164796948433, 0.00024297078198287636, 0.006856904365122318, 0.017321335151791573, 0.01252866443246603, 0.03195981681346893, -0.00933789275586605, -0.0024451734498143196, 0.007879253476858139, -0.04190981388092041, 0.00053681485587731, -0.010985372588038445, -0.02854764275252819, -0.004662434570491314, -0.0038419500924646854, -0.003548920154571533, -0.02800065279006958, -0.020264659076929092, -0.017112957313656807, -0.013817996717989445, -0.0059517668560147285, -0.002127724001184106, -0.045738741755485535, 0.01075746025890112, 0.011154678650200367, 0.008771367371082306, 0.00431731017306447, -0.02266099490225315, 0.009116492234170437, -0.044696856290102005, -0.005606642458587885, -0.019105562940239906, 0.01975673995912075, 0.028599737212061882, -0.007898788899183273, -0.011753763072192669, 0.02595595456659794, -0.0019356266129761934, -0.021059095859527588, 0.008328566327691078, 0.001979581080377102, 0.014117538928985596, 0.018727878108620644, -0.013518455438315868, 0.04516570642590523, -0.01071187760680914, -0.003379613859578967, 0.009220680221915245, 0.02174934558570385, 0.020772578194737434, -0.005740134045481682, 0.021332591772079468, 0.004004744812846184, -0.031230496242642403, 0.020694436505436897, 0.005040117539465427, -0.0028261125553399324, -0.004043815191835165, -0.005515477620065212, 0.016565967351198196, -0.008869044482707977, -0.011297938413918018, -0.0030930954962968826, 0.0070848166942596436, -0.02206191048026085, 0.02763599343597889, -0.003125654300674796 ]
9.823385
8.1122
2024-07-01
4
2024A&A...687A.104V
[ "similar GC age distributions", "Multimodal GC age distributions", "wet mergers", "MW GC", "extragalactic galaxy formation histories", "wet merger activity", "massive wet mergers", "GC formation", "GSE GC", "younger GC populations" ]
[ "Galaxy: formation", "globular clusters: general", "galaxies: formation", "galaxies: individual: M 31", "galaxies: individual: NGC 1407", "galaxies: individual: NGC 3115", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
31
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202348010", "10.48550/arXiv.2309.11545" ]
[ "Valenzuela, Lucas M.", "Remus, Rhea-Silvia", "McKenzie, Madeleine", "Forbes, Duncan A." ]
[ "Universitäts-Sternwarte, Fakultät für Physik, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Scheinerstr. 1, 81679, München, Germany", "Universitäts-Sternwarte, Fakultät für Physik, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Scheinerstr. 1, 81679, München, Germany", "Research School of Astronomy &amp; Astrophysics, Australian National University, Canberra, ACT, 2611, Australia", "Centre for Astrophysics &amp; Supercomputing, Swinburne University, Hawthorn, VIC, 3122, Australia" ]
[ "2024MNRAS.527.3692C", "2024MNRAS.528.3198B", "2024OJAp....7E..23C", "2024arXiv240212443D" ]
[ "1992ApJ...384...50A", "1994ApJS...95..107W", "1994Natur.370..194I", "1995A&A...302..718D", "1997AJ....114..482B", "1998A&A...335..943S", "1998ApJ...501..554C", "1999Natur.402...53H", "2002AJ....124..364C", "2002AJ....124..915B", "2002ARA&A..40..487F", "2002MNRAS.333..383B", "2002MNRAS.336..168B", "2004ApJ...602..705P", "2005AJ....129.1412B", "2005AJ....130..116D", "2005ApJ...623..650K", "2005ApJ...635..931B", "2005MNRAS.363.1211B", "2005MNRAS.364.1105S", "2006ARA&A..44..193B", "2006ApJ...642L.137B", "2007A&A...466..181C", "2007AJ....133.1658S", "2007AJ....134..376D", "2007ApJ...658..337B", "2008AJ....135.2055A", "2008AJ....136.1407D", "2008ApJ...680..295B", "2008ApJ...689..936J", "2008MNRAS.385..675S", "2009AJ....137.3809C", "2009ApJ...694.1498M", "2009MNRAS.392L...1S", "2010ApJ...708..698D", "2010ApJ...723..818H", "2010MNRAS.402..803P", "2010MNRAS.404.1203F", "2011A&A...525A..20C", "2011A&A...531A.155P", "2011AJ....141...61C", "2011ApJ...730....4B", "2011ApJ...736L..26A", "2011ApJ...738...74D", "2011MNRAS.414.1339K", "2011MNRAS.415.3393F", "2012ApJ...755...15V", "2012MNRAS.420.1317G", "2012MNRAS.420.2625B", "2012RAA....12.1197C", "2013A&A...558A..33A", "2013ApJ...772...82H", "2013ApJ...775..134V", "2013ApJ...776L...7S", "2013MNRAS.428..389P", "2013MNRAS.436..122L", "2013MNRAS.436.1322C", "2013NewAR..57...29B", "2014ApJ...780..128I", "2014ApJ...792...59Z", "2014ApJ...796...10L", "2014ApJ...796...52B", "2014MNRAS.442.2165H", "2015AJ....149...56M", "2015ApJ...806...36H", "2015ApJ...812...29T", "2015MNRAS.446.2789B", "2015MNRAS.450..575A", "2015MNRAS.454.2472H", "2015RAA....15.1095L", "2016A&A...591A.143G", "2016A&A...595A...2G", "2016MNRAS.458L..44F", "2017ApJ...836...67H", "2017ApJ...845..101B", "2017ApJ...846..145W", "2017Galax...5...41S", "2017MNRAS.472.3120B", "2018A&A...616A...1G", "2018A&A...616A..12G", "2018AJ....156..123A", "2018ApJ...862..114S", "2018ApJ...863..113H", "2018ApJ...863L..28M", "2018MNRAS.474.5300D", "2018MNRAS.475.2754H", "2018MNRAS.475.4309P", "2018MNRAS.477.1822M", "2018MNRAS.478..611B", "2018MNRAS.479.4760F", "2018MNRAS.479.5124Z", "2018MNRAS.480.1715P", "2018MNRAS.480.2343C", "2018MNRAS.481.5592F", "2018Natur.563...85H", "2019A&A...630L...4M", "2019ApJ...878..129F", "2019ApJ...879L..18L", "2019MNRAS.482.3426M", "2019MNRAS.482.4528E", "2019MNRAS.484.1756M", "2019MNRAS.484.2832V", "2019MNRAS.486.3180K", "2019MNRAS.487..318K", "2019MNRAS.487.3776P", "2019MNRAS.487L..47V", "2019MNRAS.488.1235M", "2019MNRAS.490..491U", "2020AJ....159...56B", "2020ARA&A..58..205H", "2020ApJ...902..119D", "2020MNRAS.493..847F", "2020MNRAS.493.3363H", "2020MNRAS.494..983R", "2020MNRAS.494.3880B", "2020MNRAS.495.1321D", "2020MNRAS.498.2138B", "2020MNRAS.499.2327G", "2020Natur.585..357H", "2021A&A...645A.115W", "2021MNRAS.500.1385H", "2021MNRAS.500.4578M", "2021MNRAS.504.2146B", "2021MNRAS.504.4923D", "2021MNRAS.505.5815V", "2021sf2a.conf..447L", "2022A&A...664A.129D", "2022A&A...664A.148P", "2022A&A...668L..10R", "2022ApJ...926..107M", "2022ApJ...932L..16D", "2022MNRAS.511..341C", "2022MNRAS.512.4086W", "2022MNRAS.513.4107C", "2022MNRAS.514.4736C", "2022MNRAS.516.3515M", "2023A&A...670L...2D", "2023A&A...672A..27B", "2023A&A...673A..86P", "2023A&A...674A...1G", "2023AJ....166...18Y", "2023ApJ...944..169D", "2023ApJ...956..110C", "2023MNRAS.518.2453D", "2023MNRAS.520.5225M", "2023MNRAS.520.5671H", "2023MNRAS.521.6368R", "2023MNRAS.522.5638C", "2023MNRAS.522.6010B", "2023PASP..135g4201U", "2023arXiv230612620D", "2024A&A...686A.182V", "2024A&A...687A..80V", "2024MNRAS.527.3692C", "2024MNRAS.528.3198B", "2024MNRAS.528.6010U", "2024MNRAS.528L.122C", "2024MNRAS.530.2760D", "2024OJAp....7E..23C" ]
29097321
2405.00376
EPOCHS Paper V. The dependence of galaxy formation on galaxy structure at z &lt; 7 from JWST observations
We measure the broad impact of galaxy structure on galaxy formation by examining the ongoing star formation and integrated star formation history as revealed through the stellar masses of galaxies at z &lt; 7 based on JWST CEERS data from the Extended Groth Strip (EGS). Using the morphological catalog of 3965 visually classified JWST galaxies from Ferreira et al. (2023), we investigate the evolution of stars, and when they form, as a function of morphological type as well as galaxies classified as passive and starburst through spectral energy distributions. Although disc galaxies dominate the structures of galaxies at z &lt; 7, we find that these discs are in general either 'passive', or on the main sequence of star formation, and do not contain a large population of starburst galaxies. We also find no significant correlation between morphological type and the star formation rate or colours of galaxies at z &lt; 7. In fact, we find that the morphologically classified 'spheroids' tend to be blue and are not found to be predominately passive systems at z &gt; 1.5. We also find that the stellar mass function for disc galaxies does not evolve significantly during this time, whereas other galaxy types, such as the peculiar population, evolve dramatically, declining at lower redshifts. This indicates that massive peculiars are more common at higher redshifts. We further find that up to z ~ 7, the specific star formation rate (sSFR) does not vary with visual morphology, but strongly depends on stellar mass and internal galaxy mass density. This demonstrates that at early epochs galaxy assembly is a mass-driven, rather than a morphologically driven process. Quenching of star formation is therefore a mass-dominated process throughout the universe's history, likely due to the presence of supermassive black holes.
[ 0.02328004688024521, 0.057506974786520004, 0.03257772698998451, -0.011705752462148666, 0.00652510579675436, 0.05057554319500923, 0.03382060304284096, 0.016181306913495064, -0.039174534380435944, -0.009530717507004738, -0.020232608541846275, 0.015476212836802006, -0.03709510713815689, -0.00031109279370866716, 0.029924660921096802, 0.03764484077692032, -0.0037704594433307648, 0.01479502022266388, -0.015332803130149841, 0.0025738913100212812, 0.048711229115724564, 0.007050938438624144, -0.03764484077692032, 0.03573272377252579, -0.06735438853502274, -0.006883628200739622, -0.02284982055425644, 0.054734405130147934, 0.015571818687021732, 0.016695188358426094, 0.031430453062057495, -0.007642500102519989, -0.018583405762910843, 0.002572397468611598, -0.06405598670244217, 0.07184787094593048, 0.032482121139764786, -0.008228086866438389, 0.006280115339905024, 0.03207579627633095, 0.010725791566073895, 0.009399259462952614, -0.029996365308761597, -0.0191928930580616, -0.002560446737334132, -0.006871677469462156, -0.010689939372241497, 0.002957809017971158, -0.02178620547056198, 0.02090184949338436, -0.04295096918940544, -0.020686736330389977, 0.03778824955224991, -0.01128150150179863, 0.0022796043194830418, 0.0019419958116486669, -0.021033307537436485, -0.010504703037440777, -0.027438906952738762, 0.02061503194272518, 0.004639876075088978, 0.030737310647964478, 0.03544590249657631, -0.008879401721060276, 0.003746557980775833, 0.011526491492986679, -0.009530717507004738, -0.0076783522963523865, 0.007714204490184784, 0.0547822080552578, -0.03021147847175598, -0.056933339685201645, -0.004735481925308704, 0.023088835179805756, 0.034513745456933975, 0.006238287780433893, -0.004929681774228811, -0.02030431292951107, -0.03315136209130287, 0.016742991283535957, 0.017471985891461372, 0.03264943137764931, -0.031191440299153328, 0.023327849805355072, 0.003913868218660355, 0.00023472006432712078, 0.03762093931436539, -0.009130368009209633, -0.05717235431075096, 0.05769818648695946, 0.02552678808569908, 0.016611533239483833, -0.0002466707956045866, -0.008753919042646885, 0.0022840858437120914, -0.01565547287464142, 0.04108665511012077, -0.05396955460309982, 0.0556904636323452, 0.0006483278120867908, -0.005210523959249258, 0.05177062004804611, -0.02133207581937313, -0.046990323811769485, 0.02170255035161972, -0.031287044286727905, 0.010170082561671734, 0.006065002176910639, -0.012118053622543812, -0.032027993351221085, 0.007331781089305878, -0.01046885084360838, -0.014508201740682125, 0.025144362822175026, -0.032912347465753555, 0.010570432059466839, -0.0468469113111496, 0.026578452438116074, -0.018941927701234818, 0.025431182235479355, 0.04794638231396675, -0.003122131573036313, -0.0017164255259558558, 0.034800563007593155, 0.023925388231873512, -0.037405826151371, -0.016635434702038765, 0.011687826365232468, -0.04075203463435173, 0.0008963057189248502, 0.028323261067271233, -0.045197710394859314, 0.03938964754343033, -0.027940837666392326, -0.050336528569459915, -0.04283146187663078, 0.007200322579592466, -0.044910892844200134, -0.0271281860768795, 0.028036443516612053, -0.00982351042330265, 0.002651571063324809, 0.004974497016519308, 0.01479502022266388, 0.01888217404484749, 0.008837574161589146, -0.057076748460531235, 0.043452903628349304, -0.028394965454936028, 0.02328004688024521, 0.02307688444852829, -0.0005045454599894583, -0.0037764348089694977, -0.05922788381576538, -0.012596082873642445, -0.032051894813776016, -0.0034836416598409414, -0.00048773971502669156, -0.0027755601331591606, 0.016611533239483833, -0.04046521708369255, -0.0028801290318369865, -0.027893034741282463, 0.019778480753302574, -0.023889536038041115, -0.005915618035942316, -0.017866361886262894, -0.0014146692119538784, -0.05669432505965233, -0.017603443935513496, 0.02369832433760166, 0.008263939060270786, -0.014639660716056824, -0.03403571620583534, -0.019097287207841873, 0.01816513016819954, -0.039509158581495285, -0.02016090415418148, -0.02276616543531418, 0.0007125630509108305, 0.02153523825109005, 0.036593176424503326, -0.05353932827711105, -0.03267333284020424, -0.03652147203683853, 0.03530249372124672, -0.02476193942129612, 0.028944699093699455, 0.014030172489583492, -0.03092852234840393, -0.03738192468881607, 0.012560230679810047, 0.03623465448617935, 0.018153179436922073, 0.01156831905245781, -0.018344391137361526, 0.0002761741925496608, 0.03307965770363808, -0.011777457781136036, 0.0191928930580616, 0.017268823459744453, 0.005159733351320028, 0.03310355916619301, -0.055929478257894516, -0.04483918845653534, -0.002579866675660014, 0.011771482415497303, -0.01363579835742712, -0.006411573849618435, 0.005389784928411245, 0.025455083698034286, -0.007552869617938995, 0.005808060988783836, 0.05148380249738693, -0.008204185403883457, 0.006531081162393093, -0.05382614582777023, 0.018607307225465775, 0.057650383561849594, 0.009345481172204018, -0.004478541202843189, 0.0055989231914281845, 0.04701422527432442, 0.029685646295547485, 0.04275975748896599, -0.020065298303961754, 0.01584668457508087, -0.03076121211051941, 0.005524231120944023, 0.023041032254695892, 0.023770028725266457, 0.036425866186618805, -0.000609487877227366, 0.00710471672937274, -0.02801254205405712, -0.009255850687623024, -0.06534666568040848, 0.03515908494591713, 0.016037898138165474, -0.01750783808529377, -0.03879211097955704, -0.00139226159080863, -0.028753487393260002, 0.017555641010403633, -0.01576302945613861, 0.04782687500119209, -0.017436133697628975, 0.003256577532738447, 0.015285000205039978, -0.01260803360491991, 0.05511682853102684, -0.057506974786520004, -0.026124324649572372, 0.01103651151061058, -0.03035488724708557, -0.02844276838004589, 0.0068537513725459576, 0.03852919489145279, -0.0028920797631144524, -0.012643885798752308, -0.007307879626750946, -0.042114417999982834, -0.027654020115733147, 0.04290316626429558, -0.02301713079214096, 0.0650598481297493, 0.03401181474328041, -0.05932348966598511, -0.016121553257107735, 0.05922788381576538, 0.009566569700837135, 0.005960433278232813, 0.04244903847575188, -0.021523287519812584, -0.021917663514614105, 0.04510210454463959, 0.0038421638309955597, 0.013886763714253902, -0.011317353695631027, -0.011944768019020557, 0.04070423170924187, 0.0015386581653729081, 0.04603426158428192, -0.0008559720008634031, -0.02441536821424961, 0.04101495072245598, -0.01465161144733429, 0.008992934599518776, -0.025000954046845436, -0.019778480753302574, 0.07050938159227371, -0.0402740053832531, -0.011598195880651474, 0.03441813960671425, -0.043333396315574646, -0.020256510004401207, 0.04177979752421379, 0.007875539362430573, -0.04694252088665962, 0.024379516020417213, 0.047563958913087845, -0.009423160925507545, 0.0133370291441679, 0.011938792653381824, -0.007349707186222076, 0.003731619566679001, 0.037597037851810455, -0.01604984886944294, 0.0010494246380403638, 0.04106275364756584, 0.00782773643732071, -0.01588253676891327, 0.0155479172244668, 0.02402099408209324, -0.05521243438124657, -0.02813204936683178, -0.01599009521305561, 0.07055718451738358, 0.03484836593270302, -0.05272667855024338, -0.047277141362428665, -0.019312400370836258, -0.016312764957547188, -0.00033555444679223, 0.019886037334799767, -0.03946135565638542, -0.017579542472958565, -0.02884909324347973, -0.02204912155866623, 0.0012503465404734015, 0.0020376017782837152, -0.019001681357622147, 0.00882562343031168, 0.0032595652155578136, -0.015189394354820251, -0.028108147904276848, 0.022455446422100067, 0.056789930909872055, -0.005446551367640495, 0.022598855197429657, -0.023375652730464935, 0.0018060560105368495, 0.0075468942523002625, -0.03456154838204384, -0.0023184441961348057, 0.021439632400870323, 0.026148226112127304, 0.009542668238282204, 0.008646362461149693, -0.014579907059669495, 0.01138308271765709, 0.001656671753153205, 0.03635416179895401, -0.025885310024023056, 0.06888408213853836, -0.037453629076480865, 0.04089544340968132, -0.05263107270002365, 0.02230008691549301, 0.01981433294713497, 0.02273031324148178, 0.0011315860319882631, 0.030283182859420776, 0.021547188982367516, -0.010176057927310467, 0.05105357617139816, -0.024953151121735573, 0.03812287002801895, -0.022001318633556366, -0.05980151891708374, -0.019599217921495438, 0.015416458249092102, -0.0007715698448009789, -0.010480801574885845, -0.013611896894872189, -0.007552869617938995, 0.016384469345211983, 0.013313127681612968, -0.010988708585500717, 0.038170672953128815, 0.038481391966342926, 0.011359181255102158, 0.00139226159080863, -0.04708592966198921, -0.027343301102519035, 0.01449625100940466, -0.018750716000795364, -0.005637763068079948, -0.1023939698934555, 0.019121188670396805, -0.0036838166415691376, 0.04512600600719452, 0.03477666154503822, -0.011604171246290207, 0.014281137846410275, -0.02492924965918064, -0.0009515779092907906, 0.05989712476730347, 0.013755305670201778, 0.03441813960671425, -0.0411822609603405, -0.04201881214976311, -0.004971509333699942, -0.03857699781656265, 0.009560594335198402, -0.011030536144971848, 0.002618706552311778, 0.01736442930996418, -0.015810832381248474, -0.03331867232918739, 0.050479937344789505, -0.04252074286341667, 0.01479502022266388, 0.006543031893670559, -0.04166029021143913, 0.030259281396865845, -0.06482083350419998, 0.0003883991448674351, -0.013121915981173515, 0.0739033967256546, -0.018511701375246048, -0.025120461359620094, 0.021917663514614105, 0.011729654856026173, -0.03766874223947525, 0.03472885861992836, -0.005870802793651819, 0.005766233429312706, 0.00623231241479516, -0.028657881543040276, -0.019372154027223587, 0.03252992406487465, 0.018834371119737625, -0.0159064382314682, 0.02478584088385105, -0.027654020115733147, 0.002076441654935479, -0.052392058074474335, 0.026458945125341415, -0.029661744832992554, 0.014125778339803219, 0.03329477086663246, 0.009387308731675148, -0.00710471672937274, 0.03484836593270302, 0.0154523104429245, 0.0594668984413147, 0.007791884709149599, 0.05597728118300438, -0.0589410662651062, -0.008407347835600376, 0.02028041146695614, 0.031167538836598396, -0.0056975167244672775, -0.050814561545848846, -0.01565547287464142, -0.016802744939923286, -0.03893551975488663, 0.01767514832317829, -0.052822284400463104, -0.01310996524989605, -0.012691689655184746, 0.002796473912894726, 0.027916936203837395, -0.04861562326550484, 0.013755305670201778, 0.0007353441906161606, -0.01933630183339119, 0.014830872416496277, -0.0062203616835176945, 0.01808147504925728, -0.05067115277051926, 0.04120616242289543, -0.014830872416496277, 0.030546098947525024, 0.008407347835600376, -0.059419095516204834, -0.0038003362715244293, 0.0632433295249939, 0.020172854885458946, 0.05043213441967964, -0.01584668457508087, 0.02075844071805477, 0.01970677636563778, 0.01105443760752678, 0.02679356560111046, -0.02607652172446251, 0.007385559380054474, -0.018117327243089676, -0.03006806969642639, -0.014113827608525753, -0.016754942014813423, 0.049906302243471146, -0.010785546153783798, -0.0031729224137961864, -0.04221002385020256, -0.04046521708369255, 0.002730744890868664, 0.004400860983878374, 0.023088835179805756, 0.05114918202161789, -0.015715226531028748, 0.016121553257107735, -0.0051806471310555935, 0.01633666642010212, -0.007140568923205137, 0.002493223873898387, -0.0065071796998381615, 0.028084246441721916, 0.0033432203345000744, -0.01267973892390728, 0.01582278311252594, 0.004580122418701649, -0.00561983697116375, 0.027056481689214706, -0.008228086866438389, -0.022491298615932465, 0.039341844618320465, 0.026196029037237167, -0.01560767088085413, 0.00633986946195364, -0.04412214457988739, -0.014472349546849728, 0.017615394666790962, 0.013683601282536983, -0.03544590249657631, -0.025431182235479355, -0.10966002196073532, -0.040656428784132004, -0.013886763714253902, 0.009470963850617409, -0.019240695983171463, 0.02930322289466858, -0.00287714134901762, -0.0294705331325531, -0.028227655217051506, -0.014902576804161072, -0.012159881182014942, -0.037023402750492096, 0.027438906952738762, 0.007522992789745331, 0.013181669637560844, -0.02521606720983982, -0.0026874232571572065, 0.010725791566073895, 0.04761176183819771, -0.03709510713815689, 0.006315967533737421, 0.03286454454064369, 0.014364792965352535, 0.05067115277051926, -0.016408370807766914, 0.017005907371640205, 0.028036443516612053, 0.0011293452698737383, 0.03549370542168617, -0.028036443516612053, 0.01443649735301733, -0.008831598795950413, 0.0005340488278307021, -0.014926478266716003, 0.0027606217190623283, -0.028514472767710686, 0.0420905165374279, 0.01155039295554161, -0.05067115277051926, 0.016671286895871162, -0.003181885462254286, -0.026172127574682236, 0.02418830431997776, -0.052678875625133514, -0.018368292599916458, 0.010672013275325298, -0.041684191673994064, -0.00843722466379404, -0.027032580226659775, -0.010331417433917522, 0.05000190809369087, 0.0294705331325531, -0.02899250201880932, -0.03389230743050575, -0.030307084321975708, 0.005625812336802483, -0.0029010428115725517, -0.052678875625133514, 0.0229334756731987, 0.0010068501578643918, 0.0035224815364927053, 0.029637843370437622, -0.01970677636563778, 0.016169356182217598, -0.011645998805761337, 0.006674489937722683, -0.013815059326589108, 0.03154996037483215, -0.018177080899477005, 0.015954243019223213, 0.024009043350815773, -0.024236107245087624, 0.008096628822386265, -0.021523287519812584, -0.007331781089305878, -0.05530804023146629, -0.029781252145767212, -0.028108147904276848, 0.015810832381248474, -0.0008604535250924528, -0.0327928401529789, 0.0013832985423505306, 0.031143637374043465, 0.011454787105321884, -0.0037764348089694977, -0.015034034848213196, 0.007977121509611607, 0.0019569341093301773, -0.015595720149576664, 0.007917366921901703, -0.013552142307162285, 0.01993384025990963, 0.034346435219049454, -0.011269550770521164, 0.013827010057866573, -0.005784159526228905, 0.021320125088095665, 0.07194347679615021, 0.011347230523824692, 0.0011928335297852755, -0.006471327506005764, 0.02478584088385105, -0.02990075945854187, -0.0075409188866615295, -0.05186622589826584, -0.0031131685245782137, 0.005330031272023916, -0.011430885642766953, -0.014759168028831482, 0.00696130795404315, 0.03284064307808876, -0.008771845139563084, -0.020411869511008263, 0.0294705331325531, 0.0133370291441679, 0.01810537651181221, -0.017005907371640205, 0.00893915630877018, 0.02061503194272518, -0.019599217921495438, 0.007349707186222076, -0.03850529342889786, -0.011532466858625412, -0.01022386085242033, -0.028801290318369865, 0.0038361884653568268, -0.015296950936317444, 0.01736442930996418, -0.02424805797636509, 0.001737339305691421, 0.020184805616736412, -0.04017839953303337, 0.041540782898664474, 0.021379878744482994, -0.03556540980935097, 0.010660062544047832, 0.010050575248897076, 0.015428408980369568, -0.006315967533737421, -0.02258690446615219, 0.0014198976568877697, 0.0042066616006195545, 0.042425137013196945, 0.06295651197433472, -0.013671650551259518, 0.037716545164585114, 0.010241786949336529, -0.023542964830994606, -0.02024455927312374, -0.013456536456942558, -0.04292706772685051, -0.04407434165477753, 0.0034059619065374136, 0.004666765220463276, 0.007176421117037535, 0.010205934755504131, 0.005258326884359121, 0.0351351834833622, 0.005282228346914053, 0.0006617723847739398, -0.017782704904675484, 0.027032580226659775, 0.012112078256905079, 0.0007282483857125044, 0.010917004197835922, 0.03910282999277115, 0.03076121211051941, -0.0053778341971337795, -0.019969692453742027, 0.017603443935513496, 0.049762893468141556, -0.04283146187663078, -0.0594668984413147, 0.037597037851810455, -0.011090289801359177, 0.01588253676891327, 0.004463602788746357, 0.015715226531028748, 0.0034268756862729788, -0.004478541202843189, 0.009590471163392067, -0.01970677636563778, -0.0155479172244668, 0.03499177470803261, 0.03563711419701576, -0.01962311938405037, -0.01950361207127571, 0.0013407239457592368, -0.023339800536632538, 0.011401008814573288, -0.02439146675169468, 0.0196828730404377, -0.0049834600649774075, -0.0036150997038930655, -0.01639642007648945, -0.05492561683058739, 0.009650224819779396, 0.042281728237867355, -0.05788939818739891, -0.0023438395000994205, 0.006680465303361416, -0.0023811855353415012, -0.0191928930580616, 0.008090653456747532, 0.017232971265912056, 0.002624681917950511, -0.03145435452461243, 0.005536181852221489, 0.04660789668560028, -0.010164107196033001, -0.020626982674002647, 0.0043381196446716785, 0.025741901248693466, 0.03284064307808876, -0.014424546621739864, 0.016181306913495064, 0.029948562383651733, 0.01363579835742712, -0.024427318945527077, 0.007200322579592466, 0.0022377767600119114, 0.0011308391112834215, 0.0032834666781127453, 0.013934566639363766, 0.00843722466379404, 0.01209415215998888, 0.019778480753302574, 0.04247293993830681, -0.03221920505166054, 0.03401181474328041, -0.005037238355726004, 0.04350070655345917, 0.015189394354820251, 0.04861562326550484, 0.022527150809764862, 0.026315536350011826, 0.012076226063072681, -0.00876586977392435, 0.016742991283535957, -0.03138265013694763, -0.004502442665398121, 0.01882242038846016, 0.0015655473107472062, -0.019575316458940506, 0.018774617463350296, 0.03092852234840393, -0.005231437738984823, 0.01787831261754036, 0.022013269364833832, 0.013803108595311642, -0.03850529342889786, -0.01473526656627655, 0.021403780207037926, -0.008084678091108799, -0.019145090132951736, 0.021140864118933678, 0.0034716909285634756, -0.003175910096615553, 0.013576043769717216, 0.03331867232918739, 0.011197846382856369, -0.003970634192228317, -0.009112441912293434, -0.017579542472958565, 0.016575681045651436, -0.00034096965100616217, -0.004000511486083269, -0.03958086296916008, -0.014316990040242672, -0.0000537316627742257, -0.09182950854301453, 0.019575316458940506, 0.020949652418494225, 0.0006292813341133296, 0.009907166473567486, 0.06142681837081909, 0.031263142824172974, 0.00700313551351428, 0.029637843370437622, -0.008323692716658115, -0.016862498596310616, -0.025861408561468124, 0.021439632400870323, 0.0019853170961141586, 0.03678438812494278, -0.031908486038446426, 0.0004619709216058254, -0.012811196967959404, -0.03166946768760681, -0.006979234050959349, -0.019264597445726395, 0.025000954046845436, 0.02987685799598694, -0.009889240376651287, 0.03719071298837662, 0.0034627278801053762, -0.02710428461432457, -0.0002059635880868882, 0.033629391342401505, -0.0011696789879351854, -0.0026814478915184736, -0.023602718487381935, -0.002213875064626336, 0.044910892844200134, -0.013850911520421505, -0.002360271755605936, -0.002518619177863002, 0.01625301130115986, -0.012500477023422718, 0.007511042058467865, -0.0133370291441679, -0.03221920505166054, 0.0007162976544350386, 0.03812287002801895, 0.026865269988775253, -0.01356409303843975, 0.021511336788535118, 0.017985869199037552, 0.01970677636563778, 0.010271663777530193, -0.0033103558234870434, -0.034226927906274796, -0.022061072289943695, -0.00518363481387496, -0.010564456693828106, 0.0072541008703410625, 0.013982369564473629, -0.035541508346796036, -0.023232243955135345, 0.008592584170401096, -0.018918026238679886, -0.005817024037241936, 0.004607011564075947, -0.010164107196033001, -0.01722102053463459, -0.03530249372124672, -0.022407643496990204, 0.005165708716958761, 0.0051806471310555935, -0.018463898450136185, 0.009793633595108986, 0.03989158198237419, 0.022264234721660614, 0.03719071298837662, 0.009793633595108986, -0.006035125348716974, -0.043476805090904236, -0.0003898929862771183, -0.04663179814815521, -0.01080944761633873, -0.002466334728524089, -0.02650674805045128, 0.028323261067271233, -0.021355977281928062, 0.008628436364233494, 0.007313854992389679, -0.009327555075287819, 0.01132332906126976, -0.0025813605170696974, 0.005825987085700035, -0.00532704358920455, -0.013934566639363766, 0.016695188358426094, 0.017842460423707962, -0.022813968360424042, -0.0034657155629247427, 0.005858851596713066, -0.014137729071080685, 0.029135912656784058, 0.007534943521022797, -0.03840968757867813, -0.021666698157787323, -0.018093425780534744, -0.02133207581937313, 0.011902940459549427, -0.0378599539399147, -0.009578520432114601, 0.006543031893670559, 0.030091971158981323, 0.012112078256905079, 0.06529886275529861, 0.010797496885061264, -0.01947971060872078, -0.0014228853397071362, 0.04985849931836128, -0.03542200103402138, -0.029781252145767212, -0.006531081162393093, -0.006889603566378355, -0.024224156513810158, -0.019204843789339066, 0.007182396482676268, -0.03006806969642639, 0.002921956591308117, 0.00037458111182786524, -0.01030751597136259, 0.0116938017308712, 0.02178620547056198, -0.023937338963150978, 0.032338712364435196, -0.004499454982578754, 0.007839687168598175, 0.04524551331996918, -0.007200322579592466, -0.00963827408850193, -0.056933339685201645, -0.015512065030634403, 0.037142910063266754, -0.0008559720008634031, -0.003764484077692032, -0.022431544959545135, -0.04529331624507904, 0.00908256508409977, 0.006895578932017088, 0.005715442821383476, -0.02110501192510128, -0.013074113056063652, -0.008491002954542637, 0.048209298402071, -0.018547553569078445, 0.015045985579490662, 0.002572397468611598, -0.0379316583275795, -0.009859363548457623, 0.015810832381248474, -0.013468487188220024, 0.00729592889547348, -0.023184441030025482, 0.004601036198437214, 0.02418830431997776, 0.03520688787102699, 0.03095242567360401, 0.017890263348817825, -0.019658971577882767, -0.01839219406247139, 0.021236469969153404, -0.023375652730464935, 0.015512065030634403, -0.0026157188694924116, -0.030570000410079956, -0.05177062004804611, -0.042257826775312424, 0.04371581971645355, -0.00046981358900666237, -0.01113809272646904, 0.005873790476471186, -0.003175910096615553, -0.005353932734578848, 0.019897988066077232, 0.001915106549859047, -0.008532830514013767, 0.011150043457746506, 0.0038272254168987274, -0.0022855796851217747, 0.011616121977567673, 0.027008678764104843, 0.012112078256905079, -0.009447062388062477, 0.00575428269803524, 0.009381333366036415, -0.020256510004401207, 0.027319399639964104, -0.009590471163392067, 0.035541508346796036, 0.008407347835600376, 0.03092852234840393, -0.010761643759906292, 0.004810173995792866, 0.0034627278801053762, -0.005085041280835867, -0.006073965225368738, -0.03456154838204384, 0.0019076373428106308, -0.002142170676961541, -0.003441814100369811, 0.006073965225368738, 0.02153523825109005, 0.03410742059350014, -0.05277448147535324, -0.047109831124544144, -0.00504022603854537, 0.00012538944429252297, 0.052392058074474335, 0.009948994033038616, 0.002481273142620921, -0.021511336788535118, 0.0392940416932106, -0.03482446447014809, -0.028514472767710686, 0.0013481932692229748, 0.0003822370490524918, -0.057937201112508774, -0.025311673060059547, 0.03721461445093155, 0.014854773879051208, 0.0026007804553955793, -0.010193984024226665, -0.010020698420703411, -0.011968669481575489, 0.006901554297655821, 0.022180579602718353, -0.009817535057663918, 0.00968010164797306, -0.043189987540245056, -0.022610805928707123, -0.00666851457208395, -0.01716126687824726, 0.011490639299154282, 0.001889711245894432, 0.023005180060863495, 0.03704730421304703, 0.02233593910932541, 0.011251624673604965, 0.01742418296635151, 0.009136343374848366, -0.01728077419102192, 0.008706116117537022, -0.0310958344489336, 0.019037533551454544, -0.005548132583498955, -0.015261098742485046, 0.013456536456942558, -0.011275526136159897, -0.027773527428507805, 0.02007724903523922, 0.02593311294913292, -0.04486308991909027, 0.022610805928707123, 0.014986231923103333, -0.026004817336797714, 0.02061503194272518, 0.0015670411521568894, -0.036879993975162506, -0.03033098578453064, -0.008670263923704624, 0.03601954132318497, -0.02901640348136425, 0.0015535965794697404, -0.01516549289226532, -0.031024130061268806, 0.015141591429710388, -0.03623465448617935, 0.03578052669763565, -0.021355977281928062, -0.012847049161791801, 0.007433362305164337, 0.008072727359831333, 0.006118780467659235, 0.021977417171001434, 0.028538374230265617, -0.022264234721660614, -0.030593901872634888, 0.015237197279930115, 0.006465352140367031, 0.00032042930251918733, 0.011167969554662704, -0.013611896894872189, -0.01473526656627655, 0.013874812982976437, -0.014460398815572262, -0.005536181852221489, 0.0337010957300663, 0.005706479772925377, 0.0015282012755051255, 0.005201560910791159, -0.03092852234840393, -0.015786930918693542, -0.00868221465498209, -0.01238096971064806, -0.011060412973165512, -0.04099104925990105, 0.014627709984779358, 0.04481528699398041, -0.019826283678412437, -0.008502953685820103, -0.04089544340968132, 0.006118780467659235, -0.01845194771885872, -0.018212933093309402, 0.0133370291441679, 0.027295498177409172, 0.0015042998129501939, -0.017352478578686714, 0.02901640348136425, 0.009524742141366005, 0.00902281142771244, -0.027654020115733147, 0.005554107949137688, 0.0282993596047163, -0.02227618545293808, -0.02042382024228573, -0.01699395664036274, 0.03384450450539589, -0.006495228968560696, -0.04589085280895233, -0.04180369898676872, 0.022527150809764862, -0.01773490197956562, 0.03778824955224991, 0.04854391887784004, 0.01822488382458687, 0.00955461896955967, 0.008485027588903904, -0.026578452438116074, -0.00369875505566597, 0.01539255678653717, -0.019826283678412437, 0.0017492900369688869, 0.008843549527227879, 0.008694165386259556, -0.03895942121744156, -0.007415436208248138, -0.050814561545848846, -0.00739751011133194, 0.024176353588700294, -0.009584495797753334, -0.0035882105585187674, -0.0203640665858984, -0.027462808415293694, -0.004257452208548784, 0.06993574649095535, -0.00011960079427808523, 0.01950361207127571, -0.03367719426751137, -0.016468124464154243, -0.04364411532878876, 0.0021451583597809076, 0.02295737713575363, 0.005778184160590172, -0.002100343117490411, 0.0034328510519117117, 0.0196828730404377, -0.00586183974519372, -0.009464988484978676, 0.04789857938885689, -0.01830853894352913, 0.0019449834944680333, 0.04173199459910393, 0.01884632185101509, 0.031884580850601196, -0.018858272582292557, 0.0024708162527531385, -0.00681789917871356, 0.032482121139764786, -0.026602353900671005, -0.005548132583498955, 0.03214750066399574, -0.004078191239386797, -0.028801290318369865, -0.0011099252151325345, 0.005144794937223196, 0.0014452929608523846, -0.0003295790811534971, -0.021594993770122528, -0.02056722901761532, -0.0049446201883256435, -0.00331334350630641, 0.0012361550470814109, 0.03061780333518982, 0.013946517370641232, 0.015285000205039978, 0.0106540871784091, 0.03566101938486099, 0.022837869822978973, -0.023578817024827003, 0.020698687061667442, 0.0022168627474457026, 0.05076675862073898, 0.001475169905461371, -0.0007954713655635715, -0.03138265013694763, -0.016312764957547188, 0.027319399639964104, -0.004317205864936113, 0.01719711907207966, 0.010277639143168926, -0.008144431747496128, 0.007074839901179075, 0.016181306913495064, -0.06281310319900513, -0.013767256401479244, 0.0023961239494383335, -0.022897623479366302, 0.04218612238764763, 0.008712091483175755, 0.017089562490582466, 0.006841800641268492, 0.019838234409689903, -0.011227723211050034, 0.01036726962774992, 0.007744081784039736, 0.02564629539847374, -0.026913072913885117, 0.022383742034435272, 0.00038578492240048945, 0.01510573923587799, -0.03960476443171501, -0.011729654856026173, -0.01839219406247139, -0.020268460735678673, -0.018212933093309402, -0.03257772698998451, -0.011663924902677536, 0.035517606884241104, -0.024092698469758034, 0.007313854992389679, 0.020208707079291344, 0.016085701063275337, -0.007779933977872133, 0.021296223625540733, -0.022479347884655, -0.017782704904675484, 0.02990075945854187, 0.005616849288344383, -0.0037107057869434357, 0.010875176638364792, -0.008467101491987705, -0.009954969398677349, 0.013062162324786186, 0.014914527535438538, -0.014101876877248287, 0.03960476443171501, 0.026554550975561142, -0.016551779583096504, 0.02653064951300621, 0.0003476919373497367, -0.009566569700837135, -0.016958104446530342, -0.0023169503547251225, -0.010295565240085125, 0.027630118653178215, 0.03470495715737343, 0.018141228705644608, 0.010964807122945786, 0.02841886691749096, 0.039341844618320465, 0.0005527218454517424, -0.0048609646037220955, -0.009237924590706825, -0.04414604604244232, 0.019981643185019493, 0.010917004197835922, 0.019909938797354698, -0.029398828744888306, -0.031884580850601196, -0.010355318896472454, 0.001776179182343185, -0.04644058644771576, 0.004953583236783743, 0.003208774607628584, -0.01765124686062336, -0.0007570048910565674, 0.0016805732157081366, 0.028896896168589592, -0.0011002152459695935, -0.010002772323787212, -0.0035314445849508047, 0.005649713799357414, 0.04737274721264839, 0.0229334756731987, -0.016599582508206367, -0.004714568145573139, -0.04005889222025871, -0.037429727613925934, 0.03441813960671425, -0.02930322289466858, 0.007588721811771393, 0.0021974428091198206, -0.016085701063275337, -0.005422649905085564, -0.01913313940167427, -0.015380606055259705, 0.03578052669763565, 0.012703640386462212, 0.0017791668651625514, 0.005046201404184103, -0.040799837559461594, 0.019324351102113724, -0.024200255051255226, 0.00829381588846445, -0.03668878227472305, 0.01679079420864582, -0.014759168028831482, -0.009524742141366005, 0.010188008658587933, 0.0037943609058856964, 0.010355318896472454, -0.008969033136963844, -0.010881152004003525, -0.013803108595311642, 0.002690410939976573, -0.027175989001989365, 0.018547553569078445, -0.059849321842193604, -0.02858617715537548, -0.03546980395913124, 0.006160608027130365, -0.0029533274937421083, -0.04589085280895233, 0.014412595890462399, 0.00006698951619910076, -0.03403571620583534, 0.028920797631144524, -0.012858999893069267, -0.00825198832899332, 0.019515562802553177, -0.003665890544652939, 0.02813204936683178, 0.003229688387364149, -0.008419298566877842, -0.01055250596255064, 0.0022168627474457026, 0.006357795558869839, -0.01502208411693573, 0.02786913327872753, 0.03752533346414566, -0.009190121665596962, -0.040106695145368576, 0.01679079420864582, 0.009423160925507545, -0.03752533346414566, -0.04058472439646721, -0.015786930918693542, -0.012500477023422718, -0.009548643603920937, -0.002100343117490411, 0.017244921997189522, 0.01699395664036274, -0.015894487500190735, 0.02870568446815014, 0.0003732740005943924, -0.016145454719662666, -0.017077611759305, 0.01479502022266388, 0.038457490503787994, 0.02182205766439438, -0.010020698420703411, 0.012112078256905079, -0.004266415257006884, -0.014030172489583492, 0.058271825313568115, -0.008323692716658115, 0.011401008814573288, -0.0008507435559295118, -0.0017418208299204707, 0.01953946426510811, 0.02108111046254635, 0.008879401721060276, 0.031717270612716675, 0.0019987619016319513, -0.028753487393260002, -0.02447512187063694, 0.0024558776058256626, -0.038027264177799225, 0.022204481065273285, 0.03721461445093155, -0.023781979456543922, 0.023232243955135345, -0.012165856547653675, 0.006393647752702236, 0.008586608804762363, -0.03527859225869179, 0.007917366921901703, 0.011030536144971848, 0.01673104055225849, 0.030450493097305298, 0.007941268384456635, 0.003181885462254286, -0.02801254205405712, -0.03410742059350014, -0.032625529915094376, 0.01435284223407507, -0.00393478199839592, -0.013791157864034176, -0.024379516020417213, -0.0063697462901473045, 0.0310958344489336, -0.03315136209130287, -0.029422730207443237, -0.011018585413694382, -0.014125778339803219, 0.007630549371242523, 0.03843358904123306, 0.02213277667760849, 0.02464243210852146, 0.011592220515012741, -0.023148588836193085, 0.010863225907087326, -0.004000511486083269, 0.014030172489583492, -0.004397873301059008, -0.021009406074881554, 0.0005045454599894583, 0.0016088688280433416, 0.021941564977169037, -0.005604898557066917, 0.0029742412734776735, 0.001099468325264752, 0.023495161905884743, 0.03948525711894035, 0.04471968114376068, -0.0007065876852720976, 0.018236834555864334, 0.0028681783005595207, -0.013850911520421505, -0.00027337323990650475, -0.023889536038041115, 0.0006632662261836231, -0.00633986946195364, 0.006602785550057888, 0.026626255363225937, -0.026865269988775253, -0.027916936203837395, -0.019431907683610916, 0.015213295817375183, -0.022694461047649384, -0.01190891582518816, -0.045341119170188904, 0.01213597971946001, -0.026315536350011826, 0.03800336271524429, -0.009512791410088539, -0.033342573791742325, 0.009704003110527992, 0.004194710869342089, -0.0165876317769289, 0.004215624649077654, -0.028084246441721916, 0.05382614582777023, -0.02273031324148178, 0.009339505806565285, 0.0033820602111518383, 0.009715953841805458, 0.03154996037483215, 0.04326169192790985, 0.026554550975561142, -0.02464243210852146, 0.05774598941206932, -0.019515562802553177, 0.04754005745053291, -0.013886763714253902, 0.011873063631355762, 0.0294705331325531, 0.02221643179655075, 0.02056722901761532, 0.009506816044449806, 0.012858999893069267, 0.018918026238679886, -0.012118053622543812, -0.012596082873642445, -0.0035822351928800344, -0.04091934487223625, 0.0051149181090295315, 0.04840051010251045, -0.009943018667399883, 0.0034776662942022085, 0.004421774763613939, 0.008819648064672947, -0.037429727613925934, -0.05588167533278465, 0.007092765998095274, -0.01939605548977852, 0.012022447772324085, -0.013205571100115776, -0.011353205889463425, 0.0025873358827084303, 0.009321579709649086, 0.0023976177908480167, -0.016169356182217598, -0.015464261174201965, 0.0014901083195582032, -0.00194348965305835, -0.027152087539434433, -0.010415072552859783, 0.0360434427857399, -0.014890626072883606, 0.010379220359027386, -0.02899250201880932, 0.030856817960739136, -0.014257236383855343, -0.06109219789505005, 0.007164470385760069, -0.020543327555060387, 0.013719453476369381, -0.006823874544352293, -0.009530717507004738, 0.027916936203837395, 0.004164834041148424, 0.00032752504921518266, 0.02178620547056198, -0.0013713478110730648, 0.030283182859420776, 0.003830213099718094, 0.03518298640847206, -0.02404489554464817, -0.061618030071258545, 0.03396401181817055, 0.024570727720856667, 0.019455809146165848, -0.005186622496694326, 0.030402690172195435, 0.016922252252697945, -0.010803472250699997, 0.010928954929113388, 0.009327555075287819, 0.013265324756503105, -0.013719453476369381, 0.02564629539847374, -0.015273049473762512 ]
12.084743
6.417032
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.531.4857C
[ "galaxy formation", "disc galaxies", "other galaxy types", "galaxy structure", "galaxies", "starburst galaxies", "star formation", "integrated star formation history", "early epochs galaxy assembly", "stars" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
39
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1180", "10.48550/arXiv.2405.00376" ]
[ "Conselice, Christopher J.", "Basham, Justin T. F.", "Bettaney, Daniel O.", "Ferreira, Leonardo", "Adams, Nathan", "Harvey, Thomas", "Ormerod, Katherine", "Caruana, Joseph", "Bluck, Asa F. L.", "Li, Qiong", "Roper, William J.", "Trussler, James", "Irodotou, Dimitrios", "Austin, Duncan" ]
[ "Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9SR, UK", "Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9SR, UK", "Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9SR, UK", "School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Victoria, Victoria, BC, Canada", "Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9SR, UK", "Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9SR, UK", "Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9SR, UK", "Department of Physics, University of Malta, Msida MSD 2080, Malta; Institute of Space Sciences &amp; Astronomy, University of Malta, Msida MSD 2080, Malta", "Stocker AstroScience Center, Department of Physics, Florida International University, 11200 SW 8th Street, Miami, FL 33199, USA", "Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9SR, UK", "Astronomy Centre, University of Sussex, Falmer, Brighton BN1 9QH, UK", "Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9SR, UK", "Department of Physics, University of Helsinki, Gustaf Hällströmin katu 2, FI-00014, Helsinki, Finland", "Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9SR, UK" ]
null
[ "1926ApJ....64..321H", "1976ApJ...203..297S", "2000AJ....119.2645B", "2000ApJ...536L..77B", "2002AJ....124..266P", "2003AJ....126.1183C", "2003MNRAS.344.1000B", "2004MNRAS.351.1151B", "2005ApJ...620..564C", "2006ApJ...638..686C", "2006ApJ...651..120B", "2006MNRAS.373.1389C", "2007ApJ...660L..43N", "2007CSE.....9...90H", "2008ApJ...686.1503B", "2009ApJ...691.1879W", "2010AJ....139.2097P", "2010ApJ...721..193P", "2010ApJ...724..915H", "2011ApJS..197...35G", "2011ApJS..197...36K", "2011MNRAS.413.2845M", "2011MNRAS.417.2770C", "2012A&A...538A..33S", "2012ApJ...747...34B", "2012ApJ...755..148G", "2012ApJ...760..131C", "2013ApJ...776...63F", "2013ApJS..206....8M", "2013MNRAS.430.1051C", "2013MNRAS.433.1185M", "2014ARA&A..52..291C", "2014ARA&A..52..415M", "2014ApJ...788...11L", "2014MNRAS.441..599B", "2014MNRAS.444.1125C", "2014MNRAS.444.1647K", "2014MNRAS.444.2960D", "2015ApJ...801...97S", "2015ApJ...808..101M", "2015ApJ...814...55F", "2015ApJS..218...33A", "2015MNRAS.447....2M", "2015ascl.soft04007P", "2016JOSS....1...24F", "2016MNRAS.459...44T", "2016MNRAS.461.1112O", "2016MNRAS.462..726A", "2017ApJS..229...32S", "2017MNRAS.465.2717P", "2017PASA...34...58E", "2018A&A...615A.146P", "2019ApJ...876..110D", "2020ApJ...902...77O", "2020MNRAS.493.4209C", "2020cegs.book.....C", "2021ApJ...909..144B", "2021ApJ...916....4T", "2021ApJ...919..139W", "2021MNRAS.500.2127L", "2021MNRAS.501.2182I", "2021MNRAS.507.4425C", "2022A&A...659A.160B", "2022ApJ...935..167A", "2022ApJ...938L...2F", "2022ApJ...938L..24F", "2022ApJ...940...55B", "2022ApJ...940..168C", "2022MNRAS.511.1502M", "2022MNRAS.512.1052P", "2022MNRAS.514.1921R", "2023A&A...673A..30P", "2023AJ....165...13W", "2023ApJ...942L..28T", "2023ApJ...944..108B", "2023ApJ...946L..15K", "2023ApJ...948L..13J", "2023ApJ...955...94F", "2023ApJS..265....5H", "2023MNRAS.520.3529E", "2023MNRAS.520.3974C", "2023MNRAS.523.1009B", "2023MNRAS.525.5328T", "2023MNRAS.525.5520L", "2024A&A...685A..48H", "2024ApJ...961..163B", "2024ApJ...961..207N", "2024ApJ...962..164T", "2024ApJ...965..169A", "2024MNRAS.527.6110O", "2024arXiv240303908H" ]
29096900
2308.16895
MIDIS: JWST/MIRI Reveals the Stellar Structure of ALMA-selected Galaxies in the Hubble Ultra Deep Field at Cosmic Noon
We present deep James Webb Space Telescope (JWST)/Mid-Infrared Instrument (MIRI) F560W observations of a flux-limited, Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA)-selected sample of 28 galaxies at z = 0.5–3.7 in the Hubble Ultra Deep Field (HUDF). The data from the MIRI Deep Imaging Survey (MIDIS) reveal the stellar structure of the HUDF galaxies at rest-frame wavelengths of λ &gt; 1 μm for the first time. We revise the stellar mass estimates using new JWST photometry and find good agreement with pre-JWST analyses; the few discrepancies can be explained by blending issues in the earlier lower-resolution Spitzer data. At z ∼ 2.5, the resolved rest-frame near-infrared (1.6 μm) structure of the galaxies is significantly more smooth and centrally concentrated than seen by the Hubble Space Telescope at rest-frame 450 nm (F160W), with effective radii of R <SUB> e </SUB>(F560W) = 1–5 kpc and Sérsic indices mostly close to an exponential (disk-like) profile (n ≈ 1), up to n ≈ 5 (excluding active galactic nuclei). We find an average size ratio of R <SUB> e </SUB>(F560W)/R <SUB> e </SUB>(F160W) ≈ 0.7 that decreases with stellar mass. The stellar structure of the ALMA-selected galaxies is indistinguishable from a HUDF reference sample of all galaxies with a MIRI flux density greater than 1 μJy. We supplement our analysis with custom-made, position-dependent, empirical point-spread function models for the F560W observations. The results imply that a smoother stellar structure is in place in massive gas-rich, star-forming galaxies at "Cosmic Noon," despite a more clumpy rest-frame optical appearance, placing additional constraints on galaxy formation simulations. As a next step, matched-resolution, resolved ALMA observations will be crucial to further link the mass- and light-weighted galaxy structures to the dusty interstellar medium.
[ -0.009559204801917076, -0.000797381391748786, 0.01908092200756073, -0.020530423149466515, -0.024766461923718452, 0.0029396116733551025, 0.010152749717235565, 0.0016494314186275005, -0.009765383787453175, 0.011214883998036385, -0.03631248325109482, -0.004161065444350243, -0.044509656727313995, -0.013882714323699474, 0.021455103531479836, 0.05608066916465759, -0.012683128006756306, 0.015769563615322113, -0.028315238654613495, 0.031039299443364143, 0.011845916509628296, -0.0198681503534317, -0.04066098481416702, -0.014569977298378944, -0.03981127589941025, -0.026915721595287323, -0.06087901443243027, -0.027365567162632942, 0.04948294162750244, 0.014220098033547401, -0.005345032550394535, -0.026815755292773247, -0.017581438645720482, -0.03008962795138359, -0.07942262291908264, 0.09121855348348618, 0.004723371937870979, 0.004704628139734268, -0.02135513909161091, 0.0013745261821895838, -0.008347122929990292, 0.026940712705254555, 0.0039173997938632965, -0.007434937171638012, 0.00454530818387866, -0.015582128427922726, -0.012426965869963169, 0.029589800164103508, 0.020855311304330826, 0.0008918800740502775, -0.020043089985847473, 0.028890041634440422, -0.008259653113782406, -0.026140987873077393, -0.01298302412033081, -0.002346066292375326, 0.022204846143722534, 0.007491167634725571, -0.03788693994283676, 0.03693726658821106, -0.010746295563876629, 0.01541968435049057, 0.019268358126282692, -0.041435714811086655, 0.0017743883654475212, -0.0174189954996109, 0.0006939014419913292, -0.0030692543368786573, 0.049832820892333984, 0.04888314753770828, -0.029339885339140892, 0.0007864476647228003, -0.01998061127960682, -0.03653740510344505, 0.016244400292634964, -0.027415549382567406, 0.008290891535580158, -0.04331006854772568, -0.053181666880846024, -0.019755689427256584, 0.011633489280939102, 0.009659170173108578, -0.03448811173439026, -0.018581094220280647, 0.0022164233960211277, -0.01616942510008812, 0.011064935475587845, 0.003761203493922949, -0.038386765867471695, 0.025716135278344154, 0.03476301580667496, 0.016581783071160316, -0.00954670924693346, -0.028315238654613495, 0.004220420029014349, -0.06562737375497818, 0.012539427727460861, -0.031514137983322144, 0.03721217066049576, 0.019168391823768616, 0.021467600017786026, 0.03006463684141636, 0.01151478011161089, -0.046483974903821945, 0.020517926663160324, -0.016881680116057396, 0.044959500432014465, -0.02719062753021717, -0.0007844952051527798, 0.01389520987868309, -0.009977810084819794, -0.010377672500908375, 0.014757412485778332, 0.01940581016242504, -0.029514824971556664, 0.022242331877350807, -0.07677353173494339, 0.025303777307271957, -0.02991468831896782, -0.010989961214363575, -0.00886569358408451, 0.009121855720877647, 0.04063599184155464, -0.001209739246405661, 0.038786631077528, -0.011814677156507969, 0.024004224687814713, -0.022992074489593506, -0.059929341077804565, 0.021242676302790642, 0.06322820484638214, -0.03401327505707741, 0.010102767497301102, -0.010096519254148006, -0.023454414680600166, -0.01616942510008812, 0.008272148668766022, -0.008322130888700485, 0.016994141042232513, -0.020492935553193092, 0.016606776043772697, 0.003489422146230936, 0.0442347526550293, -0.021867461502552032, 0.03571268916130066, -0.02426663413643837, -0.020705362781882286, 0.011246123351156712, 0.0038174339570105076, 0.029264912009239197, -0.03618752583861351, -0.012539427727460861, 0.00017093717178795487, -0.060079287737607956, -0.014869874343276024, -0.002166440710425377, 0.011777190491557121, -0.02441658265888691, -0.0008473641355521977, -0.008721993304789066, -0.04118580371141434, -0.015332214534282684, -0.008015986531972885, 0.006772665306925774, 0.006803904660046101, 0.021255172789096832, 0.00408921530470252, 0.010939978994429111, -0.0888693630695343, 0.0043891118839383125, -0.0412357859313488, 0.016594279557466507, 0.0062759616412222385, -0.03101430833339691, 0.0025288157630711794, 0.020068081095814705, -0.004139197990298271, -0.0164693221449852, -0.03303861245512962, -0.02596604824066162, -0.021929940208792686, -0.00922806840389967, -0.004373492207378149, -0.027840401977300644, -0.060229238122701645, 0.0017525209113955498, -0.005216951481997967, 0.0421854592859745, 0.022492246702313423, -0.003679981455206871, -0.004170437343418598, 0.03663736954331398, -0.014470011927187443, 0.06507756561040878, -0.004279774613678455, -0.0338883176445961, -0.005026392173022032, 0.05023268237709999, -0.030614446848630905, 0.07722337543964386, 0.02487892284989357, 0.0023476281203329563, 0.049233026802539825, -0.058079976588487625, -0.02931489422917366, -0.025528699159622192, 0.056880392134189606, 0.007316228002309799, -0.024041712284088135, 0.016456827521324158, 0.035037919878959656, 0.026215963065624237, 0.02261720411479473, 0.021330146118998528, -0.03508790582418442, 0.006691443268209696, -0.03201396390795708, -0.026016032323241234, 0.062228549271821976, 0.0574302040040493, -0.02245475910604, 0.038236819207668304, 0.047383666038513184, 0.0363374724984169, -0.006610221229493618, 0.013832731172442436, 0.02106773667037487, 0.008228413760662079, 0.03493795543909073, 0.015619615092873573, 0.038686662912368774, 0.003376960987225175, -0.057780083268880844, 0.007434937171638012, -0.030764395371079445, 0.020567908883094788, 0.008353370241820812, 0.006535246968269348, 0.008459583856165409, -0.006772665306925774, -0.018831009045243263, -0.008303388021886349, 0.014482507482171059, 0.011433558538556099, -0.03528783470392227, 0.035662706941366196, 0.002844332018867135, -0.04063599184155464, 0.03188900649547577, -0.013232938013970852, 0.05513099581003189, -0.005548087414354086, -0.0510324090719223, -0.0353877991437912, -0.04488452896475792, 0.022242331877350807, -0.03386332467198372, 0.08786971122026443, -0.03876163810491562, 0.004626530222594738, -0.04563426971435547, 0.002841208130121231, -0.0412357859313488, 0.028065325692296028, -0.02856515347957611, 0.037911929190158844, 0.05068252980709076, 0.002689697779715061, 0.0064102900214493275, 0.03786194697022438, -0.009271803312003613, 0.007559894118458033, 0.04515943303704262, -0.016144433990120888, -0.028615135699510574, 0.014457516372203827, -0.007322475779801607, 0.0274905227124691, 0.010377672500908375, 0.021442608907818794, -0.004810841754078865, -0.0012644078815355897, 0.037761982530355453, 0.0360625684261322, -0.0147324213758111, 0.03568769618868828, 0.0016119442880153656, -0.005076374858617783, -0.023154517635703087, -0.040685974061489105, 0.05598070099949837, -0.030914343893527985, 0.015932008624076843, 0.006344687659293413, -0.04398483783006668, -0.00894066784530878, 0.008522062562406063, 0.03583764657378197, 0.0002612380776554346, 0.021242676302790642, 0.05972940847277641, -0.014757412485778332, 0.028965014964342117, 0.0034644308034330606, 0.009309290908277035, 0.05957946181297302, 0.018531112000346184, -0.01367028709501028, -0.010821269825100899, 0.04685884714126587, -0.0029349257238209248, -0.017194073647260666, -0.004001745488494635, 0.048633236438035965, -0.04778352752327919, -0.020830318331718445, -0.017806362360715866, 0.02260470762848854, 0.019505776464939117, -0.018131250515580177, -0.00830963533371687, -0.018118754029273987, -0.034113239496946335, -0.011902146972715855, 0.01389520987868309, -0.04308514669537544, 0.016894176602363586, -0.04183558002114296, -0.054731134325265884, -0.004870196338742971, 0.02274215966463089, 0.026190971955657005, 0.011064935475587845, -0.051232337951660156, -0.0019602617248892784, -0.0397363007068634, 0.01788133569061756, 0.00401111738756299, -0.011933386325836182, 0.0005236475844867527, -0.008809463120996952, -0.030789386481046677, -0.011389823630452156, 0.02456653118133545, 0.006522751413285732, 0.021592555567622185, 0.03683730214834213, -0.028765084221959114, 0.007728585973381996, -0.020093074068427086, 0.0329386442899704, 0.0042704027146101, 0.03398828208446503, -0.013482851907610893, 0.026440884917974472, -0.016556791961193085, 0.03171406686306, -0.09136850386857986, 0.0027021935675293207, 0.005166968796402216, -0.03393829986453056, -0.013445365242660046, 0.03476301580667496, -0.0013799930457025766, -0.014032662846148014, 0.030139610171318054, -0.007859790697693825, 0.04288521781563759, -0.024191660806536674, -0.07617373764514923, 0.022679680958390236, 0.013495347462594509, 0.01936832256615162, -0.001063695759512484, -0.0706256553530693, 0.006394670810550451, 0.06302827596664429, -0.003789318725466728, -0.034138232469558716, -0.004329757299274206, 0.0004892844590358436, -0.028040334582328796, -0.007791064213961363, -0.018218720331788063, 0.012514435686171055, 0.004032984841614962, 0.004970161709934473, 0.026765773072838783, -0.08267150074243546, -0.00379869039170444, -0.040685974061489105, 0.015432179905474186, -0.0008762604556977749, -0.005038888193666935, -0.008715745061635971, -0.0687263086438179, 0.040511034429073334, 0.06267839670181274, 0.012058342806994915, 0.061278875917196274, -0.03191399946808815, -0.038561705499887466, -0.046958811581134796, -0.05583075433969498, -0.014819891192018986, 0.015757068991661072, 0.01676921918988228, 0.038086868822574615, -0.0022992074955254793, -0.03711220622062683, 0.010196484625339508, -0.0427352674305439, 0.015782060101628304, 0.010808774270117283, -0.02841520495712757, 0.034713033586740494, -0.051232337951660156, 0.024791453033685684, -0.018543606624007225, 0.055330924689769745, -0.019055930897593498, 0.02901499718427658, 0.028440196067094803, 0.006316572427749634, -0.011196140199899673, 0.011183644644916058, 0.018818512558937073, -0.011783437803387642, -0.013557826168835163, -0.031039299443364143, -0.03513788804411888, 0.0549810454249382, 0.030314549803733826, 0.009428000077605247, -0.023441918194293976, -0.024166669696569443, 0.013957688584923744, -0.0030098999850451946, -0.015057309530675411, -0.016669252887368202, 0.010134006850421429, 0.02322949282824993, -0.02674078196287155, -0.038536716252565384, -0.03608756139874458, -0.00034226482966914773, 0.032588765025138855, 0.04643399268388748, 0.018731042742729187, -0.026790764182806015, 0.008215918205678463, -0.015469667501747608, 0.018743539229035378, 0.02549121342599392, -0.015981990844011307, -0.008265900425612926, 0.0004279774730093777, -0.014407533220946789, -0.0027100034058094025, -0.01160225085914135, -0.006591477897018194, -0.023854276165366173, -0.026041023433208466, 0.029864704236388206, -0.05040762200951576, 0.04560927674174309, 0.04355998337268829, 0.021592555567622185, 0.00785354245454073, -0.03881162032485008, 0.020530423149466515, -0.05283178761601448, 0.02214236743748188, -0.025566186755895615, 0.004032984841614962, -0.0415106900036335, -0.012195795774459839, -0.055031027644872665, 0.03476301580667496, -0.004445342347025871, 0.042360398918390274, -0.021242676302790642, 0.009902835823595524, 0.033963292837142944, 0.057930029928684235, 0.043135128915309906, -0.03588762879371643, 0.017194073647260666, 0.005854231771081686, -0.035662706941366196, -0.036862291395664215, -0.030589455738663673, 0.025078855454921722, -0.012358239851891994, 0.012439461424946785, -0.05653051286935806, -0.02274215966463089, 0.003414447885006666, 0.007409945596009493, 0.005601194221526384, 0.061728719621896744, -0.027740437537431717, 0.009046881459653378, -0.01275185402482748, 0.014707430265843868, 0.02641589380800724, -0.01970570720732212, -0.04430972412228584, 0.014057653956115246, 0.02256722003221512, -0.016981646418571472, 0.04998277127742767, -0.0020571034401655197, 0.02761548012495041, 0.020680371671915054, 0.018993452191352844, -0.0075099109672009945, 0.03256377577781677, 0.041160810738801956, -0.00522944750264287, 0.002005558693781495, -0.004251659382134676, -0.005101366434246302, 0.006766417529433966, 0.04370993375778198, -0.013195451349020004, -0.038561705499887466, -0.10266461223363876, -0.019193382933735847, 0.009415504522621632, -0.017506465315818787, -0.0030223955400288105, 0.022329801693558693, -0.008472079411149025, -0.001633811742067337, -0.016294382512569427, 0.012776845134794712, 0.001171471201814711, 0.016544297337532043, 0.00870949774980545, 0.020492935553193092, 0.018893487751483917, -0.025091350078582764, 0.00794726051390171, 0.02869010902941227, 0.03561272472143173, -0.027240609750151634, 0.03463805839419365, 0.03588762879371643, 0.006185367703437805, 0.05633058026432991, 0.0004779602459166199, 0.019205879420042038, 0.01891847886145115, -0.013407877646386623, 0.006429033819586039, -0.023766806349158287, -0.013870218768715858, 0.01274560671299696, -0.02185496687889099, -0.001176938065327704, 0.010071528144180775, -0.024404088035225868, 0.021480094641447067, -0.0018712299643084407, -0.04393485561013222, 0.0030692543368786573, -0.008128447458148003, -0.02074284851551056, 0.01724405586719513, -0.008728241547942162, -0.029989661648869514, -0.01829369366168976, -0.031689077615737915, -0.011727207340300083, -0.0008317445171996951, -0.00713504059240222, 0.05698035657405853, 0.02689073048532009, -0.01374526135623455, -0.044034820050001144, -0.01175844669342041, -0.008053474128246307, 0.02520381100475788, -0.02256722003221512, 0.015107291750609875, -0.0035643961746245623, -0.02581609971821308, 0.038711655884981155, -0.03038952313363552, 0.009434247389435768, 0.0029833465814590454, -0.003995497711002827, -0.017631422728300095, 0.01313297264277935, -0.02928990311920643, 0.012408223003149033, 0.016906671226024628, 0.004767106845974922, -0.013382886536419392, 0.01244570966809988, -0.031039299443364143, -0.026940712705254555, -0.021555069833993912, -0.050632543861866, 0.009652921929955482, -0.005929206032305956, -0.016856689006090164, 0.005273182410746813, 0.014095140621066093, -0.01661927066743374, 0.0206178929656744, -0.020642884075641632, 0.019768185913562775, -0.016081955283880234, 0.03226387873291969, 0.03586263582110405, -0.028290247544646263, 0.0306894201785326, 0.005254438612610102, -0.04780852049589157, 0.008184678852558136, 0.004061100073158741, 0.030964326113462448, 0.02182997390627861, 0.014457516372203827, -0.005804249085485935, -0.019055930897593498, -0.01831868477165699, -0.02211737632751465, -0.02394174598157406, -0.02444157376885414, 0.03271372243762016, -0.010415159165859222, 0.008828206919133663, -0.02093028463423252, 0.03513788804411888, 0.017606429755687714, -0.02031799592077732, -0.011571011506021023, 0.022542228922247887, 0.021580060943961143, 0.03598759323358536, -0.0019836912397295237, 0.011677224189043045, 0.019743194803595543, 0.0032863670494407415, 0.00036022739368490875, -0.05543089285492897, -0.03398828208446503, -0.015757068991661072, -0.03006463684141636, -0.002249224577099085, 0.02761548012495041, 0.03913651034235954, 0.01631937362253666, 0.02211737632751465, 0.019818168133497238, -0.04910806939005852, 0.003842425299808383, 0.026490867137908936, -0.003451935015618801, -0.018356172367930412, 0.013720270246267319, -0.0250413678586483, 0.01801878772675991, -0.009665418416261673, 0.025766117498278618, -0.0014979211846366525, 0.04213547334074974, 0.07492417097091675, -0.06837642937898636, 0.0206178929656744, 0.01649431325495243, -0.019343331456184387, -0.015007326379418373, 0.00447033392265439, -0.03896157070994377, -0.046958811581134796, -0.01343286968767643, 0.00318796350620687, 0.005323165096342564, -0.010283954441547394, -0.012626897543668747, -0.03568769618868828, 0.0240916945040226, 0.03251378983259201, 0.009877844713628292, 0.0027193750720471144, 0.003483174368739128, 0.03286367282271385, 0.03618752583861351, 0.048633236438035965, 0.001866544014774263, -0.00622285483404994, -0.030264567583799362, 0.0030130238737910986, 0.007972251623868942, -0.004442218691110611, -0.027890386059880257, 0.014282576739788055, 0.0186435729265213, 0.019043434411287308, -0.015457171946763992, 0.019393315538764, 0.019043434411287308, 0.020193038508296013, 0.0046171583235263824, 0.016581783071160316, 0.004592166747897863, 0.025103846564888954, 0.015632111579179764, -0.01940581016242504, -0.013570321723818779, -0.012820580042898655, -0.001985253067687154, 0.020692866295576096, 0.012258274480700493, -0.02641589380800724, 0.014994830824434757, -0.013270425610244274, 0.0196682196110487, -0.058079976588487625, 0.028015341609716415, 0.057480186223983765, -0.051057398319244385, -0.004695256240665913, 0.013095485977828503, 0.00606978265568614, -0.025866083800792694, 0.007353715132921934, 0.01229576114565134, -0.016431836411356926, -0.056380562484264374, -0.028140299022197723, 0.00878447201102972, -0.006966348737478256, -0.02382928505539894, -0.021555069833993912, 0.032438818365335464, 0.01938081905245781, -0.02013055980205536, -0.004695256240665913, 0.003311358392238617, 0.005338784772902727, -0.023604363203048706, 0.02410419099032879, 0.0029786606319248676, -0.02214236743748188, 0.025403741747140884, -0.00167754665017128, 0.010040288791060448, 0.026365911588072777, -0.013995175249874592, 0.03421320393681526, -0.05817994475364685, 0.0196682196110487, -0.005263810511678457, 0.020967772230505943, -0.003486298257485032, 0.05857980623841286, 0.02290460467338562, 0.03571268916130066, 0.008047225885093212, -0.025166325271129608, 0.04413478448987007, -0.03353843837976456, 0.011789686046540737, 0.03311358392238617, -0.017306534573435783, -0.021442608907818794, -0.0196682196110487, 0.040236130356788635, -0.029114963486790657, 0.029739748686552048, -0.019268358126282692, 0.01137732807546854, -0.03493795543909073, -0.007284988649189472, -0.006185367703437805, -0.007966004312038422, -0.013182955794036388, 0.008884437382221222, 0.005544963292777538, -0.003261375706642866, 0.004448466468602419, -0.023104535415768623, -0.024766461923718452, -0.014669942669570446, -0.017131594941020012, -0.03256377577781677, 0.00962168350815773, -0.012039599940180779, -0.0026818879414349794, -0.008034730330109596, 0.02063038758933544, 0.02260470762848854, -0.09491728246212006, 0.021017754450440407, 0.009428000077605247, 0.005904214456677437, -0.007678602822124958, 0.05623061582446098, 0.001517445663921535, 0.03618752583861351, 0.011802181601524353, -0.007022579200565815, 0.010027793236076832, -0.028940023854374886, -0.0055512115359306335, 0.008965658955276012, 0.007778568658977747, -0.01890598237514496, -0.030764395371079445, 0.005063879303634167, -0.003992373589426279, 0.00960918702185154, -0.019793177023530006, 0.030639437958598137, 0.03038952313363552, -0.0042360397055745125, -0.007022579200565815, -0.04031110554933548, -0.014844882301986217, 0.008565797470510006, 0.029364876449108124, -0.029714755713939667, -0.01938081905245781, 0.012708119116723537, 0.01571958139538765, 0.03676232695579529, -0.02993967942893505, -0.004514068830758333, -0.014445020817220211, 0.05283178761601448, -0.04713375121355057, 0.020867805927991867, -0.037487078458070755, -0.02689073048532009, 0.02441658265888691, 0.010665073059499264, 0.02106773667037487, 0.004342253319919109, 0.0262659452855587, 0.007734833750873804, 0.020342987030744553, 0.013532835058867931, 0.00518571212887764, 0.014919856563210487, 0.00977787934243679, 0.024041712284088135, -0.013145468197762966, 0.03911151736974716, -0.011421062983572483, 0.012158309109508991, -0.015219753608107567, 0.011489789001643658, -0.060079287737607956, 0.04018614813685417, 0.019030939787626266, -0.012845572084188461, -0.0534815639257431, -0.004689008463174105, -0.015832042321562767, 0.027240609750151634, 0.028440196067094803, -0.008946916088461876, -0.002383553422987461, 0.05523096024990082, 0.02365434542298317, 0.003573768073692918, 0.043260086327791214, -0.024479061365127563, -0.03891158476471901, 0.012195795774459839, -0.01785634458065033, 0.020705362781882286, 0.012845572084188461, -0.029189936816692352, 0.03303861245512962, -0.01648181863129139, -0.0056855399161577225, 0.005957321263849735, -0.006141632795333862, -0.028015341609716415, 0.0022710920311510563, 0.00808471255004406, 0.02046794444322586, 0.033513445407152176, 0.04331006854772568, 0.0068476395681500435, 0.009384265169501305, -0.0028583896346390247, 0.01860608533024788, -0.036412447690963745, -0.01588202454149723, 0.013995175249874592, -0.025591177865862846, -0.017756378278136253, 0.0039236475713551044, -0.04513444006443024, 0.008547053672373295, -0.016381852328777313, -0.018706051632761955, 0.010096519254148006, 0.018668564036488533, 0.04443468153476715, 0.03376336023211479, 0.03178904205560684, -0.005057631526142359, 0.04318511113524437, 0.030464498326182365, -0.0009988744277507067, -0.043260086327791214, -0.016869185492396355, 0.008778223767876625, -0.005257562734186649, 0.013070493936538696, 0.009884092956781387, -0.03616253286600113, -0.03408825024962425, 0.025991039350628853, -0.003270747372880578, 0.002085218671709299, 0.0014096703380346298, 0.007341219112277031, 0.00785354245454073, 0.03861168771982193, 0.015907015651464462, 0.04665891453623772, -0.03176404908299446, 0.01603197306394577, -0.030464498326182365, 0.009459239430725574, 0.04333506152033806, -0.016844192519783974, 0.004217296373099089, -0.012820580042898655, 0.006947604939341545, 0.013407877646386623, 0.022867117077112198, 0.010796277783811092, 0.004870196338742971, -0.026790764182806015, -0.01082751713693142, 0.05758015066385269, 0.03571268916130066, 0.023104535415768623, -0.017369013279676437, 0.003223888576030731, 0.010964970104396343, -0.011408567428588867, -0.006104145664721727, -0.03263874724507332, -0.04076094925403595, -0.00962168350815773, 0.01320794690400362, 0.0202805083245039, -0.00027353852055966854, -0.018418651074171066, 0.007528654765337706, 0.028290247544646263, 0.024541540071368217, -0.021567564457654953, 0.011645985767245293, 0.03358842059969902, -0.010552612133324146, -0.004098587203770876, -0.007866038009524345, 0.02594105713069439, -0.012664384208619595, -0.009946570731699467, 0.0351128950715065, -0.027890386059880257, 0.00975913554430008, 0.02654085122048855, 0.014232593588531017, -0.006578981876373291, 0.0123519916087389, -0.0033332258462905884, -0.004382864106446505, 0.03126422315835953, 0.0242916252464056, 0.017656413838267326, -0.003495669923722744, -0.0008247157093137503, 0.02611599676311016, -0.004901435226202011, 0.020530423149466515, -0.013945193029940128, 0.01894346997141838, 0.009715400636196136, 0.01753145642578602, 0.0031364187598228455, 0.018581094220280647, -0.026440884917974472, 0.016556791961193085, -0.00930304266512394, -0.0176938995718956, 0.004589043091982603, -0.021779991686344147, 0.011939633637666702, -0.009003146551549435, 0.01818123273551464, -0.0038955321069806814, -0.017906326800584793, -0.037012241780757904, 0.013857723213732243, -0.021455103531479836, 0.020093074068427086, -0.010633834637701511, 0.06017925590276718, -0.03938642144203186, 0.0360625684261322, -0.03813685476779938, -0.017981301993131638, -0.03648742288351059, 0.033338505774736404, -0.03998621553182602, 0.012395726516842842, 0.05073251202702522, -0.0009660732466727495, 0.03203895688056946, 0.0026022279635071754, -0.029414860531687737, -0.02185496687889099, 0.007616124581545591, 0.028490178287029266, 0.0017931318143382668, -0.001596324727870524, -0.0402861125767231, -0.014782404527068138, 0.014132628217339516, -0.00968416128307581, 0.01046514231711626, -0.0047327433712780476, 0.003230136586353183, 0.05118235573172569, -0.0032395082525908947, -0.015469667501747608, -0.0014963591238483787, 0.00005691397382179275, -0.004957666154950857, 0.03113926574587822, -0.007784816436469555, -0.011333593167364597, 0.020680371671915054, 0.004214172251522541, 0.003717468585819006, 0.007922269403934479, -0.016269391402602196, -0.014032662846148014, 0.0202805083245039, -0.028465187177062035, 0.047858502715826035, 0.016231903806328773, 0.011089926585555077, 0.01228951383382082, 0.013607809320092201, -0.026340920478105545, -0.01526973582804203, 0.009140598587691784, 0.001444033463485539, -0.03806187957525253, -0.007734833750873804, -0.02154257334768772, -0.02094278112053871, 0.0023273227270692587, -0.023404432460665703, 0.03913651034235954, -0.009409256279468536, 0.013082989491522312, 0.013395382091403008, -0.028065325692296028, -0.012539427727460861, 0.0008793843444436789, 0.014057653956115246, -0.031839024275541306, -0.03323854133486748, 0.033388491719961166, -0.004829585086554289, -0.003411323996260762, 0.018993452191352844, -0.014032662846148014, -0.02231730706989765, 0.045584287494421005, -0.02075534500181675, -0.0003686229174491018, 0.01267063245177269, 0.03148914501070976, 0.009490478783845901, 0.008834454230964184, -0.02090529352426529, -0.004382864106446505, -0.010727551765739918, 0.013307912275195122, -0.03116425685584545, -0.010858756490051746, 0.02779041975736618, 0.011414814740419388, -0.04243537038564682, -0.008890684694051743, -0.022192349657416344, -0.0050232685171067715, -0.007028826978057623, 0.0035081657115370035, 0.0027459284756332636, 0.02486642822623253, 0.010071528144180775, -0.017818856984376907, -0.0071287923492491245, -0.001988376956433058, -0.019280852749943733, -0.024641504511237144, 0.008584540337324142, 0.023629354313015938, -0.020992763340473175, -0.02260470762848854, -0.013957688584923744, 0.010034040547907352, 0.017781369388103485, -0.03171406686306, 0.016919167712330818, 0.006082278210669756, -0.004945170134305954, 0.011864660307765007, 0.03631248325109482, 0.02043045684695244, 0.007428688928484917, 0.03831179440021515, -0.00713504059240222, 0.0059198341332376, 0.025553690269589424, -0.01908092200756073, -0.006947604939341545, 0.016294382512569427, 0.009196829982101917, 0.0025991040747612715, 0.030714411288499832, -0.03801189735531807, -0.002513196086511016, -0.011489789001643658, -0.04031110554933548, -0.007766072638332844, -0.014345054514706135, -0.009140598587691784, -0.009696657769382, 0.06417787820100784, -0.014932352118194103, 0.01191464252769947, -0.03978628292679787, 0.0033207302913069725, -0.03051448054611683, 0.005135729443281889, -0.0038861604407429695, 0.003692477010190487, 0.009477982297539711, -0.0007548179128207266, -0.026465876027941704, -0.04043605923652649, 0.0010574479820206761, 0.02764047123491764, -0.010240219533443451, -0.006691443268209696, 0.03208893910050392, -0.007841046899557114, 0.028465187177062035, 0.006735178176313639, -0.01951827108860016, 0.008284644223749638, 0.01848112978041172, -0.0034300675615668297, 0.03806187957525253, 0.024166669696569443, 0.0020649132784456015, -0.013495347462594509, 0.027115652337670326, 0.009040633216500282, 0.017806362360715866, 0.003608131082728505, 0.0192558616399765, -0.025103846564888954, -0.02505386248230934, 0.025866083800792694, 0.011596002615988255, 0.041010864078998566, -0.015794554725289345, 0.032288867980241776, 0.02317950874567032, 0.013607809320092201, 0.0170816108584404, -0.006660203915089369, 0.012308256700634956, -0.013195451349020004, 0.013657791540026665, -0.004251659382134676, 0.005760514177381992, -0.014057653956115246, -0.00121208222117275, 0.04383488744497299, 0.0009652922162786126, 0.0238167904317379, 0.011321097612380981, -0.0008793843444436789, 0.013520339503884315, 0.0020836566109210253, -0.0118396682664752, 0.0068476395681500435, -0.038386765867471695, -0.029714755713939667, 0.02609100565314293, 0.03116425685584545, -0.010602595284581184, -0.01006527990102768, 0.028815066441893578, -0.00698509206995368, -0.026190971955657005, 0.00924056489020586, -0.018506120890378952, -0.018281197175383568, 0.014320063404738903, -0.014057653956115246, -0.01833118125796318, -0.019805671647191048, 0.01773138716816902, -0.0053419084288179874, 0.009902835823595524, -0.03468804061412811, 0.008678258396685123, 0.02272966504096985, 0.03156412020325661, -0.018256206065416336, -0.013382886536419392, 0.008390857838094234, -0.008878189139068127, -0.04730869084596634, -0.0032488799188286066, -0.02961479127407074, -0.027415549382567406, 0.015981990844011307, 0.017144089564681053, -0.009671665728092194, 0.021592555567622185, -0.006947604939341545, -0.01130235381424427, 0.017356516793370247, -0.0036112552043050528, -0.019605740904808044, 0.005173216573894024, 0.026340920478105545, 0.002844332018867135, 0.006697691045701504, -0.006422786042094231, -0.0054606175981462, -0.03911151736974716, -0.01418261043727398, 0.0013354771072044969, 0.00404235627502203, 0.02871510200202465, 0.044034820050001144, 0.005560582969337702, 0.013532835058867931, 0.01665675826370716, 0.01694415882229805, 0.005132605787366629, -0.010402663610875607, -0.04490951821208, 0.019430801272392273, 0.022254828363656998, 0.008297139778733253, -0.018256206065416336, -0.0118396682664752, -0.03278869763016701, -0.007278740871697664, -0.02259221114218235, 0.011446054093539715, -0.011870907619595528, -0.0372871458530426, 0.020105568692088127, 0.02928990311920643, 0.03263874724507332, 0.011952130123972893, -0.0029036866035312414, -0.006860135123133659, -0.03178904205560684, 0.041585665196180344, -0.026016032323241234, 0.011502284556627274, -0.005826116539537907, -0.03938642144203186, -0.011446054093539715, 0.032588765025138855, -0.01906842738389969, -0.021342642605304718, 0.00759738078340888, -0.009384265169501305, 0.016581783071160316, -0.04131075739860535, -0.008597036823630333, 0.007791064213961363, 0.01649431325495243, 0.012614401057362556, -0.003545652609318495, -0.028915032744407654, 0.03436315432190895, -0.022504741325974464, 0.006610221229493618, -0.0192558616399765, 0.032913655042648315, -0.008890684694051743, 0.005719903390854597, 0.04308514669537544, 0.005776133853942156, -0.017431490123271942, -0.0012659698259085417, -0.017019132152199745, -0.014232593588531017, 0.013682783581316471, -0.044959500432014465, 0.033338505774736404, -0.009577948600053787, -0.03751206770539284, -0.003386332653462887, 0.011720959097146988, 0.003295738948509097, -0.03191399946808815, 0.015282231383025646, 0.010027793236076832, -0.04690882936120033, 0.06662703305482864, 0.003255127929151058, -0.002806844888255, 0.017656413838267326, 0.03248880058526993, 0.02899000607430935, 0.004592166747897863, -0.027565497905015945, 0.02382928505539894, -0.003945515025407076, -0.0250413678586483, 0.0027443664148449898, 0.02501637674868107, 0.04398483783006668, -0.005313793197274208, 0.015457171946763992, 0.023104535415768623, -0.002886504866182804, -0.00968416128307581, -0.017468977719545364, -0.01183342095464468, -0.004507821053266525, -0.026790764182806015, 0.0005025611026212573, 0.007334971334785223, 0.02521630749106407, -0.0034050762187689543, 0.01450749859213829, -0.018056275323033333, 0.00477647827938199, -0.02794036827981472, 0.021017754450440407, 0.04211048409342766, 0.0074724238365888596, -0.004417227115482092, 0.03173905983567238, -0.014145123772323132, -0.006113517563790083, 0.05023268237709999, -0.0016572412569075823, -0.010202732868492603, 0.007447432726621628, -0.01206459105014801, 0.010958721861243248, 0.016406843438744545, 0.01427008118480444, 0.0306894201785326, 0.019618237391114235, -0.015594623982906342, -0.04490951821208, 0.0071975188329815865, -0.037462085485458374, -0.013782748952507973, 0.022092383354902267, -0.001988376956433058, 0.01953076757490635, 0.012283265590667725, 0.026940712705254555, -0.027515513822436333, -0.012095830403268337, 0.030614446848630905, 0.014332558959722519, 0.0028740093111991882, 0.02322949282824993, 0.02379179745912552, 0.018393659964203835, -0.033188559114933014, 0.015632111579179764, -0.022529734298586845, 0.015144779346883297, 0.009646674618124962, -0.020268013700842857, -0.013495347462594509, -0.013495347462594509, 0.05418132245540619, -0.02030549943447113, -0.012689375318586826, 0.011845916509628296, 0.005541839636862278, 0.010408911854028702, 0.0050014010630548, 0.02337944135069847, 0.01923087053000927, 0.006597725674510002, -0.03741210326552391, 0.0029833465814590454, 0.011995865032076836, -0.02779041975736618, -0.007272493094205856, -0.03286367282271385, 0.0036674856673926115, -0.022054897621273994, 0.034288179129362106, -0.006860135123133659, -0.030789386481046677, -0.00937801692634821, 0.01099620945751667, -0.000058378311223350465, 0.037337128072977066, 0.02566615305840969, 0.029364876449108124, -0.0015611805720254779, -0.0032738714944571257, 0.013807740062475204, -0.008659514598548412, 0.0027053174562752247, -0.009115607477724552, 0.020667875185608864, 0.023279475048184395, -0.011339840479195118, -0.0060854023322463036, -0.022954586893320084, 0.014457516372203827, -0.014544986188411713, -0.0186435729265213, -0.020105568692088127, 0.02029300481081009, -0.03928645700216293, 0.0035519006196409464, 0.015956999734044075, -0.014894865453243256, 0.018243711441755295, -0.006922613363713026, -0.02519131638109684, -0.03681230917572975, 0.004598414991050959, 0.019893141463398933, -0.02550370804965496, 0.026815755292773247, 0.036862291395664215, -0.028665117919445038, 0.012739358469843864, 0.036862291395664215, 0.0326637402176857, -0.012177051976323128, 0.04993278533220291, 0.018368666991591454, 0.03156412020325661, -0.01166472863405943, 0.021255172789096832, 0.010983713902533054, 0.008584540337324142, 0.031214239075779915, 0.013395382091403008, -0.006697691045701504, 0.04428473487496376, 0.020967772230505943, 0.032738715410232544, -0.006491512060165405, -0.03968631848692894, -0.0028224645648151636, 0.017056619748473167, -0.01921837404370308, 0.00893442053347826, -0.01244570966809988, 0.03813685476779938, -0.004026737064123154, -0.04076094925403595, 0.0015400940319523215, -0.014070149511098862, 0.003530033165588975, -0.022392280399799347, -0.009428000077605247, 0.022867117077112198, 0.0046171583235263824, -0.026365911588072777, -0.017493968829512596, -0.02197992242872715, 0.036437440663576126, -0.005657424684613943, -0.0002608475915621966, -0.052731823176145554, 0.012302009388804436, -0.017144089564681053, 0.025103846564888954, 0.0010137130739167333, -0.013470356352627277, -0.026140987873077393, -0.03583764657378197, 0.0049295504577457905, 0.00387366465292871, 0.023629354313015938, -0.013645295985043049, 0.038236819207668304, 0.007278740871697664, -0.0038455494213849306, -0.02963978238403797, -0.01601947844028473, 0.03621251508593559, 0.033813342452049255, 0.021467600017786026, -0.00434537697583437, -0.029214927926659584, -0.031189247965812683, 0.031039299443364143, 0.013582817278802395, 0.01191464252769947, 0.014482507482171059, 0.030489489436149597, 0.038786631077528, -0.01006527990102768, -0.01389520987868309, 0.01145854964852333, -0.007653611712157726, -0.020705362781882286, 0.016594279557466507, 0.0017165957251563668 ]
12.960643
6.903777
2024-07-01
12
2024ApJ...969...27B
[ "galaxy formation simulations", "stellar mass", "deep James Webb Space Telescope", "pre-JWST analyses", "ALMA observations", "F560W observations", "James Webb Space", "Deep Imaging Survey", "new JWST photometry", "Atacama Large Millimeter" ]
[ "Galaxy structure", "High-redshift galaxies", "Galaxy evolution", "James Webb Space Telescope", "Millimeter astronomy", "622", "734", "594", "2291", "1061", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
57
[ "10.3847/1538-4357/ad43e5", "10.48550/arXiv.2308.16895" ]
[ "Boogaard, Leindert A.", "Gillman, Steven", "Melinder, Jens", "Walter, Fabian", "Colina, Luis", "Östlin, Göran", "Caputi, Karina I.", "Iani, Edoardo", "Pérez-González, Pablo", "van der Werf, Paul", "Greve, Thomas R.", "Wright, Gillian", "Alonso-Herrero, Almudena", "Álvarez-Márquez, Javier", "Annunziatella, Marianna", "Bik, Arjan", "Bosman, Sarah", "Costantin, Luca", "Crespo Gómez, Alejandro", "Dicken, Dan", "Eckart, Andreas", "Hjorth, Jens", "Jermann, Iris", "Labiano, Alvaro", "Langeroodi, Danial", "Meyer, Romain A.", "Moutard, Thibaud", "Peißker, Florian", "Pye, John P.", "Rinaldi, Pierluigi", "Tikkanen, Tuomo V.", "Topinka, Martin", "Henning, Thomas" ]
[ "Max Planck Institute for Astronomy, Königstuhl 17, 69117 Heidelberg, Germany", "Cosmic Dawn Center (DAWN), Denmark; DTU Space, Technical University of Denmark, Elektrovej, Building 328, 2800Kgs. Lyngby, Denmark", "Department of Astronomy, Stockholm University, Oscar Klein Centre, AlbaNova University Centre, 106 91 Stockholm, Sweden", "Max Planck Institute for Astronomy, Königstuhl 17, 69117 Heidelberg, Germany; National Radio Astronomy Observatory, Pete V. Domenici Array Science Center, P.O. Box O, Socorro, NM 87801, USA", "Centro de Astrobiología (CAB), CSIC-INTA, Ctra. de Ajalvir km 4, Torrejón de Ardoz, E-28850 Madrid, Spain", "Department of Astronomy, Stockholm University, Oscar Klein Centre, AlbaNova University Centre, 106 91 Stockholm, Sweden", "Kapteyn Astronomical Institute, University of Groningen, P.O. Box 800, 9700AV Groningen, The Netherlands", "Kapteyn Astronomical Institute, University of Groningen, P.O. Box 800, 9700AV Groningen, The Netherlands", "Centro de Astrobiología (CAB), CSIC-INTA, Ctra. de Ajalvir km 4, Torrejón de Ardoz, E-28850 Madrid, Spain", "Leiden Observatory, Leiden University, P.O. Box 9513, NL-2300 RA Leiden, The Netherlands", "Cosmic Dawn Center (DAWN), Denmark; DTU Space, Technical University of Denmark, Elektrovej, Building 328, 2800Kgs. Lyngby, Denmark; Department of Physics and Astronomy, University College London, Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, UK", "UK Astronomy Technology Centre, Royal Observatory Edinburgh, Blackford Hill, Edinburgh EH9 3HJ, UK", "Centro de Astrobiología (CAB), CSIC-INTA, Camino Bajo del Castillo s/n, 28692 Villanueva de la Cañada, Madrid, Spain", "Centro de Astrobiología (CAB), CSIC-INTA, Ctra. de Ajalvir km 4, Torrejón de Ardoz, E-28850 Madrid, Spain", "Centro de Astrobiología (CAB), CSIC-INTA, Ctra. de Ajalvir km 4, Torrejón de Ardoz, E-28850 Madrid, Spain", "Department of Astronomy, Stockholm University, Oscar Klein Centre, AlbaNova University Centre, 106 91 Stockholm, Sweden", "Max Planck Institute for Astronomy, Königstuhl 17, 69117 Heidelberg, Germany; Institute for Theoretical Physics, Heidelberg University, Philosophenweg 12, D-69120, Heidelberg, Germany", "Centro de Astrobiología (CAB), CSIC-INTA, Ctra. de Ajalvir km 4, Torrejón de Ardoz, E-28850 Madrid, Spain", "Centro de Astrobiología (CAB), CSIC-INTA, Ctra. de Ajalvir km 4, Torrejón de Ardoz, E-28850 Madrid, Spain", "UK Astronomy Technology Centre, Royal Observatory Edinburgh, Blackford Hill, Edinburgh EH9 3HJ, UK", "I.Physikalisches Institut der Universität zu Köln, Zülpicher Str. 77, 50937 Köln, Germany; Max Planck Institute for Radiosastronomie, Auf dem Hügel 69, 53121 Bonn, Germany", "DARK, Niels Bohr Institute, University of Copenhagen, Jagtvej 128, 2200 Copenhagen, Denmark", "Cosmic Dawn Center (DAWN), Denmark; DTU Space, Technical University of Denmark, Elektrovej, Building 328, 2800Kgs. Lyngby, Denmark", "Centro de Astrobiología (CAB), CSIC-INTA, Camino Bajo del Castillo s/n, 28692 Villanueva de la Cañada, Madrid, Spain; Telespazio UK for the European Space Agency, ESAC, Camino Bajo del Castillo s/n, 28692 Villanueva de la Cañada, Spain", "DARK, Niels Bohr Institute, University of Copenhagen, Jagtvej 128, 2200 Copenhagen, Denmark", "Departement d'Astronomie, University of Geneva, Chemin Pegasi 51, 1290 Versoix, Switzerland", "Aix Marseille Univ, CNRS, CNES, LAM, Marseille, France", "I.Physikalisches Institut der Universität zu Köln, Zülpicher Str. 77, 50937 Köln, Germany", "School of Physics &amp; Astronomy, Space Research Centre, Space Park Leicester, University of Leicester, 92 Corporation Road, Leicester LE4 5SP, UK", "Kapteyn Astronomical Institute, University of Groningen, P.O. Box 800, 9700AV Groningen, The Netherlands", "School of Physics &amp; Astronomy, Space Research Centre, Space Park Leicester, University of Leicester, 92 Corporation Road, Leicester LE4 5SP, UK", "Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies, Astronomy &amp; Astrophysics Section, 31 Fitzwilliam Place, Dublin 2, Ireland", "Max Planck Institute for Astronomy, Königstuhl 17, 69117 Heidelberg, Germany" ]
[ "2023arXiv230907834F", "2024A&A...686A..85A", "2024ApJ...963...97I", "2024ApJ...969...12R", "2024ApJ...969L..28L", "2024MNRAS.528.5019H", "2024arXiv240218672C", "2024arXiv240507986P", "2024arXiv240515972A", "2024arXiv240518462H", "2024arXiv240618207I", "2024arXiv240700153C" ]
[ "1963BAAA....6...41S", "1983ApJ...266..713O", "1983QJRAS..24..267H", "2002AJ....124..266P", "2003PASP..115..763C", "2004ApJS..154...10F", "2005ASPC..347...29T", "2007CSE.....9...90H", "2007CSE.....9c..21P", "2008MNRAS.388.1595D", "2010MNRAS.402..724P", "2010MNRAS.409..421G", "2011A&A...533A.119E", "2012ApJ...753..114W", "2012ApJS..203...24V", "2012SPIE.8442E..3DP", "2013ApJ...768...74T", "2013ApJ...778...23G", "2014ARA&A..52..415M", "2014ApJ...782...79W", "2014ApJ...783...84S", "2014ApJ...788...28V", "2014ApJ...795..104W", "2014SPIE.9143E..3XP", "2015ApJ...806..110D", "2015ApJS..220....1A", "2015ApJS..221...23L", "2016ApJ...817L...9N", "2016ApJ...820...83S", "2016ApJ...833...67W", "2016ApJS..225...27M", "2017A&A...605A..18C", "2017A&A...608A...1B", "2017A&A...608A...2I", "2017ApJ...850..208W", "2017ApJS..228....2L", "2017MNRAS.466..861D", "2018A&A...620A.152F", "2018ApJ...853..179T", "2018PASJ...70..105H", "2019ApJ...872....7R", "2019ApJ...882..136A", "2019ApJ...882..138D", "2019ApJ...882..139G", "2019ApJ...882..140B", "2019MNRAS.488.1779C", "2019MNRAS.490.3234N", "2019MNRAS.490.4956G", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020ARA&A..58..661F", "2020ApJ...897...91G", "2020ApJ...901...74T", "2020ApJ...901...79A", "2020ApJ...902..109B", "2020ApJ...902..110D", "2020NatMe..17..261V", "2020Natur.585..357H", "2021PASP..133a4504G", "2022ApJ...935..167A", "2022ApJ...937L..33S", "2022ApJ...939L...7C", "2022ApJ...940L..24I", "2022ApJ...941L..37M", "2022ApJS..258...11W", "2022MNRAS.510.3321P", "2023A&A...670A...4B", "2023A&A...673A..30P", "2023A&A...676A..26G", "2023A&A...678A..83M", "2023A&A...680A..95Y", "2023A&A...680A..96A", "2023ApJ...945..111B", "2023ApJ...946L..12B", "2023ApJ...946L..16P", "2023ApJ...949L..11M", "2023ApJ...952..143R", "2023ApJS..268...64W", "2023ApJS..269...16R", "2023MNRAS.525.2864O", "2023PASP..135d8003W", "2024ApJ...960...53V", "2024ApJ...965L...6B", "2024ApJ...969...90P" ]
29096793
2401.06211
Tracing the quenching journey across cosmic time
We present the latest version of the GAlaxy Evolution and Assembly (GAEA) theoretical model of galaxy formation. Our new model now combines (i) an updated treatment of feedback from active galactic nuclei, including an improved modelling of cold gas accretion on super-massive black holes and an explicit implementation of quasar winds; and (ii) a treatment for both cold and hot gas stripping from satellite galaxies. We show that our latest model version predicts specific star formation rate distributions that are in remarkable agreement with observational measurements in the local Universe. Our updated model predicts quenched fractions that are in very nice agreement with observational measurements up to z ∼ 3 − 4, and a turn-over of the number densities of quenched galaxies at low stellar masses that is in qualitative agreement with current observational estimates. We show that the main reasons for the improved behaviour with respect to previous renditions of our model are the updated treatment for satellites at low galaxy masses (&lt; 10<SUP>10</SUP> M<SUB>⊙</SUB>) and the inclusion of quasar winds at intermediate to large stellar masses (&gt; 10<SUP>10</SUP> M<SUB>⊙</SUB>). However, we show that the better treatment of the star formation threshold, due to our explicit partitioning of the cold gas in its atomic and molecular components, also plays an important role in suppressing excessive residual star formation in massive galaxies. While our analysis is based on a selection of quiescent galaxies that takes advantage of the information about their star formation rate, we demonstrate that the impact of a different (colour-colour) selection is not significant up to z ∼ 3, at least for galaxies above the completeness limits of current surveys. Our new model predicts number densities of massive quiescent galaxies at z &gt; 3 that are the largest among recently published state-of-the-art models. Yet, our model predictions still appear to be below post-JWST observational measurements. We show that the expected cosmic variance is large, and can easily accommodate some of the most recent measurements.
[ 0.021524852141737938, 0.04880266636610031, 0.028423530980944633, -0.010482091456651688, -0.034347131848335266, 0.030958734452724457, 0.03459090366959572, 0.0018160833278670907, -0.014016750268638134, 0.02995928004384041, -0.020306004211306572, -0.017953628674149513, -0.09004847705364227, -0.008964626118540764, 0.025693312287330627, 0.03385959193110466, 0.007306993007659912, -0.0071180714294314384, 0.005234951619058847, 0.0343715101480484, -0.02218303084373474, -0.024571971967816353, -0.00401305640116334, 0.028813563287258148, -0.0704006478190422, -0.02000129222869873, -0.011310908012092113, 0.016698215156793594, -0.0003818421682808548, -0.03729674220085144, 0.028106631711125374, -0.006587872747331858, -0.03624853491783142, -0.00018682652444113046, -0.06669535487890244, 0.06913305073976517, 0.018892141059041023, -0.011170740239322186, -0.05046030133962631, -0.00665490934625268, 0.002551962621510029, 0.02791161648929119, 0.005609747022390366, 0.03208007663488388, -0.019257795065641403, 0.025327658280730247, -0.01346826832741499, -0.02348719723522663, -0.038564346730709076, -0.05163039639592171, -0.05543319880962372, -0.006734134163707495, 0.019306549802422523, -0.025644559413194656, -0.004457936156541109, -0.023767532780766487, -0.015162467025220394, 0.007703118491917849, -0.01917247660458088, 0.010786803439259529, -0.022792454808950424, 0.014955262653529644, 0.011981274001300335, 0.02214646525681019, -0.024718234315514565, -0.03249448537826538, -0.0035072346217930317, 0.019733145833015442, -0.014467723667621613, 0.03702859580516815, -0.045024238526821136, -0.02520577423274517, -0.013334195129573345, -0.014613986015319824, 0.03307953104376793, -0.01958688534796238, -0.01505277119576931, -0.011469358578324318, -0.03329892456531525, 0.01541842520236969, -0.009439976885914803, -0.0036961562000215054, 0.010171284899115562, -0.036272913217544556, -0.007203390821814537, -0.012834467925131321, 0.026034589856863022, -0.013224499300122261, -0.06810921430587769, 0.03610227257013321, 0.029252348467707634, 0.0016134498873725533, 0.0029633238445967436, -0.01231645792722702, 0.0012165624648332596, -0.034664031118154526, 0.05933351442217827, -0.050655316561460495, 0.09351000934839249, 0.006983998231589794, 0.03056870400905609, 0.002366088330745697, -0.01937968097627163, -0.07790875434875488, 0.07098569720983505, -0.026083344593644142, 0.005195338744670153, -0.013517022132873535, -0.009823913685977459, 0.018209585919976234, 0.0401000939309597, -0.02114701084792614, 0.006225265562534332, 0.0117496931925416, -0.0788838341832161, -0.0308856051415205, -0.07298460602760315, 0.007818909361958504, -0.007709212601184845, 0.02098855935037136, 0.03259199112653732, -0.02593708224594593, 0.01697855070233345, 0.05343428999185562, 0.055969491600990295, -0.01750265434384346, 0.0043726167641580105, -0.007294804323464632, -0.06888928264379501, 0.034566525369882584, 0.024766989052295685, 0.01447991281747818, 0.04024635627865791, -0.005695066414773464, -0.0503140389919281, -0.01578407920897007, -0.027302192524075508, -0.019489377737045288, 0.008464897982776165, -0.001759711536578834, 0.009787348099052906, 0.01502839382737875, -0.02329218201339245, 0.016369126737117767, 0.018051136285066605, 0.013261064887046814, -0.024754799902439117, -0.01917247660458088, -0.014882132411003113, 0.021524852141737938, -0.013846111483871937, -0.002660135505720973, -0.013821734115481377, -0.04495110735297203, -0.0015890728682279587, 0.0008349107811227441, 0.003039501840248704, -0.005009464453905821, 0.030251802876591682, -0.015199032612144947, -0.022000202909111977, 0.02395036071538925, -0.049875251948833466, 0.005210574716329575, -0.003912501502782106, 0.03093435801565647, -0.05041154846549034, 0.011920331977307796, -0.07825002819299698, -0.0474131815135479, 0.028057876974344254, 0.02281683124601841, 0.0003349927137605846, -0.04543864727020264, 0.013919242657721043, 0.026010213419795036, -0.02421850711107254, -0.03683358058333397, -0.035492848604917526, 0.0024712139274924994, -0.012688206508755684, 0.04317159205675125, -0.014699305407702923, -0.019550319761037827, -0.03244572877883911, 0.019574696198105812, 0.0011655231937766075, 0.028667300939559937, -0.0025976693723350763, -0.026400243863463402, -0.024242883548140526, 0.020537586882710457, 0.015479367226362228, 0.04687688872218132, -0.04631621763110161, -0.0352003239095211, 0.033518314361572266, 0.05182541161775589, 0.01154248882085085, 0.032470107078552246, -0.0032147110905498266, 0.002370659029111266, -0.0010299264686182141, -0.07332588732242584, -0.007349652703851461, -0.041806481778621674, 0.019623450934886932, -0.012651640921831131, -0.02089105173945427, 0.006042438093572855, 0.04512174800038338, 0.009305903688073158, 0.016734780743718147, 0.015064959414303303, -0.014199577271938324, 0.025668935850262642, -0.06645158678293228, 0.022694947198033333, 0.04229402169585228, 0.0519716702401638, -0.024913249537348747, 0.007514196913689375, 0.023353124037384987, 0.03256761282682419, 0.03517594933509827, -0.015125901438295841, 0.04119705781340599, -0.02240242250263691, 0.001173902885057032, 0.0011670468375086784, 0.007703118491917849, 0.025912705808877945, -0.02386504039168358, -0.009281526319682598, -0.014748059213161469, -0.042318396270275116, 0.0024376956280320883, 0.047998227179050446, 0.005262375343590975, -0.03169004246592522, -0.037174858152866364, 0.043878521770238876, -0.020330382511019707, 0.003103491384536028, -0.0032847949769347906, 0.016344750300049782, 0.0019303503213450313, -0.010256604291498661, 0.029106086120009422, 0.008458804339170456, 0.06518398225307465, -0.03754051402211189, -0.0008097720565274358, -0.004421370569616556, -0.008867118507623672, -0.008891494944691658, -0.02047664299607277, 0.04361037537455559, -0.028350401669740677, -0.0010482091456651688, -0.0629413053393364, -0.03490780293941498, -0.00239655957557261, 0.025449542328715324, -0.010774615220725536, 0.07181451469659805, 0.03646792843937874, -0.003607789520174265, -0.004994228947907686, 0.010299264453351498, -0.010372394695878029, -0.01708824746310711, 0.022487742826342583, -0.03244572877883911, -0.02849666215479374, 0.020391324535012245, -0.00841005053371191, 0.0470719039440155, 0.018770257011055946, -0.007684835698455572, 0.03244572877883911, -0.04122143238782883, 0.04248903691768646, 0.03895437717437744, 0.000002603739858386689, 0.029642378911376, 0.0026814653538167477, 0.008154092356562614, 0.008141903206706047, -0.014114257879555225, 0.08882962912321091, -0.04400040581822395, -0.0117496931925416, 0.015162467025220394, -0.021171387284994125, -0.00240265391767025, 0.038515590131282806, 0.02895982563495636, -0.02354814112186432, 0.02359689399600029, 0.04751068726181984, 0.028106631711125374, -0.004329957067966461, 0.0008250076207332313, -0.017210131511092186, 0.010274887084960938, 0.038881246000528336, 0.010707578621804714, -0.001983674941584468, 0.061186160892248154, 0.020720412954688072, 0.020598528906702995, -0.009385128505527973, 0.043098460882902145, -0.05577447637915611, -0.04558490961790085, -0.02280464395880699, 0.03895437717437744, 0.012133629992604256, 0.008885400369763374, -0.015259974636137486, -0.03151940554380417, -0.03056870400905609, 0.018989648669958115, 0.0002510064805392176, -0.04283031448721886, -0.007770155090838671, -0.02620522864162922, -0.030227426439523697, -0.002110130386427045, 0.01010424830019474, -0.008275976404547691, 0.02202458120882511, -0.002487973077222705, -0.0019364445470273495, -0.00940341129899025, 0.0016881042392924428, 0.053726814687252045, 0.01702730357646942, -0.02156141772866249, -0.03722361475229263, 0.028618548065423965, -0.0003328978200443089, -0.011987368576228619, 0.016320372000336647, -0.0011906620347872376, 0.025668935850262642, 0.0273997001349926, 0.06367260962724686, -0.008854929357767105, 0.017124813050031662, -0.00898290891200304, 0.0273997001349926, -0.01692979596555233, 0.062161240726709366, -0.02959362603724003, 0.041855234652757645, -0.028423530980944633, 0.00934856291860342, 0.026058966293931007, 0.0035011405125260353, 0.03661419078707695, 0.03042244166135788, -0.01683228835463524, -0.027302192524075508, 0.015869399532675743, -0.03551722690463066, 0.04302532970905304, -0.0029663708992302418, -0.030909981578588486, -0.025742067024111748, 0.018782446160912514, -0.0315437838435173, 0.014540854841470718, -0.03788179159164429, -0.029764264822006226, 0.021012937650084496, 0.012931975536048412, 0.001857219380326569, 0.01443115808069706, 0.02552267350256443, 0.018221775069832802, -0.02329218201339245, -0.033055152744054794, 0.01445553544908762, 0.012615075334906578, -0.053629305213689804, -0.011975180357694626, -0.07473974674940109, 0.014114257879555225, -0.02827727049589157, 0.02395036071538925, 0.0007671123603358865, 0.007770155090838671, 0.03439588472247124, 0.004576773848384619, 0.021866129711270332, 0.05124036222696304, 0.01662508398294449, 0.041075173765420914, -0.027058422565460205, -0.008666007779538631, -0.012200666591525078, -0.07118071615695953, -0.02813100814819336, -0.003266512183472514, 0.0026311876717954874, 0.0511428564786911, 0.0322994664311409, -0.03890562430024147, 0.047169413417577744, -0.02348719723522663, 0.0259858351200819, -0.04651123285293579, 0.006661003455519676, 0.016954174265265465, -0.036443550139665604, 0.012066593393683434, -0.029764264822006226, 0.060942392796278, 0.001631732564419508, -0.04463420808315277, 0.007306993007659912, -0.021268894895911217, -0.05406808853149414, -0.037735529243946075, 0.01766110584139824, 0.007977358996868134, -0.02485230751335621, -0.05582323297858238, -0.0327138751745224, 0.03166566789150238, -0.014504289254546165, -0.01195689756423235, 0.014918697997927666, -0.012517567723989487, 0.000002591837073850911, -0.03790616616606712, 0.051484134048223495, -0.01823396421968937, 0.036272913217544556, -0.015515932813286781, -0.015479367226362228, -0.036126650869846344, 0.016588518396019936, 0.01205440517514944, 0.0023264759220182896, 0.03208007663488388, -0.014309274032711983, -0.048046983778476715, -0.014687116257846355, 0.024523219093680382, 0.0014390022261068225, -0.00875132717192173, -0.08410049974918365, -0.021805187687277794, 0.032153207808732986, -0.04392727464437485, 0.030861226841807365, -0.08712324500083923, 0.03073934279382229, -0.023511575534939766, -0.027204683050513268, 0.03780866041779518, -0.03290889039635658, 0.011390132829546928, -0.00021939260477665812, 0.025230150669813156, 0.006246595177799463, 0.0008052013581618667, 0.027277814224362373, -0.06172245368361473, -0.0026799417100846767, -0.0030257897451519966, -0.011792353354394436, 0.0034493394196033478, -0.03863747790455818, 0.013382948935031891, 0.07615361362695694, 0.02313373237848282, 0.031592536717653275, -0.002174119930714369, 0.035712242126464844, 0.015369671396911144, 0.007398406509310007, 0.034980934113264084, -0.023584706708788872, 0.01033583004027605, 0.014699305407702923, -0.015918152406811714, 0.006728040054440498, -0.004668187350034714, 0.035492848604917526, -0.011237776838243008, 0.04943646863102913, -0.008245505392551422, -0.04270842671394348, -0.021695490926504135, -0.012517567723989487, 0.026083344593644142, 0.03156815841794014, 0.014028938487172127, 0.048827044665813446, 0.011786258779466152, 0.017575785517692566, 0.004537160973995924, -0.04302532970905304, 0.014528666622936726, 0.031909435987472534, 0.009135264903306961, -0.027302192524075508, 0.012182383798062801, 0.009927515871822834, -0.026595259085297585, 0.031056243926286697, 0.05172790214419365, -0.006386762484908104, 0.05016777664422989, 0.04170897230505943, -0.013870488852262497, 0.00684992503374815, -0.004156270995736122, -0.012005651369690895, 0.0026022400707006454, -0.003063878742977977, -0.006374574266374111, -0.011767975986003876, -0.08215034753084183, -0.020964182913303375, -0.017380770295858383, 0.017356393858790398, -0.0014161488506942987, 0.008812270127236843, -0.02052539773285389, -0.023365313187241554, -0.013541399501264095, -0.00626487797126174, -0.018782446160912514, -0.011499829590320587, -0.03932003304362297, 0.032372597604990005, 0.018258340656757355, -0.01583283394575119, -0.0006936006247997284, -0.003872889094054699, 0.04302532970905304, -0.007849380373954773, -0.012663829140365124, 0.0017094340873882174, 0.033201415091753006, 0.023475009948015213, -0.02515701949596405, 0.005298940930515528, 0.011085420846939087, -0.011822824366390705, 0.0005027747247368097, -0.029032954946160316, 0.001787135610356927, -0.013687660917639732, -0.006904772948473692, -0.007983453571796417, 0.010689295828342438, -0.03515157103538513, 0.028521040454506874, -0.017892686650156975, -0.05582323297858238, -0.010134720243513584, -0.0061856526881456375, -0.00576819758862257, 0.031129373237490654, -0.03283575922250748, -0.025230150669813156, 0.004000868182629347, -0.005493956618010998, -0.006953526753932238, -0.00932418555021286, -0.009513107128441334, 0.0392712764441967, -0.0132854413241148, -0.00645989365875721, -0.017575785517692566, -0.01729545183479786, -0.0152355981990695, 0.03515157103538513, -0.06630532443523407, 0.0045889620669186115, 0.009269338101148605, -0.0003142342029605061, 0.018307095393538475, 0.029618002474308014, 0.005917506292462349, -0.01242005918174982, -0.0065208361484110355, -0.0029191405046731234, -0.013151368126273155, 0.005603652913123369, 0.00898290891200304, 0.010646635666489601, -0.02254868485033512, 0.022731512784957886, -0.015333105809986591, 0.00037212949246168137, -0.04743755981326103, -0.016381315886974335, -0.04395165294408798, 0.013797357678413391, -0.0000992218338069506, -0.02437695674598217, -0.013614530675113201, -0.011182929389178753, 0.011048855260014534, 0.008282070979475975, -0.04141645133495331, -0.019757524132728577, -0.020805733278393745, -0.02895982563495636, 0.0013910101260989904, -0.018343660980463028, 0.036541059613227844, -0.01070148404687643, 0.013151368126273155, 0.012249420396983624, 0.023621270433068275, -0.0008928060415200889, 0.051435377448797226, 0.003744910005480051, -0.02620522864162922, -0.022670570760965347, 0.00278049660846591, -0.027229061350226402, 0.012462719343602657, -0.027326568961143494, 0.026327112689614296, 0.005698113702237606, -0.007849380373954773, -0.009927515871822834, 0.0030760671943426132, 0.021524852141737938, -0.0097142169252038, -0.014748059213161469, 0.013687660917639732, -0.001665250863879919, 0.026010213419795036, -0.01031145267188549, 0.022792454808950424, 0.025961458683013916, -0.014199577271938324, -0.005423872731626034, -0.026546506211161613, -0.015576875768601894, -0.021500475704669952, -0.03705297410488129, 0.009464353322982788, 0.007398406509310007, 0.008111432194709778, -0.01242005918174982, -0.00914135854691267, 0.007483725901693106, -0.013663284480571747, 0.027302192524075508, -0.023670025169849396, -0.013090426102280617, 0.015357483178377151, 0.00556099321693182, 0.002970941597595811, 0.011755787767469883, -0.014979640021920204, -0.0012858845293521881, -0.0075081028044223785, 0.0234993863850832, 0.05850469693541527, -0.01541842520236969, 0.0032086169812828302, 0.01708824746310711, 0.00802611280232668, 0.002108606742694974, -0.00914135854691267, -0.07951763272285461, -0.02625398337841034, 0.00626487797126174, -0.01890433020889759, 0.03490780293941498, -0.015747513622045517, -0.005688972305506468, -0.0031903341878205538, -0.010975725017488003, -0.008580688387155533, -0.021597983315587044, 0.025693312287330627, 0.0027713552117347717, 0.004110564477741718, 0.0070815058425068855, 0.006441610865294933, 0.032226335257291794, -0.011444981209933758, -0.010250510647892952, -0.0012226566905155778, 0.009634992107748985, -0.022280538454651833, -0.036687321960926056, 0.018294906243681908, 0.023974737152457237, 0.030178671702742577, -0.00605767359957099, -0.00814799778163433, -0.01033583004027605, -0.0265708826482296, 0.011633902788162231, -0.016332561150193214, -0.042172133922576904, 0.04536551609635353, 0.03364020213484764, 0.008032207377254963, -0.013248875737190247, 0.0005328650586307049, -0.02198801562190056, 0.001986721996217966, 0.03746738284826279, -0.013833923265337944, -0.011292625218629837, -0.009305903688073158, -0.003650449216365814, -0.06781669706106186, 0.006170417182147503, 0.005902270786464214, -0.06269752979278564, 0.006161275785416365, 0.026912160217761993, -0.03137314319610596, -0.04543864727020264, 0.014918697997927666, 0.006910867057740688, 0.021171387284994125, -0.02406005561351776, -0.0013254970544949174, 0.027326568961143494, -0.010116437450051308, -0.027375321835279465, 0.014297084882855415, 0.030495572835206985, 0.005926647689193487, -0.011524206027388573, 0.0053934017196297646, 0.04509736970067024, 0.007739683613181114, -0.017368581146001816, 0.0034706692676991224, 0.01281009055674076, -0.0029663708992302418, 0.0062770661897957325, 0.01091478206217289, 0.009482636116445065, 0.034200869500637054, 0.02181737683713436, 0.011006196029484272, -0.03454214707016945, 0.02661963738501072, -0.030495572835206985, 0.027887238189578056, 0.018977461382746696, 0.032738253474235535, 0.015454990789294243, 0.01890433020889759, 0.03120250441133976, -0.024340391159057617, 0.0022929576225578785, 0.002746978309005499, -0.014674928039312363, 0.034030232578516006, -0.00556099321693182, -0.02395036071538925, 0.0022487742826342583, 0.014345838688313961, 0.0210495013743639, 0.005981495603919029, 0.004150176886469126, 0.015040582045912743, 0.012724771164357662, -0.03364020213484764, 0.01947718858718872, 0.012846656143665314, -0.016966361552476883, 0.007520291022956371, -0.02130546048283577, -0.011371850036084652, -0.0009347039158456028, 0.028886694461107254, -0.01129871979355812, -0.025547049939632416, 0.00013502548972610384, 0.001729240408167243, 0.028033500537276268, -0.01630818471312523, 0.034932177513837814, -0.010360206477344036, 0.0003020457224920392, -0.01833147183060646, -0.07542230188846588, 0.025132643058896065, 0.01151201780885458, 0.03203132003545761, 0.009001191705465317, 0.04219651222229004, -0.008318636566400528, -0.013261064887046814, 0.01594253070652485, -0.008708667941391468, 0.022048957645893097, -0.04677937924861908, 0.002594622317701578, 0.03739425167441368, 0.034249626100063324, -0.06250251829624176, -0.018063325434923172, 0.005652406718581915, -0.003394491272047162, -0.0008829028811305761, 0.010146908462047577, 0.018563052639365196, -0.0005004893755540252, -0.004905862733721733, -0.014236142858862877, -0.0022289680782705545, -0.014601796865463257, 0.008915872313082218, 0.017929252237081528, 0.0062770661897957325, -0.01262726355344057, -0.03078809566795826, -0.0032360409386456013, 0.04719378799200058, -0.0018038947600871325, -0.010360206477344036, 0.004866249859333038, 0.03515157103538513, -0.042318396270275116, -0.012554132379591465, -0.004631621763110161, -0.04083140194416046, 0.043147213757038116, 0.02443789876997471, 0.01408988144248724, -0.006170417182147503, 0.008915872313082218, 0.02260962687432766, 0.017002927139401436, -0.002274674829095602, -0.00441527646034956, 0.021061690524220467, -0.03722361475229263, 0.0014473818009719253, -0.012353022582828999, 0.009470447897911072, 0.0388568677008152, -0.013431703671813011, -0.03449339419603348, -0.007264333311468363, -0.02464510314166546, 0.034347131848335266, -0.01912372186779976, -0.012328646145761013, -0.015979094430804253, -0.009933609515428543, -0.005460438318550587, 0.04131894186139107, -0.01781955547630787, -0.004144082777202129, -0.005868752487003803, 0.033518314361572266, 0.003775381250306964, 0.0044061350636184216, 0.000686363666318357, -0.027692222967743874, -0.0269852913916111, 0.020427890121936798, -0.0490708127617836, 0.018112078309059143, -0.020549774169921875, -0.013602341525256634, 0.012359117157757282, -0.028764808550477028, -0.01760016195476055, 0.03093435801565647, 0.017271073535084724, -0.01408988144248724, 0.01645444519817829, 0.003680920461192727, 0.03142189607024193, -0.026595259085297585, 0.003842417849227786, 0.0022487742826342583, -0.0222927276045084, 0.006398951169103384, 0.014004562050104141, -0.015759702771902084, 0.02218303084373474, 0.0006242786184884608, -0.026522129774093628, -0.007788437884300947, -0.016332561150193214, -0.037321120500564575, 0.042367152869701385, -0.03739425167441368, 0.009927515871822834, 0.005323317833244801, 0.01629599556326866, 0.0479007214307785, 0.05514067783951759, 0.030861226841807365, -0.01828271709382534, 0.004573726560920477, 0.05007027089595795, 0.006197841372340918, -0.040807027369737625, 0.004320815671235323, -0.001154858386144042, -0.01443115808069706, 0.01614973321557045, 0.010902593843638897, -0.019148100167512894, 0.00625268928706646, 0.016990739852190018, -0.00467428145930171, -0.0041776010766625404, 0.004640763159841299, 0.0015296540223062038, 0.044512324035167694, -0.0034432450775057077, -0.013273253105580807, 0.040612008422613144, 0.010445525869727135, -0.013943619094789028, -0.04197711870074272, 0.010451620444655418, 0.03634604439139366, 0.015333105809986591, 0.005298940930515528, 0.00006475129339378327, -0.00864772591739893, 0.009817819111049175, -0.0036992032546550035, -0.012249420396983624, 0.007977358996868134, -0.0052684699185192585, -0.05465313792228699, 0.04848576709628105, 0.011243871413171291, 0.00530198821797967, -0.010933064855635166, 0.00009036614210344851, 0.024827931076288223, 0.004317768383771181, -0.006008919794112444, -0.0025732924696058035, -0.006673192139714956, 0.0007031228742562234, 0.027838485315442085, 0.07044940441846848, 0.030495572835206985, -0.011962991207838058, -0.02396254800260067, -0.0069352444261312485, -0.01148154679685831, -0.0065086474642157555, -0.00011931377957807854, -0.0048540616407990456, -0.01572313718497753, -0.016588518396019936, -0.03836933150887489, 0.05528693646192551, 0.029203593730926514, -0.0020187166519463062, 0.02089105173945427, -0.0031781457364559174, -0.016271619126200676, 0.020817920565605164, 0.02776535414159298, -0.008921965956687927, 0.004308626987040043, 0.023828474804759026, 0.0016134498873725533, 0.0347859188914299, -0.0005690495599992573, -0.008976814337074757, 0.013504833914339542, 0.02959362603724003, 0.02593708224594593, -0.006813359446823597, 0.009933609515428543, -0.02046445570886135, 0.033201415091753006, 0.009817819111049175, 0.019196853041648865, -0.00258548092097044, 0.010061589069664478, -0.009147453121840954, -0.008074866607785225, -0.029032954946160316, -0.05002151429653168, -0.033055152744054794, -0.010786803439259529, -0.0012584604555740952, 0.008288165554404259, -0.000503917399328202, -0.014297084882855415, -0.04714503511786461, -0.05777338892221451, -0.02020849660038948, -0.04443919286131859, 0.03790616616606712, 0.01578407920897007, 0.026327112689614296, -0.03417649492621422, -0.0034127740655094385, 0.005719443317502737, -0.034980934113264084, -0.02480355277657509, 0.03130001202225685, -0.036906711757183075, -0.055189430713653564, 0.03990507870912552, 0.006188699975609779, 0.019720958545804024, -0.017648916691541672, -0.010969630442559719, -0.011639997363090515, -0.0007377838483080268, 0.013577965088188648, 0.014163011685013771, -0.015174655243754387, -0.016856664791703224, -0.034347131848335266, -0.0013270205818116665, -0.022841207683086395, 0.014297084882855415, 0.0034645749256014824, 0.042318396270275116, 0.033615823835134506, 0.026790276169776917, 0.014223954640328884, -0.02260962687432766, -0.005509192124009132, 0.004010009579360485, 0.00017197181296069175, 0.003357925917953253, 0.016576331108808517, -0.010555222630500793, -0.014382404275238514, 0.004482313059270382, -0.024596350267529488, 0.0050734542310237885, 0.017685482278466225, 0.015089335851371288, -0.018563052639365196, 0.031592536717653275, 0.012566321529448032, -0.02224397286772728, -0.009677652269601822, 0.008519746363162994, -0.04609682410955429, -0.02708279900252819, 0.00851365178823471, -0.0013239735271781683, -0.025668935850262642, 0.0028018264565616846, 0.03422524780035019, -0.03944191709160805, 0.02239023521542549, -0.01408988144248724, 0.03936878591775894, 0.001886166981421411, -0.00799564179033041, -0.002372182672843337, 0.008708667941391468, -0.030763719230890274, 0.011646091006696224, 0.010055494494736195, -0.025352034717798233, 0.010384583845734596, -0.044658586382865906, 0.0051770564168691635, 0.018502110615372658, 0.03130001202225685, -0.02786286175251007, 0.015467179007828236, 0.022158654406666756, -0.005762103013694286, -0.0237431563436985, 0.04887579753994942, 0.008854929357767105, -0.01051865704357624, 0.009336374700069427, -0.027887238189578056, -0.0002849056909326464, 0.010902593843638897, -0.019391870126128197, -0.030909981578588486, -0.011408415623009205, -0.005082595627754927, 0.0029633238445967436, -0.02245117723941803, -0.01310261432081461, -0.03839370608329773, 0.010256604291498661, -0.02109825611114502, -0.005667642690241337, 0.026546506211161613, -0.018087701871991158, 0.005493956618010998, -0.018623994663357735, 0.011792353354394436, 0.012834467925131321, -0.022487742826342583, 0.009159641340374947, 0.01484556682407856, -0.0076909298077225685, -0.009080416522920132, -0.0002578624989837408, -0.02161017246544361, 0.008111432194709778, -0.023938171565532684, -0.0637701228260994, -0.025400789454579353, 0.018879953771829605, -0.024084433913230896, 0.016990739852190018, 0.02588832750916481, 0.03995383158326149, 0.03385959193110466, 0.043049704283475876, -0.019148100167512894, -0.010146908462047577, 0.007946887984871864, -0.02235366962850094, -0.0030471195932477713, 0.028764808550477028, -0.0026692766696214676, -0.04139207303524017, -0.006929149851202965, -0.0650864765048027, 0.0009126123040914536, -0.026107721030712128, 0.005588417407125235, 0.008952436968684196, -0.027619091793894768, -0.024937625974416733, -0.0049454751424491405, 0.07210703939199448, -0.009238867089152336, -0.010317547246813774, -0.03283575922250748, -0.0006193270673975348, -0.03822306916117668, -0.006246595177799463, 0.007629987318068743, 0.007093694526702166, -0.008135809563100338, 0.01713700033724308, 0.013772980310022831, 0.003073020139709115, 0.010957442224025726, 0.050752826035022736, -0.01702730357646942, -0.006045485381036997, 0.005920553579926491, -0.0002637662983033806, 0.006539118476212025, -0.029301101341843605, -0.0025108265690505505, -0.013577965088188648, 0.02276807837188244, -0.014809001237154007, 0.0009819342521950603, 0.02973988652229309, 0.006910867057740688, 0.005070406943559647, 0.03563911095261574, 0.001458808546885848, 0.015564686618745327, -0.019343115389347076, 0.01875806786119938, 0.00021615505102090538, 0.005228857044130564, 0.005719443317502737, 0.018051136285066605, 0.023730967193841934, 0.006916961632668972, 0.04088015854358673, 0.027107175439596176, 0.029666757211089134, -0.003434103913605213, 0.020147554576396942, 0.0045341141521930695, -0.023584706708788872, 0.026278359815478325, -0.007727495394647121, -0.009915327653288841, -0.029081709682941437, -0.026546506211161613, 0.005640218500047922, -0.001090868841856718, 0.007337464019656181, 0.009336374700069427, -0.018355848267674446, 0.01745390146970749, 0.026887783780694008, -0.03327454626560211, -0.006575684063136578, -0.024511029943823814, -0.02905733324587345, 0.05723709613084793, 0.016905419528484344, 0.0014390022261068225, 0.02401130273938179, 0.02254868485033512, 0.015077147632837296, 0.01052475068718195, -0.0315437838435173, 0.0030836849473416805, -0.012005651369690895, 0.0005892367335036397, 0.01208487618714571, 0.02098855935037136, -0.05158163979649544, 0.012383494526147842, -0.009884855709969997, 0.0249498151242733, -0.0001565457641845569, -0.03110499680042267, -0.012944163754582405, 0.026375867426395416, -0.015857210382819176, 0.01052475068718195, 0.004552396479994059, 0.013017294928431511, -0.007008375134319067, 0.04017322510480881, -0.02813100814819336, -0.032323844730854034, 0.0059693073853850365, 0.005335506517440081, 0.02983739599585533, 0.003903360106050968, -0.036272913217544556, -0.008946343325078487, 0.011914237402379513, 0.005146584939211607, -0.0206716600805521, 0.027643468230962753, 0.01719794236123562, -0.021159198135137558, 0.006624437868595123, 0.01703949272632599, -0.008928060531616211, -0.048412635922431946, 0.02213427610695362, 0.013565776869654655, -0.0012995965080335736, 0.026010213419795036, 0.010433337651193142, -0.008056583814322948, 0.004077046178281307, 0.03144627436995506, 0.012151912786066532, -0.004147129599004984, 0.0020933712366968393, -0.024657292291522026, 0.005298940930515528, 0.04261092096567154, -0.008495369926095009, -0.029179217293858528, -0.029764264822006226, -0.023194674402475357, -0.011621714569628239, -0.009421694092452526, 0.0021832610946148634, -0.017112623900175095, -0.04573117196559906, -0.004390899557620287, -0.004476218484342098, -0.0016713450895622373, 0.01250537857413292, 0.017892686650156975, -0.02416975237429142, -0.01031145267188549, 0.02666839025914669, 0.03454214707016945, -0.01385829970240593, -0.021890508010983467, -0.04404916241765022, -0.009458259679377079, -0.013638907112181187, -0.015613440424203873, 0.002327999332919717, -0.011469358578324318, 0.009214489720761776, -0.020342569798231125, -0.016966361552476883, 0.02078135497868061, 0.029666757211089134, 0.012170195579528809, -0.001884643454104662, -0.0076909298077225685, -0.0069352444261312485, -0.020354758948087692, -0.007989547215402126, -0.0006806503515690565, -0.03225071355700493, 0.005826092790812254, -0.006502553354948759, 0.028716055676341057, 0.021756434813141823, -0.001003264100290835, -0.007831097580492496, -0.009872667491436005, -0.034615278244018555, -0.0045341141521930695, 0.020696036517620087, -0.027545960620045662, -0.00024948292411863804, -0.013419514521956444, -0.017636727541685104, -0.03298202157020569, 0.04339098185300827, -0.0037936638109385967, -0.017673293128609657, 0.026595259085297585, 0.028447909280657768, -0.04205024987459183, 0.02431601472198963, -0.020232874900102615, -0.04536551609635353, 0.0011221017921343446, 0.0029054286424070597, -0.002650994108989835, -0.006313631776720285, -0.00760561041533947, 0.02276807837188244, -0.02386504039168358, 0.0015258451458066702, 0.006362385582178831, 0.03902750834822655, 0.05699332430958748, 0.01408988144248724, -0.0645989328622818, -0.01148154679685831, 0.02005004696547985, -0.028886694461107254, -0.03990507870912552, 0.03244572877883911, -0.02922797203063965, -0.024986380711197853, 0.027302192524075508, 0.02776535414159298, 0.024937625974416733, 0.013358572497963905, 0.058260925114154816, 0.003583412617444992, -0.014321462251245975, -0.007014469243586063, 0.03139752149581909, 0.03702859580516815, 0.010951347649097443, 0.009043850935995579, 0.015125901438295841, 0.013919242657721043, 0.0017840885557234287, 0.05431186035275459, 0.024145375937223434, 0.01672259159386158, 0.02501075714826584, 0.009525296278297901, -0.003169004339724779, 0.04636497050523758, 0.014906508848071098, 0.010207850486040115, 0.015016205608844757, -0.012602887116372585, -0.03276263177394867, 0.006983998231589794, -0.010110342875123024, -0.025376413017511368, 0.034030232578516006, -0.0030318840872496367, 0.01589377596974373, -0.014516477473080158, -0.015979094430804253, 0.019489377737045288, -0.013590153306722641, -0.0030516902916133404, 0.021634548902511597, 0.02224397286772728, 0.044146668165922165, -0.0009187065879814327, -0.0023508528247475624, -0.04095328599214554, -0.006441610865294933, -0.01153639517724514, 0.03607789799571037, -0.012176290154457092, -0.012517567723989487, -0.010439432226121426, 0.0014534760266542435, 0.00703275203704834, -0.010305358096957207, -0.021707680076360703, 0.03412773832678795, 0.004241590388119221, 0.025912705808877945, 0.03975881636142731, 0.01034192368388176, 0.035127196460962296, 0.009214489720761776, -0.01667383871972561, 0.0013536828337237239, 0.01818520948290825, -0.021171387284994125, -0.016393503174185753, -0.03541971743106842, 0.0009308950393460691, -0.004314721561968327, 0.06479395180940628, 0.007642176002264023, 0.0005644789198413491, -0.01015909668058157, -0.0024803553242236376, 0.007898134179413319, 0.0355416014790535, 0.007946887984871864, 0.0462430864572525, -0.025083888322114944, -0.022000202909111977, 0.011579054407775402, -0.013529211282730103, -0.010768520645797253, -0.023889416828751564, 0.03593163564801216, 0.030593080446124077, 0.0005115352105349302, -0.0007400691974908113, -0.010671013034880161, 0.018928706645965576, 0.0021543134935200214, -0.00814799778163433, -0.039929457008838654, 0.020440079271793365, -0.003866794751957059, 0.016539765521883965, -0.013907053507864475, -0.029813017696142197, 0.016491010785102844, 0.036541059613227844, -0.014187389053404331, -0.0013635860523208976, -0.011463264003396034, 0.043878521770238876, 0.006557401269674301, 0.030909981578588486, -0.014955262653529644, 0.01896527223289013, 0.030178671702742577, 0.010439432226121426, 0.0009407981997355819, -0.02318248525261879, 0.049972761422395706, -0.008477087132632732, 0.01745390146970749, -0.02937423251569271, 0.027058422565460205, 0.02354814112186432, -0.02047664299607277, 0.034249626100063324, 0.002791161648929119, 0.0008219605078920722, 0.009799536317586899, 0.02562018111348152, -0.008909777738153934, -0.011804541572928429, -0.02296309359371662, 0.016174111515283585, 0.016576331108808517, -0.011518112383782864, -0.015857210382819176, -0.005460438318550587, 0.018916519358754158, -0.023889416828751564, -0.010738049633800983, -0.005055171437561512, -0.04390290006995201, 0.014260520227253437, -0.02817976288497448, -0.0273997001349926, 0.015199032612144947, 0.010110342875123024, 0.0043360511772334576, -0.014187389053404331, -0.022000202909111977, -0.01168875116854906, -0.032055698335170746, -0.02020849660038948, -0.0016591566381976008, 0.025742067024111748, -0.02390160597860813, -0.017478277906775475, -0.018575241789221764, 0.026497751474380493, -0.029886148869991302, -0.02588832750916481, 0.01051865704357624, -0.01703949272632599, -0.008970719762146473, 0.003909454680979252, 0.006429422181099653, 0.019026214256882668, -0.04453669860959053, -0.004174553789198399, -0.006941338535398245, 0.03251885995268822, 0.00836129579693079, -0.017880497500300407, 0.00802001915872097, -0.056798309087753296, -0.04022197797894478, 0.027302192524075508, 0.010738049633800983, 0.017051681876182556, -0.0015646959654986858, 0.03995383158326149, 0.016649462282657623, 0.0014108163304626942, 0.005999778397381306, 0.015467179007828236, 0.008812270127236843, -0.027570338919758797, 0.03488342463970184, -0.009708123281598091 ]
11.754289
6.585069
2024-07-01
9
2024A&A...687A..68D
[ "galaxy formation", "massive quiescent galaxies", "low galaxy masses", "massive galaxies", "quiescent galaxies", "quenched galaxies", "satellite galaxies", "specific star formation rate distributions", "excessive residual star formation", "post-JWST observational measurements" ]
[ "galaxies: evolution", "galaxies: formation", "galaxies: star formation", "galaxies: statistics", "galaxies: stellar content", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
59
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202349045", "10.48550/arXiv.2401.06211" ]
[ "De Lucia, Gabriella", "Fontanot, Fabio", "Xie, Lizhi", "Hirschmann, Michaela" ]
[ "INAF - Astronomical Observatory of Trieste, Via G. B. Tiepolo 11, 34143, Trieste, Italy ; IFPU - Institute for Fundamental Physics of the Universe, Via Beirut 2, 34151, Trieste, Italy", "INAF - Astronomical Observatory of Trieste, Via G. B. Tiepolo 11, 34143, Trieste, Italy; IFPU - Institute for Fundamental Physics of the Universe, Via Beirut 2, 34151, Trieste, Italy", "Tianjin Normal University, Binshuixidao 393, 300387, Tianjin, PR China", "Institute for Physics, Laboratory for Galaxy Evolution, EPFL, Observatoire de Sauverny, Chemin Pegasi 51, 1290, Versoix, Switzerland; INAF - Astronomical Observatory of Trieste, Via G. B. Tiepolo 11, 34143, Trieste, Italy" ]
[ "2024ApJ...966L...2X", "2024MNRAS.532L..61H", "2024OJAp....7E..46U", "2024arXiv240208729S", "2024arXiv240405683D", "2024arXiv240419018F", "2024arXiv240510544C", "2024arXiv240513495E", "2024arXiv240518491F" ]
[ "1999MNRAS.303..188K", "2003ApJ...582..659K", "2003ApJ...594..186B", "2003ApJ...599...38B", "2003MNRAS.341...33K", "2004ApJ...600..681B", "2004MNRAS.349.1101D", "2004MNRAS.351.1151B", "2005Natur.435..629S", "2006MNRAS.365...11C", "2006MNRAS.370..645B", "2006MNRAS.372.1161W", "2007ApJ...671..153Y", "2007ApJS..173..267S", "2007MNRAS.375....2D", "2007MNRAS.380..877S", "2008ApJ...688..770F", "2008MNRAS.384.1301W", "2008MNRAS.388..587L", "2009ApJ...691.1879W", "2009ApJ...699..486C", "2009ApJ...706L.173B", "2009MNRAS.397.1776F", "2009MNRAS.398.1150B", "2011AJ....142..170H", "2011ApJ...735...86W", "2012MNRAS.424..232W", "2013ApJ...777...18M", "2013MNRAS.428.1351G", "2013MNRAS.428.2966P", "2013MNRAS.433.3297D", "2013MNRAS.435...87M", "2014MNRAS.444.2938H", "2014MNRAS.445..970D", "2016A&C....15...72M", "2016MNRAS.461.1760H", "2017ApJ...835..153F", "2017ApJ...842L..14F", "2017MNRAS.464.3812F", "2017MNRAS.469..968X", "2017MNRAS.470.4168B", "2017MNRAS.470.4186B", "2018ApJ...864...51W", "2019ComAC...6....2N", "2019MNRAS.482.5041D", "2019MNRAS.483.5444D", "2019MNRAS.486.2827D", "2020A&A...638A.112V", "2020A&A...643L..11A", "2020MNRAS.495.3252S", "2020MNRAS.496.3943F", "2020MNRAS.498.3215D", "2020MNRAS.498.4327X", "2021A&A...650A.105B", "2021MNRAS.500..358B", "2021MNRAS.504.4481F", "2021MNRAS.506.4760D", "2022ApJ...940..135S", "2022ApJS..258...11W", "2023A&A...677A.184W", "2023ApJ...947...20V", "2023MNRAS.518.4782K", "2023MNRAS.518.5953L", "2023MNRAS.520.3974C", "2023MNRAS.522.4481B", "2023MNRAS.525.1061H", "2024A&A...686A.302F", "2024ApJ...966L...2X", "2024MNRAS.531.3551L" ]
29096769
2403.00904
Dynamical modelling and the origin of gas turbulence in z ∼ 4.5 galaxies
Context. In recent years, a growing number of regularly rotating galaxy discs have been found at z ≥ 4. Such systems provide us with the unique opportunity to study the properties of dark matter (DM) halos at these early epochs, the turbulence within the interstellar medium and the evolution of scaling relations. <BR /> Aims: Here, we investigate the dynamics of four gas discs in galaxies at z ∼ 4.5 observed with ALMA in the [CII] 158 μm fine-structure line. We aim to derive the structural properties of the gas, stars and DM halos of the galaxies and to study the mechanisms driving the turbulence in high-z discs. <BR /> Methods: We decomposed the rotation curves into baryonic and DM components within the extent of the [CII] discs, that is, 3 to 5 kpc. Furthermore, we used the gas velocity dispersion profiles as a diagnostic tool in investigating the mechanisms driving the turbulence in the discs. <BR /> Results: We obtain total stellar, gas and DM masses in the ranges of log(M/M<SUB>⊙</SUB>) = 10.3 − 11.0, 9.8 − 11.3, and 11.2 − 13.3, respectively. We find dynamical evidence in all four galaxies for the presence of compact stellar components conceivably, stellar bulges. The turbulence present in the galaxies appears to be primarily driven by stellar feedback, negating the necessity for large-scale gravitational instabilities. Finally, we investigate the position of our galaxies in the context of local scaling relations, in particular the stellar-to-halo mass and Tully-Fisher analogue relations.
[ 0.029522113502025604, 0.06896282732486725, 0.03671439364552498, 0.01825333759188652, 0.006893686018884182, 0.05572071671485901, -0.018811583518981934, 0.017772987484931946, -0.045256853103637695, 0.02151193469762802, 0.012729301117360592, -0.015475091524422169, -0.06657405197620392, 0.0007716449326835573, 0.036091238260269165, 0.04071299359202385, -0.011885441839694977, 0.012580003589391708, -0.0003211130097042769, 0.043672993779182434, 0.017097899690270424, -0.005832369904965162, -0.014475442469120026, 0.011190880089998245, -0.05255299434065819, -0.028769129887223244, 0.0036578078288584948, 0.036065272986888885, 0.026081761345267296, -0.03393615037202835, 0.03764913231134415, -0.02404351532459259, -0.007049475330859423, -0.029444217681884766, -0.059407733380794525, 0.06756071746349335, -0.03429965674877167, -0.0009112063562497497, 0.01487789861857891, -0.03918106108903885, -0.007387019228190184, 0.028795095160603523, -0.019681409001350403, -0.017928777262568474, 0.020174741744995117, -0.02562737464904785, -0.018837548792362213, -0.013748424127697945, 0.013410880230367184, -0.02993755042552948, -0.027782462537288666, 0.028872989118099213, 0.012339827604591846, 0.01251509040594101, -0.0013526099501177669, 0.003725965740159154, 0.021005619317293167, -0.028068076819181442, 0.03240421786904335, 0.02664000727236271, 0.0003200987703166902, -0.034585271030664444, 0.031157903373241425, 0.005679825786501169, 0.01161930151283741, -0.009892634116113186, -0.04058316722512245, -0.018616845831274986, 0.05395510047674179, 0.04795720428228378, -0.011956845410168171, -0.02392667345702648, 0.005160527769476175, -0.006757370196282864, 0.0071014054119586945, -0.005423422437161207, -0.009678423404693604, -0.03507860377430916, -0.06802808493375778, -0.02151193469762802, 0.03385825455188751, 0.0241603571921587, -0.0024536848068237305, 0.02401755005121231, -0.017876846715807915, 0.004553597420454025, 0.01905824989080429, 0.041881412267684937, -0.023524217307567596, -0.008880002424120903, 0.02830176055431366, 0.011820529587566853, -0.01648772321641445, -0.026159655302762985, 0.012748775072395802, -0.06662598252296448, 0.04375088959932327, -0.010509300976991653, 0.042011238634586334, 0.030976148322224617, -0.01450140681117773, 0.046944573521614075, 0.024692637845873833, -0.05504562705755234, 0.08241265267133713, -0.014034038409590721, 0.009704388678073883, -0.01334596797823906, -0.022823164239525795, 0.0002933224313892424, 0.022005269303917885, 0.02252456732094288, -0.04164772853255272, 0.01113895047456026, -0.03152140974998474, -0.0058226329274475574, -0.0495929941534996, 0.005864826031029224, -0.04463369399309158, 0.009892634116113186, -0.007581756450235844, 0.0032261412125080824, -0.01744842529296875, -0.002242719754576683, 0.0274189542979002, -0.04060913249850273, 0.007218247279524803, -0.05374738201498985, -0.035312291234731674, 0.041206326335668564, 0.029444217681884766, -0.030041411519050598, 0.014475442469120026, -0.044296152889728546, -0.04634737968444824, 0.013540704734623432, 0.00765965087339282, -0.016059301793575287, -0.006919650826603174, 0.021992286667227745, 0.032819658517837524, -0.008854037150740623, 0.03089825250208378, 0.014060003682971, 0.01208017859607935, 0.003437106031924486, -0.03172913193702698, 0.006520440336316824, -0.024744568392634392, 0.017032986506819725, -0.022965971380472183, 0.008834563195705414, -0.006380878854542971, -0.061848435550928116, -0.008951405994594097, -0.010924739763140678, 0.0017266670474782586, 0.005050176754593849, -0.010918248444795609, -0.019642461091279984, -0.027704568579792976, -0.01904526725411415, -0.028094042092561722, -0.008821581490337849, -0.008049124851822853, 0.010165265761315823, -0.013982108794152737, 0.0013631582260131836, -0.08968283236026764, -0.014916845597326756, 0.00783491414040327, -0.0017607460031285882, -0.04008983448147774, -0.03970035910606384, 0.012495617382228374, 0.04489334300160408, -0.012631933204829693, -0.06948212534189224, -0.048528432846069336, -0.010015967302024364, 0.018655793741345406, 0.02573123387992382, 0.005053422413766384, -0.03725965693593025, -0.049463171511888504, 0.06678177416324615, -0.010463862679898739, 0.008075090125203133, 0.0247964970767498, 0.02651018276810646, -0.027159305289387703, 0.02754877880215645, -0.014462459832429886, -0.001528684631921351, -0.0366884283721447, -0.016851231455802917, 0.012333336286246777, 0.03931088745594025, -0.004543860908597708, 0.05255299434065819, 0.025380708277225494, 0.024640707299113274, 0.041803520172834396, -0.06917054206132889, -0.04629544913768768, -0.00765965087339282, 0.02164175920188427, -0.01074298471212387, -0.03562386706471443, -0.01982421614229679, 0.010515792295336723, 0.0007558225770480931, 0.013384915888309479, 0.026016848161816597, -0.04629544913768768, -0.02247263677418232, -0.046970538794994354, 0.02897685021162033, 0.05966738238930702, 0.04421825706958771, 0.019512636587023735, 0.035260360687971115, 0.019304916262626648, 0.02336842752993107, 0.03666246682405472, -0.017604215070605278, 0.03725965693593025, -0.022641409188508987, 0.04211509972810745, 0.03645474463701248, 0.046269483864307404, -0.0033657026942819357, -0.06605475395917892, 0.015176494605839252, -0.021330181509256363, 0.0030719744972884655, 0.0017558776307851076, 0.03899930790066719, 0.0046574571169912815, -0.05577264726161957, -0.012975968420505524, 0.001875965390354395, 0.036013342440128326, 0.010626142844557762, -0.01171017810702324, 0.033598605543375015, -0.012962985783815384, -0.03388421982526779, 0.007971229963004589, -0.012826669961214066, 0.024783514440059662, -0.029314393177628517, -0.037804920226335526, -0.01122982706874609, -0.02401755005121231, -0.009814739227294922, -0.055357206612825394, 0.009561581537127495, -0.021083513274788857, 0.022901058197021484, -0.032923515886068344, -0.028847023844718933, -0.05712282285094261, 0.025211935862898827, -0.016267022117972374, 0.033598605543375015, 0.028898954391479492, -0.015137547627091408, -0.06797615438699722, -0.019668426364660263, -0.018564917147159576, -0.031235797330737114, 0.035338252782821655, -0.025925971567630768, -0.04546457156538963, 0.010717020370066166, -0.0030622375197708607, 0.023835795000195503, 0.03139158710837364, 0.00828929990530014, 0.008815090171992779, 0.010567721910774708, 0.05556492507457733, 0.03398807719349861, -0.037778954952955246, 0.019395794719457626, 0.0044400012120604515, 0.016877196729183197, 0.04066106304526329, -0.038531940430402756, 0.06870317459106445, -0.04211509972810745, -0.0074714054353535175, 0.02980772592127323, -0.03570176288485527, 0.0015733117470517755, 0.008918949402868748, -0.029625972732901573, -0.016383863985538483, 0.005842106882482767, 0.05044983699917793, 0.003709737677127123, 0.02661404199898243, -0.020992636680603027, 0.007302633486688137, 0.021187374368309975, 0.05096913501620293, 0.02915860339999199, -0.028639305382966995, 0.014579301699995995, 0.030404919758439064, 0.010392459109425545, 0.01076894998550415, 0.009379826486110687, -0.04258246719837189, -0.023692987859249115, -0.021109478548169136, 0.03388421982526779, 0.016124214977025986, -0.050995100289583206, -0.03593544661998749, -0.01372245978564024, -0.015124564990401268, -0.031131938099861145, 0.019304916262626648, -0.04323159158229828, 0.0023660531733185053, -0.01740947738289833, -0.034481413662433624, -0.04930737987160683, 0.001776974182575941, 0.003959650173783302, 0.03393615037202835, 0.01752631925046444, 0.0015205706004053354, -0.03237825259566307, 0.014579301699995995, 0.08750177919864655, -0.01904526725411415, 0.023628076538443565, 0.011521932668983936, -0.0063516683876514435, 0.01657859981060028, 0.006124475039541721, -0.00027080599102191627, 0.028639305382966995, 0.024744568392634392, -0.0078089493326842785, 0.023485269397497177, -0.0008633335237391293, -0.00959403719753027, -0.03793474659323692, 0.03580562397837639, -0.0021924127358943224, 0.012729301117360592, -0.004826229065656662, -0.009074739180505276, -0.05315018817782402, -0.02248561941087246, 0.008140002377331257, 0.011742634698748589, -0.019720355048775673, 0.05722668021917343, 0.009671932086348534, 0.014748074114322662, 0.05810948833823204, -0.027912287041544914, -0.015578951686620712, -0.02234281226992607, -0.04748983681201935, 0.01455333735793829, 0.0004144244594499469, 0.020135793834924698, 0.009892634116113186, -0.058472998440265656, -0.003289430635049939, 0.03333895653486252, -0.024471936747431755, -0.008036142215132713, 0.007899826392531395, 0.02321263775229454, -0.012391757220029831, -0.015617898665368557, -0.02564035728573799, -0.009535616263747215, 0.02245965413749218, -0.035286325961351395, -0.0036805272102355957, -0.08516493439674377, 0.0366884283721447, -0.01074947603046894, 0.005588948726654053, -0.010833862237632275, 0.014008074067533016, -0.04045334458351135, -0.05421474948525429, 0.031131938099861145, 0.049489136785268784, 0.023848777636885643, 0.04642527550458908, -0.020291583612561226, -0.009574564173817635, -0.05961545184254646, -0.039570536464452744, -0.01655263639986515, -0.02400456741452217, -0.014864915981888771, 0.03837614879012108, -0.024458954110741615, -0.0274189542979002, 0.02993755042552948, -0.016461757943034172, 0.043595097959041595, -0.004216053523123264, -0.013813336379826069, 0.029236499220132828, -0.0598231740295887, 0.030171236023306847, -0.027834393084049225, 0.02329053170979023, -0.019733337685465813, 0.04131018742918968, 0.004410790745168924, -0.007698598317801952, -0.04663299396634102, 0.018006671220064163, -0.022031232714653015, 0.008990352973341942, -0.01206070464104414, -0.06802808493375778, -0.02170667238533497, 0.01368351187556982, 0.027081409469246864, 0.02497825212776661, -0.021784566342830658, -0.026302462443709373, -0.010288598947227001, -0.03928492218255997, -0.00342412362806499, -0.03248211368918419, 0.007529826369136572, 0.01499474048614502, 0.028639305382966995, -0.061121419072151184, 0.040245622396469116, 0.029340358451008797, 0.04886597767472267, 0.027185270562767982, 0.013670530170202255, -0.057797908782958984, 0.004887896124273539, -0.0024066234473139048, -0.017604215070605278, 0.01914912834763527, -0.0495929941534996, -0.0044042994268238544, -0.0054461415857076645, -0.038609832525253296, 0.03635088726878166, -0.05156632885336876, -0.009632985107600689, 0.018084565177559853, -0.01544912625104189, 0.028665270656347275, -0.051098961383104324, 0.015241406857967377, -0.022135093808174133, -0.001885702251456678, 0.013878248631954193, -0.011749126017093658, 0.04964492470026016, -0.035234395414590836, 0.0166175477206707, -0.03959650173783302, 0.02236877754330635, -0.028872989118099213, -0.028639305382966995, -0.025263866409659386, 0.06153685599565506, 0.018084565177559853, 0.02075895294547081, -0.02918456867337227, 0.019382812082767487, 0.013475792482495308, 0.02895088493824005, 0.041076499968767166, -0.01452737208455801, 0.022628426551818848, 0.016435792669653893, -0.035416148602962494, -0.03998597338795662, -0.02666597068309784, 0.05302036553621292, -0.013800354674458504, -0.010970178060233593, -0.0331052727997303, -0.031028077006340027, -0.017253687605261803, -0.018123513087630272, -0.004238773137331009, 0.03663650155067444, -0.027782462537288666, 0.02752281352877617, 0.010249651968479156, 0.05000843480229378, 0.016344916075468063, -0.042011238634586334, -0.036065272986888885, 0.017045969143509865, 0.0046964045614004135, 0.010217195376753807, 0.03925895690917969, 0.012703336775302887, -0.019733337685465813, 0.0070170192047953606, -0.01674737222492695, 0.015098600648343563, 0.0108014065772295, -0.0016974565805867314, -0.010509300976991653, -0.0021388602908700705, -0.03676632419228554, 0.009775792248547077, 0.014111933298408985, 0.021862462162971497, -0.03133965656161308, -0.015254389494657516, -0.12068494409322739, -0.03300141170620918, -0.008198423311114311, -0.019460706040263176, -0.006130966357886791, 0.017604215070605278, 0.0182793028652668, -0.010665090754628181, -0.04250457137823105, -0.015046670101583004, -0.023835795000195503, -0.008568422868847847, -0.047723520547151566, 0.03728562220931053, 0.013131757266819477, -0.02491333894431591, -0.0042452639900147915, 0.05006036162376404, 0.01907123252749443, -0.03494878113269806, 0.03253404423594475, 0.04894387349486351, 0.02993755042552948, 0.023809829726815224, -0.020551232621073723, 0.00048765362589620054, 0.027211233973503113, -0.013034389354288578, -0.021070532500743866, 0.011210354045033455, -0.0019457461312413216, 0.0075493003241717815, 0.01418982818722725, -0.026029830798506737, -0.047593697905540466, -0.012235968373715878, 0.050371941179037094, -0.0008519738912582397, -0.03232632204890251, -0.015968425199389458, -0.006815791130065918, -0.029314393177628517, 0.026925621554255486, -0.006965089589357376, -0.025964919477701187, 0.008094563148915768, -0.046269483864307404, -0.021083513274788857, -0.04253053665161133, -0.008029650896787643, 0.02988562174141407, 0.026951584964990616, -0.02980772592127323, -0.037000007927417755, -0.01837017945945263, 0.0038817552849650383, 0.01368351187556982, -0.027730533853173256, 0.010048423893749714, -0.017798950895667076, 0.030067376792430878, 0.02236877754330635, -0.022654391825199127, 0.021317198872566223, -0.008016668260097504, 0.0021794303320348263, 0.014254740439355373, -0.005907019134610891, -0.00619912426918745, 0.0024407024029642344, 0.041076499968767166, 0.0008698247838765383, -0.021213337779045105, -0.007588247302919626, -0.00038176545058377087, -0.04580211639404297, -0.041803520172834396, -0.03352070972323418, 0.04494527354836464, -0.006182896438986063, 0.025172987952828407, -0.0047775451093912125, 0.011755617335438728, 0.007906317710876465, 0.05551299452781677, -0.011976318433880806, -0.03671439364552498, -0.012119125574827194, -0.017785970121622086, 0.028016148135066032, -0.002638684818521142, 0.013008424080908298, 0.010970178060233593, -0.03250807896256447, 0.0032131588086485863, -0.0035928955767303705, 0.0033429833129048347, 0.030145270749926567, 0.0021761846728622913, -0.005059913732111454, -0.03679228946566582, -0.006783335004001856, -0.002864255104213953, -0.02406948059797287, -0.02257649600505829, 0.027055446058511734, 0.01209316123276949, 0.014618249610066414, -0.011872459203004837, 0.006410089321434498, 0.0579017698764801, 0.001728289877064526, -0.01242421381175518, 0.04922948777675629, 0.015436144545674324, 0.04733404517173767, -0.02161579579114914, 0.011320704594254494, 0.02905474416911602, -0.025458602234721184, 0.026211585849523544, -0.0550975576043129, -0.015111582353711128, -0.007250703405588865, -0.026081761345267296, 0.02405649796128273, 0.012839652597904205, 0.022965971380472183, -0.004375088959932327, 0.0011481362162157893, 0.02408246137201786, -0.06278317421674728, 0.010957195423543453, 0.01160631887614727, -0.016799302771687508, -0.012028248980641365, 0.009756318293511868, -0.002963246311992407, 0.00993158109486103, 0.008003686554729939, 0.018603865057229996, -0.01489088125526905, 0.03648070991039276, 0.07015720754861832, -0.0013331363443285227, 0.004878159146755934, 0.029677901417016983, -0.019356846809387207, -0.020213689655065536, 0.011917897500097752, -0.014735091477632523, -0.030067376792430878, 0.017824916169047356, -0.009574564173817635, -0.002252456732094288, -0.02086281217634678, -0.02396561950445175, 0.0033657026942819357, 0.020447373390197754, 0.014111933298408985, 0.022563515231013298, 0.002828553318977356, 0.014371582306921482, -0.014436494559049606, -0.004832720384001732, 0.0042874570935964584, 0.02495228685438633, 0.02165474183857441, -0.03261193633079529, 0.01986316218972206, 0.007289650849997997, 0.029210533946752548, -0.04211509972810745, 0.01838316209614277, -0.015072635374963284, 0.0011075660586357117, -0.015527021139860153, -0.006069299764931202, -0.02653614617884159, 0.016007373109459877, -0.008269826881587505, 0.024562813341617584, -0.022693339735269547, 0.029444217681884766, 0.0018110531382262707, -0.04297193884849548, 0.005329299718141556, -0.004861930850893259, -0.007159826345741749, -0.02257649600505829, -0.0013339477591216564, -0.04884001240134239, -0.001002083532512188, 0.01158035360276699, -0.0032878078054636717, -0.05784983932971954, -0.005037194117903709, 0.036195095628499985, -0.030249129980802536, -0.002026886446401477, 0.005627896171063185, -0.01534526702016592, -0.033702462911605835, 0.02336842752993107, 0.017928777262568474, 0.0034728078171610832, 0.002307632239535451, 0.013008424080908298, 0.03793474659323692, 0.02147298865020275, -0.03583158925175667, -0.003237500786781311, 0.04058316722512245, 0.024303164333105087, -0.000009660775504016783, 0.02590000629425049, 0.018876496702432632, 0.016994038596749306, -0.038583870977163315, 0.035234395414590836, -0.00784789677709341, -0.0032715797424316406, 0.01653965376317501, -0.010632634162902832, 0.011197371408343315, 0.020382462069392204, -0.010671582072973251, 0.01922702230513096, -0.02996351569890976, -0.0032878078054636717, -0.0011278511956334114, 0.00765965087339282, 0.0036870185285806656, 0.05722668021917343, 0.038609832525253296, -0.0006596712046302855, 0.009555090218782425, -0.04725615307688713, 0.028094042092561722, -0.05333194136619568, 0.016968075186014175, 0.03923299163579941, -0.006731405388563871, -0.03172913193702698, 0.03248211368918419, 0.031235797330737114, -0.014592284336686134, 0.04920352250337601, 0.004732106346637011, 0.0159164946526289, -0.005588948726654053, 0.003729211399331689, 0.018512986600399017, 0.0017704828642308712, -0.012125616893172264, -0.004550352226942778, -0.018707724288105965, 0.012138599529862404, 0.001901930314488709, 0.004917106591165066, -0.01833123341202736, 0.022732285782694817, -0.013196669518947601, -0.04728211835026741, 0.0006134212017059326, -0.012469652108848095, 0.016903162002563477, -0.010859827511012554, 0.02900281362235546, 0.022667374461889267, -0.07327300310134888, -0.02664000727236271, 0.01160631887614727, 0.018798600882291794, -0.020421408116817474, 0.056188084185123444, 0.02247263677418232, 0.06351019442081451, 0.00912666879594326, -0.029522113502025604, -0.0013891231501474977, -0.050345975905656815, 0.0050728959031403065, 0.030482813715934753, 0.037077903747558594, -0.0056376331485807896, -0.01908421516418457, 0.004991755820810795, -0.02087579481303692, -0.011353161185979843, 0.007711580954492092, 0.017578249797225, 0.004810001235455275, 0.008406142704188824, 0.0015522153116762638, -0.023628076538443565, -0.022901058197021484, -0.014060003682971, 0.047905273735523224, -0.02318667247891426, 0.02234281226992607, -0.02252456732094288, -0.020291583612561226, 0.050190187990665436, -0.02252456732094288, -0.016383863985538483, 0.010548247955739498, 0.03674035891890526, -0.06745685636997223, 0.014955793507397175, -0.024095444008708, -0.009795265272259712, -0.0013006801018491387, 0.0334947444498539, 0.06563931703567505, -0.005322808399796486, 0.01750035583972931, 0.024653689935803413, 0.030404919758439064, 0.003943421877920628, -0.011080529540777206, -0.013138248585164547, 0.04221895709633827, 0.022005269303917885, -0.029262462630867958, 0.010723511688411236, -0.01579965278506279, -0.013410880230367184, -0.044400010257959366, -0.027600709348917007, -0.018837548792362213, 0.03419579938054085, 0.008802107535302639, -0.02590000629425049, -0.0467887818813324, -0.039362818002700806, -0.033546674996614456, 0.021810531616210938, 0.015267372131347656, -0.03661053627729416, -0.019681409001350403, 0.04917755722999573, 0.03648070991039276, 0.03598737716674805, -0.004524386953562498, -0.026263514533638954, -0.03593544661998749, 0.01657859981060028, -0.06849545240402222, 0.01669544354081154, -0.019551584497094154, 0.011489477008581161, -0.012586493976414204, -0.031936850398778915, 0.013982108794152737, 0.03396211192011833, -0.022680357098579407, 0.0021842988207936287, -0.011171406134963036, 0.004819738212972879, 0.007198773790150881, 0.019356846809387207, 0.03266386687755585, 0.0036967552732676268, -0.010736494325101376, 0.008847545832395554, 0.01162579283118248, -0.017837898805737495, -0.009834213182330132, -0.01126877497881651, -0.017175793647766113, -0.016890179365873337, -0.027237199246883392, -0.028483515605330467, 0.017058951780200005, -0.015981407836079597, -0.011547897942364216, 0.02087579481303692, 0.02580912970006466, 0.017617197707295418, 0.03500071167945862, 0.000677522097248584, -0.021265268325805664, 0.043465275317430496, 0.030352989211678505, 0.01372245978564024, -0.008432107046246529, 0.012463160790503025, 0.024783514440059662, -0.056863173842430115, -0.013657547533512115, -0.005413685459643602, -0.02915860339999199, -0.0006016558618284762, 0.015527021139860153, 0.00749087892472744, -0.0051897382363677025, -0.009425265714526176, -0.013943161815404892, 0.015578951686620712, -0.001384254777804017, 0.0019035531440749764, 0.00539421197026968, -0.02251158468425274, 0.014722108840942383, -0.020979654043912888, -0.02248561941087246, 0.054318610578775406, 0.010593687184154987, 0.04585404694080353, 0.006046580616384745, -0.0005813707830384374, 0.008847545832395554, 0.02565333992242813, 0.002297895262017846, 0.020590180531144142, -0.0023060094099491835, -0.0398821160197258, 0.036948081105947495, -0.0031969305127859116, 0.02406948059797287, 0.016305968165397644, 0.009178598411381245, 0.012826669961214066, 0.007257194723933935, -0.009756318293511868, -0.009347370825707912, 0.0005119957495480776, -0.017084917053580284, 0.05159229412674904, 0.044477906078100204, 0.020551232621073723, 0.012320353649556637, -0.02897685021162033, -0.0013566670240834355, 0.016877196729183197, 0.0017071934416890144, 0.022550532594323158, -0.011917897500097752, -0.017889829352498055, -0.0248614102602005, -0.0595635250210762, 0.04310176521539688, 0.015111582353711128, -0.025302812457084656, -0.011015616357326508, -0.008633335120975971, -0.013787372037768364, 0.014631231315433979, 0.0087891248986125, -0.019434740766882896, 0.027704568579792976, -0.04071299359202385, -0.011878950521349907, 0.013878248631954193, 0.022212987765669823, -0.013878248631954193, 0.010262633673846722, -0.005426668096333742, 0.029625972732901573, -0.0024536848068237305, 0.009327896870672703, -0.020239654928445816, 0.02752281352877617, 0.009399300441145897, 0.023446321487426758, -0.018759652972221375, 0.023705970495939255, 0.007367545738816261, -0.0005736624007113278, 0.011671231128275394, -0.010496318340301514, 0.0019944303203374147, 0.004092720337212086, -0.015540003776550293, -0.012969477102160454, 0.004719124175608158, -0.008165966719388962, -0.042712289839982986, -0.020447373390197754, 0.02905474416911602, 0.002059342572465539, 0.019577547907829285, 0.007445440627634525, 0.03762316703796387, -0.029600007459521294, 0.028483515605330467, -0.019382812082767487, -0.042686328291893005, -0.03764913231134415, 0.008607370778918266, -0.04577615112066269, 0.005306580103933811, 0.04073895886540413, -0.028042111545801163, 0.032819658517837524, -0.021252285689115524, -0.0007258006371557713, -0.013131757266819477, 0.0020707023795694113, 0.016267022117972374, 0.02579614706337452, 0.003034649882465601, -0.002559167332947254, -0.02488737553358078, -0.030145270749926567, -0.0012008774792775512, 0.0016909653786569834, -0.01740947738289833, 0.016812285408377647, 0.032715797424316406, -0.012261932715773582, -0.01576070487499237, 0.001901930314488709, -0.0006016558618284762, -0.01913614571094513, 0.009029300883412361, -0.03427369147539139, -0.003797369310632348, -0.005699299741536379, -0.011067546904087067, 0.01838316209614277, -0.02913263812661171, -0.013066845014691353, -0.035390183329582214, 0.019434740766882896, -0.004014825448393822, 0.026925621554255486, 0.014462459832429886, -0.03494878113269806, 0.007400001864880323, 0.005426668096333742, 0.00027973143733106554, -0.042037203907966614, 0.011216845363378525, 0.030067376792430878, -0.03383228927850723, 0.010171757079660892, 0.0039499131962656975, 0.012222985737025738, 0.006202369928359985, -0.03178105875849724, 0.021265268325805664, 0.011911406181752682, 0.010171757079660892, -0.00912666879594326, 0.00867877434939146, -0.01995404064655304, -0.026328427717089653, 0.013540704734623432, -0.003784386906772852, -0.03227439522743225, -0.02574421651661396, -0.024342112243175507, 0.024394040927290916, -0.01322263479232788, -0.005478597711771727, 0.0011992546496912837, 0.0018775882199406624, -0.027574744075536728, -0.005371492356061935, 0.030352989211678505, 0.028847023844718933, 0.013943161815404892, 0.005342281889170408, -0.020291583612561226, -0.014670179225504398, 0.014955793507397175, -0.000572851044125855, -0.016046319156885147, -0.008594388142228127, -0.0112493010237813, 0.015540003776550293, -0.02983369119465351, -0.009710879996418953, -0.028535446152091026, -0.02504316344857216, -0.017097899690270424, -0.021278250962495804, 0.014047021046280861, -0.008237370289862156, 0.013073336333036423, 0.011891933158040047, 0.011080529540777206, 0.0153712322935462, 0.002919430611655116, -0.02902877889573574, 0.02566632255911827, 0.0016747373156249523, 0.006221843883395195, -0.015280354768037796, -0.03385825455188751, 0.025289831683039665, -0.014215793460607529, -0.051047030836343765, -0.00006562227645190433, -0.001440241583622992, 0.0011594959069043398, 0.01922702230513096, 0.03663650155067444, 0.017136845737695694, 0.01454035472124815, 0.015527021139860153, -0.015306320041418076, -0.012482634745538235, 0.022810181602835655, 0.015436144545674324, 0.012748775072395802, 0.021849479526281357, 0.016383863985538483, -0.0015530267264693975, 0.016137197613716125, -0.01242421381175518, 0.025458602234721184, 0.023563163354992867, 0.011171406134963036, -0.007451931480318308, -0.01569579355418682, -0.026821760460734367, -0.0133589506149292, 0.07488282769918442, -0.030041411519050598, 0.00292754452675581, -0.007581756450235844, 0.03424772620201111, -0.02506912872195244, -0.008886493742465973, 0.020187724381685257, -0.021745620295405388, -0.0031109219416975975, 0.004625000990927219, 0.019421759992837906, -0.007114387582987547, 0.03557194024324417, 0.023913690820336342, -0.021304216235876083, -0.021771583706140518, 0.041180361062288284, -0.014735091477632523, 0.012352810241281986, 0.022978954017162323, -0.029729831963777542, -0.00026208339841105044, 0.0022183777764439583, 0.010385967791080475, -0.03139158710837364, 0.028535446152091026, 0.0048911417834460735, -0.006598334759473801, 0.024588778614997864, 0.00018033447850029916, 0.020953688770532608, 0.023381410166621208, -0.01487789861857891, -0.012975968420505524, -0.010015967302024364, 0.010288598947227001, 0.007412984501570463, 0.027886323630809784, 0.00914614275097847, 0.023537198081612587, 0.046892642974853516, 0.02734106034040451, -0.008925440721213818, -0.03165123611688614, -0.005244913510978222, -0.007880352437496185, 0.05213755741715431, -0.02817193605005741, -0.011534915305674076, 0.000037400641303975135, 0.008068598806858063, 0.036948081105947495, -0.013527723029255867, -0.005702545400708914, 0.026977550238370895, 0.02900281362235546, 0.05914808437228203, 0.00912017747759819, -0.022083163261413574, -0.016474740579724312, -0.012586493976414204, -0.051981765776872635, 0.014319652691483498, 0.027263164520263672, 0.005309825763106346, -0.006202369928359985, -0.020174741744995117, -0.012125616893172264, 0.006913159508258104, 0.0019165355479344726, 0.02323860302567482, -0.0166175477206707, 0.020512286573648453, -0.012300880625844002, -0.017292635515332222, 0.004099211655557156, 0.010911757126450539, -0.03318316489458084, 0.014838950708508492, -0.009775792248547077, -0.0033186411019414663, 0.009568072855472565, 0.02419930510222912, -0.016111232340335846, 0.007114387582987547, 0.005199475213885307, -0.029444217681884766, -0.03133965656161308, 0.014644213952124119, 0.0037194746546447277, -0.0011221712920814753, 0.015578951686620712, 0.017993688583374023, 0.01291754748672247, -0.0033267552498728037, -0.037077903747558594, 0.009399300441145897, 0.02564035728573799, -0.024420006200671196, 0.005997896194458008, 0.014812986366450787, 0.028743164613842964, 0.007607721257954836, 0.008432107046246529, 0.010262633673846722, -0.00046209440915845335, -0.03842807933688164, -0.017889829352498055, -0.017240706831216812, 0.03302737697958946, 0.005910264793783426, 0.002559167332947254, 0.004216053523123264, 0.0015010968782007694, 0.03728562220931053, 0.0039109657518565655, -0.019252987578511238, -0.001017500297166407, -0.010210704058408737, 0.020096847787499428, -0.006166668143123388, 0.003930439706891775, -0.01454035472124815, -0.014034038409590721, -0.022849127650260925, -0.007607721257954836, 0.0050339484587311745, 0.014098950661718845, 0.00384280807338655, -0.031287726014852524, -0.0028561409562826157, 0.021304216235876083, 0.0002647204673849046, 0.021044567227363586, 0.012560529634356499, 0.018110530450940132, -0.009542107582092285, 0.02490035630762577, 0.00786737073212862, -0.02081088162958622, -0.008808598853647709, -0.06241966411471367, -0.03250807896256447, 0.030872289091348648, -0.01648772321641445, -0.009847195819020271, 0.0019100443460047245, -0.0051507907919585705, 0.00878263358026743, -0.01982421614229679, -0.007529826369136572, 0.020408425480127335, 0.008250352926552296, 0.009899125434458256, -0.022978954017162323, -0.03993404656648636, -0.01579965278506279, 0.0008673905394971371, 0.0044400012120604515, -0.016825268045067787, 0.020577197894454002, -0.011840002611279488, -0.0015798030653968453, 0.020122811198234558, -0.0069066681899130344, -0.006835265085101128, -0.01648772321641445, -0.01157386228442192, -0.010476844385266304, 0.0055662295781075954, -0.004495176486670971, 0.019629478454589844, -0.019382812082767487, -0.044503871351480484, -0.014060003682971, -0.012210003100335598, -0.0008828072459436953, -0.028898954391479492, 0.011314213275909424, -0.00289346557110548, -0.05421474948525429, 0.01826632022857666, 0.012820178642868996, 0.0037584220990538597, 0.009762809611856937, 0.010178248398005962, 0.008639826439321041, 0.036169130355119705, 0.0008779388153925538, -0.0006531800027005374, 0.0038817552849650383, 0.011664739809930325, 0.007198773790150881, 0.017772987484931946, 0.03253404423594475, 0.001319342409260571, -0.002729562111198902, 0.0020171497017145157, 0.020927725359797478, 0.0047353520058095455, -0.05060562491416931, 0.001017500297166407, -0.017695091664791107, -0.019603513181209564, -0.001322588068433106, 0.008899475447833538, 0.002789605874568224, 0.026042813435196877, 0.015578951686620712, -0.006345177069306374, -0.001976579427719116, -0.013066845014691353, 0.016163161024451256, 0.0037227203138172626, -0.012210003100335598, -0.002661404199898243, 0.03881755471229553, -0.017993688583374023, -0.0015919740544632077, 0.0297817625105381, 0.00997052900493145, 0.0036545624025166035, -0.005754475016146898, -0.011827020905911922, 0.014644213952124119, 0.008399651385843754, -0.023822812363505363, 0.031002113595604897, 0.016825268045067787, 0.005868071690201759, -0.035182464867830276, -0.014709126204252243, -0.03149544820189476, 0.018876496702432632, 0.0086917569860816, -0.023615093901753426, 0.010048423893749714, -0.021057549864053726, -0.005595440044999123, 0.00833473913371563, -0.011508950032293797, 0.023692987859249115, 0.005903773475438356, 0.023848777636885643, 0.04177755489945412, -0.0009939695009961724, -0.020460356026887894, -0.036896150559186935, 0.019681409001350403, 0.001996053149923682, 0.05057966336607933, 0.018837548792362213, 0.003414386883378029, 0.004076492041349411, -0.02749684825539589, 0.011353161185979843, -0.053591594099998474, -0.019278952851891518, 0.024407023563981056, -0.006718422751873732, -0.00916561670601368, 0.013553687371313572, -0.0007229606853798032, 0.007179299835115671, 0.007419475354254246, -0.03515649959445, -0.00019270837947260588, -0.017721056938171387, -0.016124214977025986, -0.033572640269994736, -0.019447723403573036, 0.003813597373664379, 0.0021485970355570316, -0.011340178549289703, 0.015254389494657516, -0.001976579427719116, -0.0059005278162658215, 0.016968075186014175, 0.0063873701728880405, 0.0013006801018491387, -0.004758071154356003, 0.03572772815823555, 0.004154386930167675, -0.02900281362235546, -0.016189126297831535, -0.03827229142189026, -0.012605967931449413, 0.011567370966076851, 0.01838316209614277, 0.03396211192011833, 0.013891231268644333, 0.01665649563074112, -0.033650536090135574, 0.022225970402359962, -0.023952636867761612, -0.0012747151777148247, -0.014280705712735653, 0.02334246225655079, -0.028405621647834778, 0.012937020510435104, 0.021927373483777046, -0.006377633195370436, 0.005556492600589991, 0.007289650849997997, -0.021992286667227745, -0.026003865525126457, -0.009055265225470066, 0.022135093808174133, -0.026951584964990616, 0.00375193078070879, 0.02656211145222187, 0.03635088726878166, 0.010353511199355125, 0.014371582306921482, 0.0159164946526289, 0.0024893865920603275, 0.02666597068309784, 0.0027425445150583982, 0.021122461184859276, -0.0290807094424963, 0.002216754946857691, 0.025276849046349525, -0.01666947826743126, 0.0347670279443264, 0.02913263812661171, -0.0025916234590113163, 0.061900366097688675, -0.011814038269221783, 0.006711931433528662, 0.012132108211517334, -0.044296152889728546, -0.00912017747759819, 0.010132809169590473, 0.004180351737886667, 0.0020285092759877443, 0.02579614706337452, 0.03154737502336502, -0.00703649315983057, -0.04151790589094162, -0.012489126063883305, -0.012930529192090034, -0.00832824781537056, -0.010561230592429638, -0.016176143661141396, -0.007477896753698587, -0.008535967208445072, -0.013001932762563229, -0.014449477195739746, -0.005196229554712772, 0.022251935675740242, 0.020564215257763863, -0.02998948097229004, -0.011723160743713379, 0.017617197707295418, -0.045957908034324646, 0.04063509777188301, -0.025964919477701187, 0.016150180250406265, -0.004628246650099754, -0.014592284336686134, 0.024420006200671196, -0.025938954204320908, 0.02569228783249855, -0.007244212552905083, 0.013878248631954193, 0.024316146969795227, -0.0011838380014523864, 0.009366844780743122, 0.002046360168606043, 0.006462018936872482, 0.02088877744972706, 0.006452282425016165, -0.003784386906772852, -0.020083865150809288, -0.0626273825764656, 0.032819658517837524, 0.02664000727236271, -0.0012049345532432199, 0.011405090801417828, 0.013852284289896488, 0.008750177919864655, 0.008587896823883057, -0.01750035583972931, 0.011281757615506649, 0.005180001258850098, -0.0173835139721632, 0.017760004848241806, -0.022849127650260925 ]
12.081048
7.004434
2024-07-01
3
2024A&A...687A..35R
[ "DM halos", "compact stellar components", "galaxies", "stellar feedback", "DM masses", "DM", "local scaling relations", "halo", "regularly rotating galaxy discs", "total stellar, gas" ]
[ "galaxies: evolution", "galaxies: high-redshift", "galaxies: ISM", "galaxies: kinematics and dynamics", "submillimeter: galaxies", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
48
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202348828", "10.48550/arXiv.2403.00904" ]
[ "Roman-Oliveira, F.", "Rizzo, F.", "Fraternali, F." ]
[ "Kapteyn Astronomical Institute, University of Groningen, Landleven 12, 9747 AD, Groningen, The Netherlands", "Cosmic Dawn Center (DAWN), Jagtvej 128, 2200, Copenhagen N, Denmark; Niels Bohr Institute, University of Copenhagen, Lyngbyvej 2, 2100, Copenhagen Ø, Denmark", "Kapteyn Astronomical Institute, University of Groningen, Landleven 12, 9747 AD, Groningen, The Netherlands" ]
[ "2024A&A...687A.115B", "2024arXiv240506025R", "2024arXiv240518735C" ]
[ "1964ApJ...139.1217T", "1968adga.book.....S", "1977A&A....54..661T", "1980ApJ...238..471R", "1985ApJ...295..305V", "1997ApJ...490..493N", "1999ApJ...524..169M", "2000ApJ...533L..99M", "2003PASP..115..763C", "2004AIPC..707..388S", "2004ARA&A..42..603K", "2004ApJ...609..652M", "2005MNRAS.362..197T", "2005PASA...22..118G", "2007ASPC..376..127M", "2007ApJ...670..237B", "2007MNRAS.374.1479G", "2008gady.book.....B", "2009AJ....137.4424T", "2009ApJ...690.1452N", "2009ApJ...699L.178N", "2010ApJ...710..903M", "2010Natur.463..781T", "2010gfe..book.....M", "2011ApJ...733..101G", "2011ApJ...739L..40R", "2011MNRAS.413..813C", "2011MNRAS.414..968D", "2011MNRAS.418..664N", "2012ApJ...760...11H", "2013A&A...558A..33A", "2013ARA&A..51..105C", "2013ARA&A..51..207B", "2013ARA&A..51..511K", "2013ApJ...762L..31B", "2013ApJ...766...13D", "2013ApJ...768...74T", "2013MNRAS.429..534D", "2013MNRAS.429.2924H", "2014AJ....148...13R", "2014ApJ...782...68T", "2014ApJ...783...71W", "2014ApJ...791...52B", "2014ApJ...795..158M", "2014ApJS..214...15S", "2014MNRAS.438.1985T", "2014MNRAS.441.1474I", "2014MNRAS.441.3359D", "2014MNRAS.442L..33R", "2014MNRAS.445..581H", "2014PhR...541...45C", "2015ApJ...802...18M", "2015MNRAS.446..521S", "2015MNRAS.451.3021D", "2015MNRAS.452.1217C", "2015Sci...348..314T", "2016A&A...594A..77D", "2016AJ....152..157L", "2016ApJ...816L..14L", "2016ApJ...827...34O", "2016ApJ...829...93K", "2016ApJ...830...63J", "2016ApJ...833...69D", "2016MNRAS.455..214D", "2016MNRAS.456..710F", "2016MNRAS.457.2790T", "2016MNRAS.457.4406A", "2016MNRAS.458.1671K", "2016MNRAS.460..103T", "2017A&A...608A.144Y", "2017ApJ...836..152L", "2017ApJ...837..150S", "2017ApJ...842..121U", "2017ApJ...849...45C", "2017MNRAS.466.4159I", "2017MNRAS.467.1965H", "2017MNRAS.472.2028F", "2018A&A...609A.130L", "2018A&A...612L...6P", "2018AJ....156..123A", "2018ApJ...859...55C", "2018ApJ...864...38L", "2018MNRAS.477.2716K", "2018MNRAS.478.1716P", "2018Natur.553..178S", "2019A&A...629A..59P", "2019A&A...631A..50M", "2019ApJ...870L..19N", "2019ApJS..243...14O", "2019MNRAS.485.3887O", "2019MNRAS.488.1779C", "2019MNRAS.490.3234N", "2019igfe.book.....C", "2020A&A...640A..70M", "2020A&A...641A...1P", "2020A&A...641A..70B", "2020A&A...643A...5D", "2020ARA&A..58..157T", "2020ApJ...899...37K", "2020ApJ...901...74T", "2020ApJ...902..109B", "2020ApJ...903..142G", "2020ApJS..247...61F", "2020MNRAS.493.3132S", "2020MNRAS.496.1620O", "2020MNRAS.499.1250K", "2020MNRAS.499.3578C", "2020Natur.581..269N", "2020Natur.584..201R", "2021A&A...647A.194F", "2021MNRAS.501.2659L", "2021MNRAS.505.5075Y", "2021MNRAS.507.3540J", "2021MNRAS.507.3952R", "2021Sci...371..713L", "2021Sci...372.1201T", "2022A&A...658A..76B", "2022A&A...664A..61S", "2022A&A...667A...5R", "2022A&A...668A.121S", "2022ApJ...930..128R", "2022ApJ...935..167A", "2022ApJ...938L...2F", "2022ApJ...938L..24F", "2022MNRAS.510.3266K", "2022MNRAS.510.3321P", "2022MNRAS.512.5978R", "2022MNRAS.514..480E", "2022MNRAS.517..962D", "2023A&A...671A..44T", "2023A&A...673L...6C", "2023A&A...676A..26G", "2023ApJ...942L...1W", "2023ApJ...942L..42R", "2023ApJ...946L..15K", "2023ApJ...947...20V", "2023ApJ...947...80B", "2023ApJ...948L..13J", "2023ApJ...948L..18N", "2023ApJ...955...94F", "2023ApJ...957L..15T", "2023ApJ...958..132N", "2023ApJ...958L..26H", "2023MNRAS.518.6340D", "2023MNRAS.521.1045R", "2023MNRAS.523.4654T", "2023Natur.623..499C", "2024ApJ...964..192I", "2024MNRAS.527.6110O", "2024MNRAS.527.8941T", "2024MNRAS.530.1984L" ]
29097405
2405.09503
Self-consistent modelling of the Milky Way structure using live potentials
To advance our understanding of the evolution of the interstellar medium (ISM) of our Galaxy, numerical models of Milky Way (MW) type galaxies are widely used. However, most models only vaguely resemble the MW (e.g. in total mass), and often use imposed analytic potentials (which cannot evolve dynamically). This poses a problem in asserting their applicability for the interpretation of observations of our own Galaxy. The goal of this work is to identify a numerical model that is not only an MW-type galaxy, but one that can mimic some of the main observed structures of our Galaxy, using dynamically evolving potentials, so that it can be used as a base model to study the ISM cycle in a galaxy like our own. This paper introduces a suite of 15 MW-type galaxy models developed using the AREPO numerical code, that are compared to Galactic observations of $^{12}$CO and H I emission via longitude-velocity plots, from where we extract and compare the skeletons of major galactic features and the terminal gas velocities. We found that our best-fitting model to the overall structure, also reproduces some of the more specific observed features of the MW, including a bar with a pattern speed of $30.0 \pm 0.2$ km s$^{-1}$ kpc$^{-1}$, and a bar half-length of $3.2 \pm 0.8$ kpc. Our model shows large streaming motions around spiral arms, and strong radial motions well beyond the inner bar. This model highlights the complex motions of a dynamic MW-type galaxy and has the potential to offer valuable insight into how our Galaxy regulates the ISM and star formation.
[ 0.0011840712977573276, 0.025225583463907242, 0.01751776598393917, -0.027301764115691185, -0.05216401815414429, 0.007065499201416969, -0.006046873517334461, -0.03345244750380516, 0.026263674721121788, 0.023149404674768448, -0.05021759867668152, -0.012048331089317799, -0.06379062682390213, -0.013624929822981358, 0.0291703250259161, 0.02015192061662674, -0.010640420950949192, -0.005913868546485901, -0.005810059141367674, 0.034205060452222824, -0.0028028427623212337, -0.00017497492081020027, -0.012859338894486427, 0.059274934232234955, -0.04141978546977043, 0.011198394931852818, -0.032102931290864944, 0.03311506658792496, -0.02896270714700222, -0.02849556691944599, -0.01777729019522667, 0.014027189463376999, -0.04884212836623192, -0.04694761708378792, -0.06887726485729218, 0.06275253742933273, 0.0001699061249382794, 0.02111215330660343, -0.012943683192133904, 0.004366465378552675, -0.008434480056166649, 0.007389902602881193, 0.010679349303245544, 0.04183502122759819, 0.021488461643457413, 0.010919407941401005, -0.004243192262947559, -0.0057711307890713215, 0.04790784791111946, -0.03892837092280388, -0.05302044004201889, 0.0020567155443131924, 0.03150602802634239, -0.040537409484386444, 0.017686456441879272, -0.008213886059820652, -0.011380060575902462, -0.024031780660152435, -0.004953635390847921, 0.014468377456068993, -0.022409765049815178, -0.06270062923431396, -0.05071069300174713, -0.010659885592758656, -0.019282519817352295, -0.0016122834058478475, -0.014624090865254402, -0.0029780203476548195, 0.014143974520266056, 0.05839255452156067, -0.03482791408896446, -0.009453105740249157, -0.0019383084727451205, -0.00473628519102931, -0.002077801851555705, -0.028339853510260582, -0.02553701214492321, -0.030623652040958405, -0.03135031461715698, 0.030156511813402176, -0.005939820781350136, 0.017595624551177025, 0.01145142875611782, -0.013637905940413475, 0.008453944697976112, -0.00009032598609337583, 0.019113829359412193, -0.014105046167969704, -0.028365805745124817, 0.011860176920890808, 0.03576219826936722, 0.021553341299295425, -0.010452267713844776, -0.00431131711229682, 0.003691707272082567, -0.05776970088481903, -0.002087533939629793, -0.03755290061235428, 0.0583406500518322, 0.027872713282704353, 0.004418370313942432, 0.04105645418167114, 0.0120029142126441, -0.023032618686556816, 0.0877704992890358, -0.04222430661320686, 0.03469815477728844, 0.01054958812892437, -0.03586600720882416, 0.017868122085928917, 0.05244949087500572, 0.0027217420283704996, 0.009258463978767395, 0.003315399633720517, -0.04157549887895584, -0.016855984926223755, -0.023032618686556816, 0.036800287663936615, -0.03672242909669876, -0.003234298899769783, -0.001499553327448666, 0.02468058653175831, 0.023434879258275032, 0.013021539896726608, 0.058911602944135666, -0.041705261915922165, -0.02569272555410862, -0.010328994132578373, -0.03462029621005058, 0.04684380814433098, -0.0011581190628930926, -0.00820739846676588, 0.019399303942918777, -0.009712628088891506, -0.0409526452422142, 0.0045578633435070515, -0.0305457953363657, 0.009926734492182732, 0.006831929087638855, 0.03994050994515419, 0.004810897633433342, 0.01741395704448223, 0.003909057471901178, 0.020333586260676384, 0.012969635426998138, 0.006059849634766579, -0.04598738253116608, -0.0003669809957500547, -0.033426493406295776, -0.004032330587506294, -0.008473408408463001, -0.02536832168698311, 0.0072536529041826725, -0.03586600720882416, -0.019710732623934746, 0.02891080267727375, -0.00997215136885643, -0.003750099800527096, 0.005021759774535894, -0.009589355438947678, -0.04295096918940544, 0.004677892662584782, -0.08237243443727493, 0.03127245977520943, -0.019243590533733368, 0.019334424287080765, -0.0540325790643692, 0.004126407206058502, -0.045442383736371994, -0.02135869860649109, 0.009063822217285633, 0.017128482460975647, -0.017595624551177025, -0.0376826636493206, 0.00962828379124403, -0.008492873050272465, 0.004525423049926758, -0.0540325790643692, -0.056056853383779526, -0.009556914679706097, -0.015130160376429558, 0.04282120615243912, -0.012126187793910503, -0.03872075304389, -0.03244030848145485, 0.02706819400191307, -0.025887366384267807, 0.031739600002765656, -0.01371576264500618, -0.016713246703147888, -0.009550427086651325, 0.04668809100985527, 0.059223029762506485, 0.016427772119641304, -0.039758842438459396, -0.017958955839276314, 0.01877645030617714, 0.019542042165994644, -0.024927133694291115, 0.05006188526749611, 0.04720713943243027, -0.0032488969154655933, -0.007337998133152723, -0.06571108847856522, -0.03285554423928261, 0.009031382389366627, 0.034256964921951294, 0.01567515730857849, -0.019438233226537704, 0.025835461914539337, 0.02046334743499756, 0.014624090865254402, 0.008395551703870296, 0.01577896624803543, 0.00021613355784211308, -0.009667212143540382, -0.050035931169986725, 0.04583166912198067, 0.0471552349627018, 0.020748822018504143, -0.01958097144961357, 0.028261996805667877, 0.02495308592915535, 0.0526571087539196, 0.010004591196775436, 0.012677673250436783, 0.011159466579556465, -0.029611514881253242, -0.016765151172876358, 0.018023835495114326, 0.028054378926753998, 0.0020615817047655582, -0.03921384736895561, -0.028287949040532112, -0.00761049659922719, 0.03293340280652046, 0.019451208412647247, 0.02500499039888382, 0.006514014210551977, -0.044819530099630356, -0.04341810941696167, 0.043340254575014114, 0.004587059840559959, -0.006102022249251604, -0.005180717445909977, 0.04110835865139961, 0.0017533986829221249, -0.0056770541705191135, 0.02290285751223564, -0.0240058284252882, 0.02680867165327072, -0.03565838932991028, -0.003331619780510664, -0.01260630413889885, -0.020606083795428276, 0.011243810877203941, -0.03698195144534111, 0.0724586769938469, -0.022708216682076454, 0.005203425418585539, -0.03262197598814964, 0.005427263677120209, -0.02115108072757721, 0.035580530762672424, -0.05011378973722458, 0.05382496118545532, 0.008557753637433052, -0.008719954639673233, 0.0035424816887825727, -0.004963367246091366, 0.024667611345648766, 0.008901621215045452, 0.00627719983458519, -0.023292141035199165, -0.02885889820754528, -0.012483030557632446, -0.031739600002765656, 0.05839255452156067, 0.027509381994605064, -0.017063602805137634, 0.01629801094532013, -0.04409286752343178, 0.041497644037008286, 0.04103050380945206, -0.030675556510686874, 0.03397149220108986, 0.0020486055873334408, 0.02743152529001236, -0.021228937432169914, -0.035424817353487015, 0.06083206832408905, -0.03796813637018204, -0.03257007151842117, -0.038694798946380615, 0.0005389146390371025, -0.024291303008794785, 0.024732491001486778, 0.015467539429664612, 0.009719116613268852, 0.011912081390619278, 0.048037610948085785, 0.014559210278093815, -0.008655074052512646, -0.0062090749852359295, -0.035528626292943954, -0.03607362508773804, 0.041186217218637466, 0.002368142595514655, -0.0036203383933752775, 0.05382496118545532, 0.007889483124017715, -0.006342080421745777, 0.01846502348780632, 0.018906211480498314, -0.06898107379674911, -0.03918789327144623, -0.02137167565524578, 0.02510879933834076, 0.029455801472067833, -0.01910085417330265, -0.06908488273620605, -0.03101293556392193, -0.043080732226371765, -0.005706250201910734, 0.004265900701284409, -0.02896270714700222, 0.01588277518749237, -0.030208416283130646, -0.010114888660609722, 0.027820808812975883, 0.02025572955608368, -0.021773936226963997, 0.051255688071250916, 0.0024670856073498726, 0.009485546499490738, -0.04243192449212074, -0.028469614684581757, 0.06892916560173035, -0.020774774253368378, 0.020502274855971336, -0.030727460980415344, 0.03096103109419346, -0.018542880192399025, -0.015389682725071907, 0.010050008073449135, 0.0158308707177639, -0.0008985965396277606, 0.03944741562008858, 0.035269103944301605, -0.05496685951948166, -0.0005462137050926685, -0.00862912181764841, 0.027509381994605064, 0.008661562576889992, 0.06872154772281647, -0.021345723420381546, 0.02717200294137001, -0.07598818093538284, -0.00015540936146862805, 0.02089155837893486, -0.006273955572396517, -0.0016082283109426498, 0.041290026158094406, 0.014611114747822285, -0.024719515815377235, 0.04759642109274864, -0.019957277923822403, 0.012275412678718567, -0.027665095403790474, -0.014987423084676266, 0.01361195370554924, 0.03064960427582264, -0.0633234828710556, 0.05224187299609184, -0.033634111285209656, -0.010491196066141129, 0.041341930627822876, 0.0019269543699920177, 0.0051644970662891865, 0.004882266744971275, 0.051930446177721024, 0.050087835639715195, -0.011613630689680576, -0.018815379589796066, 0.005398067645728588, 0.007123891729861498, -0.0003235920739825815, 0.003688463242724538, -0.06015731021761894, 0.020489299669861794, -0.014650044031441212, 0.008032220415771008, -0.010562564246356487, 0.02543320320546627, -0.001732312492094934, -0.03155793249607086, 0.045442383736371994, 0.0326998308300972, 0.006838417146354914, 0.03918789327144623, -0.03677433356642723, 0.008382575586438179, -0.05475924164056778, -0.0340753011405468, -0.041860975325107574, 0.010478219948709011, 0.0349317230284214, 0.027094146236777306, 0.0195290669798851, 0.029845084995031357, 0.052994489669799805, -0.02300666645169258, 0.031038887798786163, -0.04282120615243912, 0.002496281871572137, 0.01155523769557476, -0.050996165722608566, 0.04315858706831932, 0.025757605209946632, 0.06835822016000748, 0.012197555974125862, -0.022344885393977165, -0.0286512803286314, -0.020190848037600517, -0.03334863856434822, 0.004437834490090609, 0.012677673250436783, 0.019477160647511482, -0.024122614413499832, -0.07386009395122528, -0.03402339667081833, 0.06259682029485703, 0.009978638961911201, -0.008317694999277592, -0.0150133753195405, -0.0270162895321846, 0.009063822217285633, -0.005544048734009266, 0.053305916488170624, 0.00288880942389369, 0.027872713282704353, -0.029715323820710182, -0.022396789863705635, -0.02052822709083557, 0.062389202415943146, 0.023979876190423965, 0.029092468321323395, 0.03295935317873955, -0.028884850442409515, -0.033530302345752716, 0.019373351708054543, 0.0005847365828230977, -0.03238840401172638, 0.010277089662849903, -0.002167012542486191, -0.025017965584993362, 0.025913318619132042, -0.027924617752432823, 0.06690489500761032, -0.048504751175642014, 0.004269144497811794, -0.014766829088330269, -0.026678910478949547, 0.02131977118551731, -0.03319292515516281, 0.010776670649647713, -0.014182902872562408, -0.010835063643753529, -0.03560648486018181, 0.008116565644741058, 0.033374588936567307, -0.06752774864435196, -0.019191686064004898, -0.024226423352956772, 0.01110107358545065, -0.0006650263094343245, -0.035321008414030075, 0.0177253857254982, 0.06462109833955765, 0.004619500134140253, 0.0345943458378315, 0.010062984190881252, 0.017634551972150803, 0.03783837705850601, 0.025666773319244385, 0.007837578654289246, -0.035476721823215485, -0.036696478724479675, -0.021916672587394714, 0.007052523083984852, -0.0204763226211071, -0.03994050994515419, 0.058807794004678726, -0.01381957158446312, 0.0442226305603981, -0.03464625030755997, -0.029533658176660538, -0.010212209075689316, -0.028521519154310226, 0.027976522222161293, 0.04889403283596039, 0.028625328093767166, 0.019918350502848625, -0.000695033639203757, 0.02115108072757721, 0.015584324486553669, -0.023499760776758194, 0.0015863311709836125, 0.001197047415189445, -0.010348458774387836, -0.045130956918001175, 0.04562405124306679, -0.004184799734503031, 0.011406012810766697, 0.027665095403790474, 0.017388004809617996, 0.012800945900380611, 0.03449053689837456, 0.040070269256830215, -0.01956799440085888, -0.029663419350981712, 0.012372734025120735, 0.007850554771721363, -0.01804978772997856, 0.0002962205617222935, -0.014260759577155113, -0.02712009847164154, -0.10406851023435593, -0.062389202415943146, 0.01442944910377264, -0.012171603739261627, 0.0038895930629223585, 0.02479737251996994, -0.014909566380083561, -0.00360736227594316, -0.020450370386242867, -0.03070150874555111, -0.013144813477993011, -0.0025189900770783424, -0.03825361281633377, 0.024654634296894073, -0.014870638027787209, 0.006903297733515501, -0.0015936301788315177, 0.017530743032693863, 0.04020003229379654, -0.012567375786602497, -0.0007376115536317229, 0.04915355518460274, 0.044923339039087296, 0.036696478724479675, 0.006095534190535545, -0.002338946331292391, 0.016012536361813545, -0.026730814948678017, -0.00040367909241467714, -0.012093747034668922, -0.013079932890832424, 0.026419388130307198, 0.021384650841355324, -0.04040765017271042, -0.0005052578053437173, 0.01968478038907051, 0.038642894476652145, 0.018400143831968307, -0.03947336971759796, -0.03267388045787811, -0.027924617752432823, -0.03872075304389, 0.03620338439941406, -0.010218697600066662, -0.0033186436630785465, -0.003938253503292799, -0.027872713282704353, -0.01999620720744133, -0.010899944230914116, -0.0535135343670845, 0.013365407474339008, 0.014909566380083561, -0.031531982123851776, -0.010296554304659367, -0.00881078839302063, 0.011581189930438995, -0.00663404306396842, -0.034049347043037415, -0.0077921622432768345, 0.009861853905022144, 0.013988261111080647, 0.03755290061235428, 0.026704862713813782, -0.019697755575180054, -0.0305457953363657, 0.011425476521253586, -0.015026351436972618, -0.02305857092142105, -0.002124840160831809, 0.015804918482899666, 0.030052702873945236, -0.014701948501169682, -0.001972370781004429, -0.0001671689678914845, 0.00796733982861042, -0.007415854837745428, 0.001523072482086718, -0.0335562564432621, 0.026886528357863426, -0.031583886593580246, 0.014650044031441212, -0.009719116613268852, -0.01108160987496376, -0.021021319553256035, 0.010335482656955719, -0.020502274855971336, -0.040329791605472565, -0.015740038827061653, -0.010731254704296589, -0.011976961977779865, -0.003957717679440975, 0.03921384736895561, -0.003000728553161025, -0.015506467781960964, -0.01128922775387764, 0.058807794004678726, -0.006153926718980074, 0.04030384123325348, -0.009978638961911201, 0.010543100535869598, -0.022085363045334816, -0.02622474543750286, -0.003652778686955571, 0.007123891729861498, -0.04404096305370331, 0.026406411081552505, -0.008908108808100224, 0.00012996398436371237, -0.009011917747557163, -0.008609658107161522, 0.000025027191441040486, -0.02737962082028389, -0.017426934093236923, 0.002032385440543294, -0.006780024617910385, 0.011224347166717052, -0.00569651834666729, 0.02758723869919777, 0.024667611345648766, -0.012768506072461605, -0.010588516481220722, -0.044767625629901886, -0.01788109913468361, 0.008668050169944763, -0.0332188755273819, 0.02643236331641674, 0.03023436851799488, 0.02416154183447361, -0.01631098799407482, 0.004574083723127842, 0.0029780203476548195, -0.04520881548523903, 0.01023167371749878, -0.006358300801366568, 0.0018296334892511368, -0.005706250201910734, -0.03508743643760681, -0.013676834292709827, 0.01624610647559166, -0.029767228290438652, 0.02992294169962406, -0.006163658574223518, 0.023382974788546562, 0.06020921468734741, -0.006728120148181915, -0.017712408676743507, 0.02226702868938446, 0.001444404711946845, -0.0116590466350317, 0.017478838562965393, -0.06851392984390259, -0.03757885470986366, -0.006669727619737387, 0.04598738253116608, 0.022176194936037064, -0.025147726759314537, -0.0023097500670701265, 0.03560648486018181, 0.021812863647937775, 0.015765991061925888, 0.021553341299295425, -0.00011029704910470173, 0.0016804080223664641, 0.02932604029774666, -0.022487621754407883, 0.01967180334031582, 0.02474546805024147, -0.007260140962898731, -0.03620338439941406, 0.018075739964842796, -0.01128922775387764, -0.00897298939526081, -0.058859698474407196, 0.019749660044908524, 0.01725824363529682, -0.007629960775375366, -0.009135191328823566, -0.006150682456791401, -0.016959793865680695, -0.01882835477590561, 0.005466192029416561, -0.007039546966552734, -0.03861694410443306, 0.01614229753613472, 0.004645452369004488, -0.007578056305646896, -0.00650103809311986, -0.0174658615142107, -0.005806815344840288, 0.030467938631772995, 0.008940549567341805, -0.041290026158094406, -0.0008081691921688616, 0.014364568516612053, -0.008012756705284119, -0.05813303217291832, -0.00711091561242938, 0.030779365450143814, -0.035684339702129364, -0.0036008742172271013, 0.0504252165555954, -0.022344885393977165, -0.04443024843931198, 0.020009182393550873, 0.00801924429833889, 0.0022124291863292456, -0.027353668585419655, 0.010471731424331665, 0.03207697719335556, -0.009167631156742573, -0.040329791605472565, -0.0204763226211071, 0.044923339039087296, -0.0006394796073436737, 0.01239868625998497, -0.024706538766622543, -0.005962528754025698, 0.0060403854586184025, -0.011308691464364529, 0.015856822952628136, 0.0021118640433996916, 0.009044358506798744, 0.014611114747822285, 0.005109348800033331, 0.011412500403821468, 0.012353269383311272, 0.005738690495491028, 0.017154434695839882, -0.018750498071312904, 0.02743152529001236, -0.013806595467031002, 0.0163499154150486, 0.0414716899394989, 0.008343647234141827, 0.0466361865401268, 0.01366385817527771, 0.022552503272891045, -0.03135031461715698, -0.01841311901807785, -0.005135301034897566, 0.015052303671836853, 0.0259003434330225, -0.01636289246380329, -0.030623652040958405, 0.02712009847164154, 0.00484009413048625, -0.032051026821136475, 0.022176194936037064, 0.004820629954338074, 0.016868960112333298, 0.004132895264774561, -0.01882835477590561, 0.024083685129880905, -0.00019007993978448212, -0.02706819400191307, -0.003234298899769783, -0.03475005924701691, 0.005187205504626036, 0.002664971398189664, -0.0004326726193539798, -0.014844685792922974, -0.017426934093236923, -0.018426096066832542, -0.018958115950226784, 0.015532420016825199, 0.008927573449909687, 0.020229777321219444, -0.011470893397927284, 0.01946418546140194, -0.011516309343278408, -0.10775373131036758, 0.018633713945746422, 0.03451648727059364, 0.046817854046821594, -0.003312155604362488, 0.018426096066832542, -0.015623252838850021, 0.011522797867655754, 0.00377929606474936, -0.008758882991969585, 0.0038636408280581236, -0.01058202888816595, -0.00726662902161479, 0.056264471262693405, 0.046817854046821594, -0.023940948769450188, -0.0085188252851367, -0.0010640420950949192, -0.03039008192718029, -0.001420885557308793, -0.015337778255343437, 0.03376387432217598, 0.028261996805667877, -0.00952447485178709, -0.030831269919872284, -0.025082847103476524, -0.019386328756809235, 0.002999106654897332, 0.018439071252942085, -0.005388335324823856, -0.029845084995031357, -0.01448135357350111, 0.017232291400432587, 0.04157549887895584, -0.028988659381866455, -0.010614468716084957, -0.00019808864453807473, 0.012541423551738262, 0.004619500134140253, 0.006640531122684479, -0.03171364590525627, -0.031168648973107338, 0.01039387471973896, 0.022669287398457527, 0.040174078196287155, 0.0031353558879345655, 0.02305857092142105, 0.028080331161618233, -0.0019529066048562527, -0.013793619349598885, -0.0033705481328070164, -0.0009253598400391638, -0.012612791731953621, 0.020982392132282257, -0.038954321295022964, 0.007065499201416969, 0.003260251134634018, 0.011834224686026573, -0.0395771786570549, -0.023227261379361153, -0.009556914679706097, -0.014390520751476288, 0.010335482656955719, 0.013495168648660183, -0.06290824711322784, -0.02870318479835987, -0.002374630654230714, 0.022280003875494003, -0.008661562576889992, -0.01387147605419159, -0.0007635637884959579, 0.04435238987207413, 0.013190229423344135, -0.006780024617910385, 0.0006642153020948172, -0.0017258244333788753, -0.04936117306351662, 0.018023835495114326, -0.04450810328125954, -0.00016331668302882463, -0.010400363244116306, -0.04409286752343178, 0.027457477524876595, -0.028313901275396347, 0.000022822263417765498, 0.030416034162044525, 0.01973668485879898, -0.023136427626013756, -0.024992013350129128, 0.013229157775640488, 0.008655074052512646, -0.010867503471672535, 0.017323125153779984, 0.021760959178209305, -0.030312225222587585, 0.028781041502952576, 0.0188413318246603, -0.021981554105877876, 0.022928809747099876, -0.018452048301696777, -0.029845084995031357, 0.011620118282735348, -0.01532480213791132, -0.01028357818722725, 0.038383372128009796, -0.0354507714509964, -0.02416154183447361, 0.02427832782268524, 0.034101251512765884, 0.04723308980464935, 0.040329791605472565, 0.00015885614266153425, -0.03454244136810303, 0.034308869391679764, 0.04580571502447128, -0.011782320216298103, -0.022591430693864822, 0.006715144030749798, 0.01189910527318716, 0.013131837360560894, -0.041964784264564514, -0.01567515730857849, -0.04248382896184921, -0.00023640875588171184, 0.015259921550750732, 0.026367483660578728, -0.0023113719653338194, -0.01655753329396248, -0.01260630413889885, 0.01655753329396248, -0.005719226319342852, 0.019451208412647247, 0.036540765315294266, -0.015246945433318615, -0.04627285525202751, 0.0015246944967657328, -0.0003771185874938965, 0.0291703250259161, 0.0096801882609725, 0.013190229423344135, 0.008797812275588512, 0.004411882255226374, 0.020268704742193222, -0.009187095798552036, 0.04943903163075447, 0.011152978055179119, -0.015571348369121552, -0.0012027244083583355, 0.05538209527730942, 0.021397627890110016, 0.0012740931706503034, 0.001049443962983787, 0.006614578887820244, 0.0016836520517244935, -0.006517258007079363, -0.0002672270347829908, -0.014857661910355091, -0.0037922721821814775, 0.003500309307128191, 0.009842390194535255, 0.02784676104784012, 0.03796813637018204, 0.011243810877203941, -0.035372912883758545, -0.004272388760000467, 0.00952447485178709, -0.025173678994178772, 0.012580351904034615, 0.00007664022996323183, 0.018906211480498314, -0.008298231288790703, -0.03571029379963875, 0.037319332361221313, -0.02135869860649109, 0.020541204139590263, 0.03238840401172638, -0.0008734553121030331, -0.031090792268514633, 0.006030653603374958, 0.03249221295118332, 0.007136867847293615, 0.01102970540523529, 0.0015141514595597982, 0.030000798404216766, 0.024291303008794785, -0.006046873517334461, -0.00554080493748188, -0.00042659006430767477, 0.006056605838239193, 0.005339674651622772, -0.0027395840734243393, 0.03898027539253235, -0.027042241767048836, 0.06373871862888336, 0.03288149833679199, -0.00008535856613889337, -0.007545616012066603, 0.016855984926223755, 0.0029115176293998957, 0.0222021471709013, 0.00009306313586421311, -0.029248181730508804, 0.006507526151835918, -0.011801784858107567, -0.0019739929120987654, 0.03257007151842117, -0.01023167371749878, 0.011178930290043354, -0.05091831088066101, 0.005780863109976053, 0.03340054303407669, -0.0033608160447329283, 0.05218996852636337, 0.022967739030718803, 0.012288388796150684, -0.02173500694334507, -0.0062090749852359295, -0.04287311062216759, -0.02875508926808834, -0.018348239362239838, 0.051411401480436325, -0.04209454357624054, -0.020125968381762505, 0.020125968381762505, 0.008998941630125046, 0.03550267592072487, -0.011542261578142643, 0.016285035759210587, 0.00548890046775341, -0.0004249680496286601, -0.007195260375738144, 0.020696917548775673, -0.0034516488667577505, -0.01392338052392006, -0.029507705941796303, -0.006883833557367325, 0.0016009293030947447, 0.005313722416758537, 0.010964824818074703, -0.008505849167704582, 0.007655913010239601, 0.012839874252676964, 0.003357572015374899, 0.0018831599736586213, 0.009161143563687801, -0.0049730995669960976, 0.029196277260780334, -0.0013584379339590669, 0.005819791462272406, -0.01506527978926897, -0.018711570650339127, -0.004982831422239542, -0.031038887798786163, -0.009037869982421398, -0.005294258240610361, 0.04443024843931198, -0.013300526887178421, 0.02257845550775528, -0.014066117815673351, -0.010199232958257198, 0.024096662178635597, 0.006264223717153072, -0.0390581339597702, -0.02927413582801819, 0.019269542768597603, 0.01662241481244564, -0.03765670955181122, 0.0006236649351194501, 0.015791943296790123, -0.003724147565662861, 0.025705700740218163, -0.019191686064004898, 0.030260320752859116, 0.014130998402833939, 0.010802622884511948, 0.011003753170371056, -0.0033737921621650457, -0.019178710877895355, 0.010296554304659367, 0.01908787712454796, -0.011938033625483513, -0.004784945398569107, 0.01149684563279152, -0.009641259908676147, 0.024979038164019585, 0.024304280057549477, -0.016285035759210587, 0.002058337675407529, -0.0009942954638972878, -0.0029520681127905846, -0.017738360911607742, 0.020917510613799095, 0.018815379589796066, 0.0036787311546504498, -0.005690030287951231, -0.01777729019522667, -0.01767348125576973, -0.008706978522241116, -0.0181535966694355, -0.034308869391679764, -0.022565478459000587, 0.009952686727046967, 0.023344045504927635, -0.035788148641586304, -0.001582276076078415, -0.03586600720882416, -0.007305557373911142, -0.017842169851064682, -0.007746745832264423, 0.008038708940148354, -0.038383372128009796, -0.00973209273070097, 0.02120298519730568, 0.015350754372775555, 0.021501436829566956, -0.04401501268148422, -0.017647529020905495, -0.0022902858909219503, 0.012638743966817856, -0.0022221612744033337, 0.007539127953350544, -0.028184140101075172, 0.004846582189202309, -0.000277161889243871, -0.0200481116771698, -0.01798490807414055, 0.008453944697976112, -0.014792781323194504, 0.028573423624038696, 0.02295476198196411, 0.024771420285105705, 0.04103050380945206, 0.025939270853996277, -0.011457917280495167, -0.018815379589796066, -0.0030558770522475243, 0.01305398065596819, 0.034905772656202316, 0.03059769980609417, 0.006526990327984095, 0.007882995530962944, -0.019282519817352295, -0.03612552955746651, 0.014494329690933228, -0.025653796270489693, 0.02125488966703415, -0.016544558107852936, -0.0019593946635723114, -0.015363730490207672, -0.0031807722989469767, 0.06835822016000748, -0.01878942735493183, 0.0032375429291278124, -0.007247164845466614, 0.023032618686556816, -0.03443863242864609, -0.008888645097613335, 0.021657150238752365, -0.008771859109401703, -0.01614229753613472, 0.00988780613988638, -0.003234298899769783, -0.004596791695803404, 0.013313503004610538, 0.03316697105765343, -0.014416472986340523, 0.013144813477993011, 0.010757206939160824, -0.025511059910058975, 0.03783837705850601, 0.009323344565927982, -0.023123452439904213, -0.011165954172611237, 0.023499760776758194, 0.0047006006352603436, -0.013936356641352177, 0.02126786671578884, -0.0022643336560577154, -0.01226243656128645, 0.0015068523352965713, -0.02464165911078453, 0.021190010011196136, -0.017556695267558098, -0.0018199012847617269, 0.0023762525524944067, 0.0069876424968242645, 0.004006378352642059, -0.010050008073449135, 0.013255110010504723, 0.009187095798552036, 0.04572786018252373, -0.000835337967146188, 0.012126187793910503, -0.0316617414355278, -0.00041685797623358667, 0.00822686217725277, 0.013780643232166767, 0.026523197069764137, 0.025225583463907242, -0.036592669785022736, -0.024602729827165604, -0.01851692795753479, 0.015350754372775555, 0.005582977086305618, 0.03075341321527958, 0.018971092998981476, 0.005278038326650858, 0.053305916488170624, 0.025472130626440048, -0.03464625030755997, 0.020125968381762505, -0.03049389086663723, -0.007422342896461487, 0.04437834396958351, 0.011211371049284935, -0.0029017855413258076, 0.027249859645962715, -0.0017096042865887284, 0.012353269383311272, 0.023149404674768448, -0.004408637993037701, -0.007746745832264423, -0.011127025820314884, 0.005200181622058153, -0.004963367246091366, -0.010938872583210468, -0.026652958244085312, -0.0036754871252924204, -0.005514852702617645, -0.0030283029191195965, 0.009271440096199512, -0.03755290061235428, -0.013248622417449951, 0.03926575183868408, -0.02421344630420208, 0.00029642332810908556, 0.01972370781004429, 0.0025206119753420353, -0.04045955464243889, 0.03898027539253235, -0.02901461161673069, -0.01677812822163105, -0.015208017081022263, -0.01956799440085888, 0.038798607885837555, 0.011613630689680576, 0.00003429042044444941, -0.0029731544200330973, -0.0037306356243789196, 0.005203425418585539, -0.018750498071312904, -0.0039252773858606815, 0.04557214677333832, -0.037007905542850494, 0.01741395704448223, 0.0015352376503869891, -0.014442425221204758, -0.04552024230360985, -0.004577327519655228, 0.017439909279346466, 0.012126187793910503, 0.01825740560889244, 0.04025193676352501, -0.01725824363529682, 0.007831091061234474, 0.02579653449356556, 0.012904754839837551, -0.012826898135244846, -0.0013268085895106196, -0.022773096337914467, 0.014727900736033916, 0.013936356641352177, 0.002277309773489833, 0.012800945900380611, -0.037163618952035904, -0.0017290684627369046, 0.0010680971900001168, -0.0181535966694355, -0.008538288995623589, 0.01794597879052162, -0.016181226819753647, 0.01646670140326023, 0.010062984190881252, 0.014909566380083561, 0.0275353342294693, -0.017868122085928917, 0.002879077335819602, -0.029533658176660538, 0.007344486191868782, 0.005560269113630056, 0.009349296800792217, 0.005005539860576391, -0.038487181067466736, -0.028988659381866455, 0.018179548904299736, 0.01572706177830696, 0.00862263422459364, 0.018542880192399025, 0.0024573535192757845, -0.0003053444088436663, -0.03677433356642723, 0.00033109390642493963, -0.0016244484577327967, -0.005894404370337725, -0.014688972383737564, 0.002139438409358263, -0.03129841014742851, -0.0038636408280581236, -0.008051685057580471, -0.013144813477993011, -0.0049698553048074245, 0.008752395398914814, -0.0020112991333007812, 0.02758723869919777, 0.008739419281482697, 0.009206559509038925, -0.0006321805412881076, -0.01060149259865284, -0.01629801094532013, -0.03965503349900246, 0.004541643429547548, -0.01104916911572218, 0.00791543535888195, -0.004603279754519463, -0.021773936226963997, -0.03477600961923599, 0.02141060307621956, 0.008058172650635242, -0.04847879707813263, 0.0017469106242060661, -0.0006390740745700896, -0.0003698195214383304, 0.023279165849089622, -0.010828575119376183, -0.00536887114867568, -0.0025838706642389297, 0.015701109543442726, -0.00531696667894721, 0.026730814948678017, 0.00947257038205862, 0.02247464656829834, 0.00600145710632205, -0.009589355438947678, 0.036333147436380386, 0.017323125153779984, 0.04873831942677498, -0.018244430422782898, -0.04227621108293533, -0.007941387593746185, 0.03887646645307541, -0.01097780093550682, -0.01989239826798439, 0.05424019694328308, -0.018023835495114326, -0.00627719983458519, 0.0181535966694355, 0.006484817713499069, 0.021618222817778587, -0.0013762800954282284, 0.012684160843491554, -0.022072385996580124, -0.04152359440922737, -0.001056743087247014, 0.014014213345944881, 0.05444781482219696, 0.03298530727624893, -0.02927413582801819, 0.021566318348050117, -0.02395392395555973, 0.007688353303819895, 0.0457797646522522, 0.027146050706505775, -0.005557024851441383, 0.01946418546140194, -0.015908727422356606, 0.008583705872297287, 0.004551375284790993, -0.00867453869432211, 0.010556076653301716, 0.05239758640527725, -0.00696169026196003, -0.04100454971194267, -0.00973209273070097, -0.001349516911432147, -0.0209953673183918, 0.01631098799407482, 0.014234807342290878, 0.033426493406295776, -0.0019950789865106344, 0.018010860309004784, 0.010906431823968887, -0.00936876144260168, 0.0390581339597702, 0.025199631229043007, 0.0062123192474246025, 0.018010860309004784, 0.012813922017812729, 0.009329833090305328, -0.03288149833679199, 0.008097101002931595, 0.010517148301005363, 0.04689571261405945, -0.0000970167966443114, 0.01836121454834938, 0.00530074629932642, -0.007234188728034496, 0.029689371585845947, -0.020554179325699806, -0.002883943496271968, 0.04741475731134415, -0.0010599871166050434, 0.006877345498651266, 0.023447856307029724, 0.02447296865284443, 0.0325181670486927, 0.026211770251393318, -0.025731652975082397, -0.03560648486018181, -0.005232621915638447, -0.007448295131325722, 0.01189910527318716, -0.05460352823138237, -0.007260140962898731, 0.0039285216480493546, 0.034853868186473846, -0.008045196533203125, -0.006270711775869131, -0.023097500205039978, 0.031635791063308716, 0.004746017046272755, 0.026834623888134956, -0.0015003642765805125, 0.0452607199549675, -0.01108160987496376, -0.02717200294137001, 0.0025352102238684893, -0.001582276076078415, -0.019217638298869133, -0.009446618147194386, 0.01972370781004429, 0.06425776332616806, -0.018296334892511368, 0.013105885125696659, -0.03275173529982567, 0.009355785325169563, -0.0018620737828314304, -0.0019496625754982233, 0.004671404603868723, 0.04362572729587555, 0.010309530422091484, 0.006270711775869131, -0.005462948232889175, -0.03677433356642723, -0.017076577991247177, 0.021605245769023895, -0.00786353088915348, -0.010718277655541897, 0.0235776174813509, 0.02410963736474514, 0.0025562962982803583, 0.03661862015724182, 0.011672022752463818, 0.005057444330304861, 0.023655474185943604, -0.01830931007862091, 0.0286512803286314, -0.023071547970175743, 0.062181584537029266, 0.0028563691303133965, 0.0024281570222228765, -0.006050117779523134, 0.005132056772708893, 0.036956001073122025, 0.0444042943418026, 0.024044757708907127, 0.01028357818722725, 0.009777509607374668, 0.011749880388379097, 0.023863092064857483, 0.008888645097613335, 0.011646070517599583, -0.021488461643457413, 0.00639722915366292, -0.006896809674799442, -0.012859338894486427, -0.011418988928198814, -0.014079093933105469, 0.0222021471709013, 0.02490118145942688, -0.028936754912137985, 0.013028028421103954, -0.024122614413499832, 0.0032472750172019005, -0.02443404123187065, -0.028417710214853287, 0.012541423551738262, 0.008564241230487823, -0.007772698067128658, -0.03018246404826641, -0.03039008192718029, 0.011925057508051395, -0.019983230158686638, -0.03737123683094978, -0.03693004697561264, 0.028988659381866455, 0.007299069315195084, 0.0019188442965969443, -0.00592035660520196, 0.010932384058833122, -0.02051525190472603, -0.0188413318246603, 0.027665095403790474, -0.010718277655541897, -0.015753014013171196, 0.023824162781238556, 0.0026211768854409456, -0.0001580451353220269, -0.040277887135744095, -0.005832767579704523, -0.0003533966082613915, 0.025822486728429794, 0.030779365450143814, 0.0022546015679836273, -0.03433482348918915, -0.04243192449212074, -0.049984026700258255, 0.017478838562965393, 0.014195878989994526, 0.027665095403790474, 0.01311237271875143, 0.029144372791051865, 0.0016950061544775963, 0.007668889127671719, -0.00552458455786109, 0.010037031956017017, -0.0332188755273819, -0.017128482460975647, 0.010147328488528728, 0.007870019413530827 ]
10.112701
6.96693
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.532..126D
[ "most models", "strong radial motions", "MW", "large streaming motions", "major galactic features", "Galaxy", "imposed analytic potentials", "Galactic observations", "ISM", "15 MW-type galaxy models" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
34
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1469", "10.48550/arXiv.2405.09503" ]
[ "Durán-Camacho, Eva", "Duarte-Cabral, Ana", "Pettitt, Alex R.", "Treß, Robin G.", "Clark, Paul C.", "Klessen, Ralf S.", "Bogue, Kamran R. J.", "Smith, Rowan J.", "Sormani, Mattia C." ]
[ "School of Physics and Astronomy, Cardiff University, Cardiff CF24 3AA, UK", "School of Physics and Astronomy, Cardiff University, Cardiff CF24 3AA, UK", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, California State University, Sacramento, 6000 J Street, Sacramento, CA 95819-6041, USA", "Institute of Physics, Laboratory for Galaxy Evolution and Spectral Modelling, EPFL, Observatoire de Sauverny, Chemin Pegais 51, CH-1290 Versoix, Switzerland", "School of Physics and Astronomy, Cardiff University, Cardiff CF24 3AA, UK", "Zentrum fur Astronomie, Institut für Theoretische Astrophysik, Universität Heidelberg, Albert-Ueberle-Str. 2, D-69120 Heidelberg, Germany; Interdisziplinäres Zentrum fur Wissenschaftliches Rechnen, Universität Heidelberg, Im Neuenheimer Feld 205, D-69120 Heidelberg, Germany", "School of Physics and Astronomy, University of St Andrews, North Haugh, St Andrews, KY16 9SS, UK", "School of Physics and Astronomy, University of St Andrews, North Haugh, St Andrews, KY16 9SS, UK; Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9PL, UK", "Zentrum fur Astronomie, Institut für Theoretische Astrophysik, Universität Heidelberg, Albert-Ueberle-Str. 2, D-69120 Heidelberg, Germany" ]
null
[ "1958MNRAS.118..379O", "1959ApJ...129..243S", "1962MNRAS.123..327K", "1970IAUS...38..126W", "1975ApJ...195..617P", "1976A&A....49...57G", "1976MNRAS.175....1C", "1976MNRAS.176..495C", "1982ApJ...259L..63K", "1985ApJ...295..422C", "1985IAUS..106..255E", "1986ApJ...305..892D", "1989A&ARv...1..261C", "1989ApJ...344..685K", "1990ApJ...356..359H", "1991A&A...252...75P", "1991ARA&A..29..581Y", "1991ApJ...379..631B", "1991MNRAS.252..210B", "1992ApJ...384...81W", "1992MNRAS.259..328A", "1992MNRAS.259..345A", "1993ApJ...411..674T", "1994ApJ...425L..81W", "1994ApJ...429L..73S", "1996ASPC...91..286C", "1996ApJ...462..563N", "1997ApJ...482L.143R", "1997MNRAS.288..365B", "1998gaas.book.....B", "1999A&A...345..787F", "1999AJ....118..126B", "1999ApJ...513..242L", "1999ApJ...524..112W", "2000A&A...358L..13D", "2000MNRAS.317L..45H", "2001ApJ...547..792D", "2001ApJ...550..243B", "2001ApJ...551..254W", "2001ApJS..136..189S", "2002MNRAS.330..591B", "2003ApJ...582..756K", "2003MNRAS.340..949B", "2004AJ....127..279B", "2004ApJ...611L.145M", "2004JKAS...37..199M", "2005ApJ...630L.149B", "2005MNRAS.361..776S", "2005MNRAS.364.1105S", "2006PASJ...58..847N", "2007A&A...465..825C", "2007A&A...469..471L", "2007MNRAS.377.1795C", "2008A&A...477L..21M", "2008A&A...489..115R", "2008AJ....135.1301V", "2008gady.book.....B", "2009ARA&A..47...27K", "2010A&A...520A..49S", "2010ApJ...722.1460S", "2010MNRAS.401..791S", "2011A&A...528A..50D", "2011A&A...529A..41N", "2011A&A...529L...6A", "2011ARep...55..108E", "2011ApJ...735....1W", "2012MNRAS.421.2940D", "2012MNRAS.422.1283F", "2012PASJ...64...75S", "2012PASP..124.1015B", "2013A&A...555A.112P", "2013AJ....146...19L", "2013ApJ...779...45M", "2013MNRAS.429..987L", "2013MNRAS.432..653D", "2013MNRAS.435.1874W", "2013PaReL..34.1519L", "2014MNRAS.441.1628S", "2014MNRAS.444..919P", "2014MNRAS.445.2900S", "2014PASA...31...35D", "2015ApJ...800...83B", "2015MNRAS.446.4186S", "2015MNRAS.447.2144D", "2015MNRAS.449.3911P", "2015MNRAS.450.4050W", "2015MNRAS.452.2057C", "2015MNRAS.453.3999M", "2016A&A...587L...6V", "2016A&A...588A..33Q", "2016A&A...594A.116H", "2016A&A...595A...1G", "2016ASSL..418..391A", "2016ApJ...824...13L", "2016MNRAS.455.1134P", "2016MNRAS.455.3763B", "2016MNRAS.456.2885R", "2016MNRAS.459..199G", "2016MNRAS.462.3011G", "2016SciA....2E0878X", "2017MNRAS.464..246B", "2017MNRAS.465...76M", "2017MNRAS.465.1621P", "2017MNRAS.465.3291W", "2017MNRAS.469.2251R", "2017MNRAS.472.3722G", "2018A&A...616A..11G", "2018MNRAS.473.4077P", "2018MNRAS.475..648P", "2018MNRAS.475..676S", "2018MNRAS.475.1653K", "2018MNRAS.475.2383S", "2018MNRAS.478..548S", "2018MNRAS.481.4133G", "2018RAA....18..146X", "2019A&A...625L..10G", "2019ApJ...871..120E", "2019ApJ...885..131R", "2019MNRAS.486.4622C", "2019MNRAS.488.4663S", "2019MNRAS.489..116S", "2019MNRAS.489.3519C", "2019MNRAS.490.3234N", "2019MNRAS.490.4740B", "2019MNRAS.490.4786G", "2019MNRAS.490.5182L", "2020A&A...642A.201R", "2020MNRAS.491.2162P", "2020MNRAS.492.1594S", "2020MNRAS.494.4291C", "2020MNRAS.497.4390C", "2021A&A...645L...8X", "2021A&A...649A..30C", "2021A&A...652A.162C", "2021A&A...655L...2C", "2021A&A...656A.133Q", "2021A&A...656A.156Q", "2021ApJ...922...79H", "2021MNRAS.500.3027D", "2021MNRAS.500.3064S", "2021MNRAS.501.4888V", "2021MNRAS.505.5438T", "2022A&A...658A..54C", "2022A&A...663A..61P", "2022ApJ...925...71L", "2022MNRAS.510.3899I", "2022MNRAS.510.4146W", "2022MNRAS.512.2171C", "2022MNRAS.514L...1S", "2023A&A...674A..37G", "2023MNRAS.519..948L", "2023MNRAS.520.4779L", "2023MNRAS.520.5002K", "2023gbdd.confE..26K", "2023sf2a.conf...91K" ]
29096758
2403.15118
Galaxy merger challenge: A comparison study between machine learning-based detection methods
<BR /> Aims: Various galaxy merger detection methods have been applied to diverse datasets. However, it is difficult to understand how they compare. Our aim is to benchmark the relative performance of merger detection methods based on machine learning (ML). <BR /> Methods: We explore six leading ML methods using three main datasets. The first dataset consists of mock observations from the IllustrisTNG simulations, which acts as the training data and allows us to quantify the performance metrics of the detection methods. The second dataset consists of mock observations from the Horizon-AGN simulations, introduced to evaluate the performance of classifiers trained on different, but comparable data to those employed for training. The third dataset is composed of real observations from the Hyper Suprime-Cam Subaru Strategic Program (HSC-SSP) survey. We also compare mergers and non-mergers detected by the different methods with a subset of HSC-SSP visually identified galaxies. <BR /> Results: For the simplest binary classification task (i.e. mergers vs. non-mergers), all six methods perform reasonably well in the domain of the training data. At the lowest redshift explored 0.1 &lt; ɀ &lt; 0.3, precision and recall generally range between ~70% and 80%, both of which decrease with increasing ɀ as expected (by ~5% for precision and ~10% for recall at the highest ɀ explored 0.76 &lt; ɀ &lt; 1.0). When transferred to a different domain, the precision of all classifiers is only slightly reduced, but the recall is significantly worse (by ~20-40% depending on the method). Zoobot offers the best overall performance in terms of precision and F1 score. When applied to real HSC observations, different methods agree well with visual labels of clear mergers, but can differ by more than an order of magnitude in predicting the overall fraction of major mergers. For the more challenging multi-class classification task to distinguish between pre-mergers, ongoing-mergers, and post-mergers, none of the methods in their current set-ups offer good performance, which could be partly due to the limitations in resolution and the depth of the data. In particular, ongoing-mergers and post-mergers are much more difficult to classify than pre-mergers. With the advent of better quality data (e.g. from JWST and Euclid), it is of great importance to improve our ability to detect mergers and distinguish between merger stages.
[ -0.026031622663140297, 0.007672745268791914, 0.03266614302992821, -0.02237250842154026, 0.011534440331161022, 0.024461623281240463, -0.005298752337694168, 0.018523475155234337, -0.0010564267868176103, 0.04661889001727104, -0.007337220944464207, -0.06148325279355049, -0.05454486235976219, -0.0033204248175024986, -0.0008530548075214028, 0.040389534085989, -0.029298238456249237, -0.00020070130995009094, -0.02334742806851864, 0.04049082472920418, 0.016345731914043427, 0.010135367512702942, 0.006223026663064957, -0.01667492650449276, -0.03557823970913887, -0.014649119228124619, 0.008489398285746574, 0.036160659044981, 0.04636566340923309, -0.008261495269834995, 0.029475495219230652, -0.004431453533470631, -0.04509953409433365, 0.003504013642668724, -0.05137953534722328, 0.10199939459562302, -0.017776459455490112, 0.014180650934576988, -0.03403356298804283, -0.0038395379669964314, -0.012395408004522324, 0.0023518356028944254, -0.02785485051572323, -0.004507421050220728, -0.054139699786901474, -0.0031146786641329527, -0.049379050731658936, -0.06325583159923553, -0.0025844869669526815, 0.020751863718032837, -0.08989519625902176, 0.007153632119297981, 0.0002979361161123961, -0.018308233469724655, 0.004599215462803841, -0.04661889001727104, -0.0037287515588104725, 0.015256861224770546, -0.0046277036890387535, -0.018498152494430542, -0.005371554754674435, -0.025512510910630226, 0.05267098918557167, -0.040009692311286926, -0.024119768291711807, 0.002616140292957425, 0.009616253897547722, -0.0008934126817621291, 0.02351202629506588, -0.00955927837640047, 0.03836372494697571, -0.01880202442407608, 0.028361301869153976, -0.004162400960922241, 0.015598716214299202, -0.00048152488307096064, -0.009230084717273712, 0.042491309344768524, -0.02863985113799572, 0.023575332015752792, 0.016510330140590668, 0.011958593502640724, 0.008824923075735569, 0.008369116112589836, -0.017700491473078728, -0.004061110317707062, -0.01885266974568367, -0.02889307588338852, -0.07014358043670654, 0.020587267354130745, -0.018814684823155403, 0.0017994865775108337, 0.0162191204726696, -0.01362355425953865, 0.025335252285003662, -0.03388162702322006, -0.01667492650449276, -0.05424099043011665, 0.03403356298804283, 0.05986260622739792, 0.00722326897084713, 0.004000969231128693, 0.006621857639402151, -0.036287274211645126, 0.03233695030212402, -0.05727970227599144, -0.009597262367606163, -0.022613074630498886, 0.027880173176527023, 0.05793808773159981, -0.015256861224770546, 0.00962891522794962, -0.05722905695438385, 0.03266614302992821, 0.008204519748687744, 0.0008649247465655208, -0.030108559876680374, 0.02216992899775505, -0.02138492837548256, -0.01563669927418232, -0.026284849271178246, -0.007178954780101776, 0.036489855498075485, 0.03071630373597145, 0.029551463201642036, -0.0032238822896033525, 0.05874841287732124, -0.04846743866801262, -0.0032571181654930115, 0.011116617359220982, 0.013838795945048332, 0.0132563766092062, 0.013129763305187225, 0.0029516646172851324, -0.01528218388557434, -0.02386654168367386, -0.01111028715968132, 0.0001329436054220423, -0.045555341988801956, 0.005602623336017132, 0.011325528845191002, -0.019764281809329987, 0.012382746674120426, 0.0242843646556139, -0.004225707147270441, 0.0019435088615864515, -0.04441582411527634, 0.018270248547196388, -0.03598340228199959, 0.01575065217912197, -0.013269037939608097, -0.014433876611292362, -0.030412431806325912, -0.036996304988861084, -0.03152662515640259, -0.008869237266480923, -0.010920367203652859, 0.025284606963396072, -0.04428921267390251, -0.07510680705308914, -0.02485412359237671, 0.03365372493863106, -0.04165566340088844, 0.023955171927809715, -0.014066698960959911, 0.030589690431952477, -0.02475283294916153, -0.002339174272492528, -0.06902938336133957, -0.002255293307825923, 0.005656433757394552, -0.019359121099114418, 0.01740928180515766, -0.058900345116853714, -0.022562429308891296, -0.02168879844248295, 0.011945932172238827, -0.03752807900309563, -0.005412703845649958, -0.00395032437518239, 0.007457503117620945, 0.015244199894368649, 0.005197461694478989, -0.037882596254348755, -0.04692276194691658, 0.014193312264978886, -0.03950324282050133, 0.02517065592110157, -0.02263839729130268, -0.02009347639977932, 0.017523232847452164, 0.021866057068109512, 0.0354263037443161, 0.036489855498075485, 0.004504255950450897, -0.005890667904168367, 0.01632040925323963, 0.020270735025405884, -0.03686969354748726, -0.012775246985256672, 0.025385897606611252, 0.03137468919157982, 0.045656632632017136, -0.025335252285003662, -0.024005815386772156, -0.02656339854001999, 0.014573151245713234, 0.0074005271308124065, -0.009413673542439938, 0.016130490228533745, 0.04064275696873665, 0.02625952661037445, 0.021321620792150497, 0.01967565342783928, -0.038971468806266785, -0.04345356673002243, -0.06897873431444168, 0.033071305602788925, 0.04071872681379318, 0.056469377130270004, 0.022929606959223747, 0.01880202442407608, 0.010711455717682838, -0.0010714621748775244, -0.025309929624199867, -0.011793997138738632, 0.03745211288332939, -0.052113890647888184, 0.02268904075026512, -0.0453527607023716, 0.00935036689043045, 0.01595323160290718, -0.01657363586127758, 0.03378033638000488, 0.0018612104468047619, -0.01744726486504078, 0.0045390743762254715, -0.026183558627963066, 0.01245871465653181, -0.026740655303001404, 0.006621857639402151, 0.08260229229927063, -0.00170927494764328, -0.021321620792150497, 0.0029073499608784914, -0.004776473622769117, -0.018320893868803978, -0.004861937370151281, -0.00023621229047421366, -0.01994154043495655, 0.06325583159923553, 0.0035135094076395035, -0.011945932172238827, -0.05006276071071625, -0.021612832322716713, -0.019903557375073433, -0.015117586590349674, 0.05236711725592613, -0.05950808897614479, 0.04049082472920418, -0.07358744740486145, -0.0057767159305512905, -0.040313564240932465, -0.02714581787586212, -0.04844211786985397, 0.0265127532184124, -0.0030102229211479425, 0.0032238822896033525, -0.0012542596086859703, -0.0005685713258571923, -0.04421324282884598, -0.01131919864565134, 0.04459308460354805, -0.031096141785383224, -0.0703968033194542, 0.013446295633912086, -0.009514963254332542, 0.04416259750723839, 0.04867001995444298, -0.03724953159689903, -0.023853881284594536, 0.002980152377858758, 0.046315018087625504, 0.019802266731858253, -0.004915747791528702, 0.02403113804757595, -0.013142424635589123, -0.04669485613703728, -0.011053310707211494, 0.007634761277586222, 0.012218150310218334, -0.055810991674661636, 0.01580129750072956, -0.015218877233564854, -0.042592596262693405, -0.03757872432470322, 0.04241533949971199, 0.018219605088233948, -0.03859162703156471, 0.0256391242146492, 0.032083723694086075, -0.016649603843688965, -0.015168231911957264, -0.004374477546662092, 0.008957866579294205, 0.021828074008226395, -0.029500817880034447, -0.026132913306355476, -0.013408311642706394, 0.01390210259705782, -0.013522263616323471, -0.0339575931429863, 0.015142909251153469, 0.01385145727545023, -0.025195978581905365, -0.02661404386162758, -0.0085463747382164, -0.01385145727545023, 0.02049863710999489, -0.0408959835767746, -0.0132563766092062, -0.01724468357861042, -0.005963470321148634, -0.00582736125215888, -0.04221275821328163, -0.0289943665266037, -0.04299775883555412, -0.05191131308674812, -0.02309420332312584, -0.016801539808511734, 0.007679075933992863, 0.03372969105839729, 0.021258315071463585, -0.024271704256534576, -0.0010580094531178474, -0.0020131459459662437, -0.0010208169696852565, 0.03621130436658859, -0.05307615175843239, -0.0031874810811132193, -0.06123002618551254, -0.022511783987283707, -0.03724953159689903, 0.004915747791528702, 0.006830769125372171, 0.006071091163903475, 0.021739443764090538, 0.04332695156335831, 0.03276743367314339, 0.0005080344853922725, -0.025879688560962677, -0.009964440017938614, 0.023296784609556198, -0.005602623336017132, -0.0055203246884047985, 0.011844641529023647, -0.015358151867985725, -0.00812855176627636, 0.03410952910780907, -0.003260283498093486, -0.019928880035877228, -0.020030168816447258, 0.0016981962835416198, 0.014547828584909439, 0.02894372120499611, 0.027171140536665916, -0.051303569227457047, -0.002785485005006194, 0.006406615488231182, -0.03618598356842995, 0.013661538250744343, -0.010597504675388336, -0.015231538563966751, 0.027475010603666306, -0.07297971099615097, -0.02138492837548256, 0.027019204571843147, 0.02165081538259983, -0.002620888175442815, 0.056368086487054825, 0.02894372120499611, -0.01802968420088291, -0.03226098045706749, -0.05763421580195427, -0.016814200207591057, 0.03150130435824394, -0.019181862473487854, -0.027905495837330818, -0.06867486983537674, 0.001567626604810357, -0.022511783987283707, 0.010369600728154182, -0.004615042358636856, 0.009869479574263096, -0.01818162016570568, -0.015915248543024063, 0.005039195530116558, 0.054038409143686295, 0.02681662328541279, 0.07409390062093735, -0.014180650934576988, -0.02361331693828106, -0.06401550769805908, -0.039022114127874374, -0.029602108523249626, 0.011566093191504478, -0.03676840290427208, 0.04157969355583191, 0.014573151245713234, -0.03765469416975975, 0.038920823484659195, -0.005507663358002901, 0.038768887519836426, -0.0071473014540970325, -0.01982758939266205, 0.014788392931222916, -0.02785485051572323, 0.01967565342783928, -0.011376174166798592, 0.01682686246931553, 0.008153874427080154, -0.019549040123820305, 0.0035325014032423496, -0.007495487108826637, -0.03621130436658859, 0.016067184507846832, 0.0366671122610569, -0.023018235340714455, 0.04778372868895531, -0.05226582661271095, -0.0852358415722847, 0.05510195717215538, 0.03611001372337341, -0.019637668505311012, -0.0003086190845351666, 0.01637105457484722, 0.04033888876438141, 0.02449960634112358, 0.018460169434547424, -0.014737747609615326, -0.015915248543024063, -0.007520809303969145, -0.0052227843552827835, -0.031881142407655716, -0.0010089470306411386, 0.023537348955869675, 0.0265127532184124, 0.005089840851724148, 0.04079469293355942, -0.04740389063954353, -0.03474259376525879, -0.043884050101041794, 0.0267659779638052, 0.02874113991856575, -0.016953473910689354, -0.05163276195526123, 0.05474743992090225, -0.04499824345111847, 0.05338002368807793, -0.04986018314957619, 0.00019990999135188758, 0.00046688527800142765, 0.009154116734862328, 0.011141940020024776, -0.027120495215058327, 0.045504696667194366, -0.01149645633995533, -0.0009005346219055355, -0.002445212798193097, -0.018890652805566788, 0.029070334509015083, -0.08943939208984375, 0.03350178897380829, -0.008907221257686615, 0.0327167883515358, 0.029905980452895164, -0.00481445761397481, -0.006704155821353197, 0.06026776507496834, 0.019295813515782356, 0.027829527854919434, -0.035552918910980225, 0.004618207458406687, 0.026588721200823784, 0.03334985300898552, 0.05163276195526123, 0.010869721882045269, 0.012566335499286652, -0.034514691680669785, -0.009806172922253609, 0.020992428064346313, -0.024119768291711807, 0.056418731808662415, -0.012946174480021, 0.02272702567279339, -0.05338002368807793, -0.03821178898215294, -0.012889198958873749, 0.00963524542748928, 0.009590931236743927, 0.04398534074425697, -0.02671533264219761, 0.030007271096110344, 0.02324613928794861, 0.017270006239414215, -0.009565608575940132, -0.03676840290427208, -0.051784697920084, -0.01916920207440853, 0.034514691680669785, -0.012116859667003155, 0.021562187001109123, 0.02843726985156536, 0.017687829211354256, 0.010825407691299915, 0.012616980820894241, -0.010983673855662346, 0.03410952910780907, 0.007128309458494186, -0.0034723603166639805, -0.0025844869669526815, -0.03448936715722084, -0.005206957925111055, 0.0077866967767477036, -0.0033805659040808678, -0.009793512523174286, -0.031096141785383224, -0.10098649561405182, -0.04056679084897041, -0.0086729871109128, 0.002510101767256856, 0.01074310950934887, 0.01880202442407608, -0.00041347043588757515, -0.04656824469566345, -0.00989480223506689, 0.0016032365383580327, -0.022714363411068916, -0.04137711226940155, -0.006393954157829285, 0.01439589262008667, -0.0028028942178934813, -0.011167262680828571, 0.006533228326588869, -0.012642303481698036, 0.024676864966750145, 0.0016048192046582699, 0.012230811640620232, 0.04221275821328163, 0.006137562915682793, 0.030437754467129707, -0.02610759064555168, 0.04441582411527634, -0.00470050610601902, 0.003133670659735799, 0.031475979834795, -0.017928393557667732, 0.0008419761434197426, -0.012990489602088928, -0.01972629874944687, -0.008862907066941261, -0.022195251658558846, -0.014623796567320824, 0.03393227234482765, -0.0148643609136343, 0.0017076922813430429, 0.011135609820485115, -0.006944720633327961, -0.0226763803511858, 0.019802266731858253, -0.006982704624533653, -0.02641146257519722, 0.01806766912341118, -0.028108075261116028, -0.021207669749855995, -0.013180408626794815, -0.0053937118500471115, -0.02004283107817173, 0.00507717952132225, -0.03299533575773239, -0.04649227857589722, -0.028969043865799904, -0.0204479917883873, -0.0076980674639344215, -0.036895014345645905, 0.029146302491426468, -0.021511541679501534, 0.007261252962052822, 0.020169444382190704, 0.01107863336801529, 0.042744532227516174, -0.051506150513887405, 0.023474041372537613, -0.013686859980225563, 0.004820788279175758, 0.005729236174374819, 0.03613533824682236, 0.02319549396634102, -0.01989089511334896, -0.022081298753619194, 0.026284849271178246, 0.02475283294916153, -0.01509226392954588, -0.08386842161417007, -0.029424849897623062, 0.006143893580883741, 0.02641146257519722, -0.014041376300156116, -0.010895044542849064, -0.01074943970888853, -0.0029500818345695734, 0.01551008690148592, -0.00849572941660881, 0.004732158966362476, -0.011692706495523453, 0.013332344591617584, -0.008824923075735569, 0.007254922296851873, 0.02175210602581501, -0.018092991784214973, -0.03861695155501366, -0.0312227550894022, 0.01069246418774128, 0.0042731873691082, 0.08645132929086685, 0.009654237888753414, 0.011629399843513966, -0.03096952848136425, 0.005811534821987152, -0.0023629143834114075, -0.04256727546453476, 0.007736051455140114, 0.029120979830622673, -0.03889549896121025, -0.016814200207591057, 0.003966150805354118, -0.014294602908194065, 0.027829527854919434, 0.00042731873691082, 0.01724468357861042, 0.00033730483846738935, 0.048138245940208435, -0.012135852128267288, -0.03611001372337341, 0.012673956342041492, -0.008020930923521519, 0.010933028534054756, -0.013534924946725368, -0.07784164696931839, -0.0066914944909513, -0.04355485737323761, -0.03127339854836464, -0.001212319009937346, 0.004364981781691313, 0.021359605714678764, -0.0004740072472486645, 0.003725586226209998, 0.02495541423559189, -0.03433743491768837, 0.020891137421131134, -0.018004361540079117, 0.024626219645142555, 0.0052670990116894245, -0.020182104781270027, -0.03340049833059311, 0.010527866892516613, -0.015180893242359161, 0.0433775968849659, -0.002073287032544613, -0.00227270252071321, 0.034666627645492554, -0.005292421672493219, 0.007647422607988119, 0.03340049833059311, -0.008489398285746574, -0.002253710525110364, 0.0019007769878953695, -0.031982433050870895, -0.03246356174349785, 0.005678590852767229, -0.021460896357893944, 0.013509602285921574, -0.005596292670816183, -0.014598473906517029, -0.004979054443538189, 0.01900460384786129, 0.03489452973008156, -0.0020099806133657694, 0.01131919864565134, 0.00615022424608469, 0.013610892929136753, -0.019080571830272675, -0.014281941577792168, -0.0028931060805916786, 0.00604576850309968, 0.022245896980166435, -0.018675411120057106, 0.02049863710999489, -0.017687829211354256, -0.07561326026916504, 0.013015811331570148, 0.022651057690382004, 0.003494517644867301, -0.024259041994810104, -0.0007454337901435792, -0.022802993655204773, -0.0009464318281970918, 0.02200533077120781, 0.022093961015343666, -0.03013388253748417, -0.018257588148117065, 0.04464372619986534, -0.03489452973008156, -0.006283167749643326, 0.02252444438636303, 0.01357290893793106, -0.004732158966362476, -0.004159235395491123, -0.02552517130970955, -0.04441582411527634, -0.012332102283835411, 0.0025164324324578047, -0.0658893808722496, 0.027778882533311844, 0.028614528477191925, -0.017181377857923508, 0.011116617359220982, 0.04737856611609459, -0.04097195342183113, -0.003991473466157913, -0.006406615488231182, 0.023638639599084854, -0.03438808023929596, -0.03846501559019089, 0.019878234714269638, 0.022980250418186188, 0.0011877877404913306, -0.02339807339012623, -0.025980979204177856, 0.014585812576115131, 0.047150664031505585, -0.01375016663223505, 0.018244927749037743, 0.002877279417589307, -0.022081298753619194, -0.004228872712701559, 0.017270006239414215, 0.0044092959724366665, 0.011179924011230469, -0.009457987733185291, -0.011591415852308273, 0.010673471726477146, 0.01385145727545023, -0.009407342411577702, -0.0007933093002066016, -0.025246623903512955, 0.0032507877331227064, -0.013965409249067307, 0.042238082736730576, 0.023030895739793777, 0.01439589262008667, 0.034413401037454605, 0.03393227234482765, 0.04634034261107445, 0.0062546799890697, 0.01118625421077013, -0.044770341366529465, 0.002103357808664441, -0.024575574323534966, -0.024537591263651848, -0.03388162702322006, -0.034261465072631836, 0.023030895739793777, -0.025360574945807457, 0.02967807650566101, 0.015256861224770546, 0.028057429939508438, -0.010534198023378849, -0.0038648603949695826, 0.04418792203068733, -0.023841219022870064, -0.004061110317707062, -0.009660568088293076, -0.0033805659040808678, -0.026892591267824173, 0.032590173184871674, -0.0693838968873024, -0.026867268607020378, -0.01081907656043768, -0.03112146444618702, -0.00781834963709116, 0.014775731600821018, -0.004526413045823574, -0.005912824999541044, -0.0024278033524751663, 0.03152662515640259, -0.03145065903663635, -0.12418198585510254, -0.020789846777915955, 0.037680014967918396, -0.019650330767035484, 0.005789377260953188, -0.0018912809900939465, 0.02869049645960331, 0.018168959766626358, -0.024626219645142555, 0.0018817849922925234, 0.009806172922253609, -0.048391472548246384, 0.002956412499770522, 0.03175453096628189, 0.03623662889003754, -0.03175453096628189, -0.027829527854919434, 0.03013388253748417, 0.024043800309300423, -0.019435089081525803, -0.022195251658558846, 0.016611618921160698, 0.008786939084529877, 0.014243957586586475, 0.0011545518646016717, 0.006314821075648069, -0.020625250414013863, 0.011281214654445648, 0.019181862473487854, -0.0004838988825213164, -0.016966136172413826, -0.007982946932315826, 0.0037097595632076263, 0.0436055026948452, -0.010072060860693455, -0.007134640123695135, -0.008084237575531006, 0.034413401037454605, -0.02460089698433876, -0.021093718707561493, -0.01491500623524189, -0.021207669749855995, 0.019409766420722008, -0.0418582446873188, 0.028260011225938797, -0.015104925259947777, 0.025208638980984688, 0.007710728794336319, 0.026917913928627968, 0.02101775072515011, 0.02294226735830307, -0.007894317619502544, -0.0005661973264068365, -0.0034818563144654036, 0.020954443141818047, 0.019029926508665085, -0.001862793113104999, 0.00374141288921237, -0.03205839917063713, -0.005210123024880886, -0.035932756960392, 0.03150130435824394, 0.017675168812274933, -0.03509711101651192, -0.03925001621246338, -0.008008269593119621, -0.05454486235976219, 0.0227903313934803, 0.02904501184821129, -0.03390694782137871, -0.0008641334134154022, 0.011686375364661217, -0.008653995580971241, 0.028715819120407104, 0.058495186269283295, 0.02170146070420742, -0.005542482249438763, 0.020207427442073822, 0.0019118556519970298, 0.00743218045681715, 0.0013769158395007253, -0.015522748231887817, 0.016117829829454422, -0.0013729592319577932, 0.01858678087592125, -0.0039819772355258465, 0.002639880171045661, -0.04502356797456741, 0.009249076247215271, 0.01828291080892086, 0.013269037939608097, 0.005716574843972921, 0.01744726486504078, 0.008483068086206913, -0.007634761277586222, -0.0066281883046031, -0.0008261495386250317, -0.03167856112122536, 0.02838662452995777, 0.013940086588263512, 0.017839765176177025, 0.006710486486554146, 0.01962500810623169, -0.028184043243527412, -0.007197946310043335, -0.00390917481854558, -0.015991216525435448, 0.01911855675280094, 0.03231162577867508, 0.009793512523174286, 0.005944478325545788, 0.05667195841670036, -0.007495487108826637, -0.007362543139606714, 0.02470218762755394, -0.0011672131950035691, -0.014332586899399757, -0.017928393557667732, -0.0013571325689554214, -0.03127339854836464, 0.00470050610601902, 0.022701703011989594, -0.05454486235976219, 0.003902844386175275, 0.027626946568489075, 0.011540770530700684, 0.014598473906517029, -0.0032064730767160654, -0.026386139914393425, 0.04266856610774994, -0.02755097858607769, 0.011439480818808079, -0.014535167254507542, 0.012901860289275646, -0.01444653794169426, -0.019042588770389557, 0.012711940333247185, 0.03752807900309563, 0.02506936527788639, -0.004194054286926985, 0.015522748231887817, 0.017320651561021805, -0.006729478482156992, 0.021866057068109512, -0.019080571830272675, 0.015712667256593704, -0.016016539186239243, -0.03261549770832062, -0.0074005271308124065, 0.008951536379754543, 0.005624780431389809, 0.02671533264219761, 0.0075271399691700935, 0.025006059557199478, -0.03573017567396164, 0.004937905352562666, 0.027626946568489075, -0.0493030846118927, -0.01863742619752884, 0.012939844280481339, 0.027677591890096664, 0.02455025166273117, -0.012857545167207718, -0.03578082099556923, -0.0132563766092062, 0.04836614802479744, -0.022448476403951645, 0.007128309458494186, -0.0010540528455749154, 0.012205488979816437, -0.03195710852742195, -0.05191131308674812, 0.02869049645960331, 0.0025939829647541046, 0.007394196465611458, 0.030159205198287964, -0.0032159690745174885, -0.005143651273101568, -0.009185769595205784, 0.028082752600312233, 0.0019229341996833682, -0.017523232847452164, -0.023005573078989983, 0.015256861224770546, 0.025905011221766472, 0.00017626897897571325, -0.022663718089461327, 0.01615581288933754, 0.03071630373597145, 0.01509226392954588, 0.006482583470642567, -0.00193876086268574, 0.007514479104429483, 0.054190345108509064, 0.007666414603590965, 0.014522505924105644, -0.040161628276109695, 0.012629642151296139, -0.03162791579961777, -0.022701703011989594, -0.03405888378620148, -0.018055006861686707, 0.008318470790982246, -0.02843726985156536, 0.006868752650916576, -0.023739928379654884, 0.00036915589589625597, -0.011737020686268806, -0.03269146382808685, -0.015674684196710587, -0.01017335057258606, 0.0019213516497984529, 0.023790573701262474, -0.008742624893784523, 0.04165566340088844, 0.021511541679501534, 0.040364209562540054, -0.02372726798057556, -0.013066456653177738, -0.014307264238595963, -0.01041391585022211, -0.022385170683264732, -0.02557581663131714, 0.0312227550894022, -0.012946174480021, 0.02133428305387497, 0.02874113991856575, -0.02765226922929287, 0.0009741284302435815, -0.004402965307235718, -0.0005163434543646872, 0.005254437681287527, -0.012218150310218334, -0.05013873055577278, -0.03527436777949333, -0.03107081912457943, -0.01925783045589924, 0.03879420831799507, 0.008609681390225887, -0.018257588148117065, 0.0614326074719429, -0.0058621796779334545, -0.020954443141818047, -0.011781335808336735, 0.03102017380297184, -0.0045802234672009945, 0.04201017692685127, -0.019435089081525803, 0.009926456026732922, 0.02729775384068489, 0.009774520061910152, 0.014155328273773193, 0.021790089085698128, -0.0024705352261662483, 0.025208638980984688, 0.00038300419691950083, -0.008375447243452072, 0.04390937462449074, 0.046998728066682816, 0.006112240254878998, 0.011433149687945843, 0.020536622032523155, -0.027069849893450737, -0.05006276071071625, 0.014471860602498055, -0.007590446621179581, -0.033273883163928986, -0.008324801921844482, 0.0029326726216822863, -0.029095657169818878, -0.0170927494764328, -0.004140243399888277, -0.002111271023750305, 0.012965166941285133, -0.02734839916229248, -0.02034670114517212, -0.010781093500554562, -0.0034723603166639805, -0.03479323908686638, -0.002400898141786456, -0.011958593502640724, -0.015535409562289715, -0.013978070579469204, 0.009793512523174286, 0.011293875984847546, -0.00481445761397481, -0.00775504345074296, -0.006061595398932695, 0.0379079170525074, -0.0634077712893486, -0.007337220944464207, 0.029703399166464806, 0.01754855550825596, 0.0018469664501026273, 0.00722326897084713, -0.015497425571084023, 0.004941070452332497, -0.005783046595752239, -0.003475525649264455, -0.003304598154500127, -0.010394923388957977, 0.016181135550141335, 0.013395650312304497, -0.014243957586586475, 0.005419034510850906, -0.017738474532961845, -0.02510734833776951, -0.02714581787586212, -0.009780851192772388, -0.027424365282058716, -0.011129278689622879, 0.01595323160290718, 0.0043238322250545025, 0.013737505301833153, -0.019587025046348572, -0.005216453690081835, 0.000732376822270453, -0.01962500810623169, 0.0007988486322574317, -0.021967347711324692, -0.0019197689834982157, 0.019245170056819916, 0.026487430557608604, 0.012711940333247185, -0.03023517318069935, -0.005419034510850906, 0.010768432170152664, 0.004209880717098713, -0.0026462108362466097, 0.015940571203827858, -0.0035071787424385548, 0.009774520061910152, 0.014750408940017223, -0.030336463823914528, -0.006735809147357941, 0.013180408626794815, -0.017434604465961456, -0.010755770839750767, -0.012294118292629719, -0.019966863095760345, 0.034565337002277374, 0.0201947670429945, -0.019485734403133392, -0.01564936153590679, 0.015712667256593704, -0.023018235340714455, -0.005355727858841419, -0.017852427437901497, -0.01431992556899786, -0.01004673819988966, 0.06416744738817215, -0.006431938149034977, -0.014345248229801655, 0.0024135594721883535, 0.023587994277477264, 0.010236657224595547, -0.0006421650759875774, 0.00833746325224638, 0.04423856735229492, 0.002810807665809989, 0.013028472661972046, 0.009160446934401989, 0.016383716836571693, 0.040009692311286926, 0.04365614801645279, 0.0048809293657541275, 0.008907221257686615, 0.031830497086048126, -0.017472587525844574, 0.000322467356454581, 0.016700249165296555, -0.0025148498825728893, -0.001973579404875636, 0.04826485738158226, 0.0133829889819026, 0.004611876793205738, 0.042693886905908585, 0.0048397802747786045, 0.024056460708379745, 0.008584358729422092, -0.0062926639802753925, 0.010705125518143177, -0.020232750102877617, 0.009457987733185291, -0.02512001059949398, -0.02848791517317295, -0.014142666943371296, 0.008635003119707108, 0.015965893864631653, -0.016535652801394463, 0.04226340353488922, -0.017966378480196, 0.023474041372537613, -0.0007442467613145709, -0.014712424948811531, -0.006862421985715628, -0.002321765059605241, 0.012800569646060467, -0.01278790831565857, 0.01193327084183693, -0.012256134301424026, -0.03061501309275627, 0.0021840734407305717, 0.00026272187824361026, -0.008894559927284718, 0.03071630373597145, -0.0148643609136343, 0.03378033638000488, 0.042795177549123764, -0.012287787161767483, -0.021093718707561493, -0.020954443141818047, -0.009470649063587189, 0.023296784609556198, 0.012281456962227821, -0.016953473910689354, -0.014611135236918926, 0.006659841630607843, 0.00320489052683115, 0.00027340484666638076, -0.012806900776922703, 0.012186496518552303, 0.009287060238420963, 0.00029773826827295125, 0.004475768189877272, 0.01610516756772995, -0.01771315187215805, 0.021422911435365677, -0.0028266343288123608, -0.007944962941110134, -0.013193069957196712, 0.00604576850309968, -0.02201799303293228, 0.04975889250636101, -0.030463077127933502, -0.0002931881172116846, 0.013117101974785328, -0.0371735617518425, -0.03281807899475098, 0.02512001059949398, 0.00008244679338531569, 0.009749197401106358, 0.042643241584300995, 0.013218392618000507, 0.0008823340176604688, -0.008850245736539364, -0.035299692302942276, 0.003119426779448986, 0.007387865800410509, 0.009078148752450943, 0.014281941577792168, 0.03856630623340607, -0.03304598107933998, -0.006653510965406895, -0.01421863492578268, -0.0029326726216822863, -0.02620888128876686, -0.024221058934926987, 0.02049863710999489, 0.017206700518727303, 0.01910589449107647, 0.025233961641788483, 0.024524929001927376, 0.009958108887076378, 0.021144364029169083, 0.03707227483391762, 0.02962743118405342, -0.0007814393611624837, -0.027019204571843147, -0.025765735656023026, 0.03236227110028267, 0.023372750729322433, 0.005270264111459255, -0.02258775196969509, -0.004599215462803841, -0.022853638976812363, -0.014079360291361809, -0.012034561485052109, -0.005317744333297014, 0.024765493348240852, -0.055810991674661636, 0.0010635488433763385, 0.042845822870731354, -0.006989035289734602, 0.02066323347389698, 0.020587267354130745, 0.013813473284244537, 0.009812504053115845, 0.025892348960042, 0.017421942204236984, -0.01025564968585968, -0.015573393553495407, -0.015978554263710976, -0.051658086478710175, 0.01880202442407608, -0.015193554572761059, -0.021296298131346703, -0.0025987308472394943, -0.015674684196710587, 0.000012982774023839738, -0.027069849893450737, 0.0017804946983233094, -0.005469679832458496, 0.017472587525844574, -0.005700748413801193, -0.05173405259847641, -0.024018477648496628, -0.02381589636206627, -0.004732158966362476, -0.004615042358636856, 0.010660810396075249, 0.010907705873250961, -0.02325879968702793, 0.007584115955978632, 0.05424099043011665, 0.0032666141632944345, 0.010964682325720787, -0.0011039066594094038, 0.023385412991046906, -0.013712182641029358, 0.0162191204726696, -0.04165566340088844, 0.017320651561021805, 0.0028883579652756453, -0.024119768291711807, -0.017941055819392204, 0.00444094929844141, 0.0012629642151296139, -0.020599927753210068, 0.030893560498952866, 0.019802266731858253, -0.04760647192597389, 0.03129872307181358, -0.005422199610620737, -0.01481371559202671, -0.018840007483959198, 0.002187238773331046, -0.0005262350896373391, 0.0035293360706418753, -0.0289943665266037, 0.0074005271308124065, -0.006830769125372171, 0.01357290893793106, 0.006773793138563633, 0.03621130436658859, 0.06173647567629814, 0.00978718139231205, 0.004510586615651846, -0.0005923112039454281, 0.010496214032173157, -0.014332586899399757, -0.03231162577867508, 0.010629157535731792, -0.011414158158004284, -0.006185042671859264, 0.05059453845024109, 0.018523475155234337, 0.01973895914852619, 0.013408311642706394, 0.035502273589372635, -0.0063338130712509155, -0.019587025046348572, -0.013142424635589123, 0.027576301246881485, 0.007406857796013355, 0.02785485051572323, -0.004526413045823574, 0.023322105407714844, 0.004662522114813328, 0.00968589074909687, 0.012059884145855904, -0.01911855675280094, 0.030209850519895554, -0.0022568758577108383, -0.011293875984847546, 0.03140001371502876, 0.019865572452545166, 0.0024119766894727945, 0.03334985300898552, -0.00009861962462309748, -0.002785485005006194, -0.04623905196785927, -0.013484279625117779, 0.005457018502056599, 0.012604319490492344, 0.01682686246931553, -0.017624523490667343, 0.043124374002218246, 0.0017377628246322274, 0.012408069334924221, 0.00039309365092776716, 0.008761616423726082, 0.02631017193198204, 0.05087308585643768, 0.014661780558526516, 0.030209850519895554, 0.02863985113799572, 0.01139516569674015, -0.025803720578551292, -0.020840492099523544, -0.012237141840159893, 0.010103713721036911, 0.004105424974113703, -0.008951536379754543, 0.02967807650566101, -0.026943236589431763, 0.018510814756155014, -0.027095172554254532, -0.02610759064555168, -0.01687750779092312, -0.0014829542487859726, 0.009844156913459301, 0.001888115657493472, 0.007305567618459463, 0.03096952848136425, 0.027272431179881096, -0.02775355987250805, -0.0030165535863488913, -0.0039851428009569645, -0.011243230663239956, 0.008020930923521519, -0.009097141213715076, -0.011623069643974304, -0.00037212338065728545, 0.01131919864565134, 0.0023534183856099844, -0.029070334509015083, -0.003133670659735799, -0.024866783991456032, 0.007514479104429483, 0.0374014675617218, 0.009008511900901794, 0.002649376168847084, 0.004874598700553179, 0.0005024951533414423, 0.015079602599143982, 0.006400284823030233, 0.007020688150078058, -0.025297269225120544, 0.04246598482131958, 0.015624038875102997, 0.025677107274532318, 0.01972629874944687, -0.01444653794169426, -0.00870464090257883, -0.020055491477251053, -0.017383959144353867, -0.0267659779638052, -0.004045283887535334, 0.00807790644466877, 0.01273726299405098, -0.03129872307181358, -0.005463349167257547, -0.010686133056879044, 0.030285818502306938, -0.0025939829647541046, 0.02049863710999489, 0.017827104777097702, 0.013370327651500702, 0.026284849271178246, 0.009565608575940132, 0.01905524916946888, -0.009065487422049046, 0.029222270473837852, 0.0339575931429863, 0.04390937462449074, 0.002877279417589307, 0.03226098045706749, -0.004308005794882774, 0.000926648557651788, -0.02175210602581501, 0.03236227110028267, 0.025803720578551292, 0.019409766420722008, 0.018244927749037743, 0.01947307214140892, -0.011306537315249443, 0.00331409415230155, 0.004279518034309149, 0.01724468357861042, 0.015256861224770546, -0.011363512836396694, 0.02272702567279339, 0.0037224208936095238, 0.002829799661412835, 0.03132404386997223, 0.01683952286839485, 0.00572290550917387, 0.01776379719376564, -0.02595565654337406, -0.010806416161358356, -0.009793512523174286, 0.0015335994539782405, -0.010616496205329895, -0.035552918910980225, -0.00026608502957969904, -0.013231053948402405, 0.009863149374723434, -0.02646210789680481, -0.0018675411120057106, 0.025715090334415436, -0.01126855332404375, -0.002829799661412835, -0.022195251658558846, 0.029754044488072395, 0.0031874810811132193, 0.00299123115837574, -0.006343308836221695, 0.019359121099114418, -0.01563669927418232, -0.013345005922019482, -0.021448234096169472, 0.007413188461214304, 0.029804689809679985, -0.01885266974568367, -0.005532986018806696, 0.017624523490667343, -0.006640849635004997, -0.03226098045706749, -0.012471375986933708, 0.0011023239931091666, 0.016510330140590668, -0.0033963925670832396, 0.021574847400188446, -0.0009155699517577887, -0.029146302491426468, 0.022802993655204773, 0.04216211289167404, -0.0025053538847714663, -0.0164723452180624, 0.02041000872850418, 0.021828074008226395, 0.053683891892433167, -0.009812504053115845, -0.005165808368474245, 0.009749197401106358, -0.011350851505994797, 0.016143152490258217, 0.0017061096150428057 ]
11.531203
6.033199
2024-07-01
1
2024A&A...687A..24M
[ "merger detection methods", "Various galaxy merger detection methods", "mergers", "clear mergers", "different methods", "major mergers", "merger stages", "real HSC observations", "good performance", "mock observations" ]
[ "methods: numerical", "techniques: image processing", "surveys", "galaxies: evolution", "galaxies: interactions", "galaxies: structure", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
59
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202348239", "10.48550/arXiv.2403.15118" ]
[ "Margalef-Bentabol, B.", "Wang, L.", "La Marca, A.", "Blanco-Prieto, C.", "Chudy, D.", "Domínguez-Sánchez, H.", "Goulding, A. D.", "Guzmán-Ortega, A.", "Huertas-Company, M.", "Martin, G.", "Pearson, W. J.", "Rodriguez-Gomez, V.", "Walmsley, M.", "Bickley, R. W.", "Bottrell, C.", "Conselice, C.", "O'Ryan, D." ]
[ "SRON Netherlands Institute for Space Research, Landleven 12, 9747 AD, Groningen, The Netherlands", "SRON Netherlands Institute for Space Research, Landleven 12, 9747 AD, Groningen, The Netherlands; Kapteyn Astronomical Institute, University of Groningen, Postbus 800, 9700 AV, Groningen, The Netherlands", "SRON Netherlands Institute for Space Research, Landleven 12, 9747 AD, Groningen, The Netherlands; Kapteyn Astronomical Institute, University of Groningen, Postbus 800, 9700 AV, Groningen, The Netherlands", "Centro de Astrobiología (CAB), CSIC-INTA, Carretera de Ajalvir km4, 28850, Torrejón de Ardoz, Madrid, Spain", "Astronomical Observatory of the Jagiellonian University, Faculty of Physics, Astronomy and Applied Computer Science, ul. Orla 171, 30-244, Cracow, Poland", "Centro de Estudios de Física del Cosmos de Aragón (CEFCA), Plaza San Juan 1, 44001, Teruel, Spain", "Department of Astrophysical Sciences, Princeton University, 4 Ivy Lane, Princeton, NJ, 08544, USA", "Instituto de Radioastronomía y Astrofísica, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Apdo. Postal 72-3, 58089, Morelia, Mexico", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias, c/ Via Lactea sn, 38025, La Laguna, Spain", "Korea Astronomy and Space Science Institute, 776 Daedeokdae-ro, Yuseong-gu, Daejeon, 34055, Korea; Steward Observatory, University of Arizona, 933 N. Cherry Ave, Tucson, AZ, USA", "National Centre for Nuclear Research, Pasteura 7, 02-093, Warszawa, Poland", "Instituto de Radioastronomía y Astrofísica, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Apdo. Postal 72-3, 58089, Morelia, Mexico", "Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, Department of Physics &amp; Astronomy, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester, M13 9PL, UK", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Victoria, Victoria, British Columbia, V8P 1A1, Canada", "International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research, University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Hwy, Crawley, WA, 6009, Australia", "Jodrell Bank Centre for Astrophysics, Department of Physics &amp; Astronomy, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester, M13 9PL, UK", "Department of Physics, Lancaster University, Bailrigg, Lancaster, LA1 4YB, UK" ]
[ "2024A&A...687A..45P" ]
[ "1978MNRAS.183..341W", "1985ApJ...292..371D", "1993ApJS...88..253S", "1994ApJ...429..582C", "1996ApJ...461...20H", "1998ApJ...498..541K", "1999ApJS..123....3L", "2000A&AS..141..371G", "2000ApJ...536..571B", "2001MNRAS.328..726S", "2002A&A...385..337T", "2003AJ....126.1183C", "2003MNRAS.344.1000B", "2003PASP..115..763C", "2004AJ....128..163L", "2004MNRAS.352..376A", "2006A&A...457..841I", "2007AJ....134..527W", "2007ApJ...663.1269N", "2008MNRAS.386..577F", "2008MNRAS.389.1179L", "2008MNRAS.391.1489K", "2009A&A...498..379D", "2009A&A...506..647T", "2009MNRAS.399..497D", "2009MNRAS.399L..16C", "2010ApJS..189..309L", "2010MNRAS.401.1043D", "2010MNRAS.404..575L", "2011ApJ...738L..25W", "2011ApJS..192...18K", "2012ApJ...744...85M", "2012ApJ...745L..29D", "2012arXiv1212.5701Z", "2013MNRAS.430.3128E", "2013MNRAS.435.2835W", "2013MNRAS.436..150S", "2013Msngr.154...32E", "2013PhRvL.110i6401L", "2014ApJ...790....7J", "2014MNRAS.440L..66B", "2014MNRAS.441.1297S", "2014MNRAS.444.1125C", "2014MNRAS.444.1453D", "2014MNRAS.444.1518V", "2014Natur.509..177V", "2015A&A...576A..53L", "2015ApJS..221....8H", "2015MNRAS.446..521S", "2015MNRAS.449...49R", "2015MNRAS.450.1441D", "2015MNRAS.452.2087L", "2015Natur.521..436L", "2015arXiv151108458O", "2016A&A...594A..13P", "2016MNRAS.458.2371R", "2016MNRAS.463.3948D", "2017A&A...607A..70C", "2017A&A...608A...9V", "2017ApJ...848..128I", "2017MNRAS.464.1659Q", "2017MNRAS.464.4176W", "2017MNRAS.464.4420S", "2017MNRAS.467.3083R", "2017MNRAS.468..207S", "2017MNRAS.470.3507M", "2018ApJ...858..114H", "2018MNRAS.473.4077P", "2018MNRAS.475..624N", "2018MNRAS.475..648P", "2018MNRAS.475..676S", "2018MNRAS.475.1160H", "2018MNRAS.476.3661D", "2018MNRAS.477.1206N", "2018MNRAS.478.3994C", "2018MNRAS.479..319F", "2018MNRAS.479..415A", "2018MNRAS.480..800H", "2018MNRAS.480.2266M", "2018MNRAS.480.5113M", "2018PASJ...70S...1M", "2018PASJ...70S...4A", "2018PASJ...70S...5B", "2018PASJ...70S..37G", "2019A&A...625A...2K", "2019A&A...626A..49P", "2019A&A...631A..51P", "2019A&A...632A..34W", "2019ApJ...872...76N", "2019ApJ...876..110D", "2019ComAC...6....2N", "2019MNRAS.483.2968W", "2019MNRAS.483.4140R", "2019MNRAS.485.1320M", "2019MNRAS.486.3702S", "2019MNRAS.487.2491E", "2019MNRAS.490.5390B", "2019arXiv190511946T", "2020A&A...644A..87W", "2020A&C....3200390C", "2020ApJ...895..115F", "2020MNRAS.491.1408M", "2020MNRAS.491.1554W", "2020MNRAS.493.4209C", "2020MNRAS.494.3469B", "2020MNRAS.494.4969P", "2020MNRAS.494.5713M", "2020MNRAS.496.2346M", "2020arXiv201103591C", "2021ApJ...919..139W", "2021MNRAS.500.4937M", "2021MNRAS.501.4359Z", "2021MNRAS.504..372B", "2021arXiv210314030L", "2021arXiv211114725C", "2022A&A...661A..52P", "2022MNRAS.509.3966W", "2022MNRAS.509.5918H", "2022MNRAS.511..607J", "2022MNRAS.513.1459M", "2022MNRAS.514.3294B", "2022MNRAS.516.4354W", "2022PASJ...74..247A", "2023A&A...675A.159K", "2023ApJ...942...54R", "2023JOSS....8.5312W", "2023MNRAS.519.2199E", "2023MNRAS.519.4920G", "2023MNRAS.519.6149B", "2023MNRAS.520.2109L", "2023MNRAS.521.3861D", "2023MNRAS.523.4381D", "2023PASA...40....1H" ]
29059220
2405.01516
Grand Design versus Multiarmed Spiral Galaxies: Dependence on Galaxy Structure
We developed an algorithm to use Galaxy Zoo 3D spiral arm masks produced by citizen scientist volunteers to semiautomatically classify spiral galaxies as either multiarmed or grand design spirals. Our final sample consists of 299 multiarmed and 245 grand design galaxies. On average, the grand design galaxies have smaller stellar masses than the multiarmed galaxies. For a given stellar mass, the grand design galaxies have larger concentrations, earlier Hubble types, smaller half-light radii, and larger central surface mass densities than the multiarmed galaxies. Lower-mass galaxies of both arm classes have later Hubble types and lower concentrations than higher-mass galaxies. In our sample, a higher fraction of grand design galaxies have classical bulges rather than pseudo-bulges, compared to multiarmed galaxies. These results are consistent with theoretical models and simulations, which suggest that dense classical bulges support the development and/or longevity of two-armed spiral patterns. Similar specific star formation rates (sSFRs) are found in multiarmed and grand design galaxies with similar stellar masses and concentrations. This implies that the sSFRs in spiral galaxies are a function of concentration and stellar mass, but independent of the number of spiral arms. Our classifications are consistent with arm counts from the Galaxy Zoo 2 project and published m = 3 Fourier amplitudes.
[ 0.04153934493660927, 0.03208015486598015, 0.05934964120388031, -0.0006363836582750082, -0.019931858405470848, 0.04413386434316635, -0.030377503484487534, -0.034593597054481506, -0.02739110216498375, 0.0037397569976747036, -0.03332336246967316, -0.04059342294931412, -0.0014129660557955503, -0.008770017884671688, 0.0344584658741951, 0.014918489381670952, -0.029161320999264717, 0.021188577637076378, -0.023188520222902298, 0.009101089090108871, 0.034215230494737625, 0.017013022676110268, 0.012999624945223331, 0.002324257278814912, -0.04205284267663956, -0.01633736677467823, 0.007857881486415863, 0.038755640387535095, 0.035269252955913544, 0.025810066610574722, 0.009567291475832462, -0.013729333877563477, -0.035323306918144226, -0.027999192476272583, -0.06491705030202866, 0.0848083645105362, -0.012060463428497314, 0.03772864118218422, -0.013134756125509739, -0.020594000816345215, -0.02108047343790531, 0.009601074270904064, -0.030026162043213844, 0.01960754208266735, 0.03178286924958229, -0.008492998778820038, -0.0009552089613862336, -0.025485752150416374, -0.0504850298166275, 0.04289065673947334, -0.07734911888837814, 0.05443086475133896, 0.018256230279803276, -0.0071416860446333885, -0.041647449135780334, 0.00467216270044446, -0.06237658113241196, -0.01070239394903183, -0.0327017605304718, 0.006452516652643681, 0.005239713937044144, -0.01478335727006197, 0.03643138334155083, -0.01117535401135683, -0.012830710969865322, 0.008195709437131882, -0.0208777766674757, -0.020729131996631622, 0.036944881081581116, 0.02632356621325016, -0.024269571527838707, -0.012580718845129013, 0.052160657942295074, -0.007905177772045135, 0.014107701368629932, -0.001270233653485775, 0.012263160198926926, 0.014513094909489155, -0.01160777360200882, 0.01981024071574211, -0.0029880895745009184, 0.009371351450681686, 0.0044289263896644115, 0.017175180837512016, -0.010459157638251781, -0.0015075579285621643, 0.038728613406419754, -0.02085074968636036, -0.07567349821329117, 0.0033698352053761482, 0.04670135676860809, -0.013655011542141438, -0.02832350879907608, -0.00448973523452878, 0.006428868975490332, -0.020729131996631622, 0.02579655312001705, 0.001480531645938754, 0.014621200039982796, 0.050566110759973526, 0.012101002968847752, 0.045998673886060715, 0.01612115651369095, -0.027810009196400642, 0.02466145157814026, -0.04226905107498169, 0.029458610340952873, 0.022958798334002495, 0.007134929299354553, -0.014229319989681244, 0.020202120766043663, 0.007087633479386568, -0.00038723545731045306, 0.053809259086847305, 0.013567176647484303, 0.018999451771378517, -0.035107094794511795, 0.02867484837770462, -0.02521548978984356, -0.018553519621491432, -0.008033552207052708, -0.007648428436368704, 0.001105542411096394, -0.05837669596076012, 0.013317183591425419, -0.00852678157389164, -0.020553462207317352, -0.022404760122299194, -0.026066815480589867, 0.010459157638251781, 0.007033580914139748, 0.0036620565224438906, 0.03997182101011276, -0.035107094794511795, -0.019837265834212303, 0.025012793019413948, -0.045079782605171204, -0.014823896810412407, -0.036025989800691605, 0.06453868001699448, 0.020107528194785118, -0.028566744178533554, 0.02305338904261589, 0.01033078320324421, 0.026810038834810257, -0.006178875919431448, -0.040215056389570236, 0.010580776259303093, -0.058917220681905746, 0.030999107286334038, -0.01962105557322502, 0.02140478789806366, 0.007101146504282951, -0.03578275069594383, 0.011648313142359257, -0.014026623219251633, 0.007722750306129456, -0.013472585007548332, -0.0005071644554845989, 0.030053187161684036, 0.006229550112038851, 0.0051248520612716675, -0.0192156620323658, -0.015391448512673378, 0.008094361051917076, 0.042377155274152756, -0.028782954439520836, -0.004432304762303829, -0.0409717932343483, -0.02379661053419113, 0.027837036177515984, 0.04810672253370285, -0.02324257418513298, -0.059457745403051376, -0.01533739548176527, 0.010769959539175034, -0.03389091417193413, -0.014688765630126, -0.02743164263665676, -0.06697104126214981, 0.0028901193290948868, -0.010188895277678967, -0.006013340316712856, -0.06205226480960846, -0.027107326313853264, 0.022620970383286476, -0.017296798527240753, 0.0026823552325367928, 0.036566514521837234, 0.00970242265611887, 0.0474851168692112, 0.01314826961606741, 0.03997182101011276, 0.02829648181796074, 0.007601132150739431, -0.033296339213848114, 0.025256028398871422, -0.005084312986582518, -0.0008361245272681117, 0.03267473354935646, -0.00917541142553091, 0.006891693454235792, 0.013877978548407555, -0.0562145970761776, -0.04535004496574402, -0.013006381690502167, 0.015648197382688522, -0.016202235594391823, 0.001928998506627977, 0.008776773698627949, 0.021539919078350067, -0.01743192970752716, -0.0026249242946505547, 0.02122911810874939, -0.01162128709256649, -0.011486154980957508, -0.0330260768532753, 0.014580660499632359, 0.025877632200717926, 0.016040077432990074, -0.026634367182850838, 0.0028985650278627872, -0.0036654348950833082, 0.03343147039413452, -0.022918257862329483, -0.0006697442149743438, 0.05956584960222244, -0.006884936708956957, 0.009384864941239357, 0.003932319115847349, 0.03326931223273277, 0.049458034336566925, -0.027553260326385498, -0.04078260809183121, -0.026715446263551712, 0.013999596238136292, 0.006172119174152613, 0.006168741267174482, 0.00048816160415299237, -0.06724130362272263, -0.06497109681367874, 0.06848451495170593, 0.036025989800691605, 0.011986141093075275, -0.056160543113946915, 0.047647275030612946, -0.0095267528668046, 0.0013040164485573769, 0.011418589390814304, 0.016431959345936775, 0.04570138454437256, -0.01925620250403881, -0.003354632994160056, -0.01435093767940998, -0.04159339517354965, 0.044917624443769455, -0.050512056797742844, 0.0341341495513916, -0.06302521377801895, -0.010364565998315811, -0.04170149937272072, -0.010648341849446297, -0.028593771159648895, 0.03489088639616966, -0.040377214550971985, 0.07064661383628845, -0.020985880866646767, 0.009384864941239357, -0.03813403472304344, 0.003776918165385723, -0.008101117797195911, -0.03448549285531044, 0.02468847669661045, -0.0050370171666145325, -0.016850866377353668, 0.01343880221247673, -0.0033985506743192673, 0.05740375071763992, 0.025553317740559578, -0.04448520392179489, 0.0021773020271211863, 0.009580804966390133, 0.05756590887904167, 0.06183605641126633, -0.00015402850112877786, 0.05567407235503197, 0.03540438413619995, 0.007188981864601374, 0.006536973640322685, -0.02537764608860016, 0.060322586447000504, -0.03410712629556656, -0.009094332344830036, -0.02071561850607395, -0.03616112098097801, -0.008033552207052708, -0.010060520842671394, 0.01597251184284687, -0.045268964022397995, 0.03102613240480423, 0.05283631384372711, 0.015675224363803864, 0.01206722017377615, 0.015486040152609348, -0.03470170125365257, -0.00917541142553091, -0.0062971157021820545, 0.020756158977746964, -0.006364681292325258, 0.025891145691275597, 0.0056991600431501865, -0.008513268083333969, 0.01797245442867279, 0.020769672468304634, -0.04626893624663353, -0.06772777438163757, -0.04678243398666382, 0.04556625336408615, -0.0003623206284828484, -0.022580429911613464, -0.03578275069594383, -0.0024712125305086374, 0.010047007352113724, 0.024066874757409096, -0.0062971157021820545, -0.055998384952545166, -0.02067507989704609, -0.013763116672635078, -0.030080214142799377, -0.044160887598991394, 0.054349783807992935, -0.0344584658741951, 0.03464765101671219, 0.01343880221247673, 0.0003836460236925632, -0.06832235306501389, 0.04791753739118576, 0.053836286067962646, -0.019148096442222595, 0.00863488670438528, -0.007513296790421009, -0.02197233960032463, 0.023323651403188705, -0.015675224363803864, -0.012486126273870468, 0.0005341906799003482, 0.023526348173618317, 0.01613467000424862, 0.005773482378572226, -0.03378280997276306, -0.014432016760110855, 0.0001166562651633285, 0.04229607805609703, -0.007506540510803461, 0.04664730280637741, -0.0446203351020813, -0.023850664496421814, -0.06361978501081467, -0.01133075449615717, 0.014486068859696388, 0.0028174864128232002, -0.004324199631810188, -0.002081021200865507, 0.006036987993866205, -0.004624866880476475, 0.02851269207894802, -0.010297000408172607, 0.0016823839396238327, 0.021688563749194145, -0.045106809586286545, 0.02102642133831978, 0.011229406110942364, 0.011803713627159595, -0.015729276463389397, 0.000378578610252589, 0.029269427061080933, 0.043269023299217224, 0.026891116052865982, -0.012317212298512459, -0.014459042809903622, -0.0035674646496772766, 0.01117535401135683, -0.009519996121525764, -0.053484946489334106, 0.016837352886795998, 0.036404356360435486, 0.017323825508356094, 0.024472268298268318, -0.08334895223379135, 0.00004426075975061394, -0.042187973856925964, -0.011405076831579208, 0.031080184504389763, -0.005232957191765308, -0.006638322025537491, -0.02724245749413967, 0.032755814492702484, 0.029485637322068214, -0.0030674792360514402, 0.04043126851320267, 0.005759969353675842, -0.029350506141781807, -0.029728872701525688, -0.016918431967496872, -0.0037870530504733324, 0.0015818800311535597, -0.009222706779837608, 0.01889134757220745, 0.007202494889497757, 0.0022820287849754095, 0.08037605881690979, -0.05178229138255119, 0.024431727826595306, -0.023134468123316765, -0.04464736208319664, 0.02994508296251297, -0.014580660499632359, 0.011141571216285229, -0.0069862850941717625, 0.04635001718997955, 0.030593713745474815, 0.0057802386581897736, -0.001317529589869082, -0.010202408768236637, -0.017661653459072113, 0.03164773806929588, -0.01017538271844387, 0.036944881081581116, 0.006938989274203777, -0.02794514037668705, -0.025904659181833267, 0.05837669596076012, -0.0059525310061872005, -0.005506597924977541, -0.02959374152123928, -0.006381572689861059, 0.018067046999931335, -0.033296339213848114, 0.011418589390814304, -0.020810211077332497, 0.009959172457456589, -0.011972627602517605, 0.03683677688241005, 0.007317356765270233, 0.06172795221209526, 0.014215806499123573, -0.00643562525510788, 0.04359333962202072, -0.006452516652643681, -0.06994392722845078, -0.04067450389266014, -0.03340444341301918, -0.004999855998903513, 0.046187859028577805, -0.015377935022115707, -0.021999366581439972, -0.022756101563572884, 0.01470227912068367, 0.01281044166535139, -0.008094361051917076, 0.028404586017131805, -0.0027212053537368774, -0.03170178830623627, 0.010526723228394985, -0.03737730160355568, -0.00048562788288109004, -0.015364422462880611, 0.008742990903556347, -0.004793780855834484, -0.011857766658067703, 0.01069563813507557, -0.023161495104432106, -0.00008424588304478675, 0.02070210687816143, 0.03189097344875336, -0.006952502299100161, -0.020418331027030945, -0.03645841032266617, 0.07053850591182709, 0.04280957579612732, 0.009371351450681686, -0.022229088470339775, -0.0034272661432623863, 0.04899858683347702, 0.018296770751476288, 0.049971532076597214, -0.02179666981101036, -0.007168712094426155, -0.016107643023133278, -0.014026623219251633, -0.04480952024459839, -0.017391391098499298, 0.042025815695524216, -0.015472526662051678, 0.0628630518913269, -0.04643109440803528, -0.03940426930785179, -0.06513325870037079, -0.022418273612856865, -0.004131637513637543, 0.07567349821329117, -0.029107268899679184, 0.04689054191112518, 0.00817544013261795, 0.011128057725727558, -0.007878151722252369, -0.008013282902538776, -0.028404586017131805, -0.011492911726236343, 0.023472296074032784, -0.04378252103924751, 0.043106865137815475, 0.0006026008632034063, 0.0341341495513916, 0.03591788187623024, 0.0070268246345222, -0.010837525129318237, -0.016621142625808716, 0.035863831639289856, -0.003841105615720153, -0.005178904626518488, -0.010202408768236637, -0.02520197629928589, 0.01205370668321848, 0.02052643522620201, -0.02306690253317356, -0.022756101563572884, -0.10264568775892258, -0.058917220681905746, -0.009337568655610085, -0.022053418681025505, -0.022580429911613464, 0.03940426930785179, 0.002057373058050871, -0.031269367784261703, -0.03105315938591957, 0.022931771352887154, -0.024093899875879288, -0.02416146546602249, 0.008797043934464455, 0.010945630259811878, -0.006445760373026133, -0.010006468743085861, -0.004006641451269388, 0.014215806499123573, 0.024350648745894432, -0.009398377500474453, -0.02174261584877968, 0.036404356360435486, 0.011830739676952362, 0.041458263993263245, -0.016756273806095123, 0.030242372304201126, -0.01125643216073513, -0.04289065673947334, 0.0069119627587497234, -0.01025646086782217, 0.01708058826625347, -0.0010514899622648954, -0.016958970576524734, -0.012486126273870468, 0.01613467000424862, 0.018945399671792984, 0.02286420576274395, -0.01667519472539425, -0.04172852635383606, 0.01379689946770668, -0.003976236563175917, -0.006415355484932661, 0.04378252103924751, -0.023512836545705795, -0.016053590923547745, 0.020729131996631622, -0.0631873682141304, -0.01814812608063221, -0.022918257862329483, -0.017540035769343376, 0.0016241086414083838, 0.011019952595233917, -0.04283660277724266, -0.0439717061817646, -0.04734998568892479, 0.00013629252498503774, -0.0078984210267663, -0.03243149816989899, -0.02433713711798191, 0.00039483659202232957, 0.005334305576980114, 0.029485637322068214, 0.021121012046933174, 0.004814050626009703, 0.015648197382688522, 0.034377388656139374, -0.020242659375071526, 0.02978292480111122, -0.031674761325120926, -0.011013195849955082, 0.030999107286334038, 0.011033466085791588, 0.009148385375738144, -0.008560564368963242, -0.015472526662051678, -0.01671573519706726, -0.03229636698961258, -0.040944766253232956, -0.004439061041921377, -0.01089833490550518, -0.002727961866185069, -0.002351283561438322, 0.041674476116895676, 0.023485809564590454, 0.026269512251019478, -0.03737730160355568, -0.02468847669661045, 0.0009374729706905782, -0.0023428378626704216, 0.008398406207561493, 0.010128086432814598, 0.03340444341301918, 0.0035539516247808933, 0.003060722490772605, 0.02175612933933735, 0.023188520222902298, 0.01598602533340454, 0.0442960187792778, 0.01632385328412056, 0.022607456892728806, -0.03105315938591957, -0.006993041839450598, 0.009283516556024551, 0.008168683387339115, -0.005864695645868778, 0.02794514037668705, -0.00951323937624693, -0.019702134653925896, 0.015188751742243767, -0.007263304200023413, 0.05294442176818848, -0.007094390224665403, 0.002447564620524645, 0.02071561850607395, 0.004560679197311401, -0.015296856872737408, -0.018553519621491432, 0.017675166949629784, 0.020215634256601334, -0.008182196877896786, 0.009134871885180473, -0.03213420882821083, -0.0035640865098685026, -0.0003986371448263526, -0.020229145884513855, 0.012432074174284935, 0.02543170005083084, 0.0152428038418293, -0.013621228747069836, -0.022188549861311913, 0.006536973640322685, -0.07064661383628845, 0.02449929341673851, -0.010526723228394985, 0.0012584096984937787, 0.013121243566274643, -0.0338098369538784, 0.011553721502423286, 0.004496491979807615, -0.04570138454437256, 0.02721543237566948, -0.029701845720410347, 0.0037194874603301287, 0.06167389824986458, 0.006337655242532492, 0.015877921134233475, 0.04772835597395897, -0.048728324472904205, 0.00004307308336137794, -0.015742789953947067, -0.02321554720401764, -0.017161667346954346, -0.011736148037016392, -0.02178315632045269, 0.01598602533340454, -0.017202207818627357, 0.0015497864224016666, 0.020391304045915604, 0.004999855998903513, 0.021107500419020653, 0.027837036177515984, 0.030242372304201126, 0.0036417869850993156, 0.007837612181901932, -0.013540150597691536, -0.008695695549249649, 0.019323768094182014, 0.017553547397255898, 0.004053937271237373, 0.0019526464166119695, 0.01279017236083746, -0.0341341495513916, -0.05594433471560478, 0.00916189793497324, 0.020634541288018227, 0.028431612998247147, -0.00971593614667654, -0.004736349917948246, 0.032026104629039764, 0.010168625973165035, 0.013087460771203041, -0.013080704025924206, -0.0053545753471553326, 0.06226847693324089, 0.015431988053023815, -0.03299904987215996, -0.005776860751211643, -0.030377503484487534, -0.013013138435781002, 0.0037735397927463055, -0.018783241510391235, -0.012972598895430565, -0.005195796024054289, -0.025891145691275597, 0.016445472836494446, -0.06918719410896301, 0.011844253167510033, 0.03408009931445122, -0.007364652585238218, -0.00852678157389164, 0.01514821220189333, -0.030350476503372192, -0.020039962604641914, 0.003668813267722726, -0.0011139881098642945, 0.00171109929215163, -0.03735027462244034, -0.029269427061080933, 0.05626864731311798, 0.02466145157814026, -0.011959115043282509, -0.02813432365655899, 0.04078260809183121, 0.038755640387535095, -0.0020506165456026793, -0.025891145691275597, -0.0026992466300725937, -0.0072160083800554276, 0.011357780545949936, 0.018769729882478714, 0.01533739548176527, -0.0018276500049978495, 0.002168856328353286, -0.00023922452237457037, 0.012013167142868042, 0.029539689421653748, 0.003716109087690711, 0.0020134553778916597, -0.030728844925761223, 0.004091098438948393, -0.010128086432814598, 0.03308012709021568, 0.03551248833537102, 0.07870043069124222, 0.03272878751158714, 0.012323969043791294, -0.0012085799826309085, -0.029431583359837532, -0.027080301195383072, -0.016080617904663086, 0.0006017563282512128, -0.017540035769343376, 0.03218826279044151, -0.018972426652908325, 0.0064694080501794815, 0.0029678198043257, -0.02666139416396618, 0.05783617123961449, 0.001996563980355859, 0.010236191563308239, -0.027728930115699768, -0.005384979769587517, -0.004341091029345989, 0.017688678577542305, -0.029809951782226562, -0.00881055649369955, -0.0015742789255455136, -0.014675253070890903, 0.04186365753412247, 0.02140478789806366, -0.01225640345364809, 0.03118829056620598, 0.0090875755995512, -0.02194531261920929, 0.0230263639241457, -0.0011916885850951076, 0.008661912754178047, -0.011999654583632946, 0.0012128028320148587, 0.005834291223436594, -0.10421321541070938, -0.03789079934358597, 0.004530274774879217, -0.0015092469984665513, -0.03121531568467617, 0.042215000838041306, 0.024742530658841133, 0.01652655005455017, -0.011121300980448723, -0.05280929058790207, -0.0017085656290873885, -0.03608004003763199, -0.011749661527574062, 0.02975589968264103, 0.04197176173329353, -0.018648110330104828, -0.030404528602957726, -0.0031265991274267435, -0.0446203351020813, -0.002069197129458189, -0.022188549861311913, 0.016472497954964638, -0.004368117544800043, -0.011384806595742702, -0.00880380067974329, -0.031674761325120926, -0.02162099815905094, -0.005874830763787031, 0.042566340416669846, 0.015756303444504738, -0.01578332856297493, -0.025296568870544434, -0.008601103909313679, 0.023553375154733658, 0.005972800776362419, -0.04159339517354965, 0.0002765967510640621, -0.005560650490224361, -0.0023428378626704216, -0.010141599923372269, -0.010574019514024258, -0.014986054971814156, 0.016418445855379105, -0.0008610393851995468, 0.0319180004298687, 0.003766783280298114, 0.024729017168283463, 0.027147866785526276, 0.00028884303173981607, 0.018026508390903473, 0.022283142432570457, -0.00808084849268198, -0.01851297914981842, 0.019012965261936188, -0.004982964601367712, 0.004243121016770601, -0.011134814471006393, -0.015540092252194881, -0.008229492232203484, -0.032566629350185394, -0.03408009931445122, 0.03775566816329956, 0.01744544319808483, -0.022431785240769386, -0.015715762972831726, -0.04759322106838226, -0.035107094794511795, 0.007871394976973534, 0.008851096034049988, -0.015134698711335659, -0.03753945976495743, 0.03145855292677879, 0.03997182101011276, 0.0221480093896389, 0.0021418300457298756, -0.03951237350702286, -0.033999018371105194, 0.016094131395220757, -0.020823724567890167, -0.003087748773396015, 0.020823724567890167, -0.06037663668394089, 0.0029053217731416225, -0.02886403352022171, -0.011310485191643238, -0.0037363788578659296, -0.02125614322721958, 0.00299484608694911, -0.04197176173329353, 0.035836804658174515, -0.0042735254392027855, 0.020039962604641914, -0.0016232640482485294, -0.005270118359476328, 0.002542156493291259, -0.0062903594225645065, 0.0006980373291298747, -0.0424041822552681, 0.02124263159930706, 0.0007786937640048563, 0.010844281874597073, -0.011236162856221199, -0.020053476095199585, -0.03572870045900345, 0.005891722161322832, -0.043998733162879944, 0.041836630553007126, -0.011668582446873188, 0.017499495297670364, -0.011310485191643238, 0.022729074582457542, 0.012682067230343819, -0.011756418272852898, -0.019931858405470848, 0.01582386903464794, -0.011465885676443577, -0.012830710969865322, -0.02162099815905094, 0.008411919698119164, 0.008560564368963242, -0.01079022977501154, -0.019526464864611626, -0.041836630553007126, 0.022931771352887154, 0.02816135063767433, -0.051268793642520905, 0.0219858530908823, -0.000584864872507751, 0.018080560490489006, 0.06729535758495331, -0.010053764097392559, -0.0036080041900277138, 0.0018681894289329648, 0.0063781943172216415, 0.0032211910001933575, 0.011580747552216053, 0.0017220787703990936, 0.017918402329087257, -0.011519938707351685, -0.0009847689652815461, -0.012033437378704548, -0.0016536685870960355, 0.025837093591690063, -0.002795527456328273, -0.011972627602517605, -0.04013397917151451, -0.00107936083804816, 0.008459215983748436, 0.026269512251019478, 0.012398291379213333, -0.01214829832315445, 0.022256115451455116, -0.013736090622842312, -0.003229636698961258, 0.01559414528310299, 0.019918344914913177, -0.03278283774852753, -0.031323421746492386, -0.026350591331720352, 0.015040107071399689, -0.011432102881371975, 0.027999192476272583, 0.0005481261177919805, -0.012006410397589207, 0.007371409330517054, 0.019648082554340363, -0.0046181101351976395, -0.00888487882912159, 0.011729391291737556, 0.002352972747758031, 0.011080761440098286, -0.05783617123961449, 0.023837151005864143, -0.026755984872579575, -0.012573962099850178, 0.004064071923494339, 0.01160777360200882, -0.01744544319808483, 0.01598602533340454, 0.04375549405813217, -0.005439032334834337, -0.01598602533340454, 0.01533739548176527, 0.00824976246803999, 0.013783386908471584, 0.027634339407086372, -0.012911790050566196, 0.020783184096217155, 0.010661854408681393, 0.022607456892728806, -0.045620307326316833, 0.05821453779935837, -0.008695695549249649, 0.003871510038152337, 0.04045829176902771, 0.03867455944418907, 0.002996535273268819, 0.022229088470339775, -0.003435711842030287, 0.0023124334402382374, -0.0008061422850005329, -0.014364451169967651, -0.028809979557991028, 0.005013369023799896, -0.008965957909822464, -0.002383377170190215, 0.0089727146551013, 0.007952473126351833, -0.045295991003513336, -0.04770132899284363, -0.006513325963169336, -0.013107730075716972, 0.03064776584506035, -0.028809979557991028, 0.029485637322068214, -0.017567060887813568, 0.02560736984014511, -0.012546936050057411, -0.05156608298420906, 0.013141512870788574, 0.021012907847762108, -0.04024208337068558, 0.004131637513637543, 0.00988485012203455, 0.01062131579965353, 0.03759351000189781, -0.009128115139901638, 0.015080646611750126, -0.0007453332655131817, -0.005922126583755016, 0.025891145691275597, 0.009709179401397705, -0.018188664689660072, -0.005006612278521061, -0.037323247641325, 0.0005464369314722717, -0.005439032334834337, 0.015864407643675804, -0.011830739676952362, -0.003989750053733587, 0.018404874950647354, 0.02289123274385929, -0.01214829832315445, 0.00231750076636672, -0.001787110697478056, -0.00924973376095295, 0.009709179401397705, -0.029296452179551125, -0.013114486820995808, 0.008783530443906784, -0.020404817536473274, -0.0277829822152853, -0.020283199846744537, 0.015377935022115707, 0.023674992844462395, 0.00398637168109417, -0.05310657620429993, 0.045647334307432175, 0.005520110949873924, 0.006918719504028559, 0.016472497954964638, 0.01514821220189333, 0.0019526464166119695, -0.03591788187623024, 0.012026680633425713, 0.017148153856396675, -0.030945053324103355, -0.0028580257203429937, -0.016918431967496872, -0.03462062403559685, -0.003072546562179923, -0.029864003881812096, -0.0008183885947801173, 0.013742847368121147, -0.0025185085833072662, 0.004297173582017422, 0.0023867555428296328, 0.00933081191033125, 0.0034762511495500803, -0.0037127307150512934, -0.009351082146167755, -0.02414795197546482, -0.002900254214182496, -0.0064896778203547, 0.01170236524194479, 0.013850952498614788, -0.0019678487442433834, 0.012553691864013672, 0.015877921134233475, -0.010736176744103432, 0.007722750306129456, 0.02085074968636036, 0.024607399478554726, -0.028728902339935303, -0.007580862380564213, -0.01633736677467823, 0.014634713530540466, -0.008013282902538776, 0.02975589968264103, -0.02125614322721958, 0.0018732568714767694, -0.021485866978764534, 0.03070181794464588, -0.01868865080177784, 0.03124234266579151, -0.018729189410805702, 0.0005696626612916589, -0.010499697178602219, 0.005111339036375284, 0.0002723739016801119, 0.010222678072750568, -0.012222620658576488, -0.017648139968514442, -0.003197543090209365, -0.009797015227377415, -0.04107989743351936, -0.024350648745894432, -0.0009450741345062852, 0.01522929035127163, -0.02470199018716812, -0.016377907246351242, 0.0006477853748947382, 0.03791782632470131, -0.006439003627747297, -0.003638408612459898, -0.019175123423337936, 0.0101618692278862, 0.007202494889497757, -0.005232957191765308, 0.043458208441734314, 0.02360742725431919, 0.025877632200717926, 0.004952560178935528, -0.03594490885734558, -0.012182081118226051, 0.00007849224493838847, -0.024715503677725792, -0.000524478149600327, 0.01578332856297493, -0.019715648144483566, -0.01162804290652275, 0.008033552207052708, -0.02174261584877968, 0.01708058826625347, 0.01708058826625347, -0.016648169606924057, 0.014445529319345951, 0.02902618981897831, -0.04402575641870499, 0.0044289263896644115, 0.08145710825920105, -0.00006608762487303466, -0.0018377848900854588, -0.011614530347287655, 0.03226934000849724, -0.034053072333335876, 0.013986083678901196, 0.00044171023182570934, 0.016621142625808716, -0.014634713530540466, 0.009783501736819744, -0.007695724256336689, -0.0029559959657490253, 0.00037266663275659084, 0.0384313240647316, -0.005243092309683561, -0.03251257538795471, -0.002873227931559086, -0.008405162952840328, 0.009952415712177753, -0.013769873417913914, 0.02649923600256443, 0.008114631287753582, 0.03594490885734558, -0.009155141189694405, 0.004935668781399727, 0.010486184619367123, 0.03272878751158714, -0.018594058230519295, 0.016729246824979782, -0.03829619288444519, 0.013377992436289787, -0.019904831424355507, -0.0019610922317951918, -0.007074120454490185, -0.035296279937028885, -0.0006570756668224931, 0.015026593580842018, 0.014932001940906048, 0.013553663156926632, -0.007249791175127029, -0.015742789953947067, 0.01795894093811512, 0.01576981507241726, -0.023147981613874435, -0.01851297914981842, 0.011736148037016392, 0.04640406742691994, 0.006361302919685841, -0.004884994123131037, -0.021904774010181427, -0.013067190535366535, 0.0007351983804255724, 0.017715705558657646, 0.02851269207894802, 0.014756331220269203, -0.02343175746500492, 0.022566916421055794, 0.006915341131389141, -0.024364162236452103, -0.0017254570266231894, -0.0011342578800395131, 0.009492970071732998, 0.007520053535699844, 0.0186616238206625, -0.01188479270786047, -0.004300551954656839, -0.01760760135948658, -0.018931886181235313, 0.042187973856925964, 0.0005172992823645473, 0.0032363932114094496, -0.0018276500049978495, 0.023093929514288902, 0.001474619610235095, 0.0032397715840488672, 0.03721514344215393, -0.006192388944327831, -0.029080243781208992, 0.003178962506353855, -0.008472728542983532, -0.020769672468304634, 0.03226934000849724, 0.050025586038827896, -0.04378252103924751, 0.0006368059548549354, 0.016594115644693375, 0.021364249289035797, -0.04121502861380577, 0.020742645487189293, -0.016648169606924057, -0.010601045563817024, 0.010405105538666248, 0.0037363788578659296, 0.00788490753620863, 0.0169049184769392, 0.02629653923213482, -0.0046012187376618385, 0.02666139416396618, 0.04013397917151451, -0.013506367802619934, 0.009634857065975666, -0.01307394728064537, -0.004155285656452179, 0.0015556984581053257, 0.003028628882020712, -0.002042170846834779, -0.029864003881812096, 0.003288756590336561, 0.005145121831446886, 0.03321525827050209, 0.05186336860060692, 0.0107159074395895, 0.015323882922530174, 0.003483007661998272, 0.03505304455757141, -0.01416175439953804, 0.003871510038152337, 0.007195738609880209, -0.06480894237756729, 0.05394439026713371, 0.026985708624124527, -0.0019712268840521574, -0.006067392881959677, -0.017188694328069687, -0.021702077239751816, -0.011094274930655956, -0.016931943595409393, 0.0221480093896389, -0.007803828921169043, -0.03121531568467617, 0.026431670412421227, 0.013709064573049545, 0.00635792501270771, 0.022188549861311913, -0.0062160370871424675, 0.002097912598401308, -0.03153963014483452, 0.02268853597342968, 0.04116097465157509, 0.007499783765524626, -0.007432218175381422, 0.023296626284718513, -0.03156665712594986, -0.004827563650906086, -0.021377762779593468, 0.008155169896781445, 0.007033580914139748, -0.030972080305218697, 0.023499323055148125, -0.025904659181833267, -0.013986083678901196, 0.03543141111731529, 0.0186616238206625, -0.0005375689943321049, -0.010384836234152317, -0.018067046999931335, 0.02832350879907608, -0.006077527534216642, -0.01296584215015173, -0.015661710873246193, 0.016377907246351242, -0.004293795209378004, 0.005330927204340696, 0.028809979557991028, -0.006810614373534918, -0.013215835206210613, -0.0152428038418293, -0.023512836545705795, -0.015107672661542892, 0.001450127107091248, -0.004891750868409872, 0.010911847464740276, -0.002635059179738164, -0.04897155985236168, -0.017823809757828712, 0.018607571721076965, -0.0003942031762562692, 0.009519996121525764, 0.022188549861311913, -0.0169049184769392, -0.05729564651846886, 0.01197938434779644, -0.008938931860029697, -0.04024208337068558, 0.0020337251480668783, 0.00808760430663824, 0.011195623315870762, -0.014729305170476437, 0.03429630771279335, 0.02905321680009365, -0.0054626804776489735, 0.02683706395328045, 0.0008335908642038703, 0.03321525827050209, 0.05259307846426964, 0.016580604016780853, -0.01489146240055561, 0.027472181245684624, -0.0031637600623071194, -0.023864177986979485, -0.03175584226846695, -0.0020962234120815992, 0.004067450296133757, -0.0381070114672184, -0.02283717878162861, 0.016013052314519882, 0.021323708817362785, 0.00717546883970499, 0.016607629135251045, 0.009594318456947803, -0.042863629758358, 0.01253342255949974, 0.022756101563572884, 0.010540236718952656, 0.007040337659418583, 0.0010911847930401564, 0.018040020018815994, -0.030269397422671318, 0.007776802871376276, 0.0654035210609436, 0.001927309320308268, -0.0023935120552778244, 0.01816163957118988, -0.03726919740438461, -0.03086397610604763, 0.0026283026672899723, -0.0089727146551013, 0.03499899059534073, -0.0035674646496772766, -0.019107557833194733, -0.04083666205406189, -0.011499668471515179, -0.010074034333229065, -0.010776716284453869, 0.02105344645678997, -0.03429630771279335, -0.0169049184769392, 0.0011663514887914062, 0.03651246055960655, 0.010526723228394985, -0.0009501415188424289, 0.013114486820995808, 0.006614674348384142, 0.023296626284718513, 0.02308041602373123, 0.007857881486415863, -0.0032836890313774347, -0.03791782632470131, 0.01307394728064537, -0.03299904987215996, 0.05221471190452576, -0.004712702240794897, 0.027526233345270157, 0.030431555584073067, -0.013959056697785854, 0.038566455245018005, -0.016458984464406967, -0.003935697488486767, 0.010722664184868336, -0.012384777888655663, -0.0040944768115878105, 0.04107989743351936, 0.011114544235169888, 0.017661653459072113, 0.017634626477956772, -0.053430892527103424, 0.0025624260306358337, 0.006280224304646254, -0.027539746835827827, -0.03997182101011276, -0.016256287693977356, -0.01795894093811512, -0.01235099509358406, 0.01617520861327648, -0.01908053085207939, -0.023810124024748802, 0.023472296074032784, -0.009188923984766006, 0.004344469401985407, 0.042728498578071594, 0.006878179963678122, 0.01743192970752716, 0.00463500153273344, -0.007553836330771446, -0.0016004606150090694, 0.005756590981036425, -0.013506367802619934, 0.0011030087480321527, 0.040404241532087326, -0.0029103890992701054, 0.009101089090108871, 0.0117902010679245, -0.010411862283945084, 0.017931915819644928, 0.004993099253624678, -0.013405019417405128, -0.010087546892464161, -0.001959403045475483, -0.00708087719976902, 0.015040107071399689, 0.010188895277678967, -0.012749632820487022, -0.005314035806804895, 0.01559414528310299, -0.013141512870788574, -0.01671573519706726, -0.00971593614667654, -0.010080790147185326, -0.02122911810874939, 0.01867513731122017, 0.003101262031123042, -0.011391563341021538, 0.022607456892728806, 0.004939046688377857, 0.027810009196400642, -0.027499208226799965, 0.03286391869187355, -0.009540265426039696, 0.035863831639289856, -0.038782667368650436, 0.043079838156700134, 0.029296452179551125, -0.013546906411647797, 0.0017127884784713387, 0.017026536166667938, -0.026553288102149963, 0.00033233838621526957, 0.013046921230852604, 0.005023503676056862, -0.022823667153716087, -0.029999135062098503, 0.05099853128194809, -0.007574106100946665, 0.0040944768115878105, 0.028918085619807243, 0.004918776918202639, 0.025296568870544434, 0.010114572942256927, -0.0019340658327564597, 0.005060664843767881, -0.00539511488750577, 0.014945515431463718, -0.03278283774852753, -0.018472440540790558, 0.01617520861327648, 0.004570814315229654, -0.03118829056620598, -0.0006118911551311612, -0.022175036370754242, 0.034917913377285004, 0.003651921870186925, -0.0024256056640297174, -0.010378079488873482, 0.06324142217636108, -0.039809662848711014, 0.013249618001282215, 0.0037971879355609417, -0.00019287872419226915, -0.010215921327471733, -0.03013426624238491, -0.009918632917106152, 0.023485809564590454, 0.02978292480111122, -0.034404415637254715, 0.008445702493190765, 0.021850721910595894, 0.0181751511991024, 0.032053131610155106, -0.01724274642765522, 0.030431555584073067, 0.010999683290719986, 0.010290243662893772, -0.0035303037147969007, -0.010229434818029404, -0.01975618675351143, 0.036917854100465775, 0.020985880866646767, 0.06140363588929176, 0.016742760315537453, 0.007661941461265087, 0.0020100772380828857, -0.027269484475255013, -0.03283689171075821, 0.005070799961686134, 0.010026738047599792, -0.006003205198794603, 0.010479427874088287, -0.05497138947248459 ]
10.559464
7.120668
2024-07-01
0
2024AJ....168...12S
[ "grand design galaxies", "spiral galaxies", "multiarmed galaxies", "Galaxy Zoo 3D spiral arm masks", "spiral arms", "stellar mass", "larger central surface mass densities", "dense classical bulges", "Galaxy Zoo", "multiarmed and grand design galaxies" ]
[ "Disk galaxies", "Galaxy evolution", "Spiral galaxies", "391", "594", "1560", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
37
[ "10.3847/1538-3881/ad46fb", "10.48550/arXiv.2405.01516" ]
[ "Smith, Beverly J.", "Watson, Matthew", "Giroux, Mark L.", "Struck, Curtis" ]
[ "Department of Physics and Astronomy, East Tennessee State University, Johnson City, TN 37614, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, East Tennessee State University, Johnson City, TN 37614, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, East Tennessee State University, Johnson City, TN 37614, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, Iowa State University, Ames, IA 50011, USA" ]
null
[ "1926ApJ....64..321H", "1964ApJ...140..646L", "1965MNRAS.130..125G", "1966ApJ...146..810J", "1966PNAS...55..229L", "1969ApJ...158..899T", "1972ApJ...178..623T", "1976ApJ...205..363M", "1976ApJ...209...53S", "1977ApJ...212..645M", "1979ApJ...233..539K", "1980A&A....88..184A", "1981ApJS...47..229E", "1982MNRAS.199.1069E", "1982MNRAS.201.1021E", "1982MNRAS.201.1035E", "1984ApJ...282...61S", "1984ApJS...54..127E", "1985ApJ...298..486C", "1985MNRAS.217..127S", "1987ApJ...314....3E", "1989ApJ...338..104B", "1992AJ....103.1089B", "1996AJ....112..359V", "2000Ap&SS.272...31S", "2001AJ....122.1861S", "2003MNRAS.344..358B", "2004AJ....128..183B", "2004ARA&A..42..603K", "2004MNRAS.353..713K", "2005AJ....130..506B", "2006MNRAS.368..715M", "2007MNRAS.381..401L", "2008AJ....136..773F", "2008ApJ...683...94O", "2009ApJ...706..471B", "2009MNRAS.393.1531G", "2010ApJ...715L..56S", "2010ApJS..186..427N", "2010MNRAS.403..625D", "2011ApJ...737...32E", "2011JKAS...44..161C", "2011MNRAS.410.1637S", "2011MNRAS.414.2498S", "2012ApJ...751...44S", "2013ApJ...763...46B", "2013ApJ...766...34D", "2013ApJ...770...57B", "2013JKAS...46..141A", "2013MNRAS.435.2835W", "2014PASA...31...35D", "2015ApJ...808L...8D", "2015ApJS..217...32B", "2015MNRAS.447.2603L", "2015MNRAS.449..820W", "2015MNRAS.450.2217S", "2016ARA&A..54..667S", "2016ApJ...826L..21S", "2016ApJS..227....2S", "2016MNRAS.461.3663H", "2016MNRAS.462.1470L", "2017AJ....154...86W", "2017MNRAS.468.1850H", "2017MNRAS.470.2982L", "2017MNRAS.471.1070B", "2018ApJ...858...24S", "2018ApJ...859...11S", "2018ApJ...862...13Y", "2018MNRAS.476.3661D", "2018MNRAS.477.1451F", "2018MNRAS.478..932H", "2018MNRAS.478.3793D", "2018MNRAS.481..185M", "2019A&A...631A..94D", "2019MNRAS.486.4710S", "2019RAA....19....6Z", "2020ApJ...899...89S", "2020ApJ...900..150Y", "2020MNRAS.493..390S", "2020MNRAS.493.1686L", "2021A&A...654A.138M", "2021MNRAS.507.3923M", "2022AJ....164..146S", "2022ARA&A..60...73S", "2022MNRAS.509.4024D", "2022MNRAS.515.3875P", "2022MNRAS.517.4575S", "2023ApJ...942..106J", "2023ApJ...947...54X", "2023ApJ...958..182S", "2023MNRAS.518.1022S", "2024MNRAS.528.7492S", "2024MNRAS.529.4565H" ]
29184399
2404.09522
The Physalis system: Discovery of ORC-like radio shells around a massive pair of interacting early-type galaxies with offset X-ray emission
We present the discovery of large radio shells around a massive pair of interacting galaxies and extended diffuse X-ray emission within the shells. The radio data were obtained with the Australian Square Kilometer Array Pathfinder (ASKAP) in two frequency bands centred at 944 MHz and 1.4 GHz, respectively, while the X-ray data are from the XMM-Newton observatory. The host galaxy pair, which consists of the early-type galaxies ESO 184-G042 and LEDA 418116, is part of a loose group at a distance of only 75 Mpc (redshift z = 0.017). The observed outer radio shells (diameter ~145 kpc) and ridge-like central emission of the system, ASKAP J1914-5433 (Physalis), are likely associated with merger shocks during the formation of the central galaxy (ESO 184-G042) and resemble the new class of odd radio circles (ORCs). This is supported by the brightest X-ray emission found offset from the centre of the Physalis system, instead centered at the less massive galaxy, LEDA 418116. The host galaxy pair is embedded in an irregular envelope of diffuse light, highlighting on-going interactions. We complement our combined radio and X-ray study with high-resolution simulations of the circumgalactic medium (CGM) around galaxy mergers from the Magneticum project to analyse the evolutionary state of the Physalis system. We argue that ORCs / radio shells could be produced by a combination of energy release from the central AGN and subsequent lightening up in radio emission by merger shocks traveling through the CGM of these systems.
[ -0.0038926468696445227, 0.0024316490162163973, -0.026883697137236595, 0.004612267483025789, -0.004153718706220388, 0.05208046734333038, -0.001300338190048933, -0.01395060308277607, -0.00286676874384284, -0.0443420335650444, -0.03288165107369423, -0.04677870124578476, -0.03636261075735092, -0.03357784450054169, -0.004073388874530792, 0.023469680920243263, 0.006299193017184734, 0.0076781874522566795, -0.031060844659805298, 0.04485078901052475, -0.010951625183224678, -0.01834196411073208, 0.0013212573248893023, -0.01582496426999569, -0.05746256187558174, -0.025772467255592346, -0.02590635046362877, 0.05312475562095642, 0.055427540093660355, 0.008936687372624874, 0.003537856973707676, -0.02051086723804474, 0.0013890356058254838, -0.012464502826333046, -0.08605995774269104, 0.03234612196683884, -0.0068481131456792355, -0.007745128590613604, -0.0527498833835125, -0.02444702759385109, 0.031087622046470642, 0.013816720806062222, -0.03523799404501915, 0.01970756985247135, 0.0128125986084342, -0.0015530422097072005, -0.025250324979424477, -0.008280660957098007, 0.010416093282401562, -0.01248458493500948, -0.027686994522809982, 0.04996511712670326, -0.003501039231196046, 0.03997744992375374, -0.04565408453345299, -0.04924215003848076, 0.005044040270149708, 0.02843673899769783, -0.004501814022660255, -0.009914032183587551, 0.008769333362579346, 0.0010434502037242055, 0.010744106955826283, -0.0030006517190486193, 0.00025521437055431306, 0.0024952434469014406, 0.0003443302121013403, 0.004173800814896822, 0.054088711738586426, 0.027164850383996964, -0.010061304084956646, 0.005117675755172968, -0.04348518326878548, -0.03132861107587814, 0.029829122126102448, -0.028704505413770676, 0.011687981896102428, -0.004990486893802881, 0.0019563646055758, 0.008976851589977741, 0.03170348331332207, 0.010924848727881908, 0.02363034151494503, 0.002358013531193137, 0.0058138673193752766, -0.0184758473187685, 0.025049500167369843, 0.013281188905239105, -0.07036887854337692, -0.0012936439597979188, 0.0063493987545371056, -0.001487774308770895, 0.004736109171062708, -0.024286366999149323, 0.015035055577754974, -0.004987139720469713, -0.004726068116724491, -0.047876544296741486, 0.08236479014158249, 0.04404748976230621, 0.008193636313080788, -0.008702391758561134, 0.0043244194239377975, -0.07267166674137115, 0.03183736652135849, 0.003347073681652546, 0.019801288843154907, 0.012772433459758759, 0.028758058324456215, -0.007089102175086737, 0.006208821665495634, 0.02298770286142826, -0.003899340983480215, 0.01969418115913868, -0.04110206663608551, -0.021314166486263275, -0.023242080584168434, -0.020738469436764717, -0.00458549102768302, 0.029400695115327835, -0.008601979352533817, 0.04643060639500618, 0.00530511187389493, 0.029909450560808182, 0.03229256719350815, -0.015088608488440514, -0.00516118761152029, -0.06587041169404984, -0.02215762808918953, -0.0256251972168684, 0.007122572977095842, -0.05047387257218361, -0.005857379175722599, 0.027231791988015175, -0.0485459566116333, -0.03692491725087166, 0.012658633291721344, -0.03850473836064339, -0.02463446371257305, -0.012183348648250103, 0.0276066642254591, 0.004448261111974716, 0.020376985892653465, 0.026482047513127327, -0.0056130425073206425, 0.0250227227807045, -0.025866186246275902, 0.006202127784490585, -0.027820877730846405, -0.013140611350536346, -0.01377655565738678, 0.002958813216537237, -0.01471373625099659, -0.012745657004415989, -0.011915582232177258, -0.01301342248916626, 0.0317838117480278, -0.0014450991293415427, 0.0018358699744567275, 0.0014819168718531728, -0.06346052139997482, -0.037380121648311615, -0.023416128009557724, 0.0028901982586830854, 0.007035549264401197, 0.033149417489767075, 0.014084486290812492, 0.002013264922425151, -0.09923404455184937, -0.025116441771388054, -0.06072930619120598, -0.004799703601747751, -0.017083464190363884, -0.004555367399007082, -0.01976112276315689, 0.0179938692599535, 0.033792056143283844, -0.05831941217184067, -0.02737906388938427, -0.02123383618891239, 0.006613817997276783, 0.02397843636572361, 0.060300879180431366, 0.005770354997366667, -0.00030416532536037266, 0.025946516543626785, -0.0108445193618536, 0.024018600583076477, -0.006674065254628658, -0.02199696935713291, -0.005328541621565819, 0.029882675036787987, 0.004398054908961058, 0.07524222135543823, -0.026870308443903923, -0.07042243331670761, 0.006409646477550268, 0.006329316645860672, -0.01304019894450903, 0.02814219705760479, 0.046002183109521866, 0.05515977740287781, 0.044127821922302246, -0.04932247847318649, -0.03336363285779953, -0.0635676234960556, 0.016146283596754074, -0.007892400026321411, -0.005127716809511185, 0.03266743943095207, 0.05050064995884895, -0.006325969472527504, -0.0005815540789626539, 0.010670471005141735, -0.01601240038871765, -0.016454214230179787, -0.020069053396582603, 0.04436881095170975, 0.034675683826208115, -0.007122572977095842, 0.015758022665977478, 0.08113306760787964, 0.053392522037029266, 0.007932565174996853, 0.0010827783262357116, 0.011306415311992168, 0.024955781176686287, 0.00024329042935278267, 0.023081419989466667, 0.005151146557182074, -0.014124651439487934, 0.03812986612319946, -0.01164112240076065, -0.01483423076570034, -0.018569564446806908, 0.0028851774986833334, -0.002451731590554118, 0.025544866919517517, -0.010985095985233784, -0.026977414265275, -0.011882111430168152, 0.0033002146519720554, 0.024313144385814667, 0.026642708107829094, -0.023603564128279686, 0.016507767140865326, 0.0015756349312141538, -0.007283232640475035, 0.016253389418125153, -0.016146283596754074, 0.05799809470772743, 0.032453227788209915, 0.005271641071885824, -0.015517033636569977, 0.001981467707082629, -0.0012149878311902285, -0.040646862238645554, -0.017846597358584404, -0.05548109486699104, 0.019011378288269043, 0.002803174313157797, 0.0020969416946172714, -0.028865164145827293, -0.0015003258595243096, -0.0035311628598719835, 0.015128773637115955, 0.016628261655569077, -0.01063700020313263, -0.0332833006978035, -0.014927948825061321, -0.057248350232839584, -0.03100729174911976, 0.05553464964032173, -0.017632383853197098, -0.042012471705675125, 0.021059788763523102, -0.019828064367175102, 0.01788676157593727, 0.022304899990558624, -0.03331007808446884, -0.02116689458489418, -0.01852940022945404, 0.005254905670881271, -0.031462494283914566, -0.005341929849237204, 0.016561321914196014, -0.027579888701438904, -0.0278476532548666, -0.02545114979147911, -0.027526333928108215, 0.036442939192056656, -0.0076714931055903435, 0.02843673899769783, -0.00011170858488185331, -0.0788838341832161, -0.0556953065097332, 0.014191593043506145, -0.026923861354589462, -0.032801322638988495, -0.026133952662348747, 0.07433181256055832, 0.054142266511917114, 0.023817777633666992, -0.0025354083627462387, -0.0409146286547184, 0.005987914744764566, 0.028650950640439987, 0.02480851113796234, -0.027713770046830177, 0.05997956171631813, 0.02774054743349552, -0.024835286661982536, 0.010483034886419773, 0.02503611147403717, -0.012297148816287518, -0.02075185813009739, -0.004053306300193071, 0.049563467502593994, 0.01981467753648758, -0.05858717858791351, -0.009164287708699703, -0.026656094938516617, -0.027526333928108215, -0.04648416116833687, 0.011386744678020477, -0.0416375994682312, 0.003111105179414153, -0.011942359618842602, -0.01245780847966671, -0.025638585910201073, 0.004960363265126944, -0.019359475001692772, 0.05036676675081253, 0.019198814406991005, -0.0029521191027015448, -0.055373989045619965, 0.02420603670179844, -0.0070087723433971405, 0.00693513685837388, -0.01840890571475029, -0.022880597040057182, -0.018194692209362984, 0.0016501073259860277, -0.0013513810699805617, 0.0024718139320611954, 0.05406193435192108, 0.027017580345273018, 0.006737659685313702, -0.0007886542589403689, 0.027660217136144638, -0.028249302878975868, -0.00005627267819363624, 0.014164816588163376, 0.0007940932409837842, 0.03296198323369026, -0.028008313849568367, 0.0280886422842741, -0.07893738895654678, -0.025959903374314308, 0.040245216339826584, -0.007156043779104948, -0.023362575098872185, 0.004645738285034895, 0.0025504701770842075, -0.015008279122412205, 0.029052600264549255, -0.03692491725087166, 0.042012471705675125, -0.05773032829165459, -0.035318322479724884, 0.03288165107369423, 0.016320331022143364, -0.006121797952800989, 0.017980480566620827, -0.021207058802247047, -0.006533488165587187, 0.05671281740069389, 0.008454708382487297, -0.05269632861018181, 0.011125673539936543, 0.07529576867818832, -0.012538138777017593, -0.005730190314352512, -0.016735369339585304, 0.012317231856286526, 0.013615895994007587, -0.013562343083322048, -0.045707639306783676, -0.08830919116735458, 0.009780149906873703, -0.02926681376993656, -0.026000069454312325, -0.004762886092066765, -0.017779655754566193, -0.008146777749061584, 0.005740231368690729, 0.021033011376857758, 0.042414117604494095, 0.0033822180703282356, 0.0709579661488533, -0.019359475001692772, -0.05066130682826042, -0.020497480407357216, -0.020028889179229736, 0.0012166613014414907, -0.003711904864758253, -0.016855863854289055, 0.020899128168821335, 0.046698372811079025, -0.012109712697565556, 0.02134094201028347, 0.0004761212330777198, 0.042655106633901596, -0.014017544686794281, 0.031275056302547455, 0.011821864172816277, -0.03588062897324562, 0.01717718318104744, -0.06249656155705452, 0.054142266511917114, 0.05406193435192108, 0.003574674716219306, -0.014325475320219994, -0.01694958098232746, -0.025464536622166634, 0.01617306098341942, 0.03727301210165024, -0.001168128801509738, 0.012350702658295631, -0.01456646528095007, 0.00744389183819294, 0.028650950640439987, 0.006600429303944111, -0.0091174291446805, 0.03628227859735489, 0.03558608889579773, 0.0018994644051417708, -0.002828277414664626, -0.03234612196683884, -0.037192683666944504, 0.009780149906873703, 0.007169432006776333, 0.04726068302989006, 0.01000105682760477, 0.01811436377465725, -0.005753619596362114, 0.06372828781604767, 0.028222525492310524, -0.02139449492096901, -0.03588062897324562, 0.02064475044608116, -0.023242080584168434, 0.006192086264491081, 0.0480639785528183, -0.02005566656589508, 0.0232822448015213, 0.04262833297252655, -0.013026811182498932, 0.00576031394302845, -0.010911460034549236, 0.027044355869293213, 0.030444983392953873, -0.009960891678929329, -0.003842440666630864, -0.006593735422939062, 0.002108656568452716, -0.04214635118842125, 0.018020644783973694, -0.01993517205119133, 0.01389705017209053, 0.027954760938882828, -0.050152555108070374, 0.006011344492435455, 0.026977414265275, -0.04021843895316124, -0.022264733910560608, -0.009967586025595665, -0.01389705017209053, 0.04784976691007614, 0.05194658413529396, 0.0072029028087854385, 0.0050507341511547565, 0.022786878049373627, 0.03443469479680061, 0.0051444522105157375, 0.025009335950016975, 0.0057134549133479595, 0.028302855789661407, -0.02656237781047821, -0.026013458147644997, -0.027111297473311424, -0.00726984441280365, 0.057890988886356354, -0.014646794646978378, 0.04568086192011833, -0.014004156924784184, -0.03325652331113815, 0.010496423579752445, 0.015517033636569977, 0.01894443668425083, 0.07808053493499756, -0.0035512452013790607, 0.02269316092133522, -0.029159706085920334, -0.006637247279286385, 0.036737482994794846, -0.05159848928451538, 0.00005190579395275563, 0.005418912507593632, -0.03392593935132027, 0.01248458493500948, 0.03818341717123985, -0.006764436140656471, -0.02444702759385109, -0.012424337677657604, 0.0012492953101173043, -0.0404326505959034, 0.0033018882386386395, 0.00009439793939236552, -0.007437197957187891, 0.006787865422666073, -0.013883662410080433, -0.016721980646252632, 0.02104640007019043, -0.027981536462903023, -0.01952013373374939, -0.020430538803339005, -0.062228795140981674, -0.0556953065097332, -0.026160728186368942, -0.007564386818557978, -0.011025261133909225, 0.016373885795474052, 0.0362287275493145, -0.02262621931731701, -0.035907406359910965, -0.007504139561206102, 0.001730437157675624, -0.0023780958727002144, -0.026535600423812866, 0.0001910969876917079, 0.017003133893013, -0.03355106711387634, 0.01976112276315689, 0.046055734157562256, 0.07090441137552261, 0.016333719715476036, -0.0025906350929290056, 0.0313018336892128, 0.027767324820160866, 0.040191661566495895, -0.00890990998595953, -0.009485607035458088, 0.0068481131456792355, -0.01653454452753067, 0.017324453219771385, -0.040646862238645554, -0.025116441771388054, 0.010710636153817177, -0.01216326653957367, -0.05740901082754135, -0.0097935376688838, -0.015517033636569977, 0.01752527803182602, 0.0024768346920609474, -0.006587041076272726, -0.015115384943783283, 0.005562836769968271, -0.04276221618056297, 0.006044815294444561, -0.001825828687287867, -0.04431525617837906, 0.001017510425299406, -0.010476340539753437, 0.025866186246275902, -0.02550470270216465, -0.055266883224248886, 0.026468658819794655, -0.006687453482300043, -0.02713807485997677, -0.021541766822338104, -0.027981536462903023, 0.03770143911242485, 0.05955113470554352, -0.04661804437637329, -0.01648099161684513, -0.011982523836195469, -0.021140117198228836, -0.004381319507956505, -0.008903216570615768, 0.0008334213634952903, -0.0342472605407238, 0.02239861711859703, 0.020015500485897064, -0.015543811023235321, -0.006101715378463268, 0.03558608889579773, -0.016494380310177803, 0.01998872496187687, -0.046109288930892944, -0.0030977167189121246, 0.013635978102684021, -0.032158683985471725, 0.0019279144471511245, -0.012109712697565556, 0.0008919951505959034, -0.0052381702698767185, -0.03148927167057991, 0.0012091303942725062, 0.01835535280406475, 0.002878483384847641, 0.013495401479303837, -0.003427403513342142, -0.013977380469441414, -0.013843497261404991, 0.017190570011734962, 0.00293873087503016, -0.01342176552861929, 0.012290454469621181, -0.0011254535056650639, -0.006071591749787331, -0.019038155674934387, -0.0009832029463723302, 0.028276078402996063, -0.001639229361899197, -0.006228904239833355, 0.01806081086397171, -0.012477890588343143, 0.01840890571475029, -0.004592185374349356, 0.038317300379276276, -0.028650950640439987, 0.007069019600749016, 0.04032554477453232, -0.03470246121287346, 0.016507767140865326, 0.002560511464253068, 0.019131872802972794, -0.023576786741614342, 0.006128492299467325, 0.028276078402996063, 0.03189091756939888, 0.04276221618056297, -0.05050064995884895, 0.012658633291721344, -0.005375400651246309, 0.004950322210788727, 0.024005213752388954, -0.001527939224615693, 0.00870908610522747, 0.00199318234808743, 0.0015237553743645549, -0.007905787788331509, 0.009532466530799866, 0.03363139554858208, 0.010623612441122532, 0.020390372723340988, 0.02116689458489418, -0.03697847202420235, 0.028302855789661407, -0.022679772228002548, -0.035211216658353806, 0.015583975240588188, -0.04562731087207794, 0.020845575258135796, 0.006948525086045265, 0.0034173622261732817, 0.019024766981601715, 0.006028079893440008, 0.031623151153326035, 0.09998378902673721, -0.018971214070916176, 0.032694216817617416, 0.04463657736778259, 0.001675210427492857, -0.01894443668425083, -0.030391430482268333, 0.014245145954191685, 0.009405277669429779, 0.004876686260104179, 0.000810828641988337, 0.010248740203678608, -0.025317266583442688, 0.04471690580248833, -0.032988760620355606, -0.01835535280406475, 0.023991825059056282, 0.018569564446806908, -0.0010861253831535578, 0.015249268151819706, -0.012036077678203583, -0.006874889601022005, 0.030712749809026718, 0.009050487540662289, 0.025223547592759132, -0.02484867535531521, -0.007932565174996853, -0.038665395230054855, 0.00015396538947243243, -0.015195715241134167, 0.027981536462903023, 0.05001867190003395, 0.014927948825061321, 0.006968607660382986, -0.009438748471438885, -0.022733325138688087, -0.0038658701814711094, 0.02187647484242916, 0.03175703436136246, 0.014071098528802395, 0.06249656155705452, 0.03464890643954277, -0.012477890588343143, 0.018542788922786713, -0.0004313541285227984, 0.010549976490437984, -0.015249268151819706, 0.01557058747857809, -0.03231934458017349, -0.028758058324456215, 0.014445970766246319, 0.02333579771220684, -0.061479050666093826, -0.029240036383271217, 0.01463340688496828, -0.026522211730480194, 0.006195433437824249, 0.016092730686068535, -0.05411548912525177, 0.022237958386540413, 0.006476587615907192, -0.037326566874980927, 0.011393439024686813, 0.001037592883221805, -0.01834196411073208, 0.020899128168821335, 0.02092590555548668, 0.01771271415054798, -0.012518055737018585, 0.021956803277134895, 0.027633441612124443, -0.011246168054640293, 0.010817741975188255, 0.027191627770662308, 0.011353273876011372, -0.0013798311119899154, 0.004655779805034399, -0.021622097119688988, -0.015289433300495148, 0.011011872440576553, 0.020202936604619026, 0.012082936242222786, 0.011359968222677708, -0.014312087558209896, 0.03242645040154457, -0.021608708426356316, -0.0009840397397056222, 0.020832186564803123, 0.00549589516595006, 0.02731212228536606, 0.0073903389275074005, 0.03799598291516304, -0.01816791668534279, 0.023791000247001648, 0.008314130827784538, 0.03987034410238266, -0.018904272466897964, -0.043833278119564056, -0.011179226450622082, -0.0037888875231146812, 0.00436793128028512, -0.016962969675660133, 0.004732762463390827, 0.005954444408416748, 0.024232814088463783, -0.004026529844850302, 0.002466793404892087, -0.02187647484242916, -0.009345030412077904, 0.0216890387237072, 0.019921783357858658, -0.0313018336892128, -0.02774054743349552, 0.010623612441122532, 0.004267518874257803, 0.021381108090281487, -0.010114856995642185, -0.029400695115327835, -0.013595813885331154, -0.03119472786784172, -0.02498255856335163, -0.006044815294444561, -0.03036465309560299, -0.015195715241134167, 0.045172106474637985, 0.049402810633182526, -0.0027747240383177996, -0.10801676660776138, -0.021528378129005432, 0.02779410034418106, 0.018850719556212425, -0.001071063568815589, 0.02937391959130764, 0.026067011058330536, 0.04332452267408371, -0.0032901735976338387, 0.004766233265399933, 0.0480639785528183, -0.02403198927640915, -0.021916639059782028, -0.0002181873715016991, 0.02151498943567276, -0.02942747250199318, -0.016695203259587288, 0.031167950481176376, 0.03218546137213707, 0.02996300347149372, 0.003969629295170307, 0.03288165107369423, 0.0077652111649513245, 0.015463480725884438, -0.002669291337952018, -0.010034526698291302, -0.033443961292505264, 0.01582496426999569, -0.005030652042478323, 0.015851741656661034, 0.02156854420900345, 0.012665326707065105, -0.004213965963572264, 0.06790543347597122, -0.036442939192056656, -0.04209280014038086, 0.030391430482268333, 0.01835535280406475, 0.0061820452101528645, 0.001184864086098969, 0.035318322479724884, -0.020684916526079178, -0.00994080863893032, 0.02333579771220684, 0.03601451218128204, 0.014057709835469723, -0.022251347079873085, 0.0394151397049427, 0.02533065341413021, 0.015356374904513359, 0.008461402729153633, -0.016842475160956383, 0.02621428109705448, 0.02867772802710533, -0.04918859526515007, 0.012799209915101528, 0.006446463987231255, 0.02749955840408802, -0.008421237580478191, -0.025933127850294113, -0.028811611235141754, 0.036442939192056656, 0.016735369339585304, -0.024473803117871284, -0.04094140604138374, -0.016387272626161575, -0.022960925474762917, -0.027338897809386253, 0.012625162489712238, -0.0276066642254591, 0.012169959954917431, 0.010750801302492619, -0.024821899831295013, 0.02883838675916195, 0.003015713533386588, -0.007684881333261728, -0.016976358368992805, 0.014994890429079533, -0.004936933983117342, 0.004769579973071814, 0.000027953296012128703, -0.03933481127023697, 0.008689003065228462, -0.007323397323489189, 0.02234506420791149, -0.005362011957913637, -0.012444420717656612, -0.010262127965688705, -0.013301271013915539, -0.009766761213541031, 0.017270900309085846, -0.027526333928108215, -0.0008593612001277506, -0.004900116007775068, 0.009780149906873703, 0.03478278964757919, 0.01166789885610342, -0.02116689458489418, -0.011560793034732342, -0.011821864172816277, -0.007229679264128208, -0.007557692471891642, -0.031810589134693146, -0.05585596710443497, 0.032694216817617416, -0.014325475320219994, 0.029936227947473526, 0.0465644896030426, 0.024487191811203957, 0.015985624864697456, 0.04016488417983055, 0.010971708223223686, -0.030819855630397797, 0.021180283278226852, 0.008387766778469086, -0.021836308762431145, -0.018502624705433846, -0.06008666753768921, -0.005515977740287781, -0.0004974588518962264, -0.007042243145406246, 0.009693125262856483, -0.028704505413770676, 0.00044725273619405925, 0.02186308614909649, -0.010911460034549236, -0.00734347989782691, -0.015932071954011917, 0.000676108873449266, 0.03746045008301735, 0.012625162489712238, -0.008394461125135422, 0.012678715400397778, 0.012799209915101528, 0.003541204147040844, -0.005479159764945507, -0.01327449455857277, 0.04683225601911545, -0.011815170757472515, 0.025076277554035187, -0.022492336109280586, -0.006158615928143263, 0.003932811785489321, -0.003668392775580287, -0.04123594984412193, 0.01587851718068123, -0.03360462188720703, 0.00535197090357542, -0.000395373092032969, -0.02310819737613201, -0.025518089532852173, 0.009586019441485405, -0.0057168020866811275, 0.019533522427082062, 0.009478912688791752, 0.008722473867237568, -0.00635944027453661, 0.027981536462903023, -0.010114856995642185, 0.004173800814896822, 0.034033045172691345, 0.03239967301487923, -0.013562343083322048, 0.001527102431282401, 0.01658809743821621, 0.018690060824155807, -0.00515784090384841, -0.01087129581719637, -0.01840890571475029, -0.026923861354589462, 0.00022655505745206028, -0.00006301912071648985, 0.007865623570978642, 0.0014208328211680055, -0.031462494283914566, -0.030766302719712257, 0.025477925315499306, -0.03636261075735092, -0.004953669384121895, 0.04996511712670326, -0.03703202307224274, 0.018194692209362984, -0.006054856348782778, 0.0031362080480903387, -0.0004422321217134595, 0.01466018334031105, -0.030284322798252106, -0.01342176552861929, 0.017900150269269943, -0.02432653307914734, -0.028999047353863716, 0.03430081158876419, 0.022144239395856857, -0.004531937651336193, 0.016628261655569077, 0.003557939315214753, -0.032105132937431335, -0.0006744353449903429, -0.024286366999149323, -0.014392416924238205, 0.011118979193270206, 0.041423384100198746, 0.036255501210689545, -0.004568755626678467, -0.03641616180539131, -0.03729978948831558, 0.01245780847966671, -0.02609378658235073, -0.03759433329105377, -0.03266743943095207, 0.004873339552432299, -0.005251558963209391, 0.03944191709160805, -0.02854384481906891, 0.06977979093790054, -0.050688084214925766, 0.020765244960784912, 0.022639606148004532, -0.03606806695461273, 0.000828400778118521, 0.03882605582475662, -0.08413204550743103, -0.02838318608701229, 0.04404748976230621, 0.015302821062505245, 0.03740689530968666, -0.016199836507439613, 0.0035813688300549984, -0.052964095026254654, 0.00398636469617486, 0.03979001194238663, -0.015744635835289955, -0.010884683579206467, -0.011406827718019485, -0.012859457172453403, -0.04302997887134552, -0.015744635835289955, 0.007664798758924007, 0.0014107916504144669, 0.006838071625679731, -0.00046189618296921253, -0.02703096717596054, 0.02158193103969097, -0.007664798758924007, -0.010523200035095215, -0.03001655824482441, 0.006623859051615, 0.0020785327069461346, 0.027874430641531944, 0.00847479049116373, -0.02650882489979267, -0.02444702759385109, -0.02198358066380024, 0.006205474957823753, -0.016788922250270844, 0.03234612196683884, -0.027191627770662308, 0.011734840460121632, 0.008347601629793644, 0.0018877496477216482, -0.0002974711824208498, -0.002640841295942664, 0.0035847160033881664, -0.05159848928451538, 0.036496493965387344, -0.003402300411835313, -0.026482047513127327, 0.0020400413777679205, 0.028356408700346947, 0.017806433141231537, 0.0060983682051301, 0.001770602073520422, 0.00726984441280365, -0.027044355869293213, -0.00323996739462018, -0.013522177934646606, 0.01747172512114048, 0.009478912688791752, -0.021715814247727394, 0.02432653307914734, 0.018435683101415634, -0.0021504948381334543, -0.0394151397049427, 0.03823697194457054, 0.00274794758297503, 0.011554098688066006, -0.007142655551433563, -0.03764788433909416, 0.015758022665977478, -0.02567875012755394, 0.000733009132090956, 0.010944930836558342, 0.032747771590948105, 0.016681816428899765, 0.018194692209362984, -0.041423384100198746, 0.01594545878469944, 0.06078286096453667, 0.019613852724432945, -0.019011378288269043, 0.0167621448636055, 0.0017354578012600541, 0.0057168020866811275, -0.00885635707527399, -0.005100940354168415, -0.017137017101049423, -0.02609378658235073, -0.022438783198595047, 0.0029956309590488672, 0.00012059925211360678, -0.010215269401669502, -0.0008677289006300271, -0.014124651439487934, -0.02139449492096901, 0.0052046999335289, -0.008247190155088902, -0.006044815294444561, 0.02977556735277176, -0.00961949024349451, -0.027526333928108215, -0.03331007808446884, 0.005753619596362114, 0.03119472786784172, -0.004337807651609182, -0.00876263901591301, 0.02092590555548668, -0.01641405001282692, 0.003541204147040844, 0.013321354053914547, 0.0015739614609628916, 0.013595813885331154, -0.012169959954917431, -0.00334874726831913, -0.017685938626527786, -0.014071098528802395, 0.026709647849202156, 0.027071133255958557, 0.01828841120004654, -0.019024766981601715, -0.0016593118198215961, -0.010831130668520927, -0.007812070194631815, -0.003178046550601721, 0.010148327797651291, -0.0013965665129944682, -0.010958319529891014, 0.0021722507663071156, -0.037192683666944504, -0.008140083402395248, -0.008608673699200153, 0.04900116100907326, -0.01788676157593727, 0.027405839413404465, -0.0058105201460421085, 0.0480639785528183, 0.013241023756563663, 0.0016308616613969207, -0.004953669384121895, 0.011788393370807171, -0.016387272626161575, 0.01946658082306385, -0.002788112498819828, 0.05047387257218361, 0.01917203888297081, 0.03355106711387634, -0.002035020850598812, -0.004662473686039448, -0.0010258781258016825, -0.01295986957848072, -0.03349751606583595, -0.02567875012755394, -0.03419370576739311, 0.007470668759196997, 0.013615895994007587, -0.03167670592665672, 0.022077297791838646, 0.030043333768844604, -0.03100729174911976, -0.021501602604985237, 0.012725574895739555, -0.00799950584769249, 0.019493358209729195, 0.0043244194239377975, 0.03095373883843422, -0.033524289727211, -0.028168972581624985, 0.030578866600990295, -0.002481855219230056, 0.019667405635118484, 0.018154527992010117, 0.03293520584702492, 0.0051477993838489056, 0.0032901735976338387, 0.008608673699200153, -0.00573353748768568, -0.0019898354075849056, -0.01723073609173298, 0.023724058642983437, -0.017096852883696556, -0.010596835985779762, -0.010074691846966743, -0.020149383693933487, 0.0033587885554879904, -0.0017823168309405446, 0.00041859340853989124, -0.007042243145406246, -0.00005070293627795763, 0.005556142423301935, 0.03419370576739311, 0.007376950699836016, -0.04198569431900978, -0.017511889338493347, -0.00024914779351092875, 0.02578585594892502, 0.02051086723804474, 0.00885635707527399, 0.015088608488440514, -0.01800725609064102, -0.0022542541846632957, 0.0033554413821548223, -0.041182395070791245, 0.00741711538285017, -0.009258005768060684, 0.0025270406622439623, -0.015342986211180687, 0.009693125262856483, -0.015530422329902649, -0.0007204576395452023, 0.007604551501572132, 0.014178204350173473, 0.009258005768060684, -0.008950075134634972, -0.0051678819581866264, 0.05031321197748184, -0.045279212296009064, -0.011118979193270206, -0.004160412587225437, -0.00323996739462018, -0.03547898307442665, 0.013575730845332146, -0.006014691665768623, -0.016574708744883537, 0.008240495808422565, 0.03499700501561165, 0.03874572739005089, 0.03933481127023697, 0.040539756417274475, 0.02578585594892502, 0.025236936286091805, -0.01636049710214138, -0.0066339001059532166, 0.020497480407357216, 0.011841947212815285, -0.01905154436826706, 0.01682908646762371, 0.004193883389234543, -0.023603564128279686, -0.02814219705760479, 0.009331641718745232, 0.01319416519254446, 0.05159848928451538, -0.0072966208681464195, -0.00398636469617486, -0.008334213867783546, 0.00274794758297503, 0.015168937854468822, 0.019091708585619926, -0.0006798743852414191, -0.025826022028923035, -0.02063136361539364, 0.016507767140865326, 0.007430503610521555, 0.0011204329784959555, -0.03363139554858208, -0.007718352135270834, -0.019359475001692772, 0.02854384481906891, -0.010603529401123524, 0.02203713357448578, 0.009331641718745232, -0.006520099472254515, 0.008809498511254787, 0.00007060233474476263, -0.013548954389989376, 0.04145016148686409, 0.006707536056637764, 0.00805975403636694, -0.01753866672515869, 0.0817757099866867, 0.0057134549133479595, 0.02779410034418106, 0.008140083402395248, -0.036791034042835236, -0.030980514362454414, 0.023951658979058266, -0.03306908905506134, -0.003214864293113351, -0.01646760292351246, 0.009104040451347828, 0.028463514521718025, -0.009572630748152733, -0.007062325719743967, 0.003708557691425085, 0.004819786176085472, -0.03261388838291168, -0.004652432631701231, -0.03783532232046127, -0.002838318469002843, -0.03724623844027519, -0.010924848727881908, -0.03288165107369423, 0.010034526698291302, -0.020658139139413834, -0.0007200392428785563, 0.03001655824482441, -0.023362575098872185, -0.028650950640439987, -0.0023245427291840315, -0.015583975240588188, 0.009994362480938435, -0.01740478351712227, -0.025397595018148422, 0.00008299697219626978, -0.00818024855107069, -0.01466018334031105, -0.017217347398400307, 0.028945494443178177, -0.013709614053368568, -0.0355057567358017, 0.035666417330503464, -0.031221503391861916, -0.05175914987921715, 0.02854384481906891, 0.013033505529165268, 0.014124651439487934, 0.01178169995546341, -0.0021002888679504395, -0.0029454249888658524, 0.013200858607888222, -0.02526371367275715, 0.01740478351712227, 0.01681569777429104, 0.014231757260859013, 0.025236936286091805, 0.03507733345031738, 0.03355106711387634, -0.024875452741980553, -0.006901666056364775, 0.0005150309880264103, 0.008983545936644077, -0.023616952821612358, -0.02403198927640915, -0.0069150542840361595, -0.01566430553793907, 0.004381319507956505, -0.01998872496187687, 0.007644716650247574, 0.00015040913422126323, -0.011132366955280304, -0.003634922206401825, 0.017726102843880653, -0.013843497261404991, -0.0015296126948669553, 0.05368706211447716, -0.01362928468734026, 0.04348518326878548, 0.01648099161684513, 0.016347108408808708, -0.006677411962300539, 0.00961949024349451, 0.02942747250199318, 0.004023182671517134, 0.01248458493500948, 0.021354330703616142, -0.011279638856649399, 0.008869745768606663, 0.0013020116603001952, -0.000770663726143539, -0.03100729174911976, -0.0006351072224788368, 0.00941197108477354, -0.029507802799344063, 0.012270372360944748, -0.003993059042841196, 0.006704188883304596, 0.0023948312737047672, 0.0002424536505714059, -0.02104640007019043, -0.010268822312355042, 0.0228002667427063, 0.032988760620355606, 0.025477925315499306, 0.02774054743349552, -0.038076311349868774, 0.0216890387237072, 0.03395271673798561, 0.03036465309560299, 0.013140611350536346, -0.034622132778167725, -0.03791565075516701, -0.006851459853351116, 0.04094140604138374, -0.02656237781047821, -0.022827042266726494, 0.018542788922786713, 0.00681464234367013, 0.022063910961151123, -0.04509177803993225, -0.022251347079873085, -0.008220412768423557, 0.028035089373588562, -0.004180495161563158, 0.030150439590215683, 0.014124651439487934, 0.03060564212501049, 0.0382101945579052, -0.012230207212269306, 0.004070041701197624, 0.02779410034418106, 0.0020584503654390574, 0.0008501567644998431, -0.02215762808918953, 0.002612391021102667, -0.0029136277735233307, -0.0332833006978035, -0.010891377925872803, -0.017444947734475136, -0.012725574895739555, -0.01319416519254446, -0.03553253412246704, 0.009465524926781654, -0.006791212595999241, 0.02063136361539364, -0.015061832033097744, -0.03571997210383415, 0.02227812260389328, 0.025544866919517517, -0.005117675755172968, 0.01582496426999569, 0.027820877730846405, 0.017257511615753174, 0.004023182671517134, -0.010429481975734234, -0.051732372492551804, -0.0313018336892128, 0.018676672130823135, -0.019787900149822235, -0.01566430553793907, 0.0293203666806221, -0.009485607035458088, 0.011922276578843594, 0.038317300379276276, -0.029561355710029602, 0.006402952130883932, 0.02004227787256241, -0.015758022665977478, 0.004153718706220388, -0.022666383534669876, 0.013528872281312943, -0.023523233830928802, 0.03290842846035957, -0.0027914594393223524, -0.013649366796016693, 0.025705525651574135, 0.03936158865690231, 0.02276010252535343, 0.0028132156003266573, 0.012531444430351257, 0.0011739861220121384, 0.04169115051627159, 0.0030357958748936653, 0.009980973787605762, 0.012491279281675816, 0.010650388896465302, 0.011828558519482613, -0.016253389418125153, -0.00131958385463804, 0.0031663316767662764, 0.024835286661982536, 0.0035679806023836136, -0.009800232015550137, -0.01906493306159973, 0.02474156953394413, 0.020122608169913292, -0.03205157816410065, 0.02092590555548668, -0.008548426441848278, 0.026830144226551056, -0.017096852883696556, -0.021956803277134895, -0.007423809729516506, -0.00004827107841265388, -0.01058344729244709, -0.021381108090281487, -0.020015500485897064, 0.007075713947415352, 0.024781733751296997, -0.0026592500507831573, -0.02092590555548668, -0.046350277960300446, 0.006011344492435455, -0.0010216942755505443, -0.011453686282038689, 0.0024433638900518417, 0.04027199000120163, -0.007410421501845121, 0.002073512179777026, -0.0005238170269876719, 0.012913011014461517, 0.002103635808452964, -0.021180283278226852, -0.017337841913104057, 0.040780745446681976, 0.03419370576739311, -0.00677113002166152, 0.011908888816833496, -0.02316175028681755, 0.028891941532492638, -0.011031955480575562, -0.04380650073289871, 0.00856181513518095, 0.014392416924238205, 0.012571608647704124, 0.007423809729516506, -0.03322974964976311, -0.02843673899769783, 0.016253389418125153, 0.01125286240130663, -0.00688827782869339, -0.036255501210689545, 0.040780745446681976, 0.026629319414496422, 0.01986823044717312, -0.018743613734841347, -0.000423614023020491, -0.0036416163202375174, -0.043056756258010864, 0.017110241577029228, 0.014071098528802395 ]
14.39179
4.852294
2024-07-01
1
2024MNRAS.tmp.1645K
[ "diffuse X-ray emission", "radio emission", "large radio shells", "galaxy mergers", "odd radio circles", "interacting galaxies", "merger shocks", "the brightest X-ray emission", "the X-ray data", "diffuse light" ]
[ "galaxies: radio", "individual (ESO 184-G042)", "galaxy interactions/mergers", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
75
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1669", "10.48550/arXiv.2404.09522" ]
[ "Koribalski, Bärbel S.", "Khabibullin, Ildar", "Dolag, Klaus", "Churazov, Eugene", "Norris, Ray P.", "Carretti, Ettore", "Hopkins, Andrew M.", "Vernstrom, Tessa", "Shabala, Stanislav S.", "Gupta, Nikhel" ]
[ "Australia Telescope National Facility, CSIRO Astronomy and Space Science, P.O. Box 76, Epping, NSW 1710, Australia; School of Science, Western Sydney University, Locked Bag 1797, Penrith, NSW 2751, Australia", "Universitäts-Sternwarte, Fakultät für Physik, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Scheinerstr. 1, D-81679 München, Germany; Max-Planck-Institut für Astrophysik, Karl-Schwarzschildstr. 1, D-85748, Garching, Germany; Space Research Institute (IKI), Profsoyuznaya 84/32, Moscow 117997, Russia;", "Universitäts-Sternwarte, Fakultät für Physik, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Scheinerstr. 1, D-81679 München, Germany; Max-Planck-Institut für Astrophysik, Karl-Schwarzschildstr. 1, D-85748, Garching, Germany", "Max-Planck-Institut für Astrophysik, Karl-Schwarzschildstr. 1, D-85748, Garching, Germany; Space Research Institute (IKI), Profsoyuznaya 84/32, Moscow 117997, Russia", "Australia Telescope National Facility, CSIRO Astronomy and Space Science, P.O. Box 76, Epping, NSW 1710, Australia; School of Science, Western Sydney University, Locked Bag 1797, Penrith, NSW 2751, Australia;", "INAF-Istituto di Radioastronomia, Via Gobetti 101, 40129 Bologna, Italy;", "School of Mathematical and Physical Sciences, 12 Wally's Walk, Macquarie University, NSW 2109, Australia", "International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research, The University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Highway, Crawley, WA 6009, Australia; CSIRO Space &amp; Astronomy, PO Box 1130, Bentley WA 6102, Australia;", "School of Natural Sciences, Private Bag 37, University of Tasmania, Hobart 7001, Australia;", "CSIRO Space &amp; Astronomy, PO Box 1130, Bentley WA 6102, Australia" ]
[ "2024MNRAS.531.3357K" ]
[ "1980Natur.285..643M", "1983ApJ...274..534M", "1989spce.book.....L", "1996ASPC..101...17A", "1996MNRAS.282..263E", "1998ApJ...495...80B", "2001A&A...365L...1J", "2001ApJ...556L..91S", "2001MNRAS.328..726S", "2002ApJ...567L..27M", "2002MNRAS.333..649S", "2003AJ....126.2268W", "2003ApJ...590..225C", "2003MNRAS.342.1025T", "2003MNRAS.342.1117M", "2004AJ....128...16K", "2004ApJ...606L..97D", "2005AN....326..414B", "2005MNRAS.361..776S", "2005MNRAS.364..753D", "2006AJ....131.1163S", "2007MNRAS.382.1050T", "2008ApJ...672..122E", "2008ExA....22..151J", "2009ApJ...696.1431R", "2009MNRAS.399..497D", "2009MNRAS.399..574W", "2009MNRAS.399..683J", "2010MNRAS.401.1670F", "2011ApJS..192...18K", "2011PASA...28..215N", "2012ApJ...749...19K", "2012MNRAS.425.1068D", "2012MNRAS.426..296D", "2012MNRAS.426.3160G", "2012PASA...29..359K", "2013MNRAS.428.1395B", "2014A&A...570A..13M", "2014MNRAS.442.2304H", "2014MNRAS.444.3130D", "2016MNRAS.455.2110B", "2016MNRAS.458.1013S", "2016MNRAS.463.1797D", "2017ARA&A..55...59N", "2017Galax...5...35D", "2017MNRAS.464.1146H", "2017MNRAS.469.3069G", "2018A&A...618A..81T", "2018ApJ...856L...1L", "2018ApJ...864..149S", "2018MNRAS.480.3644R", "2018MNRAS.481.2213B", "2018SSRv..214..123B", "2019AJ....157..168D", "2019ApJ...875...59Y", "2019ApJS..242....8Z", "2019MNRAS.486.4001R", "2019MNRAS.487..318K", "2019MNRAS.488.5259Z", "2019MNRAS.488.5370L", "2019NatAs...3..838G", "2019SSRv..215...16V", "2020A&A...634A.135G", "2020Ap&SS.365..118K", "2021A&A...655A.115F", "2021MNRAS.500.5056R", "2021MNRAS.505L..11K", "2021PASA...38....3N", "2021PASA...38....9H", "2021PASA...38...46N", "2021PhRvD.104h3538Y", "2021Univ....7..139L", "2022A&A...661A..13P", "2022A&A...661A..17B", "2022MNRAS.513.1300N", "2022NatAs...6..308M", "2022PASA...39...35H", "2022PASA...39...51G", "2022arXiv220808245K", "2022arXiv221109827K", "2023A&A...675A.188A", "2023A&A...680A..31J", "2023ApJ...945...74D", "2023ApJ...948...25N", "2023ApJ...951..104A", "2023MNRAS.518.5953L", "2023MNRAS.520.1439L", "2023MNRAS.523.1933V", "2024A&A...683A.175K", "2024A&A...685L...2B", "2024ApJ...963....8R", "2024ApJ...967...51R", "2024MNRAS.52711233K", "2024MNRAS.528.3854Y", "2024MNRAS.531.1905R", "2024MNRAS.531.3357K", "2024MNRAS.531L...9R", "2024Natur.625..459C", "2024PASA...41...24S", "2024PhRvD.109f3513C", "2024arXiv240108207L", "2024arXiv240117276B" ]
29163060
2404.12620
Physical Properties of Type II Supernovae Inferred from ZTF and ATLAS Photometric Data
We report an analysis of a sample of 186 spectroscopically confirmed Type II supernova (SN) light curves (LCs) obtained from a combination of Zwicky Transient Facility (ZTF) and Asteroid Terrestrial-impact Last Alert System observations. We implement a method to infer physical parameters from these LCs using hydrodynamic models that take into account the progenitor mass, the explosion energy, and the presence of circumstellar matter (CSM). The CSM is modeled via the mass-loss rate, wind acceleration at the surface of the progenitor star with a β velocity law, and the CSM radius. We also infer the time of explosion, attenuation (A <SUB> V </SUB>), and the redshift for each SN. Our results favor low-mass progenitor stars (M <SUB>ZAMS</SUB> &lt; 14 M <SUB>⊙</SUB>) with a dense CSM ( &gt; 10<SUP>‑3</SUP> M <SUB>⊙</SUB> yr<SUP>‑1</SUP>, CSM radius ∼ 10<SUP>15</SUP> cm, and β &gt; 2). Additionally, we find that the redshifts inferred from the SN LCs are significantly more accurate than those inferred using the host galaxy photometric redshift, suggesting that this method could be used to infer more accurate host galaxy redshifts from large samples of Type II SNe in the LSST era. Lastly, we compare our results with similar works from the literature.
[ 0.01600462943315506, 0.027562826871871948, 0.0008392325253225863, -0.06123949959874153, 0.015562512911856174, 0.012947707436978817, 0.009429720230400562, -0.050982385873794556, -0.0016160949598997831, 0.021537406370043755, -0.03445984795689583, 0.01404668390750885, -0.07195135951042175, 0.017924679443240166, 0.013642462901771069, 0.013099290430545807, 0.011431878432631493, 0.02072896435856819, -0.04484327882528305, 0.01639621891081333, -0.010092895478010178, -0.012164529412984848, -0.009183398447930813, -0.039310503751039505, 0.009404457174241543, -0.04747071489691734, 0.039942096918821335, 0.016370955854654312, 0.06068369373679161, -0.026754384860396385, -0.006846494972705841, -0.01633305847644806, -0.07245663553476334, 0.004389588721096516, -0.06088580563664436, 0.06240163370966911, 0.028775490820407867, 0.01405931543558836, -0.024708015844225883, -0.0284217968583107, -0.03241347894072533, -0.00860864669084549, -0.00042198473238386214, 0.03322192281484604, -0.038982074707746506, -0.011968734674155712, -0.022307952865958214, -0.018531011417508125, -0.03536934778094292, 0.03440932184457779, -0.041382137686014175, 0.003947471734136343, 0.03339876979589462, 0.002354272175580263, -0.009758150205016136, -0.03627884387969971, 0.0204763263463974, 0.03617778792977333, -0.02665332891047001, -0.0021079499274492264, -0.0015663567464798689, -0.007452826946973801, 0.02155003882944584, -0.016535170376300812, 0.019958417862653732, -0.026223843917250633, 0.02287638932466507, 0.005409615114331245, 0.010459220968186855, 0.03637989982962608, -0.0065496452152729034, 0.0015063552418723702, -0.012688753195106983, -0.03471248969435692, -0.013554039411246777, 0.03440932184457779, -0.024606959894299507, 0.015031972900032997, -0.015688830986618996, 0.02905339188873768, 0.032489269971847534, 0.03296928480267525, -0.003006394486874342, 0.0170783419162035, -0.039007335901260376, 0.01721729338169098, 0.017507826909422874, -0.021373191848397255, -0.03855258971452713, 0.018467852845788002, 0.030922915786504745, 0.013768781907856464, 0.005112765356898308, -0.008065474219620228, 0.005175924859941006, -0.010749755427241325, -0.022560590878129005, -0.07073869556188583, 0.06755544990301132, 0.018417324870824814, 0.0007887048413977027, 0.0520939938724041, 0.03375246375799179, -0.05861205980181694, 0.021120553836226463, 0.02345745638012886, -0.009985524229705334, -0.027638617902994156, -0.01602989248931408, -0.0033790357410907745, 0.04934024065732956, 0.03375246375799179, -0.052195049822330475, 0.02343219332396984, -0.03355035185813904, -0.0021963731851428747, -0.04491906985640526, 0.021448982879519463, -0.03294401988387108, 0.019971048459410667, 0.007339139468967915, -0.009347612969577312, 0.009726570919156075, 0.0243669543415308, 0.03617778792977333, -0.015019340440630913, 0.023419560864567757, -0.026198580861091614, 0.002578488551080227, -0.01226558443158865, 0.0036790436133742332, -0.03370193392038345, -0.014741438440978527, 0.002239006105810404, -0.06169424578547478, 0.01226558443158865, 0.009120238944888115, -0.034535642713308334, -0.019806833937764168, 0.010080263949930668, -0.00239058886654675, 0.03529355674982071, 0.017848888412117958, 0.040194734930992126, 0.0006683069514110684, 0.01313718594610691, -0.0063727982342243195, 0.04646016284823418, -0.02725966088473797, 0.03984104469418526, -0.005264348350465298, 0.016661489382386208, -0.008008630946278572, -0.0368599109351635, -0.015575144439935684, -0.035116709768772125, 0.0010673963697627187, -0.01683833636343479, -0.012764545157551765, -0.05118449777364731, 0.027663882821798325, 0.02306586690247059, -0.033322978764772415, 0.01730571687221527, -0.05254874378442764, 0.03291875496506691, -0.017861520871520042, -0.025756463408470154, -0.07255768775939941, -0.0009513407130725682, -0.0010295006213709712, 0.024682750925421715, -0.0017005708068609238, -0.04757177084684372, -0.013629830442368984, 0.02629963681101799, 0.011223452165722847, -0.02103213034570217, -0.03233768790960312, -0.01001710444688797, -0.020867913961410522, 0.009966576471924782, 0.007648621220141649, -0.019528932869434357, -0.003577988361939788, 0.008798125199973583, -0.03701149672269821, 0.03079659678041935, 0.029760779812932014, -0.09110133349895477, 0.02033737488090992, 0.0031390294898301363, 0.014880389906466007, 0.03344929590821266, -0.016156213358044624, -0.01597936637699604, -0.008065474219620228, 0.029154447838664055, -0.009694990701973438, -0.013794044964015484, 0.032135579735040665, 0.01945314183831215, 0.047672826796770096, -0.0439843088388443, -0.018303636461496353, 0.004269585479050875, 0.03678411990404129, 0.0021158449817448854, 0.007560197729617357, 0.02213110588490963, 0.025352243334054947, -0.019794203341007233, -0.019301557913422585, 0.00009168003452941775, -0.032135579735040665, 0.01196241844445467, -0.03739045187830925, 0.03241347894072533, 0.00289428629912436, -0.014097210951149464, -0.009347612969577312, 0.0063538504764437675, 0.0022263741120696068, -0.018063630908727646, -0.004964340478181839, 0.04509591683745384, -0.0005096186068840325, 0.007231768220663071, 0.0074780904687941074, -0.012303479947149754, 0.0035716723650693893, 0.046788591891527176, -0.04307481274008751, -0.013023498468101025, -0.009012867696583271, 0.02075422741472721, -0.028042839840054512, 0.021764781326055527, -0.004080106969922781, -0.04936550185084343, -0.005106449592858553, 0.023545879870653152, 0.006808599457144737, 0.0633111298084259, 0.021891100332140923, 0.023823780938982964, 0.0031785042956471443, -0.030594484880566597, 0.014337217435240746, 0.005179082974791527, 0.017558354884386063, -0.006158056203275919, 0.018227845430374146, -0.03173135593533516, 0.0005242242477834225, -0.008646542206406593, -0.0037137814797461033, 0.005450669210404158, -0.024126946926116943, -0.004039053339511156, -0.027436507865786552, -0.03622831776738167, -0.030266055837273598, -0.0011226609349250793, -0.06487748771905899, 0.006682280451059341, 0.015764623880386353, -0.04102844372391701, -0.006410694215446711, -0.004348535090684891, -0.039942096918821335, 0.0029242869932204485, 0.04001789167523384, -0.019440509378910065, -0.052750855684280396, 0.012076105922460556, 0.0063096387311816216, 0.029129182919859886, -0.014413009397685528, -0.009404457174241543, 0.009985524229705334, -0.05055290088057518, 0.024190107360482216, 0.005333824083209038, -0.0269059669226408, -0.0015197766479104757, -0.00508434372022748, 0.04297375679016113, 0.01616884395480156, -0.0808442234992981, 0.007629673462361097, -0.04671280086040497, -0.0299376267939806, -0.04810231178998947, -0.05131081864237785, -0.012410851195454597, 0.015208818949759007, 0.012909811921417713, -0.04302428290247917, 0.013983524404466152, 0.03327244892716408, 0.048279158771038055, 0.05472143366932869, -0.026678593829274178, -0.015764623880386353, -0.0025484878569841385, 0.04757177084684372, 0.0028074418660253286, -0.015562512911856174, 0.05527723580598831, 0.0167499128729105, 0.014880389906466007, -0.04272111877799034, -0.004313797224313021, 0.015398298390209675, -0.03493986278772354, -0.01452669594436884, 0.02991236187517643, 0.0008242321200668812, -0.03860311582684517, -0.004673806484788656, -0.07462932169437408, 0.020817387849092484, -0.004613805096596479, 0.01171609666198492, -0.03112502582371235, -0.008602330461144447, -0.013730885460972786, 0.03231242671608925, 0.034889332950115204, 0.020400533452630043, -0.017116237431764603, 0.049466557800769806, 0.031301870942115784, 0.007471774704754353, -0.06624173372983932, -0.0053464556112885475, 0.019352085888385773, -0.024379584938287735, -0.008160213939845562, -0.004796967841684818, 0.013276137411594391, 0.025099605321884155, 0.017760464921593666, 0.021006865426898003, 0.006922286469489336, 0.03648095577955246, 0.014741438440978527, 0.03981577977538109, -0.007073869463056326, -0.020539484918117523, -0.032186105847358704, 0.010080263949930668, 0.0011945049045607448, 0.068313367664814, 0.019554195925593376, 0.03610199689865112, -0.05118449777364731, 0.031023969873785973, 0.014690911397337914, -0.032741911709308624, -0.00838758796453476, 0.03855258971452713, -0.025731200352311134, -0.025617513805627823, 0.01865733042359352, -0.00020625539764296263, 0.00035073288017883897, -0.01135608647018671, -0.06826283782720566, 0.020463693886995316, 0.033626142889261246, 0.015423561446368694, -0.005959103349596262, -0.03370193392038345, 0.0055548823438584805, -0.006025420967489481, -0.007737044710665941, 0.0011455563362687826, 0.01165925245732069, 0.056995175778865814, 0.00016539906209800392, 0.027310188859701157, -0.029811307787895203, -0.010541328229010105, -0.017444666475057602, 0.016876231878995895, 0.009290769696235657, -0.059016283601522446, 0.00814126618206501, -0.012259268201887608, -0.027865992859005928, -0.006082264706492424, 0.015499353408813477, 0.018328901380300522, 0.0037453612312674522, 0.04512118175625801, 0.06715123355388641, 0.04451484978199005, 0.04221584275364876, -0.021587934345006943, -0.02210584282875061, -0.01589094288647175, -0.033019810914993286, 0.01085712667554617, 0.0029763937927782536, -0.022472167387604713, 0.037819936871528625, 0.032741911709308624, -0.0053148758597671986, 0.0170783419162035, -0.01171609666198492, 0.02988709881901741, -0.06230057775974274, 0.03082185983657837, 0.0314534567296505, 0.017116237431764603, 0.056944649666547775, 0.0010113422758877277, 0.056692011654376984, -0.01611831597983837, -0.05148766562342644, 0.01683833636343479, -0.00830548070371151, -0.03976524993777275, -0.03016499988734722, 0.015158291906118393, 0.002632174175232649, 0.009758150205016136, -0.017229923978447914, -0.007269664201885462, 0.018114158883690834, 0.028522852808237076, -0.0017384665552526712, -0.004399062599986792, 0.02839653380215168, 0.021739516407251358, 0.018531011417508125, 0.009562355466187, -0.0033411402255296707, 0.039335768669843674, 0.06411956995725632, -0.0024047999177128077, -0.03491459786891937, 0.06790914386510849, 0.017065709456801414, 0.005134871229529381, -0.011318190954625607, 0.036354634910821915, -0.05376140773296356, 0.031503982841968536, -0.005516986362636089, 0.015145659446716309, 0.0362030528485775, -0.07432615756988525, -0.0014818808995187283, -0.0054222471080720425, -0.05194241181015968, 0.10247005522251129, -0.029786042869091034, -0.021739516407251358, 0.006928602699190378, -0.011438194662332535, -0.048557061702013016, 0.008545487187802792, 0.012019261717796326, -0.010749755427241325, 0.006369640585035086, 0.0066064889542758465, -0.003255874617025256, 0.03198399394750595, -0.059319447726011276, -0.013869836926460266, -0.007825467735528946, -0.007983366958796978, 0.023470088839530945, 0.004907496739178896, 0.022093210369348526, 0.07836836576461792, 0.03741571679711342, 0.030139736831188202, -0.0073265074752271175, 0.014880389906466007, 0.028270214796066284, 0.006085422355681658, 0.032767172902822495, -0.013629830442368984, 0.03461143374443054, 0.0013105606194585562, 0.021979521960020065, -0.025074340403079987, -0.035419873893260956, 0.05194241181015968, -0.012777176685631275, -0.030569221824407578, -0.050653956830501556, -0.011128712445497513, -0.010686595924198627, -0.027941783890128136, 0.014943549409508705, 0.07437668740749359, -0.02867443487048149, 0.017709936946630478, 0.03733992576599121, 0.030998706817626953, -0.0018505747430026531, 0.0012284532422199845, 0.026527009904384613, -0.05891522765159607, 0.024164842441678047, -0.026223843917250633, 0.056944649666547775, 0.0028216529171913862, -0.024354321882128716, -0.029204975813627243, -0.009473931975662708, -0.015398298390209675, 0.0035085128620266914, -0.00009927891369443387, -0.015638304874300957, 0.031200816854834557, -0.04186214879155159, -0.0013784571783617139, -0.027310188859701157, 0.03536934778094292, -0.013238240964710712, 0.018139421939849854, -0.09029289335012436, -0.027588089928030968, 0.011330823414027691, 0.002344798296689987, -0.04959287866950035, 0.0036506219767034054, -0.00535277184098959, -0.019554195925593376, -0.007187556475400925, -0.018088893964886665, 0.028598643839359283, -0.024745911359786987, -0.031554508954286575, 0.011873994953930378, -0.015789886936545372, -0.005993841215968132, -0.04908760264515877, 0.0009623936493881047, 0.020274214446544647, -0.0031121866777539253, -0.008065474219620228, 0.031175553798675537, 0.027916520833969116, 0.04848127067089081, -0.04484327882528305, 0.0004804073250852525, 0.031175553798675537, -0.006871758960187435, 0.012935075908899307, -0.00800231471657753, 0.014640383422374725, -0.0152340829372406, -0.006369640585035086, -0.03504091873764992, -0.009739202447235584, -0.016952022910118103, 0.025705935433506966, -0.002737966366112232, -0.02867443487048149, 0.011242399923503399, -0.020211055874824524, -0.004490643739700317, 0.03888101875782013, -0.039916835725307465, -0.024114316329360008, -0.021726883947849274, -0.004575909115374088, -0.02930602990090847, -0.011930839158594608, -0.03744098171591759, -0.0018032051157206297, 0.00790757592767477, -0.02779020182788372, -0.01898575946688652, -0.0013745096512138844, -0.004986446350812912, 0.015650935471057892, -0.04130634292960167, -0.022446904331445694, 0.0037011494860053062, 0.019528932869434357, -0.01467827893793583, -0.03127660974860191, 0.02376062236726284, -0.020375270396471024, -0.0055327764712274075, 0.03241347894072533, -0.029129182919859886, 0.008494959212839603, 0.05588356778025627, -0.00823600497096777, -0.03941155970096588, -0.023103762418031693, -0.02527645044028759, 0.010844494216144085, -0.014387745410203934, -0.011065552942454815, 0.01256875041872263, 0.03377772495150566, 0.01567620038986206, -0.042923230677843094, -0.023116394877433777, 0.026451218873262405, 0.0008802862139418721, 0.014690911397337914, 0.008614961989223957, -0.024985916912555695, 0.013023498468101025, 0.009720254689455032, 0.0028358637355268, -0.028876544907689095, 0.013465615920722485, -0.020691068843007088, -0.006739123724400997, -0.029482876881957054, 0.03357561677694321, 0.048607587814331055, 0.05805625766515732, 0.0027837571687996387, -0.004942234605550766, -0.01818994991481304, -0.04747071489691734, -0.0033158762380480766, 0.022699542343616486, -0.0167499128729105, 0.03804731369018555, 0.013642462901771069, -0.026804912835359573, 0.019251029938459396, 0.013869836926460266, 0.025188028812408447, -0.0013863521162420511, -0.011627673171460629, 0.0013974050525575876, 0.03499038890004158, 0.03264085575938225, -0.05199294164776802, -0.028219686821103096, 0.03595041483640671, 0.006682280451059341, 0.014160370454192162, -0.032186105847358704, -0.025592248886823654, -0.039310503751039505, 0.0054254052229225636, 0.010838178917765617, 0.016484642401337624, 0.00869075395166874, -0.0014068789314478636, 0.03319665789604187, 0.0019121553050354123, -0.014450904913246632, 0.008684437721967697, 0.00168162293266505, 0.004478012211620808, 0.005700149107724428, 0.020021576434373856, 0.014754070900380611, -0.01774783246219158, 0.005239084362983704, 0.01633305847644806, -0.026451218873262405, 0.001556882867589593, 0.046535953879356384, 0.015714095905423164, 0.01661096140742302, 0.014589855447411537, -0.0012797703966498375, 0.00023744042846374214, 0.013705622404813766, -0.03233768790960312, -0.017533089965581894, 0.023116394877433777, -0.008248637430369854, 0.00846969522535801, -0.013794044964015484, -0.023166922852396965, 0.010983445681631565, 0.026729121804237366, -0.020880546420812607, 0.0035337768495082855, -0.00869075395166874, 0.019680514931678772, -0.008406535722315311, -0.009214977733790874, -0.012657173909246922, -0.004856969229876995, 0.009505512192845345, -0.0230153389275074, -0.01554988045245409, -0.011968734674155712, 0.0006142266211099923, -0.006928602699190378, 0.005160135217010975, 0.008507590740919113, -0.000811600184533745, -0.015853047370910645, -0.026501746848225594, -0.005687517113983631, -0.028775490820407867, -0.02378588542342186, 0.04330218583345413, -0.028295477852225304, 0.02872496284544468, 0.01419826690107584, -0.034560903906822205, -0.013377192430198193, -0.02045106142759323, 0.02373535744845867, 0.018025735393166542, -0.0032590327318757772, -0.003764308989048004, -0.03019026480615139, 0.018973128870129585, 0.008627594448626041, -0.03804731369018555, 0.012909811921417713, 0.030695540830492973, 0.002398483920842409, -0.016648856922984123, 0.016813071444630623, -0.0022942705545574427, 0.009151818230748177, -0.01273296494036913, -0.016345690935850143, 0.02083001844584942, -0.0027679672930389643, 0.01901102438569069, 0.012859283946454525, -0.022611118853092194, -0.008488642983138561, 0.027158604934811592, 0.021790044382214546, 0.009593935683369637, -0.00153477699495852, -0.022030049934983253, 0.021537406370043755, 0.04067474976181984, -0.010446589440107346, -0.019137343391776085, -0.0010642383713275194, 0.030038680881261826, -0.024190107360482216, -0.0228511244058609, 0.010156054981052876, -0.010276058688759804, -0.033954571932554245, 0.019112078472971916, -0.018291005864739418, 0.023773254826664925, -0.01705307886004448, 0.04418642073869705, 0.015941470861434937, 0.022169001400470734, -0.005936997476965189, 0.031251344829797745, 0.015057235956192017, -0.003587462240830064, 0.03241347894072533, -0.04163477569818497, -0.01287191640585661, -0.001309771090745926, -0.014741438440978527, -0.02555435337126255, -0.02867443487048149, -0.020072104409337044, 0.01724255643785, -0.016737280413508415, -0.01782362535595894, -0.023305874317884445, -0.02753756381571293, 0.018922600895166397, -0.009372876957058907, -0.0009197609033435583, -0.01970577985048294, -0.000052994808356743306, -0.007888627238571644, 0.002850074553862214, 0.026249108836054802, -0.027663882821798325, -0.0003817205142695457, -0.02422800287604332, -0.026223843917250633, -0.014893021434545517, 0.01422352995723486, -0.02552909031510353, 0.002551645739004016, 0.01856890693306923, 0.03771888092160225, -0.025655409321188927, -0.08842337131500244, -0.007193872705101967, -0.016977285966277122, 0.011924522928893566, 0.016762543469667435, 0.014741438440978527, -0.017558354884386063, -0.0074907224625349045, 0.0027127026114612818, -0.028826018795371056, 0.029735514894127846, -0.01554988045245409, -0.009442352689802647, 0.007313875947147608, -0.002251637866720557, 0.0076170414686203, 0.0003094817802775651, 0.011463457718491554, -0.029659723863005638, -0.0248595979064703, -0.0012947707436978817, 0.02105739340186119, -0.028598643839359283, 0.018063630908727646, 0.012309796176850796, 0.0016342533053830266, -0.04481801390647888, 0.042013730853796005, 0.024404849857091904, -0.006688596215099096, 0.007257032208144665, -0.006202267482876778, 0.005065395962446928, 0.03789572790265083, 0.0314534567296505, 0.0038779962342232466, -0.010509748943150043, 0.025339610874652863, -0.03468722477555275, -0.020350007340312004, 0.007421246729791164, -0.01956682838499546, 0.03054395690560341, 0.021587934345006943, 0.05055290088057518, 0.004683280363678932, -0.007042289711534977, 0.01404668390750885, 0.024076420813798904, 0.015663567930459976, 0.03582409769296646, 0.02632489986717701, 0.019819466397166252, 0.010585539974272251, -0.04926444962620735, 0.014741438440978527, -0.01242979895323515, -0.019377348944544792, -0.0016516222385689616, -0.024139579385519028, -0.04686438664793968, 0.019048919901251793, -0.0065054334700107574, -0.012455062940716743, -0.0788736417889595, -0.01258138194680214, -0.04762230068445206, 0.041761092841625214, 0.020931074395775795, -0.020463693886995316, 0.006802283227443695, 0.025049077346920967, 0.023571142926812172, 0.03706202283501625, 0.02597120590507984, 0.01508249994367361, -0.0005194873083382845, -0.012960338965058327, -0.043756935745477676, -0.008570751175284386, 0.0035116709768772125, -0.02425326593220234, -0.006053842604160309, -0.031857676804065704, -0.01581515185534954, 0.01700255088508129, 0.01702781394124031, 0.022724805399775505, -0.004831705242395401, 0.023280609399080276, -0.007118081208318472, -0.02334376983344555, 0.062047939747571945, 0.011267663910984993, -0.014728806912899017, 0.0017416245536878705, -0.021398454904556274, -0.02378588542342186, -0.0016310953069478273, -0.003502196865156293, -0.0170783419162035, 0.003934839740395546, -0.012354007922112942, -0.029457613825798035, 0.01849311590194702, -0.011551881209015846, -0.010383429937064648, 0.05350876972079277, 0.017229923978447914, 0.029760779812932014, 0.038401003926992416, 0.006808599457144737, -0.015170923434197903, 0.04446432366967201, 0.05027500167489052, -0.012316112406551838, 0.013857205398380756, 0.01721729338169098, 0.043175868690013885, -0.0025216450449079275, 0.005362245719879866, 0.014690911397337914, -0.050679221749305725, -0.003096396801993251, -0.003720097476616502, 0.040194734930992126, 0.04105370491743088, -0.01280244067311287, -0.05174030363559723, 0.027007022872567177, -0.047066494822502136, 0.02431642636656761, 0.032741911709308624, -0.02751229889690876, -0.008122317492961884, 0.006770703475922346, -0.02925550378859043, 0.002957445802167058, -0.03847679868340492, 0.018619434908032417, 0.005618041846901178, 0.0395631417632103, -0.015031972900032997, -0.00671386020258069, -0.005384351592510939, 0.012025577947497368, 0.000840811466332525, -0.024417482316493988, 0.01868259534239769, 0.01884680986404419, 0.005807520356029272, -0.009189714677631855, -0.022307952865958214, 0.02141108736395836, -0.023823780938982964, -0.01342772040516138, 0.00274270330555737, 0.0033695618622004986, -0.03165556490421295, -0.01070554368197918, 0.023937469348311424, 0.04646016284823418, 0.02720913290977478, 0.009518143720924854, 0.024682750925421715, 0.033070340752601624, -0.03802204877138138, 0.011065552942454815, -0.03913365676999092, -0.043226394802331924, -0.035773567855358124, -0.03711254894733429, 0.02718386985361576, 0.02814389392733574, -0.0025974365416914225, -0.03817363083362579, 0.0038811543490737677, 0.02245953492820263, 0.011362402699887753, 0.001561619807034731, 0.02000894583761692, -0.004995920229703188, -0.004910654854029417, 0.020021576434373856, 0.0395631417632103, -0.0019516299944370985, -0.003799046855419874, 0.011861363425850868, -0.0030853438656777143, 0.03579883277416229, -0.03819889575242996, 0.02254795841872692, 0.0011850310256704688, 0.010983445681631565, 0.011311874724924564, 0.009290769696235657, -0.003096396801993251, 0.04426221176981926, -0.025478562340140343, -0.02574383281171322, -0.007421246729791164, -0.0010350270895287395, 0.03794625774025917, -0.0055801463313400745, 0.010288690216839314, -0.006953866221010685, -0.0035969363525509834, 0.0045285397209227085, -0.02902812883257866, -0.033954571932554245, 0.022611118853092194, -0.010307637974619865, 0.009789730422198772, 0.04105370491743088, 0.07402299344539642, -0.06826283782720566, 0.021701620891690254, 0.0024458535481244326, -0.0206405408680439, -0.016408851370215416, 0.01947840489447117, -0.026754384860396385, -0.012638225220143795, 0.04416115581989288, -0.01422352995723486, 0.0010295006213709712, 0.04941603168845177, 0.0031863991171121597, 0.00043422190356068313, 0.013238240964710712, 0.016509905457496643, -0.03107449784874916, 0.006158056203275919, -0.013705622404813766, -0.02227005735039711, -0.023091131821274757, 0.02124687284231186, -0.007155976723879576, -0.004888548981398344, 0.018114158883690834, 0.04721807688474655, -0.005551724229007959, -0.020350007340312004, -0.025769095867872238, -0.032489269971847534, 0.003099554916843772, 0.039285238832235336, -0.0025311189237982035, 0.019667884334921837, 0.02751229889690876, -0.0033790357410907745, -0.009562355466187, 0.005018026102334261, -0.019983680918812752, 0.026476481929421425, 0.0008866021526046097, 0.007143344730138779, 0.02546592988073826, 0.027562826871871948, 0.010200266726315022, -0.025213291868567467, 0.04097791388630867, -0.033171396702528, -0.008027578704059124, 0.010156054981052876, 0.014135107398033142, -0.04491906985640526, -0.015069868415594101, 0.012947707436978817, -0.005065395962446928, -0.024884862825274467, -0.004288533236831427, 0.019983680918812752, 0.005074869841337204, -0.01189294271171093, -0.02180267684161663, -0.012234004214406013, -0.005273822229355574, -0.006063316483050585, -0.007566513959318399, -0.044716961681842804, 0.023710094392299652, -0.02422800287604332, -0.0035969363525509834, -0.015613039955496788, -0.009113922715187073, -0.0007073869346641004, -0.005618041846901178, 0.024240635335445404, -0.017697306349873543, -0.033095601946115494, 0.03319665789604187, -0.01597936637699604, -0.009113922715187073, -0.020577380433678627, 0.01119187194854021, -0.0066380687057971954, 0.025680672377347946, 0.010358165949583054, -0.0019689989276230335, -0.0056117260828614235, -0.005539092235267162, 0.01038974616676569, -0.0037895729765295982, -0.0470159687101841, -0.02864917181432247, -0.04310007765889168, -0.014539328403770924, -0.028042839840054512, -0.05558040365576744, -0.005396983586251736, 0.01721729338169098, -0.033322978764772415, 0.00048317055916413665, 0.001972156809642911, -0.03913365676999092, 0.040245264768600464, -0.0008352850563824177, 0.01774783246219158, -0.01947840489447117, -0.02720913290977478, -0.02895233780145645, 0.051538191735744476, 0.00783810019493103, -0.025655409321188927, -0.005030658096075058, 0.020413165912032127, -0.031857676804065704, -0.008324428461492062, 0.03438405692577362, 0.03968945890665054, 0.011071869172155857, -0.02182793989777565, 0.0006580435438081622, -0.03324718773365021, 0.013048762455582619, 0.05080554261803627, 0.004752756096422672, -0.01749519445002079, 0.00801494624465704, -0.006126475986093283, 0.012006630189716816, -0.027360716834664345, -0.01782362535595894, 0.04148318991065025, 0.02094370685517788, -0.020236318930983543, -0.0204763263463974, -0.029811307787895203, 0.009840257465839386, 0.07053658366203308, -0.02627437189221382, -0.0064296419732272625, -0.030948178842663765, 0.003577988361939788, 0.03640516474843025, -0.03140292689204216, 0.0392347127199173, -0.027638617902994156, 0.007585461717098951, 0.027360716834664345, 0.011469773948192596, -0.027613354846835136, 0.016383586451411247, 0.018278373405337334, 0.008785492740571499, -0.03925997391343117, 0.014501431956887245, 0.01298560295253992, 0.0038495745975524187, -0.0055327764712274075, 0.007162292953580618, -0.020236318930983543, -0.01700255088508129, -0.0053559294901788235, 0.0054790908470749855, 0.022320585325360298, 0.022093210369348526, 0.008059157989919186, -0.010396061465144157, -0.004787493962794542, 0.016876231878995895, -0.01669938489794731, -0.002265848917886615, 0.00028717858367599547, -0.0063317446038126945, 0.01589094288647175, 0.012455062940716743, -0.009909733198583126, 0.0004492222797125578, 0.0053685614839196205, -0.006707543972879648, -0.004020105116069317, -0.0008210741216316819, -0.017924679443240166, 0.045550666749477386, -0.018366796895861626, 0.022813228890299797, 0.015688830986618996, -0.00256585655733943, -0.013099290430545807, -0.017090974375605583, 0.0034548272378742695, -0.008798125199973583, 0.028573378920555115, 0.006189635954797268, -0.005362245719879866, -0.018556274473667145, 0.014324585907161236, -0.035748302936553955, -0.04340324178338051, -0.025945942848920822, -0.050679221749305725, 0.018909968435764313, -0.006543329451233149, 0.005659095477312803, -0.0008297585882246494, -0.011172924190759659, 0.014703542925417423, -0.022320585325360298, -0.01174135971814394, 0.001068185898475349, -0.0015734622720628977, 0.0020005786791443825, 0.014754070900380611, 0.009593935683369637, -0.022307952865958214, -0.006379114463925362, -0.03256506472826004, 0.012922443449497223, -0.019528932869434357, 0.013099290430545807, 0.014299321919679642, 0.031579773873090744, -0.003135871607810259, -0.02059001289308071, 0.03625358268618584, -0.0009458142449147999, 0.026804912835359573, -0.029204975813627243, -0.016459377482533455, -0.02597120590507984, 0.048026520758867264, 0.014551959931850433, 0.01826574094593525, 0.012960338965058327, 0.000003975227627961431, -0.031251344829797745, 0.013250873424112797, -0.02660280093550682, -0.013503511436283588, 0.0074907224625349045, 0.007351771462708712, -0.014084579423069954, 0.005258032586425543, -0.00946761667728424, -0.032388217747211456, -0.056085679680109024, 0.0018268899293616414, 0.016674119979143143, 0.02695649489760399, 0.004335903096944094, 0.040245264768600464, -0.03163030371069908, -0.0013176660286262631, 0.04696543887257576, -0.00808442197740078, 0.0033032444771379232, -0.022611118853092194, -0.03051869384944439, 0.006031736731529236, -0.04075054079294205, 0.0034895651042461395, -0.02320481836795807, -0.01374351792037487, -0.04575277864933014, -0.00891181267797947, -0.03074606880545616, -0.021764781326055527, 0.05204346776008606, -0.005861205980181694, -0.030569221824407578, -0.014160370454192162, -0.014994076453149319, 0.03893154487013817, -0.004146424587816, -0.0037485191132873297, -0.017457298934459686, 0.014627751894295216, 0.024126946926116943, -0.033297713845968246, -0.011526617221534252, -0.05371088162064552, -0.054216157644987106, -0.0054127732291817665, -0.013465615920722485, -0.0023747989907860756, -0.03074606880545616, 0.017128869891166687, -0.036607272922992706, -0.01081923022866249, 0.022977443411946297, 0.012038210406899452, -0.009574987925589085, 0.013503511436283588, -0.041078969836235046, -0.02033737488090992, -0.004588541109114885, -0.03203452378511429, 0.030695540830492973, -0.01656043343245983, 0.009303401224315166, 0.01203189417719841, 0.022674277424812317, 0.03612726181745529, -0.0013437194284051657, 0.007212820462882519, -0.022421639412641525, -0.010067632421851158, -0.016926759853959084, -0.03999262675642967, -0.04716755077242851, 0.038451533764600754, -0.02334376983344555, -0.01812679134309292, -0.013389823958277702, -0.004888548981398344, 0.0017905732383951545, -0.03920944780111313, -0.011766623705625534, 0.015259346924722195, -0.055731985718011856, 0.006764387711882591, 0.015777254477143288, -0.007566513959318399, 0.0014629330253228545, 0.0003497459983918816, -0.0055454084649682045, 0.017280451953411102, 0.000481591559946537, 0.008791808970272541, 0.008356008678674698, -0.005106449592858553, 0.03708728775382042, 0.015448825433850288, 0.059673141688108444, -0.022484799847006798, -0.028826018795371056, -0.032741911709308624, 0.008097054436802864, -0.023684831336140633, -0.009353929199278355, 0.02569330483675003, -0.012764545157551765, 0.0014731964329257607, 0.019983680918812752, 0.03170609474182129, 0.014185634441673756, 0.037592563778162, -0.01330140046775341, -0.027663882821798325, 0.012852967716753483, -0.02103213034570217, 0.008217057213187218, 0.024013260379433632, -0.012758228927850723, 0.0005261980113573372, 0.021373191848397255, -0.014400376938283443, 0.009732886217534542, 0.01452669594436884, -0.007894943468272686, 0.015196187421679497, 0.031832411885261536, -0.0074465107172727585, 0.018897337839007378, 0.020400533452630043, -0.021562669426202774, 0.00017704411584418267, 0.023520614951848984, -0.019440509378910065, -0.0009710780577734113, 0.0044843279756605625, -0.0037169393617659807, 0.011387666687369347, 0.025806991383433342, 0.0044969599694013596, -0.0115076694637537, 0.006060158833861351, 0.01642148196697235, 0.0037895729765295982, 0.0002520460693631321, 0.0031737673562020063, 0.032767172902822495, 0.005147503223270178, 0.066999651491642, 0.008804441429674625, 0.026173317804932594, -0.027916520833969116, -0.006388588342815638, -0.013680358417332172, 0.023141657933592796, 0.0003509302332531661, 0.0011021341197192669, 0.021398454904556274, -0.0045948573388159275, 0.015802519395947456, -0.03289349377155304, 0.002106370870023966, 0.035748302936553955, -0.0018521538004279137, -0.011065552942454815, 0.010396061465144157, 0.015650935471057892, 0.029457613825798035, -0.003300086362287402, -0.01805099844932556, 0.010162371210753918, -0.015663567930459976, 0.0016113580204546452, 0.0055454084649682045, -0.008191793225705624, -0.028548115864396095, 0.0021221607457846403, 0.029407085850834846, -0.020792122930288315, -0.022863756865262985, -0.035975679755210876, 0.022585853934288025, 0.0037611511070281267, 0.018442587926983833, -0.017015181481838226, 0.007869679480791092, -0.001984788803383708, -0.0009844994638115168, -0.010212899185717106, 0.0065054334700107574, 0.023141657933592796, -0.049744460731744766, 0.03534408286213875, 0.01688886247575283, 0.000774888729210943, -0.011299243196845055, -0.0269059669226408, -0.0149688133969903, -0.015006708912551403, -0.036935705691576004, -0.01873312145471573, 0.030998706817626953, 0.0065938569605350494, 0.012158213183283806, 0.001721097738482058, -0.041963204741477966, 0.02935655787587166, -0.004348535090684891, 0.004358008969575167, 0.005415931344032288, -0.012657173909246922, -0.02546592988073826, 0.0032590327318757772, -0.0102381631731987, 0.03766835480928421, -0.013162449933588505, 0.018013102933764458, -0.0009008130873553455, 0.010996077209711075, 0.019086815416812897, 0.056388843804597855, 0.005772782955318689, 0.017621513456106186, -0.022169001400470734, 0.004294849466532469, 0.0010295006213709712, 0.01688886247575283, 0.017886783927679062, 0.038123104721307755, 0.011703464202582836, 0.060228943824768066, 0.024569064378738403, 0.017406770959496498, -0.00624332157894969, -0.028826018795371056, -0.04148318991065025, 0.022030049934983253, -0.01818994991481304, -0.016156213358044624, 0.0010500274365767837, 0.002539013745263219, 0.012998235411942005, -0.04388325288891792, 0.013768781907856464, -0.0031153447926044464, 0.002527961041778326, -0.006300164852291346, -0.010667648166418076, -0.003928523976355791, -0.038123104721307755, -0.0044401162303984165, -0.03733992576599121, 0.010907653719186783, 0.009871837683022022, -0.0006584383081644773, -0.056692011654376984, -0.009303401224315166, 0.04302428290247917, 0.011532933451235294, 0.010478168725967407, -0.0284217968583107, 0.016522537916898727, 0.031301870942115784, -0.02604699693620205, 0.0020763701759278774, -0.018531011417508125, 0.023053234443068504, 0.0074465107172727585, -0.02227005735039711, 0.016787808388471603, -0.024442745372653008, -0.011621356941759586, -0.022838491946458817, -0.015398298390209675, 0.06386693567037582, 0.003969577606767416, -0.002111107809469104, 0.0007362035103142262, -0.018455220386385918, 0.012600329704582691, -0.015827782452106476, -0.014021419920027256, 0.0037358873523771763, 0.023836413398385048, 0.016547800973057747, 0.017482563853263855, -0.0055233025923371315, 0.0030537641141563654, -0.006312796846032143, -0.008798125199973583, 0.022219529375433922, 0.015688830986618996 ]
2.988848
4.625547
2024-07-01
1
2024ApJ...969...57S
[ "more accurate host galaxy redshifts", "Type II SNe", "photometric redshift", "CSM", "Zwicky Transient Facility", "large samples", "Asteroid Terrestrial", "SN", "wind acceleration", "similar works" ]
[ "Type II supernovae", "Core-collapse supernovae", "Surveys", "Supernovae", "Astronomy data analysis", "Markov chain Monte Carlo", "1731", "304", "1671", "1668", "1858", "1889", "Astrophysics - High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena", "Astrophysics - Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics" ]
66
[ "10.3847/1538-4357/ad402a", "10.48550/arXiv.2404.12620" ]
[ "Silva-Farfán, Javier", "Förster, Francisco", "Moriya, Takashi J.", "Hernández-García, L.", "Muñoz Arancibia, A. M.", "Sánchez-Sáez, P.", "Anderson, Joseph P.", "Tonry, John L.", "Clocchiatti, Alejandro" ]
[ "Departamento de Astronomía, Universidad de Chile, Las Condes, Santiago, Chile", "Departamento de Astronomía, Universidad de Chile, Las Condes, Santiago, Chile; Data and Artificial Intelligence Initiative (IDIA), Faculty of Physical and Mathematical Sciences, Universidad de Chile, Chile; Millennium Institute of Astrophysics (MAS), Nuncio Monseñor Sotero Sanz 100, Of. 104, Providencia, Santiago, Chile; Center for Mathematical Modeling, Universidad de Chile (CMM), Beauchef 851, Santiago 8370456, Chile", "National Astronomical Observatory of Japan, National Institutes of Natural Sciences, 2-21-1 Osawa, Mitaka, Tokyo 181-8588, Japan; School of Physics and Astronomy, Monash University, Clayton, Victoria 3800, Australia", "Millennium Institute of Astrophysics (MAS), Nuncio Monseñor Sotero Sanz 100, Of. 104, Providencia, Santiago, Chile; Instituto de Física y Astronomía, Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad de Valparaíso, Gran Bretaña No. 1111, Playa Ancha, Valparaíso, Chile", "Millennium Institute of Astrophysics (MAS), Nuncio Monseñor Sotero Sanz 100, Of. 104, Providencia, Santiago, Chile; Center for Mathematical Modeling, Universidad de Chile (CMM), Beauchef 851, Santiago 8370456, Chile", "Millennium Institute of Astrophysics (MAS), Nuncio Monseñor Sotero Sanz 100, Of. 104, Providencia, Santiago, Chile; European Southern Observatory, Karl-Schwarzschild-Strasse 2, 85748 Garching bei München, Germany", "Millennium Institute of Astrophysics (MAS), Nuncio Monseñor Sotero Sanz 100, Of. 104, Providencia, Santiago, Chile; European Southern Observatory, Alonso de Córdova 3107, Casilla 19, Santiago, Chile", "Institute for Astronomy, University of Hawaii, HI, USA", "Millennium Institute of Astrophysics (MAS), Nuncio Monseñor Sotero Sanz 100, Of. 104, Providencia, Santiago, Chile; Instituto de Astrofísica, Facultad de Física, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Av. Vicuña Mackenna 4860, Santiago, Chile" ]
[ "2024arXiv240600928M" ]
[ "1941PASP...53..224M", "1955ApJ...121..161S", "1974ApJ...193...27K", "1975ApJ...195..157C", "1996ASPC...98..220L", "1997ARA&A..35..309F", "1998ApJ...496..454B", "2000A&AS..143....9W", "2000ApJ...532.1132B", "2003PASP..115..763C", "2006A&A...453..229B", "2009ApJ...694.1067P", "2009MNRAS.395.1409S", "2009PASP..121.1395L", "2009arXiv0912.0201L", "2010SPIE.7733E..0EK", "2011MNRAS.412.1441L", "2011PASP..123...58T", "2013PASP..125..306F", "2013PASP..125..456S", "2014ApJ...788...48S", "2016ApJ...818....3K", "2017MNRAS.469L.108M", "2017MNRAS.470.1642F", "2017NatPh..13..510Y", "2018ApJ...858...15M", "2018ApJS..236...11H", "2018MNRAS.476.2840M", "2018NatAs...2..808F", "2018PASP..130f4505T", "2019MNRAS.483.5459R", "2019PASP..131a8002B", "2020ASPC..522..117B", "2020ApJ...891L..32M", "2020ApJ...893..127S", "2020ApJS..249....3A", "2020MNRAS.495.4860D", "2020PASP..132c8001D", "2020PASP..132h5002S", "2020sea..confE.182R", "2021AJ....161..141S", "2021AJ....161..242F", "2022A&A...660A..42M", "2022MNRAS.517.1483D", "2022arXiv221104480V", "2023ApJ...945...46S", "2023MNRAS.525.2187H", "2023PASJ...75..634M" ]
29096897
2404.05676
Dark-matter-free Dwarf Galaxy Formation at the Tips of the Tentacles of Jellyfish Galaxies
When falling into a galaxy cluster, galaxies experience a loss of gas due to ram pressure stripping. In particular, disk galaxies lose gas from their disks, and very large tentacles of gas can be formed. Because of the morphology of these stripped galaxies, they have been referred to as jellyfish galaxies. It has been found that star formation is triggered not only in the disk, but also in the tentacles of such jellyfish galaxies. The observed star-forming regions located in the tentacles of those galaxies have been found to be as massive as 3 × 10<SUP>7</SUP> M <SUB>⊙</SUB> and with sizes &gt;100 pc. Interestingly, these parameters in mass and size agree with those of dwarf galaxies. In this work, we make use of the state-of-the-art magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) cosmological simulation IllustrisTNG-50 to study massive jellyfish galaxies with long tentacles. We find that, in the tentacles of TNG-50 jellyfish galaxies, the star formation regions (gas+stars) formed could be as massive as ∼2 × 10<SUP>8</SUP> M <SUB>⊙</SUB>. A particular star-forming region was analyzed. This region has a star formation rate of 0.04 M <SUB>⊙</SUB> yr<SUP>‑1</SUP>, it is metal-rich, has an average age of 0.46 Gyr, and has a half-mass radius of ∼1 kpc, typical of standard dwarf galaxies. Most importantly, this region is gravitationally self-bound. Overall, we identify a new type of dwarf galaxy being born from the gas tentacles of jellyfish galaxies that, by construction, lacks a dark matter halo.
[ 0.002379931276664138, 0.002341075334697962, -0.005138708744198084, 0.022640109062194824, -0.02341722883284092, 0.03608429431915283, 0.020541884005069733, 0.007589876186102629, 0.0030161987524479628, 0.010853782296180725, -0.0003059911832679063, -0.010005425661802292, -0.021461475640535355, -0.04271572083234787, 0.0010709691559895873, 0.010905589908361435, -0.0015858113765716553, 0.0002266601222800091, -0.013275807723402977, 0.06310217827558517, 0.02599467895925045, -0.010847305878996849, -0.022277452051639557, 0.024569958448410034, -0.044347673654556274, -0.003590943990275264, 0.022704869508743286, 0.026758847758173943, 0.03831203654408455, -0.014959568157792091, 0.034063778817653656, -0.011876991018652916, -0.021409668028354645, -0.02701788768172264, -0.03447824344038963, 0.08325549960136414, 0.0041640703566372395, 0.0006063158507458866, -0.01562012080103159, 0.014998424798250198, -0.009338397532701492, 0.014635768719017506, -0.013495991937816143, 0.029841424897313118, 0.010193229652941227, -0.007712920196354389, -0.003174860728904605, 0.0022293643560260534, -0.013029719702899456, 0.004649770446121693, -0.03450414910912514, 0.012796583585441113, 0.011313578113913536, -0.01945391483604908, -0.020243987441062927, -0.020127419382333755, -0.003843508195132017, 0.04266391322016716, -0.015503552742302418, 0.013003814965486526, -0.013923407532274723, -0.008477088995277882, 0.03419329971075058, -0.011987082660198212, -0.011637378484010696, 0.05538278445601463, -0.009034025482833385, 0.002857536543160677, 0.01778310537338257, 0.06336122006177902, -0.045798297971487045, -0.08175306767225266, 0.004474918358027935, -0.015257464721798897, 0.031861938536167145, -0.014195400290191174, 0.01935029961168766, -0.03258724883198738, -0.025916967540979385, 0.01957048289477825, 0.031058913096785545, -0.024841949343681335, -0.005796023178845644, -0.008334617130458355, 0.012459831312298775, 0.017031889408826828, -0.01977771520614624, -0.02148737944662571, -0.07051073014736176, 0.03691321983933449, 0.026447998359799385, -0.004623866640031338, -0.036576468497514725, -0.0053135608322918415, -0.007641684263944626, -0.038881927728652954, 0.03714635595679283, -0.04709349945187569, 0.061237089335918427, -0.010478174313902855, 0.01865089125931263, 0.027846815064549446, -0.011035109870135784, -0.023650364950299263, 0.0525074377655983, 0.014182448387145996, -0.023287709802389145, 0.0003731797041837126, 0.02315818890929222, 0.019311442971229553, 0.024038925766944885, -0.000016544165191589855, -0.008263380266726017, 0.03924458101391792, -0.037172261625528336, -0.004766338504850864, -0.018715649843215942, 0.0637756809592247, -0.028313087299466133, 0.002005942165851593, 0.020127419382333755, -0.004429586697369814, 0.015451745130121708, 0.004193212371319532, 0.0375090129673481, -0.030411312356591225, -0.009960093535482883, 0.0036103720776736736, -0.01721321791410446, 0.03890782967209816, -0.027639582753181458, 0.018042147159576416, 0.015361080877482891, -0.03173241764307022, -0.04963209107518196, -0.006148965563625097, -0.03945181518793106, 0.003126290859654546, 0.011274722404778004, -0.00942906178534031, 0.020269891247153282, -0.023676268756389618, 0.05066825449466705, 0.035825252532958984, 0.0211765319108963, 0.022419923916459084, -0.030255889520049095, 0.022316308692097664, -0.03800119087100029, 0.019751811400055885, -0.02309342846274376, -0.010225609876215458, -0.006657331716269255, -0.031810130923986435, -0.01323695108294487, -0.0337529294192791, -0.014817096292972565, -0.013049147091805935, -0.00012860939023084939, 0.010627121664583683, -0.031810130923986435, -0.027199216187000275, -0.00420616427436471, 0.04046206921339035, -0.030696257948875427, 0.045306120067834854, -0.0032720009330660105, -0.016682185232639313, -0.08408442884683609, -0.04121328890323639, 0.045901913195848465, -0.03683551028370857, 0.007473308127373457, -0.021085867658257484, -0.028338992968201637, 0.019544579088687897, -0.05766233801841736, -0.05781776085495949, -0.008936884813010693, 0.007693492341786623, 0.016539713367819786, 0.02662932686507702, -0.025126894935965538, -0.04517660290002823, -0.025683831423521042, 0.050461020320653915, 0.0015833829529583454, 0.017938530072569847, 0.033157140016555786, 0.0011697281152009964, -0.04385549575090408, -0.013547799549996853, 0.028494415804743767, 0.03328665718436241, -0.002530498430132866, -0.01165680680423975, 0.03359750658273697, 0.030255889520049095, 0.02776910364627838, 0.023391325026750565, 0.041783176362514496, 0.013755031861364841, 0.002841346664354205, -0.047352537512779236, -0.037871669977903366, -0.05911296233534813, 0.017537018284201622, 0.013780935667455196, 0.02968600019812584, -0.026940174400806427, 0.04092834144830704, 0.02385759726166725, -0.0006985989166423678, -0.002263363217934966, -0.007505688350647688, -0.014920712448656559, -0.050357405096292496, 0.07620961219072342, 0.022860292345285416, -0.00543984305113554, -0.0011988701298832893, 0.05162670090794563, 0.015076136216521263, 0.037819862365722656, 0.012129554525017738, -0.010918541811406612, 0.036317430436611176, -0.03048902563750744, 0.010789021849632263, 0.05178212374448776, -0.013340567238628864, 0.01511499285697937, -0.04165365546941757, -0.03388245031237602, -0.027458256110548973, 0.0077064442448318005, -0.04087653383612633, 0.04009941592812538, 0.0168894175440073, -0.019065354019403458, -0.0005569363129325211, 0.021824132651090622, -0.0019298490369692445, -0.001988133182749152, -0.019920187070965767, 0.017757201567292213, -0.010199706070125103, 0.016708089038729668, 0.03551440313458443, -0.02883116900920868, 0.043544650077819824, -0.02782091125845909, -0.003603896126151085, -0.02165575698018074, -0.032716769725084305, -0.020878635346889496, -0.05766233801841736, 0.024129590019583702, 0.020995203405618668, 0.005281181074678898, -0.003979504108428955, -0.011209961958229542, -0.03504813089966774, 0.01967409998178482, -0.03763853386044502, 0.042897049337625504, 0.02771729603409767, -0.011015682481229305, -0.017601778730750084, 0.02208317257463932, 0.0020609882194548845, -0.042689815163612366, 0.016151152551174164, -0.01446739211678505, -0.051264043897390366, 0.06020092964172363, 0.000011219170119147748, 0.01773129776120186, 0.03147337958216667, 0.0024268822744488716, 0.01726502552628517, -0.03831203654408455, 0.02352084591984749, 0.01128119882196188, -0.009979521855711937, 0.019635243341326714, 0.010478174313902855, -0.03012636862695217, -0.04398501664400101, -0.020451219752430916, 0.07848916202783585, -0.005925543140619993, -0.0025742114521563053, 0.03124024160206318, -0.03981447219848633, -0.007499212399125099, -0.0187674593180418, 0.021940700709819794, -0.05033149942755699, 0.012155459262430668, 0.04250848665833473, 0.024246158078312874, 0.0020512740593403578, -0.009921237826347351, -0.05771414563059807, -0.002880202606320381, 0.01742045022547245, -0.0061392514035105705, 0.011566142551600933, 0.0519893579185009, 0.011443098075687885, -0.019764762371778488, 0.020593691617250443, 0.014972520060837269, -0.050201982259750366, -0.017342736944556236, -0.02080092392861843, 0.06372387707233429, 0.029012495651841164, 0.006433909758925438, -0.020515980198979378, -0.020023804157972336, 0.02063254825770855, 0.02288619615137577, 0.005689169280230999, -0.06030454486608505, 0.02138376422226429, -0.029970945790410042, -0.053673118352890015, 0.00436806445941329, 0.008295760490000248, 0.04121328890323639, 0.048103753477334976, 0.027846815064549446, 0.01757587306201458, -0.07988797873258591, -0.02160394750535488, -0.0025758305564522743, -0.025606118142604828, -0.006223439704626799, -0.021837083622813225, 0.04898449033498764, 0.0289347842335701, -0.012926103547215462, 0.005413939245045185, 0.04297475889325142, 0.053673118352890015, 0.06263590604066849, 0.03263906016945839, -0.013547799549996853, -0.009668673388659954, 0.02717331051826477, -0.00942906178534031, -0.02717331051826477, 0.05279238149523735, -0.03789757192134857, 0.04367416724562645, -0.059838272631168365, -0.018184619024395943, 0.025761542841792107, 0.011831658892333508, 0.019790668040513992, 0.014674624428153038, 0.03779395669698715, -0.030359504744410515, 0.04647180065512657, -0.03981447219848633, -0.008243952877819538, -0.008872125297784805, -0.025904014706611633, -0.003801414044573903, 0.049865227192640305, 0.021901844069361687, 0.038881927728652954, -0.055227357894182205, -0.010154373943805695, 0.006229915656149387, 0.025606118142604828, -0.0375090129673481, 0.023624461144208908, 0.06196240335702896, -0.021837083622813225, 0.014363775961101055, 0.004005408380180597, -0.02958238497376442, 0.011896418407559395, 0.02128014899790287, -0.012420974671840668, -0.06854202598333359, 0.03639513999223709, -0.029919136315584183, -0.0025564024690538645, 0.021772325038909912, -0.014752336777746677, -0.005909353494644165, -0.03559211641550064, 0.006262295413762331, 0.01865089125931263, -0.035928867757320404, 0.053673118352890015, 0.00988885760307312, -0.02782091125845909, -0.034167394042015076, -0.05123814195394516, 0.02288619615137577, -0.02561907097697258, 0.03924458101391792, 0.04092834144830704, 0.020192179828882217, -0.08263380825519562, 0.020334651693701744, 0.00486347870901227, 0.023184092715382576, -0.02662932686507702, -0.03559211641550064, 0.035773444920778275, -0.06802394241094589, 0.022847341373562813, -0.0418090783059597, 0.06289494782686234, -0.03059264086186886, -0.025152798742055893, 0.007123603951185942, 0.0015307653229683638, -0.06087443605065346, 0.03463366627693176, 0.03613610193133354, 0.05245563015341759, -0.0035812300629913807, -0.03543669357895851, 0.006780375726521015, 0.03028179332613945, -0.055175550282001495, -0.013677319511771202, -0.003704274073243141, -0.028157664462924004, 0.04548744857311249, -0.0348409004509449, -0.007628732360899448, -0.03152518719434738, 0.03263906016945839, -0.00889802910387516, 0.010510553605854511, -0.0364469476044178, 0.017990337684750557, 0.017588825896382332, 0.06584800779819489, 0.0337788350880146, 0.029245631769299507, -0.04641999304294586, -0.027639582753181458, -0.01591801643371582, -0.01677284948527813, 0.004675674717873335, -0.04452900215983391, -0.03414149209856987, 0.007019987795501947, -0.025321174412965775, 0.02668113447725773, -0.0664696991443634, -0.008729652501642704, -0.012589351274073124, -0.04737844318151474, 0.010011902078986168, -0.023546749725937843, 0.011229390278458595, -0.023300660774111748, 0.013042671605944633, -0.014830048196017742, 0.01885812357068062, 0.0064986697398126125, -0.07175412029027939, 0.01571078412234783, -0.01661742478609085, 0.03585115820169449, -0.009791717864573002, -0.05224839597940445, -0.016954177990555763, 0.0921664834022522, 0.030955297872424126, 0.028364896774291992, 0.0006682426319457591, -0.0026713514234870672, -0.002760396571829915, -0.0040280744433403015, 0.037327684462070465, -0.02717331051826477, -0.0286757443100214, -0.008742605336010456, -0.01870269887149334, -0.02802814356982708, -0.012038891203701496, 0.0873483344912529, -0.013923407532274723, 0.03142156824469566, -0.032017361372709274, -0.06061539426445961, -0.05797318369150162, -0.00519699277356267, 0.023326564580202103, 0.05802499130368233, -0.014596912078559399, 0.03541078791022301, -0.020723212510347366, 0.01742045022547245, -0.029789617285132408, -0.012913151644170284, -0.009493821300566196, -0.00825042836368084, -0.011443098075687885, -0.018884027376770973, 0.03173241764307022, 0.029893232509493828, -0.023805789649486542, 0.011106346733868122, 0.003943886142224073, -0.039736758917570114, 0.026707038283348083, 0.030307697132229805, 0.010743689723312855, 0.0023022193927317858, -0.01887107454240322, -0.008095004595816135, -0.010976825840771198, -0.01037455815821886, -0.003348093945533037, -0.01960933953523636, -0.10371967405080795, -0.024608813226222992, 0.019738858565688133, 0.013049147091805935, -0.013340567238628864, 0.04090243950486183, 0.0058089750818908215, -0.05113452672958374, -0.032069168984889984, -0.021085867658257484, 0.006602285895496607, -0.01293905545026064, 0.0031813369132578373, -0.0321727879345417, 0.02706969529390335, -0.007123603951185942, 0.013081527315080166, 0.02615010365843773, 0.036524660885334015, -0.012913151644170284, 0.008794412948191166, 0.006022683344781399, 0.03901144489645958, 0.03794938325881958, -0.008891552686691284, 0.012958483770489693, 0.00135024671908468, 0.007687016390264034, -0.013897503726184368, -0.0011017301585525274, -0.019479818642139435, -0.013806839473545551, -0.004785766825079918, -0.01617705635726452, -0.008956313133239746, -0.03149928152561188, 0.024582909420132637, -0.012563447467982769, -0.03735359013080597, 0.0013016767334192991, 0.021202435716986656, -0.024906709790229797, 0.02153918892145157, -0.02877935953438282, -0.004254734609276056, 0.04680855572223663, -0.022005461156368256, -0.020399412140250206, -0.03473728522658348, -0.014506247825920582, 0.008166240528225899, -0.021293099969625473, -0.030903490260243416, -0.03227640315890312, -0.04305247217416763, -0.01591801643371582, 0.023611510172486305, -0.03499632328748703, 0.029012495651841164, -0.013521895743906498, -0.018081001937389374, 0.010542933829128742, -0.015879161655902863, -0.01194822695106268, -0.005731263197958469, 0.00860660895705223, 0.0008791175205260515, 0.011106346733868122, -0.019842475652694702, 0.008580705150961876, -0.0035002799704670906, -0.004912048578262329, -0.013418279588222504, -0.02797633595764637, 0.008289285004138947, -0.04722302034497261, -0.041342806071043015, -0.04160184785723686, -0.022795533761382103, -0.004238544497638941, 0.0005245563224889338, 0.0026422094088047743, 0.004439300391823053, -0.009357824921607971, 0.025385934859514236, -0.011844610795378685, -0.0364469476044178, -0.03204326704144478, -0.032768577337265015, 0.0013291997602209449, -0.003493804018944502, 0.002830013632774353, 0.007991388440132141, 0.006284961476922035, -0.008846220560371876, -0.016526760533452034, 0.002519165398553014, 0.047507964074611664, 0.009299540892243385, -0.000001034010324474366, -0.017588825896382332, -0.019518675282597542, -0.029608288779854774, 0.009578009136021137, -0.027199216187000275, 0.02872755192220211, 0.00002019956627918873, -0.027795007452368736, -0.013165715150535107, -0.005475461017340422, 0.04002170264720917, -0.0006382911233231425, -0.018637938424944878, 0.02320999652147293, 0.018417755141854286, 0.03227640315890312, -0.024181397631764412, 0.030359504744410515, 0.03833794221282005, -0.0321727879345417, -0.023870550096035004, -0.025580214336514473, -0.01887107454240322, 0.039788566529750824, -0.017757201567292213, -0.0017388069536536932, -0.008535373024642467, 0.013755031861364841, 0.02239402011036873, -0.0035682779271155596, -0.029038401320576668, -0.04743025079369545, 0.004468442406505346, -0.029245631769299507, 0.01800329051911831, 0.00569240702316165, 0.003307618899270892, -0.008923932909965515, -0.004280638415366411, 0.003055054694414139, 0.004549392499029636, 0.016643328592181206, 0.001965467119589448, 0.07538068294525146, 0.006702663842588663, 0.002222888171672821, 0.004235306289047003, -0.008269856683909893, 0.011125774122774601, -0.03525536507368088, -0.041239190846681595, 0.0010223990539088845, -0.014519200660288334, 0.003979504108428955, 0.03763853386044502, 0.029090208932757378, 0.005491651128977537, 0.013340567238628864, -0.003927696030586958, 0.0023297423031181097, 0.023184092715382576, 0.014234255999326706, 0.03113662637770176, 0.00597411347553134, -0.010361606255173683, 0.021357860416173935, -0.010633598081767559, 0.0016934749437496066, -0.026940174400806427, -0.006576381623744965, 0.006505145691335201, -0.020023804157972336, -0.07056253403425217, 0.0005974113591946661, 0.010400461964309216, 0.009532677009701729, -0.025308221578598022, 0.004814908839762211, -0.045202504843473434, -0.008690796792507172, 0.02229040488600731, 0.00823100097477436, -0.019220778718590736, 0.03735359013080597, 0.02561907097697258, -0.0057636434212327, 0.013191619887948036, 0.0032493348699063063, -0.01839185133576393, 0.008904504589736462, -0.0011697281152009964, -0.0022795533295720816, -0.018081001937389374, 0.0182234738022089, 0.006618475541472435, -0.029867328703403473, 0.025709735229611397, 0.04237896949052811, -0.03460776433348656, 0.01692827418446541, 0.0010984920663759112, -0.01087968610227108, -0.05781776085495949, 0.010432842187583447, 0.000862927467096597, -0.002499737311154604, -0.02159099653363228, 0.0028364895842969418, 0.04030664637684822, 0.013029719702899456, -0.019117163494229317, -0.028364896774291992, 0.018314138054847717, 0.0017630920046940446, -0.005119280889630318, 0.012854867614805698, 0.02218678779900074, 0.05533097684383392, -0.02766548842191696, 0.030618544667959213, -0.010614169761538506, 0.04496936872601509, 0.016643328592181206, 0.0035779920872300863, 0.011197010055184364, 0.03901144489645958, 0.02148737944662571, 0.013392375782132149, -0.019803619012236595, 0.03779395669698715, -0.0028915356379002333, 0.042534392327070236, 0.028442608192563057, 0.02298981323838234, 0.03038540855050087, -0.012071270495653152, 0.04709349945187569, -0.0385710783302784, 0.016656281426548958, -0.0643455758690834, 0.006459813565015793, -0.002321647247299552, -0.034271012991666794, -0.026707038283348083, 0.009247733280062675, 0.019091259688138962, -0.006485717836767435, 0.021422620862722397, -0.002812204649671912, 0.009170020930469036, -0.03769034147262573, -0.009092309512197971, 0.03561801835894585, -0.024077782407402992, -0.03258724883198738, 0.034115586429834366, -0.0009624960366636515, -0.00758340023458004, -0.006948751863092184, 0.018301187083125114, 0.00025134990573860705, -0.025916967540979385, -0.01885812357068062, -0.026655230671167374, 0.0023880263324826956, -0.010083138011395931, 0.02852031961083412, 0.001206965185701847, 0.03655056655406952, 0.006378863472491503, -0.09439422935247421, -0.016811706125736237, -0.009092309512197971, 0.015218609012663364, -0.016034584492444992, 0.047456156462430954, 0.018935834988951683, 0.023274756968021393, 0.04999474808573723, 0.009098784998059273, 0.0002916225348599255, -0.03836384415626526, 0.023753982037305832, 0.04833688959479332, -0.00019033379794564098, 0.007369691971689463, -0.02466062270104885, -0.01289372332394123, -0.03769034147262573, -0.002570973476395011, 0.009493821300566196, -0.01704484224319458, 0.018197569996118546, 0.04538383334875107, 0.02155213989317417, -0.02722511999309063, 0.0038240801077336073, -0.008904504589736462, -0.005569363012909889, -0.010568837635219097, 0.015192704275250435, -0.03313123434782028, -0.024129590019583702, 0.038881927728652954, 0.010581789538264275, -0.029867328703403473, 0.0011227771174162626, 0.04701578617095947, -0.027484159916639328, -0.003077720757573843, -0.006204011384397745, -0.013165715150535107, 0.05724787339568138, 0.045254312455654144, 0.0254506953060627, -0.0021516522392630577, -0.03745720535516739, 0.008710225112736225, -0.006103633437305689, -0.0060583013109862804, 0.0158144012093544, -0.011909370310604572, 0.01752406544983387, -0.011190534569323063, 0.009454965591430664, 0.0020836542826145887, 0.023274756968021393, -0.013612559996545315, -0.03178422525525093, 0.005015664733946323, -0.0031732418574392796, 0.016099344938993454, -0.027561871334910393, -0.05087548494338989, -0.04844050854444504, -0.02459586225450039, -0.015024328604340553, 0.00560174323618412, 0.01694122515618801, -0.027613678947091103, 0.003940648399293423, 0.011449574492871761, -0.01272534765303135, 0.022122029215097427, -0.006838659755885601, -0.02122833952307701, -0.025308221578598022, 0.009021073579788208, -0.004980046767741442, 0.007835964672267437, -0.030411312356591225, -0.030566737055778503, 0.0038370322436094284, -0.008056148886680603, 0.00399245647713542, -0.00836052093654871, 0.001916897133924067, -0.014052928425371647, 0.004481394775211811, 0.009014597162604332, 0.001706426963210106, 0.005193755030632019, -0.018534323200583458, -0.003704274073243141, 0.012213743291795254, -0.006446861661970615, -0.0039147441275417805, 0.017148457467556, -0.014027023687958717, -0.010238561779260635, -0.008917457424104214, 0.015775544568896294, -0.036317430436611176, -0.035773444920778275, -0.0012045366456732154, -0.02701788768172264, 0.01079549826681614, 0.028002239763736725, 0.04276752844452858, -0.011287674307823181, 0.04572058469057083, 0.02444043755531311, -0.009467917494475842, 0.0006245296099223197, 0.0471712090075016, 0.020593691617250443, -0.03357160463929176, -0.00852242112159729, 0.00994066521525383, 0.0093837296590209, 0.0024592624977231026, 0.007194839883595705, -0.05761053040623665, -0.0048181465826928616, 0.024427486583590508, 0.00852242112159729, -0.02186298929154873, 0.02150033228099346, 0.00675447192043066, 0.0337529294192791, -0.039943989366292953, -0.00042255924199707806, 0.024453390389680862, 0.01988133043050766, 0.00009860727732302621, -0.0034096159506589174, 0.013327615335583687, 0.04623866453766823, 0.03258724883198738, 0.010044281370937824, -0.018637938424944878, -0.043389223515987396, 0.024634718894958496, 0.01154671423137188, 0.021422620862722397, 0.00527794286608696, -0.020166276022791862, -0.03740539774298668, 0.055071935057640076, 0.024310918524861336, -0.0030534358229488134, -0.018624987453222275, -0.016682185232639313, 0.00569240702316165, 0.010478174313902855, -0.011410718783736229, -0.029556481167674065, 0.003487328067421913, -0.011067490093410015, 0.027302831411361694, 0.017459305003285408, -0.0010159231023862958, 0.012550495564937592, -0.015386984683573246, 0.028209472075104713, 0.02385759726166725, -0.03144747391343117, -0.0008596894913353026, -0.02278258092701435, 0.015607168897986412, -0.01624181680381298, -0.017964433878660202, 0.020127419382333755, -0.013780935667455196, -0.0353848822414875, -0.011481954716145992, -0.004873192869126797, -0.006722091697156429, 0.01913011446595192, 0.021565092727541924, -0.001276582246646285, 0.004465204663574696, -0.012854867614805698, 0.01805509813129902, 0.012012986466288567, -0.002847822615876794, 0.010309797711670399, 0.029711904004216194, 0.0003517279401421547, 0.004257972352206707, -0.013599608093500137, 0.040695205330848694, 0.0019314681412652135, 0.011520810425281525, 0.013159239664673805, -0.004015122074633837, -0.019428011029958725, 0.03349389135837555, 0.0012628206750378013, -0.0024932613596320152, 0.042482584714889526, -0.024790141731500626, 0.011132250539958477, -0.013949312269687653, 0.008431756868958473, -0.005841355305165052, 0.02604648657143116, 0.01524451281875372, -0.02782091125845909, -0.007078271824866533, 0.015011376701295376, 0.0009948760271072388, 0.010847305878996849, 0.037224069237709045, 0.054916512221097946, 0.003636276116594672, 0.0227696280926466, -0.008295760490000248, -0.033519793301820755, -0.020813874900341034, 0.0391150638461113, -0.05926838517189026, -0.022368116304278374, 0.01612524874508381, -0.01310095563530922, 0.05341407656669617, 0.0042709242552518845, -0.0021208911202847958, -0.019220778718590736, 0.004202926531434059, 0.018573177978396416, -0.0005844593397341669, 0.0030501976143568754, -0.008276333101093769, -0.020062658935785294, 0.006113347597420216, 0.005546696949750185, 0.015425840392708778, 0.03188784047961235, -0.004588248673826456, 0.0243886299431324, 0.009927713312208652, 0.04994294047355652, -0.00288182171061635, -0.02524346299469471, 0.0064986697398126125, -0.0021969841327518225, -0.033157140016555786, -0.00016584640252403915, -0.008846220560371876, -0.0010215896181762218, 0.012375643476843834, -0.03774214908480644, -0.013664367608726025, -0.005352417007088661, 0.04092834144830704, -0.006437147501856089, 0.023831693455576897, 0.014907760545611382, -0.026551615446805954, 0.01811985857784748, -0.020490076392889023, -0.05470927804708481, -0.03864879161119461, -0.0033999020233750343, 0.01580144837498665, -0.037016838788986206, -0.02722511999309063, 0.015205656178295612, -0.034271012991666794, 0.023546749725937843, -0.014130639843642712, 0.011307102628052235, -0.012064795009791851, 0.010387510061264038, -0.01075016614049673, 0.015853257849812508, -0.005689169280230999, -0.02363741397857666, 0.03232821077108383, -0.016915321350097656, 0.001092825667001307, -0.01960933953523636, -0.0089757414534688, 0.023015717044472694, -0.013139811344444752, 0.0033707600086927414, 0.025916967540979385, 0.02164280414581299, -0.01742045022547245, 0.008956313133239746, 0.0040572164580225945, 0.011378338560461998, 0.0035067559219896793, 0.02615010365843773, -0.035773444920778275, -0.01924668252468109, 0.0037172262091189623, 0.002582306507974863, -0.02937515266239643, -0.021461475640535355, 0.023572653532028198, -0.0005342703079804778, -0.038726501166820526, -0.02218678779900074, -0.0096427695825696, 0.022199740633368492, -0.03149928152561188, -0.014402632601559162, 0.0038532221224159002, 0.00441015837714076, 0.027302831411361694, -0.022381069138646126, -0.005381559021770954, 0.004468442406505346, 0.044503096491098404, -0.0026017343625426292, 0.013651415705680847, 0.00527794286608696, -0.006158679723739624, -0.03940000757575035, -0.02389645390212536, 0.031162530183792114, -0.05533097684383392, -0.01960933953523636, 0.027950432151556015, 0.0045202504843473434, -0.005637361202389002, 0.04512479528784752, 0.02379283681511879, 0.04605733975768089, -0.00022119599452707916, 0.015153848566114902, 0.005530507303774357, 0.0006140060722827911, 0.02401302196085453, -0.0111192986369133, 0.01039398554712534, 0.024453390389680862, -0.02647390216588974, -0.005449557211250067, 0.008328140713274479, -0.0009487345232628286, -0.013677319511771202, 0.007810060400515795, 0.009921237826347351, -0.013871599920094013, -0.042482584714889526, 0.018832217901945114, 0.013897503726184368, 0.06569258123636246, -0.019039450213313103, -0.03849336504936218, -0.020969299599528313, 0.038622885942459106, -0.0014109592884778976, 0.005944971460849047, 0.017381593585014343, 0.006760947871953249, 0.012861343100667, 0.011430146172642708, -0.007602828089147806, -0.005012426991015673, 0.013139811344444752, 0.07092519104480743, 0.00013791864330414683, -0.003199145896360278, 0.03087758459150791, 0.012440402992069721, 0.0030858158133924007, 0.016267720609903336, -0.005643837153911591, 0.0013971978332847357, 0.026292575523257256, 0.004063692409545183, 0.006582857575267553, 0.020010851323604584, 0.0013729127822443843, -0.024854902178049088, 0.023987118154764175, -0.004316256381571293, 0.03554030880331993, 0.0006941466708667576, 0.0364469476044178, 0.005073948763310909, 0.00156476441770792, -0.011520810425281525, 0.008515944704413414, 0.0027263974770903587, 0.017705393955111504, 0.026551615446805954, 0.01977771520614624, -0.009293065406382084, -0.003451709868386388, 0.021565092727541924, 0.007674064487218857, 0.015322224237024784, 0.01806805096566677, -0.0053200372494757175, -0.0027960145380347967, -0.03178422525525093, -0.010950922034680843, 0.018793363124132156, 0.006068015471100807, 0.01576259359717369, 0.020334651693701744, -0.016060488298535347, 0.00024224301159847528, 0.029452864080667496, -0.02008856274187565, -0.01195470243692398, -0.011915846727788448, -0.023119332268834114, 0.02116357907652855, 0.0013219142565503716, -0.014027023687958717, 0.0031813369132578373, 0.0179514829069376, 0.020218083634972572, 0.020593691617250443, -0.016552666202187538, 0.004921762738376856, 0.010141422040760517, 0.01762768253684044, -0.002383169252425432, 0.008626037277281284, -0.0034808518830686808, 0.011967654339969158, -0.02476423792541027, -0.016902370378375053, -0.005650313105434179, -0.014752336777746677, 0.03810480609536171, 0.044554904103279114, -0.017148457467556, -0.0005164612666703761, -0.016228865832090378, 0.00028150377329438925, -0.001582573400810361, 0.0375349186360836, 0.004018360283225775, -0.023611510172486305, 0.0132628558203578, 0.019907236099243164, 0.01725207455456257, 0.006955227814614773, -0.0026745896320790052, -0.021785276010632515, 0.01762768253684044, 0.005734501406550407, -0.017511114478111267, 0.025049181655049324, 0.020179226994514465, -0.007771204225718975, 0.032613154500722885, 0.012427451089024544, -0.01388455182313919, -0.00886564888060093, -0.015594216994941235, 0.010484649799764156, -0.018508419394493103, 0.021021107211709023, -0.009234781377017498, -0.015516504645347595, 0.021357860416173935, 0.02782091125845909, 0.011022157967090607, 0.023611510172486305, 0.004617390688508749, -0.022277452051639557, 0.01136538665741682, 0.036576468497514725, 0.007615780457854271, -0.013418279588222504, 0.004377778619527817, -0.040695205330848694, 0.01832709088921547, -0.010491126216948032, 0.006362673826515675, -0.011702138930559158, -0.002234221203252673, 0.02771729603409767, 0.0030631497502326965, 0.0235856045037508, 0.016008680686354637, 0.002627638401463628, -0.013003814965486526, -0.015905065461993217, 0.023507893085479736, 0.03784576430916786, 0.020282844081521034, 0.010620646178722382, -0.032069168984889984, -0.022264501079916954, 0.022756677120923996, -0.013418279588222504, -0.0036977981217205524, -0.014571008272469044, -0.017705393955111504, 0.02471243031322956, 0.001543717342428863, 0.019324395805597305, 0.01571078412234783, 0.015127944760024548, -0.028209472075104713, 0.007058843970298767, -0.024945566430687904, 0.021319003775715828, -0.021409668028354645, -0.04222354292869568, -0.0069681801833212376, 0.010789021849632263, -0.009532677009701729, 0.0035294219851493835, 0.028054047375917435, 0.004416634328663349, 0.006242867559194565, 0.03339027613401413, -0.04473623260855675, -0.03022998571395874, -0.010853782296180725, -0.041239190846681595, -0.002132224151864648, -0.030463121831417084, -0.030359504744410515, -0.018689746037125587, 0.010814926587045193, -0.006184583529829979, -0.041886791586875916, 0.019790668040513992, 0.009953618049621582, -0.02883116900920868, 0.014765288680791855, -0.012278502807021141, -0.027510063722729683, -0.01687646470963955, -0.002022132044658065, 0.018624987453222275, 0.029245631769299507, -0.010141422040760517, 0.008075576275587082, -0.03222459554672241, 0.008101481013000011, 0.001423911307938397, -0.002888297662138939, 0.02862393669784069, -0.0006949561648070812, -0.03890782967209816, 0.020438266918063164, 0.020062658935785294, -0.03616200387477875, -0.05007246136665344, 0.007084748242050409, -0.025929918512701988, -0.01087968610227108, 0.02717331051826477, 0.005653551314026117, 0.04116147756576538, 0.00034848993527702987, -0.0016206199070438743, 0.023831693455576897, 0.0036168480291962624, -0.019168971106410027, 0.004517012741416693, 0.006657331716269255, -0.011941750533878803, -0.00015299559163395315, 0.01827528327703476, -0.02616305463016033, 0.00001460895327909384, 0.01066597830504179, 0.006974656134843826, 0.023676268756389618, 0.017549969255924225, -0.014208352193236351, 0.005491651128977537, 0.03660237416625023, -0.009480869397521019, 0.01692827418446541, 0.030514929443597794, 0.008593657054007053, -0.029970945790410042, 0.001419863780029118, 0.005002712830901146, -0.020839780569076538, -0.022432876750826836, -0.022173836827278137, 0.04142051935195923, -0.024582909420132637, -0.007952532730996609, 0.011307102628052235, 0.0033869498874992132, 0.04486575350165367, 0.020231034606695175, 0.0063885776326060295, 0.017342736944556236, -0.0012255837209522724, 0.012420974671840668, -0.05714425817131996, -0.01656561717391014, -0.020140372216701508, 0.032017361372709274, 0.009707529097795486, 0.02459586225450039, 0.0008285237126983702, 0.01687646470963955, 0.04362235963344574, 0.005465747322887182, -0.02041236311197281, -0.008347569033503532, -0.014195400290191174, 0.03344208374619484, 0.02030874788761139, 0.008056148886680603, 0.01683760993182659, 0.016733992844820023, -0.015024328604340553, 0.0025094514712691307, 0.017498161643743515, -0.017174361273646355, 0.03028179332613945, -0.014493295922875404, 0.0020787972025573254, -0.001963848015293479, 0.007000559940934181, -0.013988167978823185, -0.018404802307486534, -0.0006289818556979299, 0.021021107211709023, -0.026603423058986664, -0.028598032891750336, -0.01885812357068062, 0.05087548494338989, -0.019207827746868134, 0.009202401153743267, 0.016228865832090378, -0.02401302196085453, 0.002211555140092969, 0.00852242112159729, 0.022950956597924232, 0.008749080821871758, -0.01624181680381298, 0.004941190592944622, -0.01646200194954872, 0.00733083626255393, 0.009850001893937588, 0.017109600827097893, 0.009921237826347351, 0.027510063722729683, -0.014441488310694695, 0.009118213318288326, -0.007971960119903088, -0.03709454834461212, 0.024803094565868378, 0.014558056369423866, -0.026240766048431396, 0.005906115286052227, -0.005281181074678898, 0.026707038283348083, -0.008470612578094006, 0.013256379403173923, 0.0036557039711624384, 0.014208352193236351, 0.04406272992491722, 0.015322224237024784, 0.0009074500412680209, 0.006459813565015793, 0.04320789501070976, -0.001091206562705338, 0.021940700709819794, 0.013612559996545315, 0.027406446635723114, 0.026758847758173943, -0.009629817679524422, 0.0017938530072569847, -0.018145762383937836, 0.018935834988951683, 0.025722686201334, -0.009934189729392529, 0.002629257505759597, 0.01736864261329174, -0.0030113416723906994, 0.01125529408454895, 0.002392883412539959, 0.020321698859333992, -0.01800329051911831, 0.022963909432291985, 0.03173241764307022, -0.017031889408826828, -0.0369650274515152, 0.02577449381351471, -0.024634718894958496, -0.004002170171588659, -0.020515980198979378, -0.027846815064549446, -0.03564392402768135, -0.012828962877392769, 0.0036913221701979637, -0.019907236099243164, -0.054864704608917236, -0.009752861224114895, -0.03043721802532673, -0.015153848566114902, -0.02727692760527134, 0.022873245179653168, -0.03458185866475105, 0.017005985602736473, -0.003633038140833378, 0.016526760533452034, -0.023015717044472694, -0.015581265091896057, 0.026862462982535362, 0.00271992152556777, 0.01289372332394123, -0.007719396147876978, 0.037871669977903366, 0.023132285103201866, 0.009014597162604332, -0.001429577823728323, -0.004827860742807388, -0.020347602665424347, 0.016915321350097656, -0.00873612891882658, -0.006760947871953249, -0.03945181518793106, -0.039684951305389404, 0.01168918702751398, 0.01104158628731966, 0.023287709802389145, 0.00247221440076828, 0.0017549969488754869, 0.018832217901945114, -0.052714668214321136, -0.00327685778029263, 0.02534707821905613, 0.03784576430916786, -0.027406446635723114, 0.03284629061818123, -0.0018084240145981312 ]
11.516339
7.299028
2024-07-01
0
2024ApJ...969...24L
[ "massive jellyfish galaxies", "dwarf galaxies", "dwarf galaxy", "jellyfish galaxies", "disk galaxies", "standard dwarf galaxies", "such jellyfish galaxies", "galaxies", "TNG-50 jellyfish galaxies", "star formation" ]
[ "Dwarf galaxies", "Dark matter", "Ram pressure stripped tails", "Cosmological models", "Cosmological evolution", "416", "353", "2126", "337", "336", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
71
[ "10.3847/1538-4357/ad3cda", "10.48550/arXiv.2404.05676" ]
[ "Lora, V.", "Smith, R.", "Fritz, J.", "Pasquali, A.", "Raga, A. C." ]
[ "Instituto de Ciencias Nucleares (UNAM), Ap. 70-264, C.P. 04510, Mexico City, Mexico", "Departamento de Física, Universidad Técnica Federico Santa María, Av. Vicuña Mackenna 3939, San Joaquín, Santiago, Chile", "Instituto de Radioastronomía y Astrofísica (UNAM), Antigua Carretera a Pátzcuaro 8701, 58089 Morelia, Mexico", "Astronomisches Rechen-Institut (ZAH), Mönchhofstr. 12-14, Heidelberg, 69120, Germany", "Instituto de Ciencias Nucleares (UNAM), Ap. 70-264, C.P. 04510, Mexico City, Mexico" ]
null
[ "1972ApJ...176....1G", "1983ApJ...272...54K", "1995ApJ...454..788C", "2002ApJ...579L..79W", "2003MNRAS.339..289S", "2004A&A...425..813B", "2004ApJ...613..898T", "2006ApJ...647..970L", "2007Sci...316.1166B", "2008MNRAS.389.1405K", "2010AJ....140.2124B", "2010AdAst2010E...1B", "2010MNRAS.401..791S", "2011ApJS..192....6L", "2012A&A...538A..18B", "2012PASA...29..395K", "2013ApJ...772...67B", "2013MNRAS.429.1858D", "2013MNRAS.436.3031V", "2014ApJ...780..119K", "2014ApJ...782...35S", "2014ApJ...792...11J", "2014MNRAS.440.1458D", "2015A&A...584A.113L", "2015ApJ...808..109M", "2015ApJS..218...29M", "2015MNRAS.447.2512P", "2015MNRAS.450.2367R", "2016A&A...594A...1P", "2016MNRAS.455.2028F", "2016MNRAS.455.2994M", "2017ApJ...839..114J", "2017ApJ...844...48P", "2018MNRAS.475..624N", "2018MNRAS.475..648P", "2018MNRAS.475..676S", "2018MNRAS.477.1206N", "2018MNRAS.479.4126G", "2018MNRAS.480.2508M", "2018MNRAS.480.5113M", "2019ApJ...883..145J", "2019MNRAS.482.4466P", "2019MNRAS.483.1042Y", "2019MNRAS.485.2656C", "2019MNRAS.490.3196P", "2019MNRAS.490.3234N", "2020ApJ...889....9M", "2020ApJ...899...13G", "2021MNRAS.508.1652J", "2022MNRAS.515.4176M", "2022RMxAA..58...61V", "2023ApJ...945...54G", "2023ApJ...949...72G", "2023MNRAS.524.3502R", "2023MNRAS.525.3551G", "2024A&A...682A.162W" ]
29072507
2405.18336
WISE2MBH: a scaling-based algorithm for probing supermassive black hole masses through WISE catalogues
Supermassive Black Holes (SMBHs) are commonly found at the centres of massive galaxies. Estimating their masses (M<SUB>BH</SUB>) is crucial for understanding galaxy-SMBH co-evolution. We present WISE2MBH, an efficient algorithm that uses cataloged Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE) magnitudes to estimate total stellar mass (M<SUB>*</SUB>) and scale this to bulge mass (M<SUB>Bulge</SUB>), and M<SUB>BH</SUB>, estimating the morphological type (T<SUB>Type</SUB>) and bulge fraction (B/T) in the process. WISE2MBH uses scaling relations from the literature or developed in this work, providing a streamlined approach to derive these parameters. It also distinguishes QSOs from galaxies and estimates the galaxy T<SUB>Type</SUB> using WISE colours with a relation trained with galaxies from the 2MASS Redshift Survey. WISE2MBH performs well up to z ~ 0.5 thanks to K-corrections in magnitudes and colours. WISE2MBH M<SUB>BH</SUB> estimates agree very well with those of a selected sample of local galaxies with M<SUB>BH</SUB> measurements or reliable estimates: a Spearman score of ~0.8 and a RMSE of ~0.63 were obtained. When applied to the ETHER sample at z ≤ 0.5, WISE2MBH provides ~1.9 million M<SUB>BH</SUB> estimates (78.5 per cent new) and ~100 thousand upper limits. The derived local black hole mass function (BHMF) is in good agreement with existing literature BHMFs. Galaxy demographic projects, including target selection for the Event Horizon Telescope, can benefit from WISE2MBH for up-to-date galaxy parameters and M<SUB>BH</SUB> estimates. The WISE2MBH algorithm is publicly available on GitHub.
[ 0.006651097442954779, 0.0004257851105649024, 0.04381899535655975, -0.0011442246614024043, -0.02005886472761631, -0.011408091522753239, 0.00345906731672585, 0.028591644018888474, -0.022046120837330818, 0.02425694279372692, 0.0038347828667610884, 0.0060114492662250996, -0.0650329515337944, -0.017810780555009842, 0.04093747213482857, 0.04309861361980438, -0.02244357205927372, 0.014270981773734093, -0.03346042335033417, 0.0010580585803836584, -0.01129009760916233, 0.020468736067414284, -0.006986446678638458, 0.03996868431568146, -0.04255211725831032, -0.01422130037099123, 0.008557620458304882, -0.00712928082793951, 0.05216546729207039, 0.015239768661558628, 0.013823849149048328, -0.006812561769038439, -0.04650178924202919, -0.007644725032150745, -0.05142024904489517, 0.07397560030221939, -0.013264933601021767, 0.010693920776247978, -0.005297278985381126, 0.00746463006362319, -0.02566044218838215, 0.01496652141213417, -0.01793498545885086, 0.023586243391036987, -0.0428253673017025, -0.03765850141644478, -0.01986013911664486, -0.00712928082793951, 0.021040072664618492, -0.010538666509091854, -0.010029432363808155, -0.006262961309403181, -0.005260018166154623, -0.007644725032150745, 0.01347607932984829, -0.008352684788405895, -0.014246140606701374, 0.055494122207164764, -0.014444866217672825, 0.010985799133777618, -0.00976860523223877, -0.009191058576107025, 0.03691327944397926, -0.0003925994969904423, -0.012892322614789009, -0.01921428181231022, 0.03346042335033417, 0.004567583557218313, 0.02166108973324299, -0.0018739202059805393, 0.0034714876674115658, 0.007688196375966072, -0.009551248513162136, -0.011786911636590958, 0.046029817312955856, -0.0037416303530335426, -0.012010478414595127, 0.007750298362225294, -0.032143864780664444, 0.006110812071710825, -0.020617781206965446, -0.011619237251579762, -0.02566044218838215, -0.008576251566410065, -0.017363648861646652, 0.009954909794032574, 0.02436872571706772, -0.027747061103582382, -0.10522520542144775, 0.0020974865183234215, 0.006334378384053707, -0.018779568374156952, 0.002577222650870681, -0.028020309284329414, 0.004396803677082062, -0.04289988800883293, -0.02528783120214939, -0.04285020753741264, 0.009718923829495907, 0.03661518916487694, 0.012395508587360382, 0.049308788031339645, 0.042974408715963364, -0.04920942708849907, 0.04217950627207756, -0.01954963058233261, 0.018978293985128403, -0.0032913926988840103, 0.016071932390332222, 0.029063617810606956, -0.019723515957593918, -0.008458257652819157, -0.023052169010043144, 0.004151501692831516, 0.004222918767482042, -0.012569393962621689, -0.013115889392793179, 0.03586997091770172, -0.030454697087407112, 0.03947187215089798, 0.03216870501637459, -0.020779244601726532, 0.017177343368530273, 0.0006772971828468144, -0.002643981948494911, -0.003412491176277399, -0.030330494046211243, -0.02321363426744938, -0.037708181887865067, -0.004309861455112696, 0.005219651851803064, 0.020431475713849068, 0.06662275642156601, 0.015562698245048523, -0.014283401891589165, -0.01022194791585207, -0.001810265937820077, 0.027299929410219193, 0.021834975108504295, 0.016084352508187294, -0.015612379647791386, 0.03979479894042015, 0.035621561110019684, 0.0019080762285739183, -0.007234853692352772, 0.014581490308046341, -0.026455344632267952, 0.023114271461963654, -0.04456421360373497, -0.006806351710110903, -0.004160817246884108, 0.0044309599325060844, 0.0019499949412420392, -0.028616486117243767, -0.011122423224151134, -0.039894163608551025, 0.0024266259279102087, 0.026852795854210854, -0.0009548143716529012, -0.02199643850326538, -0.011724810115993023, 0.011625447310507298, -0.004741468466818333, -0.012699807062745094, 0.001384092727676034, 0.07720489054918289, -0.0040086680091917515, -0.017264286056160927, -0.05539476126432419, -0.03584513068199158, 0.010718761943280697, 0.025958530604839325, 0.021040072664618492, -0.06403931975364685, -0.024853119626641273, 0.04945783317089081, 0.010041852481663227, -0.02836807817220688, -0.011842803098261356, -0.030355334281921387, 0.013078628107905388, 0.011563345789909363, 0.013563022017478943, 0.00850793905556202, -0.058723412454128265, 0.02747381292283535, 0.008924021385610104, 0.04391835629940033, 0.04123556241393089, -0.0226298775523901, -0.0077875591814517975, 0.031820934265851974, 0.06185334175825119, 0.03174641355872154, -0.003539799712598324, -0.038925375789403915, -0.0009423940209671855, 0.05812723562121391, -0.038676969707012177, 0.03701264038681984, 0.02296522632241249, -0.027424132451415062, 0.08942651748657227, -0.04232855141162872, -0.058971818536520004, -0.005980398505926132, 0.05400368198752403, 0.02824387513101101, -0.0033286537509411573, 0.04294956848025322, 0.012538342736661434, -0.016270658001303673, 0.0017062455881386995, 0.0035956911742687225, -0.00008514731598552316, 0.011749650351703167, -0.06567881256341934, 0.042204346507787704, 0.03577060624957085, 0.012016688473522663, -0.017438171431422234, 0.05445081368088722, 0.026331141591072083, 0.004567583557218313, -0.03184577822685242, -0.0034839080180972815, 0.053506866097450256, 0.009010964073240757, 0.0167674720287323, -0.03681391477584839, 0.029113300144672394, 0.02181013487279415, 0.006644886918365955, -0.003341074101626873, -0.03380819037556648, -0.0029638060368597507, -0.020816506817936897, 0.05042662099003792, -0.02036937326192856, -0.05271196365356445, -0.0020260694436728954, 0.012942004017531872, -0.0008585566538386047, 0.005818933714181185, -0.026107575744390488, 0.008042176254093647, 0.03606869652867317, -0.02662923000752926, 0.026554707437753677, -0.0009299736702814698, 0.03760881721973419, -0.031050873920321465, -0.002140957862138748, -0.026728592813014984, -0.018878931179642677, 0.014854738488793373, -0.03018144890666008, 0.07606222480535507, 0.03462793305516243, 0.002027622191235423, -0.044911984354257584, -0.03728589043021202, -0.05102279782295227, 0.0018366591539233923, -0.045955292880535126, 0.017723839730024338, 0.007029918022453785, -0.012041528709232807, -0.007713037077337503, 0.009656822308897972, -0.010960958898067474, 0.012097420170903206, 0.043371859937906265, -0.03328653797507286, -0.05360623076558113, 0.00506439758464694, -0.011172104626893997, 0.05000432953238487, -0.041310083121061325, -0.026082733646035194, 0.0115136643871665, -0.016332760453224182, 0.02316395193338394, -0.009023384191095829, 0.031448327004909515, 0.018593262881040573, -0.02270439825952053, 0.027523495256900787, -0.02269197814166546, -0.042154666036367416, 0.07208771258592606, -0.017301546409726143, -0.012892322614789009, -0.03594449162483215, -0.030454697087407112, -0.024070637300610542, 0.04816611483693123, 0.010855386033654213, 0.01792256534099579, 0.044663578271865845, 0.04881197586655617, 0.03527379408478737, 0.01787288300693035, 0.007452209945768118, -0.03241711109876633, 0.0037167896516621113, 0.025436876341700554, -0.015488175675272942, -0.014407605864107609, 0.013712066225707531, -0.02522573061287403, -0.03500054404139519, -0.0017605845350772142, 0.04245275631546974, -0.052413877099752426, -0.07581381499767303, -0.037757862359285355, 0.019114919006824493, 0.013078628107905388, -0.05951831489801407, -0.01309104822576046, -0.013016526587307453, -0.06597689539194107, -0.024753756821155548, 0.018406957387924194, -0.0450361892580986, -0.04540879651904106, -0.016022251918911934, -0.001537018222734332, -0.04742089658975601, 0.050401780754327774, 0.049557194113731384, 0.04635274410247803, -0.02638082206249237, -0.008986122906208038, -0.04496166482567787, 0.011594396084547043, 0.024915222078561783, -0.024430828168988228, -0.0025073580909520388, -0.0143455034121871, -0.019189439713954926, -0.006216384936124086, -0.01863052509725094, -0.008719085715711117, -0.015177667140960693, 0.05772978439927101, 0.029113300144672394, 0.040664225816726685, 0.0012909400975331664, -0.0062940120697021484, 0.005272438284009695, 0.05186738073825836, -0.021325740963220596, 0.04642726853489876, -0.004635895602405071, 0.02064262144267559, -0.052413877099752426, -0.050401780754327774, -0.007135490886867046, -0.029063617810606956, 0.006315747741609812, 0.028268715366721153, 0.023437200114130974, -0.015376392751932144, 0.036540668457746506, -0.014407605864107609, 0.002810104051604867, -0.01798466593027115, -0.05035209655761719, 0.00612944271415472, 0.04722217097878456, -0.003611216554418206, -0.016357600688934326, -0.007110650185495615, -0.021437523886561394, 0.028293555602431297, 0.046079497784376144, -0.027374450117349625, 0.00515755033120513, 0.03733557090163231, -0.012488661333918571, -0.03316233307123184, -0.027424132451415062, -0.011712389998137951, 0.004272600170224905, 0.031249599531292915, 0.0002782934461720288, -0.04702344536781311, 0.019040396437048912, 0.0033907555043697357, 0.0258591677993536, 0.026480184867978096, -0.02657954767346382, 0.02436872571706772, -0.019810456782579422, 0.01573658362030983, 0.047172486782073975, -0.005499109625816345, 0.036019012331962585, -0.04257695749402046, -0.05554380267858505, -0.03090183064341545, -0.06687116622924805, -0.015463335439562798, 0.009594719856977463, -0.002650192007422447, 0.022605035454034805, 0.016866834834218025, -0.02618209645152092, 0.014109517447650433, 0.005390431731939316, 0.029759157449007034, -0.005669889505952597, -0.0011675128480419517, 0.03167189285159111, -0.012855062261223793, 0.0388011708855629, -0.025238150730729103, 0.006694568321108818, -0.04451453313231468, -0.04679987579584122, 0.024877959862351418, 0.017264286056160927, -0.019711093977093697, -0.039372507482767105, 0.006557944696396589, 0.002878416096791625, 0.008017336018383503, -0.004415434319525957, -0.012252675369381905, 0.058325961232185364, -0.005654364358633757, 0.012904743663966656, -0.008520360104739666, 0.02012096717953682, 0.03403175622224808, -0.006408900488168001, 0.026728592813014984, 0.06736797839403152, -0.0185808427631855, 0.007110650185495615, 0.007042338140308857, -0.0053749061189591885, 0.04103683680295944, 0.004542742855846882, 0.024778597056865692, 0.03154768794775009, 0.03485150262713432, -0.05271196365356445, -0.0008212956017814577, -0.04682471975684166, 0.03102603368461132, 0.007961444556713104, -0.04965655878186226, -0.023114271461963654, -0.01122178602963686, -0.08495519310235977, -0.0069367652758955956, -0.06851065158843994, 0.0024111003149300814, -0.0033659148029983044, -0.010215737856924534, -0.002960700774565339, -0.02630630135536194, 0.03567124530673027, -0.01940058544278145, -0.0010549534345045686, -0.015488175675272942, 0.007390107959508896, 0.040540020912885666, -0.05261260271072388, 0.01134598907083273, -0.0030181449837982655, -0.0138362692669034, -0.016469383612275124, -0.03261583670973778, -0.00775650842115283, 0.008774977177381516, 0.03599417209625244, 0.028293555602431297, -0.026803115382790565, -0.03303813189268112, 0.011662708595395088, 0.0377827025949955, 0.04764446243643761, 0.005331435240805149, 0.0032882876694202423, 0.025362353771924973, -0.02933686599135399, -0.08798575401306152, -0.038527924567461014, 0.05623934417963028, -0.01209121011197567, 0.014444866217672825, -0.029038777574896812, -0.015252189710736275, -0.028343237936496735, 0.013376716524362564, 0.0002542290312703699, 0.08177558332681656, -0.04198078066110611, 0.0021673510782420635, 0.035050228238105774, 0.001534689450636506, -0.004477535840123892, -0.025561079382896423, -0.007390107959508896, -0.05733233317732811, -0.0190900769084692, -0.05618965998291969, 0.023114271461963654, -0.009656822308897972, 0.014196459203958511, 0.023760128766298294, 0.03308781236410141, 0.003080246737226844, 0.02038179337978363, 0.03619289770722389, 0.003980722278356552, -0.02508910559117794, -0.02618209645152092, -0.02787126414477825, -0.0027060837019234896, -0.003583270823583007, 0.0018878931878134608, -0.03244195505976677, -0.09255644679069519, -0.01573658362030983, -0.028069989755749702, -0.0205059964209795, -0.01863052509725094, 0.023201212286949158, -0.012401719577610493, -0.047122806310653687, -0.023052169010043144, -0.0008430312154814601, 0.011085161939263344, -0.0059276120737195015, 0.032342590391635895, 0.01476779580116272, -0.02379738911986351, 0.009340102784335613, 0.001349160447716713, 0.01160681713372469, 0.010190896689891815, 0.0006431412184610963, 0.03942218795418739, 0.03542283549904823, 0.024020956829190254, 0.020282430574297905, -0.0022434256970882416, 0.05718328803777695, 0.018158551305532455, -0.023747708648443222, 0.004076979588717222, 0.008992332965135574, -0.014693273231387138, 0.039695437997579575, 0.003533589420840144, -0.010147425346076488, -0.006570364814251661, 0.004179447889328003, 0.03835403919219971, -0.0038906745612621307, -0.052910689264535904, -0.01941300742328167, -0.007607464212924242, 0.0016472488641738892, 0.013662384822964668, -0.022729240357875824, -0.022679558023810387, 0.022220006212592125, -0.01921428181231022, 0.028715848922729492, -0.017450591549277306, -0.025958530604839325, 0.003272762056440115, 0.0239340141415596, -0.025511398911476135, -0.036217737942934036, -0.015898047015070915, 0.01160681713372469, 0.0037819964345544577, -0.043173134326934814, 0.01109137199819088, 0.0025027005467563868, 0.017053140327334404, 0.030429856851696968, -0.004260180052369833, -0.018655365332961082, -0.028268715366721153, 0.04761962220072746, -0.013960473239421844, 0.0008011125610210001, -0.006682148203253746, 0.01993466168642044, 0.017761100083589554, -0.037186525762081146, 0.004716627765446901, -0.0017776625463739038, -0.011277677491307259, -0.006123232189565897, -0.038478244096040726, -0.03196997940540314, -0.012271305546164513, 0.01973593607544899, -0.039695437997579575, -0.007737877778708935, -0.0017077981028705835, -0.03326169773936272, 0.017189763486385345, -0.002730924403294921, -0.013277353718876839, -0.01006048358976841, 0.010600768029689789, -0.015388812869787216, -0.026033053174614906, 0.04580624774098396, 0.0034466469660401344, -0.009197268635034561, -0.02759801782667637, 0.030330494046211243, -0.004663841333240271, 0.02359866350889206, 0.023039748892188072, 0.002195296809077263, -0.01255076378583908, -0.0005014716298319399, -0.030529219657182693, -0.0036484776064753532, -0.03899989649653435, 0.028268715366721153, -0.037708181887865067, -0.019375745207071304, 0.005260018166154623, 0.02185981534421444, 0.03057890012860298, -0.015376392751932144, -0.006262961309403181, 0.029759157449007034, -0.006185334175825119, 0.006179124116897583, -0.06185334175825119, -0.008861919865012169, -0.0005150563665665686, -0.022108223289251328, 0.026529867202043533, -0.06756670027971268, -0.021437523886561394, -0.006663517560809851, -0.006899504456669092, 0.0036640032194554806, 0.012817800976336002, 0.025126367807388306, -0.0031780570279806852, -0.004996085539460182, 0.03529863432049751, -0.05797819048166275, 0.023499300703406334, -0.00422602379694581, 0.006508263293653727, -0.0406145416200161, -0.027722220867872238, 0.03244195505976677, 0.033758509904146194, -0.03271520137786865, 0.02199643850326538, 0.0055053201504051685, 0.02379738911986351, 0.05191706120967865, -0.014755375683307648, 0.029361706227064133, 0.006253646221011877, 0.01328977383673191, -0.010364782065153122, -0.0007634633802808821, -0.011743440292775631, -0.032094184309244156, 0.01863052509725094, 0.01029025949537754, 0.02418242022395134, -0.02128847874701023, -0.013997734524309635, 0.005704045761376619, 0.023362677544355392, 0.01158197596669197, -0.016742631793022156, 0.002650192007422447, -0.02069230191409588, 0.015960149466991425, -0.01031510066241026, 0.022046120837330818, 0.006588995456695557, 0.004676261451095343, -0.008576251566410065, -0.004552057944238186, 0.04759477823972702, -0.03745977580547333, -0.07785075157880783, 0.009489146992564201, 0.03723620995879173, 0.009532618336379528, -0.01251350250095129, -0.01935090497136116, -0.021437523886561394, -0.01916459947824478, 0.020853767171502113, 0.058325961232185364, -0.019624153152108192, 0.00509234331548214, 0.02193433791399002, -0.030007565394043922, -0.005325224716216326, -0.01830759458243847, -0.012234044261276722, 0.0325164757668972, 0.03281456232070923, -0.0023924699053168297, 0.012792959809303284, 0.002493385225534439, -0.008613512851297855, -0.050029169768095016, 0.001301807933486998, 0.043943196535110474, -0.013774167746305466, 0.0016705370508134365, 0.020741984248161316, 0.011271467432379723, -0.042154666036367416, 0.014829897321760654, 0.02980883978307247, -0.05693488195538521, -0.027399292215704918, 0.005393536761403084, 0.044589053839445114, -0.006750460248440504, -0.039645757526159286, 0.002125432249158621, 0.023437200114130974, 0.017003457993268967, 0.0033628097735345364, -0.01966141350567341, -0.037633661180734634, -0.0004141410463489592, -0.01947510801255703, 0.0403909757733345, -0.027896106243133545, -0.015488175675272942, 0.0020540154073387384, 0.01787288300693035, 0.01006048358976841, -0.01592288911342621, 0.015165247023105621, 0.02269197814166546, -0.019586890935897827, 0.03661518916487694, 0.01134598907083273, 0.02510152757167816, 0.019835298880934715, 0.01754995435476303, 0.02734960988163948, 0.021772872656583786, -0.017636897042393684, -0.05005401000380516, 0.02012096717953682, -0.048215799033641815, 0.0028985990211367607, 0.025685282424092293, -0.009215899743139744, -0.011811752803623676, 0.007563992869108915, 0.0442412868142128, 0.0027417922392487526, 0.05055082216858864, -0.01656874641776085, -0.004244654439389706, -0.07427369058132172, 0.005632628686726093, 0.011097582057118416, -0.017040720209479332, -0.007706827018409967, 0.023822231218218803, -0.027523495256900787, -0.02108975313603878, 0.022033700719475746, -0.03683875873684883, 0.004688682034611702, 0.003549114800989628, -0.03996868431568146, -0.05236419290304184, 0.029262343421578407, -0.0029094668570905924, -0.00958229973912239, -0.009433255530893803, 0.014780215919017792, -0.03418080136179924, -0.08788639307022095, -0.0053655910305678844, 0.035894811153411865, 0.003269657026976347, 0.007619884330779314, 0.04309861361980438, -0.021487204357981682, 0.009284211322665215, -0.005067502614110708, 0.009352522902190685, 0.030454697087407112, -0.011600606143474579, 0.02289070375263691, 0.04476293921470642, -0.004198078066110611, -0.02045631594955921, -0.007799979764968157, 0.012904743663966656, -0.011693758890032768, -0.002622246276587248, 0.016556326299905777, 0.03281456232070923, 0.018866511061787605, 0.0009105668868869543, 0.0014539571711793542, -0.024393565952777863, -0.026157256215810776, 0.044911984354257584, 0.015463335439562798, -0.003007277147844434, 0.00030196976149454713, 0.006390269845724106, 0.013016526587307453, 0.025884008035063744, -0.049358468502759933, 0.005704045761376619, -0.010426883585751057, 0.03244195505976677, -0.01405983604490757, -0.0027138465084135532, -0.03500054404139519, -0.04133492335677147, -0.02063020132482052, 0.0004545071569737047, -0.007247273810207844, 0.03991900384426117, 0.013935632072389126, -0.002067988272756338, 0.027722220867872238, 0.01099821925163269, -0.02089102752506733, -0.0002777112531475723, 0.009774815291166306, 0.02231936901807785, -0.0022605035919696093, -0.03594449162483215, 0.025561079382896423, -0.004713522735983133, -0.05107247829437256, -0.0038627288304269314, -0.0414094440639019, -0.007154121529310942, -0.013960473239421844, -0.034205641597509384, -0.016469383612275124, -0.019102497026324272, -0.023524142801761627, -0.003536694450303912, 0.036093536764383316, -0.002462334232404828, -0.00014487173757515848, 0.020294850692152977, 0.027970626950263977, 0.008830868639051914, 0.04081326723098755, -0.00535627594217658, -0.02851712331175804, 0.025176048278808594, -0.02250567264854908, 0.0143455034121871, -0.012830221094191074, -0.06215142831206322, 0.020356953144073486, -0.0029855414759367704, -0.020853767171502113, -0.002533751307055354, 0.02722540684044361, 0.022915545850992203, -0.02115185558795929, 0.04948267340660095, 0.0005682309856638312, 0.016742631793022156, 0.009197268635034561, 0.03445405140519142, 0.02328815497457981, -0.009147587232291698, 0.017264286056160927, -0.011824172921478748, 0.015587538480758667, 0.002730924403294921, -0.04347122460603714, -0.030802467837929726, 0.012364458292722702, -0.008414787240326405, -0.02238146960735321, -0.01489199884235859, -0.001650354010052979, 0.026206938549876213, 0.028392918407917023, 0.007185172289609909, 0.036987800151109695, 0.03477697819471359, -0.023884331807494164, 0.0013693436048924923, 0.03591965138912201, 0.012414139695465565, -0.04682471975684166, 0.009905228391289711, -0.014283401891589165, -0.01701587811112404, -0.007017497438937426, 0.0085824616253376, -0.03865212947130203, -0.013078628107905388, 0.018667785450816154, -0.0028706532903015614, 0.03485150262713432, -0.006396479904651642, -0.02638082206249237, 0.025561079382896423, -0.006694568321108818, 0.04302409291267395, 0.04528459534049034, -0.00925316009670496, -0.042477596551179886, -0.008358895778656006, -0.004424749407917261, 0.030653422698378563, 0.030007565394043922, -0.011246626265347004, -0.0028722058050334454, 0.007762718480080366, 0.006893293932080269, 0.01260665524750948, 0.011550924740731716, -0.00831542443484068, -0.032740041613578796, -0.038080792874097824, 0.044539373368024826, 0.005281753838062286, 0.014208880253136158, -0.01315315067768097, -0.05877309292554855, 0.011134843342006207, -0.001613092957995832, 0.02379738911986351, 0.010787073522806168, 0.009160008281469345, -0.021822554990649223, 0.014295822009444237, 0.007917973212897778, 0.009985961019992828, 0.017959825694561005, -0.003156321356073022, -0.013327035121619701, 0.037112005054950714, -0.03283940628170967, 0.02264229767024517, -0.007706827018409967, 0.023462040349841118, -0.006247435696423054, 0.0016363810282200575, -0.013066207990050316, 0.010402042418718338, -0.026529867202043533, 0.0025974055752158165, -0.02147478424012661, -0.02901393733918667, 0.032541316002607346, -0.0006365429144352674, 0.020592939108610153, -0.014121937565505505, -0.002080408623442054, 0.016370020806789398, -0.0005340750212781131, -0.008023546077311039, 0.002639324404299259, 0.025262990966439247, 0.008576251566410065, 0.016928937286138535, -0.01845663972198963, 0.026008212938904762, 0.017202183604240417, 0.0069181346334517, 0.012954425066709518, -0.01309104822576046, -0.0005845326813869178, 0.04198078066110611, -0.017649317160248756, -0.0006051039090380073, -0.010911277495324612, -0.04235339164733887, 0.00521033676341176, -0.005527055822312832, -0.037633661180734634, 0.010992009192705154, -0.002547724172472954, 0.00014710352115798742, -0.028864892199635506, -0.01480505708605051, -0.024145159870386124, -0.0014733639545738697, 0.037559136748313904, 0.008377525955438614, 0.023760128766298294, -0.055891573429107666, 0.029560431838035583, -0.02187223546206951, 0.002033832250162959, -0.04714764654636383, 0.016593586653470993, -0.026430504396557808, 0.02392159402370453, 0.06269792467355728, -0.017972245812416077, 0.012830221094191074, 0.02998272329568863, -0.03793174773454666, -0.005657469388097525, -0.0022573985625058413, 0.032019659876823425, -0.018655365332961082, 0.021127015352249146, -0.041434288024902344, -0.027399292215704918, 0.017810780555009842, -0.005921401549130678, 0.016779892146587372, -0.017624476924538612, -0.004219813738018274, 0.023909173905849457, 0.015910467132925987, -0.008973702788352966, 0.021015232428908348, 0.012780539691448212, -0.016394861042499542, 0.01222162414342165, -0.01092990767210722, -0.0005123394075781107, -0.018469059839844704, 0.024865539744496346, -0.013066207990050316, -0.008470678701996803, -0.013910791836678982, 0.013948053121566772, 0.0006217937334440649, -0.02682795561850071, 0.040217090398073196, 0.01813371106982231, 0.0005418377695605159, 0.024232102558016777, -0.027448972687125206, -0.03095151111483574, 0.00996733084321022, 0.01638244092464447, 0.03025597147643566, -0.03748461604118347, -0.0008702007471583784, -0.008849498815834522, -0.0064337411895394325, 0.007595043629407883, -0.018270334228873253, -0.0050147161819040775, -0.006949185859411955, 0.0036329522263258696, -0.04294956848025322, 0.006402690429240465, 0.0021766661666333675, -0.005654364358633757, 0.02181013487279415, -0.008986122906208038, -0.012078789994120598, 0.0015572013799101114, 0.01367480494081974, -0.006489632651209831, 0.018469059839844704, -0.009880388155579567, -0.028790369629859924, 0.011426721699535847, -0.022977646440267563, -0.01460633147507906, 0.010072903707623482, 0.022431151941418648, 0.010656660422682762, -0.006020764354616404, 0.010010802187025547, -0.009340102784335613, -0.015339131467044353, 0.0028333922382444143, -0.011917325668036938, -0.030852148309350014, 0.00345906731672585, -0.004542742855846882, -0.03465277701616287, 0.003657792927697301, -0.023511722683906555, -0.00783724058419466, -0.019065236672759056, -0.011886274442076683, -0.005033346824347973, 0.011706179939210415, -0.002035384764894843, -0.004552057944238186, 0.003840993158519268, 0.004654526244848967, -0.0014508521417155862, 0.017748679965734482, -0.008526570163667202, 0.00020124847651459277, -0.02831839770078659, -0.0033534944523125887, -0.05296036973595619, -0.007042338140308857, 0.005620208103209734, -0.030280811712145805, 0.0074335793033242226, -0.0006823429721407592, -0.002609825925901532, -0.0030150399543344975, 0.05276164412498474, 0.020170647650957108, 0.03450373187661171, -0.0019111812580376863, -0.018655365332961082, -0.021040072664618492, 0.01328977383673191, -0.008650773204863071, -0.010892646387219429, 0.021710772067308426, 0.017326388508081436, -0.0037229997105896473, 0.055494122207164764, -0.026331141591072083, -0.03239227086305618, 0.033112652599811554, -0.02140026167035103, 0.003032117849215865, 0.012718438170850277, -0.022232426330447197, -0.004198078066110611, 0.06617562472820282, 0.004303650930523872, -0.018618104979395866, -0.01935090497136116, 0.012488661333918571, -0.016394861042499542, 0.004191868007183075, 0.0059338221326470375, -0.011358410120010376, -0.0028240769170224667, 0.005055082496255636, -0.046601150184869766, -0.020853767171502113, 0.014718114398419857, 0.010029432363808155, 0.02387191168963909, -0.0019080762285739183, 0.02662923000752926, 0.00938357412815094, -0.01280538085848093, -0.032143864780664444, 0.002689005807042122, -0.031249599531292915, 0.020332112908363342, -0.02533751353621483, -0.0032603417057543993, 0.016556326299905777, 0.030280811712145805, -0.017785940319299698, -0.037186525762081146, -0.0015292555326595902, 0.018394537270069122, -0.00422602379694581, 0.021723192185163498, -0.01940058544278145, 0.014395184814929962, -0.03976995870471001, 0.014556650072336197, 0.04451453313231468, 0.0022868968080729246, 0.03519926965236664, 0.012643915601074696, -0.0032075552735477686, 0.022791340947151184, 0.006980236619710922, 0.00017136201495304704, 0.021710772067308426, 0.014618751592934132, -0.0010262314463034272, -0.004483746364712715, -0.04071390628814697, 0.009240739978849888, 0.04314829409122467, 0.000403661368181929, -0.0037012642715126276, 0.018344856798648834, -0.009265581145882607, 0.03547251969575882, 0.04289988800883293, -0.02322605438530445, -0.001998123712837696, -0.00011828442075056955, -0.00667593814432621, 0.03303813189268112, 0.02392159402370453, 0.010302679613232613, -0.009104115888476372, 0.002501147799193859, 0.007005077321082354, 0.005297278985381126, -0.013215252198278904, 0.018394537270069122, 0.00015350776084233075, -0.013948053121566772, 0.021114595234394073, -0.034205641597509384, -0.026157256215810776, 0.022853443399071693, -0.025511398911476135, -0.01180554274469614, -0.026082733646035194, -0.004337807185947895, -0.003310023108497262, 0.05010369047522545, -0.01496652141213417, -0.017835622653365135, 0.022468412294983864, 0.007178962230682373, -0.0007246497552841902, 0.005635733716189861, -0.008917811326682568, 0.006483422592282295, 0.008986122906208038, 0.01199805736541748, 0.006539314053952694, 0.014643591828644276, -0.008358895778656006, -0.0006307208677753806, 0.01309104822576046, 0.005955557804554701, -0.01509072445333004, 0.0221206434071064, 0.031448327004909515, -0.011209365911781788, 0.023834651336073875, 0.034081440418958664, 0.021760452538728714, -0.029162980616092682, 0.010551086626946926, 0.004306756425648928, 0.023002486675977707, 0.03246679529547691, 0.027771901339292526, -0.020108545199036598, -0.01644454337656498, 0.028169352561235428, 0.027896106243133545, 0.008079437538981438, -0.007650935556739569, -0.03487634286284447, 0.0442412868142128, 0.02316395193338394, -0.0012435874668881297, -0.008625932969152927, -0.02896425500512123, -0.007390107959508896, -0.026803115382790565, -0.009843126870691776, 0.007570202928036451, 0.013438818044960499, -0.008787397295236588, 0.01613403484225273, 0.00925937108695507, 0.02734960988163948, 0.011457772925496101, 0.007005077321082354, -0.0006314971251413226, -0.011103793047368526, 0.01650664396584034, 0.010029432363808155, -0.03244195505976677, -0.017003457993268967, -0.025436876341700554, -0.004825305659323931, -0.03179609403014183, -0.010954748839139938, -0.031622208654880524, 0.04329733923077583, 0.0008049939060583711, -0.010774653404951096, -0.026778273284435272, 0.020394213497638702, 0.0021751136519014835, -0.033634308725595474, -0.00825953297317028, 0.002158035757020116, 0.003769576083868742, 0.03788206726312637, -0.027896106243133545, 0.011656498536467552, -0.005325224716216326, 0.028467440977692604, -0.039372507482767105, 0.005300384014844894, 0.04873745143413544, 0.0045116920955479145, 0.015835946425795555, -0.006284696981310844, -0.011886274442076683, -0.019785616546869278, -0.007949023507535458, -0.041757214814424515, 0.03559672087430954, -0.009663032367825508, -0.025461716577410698, -0.021487204357981682, 0.018009506165981293, -0.02181013487279415, -0.057829149067401886, 0.013823849149048328, 0.0013212147168815136, -0.03308781236410141, -0.013277353718876839, -0.02470407634973526, 0.0024359410163015127, -0.013364296406507492, -0.021685929968953133, 0.0008570041391067207, 0.014395184814929962, -0.023362677544355392, 0.017276706174016, -0.02238146960735321, -0.018928613513708115, -0.013028946705162525, 0.00896749272942543, 0.0456572063267231, 0.007104440126568079, -0.03224322944879532, -0.012414139695465565, 0.009364943951368332, -0.011122423224151134, -0.016481803730130196, -0.008085647597908974, -0.022592615336179733, -0.009464306756854057, 0.034155961126089096, 0.0003042985626962036, 0.0012870586942881346, 0.013612703420221806, 0.02264229767024517, -0.024492928758263588, -0.0011442246614024043, -0.029063617810606956, 0.047247011214494705, 0.0185808427631855, 0.008327844552695751, -0.053506866097450256, -0.020431475713849068, -0.0035211690701544285, -0.003915515262633562, 0.03301328793168068, -0.0037975218147039413, 0.020270010456442833, 0.01884167082607746, -0.015947729349136353, 0.004235339350998402, 0.014407605864107609, -0.02031969279050827, 0.04307377338409424, 0.021760452538728714, -0.0011620789300650358, -0.03062858246266842, -0.030852148309350014, 0.015351552516222, -0.01079949364066124, 0.01761205494403839, -0.011985637247562408, 0.013066207990050316, 0.004055244382470846, 0.037161685526371, -0.017301546409726143, -0.01579868420958519, -0.00354600977152586, 0.015947729349136353, 0.007098229601979256, 0.023722868412733078, 0.0349508635699749, 0.003921725321561098, -0.017313966527581215, -0.011265257373452187, -0.012569393962621689, 0.03269036114215851, -0.010973379015922546, 0.006632466800510883, 0.010159846395254135, 0.027001840993762016, 0.03644130751490593, -0.035621561110019684, 0.0040055629797279835, 0.02213306352496147, -0.02462955377995968, 0.023126691579818726, 0.025362353771924973, 0.007483260706067085, -0.0032603417057543993, 0.004840831272304058, -0.007669565733522177, 0.011532294563949108, 0.020207908004522324, -0.02031969279050827, -0.01547575555741787, -0.03979479894042015, -0.004896722733974457, -0.011134843342006207, 0.013799008913338184, 0.01363754365593195, -0.024716496467590332, -0.016394861042499542, 0.009017174132168293, 0.01759963482618332, 0.027448972687125206, -0.016742631793022156, 0.015699321404099464, -0.013811429031193256, -0.0004952614544890821, 0.031647052615880966, -0.005905876401811838, -0.008116698823869228, -0.004725942853838205, 0.028392918407917023, 0.03914894163608551, -0.02339993789792061, -0.0018925507320091128, -0.013165570795536041, -0.01953721046447754, -0.01961173303425312, -0.015190087258815765, 0.0068498230539262295, 0.014631171710789204, -0.03281456232070923, -0.008576251566410065, -0.00421049864962697, -0.04868777096271515, -0.02528783120214939, 0.020332112908363342, -0.027001840993762016, -0.013053787872195244, -0.007539152167737484, 0.034478891640901566, -0.011370830237865448, -0.008054596371948719, 0.025635601952672005, -0.0225180946290493, 0.023685606196522713, 0.028939414769411087, 0.04657630994915962, -0.003044538199901581, 0.04689924046397209, 0.024617133662104607, 0.028467440977692604, 0.009358733892440796, 0.017313966527581215, 0.019562050700187683, 0.026976998895406723, 0.008178800344467163, -0.02515120804309845, -0.005204126704484224, 0.02496490254998207, 0.0073652672581374645, 0.03798142820596695, -0.018357276916503906, -0.016357600688934326, 0.005887245759367943, 0.005964872892946005, 0.02566044218838215, -0.009110326878726482, -0.029510751366615295, 0.034553412348032, -0.004738363437354565, -0.03288908675312996, 0.0090916957706213, -0.0009912991663441062, 0.020940709859132767, -0.04868777096271515, -0.02561076171696186, 0.007924183271825314, 0.009905228391289711, -0.004617264959961176, 0.006095286458730698, -0.030926670879125595, 0.016680529341101646, -0.0034280165564268827, -0.01967383362352848, -0.03723620995879173, 0.03224322944879532, 0.009160008281469345, 0.01715250313282013, -0.0020214118994772434, 0.029187820851802826, -0.019015556201338768, -0.03383303061127663, -0.0013413977576419711, -0.043943196535110474, 0.009551248513162136, 0.016096772626042366, 0.010035642422735691, 0.0006741920951753855, -0.007085809484124184, -0.0024732020683586597, -0.005586052313446999, 0.018866511061787605, 0.06150557100772858, 0.019773196429014206, 0.001954652601853013, -0.01267496682703495, -0.0072783250361680984, 0.021884655579924583, 0.03301328793168068, 0.014159198850393295, 0.022418731823563576, 0.02598337084054947, -0.010116375051438808, 0.013625123538076878, 0.00612944271415472, 0.00838373601436615, 0.016034672036767006, -0.004154607187956572, -0.021723192185163498, 0.007768928539007902 ]
14.598227
7.401578
2024-07-01
2
2024MNRAS.531.4503H
[ "local galaxies", "massive galaxies", "BH</SUB", "galaxies", "WISE2MBH", "reliable estimates", "total stellar mass", "WISE colours", "Galaxy demographic projects", "Infrared Survey Explorer" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
34
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1372", "10.48550/arXiv.2405.18336" ]
[ "Hernández-Yévenes, J.", "Nagar, N.", "Arratia, V.", "Jarrett, T. H." ]
[ "Departamento de Astronomía, Universidad de Concepción, Av. Esteban Iturra s/n, Casilla 160-C, Concepción, Chile", "Departamento de Astronomía, Universidad de Concepción, Av. Esteban Iturra s/n, Casilla 160-C, Concepción, Chile", "Departamento de Astronomía, Universidad de Concepción, Av. Esteban Iturra s/n, Casilla 160-C, Concepción, Chile", "Department of Astronomy, University of Cape Town, Rondebosch 7700, South Africa; Centre for Astrophysics and Supercomputing, Swinburne University of Technology, John Street, Hawthorn 3122, Australia; Institute for Astronomy, University of Hawaii at Hilo, 640 N Aohoku Pl 209, Hilo, HI 96720, USA" ]
[ "2024arXiv240612917J", "2024arXiv240617754Z" ]
[ "1994ApJ...432...75A", "1996ApJS..107....1A", "2000AJ....119.2498J", "2001MNRAS.322..231K", "2001Sci...293.1273A", "2002MNRAS.336.1281W", "2003MNRAS.340.1095D", "2003MNRAS.344.1000B", "2004ApJ...604L..89H", "2004ApJS..154..235P", "2005ASPC..347...29T", "2005SSRv..116..523F", "2006MNRAS.369.1808C", "2007CSE.....9...90H", "2007MNRAS.381..401L", "2009ApJ...690...20S", "2010A&A...518A..10V", "2010A&A...521A..55C", "2010AJ....140.1868W", "2010RvMP...82.3121G", "2011ApJ...731...53M", "2011ApJ...733L..47F", "2011ApJ...735..112J", "2011MNRAS.416.2840L", "2011MNRAS.418.2785M", "2012ApJ...744...17M", "2012ApJ...753...30S", "2012ApJS..199...26H", "2012MNRAS.421..314C", "2012MNRAS.426.3271M", "2013AJ....145....6J", "2013ARA&A..51..511K", "2013ApJ...768...74T", "2013ApJ...774...62L", "2013MNRAS.435.2764M", "2013MNRAS.435.2835W", "2013OAP....26..187D", "2013PASA...30....4F", "2014A&A...570A..13M", "2014ApJ...782...90C", "2014ApJ...797...55N", "2014ApJS..210....3M", "2014ApJS..212...18B", "2014MNRAS.438..796S", "2014MNRAS.441..599B", "2015ARA&A..53..365N", "2015Ap&SS.357...75M", "2015ApJ...805...90T", "2015ApJ...805..179B", "2015ApJS..218...10V", "2015ApJS..219....8C", "2015MNRAS.451..888C", "2015PASP..127...67B", "2016A&A...586A..26M", "2016A&A...592A..25K", "2016ApJ...818...47S", "2016ApJ...831..134V", "2016MNRAS.460.3119S", "2016MNRAS.461.1131M", "2016PASJ...68....2S", "2017A&ARv..25....2P", "2017ApJ...835..280L", "2017ApJ...850...68C", "2017arXiv171103234K", "2018A&A...618A.144G", "2018ARA&A..56..625H", "2018ApJ...859..116K", "2018ApJS..234...23A", "2018ApJS..236...47W", "2018MNRAS.473..776K", "2018MNRAS.474.1342M", "2018MNRAS.478.5410D", "2018arXiv180801709G", "2019A&A...625A..62T", "2019ApJ...871...80G", "2019ApJ...874..142K", "2019ApJ...875L...1E", "2019ApJ...883L..18G", "2019ApJ...886...33L", "2019ApJ...887..245S", "2019ApJS..244...40L", "2019ApJS..245...25J", "2019MNRAS.485.2083W", "2019NewAR..8601525D", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020AJ....160..271D", "2020ARA&A..58...27I", "2020ARA&A..58..257G", "2020ApJ...898...20C", "2020ApJ...903...91Y", "2020ApJ...903..112D", "2020ApJS..247...20G", "2020MNRAS.491.2617E", "2020MNRAS.494.3317M", "2020MNRAS.495.2921N", "2020NatMe..17..261V", "2020Natur.585..357H", "2021A&A...648A.122V", "2021ApJ...907L...1W", "2021ApJ...908...19B", "2021ApJ...923..260P", "2021ApJS..253...28R", "2021ApJS..256...43S", "2021JOSS....6.3021W", "2021MNRAS.502.5487R", "2021MNRAS.504.4143S", "2022A&A...661A...5L", "2022A&A...666A.170Q", "2022AJ....163..224H", "2022ApJ...930L..12E", "2022ApJ...935..167A", "2022ApJ...939...26Y", "2022ApJ...940L..31L", "2022Galax..10..109P", "2022KosNT..28a...3V", "2022MNRAS.513..256D", "2022MNRAS.515..807K", "2022Univ....8..304L", "2023A&A...670A...4B", "2023A&A...670A..58M", "2023A&A...672A.137L", "2023A&A...672A.164P", "2023A&A...679A..37O", "2023A&A...680A..49Q", "2023ApJ...945L..35L", "2023ApJ...946...95J", "2023ApJ...950...84L", "2023ApJ...950..122L", "2023ApJ...955L...6Y", "2023Galax..11...15R", "2023Galax..11...61J", "2023Galax..11..107D", "2023MNRAS.522.3693K", "2023OJAp....6E..49F", "2023arXiv231206756S", "2024A&A...682A..34M", "2024A&A...686A.183I", "2024ApJ...966..229L" ]
29072485
2406.02196
Local versus global environment: the suppression of star formation in the vicinity of galaxy clusters
In order to examine where, how and why the quenching of star formation begins in the outskirts of galaxy clusters, we investigate the de-projected radial distribution of a large sample of quenched and star-forming galaxies (SFGs) out to 30R<SUB>500</SUB> around clusters. We identify the SFG sample using radio continuum emission from the Low-Frequency Array Two-metre Sky Survey. We find that the SFG fraction starts to decrease from the field fraction as far out as 10R<SUB>500</SUB>, well outside the virial radius of the clusters. We investigate how the SFG fraction depends on both large-scale and local environments, using radial distance from a cluster to characterise the former, and distance from fifth nearest neighbour for the latter. The fraction of SFGs in high-density local environments is consistently lower than that found in low-density local environments, indicating that galaxies' immediate surroundings have a significant impact on star formation. However, for high-mass galaxies - and low mass galaxies to a lesser extent - high-density local environments appear to act as a protective barrier for those SFGs that survived this pre-processing, shielding them from the external quenching mechanisms of the cluster outskirts. For those galaxies that are not in a dense local environment, the global environment causes the fraction of SFGs to decrease toward the cluster centre in a manner that is independent of galaxy mass. Thus, the fraction of SFGs depends on quite a complex interplay between the galaxies' mass, their local environment, and their more global cluster-centric distance.
[ 0.011656665243208408, 0.035087864845991135, 0.023449810221791267, 0.011222410015761852, 0.02269296534359455, 0.04208558797836304, 0.02413221262395382, -0.006799204275012016, -0.02284185215830803, 0.05449289456009865, 0.002898657228797674, 0.04114263132214546, -0.08079638332128525, 0.001469490467570722, 0.04005078971385956, 0.013449521735310555, -0.01795337349176407, -0.021886490285396576, 0.003387194825336337, 0.03727155178785324, 0.028660880401730537, 0.00294673559255898, -0.02610497549176216, 0.0021154459100216627, -0.06531206518411636, -0.01627838797867298, 0.020869091153144836, 0.001667231903411448, 0.014007850550115108, -0.005052876193076372, 0.009950660169124603, -0.011334075592458248, -0.03930635005235672, 0.006420781835913658, -0.04761924594640732, 0.09156592935323715, 0.00420917896553874, -0.0025202343240380287, -0.04173818230628967, -0.020285947248339653, -0.002396161202341318, 0.01420636661350727, -0.008536227978765965, -0.01697319746017456, 0.01151398103684187, -0.008858817629516125, 0.02435554377734661, -0.05771879479289055, -0.0076056793332099915, -0.0197400264441967, -0.04059670865535736, -0.01042213849723339, -0.0006785246077924967, -0.01646449789404869, 0.0025683126877993345, 0.01029186137020588, -0.030521975830197334, 0.006613094825297594, 0.030745308846235275, -0.03575785830616951, -0.0002270149561809376, 0.017841707915067673, 0.05394697189331055, 0.042507436126470566, 0.013660445809364319, 0.01725856401026249, 0.0151741374284029, 0.005000144708901644, 0.003018077462911606, 0.019355399534106255, -0.01710967719554901, -0.03575785830616951, 0.029082728549838066, -0.027941256761550903, 0.02287907525897026, -0.024094991385936737, -0.00041137979133054614, -0.031986039131879807, -0.03595637530088425, 0.007729752454906702, 0.027990885078907013, 0.010248435661196709, 0.011141762137413025, -0.008393543772399426, -0.022581299766898155, 0.002983957529067993, -0.0059865256771445274, 0.05895952507853508, -0.07925788313150406, 0.03647748380899429, 0.0017711431719362736, -0.002990161068737507, -0.0002787766861729324, -0.004823340568691492, 0.004168855492025614, -0.049802932888269424, 0.06466688960790634, -0.030298644676804543, 0.0665527954697609, 0.0028722917195409536, -0.0019277853425592184, 0.01132166851311922, -0.010899819433689117, -0.06536169350147247, 0.061887647956609726, -0.047122955322265625, -0.0165141262114048, 0.024690542370080948, 0.028909025713801384, -0.023449810221791267, 0.07235942035913467, -0.002703242003917694, -0.0026117381639778614, 0.06953055411577225, -0.05181291699409485, 0.005524353589862585, -0.026452379301190376, 0.00828187819570303, -0.010881208814680576, 0.05831434577703476, 0.014640622772276402, -0.02550942450761795, 0.011228613555431366, 0.0357082299888134, 0.01688634604215622, -0.01614190638065338, 0.049902189522981644, -0.016117092221975327, -0.012233605608344078, -0.00943575706332922, 0.044914454221725464, -0.028437549248337746, -0.008387340232729912, -0.023052778095006943, -0.050820332020521164, -0.009603256359696388, -0.004975330084562302, -0.05518770217895508, -0.03930635005235672, -0.009938253089785576, -0.0475199893116951, -0.014454512856900692, 0.021328162401914597, 0.04064634069800377, 0.014715067110955715, 0.007773178163915873, -0.06357504427433014, 0.011247224174439907, 0.024008139967918396, 0.012829155661165714, -0.011544999666512012, -0.012233605608344078, -0.03737080842256546, -0.043996311724185944, 0.0012608926044777036, -0.0027590750250965357, -0.010180195793509483, 0.02209741435945034, -0.029082728549838066, 0.005961711052805185, -0.004171957261860371, 0.027643481269478798, -0.025162018835544586, -0.02975272387266159, -0.006960499566048384, -0.025583868846297264, -0.01121000200510025, -0.03196122497320175, -0.07508902251720428, -0.016253571957349777, 0.006923277396708727, -0.010620655491948128, -0.022717779502272606, -0.041589293628931046, 0.015844130888581276, 0.03335084393620491, -0.008151601068675518, -0.03320195525884628, -0.007872436195611954, 0.010471767745912075, -0.007593272253870964, 0.029132358729839325, 0.010788153856992722, -0.026377934962511063, -0.009032519534230232, 0.025956086814403534, -0.008592060767114162, 0.0017261666944250464, 0.007239663973450661, -0.05310327559709549, -0.0071342019364237785, -0.023586291819810867, -0.02588164247572422, 0.06501428782939911, -0.01312693115323782, 0.0021557696163654327, -0.014193959534168243, 0.023040369153022766, 0.01605505496263504, 0.02445480227470398, 0.03553452715277672, 0.025348128750920296, 0.004277419298887253, -0.029256431385874748, -0.011358889751136303, -0.03858672454953194, 0.021005570888519287, -0.01132166851311922, 0.03389676287770271, 0.003799737896770239, 0.033524543046951294, 0.010800560936331749, 0.001449328614398837, 0.000999563722871244, -0.015744872391223907, 0.03141530230641365, -0.06809130311012268, 0.03925672173500061, 0.022767409682273865, 0.017146898433566093, 0.025025539100170135, 0.03416972607374191, 0.03238307312130928, 0.034070465713739395, 0.04466630518436432, -0.013188967481255531, 0.03223418444395065, -0.06456762552261353, 0.02947976253926754, -0.012059902772307396, 0.01688634604215622, 0.04826442524790764, 0.003266223706305027, -0.020447243005037308, -0.02408258430659771, 0.00715281255543232, -0.024578876793384552, 0.0596047043800354, -0.01763078384101391, -0.049852561205625534, -0.06630465388298035, 0.002918819198384881, 0.02167556621134281, 0.01439247652888298, 0.007090776227414608, 0.015471911989152431, -0.022122228518128395, -0.0008871224708855152, 0.01776726357638836, -0.003030484775081277, -0.006836426444351673, 0.006761982571333647, 0.003059952287003398, -0.026452379301190376, -0.018486887216567993, -0.0035950173623859882, 0.000738622504286468, 0.01109213288873434, 0.00003341733827255666, -0.0043642702512443066, -0.0351623110473156, -0.04831405356526375, -0.03389676287770271, 0.00455658370628953, 0.002983957529067993, 0.04871108755469322, 0.009106963872909546, 0.0002636552962940186, -0.026998301967978477, 0.057867683470249176, -0.01642727479338646, -0.02421906404197216, 0.02920680120587349, -0.025410166010260582, -0.03456676006317139, 0.04342557489871979, 0.042879655957221985, 0.02284185215830803, 0.009280665777623653, -0.046155184507369995, 0.007965491153299809, -0.02168797329068184, 0.02398332580924034, -0.004854359198361635, -0.00897048320621252, -0.002425628714263439, 0.040944114327430725, 0.012438326142728329, 0.004541074391454458, 0.021849269047379494, 0.08223563432693481, -0.025410166010260582, 0.009820383973419666, 0.02684941329061985, -0.04933145269751549, -0.02362351305782795, -0.013027672655880451, 0.002278291853144765, -0.08342673629522324, 0.011861385777592659, 0.06134172901511192, 0.04019967466592789, -0.011135558597743511, 0.01473988126963377, 0.002545048948377371, -0.022060193121433258, 0.07260756194591522, 0.02496350184082985, -0.016030240803956985, 0.06595724821090698, 0.03751969709992409, 0.016551347449421883, 0.021650752052664757, 0.02555905282497406, -0.01734541542828083, -0.022271117195487022, -0.022271117195487022, 0.03843783959746361, 0.031340859830379486, -0.0132882259786129, -0.017407452687621117, -0.02625386230647564, -0.022916296496987343, 0.036278966814279556, 0.03349972888827324, -0.03995152935385704, 0.01844966597855091, -0.0073327189311385155, -0.02301555499434471, -0.004609314724802971, 0.027941256761550903, -0.001185673289000988, 0.012264623306691647, 0.00036330148577690125, -0.022680558264255524, -0.06024988368153572, 0.0224200040102005, 0.034120094031095505, -0.022618521004915237, -0.02759385108947754, -0.013499150983989239, -0.007940676994621754, -0.020968349650502205, -0.01524858083575964, 0.04265632480382919, 0.04635370150208473, 0.014442105777561665, 0.023499440401792526, 0.05354993790388107, -0.012853970751166344, -0.021241310983896255, 0.0389341302216053, -0.026650896295905113, -0.025434980168938637, 0.09102001041173935, -0.04536111652851105, 0.04116744548082352, -0.044591862708330154, -0.00030048948246985674, 0.014442105777561665, 0.03714747726917267, -0.010999077931046486, 0.03533601015806198, -0.008083361200988293, 0.0018952161772176623, 0.019591137766838074, -0.005387873388826847, 0.010912226513028145, -0.012667860835790634, -0.04082003980875015, -0.006706149782985449, -0.006095089949667454, 0.017035232856869698, -0.009441960602998734, -0.08516375720500946, 0.021377790719270706, 0.025856828317046165, 0.007878640666604042, 0.038909316062927246, 0.033648617565631866, 0.029231617227196693, -0.01707245595753193, 0.0011593077797442675, -0.04970367252826691, 0.011340279132127762, 0.010918430984020233, -0.023722771555185318, -0.007990306243300438, -0.09925846010446548, 0.008288081735372543, -0.042333733290433884, -0.0029699993319809437, 0.055336590856313705, 0.030695678666234016, 0.008635485544800758, -0.0026319001335650682, 0.0023093100171536207, 0.06640391051769257, 0.02284185215830803, 0.02947976253926754, 0.012183976359665394, -0.014094701036810875, -0.03233344480395317, -0.03012494184076786, 0.01356118731200695, 0.0354352705180645, 0.0031917798332870007, 0.04342557489871979, -0.009925846010446548, -0.06044840067625046, 0.019045216962695122, -0.03828895092010498, 0.020186688750982285, -0.033524543046951294, -0.01363563071936369, 0.0316634476184845, -0.0496540442109108, 0.024144619703292847, -0.04655221849679947, 0.05687509849667549, -0.0043115392327308655, -0.04811553657054901, 0.022109821438789368, 0.01162564754486084, -0.02620423398911953, 0.010688895359635353, 0.020223911851644516, 0.027097558602690697, -0.00577870337292552, -0.07062239199876785, -0.010477971285581589, 0.03677526116371155, 0.0187846627086401, -0.002250375458970666, 0.0013973730383440852, -0.034442685544490814, 0.024653319269418716, -0.046577032655477524, 0.009224832989275455, -0.028760138899087906, 0.010142973624169827, -0.026328306645154953, -0.014355254359543324, -0.04203595593571663, -0.013685259968042374, 0.0008623078465461731, 0.04263150691986084, 0.012686471454799175, 0.015372654423117638, -0.010285657830536366, -0.03714747726917267, -0.020732611417770386, 0.027693109586834908, 0.03769339993596077, -0.03131604567170143, -0.0252364631742239, 0.052706241607666016, -0.012221197597682476, 0.007301700301468372, -0.04957960173487663, 0.009169000200927258, 0.010527600534260273, -0.04856220260262489, 0.0622846819460392, -0.030323458835482597, -0.008207433857023716, 0.024554060772061348, 0.00581282377243042, 0.008517616428434849, 0.026998301967978477, 0.012816748581826687, -0.06635428220033646, 0.02357388474047184, 0.004466630518436432, -0.017965780571103096, -0.030894195660948753, -0.01951669529080391, 0.0029312262777239084, 0.058661751449108124, 0.03280492126941681, 0.03263121843338013, 0.006098191719502211, 0.016030240803956985, 0.050869960337877274, -0.018015410751104355, 0.009454368613660336, -0.021117236465215683, 0.047222211956977844, -0.00640217075124383, -0.019628360867500305, -0.00326312193647027, -0.0015974408015608788, 0.056626953184604645, -0.012698879465460777, 0.015546356327831745, -0.014156738296151161, -0.009938253089785576, 0.0005218823789618909, 0.000805699557531625, 0.04585740715265274, 0.056676581501960754, 0.0542447492480278, 0.047544803470373154, -0.0029606937896460295, 0.01003130804747343, 0.022258710116147995, -0.03322676941752434, -0.015310617163777351, 0.019218919798731804, -0.020199095830321312, -0.013486742973327637, 0.014516550116240978, -0.01277952641248703, -0.003622933756560087, -0.003035137662664056, 0.0062718940898776054, -0.001416759449057281, 0.023350553587079048, 0.030000869184732437, -0.005729074124246836, 0.02809014357626438, -0.01739504560828209, 0.0006544854841195047, 0.03501342236995697, 0.004420103505253792, 0.0375693254172802, -0.03228381276130676, -0.066602423787117, -0.039331164211034775, -0.039554495364427567, 0.023412588983774185, -0.05161439999938011, 0.0009677699999883771, 0.03253196179866791, -0.03392157703638077, -0.04042300954461098, 0.0010414383141323924, -0.012177771888673306, -0.024181842803955078, -0.024529246613383293, 0.01863577589392662, 0.014032664708793163, -0.005952405743300915, -0.000878592487424612, 0.010167788714170456, 0.06828982383012772, -0.02873532474040985, -0.007915861904621124, 0.011110743507742882, 0.0018347306177020073, 0.017370229586958885, -0.008288081735372543, 0.02155149355530739, 0.013523965142667294, 0.031812336295843124, 0.007630493957549334, -0.0234870333224535, 0.004730286076664925, -0.021104829385876656, -0.009305480867624283, -0.009001501835882664, -0.0031468034721910954, -0.003554693656042218, 0.023462219163775444, -0.0019200308015570045, -0.061242468655109406, -0.000572674791328609, -0.00012155283911852166, -0.019615953788161278, -0.0016687829047441483, -0.026601267978549004, -0.01420636661350727, -0.020955942571163177, -0.015310617163777351, 0.018387630581855774, -0.02450443245470524, -0.019628360867500305, 0.016117092221975327, 0.01827596314251423, -0.024975910782814026, -0.0076925307512283325, -0.01909484528005123, 0.0017184120370075107, 0.034120094031095505, -0.010812968015670776, -0.013089708983898163, -0.011960644274950027, 0.00833150651305914, 0.034442685544490814, -0.011036300100386143, -0.008238452486693859, -0.016017833724617958, -0.0065696691162884235, 0.02209741435945034, 0.0026660203002393246, 0.003100275993347168, 0.02021150477230549, 0.024616098031401634, -0.01372248213738203, 0.013412299565970898, -0.02371036447584629, -0.02717200294137001, -0.04533630236983299, -0.031762707978487015, -0.003501962637528777, 0.0045348708517849445, 0.0014307176461443305, -0.03881005942821503, -0.01808985508978367, 0.013102116994559765, 0.01951669529080391, -0.00892705749720335, -0.037122663110494614, -0.03930635005235672, 0.04506333917379379, -0.03915746137499809, 0.031812336295843124, -0.0028753934893757105, 0.002189889783039689, 0.01960354670882225, -0.02260611392557621, -0.007698734290897846, -0.011129355058073997, 0.00036543398164212704, 0.047445543110370636, 0.010620655491948128, 0.00023593270452693105, -0.021576307713985443, 0.016551347449421883, -0.031067898496985435, 0.021576307713985443, -0.030695678666234016, -0.0024333831388503313, -0.02416943572461605, -0.010105752386152744, 0.015620799735188484, 0.0155711704865098, 0.029628649353981018, 0.011799349449574947, -0.011569813825190067, 0.05553510785102844, -0.009559830650687218, 0.039653755724430084, -0.0359811931848526, 0.011675276793539524, 0.010918430984020233, -0.026055345311760902, 0.018710220232605934, -0.010304268449544907, -0.014218774624168873, 0.007599475793540478, -0.02518683485686779, -0.018846699967980385, 0.003508166177198291, 0.02642756514251232, 0.019268548116087914, 0.00008748121035750955, 0.006966703105717897, -0.006935684941709042, 0.0394800528883934, -0.012866377830505371, 0.02593127265572548, 0.0151741374284029, 0.017543932422995567, -0.021290939301252365, -0.037296365946531296, 0.019070031121373177, 0.014082293957471848, -0.009516404941678047, 0.03394639492034912, 0.05359956994652748, -0.032780107110738754, 0.028983470052480698, 0.013511558063328266, -0.019715212285518646, 0.008244656026363373, -0.029132358729839325, -0.02985198237001896, -0.004407695960253477, 0.026551637798547745, -0.019988171756267548, -0.0069108703173696995, -0.0023449810687452555, 0.01056482270359993, -0.02219667285680771, -0.006194348447024822, 0.0013182763941586018, -0.007903454825282097, 0.032134927809238434, 0.004429408814758062, -0.0029793046414852142, -0.016303202137351036, 0.0596047043800354, -0.029976055026054382, -0.026377934962511063, -0.009193815290927887, -0.028809767216444016, 0.006110598798841238, -0.00844317302107811, -0.029256431385874748, 0.010732321068644524, 0.0018719525542110205, 0.012841563671827316, -0.009082148782908916, -0.02038520574569702, 0.00018184460350312293, -0.01924373395740986, 0.017605969682335854, 0.005710463039577007, -0.008697522804141045, 0.04848775640130043, 0.026005716994404793, -0.017779672518372536, -0.017134491354227066, 0.003318954724818468, -0.03744525462388992, -0.006836426444351673, -0.01576968841254711, 0.008771966211497784, -0.02938050404191017, -0.016390053555369377, -0.009094556793570518, -0.0064331889152526855, 0.01624116487801075, 0.020496871322393417, -0.032085295766592026, 0.0036725630052387714, -0.0057942126877605915, -0.00864789355546236, -0.024938687682151794, 0.030894195660948753, 0.005294818431138992, 0.021700380370020866, -0.0026008817367255688, 0.0067681861110031605, 0.04275558143854141, 0.0038710799999535084, -0.008827798999845982, 0.008740948513150215, 0.02043483592569828, -0.002205398865044117, -0.007860029116272926, 0.01524858083575964, 0.03039790317416191, 0.014640622772276402, -0.006088885944336653, 0.00833150651305914, 0.013685259968042374, -0.02006261609494686, -0.020410019904375076, -0.0029033098835498095, 0.00939233135432005, 0.029033100232481956, 0.01296563632786274, 0.04206077381968498, -0.01688634604215622, 0.023871660232543945, -0.006107497029006481, 0.027966070920228958, 0.012363881804049015, 0.03290417790412903, 0.015447097830474377, 0.012438326142728329, 0.029876796528697014, -0.026601267978549004, 0.040671154856681824, -0.018883921205997467, -0.00020743467030115426, -0.0046434346586465836, -0.012630638666450977, -0.001606746343895793, -0.0042836228385567665, -0.008567245677113533, -0.00817021168768406, -0.01543469075113535, -0.011898607946932316, 0.003464740701019764, 0.009528812021017075, -0.03218455612659454, 0.00943575706332922, 0.028933841735124588, -0.035460084676742554, 0.012891192920506, 0.013027672655880451, -0.014628215692937374, 0.0026737747248262167, 0.03451712802052498, -0.0007700285059399903, -0.001913827145472169, 0.006805408280342817, 0.027569036930799484, 0.014988027513027191, -0.01634042337536812, 0.03861154243350029, -0.017866522073745728, 0.0480659082531929, -0.009820383973419666, -0.10908504575490952, 0.03183715045452118, 0.009913438931107521, 0.012059902772307396, 0.02062094584107399, 0.04317742958664894, -0.006749575491994619, -0.006333930417895317, 0.0386611707508564, -0.011129355058073997, 0.011569813825190067, -0.004407695960253477, -0.01331304106861353, 0.023288516327738762, 0.008989093825221062, -0.0330282524228096, -0.00664411298930645, 0.03312751278281212, -0.015658022835850716, 0.012277030386030674, 0.03141530230641365, 0.020658167079091072, -0.02694867178797722, 0.01923132687807083, 0.02532331459224224, -0.019901320338249207, -0.038685984909534454, -0.004227790050208569, -0.025434980168938637, -0.009038723073899746, -0.011110743507742882, -0.009547422640025616, -0.027072744444012642, 0.02464091219007969, -0.006743371486663818, -0.023226479068398476, -0.0012477098498493433, 0.029554206877946854, -0.0542447492480278, 0.009559830650687218, 0.03416972607374191, -0.04451742023229599, 0.04424445703625679, 0.026402750983834267, 0.0427059531211853, -0.03677526116371155, 0.0053444476798176765, 0.02062094584107399, 0.016625791788101196, 0.014007850550115108, 0.020087430253624916, 0.015198951587080956, -0.014131923206150532, 0.032035667449235916, 0.03039790317416191, 0.0179905965924263, 0.005319633055478334, -0.01734541542828083, -0.01564561389386654, 0.012698879465460777, -0.017419859766960144, 0.006371152587234974, 0.009634274058043957, -0.033971209079027176, -0.018883921205997467, -0.014169145375490189, -0.048363685607910156, 0.01591857522726059, -0.03292899578809738, -0.013486742973327637, 0.023908881470561028, 0.018747441470623016, 0.021750010550022125, 0.03349972888827324, 0.00652624387294054, -0.002655163872987032, -0.00385246891528368, -0.032829735428094864, -0.049058493226766586, 0.019665582105517387, -0.05111810564994812, -0.01052139699459076, 0.016414867714047432, -0.01439247652888298, 0.0017029029550030828, 0.017878929153084755, 0.013821740634739399, 0.011563610285520554, -0.00585935078561306, 0.008858817629516125, 0.02287907525897026, -0.009615663439035416, 0.014466920867562294, -0.009807976894080639, -0.02237037569284439, 0.00009867686458164826, -0.003467842470854521, -0.03211010992527008, 0.03201085329055786, -0.0006719332304783165, -0.008933261036872864, -0.014491735026240349, -0.005490233656018972, -0.02486424334347248, -0.0028955554589629173, -0.011805552989244461, 0.0142311817035079, 0.011520184576511383, 0.020472057163715363, 0.00018804825958795846, 0.06933203339576721, 0.013114524073898792, 0.000058546982472762465, 0.0030894195660948753, 0.03905820474028587, -0.0016827411018311977, -0.007661512587219477, -0.0001835893781390041, -0.025633497163653374, -0.010180195793509483, 0.022122228518128395, 0.010577229782938957, -0.006228468380868435, 0.01725856401026249, 0.01596820540726185, 0.0055708810687065125, 0.01119139138609171, 0.0032879365608096123, -0.005632917396724224, 0.02513720467686653, 0.023276109248399734, -0.008685114793479443, 0.019355399534106255, -0.0006374254007823765, 0.0009980128379538655, -0.0005459215026348829, -0.006079580634832382, 0.01624116487801075, 0.01420636661350727, 0.034442685544490814, 0.009677699767053127, 0.015720058232545853, 0.004575194790959358, 0.0037035811692476273, -0.029231617227196693, -0.001096495776437223, 0.023214071989059448, -0.03518712520599365, 0.05429437756538391, -0.030571606010198593, -0.011576018296182156, 0.01804022490978241, -0.00044007168617099524, 0.00727688567712903, 0.009193815290927887, -0.02883458323776722, 0.011147965677082539, -0.014801917597651482, 0.010391119867563248, 0.028313476592302322, 0.04737110063433647, 0.03158900514245033, -0.0030909704510122538, -0.016228757798671722, 0.004845053423196077, -0.004497649148106575, -0.02694867178797722, 0.018759848549962044, 0.018610961735248566, -0.01827596314251423, -0.03555934503674507, -0.07330237329006195, 0.03431861102581024, 0.005871758330613375, -0.021836861968040466, 0.0191941037774086, -0.018027817830443382, 0.017866522073745728, -0.002067367546260357, 0.013114524073898792, 0.006293606944382191, -0.008573449216783047, 0.003371685743331909, -0.004817137029021978, 0.00911316741257906, -0.0017509813187643886, -0.03345010057091713, -0.014007850550115108, 0.015930982306599617, 0.012562398798763752, 0.01578209549188614, 0.03962894156575203, -0.00936131365597248, 0.040571894496679306, 0.0013733338564634323, 0.045832592993974686, -0.06158987432718277, -0.00839974731206894, -0.004702369682490826, -0.013511558063328266, -0.03491416200995445, -0.021166866645216942, 0.0005877962103113532, -0.01987650617957115, 0.028909025713801384, -0.01938021369278431, -0.013548779301345348, -0.001541607896797359, -0.01420636661350727, -0.03843783959746361, -0.001865748898126185, -0.008381135761737823, -0.0069108703173696995, 0.009975475259125233, 0.08298007398843765, -0.02062094584107399, 0.013064894825220108, 0.011160372756421566, -0.04617999866604805, -0.020000578835606575, 0.012543788179755211, -0.06089506670832634, -0.012264623306691647, 0.02754422277212143, -0.006699946243315935, 0.009262055158615112, 0.008002713322639465, -0.01086259726434946, -0.023263702169060707, 0.010136770084500313, 0.02284185215830803, -0.01021741796284914, -0.017556339502334595, -0.02403295412659645, -0.03104308247566223, -0.00377182150259614, 0.003784228814765811, -0.0009840545244514942, 0.0006742596160620451, 0.04151485115289688, 0.017146898433566093, -0.00589347118511796, 0.03382232040166855, 0.0003985847579315305, 0.010986670851707458, 0.021390197798609734, 0.013362670317292213, -0.04372335225343704, -0.010794357396662235, -0.026055345311760902, -0.011538796126842499, -0.004522463772445917, -0.027569036930799484, 0.015136915259063244, -0.020087430253624916, 0.02975272387266159, -0.004271215759217739, 0.023635920137166977, 0.03017457202076912, 0.0012477098498493433, 0.02662608213722706, -0.021750010550022125, -0.027693109586834908, -0.017494304105639458, 0.01859855465590954, -0.0023744485806673765, -0.03876042738556862, 0.019318178296089172, -0.016017833724617958, -0.03163863345980644, 0.009491589851677418, -0.01250036247074604, 0.026080159470438957, -0.002315513789653778, -0.018338000401854515, 0.0021836860105395317, -0.0043921866454184055, -0.0047054714523255825, 0.017593562602996826, 0.0008972033974714577, -0.013449521735310555, -0.007078369148075581, -0.009417146444320679, 0.006095089949667454, -0.017283380031585693, 0.002318615559488535, -0.03399602323770523, -0.02970309369266033, 0.02403295412659645, -0.0030894195660948753, 0.0028474770952016115, 0.030149757862091064, -0.008089564740657806, 0.02990161068737507, 0.013697667047381401, -0.03555934503674507, 0.0029699993319809437, 0.00929307285696268, -0.03382232040166855, -0.04268113896250725, -0.0042557064443826675, -0.04632888734340668, 0.02315203659236431, 0.003210390917956829, -0.032829735428094864, -0.03404565155506134, -0.004429408814758062, -0.017010418698191643, -0.02265574410557747, -0.007494013756513596, 0.021142052486538887, 0.007618086878210306, -0.02985198237001896, 0.013536372222006321, 0.0147646963596344, 0.008939464576542377, -0.011662868782877922, 0.005971016827970743, -0.010558618232607841, -0.01715930551290512, -0.060547661036252975, -0.021005570888519287, 0.019342992454767227, -0.00432394677773118, -0.04903367906808853, -0.022891482338309288, 0.007165220100432634, 0.003678766777738929, 0.014318033121526241, 0.028338290750980377, 0.002524886978790164, 0.006551058497279882, 0.021787231788039207, 0.007096979767084122, -0.0003032035892829299, 0.01578209549188614, -0.018213927745819092, -0.00664411298930645, 0.01734541542828083, 0.001267096260562539, -0.03479009121656418, -0.018114669248461723, -0.04327668994665146, -0.013201375491917133, 0.023238886147737503, 0.009305480867624283, 0.013424706645309925, -0.028487177565693855, 0.004196771886199713, -0.010781950317323208, 0.06630465388298035, -0.02089390531182289, -0.008933261036872864, -0.06144098564982414, 0.028660880401730537, -0.018375221639871597, 0.007990306243300438, 0.03667600080370903, 0.00483264634385705, 0.009876216761767864, -0.0006886055925861001, 0.0006734841736033559, -0.0031173359602689743, 0.00786623265594244, 0.022804630920290947, -0.0036167302168905735, 0.011154169216752052, 0.028387919068336487, -0.011631851084530354, -0.0045969076454639435, -0.03191159665584564, -0.005375465843826532, 0.0006242426461540163, 0.030596420168876648, -0.002472155960276723, 0.009472979232668877, 0.029628649353981018, -0.013920999132096767, -0.016079870983958244, 0.04000115767121315, 0.02873532474040985, -0.01914447546005249, 0.004559685476124287, -0.010366305708885193, -0.009286869317293167, -0.03608044981956482, 0.009491589851677418, 0.024529246613383293, 0.01404507178813219, 0.02021150477230549, -0.011178984306752682, 0.021117236465215683, 0.03201085329055786, -0.002116996794939041, -0.0224200040102005, 0.008964279666543007, 0.020931128412485123, 0.04737110063433647, -0.009491589851677418, 0.021328162401914597, -0.02398332580924034, -0.02662608213722706, 0.002602432854473591, -0.012717490084469318, -0.007971694692969322, 0.022010562941432, 0.026601267978549004, 0.01868540421128273, 0.052061062306165695, -0.007518828380852938, 0.012916007079184055, -0.044219642877578735, -0.004358066711574793, 0.035633787512779236, -0.00003954829298891127, -0.01406988687813282, 0.020831869915127754, 0.028760138899087906, 0.0062377736903727055, -0.021377790719270706, -0.015670429915189743, -0.019342992454767227, -0.0036167302168905735, 0.018288372084498405, -0.007345126010477543, 0.0014066784642636776, -0.004385983105748892, 0.018139483407139778, -0.020273540169000626, -0.007022535894066095, -0.025310907512903214, -0.038909316062927246, -0.03608044981956482, 0.016216350719332695, -0.010130566544830799, 0.010943245142698288, -0.010459360666573048, 0.02647719345986843, -0.004897784441709518, 0.04265632480382919, -0.04526185616850853, -0.007537439465522766, -0.013809333555400372, 0.0041750590316951275, -0.00491329375654459, 0.0015020596329122782, -0.013945813290774822, 0.011780738830566406, 0.00817021168768406, -0.010552414692938328, -0.014950805343687534, 0.024094991385936737, 0.0206705741584301, -0.02905791439116001, 0.02311481349170208, -0.023325737565755844, -0.014479327946901321, -0.028263846412301064, 0.04900886490941048, -0.028636066243052483, 0.01206610631197691, 0.037073034793138504, -0.014963212423026562, 0.017643190920352936, -0.00042688893154263496, 0.05290475860238075, -0.020546501502394676, 0.01988891325891018, -0.016985604539513588, 0.010130566544830799, 0.000378422875655815, 0.012791934423148632, -0.0064331889152526855, -0.03136567398905754, 0.001893665292300284, -0.03876042738556862, 0.002732709515839815, -0.008821595460176468, -0.0010670284973457456, 0.004711674991995096, -0.013226189650595188, 0.005378567613661289, -0.014342847280204296, 0.029951240867376328, 0.005310327745974064, -0.024417581036686897, -0.007673919666558504, 0.001391944824717939, 0.05295438691973686, 0.024479618296027184, -0.022717779502272606, -0.024293508380651474, -0.01257480587810278, -0.033425286412239075, 0.031489744782447815, -0.023288516327738762, 0.017829300835728645, -0.011526389047503471, 0.020955942571163177, -0.014404883608222008, -0.02006261609494686, 0.009745939634740353, 0.021799638867378235, 0.023834437131881714, -0.028065329417586327, 0.019429843872785568, -0.0252364631742239, -0.00019948623958043754, -0.03044753335416317, 0.005288614891469479, -0.0042557064443826675, 0.023375367745757103, -0.0062098572961986065, 0.0016207045409828424, 0.022221487015485764, 0.004621721804141998, -0.005409586243331432, -0.007928269915282726, -0.02620423398911953, 0.02099316380918026, 0.007810399867594242, -0.019504288211464882, 0.015211358666419983, -0.047768134623765945, -0.04335113242268562, -0.019032809883356094, 0.020831869915127754, -0.0014927542069926858, -0.012308049015700817, 0.04101855680346489, 0.006743371486663818, -0.034492313861846924, 0.02062094584107399, -0.017010418698191643, -0.006513836327940226, 0.01420636661350727, -0.005232782103121281, 0.004553481936454773, 0.022593706846237183, -0.005735277663916349, -0.006532447412610054, -0.002020840300247073, 0.019615953788161278, -0.011079725809395313, 0.008288081735372543, 0.03340047225356102, 0.02039761282503605, -0.05285513028502464, -0.017171714454889297, 0.022060193121433258, -0.03280492126941681, -0.027643481269478798, 0.022854261100292206, -0.04193669930100441, -0.0011484513524919748, -0.0020347984973341227, 0.0010623757261782885, 0.0023015555925667286, -0.0012360779801383615, 0.008517616428434849, 0.007593272253870964, -0.021936120465397835, 0.0087905777618289, 0.017829300835728645, -0.009566034190356731, -0.001242281636223197, -0.01014917716383934, 0.019181696698069572, -0.0046434346586465836, 0.0147646963596344, 0.046800363808870316, 0.0015323024708777666, 0.00936131365597248, 0.0019293363438919187, 0.011172780767083168, 0.033971209079027176, 0.04563407599925995, 0.012990450486540794, 0.024243878200650215, -0.03039790317416191, 0.01088741235435009, -0.025360535830259323, 0.0009615663439035416, -0.0029002081137150526, 0.02196093462407589, 0.03995152935385704, -0.03779266029596329, 0.005564677529036999, -0.03881005942821503, 0.012891192920506, 0.03613007813692093, -0.02759385108947754, 0.01951669529080391, 0.0045627872459590435, 0.003588813589885831, 0.012562398798763752, 0.015533949248492718, 0.01591857522726059, -0.03218455612659454, -0.010856393724679947, -0.001254688948392868, 0.023561477661132812, -0.012214994058012962, -0.013697667047381401, -0.006743371486663818, -0.018201520666480064, -0.003011873923242092, -0.046701107174158096, -0.022060193121433258, 0.008039935491979122, 0.005983423907309771, 0.01280434150248766, 0.008920853957533836, 0.012177771888673306, 0.016687829047441483, 0.011551203206181526, -0.050820332020521164, 0.012388696894049644, 0.008046139031648636, 0.03957930952310562, -0.0014415740733966231, -0.01356118731200695, -0.002343430183827877, 0.009832791052758694, -0.01524858083575964, -0.000523820985108614, 0.02459128387272358, -0.007779381703585386, 0.02818940207362175, 0.031762707978487015, -0.0004517035267781466, -0.02450443245470524, 0.030919009819626808, -0.02610497549176216, -0.03737080842256546, 0.0021588713862001896, -0.008567245677113533, 0.006200551986694336, -0.028958655893802643, 0.017742449417710304, 0.02297833375632763, 0.0013485192321240902, -0.008132990449666977, -0.004258808214217424, -0.012308049015700817, -0.00561740854755044, -0.01739504560828209, -0.03903339058160782, 0.009956864640116692, -0.007444384507834911, 0.0025993308518081903, 0.023288516327738762, -0.019342992454767227, 0.03977782651782036, 0.020558908581733704, 0.00192623445764184, -0.00491329375654459, -0.02380962297320366, 0.038785241544246674, -0.006761982571333647, 0.03456676006317139, -0.012612028047442436, 0.012419714592397213, 0.039231907576322556, 0.011855182237923145, 0.015658022835850716, 0.007245867513120174, 0.05836397409439087, -0.019132068380713463, -0.017382638528943062, -0.043574463576078415, 0.025410166010260582, 0.02841273322701454, -0.0020658166613429785, 0.024665726348757744, 0.010577229782938957, 0.0035267772618681192, -0.010167788714170456, 0.003588813589885831, -0.020682981237769127, -0.006309115793555975, -0.04225929081439972, 0.004109920468181372, 0.04856220260262489, 0.0050931996665894985, 0.024008139967918396, 0.05771879479289055, 0.044070757925510406, -0.021228903904557228, -0.014318033121526241, -0.008046139031648636, -0.01139611192047596, -0.007059758063405752, -0.02689904347062111, -0.007568457629531622, 0.00987001322209835, -0.02062094584107399, 0.009286869317293167, -0.023102406412363052, -0.05305364727973938, -0.013933406211435795, -0.011619443073868752, -0.010651673190295696, 0.01670023612678051, 0.029926424846053123, 0.02070779539644718, 0.021303346380591393, -0.008182619698345661, 0.016315609216690063, -0.005800416227430105, -0.012916007079184055, -0.0060175443068146706, -0.010229825042188168, 0.031216785311698914, 0.005242087412625551, -0.0132882259786129, 0.021154459565877914, -0.0359811931848526, -0.019318178296089172, 0.007903454825282097, 0.008802984841167927, 0.0037532104179263115, 0.011172780767083168, 0.02496350184082985, -0.03017457202076912, -0.044641491025686264, 0.016166722401976585, 0.028214218094944954, 0.015447097830474377, -0.0013950465945526958, 0.03672562912106514, 0.01955391652882099, -0.028363104909658432, -0.01670023612678051, 0.003861774457618594, -0.011706294491887093, -0.01033528707921505, 0.01183036807924509, 0.0008801433723419905 ]
12.094514
6.464417
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.531.4383D
[ "galaxy clusters", "low mass galaxies", "galaxy mass", "clusters", "star formation", "radial distance", "SFGs", "high-density local environments", "low-density local environments", "radio continuum emission" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
20
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1403", "10.48550/arXiv.2406.02196" ]
[ "de Vos, K.", "Merrifield, M. R.", "Hatch, N. A." ]
[ "School of Physics and Astronomy, University Park, University of Nottingham, Nottingham NG7 2RD, UK", "School of Physics and Astronomy, University Park, University of Nottingham, Nottingham NG7 2RD, UK", "School of Physics and Astronomy, University Park, University of Nottingham, Nottingham NG7 2RD, UK" ]
null
[ "1972ApJ...176....1G", "1974ApJ...194....1O", "1976ApJ...208...13D", "1980ApJ...236..351D", "1980ApJ...237..692L", "1981ApJ...243...32F", "1983ApJ...270....7D", "1984ApJ...281...95P", "1986ApJ...300..557B", "1996ApJ...462..563N", "1996Natur.379..613M", "1997ApJ...481...83M", "1997ApJ...488L..75B", "1998ApJ...498L...5Z", "1998ApJ...504L..75B", "1999ApJ...518..576P", "1999MNRAS.308..947A", "2002MNRAS.334..673L", "2004astro.ph..6220B", "2005ASPC..347...29T", "2007CSE.....9...90H", "2009MNRAS.394.2182W", "2009MNRAS.395.1376W", "2009MNRAS.399..983A", "2009MNRAS.400..937M", "2010AJ....140.1868W", "2010ApJ...721..193P", "2010MNRAS.408.1818W", "2012ApJS..199...34W", "2012MNRAS.419.1017C", "2013A&A...558A..33A", "2013ApJ...765...25N", "2013MNRAS.430.3017B", "2013MNRAS.432..336W", "2014MNRAS.439.2687W", "2015ApJ...806..101H", "2015ApJ...807..178W", "2015ApJS..219...12A", "2016MNRAS.462.1826H", "2018AJ....156..123A", "2018MNRAS.473L..79B", "2019A&A...622A..17S", "2019AJ....157..126G", "2019ApJ...876...40P", "2019MNRAS.490.3654C", "2020ApJS..249....3A", "2020MNRAS.492.6074H", "2020MNRAS.499..573C", "2021A&A...648A...6S", "2021MNRAS.506L..55D", "2021gcf2.confE..20W", "2022A&A...659A...1S", "2022MNRAS.513.2271L", "2022MNRAS.515.5479B", "2022MNRAS.517.4515S", "2023MNRAS.518.1316H", "2023MNRAS.518.2398H", "2023MNRAS.518.3004K", "2024A&A...683A..57R", "2024MNRAS.527L..19L" ]
29059636
2309.02310
Quenching massive galaxies across cosmic time with the semi-analytic model SHARK V2.0
We introduce version 2.0 of the SHARK semi-analytic model of galaxy formation after many improvements to the physics included. The most significant being (i) a model describing the exchange of angular momentum (AM) between the interstellar medium and stars; (ii) a new active galactic nuclei feedback model which has two modes, a wind and a jet mode, with the jet mode tied to the jet energy production; (iii) a model tracking the development of black hole (BH) spins; (iv) more sophisticated modelling of environmental effects on satellite galaxies; and (v) automatic parameter exploration using Particle Swarm Optimization. We focus on two timely research topics: the structural properties of galaxies and the quenching of massive galaxies. For the former, SHARKv2.0 is capable of producing a more realistic stellar size-mass relation with a plateau marking the transition from disc- to bulge-dominated galaxies, and scaling relations between specific AM and mass that agree well with observations. For the quenching of massive galaxies, SHARKv2.0 produces massive galaxies that are more quenched than the previous version, reproducing well the observed relations between star formation rate (SFR) and stellar mass, and specific SFR and BH mass at z = 0. SHARK v2.0 produces a number density of massive-quiescent galaxies &gt;1 dex higher than the previous version, in good agreement with JWST observations at z ≤ 5; predicts a stellar mass function of passive galaxies in reasonably good agreement with observations at 0.5 &lt; z &lt; 5; and environmental quenching to already be effective at z = 5.
[ -0.0120585598051548, 0.0379936546087265, -0.0048411269672214985, 0.005021562799811363, -0.006342489272356033, 0.04115298390388489, -0.006270995829254389, 0.03317295387387276, 0.008647301234304905, 0.03573310002684593, -0.0010238881222903728, -0.02621426060795784, -0.10224242508411407, 0.004643668886274099, 0.01214707549661398, 0.022101685404777527, -0.02059010975062847, -0.0038572412449866533, -0.004616433288902044, 0.011942808516323566, 0.011806630529463291, -0.028760788962244987, 0.0015030644135549664, 0.03954608365893364, -0.06280528008937836, -0.0128007298335433, -0.004623242188245058, -0.0017166936304420233, 0.019473450258374214, -0.014298687689006329, 0.020916936919093132, -0.009430324658751488, -0.028896966949105263, 0.01321607269346714, -0.06040855124592781, 0.08481164276599884, 0.006665911991149187, -0.031702231615781784, -0.01568770222365856, 0.029659563675522804, 0.009137541987001896, 0.0014715732540935278, -0.031593289226293564, 0.0603540800511837, -0.01004993449896574, 0.0058182040229439735, -0.027712218463420868, -0.047063108533620834, -0.01668180152773857, 0.00423853937536478, -0.034289613366127014, 0.005528825800865889, -0.028760788962244987, -0.002107354113832116, 0.004316841717809439, -0.004388335160911083, -0.015497053973376751, 0.004994327202439308, -0.057739462703466415, 0.024920569732785225, -0.04583750665187836, 0.02384476363658905, 0.00972310733050108, -0.0072855218313634396, -0.05970042571425438, -0.02379029244184494, -0.0536268875002861, 0.04736270010471344, -0.017703136429190636, 0.012923290021717548, -0.022877899929881096, -0.042324114590883255, -0.0030010221526026726, -0.013699504546821117, 0.00862006563693285, -0.009164777584373951, -0.017172042280435562, -0.0026078082155436277, 0.003782343352213502, 0.03597822040319443, -0.03605992719531059, -0.007802998181432486, 0.005140718538314104, -0.05937359854578972, -0.0004366206412669271, -0.04621880501508713, 0.0017209491925314069, 0.008688154630362988, -0.07691331952810287, 0.03322742506861687, 0.027548804879188538, 0.04047209396958351, -0.028270548209547997, 0.016477534547448158, -0.0012349640019237995, -0.06591013818979263, 0.028515668585896492, -0.014053567312657833, 0.07909216731786728, 0.03023151122033596, 0.028406726196408272, 0.01544258277863264, -0.02791648544371128, -0.042378585785627365, 0.06351340562105179, -0.01321607269346714, -0.0011924083810299635, 0.008048118092119694, 0.009627782739698887, 0.017253749072551727, -0.02995915524661541, -0.04935089871287346, -0.015742173418402672, 0.010043125599622726, -0.07636860758066177, -0.02968679927289486, -0.028978673741221428, 0.024525653570890427, -0.011118931695818901, 0.0265410877764225, 0.017607811838388443, -0.02400817722082138, 0.030313218012452126, 0.005971404258161783, 0.0727735087275505, -0.01823423057794571, 0.024580124765634537, -0.006141626741737127, -0.06645485013723373, 0.044911496341228485, -0.009348617866635323, 0.03614163398742676, 0.008061735890805721, -0.06454835832118988, -0.004534726496785879, -0.015851115807890892, -0.04346800968050957, -0.00840218085795641, -0.005276896525174379, -0.009008172899484634, -0.0076327756978571415, 0.031811174005270004, -0.03360872343182564, 0.006322062574326992, 0.006648889742791653, 0.010703588835895061, -0.017825696617364883, -0.00002423010482743848, -0.039355434477329254, -0.012024515308439732, -0.010928282514214516, 0.013427148573100567, -0.0011141060385853052, -0.010390379466116428, -0.005777350626885891, 0.029114851728081703, 0.0105742197483778, 0.018084434792399406, 0.01062869094312191, -0.005692239385098219, 0.004507490899413824, 0.06095326319336891, -0.05022243782877922, -0.0014809354906901717, -0.00972310733050108, 0.016123471781611443, -0.026527469977736473, 0.018874267116189003, -0.08116207271814346, -0.025737637653946877, 0.02044031396508217, 0.0048990026116371155, 0.013999096117913723, -0.08039947599172592, 0.009512031450867653, 0.04466637596487999, -0.006485476158559322, -0.06340446323156357, -0.03404449298977852, -0.007435317616909742, 0.01100998930633068, 0.02995915524661541, 0.00041938561480492353, -0.009879712015390396, -0.008708581328392029, 0.017703136429190636, -0.01988198421895504, 0.013290970586240292, 0.028515668585896492, -0.012623698450624943, -0.0018622338538989425, 0.04910577833652496, 0.012494329363107681, 0.006948481313884258, 0.011193829588592052, -0.04537450149655342, 0.016382209956645966, 0.06285975128412247, -0.012610080651938915, 0.02483886294066906, 0.030258746817708015, -0.0022894921712577343, 0.009988654404878616, -0.06716297566890717, -0.015592378564178944, -0.012078986503183842, 0.006434409413486719, -0.013753975741565228, 0.015878351405262947, -0.021134821698069572, 0.04621880501508713, 0.01790740340948105, 0.01662733033299446, -0.0013081596698611975, -0.0063935560174286366, 0.00766682019457221, -0.06482071429491043, 0.007128917146474123, 0.008490696549415588, 0.0196640994399786, -0.01999092660844326, 0.03981843963265419, 0.029822977259755135, 0.02180209383368492, 0.01500681322067976, 0.01674989052116871, 0.07048571854829788, -0.035052210092544556, 0.030476631596684456, -0.028706317767500877, 0.01745801605284214, 0.04875171557068825, -0.028978673741221428, -0.022060832008719444, -0.02670450136065483, -0.04940536990761757, 0.009450751356780529, 0.02511121891438961, -0.010152067989110947, -0.05844758823513985, -0.010819340124726295, 0.020399460569024086, -0.024266915395855904, 0.002890377538278699, 0.0350249744951725, 0.030313218012452126, -0.0021396963857114315, 0.011813439428806305, 0.038238774985075, -0.010887429118156433, 0.05626874044537544, -0.06917840987443924, -0.010982753708958626, -0.01269178744405508, -0.007169770542532206, -0.04665457457304001, -0.04305947571992874, 0.030313218012452126, -0.03072175197303295, 0.0001975644554477185, -0.026037229225039482, -0.03303677588701248, 0.008109398186206818, 0.011799821630120277, -0.0361143983900547, 0.038020890206098557, 0.016668183729052544, 0.01088062021881342, -0.014993195421993732, -0.0009192013530991971, 0.010567410849034786, 0.051747631281614304, 0.008211531676352024, -0.024593742564320564, -0.05512484535574913, 0.02576487325131893, -0.002357581164687872, 0.0635678768157959, 0.013141174800693989, -0.03352701663970947, 0.026187025010585785, -0.05177486687898636, 0.04763505607843399, 0.00739446422085166, 0.02165229804813862, 0.028788024559617043, -0.015088520012795925, 0.014816164039075375, 0.03039492480456829, -0.01662733033299446, 0.11063098907470703, -0.016368592157959938, -0.027848396450281143, -0.002817181870341301, -0.006284613627940416, 0.011241491883993149, 0.018969591706991196, 0.025737637653946877, -0.01646391674876213, -0.001748184789903462, 0.06492965668439865, 0.023259198293089867, -0.018492968752980232, 0.00008457928925054148, -0.009900138713419437, -0.003292102599516511, 0.052837055176496506, 0.02330005168914795, -0.017485251650214195, 0.03254653513431549, 0.01030186377465725, -0.012793920934200287, -0.02059010975062847, 0.016886068508028984, -0.03848389536142349, -0.05231957882642746, 0.013352250680327415, 0.04030868038535118, 0.032846126705408096, -0.002473332453519106, -0.04412166401743889, -0.05054926499724388, -0.00952564924955368, 0.013386295177042484, 0.013399912975728512, -0.05643215402960777, 0.022156156599521637, -0.01272583194077015, 0.0026724927593022585, 0.011105313897132874, 0.02539719268679619, -0.006945076864212751, 0.032628241926431656, -0.031021343544125557, -0.01341353077441454, -0.04077168554067612, 0.0220880676060915, 0.025070365518331528, -0.03981843963265419, -0.004412166308611631, -0.01834317296743393, -0.012719023041427135, -0.018915120512247086, 0.010254201479256153, -0.012984570115804672, 0.009770769625902176, 0.027303684502840042, 0.04295053333044052, 0.009484795853495598, -0.009287337772548199, 0.02637767419219017, -0.020944172516465187, 0.04670904576778412, -0.006992739159613848, 0.034997738897800446, 0.0021396963857114315, 0.0057330927811563015, -0.03562415763735771, 0.01689968630671501, 0.011711305938661098, -0.004194281529635191, 0.024607360363006592, 0.02665003016591072, -0.011050842702388763, 0.002488652477040887, 0.01888788491487503, -0.054226070642471313, 0.016477534547448158, -0.017771225422620773, -0.03183840960264206, -0.006342489272356033, 0.04466637596487999, -0.02236042357981205, 0.030531102791428566, -0.040281444787979126, -0.002029051771387458, 0.0765320211648941, 0.003319338196888566, -0.005896506365388632, 0.01335905957967043, 0.009103497490286827, -0.007476171012967825, -0.022183392196893692, -0.02946891449391842, -0.0012417729012668133, 0.012984570115804672, -0.03300954028964043, 0.02165229804813862, -0.0608987919986248, 0.029087616130709648, -0.00666250754147768, -0.02312302030622959, -0.014257834292948246, 0.009716298431158066, 0.03270994871854782, -0.034779854118824005, 0.004677713382989168, 0.04387654364109039, 0.0379936546087265, 0.07969135046005249, -0.03911031410098076, -0.055424436926841736, -0.01783931441605091, -0.056976865977048874, -0.05106674134731293, 0.008803905919194221, 0.010485704056918621, 0.05594191327691078, 0.002558443695306778, -0.02715388871729374, 0.04665457457304001, -0.03804812580347061, 0.027385391294956207, -0.010540175251662731, 0.009205630980432034, 0.006788472179323435, -0.014257834292948246, 0.018465733155608177, -0.013372677378356457, 0.040226973593235016, -0.01026781927794218, -0.04376760125160217, -0.0019592605531215668, -0.01674989052116871, -0.029114851728081703, 0.01088062021881342, 0.017539722844958305, 0.01937812566757202, -0.019146623089909554, -0.056050855666399, -0.018533822149038315, 0.036604639142751694, 0.014080802910029888, 0.012896054424345493, 0.012759876437485218, 0.007741718087345362, -0.011118931695818901, -0.03603269159793854, -0.01689968630671501, 0.012705405242741108, 0.020862465724349022, -0.03837495297193527, -0.018247848376631737, -0.03281889110803604, 0.00007447232928825542, -0.0241171196103096, -0.024648213759064674, 0.027603276073932648, -0.03088516555726528, -0.052183400839567184, -0.005334772169589996, -0.0211484394967556, -0.01153427455574274, 0.01888788491487503, -0.027113035321235657, -0.04147981107234955, 0.023218344897031784, -0.030204275622963905, 0.029877448454499245, -0.03851113095879555, 0.0009098391165025532, -0.022932371124625206, -0.037585120648145676, 0.0018707449780777097, 0.02059010975062847, 0.01126191858202219, -0.016777126118540764, 0.04763505607843399, -0.014816164039075375, 0.013202454894781113, 0.01473445724695921, -0.05850205942988396, -0.018792560324072838, -0.02704494632780552, -0.008170678280293941, 0.0012834774097427726, -0.03341807425022125, -0.0017771226121112704, 0.07941899448633194, 0.03586927801370621, -0.013781211338937283, 0.006669316440820694, 0.028733553364872932, 0.02181571163237095, 0.032900597900152206, 0.04831594601273537, -0.010417615063488483, 0.003368702717125416, -0.01955515705049038, 0.0028971864376217127, 0.010587837547063828, -0.0027661151252686977, 0.054335013031959534, -0.015960058197379112, 0.028733553364872932, -0.05060373619198799, -0.031756702810525894, -0.018983209505677223, 0.013079894706606865, 0.021230146288871765, 0.04687245935201645, 0.01658647693693638, 0.0241171196103096, 0.036659110337495804, -0.0015609400579705834, -0.000147348822792992, -0.016259649768471718, -0.0004979007062502205, 0.010363143868744373, 0.02686791494488716, -0.029033144935965538, -0.0048138913698494434, 0.034180670976638794, -0.023586025461554527, 0.019813895225524902, 0.02946891449391842, -0.004541535396128893, 0.031484346836805344, 0.039355434477329254, -0.0027456884272396564, 0.005807990673929453, -0.0002050116891041398, -0.024811627343297005, 0.010118023492395878, 0.020086251199245453, 0.00011064460704801604, -0.031429875642061234, -0.0888969823718071, -0.03055833838880062, -0.009825240820646286, 0.0046096243895590305, -0.0014298687456175685, 0.010839766822755337, -0.008756243623793125, -0.03834771737456322, -0.036985937505960464, -0.03589651361107826, 0.006744214333593845, -0.0007383399643003941, -0.022278716787695885, 0.022837046533823013, 0.016000911593437195, 0.003157626837491989, -0.03298230469226837, 0.005113482940942049, 0.031048579141497612, -0.01685883291065693, -0.0013387997169047594, 0.042160701006650925, 0.017117571085691452, 0.039464376866817474, -0.02566954866051674, 0.0013464597286656499, -0.011050842702388763, -0.0350249744951725, -0.0026265326887369156, -0.03287336230278015, 0.011057651601731777, -0.005419883411377668, -0.008436225354671478, -0.036550167948007584, 0.02720835991203785, -0.023150255903601646, 0.017049482092261314, -0.0363595187664032, -0.0137403579428792, -0.02065819874405861, 0.0032240136060863733, -0.023708585649728775, 0.0250567477196455, 0.004030867945402861, -0.031130285933613777, 0.015605996362864971, -0.03965502604842186, 0.012303680181503296, -0.01696777530014515, -0.023586025461554527, 0.050140731036663055, 0.010948709212243557, 0.003669996513053775, -0.03826601058244705, -0.0052734920755028725, -0.022782575339078903, 0.013086703605949879, -0.07375399023294449, -0.003775534452870488, 0.017117571085691452, 0.011323198676109314, -0.019310036674141884, 0.015360875986516476, -0.010288245975971222, -0.036495696753263474, 0.006131413392722607, 0.021543355658650398, -0.02346346527338028, -0.014965959824621677, 0.04368589445948601, -0.02577849105000496, 0.00487176701426506, -0.010295054875314236, -0.007571495603770018, 0.012228782288730145, -0.0331457182765007, -0.021407177671790123, -0.04082615673542023, -0.006880392320454121, -0.0011404905235394835, -0.03134816884994507, -0.0010766570921987295, 0.010724015533924103, 0.010553793050348759, -0.0016154112527146935, 0.002509079175069928, -0.0032989114988595247, -0.03050386719405651, -0.017417162656784058, 0.00243077683262527, -0.03815706819295883, 0.03551521524786949, 0.0011592149967327714, -0.026255114004015923, -0.0022588521242141724, 0.03614163398742676, 0.0011132549261674285, 0.02675897255539894, 0.009505222551524639, -0.03039492480456829, -0.020399460569024086, -0.007694055791944265, -0.024144355207681656, -0.007156152743846178, -0.04333183169364929, 0.028624610975384712, -0.00009356916416436434, -0.016041764989495277, 0.032955069094896317, 0.0029703821055591106, 0.04330459609627724, -0.00703359255567193, -0.014707221649587154, 0.013086703605949879, 0.030857929959893227, 0.019909219816327095, -0.04235135018825531, 0.03309124708175659, 0.03970949724316597, -0.019909219816327095, -0.0074012731201946735, -0.034071728587150574, -0.01999092660844326, -0.029986390843987465, -0.02301407791674137, -0.0015354066854342818, -0.0014179531717672944, 0.007918749004602432, 0.020140722393989563, 0.015932822600007057, -0.007530642207711935, -0.008415798656642437, 0.00968906283378601, -0.00847707875072956, 0.03848389536142349, -0.015714937821030617, -0.006533138453960419, -0.023817528039216995, 0.03856560215353966, -0.0043508862145245075, 0.013515664264559746, 0.009062644094228745, 0.031811174005270004, 0.054335013031959534, -0.001306457445025444, 0.008211531676352024, 0.008803905919194221, 0.0073740375228226185, -0.022986842319369316, -0.014271452091634274, -0.03804812580347061, -0.020467549562454224, 0.024157973006367683, -0.0009251591400243342, 0.019854748621582985, -0.02423967979848385, -0.026472998782992363, 0.031811174005270004, 0.006563778501003981, 0.011970044113695621, 0.001806060434319079, 0.015497053973376751, -0.0014639132423326373, -0.0050419894978404045, -0.0007055721362121403, 0.0012528373626992106, -0.01756695844233036, 0.011983661912381649, -0.011037224903702736, -0.0048990026116371155, 0.0293599721044302, -0.018206994980573654, -0.04371313005685806, -0.012610080651938915, 0.0007553622126579285, 0.019895602017641068, -0.03480708971619606, 0.022482983767986298, -0.029659563675522804, -0.018710853531956673, 0.054879724979400635, 0.011037224903702736, -0.032301414757966995, 0.030258746817708015, 0.019841130822896957, -0.006985930260270834, 0.01794825680553913, -0.0040649124421179295, -0.0040342723950743675, 0.003894690191373229, 0.04180663824081421, -0.02952338568866253, -0.018656382337212563, 0.010642308741807938, -0.010363143868744373, -0.07549706846475601, 0.003867454594001174, 0.01691330410540104, -0.03668634593486786, 0.015292786993086338, -0.022333187982439995, -0.004316841717809439, -0.04504767432808876, -0.0046675000339746475, 0.010730824433267117, 0.009335000067949295, -0.020358607172966003, 0.017757607623934746, 0.023558789864182472, -0.012446667067706585, -0.030803458765149117, -0.007871086709201336, 0.016273267567157745, -0.0038538367953151464, 0.008722199127078056, 0.029387207701802254, 0.040553800761699677, 0.014543808065354824, -0.022387659177184105, 0.028842495754361153, -0.008545167744159698, 0.04918748512864113, -0.0061280089430511, 0.0011047438019886613, 0.01214707549661398, 0.008443034254014492, 0.03360872343182564, 0.021339088678359985, -0.007292330730706453, 0.025015894323587418, -0.003006128827109933, 0.02219700999557972, 0.031184757128357887, 0.04098957031965256, -0.00017660581215750426, 0.00586586631834507, 0.02946891449391842, -0.008061735890805721, -0.00017756331362761557, -0.021121203899383545, -0.02158420905470848, 0.013195645995438099, 0.010240583680570126, -0.002415456809103489, 0.004224921576678753, 0.006788472179323435, 0.013141174800693989, 0.054825253784656525, -0.006145031191408634, 0.01511575561016798, 0.008408989757299423, -0.02791648544371128, -0.012630507349967957, -0.020086251199245453, -0.032955069094896317, 0.02201997861266136, -0.007871086709201336, -0.03535180166363716, -0.005113482940942049, 0.000476622924907133, -0.011772586032748222, 0.0016196668148040771, 0.02379029244184494, -0.02285066433250904, -0.004738993477076292, -0.003990014549344778, -0.009423515759408474, 0.01646391674876213, 0.023858381435275078, 0.0003140604530926794, -0.12092604488134384, -0.008851568214595318, 0.04153428226709366, 0.019950073212385178, -0.007047210354357958, 0.057793933898210526, -0.012807538732886314, 0.01696777530014515, 0.0245120357722044, -0.012807538732886314, 0.010444850660860538, -0.03298230469226837, -0.0028086707461625338, 0.027385391294956207, 0.010540175251662731, -0.06051749363541603, 0.011091696098446846, 0.016232414171099663, 0.0019081939244642854, 0.018874267116189003, -0.0018945761257782578, 0.018465733155608177, 0.040063560009002686, 0.01517022680491209, 0.005198594182729721, 0.014965959824621677, -0.004851340316236019, 0.046627338975667953, 0.0177848432213068, -0.001629029051400721, 0.013706313446164131, -0.008184296078979969, -0.037694063037633896, 0.045565150678157806, -0.02565593086183071, -0.02423967979848385, -0.011016798205673695, 0.030994107946753502, -0.015292786993086338, 0.016123471781611443, -0.027998192235827446, -0.024049030616879463, 0.0374489426612854, 0.018928738310933113, 0.03943714126944542, -0.037040408700704575, -0.0015779623063281178, 0.012242400087416172, 0.014693603850901127, 0.008218340575695038, 0.03001362644135952, 0.01812528818845749, -0.0024801413528621197, 0.025628695264458656, -0.0018384027061983943, -0.0009923969628289342, 0.026350438594818115, -0.002735475078225136, -0.014584661461412907, -0.0017515892395749688, -0.0026963239070028067, 0.03657740354537964, -0.03565139323472977, -0.04790741205215454, -0.047662291675806046, -0.0192691832780838, -0.018847031518816948, 0.013645033352077007, -0.020508402958512306, 0.008408989757299423, 0.000012015312677249312, 0.031484346836805344, 0.010587837547063828, 0.010553793050348759, 0.03821153938770294, -0.004470041953027248, -0.02576487325131893, 0.015469818376004696, -0.030149804428219795, -0.0002989532076753676, -0.006090559996664524, -0.03551521524786949, 0.03524285927414894, -0.018520204350352287, -0.01506128441542387, 0.04169769585132599, 0.02308216691017151, -0.0032835914753377438, 0.020004544407129288, 0.02351793646812439, 0.029931919649243355, -0.001860531629063189, 0.017934639006853104, 0.009900138713419437, -0.0025448258966207504, 0.005508399102836847, -0.012181119993329048, 0.006917841266840696, 0.020807994529604912, 0.0010587837314233184, -0.004664095584303141, 0.004558557644486427, 0.013665460050106049, -0.0439310148358345, -0.002360985614359379, -0.0312664620578289, -0.011901955120265484, 0.0379936546087265, 0.03783024102449417, 0.04077168554067612, 0.04019973799586296, 0.008708581328392029, -0.010676353238523006, -0.010526557452976704, 0.055152080953121185, 0.010097596794366837, -0.013011805713176727, 0.012317297980189323, -0.013175219297409058, -0.004272583872079849, -0.000055907443311298266, 0.011602363549172878, -0.03172946721315384, -0.00022192754840943962, 0.015987293794751167, -0.00782342441380024, 0.014312305487692356, 0.03055833838880062, 0.01544258277863264, 0.050304144620895386, 0.0015566844958811998, 0.017580576241016388, 0.03382660821080208, -0.0013932709116488695, -0.02813437022268772, 0.006734000984579325, 0.04687245935201645, 0.03458920493721962, -0.0020596918184310198, 0.007707673590630293, -0.002944848733022809, -0.0216931514441967, -0.015783026814460754, 0.006546756252646446, -0.00470835343003273, -0.0004251306236255914, -0.025288250297307968, -0.027439862489700317, 0.019623246043920517, 0.01406718511134386, 0.0029244220349937677, 0.0029499554075300694, 0.0015694511821493506, 0.004027463495731354, 0.021625062450766563, -0.012351342476904392, 0.014884253032505512, -0.014148891903460026, 0.0018349982565268874, 0.01668180152773857, 0.047771234065294266, 0.02979574166238308, 0.012759876437485218, -0.02556060627102852, -0.031756702810525894, 0.015796644613146782, 0.002095438539981842, 0.027276448905467987, -0.02351793646812439, -0.004361099563539028, -0.028216077014803886, -0.021897418424487114, 0.021434413269162178, 0.009430324658751488, -0.0035678630229085684, -0.005579892545938492, 0.001903087249957025, -0.006131413392722607, 0.018955973908305168, 0.018574675545096397, -0.00243588350713253, 0.019800277426838875, 0.024988658726215363, 0.01971857063472271, 0.037258293479681015, -0.0038538367953151464, 0.008061735890805721, 0.018329555168747902, 0.006475262809544802, 0.008143442682921886, -0.06275080889463425, 0.017430780455470085, -0.03349978104233742, 0.023708585649728775, -0.002847821917384863, -0.004963687155395746, -0.001848616055212915, 0.01933727227151394, 0.018697235733270645, -0.016382209956645966, 0.008885612711310387, -0.020195193588733673, 0.005208807531744242, -0.012589653953909874, 0.005406265612691641, -0.0168452151119709, -0.020086251199245453, -0.01527916919440031, -0.014530190266668797, 0.0005285407532937825, -0.006114391144365072, -0.02807989902794361, 0.0019813894759863615, 0.009389471262693405, 0.028161605820059776, -0.0374489426612854, 0.010860193520784378, -0.01269178744405508, -0.03965502604842186, -0.026445763185620308, 0.014189745299518108, -0.058066289871931076, -0.03382660821080208, 0.03954608365893364, -0.03589651361107826, -0.0018894694512709975, -0.03507944568991661, -0.015360875986516476, -0.0369042307138443, 0.000531519646756351, 0.03330913186073303, 0.024539271369576454, -0.0052871098741889, -0.0032444403041154146, -0.02968679927289486, -0.010478895157575607, -0.013624606654047966, 0.00019096833420917392, 0.004596006590873003, -0.00919882208108902, 0.01783931441605091, -0.015837498009204865, -0.007326375227421522, -0.04608262702822685, -0.03404449298977852, 0.00545052345842123, 0.022823428735136986, 0.013679077848792076, 0.032628241926431656, -0.02197912521660328, -0.015129373408854008, -0.016926921904087067, -0.03842942416667938, -0.0016954158199951053, -0.01999092660844326, 0.03529733046889305, 0.013529282063245773, 0.03592374920845032, -0.001995007274672389, -0.03415343537926674, 0.01538811158388853, -0.008129824884235859, -0.023545172065496445, -0.03162052482366562, 0.04071721434593201, 0.011663643643260002, -0.0355696864426136, 0.01272583194077015, 0.027140270918607712, -0.016055382788181305, 0.021461648866534233, -0.011466185562312603, 0.0011770883575081825, 0.025015894323587418, -0.01635497435927391, -0.008633683435618877, -0.013726740144193172, -0.006819112226366997, -0.015238315798342228, 0.02824331261217594, 0.013883344829082489, 0.015823880210518837, -0.026908768340945244, -0.01679074391722679, 0.007455744314938784, 0.003106560092419386, -0.024934187531471252, 0.01800272800028324, -0.0006923798937350512, -0.015074902214109898, 0.014026331715285778, 0.0452655591070652, 0.02682706154882908, 0.00253971922211349, 0.007619157899171114, -0.014421247877180576, -0.03750341385602951, 0.014325923286378384, -0.032737184315919876, -0.03573310002684593, -0.047389935702085495, -0.02340899407863617, 0.0018315938068553805, -0.027330920100212097, -0.007387655321508646, -0.021734004840254784, 0.0020886296406388283, -0.047444406896829605, 0.00829323846846819, 0.02675897255539894, -0.007224241737276316, -0.028896966949105263, -0.032138001173734665, 0.00952564924955368, 0.007135726045817137, -0.006148435641080141, 0.02566954866051674, 0.008858377113938332, -0.0046096243895590305, -0.020685434341430664, -0.01079210452735424, -0.01162279024720192, 0.017757607623934746, -0.008381754159927368, -0.034071728587150574, -0.03469814732670784, 0.009600547142326832, -0.0035712674725800753, 0.0011736839078366756, 0.03750341385602951, 0.01619156077504158, 0.040499329566955566, 0.022646397352218628, -0.007292330730706453, -0.03622334077954292, 0.00022448088566306978, -0.030204275622963905, -0.02026328258216381, 0.021134821698069572, -0.017635047435760498, -0.05665003880858421, 0.005392647814005613, -0.02098502591252327, -0.015660466626286507, -0.022128921002149582, 0.009437133558094501, -0.004864958114922047, -0.02103949710726738, -0.013549708761274815, -0.025737637653946877, 0.07173855602741241, -0.02699047513306141, 0.003894690191373229, -0.03349978104233742, -0.026391291990876198, -0.02246936596930027, -0.022401276975870132, 0.0336904302239418, 0.000028246291549294256, 0.00491602485999465, -0.003635952016338706, -0.01563323102891445, -0.0070267836563289165, 0.004834318067878485, 0.028433961793780327, -0.028515668585896492, 0.020072633400559425, 0.02753518708050251, 0.011609172448515892, -0.00486155366525054, -0.01227644458413124, 0.009137541987001896, 0.000995801412500441, -0.0011924083810299635, -0.006672720890492201, 0.017267366871237755, 0.02648661658167839, 0.023150255903601646, 0.0018281893571838737, 0.05109397694468498, 0.009627782739698887, -0.006730596534907818, -0.005913528613746166, 0.0379936546087265, -0.003986610099673271, -0.004167045932263136, -0.015537907369434834, 0.0196640994399786, 0.014380394481122494, 0.01745801605284214, 0.04145257547497749, -0.002732070628553629, 0.01352247316390276, -0.01343395747244358, 0.01591920480132103, -0.0031252845656126738, -0.0073740375228226185, 0.03562415763735771, -0.012773494236171246, 0.006751023232936859, -0.016613712534308434, 0.023558789864182472, 0.005304132122546434, -0.01816614158451557, -0.0020903318654745817, 0.021121203899383545, -0.02335452288389206, 0.03211076557636261, 0.019759424030780792, -0.015320022590458393, -0.00999546330422163, -0.0026929194573312998, -0.03200182318687439, 0.03055833838880062, 0.011983661912381649, 0.014965959824621677, 0.009573311544954777, 0.02203359641134739, 0.01104403380304575, 0.025315485894680023, -0.0409623347222805, 0.0320562943816185, -0.006522925104945898, 0.018261466175317764, 0.05447119101881981, 0.012283253483474255, -0.026581941172480583, 0.01921471208333969, -0.012759876437485218, 0.0002691642730496824, -0.021189292892813683, -0.014502954669296741, -0.01216750219464302, 0.02225148119032383, -0.023667732253670692, 0.04610986262559891, 0.0007391910767182708, 0.005634363740682602, 0.0013966753613203764, 0.04676351696252823, -0.01834317296743393, -0.030204275622963905, 0.04719928652048111, 0.03409896418452263, 0.006407173816114664, 0.018928738310933113, -0.019092151895165443, 0.009512031450867653, 0.010342717170715332, -0.0027797329239547253, -0.02566954866051674, 0.031184757128357887, -0.0055015902034938335, -0.03366319462656975, 0.004963687155395746, 0.005804586224257946, -0.012936907820403576, -0.02769860066473484, 0.042378585785627365, 0.009300955571234226, 0.006907627917826176, 0.01668180152773857, 0.018533822149038315, -0.009988654404878616, 0.0005174762918613851, 0.008708581328392029, -0.016926921904087067, -0.005205403082072735, -0.016886068508028984, -0.019691335037350655, 0.024825245141983032, 0.005314345471560955, -0.0028427152428776026, -0.03420790657401085, -0.01062869094312191, -0.025342721492052078, -0.007911940105259418, 0.027998192235827446, 0.013073085807263851, 0.00681570777669549, -0.04137086868286133, 0.0010375059209764004, 0.018247848376631737, 0.005154336337000132, 0.017417162656784058, 0.03360872343182564, 0.004463233053684235, -0.009900138713419437, -0.0020052206236869097, 0.023313669487833977, -0.006199502386152744, -0.023259198293089867, -0.024089884012937546, -0.027821160852909088, -0.00085877237142995, -0.008538358844816685, 0.014666368253529072, 0.013937816023826599, 0.004415570758283138, 0.008443034254014492, -0.013774402439594269, 0.013502046465873718, 0.042106229811906815, 0.019514303654432297, 0.004677713382989168, -0.023531554266810417, -0.01568770222365856, -0.018329555168747902, 0.008708581328392029, 0.0004787507059518248, -0.020467549562454224, -0.008974128402769566, -0.015374493785202503, -0.014039949513971806, 0.036822523921728134, -0.03083069436252117, -0.014080802910029888, 0.030422160401940346, -0.023327287286520004, -0.023041313514113426, 0.008157060481607914, -0.022482983767986298, -0.005886293016374111, -0.013999096117913723, 0.014162509702146053, -0.04368589445948601, 0.023259198293089867, 0.005181571934372187, -0.04515661671757698, 0.051965516060590744, 0.025969140231609344, -0.008116207085549831, 0.008912848308682442, 0.024076266214251518, -0.016327738761901855, 0.025247396901249886, 0.0019098961493000388, -0.0039491611532866955, 0.008763052523136139, -0.009464369155466557, 0.0120585598051548, -0.008463460952043533, 0.007694055791944265, -0.0037448944058269262, 0.006478667259216309, 0.06100773438811302, 0.010070361196994781, -0.01971857063472271, -0.018697235733270645, 0.0024903547018766403, -0.02726283110678196, -0.019909219816327095, 0.023994559422135353, -0.0028546308167278767, -0.030585573986172676, 0.008415798656642437, 0.00856559444218874, 0.004902407061308622, -0.0017047780565917492, 0.03486156091094017, -0.021883800625801086, -0.03336360305547714, -0.009818431921303272, 0.021270999684929848, 0.046736281365156174, 0.019541539251804352, -0.007918749004602432, -0.0007872789283283055, 0.0039185211062431335, 0.0027967551723122597, 0.03333636745810509, 0.013856109231710434, 0.0369042307138443, -0.001370290876366198, 0.0014426354318857193, 0.026037229225039482, 0.037585120648145676, 0.0028239907696843147, 0.01845211535692215, 0.014761692844331264, -0.011343625374138355, -0.03303677588701248, 0.014502954669296741, -0.02968679927289486, -0.01789378561079502, -0.013018614612519741, -0.011650025844573975, 0.02429415099322796, -0.025914669036865234, -0.002793350722640753, 0.0014477421063929796, -0.011976853013038635, 0.011214256286621094, 0.007789380382746458, 0.022837046533823013, 0.04014526680111885, 0.037040408700704575, 0.021298235282301903, -0.04379483684897423, -0.020413078367710114, 0.00955969374626875, 0.052074458450078964, 0.005219020880758762, -0.01032229047268629, 0.0030588977970182896, 0.011084887199103832, 0.03028598241508007, -0.021734004840254784, 0.0035985030699521303, 0.03385384380817413, -0.02764412946999073, 0.014407630078494549, 0.014080802910029888, 0.027603276073932648, 0.004224921576678753, 0.02418520860373974, -0.011200638487935066, -0.0006076942081563175, -0.003268271451815963, -0.0269360039383173, -0.009239675477147102, -0.021216528490185738, -0.00010325056791771203, -0.005562870297580957, 0.003423173911869526, 0.02053563855588436, -0.009518840350210667, 0.0055322302505373955, 0.016886068508028984, -0.0009575014119036496, 0.035379037261009216, 0.0015175333246588707, 0.029060380533337593, 0.002789946272969246, -0.003979801200330257, 0.042868826538324356, -0.020453931763768196, 0.005052202846854925, -0.026568323373794556, 0.027072181925177574, 0.03663187474012375, -0.001702224719338119, -0.010724015533924103, -0.0017805270617827773, 0.027712218463420868, -0.013093512505292892, -0.015183844603598118, -0.018370408564805984, -0.004061507992446423, -0.007122108247131109, 0.014666368253529072, -0.008756243623793125, -0.02192465402185917, 0.0057330927811563015, 0.03717658668756485, -0.03366319462656975, -0.004473446402698755, -0.003693827660754323, 0.04025420919060707, 0.0053586033172905445, 0.012957334518432617, -0.0014502954436466098, 0.01767590083181858, 0.01591920480132103, 0.009709489531815052, -0.0033397648949176073, 0.004701544530689716, 0.026854297146201134, 0.014584661461412907, 0.018261466175317764, -0.008014073595404625, 0.026513852179050446, 0.028379490599036217, -0.015074902214109898, 0.046899694949388504, 0.0013626308646053076, -0.031702231615781784, 0.01021334808319807, 0.027875632047653198, -0.037639591842889786, -0.006512711755931377, -0.009212439879775047, 0.008967319503426552, 0.04134363308548927, 0.014761692844331264, 0.001111552701331675, 0.006087155546993017, 0.0533272959291935, -0.01613708958029747, -0.02384476363658905, -0.0010119725484400988, -0.00829323846846819, 0.028107134625315666, -0.030422160401940346, -0.04395825043320656, -0.015415347181260586, 0.024906951934099197, 0.02626873180270195, -0.03306401148438454, -0.04572856426239014, -0.005981617607176304, 0.012065368704497814, -0.011118931695818901, 0.00016915857850108296, 0.01658647693693638, -0.015415347181260586, -0.00793236680328846, 0.023436229676008224, 0.01713118888437748, -0.015946440398693085, -0.04071721434593201, 0.011718114838004112, -0.02979574166238308, -0.00608375109732151, 0.0030827289447188377, 0.01877894252538681, -0.012174311093986034, 0.0010545281693339348, 0.01335905957967043, -0.029332736507058144, 0.014911488629877567, 0.006226737983524799, -0.007326375227421522, -0.010165685787796974, -0.032900597900152206, -0.05866547301411629, 0.021543355658650398, 0.011173402890563011, 0.02758965827524662, 0.014666368253529072, 0.0009949503000825644, 0.0023626878391951323, 0.015401729382574558, -0.008163869380950928, 0.004745802376419306, 0.008020882494747639, -0.022537454962730408, 0.02704494632780552, -0.0415070466697216 ]
11.666829
6.562716
2024-07-01
12
2024MNRAS.531.3551L
[ "massive galaxies", "galaxy formation", "satellite galaxies", "passive galaxies", "galaxies", "stellar mass", "BH mass", "star formation rate", "environmental quenching", "good agreement" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
46
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1024", "10.48550/arXiv.2309.02310" ]
[ "Lagos, Claudia del P.", "Bravo, Matías", "Tobar, Rodrigo", "Obreschkow, Danail", "Power, Chris", "Robotham, Aaron S. G.", "Proctor, Katy L.", "Hansen, Samuel", "Chandro-Gómez, Ángel", "Carrivick, Julian" ]
[ "International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research (ICRAR), M468, University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Hwy, Crawley, WA 6009, Australia; ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D); Cosmic Dawn Center (DAWN), Denmark", "Department of Physics &amp; Astronomy, McMaster University, 1280 Main Street W, Hamilton, ON L8S 4M1, Canada", "International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research (ICRAR), M468, University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Hwy, Crawley, WA 6009, Australia", "International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research (ICRAR), M468, University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Hwy, Crawley, WA 6009, Australia; ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D)", "International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research (ICRAR), M468, University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Hwy, Crawley, WA 6009, Australia; ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D)", "International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research (ICRAR), M468, University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Hwy, Crawley, WA 6009, Australia; ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D)", "International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research (ICRAR), M468, University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Hwy, Crawley, WA 6009, Australia; ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D)", "International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research (ICRAR), M468, University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Hwy, Crawley, WA 6009, Australia", "International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research (ICRAR), M468, University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Hwy, Crawley, WA 6009, Australia; ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D)", "International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research (ICRAR), M468, University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Hwy, Crawley, WA 6009, Australia" ]
[ "2023ApJ...959L..18D", "2023arXiv231003083K", "2023arXiv231016085K", "2024A&A...687A..68D", "2024ApJ...965..169A", "2024ApJ...966L...2X", "2024MNRAS.527.2624P", "2024MNRAS.531.1971H", "2024MNRAS.532...60K", "2024MNRAS.532L..61H", "2024NatSR..14.3724N", "2024arXiv240502242C" ]
[ "1970Natur.226...64B", "1972ApJ...178..347B", "1973A&A....24..337S", "1975ApJ...195L..65B", "1982AIPC...83..166R", "1983IAUS..100..391F", "1983MNRAS.202.1181P", "1993MNRAS.262..627L", "1997ApJ...477..585M", "1997ApJ...490..493N", "1998MNRAS.295..319M", "1999MNRAS.308L..39F", "2002NewAR..46..247M", "2003PASP..115..763C", "2004MNRAS.351.1151B", "2005ApJ...618..569M", "2005ApJS..160...87R", "2005MNRAS.363...49K", "2006MNRAS.365...11C", "2006MNRAS.370..645B", "2006RPPh...69.3101B", "2007ApJ...667..704V", "2007MNRAS.380..877S", "2007MNRAS.382..641S", "2008ApJ...673..226P", "2008ApJ...684..822B", "2008MNRAS.383..593M", "2008MNRAS.385.1621K", "2008MNRAS.388..587L", "2008MNRAS.389.1619F", "2008MNRAS.391..481S", "2008PhRvD..78d4002R", "2009ApJ...699..486C", "2009ApJ...701.1765M", "2009ApJ...703..785D", "2009MNRAS.397L..31L", "2009MNRAS.398.2177L", "2009MNRAS.398L..54N", "2010MNRAS.404.1775T", "2010MNRAS.405.1573B", "2011MNRAS.410...53F", "2011MNRAS.413..101G", "2011MNRAS.413L.110P", "2011MNRAS.418.1649L", "2012MNRAS.420.2662D", "2012MNRAS.421.3522H", "2013ApJ...764..184M", "2013ApJ...770...57B", "2013ApJ...777...18M", "2013MNRAS.428.3121M", "2013MNRAS.429.1922C", "2013MNRAS.432L..51S", "2013MNRAS.436..697B", "2013MNRAS.436.1787L", "2014ARA&A..52..415M", "2014ARA&A..52..529Y", "2014ApJ...783L..14S", "2014ApJ...784...26O", "2014MNRAS.444.3986R", "2015ApJ...809..147H", "2015ApJS..220....4K", "2015MNRAS.446..521S", "2015MNRAS.447.2603L", "2015MNRAS.448.1271L", "2015MNRAS.449L..46E", "2015MNRAS.450.1937C", "2015MNRAS.451...93I", "2015MNRAS.453.4337S", "2016A&A...594A..13P", "2016A&C....15...72M", "2016ApJ...824..124E", "2016ApJS..222...22C", "2016MNRAS.461..458D", "2016MNRAS.461..859S", "2016MNRAS.462.1470L", "2017ApJ...844...31C", "2017ApJ...844..170T", "2017ApJ...850...51S", "2017MNRAS.467.2066S", "2017MNRAS.467.3856C", "2017MNRAS.469.4831C", "2017MNRAS.472.2054P", "2017MNRAS.472.4992C", "2018A&A...612L...6P", "2018A&A...618A..85S", "2018ApJ...855..105O", "2018AstL...44....8K", "2018MNRAS.473..538C", "2018MNRAS.474..492M", "2018MNRAS.475.2891D", "2018MNRAS.475.5338E", "2018MNRAS.476..875C", "2018MNRAS.477....2J", "2018MNRAS.479.4056W", "2018MNRAS.481.1376Z", "2018MNRAS.481.3573L", "2018PASA...35...42P", "2019A&A...632A..80G", "2019ApJ...873...85D", "2019ApJ...874..114C", "2019ApJ...876..155S", "2019MNRAS.482.2039C", "2019MNRAS.483.2398M", "2019MNRAS.487..198G", "2019MNRAS.489.4196L", "2019MNRAS.490.3309M", "2019Msngr.175...46D", "2019PASA...36...21E", "2019PASA...36...28E", "2020MNRAS.491.3820P", "2020MNRAS.492.2535G", "2020MNRAS.493.1888T", "2020MNRAS.494.4314C", "2020MNRAS.495..905R", "2020MNRAS.496..695C", "2020MNRAS.496.3235B", "2020MNRAS.496.3943F", "2020MNRAS.497.3026B", "2020MNRAS.498...44C", "2020MNRAS.498.5581B", "2020MNRAS.499.1948L", "2020MNRAS.499.2896T", "2020MNRAS.499.3578C", "2020MNRAS.499.5656R", "2020NatRP...2...42V", "2021A&A...647A..76M", "2021ApJ...923..215C", "2021MNRAS.501.2810P", "2021MNRAS.505..540T", "2021MNRAS.506.4893C", "2021MNRAS.507.5820D", "2022A&A...660A..68C", "2022MNRAS.509.3751H", "2022MNRAS.511.5405B", "2022MNRAS.513..439D", "2022MNRAS.513.2985R", "2022MNRAS.516.4043H", "2023A&A...677A.184W", "2023AJ....165..248G", "2023ApJ...942L..27S", "2023ApJ...947...20V", "2023ApJ...951L...1P", "2023ApJ...953...11L", "2023ApJ...954...31C", "2023ApJS..265....5H", "2023MNRAS.518.1378C", "2023MNRAS.518.5953L", "2023MNRAS.518.6011D", "2023MNRAS.520.3974C", "2023MNRAS.521.4375H", "2023MNRAS.522.4481B", "2023MNRAS.523.1009B", "2023MNRAS.523.1036B", "2023MNRAS.523.5719R", "2023MNRAS.524.1448D", "2023MNRAS.526L...8M", "2023NatAs...7..731B", "2023arXiv230504662L", "2023arXiv231016085K", "2024ApJ...965..169A", "2024ApJ...966L...2X", "2024MNRAS.527.2624P", "2024MNRAS.528.5452B", "2024NatSR..14.3724N", "2024Natur.628..277G", "2024arXiv240208408W" ]
29059590
2402.07982
The ALPINE-ALMA [C II] survey: characterization of spatial offsets in main-sequence galaxies at z 4-6
The morphology of galaxies is shaped by stellar activity, feedback, gas and dust properties, and interactions with surroundings, and can therefore provide insight into these processes. In this paper, we study the spatial offsets between stellar and interstellar medium emission in a sample of 54 main-sequence star-forming galaxies at z ~ 4-6 observed with the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA), and drawn from the ALMA Large Program to INvestigate C<SUP>+</SUP> at Early times (ALPINE). We find no significant spatial offset for the majority (~70 per cent) of galaxies in the sample among any combination of [C II], far-infrared continuum, optical, and ultraviolet emission. However, a fraction of the sample (~30 per cent) shows offsets larger than the median by more than 3σ significance (compared to the uncertainty on the offsets), especially between [C II] and ultraviolet emission. We find that these significant offsets are of the order of ~0.5-0.7 arcsec, corresponding to ~3.5-4.5 kiloparsecs. The offsets could be caused by a complex dust geometry, strong feedback from stars and active galactic nuclei, large-scale gas inflow and outflow, or a combination of these phenomena. However, our current analysis does not definitively constrain the origin. Future, higher resolution ALMA and JWST observations may help resolve the ambiguity. Regardless, since there exist at least some galaxies that display such large offsets, galaxy models and spectral energy distribution fitting codes cannot assume co-spatial emission in all main-sequence galaxies, and must take into account that the observed emission across wavelengths may be spatially segregated.
[ 0.013588753528892994, 0.020838454365730286, 0.0752171203494072, 0.0024318427313119173, -0.011661019176244736, 0.05709878355264664, 0.00017102359561249614, -0.054402317851781845, -0.03602379560470581, -0.01433382835239172, -0.02696462720632553, -0.028289206326007843, -0.012406093999743462, -0.039193324744701385, 0.018141990527510643, 0.029164373874664307, -0.024670269340276718, 0.013884417712688446, -0.013624233193695545, 0.03950081393122673, 0.03008684702217579, 0.0035095408093184233, -0.01848496124148369, 0.016746453940868378, -0.06130904704332352, -0.06547200679779053, -0.032286595553159714, 0.018780626356601715, 0.03647320717573166, -0.008018428459763527, 0.03836546093225479, -0.023440303280949593, -0.023239251226186752, -0.04460990056395531, -0.0850568413734436, 0.10199252516031265, 0.01589493826031685, -0.00696586212143302, -0.01257166638970375, -0.04241015762090683, -0.027106547728180885, 0.03145873174071312, -0.03320906683802605, -0.04811057448387146, -0.00011447770521044731, 0.013636059127748013, -0.001328274025581777, -0.00552006158977747, -0.007858769968152046, 0.004733593203127384, -0.03521958738565445, 0.0003041651507373899, 0.023038199171423912, -0.018709667026996613, -0.005316052585840225, -0.0125361867249012, 0.03607110306620598, -0.007119607646018267, -0.00318430969491601, 0.002669852925464511, -0.047613855451345444, -0.004364012274891138, 0.03914601728320122, -0.003444494679570198, -0.01915907673537731, 0.011631452478468418, -0.01629704236984253, -0.016947505995631218, 0.01790545880794525, 0.039595428854227066, -0.02433912456035614, -0.0020740884356200695, 0.008361400105059147, -0.014925157651305199, 0.006942208856344223, -0.017929112538695335, -0.007959295995533466, -0.029093414545059204, -0.046029090881347656, 0.013399527408182621, 0.033824048936367035, 0.0255927424877882, 0.011187954805791378, -0.01507890410721302, 0.02134699746966362, 0.01924186386168003, 0.007302919868379831, 0.01510255690664053, -0.051090873777866364, 0.023641355335712433, 0.05643649399280548, -0.009798331186175346, 0.002180527662858367, -0.008763504214584827, 0.014499400742352009, -0.03898044303059578, 0.04749558866024017, -0.06764809787273407, 0.05563228577375412, 0.01746787503361702, -0.001751813804730773, 0.03647320717573166, 0.01099872961640358, -0.0838741809129715, 0.03162430599331856, -0.0385783389210701, 0.041014619171619415, -0.04952976480126381, 0.026373298838734627, 0.0357399582862854, 0.028241898864507675, 0.02089758589863777, 0.005455015227198601, 0.004896208643913269, -0.05421309545636177, 0.009573625400662422, -0.1256456971168518, 0.034391727298498154, -0.006682023871690035, 0.025900235399603844, -0.004092000424861908, 0.047117140144109726, -0.01180293783545494, -0.02236408367753029, 0.04976629465818405, -0.016829239204525948, -0.007622237782925367, -0.05421309545636177, -0.06168749928474426, 0.02741403877735138, 0.02644425816833973, -0.01964396797120571, -0.0024747143033891916, 0.015753019601106644, -0.0309620164334774, 0.0006401142454706132, 0.017373261973261833, -0.034462686628103256, -0.036733392626047134, -0.0016187647124752402, -0.015741193667054176, 0.002884209854528308, 0.020720187574625015, -0.00026960932882502675, 0.007427099160850048, 0.003814075607806444, -0.006457318551838398, 0.02158352918922901, -0.010584798641502857, 0.015445527620613575, -0.004582804162055254, -0.015220822766423225, -0.013186649419367313, -0.03848372772336006, 0.0052539631724357605, -0.005378142464905977, -0.007545365020632744, -0.037253763526678085, 0.009183348156511784, -0.006244440097361803, -0.053550805896520615, -0.009922510012984276, -0.01823660358786583, 0.021973805502057076, -0.018106510862708092, -0.00277481391094625, -0.023877887055277824, 0.01613146997988224, -0.0734194740653038, -0.03999753296375275, -0.02951917238533497, -0.012500707060098648, -0.020755667239427567, -0.044941045343875885, 0.021654488518834114, 0.012630799785256386, 0.0049287318252027035, -0.008124868385493755, -0.015954071655869484, 0.008118954487144947, 0.008793070912361145, 0.03557438775897026, 0.015114383772015572, 0.0019735624082386494, -0.003887991886585951, 0.054922688752412796, -0.00607295474037528, 0.047164443880319595, -0.0005931774503551424, 0.009183348156511784, -0.0021539179142564535, 0.01608416438102722, 0.0020297386217862368, 0.042599380016326904, -0.04929323121905327, -0.04742462933063507, 0.010034862905740738, 0.019596662372350693, -0.042835913598537445, 0.019513875246047974, 0.049340538680553436, 0.02305002696812153, 0.040210410952568054, -0.07786627858877182, -0.05251006409525871, -0.018461309373378754, 0.018201123923063278, -0.005351532716304064, 0.013777978718280792, 0.012548013590276241, 0.023913366720080376, -0.011507272720336914, 0.002850208431482315, 0.0034415379632264376, -0.029566477984189987, 0.009697805158793926, -0.042315542697906494, 0.02963743731379509, 0.03874391317367554, 0.032570432871580124, -0.0113417012616992, 0.04886747524142265, 0.028312860056757927, 0.02765057049691677, 0.043971266597509384, -0.018461309373378754, 0.014664973132312298, -0.021725447848439217, 0.023144638165831566, 0.004677416756749153, 0.03503036126494408, 0.017089424654841423, -0.015067077241837978, -0.014948811382055283, -0.017964592203497887, -0.010224088095128536, -0.009319353848695755, 0.012299655005335808, -0.012015816755592823, -0.0011715716682374477, -0.020152511075139046, 0.017290476709604263, 0.03304349631071091, 0.010425140149891376, -0.05005013197660446, 0.05198969319462776, -0.029093414545059204, -0.01989232562482357, 0.05369272455573082, -0.028856882825493813, 0.041984397917985916, 0.008083474822342396, -0.02530890516936779, -0.027153853327035904, -0.01336404774338007, -0.0002662830811459571, -0.03242851421236992, 0.01957300864160061, -0.016320696100592613, -0.008615671657025814, -0.048134226351976395, 0.00278516230173409, -0.05255737155675888, 0.03207371383905411, -0.00585120590403676, 0.03238120675086975, 0.01969127357006073, -0.007486232090741396, -0.04742462933063507, 0.011938943527638912, 0.0005994603270664811, -0.00008883802365744486, 0.029400905594229698, -0.06920921057462692, -0.043687429279088974, 0.02158352918922901, -0.04200805351138115, 0.03990291804075241, 0.08529337495565414, -0.027106547728180885, 0.02336934395134449, 0.0015167603269219398, 0.02644425816833973, 0.009816071018576622, -0.042149972170591354, 0.004310792312026024, -0.01532726176083088, 0.0037460727617144585, -0.0034297113306820393, -0.043356284499168396, 0.05487538129091263, -0.005239179823547602, -0.00013619058881886303, 0.006522364914417267, -0.03486479073762894, -0.02208024635910988, 0.03538516163825989, 0.02021164447069168, -0.04444433003664017, 0.017337782308459282, 0.04643119499087334, -0.009620931930840015, 0.008852203376591206, -0.008946816436946392, -0.0002649895614013076, 0.020873934030532837, 0.01633252203464508, 0.039358895272016525, -0.017940938472747803, 0.037537600845098495, 0.02526159957051277, -0.03997387737035751, 0.005046997684985399, 0.02316829189658165, -0.03287792205810547, -0.027674222365021706, -0.005653110332787037, 0.018011897802352905, 0.055206526070833206, -0.05426039919257164, 0.027390385046601295, -0.026255032047629356, 0.021098637953400612, -0.03129316121339798, 0.01859140209853649, -0.03157699853181839, 0.026373298838734627, -0.037703171372413635, -0.05198969319462776, 0.019253689795732498, 0.003199092810973525, 0.007781896740198135, 0.03699357807636261, 0.01904081180691719, -0.0017089424654841423, -0.022979065775871277, -0.013210302218794823, 0.06684388965368271, 0.004263486247509718, -0.009839723818004131, -0.03983195871114731, -0.006723416969180107, 0.01859140209853649, 0.004641937091946602, 0.027319425716996193, -0.0015906764892861247, 0.02348761074244976, 0.007817376405000687, 0.030299726873636246, -0.009810157120227814, -0.0008478187373839319, -0.016226083040237427, -0.003308488754555583, -0.0290224552154541, 0.04018675535917282, -0.015291782096028328, 0.02963743731379509, -0.067458875477314, 0.04319071024656296, -0.003958951216191053, 0.012299655005335808, -0.015977725386619568, 0.0473063662648201, 0.01868601329624653, 0.04475181922316551, 0.017124904319643974, -0.01490150485187769, 0.0003305901773273945, -0.03339829295873642, -0.05307774245738983, 0.013032902963459492, 0.03777413070201874, -0.023795101791620255, 0.00003270791785325855, -0.07195298373699188, -0.01174380537122488, 0.02009337767958641, 0.015942245721817017, -0.014594013802707195, -0.0008123389561660588, 0.03072548285126686, -0.013837111182510853, -0.009224740788340569, -0.025971194729208946, 0.030867403373122215, 0.009549972601234913, -0.0376085601747036, -0.01596589758992195, -0.0966942086815834, 0.001382971997372806, -0.024149898439645767, 0.020448176190257072, -0.005966515280306339, 0.030630871653556824, -0.006971775554120541, -0.03812893107533455, 0.0799950659275055, 0.054969996213912964, 0.0037608558777719736, 0.05038127675652504, -0.008994122967123985, -0.0492459237575531, -0.028241898864507675, -0.005330835934728384, -0.01239426713436842, -0.014369308017194271, -0.008544712327420712, 0.033895011991262436, 0.025285251438617706, 0.004949428606778383, 0.03595283627510071, -0.016675492748618126, 0.01908811740577221, -0.0018848630134016275, -0.017881805077195168, 0.02034173719584942, -0.06660736352205276, 0.030465299263596535, 0.007421185728162527, 0.013825285248458385, 0.03408423438668251, 0.005756593309342861, 0.03529054671525955, -0.014594013802707195, -0.0317898765206337, 0.021252384409308434, -0.017562488093972206, 0.0073679662309587, -0.004745419602841139, -0.0599844716489315, -0.030583564192056656, 0.05430770665407181, 0.03361117094755173, -0.006516451481729746, -0.04179517179727554, -0.01984502002596855, 0.010324614122509956, -0.022340429946780205, -0.0015093686524778605, -0.019620314240455627, 0.015445527620613575, 0.022340429946780205, -0.004086087457835674, -0.040328674018383026, 0.015315435826778412, 0.012914637103676796, 0.013801631517708302, 0.04309609904885292, 0.04229189082980156, -0.0677427127957344, 0.003089696867391467, -0.022837147116661072, -0.006291746627539396, 0.039477162063121796, -0.025048719719052315, 0.01945474185049534, -0.023310210555791855, -0.022470522671937943, 0.03328002616763115, 0.002134699607267976, -0.028975147753953934, -0.009331180714070797, -0.024433737620711327, 0.052983127534389496, -0.04747193679213524, 0.01775171421468258, 0.006439578719437122, -0.005647197365760803, -0.003976691048592329, 0.038223542273044586, 0.027887102216482162, -0.04224458336830139, 0.047566547989845276, -0.039240628480911255, -0.004523671232163906, -0.008101214654743671, -0.013896244578063488, -0.047897692769765854, 0.022056592628359795, -0.021477090194821358, 0.026515217497944832, -0.015268129296600819, 0.01790545880794525, 0.0319317951798439, 0.0462656244635582, 0.03789239749312401, -0.05336157977581024, 0.026586176827549934, -0.0027718571946024895, -0.06334321945905685, -0.04957706853747368, -0.037703171372413635, 0.056341879069805145, -0.010649845004081726, 0.022210337221622467, -0.036118410527706146, -0.01746787503361702, -0.0038968618027865887, 0.010212261229753494, 0.013281261548399925, 0.0347701795399189, -0.02166631445288658, 0.0043403590098023415, 0.030252419412136078, -0.008189914748072624, 0.009952076710760593, -0.027792489156126976, -0.010720805265009403, -0.014664973132312298, 0.01596589758992195, -0.012429747730493546, 0.024528350681066513, 0.017361436039209366, -0.013174822553992271, -0.007042734883725643, -0.0004523671232163906, -0.041913438588380814, 0.032523125410079956, 0.0329015776515007, -0.026940975338220596, 0.011318047530949116, -0.024552002549171448, -0.01507890410721302, -0.0021997459698468447, 0.03751394525170326, 0.010312787257134914, -0.017278648912906647, -0.0860975831747055, -0.03533785417675972, -0.0031222200486809015, 0.04127480462193489, -0.009721457958221436, -0.006238526664674282, -0.0026048067957162857, 0.01516168937087059, -0.021216904744505882, 0.016060510650277138, -0.013387701474130154, 0.007793723605573177, -0.024599310010671616, 0.014759586192667484, 0.01701846532523632, -0.026917321607470512, 0.03886217996478081, 0.01334039494395256, 0.011459967121481895, -0.03789239749312401, 0.007651804480701685, 0.0318608358502388, 0.06031561642885208, 0.005561454687267542, -0.01550466101616621, 0.004875512327998877, 0.028809575363993645, -0.01166693214327097, 0.00333509873598814, -0.009739197790622711, 0.02191467396914959, 0.016770105808973312, -0.003148829797282815, -0.016261562705039978, -0.008769417181611061, -0.01690019853413105, 0.05236814543604851, 0.009615018963813782, -0.022872626781463623, 0.022470522671937943, -0.010856810957193375, -0.010389660485088825, 0.010963249951601028, -0.001372623723000288, -0.03044164553284645, 0.0008396879420615733, -0.014357482083141804, -0.006090694572776556, -0.0036278069019317627, -0.027555957436561584, 0.04073077812790871, 0.007574931718409061, -0.05284120887517929, -0.023641355335712433, 0.004189569968730211, 0.0018745147390291095, 0.011755631305277348, -0.03985561057925224, -0.008657064288854599, -0.0328306183218956, -0.02542717009782791, 0.02821824699640274, -0.030347032472491264, 0.010336440987884998, -0.012086776085197926, -0.004434971604496241, -0.011318047530949116, 0.025616396218538284, 0.005180046893656254, 0.015421874821186066, 0.009567712433636189, 0.03162430599331856, -0.01370701938867569, 0.017148558050394058, -0.029117068275809288, -0.04468085989356041, -0.006427752319723368, -0.020933065563440323, 0.015386395156383514, 0.007421185728162527, -0.013624233193695545, 0.002156874630600214, 0.0188752394169569, 0.009431706741452217, 0.01872149296104908, -0.020767493173480034, -0.004266442731022835, -0.02296723984181881, -0.010052602738142014, 0.011726065538823605, -0.032972536981105804, -0.0036278069019317627, 0.010667584836483002, 0.009952076710760593, 0.004686286672949791, -0.01023000106215477, 0.003098566783592105, 0.006847596261650324, -0.01239426713436842, -0.012926463969051838, -0.02724846638739109, -0.0025781968142837286, -0.027626916766166687, -0.0011604842729866505, -0.02495410665869713, 0.018768800422549248, -0.008881770074367523, 0.022257644683122635, 0.010099909268319607, -0.017692580819129944, 0.04285956546664238, -0.004736549686640501, -0.022293124347925186, 0.026491563767194748, 0.01370701938867569, 0.05142201855778694, -0.012009902857244015, 0.011069688946008682, 0.011607798747718334, -0.0002941864659078419, 0.018295736983418465, -0.03909870982170105, 0.00009290341404266655, 0.003494757693260908, -0.01762162148952484, -0.003148829797282815, 0.0015847631730139256, 0.04267033934593201, 0.004647850524634123, 0.044018570333719254, -0.00020751971169374883, -0.0328306183218956, -0.013517793267965317, 0.0028620350640267134, -0.027343079447746277, -0.014251042157411575, -0.0026269815862178802, -0.009277960285544395, 0.0018686014227569103, -0.01972675323486328, -0.0011848765425384045, -0.008639324456453323, 0.014002683572471142, 0.06211325526237488, 0.015055250376462936, 0.00877533107995987, 0.02587658166885376, -0.02798171527683735, -0.0015197169268503785, 0.015067077241837978, -0.014546707272529602, -0.03529054671525955, -0.005774333141744137, 0.010360093787312508, 0.010537493042647839, -0.03824719414114952, 0.004916905425488949, -0.020164337009191513, 0.02535621076822281, 0.047330018132925034, -0.007226047106087208, 0.004591674078255892, -0.0066997637040913105, 0.017657101154327393, -0.004544367548078299, 0.021689968183636665, -0.0023327951785176992, 0.027674222365021706, -0.014416614547371864, 0.030583564192056656, 0.00544910179451108, -0.0012654452584683895, 0.0026077632792294025, 0.032002754509449005, -0.018946198746562004, 0.006214873865246773, 0.003887991886585951, -0.011046036146581173, -0.029968582093715668, 0.00875759031623602, 0.004597587510943413, 0.004591674078255892, -0.0033528385683894157, 0.025450823828577995, -0.0014007118297740817, -0.01879245415329933, -0.0032375294249504805, -0.000017855380065157078, -0.03831815347075462, -0.0009099083836190403, -0.01043105311691761, -0.04337993636727333, -0.03152969107031822, 0.004565064329653978, -0.0046655903570353985, -0.051374711096286774, 0.026207726448774338, 0.03680435195565224, -0.04520123079419136, -0.043640121817588806, 0.0018833846552297473, -0.010017123073339462, -0.013281261548399925, -0.004251659382134676, -0.017172209918498993, -0.009289787150919437, -0.0070368219166994095, -0.0000571926539123524, 0.02502506598830223, 0.01661636121571064, -0.0299212746322155, -0.010655758902430534, 0.031718917191028595, 0.03647320717573166, -0.0013216215884312987, 0.010537493042647839, 0.04115653783082962, 0.014203735627233982, -0.008314093574881554, -0.0006190481362864375, -0.0033824050333350897, -0.009987556375563145, 0.012559839524328709, 0.01527995616197586, 0.008343660272657871, 0.02485949546098709, -0.03938254714012146, 0.013813458383083344, -0.04193709045648575, 0.00905916839838028, 0.014073643833398819, 0.007314746733754873, -0.0063331397250294685, 0.04837075620889664, 0.016261562705039978, 0.02001059241592884, 0.032854270190000534, -0.002140613039955497, 0.028998801484704018, -0.03720645606517792, -0.003837728872895241, 0.017278648912906647, -0.02854939177632332, -0.007645891048014164, -0.015019770711660385, 0.016829239204525948, 0.0023993197828531265, 0.01629704236984253, -0.014830545522272587, 0.04621831700205803, -0.028147287666797638, 0.006847596261650324, -0.004869598895311356, 0.005546671338379383, -0.020992198958992958, 0.014463921077549458, -0.0005270224646665156, 0.030063195154070854, 0.03514862805604935, -0.012276001274585724, -0.039122361689805984, -0.011034209281206131, -0.043238017708063126, -0.02951917238533497, -0.011329874396324158, -0.0011996598914265633, 0.001751813804730773, 0.015256302431225777, 0.019277343526482582, 0.000863341148942709, -0.08359034359455109, 0.021772753447294235, 0.03834180906414986, 0.021441610530018806, -0.028076326474547386, 0.054638851433992386, 0.004943515174090862, 0.047850389033555984, 0.0043344455771148205, -0.021843714639544487, 0.02639695070683956, -0.046312931925058365, -0.014002683572471142, 0.012902811169624329, -0.01646261475980282, -0.024883147329092026, 0.011915290728211403, 0.014357482083141804, -0.023499436676502228, 0.013789805583655834, 0.003713549580425024, 0.03214467316865921, 0.014558534137904644, -0.019549354910850525, -0.010253654792904854, -0.01945474185049534, -0.03254677727818489, -0.015398222021758556, 0.039879266172647476, -0.007421185728162527, -0.022186685353517532, -0.010815417394042015, 0.03209736943244934, 0.049104005098342896, 0.006256266497075558, -0.0005710026016458869, -0.0013238390674814582, 0.04605274647474289, -0.04971899092197418, 0.01750335469841957, -0.007988862693309784, -0.015350915491580963, 0.019915979355573654, 0.04205535724759102, 0.04806326702237129, 0.009070995263755322, 0.03207371383905411, 0.03271235153079033, 0.0290224552154541, 0.004222093150019646, 0.009029602631926537, -0.011359441094100475, 0.011684671975672245, 0.02102767862379551, -0.013801631517708302, 0.01104012317955494, 0.009892943315207958, 0.008118954487144947, -0.0338003970682621, -0.0034119714982807636, -0.025781968608498573, 0.01879245415329933, 0.03413154184818268, -0.011483619920909405, -0.040375981479883194, -0.030015887692570686, -0.02288445457816124, 0.018023725599050522, 0.008142608217895031, -0.013612406328320503, -0.022754361853003502, 0.03817623481154442, 0.01356509979814291, 0.015835804864764214, 0.009715544991195202, -0.004414275288581848, -0.037821438163518906, -0.004192526452243328, -0.04986090958118439, 0.028762269765138626, -0.022328604012727737, 0.017728060483932495, 0.025237945839762688, -0.006244440097361803, -0.007923816330730915, 0.02393702045083046, -0.010862723924219608, -0.013021077029407024, -0.019466569647192955, -0.0017961635021492839, 0.03401327505707741, -0.007977035827934742, 0.05175316333770752, 0.01206903625279665, -0.019833194091916084, 0.0270119346678257, 0.03460460528731346, -0.028880534693598747, -0.005543714389204979, -0.007876509800553322, -0.016746453940868378, -0.016841065138578415, -0.04184247925877571, -0.025663703680038452, 0.017113076522946358, -0.012654452584683895, 0.002335751662030816, 0.011229348368942738, 0.02781614288687706, 0.012335134670138359, 0.05974793806672096, 0.01730230264365673, -0.00903551559895277, 0.028194593265652657, 0.021973805502057076, -0.013825285248458385, -0.05615265294909477, -0.02495410665869713, 0.023700488731265068, -0.017314128577709198, 0.015291782096028328, 0.0006774419452995062, -0.04404222592711449, -0.012080863118171692, 0.022210337221622467, 0.0033557952847331762, -0.010827244259417057, -0.0006674632313661277, -0.0241380725055933, 0.03557438775897026, 0.011956683360040188, 0.004739506170153618, 0.03453364595770836, -0.036118410527706146, 0.010708978399634361, -0.02365318313241005, -0.01077402476221323, 0.03841276839375496, 0.009739197790622711, 0.009053255431354046, 0.023724142462015152, -0.01239426713436842, -0.015173516236245632, 0.005484581459313631, 0.0019735624082386494, 0.012240521609783173, -0.025545436888933182, 0.010856810957193375, 0.04886747524142265, -0.00980424415320158, 0.0144757479429245, 0.000015014226846687961, 0.009821983985602856, 0.008118954487144947, 0.013825285248458385, 0.0073443129658699036, 0.008893596939742565, -0.031198548153042793, 0.028809575363993645, 0.02781614288687706, 0.04695156589150429, 0.0012048339704051614, -0.03517228364944458, 0.005910338833928108, 0.02215120568871498, 0.01596589758992195, -0.050996262580156326, 0.027958061546087265, 0.007988862693309784, -0.03682800382375717, -0.019466569647192955, -0.05000282824039459, 0.0212642103433609, -0.02724846638739109, 0.008260874077677727, 0.013233955018222332, 0.010159041732549667, -0.027508651837706566, 0.016569053754210472, 0.030820095911622047, -0.012033556587994099, -0.00146280147600919, -0.02793440781533718, 0.0032020495273172855, 0.009295701049268246, 0.020117031410336494, -0.012057209387421608, 0.005180046893656254, -0.029732050374150276, -0.007226047106087208, 0.01710125058889389, 0.0346992202103138, 0.007084127981215715, 0.04664407670497894, -0.009177434258162975, 0.03876756504178047, -0.009490839205682278, 0.03514862805604935, -0.01847313530743122, -0.0079652089625597, -0.04560333490371704, -0.003488844493404031, 0.003979647997766733, -0.006841682828962803, 0.00267428788356483, -0.0043344455771148205, -0.020034246146678925, 0.008420532569289207, -0.06646544486284256, -0.03758490830659866, 0.009076908230781555, 0.006977688986808062, 0.02999223582446575, -0.013032902963459492, 0.02062557451426983, -0.035077668726444244, 0.028998801484704018, -0.0118443313986063, -0.03089105524122715, -0.022659748792648315, 0.009946162812411785, -0.041416723281145096, 0.004369925241917372, 0.07611594349145889, 0.0009224741370417178, 0.04468085989356041, -0.016486268490552902, -0.0212642103433609, -0.00992842298001051, 0.0006253310129977763, 0.02592388726770878, -0.00774050410836935, -0.012808198109269142, -0.059416793286800385, -0.027437690645456314, -0.017609793692827225, 0.010868636891245842, 0.007379793096333742, -0.008237220346927643, 0.014239215292036533, 0.03486479073762894, 0.004290095996111631, 0.00445566838607192, 0.018910719081759453, -0.013529620133340359, -0.04565064236521721, 0.01860322803258896, -0.022068418562412262, 0.020306257531046867, 0.002640286460518837, 0.004633067175745964, -0.008662978187203407, -0.006037474609911442, -0.01726682297885418, 0.02154804952442646, 0.033729437738657, -0.034297116100788116, 0.034391727298498154, 0.008899509906768799, -0.030583564192056656, -0.01568206027150154, 0.005049954634159803, 0.0006748548476025462, -0.03197910264134407, -0.01089820358902216, 0.0029773442074656487, -0.06547200679779053, 0.00018543725309427828, 0.03169526532292366, -0.02935359999537468, 0.012524359859526157, -0.007911989465355873, 0.03916966915130615, -0.002041565254330635, 0.01427469588816166, 0.026799054816365242, 0.010886376723647118, -0.0056767635978758335, -0.01718403771519661, 0.0007099650683812797, -0.016368001699447632, -0.0037874658592045307, -0.023357518017292023, -0.03306714817881584, -0.01924186386168003, 0.03233389928936958, -0.008059822022914886, -0.02809998020529747, 0.029850315302610397, -0.010726718232035637, -0.00012501075980253518, 0.019738581031560898, 0.0051918732933700085, -0.008243134245276451, -0.007876509800553322, 0.006362705957144499, -0.005505278240889311, -0.0010156085481867194, 0.016143297776579857, -0.01124117523431778, -0.021323343738913536, -0.026515217497944832, 0.0338003970682621, -0.01608416438102722, 0.0024126246571540833, -0.020838454365730286, -0.024481043219566345, -0.005839379504323006, -0.012382441200315952, -0.004893252160400152, 0.023392997682094574, 0.031151240691542625, -0.0011516143567860126, 0.0000034012998639809666, 0.025166986510157585, -0.04468085989356041, -0.029448211193084717, 0.020223470404744148, 0.03020511381328106, -0.004636023659259081, 0.0036071103531867266, -0.004908035509288311, 0.018910719081759453, 0.0169356781989336, -0.02575831487774849, 0.0031340466812253, 0.0043462724424898624, -0.02086210623383522, -0.009094648994505405, 0.02639695070683956, 0.03557438775897026, -0.01000529620796442, 0.02672809548676014, -0.002232269151136279, -0.030583564192056656, 0.04915131255984306, -0.0338713563978672, 0.016923852264881134, 0.013174822553992271, 0.03493575006723404, 0.0023845364339649677, 0.015208995901048183, -0.03167160972952843, 0.0017252039397135377, 0.03675704449415207, 0.0030128241050988436, 0.00004434971560840495, -0.012104515917599201, -0.03216832876205444, -0.008272700943052769, 0.055490367114543915, -0.04314340278506279, 0.02417355217039585, -0.038057971745729446, 0.02935359999537468, 0.00766363088041544, 0.01209268905222416, 0.025852927938103676, 0.004437928553670645, -0.00933709368109703, 0.015138036571443081, 0.001762162079103291, -0.02183188684284687, 0.009413966909050941, 0.046762339770793915, 0.002779248869046569, -0.008461926132440567, 0.04806326702237129, -0.023463957011699677, 0.005366315599530935, 0.01867418736219406, 0.01843765564262867, -0.0060079083777964115, 0.01904081180691719, -0.01710125058889389, 0.00016769736248534173, 0.01661636121571064, -0.011371267028152943, -0.019679447636008263, 0.020708361640572548, -0.02348761074244976, 0.006433665752410889, 0.0061616539023816586, 0.002649156376719475, -0.02866765670478344, -0.018212949857115746, 0.015977725386619568, -0.00843235943466425, 0.019963284954428673, 0.01762162148952484, 0.0217491015791893, 0.013387701474130154, 0.02069653384387493, 0.010643932037055492, -0.02530890516936779, -0.010354180820286274, -0.0014598448760807514, 0.036733392626047134, -0.013612406328320503, -0.003264139173552394, 0.01097507681697607, -0.025545436888933182, 0.000773902575019747, -0.01848496124148369, 0.020850280299782753, -0.025214292109012604, -0.0028413385152816772, 0.03231024742126465, 0.01319847535341978, -0.03152969107031822, -0.010578885674476624, -0.014404787681996822, -0.013588753528892994, 0.025332558900117874, 0.017113076522946358, -0.013068383559584618, -0.02195015363395214, 0.03940620273351669, 0.0005473493947647512, -0.023061852902173996, -0.002510193968191743, 0.024362778291106224, -0.02138247713446617, -0.0015167603269219398, -0.030228767544031143, -0.009999383240938187, -0.03323272243142128, -0.010058515705168247, -0.009153781458735466, -0.03413154184818268, -0.013576926663517952, -0.019986938685178757, 0.0079652089625597, 0.049435149878263474, -0.047968652099370956, -0.02336934395134449, -0.0251433327794075, -0.005543714389204979, -0.045461416244506836, 0.0039116451516747475, -0.013210302218794823, -0.010543406009674072, -0.009171521291136742, -0.014085469767451286, 0.010720805265009403, -0.008597931824624538, -0.0022544439416378736, 0.017396915704011917, 0.023546742275357246, 0.004840032197535038, 0.0033173589035868645, 0.02049548178911209, 0.0010902638314291835, -0.008325920440256596, 0.017574314028024673, -0.020519135519862175, 0.01127665489912033, -0.007687284145504236, 0.011152475140988827, -0.020802974700927734, 0.01467679999768734, 0.013990857638418674, 0.01550466101616621, 0.0070309084840118885, -0.000987520324997604, 0.03077279031276703, 0.028407471254467964, 0.016793759539723396, -0.003199092810973525, -0.03065452352166176, 0.022127551957964897, -0.0022795754484832287, 0.013848938047885895, -0.03126950562000275, -0.010484272614121437, -0.016261562705039978, 0.002581153530627489, -0.009904770180583, -0.02131151780486107, -0.012808198109269142, -0.019797714427113533, 0.009047342464327812, 0.03498305752873421, 0.01848496124148369, 0.015374568291008472, -0.018910719081759453, 0.0002278466708958149, -0.030110500752925873, 0.03668608516454697, -0.008349573239684105, 0.003488844493404031, -0.01507890410721302, -0.03221563249826431, -0.029211679473519325, 0.0232037715613842, -0.012382441200315952, -0.030701830983161926, 0.002760030794888735, -0.0014206692576408386, 0.013115689158439636, -0.015800325199961662, -0.007882422767579556, 0.008237220346927643, -0.000474172382382676, -0.022931760177016258, -0.007249700371176004, -0.052462756633758545, -0.00408313050866127, -0.016722800210118294, 0.0212642103433609, -0.019336476922035217, 0.024835841730237007, -0.015067077241837978, 0.01334039494395256, 0.031718917191028595, -0.015019770711660385, -0.008988209068775177, 0.0251433327794075, -0.016675492748618126, 0.0031813529785722494, -0.01194485742598772, -0.0482051856815815, 0.029779355973005295, -0.010756284929811954, -0.049387846142053604, -0.018082857131958008, -0.0003363186842761934, -0.0015936332056298852, -0.02495410665869713, -0.0027230726554989815, -0.000853732053656131, -0.038838524371385574, 0.01319847535341978, -0.01114064920693636, -0.006729330401867628, 0.02627868577837944, 0.024599310010671616, 0.014594013802707195, 0.030630871653556824, 0.007935642264783382, -0.015776673331856728, -0.011205694638192654, -0.023948846384882927, -0.0007044213125482202, 0.025971194729208946, 0.03928793594241142, 0.022789841517806053, 0.006214873865246773, -0.0043344455771148205, 0.002239660592749715, -0.010643932037055492, -0.03065452352166176, 0.009396227076649666, -0.02199745923280716, 0.003819989040493965, 0.021725447848439217, 0.025829274207353592, 0.0019277343526482582, -0.0033528385683894157, 0.008379139937460423, 0.0031074369326233864, -0.02604215405881405, -0.006516451481729746, 0.01556379348039627, 0.009993469342589378, -0.0017089424654841423, -0.013068383559584618, 0.017657101154327393, -0.015339088626205921, 0.0036721564829349518, 0.024433737620711327, -0.01490150485187769, 0.013860764913260937, 0.01023000106215477, -0.02862035110592842, -0.0041747866198420525, 0.0018360782414674759, 0.0032700523734092712, 0.013151169754564762, -0.010945510119199753, -0.03396597132086754, -0.03003954142332077, -0.001132396049797535, -0.011572319082915783, -0.013884417712688446, 0.03164795786142349, -0.020105205476284027, -0.014759586192667484, -0.006729330401867628, 0.03335098549723625, -0.00037493990384973586, 0.003568673972040415, 0.03723010793328285, 0.00035830875276587903, -0.007693197578191757, 0.0270828939974308, 0.009183348156511784, 0.029968582093715668, -0.013872591778635979, -0.0028073370922356844, -0.00853288546204567, 0.03339829295873642, -0.008781244046986103, -0.009597279131412506, 0.0051977867260575294, -0.02089758589863777, 0.0317898765206337, -0.030299726873636246, -0.021122291684150696, 0.033492907881736755, 0.0008980817510746419, 0.03259408473968506, 0.019797714427113533, 0.02082662656903267, -0.021477090194821358, 0.01726682297885418, -0.0018774713389575481, -0.007149174343794584, 0.004526627715677023, -0.0032818790059536695, 0.010927770286798477, -0.02575831487774849, -0.02438643015921116, 0.0023638398852199316, 0.004263486247509718, -0.024764882400631905, -0.026089459657669067, -0.012134082615375519, 0.0063272262923419476, 0.012618972919881344, 0.027745183557271957, 0.013742499053478241, 0.06594507396221161, -0.016959331929683685, -0.03358751907944679, -0.004834119230508804, 0.005236223340034485, 0.00302317226305604, -0.03427346050739288, 0.010348266921937466, 0.033256374299526215, -0.0013171866303309798, 0.03169526532292366, -0.009455359540879726, 0.011974423192441463, -0.017160383984446526, -0.009218827821314335, -0.0082076545804739, 0.04697522148489952, -0.043001484125852585, 0.011927117593586445, 0.010395573452115059, -0.00629765959456563, 0.004754289519041777, 0.0012321829563006759, 0.013671539723873138, -0.02599484659731388, -0.008787157014012337, 0.024599310010671616, -0.022139377892017365, 0.002754117362201214, 0.04110923036932945, -0.0034119714982807636, 0.03219198063015938, 0.04886747524142265, -0.002276618732139468, -0.009065082296729088, 0.05534844473004341, -0.0047749863006174564, 0.045224882662296295, -0.027390385046601295, -0.005434318445622921, 0.011921203695237637, 0.003453364595770836, 0.03521958738565445, -0.0006571149569936097, 0.02199745923280716, 0.036449555307626724, 0.0019026028458029032, 0.004612370394170284, -0.004210266284644604, -0.024930454790592194, -0.013446833938360214, 0.033824048936367035, -0.021205078810453415, 0.0023047069553285837, 0.02381875365972519, 0.007462578825652599, -0.03607110306620598, -0.046715036034584045, -0.027319425716996193, -0.005679720547050238, 0.01396720390766859, -0.01319847535341978, -0.017657101154327393, -0.016675492748618126, 0.023594049736857414, 0.02385423518717289, -0.03630763292312622, -0.004937601741403341, 0.024977760389447212, -0.0018892979715019464, -0.023014545440673828, -0.003308488754555583, -0.0029832576401531696, 0.014487573876976967, -0.00485185906291008, -0.017964592203497887, 0.031718917191028595, -0.036118410527706146, -0.016474440693855286, -0.007894249632954597, -0.01848496124148369, 0.016959331929683685, -0.008343660272657871, 0.019017158076167107, 0.025640049949288368, -0.010484272614121437, -0.013127516023814678, -0.003837728872895241, 0.018851585686206818, 0.05080703645944595, 0.009857463650405407, 0.015634752810001373, -0.027059240266680717, -0.04354550689458847, 0.017527008429169655, 0.03136412054300308, 0.0022795754484832287, -0.008728024549782276, 0.037017229944467545, 0.020471829921007156, -0.00609660753980279, -0.0027393342461436987, 0.015469181351363659, 0.01490150485187769, -0.026538871228694916, 0.002006085589528084, 0.022009285166859627 ]
13.173739
7.625311
2024-07-01
5
2024MNRAS.531.3222K
[ "such large offsets", "galaxy models", "offsets", "galaxies", "co-spatial emission", "ultraviolet emission", "INvestigate C", "spectral energy distribution fitting codes", "ALMA", "stellar activity" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
40
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1371", "10.48550/arXiv.2402.07982" ]
[ "Killi, Meghana", "Ginolfi, Michele", "Popping, Gergö", "Watson, Darach", "Zamorani, Giovanni", "Lemaux, Brian C.", "Fujimoto, Seiji", "Faisst, Andreas", "Bethermin, Matthieu", "Romano, Michael", "Fudamoto, Yoshinobu", "Bardelli, Sandro", "Boquien, Médéric", "Carniani, Stefano", "Dessauges-Zavadsky, Miroslava", "Gruppioni, Carlotta", "Hathi, Nimish", "Ibar, Eduardo", "Jones, Gareth C.", "Koekemoer, Anton M.", "Langan, Ivanna", "Méndez-Hernández, Hugo", "Sugahara, Yuma", "Vallini, Livia", "Vergani, Daniela" ]
[ "Cosmic Dawn Center (DAWN); Niels Bohr Institute, University of Copenhagen, Jagtvej 128, DK-2200, Copenhagen N, Denmark; European Southern Observatory, Karl-Schwarzschild-Straße 2, D-85748 Garching bei München, Germany; Facultad de Ingeniería y Ciencias, Instituto de Estudios Astrofísicos, Universidad Diego Portales, Av. Ejército 441, Santiago 8370191, Chile", "Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia, Università di Firenze, Via G. Sansone 1, I-50019 Sesto Fiorentino (Firenze), Italy; INAF - Osservatorio Astrofisico di Arcetri, Largo E. Fermi 5, I-50125 Firenze, Italy", "European Southern Observatory, Karl-Schwarzschild-Straße 2, D-85748 Garching bei München, Germany", "Cosmic Dawn Center (DAWN); Niels Bohr Institute, University of Copenhagen, Jagtvej 128, DK-2200, Copenhagen N, Denmark", "INAF - Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio, Via P. Gobetti 93/3, I-40129 Bologna, Italy", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California, Davis, One Shields Ave., Davis, CA 95616, USA; Gemini Observatory, NSF's NOIRLab, 670 N. A'ohoku Place, Hilo, HI 96720, USA", "Department of Astronomy, The University of Texas at Austin, 2515 Speedway Blvd Stop C1400, Austin, TX 78712, USA", "IPAC, California Institute of Technology, 1200 East California Boulevard, Pasadena, CA 91125, USA", "Aix Marseille Univ, CNRS, CNES, LAM, UMR 7326, F-13388, Marseille, France; Université de Strasbourg, CNRS, Observatoire astronomique de Strasbourg, UMR 7550, F-67000 Strasbourg, France", "National Centre for Nuclear Research, ul. Pasteura 7, PL-02-093 Warsaw, Poland; INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova, Vicolo dell'Osservatorio 5, I-35122 Padova, Italy", "National Astronomical Observatory of Japan, 2-21-1 Osawa, Mitaka, Tokyo 181-8588, Japan; Faculty of Science and Engineering, Waseda Research Institute for Science and Engineering, Waseda University, 3-4-1, Okubo, Shinjuku, Tokyo 169-8555, Japan", "INAF - Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio, Via P. Gobetti 93/3, I-40129 Bologna, Italy", "Université Côte d'Azur, Observatoire de la Côte d'Azur, CNRS, Laboratoire Lagrange, F-06000 Nice, France", "Scuola Normale Superiore, Piazza dei Cavalieri 7, I-56126 Pisa, Italy", "Department of Astronomy, University of Geneva, Chemin Pegasi 51, CH-1290 Versoix, Switzerland", "Istituto Nazionale di Astrofisica: Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio di Bologna, Via Gobetti 93/3, I-40129 Bologna, Italy", "Space Telescope Science Institute, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA", "Instituto de Física y Astronomía, Universidad de Valparaíso, Avda. Gran Bretaña 1111, Valparaíso, Chile", "Department of Physics, University of Oxford, Denys Wilkinson Building, Keble Road, Oxford OX1 3RH, UK", "Space Telescope Science Institute, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA", "European Southern Observatory, Karl-Schwarzschild-Straße 2, D-85748 Garching bei München, Germany; Univ Lyon, Univ Lyon1, Ens de Lyon, CNRS, Centre de Recherche Astrophysique de Lyon (CRAL), UMR5574, F-69230 Saint-Genis-Laval, France", "Instituto Multidisciplinario de Investigación y Postgrado, Universidad de La Serena, Raúl Bitrán 1305, La Serena, Chile; Departamento de Astronomía, Universidad de La Serena, Av. Juan Cisternas 1200 N, La Serena, Chile", "National Astronomical Observatory of Japan, 2-21-1 Osawa, Mitaka, Tokyo 181-8588, Japan; Faculty of Science and Engineering, Waseda Research Institute for Science and Engineering, Waseda University, 3-4-1, Okubo, Shinjuku, Tokyo 169-8555, Japan", "INAF - Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio, Via P. Gobetti 93/3, I-40129 Bologna, Italy", "Istituto Nazionale di Astrofisica: Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio di Bologna, Via Gobetti 93/3, I-40129 Bologna, Italy" ]
[ "2024ApJ...969L..28L", "2024MNRAS.tmp.1581B", "2024arXiv240512955J", "2024arXiv240518476C", "2024arXiv240603544G" ]
[ "1998ARA&A..36..189K", "1999MNRAS.310..540A", "1999RvMP...71..173H", "2000ApJ...533..682C", "2000ApJ...539..718C", "2003MNRAS.344.1000B", "2004AJ....128..163L", "2004ApJ...600L..93G", "2005ApJ...631..101P", "2005MNRAS.360.1413B", "2006A&A...457..841I", "2006ARA&A..44..415F", "2007ApJ...660L..43N", "2007ApJS..172....1S", "2007ApJS..172...38S", "2007ApJS..172..196K", "2008MNRAS.388.1595D", "2009A&A...507.1793N", "2009ApJ...695..292C", "2010ApJ...709..780Y", "2010ApJS..189..270C", "2011ApJS..197...36K", "2011ascl.soft08009A", "2012A&A...544A.156M", "2012ARA&A..50..531K", "2012ApJ...753..114W", "2012ApJ...757..120G", "2012ApJ...760...11H", "2013ARA&A..51..105C", "2013ApJ...778..102O", "2013MNRAS.433.1567V", "2014A&A...568A..62D", "2014ApJ...796...95C", "2014ApJS..214...15S", "2015A&A...574A..14C", "2015ApJ...799..209W", "2015ApJ...807..180W", "2015MNRAS.451.3021D", "2015MNRAS.452...54M", "2015PASJ...67...93H", "2016A&A...593A..22R", "2016ApJ...829L..11P", "2016ApJ...833..103H", "2016ApJ...833..254S", "2017A&A...605A..42C", "2017ApJ...837L..21L", "2017ApJ...847...21F", "2017MNRAS.467.1300V", "2017MNRAS.468.4831K", "2017MNRAS.468L..31D", "2017MNRAS.472.2315P", "2018A&A...609A.130L", "2018A&A...616A..14G", "2018A&A...616A.110E", "2018ApJ...856..121G", "2018ApJ...863...56C", "2018ApJ...866...70L", "2018MNRAS.474.1718N", "2018MNRAS.476.1532S", "2018MNRAS.477..552B", "2018MNRAS.478.1170C", "2018MNRAS.480.3993B", "2018MNRAS.481.1631B", "2018MNRAS.481.1976Z", "2018PhR...780....1D", "2019A&A...622A.103B", "2019A&A...630A..59B", "2019ApJ...881..124M", "2019ApJ...884..133F", "2019MNRAS.487.1689P", "2019MNRAS.487.3007K", "2019MNRAS.487.5902K", "2019MNRAS.488.2629A", "2019MNRAS.490.1076E", "2019Natur.572..211W", "2020A&A...633A..90G", "2020A&A...643A...1L", "2020A&A...643A...2B", "2020A&A...643A...3S", "2020A&A...643A...4F", "2020A&A...643A...6C", "2020A&A...643A...8G", "2020ARA&A..58..661F", "2020ApJ...900....1F", "2020ApJS..247...61F", "2020MNRAS.494.1071G", "2020MNRAS.496..875R", "2020MNRAS.497..956S", "2020MNRAS.497.5292T", "2020NatMe..17..261V", "2021A&A...649A..31H", "2021A&A...653A..84P", "2021A&A...653A.111R", "2021ApJ...909...23T", "2021MNRAS.503.2622C", "2021MNRAS.507.3540J", "2021Natur.597..489F", "2022A&A...660A..14R", "2022A&A...661A..80J", "2022A&A...663A..50B", "2022A&A...667A...5R", "2022ARA&A..60..121R", "2022ARA&A..60..247W", "2022ApJ...928...31S", "2022ApJ...935..167A", "2022ApJ...935..177S", "2022MNRAS.510.5088B", "2022MNRAS.511.4464A", "2022MNRAS.512...58F", "2022MNRAS.513.5621P", "2022MNRAS.515.3126I", "2022MNRAS.517.5930S", "2022Natur.604..261F", "2023A&A...677A..44R", "2023ApJ...944..141P", "2023ApJ...946L..13F", "2023MNRAS.518.5607C", "2023MNRAS.519.1526P", "2023MNRAS.519.4608P", "2023MNRAS.519.5076B", "2023MNRAS.525.1535H", "2023arXiv230602465E", "2023arXiv231117671M", "2024ApJ...964..146F", "2024MNRAS.527.6867A", "2024arXiv240303379P" ]
29184197
2404.19544
Extinction and AGN over host galaxy contrast effects on the optical spectroscopic classification of AGN
The optical spectroscopic classification of active galactic nuclei (AGN) into type 1 and type 2 can be understood in the frame of the AGN unification models. However, it remains unclear which physical properties are driving the classification into intermediate sub-types (1.0, 1.2, 1.5, 1.8, 1.9). To shed light on this issue, we present an analysis of the effect of extinction and AGN and host galaxy luminosities on sub-type determination for a sample of 159 X-ray selected AGN with a complete and robust optical spectroscopic classification. The sample spans a rest-frame 2-10 keV X-ray luminosity range of 10<SUP>42</SUP>-10<SUP>46</SUP> erg s<SUP>−1</SUP> and redshifts between 0.05 and 0.75. From the fitting of their ultraviolet-to-mid-infrared spectral energy distributions, we extracted the observed AGN over total AGN+galaxy contrast, optical/ultraviolet line-of-sight extinction, as well as host galaxy and AGN luminosities. The observed contrast exhibits a clear decline with sub-type, distinguishing two main groups: 1.0-5 and 1.8-2. This difference is partly driven by an increase in extinction following the same trend. Nevertheless, 50% of 1.9s and 2s lack sufficient extinction to explain the lack of detection of broad emission lines, unveiling the necessity of an additional effect. Our findings show that 1.8-2s preferentially live in host galaxies with higher luminosities while displaying similar intrinsic AGN luminosities to 1.0-5s. Consequently, the AGN to host galaxy luminosity ratio diminishes, hindering the detection of the emission of the broad emission lines, resulting in the 1.8-2 classification of those with insufficient extinction. Thus, the combination of increasing extinction and decreasing AGN over galaxy luminosity ratio, mainly driven by an increasing host galaxy luminosity, constitutes the main reasons behind the sub-type classification into 1.0-5 and 1.8-2. <P />The optical and NIR fitting results of the BUXS sample will be made publicly available in Mateos et al. (in prep.). The other data products underlying this article will be shared upon a reasonable request to Silvia Mateos.
[ -0.05514926463365555, 0.018300175666809082, -0.01532713696360588, -0.04335187003016472, -0.01234225369989872, 0.029801450669765472, -0.009203389286994934, -0.028285318985581398, 0.006336953956633806, 0.004711258690804243, -0.03754793107509613, -0.011613800190389156, -0.01917668804526329, 0.023654012009501457, 0.0164050105959177, 0.032762642949819565, 0.012851579114794731, 0.014545382000505924, -0.006325108930468559, 0.022694585844874382, -0.034942083060741425, -0.011394672095775604, -0.004237467888742685, -0.013503042049705982, -0.08656160533428192, -0.04581558331847191, -0.020124269649386406, 0.031886130571365356, 0.017672402784228325, 0.00933960359543562, 0.018406778573989868, -0.022540604695677757, 0.025016162544488907, -0.016819577664136887, -0.04377828165888786, 0.04240429028868675, 0.010168737731873989, -0.003455712692812085, 0.015433739870786667, -0.04183574020862579, 0.010642528533935547, -0.03996426612138748, -0.032217785716056824, -0.04103029519319534, -0.025916364043951035, -0.007166088093072176, -0.014012367464601994, -0.06874706596136093, -0.03804541379213333, -0.036647729575634, -0.05567043647170067, 0.018513381481170654, 0.002814614214003086, -0.004773443564772606, -0.027622012421488762, 0.006061562802642584, -0.018454156816005707, 0.015682479366660118, -0.002564393449574709, -0.024021200835704803, -0.03297584876418114, 0.005294613540172577, 0.04799502342939377, 0.01286342367529869, -0.009760092943906784, -0.03122282214462757, -0.017992211505770683, -0.0035415873862802982, -0.0008639281732030213, -0.01617996022105217, 0.028853869065642357, -0.04408624768257141, -0.015066551975905895, 0.0027168949600309134, 0.014474312774837017, 0.031933508813381195, -0.0013014444848522544, 0.011211077682673931, 0.02168777957558632, -0.0001812805567169562, 0.0033461484126746655, 0.07917046546936035, -0.019034551456570625, 0.0004963700193911791, 0.016630062833428383, 0.014569071121513844, 0.012294874526560307, -0.04114874452352524, -0.09845376014709473, -0.00917377695441246, 0.01317138783633709, 0.013254301622509956, -0.0537278912961483, -0.010701753199100494, 0.011986910365521908, -0.020704664289951324, 0.01976892724633217, -0.04851619154214859, 0.06121378764510155, 0.011228845454752445, 0.004302613902837038, 0.06021882966160774, 0.01859629526734352, -0.08798297494649887, 0.013396439142525196, -0.03316536545753479, -0.022303707897663116, 0.016653751954436302, -0.0000371999922208488, -0.03735841438174248, 0.06760996580123901, 0.021794382482767105, 0.022576138377189636, 0.08528237044811249, -0.06415129452943802, -0.021012628450989723, -0.07457469403743744, 0.0334259495139122, -0.0011704117059707642, 0.01672481931746006, 0.016665596514940262, -0.0013688115868717432, 0.021048162132501602, -0.00864668469876051, 0.01946096308529377, -0.002222375711426139, 0.021770693361759186, -0.0482792966067791, -0.06396177411079407, -0.010553693398833275, 0.07462207227945328, -0.03667141869664192, -0.0052205841057002544, 0.022362932562828064, -0.03529742360115051, 0.0004134566115681082, 0.014059745706617832, -0.043967798352241516, -0.07533276081085205, 0.026129569858312607, -0.028996005654335022, -0.021486418321728706, -0.004569121170789003, 0.028403766453266144, -0.007853085175156593, 0.0074266730807721615, -0.020444078370928764, -0.0048652407713234425, -0.04626568406820297, 0.03269157558679581, -0.01645239070057869, 0.016665596514940262, 0.012602838687598705, -0.052259139716625214, -0.013503042049705982, -0.02083495631814003, 0.012898958288133144, 0.053017206490039825, -0.009019794873893261, -0.0361502505838871, 0.03977474942803383, 0.00836240965873003, -0.020147960633039474, 0.0035238200798630714, 0.0007595461211167276, 0.03179137036204338, -0.03368653729557991, -0.01890425942838192, -0.05169059336185455, 0.0033639157190918922, -0.02278934419155121, 0.02769307978451252, -0.001344381831586361, -0.02956455387175083, -0.008978337980806828, 0.028711730614304543, -0.010476701892912388, -0.03761900216341019, -0.011323603801429272, 0.01970970258116722, 0.0153508260846138, 0.028380077332258224, 0.026508603245019913, -0.03747686371207237, -0.0007721311994828284, -0.02657967247068882, -0.04031961038708687, 0.02385537326335907, 0.04195418953895569, -0.03176768124103546, 0.010879424400627613, 0.010695830918848515, 0.008913191966712475, 0.08424002677202225, -0.024850334972143173, -0.027977354824543, 0.007628034334629774, 0.029114453122019768, -0.03401818871498108, 0.024874024093151093, 0.0233342032879591, 0.02795366570353508, 0.06822589784860611, -0.0361502505838871, -0.02300255000591278, -0.01233040913939476, 0.0318150632083416, -0.008818433620035648, -0.00013038504403084517, 0.013431972824037075, 0.02004135586321354, -0.012792355380952358, -0.04268856346607208, 0.03612655773758888, -0.028877558186650276, -0.025087229907512665, -0.05846580117940903, 0.046502579003572464, 0.04690530151128769, 0.022327398881316185, -0.009594266302883625, -0.020136114209890366, 0.008569693192839622, 0.014426934532821178, 0.028901247307658195, 0.0015842384891584516, 0.0159075316041708, -0.02031378634274006, 0.04498644918203354, -0.03406556695699692, -0.010079902596771717, 0.03984581679105759, -0.03745317459106445, -0.0406038835644722, -0.021877296268939972, -0.02603481151163578, 0.050600871443748474, 0.03254943713545799, -0.018229106441140175, -0.07334283739328384, -0.04714220017194748, 0.030867479741573334, -0.01646423526108265, 0.002977479947730899, -0.010855735279619694, -0.0018537070136517286, 0.006354720797389746, -0.03432615473866463, 0.01533898152410984, -0.00533607043325901, 0.01785007305443287, -0.007894541136920452, -0.007130553480237722, -0.0022490264382213354, -0.030559515580534935, -0.01532713696360588, 0.0052620405331254005, 0.019614944234490395, -0.014924414455890656, -0.0017485846765339375, -0.04602878913283348, -0.023192066699266434, 0.016014134511351585, 0.006970649119466543, -0.053585756570100784, 0.013893919065594673, 0.0035386260133236647, 0.008723675273358822, -0.015232378616929054, -0.010393789038062096, -0.04410993680357933, -0.013052940368652344, 0.014344020746648312, -0.05728132650256157, -0.04164622351527214, 0.014580916613340378, 0.02059806138277054, 0.028143182396888733, -0.03150709718465805, -0.0422147735953331, 0.009238922968506813, -0.013870229944586754, 0.05188010632991791, 0.02738511562347412, -0.042072635143995285, -0.008297263644635677, -0.03818754851818085, -0.007888618856668472, 0.013953142799437046, -0.03399449959397316, 0.08082873374223709, -0.019330671057105064, 0.003206972498446703, -0.016322098672389984, -0.06699404120445251, -0.03366284444928169, 0.029256589710712433, 0.004424022976309061, -0.005812822375446558, 0.025110919028520584, 0.03913513198494911, 0.03224147483706474, 0.038542892783880234, -0.0030381844844669104, -0.004714219830930233, 0.020704664289951324, 0.043991487473249435, 0.07163719087839127, -0.008990183472633362, 0.019366204738616943, 0.03141234070062637, -0.021202145144343376, 0.0018581488402560353, 0.011163699440658092, -0.05169059336185455, -0.013763627037405968, -0.013763627037405968, 0.014249262399971485, -0.004030184354633093, -0.01697356067597866, 0.007201622240245342, -0.01785007305443287, -0.004281885456293821, 0.017743470147252083, -0.025632089003920555, -0.02847483567893505, -0.027906285598874092, 0.01780269481241703, 0.016369476914405823, 0.0014643101021647453, 0.04024853929877281, -0.007556965574622154, 0.08428740501403809, 0.027740459889173508, 0.01066621858626604, -0.024471301585435867, 0.022114191204309464, 0.04574451595544815, -0.01833570934832096, -0.030346309766173363, -0.03809279203414917, -0.01564694568514824, -0.03148340806365013, 0.008551926352083683, -0.018821345642209053, -0.0026917248032987118, 0.013088474981486797, 0.03477625548839569, 0.04304390773177147, 0.026248017325997353, 0.02792997658252716, -0.01249623578041792, 0.019342515617609024, 0.042048946022987366, 0.03678986802697182, -0.01587199606001377, 0.0399879552423954, -0.020349320024251938, -0.005570004694163799, 0.032762642949819565, -0.00781755056232214, -0.003657073713839054, 0.02243400178849697, 0.0037903275806456804, 0.0015916414558887482, -0.02246953547000885, -0.0015102085890248418, 0.023961976170539856, -0.0199939776211977, -0.06704141944646835, 0.0014480235986411572, 0.007379293907433748, 0.0031595933251082897, -0.024826645851135254, -0.04254642501473427, 0.004228584002703428, 0.0216048676520586, -0.03655296936631203, 0.0016775160329416394, 0.0059727272018790245, 0.020100580528378487, -0.0007117968634702265, 0.034942083060741425, -0.05022183805704117, -0.026674430817365646, -0.00864076241850853, 0.0033579932060092688, -0.009434361942112446, -0.076754130423069, 0.017186766490340233, -0.00903163943439722, 0.021498264744877815, 0.0010334565304219723, -0.004980727098882198, 0.012401477433741093, 0.01029903069138527, 0.011234767735004425, 0.07045271247625351, 0.05093252658843994, 0.06869968771934509, -0.015386360697448254, -0.017352594062685966, -0.05268555134534836, -0.016618216410279274, -0.04136195033788681, -0.021261367946863174, -0.010938648134469986, 0.027882596477866173, 0.017447350546717644, -0.0034172171726822853, 0.03967999294400215, 0.0007543640094809234, 0.01593122072517872, -0.02415149286389351, -0.015031017363071442, 0.029540864750742912, -0.025845296680927277, 0.036292385309934616, -0.019686013460159302, 0.04143301770091057, 0.0027257786132395267, -0.038448136299848557, 0.023784305900335312, 0.0051524764858186245, -0.035178977996110916, -0.045389171689748764, 0.018821345642209053, 0.022362932562828064, -0.0059608821757137775, -0.01645239070057869, 0.024826645851135254, 0.04228584095835686, -0.021782537922263145, -0.02823794074356556, -0.025868985801935196, 0.018217261880636215, -0.003013014327734709, -0.03922988846898079, 0.0033313424792140722, 0.009499507956206799, -0.017222300171852112, 0.03344963863492012, -0.04022485017776489, -0.04636044427752495, 0.061545442789793015, 0.0032336232252418995, 0.0005989013588987291, -0.012099436484277248, 0.06244564428925514, -0.06974202394485474, -0.03913513198494911, 0.00773463724181056, -0.03598442301154137, 0.025608399882912636, -0.015765393152832985, -0.02334604784846306, 0.04330449178814888, -0.028688041493296623, 0.018229106441140175, -0.0295882448554039, -0.017589488998055458, -0.04524703323841095, -0.02909076400101185, -0.0034675574861466885, -0.05505450814962387, 0.017411816865205765, 0.0043322257697582245, -0.016807733103632927, 0.027195600792765617, -0.025134610012173653, 0.015552187338471413, -0.03967999294400215, -0.015812773257493973, -0.024874024093151093, 0.009238922968506813, 0.008960571140050888, 0.01723414473235607, 0.011193310841917992, 0.06704141944646835, 0.015220534056425095, -0.0002964894811157137, -0.039324648678302765, -0.021320592612028122, -0.019070085138082504, 0.0521170049905777, 0.0216640904545784, 0.006520547904074192, 0.059034351259469986, -0.04683423414826393, 0.0227182749658823, -0.022860413417220116, -0.03252574801445007, 0.03262050449848175, -0.010488547384738922, 0.02115476503968239, -0.012016522698104382, -0.024874024093151093, -0.020657284185290337, -0.027219289913773537, -0.008166971616446972, 0.01920037716627121, -0.0066034612245857716, 0.021202145144343376, -0.03667141869664192, 0.012129047885537148, 0.0015005847672000527, 0.02634277567267418, -0.015599566511809826, -0.04842143505811691, -0.006147437263280153, -0.03809279203414917, 0.028877558186650276, -0.025632089003920555, -0.01614442653954029, -0.010411555878818035, 0.0013406802900135517, -0.013479351997375488, 0.04188311845064163, 0.010227961465716362, -0.021877296268939972, 0.01247254665941, -0.03311798721551895, -0.010885346680879593, 0.007325992453843355, 0.0065501597709953785, 0.014888879843056202, -0.00766949076205492, -0.09996988624334335, -0.040177471935749054, -0.0003044476907234639, 0.004424022976309061, -0.04278332367539406, 0.005253157112747431, 0.024033045396208763, -0.011613800190389156, -0.037429485470056534, 0.01330168079584837, 0.021036317571997643, -0.02031378634274006, -0.0011452415492385626, 0.006479091010987759, -0.026698119938373566, -0.009961454197764397, -0.002801288850605488, 0.007764249108731747, 0.017080163583159447, -0.010932725854218006, -0.0031181366648525, 0.01813434809446335, 0.027337737381458282, 0.03643452376127243, 0.009724559262394905, 0.04195418953895569, 0.01247254665941, -0.04136195033788681, -0.005570004694163799, 0.0036304229870438576, 0.011181466281414032, -0.006562004331499338, -0.006348798517137766, -0.010168737731873989, -0.015054707415401936, -0.010346409864723682, 0.04197787865996361, 0.011453895829617977, -0.04238060116767883, -0.0026384233497083187, -0.02360663376748562, 0.007231234107166529, 0.0323125422000885, -0.04086446762084961, -0.025868985801935196, 0.0038495513144880533, 0.011821083724498749, -0.01397683285176754, -0.005190971773117781, -0.03375760465860367, 0.008966493420302868, 0.0153508260846138, -0.024329164996743202, -0.022339243441820145, -0.009837084449827671, -0.0067278314381837845, 0.022256329655647278, -0.019911063835024834, -0.0362686961889267, 0.008409788832068443, 0.00014537609240505844, -0.0009364773868583143, 0.023760614916682243, 0.020219027996063232, -0.041006606072187424, -0.001775235403329134, -0.011323603801429272, 0.003402411239221692, -0.00835056509822607, 0.06111903116106987, 0.021533798426389694, -0.013372749090194702, -0.009090864099562168, 0.0433281809091568, 0.007610267028212547, -0.02771677076816559, -0.004077563062310219, -0.01001475565135479, 0.019650479778647423, 0.02546626329421997, -0.024897713214159012, -0.009067174047231674, 0.013905764557421207, 0.002206088975071907, 0.01777900569140911, -0.007651723455637693, -0.0054160226136446, 0.005519664380699396, -0.018714742735028267, -0.007562887854874134, -0.030914857983589172, 0.008557848632335663, -0.012004678137600422, 0.00985485129058361, -0.01563510112464428, 0.0012888594064861536, 0.03896930441260338, 0.029540864750742912, -0.0002394865150563419, -0.026200639083981514, -0.02901969477534294, 0.05041135475039482, -0.018572604283690453, -0.008178816176950932, -0.02629539743065834, 0.0428307019174099, -0.011234767735004425, -0.025845296680927277, -0.03153078630566597, -0.02252875827252865, -0.004190088715404272, -0.012235650792717934, 0.007142398506402969, 0.00850454717874527, 0.022611672058701515, 0.03122282214462757, -0.021829918026924133, -0.01567063480615616, -0.018762120977044106, 0.009694946929812431, -0.03041737899184227, -0.03335488215088844, -0.012152737937867641, -0.01782638393342495, -0.02688763663172722, -0.008984260261058807, 0.006336953956633806, 0.02107185125350952, 0.0040538739413022995, 0.012602838687598705, 0.0031803217716515064, -0.03127020224928856, 0.04003533348441124, -0.017080163583159447, 0.010115436278283596, 0.009552809409797192, 0.002314172685146332, -0.020752042531967163, -0.0018122503533959389, -0.029754070565104485, -0.0008128475747071207, -0.03721627965569496, 0.02299070544540882, 0.06107165291905403, -0.022303707897663116, 0.005270924419164658, 0.021474573761224747, 0.007219389546662569, 0.006177049595862627, 0.023357894271612167, 0.017909297719597816, -0.017613178119063377, 0.0015723936958238482, 0.004080524668097496, 0.0012999639147892594, -0.009819317609071732, -0.011288069188594818, 0.025063540786504745, -0.002835342660546303, 0.008907269686460495, -0.0008276535663753748, 0.0017974444199353456, 0.006869968492537737, 0.014628294855356216, 0.003778482787311077, 0.0009490624652244151, -0.016298407688736916, -0.017684247344732285, 0.004009455908089876, -0.005362721160054207, 0.0010186504805460572, -0.04003533348441124, -0.03430246561765671, 0.019046396017074585, 0.04169360175728798, 0.02987251803278923, -0.02161671221256256, -0.025963744148612022, 0.01866736263036728, -0.009487663395702839, 0.029114453122019768, 0.00004233581057633273, -0.06002931296825409, 0.013858385384082794, 0.03645821288228035, -0.0023911637254059315, 0.0025022083427757025, -0.002380799502134323, -0.0006366565939970315, 0.010358254425227642, 0.0013118087081238627, -0.010168737731873989, -0.033615466207265854, -0.017151232808828354, 0.030298931524157524, -0.023132842034101486, -0.007900464348495007, 0.016558993607759476, -0.022386621683835983, -0.020076891407370567, 0.024826645851135254, -0.03013310395181179, 0.01807512529194355, -0.001092680380679667, -0.008445323444902897, 0.000627772998996079, -0.041788361966609955, -0.008676297031342983, 0.05514926463365555, 0.016926180571317673, -0.030251551419496536, 0.0052650016732513905, 0.031128065660595894, 0.03721627965569496, -0.028166871517896652, 0.005753598641604185, 0.003956154454499483, 0.013787316158413887, 0.02194836549460888, 0.004231545142829418, 0.00037311037885956466, -0.0035386260133236647, 0.01943727396428585, 0.0031299814581871033, 0.008575616404414177, 0.0008024834096431732, -0.02135612629354, 0.015540342777967453, -0.026437534019351006, 0.05448595806956291, -0.013230611570179462, 0.01730521395802498, 0.03209933638572693, 0.0037873664405196905, -0.021510109305381775, 0.015836462378501892, 0.0041634379886090755, -0.014533537440001965, -0.0032691573724150658, -0.03318905457854271, -0.015398205257952213, 0.015007328242063522, 0.005309419706463814, -0.039608921855688095, -0.02252875827252865, -0.01723414473235607, -0.007035795599222183, 0.01247254665941, 0.010251651518046856, -0.007551043294370174, -0.055812571197748184, 0.02299070544540882, 0.01068398542702198, -0.017956675961613655, -0.02274196594953537, -0.006188894156366587, 0.0013636295916512609, -0.010458935052156448, 0.04406255856156349, 0.016570838168263435, 0.02133243717253208, -0.027361426502466202, -0.02627170830965042, -0.014261106960475445, 0.024589749053120613, -0.0025851218961179256, 0.0006344356806948781, 0.00386731862090528, 0.008066290989518166, -0.005294613540172577, -0.09082572162151337, 0.0021942441817373037, 0.004104213789105415, 0.01148943044245243, 0.008836201392114162, 0.0111103979870677, 0.017411816865205765, 0.023120997473597527, 0.020977094769477844, 0.003135903738439083, 0.002903450047597289, -0.024198872968554497, 0.002437062095850706, 0.01970970258116722, 0.016641907393932343, -0.01217642705887556, 0.029161833226680756, -0.0006721909157931805, -0.00624219560995698, 0.0026843217201530933, -0.005759520921856165, 0.014237417839467525, -0.02932765893638134, 0.007876774296164513, 0.004196010995656252, -0.019674168899655342, -0.017210455611348152, -0.0009727520518936217, 0.04247535765171051, 0.018323864787817, -0.021806228905916214, 0.0015649907290935516, -0.032502058893442154, 0.06552528589963913, -0.003387605305761099, -0.005975688342005014, 0.0068936580792069435, 0.013396439142525196, 0.004062757361680269, -0.0022120114881545305, 0.024471301585435867, -0.009908152744174004, -0.004136787261813879, 0.011892152950167656, 0.039372026920318604, 0.008753287605941296, 0.009919998236000538, 0.005567043554037809, 0.025868985801935196, -0.014059745706617832, 0.02411595918238163, -0.0014657906722277403, -0.012294874526560307, 0.023073619231581688, -0.034965772181749344, -0.010701753199100494, -0.005007377825677395, -0.016310252249240875, -0.02196021005511284, -0.00615336000919342, -0.020752042531967163, 0.032478369772434235, 0.019046396017074585, -0.013266146183013916, -0.04797133430838585, -0.032738953828811646, -0.03555801138281822, 0.019224068149924278, 0.012448856607079506, -0.04304390773177147, 0.00933368131518364, 0.024447612464427948, -0.019532032310962677, 0.01920037716627121, 0.025679469108581543, -0.003278041025623679, 0.006496858317404985, 0.014877035282552242, -0.0388745479285717, 0.0175776444375515, 0.02216157130897045, -0.023736925795674324, 0.0021749965380877256, 0.0001626805606065318, 0.015528498217463493, 0.02245769090950489, 0.033568087965250015, 0.030535826459527016, -0.021995743736624718, 0.0027213366702198982, 0.007462207227945328, 0.0020906024146825075, 0.04631306603550911, 0.02496878243982792, -0.013751782476902008, 0.016558993607759476, -0.0013206922449171543, -0.010784666053950787, -0.04005902260541916, 0.007681335788220167, 0.009949609637260437, -0.03018048219382763, -0.009244846180081367, -0.02932765893638134, -0.025087229907512665, -0.029540864750742912, 0.022019434720277786, -0.0067159864120185375, -0.008249884471297264, 0.015718014910817146, 0.0630141943693161, 0.007989299483597279, 0.008125514723360538, 0.04027222841978073, 0.031649235635995865, -0.011738170869648457, 0.029446106404066086, 0.0076576462015509605, -0.005756559781730175, 0.0016819578595459461, 0.014284797012805939, -0.013029251247644424, -0.06111903116106987, -0.012437012046575546, -0.019235912710428238, -0.0009720117086544633, 0.018205417320132256, -0.04022485017776489, -0.036576662212610245, 0.030772721394896507, -0.026200639083981514, 0.028309008106589317, 0.04086446762084961, -0.05401216819882393, 0.014545382000505924, -0.018714742735028267, -0.02188914082944393, 0.018773965537548065, -0.06396177411079407, -0.012437012046575546, 0.0031803217716515064, -0.015019172802567482, 0.031033307313919067, 0.003686685813590884, -0.035178977996110916, -0.008622994646430016, 0.010595150291919708, -0.02738511562347412, 0.02963562309741974, -0.01620364934206009, -0.0012207520194351673, -0.00044491930748336017, -0.010222039185464382, 0.04965329170227051, -0.0017515459330752492, -0.001560548902489245, 0.024850334972143173, 0.008551926352083683, -0.007112786639481783, 0.013479351997375488, 0.057139188051223755, 0.010725442320108414, 0.00609413580968976, 0.013668868690729141, 0.0015753548359498382, 0.028688041493296623, 0.006532392464578152, 0.012981872074306011, -0.007941920310258865, -0.04053281620144844, -0.015540342777967453, -0.028166871517896652, 0.020207183435559273, 0.014225573278963566, 0.01586015149950981, 0.020645439624786377, 0.009973299689590931, 0.01136505976319313, 0.006964726839214563, 0.0035060530062764883, 0.03157816454768181, -0.013491196557879448, -0.021758848801255226, 0.0003305432037450373, 0.038756098598241806, 0.011524965055286884, 0.016108892858028412, 0.022955171763896942, 0.048350363969802856, 0.03889823704957962, -0.03323643282055855, 0.026769187301397324, 0.017174921929836273, 0.006508702877908945, -0.001667151926085353, 0.012721287086606026, -0.019034551456570625, 0.014450623653829098, 0.021865451708436012, 0.008670373819768429, -0.0033787216525524855, -0.05562305822968483, 0.009084940887987614, -0.01328983623534441, 0.01776716113090515, -0.008403866551816463, 0.025347815826535225, -0.017589488998055458, -0.03186244145035744, -0.025845296680927277, 0.010861657559871674, 0.004361837636679411, 0.002237181644886732, 0.01000291109085083, 0.024494990706443787, -0.00766356848180294, 0.028380077332258224, -0.010932725854218006, 0.02137981541454792, -0.012152737937867641, 0.013811006210744381, -0.06059786304831505, -0.03588966280221939, 0.05941338464617729, 0.016665596514940262, 0.011465740390121937, 0.04114874452352524, -0.0032513902988284826, 0.014746743254363537, 0.01178555004298687, 0.0153508260846138, -0.0005222804611548781, -0.002619175473228097, -0.023132842034101486, -0.05041135475039482, 0.006650840397924185, -0.012152737937867641, 0.019378049299120903, 0.0028960471972823143, 0.008018911816179752, 0.04801871255040169, 0.006479091010987759, -0.012816044501960278, -0.024494990706443787, -0.01833570934832096, -0.005546315107494593, 0.017684247344732285, 0.007468129508197308, 0.0035238200798630714, -0.014829656109213829, -0.006040834356099367, -0.04297283664345741, 0.0023200949653983116, 0.002580679953098297, 0.003064835211262107, 0.0049748048186302185, -0.02114292047917843, 0.040461745113134384, 0.023132842034101486, 0.010447090491652489, 0.01591937616467476, -0.01166117936372757, -0.04612354934215546, -0.03750055283308029, 0.017636867240071297, 0.01667744107544422, -0.02852221392095089, 0.00274354568682611, 0.01749473065137863, -0.014569071121513844, -0.03145971894264221, -0.005297575145959854, 0.032454680651426315, 0.0052205841057002544, 0.000026396262910566293, -0.0008298744214698672, -0.016558993607759476, 0.008540081791579723, 0.009718636982142925, 0.014734898693859577, -0.03814017027616501, 0.012010600417852402, -0.01466382946819067, -0.012259340845048428, 0.03176768124103546, 0.021024473011493683, -0.022694585844874382, -0.009256690740585327, 0.00555816013365984, -0.028143182396888733, -0.022824877873063087, 0.031080685555934906, 0.00267247692681849, 0.005652918014675379, 0.02165224589407444, 0.005883891135454178, 0.009872619062662125, 0.027882596477866173, 0.007924153469502926, -0.012211961671710014, 0.010701753199100494, -0.030062034726142883, 0.013408283703029156, 0.00945212971419096, -0.007408905774354935, -0.0014709727838635445, -0.0334259495139122, -0.0002183880133088678, -0.002995247021317482, -0.001489480258896947, 0.012354099191725254, 0.00945212971419096, -0.04880046844482422, -0.006378410384058952, 0.0074799745343625546, -0.004261157475411892, -0.011744093149900436, -0.012756820768117905, -0.002613253192976117, -0.018537070602178574, 0.0017248950898647308, -0.031909819692373276, -0.017660558223724365, 0.00698841642588377, -0.013420128263533115, -0.012816044501960278, 0.000551152101252228, -0.02409227006137371, -0.005845395848155022, 0.01809881441295147, 0.027503564953804016, 0.030488446354866028, -0.011341370642185211, 0.007876774296164513, -0.015445584431290627, 0.022374777123332024, 0.04084077849984169, 0.036339763551950455, 0.009653490036725998, 0.02162855677306652, -0.03401818871498108, -0.002488882979378104, -0.022967016324400902, 0.002240142785012722, 0.03375760465860367, -0.022931480780243874, -0.01411897037178278, -0.026532292366027832, -0.03224147483706474, -0.027266668155789375, 0.057139188051223755, -0.02603481151163578, 0.026721809059381485, -0.00878289993852377, 0.0009994027204811573, -0.009084940887987614, 0.02930396981537342, 0.015682479366660118, 0.0070713297463953495, 0.012958182021975517, -0.005590733140707016, 0.03394712135195732, -0.009588344022631645, 0.0024311398155987263, -0.0013406802900135517, 0.006342876236885786, -0.017340747639536858, -0.0002354148746235296, -0.0023423039820045233, 0.012827889993786812, -0.02108369767665863, 0.01776716113090515, -0.016795888543128967, 0.04664471745491028, 0.01315954327583313, -0.0017781966598704457, 0.026366466656327248, 0.036860935389995575, 0.019567565992474556, 0.0009283341350965202, -0.0028234978672116995, -0.003263235092163086, -0.0002246805524919182, -0.016251029446721077, -0.011098552495241165, -0.008166971616446972, 0.008771054446697235, -0.009783782996237278, -0.011169621720910072, 0.01617996022105217, 0.027764149010181427, 0.003224739572033286, 0.03870872035622597, 0.008078135550022125, -0.02577422745525837, 0.016653751954436302, 0.010553693398833275, 0.029943587258458138, 0.0094698965549469, -0.010784666053950787, -0.024175181984901428, -0.012839734554290771, 0.015244223177433014, -0.002204608405008912, 0.011163699440658092, -0.0015035459073260427, -0.020929714664816856, 0.020432233810424805, 0.020219027996063232, -0.03482363373041153, -0.011459818109869957, -0.000649611814878881, -0.0020002860110253096, 0.022078657522797585, 0.04832667484879494, -0.0028738381806761026, 0.024755576625466347, -0.006544237490743399, 0.0034468290396034718, -0.00833872053772211, -0.006834434345364571, 0.006014183629304171, -0.009392905049026012, -0.0067159864120185375, -0.01916484348475933, 0.00012298206274863333, -0.010565537959337234, -0.005143593065440655, 0.0373821035027504, 0.016630062833428383, -0.012140892446041107, -0.04709481820464134, -0.009919998236000538, 0.007189777679741383, -0.03373391553759575, -0.03458673879504204, 0.023784305900335312, -0.01998213306069374, -0.055480919778347015, 0.008972415700554848, 0.00706540746614337, -0.0093455258756876, 0.02819056063890457, -0.006804822478443384, 0.022422155365347862, 0.020100580528378487, -0.02056252770125866, 0.004847473464906216, 0.022659052163362503, 0.036837246268987656, -0.007260845974087715, 0.02297886088490486, -0.0246371291577816, -0.02381983958184719, 0.015279757790267467, 0.009363293647766113, -0.012958182021975517, -0.050269220024347305, 0.03702676296234131, 0.028948625549674034, 0.034349843859672546, 0.0013140295632183552, -0.00782347284257412, -0.02386721782386303, 0.005611461587250233, 0.0505061149597168, 0.005155437625944614, -0.027290357276797295, -0.026911325752735138, -0.0013155101332813501, -0.005993455182760954, -0.04081708937883377, 0.05500712990760803, -0.03911144286394119, 0.0002394865150563419, -0.01944911852478981, -0.008848045952618122, -0.028901247307658195, -0.016061512753367424, 0.019046396017074585, -0.019520185887813568, -0.0006647878908552229, -0.002996727591380477, 0.003064835211262107, 0.02629539743065834, -0.007894541136920452, 0.0017278563464060426, -0.025561021640896797, 0.01494810450822115, 0.03124651312828064, -0.008279496803879738, -0.007758326828479767, -0.011394672095775604, -0.03506052866578102, 0.01997028850018978, -0.005623306147754192, 0.014071591198444366, -0.012721287086606026, 0.003206972498446703, 0.006177049595862627, -0.01481781154870987, 0.004885969217866659, -0.005966804455965757, 0.012063901871442795, 0.01645239070057869, -0.012685752473771572, -0.036079179495573044, 0.01728152483701706, -0.03093854896724224, 0.03418401628732681, 0.010589227080345154, 0.030583204701542854, -0.01782638393342495, -0.021829918026924133, 0.04429945349693298, -0.007497741840779781, 0.011998755857348442, -0.008605227805674076, -0.0010378982406109571, 0.038258619606494904, -0.040414366871118546, 0.00834464281797409, 0.01400052197277546, -0.007225311826914549, -0.011098552495241165, -0.019662324339151382, 0.043470319360494614, -0.005072524305433035, -0.027077151462435722, 0.012004678137600422, -0.012046135030686855, -0.05429644137620926, -0.008919114246964455, 0.0044536348432302475, -0.028048424050211906, 0.006804822478443384, -0.009706791490316391, 0.020455922931432724, 0.038471825420856476, -0.01532713696360588, 0.012827889993786812, -0.004142709542065859, 0.01612073741853237, 0.009108630940318108, 0.02252875827252865, 0.040414366871118546, -0.02051514759659767, -0.011288069188594818, 0.02052699215710163, -0.014569071121513844, -0.02004135586321354, -0.02800104394555092, 0.037168897688388824, -0.017352594062685966, 0.003959115594625473, 0.00465499609708786, -0.0028397843707352877, 0.026413844898343086, 0.0024977666325867176, 0.03861396014690399, -0.01179147232323885, -0.010044367983937263, -0.021060006693005562, -0.01724598929286003, 0.0172696802765131, 0.015457428991794586, -0.0013821369502693415, 0.028095802292227745, -0.016535304486751556, 0.0030204171780496836, 0.030346309766173363, 0.008137359283864498, 0.00796561036258936, 0.0076576462015509605, 0.03096223808825016, -0.003994649741798639, 0.003011533757671714, 0.0024133725091814995, 0.014498002827167511, 0.003064835211262107, -0.025324124842882156, 0.005990494042634964, -0.004465479403734207, -0.021806228905916214, 0.013112164102494717, 0.012437012046575546, -0.008439401164650917, -0.035771217197179794, 0.009440284222364426, -0.0001974745828192681, 0.00985485129058361, 0.0006425789906643331, -0.0543438196182251, -0.019070085138082504, -0.0013214325299486518, 0.054391201585531235, 0.03228885307908058, -0.011773704551160336, -0.044252075254917145, -0.030512137338519096, -0.00045121184666641057, 0.0071838549338281155, -0.012365943752229214, -0.01620364934206009, -0.015279757790267467, 0.02819056063890457, -0.019804460927844048, -0.03015679307281971, -0.023725081235170364, 0.040959227830171585, -0.019591255113482475, 0.04735540598630905, 0.011199233122169971, 0.012804199941456318, 0.022054968401789665, 0.036339763551950455, -0.0345393605530262, 0.026769187301397324, 0.0021705548278987408, -0.037666380405426025, -0.01642870157957077, -0.0016567877028137445, -0.01615627110004425, 0.006218506023287773, -0.010997871868312359, 0.015232378616929054, -0.019804460927844048, -0.019828150048851967, -0.003633384360000491, 0.04197787865996361, -0.010772821493446827, -0.00026002980303019285, 0.027858907356858253, 0.006378410384058952, -0.01890425942838192, 0.01217642705887556, 0.014498002827167511, 0.04136195033788681, -0.03809279203414917, -0.003597849979996681, 0.018856879323720932, 0.03262050449848175, 0.0032750798854976892, -0.02546626329421997, -0.01920037716627121, -0.026390155777335167, -0.04297283664345741, -0.004900774918496609, -0.0037962498608976603, -0.007444439921528101, 0.015149465762078762, 0.006556082051247358, -0.020219027996063232, 0.006585693918168545, 0.02634277567267418, 0.01920037716627121, -0.022362932562828064, -0.008332798257470131, -0.028356388211250305, -0.017352594062685966, 0.021249523386359215, -0.021202145144343376, -0.0339234322309494, 0.00795968808233738, -0.0004515819891821593, 0.024246251210570335, 0.001846304046921432, 0.06334584951400757, 0.00020025069534312934, -0.00008587460615672171, -0.01642870157957077, 0.002799808280542493, 0.017056474462151527, -0.005054756999015808, 0.07040533423423767, 0.03612655773758888, 0.025584710761904716, 0.04273594170808792, 0.049416396766901016, -0.016097046434879303, -0.0048652407713234425, -0.020076891407370567, 0.004361837636679411, -0.0031566321849823, -0.01217642705887556, 0.056570637971162796, -0.01369255781173706, 0.02109554223716259, -0.017873764038085938, -0.023938287049531937, -0.012662062421441078, -0.02662705071270466, 0.011572343297302723, -0.040982916951179504, -0.002890124684199691, 0.028877558186650276, 0.014083435758948326, -0.023713236674666405, -0.028853869065642357, -0.03560538962483406, 0.0062066614627838135, -0.01315954327583313, -0.02164040133357048, -0.02548995241522789, 0.1026231199502945, 0.010903114452958107, -0.006218506023287773, -0.016926180571317673, 0.04832667484879494, 0.019674168899655342, -0.039869505912065506, -0.034681495279073715, -0.011933608911931515, -0.006810744758695364, 0.026153258979320526, -0.0031625544652342796, 0.018205417320132256, -0.03866134211421013, 0.004681646823883057, -0.006899580359458923, -0.006787055172026157, 0.029398728162050247, -0.0013399400049820542, 0.010168737731873989, -0.02548995241522789, -0.01068398542702198, -0.013728092424571514, 0.014438779093325138, 0.026366466656327248, -0.02141535095870495, -0.005460440646857023, 0.0091619323939085, -0.007989299483597279, 0.0026858022902160883, 0.004779366310685873, 0.01083796750754118, -0.0076754130423069, -0.006348798517137766, -0.003476441139355302 ]
14.912473
7.250769
2024-07-01
0
2024A&A...687A.159B
[ "galaxy luminosity ratio", "similar intrinsic AGN luminosities", "host galaxies", "host galaxy", "AGN luminosities", "higher luminosities", "increasing extinction", "sufficient extinction", "luminosities", "sub-type determination" ]
[ "galaxies: active", "galaxies: nuclei", "quasars: emission lines", "quasars: general", "galaxies: Seyfert", "infrared: galaxies", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
38
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202348948", "10.48550/arXiv.2404.19544" ]
[ "Barquín-González, L.", "Mateos, S.", "Carrera, F. J.", "Ordovás-Pascual, I.", "Alonso-Herrero, A.", "Caccianiga, A.", "Cardiel, N.", "Corral, A.", "Domínguez, R. M.", "García-Bernete, I.", "Mountrichas, G.", "Severgnini, P." ]
[ "IFCA (University of Cantabria-CSIC), Avenida de los Castros, 39005, Santander, Spain", "IFCA (University of Cantabria-CSIC), Avenida de los Castros, 39005, Santander, Spain", "IFCA (University of Cantabria-CSIC), Avenida de los Castros, 39005, Santander, Spain", "IFCA (University of Cantabria-CSIC), Avenida de los Castros, 39005, Santander, Spain", "Centro de Astrobiología (CAB), CSIC-INTA, Camino Bajo del Castillo s/n, 28692, Villanueva de la Cañada, Madrid, Spain", "INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Brera, via Brera 28, 20121, Milan, Italy", "Departamento de Física de la Tierra y Astrofísica, Fac. CC. Físicas, Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Plaza de las Ciencias 1, 28040, Spain", "IFCA (University of Cantabria-CSIC), Avenida de los Castros, 39005, Santander, Spain", "IFCA (University of Cantabria-CSIC), Avenida de los Castros, 39005, Santander, Spain", "Astrophysics, University of Oxford, DWB, Keble Road, Oxford, OX1 3RH, UK", "IFCA (University of Cantabria-CSIC), Avenida de los Castros, 39005, Santander, Spain", "INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Brera, via Brera 28, 20121, Milan, Italy" ]
null
[ "1976asqu.book.....A", "1977ApJ...215..733O", "1978LNM...630..105M", "1981ApJ...249..462O", "1982PASP...94..891G", "1984PASP...96..393G", "1988LNP...307...79W", "1989ApJ...345..245C", "1990ARA&A..28..215D", "1992ApJS...79...49W", "1992MNRAS.257..677W", "1993ARA&A..31..473A", "1995ApJ...454...95M", "1995PASP..107..803U", "1998ApJ...500..816G", "1998ApJS..117...25M", "2000AJ....119.2498J", "2000ApJ...533..682C", "2000MNRAS.312..813S", "2001A&A...365L..18S", "2001SPIE.4477...76F", "2003AJ....125..525J", "2003AJ....126...81A", "2003MNRAS.343..978S", "2003MNRAS.344.1000B", "2003PASP..115..763C", "2004A&A...416..901C", "2004MNRAS.355..196F", "2004MNRAS.355..973S", "2005A&A...444..119G", "2005AJ....130..381B", "2005ApJ...630..122G", "2006ApJ...648L.101E", "2006ApJS..166..470R", "2006Msngr.126...41E", "2007ASPC..376..543D", "2007ApJ...663...81P", "2007MNRAS.379.1599L", "2008A&A...477..735C", "2008A&A...487..119D", "2008ApJ...685..147N", "2008ApJ...685..160N", "2008MNRAS.383..581D", "2009ApJ...690.1322W", "2009ApJS..182..543A", "2009PhST..134a4006V", "2010AJ....140.1868W", "2010ASPC..434..353P", "2010ApJ...725.1749T", "2011ApJ...728...58B", "2011ApJ...739...57K", "2011ApJS..194...45S", "2012ApJ...747L..33E", "2012MNRAS.420.1825J", "2012MNRAS.426.2703S", "2012MNRAS.426.3271M", "2013ApJ...777...86L", "2013MNRAS.429.1494R", "2014ApJ...786..104U", "2014MNRAS.438..494R", "2014MNRAS.439.1403M", "2015ARA&A..53..365N", "2015ApJ...802..102L", "2015MNRAS.449.1422M", "2016A&A...586A..28B", "2016ApJ...821...55M", "2016ApJ...823L..12G", "2016ApJ...829L...7G", "2016ApJ...832....8B", "2016MNRAS.461.4227H", "2016MNRAS.462.3570S", "2017ApJ...850...74K", "2017ApJS..230...24B", "2017MNRAS.467..226G", "2017MNRAS.472.4051C", "2018ApJ...853L..25I", "2018ApJ...856..154S", "2018ApJ...859..144A", "2019A&A...625A.123C", "2019A&A...632A..61G", "2019ASPC..523..317C", "2019ApJ...870...31I", "2019ApJ...872..168S", "2019ApJ...878...11Z", "2019MNRAS.483.1722L", "2020MNRAS.491.5867R", "2020Natur.585..357H", "2021A&A...652A..98G", "2021A&A...653A..70M", "2021A&A...654A..93B", "2022A&A...658A..35K", "2022ApJ...935..167A", "2022ApJS..259...35A", "2022ApJS..261....4O", "2022ApJS..261....5M", "2022MNRAS.515.5617M", "2023ApJ...950...67M", "2023ApJ...954L...4K", "2023ApJ...959...39H", "2023MNRAS.518..130S", "2023arXiv230801230M" ]
29163012
2404.14103
The quiescent population at 0.5 ≤ z ≤ 0.9: Environmental impact on the mass-size relation
Context. How the quiescent galaxies evolve with redshift and the factors that impact their evolution are still debated. It is still unclear what the dominant mechanisms of passive galaxy growth are and what role is played by the environment in shaping their evolutionary paths over cosmic time. <BR /> Aims: The population of quiescent galaxies is altered over time by several processes that can affect their mean properties. Our aim is to study the mass-size relation (MSR) of the quiescent population and to understand how the environment shapes the MSR at intermediate redshift. <BR /> Methods: We used the VIMOS Public Extragalactic Redshift Survey (VIPERS), a large spectroscopic survey of ∼90 000 galaxies in the redshift range 0.5 ≤ z ≤ 1.2. We selected a mass-complete sample of 4786 passive galaxies based on the NUVrK diagram and refined it using the D<SUB>n</SUB>4000 spectral index to study the MSR of the passive population over 0.5 ≤ z ≤ 0.9. The impact of the environment on the MSR and on the growth of the quiescent population is studied through the density contrast. <BR /> Results: The slope and the intercept of the MSR, α = 0.62 ± 0.04 and log(A) = 0.52 ± 0.01, agree well with values from the literature at the same redshift. The intercept decreases with redshift, R<SUB>e</SUB>(z) = 8.20 × (1 + z)<SUP>−1.70</SUP>, while the slope remains roughly constant, and the same trend is observed in the low-density (LD) and high-density (HD) environments. Thanks to the largest spectroscopic sample at 0.5 ≤ z ≤ 0.9, these results are not prone to redshift uncertainties from photometric measurements. We find that the average size of the quiescent population in the LD and HD environments are identical within 3σ and this result is robust against a change in the definition of the LD and HD environments or a change in the selection of quiescent galaxies. In the LD and HD environments, ∼30 and ∼40% of the population have experienced a minor merger process between 0.5 ≤ z ≤ 0.9. However, minor mergers account only for 30-40% of the size evolution in this redshift range, the remaining evolution likely being due to the progenitor bias.
[ 0.0329563170671463, 0.05303946137428284, 0.036648619920015335, 0.03188355267047882, 0.03238251060247421, 0.052091438323259354, 0.012361736968159676, -0.003458417486399412, -0.023775450885295868, 0.03677336126565933, -0.014706850051879883, 0.011706852354109287, -0.057530101388692856, 0.02205403707921505, 0.06356751918792725, 0.031234903261065483, 0.005391887854784727, 0.008432426489889622, -0.014507265761494637, 0.048798300325870514, 0.0191974900662899, -0.0024433452636003494, 0.004777543246746063, 0.04894798994064331, -0.06167147308588028, -0.02871515601873398, -0.009698537178337574, 0.024523889645934105, 0.05902698263525963, -0.02637004293501377, 0.0331808477640152, -0.017363812774419785, -0.050469815731048584, 0.015617451630532742, -0.041638221591711044, 0.07045316696166992, 0.006661117542535067, -0.01456963550299406, -0.01716422848403454, 0.0008388767018914223, 0.011931383982300758, -0.019110172986984253, -0.013559241779148579, 0.010596665553748608, -0.01988356187939644, 0.020182937383651733, 0.0016262981807813048, -0.03585028648376465, 0.015592504292726517, 0.007584193721413612, -0.0718003585934639, -0.030137192457914352, -0.00034907719236798584, -0.009729722514748573, -0.010503110475838184, -0.02644488587975502, -0.0166153721511364, -0.017363812774419785, -0.02814135141670704, 0.0009051448432728648, 0.01712680608034134, -0.0037733858916908503, 0.023476073518395424, 0.02864031121134758, 0.01822451874613762, 0.02696879394352436, -0.00521725183352828, 0.023426178842782974, -0.021043643355369568, 0.003935548011213541, -0.013446975499391556, -0.022141356021165848, -0.012823275290429592, 0.02037004753947258, 0.021879401057958603, 0.01816214807331562, 0.03590017929673195, 0.0028612245805561543, -0.01937212608754635, -0.00017570803174749017, 0.012112257070839405, 0.01297296304255724, -0.005164237227290869, 0.029089374467730522, -0.03505194932222366, -0.01460705790668726, 0.021243227645754814, -0.008064443245530128, -0.044432397931814194, 0.043733853846788406, 0.023563392460346222, 0.0047370027750730515, -0.00493658659979701, -0.04448229447007179, -0.009810803458094597, -0.031010372564196587, 0.04021618515253067, -0.06476502120494843, 0.039866913110017776, 0.04009144753217697, 0.01179417036473751, 0.027916818857192993, 0.006891886703670025, -0.050893932580947876, 0.003957377281039953, -0.03981701657176018, 0.019097698852419853, -0.03365486115217209, -0.009324317798018456, -0.04036587476730347, 0.024636156857013702, 0.030461516231298447, 0.026844054460525513, 0.0007121876114979386, -0.036523882299661636, 0.026020770892500877, -0.07938455790281296, -0.020070670172572136, 0.0016481276834383607, 0.014781693927943707, -0.027767131105065346, -0.03150933235883713, -0.0013978680362924933, 0.031659018248319626, 0.032207876443862915, -0.01766318827867508, 0.0075592459179461, -0.03036172315478325, -0.05059455707669258, 0.042137183248996735, 0.04672761633992195, 0.006979204714298248, 0.02257794514298439, -0.006972967647016048, -0.06556335836648941, -0.03682325780391693, 0.008856542408466339, -0.04228686913847923, -0.020482312887907028, -0.00992930680513382, -0.018261941149830818, 0.021929297596216202, 0.0003124348004348576, 0.03739706054329872, 0.06471512466669083, -0.0001091475278371945, -0.021841978654265404, 0.027268171310424805, 0.008956334553658962, 0.011345106177031994, 0.03644903749227524, -0.019634081050753593, -0.043733853846788406, -0.025534285232424736, -0.01297296304255724, 0.00032861201907508075, 0.032756730914115906, 0.004393967799842358, -0.02302701026201248, 0.0035987498704344034, -0.016665268689393997, -0.022291043773293495, -0.002192306099459529, -0.03455298766493797, -0.01761329174041748, 0.0219916682690382, -0.0302619319409132, -0.0023716199211776257, -0.09255710244178772, -0.03228272125124931, 0.01862368732690811, 0.0009168392280116677, -0.038494773209095, -0.06152178347110748, -0.016415787860751152, 0.02804155834019184, -0.03634924441576004, -0.03904363140463829, 0.015143440105021, 0.01072140596807003, 0.010291052982211113, 0.030187087133526802, -0.012580032460391521, -0.04355921968817711, -0.025122642517089844, 0.006474007852375507, -0.03076089173555374, 0.0193471796810627, -0.0001255196548299864, -0.054785821586847305, -0.03427856042981148, 0.022889796644449234, -0.02044489048421383, -0.0015748428413644433, -0.013122651726007462, -0.0441579706966877, 0.0035706833004951477, 0.03128480166196823, -0.03540122136473656, 0.014095623977482319, 0.039392903447151184, -0.012392922304570675, 0.055334679782390594, -0.08143029361963272, 0.00676714675500989, -0.07958413660526276, 0.05857791751623154, -0.017713084816932678, -0.0015896557597443461, -0.00549791706725955, 0.039891861379146576, 0.03078584000468254, -0.013422027230262756, 0.012099782936275005, -0.015180861577391624, -0.014931381680071354, -0.05548436567187309, 0.04899788275361061, 0.03687315434217453, 0.03088563121855259, -0.00933055393397808, 0.02100622095167637, 0.06321825087070465, 0.03240745887160301, 0.03784612566232681, 0.021280650049448013, 0.03248230367898941, -0.007970888167619705, 0.01455716136842966, -0.0021361729595810175, 0.007752593141049147, 0.02527233026921749, -0.04238666221499443, 0.004515589214861393, -0.013185021467506886, -0.0109958341345191, -0.01153221633285284, 0.03901868313550949, -0.02649478241801262, -0.027193326503038406, -0.015841983258724213, 0.011401238851249218, -0.006417874712496996, 0.009130970574915409, -0.012081071734428406, 0.01989603415131569, -0.02859041467308998, -0.04620370641350746, 0.019509341567754745, -0.03812055289745331, 0.006792094558477402, 0.02045736461877823, 0.002440226962789893, -0.00854469183832407, -0.022141356021165848, 0.012374211102724075, -0.02201661467552185, 0.05019538849592209, -0.037621594965457916, -0.011781696230173111, -0.017900194972753525, -0.04555505886673927, -0.0033149663358926773, 0.0038326375652104616, 0.0012021820293739438, 0.04520578682422638, 0.057530101388692856, -0.060573760420084, -0.01430768147110939, 0.030087295919656754, -0.0109771229326725, -0.0660124272108078, 0.012024939060211182, -0.02529727853834629, -0.038819096982479095, 0.04083988815546036, -0.0009363298886455595, 0.01125155109912157, 0.006536377593874931, -0.005591472145169973, -0.004032221622765064, -0.004708935972303152, 0.0496215857565403, 0.019683977589011192, 0.008644483983516693, 0.012823275290429592, -0.008232842199504375, 0.016914747655391693, 0.008345108479261398, 0.00549479853361845, 0.0658128410577774, -0.05051971226930618, 0.000367203465430066, -0.00017531821504235268, -0.051442790776491165, -0.0032962553668767214, 0.013110177591443062, 0.005507272202521563, -0.05553426221013069, 0.03727232292294502, 0.05219122767448425, 0.042087286710739136, -0.027667339891195297, 0.007814963348209858, -0.017987512052059174, 0.003486483823508024, 0.0770394429564476, -0.0022375243715941906, -0.004528063349425793, 0.03245735540986061, 0.014494791626930237, 0.013571714982390404, 0.016889799386262894, 0.03692305088043213, -0.037147581577301025, -0.018848218023777008, -0.07100202888250351, 0.03894383832812309, 0.03522658348083496, -0.032706838101148605, -0.011014544405043125, -0.010091468691825867, -0.01489396020770073, 0.006654880475252867, -0.017875246703624725, -0.06825774163007736, -0.027841975912451744, -0.051542580127716064, 0.002469852566719055, -0.007540534716099501, 0.029887711629271507, 0.0024028047919273376, 0.05059455707669258, 0.015355497598648071, 0.013022859580814838, -0.026594575494527817, -0.0037546749226748943, 0.08681906014680862, 0.011101862415671349, 0.011925146915018559, -0.028515571728348732, 0.004833676386624575, 0.00962993036955595, -0.024598734453320503, -0.006268186494708061, 0.0007437624153681099, 0.01604156754910946, 0.025671498849987984, 0.03148438408970833, -0.00020270254753995687, 0.017900194972753525, 0.004437626805156469, 0.027742182835936546, -0.027093535289168358, 0.06446564942598343, -0.02306443266570568, 0.03677336126565933, -0.06451554596424103, -0.042112234979867935, 0.03575049340724945, 0.009972965344786644, -0.03580038994550705, 0.021118488162755966, -0.004181909374892712, -0.009985439479351044, 0.02854051999747753, -0.005129933822900057, 0.008875253610312939, 0.00935550220310688, -0.03809560462832451, -0.0056444862857460976, 0.03477752208709717, -0.010864856652915478, -0.004484404344111681, -0.06291887164115906, -0.01539292000234127, 0.02911432273685932, 0.02916421927511692, -0.007228684611618519, 0.020058197900652885, 0.009405398741364479, 0.036623671650886536, -0.004113302566111088, -0.028440726920962334, 0.007615379057824612, 0.008083154447376728, -0.05328894034028053, -0.02869020774960518, -0.11785437911748886, 0.017426181584596634, 0.02040746994316578, 0.008607062511146069, 0.017912669107317924, 0.005061326548457146, 0.037796229124069214, -0.012455292046070099, 0.0013510904973372817, 0.053089357912540436, 0.02148023433983326, 0.04637834429740906, 0.012723483145236969, -0.05239081382751465, -0.005027023144066334, -0.04572969675064087, -0.009037415497004986, -0.006966730579733849, -0.028390830382704735, -0.009031178429722786, -0.004867979791015387, -0.013596663251519203, 0.053089357912540436, -0.013297287747263908, 0.028266090899705887, 0.009848225861787796, -0.00908107403665781, 0.02417461760342121, -0.04999580606818199, 0.02911432273685932, -0.0010922548826783895, 0.03916836902499199, -0.013708929531276226, -0.025022849440574646, 0.00234355335123837, -0.0022702685091644526, -0.02981286682188511, 0.05857791751623154, 0.014906433410942554, 0.051991645246744156, -0.031185008585453033, -0.03699789196252823, -0.038868993520736694, 0.0075779571197927, -0.0005874476046301425, -0.02483574114739895, 0.026644470170140266, -0.012336788699030876, 0.006523903459310532, -0.02806650660932064, 0.0030031162314116955, -0.026644470170140266, 0.04350932314991951, -0.019397074356675148, -0.014482317492365837, -0.03430350869894028, 0.05937625467777252, 0.007322239689528942, 0.04246150702238083, 0.015692295506596565, -0.003548853797838092, -0.042661089450120926, -0.014245311729609966, 0.0009823277359828353, 0.039916809648275375, -0.012236997485160828, -0.029438648372888565, -0.011694378219544888, 0.005298332776874304, -0.03585028648376465, -0.010247393511235714, -0.05079413950443268, -0.011008307337760925, 0.004465693142265081, 0.015854457393288612, 0.04355921968817711, -0.0073783728294074535, 0.021180856972932816, -0.008189182728528976, -0.005653841886669397, -0.019022854045033455, 0.00378897855989635, 0.016166308894753456, -0.03799581527709961, 0.01353429351001978, -0.01917254365980625, 0.012948015704751015, -0.019995827227830887, -0.048773352056741714, 0.007509349845349789, 0.03587523475289345, 0.028266090899705887, 0.033829495310783386, -0.002460497198626399, 0.022328466176986694, 0.037197478115558624, 0.007640326861292124, 0.04448229447007179, -0.008045732043683529, 0.03672346472740173, 0.0029703720938414335, -0.0007375254645012319, 0.0032713073305785656, -0.005875255446881056, 0.03198334574699402, -0.013010385446250439, 0.022765055298805237, -0.0008458933443762362, 0.014145519584417343, 0.027318065986037254, 0.007122655864804983, 0.03255714848637581, 0.05957584083080292, 0.0046309735625982285, 0.031010372564196587, -0.006115380208939314, 0.019422022625803947, -0.012018701992928982, -0.00550103560090065, -0.012367974035441875, 0.002165798796340823, 0.04236171394586563, -0.029912659898400307, 0.005554049741476774, 0.0038669409696012735, -0.012573795393109322, 0.004998956806957722, 0.027143429964780807, 0.005725567229092121, 0.02534717507660389, 0.02043241634964943, 0.021205805242061615, 0.018885640427470207, -0.014432421885430813, 0.011900198645889759, 0.025496862828731537, 0.006159039214253426, 0.011563400737941265, -0.05194174870848656, -0.11945105344057083, -0.026769211515784264, -0.023837819695472717, -0.025671498849987984, -0.017887720838189125, 0.011563400737941265, 0.02921411581337452, -0.014494791626930237, -0.05613301321864128, -0.0028362765442579985, -0.02699374221265316, -0.00004619279206963256, -0.0275176502764225, 0.020806636661291122, -0.001763512147590518, -0.0012162153143435717, -0.006673591677099466, -0.0041444874368608, 0.062070637941360474, -0.017239071428775787, 0.0024261935614049435, 0.03340538218617439, 0.020220359787344933, 0.034528039395809174, 0.009467768482863903, 0.019359653815627098, 0.027966715395450592, 0.022178778424859047, -0.0008139287238009274, -0.010284815914928913, 0.016727637499570847, 0.01872347854077816, -0.007584193721413612, -0.01712680608034134, -0.0032525963615626097, -0.005466731730848551, 0.017738033086061478, -0.03091057948768139, -0.045530110597610474, 0.024686051532626152, 0.007590430788695812, -0.05129310116171837, 0.013871091417968273, -0.02363823540508747, 0.000511044345330447, 0.011419950053095818, -0.006339912302792072, 0.0014859656803309917, -0.006343030836433172, -0.027792079374194145, 0.015754666179418564, 0.027193326503038406, -0.03086068294942379, -0.04834923520684242, -0.03565070033073425, 0.007740119006484747, -0.004506233613938093, -0.05772968754172325, 0.017451129853725433, -0.03682325780391693, -0.005014549475163221, 0.03899373486638069, 0.037746332585811615, 0.021891875192523003, -0.02866525948047638, 0.000513383187353611, 0.011906435713171959, 0.0151184918358922, -0.001888252212665975, 0.047675639390945435, 0.003208937356248498, -0.04607896879315376, -0.02701869048178196, -0.004253635182976723, -0.005875255446881056, -0.04014134034514427, -0.026120562106370926, 0.007122655864804983, 0.03732221573591232, -0.027143429964780807, -0.053638212382793427, -0.007496875710785389, 0.016902273520827293, -0.016103938221931458, 0.009954254142940044, 0.004512470681220293, -0.0151184918358922, 0.0012177745811641216, -0.019933456555008888, 0.012386685237288475, -0.03535132482647896, 0.012642402201890945, -0.002747399266809225, -0.009199577383697033, 0.015530133619904518, -0.022939691320061684, 0.005563405342400074, 0.054336756467819214, 0.009517664089798927, -0.022166304290294647, -0.021031169220805168, -0.006237001623958349, -0.02746775560081005, 0.00855716597288847, -0.04291057214140892, 0.00466527696698904, -0.002491682069376111, -0.016166308894753456, 0.0033180848695337772, 0.00648024445399642, 0.012174626812338829, -0.00908107403665781, -0.015305601991713047, 0.058627814054489136, 0.03228272125124931, 0.021829506382346153, -0.024411624297499657, 0.02320164628326893, 0.030037399381399155, -0.004652803298085928, -0.004992719739675522, -0.009754670783877373, 0.00884406827390194, -0.03622450679540634, -0.033829495310783386, -0.006517666857689619, 0.002742721466347575, 0.044282712042331696, 0.020245306193828583, 0.007802488747984171, 0.012910593301057816, -0.00962993036955595, 0.03093552775681019, -0.010846145451068878, -0.036124713718891144, 0.016415787860751152, 0.0082827378064394, 0.005678790155798197, 0.0029906423296779394, 0.006517666857689619, 0.010409555397927761, 0.007365898694843054, 0.02210393361747265, 0.0658128410577774, -0.008962571620941162, 0.0494219996035099, 0.029538439586758614, 0.012723483145236969, -0.03190850093960762, 0.0013370572123676538, -0.01072764303535223, -0.028864843770861626, 0.0040228660218417645, 0.026095613837242126, 0.002497919136658311, -0.021355492994189262, 0.0016559239011257887, -0.01706443540751934, 0.00025045458460226655, 0.017201650887727737, -0.011713089421391487, 0.012923067435622215, -0.0191974900662899, 0.01269229780882597, 0.019584184512495995, 0.039866913110017776, 0.0031262971460819244, -0.015854457393288612, -0.02044489048421383, 0.000025118550183833577, 0.008719327859580517, 0.00701038958504796, -0.027941767126321793, 0.030436567962169647, -0.008931386284530163, 0.026270249858498573, -0.0037172529846429825, -0.013072755187749863, 0.012573795393109322, -0.02701869048178196, -0.01647815853357315, -0.0022453204728662968, -0.02634509466588497, 0.05468602851033211, 0.04717668145895004, -0.023937612771987915, -0.00906859990209341, 0.002909561153501272, -0.0151060177013278, -0.029363803565502167, 0.010534295812249184, -0.022440731525421143, 0.005320162512362003, 0.008925149217247963, -0.02096879854798317, -0.0439334399998188, 0.0004880453634541482, 0.027667339891195297, -0.04368395730853081, 0.014694375917315483, 0.01708938367664814, -0.018049882724881172, 0.0052796220406889915, -0.00015076002455316484, 0.04071514680981636, 0.011064440943300724, 0.002153324894607067, 0.01322244293987751, 0.04523073509335518, -0.007166314870119095, -0.003530142828822136, -0.0038607039023190737, 0.033829495310783386, -0.003321203403174877, -0.011282735504209995, 0.03360496461391449, 0.01349687110632658, 0.014270259998738766, 0.0007285597384907305, 0.012629928067326546, -0.01917254365980625, 0.0008380970684811473, -0.016902273520827293, -0.014993751421570778, 0.009405398741364479, 0.00521101476624608, -0.009318080730736256, 0.037197478115558624, -0.00729729188606143, 0.030686046928167343, -0.01489396020770073, -0.0016715164529159665, 0.009056126698851585, 0.02983781509101391, 0.00378274149261415, 0.004175672773271799, 0.021580025553703308, 0.020819110795855522, 0.03694799914956093, -0.021118488162755966, -0.021692290902137756, 0.018037408590316772, -0.03345527499914169, -0.022752581164240837, 0.0151559142395854, 0.011943858116865158, -0.0026834700256586075, 0.0007652021595276892, -0.012636165134608746, 0.030611203983426094, -0.028765050694346428, -0.007958414033055305, 0.005840952042490244, -0.0110020712018013, -0.023451125249266624, -0.010534295812249184, -0.041663169860839844, -0.02587108314037323, 0.019596658647060394, 0.029613284394145012, -0.022765055298805237, 0.013846143148839474, 0.016228677704930305, 0.004440745338797569, -0.007397084031254053, -0.006377334240823984, 0.021904349327087402, -0.010509347543120384, -0.006642406806349754, -0.0012668909039348364, -0.10807476192712784, 0.05184195563197136, 0.011943858116865158, 0.016777534037828445, 0.017950089648365974, 0.04775048419833183, 0.0007129672449082136, 0.010683983564376831, 0.05952594429254532, -0.0020691251847893, 0.009212051518261433, -0.024548837915062904, 0.02918916754424572, -0.022802477702498436, 0.0192848090082407, -0.03091057948768139, -0.037172529846429825, 0.040989574044942856, -0.0015530133387073874, -0.0012310282327234745, -0.01705196313560009, 0.016353419050574303, -0.001595892827026546, -0.00018213993462268263, 0.015268179588019848, -0.01715175434947014, 0.005332636181265116, -0.0007882010540924966, 0.04183780774474144, 0.009586271829903126, 0.014457369223237038, -0.02474842220544815, -0.023288963362574577, 0.0439583882689476, -0.041638221591711044, -0.0053419917821884155, 0.0007940482464618981, 0.0035893945023417473, -0.03784612566232681, -0.005709975026547909, -0.010054046288132668, -0.01430768147110939, 0.026020770892500877, 0.039367955178022385, 0.0330810546875, -0.020095618441700935, 0.013035333715379238, 0.05069435015320778, 0.020008301362395287, 0.025185013189911842, 0.013060281053185463, 0.022877322509884834, 0.010415792465209961, -0.005357584450393915, -0.0037390824873000383, 0.0192349124699831, 0.004278582986444235, -0.02143033780157566, -0.005023904610425234, -0.008650721050798893, -0.019484393298625946, 0.02255299687385559, 0.007746356073766947, -0.05842823162674904, -0.037796229124069214, -0.015742192044854164, 0.016365891322493553, 0.019110172986984253, -0.0031387710478156805, -0.003608105471357703, -0.0034085214138031006, 0.039293110370635986, 0.00991683267056942, 0.016902273520827293, -0.004577958956360817, -0.016790008172392845, 0.020831584930419922, 0.007540534716099501, -0.033205796033144, 0.003792096860706806, -0.0440332293510437, -0.03233261778950691, 0.009442820213735104, -0.02594592608511448, 0.015081069432199001, 0.028291039168834686, -0.0031138230115175247, -0.014182941988110542, 0.0009636167669668794, 0.026644470170140266, 0.019970878958702087, -0.005507272202521563, 0.011338869109749794, 0.002179831964895129, -0.027941767126321793, -0.0037110159173607826, 0.018274415284395218, -0.04525568336248398, 0.010272341780364513, -0.018898114562034607, -0.05278998240828514, -0.030187087133526802, 0.005744278430938721, -0.048299338668584824, -0.013609137386083603, -0.031135112047195435, 0.00730976602062583, 0.03427856042981148, 0.022328466176986694, 0.016839904710650444, 0.02254052460193634, 0.002172035863623023, -0.0013097702758386731, 0.04750100523233414, 0.05244071036577225, 0.027118483558297157, 0.014756745658814907, 0.006112261675298214, -0.015604977495968342, -0.015517659485340118, 0.006355504505336285, -0.008625772781670094, -0.012654876336455345, 0.008700617589056492, 0.022315992042422295, -0.02421204000711441, 0.025234907865524292, 0.009948017075657845, 0.0005348228733055294, 0.03143448755145073, -0.010683983564376831, -0.00006134675641078502, 0.015841983258724213, 0.03350517153739929, -0.0027099770959466696, -0.011812880635261536, 0.0005741939530707896, 0.034403301775455475, 0.010952174663543701, 0.007178789004683495, -0.006885649636387825, 0.004344071727246046, 0.013209969736635685, 0.004802491050213575, -0.02086900733411312, 0.007160077802836895, 0.022353414446115494, -0.027243223041296005, 0.019185015931725502, 0.005956336390227079, 0.007702697068452835, -0.008401241153478622, 0.01405820157378912, 0.01703948900103569, 0.01713928021490574, 0.013571714982390404, 0.016390839591622353, -0.03422866389155388, -0.00800207257270813, 0.03517669066786766, 0.03380454704165459, 0.025047797709703445, 0.004496878013014793, -0.051542580127716064, -0.004244279582053423, 0.0032993739005178213, -0.03091057948768139, 0.013733877800405025, -0.01706443540751934, -0.02085653319954872, -0.03891889005899429, -0.03744695708155632, 0.04286067560315132, 0.00352078746072948, -0.011781696230173111, 0.006037417333573103, -0.003087315708398819, 0.004836794920265675, 0.021729713305830956, 0.02305195853114128, 0.028266090899705887, -0.007222448009997606, -0.01071516890078783, 0.03365486115217209, 0.030162138864398003, 0.00233575701713562, -0.006916834972798824, -0.000290410389425233, 0.02096879854798317, -0.0013651236658915877, -0.013609137386083603, 0.03926816210150719, 0.008769224397838116, 0.044881463050842285, 0.012505188584327698, 0.03135964274406433, -0.033255692571401596, 0.01485653780400753, -0.0029080018866807222, -0.010272341780364513, -0.015480238012969494, -0.039318058639764786, -0.018411628901958466, -0.015280653722584248, 0.013858617283403873, 0.004440745338797569, 0.00016508562839590013, -0.027193326503038406, -0.035625752061605453, -0.020008301362395287, -0.022353414446115494, -0.015517659485340118, 0.0220041424036026, 0.000887213449459523, 0.025047797709703445, -0.002317046048119664, 0.010478162206709385, -0.02372555434703827, -0.042087286710739136, -0.027093535289168358, -0.019459445029497147, -0.05239081382751465, -0.01974634639918804, 0.02634509466588497, -0.017937617376446724, 0.01767566241323948, -0.004378375131636858, -0.013446975499391556, -0.017825350165367126, 0.01756339706480503, 0.03185860440135002, 0.029413700103759766, 0.00011996482498943806, -0.04011639580130577, -0.02859041467308998, -0.016790008172392845, -0.0022640316747128963, -0.001594333560205996, -0.007933465763926506, 0.0006619017804041505, 0.01984613947570324, 0.005179829895496368, -0.027392910793423653, -0.030411619693040848, -0.016927221789956093, -0.020706845447421074, 0.005298332776874304, -0.029513491317629814, 0.0020800400525331497, -0.027392910793423653, -0.039866913110017776, -0.010765064507722855, -0.029488543048501015, -0.02312680147588253, 0.020544683560729027, -0.004867979791015387, -0.020619526505470276, 0.01823699288070202, 0.02030767686665058, -0.029912659898400307, -0.028191247954964638, -0.012474003247916698, -0.03372970595955849, -0.02259041927754879, 0.023276489228010178, -0.003084197174757719, 0.005104986019432545, 0.028440726920962334, 0.010078994557261467, -0.030710995197296143, -0.006137209478765726, -0.016291048377752304, 0.018486471846699715, 0.009723485447466373, -0.005822240840643644, 0.016428261995315552, -0.0009230762370862067, -0.004886690527200699, -0.02528480440378189, 0.015792088583111763, -0.023251540958881378, -0.01324739120900631, -0.013621611520648003, 0.0031013491097837687, -0.034927207976579666, 0.02155507728457451, 0.0004529622383415699, -0.012636165134608746, 0.004877335391938686, -0.014669427648186684, -0.008076917380094528, 0.05458623915910721, 0.013422027230262756, 0.03233261778950691, 0.015604977495968342, -0.01758834533393383, -0.012935541570186615, 0.031135112047195435, -0.019621606916189194, -0.025721395388245583, -0.012923067435622215, -0.009474005550146103, -0.0020067552104592323, -0.00206756591796875, -0.011681904084980488, -0.02477337047457695, 0.010241156443953514, -0.01713928021490574, -0.010515584610402584, 0.0011483879061415792, 0.031234903261065483, 0.0033305587712675333, -0.03198334574699402, 0.019409548491239548, 0.015243232250213623, -0.008332634344696999, -0.023975033313035965, 0.022864848375320435, 0.006040535867214203, -0.01767566241323948, -0.01348439697176218, 0.016777534037828445, 0.022166304290294647, 0.018386680632829666, -0.04004155099391937, -0.026869002729654312, -0.01606651581823826, -0.013060281053185463, 0.02318917214870453, 0.04283572733402252, 0.02421204000711441, 0.03580038994550705, 0.000587057787925005, -0.005557168275117874, -0.007752593141049147, 0.014157993718981743, 0.018486471846699715, -0.012467766180634499, 0.03684820607304573, 0.017837824299931526, -0.059775423258543015, -0.02691889926791191, -0.011918909847736359, -0.010216208174824715, 0.014644479379057884, 0.002460497198626399, 0.02639499120414257, -0.0151559142395854, -0.019097698852419853, 0.0074844020418822765, 0.06865691393613815, -0.02749270386993885, -0.005027023144066334, -0.03817044943571091, 0.011613297276198864, -0.015280653722584248, 0.030112244188785553, 0.015754666179418564, -0.00648648152127862, -0.00442203413695097, 0.004063406493514776, 0.005089393351227045, -0.022266095504164696, 0.024473994970321655, 0.01434510387480259, -0.030137192457914352, -0.001177233993075788, 0.03637419268488884, -0.019397074356675148, -0.03248230367898941, -0.014956329949200153, -0.014694375917315483, -0.008226605132222176, 0.010565480217337608, -0.021729713305830956, -0.00016167477588169277, 0.023451125249266624, 0.01408314984291792, -0.010627850890159607, 0.02866525948047638, -0.01152597926557064, -0.0058160037733614445, -0.02357586659491062, -0.007727644871920347, 0.0006065483903512359, -0.02303948439657688, 0.014532214030623436, 0.011076915077865124, 0.03415381908416748, -0.0019942813087254763, 0.018049882724881172, 0.00855716597288847, 0.0024137196596711874, -0.008519744500517845, -0.027093535289168358, 0.008918912149965763, -0.00377650442533195, 0.03595007583498955, -0.004113302566111088, 0.013970883563160896, -0.0330561101436615, 0.00989188440144062, 0.0082765007391572, -0.007521823979914188, 0.02814135141670704, 0.008432426489889622, 0.02644488587975502, 0.050370026379823685, 0.01816214807331562, -0.025135116651654243, -0.02649478241801262, -0.008794172666966915, -0.016141360625624657, 0.020083144307136536, 0.05014549195766449, -0.008875253610312939, 0.02098127268254757, 0.039417851716279984, -0.001613824162632227, -0.000873959856107831, -0.026619521901011467, -0.001894489279948175, -0.010316000320017338, 0.018336784094572067, -0.018024934455752373, 0.0016652793856337667, -0.0017089383909478784, 0.005401243455708027, 0.027193326503038406, 0.016777534037828445, -0.009474005550146103, -0.016964644193649292, -0.024623682722449303, 0.02363823540508747, 0.0021096658892929554, -0.010303526185452938, 0.014943855814635754, 0.025097694247961044, -0.013471923768520355, 0.0383949801325798, -0.04390849173069, -0.023226594552397728, 0.014444896019995213, 0.040390823036432266, 0.008438663557171822, 0.003530142828822136, -0.0066673546098172665, 0.011850303038954735, 0.019571710377931595, 0.01151974219828844, -0.031010372564196587, 0.030137192457914352, 0.030611203983426094, -0.01600414514541626, 0.02367565780878067, 0.016715163365006447, 0.002745839999988675, -0.02864031121134758, 0.02968812733888626, 0.004593551624566317, 0.008101864717900753, 0.001602909411303699, -0.0021439692936837673, -0.004181909374892712, -0.0032494778279215097, 0.05194174870848656, 0.027218274772167206, -0.00936797633767128, 0.000059592599427560344, -0.048199549317359924, 0.004612262826412916, 0.016153834760189056, -0.02861536294221878, -0.022964639589190483, -0.02312680147588253, -0.028365883976221085, 0.011476082727313042, -0.010035335086286068, 0.014494791626930237, 0.02264031581580639, -0.03809560462832451, 0.01819957047700882, 0.009767144918441772, 0.01862368732690811, -0.017313916236162186, -0.005538457538932562, -0.006112261675298214, -0.0011304565705358982, 0.026569627225399017, 0.0006194122252054513, -0.012523898854851723, -0.015430341474711895, -0.015492712147533894, -0.02639499120414257, 0.006954256910830736, -0.015505186282098293, 0.02308937907218933, -0.012243234552443027, 0.03410392627120018, -0.010939700528979301, -0.012293130159378052, 0.020145514979958534, 0.04201244190335274, 0.0021439692936837673, 0.024598734453320503, 0.004234923981130123, -0.016889799386262894, 0.014519739896059036, -0.008095627650618553, -0.007609141990542412, -0.005354465916752815, 0.005267147906124592, -0.0302619319409132, 0.013883565552532673, 0.041613273322582245, -0.044432397931814194, -0.013983357697725296, -0.015343023464083672, -0.05244071036577225, -0.010103942826390266, -0.03422866389155388, -0.010484399273991585, 0.0023700606543570757, -0.02259041927754879, -0.055933430790901184, -0.0037359639536589384, -0.01711433194577694, -0.011738036759197712, -0.03380454704165459, 0.022952165454626083, -0.021193331107497215, -0.009679826907813549, 0.0151559142395854, -0.016827430576086044, -0.022752581164240837, 0.002033262513577938, -0.029039479792118073, 0.0275924950838089, -0.009180866181850433, 0.00729729188606143, 0.0036798310466110706, -0.0050394972786307335, 0.03258209675550461, -0.0022655907087028027, 0.011625770479440689, 0.04168811812996864, 0.028291039168834686, -0.044282712042331696, 0.01429520733654499, 0.03138459101319313, -0.0275924950838089, -0.04183780774474144, 0.00703533785417676, -0.00909978523850441, -0.018923062831163406, 0.016790008172392845, -0.0031559227500110865, 0.016952170059084892, -0.008762987330555916, 0.008507270365953445, -0.002918916754424572, -0.020270254462957382, -0.008220368064939976, 0.03812055289745331, 0.03143448755145073, 0.01701454073190689, 0.012012464925646782, 0.026120562106370926, -0.007771303877234459, 0.03732221573591232, 0.04001660272479057, -0.010415792465209961, 0.004256753716617823, -0.027692286297678947, 0.03148438408970833, 0.02530975267291069, 0.03507689759135246, -0.015817036852240562, 0.010528058744966984, 0.0005882272380404174, -0.021866926923394203, -0.0192972831428051, -0.005934507120400667, -0.04453219100832939, 0.00028417338035069406, 0.021754661574959755, -0.014394999481737614, 0.02207898534834385, -0.017413709312677383, 0.00963616743683815, 0.010814961045980453, -0.03143448755145073, 0.01180040743201971, 0.01591682806611061, -0.020632000640034676, 0.002056651283055544, 0.002953220158815384, -0.005332636181265116, -0.037646543234586716, 0.0032993739005178213, 0.005547812674194574, 0.0056444862857460976, 0.0024324306286871433, -0.0109771229326725, -0.006648643873631954, -0.023937612771987915, -0.008482322096824646, -0.032232824712991714, -0.009243235923349857, 0.015530133619904518, -0.00701662665233016, 0.0022297280374914408, -0.0034116399474442005, 0.025484388694167137, 0.02421204000711441, 0.003985444083809853, -0.04994590952992439, 0.017363812774419785, 0.0076839858666062355, 0.0033336773049086332, -0.0047650691121816635, -0.032207876443862915, -0.003938666544854641, 0.02584613487124443, -0.019160069525241852, 0.010078994557261467, -0.008108101785182953, -0.023014536127448082, 0.026295198127627373, 0.006121617276221514, 0.02918916754424572, 0.010278578847646713, 0.019559236243367195, -0.012885645031929016, -0.0275924950838089, 0.007166314870119095, -0.015642400830984116, -0.00495529780164361, -0.012230760417878628, 0.004113302566111088, 0.0302369836717844, 0.03517669066786766, 0.012018701992928982, -0.03490225970745087, 0.00967358984053135, -0.010777538642287254, -0.026020770892500877, -0.05288977175951004, -0.002457378664985299, -0.027193326503038406, 0.013297287747263908, 0.0193097572773695, -0.026869002729654312, 0.018049882724881172, 0.021168382838368416, 0.00854469183832407, -0.027118483558297157, -0.0020971917547285557, 0.015343023464083672, -0.00016099259664770216, -0.002226609503850341, 0.02696879394352436, -0.0009527020156383514, 0.017363812774419785, 0.006679828744381666, -0.0036735939793288708, -0.005578998010605574, 0.049372103065252304, 0.014494791626930237, 0.03807065635919571, -0.02096879854798317, 0.018274415284395218, 0.010384608060121536, 0.0028877316508442163, 0.022128881886601448, -0.004836794920265675, 0.017301442101597786, -0.017251545563340187, 0.010384608060121536, -0.04141369089484215, -0.004169435705989599, -0.03642408922314644, -0.017251545563340187, 0.00261018518358469, -0.02537212334573269, -0.007627852726727724, 0.019422022625803947, 0.04116421192884445, -0.022315992042422295, -0.02041994407773018, 0.004178790841251612, -0.013384605757892132, 0.00854469183832407, -0.05169226974248886, -0.018498945981264114, -0.003212055889889598, 0.0005523644504137337, -0.0009332113550044596, 0.001154624973423779, -0.039367955178022385, 0.013334709219634533, 0.030286880210042, -0.03353011980652809, 0.04742616042494774, 0.0718003585934639, -0.012130968272686005, 0.03457793593406677, -0.05608311668038368, 0.0074095577001571655, -0.016802482306957245, -0.011750510893762112, -0.0013869531685486436, -0.021580025553703308, 0.03599997237324715, -0.014507265761494637, 0.009592507965862751, 0.013209969736635685, -0.023550918325781822, 0.0016606017015874386, -0.015343023464083672, 0.00964864157140255, 0.019147595390677452, -0.013609137386083603, 0.020257780328392982, -0.015841983258724213, -0.0663616955280304, 0.015866931527853012, 0.010365896858274937, 0.027841975912451744, -0.014644479379057884, 0.03188355267047882, 0.02528480440378189, 0.012012464925646782, 0.005404361989349127, 0.006841990631073713, 0.008220368064939976, -0.029962556436657906, 0.021255701780319214, -0.017251545563340187 ]
12.22233
6.504461
2024-07-01
1
2024A&A...687A.117F
[ "quiescent galaxies", "passive galaxy growth", "intermediate redshift", "redshift", "MSR", "several processes", "LD", "minor mergers", "the quiescent galaxies", "the quiescent population" ]
[ "galaxies: elliptical and lenticular", "cD", "galaxies: evolution", "galaxies: formation", "galaxies: fundamental parameters", "galaxies: structure", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
49
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202347774", "10.48550/arXiv.2404.14103" ]
[ "Figueira, M.", "Siudek, M.", "Pollo, A.", "Krywult, J.", "Vergani, D.", "Bolzonella, M.", "Cucciati, O.", "Iovino, A." ]
[ "Max-Planck-Institut für Radioastronomie, Auf dem Hügel 69, 53121, Bonn, Germany ; National Centre for Nuclear Research, Pasteura 7, 02-093, Warszawa, Poland", "Institute of Space Sciences (ICE, CSIC), Campus UAB, Carrer de Can Magrans, s/n, 08193, Barcelona, Spain", "National Centre for Nuclear Research, Pasteura 7, 02-093, Warszawa, Poland; Astronomical Observatory of the Jagiellonian University, Orla 171, 30-244, Kraków, Poland", "Institute of Physics, Jan Kochanowski University, ul. Swiętokrzyska 15, 25-406, Kielce, Poland", "INAF - Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio, Via Piero Gobetti 93/3, 40129, Bologna, Italy", "INAF - Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio, Via Piero Gobetti 93/3, 40129, Bologna, Italy", "INAF - Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio, Via Piero Gobetti 93/3, 40129, Bologna, Italy", "INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Brera, Via Brera 28, 20122 Milano, Via E. Bianchi 46, 23807, Merate, Italy" ]
[ "2024arXiv240614613N" ]
[ "1936rene.book.....H", "1963BAAA....6...41S", "1969A&A.....3..455M", "1974ApJS...27...21O", "1980ApJ...236..351D", "1983ApJ...273..105B", "1983MNRAS.202..615P", "1984A&A...132..389P", "1985A&A...149..330B", "1992ApJ...392...41C", "1994ApJS...95..107W", "1996A&AS..117..393B", "1999A&A...352..447C", "1999ApJ...527...54B", "1999MNRAS.310..540A", "2000A&AS..141..371G", "2000AJ....120.1579Y", "2000ApJ...533..682C", "2001AJ....122...38T", "2001MNRAS.328.1039C", "2002AJ....124..266P", "2003MNRAS.341...33K", "2003MNRAS.343..978S", "2003MNRAS.344.1000B", "2003PASJ...55..757G", "2003PASP..115..763C", "2003SPIE.4841.1670L", "2003astro.ph..6581C", "2004ApJ...608..752B", "2004ApJ...612..168P", "2004MNRAS.351.1151B", "2005A&A...439..845L", "2005AJ....130.2647V", "2005ApJ...626..680D", "2005MNRAS.362..689P", "2005Natur.435..629S", "2006A&A...457..841I", "2006ApJ...636L..81N", "2006ApJ...648L..21K", "2006ApJ...650...18T", "2006ApJ...650..791C", "2006MNRAS.370..198C", "2006MNRAS.373L..36T", "2007A&A...465..711F", "2007A&A...476.1179B", "2007ApJ...656...66Z", "2007ApJS..172..284C", "2007MNRAS.375....2D", "2007MNRAS.376.1445C", "2008A&A...482...21C", "2008A&A...486..683G", "2008ApJ...672..153C", "2008ApJ...677L...5V", "2008ApJ...681..232L", "2008ApJ...683L..17T", "2008ApJ...684..888P", "2008ApJ...688...48V", "2008ApJ...688..770F", "2008ApJ...689L.101F", "2008MNRAS.388.1537M", "2008gady.book.....B", "2009A&A...493...39M", "2009A&A...501..505L", "2009AIPC.1111..183R", "2009ApJ...690.1236I", "2009ApJ...690.1452N", "2009ApJ...691.1879W", "2009ApJ...695..101D", "2009ApJ...697.1290B", "2009ApJ...699L.178N", "2009ApJ...706L..86N", "2009MNRAS.392..718S", "2009MNRAS.394.1213W", "2009MNRAS.394.1825F", "2009MNRAS.398.1129G", "2010A&A...518L...2P", "2010A&A...523A..13P", "2010ApJ...708..505K", "2010ApJ...709..644I", "2010ApJ...713..738W", "2010ApJ...718...86K", "2010ApJ...718.1158L", "2010ApJ...718.1460F", "2010ApJ...721..193P", "2010ApJ...725.2312O", "2010JKAS...43..191C", "2010MNRAS.401.1552D", "2010MNRAS.402..282M", "2010MNRAS.408L..21S", "2010PASP..122..827G", "2011A&A...530A..20L", "2011ApJ...732...12R", "2011ApJ...739L..44D", "2011ApJ...742..103L", "2011MNRAS.410.1660D", "2011MNRAS.412.2707S", "2011MNRAS.412L...6B", "2011MNRAS.414.3690R", "2011MNRAS.415.3903T", "2012A&A...548A...7L", "2012ApJ...745..130R", "2012ApJ...746..162N", "2012ApJ...750...93P", "2012ApJ...754....3T", "2012ApJ...754...26J", "2012ApJ...754L..29W", "2012MNRAS.419.3018C", "2012MNRAS.422.1014I", "2012MNRAS.422L..62C", "2013A&A...556A..55I", "2013A&A...558A..67A", "2013ApJ...762...77P", "2013ApJ...770...58B", "2013ApJ...772..118S", "2013ApJ...773..112C", "2013ApJ...778L...2C", "2013ApJ...779...29H", "2013MNRAS.428..109S", "2013MNRAS.428..641O", "2013MNRAS.428.1088M", "2013MNRAS.428.1715H", "2013MNRAS.434..325F", "2013MNRAS.435..207L", "2013Msngr.151...41G", "2013RMxAA..49..137F", "2014A&A...562A..23G", "2014A&A...563A..92F", "2014A&A...565A..67C", "2014A&A...567A..94S", "2014A&A...571A..69D", "2014ApJ...783..117B", "2014ApJ...788...28V", "2014ApJ...788...51N", "2014ApJ...794...65M", "2014ApJ...797...17K", "2014ApJS..211...17A", "2014ApJS..212....2G", "2014MNRAS.441..203D", "2014MNRAS.444..682C", "2014MNRAS.444..906F", "2014MNRAS.445..970D", "2015A&A...576A.103B", "2015ApJ...799..206B", "2015ApJ...804..117M", "2015ApJ...806....3A", "2015MNRAS.447.2603L", "2015MNRAS.450.1246K", "2016A&A...586A..23D", "2016A&A...590A.102M", "2016A&A...590A.103M", "2016A&A...592A.132G", "2016ApJ...824...68Z", "2016ApJ...830...89M", "2016ApJS..222...10S", "2016MNRAS.455.3911D", "2016MNRAS.456..300O", "2016MNRAS.458.3181C", "2016MNRAS.461..458D", "2016MNRAS.462.1470L", "2017A&A...597A.107S", "2017A&A...597A.122S", "2017A&A...598A.120K", "2017A&A...602A..15C", "2017A&A...604A..54K", "2017A&A...605A...4H", "2017A&A...606A.113G", "2017ApJ...834...73Y", "2017ApJ...839...71F", "2017MNRAS.464.2910S", "2017MNRAS.465..722F", "2017MNRAS.471.2687B", "2018A&A...609A..84S", "2018A&A...617A..70S", "2018ApJ...854...70J", "2018ApJ...855...85W", "2018ApJ...856....8C", "2018ApJ...859...11S", "2018MNRAS.479.2147M", "2018MNRAS.480..521H", "2018MNRAS.480..768D", "2018MNRAS.480.1415F", "2019A&A...630A..57P", "2019A&A...631A..15G", "2019A&A...631A.156D", "2019A&A...631A.158D", "2019ApJ...872...91D", "2019ApJ...872L..13M", "2019ApJ...872L..14M", "2019ApJ...873...85D", "2019ApJ...876..155S", "2019ApJ...877..103S", "2019ApJ...880...57M", "2019MNRAS.484..595M", "2020A&A...638A.133L", "2020ApJ...889...37W", "2020ApJ...905..170M", "2020MNRAS.496.2673J", "2021A&A...647A..89N", "2021ApJ...921...38K", "2021MNRAS.501.1028Y", "2021MNRAS.505L..84Z", "2021MNRAS.506..928N", "2021MNRAS.507.5272N", "2022A&A...660A..69W", "2022A&A...662A.112E", "2022A&A...666A.131S", "2022A&A...667A..29F", "2022ApJ...929...61D", "2022ApJ...940..168C", "2022MNRAS.512.1262H", "2022MNRAS.512.3828B", "2022MNRAS.513.3893M", "2022MNRAS.514.3410H", "2022RAA....22g5017C", "2023A&A...669A..95L", "2023A&A...670A..95A", "2023A&A...679A..26H", "2023A&A...679A..35P", "2023ApJ...943..149D", "2023ApJ...945..155M", "2023MNRAS.519.4651H", "2023MNRAS.523.4294S", "2023arXiv230602465E", "2024ApJ...962..176W" ]
29162988
2402.09060
Merge and strip: Dark matter-free dwarf galaxies in clusters can be formed by galaxy mergers
Context. Recent observations of galaxy mergers inside galaxy cluster environments, such as NGC 5291 in the vicinity of Abell 3574, report high star formation rates in the ejected tidal tails, which point towards currently developing tidal dwarf galaxies. This prompts the intriguing question whether these newly formed stellar structures could get stripped from the galaxy potential by the cluster and thus populate it with dwarf galaxies. <BR /> Aims: We verify whether environmental stripping of tidal dwarf galaxies from galaxy mergers inside galaxy cluster environments is a possible evolutionary channel to populate a galaxy cluster with low-mass and low surface brightness galaxies. <BR /> Methods: We performed three high-resolution hydrodynamical simulations of mergers between spiral galaxies in a cluster environment, implementing a stellar mass ratio of 2:1 with M<SUB>200</SUB> = 9.5 × 10<SUP>11</SUP> M<SUB>⊙</SUB> for the more massive galaxy. Between the three different simulations, we varied the initial orbit of the infalling galaxies with respect to the cluster center. <BR /> Results: We demonstrate that cluster environments are capable of stripping tidal dwarf galaxies from the host potential independently of the infall orbit of the merging galaxy pair, without instantly destroying the tidal dwarfs. Starting to evolve separately from their progenitor, these newly formed dwarf galaxies reach total masses of M<SUB>tot</SUB> ≈ 10<SUP>7 − 9</SUP> M<SUB>⊙</SUB> within the limits of our resolution. In the three tested orbit scenarios, we find three, seven, and eight tidal dwarf galaxies per merger, respectively, which survive longer than 1 Gyr after the merger event. Exposed to ram pressure, these gas dominated dwarf galaxies exhibit high star formation rates while also losing gas to the environment. Experiencing a strong headwind due to their motion through the intracluster medium, they quickly lose momentum and start spiraling towards the cluster center, reaching distances on the order of 1 Mpc from their progenitor. About 4 Gyr after the merger event, we still find three and four intact dwarf galaxies in two of the tested scenarios, respectively. The other stripped tidal dwarf galaxies either evaporate in the hostile cluster environment due to their low initial mass, or are disrupted as soon as they reach the cluster center. <BR /> Conclusions: The dwarf production rate due to galaxy mergers is elevated when the interaction with a cluster environment is taken into account. Comparing their contribution to the observed galaxy mass function in clusters, our results indicate that ∼30% of dwarf galaxies in clusters could have been formed by stripping from galaxy mergers. <P />Movie associated to Fig. 3 is available at <A href="https://www.aanda.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202449605/olm">https://www.aanda.org</A>.
[ 0.01529824547469616, 0.052931930869817734, -0.0021178508177399635, 0.02039766125380993, 0.019173800945281982, 0.027332864701747894, 0.04018339142203331, 0.027995789423584938, -0.031361404806375504, 0.05808233842253685, -0.009051461704075336, -0.03633333370089531, -0.05502269044518471, -0.01293976604938507, 0.013819415122270584, -0.0007848318782635033, 0.0039647952653467655, -0.022526666522026062, -0.022832632064819336, 0.06476256996393204, 0.019772982224822044, 0.01654760167002678, -0.0014126973692327738, 0.014252865687012672, -0.043727483600378036, -0.02349555492401123, 0.04334503039717674, -0.012799532152712345, 0.0272818710654974, -0.0009513596305623651, 0.021978478878736496, -0.014163625426590443, -0.039596959948539734, 0.019887719303369522, -0.03426807001233101, 0.12473169714212418, 0.03156537935137749, 0.027077894657850266, -0.04352350905537605, -0.0100012281909585, -0.007457894738763571, 0.014176374301314354, -0.008828362450003624, 0.02695040963590145, -0.000791604514233768, -0.007349532097578049, -0.01100198831409216, -0.03607836365699768, 0.018740350380539894, 0.00012111110845580697, -0.03702175244688988, 0.003030964871868491, 0.019619999453425407, -0.010485672391951084, -0.042299650609493256, -0.04212116822600365, -0.003999853972345591, -0.0032285673078149557, -0.04472187161445618, -0.008783742785453796, 0.014813801273703575, 0.0004912171280011535, 0.034497544169425964, 0.00801883079111576, -0.01024982426315546, 0.04061684384942055, 0.017248772084712982, 0.03375812992453575, 0.014864794909954071, 0.05201403424143791, -0.015234502963721752, -0.06165193021297455, 0.005956754554063082, 0.004752017557621002, 0.013067251071333885, -0.02980608120560646, 0.03579789400100708, 0.005733654834330082, -0.07445146143436432, 0.022615905851125717, 0.02712888829410076, -0.0013226608280092478, 0.01839614100754261, 0.015769941732287407, -0.014724561013281345, 0.011562923900783062, -0.022297192364931107, 0.0038946783170104027, -0.06093801185488701, 0.060887016355991364, 0.02420947328209877, -0.010702397674322128, 0.0016780262812972069, -0.01155017502605915, 0.0006665094988420606, -0.03867906332015991, 0.012136608362197876, -0.033350177109241486, 0.05066268891096115, 0.04288608208298683, 0.0051057892851531506, 0.014240116812288761, 0.009688888676464558, -0.06246783584356308, 0.059663157910108566, -0.046404678374528885, -0.013526198454201221, -0.0066993567161262035, 0.00678222207352519, 0.03097894787788391, 0.03278924152255058, 0.0026628507766872644, 0.009561403654515743, 0.01615239679813385, -0.01786070130765438, 0.015412982553243637, -0.030035555362701416, 0.06364069879055023, -0.0385005846619606, 0.006090614013373852, -0.019798479974269867, -0.03980093449354172, -0.011205964721739292, 0.015540467575192451, 0.03490549698472023, -0.021328303962945938, 0.06670035421848297, -0.020308421924710274, -0.06511953473091125, -0.0019951462745666504, 0.023776022717356682, 0.027868304401636124, -0.024362456053495407, 0.0018007309408858418, -0.04395695775747299, -0.021800000220537186, 0.0028461110778152943, -0.020627133548259735, 0.0023505117278546095, 0.03373263031244278, 0.004627719055861235, -0.020486900582909584, 0.0299080703407526, 0.023380817845463753, 0.004407806787639856, 0.0278428066521883, -0.023431813344359398, 0.03273824602365494, -0.028531227260828018, 0.024502690881490707, 0.030112046748399734, 0.010594035498797894, -0.0033592397812753916, -0.004372748546302319, -0.01956900581717491, -0.03544093668460846, -0.039494968950748444, 0.008063450455665588, 0.0001450146228307858, -0.07113683968782425, -0.06547649204730988, -0.011703157797455788, -0.047654036432504654, 0.004267572890967131, -0.01395964901894331, -0.005249210633337498, -0.015629706904292107, 0.022131461650133133, -0.08266151696443558, -0.03062198869884014, 0.011735029518604279, -0.012531813234090805, -0.05344187095761299, -0.00631052628159523, -0.04660865664482117, 0.03694526478648186, -0.03439555689692497, -0.05854128673672676, 0.013730175793170929, 0.001195175456814468, 0.03411508724093437, 0.03842409327626228, -0.016177894547581673, -0.06787321716547012, -0.052319999784231186, 0.0358743853867054, -0.026669941842556, 0.02160877175629139, 0.004493859596550465, -0.0034962864592671394, -0.0518355555832386, 0.013946900144219398, -0.04018339142203331, 0.056246548891067505, 0.003378362627699971, -0.011358947493135929, 0.006960701663047075, 0.03447204828262329, 0.030902456492185593, 0.03773567080497742, 0.045767251402139664, 0.031131930649280548, 0.014979531988501549, -0.027434853836894035, -0.023865263909101486, -0.022054970264434814, 0.02464292384684086, -0.0005617324495688081, 0.00619578966870904, 0.00764912273734808, 0.05905122682452202, 0.008076198399066925, -0.04043836146593094, -0.016917310655117035, -0.026746433228254318, -0.014163625426590443, -0.03131040930747986, 0.02299836277961731, 0.04905637353658676, 0.00464365491643548, 0.01942877098917961, 0.031998831778764725, 0.03454853966832161, 0.021162573248147964, 0.02353380061686039, -0.030647484585642815, 0.008936725556850433, -0.05288093537092209, 0.012557310052216053, 0.03516046702861786, 0.010262573137879372, 0.011773275211453438, -0.025407835841178894, -0.04495134577155113, 0.031004443764686584, -0.019581753760576248, -0.009204444475471973, 0.05415578931570053, 0.0050324853509664536, -0.016203392297029495, -0.017299765720963478, 0.03197333216667175, 0.019020818173885345, 0.016713332384824753, -0.003754444420337677, 0.0323047935962677, -0.011703157797455788, -0.020410409197211266, -0.018447134643793106, -0.003744882997125387, 0.04831695929169655, -0.00381499994546175, -0.008898479864001274, 0.006444385740906, -0.024196725338697433, -0.023151345551013947, -0.002320233965292573, 0.02542058564722538, -0.0005390241276472807, 0.036460816860198975, -0.01714678294956684, -0.06420163810253143, -0.043982457369565964, 0.020270176231861115, -0.01835789531469345, 0.032534267753362656, 0.06292678415775299, -0.012595555745065212, -0.02545882947742939, 0.028505731374025345, -0.039341989904642105, -0.044160936027765274, 0.023304328322410583, -0.02567555569112301, -0.045767251402139664, 0.01467356737703085, 0.01956900581717491, 0.03169286623597145, 0.021723508834838867, -0.0149540351703763, 0.016534853726625443, -0.02791929803788662, 0.020231930539011955, 0.006967076100409031, -0.0018405701266601682, 0.01918654888868332, 0.008828362450003624, 0.012531813234090805, 0.019377777352929115, -0.017605731263756752, 0.05226900428533554, -0.03939298167824745, -0.0046850875951349735, -0.006074678152799606, -0.02927064336836338, -0.042988069355487823, -0.01704479567706585, 0.005121725145727396, -0.06420163810253143, 0.028837192803621292, 0.034242574125528336, 0.018957076594233513, 0.0016302192816510797, 0.01369193010032177, -0.04607321694493294, -0.028250759467482567, 0.036307837814092636, -0.021328303962945938, 0.016483860090374947, 0.033350177109241486, -0.009778128936886787, -0.02613450214266777, -0.010753392241895199, 0.031284913420677185, -0.003987105097621679, 0.003633333370089531, -0.0385005846619606, 0.0545637421309948, 0.04752654954791069, -0.0387810543179512, -0.06262081861495972, -0.05864327400922775, -0.04770502820611, 0.013029005378484726, 0.022972865030169487, -0.03564491122961044, -0.0009601242491044104, -0.04020888730883598, -0.027868304401636124, -0.0034293567296117544, 0.011084853671491146, 0.019619999453425407, 0.03426807001233101, 0.022654151543974876, 0.013806666247546673, -0.04375298321247101, 0.028225263580679893, 0.023623039945960045, 0.022717894986271858, 0.04258011654019356, -0.010638655163347721, 0.003531344933435321, 0.02570105344057083, -0.02281988225877285, 0.004200643394142389, 0.0076108770444989204, 0.030749473720788956, 0.03472701832652092, 0.052218012511730194, 0.006183040793985128, -0.005685847718268633, -0.016802573576569557, 0.01098286546766758, -0.040871813893318176, 0.004809386096894741, 0.02303660847246647, 0.04010690003633499, -0.060275088995695114, -0.010402807034552097, 0.040055904537439346, 0.040846314281225204, -0.02517836168408394, 0.004375935532152653, 0.024375203996896744, -0.00561573076993227, 0.032814737409353256, -0.057674385607242584, 0.015234502963721752, -0.027715321630239487, -0.014699064195156097, 0.015400233678519726, -0.0007043567020446062, -0.017707718536257744, 0.014533333480358124, -0.06420163810253143, -0.038347601890563965, 0.006890584714710712, 0.025905029848217964, 0.02417122758924961, -0.00864350888878107, 0.027689823880791664, -0.016420116648077965, 0.005402192939072847, -0.02234818786382675, -0.055889591574668884, 0.04456888884305954, -0.004079532343894243, -0.011798772029578686, -0.11912234127521515, 0.008382163941860199, -0.0032285673078149557, 0.0014597076224163175, 0.006814093329012394, 0.026363976299762726, -0.029398128390312195, -0.036027368158102036, -0.022756140679121017, 0.03732771798968315, 0.021226314827799797, 0.03204982355237007, -0.01324573066085577, -0.018306899815797806, -0.023202339187264442, -0.06445660442113876, -0.005883450154215097, 0.013003508560359478, -0.0022995176259428263, 0.017389005050063133, -0.005099415313452482, -0.06200888752937317, 0.03291672468185425, 0.0032668127678334713, 0.030902456492185593, -0.06313075870275497, -0.010390058159828186, 0.04903087764978409, -0.06649637222290039, 0.03679228201508522, -0.025866784155368805, 0.05736842006444931, -0.040948305279016495, -0.02766432799398899, 0.014852046966552734, 0.021200818940997124, -0.051325615495443344, 0.03551742807030678, 0.008994093164801598, 0.03804163634777069, 0.003630146151408553, -0.07093286514282227, -0.04931134358048439, 0.029423626139760017, 0.003091520396992564, -0.011868888512253761, 0.05655251443386078, -0.022475672885775566, 0.03597637265920639, -0.01972198858857155, 0.006947953253984451, -0.040871813893318176, 0.002565643284469843, -0.01356444414705038, -0.004809386096894741, -0.04831695929169655, 0.03386011719703674, 0.020690876990556717, 0.02899017557501793, 0.020474152639508247, -0.029296141117811203, -0.0417897067964077, -0.028352748602628708, -0.008114444091916084, -0.03518596664071083, 0.012270467355847359, -0.046404678374528885, -0.06608842313289642, 0.024260466918349266, -0.02545882947742939, 0.03523695841431618, -0.04064233973622322, 0.004092280752956867, 0.02534409426152706, -0.020512398332357407, -0.000476476619951427, -0.04181520640850067, 0.02182549610733986, 0.0019250292098149657, 0.0049719298258423805, -0.005893011577427387, 0.015820935368537903, 0.05665450170636177, -0.036486316472291946, 0.018370643258094788, 0.008554268628358841, 0.007336783688515425, 0.008496901020407677, -0.008974970318377018, 0.005641228053718805, 0.06195789575576782, 0.002916228026151657, 0.05237099528312683, -0.00418152054771781, -0.013079999946057796, 0.02188923954963684, 0.006584619637578726, 0.027052396908402443, -0.00630096485838294, 0.014533333480358124, -0.02321508713066578, -0.010052221827208996, -0.005660350900143385, -0.004557602107524872, 0.04885239899158478, -0.013755672611296177, -0.003996666520833969, -0.02349555492401123, -0.018957076594233513, -0.022016724571585655, 0.01768222264945507, 0.016139648854732513, 0.054818712174892426, -0.008669005706906319, 0.031131930649280548, -0.01861286535859108, 0.000746586243622005, -0.008656256832182407, -0.013449707999825478, -0.06328374147415161, 0.0069989473558962345, -0.002911447314545512, -0.03169286623597145, 0.00937655009329319, 0.032253801822662354, -0.015846433117985725, 0.014597075991332531, 0.01847263239324093, -0.0420701764523983, 0.00803795363754034, 0.04405894875526428, -0.02424771897494793, 0.0046723391860723495, -0.04033637419342995, 0.00968251470476389, 0.011346198618412018, 0.002205497119575739, -0.018740350380539894, -0.04472187161445618, -0.08337543904781342, -0.04439041018486023, 0.004630906507372856, 0.005638041067868471, 0.004522543866187334, 0.02264140360057354, 0.004978304263204336, -0.03470151871442795, -0.03572140261530876, 0.0005848392029292881, 0.011193216778337955, -0.00962514616549015, 0.0076108770444989204, 0.037378713488578796, 0.03533894568681717, 0.006858713459223509, 0.00011623081081779674, 0.009905613958835602, 0.034421052783727646, -0.010472923517227173, -0.009115204215049744, 0.04464538022875786, 0.017248772084712982, 0.03569590672850609, 0.0005995796527713537, 0.0106577780097723, 0.004477923735976219, 0.001732207601889968, 0.006527251563966274, -0.0037735672667622566, 0.0023074853233993053, 0.015731696039438248, 0.011473684571683407, -0.029755087569355965, 0.004446052480489016, -0.0012135014403611422, 0.013883157633244991, -0.005880263168364763, -0.019976958632469177, -0.00926818698644638, 0.00957415159791708, -0.055175673216581345, 0.024234971031546593, -0.029117660596966743, 0.005842017475515604, 0.017835205420851707, -0.018192164599895477, 0.011046607978641987, -0.0018230408895760775, -0.00567628676071763, 0.028480233624577522, 0.018268654122948647, -0.037633683532476425, -0.03141239657998085, -0.015196257270872593, -0.0029990936163812876, 0.0040253507904708385, -0.045690760016441345, 0.02677192911505699, -0.0015377923846244812, 0.013742923736572266, 0.033885613083839417, -0.025905029848217964, 0.003454853780567646, -0.01589742675423622, 0.014699064195156097, 0.033324677497148514, 0.03355415165424347, -0.00747701758518815, 0.03062198869884014, -0.0014979531988501549, -0.026516959071159363, -0.02573929727077484, -0.00868175458163023, 0.020550644025206566, -0.019173800945281982, -0.03712374344468117, -0.020652631297707558, -0.005577485542744398, 0.006061929743736982, -0.05247298255562782, -0.013079999946057796, 0.020066197961568832, -0.00007853298302507028, 0.014711813069880009, 0.008012455888092518, -0.03768467903137207, -0.006890584714710712, -0.03059649094939232, 0.012729414738714695, -0.008063450455665588, 0.009440292604267597, -0.00727304071187973, -0.002328201662749052, -0.0016509356210008264, 0.005373508669435978, -0.019938712939620018, 0.03141239657998085, -0.000713918125256896, -0.017172280699014664, -0.03238128498196602, -0.0004908186965622008, -0.004442865494638681, 0.0030644298531115055, -0.0367157906293869, 0.02720537967979908, 0.0015107017243281007, -0.024540934711694717, -0.0031217981595546007, 0.00006234832108020782, 0.07378853857517242, -0.01946701668202877, -0.012914269231259823, 0.00933830440044403, 0.013009883463382721, 0.012085613794624805, -0.016879064962267876, 0.0043249414302408695, 0.04464538022875786, -0.0011457748478278518, 0.017185028642416, -0.049897778779268265, -0.008286549709737301, 0.0136409355327487, -0.010396433062851429, 0.044976841658353806, -0.0038819299079477787, 0.024324210360646248, 0.015846433117985725, -0.04530830308794975, -0.01565520465373993, -0.024336958304047585, 0.01946701668202877, -0.01744000054895878, 0.01693005859851837, -0.0018023245502263308, -0.006960701663047075, -0.036562807857990265, -0.012111110612750053, 0.018982572481036186, 0.005851578898727894, -0.01889333315193653, 0.01907181367278099, 0.07638923823833466, -0.01490304060280323, 0.03457403555512428, 0.013500701636075974, -0.008496901020407677, -0.013334970921278, -0.02160877175629139, -0.04092280566692352, 0.007521637249737978, 0.014724561013281345, -0.012378830462694168, 0.012448946945369244, -0.0031265788711607456, 0.026618948206305504, -0.002927382942289114, -0.006967076100409031, -0.0009935891721397638, 0.006422075908631086, 0.01467356737703085, 0.01946701668202877, 0.002450906438753009, -0.042554620653390884, 0.041126783937215805, 0.006622865330427885, 0.00028704130090773106, 0.01101473718881607, 0.003158450359478593, -0.0003766794688999653, 0.018230408430099487, -0.03811812773346901, 0.001401542336679995, 0.0065176901407539845, 0.0028684211429208517, 0.0068650878965854645, -0.00026851607253775, -0.005896199028939009, 0.009319181554019451, 0.01654760167002678, 0.015425730496644974, -0.032712750136852264, 0.04375298321247101, 0.014456842094659805, -0.03822011500597, 0.007604503072798252, -0.020729122683405876, -0.022692397236824036, -0.012397953309118748, 0.008560643531382084, -0.031539883464574814, -0.004321754444390535, 0.029194151982665062, -0.0065654972568154335, -0.06853614002466202, 0.01292701717466116, 0.013181988149881363, -0.0030325583647936583, 0.055277660489082336, 0.023113099858164787, -0.015846433117985725, -0.03161637485027313, 0.010791637003421783, 0.029653098434209824, 0.003330555511638522, -0.016343625262379646, -0.0011664911871775985, 0.054002806544303894, 0.009727134369313717, -0.012238596566021442, -0.001673245569691062, 0.046659648418426514, 0.026287484914064407, 0.012327835895121098, 0.023125847801566124, 0.02093309909105301, 0.02702690102159977, 0.012831403873860836, 0.044543392956256866, 0.0028859502635896206, 0.021404795348644257, 0.01690456084907055, 0.008885730989277363, 0.009816374629735947, 0.01782245561480522, 0.033528655767440796, 0.03347766026854515, -0.015744443982839584, 0.02057613991200924, -0.017567485570907593, 0.03913801163434982, 0.029959063977003098, 0.05415578931570053, 0.028505731374025345, -0.0015083113685250282, 0.04275859519839287, -0.04163672402501106, 0.00798695906996727, -0.06690432876348495, -0.003926549572497606, 0.01825590617954731, -0.020920351147651672, -0.03605286404490471, 0.017032045871019363, 0.033248186111450195, -0.015056023374199867, -0.00323175429366529, 0.007942339405417442, 0.004474736750125885, -0.011690408922731876, 0.0028986989054828882, 0.009293683804571629, 0.005864327307790518, -0.0031457017175853252, -0.02589228004217148, 0.00821643229573965, -0.002849298296496272, -0.007929590530693531, -0.011040234006941319, -0.014737309888005257, -0.0011099196271970868, 0.023648537695407867, -0.033350177109241486, 0.028684210032224655, -0.010651403106749058, 0.030494503676891327, -0.033783625811338425, 0.0012158917961642146, -0.026746433228254318, -0.11453286558389664, -0.002036578953266144, 0.030749473720788956, -0.002391944406554103, 0.0009975731372833252, 0.038092631846666336, 0.006275468040257692, -0.009076959453523159, 0.01861286535859108, -0.006355146411806345, -0.0004111403541173786, -0.03488000109791756, 0.03176935762166977, 0.0035536549985408783, 0.024681169539690018, -0.006763099227100611, -0.021812748163938522, -0.009491286240518093, 0.016636842861771584, 0.0002924196014646441, -0.011894386261701584, 0.004602222237735987, -0.0010222734417766333, 0.007209298200905323, 0.013577193021774292, -0.047552045434713364, 0.000039565285987919196, -0.0018246344989165664, -0.006743976380676031, -0.012748537585139275, 0.021022338420152664, 0.007712865248322487, -0.02167251519858837, 0.03222830221056938, -0.022093215957283974, -0.027434853836894035, -0.007923216558992863, 0.04831695929169655, -0.042376141995191574, 0.00646350858733058, 0.006096988450735807, -0.0019250292098149657, 0.05068818852305412, 0.02224619872868061, 0.0035058478824794292, -0.021991228684782982, -0.007961462251842022, 0.020486900582909584, -0.004366374108940363, 0.024744912981987, 0.020984092727303505, -0.012831403873860836, 0.03062198869884014, 0.001915467786602676, 0.01728701777756214, 0.015961170196533203, -0.002103508682921529, -0.02891368418931961, 0.013972397893667221, -0.0070116957649588585, 0.004978304263204336, 0.03595087677240372, -0.0014198684366419911, -0.02502538077533245, -0.05354385823011398, -0.036205846816301346, -0.02909216284751892, 0.005201403517276049, 0.0013027412351220846, -0.019836725667119026, 0.0032014765311032534, 0.01847263239324093, 0.023508304730057716, 0.03921450302004814, 0.00298634497448802, -0.00039221675251610577, -0.01946701668202877, 0.044976841658353806, -0.0025688305031508207, -0.0030580556485801935, -0.03312070295214653, 0.0025353655219078064, 0.028760701417922974, 0.011722280643880367, 0.02032116986811161, -0.003207850968465209, -0.01228321623057127, -0.011594795621931553, -0.000446995603851974, 0.013857660815119743, 0.0032381287310272455, 0.009389298036694527, -0.0158719290047884, -0.034370057284832, -0.0043376898393034935, 0.008477778173983097, -0.0016071125864982605, -0.055787600576877594, 0.025216607376933098, -0.005188655108213425, -0.013513450510799885, 0.00029759868630208075, -0.0052587720565497875, 0.0040380991995334625, 0.010791637003421783, -0.0007414071587845683, 0.03689426928758621, 0.03317169472575188, -0.0026628507766872644, 0.014558830298483372, 0.024438947439193726, 0.02281988225877285, -0.02085660770535469, 0.017376257106661797, 0.053033918142318726, -0.00191228068433702, -0.023074854165315628, 0.01125058438628912, -0.013232982717454433, -0.0017449561273679137, 0.020741870626807213, 0.00536713469773531, -0.05614456161856651, -0.0008206871571019292, 0.012487192638218403, 0.0023521052207797766, 0.017414502799510956, -0.008133566938340664, -0.006240409333258867, 0.01853637397289276, 0.0022819882724434137, -0.007030818611383438, 0.007955087348818779, 0.009478538297116756, 0.0026724121998995543, 0.006122485268861055, 0.004904999863356352, 0.05543064326047897, 0.03516046702861786, 0.026797426864504814, -0.029959063977003098, -0.012774035334587097, -0.003397485474124551, -0.00996298249810934, 0.015017777681350708, 0.0021003216970711946, 0.003085146192461252, -0.022080468013882637, 0.01427836250513792, 0.011875263415277004, 0.00452891830354929, 0.03783766180276871, -0.018957076594233513, 0.006654737051576376, 0.010300818830728531, -0.018383391201496124, 0.0033751754090189934, 0.01647111028432846, -0.006584619637578726, 0.005287456326186657, 0.04862292483448982, 0.03403859585523605, 0.02228444442152977, -0.05022924020886421, -0.002031798241659999, 0.039596959948539734, -0.019237544387578964, 0.006348771974444389, -0.018408888950943947, -0.023584796115756035, -0.023661285638809204, -0.03095345012843609, 0.03416608273983002, -0.00024421417037956417, -0.02010444365441799, -0.010619532316923141, -0.004082719329744577, 0.007171052508056164, 0.006014122627675533, 0.02809777855873108, -0.010115965269505978, -0.006511315703392029, 0.0027489035855978727, -0.020333917811512947, 0.008356666192412376, -0.009841871447861195, -0.013271228410303593, 0.03080046735703945, 0.014469590969383717, 0.014826549217104912, -0.008586140349507332, 0.05318690091371536, -0.010077719576656818, 0.029245145618915558, 0.022577660158276558, 0.02881169505417347, -0.025229357182979584, 0.012468069791793823, -0.008694502525031567, 0.002796710468828678, -0.017962690442800522, -0.0420701764523983, -0.0006521674222312868, -0.03238128498196602, 0.009185321629047394, -0.02589228004217148, -0.002806271892040968, -0.0005884246784262359, -0.03115742653608322, -0.016305379569530487, 0.009472163394093513, 0.02809777855873108, 0.0016461549093946815, 0.014265613630414009, 0.056501518934965134, -0.007961462251842022, 0.030570993199944496, -0.01722327433526516, -0.011097602546215057, -0.023584796115756035, -0.0023122660350054502, -0.049081869423389435, -0.032814737409353256, 0.015361987985670567, -0.019518012180924416, 0.038985028862953186, 0.025611812248826027, 0.00937655009329319, -0.010791637003421783, 0.0022453363053500652, 0.01226409338414669, 0.00823555514216423, -0.020920351147651672, 0.009204444475471973, -0.05532865598797798, 0.005083479452878237, 0.0076299998909235, 0.01764397695660591, -0.010498421266674995, 0.028939181938767433, 0.05369684100151062, 0.013883157633244991, 0.012678421102464199, -0.01579543948173523, -0.002258084714412689, -0.007049941457808018, 0.009300058707594872, -0.012136608362197876, 0.007904093712568283, -0.03337567299604416, -0.02649146132171154, 0.003945672418922186, -0.01328397635370493, 0.01454608142375946, 0.009159824810922146, 0.02730736881494522, -0.007445146329700947, 0.03755719214677811, 0.02270514704287052, -0.003445292357355356, 0.01165853813290596, -0.006055555306375027, -0.03676678240299225, -0.014686315320432186, -0.008503274992108345, 0.0002390350855421275, -0.044976841658353806, -0.005947193130850792, 0.013934152200818062, -0.029933568090200424, 0.026542456820607185, 0.0038978655356913805, 0.002194342203438282, 0.010045847855508327, 0.0007358297007158399, -0.010479298420250416, 0.0003442105371505022, -0.005163157824426889, -0.02542058564722538, 0.0066866083070635796, -0.011327075771987438, -0.024948889389634132, -0.007266666740179062, 0.015782689675688744, 0.016126900911331177, -0.004446052480489016, -0.018944326788187027, -0.008821988478302956, 0.030010057613253593, -0.019836725667119026, -0.013946900144219398, 0.013730175793170929, 0.02085660770535469, 0.00791684165596962, 0.02125181257724762, -0.053033918142318726, -0.015451228246092796, 0.016381870955228806, -0.01356444414705038, -0.01565520465373993, -0.03115742653608322, -0.014150877483189106, 0.009446666575968266, -0.01803918182849884, -0.011779649183154106, 0.005230087786912918, -0.004423742648214102, -0.0320243276655674, -0.0246046781539917, 0.0034962864592671394, -0.0032668127678334713, 0.0123724564909935, -0.013156491331756115, 0.009727134369313717, -0.02292187139391899, 0.010753392241895199, 0.017376257106661797, 0.016700584441423416, -0.006610116921365261, 0.006045994348824024, -0.03133590519428253, 0.011091227643191814, 0.036027368158102036, 0.009070584550499916, -0.039596959948539734, -0.004506608005613089, -0.002508274745196104, -0.002559269079938531, 0.04232514649629593, 0.020346665754914284, 0.01782245561480522, 0.005975877400487661, 0.029653098434209824, -0.0063997660763561726, -0.006402953062206507, 0.02371228113770485, -0.014444093219935894, 0.004022163804620504, 0.009484912268817425, 0.005003801081329584, -0.0013640935067087412, 0.01661134511232376, -0.04734807088971138, 0.03062198869884014, -0.006297777872532606, 0.017771461978554726, 0.005038859788328409, -0.023878011852502823, 0.02146853879094124, -0.012340584769845009, 0.07995883375406265, -0.01682806946337223, -0.06083602458238602, -0.018230408430099487, 0.052218012511730194, -0.02032116986811161, -0.002932163653895259, -0.006243596319109201, -0.020665379241108894, -0.005969502963125706, -0.01196450274437666, -0.0018835965311154723, 0.007687368430197239, 0.022016724571585655, 0.02299836277961731, 0.012818654999136925, -0.008127192966639996, 0.019199298694729805, 0.0045990352518856525, -0.013309474103152752, -0.014699064195156097, 0.005297017749398947, -0.016381870955228806, 0.04278409481048584, -0.0015138888265937567, 0.004254824481904507, 0.03964795172214508, 0.000044943575630895793, -0.0017130847554653883, 0.02103508822619915, -0.003346491139382124, -0.005118538159877062, -0.024413449689745903, 0.005590233951807022, -0.026746433228254318, -0.01932678371667862, -0.013169239275157452, -0.0072857895866036415, 0.02345730923116207, -0.005121725145727396, 0.0004581505781970918, -0.014979531988501549, 0.002871608128771186, -0.028046783059835434, -0.00274093565531075, 0.016662338748574257, -0.0032827486284077168, 0.037710174918174744, -0.0014780336059629917, 0.006214912049472332, -0.03796514496207237, -0.03238128498196602, 0.005778274964541197, -0.0063997660763561726, -0.006973450072109699, 0.03278924152255058, 0.008955847471952438, 0.04439041018486023, 0.027001403272151947, -0.02581578865647316, -0.007795731071382761, -0.01589742675423622, -0.02901567332446575, 0.013768420554697514, 0.01629263162612915, -0.01736350916326046, 0.011913509108126163, 0.013946900144219398, -0.00898771919310093, 0.016088655218482018, -0.012767660431563854, 0.007993333041667938, -0.00631052628159523, 0.0009680921211838722, -0.018485380336642265, -0.010281695984303951, -0.02164701744914055, 0.020512398332357407, -0.005169532261788845, 0.011422690004110336, -0.025305848568677902, -0.019263040274381638, 0.004446052480489016, 0.05798035115003586, -0.006571871228516102, 0.002854079008102417, -0.011027485132217407, -0.014061637222766876, -0.018663858994841576, 0.04171321541070938, -0.01693005859851837, -0.03317169472575188, 0.02712888829410076, 0.01726152002811432, 0.0207546204328537, 0.014775555580854416, -0.009561403654515743, 0.020053450018167496, 0.008101696148514748, -0.00431538000702858, -0.015680702403187752, 0.018561871722340584, 0.0284547358751297, -0.014711813069880009, 0.011473684571683407, -0.015285496599972248, -0.0044301170855760574, -0.03143789619207382, -0.014775555580854416, 0.004646841902285814, 0.0004900219500996172, 0.035313449800014496, 0.006422075908631086, 0.02292187139391899, 0.012136608362197876, 0.07159578800201416, 0.030316023156046867, 0.01900807023048401, 0.01037731021642685, -0.025764795020222664, 0.026261989027261734, 0.027332864701747894, -0.01024982426315546, -0.012149356305599213, -0.010173332877457142, -0.0346505269408226, -0.000670493405777961, 0.002970409346744418, 0.020168187096714973, -0.0003501863975543529, -0.029780585318803787, 0.014138128608465195, 0.017809707671403885, 0.0025417397264391184, 0.0022278069518506527, 0.01575719378888607, -0.00863076001405716, -0.004331315867602825, 0.04599672555923462, 0.007177426945418119, 0.012876023538410664, -0.008592514321208, -0.009032338857650757, -0.010702397674322128, 0.02702690102159977, -0.002197529189288616, -0.0033018712420016527, 0.005577485542744398, 0.009867368265986443, -0.0010541446972638369, 0.0032668127678334713, -0.027103392407298088, 0.0018230408895760775, 0.030290525406599045, -0.02677192911505699, -0.0019935525488108397, -0.04125426709651947, 0.015667952597141266, -0.009561403654515743, -0.008713625371456146, 0.0030022806022316217, 0.02817426808178425, -0.002398318611085415, 0.020741870626807213, 0.03250877186655998, -0.002015862613916397, -0.03865356743335724, 0.0031425144989043474, -0.037276726216077805, -0.0060045612044632435, -0.004344064276665449, -0.02998456172645092, 0.012971637770533562, -0.031182924285531044, -0.051427602767944336, 0.0015569152310490608, -0.004229327663779259, 0.005379883106797934, -0.062416840344667435, 0.019454268738627434, 0.007795731071382761, -0.02371228113770485, 0.05716444551944733, -0.01853637397289276, -0.014597075991332531, -0.025943275541067123, -0.015565965324640274, 0.01356444414705038, 0.055073682218790054, -0.004640467930585146, 0.014648070558905602, -0.024324210360646248, -0.0022533040028065443, 0.019581753760576248, 0.009771754033863544, 0.027409356087446213, 0.009497661143541336, -0.01301625743508339, -0.00417195912450552, 0.022475672885775566, -0.010115965269505978, -0.04115227982401848, 0.014852046966552734, -0.014252865687012672, 0.005988625809550285, 0.02659345045685768, -0.004614970646798611, 0.0207546204328537, 0.013857660815119743, -0.00038743604090996087, -0.009599649347364902, -0.0008302485221065581, -0.023074854165315628, -0.0035664034076035023, 0.0164328645914793, 0.014482338912785053, -0.022437427192926407, 0.03814362734556198, -0.017605731263756752, 0.0030708040576428175, 0.009402046911418438, -0.0006242799572646618, -0.0007398136076517403, 0.021583274006843567, -0.008331169374287128, -0.0009951827814802527, 0.05772538110613823, -0.007470643147826195, 0.03625684231519699, 0.023979999125003815, 0.039494968950748444, -0.05028023198246956, 0.005867514759302139, 0.0328657291829586, -0.01257005799561739, 0.013487952761352062, 0.0024046930484473705, 0.030749473720788956, -0.04314105212688446, -0.033528655767440796, 0.011008362285792828, -0.013819415122270584, 0.04242713376879692, 0.0026580700650811195, -0.01329672522842884, 0.03669029101729393, 0.01629263162612915, -0.0008788523264229298, -0.03006105311214924, 0.015680702403187752, 0.0008075402001850307, 0.029576608911156654, 0.03296772018074989, 0.030316023156046867, 0.00825467798858881, -0.01946701668202877, 0.025777542963624, -0.034319065511226654, -0.02613450214266777, 0.013130994513630867, -0.016764327883720398, 0.004487485159188509, -0.00332418130710721, 0.027052396908402443, 0.021876491606235504, 0.014813801273703575, -0.026516959071159363, -0.003862807061523199, 0.03533894568681717, 0.0062308479100465775, -0.0073112864047288895, -0.02817426808178425, 0.02837824635207653, 0.005166344810277224, 0.003913801163434982, -0.008802865631878376, -0.013436959125101566, -0.0002565643226262182, -0.0052109649404883385, 0.0005768713308498263, 0.013615438714623451, -0.002256491221487522, 0.04189169406890869, 0.0060396199114620686, -0.03340116888284683, -0.010613157413899899, -0.0211753211915493, -0.024591930210590363, -0.00035397111787460744, 0.023189591243863106, 0.01728701777756214, 0.013462455943226814, 0.000861323089338839, 0.0018835965311154723, 0.011346198618412018, 0.004015789367258549, -0.005341637413948774, -0.026797426864504814, 0.027613332495093346, -0.03411508724093437, 0.0014955628430470824, 0.0027823683340102434, -0.02649146132171154, 0.006890584714710712, -0.0008501681149937212, -0.026363976299762726, 0.005159970838576555, -0.003760818624868989, 0.008312046527862549, 0.000546195195056498, 0.024018244817852974, 0.02899017557501793, 0.01360268983989954, 0.043905965983867645, 0.018587367609143257, 0.01847263239324093, -0.0017736403970047832, 0.013742923736572266, 0.0030006871093064547, 0.020066197961568832, -0.020423157140612602, 0.023878011852502823, -0.0019361842423677444, 0.001511498587206006, -0.02339356765151024, -0.010785263031721115, 0.005421315785497427, 0.02873520366847515, -0.01811567321419716, 0.019135555252432823, 0.0014047295553609729, -0.024273216724395752, 0.008694502525031567, -0.006058742757886648, 0.0013903874205425382, 0.0004525730910245329, 0.03786315768957138, 0.010160584934055805, -0.0021704386454075575, -0.0021608772221952677, 0.03714923933148384, -0.005969502963125706, -0.007177426945418119, -0.006794970948249102, -0.021761754527688026, -0.01664959080517292, 0.0021082893945276737, 0.027256373316049576, -0.001168881542980671, -0.032432280480861664, 0.016777075827121735, -0.018408888950943947, -0.013755672611296177, -0.03416608273983002, 0.020231930539011955, -0.0018007309408858418, 0.036486316472291946, -0.027944795787334442, 0.007872221991419792, -0.004382309969514608, 0.006922455970197916, 0.018765848129987717, -0.013092748820781708, 0.019581753760576248, -0.0033688012044876814, 0.01736350916326046, 0.04092280566692352, 0.0003294700291007757, -0.018549121916294098, -0.0036014618817716837, 0.002862046705558896, 0.018421636894345284, -0.00926818698644638, 0.01821766048669815, -0.019454268738627434, -0.04956631734967232, 0.030902456492185593, 0.036919765174388885, 0.002745716366916895, -0.021022338420152664, -0.0013927777763456106, 0.01708304136991501, -0.028709707781672478, -0.009650642983615398, -0.004952806979417801, 0.002858859719708562, -0.024196725338697433, 0.011103976517915726, 0.005252397619187832 ]
10.97347
7.128538
2024-07-01
2
2024A&A...687A.105I
[ "galaxy cluster environments", "tidal dwarf galaxies", "dwarf galaxies", "galaxy mergers", "spiral galaxies", "cluster environments", "clusters", "eight tidal dwarf galaxies", "these gas dominated dwarf galaxies", "high star formation rates" ]
[ "galaxies: clusters: intracluster medium", "galaxies: dwarf", "galaxies: formation", "galaxies: interactions", "galaxies: starburst", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
22
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202449605", "10.48550/arXiv.2402.09060" ]
[ "Ivleva, Anna", "Remus, Rhea-Silvia", "Valenzuela, Lucas M.", "Dolag, Klaus" ]
[ "Universitäts-Sternwarte, Fakultät für Physik, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Scheinerstr. 1, 81679, München, Germany", "Universitäts-Sternwarte, Fakultät für Physik, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Scheinerstr. 1, 81679, München, Germany", "Universitäts-Sternwarte, Fakultät für Physik, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Scheinerstr. 1, 81679, München, Germany", "Universitäts-Sternwarte, Fakultät für Physik, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Scheinerstr. 1, 81679, München, Germany; Max-Planck-Institut für Astrophysik, Karl-Scharzschild-Str. 1, 85748, Garching, Germany" ]
[ "2024arXiv240406537M", "2024arXiv240613732K" ]
[ "1955ApJ...121..161S", "1978A&A....70..677C", "1978Msngr..13...11P", "1979MNRAS.188..285L", "1980ApJ...238..510B", "1986Natur.324..446B", "1990ApJ...356..359H", "1992A&A...256L..19M", "1992Natur.360..715B", "1996ApJ...469..623S", "1996ApJS..105...19K", "1997AJ....114.1427M", "1997ApJ...490..493N", "1998A&A...333..813D", "1998A&AS..131...77M", "2000ApJ...540..715R", "2000ApJ...543..149O", "2001A&A...369..763D", "2001ApJ...562..689P", "2001MNRAS.328..726S", "2003A&A...401..817B", "2003A&A...406..453I", "2003AJ....125...66C", "2003AJ....126.1183C", "2003MNRAS.339..289S", "2003MNRAS.341..981S", "2004A&A...425..813B", "2004ApJ...617L...9L", "2005MNRAS.361..776S", "2005MNRAS.364.1105S", "2006A&A...456..481B", "2007A&A...467...93B", "2007MNRAS.375..805W", "2008A&A...487..431C", "2008AN....329.1025B", "2008MNRAS.389..967M", "2008NJPh...10l5006D", "2009A&A...499...87K", "2009ApJ...690..802J", "2009ApJ...697.1971J", "2009ApJ...707L.184J", "2009MNRAS.394.1713K", "2009MNRAS.399..497D", "2010ApJ...720L.149T", "2011AJ....142..199B", "2012ASSP...28..305D", "2012MNRAS.419...70K", "2012MNRAS.425.1068D", "2012MNRAS.425.2058B", "2012PASA...29..395K", "2013ApJ...766...71R", "2014ApJ...782...35S", "2014MNRAS.438.1971D", "2015ApJ...798L..45V", "2015MNRAS.446..521S", "2016A&A...596A..14S", "2016MNRAS.455.2110B", "2018ApJ...868...96C", "2018ApJS..237...14O", "2018MNRAS.474..580P", "2018MNRAS.480L.106O", "2018Natur.555..629V", "2019A&A...626A..47H", "2019A&A...628A..60F", "2019ApJ...874L...5V", "2019ApJ...883L..33M", "2019ApJ...887...92J", "2019MNRAS.487..318K", "2019MNRAS.487..653N", "2019MNRAS.488.3298J", "2019MNRAS.488L..24S", "2020ApJ...892....3H", "2020ApJ...899...25S", "2020MNRAS.495.2582G", "2020NatAs...4..246G", "2021A&A...649L..14R", "2021ApJ...911...68T", "2021ApJ...917L..15L", "2021MNRAS.502.1785J", "2022A&A...659A..92L", "2022ApJ...928..144L", "2022NatAs...6..496M", "2022Natur.605..435V", "2023AJ....165..197G", "2023ApJ...942L...5J", "2023ApJ...949...60S", "2023MNRAS.522.1196R", "2023MNRAS.525.2535O", "2024ApJS..271...52Z" ]
29097340
2310.03024
AstroCLIP: a cross-modal foundation model for galaxies
We present AstroCLIP, a single, versatile model that can embed both galaxy images and spectra into a shared, physically meaningful latent space. These embeddings can then be used - without any model fine-tuning - for a variety of downstream tasks including (1) accurate in-modality and cross-modality semantic similarity search, (2) photometric redshift estimation, (3) galaxy property estimation from both images and spectra, and (4) morphology classification. Our approach to implementing AstroCLIP consists of two parts. First, we embed galaxy images and spectra separately by pre-training separate transformer-based image and spectrum encoders in self-supervised settings. We then align the encoders using a contrastive loss. We apply our method to spectra from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument and images from its corresponding Legacy Imaging Survey. Overall, we find remarkable performance on all downstream tasks, even relative to supervised baselines. For example, for a task like photometric redshift prediction, we find similar performance to a specifically trained ResNet18, and for additional tasks like physical property estimation (stellar mass, age, metallicity, and specific-star-formation rate), we beat this supervised baseline by 19 per cent in terms of R<SUP>2</SUP>. We also compare our results with a state-of-the-art self-supervised single-modal model for galaxy images, and find that our approach outperforms this benchmark by roughly a factor of two on photometric redshift estimation and physical property prediction in terms of R<SUP>2</SUP>, while remaining roughly in-line in terms of morphology classification. Ultimately, our approach represents the first cross-modal self-supervised model for galaxies, and the first self-supervised transformer-based architectures for galaxy images and spectra.
[ -0.009411005303263664, -0.008771196007728577, 0.0047374931164085865, -0.004519376438111067, 0.014936625957489014, 0.032130032777786255, 0.009317941963672638, 0.001320332637988031, -0.019694477319717407, 0.044786613434553146, -0.024522123858332634, -0.0643065944314003, -0.013331287540495396, -0.034223951399326324, -0.014273551292717457, 0.002759902272373438, 0.004810198675841093, 0.012226163409650326, -0.016146445646882057, 0.04446089267730713, 0.003716707229614258, -0.01763545535504818, -0.03385169804096222, 0.024405796080827713, -0.015483371913433075, -0.07649786025285721, -0.020881030708551407, 0.0220908522605896, 0.03555010259151459, -0.005996752995997667, -0.00375742232427001, -0.019229160621762276, -0.04769483581185341, -0.008899157866835594, -0.011091956868767738, 0.07589294761419296, -0.0015864348970353603, 0.04031958431005478, -0.03420068696141243, -0.013261490501463413, 0.0025301529094576836, 0.01960141398012638, 0.016320940107107162, 0.02351006306707859, -0.013203325681388378, 0.006968099158257246, -0.02283535525202751, 0.00879446230828762, -0.024708250537514687, 0.04820668324828148, -0.044042106717824936, -0.0031176134943962097, -0.02994304895401001, 0.028500571846961975, -0.002024122281000018, -0.020101627334952354, -0.028849558904767036, 0.01834506168961525, -0.031385526061058044, -0.008207001723349094, -0.008887525647878647, -0.012924136593937874, 0.026755638420581818, -0.01598358526825905, -0.03001284785568714, 0.0018249090062454343, -0.03092021308839321, 0.015809092670679092, -0.005202808417379856, 0.03662032634019852, 0.018763845786452293, -0.03741136193275452, -0.01598358526825905, -0.023521697148680687, 0.036271341145038605, -0.010487047024071217, -0.02733728289604187, 0.05490722507238388, -0.01573929563164711, -0.0323394238948822, 0.02710462547838688, -0.018566086888313293, 0.006462068296968937, 0.021323081105947495, -0.02083449997007847, -0.003737064776942134, -0.002367292298004031, -0.01760055683553219, -0.06016528978943825, 0.000772132829297334, -0.0032310341484844685, -0.000617997080553323, -0.0014919176464900374, -0.009771624580025673, 0.02591807022690773, 0.03573622554540634, -0.004824739880859852, -0.05099857598543167, 0.03755095601081848, 0.03459620475769043, 0.054255783557891846, 0.036666858941316605, 0.01732136867940426, -0.05802483856678009, 0.03112960420548916, -0.04118041694164276, 0.011167570948600769, -0.0065900301560759544, 0.026173993945121765, 0.018635883927345276, -0.010306737385690212, -0.02106715738773346, 0.0013632288901135325, 0.03987753391265869, 0.028337711468338966, -0.03948201611638069, -0.026848701760172844, 0.021008992567658424, -0.02197452262043953, 0.015308878384530544, -0.004984691739082336, 0.020183058455586433, 0.03101327456533909, 0.0021346346475183964, 0.03129246458411217, -0.0465548112988472, 0.002627578331157565, -0.045344989746809006, -0.037806879729032516, -0.009434270672500134, -0.005836800672113895, -0.03815586864948273, 0.03199043869972229, -0.0011974602239206433, -0.06542335450649261, -0.028035257011651993, -0.02982672117650509, -0.020031830295920372, -0.007956894114613533, 0.00005398386201704852, -0.022474735975265503, -0.016704825684428215, 0.01315679494291544, 0.01877547800540924, -0.041040822863578796, -0.00925396103411913, -0.02547602169215679, 0.011557272635400295, -0.05914159491658211, 0.055558666586875916, -0.012970668263733387, -0.02126491628587246, -0.05495375394821167, -0.004056969191879034, -0.045391522347927094, -0.043972309678792953, -0.022416573017835617, -0.002367292298004031, 0.0019964941311627626, -0.02852383814752102, 0.018566086888313293, 0.007654439192265272, -0.014448044821619987, -0.017879746854305267, -0.037225235253572464, 0.014471311122179031, -0.006159613374620676, 0.012086569331586361, -0.07491578906774521, -0.06556294858455658, -0.031734514981508255, -0.0029736566357314587, -0.021567370742559433, -0.0639343410730362, 0.02095082774758339, -0.016437267884612083, -0.0005013046902604401, -0.03534070774912834, -0.026685841381549835, -0.04394904524087906, -0.01023694034665823, 0.04862546548247337, -0.001874348847195506, -0.005755370482802391, -0.05388353019952774, -0.0070378961972892284, 0.007997609674930573, 0.025499287992715836, 0.022428205236792564, 0.005400567315518856, -0.01862425170838833, 0.03112960420548916, -0.005258064717054367, 0.047322582453489304, -0.03152512386441231, 0.0047374931164085865, 0.010359085164964199, 0.03401456028223038, -0.012179631739854813, -0.008910791017115116, 0.0238706823438406, 0.047787897288799286, 0.04113388806581497, -0.046368684619665146, 0.005854249931871891, -0.04169226437807083, -0.017623823136091232, -0.014762133359909058, -0.049323439598083496, 0.030757352709770203, 0.031385526061058044, 0.015692763030529022, -0.0007866739179007709, -0.00427217734977603, -0.04031958431005478, -0.01964794471859932, -0.03022223897278309, 0.0022495093289762735, 0.03571296110749245, 0.04087796434760094, -0.051929205656051636, -0.0008630147785879672, 0.049602627754211426, -0.017542392015457153, -0.004772391635924578, -0.010359085164964199, -0.02138124592602253, -0.061561234295368195, 0.022160649299621582, -0.04492620751261711, 0.03364230692386627, 0.0406220406293869, -0.011214102618396282, -0.004906170070171356, 0.02110205590724945, -0.03096674382686615, 0.011679418385028839, -0.04027305170893669, 0.01060919277369976, -0.04899771884083748, -0.04413517192006111, 0.024661719799041748, 0.01991550251841545, -0.04015672579407692, -0.005668123718351126, 0.016320940107107162, -0.007113510277122259, -0.03447987511754036, 0.030082644894719124, 0.01778668351471424, 0.025569085031747818, 0.02852383814752102, -0.03941221907734871, -0.029873251914978027, -0.028500571846961975, 0.03931915760040283, -0.004533917643129826, 0.0007459588232450187, -0.009620397351682186, -0.018519556149840355, -0.028826292604207993, 0.04162246733903885, -0.05872281268239021, -0.02477804757654667, -0.030385099351406097, 0.003309556283056736, 0.0041325828060507774, 0.005388934630900621, -0.015553168952465057, 0.02966386079788208, 0.015343776904046535, -0.016309306025505066, 0.0044263130985200405, -0.05835055932402611, -0.022311875596642494, 0.02445232681930065, 0.03073408640921116, 0.024545390158891678, 0.018240366131067276, -0.008515273220837116, -0.020729804411530495, -0.03452640771865845, 0.02535969205200672, 0.03727176785469055, -0.03492192551493645, -0.0019412379479035735, -0.007096060551702976, -0.047276049852371216, -0.00871884822845459, -0.03931915760040283, 0.06318984180688858, -0.06621439009904861, 0.005860066507011652, -0.016041750088334084, -0.04839280620217323, 0.01621624454855919, 0.043809451162815094, 0.05486069247126579, -0.007567192427814007, -0.013505781069397926, 0.04311147704720497, -0.02887282334268093, -0.020497145131230354, 0.03845832124352455, -0.0063806381076574326, 0.0339214950799942, -0.03436354547739029, 0.010713888332247734, 0.06923893839120865, -0.03005937859416008, -0.005668123718351126, -0.01668155938386917, -0.0037108908873051405, -0.007002997677773237, -0.03987753391265869, -0.012935769744217396, 0.017647089436650276, -0.03336311876773834, 0.02887282334268093, -0.017181772738695145, -0.05993263050913811, -0.032409220933914185, -0.04476334527134895, -0.012947402894496918, 0.017367899417877197, -0.012354125268757343, -0.06486497819423676, 0.007956894114613533, -0.014994790777564049, 0.023800885304808617, 0.01735626719892025, -0.0355035699903965, 0.05076591670513153, -0.005147552117705345, 0.008840993978083134, -0.048858124762773514, 0.017623823136091232, 0.02011326141655445, 0.03652726486325264, -0.04343719780445099, -0.05341821536421776, -0.033037398010492325, -0.007311269175261259, 0.036317870020866394, 0.0026741097681224346, 0.044088639318943024, -0.024684984236955643, 0.05914159491658211, 0.014285184442996979, -0.021485941484570503, 0.015995219349861145, -0.01920589618384838, 0.01948508433997631, -0.011551456525921822, 0.023649659007787704, 0.0010571385500952601, -0.06291065365076065, -0.008340779691934586, -0.02931487374007702, -0.010713888332247734, -0.011993505991995335, -0.014843563549220562, 0.05755952373147011, 0.02512703463435173, -0.016402369365096092, -0.03364230692386627, -0.03783014789223671, 0.03608521446585655, 0.020345918834209442, -0.04446089267730713, 0.02114858850836754, 0.022532900795340538, -0.03347944840788841, -0.002172441454604268, -0.04111061990261078, 0.013261490501463413, -0.012807807885110378, 0.022230446338653564, 0.005950221326202154, 0.029570797458291054, 0.025196831673383713, -0.02631358988583088, -0.0402497872710228, -0.05267370864748955, -0.008747930638492107, 0.007421781774610281, 0.03333985432982445, 0.011062875390052795, -0.036038681864738464, 0.05258064717054367, -0.03480559587478638, -0.009044568985700607, -0.020380817353725433, 0.008736297488212585, 0.017181772738695145, 0.005313321016728878, 0.03057122603058815, 0.006450435612350702, 0.04236697405576706, 0.0461592935025692, 0.008492006920278072, -0.037341564893722534, -0.02750014327466488, -0.0658886656165123, -0.018333429470658302, -0.0004634978249669075, -0.016635026782751083, 0.032525550574064255, 0.020939195528626442, -0.027407079935073853, 0.052441053092479706, -0.03973793983459473, 0.0006674368632957339, -0.009550599381327629, -0.0037748715840280056, -0.0073868827894330025, -0.009416821412742138, 0.012586782686412334, -0.004920710809528828, 0.09217899292707443, 0.0347125343978405, -0.032292891293764114, 0.014529475010931492, -0.021672068163752556, 0.008055773563683033, -0.008364045061171055, 0.0729614645242691, -0.002102644182741642, -0.025964602828025818, -0.014808664098381996, -0.016623394563794136, 0.03971467539668083, 0.06872709095478058, -0.005063213873654604, -0.03727176785469055, -0.00106222799513489, 0.023765986785292625, 0.01905466802418232, -0.02910548262298107, -0.008666500449180603, 0.004897444974631071, -0.03324678912758827, -0.05081244930624962, -0.05862974748015404, -0.0128194410353899, -0.019694477319717407, 0.01900813728570938, 0.05034713074564934, -0.04371638596057892, -0.016204610466957092, -0.009632029570639133, 0.0027773515321314335, 0.012540251947939396, 0.01968284323811531, -0.02535969205200672, -0.0315483883023262, -0.0031030725222080946, -0.05309249460697174, 0.03957508131861687, -0.023696189746260643, -0.02717442251741886, -0.0008295702282339334, -0.005359852220863104, -0.0029242169111967087, 0.03166471794247627, 0.009027119725942612, 0.008015058934688568, 0.03489866107702255, 0.02801199071109295, 0.0019557790365070105, 0.0027744434773921967, 0.011603804305195808, 0.007945261895656586, 0.025545818731188774, -0.0012243612436577678, 0.013261490501463413, 0.043693121522665024, -0.006502783391624689, -0.0051359194330871105, -0.021055525168776512, 0.039109762758016586, -0.049323439598083496, -0.019298959523439407, 0.002473442582413554, -0.029570797458291054, 0.08445475250482559, 0.00019721378339454532, -0.0056826649233698845, 0.023893948644399643, 0.005339494906365871, 0.02812832035124302, -0.019077934324741364, 0.004536825697869062, -0.0098646879196167, 0.00812557153403759, -0.014587639831006527, -0.05085897818207741, 0.020217956975102425, -0.011394412256777287, 0.022067585960030556, 0.047834429889917374, 0.005618683993816376, 0.006659827660769224, 0.026616044342517853, 0.012551884166896343, 0.005301687866449356, -0.036155011504888535, -0.0034404261969029903, -0.015180916525423527, 0.002123001730069518, -0.05914159491658211, 0.044600486755371094, 0.04848587140440941, 0.023963745683431625, -0.014389880932867527, 0.02271902747452259, -0.04508906975388527, 0.021648801863193512, 0.01712360978126526, -0.002326577203348279, 0.0051853591576218605, 0.002938757883384824, -0.01287760492414236, -0.012982301414012909, 0.022021053358912468, 0.034968458116054535, -0.043693121522665024, -0.09441250562667847, -0.0402265228331089, -0.009829789400100708, 0.0074857622385025024, -0.026848701760172844, 0.010626642033457756, 0.020485512912273407, -0.05993263050913811, 0.01338945236057043, -0.01979917287826538, -0.02568541280925274, -0.041040822863578796, 0.008329146541655064, 0.00038097702781669796, 0.021509207785129547, 0.014075792394578457, 0.026057666167616844, 0.016320940107107162, 0.012074936181306839, -0.03301413357257843, -0.00461534783244133, 0.009172530844807625, 0.012947402894496918, 0.03336311876773834, -0.06286411732435226, 0.004022070672363043, -0.019694477319717407, 0.0037341564893722534, 0.025964602828025818, 0.04150613769888878, 0.03580602630972862, 0.014180488884449005, 0.0010476867901161313, -0.025731945410370827, 0.014192121103405952, -0.02063674107193947, 0.025662148371338844, -0.001395219354890287, 0.01570439711213112, -0.0037545140367001295, -0.018077505752444267, 0.009637846611440182, -0.017030546441674232, -0.02473151683807373, -0.00657839747145772, 0.02477804757654667, -0.030757352709770203, -0.025452755391597748, 0.0017725611105561256, -0.009021303616464138, 0.01039398368448019, -0.00550235528498888, -0.03210676833987236, -0.04446089267730713, -0.01102797593921423, -0.0061363475397229195, -0.000274099875241518, -0.004353607539087534, -0.009451719932258129, -0.019322223961353302, -0.013377819210290909, 0.02019469067454338, -0.004679328761994839, 0.04283228889107704, -0.01505295466631651, -0.006909934338182211, -0.032525550574064255, -0.02847730554640293, -0.010452148504555225, 0.05188267305493355, 0.01023694034665823, -0.004059877246618271, -0.01609991490840912, 0.013098630122840405, 0.020206322893500328, -0.048532404005527496, -0.06281758844852448, 0.0028035256545990705, -0.003702166024595499, -0.00899222120642662, -0.000049757854867493734, -0.04078489914536476, 0.018356693908572197, 0.02836097776889801, -0.0007808575173839927, -0.030431630089879036, -0.02971039153635502, -0.009213246405124664, -0.00751484464854002, 0.008364045061171055, 0.012865972705185413, 0.03478233143687248, -0.01355231273919344, 0.006997181102633476, -0.04350699484348297, 0.0008113938383758068, -0.024359263479709625, 0.04736911505460739, 0.007008814252912998, -0.003463692031800747, -0.055605195462703705, -0.02205595187842846, 0.005985120311379433, -0.007730053272098303, 0.019706109538674355, 0.04657807573676109, 0.00474330922588706, -0.004182022530585527, 0.004522284492850304, 0.021672068163752556, 0.017484229058027267, 0.018903439864516258, -0.003175778081640601, -0.02552255243062973, 0.01613481342792511, -0.022242078557610512, -0.026732373982667923, 0.01608828268945217, 0.006950649432837963, 0.007892913185060024, -0.009463353082537651, -0.01250535249710083, -0.011824829503893852, -0.02666257508099079, -0.03108307346701622, 0.014552741311490536, 0.007322901859879494, 0.03799300640821457, 0.002806433942168951, -0.012458821758627892, 0.021672068163752556, -0.010667356662452221, 0.002585408976301551, -0.02812832035124302, -0.0011669239029288292, -0.0015369951725006104, -0.009632029570639133, 0.0012752552283927798, 0.006020018830895424, -0.014331716112792492, 0.03322352468967438, -0.009044568985700607, -0.00451646838337183, 0.03759748861193657, -0.023451898247003555, 0.016472166404128075, 0.0071891238912940025, -0.01747259497642517, -0.0008971863426268101, -0.00001885799974843394, -0.015250714495778084, -0.019345490261912346, 0.004848005250096321, -0.023370468989014626, 0.021404510363936424, -0.03801627457141876, -0.011859728023409843, 0.01664666086435318, 0.021276548504829407, 0.02619726024568081, 0.002082286635413766, 0.0038184949662536383, 0.013203325681388378, -0.0036905333399772644, 0.012831074185669422, -0.010114794597029686, -0.008701398968696594, 0.009556416422128677, 0.018566086888313293, 0.010498680174350739, 0.028430774807929993, -0.012272695079445839, -0.018926706165075302, 0.006659827660769224, 0.0050864797085523605, -0.019112832844257355, -0.021404510363936424, 0.0004976694472134113, -0.004679328761994839, -0.01248208712786436, -0.008614152669906616, 0.017891379073262215, -0.030501428991556168, 0.0098646879196167, 0.01928732544183731, 0.015960320830345154, -0.03108307346701622, 0.00791036244481802, 0.005647766403853893, 0.021625535562634468, 0.013168427161872387, -0.014599272049963474, -0.03829546272754669, -0.041203685104846954, -0.016623394563794136, -0.08254696428775787, -0.013936198316514492, 0.0035189480986446142, -0.028965886682271957, -0.049090780317783356, 0.021672068163752556, -0.039551813155412674, 0.022591065615415573, 0.00881772767752409, -0.02698829583823681, -0.009422638453543186, -0.047438912093639374, 0.003687625052407384, 0.004798565525561571, -0.015332144685089588, -0.01582072488963604, -0.014738867059350014, -0.0024545390624552965, -0.012726377695798874, 0.028616901487112045, 0.028593635186553, 0.030594490468502045, 0.0007361436146311462, -0.017495861276984215, 0.02789566107094288, 0.011888809502124786, 0.020055096596479416, -0.0005772819858975708, -0.014843563549220562, 0.007834749296307564, 0.005708838813006878, 0.005796085577458143, -0.03776035085320473, -0.007474129553884268, 0.0033473630901426077, -0.028174851089715958, 0.017018912360072136, -0.018484655767679214, 0.04515886679291725, 0.043530259281396866, 0.01921752840280533, 0.05183614045381546, -0.03040836565196514, -0.029687127098441124, -0.021788395941257477, 0.005412200465798378, -0.010085712186992168, 0.0002810069127008319, -0.004068601876497269, 0.02528989501297474, -0.007084427867084742, 0.006293391343206167, 0.0002917309757322073, 0.009981016628444195, 0.02824464812874794, -0.0016911309212446213, -0.008881708607077599, 0.022463103756308556, -0.011644518934190273, -0.010603375732898712, 0.023044748231768608, -0.018019340932369232, -0.015087854117155075, 0.005138827487826347, -0.01900813728570938, -0.02887282334268093, -0.001954325009137392, -0.030710820108652115, -0.043181274086236954, 0.05821096524596214, -0.019159363582730293, 0.014843563549220562, -0.017937911674380302, 0.04950956627726555, -0.029477734118700027, -0.0883634090423584, -0.021090423688292503, 0.0402265228331089, 0.01960141398012638, 0.014576006680727005, 0.01205167081207037, -0.005941496696323156, 0.021404510363936424, 0.00856180489063263, 0.026616044342517853, 0.013098630122840405, -0.04702012613415718, -0.0035451222211122513, 0.030082644894719124, 0.03413088992238045, -0.03689951449632645, -0.013622109778225422, -0.01224942971020937, -0.014087425544857979, 0.006950649432837963, -0.039668142795562744, -0.0002737363683991134, 0.01917099766433239, 0.029617328196763992, -0.0033706289250403643, 0.011981872841715813, 0.005362760741263628, 0.017565658316016197, -0.027802597731351852, 0.014820297248661518, -0.01536704320460558, -0.014285184442996979, 0.004301259759813547, 0.05388353019952774, -0.01668155938386917, 0.028314445167779922, 0.003030366962775588, 0.010620824992656708, -0.020974094048142433, 0.006764523684978485, -0.011074507609009743, -0.013878033496439457, 0.000570374948438257, -0.026522981002926826, 0.05644276365637779, 0.026336854323744774, 0.028058521449565887, -0.0014439320657402277, 0.013261490501463413, 0.047392379492521286, 0.00557215278968215, -0.02252126857638359, -0.007578825578093529, 0.013331287540495396, -0.004315800964832306, -0.013575578108429909, -0.004993416368961334, -0.017693620175123215, -0.034572940319776535, 0.01684441976249218, -0.029012419283390045, 0.04548458755016327, 0.0477413646876812, 0.006543498486280441, -0.05472109839320183, 0.01936875656247139, -0.03645746782422066, 0.030478162690997124, 0.01720503903925419, -0.03301413357257843, 0.01822873391211033, 0.013052098453044891, 0.04634542018175125, 0.01205167081207037, -0.014366614632308483, -0.010952362790703773, -0.0012396294623613358, 0.042460035532712936, -0.046205826103687286, -0.002266958821564913, 0.06570254266262054, 0.007607907522469759, 0.054023124277591705, -0.0029867435805499554, -0.01874057948589325, 0.04390251263976097, -0.009271410293877125, -0.019112832844257355, -0.008393127471208572, 0.03322352468967438, 0.04162246733903885, -0.029058950021862984, 0.012365758419036865, -0.012970668263733387, -0.028826292604207993, -0.01814730279147625, 0.021125322207808495, -0.016507066786289215, 0.030896946787834167, -0.0010382351465523243, 0.0560239814221859, 0.016274407505989075, -0.05872281268239021, -0.02146267518401146, 0.005796085577458143, -0.048858124762773514, 0.008910791017115116, 0.03259534761309624, 0.03010590933263302, -0.0031525122467428446, 0.030082644894719124, -0.017658721655607224, -0.00439723115414381, -0.040528975427150726, 0.01771688647568226, -0.023765986785292625, -0.025894805788993835, 0.015099486336112022, 0.0646788477897644, -0.02587153948843479, 0.04474008083343506, 0.007398515939712524, -0.009445903822779655, -0.01319169346243143, -0.0032513916958123446, -0.003324097255244851, 0.015262346714735031, -0.017728518694639206, -0.019031401723623276, 0.011464209295809269, -0.008433843031525612, -0.00660747941583395, 0.0019456002628430724, -0.019834071397781372, 0.022358408197760582, 0.025429489091038704, 0.023614758625626564, 0.04753197357058525, -0.03010590933263302, 0.014959892258048058, 0.017484229058027267, -0.014157222583889961, 0.00667727692052722, 0.0038010457064956427, -0.0378766767680645, 0.026918498799204826, 0.0220908522605896, 0.014727233909070492, -0.019624680280685425, 0.014133957214653492, 0.016541965305805206, 0.02528989501297474, -0.02768626995384693, 0.04725278541445732, 0.002102644182741642, 0.02323087491095066, 0.008742114529013634, -0.008061590604484081, -0.0035218563862144947, 0.046368684619665146, 0.03601541742682457, 0.01304046530276537, -0.00962621346116066, -0.004199471790343523, 0.015995219349861145, 0.008439659141004086, -0.041645731776952744, 0.020299386233091354, -0.0167629886418581, 0.021008992567658424, 0.013110263273119926, -0.006543498486280441, 0.012900871224701405, 0.010469597764313221, -0.028384242206811905, 0.011289716698229313, 0.007468312978744507, 0.013715173117816448, 0.041366543620824814, 0.012319226749241352, -0.014843563549220562, 0.04027305170893669, -0.017763417214155197, 0.02311454527080059, 0.05383699759840965, 0.008154653012752533, -0.006869219243526459, -0.01080695167183876, -0.004414680413901806, 0.0315716527402401, -0.02626705728471279, 0.00704952934756875, 0.012319226749241352, 0.039109762758016586, 0.023382101207971573, 0.00677615636959672, -0.02489437721669674, 0.010754603892564774, -0.03001284785568714, -0.03673665598034859, -0.0319671705365181, 0.012144733220338821, -0.02608093060553074, -0.018787112087011337, -0.023521697148680687, 0.006793605629354715, 0.0017812857404351234, -0.006403903942555189, -0.009794889949262142, -0.04248329997062683, -0.008550171740353107, -0.019985299557447433, 0.03033856861293316, 0.0020197599660605192, 0.03389823064208031, -0.025313161313533783, 0.036271341145038605, 0.005159185267984867, -0.03124593384563923, -0.013052098453044891, -0.00392609927803278, 0.0035363975912332535, -0.0128194410353899, 0.017542392015457153, 0.0025679597165435553, 0.01520418282598257, 0.029919784516096115, -0.026848701760172844, -0.0030419998802244663, -0.0005594691610895097, 0.03657379373908043, -0.033944763243198395, 0.03703911229968071, 0.0011400228831917048, -0.033549245446920395, 0.006752890534698963, -0.0032862904481589794, -0.023731088265776634, 0.011475842446088791, 0.025941336527466774, 0.025080503895878792, 0.009277227334678173, 0.017530759796500206, -0.028826292604207993, 0.017844848334789276, 0.0012483540922403336, 0.038132600486278534, 0.025103768333792686, 0.04362332448363304, 0.00006148162356112152, -0.013703539967536926, 0.002128818305209279, 0.030431630089879036, 0.0047811162658035755, 0.01210983470082283, 0.021939624100923538, 0.0014039439847692847, 0.03929588943719864, 0.03399129584431648, -0.010324186645448208, 0.003408435732126236, 0.01798444241285324, -0.026453183963894844, -0.05509335175156593, 0.012993934564292431, 0.013180060312151909, -0.01783321425318718, -0.02773280069231987, 0.007799850311130285, 0.03566642850637436, 0.0011480204993858933, -0.019636312499642372, -0.01837996020913124, -0.008951506577432156, 0.009166714735329151, 0.0068401372991502285, -0.018949972465634346, 0.0019601413514465094, 0.01857771910727024, -0.0038214032538235188, -0.0008070315234363079, -0.048858124762773514, -0.0038243113085627556, -0.006229410879313946, 0.0029489367734640837, 0.013843134976923466, -0.03217656537890434, 0.03601541742682457, 0.008067406713962555, -0.007770768366754055, -0.017647089436650276, 0.03724850341677666, -0.00019685024744831026, -0.012796174734830856, 0.005679756868630648, 0.0010680443374440074, 0.019810805097222328, 0.027151156216859818, 0.015843991190195084, -0.017856480553746223, 0.010463781654834747, -0.02220718003809452, 0.016600128263235092, -0.014157222583889961, 0.027314016595482826, 0.005415108520537615, -0.03492192551493645, -0.05993263050913811, 0.0009488072828389704, -0.012284328229725361, -0.028105054050683975, 0.00439723115414381, 0.021753497421741486, -0.009201613254845142, 0.0016954932361841202, -0.0017856480553746223, -0.005420925095677376, -0.012365758419036865, 0.006962282583117485, -0.015529903583228588, -0.006403903942555189, -0.00802669208496809, 0.004571724217385054, 0.043018415570259094, -0.026057666167616844, -0.04627562314271927, 0.021427776664495468, -0.001365410047583282, 0.023021481931209564, 0.02840750850737095, 0.02378925308585167, 0.029291607439517975, 0.0022655045613646507, -0.003137971041724086, -0.02331230416893959, 0.0036061948630958796, -0.025103768333792686, 0.015832358971238136, -0.004917802754789591, -0.013482515700161457, -0.017577290534973145, 0.0005623773322440684, -0.026336854323744774, 0.03029203601181507, -0.013843134976923466, -0.0028675065841525793, -0.021369611844420433, 0.0007743139867670834, -0.03206023573875427, 0.011708499863743782, 0.05304596200585365, -0.01917099766433239, -0.002964932005852461, -0.026499714702367783, -0.014645803719758987, 0.01049286313354969, -0.023498430848121643, 0.02808178775012493, 0.03534070774912834, 0.00565067445859313, -0.017460962757468224, 0.02192799188196659, -0.013086996972560883, 0.00818373542279005, 0.03143205866217613, -0.011859728023409843, 0.005028315354138613, 0.01578582637012005, 0.036713387817144394, 0.006124714855104685, 0.017367899417877197, 0.009416821412742138, -0.023440266028046608, 0.013052098453044891, 0.00909110065549612, -0.0024036450777202845, -0.0035160400439053774, 0.007794033735990524, 0.0043768733739852905, 0.030710820108652115, 0.00041442157817073166, -0.02891935594379902, -0.03140879422426224, 0.00596767058596015, -0.001679498003795743, -0.017170140519738197, -0.04178532958030701, -0.00885844323784113, 0.0018118220614269376, -0.010178775526583195, 0.015692763030529022, -0.02141614444553852, 0.0017522035632282495, -0.022335141897201538, -0.04678747057914734, -0.0014671977842226624, -0.003199043683707714, 0.02943120338022709, 0.022300243377685547, 0.012947402894496918, -0.004903261549770832, 0.010644091293215752, 0.017681987956166267, -0.01740279793739319, -0.008538538590073586, 0.01940365508198738, 0.011022159829735756, 0.020822865888476372, 0.02528989501297474, -0.014959892258048058, -0.029687127098441124, 0.0402497872710228, -0.01960141398012638, 0.028989152982831, -0.0029489367734640837, -0.021916357800364494, -0.039435483515262604, -0.013342920690774918, -0.004059877246618271, 0.03680645301938057, -0.017426064237952232, 0.025266628712415695, -0.016379104927182198, -0.021288182586431503, 0.001176375662907958, 0.023719456046819687, 0.007927811704576015, 0.010184591636061668, -0.007590458262711763, -0.03238595649600029, -0.007956894114613533, 0.0031059805769473314, 0.0035654797684401274, 0.022032687440514565, 0.010324186645448208, 0.022044319659471512, -0.012226163409650326, -0.0027439070399850607, -0.04599643126130104, 0.043879248201847076, -0.010969812050461769, -0.03180431202054024, 0.03580602630972862, 0.03285127133131027, 0.01799607463181019, -0.002252417616546154, -0.04515886679291725, -0.014378247782588005, 0.005109745543450117, 0.00021611721604131162, 0.0031030725222080946, 0.029175279662013054, -0.030594490468502045, -0.026057666167616844, -0.024568656459450722, 0.022556167095899582, -0.022032687440514565, 0.022381672635674477, -0.015809092670679092, -0.005217349622398615, 0.042622897773981094, 0.006886668968945742, -0.01130134891718626, 0.030780617147684097, -0.008108122274279594, 0.01542520709335804, 0.013401085510849953, 0.015692763030529022, -0.018158935010433197, -0.04178532958030701, 0.02240493893623352, 0.022928418591618538, 0.015448473393917084, -0.009597131051123142, 0.03494518995285034, -0.02059020847082138, -0.016669927164912224, -0.02733728289604187, 0.015134384855628014, 0.015041322447359562, -0.018717315047979355, 0.020206322893500328, 0.04527519270777702, 0.0016736815450713038, 0.04169226437807083, 0.01522744819521904, 0.01573929563164711, -0.031501855701208115, 0.011906259693205357, 0.018728947266936302, 0.009294676594436169, 0.015611333772540092, 0.006555131636559963, 0.006159613374620676, 0.04669440537691116, 0.011109406128525734, -0.004525193013250828, -0.016006851568818092, -0.007933628745377064, 0.008340779691934586, -0.02121838554739952, -0.025150300934910774, 0.0031815944239497185, -0.012831074185669422, 0.038714244961738586, -0.016949115321040154, -0.014727233909070492, -0.030896946787834167, 0.005985120311379433, -0.0033357301726937294, -0.00650859996676445, 0.0011771026765927672, -0.00913181621581316, 0.0006496239802800119, 0.04106409102678299, -0.0019499625777825713, -0.012586782686412334, -0.0032455753535032272, 0.011667785234749317, -0.006514416541904211, -0.0028878641314804554, -0.02756994031369686, 0.020171424373984337, 0.011365329846739769, -0.025615615770220757, -0.015681130811572075, 0.022928418591618538, 0.011109406128525734, -0.03806280344724655, 0.007573009002953768, 0.012377391569316387, -0.03199043869972229, 0.01940365508198738, 0.04236697405576706, 0.00027210047119297087, 0.006083999760448933, -0.012633314356207848, -0.017658721655607224, -0.0055779688991606236, 0.01375007163733244, -0.009550599381327629, -0.01338945236057043, -0.020299386233091354, 0.010004281997680664, 0.01649543270468712, 0.03131572902202606, 0.02043898217380047, 0.028430774807929993, -0.006281758658587933, 0.02670910768210888, -0.0017507494194433093, -0.013982729986310005, 0.021916357800364494, -0.017809949815273285, 0.00842220988124609, 0.004112225491553545, 0.02824464812874794, -0.009678561240434647, 0.006444619037210941, -0.00333863846026361, 0.05849015340209007, -0.04904424771666527, -0.02225371263921261, -0.0030768983997404575, -0.015797460451722145, 0.014424779452383518, 0.024126606062054634, -0.006723808590322733, 0.0017333000432699919, -0.013622109778225422, 0.011493291705846786, -0.005013774149119854, -0.0142968175932765, -0.003998804837465286, -0.0038184949662536383, 0.03415415436029434, 0.0678429901599884, 0.007014630362391472, 0.015122752636671066, 0.03838852420449257, -0.025429489091038704, -0.03329332172870636, 0.02050877921283245, -0.01767035387456417, -0.010917464271187782, 0.02110205590724945, 0.011627069674432278, -0.0071833073161542416, 0.010178775526583195, 0.021195119246840477, -0.0019426920916885138, 0.007351984269917011, 0.020881030708551407, 0.009515700861811638, -0.020229589194059372, 0.04504253715276718, 0.0031525122467428446, 0.045810308307409286, -0.02517356537282467, 0.003373536979779601, 0.020718170329928398, 0.03126920014619827, -0.005095204338431358, -0.010376534424722195, 0.014238652773201466, -0.009544783271849155, 0.04848587140440941, -0.022381672635674477, -0.025987869128584862, -0.0033008314203470945, -0.0028922264464199543, 0.009411005303263664, 0.0199271347373724, -0.027802597731351852, 0.02982672117650509, 0.012796174734830856, 0.014087425544857979, 0.019985299557447433, -0.0032659329008311033, -0.030245505273342133, -0.017263203859329224, -0.02445232681930065, -0.013610477559268475, -0.005098112393170595, 0.0009720730595290661, 0.009079467505216599, -0.01692584902048111, 0.03799300640821457, 0.007218205835670233, -0.02271902747452259, 0.021474309265613556, 0.0017463871045038104, -0.01783321425318718, -0.025731945410370827, 0.01578582637012005, -0.0012578058522194624, 0.019426919519901276, -0.003353179432451725, -0.020148159936070442, 0.010010099038481712, -0.006520232651382685, 0.0157741941511631, -0.0026450275909155607, -0.03399129584431648, -0.010324186645448208, -0.024126606062054634, -0.007322901859879494, -0.022730659693479538, -0.01917099766433239, 0.02240493893623352, 0.006334106903523207, 0.012726377695798874, 0.003178686136379838, 0.020427348092198372, 0.03878404200077057, 0.040854696184396744, -0.028314445167779922, 0.032758209854364395, -0.0096669290214777, 0.0007801304454915226, 0.030036112293601036, -0.004801474045962095, -0.026918498799204826, 0.022102484479546547, 0.015762561932206154, 0.007096060551702976, 0.013575578108429909, 0.03401456028223038, -0.016344206407666206, 0.013121895492076874, -0.04115715250372887, 0.025057237595319748, 0.022242078557610512, 0.04622909054160118, 0.02149757370352745, 0.005990936420857906, 0.009748359210789204, 0.0023134902585297823, 0.044670283794403076, 0.03417741879820824, -0.002306219656020403, -0.03096674382686615, -0.015390308573842049, 0.014994790777564049, -0.006049100775271654, -0.028686698526144028, 0.005679756868630648, 0.0026886509731411934, 0.03182757645845413, -0.041878391057252884, 0.012982301414012909, -0.03529417887330055, 0.011597988195717335, -0.01352904736995697, -0.017809949815273285, 0.004010437522083521, 0.014471311122179031, 0.002043025800958276, -0.035480305552482605, -0.03566642850637436, 0.04876505956053734, 0.014587639831006527, 0.040645305067300797, -0.00456590810790658, 0.003722523571923375, 0.012551884166896343, -0.010004281997680664, -0.02768626995384693, 0.011510740965604782, -0.010644091293215752, -0.03131572902202606, -0.01406416017562151, -0.0319671705365181, -0.014715601690113544, -0.006049100775271654, 0.022230446338653564, -0.002672655740752816, -0.01500642392784357, -0.01009734533727169, -0.021962890401482582, 0.0064795175567269325, -0.01901976950466633, 0.002605766523629427, 0.012714744545519352, -0.03301413357257843, -0.061514705419540405, 0.013005566783249378, -0.0056332251988351345, 0.006008385680615902, -0.03238595649600029, 0.022509634494781494, -0.006985548418015242, -0.018635883927345276, 0.00328919873572886, 0.016320940107107162, 0.01806587353348732, 0.008666500449180603, -0.00009806159505387768, -0.019834071397781372 ]
11.415325
4.697561
2024-07-01
14
2024MNRAS.531.4990P
[ "galaxy images", "photometric redshift estimation", "physical property estimation", "downstream tasks", "physical property prediction", "galaxies", "photometric redshift prediction", "additional tasks", "pre-training separate transformer-based image", "supervised baselines" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics", "Computer Science - Artificial Intelligence", "Computer Science - Machine Learning" ]
53
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1450", "10.48550/arXiv.2310.03024" ]
[ "Parker, Liam", "Lanusse, Francois", "Golkar, Siavash", "Sarra, Leopoldo", "Cranmer, Miles", "Bietti, Alberto", "Eickenberg, Michael", "Krawezik, Geraud", "McCabe, Michael", "Morel, Rudy", "Ohana, Ruben", "Pettee, Mariel", "Régaldo-Saint Blancard, Bruno", "Cho, Kyunghyun", "Ho, Shirley", "Polymathic AI Collaboration" ]
[ "The Flatiron Institute, 162 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA", "The Flatiron Institute, 162 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA; CEA, CNRS, AIM, Université Paris-Saclay, Université Paris Cité, Paris 91190, France", "The Flatiron Institute, 162 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA", "The Flatiron Institute, 162 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA", "Department of Astronomy, University of Cambridge, Madingley Rd, Cambridge CB3 0HA, UK", "The Flatiron Institute, 162 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA", "The Flatiron Institute, 162 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA", "The Flatiron Institute, 162 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA", "The Flatiron Institute, 162 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA; Department of Computer Science, University of Colorado, Boulder, 430 UCB, 1111 Engineering Dr, Boulder, CO 80309, USA", "The Flatiron Institute, 162 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA", "The Flatiron Institute, 162 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA", "The Flatiron Institute, 162 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA; Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, 1 Cyclotron Rd, CA 94720, USA", "The Flatiron Institute, 162 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA", "Center for Data Science, New York University, 60 5th Ave, New York, NY 10011, USA; Prescient Design, Genentech, 149 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA; CIFAR Learning in Machines and Brains Fellow, Toronto, ON M5G 1M1, Canada", "The Flatiron Institute, 162 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA; Center for Data Science, New York University, 60 5th Ave, New York, NY 10011, USA; Department of Astrophysics, Princeton University, 4 Ivy Lane, Princeton, NJ 08544, USA", "-" ]
[ "2023arXiv231216687G", "2024MLS&T...5b5075V", "2024arXiv240113537G", "2024arXiv240215734C", "2024arXiv240307066H", "2024arXiv240308851M", "2024arXiv240402973W", "2024arXiv240510890F", "2024arXiv240511752W", "2024arXiv240514930S", "2024arXiv240600031C", "2024arXiv240602585G", "2024arXiv240617057T", "2024arXiv240617809Y" ]
[ "2011arXiv1110.3193L", "2014arXiv1409.0473B", "2016arXiv160508803D", "2018arXiv180603198S", "2018arXiv180703748V", "2018arXiv181004805D", "2019A&A...621A..26P", "2019AJ....157..168D", "2019ApJ...873..111I", "2019arXiv191006222S", "2020AJ....160...45P", "2020MNRAS.494.3750C", "2020MNRAS.496.2346M", "2020arXiv200205709C", "2020arXiv201011929D", "2020sdmm.book.....I", "2021ApJ...911L..33H", "2021arXiv210104293A", "2021arXiv210104731F", "2021arXiv210807258B", "2021arXiv211013151S", "2021arXiv211106377H", "2021arXiv211107832Z", "2022AJ....163...71T", "2022MNRAS.509.3966W", "2023AGUFMGC21A..01N", "2023AJ....165..253H", "2023AJ....166...74M", "2023AJ....166...75L", "2023ApJ...945...16H", "2023ApJ...956L...6L", "2023PASA...40....1H", "2023arXiv230315389S", "2023arXiv230407193O", "2023arXiv230412210B", "2023arXiv231002994M", "2024AJ....168...58D" ]
29096786
2403.03064
CHEX-MATE: Turbulence in the intra-cluster medium from X-ray surface brightness fluctuations
The intra-cluster medium is prone to turbulent motion that will contribute to the non-thermal heating of the gas, complicating the use of galaxy clusters as cosmological probes. Indirect approaches can estimate the intensity and structure of turbulent motions by studying the associated fluctuations in gas density and X-ray surface brightness. In this work, we aim to constrain the gas density fluctuations occurring in the CHEX-MATE sample to obtain a detailed view of their properties in a large population of clusters. To do so, we use a simulation-based approach to constrain the parameters of the power spectrum of density fluctuations, assuming a Kolmogorov-like spectrum and including the stochastic nature of the fluctuation-related observables in the error budget. Using a machine-learning approach, we learn an approximate likelihood for each cluster. This method requires clusters not to be too disturbed, as fluctuations can originate from dynamic processes such as merging. Accordingly, we removed the less relaxed clusters (centroid shift w &gt; 0.02) from our sample, resulting in a sample of 64 clusters. We defined different subsets of CHEX-MATE to determine properties of density fluctuations as a function of dynamical state, mass, and redshift, and we investigated the correlation with the presence or not of a radio halo. We found a positive correlation between the dynamical state and density fluctuation variance, a non-trivial behaviour with mass, and no specific trend with redshift or the presence of a radio halo. The injection scale is mostly constrained by the core region. The slope in the inertial range is consistent with the Kolmogorov theory. When interpreted as originating from turbulent motion, the density fluctuations in R<SUB>500</SUB> yield an average Mach number of ℳ<SUB>3D</SUB> ≃ 0.4 ± 0.2, an associated non-thermal pressure support of P<SUB>turb</SUB>/P<SUB>tot</SUB> ≃ (9 ± 6)%, or a hydrostatic mass bias b<SUB>turb</SUB> ≃ 0.09 ± 0.06. These findings align with expectations from existing literature.
[ 0.004997453652322292, 0.03228630870580673, -0.0004972610622644424, -0.020861724391579628, -0.010841172188520432, 0.036748435348272324, -0.00315265916287899, -0.006513678934425116, -0.013796689920127392, 0.025311028584837914, -0.017271507531404495, 0.018810171633958817, -0.06621385365724564, 0.019746191799640656, 0.0023256270214915276, 0.048955172300338745, -0.017309974879026413, 0.0051320865750312805, -0.056417692452669144, 0.015001977793872356, -0.03215808421373367, -0.010847583413124084, -0.012591402977705002, -0.012411892414093018, -0.05003223568201065, -0.0011435801861807704, 0.013630001805722713, -0.001153196906670928, 0.061649151146411896, -0.03454301506280899, 0.0036895889788866043, -0.017617706209421158, -0.010757828131318092, -0.04485206678509712, -0.06411101669073105, 0.043108247220516205, -0.05005788058042526, 0.062418483197689056, -0.03259404003620148, -0.05144267901778221, -0.03900514170527458, 0.00875756423920393, -0.03533799201250076, 0.04531366378068924, -0.016784263774752617, -0.06893216073513031, -0.0196307934820652, -0.046262506395578384, 0.028849957510828972, 0.01491222158074379, -0.050339967012405396, 0.029542354866862297, -0.011892593465745449, -0.020656568929553032, 0.012758092023432255, -0.020605280995368958, -0.0035709834191948175, 0.013347913511097431, -0.0019489747937768698, -0.0025900849141180515, 0.01288631372153759, -0.023272298276424408, 0.021451545879244804, -0.010937338694930077, 0.001383996568620205, 0.012014403939247131, 0.01851526089012623, 0.008962719701230526, 0.028901245445013046, 0.04954499378800392, 0.03503025695681572, -0.039441097527742386, -0.023387698456645012, -0.01561744324862957, -0.009283275343477726, -0.01277091447263956, -0.011257894337177277, -0.03910771757364273, -0.05126316845417023, 0.009834629483520985, 0.012001581490039825, 0.0018223555525764823, 0.04326211288571358, 0.010950161144137383, -0.024798139929771423, 0.00666113430634141, 0.01351460162550211, -0.01645088568329811, -0.04631379619240761, 0.004837175831198692, -0.041467003524303436, 0.00771255511790514, 0.019912881776690483, -0.011514338664710522, 0.005459052976220846, -0.07442006468772888, 0.033978838473558426, -0.05687929317355156, 0.05267360806465149, 0.024157030507922173, 0.007315066643059254, 0.04177473857998848, 0.02564440667629242, -0.03949238359928131, 0.09996189177036285, -0.0505707673728466, -0.05090414732694626, 0.0322093740105629, 0.01063601765781641, 0.00830878783017397, 0.06498292088508606, 0.015245599672198296, -0.04810890555381775, 0.021028412505984306, -0.03633812442421913, -0.02381082996726036, -0.08949897438287735, 0.0019473721040412784, -0.06877829879522324, 0.02690098248422146, -0.04559575393795967, -0.018399860709905624, 0.04600606486201286, 0.025400783866643906, -0.007686910685151815, -0.06031564250588417, 0.023836474865674973, -0.0039780884981155396, -0.0439545102417469, 0.03036297671496868, -0.004942959174513817, -0.0273112915456295, -0.019489748403429985, -0.01700224168598652, -0.023285120725631714, -0.012892724946141243, 0.025939317420125008, -0.0016444475622847676, 0.015886709094047546, -0.03210679441690445, 0.0027760069351643324, -0.004497387446463108, 0.014142889529466629, 0.03341466188430786, -0.028875600546598434, 0.04372371360659599, -0.03592781350016594, 0.03431221470236778, -0.013771045953035355, 0.010219295509159565, 0.022002900019288063, -0.006484829355031252, -0.050468191504478455, -0.024657096713781357, -0.014771177433431149, -0.02027190290391445, 0.020361658185720444, 0.04080025106668472, -0.015963641926646233, -0.061238840222358704, 0.009071708656847477, -0.01089246105402708, -0.047160062938928604, -0.010520617477595806, 0.009834629483520985, 0.006744478829205036, -0.016976596787571907, 0.010802705772221088, -0.05980275571346283, -0.02833706885576248, -0.017758751288056374, 0.01345049124211073, -0.02969622239470482, -0.03300435096025467, 0.00463522644713521, 0.031414397060871124, 0.027516447007656097, -0.0599566213786602, -0.029003823176026344, 0.028234491124749184, -0.018271639943122864, 0.025798272341489792, 0.07775384187698364, -0.009603830054402351, -0.021425900980830193, 0.01975901424884796, -0.023246653378009796, 0.034466080367565155, 0.010385984554886818, -0.005055153276771307, -0.023990342393517494, 0.006738067604601383, -0.00416080467402935, 0.030798930674791336, -0.04154393821954727, -0.05192992091178894, 0.011289949528872967, 0.023028677329421043, -0.021925967186689377, 0.03474817052483559, 0.03821016475558281, -0.006648312322795391, 0.02223370037972927, -0.03985140845179558, -0.026824047788977623, -0.03087586537003517, 0.02532385103404522, 0.004814737010747194, -0.0433134026825428, 0.03202986344695091, 0.004872437100857496, -0.0059462967328727245, 0.005436614155769348, -0.0018351777689531446, -0.01754077337682247, 0.024246785789728165, -0.05146832391619682, 0.04308260232210159, 0.011565626598894596, 0.04941676929593086, -0.003708822187036276, 0.06729092448949814, 0.02397751994431019, 0.006087340880185366, 0.002053155330941081, -0.009437141008675098, 0.026029072701931, -0.05369938537478447, 0.04762165993452072, 0.007032978348433971, -0.001956988824531436, 0.01365564577281475, -0.023836474865674973, -0.035466212779283524, 0.008334431797266006, 0.0008294362341985106, 0.023785186931490898, 0.014873755164444447, -0.015963641926646233, -0.024823784828186035, -0.052058145403862, -0.0017470251768827438, -0.022374743595719337, -0.0058789802715182304, -0.004247354809194803, 0.01102068368345499, -0.009789751842617989, 0.003490844741463661, 0.026029072701931, -0.008680631406605244, 0.007924121804535389, 0.018489615991711617, -0.024605806916952133, -0.04777552932500839, -0.02564440667629242, -0.006564967799931765, -0.03020910918712616, 0.028131913393735886, -0.026952270418405533, 0.017720283940434456, -0.009507663547992706, 0.0005465464200824499, -0.048826947808265686, -0.0006034449324943125, -0.002107649575918913, 0.008475475944578648, -0.0007452905410900712, -0.02050270326435566, -0.05267360806465149, -0.023246653378009796, -0.005776402540504932, -0.002033921889960766, 0.007840776816010475, -0.022067010402679443, -0.06867571920156479, 0.06246977299451828, 0.00369920558296144, 0.027003560215234756, -0.007148378062993288, -0.02050270326435566, -0.0548277385532856, -0.03508154675364494, 0.04290309175848961, 0.007539455313235521, -0.0018864666344597936, 0.01860501617193222, 0.01860501617193222, 0.01389926765114069, 0.016925306990742683, -0.019848769530653954, 0.05298134312033653, -0.023067142814397812, -0.009187108837068081, 0.007391999941319227, 0.0025516184978187084, -0.014130068011581898, 0.00377613864839077, -0.004817942623049021, -0.032568395137786865, -0.011995171196758747, -0.007065034005790949, 0.022695299237966537, 0.04559575393795967, -0.0037793442606925964, -0.002745554316788912, 0.02908075600862503, 0.06882958859205246, 0.03290177136659622, 0.01819470524787903, 0.034363504499197006, 0.010712950490415096, 0.03108101896941662, -0.010084662586450577, 0.02754209190607071, -0.05395583063364029, 0.009969262406229973, -0.011302771978080273, 0.05636640265583992, 0.019771836698055267, 0.001730997348204255, -0.08088245242834091, -0.04836535081267357, 0.0025964961387217045, -0.03836403042078018, 0.008994774892926216, -0.038517896085977554, 0.0105077950283885, -0.01433522254228592, -0.008667808957397938, -0.02261836640536785, -0.0076740882359445095, 0.016040576621890068, 0.05003223568201065, -0.04585219919681549, 0.03800500929355621, -0.04998094588518143, 0.03385061398148537, 0.06195688620209694, -0.02242603339254856, -0.01498915534466505, 0.009212752804160118, -0.01262987032532692, -0.006068107672035694, 0.004737804178148508, 0.030901508405804634, 0.010142362676560879, -0.002245488343760371, 0.026849692687392235, 0.061649151146411896, 0.007802310399711132, -0.013771045953035355, 0.008924253284931183, 0.0035613668151199818, -0.019938524812459946, 0.059597600251436234, -0.02287480980157852, 0.00047963051474653184, -0.03174777328968048, -0.03020910918712616, -0.01126430556178093, 0.004753831773996353, 0.00272792368195951, 0.06457261741161346, 0.031209241598844528, 0.05410969629883766, 0.017758751288056374, -0.037286967039108276, 0.022733766585588455, -0.03403012827038765, -0.0341327041387558, 0.004122338257730007, 0.022695299237966537, -0.0399026945233345, -0.02908075600862503, -0.041467003524303436, -0.02082325704395771, 0.037902433425188065, -0.005260308738797903, 0.037774208933115005, 0.026567604392766953, 0.07041953504085541, 0.011552805081009865, 0.028542224317789078, -0.04536495357751846, -0.01383515726774931, 0.017207397148013115, -0.020259080454707146, -0.041313137859106064, -0.09037088602781296, 0.04072331637144089, -0.02278505451977253, -0.009392263367772102, 0.003913977649062872, 0.029773155227303505, -0.02702920325100422, -0.012879902496933937, 0.014142889529466629, 0.062008172273635864, 0.03567136824131012, 0.0533403642475605, -0.01657910831272602, -0.022938920184969902, -0.052622321993112564, -0.011091205291450024, -0.0217592790722847, -0.008231854066252708, -0.017361262813210487, 0.06170044094324112, -0.0008566834148950875, -0.018502438440918922, 0.04344162344932556, -0.0038081943057477474, 0.01554050948470831, -0.020028280094265938, -0.013822334818542004, 0.0004171222972217947, -0.03710745647549629, 0.04344162344932556, -0.01670733094215393, 0.058315377682447433, -0.0366971455514431, 0.002716704271733761, -0.0009416305110789835, 0.01841268315911293, -0.05234023183584213, 0.03159390762448311, 0.035466212779283524, 0.0008350459393113852, -0.024221140891313553, -0.0021044439636170864, -0.004189654719084501, 0.02679840475320816, -0.0039780884981155396, 0.02728564850986004, 0.0005521561251953244, -0.0004776270652655512, 0.02641373872756958, -0.021515656262636185, 0.006859878543764353, -0.047031842172145844, 0.004436482209712267, -0.004446099046617746, 0.008654987439513206, -0.031004086136817932, 0.02001545950770378, -0.004167215898633003, 0.035620078444480896, 0.004574320744723082, 0.03515848144888878, -0.020066747441887856, -0.011206605471670628, -0.029029468074440956, 0.0004061032086610794, 0.04536495357751846, 0.0065200901590287685, -0.03123488649725914, 0.044005800038576126, -0.01542511023581028, 0.03887692093849182, -0.04405708983540535, -0.012334959581494331, 0.029773155227303505, -0.03226066380739212, 0.010655250400304794, -0.009001186117529869, 0.022387566044926643, -0.007372766733169556, -0.005699469242244959, 0.014424978755414486, 0.015989286825060844, 0.033722393214702606, -0.07262495905160904, 0.047570373862981796, -0.014860933646559715, 0.0115207489579916, -0.04072331637144089, -0.022413210943341255, -0.00019343495659995824, 0.08472912013530731, 0.022951742634177208, 0.06026435270905495, -0.004785887431353331, -0.0339275486767292, 0.023644141852855682, 0.04049251601099968, 0.06370070576667786, -0.012488825246691704, 0.03759469836950302, 0.013745401985943317, -0.0019778248388320208, -0.007347122300416231, -0.028003690764307976, 0.051981210708618164, -0.01339920237660408, 0.017976729199290276, 0.0057699913159012794, -0.022644009441137314, 0.006404690444469452, -0.011770782060921192, 0.025695694610476494, 0.05267360806465149, 0.003151056356728077, 0.0034748169127851725, -0.024285253137350082, 0.004984631203114986, 0.0173869077116251, -0.05487902835011482, -0.048314061015844345, -0.02551618404686451, 0.005737935658544302, -0.026029072701931, 0.04000527411699295, 0.025362316519021988, 0.024913540109992027, 0.005257103126496077, 0.018130594864487648, -0.028208846226334572, 0.022669654339551926, 0.006968867499381304, -0.006068107672035694, -0.002041935920715332, -0.009225575253367424, -0.01351460162550211, 0.018297282978892326, -0.019258948042988777, -0.018874282017350197, -0.033696748316287994, -0.12370861321687698, -0.03377368301153183, -0.0052122254855930805, 0.007353533525019884, -0.011322004720568657, -0.0037569054402410984, 0.022926099598407745, -0.021387433633208275, -0.03492768108844757, -0.046518951654434204, -0.013937734998762608, 0.028798667713999748, -0.016079042106866837, -0.002485904609784484, -0.010411628521978855, -0.03367110341787338, 0.025362316519021988, 0.03618425503373146, 0.03567136824131012, 0.024477586150169373, 0.00502950930967927, 0.02372107468545437, 0.036517634987831116, 0.02088736928999424, -0.028901245445013046, 0.0064976513385772705, 0.010732184164226055, 0.001254171715117991, -0.00144009361974895, 0.018912749364972115, -0.026490671560168266, 0.01466859970241785, 0.007097089197486639, -0.02522127330303192, -0.0039844997227191925, -0.010020551271736622, 0.039800118654966354, -0.02522127330303192, -0.023759542033076286, -0.025670049712061882, -0.026875337585806847, -0.02718307077884674, 0.018656305968761444, -0.024592984467744827, -0.007212489377707243, 0.0020178942941129208, -0.003094959305599332, 0.01934870332479477, -0.01657910831272602, 0.005510341841727495, -0.004776270594447851, 0.008135687559843063, -0.02920897863805294, -0.009526897221803665, 0.004375576972961426, 0.04569832980632782, 0.041210561990737915, -0.009892329573631287, 0.0037857554852962494, 0.013732579536736012, 0.007802310399711132, -0.0051961978897452354, -0.009014008566737175, 0.012892724946141243, -0.020810434594750404, 0.01834857277572155, 0.0027647875249385834, -0.018040839582681656, 0.025503361597657204, 0.010655250400304794, -0.005362886469811201, -0.007994643412530422, -0.014142889529466629, 0.008328020572662354, 0.026208583265542984, -0.033722393214702606, -0.05652027204632759, -0.0259264949709177, 0.03223501890897751, 0.009347385726869106, -0.0016957363113760948, -0.02432371862232685, 0.03364546224474907, 0.004926931578665972, 0.016399597749114037, 0.00850112084299326, -0.05508418381214142, 0.002424999140202999, -0.009244807995855808, 0.005955913104116917, -0.051237523555755615, 0.039056431502103806, -0.002796842949464917, -0.019553858786821365, -0.021002767607569695, -0.0013142757816240191, -0.00311258970759809, 0.00007342714525293559, 0.016861196607351303, 0.022067010402679443, -0.012751680798828602, 0.0169637743383646, 0.01365564577281475, 0.008776797913014889, -0.006036052014678717, 0.005943091120570898, 0.013386379927396774, -0.007058622781187296, 0.0274138692766428, -0.0029971899930387735, 0.013232513330876827, -0.03161955252289772, -0.01911790482699871, 0.05308391898870468, 0.01465577818453312, 0.029285911470651627, -0.047416508197784424, 0.0190922599285841, -0.0037793442606925964, -0.009526897221803665, 0.006879111751914024, -0.015591798350214958, 0.007911299355328083, 0.01523277722299099, -0.021810567006468773, 0.004071049392223358, 0.012873492203652859, 0.023798009380698204, -0.012918369844555855, 0.0024169853422790766, -0.011674615554511547, -0.037902433425188065, 0.013309447094798088, 0.00987950712442398, 0.011148905381560326, -0.007545866537839174, 0.0032167702447623014, -0.05816151201725006, 0.01802801713347435, -0.012245203368365765, 0.0130145363509655, -0.012129804119467735, 0.03138875216245651, 0.05164783447980881, 0.012508058920502663, 0.008526764810085297, 0.024695562198758125, -0.023759542033076286, 0.005862952210009098, 0.021682344377040863, -0.010411628521978855, -0.011155316606163979, 0.017079174518585205, -0.015963641926646233, 0.021323323249816895, -0.030003955587744713, 0.0019553860183805227, 0.011232249438762665, 0.00946278590708971, 0.02214394509792328, 0.021066879853606224, 0.011847715824842453, 0.004987836815416813, 0.010148773901164532, -0.0027583763003349304, 0.014630133286118507, 0.022413210943341255, -0.021054057404398918, -0.027849825099110603, -0.035620078444480896, -0.004808326251804829, 0.040569450706243515, -0.009065297432243824, 0.03254275023937225, 0.023798009380698204, -0.0018479999853298068, -0.0029891759622842073, -0.00987950712442398, -0.026016250252723694, 0.003625477897003293, -0.012379837222397327, 0.05646898224949837, -0.011828482151031494, 0.008911430835723877, 0.03556879237294197, 0.009340974502265453, 0.005135292187333107, -0.0010225706500932574, 0.012328548356890678, -0.013020946644246578, 0.00432108249515295, -0.003846660954877734, -0.017733106389641762, 0.04254407063126564, -0.009001186117529869, -0.03318386152386665, -0.01364282425493002, 0.04326211288571358, -0.03354288265109062, -0.01786132901906967, 0.008430598303675652, -0.000531720754224807, -0.035107191652059555, 0.02831142395734787, 0.013258158229291439, 0.0008065967122092843, -0.04413402080535889, 0.011161727830767632, 0.014104423113167286, 0.0038658941630274057, 0.0031542619690299034, 0.018271639943122864, 0.020810434594750404, 0.011738726869225502, -0.019874414429068565, 0.03469688072800636, -0.005789224524050951, 0.046134285628795624, 0.008116454817354679, 0.07067598402500153, -0.009257630445063114, 0.014437800273299217, -0.01345049124211073, 0.00471536535769701, 0.011046327650547028, 0.023015854880213737, -0.011155316606163979, -0.004372371360659599, -0.019297415390610695, -0.0000893547257874161, -0.006523295771330595, 0.021233567968010902, 0.03715874254703522, 0.018720416352152824, 0.050955433398485184, -0.014630133286118507, 0.02040012553334236, -0.02969622239470482, 0.006177096161991358, -0.03177341818809509, -0.0326453298330307, 0.016271375119686127, -0.04508286714553833, -0.006488034501671791, 0.028798667713999748, 0.020784791558980942, -0.003997321706265211, 0.029132045805454254, -0.006815000902861357, 0.02982444316148758, -0.009937207214534283, 0.010026962496340275, -0.011693849228322506, -0.014014667831361294, -0.017848506569862366, 0.01732279546558857, -0.026952270418405533, -0.0460829958319664, -0.004154393915086985, -0.022451676428318024, -0.018694771453738213, -0.011533571407198906, 0.026080360636115074, -0.012290081940591335, 0.002750362502411008, 0.016053397208452225, -0.00867422018200159, -0.02985008805990219, 0.05964888632297516, 0.008090809918940067, -0.09780776500701904, 0.00560650834813714, 0.022900454699993134, 0.02522127330303192, 0.03233759477734566, 0.024477586150169373, 0.00021958022261969745, 0.03274790570139885, -0.0004447701503522694, -0.0059462967328727245, 0.01854090578854084, -0.021451545879244804, 0.008719097822904587, 0.06026435270905495, -0.0025948933325707912, -0.027849825099110603, 0.009084531106054783, 0.041979894042015076, 0.017104819416999817, 0.01979748159646988, 0.0086421649903059, 0.0003235602634958923, -0.020900189876556396, 0.009501252323389053, 0.003135028528049588, 0.008706275373697281, -0.027490803971886635, -0.005625741556286812, 0.034978970885276794, -0.008026698604226112, -0.008648576214909554, 0.00179190281778574, 0.009860274381935596, 0.05016045644879341, -0.035850878804922104, -0.022182410582900047, -0.01905379444360733, 0.021054057404398918, -0.02310561016201973, -0.008770386688411236, 0.013937734998762608, -0.008616520091891289, 0.03874869644641876, 0.032055508345365524, 0.03826145455241203, -0.003930005244910717, -0.018015194684267044, -0.003981294110417366, 0.028080623596906662, 0.007943354547023773, -0.009885918349027634, 0.02300303243100643, 0.029439777135849, 0.026849692687392235, -0.0027647875249385834, 0.031799063086509705, -0.021387433633208275, 0.026208583265542984, -0.014642955735325813, -0.011354060843586922, -0.004539059940725565, 0.01732279546558857, 0.0150404442101717, -0.038030654191970825, -0.057443469762802124, -0.02487507276237011, -0.03300435096025467, 0.033696748316287994, -0.0006575385923497379, -0.018207527697086334, -0.003603039076551795, 0.029260266572237015, 0.050339967012405396, 0.031824707984924316, -0.0257085170596838, 0.001149189891293645, 0.0071740224957466125, 0.007706143893301487, -0.05082721263170242, 0.026567604392766953, -0.021938789635896683, -0.0045005930587649345, 0.04346726834774017, -0.02985008805990219, 0.017425373196601868, 0.04367242380976677, -0.009046063758432865, -0.017976729199290276, -0.01934870332479477, -0.01025135163217783, 0.011116850189864635, -0.005468669347465038, 0.03241452947258949, -0.001444100635126233, 0.00003325758734717965, 0.011636149138212204, -0.0014793616719543934, -0.038799986243247986, 0.024977650493383408, -0.010142362676560879, 0.0022535021416842937, -0.03710745647549629, 0.027106136083602905, -0.023592853918671608, -0.0035902168601751328, 0.0011035108473151922, -0.010353928431868553, -0.010437273420393467, 0.018040839582681656, 0.014630133286118507, 0.036004744470119476, 0.02558029443025589, -0.0197333712130785, 0.054520007222890854, 0.07375331223011017, 0.015399465337395668, -0.010257761925458908, -0.019784659147262573, 0.02468273974955082, -0.03177341818809509, 0.025246918201446533, 0.009802574291825294, -0.035466212779283524, -0.02349027618765831, -0.006680367514491081, 0.0017069557216018438, -0.00007097289926605299, -0.0105077950283885, -0.03315821662545204, 0.005112853366881609, -0.023118432611227036, 0.003372239414602518, 0.004859615117311478, 0.03354288265109062, -0.02756773680448532, 0.004147982690483332, -0.01466859970241785, 0.03185035288333893, 0.0057411412708461285, 0.03503025695681572, -0.003744083223864436, -0.015514865517616272, 0.01854090578854084, -0.032311949878931046, -0.015219954773783684, 0.01574566587805748, 0.02236192114651203, -0.024092920124530792, 0.04346726834774017, 0.02240038849413395, -0.023477453738451004, 0.011604093946516514, 0.017117640003561974, 0.009629474021494389, -0.015963641926646233, -0.0299783106893301, 0.016976596787571907, 0.02464427426457405, -0.0036607389338314533, 0.002171760657802224, 0.02425960823893547, 0.033594172447919846, 0.02216958813369274, -0.000803791859652847, -0.009206341579556465, -0.002073991345241666, -0.04839099198579788, 0.005465464200824499, -0.0018031223444268107, 0.016412420198321342, 0.0071868449449539185, -0.06754736602306366, 0.01110402774065733, 0.009597418829798698, -0.010777061805129051, 0.03190164268016815, -0.0006515281856991351, 0.015284066088497639, 0.008892198093235493, 0.01441215630620718, -0.017053529620170593, -0.028465289622545242, -0.017912616953253746, -0.026567604392766953, 0.036132968962192535, 0.032953061163425446, -0.0315682627260685, 0.03859483078122139, 0.0039780884981155396, 0.010379573330283165, -0.022990209981799126, 0.023733897134661674, 0.010482151061296463, 0.031157953664660454, 0.025503361597657204, 0.0038883329834789038, -0.04218504577875137, 0.02169516682624817, -0.02554182894527912, -0.0025067406240850687, -0.019130727276206017, -0.018720416352152824, 0.007795899175107479, -0.02291327714920044, -0.019682081416249275, 0.0000760316543164663, -0.0014304770156741142, -0.021451545879244804, -0.0003309731255285442, 0.017374085262417793, 0.014822466298937798, 0.020002637058496475, 0.009469197131693363, 0.02522127330303192, 0.06667545437812805, -0.04444175586104393, 0.04713441804051399, -0.018297282978892326, -0.0031157953198999166, -0.00047963051474653184, 0.0518529899418354, -0.0381845198571682, -0.0003574189031496644, 0.0533403642475605, 0.005260308738797903, 0.052135076373815536, -0.030516842380166054, 0.003827427513897419, -0.03987704962491989, 0.006981689482927322, 0.010078251361846924, -0.01870759390294552, 0.0012333357008174062, 0.00009185906674247235, -0.03908207267522812, -0.024080097675323486, -0.021169457584619522, 0.013053002767264843, -0.005048742517828941, -0.0012942410539835691, 0.014130068011581898, 0.03544056788086891, -0.00393641646951437, -0.003027642611414194, -0.023477453738451004, -0.018681949004530907, 0.028465289622545242, -0.008847320452332497, 0.022028544917702675, -0.007879244163632393, -0.028901245445013046, -0.006064902059733868, -0.01359153538942337, 0.027080493047833443, -0.009058886207640171, 0.042108114808797836, -0.012322137132287025, 0.05621253699064255, 0.022964565083384514, 0.004997453652322292, -0.0013872020645067096, -0.029362844303250313, -0.04477513208985329, -0.019682081416249275, 0.03364546224474907, -0.00851394236087799, -0.05749475955963135, 0.010264173150062561, 0.006725245621055365, -0.0015971655957400799, -0.020836079493165016, -0.034209638833999634, 0.01702788472175598, 0.012597814202308655, -0.011892593465745449, 0.0128542585298419, 0.00034740156843326986, -0.022310633212327957, -0.024759674444794655, 0.02982444316148758, -0.0016556669725105166, -0.03261968493461609, -0.010527028702199459, -0.0058885966427624226, 0.01209774799644947, 0.0070714447647333145, -0.02481096237897873, -0.004811531864106655, 0.030286043882369995, -0.010655250400304794, -0.0007529037538915873, 0.023785186931490898, 0.024246785789728165, 0.011636149138212204, -0.00716761127114296, -0.01094374991953373, -0.0021749662701040506, 0.030286043882369995, -0.012110570445656776, -0.01071936171501875, -0.011546393856406212, -0.00830878783017397, -0.0037248500157147646, -0.008443420752882957, -0.0140274902805686, 0.008815264329314232, -0.039030786603689194, -0.018207527697086334, -0.022823521867394447, -0.040569450706243515, 0.004221710376441479, 0.00611298531293869, -0.00455508753657341, 0.015271243639290333, 0.010302640497684479, -0.00837289821356535, -0.009885918349027634, 0.01889992691576481, 0.005507136229425669, -0.008558820001780987, -0.033081281930208206, -0.021669523790478706, 0.011232249438762665, -0.012181092984974384, -0.018630661070346832, -0.01140534970909357, -0.01568155363202095, 0.020412947982549667, 0.005830896552652121, 0.03792807459831238, 0.003381856018677354, 0.050109170377254486, 0.005532780662178993, -0.020451413467526436, -0.008347254246473312, 0.026003427803516388, -0.002769595943391323, -0.0011363677913323045, 0.006359812803566456, 0.013937734998762608, -0.014860933646559715, 0.01102068368345499, -0.030927153304219246, -0.003551750211045146, -0.01661757566034794, 0.013059413991868496, -0.006087340880185366, -0.02818320132791996, -0.012187504209578037, -0.0452367328107357, 0.05964888632297516, -0.008174153976142406, -0.017694640904664993, -0.01988723687827587, 0.03569701313972473, -0.01107197254896164, -0.0019778248388320208, 0.014155711978673935, -0.005285953171551228, 0.005308391992002726, 0.01327097974717617, 0.021874677389860153, -0.010328284464776516, 0.017297152429819107, 0.022823521867394447, -0.0005898213130421937, -0.01747666299343109, 0.01086040586233139, -0.01428393367677927, 0.009693585336208344, -0.01841268315911293, -0.0005882185650989413, 0.004894875921308994, 0.0017999167321249843, -0.014950688928365707, -0.006465595681220293, 0.00771255511790514, -0.010809116996824741, 0.005039125680923462, 0.04900645837187767, -0.004029377363622189, 0.005869363434612751, 0.0036895889788866043, -0.006356607191264629, -0.01409160066395998, -0.026388093829154968, -0.021028412505984306, 0.03708181157708168, -0.003721644403412938, 0.007007333915680647, 0.037286967039108276, -0.0038723053876310587, -0.01250164769589901, -0.026080360636115074, -0.01384797878563404, 0.0366971455514431, -0.005670619197189808, 0.02487507276237011, 0.003824222134426236, -0.015578976832330227, 0.015886709094047546, 0.006061696447432041, 0.01102068368345499, -0.00008584865281591192, 0.011232249438762665, 0.00682141212746501, 0.0332864373922348, 0.031696487218141556, 0.018553728237748146, -0.007411233149468899, 0.008687042631208897, -0.024413473904132843, -0.04554446414113045, 0.028106268495321274, 0.013335091061890125, -0.014809644781053066, 0.028721734881401062, 0.02233627811074257, -0.00867422018200159, -0.005282747559249401, -0.03072199784219265, -0.0070778559893369675, 0.007270189002156258, 0.004792298190295696, -0.013040180318057537, -0.0026093183550983667, -0.012828613631427288, 0.018117772415280342, -0.0005966331227682531, 0.010135951451957226, -0.015720020979642868, -0.011950293555855751, -0.02679840475320816, 0.029439777135849, -0.025849560275673866, 0.029234623536467552, 0.011386116035282612, -0.02361849695444107, -0.035363636910915375, 0.04318517819046974, -0.013681290671229362, -0.0070265671238303185, 0.014450622722506523, 0.016976596787571907, 0.020387303084135056, 0.004590348806232214, -0.002311201998963952, -0.008751153945922852, 0.019002504646778107, -0.04339033365249634, -0.03951802849769592, 0.02677275985479355, 0.030927153304219246, -0.006068107672035694, -0.012059281580150127, -0.008199798874557018, -0.01561744324862957, -0.023631319403648376, 0.008802441880106926, -0.007295833434909582, 0.0197333712130785, 0.01722021773457527, 0.0013375160051509738, -0.00771255511790514, -0.014681422151625156, 0.04759601876139641, 0.004051816184073687, 0.003353005973622203, -0.013912090100347996, -0.0038434553425759077, 0.01465577818453312, 0.026234226301312447, 0.0086421649903059, -0.012059281580150127, -0.027106136083602905, -0.037261322140693665, 0.011475871317088604, 0.0039396220818161964, 0.01554050948470831, 0.01892557181417942, -0.04441611096262932, 0.004311465658247471, 0.022746587172150612, -0.011950293555855751, 0.017297152429819107, -0.009937207214534283, 0.015271243639290333, -0.006202740594744682, 0.03159390762448311, 0.0039620609022676945, -0.001260582823306322, -0.005471874959766865, -0.0038146052975207567, -0.01988723687827587, 0.019682081416249275, -0.00977051816880703, -0.0003696400672197342, 0.002445835154503584, 0.004936547949910164, -0.0053148032166063786, 0.0010578316869214177, 0.006311729550361633, -0.011777193285524845, 0.00682141212746501, -0.02577262744307518, 0.002710293047130108, -0.04231327027082443, -0.025939317420125008, 0.01873323880136013, 0.006379046011716127, 0.019771836698055267, 0.005157731007784605, 0.0023753130808472633, 0.004622403997927904, 0.04726263880729675, -0.025631584227085114, -0.001383996568620205, -0.01465577818453312, -0.015014799311757088, 0.01176437083631754, -0.015296888537704945, -0.018784526735544205, 0.023823652416467667, -0.012995302677154541, -0.023195365443825722, -0.011289949528872967, 0.006641901098191738, -0.00669960118830204, -0.021002767607569695, 0.03736389800906181, 0.020194970071315765, -0.031055375933647156, 0.0018463971791788936, 0.02374671958386898, 0.020336013287305832, -0.015835421159863472, -0.014130068011581898, 0.006808589678257704, 0.036902301013469696, -0.0028096651658415794, 0.004965397994965315, -0.015027621760964394, 0.021861856803297997, 0.002857748419046402, 0.019617971032857895, 0.01580977626144886, -0.015771308913826942, -0.0313631072640419, -0.0031863173935562372, 0.02092583477497101, -0.03272226080298424, -0.03554314747452736, 0.012091337703168392, -0.018502438440918922, -0.003782549872994423, 0.024849429726600647, -0.018694771453738213, 0.015758488327264786, 0.008071577176451683, 0.008507532067596912, 0.015296888537704945, -0.021541301161050797, -0.01225802581757307, -0.004061432555317879, 0.021797744557261467, -0.0035902168601751328, -0.007930532097816467, 0.019592326134443283, -0.008001054637134075, -0.013085057958960533, 0.02352874167263508, 0.026439381763339043, -0.009469197131693363, 0.005497519392520189, 0.0196307934820652, 0.0480063259601593, 0.03826145455241203, 0.0004431674024090171, 0.022310633212327957, 0.019810304045677185, -0.011892593465745449, -0.016412420198321342, 0.003869099775329232, 0.012687569484114647, -0.007366355508565903, 0.0014424978289753199, -0.030645065009593964, 0.0016276183305308223, -0.00666113430634141, -0.016566285863518715, 0.01031546201556921, -0.014309578575193882, 0.011879771016538143, 0.02381082996726036, -0.0010730581125244498, 0.017297152429819107, 0.021156635135412216, 0.03097844310104847, -0.018169062212109566, -0.018130594864487648, 0.003181509207934141, 0.04592913016676903, -0.0293371994048357, 0.003353005973622203, 0.007545866537839174, -0.031157953664660454, -0.0012052870588377118, -0.05764862522482872, 0.00014194579853210598, 0.01734844036400318, -0.005000659264624119, 0.002223049523308873, 0.02969622239470482, 0.002011483069509268, 0.030619420111179352, 0.02931155636906624, -0.015899531543254852, 0.0130145363509655, -0.007039389573037624, -0.018335750326514244, -0.010642428882420063, -0.028516579419374466, -0.004215299151837826, -0.005904624238610268, 0.016861196607351303, 0.03351723775267601, -0.010103896260261536, -0.02069503627717495, 0.006847056560218334, -0.01915637031197548, 0.0013920103665441275, -0.017309974879026413, 0.011174550279974937, -0.006189918611198664, -0.037902433425188065, -0.009796163067221642, -0.01661757566034794, 0.01834857277572155, -0.009276864118874073, 0.03390190377831459, 0.02281069941818714, -0.000483637471916154, 0.017630528658628464, -0.02236192114651203, -0.02069503627717495, -0.02249014377593994, -0.009424319490790367, -0.03164519742131233, 0.014117245562374592, -0.03164519742131233, 0.00973846297711134, -0.03515848144888878, -0.026106005534529686, -0.005587275139987469, 0.0022310633212327957, 0.006407896056771278, 0.008796031586825848, -0.012078515253961086, 0.012322137132287025, 0.008962719701230526, 0.0038979495875537395, 0.004420454613864422, -0.004410837776958942, 0.03679972141981125, 0.004372371360659599, -0.002125280210748315, -0.01722021773457527, 0.05652027204632759, 0.009783340618014336, 0.0038306331261992455, -0.006750890053808689, 0.012142626568675041, 0.005478286184370518, -0.01479682233184576, 0.0150404442101717, -0.025246918201446533, 0.02240038849413395, 0.028414001688361168, 0.015848243609070778, 0.01447626668959856, 0.02088736928999424, -0.04033865034580231, 0.020220613107085228, -0.0375434085726738, -0.007148378062993288, -0.005587275139987469, 0.02664453722536564, 0.026054715737700462, 0.0022390771191567183, -0.033594172447919846, 0.029414134100079536, -0.015822598710656166, 0.0032231812365353107, -0.030183466151356697, -0.011623326689004898, 0.005042331293225288, -0.003184714587405324, 0.004721776116639376, -0.027234358713030815, -0.010777061805129051, 0.011732315644621849, -0.03033733181655407, -0.02114381268620491, -0.01747666299343109, 0.04149264842271805, 0.025246918201446533, 0.03374803811311722, 0.014271112158894539, 0.010546261444687843, 0.01655346341431141, -0.006680367514491081, 0.01257858145982027, 0.020618101581931114, 0.01956668123602867, -0.0150404442101717, 0.03010653331875801, 0.029388489201664925, -0.006036052014678717, -0.023195365443825722, -0.0118413046002388, 0.0036671499256044626, 0.012719625607132912, -0.006103368476033211, 0.012136215344071388, -0.01339920237660408, -0.027875469997525215, -0.0018848638283088803, 0.006353401578962803, 0.008469064719974995, -0.008007465861737728, 0.037774208933115005, -0.02249014377593994, -0.002383326878771186, -0.009238396771252155, 0.006962456274777651, 0.0028000485617667437, -0.013809512369334698, -0.018887104466557503, -0.025144340470433235 ]
13.560155
4.86835
2024-07-01
2
2024A&A...687A..58D
[ "density fluctuations", "gas density", "fluctuations", "galaxy clusters", "turbulent motion", "turbulent motions", "clusters", "the gas density fluctuations", "Indirect approaches", "the density fluctuations" ]
[ "turbulence", "galaxies: clusters: intracluster medium", "X-rays: galaxies: clusters", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
28
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202348701", "10.48550/arXiv.2403.03064" ]
[ "Dupourqué, S.", "Clerc, N.", "Pointecouteau, E.", "Eckert, D.", "Gaspari, M.", "Lovisari, L.", "Pratt, G. W.", "Rasia, E.", "Rossetti, M.", "Vazza, F.", "Balboni, M.", "Bartalucci, I.", "Bourdin, H.", "De Luca, F.", "De Petris, M.", "Ettori, S.", "Ghizzardi, S.", "Mazzotta, P." ]
[ "IRAP, Université de Toulouse, CNRS, CNES, UT3-PS, Toulouse, France", "IRAP, Université de Toulouse, CNRS, CNES, UT3-PS, Toulouse, France", "IRAP, Université de Toulouse, CNRS, CNES, UT3-PS, Toulouse, France", "Department of Astronomy, University of Geneva, Ch. d'Ecogia 16, 1290, Versoix, Switzerland", "Department of Astrophysical Sciences, Princeton University, 4 Ivy Lane, Princeton, NJ, 08544-1001, USA", "Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia, Universitá di Bologna, Via Gobetti 93/2, 40122, Bologna, Italy; Center for Astrophysics | Harvard &amp; Smithsonian, 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA, 02138, USA", "Université Paris-Saclay, Université Paris Cité, CEA, CNRS, AIM, 91191, Gif-sur-Yvette, France", "INAF, Osservatorio di Trieste, v. Tiepolo 11, 34131, Trieste, Italy; IFPU, Institute for Fundamental Physics of the Universe, Via Beirut 2, 34014, Trieste, Italy", "Istituto Nazionale di Astrofisica, IASF-Milano, Via A. Corti 12, 20133, Milano, Italy", "Hamburger Sternwarte, University of Hamburg, Gojenbergsweg 112, 21029, Hamburg, Germany; Istituto di Radioastronomia, INAF, Via Gobetti 101, 40122, Bologna, Italy; INAF, Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio, Via Piero Gobetti 93/3, 40129, Bologna, Italy", "Istituto Nazionale di Astrofisica, IASF-Milano, Via A. Corti 12, 20133, Milano, Italy; DiSAT, Università degli Studi dell'Insubria, Via Valleggio 11, 22100, Como, Italy", "Istituto Nazionale di Astrofisica, IASF-Milano, Via A. Corti 12, 20133, Milano, Italy", "Università degli studi di Roma \"Tor Vergata\", Via della ricerca scientifica, 1, 00133, Roma, Italy; INFN, Sezione di Roma 2, Università degli studi di Roma Tor Vergata, Via della Ricerca Scientifica, 1, Roma, Italy", "Università degli studi di Roma \"Tor Vergata\", Via della ricerca scientifica, 1, 00133, Roma, Italy; INFN, Sezione di Roma 2, Università degli studi di Roma Tor Vergata, Via della Ricerca Scientifica, 1, Roma, Italy", "Dipartimento di Fisica, Sapienza Università di Roma, Piazzale Aldo Moro 5, 00185, Roma, Italy", "INAF, Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio, Via Piero Gobetti 93/3, 40129, Bologna, Italy", "Istituto Nazionale di Astrofisica, IASF-Milano, Via A. Corti 12, 20133, Milano, Italy", "Università degli studi di Roma \"Tor Vergata\", Via della ricerca scientifica, 1, 00133, Roma, Italy; INFN, Sezione di Roma 2, Università degli studi di Roma Tor Vergata, Via della Ricerca Scientifica, 1, Roma, Italy" ]
[ "2024arXiv240506489R", "2024arXiv240611973M" ]
[ "1941DoSSR..30..301K", "1989GeCoA..53..197A", "2003ApJ...590..858V", "2003MNRAS.342..345C", "2004A&A...426..387S", "2006A&A...459..341M", "2006ApJ...640..691V", "2006ApJ...650..128K", "2007PASJ...59S.351O", "2008A&A...478..615S", "2008A&A...491...71P", "2008MNRAS.384.1567M", "2009ApJ...705.1129L", "2009PASJ...61.1293S", "2010ApJ...711.1033Z", "2011MNRAS.410.1797S", "2011PASJ...63S1009T", "2012A&A...544A.103V", "2012ApJ...751..121N", "2012MNRAS.421.1123C", "2012MNRAS.426.1793A", "2012NJPh...14e5018R", "2012NJPh...14e5023M", "2013A&A...556A...2V", "2013A&A...558A..33A", "2013A&A...559A..78G", "2013ATel.5032....1R", "2013MNRAS.429.2727S", "2014A&A...569A..67G", "2014ApJ...782...38T", "2014ApJ...782..107N", "2014ApJ...783L..10G", "2014ApJ...788L..13Z", "2014IJMPD..2330007B", "2014Natur.515...85Z", "2015A&A...575A..38P", "2015MNRAS.450.4184Z", "2016A&A...585A.130H", "2016A&A...594A..27P", "2016A&A...594A.116H", "2016ApJ...817..110Z", "2016ApJ...827..112B", "2016JOSS....1...45H", "2016MNRAS.455.2936S", "2016MNRAS.458.2584B", "2016MNRAS.459..701S", "2016MNRAS.463..655K", "2016Natur.535..117H", "2016PASJ...68S..19O", "2017AN....338..293E", "2017ApJ...843L..29E", "2017ApJ...845...80V", "2017ApJ...846...51L", "2017MNRAS.472.1659O", "2018A&A...618A..39R", "2018AJ....156..123A", "2018ApJ...853..180Z", "2018ApJ...865...53Z", "2018MNRAS.481L.120V", "2019A&A...621A..40E", "2019A&A...621A..41G", "2019A&A...622A...1S", "2019A&A...629A.143C", "2019A&A...629A.144C", "2019MNRAS.484.4881M", "2019MNRAS.487.1072S", "2019SSRv..215...24S", "2019SSRv..215...25P", "2019arXiv191211554P", "2020AN....341..224B", "2020JOSS....5.2004V", "2020JOSS....5.2505T", "2020MNRAS.493.5838M", "2020MNRAS.495..864A", "2020arXiv200304962X", "2021A&A...650A.104C", "2021JATIS...7c7001T", "2021MNRAS.500.5072M", "2021MNRAS.504.5383D", "2022A&A...657L...1E", "2022A&A...658A.149S", "2022A&A...659A...1S", "2022A&A...660A..78B", "2022MNRAS.509.5918H", "2022MNRAS.511.4511G", "2022MNRAS.513.1932G", "2022arXiv221109827K", "2023A&A...672A..42Z", "2023A&A...673A..91D", "2023A&A...674A.179B", "2023ApJ...951...41R", "2023MNRAS.518.4238G", "2023MNRAS.520.5157Z", "2023MNRAS.522.2325G", "2023MNRAS.524.2945G", "2024A&A...682A..45L", "2024A&A...686A..68R", "2024MNRAS.530.4234Z" ]
29072411
2404.10055
The environmental dependence of the stellar mass-gas metallicity relation in Horizon Run 5
Metallicity offers a unique window into the baryonic history of the cosmos, being instrumental in probing evolutionary processes in galaxies between different cosmic environments. We aim to quantify the contribution of these environments to the scatter in the mass-metallicity relation (MZR) of galaxies. By analysing the galaxy distribution within the cosmic skeleton of the Horizon Run 5 cosmological hydrodynamical simulation at redshift z = 0.625, computed using a careful calibration of the T-ReX filament finder, we identify galaxies within three main environments: nodes, filaments, and voids. We also classify galaxies based on the dynamical state of the clusters and the length of the filaments in which they reside. We find that the cosmic environment significantly contributes to the scatter in the MZR; in particular, both the gas metallicity and its average relative standard deviation increase when considering denser large-scale environments. The difference in the average metallicity between galaxies within relaxed and unrelaxed clusters is ≈0.1dex, with both populations displaying positive residuals, δZ<SUB>g</SUB>, from the averaged MZR. Moreover, the difference in metallicity between node and void galaxies accounts for $\approx 0.14 \, \text{dex}$ in the scatter of the MZR at stellar mass $M_{\star } \approx 10^{9.35}\, \text{M}_{\odot }$. Finally, both the average [O/Fe] in the gas and the galaxy gas fraction decrease when moving to higher large-scale densities in the simulation, suggesting that the cores of cosmic environments host - on average - older and more massive galaxies, whose enrichment is affected by a larger number of Type Ia Supernova events.
[ 0.04033317044377327, 0.07676153630018234, 0.016718989238142967, -0.005770707968622446, 0.03682379052042961, 0.009150341153144836, 0.029088322073221207, 0.017052628099918365, -0.03670021891593933, 0.023082831874489784, -0.05397527292370796, 0.017336837947368622, -0.05807778984308243, -0.004627687856554985, 0.050910741090774536, 0.021995417773723602, -0.03126315027475357, 0.025270016863942146, -0.052393581718206406, 0.02316933125257492, 0.019845305010676384, -0.015891071408987045, 0.02686406672000885, 0.02446681261062622, -0.08150661736726761, -0.003985125105828047, 0.01337024848908186, 0.025727225467562675, 0.026592213660478592, -0.02310754545032978, 0.02316933125257492, -0.010509608313441277, -0.005230090115219355, 0.015643931925296783, -0.07438899576663971, 0.08496657013893127, 0.023194044828414917, 0.003500113496556878, -0.017312124371528625, -0.0368979312479496, -0.036601364612579346, 0.027531344443559647, -0.018362466245889664, -0.007111439947038889, -0.03286955878138542, -0.03049701824784279, 0.02376246638596058, -0.052146442234516144, 0.053233854472637177, -0.01592814177274704, -0.0795789286494255, 0.010219219140708447, 0.00099550886079669, -0.03553866595029831, -0.013382605277001858, -0.003265331033617258, 0.009168876335024834, 0.022699765861034393, -0.03546452149748802, -0.02518351748585701, 0.0018937066197395325, -0.022316699847579002, -0.0011553772492334247, 0.004939701408147812, 0.0003442576271481812, 0.026913493871688843, 0.00016073723963927478, -0.017818760126829147, 0.05407412722706795, 0.009162697941064835, 0.009032949805259705, -0.026097934693098068, 0.014148738235235214, -0.017843473702669144, -0.011862697079777718, -0.04218671843409538, 0.021649422124028206, -0.050465893000364304, -0.04426268860697746, -0.01501372642815113, -0.011547594331204891, -0.010552858002483845, 0.014321736060082912, 0.011059493757784367, -0.0016882718773558736, -0.005517390090972185, 0.02407138980925083, -0.02881646901369095, -0.02408374659717083, 0.03897390514612198, 0.0005487269954755902, -0.055705249309539795, -0.01896795816719532, 0.0038430197164416313, 0.03131257742643356, -0.048464059829711914, -0.016842558979988098, -0.08916794508695602, 0.000725586200132966, 0.016521276906132698, -0.03269656002521515, 0.04053088277578354, 0.022959262132644653, -0.052195869386196136, 0.014124023728072643, -0.02913775108754635, 0.020636150613427162, -0.0013654459035024047, 0.001129118725657463, -0.018102969974279404, 0.02434324286878109, 0.022353770211338997, -0.04058030992746353, 0.024825165048241615, -0.04156886786222458, 0.016484206542372704, -0.06811165064573288, 0.029557887464761734, -0.010058579035103321, 0.02861875668168068, -0.002329290146008134, -0.0019585806876420975, 0.011831805109977722, 0.006641875021159649, 0.0010225398000329733, -0.030002739280462265, -0.017386265099048615, -0.028767041862010956, -0.04581966996192932, 0.02433088608086109, -0.006573911290615797, 0.013444390147924423, -0.013011896051466465, -0.008180318400263786, -0.06045033037662506, -0.009113269858062267, -0.04374369606375694, -0.041395872831344604, -0.019388096407055855, -0.013394962064921856, -0.03707093000411987, 0.0239478200674057, 0.01349381823092699, 0.021476425230503082, 0.017114412039518356, -0.027605485171079636, -0.0479203537106514, 0.04614095017313957, 0.010799997486174107, 0.05867092311382294, 0.013086037710309029, 0.03781234845519066, -0.011380774900317192, -0.025875508785247803, 0.013815099373459816, 0.00993500929325819, 0.015124939382076263, 0.025727225467562675, 0.010367503389716148, -0.018794961273670197, 0.02666635438799858, 0.011393132619559765, -0.02124164253473282, -0.01240022573620081, 0.035958800464868546, 0.0052177333272993565, -0.0063761998899281025, 0.004998397082090378, -0.057188086211681366, -0.04386726766824722, -0.013679172843694687, 0.009403659030795097, -0.03282012790441513, -0.056150101125240326, 0.034599535167217255, 0.06129060313105583, -0.02136521227657795, -0.04374369606375694, 0.011640272103250027, 0.04413912072777748, 0.028173906728625298, 0.043076418340206146, -0.03094186820089817, -0.04221143200993538, -0.03875147923827171, 0.03978946432471275, -0.024689238518476486, 0.03390754386782646, 0.01048489473760128, -0.0015299482038244605, -0.034846674650907516, 0.0414452999830246, -0.010348968207836151, 0.007772538345307112, -0.044682826846838, -0.011918303556740284, 0.024417385458946228, 0.06494826823472977, 0.0011082662967965007, 0.0329931266605854, 0.02370068058371544, 0.024751024320721626, 0.05792950466275215, -0.06845764815807343, -0.06292172521352768, 0.0027417042292654514, 0.018473679199814796, -0.01618763990700245, -0.015075511299073696, -0.000643335108179599, 0.031213723123073578, -0.015087868086993694, 0.00019703585712704808, -0.0028637293726205826, 0.0317080020904541, -0.019178027287125587, -0.05773179233074188, 0.04510296508669853, 0.023997249081730843, 0.02440502867102623, 0.01915331371128559, 0.001926143653690815, 0.037713490426540375, 0.01333317719399929, 0.024120818823575974, -0.009205947630107403, 0.04685765504837036, -0.021661778911948204, 0.05575467646121979, -0.010002972558140755, 0.012208692729473114, 0.059066347777843475, -0.0433729887008667, 0.012319905683398247, -0.012752399779856205, -0.001351544284261763, -0.040036603808403015, 0.014544161036610603, 0.020611437037587166, -0.0012750854948535562, -0.046264518052339554, 0.010213040746748447, -0.023515326902270317, 0.06262515485286713, 0.002885353984311223, 0.024961091578006744, -0.015075511299073696, 0.010633178055286407, 0.043990835547447205, -0.020636150613427162, 0.011016244068741798, -0.003948053810745478, -0.02376246638596058, -0.032795414328575134, -0.032004568725824356, -0.007754002697765827, -0.04885948449373245, 0.03348740562796593, -0.018992673605680466, -0.007581004872918129, -0.031040724366903305, -0.04292813688516617, -0.048464059829711914, 0.0007209523464553058, -0.0007402601186186075, 0.030447589233517647, 0.02337939850986004, -0.008192675188183784, -0.027803197503089905, 0.02790205366909504, 0.02156292460858822, -0.03254827484488487, 0.02148878201842308, -0.053184427320957184, -0.03361097723245621, 0.011671164073050022, 0.01780640333890915, 0.06015376001596451, 0.028841182589530945, -0.005118877626955509, -0.023255828768014908, -0.005986955016851425, 0.036156512796878815, 0.009008236229419708, -0.06272400915622711, 0.0059622409753501415, 0.038800906389951706, 0.026172075420618057, 0.03405582532286644, -0.03247413411736488, 0.07369700819253922, -0.059264060109853745, -0.006907549686729908, 0.02206956036388874, -0.038034774363040924, -0.025554226711392403, 0.02646864391863346, -0.028248047456145287, -0.06633225083351135, 0.005316589027643204, 0.06781508773565292, 0.051751017570495605, 0.0281491931527853, -0.014247593469917774, -0.010694962926208973, -0.022440269589424133, 0.0440402626991272, -0.017275052145123482, -0.028445759788155556, 0.039962463080883026, 0.03143614903092384, -0.008050570264458656, -0.01579221524298191, 0.04717893525958061, -0.02543065696954727, -0.004284781403839588, -0.037837062031030655, 0.029928596690297127, 0.017707547172904015, -0.02064850740134716, -0.02176063507795334, -0.025999078527092934, -0.01349381823092699, 0.005508122034370899, 0.023861320689320564, -0.03714507073163986, -0.03062058798968792, 0.0003809424233622849, -0.03707093000411987, -0.02135285548865795, -0.029780313372612, 0.005332035478204489, 0.04564667120575905, -0.020883290097117424, 0.04937847703695297, -0.019659949466586113, 0.043026991188526154, 0.09435787051916122, 0.0052177333272993565, 0.009422194212675095, 0.02194599062204361, -0.021019216626882553, 0.00837802980095148, -0.0021269444841891527, 0.019956516101956367, -0.0007614986971020699, 0.030768871307373047, 0.027556058019399643, 0.0078034307807683945, 0.004309495445340872, 0.015495648607611656, 0.008588098920881748, 0.015755144879221916, -0.036280084401369095, 0.04752493277192116, -0.023923106491565704, 0.03422882407903671, -0.060944609344005585, 0.011739127337932587, 0.004550456535071135, 0.0013971106382086873, -0.008303888142108917, 0.043026991188526154, -0.008699311874806881, 0.02381189353764057, 0.011788555420935154, -0.03328969329595566, 0.030447589233517647, -0.02480045147240162, -0.0718681737780571, -0.01226429920643568, 0.027753768488764763, -0.026715783402323723, -0.00385228730738163, -0.026369787752628326, -0.008526314049959183, 0.032276421785354614, 0.005356749519705772, 0.017188554629683495, -0.009156519547104836, 0.041395872831344604, 0.030595874413847923, 0.0323752798140049, -0.04977390170097351, 0.011121278628706932, 0.0009870134526863694, -0.06549197435379028, -0.015829287469387054, -0.08832766860723495, 0.02562836930155754, 0.03341326490044594, -0.022502053529024124, 0.000719793897587806, 0.004568992182612419, 0.0042755138128995895, -0.033042553812265396, 0.000556063954718411, 0.04030845686793327, 0.02654278464615345, 0.04376840963959694, -0.030126309022307396, -0.05916520208120346, -0.04876063019037247, -0.00605491828173399, 0.0063761998899281025, -0.009428372606635094, 0.00440217275172472, 0.021958347409963608, 0.0038306626956909895, -0.034278251230716705, 0.04700594022870064, 0.009471622295677662, 0.0369226448237896, 0.020562008023262024, -0.03761463612318039, 0.03573637455701828, -0.03143614903092384, 0.04977390170097351, -0.02958260104060173, 0.05397527292370796, -0.000919050129596144, -0.00019771161896642298, 0.039072759449481964, -0.013988097198307514, -0.014877799898386002, 0.02156292460858822, 0.00926155410706997, 0.02368832379579544, -0.024442099034786224, -0.05397527292370796, -0.03487138822674751, 0.02822333388030529, 0.026369787752628326, 0.034278251230716705, -0.014581232331693172, -0.02886589616537094, 0.013506175018846989, -0.0017052626935765147, 0.03062058798968792, -0.017917616292834282, 0.06247687339782715, 0.0009144162759184837, 0.006450341548770666, -0.04705536738038063, 0.016817845404148102, 0.011621735990047455, 0.033363837748765945, 0.004785239230841398, 0.027852624654769897, -0.018436608836054802, 0.0440155491232872, -0.03398168459534645, 0.020351940765976906, 0.01954873651266098, -0.012344619259238243, 0.011115100234746933, 0.01857253536581993, -0.0011074939975515008, 0.024355599656701088, -0.04492996633052826, -0.03709564357995987, 0.020858576521277428, -0.0062310053035616875, 0.04549838602542877, -0.015075511299073696, -0.0020157317630946636, 0.00031336519168689847, -0.018041186034679413, 0.026394501328468323, -0.006759265903383493, 0.03489610180258751, -0.03541509434580803, -0.002001830143854022, -0.02220548689365387, 0.006981691811233759, -0.04166772589087486, -0.027852624654769897, 0.0022860406897962093, 0.06880364567041397, 0.008680775761604309, 0.059906620532274246, -0.012888326309621334, 0.0002235840365756303, -0.011102743446826935, 0.01884438842535019, 0.05333270877599716, -0.009570478461682796, 0.027432488277554512, -0.03101601079106331, 0.01214072946459055, 0.009409837424755096, -0.021661778911948204, 0.03190571442246437, -0.012826541438698769, 0.03521738201379776, 0.008785810321569443, -0.028643472120165825, -0.035118527710437775, -0.016422422602772713, 0.00414267648011446, 0.046313948929309845, -0.03262241929769516, 0.0478956401348114, 0.0016002284828573465, -0.0020867844577878714, 0.00028923049103468657, -0.02408374659717083, -0.0537281334400177, 0.01103478018194437, 0.025850795209407806, -0.006666588596999645, 0.02103157341480255, 0.017114412039518356, 0.01353088952600956, 0.014581232331693172, 0.011176885105669498, 0.016657203435897827, 0.009545763954520226, 0.020413724705576897, 0.018745534121990204, 0.01851075142621994, 0.001433409284800291, 0.011868875473737717, -0.0042693354189395905, 0.010645534843206406, 0.0018659034976735711, -0.016879629343748093, -0.09816382080316544, -0.01459358911961317, -0.01281418465077877, 0.00702494103461504, -0.012251942418515682, 0.01696612872183323, 0.003914072178304195, -0.0018365556607022882, -0.0349455289542675, -0.010935924015939236, -0.01501372642815113, -0.00264748209156096, -0.04196429252624512, 0.037911202758550644, 0.0030243699438869953, -0.021970704197883606, 0.021056286990642548, 0.012338440865278244, 0.04245857149362564, 0.013567959889769554, -0.006017847452312708, 0.04488053917884827, 0.0022814066614955664, 0.027803197503089905, -0.032597705721855164, -0.0032529740128666162, -0.037194497883319855, -0.0034228824079036713, -0.0003463815082795918, 0.009972079657018185, -0.022502053529024124, 0.007852858863770962, 0.015631575137376785, -0.018807318061590195, -0.020117158070206642, 0.004797596018761396, 0.051503878086805344, -0.010843247175216675, -0.05204758420586586, 0.010528143495321274, -0.0009731118916533887, -0.015693360939621925, 0.03062058798968792, -0.00398203544318676, 0.0067160166800022125, 0.015779858455061913, -0.047154221683740616, -0.01349381823092699, -0.021068645641207695, -0.023317614570260048, -0.006808693986386061, 0.04416383430361748, -0.01657070592045784, -0.02491166442632675, 0.00031046904041431844, -0.006116703152656555, -0.01857253536581993, -0.0375652089715004, -0.0021408461034297943, -0.010818532668054104, -0.0023385577369481325, 0.01265354361385107, -0.014321736060082912, 0.02110571600496769, -0.005684209056198597, -0.0028513723518699408, 0.008291531354188919, 0.0040808916091918945, 0.023935463279485703, 0.056150101125240326, 0.03326497972011566, -0.008538670837879181, 0.010577571578323841, 0.013889241963624954, 0.010138899087905884, -0.04801921173930168, -0.01379038579761982, -0.016459492966532707, 0.05659495294094086, 0.021476425230503082, -0.018621964380145073, -0.05535925552248955, 0.004711097106337547, -0.03934461250901222, 0.025331800803542137, -0.03126315027475357, -0.026073221117258072, -0.017658120021224022, 0.019573450088500977, 0.03222699463367462, -0.011547594331204891, 0.0016836380818858743, 0.020240727812051773, -0.04253271222114563, 0.005696566309779882, -0.028075050562620163, -0.016286494210362434, 0.06064803898334503, 0.007741645909845829, 0.0011152171064168215, -0.002792676677927375, 0.0038399305194616318, -0.02206956036388874, 0.00120634981431067, -0.028767041862010956, -0.009762011468410492, -0.017559263855218887, -0.029854455962777138, 0.04050616919994354, 0.01197391003370285, 0.032078709453344345, -0.03029930591583252, -0.022106630727648735, 0.07013820111751556, 0.004538099747151136, -0.010182148776948452, -0.02730891853570938, 0.007451256737112999, 0.002001830143854022, 0.002452859887853265, 0.02997802570462227, -0.008464529179036617, -0.02148878201842308, -0.015779858455061913, -0.0150507977232337, -0.020796790719032288, 0.0020373566076159477, -0.0015592959243804216, 0.0005155176040716469, 0.01185034029185772, -0.0032344385981559753, -0.05125673860311508, 0.021056286990642548, 0.0022628712467849255, 0.004945879802107811, -0.02842104621231556, 0.03603294491767883, -0.008761096745729446, 0.0029564066790044308, 0.013357891701161861, 0.01857253536581993, -0.006802515592426062, 0.017979400232434273, 0.036082372069358826, 0.04060502350330353, -0.011473452672362328, 0.04008603096008301, 0.032721273601055145, -0.006543018855154514, 0.025850795209407806, 0.029014181345701218, -0.03190571442246437, 0.005517390090972185, 0.010534322820603848, 0.016854915767908096, -0.00592208094894886, -0.04129701480269432, 0.0061723096296191216, 0.013061324134469032, 0.017176197841763496, 0.017559263855218887, 0.0029486834537237883, 0.004494850058108568, -0.0039048045873641968, -0.029286034405231476, 0.040876876562833786, 0.015137296169996262, 0.008303888142108917, -0.016484206542372704, -0.0018705372931435704, 0.0026768299285322428, 0.02336704172194004, -0.04843934625387192, 0.023601824417710304, -0.01362974476069212, 0.002130033913999796, -0.011930660344660282, -0.022427912801504135, -0.004497939255088568, -0.013308463618159294, 0.0022628712467849255, 0.04258213937282562, -0.0407780222594738, 0.03961646556854248, 0.03133729100227356, -0.0111645283177495, 0.010404573753476143, 0.02550479955971241, -0.012066587805747986, 0.026913493871688843, 0.01214072946459055, -0.026048505678772926, 0.011868875473737717, -0.004729632753878832, -0.008773453533649445, -0.037120357155799866, 0.024034319445490837, 0.020364297553896904, -0.024367958307266235, -0.013172537088394165, 0.025677796453237534, -0.023675967007875443, -0.01459358911961317, 0.015693360939621925, 0.015248509123921394, -0.017695190384984016, -0.02478809468448162, 0.0013476827880367637, 0.04218671843409538, 0.008106176741421223, -0.046832941472530365, 0.0021964525803923607, 0.03501966968178749, 0.04085216298699379, 0.015458577312529087, 0.02674049697816372, -0.03380868583917618, 0.009453087113797665, 0.008643705397844315, 0.0168302021920681, -0.006014758255332708, 0.013271392323076725, 0.011047136969864368, -0.019054457545280457, 0.009168876335024834, -0.012190157547593117, 0.008569562807679176, 0.027753768488764763, -0.03314141184091568, 0.046832941472530365, -0.010849425569176674, 0.00838420819491148, 0.0011314356233924627, 0.010713499039411545, 0.06040089949965477, 0.011374596506357193, 0.026616927236318588, -0.0355880931019783, 0.01571807451546192, -0.02693820931017399, -0.01916567049920559, 0.008791988715529442, -0.016459492966532707, -0.015297937206923962, 0.009014414623379707, 0.02698763646185398, -0.02098214626312256, 0.027630198746919632, 0.01168969925493002, 0.018177112564444542, -0.01898031495511532, -0.01826361194252968, -0.015458577312529087, 0.009150341153144836, -0.017324481159448624, 0.02297161892056465, -0.026196790859103203, -0.028248047456145287, 0.01837482489645481, 0.00967551302164793, -0.027111206203699112, -0.010960638523101807, 0.009848509915173054, -0.020549651235342026, 0.003441418055444956, -0.002704633167013526, 0.013036610558629036, -0.014556517824530602, 0.023478254675865173, -0.0036885575391352177, -0.0931716039776802, -0.00482539925724268, 0.008853773586452007, -0.007420364301651716, 0.024689238518476486, 0.05189930275082588, 0.00621555931866169, 0.021253999322652817, 0.005097252782434225, 0.004099426791071892, 0.025603655725717545, -0.0011546049499884248, -0.01982058957219124, 0.01644713617861271, -0.005986955016851425, -0.018621964380145073, -0.019795875996351242, 0.012702971696853638, -0.01004004292190075, 0.01184416189789772, -0.05096017196774483, 0.015236152336001396, 0.003586612408980727, -0.011664985679090023, -0.010311896912753582, -0.009731118567287922, -0.016545992344617844, -0.008618990890681744, 0.026443930342793465, -0.01210983656346798, 0.0035835232120007277, -0.019264526665210724, -0.008859951980412006, 0.01637299358844757, -0.03338855132460594, -0.02258855290710926, 0.000889702292624861, 0.013555603101849556, -0.03393225744366646, -0.0006302057881839573, 0.0060271150432527065, -0.011207778006792068, 0.0018720818916335702, 0.050515320152044296, 0.03373454511165619, -0.0181276835501194, 0.016261780634522438, 0.01556979026645422, -0.02026544138789177, 0.011251026764512062, -0.024973450228571892, 0.0414452999830246, 0.005597710143774748, 0.004046909976750612, 0.013605031184852123, 0.017831116914749146, 0.00024540183949284256, 0.010571393184363842, 0.005328946281224489, 0.010546679608523846, -0.006641875021159649, -0.024232029914855957, -0.01252997387200594, -0.05229472368955612, -0.033882830291986465, -0.012455832213163376, -0.014457662589848042, -0.018807318061590195, -0.025084661319851875, -0.021711207926273346, 0.0246027410030365, 0.050194039940834045, 0.027358345687389374, 0.019178027287125587, -0.009082377888262272, -0.009397480636835098, 0.0009522595210000873, 0.005260982550680637, -0.046511657536029816, 0.025924935936927795, -0.031485576182603836, -0.03341326490044594, -0.006221737712621689, -0.02472631074488163, 0.02239084057509899, 0.02738305926322937, -0.0022675052750855684, -0.023737750947475433, -0.00099550886079669, 0.023280544206500053, 0.009885581210255623, 0.006672767456620932, 0.03840548172593117, 0.0025609834119677544, -0.009372767060995102, 0.016731346026062965, -0.010682606138288975, -0.02854461595416069, 0.00419210409745574, -0.004019106738269329, -0.03153500333428383, -0.023589467629790306, -0.008798167109489441, 0.006573911290615797, 0.04109930247068405, 0.005588442552834749, -0.02337939850986004, -0.033314406871795654, 0.022168416529893875, 0.0008441359386779368, 0.027358345687389374, 0.008946451358497143, -0.037713490426540375, 0.017398623749613762, 0.02582608163356781, 0.010009150952100754, -0.029953310266137123, -0.01433409284800291, 0.02452859841287136, -0.019783519208431244, -0.00008437498036073521, -0.021958347409963608, -0.014383520931005478, -0.002564072608947754, 0.0038955367635935545, 0.016348280012607574, 0.022477339953184128, 0.02829747647047043, -0.014358806423842907, 0.04376840963959694, -0.002031177980825305, 0.0040160175412893295, 0.0336604043841362, 0.01240022573620081, -0.02240319922566414, 0.0014465386047959328, 0.009632263332605362, 0.006629517767578363, 0.018226539716124535, 0.014902513474225998, 0.020796790719032288, -0.022217843681573868, 0.008439814671874046, 0.011671164073050022, 0.00006106084038037807, -0.01320960745215416, 0.028322190046310425, -0.02142699807882309, 0.02713591977953911, 0.0018164755310863256, 0.007945535704493523, -0.02271212264895439, 0.007062011864036322, 0.003044449957087636, 0.015335007570683956, -0.013605031184852123, 0.007698396220803261, -0.018745534121990204, 0.011615557596087456, 0.036996789276599884, 0.022254914045333862, 0.03049701824784279, 0.0021207660902291536, -0.03917161375284195, -0.003447596449404955, 0.02077207714319229, 0.0278279110789299, 0.036280084401369095, -0.012276655994355679, -0.014692445285618305, -0.020426081493496895, -0.057583510875701904, 0.028569329530000687, 0.01353088952600956, -0.03568694740533829, 0.021538209170103073, 0.005718190688639879, 0.016867272555828094, 0.01956109330058098, 0.01171441376209259, 0.014519447460770607, -0.010250112041831017, 0.004568992182612419, 0.010812354274094105, 0.042631570249795914, 0.0056625846773386, 0.006159952841699123, -0.009533407166600227, 0.02109335921704769, 0.004525742493569851, -0.026765210554003716, 0.03969061002135277, -0.011529059149324894, 0.04384255409240723, 0.017497478052973747, 0.03823248669505119, -0.0220201313495636, 0.023589467629790306, -0.0010101827792823315, -0.012462010607123375, 0.03936932608485222, -0.025603655725717545, 0.018140042200684547, -0.014507090672850609, -0.006388556677848101, -0.01618763990700245, 0.013456746935844421, 0.005100341979414225, 0.007951714098453522, -0.01624942384660244, 0.01580457203090191, 0.005946794990450144, 0.029286034405231476, 0.015643931925296783, 0.01459358911961317, -0.015891071408987045, 0.03412996977567673, -0.016731346026062965, -0.028717612847685814, -0.0343029648065567, 0.007772538345307112, -0.03383340314030647, 0.03034873493015766, 0.005708923097699881, -0.02284804917871952, 0.0537281334400177, 0.0034970242995768785, -0.0037379853893071413, 0.009706404991447926, -0.0029564066790044308, 0.01708969846367836, 0.010503429919481277, -0.006351485848426819, -0.04253271222114563, -0.03049701824784279, -0.0010032319696620107, -0.009570478461682796, 0.028643472120165825, -0.0356128066778183, 0.0031402166932821274, 0.01980823278427124, -0.02188420481979847, 0.005520479287952185, -0.011226313188672066, -0.022749193012714386, -0.025850795209407806, 0.017386265099048615, -0.029211891815066338, 0.004121051635593176, -0.026196790859103203, -0.017645763233304024, 0.021204572170972824, -0.03452539071440697, -0.006249540951102972, 0.012437297031283379, 0.008056748658418655, -0.02693820931017399, 0.01527322269976139, 0.010626999661326408, -0.003475399687886238, -0.004093248397111893, -0.011640272103250027, -0.03546452149748802, -0.013432033360004425, -0.007222652900964022, 0.002639759099110961, -0.009712583385407925, 0.023218758404254913, 0.017831116914749146, -0.03746635094285011, -0.005773797165602446, -0.018535465002059937, 0.017052628099918365, 0.011763841845095158, 0.015100224874913692, -0.002448225859552622, -0.016521276906132698, -0.007031119428575039, -0.028470473363995552, 0.007148510776460171, -0.02032722532749176, -0.01255468837916851, 0.0012356976512819529, -0.013024252839386463, -0.02407138980925083, -0.005980776622891426, -0.01902974396944046, -0.015335007570683956, 0.021464068442583084, -0.00796407088637352, -0.0075995405204594135, -0.0035680769942700863, 0.028519902378320694, -0.011837983503937721, 0.04389198124408722, -0.006870478857308626, 0.012128372676670551, 0.009107091464102268, -0.001346138073131442, -0.03074415773153305, -0.015458577312529087, -0.02634507417678833, 0.005208465736359358, -0.009842331521213055, -0.043397702276706696, -0.0016419332241639495, -0.01825125329196453, -0.010126542299985886, -0.03652722388505936, 0.01404988206923008, 0.02066086418926716, -0.012122194282710552, -0.010478716343641281, -0.021513495594263077, -0.003521738341078162, -0.01285125594586134, -0.004939701408147812, 0.024998163804411888, -0.008952629752457142, -0.0013592673931270838, -0.0033147588837891817, -0.02510937675833702, 0.0018643587827682495, -0.0069260853342711926, -0.051751017570495605, 0.003787413239479065, -0.018362466245889664, -0.024355599656701088, 0.025257660076022148, 0.04342241585254669, 0.0242691021412611, 0.04134644195437431, 0.018164755776524544, 0.0009646164835430682, -0.009854688309133053, 0.017917616292834282, 0.00048501131823286414, -0.010318075306713581, 0.0129501111805439, 0.027234775945544243, -0.02077207714319229, -0.009792903438210487, -0.014111666940152645, -0.01799175702035427, 0.018473679199814796, 0.0065059480257332325, 0.0010341245215386152, 0.012789471074938774, -0.007333865389227867, -0.007747824303805828, 0.06302057951688766, -0.02323111519217491, -0.007377115078270435, -0.014914870262145996, 0.03435239568352699, 0.0008271451224572957, -0.03892447426915169, 0.05189930275082588, -0.0078096091747283936, 0.003256063209846616, -0.02970617078244686, 0.02092036046087742, -0.02323111519217491, -0.010015329346060753, 0.018140042200684547, 0.0011275741271674633, -0.020945075899362564, 0.05703980475664139, 0.0017516014631837606, 0.009088556282222271, 0.006388556677848101, 0.008606634102761745, -0.0006649597780779004, 0.01930159702897072, -0.00981143955141306, -0.016558349132537842, 0.002801944501698017, 0.010830889455974102, -0.028470473363995552, 0.003342562122270465, -0.03353683277964592, -0.01910388469696045, 0.0015253142919391394, 0.007488327566534281, -0.01922745443880558, -0.024689238518476486, 0.008878487162292004, 0.024454455822706223, 0.03054644539952278, -0.004782150033861399, 0.049749188125133514, -0.004151944071054459, 0.0008364128298126161, 0.020216014236211777, -0.00131061184220016, 0.02052493765950203, -0.010546679608523846, 0.031164294108748436, 0.016484206542372704, 0.0030351823661476374, -0.019635235890746117, -0.018992673605680466, 0.009335695765912533, -0.01993180252611637, 0.0026243128813803196, -0.004256978165358305, 0.05911577492952347, 0.036601364612579346, -0.005854117684066296, -0.022415556013584137, -0.005177573300898075, -0.06163659691810608, -0.07972721010446548, 0.0440402626991272, 0.026196790859103203, -0.009181233122944832, -0.006944620981812477, -0.009156519547104836, 0.004720365162938833, -0.0016002284828573465, -0.012635008431971073, -0.017386265099048615, -0.020500224083662033, 0.03976475074887276, -0.012888326309621334, -0.01421052310615778, -0.001199399004690349, 0.02666635438799858, 0.015816930681467056, -0.031485576182603836, 0.003059896407648921, 0.002533180173486471, -0.04072859510779381, 0.0355880931019783, -0.011770020239055157, -0.008656062185764313, 0.0016635579522699118, -0.02602379210293293, -0.027358345687389374, 0.03590937331318855, 0.021192215383052826, 0.0009576656739227474, -0.0016573794418945909, 0.04060502350330353, 0.02686406672000885, -0.013432033360004425, -0.024837521836161613, 0.02116749994456768, 0.013469104655086994, -0.0009020592551678419, -0.020636150613427162, 0.028915325179696083, 0.011232491582632065, 0.002222711220383644, 0.025924935936927795, -0.021402282640337944, 0.017707547172904015, -0.03993774950504303, 0.0184489656239748, 0.0356128066778183, 0.01734919473528862, 0.03274598717689514, 0.023713037371635437, -0.0022566928528249264, -0.016101140528917313, 0.041717153042554855, 0.0055729965679347515, -0.015878714621067047, -0.027654914185404778, -0.004593706224113703, 0.03370983153581619, -0.004772881977260113, 0.019536379724740982, -0.00710526155307889, -0.022897478193044662, -0.030595874413847923, -0.01210365816950798, -0.005257893353700638, -0.002219621790573001, 0.015594503842294216, -0.022032488137483597, 0.014259951189160347, -0.017769332975149155, -0.001504461863078177, 0.01517436746507883, -0.012122194282710552, 0.00220108637586236, -0.022885119542479515, 0.025529513135552406, -0.002165560144931078, -0.014494732953608036, 0.004266246221959591, -0.020240727812051773, -0.038281913846731186, 0.011695878580212593, -0.015495648607611656, -0.013876884244382381, -0.009737297892570496, 0.04156886786222458, 0.003892447566613555, -0.007568648084998131, 0.03462424874305725, -0.0071299755945801735, 0.001750056748278439, 0.022934548556804657, 0.0090638417750597, -0.044831112027168274, -0.013642101548612118, -0.008520135655999184, 0.003710182150825858, 0.02614736184477806, 0.02997802570462227, -0.0187826044857502, -0.01433409284800291, 0.03190571442246437, -0.0013013441348448396, -0.01353088952600956, 0.000039484402805101126, -0.045275960117578506, 0.008859951980412006, -0.010089471004903316, -0.018597248941659927, 0.015470934100449085, -0.030670015141367912, -0.06544254720211029, -0.015742788091301918, -0.0043403878808021545, -0.02323111519217491, -0.024615097790956497, 0.020636150613427162, -0.0009159608744084835, -0.03529152646660805, -0.0058263144455850124, 0.002686097752302885, -0.0062371836975216866, -0.013901598751544952, 0.008581920526921749, 0.0046245986595749855, 0.04480639845132828, 0.010515786707401276, -0.0029486834537237883, -0.026567500084638596, 0.02194599062204361, -0.005063271149992943, 0.03215285390615463, 0.014519447460770607, -0.0021454801317304373, -0.02758077159523964, -0.002599598839879036, 0.012826541438698769, -0.026839353144168854, -0.02012951485812664, 0.0058324928395450115, -0.01857253536581993, -0.007846680469810963, 0.022378483787178993, -0.003120136447250843, 0.026122648268938065, -0.0012179345358163118, -0.008069105446338654, 0.0013453657738864422, -0.029928596690297127, 0.0005429346347227693, -0.004102515988051891, 0.012740042991936207, -0.001000915071927011, -0.03042287565767765, 0.025751939043402672, -0.011868875473737717, 0.009879402816295624, 0.017336837947368622, -0.02240319922566414, -0.01433409284800291, -0.017176197841763496, -0.015063154511153698, -0.006357664242386818, 0.018214182928204536, -0.01786818727850914, 0.03034873493015766, 0.021204572170972824, -0.02829747647047043, -0.028075050562620163, -0.02187184803187847, -0.014692445285618305, 0.02064850740134716, 0.016916701570153236, -0.017460407689213753, -0.019721735268831253, -0.03662607818841934, 0.010429288260638714, 0.013827457092702389, -0.0394928976893425, 0.0020172763615846634, 0.01962287910282612, 0.001058838446624577, 0.015940500423312187, 0.01928924024105072, -0.026246218010783195, -0.009440730325877666, -0.0026845531538128853, -0.0059715090319514275, 0.02582608163356781, -0.004556634929031134, 0.0015585236251354218, -0.004368191119283438, -0.04112401604652405, 0.01612585410475731, -0.011102743446826935, -0.0053474814631044865, -0.0005776886246167123, 0.012937754392623901, 0.02634507417678833, 0.03306726738810539, 0.026691069826483727, 0.033561546355485916, 0.03598351404070854, -0.03845490887761116, 0.01459358911961317, -0.0025069215334951878, 0.0029363264329731464, -0.016731346026062965, -0.042878709733486176, -0.012740042991936207, -0.009471622295677662, 0.00980526115745306, 0.025875508785247803, 0.018856745213270187, -0.008439814671874046, 0.011955374851822853, 0.031362004578113556, 0.00825446005910635, -0.01909152790904045, 0.008408922702074051, -0.002354003954678774, -0.04324941709637642, -0.021278712898492813, -0.016199996694922447, 0.0036731113214045763, -0.006950799375772476, 0.01553271897137165, 0.02220548689365387, 0.009187412448227406, 0.008452171459794044, -0.017831116914749146, 0.007871394045650959, -0.035439807921648026, -0.019054457545280457, -0.04747550189495087, 0.00009904889157041907, -0.021797707304358482, 0.001878260402008891, -0.011078028939664364, 0.0020172763615846634, -0.00042284029768779874, 0.016026997938752174, 0.003586612408980727, -0.012925397604703903, -0.019116243347525597, 0.02342882752418518, 0.00013708521146327257, 0.006039472296833992, 0.012888326309621334, -0.02693820931017399, 0.02330525778234005, 0.010404573753476143, -0.006938442122191191, -0.0021207660902291536, 0.07982606440782547, 0.00196475931443274, 0.016941415145993233, -0.01459358911961317, 0.00495205819606781, -0.007550112437456846, 0.0030938780400902033, 0.03319083899259567, -0.016410063952207565, 0.0012140729231759906, -0.00012105975474696606, 0.011436381377279758, -0.005983865819871426, 0.009137984365224838, -0.02370068058371544, -0.007778716739267111, 0.03338855132460594, 0.01728741079568863, 0.011349882930517197, -0.01375331450253725, 0.012801827862858772, -0.008396565914154053, -0.03341326490044594, 0.019190384075045586, 0.0031185918487608433, 0.019276883453130722, -0.004856291692703962, -0.02376246638596058, 0.0011337526375427842, 0.012190157547593117, -0.005140502005815506, -0.012567045167088509, -0.018164755776524544, -0.00621247012168169, -0.02570251189172268, -0.05585353448987007, -0.01988237537443638, 0.007747824303805828, 0.03514324128627777, 0.037762921303510666, -0.016990842297673225, 0.011189241893589497, -0.0003342175914440304, 0.011955374851822853, 0.011028601787984371, -0.03412996977567673, 0.040876876562833786, -0.00435274513438344, 0.02480045147240162, 0.03897390514612198, -0.01644713617861271, 0.0070496550761163235, -0.0034723104909062386, 0.017015555873513222, 0.010015329346060753, -0.005378373898565769, 0.027803197503089905, -0.01611349731683731, -0.052541863173246384, 0.03578580543398857, -0.02012951485812664, 0.017386265099048615, 0.002914701821282506, 0.012221049517393112, 0.010806175880134106, -0.002732436405494809, -0.03590937331318855, 0.020537294447422028, -0.00841510109603405, -0.027086492627859116, 0.014247593469917774, -0.01285125594586134 ]
11.943369
7.396467
2024-07-01
1
2024MNRAS.531.3858R
[ "galaxies", "cosmic environments", "different cosmic environments", "Metallicity", "metallicity", "the galaxy gas fraction decrease", "MZR", "Type Ia Supernova events", "denser large-scale environments", "filaments" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
66
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1384", "10.48550/arXiv.2404.10055" ]
[ "Rowntree, Aaron R.", "Singh, Ankit", "Vincenzo, Fiorenzo", "Gibson, Brad K.", "Gouin, Céline", "Galárraga-Espinosa, Daniela", "Lee, Jaehyun", "Kim, Juhan", "Laigle, Clotilde", "Park, Changbom", "Pichon, Christophe", "Few, Gareth", "Hong, Sungwook E.", "Kim, Yonghwi" ]
[ "E. A. Milne Centre for Astrophysics, University of Hull, Hull HU6 7RX, UK", "Korea Institute for Advanced Study (KIAS), 85 Hoegiro, Dongdaemun-gu, Seoul 02455, Republic of Korea", "E. A. Milne Centre for Astrophysics, University of Hull, Hull HU6 7RX, UK", "Woodmansey Primary School, Hull Road, Woodmansey HU17 0TH, UK", "Université Paris-Saclay, CNRS, Institut d'Astrophysique Spatiale, F-91405 Orsay, France", "Max-Planck-Institut für Astrophysik, Karl-Schwarzschild-Str. 1, D-85748 Garching, Germany", "Korea Astronomy and Space Science Institute, 776 Daedeok-daero, Yuseong-gu, Daejeon 34055, Republic of Korea", "Korea Institute for Advanced Study (KIAS), 85 Hoegiro, Dongdaemun-gu, Seoul 02455, Republic of Korea", "Institut d'Astrophysique de Paris, UMR 7095, CNRS, and Sorbonne Université, 98 bis Boulevard Arago, F-75014 Paris, France", "Korea Institute for Advanced Study (KIAS), 85 Hoegiro, Dongdaemun-gu, Seoul 02455, Republic of Korea", "Korea Institute for Advanced Study (KIAS), 85 Hoegiro, Dongdaemun-gu, Seoul 02455, Republic of Korea; Institut d'Astrophysique de Paris, UMR 7095, CNRS, and Sorbonne Université, 98 bis Boulevard Arago, F-75014 Paris, France; Korea Astronomy and Space Science Institute, 776 Daedeok-daero, Yuseong-gu, Daejeon 34055, Republic of Korea", "E. A. Milne Centre for Astrophysics, University of Hull, Hull HU6 7RX, UK", "Astronomy Campus, University of Science and Technology, 776 Daedeok-daero, Yuseong-gu, Daejeon 34055, Republic of Korea; Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information, 245 Daehak-ro, Yuseong-gu, Daejeon 34141, Korea", "IPhT, DRF-INP, UMR 3680, CEA, L'Orme des Merisiers, Bât 774, F-91191 Gif-sur-Yvette, France" ]
[ "2024arXiv240706254G" ]
[ "1970Ap......6..164Z", "1972ARA&A..10..375D", "1972ApJ...176....1G", "1972ApJ...178..623T", "1978ApJ...222..784G", "1979A&A....80..155L", "1980lssu.book.....P", "1982ApJ...252..455S", "1984ApJ...284L...9K", "1986A&A...154..279M", "1986ApJ...302L...1D", "1986ApJ...304...15B", "1987ApJ...314..493K", "1989RvMP...61..185S", "1989Sci...246..897G", "1991ApJ...371...82S", "1992MNRAS.258..321H", "1993ApJS...88..253S", "1996ApJ...461...20H", "1996ApJ...462..147S", "1996Natur.380..603B", "2002A&A...385..337T", "2002A&A...396..449G", "2004ApJ...613..898T", "2005ApJ...621..673T", "2005ApJ...635..260S", "2005MNRAS.363....2K", "2006A&A...445....1R", "2006ApJ...639..600K", "2006ApJ...639..858M", "2007MNRAS.382..801M", "2008A&A...477...79D", "2008A&A...488..463M", "2008MNRAS.388.1152P", "2008MNRAS.391..481S", "2009ARA&A..47..481A", "2009MNRAS.396.1257E", "2009Natur.457..451D", "2010ApJ...721..193P", "2010MNRAS.408.2115M", "2011AstBu..66..255P", "2011MNRAS.412..145H", "2011MNRAS.414..350S", "2012A&A...544A..68L", "2012A&A...547A..79F", "2012ApJ...749..133P", "2012ApJ...754...26J", "2012MNRAS.420.2662D", "2012MNRAS.421..262C", "2012MNRAS.422..215Y", "2012MNRAS.424L..11F", "2013A&A...554A..58S", "2013ApJ...771L..19Z", "2013MNRAS.429.1286C", "2013MNRAS.430.2680M", "2013MNRAS.432.1217P", "2014ApJ...792...95C", "2014MNRAS.438..262P", "2014MNRAS.441.2923C", "2015ApJ...798L..15K", "2015ApJ...811...28T", "2015ApJ...812..158M", "2015ApJ...814...84D", "2015ApJ...815L..17M", "2015MNRAS.452.3369C", "2016A&A...594A..13P", "2016MNRAS.455..127M", "2016MNRAS.457.2287A", "2016MNRAS.463.3948D", "2016SPIE.9904E..0OR", "2016arXiv161100036D", "2017A&A...600L...6K", "2017MNRAS.466.1880C", "2017MNRAS.468.1881W", "2018MNRAS.473.1195L", "2018MNRAS.474..547K", "2018MNRAS.474.5437L", "2018MNRAS.476.4877M", "2018MNRAS.477L..35G", "2018MNRAS.478.4336M", "2019A&A...632A..49S", "2019ApJ...883...29W", "2019ComAC...6....2N", "2019MNRAS.483.4354S", "2019MNRAS.484.5587T", "2019MNRAS.485..464L", "2019MNRAS.489.5582S", "2020A&A...637A..18B", "2020A&A...641A.173G", "2020MNRAS.497.2265S", "2020MNRAS.498.3215D", "2021A&A...645A..85M", "2021A&A...649A.117G", "2021A&A...651A..56G", "2021ApJ...908...11L", "2021MNRAS.501.4635S", "2021MNRAS.502.4457G", "2021MNRAS.504.4817V", "2021arXiv210609035B", "2022A&A...661A.115G", "2022A&A...662A.112E", "2022ApJ...933...39C", "2022ApJ...940....2J", "2022ApJS..259...43C", "2022MNRAS.512.2867H", "2022MNRAS.515.4065I", "2022MNRAS.516...26Z", "2022NatAs...6..599D", "2022arXiv220614908G", "2023A&A...671A.160G", "2023A&A...680A.111D", "2023ApJ...950..114H", "2023ApJ...951...66W", "2023ApJ...951..137K", "2023ApJ...952...59S", "2023MNRAS.520.4517A", "2023MNRAS.525.4079Z", "2024A&A...684A..63G", "2024AJ....168...58D", "2024ApJ...965..145Y", "2024MNRAS.52711043Y", "2024MNRAS.529.2595B", "2024MNRAS.530..699S", "2024arXiv240211678W" ]
29184179
2403.19635
Radio properties of green pea galaxies
<BR /> Aims: Green peas (GPs) are young, compact, star-forming dwarf galaxies, and local (z ∼ 0.3) analogues of the early galaxies (z ≥ 6) considered to be mainly responsible for the reionisation of the Universe. Recent X-ray observations of GPs led to the detection of high excess emission, which cannot be accounted for by star formation alone and implies the presence of an active galactic nucleus (AGN). We employ radio observations to study the radio properties of GPs, build their radio spectral energy distributions, and verify the presence of AGNs. <BR /> Methods: We performed new radio observations of three GPs with the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (JVLA) in the L, C, and X bands (1.4, 6 and 10 GHz resp.), and analysed them alongside data from archival observations and large radio surveys. We also analysed the archival radio data for a larger sample of GPs and blueberry (BBs) galaxies, which are lower-mass and lower-redshift analogues of the GPs. To understand the significance of the radio observations, we assess the detectability of these sources, and compare the detected radio luminosities with expectations from theoretical and empirical relations. <BR /> Results: Two of the three targeted GPs are strongly detected (&gt; 10σ) in the JVLA observations and their fluxes are consistent with star formation, while the third source is undetected. Although archival radio surveys have the sensitivity to detect a large fraction (∼75%) of the sources from the larger archival sample of GPs and BBs, we only detect a small number (&lt; 40%) of them and their radio luminosity is significantly lower than the expectation from empirical relations. <BR /> Conclusions: Our results show that the majority of the dwarf galaxies in our sample are highly underluminous. The radio luminosity-star formation rate (SFR) relation deviates from the empirical relations, especially towards the lower end of galaxy mass and SFR, suggesting that the relations established for larger galaxies may not hold towards the low-mass end.
[ -0.012078105472028255, 0.030174409970641136, 0.02936403825879097, -0.036395199596881866, -0.02353651635348797, 0.02490699663758278, -0.03258168697357178, -0.00037278563831932843, 0.024311136454343796, 0.0016609630547463894, -0.015265963040292263, 0.002743940567597747, -0.037801433354616165, -0.01104130782186985, 0.025717368349432945, -0.02177276648581028, -0.035012803971767426, -0.02180851809680462, 0.009635074995458126, 0.04035171866416931, 0.007996456697583199, 0.014455592259764671, -0.01401465479284525, -0.010302439332008362, -0.04361703619360924, -0.05262645706534386, -0.017923504114151, 0.06568773835897446, 0.047096867114305496, -0.023596102371811867, 0.025455189868807793, -0.01088042464107275, -0.05710733309388161, -0.006631935015320778, -0.06969191879034042, 0.04345019534230232, 0.01537321787327528, -0.024060873314738274, -0.02415621094405651, -0.012161526829004288, 0.01401465479284525, 0.01791158691048622, -0.05052902549505234, -0.04325952008366585, 0.00999259203672409, 0.0011038328520953655, 0.0035990015603601933, -0.025645865127444267, -0.03522731363773346, -0.0442844033241272, -0.04847926273941994, 0.04323568567633629, 0.004331910517066717, -0.010761252604424953, -0.043521698564291, 0.010844673030078411, -0.02383444644510746, 0.008359932340681553, -0.033368226140737534, -0.0023298172745853662, -0.01502761896699667, 0.0010889362310990691, 0.06726080924272537, 0.016457686200737953, -0.009754247032105923, -0.01829293742775917, 0.007358885370194912, 0.008943876251578331, 0.036395199596881866, 0.0034887671936303377, -0.010570577345788479, -0.0038522423710674047, -0.012596504762768745, -0.04349786415696144, 0.02793397195637226, 0.025765037164092064, 0.02457331493496895, -0.01866237260401249, -0.03808744624257088, -0.009885337203741074, 0.030460422858595848, -0.004287221003323793, -0.027886303141713142, -0.04178178682923317, 0.02043803781270981, -0.004266365896910429, 0.014682019129395485, -0.005815605167299509, -0.051244061440229416, 0.02179660089313984, 0.04809791222214699, -0.016362348571419716, -0.005076737143099308, 0.024406474083662033, -0.0019201625837013125, 0.0022478862665593624, 0.03908849135041237, -0.016171671450138092, 0.09800724685192108, 0.021546339616179466, 0.02490699663758278, 0.02657540887594223, -0.012703760527074337, -0.081656813621521, 0.035012803971767426, 0.008407601155340672, 0.0221422016620636, 0.01761365681886673, 0.0352034792304039, -0.038182783871889114, 0.010105805471539497, 0.00569345336407423, 0.012358160689473152, 0.045452289283275604, -0.058585070073604584, -0.011655044741928577, -0.09204863011837006, -0.00767469173297286, -0.001359308254905045, 0.008914083242416382, 0.025788871571421623, 0.05281713232398033, 0.022201787680387497, -0.004933730233460665, 0.031008614227175713, 0.004680489655584097, 0.053722843527793884, -0.0280293095856905, -0.015277880243957043, -0.0076687331311404705, 0.06621209532022476, -0.02485932782292366, -0.011142604053020477, -0.008050084114074707, -0.04943264275789261, 0.01449134387075901, 0.006003301125019789, -0.03863563761115074, -0.027171269059181213, 0.03208116441965103, 0.030174409970641136, 0.008705531246960163, 0.027862468734383583, 0.016386182978749275, 0.029888395220041275, 0.009789998643100262, -0.061016183346509933, 0.014241081662476063, 0.008550607599318027, 0.03389258310198784, 0.0038671388756483793, 0.020247362554073334, -0.04447507858276367, -0.05586794391274452, -0.03224800527095795, -0.04004187136888504, 0.024763990193605423, 0.022523552179336548, -0.011273693293333054, -0.018138013780117035, -0.036848053336143494, 0.01090425904840231, -0.00897962786257267, 0.004942668601870537, -0.012620339170098305, 0.03172364830970764, -0.007400595583021641, -0.031938157975673676, -0.0824195146560669, -0.0010621225228533149, 0.008788952603936195, -0.0006997644668444991, -0.014622433111071587, 0.01501570176333189, -0.014682019129395485, 0.007746194954961538, -0.016791367903351784, -0.017756663262844086, -0.00526145426556468, 0.0012900393921881914, -0.0025041066110134125, 0.030484257265925407, 0.03601384907960892, -0.04104291647672653, 0.02695675939321518, 0.0373724140226841, -0.025788871571421623, -0.011494161561131477, -0.009742329828441143, -0.03038891963660717, 0.03320138528943062, 0.013835896737873554, 0.01105322502553463, 0.08852113783359528, -0.01245349831879139, -0.017804332077503204, 0.005365729797631502, 0.03246251493692398, -0.019115226343274117, 0.025383684784173965, 0.04218697175383568, 0.027481116354465485, 0.011655044741928577, -0.07426813244819641, -0.04278283193707466, -0.06473435461521149, 0.06687945872545242, -0.006608100142329931, -0.00898558646440506, -0.005657701753079891, 0.0491466298699379, 0.0036287945695221424, -0.020950479432940483, -0.013883565552532673, -0.015051453374326229, -0.013132779859006405, -0.034988969564437866, 0.03751542046666145, 0.029888395220041275, 0.00846718717366457, -0.005946694407612085, 0.01936548762023449, 0.040923744440078735, 0.016064416617155075, 0.04235381260514259, -0.021975358948111534, 0.030293582007288933, -0.0634949654340744, 0.0339164175093174, 0.006870279088616371, 0.019758757203817368, 0.002358120633289218, -0.008520814590156078, -0.02793397195637226, -0.013859731145203114, 0.0020780658815056086, 0.050910379737615585, 0.0441652312874794, -0.014634350314736366, -0.015814155340194702, 0.0021555277053266764, 0.03215266764163971, -0.01832868903875351, 0.015754569321870804, 0.0064233834855258465, 0.011827844195067883, -0.011774216778576374, -0.026432400569319725, 0.05696432664990425, 0.013895482756197453, 0.01794733852148056, 0.00013406875950749964, -0.026337062940001488, 0.003381512127816677, -0.022368628531694412, 0.020545292645692825, -0.051959093660116196, 0.01789966970682144, -0.045380786061286926, 0.004454062320291996, -0.029173363000154495, -0.027743296697735786, 0.003295112168416381, 0.009795957244932652, -0.019210563972592354, 0.05520057678222656, 0.014217247255146503, -0.018435943871736526, -0.008294387720525265, 0.017697077244520187, -0.029459375888109207, -0.032915372401475906, 0.06406699120998383, -0.050243012607097626, -0.047120701521635056, 0.052292775362730026, -0.003034423105418682, 0.013097028248012066, 0.013001690618693829, -0.03258168697357178, 0.009033255279064178, 0.027075931429862976, 0.06211256980895996, 0.03000756911933422, -0.01538513507694006, -0.00594371510669589, -0.0002830340526998043, 0.013788226991891861, -0.008836621418595314, 0.018567033112049103, 0.06044415757060051, -0.025383684784173965, 0.02800547517836094, -0.0026903131511062384, -0.024740155786275864, -0.02413237653672695, 0.061969559639692307, -0.009045172482728958, -0.04704919829964638, 0.009092841297388077, 0.06001513823866844, 0.028935018926858902, -0.015420886687934399, -0.012250905856490135, -0.02559819631278515, 0.020092438906431198, 0.04280666634440422, 0.03005523793399334, -0.0380159430205822, 0.05086271092295647, 0.023298172280192375, 0.010975762270390987, 0.0032831949647516012, 0.0035304774064570665, -0.03179515153169632, -0.04383154585957527, -0.03038891963660717, 0.03286770358681679, 0.023405427113175392, 0.001800990430638194, -0.05772703140974045, -0.022213704884052277, -0.02657540887594223, -0.013514131307601929, -0.025383684784173965, -0.06611675769090652, -0.007609147112816572, -0.032295674085617065, -0.005896046292036772, 0.006691521033644676, 0.03241484612226486, 0.007126499433070421, 0.02388211525976658, 0.060968514531850815, -0.031556807458400726, -0.06120685860514641, -0.0024638858158141375, 0.0477403961122036, -0.04173411428928375, -0.02693292498588562, -0.006125452928245068, 0.008199050091207027, 0.007615105714648962, -0.0029539817478507757, -0.013633303344249725, 0.03622835874557495, 0.05968145281076431, 0.03944600746035576, 0.024763990193605423, 0.0021659552585333586, 0.03389258310198784, 0.0029078025836497545, 0.016850953921675682, -0.02726660668849945, 0.048503097146749496, -0.053770512342453, 0.05224510654807091, -0.015075287781655788, 0.011172397062182426, 0.03665737807750702, -0.03463144972920418, -0.01725613884627819, -0.00030016506207175553, -0.002584547735750675, -0.008419518359005451, 0.017792414873838425, 0.004608985967934132, 0.01140478253364563, -0.012751429341733456, -0.026670746505260468, 0.013704806566238403, 0.026337062940001488, 0.010415652766823769, -0.002448989311233163, -0.05500990152359009, -0.02353651635348797, 0.033678073436021805, -0.019568080082535744, -0.03703872859477997, 0.02178468368947506, 0.0028869472444057465, -0.01534938346594572, -0.0035572911147028208, -0.054008856415748596, -0.003896932117640972, -0.014181495644152164, -0.018590867519378662, -0.04735904559493065, -0.08580400794744492, 0.024370722472667694, -0.026027215644717216, -0.0008237780421040952, 0.030817938968539238, -0.03408325836062431, -0.008896207436919212, -0.021260326728224754, 0.02903035655617714, 0.04452274739742279, 0.02416812814772129, 0.04948031157255173, -0.01789966970682144, -0.027504950761795044, -0.057488683611154556, -0.05291246995329857, -0.015087204985320568, -0.02662307769060135, -0.02631322853267193, 0.060587164014577866, 0.03761075809597969, -0.04845542833209038, 0.03034125082194805, 0.01583798974752426, 0.020473789423704147, -0.013406876474618912, 0.029864560812711716, 0.019436990842223167, -0.01534938346594572, 0.03000756911933422, -0.04306884482502937, 0.02590804360806942, 0.021319912746548653, -0.020557209849357605, 0.01762557402253151, 0.017840083688497543, -0.0330345444381237, 0.028935018926858902, 0.013633303344249725, -0.010826797224581242, -0.005514695309102535, -0.0601581446826458, -0.038182783871889114, 0.01930590160191059, -0.01625509187579155, -0.042639825493097305, 0.009366937913000584, 0.030484257265925407, 0.03215266764163971, -0.01295402180403471, -0.00008188436186173931, -0.010969803668558598, 0.022225622087717056, -0.008407601155340672, -0.009724454022943974, -0.02109348587691784, 0.019246315583586693, -0.01102343201637268, 0.02102198265492916, 0.027147434651851654, 0.05791770666837692, -0.07770029455423355, -0.0042842417024075985, 0.005830501671880484, 0.01903180591762066, -0.00516909547150135, -0.03258168697357178, -0.008365890942513943, 0.030317416414618492, -0.0019201625837013125, -0.00371817359700799, -0.05667831376194954, 0.01629084348678589, 0.0025115548633038998, -0.03138996660709381, 0.018578950315713882, 0.008818745613098145, 0.006196956150233746, -0.007889201864600182, 0.03179515153169632, 0.012882518582046032, 0.023226669058203697, 0.026480069383978844, -0.04457041621208191, -0.017136966809630394, -0.019460825249552727, -0.035084307193756104, 0.04171027988195419, -0.024787824600934982, -0.018233351409435272, 0.06463901698589325, 0.030913276597857475, 0.031914323568344116, 0.012632256373763084, 0.026027215644717216, -0.003676463384181261, 0.029221031814813614, 0.028482163324952126, 0.019246315583586693, 0.04671551659703255, -0.011535871773958206, -0.015468555502593517, -0.03308221325278282, -0.029197197407484055, -0.004513648338615894, -0.01088042464107275, 0.013001690618693829, -0.007579354103654623, -0.05357983708381653, -0.0077402363531291485, 0.00950398575514555, 0.0552959181368351, 0.04490409791469574, -0.015730734914541245, 0.016147837042808533, 0.05486689507961273, 0.012656090781092644, 0.03837345913052559, -0.04971865564584732, -0.002145100152119994, 0.010588453151285648, 0.0017726869555190206, 0.00741847138851881, 0.022309042513370514, 0.0031699812971055508, -0.0339164175093174, 0.00384330446831882, 0.017136966809630394, -0.027004428207874298, 0.026694580912590027, 0.0067511070519685745, 0.010070053860545158, 0.05391351878643036, -0.010147515684366226, 0.01086254883557558, 0.032963041216135025, -0.001083722454495728, 0.004129318054765463, 0.0025756098330020905, -0.09972332417964935, -0.053341493010520935, -0.04909896105527878, -0.009545695967972279, -0.027814799919724464, -0.00545510882511735, -0.026861421763896942, -0.0456906333565712, -0.019210563972592354, -0.02215411886572838, 0.0007038610056042671, -0.028053143993020058, -0.018412109464406967, 0.014217247255146503, 0.00948015134781599, -0.051577743142843246, -0.0018278041388839483, 0.02628939412534237, 0.02998373471200466, -0.015969078987836838, -0.016767533496022224, -0.004162090364843607, 0.05071970075368881, 0.0732194185256958, -0.03587084263563156, 0.03074643574655056, -0.007132458034902811, -0.01594524458050728, 0.01828102022409439, -0.026694580912590027, 0.014920363202691078, 0.01552814245223999, -0.016016747802495956, 0.000041454248275840655, 0.0006342197302728891, 0.004421290010213852, 0.032700859010219574, -0.017351476475596428, -0.05744101479649544, 0.02793397195637226, -0.0231670830398798, -0.05262645706534386, 0.014717770740389824, -0.025455189868807793, -0.004859247710555792, 0.019270149990916252, -0.017756663262844086, 0.013216200284659863, 0.004847330506891012, -0.05286480113863945, 0.022177953273057938, -0.002164465608075261, -0.024060873314738274, -0.020867057144641876, 0.0003212064038962126, 0.010201143100857735, 0.02445414289832115, -0.04626266285777092, -0.030317416414618492, -0.03620452433824539, -0.006113535724580288, 0.03386874869465828, 0.00020538589160423726, -0.016100168228149414, -0.03830195590853691, 0.0036585875786840916, 0.005928818602114916, -0.02762412279844284, -0.020295031368732452, 0.01932973600924015, 0.0005697922315448523, -0.03589467704296112, 0.006834527477622032, 0.02347693033516407, 0.01755407080054283, -0.03753925487399101, -0.011601417325437069, 0.0019529350101947784, 0.007394636981189251, -0.011482244357466698, -0.032915372401475906, -0.024037038907408714, -0.01502761896699667, 0.009784040041267872, 0.0024817618541419506, -0.014074240811169147, -0.02388211525976658, -0.024430308490991592, -0.006572348531335592, 0.027433447539806366, -0.023619936779141426, 0.00022251690097618848, -0.022606972604990005, -0.01192318182438612, 0.019055640324950218, 0.00037799941492266953, 0.002784161362797022, 0.011821885593235493, 0.0000482740651932545, 0.0002493306528776884, -0.012084064073860645, 0.01502761896699667, -0.007793864235281944, 0.00949802715331316, -0.060253482311964035, 0.0367288812994957, 0.02662307769060135, 0.0020318864844739437, -0.017756663262844086, -0.012095981277525425, -0.01139882393181324, -0.015814155340194702, 0.0005910198087804019, 0.033010710030794144, 0.011261776089668274, 0.03634753078222275, -0.06468668580055237, 0.007662774529308081, -0.012465415522456169, -0.026670746505260468, 0.010415652766823769, 0.01085659023374319, -0.023274337872862816, -0.005118447355926037, 0.0015596665907651186, 0.025383684784173965, 0.03386874869465828, 0.009569530375301838, -0.004769868683069944, 0.006286335177719593, 0.013645220547914505, -0.023572267964482307, 0.06258925795555115, -0.031151622533798218, -0.010463322512805462, 0.03422626480460167, -0.0044004349038004875, 0.026122553274035454, -0.0010762742022052407, -0.00690603069961071, 0.018138013780117035, -0.015957161784172058, 0.0353226512670517, 0.0704069584608078, -0.0399465337395668, 0.023405427113175392, -0.01968725211918354, 0.0009228399721905589, -0.0026813752483576536, 0.011607375927269459, -0.022726144641637802, 0.0030210160184651613, 0.010153474286198616, -0.0028258715756237507, -0.010999596677720547, -0.029197197407484055, 0.027028262615203857, -0.027409613132476807, -0.014622433111071587, -0.0009489089134149253, 0.015325549058616161, 0.0062327077612280846, -0.006173121742904186, -0.005407440010458231, 0.03694339096546173, 0.017375310882925987, 0.035394154489040375, 0.014038489200174809, -0.027576453983783722, -0.015683066099882126, -0.006113535724580288, -0.030937111005187035, -0.03224800527095795, 0.01794733852148056, 0.0014390046708285809, 0.04392688348889351, 0.03167597949504852, -0.020449955016374588, 0.03589467704296112, -0.027433447539806366, 0.018233351409435272, -0.011833802796900272, -0.008604235015809536, 0.04464191943407059, 0.04278283193707466, 0.00297483685426414, -0.0012170464033260942, 0.03803977742791176, -0.016147837042808533, -0.01053482573479414, 0.004674531053751707, -0.004251469392329454, 0.003715194296091795, -0.010659956373274326, 0.0248354934155941, -0.04104291647672653, -0.016088251024484634, 0.01192914042621851, -0.06997793912887573, 0.005183991976082325, 0.02313133142888546, -0.056487638503313065, -0.003983331844210625, 0.0026515822391957045, -0.00795474648475647, -0.009188178926706314, -0.0015566872898489237, -0.0009697640780359507, 0.043521698564291, -0.021188823506236076, 0.03005523793399334, -0.018590867519378662, 0.01836444064974785, 0.0353226512670517, -0.012620339170098305, 0.0002416961797280237, -0.006417424883693457, -0.026170222088694572, -0.0027796924114227295, 0.018769627436995506, -0.0071860854513943195, -0.013692889362573624, -0.008258636109530926, 0.005848377477377653, 0.008693614043295383, 0.026766084134578705, -0.005830501671880484, 0.06635510176420212, -0.030174409970641136, 0.03353506699204445, -0.006399549078196287, -0.01034414954483509, 0.010999596677720547, 0.004442145116627216, 0.000028675818612100556, 0.0042484900914132595, 0.006131411530077457, -0.008300346322357655, 0.008741282857954502, -0.015051453374326229, -0.018912633880972862, -0.00010930328426184133, -0.030913276597857475, -0.029554713517427444, -0.02695675939321518, 0.023584185168147087, -0.011142604053020477, 0.02240438014268875, 0.006739189848303795, -0.01189338881522417, -0.0407092347741127, -0.01932973600924015, 0.013108945451676846, 0.020223528146743774, -0.018900716677308083, -0.025359850376844406, 0.004722199868410826, 0.00999855063855648, 0.0016877767629921436, 0.014825025573372841, -0.005866253282874823, -0.029840726405382156, -0.016445768997073174, 0.01053482573479414, 0.009069006890058517, -0.027576453983783722, 0.009444399736821651, 0.005434253718703985, 0.029530879110097885, -0.00545510882511735, -0.08585167676210403, 0.03966052085161209, 0.021558256819844246, -0.005413398612290621, -0.005672598257660866, 0.05744101479649544, 0.034988969564437866, 0.03324905410408974, 0.007585312705487013, 0.01791158691048622, 0.01000450924038887, -0.050624363124370575, 0.002614340977743268, 0.021260326728224754, 0.002852685283869505, -0.02519300952553749, -0.0210577342659235, -0.004787744488567114, 0.022380545735359192, 0.005997342523187399, 0.015170625410974026, 0.02279764786362648, 0.008926000446081161, 0.014586681500077248, 0.009748288430273533, 0.024930831044912338, -0.030484257265925407, 0.0033249054104089737, 0.022523552179336548, -0.0038522423710674047, 0.023703357204794884, -0.004808599594980478, 0.0008155849645845592, 0.06454367935657501, -0.021915772929787636, -0.026432400569319725, -0.012834849767386913, 0.014467509463429451, -0.0055355504155159, 0.0050946129485964775, 0.01295402180403471, -0.003932683728635311, -0.003003140212967992, 0.0008833641768433154, 0.03880247846245766, -0.014431757852435112, 0.017041629180312157, 0.02903035655617714, 0.02317900024354458, 0.018030758947134018, 0.020640630275011063, 0.01189934741705656, -0.02731427550315857, 0.02423963136970997, -0.016016747802495956, 0.003983331844210625, 0.03422626480460167, -0.022213704884052277, -0.023941701278090477, -0.0022866171784698963, -0.022678475826978683, 0.018590867519378662, -0.0057202670723199844, -0.04032788425683975, -0.04242531582713127, -0.03272469714283943, -0.025026168674230576, 0.01191722322255373, -0.011172397062182426, -0.02445414289832115, -0.009736371226608753, 0.024668652564287186, 0.008300346322357655, 0.026718415319919586, 0.0028899265453219414, 0.016815202310681343, -0.033678073436021805, 0.013669054955244064, -0.026098718866705894, 0.03932683542370796, -0.010844673030078411, -0.024001287296414375, 0.0009057089919224381, 0.0007031161803752184, 0.0258603747934103, 0.01901988871395588, 0.028887350112199783, -0.001938038389198482, 0.011506078764796257, 0.013406876474618912, 0.017446814104914665, -0.009813833050429821, 0.011357113718986511, 0.002197238150984049, -0.021319912746548653, 0.010397776961326599, 0.015420886687934399, -0.029888395220041275, -0.035036638379096985, 0.005335936788469553, 0.00018890660430770367, -0.01722038723528385, -0.04016104340553284, -0.0552959181368351, 0.018030758947134018, -0.04345019534230232, 0.01002238504588604, 0.018888799473643303, -0.026122553274035454, -0.018817296251654625, 0.05968145281076431, 0.027790965512394905, 0.008353973738849163, 0.006185038946568966, -0.002101900288835168, -0.016112085431814194, -0.005735163576900959, -0.006774941459298134, -0.020175859332084656, -0.018769627436995506, 0.004272324498742819, 0.0051661161705851555, -0.01584990695118904, 0.008276511915028095, 0.005562364123761654, -0.041305094957351685, 0.008669779635965824, 0.0025979545898735523, 0.0004301372682675719, -0.006739189848303795, -0.01534938346594572, 0.005937756504863501, 0.009170303121209145, -0.0016550043364986777, 0.005315081682056189, -0.054390206933021545, -0.023274337872862816, 0.023202834650874138, 0.01692245714366436, 0.002758837305009365, 0.0013220669934526086, -0.00525549566373229, 0.012090022675693035, 0.016433851793408394, -0.042997341603040695, 0.004045897163450718, 0.008062001317739487, -0.010093888267874718, 0.03832579031586647, -0.007317175157368183, -0.006036073435097933, 0.008860455825924873, 0.004778806585818529, 0.04485642910003662, 0.0159333273768425, 0.01686287112534046, 0.01756598800420761, 0.010648039169609547, 0.001997624523937702, 0.00986746046692133, 0.07159867882728577, 0.008073918521404266, -0.013371124863624573, -0.03522731363773346, 0.013061276637017727, 0.004051855765283108, -0.01868620701134205, -0.02137949876487255, -0.009128592908382416, -0.01861470192670822, -0.022618889808654785, -0.025765037164092064, 0.04728754237294197, 0.033654239028692245, 0.0025115548633038998, -0.012763346545398235, -0.010832755826413631, 0.0030225056689232588, -0.003601980861276388, 0.026337062940001488, 0.01436025369912386, 0.016839036718010902, 0.012084064073860645, -0.0037122149951756, 0.003905870020389557, -0.000911667593754828, -0.020187776535749435, -0.029936065897345543, 0.04499943554401398, 0.02900652214884758, -0.006363797467201948, 0.0053895642049610615, 0.01656494103372097, 0.025383684784173965, 0.004278283100575209, -0.002590506337583065, -0.010123681277036667, 0.017887752503156662, -0.003426201641559601, -0.01836444064974785, -0.0034291809424757957, -0.010457363910973072, 0.013240034691989422, -0.026456234976649284, 0.012584587559103966, -0.025336015969514847, 0.018531281501054764, -0.009182220324873924, -0.03320138528943062, -0.021284161135554314, -0.006536596920341253, -0.02108156867325306, 0.021510588005185127, 0.0029524920973926783, 0.03224800527095795, 0.0050618406385183334, 0.00847910437732935, 0.004960544407367706, -0.016719864681363106, -0.036824218928813934, 0.025765037164092064, -0.058585070073604584, -0.021689346060156822, 0.03322521969676018, 0.0048741442151367664, 0.018090344965457916, 0.01141669973731041, -0.024001287296414375, 0.015766486525535583, 0.0029182301368564367, -0.004662613850086927, -0.005991383921355009, -0.031223125755786896, -0.001984217669814825, -0.0581083819270134, -0.009545695967972279, -0.0011723568895831704, 0.039851196110248566, -0.02143908478319645, 0.029840726405382156, 0.025979546830058098, 0.004397455602884293, 0.0015924390172585845, -0.01686287112534046, -0.005118447355926037, -0.01036798395216465, -0.004868185613304377, -0.02762412279844284, 0.005985425319522619, 0.00796070508658886, -0.01930590160191059, -0.021212657913565636, -0.013144697062671185, -0.004960544407367706, -0.0027826717123389244, 0.03594234585762024, -0.04349786415696144, 0.018590867519378662, 0.007513809483498335, -0.006882196292281151, -0.020235445350408554, -0.009539737366139889, -0.017494484782218933, -0.04928963631391525, 0.010332232341170311, 0.0004107717832084745, -0.006852403283119202, 0.025788871571421623, 0.025121506303548813, -0.034393105655908585, 0.010189225897192955, -0.010278604924678802, 0.011762299574911594, -0.006405507680028677, -0.035727836191654205, 0.000533668149728328, 0.010969803668558598, -0.046787019819021225, 0.021200740709900856, 0.04840775951743126, -0.040256381034851074, 0.01657685823738575, -0.019234398379921913, 0.031008614227175713, 0.008931959047913551, -0.0032057331409305334, -0.026742249727249146, -0.03260552138090134, 0.034988969564437866, -0.0003249305300414562, 0.010785087011754513, 0.036848053336143494, 0.03463144972920418, -0.0002893650671467185, 0.026337062940001488, -0.04051855951547623, 0.012119815684854984, 0.03827812150120735, 0.02729044109582901, -0.01723230443894863, 0.016707947477698326, -0.010969803668558598, 0.005362750496715307, -0.0018799420213326812, -0.040542393922805786, -0.024740155786275864, -0.003348739817738533, -0.017697077244520187, -0.023274337872862816, 0.03103245049715042, 0.013716723769903183, 0.003476849989965558, -0.026122553274035454, -0.008389725349843502, 0.02588420920073986, -0.011243900284171104, -0.01436025369912386, -0.01189934741705656, -0.0020482728723436594, -0.019889846444129944, -0.026646912097930908, 0.00517505407333374, 0.04013720899820328, -0.007901119068264961, -0.023024074733257294, 0.006864320486783981, -0.006310169585049152, -0.008115628734230995, 0.0007094471948221326, 0.001590949366800487, 0.004412352107465267, -0.0012952531687915325, 0.009909171611070633, -0.028386825695633888, -0.026122553274035454, 0.0436408706009388, 0.009051131084561348, 0.0012386464513838291, 0.02104581706225872, -0.00792495347559452, -0.016004830598831177, -0.022869151085615158, -0.02941170707345009, 0.028434494510293007, 0.004820516798645258, 0.01760173961520195, 0.02249971777200699, -0.028100812807679176, -0.01105918362736702, 0.0006543300696648657, 0.06430533528327942, -0.010481198318302631, -0.013061276637017727, -0.0168986227363348, 0.02203494682908058, 0.017458731308579445, -0.005124405957758427, -0.015790320932865143, 0.003876076778396964, -0.01107705943286419, 0.007227796129882336, -0.033368226140737534, 0.02008052170276642, 0.009646992199122906, 0.02590804360806942, -0.006667686626315117, -0.007144375238567591, -0.0042484900914132595, -0.0035006843972951174, -0.013573717325925827, -0.010832755826413631, 0.01590949296951294, 0.0105586601421237, 0.017089297994971275, -0.025097671896219254, -0.02447797730565071, 0.05348449945449829, -0.023751026019454002, 0.0052823093719780445, -0.013919317163527012, 0.02244013175368309, 0.023739108815789223, -0.0041769868694245815, 0.01395506877452135, -0.0003973649290855974, -0.01836444064974785, -0.0020721072796732187, 0.001007005339488387, 0.03637136518955231, 0.0003761373518500477, 0.026003381237387657, 0.020259279757738113, 0.007049037609249353, -0.028601335361599922, -0.006053949240595102, 0.015111039392650127, 0.03603768348693848, 0.02454948052763939, -0.023333923891186714, 0.005341895390301943, -0.006226749159395695, -0.03763459250330925, -0.010183267295360565, -0.007781947031617165, -0.006965617183595896, 0.010773169808089733, -0.009629116393625736, 0.007323133759200573, -0.004829454701393843, -0.021963441744446754, -0.013919317163527012, -0.02764795906841755, 0.0031372089870274067, 0.0008528262842446566, 0.03105628490447998, 0.016719864681363106, 0.02826765365898609, 0.006375714670866728, 0.010701666586101055, -0.0010271157370880246, 0.012834849767386913, 0.009313310496509075, -0.023608019575476646, -0.0006975299911573529, -0.015754569321870804, -0.004004186950623989, -0.02490699663758278, 0.0023759964387863874, 0.013645220547914505, 0.010653997771441936, 0.005216764286160469, -0.013085111044347286, -0.014062323607504368, 0.03839729353785515, -0.04671551659703255, 0.00001765471461112611, 0.015635397285223007, 0.00026608924963511527, -0.02353651635348797, 0.007984539493918419, -0.010046219453215599, 0.021498670801520348, 0.0036198566667735577, 0.012393912300467491, 0.002191279549151659, -0.0060956599190831184, -0.011106852442026138, 0.01447942666709423, 0.006518721114844084, 0.02282148227095604, -0.002772244159132242, 0.025765037164092064, 0.018710041418671608, -0.023238586261868477, 0.0036556082777678967, -0.003131250385195017, -0.007752153556793928, -0.057202670723199844, 0.012560753151774406, 0.012787180952727795, 0.02382252924144268, 0.025073837488889694, -0.033296722918748856, -0.013120862655341625, 0.00717416824772954, 0.045118607580661774, 0.008318222127854824, -0.0024117480497807264, -0.004534503445029259, -0.050624363124370575, 0.01190530601888895, 0.040232546627521515, -0.009432482533156872, 0.0015328528825193644, -0.015504307113587856, -0.006328045390546322, -0.003950559534132481, 0.0012602463830262423, -0.0002722340577747673, -0.019413156434893608, -0.027457281947135925, -0.021296078339219093, -0.013943151570856571, 0.012536918744444847, 0.02171318046748638, 0.013168531470000744, 0.0021138174924999475, -0.030960945412516594, 0.044355906546115875, -0.008890248835086823, 0.039898864924907684, -0.03751542046666145, -0.014610515907406807, -0.011154521256685257, 0.008604235015809536, -0.03320138528943062, 0.020295031368732452, 0.006316128186881542, 0.001777155906893313, -0.0007701505674049258, -0.01730380766093731, -0.00020575830421876162, -0.008193091489374638, 0.024430308490991592, -0.015158708207309246, -0.014801191166043282, -0.016421934589743614, 0.03417859598994255, -0.04423673450946808, 0.00006158783799037337, -0.03415476158261299, 0.02347693033516407, 0.01194701623171568, 0.01483694277703762, 0.02042612060904503, -0.008812787011265755, -0.0049545858055353165, -0.00019775141845457256, -0.01488461159169674, 0.010689749382436275, 0.0071860854513943195, -0.003485787892714143, 0.0210577342659235, -0.020843222737312317, -0.0258603747934103, -0.0158737413585186, 0.0211173202842474, -0.0055772606283426285, -0.011434575542807579, 0.05663064494729042, -0.021570174023509026, -0.04399838671088219, 0.022869151085615158, -0.013621386140584946, -0.00716225104406476, 0.007406554184854031, 0.015170625410974026, 0.010564618743956089, 0.021212657913565636, -0.033630404621362686, 0.01556389406323433, 0.013025525026023388, 0.05186375603079796, 0.01929398439824581, 0.026646912097930908, 0.05601095035672188, 0.012262823060154915, -0.04030404984951019, -0.010957886464893818, 0.0021465898025780916, -0.047502052038908005, -0.018483612686395645, 0.023977452889084816, 0.014443675056099892, -0.007728319149464369, 0.013514131307601929, 0.030937111005187035, 0.018555115908384323, -0.006828568875789642, 0.016338512301445007, 0.012143651023507118, -0.0210577342659235, -0.03465528413653374, 0.027695627883076668, -0.019222481176257133, 0.024346888065338135, 0.03374957665801048, -0.010332232341170311, -0.04356936737895012, 0.0153613006696105, 0.06139753386378288, 0.00899154506623745, -0.004281262401491404, -0.006965617183595896, -0.01929398439824581, -0.0218204353004694, 0.004668572451919317, 0.0098257502540946, -0.013299621641635895, 0.013549882918596268, 0.004778806585818529, -0.041662611067295074, -0.003929704427719116, -0.030865607783198357, -0.003161043394356966, 0.030722601339221, -0.000029537024602177553, -0.006477010902017355, -0.011512037366628647, 0.024763990193605423, 0.011613334529101849, -0.016088251024484634, 0.0199732668697834, -0.010117722675204277, -0.01758982241153717, 0.013323456048965454, -0.0044361865147948265, 0.006417424883693457, -0.069119893014431, -0.00792495347559452, 0.010487156920135021, -0.009349062107503414, 0.0028973750304430723, -0.017863918095827103, -0.02285723388195038, -0.007311216555535793, 0.009557613171637058, -0.018900716677308083, -0.02974538877606392, 0.024668652564287186, -0.0023983411956578493, 0.01295402180403471, 0.01936548762023449, 0.029554713517427444, 0.03317755088210106, 0.0148488599807024, -0.014944197610020638, 0.011845720000565052, -0.00450471043586731, -0.0007079575443640351, 0.024287302047014236, 0.012477332726120949, -0.0025458168238401413, 0.010076012462377548, -0.0009503985638730228, -0.01039181835949421, 0.0004722199810203165, 0.013108945451676846, 0.003473870689049363, 0.009039213880896568, -0.0024847411550581455, -0.008788952603936195, 0.0016222320264205337, 0.03563249856233597, -0.044022224843502045, 0.028410660102963448, -0.01592141017317772, -0.00043274418567307293, -0.02690909057855606, 0.022559303790330887, 0.010451405309140682, 0.01191126462072134, -0.02628939412534237, -0.011702713556587696, 0.01830485463142395, 0.010642080567777157, -0.008914083242416382, -0.011744423769414425, 0.0372532419860363, -0.008943876251578331, 0.0015626458916813135, 0.012787180952727795, -0.016326595097780228, 0.0056457845494151115, 0.012310491874814034, 0.008175214752554893, -0.02898268774151802, -0.007889201864600182, 0.018602784723043442, -0.002384934341534972, 0.025741202756762505, -0.004200821276754141, -0.0008453780319541693, 0.03668121248483658, 0.038182783871889114, 0.019806426018476486, -0.017708994448184967, 0.02416812814772129, -0.003342781215906143, 0.024692486971616745, -0.022285208106040955, 0.021236492320895195, 0.012358160689473152, -0.020116273313760757, 0.0065306383185088634, 0.0067153554409742355, 0.02043803781270981, 0.018853047862648964, 0.016648361459374428, -0.015337466262280941, 0.0012408809270709753, -0.02628939412534237, 0.036466702818870544, 0.038135115057229996, 0.009444399736821651, 0.02008052170276642, -0.02072405070066452, 0.028076978400349617, -0.029936065897345543, -0.010701666586101055, -0.0006077783764339983, -0.019830260425806046, 0.009927047416567802, -0.02862516976892948, -0.002197238150984049, 0.035417988896369934, 0.03324905410408974, -0.014920363202691078, -0.008747242391109467, -0.007084789220243692, 0.006637893617153168, -0.014801191166043282, -0.01242966391146183, -0.0020899830851703882, 0.03322521969676018, -0.017840083688497543, -0.0014807150000706315, -0.00849102158099413, 0.017542153596878052, -0.004677510354667902, -0.03763459250330925, -0.021856186911463737, 0.004969482310116291, 0.020509541034698486, 0.006137370131909847, 0.0004435441514942795, 0.02378677763044834, -0.04290200397372246, -0.00986150186508894, -0.01760173961520195, 0.02733810991048813, 0.024287302047014236, -0.03360657021403313, -0.0009422054863534868, -0.03179515153169632, -0.0026947821024805307, -0.00986150186508894, -0.015206377021968365, 0.019627666100859642, -0.0103381909430027, 0.03808744624257088, 0.027028262615203857, 0.03360657021403313, -0.018042676150798798, 0.009301392361521721, 0.01138690672814846, -0.01730380766093731, 0.029125694185495377, 0.005913922097533941 ]
13.576926
6.80821
2024-07-01
1
2024A&A...687A.137B
[ "radio observations", "new radio observations", "large radio surveys", "larger galaxies", "archival radio surveys", "archival observations", "star formation", "Recent X-ray observations", "galaxy mass", "empirical relations" ]
[ "galaxies: dwarf", "galaxies: starburst", "galaxies: star formation", "radio continuum: galaxies", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies", "Astrophysics - High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena" ]
25
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202348819", "10.48550/arXiv.2403.19635" ]
[ "Borkar, A.", "Grossová, R.", "Svoboda, J.", "Moravec, E.", "Kouroumpatzakis, K.", "Boorman, P. G.", "Adamcová, B.", "Mingo, B.", "Ehle, M." ]
[ "Astronomical Institute of the Czech Academy of Sciences, Boční II 1401, 14100, Prague, Czech Republic", "Astronomical Institute of the Czech Academy of Sciences, Boční II 1401, 14100, Prague, Czech Republic ; Department of Theoretical Physics and Astrophysics, Faculty of Science, Masaryk University, Kotlářská 2, Brno, 61137, Czech Republic", "Astronomical Institute of the Czech Academy of Sciences, Boční II 1401, 14100, Prague, Czech Republic", "Green Bank Observatory, PO Box 2, Green Bank, WV, 24944, USA", "Astronomical Institute of the Czech Academy of Sciences, Boční II 1401, 14100, Prague, Czech Republic", "Cahill Center for Astronomy and Astrophysics, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA, 91125, USA", "Astronomical Institute of the Czech Academy of Sciences, Boční II 1401, 14100, Prague, Czech Republic", "School of Physical Sciences, The Open University, Walton Hall, Milton Keynes, MK7 6AA, UK", "European Space Agency, European Space Astronomy Centre (ESA/ESAC), Camino Bajo del Castillo s/n, 28692, Villanueva de la Cañada, Madrid, Spain" ]
[ "2024arXiv240503391K" ]
[ "1981PASP...93....5B", "1987ApJ...321L.107S", "1989A&A...218...67V", "1992ARA&A..30..575C", "1997ApJ...475..479W", "1998AJ....115.1693C", "2000A&AS..143....9W", "2000MNRAS.319..168C", "2001ARA&A..39...19L", "2001ApJ...546..665S", "2002ApJ...568...88Y", "2003ApJ...586..794B", "2006MNRAS.372.1366K", "2007MNRAS.376.1182B", "2008MNRAS.385.1143B", "2009ApJ...703.2113V", "2009ApJS..182..543A", "2009MNRAS.399.1191C", "2010ApJ...717....1L", "2010ApJ...717..196L", "2010MNRAS.405..887C", "2012ApJ...746L...6C", "2012ApJ...753..103N", "2012MNRAS.421.1569B", "2012MNRAS.423L.127R", "2013A&A...558A..33A", "2014ApJ...787L..30R", "2015A&A...578A..83G", "2015ApJ...799...98M", "2015ApJ...802L..19R", "2015ApJ...811..140B", "2015MNRAS.454.3722S", "2015PASA...32...27H", "2017A&A...598A..78I", "2017ApJ...844..171Y", "2017ApJ...847...38Y", "2017PASP..129b8001B", "2018A&C....24...97G", "2018AJ....156..123A", "2018MNRAS.475.3010G", "2019ApJ...874...52M", "2019ApJ...880..144S", "2019ApJ...882L..19S", "2019ApJ...884...78L", "2019ApJ...885...96J", "2019MNRAS.488..685M", "2019MNRAS.489L..12K", "2019NatAs...3..387P", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020ApJ...888...36R", "2020ApJ...901..159C", "2020Natur.585..357H", "2021A&A...648A...6S", "2021ApJS..255...30G", "2021MNRAS.506.3079K", "2021PASA...38...58H", "2022A&A...659A...1S", "2022A&A...662A..28M", "2022A&A...664A..83H", "2022A&A...665L...4S", "2022AJ....163..150K", "2022ApJ...926..131B", "2022ApJ...927..212F", "2022ApJ...935..167A", "2022ApJ...938L..15C", "2022ApJ...940L..14N", "2022ApJ...940L..55F", "2022NatAs...6...26R", "2022PASP..134k4501C", "2023A&A...673A..16K", "2023ApJ...942L..14R", "2023ApJ...955L..24G", "2023MNRAS.518.4755A", "2023MNRAS.519.1201A", "2023MNRAS.524.5486A", "2023MNRAS.525.1353J", "2023Natur.616..266L", "2024NatAs...8..126B" ]
29163277
2406.11962
The properties of AGN in dwarf galaxies identified via SED fitting
Given their dominance of the galaxy number density, dwarf galaxies are central to our understanding of galaxy formation. While the incidence of active galactic nuclei (AGN) and their impact on galaxy evolution have been extensively studied in massive galaxies, much less is known about the role of AGN in the evolution of dwarfs. We search for radiatively efficient AGN in the nearby (0.1 &lt; z &lt; 0.3) dwarf (10<SUP>8</SUP> M<SUB>⊙</SUB> &lt; M<SUB>⋆</SUB> &lt; 10<SUP>10</SUP> M<SUB>⊙</SUB>) population, using spectral energy distribution fitting (via PROSPECTOR) applied to deep ultraviolet to mid-infrared photometry of 508 dwarf galaxies. Around a third (32 ± 2 per cent) of our dwarfs show signs of AGN activity. We compare the properties of our dwarf AGN to control samples, constructed from non-AGN, which have the same distributions of redshift and stellar mass as their AGN counterparts. Kolmogorov-Smirnov tests between the AGN and control distributions indicate that the AGN do not show differences in their distances to nodes, filaments, and nearby massive galaxies from their control counterparts. This indicates that AGN triggering in the dwarf regime is not strongly correlated with local environment. The fraction of AGN hosts with early-type morphology and those that are interacting are also indistinguishable from the controls within the uncertainties, suggesting that interactions do not play a significant role in inducing AGN activity in our sample. Finally, the star formation activity in dwarf AGN is only slightly lower than that in their control counterparts, suggesting that the presence of radiatively efficient AGN does not lead to significant, prompt quenching of star formation in these systems.
[ -0.017486171796917915, 0.04861593246459961, 0.009430129081010818, -0.015516241081058979, 0.003824339946731925, 0.06318368762731552, 0.021304430440068245, -0.010585335083305836, -0.013315269723534584, 0.024551168084144592, -0.03244305029511452, -0.030667679384350777, -0.028649108484387398, 0.019127778708934784, 0.041927896440029144, 0.006596834398806095, -0.024137726053595543, 0.012123582884669304, 0.012464065104722977, 0.02643597684800625, 0.023675642907619476, 0.02718990109860897, 0.028892310336232185, 0.021961074322462082, -0.062064964324235916, -0.023468922823667526, -0.03385361656546593, 0.010980537161231041, 0.02621709555387497, 0.0060891518369317055, 0.009898291900753975, -0.0027010540943592787, -0.03762323409318924, -0.007265637628734112, -0.021061230450868607, 0.07164709270000458, 0.005371707957237959, 0.00509810633957386, -0.01878729835152626, -0.031275682151317596, -0.020343786105513573, -0.04662168398499489, -0.020258665084838867, -0.01511495839804411, -0.017863132059574127, 0.0021006509196013212, -0.010056372731924057, -0.047108083963394165, 0.0024320126976817846, -0.025147011503577232, -0.053893402218818665, 0.019468260928988457, 0.041709017008543015, -0.03295377269387245, -0.007600039709359407, 0.01290182676166296, -0.019674982875585556, -0.018848098814487457, -0.047059446573257446, -0.023140599951148033, -0.031737763434648514, -0.016951128840446472, 0.01883593760430813, 0.04645144194364548, -0.0007721640286035836, -0.008889006450772285, -0.02222859486937523, 0.01583240181207657, 0.020514026284217834, 0.022435316815972328, -0.004404983017593622, -0.04197653755545616, 0.037088192999362946, -0.031324323266744614, 0.008293163031339645, 0.004611704032868147, 0.03378065675497055, -0.033683374524116516, -0.04217109829187393, 0.02877070941030979, 0.02738446183502674, 0.0261684563010931, -0.029062550514936447, -0.012585665099322796, 0.0016841688193380833, 0.01600264385342598, -0.02338380180299282, -0.011418299749493599, -0.06517793983221054, 0.024903809651732445, 0.06430241465568542, -0.005772990174591541, -0.0020945710130035877, -0.01817929372191429, 0.009861811064183712, 0.0030065756291151047, 0.06902051717042923, -0.023116279393434525, 0.0683881938457489, 0.021316591650247574, 0.002962495433166623, 0.027141261845827103, 0.012062782421708107, -0.05686045438051224, 0.03022991679608822, -0.004040181171149015, 0.005991871003061533, 0.01657416671514511, 0.030959520488977432, 0.019273700192570686, 0.03319697454571724, -0.012500545009970665, -0.01219046302139759, 0.04521111398935318, -0.05253147333860397, 0.014616396278142929, -0.05355291813611984, 0.033926576375961304, -0.0015139278257265687, 0.005839870311319828, -0.004173941910266876, -0.0012053662212565541, -0.006210752297192812, 0.010147572495043278, 0.048688892275094986, 0.016634967178106308, 0.04161173477768898, -0.03781779855489731, -0.06678307056427002, -0.012804546393454075, 0.05992479249835014, -0.01860489696264267, -0.0315675251185894, 0.032880812883377075, -0.011436539702117443, -0.019237220287322998, -0.016270164400339127, -0.03441298007965088, -0.0020824107341468334, 0.06999332457780838, -0.003030895721167326, 0.004195221699774265, 0.028503188863396645, 0.039666127413511276, -0.020465387031435966, -0.027068300172686577, -0.04219542071223259, 0.016707926988601685, -0.005277467425912619, 0.04005524888634682, 0.0034838581923395395, -0.004034101031720638, -0.021936753764748573, -0.050877705216407776, -0.03915540501475334, 0.01781449280679226, -0.026873739436268806, 0.01882377825677395, -0.008536364883184433, -0.07417638599872589, -0.023882364854216576, 0.008785645477473736, -0.006384033244103193, 0.01822793483734131, -0.04102805256843567, 0.007904041558504105, -0.02081802859902382, -0.03813396021723747, -0.07407910376787186, -0.01678088679909706, 0.0007888841209933162, 0.013023427687585354, -0.020295144990086555, 0.007204837631434202, -0.039520204067230225, 0.02477004937827587, -0.03922836482524872, -0.013169348239898682, 0.01796041429042816, -0.007642599754035473, 0.0011521660489961505, 0.03407249599695206, 0.040298450738191605, -0.03336721286177635, 0.01742537133395672, 0.027919504791498184, -0.027141261845827103, 0.01961418241262436, 0.0023575322702527046, -0.02478220872581005, -0.0031220961827784777, 0.0037848197389394045, -0.004988666158169508, 0.07811624556779861, -0.03098384104669094, -0.012719426304101944, 0.01489607710391283, 0.03421841934323311, -0.046329841017723083, 0.014057032763957977, 0.014908237382769585, -0.006189472042024136, 0.008925486356019974, -0.06264864653348923, -0.04163605719804764, -0.061092156916856766, 0.06323233246803284, -0.026654858142137527, 0.03147024288773537, 0.014105673879384995, 0.0251956507563591, -0.011363578960299492, -0.010220533236861229, -0.015954002737998962, -0.017279449850320816, -0.0034291378688067198, -0.07417638599872589, 0.04647576063871384, 0.06527522206306458, 0.020903149619698524, 0.012755906209349632, 0.01899401843547821, 0.013971912674605846, 0.012828866951167583, 0.04577047750353813, 0.0036267389077693224, 0.03694227337837219, -0.029889436438679695, 0.051704589277505875, 0.007910121232271194, -0.00010250553168589249, 0.017230810597538948, -0.01702408865094185, -0.03212688863277435, 0.007563559338450432, -0.024295806884765625, 0.04080917313694954, 0.04783768951892853, 0.008049962110817432, -0.027700623497366905, -0.01470151636749506, 0.0041192215867340565, -0.0027785743586719036, 0.013825992122292519, -0.02199755422770977, 0.04217109829187393, 0.004666424356400967, -0.04139285534620285, 0.00559970922768116, 0.006280672736465931, -0.0048001850955188274, -0.02823566645383835, 0.03232144936919212, 0.0033865775913000107, -0.019906023517251015, -0.010171893052756786, -0.006730595137923956, 0.03784211724996567, -0.02497676946222782, 0.030935201793909073, -0.04263318330049515, -0.020076263695955276, 0.014725836925208569, -0.0014272874686866999, -0.05214235186576843, 0.04302230477333069, 0.021961074322462082, -0.04297366365790367, -0.01763209141790867, 0.034680500626564026, -0.023468922823667526, -0.05043994262814522, 0.030351517722010612, -0.057103656232357025, -0.058271024376153946, 0.017692891880869865, 0.007788520772010088, 0.05092634633183479, 0.005712189711630344, -0.051072265952825546, 0.018921058624982834, 0.012263423763215542, 0.08370987325906754, 0.02417420595884323, -0.01861705631017685, 0.018349535763263702, 0.002261771820485592, -0.0005209827213548124, 0.0014538875548169017, 0.00820196233689785, 0.07690024375915527, -0.0491509772837162, 0.023639163002371788, 0.005706109572201967, -0.007977001368999481, -0.047716088593006134, 0.014361035078763962, -0.0008002841495908797, -0.03920404240489006, 0.009241648018360138, 0.03166480362415314, 0.04798360913991928, 0.012938307598233223, -0.025560453534126282, -0.03040015883743763, -0.01699976809322834, 0.07164709270000458, 0.04839705303311348, -0.011539899744093418, 0.022338036447763443, 0.041514456272125244, 0.005648349411785603, 0.015431120060384274, 0.04039572924375534, -0.04037141054868698, -0.014786637388169765, -0.030108315870165825, 0.01740105077624321, 0.044700391590595245, -0.04073621332645416, -0.02397964522242546, -0.029305752366781235, -0.004882265347987413, 0.01131493877619505, -0.035312823951244354, -0.048129528760910034, -0.02017354592680931, -0.004684664309024811, -0.037063874304294586, -0.013740871101617813, 0.03120272234082222, 0.017668571323156357, 0.060119353234767914, 0.03254032880067825, -0.024952450767159462, -0.02118282951414585, 0.00009618799958843738, 0.035531703382730484, -0.026922380551695824, 0.004216501954942942, -0.031737763434648514, 0.020282985642552376, 0.03740435466170311, -0.01999114453792572, -0.04584343731403351, 0.03426705673336983, 0.01108997780829668, 0.056325413286685944, 0.0347534604370594, 0.032516010105609894, 0.011770941317081451, 0.006785315461456776, 0.02818702720105648, 0.0017419290961697698, 0.025755014270544052, -0.03939860686659813, 0.022654198110103607, -0.04175765812397003, 0.008968046866357327, 0.02197323366999626, -0.016744406893849373, -0.02682510018348694, 0.029694873839616776, 0.016647126525640488, 0.014458315446972847, 0.024843009188771248, -0.004979545716196299, 0.0058702705428004265, -0.011302778497338295, -0.051704589277505875, 0.009497009217739105, 0.018677856773138046, 0.006888675969094038, -0.004274262115359306, -0.06824227422475815, -0.016926808282732964, -0.015345999971032143, -0.015224399045109749, 0.02577933482825756, 0.009472689591348171, 0.03217552602291107, 0.013290949165821075, 0.014336714521050453, -0.05365020036697388, -0.0063901133835315704, -0.013777351938188076, -0.017486171796917915, -0.042073819786310196, -0.12053054571151733, 0.020331624895334244, 0.024660607799887657, -0.0038273800164461136, 0.010937976650893688, -0.041295573115348816, -0.035118263214826584, -0.019115619361400604, -0.01240934431552887, 0.03477778285741806, 0.0024274527095258236, 0.08220202475786209, -0.025463173165917397, -0.009424049407243729, -0.024076925590634346, -0.05136410892009735, -0.010889336466789246, -0.004462743178009987, -0.004256022162735462, 0.028722070157527924, 0.011479100212454796, -0.03645586967468262, 0.05544988811016083, 0.032710570842027664, 0.01488391775637865, -0.06527522206306458, -0.022642038762569427, 0.039520204067230225, -0.04183061793446541, 0.014336714521050453, -0.00950308982282877, 0.0423656590282917, -0.019674982875585556, -0.047108083963394165, 0.02359052188694477, -0.005228827241808176, -0.05501212552189827, 0.020708587020635605, 0.04020116850733757, 0.049296896904706955, -0.007934440858662128, -0.041709017008543015, -0.023286521434783936, 0.046791922301054, -0.030156956985592842, -0.01161286048591137, 0.018556255847215652, -0.01822793483734131, 0.025657733902335167, -0.014166473411023617, -0.0007505039102397859, -0.006578594446182251, 0.016330964863300323, -0.02121931128203869, -0.04433559253811836, -0.028454547747969627, 0.040711890906095505, 0.03120272234082222, 0.00505250645801425, 0.021900273859500885, 0.06731811165809631, -0.0772407203912735, -0.02120715007185936, -0.0193831417709589, -0.015151439234614372, -0.013400389812886715, -0.040322769433259964, -0.05613085255026817, 0.03939860686659813, 0.010068532079458237, 0.029257113113999367, -0.0305947195738554, 0.021523311734199524, -0.042292699217796326, -0.048105210065841675, -0.016890328377485275, -0.0419522188603878, 0.0009522849577479064, 0.007168357260525227, 0.024356607347726822, 0.005928030703216791, 0.026265736669301987, 0.020343786105513573, -0.04859161376953125, -0.027043981477618217, 0.01741321012377739, 0.00808644201606512, 0.00005856780626345426, 0.030740639194846153, 0.010269173420965672, 0.054087962955236435, -0.009247727692127228, 0.01703624799847603, -0.007362918462604284, 0.006833955645561218, 0.0005753230070695281, 0.027700623497366905, 0.013400389812886715, -0.014166473411023617, 0.0695069208741188, -0.010257013142108917, -0.023748602718114853, -0.022301556542515755, -0.042098138481378555, 0.06114079803228378, -0.01158853992819786, 0.025317251682281494, 0.001956250285729766, -0.03896084427833557, 0.007873641327023506, -0.008347883820533752, 0.0054993885569274426, 0.027335822582244873, -0.01191078219562769, -0.0033075371757149696, 0.04185493662953377, 0.008706605061888695, -0.01779017224907875, 0.022119155153632164, -0.04851865395903587, 0.012305984273552895, 0.01168582122772932, -0.05063450336456299, 0.017559131607413292, -0.025949575006961823, -0.01599048264324665, -0.022240756079554558, -0.0028120146598666906, -0.016513366252183914, 0.038498759269714355, 0.0051923468708992004, -0.010098932310938835, 0.02362700365483761, -0.02658189833164215, -0.007624359801411629, 0.0030506558250635862, 0.033124011009931564, 0.008274923078715801, -0.005274427589029074, -0.08283434808254242, -0.049467138946056366, -0.0007615239592269063, 0.003806099761277437, -0.021644912660121918, 0.05374747887253761, -0.006004031281918287, -0.02058698795735836, -0.04024980962276459, -0.000002942046648968244, 0.017510490491986275, -0.0395931676030159, -0.031324323266744614, 0.017109209671616554, -0.002118891105055809, -0.021316591650247574, -0.015905363485217094, 0.022763637825846672, 0.024879489094018936, -0.05219099298119545, -0.011491259559988976, -0.0038030596915632486, -0.0011362058576196432, 0.0775325670838356, 0.008657964877784252, 0.006396193522959948, -0.0025885733775794506, -0.02220427617430687, -0.004666424356400967, -0.03125136345624924, 0.040906451642513275, 0.0009895251132547855, -0.011594620533287525, -0.02840590849518776, 0.017121369019150734, -0.01819145493209362, 0.007368998136371374, -0.014774477109313011, -0.05126682668924332, 0.03584786504507065, 0.00022629117302130908, -0.05686045438051224, 0.022459637373685837, -0.024830849841237068, -0.01837385632097721, 0.0070102764293551445, -0.017546972259879112, 0.008572844788432121, -0.0005232627154327929, -0.053309716284275055, 0.03998228907585144, 0.026508938521146774, -0.04059028998017311, -0.02521997131407261, -0.03297809138894081, -0.0038790602702647448, 0.01131493877619505, -0.009946932084858418, -0.018884578719735146, 0.003407857846468687, 0.013266628608107567, 0.02757902443408966, -0.03361041471362114, 0.004310742486268282, -0.03720979392528534, 0.00609219167381525, -0.0001337606954621151, -0.008396524004638195, 0.003030895721167326, 0.02441740781068802, 0.015175758861005306, -0.027554703876376152, 0.023140599951148033, 0.007338598370552063, -0.010427254252135754, -0.03506962209939957, -0.010475894436240196, -0.005371707957237959, 0.008177642710506916, 0.0017586491303518414, -0.05904926732182503, 0.009375409223139286, 0.004839705303311348, -0.017328090965747833, -0.02138955146074295, -0.024040445685386658, -0.006268512457609177, 0.003602418815717101, -0.014908237382769585, 0.015844563022255898, -0.005669629666954279, 0.007922281511127949, -0.0014250074746087193, -0.018969697877764702, 0.0003370617632754147, 0.0007691240170970559, 0.027165580540895462, 0.029500313103199005, 0.0024076926056295633, 0.0033257773611694574, -0.03385361656546593, -0.013376069255173206, -0.05258011445403099, -0.017911773175001144, -0.028867989778518677, 0.011667580343782902, -0.011746620759367943, -0.005478108301758766, -0.03601810708642006, -0.02400396578013897, 0.005687869619578123, -0.014421834610402584, -0.001441727508790791, 0.026533257216215134, 0.004502263385802507, 0.013290949165821075, -0.004745464771986008, -0.010561014525592327, 0.01161894015967846, -0.005548028741031885, -0.022119155153632164, -0.020441066473722458, -0.04542999714612961, 0.003955060616135597, -0.017522651702165604, -0.0061712320894002914, 0.000755443936213851, 0.010743415914475918, 0.03497234359383583, -0.0038121799007058144, -0.014494795352220535, -0.022775799036026, 0.05452572554349899, -0.02179083414375782, -0.01719432882964611, 0.02019786462187767, 0.0077702803537249565, -0.018495455384254456, -0.011831741780042648, 0.017923932522535324, 0.013886792585253716, -0.014604235999286175, 0.02823566645383835, 0.06629666686058044, -0.019115619361400604, 0.0041526616550982, 0.023918844759464264, -0.006536033935844898, 0.003955060616135597, 0.008068202063441277, -0.035677626729011536, -0.02137739211320877, 0.0018969698576256633, 0.017899613827466965, 0.008706605061888695, -0.02340812236070633, 0.009557809680700302, 0.00020938109082635492, -0.012609985657036304, 0.03421841934323311, -0.008475564420223236, 0.015394640155136585, -0.01637960597872734, 0.012695105746388435, -0.01816713437438011, 0.0488591343164444, 0.01500551775097847, -0.016695767641067505, -0.0024396127555519342, 0.0020474507473409176, 0.00025251132319681346, -0.04676760360598564, -0.022860918194055557, 0.03154320269823074, 0.033294253051280975, 0.0269953403621912, 0.006274592597037554, -0.00759395956993103, 0.008955886587500572, -0.002390972338616848, -0.008651885204017162, 0.006961636245250702, -0.03125136345624924, 0.0755869522690773, 0.027287181466817856, -0.02041674591600895, 0.004751544911414385, 0.006852195598185062, -0.03195664659142494, -0.009265968576073647, 0.017534811049699783, -0.009308528155088425, -0.02621709555387497, -0.0036784191615879536, 0.0008626044727861881, -0.029135512188076973, -0.016367444768548012, 0.022277235984802246, -0.0004723424499388784, -0.015881042927503586, 0.03020559810101986, -0.025560453534126282, -0.027311502024531364, 0.006840035784989595, 0.014932557940483093, 0.02098826877772808, -0.0017404090613126755, -0.019735783338546753, 0.03137296438217163, 0.014361035078763962, -0.0012798466486856341, -0.01582024246454239, 0.03577490523457527, 0.026290057227015495, -0.009861811064183712, -0.006262432783842087, 0.008700525388121605, 0.030278557911515236, 0.007454118691384792, 0.013947593048214912, -0.022763637825846672, -0.007581799291074276, 0.011971582658588886, -0.01861705631017685, 0.009223408065736294, 0.008153322152793407, 0.0037696196231991053, 0.021705713123083115, -0.015260879881680012, 0.0340481773018837, -0.016258005052804947, 0.0315675251185894, 0.018896738067269325, 0.005113306455314159, -0.01160678081214428, 0.0025794534012675285, 0.0491509772837162, -0.026338696479797363, 0.012160063721239567, -0.03759891539812088, -0.013996233232319355, 0.02459980733692646, 0.006010111421346664, -0.003064336022362113, 0.011783101595938206, 0.008445164188742638, -0.019237220287322998, 0.014737996272742748, -0.002128011081367731, 0.005380827933549881, -0.046281199902296066, 0.005265307612717152, 0.008955886587500572, -0.016866007819771767, -0.0148109570145607, 0.026679178699851036, 0.0018468096386641264, 0.006688034627586603, 0.012123582884669304, 0.008578924462199211, -0.018665697425603867, -0.007697320077568293, 0.002219211542978883, -0.032516010105609894, 0.01960202120244503, -0.007174437399953604, 0.036528829485177994, -0.004444503225386143, 3.4437678664289706e-7, -0.010810296051204205, -0.09100591391324997, -0.012239104136824608, 0.015260879881680012, 0.028892310336232185, -0.010980537161231041, 0.03460754081606865, 0.029062550514936447, 0.016744406893849373, 0.04759448766708374, 0.025098370388150215, 0.00042674221913330257, -0.04363030567765236, -0.0024791329633444548, -0.002456332789734006, 0.014044873416423798, 0.016294484958052635, 0.0011666060891002417, -0.012330303899943829, 0.02260555699467659, 0.024332286790013313, 0.012974787503480911, 0.008633645251393318, -0.008743085898458958, -0.01049413438886404, -0.002067210851237178, -0.006852195598185062, -0.02957327477633953, 0.02282443828880787, 0.01290182676166296, -0.01119941845536232, 0.015747282654047012, -0.0297678355127573, -0.006973796524107456, 0.03375633433461189, -0.01837385632097721, -0.03684499114751816, 0.014275914058089256, 0.011345339007675648, -0.02821134775876999, 0.022921718657016754, 0.013959752395749092, -0.02697101980447769, 0.002573373494669795, 0.009004526771605015, 0.026946701109409332, -0.019711462780833244, -0.01600264385342598, 0.0019896903540939093, 0.009077487513422966, -0.030691999942064285, 0.0376475565135479, 0.021961074322462082, 0.006274592597037554, 0.0008192842360585928, -0.010050292126834393, 0.012233023531734943, 0.005517628509551287, -0.008341803215444088, -0.015479760244488716, -0.02040458656847477, -0.010056372731924057, 0.03399953618645668, -0.003876020200550556, -0.0134976701810956, -0.02577933482825756, -0.020039783790707588, -0.03246736899018288, 0.013947593048214912, -0.0005848230211995542, -0.03555602580308914, 0.00419218186289072, 0.027651984244585037, -0.0166106466203928, 0.009174767881631851, 0.008676204830408096, 0.011673660948872566, -0.027433102950453758, 0.0035020981449633837, -0.05058586224913597, 0.01859273761510849, -0.0269953403621912, -0.0038304198533296585, 0.002714734058827162, -0.0025140931829810143, 0.03380497545003891, 0.004240822046995163, 0.018531937152147293, -0.0010184053098782897, -0.01802121289074421, 0.004538743756711483, 0.025098370388150215, -0.0166106466203928, 0.009527409449219704, 0.01782665215432644, -0.014616396278142929, 0.020441066473722458, 0.00424690218642354, -0.04423831030726433, -0.005763870198279619, -0.0022359315771609545, -0.001089085708372295, -0.014263753779232502, -0.03645586967468262, -0.011929022148251534, 0.016099924221634865, -0.009308528155088425, 0.005383868236094713, -0.002313452074304223, -0.002053530653938651, 0.02701966091990471, 0.049126654863357544, 0.04105237498879433, 0.009685490280389786, -0.0015564881032332778, 0.018495455384254456, 0.011959422379732132, -0.02643597684800625, -0.0025201730895787477, -0.048105210065841675, -0.00016378084546886384, 0.04423831030726433, -0.01420295424759388, -0.054282523691654205, 0.015613521449267864, 0.0051224264316260815, -0.02181515283882618, 0.006979876197874546, -0.026654858142137527, -0.017242969945073128, 0.0013649670872837305, 0.006222912576049566, -0.013667911291122437, 0.027457423508167267, -0.029086871072649956, 0.015662161633372307, -0.009417968802154064, 0.010421174578368664, 0.033099692314863205, -0.005921951029449701, 0.011722301132977009, -0.030156956985592842, -0.013935432769358158, 0.02317707985639572, 0.033294253051280975, -0.03001103550195694, -0.006292832549661398, -0.011758781038224697, -0.023116279393434525, 0.035312823951244354, -0.021049069240689278, 0.011430459097027779, 0.005578428972512484, 0.008664045482873917, 0.026095496490597725, 0.022544756531715393, 0.012008062563836575, 0.02580365352332592, 0.0038273800164461136, -0.013534150086343288, 0.03438865765929222, 0.05656861513853073, 0.011217658407986164, -0.00939364917576313, -0.03234576806426048, 0.009065327234566212, 0.030862240120768547, -0.013181508518755436, -0.005703069735318422, -0.0026691339444369078, -0.029354393482208252, 0.004155701491981745, -0.06289184838533401, 0.012804546393454075, 0.006596834398806095, -0.0061803520657122135, -0.00021850113989785314, 0.008208042941987514, -0.004517463501542807, -0.02299468033015728, 0.04200085997581482, 0.01428807433694601, -0.007119717076420784, 0.006608994212001562, 0.008664045482873917, 0.040687572211027145, 0.03193232789635658, 0.009679410606622696, -0.010737336240708828, 0.04625688120722771, 0.007454118691384792, -0.013838152401149273, 0.04936985671520233, -0.0027800945099443197, 0.01839817501604557, -0.01620936393737793, 0.030302878469228745, -0.014117833226919174, 0.014239434152841568, 0.0053382678888738155, -0.02219211496412754, -0.012585665099322796, -0.026363017037510872, 0.01421511359512806, -0.011363578960299492, -0.0056939497590065, -0.011813501827418804, 0.02738446183502674, -0.015662161633372307, -0.05457436293363571, 0.01900617964565754, -0.010889336466789246, 0.028357267379760742, 0.02361484244465828, -0.0027846544981002808, 0.061919040977954865, -0.005174106918275356, 0.016355285421013832, -0.0067792353220283985, -0.033707696944475174, -0.02560909278690815, 0.008998447097837925, -0.0695069208741188, -0.0065481942147016525, 0.0191764198243618, 0.01780233345925808, 0.05301787704229355, 0.004724184516817331, -0.0016309685306623578, 0.01999114453792572, 0.010512374341487885, 0.021802993491292, 0.0037756997626274824, 0.011898621916770935, -0.014409675262868404, -0.05296923592686653, -0.0026721740141510963, -0.003942900337278843, 0.04735128581523895, -0.020477546378970146, 0.026703499257564545, 0.028138386085629463, 0.005627069156616926, 0.003897300222888589, -0.024526847526431084, -0.02541453205049038, -0.004186101723462343, 0.007764200214296579, 0.003111456288024783, -0.012020222842693329, -0.008408683352172375, -0.021146349608898163, -0.0269953403621912, -0.013485509902238846, 0.022678518667817116, -0.018860258162021637, 0.02658189833164215, -0.03662611171603203, 0.020076263695955276, 0.013120708055794239, -0.0242228452116251, -0.012451904825866222, -0.010609655641019344, -0.05437980219721794, -0.041076693683862686, -0.017048409208655357, -0.009338928386569023, -0.04005524888634682, 0.006785315461456776, -0.007144037168473005, -0.03942292556166649, 0.009551730006933212, 0.006371872965246439, 0.013716551475226879, -0.001980570377781987, -0.011223738081753254, 0.003997620660811663, -0.001737368991598487, -0.020149225369095802, 0.013047748245298862, 0.01862921752035618, -0.018483296036720276, 0.003286257153376937, -0.020538346841931343, 0.009253808297216892, 0.006809635553508997, 0.011856061406433582, -0.023870203644037247, 0.009265968576073647, -0.005128506571054459, -0.01368007156997919, 0.00735075818374753, 0.04825112968683243, 0.032710570842027664, -0.01281670667231083, 0.00789188127964735, -0.03803667798638344, -0.012646465562283993, 0.016683606430888176, 0.01089541707187891, -0.018896738067269325, -0.01089541707187891, -0.03506962209939957, 0.02298251911997795, -0.018933217972517014, 0.014385354705154896, -0.04134421423077583, 0.0029685753397643566, -0.029524633660912514, -0.0012441264698281884, 0.004398902878165245, -0.024952450767159462, 0.016853848472237587, -0.023943165317177773, 0.03161616623401642, -0.00928420852869749, 0.011442619375884533, -0.007204837631434202, -0.01618504337966442, -0.008329642936587334, -0.010433333925902843, -0.04243862256407738, 0.00599795114248991, 0.027238542214035988, 0.000727703794836998, -0.02558477409183979, -0.0028211346361786127, -0.02059914730489254, -0.013449029996991158, 0.020514026284217834, 0.02258123829960823, 0.01341255009174347, 0.024928130209445953, -0.010627895593643188, 0.010883256793022156, -0.0261684563010931, 0.013315269723534584, -0.007423718459904194, 0.022897399961948395, 0.012780226767063141, 0.00931460876017809, -0.022836599498987198, -0.01601480320096016, -0.03424273803830147, 0.017097048461437225, 0.03426705673336983, 0.0001838259631767869, 0.020769387483596802, -0.025706373155117035, -0.014020552858710289, -0.0018361695110797882, 0.058708786964416504, -0.04243862256407738, -0.008542444556951523, -0.02322572097182274, 0.03244305029511452, 0.005684829782694578, 0.009186928160488605, -0.021936753764748573, -0.005456828512251377, -0.002818094566464424, -0.001454647514037788, 0.003790899645537138, -0.0001717608975013718, 0.009126127697527409, 0.015881042927503586, 0.016367444768548012, -0.007016356568783522, 0.00017518091772217304, -0.0020793708972632885, -0.003152496414259076, 0.0062502725049853325, 0.027141261845827103, -0.020647786557674408, 0.027943825349211693, -0.008700525388121605, -0.007721640169620514, 0.018142813816666603, 0.005262267310172319, -0.007058916613459587, -0.003359217429533601, 0.002883455017581582, 0.004873145371675491, 0.0014303274219855666, 0.022885238751769066, 0.0033075371757149696, -0.016039123758673668, -0.00357809872366488, -0.002793774474412203, 0.0038456199690699577, 0.02998671680688858, 0.0025338532868772745, 0.009296368807554245, 0.012658625841140747, -0.02219211496412754, -0.010092852637171745, 0.012828866951167583, 0.03832852095365524, 0.018106333911418915, -0.0016188083682209253, 0.005423388443887234, -0.021681392565369606, -0.025171330198645592, -0.0019258500542491674, -0.009320688433945179, 0.0157837625592947, 0.010500214993953705, 0.00559970922768116, 0.013120708055794239, 0.003921620547771454, -0.033707696944475174, 0.009563889354467392, -0.0022556916810572147, -0.00038627200410701334, 0.026654858142137527, 0.02320140041410923, -0.010323893278837204, 0.0030658559408038855, 0.0020200905855745077, 0.019273700192570686, -0.006645474582910538, -0.016707926988601685, 0.011169018223881721, 0.023079799488186836, 0.01338822953402996, 0.0027831345796585083, -0.009673330001533031, -0.02619277685880661, -0.005493308417499065, 0.017936093732714653, 0.02318924106657505, -0.01601480320096016, -0.03361041471362114, 0.01899401843547821, 0.031713444739580154, -0.019529061391949654, -0.03283217176795006, 0.014908237382769585, -0.0037513794377446175, -0.028697749599814415, 0.032710570842027664, -0.012269503436982632, -0.016367444768548012, 0.00800132192671299, 0.018860258162021637, 0.009375409223139286, -0.0016400885069742799, 0.03336721286177635, 0.021267950534820557, 0.009320688433945179, 0.004636024124920368, -0.003392657730728388, 0.03344017267227173, 0.003973300568759441, -0.013254469260573387, 0.03623699024319649, 0.02141387201845646, 0.009320688433945179, -0.03803667798638344, 0.0220097154378891, 0.01980874314904213, 0.019468260928988457, 0.040857814252376556, -0.006420513615012169, -0.026265736669301987, -0.005392988212406635, 0.03900948166847229, -0.0019228099845349789, 0.009916531853377819, -0.007660839706659317, -0.047302644699811935, -0.0038821001071482897, 0.004216501954942942, -0.002433532616123557, -0.01618504337966442, 0.0032406568061560392, -0.005164986941963434, 0.017157848924398422, -0.009120047092437744, -0.013400389812886715, 0.019127778708934784, -0.017340250313282013, -0.0007911641150712967, 0.026630539447069168, 0.02918415144085884, 0.006846115458756685, -0.020076263695955276, 0.02261771820485592, -0.023481082171201706, 0.054477084428071976, 0.03514258190989494, 0.009861811064183712, -0.026071175932884216, -0.017936093732714653, -0.0359937883913517, 0.021961074322462082, -0.023128440603613853, 0.0026007334236055613, 0.01577160134911537, 0.016330964863300323, 0.006064831744879484, -0.0182036142796278, 0.003866900224238634, 0.0017647291533648968, 0.03254032880067825, -0.023468922823667526, 0.009259887970983982, -0.021742193028330803, 0.00400370080024004, -0.030764959752559662, -0.00781284086406231, -0.01341255009174347, 0.029111191630363464, -0.010737336240708828, 0.012263423763215542, 0.02039242535829544, -0.0091018071398139, -0.011935101822018623, -0.002238971646875143, -0.014519115909934044, 0.009417968802154064, -0.017133528366684914, -0.012050623074173927, 0.01721864938735962, -0.028843669220805168, -0.05374747887253761, -0.018896738067269325, -0.0032740971073508263, -0.01718216948211193, -0.03317265212535858, 0.025536132976412773, 0.010238773189485073, -0.05097498372197151, 0.033902257680892944, -0.028065426275134087, -0.011533820070326328, 0.021340910345315933, -0.022678518667817116, 0.010889336466789246, 0.04764312878251076, 0.016245843842625618, 0.0033683376386761665, -0.019334500655531883, 0.03679635003209114, 0.024441726505756378, 0.007186597213149071, 0.04866457358002663, 0.013363909907639027, -0.027895186096429825, 0.01699976809322834, 0.003912500571459532, -0.03584786504507065, -0.03246736899018288, 0.0278222244232893, -0.009326768107712269, 0.008463404141366482, 0.03436433896422386, 0.01139397919178009, 0.03504530340433121, -0.008049962110817432, 0.02697101980447769, 0.008706605061888695, -0.007551399525254965, -0.008597164414823055, 0.014616396278142929, 0.028454547747969627, 0.00740547850728035, 0.020769387483596802, 0.04455447196960449, -0.042511582374572754, 0.011533820070326328, 0.006864355877041817, 0.007454118691384792, -0.00879780575633049, 0.022897399961948395, -0.01922506093978882, -0.03623699024319649, 0.021340910345315933, 0.03742867335677147, 0.01500551775097847, 0.005706109572201967, 0.021061230450868607, -0.023262200877070427, -0.01288966741412878, -0.026484617963433266, -0.040128208696842194, 0.025074049830436707, 0.013108547776937485, 0.001909129903651774, -0.0028940951451659203, -0.00044156229705549777, -0.03767187520861626, -0.007989161647856236, 0.007612199522554874, 0.0009218847844749689, 0.001580808195285499, 0.02801678515970707, 0.0061712320894002914, 0.004936985671520233, -0.06420513242483139, -0.00005182276800042018, -0.0017160889692604542, -0.012318144552409649, -0.002451772801578045, 0.0024639328476041555, 0.001330766943283379, 0.02056266739964485, 0.001947130193002522, -0.02199755422770977, -0.03202960640192032, 0.029548954218626022, -0.05384476110339165, 0.01922506093978882, -0.006040511652827263, 0.05656861513853073, 0.02063562721014023, 0.022544756531715393, -0.03740435466170311, 0.015577041544020176, -0.02680077962577343, -0.024089084938168526, -0.006961636245250702, -0.007904041558504105, 0.0013938472839072347, -0.0006634834571741521, -0.0060891518369317055, -0.011770941317081451, -0.00729603786021471, 0.019079139456152916, -0.019322341307997704, 0.017948253080248833, 0.015163598582148552, -0.005779069848358631, 0.026849418878555298, -0.008062122389674187, -0.04934553802013397, 0.019152099266648293, -0.012926147319376469, -0.0017738492460921407, -0.029086871072649956, 0.000773684005253017, 0.00005761779902968556, 0.026752138510346413, 0.004079701378941536, -0.040517330169677734, -0.02120715007185936, 0.007095396984368563, 0.009825331158936024, -0.013169348239898682, 0.02119499072432518, -0.029086871072649956, -0.007332518231123686, 0.009788851253688335, -0.025438852608203888, 0.011102138087153435, 0.010165812447667122, 0.021632753312587738, -0.023529723286628723, 0.008846445940434933, 0.03538578376173973, -0.0064691537991166115, 0.0017996893730014563, 0.019310180097818375, 0.006852195598185062, 0.03232144936919212, 0.029719194397330284, 0.043314144015312195, -0.007831080816686153, 0.03623699024319649, -0.0004894425510428846, 0.017875293269753456, -0.039495885372161865, 0.01158853992819786, 0.011296698823571205, -0.013521990738809109, 0.02497676946222782, 0.049904901534318924, -0.0019820902962237597, 0.03575058653950691, 0.010372534394264221, -0.012768066488206387, -0.001330766943283379, -0.01777801290154457, 0.019504740834236145, 0.017668571323156357, 0.008530284278094769, 0.026946701109409332, 0.024259326979517937, 0.05223963037133217, -0.0008702045306563377, -0.0343400202691555, -0.007022436708211899, -0.025463173165917397, 0.007113636936992407, -0.026071175932884216, -0.0244295671582222, -0.008025641553103924, 0.007253477815538645, -0.0016020883340388536, -0.015017678029835224, -0.01918857917189598, -0.00132544687949121, -0.0328078493475914, -0.014908237382769585, 0.006347552873194218, 0.02023434452712536, -0.00909572746604681, 0.01160678081214428, -0.013813831843435764, 0.020550506189465523, -0.00931460876017809, -0.019115619361400604, -0.025341572239995003, -0.01079813577234745, 0.023554041981697083, -0.01029957365244627, 0.009794930927455425, 0.024368766695261, -0.02362700365483761, -0.011473019607365131, 0.009934771806001663, 0.012081023305654526, 0.037112511694431305, -0.016306644305586815, 0.00829924363642931, -0.03762323409318924, -0.05345563963055611, 0.016343124210834503, 0.02959759347140789, 0.01511495839804411, -0.030643358826637268, 0.02202187478542328, 0.007496679201722145, 0.00046512242988683283, 0.0029700954910367727, 0.006162112113088369, -0.0025429732631891966, -0.02539021149277687, 0.013898951932787895, 0.02577933482825756 ]
14.661353
7.147364
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.532..613B
[ "AGN hosts", "AGN", "non-AGN", "dwarf galaxies", "nearby massive galaxies", "galaxy formation", "massive galaxies", "galaxy evolution", "AGN activity", "dwarf" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
23
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1441", "10.48550/arXiv.2406.11962" ]
[ "Bichang'a, B.", "Kaviraj, S.", "Lazar, I.", "Jackson, R. A.", "Das, S.", "Smith, D. J. B.", "Watkins, A. E.", "Martin, G." ]
[ "Centre for Astrophysics Research, University of Hertfordshire, Hatfield AL10 9AB, UK", "Centre for Astrophysics Research, University of Hertfordshire, Hatfield AL10 9AB, UK", "Centre for Astrophysics Research, University of Hertfordshire, Hatfield AL10 9AB, UK", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Victoria, Victoria, BC V8P 5C2, Canada", "Centre for Astrophysics Research, University of Hertfordshire, Hatfield AL10 9AB, UK", "Centre for Astrophysics Research, University of Hertfordshire, Hatfield AL10 9AB, UK", "Centre for Astrophysics Research, University of Hertfordshire, Hatfield AL10 9AB, UK", "School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Nottingham, University Park, Nottingham NG7 2RD, UK" ]
null
[ "1981PASP...93....5B", "1998A&A...331L...1S", "1998ARA&A..36..435M", "1998Natur.395A..14R", "2000A&A...363L..29S", "2000AJ....120.1579Y", "2000ApJ...533..682C", "2000ApJ...539..718C", "2001ApJ...556..121K", "2002AJ....124.1810S", "2004ApJS..154...10F", "2005MNRAS.362...41G", "2007A&A...462..581H", "2007ApJ...657..810D", "2007ApJ...670...92G", "2007ApJS..172..196K", "2007ApJS..172..468Z", "2008ApJ...685..147N", "2008ApJ...685..160N", "2008MNRAS.391.1117P", "2009ARA&A..47..371T", "2009ApJ...699..486C", "2010ApJ...713..970A", "2010MNRAS.401..371M", "2010MNRAS.403.1036C", "2011MNRAS.413.1687C", "2011MNRAS.414..384S", "2011PASA...28..128C", "2011arXiv1105.0370C", "2012A&A...544A.156M", "2012ARA&A..50..455F", "2012MNRAS.427..703S", "2013ApJ...769...80A", "2013ApJ...775..116R", "2013ApJ...775L..16K", "2013RMxAA..49..137F", "2014ApJ...791L..25S", "2014MNRAS.439.2736D", "2014arXiv1404.0402S", "2015ApJS..218...33A", "2015ApJS..219...12A", "2015MNRAS.447..110S", "2016A&A...595A...1G", "2016ApJS..224...24L", "2017A&A...602A...3D", "2017A&A...602A..28M", "2017ApJ...837..170L", "2017ApJ...839...26D", "2017ApJ...839L..13S", "2017ApJ...840...44B", "2017ApJ...845...50N", "2017MNRAS.467.4739K", "2017MNRAS.470..283W", "2017MNRAS.472..949B", "2018ARA&A..56..625H", "2018ApJ...854...62L", "2018ApJ...858...38S", "2018ApJS..237...39A", "2018MNRAS.473.1195L", "2018MNRAS.474.1995R", "2018MNRAS.474.5437L", "2018MNRAS.475.3010G", "2018MNRAS.476..979P", "2018MNRAS.478.2576M", "2018MNRAS.479..807L", "2018MNRAS.480.2266M", "2018PASJ...70S...8A", "2019A&A...622A...1S", "2019ApJ...872..104N", "2019ApJ...873..111I", "2019ApJ...876....3L", "2019ApJ...884...78L", "2019ApJ...884..180D", "2019ApJ...887..245S", "2019MNRAS.482.2913B", "2019MNRAS.485..796M", "2019MNRAS.487.5549B", "2019MNRAS.488..685M", "2019MNRAS.489.5202S", "2019MNRAS.489L..12K", "2019PASJ...71..114A", "2019S&C....29..891H", "2019ascl.soft05025J", "2020ApJ...888...36R", "2020ApJ...889..113M", "2020ApJ...896...10B", "2020MNRAS.493.3132S", "2020MNRAS.496.2577K", "2020MNRAS.496.4061D", "2021A&A...651A.109D", "2021ApJ...920..134P", "2021ApJS..254...22J", "2021MNRAS.502.4262J", "2021MNRAS.502L...1K", "2021NatRP...3..732V", "2022ApJ...935..146S", "2022ApJS..258...11W", "2022MNRAS.509.4940T", "2022MNRAS.511.4109D", "2022MNRAS.512.1052P", "2022MNRAS.513..439D", "2022MNRAS.514.2936W", "2022MNRAS.516.2112K", "2023ApJ...944..141P", "2023MNRAS.520.2109L", "2023MNRAS.521.2012W", "2023MNRAS.523.1729B", "2024MNRAS.528.4976D", "2024MNRAS.528.5252M", "2024MNRAS.529..499L", "2024MNRAS.531..977D", "2024arXiv240200929A" ]
29163268
2406.05047
The dark energy survey: detection of weak lensing magnification of supernovae and constraints on dark matter haloes
The residuals of the distance moduli of Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) relative to a Hubble diagram fit contain information about the inhomogeneity of the Universe, due to weak lensing magnification by foreground matter. By correlating the residuals of the Dark Energy Survey Year 5 SN Ia sample (DES-SN5YR) with extragalactic foregrounds from the DES Y3 Gold catalogue, we detect the presence of lensing at $6.0 \sigma$ significance. This is the first detection with a significance level above $5\sigma$. Constraints on the effective mass-to-light ratios and radial profiles of dark matter haloes surrounding individual galaxies are also obtained. We show that the scatter of SNe Ia around the Hubble diagram is reduced by modifying the standardization of the distance moduli to include an easily calculable de-lensing (i.e. environmental) term. We use the de-lensed distance moduli to recompute cosmological parameters derived from SN Ia, finding in Flat wcold dark matter a difference of $\Delta \Omega _{\rm M} = +0.036$ and $\Delta w = -0.056$ compared to the unmodified distance moduli, a change of $\sim 0.3\sigma$. We argue that our modelling of SN Ia lensing will lower systematics on future surveys with higher statistical power. We use the observed dispersion of lensing in DES-SN5YR to constrain $\sigma _8$, but caution that the fit is sensitive to uncertainties at small scales. Nevertheless, our detection of SN Ia lensing opens a new pathway to study matter inhomogeneity that complements galaxy-galaxy lensing surveys and has unrelated systematics.
[ 0.01837785728275776, 0.02885383367538452, -0.023083066567778587, -0.015241050161421299, 0.006177833303809166, -0.00363067421130836, -0.01251130923628807, -0.005558254197239876, -0.02145479992032051, 0.003986857365816832, -0.0567498654127121, 0.02307109348475933, -0.08783058822154999, -0.027225567027926445, 0.04932688549160957, 0.0541159026324749, -0.015731925144791603, 0.0567498654127121, -0.028829889371991158, 0.021335074678063393, -0.009482256136834621, 0.01200846303254366, 0.023358436301350594, -0.0077222916297614574, 0.009793542325496674, -0.02043713442981243, 0.028135480359196663, 0.01125419232994318, 0.057659778743982315, -0.011110521852970123, -0.019072264432907104, -0.029476406052708626, -0.04283776506781578, -0.007997659966349602, -0.05483425781130791, 0.08945886045694351, 0.02126323990523815, 0.028470711782574654, -0.0430532731115818, -0.008859683759510517, -0.029883472248911858, 0.01253525447100401, -0.032373763620853424, -0.013864207081496716, -0.05813867971301079, -0.03768957033753395, -0.010871071368455887, -0.030410263687372208, -0.018952539190649986, 0.0005956341046839952, -0.06398127973079681, 0.014163521118462086, 0.005378665868192911, -0.006495105568319559, -0.022723890841007233, -0.012762732803821564, 0.044513922184705734, 0.02521418035030365, -0.01619885303080082, -0.026315653696656227, 0.012427501380443573, -0.020951954647898674, -0.019180016592144966, -0.014738203026354313, -0.01589953899383545, -0.004717182833701372, 0.0051990775391459465, 0.006153888069093227, -0.004513649269938469, 0.030075034126639366, 0.01777922920882702, 0.022376686334609985, -0.017420053482055664, -0.027800248935818672, -0.013481086120009422, 0.035941582173109055, 0.018174324184656143, 0.02182595059275627, -0.013097964227199554, 0.02059277705848217, 0.010475977323949337, 0.030003197491168976, -0.041161611676216125, 0.004663306288421154, -0.05167350545525551, -0.0045824917033314705, 0.016366468742489815, 0.0029108249582350254, -0.05971905589103699, 0.023981008678674698, 0.011038686148822308, -0.01439099945127964, -0.017336245626211166, -0.023585913702845573, -0.024807114154100418, -0.0333794541656971, 0.016246743500232697, -0.040299586951732635, 0.07988081872463226, 0.006031169556081295, 0.022616136819124222, 0.05651041120290756, 0.026698775589466095, -0.09070400148630142, 0.05900070071220398, 0.01488187350332737, 0.014678340405225754, -0.03814452886581421, -0.012702870182693005, 0.022616136819124222, 0.08232322335243225, 0.026363544166088104, -0.02475922368466854, 0.035797908902168274, -0.03364285081624985, -0.00505540706217289, -0.05933593213558197, 0.026243818923830986, -0.014007877558469772, -0.009572049602866173, 0.008650164119899273, -0.009446337819099426, 0.028877777978777885, 0.0224006325006485, 0.026100147515535355, -0.07341564446687698, -0.00021400924015324563, -0.028542546555399895, -0.034480929374694824, -0.020748421549797058, 0.04226308315992355, -0.011661258526146412, 0.04257437214255333, 0.011475684121251106, -0.0599106140434742, 0.0013888152316212654, 0.002427433617413044, -0.052439749240875244, -0.004806976765394211, 0.023095039650797844, -0.0002589062787592411, 0.02667483128607273, 0.030482100322842598, 0.021275212988257408, 0.0484888069331646, -0.004561539739370346, -0.014259301126003265, -0.007416991516947746, 0.01969483681023121, 0.04444208741188049, 0.000367781613022089, -0.007440936751663685, -0.008249083533883095, -0.06771671772003174, -0.027417128905653954, -0.05440324544906616, 0.0004074406751897186, 0.003870125161483884, 0.013038101606070995, -0.014379026368260384, -0.01969483681023121, 0.027608688920736313, 0.013768427073955536, 0.008135344833135605, -0.009548104368150234, 0.03345129266381264, 0.016749590635299683, -0.022364715114235878, -0.06838718056678772, -0.023945089429616928, -0.03431331366300583, 0.04626191407442093, 0.012391583994030952, -0.0551694892346859, 0.020161766558885574, 0.04554356262087822, 0.0005604647449217737, -0.011266164481639862, -0.00836282316595316, -0.006321503780782223, 0.0055013843812048435, 0.04494493454694748, -0.029931362718343735, -0.019742727279663086, -0.03239770606160164, 0.008590301498770714, -0.033571016043424606, 0.07173948734998703, 0.04453786835074425, -0.026100147515535355, 0.03658809885382652, 0.007249376270920038, 0.00928470864892006, 0.03761773556470871, -0.026507215574383736, 0.002737223170697689, -0.018102487549185753, 0.03893471509218216, -0.04288565739989281, -0.009416406974196434, 0.02746501751244068, -0.0015077923890203238, 0.03503166511654854, -0.03819241747260094, -0.038048747926950455, -0.04487309977412224, 0.030075034126639366, 0.013133881613612175, 0.0015713965985924006, 0.03371468558907509, 0.011810915544629097, -0.010703455656766891, 0.057995010167360306, -0.008590301498770714, -0.02431623823940754, 0.009135051630437374, -0.041281335055828094, -0.007800112944096327, 0.03893471509218216, 0.04681264981627464, -0.01751583255827427, 0.02329857274889946, 0.04032353311777115, 0.0008380781509913504, 0.014810038730502129, 0.008410712704062462, 0.04628586024045944, 0.016510140150785446, -0.031463850289583206, 0.010883043520152569, 0.024855002760887146, 0.0358458012342453, -0.031128617003560066, 0.026914281770586967, -0.00765644246712327, -0.005935389082878828, -0.03170330077409744, 0.006123956758528948, -0.02194567583501339, -0.021933702751994133, -0.011188343167304993, 0.010972837917506695, -0.019323688000440598, 0.052774976938962936, -0.036348648369312286, 0.02547757513821125, 0.001556430826894939, 0.011679218150675297, -0.0034121754579246044, 0.017012987285852432, 0.0215266365557909, -0.007129650563001633, 0.04611824452877045, -0.06196989491581917, -0.019215933978557587, -0.0014748679241165519, -0.06493908166885376, 0.04903954640030861, -0.014618477784097195, 0.026052258908748627, -0.015444583259522915, -0.03292449936270714, -0.022568248212337494, 0.019515248015522957, -0.0049865650944411755, -0.00882975198328495, 0.0281115360558033, 0.006363407708704472, -0.014941736124455929, -0.010619647800922394, -0.02092800848186016, -0.013253607787191868, 0.024412019178271294, -0.015516418032348156, -0.03009897843003273, 0.03591763600707054, -0.009703747928142548, 0.018916621804237366, 0.026483269408345222, -0.045112550258636475, 0.015827704221010208, -0.008410712704062462, 0.018581390380859375, 0.0743255615234375, -0.03773746266961098, 0.005396624561399221, -0.042861711233854294, -0.017575696110725403, -0.03998830169439316, -0.029787691310048103, 0.05023679882287979, -0.0556962788105011, 0.0011037189979106188, 0.006525036878883839, -0.059048593044281006, -0.010553798638284206, 0.01253525447100401, 0.02976374700665474, -0.041616566479206085, 0.01785106398165226, 0.01946735754609108, 0.02950035035610199, -0.004187397658824921, -0.011852819472551346, -0.047554947435855865, 0.017180602997541428, 0.0469084307551384, -0.006435242947191, 0.0063035450875759125, 0.06053318828344345, 0.041353169828653336, -0.005686958786100149, -0.020341353490948677, 0.022556275129318237, -0.009081175550818443, -0.025357849895954132, -0.024292293936014175, 0.05114671215415001, 0.032780829817056656, -0.03737828508019447, -0.03946150839328766, 0.014067740179598331, -0.00560913747176528, -0.028494657948613167, -0.006884213536977768, -0.027800248935818672, 0.01581573113799095, 0.004962619859725237, -0.039964355528354645, 0.009649870917201042, 0.009176955558359623, 0.01212220173329115, 0.03915022313594818, 0.021406911313533783, -0.005151187535375357, -0.05325388163328171, -0.006489119492471218, 0.044801265001297, -0.01316979993134737, -0.017791202291846275, -0.01281062327325344, 0.0041335211135447025, 0.03148779273033142, -0.025597302243113518, 0.02566913701593876, -0.00426521897315979, 0.01593545824289322, 0.0011546022724360228, 0.02205342799425125, -0.00190962094347924, -0.01927579753100872, 0.007698346395045519, 0.03359496220946312, 0.009141038171947002, 0.04106583073735237, -0.018844785168766975, 0.013241634704172611, -0.06532220542430878, -0.02013782039284706, -0.01668972708284855, 0.014762148261070251, -0.025908587500452995, 0.047363389283418655, -0.0052948580123484135, 0.002563621150329709, -0.006082052830606699, 0.004842894617468119, 0.013445167802274227, -0.00040556996827945113, -0.04580695927143097, 0.025046564638614655, 0.04705210402607918, -0.013852234929800034, 0.012822595424950123, -0.059766944497823715, 0.002994632814079523, 0.0012818105751648545, 0.006991966161876917, 0.02183792181313038, -0.007393046747893095, 0.02705795131623745, -0.0011837853817269206, 0.01114045362919569, -0.05789922922849655, 0.021969620138406754, 0.008997367694973946, 0.010924947448074818, -0.02224498800933361, -0.06479541212320328, -0.02983558177947998, -0.02990741841495037, -0.031846970319747925, 0.00836282316595316, 0.008997367694973946, -0.013840261846780777, -0.00686625437811017, 0.040754541754722595, 0.047028157860040665, 0.0347922146320343, 0.01214016042649746, 0.003478024387732148, -0.03407386317849159, -0.029739802703261375, -0.06948865205049515, -0.05880914255976677, -0.006351435091346502, 0.012499337084591389, 0.041951797902584076, 0.0414728969335556, 0.011122494004666805, 0.014355081133544445, -0.03457671031355858, 0.01698904111981392, -0.07312830537557602, -0.0018991449614986777, 0.010607674717903137, 0.0015998313901945949, 0.017647530883550644, 0.019000429660081863, 0.03498377650976181, 0.018725059926509857, -0.012391583994030952, -0.00029613342485390604, -0.009494228288531303, -0.027967864647507668, 0.00961994007229805, -0.012229954823851585, 0.04772256314754486, 0.020113876089453697, -0.0036037361714988947, -0.03512744605541229, 0.05100304260849953, 0.03843186795711517, -0.017683448269963264, -0.01976667158305645, -0.018880704417824745, 0.029452461749315262, 0.004756093490868807, 0.0217900313436985, -0.0030006191227585077, 0.04219124838709831, -0.005555260926485062, -0.011739080771803856, -0.06551376730203629, 0.035869743674993515, 0.016103073954582214, 0.04422658309340477, 0.0036037361714988947, 0.027034007012844086, -0.012619062326848507, -0.0005387645214796066, 0.002425936982035637, 0.025190234184265137, -0.020975898951292038, -0.05900070071220398, -0.038719210773706436, -0.02025754563510418, -0.02190975658595562, 0.04587879404425621, -0.025118399411439896, -0.010631619952619076, 0.02426834963262081, -0.017875010147690773, 0.04460970312356949, -0.01777922920882702, 0.01593545824289322, -0.004298143554478884, 0.02514234557747841, -0.01527696754783392, 0.011894723400473595, 0.006219737231731415, -0.03498377650976181, 0.04077848792076111, -0.003828221233561635, 0.0011822888627648354, -0.0057528079487383366, -0.02588464319705963, -0.02043713442981243, 0.06369394063949585, 0.051481943577528, 0.03610919415950775, -0.016330551356077194, -0.039581235498189926, 0.013816316612064838, 0.05100304260849953, 0.013409250415861607, -0.008482548408210278, 0.009991088882088661, -0.03728250414133072, -0.012391583994030952, -0.043532174080610275, -0.03919811174273491, 0.028997505083680153, -0.010912975296378136, -0.01830602064728737, -0.00537267979234457, -0.01356489397585392, -0.005255947355180979, -0.0332118384540081, 0.03697121888399124, 0.07949770241975784, -0.041544731706380844, 0.022460494190454483, 0.01003299281001091, 0.04310116171836853, 0.0024708339478820562, -0.020389243960380554, -0.013433195650577545, -0.05813867971301079, 0.02043713442981243, -0.06173044070601463, 0.09592403471469879, 0.003735434031113982, 0.0039718919433653355, -0.01799473538994789, 0.0033702715300023556, -0.01634252443909645, 0.010793249122798443, 0.008195207454264164, -0.003708495758473873, 0.0363725908100605, -0.03991646692156792, 0.02751290798187256, -0.0014748679241165519, 0.012355666607618332, -0.01713271252810955, 0.00007669911428820342, -0.07150004059076309, -0.005270912777632475, 0.002458861330524087, -0.013313470408320427, -0.0358458012342453, -0.0009720210218802094, 0.01758766919374466, -0.03081733174622059, -0.031104672700166702, -0.0045375945046544075, -0.004307122901082039, 0.0103682242333889, -0.006608844734728336, 0.028422821313142776, 0.008285000920295715, -0.0010692978976294398, -0.026363544166088104, 0.018844785168766975, 0.01336135994642973, 0.011445753276348114, 0.005354720633476973, 0.031176507472991943, 0.04396318644285202, 0.012978238984942436, 0.012229954823851585, -0.0029617082327604294, 0.02198159322142601, -0.024567661806941032, 0.030458154156804085, 0.00016911220154725015, 0.0002095195377478376, -0.005633082240819931, 0.028805943205952644, -0.022304851561784744, -0.013421223498880863, -0.024974729865789413, 0.06321503967046738, -0.007907865568995476, -0.04611824452877045, 0.014594532549381256, -0.004513649269938469, 0.005127242300659418, 0.03134412318468094, -0.03998830169439316, -0.014235355891287327, -0.009117092937231064, -0.02032938227057457, -0.005564240273088217, 0.01243947446346283, -0.012798651121556759, 0.0016192867187783122, 0.018808867782354355, -0.010577743873000145, -0.0169531237334013, -0.01006891019642353, 0.007387060206383467, 0.025788862258195877, -0.057659778743982315, 0.002204444957897067, -0.016581974923610687, 0.020077958703041077, 0.012547227554023266, -0.011092563159763813, 0.026555104181170464, -0.02375352941453457, 0.010727399960160255, 0.015324858017265797, -0.004304130095988512, -0.02983558177947998, 0.026770610362291336, -0.010170676745474339, 0.02022162824869156, -0.021323103457689285, -0.006692652590572834, -0.01082318089902401, 0.01825813204050064, -0.03979673981666565, 0.011020727455615997, 0.0014232363319024444, 0.025381796061992645, -0.042813822627067566, -0.015600225888192654, -0.01706087589263916, -0.01369659136980772, 0.01716862991452217, 0.005522336345165968, -0.012631035409867764, -0.00248879287391901, 0.016222799196839333, 0.015947429463267326, -0.013900124467909336, 0.031966693699359894, -0.02528601512312889, -0.010721414349973202, -0.0046782721765339375, -0.020018095150589943, 0.023310545831918716, 0.054499026387929916, 0.012068325653672218, -0.01852152682840824, -0.04336455836892128, -0.020568832755088806, -0.026483269408345222, 0.008458603173494339, -0.014941736124455929, 0.032780829817056656, -0.03036237508058548, -0.011134467087686062, 0.011421808041632175, -0.009141038171947002, 0.017264410853385925, -0.02134704776108265, -0.03381046652793884, 0.010565770789980888, -0.02017373777925968, 0.05588784068822861, -0.02863832749426365, 0.005369686521589756, 0.010930933989584446, 0.020868146792054176, -0.0030529990326613188, -0.044777318835258484, -0.03412175178527832, -0.003621694864705205, 0.0015444583259522915, -0.0013521492946892977, 0.03716278076171875, 0.03768957033753395, -0.002373557072132826, 0.01980258896946907, 0.00839874055236578, -0.03460065647959709, -0.031320177018642426, -0.012738787569105625, 0.017707394436001778, -0.01612701825797558, -0.021335074678063393, 0.01690523326396942, -0.022903479635715485, 0.006926117464900017, -0.002934770192950964, 0.014594532549381256, -0.012643007561564445, 0.031583573669195175, -0.009679802693426609, 0.04283776506781578, 0.014666367322206497, -0.006638776045292616, 0.00229723216034472, 0.02375352941453457, 0.0018901654984802008, -0.024004952982068062, 0.021179432049393654, -0.010027006268501282, -0.0022687972523272038, 0.007189513184130192, -0.038910772651433945, -0.021885812282562256, 0.02423243038356304, 0.015923485159873962, 0.014570587314665318, -0.03852764889597893, 0.017503861337900162, 0.0023121978156268597, -0.0347922146320343, 0.045232273638248444, -0.014343108981847763, 0.03661204129457474, -0.0019859459716826677, -0.0009084168705157936, -0.005022482480853796, 0.03407386317849159, -0.037521954625844955, 0.009428379125893116, -0.014905818738043308, 0.006135929375886917, -0.026171984151005745, -0.023083066567778587, -0.011463711969554424, -0.02408876083791256, 0.005483425687998533, 0.08007238060235977, 0.004004816524684429, 0.05478636547923088, -0.00768637377768755, -0.039772793650627136, 0.010027006268501282, 0.02619592845439911, -0.011619354598224163, 0.003002115758135915, 0.024412019178271294, -0.027560798451304436, -0.018401801586151123, -0.019826535135507584, -0.035342954099178314, -0.0400601364672184, 0.01078127697110176, 0.038383979350328445, 0.0018707101698964834, -0.0405869260430336, 0.015145269222557545, 0.0038342075422406197, 0.005381659138947725, -0.014929763972759247, 0.0036695851013064384, -0.012014448642730713, 0.0014127603499218822, -0.017216520383954048, 0.01992231421172619, -0.017575696110725403, -0.008249083533883095, -0.003142793197184801, 0.035342954099178314, 0.024591607972979546, 0.006764487829059362, 0.012086284346878529, 0.012499337084591389, 0.028662273660302162, -0.009404433891177177, 0.013780399225652218, -0.013552920892834663, 0.004292157478630543, -0.02287953346967697, -0.004381951410323381, 0.008751930668950081, -0.009081175550818443, -0.02588464319705963, 0.0006420277059078217, -0.012978238984942436, 0.021885812282562256, -0.01296626590192318, 0.03991646692156792, 0.0038222349248826504, 0.01777922920882702, 0.01627068966627121, 0.02431623823940754, 0.01326557993888855, 0.022915450856089592, 0.032182201743125916, -0.06881818920373917, 0.008285000920295715, 0.006710611749440432, -0.023358436301350594, -0.002177506685256958, 0.02396903559565544, -0.00993721280246973, 0.02923695556819439, 0.05588784068822861, -0.013253607787191868, -0.021466773003339767, 0.00263096671551466, -0.009153010323643684, -0.018557444214820862, 0.0021400924306362867, -0.024028897285461426, 0.04314905405044556, -0.016222799196839333, -0.008279015310108662, 0.00039733885205350816, 0.01011081412434578, -0.02153860777616501, 0.01296626590192318, -0.0005967565230093896, -0.019227907061576843, -0.0012159616453573108, 0.01623477041721344, 0.011182357557117939, -0.002970687812194228, 0.042933546006679535, -0.016629865393042564, -0.06857873499393463, 0.042813822627067566, 0.026243818923830986, 0.007997659966349602, 0.008835738524794579, 0.038767099380493164, -0.015121323987841606, 0.03002714365720749, -0.022903479635715485, 0.0036815577186644077, 0.01690523326396942, 0.011487657204270363, -0.01743202656507492, 0.0379529669880867, -0.0015534376725554466, -0.025118399411439896, -0.02739318273961544, 0.012235941365361214, -0.016977068036794662, 0.024076787754893303, 0.007416991516947746, 0.030937056988477707, 0.007973714731633663, -0.011828874237835407, -0.029596131294965744, -0.006764487829059362, -0.040491148829460144, -0.015193159691989422, 0.029021449387073517, -0.013313470408320427, -0.023657748475670815, 0.008488534018397331, -0.01788698323071003, 0.010972837917506695, -0.014666367322206497, -0.01637844182550907, 0.006788433063775301, 0.031966693699359894, -0.023538023233413696, 0.0012743277475237846, -0.01995823346078396, -0.01006891019642353, -0.008769889362156391, 0.023118983954191208, 0.012678924947977066, 0.02070053108036518, -0.00084780587349087, -0.006644762586802244, 0.01012877281755209, 0.0056031509302556515, 0.0024902892764657736, 0.03333156555891037, -0.006979994010180235, 0.015887567773461342, -0.006037155631929636, -0.00381924188695848, 0.006339462473988533, 0.019599055871367455, -0.020042041316628456, -0.043196942657232285, -0.039437562227249146, 0.0013753460953012109, 0.0000036098861073696753, -0.016749590635299683, -0.05564839020371437, 0.0033283676020801067, -0.019754698500037193, 0.005115269683301449, 0.02096392586827278, -0.029093284159898758, -0.014510724693536758, 0.04580695927143097, 0.013612783513963223, 0.015600225888192654, -0.002057781210169196, -0.023992979899048805, -0.018581390380859375, -0.006626803893595934, -0.04185601696372032, 0.029859527945518494, 0.012954293750226498, -0.028470711782574654, -0.02235274203121662, -0.005456487648189068, -0.024412019178271294, 0.025190234184265137, -0.007883921265602112, 0.0092248460277915, -0.01837785728275776, 0.014319163747131824, 0.005163160152733326, -0.010559785179793835, 0.038838937878608704, 0.0076205250807106495, -0.019335661083459854, -0.01698904111981392, -0.01121827494353056, -0.04434630647301674, 0.011296096257865429, 0.022041454911231995, 0.011972544714808464, 0.0010438562603667378, -0.036204975098371506, -0.018832813948392868, 0.011194329708814621, 0.017264410853385925, 0.0002327163383597508, 0.0363725908100605, 0.013253607787191868, 0.05028469115495682, 0.021849894896149635, 0.0042173289693892, -0.00811738520860672, 0.050715699791908264, 0.022149208933115005, -0.02104773372411728, -0.025262070819735527, -0.006441229023039341, 0.03855159506201744, -0.020425161346793175, 0.008075481280684471, 0.006273613777011633, -0.029667966067790985, -0.005082345567643642, 0.015288939699530602, -0.021514663472771645, 0.007141623180359602, -0.018174324184656143, -0.045639343559741974, 0.0101467315107584, -0.019072264432907104, -0.011583437211811543, 0.04257437214255333, -0.021299157291650772, -0.007991673424839973, -0.013840261846780777, 0.020245574414730072, 0.028422821313142776, 0.009272736497223377, 0.016857342794537544, 0.014714257791638374, 0.005585192237049341, -0.0013094971654936671, 0.02667483128607273, -0.010314347222447395, 0.0026728706434369087, 0.0015010578790679574, -0.025501521304249763, 0.009200900793075562, 0.03948545455932617, -0.003501969389617443, -0.0024663442745804787, -0.01991034299135208, 0.008584314957261086, 0.026650885120034218, -0.006932103540748358, 0.03460065647959709, -0.03292449936270714, 0.0026025320403277874, 0.03345129266381264, -0.004606436938047409, -0.001824316568672657, -0.003313401946797967, -0.00008595913095632568, -0.004878812003880739, 0.04580695927143097, -0.026746666058897972, -0.005312816705554724, -0.02930879034101963, -0.011002768762409687, 0.00583362253382802, -0.054355353116989136, -0.02454371750354767, 0.022520357742905617, -0.009440352208912373, -0.001994925318285823, -0.01980258896946907, 0.03912627696990967, 0.01739610731601715, -0.031200451776385307, -0.01251130923628807, -0.015360775403678417, 0.004205356352031231, -0.016282660886645317, 0.03809664025902748, 0.03735433891415596, 0.0031068753451108932, 0.002271790523082018, 0.03503166511654854, 0.03723461553454399, -0.0062137506902217865, 0.04765072837471962, -0.01574389636516571, 0.033762577921152115, 0.020580805838108063, 0.006525036878883839, -0.03345129266381264, 0.046836595982313156, -0.028063645586371422, -0.0012129684910178185, -0.042406756430864334, -0.008913559839129448, -0.009039271622896194, 0.00930266734212637, 0.009344571270048618, -0.0281115360558033, 0.005902464501559734, -0.021275212988257408, 0.004001823253929615, -0.035534512251615524, 0.01209825649857521, -0.011972544714808464, 0.027034007012844086, 0.011457725428044796, 0.07039856165647507, -0.05775555595755577, 0.04772256314754486, -0.01557628158479929, -0.03325973078608513, -0.028877777978777885, 0.049135323613882065, -0.04331666976213455, 0.005312816705554724, 0.07509180158376694, -0.04738733172416687, 0.02247246727347374, 0.017527805641293526, -0.004013795871287584, -0.016749590635299683, 0.00010017652675742283, 0.034887995570898056, -0.021658334881067276, -0.0168693158775568, -0.013097964227199554, -0.024591607972979546, -0.00759059377014637, 0.021670306101441383, -0.02408876083791256, -0.007770181633532047, -0.00956007745116949, 0.046166133135557175, -0.03340340033173561, -0.0037444133777171373, -0.005770766641944647, -0.0010528357233852148, 0.013038101606070995, 0.007416991516947746, -0.023095039650797844, 0.022616136819124222, 0.012188050895929337, 0.012211996130645275, 0.011379904113709927, -0.030242647975683212, 0.026243818923830986, -0.01630660705268383, 0.01585165038704872, 0.00640531163662672, 0.018533499911427498, 0.02633959986269474, -0.0029721842147409916, -0.0009278722573071718, 0.007895893417298794, -0.027441073209047318, 0.0006760746473446488, -0.012990211136639118, -0.01706087589263916, -0.025262070819735527, 0.04013197124004364, 0.01439099945127964, -0.0038850908167660236, 0.0029138182289898396, -0.004444807302206755, 0.03747406601905823, 0.018401801586151123, 0.0008111399365589023, 0.025764916092157364, 0.009392461739480495, -0.012056352570652962, -0.008985395543277264, -0.011547519825398922, -0.0019664906430989504, -0.036540206521749496, -0.00803956389427185, -0.014702285639941692, 0.010930933989584446, -0.024328211322426796, 0.0026878362987190485, 0.022364715114235878, 0.06742937117815018, 0.009212873876094818, -0.02938062511384487, 0.032565321773290634, 0.0358458012342453, 0.0036695851013064384, -0.013552920892834663, -0.020532915368676186, 0.017240464687347412, 0.009440352208912373, 0.03563029319047928, -0.0036875437945127487, -0.02878199890255928, -0.019670890644192696, 0.015420638024806976, -0.016210826113820076, 0.010416113771498203, -0.007758209016174078, -0.02475922368466854, -0.002478316891938448, -0.01822221279144287, -0.001509288907982409, 0.02036529965698719, -0.0027072918601334095, 0.007812085561454296, -0.0055522676557302475, -0.022951368242502213, -0.038838937878608704, 0.006471160799264908, 0.03378652408719063, 0.028303096070885658, 0.007674401625990868, -0.030673660337924957, 0.01567206159234047, 0.056414633989334106, 0.018126433715224266, -0.014343108981847763, 0.0012226961553096771, 0.00540261110290885, -0.028662273660302162, 0.010296388529241085, 0.039174169301986694, 0.015121323987841606, 0.01395998802036047, 0.01904832012951374, -0.010038979351520538, -0.03361890837550163, 0.04312510788440704, -0.004313109442591667, -0.0032146284356713295, 0.02581280656158924, 0.016222799196839333, -0.0034720380790531635, 0.01120031625032425, -0.017503861337900162, -0.026483269408345222, 0.012211996130645275, 0.0001753790711518377, 0.0026983122806996107, 0.013481086120009422, -0.009895308874547482, 0.011379904113709927, 0.053637001663446426, -0.017803175374865532, 0.03783324360847473, 0.000869506096933037, 0.018066570162773132, -0.005582198966294527, -0.003912029322236776, 0.03438514843583107, -0.002228389959782362, -0.012643007561564445, 0.020425161346793175, 0.007321211509406567, -0.018461665138602257, 0.04592668265104294, -0.001737515558488667, 0.03258926793932915, -0.004860853310674429, 0.01251130923628807, 0.005270912777632475, 0.016294633969664574, -0.011936627328395844, 0.02329857274889946, -0.02502261847257614, 0.004516642540693283, -0.003175717545673251, 0.002176010049879551, -0.012427501380443573, 0.02085617370903492, 0.011523574590682983, 0.008626218885183334, -0.007237403653562069, -0.007357128895819187, -0.0005892736953683197, -0.015444583259522915, -0.017240464687347412, -0.011828874237835407, 0.011164397932589054, 0.031032836064696312, 0.0039269947446882725, -0.025381796061992645, 0.05737243592739105, -0.028063645586371422, 0.011343986727297306, -0.004052706528455019, -0.016558030620217323, 0.01003299281001091, -0.014738203026354313, 0.008632205426692963, 0.022340768948197365, -0.02401692606508732, -0.017491888254880905, 0.01781514659523964, 0.008961450308561325, -0.002149071777239442, 0.008482548408210278, -0.010230539366602898, 0.009410420432686806, 0.000668591819703579, 0.016486193984746933, -0.026219874620437622, -0.01901240088045597, -0.02581280656158924, -0.043580062687397, 0.05205662548542023, 0.029787691310048103, -0.004121548496186733, -0.0032625184394419193, -0.003475031116977334, -0.010296388529241085, -0.01736018992960453, -0.02111957035958767, -0.008237111382186413, -0.007877934724092484, -0.00809942651540041, 0.005246968008577824, 0.0003434623940847814, -0.025333905592560768, 0.006088039372116327, -0.024364128708839417, 0.01042808685451746, 0.0031876901630312204, 0.023801419883966446, 0.00995517149567604, 0.04156867787241936, -0.013433195650577545, -0.022867560386657715, 0.011493642814457417, -0.00721345841884613, -0.02412467822432518, -0.0009001857251860201, -0.020089929923415184, 0.004615416284650564, 0.006997952703386545, 0.025717027485370636, 0.025262070819735527, 0.017791202291846275, 0.012164105661213398, 0.004319095518440008, 0.018557444214820862, -0.008991381153464317, 0.0012286824639886618, 0.026555104181170464, 0.024040870368480682, -0.01660591922700405, 0.02521418035030365, 0.019036347046494484, -0.021287186071276665, -0.07461290061473846, -0.010793249122798443, -0.024136651307344437, 0.01452269684523344, -0.005121256224811077, 0.004717182833701372, -0.025764916092157364, -0.02957218699157238, 0.012128188274800777, 0.012487364932894707, -0.02547757513821125, -0.02588464319705963, -0.02540574036538601, 0.006608844734728336, -0.0029123215936124325, -0.01690523326396942, 0.00017397604824509472, -0.041544731706380844, -0.04046720266342163, -0.003142793197184801, -0.019862452521920204, 0.011517588049173355, 0.05536104738712311, -0.005944368429481983, 0.008171262219548225, 0.005962327588349581, -0.0032804773654788733, -0.0021804997231811285, 0.007560661993920803, 0.013900124467909336, -0.03517533838748932, 0.013181772083044052, 0.009853404946625233, 0.014187466353178024, -0.03009897843003273, -0.03675571456551552, -0.028231261298060417, -0.01198451779782772, -0.01373250875622034, -0.02633959986269474, -0.010386182926595211, 0.003259525401517749, -0.02314293012022972, -0.00498955836519599, 0.001954518025740981, -0.005489411763846874, 0.0007538961945101619, 0.028805943205952644, -0.014558615162968636, -0.0296919122338295, -0.005070372950285673, -0.02217315323650837, 0.008751930668950081, -0.016150962561368942, 0.022197099402546883, -0.00800364650785923, 0.01781514659523964, 0.0472676083445549, -0.011960572563111782, -0.024639498442411423, -0.01574389636516571, -0.00952416006475687, 0.023945089429616928, -0.008572341874241829, -0.04549567028880119, 0.031511738896369934, -0.02055685967206955, -0.011146439239382744, -0.02554941177368164, -0.017240464687347412, -0.032637156546115875, -0.012547227554023266, 0.003672578139230609, 0.009835445322096348, -0.04856064170598984, 0.009111106395721436, 0.01946735754609108, -0.02514234557747841, -0.004244267009198666, 0.002720760880038142, 0.006513064727187157, 0.007422978058457375, -0.001415005186572671, 0.029667966067790985, 0.023095039650797844, -0.008548397570848465, 0.022316824644804, 0.0066567352041602135, 0.035151392221450806, 0.008656149730086327, -0.05473847687244415, 0.011296096257865429, 0.013948014937341213, -0.024735277518630028, -0.003606729209423065, -0.006644762586802244, -0.025573356077075005, 0.018725059926509857, 0.027536854147911072, 0.03419359028339386, 0.020317409187555313, 0.02791997604072094, 0.015444583259522915, -0.004100596532225609, -0.01336135994642973, 0.005528322886675596, 0.0011216778075322509, 0.027345292270183563, -0.004687251523137093, -0.016845371574163437, 0.01890464872121811, -0.013983932323753834, -0.006019196938723326, 0.04707604646682739, -0.012666952796280384, -0.00435800664126873, 0.040826380252838135, -0.03572607412934303, -0.01634252443909645, 0.06546587496995926, 0.016150962561368942, 0.020269518718123436, 0.031463850289583206, -0.026028312742710114, 0.009841431863605976, -0.0035408802796155214, -0.037066999822854996, -0.02667483128607273, 0.01743202656507492, -0.00967381615191698, 0.022077372297644615, -0.01087705697864294, 0.011978531256318092, 0.020197683945298195, -0.01134997233748436, 0.0120802978053689, 0.0176595039665699, -0.028566492721438408, 0.06714203208684921, 0.024902893230319023, 0.02059277705848217, -0.02791997604072094, 0.03371468558907509, -0.04262226074934006, 0.02006598562002182, -0.003924001473933458, -0.014379026368260384, -0.002436412964016199, -0.009087162092328072, 0.03275688365101814, -0.01322966255247593, -0.010380196385085583, 0.04226308315992355, 0.004549567122012377, 0.01660591922700405, 0.02468738704919815, 0.002514234511181712, 0.01646224968135357, -0.020604750141501427, -0.03381046652793884, 0.0032655117101967335, -0.004953640513122082, -0.02698611654341221, 0.001340924995020032, -0.028805943205952644, 0.005040441639721394, -0.004723168909549713, 0.026483269408345222, 0.027680523693561554, 0.00007646527956239879, -0.027536854147911072, 0.030482100322842598, 0.027872085571289062, 0.013612783513963223, -0.019706809893250465, 0.0029362665954977274, 0.01649816706776619, -0.02017373777925968, 0.006171846762299538, 0.010984810069203377, 0.023023204877972603, -0.013062046840786934, 0.028614383190870285, 0.0225802194327116, 0.010206595063209534, 0.01448677945882082, -0.011595410294830799, -0.011044672690331936, -0.011595410294830799, 0.0023361428175121546, -0.0039030497428029776, 0.020760392770171165, -0.006979994010180235, 0.03723461553454399, 0.004363992717117071, -0.0484888069331646, 0.017635559663176537, 0.0005720631452277303, 0.02043713442981243, -0.017012987285852432, -0.02224498800933361, -0.002815044717863202, -0.016019266098737717, -0.023322517052292824, 0.061012089252471924, -0.026363544166088104, 0.023909172043204308, -0.0039778780192136765, 0.02428032085299492, 0.014103658497333527, 0.04420263692736626, 0.03187091648578644, 0.007830044254660606, 0.005944368429481983, 0.03438514843583107, 0.0070757740177214146, 0.013948014937341213, 0.031846970319747925, 0.0039778780192136765, 0.003036536742001772, -0.007476854603737593, 0.033690743148326874, 0.018533499911427498, 0.01409168541431427, -0.019790617749094963, -0.003621694864705205, 0.002873410703614354, -0.02990741841495037, -0.008919546380639076, 0.00502547575160861, 0.009117092937231064, 0.01488187350332737, -0.028997505083680153, -0.011230247095227242, -0.01597137562930584, 0.011385890655219555, -0.007183527108281851, 0.0034121754579246044, 0.011565478518605232, -0.02897355891764164, -0.008817779831588268, -0.03440909460186958, 0.002360088052228093, -0.010607674717903137, -0.012050366960465908, -0.03419359028339386, -0.03294844552874565, 0.024926839396357536, 0.01829404942691326, 0.03213430941104889, -0.037785351276397705, 0.023286599665880203, -0.009099134244024754, -0.0023181841243058443, -0.00048451393377035856, -0.016103073954582214, 0.01085909828543663, -0.010559785179793835, 0.002942252904176712, 0.04415474459528923, -0.02540574036538601, -0.01987442560493946, -0.007279307581484318, 0.03663598746061325, 0.024807114154100418, -0.01085909828543663, -0.015288939699530602, -0.0030425230506807566, -0.013193744234740734, 0.031846970319747925, 0.006345449015498161, 0.020808283239603043, -0.01042808685451746, 0.03122439794242382, -0.01574389636516571, 0.011367931962013245, -0.020353326573967934, 0.010847126133739948, -0.012714843265712261, 0.010901002213358879, -0.0016372455283999443, -0.006159874610602856 ]
11.154621
2.07478
2024-07-01
1
2024MNRAS.532..932S
[ "SN Ia", "SNe Ia", "Type Ia supernovae", "weak lensing magnification", "dark matter haloes", "Flat wcold dark matter", "matter inhomogeneity", "foreground matter", "SN", "galaxy-galaxy lensing surveys" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
22
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1515", "10.48550/arXiv.2406.05047" ]
[ "Shah, P.", "Davis, T. M.", "Bacon, D.", "Brout, D.", "Frieman, J.", "Galbany, L.", "Kessler, R.", "Lahav, O.", "Lee, J.", "Lidman, C.", "Nichol, R. C.", "Sako, M.", "Sánchez, B. O.", "Scolnic, D.", "Sullivan, M.", "Vincenzi, M.", "Wiseman, P.", "Allam, S.", "Abbott, T. M. C.", "Aguena, M.", "Alves, O.", "Andrade-Oliveira, F.", "Annis, J.", "Bechtol, K.", "Bertin, E.", "Bocquet, S.", "Brooks, D.", "Rosell, A. Carnero", "Carretero, J.", "Castander, F. J.", "da Costa, L. N.", "Pereira, M. E. S.", "Diehl, H. T.", "Doel, P.", "Doux, C.", "Everett, S.", "Ferrero, I.", "Flaugher, B.", "Friedel, D.", "Gatti, M.", "Gruen, D.", "Gruendl, R. A.", "Gutierrez, G.", "Hinton, S. R.", "Hollowood, D. L.", "Honscheid, K.", "Huterer, D.", "James, D. J.", "Kuehn, K.", "Lee, S.", "Marshall, J. L.", "Mena-Fernández, J.", "Miquel, R.", "Myles, J.", "Ogando, R. L. C.", "Palmese, A.", "Pieres, A.", "Roodman, A.", "Sanchez, E.", "Sevilla-Noarbe, I.", "Smith, M.", "Soares-Santos, M.", "Suchyta, E.", "Swanson, M. E. C.", "Tarle, G.", "Weaverdyck, N.", "DES Collaboration" ]
[ "Department of Physics &amp; Astronomy, University College London, Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, UK", "School of Mathematics and Physics, University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD 4072, Australia", "Institute of Cosmology and Gravitation, University of Portsmouth, Portsmouth PO1 3FX, UK", "Department of Astronomy, 725 Commonwealth Avenue, Boston University, Boston, MA 02215, USA", "Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, P. O. Box 500, Batavia, IL 60510, USA; Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL 60637, USA", "Institut d'Estudis Espacials de Catalunya (IEEC), E-08034 Barcelona, Spain; Institute of Space Sciences (ICE, CSIC), Campus UAB, Carrer de Can Magrans, s/n, E-08193 Barcelona, Spain", "Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL 60637, USA; Department of Astronomy and Astrophysics, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL 60637, USA", "Department of Physics &amp; Astronomy, University College London, Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, UK", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA", "Centre for Gravitational Astrophysics, College of Science, The Australian National University, Canberra, ACT 2601, Australia; The Research School of Astronomy and Astrophysics, Australian National University, Canberra, ACT 2601, Australia", "Institute of Cosmology and Gravitation, University of Portsmouth, Portsmouth PO1 3FX, UK", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA", "Department of Physics, Duke University, 120 Science Drive, Durham, NC 27710, USA; CNRS/IN2P3, CPPM, Aix Marseille University, 13007 Marseille, France", "Department of Physics, Duke University, 120 Science Drive, Durham, NC 27710, USA", "School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Southampton, Southampton SO17 1BJ, UK", "Institute of Cosmology and Gravitation, University of Portsmouth, Portsmouth PO1 3FX, UK; School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Southampton, Southampton SO17 1BJ, UK", "School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Southampton, Southampton SO17 1BJ, UK", "Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, P. O. Box 500, Batavia, IL 60510, USA", "Cerro Tololo Inter-American Observatory, NSF's National Optical-Infrared Astronomy Research Laboratory, Casilla 603, La Serena, Chile", "Laboratório Interinstitucional de e-Astronomia - LIneA, Rua Gal. José Cristino 77, Rio de Janeiro, RJ 20921-400, Brazil", "Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA", "Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA", "Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, P. O. Box 500, Batavia, IL 60510, USA", "Physics Department, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2320 Chamberlin Hall, 1150 University Avenue Madison, WI 53706-1390, USA", "CNRS, Institut d'Astrophysique de Paris, UMR 7095, F-75014 Paris, France; Institut d'Astrophysique de Paris, Sorbonne Universités, UPMC Univ Paris 06, UMR 7095, F-75014 Paris, France", "Faculty of Physics, University Observatory, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität, Scheinerstr 1, D-81679 Munich, Germany", "Department of Physics &amp; Astronomy, University College London, Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, UK", "Instituto de Astrofisica de Canarias, E-38205 La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Laboratório Interinstitucional de e-Astronomia - LIneA, Rua Gal. José Cristino 77, Rio de Janeiro, RJ 20921-400, Brazil", "Institut de Física d'Altes Energies (IFAE), The Barcelona Institute of Science and Technology, Campus UAB, E-08193 Bellaterra (Barcelona) Spain", "Institut d'Estudis Espacials de Catalunya (IEEC), E-08034 Barcelona, Spain; Institute of Space Sciences (ICE, CSIC), Campus UAB, Carrer de Can Magrans, s/n, E-08193 Barcelona, Spain", "Laboratório Interinstitucional de e-Astronomia - LIneA, Rua Gal. José Cristino 77, Rio de Janeiro, RJ 20921-400, Brazil", "Hamburger Sternwarte, Universität Hamburg, Gojenbergsweg 112, D-21029 Hamburg, Germany", "Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, P. O. Box 500, Batavia, IL 60510, USA", "Department of Physics &amp; Astronomy, University College London, Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, UK", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA; CNRS, LPSC-IN2P3, Université Grenoble Alpes, F-38000 Grenoble, France", "Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, 4800 Oak Grove Dr, Pasadena, CA 91109, USA", "Institute of Theoretical Astrophysics, University of Oslo, P.O. Box 1029 Blindern, NO-0315 Oslo, Norway", "Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, P. O. Box 500, Batavia, IL 60510, USA", "Center for Astrophysical Surveys, National Center for Supercomputing Applications, 1205 West Clark St, Urbana, IL 61801, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA", "Faculty of Physics, University Observatory, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität, Scheinerstr 1, D-81679 Munich, Germany", "Center for Astrophysical Surveys, National Center for Supercomputing Applications, 1205 West Clark St, Urbana, IL 61801, USA; Department of Astronomy, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 1002 W. Green Street, Urbana, IL 61801, USA", "Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, P. O. Box 500, Batavia, IL 60510, USA", "School of Mathematics and Physics, University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD 4072, Australia", "Santa Cruz Institute for Particle Physics, Santa Cruz, CA 95064, USA", "Center for Cosmology and Astro-Particle Physics, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43210, USA; Department of Physics, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43210, USA", "Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA", "Center for Astrophysics | Harvard &amp; Smithsonian, 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA", "Australian Astronomical Optics, Macquarie University, North Ryde, NSW 2113, Australia; Lowell Observatory, 1400 Mars Hill Rd, Flagstaff, AZ 86001, USA", "Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, 4800 Oak Grove Dr, Pasadena, CA 91109, USA", "George P. and Cynthia Woods Mitchell Institute for Fundamental Physics and Astronomy, and Department of Physics and Astronomy, Texas A&amp;M University, College Station, TX 77843, USA", "LPSC Grenoble - 53, Avenue des Martyrs, F-38026 Grenoble, France", "Institut de Física d'Altes Energies (IFAE), The Barcelona Institute of Science and Technology, Campus UAB, E-08193 Bellaterra (Barcelona) Spain; Institució Catalana de Recerca i Estudis Avançats, E-08010 Barcelona, Spain", "Department of Astrophysical Sciences, Princeton University, Peyton Hall, Princeton, NJ 08544, USA", "Observatório Nacional, Rua Gal. José Cristino 77, Rio de Janeiro, RJ 20921-400, Brazil", "Department of Physics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15312, USA", "Laboratório Interinstitucional de e-Astronomia - LIneA, Rua Gal. José Cristino 77, Rio de Janeiro, RJ 20921-400, Brazil; Observatório Nacional, Rua Gal. José Cristino 77, Rio de Janeiro, RJ 20921-400, Brazil", "Kavli Institute for Particle Astrophysics &amp; Cosmology, P. O. Box 2450, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, USA; SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory, Menlo Park, CA 94025, USA", "Centro de Investigaciones Energéticas, Medioambientales y Tecnológicas (CIEMAT), 28040 Madrid, Spain", "Centro de Investigaciones Energéticas, Medioambientales y Tecnológicas (CIEMAT), 28040 Madrid, Spain", "School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Southampton, Southampton SO17 1BJ, UK", "Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA", "Computer Science and Mathematics Division, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, TN 37831, USA", "Center for Astrophysical Surveys, National Center for Supercomputing Applications, 1205 West Clark St, Urbana, IL 61801, USA", "Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA", "Department of Astronomy, University of California, Berkeley, 501 Campbell Hall, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA; Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 1 Cyclotron Road, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA", "-" ]
[ "2024arXiv240706621T" ]
[ "1973ApJ...180L..31D", "1976ApJ...208L...1W", "1985A&A...143..413S", "1993ApJ...413L.105P", "1996ComAp..18..323F", "1997ApJ...490..493N", "1999ApJ...525..209T", "2000ApJ...534...34W", "2005ApJ...631..678H", "2005MNRAS.362.1451M", "2006ApJ...648..868S", "2007AJ....133..734B", "2008JCAP...08..006M", "2008MNRAS.390L..64D", "2009PASP..121.1028K", "2009PhRvD..80l3020K", "2010A&A...514A..44K", "2010ApJ...715..743K", "2010ApJ...722..566L", "2010MNRAS.405..535J", "2010MNRAS.405.1025M", "2010MNRAS.406..782S", "2011MNRAS.411..584M", "2011PhRvD..83b3009K", "2011PhRvD..84f3004K", "2012MNRAS.420.1239L", "2013PhRvD..88f3004M", "2014ApJ...780...24S", "2014MNRAS.439.2505B", "2015MNRAS.453.4384H", "2015Sci...347.1123K", "2016AJ....152..154G", "2016MNRAS.455.4518K", "2016MNRAS.460.1270D", "2018ApJ...859..101S", "2018ApJ...867...23H", "2019ApJ...873..111I", "2019ApJ...874..106B", "2019ApJ...874..150B", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020A&A...643A.165B", "2020JCAP...10..056H", "2020MNRAS.495.4040W", "2020MNRAS.496...19L", "2020MNRAS.498.1420W", "2021ApJ...923..265K", "2021ApJS..254...24S", "2021MNRAS.502.1401M", "2021MNRAS.505.2819V", "2021MNRAS.505.4626J", "2021NatAs...5.1118R", "2022JHEAp..34...49A", "2022MNRAS.509.3547H", "2022MNRAS.515.2305S", "2022MNRAS.516.5355A", "2022PhRvD.105b3520A", "2023NatAs...7.1098G", "2023OJAp....6E..39A", "2024ApJ...964..134Q", "2024arXiv240102929D", "2024arXiv240102945V", "2024arXiv240605046S" ]
29163209
2406.19264
A Rare, Strong Shock Front in the Merging Cluster SPT-CLJ 2031-4037
We present our findings from the new deep Chandra observations (256 ks) of the merging galaxy cluster SPT-CLJ 2031-4037 at z = 0.34. Our observations reveal intricate structures seen in a major merger akin to the Bullet Cluster. The X-ray data confirm the existence of two shock fronts, one to the northwest and one to the southeast, by directly measuring the temperature jump of gas across the surface brightness edges. The stronger shock front in the northwest has a density jump of 3.16 ± 0.34 across the sharp surface brightness edge and Mach number , which makes this cluster one of the rare merging systems with a Mach number M &gt; 2. We use the northwestern shock to compare two models for shock heating—the instant heating model and the Coulomb collisional heating model—and we determine that the temperatures across the shock front agree with the Coulomb collisional model of heating. For the shock front in the southeastern region, we find a density jump of 1.53 ± 0.14 and a Mach number of .
[ -0.017387958243489265, -0.012219980359077454, -0.010322874411940575, -0.014247921295464039, -0.016118859872221947, 0.022542854771018028, 0.017675796523690224, -0.00007395238208118826, -0.0027099179569631815, -0.025421222671866417, -0.02099900133907795, 0.029437853023409843, -0.08703137934207916, 0.0009510061936452985, 0.005105832125991583, 0.018486972898244858, 0.0005290636327117682, -0.013750748708844185, -0.0029045348055660725, 0.03982614353299141, -0.04063732177019119, -0.03336289897561073, 0.02555205672979355, 0.02162700891494751, -0.03700011223554611, -0.0064272647723555565, -0.00739871384575963, -0.04974343255162239, 0.042573679238557816, -0.002888180548325181, 0.014378756284713745, -0.022843774408102036, -0.029751857742667198, 0.009106108918786049, -0.08865372836589813, 0.06662113219499588, -0.04105599224567413, 0.06620246171951294, -0.05835236608982086, -0.007254795636981726, -0.02455771155655384, 0.04262601211667061, -0.04542588070034981, 0.0461585558950901, -0.0025529160629957914, -0.09357312321662903, -0.044483866542577744, -0.032708726823329926, -0.024165207520127296, -0.018029049038887024, -0.029019182547926903, 0.012403149157762527, -0.010061204433441162, -0.00614269869402051, -0.02750149741768837, 0.0072220866568386555, 0.027135159820318222, 0.030667701736092567, -0.017505710944533348, -0.015412352047860622, 0.03720944747328758, -0.046210888773202896, 0.019716819748282433, -0.015032930299639702, 0.02491096593439579, -0.017963632941246033, 0.013986251316964626, 0.03336289897561073, 0.05898037552833557, 0.0016272590728476644, 0.009662157855927944, -0.008353808894753456, -0.03870096430182457, -0.002767158206552267, 0.025159552693367004, -0.024963300675153732, 0.013076948933303356, -0.0009174797451123595, -0.01539926789700985, 0.005717485211789608, 0.006509036291390657, 0.007110876962542534, 0.020619580522179604, 0.0028145858086645603, -0.032080717384815216, 0.014849761500954628, 0.041396163403987885, 0.020671915262937546, -0.05992238596081734, 0.023484865203499794, -0.011677015572786331, 0.002925795502960682, 0.009675241075456142, -0.02616698108613491, -0.017832797020673752, -0.029856525361537933, -0.008373433724045753, -0.047126732766628265, 0.03864863142371178, 0.011310677044093609, -0.005279188510030508, 0.0335984043776989, 0.05536933243274689, -0.0671968087553978, 0.03723561391234398, -0.04435303434729576, -0.02532963827252388, 0.017950549721717834, 0.02925468422472477, 0.0164459478110075, 0.037758953869342804, 0.049220092594623566, -0.035665594041347504, 0.06280075758695602, -0.033493734896183014, 0.007608049549162388, -0.02399512194097042, 0.017309457063674927, -0.060288723558187485, 0.030144361779093742, -0.019193479791283607, -0.00111127900891006, 0.03825612738728523, -0.00283257570117712, 0.002130973618477583, -0.03354606777429581, 0.06960416585206985, -0.035874929279088974, -0.0440913625061512, -0.0007944132084958255, 0.022163432091474533, -0.021365340799093246, 0.012180729769170284, -0.0227391067892313, -0.03380773961544037, -0.022241933271288872, 0.030118195340037346, -0.0014825230464339256, -0.046577226370573044, -0.03820379078388214, -0.01776738092303276, 0.021797094494104385, 0.027763167396187782, 0.0030533596873283386, -0.0009272923925891519, 0.05421798303723335, -0.03862246498465538, 0.019428983330726624, -0.0118928924202919, -0.01812063343822956, 0.008942565880715847, 0.002489133970811963, 0.025172635912895203, -0.037392616271972656, 0.003378811525180936, -0.04380352422595024, 0.019088812172412872, -0.0011014663614332676, 0.004625014029443264, -0.04801641032099724, -0.00012102228356525302, -0.02679498866200447, -0.027318328619003296, -0.01420867070555687, 0.016773033887147903, -0.0016656918451189995, -0.020815832540392876, 0.006109990179538727, -0.07954762130975723, -0.049167755991220474, 0.004193258471786976, -0.034959085285663605, -0.024335293099284172, -0.017401041463017464, -0.014758177101612091, 0.0029634106904268265, 0.010820046998560429, -0.056991685181856155, -0.032839562743902206, 0.02016165852546692, 0.01699545420706272, 0.045164208859205246, 0.04362035542726517, 0.0041736336424946785, -0.060707394033670425, 0.040140148252248764, -0.012442399747669697, 0.04019248113036156, -0.009387404657900333, -0.025028716772794724, -0.02679498866200447, 0.0043633440509438515, 0.006361847277730703, 0.03577026352286339, 0.015346934087574482, -0.018735557794570923, 0.022856857627630234, -0.021993348374962807, 0.01130413543432951, 0.03317973017692566, 0.005030602216720581, 0.025565139949321747, 0.022477436810731888, -0.004438573960214853, -0.022634439170360565, -0.023890454322099686, 0.023419447243213654, -0.0003644978569354862, -0.014548840932548046, 0.012802195735275745, 0.03409557789564133, -0.02616698108613491, -0.010748087428510189, 0.02400820516049862, 0.005122186616063118, -0.026572568342089653, -0.02896684780716896, 0.018800975754857063, 0.030065860599279404, 0.010761170648038387, 0.025800643488764763, 0.029490187764167786, 0.05693935230374336, 0.030327530577778816, 0.012520899996161461, 0.0475977398455143, 0.028103336691856384, -0.029071515426039696, 0.05225545912981033, 0.027658497914671898, 0.01140880398452282, 0.021443840116262436, -0.01742720976471901, -0.029621021822094917, -0.019023394212126732, 0.010270539671182632, 0.022726023569703102, -0.001120273838751018, 0.01755804382264614, -0.006384743377566338, -0.06081206351518631, 0.027239827439188957, 0.002852200996130705, 0.026821155101060867, 0.005782902706414461, 0.016419781371951103, -0.02238585241138935, 0.005289000924676657, 0.0074379644356667995, 0.02938552014529705, 0.049429427832365036, 0.020344827324151993, -0.020541079342365265, -0.04351568967103958, -0.015477769076824188, -0.03731411322951317, -0.03372923657298088, 0.03948597237467766, -0.01923273131251335, -0.009622907266020775, -0.022241933271288872, -0.006247366778552532, -0.06243441626429558, 0.008942565880715847, -0.04189333692193031, 0.0315050445497036, 0.02700432389974594, 0.009649074636399746, -0.0028015023563057184, -0.025499721989035606, -0.024335293099284172, -0.04171016812324524, 0.059032708406448364, -0.012089145369827747, -0.04770240560173988, 0.004850704222917557, -0.009779908694326878, 0.03276105970144272, 0.03786361962556839, -0.022569021210074425, -0.005210500210523605, -0.0342787466943264, 0.0412914976477623, -0.024583877995610237, -0.014679675921797752, 0.01609269343316555, 0.019690653309226036, 0.0036535647232085466, -0.01706087216734886, -0.007496839854866266, 0.02757999859750271, 0.003311758628115058, -0.015582436695694923, 0.01804213412106037, -0.08106530457735062, -0.03239472210407257, 0.01358066312968731, 0.029359351843595505, -0.024714713916182518, 0.004729681648313999, 0.028077170252799988, -0.008229515515267849, 0.031452711671590805, 0.014718926511704922, 0.022647522389888763, 0.03234238922595978, 0.018944894894957542, 0.002724636811763048, 0.01539926789700985, 0.03226388618350029, -0.015216099098324776, -0.026624903082847595, -0.0070323762483894825, -0.007182836066931486, -0.023550283163785934, -0.00029805826488882303, 0.016916953027248383, 0.038517795503139496, -0.0056226300075650215, 0.007725801318883896, -0.038439296185970306, 0.0016812285175547004, -0.007052001543343067, -0.005462357308715582, 0.000584668479859829, 0.020070074126124382, 0.016681449487805367, -0.05887570604681969, 0.036843109875917435, -0.028103336691856384, 0.03503758832812309, -0.017100121825933456, 0.03129570931196213, -0.04422219842672348, -0.012507816776633263, -0.026899656280875206, 0.054270319640636444, 0.046001553535461426, -0.03354606777429581, -0.032368555665016174, -0.027187492698431015, -0.007653841748833656, 0.020331744104623795, 0.02259518764913082, 0.026821155101060867, 0.018094466999173164, 0.009348154067993164, 0.013489078730344772, 0.053354475647211075, 0.0015561176696792245, -0.009773367084562778, -0.03563942760229111, 0.026899656280875206, 0.010591085068881512, 0.0433848537504673, 0.04767623916268349, -0.031191041693091393, -0.04498104006052017, 0.0019396274583414197, 0.004795099142938852, -0.0029895775951445103, -0.008582769893109798, 0.03802062198519707, 0.032787226140499115, 0.025277303531765938, 0.025565139949321747, -0.06337642669677734, 0.03380773961544037, -0.012802195735275745, -0.024649295955896378, 0.00849772710353136, -0.0033689988777041435, 0.00020841592049691826, 0.014496507123112679, -0.06824348866939545, -0.007653841748833656, 0.07635524868965149, 0.01763654500246048, 0.02665106952190399, 0.024178290739655495, 0.028155671432614326, -0.030065860599279404, -0.006002051290124655, -0.013973168097436428, -0.011572347022593021, -0.018447721377015114, -0.004893225617706776, -0.0014007511781528592, -0.05568333715200424, -0.009577115066349506, -0.007058543153107166, -0.0005523686413653195, 0.02595764584839344, -0.019926156848669052, -0.04696973040699959, 0.03595343232154846, 0.06384743005037308, 0.04333252087235451, -0.0002898810780607164, 0.06594078987836838, -0.037392616271972656, -0.01867014169692993, 0.002603614702820778, -0.0755702406167984, 0.013109656982123852, 0.009276194497942924, -0.03443574532866478, 0.04019248113036156, -0.010597627609968185, -0.044536203145980835, 0.008831355720758438, -0.010865839198231697, 0.022307351231575012, -0.006751080974936485, -0.012795654125511646, 0.03974764421582222, -0.05536933243274689, 0.06468477845191956, -0.017597295343875885, 0.08425767719745636, -0.0023043297696858644, -0.004847433418035507, 0.01228539738804102, 0.04605388641357422, -0.011834017001092434, 0.005311897024512291, 0.021156003698706627, 0.012265772558748722, 0.055526334792375565, -0.034880585968494415, 0.002034482778981328, 0.0213391724973917, 0.005818882491439581, -0.01077425479888916, -0.005305355414748192, 0.06201574578881264, 0.027239827439188957, 0.00008412275201408193, -0.008164098486304283, -0.025159552693367004, -0.014810510911047459, 0.034618914127349854, 0.04505953937768936, -0.009112651459872723, -0.03242088854312897, -0.02016165852546692, 0.048879921436309814, 0.016406696289777756, 0.03749728202819824, -0.03757578507065773, -0.006152511574327946, -0.017479542642831802, 0.015124514698982239, 0.04262601211667061, -0.03168821334838867, -0.01903647929430008, 0.03485441952943802, -0.005570296198129654, 0.016288945451378822, -0.03577026352286339, -0.008602394722402096, 0.021221421658992767, -0.03676460683345795, 0.01979532092809677, -0.05584033578634262, 0.04254751279950142, -0.015569353476166725, 0.01515068206936121, -0.006280075293034315, -0.004369885660707951, -0.0011014663614332676, -0.06913316249847412, 0.02546047233045101, 0.0038367335218936205, -0.013528329320251942, -0.004432032350450754, 0.001996867824345827, -0.0038661714643239975, 0.05913737788796425, 0.00913227628916502, 0.0356917604804039, -0.033127397298812866, 0.004683889448642731, 0.0328657291829586, 0.05058077350258827, 0.025368887931108475, -0.02315777726471424, 0.0025332907680422068, -0.011009757407009602, -0.01931123249232769, 0.019049562513828278, 0.014614258892834187, 0.08012329787015915, -0.013515246100723743, 0.023432532325387, -0.005154895130544901, -0.010617252439260483, -0.01137609500437975, 0.016890786588191986, -0.003398436587303877, 0.04050648584961891, 0.023131610825657845, 0.030065860599279404, -0.06421376764774323, 0.011258343234658241, -0.002772064646705985, -0.03294422850012779, -0.00566842220723629, -0.014666592702269554, -0.01360683050006628, 0.0018791162874549627, 0.05866637080907822, 0.024937132373452187, 0.015621687285602093, -0.00850426871329546, 0.01140880398452282, -0.004235779866576195, 0.050083599984645844, 0.019899988546967506, -0.0021473278757184744, 0.0029895775951445103, -0.02616698108613491, 0.015333850868046284, -0.008242598734796047, -0.00314985029399395, -0.011820933781564236, -0.03582259640097618, -0.08347266912460327, -0.06866215914487839, -0.010414458811283112, -0.009498613886535168, -0.006744539365172386, 0.0007715170504525304, 0.018382303416728973, -0.030693868175148964, -0.01228539738804102, -0.02413903921842575, -0.016275862231850624, -0.023890454322099686, 0.019049562513828278, -0.026847321540117264, 0.03626743704080582, -0.016184277832508087, -0.012802195735275745, 0.02106441929936409, 0.04095132648944855, 0.002953598042950034, -0.016759950667619705, 0.04212883859872818, 0.038439296185970306, 0.05065927654504776, -0.000820171320810914, 0.0171393733471632, 0.01354141253978014, -0.008268766105175018, 0.012416232377290726, -0.00906031671911478, -0.010152788832783699, 0.021718593314290047, -0.0065679121762514114, -0.026899656280875206, -0.028103336691856384, -0.021731678396463394, 0.04275684803724289, -0.02400820516049862, -0.05589267238974571, 0.01074154581874609, -0.030667701736092567, -0.009557490237057209, -0.0011505294824019074, -0.01231156475841999, -0.010885464027523994, 0.006109990179538727, -0.016184277832508087, -0.0039152344688773155, -0.017191706225275993, -0.04799024388194084, 0.007536090444773436, -0.01070229522883892, -0.03037986531853676, -0.0405849888920784, 0.0055637541227042675, 0.012926488183438778, 0.03524692356586456, -0.005890841595828533, 0.015203015878796577, -0.021299922838807106, -0.014391839504241943, 0.0117228077724576, -0.008406142704188824, -0.011114425025880337, -0.028574343770742416, 0.03263022378087044, 0.014692760072648525, 0.005851591005921364, -0.0157394390553236, -0.0021064418833702803, -0.03399090841412544, 0.007078168448060751, -0.00222255801782012, -0.0075295488350093365, 0.015072180889546871, -0.028862180188298225, -0.042521342635154724, -0.009864951483905315, 0.0011587066110223532, 0.016001109033823013, -0.009949994273483753, -0.014692760072648525, 0.02484554797410965, 0.008994899690151215, 0.010054662823677063, 0.0004342083411756903, 0.006391284987330437, 0.014653509482741356, 0.010728462599217892, 0.0032904979307204485, -0.011225635185837746, 0.05215079337358475, 0.0002019763778662309, -0.014287171885371208, -0.007509923540055752, 0.011493846774101257, 0.0032725080382078886, 0.0378112867474556, 0.012547067366540432, -0.025931477546691895, -0.05131344869732857, 0.010028495453298092, 0.014732010662555695, -0.003342831740155816, -0.002997754840180278, 0.03294422850012779, 0.008909856900572777, 0.006253908388316631, -0.006293158978223801, 0.01924581453204155, 0.005841778591275215, -0.02674265392124653, -0.011068632826209068, 0.007542632054537535, 0.03770662099123001, 0.013646080158650875, -0.03401707485318184, -0.0035325423814356327, 0.03304889798164368, -0.0033215710427612066, -0.009341612458229065, -0.01657678186893463, -0.004667535424232483, -0.03030136413872242, -0.01004157867282629, -0.003571792971342802, 0.004886683542281389, 0.017453376203775406, -0.029437853023409843, -0.00324470573104918, -0.0056815058924257755, -0.03338906913995743, 0.025839893147349358, 0.010185496881604195, 0.01638052985072136, 0.011277968995273113, -0.016969287768006325, -0.018997227773070335, 0.021587759256362915, -0.008288390934467316, 0.03338906913995743, -0.007928594946861267, 0.0363982692360878, 0.07813460379838943, 0.009335070848464966, 0.050423771142959595, 0.03702627867460251, 0.008994899690151215, 0.005138541106134653, 0.004903038032352924, -0.018722474575042725, -0.03673844039440155, -0.0006778883398510516, -0.0050665815360844135, 0.007025834172964096, -0.004340447951108217, 0.04259984567761421, 0.012959197163581848, -0.0068753743544220924, -0.013868499547243118, 0.04011398181319237, 0.0004407500964589417, -0.006365118082612753, 0.0026690319646149874, -0.005910466890782118, 0.032996561378240585, -0.007307129446417093, -0.006083823274821043, -0.044745538383722305, -0.006849207449704409, 0.02071116492152214, 0.025028716772794724, -0.0434110201895237, 0.024243708699941635, 0.006155782379209995, 0.037052445113658905, -0.012821820564568043, -0.007987471297383308, -0.026847321540117264, 0.004382969345897436, -0.0018594911089166999, 0.04660339280962944, -0.005462357308715582, 0.04071582108736038, 0.0545843206346035, -0.023968953639268875, 0.001241296180523932, 0.01137609500437975, 0.03626743704080582, -0.0035456258337944746, 0.0454782135784626, -0.03001352772116661, -0.03626743704080582, 0.009341612458229065, -0.026507152244448662, -0.04539971053600311, -0.008321099914610386, 0.018172968178987503, -0.026009978726506233, 0.012233063578605652, 0.011199467815458775, -0.00305172405205667, -0.007464131340384483, 0.01615811139345169, 0.0022618083748966455, -0.02428295835852623, -0.032577890902757645, 0.0005441914545372128, 0.039642974734306335, 0.011186384595930576, 0.0018120633903890848, -0.03140037879347801, 0.0342787466943264, 0.03372923657298088, -0.0181860513985157, 0.02175784483551979, 0.045949216932058334, 0.028731344267725945, 0.013462911359965801, 0.01974298618733883, -0.025290386751294136, -0.004098403267562389, 0.0032496119383722544, 0.01679920218884945, 0.011677015572786331, 0.022974608466029167, -0.002901264000684023, 0.01770196296274662, -0.008975274860858917, -0.006031488999724388, -0.0007261337013915181, 0.033703070133924484, 0.03577026352286339, 0.032996561378240585, 0.01861780695617199, 0.028365006670355797, 0.04309701919555664, 0.005122186616063118, 0.016969287768006325, -0.02322319522500038, -0.012723694555461407, -0.007666925434023142, -0.01360683050006628, -0.018212217837572098, -0.0010221477132290602, 0.030903205275535583, -0.02505488507449627, 0.008478102274239063, -0.0164459478110075, -0.008929482661187649, 0.005972613580524921, -0.03948597237467766, 0.002611791715025902, 0.0009665428660809994, -0.006077281199395657, 0.009472447447478771, -0.04134383052587509, -0.04236434027552605, -0.009151901118457317, -0.00594644621014595, -0.0164459478110075, -0.033833906054496765, -0.0045694089494645596, 0.002827669261023402, 0.003578334581106901, 0.015216099098324776, 0.006257179193198681, 0.02385120280086994, 0.021744761615991592, -0.016459031030535698, -0.09697483479976654, 0.0033657278399914503, 0.030353697016835213, 0.02757999859750271, -0.0014130169292911887, -0.007333296351134777, -0.03126954287290573, -0.009119193069636822, -0.005933362990617752, -0.005452544428408146, 0.03480208292603493, -0.0001006815509754233, -0.00566515140235424, 0.025447389110922813, -0.01699545420706272, -0.025290386751294136, -0.009321986697614193, 0.028312673792243004, 0.0009093025582842529, 0.011349927634000778, -0.006836123764514923, 0.012736777774989605, 0.038308460265398026, 0.0010744816390797496, -0.025565139949321747, -0.004333906341344118, -0.009649074636399746, 0.00475911982357502, 0.019193479791283607, -0.005177791230380535, 0.014025501906871796, -0.006443619262427092, -0.0054656281135976315, 0.03870096430182457, -0.02420445717871189, 0.006322596687823534, -0.027972502633929253, 0.024256791919469833, -0.006172136403620243, -0.03126954287290573, 0.02631090022623539, -0.008674354292452335, 0.03435724601149559, 0.03121720813214779, 0.03092937171459198, -0.012867612764239311, -0.014810510911047459, -0.002477685920894146, 0.03480208292603493, 0.017610378563404083, 0.010551835410296917, 0.012671360746026039, 0.006486140191555023, 0.014117086306214333, 0.009662157855927944, 0.02652023546397686, -0.020043907687067986, -0.009721033275127411, 0.016838451847434044, -0.0004930840223096311, -0.019899988546967506, 0.032918062061071396, 0.019847655668854713, -0.024753963574767113, -0.01755804382264614, 0.012723694555461407, -0.028809845447540283, 0.028234172612428665, 0.024335293099284172, -0.030327530577778816, 0.010296707041561604, 0.04280918091535568, 0.04184100404381752, 0.035168420523405075, 0.016916953027248383, 0.008412684313952923, -0.01011353824287653, 0.02553897351026535, -0.004997893236577511, 0.015647854655981064, -0.005540858022868633, 0.002256902167573571, 0.056573010981082916, -0.014745093882083893, -0.0014416370540857315, -0.016223527491092682, 0.005171249620616436, -0.025499721989035606, -0.010754629038274288, -0.007156669162213802, -0.0020328473765403032, -0.008406142704188824, 0.018356136977672577, 0.013659164309501648, 0.015608604066073895, 0.025735225528478622, 0.0032136323861777782, -0.04890608787536621, -0.011114425025880337, 0.032708726823329926, 0.015438518486917019, -0.01326011773198843, 0.02056724764406681, -0.026572568342089653, -0.00453015835955739, -0.030144361779093742, 0.0048605166375637054, 0.02400820516049862, -0.004546512849628925, 0.0164459478110075, 0.03184521570801735, 0.029568688943982124, -0.017741212621331215, 0.02092050202190876, 0.020737333223223686, -0.029568688943982124, -0.050423771142959595, 0.0030010256450623274, 0.025041799992322922, -0.04668189212679863, 0.014823595061898232, -0.0028374819085001945, -0.027344495058059692, -0.028234172612428665, -0.0013410578249022365, 0.00853043608367443, 0.018918726593255997, -0.0048179952427744865, -0.024230623617768288, -0.002943785395473242, -0.013129282742738724, 0.004458199255168438, 0.022359685972332954, 0.02085508406162262, 0.031792882829904556, -0.0094528216868639, 0.001081841066479683, 0.034331079572439194, -0.02750149741768837, 0.01986073888838291, -0.04108215868473053, -0.008294932544231415, 0.02854817546904087, -0.010087370872497559, -0.004503991454839706, 0.017453376203775406, -0.0164459478110075, -0.00053560541709885, 0.02252976968884468, 0.04163166508078575, -0.017754295840859413, 0.018172968178987503, 0.0012821820564568043, 0.019468232989311218, 0.009236943908035755, 0.00504041463136673, 0.003928318154066801, 0.0004176495422143489, -0.012762945145368576, 0.01895797811448574, 0.020815832540392876, 0.01392083428800106, 0.005903925281018019, -0.00003914825720130466, 0.0157394390553236, 0.026153897866606712, -0.043698858469724655, -0.00033424230059608817, -0.028652844950556755, 0.003179288236424327, -0.022555937990546227, -0.01078079640865326, 0.0031155061442404985, -0.002480956958606839, -0.0006382290157489479, 0.026546401903033257, 0.002948691602796316, 0.006224470678716898, -0.014247921295464039, 0.029830358922481537, -0.02631090022623539, -0.015909524634480476, -0.01392083428800106, -0.012520899996161461, 0.03911963477730751, 0.06384743005037308, -0.0195990689098835, 0.011585431173443794, 0.033624570816755295, -0.005589921493083239, -0.032708726823329926, 0.0094528216868639, 0.00853043608367443, 0.023668034002184868, 0.015974942594766617, 0.009544406086206436, -0.027187492698431015, 0.024256791919469833, -0.035927265882492065, -0.03213305398821831, 0.0055114203132689, 0.0009886212646961212, 0.011343386024236679, -0.031949885189533234, -0.01791129820048809, -0.017505710944533348, -0.002220922615379095, -0.04032331705093384, -0.00491612171754241, -0.03532542288303375, 0.010296707041561604, -0.011546180583536625, 0.019913071766495705, 0.015098348259925842, 0.06913316249847412, -0.02211109921336174, 0.04144849628210068, -0.030484532937407494, 0.022307351231575012, 0.006934249773621559, 0.05505532771348953, -0.057201020419597626, -0.002839117543771863, 0.06562678515911102, -0.012900321744382381, 0.0063193258829414845, 0.008111763745546341, -0.0031155061442404985, -0.05332830548286438, 0.013004989363253117, 0.0398784801363945, -0.023183945566415787, -0.016262779012322426, -0.01073500420898199, -0.06520811468362808, -0.00947898905724287, -0.03820379078388214, 0.004549783654510975, -0.004961913917213678, 0.029516354203224182, 0.013332076370716095, -0.0024368001613765955, 0.020410245284438133, 0.0006762529374100268, -0.014143252745270729, 0.0018987415824085474, 0.005645526107400656, -0.0067249140702188015, 0.015490852296352386, 0.002705011749640107, -0.02436145953834057, -0.021077502518892288, 0.007496839854866266, -0.021496174857020378, -0.011467679403722286, 0.016288945451378822, -0.016642199829220772, 0.04521654173731804, 0.019834572449326515, 0.00976682547479868, 0.01993924006819725, -0.013711498118937016, -0.035508591681718826, -0.03877946734428406, -0.008236057125031948, 0.00794167909771204, -0.0665164664387703, 0.02483246475458145, 0.03469741716980934, -0.003179288236424327, -0.0094528216868639, -0.015974942594766617, -0.02260827086865902, -0.026755737140774727, -0.008007096126675606, -0.05767202749848366, 0.014902095310389996, 0.007346380036324263, -0.00008632037497591227, 0.012193812988698483, -0.004118028562515974, -0.016877703368663788, -0.008118306286633015, 0.007542632054537535, 0.029228517785668373, 0.012887238524854183, -0.022778356447815895, 0.0004853157151956111, 0.03974764421582222, -0.047336068004369736, 0.0005401028320193291, -0.0025365618057549, 0.014104003086686134, 0.028731344267725945, 0.01448342390358448, -0.007209003437310457, -0.008229515515267849, 0.04396052658557892, -0.0371047779917717, -0.04003548249602318, -0.001955981831997633, -0.004981539212167263, 0.003359186230227351, -0.017113205045461655, -0.009891118854284286, -0.003323206678032875, -0.031452711671590805, -0.017662711441516876, 0.0006778883398510516, -0.012991906143724918, -0.009982703253626823, 0.007614591624587774, -0.011042466387152672, 0.015137598849833012, -0.018840225413441658, 0.009773367084562778, -0.026219313964247704, 0.017479542642831802, 0.013037698343396187, -0.016890786588191986, -0.028652844950556755, -0.011467679403722286, 0.03877946734428406, 0.025355804711580276, -0.022856857627630234, 0.003921776078641415, 0.02281760796904564, 0.002163682132959366, 0.020344827324151993, 0.016393613070249557, 0.01479742769151926, 0.01881405897438526, 0.014692760072648525, -0.027265993878245354, -0.010192039422690868, 0.010970506817102432, 0.007987471297383308, 0.01511143147945404, -0.054479654878377914, -0.018290719017386436, 0.022634439170360565, 0.017401041463017464, -0.03263022378087044, 0.015569353476166725, 0.01742720976471901, -0.029568688943982124, -0.003529271576553583, -0.014156336896121502, 0.026624903082847595, -0.035168420523405075, 0.07452356070280075, -0.0023713826667517424, -0.012298480607569218, -0.018146801739931107, 0.01993924006819725, -0.021731678396463394, -0.008229515515267849, 0.03618893399834633, 0.008582769893109798, -0.022058764472603798, -0.008909856900572777, 0.005972613580524921, -0.016066526994109154, 0.04079432412981987, 0.0475715696811676, 0.009420112706720829, 0.00692770816385746, -0.0018496784614399076, -0.0051254574209451675, -0.001895470661111176, -0.02071116492152214, -0.025591308251023293, -0.002919253893196583, 0.025303469970822334, 0.015203015878796577, 0.016341280192136765, 0.022542854771018028, -0.008903315290808678, 0.0004849068645853549, 0.03854396194219589, -0.012847987934947014, 0.019271980971097946, 0.013829248957335949, -0.012010644190013409, -0.021456925198435783, -0.02476704679429531, -0.017374875023961067, 0.024884799495339394, 0.012265772558748722, -0.006008592899888754, 0.026428651064634323, -0.011775141581892967, 0.01298536453396082, -0.01294611394405365, -0.010538751259446144, -0.0036241267807781696, -0.01448342390358448, 0.02616698108613491, -0.011153675615787506, 0.015713272616267204, -0.0032888625282794237, -0.04092515632510185, 0.02119525521993637, 0.0049095796421170235, 0.0006439530407078564, 0.013103115372359753, 0.002852200996130705, 0.03184521570801735, 0.02455771155655384, 0.006836123764514923, -0.02156159281730652, -0.029228517785668373, -0.015072180889546871, 0.059503715485334396, 0.003125318791717291, 0.0015070545487105846, -0.014810510911047459, 0.01354141253978014, -0.02581372670829296, -0.019677570089697838, -0.021849429234862328, -0.009210777468979359, 0.026323983445763588, 0.00610344810411334, -0.007104335352778435, -0.006633329670876265, -0.01581794023513794, 0.029071515426039696, -0.029411686584353447, 0.009649074636399746, -0.02568289265036583, -0.013148907572031021, 0.018486972898244858, 0.058457035571336746, -0.03480208292603493, -0.002314142417162657, 0.018526222556829453, -0.03226388618350029, -0.02862667664885521, 0.01995232328772545, -0.0009518239530734718, 0.012861071154475212, 0.033703070133924484, 0.015988025814294815, 0.02721366100013256, 0.02140459045767784, -0.016393613070249557, -0.004742765333503485, -0.01157888863235712, -0.001785896485671401, -0.012357356958091259, -0.003190736286342144, 0.01360683050006628, -0.029647190123796463, -0.010139704681932926, -0.0009959806920960546, -0.008713604882359505, -0.016131943091750145, 0.00011427611025283113, -0.013384411111474037, 0.02638939954340458, 0.03113870695233345, 0.011827475391328335, -0.009106108918786049, -0.01568710431456566, 0.019834572449326515, 0.00972757488489151, -0.012475107796490192, -0.029019182547926903, -0.013750748708844185, 0.03234238922595978, 0.006185220088809729, -0.0001234754454344511, -0.016537532210350037, -0.0062866173684597015, -0.04882758483290672, 0.001391756348311901, -0.02093358524143696, 0.028652844950556755, 0.018931809812784195, -0.02561747469007969, -0.00025308376643806696, 0.030353697016835213, 0.00015689966676291078, 0.02400820516049862, 0.005593192297965288, -0.005949717480689287, 0.0022896109148859978, 0.06688280403614044, 0.007339837960898876, 0.0015716543421149254, -0.01778046414256096, -0.0234456155449152, -0.0016460666665807366, 0.02317086234688759, -0.00877902191132307, -0.029019182547926903, -0.02891451306641102, -0.010008870624005795, 0.014653509482741356, -0.004742765333503485, -0.014431090094149113, 0.001510325470007956, -0.009969620034098625, -0.013024615123867989, -0.008033263497054577, -0.03519459068775177, -0.01610577665269375, -0.012030269019305706, 0.005403481423854828, -0.005894112400710583, 0.004199800547212362, -0.004239051137119532, -0.010506043210625648, 0.045373544096946716, -0.014875928871333599, 0.0007200008258223534, -0.007248253561556339, 0.027344495058059692, -0.020279409363865852, -0.021496174857020378, -0.009878035634756088, 0.030772369354963303, -0.021247588098049164, -0.01728329062461853, 0.0101462472230196, 0.010813504457473755, -0.014378756284713745, -0.035168420523405075, 0.0110162990167737, 0.025107217952609062, -0.04833041504025459, 0.03532542288303375, 0.0377851203083992, -0.009112651459872723, -0.03660760447382927, 0.00843230914324522, 0.014928262680768967, 0.028391174972057343, -0.015124514698982239, 0.016563698649406433, -0.020658832043409348, 0.006554828491061926, 0.049089256674051285, 0.0110228406265378, 0.02492404915392399, -0.02351103164255619, 0.000011569433809199836, -0.022516686469316483, -0.011310677044093609, -0.02721366100013256, -0.039773810654878616, -0.012200354598462582, -0.010120079852640629, 0.012167646549642086, 0.008052888326346874, 0.007326754741370678, 0.003754961770027876, -0.0060707395896315575, 0.011323761194944382, -0.013103115372359753, 0.016249695792794228, -0.02078966610133648, -0.030772369354963303, -0.0018513138638809323, 0.03611043468117714, 0.008445393294095993, 0.03652910515666008, 0.008798647671937943, -0.02917618304491043, 0.045504380017519, 0.016145026311278343, 0.008052888326346874, 0.040820490568876266, -0.01381616573780775, 0.04108215868473053, 0.04322785139083862, 0.012507816776633263, 0.0007232716889120638, 0.02700432389974594, 0.0085762282833457, -0.027736999094486237, -0.0013484172523021698, 0.013312451541423798, 0.020056990906596184, 0.005580108612775803, -0.02674265392124653, 0.04372502490878105, -0.03514225408434868, -0.02112983725965023, 0.03896263614296913, 0.006796873174607754, 0.01903647929430008, 0.043777357786893845, 0.008543519303202629, 0.06730147451162338, 0.027946336194872856, 0.030981704592704773, -0.02198026329278946, -0.04147466644644737, -0.019402816891670227, 0.06792948395013809, -0.005805798806250095, 0.012017185799777508, 0.005024060141295195, 0.0024874985683709383, 0.02954252064228058, -0.037471115589141846, 0.0026575839146971703, 0.0018660328350961208, 0.006221199873834848, -0.0118928924202919, 0.014810510911047459, -0.010538751259446144, 0.011382636614143848, 0.005936633795499802, -0.02867901138961315, -0.010767712257802486, 0.011480762623250484, 0.04105599224567413, 0.004098403267562389, -0.016459031030535698, -0.01868322491645813, 0.016681449487805367, 0.0022618083748966455, 0.008164098486304283, -0.007418339140713215, -0.0029601396527141333, 0.00038310096715576947, -0.006692205555737019, 0.0016689627664163709, 0.008661271072924137, 0.004994622431695461, -0.021509258076548576, -0.04087282344698906, -0.002778606256470084, 0.006162323988974094, 0.030327530577778816, -0.008765938691794872, 0.04147466644644737, 0.03273489326238632, 0.018931809812784195, 0.02778933383524418, -0.03618893399834633, -0.00008601372974226251, -0.016563698649406433, -0.018303802236914635, -0.012416232377290726, -3.2580956599304045e-7, -0.023419447243213654, 0.045739881694316864, -0.007745426148176193, -0.015386184677481651, 0.02455771155655384, 0.015268432907760143, 0.007339837960898876, 0.019821487367153168, -0.000047172117774607614, 0.021862512454390526, -0.012239605188369751, 0.013240491971373558, 0.014967513270676136, 0.004589034244418144, 0.032891895622015, -0.004782015923410654, 0.02512030117213726, 0.02611464634537697, 0.04770240560173988, 0.003421332687139511, 0.013750748708844185, 0.012952655553817749, 0.01291340496391058, 0.012749860994517803, -0.002417174866423011, 0.018316887319087982, -0.03597959876060486, 0.007863177917897701, 0.05243862792849541, 0.01986073888838291, 0.012331189587712288, 0.016890786588191986, -0.024191373959183693, -0.0018398658139631152, -0.01568710431456566, -0.01995232328772545, 0.027396829798817635, 0.01979532092809677, 0.004448386840522289, -0.025996895506978035, -0.02820800617337227, 0.032577890902757645, -0.02392970398068428, 0.012403149157762527, -0.03310123085975647, -0.023144694045186043, 0.001292812405154109, -0.0034376871772110462, -0.011349927634000778, -0.02933318540453911, -0.004638097248971462, 0.034618914127349854, -0.015373101457953453, -0.01596185751259327, -0.02169242687523365, 0.017165539786219597, 0.0195859856903553, 0.023406364023685455, 0.0035946890711784363, 0.007588424254208803, -0.001003340119495988, -0.02000465616583824, 0.0011971393832936883, 0.032891895622015, 0.016694534569978714, -0.001955981831997633, 0.01741412654519081, -0.004716598428785801, 0.019206564873456955, 0.002924160100519657, -0.011199467815458775, 0.014758177101612091, 0.010963965207338333, -0.004206342156976461, 0.03030136413872242, -0.0022896109148859978, -0.030955538153648376, 0.026925822719931602, 0.02532963827252388, 0.002615062752738595, -0.006590808276087046, 0.022346600890159607, 0.021299922838807106, -0.0057207560166716576, 0.005429648328572512, -0.0037876705173403025, -0.0036535647232085466, -0.012448941357433796, -0.008438851684331894, -0.0068819159641861916 ]
13.91647
4.801347
2024-07-01
0
2024ApJ...969..115D
[ "shock heating", "Mach number", "Mach", "intricate structures", "the merging galaxy cluster SPT-CLJ", "The stronger shock front", "heating", "the shock front", "two shock fronts", "the Coulomb collisional heating model" ]
[ "Galaxy clusters", "Shocks", "X-ray astronomy", "Intracluster medium", "584", "2086", "1810", "858", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics", "Astrophysics - High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena" ]
19
[ "10.3847/1538-4357/ad47f8", "10.48550/arXiv.2406.19264" ]
[ "Diwanji, Purva", "Walker, Stephen A.", "Mirakhor, M. S." ]
[ "Department of Physics and Astronomy, The University of Alabama in Huntsville, 301 Sparkman Drive NW, Huntsville, AL 35899, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, The University of Alabama in Huntsville, 301 Sparkman Drive NW, Huntsville, AL 35899, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, The University of Alabama in Huntsville, 301 Sparkman Drive NW, Huntsville, AL 35899, USA" ]
null
[ "1986RvMP...58....1S", "1987PhR...154....1B", "1987flme.book.....L", "1996ASPC..101...17A", "1998MNRAS.293L..33E", "1999ApJ...520..514T", "2004A&A...425..367B", "2005A&A...440..775K", "2006MNRAS.371..829S", "2006SPIE.6270E..1VF", "2007PhR...443....1M", "2008LNP...740....1S", "2010ApJ...716.1118P", "2010MNRAS.406.1721R", "2011A&A...526A..79E", "2011A&A...534A.109P", "2011ApJ...728...27O", "2011ApJ...728...82M", "2011ApJ...738..139W", "2011MmSAI..82..662C", "2012MNRAS.423..236R", "2013ApJ...764...82B", "2014ApJ...780..163O", "2014MNRAS.440.3416O", "2015MNRAS.446L..16R", "2016A&A...594A..13P", "2016ApJ...820L..20D", "2016MNRAS.460.1898S", "2016MNRAS.461..684W", "2016MNRAS.463.1534B", "2017ApJ...841....5N", "2018ApJ...856..162W", "2018MNRAS.478.3072C", "2019A&A...628A.100D", "2020MNRAS.493L..28R", "2022ApJ...935L..23S", "2022MNRAS.514.1477R", "2023MNRAS.522.2105M" ]
29097435
2406.04213
Systematic analysis of jellyfish galaxy candidates in Fornax, Antlia, and Hydra from the S-PLUS survey: a self-supervised visual identification aid
We study 51 jellyfish galaxy candidates in the Fornax, Antlia, and Hydra clusters. These candidates are identified using the JClass scheme based on the visual classification of wide-field, twelve-band optical images obtained from the Southern Photometric Local Universe Survey. A comprehensive astrophysical analysis of the jellyfish (JClass &gt; 0), non-jellyfish (JClass = 0), and independently organized control samples is undertaken. We develop a semi-automated pipeline using self-supervised learning and similarity search to detect jellyfish galaxies. The proposed framework is designed to assist visual classifiers by providing more reliable JClasses for galaxies. We find that jellyfish candidates exhibit a lower Gini coefficient, higher entropy, and a lower 2D Sérsic index as the jellyfish features in these galaxies become more pronounced. Jellyfish candidates show elevated star formation rates (including contributions from the main body and tails) by $\sim$1.75 dex, suggesting a significant increase in the SFR caused by the ram-pressure stripping phenomenon. Galaxies in the Antlia and Fornax clusters preferentially fall towards the cluster's centre, whereas only a mild preference is observed for Hydra galaxies. Our self-supervised pipeline, applied in visually challenging cases, offers two main advantages: it reduces human visual biases and scales effectively for large data sets. This versatile framework promises substantial enhancements in morphology studies for future galaxy image surveys.
[ -0.031235801056027412, -0.0033554602414369583, 0.019519058987498283, -0.009547221474349499, 0.028953490778803825, -0.009182317182421684, -0.007145488169044256, -0.02558310329914093, -0.00014606535842176527, 0.050741590559482574, -0.0048764473758637905, -0.04750389605760574, -0.03083772398531437, -0.01588328555226326, 0.01431751437485218, 0.02242502197623253, -0.003101685782894492, -0.01597617007791996, -0.019426174461841583, 0.040869273245334625, 0.03362426534295082, -0.03741926699876785, -0.011112991720438004, -0.010336740873754025, -0.030864262953400612, -0.043921198695898056, 0.012307223863899708, 0.029510799795389175, 0.03370388224720955, 0.029139259830117226, 0.033836573362350464, -0.02133694477379322, -0.01587001606822014, -0.0008343037334270775, -0.0655500665307045, 0.0662931427359581, -0.01792674884200096, 0.011292126961052418, -0.033942725509405136, 0.016228286549448967, -0.03179311007261276, 0.025742333382368088, -0.0037153884768486023, -0.011006837710738182, 0.0208592526614666, -0.00545034185051918, 0.0051152934320271015, -0.010303568094968796, -0.030864262953400612, 0.03696811571717262, -0.06831006705760956, 0.023619255051016808, -0.03649042174220085, -0.0009976812871173024, -0.009460970759391785, -0.012678762897849083, -0.01348155178129673, 0.01866982690989971, -0.03232387825846672, -0.0028644981794059277, -0.01901482790708542, 0.03359772637486458, 0.040948886424303055, -0.017847133800387383, -0.0208592526614666, 0.022770022973418236, -0.032828111201524734, 0.01681213267147541, 0.04477043077349663, 0.012585878372192383, 0.008260104805231094, -0.05976467579603195, 0.024680795148015022, -0.02310175448656082, -0.012446551583707333, 0.01699790172278881, 0.021947329863905907, -0.025556564331054688, -0.007709430996328592, 0.008425970561802387, 0.002841276815161109, 0.036623112857341766, 0.004030533134937286, -0.034128494560718536, -0.0030187531374394894, -0.022279061377048492, 0.012307223863899708, -0.018789250403642654, -0.08264085650444031, 0.00077915342990309, 0.00044742232421413064, 0.01679886318743229, -0.07956238836050034, -0.008711258880794048, -0.047716204077005386, -0.03853388503193855, 0.02852887474000454, -0.0796685442328453, 0.04615043103694916, 0.007702796254307032, 0.02125732973217964, 0.019187327474355698, -0.02519829571247101, -0.06470083445310593, 0.06390468031167984, -0.02048771269619465, -0.03205849230289459, 0.010058087296783924, 0.03312003239989281, 0.03879927098751068, 0.0006166052189655602, -0.014821745455265045, 0.005636111367493868, 0.031341955065727234, -0.0034400515723973513, 0.0006837807595729828, -0.03646388277411461, 0.02245156094431877, -0.01845751889050007, 0.011338569223880768, -0.017515402287244797, -0.047981586307287216, 0.02235867641866207, 0.006312842946499586, 0.024999255314469337, -0.00521813053637743, -0.024879833683371544, -0.0443192757666111, -0.030360030010342598, 0.004750389605760574, -0.014556361362338066, -0.01528616901487112, 0.024627717211842537, -0.0009545562788844109, -0.029112722724676132, -0.017024440690875053, -0.00486981263384223, -0.0014844967518001795, -0.008134046569466591, 0.01920059695839882, 0.035216573625802994, -0.01736943982541561, 0.027812335640192032, 0.03768465295433998, 0.01957213506102562, -0.015617900528013706, -0.038003116846084595, 0.007238372694700956, -0.036702729761600494, 0.04121427237987518, -0.03853388503193855, -0.022862907499074936, -0.012665493413805962, -0.01847078837454319, -0.027493873611092567, -0.012075012549757957, -0.0021894252859055996, -0.01348155178129673, -0.012658858671784401, 0.004909620154649019, 0.00583846727386117, -0.013627514243125916, 0.008107508532702923, 0.016573285683989525, -0.04904312640428543, 0.0196517501026392, -0.01066183764487505, -0.011212510988116264, -0.08333085477352142, 0.016785593703389168, 0.00627635233104229, -0.015418861992657185, 0.05034351348876953, -0.036437343806028366, -0.023964256048202515, 0.008226931095123291, -0.016122132539749146, -0.04389465972781181, -0.018802519887685776, -0.012625685892999172, 0.013037032447755337, 0.031235801056027412, -0.0004938647034578025, -0.05912775173783302, -0.04535427689552307, 0.004511543083935976, 0.005015774164348841, 0.0006439730059355497, 0.01790020987391472, 0.012917608954012394, -0.019970212131738663, -0.0018941846210509539, 0.03988735005259514, 0.0674077644944191, 0.00711231492459774, -0.0017880306113511324, 0.015153476968407631, 0.038560424000024796, -0.03312003239989281, 0.01884232647716999, 0.00808760430663824, 0.014529822394251823, 0.009945298545062542, -0.0098258750513196, -0.015405592508614063, -0.06305544823408127, 0.012274051085114479, -0.009023086167871952, -0.0011237391736358404, 0.010469433851540089, 0.04920235648751259, 0.0007862027268856764, -0.011995396576821804, 0.020845983177423477, -0.04644235596060753, -0.0019472616259008646, -0.04986581951379776, 0.032270800322294235, 0.027838874608278275, -0.001817886484786868, -0.00044576366781257093, 0.037817347794771194, 0.04240850359201431, 0.018444249406456947, -0.019266942515969276, -0.015644438564777374, 0.0513785146176815, -0.04540735483169556, -0.009228759445250034, -0.029298491775989532, 0.04808774217963219, -0.0046309661120176315, -0.03304041922092438, -0.0476631261408329, -0.05320966988801956, -0.026896758005023003, -0.02456137165427208, -0.031633879989385605, 0.029245413839817047, -0.02077963575720787, -0.020381558686494827, 0.032907724380493164, -0.013614244759082794, -0.022398484870791435, -0.013421840965747833, 0.020169250667095184, -0.01847078837454319, 0.008465778082609177, 0.048167355358600616, -0.029298491775989532, 0.02014271356165409, -0.017966557294130325, -0.01625482365489006, -0.04278004169464111, -0.042726967483758926, 0.007384334225207567, -0.03110310807824135, -0.010422991588711739, -0.016414055600762367, 0.006342698819935322, -0.021827906370162964, 0.017621556296944618, -0.03280157223343849, 0.009076163172721863, -0.0493350513279438, 0.0053541399538517, 0.019346557557582855, -0.015379054471850395, -0.05551851913332939, 0.005685871001332998, -0.03519003465771675, 0.01587001606822014, 0.00882404763251543, -0.01994367502629757, -0.04296581447124481, 0.051484666764736176, 0.0017050978494808078, 0.0215094443410635, 0.044080428779125214, -0.022186176851391792, -0.005297745577991009, -0.02586175687611103, 0.018908673897385597, 0.010681741870939732, -0.023154830560088158, 0.0419042743742466, -0.001354292267933488, -0.06836314499378204, -0.01698463223874569, 0.00965337548404932, 0.06103852391242981, -0.021628867834806442, -0.004285966046154499, 0.0014272730331867933, -0.023115023970603943, -0.0026969739701598883, 0.016480401158332825, 0.02279656194150448, -0.018152326345443726, 0.011749915778636932, 0.00535745732486248, -0.024866564199328423, -0.03489811345934868, -0.014277706854045391, -0.02659156545996666, 0.01882905699312687, 0.013401936739683151, -0.0004088585847057402, -0.014344053342938423, 0.005815246142446995, -0.007477219216525555, -0.014609438367187977, -0.0007364430348388851, 0.053156591951847076, 0.0007040992495603859, -0.06862853467464447, -0.013269244693219662, -0.0001241918362211436, 0.024587908759713173, 0.03065195493400097, -0.04347004368901253, 0.003635772969573736, 0.023977523669600487, 0.025277910754084587, -0.024269448593258858, -0.06348006427288055, -0.019465981051325798, -0.03378349542617798, -0.013906167820096016, -0.027759259566664696, 0.002584185218438506, 0.013959244824945927, 0.05514698103070259, -0.038003116846084595, -0.010595491155982018, -0.09023085981607437, -0.04922889545559883, 0.01306357141584158, -0.031156186014413834, -0.048910435289144516, -0.03561465069651604, -0.03009464591741562, -0.0006120438920333982, 0.017979826778173447, 0.04384158179163933, 0.04718543216586113, 0.006375872064381838, 0.07202545553445816, 0.011975493282079697, -0.027945028617978096, -0.013746936805546284, 0.03285465016961098, 0.022730214521288872, 0.007371065206825733, 0.030147723853588104, -0.06252467632293701, 0.003033681074157357, -0.008047796785831451, -0.02953733690083027, 0.029218876734375954, -0.009261932224035263, -0.03667619079351425, 0.027918489649891853, 0.06486006826162338, 0.025556564331054688, 0.018165595829486847, -0.017104055732488632, -0.040126193314790726, 0.02198713831603527, -0.03590657562017441, -0.013017128221690655, 0.026989642530679703, 0.04439889267086983, 0.015617900528013706, -0.05880929157137871, 0.01847078837454319, 0.024256179109215736, 0.012771647423505783, -0.014635976403951645, 0.07436084747314453, 0.036623112857341766, 0.013242705725133419, 0.02233213745057583, -0.049281973391771317, -0.025423871353268623, 0.0032012052834033966, -0.008094239048659801, -0.030864262953400612, -0.05429774895310402, 0.043735429644584656, -0.04328427463769913, 0.009726355783641338, -0.014529822394251823, 0.005181639920920134, 0.02030194364488125, -0.014251167885959148, 0.021814636886119843, 0.015498477034270763, 0.010296933352947235, 0.037817347794771194, 0.00155830685980618, -0.016772324219346046, -0.027546951547265053, -0.023141561076045036, -0.021748291328549385, -0.01726328767836094, -0.013972514308989048, 0.025078872218728065, 0.027281565591692924, -0.027573490515351295, 0.01819213479757309, -0.014781937934458256, 0.03712734580039978, -0.0018693048041313887, -0.06215314194560051, 0.01957213506102562, -0.047689665108919144, 0.023592716082930565, -0.03293426334857941, 0.06533776223659515, 0.01801963336765766, -0.028104258701205254, 0.0014289317186921835, -0.024614447727799416, -0.023765215650200844, 0.0030419742688536644, 0.05352813005447388, 0.002159569412469864, -0.01828501932322979, -0.02420310117304325, -0.02253117598593235, 0.07818238437175751, -0.06321468204259872, -0.01076135691255331, -0.017196940258145332, -0.04986581951379776, 0.05098043754696846, -0.026166949421167374, -0.010257125832140446, 0.0030038252007216215, 0.012406743131577969, 0.000962849531788379, -0.025609642267227173, -0.04901658743619919, 0.029961952939629555, 0.010230586864054203, 0.01052914559841156, 0.030625415965914726, 0.000657656928524375, -0.021575791761279106, -0.05106005072593689, -0.0009603615617379546, 0.007536930963397026, 0.025185026228427887, 0.020341752097010612, -0.05721697956323624, 0.03407542034983635, -0.03933003917336464, 0.036145422607660294, -0.06379852443933487, -0.01325597520917654, 0.014781937934458256, -0.02927195280790329, 0.05376697704195976, -0.0026306277140975, 0.049441203474998474, -0.05238697677850723, -0.008193758316338062, 0.026007719337940216, -0.0032061811070889235, 0.005984429270029068, -0.06003006175160408, 0.049281973391771317, -0.04368235170841217, 0.015020784921944141, -0.007556834723800421, -0.03293426334857941, -0.021482907235622406, 0.05132543668150902, 0.04405388981103897, 0.005032361019402742, -0.009076163172721863, -0.02972310781478882, -0.008213662542402744, 0.018603481352329254, 0.0234600231051445, -0.007390968967229128, -0.03288118913769722, 0.00065848627127707, -0.031235801056027412, 0.004551350604742765, -0.004604427609592676, 0.058968521654605865, -0.014516552910208702, -0.0027865413576364517, -0.08694008737802505, -0.05827851966023445, -0.02307521551847458, -0.031527724117040634, -0.030890800058841705, 0.058225445449352264, -0.038931962102651596, 0.04845928028225899, 0.016944825649261475, 0.008983278647065163, 0.0006394116790033877, -0.02032848261296749, -0.032907724380493164, -0.03009464591741562, 0.004219619557261467, 0.018882134929299355, 0.06411698460578918, 0.02815733663737774, 0.005785390269011259, 0.01568424701690674, 0.027082527056336403, -0.017250018194317818, 0.003688849974423647, 0.005194908939301968, 0.038931962102651596, 0.019054634496569633, -0.0005000846576876938, -0.017661364749073982, -0.02020905911922455, 0.0018543768674135208, -0.010389817878603935, -0.007954912260174751, -0.09824548661708832, -0.047318123281002045, 0.013773475773632526, 0.012433282099664211, 0.02014271356165409, 0.0041234176605939865, 0.013269244693219662, -0.05854390561580658, -0.005208178423345089, -0.02556983381509781, -0.015312707982957363, -0.02372540906071663, 0.018152326345443726, -0.035322729498147964, 0.025277910754084587, -0.02502579428255558, 0.015750592574477196, 0.011690204031765461, 0.037525422871112823, -0.02133694477379322, -0.010840972885489464, 0.005738948006182909, 0.02282310090959072, 0.043443504720926285, -0.03224426507949829, 0.0011934026842936873, 0.01569751650094986, -0.004972649272531271, 0.021867714822292328, 0.008352989330887794, 0.02622002735733986, -0.03179311007261276, -0.012599147856235504, -0.0014679101295769215, -0.0016876820009201765, -0.007324622943997383, 0.021854445338249207, 0.014012321829795837, -0.036596573889255524, 0.02353964000940323, -0.010880780406296253, 0.0027682960499078035, 0.031156186014413834, -0.013149821199476719, -0.023566177114844322, 0.02945772185921669, -0.09437086433172226, -0.0070592379197478294, -0.0226240623742342, -0.020527521148324013, 0.0028462528716772795, -0.004836639389395714, 0.004471735097467899, -0.041055042296648026, -0.04875120520591736, -0.02807772159576416, 0.0037950037512928247, -0.018258480355143547, -0.01510039996355772, -0.022677138447761536, -0.005098707042634487, 0.006893372628837824, -0.006226592697203159, 0.01836463436484337, -0.012811454944312572, -0.007072507403790951, -0.019134249538183212, 0.009620201773941517, -0.035216573625802994, 0.0073511614464223385, 0.007278180681169033, -0.008711258880794048, -0.003391950624063611, -0.004276013933122158, -0.0032310609240084887, -0.04368235170841217, -0.049892358481884, -0.028555413708090782, -0.009062893688678741, 0.017701171338558197, -0.03853388503193855, 0.03128887712955475, 0.01764809526503086, -0.011829530820250511, -0.006558324210345745, -0.006346016190946102, -0.04211658239364624, -0.01836463436484337, -0.01671924814581871, 0.005204861052334309, -0.0019456029403954744, 0.017316363751888275, -0.03627811372280121, -0.020116174593567848, -0.03288118913769722, -0.00008054845966398716, -0.005065533798187971, 0.05318313091993332, 0.007424142211675644, 0.0011842800304293633, -0.02604752592742443, -0.03434080258011818, -0.03895850107073784, -0.02990887686610222, -0.0014820087235420942, 0.018762711435556412, -0.03548195958137512, 0.008207027800381184, 0.004398754332214594, -0.010588857345283031, 0.027812335640192032, -0.0012174531584605575, 0.011232415214180946, 0.01580367051064968, 0.03473887965083122, 0.014755399897694588, -0.03712734580039978, 0.013627514243125916, 0.0019041365012526512, -0.006757362745702267, -0.03611888363957405, -0.02834310568869114, -0.037260036915540695, -0.028210412710905075, -0.030970416963100433, 0.021190982311964035, -0.003131541656330228, 0.033013880252838135, -0.015936361625790596, -0.00667442986741662, -0.009799337014555931, -0.017940018326044083, 0.010283663868904114, -0.03020079992711544, 0.03359772637486458, -0.0024000746197998524, -0.04285965859889984, -0.013455013744533062, -0.007045968901365995, -0.021456368267536163, 0.03298734128475189, -0.0031514454167336226, -0.001895843306556344, 0.031527724117040634, 0.0063725546933710575, 0.022279061377048492, 0.014821745455265045, -0.046760816127061844, 0.0026438969653099775, -0.014277706854045391, -0.027308104559779167, -0.042249273508787155, -0.01569751650094986, -0.024906370788812637, 0.01663963310420513, 0.014609438367187977, -0.02400406263768673, 0.01348155178129673, -0.030439646914601326, -0.011053280904889107, 0.011530973017215729, 0.019187327474355698, 0.04625658690929413, 0.021841175854206085, -0.0034433689434081316, -0.0009412870276719332, 0.0017979826079681516, 0.007271545939147472, -0.008578566834330559, -0.013959244824945927, 0.012924243696033955, -0.028396183624863625, -0.043071966618299484, 0.007709430996328592, -0.014821745455265045, 0.02208002284169197, -0.019280212000012398, 0.011875974014401436, -0.026472141966223717, -0.00987895205616951, 0.01679886318743229, 0.026379257440567017, -0.00003503909829305485, -0.013746936805546284, 0.02226579189300537, -0.01413174532353878, 0.004697312600910664, 0.008525489829480648, -0.010396452620625496, 0.002131372457370162, -0.014609438367187977, -0.006216641049832106, -0.06241852417588234, -0.006710920482873917, 0.028475798666477203, -0.034393880516290665, 0.03702118992805481, 0.02744079753756523, -0.01827174983918667, -0.00530769769102335, -0.02206675335764885, -0.0476631261408329, -0.030784646049141884, -0.010369914583861828, 0.002701949793845415, -0.006710920482873917, -0.03516349568963051, 0.0066445739939808846, 0.029749644920229912, -0.028980029746890068, -0.004256110172718763, -0.027493873611092567, 0.010794530622661114, 0.0009852413786575198, 0.005344188306480646, 0.041240811347961426, 0.018868865445256233, 0.011922416277229786, 0.000023428508939105086, 0.04052427038550377, -0.0123802050948143, 0.017117325216531754, 0.03553503751754761, 0.005055582150816917, 0.011922416277229786, 0.02882079780101776, -0.00048598606372252107, -0.0009296764037571847, -0.03277503326535225, 0.02632618136703968, -0.007735969498753548, 0.044558122754096985, 0.016931556165218353, 0.03821542486548424, 0.04800812527537346, 0.01995694264769554, 0.027122335508465767, -0.020567327737808228, 0.03187272325158119, -0.02020905911922455, 0.02298233099281788, -0.013853090815246105, -0.026339448988437653, -0.035773880779743195, -0.0068668341264128685, 0.009686548262834549, -0.004548033699393272, 0.006710920482873917, -0.01431751437485218, 0.01058222260326147, -0.037260036915540695, -0.005782073363661766, 0.03978119418025017, -0.010847607627511024, -0.021642137318849564, 0.03205849230289459, -0.0016926579410210252, -0.007636450231075287, 0.0019124298123642802, 0.014158283360302448, -0.010734818875789642, 0.005994380917400122, -0.020912328734993935, 0.009467605501413345, 0.040391579270362854, 0.002695315284654498, 0.01579040102660656, -0.003718705615028739, 0.04129388928413391, -0.0031613975297659636, -0.09150470793247223, -0.026273103430867195, 0.003255940740928054, 0.014529822394251823, -0.007782411761581898, 0.021575791761279106, -0.0028163969982415438, 0.031262338161468506, 0.02003655955195427, 0.03492465242743492, -0.0013186311116442084, -0.03192580118775368, 0.02797156758606434, 0.06544391065835953, -0.002499593887478113, -0.012094915844500065, 0.0027301469817757607, -0.01605578511953354, -0.006860199384391308, 0.006551689468324184, -0.009533951990306377, -0.032191187143325806, 0.006133708171546459, 0.027387719601392746, 0.022464830428361893, -0.0406038872897625, 0.004936158657073975, -0.023486562073230743, 0.028130797669291496, -0.002952406881377101, -0.02188098430633545, -0.027759259566664696, 0.0012083305045962334, 0.02501252479851246, 0.04275350645184517, -0.0213236752897501, -0.0018046172335743904, 0.05366082489490509, -0.04222273454070091, 0.0024614448193460703, -0.037525422871112823, -0.024627717211842537, 0.03795003890991211, 0.021854445338249207, 0.02649868093430996, -0.015087130479514599, -0.006972987670451403, 0.009945298545062542, 0.002199377166107297, 0.01519328448921442, 0.027361182495951653, -0.020275404676795006, -0.008850585669279099, 0.02077963575720787, -0.014211360365152359, -0.003516349708661437, -0.001206671935506165, -0.010840972885489464, -0.050476204603910446, -0.0012439916608855128, -0.014689053408801556, 0.019081173464655876, -0.0038646673783659935, -0.030360030010342598, -0.040126193314790726, -0.0035296189598739147, -0.07643084973096848, 0.05244005471467972, 0.02438887022435665, -0.03802965581417084, 0.006346016190946102, -0.00006810854392824695, -0.0000922627150430344, 0.04485004395246506, 0.01407866831868887, -0.015617900528013706, -0.012811454944312572, -0.00241334387101233, 0.0011411550221964717, 0.004159908276051283, -0.021841175854206085, -0.029431182891130447, -0.001786372042261064, -0.013972514308989048, -0.011809627525508404, 0.03075810894370079, 0.012851263396441936, -0.0213236752897501, -0.019691558554768562, 0.0011253977427259088, 0.01827174983918667, 0.010641934350132942, -0.0014579582493752241, 0.007311353459954262, 0.009487509727478027, -0.022849638015031815, -0.011869339272379875, 0.01985078863799572, 0.030625415965914726, 0.009500779211521149, 0.002993873320519924, 0.016122132539749146, -0.009673278778791428, -0.037366192787885666, -0.007079141680151224, -0.03179311007261276, 0.01154424250125885, 0.005234716925770044, 0.006953083910048008, -0.009865683503448963, 0.040126193314790726, 0.037074267864227295, -0.03155426308512688, -0.030890800058841705, 0.02208002284169197, 0.009381355717778206, -0.027865413576364517, 0.005715726874768734, 0.026989642530679703, 0.01839117333292961, 0.013421840965747833, -0.0023619255516678095, -0.0245746411383152, -0.013640782795846462, 0.011385011486709118, -0.0063393814489245415, 0.0024680793285369873, 0.006292939186096191, -0.016772324219346046, 0.060985445976257324, -0.03922388702630997, -0.013839821331202984, 0.012665493413805962, 0.01403886079788208, 0.00530769769102335, -0.0016420689644291997, 0.0035229844506829977, 0.01893521100282669, 0.014755399897694588, 0.017940018326044083, 0.00487313000485301, -0.012658858671784401, 0.013959244824945927, 0.016002709046006203, -0.012075012549757957, 0.024999255314469337, -0.00812077708542347, -0.007371065206825733, 0.01642732508480549, 0.03500426560640335, -0.02206675335764885, -0.00010097065387526527, -0.020991943776607513, 0.02614041045308113, -0.0016254824586212635, 0.0012356983497738838, -0.007875296287238598, -0.02760002762079239, -0.007742604240775108, 0.022371945902705193, 0.02584848739206791, 0.009215489961206913, 0.009520682506263256, -0.03266888111829758, 0.011975493282079697, 0.015365784987807274, -0.029484260827302933, 0.006760680116713047, 0.00890366267412901, 0.010920587927103043, -0.009918760508298874, -0.05679236724972725, 0.02243829146027565, -0.0031978879123926163, -0.007125583942979574, 0.005719044245779514, 0.0058451020158827305, 0.014277706854045391, 0.018908673897385597, -0.0058318329975008965, -0.01500751543790102, 0.026458872482180595, -0.03057233802974224, 0.0071056801825761795, 0.02400406263768673, -0.00793500803411007, 0.02344675548374653, -0.000002662919541762676, 0.02549021877348423, 0.0009197244653478265, -0.045938123017549515, 0.017780788242816925, -0.02142982929944992, 0.01689174771308899, 0.03914427012205124, 0.02594137191772461, -0.02391117811203003, 0.023765215650200844, -0.0018543768674135208, -0.0014289317186921835, 0.058596983551979065, -0.010170876048505306, 0.008412701077759266, -0.026724258437752724, 0.012546070851385593, 0.02640579640865326, 0.01159731950610876, -0.005722361616790295, -0.01671924814581871, -0.010728184133768082, 0.004047119524329901, 0.009799337014555931, 0.023685600608587265, 0.02392444759607315, 0.045938123017549515, 0.004169859923422337, 0.054616209119558334, -0.03314657136797905, -0.02900656871497631, -0.028369644656777382, 0.046866971999406815, -0.007570103742182255, -0.022000407800078392, 0.027082527056336403, -0.010748087428510189, 0.017568480223417282, 0.033756956458091736, -0.03537580370903015, -0.02180136740207672, 0.012778282165527344, 0.03842773288488388, 0.02687021903693676, 0.015525016002357006, 0.014211360365152359, -0.04968005046248436, -0.008140681311488152, 0.006249813828617334, 0.018125787377357483, 0.016785593703389168, -0.01986405812203884, 0.03009464591741562, 0.012546070851385593, -0.0011950613697990775, -0.023526370525360107, -0.0006609742413274944, -0.0006008479394949973, 0.018178865313529968, -0.025092141702771187, 0.0009188951808027923, -0.0016337756533175707, -0.010290298610925674, 0.0012240877840667963, 0.009985106065869331, -0.003954234998673201, -0.004501590970903635, 0.014821745455265045, -0.009275201708078384, 0.03704772889614105, 0.0246675256639719, 0.003911109641194344, 0.027732720598578453, -0.02538406476378441, -0.04293927550315857, -0.059976983815431595, 0.013654052279889584, -0.0006800487753935158, -0.043629273772239685, -0.014715591445565224, -0.005231399554759264, -0.008717893622815609, 0.01588328555226326, -0.020262135192751884, -0.01828501932322979, -0.013030397705733776, -0.017422517761588097, -0.017608286812901497, -0.00186432886403054, 0.01763482578098774, -0.003987407777458429, -0.010237221606075764, -0.016745787113904953, -0.018775980919599533, 0.005937987007200718, 0.009500779211521149, -0.0013833186822012067, 0.008711258880794048, -0.012274051085114479, 0.004667456727474928, 0.03221772611141205, -0.002536084270104766, 0.008266739547252655, 0.008286642841994762, 0.012101550586521626, -0.004053754266351461, 0.021827906370162964, -0.03211157023906708, -0.021920790895819664, -0.018125787377357483, 0.021018482744693756, -0.03112964704632759, 0.007536930963397026, 0.03787042200565338, 0.021907521411776543, -0.012857898138463497, -0.007026064675301313, -0.017342902719974518, -0.02254444546997547, -0.02383156307041645, -0.006551689468324184, -0.008067700080573559, 0.03580041974782944, 0.012725205160677433, 0.0016694368096068501, -0.007789046503603458, 0.02871464379131794, 0.025875026360154152, -0.02558310329914093, -0.024893103167414665, -0.01334222499281168, -0.027945028617978096, -0.023287523537874222, -0.007782411761581898, 0.028051182627677917, 0.006336064077913761, -0.012930878438055515, -0.022305600345134735, 0.020527521148324013, 0.018218671903014183, -0.003093392588198185, 0.03354464843869209, 0.03312003239989281, 0.005526640452444553, 0.00788856577128172, -0.012260781601071358, -0.015724053606390953, 0.009965202771127224, -0.029776183888316154, -0.01892194151878357, 0.016958093270659447, -0.004886399023234844, 0.0060905832797288895, 0.015485208481550217, -0.02530444972217083, -0.015418861992657185, 0.004130052402615547, -0.00872452836483717, 0.012625685892999172, 0.0004283477901481092, 0.004975966643542051, 0.006700968369841576, 0.0674077644944191, -0.02900656871497631, -0.008764335885643959, -0.027998104691505432, 0.03176657110452652, -0.003907792270183563, -0.0031298829708248377, -0.008936836384236813, 0.06156929209828377, 0.02863502874970436, -0.0009935346897691488, -0.025649448856711388, 0.008352989330887794, 0.001465422217734158, 0.0688939169049263, -0.010343375615775585, -0.012599147856235504, 0.03460618853569031, 0.008790873922407627, 0.017117325216531754, -0.0058318329975008965, -0.00009018939454108477, 0.010993569158017635, 0.01496770791709423, 0.011836165562272072, 0.0472915880382061, 0.011988761834800243, 0.01510039996355772, -0.008664816617965698, 0.02473387122154236, 0.006034188903868198, 0.008326450362801552, -0.015923094004392624, 0.00964674074202776, -0.00987231731414795, -0.01255933940410614, -0.013037032447755337, 0.02530444972217083, 0.014277706854045391, 0.011099723167717457, -0.0022109877318143845, -0.0034035611897706985, 0.0034234649501740932, 0.010947126895189285, 0.0015939680160954595, 0.013760206289589405, 0.03388965129852295, 0.050184283405542374, -0.013999052345752716, -0.014728860929608345, -0.005669284611940384, 0.001246479689143598, -0.0073179882019758224, -0.004047119524329901, -0.00784212350845337, 0.004757023882120848, -0.01744905672967434, 0.010223953053355217, 0.02559637278318405, -0.03396926447749138, -0.01799309439957142, -0.017701171338558197, -0.0216023288667202, 0.01568424701690674, 0.006946449168026447, 0.0011171045480296016, -0.00486981263384223, 0.013906167820096016, -0.0011411550221964717, 0.026896758005023003, -0.006535102613270283, -0.004461783450096846, 0.02807772159576416, 0.010495971888303757, 0.03333234041929245, 0.02391117811203003, -0.011796358041465282, 0.024455217644572258, -0.026551757007837296, -0.008923566900193691, 0.00016472522111143917, 0.011663665995001793, 0.03630465269088745, 0.0016122132074087858, -0.030598876997828484, 0.000689171371050179, -0.012048473581671715, -0.019718097522854805, -0.023526370525360107, 0.03667619079351425, -0.029404645785689354, -0.015365784987807274, 0.03057233802974224, 0.014198091812431812, -0.008406066335737705, 0.006067362148314714, -0.026657911017537117, -0.017687901854515076, 0.018975019454956055, -0.0024332476314157248, -0.0019538961350917816, 0.013527994975447655, -0.015365784987807274, -0.008644912391901016, 0.0007389310630969703, -0.006966353394091129, -0.021668676286935806, 0.01994367502629757, -0.010894049890339375, 0.005964525509625673, 0.005675919353961945, 0.024229640141129494, 0.00404048478230834, -0.010091260075569153, 0.003406878560781479, 0.022969061508774757, -0.0024398823734372854, 0.0035030804574489594, -0.020819444209337234, -0.01718367077410221, 0.0058218808844685555, 0.017104055732488632, 0.00788856577128172, -0.005971159785985947, -0.005178322549909353, -0.03516349568963051, 0.01339530199766159, -0.06608083844184875, 0.00100929185282439, 0.0018626701785251498, -0.007961547002196312, 0.02125732973217964, 0.013090109452605247, 0.01334222499281168, -0.0033819987438619137, -0.0061502945609390736, -0.01920059695839882, -0.009268566966056824, 0.012725205160677433, 0.03649042174220085, 0.019280212000012398, -0.023048676550388336, -0.003390291938558221, -0.018523864448070526, 0.011199242435395718, -0.006017602048814297, 0.0009280177764594555, -0.00798145029693842, -0.011066549457609653, 0.023513101041316986, 0.0028047864325344563, 0.02401733212172985, 0.013508090749382973, 0.03325272724032402, 0.016467131674289703, -0.01910771243274212, -0.03176657110452652, 0.025901565328240395, -0.020155981183052063, -0.030041569843888283, -0.013999052345752716, 0.022756753489375114, -0.019784443080425262, -0.007921738550066948, 0.026565026491880417, 0.016546746715903282, 0.015644438564777374, 0.039011579006910324, -0.03649042174220085, -0.009275201708078384, -0.008114143274724483, -0.033199649304151535, 0.026936566457152367, -0.01857694238424301, -0.026339448988437653, -0.040763117372989655, 0.01141155045479536, 0.006773949135094881, -0.03020079992711544, 0.026166949421167374, -0.0022673821076750755, -0.036357730627059937, 0.03304041922092438, 0.023884639143943787, -0.02530444972217083, 0.0020169250201433897, 0.024786949157714844, 0.012293954379856586, 0.009514047764241695, 0.015564823523163795, 0.020885789766907692, -0.015816939994692802, -0.0006783900898881257, 0.0015923093305900693, 0.008432604372501373, 0.04453158378601074, 0.013182993978261948, -0.020368289202451706, 0.029776183888316154, 0.0051351976580917835, -0.03877273201942444, -0.006926545407623053, -0.0018228624248877168, -0.02279656194150448, -0.01995694264769554, 0.004564620088785887, 0.025410601869225502, 0.024773679673671722, -0.008200393058359623, -0.004518177825957537, 0.023314062505960464, -0.01417155284434557, -0.025078872218728065, 0.009540586732327938, 0.009713087230920792, 0.008671451359987259, 0.020554060116410255, 0.012446551583707333, -0.0009570442489348352, 0.039568886160850525, 0.022119829431176186, -0.02890041470527649, 0.02945772185921669, -0.0022491367999464273, 0.012048473581671715, 0.03184618800878525, 0.03972811624407768, 0.002043463522568345, 0.022690407931804657, -0.004239523317664862, 0.0003742341650649905, -0.05631467327475548, -0.005165053531527519, -0.004737120121717453, -0.023247715085744858, 0.01642732508480549, -0.02623329684138298, 0.023950986564159393, 0.005188274662941694, 0.009142509661614895, -0.0010515876347199082, 0.0006016772822476923, 0.024057140573859215, 0.031262338161468506, 0.014211360365152359, 0.03232387825846672, 0.02170848287642002, -0.003406878560781479, -0.03914427012205124, -0.04203696548938751, -0.02428271621465683, 0.038852348923683167, -0.013567802496254444, -0.008280008099973202, 0.048910435289144516, -0.032085031270980835, 0.03593311458826065, 0.006618035491555929, -0.007908469997346401, -0.01053578034043312, 0.007782411761581898, 0.04904312640428543, 0.02696310356259346, -0.010031548328697681, 0.037366192787885666, 0.004266061820089817, -0.024587908759713173, 0.02752041257917881, -0.0007181978435255587, -0.020527521148324013, 0.011530973017215729, -0.03298734128475189, -0.024879833683371544, -0.004624331835657358, -0.0040902444161474705, 0.023592716082930565, -0.01930675096809864, 0.020845983177423477, 0.011484530754387379, -0.0021247377153486013, 0.0246675256639719, -0.026843681931495667, 0.014609438367187977, -0.01912098191678524, 0.02916579879820347, 0.017382709309458733, 0.002647214336320758, 0.012705300934612751, 0.007749238517135382, 0.04684043303132057, 0.009308374486863613, 0.023950986564159393, 0.038852348923683167, -0.018988288938999176, -0.0035229844506829977, -0.009660010226070881, 0.018709633499383926, -0.012884436175227165, 0.007185295689851046, 0.0036855326034128666, 0.017011171206831932, -0.05169697478413582, -0.011006837710738182, 0.01519328448921442, 0.022783292457461357, 0.013508090749382973, 0.023791754618287086, 0.011438088491559029, -0.018032902851700783, -0.015644438564777374, 0.01343510951846838, 0.013143186457455158, -0.012692032381892204, 0.021854445338249207, 0.013932706788182259, 0.032828111201524734, 0.0022590889129787683, 0.03136849403381348, 0.005818563513457775, 0.037180423736572266, 0.010303568094968796, 0.028794260695576668, 0.016865208745002747, 0.014105206355452538, -0.004169859923422337, -0.011564146727323532, 0.004295917693525553, 0.03362426534295082, 0.019824251532554626, 0.006014285143464804, 0.0211379062384367, -0.009149143472313881, 0.017104055732488632, 0.005221447441726923, 0.013196263462305069, 0.005490149836987257, 0.023579446598887444, 0.035243112593889236, -0.0020716607104986906, -0.027865413576364517, -0.01771444082260132, -0.02104502171278, -0.021628867834806442, -0.03221772611141205, -0.011026741936802864, -0.013654052279889584, -0.0038016384933143854, 0.018882134929299355, -0.010210683569312096, -0.04349658265709877, 0.017064247280359268, -0.0008396943449042737, 0.019465981051325798, 0.004203033167868853, 0.019996751099824905, -0.00983250979334116, 0.035402342677116394, -0.022650599479675293, -0.016294632107019424, -0.05456313118338585, -0.041426580399274826, 0.029033105820417404, -0.041506197303533554, 0.006445535458624363, -0.009660010226070881, 0.03120926208794117, -0.00267872866243124, 0.0010043159127235413, -0.011935684829950333, -0.030678492039442062, -0.008160585537552834, -0.0026870218571275473, 0.011471261270344257, 0.032270800322294235, -0.039197348058223724, -0.023685600608587265, -0.0017332950374111533, 0.041426580399274826, 0.03195234015583992, -0.007556834723800421, -0.004677408374845982, 0.01801963336765766, -0.024362333118915558, -0.018258480355143547, -0.010396452620625496, 0.0471058189868927, 0.006551689468324184, -0.0002910940384026617, -0.025914834812283516 ]
11.559106
4.971068
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.532..270G
[ "jellyfish galaxies", "jellyfish candidates", "future galaxy image surveys", "Hydra galaxies", "Galaxies", "galaxies", "human visual biases", "visual classifiers", "Jellyfish candidates", "elevated star formation rates" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
10
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1410", "10.48550/arXiv.2406.04213" ]
[ "Gondhalekar, Yash", "Chies-Santos, Ana L.", "de Souza, Rafael S.", "Queiroz, Carolina", "Lopes, Amanda R.", "Ferrari, Fabricio", "Azevedo, Gabriel M.", "Monteiro-Pereira, Hellen", "Overzier, Roderik", "Smith Castelli, Analía V.", "Jaffé, Yara L.", "Haack, Rodrigo F.", "Rahna, P. T.", "Shen, Shiyin", "Mu, Zihao", "Lima-Dias, Ciria", "Barbosa, Carlos E.", "Oliveira Schwarz, Gustavo B.", "Riffel, Rogério", "Jimenez-Teja, Yolanda", "Grossi, Marco", "Mendes de Oliveira, Claudia L.", "Schoenell, William", "Ribeiro, Thiago", "Kanaan, Antonio" ]
[ "Department of CSIS, BITS Pilani K.K Birla Goa Campus, Goa 403726, Goa, India", "Instituto de Física, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS), Av. Bento Gonçalves, 9500 Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil", "Centre for Astrophysics Research, University of Hertfordshire, College Lane, Hatfield AL10 9AB, UK", "Departamento de Física Matemática, Instituto de Física, Universidade de São Paulo, Rua do Matão, 1371, CEP 05508-090, São Paulo, Brazil", "Instituto de Astrofísica de La Plata, UNLP-CONICET, Paseo del Bosque s/n, La Plata B1900FWA, Argentina", "Instituto de Matemática Estatística e Física, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande, 96203-900, Rio Grande, RS, Brazil", "Instituto de Física, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS), Av. Bento Gonçalves, 9500 Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil", "Instituto de Física, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS), Av. Bento Gonçalves, 9500 Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil", "Observatório Nacional, Rua General José Cristino, 77, São Cristóvão, 20921-400 Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil; Leiden Observatory, Leiden University, Niels Bohrweg 2, NL-2333 CA Leiden, the Netherlands", "Instituto de Astrofísica de La Plata, UNLP-CONICET, Paseo del Bosque s/n, La Plata B1900FWA, Argentina; Facultad de Ciencias Astrónomicas y Geofísicas, Universidad Nacional de La Plata, Paseo del Bosque s/n, La Plata B1900FWA, Argentina", "Departamento de Física, Universidad Técnica Federico Santa María, Avenida España 1600, 2390123 Valparaíso, Chile", "Instituto de Astrofísica de La Plata, UNLP-CONICET, Paseo del Bosque s/n, La Plata B1900FWA, Argentina; Facultad de Ciencias Astrónomicas y Geofísicas, Universidad Nacional de La Plata, Paseo del Bosque s/n, La Plata B1900FWA, Argentina", "Centro de Estudios de Física del Cosmos de Aragón (CEFCA), Plaza San Juan, 1, E-44001 Teruel, Spain", "Shanghai Astronomical Observatory, Chinese Academy of Sciences, 200030 Shanghai, China", "Shanghai Astronomical Observatory, Chinese Academy of Sciences, 200030 Shanghai, China", "Instituto Multidisciplinario de Investigación y Postgrado, Universidad de La Serena, Raúl Bitrán 1305, 1700000 La Serena, Chile", "Universidade de São Paulo, IAG, Rua do Mato 1225, 05508-900 Sao Paulo, SP, Brazil", "Universidade de São Paulo, IAG, Rua do Mato 1225, 05508-900 Sao Paulo, SP, Brazil; Universidade Presbiteriana Mackenzie, R. da Consolação, 930 - Consolação, 01302-907 São Paulo, Brazil", "Instituto de Física, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS), Av. Bento Gonçalves, 9500 Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil; Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias, Calle Vía Láctea s/n, E-38205 La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucía-CSIC, Glorieta de la Astronomía s/n, E-18008 Granada, Spain", "Observatório do Valongo, Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, 20080-090 Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil", "Universidade de São Paulo, IAG, Rua do Mato 1225, 05508-900 Sao Paulo, SP, Brazil", "GMTO Corporation 465 N. Halstead Street, Suite 250 Pasadena, CA 91107, USA", "Rubin Observatory Project Office, 950 N. Cherry Ave., Tucson, AZ 85719, USA", "Departamento de Física - CFM - Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, PO BOx 476, 88040-900 Florianópolis, SC, Brazil" ]
null
[ "1972ApJ...176....1G", "1980ApJ...236..351D", "1980ApJ...237..692L", "1984ARA&A..22..445H", "1985A&AS...61...93H", "1996A&AS..117..393B", "1998ApJ...498..541K", "1999AJ....117..181K", "1999MNRAS.308..947A", "2001ApJ...546..681T", "2001ApJ...548L.139D", "2002ApJ...567..716R", "2003MNRAS.346..601G", "2004AJ....128..163L", "2006ApJS..162...49H", "2006PASA...23..135M", "2006PASP..118..517B", "2007CSE.....9...90H", "2007PASP..119...30P", "2010MNRAS.408.1417S", "2012A&A...545A..37A", "2012ApJ...757...22C", "2013A&A...558A..33A", "2013MNRAS.429.1747M", "2013MNRAS.430.3017B", "2014ApJ...780..119K", "2014MNRAS.445.4335F", "2015A&A...580A..47V", "2015ApJ...814...55F", "2015ApJS..219....4S", "2015ApJS..219...12A", "2015ApJS..220....1A", "2015MNRAS.447.2603L", "2015MNRAS.448.1715J", "2015MNRAS.451.3427H", "2016AJ....151...78P", "2016ApJ...829...49W", "2016MNRAS.455.2994M", "2016arXiv160803983L", "2017ApJ...840L...7S", "2017ApJ...843..128R", "2017ApJ...844...48P", "2017ApJ...846...27G", "2017ExA....43..131S", "2017MNRAS.471..182W", "2017arXiv171105101L", "2018A&A...614A..57F", "2018AJ....156..123A", "2018ApJ...866L..25V", "2018MNRAS.475.3654Z", "2018MNRAS.475.4055M", "2018MNRAS.476.4753J", "2018MNRAS.479.4126G", "2019A&A...622A.103B", "2019A&A...622A.176C", "2019A&A...622A.180L", "2019A&A...623A...1I", "2019ApJ...887..155P", "2019JPhCS1168b2022Y", "2019MNRAS.482.4466P", "2019MNRAS.483.1042Y", "2019MNRAS.484..892R", "2019MNRAS.484..906R", "2019MNRAS.484.1702P", "2019MNRAS.487.4580R", "2019MNRAS.489..241M", "2019arXiv190911230A", "2019arXiv190912031L", "2020A&A...640A..22R", "2020AJ....159..170T", "2020ApJ...889....9M", "2020ApJ...899...13G", "2020ApJ...899...98V", "2020ApJS..251...28G", "2020MNRAS.494.5029D", "2020NatMe..17..261V", "2020Natur.585..357H", "2020arXiv200805659X", "2021A&A...648A..63D", "2021A&A...650A.111R", "2021A&A...652A.153R", "2021ApJ...911L..33H", "2021ApJ...915...70W", "2021ApJ...921..177S", "2021MNRAS.500...40R", "2021MNRAS.500.1323L", "2021MNRAS.501.5073O", "2021MNRAS.506.1927V", "2021MNRAS.506.3079K", "2021RemS...13.2181I", "2021arXiv210104293A", "2021arXiv210313559C", "2021arXiv211004403Z", "2021arXiv211013151S", "2021arXiv211210740E", "2022A&A...662A..84D", "2022A&ARv..30....3B", "2022ApJ...927...91V", "2022ApJ...932..107S", "2022ApJ...934...86S", "2022ApJ...937...18B", "2022Entrp..24..551A", "2022ISPM...39c..42E", "2022MNRAS.511.4590A", "2022MNRAS.515.5877K", "2022MNRAS.516.3068S", "2022RNAAS...6..128G", "2023A&A...670L..20R", "2023A&A...673A.146S", "2023A&A...675A.108K", "2023ApJ...958...73G", "2023MNRAS.518.5260P", "2023MNRAS.523.4680A", "2023MNRAS.524.3502R", "2023MNRAS.525.3551G", "2023MNRAS.526.6391X", "2024MNRAS.527.8257Z", "2024MNRAS.528.1125K", "2024MNRAS.530.3195H", "2024MNRAS.530.3787S" ]
29096908
2405.04270
Very Long Baseline Array Observations of Parsec-scale Radio Emission in Dual Active Galactic Nuclei
It is believed that dual active galactic nuclei (AGN) form during galaxy mergers. Studying dual-AGN emission can provide valuable insights into galaxy merging and evolution. To investigate parsec-scale radio emission properties, we observed eight radio components of four selected dual-AGN systems using the Very Long Baseline Array (VLBA) at 5 GHz in multiple-phase-center mode. Among them, two compact radio components, labeled J0051+0020B and J2300-0005A, were detected clearly on parsec scales for the first time. However, the radio emission of the other six components was resolved out in the high-resolution images. We provide the values or upper limits of the brightness temperature and radio emission power, and analyze the emission origins in detail for each target. Based on their physical properties reported in this work and in the literature, we suggest that the radio emission in J0051+0020B and J2300-0005A originates primarily from compact jets, while the other six sources show more complex emission mechanisms. In addition, our VLBA observations suggest that the systematic X-ray deficit in our dual-AGN sample is likely attributed to the tidally induced effect and possibly a viewing angle effect.
[ -0.02029070258140564, 0.03098445199429989, 0.006605695933103561, -0.036842335015535355, -0.04434540495276451, 0.04207703471183777, -0.022883126512169838, -0.013572835363447666, 0.015915988013148308, -0.024303974583745003, -0.015380053780972958, -0.0010266870958730578, -0.03342731297016144, -0.04611523449420929, -0.0009519056766293943, 0.007652636151760817, -0.01992926001548767, 0.0031470530666410923, 0.013622689992189407, 0.02056490257382393, -0.031134014949202538, -0.02148720622062683, 0.008655954152345657, 0.007945530116558075, -0.04611523449420929, -0.059825170785188675, -0.022808345034718513, 0.05097603052854538, 0.005991864483803511, -0.04015764594078064, 0.025114107877016068, -0.0157414972782135, -0.005546291824430227, -0.02136257104575634, -0.05284556746482849, 0.05922691896557808, -0.004165950696915388, -0.006668013520538807, -0.03557104989886284, -0.012264159508049488, 0.028491737321019173, -0.006487291771918535, -0.04474424198269844, -0.0007100343937054276, 0.010151583701372147, -0.026597272604703903, -0.04135414958000183, -0.03215602785348892, -0.0025005051866173744, -0.0004432359419297427, -0.014918901957571507, 0.035371631383895874, 0.027245379984378815, 0.011422867886722088, -0.024279048666357994, -0.032255735248327255, 0.003016185713931918, 0.029314333572983742, 0.002129713771864772, -0.03108416125178337, -0.01943071559071541, -0.038886360824108124, 0.03462381660938263, -0.01065012626349926, -0.004228268284350634, -0.01297458354383707, -0.0019598975777626038, -0.0001788718072930351, 0.06137065216898918, -0.029987366870045662, 0.01943071559071541, -0.00574570894241333, -0.014308186247944832, -0.02649756520986557, 0.04205210879445076, -0.016975391656160355, -0.00493557658046484, -0.01858319342136383, -0.0037110301200300455, 0.021225471049547195, 0.03417512774467468, 0.03168241307139397, -0.009590722620487213, -0.02298283576965332, 0.009995788335800171, 0.01425833161920309, -0.014021524228155613, 0.0024849255569279194, -0.06351438909769058, -0.007521768566220999, 0.03041112795472145, -0.0010578461224213243, 0.00021577566803898662, -0.027669141069054604, 0.03517221286892891, 0.025774676352739334, 0.014108768664300442, -0.03003722056746483, 0.08604853600263596, 0.04609030857682228, 0.003848129417747259, 0.02536337822675705, 0.006935980636626482, -0.030211711302399635, 0.03260471671819687, -0.017461471259593964, 0.023630941286683083, 0.009547099471092224, 0.02744479663670063, -0.00392602663487196, 0.05339396372437477, 0.02310747094452381, 0.0014395430916920304, 0.041428931057453156, -0.06007444113492966, -0.026273220777511597, -0.08026543259620667, 0.014707020483911037, 0.010837079957127571, 0.009908543899655342, 0.004602175671607256, 0.05035284906625748, -0.0007614466594532132, -0.013011974282562733, 0.028765935450792313, -0.000010163170372834429, 0.01782291568815708, -0.0495053268969059, -0.028018120676279068, 0.006512219086289406, -0.010226365178823471, -0.04272514209151268, 0.03878664970397949, 0.021561987698078156, -0.05788085237145424, -0.01877014711499214, 0.032405298203229904, -0.06605695933103561, -0.02986272983253002, 0.007297424133867025, 0.0090173976495862, 0.029139842838048935, 0.044819023460149765, 0.004748622886836529, -0.008194801397621632, 0.03098445199429989, -0.049430545419454575, -0.0010266870958730578, -0.030062148347496986, -0.019443180412054062, -0.04085560515522957, -0.00857494119554758, 0.003848129417747259, -0.05032792314887047, -0.02157445251941681, -0.018022332340478897, 0.0037577685434371233, 0.009297828190028667, -0.022820809856057167, -0.041703127324581146, -0.021138226613402367, -0.00426254328340292, -0.015454835258424282, 0.0339258573949337, 0.016028160229325294, 0.029563603922724724, -0.024279048666357994, 0.0027778197545558214, -0.07876980304718018, 0.00950347725301981, -0.03272935375571251, -0.029164770618081093, -0.017548715695738792, -0.028566518798470497, -0.040780823677778244, 0.00039474485674872994, 0.0003809180634561926, -0.055238571017980576, -0.03340238705277443, -0.0014925133436918259, -0.00014040998939890414, 0.05189833417534828, 0.05339396372437477, -0.012120828963816166, -0.0037546525709331036, 0.03744058683514595, -0.03502264991402626, 0.04878244176506996, 0.021337643265724182, -0.050651974976062775, -0.00633461307734251, 0.024428611621260643, -0.0036954504903405905, 0.048732586205005646, 0.014495139941573143, -0.01974230632185936, -0.015467299148440361, 0.0032249505165964365, -0.05354352667927742, 0.017336836084723473, 0.06765229254961014, 0.014869047328829765, 0.050901249051094055, -0.05459046736359596, -0.04459467902779579, -0.06062283739447594, 0.035222068428993225, -0.0009075041743926704, 0.007864517159759998, 0.004814056679606438, 0.033601801842451096, -0.0060541825369000435, -0.0009869595523923635, -0.0017807335825636983, -0.03863708674907684, -0.021437352523207664, -0.023543696850538254, 0.041852690279483795, 0.030635472387075424, -0.032380372285842896, 0.042924560606479645, 0.000053262316214386374, 0.006153890863060951, 0.02298283576965332, 0.03823825344443321, 0.006805113051086664, 0.05454061180353165, -0.024490928277373314, 0.05518871918320656, 0.02172401361167431, 0.002893107710406184, 0.0027310813311487436, 0.0031174521427601576, 0.001424742629751563, 0.0077024903148412704, 0.02426658384501934, 0.045766253024339676, 0.01580381579697132, 0.010394623503088951, -0.027918411418795586, -0.03325282409787178, 0.012675457634031773, 0.00823842454701662, 0.0259740948677063, 0.010899397544562817, 0.021462280303239822, -0.010444477200508118, -0.018146967515349388, 0.02083910070359707, 0.011198523454368114, 0.03382614627480507, -0.0018041027942672372, -0.005247165914624929, 0.010226365178823471, -0.0057332455180585384, 0.004926228895783424, -0.023693259805440903, 0.02662220038473606, -0.048607949167490005, 0.0291896965354681, 0.00328103662468493, -0.00515680480748415, -0.030087074264883995, 0.014956292696297169, -0.03694204241037369, 0.05027806758880615, 0.01595337875187397, 0.006013676058501005, -0.03218095377087593, -0.03295369818806648, -0.058877937495708466, -0.05743216350674629, 0.06336482614278793, -0.062268029898405075, -0.061570070683956146, 0.02906506136059761, 0.019505497068166733, 0.030535763129591942, 0.04868273064494133, -0.026422783732414246, -0.02961345948278904, 0.01628989540040493, 0.02622336521744728, 0.011902716010808945, -0.014856583438813686, -0.018084650859236717, -0.018894782289862633, -0.00016426604997832328, 0.004972967319190502, -0.03619422763586044, 0.07642665505409241, 0.015691643580794334, 0.028043048456311226, -0.02702103555202484, -0.019817087799310684, -0.04202718287706375, 0.059974733740091324, -0.014009060338139534, -0.024790054187178612, 0.011784312315285206, 0.030859816819429398, 0.0354464128613472, 0.03173226863145828, -0.026198439300060272, -0.01514324638992548, 0.03504757955670357, 0.03596988320350647, 0.05568725988268852, -0.006649318151175976, 0.04748622700572014, 0.047660719603300095, -0.03624408319592476, 0.011086351238191128, -0.011204755865037441, -0.05917706340551376, -0.010083033703267574, -0.008419145829975605, 0.028416955843567848, 0.020253311842679977, -0.03043605387210846, 0.009260437451303005, -0.017336836084723473, 0.002023773267865181, -0.022995298728346825, -0.014058914966881275, -0.029688240960240364, 0.0059856330044567585, -0.027918411418795586, -0.022272411733865738, -0.03168241307139397, 0.03287891671061516, 0.013186464086174965, 0.08395465463399887, 0.02304515428841114, -0.008531318046152592, -0.055388133972883224, -0.023032689467072487, 0.044420186430215836, -0.047261882573366165, -0.03674262389540672, -0.025600187480449677, 0.00854378193616867, 0.0028650646563619375, 0.03921041265130043, 0.00020759645849466324, 0.04205210879445076, 0.053344108164310455, 0.00964057631790638, 0.030485909432172775, 0.029239552095532417, 0.0027731459122151136, -0.04190254583954811, 0.0008965985616669059, -0.0017807335825636983, 0.04666363075375557, -0.06436190754175186, 0.006935980636626482, -0.037365805357694626, -0.025899313390254974, 0.02557525970041752, -0.014956292696297169, 0.01744900830090046, 0.030460981652140617, 0.00849392730742693, -0.002555033192038536, -0.012862411327660084, -0.018209286034107208, 0.009927239269018173, -0.06924763321876526, -0.022633856162428856, 0.04392164573073387, 0.025749750435352325, -0.009304060600697994, 0.03357687592506409, -0.07353510707616806, 0.006599463988095522, 0.062417592853307724, -0.011721993796527386, -0.0009043883183039725, 0.01766088791191578, 0.061619922518730164, -0.045915815979242325, 0.0074843778274953365, -0.03921041265130043, -0.025114107877016068, 0.006512219086289406, 0.019268689677119255, -0.05718288943171501, -0.051599208265542984, 0.013074291869997978, -0.06451147049665451, -0.010911861434578896, 0.03257979080080986, -0.02936418727040291, 0.014669629745185375, 0.0011131531791761518, 0.01393427886068821, 0.0702945739030838, -0.004299934022128582, 0.0727374330163002, 0.011871556751430035, -0.01738668978214264, -0.01265053078532219, -0.027070889249444008, -0.022758491337299347, -0.016539165750145912, -0.006848735734820366, 0.04474424198269844, 0.01616525836288929, -0.011902716010808945, 0.050627049058675766, 0.02624829299747944, 0.03297862410545349, -0.009740285575389862, 0.025288596749305725, 0.049280982464551926, -0.013535444624722004, 0.0476856455206871, -0.026971179991960526, 0.035496268421411514, -0.0005359338247217238, -0.023855285719037056, 0.03016185574233532, 0.009596954099833965, -0.021138226613402367, -0.039684027433395386, 0.029962439090013504, 0.016127867624163628, 0.023705722764134407, -0.011204755865037441, -0.022883126512169838, 0.0013577508507296443, -0.01132315956056118, -0.03734087571501732, -0.019331008195877075, 0.024503393098711967, 0.01671365648508072, 0.010656358674168587, -0.021948358044028282, 0.018969563767313957, 0.008350596763193607, 0.021188080310821533, 0.0028884338680654764, 0.007752344943583012, -0.011765616945922375, 0.0027747037820518017, 0.004748622886836529, 0.04100516811013222, 0.06615666300058365, -0.06695433706045151, -0.023095007985830307, -0.07592810690402985, 0.011098815128207207, 0.01882000081241131, -0.02555033192038536, -0.015130782499909401, 0.049580108374357224, 0.003598857903853059, 0.03517221286892891, -0.018483484163880348, 0.012937192805111408, -0.031158942729234695, -0.02313239872455597, 0.002277718624100089, -0.023007763549685478, 0.006353308446705341, -0.008120019920170307, 0.007746112998574972, -0.024777591228485107, 0.0171124916523695, -0.0015470414655283093, -0.04803462699055672, -0.018907245248556137, 0.019206371158361435, -0.00442456966266036, 0.012631835415959358, 0.013822106644511223, -0.02148720622062683, 0.05952604487538338, 0.0014823867240920663, 0.011834166012704372, 0.004888838157057762, -0.004337324760854244, 0.0017293213168159127, 0.03741565719246864, 0.027768848463892937, -0.01346066314727068, 0.04372222721576691, 0.015579471364617348, -0.014893974177539349, 0.0036642916966229677, -0.022210093215107918, 0.0330035500228405, -0.011946338228881359, 0.039559394121170044, -0.017860306426882744, -0.06321526318788528, -0.021661696955561638, 0.030735179781913757, 0.012532126158475876, 0.0586785189807415, -0.009129569865763187, 0.04743637517094612, -0.02879086323082447, 0.049280982464551926, 0.013585299253463745, -0.018844928592443466, -0.01555454358458519, -0.03267949819564819, -0.0038637088146060705, 0.02824246510863304, 0.019754769280552864, -0.017075100913643837, -0.04235123470425606, -0.035346705466508865, -0.0007929950952529907, -0.044968586415052414, 0.035246994346380234, -0.0015805372968316078, -0.024029776453971863, 0.016888147220015526, -0.009677967056632042, 0.01641453057527542, 0.012370100244879723, 0.014158623293042183, 0.004184646066278219, -0.00871204026043415, -0.05032792314887047, -0.040905460715293884, -0.01459484826773405, 0.0012954330304637551, -0.03559597581624985, -0.019605206325650215, 0.0012572633568197489, -0.005378033500164747, -0.04294948652386665, 0.0022247484885156155, 0.011410404928028584, -0.03611944615840912, -0.009117106907069683, -0.0009067252394743264, -0.00039493959047831595, -0.03579539433121681, -0.01708756387233734, 0.025924239307641983, 0.029912585392594337, -0.0016560978256165981, -0.005365570075809956, 0.01717480830848217, 0.03975880891084671, 0.002072069561108947, -0.010662590153515339, 0.010058106854557991, 0.020552437752485275, 0.00013651511108037084, -0.0023447105195373297, -0.014370503835380077, -0.0216990876942873, 0.02206053026020527, -0.0076339407823979855, -0.025774676352739334, 0.002614235272631049, -0.0016872567357495427, 0.0391107052564621, 0.010837079957127571, -0.03906084969639778, 0.010126655921339989, -0.013610226102173328, -0.045342493802309036, -0.0040413145907223225, -0.026472637429833412, -0.03135836124420166, 0.006128964014351368, 0.018695365637540817, 0.007253801915794611, -0.01132315956056118, -0.034000638872385025, 0.02184865064918995, -0.013522980734705925, -0.04843346029520035, -0.04167820140719414, -0.02637292817234993, 0.0025488014798611403, 0.020303167402744293, -0.004954271949827671, -0.03599480912089348, -0.011042729020118713, -0.0053312950767576694, 0.025674968957901, -0.023518769070506096, 0.012370100244879723, -0.026148583739995956, 0.007646404206752777, -0.004215804859995842, -0.03689218685030937, -0.00818856991827488, 0.035895101726055145, 0.002463114447891712, -0.0008677765144966543, -0.02622336521744728, 0.03272935375571251, 0.014420358464121819, -0.0446196049451828, -0.009970861487090588, 0.0029959322419017553, -0.03582032024860382, 0.010556649416685104, -0.011310695670545101, -0.020303167402744293, 0.006711636204272509, 0.011055192910134792, 0.0052627455443143845, -0.02178633213043213, -0.008082629181444645, 0.0018664206145331264, 0.0015727475984022021, -0.014731948263943195, -0.011746921576559544, 0.004969851113855839, -0.0009238626225851476, -0.023543696850538254, -0.011678371578454971, -0.0024553246330469847, 0.025139033794403076, 0.02879086323082447, 0.014756875112652779, -0.03220588341355324, -0.04987923428416252, 0.02756943181157112, -0.008817980997264385, -0.0071790204383432865, -0.017548715695738792, 0.050078652799129486, 0.028741007670760155, -0.014968755654990673, -0.015454835258424282, -0.0033963248133659363, -0.000036855184589512646, -0.010488100349903107, -0.03190675750374794, 0.016127867624163628, 0.03691711649298668, 0.03609452024102211, -0.05459046736359596, -0.008761894889175892, -0.005558755248785019, 0.007552927825599909, -0.040082864463329315, -0.015267881564795971, -0.016638875007629395, -0.008961311541497707, -0.008400450460612774, 0.01717480830848217, 0.013809642754495144, 0.03031141869723797, 0.00791437178850174, 0.004926228895783424, -0.01447021309286356, -0.05169891566038132, 0.04175298288464546, -0.015130782499909401, -0.012675457634031773, 0.00807016622275114, -0.025924239307641983, -0.0032311822287738323, 0.009459855034947395, 0.015130782499909401, 0.005677159409970045, -0.021861113607883453, 0.013522980734705925, 0.0632651150226593, -0.04883229359984398, 0.029663313180208206, 0.04696275666356087, 0.010943020693957806, 0.0052658612839877605, -0.005779983941465616, 0.023792969062924385, 0.0069297486916184425, 0.017536252737045288, -0.018259139731526375, 0.004969851113855839, -0.027619285508990288, 0.0010523932287469506, -0.029264478012919426, -0.004175298381596804, 0.011217218823730946, -0.004720579832792282, -0.0005503448192030191, -0.0031766542233526707, -0.0027575662825256586, 0.013560371473431587, 0.020116213709115982, 0.006340844556689262, -0.006368887610733509, -0.010114192962646484, 0.014033987186849117, -0.01870782859623432, -0.032928768545389175, -0.003661175724118948, 0.010438245721161366, 0.0062255566008389, 0.035371631383895874, 0.003234298201277852, -0.02426658384501934, -0.009497245773673058, 0.02047765627503395, 0.00022629181330557913, 0.00114820699673146, -0.0033153113909065723, 0.04451989755034447, 0.02582453191280365, 0.004259427543729544, 0.015654252842068672, 0.01843363046646118, 0.015579471364617348, -0.0160406231880188, 0.02323210798203945, -0.06341467797756195, -0.0375901497900486, -0.002643836196511984, 0.017797987908124924, -0.03474845364689827, -0.003938490524888039, 0.02594916708767414, -0.04020749777555466, -0.014632239006459713, 0.008001616224646568, -0.03704174980521202, 0.0002938677789643407, 0.0033527021296322346, -0.004321745131164789, 0.012214305810630322, -0.02176140435039997, 0.005434119608253241, 0.056734200567007065, -0.01135431881994009, -0.016240039840340614, -0.046838123351335526, 0.021399961784482002, 0.058329541236162186, -0.02866622619330883, 0.012594444677233696, 0.023144861683249474, 0.0026235829573124647, -0.0010516142938286066, 0.025774676352739334, -0.04344802722334862, -0.010157815180718899, -0.0180347952991724, -0.0010562881361693144, 0.010151583701372147, 0.035097431391477585, -0.03935997560620308, 0.016190186142921448, -0.020789247006177902, 0.028990279883146286, -0.01953042484819889, 0.03459889069199562, 0.019056808203458786, -0.01447021309286356, -0.024490928277373314, 0.009958397597074509, 0.025625113397836685, -0.004652030300348997, 0.029987366870045662, -0.010220132768154144, -0.01278762985020876, 0.02249675616621971, -0.00965927168726921, -0.03487308695912361, -0.00855624582618475, 0.02026577666401863, -0.021985748782753944, 0.040656186640262604, 0.01331110019236803, 0.006016791798174381, -0.011030265130102634, -0.0168133657425642, 0.013473127037286758, 0.022197630256414413, -0.005362453870475292, -0.01570410653948784, -0.01852087490260601, 0.011572430841624737, 0.03295369818806648, 0.00987115316092968, 0.006568305194377899, -0.035770464688539505, -0.034274835139513016, -0.018209286034107208, -0.01675104722380638, 0.00507267564535141, -0.000393965863622725, 0.05189833417534828, 0.03654320910573006, 0.0032841525971889496, -0.09940949082374573, 0.006749026942998171, 0.015305272303521633, -0.008687113411724567, -0.019854478538036346, 0.02407963015139103, 0.049280982464551926, 0.0537927970290184, -0.011161132715642452, 0.009297828190028667, 0.01854580268263817, -0.028691153973340988, 0.0010671938071027398, 0.023481378331780434, -0.006879894528537989, -0.022509219124913216, -0.014769339002668858, -0.00011889083543792367, 0.03843767195940018, 0.006365771871060133, 0.014756875112652779, 0.02218516729772091, -0.014046451076865196, 0.013809642754495144, 0.012432417832314968, -0.007739881053566933, -0.0134481992572546, 0.003343354444950819, 0.017274517565965652, -0.011429100297391415, 0.019991576671600342, 0.009073483757674694, -0.005580566357821226, 0.06515958160161972, -0.01297458354383707, -0.008986239321529865, 0.02188604138791561, 0.021798795089125633, 0.00872450415045023, -0.0018165663350373507, 0.01668872870504856, -0.022683709859848022, -0.0031439373269677162, 0.0005776088801212609, 0.028043048456311226, 0.011416636407375336, -0.03487308695912361, 0.019480571150779724, 0.042924560606479645, -0.03327775001525879, 0.04120458662509918, -0.017673352733254433, 0.005047748796641827, -0.015542080625891685, -0.003215602831915021, 0.010394623503088951, 0.0006979603203944862, 0.008687113411724567, -0.005216007120907307, -0.012625603005290031, -0.0036580597516149282, 0.04514307528734207, 0.0018991375109180808, -0.025101643055677414, -0.006044834852218628, -0.006175702437758446, -0.012021119706332684, 0.024441074579954147, 0.0009036093251779675, -0.040232427418231964, 0.004321745131164789, 0.001447332906536758, -0.029114915058016777, -0.025114107877016068, 0.012457344681024551, -0.0007626151200383902, -0.021050982177257538, -0.01200865674763918, -0.018022332340478897, 0.027270305901765823, 0.01017651055008173, -0.007048152852803469, 0.020066358149051666, -0.010076802223920822, 0.036568135023117065, 0.012444881722331047, 0.020340558141469955, -0.00639381492510438, -0.023493843153119087, 0.00434667244553566, -0.005957589950412512, -0.016663802787661552, 0.030934598296880722, -0.010830848477780819, 0.00891145784407854, 0.04661377891898155, 0.01925622671842575, -0.022048067301511765, -0.022696172818541527, 0.00048023718409240246, 0.006661782041192055, -0.012550821527838707, -0.037664927542209625, -0.04459467902779579, 0.006886126007884741, -0.03921041265130043, 0.011136205866932869, 0.016551630571484566, 0.021923432126641273, 0.004957387689501047, 0.034424398094415665, 0.0537927970290184, -0.018558265641331673, -0.0038169703911989927, 0.025463087484240532, -0.004486887715756893, 0.013423272408545017, -0.00015248407726176083, -0.021686624735593796, -0.015666715800762177, 0.005321947392076254, 0.017897697165608406, -0.054440904408693314, 0.00044752031681127846, 0.012064742855727673, -0.04270021617412567, -0.008550013415515423, 0.0036923347506672144, -0.01776059716939926, 0.010419550351798534, 0.014482676051557064, 0.010338537395000458, -0.025114107877016068, -0.01675104722380638, 0.024042239412665367, 0.0005012694746255875, -0.02151213400065899, 0.018807537853717804, -0.035346705466508865, 0.020066358149051666, 0.010837079957127571, -0.018894782289862633, 0.020864028483629227, 0.013036901131272316, -0.027818704023957253, -0.0017838494386523962, -0.025674968957901, -0.010562881827354431, 0.008244656026363373, -0.0036923347506672144, -0.006047950591892004, 0.006636854726821184, 0.013024438172578812, 0.050776612013578415, -0.004271890968084335, 0.011547503992915154, 0.019567815586924553, 0.01589106023311615, -0.0018134504789486527, 0.02584945783019066, 0.024191802367568016, 0.050103578716516495, -0.00883044395595789, 0.00420334143564105, 0.05598638579249382, 0.02533845230937004, -0.030735179781913757, -0.024366293102502823, -0.02053997479379177, -0.010936788283288479, -0.021873576566576958, -0.028716081753373146, 0.045217856764793396, 0.03195660933852196, -0.02298283576965332, -0.003947838209569454, -0.007976689375936985, -0.020452730357646942, 0.008730735629796982, -0.004608407616615295, 0.0016888147220015526, -0.01766088791191578, -0.018832463771104813, 0.012825020588934422, 0.01921883597970009, 0.055388133972883224, 0.012706616893410683, -0.034150201827287674, 0.0492062009871006, -0.005175500176846981, -0.010120424441993237, -0.017561180517077446, 0.032106172293424606, 0.002851043129339814, 0.023606015369296074, 0.042126890271902084, -0.0023883329704403877, 0.030510835349559784, -0.04068111628293991, -0.00114820699673146, -0.0412544384598732, -0.005873460788279772, 0.015168173238635063, 0.0071665565483272076, -0.005518248770385981, -0.0385124534368515, 0.007322351448237896, -0.03529684990644455, -0.03975880891084671, -0.004047546535730362, 0.024466002359986305, -0.03878664970397949, -0.01778552494943142, 0.007353510241955519, 0.03843767195940018, 0.007041920907795429, 0.016676265746355057, 0.001487839501351118, -0.0009706010459922254, 0.005599261727184057, 0.045392345637083054, -0.05354352667927742, -0.018932173028588295, 0.03886143118143082, 0.03517221286892891, 0.054690174758434296, 0.012800093740224838, -0.026198439300060272, -0.01955535262823105, 0.01460731215775013, 0.0066929408349096775, 0.0014839445939287543, -0.007054384332150221, -0.002407028339803219, -0.04392164573073387, -0.01650177501142025, -0.04337324947118759, 0.024104557931423187, -0.003966533578932285, -0.01521802693605423, 0.024378756061196327, 0.009341451339423656, -0.010089265182614326, -0.0029772368725389242, -0.015292808413505554, -0.028167683631181717, -0.008631027303636074, 0.008331901393830776, 0.010114192962646484, 0.026946254074573517, 0.0037110301200300455, -0.03098445199429989, -0.006343960762023926, 0.01169083546847105, -0.00785205326974392, 0.02093880996108055, -0.028217537328600883, 0.02188604138791561, 0.014482676051557064, -0.017411617562174797, 0.006543377880007029, -0.040780823677778244, -0.016127867624163628, -0.05204789713025093, 0.006241136230528355, 0.004748622886836529, -0.05678405612707138, -0.004184646066278219, 0.043472956866025925, -0.02203560434281826, -0.012519663199782372, -0.013336027041077614, -0.006823808420449495, -0.0012113038683310151, -0.0147444112226367, -0.0067926496267318726, -0.0026936905924230814, -0.04422077164053917, -0.03429976478219032, 0.03646842762827873, -0.013360954821109772, 0.002879086183384061, -0.02481498196721077, -0.004605291876941919, -0.0016000117175281048, 0.0026734373532235622, -0.0004701105353888124, -0.026422783732414246, 0.023880213499069214, -0.03233051672577858, -0.017810450866818428, 0.03706667944788933, 0.02744479663670063, 0.020926345139741898, 0.02506425231695175, -0.031134014949202538, 0.027469724416732788, 0.03449917957186699, 0.003944722004234791, -0.0449187308549881, 0.013435736298561096, 0.0036518280394375324, 0.012874875217676163, -0.00034644847619347274, -0.005275208968669176, -0.03312818706035614, -0.00507267564535141, -0.01723712682723999, -0.015604398213326931, 0.007926834747195244, -0.010886934585869312, 0.011647212319076061, -0.026073802262544632, -0.0024599984753876925, 0.009104643017053604, -0.022758491337299347, -0.008169874548912048, 0.00574570894241333, 0.019306080415844917, -0.020888954401016235, -0.03267949819564819, -0.015429908409714699, -0.005001010373234749, 0.008923920802772045, -0.021686624735593796, -0.018745219334959984, -0.0049449242651462555, -0.019144054502248764, 0.004645798355340958, 0.016738584265112877, 0.023269498720765114, -0.024677881971001625, 0.02662220038473606, -0.008138715289533138, -0.012594444677233696, 0.02384282276034355, 0.018383776769042015, 0.043622519820928574, -0.0074968417175114155, -0.0013032227288931608, 0.002763798227533698, -0.011086351238191128, -0.0025612651370465755, 0.006979602854698896, 0.026597272604703903, -0.0014527856837958097, 0.02395499497652054, -0.03447425365447998, -0.015355126932263374, -0.011422867886722088, 0.04621494188904762, -0.03315311297774315, 0.03297862410545349, 0.009846225380897522, 0.03741565719246864, 0.03587017580866814, 0.0019645714201033115, -0.006247367709875107, 0.021736478433012962, -0.009653040207922459, 0.015367589890956879, 0.0046956525184214115, 0.004075589589774609, -0.0014520067488774657, 0.017012782394886017, -0.009584490209817886, 0.006244251970201731, -0.010425781831145287, 0.007515537086874247, -0.007658868096768856, 0.028067974373698235, 0.011821703054010868, -0.01479426585137844, 0.022135311737656593, -0.034424398094415665, 0.0037328412290662527, 0.017611034214496613, 0.005452814977616072, -0.007982920855283737, -0.026721909642219543, -0.012139524333178997, 0.006203745491802692, 0.0019598975777626038, 0.004490003455430269, -0.011896484531462193, -0.013560371473431587, 0.008687113411724567, -0.0019116010516881943, 0.034698598086833954, 0.03432469069957733, 0.0339258573949337, 0.005368685815483332, -0.007085543591529131, -0.020527511835098267, 0.0049978941679000854, -0.004268775228410959, -0.0017324371729046106, 0.030062148347496986, -0.013959205709397793, -0.008088861592113972, -0.008138715289533138, -0.013149073347449303, 0.008394218981266022, 0.0027622401248663664, 0.01601569540798664, 0.0008132483926601708, 0.000030720770155312493, -0.012214305810630322, -0.008213496766984463, 0.008824212476611137, -0.0397338829934597, -0.011821703054010868, -0.029264478012919426, 0.027669141069054604, 0.035097431391477585, 0.0012237674091011286, 0.00041441392386332154, 0.021985748782753944, 0.004985430743545294, -0.020527511835098267, -0.003041112795472145, -0.007029457483440638, 0.022072995081543922, -0.0052720932289958, -0.02331935241818428, -0.004994778428226709, -0.025600187480449677, -0.0022154008038342, 0.012544590048491955, -0.018284067511558533, -0.011148669756948948, -0.00922927912324667, -0.004031966906040907, 0.04344802722334862, -0.04419584199786186, -0.01696292869746685, -0.010201437398791313, -0.03150792419910431, -0.052945274859666824, -0.016975391656160355, 0.014520066790282726, 0.00605729827657342, 0.0016358444700017571, 0.022010676562786102, 0.01162851694971323, 0.0050165895372629166, 0.011042729020118713, 0.00044829928083345294, 0.02420426718890667, 0.0062878746539354324, -0.008151179179549217, 0.0336267314851284, -0.005742593202739954, 0.0004381726321298629, 0.025525406002998352, 0.007272497285157442, 0.001127174706198275, -0.03798898309469223, 0.024765126407146454, 0.04088053107261658, 0.04175298288464546, 0.024279048666357994, -0.014669629745185375, -0.03145806863903999, -0.003654944011941552, 0.03878664970397949, 0.02771899476647377, -0.01928115263581276, -0.006879894528537989, -0.019031882286071777, 0.018957100808620453, 0.00498854648321867, 0.010824616998434067, -0.03554612025618553, -0.024366293102502823, -0.03434961661696434, 0.014569921419024467, -0.002082975348457694, 0.0014504487626254559, -0.000265629991190508, -0.025999020785093307, -0.005795563105493784, 0.015691643580794334, 0.009023630060255527, 0.045392345637083054, -0.010693749412894249, 0.007334814872592688, -0.022347193211317062, 0.05125022679567337, 0.024977007880806923, 0.03028649277985096, -0.038736797869205475, -0.017810450866818428, -0.0134481992572546, 0.033477168530225754, -0.04282484948635101, -0.018495948985219002, -0.0252138152718544, 0.00018091661331709474, 0.02702103555202484, -0.007135397754609585, -0.0006161680794321001, -0.002042468637228012, 0.004521162714809179, -0.008363059721887112, 0.014632239006459713, -0.044819023460149765, 0.022621391341090202, -0.004686304833739996, 0.0040724738501012325, -0.005795563105493784, 0.016389602795243263, -0.004633334930986166, -0.0019894985016435385, 0.03407542034983635, -0.0045086988247931, 0.008095093071460724, 0.029837803915143013, 0.004315513651818037, -0.007951762527227402, -0.009852457791566849, -0.024216730147600174, 0.00949101336300373, -0.013410808518528938, 0.00019815139239653945, -0.029040133580565453, 0.026597272604703903, 0.0017417848575860262, -0.01432065013796091, 0.03444932773709297, 0.00473615899682045, -0.04222659766674042, 0.013011974282562733, 0.01805972307920456, 0.022259948775172234, 0.005642884410917759, 0.013871961273252964, -0.009646808728575706, 0.019966650754213333, -0.026871472597122192, 0.009304060600697994, 0.014507603831589222, 0.0589776448905468, 0.04297441244125366, 0.021537061780691147, 0.052795711904764175, 0.001723089488223195, -0.009459855034947395, -0.010101729072630405, -0.00336516578681767, -0.03380122035741806, -0.02506425231695175, 0.003259225282818079, 0.01949303410947323, 0.0001289201172767207, 0.02609873004257679, 0.03255486115813255, 0.009734053164720535, -0.019754769280552864, 0.00013096492330078036, -0.006259831599891186, -0.0019458759343251586, -0.046987686306238174, -0.006867431104183197, -0.009584490209817886, 0.025924239307641983, 0.005300136283040047, 0.014083841815590858, -0.01921883597970009, -0.006051066797226667, 0.029937511309981346, 0.023581087589263916, 0.018284067511558533, 0.025051789358258247, -0.007122934330254793, 0.003318427363410592, 0.0019084851955994964, -0.005088255275040865, -0.0009620323544368148, -0.034025564789772034, -0.03285398706793785, -0.023269498720765114, 0.02346891537308693, 0.017561180517077446, 0.006499755196273327, 0.0015665157698094845, -0.016800900921225548, -0.0017417848575860262, 0.011129974387586117, 0.031582705676555634, 0.032405298203229904, 0.019206371158361435, 0.005427887663245201, 0.012108365073800087, 0.0189446359872818, 0.04297441244125366, 0.00815741065889597, 0.01514324638992548, -0.059575896710157394, -0.05097603052854538, -0.008687113411724567, 0.03110908716917038, -0.023967457935214043, -0.012201841920614243, -0.0007104238611645997, 0.012226768769323826, -0.01460731215775013, -0.020116213709115982, -0.026073802262544632, 0.016850756481289864, -0.02958853170275688, 0.010500563308596611, 0.007789735682308674, 0.030460981652140617, 0.03786434605717659, 0.03569568321108818, 0.00007195768557721749, 0.015093391761183739, 0.014520066790282726, -0.00021421772544272244, 0.0035645829048007727, -0.01241995394229889, -0.012102133594453335, 0.009964630007743835, -0.003907331265509129, -0.001640518312342465, -0.011210987344384193, -0.026173511520028114, -0.0259740948677063, -0.005312599707394838, 0.005315715447068214, 0.011267073452472687, 0.02083910070359707, 0.00919811986386776, -0.05125022679567337, 0.007428291719406843, 0.00982753001153469, 0.01217691507190466, -0.007559159304946661, 0.013211391866207123, -0.00818856991827488, 0.007789735682308674, -0.009515941143035889, -0.02946389652788639, -0.027245379984378815, -0.002721733646467328, -0.0424758717417717, 0.012326477095484734, 0.053593382239341736, -0.0064561329782009125, -0.006705404259264469, 0.008942616172134876, -0.0348481610417366, 0.014569921419024467, 0.01521802693605423, 0.0032218345440924168, 0.0030115118715912104, -0.002067395718768239, 0.012912265956401825, -0.021325180307030678, 0.01508092787116766, -0.016800900921225548, -0.00409428495913744, 0.03786434605717659, 0.02121300809085369, 0.006007444113492966, -0.015255417674779892, 0.018134504556655884, -0.027818704023957253, -0.007515537086874247, 0.008232192136347294, -0.005695854779332876, 0.009833762422204018, -0.005674043204635382, 0.07498087733983994, 0.00019055641314480454, 0.009372609667479992, 0.03624408319592476, 0.03499772399663925, 0.005549407564103603, 0.012388795614242554, -0.0035895102191716433, 0.04384686425328255, -0.0168133657425642, -0.011915179900825024, 0.05608609691262245, 0.011908947490155697, 0.015729034319519997, -0.0017417848575860262, -0.0200165044516325, 0.003558351192623377, -0.034823235124349594, -0.005832953844219446, -0.03218095377087593, -0.0043747154995799065, 0.009441159665584564, 0.002156198723241687, -0.00013748883793596178, 0.005290788598358631, -0.021350108087062836, 0.011210987344384193, -0.023693259805440903, -0.0249022264033556, -0.032380372285842896, 0.021138226613402367, -0.000490363861899823, -0.018695365637540817, -0.0013102334924042225, 0.015043537132441998, -0.016514239832758904, -0.031034305691719055, -0.017037710174918175, 0.03906084969639778, 0.0024226077366620302, 0.016215113922953606, 0.01766088791191578, 0.014046451076865196, -0.004524278454482555, -0.01925622671842575, -0.03868694230914116, 0.016975391656160355, 0.034150201827287674, -0.0014325323281809688, 0.003966533578932285, -0.022534146904945374, -0.035097431391477585, -0.005795563105493784, 0.010999106802046299, 0.009316523559391499, -0.030934598296880722, 0.02020345814526081, 0.017124954611063004, 0.023157326504588127, -0.026123657822608948, 0.0018648627446964383, 0.014158623293042183, -0.025400768965482712, 0.026547418907284737, 0.02121300809085369 ]
15.337153
6.81506
2024-07-01
0
2024ApJ...969...36X
[ "dual active galactic nuclei", "parsec-scale radio emission properties", "parsec scales", "dual-AGN emission", "galaxy merging", "galaxy mergers", "the radio emission", "compact jets", "valuable insights", "two compact radio components" ]
[ "Active galactic nuclei", "Very long baseline interferometry", "Galaxy mergers", "Jets", "Galaxy pairs", "Star formation", "16", "1769", "608", "870", "610", "1569", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
32
[ "10.3847/1538-4357/ad463b", "10.48550/arXiv.2405.04270" ]
[ "Xu, Wancheng", "Cui, Lang", "Liu, Xiang", "An, Tao", "Cao, Hongmin", "Jiang, Pengfei", "Ho, Luis C.", "Chang, Ning", "Yang, Xiaolong", "Shen, Yuling", "Tan, Guiping", "Han, Zhenhua", "Fan, Junhui", "Zhang, Ming" ]
[ "Xinjiang Astronomical Observatory, CAS, 150 Science-1 Street, Urumqi 830011, People's Republic of China; College of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, No.1 Yanqihu East Road, Beijing 101408, People's Republic of China", "Xinjiang Astronomical Observatory, CAS, 150 Science-1 Street, Urumqi 830011, People's Republic of China; Key Laboratory of Radio Astronomy, CAS, 150 Science 1-Street, Urumqi 830011, People's Republic of China; Xinjiang Key Laboratory of Radio Astrophysics, 150 Science 1-Street, Urumqi 830011, People's Republic of China", "Xinjiang Astronomical Observatory, CAS, 150 Science-1 Street, Urumqi 830011, People's Republic of China; Key Laboratory of Radio Astronomy, CAS, 150 Science 1-Street, Urumqi 830011, People's Republic of China; Xinjiang Key Laboratory of Radio Astrophysics, 150 Science 1-Street, Urumqi 830011, People's Republic of China", "Shanghai Astronomical Observatory, CAS, 80 Nandan Road, Shanghai 200030, People's Republic of China", "School of Electronic and Electrical Engineering, Shangqiu Normal University, 298 Wenhua Road, Shangqiu, Henan 476000, People's Republic of China", "Xinjiang Astronomical Observatory, CAS, 150 Science-1 Street, Urumqi 830011, People's Republic of China", "Kavli Institute for Astronomy and Astrophysics, Peking University, Beijing 100871, People's Republic of China; Department of Astronomy, School of Physics, Peking University, Beijing 100871, People's Republic of China", "Xinjiang Astronomical Observatory, CAS, 150 Science-1 Street, Urumqi 830011, People's Republic of China", "Shanghai Astronomical Observatory, CAS, 80 Nandan Road, Shanghai 200030, People's Republic of China", "Xinjiang Astronomical Observatory, CAS, 150 Science-1 Street, Urumqi 830011, People's Republic of China", "Xinjiang Astronomical Observatory, CAS, 150 Science-1 Street, Urumqi 830011, People's Republic of China", "College of Physics and Electronic Engineering, Xinjiang Normal University, 102 Xinyi Road, Urumqi 830054, People's Republic of China", "Center for Astrophysics, Guangzhou University, Guangzhou 510006, People's Republic of China", "Xinjiang Astronomical Observatory, CAS, 150 Science-1 Street, Urumqi 830011, People's Republic of China; Key Laboratory of Radio Astronomy, CAS, 150 Science 1-Street, Urumqi 830011, People's Republic of China; Xinjiang Key Laboratory of Radio Astrophysics, 150 Science 1-Street, Urumqi 830011, People's Republic of China" ]
null
[ "1982ApJ...252..102C", "1989Natur.340..687H", "1992ARA&A..30..575C", "1993ApJ...405L..63G", "1993ApJ...409..130R", "1995ASPC...82..327B", "1995ApJ...450..559B", "1996ApJ...460..207L", "1996ApJ...471..115B", "1997ASPC..125...77S", "1998MNRAS.299..165B", "1999ASPC..180..301F", "2000MNRAS.315..371S", "2001ApJ...554..803Y", "2002ApJ...564..120H", "2002Sci...297.1310M", "2002astro.ph.10394H", "2003ASSL..285..109G", "2003ApJ...582L..15K", "2003ApJ...599..971H", "2004ApJ...613..109H", "2005A&A...435..521N", "2005ApJ...619L...1M", "2005Natur.433..604D", "2005Natur.435..629S", "2005astro.ph..3225L", "2006A&A...452.1099P", "2006A&A...455..173P", "2006ApJ...642L.115H", "2006ApJS..166....1H", "2007MNRAS.379.1599L", "2007Msngr.127...28A", "2007PASP..119..318D", "2008AJ....136..159L", "2008MNRAS.386..105B", "2008MNRAS.390..847L", "2009AJ....137.3718L", "2009NewAR..53..113B", "2010ApJ...710.1578G", "2010ApJ...720.1066C", "2011A&A...526A..74M", "2011AJ....142....3H", "2011ApJ...737...67M", "2011PASP..123..275D", "2012ApJ...745...67F", "2012ApJ...745...94L", "2012ApJ...746L..22K", "2012ApJ...748L...7V", "2012ApJ...752...63S", "2012ApJS..200...17T", "2012JPhCS.372a2029B", "2013ARA&A..51..511K", "2013ApJ...762..110L", "2013ApJ...768...12M", "2013MNRAS.433L..59P", "2013MNRAS.435.3627E", "2014AJ....147...14D", "2014ApJ...792L...8W", "2014ApJS..213...12J", "2015ApJ...799...72F", "2015ApJ...815L...6F", "2016A&A...595A...1G", "2017MNRAS.471.1873Y", "2018ApJ...856...93F", "2019ApJ...883...50G", "2019NatAs...3..387P", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020ApJ...888...73H", "2021A&A...649A...2L", "2021MNRAS.500.2620Y", "2021MNRAS.507..991S", "2022ApJ...939L...5L", "2023A&A...674A...1G", "2023ApJ...942..107S", "2023ApJ...945...73G", "2023ApJ...958...29C", "2023MNRAS.518...39W", "2023MNRAS.524L..38W", "2023MNRAS.525.6064W", "2023Natur.616...45C" ]
29031891
2403.00984
Ly α emission strength and stellar properties of faint galaxies from 5 &lt; z &lt; 8.2
We present a study on stellar properties of Lyman-alpha (Ly α) emitters at 5 &lt; z &lt; 8.2. We use 247 photometrically selected, lensed, high-redshift, low-luminosity galaxy candidates with spectroscopic follow-up. Of these, 38 are confirmed spectroscopically to be between 5 &lt; z &lt; 8.2 via detection of Ly α. For each galaxy and candidate, we estimate stellar mass, star formation rate, specific star formation rate, and mass-weighted age with spectral energy distribution fitting. We also measure the UV β slope and luminosity using values from photometry. We find no strong correlation between Ly α equivalent width and any of these properties, as well as no significant difference between the physical properties of Ly α emitters and candidates without Ly α detected. This lack of expected trends may be explained by a combination of the evolving opacity of the intergalactic medium at these redshifts as well as the unique phase space probed by our lensed sample. Via tests on other galaxy samples which show varying strengths of correlations, we conclude that if there exist any relationships between Ly α equivalent width and physical properties in the underlying population of faint galaxies, they are weak correlations. We also present the results of a spectroscopic search for C III] emission in confirmed Ly α emitters at z ~ 7, finding no C III] detections, but putting constraints on strong active galactic nuclei activity and extreme nebular emission.
[ 0.021626876667141914, 0.041542358696460724, 0.025366157293319702, -0.04205812141299248, 0.012776853516697884, 0.04144858196377754, -0.00921340100467205, -0.023631319403648376, -0.02146277017891407, 0.001598572009243071, -0.04414461553096771, -0.005008175037801266, -0.05246715620160103, 0.0040997290052473545, 0.01727805845439434, 0.01759454794228077, 0.006798692978918552, 0.018649518489837646, -0.03976063057780266, 0.024404963478446007, 0.008416312746703625, -0.0009567987872287631, -0.01166913565248251, -0.009430255740880966, -0.045012034475803375, -0.056499481201171875, 0.007695416919887066, 0.017782097682356834, 0.022482573986053467, -0.01644580438733101, 0.0058052632957696915, -0.017899317666888237, -0.0041583385318517685, -0.041565801948308945, -0.07239435613155365, 0.0758640393614769, 0.02527238242328167, -0.0077833314426243305, -0.019317666068673134, -0.0301955733448267, 0.00063334807055071, 0.053404904901981354, -0.005394997075200081, -0.06737738847732544, 0.004738571587949991, 0.013386392034590244, 0.008767969906330109, -0.026960333809256554, -0.012366588227450848, -0.021005617454648018, -0.046981312334537506, 0.00042345307883806527, 0.007777470164000988, -0.03947930783033371, -0.010022210888564587, -0.018649518489837646, 0.02492072619497776, -0.02485039457678795, -0.02562403865158558, 0.01795792765915394, -0.005107811186462641, 0.013702882453799248, 0.019376274198293686, -0.03448578342795372, -0.017723489552736282, -0.01770004630088806, -0.013937320560216904, 0.006388426758348942, 0.04205812141299248, 0.004978870507329702, 0.015789378434419632, -0.06165711209177971, -0.004556882660835981, 0.00826978962868452, 0.017711767926812172, 0.015601827763020992, -0.02832007221877575, -0.0407218262553215, -0.06273552775382996, -0.008445617742836475, 0.012296256609261036, 0.04414461553096771, -0.03296193853020668, -0.015883153304457664, 0.011733606457710266, -0.004606700502336025, 0.026585234329104424, -0.006874885410070419, -0.04442594200372696, 0.011774633079767227, 0.01151675172150135, -0.00862144585698843, 0.009922575205564499, -0.010573139414191246, -0.02571781352162361, -0.00508729787543416, 0.04984145238995552, -0.035118766129016876, 0.06404837965965271, 0.013140232302248478, 0.016949845477938652, 0.05256092920899391, -0.007460979279130697, -0.06845580786466599, 0.012847185134887695, 0.020185085013508797, 0.0214979350566864, -0.0016073633451014757, 0.021146278828382492, 0.006493923719972372, 0.022013699635863304, 0.029984580352902412, -0.012530694715678692, 0.055374182760715485, -0.07652045786380768, 0.01684434711933136, -0.08031835407018661, -0.0034520949702709913, -0.038072679191827774, 0.005866803228855133, 0.0076661123894155025, 0.017852429300546646, 0.0037187677808105946, 0.0222364142537117, 0.04843482747673988, 0.012917516753077507, 0.018942564725875854, -0.0414016954600811, -0.04487137496471405, 0.007121044676750898, 0.04862237721681595, -0.04597323015332222, 0.009342341683804989, 0.03171942010521889, -0.0686902403831482, 0.009881548583507538, 0.04857548698782921, -0.05096675455570221, 0.0009970928076654673, 0.023584431037306786, 0.014031095430254936, 0.025975694879889488, 0.041987791657447815, 0.04512925446033478, 0.021275220438838005, -0.007337899412959814, -0.043511636555194855, 0.01767660118639469, 0.002518740016967058, 0.04644210636615753, 0.0004256509128026664, -0.00650564581155777, -0.022506017237901688, -0.033571477979421616, -0.018637796863913536, -0.006921772845089436, 0.036572277545928955, -0.008943798020482063, -0.014031095430254936, -0.0303127933293581, 0.012179037556052208, 0.002335585420951247, -0.009113765321671963, 0.009658833034336567, -0.02221297100186348, 0.007091740146279335, 0.008527670986950397, -0.03319637477397919, -0.06704917550086975, -0.009629528038203716, -0.022670123726129532, 0.004055771976709366, -0.017313223332166672, -0.047754958271980286, 0.026702452450990677, 0.01566043682396412, 0.0560774952173233, -0.013105066493153572, -0.02227158099412918, 0.04065149649977684, 0.017442163079977036, 0.029703255742788315, 0.006271208170801401, 0.020970450714230537, -0.025928808376193047, -0.0041173119097948074, -0.005028688348829746, 0.0008219971205107868, 0.010473503731191158, -0.03610340505838394, 0.001230065245181322, 0.016398916020989418, -0.0008212645188905299, 0.03188352659344673, -0.030969219282269478, -0.05443643033504486, 0.007660251576453447, 0.04862237721681595, -0.03671294078230858, -0.011247147805988789, 0.03300882503390312, 0.002354633528739214, 0.043488189578056335, -0.06751805543899536, -0.041987791657447815, 0.0035341482143849134, 0.01549633126705885, -0.01575421169400215, -0.0233734380453825, -0.005271917674690485, 0.01721944846212864, -0.008568697609007359, -0.00449534272775054, 0.0057876803912222385, -0.007460979279130697, -0.012483807280659676, -0.02801530435681343, -0.005022827535867691, 0.07581714540719986, 0.020876675844192505, -0.053451791405677795, 0.02764020301401615, 0.05331113189458847, 0.033946577459573746, 0.02527238242328167, -0.00146230508107692, 0.02298661507666111, -0.043886736035346985, 0.04051083326339722, -0.012507250532507896, -0.001979533117264509, 0.010444198735058308, -0.04395706579089165, 0.004102659411728382, 0.000692690082360059, -0.016996731981635094, -0.030875442549586296, 0.02726510353386402, 0.0034696778748184443, -0.04011228680610657, -0.03865877538919449, -0.01607070304453373, 0.004442594014108181, 0.022130917757749557, 0.00010998424113495275, 0.025155164301395416, -0.002800065092742443, -0.007472701370716095, 0.051576290279626846, -0.020161641761660576, 0.02188475802540779, -0.030031466856598854, -0.008533531799912453, -0.04008884355425835, 0.00040953332791104913, 0.024639401584863663, -0.029726698994636536, 0.027358878403902054, -0.021755818277597427, -0.030828556045889854, -0.02143932692706585, -0.02334999293088913, -0.008615585044026375, -0.006423592567443848, -0.026655565947294235, 0.04979456588625908, 0.018895678222179413, 0.006183294113725424, -0.03408724069595337, -0.01986859366297722, 0.004606700502336025, 0.016750572249293327, 0.04634832963347435, -0.02574125863611698, -0.0344623401761055, 0.014921958558261395, 0.01641063764691353, 0.04172990843653679, 0.0009729164303280413, 0.018309583887457848, 0.006177432835102081, 0.00979363452643156, 0.04641866311430931, 0.030547231435775757, -0.02447529509663582, -0.016223087906837463, -0.013480166904628277, -0.01794620417058468, 0.0073613435961306095, -0.026327352970838547, 0.07361343502998352, -0.01803998090326786, 0.02145104855298996, 0.0005428697913885117, -0.05293602868914604, -0.032352399080991745, 0.0657363310456276, -0.019798262044787407, -0.02485039457678795, 0.007038991432636976, 0.05635882169008255, 0.0017348389374092221, 0.035376645624637604, -0.04752051830291748, -0.018567465245723724, 0.017758654430508614, 0.0635794997215271, -0.004451385699212551, -0.02649145945906639, 0.028812391683459282, 0.040768712759017944, 0.01494540274143219, -0.0044631073251366615, 0.008363564498722553, -0.057718560099601746, -0.042691104114055634, -0.036947380751371384, 0.040041957050561905, 0.00726756826043129, -0.04409772902727127, -0.0065173679031431675, -0.010602444410324097, -0.02340860292315483, -0.02993769198656082, -0.0036396451760083437, -0.020442966371774673, -0.008193597197532654, -0.03947930783033371, -0.030031466856598854, -0.009318898431956768, 0.01794620417058468, -0.0360565148293972, 0.016234809532761574, -0.018485412001609802, -0.015320503152906895, -0.012390031479299068, 0.003484330140054226, 0.09837005287408829, -0.019012896344065666, -0.027663646265864372, -0.03209451958537102, 0.00450706435367465, 0.01611759141087532, 0.02029058150947094, 0.006511506624519825, 0.015402556397020817, 0.01833302713930607, -0.010789994150400162, 0.023115556687116623, 0.03181319311261177, -0.014851627871394157, 0.004234530497342348, 0.037369366735219955, 0.023631319403648376, 0.03748658671975136, -0.028273185715079308, 0.040393613278865814, -0.07820840924978256, -0.006347400601953268, 0.045152697712183, 0.009822939522564411, -0.024029862135648727, 0.006751805543899536, -0.0019048062385991216, 0.008199458010494709, 0.000755328917875886, 0.0002531194477342069, 0.0218378696590662, -0.01509778667241335, -0.045457467436790466, 0.023654762655496597, 0.023678205907344818, 0.004369332455098629, -0.006048492155969143, -0.02074773609638214, 0.021240053698420525, 0.008785552345216274, -0.002460130490362644, 0.03190696984529495, 0.022845951840281487, 0.007718860637396574, 0.012436918914318085, 0.016234809532761574, -0.0536862313747406, -0.012014931067824364, 0.0006820671260356903, -0.08805479854345322, -0.010602444410324097, -0.08139676600694656, 0.02949226088821888, -0.017430441454052925, 0.012296256609261036, -0.021978532895445824, -0.013116789050400257, 0.05415510758757591, 0.002580279717221856, 0.01718428172171116, 0.06620520353317261, 0.029257822781801224, 0.0391276516020298, -0.018485412001609802, -0.03720526024699211, -0.010028071701526642, -0.013140232302248478, -0.002693102927878499, -0.018579186871647835, -0.016234809532761574, 0.052279602736234665, 0.010678636841475964, -0.03305571526288986, 0.046981312334537506, -0.005072645377367735, 0.030008023604750633, 0.008246345445513725, 0.003323154291138053, 0.04951323941349983, -0.02215436100959778, 0.03802579268813133, -0.04794250801205635, 0.025436488911509514, 0.012729966081678867, -0.020138196647167206, 0.035845521837472916, 0.020442966371774673, -0.03973718732595444, -0.03244617581367493, 0.03178974986076355, 0.009260288439691067, -0.0303127933293581, 0.0017685393104329705, -0.010086681693792343, 0.01265963539481163, 0.02949226088821888, -0.023865757510066032, -0.014113148674368858, -0.01995064690709114, 0.00025055528385564685, -0.011622248217463493, 0.0001832460256991908, -0.0028249742463231087, -0.001985394163057208, 0.015250171534717083, -0.048856813460588455, -0.07581714540719986, 0.04189401492476463, 0.022084029391407967, 0.049653902649879456, 0.028226297348737717, 0.03718181699514389, -0.02492072619497776, -0.024428406730294228, 0.005412579979747534, -0.012190760113298893, 0.029257822781801224, -0.036970824003219604, 0.004466037731617689, -0.03422790393233299, -0.04946635290980339, 0.02412363886833191, -0.0445900484919548, -0.0036308537237346172, -0.025155164301395416, -0.0009121090988628566, 0.03291505202651024, -0.035868965089321136, 0.016750572249293327, -0.006915911566466093, 0.0055971997790038586, 0.019610712304711342, -0.0017026036512106657, 0.06273552775382996, -0.031203655526041985, -0.002044003689661622, -0.029257822781801224, 0.007419952657073736, 0.019774818792939186, -0.020513297989964485, -0.02380714751780033, 0.06372016668319702, -0.014042817056179047, 0.026163246482610703, -0.02414708212018013, 0.0012989313108846545, -0.0008908631862141192, 0.023256218060851097, 0.0032909191213548183, 0.007367204409092665, 0.02726510353386402, -0.013339504599571228, -0.01841508038341999, -0.006470480002462864, -0.03024246171116829, 0.05176384001970291, -0.010256648994982243, 0.02298661507666111, -0.043113090097904205, -0.029046829789876938, -0.0015956414863467216, -0.023080389946699142, 0.006224320735782385, 0.0029714975971728563, -0.056827694177627563, 0.017770376056432724, 0.025037944316864014, 0.009787773713469505, -0.010889630764722824, -0.005755445454269648, -0.019329387694597244, -0.004773737397044897, 0.028531067073345184, 0.018966009840369225, 0.02953914925456047, -0.0026066540740430355, -0.02796841599047184, -0.006042631343007088, -0.012718244455754757, -0.007378926035016775, 0.05509285628795624, -0.0012454502284526825, 0.029398486018180847, 0.017512494698166847, -0.008129126392304897, 0.0029993371572345495, -0.015390833839774132, 0.019282499328255653, 0.0008872001199051738, -0.0060777971521019936, -0.07923993468284607, -0.007238263729959726, 0.007437535561621189, 0.017512494698166847, -0.03518909588456154, -0.004038189072161913, -0.024006418883800507, -0.0007322514429688454, -0.022318467497825623, -0.003950275015085936, 0.026233578100800514, -0.010280092246830463, -0.019423162564635277, 0.0021612225100398064, 0.012601025402545929, -0.030078355222940445, -0.02259979397058487, 0.009066877886652946, 0.0025011571124196053, -0.016328584402799606, 0.03748658671975136, 0.03289160877466202, -0.010045655071735382, 0.070518858730793, -0.016340306028723717, 0.012483807280659676, 0.03373558446764946, -0.028531067073345184, 0.010883769951760769, -0.009600223042070866, 0.022693568840622902, -0.004574465565383434, -0.008322537876665592, -0.006323956418782473, -0.0188253466039896, 0.00441035907715559, 0.035423535853624344, -0.0035165653098374605, -0.02794497273862362, 0.027054108679294586, -0.04946635290980339, -0.02649145945906639, 0.03256339579820633, -0.03258683905005455, -0.0375334732234478, -0.0011992952786386013, -0.067330501973629, 0.012319700792431831, 0.005699766334146261, -0.003425720613449812, -0.004255043808370829, 0.035822078585624695, -0.03823678568005562, -0.003589827101677656, 0.0077423048205673695, 0.0025055527221411467, -0.004354679957032204, -0.027663646265864372, -0.030828556045889854, -0.001219075988046825, 0.008855883963406086, 0.012565859593451023, -0.0038858046755194664, 0.019845150411128998, -0.00035477016353979707, -0.03729903697967529, -0.009858104400336742, 0.02218952775001526, 0.009957741014659405, 0.03028935007750988, 0.003091647056862712, -0.005509285721927881, -0.028554510325193405, 0.025178607553243637, 0.006042631343007088, -0.06362638622522354, 0.005576686467975378, -0.02030230313539505, 0.06123512238264084, 0.010707941837608814, -0.03033623658120632, -0.01188012957572937, 0.004641866311430931, -0.01035628467798233, 0.019821707159280777, -0.046864092350006104, -0.018696404993534088, 0.02034919150173664, -0.0003084320924244821, 0.01920044608414173, -0.01149916835129261, 0.023514099419116974, 0.010297675617039204, 0.009248566813766956, 0.024287743493914604, -0.0068807462230324745, 0.015132952481508255, 0.0713159441947937, 0.02065395936369896, -0.020091310143470764, -0.03558764234185219, 0.01493368111550808, -0.014851627871394157, -0.014429640024900436, -0.032750945538282394, 0.011335061863064766, -0.007197237107902765, 0.027921529486775398, -0.033548034727573395, -0.017524216324090958, 0.028179410845041275, -0.03882288187742233, -0.01075482927262783, 0.045035481452941895, 0.004433802794665098, 0.021286942064762115, -0.006693196017295122, -0.022388799116015434, -0.0022755106911063194, -0.010784133337438107, -0.014722687192261219, -0.0222364142537117, 0.004788389895111322, -0.022881118580698967, -0.0011033223709091544, 0.013515332713723183, 0.0025714884977787733, 0.015367390587925911, -0.00017298937018495053, 0.026257021352648735, 0.03793201968073845, 0.006253625266253948, 0.014558580704033375, 0.022084029391407967, -0.0014007651479914784, 0.014886792749166489, 0.03178974986076355, -0.0020073726773262024, 0.0077833314426243305, 0.030500343069434166, 0.03497810289263725, -0.024592513218522072, 0.0005245543434284627, 0.02829662896692753, 0.004170060157775879, 0.007027269806712866, 0.013151953928172588, -0.02717132866382599, -0.028953054919838905, 0.0077833314426243305, -0.016398916020989418, -0.044613491743803024, -0.011850825510919094, 0.0049437046982347965, -0.004375193268060684, 0.006224320735782385, -0.03760380670428276, -0.011264731176197529, 0.0005362762021832168, -0.0020908911246806383, -0.0090141287073493, 0.009588501416146755, 0.008844161406159401, 0.011944600380957127, 0.009518169797956944, 0.006827997509390116, 0.0187667366117239, 0.035868965089321136, -0.014628911390900612, -0.016234809532761574, 0.025881920009851456, 0.006195015739649534, -0.02454562671482563, 0.04175335168838501, 0.018227530643343925, 0.015015733428299427, -0.015906596556305885, -0.007765748538076878, -0.01683262549340725, -0.035095322877168655, -0.025553707033395767, 0.004861651454120874, -0.00240152096375823, 0.02368992753326893, 0.03406379744410515, -0.02832007221877575, -0.01954038068652153, 0.016938121989369392, -0.03856499865651131, 0.011258870363235474, -0.030008023604750633, -0.02569437026977539, 0.00977605115622282, -0.011745328083634377, -0.0003474439727142453, -0.0390104316174984, 0.022775622084736824, 0.03828367590904236, -0.02794497273862362, -0.00900240708142519, -0.00842217355966568, -0.018696404993534088, -0.024709731340408325, -0.0006615538732148707, 0.009336480870842934, 0.012518972158432007, -0.02496761456131935, 0.008498365990817547, 0.02606947161257267, 0.01246036309748888, -0.017535939812660217, 0.004858721047639847, 0.016316862776875496, 0.055749282240867615, -0.00098610355053097, 0.016023816540837288, 0.00719137629494071, 0.025905365124344826, 0.035095322877168655, 0.0005809658905491233, 0.014359308406710625, 0.0009069808293133974, -0.01612931303679943, -0.04519958794116974, 0.007619224954396486, -0.012483807280659676, -0.004085076507180929, 0.03256339579820633, -0.06761182844638824, 0.025084832683205605, -0.015941763296723366, 0.038541555404663086, -0.014605468139052391, 0.02531927078962326, 0.018684683367609978, 0.035048432648181915, 0.03033623658120632, -0.012518972158432007, 0.01607070304453373, -0.02070084773004055, -0.02606947161257267, 0.04512925446033478, -0.026608677580952644, -0.005526868626475334, 0.021908201277256012, 0.02305694669485092, 0.020993895828723907, 0.017746932804584503, 0.023221053183078766, 0.018485412001609802, -0.05326424166560173, 0.010033933445811272, 0.0022916283924132586, 0.006206737831234932, -0.004551021382212639, 0.01152847334742546, -0.002038142643868923, 0.01807514578104019, 0.005207447335124016, 0.027382321655750275, 0.013738048262894154, -0.03985440731048584, -0.0309926625341177, -0.0222364142537117, 0.009600223042070866, -0.0041583385318517685, 0.007197237107902765, -0.010362145490944386, 0.02574125863611698, 0.01642235927283764, -0.06123512238264084, 0.018637796863913536, -0.02179098315536976, -0.0058462899178266525, 0.033852800726890564, 0.04374607279896736, 0.00901999045163393, 0.018239252269268036, -0.021568266674876213, -0.02454562671482563, 0.02871861681342125, -0.04679376259446144, 0.006265347357839346, -0.012683078646659851, -0.008187736384570599, -0.009430255740880966, -0.010930657386779785, -0.014124870300292969, 0.008527670986950397, 0.0073203169740736485, 0.01267135702073574, 0.01680918224155903, -0.01056727860122919, -0.019763097167015076, 0.010403172113001347, -0.0032440314535051584, -0.02182614803314209, 0.011757049709558487, 0.03422790393233299, -0.023232774809002876, 0.009711581282317638, -0.023303106427192688, 0.015531497076153755, 0.02637423947453499, 0.026655565947294235, -0.004205225966870785, -0.004433802794665098, 0.023478934541344643, -0.03940897434949875, 0.019634155556559563, 0.006658030208200216, -0.008246345445513725, 0.022881118580698967, 0.036197178065776825, 0.04325375333428383, 0.01923561282455921, 0.009506448172032833, 0.030969219282269478, 0.03748658671975136, -0.003211796283721924, -0.018215809017419815, 0.018086867406964302, 0.03905731812119484, 0.001926784752868116, -0.027780866250395775, 0.026186689734458923, 0.006376705132424831, -0.01651613600552082, -0.03270405903458595, -0.005131254903972149, -0.032727502286434174, 0.011774633079767227, -0.010930657386779785, -0.02836696058511734, -0.03978407382965088, -0.010285953991115093, -0.056827694177627563, 0.035845521837472916, 0.009693997912108898, -0.02187303639948368, 0.027452653273940086, 0.04857548698782921, 0.013503611087799072, 0.0301955733448267, 0.015965206548571587, -0.013304338790476322, -0.036267511546611786, -0.00042345307883806527, -0.046559326350688934, 0.01037386804819107, -0.026679009199142456, -0.023514099419116974, -0.0014571767533198, 0.011452280916273594, -0.0010212691267952323, 0.04512925446033478, -0.00807051733136177, 0.0014586419565603137, -0.011352645233273506, -0.00747856218367815, 0.01767660118639469, 0.001646924763917923, 0.04032328352332115, 0.027757422998547554, -0.022412242367863655, -0.01806342415511608, 0.03373558446764946, -0.04095626249909401, 0.014042817056179047, 0.00883243978023529, -0.022845951840281487, -0.0160941481590271, -0.036642611026763916, -0.0184268020093441, 0.04712197557091713, -0.03788512945175171, 0.002246206160634756, -0.004744432866573334, -0.00046118287718854845, 0.016012094914913177, 0.037369366735219955, 0.008937937207520008, -0.003311432432383299, 0.011757049709558487, 0.0042902096174657345, -0.002675520023331046, -0.028484178707003593, -0.009148931130766869, 0.03228206932544708, -0.027335435152053833, 0.015613550320267677, 0.013398113660514355, -0.06292307376861572, -0.023994697257876396, -0.0016439942410215735, 0.01224936917424202, 0.02419396862387657, 0.030172130092978477, -0.03636128455400467, 0.03345425799489021, 0.0016498551703989506, 0.024615956470370293, 0.028554510325193405, -0.04562157392501831, 0.030453454703092575, -0.05218582972884178, -0.027733977884054184, 0.026608677580952644, 0.022107474505901337, 0.004609630908817053, 0.0037597944028675556, -0.0025524403899908066, 0.015613550320267677, -0.009043433703482151, -0.02452218160033226, 0.006277068983763456, -0.014781296253204346, -0.014277255162596703, 0.02182614803314209, 0.01730150170624256, 0.01807514578104019, -0.021744094789028168, -0.02292800508439541, 0.028835834935307503, 0.009770190343260765, -0.0044220807030797005, 0.02073601260781288, -0.0020850300788879395, -0.0063591222278773785, 0.013163676485419273, 0.05171695351600647, 0.0328681655228138, 0.017020175233483315, 0.016668519005179405, -0.002852813573554158, 0.0019121323712170124, -0.02754642814397812, 0.005526868626475334, -0.001903340918943286, -0.04700475558638573, -0.027710534632205963, -0.04437905550003052, 0.025788145139813423, 0.032727502286434174, 0.00450706435367465, -0.020138196647167206, 0.006312234792858362, 0.02106422558426857, 0.023971254006028175, 0.013679439201951027, 0.01651613600552082, 0.010965823195874691, -0.040862489491701126, -0.0011040549725294113, 0.05204516649246216, 0.010596583597362041, 0.015179839916527271, 0.020818065851926804, 0.01112992875277996, 0.015285337343811989, -0.014781296253204346, 0.011727745644748211, 0.0031004385091364384, 0.02445184998214245, 0.029609479010105133, 0.05940651148557663, 0.017324944958090782, 0.017899317666888237, 0.005790610797703266, -0.009664693847298622, 0.014652355574071407, 0.0014044282725080848, 0.025600595399737358, -0.00022454734425991774, 0.01644580438733101, -0.014617189764976501, 0.004990592133253813, 0.012214203365147114, -0.0303127933293581, -0.035423535853624344, 0.00197220710106194, 0.012683078646659851, 0.02032574824988842, 0.005723210051655769, 0.006101240869611502, -0.023197609931230545, 0.03647850453853607, -0.00897896382957697, -0.021603433415293694, -0.034321676939725876, 0.016621632501482964, -0.03631439805030823, -0.02256462723016739, 0.07033130526542664, -0.02569437026977539, 0.013679439201951027, 0.039690300822257996, -0.023455491289496422, 0.006411870941519737, 0.012085262686014175, 0.018602630123496056, -0.02109939232468605, 0.002282836940139532, -0.04149547219276428, -0.04147202521562576, -0.004682892933487892, 0.005720279645174742, 0.0010300605790689588, -0.019012896344065666, 0.020091310143470764, 0.004146616440266371, 0.028249740600585938, -0.021228332072496414, -0.0016308071790263057, -0.0067225005477666855, -0.0022256928496062756, 0.01549633126705885, -0.015449443832039833, 0.008920353837311268, 0.01568388193845749, -0.01418348029255867, 0.00918995775282383, -0.006910050753504038, -0.004559813067317009, 0.005799402482807636, 0.009635388851165771, -0.021333830431103706, 0.017875874415040016, -0.0011450815945863724, -0.021228332072496414, -0.004498273134231567, 0.008779691532254219, -0.035048432648181915, -0.04315997660160065, 0.00421987846493721, 0.0329853817820549, -0.02679622732102871, 0.0036367145366966724, 0.020513297989964485, -0.008932075463235378, -0.023279663175344467, -0.01576593518257141, 0.03251650556921959, 0.006786970887333155, -0.016246531158685684, 0.043910179287195206, 0.008222902193665504, -0.02026713825762272, 0.011663274839520454, 0.025061389431357384, -0.035423535853624344, -0.008164292201399803, -0.0094126733019948, -0.0040997290052473545, -0.033524587750434875, 0.0107489675283432, -0.024709731340408325, -0.048856813460588455, 0.0009025851031765342, -0.030969219282269478, 0.010831020772457123, 0.052279602736234665, 0.011534334160387516, -0.006529089529067278, 0.008826578967273235, -0.010801716707646847, -0.013280894607305527, 0.005682183429598808, 0.0018139616586267948, -0.0037363506853580475, -0.0007509331917390227, 0.03666605427861214, 0.023537544533610344, -0.00024670903803780675, -0.016258252784609795, -0.028132522478699684, -0.02717132866382599, 0.004709267057478428, -0.013316060416400433, -0.030359679833054543, 0.002889444585889578, -0.013269172981381416, -0.008656611666083336, -0.005210377741605043, 0.008345982059836388, -0.023572709411382675, -0.0007721791043877602, 0.019294220954179764, 0.012964404188096523, 0.0027619691099971533, -0.01644580438733101, -0.01604725979268551, 0.0036425755824893713, 0.010256648994982243, -0.03518909588456154, 0.014570302329957485, 0.018895678222179413, -0.013046457432210445, 0.027030665427446365, 0.018977731466293335, 0.006241903640329838, 0.03397002071142197, 0.018133755773305893, -0.017031898722052574, -0.0034110683482140303, 0.014019373804330826, 0.0307113379240036, 0.026936890557408333, -0.0004381054313853383, 0.012530694715678692, 0.020818065851926804, -0.025553707033395767, -0.03783824294805527, 0.001117242150940001, 0.03425134718418121, 0.016668519005179405, -0.015601827763020992, -0.02487383782863617, -0.05012277886271477, 0.0032909191213548183, 0.07197237014770508, -0.012026653625071049, 0.023150721564888954, -0.018684683367609978, 0.0009436116670258343, -0.011592943221330643, -0.02264668047428131, 0.041917458176612854, -0.011024432256817818, -0.011047876439988613, -0.006470480002462864, 0.004788389895111322, -0.005005244631320238, 0.033102601766586304, 0.018590908497571945, -0.00764852948486805, -0.016258252784609795, 0.0309926625341177, 0.03675983101129532, 0.007003826089203358, -0.005122463684529066, 0.0030828556045889854, -0.007988464087247849, 0.026936890557408333, -0.01683262549340725, -0.015191562473773956, 0.01691467873752117, 0.03704115375876427, -0.018848789855837822, -0.0054975636303424835, 0.0004915865138173103, -0.02182614803314209, 0.00210554338991642, -0.00938336830586195, -0.028906166553497314, -0.0038711524102836847, 0.019856872037053108, 0.014640633948147297, 0.011827381327748299, 0.015836264938116074, 0.028202854096889496, 0.009453699924051762, 0.015836264938116074, 0.0051927948370575905, -0.009406812489032745, -0.006177432835102081, -0.014980568550527096, 0.04252699762582779, 0.01991548202931881, 0.024311188608407974, -0.03894009813666344, -0.008937937207520008, 0.01805170252919197, -0.0012996639125049114, 0.031625643372535706, 0.002745851408690214, 0.03472021967172623, 0.02524893917143345, -0.007531310897320509, -0.03647850453853607, -0.005479980725795031, -0.04301931709051132, -0.0398075208067894, 0.012507250532507896, 0.03326670825481415, 0.008943798020482063, 0.03488432615995407, 0.027452653273940086, -0.0114874467253685, -0.020372634753584862, 0.0015502192545682192, 0.024709731340408325, -0.03783824294805527, -0.0028366961050778627, -0.010971684008836746, 0.0030242460779845715, -0.020525019615888596, -0.008750386536121368, -0.019798262044787407, -0.016387194395065308, -0.027311990037560463, -0.012554137967526913, -0.0031121603678911924, 0.0076075028628110886, -0.009875687770545483, 0.0036249926779419184, 0.01728978008031845, 0.004756154492497444, -0.009529892355203629, 0.014265533536672592, -0.007502005901187658, -0.008375286124646664, 0.026890002191066742, 0.032750945538282394, 0.014781296253204346, -0.01993892528116703, -0.0027077551931142807, 0.01321056392043829, 0.004073354881256819, -0.011481585912406445, -0.010655192658305168, 0.025788145139813423, 0.012905795127153397, -0.02534271404147148, 0.0343451201915741, 0.0028264394495636225, -0.025366157293319702, -0.020103031769394875, 0.0014769574627280235, 0.002098217373713851, 0.05218582972884178, 0.02296317182481289, 0.05781233310699463, -0.035118766129016876, -0.0032586839515715837, 0.05720279738306999, -0.015543218702077866, -0.034298233687877655, -0.015390833839774132, -0.024826951324939728, 0.01911839284002781, -0.0021553614642471075, 0.016574744135141373, -0.03329015150666237, -0.020138196647167206, -0.0005992813385091722, -0.0018476620316505432, -0.0014850161969661713, -0.02574125863611698, 0.03176630660891533, -0.015050899237394333, -0.02228330262005329, -0.007777470164000988, 0.007449257653206587, 0.020571907982230186, 0.006030909717082977, -0.004931983072310686, -0.00489681726321578, 0.024334631860256195, -0.012776853516697884, -0.014324142597615719, -0.029210936278104782, -0.024264300242066383, -0.009113765321671963, 0.027382321655750275, -0.009283732622861862, -0.009459560737013817, 0.008926214650273323, -0.0008923284476622939, -0.0038564999122172594, -0.022470852360129356, -0.016269976273179054, -0.0065583945252001286, 0.01614103466272354, 0.013093344867229462, -0.014793017879128456, -0.039619967341423035, -0.007009686902165413, -0.02637423947453499, 0.02869517356157303, -0.029820473864674568, 0.022892840206623077, -0.00726756826043129, -0.019622433930635452, -0.00216268771328032, 0.013468445278704166, -0.02065395936369896, -0.007865384221076965, -0.03193041309714317, 0.021298663690686226, -0.019329387694597244, -0.02188475802540779, 0.01997409015893936, -0.016996731981635094, -0.03997162729501724, -0.03155531361699104, -0.006030909717082977, -0.002098217373713851, -0.023936087265610695, 0.008263928815722466, -0.001236658776178956, -0.049278803169727325, 0.01770004630088806, 0.009688137099146843, -0.0016190853202715516, -0.03155531361699104, 0.025553707033395767, -0.0019472980638965964, 0.0315084233880043, 0.009125486947596073, 0.0005732733989134431, -0.011100624687969685, 0.011592943221330643, -0.00467703165486455, 0.0343451201915741, 0.03983096405863762, -0.008691777475178242, -0.017442163079977036, 0.02293972857296467, 0.0005871931207366288, -0.03460300341248512, -0.025975694879889488, 0.0023810076527297497, -0.010198039002716541, 0.002716546645388007, 0.02602258324623108, 0.033852800726890564, 0.016609910875558853, -0.01874329335987568, 0.039291758090257645, 0.03146153688430786, -0.019681043922901154, -0.027054108679294586, 0.016797460615634918, 0.00368653261102736, 0.002394194947555661, 0.008357703685760498, -0.009078599512577057, -0.039713744074106216, -0.003704115515574813, 0.049278803169727325, 0.01210870686918497, -0.0030682033393532038, 0.0050755757838487625, 0.022013699635863304, -0.0022139709908515215, 0.03490777313709259, 0.010784133337438107, 0.046910982578992844, -0.007502005901187658, -0.01642235927283764, -0.0544833168387413, -0.0018828277243301272, -0.050779204815626144, 0.008680054917931557, 0.03575174883008003, -0.01399592962116003, -0.010180456563830376, 0.00671663973480463, -0.023654762655496597, -0.017770376056432724, -0.0474267452955246, 0.021990254521369934, 0.0192238911986351, 0.009477143175899982, 0.04358196631073952, 0.007701278198510408, -0.0028689312748610973, -0.05781233310699463, -0.018930843099951744, -0.02916404791176319, 0.002896770602092147, -0.012143871746957302, -0.03178974986076355, -0.011387811042368412, -0.012964404188096523, 0.03523598611354828, -0.039338644593954086, -0.032375846058130264, 0.011165094561874866, -0.035024989396333694, 0.012190760113298893, 0.0014703638153150678, 0.00978191290050745, 0.029351597651839256, 0.010872047394514084, -0.019727932289242744, 0.015402556397020817, -0.04323031008243561, 0.008568697609007359, 0.0030418289825320244, -0.007795053068548441, -0.024615956470370293, -0.009277871809899807, 0.02878894843161106, -0.009828800335526466, 0.010104264132678509, -0.06325128674507141, 0.020149920135736465, 0.023490656167268753, 0.010063237510621548, -0.006464619189500809, 0.03319637477397919, 0.011042014695703983, -0.0499352291226387, -0.008844161406159401, -0.004589117597788572, 0.018122034147381783, -0.04909125342965126, 0.0054418849758803844, 0.02562403865158558, 0.019411440938711166, -0.01988031528890133, -0.04102659597992897, -0.001414684928022325, -0.026679009199142456, -0.036197178065776825, -0.046160779893398285, 0.03443889692425728, -0.02075945772230625, -0.00002822867827489972, -0.012788576073944569, 0.000698551069945097, 0.017137395218014717, -0.004527577664703131, 0.02112283557653427, -0.007906410843133926, -0.016938121989369392, 0.014781296253204346, -0.019048061221837997, 0.007976742461323738, -0.003460886422544718, -0.016234809532761574, 0.030781667679548264, 0.04285521060228348, 0.025858476758003235, -0.010848604142665863, 0.04791906476020813, 0.006675613112747669, 0.04838793724775314, -0.04552779719233513, 0.0012623004149645567, 0.038518112152814865, -0.00595471728593111, 0.05715590715408325, 0.01454685814678669, 0.03650194779038429, 0.06128201261162758, 0.033548034727573395, 0.025389602407813072, -0.01920044608414173, -0.006452897563576698, -0.023092111572623253, 0.020970450714230537, 0.007841940969228745, 0.002949519082903862, 0.0064763412810862064, 0.009219261817634106, -0.016316862776875496, -0.02724165841937065, 0.01224936917424202, -0.013058179058134556, -0.011030293069779873, 0.0001511939917691052, -0.014898515306413174, -0.0015121230389922857, 0.005611852277070284, 0.007636807858943939, -0.02492072619497776, 0.001397102139890194, 0.046606212854385376, -0.0006055085686966777, -0.02993769198656082, -0.0009223657543770969, 0.035868965089321136, -0.007671973202377558, -0.014242089353501797, -0.01833302713930607, 0.006874885410070419, 0.017852429300546646, -0.03033623658120632, -0.009471282362937927, -0.02179098315536976, 0.005099019501358271, 0.0030652727000415325, 0.0008058795356191695, 0.03211796283721924, -0.0303127933293581, 0.019763097167015076, -0.003786168759688735, 0.008949658833444118, 0.06451725214719772, 0.008011908270418644, 0.012167315930128098, -0.0384477823972702, -0.04517614096403122, 0.02064223773777485, 0.002877722727134824, -0.0027971346862614155, 0.01034456305205822, 0.0008014838676899672, 0.018661240115761757, 0.007138627581298351, -0.006118823774158955, 0.014910236932337284, -0.00023553661594633013, -0.011469864286482334, 0.002972963033244014, -0.0010249322513118386 ]
13.576735
6.364363
2024-07-01
1
2024MNRAS.531.2998B
[ "Ly α emitters", "other galaxy samples", "confirmed Ly", "stellar properties", "faint galaxies", "Ly", "physical properties", "strong active galactic nuclei activity", "specific star formation rate", "C III" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
43
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1339", "10.48550/arXiv.2403.00984" ]
[ "Bolan, Patricia", "Bradăc, Marus̆a", "Lemaux, Brian C.", "Strait, Victoria", "Treu, Tommaso", "Pentericci, Laura", "Pelliccia, Debora", "Glazer, Kelsey", "Jones, Gareth C." ]
[ "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California, Davis, 1 Shields Ave, Davis, CA 95616, USA;", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California, Davis, 1 Shields Ave, Davis, CA 95616, USA; Department of Mathematics and Physics, University of Ljubljana, Jadranska ulica 19, SI-1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia;", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California, Davis, 1 Shields Ave, Davis, CA 95616, USA; Gemini Observatory, NSF's NOIRLab, 670 N. A'ohoku Place, Hilo, HI 96720, USA;", "Cosmic Dawn Center (DAWN); Niels Bohr Institute, University of Copenhagen, Jagtvej 128, København N, DK-2200, Denmark;", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California, Los Angeles, CA 90095-1547, USA;", "INAF Osservatorio Astronomico di Roma, Via Frascati 33, I-00040 Monteporzio (RM), Italy", "UCO/Lick Observatory, Department of Astronomy &amp; Astrophysics, UC Santa Cruz, 1156 High Street, Santa Cruz, CA 95064, USA;", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California, Davis, 1 Shields Ave, Davis, CA 95616, USA;", "Department of Physics, University of Oxford, Denys Wilkinson Building, Keble Road, Oxford OX1 3RH, UK;" ]
[ "2024arXiv240603956H" ]
[ "1983ApJ...266..713O", "1996A&AS..117..393B", "1998ApJ...509..103S", "1998SPIE.3356..234F", "2000ApJ...533..682C", "2000ApJ...539..718C", "2002MNRAS.336.1188K", "2003MNRAS.344.1000B", "2003SPIE.4841.1657F", "2004ApJS..154...10F", "2005A&A...437...49B", "2006A&A...460..397V", "2006ARA&A..44..415F", "2006MNRAS.365.1012F", "2007A&A...471..433P", "2008A&A...491...89V", "2008ApJ...686.1503B", "2008MNRAS.384..449F", "2008MNRAS.386.1990M", "2008SPIE.7010E..1EK", "2009A&A...494..553P", "2009ApJ...706.1201B", "2009MNRAS.398.1601F", "2010ApJ...711..693K", "2010ApJ...719.1168E", "2010MNRAS.408.1628S", "2010SPIE.7735E..1EM", "2011A&A...529A...9N", "2011ApJ...730....8H", "2011ApJ...736...31B", "2012A&A...539A..61T", "2012A&A...545A.141B", "2012ApJ...747...27T", "2012ApJ...751...51J", "2012ApJS..199...25P", "2013ApJ...775L..29T", "2014A&A...561A..89A", "2014ApJ...785..108B", "2014ApJ...786...59H", "2014MNRAS.440.1662S", "2014MNRAS.445.3200S", "2014PASA...31...40D", "2015A&A...576A..79L", "2015A&A...582A..15M", "2015ApJ...802L..19R", "2015ApJ...811..140B", "2015ApJS..218...15K", "2015MNRAS.450.1846S", "2016A&A...587A.122A", "2016A&A...588A..26H", "2016A&A...590A..31C", "2016ApJ...817...11H", "2016ApJ...821L..14O", "2016ApJ...823L..14H", "2016ApJ...826..159S", "2016ApJ...831..182H", "2017A&A...600A.110T", "2017A&A...606A..19G", "2017A&A...607A..30D", "2017ApJ...837...97L", "2017ApJ...843..133O", "2017ApJ...844..171Y", "2017MNRAS.471.4527T", "2018A&A...612A..94N", "2018A&A...619A.147P", "2018ApJ...855...42S", "2018ApJ...856....2M", "2018ApJ...859...11S", "2018ApJ...859...58F", "2018ApJ...860...75D", "2018ApJ...863L...3C", "2018MNRAS.477.2098N", "2018MNRAS.480.4379C", "2019A&A...631A..19M", "2019ApJ...878...12H", "2019ApJ...878...87F", "2019ApJ...879...36F", "2019ApJ...879...70H", "2019ApJ...884...85C", "2019ApJ...887...85T", "2019MNRAS.489...99B", "2019PASJ...71...51Y", "2020A&A...643A...6C", "2020ApJ...888..109J", "2020ApJ...888..124S", "2020ApJ...890...65D", "2020ApJ...892..109N", "2020ApJ...896..156F", "2020MNRAS.491..468I", "2020MNRAS.493..141S", "2021A&A...646A..39C", "2021ApJ...908L..30P", "2021ApJ...917L..36T", "2021MNRAS.501.3238T", "2021MNRAS.502.6044E", "2021MNRAS.504.3662L", "2021MNRAS.505.2447P", "2022A&A...659A..16L", "2022A&A...662A..33L", "2022AJ....164..159P", "2022ARA&A..60..121R", "2022ApJ...926...31R", "2022ApJ...930..104L", "2022ApJ...930..126F", "2022ApJ...936..131M", "2022ApJ...940...55B", "2022MNRAS.513.3510B", "2022MNRAS.517.3263B", "2022MNRAS.517.5104C", "2022arXiv221209850J", "2023A&A...672A.155M", "2023A&A...672A.186P", "2023A&A...673A..84S", "2023A&A...677A..88B", "2023A&A...677A.138N", "2023A&A...678A..68S", "2023ARA&A..61..373F", "2023ApJ...947L..24M", "2023ApJ...952..110C", "2023ApJ...955L...2H", "2023ApJ...956...11M", "2023ApJS..269...33N", "2023MNRAS.520.2757Y", "2023MNRAS.522.6295S", "2023MNRAS.523.3201D", "2023MNRAS.524.5891T", "2023MNRAS.525.2422S", "2023MNRAS.526.1657T", "2023MNRAS.526.3504H", "2023NatAs...7..611R", "2023arXiv230609142S", "2023arXiv230906656C", "2024A&A...682A..40W", "2024A&A...683A.238J", "2024A&A...684A..75C", "2024A&A...685A...3M", "2024ApJ...963...97I", "2024ApJ...967...73J", "2024MNRAS.527.4173L", "2024MNRAS.tmp.1657C" ]
29184554
2404.14184
Kinematic morphology of low-mass galaxies in IllustrisTNG
The origin of diverse kinematic morphologies observed in low-mass galaxies is unclear. In this study, we investigate the kinematic morphologies of central galaxies with stellar mass 10<SUP>8.5 - 9.0</SUP>M<SUB>⊙</SUB> at z = 0 in the TNG50-1 cosmological simulation. The majority of the low-mass galaxies in TNG50-1 are dispersion-dominated, consistent with observations. By tracing the evolutionary histories of simulated low-mass galaxies, we find that while most stars form in rotating cold gas discs, the orientation of the star-forming discs relative to the galaxies may evolve with cosmic time. If the cold gas disc remains aligning with the galaxy during its evolution, stars formed at different times share the same rotational direction, leading to a rotation-dominated system. On the contrary, frequent misalignment of cold gas disc would result in a dispersion-dominated system. In addition, we also find that the two-body scattering can have a non-negligible numerical heating effect on the simulated galaxy morphology, especially at central regions of galaxies and for relatively low-mass galaxies. By comparing results of simulations with different resolutions, our results suggest that the simulated morphology of galaxies is roughly reliable when their number of stellar particles exceeds about 10<SUP>4</SUP>, and bulge morphology of galaxies can not be resolved robustly at the resolution level of TNG50-1.
[ 0.023099081590771675, 0.04565214365720749, 0.030862081795930862, -0.004564027301967144, -0.0021989233791828156, 0.04375293850898743, -0.0050121210515499115, -0.014208427630364895, -0.021449146792292595, 0.003955687861889601, -0.0358474962413311, 0.019003920257091522, -0.033141128718853, -0.019811082631349564, 0.029342718422412872, 0.04126023128628731, 0.0039912983775138855, 0.0058905030600726604, 0.004098128527402878, 0.0400020070374012, 0.035515133291482925, 0.0055996873416006565, -0.004216828849166632, 0.0037509300746023655, -0.0551244281232357, 0.0007433607243001461, 0.007430640049278736, 0.03366341069340706, 0.02207825891673565, -0.026256510987877846, 0.006267376709729433, -0.0023443312384188175, -0.02236313931643963, -0.03299868851900101, -0.07706024497747421, 0.0992334634065628, 0.017306506633758545, 0.007579015102237463, -0.004733175039291382, -0.03114696405827999, -0.0275859534740448, 0.030173620209097862, -0.03769921883940697, 0.013080774806439877, -0.014956239610910416, -0.017888138070702553, 0.016891054809093475, -0.028345635160803795, -0.039218585938215256, -0.005905340891331434, -0.07786741107702255, 0.0029749267268925905, 0.018505379557609558, -0.016748614609241486, -0.036488477140665054, 0.00610119616612792, -0.012321093119680882, -0.022517450153827667, -0.011442710645496845, 0.03504033386707306, -0.042827073484659195, -0.02071320451796055, 0.04223357141017914, -0.010570263490080833, 0.012261742725968361, -0.005905340891331434, -0.046126943081617355, -0.03352097049355507, 0.01370988693088293, 0.08171329647302628, -0.02979378029704094, -0.029580118134617805, 0.009549440816044807, 0.029318979009985924, 0.014979979954659939, 0.02523568645119667, -0.007365354802459478, -0.019526202231645584, -0.02232752926647663, -0.008576097898185253, 0.038791265338659286, 0.016356904059648514, 0.01988230273127556, 0.020653855055570602, 0.009003419429063797, 0.013401266187429428, 0.05616898834705353, 0.0017493459163233638, -0.04178251326084137, 0.01779317669570446, 0.036488477140665054, 0.026802532374858856, -0.01724715530872345, -0.019621161743998528, 0.030814602971076965, -0.03886248543858528, 0.04425147920846939, -0.05987244099378586, 0.05051885545253754, 0.022695500403642654, -0.008196257054805756, 0.05360506474971771, 0.007359419483691454, -0.021152395755052567, 0.060204800218343735, -0.026992451399564743, -0.010718639008700848, -0.01054652314633131, 0.01670113392174244, 0.04541474208235741, 0.043539274483919144, -0.00000329787508235313, -0.0004911225405521691, 0.02219695970416069, -0.013923547230660915, -0.001418468775227666, -0.028606776148080826, 0.03515903279185295, -0.04785996675491333, 0.014493308961391449, 0.01875464990735054, -0.003169298404827714, -0.006362337153404951, 0.004988380707800388, -0.0029482191894203424, -0.04123649001121521, 0.013638666830956936, -0.01488501951098442, -0.0509936548769474, 0.037438079714775085, 0.03418569266796112, -0.02813197486102581, 0.003460114123299718, -0.022125739604234695, -0.05175333842635155, 0.0019348151981830597, -0.008356502279639244, 0.008528618142008781, -0.00012509900261648, 0.020891256630420685, 0.002909641480073333, -0.0106889633461833, 0.016986016184091568, 0.004934965632855892, 0.03644099831581116, 0.038696303963661194, -0.04769378900527954, 0.038150280714035034, -0.03235770761966705, 0.0029155765660107136, 0.005213911645114422, 0.035776276141405106, -0.00096147257136181, -0.060347240418195724, -0.03363966941833496, -0.008493008092045784, -0.023811284452676773, -0.016772354021668434, -0.02580544911324978, -0.006528517231345177, -0.008095361292362213, -0.006617542821913958, -0.008190321736037731, 0.010552458465099335, -0.023787543177604675, 0.019953522831201553, -0.013959157280623913, -0.008243736810982227, -0.06941594183444977, -0.014564529061317444, 0.04121274873614311, -0.02358575351536274, -0.03905240446329117, -0.03748555853962898, -0.007905441336333752, 0.04923688992857933, -0.012772154062986374, -0.0620565265417099, -0.017994968220591545, 0.0282744150608778, 0.011223115026950836, 0.03667839616537094, -0.006320791784673929, -0.033022429794073105, -0.07758253067731857, 0.024903327226638794, -0.04320691525936127, 0.0524180606007576, 0.021461017429828644, 0.0026826271787285805, -0.040334366261959076, 0.011407100595533848, -0.0013116385089233518, 0.005130821373313665, -0.024927066639065742, -0.018576599657535553, 0.03228648751974106, 0.031526803970336914, 0.003409666707739234, 0.025995370000600815, 0.07406900078058243, 0.000613903219345957, 0.028298156335949898, -0.07079286873340607, -0.06746926158666611, -0.012380442582070827, 0.008386177010834217, -0.004187153652310371, -0.040049485862255096, -0.007258524186909199, 0.010338797233998775, 0.008801628835499287, -0.011258725076913834, 0.024214863777160645, -0.027657173573970795, 0.019336281344294548, -0.03974086791276932, 0.012855243869125843, 0.03278502821922302, 0.05422230437397957, 0.014790059067308903, 0.009466350078582764, 0.05279790237545967, 0.04301699623465538, 0.013294435106217861, -0.011549540795385838, 0.021057436242699623, -0.016582434996962547, 0.027134891599416733, 0.006872748490422964, 0.02245810069143772, 0.03575253486633301, -0.010184487327933311, -0.003469016868621111, 0.010522782802581787, 0.006854943465441465, -0.026375209912657738, 0.0441090390086174, -0.003905240446329117, 0.0017285733483731747, -0.024998286738991737, 0.02939019910991192, 0.015561611391603947, 0.012024342082440853, -0.03271380811929703, -0.0039230454713106155, -0.028986617922782898, 0.009264559485018253, 0.01365053653717041, -0.0063504669815301895, 0.0386013425886631, -0.04785996675491333, 0.009632530622184277, -0.031526803970336914, -0.039503466337919235, -0.0050417957827448845, -0.03155054524540901, 0.017555776983499527, -0.015941452234983444, 0.03480293229222298, -0.040880389511585236, -0.031811684370040894, -0.01629755273461342, 0.015466650947928429, -0.026446430012583733, 0.06044220179319382, -0.003908208105713129, -0.016748614609241486, -0.02784709446132183, 0.029295237734913826, -0.006849008146673441, -0.03387707099318504, -0.00538305938243866, -0.03760426118969917, -0.05156341940164566, 0.02414364367723465, -0.030292320996522903, 0.047931186854839325, 0.026114068925380707, -0.02756221406161785, 0.018422288820147514, -0.027633434161543846, 0.053035300225019455, 0.0071516940370202065, -0.037984102964401245, 0.02663635089993477, -0.021734027191996574, 0.018825870007276535, -0.027087412774562836, -0.04581832140684128, 0.06865626573562622, -0.023941854014992714, -0.0358000174164772, -0.004650084767490625, -0.028749216347932816, -0.02744351327419281, 0.0039230454713106155, 0.016439994797110558, -0.038696303963661194, -0.008706668391823769, 0.04154511168599129, 0.00143182254396379, 0.02042832411825657, 0.014065987430512905, -0.03143184259533882, -0.0003292079200036824, 0.04109404981136322, 0.027490993961691856, 0.014600139111280441, 0.046672966331243515, 0.021567847579717636, -0.013353785499930382, 0.008872848935425282, 0.01944311149418354, -0.05545678734779358, -0.025757968425750732, -0.03195412456989288, 0.043373096734285355, 0.026992451399564743, -0.027799613773822784, -0.08052629232406616, -0.03238144516944885, 0.004593702033162117, 0.021461017429828644, 0.022090129554271698, -0.010243837721645832, -0.008801628835499287, -0.009786841459572315, -0.0523705780506134, -0.020475804805755615, 0.015359820798039436, -0.014991849660873413, 0.0634809285402298, 0.03532521426677704, -0.01571592129766941, -0.04650678485631943, 0.03264258801937103, 0.0647154152393341, -0.007133889012038708, 0.02123548649251461, -0.031194442883133888, 0.005466149654239416, -0.005783672910183668, 0.0005463924026116729, 0.02097434550523758, 0.031787943094968796, 0.0015327178407460451, 0.020333364605903625, 0.03354470804333687, -0.031906645745038986, -0.003184136003255844, 0.004985413514077663, 0.05574166774749756, -0.004774720408022404, 0.07383159548044205, 0.0034660492092370987, 0.007596820127218962, -0.05113609507679939, -0.010030176490545273, 0.010908558964729309, 0.023609492927789688, -0.029318979009985924, 0.027799613773822784, 0.028725476935505867, 0.015407301485538483, 0.04700532555580139, -0.03653595596551895, 0.02232752926647663, -0.023894373327493668, -0.00046664063120260835, 0.01780504733324051, 0.0578782744705677, -0.04104657098650932, 0.0413314513862133, -0.03682084009051323, -0.00479846028611064, 0.01538356114178896, 0.008101296611130238, -0.014089727774262428, -0.003926013130694628, 0.02511698752641678, -0.042803335934877396, 0.022101998329162598, -0.03128940239548683, -0.018244238570332527, 0.051515936851501465, -0.007181369233876467, 0.01102725975215435, -0.09196900576353073, 0.02537812851369381, -0.020036613568663597, 0.02867799624800682, 0.020226534456014633, 0.028345635160803795, 0.0038310526870191097, 0.0031040133908391, 0.009531635791063309, 0.0468628853559494, -0.0017241220921278, 0.014635749161243439, 0.015347951091825962, -0.038553863763809204, -0.047218985855579376, -0.05313026160001755, -0.018457898870110512, -0.007828285917639732, -0.0014793026493862271, 0.033426009118556976, 0.012190522626042366, -0.01709284633398056, 0.03323609009385109, -0.006890553515404463, 0.009460415691137314, -0.02345518209040165, -0.018564729019999504, 0.026707570999860764, -0.058542996644973755, 0.0033829589374363422, -0.023253392428159714, 0.051800817251205444, -0.022802330553531647, 0.009626595303416252, 0.03378210961818695, -0.013804846443235874, -0.0675642192363739, 0.03183542564511299, -0.0006762208649888635, 0.02950889803469181, -0.00826747715473175, -0.03259510546922684, -0.014445828273892403, 0.054127342998981476, 0.010012371465563774, 0.02606659010052681, 0.008297151885926723, -0.01290272455662489, 0.023953724652528763, -0.03874378278851509, 0.019134491682052612, -0.05464962497353554, 0.004018005914986134, 0.022778591141104698, 0.010095462203025818, -0.06286368519067764, 0.05982495844364166, 0.0019808115903288126, 0.0317167229950428, 0.04040558636188507, 0.035111553966999054, -0.07088782638311386, -0.011905642226338387, 0.024570966139435768, 0.007406899705529213, -0.019633032381534576, -0.02511698752641678, -0.008807563222944736, 0.019383762031793594, -0.03679709881544113, 0.05113609507679939, -0.06153424456715584, -0.014968110248446465, 0.013057034462690353, -0.01220239233225584, 0.0008702217019163072, -0.040334366261959076, 0.022992251440882683, 0.0032405187375843525, -0.026375209912657738, -0.015561611391603947, 0.0015801979461684823, 0.06314856559038162, -0.019538072869181633, 0.008243736810982227, -0.01723528653383255, -0.006534452550113201, 0.00792324636131525, -0.03223900496959686, 0.004397846758365631, 0.060062360018491745, 0.016914794221520424, 0.051800817251205444, -0.02798953466117382, 0.018030578270554543, 0.01137149054557085, 0.017009755596518517, 0.03822150081396103, -0.028298156335949898, 0.031787943094968796, 0.001299768453463912, -0.009122119285166264, -0.04634060338139534, -0.02578170970082283, 0.06538013368844986, -0.010991649702191353, 0.004745045211166143, -0.046554263681173325, -0.04332561418414116, -0.018529118970036507, -0.011086609214544296, 0.010742378421127796, 0.037722960114479065, -0.004872648045420647, 0.01876652054488659, -0.009412935003638268, 0.0071516940370202065, -0.0011350717395544052, -0.0019778439309448004, -0.006231766659766436, -0.008255607448518276, 0.011353685520589352, -0.023336483165621758, 0.021271096542477608, 0.00874821376055479, -0.004148575942963362, 0.031906645745038986, 0.031811684370040894, -0.033568449318408966, 0.027680912986397743, 0.021033696830272675, -0.015300470404326916, 0.0014644651673734188, -0.021864598616957664, -0.01724715530872345, 0.0023576850071549416, 0.020499544218182564, -0.02882043644785881, -0.0006580448825843632, -0.1226886510848999, -0.040073227137327194, -0.00008893250196706504, 0.0165705643594265, -0.02150849811732769, 0.061154402792453766, 0.031645502895116806, -0.024096164852380753, -0.057735834270715714, -0.016345033422112465, -0.013318175449967384, -0.023229651153087616, -0.03532521426677704, 0.027965795248746872, -0.010884818620979786, 0.009507895447313786, 0.012178652919828892, 0.010920429602265358, 0.022837940603494644, -0.009365455247461796, 0.008510813117027283, 0.030553461983799934, 0.03183542564511299, 0.0131045151501894, -0.009163664653897285, 0.01330630574375391, 0.014790059067308903, -0.011697916314005852, -0.01625007390975952, -0.008214062079787254, 0.008860978297889233, -0.010220097377896309, 0.0074662500992417336, -0.03197786584496498, -0.025330647826194763, 0.004712402354925871, 0.050423894077539444, 0.009128054603934288, -0.041735030710697174, -0.01076611876487732, 0.005205008666962385, -0.03570505604147911, 0.010475303046405315, -0.03271380811929703, -0.017626997083425522, 0.03223900496959686, -0.025069506838917732, -0.021140526980161667, -0.014742579311132431, -0.014873149804770947, 0.008504877798259258, 0.010653353296220303, -0.06162920594215393, -0.005561109632253647, -0.04508237913250923, 0.019466852769255638, -0.02179337851703167, -0.028986617922782898, 0.020499544218182564, -0.009899605996906757, 0.034707970917224884, 0.04600824415683746, -0.0055225323885679245, 0.013876067474484444, 0.0012641584035009146, 0.01808992773294449, 0.01102725975215435, 0.008451462723314762, 0.0012678677449002862, -0.004890453070402145, -0.008214062079787254, 0.0018279849318787456, 0.004335529170930386, -0.012795894406735897, 0.018671559169888496, -0.04026314616203308, -0.012867114506661892, -0.006510712206363678, 0.010878884233534336, -0.006154611241072416, -0.0013227666495367885, -0.001034918357618153, 0.013045164756476879, 0.021152395755052567, 0.05365254357457161, -0.014801929704844952, -0.003566944506019354, 0.011478320695459843, 0.004258373752236366, 0.005320741795003414, 0.017876267433166504, 0.010113267228007317, 0.0007841639453545213, -0.01780504733324051, -0.02977003902196884, -0.002759782364591956, -0.003495724406093359, 0.0372481606900692, 0.000009783502719074022, 0.0008991549257189035, -0.005670907441526651, -0.016606174409389496, -0.03074338287115097, 0.008700733073055744, -0.03363966941833496, 0.01959742233157158, 0.015063069760799408, -0.008587967604398727, -0.004807362798601389, -0.006249571684747934, 0.02497454732656479, -0.007489989977329969, -0.020214663818478584, 0.025283167138695717, 0.006510712206363678, 0.0032078761141747236, -0.02825067564845085, -0.005762900225818157, -0.0010979779763147235, -0.011282465420663357, 0.017009755596518517, -0.05493450537323952, 0.0009918895084410906, 0.017140325158834457, -0.02746725268661976, 0.02041645534336567, 0.01655869372189045, 0.022564930841326714, -0.011543605476617813, -0.02245810069143772, -0.002237501088529825, -0.058685436844825745, 0.03736685961484909, -0.010706768371164799, -0.006635347846895456, -0.00751966517418623, 0.027657173573970795, 0.003899305360391736, 0.004946835804730654, -0.0124160535633564, 0.028749216347932816, 0.0031336883548647165, 0.008439592085778713, 0.0979040190577507, -0.0001308485516346991, 0.0028547425754368305, 0.02125922590494156, -0.009169599041342735, -0.01808992773294449, -0.0011053966591134667, -0.0317167229950428, -0.023787543177604675, -0.010184487327933311, 0.02287355065345764, 0.004059550818055868, -0.006932098418474197, 0.00521094398573041, 0.025473088026046753, -0.007122018840163946, 0.006825268268585205, 0.01102725975215435, 0.024476004764437675, 0.006439492106437683, 0.013282565400004387, -0.03321234881877899, 0.0050121210515499115, 0.03518277406692505, 0.002379941288381815, -0.0072941347025334835, 0.013603055849671364, 0.004807362798601389, -0.003317673923447728, -0.02109304629266262, 0.014647618867456913, 0.013401266187429428, 0.007193239405751228, -0.02302786149084568, 0.0021915046963840723, -0.028369376435875893, 0.024226734414696693, -0.011828486807644367, 0.007555275224149227, -0.0018487573834136128, 0.02014344371855259, 0.00727039435878396, -0.014766319654881954, -0.00015486682241316885, -0.0013509580167010427, -0.010291317477822304, -0.020499544218182564, -0.017816917970776558, -0.016641784459352493, -0.0007170240860432386, 0.02910531684756279, -0.008326827548444271, -0.04453635960817337, 0.004400814417749643, 0.04012070596218109, -0.021152395755052567, 0.025283167138695717, 0.027134891599416733, -0.0002819132641889155, -0.038411423563957214, 0.011157830245792866, 0.00572729017585516, -0.0034986918326467276, -0.022529320791363716, -0.005430539604276419, 0.04223357141017914, 0.04069046676158905, -0.027680912986397743, 0.0075849504210054874, 0.0317167229950428, 0.0069558387622237206, 0.010368472896516323, 0.0053504169918596745, 0.005682777613401413, 0.021306706592440605, -0.00572729017585516, 0.032879989594221115, 0.0036233272403478622, -0.004092193208634853, -0.004682727623730898, 0.02953263930976391, 0.008493008092045784, 0.01959742233157158, 0.002149959560483694, 0.043539274483919144, -0.03641725704073906, 0.01874277926981449, -0.0022167284041643143, 0.00820812676101923, 0.02096247673034668, 0.047124024480581284, 0.0275859534740448, 0.0056204600259661674, 0.015644701197743416, -0.024927066639065742, 0.007080473937094212, -0.03788914158940315, -0.008154711686074734, 0.013769236393272877, 0.0071516940370202065, -0.0037924752105027437, 0.042399752885103226, 0.03102826327085495, -0.03007866069674492, 0.026517650112509727, -0.01041001733392477, 0.005650135222822428, -0.016190722584724426, -0.013068905100226402, 0.029888739809393883, 0.005291066598147154, -0.0065225823782384396, 0.030102400109171867, -0.042684633284807205, -0.0028146812692284584, 0.01971612311899662, 0.024381045252084732, -0.02300412207841873, -0.0004829619138035923, -0.026090329512953758, -0.048216067254543304, 0.02454722486436367, 0.01600080356001854, 0.035111553966999054, -0.015893971547484398, 0.03679709881544113, 0.010582133196294308, -0.1006578654050827, 0.013033295050263405, 0.008047881536185741, -0.0029882804956287146, 0.00985806155949831, 0.06314856559038162, 0.027253592386841774, 0.0059646908193826675, 0.02218508906662464, 0.0015037846751511097, -0.03102826327085495, -0.01338939554989338, -0.0011439742520451546, 0.030577201396226883, 0.06428809463977814, -0.020202793180942535, -0.020938735455274582, -0.02110491693019867, -0.013781107030808926, 0.021817117929458618, -0.01587023213505745, 0.02606659010052681, -0.011763201095163822, -0.01020229235291481, 0.0046738251112401485, -0.011145959608256817, -0.021211747080087662, -0.01573966257274151, 0.01573966257274151, -0.01468322891741991, 0.0192888006567955, -0.03779418021440506, -0.00036574536352418363, 0.047361426055431366, -0.020321493968367577, -0.040073227137327194, 0.009306104853749275, 0.0016128405695781112, -0.038696303963661194, 0.012617843225598335, -0.009128054603934288, -0.00041953142499551177, 0.019478721544146538, 0.014303388074040413, 0.04161633178591728, 0.007632430177181959, 0.02427421510219574, 0.04028688743710518, 0.026422690600156784, -0.009039029479026794, 0.027277333661913872, -0.02953263930976391, 0.009306104853749275, 0.010380342602729797, 0.025188207626342773, 0.01611950248479843, 0.017864396795630455, -0.00917553436011076, -0.04346805438399315, 0.011988732032477856, -0.01255849376320839, 0.04161633178591728, -0.008938133716583252, -0.04249471426010132, -0.02344331331551075, -0.04016818851232529, -0.019419372081756592, 0.022101998329162598, -0.006142741534858942, -0.005845990497618914, -0.019692381843924522, 0.029580118134617805, 0.033188607543706894, 0.03874378278851509, -0.024855846539139748, -0.025829188525676727, -0.025211947038769722, 0.019526202231645584, -0.028796697035431862, 0.012522883713245392, -0.04482124000787735, -0.03418569266796112, 0.014991849660873413, 0.0007678426918573678, 0.005415701773017645, 0.01240418292582035, 0.00015013734810054302, 0.0017716021975502372, -0.028867917135357857, -0.004311788827180862, 0.004178251139819622, 0.0013034779112786055, 0.01818488910794258, 0.012148977257311344, -0.013436876237392426, 0.013519966043531895, 0.02220882847905159, -0.030316060408949852, -0.005608589854091406, -0.03269006684422493, -0.008356502279639244, -0.02236313931643963, -0.01915823109447956, -0.011389295570552349, 0.03416195139288902, -0.010950104333460331, -0.014303388074040413, 0.00813097134232521, 0.04702906683087349, 0.020641984418034554, 0.03499285504221916, 0.025591788813471794, 0.005359319504350424, 0.007110149133950472, 0.04726646468043327, -0.016060153022408485, -0.006961773615330458, 0.012071821838617325, 0.006575997453182936, -0.004344431683421135, 0.005700582638382912, 0.0035847495310008526, -0.049284372478723526, -0.01435086876153946, -0.004831102676689625, -0.011424905620515347, -0.016463734209537506, 0.011644501239061356, -0.025022026151418686, 0.023799413815140724, -0.0029734428972005844, -0.02810823544859886, 0.014564529061317444, -0.021009955555200577, 0.016511214897036552, -0.010433757677674294, -0.035894975066185, 0.03594245761632919, -0.018588470295071602, -0.005748062860220671, 0.00002849271368177142, -0.019763601943850517, 0.0028488074894994497, 0.011264660395681858, 0.016463734209537506, -0.014813799411058426, 0.00734754977747798, -0.026114068925380707, 0.07492364197969437, -0.0093120401725173, 0.01998913288116455, 0.020190924406051636, -0.0015104615595191717, 0.03651221841573715, -0.001280479715205729, -0.014778189361095428, 0.028369376435875893, -0.015419171191751957, -0.02429795451462269, 0.026303989812731743, 0.029841259121894836, 0.023953724652528763, -0.011668241582810879, -0.01336565613746643, 0.022814201191067696, 0.01750829629600048, -0.02632773108780384, 0.027134891599416733, 0.0010200808756053448, -0.011775071732699871, -0.031123222783207893, -0.03622733801603317, 0.039384763687849045, -0.01836293935775757, 0.0017345084343105555, 0.018695300444960594, 0.022731110453605652, -0.002181118354201317, 0.028440596535801888, 0.017437076196074486, -0.003210843540728092, 0.018422288820147514, -0.038435161113739014, 0.0014548207400366664, -0.0031277532689273357, -0.0072941347025334835, -0.042114872485399246, 0.0048667131923139095, -0.022018909454345703, -0.0011558443075045943, -0.016891054809093475, 0.03466049209237099, -0.019407501444220543, 0.042281053960323334, 0.04527230188250542, 0.021710287779569626, -0.03131314367055893, 0.02440478466451168, 0.0065641277469694614, 0.013128255493938923, -0.0029452515300363302, -0.012855243869125843, -0.014184688217937946, -0.031906645745038986, 0.011757266707718372, 0.005561109632253647, -0.001373214297927916, 0.006249571684747934, -0.03947972506284714, -0.0634334459900856, 0.018802130594849586, -0.0012522883480414748, 0.020167183130979538, -0.021449146792292595, 0.034423090517520905, -0.026850011199712753, 0.051800817251205444, -0.007537470199167728, -0.04852468892931938, 0.016238203272223473, 0.03596619516611099, -0.04615068435668945, 0.0021707320120185614, 0.012985814362764359, 0.004997283220291138, 0.05559922754764557, -0.015003720298409462, 0.016345033422112465, 0.0020134542137384415, 0.0027375260833650827, 0.011003519408404827, -0.009424804709851742, 0.003056533169001341, -0.025757968425750732, -0.0372244194149971, -0.005270293913781643, -0.0000027646508442558115, 0.0008984130108729005, 0.0036886122543364763, 0.0014837539056316018, 0.025757968425750732, 0.003908208105713129, 0.01373362634330988, -0.004124836064875126, 0.0015801979461684823, -0.03136062249541283, -0.0110331941395998, -0.028725476935505867, -0.004940900485962629, 0.004801427945494652, -0.010398147627711296, 0.018719039857387543, -0.033710889518260956, -0.029580118134617805, 0.01454078871756792, 0.022683629766106606, -0.04230479151010513, 0.03223900496959686, 0.020998086780309677, -0.013603055849671364, 0.008041946217417717, -0.00909837894141674, -0.017270896583795547, -0.038838744163513184, -0.006997383665293455, 0.011686046607792377, -0.04016818851232529, 0.023122821003198624, 0.011668241582810879, -0.02893913723528385, -0.0008531585335731506, -0.016226332634687424, 0.04216235131025314, 0.006368272006511688, -0.009359519928693771, 0.007193239405751228, 0.016582434996962547, 0.0015742629766464233, -0.007905441336333752, 0.023419572040438652, -0.012997685000300407, -0.03570505604147911, -0.017187805846333504, -0.020879385992884636, 0.012309222482144833, -0.014754449017345905, -0.02303973212838173, -0.009329845197498798, -0.006920228246599436, -0.014873149804770947, -0.02756221406161785, 0.013769236393272877, 0.01615511253476143, -0.002498641610145569, 0.010950104333460331, -0.02841685526072979, 0.003071370767429471, 0.015597221441566944, 0.005724322982132435, -0.0008998967823572457, -0.03349722921848297, -0.011080674827098846, 0.021342316642403603, -0.03223900496959686, 0.00406251847743988, -0.017579516395926476, 0.000673253380227834, -0.011644501239061356, -0.020511414855718613, -0.002473417902365327, 0.025401867926120758, 0.015478521585464478, -0.011365555226802826, 0.030695902183651924, 0.0011135573731735349, -0.006439492106437683, -0.006979578640311956, 0.009953022003173828, 0.017045365646481514, -0.0009599887998774648, -0.031004521995782852, -0.02096247673034668, 0.008795693516731262, -0.03387707099318504, -0.03769921883940697, -0.006166481412947178, 0.006291116587817669, -0.008807563222944736, 0.02097434550523758, 0.031669244170188904, 0.041711293160915375, 0.014303388074040413, 0.016095763072371483, -0.02801327407360077, -0.0023235587868839502, 0.02825067564845085, 0.008985614404082298, 0.01469509955495596, 0.014410218223929405, -0.022778591141104698, -0.02371632307767868, 0.015609092079102993, -0.0455096997320652, 0.02841685526072979, -0.007697715424001217, 0.00017860688967630267, -0.020357104018330574, -0.0067659178748726845, -0.040191926062107086, -0.013721756637096405, 0.05906527861952782, -0.03240518644452095, -0.008036011829972267, -0.010872948914766312, 0.04909444972872734, -0.022719239816069603, 0.021294835954904556, 0.011763201095163822, 0.004949802998453379, -0.002028291579335928, 0.0003820666461251676, 0.004605572205036879, 0.0029333815909922123, 0.012042147107422352, 0.06447800993919373, 0.0057450952008366585, -0.017033495008945465, 0.04052428901195526, 0.002501609269529581, 0.013603055849671364, 0.00048667131341062486, -0.0002667047665454447, -0.004590734839439392, 0.0030135042034089565, -0.01681983470916748, -0.015122420154511929, 0.011875966563820839, 0.02497454732656479, -0.018279848620295525, 0.042281053960323334, -0.011430840939283371, -0.0024778691586107016, -0.010605873540043831, -0.0014132756041362882, -0.013662406243383884, -0.01808992773294449, 0.004593702033162117, -0.020653855055570602, 0.005801477935165167, 0.007110149133950472, 0.031384363770484924, -0.013923547230660915, 0.04771752655506134, -0.010588068515062332, -0.03501659259200096, 0.010516848415136337, 0.010843274183571339, 0.027514733374118805, 0.0028755152598023415, 0.0033829589374363422, -0.012795894406735897, 0.006878683343529701, -0.015146160498261452, 0.0015342015540227294, 0.021330447867512703, 0.01234483253210783, 0.029983699321746826, 0.03824524208903313, 0.010137006640434265, -0.01890896074473858, 0.02563926763832569, -0.0037301573902368546, -0.03366341069340706, 0.02344331331551075, 0.027490993961691856, 0.00012602635251823813, 0.001974876504391432, 0.014374608173966408, 0.015893971547484398, 0.016309423372149467, -0.0009399581467732787, 0.0006150160334073007, -0.02429795451462269, 0.014493308961391449, -0.015146160498261452, -0.009751231409609318, -0.0029927317518740892, -0.017864396795630455, -0.03209656476974487, -0.013472486287355423, 0.00441565178334713, -0.012689064256846905, -0.005751030519604683, 0.05697615072131157, -0.05089869722723961, -0.018956441432237625, -0.005098178517073393, 0.0017805047100409865, -0.0012463533785194159, 0.021769637241959572, -0.019514331594109535, -0.020499544218182564, 0.019834822043776512, 0.0248083658516407, 0.02400120347738266, 0.02730107307434082, -0.02236313931643963, -0.001658836961723864, 0.021852727979421616, 0.009869931265711784, -0.008368371985852718, 0.0427558533847332, 0.020796295255422592, -0.007406899705529213, 0.007573080249130726, 0.014184688217937946, -0.015537871047854424, -0.03848264366388321, 0.02082003466784954, -0.00986399594694376, 0.020630115643143654, 0.025971628725528717, 0.006403882056474686, 0.012238002382218838, -0.0024956741835922003, 0.027253592386841774, -0.004804395139217377, -0.010807664133608341, 0.0038904028479009867, -0.009953022003173828, 0.05294034257531166, 0.008795693516731262, 0.019775472581386566, -0.02179337851703167, -0.01972799189388752, -0.042803335934877396, 0.0014726257650181651, 0.002733074827119708, 0.0006847524782642722, 0.001857660012319684, -0.035230252891778946, -0.005872698035091162, 0.012700933963060379, 0.031764205545186996, 0.03532521426677704, -0.019965393468737602, 0.007317874580621719, -0.010760183446109295, 0.043254394084215164, -0.0050892760045826435, 0.03836394101381302, -0.0009733426268212497, -0.012048082426190376, -0.0296513382345438, 0.009899605996906757, -0.02855929546058178, 0.009133988991379738, 0.01970425248146057, -0.0003939366724807769, -0.007228849455714226, -0.00931797455996275, -0.01970425248146057, 0.021449146792292595, -0.020463934168219566, -0.03682084009051323, -0.009044963866472244, -0.0358712375164032, -0.02784709446132183, -0.002845840062946081, 0.024036813527345657, -0.003038728144019842, 0.017686346545815468, -0.022731110453605652, 0.019763601943850517, 0.022173218429088593, -0.022030778229236603, -0.025449348613619804, -0.005166431423276663, -0.0031811685767024755, 0.013330045156180859, -0.03328356891870499, 0.005178301129490137, 0.016891054809093475, -0.017175935208797455, -0.043657977133989334, -0.029342718422412872, 0.00957911554723978, -0.003317673923447728, -0.025568047538399696, 0.028298156335949898, 0.011074739508330822, -0.03019736148416996, 0.019336281344294548, -0.03126566484570503, -0.018315458670258522, -0.004439391661435366, -0.03378210961818695, 0.013674276880919933, 0.02097434550523758, -0.017164066433906555, 0.0010052432771772146, -0.006083391141146421, 0.011585150845348835, -0.006154611241072416, 0.00465602008625865, 0.026422690600156784, -0.004555124789476395, -0.03962216526269913, -0.01628568395972252, 0.025425607338547707, 0.005857860669493675, -0.05626394972205162, 0.0036619047168642282, -0.03988330811262131, -0.02111678570508957, 0.016760485246777534, -0.021555976942181587, 0.024737145751714706, 0.014374608173966408, -0.00026522102416493, 0.00041285454062744975, -0.0004829619138035923, -0.018244238570332527, 0.013971026986837387, 0.01668926514685154, 0.028583036735653877, -0.002004551701247692, 0.013460615649819374, -0.01915823109447956, -0.008457397110760212, 0.024618444964289665, 0.019336281344294548, -0.017033495008945465, 0.0200010035187006, -0.01972799189388752, 0.013887937180697918, 0.028725476935505867, 0.003976460546255112, 0.037865400314331055, 0.015359820798039436, -0.0148256691172719, -0.022125739604234695, 0.012392313219606876, -0.00465602008625865, 0.00012602635251823813, 0.022659890353679657, -0.013258825056254864, 0.020867515355348587, -0.011709786020219326, -0.013828586786985397, -0.019229451194405556, 0.0018799162935465574, 0.02703993208706379, 0.014149078167974949, -0.023775672540068626, 0.0033443814609199762, 0.016072023659944534, -0.006730307824909687, -0.03601367771625519, 0.004700532648712397, -0.007679910399019718, 0.027894575148820877, -0.008860978297889233, 0.03368714824318886, -0.0062080267816782, -0.0007455863524228334, 0.007300069555640221, -0.023645102977752686, -0.038696303963661194, 0.017342116683721542, -0.0036767423152923584, 0.015893971547484398, 0.03639351576566696, 0.017199676483869553, 0.03914736583828926, 0.01598893292248249, -0.03114696405827999, -0.006451362278312445, 0.02387063391506672, -0.028464335948228836, -0.03805532306432724, -0.027253592386841774, 0.007027058862149715, 0.00424353638663888, 0.02040458470582962, -0.001936298911459744, -0.013840456493198872, -0.011947186663746834, 0.00923488475382328, -0.010961974039673805, 0.03022110089659691, -0.009021224454045296, 0.021484756842255592, 0.0032049084547907114, -0.04168755188584328, -0.006771853193640709, -0.025022026151418686, -0.008783823810517788, -0.014528919011354446, 0.026280250400304794, 0.02882043644785881, 0.012475403025746346, 0.009371389634907246, -0.029295237734913826, -0.0275859534740448, -0.02442852593958378, -0.004065485671162605, -0.03504033386707306, 0.01905140094459057, -0.01780504733324051, 0.019146360456943512, -0.010356602258980274, -0.0024645153898745775, -0.006997383665293455, 0.008463332429528236, -0.011193440295755863, 0.0013561510713770986, -0.0179356187582016, 0.008653253316879272, -0.001731540891341865, 0.019336281344294548, 0.018303588032722473, 0.006261441856622696, 0.03489789366722107, 0.0062258318066596985, 0.0282744150608778, -0.028321895748376846, 0.03803158178925514, -0.02040458470582962, 0.02882043644785881, -0.011947186663746834, 0.016190722584724426, 0.02315843105316162, 0.018529118970036507, 0.04541474208235741, 0.023953724652528763, 0.019087010994553566, 0.027348553761839867, 0.0010653353529050946, 0.014303388074040413, 0.0172234158962965, -0.02772839367389679, 0.002752363681793213, 0.012107431888580322, 0.014493308961391449, -0.002003067871555686, 0.015478521585464478, 0.003231616225093603, 0.014030377380549908, -0.029675079509615898, 0.008445527404546738, -0.02302786149084568, 0.0013123804237693548, -0.034684233367443085, -0.043515536934137344, 0.020772555842995644, -0.0014874633634462953, 0.006113066338002682, -0.025188207626342773, -0.050281453877687454, 0.010493108071386814, -0.010700833983719349, -0.042019911110401154, -0.024760885164141655, 0.039645906537771225, -0.02262428030371666, 0.03736685961484909, -0.007300069555640221, 0.006009203381836414, -0.047100286930799484, -0.018030578270554543, 0.014706969261169434, -0.0045313844457268715, 0.016036413609981537, 0.002114349277690053, 0.012950204312801361, 0.03791288286447525, 0.005869730841368437, 0.007050798740237951, 0.0028547425754368305, -0.011151894927024841, 0.01984669268131256, 0.0003273532202001661, -0.02673131227493286, 0.004255406558513641, -0.036749616265296936, 0.03682084009051323, 0.01570405252277851, 0.05256050080060959, 0.02442852593958378, 0.022410620003938675, 0.018244238570332527, -0.028488075360655785, 0.004890453070402145, 0.002102479338645935, 0.015905842185020447, -0.012997685000300407, 0.004851875361055136, -0.018695300444960594 ]
11.479405
6.496417
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.tmp.1621Z
[ "central galaxies", "galaxies", "cold gas disc", "cold gas discs", "diverse kinematic morphologies", "simulated low-mass galaxies", "the simulated galaxy morphology", "low-mass galaxies", "different resolutions", "most stars" ]
[ "galaxies: disc", "galaxies: evolution", "galaxies: formation", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
40
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1651", "10.48550/arXiv.2404.14184" ]
[ "Zeng, Guangquan", "Wang, Lan", "Gao, Liang", "Yang, Hang" ]
[ "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China; School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China;", "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China; School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China;", "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China; School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China; School of Physics and Microelectronics, Zhengzhou University, Zhengzhou 450001, China; Institute for Frontiers in Astronomy and Astrophysics, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 102206, China", "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China; School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China;" ]
null
[ "1926ApJ....64..321H", "1948AnAp...11..247D", "1959HDP....53..275D", "1961hag..book.....S", "1963BAAA....6...41S", "1976ApJ...206..883V", "1977egsp.conf..401T", "1978MNRAS.183..341W", "1979Natur.281..200F", "1980MNRAS.193..189F", "1983ApJ...266L..17F", "1984AJ.....89..919S", "1984ARA&A..22...37G", "1987gady.book.....B", "1994A&ARv...6...67F", "1998ARA&A..36..435M", "1998MNRAS.295..319M", "1999A&A...352..447C", "2001MNRAS.328..726S", "2003MNRAS.338...14P", "2003MNRAS.339..289S", "2004MNRAS.348..977D", "2007MNRAS.382.1187K", "2008MNRAS.384....2G", "2008gady.book.....B", "2009A&A...493..871S", "2009MNRAS.396..696S", "2009MNRAS.399..497D", "2010ApJ...716..942F", "2011ApJS..196...11S", "2012AJ....144....4M", "2012ApJS..198....2K", "2012MNRAS.421.1007K", "2012MNRAS.423.1544S", "2012MNRAS.423.1726S", "2013ARA&A..51..457N", "2013MNRAS.428.3121M", "2013MNRAS.429.3068T", "2013MNRAS.435.2835W", "2013pss6.book.....O", "2014ARA&A..52..291C", "2014ARA&A..52..487S", "2014ApJ...795L..37C", "2014MNRAS.438.1870D", "2014MNRAS.439.1015K", "2014MNRAS.439.1245K", "2015ApJS..217...32B", "2015MNRAS.446.2967M", "2015MNRAS.446.3943M", "2015MNRAS.449...49R", "2015MNRAS.450.2327Z", "2015MNRAS.452..986S", "2016A&A...594A..13P", "2016ApJ...820..131E", "2016ApJS..225...11Y", "2016MNRAS.457.2790T", "2016MNRAS.458..242T", "2016MNRAS.458.2371R", "2016MNRAS.458.4477T", "2017A&A...607A..13V", "2017ARA&A..55...59N", "2017ApJ...835..193E", "2017MNRAS.465.1682H", "2017MNRAS.465.2420W", "2017MNRAS.465.3291W", "2017MNRAS.467.3083R", "2017MNRAS.468.4039R", "2018ApJS..238...33D", "2018MNRAS.473.1930E", "2018MNRAS.473.4077P", "2018MNRAS.475..624N", "2018MNRAS.475..648P", "2018MNRAS.475..676S", "2018MNRAS.477.1206N", "2018MNRAS.477.1536E", "2018MNRAS.478.3994C", "2018MNRAS.480.5113M", "2018MNRAS.481.1950L", "2018NatAs...2..233Z", "2019ApJ...883...25P", "2019MNRAS.483.2057F", "2019MNRAS.484.1401R", "2019MNRAS.487.1227Z", "2019MNRAS.487.5416T", "2019MNRAS.488.3663L", "2019MNRAS.488.4801J", "2019MNRAS.488L.123L", "2019MNRAS.490.3196P", "2019MNRAS.490.3234N", "2020MNRAS.493.2926L", "2020MNRAS.493.4126D", "2020NatRP...2...42V", "2021MNRAS.507.3301Z", "2021MNRAS.507.4445N", "2021MNRAS.508.5114L", "2022MNRAS.509.3966W", "2022MNRAS.514.2031C", "2022MNRAS.515..213P", "2023ApJ...951...52D", "2023MNRAS.519.5942W", "2023MNRAS.522.4515L", "2023MNRAS.525.2241H", "2023MNRAS.525.5614L", "2023MNRAS.526.4768W", "2024MNRAS.527..706Z", "2024MNRAS.528.5295Y", "2024MNRAS.529.4565H" ]
29163302
2407.01661
The infall region as a complementary probe to cluster abundance
Galaxy cluster abundance measurements provide a classic test of cosmology. They are most sensitive to the evolved amplitude of fluctuations, usually expressed as $S_8 = \sigma _8\sqrt{\Omega _m/0.3}$. Thus, abundance constraints exhibit a strong degeneracy between σ<SUB>8</SUB> and Ω<SUB>m</SUB>, as do other similar low-redshift tests such as cosmic shear. The mass distribution in the infall region around galaxy clusters, where material is being accreted from the surrounding field, also exhibits a cosmological dependence, but in this case it is nearly orthogonal to the S<SUB>8</SUB> direction in the Ω<SUB>m</SUB>-σ<SUB>8</SUB> plane, making it highly complementary to halo abundance or cosmic shear studies. We explore how weak lensing measurements of the infall region might be used to complement abundance studies, considering three different tests. The splashback radius is a prominent feature of the infall region; we show that detection of this feature in lensing data from the Euclid survey could independently constrain Ω<SUB>m</SUB> and σ<SUB>8</SUB> to ±0.05. Another feature, the depletion radius where the bias reaches a minimum, also shows cosmological dependence, though it is challenging to observe in practice. The strongest constraints come from direct measurements of the shear profile in the infall region at 2-4 r<SUB>200c</SUB>. Combining the latter with abundance constraints such as those reported from SRG/eROSITA should reduce the area of the error contours by an estimated factor of 1.2 using a sample of clusters observed by the UNIONS survey, or a factor of 3 using clusters observed by the Euclid Wide survey over a broader range of redshift.
[ 0.03997742012143135, 0.016994193196296692, 0.06782515347003937, 0.022414647042751312, 0.008408650755882263, 0.02693800814449787, 0.021871337667107582, 0.012350798584520817, -0.03307865932583809, 0.03343244269490242, -0.014391365461051464, 0.013784880749881268, -0.07232324779033661, -0.014795687980949879, 0.0038600193802267313, 0.04619388282299042, -0.03671756759285927, -0.008749798871576786, -0.01656460016965866, 0.05281466990709305, -0.01161164604127407, 0.0023832935839891434, 0.02666003629565239, 0.018396688625216484, -0.0496811680495739, -0.06049680337309837, 0.02751922234892845, 0.004902414046227932, 0.04298457130789757, -0.015465348027646542, 0.029010161757469177, -0.014505080878734589, -0.039067693054676056, 0.0009800089756026864, -0.05630195140838623, 0.10451745241880417, 0.008004328235983849, 0.036970268934965134, -0.029465025290846825, -0.009261519648134708, -0.017853379249572754, 0.03312920033931732, -0.026988547295331955, -0.044323887676000595, 0.005597344134002924, -0.0489988699555397, -0.030576912686228752, -0.02569977007806301, -0.031638260930776596, -0.0186872947961092, -0.04121565818786621, 0.02337491326034069, 0.0016978399362415075, -0.03530243784189224, 0.00023611821234226227, -0.0029155465308576822, 0.0032172093633562326, 0.007069331593811512, 0.015452712774276733, -0.029338674619793892, -0.008768751285970211, -0.006892440374940634, 0.03242163732647896, -0.030753804370760918, -0.028605839237570763, 0.013810151256620884, 0.05695897713303566, -0.011719044297933578, 0.0072651756927371025, -0.0014451382448896766, -0.009893273934721947, -0.01460616197437048, 0.00019505417731124908, 0.00549626350402832, 0.021302757784724236, -0.04028066247701645, -0.009962767362594604, 0.01926850900053978, -0.017828108742833138, 0.013064681552350521, -0.0010700339917093515, -0.0003541773185133934, 0.012142319232225418, -0.015301091596484184, 0.0009026190964505076, 0.004921366926282644, -0.0028665855061262846, 0.014479811303317547, -0.06241733580827713, 0.041392549872398376, -0.009046723134815693, -0.018055541440844536, -0.004990859888494015, -0.031865693628787994, -0.018447227776050568, -0.04510726407170296, 0.048468198627233505, -0.057717081159353256, 0.019129524007439613, 0.053421150892972946, 0.019495941698551178, 0.0011055702343583107, 0.03823377564549446, -0.11654604971408844, 0.06560137867927551, -0.01536426693201065, 0.014656702056527138, -0.027140168473124504, 0.03785472363233566, -0.0034904431086033583, 0.05235980451107025, -0.0067155491560697556, -0.024095112457871437, 0.029262863099575043, -0.03416527807712555, -0.04306038096547127, -0.08601967990398407, -0.0005946388118900359, -0.0554933063685894, -0.009943814016878605, -0.01566750928759575, -0.0018510404042899609, 0.03825904801487923, 0.0433383509516716, 0.022035593166947365, -0.0280498955398798, 0.008743480779230595, -0.0042580245062708855, -0.07990429550409317, 0.01806817576289177, 0.02913651242852211, -0.003594682551920414, 0.013266842812299728, 0.015200011432170868, -0.005739488638937473, 0.0153263621032238, 0.015149470418691635, -0.036742836236953735, -0.0377536416053772, 0.03502446413040161, 0.001937906607054174, 0.022124039009213448, 0.03815796598792076, 0.02898489125072956, 0.003623111406341195, -0.008181219920516014, -0.025219636037945747, 0.006753454450517893, 0.041190385818481445, 0.04397010803222656, 0.007486289832741022, 0.006232257001101971, -0.04040701314806938, -0.04121565818786621, 0.00011588745110202581, -0.06049680337309837, -0.03578256815671921, 0.02643260359764099, -0.006339655257761478, -0.028883811086416245, 0.02058255858719349, 0.010044895112514496, -0.01522528100758791, -0.02701381780207157, -0.013898597098886967, 0.013570084236562252, -0.025661863386631012, 0.012950965203344822, -0.06918974220752716, -0.005249879322946072, -0.02731706015765667, -0.00014698160521220416, -0.04086187481880188, -0.0557965487241745, 0.03396311774849892, 0.0747491791844368, 0.0019805501215159893, -0.007170412689447403, 0.023728694766759872, 0.006911393254995346, 0.01489676907658577, 0.0017357452306896448, 0.012508736923336983, -0.02650841511785984, -0.041342008858919144, 0.02046884223818779, -0.013039411045610905, 0.013431098312139511, 0.023981397971510887, -0.02994515933096409, -0.021024785935878754, 0.038562290370464325, 0.03421581909060478, 0.049706436693668365, 0.012584547512233257, -0.03532770648598671, -0.004077974706888199, 0.04707833752036095, 0.0021305917762219906, -0.0062859561294317245, 0.021530190482735634, 0.04808914661407471, 0.05018657073378563, -0.06039572134613991, -0.037172429263591766, -0.0436415933072567, 0.016311898827552795, 0.017171084880828857, 0.006279638968408108, -0.0036957631818950176, 0.010360771790146828, 0.011592693626880646, -0.00878138653934002, -0.01579385995864868, -0.026761116459965706, 0.00024677906185388565, -0.0366922952234745, 0.003310393076390028, 0.018750470131635666, 0.047886982560157776, -0.012350798584520817, 0.04298457130789757, 0.05134899914264679, 0.019597021862864494, 0.013140491209924221, -0.008307570591568947, 0.05908167362213135, -0.024600517004728317, 0.02480267733335495, -0.02523227035999298, 0.012527690269052982, 0.02174498699605465, -0.04237808659672737, 0.01190225314348936, -0.0020058201625943184, -0.05011076107621193, 0.0001204281797981821, 0.032825957983732224, -0.016501424834132195, -0.030273670330643654, -0.007164095062762499, -0.015768589451909065, -0.008743480779230595, 0.005808981601148844, -0.014858863316476345, 0.007189365103840828, -0.018864186480641365, 0.040305931121110916, -0.012527690269052982, 0.00358836492523551, 0.018434593454003334, -0.02511855587363243, -0.00512668676674366, -0.04457658901810646, -0.02503011003136635, -0.004810809623450041, -0.0040147993713617325, 0.023147480562329292, -0.03431690111756325, 0.03876445069909096, -0.02024141140282154, -0.00059977185446769, -0.03045056201517582, 0.01054398063570261, -0.008080138824880123, 0.017512232065200806, 0.04121565818786621, -0.0037747325841337442, -0.03656594455242157, 0.009842733852565289, -0.01857358030974865, -0.0024148812517523766, 0.026280982419848442, -0.03520135581493378, -0.03770310431718826, 0.019950803369283676, 0.014201839454472065, -0.025750309228897095, 0.043363623321056366, 0.014530351385474205, -0.025472337380051613, -0.012173907831311226, -0.00701247388496995, -0.003872654400765896, -0.010828270576894283, -0.0029029115103185177, 0.03939620405435562, -0.009975401684641838, -0.0011750631965696812, -0.017347976565361023, 0.032295286655426025, -0.0557965487241745, 0.009836415760219097, 0.010000672191381454, -0.04187268018722534, -0.024006666615605354, -0.003484125481918454, 0.013595354743301868, -0.03029894083738327, 0.030905425548553467, 0.030324211344122887, 0.007618958130478859, 0.07186838239431381, -0.008275982923805714, -0.016463520005345345, -0.016400344669818878, 0.04834184795618057, 0.020102424547076225, -0.02000134438276291, 0.042352814227342606, 0.0014956785598769784, 0.025586053729057312, -0.02701381780207157, 0.04240335524082184, -0.04487983137369156, 0.010316549800336361, -0.023892952129244804, 0.0277466531842947, 0.03595945984125137, -0.02329910174012184, -0.013595354743301868, -0.045334696769714355, -0.019028441980481148, 0.0007213845383375883, 0.02078472077846527, -0.03130974993109703, -0.022465186193585396, -0.03598473221063614, -0.029262863099575043, -0.03052637353539467, 0.016931017860770226, 0.016147643327713013, 0.07090811431407928, -0.018560944125056267, -0.026912737637758255, -0.028302596881985664, 0.018548309803009033, 0.04083660617470741, -0.006222780793905258, -0.017234260216355324, -0.007025109138339758, -0.00691771088168025, 0.023817140609025955, -0.0015651715220883489, 0.040027957409620285, 0.0076631810516119, -0.022540997713804245, 0.029338674619793892, 0.05731276050209999, 0.02313484624028206, -0.020696274936199188, 0.017967095598578453, 0.01478305272758007, 0.006728184409439564, 0.04616861045360565, 0.012401338666677475, -0.0023832935839891434, -0.06944244354963303, -0.012205495499074459, 0.012988870963454247, 0.0006187244434840977, -0.0431867316365242, 0.006519705522805452, 0.020923705771565437, -0.016261357814073563, 0.00165677594486624, -0.03130974993109703, 0.005189862567931414, -0.04712887853384018, -0.020759450271725655, -0.007966423407196999, 0.023071670904755592, -0.01969810202717781, -0.03520135581493378, -0.06635948270559311, 0.038713909685611725, 0.00199792324565351, 0.0020089789759367704, 0.05316844955086708, 0.03254798799753189, 0.03214366361498833, 0.00008938337850850075, 0.022124039009213448, -0.03482230380177498, 0.015414807014167309, -0.0015809653559699655, -0.02442362532019615, -0.051172107458114624, -0.08839507400989532, -0.007050379179418087, -0.02921232394874096, 0.017347976565361023, 0.02600301057100296, 0.01536426693201065, 0.017398515716195107, -0.015250551514327526, 0.02673584595322609, 0.04601699113845825, 0.022970590740442276, 0.04040701314806938, 0.012110731564462185, -0.020254045724868774, -0.06544975936412811, -0.046724554151296616, 0.015768589451909065, -0.0019063189392909408, 0.016223452985286713, 0.009602666832506657, -0.004371740389615297, 0.0037178746424615383, 0.03307865932583809, 0.004494932480156422, 0.015932846814393997, -0.05190494284033775, 0.0026075663045048714, 0.06368084251880646, -0.021075326949357986, 0.051096297800540924, -0.019748643040657043, 0.05433087795972824, -0.01002594269812107, -0.017941825091838837, -0.011516883037984371, -0.02534598670899868, 0.0029487137217074633, 0.0008876149659045041, 0.0027512903325259686, 0.018586214631795883, -0.01784074492752552, -0.034266360104084015, -0.026028281077742577, 0.022086134180426598, 0.02739287167787552, -0.00808645598590374, -0.024827947840094566, -0.043742675334215164, 0.043085649609565735, -0.010815635323524475, 0.0011600590078160167, -0.022932684049010277, 0.045258887112140656, 0.0034872842952609062, -0.04278240725398064, -0.04581483080983162, -0.014593526721000671, 0.010581886395812035, 0.013203667476773262, -0.008673988282680511, 0.008345475420355797, -0.010960939340293407, -0.0306527242064476, 0.011062019504606724, 0.000516064406838268, 0.006507070269435644, -0.0011268919333815575, -0.017903920263051987, 0.008996183052659035, -0.05215764418244362, 0.05857626721262932, -0.03320500999689102, -0.0123444814234972, -0.002054781187325716, -0.024827947840094566, 0.005218291189521551, -0.003547301050275564, 0.029439754784107208, -0.01667831651866436, -0.0008058816893026233, 0.007764261681586504, 0.006898758001625538, 0.030096780508756638, -0.029010161757469177, 0.046294961124658585, 0.008737163618206978, 0.017082639038562775, -0.023728694766759872, -0.017272165045142174, -0.058677349239587784, 0.045688480138778687, 0.020216140896081924, 0.0433383509516716, 0.003108231583610177, -0.042858220636844635, 0.0156296044588089, 0.019862359389662743, 0.017284801229834557, 0.00948263332247734, 0.032017312943935394, -0.007751626428216696, -0.0367681048810482, -0.020708909258246422, -0.013014140538871288, 0.03189096227288246, -0.012938329949975014, 0.034695953130722046, 0.012104414403438568, -0.0017231100937351584, -0.006563928443938494, 0.0092488843947649, 0.027493951842188835, 0.06479272991418839, -0.03985106945037842, 0.020380396395921707, 0.028782730922102928, 0.021883971989154816, -0.023817140609025955, -0.035226624459028244, -0.0496811680495739, -0.012818296439945698, 0.020026614889502525, -0.034923382103443146, 0.05099521577358246, 0.02380450628697872, 0.011453707702457905, 0.01160532794892788, 0.021770257502794266, -0.030475832521915436, 0.02321065589785576, 0.03118339739739895, -0.008092774078249931, 0.041619978845119476, 0.0031335018575191498, 0.013026775792241096, 0.0016946812393143773, 0.01594548113644123, -0.03328082337975502, -0.027696112170815468, -0.10032259672880173, 0.0041601029224693775, -0.0033325045369565487, -0.0003304865094833076, -0.0747491791844368, -0.011978063732385635, -0.007031426299363375, -0.021138502284884453, -0.01701946370303631, -0.001794182462617755, -0.006683961488306522, 0.01431555487215519, -0.012950965203344822, 0.033533524721860886, 0.0009523697663098574, -0.02003924921154976, 0.002168497070670128, 0.003834749339148402, 0.04058390110731125, -0.0007557361968792975, -0.012123366817831993, 0.029919888824224472, 0.01795445941388607, -0.0040748161263763905, -0.021959783509373665, 0.009817463345825672, -0.0032882816158235073, 0.007682133466005325, 0.02294532023370266, 0.031132856383919716, -0.019786547869443893, 0.0310317762196064, 0.014631431549787521, -0.0004619703977368772, -0.024158287793397903, -0.03800634667277336, 0.017853379249572754, -0.01679203286767006, -0.06459057331085205, -0.0005800295039080083, -0.015844400972127914, -0.014858863316476345, 0.022970590740442276, -0.03037475235760212, -0.003114549210295081, -0.014820958487689495, -0.006197510752826929, 0.008926689624786377, 0.01594548113644123, -0.02681165747344494, -0.009242567233741283, 0.003171407151967287, -0.030829614028334618, -0.019559117034077644, -0.0025870343670248985, -0.0015936004929244518, 0.009274154901504517, -0.06307435780763626, -0.0017483803676441312, 0.02228829450905323, 0.0313350185751915, 0.00959634967148304, -0.0023580233100801706, 0.02259153686463833, 0.008010645397007465, -0.0055278511717915535, 0.018586214631795883, 0.014378730207681656, 0.00027501059230417013, 0.01744905672967434, 0.02569977007806301, 0.013923866674304008, -0.03727351129055023, 0.008212807588279247, 0.016577236354351044, 0.007183047477155924, -0.05574600771069527, 0.001311680069193244, 0.029187053442001343, -0.009615302085876465, -0.02658422477543354, -0.0046086483635008335, 0.025143824517726898, -0.00992486160248518, -0.02890908159315586, -0.004839238710701466, -0.016741491854190826, -0.009451045654714108, 0.019167428836226463, 0.009627937339246273, -0.021075326949357986, 0.037121888250112534, -0.003885289654135704, -0.03598473221063614, -0.01827033795416355, 0.005622614175081253, -0.0018147145165130496, 0.0620635524392128, 0.0006984834908507764, -0.02855529822409153, -0.0429592989385128, -0.013039411045610905, -0.0013511647703126073, 0.013064681552350521, -0.036464862525463104, -0.00023197231348603964, -0.02123958244919777, -0.016387708485126495, 0.018737835809588432, 0.00251596188172698, 0.06352922320365906, -0.03530243784189224, 0.016223452985286713, 0.031057046726346016, 0.01373434066772461, 0.03590891882777214, -0.050590891391038895, 0.02847948856651783, 0.0309559665620327, 0.03916877135634422, -0.0091541213914752, -0.037399861961603165, -0.0056921071372926235, -0.01329211238771677, 0.009975401684641838, 0.014517716132104397, 0.03876445069909096, 0.0006309646996669471, -0.006778724957257509, 0.01795445941388607, 0.0036136351991444826, -0.007157777436077595, 0.004049545619636774, -0.021719716489315033, 0.03323028236627579, 0.02326119691133499, -0.012988870963454247, -0.02093634009361267, -0.04391956701874733, -0.0009563182247802615, 0.007018791511654854, -0.011586375534534454, -0.00009520736057311296, 0.05230926349759102, 0.016842572018504143, 0.024549975991249084, 0.017385881394147873, -0.02484058402478695, -0.0006033254321664572, -0.0011766426032409072, -0.007132507394999266, -0.04503145441412926, 0.035580407828092575, -0.02906070277094841, 0.027140168473124504, 0.004611806944012642, -0.05003494769334793, -0.0094384104013443, -0.0031224461272358894, -0.004757110495120287, -0.0011892776237800717, 0.015465348027646542, -0.0013266842579469085, 0.013241572305560112, -0.010247056372463703, 0.05246088653802872, -0.0003830011119134724, 0.010714555159211159, -0.012660358101129532, -0.005565756466239691, 0.0068355826660990715, 0.03520135581493378, -0.022427281364798546, 0.02581348456442356, -0.009912226349115372, 0.006930345669388771, -0.042277004569768906, -0.0368439182639122, 0.007877977564930916, 0.0007348093204200268, 0.01768912374973297, 0.05690843611955643, -0.008023280650377274, 0.02545970305800438, 0.037399861961603165, -0.014505080878734589, 0.012110731564462185, 0.0029218641575425863, -0.02979353815317154, 0.010266008786857128, -0.0020689957309514284, -0.044172268360853195, -0.013494273647665977, -0.010070165619254112, -0.04215065389871597, -0.04470294341444969, -0.010468170046806335, 0.04086187481880188, -0.024170923978090286, 0.0056257727555930614, 0.01942013017833233, 0.006728184409439564, 0.0034999193158000708, -0.0023501263931393623, 0.012167589738965034, -0.039295125752687454, -0.01988762803375721, -0.00011569002526812255, 0.014871498569846153, 0.028201516717672348, -0.0186114851385355, 0.0058974274434149265, 0.02267998270690441, 0.008617130108177662, -0.024827947840094566, 0.0035536184441298246, 0.010013307444751263, 0.013607989996671677, 0.028302596881985664, 0.030400022864341736, -0.002624939661473036, 0.002855530008673668, 0.006232257001101971, -0.009855369105935097, 0.01041131280362606, 0.03563094884157181, -0.005562597420066595, 0.016501424834132195, -0.016349803656339645, 0.0007770578959025443, -0.02484058402478695, 0.033331360667943954, 0.016589870676398277, 0.050515081733465195, 0.04798806458711624, 0.00828230008482933, 0.02782246470451355, -0.0436415933072567, 0.03527716547250748, -0.04887251928448677, -0.01900317333638668, 0.03649013489484787, -0.019597021862864494, 0.006197510752826929, 0.021618636325001717, 0.05827302485704422, 0.008730845525860786, 0.02453734166920185, 0.031360287219285965, -0.017436422407627106, -0.021504919975996017, -0.034190546721220016, -0.0062670037150382996, 0.04821549728512764, -0.016779396682977676, 0.04422280937433243, -0.013898597098886967, -0.01571805030107498, -0.006131176371127367, 0.029616646468639374, -0.0002272341662319377, 0.01686784252524376, 0.026104092597961426, -0.035656217485666275, 0.03060218319296837, -0.01660250499844551, -0.00919202622026205, -0.03216893598437309, 0.045258887112140656, -0.021365933120250702, -0.11108769476413727, 0.0048929378390312195, 0.019976073876023293, -0.0009026190964505076, 0.01263508852571249, 0.021100597456097603, 0.010979891754686832, 0.017979729920625687, -0.019900264218449593, 0.0030924377497285604, -0.011485295370221138, -0.01701946370303631, -0.009078310802578926, 0.01818189211189747, 0.005325689446181059, -0.016577236354351044, -0.030905425548553467, 0.024777406826615334, 0.0015857035759836435, 0.04503145441412926, 0.011737996712327003, 0.024512071162462234, 0.019495941698551178, 0.035150814801454544, 0.018902091309428215, -0.04055863246321678, -0.01900317333638668, -0.003304075449705124, 0.0008623447502031922, 0.015781225636601448, -0.01325420755892992, 0.01613500714302063, -0.012211812660098076, 0.02928813360631466, -0.0034335851669311523, -0.0280498955398798, 0.0034904431086033583, 0.014985214918851852, -0.03853701800107956, 0.014669337309896946, -0.004886620212346315, -0.014618797227740288, 0.03431690111756325, 0.01748696155846119, 0.026862196624279022, -0.004580219276249409, -0.007461019326001406, -0.0012342901900410652, 0.0015549055533483624, 0.005022447556257248, -0.0021290122531354427, 0.021302757784724236, -0.012565595097839832, 0.018813645467162132, 0.0033735684119164944, 0.01416393369436264, 0.01161164604127407, 0.010379725135862827, -0.0015225281240418553, 0.003648381680250168, -0.02561132423579693, 0.0093436473980546, 0.01344373356550932, -0.01733534038066864, -0.051020484417676926, -0.02572503872215748, -0.022616807371377945, 0.017436422407627106, -0.017891284078359604, -0.013241572305560112, 0.006538657937198877, 0.02065836824476719, 0.016514061018824577, -0.005133004393428564, 0.002913967240601778, -0.006829265039414167, 0.013759611174464226, 0.007707403507083654, -0.05796978250145912, 0.034847572445869446, 0.0019552798476070166, -0.014290284365415573, 0.013456368818879128, -0.006766089703887701, -0.005622614175081253, 0.0433383509516716, -0.007511559873819351, -0.010878810659050941, 0.007322033401578665, 0.016627775505185127, -0.0069998386316001415, -0.0057710763067007065, 0.04167051985859871, -0.0031777245458215475, -0.016147643327713013, -0.009084627963602543, 0.029667187482118607, -0.05943545326590538, 0.024512071162462234, 0.0012887789634987712, -0.01768912374973297, -0.01857358030974865, -0.004131673835217953, -0.012830931693315506, 0.005452040582895279, -0.009469998069107533, 0.02240201085805893, 0.008313887752592564, -0.005398341454565525, 0.008307570591568947, 0.04510726407170296, 0.006213304586708546, -0.0061027477495372295, 0.05928383395075798, 0.07798376679420471, -0.000712697918061167, 0.00525303790345788, 0.013039411045610905, 0.020342491567134857, 0.016956288367509842, 0.02971772663295269, -0.017006829380989075, -0.029540836811065674, -0.010979891754686832, 0.019862359389662743, -0.0028349978383630514, 0.004248548299074173, -0.014100758358836174, -0.0008378642960451543, 0.03757675364613533, 0.0071388245560228825, 0.004712888039648533, 0.02898489125072956, 0.00021262484369799495, -0.02116377279162407, 0.03535297513008118, 0.0140249477699399, 0.02228829450905323, 0.0051172105595469475, 0.034342169761657715, -0.010316549800336361, -0.00013997308269608766, 0.005777393933385611, 0.01888945698738098, -0.015894940122961998, 0.023690789937973022, -0.016375074163079262, -0.010139658115804195, 0.0029360787011682987, 0.014391365461051464, -0.0036199528258293867, 0.014555621892213821, -0.01590757630765438, 0.019129524007439613, -0.015528523363173008, -0.003307234263047576, 0.03535297513008118, -0.010228103958070278, 0.006090112496167421, 0.02217458002269268, 0.007688451092690229, 0.020077155902981758, -0.008623447269201279, -0.01915479265153408, 0.006924028042703867, 0.027999354526400566, -0.031865693628787994, 0.012205495499074459, 0.002389610977843404, -0.005654201842844486, -0.012691945768892765, -0.07717511802911758, 0.028024625033140182, 0.015806494280695915, -0.010032259859144688, 0.008073821663856506, -0.007271493319422007, 0.015541158616542816, 0.0016022870549932122, -0.0016504584345966578, -0.01784074492752552, -0.0186114851385355, -0.018624119460582733, 0.00365154049359262, 0.04783644527196884, -0.035580407828092575, 0.005041399970650673, 0.0312592089176178, 0.01945803500711918, 0.024701597169041634, -0.01127681601792574, 0.02425936982035637, 0.005221450235694647, 0.011295768432319164, -0.01503575500100851, 0.014302919618785381, -0.0490746833384037, 0.01373434066772461, -0.012072826735675335, 0.007827437482774258, -0.03656594455242157, -0.010221785865724087, -0.029035432264208794, -0.038208507001399994, -0.022427281364798546, -0.019205333665013313, -0.025105919688940048, -0.015465348027646542, -0.026129363104701042, -0.03606054186820984, 0.01583176478743553, -0.012818296439945698, 0.009590031579136848, 0.035075005143880844, 0.037096619606018066, -0.04712887853384018, 0.04697725921869278, -0.019091617316007614, -0.012363433837890625, -0.03184042125940323, 0.0013559028739109635, -0.034923382103443146, -0.009324694983661175, 0.04909995198249817, 0.004144309088587761, 0.029540836811065674, 0.04669928550720215, -0.047735363245010376, -0.02418355830013752, 0.013645894825458527, 0.06170976907014847, 0.010897763073444366, -0.008016963489353657, -0.005559438839554787, -0.02635679394006729, -0.02151755429804325, -0.022818969562649727, 0.014542986638844013, 0.00017205436597578228, 0.024815313518047333, 0.04005322977900505, -0.027039088308811188, 0.00474131666123867, 0.00810540933161974, 0.0013243152061477304, -0.002031090436503291, 0.024019302800297737, 0.003547301050275564, 0.010095435194671154, 0.006494435481727123, -0.000884456152562052, 0.024714231491088867, -0.01112519484013319, 0.009463680908083916, -0.03848647698760033, -0.014985214918851852, -0.01267299335449934, 0.018080811947584152, 0.028858540579676628, 0.017941825091838837, 0.02228829450905323, 0.019319050014019012, -0.04007849842309952, 0.008459191769361496, -0.009084627963602543, 0.02410774864256382, -0.03371041640639305, 0.018055541440844536, 0.0038789720274508, -0.025750309228897095, 0.021757621318101883, -0.05776762217283249, 0.020759450271725655, -0.006469164974987507, -0.03494865447282791, 0.0036989219952374697, 0.006507070269435644, -0.006911393254995346, -0.023829776793718338, 0.009962767362594604, -0.03292704001069069, -0.018245067447423935, -0.02577557973563671, -0.008857197128236294, -0.02600301057100296, 0.03146136924624443, 0.015591698698699474, 0.003395679872483015, 0.023690789937973022, -0.009747970849275589, -0.027999354526400566, 0.024714231491088867, 0.006639738567173481, -0.01435345970094204, 0.023829776793718338, 0.007840071804821491, 0.01954648084938526, -0.008730845525860786, 0.02384241111576557, -0.016362439841032028, -0.018699930980801582, -0.006118541583418846, -0.004204325377941132, -0.01296360045671463, -0.008964595384895802, -0.01698155887424946, -0.011681138537824154, 0.0045233615674078465, -0.025788214057683945, -0.030122049152851105, 0.025661863386631012, -0.0010700339917093515, -0.0039042423013597727, 0.004485456272959709, -0.01054398063570261, -0.019685467705130577, 0.00977324042469263, 0.01566750928759575, -0.00484555633738637, -0.014201839454472065, -0.04245389625430107, 0.006822947412729263, 0.022338835522532463, 0.0016630934551358223, -0.04217592254281044, -0.003195097902789712, -0.02005188539624214, -0.0124392444267869, 0.003307234263047576, 0.013721705414354801, 0.024701597169041634, 0.024587880820035934, -0.006352290511131287, -0.02847948856651783, -0.01617291197180748, 0.04596645012497902, 0.031865693628787994, -0.013949137181043625, -0.0025522878859192133, 0.03686918690800667, -0.005047717597335577, -0.0065260231494903564, -0.018396688625216484, 0.011523200199007988, 0.030122049152851105, 0.026609495282173157, -0.00983009859919548, -0.0032914404291659594, -0.02290741540491581, 0.029894618317484856, 0.062316253781318665, -0.020885800942778587, -0.0005002705147489905, -0.012319210916757584, 0.01387332659214735, -0.04331308230757713, 0.015642238780856133, 0.01748696155846119, 0.01112519484013319, -0.014719877392053604, -0.004706570412963629, 0.05842464789748192, -0.011024114675819874, 0.025143824517726898, -0.011573740281164646, 0.0038094790652394295, -0.008092774078249931, 0.04376794397830963, -0.005695266183465719, -0.00542677054181695, -0.03621216118335724, 0.0015517467400059104, -0.01170640904456377, 0.030779074877500534, 0.0020974245853722095, -0.030703263357281685, -0.007840071804821491, -0.006017460487782955, -0.013658530078828335, 0.02232620120048523, -0.01818189211189747, 0.001795761869288981, -0.02414565347135067, 0.023122211918234825, -0.012755121104419231, -0.03373568505048752, -0.019521210342645645, 0.03633851185441017, 0.0037810502108186483, -0.0036926046013832092, 0.01315312646329403, 0.01315312646329403, 0.0006972989067435265, -0.03858755901455879, -0.011908570304512978, 0.010651378892362118, 0.009432093240320683, -0.006595516111701727, 0.0002055176009889692, 0.02236410602927208, -0.0434141643345356, -0.007366256322711706, 0.0047539519146084785, -0.011226275935769081, -0.01050607580691576, 0.008768751285970211, -0.00358836492523551, 0.048468198627233505, 0.028353137895464897, -0.0217828918248415, -0.0003454906982369721, -0.008907737210392952, -0.029768267646431923, 0.050944674760103226, 0.029591375961899757, -0.010291279293596745, 0.02348862960934639, 0.025143824517726898, -0.016463520005345345, -0.00037332737701945007, -0.02264207787811756, -0.004858191590756178, -0.011946476064622402, 0.005761600099503994, -0.017979729920625687, -0.0012335004284977913, -0.020645733922719955, 0.016261357814073563, 0.005193021148443222, -0.038056883960962296, -0.04639604315161705, -0.00007472470315406099, -0.00445070955902338, 0.008478144183754921, 0.010354454629123211, -0.019483305513858795, 0.007562100421637297, -0.001680466695688665, -0.03881499171257019, 0.020683638751506805, -0.021454378962516785, -0.02232620120048523, -0.02151755429804325, 0.04462713003158569, 0.02012769505381584, -0.002091107191517949, -0.015920210629701614, 0.013469004072248936, 0.014252379536628723, -0.01387332659214735, -0.00503192376345396, 0.0023169592022895813, 0.01682993769645691, -0.0028744826558977365, 0.0005914800567552447, 0.012205495499074459, -0.008301252499222755, -0.009514220990240574, -0.0011632178211584687, -0.00828230008482933, 0.019066348671913147, 0.030122049152851105, 0.00977324042469263, 0.033028122037649155, 0.014909404329955578, 0.05296628922224045, 0.023855045437812805, 0.01575595512986183, -0.018131351098418236, -0.025017473846673965, -0.001854199217632413, 0.041190385818481445, -0.021252218633890152, -0.025560783222317696, -0.016476154327392578, -0.02825205773115158, -0.024714231491088867, -0.018320877104997635, 0.014050218276679516, 0.027418140321969986, 0.0017373246373608708, 0.006696596741676331, 0.006968250963836908, 0.0065260231494903564, -0.004090609960258007, -0.004226436838507652, 0.0025807167403399944, -0.017929190769791603, 0.015048390254378319, 0.02123958244919777, -0.015061024576425552, -0.00822544191032648, -0.016728857532143593, -0.005521533545106649, -0.005584708880633116, -0.00930574256926775, -0.015098930336534977, 0.002683376893401146, 0.006068001035600901, -0.0022648395970463753, -0.021340664476156235, -0.03328082337975502, 0.008933007717132568, 0.02782246470451355, -0.007720038760453463, 0.005483628250658512, 0.0069998386316001415, 0.022616807371377945, -0.03439271077513695, 0.016438249498605728, 0.025181731209158897, 0.03022313117980957, -0.00108345877379179, 0.01590757630765438, 0.04634550213813782, -0.02105005644261837, -0.020291950553655624, -0.012894107028841972, -0.03221947327256203, -0.00662710377946496, -0.0019884470384567976, -0.040609173476696014, 0.027064358815550804, -0.05091940611600876, -0.024082478135824203, 0.008730845525860786, 0.003597841365262866, -0.012925694696605206, -0.025598688051104546, 0.027114899829030037, -0.010607156902551651, -0.02422146312892437, 0.024170923978090286, -0.002681797370314598, -0.02847948856651783, -0.025434432551264763, -0.0071198721416294575, 0.019938169047236443, 0.021037422120571136, 0.02375396527349949, 0.0016441408079117537, -0.014302919618785381, 0.007966423407196999, 0.0023643409367650747, 0.019331684336066246, 0.01536426693201065, -0.0108345877379179, -0.0625184178352356, 0.004725522827357054, -0.0016030768165364861, -0.01772702857851982, -0.036464862525463104, 0.03320500999689102, 0.010872493498027325, -0.007720038760453463, 0.022882144898176193, 0.01729743555188179, 0.033685144037008286, 0.024234099313616753, 0.010417629964649677, 0.031132856383919716, 0.010809318162500858, -0.014201839454472065, -0.012805662117898464, -0.015162105672061443, 0.018636755645275116, -0.01767648756504059, 0.022376740351319313, 0.0056068203411996365, 0.012875154614448547, 0.04596645012497902, -0.0015320044476538897, -0.009090946055948734, -0.0014482969418168068, -0.02414565347135067, 0.03891607001423836, 0.03851174935698509, -0.021302757784724236, -0.0217828918248415, 0.021947147324681282, -0.015768589451909065, -0.03894134238362312, -0.022995861247181892, -0.019180063158273697, -0.0015801757108420134, 0.0023201180156320333, -0.0372987799346447, -0.0025775579269975424, -0.06807785481214523, -0.013014140538871288, 0.026457874104380608, -0.020418303087353706, 0.027266521006822586, 0.021694445982575417, -0.01387332659214735, 0.028858540579676628, 0.04455132037401199, -0.013885961845517159, -0.006007984280586243, -0.008497096598148346, -0.026407334953546524, 0.020519383251667023, 0.008914054371416569, 0.01919269934296608, -0.019571751356124878, -0.018093446269631386, 0.02290741540491581, -0.03611108288168907, -0.005850045941770077, 0.01853567361831665, -0.025105919688940048, 0.02883327193558216, 0.045713748782873154, 0.004700252786278725, 0.016476154327392578, 0.005189862567931414, -0.009684794582426548, 0.021542824804782867, -0.0021590206306427717, -0.03818323463201523, 0.01919269934296608, -0.028883811086416245, 0.012192860245704651, -0.005657360889017582, 0.020721543580293655, 0.02399403229355812, 0.008162266574800014, -0.014959944412112236, 0.015275821089744568, -0.0018778899684548378, 0.016690950840711594, -0.001794182462617755, 0.02630625292658806, -0.005818458274006844, -0.029818808659911156, 0.013860691338777542, -0.015768589451909065, 0.01263508852571249, -0.015061024576425552, 0.01834614761173725, 0.013721705414354801, 0.014795687980949879, -0.004570743069052696, 0.00530041940510273, -0.003310393076390028, -0.015958115458488464, 0.002253783866763115, -0.04376794397830963, 0.0014143402222543955, -0.019407495856285095, 0.04740685224533081, -0.022149309515953064, -0.018042905256152153, 0.03482230380177498, -0.009488951414823532, 0.04058390110731125, -0.003364092204719782, 0.014681972563266754, -0.0007004577200859785, -0.029111243784427643, 0.021770257502794266, 0.025901930406689644, -0.01286883745342493, -0.0022364105097949505, -0.022048229351639748, 0.0022743158042430878, -0.03242163732647896, 0.0629732757806778, 0.02016559988260269, 0.008408650755882263, -0.0036989219952374697, 0.01930641382932663, 0.02031722106039524, -0.010859858244657516, -0.014732512645423412, -0.02062046341598034, 0.015768589451909065, -0.002370658330619335, -0.002362761413678527, -0.005436246749013662, 0.011112559586763382, -0.026382064446806908, 0.010803000070154667, 0.005717377178370953, -0.019129524007439613, -0.01127681601792574, -0.00609327107667923, -0.0026944326236844063, -0.029262863099575043, -0.03414000943303108, 0.04323727265000343, -0.021770257502794266, 0.009059358388185501, -0.002708646934479475, -0.008155949413776398, -0.00730308098718524, -0.002203243551775813, 0.012331846170127392, -0.014795687980949879, -0.01121995784342289, 0.01947067119181156, -0.03588365018367767, -0.018042905256152153, -0.014505080878734589, 0.02592720091342926, 0.006576563231647015, -0.002021613996475935, -0.03184042125940323, 0.02673584595322609, 0.0034778080880641937, -0.004934001713991165, 0.02086053043603897, -0.02035512775182724, 0.03143610060214996, 0.004949795547872782, 0.025472337380051613, 0.019521210342645645, 0.000968163600191474, -0.03985106945037842, -0.01325420755892992, 0.02581348456442356, 0.032724879682064056, 0.009356282651424408, 0.03517608344554901, -0.008598177693784237, 0.00002482597301423084, 0.007063014432787895, 0.0369955375790596, 0.015111565589904785, 0.007934835739433765, 0.031208667904138565, -0.015503252856433392, 0.02213667519390583, -0.0024685803800821304, 0.02746868133544922, -0.016690950840711594, 0.006292273756116629, 0.0020737338345497847, 0.006424942519515753 ]
12.628709
3.660394
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.tmp.1594M
[ "Galaxy cluster abundance measurements", "abundance constraints", "abundance studies", "galaxy clusters", "cosmological dependence", "direct measurements", "clusters", "cosmic shear", "halo abundance or cosmic shear studies", "Euclid Wide" ]
[ "gravitational lensing: weak", "methods: observational", "galaxies: clusters: general", "galaxies: groups: general", "galaxies: haloes", "cosmological parameters", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
12
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1637", "10.48550/arXiv.2407.01661" ]
[ "Mpetha, C. T.", "Taylor, J. E.", "Amoura, Y.", "Haggar, R." ]
[ "Institute for Astronomy, School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, Royal Observatory, Blackford Hill, Edinburgh, EH9 3HJ, United Kingdom; Waterloo Centre for Astrophysics, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario N2L 3G1, Canada; Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Waterloo, 200 University Avenue West, Waterloo, Ontario N2L 3G1, Canada", "Waterloo Centre for Astrophysics, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario N2L 3G1, Canada; Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Waterloo, 200 University Avenue West, Waterloo, Ontario N2L 3G1, Canada", "Waterloo Centre for Astrophysics, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario N2L 3G1, Canada; Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Waterloo, 200 University Avenue West, Waterloo, Ontario N2L 3G1, Canada", "Waterloo Centre for Astrophysics, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario N2L 3G1, Canada; Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Waterloo, 200 University Avenue West, Waterloo, Ontario N2L 3G1, Canada" ]
null
[ "1965TrAlm...5...87E", "1992ApJ...393..477R", "1993ApJ...419L...9E", "1995ApJ...447....8M", "1996MNRAS.281..323V", "1997ASPC..126..365B", "2001PhR...340..291B", "2004A&A...416..853D", "2004MNRAS.348..811T", "2004MNRAS.350..893H", "2007ApJS..172...29H", "2007ApJS..172..219L", "2009A&A...502..721E", "2009ApJS..182..608K", "2009ApJS..184..158E", "2012ApJ...757....2G", "2013ApJ...766...25D", "2013ApJ...777..151L", "2014ApJ...789....1D", "2014MNRAS.437.2328B", "2015ApJ...810...36M", "2015MNRAS.449.1897O", "2015RPPh...78h6901K", "2016MNRAS.456.2486D", "2016MNRAS.459.1764S", "2016MNRAS.459.3711S", "2017ApJ...843..140D", "2017MNRAS.470.4767B", "2018ApJ...864...83C", "2018ApJS..239...35D", "2019ApJ...873..111I", "2019ApJ...874..184Z", "2019MNRAS.485..408C", "2019MNRAS.487.2578Z", "2019MNRAS.488.1652H", "2019MNRAS.490.2606W", "2019MNRAS.490.4945S", "2020A&A...638A.141P", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020A&A...642A.191E", "2020AAS...23515404C", "2020ApJ...903...87D", "2020MNRAS.499.3534X", "2020PASJ...72...64M", "2021ApJ...911...82C", "2021ApJ...911..136B", "2021ApJ...923...37A", "2021ApJ...923..154T", "2021MNRAS.502.1191H", "2021MNRAS.502.5115G", "2021MNRAS.503.4250F", "2021MNRAS.504.4649O", "2021MNRAS.505..593D", "2021MNRAS.505.1195G", "2021MNRAS.505.3907L", "2021MNRAS.506.2871S", "2021MNRAS.506.4210I", "2021MNRAS.507.5758S", "2021MNRAS.508..100A", "2022A&A...666A.162G", "2022MNRAS.513.4754F", "2023ApJ...953...37G", "2023MNRAS.518.2640C", "2023MNRAS.519.3292D", "2023MNRAS.521.5570S", "2023MNRAS.522.4181R", "2023MNRAS.525.2489Z", "2024A&A...681A..67E", "2024A&A...682A..80P", "2024A&A...687A..79G", "2024MNRAS.527.3459A", "2024MNRAS.529.2017T", "2024arXiv240208458G", "2024arXiv240617849H" ]
29163293
2406.03676
Revisiting the accretion disc spectra of dwarf novae and nova-like variables: implications for the standard disc model
Accretion discs are fundamental to much of astronomy. They can occur around stars, both young and old, around compact objects they provide a window into the extremes of physics, and around supermassive black holes in galaxy centres, they generate spectacular luminosities that can outshine the entire galaxy. However, our understanding of the inner workings of accretion discs remains far from complete. Here, we revisit a conundrum in the observations of some of the simplest accreting systems: the cataclysmic variables (CVs). The high-accretion-rate states of (non-magnetic) CVs can be divided into the short-lived outbursts (~a week), typical of dwarf novae (DNe), and the long-lived (and sometimes perpetual) high states of nova-like (NL) CVs. Since both sorts of high-state occur in approximately steady-state accretion discs with similar properties and accretors, we would expect them to display similar spectral energy distributions. However, previous analyses based on UV spectra from the International Ultraviolet Explorer have shown that their spectral energy distributions are different. We perform a re-analysis of the data using up to date calibrations and distance (and thus dereddening) estimates to test whether this difference persists and whether it is statistically significant over the sample. We find that it does persist, and it is statistically significant. We propose routes to investigating this discrepancy further and discuss the implications this has for other accreting systems, such as X-ray binaries, active galactic nuclei, and protoplanetary discs.
[ 0.0021434244699776173, 0.046978022903203964, 0.0379384383559227, 0.011229945346713066, 0.023016173392534256, 0.08438799530267715, 0.023961851373314857, -0.02716047503054142, -0.004784026183187962, 0.03618615120649338, 0.013003094121813774, -0.01926126889884472, -0.05482160300016403, 0.009435934945940971, 0.04386284574866295, 0.04325093328952789, -0.017022233456373215, 0.02848164364695549, 0.0006918758735992014, 0.03423916548490524, -0.011243851855397224, -0.006776211317628622, 0.032403431832790375, 0.01838512346148491, -0.0154090141877532, -0.058465249836444855, 0.010638895444571972, 0.041554272174835205, 0.08099467307329178, -0.04920315369963646, 0.0496203638613224, -0.030067048966884613, -0.04333437606692314, -0.013336863368749619, -0.042861536145210266, 0.08305291831493378, 0.01358023751527071, 0.007329016923904419, -0.022167842835187912, -0.057797711342573166, -0.03045644611120224, 0.008351185359060764, -0.02848164364695549, 0.011382922530174255, -0.01940033957362175, -0.019289081916213036, -0.03688150271773338, -0.04027482494711876, 0.02870415709912777, 0.04611578583717346, -0.06530752032995224, 0.04071985185146332, 0.04369596019387245, 0.03888411819934845, 0.0027848873287439346, -0.02312742918729782, 0.004516315646469593, 0.03326566889882088, -0.01072233822196722, -0.03293190151453018, 0.001265541766770184, 0.011980925686657429, 0.024184364825487137, -0.018913591280579567, 0.009908774867653847, -0.012182578444480896, -0.010951803997159004, 0.03090147115290165, 0.030929286032915115, 0.0193168967962265, 0.0002401139645371586, -0.03941258788108826, 0.0021816689986735582, -0.0269518680870533, 0.05490504577755928, -0.006734490394592285, -0.022279098629951477, -0.021486395969986916, -0.028815412893891335, 0.016897069290280342, 0.08666875213384628, 0.02168109454214573, -0.024476412683725357, -0.0003661466180346906, -0.018037447705864906, 0.04950910806655884, 0.023196963593363762, -0.009929635562002659, -0.0028752831276506186, -0.03688150271773338, 0.040803294628858566, 0.04186023026704788, -0.02307180128991604, -0.02248770371079445, 0.009825333021581173, 0.010680616833269596, 0.0018826673040166497, -0.057074546813964844, 0.0458376444876194, 0.001545421197079122, -0.043223120272159576, 0.028147874400019646, 0.020832765847444534, -0.07443054765462875, 0.05585072562098503, -0.01641032285988331, -0.028676342219114304, 0.03332129865884781, 0.0007874868460930884, -0.02818959578871727, 0.0370762012898922, -0.0028735448140650988, -0.026993589475750923, 0.021486395969986916, -0.0021069184876978397, 0.0061156265437603, -0.04795151948928833, 0.0449754074215889, -0.0067101530730724335, 0.010812733322381973, -0.013941820710897446, 0.024990973994135857, -0.00022924906807020307, -0.009143887087702751, 0.03735434263944626, -0.008288603276014328, 0.0027814104687422514, -0.0027362126857042313, -0.08077216148376465, -0.01020777691155672, 0.051650796085596085, -0.02467111125588417, 0.0008704945794306695, -0.07164913415908813, -0.07187164574861526, -0.009428981691598892, -0.029677649959921837, -0.04099799320101738, -0.01670237071812153, 0.05131702497601509, 0.014449427835643291, 0.006574559025466442, 0.036213964223861694, 0.004857038147747517, -0.0021816689986735582, 0.020179133862257004, 0.008045230060815811, 0.01457459107041359, -0.009206469170749187, 0.03053988888859749, -0.02211221493780613, 0.04817403107881546, -0.0016505933599546552, -0.026103537529706955, -0.027271730825304985, -0.027549872174859047, 0.020401647314429283, -0.021875794976949692, -0.007843578234314919, -0.04820184409618378, 0.003534129820764065, -0.013997448608279228, -0.06413932889699936, 0.00013591970491688699, 0.0014202577294781804, 0.013531562872231007, -0.06580817699432373, -0.02825913205742836, -0.07977085560560226, -0.01471366174519062, -0.015937482938170433, -0.012321649119257927, -0.02759159356355667, -0.012836209498345852, 0.0012351201148703694, 0.017244745045900345, 0.0007118672947399318, -0.02590883895754814, 0.005486332345753908, -0.013281235471367836, 0.015937482938170433, 0.007947880774736404, 0.034517306834459305, -0.03190277889370918, 0.007329016923904419, -0.0063485694117844105, -0.029622022062540054, -0.006731013767421246, -0.017022233456373215, -0.03799406811594963, -0.035685498267412186, 0.033794138580560684, 0.014671940356492996, 0.06897898018360138, -0.0528746135532856, -0.01749507337808609, 0.014046123251318932, 0.0047110142186284065, -0.03601926565170288, -0.013336863368749619, 0.04302842170000076, 0.051650796085596085, 0.03930133208632469, -0.04269465059041977, -0.013232560828328133, -0.011097827926278114, 0.021249976009130478, 0.02371152490377426, -0.006421581842005253, -0.018691079691052437, 0.01127166673541069, -0.0012472887756302953, -0.040970176458358765, 0.02080495096743107, -0.0578533411026001, 0.02489362470805645, 0.021263884380459785, 0.05829836428165436, 0.08355357497930527, -0.022515518590807915, 0.02649293653666973, 0.024281714111566544, 0.023155242204666138, 0.022209564223885536, -0.0044989315792918205, 0.03710401803255081, 0.030428631231188774, 0.024365156888961792, 0.05198456346988678, 0.039662916213274, -0.014630219899117947, 0.03112398460507393, -0.0029535102657973766, -0.025143951177597046, -0.02321087196469307, -0.010221683420240879, -0.018635449931025505, 0.04319530725479126, 0.00897004920989275, -0.017300372943282127, -0.019873177632689476, 0.028787599876523018, -0.015047430992126465, 0.04313967749476433, -0.03735434263944626, 0.0076836468651890755, -0.037604670971632004, -0.002026953035965562, 0.009053491055965424, 0.06669822335243225, 0.02678498439490795, -0.020457275211811066, -0.021917514503002167, 0.004749258514493704, -0.0339888371527195, -0.01197397243231535, 0.009157794527709484, 0.028815412893891335, -0.026673726737499237, 0.01170973852276802, -0.013163025490939617, -0.015687156468629837, -0.042416512966156006, 0.03791062533855438, -0.02862071432173252, 0.038188766688108444, -0.011341202072799206, -0.05593416839838028, -0.03234780579805374, -0.005667123943567276, -0.00761411152780056, -0.050260089337825775, 0.024351250380277634, -0.012168671004474163, -0.01589576154947281, -0.009686262346804142, 0.005687984637916088, 0.0026110492181032896, 0.05014883354306221, 0.00816344004124403, 0.03359944000840187, -0.014199101366102695, 0.04255558177828789, -0.003942649345844984, -0.029844535514712334, -0.018204331398010254, -0.03499014675617218, 0.02716047503054142, 0.016924884170293808, -0.036353036761283875, 0.019136104732751846, -0.04503103718161583, 0.0005058690439909697, -0.024990973994135857, 0.003431565361097455, -0.032236550003290176, 0.017425537109375, 0.029399510473012924, -0.006765781436115503, -0.02393403835594654, 0.019817549735307693, 0.010492871515452862, 0.04369596019387245, 0.033210042864084244, -0.0537368506193161, 0.012641510926187038, 0.07598813623189926, 0.013246468268334866, -0.015242129564285278, 0.029705464839935303, 0.04517010599374771, -0.002395489951595664, -0.007238620892167091, 0.003309878520667553, -0.0951242446899414, -0.022167842835187912, 0.013976587913930416, -0.024768460541963577, 0.02386450208723545, -0.03529610112309456, -0.020957928150892258, -0.0117166917771101, -0.02964983694255352, -0.003348123049363494, 0.029816720634698868, -0.042499952018260956, -0.02386450208723545, 0.0154090141877532, 0.004318139981478453, -0.0017053523333743215, 0.04544824734330177, -0.01552027091383934, 0.000366798514733091, 0.043751589953899384, -0.015256037004292011, -0.029121369123458862, 0.018454659730196, 0.024865809828042984, -0.040441710501909256, -0.016869254410266876, -0.029844535514712334, -0.026326050981879234, 0.04094236344099045, 0.023892316967248917, 0.009533285163342953, -0.023683711886405945, 0.027702849358320236, -0.01292660553008318, 0.04781244695186615, 0.010576313361525536, -0.04124831780791283, 0.015784505754709244, 0.0388006791472435, 0.02657637745141983, 0.04041389748454094, -0.010409428738057613, -0.009790564887225628, -0.04144301638007164, -0.00855979137122631, -0.009331632405519485, -0.00021849284530617297, 0.010249498300254345, 0.03226436302065849, -0.007523715496063232, -0.025797583162784576, -0.01211999636143446, -0.015019617043435574, -0.020985743030905724, -0.0042068837210536, -0.07354049384593964, 0.014783197082579136, 0.023155242204666138, -0.03220873326063156, 0.005062167067080736, -0.063861183822155, 0.029037926346063614, 0.040386080741882324, -0.014143472537398338, 0.019567223265767097, 0.029677649959921837, 0.034155722707509995, 0.021263884380459785, -0.0033620300237089396, -0.018287774175405502, 0.003050859784707427, 0.010423336178064346, -0.024142643436789513, -0.025088323280215263, -0.09284348785877228, 0.016563300043344498, -0.011918344534933567, 0.011049153283238411, -0.029844535514712334, 0.009825333021581173, -0.012272974476218224, -0.0034228733275085688, 0.008990909904241562, 0.08522242307662964, 0.03902319073677063, 0.05170642212033272, -0.030734587460756302, -0.0013741906732320786, -0.02782801352441311, -0.037827182561159134, 0.028787599876523018, 0.024935346096754074, -0.00030595515272580087, 0.028453830629587173, 0.021542025730013847, -0.04597671702504158, 0.05980032682418823, 0.013809703290462494, 0.03535172715783119, -0.014560684561729431, 0.034072279930114746, 0.056045424193143845, 0.001724474597722292, 0.01237032376229763, 0.006765781436115503, 0.053264010697603226, -0.050343532115221024, -0.04614360257983208, 0.024768460541963577, -0.022960543632507324, -0.049592550843954086, -0.03830002248287201, -0.0013176932698115706, 0.03615833818912506, -0.00726643530651927, -0.03651992231607437, -0.003678415436297655, 0.0618029423058033, 0.004165162332355976, 0.026965774595737457, 0.018259961158037186, 0.00977665837854147, 0.028022712096571922, -0.043084051460027695, -0.004033045377582312, -0.03768811374902725, 0.060801636427640915, 0.007447226904332638, -0.03257031738758087, -0.006094765849411488, 0.02027648314833641, 0.03476763144135475, 0.045142292976379395, 0.0023763675708323717, 0.071426622569561, 0.0029030973091721535, 0.026395587250590324, 0.018830150365829468, -0.015103059820830822, -0.00015232569421641529, -0.02642340026795864, -0.022223470732569695, 0.017634142190217972, -0.012884884141385555, 0.01047201082110405, -0.017369909211993217, 0.01596529595553875, -0.035045772790908813, -0.010896176099777222, 0.023614175617694855, -0.025088323280215263, 0.001534121809527278, 0.01412956602871418, 0.01362195797264576, 0.02072150819003582, -0.037743739783763885, 0.03067895770072937, -0.039273519068956375, 0.030929286032915115, -0.015534178353846073, 0.022390354424715042, -0.024114830419421196, 0.01851028762757778, 0.016507672145962715, 0.0154090141877532, 0.019900992512702942, 0.03359944000840187, -0.018065262585878372, -0.028759784996509552, 0.025519441813230515, 0.03140212595462799, 0.03226436302065849, -0.008608466014266014, -0.00640419777482748, 0.01417128648608923, -0.0009952235268428922, -0.01595138944685459, -0.02914918214082718, 0.05298587307333946, -0.01574278436601162, 0.02489362470805645, 0.003144732443615794, -0.012731906957924366, -0.011056107468903065, -0.013774936087429523, 0.020151318982243538, 0.06069037690758705, -0.0029987082816660404, 0.051734235137701035, 0.012342509813606739, 0.03490670397877693, 0.007989602163434029, -0.020304298028349876, -0.0006753612542524934, 0.004857038147747517, -0.022598961368203163, -0.028314759954810143, 0.04119269177317619, 0.01047201082110405, -0.013914006762206554, -0.0377715565264225, -0.015603713691234589, -0.020777136087417603, 0.01809307560324669, 0.0014498102245852351, -0.023391662165522575, 0.007725367788225412, -0.03579675406217575, 0.03471200540661812, 0.003987847361713648, 0.00750285480171442, -0.026465121656656265, -0.03243124857544899, -0.07598813623189926, -0.02467111125588417, -0.013823610730469227, 0.015756690874695778, -0.04386284574866295, 0.026479028165340424, 0.020262576639652252, -0.031513381749391556, -0.017397722229361534, -0.0389675609767437, -0.00926905032247305, -0.03154119476675987, -0.046672068536281586, 0.00746808759868145, -0.020624158903956413, 0.002750119660049677, 0.019859271124005318, 0.024504227563738823, 0.056935474276542664, -0.020888393744826317, 0.021208256483078003, 0.012140857055783272, 0.004540652967989445, -0.011076967231929302, -0.020902300253510475, -0.002725782338529825, 0.006755351088941097, 0.014755383133888245, 0.026159167289733887, -0.0063589997589588165, -0.02642340026795864, -0.0035132691264152527, -0.0031847150530666113, -0.031096169725060463, -0.03301534429192543, -0.036937132477760315, 0.03162463754415512, -0.01306567620486021, -0.007182992994785309, -0.0017957482486963272, -0.029176997020840645, -0.026910146698355675, 0.03376632556319237, -0.051428280770778656, -0.013163025490939617, 0.005183854140341282, -0.0317637100815773, -0.014560684561729431, -0.016521578654646873, -0.03301534429192543, 0.028467737138271332, 0.029816720634698868, -0.050788555294275284, -0.008212114684283733, -0.0346841886639595, 0.00235203024931252, 0.022877102717757225, -0.03134649619460106, 0.022223470732569695, 0.030484259128570557, 0.0016931836726143956, 0.010242544114589691, -0.010492871515452862, 0.020777136087417603, -0.010152149014174938, -0.01705004647374153, 0.054877229034900665, -0.05240177363157272, 0.03287627175450325, 0.03813314065337181, 0.020902300253510475, 0.002087796339765191, -0.005879206582903862, 0.01003393903374672, -0.01743944361805916, -0.022418169304728508, -0.05418187752366066, 0.018649358302354813, -0.0012116519501432776, 0.0298723503947258, -0.03287627175450325, -0.02841210924088955, 0.0370762012898922, 0.0033568148501217365, -0.004989155102521181, -0.010777966119349003, -0.00896309595555067, 0.009568052366375923, 0.017634142190217972, -0.023099614307284355, -0.022529425099492073, -0.001606264617294073, -0.02387841045856476, -0.00340548949316144, -0.004853561520576477, 0.004780549556016922, 0.016507672145962715, 0.03871723636984825, 0.015436829067766666, -0.004888329189270735, -0.05259647220373154, -0.006091289222240448, -0.0239479448646307, 0.004259034991264343, 0.006174731533974409, 0.055016301572322845, 0.014560684561729431, 0.0010612820042297244, -0.018204331398010254, -0.006077382247895002, 0.025463813915848732, 0.0047631654888391495, 0.008114765398204327, 0.01182099524885416, 0.02458767034113407, 0.024295620620250702, 0.007433319929987192, 0.0012159979669377208, 0.006786641664803028, 0.005555867683142424, -0.009721029549837112, -0.026993589475750923, 0.016591114923357964, -0.02233472652733326, -0.026006188243627548, -0.00025054425350390375, -0.008427673950791359, 0.01860763691365719, 0.0020008771680295467, 0.022960543632507324, -0.01970629394054413, -0.057797711342573166, 0.030567701905965805, -0.009435934945940971, -0.024615483358502388, 0.039496030658483505, -0.01200178638100624, -0.006438965443521738, -0.007954834029078484, 0.009978310205042362, 0.03743778541684151, -0.032904088497161865, 0.05401499196887016, 0.056935474276542664, -0.00039004936115816236, -0.006828363053500652, 0.026632005348801613, 0.015534178353846073, -0.016897069290280342, 0.03170808032155037, -0.00755848316475749, -0.030400818213820457, 0.03646429255604744, -0.023447291925549507, -0.005639309994876385, -0.024490319192409515, 0.0019000511383637786, -0.03423916548490524, -0.0007883560610935092, 0.00951937772333622, 0.012877930887043476, 0.018788428977131844, 0.008629326708614826, 0.009074351750314236, 0.027271730825304985, -0.018635449931025505, 0.008844885975122452, -0.003734043799340725, -0.00011690616520354524, 0.00845548789948225, -0.018496381118893623, 0.00039569911314174533, -0.006032184232026339, 0.02056853100657463, -0.0007214283687062562, -0.019275175407528877, -0.012203439138829708, -0.03009486198425293, -0.01156371459364891, 0.045865461230278015, -0.014039169996976852, 0.01552027091383934, -0.04466945305466652, 0.02321087196469307, 0.021333418786525726, -0.017230838537216187, 0.015993110835552216, -0.011654110625386238, 0.010339893400669098, -0.005239482037723064, 0.016368601471185684, 0.005931357853114605, -0.004617141559720039, 0.006153870839625597, 0.019094383344054222, -0.035323914140462875, -0.010339893400669098, 0.04466945305466652, -0.005521100014448166, 0.01237727701663971, 0.01821823976933956, -0.035184845328330994, 0.022821472957730293, -0.015603713691234589, -0.03946821764111519, 0.022432075813412666, -0.03104054182767868, -0.012558069080114365, 0.030512074008584023, -0.012502440251410007, -0.006762304343283176, 0.0035584671422839165, 0.046894583851099014, -0.013030908070504665, -0.025143951177597046, 0.015033524483442307, 0.019817549735307693, 0.03749341517686844, 0.016229530796408653, 0.008775350637733936, 0.008372046053409576, -0.008580652065575123, 0.0024285190738737583, 0.0011177794076502323, 0.013441166840493679, 0.028008803725242615, -0.03440604731440544, 0.019887086004018784, -0.020999649539589882, 0.016396414488554, -0.015450735576450825, -0.020777136087417603, 0.012940512970089912, 0.02248770371079445, 0.015395107679069042, 0.009123026393353939, 0.013385538011789322, -0.026034003123641014, 0.021639375016093254, -0.002845730632543564, -0.0029482950922101736, 0.00831641722470522, -0.0028074863366782665, -0.0007514154422096908, -0.005302064120769501, -0.015242129564285278, -0.023183057084679604, 0.04369596019387245, 0.027494244277477264, 0.02620088681578636, -0.05518318712711334, 0.02336384914815426, 0.018913591280579567, -0.009860100224614143, -0.005879206582903862, -0.006146917585283518, -0.03487888723611832, -0.008664093911647797, 0.005465471651405096, 0.020234761759638786, -0.022668495774269104, -0.024990973994135857, -0.03677024692296982, -0.015214315615594387, 0.004575420171022415, -0.031151797622442245, 0.004930050112307072, 0.033849768340587616, -0.009971356950700283, -0.004196453373879194, -0.08822634071111679, -0.014143472537398338, 0.013489841483533382, 0.00761411152780056, 0.016132181510329247, 0.03354381024837494, 0.067977674305439, 0.01617390289902687, 0.016271252185106277, -0.010562406852841377, 0.011153456754982471, -0.01859373040497303, -0.002571066375821829, -0.004599757958203554, 0.03142993897199631, 0.01376102864742279, -0.03126305341720581, 0.008093904703855515, -0.014783197082579136, -0.02248770371079445, -0.02195923589169979, 0.013628912158310413, -0.02606181614100933, 0.0018861440476030111, 0.007523715496063232, 0.008121718652546406, -0.025964466854929924, -0.004318139981478453, -0.006188638508319855, 0.01332295686006546, 0.022237377241253853, 0.01874670758843422, -0.02614525891840458, 0.08099467307329178, 0.007287295535206795, 0.017661957070231438, 0.008538930676877499, 0.027216102927923203, -0.012697138823568821, 0.008615419268608093, 0.03816095367074013, -0.006327709183096886, 0.037660300731658936, -0.0026840611826628447, 0.04597671702504158, 0.0061156265437603, 0.025227393954992294, 0.02101355604827404, 0.0032681573648005724, 0.010965711437165737, 0.018454659730196, -0.017091767862439156, 0.01075710542500019, -0.031151797622442245, -0.015506364405155182, 0.009324679151177406, -0.028759784996509552, -0.01167497131973505, -0.018718892708420753, -0.0004104753606952727, -0.017189117148518562, 0.004509361926466227, -0.005169946700334549, -0.0022146981209516525, -0.040163569152355194, -0.04539262130856514, 0.017967911437153816, 0.02789754793047905, 0.020610252395272255, -0.02597837522625923, 0.031207427382469177, 0.021124813705682755, -0.011556761339306831, 0.00014863163232803345, -0.028648529201745987, 0.005778380669653416, -0.006393767427653074, -0.01924736052751541, -0.03557424247264862, 0.013865332119166851, 0.030567701905965805, -0.015784505754709244, 0.007878345437347889, -0.020693695172667503, 0.012391184456646442, 0.02268240414559841, -0.008066090755164623, 0.03156901150941849, -0.01750897988677025, 0.010541546158492565, 0.016521578654646873, -0.013628912158310413, 0.01252330094575882, -0.03309878706932068, -0.02803661860525608, 0.02752205729484558, 0.01670237071812153, -0.012036554515361786, -0.012168671004474163, -0.008615419268608093, -0.0003150816773995757, -0.023336034268140793, -0.03490670397877693, -0.029816720634698868, -0.004537175875157118, -0.013482887297868729, -0.01522822305560112, 0.011438551358878613, 0.02020694874227047, 0.015909668058156967, 0.06719888001680374, 0.03565768525004387, 0.01364977192133665, 0.021917514503002167, 0.04956473782658577, -0.017397722229361534, -0.013482887297868729, 0.02738298662006855, 0.020540717989206314, -0.012203439138829708, 0.005760996602475643, 0.0011186485644429922, -0.04606015980243683, 0.011834901757538319, 0.025533348321914673, 0.0022129598073661327, -0.0054619950242340565, -0.03771592676639557, -0.008372046053409576, 0.013260374777019024, -0.01538120023906231, 0.015089152380824089, -0.017620235681533813, -0.018482472747564316, 0.020999649539589882, -0.022070493549108505, -0.039496030658483505, 0.054877229034900665, -0.00007583689875900745, 0.02371152490377426, -0.029816720634698868, 0.0011595005635172129, 0.021542025730013847, 0.0015323833795264363, -0.016229530796408653, -0.0013585452688857913, -0.018844056874513626, -0.0018600682960823178, 0.048146218061447144, 0.01809307560324669, -0.009276004508137703, 0.0109031293541193, -0.03243124857544899, 0.02942732349038124, -0.0012985710054636002, 0.020234761759638786, 0.02115262672305107, -0.014150426723062992, 0.016354694962501526, 0.03821657970547676, 0.06897898018360138, 0.020179133862257004, -0.0005632356624118984, -0.031068356707692146, 0.039440400898456573, -0.012328602373600006, -0.022751938551664352, -0.015979204326868057, 0.004870945122092962, -0.014268636703491211, -0.047256164252758026, -0.04380721598863602, 0.030929286032915115, 0.032542504370212555, 0.0019156965427100658, -0.009428981691598892, 0.012050461024045944, 0.03387758135795593, 0.033432554453611374, 0.010548499412834644, 0.0032942332327365875, 0.007982647977769375, -0.0258393045514822, -0.012182578444480896, 0.06441746652126312, 0.02650684304535389, 0.011612389236688614, 0.00495786452665925, 0.006584989372640848, 0.0017505502328276634, -0.0007118672947399318, 0.01946987397968769, 0.007628018502146006, 0.0023311697877943516, -0.030400818213820457, 0.01036075409501791, -0.03432260826230049, 0.031958408653736115, 0.036937132477760315, -0.006105196196585894, -0.03640866279602051, -0.028898855671286583, 0.001483708736486733, 0.007016108371317387, -0.016785813495516777, -0.014811011031270027, 0.02556116320192814, -0.0032507735304534435, 0.0038453000597655773, -0.022738032042980194, -0.0084137674421072, 0.008538930676877499, -0.01402526255697012, -0.017536792904138565, 0.005608018953353167, -0.028787599876523018, 0.008893560618162155, 0.008810117840766907, -0.023461198434233665, -0.007794903125613928, 0.008198207244277, -0.040525153279304504, -0.01361500471830368, 0.019428152590990067, -0.0070473989471793175, 0.023085707798600197, 0.013830563984811306, 0.019219547510147095, -0.0117166917771101, -0.0028700679540634155, -0.022432075813412666, -0.011668017134070396, 0.005771426949650049, -0.010576313361525536, -0.029455138370394707, -0.0060739051550626755, -0.013594144023954868, 0.0013811441604048014, -0.011737552471458912, 0.024031387642025948, 0.031819336116313934, -0.0029987082816660404, -0.0037653346080332994, -0.046087972819805145, -0.03354381024837494, -0.03376632556319237, -0.02166718803346157, -0.00043872406240552664, 0.014755383133888245, 0.023489011451601982, -0.031235240399837494, -0.00761411152780056, -0.0058096712455153465, 0.009839239530265331, 0.012655418366193771, -0.013510702177882195, -0.0009135195286944509, 0.017634142190217972, 0.008073044009506702, 0.02693796157836914, 0.008295557461678982, 0.005378552712500095, -0.003235128242522478, -0.05484941601753235, 0.016869254410266876, 0.009894868358969688, -0.03529610112309456, -0.006762304343283176, 0.037743739783763885, 0.0010708430781960487, -0.010882268659770489, -0.01970629394054413, -0.00495786452665925, 0.012717999517917633, -0.005618449300527573, 0.01792619191110134, -0.024476412683725357, 0.003980894107371569, -0.0214585829526186, 0.020151318982243538, 0.002223390154540539, 0.005225575063377619, -0.036492105573415756, -0.025588978081941605, 0.02812006138265133, 0.0006545006763190031, -0.005896590184420347, -0.02423999272286892, 0.015589806251227856, -0.03543516993522644, -0.02686842530965805, 0.041999299079179764, 0.021347325295209885, -0.012704093009233475, -0.008358138613402843, -0.04914752393960953, -0.02204267866909504, 0.030178304761648178, 0.013128258287906647, -0.0037097062449902296, 0.024712832644581795, -0.043000608682632446, 0.031374312937259674, -0.019748015329241753, -0.006449395790696144, 0.0010551976738497615, -0.00640419777482748, 0.004745781887322664, -0.01955331675708294, -0.0061608245596289635, -0.00817039329558611, -0.013517655432224274, -0.0038522535469383, 0.0062338365241885185, -0.015645435079932213, -0.03001141920685768, -0.036130525171756744, -0.004651909228414297, -0.013851424679160118, 0.004964817781001329, -0.0032107909210026264, 0.0274664293974638, 0.0028005328495055437, -0.005222098436206579, 0.002291186945512891, -0.0069222357124090195, -0.0008105204324238002, -0.012613696977496147, -0.0002038252423517406, 0.03268157318234444, 0.017453351989388466, 0.01310044340789318, 0.012509394437074661, 0.0016088722040876746, -0.006717106327414513, 0.038550350815057755, 0.018857963383197784, 0.03268157318234444, 0.010173008777201176, 0.017689771950244904, -0.01595138944685459, -0.013246468268334866, -0.0033585531637072563, -0.0028474691789597273, 0.008246881887316704, -0.016521578654646873, 0.004165162332355976, -0.005528053734451532, -0.05401499196887016, -0.0008987432811409235, 0.07582125067710876, -0.037966255098581314, -0.006272080820053816, -0.017550701275467873, 0.020026156678795815, -0.026757169514894485, 0.023558547720313072, 0.004053906071931124, -0.006675385404378176, -0.00010386830399511382, 0.008107812143862247, 0.05014883354306221, -0.015867946669459343, 0.010374661535024643, -0.006637141108512878, -0.00521862180903554, -0.018579822033643723, 0.015687156468629837, -0.013934866525232792, 0.013267328031361103, -0.013246468268334866, -0.019511595368385315, 0.0007457656902261078, 0.004797933157533407, -0.015534178353846073, -0.011035246774554253, 0.032987527549266815, -0.009832286275923252, -0.011229945346713066, -0.017300372943282127, 0.008511116728186607, -0.002984801307320595, -0.010075659491121769, -0.01237727701663971, -0.006824885960668325, -0.01413651928305626, 0.000665800180286169, -0.009714076295495033, -0.006894421298056841, 0.055016301572322845, 0.019233454018831253, 0.028203502297401428, -0.009213422425091267, 0.01278058160096407, -0.008066090755164623, -0.006744920741766691, -0.013642818666994572, 0.04942566528916359, 0.004839654546231031, 0.018704986199736595, -0.016799720004200935, -0.009727983735501766, 0.03996887058019638, -0.01903875544667244, -0.0389675609767437, 0.003315093694254756, -0.003424611873924732, -0.004683200269937515, 0.005496762692928314, -0.026256516575813293, -0.025505535304546356, 0.042722467333078384, -0.03899537771940231, 0.02415654994547367, 0.029983606189489365, -0.010249498300254345, -0.0022703264839947224, -0.021486395969986916, -0.008406813256442547, 0.01955331675708294, -0.0022703264839947224, 0.011104782111942768, 0.014880546368658543, 0.002346815075725317, 0.0014654557453468442, -0.008775350637733936, -0.019900992512702942, 0.04422442987561226, -0.009185608476400375, 0.025533348321914673, -0.015561992302536964, -0.040664222091436386, -0.015422921627759933, 0.017425537109375, -0.02357245422899723, 0.026395587250590324, 0.015464643016457558, -0.004714490845799446, -0.03941258788108826, -0.0062859877943992615, -0.014741475693881512, -0.010666709393262863, 0.019344709813594818, 0.017175210639834404, 0.02642340026795864, 0.017314281314611435, -0.018704986199736595, 0.025130044668912888, 0.03023393265902996, -0.017244745045900345, 0.013545469380915165, 0.0031899302266538143, -0.011751459911465645, -0.003410704666748643, -0.0027692418079823256, 0.0022407739888876677, -0.0030317376367747784, -0.04288935288786888, -0.024337342008948326, 0.003335954388603568, 0.029677649959921837, 0.010277312248945236, 0.000018402399291517213, -0.037966255098581314, 0.011911390349268913, 0.026103537529706955, -0.002082581166177988, -0.02415654994547367, -0.013114350847899914, -0.011626295745372772, -0.011466365307569504, -0.006282511167228222, 0.002659723861142993, -0.03206966444849968, 0.011501132510602474, -0.03905100375413895, -0.0209440216422081, 0.013427259400486946, 0.009533285163342953, -0.014094797894358635, -0.015617620199918747, 0.009748844429850578, 0.00980447232723236, 0.049675993621349335, -0.009498517028987408, -0.007530669216066599, 0.03682587668299675, -0.01574278436601162, 0.016938790678977966, 0.009345539845526218, -0.01538120023906231, -0.015840133652091026, -0.02568632736802101, -0.04508666694164276, 0.020471181720495224, -0.013886191882193089, -0.0044989315792918205, -0.0030091386288404465, 0.012738860212266445, 0.021416861563920975, -0.017383815720677376, 0.020220855250954628, 0.011640203185379505, 0.0008235583081841469, 0.016354694962501526, -0.060801636427640915, -0.0139070525765419, 0.02086057886481285, -0.006087812595069408, 0.008511116728186607, 0.006126056890934706, 0.011925297789275646, 0.000153955421410501, 0.0017253437545150518, 0.020373832434415817, -0.017328187823295593, -0.006960480008274317, -0.009011770598590374, 0.031151797622442245, 0.006998724304139614, -0.035546425729990005, -0.042861536145210266, 0.020387738943099976, -0.004126918036490679, -0.048952825367450714, -0.006188638508319855, 0.023266499862074852, 0.006574559025466442, -0.01208522915840149, 0.04597671702504158, -0.003640171140432358, -0.039662916213274, 0.021695002913475037, 0.02556116320192814, -0.018246052786707878, 0.027633314952254295, -0.01610436663031578, 0.01889968477189541, 0.001231643371284008, -0.020040063187479973, -0.01208522915840149, -0.00340375117957592, 0.02365589700639248, 0.02116653509438038, 0.04731179401278496, 0.03757685795426369, 0.01127861998975277, 0.007176039274781942, -0.018399031832814217, -0.00790615938603878, -0.02898229844868183, -0.029844535514712334, 0.007280342280864716, -0.02219565585255623, -0.019066570326685905, 0.024267807602882385, -0.01814870350062847, 0.000665800180286169, 0.02108309231698513, 0.009248190559446812, 0.0018722369568422437, 0.01582622528076172, 0.009380307048559189, 0.0179400984197855, -0.0018183471402153373, 0.010819687508046627, -0.01142464391887188, 0.02920481190085411, -0.020596345886588097, -0.008684954605996609, 0.02202877216041088, 0.022390354424715042, -0.011146502569317818, 0.012043507769703865, 0.004971771501004696, 0.01778712123632431, 0.01955331675708294, -0.008177347481250763, 0.014769290573894978, 0.008671047165989876, -0.02906574122607708, -0.0163129735738039, -0.0029083124827593565, 0.014240821823477745, 0.013204746879637241, 0.033070970326662064, -0.003151685930788517, 0.01588185504078865, -0.010541546158492565, 0.007245574612170458, 0.02914918214082718, 0.0013142165262252092, 0.004140825010836124, -0.01182099524885416, 0.023308221250772476, 0.05204019322991371, 0.013385538011789322, -0.014407706446945667, -0.013253421522676945, -0.030706772580742836, -0.003685368923470378, 0.027688942849636078, -0.00855979137122631, 0.014755383133888245, 0.008671047165989876, -0.01457459107041359, 0.0011629773071035743, -0.034378234297037125, -0.02686842530965805, 0.0068353163078427315, -0.011229945346713066, 0.019010940566658974, 0.006272080820053816, -0.001249027205631137, 0.026632005348801613, 0.023975759744644165, -0.030122676864266396, 0.03387758135795593, -0.046171415597200394, -0.0299557913094759, -0.03404446691274643, -0.008469395339488983, 0.018871869891881943, 0.006929188966751099, -0.013462027534842491, 0.00025662858388386667, 0.015103059820830822, -0.010075659491121769, -0.024184364825487137, 0.007252527866512537, -0.01321170013397932, 0.014963989146053791, 0.02159765362739563, -0.0025102230720221996, -0.006883990950882435, -0.029983606189489365, -0.01896921917796135, 0.00830946397036314, 0.015436829067766666, 0.024559855461120605, 0.01061803475022316, 0.026826705783605576, -0.024782368913292885, -0.014602405950427055, -0.015033524483442307, -0.011382922530174255, -0.024851903319358826, 0.0009074351983144879, 0.021069185808300972, -0.012078274972736835, -0.02437906339764595, 0.010597174055874348, -0.019859271124005318, 0.010166055522859097, 0.007600204553455114, 0.024768460541963577, 0.0020443368703126907, -0.004996108822524548, -0.00415820861235261, -0.02599228173494339, 0.018190424889326096, 0.005941788200289011, 0.005486332345753908, 0.0350179597735405, -0.0021434244699776173, 0.01596529595553875, 0.010228637605905533, 0.012314694933593273, 0.0065606520511209965, 0.010416382923722267, 0.008462442085146904, 0.005594111979007721, 0.021208256483078003, 0.018565915524959564, 0.010694523341953754, 0.007026538252830505, -0.0042764185927808285, 0.03323785588145256, -0.0018704986432567239, -0.011264712549746037, 0.035880196839571, -0.03229217603802681, 0.006212975829839706, 0.013392492197453976, -0.05045478790998459, -0.03830002248287201, 0.0032803260255604982, -0.004505885299295187, 0.0057088453322649, -0.024212179705500603, 0.020971836522221565, -0.024504227563738823, 0.0004506754339672625, -0.003433303674682975, 0.0018409461481496692, -0.008872699923813343, -0.0008357269689440727, -0.013239514082670212, -0.03293190151453018, 0.007940927520394325, -0.004147778730839491, -0.035685498267412186, -0.021277790889143944, 0.0036575549747794867, 0.04847998544573784, -0.021291697397828102, 0.029482951387763023, -0.014588498510420322, 0.0466998852789402, 0.005980032961815596, -0.02629823610186577, 0.00845548789948225, -0.030345188453793526, -0.00415820861235261, 0.009053491055965424, 0.030484259128570557, -0.00002900924300774932, -0.029455138370394707, -0.022515518590807915, -0.0028735448140650988, 0.0030421677511185408, 0.022932730615139008, 0.01881624199450016, -0.009526330977678299, -0.014268636703491211, -0.03560205549001694, 0.005121272057294846, 0.015422921627759933, 0.011619342491030693, -0.022098306566476822, 0.04414098709821701, -0.015770597383379936, 0.01362195797264576, -0.013489841483533382, -0.004471117630600929, -0.011633249931037426, -0.009248190559446812, 0.01969238743185997, -0.013754075393080711 ]
5.452732
9.741269
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.532..592Z
[ "Accretion discs", "accretion discs", "other accreting systems", "similar spectral energy distributions", "protoplanetary discs", "X-ray binaries", "supermassive black holes", "galaxy centres", "active galactic nuclei", "similar properties" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Solar and Stellar Astrophysics", "Astrophysics - Earth and Planetary Astrophysics", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies", "Astrophysics - High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena" ]
16
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1416", "10.48550/arXiv.2406.03676" ]
[ "Zsidi, Gabriella", "Nixon, C. J.", "Naylor, T.", "Pringle, J. E." ]
[ "School of Physics and Astronomy, Sir William Henry Bragg Building, Woodhouse Ln., University of Leeds, Leeds LS2 9JT, UK; Konkoly Observatory, HUN-REN Research Centre for Astronomy and Earth Sciences, Konkoly-Thege Miklós út 15-17, 1121 Budapest, Hungary; CSFK, MTA Centre of Excellence, Budapest, Konkoly Thege Miklós út 15-17, 1121, Hungary", "School of Physics and Astronomy, Sir William Henry Bragg Building, Woodhouse Ln., University of Leeds, Leeds LS2 9JT, UK", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Exeter, Stocker Road, Exeter EX4 4QL, UK", "Institute of Astronomy, University of Cambridge, Madingley Road, Cambridge CB3 0HA, UK" ]
null
[ "1969Natur.223..690L", "1972A&A....21....1P", "1973A&A....24..337S", "1975ApJ...198..383L", "1981A&A...104L..10M", "1981ARA&A..19..137P", "1983A&A...121...29M", "1983MNRAS.205..359F", "1984MNRAS.208..381W", "1984PASP...96....5S", "1985AJ.....90.1837S", "1985MNRAS.216..335H", "1986A&A...159L...5S", "1986ApJ...308..765S", "1986BAICz..37..129K", "1988ApJ...335..394W", "1990A&A...229..292C", "1990ApJ...351..632H", "1991A&A...252..100L", "1991EIUEN..38...27P", "1992MNRAS.259..604T", "1992RvMA....5...97P", "1993MNRAS.265L...5T", "1994ApJ...426..704L", "1995cvs..book.....W", "1996AJ....111..517N", "1996ApJ...463..656S", "1997ApJ...486..372B", "1998ApJ...509..350W", "2000ApJS..126..517M", "2001NewAR..45..449L", "2002MNRAS.332..127H", "2003A&A...404..301R", "2004MNRAS.348..111K", "2007AJ....134.1923P", "2007ApJ...654.1036L", "2007ApJ...656.1092G", "2007ApJ...662.1204L", "2007ApJ...667.1139H", "2007MNRAS.376.1740K", "2010ApJ...719..271L", "2010PASP..122..299M", "2011AJ....142...44J", "2011ARA&A..49..195A", "2012A&A...545A.115K", "2013A&ARv..21...69R", "2013AJ....145..168W", "2015MNRAS.451.2517S", "2015MNRAS.453L..46K", "2017ApJ...846...52G", "2018A&A...617A..26D", "2019A&A...628A.121N", "2019ApJ...886..108F", "2019NewA...70....7M", "2020A&A...636A..34N", "2020MNRAS.491.3730K", "2020MNRAS.494.3799P", "2021A&A...649A...5F", "2021AJ....161..147B", "2021MNRAS.503.5534H", "2022A&A...664A.174V", "2023A&A...679L...3Z", "2024A&A...681A..83G" ]
29096884
2404.13561
The Relationship of Supermassive Black Holes and Host Galaxies at z &lt; 4 in the Deep Optical Variability-selected Active Galactic Nuclei Sample in the COSMOS Field
We present the study on the relationship between supermassive black holes (SMBHs) and their host galaxies using our variability-selected active galactic nuclei (AGNs) sample (i <SUB>AB</SUB> ≤ 25.9 and z ≤ 4.5) constructed from the Hyper Suprime-Cam Subaru Strategic Program Ultradeep survey in the COSMOS field. We estimated the black hole (BH) mass (M <SUB>BH</SUB> = 10<SUP>5.5‑10</SUP> M <SUB>⊙</SUB>) based on the single-epoch virial method and the total stellar mass (M <SUB>star</SUB> = 10<SUP>10‑12</SUP> M <SUB>⊙</SUB>) by separating the AGN component with spectral energy distribution fitting. We found that the redshift evolution of the BH–stellar mass ratio (M <SUB>BH</SUB>/M <SUB>star</SUB>) depends on the M <SUB>BH</SUB>, which is caused by no significant correlation between M <SUB>BH</SUB> and M <SUB>star</SUB>. Variable AGNs with massive SMBHs (M <SUB>BH</SUB> &gt; 10<SUP>9</SUP> M <SUB>⊙</SUB>) at 1.5 &lt; z &lt; 3 show considerably higher BH–stellar mass ratios (&gt; ∼1%) than the BH–bulge ratios (M <SUB>BH</SUB>/M <SUB>bulge</SUB>) observed in the local Universe for the same BH range. This implies that there is a typical growth path of massive SMBHs, which is faster than the formation of the bulge component as final products seen in the present day. For the low-mass SMBHs (M <SUB>BH</SUB> &lt; 10<SUP>8</SUP> M <SUB>⊙</SUB>) at 0.5 &lt; z &lt; 3, on the other hand, variable AGNs show similar BH–stellar mass ratios with the local objects (∼0.1%), but smaller than those observed at z &gt; 4. We interpret that host galaxies harboring less massive SMBHs at intermediate redshift have already acquired sufficient stellar mass, although high-z galaxies are still in the early stage of galaxy formation relative to those at the intermediate/local Universe.
[ 0.02538837492465973, 0.04116850346326828, 0.03187676519155502, 0.018809553235769272, 0.00961389672011137, 0.027468277141451836, 0.03400188311934471, 0.0002748240658547729, -0.04901335388422012, 0.0024840140249580145, -0.01565578766167164, -0.0070083667524158955, -0.064974345266819, -0.012513326480984688, 0.007861805148422718, 0.029163850471377373, -0.033979274332523346, -0.009608245454728603, -0.02333107963204384, -0.008641768246889114, 0.0011021222453564405, 0.022268520668148994, 0.03942771628499031, 0.03666958585381508, -0.06113104522228241, -0.023353686556220055, -0.006731423549354076, 0.01988341473042965, 0.05981980264186859, -0.018549565225839615, 0.014502798207104206, -0.018933894112706184, -0.034793149679899216, 0.0067427270114421844, -0.07049060612916946, 0.12985825538635254, -0.021025100722908974, 0.004391533322632313, 0.013440239243209362, -0.009139136411249638, -0.006465783808380365, 0.019939934834837914, -0.006556214299052954, -0.00485498970374465, -0.029525572434067726, -0.0025532497093081474, -0.024823183193802834, -0.07392697036266327, -0.0069235884584486485, 0.004402836784720421, -0.06922458112239838, -0.02961600199341774, 0.02934471145272255, -0.026880478486418724, 0.017701778560876846, -0.015689698979258537, -0.015226242132484913, 0.00032339515746571124, -0.03852340951561928, 0.006725771352648735, -0.026880478486418724, -0.005575607996433973, 0.032781071960926056, 0.0017775252927094698, 0.015554052777588367, -0.0488324910402298, 0.0020714246202260256, -0.004303928464651108, 0.011411204002797604, 0.012479414232075214, -0.019352136179804802, -0.045531775802373886, -0.0012010306818410754, 0.016334015876054764, 0.03239674121141434, 0.01486452016979456, 0.0025023827329277992, 0.0021251176949590445, -0.014299329370260239, 0.005086718127131462, 0.003908295184373856, 0.014344544149935246, -0.012388983741402626, -0.020493822172284126, -0.025478804484009743, 0.01767917163670063, 0.023986700922250748, -0.01155250146985054, -0.070264533162117, 0.031537652015686035, 0.04182412475347519, 0.0024034741800278425, 0.010399512015283108, -0.043361444026231766, 0.037619106471538544, -0.031808942556381226, 0.026383111253380775, -0.05168105289340019, 0.058011192828416824, 0.030226407572627068, 0.017046157270669937, 0.0524044968187809, 0.016334015876054764, -0.06569778919219971, 0.004111763555556536, -0.008800022304058075, 0.02430320717394352, -0.0020191443618386984, -0.0035296170972287655, 0.00583276990801096, 0.06108583137392998, -0.0009919099975377321, -0.02821432799100876, 0.03174111992120743, -0.07406261563301086, 0.0025122733786702156, -0.07207313925027847, 0.02061816304922104, -0.027739567682147026, 0.012388983741402626, 0.049103785306215286, -0.02647354081273079, -0.01585925556719303, 0.003269629320129752, 0.012479414232075214, 0.013677619397640228, 0.000014306394405139145, -0.002561727771535516, -0.05620258301496506, -0.006991411093622446, 0.049058567732572556, -0.030610738322138786, -0.012841137126088142, -0.005055632442235947, -0.012660276144742966, 0.017351360991597176, 0.006703163962811232, -0.01957821287214756, 0.007997451350092888, 0.017701778560876846, 0.000812461890745908, 0.023715408518910408, 0.005247797351330519, 0.008494818583130836, 0.00003631793151726015, 0.049872443079948425, -0.023116307333111763, 0.008766110986471176, -0.024325815960764885, 0.009506510570645332, -0.010766886174678802, 0.019600819796323776, -0.016560092568397522, -0.03266803175210953, -0.03047509305179119, -0.010246911086142063, -0.009896492585539818, 0.02178245596587658, -0.009512162767350674, -0.03217066451907158, 0.022166786715388298, -0.021149443462491035, -0.005386269185692072, -0.01480800099670887, -0.008749155327677727, 0.05059588700532913, -0.008042666129767895, -0.016582701355218887, -0.05724253132939339, -0.038907740265131, 0.009760846383869648, 0.0005358716007322073, -0.02217809110879898, -0.034408822655677795, -0.0038517757784575224, 0.06705424934625626, 0.010546461679041386, -0.029141241684556007, -0.0020869672298431396, 0.009336953051388264, 0.028282152488827705, 0.04143979400396347, 0.000678229087498039, -0.010156480595469475, -0.031650688499212265, 0.019917326048016548, -0.012875048443675041, 0.03644350916147232, 0.026224857196211815, -0.028463013470172882, 0.003718955907970667, -0.0016743779415264726, -0.004450878128409386, 0.02174854464828968, -0.0077261594124138355, -0.044197928160429, -0.00852873083204031, 0.0451248399913311, -0.030452484264969826, 0.036692190915346146, 0.05688080936670303, -0.010608633048832417, 0.060724109411239624, -0.03660176321864128, -0.06167363002896309, -0.034634895622730255, 0.043406661599874496, 0.028440404683351517, 0.03981204703450203, 0.022279825061559677, 0.019171275198459625, -0.010495594702661037, -0.019589515402913094, -0.01418629102408886, -0.016334015876054764, -0.02468753792345524, -0.07510256767272949, 0.024122346192598343, 0.06393439322710037, 0.004162630997598171, 0.00427284324541688, 0.04462747275829315, 0.02186158299446106, -0.009026098065078259, 0.030904637649655342, 0.003348755883052945, 0.04123632609844208, -0.021115532144904137, 0.06221621111035347, -0.00035200794809497893, 0.027310023084282875, 0.04345187544822693, 0.0026380284689366817, -0.0002776500186882913, -0.003300714772194624, -0.00477868877351284, 0.016560092568397522, 0.061854489147663116, -0.013541973195970058, -0.052585359662771225, -0.016639219596982002, 0.04245713725686073, 0.024257993325591087, 0.04833512380719185, 0.007630076725035906, 0.026066603139042854, 0.020787721499800682, -0.010472986847162247, 0.020957278087735176, 0.033391475677490234, -0.004903031047433615, -0.03345930203795433, 0.0019682771526277065, 0.008800022304058075, -0.027490884065628052, -0.005945808254182339, -0.05534349009394646, 0.02721959352493286, -0.029480356723070145, -0.03302975371479988, -0.055026985704898834, -0.02586313523352146, -0.0026691139210015535, 0.005230841692537069, -0.040603313595056534, 0.044197928160429, 0.01350806187838316, -0.018515653908252716, -0.03402449190616608, 0.05059588700532913, -0.006081453990191221, -0.028621265664696693, 0.0542583242058754, -0.05195234715938568, -0.017396574839949608, 0.008347868919372559, 0.012072477489709854, 0.04693344980478287, -0.034250568598508835, -0.03795821964740753, -0.004956724122166634, -0.006561866030097008, 0.06013631075620651, 0.01683138497173786, 0.023195434361696243, -0.005747991148382425, -0.0026493321638554335, 0.028508227318525314, 0.0007651271298527718, -0.02251720428466797, 0.054755691438913345, -0.023692801594734192, 0.009404776617884636, 0.006030586548149586, -0.021578988060355186, -0.010727322660386562, 0.018662603572010994, 0.01752091757953167, -0.026993516832590103, 0.04123632609844208, 0.043632734566926956, 0.04299972206354141, 0.02543359063565731, 0.01494364719837904, -0.00785050168633461, 0.016074027866125107, 0.06714467704296112, 0.02468753792345524, -0.04639086872339249, 0.045757852494716644, 0.004696736112236977, -0.02701612375676632, -0.0014737352030351758, 0.0324193499982357, -0.06361788511276245, -0.04756646603345871, -0.06624037027359009, 0.007737463340163231, 0.007217487785965204, -0.022686762735247612, -0.03879470378160477, -0.004490441642701626, -0.0505506731569767, -0.018753033131361008, -0.011586412787437439, -0.03746085241436958, -0.00391394691541791, -0.028508227318525314, -0.021059012040495872, -0.0005461156833916903, 0.060452815145254135, -0.029163850471377373, 0.03779996559023857, -0.006618385203182697, -0.0006937718135304749, -0.03829733282327652, 0.026496147736907005, 0.056066934019327164, -0.029796862974762917, 0.003015293274074793, -0.004487615544348955, -0.004821078386157751, 0.02744566835463047, -0.0027779131196439266, -0.021646810695528984, 0.00415697880089283, 0.04225366935133934, 0.039721615612506866, 0.04381359741091728, -0.008800022304058075, 0.019872112199664116, -0.001615032902918756, 0.04756646603345871, -0.005485177505761385, 0.06529085338115692, -0.011869008652865887, 0.03540355712175369, -0.04815426468849182, -0.016187066212296486, -0.00777137465775013, -0.006522302981466055, -0.021409431472420692, 0.006104061380028725, -0.024710144847631454, 0.0024430376943200827, 0.022765887901186943, -0.00912783294916153, 0.00015030545182526112, -0.015497533604502678, -0.06786812096834183, 0.010727322660386562, 0.01597229391336441, 0.014932342804968357, -0.007025322876870632, -0.030226407572627068, -0.023308472707867622, 0.0009813127107918262, -0.004806948360055685, 0.01407325267791748, -0.006335789803415537, 0.014706267043948174, 0.005304316524416208, -0.002919210819527507, -0.027468277141451836, -0.007364436984062195, -0.007420956157147884, -0.04042245075106621, -0.002660636091604829, -0.09323389083147049, 0.038862526416778564, 0.014016733504831791, 0.019917326048016548, 0.0000024368337108171545, -0.020923366770148277, 0.009647808037698269, -0.01600620523095131, 0.037076521664857864, 0.04648129642009735, 0.0038263422902673483, 0.0859542265534401, -0.05276622250676155, -0.02391887828707695, -0.04901335388422012, -0.05701645463705063, -0.004730647895485163, -0.031695906072854996, -0.029276886954903603, 0.013485454022884369, -0.0024656453169882298, -0.029322102665901184, 0.05272100493311882, 0.03144722059369087, 0.005309968255460262, -0.030022939667105675, -0.009495207108557224, 0.06832027435302734, -0.050686318427324295, 0.02690308541059494, -0.028123898431658745, 0.024280600249767303, -0.01973646506667137, -0.044943977147340775, 0.045418739318847656, 0.0018213276052847505, -0.06289444118738174, -0.004015681333839893, 0.00739269657060504, 0.028666481375694275, -0.006799246184527874, 0.0035720064770430326, -0.0029700780287384987, 0.031062891706824303, -0.02197462134063244, 0.02918645739555359, -0.02337629534304142, 0.024325815960764885, 0.007703551556915045, 0.0014440626837313175, 0.02516229823231697, 0.004693910479545593, 0.025569235906004906, 0.007861805148422718, -0.020324263721704483, -0.06515520811080933, 0.025727488100528717, 0.026043996214866638, 0.01756613329052925, 0.044401396065950394, 0.05534349009394646, -0.035335734486579895, -0.002961600199341774, -0.02988729439675808, 0.013948910869657993, -0.007669640239328146, -0.04132675752043724, 0.0036370032466948032, 0.01682008057832718, -0.03906599432229996, -0.007652684580534697, -0.0786745697259903, 0.018673906102776527, -0.011213387362658978, -0.01849304512143135, -0.0017817642074078321, -0.015452318824827671, -0.00031897961162030697, 0.021624203771352768, -0.016254890710115433, 0.005321272183209658, -0.006787942722439766, 0.030407268553972244, -0.06189970672130585, 0.0011000027880072594, 0.025049259886145592, -0.00850612297654152, -0.017000941559672356, -0.02042599767446518, -0.027897821739315987, 0.028485620394349098, 0.011055133305490017, 0.025094475597143173, -0.013960215263068676, -0.007901368662714958, -0.00191882299259305, 0.021522467955946922, 0.04535091668367386, 0.011190779507160187, 0.0406259223818779, 0.032894108444452286, -0.011575109325349331, -0.04017376899719238, -0.03260020911693573, 0.04044505953788757, -0.00915044080466032, -0.005502133164554834, 0.010896880179643631, -0.03167329728603363, -0.022494597360491753, -0.02008688449859619, -0.013112428598105907, 0.05552435293793678, -0.05222363770008087, -0.019917326048016548, 0.021533772349357605, 0.006844461429864168, -0.02744566835463047, -0.007500083185732365, -0.02468753792345524, -0.020572947338223457, 0.06199013441801071, -0.06375353038311005, 0.006409264635294676, -0.01600620523095131, -0.01282983273267746, -0.028711697086691856, 0.01550883799791336, -0.012321161106228828, 0.045531775802373886, 0.015192330814898014, 0.010862968862056732, 0.0013635229552164674, -0.04489876329898834, -0.007279658690094948, -0.00786745734512806, 0.003687870455905795, 0.012863744050264359, -0.008325261995196342, -0.12126735597848892, -0.03920163959264755, -0.029751647263765335, -0.039246853440999985, -0.023602372035384178, 0.03861384093761444, -0.02880212664604187, -0.015192330814898014, -0.04191455617547035, -0.01624358631670475, 0.024371031671762466, -0.020098187029361725, -0.003035075031220913, 0.008082229644060135, -0.018673906102776527, 0.0017068764427676797, -0.013225466944277287, 0.0002285490627400577, 0.015192330814898014, 0.0022494597360491753, 0.026337895542383194, 0.020674683153629303, 0.01737396791577339, 0.040761567652225494, 0.012015958316624165, 0.025478804484009743, 0.023353686556220055, -0.007861805148422718, 0.007686595898121595, -0.008364825509488583, -0.005567130167037249, 0.02988729439675808, 0.0031368094496428967, 0.002232504077255726, -0.012264641933143139, -0.03633046895265579, 0.01953299716114998, -0.014005430042743683, -0.061311908066272736, 0.0008357760380022228, -0.004278494976460934, -0.028892558068037033, 0.028892558068037033, -0.00483520794659853, -0.006409264635294676, 0.03779996559023857, -0.007228791248053312, 0.008065273985266685, 0.0029446445405483246, -0.026270072907209396, 0.0022960880305618048, 0.03309757634997368, -0.06936022639274597, -0.025207513943314552, -0.04415271058678627, -0.007952235639095306, -0.00025451253168284893, -0.0002465645084157586, -0.016096636652946472, -0.009003491140902042, 0.019623426720499992, 0.0234893336892128, 0.014491493813693523, -0.002564553637057543, -0.028734304010868073, 0.007624424993991852, 0.006669252645224333, -0.006782290525734425, 0.011337729170918465, -0.00841004028916359, -0.001156521844677627, -0.014774089679121971, 0.00889610406011343, 0.002351194154471159, -0.006256663240492344, -0.030249016359448433, -0.022268520668148994, -0.024868398904800415, 0.0110664376989007, -0.026970908045768738, -0.0542583242058754, -0.010422119870781898, 0.03266803175210953, 0.0015429711202159524, 0.01721571385860443, -0.027242200449109077, 0.0003857427800539881, 0.009252174757421017, -0.001771873445250094, -0.014638443477451801, -0.03508704900741577, 0.01756613329052925, 0.012954175472259521, -0.009156092070043087, 0.014841912314295769, 0.0052760569378733635, 0.024913614615797997, 0.042276278138160706, 0.018741728737950325, -0.01412977185100317, -0.024777967482805252, 0.03133418411016464, -0.025682274252176285, 0.004128719214349985, -0.0387720949947834, 0.007788330316543579, -0.026111818850040436, -0.010258214548230171, -0.019917326048016548, -0.019781680777668953, 0.038478195667266846, -0.042502354830503464, -0.017577435821294785, 0.04033202305436134, 0.011213387362658978, 0.007042278535664082, -0.0334819070994854, -0.00843264814466238, 0.028598658740520477, -0.028282152488827705, -0.01830088160932064, -0.03151504322886467, -0.02679004706442356, -0.014141076244413853, -0.0072005316615104675, -0.0027976948767900467, -0.017724385485053062, 0.013293289579451084, 0.0054682218469679356, 0.006691860035061836, 0.0022522856015712023, -0.02194071002304554, 0.041191112250089645, 0.005617997143417597, 0.003009641543030739, 0.0009028924396261573, 0.023082396015524864, -0.005479525774717331, 0.007019670680165291, -0.0023172826040536165, 0.04279625415802002, -0.0024232559371739626, 0.009314346127212048, 0.06800376623868942, 0.003738737665116787, 0.018346095457673073, 0.02062946744263172, 0.0055162631906569, -0.02313891425728798, 0.01632271334528923, 0.00007325403566937894, -0.011230343021452427, 0.017317447811365128, 0.02674483321607113, 0.004713691771030426, -0.01892259158194065, -0.00016902739298529923, 0.013281986117362976, 0.023715408518910408, -0.010179087519645691, 0.0028895384166389704, 0.003108549863100052, -0.02798825316131115, 0.004959550220519304, -0.01304460596293211, -0.005728209391236305, 0.004281321074813604, -0.0008640355663374066, -0.007358785253018141, -0.02144334279000759, 0.042276278138160706, -0.02581791952252388, -0.037347812205553055, 0.018911287188529968, 0.011156868189573288, 0.03531312569975853, -0.0011430985759943724, -0.012524629943072796, -0.031967196613550186, -0.02489100582897663, -0.019906023517251015, -0.01973646506667137, -0.051500193774700165, 0.04792818799614906, 0.04810904711484909, -0.02896038070321083, 0.023093698546290398, 0.007630076725035906, -0.0042332797311246395, -0.015327977016568184, 0.02012079581618309, -0.014683659188449383, 0.005479525774717331, 0.011382943950593472, -0.020799024030566216, -0.04487615451216698, 0.0019781680312007666, 0.029977723956108093, -0.018459133803844452, 0.006499695125967264, 0.014502798207104206, -0.036420900374650955, -0.02663179486989975, 0.014016733504831791, 0.020979885011911392, -0.019939934834837914, -0.0051941042765975, -0.010280822403728962, 0.04729517176747322, -0.008500470779836178, -0.025456197559833527, 0.0010667977621778846, 0.04437878727912903, 0.042818862944841385, -0.013248073868453503, -0.024936221539974213, 0.019939934834837914, 0.0035324429627507925, -0.004436748567968607, 0.01682008057832718, -0.010241258889436722, 0.008969578891992569, 0.01234376896172762, -0.01756613329052925, 0.0070083667524158955, 0.0018015459645539522, -0.0007962126401253045, 0.01838000677525997, -0.026383111253380775, 0.03646611422300339, -0.006917936261743307, 0.03727998957037926, 0.023240648210048676, 0.0370539128780365, 0.005889289081096649, 0.007788330316543579, 0.0046769543550908566, -0.044514432549476624, 0.016763562336564064, -0.029977723956108093, -0.016763562336564064, 0.017193106934428215, 0.014434975571930408, 0.00009272663010051474, 0.019318224862217903, 0.024393638595938683, -0.016808776184916496, 0.03906599432229996, -0.010128220543265343, -0.010614284314215183, -0.058011192828416824, -0.01903562806546688, -0.033120185136795044, -0.002492491854354739, -0.005394747015088797, -0.00023791003332007676, -0.018673906102776527, -0.02131900005042553, 0.03522269427776337, 0.0018029588973149657, -0.0202790480107069, -0.021567683666944504, -0.023986700922250748, -0.01737396791577339, 0.01748700626194477, 0.0026408543344587088, -0.011857704259455204, 0.0008739263867028058, 0.022166786715388298, -0.00479847053065896, -0.09133484959602356, -0.008890452794730663, 0.019024325534701347, 0.016582701355218887, 0.0026055299676954746, 0.03578788787126541, 0.011077741160988808, 0.011597717180848122, 0.03004554659128189, 0.010642544366419315, 0.023421511054039, -0.03128896653652191, 0.006522302981466055, 0.033821024000644684, 0.0017817642074078321, -0.026835262775421143, -0.03596874698996544, 0.0019838199950754642, -0.01926170475780964, 0.00969302374869585, -0.0033318002242594957, 0.026134425774216652, 0.004804122727364302, -0.009738238528370857, 0.010732974857091904, -0.020765112712979317, -0.021307695657014847, 0.042547568678855896, 0.0271291621029377, -0.005502133164554834, 0.012897656299173832, -0.010116917081177235, -0.020685985684394836, 0.056112151592969894, -0.030362054705619812, -0.017430486157536507, 0.005844073835760355, 0.023195434361696243, -0.01903562806546688, -0.012897656299173832, -0.021771153435111046, -0.0361270010471344, 0.004408488981425762, -0.004366099368780851, 0.012275946326553822, -0.01041081640869379, 0.002469884231686592, 0.01860608346760273, 0.0050301989540457726, -0.0036991743836551905, 0.002098271157592535, 0.014367152005434036, 0.022223304957151413, 0.03402449190616608, -0.0002320815110579133, -0.013813265599310398, -0.0028061727061867714, -0.04012855142354965, -0.023285863921046257, -0.008121793158352375, -0.010173436254262924, 0.017927855253219604, -0.011857704259455204, -0.030113371089100838, 0.009568681940436363, -0.039676401764154434, -0.02527533657848835, -0.011880312114953995, 0.02500404417514801, -0.002693134592846036, -0.015271457843482494, 0.028982987627387047, 0.027423061430454254, 0.01953299716114998, 0.02333107963204384, 0.014016733504831791, -0.046300437301397324, 0.017973070964217186, -0.03714434430003166, 0.016367927193641663, 0.018131323158740997, -0.048244692385196686, 0.03368537500500679, -0.025456197559833527, 0.011343381367623806, -0.012038566172122955, 0.04232149198651314, 0.006104061380028725, -0.01027517020702362, 0.028191721066832542, 0.006160580553114414, -0.0007230910705402493, 0.028191721066832542, 0.033165402710437775, 0.027310023084282875, -0.0026281375903636217, 0.02019992284476757, -0.0046656508930027485, -0.017893943935632706, -0.01946517452597618, -0.05109325423836708, -0.01868521049618721, -0.005584085825830698, -0.009896492585539818, -0.003515487303957343, -0.0342731736600399, 0.001761982566677034, 0.01537319179624319, 0.012468110769987106, 0.011399900540709496, 0.04449182748794556, 0.04761167988181114, -0.023851055651903152, -0.02523012086749077, 0.03585571050643921, 0.0036709147971123457, -0.0243484228849411, 0.011292513459920883, -0.019747769460082054, -0.016887903213500977, 0.00212653074413538, -0.01298808678984642, -0.03770953416824341, -0.013496758416295052, 0.013078517280519009, -0.012072477489709854, 0.03298453986644745, -0.023150218650698662, -0.03047509305179119, 0.012807225808501244, -0.0097099794074893, 0.0022282651625573635, 0.038319941610097885, -0.038478195667266846, -0.009331301786005497, -0.034408822655677795, -0.04392663389444351, 0.020019061863422394, -0.010648196563124657, -0.0037330857012420893, -0.021002493798732758, -0.003439186606556177, -0.018707817420363426, 0.013055909425020218, -0.025998780503869057, 0.0007750180084258318, -0.026428325101733208, -0.05787554755806923, 0.04028680548071861, -0.017181802541017532, 0.0257048811763525, -0.007517038844525814, -0.01605142094194889, 0.03508704900741577, 0.010133872739970684, -0.014909735880792141, 0.02396409399807453, -0.03253238648176193, -0.022698065266013145, 0.03429578244686127, 0.024936221539974213, 0.047385603189468384, 0.01697833463549614, -0.0459839291870594, 0.018832160159945488, 0.0257727038115263, -0.00043166454997844994, 0.01732875220477581, 0.0056151715107262135, -0.015847953036427498, -0.016074027866125107, -0.045531775802373886, 0.018741728737950325, 0.010472986847162247, -0.007426608353853226, -0.019781680777668953, 0.013349808752536774, 0.00003099718742305413, 0.01868521049618721, 0.017113979905843735, 0.02291283756494522, -0.03085942193865776, -0.024777967482805252, -0.002204244490712881, 0.0009382168645970523, 0.014434975571930408, -0.015316672623157501, 0.008720895275473595, 0.017419183626770973, 0.004702388308942318, -0.010529506020247936, 0.0424797460436821, 0.0333462618291378, 0.013779353350400925, -0.007873108610510826, 0.0559765063226223, -0.021183354780077934, 0.018707817420363426, 0.013293289579451084, -0.01957821287214756, -0.01155250146985054, -0.049555934965610504, -0.015327977016568184, -0.00916739646345377, 0.01755482889711857, -0.0202790480107069, 0.009308693930506706, -0.008856541477143764, -0.03330104798078537, -0.0016009032260626554, -0.013881088234484196, 0.005041502881795168, 0.008771762251853943, 0.003153765108436346, 0.02171463333070278, -0.03757388889789581, 0.02821432799100876, -0.012841137126088142, -0.027377845719456673, -0.025727488100528717, 0.01573491469025612, -0.04865163192152977, 0.004295450635254383, 0.030249016359448433, -0.018153931945562363, 0.016887903213500977, 0.016074027866125107, -0.0076470328494906425, 0.01033168938010931, 0.0029870339203625917, 0.0360591784119606, -0.008573945611715317, -0.0037754750810563564, -0.036737408488988876, -0.057468608021736145, 0.01030908152461052, -0.02053903602063656, 0.03449925035238266, -0.035607025027275085, 0.008913060650229454, 0.0079070208594203, -0.014875823631882668, -0.014141076244413853, -0.03727998957037926, -0.016571396961808205, -0.0451248399913311, -0.015316672623157501, -0.01895650289952755, 0.007087493781000376, -0.010303429327905178, 0.011812489479780197, -0.020878151059150696, -0.015678394585847855, -0.005691471975296736, 0.02403191663324833, 0.020810328423976898, -0.0221328753978014, 0.018131323158740997, 0.014028037898242474, -0.012524629943072796, -0.015226242132484913, -0.009721282869577408, -0.03352712467312813, -0.023828446865081787, -0.007245746906846762, 0.02755870670080185, -0.023048484697937965, 0.03135678917169571, 0.01358718890696764, -0.022166786715388298, -0.0019018673337996006, -0.018357399851083755, -0.010636892169713974, 0.001971103250980377, -0.011586412787437439, 0.0005701362970285118, 0.0166731309145689, 0.013361112214624882, 0.004685432184487581, 0.02353454753756523, -0.03775475174188614, 0.013881088234484196, -0.0244162455201149, -0.0015980772441253066, 0.004442400299012661, 0.004606305621564388, 0.0025249903555959463, -0.016526181250810623, 0.0006718706572428346, -0.026925694197416306, 0.003620047587901354, 0.04218584671616554, 0.03244195505976677, 0.013881088234484196, 0.018357399851083755, -0.013756746426224709, -0.013315897434949875, 0.01884346455335617, 0.006426220294088125, -0.016910512000322342, -0.031650688499212265, -0.02419017069041729, 0.009184352122247219, -0.024664930999279022, 0.00413719704374671, -0.03239674121141434, 0.005394747015088797, -0.010099961422383785, 0.001111306599341333, 0.017475701868534088, 0.014819305390119553, 0.005346705671399832, -0.032509781420230865, -0.016175763681530952, 0.0032922369427978992, -0.001359284040518105, 0.014355848543345928, 0.007104449439793825, -0.008619161322712898, -0.0202790480107069, -0.019521692767739296, -0.013202859088778496, 0.008749155327677727, 0.02321804128587246, -0.024325815960764885, -0.005951459985226393, -0.016040116548538208, -0.0017506787553429604, 0.01724962517619133, 0.035652242600917816, 0.013417631387710571, 0.047204744070768356, 0.010037790052592754, 0.008573945611715317, -0.027965644374489784, 0.0334140844643116, 0.012615060433745384, 0.02034687250852585, 0.004055244382470846, 0.01480800099670887, -0.009992574341595173, -0.003922424744814634, -0.04465008154511452, -0.0013755332911387086, 0.0316280834376812, -0.015147116035223007, 0.004094807896763086, -0.0028810605872422457, -0.03551659360527992, -0.014717570506036282, 0.0622614286839962, -0.023116307333111763, -0.013180251233279705, -0.009291738271713257, 0.020900757983326912, -0.01613054797053337, 0.01432193722575903, 0.020019061863422394, -0.014299329370260239, -0.012027261778712273, -0.0016206848667934537, -0.012999390251934528, -0.0066636004485189915, 0.006997063290327787, 0.015915775671601295, 0.02128508873283863, -0.0013684683945029974, 0.029254280030727386, 0.004470659885555506, 0.01234376896172762, -0.011473375372588634, 0.022539813071489334, -0.020052973181009293, 0.01817653886973858, -0.014480190351605415, 0.01356458105146885, 0.021375518292188644, 0.03128896653652191, -0.015644483268260956, 0.00371613004244864, 0.010286473669111729, 0.019397351890802383, -0.005394747015088797, 0.00839308463037014, -0.03406970575451851, -0.029322102665901184, -0.016910512000322342, 0.009376516565680504, 0.03350451588630676, 0.010037790052592754, 0.025139691308140755, 0.028123898431658745, 0.001586773432791233, 0.012942871078848839, -0.007307918276637793, 0.0011367402039468288, -0.00021212321007624269, 0.04290929064154625, 0.006867069285362959, 0.0017888291040435433, -0.04058070480823517, 0.004654346965253353, 0.007748766802251339, -0.010687759146094322, 0.009563029743731022, 0.011292513459920883, 0.014480190351605415, 0.0036256995517760515, 0.013688922859728336, -0.029977723956108093, 0.005996675230562687, -0.02178245596587658, -0.01868521049618721, 0.00959128886461258, 0.011642931960523129, 0.028666481375694275, -0.01737396791577339, 0.011173823848366737, 0.007873108610510826, 0.014367152005434036, -0.014039341360330582, 0.007177924271672964, -0.005671690683811903, -0.0029022551607340574, 0.010342992842197418, -0.030610738322138786, -0.004335014149546623, 0.015079292468726635, 0.008246134966611862, -0.0008287111413665116, -0.01844783127307892, -0.03651133179664612, -0.013926303014159203, 0.035335734486579895, -0.017622651532292366, -0.019906023517251015, 0.025478804484009743, 0.026812655851244926, -0.0037952568382024765, 0.03779996559023857, -0.006149276625365019, -0.002526403171941638, 0.016616612672805786, 0.03350451588630676, 0.015169722959399223, 0.016684435307979584, 0.013722834177315235, -0.0011459245579317212, 0.015395799651741982, 0.016560092568397522, -0.02307109162211418, 0.037822574377059937, 0.01961212418973446, -0.03194458782672882, 0.008534382097423077, 0.020731201395392418, -0.016074027866125107, -0.0220989640802145, 0.012682883068919182, 0.009907796047627926, 0.01565578766167164, 0.036692190915346146, 0.01818784326314926, -0.02658657915890217, 0.002475535962730646, 0.058553773909807205, 0.025840526446700096, -0.0063188341446220875, -0.022076355293393135, -0.021273784339427948, 0.0021703329402953386, -0.013248073868453503, 0.010009530931711197, -0.027400454506278038, -0.03741563484072685, -0.01353066973388195, -0.02066337876021862, 0.008426995947957039, -0.006007979158312082, 0.018086107447743416, -0.02291283756494522, 0.009065661579370499, -0.0036765667609870434, 0.020708594471216202, 0.013270681723952293, 0.0072740064933896065, -0.0028203024994581938, -0.00513758510351181, 0.03146982938051224, 0.009257826954126358, -0.01410716399550438, -0.017419183626770973, -0.02810129150748253, -0.03269064053893089, 0.008636116981506348, -0.0048578158020973206, -0.004117415752261877, 0.05104804039001465, 0.009235219098627567, -0.003470272058621049, -0.012784617953002453, 0.005126281175762415, 0.011936831288039684, -0.010766886174678802, 0.016650523990392685, 0.026383111253380775, -0.01293156761676073, 0.017927855253219604, -0.019092148169875145, -0.009828669019043446, -0.014174987562000751, 0.009489554911851883, -0.033120185136795044, -0.00022554649331141263, 0.04501180350780487, -0.015474926680326462, 0.012106388807296753, -0.008223527111113071, -0.01825566589832306, 0.014717570506036282, -0.021759849041700363, -0.024913614615797997, 0.022234609350562096, -0.011755970306694508, -0.04372316598892212, -0.012490718625485897, 0.016729651018977165, 0.005584085825830698, -0.02047121338546276, 0.021409431472420692, -0.0020897933281958103, -0.06316573172807693, -0.008698287419974804, -0.03942771628499031, -0.013135036453604698, -0.023444117978215218, -0.012818529270589352, 0.014853216707706451, 0.02403191663324833, 0.014333240687847137, -0.009856929071247578, -0.024710144847631454, 0.03854601830244064, 0.002383692655712366, 0.021138139069080353, 0.057513825595378876, 0.006087105721235275, -0.03128896653652191, 0.01418629102408886, 0.017260929569602013, -0.020708594471216202, -0.03825211897492409, 0.0307011678814888, -0.005358009599149227, -0.009862581267952919, 0.036149609833955765, 0.0117446668446064, 0.020245136693120003, 0.008884800598025322, 0.04582567512989044, 0.009353908710181713, -0.0020827283151447773, -0.040060728788375854, 0.013146339915692806, 0.002568792551755905, 0.00583276990801096, -0.005160192959010601, 0.0046769543550908566, -0.010586025193333626, 0.011778578162193298, 0.03178633376955986, 0.006765334866940975, 0.004467833787202835, 0.001976755214855075, -0.0009050118969753385, -0.010540810413658619, 0.03682783618569374, -0.012841137126088142, 0.039450325071811676, 0.018323488533496857, 0.005163018591701984, -0.03212545067071915, 0.01640183851122856, -0.02353454753756523, -0.0051969303749501705, 0.04259278625249863, -0.016492269933223724, 0.004919986706227064, 0.0019075191812589765, 0.021658115088939667, -0.029796862974762917, -0.032894108444452286, -0.00034494305145926774, 0.010280822403728962, 0.026066603139042854, 0.025094475597143173, -0.011219038628041744, -0.003102897899225354, -0.06479348242282867, -0.01736266352236271, 0.01728353649377823, 0.01755482889711857, 0.0244162455201149, 0.012140300124883652, -0.02151116542518139, -0.004145675338804722, 0.0023709756787866354, -0.022731976583600044, -0.02733263187110424, 0.017147891223430634, -0.03449925035238266, 0.010450378991663456, 0.015452318824827671, 0.025456197559833527, 0.008958275429904461, -0.007918324321508408, -0.042502354830503464, 0.013971518725156784, -0.026654401794075966, -0.03174111992120743, -0.01542971096932888, -0.018323488533496857, -0.02008688449859619, -0.00192871387116611, -0.018515653908252716, -0.009427383542060852, -0.026043996214866638, -0.030407268553972244, -0.013372416608035564, 0.028598658740520477, 0.028779519721865654, -0.010625588707625866, 0.006098409648984671, -0.004261539317667484, -0.01871912181377411, 0.018470438197255135, -0.019589515402913094, 0.018278272822499275, -0.023195434361696243, 0.019487781450152397, 0.015056685544550419, 0.026880478486418724, -0.01356458105146885, -0.015994902700185776, -0.001321133691817522, -0.02186158299446106, -0.022935446351766586, -0.000926206586882472, 0.022200698032975197, -0.034793149679899216, 0.0014963428257033229, 0.023308472707867622, -0.006997063290327787, -0.01822175458073616, 0.02243807725608349, 0.001959799323230982, -0.02023383416235447, -0.009404776617884636, 0.012682883068919182, -0.01593838259577751, 0.002402061363682151, 0.0342731736600399, 0.0002847149153240025, 0.04223106428980827, 0.026179641485214233, 0.022664153948426247, -0.011507286690175533, 0.05172627046704292, 0.011111652478575706, 0.02144334279000759, -0.005510610993951559, 0.0038969910237938166, 0.0063244858756661415, -0.011100349016487598, 0.030090762302279472, 0.007138360757380724, 0.011117304675281048, 0.04039984568953514, 0.014536709524691105, -0.00963085237890482, -0.009105225093662739, -0.029909901320934296, 0.013067212887108326, 0.0334819070994854, 0.029548179358243942, 0.024054523557424545, 0.010704715736210346, 0.012298553250730038, -0.037935610860586166, -0.02333107963204384, 0.016153154894709587, -0.009410427883267403, 0.023851055651903152, -0.03325583040714264, 0.008568293415009975, 0.0059853713028132915, -0.0009078378789126873, 0.007946583442389965, -0.0043124062940478325, -0.035878315567970276, -0.00387720949947834, -0.002469884231686592, -0.036805231124162674, 0.010184739716351032, 0.05281143635511398, -0.024710144847631454, 0.028508227318525314, -0.021737242117524147, 0.008794370107352734, 0.009953011758625507, -0.020369479432702065, -0.030633345246315002, -0.04367795214056969, 0.004948246292769909, -0.005711253732442856, 0.027423061430454254, 0.018888678401708603, -0.0035522247198969126, 0.002652158262208104, -0.013971518725156784, 0.005386269185692072, 0.04856120049953461, -0.005403224844485521, 0.02061816304922104, -0.017939157783985138, -0.03827472776174545, 0.020414695143699646, 0.04110068082809448, 0.012694187462329865, 0.0031481131445616484, 0.015226242132484913, 0.02333107963204384, -0.016876600682735443, 0.006104061380028725, 0.012592452578246593, 0.009065661579370499, -0.02988729439675808, -0.010060397908091545, 0.002427494851872325 ]
14.697659
7.13013
2024-07-01
1
2024ApJ...969...11H
[ "sufficient stellar mass", "massive SMBHs", "SUB", "galaxy formation", "host galaxies", "supermassive black holes", "SMBHs", "spectral energy distribution", "BH", "M <SUB" ]
[ "Active galactic nuclei", "Supermassive black holes", "Black hole physics", "Seyfert galaxies", "16", "1663", "159", "1447", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies", "Astrophysics - High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena" ]
49
[ "10.3847/1538-4357/ad414c", "10.48550/arXiv.2404.13561" ]
[ "Hoshi, Atsushi", "Yamada, Toru", "Kokubo, Mitsuru", "Matsuoka, Yoshiki", "Nagao, Tohru" ]
[ "Astronomical Institute, Tohoku University, 6-3 Aramaki, Aoba-ku, Sendai, Miyagi 980-8578, Japan; Institute of Space and Astronautical Science, Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency, 3-1-1, Yoshinodai, Chuou-ku, Sagamihara, Kanagawa 252-5210, Japan", "Astronomical Institute, Tohoku University, 6-3 Aramaki, Aoba-ku, Sendai, Miyagi 980-8578, Japan; Institute of Space and Astronautical Science, Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency, 3-1-1, Yoshinodai, Chuou-ku, Sagamihara, Kanagawa 252-5210, Japan", "National Astronomical Observatory of Japan, 2-21-1 Osawa, Mitaka, Tokyo 181-0015, Japan", "Research Center for Space and Cosmic Evolution, Ehime University, 2-5 Bunkyo-cho, Matsuyama, Ehime 790-8577, Japan", "Research Center for Space and Cosmic Evolution, Ehime University, 2-5 Bunkyo-cho, Matsuyama, Ehime 790-8577, Japan; Amanogawa Galaxy Astronomy Research Center, Kagoshima University, 1-21-35 Korimoto, Kagoshima 890-0065, Japan" ]
[ "2024arXiv240206882B" ]
[ "1955ApJ...121..161S", "1981PASP...93....5B", "1998AJ....115.2285M", "2000ApJ...539..718C", "2003MNRAS.344.1000B", "2004ApJ...601..692V", "2004ApJ...604L..89H", "2005ApJ...630..122G", "2006ApJ...641..689V", "2006ApJS..166..470R", "2006MNRAS.369.1808C", "2007ApJS..172...70L", "2009A&A...497...81B", "2010ApJ...708..137M", "2010MNRAS.402.2453D", "2011ApJS..194...45S", "2011MNRAS.415.2920I", "2012MNRAS.419.2497B", "2012MNRAS.420.2756S", "2012MNRAS.420.3621T", "2012MNRAS.425..623L", "2012Natur.491..729V", "2013A&A...549A.119C", "2013ARA&A..51..511K", "2013ApJ...764..184M", "2014ApJ...784...83D", "2015ApJ...808...79F", "2015ApJ...813...82R", "2015ApJS..220...12S", "2015MNRAS.452.1792Y", "2016ApJ...817...34M", "2016ApJ...821...72S", "2016ApJS..224...24L", "2016MNRAS.458.2288S", "2016MNRAS.461..647C", "2017A&A...608A..41C", "2017MNRAS.467.1929F", "2018ApJ...858...77H", "2018ApJ...869..113D", "2018PASJ...70S...4A", "2018PASJ...70S...8A", "2019A&A...622A.103B", "2019A&A...627A..88M", "2019ApJ...875...50B", "2019ApJ...876..155S", "2019ApJS..241...10K", "2019ApJS..243...21L", "2019PASJ...71..111I", "2020A&A...637A..84P", "2020ApJ...888...37D", "2020ApJ...889...32S", "2020ApJ...894...24K", "2020ApJS..249....3A", "2020MNRAS.496.3636G", "2020NatMe..17..261V", "2021ApJ...914...36I", "2022AJ....164..207D", "2022ApJS..258...11W", "2023ApJ...957L...3P", "2023ApJ...959...39H", "2023arXiv230801230M", "2024AJ....168...58D", "2024ApJ...964..154P" ]
29096796
2404.13956
Unraveling the kinematics of IZw18: A detailed study of ionized gas with MEGARA/GTC
This study offers an in-depth analysis of the kinematic behavior of ionized gas in IZw18, a galaxy notable for its extremely low metallicity and close proximity, utilizing data from MEGARA/GTC. We explored the structure and dynamics of the galaxy through Hα line profiles, applying single and double Gaussian component fittings to create detailed maps of the luminosity, velocity, and velocity dispersion in the main body (MB) and halo regions. Additionally, we retrieved integrated spectra from various galactic regions to achieve a higher signal-to-noise ratio. In the MB, a rotational pattern is evident, yet a secondary, more complex kinematic pattern emerges from the double-component fitting, which is further enriched by the identification of a very broad component. Distinguished by a full width at half maximum of nearly 2000 km s<SUP>−1</SUP> and a wide spatial extension, this component suggests a high-energy outflow and points toward large-scale, nonlocalized sources of high kinetic energy. Additionally, the observed significant velocity differences between the narrow and very broad components imply that these gases may occupy distinct spatial regions. This is potentially explained by high-density gas near the origin of the kinematic input, acting as a "wall" that reflects back the momentum of the gas. Regarding the halos, while the NE halo exhibits a tranquil state with low velocity dispersions, the SW halo presents higher velocities and more complex kinematics, indicative of diverse dynamic interactions. The identification of the very broad component across the MB and the high kinematic complexity in all regions of the galaxy points toward a scenario of widespread and subtle turbulent motion. This nuanced understanding of the kinematic behavior in IZw18, including the interplay of different gas components and the influence of internal structures, enhances our comprehension of the dynamics in blue compact dwarf galaxies. It may provide critical insights into early galaxy formation and the intricate kinematics characteristic of such environments.
[ 0.014628714881837368, 0.06849373131990433, -0.007490685675293207, 0.02502555213868618, -0.023027164861559868, 0.01656179502606392, -0.005769852548837662, 0.001218787394464016, -0.011409091763198376, 0.04561024159193039, -0.0012571552069857717, -0.00920825358480215, -0.03803465887904167, -0.01519035268574953, 0.022805120795965195, 0.05026008561253548, -0.01808997243642807, 0.0008489878964610398, -0.039157934486866, 0.04446084424853325, -0.03095540590584278, -0.026148827746510506, -0.028029661625623703, 0.026488423347473145, -0.05287235602736473, -0.0188605934381485, -0.004630249459296465, 0.00875763688236475, 0.011317661963403225, -0.03968038782477379, 0.026148827746510506, -0.014850758016109467, 0.004195959307253361, -0.06295572221279144, -0.08526451140642166, 0.06488879770040512, -0.025443514809012413, -0.0036963627208024263, -0.021995317190885544, -0.04493105411529541, 0.002120837103575468, 0.007111906539648771, -0.02196919545531273, 0.017541395500302315, 0.0175152737647295, -0.00964580848813057, -0.002163286553695798, -0.0188605934381485, 0.0010579695226624608, -0.02771618962287903, -0.07340480387210846, 0.03077254630625248, -0.020885102450847626, -0.02062387578189373, -0.013609929010272026, -0.011167456395924091, 0.024568403139710426, 0.0030155398417264223, -0.008300489746034145, -0.006537206936627626, -0.04406900331377983, -0.05882833153009415, 0.02680189535021782, 0.018403446301817894, -0.011285008862614632, 0.0031200305093079805, 0.0020963470451533794, -0.01861242763698101, 0.01311359740793705, 0.01086051482707262, 0.029779883101582527, -0.020989593118429184, -0.0054073999635875225, -0.0028588036075234413, 0.0003693913749884814, -0.03994161635637283, 0.006370674818754196, -0.058358121663331985, -0.04767393693327904, -0.006106182467192411, 0.016052402555942535, -0.00635108258575201, 0.045009419322013855, -0.021838581189513206, -0.017920175567269325, 0.016444243490695953, 0.03314971178770065, -0.014080137945711613, -0.018547119572758675, 0.025090858340263367, -0.0077192592434585094, 0.02340594306588173, -0.0334109403192997, -0.021956132724881172, 0.013276864774525166, -0.04879721254110336, 0.028630483895540237, -0.061127129942178726, 0.0585671029984951, 0.04255388677120209, 0.004453921224921942, 0.03547463193535805, 0.015464641153812408, -0.038348130881786346, 0.06462757289409637, -0.006870271172374487, -0.036101579666137695, 0.0006542921182699502, 0.03638892620801926, 0.011311131529510021, 0.060029976069927216, 0.009012333117425442, -0.008979680016636848, 0.033672165125608444, -0.018063850700855255, 0.006553533487021923, -0.041273873299360275, 0.04540126025676727, -0.023379821330308914, 0.011729094199836254, -0.00878375954926014, 0.028787219896912575, 0.006191080901771784, 0.010736431926488876, 0.0005408216384239495, -0.048875581473112106, -0.014916064217686653, -0.03014560230076313, -0.0423971489071846, 0.021890826523303986, 0.01124582439661026, 0.0020816531032323837, -0.017880991101264954, -0.018442628905177116, -0.03168684244155884, 0.007235989440232515, 0.015085862018167973, -0.003513503819704056, 0.017162617295980453, 0.02330145239830017, -0.018677733838558197, 0.03393339365720749, 0.05877608433365822, -0.030014988034963608, 0.020375709980726242, 0.0262271948158741, -0.03445584699511528, 0.014759328216314316, -0.023719416931271553, 0.022021440789103508, -0.012401754036545753, -0.010945413261651993, -0.009573970921337605, -0.10245324671268463, 0.001114296610467136, -0.017214862629771233, -0.0004983722465112805, -0.024006765335798264, -0.0017861399101093411, 0.00025224738055840135, -0.03312359005212784, 0.004943721927702427, -0.025926783680915833, 0.017541395500302315, -0.008777229115366936, -0.005240867845714092, -0.01799854449927807, 0.004254735540598631, -0.07100151479244232, -0.03722485527396202, -0.013740542344748974, -0.017972420901060104, -0.02852599322795868, -0.027481084689497948, 0.019735703244805336, 0.025391269475221634, -0.0048424964770674706, -0.041744083166122437, -0.02067612111568451, -0.0035396264865994453, 0.002808190882205963, 0.020780611783266068, -0.005355154629796743, -0.032418277114629745, -0.05412624403834343, 0.04252776503562927, -0.013316049240529537, 0.06034344807267189, -0.023810844868421555, 0.03354155272245407, -0.012427876703441143, 0.04853598400950432, 0.003627790603786707, 0.018011605367064476, -0.037642817944288254, -0.03244439885020256, 0.01121970172971487, 0.024999428540468216, -0.002243287395685911, 0.04082978889346123, 0.0493980348110199, -0.0045845345593988895, 0.037930168211460114, -0.059507522732019424, -0.07298683375120163, 0.03147786110639572, 0.015569131821393967, -0.01428911928087473, -0.0493980348110199, -0.019082635641098022, 0.027768434956669807, -0.008953557349741459, 0.009005802683532238, -0.02957090176641941, -0.02177327498793602, -0.023366758599877357, -0.05590258911252022, 0.0688072070479393, 0.039079565554857254, 0.03881834074854851, -0.04555799812078476, 0.03492605686187744, 0.003915140405297279, 0.01533402781933546, 0.01722792349755764, -0.020205913111567497, 0.020493261516094208, -0.03941916301846504, 0.007640891242772341, 0.013622990809381008, 0.039837125688791275, 0.016352813690900803, -0.044042881578207016, -0.030354583635926247, 0.00609965156763792, 0.012453999370336533, 0.0033355429768562317, 0.014981371350586414, 0.015817297622561455, -0.005508625414222479, -0.0015298109501600266, 0.0485098622739315, 0.03743383660912514, 0.02899620309472084, 0.006060467567294836, -0.005825363099575043, -0.0005244949134066701, -0.015751991420984268, 0.008542124181985855, -0.02081979624927044, 0.008790289983153343, -0.0049698445945978165, 0.003856364404782653, -0.04038570076227188, -0.0286566074937582, -0.01029234565794468, -0.02771618962287903, 0.0528201088309288, -0.025234533473849297, 0.049554772675037384, -0.028682729229331017, -0.013172374106943607, -0.04393839091062546, -0.006876802071928978, -0.025038613006472588, 0.04474819451570511, 0.02000999264419079, -0.00514617282897234, -0.016823021695017815, 0.01857324317097664, -0.017737315967679024, -0.03717260807752609, 0.030276214703917503, -0.026253318414092064, -0.07047905772924423, 0.05647728964686394, -0.01346625480800867, 0.022321851924061775, 0.033619921654462814, 0.006243326235562563, 0.010945413261651993, -0.022792059928178787, 0.024281054735183716, -0.013636051677167416, -0.04143061116337776, 0.05585034191608429, -0.01812915690243244, 0.025717802345752716, 0.0036833013873547316, -0.023223085328936577, 0.04736046493053436, -0.042135924100875854, -0.011147864162921906, -0.010018057189881802, -0.022217361256480217, -0.020127544179558754, 0.009391112253069878, 0.00047020867350511253, -0.013962585479021072, -0.0032555421348661184, 0.04474819451570511, 0.0005053110653534532, 0.04555799812078476, -0.015634438022971153, -0.047882918268442154, 0.015438518486917019, 0.06713534891605377, -0.015425457619130611, -0.029361920431256294, 0.050651926547288895, -0.005237602163106203, -0.003722485387697816, -0.0006200060597620904, 0.03038070537149906, -0.05757443979382515, -0.01837732270359993, -0.005309439729899168, 0.07021783292293549, 0.047151483595371246, -0.02229572832584381, -0.054335225373506546, -0.03286236152052879, -0.013002576306462288, -0.013871156610548496, -0.00156736234202981, -0.01929161697626114, 0.01340094767510891, -0.02181245945394039, -0.013936462812125683, -0.011493990197777748, 0.017306292429566383, -0.006138835567981005, 0.06478431075811386, -0.017149556428194046, 0.004427798558026552, -0.029492534697055817, 0.013622990809381008, 0.09116823971271515, -0.02631862461566925, 0.023719416931271553, -0.0005812302115373313, 0.005110254045575857, 0.00028571707662194967, 0.018050789833068848, -0.0029290083330124617, 0.02125081978738308, 0.04119550436735153, 0.022752875462174416, 0.005916792433708906, -0.005351888947188854, -0.0014016464119777083, -0.0028408442158252, 0.028891712427139282, -0.020036114379763603, 0.07319582253694534, -0.03832200914621353, 0.009547848254442215, -0.0569474957883358, -0.0218255203217268, 0.015660561621189117, 0.0175152737647295, 0.005694749765098095, 0.03698974847793579, 0.033515430986881256, 0.004362491890788078, 0.027167612686753273, -0.03688525781035423, 0.013962585479021072, -0.047203727066516876, -0.04020284116268158, 0.029257429763674736, 0.0005885771824978292, -0.03704199567437172, 0.017045065760612488, -0.04004610702395439, -0.01172256376594305, 0.045766979455947876, -0.000038724869227735326, 0.007209866773337126, 0.01533402781933546, 0.051461730152368546, 0.03105989657342434, 0.014419733546674252, -0.061283864080905914, 0.009240906685590744, 0.005926588550209999, -0.012826248072087765, -0.016196077689528465, -0.08657064288854599, 0.046446170657873154, 0.007484154775738716, -0.010416428558528423, -0.01261073537170887, 0.0015183822251856327, 0.00887518934905529, -0.031503982841968536, 0.019356925040483475, 0.04613269865512848, 0.021041838452219963, 0.030563564971089363, -0.03273174911737442, -0.03641505166888237, -0.06353041529655457, -0.021316127851605415, -0.015464641153812408, -0.010298876091837883, -0.018938960507512093, 0.0270370002835989, 0.018625488504767418, -0.01904345117509365, 0.04911068454384804, -0.00098694849293679, 0.02727210335433483, -0.025430453941226006, -0.010501326993107796, 0.015229537151753902, -0.05585034191608429, 0.052140917629003525, -0.040934279561042786, 0.04895395040512085, 0.00985479075461626, -0.02196919545531273, -0.032522767782211304, -0.03163459524512291, -0.022138992324471474, 0.025051673874258995, 0.03913181275129318, 0.013727481476962566, -0.0029714577831327915, -0.045819222927093506, -0.016013218089938164, 0.0393407940864563, -0.0037257508374750614, 0.007875995710492134, -0.021041838452219963, -0.024137379601597786, 0.017449967563152313, -0.011454805731773376, 0.00923437625169754, -0.019500598311424255, 0.02513004280626774, -0.01755445823073387, -0.000324084801832214, -0.019683457911014557, 0.0510176420211792, -0.00223675649613142, 0.035239528864622116, 0.017593640834093094, 0.010880106128752232, -0.04709923639893532, 0.024947183206677437, 0.03134724497795105, -0.016209138557314873, 0.006935578305274248, -0.0321570485830307, 0.0002487779420334846, 0.01225154846906662, -0.018364261835813522, 0.02042795531451702, -0.054962169378995895, -0.03163459524512291, 0.018651612102985382, -0.027872925624251366, 0.045584119856357574, -0.036101579666137695, 0.028055785223841667, -0.046968623995780945, -0.018912838771939278, 0.00928662158548832, 0.0072882347740232944, 0.01157888863235712, -0.016300568357110023, 0.001039193826727569, -0.010782146826386452, 0.03440360352396965, 0.009306213818490505, -0.01812915690243244, -0.007242519874125719, 0.0573132149875164, 0.026253318414092064, 0.0024930855724960566, -0.011141333729028702, 0.010416428558528423, 0.01631362922489643, 0.05020783841609955, 0.019409170374274254, -0.03450809419155121, 0.011500520631670952, -0.00677231140434742, -0.04111713916063309, -0.03244439885020256, -0.028865588828921318, 0.0761738047003746, -0.013636051677167416, 0.02857823856174946, -0.03111214190721512, -0.04819639027118683, -0.046968623995780945, -0.008496410213410854, 0.014158505946397781, 0.04913680627942085, -0.006129039451479912, 0.041378363966941833, 0.017214862629771233, -0.022021440789103508, 0.020114483311772346, -0.04947640374302864, -0.04775230586528778, -0.008496410213410854, 0.02306634932756424, -0.0011053169146180153, 0.014040953479707241, 0.017672009766101837, -0.0028800282161682844, 0.00769313657656312, 0.015869542956352234, 0.004610657226294279, -0.000008061303560680244, 0.014184628613293171, -0.030067233368754387, 0.005404134746640921, -0.00021857356477994472, 0.02383696846663952, -0.026331687346100807, 0.0005579646676778793, 0.0047804550267755985, 0.0077257901430130005, -0.08312244713306427, -0.022504709661006927, 0.015856482088565826, 0.01406707614660263, -0.019970808178186417, 0.017933236435055733, 0.011833584867417812, -0.006804964505136013, -0.038165271282196045, -0.033045221120119095, -0.0061518969014286995, 0.005916792433708906, -0.04686413332819939, 0.012806655839085579, -0.0038530989550054073, -0.005048212595283985, 0.01799854449927807, 0.028369257226586342, 0.038687724620103836, -0.009724176488816738, 0.009338866919279099, 0.03957589715719223, 0.04937191307544708, 0.014315241947770119, -0.013805849477648735, 0.044774316251277924, 0.0262271948158741, -0.002651454648002982, 0.0043984102085232735, 0.006671085953712463, 0.003190235234797001, 0.011539705097675323, -0.007875995710492134, -0.023340636864304543, -0.020349586382508278, -0.006204142235219479, 0.029414165765047073, -0.0015738930087536573, -0.05135723948478699, -0.004604126792401075, 0.000568985182326287, -0.02522147074341774, 0.049502525478601456, -0.0002728598192334175, 0.0004706168547272682, 0.022596139460802078, -0.004767393693327904, 0.009214784018695354, -0.024659832939505577, -0.024320237338542938, 0.008463756181299686, 0.010821330361068249, -0.031791333109140396, -0.04082978889346123, -0.015347088687121868, -0.0012473592069000006, 0.021224698051810265, -0.012297263368964195, -0.010932352393865585, 0.0032865628600120544, -0.005449849180877209, 0.013479315675795078, -0.007170682307332754, 0.018116096034646034, -0.017123432829976082, 0.013962585479021072, 0.013309517875313759, -0.0029143141582608223, 0.004052284639328718, 0.027350472286343575, -0.02637086994946003, -0.0184165071696043, -0.005358419846743345, -0.0024539015721529722, 0.0006236796034500003, -0.07194192707538605, -0.022165115922689438, -0.033802781254053116, 0.028081906959414482, 0.019304679706692696, -0.0284737478941679, -0.006373940035700798, 0.011010720394551754, -0.011010720394551754, 0.044957175850868225, -0.009247437119483948, -0.01986631751060486, -0.02383696846663952, 0.01875610277056694, -0.03800853714346886, -0.005103723611682653, 0.03398564085364342, 0.021185513585805893, 0.01713649369776249, -0.01746302843093872, 0.008267835713922977, -0.014171567745506763, 0.03422074392437935, 0.033045221120119095, -0.011996852234005928, -0.032705627381801605, -0.006514349486678839, -0.025051673874258995, 0.010102956555783749, -0.03228766471147537, 0.020663060247898102, -0.004956783261150122, 0.002101245103403926, -0.008235182613134384, -0.03038070537149906, 0.026632098481059074, -0.04158734530210495, -0.012205833569169044, 0.011781339533627033, -0.009097231552004814, 0.016431180760264397, -0.04119550436735153, 0.023758599534630775, 0.002016346203163266, 0.0016179750673472881, 0.01660097949206829, -0.03910569101572037, -0.013688297010958195, -0.0006551084807142615, -0.016104647889733315, 0.03740771487355232, 0.040803663432598114, 0.029414165765047073, -0.01242134626954794, 0.04741270840167999, -0.005381277296692133, -0.0528201088309288, 0.014994432218372822, 0.006426185369491577, 0.024098195135593414, 0.009534787386655807, 0.014093199744820595, -0.02321002259850502, 0.014628714881837368, -0.03398564085364342, 0.017724255099892616, -0.01660097949206829, 0.03134724497795105, 0.09163844585418701, -0.0069747623056173325, 0.0026906386483460665, 0.018220586702227592, 0.014249935746192932, 0.011376437731087208, 0.029649270698428154, -0.01631362922489643, -0.0528201088309288, 0.004241674207150936, 0.028917834162712097, 0.003722485387697816, -0.011598480865359306, 0.011598480865359306, -0.003676770720630884, -0.013557683676481247, 0.03560524806380272, 0.012231956236064434, 0.03239215537905693, -0.01660097949206829, 0.02502555213868618, -0.020872041583061218, 0.0284737478941679, 0.02985825203359127, 0.00007234764780150726, -0.03722485527396202, 0.009012333117425442, 0.0067788418382406235, 0.008195999078452587, -0.03153010457754135, 0.015320966020226479, 0.003689832054078579, 0.001422054716385901, -0.04511390998959541, -0.020401831716299057, -0.022478587925434113, 0.017724255099892616, -0.020401831716299057, 0.027637822553515434, -0.03871385008096695, 0.003028601175174117, 0.01289808563888073, -0.02894395776093006, 0.015490763820707798, -0.0008506205631420016, -0.02737659402191639, -0.0003926569188479334, 0.008182937279343605, -0.021067962050437927, -0.013596868142485619, -0.004822904244065285, 0.012460529804229736, -0.01641811989247799, -0.015869542956352234, 0.031608473509550095, -0.04150897637009621, -0.0023902275133877993, 0.03134724497795105, -0.008907842449843884, -0.025665557011961937, 0.037721186876297, 0.0064098588190972805, -0.02980600669980049, -0.04741270840167999, 0.01186623889952898, 0.0450877882540226, 0.004786985460668802, -0.031503982841968536, -0.010978066362440586, 0.020114483311772346, 0.012382161803543568, -0.01669240929186344, 0.005103723611682653, 0.010468673892319202, -0.007889056578278542, -0.0036310560535639524, 0.018246708437800407, 0.013250742107629776, 0.010501326993107796, -0.009965811856091022, 0.0061584278009831905, 0.011820523999631405, 0.01012254785746336, 0.015947911888360977, 0.016731591895222664, -0.024372484534978867, 0.02368023246526718, -0.03291460871696472, 0.03779955580830574, 0.013244211673736572, 0.022570017725229263, 0.04085591062903404, 0.004124122206121683, 0.016666285693645477, -0.03429911285638809, 0.03158235177397728, -0.02852599322795868, -0.0204802006483078, 0.023667169734835625, -0.010370713658630848, 0.023654108867049217, 0.017815684899687767, 0.023419005796313286, -0.01141562219709158, 0.050416819751262665, 0.01742384396493435, -0.0005706178490072489, 0.0029828862752765417, 0.012022974900901318, 0.015712806954979897, 0.00940417405217886, -0.016235260292887688, 0.006798434071242809, -0.041744083166122437, -0.0120360367000103, 0.021081022918224335, 0.015320966020226479, -0.03429911285638809, -0.0011665420606732368, -0.024333300068974495, -0.011239293962717056, 0.013949524611234665, 0.0020016522612422705, -0.0006685779662802815, -0.029988864436745644, 0.043572671711444855, -0.001964100869372487, -0.1126411035656929, -0.01076908502727747, 0.009214784018695354, 0.009587032720446587, -0.004192694090306759, 0.03309746831655502, 0.016352813690900803, 0.01670547015964985, -0.012819717638194561, -0.020741427317261696, 0.04613269865512848, -0.01923937164247036, -0.010102956555783749, 0.00652088038623333, 0.010259692557156086, 0.03228766471147537, -0.02445085160434246, -0.002186143770813942, -0.006249857135117054, 0.02392839826643467, -0.028552116826176643, 0.02268756926059723, -0.011611542664468288, -0.012800125405192375, -0.012297263368964195, -0.01340094767510891, -0.025064734742045403, -0.01731935329735279, 0.03785179927945137, -0.009267029352486134, -0.02526065520942211, -0.025874538347125053, 0.004316776990890503, 0.0397065095603466, -0.02842150256037712, -0.0018987940857186913, 0.001563280588015914, 0.031190508976578712, -0.04756944626569748, 0.010194385424256325, -0.00033143183100037277, -0.00048694355064071715, -0.008574778214097023, 0.03330644965171814, 0.05454420670866966, -0.006191080901771784, -0.0004551064921543002, 0.026579851284623146, 0.01895202323794365, -0.000021479801944224164, -0.008483348414301872, 0.02680189535021782, 0.032757870852947235, 0.01986631751060486, -0.04900619387626648, 0.0232622679322958, -0.01351850014179945, 0.007203335873782635, -0.023810844868421555, -0.01328339520841837, -0.013126659207046032, 0.011141333729028702, -0.004855557810515165, -0.02904844842851162, -0.04597596079111099, -0.013342171907424927, -0.021368373185396194, 0.02038877084851265, -0.0032783993519842625, -0.01189236156642437, -0.010488266125321388, 0.043520424515008926, 0.0012661349028348923, -0.010037649422883987, 0.010723370127379894, 0.0014016464119777083, -0.04856210947036743, 0.02358880266547203, -0.05888057500123978, 0.031373366713523865, -0.02771618962287903, -0.03800853714346886, 0.00417310232296586, -0.031791333109140396, 0.0025567596312612295, 0.03928854689002037, -0.0032261540181934834, -0.006759250070899725, 0.0021404291037470102, 0.023131655529141426, 0.013505438342690468, -0.014955248683691025, 0.01593484915792942, 0.012042567133903503, -0.029205184429883957, 0.00873151421546936, 0.002682475373148918, -0.02349737286567688, 0.01856018230319023, -0.023601863533258438, -0.013570745475590229, -0.012310324236750603, -0.010658063925802708, -0.034090131521224976, 0.03236602991819382, -0.0008244978962466121, -0.013224619440734386, 0.01875610277056694, 0.029832128435373306, 0.021551230922341347, 0.03779955580830574, 0.006798434071242809, -0.033567674458026886, 0.0048980070278048515, 0.017828745767474174, 0.002948600333184004, -0.009802545420825481, -0.026488423347473145, 0.0379040464758873, -0.02957090176641941, -0.014876880683004856, -0.0050873965956270695, -0.03307134285569191, -0.017489150166511536, 0.02813415229320526, 0.03173908591270447, -0.006968231406062841, -0.002006550319492817, -0.051461730152368546, 0.0075364005751907825, -0.0120817506685853, -0.007732320576906204, 0.020597752183675766, -0.02980600669980049, -0.03369829058647156, -0.009874382056295872, -0.021799396723508835, 0.020205913111567497, -0.005423726513981819, 0.04417349398136139, -0.005315970629453659, 0.0005836791824549437, 0.013159312307834625, 0.02292267419397831, -0.005740464199334383, -0.009874382056295872, 0.002217164495959878, -0.009469480253756046, 0.04571473225951195, -0.00724905077368021, 0.010873575694859028, -0.00811109971255064, 0.025443514809012413, 0.00553801329806447, -0.00543025741353631, -0.012264610268175602, 0.00517882639542222, 0.01253889873623848, -0.007379664108157158, 0.056686270982027054, 0.046211063861846924, 0.020597752183675766, 0.002718393923714757, -0.0062857759185135365, -0.024241870269179344, 0.020649997517466545, -0.02588760107755661, 0.009273559786379337, -0.02277899906039238, -0.001145317335613072, -0.013120128773152828, -0.04550575092434883, 0.02904844842851162, -0.0062857759185135365, -0.00964580848813057, 0.03829588368535042, -0.0007812321418896317, -0.04746495559811592, 0.037303224205970764, 0.02996274270117283, -0.0002800027432385832, 0.001139602973125875, -0.04699474573135376, -0.01627444475889206, 0.047778427600860596, 0.01846875250339508, -0.025770047679543495, -0.0062759798020124435, 0.005792709998786449, 0.016535671427845955, -0.011591950431466103, 0.03779955580830574, -0.027219858020544052, 0.018886715173721313, 0.004431063774973154, 0.026475360617041588, -0.01857324317097664, 0.02761169895529747, -0.02354961819946766, 0.0033894209191203117, 0.001681649126112461, -0.028787219896912575, 0.0225438941270113, -0.02761169895529747, 0.01555607095360756, 0.02243940345942974, -0.006031079683452845, -0.022099807858467102, -0.04540126025676727, 0.0009028660133481026, 0.02766394428908825, 0.0029126815497875214, 0.0307203009724617, 0.0047837202437222, 0.03014560230076313, -0.02340594306588173, 0.03612770140171051, -0.02933579683303833, -0.0188605934381485, -0.04106489196419716, 0.037642817944288254, -0.03142561390995979, 0.03019784763455391, 0.0393407940864563, 0.012865432538092136, 0.045584119856357574, -0.04229265823960304, 0.014432794414460659, -0.007980486378073692, 0.0010228671599179506, 0.010253162123262882, 0.026383932679891586, -0.018338138237595558, -0.035814229398965836, -0.03991549462080002, -0.003418809035792947, -0.014419733546674252, 0.02455534227192402, -0.019265495240688324, -0.004346164874732494, 0.03625831380486488, 0.021211637184023857, 0.02526065520942211, 0.018220586702227592, -0.0284737478941679, -0.030093355104327202, 0.033855024725198746, -0.025952907279133797, 0.003136357292532921, 0.011827054433524609, -0.014876880683004856, 0.0211985744535923, -0.028682729229331017, -0.005302909296005964, -0.010664594359695911, 0.005600054748356342, -0.031895823776721954, 0.011964199133217335, -0.017018942162394524, -0.02565249614417553, 0.011082557961344719, -0.023288391530513763, -0.001996754202991724, -0.05376052483916283, 0.007379664108157158, 0.02779455855488777, -0.04764781519770622, -0.001735527184791863, 0.016300568357110023, 0.006674351170659065, 0.012140527367591858, -0.022752875462174416, 0.019448352977633476, 0.01184011623263359, -0.002257981337606907, -0.009201723150908947, -0.005936384666711092, 0.006935578305274248, 0.004832700360566378, 0.030850915238261223, -0.0017110371263697743, -0.019970808178186417, -0.0023347167298197746, -0.002132265828549862, 0.013172374106943607, -0.0007375582354143262, -0.013583806343376637, -0.001108582247979939, 0.0028685994911938906, -0.005619646981358528, 0.008045793510973454, -0.004747801460325718, 0.03038070537149906, 0.006230264902114868, 0.009534787386655807, -0.009521725587546825, -0.0010114384349435568, -0.0035722798202186823, 0.006684147287160158, -0.010187854990363121, -0.0291006937623024, 0.002777170157060027, 0.020649997517466545, -0.03497830033302307, -0.029257429763674736, -0.024137379601597786, -0.00878375954926014, -0.011330722831189632, -0.0268541406840086, 0.01062540989369154, 0.002478391630575061, -0.005459645297378302, 0.004496370442211628, 0.01669240929186344, 0.026619035750627518, -0.011709502898156643, -0.010814799927175045, 0.014876880683004856, 0.04263225570321083, -0.008189467713236809, -0.03631056100130081, -0.0042188167572021484, 0.02177327498793602, -0.001263685873709619, -0.017789561301469803, -0.00543025741353631, -0.013714419677853584, -0.002653087256476283, 0.0028604362159967422, 0.024581465870141983, 0.01124582439661026, 0.03186969831585884, 0.008790289983153343, -0.02631862461566925, -0.02899620309472084, 0.010827860794961452, 0.03458645939826965, 0.02593984641134739, 0.01713649369776249, 0.013067883439362049, 0.012349508702754974, 0.009658870287239552, -0.042475517839193344, -0.01115439459681511, 0.01708424836397171, -0.0001082663657143712, -0.0016849144594743848, -0.002068591769784689, -0.014772390015423298, -0.008176406845450401, 0.06885945051908493, -0.022883489727973938, 0.035683613270521164, -0.044147372245788574, 0.027820680290460587, -0.0005620463052764535, 0.0029845191165804863, 0.044486965984106064, 0.0015240965876728296, 0.015921788290143013, 0.009600093588232994, -0.01026622299104929, 0.0036179947201162577, 0.0019869583193212748, 0.031660716980695724, -0.011670318432152271, -0.00309227523393929, 0.030354583635926247, -0.019108759239315987, 0.016640162095427513, 0.017018942162394524, 0.012440938502550125, -0.02795129455626011, 0.016783837229013443, -0.03456033766269684, -0.041848573833703995, 0.017449967563152313, 0.015438518486917019, -0.010853983461856842, 0.018351200968027115, -0.00990703608840704, -0.02642311528325081, -0.006380470469594002, -0.022021440789103508, -0.0021910418290644884, 0.027219858020544052, 0.013818911276757717, -0.009397642686963081, 0.018965084105730057, 0.014080137945711613, 0.040176719427108765, 0.02267450839281082, -0.002987784333527088, 0.0010163364931941032, -0.004195959307253361, -0.004881680477410555, 0.005701280198991299, 0.03111214190721512, 0.0016277710674330592, -0.011115211062133312, -0.025861477479338646, 0.0073339492082595825, 0.028029661625623703, 0.016979757696390152, 0.03145173564553261, -0.009476011618971825, 0.027768434956669807, 0.04030733183026314, -0.016901390627026558, -0.03432523459196091, -0.031321123242378235, -0.03317583352327347, -0.04453921318054199, 0.019657336175441742, 0.043102461844682693, -0.016640162095427513, 0.005201683379709721, 0.009182130917906761, 0.017737315967679024, -0.011585419997572899, -0.017005881294608116, 0.007673544343560934, -0.007327418774366379, 0.02784680388867855, -0.029753761366009712, -0.016248323023319244, 0.0028245174326002598, 0.020649997517466545, -0.006426185369491577, -0.002091448986902833, -0.010775615461170673, -0.025090858340263367, -0.013858094811439514, 0.038975074887275696, -0.057835668325424194, 0.0007183743873611093, 0.006050671450793743, -0.019931623712182045, -0.016378935426473618, 0.02058469131588936, -0.016104647889733315, 0.003237582743167877, -0.01157888863235712, 0.018338138237595558, 0.028839467093348503, -0.0031330918427556753, -0.0020424691028892994, 0.0034318703692406416, 0.016836082562804222, 0.00528658227995038, -0.029727637767791748, 0.0348476879298687, 0.017345476895570755, -0.02737659402191639, 0.023249207064509392, 0.006514349486678839, -0.011206639930605888, -0.045479629188776016, 0.008463756181299686, 0.0029404370579868555, 0.027481084689497948, 0.03014560230076313, 0.014145445078611374, -0.012689104303717613, 0.006981292739510536, 0.02646229974925518, 0.019552845507860184, -0.031033772975206375, -0.024894937872886658, -0.010200915858149529, 0.02818639948964119, -0.019774887710809708, 0.014001769945025444, -0.010200915858149529, -0.0014661367749795318, -0.031948067247867584, 0.005635973531752825, -0.00988091342151165, -0.023001041263341904, -0.008581308647990227, -0.03168684244155884, 0.006142100784927607, 0.014093199744820595, 0.013727481476962566, 0.006844148505479097, 0.003898813622072339, 0.02267450839281082, -0.0120360367000103, 0.016091587021946907, 0.014132383279502392, 0.019578967243433, -0.016522610560059547, -0.029492534697055817, -0.03236602991819382, 0.02980600669980049, -0.012009913101792336, -0.011500520631670952, 0.0041633062064647675, 0.04618494212627411, 0.006889863405376673, -0.012532367371022701, 0.0014865451958030462, -0.006073528900742531, 0.013753604143857956, -0.03651954233646393, -0.016196077689528465, -0.04244939610362053, -0.004679229576140642, -0.00027000263798981905, -0.004803312476724386, -0.005247398279607296, 0.009005802683532238, -0.03641505166888237, -0.006037610117346048, 0.03406400606036186, -0.01298951543867588, 0.002560025081038475, -0.005433522630482912, -0.009364989586174488, 0.010018057189881802, -0.015125046484172344, -0.003895548405125737, 0.017097311094403267, -0.0006118427263572812, -0.03829588368535042, -0.018050789833068848, 0.02737659402191639, 0.023954520002007484, -0.02779455855488777, 0.017214862629771233, -0.00397065095603466, -0.0425800085067749, 0.003986977972090244, -0.02430717647075653, 0.009528256952762604, -0.01938304677605629, 0.0005604136385954916, 0.008986210450530052, 0.05647728964686394, -0.011448275297880173, 0.013074413873255253, -0.019056513905525208, 0.018298955634236336, 0.004496370442211628, 0.023575741797685623, 0.03800853714346886, -0.033228080719709396, 0.006831087172031403, 0.0067788418382406235, 0.029779883101582527, -0.006915986072272062, -0.029701516032218933, 0.008809882216155529, 0.0025159430224448442, -0.011285008862614632, 0.02813415229320526, -0.013270334340631962, 0.02737659402191639, -0.005002498161047697, 0.005420461297035217, -0.022478587925434113, -0.01889977790415287, 0.0020016522612422705, -0.007360071875154972, 0.02464677207171917, 0.014014830812811852, -0.018834469839930534, 0.030041109770536423, 0.0025241062976419926, 0.004796781577169895, 0.036780767142772675, 0.016496488824486732, -0.014720143750309944, -0.01533402781933546, -0.016444243490695953, -0.000034821769077098, 0.0013461356284096837, -0.0202973410487175, 0.02565249614417553, 0.011324192397296429, -0.007797627244144678, -0.027063122019171715, -0.0010163364931941032, -0.023523496463894844, -0.0035102383699268103, 0.0064033279195427895, -0.025391269475221634, 0.00020010399748571217, -0.013727481476962566, 0.014302181079983711, -0.00024387994199059904, -0.0010612348560243845, 0.027872925624251366, 0.03474319726228714, 0.009195191785693169, 0.03550075739622116, 0.012271140702068806, -0.007960894145071507, -0.022478587925434113, 0.006145366467535496, -0.027298226952552795, 0.032992977648973465, -0.0116311339661479, 0.0006710269954055548, -0.004607392009347677, -0.009044986218214035, 0.026906386017799377, -0.050129469484090805, -0.03147786110639572, 0.03573586046695709, -0.027533330023288727, 0.01660097949206829, 0.058462612330913544, 0.01354462280869484, 0.026671281084418297, 0.011526643298566341, -0.024620648473501205, 0.0007432725979015231, 0.00887518934905529, -0.016979757696390152, 0.0000709700834704563, -0.03403788432478905, -0.02166878432035446, -0.015085862018167973, 0.023902274668216705, 0.01785486936569214, -0.012186242267489433, -0.019931623712182045, 0.02349737286567688, 0.008724983781576157, 0.014485039748251438, 0.000305717287119478, 0.028081906959414482, -0.010984597727656364, -0.026279442012310028, -0.03860935941338539, -0.004326573107391596, 0.007072722539305687, -0.026449238881468773, 0.02985825203359127, 0.01654873415827751, 0.013035229407250881, 0.018050789833068848, -0.035056669265031815, 0.0029094163328409195, -0.0017061391845345497, -0.006955170072615147, -0.012649919837713242, 0.03565749153494835, -0.007484154775738716, 0.000042500414565438405, -0.004176367539912462, -0.03239215537905693, -0.04106489196419716, 0.00010704186570364982, -0.00943029671907425, -0.0095674404874444, -0.0034873811528086662, 0.021838581189513206, -0.00825477484613657, 0.018586304038763046, 0.010788677260279655, -0.017632825300097466, 0.010344590991735458, 0.011670318432152271, -0.003333910135552287, 0.011252354830503464, 0.051461730152368546, 0.024516157805919647, 0.019657336175441742, -0.014720143750309944, 0.03095540590584278, 0.04088203236460686, -0.009332336485385895, 0.049319665879011154, -0.012499714270234108, 0.00920825358480215, 0.031608473509550095, 0.008104569278657436, 0.04255388677120209, 0.014615653082728386, -0.03445584699511528, 0.0334109403192997, -0.0036114640533924103, -0.01999692991375923, -0.01083439216017723, 0.0084441639482975, 0.019513661041855812, -0.0012057260610163212, -0.04393839091062546, -0.015595254488289356, -0.01756751909852028, 0.014811573550105095, -0.020558569580316544, -0.04030733183026314, 0.01990550197660923, -0.013675236143171787, -0.011258886195719242, 0.018847530707716942, -0.04020284116268158, 0.012382161803543568, -0.01857324317097664, -0.04169183596968651, -0.03631056100130081, 0.005688218865543604, 0.00796742457896471, 0.024712078273296356, 0.0012628695694729686, 0.011820523999631405, -0.016731591895222664, -0.04694250226020813, 0.00486861914396286, 0.0000012149354233770282, 0.01942223124206066, -0.023941459134221077, 0.005475971847772598, 0.02215205319225788, 0.016483426094055176, 0.013107066974043846, 0.01550382561981678, 0.023967580869793892, 0.03168684244155884, -0.0020179790444672108, -0.020545506849884987, -0.026305563747882843, -0.061754073947668076, 0.015451580286026001, 0.011480928398668766, 0.01818140223622322, -0.0007636809605173767, 0.04461757838726044, -0.010351121425628662, 0.0011518480023369193, 0.0039053442887961864, 0.03163459524512291, -0.008790289983153343, -0.01914794184267521, 0.016587916761636734, -0.0008375592296943069 ]
11.913901
8.049339
2024-07-01
0
2024A&A...687A..77A
[ "higher velocities", "different gas components", "low velocity dispersions", "high kinetic energy", "early galaxy formation", "velocity dispersion", "halo regions", "blue compact dwarf galaxies", "ionized gas", "velocity" ]
[ "ISM: kinematics and dynamics", "galaxies: evolution", "galaxies: kinematics and dynamics", "galaxies: starburst", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
52
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202449606", "10.48550/arXiv.2404.13956" ]
[ "Arroyo-Polonio, A.", "Kehrig, C.", "Iglesias-Páramo, J.", "Vílchez, J. M.", "Pérez-Montero, E.", "Duarte Puertas, S.", "Gallego, J.", "Reverte, D.", "Cabrera-Lavers, A." ]
[ "Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucía, CSIC, Apartado de correos 3004, 18080, Granada, Spain", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucía, CSIC, Apartado de correos 3004, 18080, Granada, Spain", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucía, CSIC, Apartado de correos 3004, 18080, Granada, Spain; Centro Astronómico Hispano en Andalucía, Observatorio de Calar Alto, Sierra de los Filabres, 04550, Gérgal, Spain", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucía, CSIC, Apartado de correos 3004, 18080, Granada, Spain", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucía, CSIC, Apartado de correos 3004, 18080, Granada, Spain", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucía, CSIC, Apartado de correos 3004, 18080, Granada, Spain; Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Universidad de Granada, Granada, Spain", "Departamento de Física de la Tierra y Astrofísica, Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Madrid, Spain", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias, C/ Vía Láctea s/n, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias, C/ Vía Láctea s/n, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain" ]
null
[ "1981ApJ...247..823T", "1989AJ.....97.1591D", "1990ApJ...350..149D", "1992A&A...260...58P", "1995Ap.....38..335P", "1996ApJ...465..680M", "1996ApJ...471L..87D", "1997A&A...318..390P", "1997A&A...326L..17L", "1998AJ....115.1000V", "1998ApJ...508..248V", "1999ApJ...511..639I", "2000A&A...354..504L", "2006MNRAS.368...65E", "2007ApJ...667L.151A", "2007AstL...33..137T", "2008RMxAA..44..181G", "2011ApJ...739...74C", "2012A&A...537A..72L", "2012A&A...537A.126P", "2012ApJ...754L..22A", "2015ApJ...801L..28K", "2015MNRAS.451.3001T", "2016MNRAS.459.2992K", "2016SPIE.9908E..1KG", "2017A&A...602A..45L", "2017ApJ...834..181O", "2019MNRAS.489.1787B", "2019hsax.conf..227P", "2020MNRAS.494.3541H", "2021ApJ...911L..17R", "2023ApJ...951..102I", "2023arXiv230403726H", "2024ApJ...961...49X" ]
29096772
2404.03300
MusE GAs FLOw and Wind (MEGAFLOW). XI. Scaling relations between outflows and host galaxy properties
Absorption line spectroscopy using background quasars can provide strong constraints on galactic outflows. In this paper we investigate possible scaling relations between outflow properties, namely outflow velocity V<SUB>out</SUB>, mass ejection rate Ṁ<SUB>out</SUB>, and mass loading factor η, and the host galaxy properties, such as star formation rate (SFR), SFR surface density, redshift, and stellar mass, using galactic outflows probed by background quasars from MEGAFLOW and other surveys. We find that V<SUB>out</SUB> (η) is (anti-)correlated with SFR and SFR surface density. We extend the formalism of momentum-driven outflows from a previous study to show that it applies not only to "down-the-barrel" studies, but also to winds probed by background quasars, suggesting a possible universal wind formalism. Under this formalism, we find a clear distinction between strong and weak outflows where strong outflows seem to have tighter correlations with galaxy properties (SFR or galaxy stellar mass) than weak outflows. <P />Based on observations made at the ESO telescopes at La Silla Paranal Observatory under program IDs 094.A-0211(B), 095.A-0365(A), 096.A-0164(A), 097.A-0138(A), 099.A-0059(A), 096.A-0609(A), 097.A-0144(A), 098.A-0310(A), 293.A-5038(A).
[ 0.025117143988609314, 0.04626455157995224, 0.004370995331555605, -0.005727933719754219, -0.013220193795859814, 0.04452472925186157, 0.011302714236080647, -0.03362021595239639, -0.002041533589363098, 0.028449758887290955, -0.03810454532504082, 0.029086876660585403, -0.07861053198575974, 0.03915823996067047, 0.03374273702502251, 0.009060549549758434, 0.009930460713803768, 0.026146333664655685, 0.00804973766207695, 0.04837194085121155, 0.00011046182771679014, -0.03134129196405411, -0.043544549494981766, 0.05699753761291504, -0.07856152206659317, -0.03746742755174637, 0.003231534967198968, 0.028645794838666916, 0.0291603896766901, -0.046411581337451935, 0.019971191883087158, -0.02896435372531414, -0.008809378370642662, -0.02451678179204464, -0.058908890932798386, 0.10291902720928192, -0.03719787672162056, -0.009599649347364902, -0.03119426593184471, -0.013857311569154263, -0.013171184808015823, 0.012681093998253345, -0.000973289308603853, 0.04572545364499092, 0.004729374311864376, -0.015584881417453289, -0.010941272601485252, -0.02999354526400566, 0.00508775282651186, -0.03210093453526497, -0.031414806842803955, 0.008288657292723656, -0.0056544202379882336, -0.026881469413638115, 0.0008622531313449144, -0.015401097014546394, -0.010383794084191322, 0.008166134357452393, -0.006671358365565538, -0.0008293251739814878, -0.0005582438316196203, -0.01934632658958435, 0.01785155013203621, 0.026685433462262154, -0.04680365324020386, 0.01710416190326214, 0.02349984459578991, 0.008117125369608402, 0.005825952161103487, -0.005032617598772049, -0.0014557222602888942, -0.0017459477530792356, 0.021049391478300095, -0.0214659683406353, 0.025852279737591743, -0.053615912795066833, 0.031169762834906578, -0.008025233633816242, -0.027371559292078018, 0.002458110684528947, 0.05876186117529869, 0.004842707887291908, 0.019922181963920593, -0.013710284605622292, -0.031316790729761124, 0.016797855496406555, 0.00544000556692481, -0.005746312439441681, -0.03491895645856857, -0.007633161265403032, -0.001992524601519108, 0.00016626706928946078, -0.01638127863407135, -0.007118565961718559, 0.010383794084191322, 0.0002992232912220061, 0.06611321866512299, -0.05905591696500778, 0.04320148751139641, 0.04545590281486511, 0.010984155349433422, 0.014420915395021439, 0.022887231782078743, -0.07282746583223343, 0.04712221026420593, -0.024676062166690826, -0.01007748767733574, -0.00926271267235279, 0.03016507625579834, -0.02609732374548912, 0.05513519048690796, -0.0019113533198833466, 0.006959286518394947, 0.050479330122470856, -0.04935212433338165, -0.011461993679404259, -0.04445121809840202, -0.007302349898964167, -0.03665877506136894, 0.014874249696731567, 0.0035500938538461924, 0.02240939252078533, 0.029013363644480705, 0.020792093127965927, 0.0034796432591974735, 0.03624219819903374, -0.015768665820360184, -0.02147822082042694, -0.0761110708117485, -0.0036603640764951706, 0.06018312647938728, -0.01821911707520485, 0.004067752044647932, -0.03893769904971123, -0.003473517019301653, -0.002089011250063777, 0.023842908442020416, -0.04457373917102814, 0.008987036533653736, 0.023806151002645493, -0.015989204868674278, 0.024553539231419563, 0.015094790607690811, 0.02813120000064373, 0.035213008522987366, 0.0333261601626873, -0.04971969127655029, -0.01905227266252041, 0.02776363305747509, -0.023205790668725967, -0.012877130880951881, 0.014065600000321865, -0.019762903451919556, -0.05346888303756714, 0.00005221570609137416, -0.007057304494082928, -0.010555326007306576, -0.01012649666517973, 0.020522544160485268, -0.01518055610358715, -0.025141647085547447, 0.014935511164367199, -0.033914268016815186, -0.02592579275369644, -0.009765055030584335, 0.019101280719041824, -0.012681093998253345, -0.027641110122203827, -0.06518205255270004, -0.049548160284757614, -0.009532262571156025, 0.018905244767665863, -0.013918573036789894, -0.05199861153960228, 0.04016292467713356, 0.027739128097891808, 0.011216948740184307, -0.03202741965651512, -0.014237131923437119, 0.005752438213676214, -0.014604699797928333, 0.04231932386755943, 0.02193155512213707, -0.031684357672929764, -0.007155322935432196, 0.022544167935848236, -0.021539481356739998, 0.050479330122470856, 0.017153171822428703, -0.030949221923947334, 0.011308840475976467, 0.004098382778465748, 0.003197841113433242, 0.031708862632513046, -0.045676443725824356, -0.027445074170827866, -0.00760865630581975, 0.04626455157995224, -0.041780222207307816, 0.016087224707007408, 0.028743812814354897, 0.03805553540587425, 0.03616868704557419, -0.06738745421171188, -0.03327715024352074, -0.046779148280620575, 0.0010445056250318885, 0.0018883803859353065, -0.012111363932490349, 0.02516615204513073, 0.030459130182862282, 0.02258092351257801, -0.020338760688900948, 0.04185373708605766, -0.031880393624305725, -0.015376592054963112, -0.01989767886698246, 0.05969303473830223, 0.062339525669813156, 0.010549199767410755, -0.0334731861948967, 0.0256317388266325, 0.006891898810863495, 0.01888073980808258, 0.03357120603322983, 0.010653343982994556, 0.048273924738168716, -0.05322383716702461, 0.009366856887936592, -0.0717492625117302, 0.004211715888231993, 0.02293623983860016, -0.036046162247657776, -0.010279649868607521, 0.001764326123520732, -0.01439641136676073, -0.015094790607690811, 0.037785984575748444, -0.009820190258324146, -0.048151399940252304, -0.012423796579241753, 0.031071742996573448, -0.002519371919333935, -0.012938391417264938, 0.0038257697597146034, 0.022899482399225235, -0.014065600000321865, -0.015009024180471897, -0.008068116381764412, 0.0022421644534915686, 0.03146381676197052, 0.004594599362462759, -0.018488667905330658, -0.019640380516648293, -0.0010958119528368115, -0.04609302058815956, -0.03072868101298809, 0.010751362890005112, -0.01841515488922596, -0.005905591882765293, -0.01088001113384962, -0.050479330122470856, -0.012319652363657951, 0.07277845591306686, 0.010757488198578358, 0.03315462917089462, 0.0031855888664722443, 0.03893769904971123, -0.034379854798316956, 0.0061445110477507114, -0.0028624352999031544, -0.016822360455989838, 0.030606158077716827, -0.01693263091146946, -0.04638707637786865, 0.05822276324033737, 0.014886502176523209, 0.024112457409501076, 0.010965777561068535, -0.0006665997789241374, 0.014188122935593128, -0.022519662976264954, 0.038619138300418854, 0.023095520213246346, -0.0022789211943745613, -0.02063281461596489, 0.001804145984351635, 0.04065301641821861, -0.004619103856384754, 0.010365416295826435, 0.07939467579126358, -0.01971389353275299, -0.0033816250506788492, -0.0052378433756530285, 0.017459478229284286, -0.025680746883153915, 0.005770816933363676, 0.030116066336631775, -0.010328659787774086, 0.02702849730849266, 0.019738398492336273, 0.030655166134238243, 0.07184728235006332, 0.0357276052236557, -0.0032131564803421497, 0.018072091042995453, 0.06052618846297264, 0.014445420354604721, -0.014665961265563965, 0.05033230409026146, 0.026244351640343666, 0.030385617166757584, 0.019199298694729805, 0.027886154130101204, -0.06748547405004501, -0.0033203638158738613, -0.0321989506483078, 0.07861053198575974, 0.05699753761291504, -0.055282220244407654, -0.00915856845676899, 0.0123564088717103, 0.01212361641228199, -0.01851317286491394, 0.00855208095163107, -0.04227031394839287, -0.007718926761299372, 0.00034344629966653883, -0.026905974373221397, 0.0173001978546381, 0.020130470395088196, -0.03357120603322983, 0.027910659089684486, 0.011970463208854198, -0.012227760627865791, -0.01443316787481308, 0.01448217686265707, 0.07910062372684479, 0.0043771215714514256, -0.012031723745167255, -0.0388396792113781, 0.016810107976198196, -0.01961587555706501, -0.027077505365014076, 0.003073787083849311, 0.0002475340443197638, 0.0273960642516613, 0.009918208234012127, 0.061947450041770935, -0.015229565091431141, 0.005366492085158825, 0.026856964454054832, 0.007014421746134758, 0.016332268714904785, 0.08654999732971191, -0.023475339636206627, -0.005452258046716452, -0.08753018081188202, -0.03785949945449829, 0.014188122935593128, -0.00870523415505886, -0.021220922470092773, -0.0006600907654501498, -0.0069531602784991264, -0.036683280020952225, 0.0007918025949038565, 0.005599285010248423, 0.024578044191002846, -0.0173001978546381, -0.061751414090394974, 0.03202741965651512, 0.014849744737148285, 0.0025714440271258354, -0.019505605101585388, -0.08052188158035278, -0.02211533859372139, -0.0026663991156965494, -0.003672616323456168, -0.008282531052827835, 0.013269202783703804, 0.03805553540587425, 0.045578423887491226, -0.0333261601626873, -0.011321092955768108, -0.0033693728037178516, -0.005666672717779875, -0.019211551174521446, -0.020608309656381607, -0.04665662348270416, 0.02183353528380394, -0.007620908785611391, 0.03202741965651512, -0.007547395303845406, 0.027249036356806755, 0.012423796579241753, -0.00717370118945837, 0.0653780847787857, 0.06155537813901901, 0.00756577355787158, -0.00568811409175396, -0.00469874357804656, -0.011339470744132996, -0.02896435372531414, -0.0032744177151471376, -0.03232147544622421, 0.0005107662873342633, -0.019272813573479652, -0.0034000035375356674, 0.016859116032719612, -0.01896650530397892, 0.023928673937916756, -0.009740551002323627, 0.03393877297639847, 0.010261272080242634, 0.013538752682507038, 0.006025051232427359, -0.04523536190390587, 0.048715006560087204, -0.007535142824053764, 0.057193573564291, 0.03675679489970207, 0.005703429225832224, 0.011088299565017223, 0.03670778498053551, -0.004312797449529171, -0.0074126203544437885, 0.032247960567474365, 0.016442539170384407, -0.00574018619954586, -0.06895574927330017, -0.016908125951886177, 0.019738398492336273, 0.021220922470092773, 0.007179827429354191, -0.030851203948259354, -0.007774061989039183, 0.023720385506749153, -0.0020522542763501406, 0.029086876660585403, -0.013036410324275494, 0.039011210203170776, -0.021514976397156715, 0.034012287855148315, -0.04258887469768524, 0.04080004245042801, -0.03295859321951866, 0.032885078340768814, 0.023169033229351044, -0.0050938790664076805, -0.046313561499118805, -0.008221269585192204, -0.01728794537484646, -0.01563389040529728, 0.00677550258114934, -0.021245427429676056, -0.02673444151878357, 0.005360365845263004, -0.020657319575548172, 0.017692269757390022, -0.05155752971768379, -0.013195689767599106, -0.02879282273352146, -0.05018527805805206, 0.02046128176152706, -0.0012880193535238504, 0.03536003828048706, 0.014653708785772324, -0.009232081472873688, 0.007100187707692385, 0.023389574140310287, 0.043078962713479996, -0.05562528222799301, 0.012583076022565365, -0.01008361391723156, 0.0011432894971221685, -0.010543073527514935, -0.039550311863422394, -0.02950345352292061, 0.053811948746442795, 0.03766346350312233, 0.06106529012322426, 0.019089028239250183, -0.028449758887290955, 0.017091909423470497, 0.01378379762172699, 0.01916254311800003, 0.007112439721822739, 0.02590128779411316, -0.03433084487915039, -0.01787605509161949, -0.03327715024352074, -0.012540193274617195, 0.05327284708619118, -0.011504876427352428, 0.017434973269701004, -0.022421645000576973, 0.0047691939398646355, -0.01638127863407135, -0.012754607945680618, -0.0027062189765274525, 0.06606421619653702, -0.007302349898964167, 0.05008725821971893, -0.004873338155448437, 0.032885078340768814, 0.01794956810772419, -0.03930526599287987, -0.022544167935848236, -0.011308840475976467, -0.023352816700935364, -0.019027767702937126, 0.011125057004392147, -0.02017948031425476, 0.0011532444041222334, 0.005960727110505104, -0.013624518178403378, -0.01230127364397049, 0.03136579692363739, -0.0017444161931052804, -0.027053000405430794, 0.002291173441335559, -0.030140571296215057, -0.01069010142236948, 0.022078581154346466, 0.014028843492269516, -0.01628326065838337, -0.02996904030442238, -0.07900260388851166, -0.01013874914497137, -0.02962597645819187, 0.012325778603553772, -0.03849661722779274, -0.011339470744132996, -0.005773880053311586, -0.004367932677268982, -0.016136232763528824, -0.02155173383653164, -0.03264003247022629, -0.0006164420628920197, -0.02656291052699089, -0.0013125238474458456, 0.00028965118690393865, -0.019505605101585388, 0.016332268714904785, 0.018856234848499298, 0.05341987684369087, 0.009856946766376495, 0.005645230878144503, 0.02293623983860016, 0.0029267598874866962, -0.012338031083345413, 0.016540557146072388, -0.00005647528450936079, 0.014960015192627907, -0.01592794433236122, 0.008368296548724174, 0.006015861872583628, 0.008392801508307457, -0.01592794433236122, 0.014163617976009846, -0.011909201741218567, -0.008368296548724174, -0.0013209473108872771, 0.0023585609160363674, 0.016234250739216805, -0.03009156323969364, -0.01941983960568905, -0.028915345668792725, -0.01374704111367464, 0.03415931388735771, -0.011651904322206974, -0.009679289534687996, 0.03264003247022629, 0.003528652247041464, 0.0009426586329936981, -0.028376245871186256, -0.015401097014546394, 0.024357503280043602, 0.00865622516721487, -0.04763680696487427, -0.030875707045197487, -0.005660546477884054, 0.005522708408534527, 0.0099917221814394, -0.04624004662036896, -0.011621273122727871, 0.03295859321951866, -0.008135504089295864, 0.01235028263181448, 0.004337301943451166, -0.00343676027841866, -0.036609768867492676, -0.016344521194696426, 0.014861997216939926, 0.009758928790688515, 0.014714970253407955, 0.028915345668792725, 0.02332831174135208, -0.0059454115107655525, -0.00864397268742323, 0.008074242621660233, -0.04959717020392418, -0.02599930576980114, -0.015670645982027054, -0.005109194666147232, 0.03717337176203728, -0.0232302937656641, -0.04283391684293747, -0.02221335656940937, 0.022507410496473312, -0.009716046042740345, -0.021135156974196434, -0.027175523340702057, -0.03322814404964447, 0.027003992348909378, -0.007982350885868073, 0.00015296187484636903, -0.007988477125763893, 0.012043976224958897, 0.01728794537484646, -0.0022023445926606655, 0.018905244767665863, 0.022715698927640915, 0.007081808988004923, 0.010010100901126862, 0.009544514119625092, 0.008833883330225945, -0.016074972227215767, 0.008864513598382473, -0.05219464749097824, 0.015976954251527786, -0.030189581215381622, 0.018758216872811317, -0.011621273122727871, -0.009495505131781101, -0.0017321639461442828, -0.0056207263842225075, -0.00539405969902873, -0.0007301584118977189, 0.012227760627865791, 0.03560508042573929, -0.02663642354309559, 0.060477178543806076, 0.004122887272387743, 0.053615912795066833, 0.017324702814221382, -0.0405304916203022, 0.013943077065050602, -0.027322551235556602, 0.0077495574951171875, -0.015241817571222782, -0.004818203393369913, 0.021220922470092773, 0.01504578161984682, 0.0017076594522222877, 0.017741279676556587, 0.012031723745167255, 0.02479858510196209, -0.04182923212647438, 0.0058106365613639355, -0.021772274747490883, 0.0021609931718558073, 0.013538752682507038, -0.024038944393396378, -0.002073695883154869, -0.0004916221369057894, 0.01438415888696909, 0.03359571099281311, -0.028841830790042877, 0.04388761147856712, 0.04766131192445755, 0.0027445072773844004, -0.00144500145688653, 0.002594417193904519, -0.023095520213246346, -0.01971389353275299, 0.009930460713803768, -0.021674256771802902, -0.01840290240943432, 0.06380979716777802, -0.0370018407702446, 0.020865608006715775, 0.014090104959905148, 0.010806498117744923, -0.01448217686265707, -0.006009736098349094, -0.012374787591397762, -0.005164329893887043, 0.01012649666517973, -0.001969551667571068, 0.022593175992369652, 0.017508486285805702, 0.043176982551813126, -0.011363975703716278, 0.005268474109470844, -0.01629551313817501, -0.018464162945747375, 0.017006143927574158, 0.002755227964371443, -0.008889018557965755, 0.028425253927707672, -0.009011540561914444, 0.03915823996067047, -0.038619138300418854, -0.04984221234917641, -0.001598920556716621, -0.01299965288490057, 0.012681093998253345, -0.005969916004687548, -0.03379174694418907, 0.030581653118133545, 0.06380979716777802, -0.045014820992946625, -0.03320363909006119, -0.03136579692363739, 0.007283971644937992, -0.010714605450630188, -0.0013967582490295172, 0.0012972085969522595, 0.005069374572485685, 0.019946686923503876, -0.007486133836209774, -0.047416266053915024, -0.013073166832327843, 0.026758946478366852, -0.03597265109419823, 0.002223786199465394, 0.00007648093742318451, 0.0066529796458780766, 0.008282531052827835, 0.027273541316390038, 0.029920030385255814, -0.0006761718541383743, -0.00939748715609312, -0.017888307571411133, 0.020571552217006683, 0.021245427429676056, -0.006518205162137747, 0.0008101810235530138, 0.021220922470092773, 0.009758928790688515, -0.03423282876610756, 0.005847393535077572, 0.01638127863407135, -0.01600145734846592, -0.016822360455989838, 0.029723994433879852, 0.0026893720496445894, -0.01216037292033434, -0.037442922592163086, 0.01721443235874176, 0.00934847816824913, 0.022531915456056595, 0.008582711219787598, -0.015695150941610336, -0.013673528097569942, 0.017091909423470497, 0.000882163061760366, 0.021956058219075203, 0.008570459671318531, 0.021612996235489845, -0.0033693728037178516, 0.016601819545030594, 0.021821284666657448, -0.02580326981842518, 0.026587415486574173, -0.023426329717040062, -0.006438565440475941, 0.04055499657988548, -0.0078046927228569984, -0.011621273122727871, 0.020951373502612114, -0.009936586953699589, -0.0033601836767047644, -0.009520010091364384, 0.02009371481835842, 0.013232446275651455, -0.010095866397023201, -0.026685433462262154, 0.0027766695711761713, 0.03849661722779274, -0.04119211435317993, -0.005890276283025742, -0.03533553332090378, -0.027837146073579788, -0.005587032996118069, 0.031414806842803955, 0.007486133836209774, 0.009268837980926037, -0.05043032392859459, -0.01003460492938757, -0.02081659808754921, -0.04802887886762619, -0.025705251842737198, 0.002291173441335559, 0.04192725196480751, -0.004272977355867624, -0.07914963364601135, 0.019934434443712234, 0.006836764048784971, 0.008147756569087505, 0.005770816933363676, 0.036413732916116714, 0.026415882632136345, 0.014800735749304295, 0.01161514688283205, -0.020485786721110344, 0.02896435372531414, -0.01290163490921259, -0.011406858451664448, 0.01611172780394554, 0.009875325486063957, -0.04805338382720947, 0.006720367353409529, 0.02999354526400566, 0.016050467267632484, -0.0002994147362187505, -0.001820992911234498, 0.012754607945680618, -0.012546319514513016, 0.015303079038858414, -0.014139113947749138, -0.013685779646039009, -0.012681093998253345, 0.013195689767599106, 0.008092621341347694, 0.006530457176268101, -0.00045563108869828284, -0.03143931180238724, 0.007700548507273197, 0.003657301189377904, -0.0017091910121962428, 0.02035101130604744, -0.0012466679327189922, 0.020424526184797287, -0.022164346650242805, 0.0006087844376452267, -0.029723994433879852, -0.03420832380652428, 0.00031204987317323685, 0.02331605926156044, 0.03989337384700775, 0.013269202783703804, -0.007645413279533386, 0.01694488152861595, 0.019309569150209427, 0.0031304536387324333, 0.0022743267472833395, -0.012092985212802887, 0.005011176224797964, 0.014604699797928333, -0.0018776595825329423, 0.0187092088162899, 0.007357485126703978, -0.028915345668792725, -0.029209399595856667, -0.04496581107378006, -0.012417670339345932, 0.005685050971806049, 0.023291556164622307, -0.025778764858841896, -0.014151366427540779, -0.02683245949447155, -0.004851896781474352, 0.0256317388266325, -0.007081808988004923, -0.013318211771547794, 0.02925840951502323, 0.014739474281668663, 0.013318211771547794, 0.031243275851011276, 0.00010270843631587923, -0.020939121022820473, -0.02639137953519821, -0.01458019483834505, -0.05920294299721718, 0.025876782834529877, 0.013011905364692211, 0.00460072560235858, 0.045749958604574203, -0.012583076022565365, 0.00025576603366062045, 0.032517511397600174, 0.018194613978266716, 0.0038900941144675016, -0.03518850356340408, 0.02073083259165287, -0.004665049724280834, -0.00795171968638897, 0.04033445566892624, -0.0158176738768816, 0.01212974265217781, 0.02432074584066868, 0.007375863380730152, -0.013501996174454689, 0.02193155512213707, -0.004321986343711615, -0.048911042511463165, -0.04202526807785034, -0.0021931554656475782, -0.014702717773616314, 0.006230276543647051, -0.022813716903328896, -0.018194613978266716, 0.018439657986164093, 0.032345980405807495, -0.009048298001289368, 0.03969733789563179, 0.016895873472094536, -0.014653708785772324, 0.05376293882727623, 0.04393662139773369, -0.011737669818103313, -0.01999569684267044, -0.013734788633883, 0.031708862632513046, -0.0055288346484303474, -0.004236220382153988, 0.018574433401226997, -0.018194613978266716, -0.018660198897123337, 0.01364902313798666, -0.02155173383653164, 0.020841103047132492, -0.007247214671224356, -0.04994023218750954, 0.040113914757966995, -0.024173717945814133, 0.0018332451581954956, 0.02238488756120205, -0.032811567187309265, -0.004640545230358839, 0.01749623380601406, 0.0062792859971523285, 0.0038288328796625137, -0.022825969383120537, 0.04459824413061142, -0.012485058046877384, -0.00008275065192719921, 0.03109624795615673, 0.01378379762172699, -0.003317300695925951, 0.009029919281601906, 0.02228686958551407, -0.016087224707007408, 0.03839859738945961, 0.02164975181221962, 0.001868470455519855, 0.027788136154413223, -0.000882163061760366, 0.04258887469768524, 0.0008385143592022359, -0.02044902928173542, -0.02015497535467148, 0.00717370118945837, -0.002939012134447694, 0.03810454532504082, 0.03754093870520592, 0.03906022012233734, 0.006518205162137747, -0.017986325547099113, -0.0033693728037178516, 0.0024918043054640293, -0.008368296548724174, 0.05645843595266342, 0.02128218486905098, -0.006910277530550957, -0.03202741965651512, -0.06042817234992981, 0.05180257558822632, 0.019272813573479652, -0.003819643519818783, 0.007308476138859987, -0.011069921776652336, -0.0314883217215538, 0.011909201741218567, -0.007363611366599798, 0.002458110684528947, -0.026611918583512306, -0.009127937257289886, 0.02027749828994274, 0.012062354944646358, 0.02210308611392975, 0.004824329167604446, 0.025950297713279724, -0.0048580230213701725, 0.009189198724925518, -0.01858668588101864, 0.029356427490711212, 0.011345596984028816, 0.027151018381118774, 0.006395682226866484, 0.018758216872811317, -0.015682898461818695, 0.016528304666280746, -0.0123564088717103, 0.0056207263842225075, -0.05023428797721863, -0.020767588168382645, -0.011394605971872807, -0.003899283241480589, -0.029013363644480705, -0.00284712016582489, -0.027616605162620544, -0.008282531052827835, -0.044181667268276215, 0.013734788633883, 0.014886502176523209, -0.017091909423470497, 0.028572281822562218, 0.015315331518650055, 0.009575145319104195, -0.026440387591719627, -0.00044605901348404586, -0.013955329544842243, -0.028915345668792725, -0.04665662348270416, 0.01888073980808258, -0.020044704899191856, -0.025558223947882652, 0.04499031603336334, 0.002670993795618415, 0.03192940354347229, -0.003721625544130802, -0.008821630850434303, -0.022446149960160255, 0.004683428443968296, -0.008135504089295864, 0.017447225749492645, -0.028621291741728783, -0.022152094170451164, -0.05689951777458191, -0.03156183287501335, 0.0009426586329936981, -0.0024963989853858948, 0.01756974868476391, 0.014139113947749138, 0.02063281461596489, 0.005170455668121576, -0.0049468521028757095, -0.010151001624763012, -0.011419110931456089, -0.028425253927707672, 0.01785155013203621, -0.008025233633816242, 0.0143351498991251, 0.010328659787774086, -0.020105967298150063, -0.0073697371408343315, 0.005868834909051657, 0.005510455928742886, 0.0029022551607340574, 0.008288657292723656, -0.017618756741285324, 0.02683245949447155, 0.008153881877660751, -0.006597844883799553, 0.02092686854302883, -0.008594963699579239, -0.03915823996067047, -0.03800652548670769, 0.03690382093191147, 0.021318940445780754, -0.04883752763271332, 0.005185771267861128, 0.013869564048945904, -0.01941983960568905, 0.011584516614675522, -0.019677137956023216, -0.0052378433756530285, 0.014518934302031994, -0.026219846680760384, 0.03896220400929451, 0.01981191150844097, -0.010720731690526009, -0.023303808644413948, 0.026023810729384422, -0.026146333664655685, -0.010157127864658833, 0.006123069208115339, 0.007492260076105595, -0.007357485126703978, 0.03670778498053551, -0.004560905508697033, -0.02006920985877514, 0.007375863380730152, -0.01694488152861595, -0.020559299737215042, 0.044475723057985306, -0.013930825516581535, 0.0026418946217745543, 0.0037951390258967876, 0.0014411726733669639, -0.017900558188557625, 0.01693263091146946, -0.015462358482182026, -0.015376592054963112, -0.02749408222734928, -0.007045052479952574, 0.011786678805947304, -0.027151018381118774, -0.02098812907934189, -0.02526417002081871, -0.034012287855148315, 0.002366218715906143, -0.020203985273838043, -0.019873173907399178, 0.017839297652244568, 0.006554961670190096, -0.008356045000255108, 0.01712866686284542, -0.003926850855350494, 0.012276769615709782, -0.01711641438305378, 0.017618756741285324, -0.012693346478044987, 0.019383084028959274, -0.034379854798316956, -0.028988858684897423, -0.013085419312119484, -0.0040524364449083805, -0.04810239374637604, -0.03592364117503166, -0.014237131923437119, -0.009121811017394066, 0.04175571724772453, 0.030777689069509506, 0.011492624878883362, 0.03499246761202812, -0.00356234610080719, -0.0004537166969384998, -0.02793516404926777, 0.015376592054963112, 0.052145641297101974, -0.006989917252212763, 0.034551385790109634, -0.0012880193535238504, -0.03536003828048706, 0.02313227578997612, -0.041314639151096344, -0.009183072485029697, 0.02962597645819187, 0.01776578463613987, 0.0005727933603338897, -0.020608309656381607, -0.030949221923947334, 0.022176599130034447, 0.056850507855415344, -0.019946686923503876, 0.003350994549691677, -0.04822491481900215, 0.02191930264234543, -0.008956405334174633, -0.007651539519429207, 0.042245808988809586, 0.011737669818103313, -0.006744871847331524, -0.00043074367567896843, 0.017447225749492645, 0.006916403770446777, 0.001376082538627088, 0.042343828827142715, 0.010157127864658833, 0.031169762834906578, 0.048273924738168716, -0.025974800810217857, 0.026881469413638115, -0.004070815164595842, 0.00042500044219195843, -0.03146381676197052, 0.03129228577017784, -0.03467391058802605, -0.027812641113996506, 0.026342369616031647, 0.01731245033442974, -0.0021563987247645855, 0.032811567187309265, 0.015339835546910763, -0.014077852480113506, 0.015462358482182026, -0.021171914413571358, -0.03256652131676674, -0.03648724406957626, 0.020841103047132492, 0.014310645870864391, -0.00652433093637228, 0.025411197915673256, 0.014212626963853836, 0.03192940354347229, -0.0002440880925860256, -0.006610096897929907, 0.026881469413638115, 0.005008113104850054, 0.03126778081059456, 0.05405699461698532, -0.008239648304879665, -0.002560723340138793, -0.055380236357450485, 0.00400036433711648, -0.015143799595534801, -0.028180209919810295, -0.011645778082311153, 0.02164975181221962, 0.009691542014479637, 0.03876616805791855, 0.03482093662023544, 0.006463069934397936, -0.02509263902902603, -0.03518850356340408, -0.022911734879016876, 0.031169762834906578, 0.04413265734910965, 0.012926139868795872, 0.015339835546910763, 0.007228836417198181, -0.00360829196870327, -0.01951785758137703, -0.0022023445926606655, -0.0026663991156965494, -0.017741279676556587, -0.0017045963322743773, -0.01494776364415884, 0.0076944222673773766, -0.0065733399242162704, -0.02220110408961773, -0.013428482227027416, -0.016234250739216805, -0.024945611134171486, -0.029478948563337326, -0.038178056478500366, 0.027690118178725243, -0.008386675268411636, 0.008429558016359806, -0.0017444161931052804, 0.0009993253042921424, -0.01739821583032608, 0.00529604172334075, 0.01656506210565567, -0.02221335656940937, -0.0008936495869420469, 0.0018654073355719447, 0.014714970253407955, 0.006025051232427359, -0.007939468137919903, 0.020890111103653908, 0.0077495574951171875, 0.0008530639461241663, -0.024737322703003883, 0.025411197915673256, -0.00013812514953315258, -0.006165952421724796, 0.019873173907399178, 0.017643261700868607, -0.020216237753629684, -0.057683661580085754, 0.02361011505126953, -0.013465238735079765, 0.04981771111488342, 0.015156052075326443, -0.018451910465955734, -0.011896949261426926, 0.01088001113384962, 0.030557148158550262, 0.04170671105384827, -0.04013841971755028, 0.00390847260132432, -0.032051924616098404, -0.014935511164367199, -0.005504330154508352, -0.008950279094278812, -0.043348513543605804, -0.023267051205039024, 0.00009064761979971081, 0.011994967237114906, -0.018635695800185204, -0.020877858623862267, 0.0005819826037622988, -0.053076811134815216, 0.025974800810217857, -0.0005762393120676279, 0.009587396867573261, 0.028988858684897423, 0.011088299565017223, 0.023205790668725967, 0.0020369391422718763, 0.018451910465955734, -0.011125057004392147, 0.003681805683299899, -0.0060893758200109005, -0.03509048745036125, -0.04670563340187073, -0.0058565824292600155, -0.013171184808015823, -0.018635695800185204, -0.01142523717135191, 0.011786678805947304, -0.0012673436431214213, 0.021784527227282524, 0.009599649347364902, 0.0072227101773023605, 0.022519662976264954, 0.009893704205751419, -0.009189198724925518, -0.02405119687318802, -0.015278574079275131, -0.016442539170384407, 0.0022008130326867104, 0.013832807540893555, 0.03212543949484825, -0.02193155512213707, 0.027837146073579788, 0.0035439676139503717, -0.035776615142822266, -0.012742355465888977, -0.0076147825457155704, -0.04347103461623192, -0.0018638757755979896, -0.04026094079017639, -0.015462358482182026, 0.03200291469693184, -0.03646273910999298, -0.06106529012322426, -0.011449741199612617, 0.002032344462350011, -0.017263440415263176, -0.02256867289543152, -0.003547030733898282, 0.0006451583467423916, -0.022176599130034447, -0.006227213889360428, 0.007161448709666729, -0.0011371633736416698, -0.011357849463820457, -0.024553539231419563, 0.012344157323241234, 0.027420569211244583, 0.004763068165630102, -0.0010896858293563128, -0.022813716903328896, 0.0375654436647892, -0.009532262571156025, 0.00864397268742323, 0.05062635987997055, 0.004230094607919455, -0.03783499449491501, -0.003026309423148632, 0.028915345668792725, -0.013796050101518631, -0.05822276324033737, 0.009274964220821857, -0.02626885659992695, 0.011247579008340836, -0.0062364027835428715, -0.017189927399158478, 0.008870639838278294, -0.009826316498219967, 0.02221335656940937, -0.01832938753068447, 0.0020139659754931927, -0.018831731751561165, 0.010892263613641262, 0.025055881589651108, 0.015989204868674278, -0.011419110931456089, 0.024737322703003883, 0.002830273238942027, 0.0067632501013576984, 0.040677521377801895, -0.00879712589085102, -0.002752165077254176, 0.014016591012477875, 0.002940543694421649, 0.04675464332103729, 0.046681128442287445, -0.014322897419333458, 0.023818403482437134, -0.017447225749492645, -0.03349769115447998, -0.010408299043774605, -0.02046128176152706, -0.03053264506161213, 0.008153881877660751, 0.04339752346277237, -0.011676408350467682, 0.023659123107790947, -0.0108738848939538, -0.01794956810772419, 0.04513734579086304, -0.0047140587121248245, -0.01787605509161949, 0.03837409242987633, -0.0006819151458330452, 0.05116545781493187, 0.038545627146959305, -0.0006746403523720801, -0.01498452015221119, -0.020400021225214005, 0.017655514180660248, 0.0073697371408343315, -0.0032989224418997765, 0.006113880313932896, -0.018439657986164093, -0.0048120771534740925, -0.00648144818842411, -0.033546701073646545, -0.009893704205751419, 0.021796779707074165, -0.003176399739459157, -0.0008063521818257868, 0.023254798725247383, 0.03423282876610756, -0.006971538532525301, 0.015842178836464882, -0.022237861528992653, 0.005639105103909969, -0.008019107393920422, 0.01216037292033434, 0.002056848956272006, -0.02913588657975197, 0.011798931285738945, 0.011394605971872807, -0.006414060480892658, -0.008196765556931496, -0.0030462194699794054, -0.017532991245388985, 0.03283606842160225, 0.029650481417775154, 0.029184894636273384, 0.009905955754220486, 0.045014820992946625, -0.002263606060296297, -0.018929749727249146, 0.005222527775913477, 0.007627035025507212, 0.013955329544842243, -0.02109839953482151, 0.015584881417453289, 0.017349207773804665, 0.02756759524345398, -0.009783433750271797, -0.021711014211177826, -0.014825240708887577, -0.013060914352536201, -0.018991010263562202, -0.023303808644413948, -0.005893339402973652, -0.04072652757167816, 0.01851317286491394, 0.012191003188490868, -0.00920145120471716, 0.0003287052968516946, 0.0004862617643084377, -0.01165802963078022, 0.013955329544842243, -0.03709985688328743, 0.013734788633883, -0.02543570287525654, 0.026293359696865082, -0.022531915456056595, 0.0005636041751131415, 0.04185373708605766, 0.014273888431489468, 0.00939748715609312, -0.025043629109859467, 0.05699753761291504, -0.01916254311800003, 0.0008300909539684653, -0.01639353111386299, -0.005629915744066238, 0.032983098179101944, -0.031071742996573448, 0.0418047271668911, 0.00025136288604699075, 0.01999569684267044, 0.028008677065372467, 0.019738398492336273, -0.01777803711593151, -0.0261953417211771, -0.024308493360877037, -0.010279649868607521, 0.013612266629934311, -0.022997500374913216, -0.008031359873712063, 0.01078811939805746, 0.03183138370513916, -0.02702849730849266, -0.01665082760155201, 0.019138038158416748, -0.014874249696731567, 0.0036542380694299936, -0.024112457409501076, -0.024369755759835243, -0.016981638967990875, 0.0032805439550429583, -0.008135504089295864, -0.0012099111918359995, -0.03229697048664093, 0.01896650530397892, 0.01420037541538477, -0.046852659434080124, -0.021318940445780754, 0.047881852835416794, 0.015670645982027054, 0.006101627834141254, -0.0033050484489649534, -0.00023815339955035597, 0.011235326528549194, -0.01601370982825756, 0.020767588168382645, -0.01858668588101864, -0.011278210207819939, 0.0020216237753629684, -0.0351639986038208, 0.02639137953519821, -0.05243969336152077, 0.013195689767599106, -0.039109230041503906, 0.022360382601618767, 0.013501996174454689, 0.002159461611881852, -0.007271719165146351, -0.06229051575064659, -0.06528006494045258, 0.023720385506749153, 0.029723994433879852, 0.02933192253112793, -0.014286140911281109, 0.011223074980080128, -0.0008415774209424853, -0.018623443320393562, -0.00215180404484272, 0.014911006204783916, -0.002735318150371313, -0.01563389040529728, 0.01590343937277794, 0.002674056915566325 ]
13.695867
8.15043
2024-07-01
0
2024A&A...687A..39S
[ "outflow properties", "strong outflows", "galactic outflows", "weak outflows", "background quasars", "mass loading factor η", "stellar mass", "SFR surface density", "galaxy properties", "La Silla Paranal Observatory" ]
[ "galaxies: evolution", "galaxies: formation", "intergalactic medium", "galaxies: kinematics and dynamics", "quasars: absorption lines", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
109
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202348725", "10.48550/arXiv.2404.03300" ]
[ "Schroetter, Ilane", "Bouché, Nicolas F.", "Zabl, Johannes", "Wendt, Martin", "Cherrey, Maxime", "Langan, Ivanna", "Schaye, Joop", "Contini, Thierry" ]
[ "Institut de Recherche en Astrophysique et Planétologie, Université de Toulouse, CNRS, CNES, UPS, 9 Av. du colonel Roche, 31028, Toulouse Cedex 04, France", "Centre de Recherche Astrophysique de Lyon (CRAL) UMR5574, Univ Lyon1, Ens de Lyon, CNRS, 69230, Saint-Genis-Laval, France", "Centre de Recherche Astrophysique de Lyon (CRAL) UMR5574, Univ Lyon1, Ens de Lyon, CNRS, 69230, Saint-Genis-Laval, France; Institute for Computational Astrophysics and Department of Astronomy &amp; Physics, Saint Mary's University, 923 Robie Street Halifax, Nova Scotia, B3H 3C3, Canada", "Institut für Physik und Astronomie, Universität Potsdam, Karl-Liebknecht-Str. 24/25, 14476, Golm, Germany", "Centre de Recherche Astrophysique de Lyon (CRAL) UMR5574, Univ Lyon1, Ens de Lyon, CNRS, 69230, Saint-Genis-Laval, France", "European Southern Observatory, Karl-Schwarzschild-Str. 2, 85748, Garching, Germany; Centre de Recherche Astrophysique de Lyon (CRAL) UMR5574, Univ Lyon1, Ens de Lyon, CNRS, 69230, Saint-Genis-Laval, France", "Leiden Observatory, Leiden University, PO Box 9513, 2300 RA, Leiden, The Netherlands", "Institut de Recherche en Astrophysique et Planétologie, Université de Toulouse, CNRS, CNES, UPS, 9 Av. du colonel Roche, 31028, Toulouse Cedex 04, France" ]
null
[ "1986A&A...169....1B", "1986ApJ...303...39D", "1995ApJ...440L..45S", "1996ApJ...460L...1L", "1996MNRAS.283.1388M", "1998A&A...331L...1S", "2000ApJS..129..493H", "2000SPIE.4008..534D", "2002MNRAS.331...98V", "2003PASP..115..763C", "2005ApJ...618..569M", "2005ApJ...621..227M", "2005ApJS..160..115R", "2006MNRAS.373.1265O", "2006Msngr.124....5B", "2007ApJ...669L...5B", "2008MNRAS.387..577O", "2009ApJS..181..272G", "2009MNRAS.393..808M", "2010AJ....140..445C", "2010SPIE.7735E..08B", "2011ApJ...733..101G", "2011ApJ...743...10B", "2011MNRAS.416.1354D", "2011MNRAS.416.3118K", "2012ApJ...752..111N", "2012ApJ...760..127M", "2012ApJS..199....3R", "2012MNRAS.421.3522H", "2012MNRAS.426..801B", "2013ApJ...762L..31B", "2013ApJ...770..130Z", "2013ApJ...776..114N", "2013MNRAS.428.3121M", "2014A&A...568A..14A", "2014ApJ...792L..12K", "2014ApJ...794..156R", "2014ApJ...795..165S", "2014MNRAS.445..794T", "2015A&A...575A..75B", "2015ApJ...804...83S", "2015ApJ...809..147H", "2015ApJ...810..104A", "2015ApJ...811..132M", "2015ApJ...812...83N", "2015ApJS..219...12A", "2015MNRAS.454.2691M", "2016ApJ...833...39S", "2017ApJ...835..267H", "2017ApJ...846..151H", "2017ApJ...850..156L", "2018A&A...619A..27B", "2018MNRAS.480.5046R", "2019ApJ...878...84M", "2019MNRAS.485.1961Z", "2019MNRAS.490.4368S", "2020A&A...635A.194M", "2020MNRAS.491.2057L", "2020MNRAS.496.1013M", "2020MNRAS.497..498C", "2021ApJ...913...50L", "2023ApJ...949....9P" ]
29072529
2406.02185
The MAGPI Survey: massive slow rotator population in place by z 0.3
We use the 'Middle Ages Galaxy Properties with Integral field spectroscopy' (MAGPI) survey to investigate whether galaxies have evolved in the distribution of their stellar angular momentum in the past 3-4 Gyr, as probed by the observational proxy for spin, λ<SUB>R</SUB>. We use 2D stellar kinematics to measure λ<SUB>R</SUB> along with detailed photometric models to estimate galaxy ellipticity. The combination of these measurements quantifies the kinematic classes of 'fast rotators' and the rarer 'slow rotators', which show no regular rotation in their line-of-sight velocity fields. We compare 51 MAGPI galaxies with log<SUB>10 </SUB>(M<SUB>⋆</SUB>/M<SUB>⊙</SUB>) &gt; 10 to carefully drawn samples of MaNGA galaxies in the local Universe, selected to represent possible descendants of the MAGPI progenitors. The EAGLE simulations are used to identify possible evolutionary pathways between the two samples, explicitly accounting for progenitor bias in our results and the varied evolutionary pathways a galaxy might take between the two epochs. We find that the occurrence of slow rotating galaxies is unchanged between the MAGPI (z ~ 0.3) and MaNGA (z ~ 0) samples, suggesting the massive slow rotator population was already in place ~4 Gyr ago and has not accumulated since. There is a hint of the MAGPI sample having an excess of high λ<SUB>R</SUB> galaxies compared to the MaNGA sample, corresponding to more ordered rotation, but statistically the samples are not significantly different. The large-scale stellar kinematics, as quantified through the λ<SUB>R</SUB> parameter, of galaxies at z ~ 0.3 have already evolved into the diversity of structures seen today in the local Universe.
[ 0.021426081657409668, 0.030900370329618454, -0.005975897423923016, -0.01810198836028576, -0.029057800769805908, 0.04486902803182602, -0.02131403423845768, -0.01525098830461502, -0.022658610716462135, 0.008372480981051922, -0.015039341524243355, -0.019521264359354973, -0.03052687644958496, 0.0043387506157159805, 0.01338351983577013, 0.011547177098691463, -0.040710799396038055, -0.02616945095360279, -0.04519272595643997, 0.05149231478571892, 0.008864248171448708, -0.007862039841711521, 0.03919192776083946, 0.0262441486120224, -0.03767305240035057, 0.010065652430057526, 0.02356744557619095, 0.015163839794695377, -0.007774891331791878, -0.0262441486120224, 0.003538851859048009, -0.021724877879023552, -0.0223598163574934, -0.008005212992429733, -0.09466817229986191, 0.059709176421165466, 0.001688502263277769, -0.010488945059478283, -0.004746480844914913, -0.05154211446642876, -0.030950168147683144, -0.005104412324726582, -0.01808954030275345, 0.02079114317893982, 0.03067627362906933, -0.018263837322592735, 0.0033209805842489004, -0.04113409295678139, 0.01634657010436058, -0.011578300967812538, -0.06797583401203156, -0.015612032264471054, 0.022098369896411896, 0.018201587721705437, -0.002858782187104225, 0.013283922336995602, -0.0006364953005686402, -0.0037567229010164738, -0.002941261976957321, 0.01338351983577013, -0.02953089214861393, -0.04158228635787964, 0.03007868304848671, -0.022733310237526894, 0.00039255732554011047, 0.012119866907596588, -0.050496332347393036, 0.014790345914661884, 0.008938946761190891, 0.030975067988038063, -0.011771272867918015, -0.015562232583761215, 0.003227607114240527, 0.015138939954340458, -0.002298541832715273, -0.02462567761540413, 0.012169665656983852, -0.004541059490293264, -0.004323188215494156, 0.02074134349822998, 0.034062616527080536, 0.001963953720405698, 0.015487533994019032, 0.012014043517410755, 0.011864646337926388, 0.0059821223840117455, 0.0730055496096611, -0.025434913113713264, -0.016533317044377327, 0.0360545814037323, 0.005253809969872236, -0.00895762164145708, -0.01914777047932148, -0.0048056175000965595, 0.032518841326236725, -0.0349091999232769, 0.024849774315953255, -0.036303576081991196, 0.05012283846735954, 0.042354173958301544, -0.011652999557554722, 0.010302198119461536, 0.03874373435974121, -0.023642143234610558, 0.028012018650770187, 0.00531605863943696, 0.025422463193535805, 0.007034129463136196, -0.004257827065885067, -0.01576142944395542, -0.0042360397055745125, 0.006772683933377266, -0.024725275114178658, 0.02674214169383049, -0.03817104548215866, 0.012362637557089329, -0.0833139717578888, 0.014927294105291367, -0.009337339550256729, -0.014317254535853863, -0.015387935563921928, -0.01969556137919426, -0.013595166616141796, -0.012449786067008972, 0.023579895496368408, -0.025995153933763504, -0.03281763568520546, -0.022135719656944275, -0.012972677126526833, 0.05062083154916763, 0.023617245256900787, -0.013607616536319256, 0.044445738196372986, -0.0428023636341095, -0.02455097809433937, 0.01395621057599783, 0.015425285324454308, -0.024862222373485565, -0.022210419178009033, 0.060456160455942154, -0.005216460675001144, -0.01366986520588398, 0.00787448976188898, 0.006234230473637581, 0.027613626793026924, 0.022073471918702126, -0.04628830403089523, -0.006358728278428316, 0.022509213536977768, -0.00408353004604578, -0.023318449035286903, -0.01314697414636612, -0.029779888689517975, -0.013246572576463223, -0.04805617406964302, 0.020069055259227753, 0.0033365427516400814, -0.020093955099582672, -0.02517346851527691, -0.02020600251853466, -0.04656220227479935, 0.024364231154322624, -0.020069055259227753, 0.015462634153664112, -0.025895554572343826, 0.025870656594634056, -0.03565618768334389, -0.012437336146831512, -0.06837422400712967, -0.039042528718709946, 0.027738124132156372, -0.02460077777504921, -0.020517248660326004, -0.051143720746040344, 0.0327429361641407, 0.010046977549791336, -0.002941261976957321, -0.053832877427339554, -0.004145778715610504, -0.014952193014323711, -0.005891861394047737, 0.035755787044763565, 0.0057424637489020824, -0.04033730924129486, -0.07240795344114304, 0.030850570648908615, -0.012686331756412983, 0.04743368551135063, 0.004500597715377808, -0.017902793362736702, -0.007208426017314196, 0.03448590636253357, 0.022061021998524666, 0.025310415774583817, -0.036278676241636276, -0.029082700610160828, 0.0458650141954422, 0.005695777013897896, 0.004930115304887295, -0.009723283350467682, 0.0327429361641407, 0.029207197949290276, 0.0340128168463707, -0.08062481880187988, -0.045516420155763626, -0.015636932104825974, 0.023691942915320396, -0.01856263168156147, -0.038519639521837234, 0.03769795224070549, 0.025434913113713264, 0.00017001738888211548, -0.037897150963544846, 0.034635305404663086, -0.012163441628217697, -0.01746704988181591, -0.04760798439383507, -0.0035077272914350033, 0.04494372755289078, 0.04636300355195999, -0.012449786067008972, 0.020554596558213234, 0.020044155418872833, 0.060356564819812775, 0.018973473459482193, 0.011223481968045235, 0.06623286008834839, -0.012368862517178059, 0.042304374277591705, 0.017018858343362808, 0.014777895994484425, 0.019558614119887352, -0.03426181152462959, -0.011901996098458767, 0.029057800769805908, -0.02674214169383049, -0.01581122912466526, 0.031896352767944336, -0.016222070902585983, -0.005191560834646225, -0.006355615798383951, 0.034187112003564835, -0.03239434212446213, 0.0053036087192595005, -0.06284651905298233, -0.00035734777338802814, -0.010277298279106617, 0.020069055259227753, 0.028734106570482254, -0.002619123784825206, -0.016682714223861694, -0.026069851592183113, -0.004226702265441418, -0.0382208451628685, -0.023679492995142937, 0.03889313340187073, -0.04651240259408951, 0.01117368321865797, -0.05443046614527702, 0.00982910580933094, -0.010962036438286304, 0.02851000986993313, -0.03759835287928581, 0.05557584762573242, -0.02778792381286621, 0.060406364500522614, 0.011684124357998371, -0.034212011843919754, -0.0426778681576252, 0.009256416000425816, 0.00710260309278965, -0.019384317100048065, -0.005057725589722395, -0.034187112003564835, -0.020318051800131798, 0.015437735244631767, -0.015562232583761215, 0.030850570648908615, 0.01578632928431034, 0.005798487924039364, 0.01755419932305813, -0.01801484078168869, 0.04795657843351364, 0.04247866943478584, -0.03010358288884163, 0.03371402248740196, 0.0175790973007679, 0.0058451746590435505, -0.02351764589548111, -0.04653730243444443, 0.05467946082353592, -0.059310782700777054, 0.02410278655588627, 0.0017507511656731367, -0.01586102694272995, 0.005191560834646225, 0.03112446516752243, 0.031248964369297028, -0.04213007539510727, 0.019384317100048065, 0.03321602940559387, -0.023766642436385155, 0.016222070902585983, -0.006203106138855219, -0.012810830026865005, 0.023853790014982224, 0.009107018820941448, -0.020977890118956566, -0.03485940024256706, 0.0741509273648262, 0.001974847400560975, 0.01699395850300789, 0.01852528192102909, 0.016110023483633995, -0.04847946763038635, -0.02564655989408493, -0.04046180471777916, 0.04745858535170555, 0.02285780757665634, -0.07101357728242874, -0.08709870278835297, -0.04808107390999794, 0.008826898410916328, -0.009741957299411297, -0.014553800225257874, -0.055376648902893066, 0.01036444678902626, -0.03871883451938629, -0.0142052061855793, -0.010065652430057526, 0.03127386420965195, -0.03269314020872116, 0.01864977926015854, 0.02463812753558159, -0.008515654131770134, -0.01037067174911499, 0.04581521451473236, 0.06394210457801819, -0.026318848133087158, 0.016010425984859467, -0.016819661483168602, 0.009567661210894585, 0.03202085196971893, 0.0003748552699107677, 0.031373459845781326, 0.0019468353129923344, -0.004846079275012016, 0.05034693703055382, 0.015562232583761215, -0.0024884010199457407, -0.0008621477172710001, 0.011640550568699837, 0.044570233672857285, 0.011796172708272934, 0.0666312575340271, -0.03657747060060501, 0.021052587777376175, -0.04270276799798012, -0.04974934458732605, 0.03749875724315643, -0.004298288840800524, -0.03431161120533943, 0.021089937537908554, 0.03396301716566086, 0.00791183952242136, 0.03348992392420769, -0.007575694937258959, -0.006380515638738871, 0.016284320503473282, -0.033016834408044815, -0.004015055950731039, 0.038494739681482315, -0.048902761191129684, 0.024887122213840485, -0.015325686894357204, -0.008347582072019577, 0.01751684956252575, -0.00960501004010439, -0.0018456807592883706, -0.008901597000658512, -0.00895762164145708, -0.01684456132352352, 0.028136517852544785, -0.05891238898038864, 0.008714850060641766, 0.048305172473192215, -0.0402626097202301, -0.010464045219123363, -0.07205936312675476, 0.06125294789671898, -0.023144152015447617, 0.004158228635787964, -0.028659408912062645, 0.005633528344333172, 0.024762624874711037, -0.06478868424892426, 0.025571860373020172, 0.04526742175221443, 0.009648584760725498, 0.030775871127843857, -0.039042528718709946, -0.024663027375936508, -0.06130274757742882, -0.016284320503473282, -0.027588726952672005, -0.021077487617731094, 0.0019499477930366993, 0.05094452574849129, -0.0018005503807216883, -0.00708392821252346, 0.032991934567689896, 0.008117260411381721, 0.013570266775786877, -0.04437103867530823, 0.013433319516479969, 0.013221672736108303, -0.04362405091524124, 0.024924471974372864, -0.027688324451446533, 0.05014773830771446, -0.014304804615676403, -0.014342153444886208, 0.01848793216049671, -0.021027689799666405, -0.026667442172765732, 0.01958351396024227, 0.005580616649240255, 0.048429667949676514, -0.011528502218425274, -0.01750439964234829, -0.007563245017081499, 0.024961821734905243, 0.018450582399964333, -0.0033707795664668083, -0.006585936993360519, -0.03560638800263405, 0.028485111892223358, -0.04526742175221443, -0.0018285623518750072, -0.04048670455813408, 0.054928455501794815, -0.019471466541290283, -0.0009197279578074813, -0.01801484078168869, 0.040113210678100586, 0.000213008068385534, -0.006741559132933617, 0.01591082662343979, -0.004145778715610504, -0.06668105721473694, -0.006542362738400698, 0.007258225232362747, 0.03202085196971893, -0.027663424611091614, 0.00037193737807683647, -0.025372663512825966, 0.0016853897832334042, -0.03717506304383278, 0.00931866466999054, -0.05042163282632828, -0.003924794960767031, 0.011279506608843803, -0.012418662197887897, -0.009492961689829826, -0.015338136814534664, 0.01969556137919426, 0.001586569589562714, -0.01342086959630251, -0.0002748679253272712, -0.002158481627702713, 0.05037183687090874, -0.03729955852031708, -0.004363649990409613, -0.01752929948270321, -0.021426081657409668, 0.017317652702331543, -0.020965440198779106, -0.009337339550256729, 0.03941602259874344, 0.02356744557619095, 0.059211183339357376, -0.00708392821252346, -0.03266824036836624, -0.0012200790224596858, 0.0207662433385849, 0.04549152031540871, -0.01587347686290741, 0.03493409976363182, -0.05622323602437973, -0.04105939343571663, -0.006704209838062525, -0.026642542332410812, 0.005070175509899855, -0.012549384497106075, -0.0014278348535299301, -0.021525681018829346, -0.0003184421802870929, -0.05348428338766098, -0.013781913556158543, 0.018861426040530205, 0.04354935139417648, -0.005412544589489698, 0.011665449477732182, 0.027439329773187637, 0.01037689670920372, -0.003983931615948677, -0.03488430008292198, -0.02140118181705475, -0.009119468741118908, 0.010999386198818684, -0.004214252810925245, 0.02452607825398445, 0.017317652702331543, -0.012717456556856632, 0.02179957553744316, 0.01848793216049671, -0.013458219356834888, 0.03062647394835949, -0.007494771387428045, -0.02125178463757038, 0.024936921894550323, -0.007326699327677488, 0.009212842211127281, 0.0014690747484564781, 0.003868771018460393, -0.022832907736301422, -0.01169657427817583, -0.11931875348091125, -0.05089472606778145, 0.005026601254940033, -0.0018845864105969667, 0.0007162517867982388, 0.04521762207150459, -0.013234122656285763, -0.015176289714872837, -0.024750174954533577, -0.012848179787397385, 0.011298181489109993, -0.026493145152926445, -0.04579031467437744, 0.05074532702565193, 0.02405298687517643, 0.0028945752419531345, 0.019546164199709892, 0.003952807281166315, 0.013171873986721039, -0.019770260900259018, 0.004721581470221281, 0.030825670808553696, 0.041681885719299316, 0.04200557991862297, -0.025011621415615082, -0.006548587698489428, 0.013171873986721039, -0.0021693753078579903, -0.01798994094133377, -0.00682248268276453, -0.0027996457647532225, 0.025285515934228897, 0.03451080620288849, -0.03062647394835949, 0.005745576228946447, 0.012736131437122822, 0.011366655118763447, 0.022720860317349434, -0.03495899960398674, 0.011254606768488884, 0.001923491945490241, -0.0026658105198293924, 0.03007868304848671, -0.004995476920157671, 0.03057667426764965, 0.052189502865076065, -0.007426297292113304, -0.008204408921301365, 0.005751801189035177, -0.03784735128283501, -0.0003614328452385962, 0.0059509980492293835, -0.06279671937227249, -0.03602968156337738, -0.042329274117946625, 0.0008084580185823143, -0.018189137801527977, -0.01698150858283043, -0.009393364191055298, 0.010569868609309196, 0.00006409694469766691, 0.04813087359070778, 0.007737542036920786, -0.00029509884188883007, -0.022272666916251183, -0.002121132332831621, 0.0003789403708651662, -0.002244073897600174, -0.0006559481262229383, -0.01577387936413288, 0.028186315670609474, -0.014030909165740013, 0.005051500629633665, -0.013358620926737785, 0.024426480755209923, -0.025895554572343826, 0.008366256020963192, -0.012007818557322025, 0.02066664583981037, -0.009492961689829826, -0.035730887204408646, -0.009966053999960423, 0.01592327654361725, -0.011789947748184204, 0.021450981497764587, -0.002454164205119014, -0.017205605283379555, 0.004989251960068941, -0.016558215022087097, 0.011372880078852177, 0.01754174940288067, 0.009953604079782963, 0.008976295590400696, -0.016222070902585983, 0.002807426732033491, 0.050471432507038116, 0.007519670762121677, 0.025497162714600563, 0.004008830990642309, 0.012113641947507858, -0.03294213488698006, -0.012692556716501713, -0.03837024047970772, 0.012524484656751156, -0.04203047975897789, 0.0072146509774029255, -0.003924794960767031, 0.020542146638035774, 0.017753394320607185, -0.031871452927589417, 0.012568059377372265, -0.014927294105291367, -0.009636134840548038, 0.029281897470355034, 0.01093713752925396, -0.015076691284775734, -0.03493409976363182, 0.01010300125926733, -0.02011885493993759, 0.012437336146831512, 0.021612828597426414, -0.04765778034925461, 0.0024370455648750067, -0.018687129020690918, -0.022733310237526894, 0.0063058165833354, 0.01577387936413288, 0.03055177628993988, 0.00544989388436079, 0.031323663890361786, 0.008011437021195889, -0.029779888689517975, 0.002933480776846409, 0.011092759668827057, -0.014902394264936447, 0.0005407875869423151, 0.010962036438286304, -0.017118455842137337, 0.03884333372116089, 0.003109334036707878, 0.017753394320607185, -0.01093713752925396, 0.025546960532665253, 0.05413167178630829, -0.0012667657574638724, -0.016819661483168602, 0.02407788671553135, -0.029904386028647423, -0.01737990230321884, -0.027414429932832718, -0.0015328798908740282, -0.03164735808968544, -0.019297169521450996, 0.021102387458086014, -0.009349789470434189, -0.01858753152191639, -0.003993269056081772, -0.008378705941140652, -0.004724693950265646, 0.006816258188337088, 0.03625377640128136, 0.00814838521182537, -0.001367142191156745, 0.007961638271808624, 0.012443561106920242, 0.03971481695771217, 0.02786262147128582, -0.000292569980956614, -0.016122473403811455, 0.00879577361047268, 0.0050795129500329494, 0.016184723004698753, -0.034809600561857224, 0.0393662229180336, 0.018699578940868378, 0.016632914543151855, 0.015587132424116135, -0.028634509071707726, -0.009642359800636768, 0.01038934662938118, -0.0213389340788126, 0.002231624210253358, -0.02791242115199566, -0.012076293118298054, 0.01686946116387844, -0.023106804117560387, -0.005098187364637852, -0.011509827338159084, -0.014130507595837116, 0.00982910580933094, -0.006890956778079271, -0.0600079707801342, -0.0073204743675887585, -0.0036166629288345575, -0.023330898955464363, -0.06912121176719666, -0.011547177098691463, 0.0019701786804944277, -0.034187112003564835, -0.011864646337926388, 0.06822483241558075, -0.015101591125130653, -0.025895554572343826, 0.008671276271343231, 0.004749593324959278, 0.007413847837597132, -0.028833704069256783, 0.025360215455293655, 0.05836459621787071, 0.024999171495437622, -0.0072146509774029255, -0.0038812209386378527, 0.04601440951228142, -0.002917918609455228, -0.0029428182169795036, 0.012194565497338772, 0.009094568900763988, 0.0012418661499395967, -0.013271472416818142, 0.039689917117357254, -0.014952193014323711, 0.018873875960707664, -0.00518222339451313, 0.008229308761656284, 0.009735733270645142, 0.004870978649705648, 0.029804788529872894, 0.028211215510964394, -0.022559013217687607, 0.025335315614938736, -0.004986139480024576, -0.001554667018353939, 0.003722486086189747, 0.04516782611608505, 0.020069055259227753, 0.018276285380125046, 0.005617965944111347, -0.006066158413887024, 0.015076691284775734, -0.0048367418348789215, 0.0005816384800709784, 0.009748182259500027, -0.0034299162216484547, -0.006212443578988314, 0.056571830064058304, 0.055376648902893066, -0.021152187138795853, 0.04653730243444443, 0.015661831945180893, 0.05457986146211624, -0.029182298108935356, 0.005829612258821726, 0.0037629478611052036, -0.013607616536319256, -0.01904817298054695, 0.004768268205225468, -0.05393247306346893, -0.0012737687211483717, 0.007955413311719894, 0.0066108363680541515, -0.023119252175092697, 0.011920670047402382, 0.004183128010481596, -0.022521663457155228, 0.012536934576928616, 0.014068258926272392, 0.026119651272892952, -0.031473059207201004, 0.0294312946498394, -0.01577387936413288, -0.10826334357261658, -0.012761031277477741, 0.013358620926737785, -0.014902394264936447, 0.019309617578983307, 0.05836459621787071, 0.025372663512825966, 0.01501444261521101, 0.01574897952377796, -0.02013130486011505, 0.027165433391928673, -0.048280272632837296, -0.016769861802458763, 0.0070465789176523685, 0.025522062554955482, -0.028759006410837173, -0.00532228359952569, 0.020629296079277992, -0.01260540820658207, 0.0014255004934966564, -0.022023672237992287, 0.05089472606778145, -0.010837539099156857, 0.004111541900783777, 0.0005843618419021368, -0.027439329773187637, 0.0014682966284453869, 0.03182165324687958, 0.028559809550642967, -0.0003271959431003779, -0.020865842700004578, -0.03495899960398674, -0.0002991839137393981, 0.01391886081546545, -0.02453852817416191, -0.02029315195977688, -0.013171873986721039, 0.004376099910587072, -0.03443611040711403, 0.002066664630547166, -0.029879486188292503, -0.01589837670326233, 0.03762325271964073, 0.0207039937376976, 0.038544539362192154, 0.009156817570328712, 0.01749194972217083, 0.02836061269044876, 0.03652767464518547, 0.009349789470434189, 0.01791524328291416, 0.024787524715065956, 0.0013492455473169684, 0.0017414138419553638, -0.0005680214962922037, 0.008901597000658512, 0.014404403045773506, -0.015599582344293594, -0.011011836118996143, 0.02066664583981037, -0.027962220832705498, 0.022683510556817055, -0.020044155418872833, -0.02728993073105812, -0.054380666464567184, -0.01916022039949894, -0.028534909710288048, -0.0252232663333416, -0.012561834417283535, -0.028012018650770187, 0.0002867341390810907, 0.036353375762701035, 0.0042360397055745125, -0.0004042290092911571, -0.0006073161493986845, -0.012418662197887897, -0.04081039875745773, -0.001001429627649486, -0.04631320387125015, -0.019857408478856087, -0.030825670808553696, -0.0689220204949379, 0.02074134349822998, -0.02674214169383049, 0.02123933471739292, 0.008272882550954819, -0.010999386198818684, -0.02793732099235058, -0.021463431417942047, 0.024127686396241188, 0.013283922336995602, 0.028285915032029152, 0.024401580914855003, -0.001237197546288371, -0.01146002858877182, 0.0070154545828700066, 0.024924471974372864, 0.011833521537482738, -0.00599145982414484, -0.003115558996796608, -0.034137312322854996, 0.009804206900298595, -0.0168819110840559, -0.01224436517804861, 0.010208824649453163, -0.041183892637491226, 0.023318449035286903, 0.009922479279339314, 0.00878954865038395, 0.024849774315953255, 0.023667043074965477, 0.02577105723321438, -0.048404768109321594, 0.004033730830997229, 0.036278676241636276, 0.01583612896502018, 0.021002789959311485, 0.004435236565768719, 0.038519639521837234, -0.015313236974179745, -0.014279904775321484, -0.04529232159256935, -0.04870356246829033, -0.016184723004698753, 0.0058420621789991856, -0.021737325936555862, -0.006511238403618336, -0.014616048894822598, 0.01009055133908987, 0.018413234502077103, 0.01750439964234829, -0.02455097809433937, 0.044495537877082825, -0.02021845243871212, -0.011565851047635078, -0.018936125561594963, -0.012773480266332626, 0.0039030080661177635, -0.0196831114590168, 0.021961422637104988, -0.001841012155637145, -0.009692158550024033, -0.004765155725181103, 0.022110819816589355, -0.0011484927963465452, 0.005804712884128094, -0.0006376624805852771, -0.02191162295639515, 0.015039341524243355, 0.0073827230371534824, 0.012169665656983852, 0.009256416000425816, -0.026044953614473343, 0.052189502865076065, -0.018662229180336, 0.008185734041035175, 0.02186182513833046, -0.008210633881390095, -0.03600478172302246, 0.03062647394835949, 0.058663394302129745, 0.042254574596881866, 0.013308821246027946, -0.04937585070729256, -0.019919658079743385, 0.015985526144504547, -0.02843531221151352, 0.014616048894822598, -0.009430713020265102, -0.013308821246027946, -0.00708392821252346, -0.034610405564308167, 0.027663424611091614, -0.01848793216049671, 0.00171028939075768, -0.0014286129735410213, 0.058663394302129745, -0.02136383391916752, 0.0023639032151550055, 0.014429301954805851, -0.0028976877219974995, 0.017043758183717728, -0.04546662047505379, 0.025484712794423103, 0.016744961962103844, 0.0035077272914350033, -0.04203047975897789, -0.01754174940288067, 0.012014043517410755, 0.0392417274415493, -0.03475980460643768, 0.05298629030585289, -0.003361442359164357, 0.048354968428611755, 0.025235716253519058, -0.0008831567247398198, -0.016720062121748924, 0.004488147795200348, 0.001580344745889306, 0.010837539099156857, -0.006810033228248358, 0.01038934662938118, -0.0032960809767246246, -0.00985400564968586, 0.012269264087080956, 0.010227499529719353, 0.0067477840930223465, -0.02292005717754364, -0.0294312946498394, -0.006296479608863592, 0.01746704988181591, -0.003694473998621106, 0.043399956077337265, -0.0058171628043055534, 0.03697586432099342, -0.034710004925727844, 0.05702001973986626, -0.003968369215726852, -0.06005777046084404, -0.03276783600449562, 0.013532917946577072, -0.043375056236982346, -0.018873875960707664, 0.03224494680762291, -0.025273066014051437, 0.040163010358810425, -0.01699395850300789, -0.028833704069256783, -0.002429264597594738, 0.0008543665753677487, 0.030203182250261307, 0.007027904503047466, -0.021699978038668633, -0.03269314020872116, -0.01921002008020878, -0.018811626359820366, 0.010233724489808083, 0.023803992196917534, 0.0015468859346583486, 0.0013928198022767901, -0.01746704988181591, -0.012399987317621708, -0.01574897952377796, -0.0024728388525545597, -0.0032151571940630674, 0.0017367452383041382, 0.015450185164809227, -0.02509876899421215, 0.0019764036405831575, -0.017790744081139565, -0.013545367866754532, 0.0025646560825407505, -0.023916039615869522, -0.024899572134017944, 0.01287307869642973, 0.014815245755016804, -0.03329072892665863, 0.029256997630000114, 0.019857408478856087, -0.0038034096360206604, -0.023131702095270157, 0.017106005921959877, -0.0008442511316388845, -0.041806381195783615, 0.010607217438519001, 0.019533714279532433, -0.016184723004698753, 0.027489127591252327, 0.004877203609794378, -0.009499186649918556, -0.01589837670326233, -0.008584127761423588, 0.027962220832705498, 0.02128913439810276, -0.01699395850300789, 0.012144766747951508, 0.014142957516014576, -0.014367053285241127, -0.006617061328142881, 0.03060157410800457, -0.019346967339515686, -0.03767305240035057, 0.017603997141122818, -0.010787739418447018, -0.003176251659169793, 0.029331697151064873, 0.012536934576928616, -0.002393471309915185, 0.02669234201312065, -0.02234736643731594, -0.01145380362868309, 0.04277746379375458, 0.009934929199516773, -0.012194565497338772, 0.03294213488698006, -0.02024335227906704, -0.027563827112317085, 0.026617642492055893, -0.004687344655394554, -0.0010442258790135384, 0.005228910129517317, 0.01234396267682314, 0.01634657010436058, -0.01969556137919426, -0.02132648415863514, -0.04205537959933281, -0.009194167330861092, -0.024750174954533577, -0.004597083665430546, -0.018898775801062584, 0.0056459782645106316, 0.0008769318228587508, -0.020903190597891808, 0.0022269554901868105, -0.0039061205461621284, 0.010426696389913559, -0.03344012424349785, 0.002317216480150819, 0.005088849924504757, -0.04043690487742424, -0.005123087204992771, 0.004105316940695047, -0.009393364191055298, 0.003946582321077585, -0.03381361812353134, -0.006243567913770676, -0.01445420179516077, 0.008739749900996685, 0.005997684318572283, 0.01684456132352352, 0.0018752490868791938, 0.052687495946884155, -0.00045441719703376293, -0.015960626304149628, -0.013097175396978855, 0.029281897470355034, 0.031224064528942108, 0.002381021622568369, 0.011385329999029636, 0.008683726191520691, 0.017653796821832657, -0.005530817434191704, -0.0657348707318306, 0.04486902803182602, -0.0019732911605387926, 0.012350187636911869, 0.03329072892665863, -0.000995204783976078, -0.04158228635787964, 0.011777497828006744, 0.05702001973986626, -0.00814838521182537, 0.011509827338159084, -0.011895771138370037, 0.027987118810415268, -0.0038251967635005713, 0.025970254093408585, 0.02521081641316414, -0.003137346124276519, 0.006548587698489428, 0.0062809172086417675, -0.0013367957435548306, 0.024289533495903015, 0.008801998570561409, 0.05721921846270561, -0.026493145152926445, -0.022808007895946503, 0.03426181152462959, 0.0014651842648163438, 0.012692556716501713, -0.001519652083516121, 0.01802729070186615, -0.0016169160371646285, 0.03652767464518547, -0.020567046478390694, -0.013981110416352749, 0.001700952067039907, 0.007127502467483282, -0.02518591843545437, 0.01963331364095211, 0.010713040828704834, -0.011410228908061981, -0.004550396930426359, 0.00003798157558776438, -0.018948575481772423, 0.003850096371024847, 0.02011885493993759, 0.006330716423690319, 0.008322682231664658, 0.0009905360639095306, 0.03727465867996216, 0.01589837670326233, 0.01340841967612505, -0.036278676241636276, -0.01065079215914011, -0.013010026887059212, 0.022160619497299194, 0.02340559847652912, 0.00024938478600233793, -0.012480910867452621, -0.04907705634832382, 0.0052724843844771385, 0.01690680906176567, 0.0100967762991786, 0.0011866202112287283, 0.02407788671553135, 0.0036571247037500143, 0.03655257076025009, 0.0006127629312686622, -0.027563827112317085, -0.00040111655835062265, 0.020928090438246727, -0.042901962995529175, 0.015325686894357204, 0.0284104123711586, 0.013470668345689774, -0.00657348707318306, 0.019533714279532433, 0.016085123643279076, 0.0039621442556381226, 0.017790744081139565, 0.01749194972217083, -0.012294163927435875, 0.021724877879023552, -0.009679708629846573, -0.011733923107385635, 0.00133523961994797, 0.014504000544548035, -0.03266824036836624, -0.020529696717858315, -0.015450185164809227, -0.02125178463757038, 0.0005987568874843419, 0.05741841346025467, -0.04593970999121666, 0.0028338825795799494, 0.021587928757071495, 0.00737027358263731, -0.020081505179405212, 0.030999967828392982, -0.008353807032108307, 0.01742970012128353, 0.010843764059245586, 0.028858603909611702, 0.01918512023985386, 0.022509213536977768, -0.011995368637144566, 0.027414429932832718, 0.024675477296113968, 0.037971846759319305, -0.033091530203819275, 0.03642807528376579, -0.011484927497804165, -0.03710036352276802, 0.02890840359032154, -0.007806016132235527, -0.01091223768889904, -0.03324092924594879, 0.00267047923989594, 0.011665449477732182, 0.043972644954919815, 0.04036220535635948, 0.029082700610160828, 0.0072146509774029255, -0.027016036212444305, 0.016010425984859467, 0.02239716611802578, 0.005356520414352417, 0.008297782391309738, -0.04429633915424347, 0.010862438939511776, 0.0022176182828843594, 0.029331697151064873, 0.011260831728577614, -0.014429301954805851, -0.0338883176445961, -0.001249647350050509, -0.015549782663583755, 0.0022082808427512646, 0.035730887204408646, -0.058663394302129745, 0.006965655367821455, 0.007463647052645683, 0.029929285869002342, 0.029929285869002342, -0.015960626304149628, 0.01909797266125679, -0.03971481695771217, 0.022658610716462135, -0.0031995950266718864, 0.011291956529021263, -0.025845756754279137, 0.02791242115199566, -0.029804788529872894, 0.029854588210582733, 0.001968622440472245, 0.013283922336995602, -0.0036913615185767412, -0.003411241341382265, 0.018786728382110596, -0.03715016320347786, -0.028211215510964394, 0.02995418570935726, -0.015213638544082642, 0.008322682231664658, -0.020865842700004578, -0.03109956532716751, -0.016246970742940903, -0.014852594584226608, 0.005854512099176645, -0.005197785794734955, -0.007401397917419672, -0.010737940669059753, -0.014068258926272392, 0.023604795336723328, -0.014080707915127277, -0.013831712305545807, 0.008030111901462078, -0.030701173469424248, 0.010426696389913559, -0.012188340537250042, -0.005929210688918829, 0.015636932104825974, -0.02679193951189518, -0.020952990278601646, -0.030452176928520203, 0.008932721801102161, -0.0033396552316844463, -0.045043326914310455, 0.025260616093873978, -0.002374796662479639, -0.022534113377332687, 0.01904817298054695, -0.04847946763038635, -0.01640881784260273, -0.022695960476994514, -0.025895554572343826, 0.015587132424116135, 0.0004610311589203775, -0.003233832074329257, 0.007451197132468224, -0.014952193014323711, 0.015711629763245583, 0.0262441486120224, -0.002066664630547166, 0.0493011549115181, 0.032991934567689896, -0.026617642492055893, 0.030750971287488937, -0.002286091912537813, -0.03057667426764965, -0.017740946263074875, -0.0035201769787818193, 0.010028302669525146, -0.0012761030811816454, 0.03874373435974121, -0.009692158550024033, 0.030327679589390755, 0.005798487924039364, 0.006922081112861633, -0.0111799081787467, -0.024775074794888496, -0.017205605283379555, 0.031946152448654175, 0.02294495701789856, -0.01797749102115631, -0.026119651272892952, 0.02776302397251129, -0.01749194972217083, -0.005932323168963194, 0.025945354253053665, 0.010856213979423046, -0.022820457816123962, -0.005888748914003372, -0.024799974635243416, 0.004260939545929432, -0.013632516376674175, 0.020479898899793625, 0.020928090438246727, 0.011316855438053608, -0.020878290757536888, -0.04193088039755821, -0.013582716695964336, -0.04110919311642647, 0.0073515987023711205, 0.029705189168453217, -0.020006805658340454, 0.012263039126992226, -0.024177484214305878, 0.003380117006599903, 0.002254967577755451, -0.005652202758938074, 0.05856379494071007, 0.011391554027795792, -0.010725490748882294, 0.02619435079395771, 0.029406394809484482, -0.00814838521182537, -0.03991401568055153, 0.001097137457691133, 0.00493322778493166, 0.02567145973443985, 0.012076293118298054, 0.02514856867492199, -0.0022938731126487255, 0.005605516489595175, 0.018350984901189804, -0.021762225776910782, -0.023169051855802536, 0.03724975883960724, -0.016072673723101616, -0.018151788040995598, 0.0338883176445961, 0.007700192742049694, 0.036950964480638504, 0.02733973041176796, -0.024675477296113968, -0.0022207305300980806, 0.008609027601778507, -0.04407224431633949, -0.00008500869444105774, -0.017180705443024635, 0.00559617904946208, 0.006150194443762302, 0.014840145595371723, 0.008235533721745014, -0.026343747973442078, 0.006697984877973795, -0.003439253428950906, -0.008770874701440334, 0.0315975584089756, 0.021662628278136253, 0.02831081487238407, 0.003233832074329257, -0.01038934662938118, 0.010264848358929157, -0.027065835893154144, -0.005537042394280434, 0.002846332499757409, 0.035133298486471176, 0.027115633711218834, 0.010756615549325943, -0.0042360397055745125, -0.02736463025212288, -0.007233325857669115, -0.006038146559149027, 0.01093091256916523, -0.023218851536512375, 0.0077562169171869755, -0.010451595298945904, 0.014279904775321484, 0.02559676021337509, -0.022160619497299194, -0.018861426040530205, 0.008017661981284618, -0.0017491949256509542, -0.03162245824933052, -0.017031308263540268, 0.009001195430755615, -0.015636932104825974, 0.04466983303427696, 0.014902394264936447, -0.0010605661664158106, 0.023617245256900787, 0.0052102357149124146, 0.026418445631861687, -0.03891803324222565, 0.03991401568055153, 0.0002814818872138858, 0.007712642662227154, -0.04110919311642647, 0.006000796798616648, 0.020467448979616165, 0.0014986430760473013, 0.0426778681576252, 0.029356595128774643, 0.0045379470102488995, 0.03149795904755592, 0.016047773882746696, -0.003694473998621106, -0.0019374979892745614, -0.05303608998656273, 0.01700640842318535, -0.0013484674273058772, -0.018226487562060356, 0.0022020558826625347, -0.0041022044606506824, 0.02192407287657261, 0.021724877879023552, -0.014342153444886208, -0.0006399968406185508, -0.015387935563921928, 0.0017491949256509542, -0.03495899960398674, -0.04576541483402252, -0.016483517363667488, 0.007998988032341003, -0.014865044504404068, 0.0017398576019331813, -0.04628830403089523, 0.030302779749035835, 0.008826898410916328, -0.026642542332410812, -0.009138142690062523, 0.03149795904755592, -0.016645364463329315, -0.0021662628278136253, -0.018463032320141792, -0.0025008507072925568, 0.0017351889982819557, -0.013607616536319256, 0.017566649243235588, 0.01497709285467863, -0.0006030365475453436, -0.013059825636446476, -0.012263039126992226, 0.026916438713669777, 0.022135719656944275, -0.011217257007956505, -0.02514856867492199, 0.01062589231878519, 0.007669068407267332, -0.007737542036920786, -0.013869062066078186, -0.030875470489263535, -0.03553168848156929, 0.03012848272919655, 0.012051393277943134, 0.059709176421165466, 0.008901597000658512, 0.001926604425534606, 0.005593066569417715, -0.009131918661296368, 0.006585936993360519, 0.017242953181266785, -0.0033552173990756273, -0.022559013217687607, 0.04270276799798012, -0.021973872557282448 ]
11.26764
6.544767
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.531.4602D
[ "slow rotating galaxies", "MaNGA galaxies", "galaxies", "galaxy ellipticity", "samples", "possible evolutionary pathways", "2D stellar kinematics", "MAGPI", "λ", "SUB" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
11
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1407", "10.48550/arXiv.2406.02185" ]
[ "Derkenne, Caro", "McDermid, Richard M.", "D'Eugenio, Francesco", "Foster, Caroline", "Khalid, Aman", "Harborne, Katherine E.", "van de Sande, Jesse", "Croom, Scott M.", "Lagos, Claudia D. P.", "Bellstedt, Sabine", "Mendel, J. Trevor", "Mun, Marcie", "Wisnioski, Emily", "Bagge, Ryan S.", "Battisti, Andrew J.", "Bland-Hawthorn, Joss", "Ferré-Mateu, Anna", "Peng, Yingjie", "Santucci, Giulia", "Sweet, Sarah M.", "Thater, Sabine", "Valenzuela, Lucas M.", "Ziegler, Bodo" ]
[ "Astrophysics and Space Technologies Research Centre, School of Mathematical and Physical Sciences, Macquarie University, NSW 2109, Australia; ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D), Australia", "Astrophysics and Space Technologies Research Centre, School of Mathematical and Physical Sciences, Macquarie University, NSW 2109, Australia; ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D), Australia", "Kavli Institute for Cosmology, University of Cambridge, Madingley Road, Cambridge CB3 0HA, United Kingdom; Cavendish Laboratory - Astrophysics Group, University of Cambridge, 19 JJ Thomson Avenue, Cambridge CB3 0HE, United Kingdom", "ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D), Australia; School of Physics, University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW 2052, Australia", "ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D), Australia; School of Physics, University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW 2052, Australia", "ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D), Australia; International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research, The University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Highway, Crawley WA 6009, Australia", "ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D), Australia; Sydney Institute for Astronomy, School of Physics, University of Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia", "ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D), Australia; Sydney Institute for Astronomy, School of Physics, University of Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia", "ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D), Australia; International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research, The University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Highway, Crawley WA 6009, Australia", "International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research, The University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Highway, Crawley WA 6009, Australia", "ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D), Australia; Research School of Astronomy and Astrophysics, Australian National University, Canberra ACT 2611, Australia", "ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D), Australia; Research School of Astronomy and Astrophysics, Australian National University, Canberra ACT 2611, Australia", "ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D), Australia; Research School of Astronomy and Astrophysics, Australian National University, Canberra ACT 2611, Australia", "ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D), Australia; School of Physics, University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW 2052, Australia", "ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D), Australia; Research School of Astronomy and Astrophysics, Australian National University, Canberra ACT 2611, Australia", "Sydney Institute for Astronomy, School of Physics, University of Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias, Vía Láctea s/n, E-38205 La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Departamento de Astrofisica, Universidad de La Laguna, E-38200 La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Center for Astrophysics and Supercomputing, Swinburne University, John Street, Hawthorn VIC 3122, Australia", "Department of Astronomy, School of Physics, Peking University, 5 Yiheyuan Road, Beijing 100871, P. R. China; Kavli Institute for Astronomy and Astrophysics, Peking University, 5 Yiheyuan Road, Beijing 100871, P. R. China", "ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D), Australia; International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research, The University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Highway, Crawley WA 6009, Australia", "ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D), Australia; School of Mathematics and Physics, University of Queensland, Brisbane QLD 4072, Australia", "Department of Astrophysics, University of Vienna, Türkenschanzstrasse 17, 1180 Wien, Austria", "Universitäts-Sternwarte, Fakultät für Physik, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Scheinerstr. 1, 81679 München, Germany", "Department of Astrophysics, University of Vienna, Türkenschanzstrasse 17, 1180 Wien, Austria" ]
null
[ "1978MNRAS.183..501B", "1994A&A...285..723E", "1996MNRAS.281..985V", "2002AJ....124..266P", "2002MNRAS.333..400C", "2003PASP..115..763C", "2004ApJS..152..251V", "2004PASP..116..138C", "2005MNRAS.363..937B", "2007MNRAS.379..401E", "2011ApJ...730...38V", "2011MNRAS.413..813C", "2011MNRAS.414..888E", "2011MNRAS.416.1680C", "2011PASA...28..128C", "2012MNRAS.421..872C", "2013MNRAS.432.1862C", "2014MNRAS.443..485F", "2014MNRAS.444.3357N", "2015AJ....150...19L", "2015ApJ...798....7B", "2015MNRAS.446..521S", "2015MNRAS.450.1937C", "2015MNRAS.450.4486F", "2015MNRAS.454.2770T", "2016AJ....151....8Y", "2016ARA&A..54..597C", "2016MNRAS.458.3210S", "2016MNRAS.463..170C", "2017AJ....154...86W", "2017ApJ...835..104V", "2017ApJ...844...59B", "2017ApJ...851L..33G", "2017MNRAS.466..798C", "2017MNRAS.467.3887W", "2017MNRAS.471.1428V", "2017MNRAS.472.1272V", "2018ApJ...858...60B", "2018ApJ...862..126N", "2018MNRAS.473.4956L", "2018MNRAS.476.3137R", "2018MNRAS.476.4327L", "2018MNRAS.480.4636S", "2019A&A...628A.117B", "2019A&A...632A..59F", "2019AJ....158..231W", "2019MNRAS.484..869V", "2020A&A...641A..28W", "2020MNRAS.495.1958W", "2020MNRAS.496.3235B", "2020MNRAS.497.2018H", "2020NatMe..17..261V", "2020arXiv200909242M", "2021MNRAS.505.2247C", "2021MNRAS.505.3078V", "2021PASA...38...31F", "2022ApJ...930..153S", "2022ApJ...937..117F", "2023MNRAS.522.3602D", "2023MNRAS.525.2789D", "2023PASA...40...48H", "2024MNRAS.528.5852V", "2024MNRAS.530.5072M" ]
29072440
2406.08921
AuriDESI: mock catalogues for the DESI Milky Way Survey
The Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument Milky Way Survey (DESI MWS) will explore the assembly history of the Milky Way by characterizing remnants of ancient dwarf galaxy accretion events and improving constraints on the distribution of dark matter in the outer halo. We present mock catalogues that reproduce the selection criteria of MWS and the format of the final MWS data set. These catalogues can be used to test methods for quantifying the properties of stellar halo substructure and reconstructing the Milky Way's accretion history with the MWS data, including the effects of halo-to-halo variance. The mock catalogues are based on a phase-space kernel expansion technique applied to star particles in the Auriga suite of six high-resolution lambda-cold dark matter magnetohydrodynamic zoom-in simulations. They include photometric properties (and associated errors) used in DESI target selection and the outputs of the MWS spectral analysis pipeline (radial velocity, metallicity, surface gravity, and temperature). They also include information from the underlying simulation, such as the total gravitational potential and information on the progenitors of accreted halo stars. We discuss how the subset of halo stars observable by MWS in these simulations corresponds to their true content and properties. These mock Milky Ways have rich accretion histories, resulting in a large number of substructures that span the whole stellar halo out to large distances and have substantial overlap in the space of orbital energy and angular momentum.
[ 0.033654265105724335, 0.03838362917304039, 0.014161965809762478, 0.015115677379071712, -0.019374718889594078, -0.016670357435941696, 0.0015293682226911187, -0.01203897688537836, -0.0002729264961089939, 0.03354974836111069, -0.012195752002298832, -0.04238137975335121, -0.0384097583591938, -0.038043953478336334, 0.006176263093948364, 0.03015296719968319, -0.031616196036338806, 0.04151912033557892, -0.012228413484990597, 0.009354213252663612, 0.0016616466455161572, 0.05413946881890297, 0.002449601888656616, 0.019518429413437843, -0.07770790904760361, -0.018812943249940872, -0.019845042377710342, -0.006826224271208048, 0.004474606364965439, 0.06192593649029732, -0.0008332729339599609, -0.00406633922830224, -0.040656860917806625, 0.006610659416764975, -0.06307561695575714, 0.10195570439100266, -0.022680047899484634, 0.01968826726078987, -0.05301591753959656, -0.018551653251051903, -0.0186561681330204, 0.026782315224409103, -0.03263523057103157, 0.04141460359096527, 0.0041708555072546005, 0.0002176063135266304, 0.01733664982020855, 0.005990093573927879, 0.03838362917304039, -0.029551997780799866, -0.05022010579705238, 0.006097876001149416, 0.045438483357429504, 0.011901799589395523, -0.03425523266196251, -0.01736277900636196, -0.03125038743019104, -0.013391157612204552, -0.03294878080487251, 0.0038181128911674023, -0.011163652874529362, -0.02714812196791172, -0.01872149109840393, -0.003778919344767928, -0.023098113015294075, -0.02767070382833481, 0.051082365214824677, 0.019426977261900902, 0.011372685432434082, 0.03718169033527374, -0.0006348551833070815, 0.01953149400651455, -0.022418757900595665, -0.0357707217335701, 0.01891745999455452, -0.02517537586390972, -0.006457150913774967, -0.006924208253622055, -0.015808098018169403, 0.021295206621289253, -0.0027517196722328663, 0.010823974385857582, -0.0373123362660408, -0.030649419873952866, -0.030492644757032394, -0.0023810132406651974, 0.012777123600244522, -0.005219285376369953, -0.024914085865020752, 0.02633812092244625, -0.0005364628159441054, 0.023385534062981606, 0.01173196081072092, 0.007427193224430084, -0.014305675402283669, -0.025005538016557693, -0.030362000688910484, -0.04013427719473839, 0.014723741449415684, 0.009145180694758892, 0.016186969354748726, 0.00733574153855443, 0.017166810110211372, -0.02420859970152378, 0.0735272541642189, -0.024221664294600487, 0.0066237240098416805, -0.022902145981788635, -0.021765530109405518, 0.015285516157746315, 0.005839851219207048, -0.011451072990894318, -0.012457042932510376, 0.0340200737118721, 0.03801782429218292, 0.00826332438737154, 0.007466387003660202, 0.019544558599591255, -0.008733647875487804, -0.008191469125449657, -0.0603581927716732, 0.013770028948783875, 0.0406046025454998, -0.0005250313552096486, 0.02394730970263481, -0.04172815382480621, -0.00792364589869976, -0.051343657076358795, -0.031302645802497864, 0.030649419873952866, 0.018734555691480637, 0.023973438888788223, 0.032687488943338394, -0.04248589649796486, -0.03739072382450104, -0.00337391858920455, -0.03438587859272957, -0.0026994612999260426, -0.007838726043701172, 0.02673005685210228, 0.006636788137257099, 0.0011839743237942457, 0.06600207835435867, 0.006215456873178482, 0.0015742775285616517, -0.020119396969676018, -0.001211736467666924, 0.0342291034758091, 0.01782003790140152, 0.006708643399178982, -0.007616628892719746, -0.03185135871171951, -0.002229137811809778, -0.0028480705805122852, -0.02040681801736355, -0.00868138950318098, -0.012372123077511787, -0.002196476561948657, 0.018812943249940872, -0.04536009579896927, 0.005163760855793953, 0.001967846881598234, -0.007838726043701172, -0.0021523835603147745, -0.00939340703189373, 0.013613254763185978, -0.0007838726160116494, 0.03125038743019104, -0.057379476726055145, -0.016017131507396698, -0.030048450455069542, 0.01846020109951496, 0.003419644432142377, -0.030335871502757072, 0.029578126966953278, -0.004781622905284166, -0.0032416400499641895, -0.041336216032505035, -0.036972660571336746, -0.04716300219297409, -0.002057665726169944, 0.03428136184811592, 0.0206289142370224, -0.04423654451966286, -0.061507873237133026, -0.007263886276632547, -0.00842663086950779, 0.03561394661664963, 0.0030522041488438845, 0.005741867236793041, 0.03553555905818939, 0.039272017776966095, 0.03360200673341751, -0.00200867373496294, -0.050951723009347916, -0.013626319356262684, -0.00504291383549571, 0.04483751580119133, -0.017323585227131844, 0.01189526729285717, 0.030910711735486984, 0.03326232731342316, 0.03373265266418457, -0.0368681438267231, -0.03177297115325928, 0.013456480577588081, 0.04460235312581062, 0.016004066914319992, 0.021674077957868576, 0.012241478078067303, 0.04350493103265762, 0.014762934297323227, 0.0009520786115899682, 0.029996192082762718, -0.03702491894364357, -0.006310174707323313, -0.05575947463512421, -0.006039085332304239, 0.03574459254741669, 0.019021976739168167, -0.020550528541207314, 0.0715414434671402, 0.04042169824242592, 0.024443762376904488, 0.012163090519607067, 0.04854784533381462, 0.030884582549333572, -0.03464717045426369, -0.009589374996721745, 0.004190452396869659, 0.010111956857144833, -0.0024398036766797304, -0.025332150980830193, 0.005588358733803034, -0.05429624393582344, -0.036659110337495804, -0.0269913487136364, 0.014867451041936874, 0.020994722843170166, -0.0290816742926836, -0.013456480577588081, 0.0019988752901554108, -0.023189565166831017, 0.047790102660655975, 0.001798007870092988, 0.039820730686187744, -0.0020168388728052378, -0.010921958833932877, -0.00587577885016799, -0.027461672201752663, 0.02640344388782978, -0.006316707003861666, -0.015520677901804447, -0.011633976362645626, 0.004566058050841093, 0.024613600224256516, -0.02034149505198002, 0.06558401137590408, -0.005895375274121761, -0.008877357468008995, -0.05074268952012062, 0.00857034046202898, -0.04823429509997368, 0.03195587545633316, -0.0399513766169548, 0.05045526847243309, 0.016291486099362373, -0.02001488208770752, -0.015442291274666786, 0.030231354758143425, -0.008478889241814613, 0.0038899679202586412, 0.03498684987425804, 0.02611602284014225, -0.004886139649897814, 0.018551653251051903, 0.036005884408950806, 0.0517878532409668, -0.019191814586520195, -0.005843117367476225, -0.003042405704036355, -0.03699878975749016, -0.006114206742495298, 0.025005538016557693, -0.008446227759122849, 0.04248589649796486, 0.012809785082936287, 0.018473265692591667, -0.02879425510764122, -0.011065668426454067, 0.0018404676811769605, -0.0438968688249588, -0.004654243588447571, -0.02821941487491131, 0.006460417062044144, -0.007028724532574415, 0.011059136129915714, 0.04334815591573715, 0.006506142672151327, 0.025998443365097046, 0.07060079276561737, 0.025645699352025986, 0.004161057062447071, -0.016970843076705933, -0.01267260778695345, 0.03373265266418457, 0.056700121611356735, -0.018904395401477814, 0.0008051025215536356, 0.04771171510219574, 0.014932774007320404, -0.017650198191404343, -0.010693329386413097, 0.0053858584724366665, -0.009791875258088112, -0.05711818486452103, -0.005477310158312321, 0.023189565166831017, 0.020106332376599312, -0.061089806258678436, -0.033811040222644806, -0.025358280166983604, -0.08167953044176102, -0.024927150458097458, 0.007120176684111357, -0.0923924520611763, -0.00798896886408329, 0.0010337320854887366, -0.02324182353913784, 0.014684547670185566, 0.034464266151189804, 0.004536662716418505, 0.03483007475733757, -0.0035470237489789724, 0.0016918584005907178, -0.057954318821430206, 0.02976103127002716, 0.00630364241078496, -0.035300396382808685, 0.015520677901804447, -0.02657328173518181, -0.027775220572948456, 0.009628568775951862, -0.029264578595757484, 0.024169405922293663, -0.03712943568825722, 0.003393515245988965, 0.012091235257685184, 0.050246234983205795, -0.06939885765314102, 0.0002551668731030077, -0.02339859865605831, 0.046953972429037094, -0.013482609763741493, 0.020223913714289665, -0.00328409974463284, 0.0024855295196175575, -0.07128015160560608, -0.01099381409585476, -0.019191814586520195, -0.008864292874932289, -0.0009234999306499958, 0.05348624289035797, 0.015324709936976433, -0.03404620289802551, 0.04580429196357727, -0.0423552505671978, 0.03496072068810463, -0.01203897688537836, -0.024861827492713928, 0.02795812487602234, 0.02675618603825569, -0.05894722044467926, 0.018773749470710754, -0.04073524847626686, 0.01672261580824852, 0.01878681406378746, 0.0049743251875042915, -0.013332366943359375, 0.023189565166831017, 0.0750427395105362, 0.019100362434983253, -0.025423603132367134, -0.04245976731181145, 0.04013427719473839, 0.017349714413285255, -0.030623290687799454, 0.005679810419678688, -0.03616265580058098, -0.004611784126609564, -0.022392628714442253, -0.01878681406378746, 0.02840231917798519, 0.009563245810568333, -0.022392628714442253, -0.0406046025454998, 0.011320427060127258, 0.019152620807290077, 0.021295206621289253, 0.02082488313317299, 0.0099878441542387, -0.033366844058036804, -0.06851046532392502, -0.08042532950639725, -0.015024225227534771, 0.01575583964586258, 0.03143329173326492, 0.019910365343093872, 0.0351174958050251, -0.012875108048319817, 0.031328774988651276, -0.0034425072371959686, 0.038592662662267685, -0.02440456859767437, 0.02767070382833481, 0.017415037378668785, -0.021582625806331635, 0.027331026270985603, 0.014527772553265095, 0.030414259061217308, 0.034490395337343216, -0.012548494152724743, -0.006061948370188475, -0.007035256829112768, -0.0029084940906614065, 0.008668324910104275, 0.024914085865020752, 0.033811040222644806, 0.007224692963063717, -0.051186881959438324, -0.02824554406106472, 0.0318252295255661, 0.05622979626059532, 0.007178966887295246, 0.004824082832783461, -0.04993268847465515, 0.007662354968488216, -0.004817550536245108, 0.03302716836333275, -0.027905866503715515, 0.01904810592532158, -0.0013154363259673119, -0.04031718149781227, -0.01578196883201599, 0.008002033457159996, -0.010935023427009583, 0.031224260106682777, 0.04086589440703392, -0.005389124155044556, -0.017506489530205727, 0.013835351914167404, -0.011581717990338802, 0.00918437447398901, -0.012868575751781464, -0.0038540405221283436, -0.02989167720079422, -0.027043605223298073, -0.02514924667775631, 0.03987298905849457, -0.021099237725138664, 0.029787160456180573, 0.011856073513627052, -0.04935784637928009, 0.04922720044851303, -0.035875238478183746, 0.03234780952334404, 0.01281631737947464, 0.005457713268697262, 0.009968247264623642, -0.0034882333129644394, 0.06453884392976761, -0.01604326069355011, 0.0123982522636652, 0.03383716940879822, 0.01817278005182743, -0.035587817430496216, -0.016056325286626816, 0.013600190170109272, 0.05497560277581215, 0.01940084807574749, 0.06725627183914185, 0.0134956743568182, -0.03966395556926727, 0.059992384165525436, 0.004187186248600483, 0.02602457068860531, -0.0583723820745945, 0.004144726786762476, 0.007237757556140423, -0.026965219527482986, -0.05314656347036362, 0.005598157178610563, 0.013404222205281258, -0.014253417029976845, 0.018473265692591667, -0.04496816173195839, 0.0040042828768491745, -0.006091343704611063, -0.0301790963858366, 0.047345906496047974, 0.035169750452041626, -0.026455702260136604, 0.026521023362874985, 0.009439133107662201, 0.0583723820745945, 0.010013973340392113, -0.08424017578363419, -0.016565842553973198, -0.006924208253622055, 0.013286640867590904, -0.05440076068043709, 0.07493822276592255, -0.013665513135492802, 0.0220529492944479, 0.01210429985076189, 0.03085845336318016, 0.007067918311804533, 0.008380904793739319, 0.05455753579735756, -0.01363938394933939, 0.021295206621289253, 0.00027925462927669287, -0.013443415984511375, -0.004027145449072123, 0.009857198223471642, -0.0051245675422251225, -0.05029849335551262, -0.08842083066701889, -0.030257483944296837, 0.027487801387906075, 0.0007904049125500023, -0.008250259794294834, 0.06004464253783226, 0.005366261582821608, -0.0445500947535038, -0.016030196100473404, 0.00406633922830224, 0.025057794526219368, 0.02192230522632599, 0.026939090341329575, 0.052153658121824265, -0.0022454685531556606, 0.02343779243528843, -0.022026821970939636, 0.034882333129644394, 0.045856550335884094, 0.009203971363604069, -0.0004695070383604616, 0.009850665926933289, -0.0010729256318882108, -0.010791312903165817, 0.03441200777888298, 0.04363557696342468, 0.032556843012571335, -0.00785832293331623, 0.021033916622400284, -0.022771500051021576, -0.06061948463320732, 0.0375213697552681, -0.012306800112128258, -0.047215260565280914, -0.009883327409625053, 0.009419536218047142, 0.04303460940718651, 0.00160203967243433, -0.0397162139415741, 0.01309067290276289, -0.008942680433392525, -0.003984685987234116, -0.0003919363080058247, -0.023058919236063957, -0.02192230522632599, -0.005656947381794453, -0.05356463044881821, 0.024091018363833427, -0.005614487919956446, -0.004056540783494711, -0.0062546501867473125, 0.010647603310644627, -0.01004010159522295, -0.011150588281452656, -0.012809785082936287, 0.009497923776507378, 0.009739617817103863, -0.019061170518398285, 0.04212008789181709, -0.00939340703189373, -0.011503331363201141, 0.021229883655905724, -0.00897534191608429, -0.025711022317409515, -0.03605814278125763, 0.02098165825009346, -0.001922121038660407, 0.0028774659149348736, -0.013391157612204552, 0.04319138079881668, 0.04266880080103874, 0.003088131546974182, -0.021843917667865753, 0.0005099254776723683, 0.029107803478837013, -0.012685672380030155, -0.030753936618566513, 0.008211066015064716, 0.0043145655654370785, 0.022314241155982018, -0.04470686987042427, -0.020903270691633224, -0.0006720075034536421, -0.05842464044690132, 0.0213997233659029, -0.008060823194682598, -0.014292610809206963, 0.004925332963466644, 0.01966213807463646, 0.023359404876828194, -0.016748744994401932, 0.03198200464248657, -0.018930524587631226, 0.010079295374453068, -0.010157682932913303, 0.029551997780799866, 0.039559438824653625, 0.06182142347097397, 0.0006332221091724932, -0.003223676234483719, -0.04266880080103874, -0.039690084755420685, -0.0040108151733875275, -0.022653918713331223, -0.021386658772826195, 0.0493839755654335, 0.01646132580935955, -0.03673749789595604, 0.024574406445026398, -0.005794125143438578, 0.02108617313206196, 0.008191469125449657, 0.025580376386642456, -0.007446790114045143, -0.027331026270985603, 0.019570685923099518, -0.0290816742926836, 0.03341910243034363, -0.00007139569061109796, 0.017898425459861755, 0.01946617104113102, -0.025606505572795868, -0.011228975839912891, -0.018094392493367195, -0.02004101127386093, -0.004043476190418005, 0.011130991391837597, 0.03399394452571869, -0.028350060805678368, 0.015181000344455242, 0.006466949358582497, -0.012156558223068714, -0.018159715458750725, -0.018068265169858932, -0.009713488630950451, 0.003138756612315774, -0.0467449389398098, -0.01869536191225052, 0.032974909991025925, -0.00798896886408329, 0.023476986214518547, -0.01079784519970417, 0.01258768793195486, 0.06683820486068726, 0.0009202338405884802, 0.030884582549333572, 0.028872642666101456, 0.01433180458843708, -0.005134365987032652, 0.007734210230410099, -0.05032462254166603, -0.042590413242578506, 0.008250259794294834, 0.011313894763588905, 0.00598029512912035, -0.031067484989762306, 0.021896176040172577, -0.008576872758567333, 0.007159369997680187, 0.02543666772544384, 0.010275264270603657, 0.008374372497200966, 0.015808098018169403, 0.019231008365750313, -0.03430749103426933, 0.03213877975940704, 0.008962277323007584, 0.02565876394510269, -0.010823974385857582, 0.008126146160066128, -0.00026353634893894196, 0.030649419873952866, -0.056125279515981674, 0.02175246551632881, 0.03948105126619339, 0.02798425406217575, 0.007904049009084702, 0.003277567448094487, -0.014384062960743904, 0.001022300566546619, 0.0013121701776981354, 0.05372140556573868, 0.0010802744654938579, 0.029238449409604073, 0.020067138597369194, -0.022000692784786224, -0.02376440539956093, -0.010954620316624641, 0.005411987192928791, 0.019426977261900902, 0.01258768793195486, -0.057536251842975616, -0.02091633528470993, 0.0032987974118441343, -0.015050354413688183, -0.0680401474237442, 0.0009863730520009995, 0.0047065019607543945, -0.03260910138487816, 0.007806065026670694, 0.04005589336156845, 0.009615504182875156, -0.030753936618566513, -0.006525739561766386, 0.03456878289580345, -0.031093614175915718, -0.059731096029281616, -0.02414327673614025, -0.021138431504368782, -0.0014869084116071463, -0.022261982783675194, -0.006166464649140835, 0.02624666877090931, -0.0030048449989408255, 0.02034149505198002, 0.00017249280062969774, 0.005947633646428585, 0.03399394452571869, -0.03273974731564522, 0.006917675957083702, -0.02317650057375431, -0.011039539240300655, -0.015024225227534771, -0.012326397001743317, 0.011111394502222538, 0.0020641980227082968, -0.012731398455798626, 0.013286640867590904, -0.024874892085790634, 0.006382029503583908, -0.007087515201419592, 0.025933120399713516, 0.03472555801272392, 0.016317615285515785, 0.04909655451774597, 0.004376622382551432, 0.006689046509563923, -0.053251080214977264, 0.006417957134544849, -0.03498684987425804, 0.020289236679673195, 0.0493839755654335, -0.03519587963819504, -0.013247448019683361, -0.013587125577032566, 0.03098909743130207, -0.019779719412326813, 0.026076829060912132, 0.005134365987032652, 0.01597793772816658, -0.019374718889594078, -0.0329226516187191, 0.026285862550139427, -0.003831177484244108, -0.02175246551632881, 0.033131685107946396, -0.008903486654162407, -0.0032530713360756636, 0.004784889053553343, -0.0408136360347271, -0.023333275690674782, -0.014854386448860168, -0.005395656451582909, -0.04742429405450821, 0.04018653556704521, 0.04018653556704521, -0.0015252855373546481, -0.025541182607412338, -0.010902361944317818, -0.0203023012727499, -0.09056341648101807, 0.0010721090948209167, 0.05063817277550697, 0.03974234312772751, -0.0022895613219588995, 0.026168281212449074, 0.008851228281855583, 0.011601314879953861, 0.003622144926339388, -0.010673732496798038, 0.009661230258643627, -0.021491175517439842, -0.004196984693408012, 0.027226509526371956, 0.0342291034758091, -0.013952933251857758, -0.03125038743019104, 0.03658072277903557, -0.022719241678714752, -0.009497923776507378, -0.017872296273708344, 0.03702491894364357, 0.0012607284588739276, -0.017806973308324814, 0.002766417106613517, -0.05301591753959656, -0.012293735519051552, 0.023620694875717163, 0.012280670925974846, -0.017611004412174225, -0.025488926097750664, -0.00037029816303402185, -0.021060043945908546, 0.02460053563117981, -0.05225817486643791, 0.011418411508202553, 0.01107220072299242, 0.014514707960188389, -0.017584875226020813, -0.015638258308172226, -0.021360529586672783, -0.03937653452157974, 0.006930740550160408, -0.0012615449959412217, 0.030649419873952866, 0.034490395337343216, 0.003093030769377947, -0.018682297319173813, -0.017232133075594902, 0.025711022317409515, -0.01966213807463646, -0.020864076912403107, -0.007080982904881239, 0.002676598494872451, 0.008237195201218128, 0.024156341329216957, 0.014227288775146008, -0.0011994884116575122, -0.0017310520634055138, 0.021033916622400284, -0.033105555921792984, -0.01891745999455452, 0.019845042377710342, -0.0301790963858366, -0.03663298115134239, -0.02767070382833481, -0.010301392525434494, 0.013547931797802448, 0.024927150458097458, -0.0042721061035990715, 0.011431476101279259, 0.03483007475733757, 0.005670011974871159, 0.011104862205684185, 0.016278421506285667, -0.01363938394933939, -0.04253815487027168, 0.009994376450777054, -0.018329555168747902, 0.024966344237327576, -0.017806973308324814, -0.03590136766433716, 0.014645353890955448, -0.04031718149781227, -0.028141027316451073, 0.04768558591604233, -0.00434069475159049, -0.004556259606033564, 0.0052617453038692474, 0.01650051958858967, -0.0008761409553699195, -0.022614724934101105, 0.0026978282257914543, -0.002818675246089697, -0.03812234103679657, 0.012888172641396523, -0.007139773108065128, -0.030231354758143425, 0.019936494529247284, -0.006140335462987423, 0.008511550724506378, 0.0150895481929183, -0.025776345282793045, -0.012829381972551346, 0.00015238566265907139, 0.015298580750823021, -0.042146217077970505, 0.00923010054975748, 0.03289652243256569, 0.03989911824464798, 0.016774874180555344, 0.042590413242578506, -0.028820384293794632, 0.00527154328301549, 0.029029415920376778, -0.009948650375008583, -0.01630455069243908, -0.012483172118663788, 0.012613817118108273, 0.004866542760282755, -0.020903270691633224, 0.017571812495589256, -0.040526214987039566, -0.020955529063940048, 0.0005540183046832681, -0.0017604472814127803, 0.020223913714289665, -0.028323931619524956, 0.011483734473586082, -0.004543195012956858, 0.028271673247218132, 0.014736805111169815, 0.02321569435298443, 0.006346102338284254, -0.03454265370965004, 0.037782661616802216, -0.006871950346976519, 0.0583723820745945, 0.0073814671486616135, 0.009759214706718922, 0.0038017823826521635, -0.008981874212622643, -0.0065290057100355625, 0.027905866503715515, 0.004585654940456152, 0.0023597832769155502, -0.007904049009084702, -0.008446227759122849, 0.018120521679520607, 0.0395071804523468, 0.001127633498981595, -0.00874671246856451, -0.018512459471821785, -0.027200380340218544, -0.0056765442714095116, 0.005314003210514784, -0.03198200464248657, -0.006904611364006996, 0.008994938805699348, 0.005523035768419504, 0.006976466625928879, 0.016539713367819786, -0.002292827470228076, -0.006930740550160408, -0.003445773385465145, 0.028715867549180984, -0.014802128076553345, -0.0031485550571233034, 0.005265010986477137, 0.010954620316624641, 0.032400067895650864, -0.020132461562752724, 0.007479451596736908, 0.006297110114246607, -0.01418809499591589, 0.05607302114367485, -0.018839072436094284, -0.03867105022072792, 0.04047395661473274, 0.023189565166831017, -0.015651322901248932, 0.0009471794473938644, 0.0030783331021666527, 0.012809785082936287, 0.038043953478336334, 0.006107674445956945, 0.010837038978934288, -0.015403097495436668, -0.00483388127759099, 0.0018192377174273133, 0.0035208945628255606, 0.031198130920529366, -0.009824536740779877, 0.01412277203053236, -0.011692767031490803, 0.009138648398220539, -0.02027617208659649, -0.010628006421029568, -0.02346392162144184, -0.01288164034485817, -0.01694471389055252, -0.029238449409604073, -0.004686905071139336, 0.01591261476278305, -0.03428136184811592, -0.013234383426606655, 0.007427193224430084, 0.02514924667775631, 0.00792364589869976, -0.024482956156134605, 0.0011896900832653046, -0.00761009706184268, 0.02405182458460331, 0.01405744906514883, 0.04198944568634033, -0.05879044905304909, 0.0445500947535038, -0.04441944882273674, 0.004543195012956858, -0.055027857422828674, 0.000547486066352576, -0.025554247200489044, 0.003785451641306281, 0.06777885556221008, -0.013214786536991596, 0.03098909743130207, -0.021060043945908546, -0.005046179983764887, -0.022261982783675194, 0.02572408691048622, 0.038435887545347214, -0.00008594020619057119, 0.013952933251857758, -0.02137359417974949, -0.03030974231660366, 0.0014934407081454992, -0.01494583860039711, 0.00826332438737154, 0.005836585070937872, -0.029133932664990425, 0.014789063483476639, -0.03307942673563957, -0.015324709936976433, -0.0003529468085616827, 0.025136182084679604, 0.008015098050236702, 0.03263523057103157, 0.0015252855373546481, -0.010536554269492626, -0.002833372913300991, -0.0009871895890682936, 0.007525177206844091, -0.0007487616967409849, -0.0036907335743308067, 0.005679810419678688, 0.009752682410180569, -0.021896176040172577, 0.011490266770124435, -0.009465262293815613, 0.013175592757761478, 0.018225038424134254, 0.010510426014661789, -0.012097767554223537, -0.018643103539943695, 0.026011506095528603, -0.0017081891419366002, -0.028036510571837425, -0.010569215752184391, -0.012065106071531773, -0.013874545693397522, 0.01426648162305355, -0.022444887086749077, 0.028611350804567337, -0.003707064315676689, 0.0026014773175120354, 0.01363938394933939, -0.011157120577991009, -0.031145872548222542, -0.0006956869619898498, 0.0003719312371686101, 0.007570903282612562, -0.036554593592882156, 0.01488051563501358, 0.0018094393890351057, -0.016056325286626816, 0.010830506682395935, -0.01927020214498043, 0.00347843486815691, 0.05701366811990738, -0.03814846649765968, 0.005167027004063129, 0.040212664753198624, 0.0342291034758091, -0.009034132584929466, -0.014906644821166992, -0.031015226617455482, -0.006728240288794041, -0.00428517023101449, 0.028846513479948044, -0.012790188193321228, -0.03759975731372833, -0.011954057961702347, 0.005333600100129843, -0.03647620603442192, 0.012679140083491802, -0.03464717045426369, -0.006444086320698261, -0.02740941382944584, 0.0024528680369257927, 0.029421353712677956, -0.02811489813029766, -0.006607393268495798, 0.034072332084178925, -0.0018976250430569053, -0.009772279299795628, -0.0233724694699049, -0.040630731731653214, 0.04402751475572586, 0.00477835675701499, 0.01843407191336155, -0.03974234312772751, -0.005663479678332806, 0.025253763422369957, -0.01663116365671158, 0.006270980928093195, -0.0031158938072621822, 0.004716300405561924, 0.006061948370188475, 0.014488579705357552, 0.036685239523649216, -0.006091343704611063, 0.00028497035964392126, 0.003452305682003498, -0.00966776255518198, 0.0026798646431416273, -0.004944929853081703, -0.0570659264922142, 0.0013187023578211665, 0.014998096041381359, 0.016539713367819786, 0.00198091147467494, 0.03564007580280304, -0.03185135871171951, -0.015546807087957859, -0.016578907147049904, -0.018329555168747902, 0.003093030769377947, 0.02043294720351696, -0.0066727157682180405, 0.006221989169716835, 0.06814466416835785, -0.015651322901248932, -0.0037560563068836927, -0.023973438888788223, 0.006679248064756393, -0.05372140556573868, 0.010366715490818024, 0.027095863595604897, -0.035457171499729156, -0.012156558223068714, 0.02166101336479187, -0.028350060805678368, 0.004905736073851585, 0.015246322378516197, 0.004281904082745314, -0.0010410808026790619, -0.033131685107946396, -0.01175155770033598, -0.012476639822125435, 0.009066793136298656, -0.006071746814996004, 0.031015226617455482, 0.021778594702482224, -0.00787791982293129, -0.010000908747315407, -0.01927020214498043, -0.019583750516176224, -0.024522148072719574, 0.005663479678332806, -0.0020233711693435907, 0.010510426014661789, -0.00337391858920455, -0.003550289897248149, -0.019714396446943283, 0.006055416073650122, -0.020472140982747078, 0.003609080333262682, 0.012463575229048729, 0.0200802031904459, -0.026364250108599663, 0.0399513766169548, 0.02475731074810028, 0.00723122525960207, -0.012764059007167816, -0.005013518966734409, -0.007316144648939371, 0.013031882233917713, -0.00803469493985176, -0.02517537586390972, -0.014593095518648624, -0.030753936618566513, 0.007028724532574415, 0.04995881766080856, 0.0008120430866256356, -0.0039977505803108215, 0.015664387494325638, -0.00030048450571484864, 0.02837618999183178, 0.015494548715651035, -0.02501860074698925, 0.021830853074789047, -0.017062295228242874, -0.021517304703593254, 0.04541235417127609, 0.04068299010396004, 0.011424943804740906, 0.03582298010587692, -0.005572027992457151, 0.026168281212449074, 0.013260511681437492, -0.025580376386642456, -0.01069986168295145, -0.0028039778117090464, 0.0062546501867473125, -0.00598029512912035, 0.0006381213315762579, -0.010111956857144833, 0.011986719444394112, -0.019649073481559753, -0.010608409531414509, -0.002774582477286458, 0.02620747499167919, -0.005585092585533857, 0.04282557591795921, -0.02298053354024887, 0.007616628892719746, -0.012803252786397934, -0.03151167929172516, -0.03937653452157974, 0.015076483599841595, -0.01071945857256651, -0.03190361708402634, -0.021582625806331635, 0.0134956743568182, 0.02418247051537037, 0.017989877611398697, -0.006976466625928879, 0.02624666877090931, 0.016513584181666374, -0.008452760055661201, -0.042721059173345566, 0.015612130053341389, 0.025946184992790222, 0.005500173196196556, 0.016409067437052727, 0.0006466949125751853, 0.009510988369584084, -0.03127651661634445, -0.021216819062829018, -0.010601877234876156, -0.0222750473767519, 0.004324364010244608, -0.0145408371463418, -0.024587471038103104, 0.009700424037873745, -0.0034751687198877335, 0.02921232022345066, -0.011170185171067715, -0.016409067437052727, -0.016905520111322403, 0.0030848653987050056, 0.0362149141728878, 0.00274845352396369, -0.004036943893879652, -0.003543757600709796, -0.024234728887677193, -0.023672953248023987, -0.0034490395337343216, 0.01494583860039711, 0.02137359417974949, -0.02569795772433281, 0.035300396382808685, 0.03945492208003998, 0.03574459254741669, -0.018159715458750725, 0.0020103068090975285, -0.004990655928850174, -0.015559871681034565, 0.006708643399178982, 0.009726553224027157, 0.00685235345736146, 0.0052552130073308945, -0.029160061851143837, -0.023751340806484222, -0.014958903193473816, -0.0020560326520353556, -0.028062639757990837, 0.0019956091418862343, 0.017454231157898903, -0.0025965780951082706, -0.031093614175915718, 0.003938959911465645, 0.041179440915584564, -0.0025002271868288517, 0.01329970546066761, 0.00902106799185276, -0.0013570794835686684, 0.016317615285515785, 0.012875108048319817, -0.006166464649140835, -0.001419952604919672, -0.01876068487763405, -0.025959249585866928, 0.018904395401477814, 0.016565842553973198, 0.021556496620178223, -0.0073749348521232605, 0.013730836100876331, -0.0030326072592288256, -0.008870825171470642, 0.011856073513627052, -0.03535265475511551, 0.03961169719696045, 0.0005111502832733095, -0.03454265370965004, -0.007949775084853172, -0.014749869704246521, 0.011535991914570332, -0.03300103917717934, 0.01315599586814642, 0.0118495412170887, -0.0036319431383162737, 0.033654265105724335, 0.012208816595375538, 0.03631943091750145, 0.01913955621421337, -0.020681172609329224, -0.0021376858931034803, 0.0058267866261303425, 0.027383284643292427, -0.003837709780782461, 0.018355684354901314, -0.008668324910104275, 0.006930740550160408, 0.02379053458571434, 0.015259386971592903, 0.00020372522703837603, -0.03300103917717934, 0.0012019380228593946, 0.040656860917806625, -0.02098165825009346, 0.0026978282257914543, 0.013482609763741493, 0.007459854707121849, 0.012666075490415096, 0.027905866503715515, -0.009171309880912304, 0.015599065460264683, 0.03096296824514866, 0.040656860917806625, -0.00831558182835579, -0.009680827148258686, -0.020184719935059547, 0.043008480221033096, 0.05126526951789856, 0.016696486622095108, -0.009275826625525951, 0.0181074570864439, -0.014344869181513786, 0.01788536086678505, 0.030884582549333572, -0.0033363578841090202, -0.005572027992457151, 0.017963748425245285, -0.036241043359041214, 0.023359404876828194, 0.03728620707988739, -0.006911143660545349, 0.024848762899637222, 0.014279546216130257, -0.020537463948130608, 0.003367386292666197, -0.00819800142198801, 0.001992342993617058, -0.03924588859081268, 0.015651322901248932, -0.024992473423480988, -0.0004637913079932332, -0.014044384472072124, 0.023281017318367958, 0.023751340806484222, -0.00043684570118784904, 0.015076483599841595, -0.00413166219368577, -0.019165685400366783, 0.029107803478837013, 0.02618134580552578, 0.016017131507396698, -0.022640854120254517, 0.006251384504139423, -0.027775220572948456, 0.018421007320284843, 0.005046179983764887, -0.012966560199856758, 0.015128741972148418, 0.023829728364944458, 0.05455753579735756, -0.010066230781376362, 0.014161965809762478, 0.021674077957868576, -0.010823974385857582, 0.016356809064745903, 0.05393043905496597, 0.01118324976414442, 0.006591062527149916, 0.0034229105804115534, -0.017519554123282433, 0.019962623715400696, 0.0017375843599438667, -0.011209378950297832, -0.00009793304343475029, -0.07112337648868561, 0.014789063483476639, -0.033105555921792984, -0.005977028980851173, 0.010477764531970024, -0.012084702961146832, 0.00008435816562268883, 0.02530602179467678, 0.018643103539943695, -0.006826224271208048, 0.011627444066107273, 0.038043953478336334, -0.007538241799920797, -0.029917806386947632, -0.005751665681600571, 0.02146504633128643, -0.02288908138871193, -0.01265301089733839, 0.040656860917806625, 0.0206289142370224, -0.017833102494478226, -0.024718116968870163, -0.008367840200662613, 0.004396218806505203, -0.017859231680631638, 0.007080982904881239, -0.008269856683909893, 0.018120521679520607, -0.007864855229854584, -0.003413112135604024, 0.014044384472072124, -0.03574459254741669, -0.003354321699589491, 0.01044510304927826, 0.014593095518648624, -0.0351174958050251, -0.02034149505198002, 0.032295551151037216, -0.02795812487602234, -0.0004899203777313232, 0.027357155457139015, -0.024195535108447075, 0.0014673116384074092, 0.0024985941126942635, 0.02181778848171234, -0.019583750516176224, 0.05296366289258003, 0.03903685882687569, 0.016565842553973198, 0.012202284298837185, 0.007975904271006584, 0.021909240633249283, 0.0264426376670599, 0.013358496129512787, 0.015808098018169403, 0.0035535560455173254, -0.019061170518398285, 0.01363938394933939, 0.02330714650452137, 0.018421007320284843, -0.03263523057103157, 0.01687939092516899, 0.01336502842605114, -0.000566674571018666, -0.027043605223298073, -0.03250458464026451, 0.04185879975557327, 0.010850103572010994, -0.02262778952717781, 0.0003496806893963367, 0.008603001944720745, -0.003106095362454653, 0.018277296796441078, -0.017192939296364784, 0.03485620394349098, -0.018094392493367195, 0.00934768095612526, -0.006476747803390026, -0.04355718940496445, 0.023816663771867752, -0.037207819521427155, -0.002403876045718789, -0.008812034502625465, -0.01571664586663246, 0.004513800144195557, -0.00836130790412426, 0.0048436797223985195, 0.023281017318367958, -0.02611602284014225, -0.016017131507396698, -0.004530130419880152, -0.034464266151189804, 0.021804723888635635, -0.0007573352777399123, 0.012770591303706169, 0.013560996390879154, -0.016866326332092285, -0.04418428614735603, -0.0049873897805809975, 0.004997188225388527, 0.024482956156134605, 0.020093267783522606, -0.02130827121436596, -0.0019645807333290577, -0.0335758775472641, 0.019923429936170578, -0.0006916042766533792, 0.006610659416764975, 0.016840197145938873, 0.019845042377710342, 0.025959249585866928, 0.010497361421585083, -0.010275264270603657, 0.005170293152332306, -0.05296366289258003, 0.005199688486754894, -0.000547486066352576, -0.003556822193786502 ]
10.268952
6.272073
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.531.4108K
[ "stellar halo substructure", "DESI MWS", "halo stars", "accreted halo stars", "halo", "MWS", "rich accretion histories", "ancient dwarf galaxy accretion events", "DESI target selection", "dark matter" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
23
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1415", "10.48550/arXiv.2406.08921" ]
[ "Kizhuprakkat, Namitha", "Cooper, Andrew P.", "Riley, Alexander H.", "Koposov, Sergey E.", "Aguilar, Jessica Nicole", "Ahlen, Steven", "Allende Prieto, Carlos", "Brooks, David", "Claybaugh, Todd", "Dawson, Kyle", "de la Macorra, Axel", "Doel, Peter", "Forero-Romero, Jaime E.", "Frenk, Carlos", "Gaztañaga, Enrique", "Gnedin, Oleg Y.", "Grand, Robert J. J.", "Gontcho A Gontcho, Satya", "Honscheid, Klaus", "Kehoe, Robert", "Landriau, Martin", "Manera, Marc", "Meisner, Aaron", "Miquel, Ramon", "Nie, Jundan", "Prada, Francisco", "Rezaie, Mehdi", "Rossi, Graziano", "Sanchez, Eusebio", "Schubnell, Michael", "Seo, Hee-Jong", "Tarlé, Gregory", "Valluri, Monica", "Zhou, Zhimin" ]
[ "Institute of Astronomy and Department of Physics, National Tsing Hua University, Hsinchu 30013, Taiwan; Center for Informatics and Computation in Astronomy, National Tsing Hua University, Hsinchu 30013, Taiwan", "Institute of Astronomy and Department of Physics, National Tsing Hua University, Hsinchu 30013, Taiwan; Center for Informatics and Computation in Astronomy, National Tsing Hua University, Hsinchu 30013, Taiwan", "Institute for Computational Cosmology, Department of Physics, Durham University, South Road, Durham DH1 3LE, UK", "Institute for Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, Royal Observatory, Blackford Hill, Edinburgh EH9 3HJ, UK; Institute of Astronomy, University of Cambridge, Madingley Road, Cambridge CB3 0HA, UK; Kavli Institute for Cosmology, University of Cambridge, Madingley Road, Cambridge CB3 0HA, UK", "Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 1 Cyclotron Road, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA", "Physics Department, Boston University, 590 Commonwealth Avenue, Boston, MA 02215, USA", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias, C/ Vía Láctea, s/n, E-38205 La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Departmento de Astrofísica, Universidad de La Laguna, E-38206 La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University College London, Gower Street, London, WC1E 6BT, UK", "Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 1 Cyclotron Road, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, The University of Utah, 115 South 1400 East, Salt Lake City, UT 84112, USA", "Instituto de Física, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Cd. de México C.P. 04510, México", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University College London, Gower Street, London, WC1E 6BT, UK", "Departamento de Física, Universidad de los Andes, Cra. 1 No. 18A-10, Edificio Ip, CP 111711, Bogotá, Colombia; Observatorio Astronómico, Universidad de los Andes, Cra. 1 No. 18A-10, Edificio H, CP 111711 Bogotá, Colombia", "Institute for Computational Cosmology, Department of Physics, Durham University, South Road, Durham DH1 3LE, UK", "Institut d'Estudis Espacials de Catalunya (IEEC), E-08034 Barcelona, Spain; Institute of Cosmology and Gravitation, University of Portsmouth, Dennis Sciama Building, Portsmouth, PO1 3FX, UK; Institute of Space Sciences, ICE-CSIC, Campus UAB, Carrer de Can Magrans s/n, E-08913 Bellaterra, Barcelona, Spain", "Department of Astronomy, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA", "Astrophysics Research Institute, Liverpool John Moores University, 146 Brownlow Hill, Liverpool L3 5RF, UK", "Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 1 Cyclotron Road, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA", "Center for Cosmology and AstroParticle Physics, The Ohio State University, 191 West Woodruff Avenue, Columbus, OH 43210, USA; Department of Physics, The Ohio State University, 191 West Woodruff Avenue, Columbus, OH 43210, USA", "Department of Physics, Southern Methodist University, 3215 Daniel Avenue, Dallas, TX 75275, USA", "Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 1 Cyclotron Road, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA", "Institut de Física d'Altes Energies (IFAE), The Barcelona Institute of Science and Technology, Campus UAB, E-08193 Bellaterra Barcelona, Spain; Departament de Física, Serra Húnter, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, E-08193 Bellaterra (Barcelona), Spain", "NSF's NOIRLab, 950 N. Cherry Ave., Tucson, AZ 85719, USA", "Institut de Física d'Altes Energies (IFAE), The Barcelona Institute of Science and Technology, Campus UAB, E-08193 Bellaterra Barcelona, Spain; Institució Catalana de Recerca i Estudis Avançats, Passeig de Lluís Companys, 23, E-08010 Barcelona, Spain", "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, A20 Datun Rd., Chaoyang District, Beijing 100012, P. R. China", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucía (CSIC), Glorieta de la Astronomía, s/n, E-18008 Granada, Spain", "Department of Physics, Kansas State University, 116 Cardwell Hall, Manhattan, KS 66506, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, Sejong University, Seoul 143-747, Korea", "CIEMAT, Avenida Complutense 40, E-28040 Madrid, Spain", "Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, Ohio University, Athens, OH 45701, USA", "Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA", "Department of Astronomy, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA", "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, A20 Datun Rd., Chaoyang District, Beijing 100012, P. R. China" ]
null
[ "1962ApJ...136..748E", "1975MSRSL...8..369R", "1995MNRAS.277..781I", "2000AJ....119.2843C", "2000MNRAS.319..657H", "2001ApJ...548...33B", "2001MNRAS.328..726S", "2003A&A...409..523R", "2005ApJ...622..759G", "2005ApJ...635..931B", "2006AJ....131.2332G", "2006ApJ...636..804A", "2006MNRAS.373.1293S", "2007A&A...469..239M", "2007CSE.....9...90H", "2007Natur.450.1020C", "2008A&A...482..883M", "2008A&ARv..15..145H", "2008ApJ...673..864J", "2008ApJ...680..295B", "2008ApJ...684..287I", "2008MNRAS.391...14D", "2008MNRAS.391.1685S", "2009AJ....137.4377Y", "2009ApJ...694..130M", "2009ApJ...702.1058Z", "2009MNRAS.398.1757W", "2009astro2010S..14R", "2010A&A...511L..10N", "2010MNRAS.406..744C", "2011ApJ...730....3S", "2011ApJ...731....4S", "2011ApJ...736..146K", "2011MNRAS.416.2802F", "2011MNRAS.416.2903D", "2012MNRAS.425.2840D", "2012MNRAS.427..127B", "2013A&A...558A..33A", "2013ApJ...763..113D", "2013ApJ...770...57B", "2013ApJ...777..154D", "2013ApJ...779..102K", "2014MNRAS.444.2525C", "2014MNRAS.445.4287T", "2015AAS...22533607S", "2015MNRAS.446.2274L", "2015MNRAS.450.2132H", "2015MNRAS.452.1068C", "2015MNRAS.454.3185C", "2016A&A...595A...1G", "2016ARA&A..54..529B", "2016ApJ...821....5D", "2016ApJ...827L..23W", "2016MNRAS.459L..46M", "2016arXiv161100036D", "2017A&A...608A.145B", "2017ApJ...845..101B", "2017MNRAS.464.2882A", "2017MNRAS.464L..80P", "2017MNRAS.467..179G", "2017MNRAS.468.4887W", "2017MNRAS.469.1691C", "2017arXiv171103234K", "2018A&A...616A...1G", "2018AJ....156..123A", "2018ApJ...862L...1D", "2018MNRAS.474.3629G", "2018MNRAS.478..548S", "2018MNRAS.478..611B", "2018MNRAS.481.1726G", "2018Natur.563...85H", "2018PASP..130b5005F", "2018SPIE10702E..1FM", "2019ApJ...883..107C", "2019JOSS....4.1298Z", "2019MNRAS.484.1285S", "2019MNRAS.484.4471F", "2019MNRAS.485.2589M", "2019MNRAS.486..378L", "2019MNRAS.487L..72G", "2019MNRAS.490L..32S", "2019Msngr.175....3D", "2019ascl.soft07013K", "2020ApJ...897L..18B", "2020ApJS..246....6S", "2020MNRAS.496..638H", "2020NatMe..17..261V", "2020Natur.585..357H", "2021A&A...649A...1G", "2021ApJ...908..191C", "2021ApJ...923...92N", "2021MNRAS.507.4953G", "2022ApJ...937...12A", "2022ApJS..259...60R", "2022MNRAS.514..689B", "2022arXiv220409057N", "2022arXiv220614908G", "2022arXiv221111765L", "2023AJ....165...50M", "2023AJ....165..253H", "2023ApJ...947...37C", "2023ApJ...949...44S", "2023MNRAS.520.5225M", "2023arXiv231202268T", "2024AJ....167...62D", "2024AJ....168...58D", "2024ApJ...966..108N", "2024MNRAS.530.2688J", "2024MNRAS.532.1814G" ]
29184342
2407.01889
ALMA Reveals Spatially Resolved Properties of Molecular Gas in the Host Galaxy of FRB 20191001A at z = 0.2340
We report the detection of the CO(2–1) emission line with a spatial resolution of 0.″9 (3.5 kpc) from the host galaxy of the fast radio burst (FRB), FRB 20191001A at z = 0.2340, using the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array. This is the first detection of spatially resolved CO emission from the host galaxy of an FRB at a cosmological distance. The inferred molecular gas mass of the host galaxy is (2.3 ± 0.4) × 10<SUP>10</SUP> M <SUB>⊙</SUB>, indicating that it is gas-rich, as evidenced by the measured molecular gas fraction μ <SUB>gas</SUB> = 0.50 ± 0.22. This molecular gas mass and the star formation rate of the host, SFR = (8.06 ± 2.42) M <SUB>⊙</SUB> yr<SUP>‑1</SUP>, differ from those observed in the other FRB host galaxies with the average M <SUB>gas</SUB> = 9.6 × 10<SUP>8</SUP> M <SUB>⊙</SUB> and SFR = 0.90M <SUB>⊙</SUB> yr<SUP>‑1</SUP>. This lends further credibility to the hypothesis that FRBs may originate from single or multiple progenitors across a diverse range of galaxy environments. Based on the observed velocity field modeling, we find that the molecular gas disk is dominated by an ordered circular rotation, despite the fact that the host galaxy has a gas-rich companion galaxy with a projected separation of ∼25 kpc. The formation of the FRB's progenitor might not have been triggered by this interaction. We derive the 3σ upper limit of the molecular gas column density at the FRB detection site to be &lt;2.1 × 10<SUP>21</SUP> cm<SUP>‑2</SUP> with a 3σ upper limit.
[ -0.0027364357374608517, 0.008977330289781094, 0.000902426487300545, -0.00592799624428153, -0.04219003766775131, 0.04642269387841225, 0.007845208048820496, -0.01974102295935154, -0.02192562073469162, -0.005768702365458012, 0.0029526199214160442, 0.04476149007678032, -0.008573407307267189, -0.012504545040428638, 0.007344570942223072, 0.009916024282574654, -0.05097394064068794, 0.005253843031823635, -0.0011257219593971968, -0.014461579732596874, -0.0082491310313344, -0.019012823700904846, -0.041188765317201614, -0.011127793230116367, -0.02867284044623375, -0.04253138229250908, 0.010775071568787098, 0.00844824779778719, -0.029969945549964905, -0.033679209649562836, 0.0010809205705299973, -0.028945915400981903, -0.02883213385939598, -0.043327849358320236, -0.0578463189303875, 0.03208627551794052, -0.016020381823182106, -0.027739835903048515, -0.019581729546189308, 0.01324412226676941, -0.024895308539271355, -0.0018020083662122488, -0.016100028529763222, -0.02217593975365162, -0.0271481741219759, -0.01897869072854519, -0.030993975698947906, -0.0040022507309913635, -0.0014947993913665414, -0.010041183792054653, -0.0634443536400795, 0.02730746753513813, -0.011810479685664177, -0.02639721892774105, -0.031289808452129364, 0.007577822078019381, 0.011730832979083061, 0.03711539879441261, 0.005586652550846338, 0.04521661624312401, -0.004164388868957758, -0.024076083675026894, 0.020230282098054886, -0.028035666793584824, -0.010314257815480232, -0.000029600867492263205, -0.002983909798786044, 0.01061008870601654, 0.06781354546546936, 0.02491806447505951, -0.012402141466736794, 0.002422115532681346, -0.006007642950862646, -0.0553431361913681, 0.03647822514176369, -0.05461493507027626, 0.03600034490227699, 0.003211471950635314, -0.09630433470010757, -0.024758771061897278, 0.008152416907250881, -0.004411862697452307, -0.013096206821501255, -0.03374747931957245, -0.03600034490227699, -0.017977416515350342, 0.03695610538125038, 0.018910421058535576, -0.046308912336826324, -0.0005831281887367368, 0.024804282933473587, 0.000012755929674312938, 0.013255500234663486, 0.02528216317296028, 0.003183026798069477, -0.06480972468852997, 0.024440184235572815, -0.014552604407072067, 0.07013467699289322, -0.0055269175209105015, -0.005652077030390501, 0.03122153878211975, 0.015462853945791721, -0.05893861874938011, 0.027193685993552208, 0.023484421893954277, 0.017727097496390343, 0.008544961921870708, 0.025964850559830666, -0.0017650295048952103, 0.08328777551651001, 0.013369280844926834, -0.00442893011495471, 0.050018180161714554, -0.05648094415664673, 0.005000680219382048, -0.054888010025024414, -0.022961029782891273, -0.03406606614589691, 0.023689229041337967, 0.013141718693077564, 0.04942651465535164, -0.03151736781001091, 0.022244207561016083, 0.05161111429333687, -0.017374375835061073, 0.004255413543432951, -0.024849794805049896, -0.02425813302397728, 0.049107927829027176, 0.02821771614253521, -0.02035544067621231, -0.011139171198010445, 0.022608308121562004, -0.049517542123794556, -0.02887764759361744, 0.018204977735877037, -0.052111752331256866, -0.0011435002088546753, -0.014120236039161682, -0.005842660088092089, -0.005265220999717712, 0.053067512810230255, 0.027193685993552208, 0.009347118437290192, 0.03675130009651184, -0.0684962347149849, 0.018739750608801842, 0.00020107255841139704, 0.0017508069286122918, -0.039163459092378616, 0.0017166725592687726, -0.012094932608306408, -0.04578552022576332, 0.016225187107920647, -0.032768961042165756, 0.011247263289988041, 0.006986160296946764, -0.019627243280410767, -0.009102488867938519, -0.021402228623628616, 0.008596163243055344, -0.013141718693077564, 0.010439417324960232, 0.02933277189731598, 0.012697972357273102, -0.045557957142591476, 0.006707396823912859, -0.07573270797729492, 0.00789640937000513, 0.009631571359932423, -0.004258258268237114, -0.024121595546603203, -0.040324028581380844, 0.0061669363640248775, 0.04558071494102478, 0.022198695689439774, -0.021789083257317543, 0.0005123706068843603, 0.016680311411619186, -0.03536317124962807, -0.002211620332673192, 0.03192698210477829, 0.014063346199691296, 0.030288532376289368, 0.01664617657661438, 0.01121881790459156, 0.03647822514176369, 0.03759327903389931, -0.018591834232211113, 0.015519743785262108, 0.016304833814501762, 0.018534943461418152, 0.041120495647192, -0.030993975698947906, -0.04492078348994255, -0.009557614102959633, -0.00007031317363725975, -0.01408610213547945, 0.009705529548227787, 0.021151909604668617, 0.0016028914833441377, 0.03836699202656746, -0.050882913172245026, -0.06831417977809906, -0.03229108080267906, 0.053022000938653946, 0.007566444110125303, -0.0009500723099336028, 0.015292181633412838, 0.06339883804321289, 0.022414879873394966, 0.010462173260748386, 0.007566444110125303, -0.04153010621666908, -0.018967311829328537, -0.009745352901518345, 0.028809377923607826, 0.06389947235584259, -0.014302286319434643, -0.020685406401753426, 0.03898141160607338, 0.022710710763931274, 0.020230282098054886, 0.010945742949843407, 0.014256773516535759, 0.022665198892354965, -0.004938100464642048, 0.06176038831472397, -0.0026710117235779762, 0.02578280121088028, 0.004039229825139046, 0.007560755126178265, -0.0426224060356617, 0.019456570968031883, 0.045398663729429245, -0.008089837618172169, 0.030743656679987907, -0.01235662866383791, -0.04080190882086754, -0.016759958118200302, 0.014359177090227604, 0.03188147023320198, 0.013312390074133873, 0.013517196290194988, -0.009125245735049248, -0.00008071347838267684, -0.02176632732152939, 0.057982854545116425, 0.006946336943656206, 0.05274892598390579, 0.007054429035633802, -0.005842660088092089, -0.028513547033071518, -0.018762506544589996, 0.012550056912004948, -0.03791186586022377, 0.03850352764129639, -0.047833580523729324, -0.011651186272501945, -0.02482703886926174, -0.020924346521496773, -0.06672124564647675, 0.015917977318167686, -0.019763778895139694, 0.01679409295320511, 0.02242625690996647, 0.0042127459309995174, -0.017772609367966652, 0.02878662198781967, -0.016316212713718414, -0.037684306502342224, 0.04988164082169533, -0.02680683135986328, -0.05543415993452072, 0.041552864015102386, 0.030948463827371597, 0.02197113260626793, 0.015269425697624683, -0.025213895365595818, 0.0037803775630891323, 0.007242167834192514, 0.03948204591870308, 0.0030607120133936405, -0.050518814474344254, -0.03481702134013176, 0.008874926716089249, 0.0294465534389019, -0.015474231913685799, -0.03135807439684868, 0.08588198572397232, -0.01745402254164219, -0.0016853827983140945, -0.006019020918756723, -0.06380844861268997, -0.034134335815906525, 0.06958852708339691, 0.015474231913685799, -0.025418700650334358, 0.018739750608801842, 0.016418615356087685, 0.028968671336770058, 0.03902692347764969, 0.020696785300970078, -0.03188147023320198, 0.026943368837237358, 0.03691059350967407, 0.05679953098297119, -0.005589497275650501, 0.04330509155988693, -0.021709436550736427, 0.02396230213344097, 0.011378111317753792, -0.010467862710356712, -0.057937342673540115, 0.015110132284462452, 0.005990575533360243, 0.039823390543460846, 0.035249389708042145, -0.04746948182582855, -0.008567717857658863, -0.030789170414209366, 0.006462767254561186, 0.011122103780508041, -0.01699889823794365, -0.0005500605911947787, 0.026465486735105515, -0.021436361595988274, -0.018091198056936264, -0.009961537085473537, 0.03440741077065468, 0.036364443600177765, 0.06631163507699966, 0.0013106162659823895, -0.011429312638938427, -0.05811939388513565, 0.007651779800653458, 0.04578552022576332, 0.013835784047842026, -0.007060118019580841, -0.004090431146323681, 0.022460391744971275, -0.017681585624814034, 0.005120150279253721, -0.011651186272501945, 0.05156560242176056, 0.05270341411232948, -0.016759958118200302, 0.0031972492579370737, -0.039413779973983765, 0.011708077043294907, 0.0009628726984374225, 0.03575002774596214, -0.0223238542675972, 0.050473302602767944, -0.00783951859921217, 0.060986679047346115, 0.003825889900326729, 0.020025476813316345, -0.008112593553960323, -0.02192562073469162, 0.004938100464642048, 0.07527758926153183, -0.003524370025843382, -0.010268745943903923, -0.004673559218645096, -0.03559073433279991, 0.012220092117786407, -0.0019797913264483213, -0.06180590018630028, 0.004650803282856941, -0.012902778573334217, -0.02015063539147377, 0.0025415855925530195, -0.04385124146938324, -0.027079906314611435, 0.029856164008378983, -0.0040989648550748825, 0.014928082004189491, -0.013130340725183487, 0.03745674341917038, 0.0011470558820292354, -0.010081007145345211, -0.035294901579618454, 0.027694324031472206, -0.0038970031309872866, -0.019069714471697807, -0.017499536275863647, -0.07728013396263123, 0.02147049643099308, -0.022926894947886467, 0.006030398886650801, 0.07295645028352737, -0.03397504240274429, -0.04378297179937363, -0.0010645645670592785, 0.06676676124334335, 0.04856178164482117, 0.0066391280852258205, 0.055707234889268875, -0.02045784518122673, -0.030993975698947906, 0.009324362501502037, 0.0035414372105151415, -0.017044411972165108, 0.0035556599032133818, -0.0019911695271730423, 0.07336606085300446, 0.027330223470926285, 0.0034617905039340258, 0.01563352532684803, -0.057436708360910416, 0.013039316050708294, -0.008914750069379807, 0.012823131866753101, 0.06758598238229752, -0.0649462640285492, 0.018387028947472572, -0.05957579240202904, 0.03952755779027939, 0.04983612895011902, 0.03709264472126961, 0.022676575928926468, 0.050427790731191635, -0.021083639934659004, 0.003168804105371237, -0.0049665458500385284, 0.006257961504161358, 0.0030493338126689196, -0.022005267441272736, 0.0020494824275374413, -0.019320033490657806, 0.030493339523673058, -0.03456670418381691, -0.0029895987827330828, 0.017590560019016266, -0.005617942661046982, 0.028490791097283363, -0.03122153878211975, -0.0023453133180737495, -0.011912882328033447, 0.03563624620437622, 0.04244035482406616, -0.052157264202833176, 0.0075038643553853035, -0.00929022766649723, 0.034179847687482834, 0.026715805754065514, 0.02710266225039959, -0.030993975698947906, -0.017772609367966652, -0.058802079409360886, 0.0014990662457421422, 0.025851069018244743, -0.05893861874938011, 0.00809552613645792, 0.008670121431350708, -0.018057063221931458, 0.028695596382021904, -0.0279218852519989, -0.0009372719214297831, 0.011264330707490444, -0.03538592532277107, 0.003723487025126815, -0.06795008480548859, 0.00915937963873148, -0.004363505635410547, -0.006513969041407108, 0.01655515283346176, 0.026556512340903282, 0.0017536514205858111, -0.07327503710985184, -0.008670121431350708, 0.007304747588932514, -0.018307382240891457, -0.013847162015736103, -0.020059609785676003, -0.01912660524249077, 0.04801563173532486, 0.03210902959108353, 0.01053613144904375, 0.04394226521253586, 0.031904224306344986, -0.020332684740424156, 0.008749768137931824, 0.03645547106862068, 0.003962427377700806, 0.0537957102060318, -0.0197979137301445, -0.037638794630765915, -0.02339339815080166, -0.023438910022377968, 0.056571971625089645, -0.009176447056233883, -0.014370555058121681, -0.035408683121204376, -0.028331497684121132, -0.022824492305517197, -0.002992443274706602, -0.018239112570881844, 0.03356542810797691, 0.020025476813316345, 0.03998268395662308, -0.029969945549964905, -0.007816762663424015, 0.0598943792283535, -0.052202776074409485, 0.0035556599032133818, -0.010917297564446926, 0.04307752847671509, 0.04649096354842186, 0.03379299119114876, -0.0014578205300495028, -0.0012274137698113918, 0.0009692728635855019, -0.021834595128893852, -0.011514648795127869, 0.04036954045295715, -0.013756136409938335, 0.0016313367523252964, 0.0649917721748352, -0.03493080288171768, 0.009028531610965729, 0.027034392580389977, -0.01963862031698227, -0.013938186690211296, -0.018489431589841843, -0.06776802986860275, -0.033929526805877686, -0.07454938441514969, 0.010268745943903923, -0.019729645922780037, -0.02867284044623375, 0.035659000277519226, -0.0083742905408144, -0.013027938082814217, -0.03279171884059906, 0.007213722914457321, -0.003652373794466257, -0.0075835115276277065, 0.007350259926170111, -0.007856586016714573, -0.039573073387145996, -0.013585465028882027, 0.025919338688254356, 0.041894204914569855, -0.021095018833875656, 0.013778893277049065, 0.032313838601112366, 0.053932249546051025, 0.022881383076310158, 0.02238074503839016, 0.023894034326076508, 0.011787723749876022, 0.004602446220815182, -0.00451711006462574, -0.021800462156534195, -0.03329235315322876, 0.00027911929646506906, -0.014120236039161682, -0.007031673099845648, 0.007987434044480324, -0.015075997449457645, 0.041120495647192, -0.002750658430159092, -0.03427087143063545, 0.002262821886688471, -0.02878662198781967, -0.02812669239938259, -0.014791545458137989, 0.009779486805200577, -0.019581729546189308, 0.013016559183597565, -0.017328863963484764, 0.017135435715317726, -0.0025757199618965387, -0.02050335705280304, 0.02446294017136097, 0.027489516884088516, -0.02294965088367462, -0.009654327295720577, 0.008988708257675171, 0.0070373620837926865, 0.043828487396240234, -0.01583833061158657, -0.0031744930893182755, 0.021174665540456772, 0.0056008752435445786, 0.0014158637495711446, -0.031699419021606445, -0.0007829563110135496, -0.00984206609427929, 0.003276896197348833, 0.0025842536706477404, -0.004235501866787672, 0.0027165240608155727, 0.0019385457271710038, 0.024030571803450584, -0.029514821246266365, -0.0028303051367402077, 0.007759871892631054, -0.0324731320142746, -0.04482975974678993, -0.009500723332166672, -0.012208713218569756, 0.024736015126109123, 0.00844824779778719, -0.008254819549620152, -0.015462853945791721, -0.004147321451455355, -0.0010645645670592785, 0.026511000469326973, -0.03315581753849983, -0.012265603989362717, 0.011662564240396023, 0.007941922172904015, -0.01786363497376442, -0.030993975698947906, 0.012550056912004948, 0.03126705065369606, -0.007822452113032341, -0.01088885311037302, 0.023029297590255737, -0.011719455011188984, 0.009483655914664268, 0.006531035993248224, -0.02557799406349659, 0.0067529091611504555, 0.00893181748688221, -0.020412331447005272, 0.01751091331243515, -0.050382278859615326, 0.011890126392245293, 0.016942007467150688, -0.010524753481149673, -0.004727605264633894, -0.011349665932357311, 0.060986679047346115, -0.03848077356815338, -0.05711812153458595, 0.03411157801747322, 0.007048740051686764, 0.03358818590641022, -0.02685234323143959, 0.03593207523226738, -0.0006055288831703365, -0.00632054079324007, -0.017340242862701416, -0.03547695279121399, -0.02045784518122673, 0.00277341459877789, 0.008300332352519035, 0.0007509553688578308, 0.007560755126178265, 0.02126569114625454, 0.005677677690982819, 0.02751227281987667, 0.013426171615719795, -0.005398913752287626, 0.03379299119114876, 0.02669304981827736, 0.02628343738615513, -0.022801736369729042, 0.019479326903820038, -0.014393310993909836, 0.037889111787080765, -0.011588606983423233, -0.00491249980404973, -0.010718180797994137, 0.018853530287742615, 0.07190966606140137, -0.05557069554924965, -0.011878748424351215, 0.011423624120652676, 0.003148892428725958, 0.008414113894104958, 0.005748790688812733, -0.007054429035633802, -0.01999134197831154, -0.0003397433029022068, 0.0012722150422632694, -0.02152738720178604, -0.0031403587199747562, -0.016862360760569572, -0.0025486969389021397, 0.009836377575993538, 0.0029554644133895636, -0.0009301606332883239, -0.02644273079931736, 0.006144180428236723, -0.0007623334531672299, 0.0026155433151870966, 0.020878834649920464, 0.05370468646287918, 0.005643543321639299, -0.06512831151485443, 0.002442027209326625, -0.00999567098915577, 0.023006541654467583, 0.0021860196720808744, 0.03085743822157383, 0.0032712069805711508, -0.004164388868957758, -0.029969945549964905, 0.004440308082848787, -0.029469309374690056, 0.020230282098054886, -0.03015199489891529, -0.014017833396792412, 0.006997538730502129, 0.04614961892366409, 0.03138083219528198, -0.01974102295935154, -0.019024202600121498, 0.009546235203742981, 0.01938830129802227, 0.016634799540042877, 0.024531207978725433, -0.01579281874001026, -0.030129238963127136, -0.001975524704903364, 0.00228984490968287, -0.028604572638869286, -0.026010362431406975, 0.04055158793926239, -0.03638720139861107, 0.024394670501351357, 0.007720048539340496, -0.018250491470098495, 0.002574297832325101, 0.04141632467508316, -0.008402734994888306, -0.014131614938378334, -0.016429992392659187, -0.026875099167227745, 0.014199882745742798, 0.017044411972165108, -0.008362911641597748, -0.014268151484429836, 0.03618239611387253, 0.02837700955569744, -0.01614554040133953, -0.0013625288847833872, -0.016327589750289917, -0.008328777737915516, 0.001601469237357378, 0.0061896927654743195, -0.010900231078267097, -0.007782628294080496, -0.0005756613099947572, -0.021948376670479774, 0.007481108419597149, 0.01588384434580803, -0.0031005353666841984, 0.035909321159124374, -0.02223283052444458, 0.036523737013339996, 0.014962216839194298, -0.020628515630960464, 0.014142992906272411, 0.035203877836465836, 0.002133395988494158, 0.020480601117014885, 0.03406606614589691, -0.0157359279692173, 0.04847075417637825, -0.03110775724053383, -0.0039994060061872005, -0.0055269175209105015, -0.0038372681010514498, 0.0018389872275292873, -0.009819310158491135, -0.00489827711135149, 0.00006391298666130751, 0.03936826437711716, -0.012914156541228294, -0.022722089663147926, 0.008812347427010536, -0.03923172876238823, -0.021038128063082695, -0.00721941189840436, -0.047742556780576706, -0.015656281262636185, -0.035408683121204376, -0.028809377923607826, 0.05365917459130287, 0.024440184235572815, -0.002918485552072525, -0.034179847687482834, 0.002776259323582053, 0.004787340294569731, -0.025145625695586205, 0.0020878834184259176, -0.029014185070991516, -0.004980768542736769, 0.040983956307172775, -0.004744672682136297, -0.09521203488111496, 0.006650506053119898, 0.010684046894311905, 0.03477150946855545, -0.029605846852064133, 0.02812669239938259, -0.007981745526194572, 0.05848349258303642, -0.0017977416282519698, -0.020878834649920464, 0.023894034326076508, -0.024804282933473587, -0.03736571967601776, 0.028991427272558212, -0.007560755126178265, -0.007526620756834745, -0.025669019669294357, 0.014461579732596874, 0.01012651901692152, 0.009000086225569248, 0.00835153367370367, 0.035249389708042145, 0.003766154870390892, 0.009017153643071651, -0.0026511000469326973, 0.04599032551050186, -0.05625338479876518, -0.020981237292289734, 0.025441456586122513, 0.003703575348481536, 0.028900403529405594, -0.014632251113653183, 0.027421249076724052, 0.03506733849644661, 0.001344039454124868, -0.014609495177865028, -0.01357408706098795, -0.0012843043077737093, -0.018182221800088882, 0.0016910717822611332, -0.0024477161932736635, -0.03422535955905914, 0.003922604024410248, 0.016509639099240303, 0.04391951113939285, -0.007668847218155861, 0.00632054079324007, -0.017681585624814034, 0.03233659267425537, -0.03668303042650223, -0.021607033908367157, 0.008072770200669765, 0.003621083917096257, 0.011764966882765293, -0.025509726256132126, 0.028513547033071518, 0.03593207523226738, 0.011628430336713791, 0.0011961240088567138, -0.05953028053045273, -0.03493080288171768, 0.009455210529267788, 0.005171351600438356, -0.0013056383468210697, -0.03201800584793091, -0.02202802337706089, -0.03338338062167168, 0.007549377158284187, -0.0074867974035441875, -0.048698317259550095, 0.005652077030390501, 0.01190150436013937, -0.006098667625337839, 0.019729645922780037, -0.0030493338126689196, 0.009278849698603153, 0.0009308717562817037, 0.011270019225776196, -0.06553792208433151, 0.012697972357273102, -0.013938186690211296, -0.04114324972033501, 0.020821943879127502, -0.0410977378487587, -0.01633896864950657, 0.0200482327491045, 0.04792460426688194, 0.00770298158749938, -0.01190150436013937, -0.01225422602146864, 0.014518470503389835, -0.016839604824781418, 0.02207353711128235, 0.016680311411619186, -0.009881889447569847, 0.041803181171417236, -0.02669304981827736, -0.0003504102642182261, -0.0010261634597554803, 0.004790185019373894, -0.011685320176184177, -0.024849794805049896, -0.015360450372099876, -0.013744758442044258, 0.050018180161714554, -0.034134335815906525, -0.011890126392245293, 0.004127409774810076, 0.03242761641740799, -0.028604572638869286, 0.044078804552555084, 0.024553963914513588, -0.007617645896971226, 0.057937342673540115, 0.020594382658600807, 0.00941538717597723, -0.016919251531362534, -0.011719455011188984, -0.014131614938378334, -0.018284624442458153, -0.012072176672518253, 0.01202666386961937, -0.011685320176184177, -0.0036068614572286606, 0.026966124773025513, -0.024144353345036507, 0.002789059653878212, 0.019354168325662613, -0.04503456503152847, 0.0018148088129237294, -0.020070988684892654, 0.0032285391353070736, 0.006366053596138954, -0.004158699885010719, 0.026533756405115128, -0.030015457421541214, -0.021800462156534195, 0.001625647651962936, 0.010917297564446926, 0.0446704663336277, -0.023461665958166122, -0.009022842161357403, 0.022722089663147926, -0.00811828300356865, -0.0507463775575161, -0.0004227679455652833, -0.023575447499752045, -0.0026070098392665386, 0.014780166558921337, 0.004076208453625441, -0.01111641526222229, -0.0033224085345864296, 0.011173305101692677, -0.0028687063604593277, -0.0024007814936339855, -0.03233659267425537, -0.015201156958937645, 0.03151736781001091, -0.0230861883610487, 0.038799360394477844, 0.02887764759361744, 0.04232657328248024, -0.0037803775630891323, -0.013164474628865719, 0.0461723767220974, 0.00453133275732398, -0.016282077878713608, 0.019570352509617805, -0.012470410205423832, -0.02167530171573162, -0.028058422729372978, -0.04005095362663269, 0.055661723017692566, 0.011548783630132675, -0.009267471730709076, -0.02594209462404251, -0.018455296754837036, -0.01781812310218811, 0.022813113406300545, 0.018159465864300728, 0.00024160709290299565, -0.025259407237172127, 0.014939460903406143, 0.030129238963127136, 0.0033224085345864296, -0.005654921289533377, -0.04178042709827423, -0.017988793551921844, 0.002902840729802847, 0.030948463827371597, -0.008692877367138863, 0.04066536948084831, 0.03356542810797691, 0.02400781586766243, 0.01398369949311018, 0.03989166021347046, -0.02516838349401951, 0.0461951345205307, -0.05247585102915764, -0.004554089158773422, 0.02172081544995308, -0.02177770622074604, 0.02516838349401951, -0.012982425279915333, 0.00011733677820302546, -0.012561434879899025, 0.019069714471697807, -0.0016839605523273349, -0.03370196744799614, -0.0067529091611504555, 0.02243763580918312, -0.006457078270614147, 0.012197335250675678, -0.023575447499752045, 0.06503728777170181, -0.04266791790723801, 0.028354253619909286, -0.009756730869412422, -0.022266963496804237, -0.017328863963484764, 0.019376924261450768, -0.039163459092378616, 0.001211057766340673, 0.05766426771879196, 0.025555238127708435, 0.035954833030700684, -0.019274521619081497, -0.01801155135035515, -0.020685406401753426, -0.006559481378644705, 0.035704512149095535, -0.03358818590641022, -0.00811828300356865, -0.020799187943339348, -0.05638992041349411, 0.010297191329300404, -0.010183409787714481, 0.02516838349401951, -0.02735297940671444, -0.004810096696019173, -0.02644273079931736, -0.01761331595480442, 0.019308654591441154, 0.020890213549137115, -0.013505818322300911, -0.006417254917323589, 0.0016597820213064551, 0.007270613219588995, 0.01913798414170742, 0.0116739422082901, 0.0022941117640584707, -0.010883163660764694, -0.012595569714903831, 0.0011648341314867139, 0.014017833396792412, 0.021038128063082695, -0.021538764238357544, 0.004044918809086084, 0.022449014708399773, -0.032518643885850906, -0.002312601078301668, -0.021049506962299347, -0.02780810371041298, -0.01550836581736803, 0.0032598290126770735, 0.0013625288847833872, -0.032768961042165756, 0.0000806690295576118, -0.024599477648735046, -0.024303646758198738, -0.002157574286684394, -0.024576721712946892, 0.002348157810047269, -0.023438910022377968, 0.011577228084206581, -0.009517790749669075, 0.017681585624814034, -0.014245395548641682, -0.0003729887248482555, 0.0248725526034832, -0.0009671394946053624, -0.000529437733348459, -0.04016473516821861, -0.026761317625641823, -0.01603175885975361, 0.04325957968831062, 0.010553198866546154, 0.006252272520214319, 0.017124058678746223, -0.011662564240396023, 0.026624780148267746, 0.012606947682797909, 0.0195475947111845, 0.00491249980404973, 0.03361093997955322, 0.008738389238715172, 0.014427445828914642, 0.016361724585294724, 0.015019107609987259, -0.030493339523673058, 0.013323768973350525, 0.025259407237172127, 0.021561522036790848, -0.033019278198480606, -0.01159998495131731, -0.01943381503224373, -0.04578552022576332, -0.006337608210742474, -0.016873739659786224, -0.025964850559830666, -0.028399765491485596, -0.00554682919755578, -0.030425069853663445, -0.027421249076724052, 0.008050014264881611, -0.03131256252527237, 0.01964999921619892, 0.025805557146668434, 0.0001857832248788327, -0.025760045275092125, -0.01903558149933815, -0.00977379735559225, 0.014017833396792412, -0.01253867894411087, -0.037479501217603683, -0.0003210760769434273, 0.002870128722861409, -0.011508960276842117, 0.010814894922077656, 0.03311030566692352, -0.010359770618379116, 0.010473551228642464, 0.014370555058121681, 0.010120830498635769, -0.009864822961390018, 0.017943281680345535, 0.03192698210477829, 0.0380711629986763, 0.016373101621866226, 0.008078459650278091, 0.008306021802127361, 0.019706889986991882, -0.02076505310833454, 0.006633439101278782, 0.022813113406300545, 0.02796739898622036, 0.00893181748688221, -0.022494526579976082, 0.004013628698885441, -0.014063346199691296, 0.05320404842495918, -0.030584363266825676, 0.011270019225776196, 0.010268745943903923, 0.0117991017177701, -0.003171648597344756, 0.0047731176018714905, 0.0629437118768692, 0.02735297940671444, -0.011764966882765293, -0.0022400657180696726, 0.008141038939356804, 0.02751227281987667, 0.00436635036021471, 0.045193858444690704, 0.012265603989362717, 0.0006371742347255349, -8.083570719463751e-7, -0.0032285391353070736, 0.02994718961417675, 0.009853444993495941, -0.02710266225039959, 0.01454122643917799, 0.018489431589841843, -0.0052253976464271545, -0.02603311836719513, 0.023780252784490585, 0.00042916813981719315, -0.018091198056936264, 0.005578119307756424, -0.0037092643324285746, 0.023916790261864662, 0.029583090916275978, -0.01635034568607807, 0.0019357012351974845, 0.0035329037345945835, 0.004784496035426855, 0.00232824613340199, 0.021277068182826042, -0.0008042902336455882, 0.010001360438764095, 0.019103849306702614, -0.0020053922198712826, 0.006741531193256378, 0.005703278351575136, -0.011878748424351215, -0.018466675654053688, -0.007031673099845648, 0.006479834672063589, -0.009335740469396114, -0.007805384695529938, -0.017294729128479958, -0.0015659126220270991, -0.0026070098392665386, -0.009375563822686672, 0.03158563748002052, 0.004386262036859989, 0.020776432007551193, 0.03290550038218498, -0.0016512484289705753, -0.02364371530711651, -0.05552518367767334, 0.010445106774568558, -0.019206251949071884, -0.01594073511660099, -0.0009913180256262422, -0.02537318877875805, -0.02628343738615513, 0.0018176533048972487, -0.026556512340903282, 0.003939670976251364, 0.00025049623218365014, -0.023325128480792046, -0.003535748226568103, -0.007907787337899208, -0.024121595546603203, -0.002102106111124158, 0.0017522291745990515, -0.01512151025235653, -0.03270069137215614, -0.045102834701538086, 0.016100028529763222, 0.002149040810763836, 0.04979061707854271, -0.023871278390288353, -0.012902778573334217, -0.002909952076151967, -0.0004796585126314312, -0.006980471312999725, -0.005754480138421059, -0.002776259323582053, -0.003265517996624112, -0.013392037712037563, 0.012424897402524948, 0.008994396775960922, 0.006531035993248224, -0.002527363132685423, -0.012527300976216793, -0.003933981992304325, 0.0018802329432219267, -0.005299355369061232, 0.03618239611387253, 0.017624694854021072, 0.0030493338126689196, 0.011844614520668983, 0.01578143984079361, -0.014472957700490952, -0.04760601744055748, -0.018296003341674805, 0.0304478257894516, 0.014450201764702797, 0.011497581377625465, 0.007737115956842899, -0.008818036876618862, 0.009648638777434826, 0.01765882968902588, 0.03085743822157383, 0.00022791780065745115, 0.008618919178843498, -0.023529933765530586, 0.029105208814144135, 0.009102488867938519, 0.0461723767220974, -0.04266791790723801, -0.02238074503839016, -0.029560333117842674, -0.0007808228838257492, -0.016213808208703995, 0.015019107609987259, -0.00661068269982934, -0.0041928342543542385, -0.015383207239210606, 0.018489431589841843, 0.013414793647825718, 0.03110775724053383, 0.00001606713885848876, -0.008180862292647362, 0.00715683214366436, 0.03850352764129639, -0.015075997449457645, -0.01241351943463087, -0.00488405441865325, -0.023438910022377968, -0.012584191747009754, 0.02771707996726036, 0.0022045092191547155, -0.003879935946315527, 0.0023524246644228697, 0.035408683121204376, 0.0034248116426169872, -0.0116739422082901, -0.030789170414209366, -0.004699159879237413, 0.011167616583406925, -0.013528574258089066, -0.003231383627280593, -0.04938100278377533, -0.009483655914664268, -0.01635034568607807, 0.008909061551094055, -0.0006958426092751324, 0.017146814614534378, 0.0074128396809101105, -0.028490791097283363, 0.031494613736867905, -0.010473551228642464, 0.02924174629151821, 0.0021732193417847157, -0.03242761641740799, 0.029196234419941902, 0.005629320628941059, -0.03989166021347046, -0.014450201764702797, -0.028559060767292976, -0.014814301393926144, -0.02010512351989746, -0.00034703241544775665, 0.008863548748195171, -0.04760601744055748, 0.01567903719842434, -0.008271886967122555, -0.0436464361846447, 0.014472957700490952, 0.0045654671266674995, 0.016407236456871033, 0.0038344236090779305, 0.016111405566334724, 0.012561434879899025, -0.0013276833342388272, 0.0036068614572286606, 0.011730832979083061, 0.002808971330523491, 0.0324958860874176, 0.04323682561516762, -0.0005557496333494782, 0.029719626531004906, -0.035454194992780685, -0.009449522010982037, -0.02619241364300251, 0.03229108080267906, -0.036774057894945145, -0.009045599028468132, 0.04064261540770531, 0.005990575533360243, 0.013995077461004257, -0.008089837618172169, 0.009375563822686672, -0.0059052398428320885, -0.010467862710356712, -0.0016967608826234937, -0.009802242740988731, -0.028559060767292976, -0.022915516048669815, 0.008158106356859207, 0.026169655844569206, 0.014563982374966145, -0.03486253321170807, 0.027125418186187744, 0.002043793210759759, -0.0024164265487343073, 0.05243033915758133, 0.00796467810869217, -0.0010617200750857592, 0.019957207143306732, -0.00683824485167861, 0.022983785718679428, -0.013073449954390526, 0.010951432399451733, -0.019502082839608192, -0.013835784047842026, -0.0050376588478684425, -0.021845974028110504, 0.024644989520311356, 0.004343593958765268, 0.02339339815080166, -0.01119037251919508, -0.011622740887105465, -0.0005742390640079975, -0.004707693587988615, -0.0022400657180696726, -0.005478560924530029, -0.0028857735451310873, -0.009358496405184269, 0.0032882741652429104, -0.022198695689439774, 0.020696785300970078, 0.007981745526194572, 0.04303201660513878, -0.044488415122032166, -0.010780761018395424, -0.023416154086589813, -0.005336334463208914, -0.012288360856473446, 0.0022201540414243937, 0.010649912059307098, -0.006855312269181013, 0.006502590607851744, -0.020321307703852654, -0.03160839527845383, 0.01334652490913868, -0.01919487491250038, -0.004133099224418402, -0.007230789866298437, 0.031176025047898293, 0.0015388895990327, 0.002203086856752634, -0.028035666793584824, -0.005407447461038828, -0.002370913978666067, 0.022062158212065697, 0.029969945549964905, -0.023939546197652817, -0.014746032655239105, 0.0038429570849984884, -0.002356691285967827, -0.00855065044015646, -0.0003475657431408763, -0.04710538312792778, 0.009563302621245384, 0.00954054668545723, 0.025350432842969894, -0.02557799406349659, 0.03279171884059906, -0.006422943901270628, -0.036978863179683685, 0.01443882379680872, 0.019069714471697807, 0.024485696107149124, -0.028445279225707054, 0.014370555058121681, 0.0029085297137498856, -0.0013426172081381083, 0.016202431172132492, -0.03836699202656746, 0.0037889110390096903, -0.013596842996776104, -0.009477966465055943, 0.012595569714903831, -0.001910100458189845, -0.018182221800088882, -0.009278849698603153, 0.028900403529405594, -0.0019314343808218837, -0.0033650763798505068, 0.0041928342543542385, -0.0015360451070591807, -0.02293827198445797, 0.001164123066700995, 0.010519064031541348, -0.026055876165628433, 0.003348009428009391, -0.004044918809086084, -0.014973594807088375, 0.002863017376512289, 0.031153269112110138, -0.01767020672559738, 0.01380164921283722, 0.024189865216612816, -0.019115228205919266, 0.007742804940789938, -0.025714531540870667, -0.006195381749421358, 0.021993890404701233, 0.0162365660071373, 0.06571996957063675, -0.002083616564050317, 0.030083727091550827, 0.03295101225376129, 0.018739750608801842, 0.009779486805200577, -0.02182321809232235, -0.032814472913742065, -0.009603125974535942, 0.0070146056823432446, -0.014336420223116875, 0.02167530171573162, -0.012459032237529755, 0.03691059350967407, 0.010041183792054653, -0.05912066623568535, 0.010649912059307098, 0.007930544205009937, 0.005726034753024578, -0.009432454593479633, 0.00388278067111969, 0.009563302621245384, -0.00938694179058075, -0.0031972492579370737, 0.01119037251919508, -0.005142906215041876, 0.027034392580389977, -0.015895221382379532, -0.04405604675412178, -0.01553112268447876, -0.0008220685413107276, 0.015872465446591377, 0.014393310993909836, 0.010069628246128559, 0.009432454593479633, -0.005933685228228569, -0.04906241595745087, 0.019866183400154114, -0.010183409787714481, 0.0024263823870569468, -0.0002536963438615203, -0.0036153949331492186, 0.011241573840379715, -0.0012949713272973895, -0.004010784439742565, -0.03672854229807854, 0.005205485969781876, 0.008522205986082554, -0.010894541628658772, 0.010689735412597656, -0.018512187525629997, -0.030629877001047134, 0.014234017580747604, 0.008135349489748478, 0.015246669761836529, -0.013653733767569065, 0.01334652490913868, 0.014677763916552067, -0.004036385100334883, -0.006906513590365648, 0.023063432425260544, -0.019115228205919266, -0.017931904643774033, 0.02035544067621231, 0.008209307678043842 ]
6.500853
3.080803
2024-07-01
0
2024ApJ...969..122Y
[ "galaxy environments", "FRB", "the other FRB host galaxies", "The inferred molecular gas mass", "the molecular gas column density", "the measured molecular gas fraction", "This molecular gas mass", "the molecular gas disk", "the host galaxy", "×" ]
[ "Radio transient sources", "Radio bursts", "Extragalactic radio sources", "CO line emission", "Molecular gas", "Interstellar medium", "2008", "1339", "508", "262", "1073", "847", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
12
[ "10.3847/1538-4357/ad553f", "10.48550/arXiv.2407.01889" ]
[ "Yamanaka, Itsuki", "Hatsukade, Bunyo", "Egusa, Fumi", "Hashimoto, Tetsuya", "Niino, Yuu", "Hsu, Tzu-Yin", "Kaneko, Hiroyuki", "Kohno, Kotaro" ]
[ "Institute of Astronomy, Graduate School of Science, The University of Tokyo, 2-21-1 Osawa, Mitaka, Tokyo 181-0015, Japan", "Institute of Astronomy, Graduate School of Science, The University of Tokyo, 2-21-1 Osawa, Mitaka, Tokyo 181-0015, Japan; National Astronomical Observatory of Japan, 2-21-1 Osawa, Mitaka, Tokyo 181-8588, Japan; Graduate Institute for Advanced Studies, SOKENDAI, Osawa, Mitaka, Tokyo 181-8588, Japan", "Institute of Astronomy, Graduate School of Science, The University of Tokyo, 2-21-1 Osawa, Mitaka, Tokyo 181-0015, Japan", "Department of Physics, National Chung Hsing University, No. 145, Xingda Rd., South Dist., Taichung, 40227, Taiwan R.O.C.", "Kiso Observatory, Institute of Astronomy, Graduate School of Science, The University of Tokyo, 10762-30 Mitake, Kiso-machi, Kiso-gun, Nagano 397-0101, Japan", "Department of Physics, National Tsing Hua University, 101, Section 2. Kuang-Fu Rd., Hsinchu, 30013, Taiwan R.O.C.", "Department of Environmental Science, Faculty of Science, 8050 Ikarashi 2-no-cho, Nishi-ku, Niigata, Niigata 950-2181, Japan", "Institute of Astronomy, Graduate School of Science, The University of Tokyo, 2-21-1 Osawa, Mitaka, Tokyo 181-0015, Japan" ]
null
[ "2005ARA&A..43..677S", "2007Sci...318..777L", "2013Sci...341...53T", "2014ApJ...794..135B", "2015ApJ...800...20G", "2015MNRAS.451.3021D", "2016MNRAS.461.1498M", "2017A&A...599A..25P", "2017ApJ...846..159B", "2017MNRAS.468..628G", "2018ApJ...853..179T", "2018ApJ...868..132P", "2018ApJ...868L...4M", "2019A&A...622A.105F", "2019ApJ...879L..13M", "2019NatAs...3..928R", "2019PhR...821....1P", "2020ApJ...892...42H", "2020ApJ...901L..20B", "2020ApJ...903..152H", "2020MNRAS.494.2886H", "2020PASJ...72L...6H", "2021ApJ...912...21E", "2021ApJ...920L..21M", "2022ApJ...925L..20K", "2022ApJ...927L...3N", "2022ApJ...940L..34H", "2022PASP..134k4501C", "2023ApJ...949...25G", "2023ApJ...954...80G", "2023MNRAS.519.2030H", "2023arXiv230410377C" ]
29163294
2404.02373
Size-mass relations for simulated low-mass galaxies: mock imaging versus intrinsic properties
The observationally inferred size versus stellar-mass relationship (SMR) for low-mass galaxies provides an important test for galaxy formation models. However, the relationship relies on assumptions that relate observed luminosity profiles to underlying stellar mass profiles. Here we use the Feedback in Realistic Environments simulations of low-mass galaxies to explore how the predicted SMR changes depending on whether one uses star-particle counts directly or mock observations. We reproduce the SMR found in The Exploration of Local Volume Satellites survey remarkably well only when we infer stellar masses and sizes using mock observations. However, when we use star particles to directly infer stellar masses and half-mass radii, we find that our galaxies are too large and obey an SMR with too little scatter compared to observations. This discrepancy between the 'true' galaxy size and mass and those derived in the mock observation approach is twofold. First, our simulated galaxies have higher and more varied mass-to-light ratios (MLR) at a fixed colour than those commonly adopted, which tends to underestimate their stellar masses compared to their true, simulated values. Second, our galaxies have radially increasing MLR gradients therefore using a single MLR tends to underpredict the mass in the outer regions. Similarly, the true half-mass radius is larger than the half-light radius because the light is more concentrated than the mass. If our simulations are accurate representations of the real Universe, then the relationship between galaxy size and stellar mass is even tighter for low-mass galaxies than is commonly inferred from observed relations.
[ 0.01580003648996353, 0.012063384987413883, 0.01789901778101921, -0.02479567751288414, -0.0032638029661029577, 0.016192153096199036, 0.011740464717149734, -0.03203831985592842, -0.003260919824242592, 0.041195422410964966, -0.06970468163490295, -0.0005337557522580028, -0.019421357661485672, -0.00999900046736002, 0.01441609114408493, 0.004174899775534868, -0.007594396825879812, -0.01979040913283825, -0.0007770273368805647, 0.007161913905292749, 0.04131074994802475, 0.0087822824716568, -0.01097352895885706, 0.01881011575460434, -0.03155393898487091, -0.002752031898126006, 0.014220031909644604, 0.0061758533120155334, 0.0201363954693079, 0.00864388793706894, 0.01490047201514244, 0.0006292623584158719, -0.051021430641412735, -0.04317907616496086, -0.07053504884243011, 0.07214964926242828, 0.02779422327876091, 0.009174400009214878, 0.02005566656589508, 0.022685160860419273, -0.02368852123618126, 0.029847074300050735, -0.03734344244003296, 0.030285324901342392, 0.003950009122490883, 0.0235501267015934, 0.022385306656360626, -0.05175953358411789, 0.016215220093727112, -0.015096530318260193, -0.08312894403934479, 0.01034498680382967, 0.0065276059322059155, -0.03473701328039169, -0.010120095685124397, -0.015834635123610497, -0.001594419707544148, 0.0016218102537095547, -0.04876098781824112, 0.008078777231276035, -0.0005081671988591552, -0.0071676806546747684, 0.01699945516884327, -0.004760193172842264, -0.03185379505157471, -0.03473701328039169, 0.012351706624031067, -0.006083590444177389, 0.0388888455927372, 0.013112876564264297, -0.020090265199542046, -0.03286868706345558, 0.027609698474407196, 0.01212104968726635, 0.0048380400985479355, 0.012939883396029472, 0.02500326931476593, -0.013839447870850563, -0.006729431450366974, -0.004425739869475365, -0.025672174990177155, 0.0003315701032988727, 0.013666454702615738, -0.022131582722067833, -0.010944696143269539, -0.019536687061190605, 0.02067844197154045, -0.04075717180967331, -0.022961949929594994, 0.013089810498058796, 0.056326549500226974, -0.04158753901720047, 0.0029394410084933043, 0.01693025790154934, 0.018348800018429756, -0.056049760431051254, -0.010500680655241013, -0.05609589442610741, 0.06527606397867203, 0.04128768667578697, 0.01860252395272255, 0.031046492978930473, 0.00689665786921978, -0.04613149166107178, 0.05558844655752182, 0.0013529501156881452, 0.016526605933904648, -0.004022089298814535, -0.0011093182256445289, 0.02305421233177185, 0.04996040463447571, 0.0036299717612564564, -0.01907537132501602, -0.0010509330313652754, -0.06661387532949448, 0.016492007300257683, -0.07491753995418549, 0.03224591165781021, -0.05042171850800514, -0.006435343064367771, 0.02291581779718399, -0.016492007300257683, 0.032984014600515366, 0.006787095684558153, 0.056603338569402695, -0.02451888844370842, 0.03261496499180794, -0.019675081595778465, -0.03732037544250488, 0.023919178172945976, 0.016837993636727333, -0.011625136248767376, 0.0018135443096980453, -0.0021249318961054087, -0.032453503459692, -0.0017068651504814625, -0.0327533595263958, -0.029570285230875015, 0.02271975949406624, -0.003941359464079142, -0.005333953537046909, 0.008909144438803196, -0.04424010217189789, 0.0111061567440629, -0.021162820979952812, 0.008903377689421177, -0.030885033309459686, 0.017795223742723465, -0.007283009123057127, 0.02952415496110916, 0.012317107990384102, -0.00852855946868658, -0.05037558823823929, -0.004647747613489628, -0.020862966775894165, -0.02389611303806305, 0.005584793630987406, -0.013228205032646656, 0.0007489159470424056, -0.02980094403028488, 0.01607682555913925, 0.006810161285102367, -0.03356065973639488, 0.0026035460177809, -0.03379131853580475, 0.008113375864923, -0.002123490208759904, 0.006221984978765249, -0.06795168668031693, -0.04816127568483353, -0.006037458777427673, 0.03662840276956558, -0.0024709179997444153, -0.06310787796974182, -0.0187985822558403, 0.03065437637269497, 0.003318584058433771, -0.04537032172083855, 0.02548764832317829, 0.046984925866127014, -0.003860629163682461, 0.05549618601799011, -0.016826462000608444, -0.03010079823434353, 0.015188793651759624, 0.005480997730046511, -0.036190155893564224, 0.0293857604265213, 0.0348292775452137, -0.04721558094024658, -0.010241190902888775, 0.03801234811544418, 0.03208445385098457, 0.012443969957530499, -0.0594634935259819, -0.01128491573035717, 0.01859099045395851, 0.06393824517726898, -0.04410170763731003, 0.0484841987490654, 0.050560113042593, 0.012409371323883533, 0.06596802920103073, -0.060847438871860504, -0.04693879187107086, -0.0026799512561410666, 0.008130675181746483, 0.023434797301888466, 0.01929449662566185, 0.0072714765556156635, 0.03909643739461899, 0.03192299231886864, 0.015984561294317245, -0.007081184070557356, -0.02848619595170021, 0.00168956583365798, -0.07500980794429779, 0.008038412779569626, 0.03738957270979881, 0.06449182331562042, 0.0021595305297523737, 0.011002360843122005, 0.07122702151536942, -0.00689665786921978, -0.008211405947804451, -0.009456955827772617, 0.054988738149404526, -0.04018053039908409, -0.0014963902067393064, -0.023146476596593857, 0.027355974540114403, 0.023527061566710472, -0.02855539321899414, -0.01581156812608242, 0.014369959942996502, -0.04587776958942413, -0.0229042861610651, 0.03436795994639397, -0.026917725801467896, -0.03704358637332916, -0.03519832715392113, 0.03279948979616165, 0.013943243771791458, 0.014381492510437965, -0.0385889932513237, 0.01712631620466709, -0.0076174624264240265, 0.022754358127713203, 0.07122702151536942, 0.0036761031951755285, 0.013620322570204735, -0.08580457419157028, -0.005870232358574867, 0.005584793630987406, -0.02360779047012329, 0.020805303007364273, -0.02961641736328602, 0.06652160733938217, 0.01413930207490921, -0.024011440575122833, -0.05890991538763046, -0.01950208842754364, -0.018475662916898727, 0.009635715745389462, -0.02235070802271366, 0.02973174676299095, 0.006429576780647039, -0.0013089810963720083, -0.008845713920891285, 0.03644387796521187, 0.005530012771487236, 0.01413930207490921, -0.002767889527603984, -0.03817380964756012, -0.025533780455589294, 0.011671267449855804, -0.008914911188185215, 0.05960188806056976, 0.005034098867326975, -0.014785142615437508, 0.012813021428883076, -0.011994187720119953, 0.024334361776709557, 0.0051205954514443874, -0.02966254949569702, 0.02862459048628807, 0.01907537132501602, 0.023077279329299927, -0.000005068156951892888, -0.053466398268938065, 0.030977295711636543, -0.03817380964756012, -0.004492053762078285, -0.0007503575179725885, -0.029339628294110298, -0.0031513574067503214, 0.01721857860684395, -0.007928850129246712, -0.021831728518009186, -0.011181119829416275, 0.06403051316738129, 0.037574101239442825, 0.015165727585554123, 0.0075540319085121155, -0.03575190529227257, -0.01483127474784851, 0.023515528067946434, 0.03879658505320549, -0.017529966309666634, 0.05295895040035248, 0.002171063330024481, 0.012928350828588009, -0.007144614588469267, 0.030146930366754532, -0.003993257414549589, -0.015050399117171764, -0.015984561294317245, -0.006625635549426079, 0.01699945516884327, -0.029639482498168945, -0.03801234811544418, -0.0321536511182785, -0.013412730768322945, -0.027632763609290123, -0.005284938961267471, -0.0717344656586647, -0.02438049390912056, -0.03976534679532051, -0.07108862698078156, -0.019167635589838028, 0.007594396825879812, -0.003134058089926839, 0.060155466198921204, -0.0009723653201945126, 0.006833227351307869, -0.06393824517726898, -0.01082936767488718, 0.036466944962739944, -0.015073465183377266, 0.02786342054605484, -0.013043679296970367, -0.003134058089926839, 0.002000953536480665, 0.005619392264634371, 0.0013889903202652931, -0.004751543514430523, 0.010033599101006985, 0.016134489327669144, 0.04550871625542641, -0.01588076539337635, 0.03501380234956741, 0.012836087495088577, 0.02772502601146698, -0.0341373048722744, 0.051990192383527756, -0.008695785887539387, 0.013470395468175411, -0.0764860138297081, 0.018221938982605934, 0.00933009386062622, -0.021508807316422462, -0.02276589162647724, 0.008165273815393448, 0.0013889903202652931, -0.010189292952418327, 0.04638521373271942, -0.018752451986074448, 0.0546196848154068, -0.041749000549316406, -0.031231019645929337, -0.002331082010641694, 0.034160368144512177, 0.009589583612978458, 0.018302669748663902, -0.02040165290236473, -0.012813021428883076, 0.02236223965883255, -0.001120851025916636, -0.04241790622472763, 0.006170087028294802, -0.007998047396540642, 0.02758663147687912, 0.000662419362924993, -0.029339628294110298, -0.004722711630165577, 0.02248910255730152, 0.00839016493409872, -0.03247657045722008, -0.09120196104049683, -0.005558844655752182, -0.009024472907185555, 0.015719305723905563, 0.005668406840413809, -0.00804994534701109, 0.03434489667415619, -0.00412588519975543, 0.020147928968071938, 0.053189609199762344, 0.01922529935836792, 0.04082636907696724, -0.00032814627047628164, -0.06721358001232147, -0.05494260787963867, -0.011031192727386951, -0.008695785887539387, -0.0027693312149494886, 0.007819287478923798, 0.008263302966952324, 0.008234471082687378, -0.006556438282132149, 0.04603922739624977, -0.009416590444743633, 0.022396838292479515, -0.02486487478017807, -0.0012102308683097363, 0.027402106672525406, -0.013205139897763729, 0.053189609199762344, -0.016745731234550476, 0.06246203929185867, -0.02431129664182663, -0.02827860414981842, 0.04394024610519409, -0.0038289139047265053, -0.005861582700163126, 0.03376825153827667, -0.0009161425987258554, -0.003116759005934, 0.0024017207324504852, -0.03399891033768654, -0.07122702151536942, 0.07759317010641098, 0.028509261086583138, 0.012386305257678032, 0.002005278365686536, -0.015396385453641415, -0.004123001825064421, -0.05849473178386688, 0.019801942631602287, -0.04806901514530182, 0.07754703611135483, 0.014912004582583904, -0.01225944422185421, -0.053051214665174484, 0.040434252470731735, 0.02334253489971161, 0.005455048754811287, 0.013551125302910805, 0.030700508505105972, -0.03279948979616165, 0.007467535324394703, -0.017656829208135605, 0.02201625518500805, 0.0010977853089571, -0.02903977409005165, -0.020297857001423836, 0.026133490726351738, -0.02534925378859043, 0.04620068892836571, -0.051713403314352036, 0.008770749904215336, 0.027402106672525406, 0.009560751728713512, -0.004160483833402395, 0.011573238298296928, 0.021335814148187637, 0.015327188186347485, 0.028163274750113487, -0.0023844214156270027, 0.041057027876377106, 0.028532328084111214, -0.07745477557182312, 0.03254576772451401, -0.019144568592309952, 0.0038375635631382465, -0.014542953111231327, -0.0266178697347641, -0.020932164043188095, 0.039949871599674225, 0.026202687993645668, 0.040503449738025665, -0.0005261873011477292, 0.0320613868534565, -0.006654467433691025, -0.01698792167007923, 0.013332000933587551, -0.013966308906674385, -0.009422357194125652, -0.004068220965564251, -0.008557391352951527, -0.04444769024848938, -0.06426116824150085, 0.024611150845885277, -0.009387758560478687, 0.014012440107762814, -0.026986923068761826, 0.024565018713474274, -0.0009658780763857067, -0.008349799551069736, 0.04340973496437073, 0.038427531719207764, -0.017103251069784164, -0.016665000468492508, 0.04652360826730728, -0.011573238298296928, 0.032638031989336014, -0.019052306190133095, -0.029362693428993225, 0.021566472947597504, 0.0034886940848082304, -0.03157700598239899, 0.029777877032756805, 0.016411278396844864, -0.0061758533120155334, 0.008442062884569168, 0.011013893410563469, -0.03134634718298912, 0.012005720287561417, 0.02827860414981842, 0.010073964484035969, 0.030631311237812042, -0.006769796367734671, -0.012224845588207245, 0.010489148087799549, 0.03369905427098274, -0.005233041010797024, -0.016895659267902374, -0.05955575406551361, -0.03466781601309776, -0.026364147663116455, 0.01575390435755253, -0.021024426445364952, 0.0461084246635437, -0.010956229642033577, -0.013274336233735085, -0.04128768667578697, -0.014589084312319756, -0.006637168116867542, 0.0055617280304431915, -0.0020470849703997374, 0.019144568592309952, 0.017610697075724602, -0.007081184070557356, 0.013297402299940586, -0.014427623711526394, 0.04121848940849304, -0.017945149913430214, -0.0003310294996481389, 0.04523192718625069, -0.009802942164242268, 0.04052651673555374, 0.003050444880500436, 0.03335306793451309, 0.00961264967918396, -0.044263165444135666, -0.03392971307039261, -0.04080330580472946, 0.019559752196073532, -0.010639075189828873, 0.003670336678624153, 0.00783658679574728, -0.008966808207333088, -0.00602592620998621, 0.04417090490460396, -0.029155103489756584, -0.03642081096768379, -0.0026093125343322754, -0.039050307124853134, -0.03462168574333191, 0.03169233351945877, -0.0156847070902586, 0.00009149713150691241, 0.021566472947597504, -0.03909643739461899, -0.01062754262238741, -0.028809117153286934, -0.010333454236388206, -0.006441109348088503, 0.014023973606526852, 0.003658803878352046, -0.021059025079011917, -0.03630548343062401, 0.026018161326646805, -0.02375771850347519, -0.04034198820590973, 0.0038058480713516474, -0.014300762675702572, 0.009036005474627018, 0.006798628717660904, 0.010373818688094616, 0.004561251029372215, -0.0094742551445961, 0.00595672894269228, -0.029085906222462654, -0.004443039186298847, 0.012859153561294079, 0.023942243307828903, 0.009774109348654747, -0.017645295709371567, -0.02993933856487274, 0.002824112307280302, 0.023503994569182396, -0.027425171807408333, 0.002158088842406869, 0.009975935332477093, 0.021301215514540672, -0.0027275243774056435, -0.005201325751841068, -0.02675626426935196, 0.0034540954511612654, -0.010840900242328644, 0.009802942164242268, -0.038219939917325974, -0.01951362006366253, -0.03457555174827576, -0.015384851954877377, 0.052636031061410904, -0.025948964059352875, 0.025303123518824577, -0.003246503649279475, -0.034091170877218246, -0.022662095725536346, 0.018164275214076042, 0.021266616880893707, 0.02458808571100235, -0.018752451986074448, 0.005146544426679611, -0.00839593168348074, -0.025533780455589294, -0.038565926253795624, 0.02271975949406624, -0.023492462933063507, 0.024219032377004623, -0.012317107990384102, -0.012420903891324997, -0.011279149912297726, 0.008978341706097126, 0.030908098444342613, -0.052220847457647324, -0.017818288877606392, 0.06135488301515579, 0.01770295947790146, 0.01831420138478279, -0.03466781601309776, -0.026364147663116455, 0.015396385453641415, 0.02334253489971161, 0.0040566879324615, -0.02751743420958519, -0.01853332668542862, -0.0030908100306987762, -0.025303123518824577, -0.013332000933587551, 0.004293112084269524, -0.008176807314157486, 0.0252800565212965, 0.027632763609290123, 0.010258490219712257, -0.036951325833797455, 0.02751743420958519, -0.02020559273660183, -0.005455048754811287, 0.0021638553589582443, -0.016492007300257683, 0.016261350363492966, 0.011054258793592453, 0.01076593715697527, 0.03969614952802658, 0.00783658679574728, 0.042048852890729904, 0.026110423728823662, -0.005463698413223028, 0.01623828522861004, -0.005463698413223028, -0.03157700598239899, -0.015177261084318161, -0.001500715035945177, -0.038565926253795624, -0.008955275639891624, -0.0022344940807670355, 0.014646749012172222, -0.009987467899918556, -0.025464583188295364, -0.03192299231886864, 0.003165773581713438, 0.01749536767601967, 0.002896192716434598, -0.009877905249595642, 0.011273383162915707, 0.011803895235061646, 0.0006281811511144042, -0.006100889761000872, 0.023377133533358574, -0.002848619595170021, 0.004933186341077089, -0.01138294581323862, -0.018348800018429756, 0.011596303433179855, 0.002111957408487797, -0.04797675088047981, 0.0252800565212965, 0.00783658679574728, 0.007473301608115435, 0.0024118120782077312, -0.021266616880893707, -0.01992880366742611, -0.03010079823434353, 0.006487241014838219, 0.016549672931432724, 0.008430530317127705, 0.035428985953330994, 0.037435706704854965, 0.008470894768834114, -0.010892798192799091, -0.005737604107707739, -0.026871593669056892, -0.008090310730040073, -0.0090533047914505, 0.007081184070557356, 0.01705711893737316, -0.023181075230240822, -0.002802488161250949, -0.06130875274538994, 0.029570285230875015, 0.03586723282933235, 0.005169610492885113, -0.025879766792058945, 0.037989284843206406, -0.03978841006755829, -0.009837540797889233, 0.0031715400982648134, 0.022800490260124207, 0.01219024695456028, 0.0040999362245202065, 0.008545858785510063, 0.0021379063837230206, -0.0010264257434755564, 0.0006389932241290808, -0.004068220965564251, 0.04931456595659256, -0.013597257435321808, 0.00405957130715251, 0.028993641957640648, 0.006037458777427673, -0.016561204567551613, 0.013551125302910805, 0.003926943056285381, 0.021439610049128532, 0.0006534093408845365, -0.008701552636921406, 0.0031052259728312492, 0.007611696142703295, 0.022881219163537025, 0.007473301608115435, 0.029847074300050735, -0.02465728297829628, 0.014542953111231327, -0.009283962659537792, -0.0037827822379767895, 0.03902724012732506, 0.03971921280026436, 0.02180866338312626, 0.014427623711526394, 0.03185379505157471, -0.015281056985259056, -0.0035838403273373842, -0.033468395471572876, -0.037781693041324615, 0.0252800565212965, -0.01762223057448864, -0.038612060248851776, 0.00019786084885708988, 0.01543098408728838, 0.00044978203368373215, 0.023942243307828903, 0.00022741383872926235, 0.012305575422942638, -0.008568924851715565, -0.025233926251530647, 0.015350254252552986, 0.005034098867326975, -0.027286777272820473, 0.00493030296638608, -0.02924736589193344, -0.03051598183810711, 0.008315200917422771, -0.016065292060375214, -0.026525607332587242, -0.020528513938188553, -0.01705711893737316, -0.028509261086583138, 0.022327641025185585, -0.0073695057071745396, -0.0182565376162529, 0.004347892943769693, 0.03886578232049942, 0.005803918465971947, -0.09313948452472687, 0.02068997360765934, 0.04806901514530182, 0.010852433741092682, 0.025303123518824577, 0.07957682013511658, 0.015696240589022636, 0.002649677451699972, 0.011181119829416275, -0.01062177587300539, 0.008009579963982105, -0.05000653862953186, -0.03845059871673584, 0.02229304239153862, 0.04530112445354462, -0.03427569940686226, -0.01789901778101921, 0.022592898458242416, 0.006343080196529627, -0.0011907691368833184, 0.0072368779219686985, 0.04237177595496178, 0.0014625124167650938, 0.0001235278759850189, 0.014773610047996044, 0.000008092157258943189, -0.0365130752325058, 0.013551125302910805, 0.011613602750003338, -0.016665000468492508, 0.030885033309459686, -0.007727024611085653, 0.007790455594658852, 0.022316109389066696, -0.029362693428993225, -0.006752497050911188, 0.029708679765462875, 0.02241990529000759, -0.04871485382318497, 0.02265056222677231, -0.015973029658198357, -0.010200826451182365, 0.030285324901342392, 0.019133036956191063, 0.046292953193187714, -0.0015727955615147948, 0.0073349070735275745, 0.030008535832166672, 0.02333100140094757, 0.015546312555670738, -0.02779422327876091, -0.020989827811717987, -0.01277842279523611, 0.01770295947790146, 0.0017155148088932037, 0.0032493870239704847, 0.041264619678258896, -0.0189485102891922, -0.016399744898080826, 0.04857645928859711, -0.026064293459057808, 0.01393171027302742, -0.00857469066977501, -0.03086196817457676, -0.036051761358976364, -0.03607482463121414, -0.01550018135458231, -0.009393525309860706, -0.008205639198422432, 0.0033618323504924774, 0.009370459243655205, 0.036812931299209595, 0.011279149912297726, 0.014981201849877834, -0.01657273806631565, -0.01915610209107399, -0.008240237832069397, 0.026779331266880035, -0.039280965924263, 0.023031147196888924, -0.02236223965883255, -0.0539277121424675, 0.03519832715392113, -0.001993745332583785, 0.017818288877606392, 0.03969614952802658, 0.008799581788480282, 0.0216702688485384, -0.03489847481250763, 0.03392971307039261, 0.03369905427098274, 0.006977388169616461, 0.013332000933587551, -0.009797175414860249, -0.03203831985592842, 0.03293788433074951, 0.0344371572136879, -0.030193060636520386, 0.01712631620466709, -0.02048238180577755, -0.021485742181539536, -0.017045585438609123, -0.012559298425912857, -0.041910458356142044, 0.023919178172945976, -0.014958135783672333, 0.0033820150420069695, -0.0028212289325892925, 0.053189609199762344, 0.0017313725547865033, -0.0030792769975960255, 0.04894551262259483, 0.03208445385098457, 0.02103595994412899, 0.02200472168624401, 0.006158553995192051, -0.01832573488354683, 0.016468942165374756, -0.005062931217253208, 0.035705775022506714, 0.009647248312830925, 0.028855247423052788, -0.0018841831479221582, -0.017933616414666176, 0.003223438048735261, -0.0014077313244342804, 0.01984807476401329, -0.006014393176883459, 0.0036761031951755285, 0.041679803282022476, 0.00010127304267371073, 0.015650108456611633, 0.04018053039908409, -0.015846166759729385, 0.004688112996518612, 0.013885579071938992, 0.009185933507978916, 0.039327096194028854, 0.025579912588000298, -0.006821694318205118, -0.01055257860571146, -0.0001850665721576661, -0.014750543981790543, 0.01034498680382967, -0.00642381003126502, -0.0013039354234933853, 0.015407918021082878, -0.01999800093472004, 0.050744641572237015, -0.027402106672525406, -0.004494937136769295, 0.013770250603556633, -0.010592943988740444, -0.006170087028294802, -0.012443969957530499, -0.017922084778547287, 0.001711189979687333, -0.022869687527418137, -0.00110138941090554, -0.022408371791243553, 0.0032493870239704847, 0.036536142230033875, -0.022166181355714798, -0.007721258327364922, 0.00473424419760704, 0.01601915992796421, -0.009093670174479485, 0.03058517910540104, -0.010177760384976864, -0.015096530318260193, -0.009295495226979256, -0.047054123133420944, 0.040226660668849945, -0.00933586061000824, -0.003134058089926839, -0.004518002737313509, -0.0008246003999374807, 0.009583817794919014, -0.0003104865609202534, 0.020586177706718445, -0.010195059701800346, 0.01212104968726635, -0.002345497952774167, 0.016814928501844406, 0.02793261781334877, -0.034160368144512177, -0.01853332668542862, -0.009174400009214878, -0.009381991811096668, 0.005798151716589928, -0.03965001553297043, 0.018579458817839622, 0.037089720368385315, 0.009295495226979256, 0.047746092081069946, 0.0009853398660197854, -0.00791155081242323, 0.04382491856813431, 0.010840900242328644, -0.007040818687528372, -0.030769703909754753, -0.011365646496415138, -0.008937976323068142, -0.01803741231560707, 0.026156555861234665, -0.019974935799837112, -0.027494369074702263, 0.004483404103666544, -0.04061877727508545, -0.041195422410964966, 0.003696285653859377, 0.010523746721446514, 0.026410279795527458, 0.010915864259004593, 0.022408371791243553, -0.04585470259189606, 0.012616963125765324, -0.017645295709371567, -0.033606790006160736, -0.025095531716942787, 0.04756156727671623, -0.02229304239153862, -0.01789901778101921, 0.03992680460214615, -0.0006357496022246778, 0.0648147463798523, -0.0042383307591080666, 0.0003852700465358794, -0.019029241055250168, -0.003941359464079142, 0.02751743420958519, 0.014508354477584362, -0.012939883396029472, -0.042187247425317764, -0.04700798913836479, -0.005287822335958481, -0.014312295243144035, -0.00933586061000824, 0.013689519837498665, -0.009670313447713852, 0.018821649253368378, -0.016053758561611176, -0.030769703909754753, -0.0280018150806427, 0.020770704373717308, -0.01515419501811266, 0.020170994102954865, -0.027056120336055756, -0.025256991386413574, 0.0072368779219686985, -0.03895804286003113, -0.004641981329768896, -0.04562404379248619, -0.00006086293433327228, 0.00743870297446847, 0.013943243771791458, -0.05042171850800514, 0.02320414036512375, 0.026871593669056892, 0.007571331225335598, -0.012789956294000149, 0.010921631008386612, -0.031046492978930473, -0.008649654686450958, 0.017945149913430214, -0.0049216533079743385, -0.01770295947790146, 0.025303123518824577, 0.009601117111742496, -0.03803541511297226, -0.0087822824716568, -0.010725571773946285, 0.03865819051861763, -0.010927396826446056, -0.0022561182267963886, 0.024980202317237854, 0.009082137607038021, -0.020309388637542725, -0.008447829633951187, 0.0047746095806360245, -0.04751543700695038, -0.01866018772125244, -0.015257990919053555, -0.008563158102333546, 0.0059624952264130116, -0.011959589086472988, -0.004235447384417057, -0.018371867015957832, 0.026202687993645668, -0.012443969957530499, 0.008113375864923, 0.038127679377794266, 0.030677441507577896, -0.0030187293887138367, 0.021428078413009644, -0.020078731700778008, -0.023503994569182396, 0.0012873569503426552, 0.013608790002763271, -0.009895204566419125, -0.04094170033931732, -0.027079185470938683, -0.000360762671334669, -0.03185379505157471, 0.010667907074093819, -0.043294403702020645, -0.01915610209107399, 0.015384851954877377, -0.009941336698830128, -0.008493960835039616, 0.006844759918749332, -0.01529258955270052, -0.009393525309860706, -0.013089810498058796, -0.0090533047914505, -0.04354812949895859, 0.006977388169616461, 0.009030239656567574, -0.024980202317237854, -0.010979294776916504, -0.03178459778428078, -0.039603885263204575, 0.018637122586369514, -0.030838901177048683, -0.03065437637269497, -0.006648701149970293, 0.006487241014838219, -0.02265056222677231, 0.0062162186950445175, 0.041633669286966324, 0.04880711808800697, 0.04507046565413475, -0.0033214674331247807, -0.0011792362201958895, -0.00588753167539835, 0.019663548097014427, -0.004466105252504349, -0.013205139897763729, 0.008499727584421635, -0.010356520302593708, -0.012951415963470936, 0.0228581540286541, -0.047746092081069946, 0.025879766792058945, 0.0035261758603155613, 0.006521839648485184, 0.0035665410105139017, 0.0020110446494072676, -0.04428623244166374, 0.022039320319890976, 0.0676748976111412, -0.02215464971959591, -0.01943289116024971, -0.028186341747641563, 0.014958135783672333, 0.0006735918577760458, 0.021047493442893028, 0.017529966309666634, 0.011728932149708271, -0.0010776028502732515, -0.013897111639380455, -0.026571739464998245, 0.013620322570204735, 0.0061470214277505875, 0.03476008027791977, 0.008707319386303425, -0.01908690482378006, 0.02569524012506008, -0.015788502991199493, -0.018141208216547966, -0.014393025077879429, -0.012870686128735542, -0.003999023698270321, 0.03238430619239807, -0.016803395003080368, 0.006735197734087706, 0.020632309839129448, 0.0016319014830514789, -0.009595350362360477, 0.007876952178776264, -0.011446376331150532, 0.0010646283626556396, -0.014427623711526394, 0.0402727909386158, -0.026986923068761826, -0.026456410065293312, 0.010610243305563927, 0.01852179318666458, 0.023942243307828903, -0.007940382696688175, 0.03623628616333008, -0.02067844197154045, 0.02583363465964794, -0.002907725516706705, -0.006608336232602596, 0.01915610209107399, 0.015073465183377266, 0.014243097975850105, -0.014162368141114712, 0.010812068358063698, -0.002132139867171645, -0.012467036023736, -0.006516073364764452, 0.016595803201198578, 0.023296402767300606, 0.0008584782481193542, 0.03637468069791794, 0.02924736589193344, 0.008378632366657257, -0.01462368294596672, 0.016399744898080826, -0.02353859320282936, -0.02931656315922737, 0.044678349047899246, 0.03079277090728283, -0.01097352895885706, 0.03425263240933418, 0.016826462000608444, 0.03224591165781021, 0.04200272262096405, -0.014323827810585499, 0.010010533966124058, -0.024611150845885277, 0.023031147196888924, -0.027125317603349686, -0.009704912081360817, -0.011607836931943893, 0.020159462466835976, -0.013643388636410236, -0.024980202317237854, -0.028186341747641563, -0.03058517910540104, -0.012547765858471394, 0.023158008232712746, -0.03692825883626938, -0.0008887519943527877, 0.01748383603990078, -0.010673673823475838, -0.01791055127978325, 0.036120958626270294, -0.04894551262259483, -0.021831728518009186, 0.03579803556203842, 0.01992880366742611, 0.014612150378525257, -0.004679463338106871, 0.00783658679574728, 0.003846212988719344, 0.008021113462746143, 0.016826462000608444, -0.03489847481250763, 0.016261350363492966, 0.02751743420958519, -0.02368852123618126, 0.006677533499896526, 0.04700798913836479, -0.017795223742723465, -0.06504540145397186, 0.026294950395822525, 0.011746231466531754, -0.0036616872530430555, 0.03406810760498047, 0.024841807782649994, 0.023365600034594536, 0.009208998642861843, 0.030054666101932526, 0.010108563117682934, 0.013804849237203598, -0.007888484746217728, -0.013066745363175869, 0.013574191369116306, 0.03173846751451492, -0.00048293903819285333, -0.013539592735469341, -0.03801234811544418, -0.015465582720935345, -0.014023973606526852, 0.009583817794919014, -0.0021753881592303514, 0.015038866549730301, -0.040918633341789246, 0.021981656551361084, 0.013528060168027878, -0.016330547630786896, -0.018544860184192657, -0.002358472440391779, -0.022304575890302658, -0.03173846751451492, 0.03231510892510414, -0.0027981633320450783, 0.006325780879706144, 0.005181143060326576, -0.014369959942996502, -0.024357426911592484, 0.009900971315801144, -0.035705775022506714, 0.02368852123618126, 0.02987014129757881, -0.015396385453641415, 0.0026467943098396063, -0.02472648024559021, -0.000756123976316303, -0.01142331026494503, -0.0009903854224830866, -0.01594996266067028, 0.018821649253368378, -0.018291136249899864, -0.021358881145715714, -0.019144568592309952, 0.005420450121164322, -0.01601915992796421, 0.015131128951907158, 0.000004327643182477914, 0.014081637375056744, 0.05042171850800514, -0.014358426444232464, -0.019663548097014427, 0.0019029240356758237, -0.0341373048722744, -0.00703505240380764, -0.017045585438609123, -0.018014347180724144, 0.009422357194125652, -0.023227205500006676, -0.04982201009988785, -0.00534836994484067, 0.0045353020541369915, -0.004477637819945812, -0.03316854313015938, 0.02945495769381523, 0.03155393898487091, -0.02583363465964794, -0.012536232359707355, -0.003785665612667799, 0.00003344983633724041, -0.019559752196073532, 0.016734197735786438, 0.013389665633440018, 0.02451888844370842, -0.009710678830742836, 0.000496273918543011, 0.0019995118491351604, -0.008073011413216591, -0.01600762829184532, 0.025464583188295364, 0.041979655623435974, 0.0033935478422790766, -0.03526752442121506, -0.021093623712658882, 0.009116736240684986, 0.018441064283251762, -0.03773555904626846, 0.013551125302910805, -0.024611150845885277, -0.028647655621170998, 0.030123863369226456, 0.003520409343764186, 0.013458862900733948, 0.019548218697309494, 0.004492053762078285, 0.013874046504497528, -0.0017529967008158565, -0.015211859717965126, 0.03900417685508728, 0.023284871131181717, 0.011267616413533688, 0.004379608668386936, -0.0007568447617813945, -0.0012909609358757734, -0.006204685661941767, 0.018406465649604797, 0.0016073941951617599, 0.016837993636727333, 0.009618416428565979, -0.01550018135458231, -0.009105202741920948, 0.02910897135734558, 0.007721258327364922, 0.025395385921001434, 0.00668906606733799, 0.00534548657014966, -0.028647655621170998, -0.015315655618906021, -0.006516073364764452, -0.012455502524971962, 0.02326180413365364, -0.014865873381495476, 0.004639097955077887, -0.01803741231560707, 0.004301761742681265, 0.0007272918010130525, 0.0002863396075554192, 0.019594350829720497, 0.010794769041240215, -0.0050831139087677, 0.011832727119326591, 0.018913911655545235, 0.007513666525483131, -0.011065791361033916, -0.010264256969094276, -0.004396907985210419, 0.0019894205033779144, 0.003318584058433771, -0.012282509356737137, 0.014369959942996502, -0.016745731234550476, 0.027978749945759773, -0.0008815439650788903, -0.0008555949898436666, 0.028786050155758858, 0.006937023252248764, 0.03524446114897728, 0.038289137184619904, 0.04894551262259483, 0.026179620996117592, 0.0027246412355452776, -0.02465728297829628, -0.02724064514040947, -0.014093170873820782, -0.0177606251090765, -0.0043911412358284, -0.04004213586449623, 0.026364147663116455, -0.005628041923046112, 0.014888938516378403, -0.018763983622193336, -0.01476207748055458, -0.037850890308618546, 0.031231019645929337, -0.03058517910540104, 0.015557845123112202, -0.01386251300573349, 0.009324328042566776, 0.014704412780702114, -0.039465490728616714, 0.03672066703438759, -0.010039365850389004, -0.018994642421603203, -0.03323774039745331, 0.018971575424075127, 0.018198873847723007, -0.01543098408728838, 0.0017457886133342981, -0.021785596385598183, -0.010592943988740444, -0.03342226520180702, -0.014508354477584362, -0.022477569058537483, 0.003367598867043853, -0.021151289343833923, 0.020563112571835518, 0.01522339228540659, 0.012628495693206787, 0.023642389103770256, 0.007127315271645784, 0.02590283192694187, -0.023584725335240364, 0.007628995459526777, 0.02313494309782982, -0.008332500234246254, 0.03662840276956558, 0.0027938385028392076, -0.011480974964797497, 0.03782782331109047, 0.009918270632624626, 0.014058572240173817, -0.04221031442284584, 0.017714492976665497, 0.006971621885895729, 0.06306175142526627, -0.02479567751288414, 0.013043679296970367, 0.004690995905548334, 0.01644587703049183, -0.004042271990329027, 0.0196404829621315, 0.04255630075931549, -0.013839447870850563, 0.017933616414666176, 0.024288229644298553, 0.002169621642678976, -0.035428985953330994, 0.0009766902076080441, 0.03044678457081318, 0.01156747154891491, -0.01469288021326065, -0.030700508505105972, 0.019767343997955322, 0.0045353020541369915, -0.020378585904836655, -0.008615056052803993, 0.0024824508000165224, -0.016480475664138794, -0.022050853818655014, -0.04686959460377693, 0.0073349070735275745, 0.011734697967767715, -0.02465728297829628, -0.02876298502087593, -0.04470141604542732, 0.0015151312109082937, 0.01741463877260685, -0.0313694141805172, -0.0259720291942358, 0.028739919885993004, -0.02786342054605484, 0.010875498875975609, -0.019836541265249252, -0.011694333516061306, -0.007473301608115435, -0.021820195019245148, 0.0012159972684457898, -0.008090310730040073, -0.036536142230033875, 0.034160368144512177, 0.019421357661485672, 0.04793062061071396, -0.04324827343225479, -0.0036155555862933397, -0.006521839648485184, 0.011227251961827278, 0.06052451580762863, 0.002860152395442128, 0.003353182692080736, -0.015523246489465237, -0.028739919885993004, 0.025672174990177155, -0.011181119829416275, 0.023008082062005997, -0.0170686524361372, 0.026940790936350822, 0.018960043787956238, -0.008609289303421974, -0.01845259591937065, -0.001219601253978908, -0.021082092076539993, -0.01596149615943432, 0.0009947102516889572, 0.018014347180724144 ]
11.780043
6.778921
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.532..538K
[ "stellar mass", "stellar mass profiles", "galaxy size", "mass", "stellar masses", "galaxy formation models", "low-mass galaxies", "mock observations", "stellar-mass relationship", "SMR" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
69
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1505", "10.48550/arXiv.2404.02373" ]
[ "Klein, Courtney", "Bullock, James S.", "Moreno, Jorge", "Mercado, Francisco J.", "Hopkins, Philip F.", "Cochrane, Rachel K.", "Benavides, Jose A." ]
[ "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California Irvine, Irvine, CA 92697, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California Irvine, Irvine, CA 92697, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, Pomona College, Claremont CA 91711, USA; The Observatories of the Carnegie Institution for Science, 813 Santa Barbara Street, Pasadena, CA 91101, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, Pomona College, Claremont CA 91711, USA; TAPIR, California Institute of Technology, Mailcode 350-17, Pasadena, CA 91125, USA", "TAPIR, California Institute of Technology, Mailcode 350-17, Pasadena, CA 91125, USA", "Department of Astronomy, Columbia University, New York, NY 10027, USA; Center for Computational Astrophysics, Flatiron Institute, 162 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California, Riverside, 900 University Avenue, Riverside, CA 92521, USA" ]
null
[ "1958MeLuS.136....1H", "1963BAAA....6...41S", "1969ApJ...155..393P", "1976ApJ...209L...1P", "1983ApJ...270..119M", "1992ApJ...395..130P", "1998ApJ...495...80B", "1998MNRAS.295..319M", "2001MNRAS.322..231K", "2003MNRAS.343..978S", "2003MNRAS.344.1000B", "2003PASP..115..763C", "2005ApJ...625L..71H", "2006MNRAS.369.1081B", "2007MNRAS.382.1187K", "2010MNRAS.407..144T", "2010gfe..book.....M", "2011MNRAS.413..971D", "2011MNRAS.415.3903T", "2011MNRAS.418.1557T", "2011MNRAS.418.1587T", "2012ApJS..203...24V", "2012MNRAS.425.2741H", "2013MNRAS.430.2715I", "2014A&A...571A..16P", "2014AJ....147...13K", "2014ApJ...788...28V", "2014MNRAS.437.1894O", "2015ApJ...805....2S", "2015MNRAS.447.2603L", "2015MNRAS.452.2087L", "2016ApJ...820..131E", "2016MNRAS.462.1470L", "2017AJ....154...28B", "2017ARA&A..55..343B", "2017ApJ...838....6H", "2017MNRAS.471.3547F", "2018MNRAS.480..800H", "2018MNRAS.481.4133G", "2019ApJ...880...57M", "2019MNRAS.488.4801J", "2019MNRAS.489.4574G", "2019MNRAS.490.1186G", "2020ApJ...904...33L", "2020MNRAS.493...87T", "2021ApJ...922..267C", "2021MNRAS.501.1591P", "2021MNRAS.501.4812F", "2021MNRAS.501.5121M", "2021MNRAS.505.3192R", "2022ApJ...935..167A", "2022ApJ...940...88L", "2022MNRAS.510.3967R", "2022MNRAS.511.2544D", "2022ascl.soft02006G", "2023ApJ...957L..34W", "2023MNRAS.522.1033B", "2023MNRAS.522.1208A", "2023MNRAS.523.2409C", "2024MNRAS.528.4797G" ]
29163240
2406.15555
Reconsidering the dynamical states of galaxy clusters using PCA and UMAP
Numerous metrics exist to quantify the dynamical state of galaxy clusters, both observationally and within simulations. Many of these correlate strongly with one another, but it is not clear whether all of these measures probe the same intrinsic properties. In this work, we use two different statistical approaches - principal component analysis (PCA) and uniform manifold approximation and projection (UMAP) - to investigate which dynamical properties of a cluster are in fact the best descriptors of its dynamical state. We use measurements taken directly from THE THREE HUNDRED suite of galaxy cluster simulations, as well as morphological properties calculated using mock X-ray and SZ maps of the same simulated clusters. We find that four descriptions of dynamical state naturally arise, and although correlations exist between these, a given cluster can be 'dynamically relaxed' according to all, none, or some of these four descriptions. These results demonstrate that it is highly important for future observational and theoretical studies to consider in which sense clusters are dynamically relaxed. Cluster dynamical states are complex and multidimensional, and so it is not meaningful to classify them simply as 'relaxed' and 'unrelaxed' based on a single linear scale.
[ -0.01492463331669569, 0.05218613147735596, 0.0006252507446333766, 0.009922627359628677, 0.022812651470303535, 0.04662695899605751, -0.007293287664651871, -0.03395604342222214, 0.028547117486596107, 0.048204559832811356, -0.004629516042768955, -0.030800836160779, -0.030926043167710304, -0.015012277290225029, 0.043021004647016525, 0.01622678153216839, 0.00304878200404346, 0.013847855851054192, -0.02759554609656334, 0.023476246744394302, -0.00726824626326561, -0.01330946758389473, 0.012526925653219223, -0.02144789882004261, -0.026819264516234398, 0.0008787941769696772, 0.003831323469057679, -0.022374428808689117, 0.03423149883747101, 0.005856540985405445, 0.011750644072890282, -0.017829427495598793, -0.013159219175577164, 0.009728556498885155, -0.06240299716591835, 0.11849557608366013, -0.05594233050942421, 0.04765365272760391, -0.04419794678688049, -0.03748686984181404, 0.0011839853832498193, 0.009553267620503902, -0.023513808846473694, -0.014624137431383133, -0.0024665710516273975, -0.04790406674146652, -0.03971555083990097, -0.006836283020675182, 0.007549961097538471, 0.005408927332609892, -0.05789555609226227, 0.02834678627550602, 0.03185257315635681, -0.027946123853325844, -0.03620976209640503, -0.014574054628610611, 0.024765875190496445, -0.029173150658607483, 0.013910459354519844, -0.007850456982851028, 0.029148109257221222, -0.01503731869161129, 0.011512751691043377, 0.035158026963472366, -0.04126811400055885, -0.012545706704258919, -0.015500583685934544, -0.011162173002958298, -0.0023147580213844776, 0.002086255932226777, 0.029523728415369987, -0.004754722584038973, 0.012821161188185215, 0.012213909067213535, -0.00001892772525025066, -0.01751640997827053, -0.010429713875055313, -0.0011417281348258257, -0.022775089368224144, 0.042019352316856384, -0.021285131573677063, 0.0320529043674469, 0.030951084569096565, 0.018367815762758255, -0.039865799248218536, -0.014436326920986176, -0.015162525698542595, -0.02537938766181469, -0.011425106786191463, 0.006567088887095451, 0.021898644044995308, 0.011343722231686115, -0.011062007397413254, 0.003289804793894291, 0.011074528098106384, -0.052286297082901, 0.036134641617536545, -0.025554677471518517, -0.010022792965173721, 0.006207119673490524, 0.005787677597254515, 0.029223233461380005, -0.025254182517528534, -0.01924426294863224, 0.04041670635342598, -0.033405136317014694, -0.04557522013783455, 0.020321039482951164, 0.02661893516778946, 0.020809344947338104, 0.013860376551747322, 0.03803778067231178, -0.048955801874399185, 0.06165175512433052, -0.01431111991405487, -0.016652485355734825, -0.057094234973192215, 0.03212802857160568, -0.06605903059244156, 0.0073120687156915665, -0.015713434666395187, 0.0034995258320122957, 0.05343819782137871, 0.009822461754083633, 0.0030613027047365904, -0.038613732904195786, -0.006861324422061443, -0.026694057509303093, -0.09220217913389206, 0.04777885973453522, -0.006804981734603643, -0.02764562889933586, -0.02540442906320095, -0.013722648844122887, -0.036635465919971466, -0.028547117486596107, -0.0015032623196020722, 0.008432667702436447, -0.0330795980989933, -0.004976964555680752, 0.027520421892404556, -0.024753354489803314, 0.0034557036124169827, 0.06370514631271362, -0.02516653761267662, 0.01134998258203268, -0.02737017348408699, 0.05664348974823952, -0.0051146917976439, -0.004244505427777767, 0.025529636070132256, -0.019331907853484154, -0.024465380236506462, -0.04950670897960663, -0.011256078258156776, -0.041318196803331375, 0.005039567593485117, 0.0072369445115327835, -0.003903317265212536, -0.037837449461221695, 0.0067298575304448605, -0.0020831257570534945, -0.024953685700893402, 0.005271200090646744, 0.00573446461930871, 0.0011714646825566888, -0.03974059224128723, -0.0020737352315336466, -0.030450258404016495, -0.025254182517528534, 0.01344719436019659, -0.02907298505306244, -0.03671059012413025, -0.03325488790869713, 0.014348682016134262, 0.016314426437020302, 0.0199454203248024, -0.016652485355734825, -0.006150776986032724, 0.008000705391168594, 0.028547117486596107, 0.021360255777835846, 0.000019722492652363144, -0.05323787033557892, -0.06065010279417038, 0.041318196803331375, -0.030875960364937782, 0.017866989597678185, 0.013271905481815338, -0.007380932103842497, -0.019369469955563545, 0.04630142077803612, -0.0036278627812862396, 0.07377175986766815, 0.007111737970262766, -0.04086745157837868, -0.0012638046173378825, 0.03175240755081177, -0.024515463039278984, 0.014323640614748001, -0.009647172875702381, 0.008914713747799397, 0.05303753912448883, -0.058546628803014755, -0.036109600216150284, -0.01467421930283308, 0.02884761244058609, -0.0038438441697508097, -0.04171885550022125, 0.003530827583745122, -0.004338410682976246, -0.009741077199578285, -0.008463969454169273, 0.04184406250715256, -0.025742487981915474, -0.023801784962415695, -0.06190216913819313, 0.025792570784687996, 0.02069666050374508, 0.04883059486746788, 0.0060913036577403545, 0.03453199565410614, 0.027570504695177078, 0.005690642166882753, 0.0189813282340765, -0.04064207896590233, 0.009797420352697372, -0.08669308573007584, 0.029173150658607483, -0.0355837307870388, 0.024340173229575157, 0.004695249255746603, -0.04191918671131134, 0.03523315116763115, -0.01001027226448059, -0.012345375493168831, 0.007462316658347845, 0.0320529043674469, -0.025041330605745316, -0.01295888889580965, -0.019669964909553528, 0.0002756502653937787, -0.05579208582639694, -0.009991491213440895, 0.013221822679042816, 0.02512897551059723, -0.017866989597678185, 0.03127662092447281, -0.01603897288441658, -0.015976369380950928, 0.006332326214760542, 0.03127662092447281, -0.05353836342692375, -0.03060050494968891, -0.02122252807021141, -0.0006905929185450077, -0.005480921361595392, 0.05208596587181091, 0.026543810963630676, 0.042269766330718994, -0.0354585237801075, 0.0034494432620704174, -0.03578406199812889, -0.001273977686651051, -0.024703271687030792, 0.010116697289049625, 0.015287731774151325, -0.03275405988097191, -0.04434819519519806, -0.022562239319086075, -0.007174341008067131, -0.017103228718042374, 0.01655231975018978, -0.008676821365952492, -0.05889720842242241, 0.021397816017270088, 0.016890376806259155, 0.0017685439670458436, 0.02737017348408699, -0.022324346005916595, 0.006742378231137991, -0.03305455669760704, 0.05549158900976181, 0.03913959860801697, -0.0005755593301728368, 0.029173150658607483, 0.02984926663339138, 0.017441285774111748, 0.006861324422061443, 0.010079135186970234, 0.06640961021184921, -0.013246864080429077, -0.005844020284712315, 0.004889319650828838, -0.022862734273076057, -0.046000923961400986, -0.020521370694041252, -0.009922627359628677, -0.04469877481460571, 0.040566954761743546, 0.008244858123362064, -0.03175240755081177, -0.02412732131779194, -0.00394400954246521, -0.039540261030197144, 0.02441529743373394, 0.04900588467717171, 0.024790916591882706, 0.01899384893476963, 0.02537938766181469, 0.023551370948553085, 0.024465380236506462, 0.004858017899096012, 0.03077579475939274, -0.0629539042711258, -0.02192368544638157, 0.0063354563899338245, 0.03375571221113205, 0.02092203125357628, -0.006911407224833965, -0.07126762717962265, -0.08539094030857086, 0.012727255932986736, -0.027996206656098366, -0.03498273715376854, -0.008157213218510151, -0.028471993282437325, -0.0006471618544310331, 0.01468674000352621, -0.013096615672111511, 0.008038267493247986, 0.01802975870668888, 0.060549937188625336, 0.03618472069501877, 0.009121304377913475, -0.017341122031211853, 0.026944471523165703, 0.034431830048561096, -0.043296460062265396, -0.0008255813736468554, -0.053638529032468796, -0.026017941534519196, -0.018918724730610847, -0.00826363917440176, 0.06060001999139786, 0.03768720105290413, -0.004210073500871658, 0.036635465919971466, -0.0008381020161323249, -0.02489108219742775, 0.04537488892674446, -0.02611810714006424, 0.021823519840836525, 0.015350335277616978, 0.01679021120071411, -0.00746857700869441, 0.004510569851845503, -0.012652132660150528, -0.02832174487411976, 0.011368763633072376, 0.07226928323507309, -0.040291499346494675, 0.044999271631240845, 0.027244968339800835, -0.014110789634287357, 0.026593893766403198, -0.019619882106781006, -0.015074880793690681, -0.029423562809824944, 0.021785957738757133, 0.001522043370641768, -0.030650587752461433, -0.02368909865617752, -0.03605951741337776, -0.04119298979640007, 0.03766215965151787, 0.03763711825013161, 0.0053870161063969135, 0.02887265384197235, 0.01220764871686697, 0.032178111374378204, -0.0035496086347848177, -0.0056342994794249535, -0.033931002020835876, 0.010579962283372879, 0.019532237201929092, 0.015237649902701378, -0.03312968090176582, -0.05694398656487465, 0.020659098401665688, -0.004704639781266451, 0.00022458942839875817, 0.004191292449831963, 0.000008106641871563625, -0.010648826137185097, -0.04557522013783455, -0.00012892372615169734, 0.04812943562865257, 0.03403116762638092, 0.007299548014998436, -0.0013639699900522828, 0.01047353632748127, -0.02884761244058609, -0.009403019212186337, 0.00714929960668087, 0.03721141815185547, -0.02689438872039318, 0.012433020398020744, 0.0061413864605128765, 0.026819264516234398, 0.04760356992483139, -0.01280238013714552, 0.014436326920986176, -0.02241199091076851, 0.012307814322412014, 0.02664397470653057, -0.03007463738322258, 0.05764514207839966, 0.0004777416179422289, 0.0743226706981659, 0.001648032572120428, 0.010748990811407566, 0.015638310462236404, 0.016815252602100372, 0.008395105600357056, 0.041343238204717636, 0.027971165254712105, 0.0008913148776628077, -0.02789604291319847, -0.03533331677317619, 0.03478240966796875, 0.07697705179452896, 0.04382232949137688, -0.0008279290050268173, -0.0027279399801045656, -0.011262338608503342, 0.05674365535378456, -0.03580910339951515, 0.009021139703691006, -0.03623480349779129, 0.011800726875662804, 0.008138432167470455, -0.03575902059674263, -0.05278712511062622, 0.0022067672107368708, 0.005405797157436609, 0.01968248561024666, -0.006100694183260202, 0.034156374633312225, -0.008257378824055195, -0.028772488236427307, -0.004723420832306147, -0.03923976421356201, 0.006686035078018904, -0.03077579475939274, 0.00910252332687378, 0.07317076623439789, -0.049907371401786804, 0.06019935756921768, -0.035158026963472366, 0.033430177718400955, 0.05464018136262894, -0.014962194487452507, 0.025542156770825386, -0.012833681888878345, 0.03107629157602787, -0.0012301553506404161, -0.01307157427072525, -0.02022087387740612, 0.016452154144644737, 0.015588228590786457, -0.08288680016994476, 0.037587035447359085, -0.026543810963630676, 0.05739472806453705, 0.02365153655409813, 0.005515352822840214, -0.022061411291360855, 0.06485704332590103, -0.013246864080429077, -0.0032146808225661516, -0.023501288145780563, -0.040266457945108414, 0.028446951881051064, 0.023977074772119522, 0.030199844390153885, 0.006836283020675182, 0.050633568316698074, -0.017416246235370636, 0.03493265435099602, -0.00023319739557337016, -0.02043372578918934, 0.06180200353264809, -0.012608310207724571, 0.02957381121814251, -0.019043931737542152, -0.0019438333110883832, 0.007111737970262766, -0.006723597180098295, 0.027244968339800835, 0.06580861657857895, 0.01729103922843933, 0.025842653587460518, 0.000824016286060214, -0.0018374075880274177, 0.03778736665844917, -0.023851867765188217, -0.05894729122519493, -0.0034494432620704174, -0.016677526757121086, 0.01697802171111107, 0.04640158638358116, 0.016089055687189102, -0.012094962410628796, 0.01293384749442339, 0.004407274071127176, 0.016114095225930214, -0.010648826137185097, 0.01098062377423048, -0.010598743334412575, -0.02264988422393799, -0.023639015853405, 0.006604650989174843, 0.0009766118600964546, 0.003574649803340435, -0.02862223982810974, -0.01012295763939619, -0.07918068766593933, -0.03130166232585907, -0.0057970681227743626, 0.015826120972633362, -0.03816298767924309, 0.017679179087281227, 0.011262338608503342, -0.028947778046131134, 0.0013874461874365807, -0.005211726762354374, -0.03480745106935501, -0.0009860023856163025, -0.012357896193861961, 0.02166075073182583, -0.004285197705030441, 0.0058784522116184235, -0.019369469955563545, 0.019857775419950485, 0.01630190573632717, 0.02069666050374508, 0.0209721140563488, 0.05934795364737511, 0.030024554580450058, 0.025742487981915474, -0.03901439160108566, 0.006604650989174843, 0.0007880193879827857, -0.015588228590786457, 0.008282420225441456, 0.005158514250069857, 0.008075828664004803, 0.008601697161793709, -0.0036184722557663918, -0.03555868938565254, 0.020896989852190018, 0.041819021105766296, 0.037962656468153, -0.017604054883122444, -0.018367815762758255, -0.005246158689260483, -0.007662646938115358, -0.03448191285133362, 0.04837984964251518, -0.03896430879831314, -0.0021911163348704576, -0.02442781813442707, -0.03593431040644646, -0.014348682016134262, 0.0042413752526044846, -0.023125668987631798, -0.015150004997849464, 0.020834386348724365, -0.04392249509692192, 0.010135478340089321, -0.03625984489917755, 0.005089650396257639, 0.019882816821336746, -0.06215258315205574, 0.005505962297320366, 0.011168433353304863, -0.01464917790144682, -0.013847855851054192, 0.009910106658935547, 0.021297652274370193, -0.027545463293790817, 0.03230331465601921, 0.013196781277656555, -0.030525382608175278, 0.028246620669960976, -0.03493265435099602, -0.003850104520097375, -0.03969050943851471, 0.013196781277656555, 0.01899384893476963, 0.012727255932986736, -0.03453199565410614, -0.060800351202487946, -0.01259578950703144, 0.007437275256961584, -0.02611810714006424, 0.007130519021302462, -0.03450695425271988, 0.01999550312757492, 0.008395105600357056, -0.002474396489560604, 0.047753818333148956, -0.04790406674146652, 0.004075476434081793, 0.018405377864837646, 0.029173150658607483, 0.0033868399914354086, 0.06135125830769539, -0.03828819468617439, -0.03172736614942551, 0.014148351736366749, 0.011281119659543037, -0.02271248586475849, 0.033430177718400955, 0.01600141078233719, 0.009465622715651989, -0.04169381409883499, -0.01060500368475914, -0.021898644044995308, 0.00007126019045244902, 0.01575099676847458, 0.018054800108075142, -0.021823519840836525, -0.011487710289657116, 0.04732811450958252, -0.005856540985405445, 0.04484902322292328, -0.02093455195426941, 0.014599096029996872, 0.034882571548223495, 0.05083389952778816, 0.013897938653826714, -0.05268695950508118, 0.007180601358413696, -0.03225323185324669, 0.021523023024201393, -0.021785957738757133, -0.055341340601444244, -0.027996206656098366, -0.03135174512863159, -0.01945711299777031, 0.007575002498924732, 0.03172736614942551, -0.001207461697049439, -0.018580667674541473, 0.004069216083735228, 0.023038024082779884, -0.080933578312397, 0.027420256286859512, -0.020759262144565582, 0.018831079825758934, 0.00012129394599469379, -0.0276205874979496, -0.01849302276968956, 0.02664397470653057, -0.012526925653219223, 0.019619882106781006, -0.018067320808768272, 0.04016629233956337, 0.06190216913819313, 0.02884761244058609, 0.019820213317871094, 0.040291499346494675, -0.03891422599554062, -0.02121000736951828, 0.011462668888270855, -0.037812408059835434, -0.05839638411998749, 0.014010624028742313, -0.01771674118936062, 0.029273314401507378, 0.005834629759192467, 0.030976125970482826, 0.02560476027429104, 0.006861324422061443, 0.013034012168645859, 0.007925581187009811, -0.006535787135362625, -0.025817612186074257, 0.0008412321913056076, 0.0023914470802992582, 0.003718637628480792, 0.014486409723758698, -0.00517416512593627, -0.022261742502450943, -0.03255372866988182, 0.0201707910746336, 0.00803200714290142, -0.02119748666882515, 0.03127662092447281, 0.04016629233956337, -0.05095910653471947, -0.020358601585030556, -0.027520421892404556, -0.017103228718042374, -0.00036290366551838815, -0.0007492835866287351, 0.028697364032268524, -0.018630750477313995, 0.019144097343087196, 0.03132670372724533, -0.00814469251781702, 0.006567088887095451, 0.01259578950703144, -0.003393100341781974, -0.005133472848683596, 0.005443359259516001, -0.012107483111321926, -0.025028809905052185, 0.0010791248641908169, -0.011644219048321247, -0.03533331677317619, -0.009578309021890163, 0.042269766330718994, -0.012339115142822266, -0.030199844390153885, 0.0049550533294677734, -0.040541913360357285, 0.009565788321197033, 0.0026277746073901653, 0.028722405433654785, -0.0050927805714309216, -0.01134998258203268, -0.0050270468927919865, 0.016176698729395866, 0.04099265858530998, -0.0009445276809856296, -0.013609963469207287, 0.01823008805513382, 0.011882111430168152, 0.005521613173186779, 0.0044385758228600025, -0.040091171860694885, 0.007443535607308149, 0.009202688932418823, 0.03137678653001785, -0.016089055687189102, 0.010129217989742756, 0.030425217002630234, -0.011431367136538029, 0.010185561142861843, -0.006660993676632643, 0.007431014906615019, 0.0012450236827135086, 0.00801948644220829, 0.0035683896858245134, 0.004545001313090324, 0.023513808846473694, 0.05689390376210213, 0.023238355293869972, 0.05173538997769356, 0.0015165655640885234, 0.012652132660150528, -0.011750644072890282, -0.03110133297741413, -0.036360010504722595, -0.019106535241007805, 0.0006471618544310331, -0.05133472755551338, -0.03175240755081177, 0.03838836029171944, -0.0020486938301473856, -0.01304653286933899, 0.031451910734176636, -0.005988008342683315, 0.05075877532362938, -0.019669964909553528, -0.013359549455344677, 0.03202786296606064, 0.003418141510337591, -0.011763164773583412, 0.03813794627785683, -0.001517348107881844, -0.0011425106786191463, 0.015550666488707066, 0.04752844572067261, -0.010999404825270176, 0.011118350550532341, 0.036860838532447815, 0.00103295489680022, 0.05008266121149063, 0.005988008342683315, 0.02049632929265499, -0.02494116500020027, 0.04504935443401337, 0.0021003414876759052, -0.09831226617097855, -0.0017904550768435001, 0.010736470110714436, -0.0017638487042859197, -0.004066085908561945, -0.003505786182358861, 0.005803328473120928, 0.046677038073539734, 0.004238245077431202, -0.02709471993148327, 0.029924388974905014, -0.03718637675046921, 0.02241199091076851, 0.04657687619328499, 0.0041443402878940105, -0.025078892707824707, -0.046226296573877335, 0.004106778185814619, 0.011500230990350246, -0.011368763633072376, 0.0003699465305544436, -0.00243370421230793, -0.0177918653935194, 0.022762568667531013, 0.01921922154724598, 0.0016010800609365106, -0.030024554580450058, -0.04249513894319534, 0.030174802988767624, 0.012433020398020744, 0.0002476744120940566, 0.00004700140198110603, -0.012213909067213535, 0.02711976133286953, 0.010824115015566349, 0.013772731646895409, -0.013710128143429756, 0.03656034171581268, -0.029273314401507378, -0.018117401748895645, -0.008470229804515839, -0.009953929111361504, 0.01342215295881033, -0.002438399475067854, 0.0335303395986557, -0.006454403046518564, 0.02173587493598461, 0.009284073486924171, -0.01605149358510971, 0.0314769521355629, -0.028196537867188454, -0.002034608041867614, -0.02367657795548439, 0.001652727834880352, 0.01944459229707718, 0.032378438860177994, -0.0084952712059021, -0.0038094124756753445, -0.01575099676847458, 0.005365104880183935, 0.00024571805261075497, 0.000695679453201592, 0.022061411291360855, -0.014048186130821705, -0.0695648193359375, -0.016339467838406563, -0.03060050494968891, 0.012883764691650867, 0.021510502323508263, -0.013960542157292366, 0.006160167511552572, 0.01845546066761017, 0.0003108646487817168, 0.00947814341634512, -0.03270397707819939, -0.00003391828795429319, 0.030425217002630234, -0.00788801908493042, -0.021084800362586975, 0.005318152718245983, -0.000036314821045380086, -0.020045585930347443, 0.04900588467717171, -0.012764818035066128, 0.0038156728260219097, 0.0192693043500185, -0.015187567099928856, -0.02023339457809925, -0.03435670584440231, 0.024227486923336983, -0.0049300119280815125, 0.01894376613199711, 0.0244403388351202, 0.002123817801475525, 0.008845849893987179, 0.001205114065669477, 0.027019595727324486, -0.028446951881051064, 0.013660045340657234, 0.02834678627550602, 0.03247860446572304, -0.017904551699757576, 0.023563891649246216, -0.03771224245429039, -0.023601453751325607, -0.03182753175497055, 0.01851806417107582, -0.007806634530425072, 0.002187986159697175, 0.061050765216350555, 0.023989595472812653, -0.012357896193861961, -0.014348682016134262, 0.024966206401586533, 0.016727609559893608, -0.007330849301069975, 0.011268598958849907, -0.0008075829246081412, 0.022349387407302856, -0.02641860395669937, 0.028471993282437325, -0.02862223982810974, -0.020884469151496887, 0.0118195079267025, 0.007656386587768793, 0.0138102937489748, -0.026042982935905457, 0.013635004870593548, -0.020546412095427513, 0.02318827249109745, -0.01648971624672413, -0.0064356219954788685, 0.0010298247216269374, 0.013647524639964104, -0.026068024337291718, 0.01972004771232605, -0.008282420225441456, 0.020671619102358818, 0.01416087243705988, -0.005499702412635088, -0.01011043693870306, -0.025717446580529213, 0.04567538574337959, -0.0022505896631628275, 0.02121000736951828, -0.0030581725295633078, 0.020546412095427513, -0.027069678530097008, 0.02317575179040432, 0.008213556371629238, 0.021147403866052628, 0.03628488630056381, 0.002499437890946865, 0.02814645506441593, 0.004898710176348686, 0.01848050206899643, -0.0003666207194328308, 0.00047813288983888924, -0.003175553632900119, 0.015187567099928856, 0.024039676412940025, 0.040817368775606155, -0.012983929365873337, -0.024214966222643852, 0.024615628644824028, 0.0045606521889567375, -0.05233637988567352, -0.028522076085209846, 0.013547359965741634, -0.0006534222047775984, 0.018092360347509384, -0.08203539997339249, 0.006106954533606768, 0.003274153918027878, -0.0036216024309396744, 0.034156374633312225, 0.007099217269569635, 0.013034012168645859, 0.010536139830946922, 0.038563650101423264, -0.015675872564315796, -0.003677945351228118, -0.029924388974905014, 0.00912756472826004, 0.05223621428012848, 0.030525382608175278, 0.004426055122166872, -0.0000016170488379430026, 0.008595436811447144, 0.0345570370554924, -0.024002114310860634, 0.03257877007126808, 0.00437597231939435, 0.03230331465601921, -0.007017832715064287, 0.007117998320609331, -0.02393951267004013, 0.004654557444155216, 0.014048186130821705, 0.012727255932986736, -0.058346301317214966, 0.0015877768164500594, -0.013246864080429077, -0.02929835580289364, -0.004172511864453554, 0.0012551966356113553, 0.0246657095849514, -0.025592239573597908, -0.007105477619916201, -0.007330849301069975, 0.019932899624109268, 0.00885837059468031, 0.023300958797335625, 0.019381990656256676, 0.04064207896590233, -0.029724059626460075, 0.01874343492090702, -0.04394753649830818, -0.028672322630882263, -0.010824115015566349, 0.0024305740371346474, -0.01344719436019659, -0.04174389690160751, 0.05619274452328682, 0.0009304419509135187, 0.051134396344423294, -0.0320529043674469, -0.014235996641218662, -0.04712778329849243, -0.013334508053958416, 0.012495623901486397, 0.019169138744473457, 0.0013741430593654513, 0.008000705391168594, -0.022775089368224144, -0.04655183479189873, -0.009547007270157337, 0.013121657073497772, 0.01024190429598093, -0.00033903613802976906, 0.006742378231137991, -0.007318328600376844, 0.002662206534296274, 0.005988008342683315, -0.02020835317671299, -0.011500230990350246, 0.00901487935334444, -0.025003768503665924, 0.03851356729865074, -0.015600749291479588, -0.03009967878460884, 0.011612917296588421, 0.02241199091076851, -0.010636305436491966, -0.01895628683269024, 0.00283280061557889, -0.01648971624672413, 0.03280414268374443, 0.013221822679042816, -0.0006592912832275033, -0.02365153655409813, -0.014999756589531898, -0.028647281229496002, -0.045024313032627106, 0.022048890590667725, 0.0060255699791014194, -0.026068024337291718, -0.0006088173249736428, -0.004851757548749447, -0.023926991969347, -0.025817612186074257, -0.012376677244901657, 0.03368058800697327, 0.0009116609580814838, 0.002036173129454255, 0.018818559125065804, -0.010924280621111393, 0.00117302977014333, -0.014148351736366749, 0.02465318888425827, -0.02214905619621277, -0.025492073968052864, 0.0013741430593654513, -0.009572048671543598, 0.02734513208270073, -0.02413984201848507, -0.023088106885552406, -0.030675629153847694, 0.02686934731900692, -0.03004959598183632, -0.004858017899096012, -0.007374671753495932, 0.0003550782275851816, -0.0189813282340765, -0.007412233855575323, -0.041092824190855026, -0.017153311520814896, 0.009121304377913475, 0.01096810307353735, -0.011731863021850586, -0.030199844390153885, -0.009584569372236729, 0.008038267493247986, 0.011537793092429638, -0.0012943237088620663, -0.02561728097498417, -0.023025503382086754, -0.016715088859200478, -0.02937348000705242, -0.020108187571167946, 0.01628938503563404, -0.03821307048201561, -0.01950719580054283, 0.05689390376210213, 0.016389550641179085, 0.010160519741475582, -0.03335505351424217, 0.023588933050632477, -0.02636852115392685, 0.01722843572497368, -0.036360010504722595, -0.0038688855711370707, 0.018593188375234604, -0.025441991165280342, -0.02732009068131447, -0.004244505427777767, 0.005048958119004965, 0.008413886651396751, 0.010817854665219784, 0.015938807278871536, -0.028471993282437325, 0.02837182767689228, 0.020834386348724365, -0.029448604211211205, -0.026919430121779442, 0.026944471523165703, -0.007869238033890724, -0.0072369445115327835, -0.0007031136192381382, 0.016852814704179764, 0.01923174224793911, 0.008833329193294048, -0.018643271178007126, 0.008514052256941795, -0.01070516835898161, 0.0314769521355629, -0.008457709103822708, -0.009077481925487518, -0.020784303545951843, 0.016940459609031677, 0.06696052104234695, -0.013685086742043495, -0.004864278249442577, -0.022299304604530334, 0.011544053442776203, -0.02954876981675625, -0.019031411036849022, -0.005700032692402601, -0.005346323829144239, -0.026593893766403198, 0.004175642039626837, 0.006031830329447985, 0.0012731951428577304, 0.0023836216423660517, -0.0004683511215262115, -0.013034012168645859, -0.02636852115392685, 0.017879510298371315, -0.009453102014958858, 0.006448142696171999, 0.005246158689260483, -0.0026935080531984568, 0.019795171916484833, 0.018856121227145195, -0.0027467210311442614, -0.027270009741187096, 0.023538850247859955, -0.0011878981022164226, -0.011450148187577724, 0.012289033271372318, -0.00010476275201654062, -0.04309612885117531, -0.027720753103494644, -0.026443645358085632, -0.011863330379128456, 0.003008089726790786, -0.0046608177945017815, 0.003305455669760704, 0.01724095642566681, -0.020896989852190018, 0.05373869463801384, 0.002360145328566432, -0.002763936761766672, -0.015312773175537586, -0.013534839265048504, 0.03227827325463295, 0.012983929365873337, 0.02362649515271187, 0.02268744446337223, -0.015500583685934544, -0.028797529637813568, -0.019594840705394745, 0.009277813136577606, -0.007205642759799957, -0.0016057753236964345, 0.0034337923862040043, -0.0020173920784145594, 0.038638774305582047, 0.0008850545273162425, -0.01538789737969637, 0.020621536299586296, -0.004300848580896854, -0.024064717814326286, 0.010830375365912914, 0.024690750986337662, -0.013872897252440453, -0.002788978163152933, -0.005728204268962145, -0.022737527266144753, 0.02814645506441593, -0.008720642887055874, 0.019294345751404762, -0.03896430879831314, -0.012107483111321926, -0.008714382536709309, -0.009709775447845459, 0.00598174799233675, 0.02338860183954239, 0.006635952740907669, -0.02018331177532673, 0.000733632710762322, -0.031426869332790375, -0.007042874116450548, 0.02391447126865387, -0.024302611127495766, 0.03235339745879173, 0.010792813263833523, -0.004231984727084637, -0.025742487981915474, 0.04482398182153702, -0.011663000099360943, 0.029699018225073814, 0.009572048671543598, 0.02196124754846096, 0.01775430329144001, 0.007168080657720566, -0.027194885537028313, 0.014273558743298054, 0.04307108744978905, -0.01035458967089653, -0.023751702159643173, 0.023751702159643173, 0.02837182767689228, -0.00803200714290142, 0.012983929365873337, -0.01502479799091816, 0.0011792901204898953, -0.015437980182468891, 0.021898644044995308, -0.015012277290225029, 0.05048332363367081, 0.03009967878460884, 0.02269996516406536, 0.012501884251832962, 0.0025933426804840565, 0.036835797131061554, -0.03523315116763115, -0.02516653761267662, -0.023125668987631798, -0.003615342080593109, 0.018192525953054428, -0.015375376679003239, -0.017629096284508705, -0.008939755149185658, -0.0016840294701978564, -0.012971409596502781, -0.0020674748811870813, -0.01676516979932785, 0.0015580402687191963, 0.01975760981440544, -0.05674365535378456, 0.04640158638358116, 0.026318438351154327, 0.012307814322412014, 0.014523971825838089, -0.014023144729435444, 0.004238245077431202, 0.0006495094858109951, 0.026468686759471893, -0.0019047062378376722, 0.028797529637813568, 0.00912756472826004, -0.014436326920986176, -0.039089515805244446, 0.01849302276968956, 0.008708123117685318, 0.002886013360694051, -0.020646577700972557, 0.007518659345805645, 0.00985376350581646, -0.005906623788177967, 0.018054800108075142, -0.00206590979360044, 0.004792284686118364, -0.010961842723190784, -0.002862537046894431, -0.026719098910689354, 0.021084800362586975, 0.010986884124577045, -0.016665006056427956, 0.025717446580529213, 0.044773899018764496, -0.023714140057563782, -0.010561181232333183, 0.03555868938565254, 0.015951327979564667, -0.02982422523200512, -0.01418591383844614, -0.02338860183954239, -0.03701108694076538, -0.001972004771232605, -0.010304507799446583, 0.030875960364937782, 0.02492864429950714, -0.02368909865617752, -0.010022792965173721, 0.003859495045617223, -0.016965501010417938, -0.028446951881051064, 0.017866989597678185, -0.0073120687156915665, -0.018430419266223907, 0.015538145788013935, 0.018054800108075142, -0.004898710176348686, 0.00007972142338985577, 0.02002054452896118, -0.002108166925609112, 0.015625789761543274, -0.0014062272384762764, 0.013534839265048504, -0.028271662071347237, 0.013146698474884033, 0.020408684387803078, 0.018067320808768272, 0.04627637937664986, 0.01944459229707718, -0.032678935676813126, -0.006723597180098295, 0.01899384893476963, -0.0009507880313321948, -0.047853983938694, -0.03155207633972168, 0.007180601358413696, 0.01575099676847458, 0.006880105473101139, 0.007737771142274141, 0.01970752701163292, 0.000019746947145904414, 0.017679179087281227, 0.019144097343087196, -0.03322984650731087, -0.0046608177945017815, -0.024578066542744637, -0.015826120972633362, 0.038338277488946915, -0.010079135186970234, 0.026218272745609283, -0.0037436787970364094, 0.015613269060850143, 0.01945711299777031, 0.027069678530097008, 0.0003044086624868214, -0.025028809905052185, 0.015863683074712753, 0.013922980055212975, 0.0194946750998497, -0.006936448626220226, 0.007963143289089203, 0.007894279435276985, -0.004704639781266451, -0.03187761455774307, -0.0056092580780386925, 0.020871948450803757, 0.01900636963546276, 0.024828478693962097, -0.02764562889933586, 0.0003883362514898181, -0.017942113801836967, -0.006535787135362625, 0.03848852589726448, -0.008814548142254353, 0.03676067292690277, -0.009215209633111954, 0.01541293878108263, 0.014436326920986176, 0.020759262144565582, -0.013171739876270294, -0.0016073404112830758, -0.028471993282437325, -0.013459715060889721, 0.046251337975263596, -0.0017466327408328652, 0.012639611959457397, 0.012151305563747883, -0.0004965226398780942, 0.0244403388351202, -0.05058348923921585, 0.0016793342074379325, 0.0458005927503109, -0.008532833307981491, 0.011068267747759819, 0.024578066542744637, 0.013559880666434765, 0.027720753103494644, 0.025567198172211647, -0.0030002642888575792, 0.014148351736366749, -0.017604054883122444, -0.015876203775405884, -0.014286079443991184, -0.013647524639964104, -0.03508290275931358, -0.0022552849259227514, 0.027445297688245773, 0.004911230877041817, -0.004588823765516281, 0.005196075886487961, 0.01012295763939619, -0.005678121466189623, 0.013472235761582851, 0.011387544684112072, 0.0027028985787183046, -0.020295998081564903, -0.012551967054605484, -0.02641860395669937, -0.009052440524101257, 0.012395458295941353, -0.010561181232333183, 0.01098062377423048, -0.008294940926134586, -0.013948021456599236, 0.003571519860997796, 0.0023773612920194864, -0.011500230990350246, -0.01776682399213314, -0.0154004180803895, -0.03798769786953926, 0.0064105805940926075, -0.019544757902622223, 0.02412732131779194, 0.005058348644524813, -0.02390195056796074, 0.004253895953297615, -0.012501884251832962, -0.015162525698542595, 0.014724302105605602, 0.00444796634837985, -0.006761159282177687, 0.006498225033283234, 0.010961842723190784, 0.009340416640043259, -0.007499878294765949, 0.01025442499667406, -0.009052440524101257, 0.024828478693962097, -0.028046289458870888, 0.03923976421356201, 0.018142443150281906, 0.006250942125916481, -0.013948021456599236, 0.006610911339521408, -0.013121657073497772, 0.0005943403230048716, 0.01157535519450903, -0.00047343765618279576, 0.006923927925527096, 0.016940459609031677, 0.006886365823447704, 0.013584922067821026, 0.03926480561494827, -0.02839686907827854, 0.013697607442736626, -0.00225371983833611, -0.011644219048321247, 0.0120761813595891, 0.006047481205314398, 0.018906204029917717, -0.007368411403149366, -0.001912531559355557, 0.016627443954348564, -0.015099922195076942, -0.009484403766691685, -0.030400175601243973, -0.014761864207684994, -0.0042413752526044846, -0.006203989498317242, 0.009828722104430199, -0.0013968367129564285, 0.003649774007499218, -0.0004198335518594831, 0.0007504573441110551, -0.011907152831554413, -0.0064356219954788685, 0.05694398656487465, -0.0023351041600108147, 0.022299304604530334, -0.003349277889356017, -0.03651025891304016, 0.02641860395669937, -0.038112904876470566, 0.0025589109864085913, -0.005171034950762987, 0.006567088887095451, 0.004278937354683876, 0.008351284079253674, 0.029949430376291275, 0.0019892207346856594, -0.017579013481736183, -0.026669016107916832, 0.028171496465802193, -0.024352693930268288, -0.005759506020694971, 0.011813247576355934, -0.023876909166574478, -0.012639611959457397, 0.01168804056942463, 0.02070917934179306, 0.006147646810859442, 0.012808640487492085, 0.003918968141078949, 0.001710635842755437, 0.005318152718245983, 0.0030722583178430796, -0.005102171096950769, 0.03926480561494827, -0.0012387633323669434, 0.0059191444888710976, -0.031677283346652985 ]
12.745229
4.824043
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.532.1031H
[ "Cluster dynamical states", "galaxy cluster simulations", "dynamical state", "galaxy clusters", "clusters", "morphological properties", "uniform manifold approximation", "mock X", "the same simulated clusters", "its dynamical state" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
26
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1566", "10.48550/arXiv.2406.15555" ]
[ "Haggar, Roan", "De Luca, Federico", "De Petris, Marco", "Sazonova, Elizaveta", "Taylor, James E.", "Knebe, Alexander", "Gray, Meghan E.", "Pearce, Frazer R.", "Contreras-Santos, Ana", "Cui, Weiguang", "Kuchner, Ulrike", "Mostoghiu Paun, Robert A.", "Power, Chris" ]
[ "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada; Waterloo Centre for Astrophysics, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada", "Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Roma Tor Vergata, Via della Ricerca Scientifica 1, I-00133 Roma, Italy; INFN, Sezione di Roma 2, Università degli studi di Roma Tor Vergata, Via della Ricerca Scientifica, 1, I-00133 Roma, Italy", "Dipartimento di Fisica, Sapienza Università di Roma, Piazzale Aldo Moro 5, I-00185 Roma, Italy", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada; Waterloo Centre for Astrophysics, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada; Waterloo Centre for Astrophysics, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada", "Departamento de Física Teórica, Módulo 15 Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, E-28049 Madrid, Spain; Centro de Investigación Avanzada en Física Fundamental (CIAFF), Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, E-28049 Madrid, Spain; International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research, University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Highway, Crawley, Western Australia 6009, Australia", "School and Physics &amp; Astronomy, University of Nottingham, Nottingham NG7 2RD, UK", "School and Physics &amp; Astronomy, University of Nottingham, Nottingham NG7 2RD, UK", "Departamento de Física Teórica, Módulo 15 Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, E-28049 Madrid, Spain", "Departamento de Física Teórica, Módulo 15 Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, E-28049 Madrid, Spain; Centro de Investigación Avanzada en Física Fundamental (CIAFF), Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, E-28049 Madrid, Spain; Institute for Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, Royal Observatory, Edinburgh EH9 3HJ, UK", "School and Physics &amp; Astronomy, University of Nottingham, Nottingham NG7 2RD, UK", "Centre for Astrophysics &amp; Supercomputing, Swinburne University of Technology, 1 Alfred St, Hawthorn, VIC 3122, Australia; ARC Centre of Excellence for Dark Matter Particle Physics (CDM), Australia", "International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research, University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Highway, Crawley, Western Australia 6009, Australia; ARC Centre of Excellence for All-Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D), Australia" ]
null
[ "1958ApJS....3..211A", "1969ApJ...155..393P", "1972ApJ...176....1G", "1980ApJ...237..692L", "1987gady.book.....B", "1989ApJ...341L..71E", "1993ApJ...413..492M", "1995ApJ...451L...1S", "1995ApJ...452..522B", "1996ApJ...462..563N", "1996Natur.379..613M", "1997MNRAS.286..865T", "1999A&A...350..381D", "2001ApJ...555..240B", "2003MNRAS.339..289S", "2004ApJ...617..879L", "2004MNRAS.351..399G", "2005MNRAS.364.1105S", "2006ApJ...646..815S", "2006MNRAS.368..741K", "2006MNRAS.373..881P", "2007A&A...475..169M", "2007ApJ...655...98N", "2007CSE.....9...90H", "2007MNRAS.381.1450N", "2007MNRAS.382.1050T", "2008A&A...483...35S", "2009ApJ...705.1129L", "2009ApJS..182..608K", "2009MNRAS.394.1825F", "2009MNRAS.399..410P", "2010MNRAS.405.1491M", "2011ApJ...731L..10N", "2011ApJS..193...29A", "2011CSE....13b..22V", "2011MNRAS.410.2617M", "2011MNRAS.414..350S", "2011MNRAS.415.2293K", "2011MNRAS.415L..69J", "2011MNRAS.416.2388S", "2012ARA&A..50..353K", "2012ApJ...757..102W", "2012MNRAS.419.1576P", "2012MNRAS.423.3018P", "2013ApJ...777..151L", "2013AstRv...8a..40R", "2013MNRAS.429..799V", "2013MNRAS.435.1618K", "2013MNRAS.436..150S", "2013MNRAS.436..275W", "2014ApJ...789....1D", "2014JCAP...11..019A", "2015A&A...575A.127P", "2015ApJ...806...68L", "2015ApJ...810...36M", "2015ApJ...813L..17R", "2015MNRAS.448.1504S", "2015MNRAS.454.3020B", "2016A&A...594A..13P", "2016ApJ...832...95D", "2016MNRAS.455.2110B", "2016MNRAS.457.4063S", "2016MNRAS.457.4340K", "2016MNRAS.459..366G", "2016RSPTA.37450202J", "2017ApJ...834...16M", "2017MNRAS.464.2502C", "2017MNRAS.467.3268R", "2018MNRAS.477..139C", "2018MNRAS.480.2898C", "2018arXiv180203426M", "2019BAAS...51c.218W", "2019ComAC...6....2N", "2019MNRAS.483.2251Z", "2019MNRAS.485.2287B", "2019MNRAS.486.4001R", "2019MNRAS.489.5695D", "2019MNRAS.490.2380C", "2020A&A...642A..89Z", "2020ApJ...891..129S", "2020ApJ...901...90A", "2020ApJ...904...36Z", "2020MNRAS.492...96B", "2020MNRAS.492.6074H", "2020MNRAS.495..705Z", "2020MNRAS.495.3002K", "2020MNRAS.497.5485Y", "2020MNRAS.498.4450W", "2020MNRAS.499.2303V", "2020NatMe..17..261V", "2021A&A...651A..56G", "2021MNRAS.500.1029L", "2021MNRAS.502.1191H", "2021MNRAS.502.5115G", "2021MNRAS.503.6155C", "2021MNRAS.504..510V", "2021MNRAS.504.5383D", "2021MNRAS.508..100A", "2022A&A...658A.149S", "2022A&A...661A..17B", "2022A&A...664A..90L", "2022A&A...665A.117C", "2022A&A...666A..41E", "2022MNRAS.510..581K", "2022MNRAS.510.3622B", "2022MNRAS.511.2897C", "2022MNRAS.513.3013Y", "2022MNRAS.513.4951R", "2022MNRAS.514..313B", "2022MNRAS.514.5890L", "2022MNRAS.516...26Z", "2022MNRAS.517.1678C", "2023ApJ...945..152C", "2023ApJ...949...92K", "2023MNRAS.518.1316H", "2023MNRAS.519.6111V", "2023MNRAS.523.6386M", "2023MNRAS.525.4685S", "2023MNRAS.526.4831L", "2024EPJWC.29300048S", "2024MNRAS.530.4234Z" ]
29163013
2311.06333
The heart of galaxy clusters: Demographics and physical properties of cool-core and non-cool-core halos in the TNG-Cluster simulation
We analyzed the physical properties of the gaseous intracluster medium (ICM) at the center of massive galaxy clusters with TNG-Cluster, a new cosmological magnetohydrodynamical simulation. Our sample contains 352 simulated clusters spanning a halo mass range of 10<SUP>14</SUP> &lt; M<SUB>500c</SUB>/M<SUB>⊙</SUB> &lt; 2 × 10<SUP>15</SUP> at z = 0. We focused on the proposed classification of clusters into cool-core (CC) and non-cool-core (NCC) populations, the z = 0 distribution of cluster central ICM properties, and the redshift evolution of the CC cluster population. We analyzed the resolved structure and radial profiles of entropy, temperature, electron number density, and pressure. To distinguish between CC and NCC clusters, we considered several criteria: central cooling time, central entropy, central density, X-ray concentration parameter, and density profile slope. According to TNG-Cluster and with no a priori cluster selection, the distributions of these properties are unimodal, whereby CCs and NCCs represent the two extremes. Across the entire TNG-Cluster sample at z = 0 and based on the central cooling time, the strong CC fraction is f<SUB>SCC</SUB> = 24%, compared to f<SUB>WCC</SUB> = 60% and f<SUB>NCC</SUB> = 16% for weak and NCCs, respectively. However, the fraction of CCs depends strongly on both halo mass and redshift, although the magnitude and even direction of the trends vary with definition. The abundant statistics of simulated high-mass clusters in TNG-Cluster enabled us to match observational samples and make a comparison with data. The CC fractions from z = 0 to z = 2 are in broad agreement with observations, as are the radial profiles of thermodynamical quantities, globally as well as when divided as CC versus NCC halos. TNG-Cluster can therefore be used as a laboratory to study the evolution and transformations of cluster cores due to mergers, AGN feedback, and other physical processes.
[ 0.036186087876558304, 0.018380632624030113, 0.011741098016500473, 0.00023112550843507051, 0.029784128069877625, 0.012472571805119514, 0.03408544510602951, 0.011053387075662613, -0.03168470785021782, 0.013366595841944218, -0.0028586885891854763, 0.02498265542089939, -0.06326939165592194, -0.010934600606560707, -0.01512963604182005, 0.01898081600666046, -0.02419491484761238, -0.014491940848529339, -0.00710842851549387, 0.047289490699768066, -0.032685015350580215, 0.022144285961985588, 0.004510757513344288, 0.0028039843309670687, -0.0738726407289505, -0.0016004904173314571, 0.02291952446103096, 0.016805149614810944, 0.03498572111129761, -0.01943095400929451, 0.04378841817378998, -0.01599240116775036, -0.04878995195031166, -0.0059643276035785675, -0.046214163303375244, 0.07992449402809143, -0.004298191983252764, 0.029158934950828552, -0.03088446520268917, -0.010328165255486965, -0.028983881697058678, 0.04441361129283905, -0.012184984050691128, 0.02209427021443844, -0.015954889357089996, -0.04543892294168472, 0.011128410696983337, -0.057917747646570206, -0.022069262340664864, 0.00028035935247316957, -0.06807085871696472, -0.004620166029781103, 0.004326325841248035, -0.04236298054456711, -0.042913150042295456, 0.038736872375011444, -0.007127183955162764, 0.002918081823736429, 0.008471346460282803, -0.015292186290025711, -0.017592892050743103, -0.03353527560830116, 0.060768622905015945, 0.009152804501354694, 0.026007970795035362, -0.01347913034260273, -0.008533865213394165, -0.01256635133177042, 0.03266000747680664, 0.02980913408100605, -0.016842661425471306, -0.00947165209800005, -0.015092125162482262, -0.038236718624830246, -0.00663953460752964, 0.018018022179603577, -0.04706442356109619, -0.042663075029850006, -0.041537728160619736, -0.006864603608846664, 0.0022225561551749706, 0.029208950698375702, 0.03448556736111641, -0.002913392847403884, 0.017130250111222267, -0.002139718271791935, 0.016254981979727745, -0.027508430182933807, -0.08482599258422852, 0.015067117288708687, 0.005873674992471933, 0.02011866495013237, -0.0025617224164307117, -0.02675819955766201, 0.0028164880350232124, -0.06732062995433807, 0.03331020846962929, -0.020831383764743805, 0.058167826384305954, 0.05099062621593475, -0.019856084138154984, 0.020681338384747505, 0.009384125471115112, -0.028108613565564156, 0.08302544057369232, 0.003554214257746935, -0.03921201452612877, -0.004385719075798988, -0.0092715909704566, 0.017205271869897842, 0.049265097826719284, 0.031359609216451645, -0.019555993378162384, 0.029534051194787025, -0.05106564983725548, 0.019393442198634148, -0.03220986947417259, 0.025345267727971077, -0.04914005845785141, 0.0027227094396948814, -0.012435060925781727, -0.034060437232255936, 0.026483114808797836, 0.01671762391924858, -0.011516029015183449, -0.050640519708395004, 0.031159548088908195, -0.027458414435386658, -0.03198480233550072, 0.035785965621471405, -0.018868282437324524, -0.029734112322330475, -0.00022721807181369513, -0.003563591977581382, -0.05281618610024452, -0.007627337239682674, 0.005723629146814346, 0.004767085891216993, -0.024970151484012604, -0.014666995033621788, -0.018580693751573563, 0.0062894271686673164, 0.04781465232372284, 0.021319033578038216, 0.007921176962554455, 0.02783352881669998, -0.05161581560969353, 0.035385843366384506, -0.0025961080100387335, 0.03833674639463425, -0.002783665433526039, 0.02620803192257881, -0.018268099054694176, -0.06266920268535614, -0.021531598642468452, -0.030509348958730698, -0.0008080601110123098, 0.02031872607767582, 0.0025226480793207884, -0.04568900167942047, 0.016842661425471306, -0.021269017830491066, -0.044488634914159775, -0.010697027668356895, -0.010471958667039871, 0.02199424058198929, -0.028808828443288803, 0.035485874861478806, -0.07722366601228714, -0.020306222140789032, 0.014879560098052025, -0.033810362219810486, -0.04171278327703476, -0.04548893868923187, 0.007658597081899643, 0.05361643061041832, 0.024457495659589767, -0.03218486160039902, -0.011853632517158985, 0.03666123375296593, -0.013104015961289406, 0.02778351493179798, 0.003435427788645029, -0.017480356618762016, -0.07697358727455139, 0.03138461709022522, -0.02813362143933773, 0.03000919707119465, -0.01899331994354725, -0.02360723353922367, -0.042613059282302856, 0.03501072898507118, 0.014767025597393513, 0.007764879614114761, -0.015954889357089996, -0.044288571923971176, 0.011803616769611835, 0.040112290531396866, 0.019743550568819046, 0.0362861193716526, 0.03005921095609665, 0.020631322637200356, 0.06557009369134903, -0.05436665937304497, -0.04051241651177406, 0.019268404692411423, 0.03571094200015068, 0.006814588326960802, -0.025607846677303314, 0.006126877386122942, 0.018780754879117012, 0.02016868069767952, 0.0040387376211583614, 0.007958688773214817, -0.024732578545808792, -0.027608459815382957, -0.10003065317869186, 0.040312353521585464, 0.012228747829794884, 0.05666736513376236, 0.036761265248060226, 0.043113213032484055, 0.02514520473778248, 0.05346638336777687, 0.0042106653563678265, -0.009727980941534042, -0.010471958667039871, -0.04008728638291359, 0.04851486533880234, 0.012109961360692978, 0.01835562475025654, 0.028358690440654755, -0.028758812695741653, -0.025932947173714638, -0.03566092997789383, -0.005789273884147406, -0.0020678211003541946, 0.02469506859779358, 0.01569230854511261, -0.03298510983586311, -0.034510575234889984, 0.013829237781465054, 0.015392216853797436, 0.02316959947347641, 0.007020901422947645, -0.015267178416252136, 0.006464480888098478, 0.018868282437324524, 0.034360527992248535, 0.0009565431391820312, 0.013904260471463203, -0.011090898886322975, -0.009727980941534042, -0.05421661585569382, -0.032334908843040466, -0.002608611946925521, 0.01981857419013977, 0.038986947387456894, 0.0004149709129706025, 0.012253754772245884, -0.04263806715607643, -0.04038737714290619, -0.02705829218029976, -0.003919951152056456, -0.026333069428801537, 0.04363837093114853, 0.012253754772245884, 0.0013535397592931986, -0.04944014921784401, 0.006989642046391964, -0.00892773550003767, -0.0374864861369133, 0.033135153353214264, -0.028608767315745354, -0.05091560259461403, 0.03683628886938095, 0.006458228919655085, 0.033185169100761414, 0.015017101541161537, -0.03198480233550072, -0.024069875478744507, -0.03193478658795357, 0.03496071323752403, 0.025932947173714638, -0.017780449241399765, 0.03336022421717644, 0.0036323631647974253, 0.01554226316511631, 0.01963101513683796, -0.050140365958213806, 0.10843323171138763, -0.04136267676949501, -0.0219817366451025, 0.004951517563313246, -0.047939691692590714, -0.03603604435920715, 0.004717070609331131, 0.01888078637421131, -0.04073748365044594, 0.008996507152915001, 0.019055839627981186, -0.011834876611828804, 0.025420289486646652, -0.004957769066095352, -0.012216243892908096, 0.002650812268257141, 0.06296929717063904, 0.03978719189763069, 0.03448556736111641, 0.03713637962937355, 0.002641434548422694, -0.0061362553387880325, 0.016880173236131668, 0.030134234577417374, -0.0301092267036438, -0.009152804501354694, -0.018905794247984886, 0.03803665563464165, 0.02940901182591915, 0.020481277257204056, -0.011441006325185299, -0.03968716040253639, 0.0025617224164307117, 0.03398541361093521, 0.0017630403162911534, 0.01795550249516964, 0.006317561026662588, -0.012478823773562908, -0.0026726939249783754, -0.040212322026491165, 0.021606620401144028, 0.02271946147084236, 0.08792694658041, 0.007158443797379732, 0.02233184315264225, -0.04038737714290619, 0.025957955047488213, 0.04944014921784401, -0.0366862416267395, -0.012735152617096901, 0.005276617128401995, -0.009777996689081192, 0.001541097299195826, 0.01981857419013977, 0.055116891860961914, 0.025407785549759865, 0.0020740730687975883, 0.041787806898355484, 0.03591100499033928, 0.0034416797570884228, -0.028258658945560455, 0.0062894271686673164, 0.0255703367292881, -0.0021053326781839132, 0.055416982620954514, -0.015967393293976784, 0.0027649097610265017, -0.03851180151104927, -0.024757586419582367, 0.026833223178982735, 0.004401348996907473, -0.00836506299674511, 0.06376954168081284, 0.03663622587919235, 0.03281005471944809, 0.031259577721357346, -0.06246914342045784, 0.03533582761883736, -0.02980913408100605, -0.04108759015798569, 0.012291266582906246, 0.019293412566184998, -0.018405640497803688, -0.04181281477212906, -0.05441667512059212, 0.015354705043137074, 0.05686742812395096, 0.019993627443909645, 0.023444684222340584, 0.01976855844259262, 0.05926816165447235, -0.0025789153296500444, 0.047089431434869766, -0.026233039796352386, 0.02434496022760868, -0.00974048487842083, -0.013754215091466904, -0.012878946959972382, -0.07697358727455139, 0.06211903691291809, -0.009359117597341537, -0.014154337346553802, 0.011903648264706135, 0.02843371406197548, -0.022069262340664864, -0.014516948722302914, 0.00872767437249422, 0.03603604435920715, 0.01648005098104477, 0.05016537383198738, 0.00629567913711071, -0.0058142817579209805, -0.04648924618959427, -0.05626724287867546, 0.008377566933631897, 0.0040168557316064835, -0.018568189814686775, 0.06346944719552994, 0.020793871954083443, -0.027508430182933807, 0.004801471251994371, -0.010947104543447495, -0.003238492412492633, 0.00034151089494116604, 0.00003069788363063708, 0.040112290531396866, -0.052516091614961624, 0.08307545632123947, -0.03693632036447525, 0.052566107362508774, -0.019218388944864273, 0.009934294037520885, 0.015267178416252136, -0.003071253653615713, -0.05606717988848686, 0.015904873609542847, 0.039237022399902344, -0.009903035126626492, -0.025782901793718338, -0.022019248455762863, 0.007689856458455324, 0.06612025946378708, -0.01391676440834999, 0.04696439206600189, -0.012266258709132671, -0.024620044976472855, 0.040262337774038315, 0.007471039425581694, 0.035835981369018555, -0.01671762391924858, -0.010346921160817146, 0.029233958572149277, -0.01673012599349022, -0.07067165523767471, 0.022056758403778076, 0.008321300148963928, 0.029834141954779625, 0.0015348453307524323, 0.008621391840279102, -0.03641115874052048, -0.012022433802485466, 0.005298498552292585, 0.004732700530439615, -0.006908366922289133, -0.06416966766119003, -0.0016692614881321788, 0.01436690241098404, -0.020581306889653206, 0.04658927768468857, -0.073372483253479, -0.007039657328277826, 0.028708796948194504, -0.021181490272283554, 0.04541391506791115, -0.055366966873407364, 0.012797671370208263, -0.024382472038269043, 0.011172173544764519, 0.03826172649860382, -0.008946491405367851, 0.03836175426840782, -0.04116261377930641, -0.0006501992465928197, -0.030409319326281548, 0.02209427021443844, 0.0024116765707731247, 0.009515415877103806, 0.021369049325585365, 0.06331940740346909, -0.016555072739720345, 0.06421968340873718, -0.015717316418886185, -0.026233039796352386, 0.011559792794287205, 0.047639597207307816, 0.03466062247753143, -0.01746785268187523, 0.025807907804846764, 0.02813362143933773, -0.00014613854000344872, -0.02940901182591915, -0.001803677761927247, 0.06597021967172623, -0.012653877958655357, 0.007095924578607082, -0.04191284254193306, -0.023544715717434883, -0.025857923552393913, -0.025907939299941063, 0.0299591813236475, 0.03423549234867096, 0.0010581368114799261, 0.021031444892287254, -0.019893595948815346, 0.01943095400929451, 0.00949040800333023, -0.01335409190505743, -0.01424186397343874, -0.024369968101382256, 0.009846767410635948, -0.017155257984995842, 0.06376954168081284, 0.016755133867263794, 0.0023350906558334827, 0.028683790937066078, 0.004792093299329281, 0.013141526840627193, 0.009240332059562206, 0.03971216827630997, -0.01421685703098774, 0.01622997410595417, -0.009809255599975586, -0.015442232601344585, 0.007352252956479788, -0.005157830659300089, -0.010059332475066185, -0.0038636839017271996, -0.1178361102938652, -0.03351026773452759, -0.011572296731173992, 0.009427889250218868, -0.03941207751631737, 0.023969845846295357, 0.00415439810603857, -0.043213240802288055, -0.012685136869549751, -0.023719768971204758, 0.0014098070096224546, -0.013254061341285706, -0.058367885649204254, 0.02140655927360058, 0.0021944225300103426, -0.003954336978495121, -0.026133008301258087, 0.00907152984291315, 0.0371863953769207, 0.007283481769263744, 0.0017380325589329004, 0.031309593468904495, 0.019981123507022858, 0.017642905935645103, -0.017392829060554504, 0.036861296743154526, 0.005142200738191605, 0.005920564290136099, -0.02246938645839691, 0.005670487880706787, -0.02276947721838951, 0.016605088487267494, -0.022706957533955574, -0.027183329686522484, -0.008333804085850716, -0.0186432134360075, 0.018618205562233925, 0.024032365530729294, -0.03341023996472359, 0.01638001948595047, -0.005445418879389763, -0.017342815175652504, 0.021681644022464752, -0.029008889570832253, -0.0018114926060661674, -0.005973705556243658, -0.024770090356469154, 0.0008682348416186869, -0.02833368256688118, -0.03503573685884476, -0.005382899660617113, 0.011641067452728748, -0.013316581025719643, 0.006495740730315447, -0.00794618483632803, 0.013641680590808392, 0.0059486981481313705, 0.004313821904361248, 0.006408213637769222, -0.00979050062596798, -0.004326325841248035, 0.012059945613145828, -0.020768864080309868, 0.022794485092163086, -0.0033135153353214264, 0.04231296479701996, 0.005064052063971758, -0.02109396457672119, 0.010040576569736004, -0.0009690469596534967, 0.00850885733962059, -0.01731780730187893, 0.034410543739795685, -0.007989948615431786, 0.02189420908689499, -0.044688694179058075, -0.04328826442360878, -0.031259577721357346, 0.03276003897190094, 0.0011855195043608546, -0.014179345220327377, -0.02199424058198929, 0.026057984679937363, -0.0007795357378199697, 0.009427889250218868, 0.013704199343919754, -0.038436777889728546, 0.012941465713083744, 0.0058142817579209805, 0.01711774617433548, -0.015017101541161537, 0.013254061341285706, 0.0033697825856506824, -0.0227819811552763, 0.00436383718624711, 0.008527613244950771, -0.04213791340589523, 0.04293815791606903, 0.01114091370254755, 0.020031139254570007, -0.01780545711517334, -0.011553540825843811, -0.012853939086198807, 0.013716703280806541, -0.013904260471463203, 0.026133008301258087, 0.0004993717884644866, -0.01070327963680029, 0.01140974648296833, 0.020231200382113457, 0.05261612311005592, -0.001964664552360773, -0.006276923697441816, 0.026082992553710938, 0.019193381071090698, 0.010784555226564407, -0.0377865806221962, 0.015067117288708687, 0.014054306782782078, 0.0033666566014289856, -0.01037818007171154, -0.031009502708911896, -0.02783352881669998, -0.0032416183967143297, -0.050390440970659256, 0.03473564609885216, -0.0027117684949189425, 0.018180571496486664, -0.021619124338030815, -0.00427943654358387, -0.025657862424850464, -0.07867410778999329, 0.042963165789842606, -0.01579234004020691, 0.00035479621146805584, 0.02139405533671379, 0.05136574059724808, -0.028658783063292503, -0.0057767704129219055, -0.022356851026415825, 0.03911198675632477, -0.02424493059515953, 0.022156789898872375, 0.0435633510351181, 0.021919216960668564, 0.01673012599349022, 0.03473564609885216, 0.0024913884699344635, 0.021381551399827003, 0.003913699183613062, -0.021531598642468452, -0.033960405737161636, 0.020981429144740105, 0.016930188983678818, 0.011522280983626842, 0.0069208708591759205, -0.020668834447860718, 0.01055323425680399, -0.008402574807405472, 0.021806683391332626, 0.0295590590685606, 0.01810554787516594, -0.01128470804542303, -0.0026555012445896864, -0.00941538531333208, 0.006627030670642853, -0.0009041833109222353, -0.01389175746589899, -0.017080234363675117, -0.03821171075105667, -0.0034823170863091946, 0.010878333821892738, -0.04221293702721596, 0.010959608480334282, 0.01963101513683796, 0.0190433356910944, -0.03358529135584831, 0.0032791299745440483, 0.014591971412301064, -0.012410053052008152, -0.003207232803106308, 0.03373533859848976, -0.0150546133518219, 0.02065633051097393, 0.02583291567862034, -0.018730739131569862, 0.010096844285726547, 0.014954582788050175, -0.006620778702199459, 0.002650812268257141, 0.018605701625347137, -0.02271946147084236, -0.02425743266940117, 0.02271946147084236, 0.00946540106087923, -0.05121569335460663, 0.006433221511542797, 0.03556089848279953, 0.00026277583674527705, 0.005382899660617113, 0.0050515481270849705, -0.008465094491839409, -0.04323824867606163, 0.010765799321234226, 0.009015263058245182, -0.02833368256688118, -0.01760539598762989, 0.005057800095528364, 0.06922121345996857, 0.017968006432056427, -0.018268099054694176, -0.001781795988790691, 0.02271946147084236, 0.026883238926529884, 0.010459455661475658, 0.006802084390074015, -0.017405332997441292, 0.010728287510573864, 0.020893903449177742, 0.025357771664857864, -0.00868391152471304, 0.00048647719086147845, -0.0003288117004558444, -0.03178473934531212, 0.01037818007171154, -0.00150593020953238, 0.014942078851163387, 0.00843383464962244, -0.008602635934948921, 0.024132395163178444, -0.024182410910725594, 0.03358529135584831, 0.023294638842344284, 0.035785965621471405, 0.05261612311005592, -0.014254367910325527, 0.035785965621471405, -0.026082992553710938, 0.002517959102988243, -0.044838741421699524, -0.002966534113511443, 0.020243704319000244, -0.0069208708591759205, -0.0004685029562097043, 0.023819798603653908, 0.015817347913980484, -0.03971216827630997, 0.003466687398031354, -0.0069208708591759205, -0.011528532952070236, -0.04241299629211426, -0.019368436187505722, 0.01988109201192856, 0.014967086724936962, -0.027283361181616783, 0.01963101513683796, -0.052216000854969025, -0.011666075326502323, 0.0076836044900119305, 0.009252835065126419, 0.005492308177053928, 0.006370702292770147, -0.017592892050743103, -0.024657556787133217, 0.04698939993977547, 0.0035667179618030787, 0.046364206820726395, -0.013654184527695179, 0.04313822090625763, 0.012066197581589222, -0.10108097642660141, -0.015242170542478561, 0.009821759536862373, 0.00525160925462842, -0.008827704936265945, 0.011297211982309818, -0.006989642046391964, 0.000500934780575335, 0.030459333211183548, -0.009184064343571663, 0.008658903650939465, -0.02385731041431427, -0.001803677761927247, 0.04363837093114853, -0.0045701502822339535, -0.00863389577716589, 0.019255900755524635, -0.01948096975684166, -0.018368128687143326, 0.02134404145181179, -0.011397242546081543, 0.0001044265300151892, -0.0024523138999938965, 0.0036980081349611282, 0.00026394808082841337, -0.014066810719668865, -0.022456882521510124, -0.0043825930915772915, 0.013691695407032967, -0.0050671775825321674, 0.0011675453279167414, -0.020343733951449394, 0.008546369150280952, 0.03326019272208214, 0.013666688464581966, -0.0027758507058024406, -0.006298805121332407, 0.0114660132676363, -0.038586825132369995, -0.02085639163851738, 0.011109654791653156, -0.018955808132886887, 0.02665816992521286, 0.005342262331396341, 0.035986028611660004, 0.004851486533880234, 0.007702360395342112, 0.004191909451037645, -0.0015958015574142337, 0.02268195152282715, 0.011084646917879581, 0.023007050156593323, 0.038736872375011444, 0.012672633863985538, 0.03198480233550072, 0.029984189197421074, -0.015917377546429634, -0.006733313202857971, -0.013991788029670715, -0.0002934492949862033, -0.004920257721096277, 0.01554226316511631, 0.0069208708591759205, -0.047589585185050964, -0.025932947173714638, -0.03291008621454239, -0.015342201106250286, 0.03193478658795357, 0.001631750026717782, -0.0016270610503852367, 0.014004291966557503, 0.02286950871348381, 0.014679498039186, 0.01320404652506113, 0.004751455970108509, -0.006070610135793686, -0.01844315230846405, -0.00517658656463027, -0.03891192376613617, 0.021319033578038216, -0.04008728638291359, -0.02843371406197548, -0.01579234004020691, -0.02474508248269558, 0.015592277981340885, -0.00047592708142474294, -0.0111909294500947, -0.027558445930480957, -0.004964021034538746, -0.014491940848529339, 0.014279375784099102, 0.008802697993814945, 0.028608767315745354, 0.012866443023085594, -0.00587680097669363, 0.016154950484633446, 0.002818051027134061, -0.04161275178194046, -0.03123457171022892, -0.01579234004020691, -0.005951824132353067, 0.005517315585166216, 0.012653877958655357, -0.039912231266498566, -0.006583267357200384, -0.014141833409667015, -0.011916151270270348, 0.02563285455107689, 0.0047264485619962215, 0.016792645677924156, 0.06036850064992905, 0.016267485916614532, -0.03413546085357666, 0.012503831647336483, 0.04078749939799309, -0.011434754356741905, -0.0012683573877438903, -0.0010370365343987942, 0.02119399420917034, -0.04216292127966881, 0.016254981979727745, -0.0019521607318893075, -0.029008889570832253, -0.034310515969991684, 0.006226908415555954, -0.000002692475391086191, -0.01291645783931017, -0.006392584182322025, -0.0366862416267395, -0.013629176653921604, -0.037011340260505676, -0.013904260471463203, 0.02164413221180439, -0.01711774617433548, -0.01512963604182005, -0.004826479125767946, -0.01761789806187153, 0.030084218829870224, -0.021619124338030815, 0.009721728973090649, -0.012866443023085594, -0.017867974936962128, 0.00994054600596428, -0.0034229238517582417, 0.017780449241399765, -0.004170028027147055, 0.004410726483911276, -0.03168470785021782, 0.06131879240274429, 0.028008583933115005, 0.003941833041608334, -0.019055839627981186, 0.014992094598710537, 0.017180263996124268, -0.030434327200055122, -0.0040387376211583614, -0.0014520074473693967, 0.008946491405367851, -0.012360037304461002, 0.030434327200055122, 0.01617995835840702, 0.03943708539009094, 0.018093043938279152, -0.0021475329995155334, 0.0077398717403411865, 0.02006864920258522, -0.035835981369018555, 0.025320259854197502, 0.019343428313732147, -0.01062825694680214, -0.006527000106871128, -0.06491989642381668, 0.01084707397967577, 0.011616059578955173, -0.008390070870518684, 0.03673625737428665, 0.01671762391924858, 0.02006864920258522, 0.015454735606908798, -0.005511063616722822, -0.02370726503431797, 0.012403801083564758, -0.029083913192152977, -0.0009291910100728273, 0.04058743640780449, -0.024032365530729294, -0.03541085124015808, 0.015279682353138924, -0.017405332997441292, 0.03205982595682144, -0.01874324306845665, 0.017442844808101654, -0.013566657900810242, 0.047339506447315216, -0.004529512953013182, 0.019193381071090698, -0.021519094705581665, 0.011841128580272198, -0.009934294037520885, 0.002356972312554717, -0.009221576154232025, -0.013954276219010353, 0.0052797431126236916, -0.045663993805646896, 0.03178473934531212, -0.005808029789477587, -0.011009624227881432, -0.037011340260505676, -0.03621109575033188, -0.017742937430739403, 0.03503573685884476, -0.0016848912928253412, 0.0018552560359239578, 0.026333069428801537, 0.03528581187129021, -0.01633000373840332, 0.02115648239850998, -0.015854857861995697, 0.0223818589001894, -0.004542016889899969, 0.02434496022760868, -0.032634999603033066, 0.0014269998064264655, 0.038986947387456894, -0.019405946135520935, 0.050740547478199005, -0.011816120706498623, 0.005010910797864199, -0.019618511199951172, 0.012478823773562908, 0.03503573685884476, 0.007414772175252438, 0.008440086618065834, -0.01750536449253559, -0.020393749698996544, -0.013391603715717793, -0.010865829885005951, 0.011215937323868275, -0.002535151783376932, 0.02793356031179428, 0.03205982595682144, 0.022344347089529037, 0.017292799428105354, 0.00007101785740815103, -0.0035573402419686317, 0.010728287510573864, 0.019368436187505722, -0.01923089288175106, 0.009915538132190704, -0.015767332166433334, -0.0015661049401387572, 0.01574232429265976, -0.017993014305830002, -0.018630709499120712, -0.015017101541161537, 0.04008728638291359, -0.003701134119182825, 0.01913086324930191, 0.017255287617444992, 0.0009291910100728273, -0.0110658910125494, -0.017780449241399765, -0.017280295491218567, -0.03673625737428665, 0.004404474515467882, 0.0023304016795009375, -0.030909471213817596, -0.015092125162482262, 0.007320993579924107, -0.031509656459093094, -0.0061018699780106544, -0.02203175239264965, 0.009096537716686726, 0.021769171580672264, -0.011928655207157135, -0.020781368017196655, -0.0023475943598896265, 0.0021193993743509054, -0.017130250111222267, 0.007927428930997849, -0.03653619810938835, 0.007458535488694906, -0.029384003952145576, 0.016392523422837257, 0.03260999172925949, 0.02690824680030346, -0.02514520473778248, -0.029333990067243576, 0.02843371406197548, -0.010409439913928509, -0.006727061700075865, -0.0030134234111756086, 0.0029540301766246557, -0.006320687010884285, 0.0029087038710713387, -0.003491695038974285, 0.023232119157910347, 0.003907447215169668, -0.01804303005337715, -0.036961328238248825, 0.006589519325643778, 0.007039657328277826, 0.023382164537906647, -0.012016182765364647, -0.03683628886938095, -0.008896476589143276, -0.014529452659189701, -0.01579234004020691, -0.02950904332101345, -0.013929268345236778, 0.01825559511780739, 0.00427943654358387, -0.02350720390677452, 0.013541650027036667, 0.012435060925781727, -0.013266565278172493, -0.00012406145106069744, -0.002797732362523675, 0.0014520074473693967, 0.006145633291453123, -0.05246607959270477, -0.02301955409348011, 0.022506896406412125, -0.0019834202248603106, -0.03281005471944809, 0.013341588899493217, 0.031059518456459045, 0.0050296662375330925, -0.00016421047621406615, 0.018905794247984886, 0.003291633678600192, 0.035735949873924255, 0.018668221309781075, -0.02409488335251808, -0.010240638628602028, 0.02503267116844654, 0.013804229907691479, 0.014154337346553802, 0.003497947007417679, 0.007708612363785505, 0.012653877958655357, 0.014754521660506725, -0.012378793209791183, 0.007502299267798662, -0.012603862211108208, 0.00018599450413603336, -0.0030696906615048647, -0.00547042628750205, 0.006927122827619314, -0.016517560929059982, 0.06617027521133423, -0.015217163600027561, -0.0009807692840695381, 0.008996507152915001, 0.040262337774038315, -0.012903953902423382, 0.0012433497468009591, 0.029133927077054977, 0.0018536930438131094, 0.004710818640887737, -0.001781795988790691, -0.01701771467924118, -0.029784128069877625, -0.013666688464581966, 0.020156176760792732, 0.0006322250119410455, -0.03178473934531212, 0.020393749698996544, -0.006258167792111635, -0.008965247310698032, 0.0020787620451301336, 0.00830879621207714, -0.007614833302795887, 0.015579774044454098, 0.028608767315745354, -0.023819798603653908, 0.0056611099280416965, 0.010690775699913502, -0.021681644022464752, 0.04221293702721596, -0.027958568185567856, -0.005301624536514282, -0.007777383551001549, -0.0013801103923469782, 0.008883972652256489, -0.02025620825588703, -0.050940610468387604, 0.005954949650913477, 0.003204106818884611, 0.011259700171649456, 0.03123457171022892, -0.018718235194683075, 0.012353785336017609, -0.002153784967958927, -0.028933865949511528, 0.00841507874429226, -0.008915232494473457, 0.02321961522102356, -0.0037824090104550123, 0.010853325948119164, -0.02469506859779358, -0.023832302540540695, -0.008958995342254639, -0.002331964671611786, 0.014829544350504875, 0.013554153963923454, 0.04363837093114853, 0.03793662413954735, 0.04481373354792595, -0.004451364278793335, 0.007789887022227049, -0.01497959066182375, -0.049515172839164734, 0.02710830792784691, 0.01320404652506113, -0.009384125471115112, -0.004448238294571638, 0.012366289272904396, 0.01574232429265976, -0.00796494074165821, -0.019593505188822746, -0.010321913287043571, -0.029058905318379402, 0.004098130855709314, 0.008883972652256489, 0.001068296143785119, -0.019205885007977486, 0.02178167551755905, 0.00941538531333208, 0.0003071253595408052, 0.009215324185788631, -0.008021208457648754, -0.023594729602336884, 0.05641729012131691, -0.024282440543174744, -0.007502299267798662, 0.003616733243688941, -0.031259577721357346, -0.002482010517269373, 0.03473564609885216, -0.034060437232255936, -0.0037824090104550123, -0.00256328540854156, 0.023057065904140472, 0.00026355733280070126, -0.0022850751411169767, -0.010484462603926659, -0.013003985397517681, 0.0218817051500082, -0.01638001948595047, -0.02011866495013237, 0.016755133867263794, 0.025807907804846764, -0.014066810719668865, 0.0026476862840354443, 0.008352559991180897, -0.006820840295404196, -0.010184370912611485, 0.00855887308716774, -0.0029712230898439884, 0.016392523422837257, 0.016605088487267494, 0.010484462603926659, 0.003288507694378495, -0.027758507058024406, 0.020693842321634293, 0.0022772604133933783, -0.0007088109850883484, -0.030859457328915596, 0.008196261711418629, 0.02965908870100975, -0.01988109201192856, 0.025020167231559753, -0.011034631170332432, 0.0026007969863712788, -0.052366048097610474, -0.00573300663381815, -0.0029743490740656853, 0.0008596384432166815, 0.025157708674669266, -0.004807723220437765, 0.007158443797379732, 0.010115600191056728, 0.01128470804542303, 0.023919830098748207, 0.007008397486060858, 0.006248789839446545, -0.013566657900810242, 0.03551088273525238, 0.023882318288087845, -0.010296905413269997, 0.006933374796062708, -0.02268195152282715, -0.005307876504957676, 0.017942998558282852, 0.0149295749142766, 0.009584186598658562, 0.0021662889048457146, 0.022319339215755463, -0.010759547352790833, -0.015029605478048325, 0.008446338586509228, 0.024807602167129517, 0.007896170020103455, -0.039036963135004044, -0.032935094088315964, -0.04653926193714142, -0.019293412566184998, -0.0011050261091440916, 0.011672327294945717, -0.006777076981961727, 0.01785547100007534, -0.0019802942406386137, -0.030509348958730698, 0.04421354830265045, -0.0008182195015251637, 0.008002452552318573, 0.0036511188372969627, -0.014692001976072788, 0.008677659556269646, -0.0057767704129219055, -0.0019834202248603106, 0.028208645060658455, -0.027383390814065933, -0.03476065397262573, -0.009759240783751011, 0.011172173544764519, 0.010459455661475658, -0.0295590590685606, 0.02031872607767582, 0.016930188983678818, -0.04151272028684616, 0.020131168887019157, 0.01165982335805893, -0.014604475349187851, -0.04513883218169212, -0.0020631321240216494, 0.011741098016500473, 0.04823978245258331, 0.013579160906374454, 0.0018990194657817483, 0.007220963016152382, 0.0012136531295254827, 0.01347913034260273, 0.022006744518876076, 0.027308369055390358, 0.011028379201889038, -0.011647319421172142, -0.017780449241399765, 0.004029359668493271, -0.017817961052060127, -0.038436777889728546, 0.0009424763265997171, -0.022394362837076187, 0.0009252835297957063, 0.019606007263064384, -0.0031368988566100597, 0.02036874182522297, 0.010196874849498272, 0.005010910797864199, -0.006280049681663513, -0.030409319326281548, -0.02468256466090679, 0.0007998544606380165, -0.007233466487377882, 0.025245236232876778, 0.01242255698889494, 0.003610481508076191, -0.008265032432973385, -0.001747410511597991, 0.05046546459197998, 0.005151578690856695, 0.014516948722302914, -0.013166534714400768, 0.013254061341285706, 0.02828366681933403, 0.020193688571453094, -0.006570763420313597, 0.017767945304512978, 0.0302592720836401, -0.0033291452564299107, -0.023444684222340584, -0.006011216901242733, 0.013904260471463203, -0.00034307388705201447, 0.023782288655638695, -0.032484956085681915, 0.0092715909704566, -0.03931204602122307, -0.01271639671176672, -0.041887834668159485, -0.028208645060658455, 0.050090350210666656, 0.005079681519418955, -0.008540117181837559, 0.02468256466090679, -0.016792645677924156, 0.00015991229156497866, -0.025782901793718338, -0.018455656245350838, 0.005311002489179373, 0.0440635047852993, -0.012447564862668514, 0.012228747829794884, -0.01541722472757101, -0.02336966060101986, 0.01676763780415058, -0.05386650562286377, 0.0016192462062463164, 0.023157095536589622, -0.029358996078372, 0.032084833830595016, 0.011978670954704285, 0.02286950871348381, 0.047839660197496414, 0.02341967634856701, -0.03633613511919975, 0.010196874849498272, 0.017717929556965828, -0.015879865735769272, -0.010040576569736004, -0.03783659636974335, -0.021681644022464752, 0.005632976070046425, 0.0295590590685606, 0.02950904332101345, -0.017492860555648804, -0.007521054707467556, 0.019005823880434036, -0.018518174067139626, 0.008396322838962078, 0.010490714572370052, 0.017717929556965828, -0.028958873823285103, -0.03916200250387192, -0.004576402250677347, -0.0011652008397504687, 0.027908552438020706, 0.003694882383570075, 0.020231200382113457, 0.03418547660112381, 0.017180263996124268, 0.01761789806187153, 0.002535151783376932, -0.006870855577290058, -0.016455043107271194, -0.02798357605934143, -0.010740791447460651, 0.032334908843040466, -0.017380326986312866, 0.0024319952353835106, 0.018655717372894287, -0.021419063210487366, -0.016805149614810944, 0.014529452659189701, -0.01396678015589714, 0.009909287095069885, -0.015204659663140774, -0.013254061341285706, -0.001705210073851049, 0.012016182765364647, 0.015767332166433334, 0.003260374069213867, 0.013079008087515831, 0.0020756360609084368, 0.014391910284757614, -0.0026476862840354443, 0.05751762539148331, -0.004204413387924433, 0.011759853921830654, 0.002885259222239256, 0.012278762646019459, -0.023869814351201057, 0.00023053940094541758, 0.046514254063367844, 0.000787741388194263, 0.015229666605591774, 0.06812087446451187, 0.012816427275538445, 0.01790548674762249, 0.035585906356573105, -0.03493570536375046, 0.01436690241098404, 0.006664542481303215, 0.019606007263064384, 0.003119705943390727, 0.010315661318600178, 0.018330616876482964, -0.005289120599627495, -0.019318420439958572, 0.03766154125332832, -0.01923089288175106, 0.012491327710449696, -0.006858351640403271, -0.008190009742975235, 0.032584983855485916, -0.01721777580678463, 0.0017302177147939801, -0.024044867604970932, 0.0037136380560696125, -0.011884892359375954, -0.026683177798986435, -0.015717316418886185, -0.004107508808374405, 0.038886915892362595, 0.0109408525750041, 0.02818363718688488, -0.016292491927742958, -0.025257740169763565, -0.003432301804423332, 0.014204353094100952, -0.0024069875944405794, 0.0015840792329981923, 0.0015481306472793221, -0.009377873502671719, 0.0028133620508015156, 0.02144407108426094, 0.00235384632833302, -0.007752375677227974, -0.00816500186920166, 0.00207251007668674, 0.01678014174103737, 0.0037386456970125437, 0.01077205128967762, -0.012366289272904396, -0.010690775699913502, 0.019843580201268196, 0.015517255291342735, -0.003848054213449359, 0.012366289272904396, 0.02424493059515953, -0.013954276219010353, -0.0182430911809206, 0.0007009960827417672, 0.022694455459713936, 0.013291573151946068, -0.013654184527695179, 0.030509348958730698, -0.01835562475025654 ]
13.529484
5.096989
2024-07-01
2
2024A&A...687A.129L
[ "cluster central ICM properties", "cluster cores", "NCC clusters", "clusters", "massive galaxy clusters", "central density", "central cooling time", "density profile slope", "radial profiles", "NCC halos" ]
[ "galaxies: clusters: intracluster medium", "galaxies: evolution", "galaxies: halos", "X-rays: galaxies: clusters", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
33
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202348609", "10.48550/arXiv.2311.06333" ]
[ "Lehle, Katrin", "Nelson, Dylan", "Pillepich, Annalisa", "Truong, Nhut", "Rohr, Eric" ]
[ "Universität Heidelberg, Zentrum für Astronomie, ITA, Albert-Ueberle-Str. 2, 69120, Heidelberg, Germany", "Universität Heidelberg, Zentrum für Astronomie, ITA, Albert-Ueberle-Str. 2, 69120, Heidelberg, Germany", "Max-Planck-Institut für Astronomie, Königstuhl 17, 69117, Heidelberg, Germany", "NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt, MD, 20771, USA", "Max-Planck-Institut für Astronomie, Königstuhl 17, 69117, Heidelberg, Germany" ]
[ "2024ApJ...966..236L", "2024MNRAS.tmp.1430B" ]
[ "1973ApJ...184L.105L", "1977ApJ...215..723C", "1977MNRAS.180..479F", "1978ApJ...225...21M", "1990ApJ...348...73S", "1992MNRAS.258..177E", "1993ApJ...416..554T", "1994ARA&A..32..277F", "1999ApJ...517..627M", "1999PhR...310...97B", "2001ApJ...556L..91S", "2001ApJ...560..194M", "2001MNRAS.328..726S", "2002ApJ...581L...1C", "2003ApJ...590..225C", "2003MNRAS.339..289S", "2005RvMP...77..207V", "2006MNRAS.366..417F", "2007A&A...469..363B", "2007MNRAS.376..497M", "2007MNRAS.377..317K", "2007MNRAS.381.1381S", "2007hvcg.conf...42H", "2007hvcg.conf...48V", "2008A&A...483...35S", "2008A&A...487..431C", "2008MNRAS.391.1163P", "2009A&A...501..835M", "2009ApJS..182...12C", "2009MNRAS.399..410P", "2009MNRAS.400.1992G", "2010A&A...511A..85P", "2010A&A...513A..37H", "2010ApJ...713.1037H", "2010MNRAS.401..791S", "2011A&A...526A..79E", "2011A&A...536A..11P", "2011MNRAS.418.1392P", "2011PASJ...63S1009T", "2012ApJ...746...94G", "2012MNRAS.420.3174S", "2012MNRAS.421.1583M", "2013A&A...550A.131P", "2013A&A...559A..78G", "2013AN....334..394G", "2013ApJ...764...60R", "2013ApJ...764...82B", "2013ApJ...774...23M", "2013MNRAS.432..176P", "2013MNRAS.432..554W", "2014ApJ...794...67M", "2014MNRAS.443..687B", "2015ApJ...802...34L", "2015ApJ...811...73L", "2015ApJ...813L..17R", "2015MNRAS.447.3723P", "2015MNRAS.449...49R", "2016A&A...594A..13P", "2016ApJ...821...29L", "2016MNRAS.460.2625L", "2016MNRAS.461.1548B", "2017ApJ...843...28M", "2017ApJ...843...76A", "2017ApJ...845...80V", "2017MNRAS.465.3291W", "2017MNRAS.468.1917R", "2017MNRAS.470..166H", "2017MNRAS.470.4186B", "2017MNRAS.471.1088B", "2018MNRAS.473.4077P", "2018MNRAS.474.1065S", "2018MNRAS.475..624N", "2018MNRAS.475..648P", "2018MNRAS.475..676S", "2018MNRAS.477.1206N", "2018MNRAS.478.4785Z", "2018MNRAS.480.2898C", "2018MNRAS.480.5113M", "2018MNRAS.481.1809B", "2019A&A...621A..41G", "2019A&A...631A..22O", "2019ApJ...880...70G", "2019ApJ...882..119Z", "2019ComAC...6....2N", "2019MNRAS.483.1042Y", "2019MNRAS.484.4881M", "2019MNRAS.488.3003B", "2019MNRAS.488.3195C", "2019MNRAS.490.3196P", "2019MNRAS.490.3234N", "2020A&A...633A..42S", "2020MNRAS.498.2391N", "2021ApJ...908L..16V", "2021ApJ...918...43R", "2021MNRAS.508.4667P", "2023A&ARv..31....4R", "2023ApJ...948...49R", "2023MNRAS.518.4622E", "2023MNRAS.520.3164A", "2023MNRAS.524.2539P", "2023MNRAS.525.3831M", "2023MNRAS.526.4978S", "2023RNAAS...7...86G", "2024A&A...686A..55L", "2024A&A...686A..86R", "2024A&A...686A.157N", "2024A&A...686A.200T" ]
29097444
2403.07060
Scrutinizing evidence for the triggering of active galactic nuclei in the outskirts of massive galaxy clusters at z ≈ 1
Environmental effects are believed to play an important yet poorly understood role in triggering accretion events onto the supermassive black holes (SMBHs) of galaxies (active galactic nuclei; AGNs). Massive clusters, which represent the densest structures in the Universe, provide an excellent laboratory to isolate environmental effects and study their impact on black hole growth. In this work, we critically review observational evidence for the preferential activation of SMBHs in the outskirts of galaxy clusters. We develop a semi-empirical model under the assumption that the incidence of AGN in galaxies is independent of environment. We demonstrate that the model is broadly consistent with recent observations on the AGN halo occupation at z =
[ 0.008138195611536503, 0.03765026852488518, 0.05519510433077812, 0.047039128839969635, 0.025629686191678047, 0.03416501358151436, 0.06098015978932381, 0.0007772184326313436, -0.04594850167632103, 0.021966608241200447, -0.011024795472621918, -0.007154262624680996, -0.05306127294898033, -0.019168918952345848, 0.005156759172677994, -0.008031504228711128, -0.017936037853360176, 0.007557319477200508, 0.0014595999382436275, 0.0076047382317483425, -0.006982370745390654, 0.016537193208932877, 0.027502715587615967, 0.026933694258332253, -0.048698775470256805, -0.06107499822974205, 0.019726086407899857, 0.012542187236249447, 0.06681263446807861, 0.013253464363515377, 0.056949589401483536, -0.0210063848644495, -0.03968926519155502, 0.026364672929048538, -0.044170308858156204, 0.09360407292842865, -0.0030095914844423532, -0.028000609949231148, -0.004881139378994703, -0.0013084536185488105, -0.0006775655783712864, 0.002265714108943939, -0.05438899248838425, 0.03205488994717598, -0.023851493373513222, -0.0028569630812853575, -0.03319293260574341, -0.043743543326854706, 0.03459177911281586, 0.010580247268080711, -0.035231929272413254, -0.022025881335139275, 0.04023457691073418, -0.002022694330662489, -0.002988845808431506, -0.03551643714308739, -0.02264232188463211, -0.004202462267130613, -0.0325290746986866, -0.012838552705943584, -0.0013195673236623406, -0.00046158922486938536, 0.0035534221678972244, 0.03919136896729469, -0.008126341737806797, -0.03824299946427345, 0.00025116975302807987, 0.014510054141283035, 0.0006734905182383955, 0.016039298847317696, 0.004445482045412064, -0.06406236439943314, 0.028925269842147827, -0.004015752114355564, 0.025297757238149643, -0.010929958894848824, 0.00905692856758833, -0.030063314363360405, 0.009892679750919342, 0.031059101223945618, 0.019809069111943245, 0.017390726134181023, 0.0028865996282547712, -0.01647792011499405, -0.03067975491285324, 0.014000304974615574, -0.0014551545027643442, 0.005467942915856838, -0.06278206408023834, 0.03063233569264412, 0.0635407567024231, -0.004934485070407391, -0.012364367954432964, -0.012399931438267231, 0.04051908850669861, 0.0318889245390892, 0.05894116684794426, -0.04390950873494148, 0.07402024418115616, 0.05381996929645538, 0.000396388815715909, -0.0066267321817576885, -0.007231317460536957, -0.08578002452850342, 0.02475244365632534, -0.04665977880358696, 0.00042713675065897405, 0.014782710000872612, 0.031485866755247116, 0.0041609713807702065, 0.014699727296829224, -0.007284663617610931, -0.043506450951099396, 0.06406236439943314, -0.07956819981336594, -0.0038053328171372414, -0.041135527193546295, 0.021397586911916733, 0.009465913288295269, 0.018445787951350212, 0.023057233542203903, 0.024610189720988274, 0.00017800451314542443, 0.0049700490199029446, 0.052018068730831146, -0.007533610332757235, 0.036156587302684784, -0.025819359347224236, -0.07079578191041946, -0.016323810443282127, 0.04945747181773186, 0.038053326308727264, 0.004581810440868139, -0.016797995194792747, -0.04037683084607124, -0.001258812379091978, -0.010947740636765957, -0.008950237184762955, 0.007954449392855167, 0.030490079894661903, -0.025392593815922737, 0.029091235250234604, 0.023732947185635567, 0.03795849159359932, -0.03373824432492256, 0.02011728845536709, -0.023294325917959213, -0.02736045978963375, 0.02923349104821682, 0.020970821380615234, 0.005109340883791447, 0.030750881880521774, 0.0022909052204340696, -0.034544359892606735, -0.023258762434124947, -0.024894699454307556, 0.02498953603208065, 0.03606175258755684, -0.010135699063539505, -0.03741317614912987, 0.008713144809007645, 0.01600373536348343, -0.01913335546851158, -0.017651528120040894, 0.011753854341804981, 0.060932740569114685, -0.008588671684265137, 0.014818273484706879, -0.05486317723989487, -0.035018544644117355, 0.0016344556352123618, 0.0011335979215800762, -0.04763185977935791, 0.0035000762436538935, -0.028593340888619423, 0.05396222695708275, -0.027170786634087563, -0.029755093157291412, 0.022831996902823448, 0.008837618865072727, 0.01969052292406559, 0.042558081448078156, 0.01224582176655531, -0.025060664862394333, 0.0038912787567824125, 0.03629884496331215, -0.01652533933520317, 0.03191263601183891, -0.014320380054414272, -0.0519232302904129, -0.00765215652063489, -0.008090777322649956, 0.009412567131221294, 0.020223980769515038, -0.009311803616583347, -0.011303379200398922, -0.007077207788825035, 0.047940079122781754, -0.0376976877450943, 0.058846328407526016, 0.06477364152669907, -0.01000529807060957, 0.01509093027561903, -0.04969456419348717, -0.04272404685616493, -0.01624082773923874, 0.032908421009778976, 0.014189979061484337, 0.06757132709026337, 0.021030094474554062, 0.028427377343177795, -0.044217728078365326, -0.014059578068554401, -0.004403991159051657, 0.003055528039112687, -0.0072135357186198235, -0.0637778490781784, 0.0026080161333084106, 0.052207741886377335, 0.000776477565523237, 0.031201357021927834, 0.012257675640285015, 0.0093177305534482, 0.021314604207873344, 0.014296670444309711, 0.013526120223104954, 0.024373097345232964, -0.01839836873114109, 0.057613447308540344, -0.011967238038778305, 0.011184833012521267, 0.06169143691658974, -0.0028984544333070517, -0.018682880327105522, -0.014782710000872612, -0.006934951990842819, -0.01191389188170433, 0.059320513159036636, 0.004513646010309458, -0.012542187236249447, 0.009910461492836475, 0.016039298847317696, -0.02319948934018612, 0.01790047436952591, -0.026127580553293228, 0.05538478121161461, 0.014830128289759159, 0.016880977898836136, -0.00976820569485426, 0.02520292066037655, 0.011581962928175926, -0.022820141166448593, -0.02378036640584469, 0.026317253708839417, -0.005547961685806513, -0.03679673746228218, -0.03333519026637077, 0.047750405967235565, -0.01605115458369255, -0.007782557513564825, 0.00861830823123455, -0.030324116349220276, 0.012577750720083714, 0.0022583049722015858, -0.025084374472498894, -0.0159444622695446, 0.01826796866953373, -0.06662295758724213, -0.04779782518744469, 0.017035087570548058, 0.005571670830249786, -0.0551476888358593, 0.052018068730831146, -0.08094333857297897, -0.03091684728860855, 0.030087023973464966, 0.05116453394293785, 0.00671564182266593, -0.010272026993334293, -0.026767728850245476, -0.02897268906235695, 0.012281385250389576, 0.045877374708652496, 0.001790047506801784, -0.012589605525135994, 0.005761344917118549, -0.003565276740118861, 0.007094989530742168, 0.006176256574690342, 0.020662600174546242, 0.05367771536111832, -0.026364672929048538, 0.003085164586082101, 0.023318035528063774, -0.03136732056736946, -0.02053220011293888, 0.01874215342104435, 0.03084571845829487, -0.06240271404385567, 0.03824299946427345, 0.05538478121161461, 0.05898858606815338, -0.009104347787797451, -0.023756656795740128, -0.00014734921569470316, 0.025036955252289772, 0.06927839666604996, 0.012791133485734463, -0.0024390879552811384, 0.0376976877450943, 0.013810630887746811, -0.0646313801407814, 0.009845261462032795, 0.031485866755247116, -0.01682170480489731, -0.01050319243222475, -0.037104956805706024, -0.005076740402728319, 0.01882513426244259, -0.029589129611849785, -0.034994836896657944, 0.012399931438267231, -0.04177567735314369, -0.03060862608253956, 0.019074082374572754, -0.027953192591667175, -0.001970830373466015, 0.029280908405780792, -0.04075618088245392, -0.002477615373209119, 0.05026358366012573, 0.03297955170273781, 0.04993165656924248, 0.037104956805706024, 0.03610916808247566, -0.03262391313910484, 0.02525033801794052, 0.019145209342241287, -0.013146772049367428, -0.006407421547919512, -0.013123063370585442, -0.013846195302903652, 0.011967238038778305, -0.010995158925652504, -0.0012795579386875033, -0.0026109798345714808, 0.03625142574310303, 0.05799279734492302, 0.03938104584813118, 0.013632811605930328, 0.02736045978963375, -0.000005059051090938738, -0.009928243234753609, 0.013028225861489773, 0.02707595005631447, -0.0135735385119915, -0.01671501249074936, -0.027858354151248932, -0.012103565968573093, 0.0196075402200222, 0.030750881880521774, 0.0019471212290227413, 0.050358422100543976, 0.020200271159410477, 0.0038942424580454826, 0.027289332821965218, -0.0476081483066082, 0.020212125033140182, -0.05073776841163635, -0.03340631723403931, 0.0037430960219353437, 0.0063540758565068245, -0.01771080121397972, -0.02040180005133152, -0.10982119292020798, 0.03191263601183891, 0.010698793455958366, -0.009898606687784195, 0.032410528510808945, -0.009483695030212402, -0.005678362678736448, 0.024005603045225143, -0.007592883426696062, -0.042818885296583176, -0.018789570778608322, 0.004249881021678448, -0.029114944860339165, -0.02419527806341648, -0.09573790431022644, -0.004012788645923138, 0.03191263601183891, 0.003609731560572982, -0.010592102073132992, 0.0026435800828039646, -0.014664163812994957, -0.012826697900891304, 0.014355943538248539, 0.0478215329349041, 0.025084374472498894, 0.029589129611849785, -0.03516079857945442, -0.00116323446854949, -0.042344700545072556, -0.00509452261030674, 0.02567710541188717, -0.02180064469575882, -0.02899639867246151, 0.0473947674036026, 0.008719072677195072, -0.055953800678253174, 0.06292431801557541, 0.0065911682322621346, 0.008973946794867516, 0.010811412706971169, -0.0027250805869698524, 0.04661236330866814, -0.059794697910547256, 0.047489602118730545, -0.044952716678380966, 0.056475404649972916, -0.03300325945019722, -0.0247761532664299, 0.06263981014490128, 0.030015895143151283, -0.05965244397521019, -0.026222417131066322, 0.0022153318859636784, 0.016880977898836136, -0.022630468010902405, -0.03701012209057808, -0.05415190011262894, 0.012109492905437946, 0.010390573181211948, 0.0342598482966423, 0.00013688379840459675, -0.030703462660312653, 0.03134361281991005, -0.008440488949418068, -0.017995310947299004, -0.02391076646745205, 0.04246324673295021, 0.008873182348906994, -0.048698775470256805, -0.013170481659471989, 0.026127580553293228, 0.005414597224444151, 0.005118231754750013, -0.0004026865935884416, -0.002922163577750325, -0.03589578717947006, -0.04575882852077484, -0.042771466076374054, 0.012269530445337296, -0.021160494536161423, -0.03423614054918289, -0.016145991161465645, 0.04623301327228546, -0.012802988290786743, 0.013775067403912544, -0.048935867846012115, 0.02804802916944027, -0.02781093679368496, -0.011315234005451202, 0.01026610005646944, -0.01712992414832115, 0.012530332431197166, 0.005604271311312914, 0.022820141166448593, 0.006923097651451826, 0.0398552305996418, 0.010621738620102406, -0.04004490375518799, 0.015529550611972809, 0.00027988015790469944, 0.013644666410982609, -0.03378566354513168, -0.017604108899831772, -0.01740258000791073, 0.049884237349033356, -0.025748232379555702, 0.04625672474503517, -0.00819746870547533, -0.008973946794867516, 0.010349082760512829, -0.007806266658008099, 0.010485410690307617, -0.028379958122968674, 0.01768709160387516, -0.008523470722138882, 0.03814816474914551, -0.01945343054831028, 0.003437839448451996, 0.07544279843568802, -0.010864757932722569, 0.0247761532664299, 0.011415998451411724, -0.01816127635538578, -0.028474794700741768, 0.038053326308727264, 0.030466370284557343, 0.051022280007600784, -0.007936667650938034, -0.024218985810875893, -0.004599592182785273, -0.005539070814847946, 0.0037845871411263943, -0.022654177621006966, -0.012542187236249447, 0.004312117584049702, 0.023839639499783516, -0.03864605724811554, 0.020994530990719795, -0.020235834643244743, 0.005542034283280373, -0.008167832158505917, -0.008962091989815235, -0.009412567131221294, 0.03250536695122719, 0.03108281083405018, -0.039523299783468246, 0.021966608241200447, -0.010799557901918888, 0.0009676332701928914, 0.02061518281698227, 0.021990317851305008, 0.00040527977398596704, -0.04708654806017876, -0.06904130429029465, -0.043221939355134964, -0.0450238436460495, -0.03561127558350563, -0.04850910231471062, 0.016193410381674767, -0.02108936756849289, -0.01159974467009306, -0.039049115031957626, -0.017521126195788383, -0.02619870752096176, -0.045379482209682465, -0.015849625691771507, 0.03610916808247566, 0.041372619569301605, -0.004919666796922684, -0.030987974256277084, -0.006620804779231548, 0.04815346375107765, -0.025131791830062866, -0.006211820524185896, 0.016086718067526817, 0.021729515865445137, -0.0009831924689933658, -0.02925720065832138, 0.021812498569488525, 0.024610189720988274, 0.008013722486793995, 0.00022042181808501482, -0.01671501249074936, 0.0050411769188940525, 0.013372010551393032, 0.008221178315579891, -0.00327187473885715, -0.01818498596549034, -0.02707595005631447, 0.0022494138684123755, -0.019074082374572754, -0.027431588619947433, 0.03565869480371475, 0.028451085090637207, -0.02343658171594143, -0.005939164198935032, -0.008547180332243443, -0.009940098039805889, 0.03084571845829487, -0.010023080743849277, 0.005044140387326479, -0.017390726134181023, -0.024053022265434265, -0.0032303836196660995, -0.008019649423658848, -0.03305067867040634, -0.026222417131066322, -0.009151766076683998, -0.018232403323054314, 0.00011419332440709695, -0.04604334011673927, -0.022997960448265076, 0.02074558287858963, 0.010752139613032341, 0.03373824432492256, -0.01613413728773594, 0.011730145663022995, -0.06401494145393372, -0.0006805292214266956, -0.0033785663545131683, 0.0010306109907105565, 0.022938687354326248, 0.02781093679368496, 0.0027413805946707726, -0.003428948577493429, -0.0010743248276412487, 0.0034882216714322567, 0.023080943152308464, -0.03305067867040634, -0.03376195579767227, 0.021373877301812172, -0.008760563097894192, -0.029091235250234604, -0.0277872271835804, 0.0012921534944325686, 0.0015047957422211766, 0.011925746686756611, 0.0023398054763674736, -0.01309935376048088, -0.0024390879552811384, -0.005879891104996204, -0.02520292066037655, 0.0353267639875412, -0.04637527093291283, -0.01506722066551447, -0.013537975028157234, -0.011789418756961823, 0.04831942543387413, -0.006537822540849447, 0.014735291711986065, 0.006531895138323307, -0.0022894232533872128, -0.03746059536933899, -0.016276391223073006, 0.01167679950594902, -0.03651222586631775, 0.015209476463496685, -0.034734033048152924, 0.027644971385598183, -0.009590386413037777, -0.01742628961801529, -0.0015914825489744544, -0.0011521207634359598, 0.022452648729085922, -0.007112771272659302, -0.015624388121068478, 0.025155501440167427, 0.02826141193509102, 0.02332988940179348, -0.02111307717859745, -0.02548743039369583, 0.03139103204011917, -0.012885970994830132, -0.022440792992711067, 0.00535828759893775, -0.0004638119717128575, 0.0009572604903951287, -0.02378036640584469, -0.011220396496355534, -0.010538755916059017, 0.004729993175715208, 0.01731959916651249, 0.009282167069613934, -0.01977350376546383, 0.0007553615141659975, 0.02878301590681076, -0.024373097345232964, 0.0022671958431601524, 0.018564334139227867, 0.009133984334766865, -0.005616125650703907, -0.015719225630164146, -0.00013540197687689215, 0.036654483526945114, -0.0240174587816, -0.008250814862549305, 0.048698775470256805, -0.005651689600199461, 0.007681793067604303, 0.047726694494485855, 0.04412289336323738, -0.0034170940052717924, 0.003677895525470376, 0.0046766470186412334, -0.027407879009842873, 0.01887255348265171, 0.020212125033140182, 0.010704721324145794, 0.001790047506801784, -0.017284033820033073, 0.0018182022031396627, -0.005580561701208353, 0.02854592353105545, -0.005023394711315632, 0.013786922208964825, -0.004418809432536364, 0.016098571941256523, -0.036891575902700424, 0.029755093157291412, -0.007278736215084791, 0.02427825890481472, 0.008879109285771847, 0.002196068176999688, 0.01816127635538578, -0.04315081238746643, -0.01530431304126978, 0.01366837602108717, 0.022357812151312828, 0.06173885613679886, 0.004596628714352846, -0.021314604207873344, -0.0012669623829424381, 0.002936981851235032, -0.0018878481350839138, 0.012222112156450748, -0.0642046183347702, 0.03506596386432648, 0.02169395238161087, -0.016560902819037437, 0.028901562094688416, 0.014225542545318604, -0.014640454202890396, 0.00445437291637063, 0.007889249362051487, -0.002159022493287921, -0.016916541382670403, -0.02451535128057003, -0.01615784503519535, -0.03653593733906746, 0.005820618011057377, 0.019548267126083374, -0.005233814474195242, 0.01295709889382124, 0.008375287987291813, -0.027004821226000786, -0.04025828465819359, 0.014486344531178474, 0.007029789034277201, 0.005097486078739166, -0.020366234704852104, 0.013810630887746811, 0.03907282277941704, 0.0015292458701878786, -0.029849931597709656, -0.04149116575717926, 0.009021365083754063, 0.028711887076497078, 0.02005801536142826, -0.003781623439863324, 0.039523299783468246, 0.00860645342618227, 0.00647854944691062, 0.024136004969477654, -0.004238026216626167, -0.0018626570235937834, -0.0376976877450943, -0.01485383789986372, 0.008298233151435852, 0.005236777942627668, 0.003974261227995157, 0.0138936135917902, 0.011694581247866154, 0.015873335301876068, -0.008950237184762955, -0.0010276472894474864, -0.001137302489951253, 0.02427825890481472, 0.013644666410982609, -0.009282167069613934, 0.017070651054382324, -0.02417156845331192, 0.0075691742822527885, -0.011001086793839931, -0.0015277640195563436, 0.01837465912103653, 0.015256894752383232, 0.02643579989671707, 0.009181402623653412, 0.030584916472434998, -0.03037153370678425, 0.0172366164624691, 0.03859863802790642, 0.020579619333148003, -0.01982092298567295, 0.01190203707665205, -0.012222112156450748, 0.014332234859466553, -0.022002173587679863, -0.011943528428673744, 0.005553889088332653, -0.03385679051280022, 0.019643103703856468, 0.047702986747026443, 0.00115508446469903, 0.0029088270384818316, -0.0238040741533041, -0.007509901188313961, -0.004967085551470518, 0.006792696658521891, 0.005485725123435259, -0.0033133660908788443, 0.03506596386432648, -0.010906249284744263, -0.10669156908988953, 0.0028421448078006506, 0.05424673482775688, 0.03385679051280022, -0.02361440099775791, 0.023069089278578758, -0.0017589291092008352, 0.028356248512864113, 0.06083790585398674, 0.019714230671525, 0.03203118219971657, -0.010520974174141884, -0.011581962928175926, 0.021705808117985725, 0.0012269531143829226, -0.04637527093291283, -0.041799385100603104, -0.0053760698065161705, 0.022085154429078102, 0.0327424593269825, -0.0049493033438920975, -0.0015396185917779803, -0.011244106106460094, 0.012305094860494137, -0.010319446213543415, -0.025843068957328796, -0.027668680995702744, 0.019097791984677315, 0.010135699063539505, 0.012305094860494137, -0.021053804084658623, -0.012068002484738827, -0.03345373645424843, 0.06387268751859665, -0.055289942771196365, 0.01800716668367386, 0.0261749979108572, 0.02688627503812313, -0.06173885613679886, -0.005980655085295439, -0.009104347787797451, 0.0023546237498521805, 0.02548743039369583, 0.01555326022207737, 0.017272179946303368, -0.006662295665591955, 0.002376851160079241, -0.0006916429265402257, 0.0011343389051035047, 0.016145991161465645, 0.014735291711986065, 0.017461853101849556, 0.005995473358780146, 0.028000609949231148, -0.005346433259546757, 0.0026524709537625313, 0.009187329560518265, -0.002022694330662489, 0.005082667805254459, -0.01848135143518448, -0.017864910885691643, 0.011178906075656414, -0.017864910885691643, -0.045142389833927155, -0.016335664317011833, -0.017746364697813988, -0.0190622266381979, 0.028474794700741768, 0.005527216009795666, 0.0008001867681741714, 0.005408669821918011, -0.001788565656170249, -0.015173912048339844, 0.01568366028368473, -0.005945091601461172, 0.009513331577181816, -0.009128056466579437, 0.01484198309481144, -0.027905773371458054, 0.03651222586631775, -0.0027887991163879633, -0.005974728148430586, -0.009311803616583347, -0.01333644613623619, 0.024100439622998238, 0.007409136742353439, 0.026293544098734856, -0.015754789113998413, -0.03551643714308739, 0.024562770500779152, 0.008078922517597675, -0.031699251383543015, 0.05680733546614647, 0.01121446955949068, 0.015778498724102974, 0.03793478012084961, 0.022049590945243835, -0.011356725357472897, 0.00955482292920351, -0.020674455910921097, 0.0022390412632375956, -0.019809069111943245, -0.021610969677567482, 0.010633593425154686, 0.017627818509936333, -0.01705879718065262, 0.005696144420653582, 0.003900169627740979, 0.02570081315934658, 0.03840896487236023, 0.07202866673469543, 0.04189422354102135, -0.019619394093751907, 0.011605671606957912, 0.05747119337320328, -0.012020583264529705, -0.0368441566824913, 0.04414660111069679, -0.014083287678658962, -0.02897268906235695, 0.008227105252444744, -0.039712972939014435, -0.027289332821965218, 0.01592075265944004, 0.024444224312901497, -0.036180298775434494, 0.006828260608017445, -0.022571194916963577, -0.04051908850669861, 0.011398215778172016, -0.030987974256277084, -0.015411004424095154, 0.03084571845829487, -0.0063185119070112705, -0.03207859769463539, -0.019524557515978813, -0.025179211050271988, 0.029565420001745224, -0.018457641825079918, 0.012026511132717133, 0.006668223068118095, -0.03518451005220413, -0.006988298147916794, 0.028901562094688416, -0.021895481273531914, 0.016880977898836136, -0.003446730552241206, -0.016726868227124214, 0.026246126741170883, -0.02615129016339779, -0.00045640283497050405, 0.005823581479489803, 0.008926528505980968, 0.019654957577586174, -0.010485410690307617, -0.003185928799211979, 0.04808233305811882, -0.017971603199839592, -0.02135016955435276, 0.030276697129011154, 0.042984846979379654, 0.01592075265944004, 0.005177504848688841, -0.035966914147138596, -0.014806419610977173, 0.015173912048339844, -0.03160441294312477, 0.0044336277060210705, 0.01624082773923874, -0.04689687117934227, -0.04101698100566864, -0.04741847515106201, 0.028000609949231148, 0.00231016892939806, -0.028095446527004242, 0.0024153785780072212, 0.00766401132568717, 0.004729993175715208, 0.007581029087305069, 0.01533987745642662, -0.01507907547056675, -0.008885037153959274, -0.0027191531844437122, 0.01605115458369255, 0.05443641170859337, 0.024242695420980453, -0.0006927542854100466, 0.03701012209057808, -0.0013143809046596289, 0.012233966961503029, -0.007770702708512545, 0.03440210595726967, 0.010692866519093513, 0.0022034773137420416, -0.028593340888619423, 0.0213264599442482, -0.020472927019000053, 0.036630772054195404, 0.01995132304728031, 0.0002548743213992566, -0.023709237575531006, 0.00007117402128642425, 0.02804802916944027, -0.01929931901395321, 0.00583839975297451, 0.0006942361360415816, 0.013941031880676746, -0.03039524331688881, -0.03409388288855553, -0.01413070596754551, -0.012577750720083714, 0.025605976581573486, -0.002430196851491928, 0.01379877608269453, 0.0353267639875412, -0.02261861227452755, -0.009827478788793087, -0.03466290608048439, -0.017201052978634834, -0.018706588074564934, -0.009448131546378136, -0.03848009184002876, 0.018789570778608322, 0.01837465912103653, -0.006407421547919512, 0.05638056993484497, 0.011481198482215405, -0.023898912593722343, -0.01184869185090065, 0.013028225861489773, 0.036156587302684784, -0.014486344531178474, 0.005633907858282328, -0.029565420001745224, -0.032932132482528687, -0.0071779717691242695, -0.051970649510622025, 0.010995158925652504, -0.0009483695030212402, 0.009234747849404812, 0.022440792992711067, 0.0016270464984700084, 0.02177693508565426, -0.043956927955150604, -0.014474489726126194, -0.05675991624593735, 0.014830128289759159, -0.017995310947299004, 0.001770783681422472, -0.03482887148857117, -0.013763212598860264, -0.00947776809334755, -0.009163620881736279, -0.009548895992338657, -0.01286226138472557, 0.006360003259032965, -0.002495397347956896, 0.01682170480489731, -0.0053760698065161705, 0.01366837602108717, 0.02404116652905941, -0.018078293651342392, -0.03608546033501625, -0.008707217872142792, 0.01641864702105522, -0.011024795472621918, -0.0471813827753067, 0.0057731992565095425, 0.022239265963435173, -0.04239211603999138, 0.0025680067483335733, -0.011718290857970715, -0.007012007292360067, 0.0009372557979077101, -0.007616592571139336, 0.013182336464524269, -0.031485866755247116, 0.004137262236326933, -0.024823572486639023, -0.01721290685236454, 0.010864757932722569, 0.00765808392316103, -0.034520652145147324, -0.030063314363360405, 0.027763517573475838, 0.013217899948358536, 0.004727029241621494, -0.01771080121397972, -0.008037432096898556, -0.003408202901482582, -0.018730297684669495, 0.053393203765153885, 0.036393679678440094, 0.007249099668115377, 0.013407574035227299, -0.008487907238304615, 0.0005993991508148611, 0.022417085245251656, -0.01074028480798006, -0.037128668278455734, -0.017544835805892944, -0.04291372001171112, 0.016323810443282127, 0.006025109905749559, -0.007575101684778929, -0.005619089584797621, -0.009785988368093967, -0.00861830823123455, -0.019121499732136726, 0.011706436052918434, -0.04120665416121483, 0.020781146362423897, -0.02544001303613186, 0.0031266557052731514, -0.0012402895372360945, -0.02496582828462124, 0.014936819672584534, 0.00031748152105137706, -0.004060206934809685, -0.03957071900367737, -0.015043511986732483, -0.026791438460350037, 0.005580561701208353, 0.01777007430791855, -0.011528616771101952, -0.03321664407849312, -0.0054116337560117245, -0.025084374472498894, -0.021942900493741035, 0.023555127903819084, 0.003286693012341857, 0.014960529282689095, 0.025321466848254204, 0.01673872210085392, -0.01835094951093197, 0.047750405967235565, -0.026744021102786064, 0.009110274724662304, 0.006099201273173094, 0.028356248512864113, -0.036678191274404526, 0.0051241591572761536, -0.03186521679162979, 0.01837465912103653, 0.03608546033501625, 0.014735291711986065, 0.0011595299001783133, -0.019832776859402657, -0.011641236022114754, -0.032908421009778976, 0.06453654915094376, -0.050595514476299286, -0.015470277518033981, -0.03527934476733208, 0.037128668278455734, 0.00035378627944737673, 0.014676018618047237, 0.031722959131002426, -0.022369666025042534, -0.009258457459509373, 0.0041817170567810535, -0.0030999828595668077, 0.00009386450255988166, -0.013964741490781307, -0.0050056129693984985, -0.008179686963558197, -0.016217118129134178, 0.0036571500822901726, 0.006881606299430132, 0.00510045001283288, -0.026957403868436813, 0.038574930280447006, -0.02087598480284214, -0.008233033120632172, -0.004910775925964117, 0.003073310013860464, 0.013206045143306255, -0.0019441575277596712, -0.030015895143151283, 0.015493987128138542, -0.008167832158505917, 0.002196068176999688, -0.015150203369557858, 0.02190733514726162, -0.026317253708839417, -0.009299948811531067, -0.025558559224009514, 0.014462634921073914, -0.0005201214225962758, 0.043696124106645584, 0.0329558402299881, 0.0046973926946520805, -0.013881758786737919, -0.024396805092692375, -0.03238682076334953, -0.01652533933520317, 0.014320380054414272, 0.01026610005646944, -0.02660176530480385, 0.006982370745390654, -0.03935733437538147, -0.005441270302981138, -0.005788017529994249, -0.006798624061048031, 0.0046588652767241, 0.010639520362019539, -0.017035087570548058, 0.020461073145270348, -0.0012462168233469129, -0.016228973865509033, -0.03942846134305, -0.012233966961503029, -0.019014809280633926, 0.022523775696754456, 0.03283729404211044, -0.00004195423753117211, 0.01871844381093979, 0.02148056961596012, 0.005725780967622995, 0.012731860391795635, 0.0011854618787765503, -0.01215098425745964, 0.015588823705911636, 0.0028554813470691442, 0.0043417541310191154, -0.027052240446209908, -0.00419060792773962, 0.00032507587457075715, 0.009116201661527157, 0.0010350564261898398, -0.009234747849404812, -0.01652533933520317, -0.02520292066037655, 0.017378872260451317, -0.0038794241845607758, 0.020283253863453865, -0.0002376480697421357, -0.024159712716937065, -0.03504225239157677, 0.01913335546851158, -0.010852904058992863, -0.0037549505941569805, -0.0056013073772192, 0.024799862876534462, 0.01485383789986372, 0.006822333205491304, -0.0024731699377298355, 0.04004490375518799, 0.01665573939681053, -0.012921534478664398, -0.017355162650346756, 0.019619394093751907, 0.012269530445337296, -0.019500847905874252, -0.002041958039626479, 0.019571976736187935, 0.02095896564424038, -0.005109340883791447, 0.033145513385534286, 0.011973164975643158, 0.0040068612433969975, 0.013881758786737919, 0.006697859615087509, -0.01705879718065262, -0.001301044481806457, 0.03402275592088699, 0.022025881335139275, 0.005038212984800339, 0.0006979407044127584, -0.02201402746140957, -0.010260173119604588, -0.017936037853360176, -0.03698641061782837, -0.02111307717859745, -0.026103870943188667, -0.004916703328490257, 0.020864129066467285, -0.007533610332757235, 0.0024702062364667654, 0.01699952408671379, -0.013182336464524269, 0.03610916808247566, 0.02059147320687771, 0.009288094006478786, 0.0008298233151435852, 0.0013706902973353863, 0.03677302971482277, -0.011220396496355534, 0.0263883825391531, 0.014474489726126194, 0.01758039928972721, -0.01858804188668728, -0.02709965966641903, -0.02544001303613186, 0.020520346239209175, -0.019406011328101158, 0.016145991161465645, 0.017414435744285583, -0.0051863957196474075, -0.007782557513564825, 0.014640454202890396, 0.037863653153181076, 0.018256112933158875, 0.03136732056736946, 0.00035915791522711515, 0.03086942806839943, -0.017959747463464737, -0.014924965798854828, -0.028593340888619423, -0.011522689834237099, -0.02216813713312149, 0.023863347247242928, 0.0011743481736630201, 0.00742099154740572, 0.020970821380615234, 0.0033489298075437546, 0.0028006536886096, 0.01678614132106304, 0.006205893121659756, 0.001721883425489068, 0.005432378966361284, -0.01826796866953373, 0.00418468052521348, -0.04168083891272545, -0.03968926519155502, -0.020603327080607414, 0.018813280388712883, -0.0036423318088054657, -0.03086942806839943, 0.024467933923006058, 0.004442518576979637, -0.03874089568853378, 0.005565743427723646, -0.021942900493741035, -0.014782710000872612, -0.016252683475613594, 0.007053498178720474, 0.010609883815050125, 0.010141626931726933, 0.0045166099444031715, -0.025274047628045082, -0.03625142574310303, 0.029612839221954346, -0.007438773289322853, 0.005118231754750013, 0.03063233569264412, 0.007373573258519173, -0.0631139948964119, 0.0045166099444031715, 0.003781623439863324, -0.028688177466392517, -0.039499592036008835, 0.015529550611972809, -0.018090149387717247, 0.0003697159409057349, 0.023875202983617783, 0.007853684946894646, 0.014047723263502121, 0.0017322562634944916, 0.002147167921066284, 0.029280908405780792, 0.007089062128216028, 0.011747927404940128, 0.008298233151435852, 0.008191541768610477, 0.03992635756731033, -0.011724217794835567, 0.0029429092537611723, -0.053156111389398575, -0.0004790007078554481, 0.00016855786088854074, -0.014759000390768051, 0.012814843095839024, 0.006668223068118095, -0.00007538796489825472, 0.004807048011571169, 0.03286100551486015, 0.0022820141166448593, 0.03369082883000374, 0.007106844335794449, -0.014462634921073914, 0.0051508317701518536, 0.012767424806952477, -0.013111208565533161, -0.027621261775493622, 0.007806266658008099, -0.0277872271835804, -0.012233966961503029, -0.018315386027097702, 0.00839307066053152, -0.013834340497851372, -0.008316014893352985, -0.0025576341431587934, 0.02949429303407669, 0.004703320097178221, 0.034520652145147324, 0.000519010063726455, -0.013810630887746811, -0.027858354151248932, -0.01579035259783268, 0.0213264599442482, 0.019868342205882072, -0.00581172714009881, 0.0031444376800209284, -0.01615784503519535, -0.0166913028806448, -0.005544998217374086, -0.040685053914785385, -0.02290312387049198, 0.02690998464822769, -0.00327483844012022, 0.028451085090637207, -0.008019649423658848, 0.035492729395627975, 0.004329899791628122, 0.03278987482190132, -0.04082730785012245, 0.004163934849202633, 0.003989079501479864, -0.0015425822930410504, -0.018789570778608322, -0.004226171877235174, -0.012459204532206059, 0.02298610657453537, -0.016620175912976265, 0.029518000781536102, 0.005450161173939705, -0.017959747463464737, -0.005814690608531237, -0.0014981274725869298, 0.011291524395346642, 0.012506622821092606, 0.0162645373493433, -0.020887838676571846, -0.029873639345169067, 0.011718290857970715, 0.005061922129243612, -0.0051389774307608604, -0.0017441108357161283, -0.010681011714041233, -0.016015591099858284, 0.00302440975792706, -0.016667595133185387, -0.013490556739270687, 0.006638586521148682, -0.03866976872086525, -0.028166575357317924, -0.015173912048339844, 0.0236973837018013, -0.02572452276945114, 0.0025828250218182802, 0.021160494536161423, -0.011101850308477879, 0.02106565795838833, -0.00347933080047369, 0.0000010476982197360485, 0.0011928710155189037, -0.002649507252499461, 0.013111208565533161, -0.022784577682614326, 0.0046618287451565266, 0.0020271397661417723, -0.007936667650938034, 0.024657607078552246, -0.000138921313919127, 0.006774914916604757, 0.0035119308158755302, 0.06629102677106857, 0.0007475818856619298, 0.02298610657453537, 0.004092807415872812, -0.006001400761306286, -0.01065137516707182, 0.0015277640195563436, 0.03672561049461365, -0.018220549449324608, 0.001341794733889401, 0.018433932214975357, 0.019228192046284676, 0.002156058792024851, -0.012222112156450748, -0.014936819672584534, 0.0068697514943778515, 0.03143845126032829, -0.008274524472653866, 0.006425203289836645, 0.021729515865445137, 0.016217118129134178, -0.024373097345232964, -0.012506622821092606, -0.003796441713348031, -0.024847282096743584, -0.0007357273134402931, -0.019998742267489433, -0.0018537660362198949, 0.0120620746165514, 0.02219184674322605, 0.01953641138970852, -0.023732947185635567, -0.009785988368093967, -0.012909679673612118, -0.050832606852054596, -0.020472927019000053, -0.01462860032916069, 0.015778498724102974, -0.006028073839843273, 0.031177647411823273, -0.01568366028368473, 0.05216032266616821, -0.022559339180588722, 0.0025339247658848763, -0.007978159002959728, -0.020793002098798752, 0.02072187326848507, -0.0011743481736630201, 0.02014099806547165, 0.013680229894816875, 0.004798157140612602, -0.01839836873114109, -0.015873335301876068, -0.007877394556999207, 0.05168613791465759, 0.006265166215598583, 0.03940475359559059, -0.032173436135053635, -0.05050067603588104, 0.003458585124462843, 0.012542187236249447, 0.025274047628045082, -0.029091235250234604, 0.007136480882763863, 0.008464197628200054, -0.02641209028661251, -0.0379110723733902, -0.008262669667601585, -0.006804551463574171, -0.03409388288855553, 0.004158007446676493, 0.005050067789852619 ]
14.628882
6.769067
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.532..336M
[ "galaxy clusters", "black hole growth", "Environmental effects", "environmental effects", "galaxies", "active galactic nuclei", "AGN", "recent observations", "SMBHs", "observational evidence" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies", "Astrophysics - High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena" ]
25
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1465", "10.48550/arXiv.2403.07060" ]
[ "Muñoz Rodríguez, Iván", "Georgakakis, Antonis", "Shankar, Francesco", "Ruiz, Ángel", "Bonoli, Silvia", "Comparat, Johan", "Fu, Hao", "Koulouridis, Elias", "Lapi, Andrea", "Almeida, Cristina Ramos" ]
[ "Institute for Astronomy and Astrophysics, National Observatory of Athens, V. Paulou &amp; I. Metaxa, 11532, Athens, Greece; School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Southampton, Highfield SO17 1BJ, Southampton, UK", "Institute for Astronomy and Astrophysics, National Observatory of Athens, V. Paulou &amp; I. Metaxa, 11532, Athens, Greece", "School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Southampton, Highfield SO17 1BJ, Southampton, UK", "Institute for Astronomy and Astrophysics, National Observatory of Athens, V. Paulou &amp; I. Metaxa, 11532, Athens, Greece", "Donostia International Physics Center (DIPC), Manuel Lardizabal Ibilbidea, 4, 20018, San Sebastián, Spain; Ikerbasque, Basque Foundation for Science, E-48013 Bilbao, Spain", "Max-Planck-Institut für Extraterrestrische Physik (MPE), Giessenbachstrasse 1, D-85748 Garching bei München, Germany", "School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Southampton, Highfield SO17 1BJ, Southampton, UK", "Institute for Astronomy and Astrophysics, National Observatory of Athens, V. Paulou &amp; I. Metaxa, 11532, Athens, Greece", "SISSA, Via Bonomea 265, I-34136 Trieste, Italy", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias, Calle Vía Láctea, s/n, E-38205 La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Departamento de Astrofísica, Universidad de La Laguna, E-38206 La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain" ]
null
[ "1972ApJ...176....1G", "1980ApJ...237..692L", "1996ApJ...462..563N", "1996Natur.379..613M", "2003ApJ...597..142M", "2003MNRAS.343..924J", "2005ApJ...623L..81R", "2005MNRAS.360..159B", "2005Natur.433..604D", "2006ApJ...651...93K", "2006ApJS..166....1H", "2007ApJ...664..761M", "2007ApJ...664L...9E", "2007ApJ...665.1038C", "2007CSE.....9...90H", "2008MNRAS.388.1205G", "2009ApJ...694.1309G", "2009ApJ...700..901K", "2009ApJ...701...66M", "2009ApJS..180..102L", "2009MNRAS.395...11V", "2009MNRAS.400..299L", "2010ApJ...723.1447H", "2010MNRAS.407..846D", "2010PhR...495...33B", "2011CSE....13b..22V", "2011MNRAS.412.2211G", "2012A&A...546A..98A", "2012ARA&A..50..455F", "2012AdAst2012E..32F", "2012ApJ...746...90A", "2012ApJ...754...97H", "2012ApJ...757...81B", "2012MNRAS.427.3103B", "2013A&A...552A.135K", "2013A&A...558A..33A", "2013ARA&A..51..511K", "2013ApJ...768....1M", "2013ApJ...768..118N", "2013MNRAS.429.1827P", "2013MNRAS.430..638S", "2014A&A...567A..83K", "2014ApJ...786..104U", "2014MNRAS.437.1942E", "2014MNRAS.441..378L", "2015ARA&A..53...51S", "2015ApJ...802..137C", "2015ApJ...806..218G", "2015ApJS..216...27B", "2015ApJS..220...10N", "2015MNRAS.451.1892A", "2016A&A...588A..78B", "2016A&A...591A..51S", "2016A&A...594A..13P", "2016ApJ...816...48N", "2016ApJS..223....9B", "2016MNRAS.456.1073G", "2016MNRAS.457.4340K", "2016MNRAS.461.2115D", "2017A&A...608A..88B", "2017ApJ...843..105S", "2017ApJ...843..128R", "2017MNRAS.465.2531B", "2017MNRAS.466.1462D", "2017MNRAS.470.2170K", "2017MNRAS.471.1976G", "2017MNRAS.472..409L", "2017Natur.548..304P", "2018A&A...617A..64B", "2018AJ....156..123A", "2018ApJ...857...22L", "2018ApJ...869..131M", "2018ApJS..239...35D", "2018MNRAS.474.1225A", "2018MNRAS.474.3615M", "2018MNRAS.477.1822M", "2018MNRAS.480.2898C", "2019A&A...623L..10K", "2019MNRAS.483.2506G", "2019MNRAS.487..275G", "2019MNRAS.487.2005C", "2019MNRAS.488.3143B", "2020AJ....159...69M", "2020ApJ...895L...8R", "2020NatMe..17..261V", "2020OJAp....3E..13C", "2021ApJ...912...55S", "2021ApJ...916...34A", "2021MNRAS.502.5962A", "2022A&A...665A..78S", "2022A&A...667A.134T", "2022ApJ...927..130P", "2022MNRAS.512.1185C", "2023A&A...673A.122C", "2023ApJ...951...15M", "2023ApJ...952..109K", "2023ApJ...955...32K", "2023MNRAS.518.1041M", "2023MNRAS.518.2123Z", "2023MNRAS.522.5165A", "2023PASJ...75.1246H", "2024A&A...683A..57R", "2024A&A...684A.111K", "2024ApJ...967...65T" ]
29096797
2402.06717
AMICO galaxy clusters in KiDS-DR3: Measuring the splashback radius from weak gravitational lensing
Context. Weak gravitational lensing offers a powerful method to investigate the projected matter density distribution within galaxy clusters, granting crucial insights into the broader landscape of dark matter on cluster scales. <BR /> Aims: In this study, we make use of the large photometric galaxy cluster data set derived from the publicly available Third Data Release of the Kilo-Degree Survey, along with the associated shear signal. Our primary objective is to model the peculiar sharp transition in the cluster profile slope, that is what is commonly referred to as the splashback radius. The data set under scrutiny includes 6962 galaxy clusters, selected by AMICO (an optimised detection algorithm of galaxy clusters) on the KiDS-DR3 data, in the redshift range of 0.1 ≤ z ≤ 0.6, all observed at a signal-to-noise ratio greater than 3.5. <BR /> Methods: Employing a comprehensive Bayesian analysis, we model the stacked excess surface mass density distribution of the clusters. We adopt a model from recent results on numerical simulations that capture the dynamics of both orbiting and infalling materials, separated by the region where the density profile slope undergoes a pronounced deepening. <BR /> Results: We find that the adopted profile successfully characterizes the cluster masses, consistent with previous works, and models the deepening of the slope of the density profiles measured with weak-lensing data up to the outskirts. Moreover, we measure the splashback radius of galaxy clusters and show that its value is close to the radius within which the enclosed overdensity is 200 times the mean matter density of the Universe, while theoretical models predict a larger value consistent with a low accretion rate. This points to a potential bias of optically selected clusters preferentially characterized by a high density at small scales compared to a pure mass-selected cluster sample.
[ 0.039932023733854294, 0.0025615135673433542, 0.013293566182255745, 0.01389665249735117, 0.009386335499584675, 0.034542739391326904, 0.025932718068361282, 0.01695057936012745, -0.03528697416186333, 0.03628784045577049, -0.01937575824558735, 0.020787237212061882, -0.09007802605628967, -0.01811825856566429, 0.03233570232987404, 0.05068492889404297, -0.0029175912495702505, 0.000999263022094965, -0.023212414234876633, 0.0245340708643198, -0.009495404548943043, -0.0093927513808012, 0.005312293767929077, -0.006521674804389477, -0.051685795187950134, -0.032848965376615524, 0.017823129892349243, -0.031822435557842255, 0.06708374619483948, -0.0024572566617280245, -0.0037179640494287014, -0.020684583112597466, -0.04960707202553749, -0.03166845813393593, -0.048785846680402756, 0.08571527153253555, -0.00044108720612712204, 0.0684695616364479, -0.04639916494488716, -0.012530083768069744, 0.017117390409111977, 0.01804126799106598, -0.025753075256943703, 0.006130309775471687, -0.0008581150905229151, -0.04547528922557831, 0.003737211460247636, -0.03433743491768837, 0.001919932197779417, 0.0019119124626740813, -0.06343956291675568, 0.033464882522821426, -0.0016681115375831723, 0.018143920227885246, -0.021723944693803787, -0.011805097572505474, 0.03100121207535267, 0.007204958703368902, -0.005148690659552813, -0.007666897494345903, 0.019516905769705772, 0.02930743619799614, 0.03010299801826477, 0.003307352075353265, -0.031283508986234665, 0.005533639341592789, 0.01380683109164238, -0.00117409392260015, -0.01670677959918976, 0.040855903178453445, 0.03646748512983322, -0.017181549221277237, -0.009675047360360622, -0.007256285287439823, 0.01474353950470686, 0.003371510189026594, 0.02040228806436062, -0.0027700276114046574, -0.01787445694208145, 0.029461417347192764, 0.011561295948922634, 0.0024781080428510904, -0.014371423050761223, -0.0009912431705743074, -0.022558001801371574, -0.01720721274614334, 0.014499738812446594, 0.0075065018609166145, -0.05358487740159035, 0.02538095973432064, 0.009963758289813995, -0.0051230271346867085, 0.029820702970027924, 0.014127621427178383, -0.041163861751556396, -0.02477787248790264, 0.050351306796073914, -0.02259649522602558, 0.04398681968450546, 0.036980751901865005, 0.01943991519510746, 0.03749401494860649, 0.02101820521056652, -0.11107056587934494, 0.08545863628387451, -0.014512570574879646, 0.009559562429785728, 0.002681810175999999, 0.02520131692290306, -0.0020819315686821938, 0.03585156798362732, 0.026997743174433708, -0.015551932156085968, 0.034850701689720154, -0.046424828469753265, -0.028742846101522446, -0.040855903178453445, 0.015770070254802704, -0.0381612591445446, -0.01585989072918892, -0.03541529178619385, 0.00740384915843606, 0.0181567519903183, 0.020581930875778198, 0.038854166865348816, -0.055432628840208054, 0.0196837168186903, -0.013511703349649906, -0.07344823330640793, -0.003650597995147109, 0.026869427412748337, -0.005277006886899471, 0.024931851774454117, -0.016809431836009026, -0.028486212715506554, 0.0013890236150473356, -0.0070830583572387695, 0.026997743174433708, -0.018875323235988617, 0.006152765359729528, -0.02828090637922287, 0.028332233428955078, 0.05237870290875435, 0.04247268661856651, 0.004192734137177467, 0.049504417926073074, -0.030385293066501617, 0.018631523475050926, 0.007095890119671822, 0.055432628840208054, -0.0023947025183588266, 0.019401419907808304, -0.029641060158610344, -0.02300710789859295, -0.05117252841591835, -0.050530947744846344, 0.01653996855020523, 0.006576208863407373, -0.016373155638575554, -0.02621501497924328, -0.0010217183735221624, -0.003183847526088357, -0.017912952229380608, -0.004000260028988123, -0.02313542366027832, 0.022724812850356102, 0.0007113533210940659, -0.00472524669021368, -0.09562128782272339, -0.02452123910188675, -0.04621952027082443, 0.026510141789913177, -0.03615952655673027, -0.03972671926021576, -0.002753988141193986, 0.03651881217956543, 0.020787237212061882, -0.03010299801826477, 0.0024989594239741564, -0.02216022089123726, 0.018131090328097343, 0.009399167262017727, 0.027690652757883072, -0.018849661573767662, -0.04390982910990715, 0.023725679144263268, 0.00875116977840662, 0.06087324023246765, 0.007185711525380611, -0.014127621427178383, -0.020132822915911674, 0.033875495195388794, 0.01781029812991619, 0.04773365333676338, -0.008712675422430038, -0.027023406699299812, -0.014063463546335697, 0.056664466857910156, -0.01979920081794262, 0.034671057015657425, -0.009302929975092411, 0.031514476984739304, 0.044910695403814316, -0.06256701797246933, -0.011381653137505054, -0.019042134284973145, 0.05461140722036362, 0.015051499009132385, -0.015885554254055023, -0.004074041731655598, 0.015949713066220284, -0.008411131799221039, 0.03518432378768921, 0.016745273023843765, -0.00948257278650999, -0.007031731773167849, -0.06189977005124092, -0.008821743540465832, 0.06446609646081924, 0.04195941984653473, 0.0010497875045984983, 0.06061660870909691, 0.04113819822669029, 0.032130394130945206, 0.044371768832206726, 0.003942517563700676, 0.06667313724756241, -0.03531263768672943, 0.04791329801082611, -0.003984220325946808, 0.029820702970027924, 0.001253489637747407, -0.04614253342151642, -0.012068145908415318, 0.00349661847576499, -0.034799374639987946, 0.008577942848205566, 0.0327206514775753, -0.00201296154409647, -0.05153181403875351, -0.003138936823233962, 0.007320443633943796, -0.021364659070968628, -0.01447407528758049, 0.00023397670884151012, 0.012992022559046745, -0.02404646947979927, 0.014794866554439068, -0.01610369235277176, 0.015577595680952072, 0.022801801562309265, -0.012908617034554482, -0.02525264210999012, -0.05917946621775627, -0.01793861575424671, 0.018516037613153458, 0.0025085832457989454, 0.024611061438918114, -0.008642100729048252, 0.018028436228632927, -0.011105773970484734, -0.03657013922929764, -0.017643487080931664, 0.020620424300432205, -0.002798898611217737, 0.024739377200603485, 0.0369294248521328, -0.011914165690541267, -0.053995486348867416, 0.001321657677181065, -0.033336568623781204, -0.02149297669529915, 0.05722905695438385, -0.02621501497924328, -0.030898557975888252, 0.05137783661484718, 0.019696548581123352, -0.015000171959400177, 0.03736569732427597, -0.012998438440263271, -0.013588692992925644, -0.02464955672621727, 0.003304144134745002, 0.004359545186161995, -0.007262701168656349, 0.013922316022217274, 0.015770070254802704, 0.005167937837541103, 0.004516732878983021, -0.03780197352170944, 0.04216472804546356, -0.07237038016319275, -0.027690652757883072, 0.010374370962381363, -0.01755366660654545, -0.01781029812991619, -0.034542739391326904, 0.037160392850637436, -0.015192646533250809, 0.01587272249162197, 0.026138024404644966, 0.026997743174433708, 0.02658713236451149, -0.018580196425318718, -0.0027844631113111973, -0.020620424300432205, 0.0538928359746933, -0.005386075470596552, -0.037083402276039124, 0.03674978017807007, -0.026741111651062965, 0.012100224383175373, -0.028332233428955078, 0.02694641798734665, -0.045039013028144836, 0.0008950060000643134, 0.0006844871095381677, 0.029102131724357605, 0.027844632044434547, -0.028922488912940025, -0.026484478265047073, -0.018875323235988617, -0.015115656889975071, -0.027895957231521606, -0.011529217474162579, -0.035697586834430695, -0.02131333388388157, -0.024752208963036537, 0.0005128640914335847, -0.0157444067299366, 0.019645221531391144, 0.014217442832887173, 0.021454481407999992, -0.010380786843597889, 0.0037853301037102938, -0.0430116131901741, 0.028486212715506554, 0.03977804630994797, -0.01822091080248356, -0.033875495195388794, -0.025111494585871696, -0.014666549861431122, 0.011875671334564686, -0.02222437784075737, 0.046604469418525696, 0.04863186925649643, 0.016745273023843765, 0.026138024404644966, 0.027767641469836235, 0.02100537344813347, -0.026561468839645386, 0.0006066953646950424, 0.02064608782529831, -0.02191641926765442, 0.09315761178731918, -0.020633256062865257, -0.023481877520680428, -0.07745170593261719, 0.009309345856308937, 0.012433846481144428, -0.0007145612617023289, -0.0036313505843281746, 0.03246401622891426, 0.018143920227885246, 0.003653805935755372, 0.02282746508717537, -0.03544095531105995, -0.02289162389934063, -0.018092595040798187, -0.0005621856544166803, 0.016989074647426605, 0.007891451008617878, -0.027664989233016968, -0.0245340708643198, -0.06343956291675568, 0.003692300757393241, 0.01407629530876875, 0.002211851766332984, 0.013883820734918118, 0.0007145612617023289, 0.028871161863207817, -0.012003987096250057, 0.014525402337312698, -0.00309723406098783, 0.01489751972258091, 0.02033812925219536, -0.007679728791117668, -0.025060167536139488, -0.08674179762601852, -0.007095890119671822, -0.02822958119213581, 0.035466618835926056, 0.025175653398036957, -0.017758972942829132, 0.027331367135047913, -0.03372151777148247, 0.017835961654782295, 0.031334832310676575, 0.03746835142374039, 0.050120335072278976, -0.011163515970110893, -0.0326949879527092, -0.047759316861629486, -0.06282364577054977, 0.015333794988691807, -0.030513610690832138, -0.011432980187237263, 0.029641060158610344, 0.005578550044447184, -0.0006636357284151018, 0.03982936963438988, -0.009476156905293465, 0.01787445694208145, -0.05135217308998108, -0.004885642323642969, 0.0436275340616703, -0.01621917635202408, 0.06908547878265381, -0.013011270202696323, 0.05317426472902298, 0.01048344001173973, 0.007435928098857403, -0.01585989072918892, -0.000535720435436815, -0.002057872246950865, 0.03793029114603996, 0.003307352075353265, 0.040009014308452606, -0.002774839522317052, -0.030308304354548454, -0.004359545186161995, 0.05656181275844574, 0.043576207011938095, 0.009091207757592201, -0.02948707900941372, -0.013332060538232327, 0.04488503187894821, -0.022262873128056526, 0.026022540405392647, -0.01919611543416977, 0.028973814100027084, -0.013344892300665379, -0.05009467154741287, -0.039033811539411545, 0.011696028523147106, 0.016026701778173447, 0.0399833507835865, 0.032489679753780365, -0.007808045484125614, -0.03428610786795616, -0.01956823095679283, 0.01447407528758049, 0.004680335987359285, 0.018734175711870193, -0.032617997378110886, -0.0321047306060791, -0.0046963756904006, -0.05142916366457939, 0.05348222330212593, -0.055997222661972046, -0.015102825127542019, 0.011003120802342892, -0.04262666776776314, 0.002125238301232457, -0.027408355847001076, 0.015051499009132385, 0.003657013876363635, 0.010278133675456047, -0.0015630526468157768, 0.025342464447021484, 0.036185190081596375, -0.04493635892868042, 0.029718048870563507, -0.01474353950470686, -0.005270591005682945, -0.015551932156085968, -0.05142916366457939, -0.02181376703083515, 0.02512432634830475, 0.011240505613386631, 0.049632735550403595, -0.02082573063671589, -0.0405736044049263, 0.002389890607446432, 0.022609326988458633, 0.01926027238368988, -0.03313126042485237, 0.010117738507688046, 0.00044349313247948885, -0.02518848516047001, -0.0314888134598732, -0.02494468353688717, 0.04160013422369957, -0.013614356517791748, 0.0034837869461625814, 0.006576208863407373, -0.008257152512669563, -0.013601524755358696, -0.0005641906172968447, 0.016578461974859238, 0.05979538336396217, -0.031206518411636353, 0.0033362230751663446, -0.006175220478326082, 0.008244320750236511, 0.001068232930265367, -0.059744056314229965, -0.026022540405392647, -0.00516472989693284, 0.014692213386297226, -0.03354187309741974, 0.030718915164470673, 0.026612795889377594, -0.0034196285996586084, 0.010817062109708786, 0.039033811539411545, -0.036724116653203964, 0.026176519691944122, 0.017733309417963028, 0.003506242297589779, 0.013729841448366642, -0.014666549861431122, -0.03980370983481407, 0.012061730027198792, -0.004975463729351759, -0.031155191361904144, -0.03343922272324562, -0.09957342594861984, -0.016090860590338707, 0.0017691606190055609, 0.005174353718757629, -0.04578324779868126, -0.014217442832887173, 0.017604993656277657, -0.020440783351659775, -0.01888815499842167, -0.015102825127542019, -0.032848965376615524, 0.002895135898143053, -0.006082191597670317, 0.02064608782529831, 0.03541529178619385, -0.0038174090441316366, 0.017271369695663452, -0.006521674804389477, 0.01456389669328928, 0.036672789603471756, -0.011304663494229317, 0.026433153077960014, 0.03911080211400986, 0.02840922214090824, -0.032310038805007935, 0.01420461107045412, -0.009059129282832146, -0.02004300244152546, 0.005639500450342894, 0.00810958817601204, -0.007095890119671822, 0.023648688569664955, 0.012023234739899635, -0.018605859950184822, 0.011413732543587685, -0.02404646947979927, 0.04039396345615387, -0.00866134837269783, -0.04953008145093918, 0.01895231381058693, -0.013729841448366642, -0.012247788719832897, 0.016142187640070915, -0.030359629541635513, 0.01007924322038889, 0.011586959473788738, -0.0321047306060791, -0.0015285676345229149, -0.00034424851764924824, -0.032002080231904984, 0.008045430295169353, 0.008128835819661617, -0.03577457740902901, -0.019388588145375252, -0.025047335773706436, -0.01562892273068428, 0.003100442001596093, -0.059744056314229965, 0.0009816194651648402, 0.0034292524214833975, 0.01344754546880722, -0.014268769882619381, 0.012305530719459057, 0.003371510189026594, -0.03046228364109993, 0.013511703349649906, 0.02266065403819084, 0.025278305634856224, -0.0022984652314335108, 0.03028264082968235, 0.009861106052994728, 0.011349574662744999, -0.02622784674167633, -0.02276330627501011, 0.005973122548311949, -0.023764174431562424, -0.05214773491024971, 0.009713541716337204, 0.04324258491396904, -0.012196461670100689, -0.01585989072918892, -0.008192993700504303, 0.020543435588479042, 0.004385208711028099, 0.02495751529932022, 0.008520200848579407, -0.041394829750061035, 0.006922663189470768, -0.01870851218700409, 0.009411999024450779, -0.02216022089123726, 0.03964972868561745, -0.012613489292562008, -0.027203049510717392, -0.0035383212380111217, 0.007731055375188589, -0.015038667246699333, 0.05527865141630173, 0.03287462890148163, -0.031591467559337616, -0.059436097741127014, -0.010425697080790997, -0.011214842088520527, 0.027151724323630333, -0.027664989233016968, 0.03292595595121384, -0.009206692688167095, -0.010605339892208576, 0.032181721180677414, -0.0013641624245792627, 0.042421359568834305, -0.02095404826104641, 0.010650251060724258, 0.022198716178536415, 0.02023547701537609, 0.04401248320937157, -0.06343956291675568, 0.05820426344871521, 0.018516037613153458, 0.01737402379512787, -0.003852696157991886, -0.04190809652209282, -0.004856770858168602, 0.001823695027269423, -0.014281601645052433, 0.019709380343556404, 0.011850007809698582, 0.019042134284973145, -0.007243453525006771, 0.011715276166796684, 0.002431593369692564, -0.03408080339431763, 0.004744494333863258, -0.021518638357520103, 0.007641233969479799, 0.004186318255960941, -0.017168717458844185, -0.01520547829568386, -0.034671057015657425, -0.007262701168656349, 0.009315761737525463, -0.013036933727562428, 0.011182763613760471, 0.046476155519485474, 0.024457082152366638, 0.028563203290104866, 0.0272543765604496, -0.010605339892208576, 0.008379052393138409, -0.019632389768958092, -0.011522801592946053, -0.0281525906175375, 0.027947284281253815, -0.011054446920752525, -0.0006544130155816674, -0.006242586765438318, -0.018002772703766823, 0.01605236530303955, -0.014255938120186329, 0.01737402379512787, 0.0333109050989151, 0.03372151777148247, -0.01520547829568386, 0.00496583990752697, -0.022083230316638947, 0.03949574753642082, -0.03033396787941456, 0.00045111190411262214, 0.0066531989723443985, 0.004041962791234255, 0.012773885391652584, 0.028563203290104866, -0.01986335963010788, 0.02925611101090908, -0.023610195145010948, -0.00311166956089437, -0.015667416155338287, -0.019054966047406197, 0.0040932889096438885, -0.017720477655529976, 0.0038109933957457542, 0.06097589433193207, -0.039521411061286926, 0.023225245997309685, 0.04011166840791702, -0.03587723150849342, -0.0036634295247495174, 0.016796600073575974, -0.006961158011108637, -0.010265301913022995, 0.028794171288609505, -0.03138615936040878, -0.005764608737081289, -0.013319228775799274, -0.02609953097999096, -0.05953875184059143, 0.0035222817678004503, 0.020812898874282837, -0.004750910215079784, -0.005601005163043737, 0.013383387587964535, 0.03726304695010185, -0.01924744062125683, 0.008398300036787987, 0.018554532900452614, -0.006232962943613529, -0.03141182288527489, -0.000577022263314575, 0.004279347602277994, 0.012453094124794006, -0.008456042036414146, 0.005267383065074682, 0.022429684177041054, 0.002401118166744709, 0.0043146344833076, 0.01168961264193058, 0.0405736044049263, 0.015847058966755867, -0.008456042036414146, 0.02797294780611992, 0.0035928557626903057, 0.01238893624395132, -0.01054118201136589, 0.007320443633943796, 0.010740072466433048, 0.014243106357753277, 0.0014820529613643885, 0.02199340984225273, -0.0075000859797000885, -0.005729321856051683, -0.03441442549228668, 0.021634124219417572, 0.020030170679092407, 0.061078544706106186, 0.061694465577602386, -0.002455652691423893, 0.03192508965730667, -0.030744578689336777, 0.007050979416817427, -0.055432628840208054, -0.010964625515043736, 0.03895682096481323, -0.030564935877919197, 0.011092942208051682, 0.02168544940650463, 0.04039396345615387, 0.017848793417215347, 0.040239982306957245, 0.005321917589753866, 0.007095890119671822, 0.001229430316016078, -0.00384628027677536, 0.005507976282387972, 0.021954914554953575, -0.03500467911362648, 0.045090340077877045, -0.026381826028227806, -0.011445811949670315, -0.005604213103652, 0.04208773747086525, -0.007769550196826458, -0.005514391697943211, 0.0061142705380916595, -0.026510141789913177, 0.01647580973803997, -0.011676780879497528, 0.005812727380543947, 0.006820010021328926, 0.03220738470554352, -0.013332060538232327, -0.11199444532394409, 0.02015848644077778, 0.03559493273496628, 0.025996876880526543, 0.008500953204929829, 0.02313542366027832, 0.01050910260528326, 0.006550545804202557, -0.009617304429411888, -0.028434885665774345, 0.019157620146870613, -0.01683509536087513, -0.010008669458329678, 0.05009467154741287, -0.029718048870563507, -0.012170798145234585, -0.03236136585474014, 0.01465371809899807, -0.01937575824558735, 0.023469045758247375, -0.008013350889086723, 0.003371510189026594, 0.01646297797560692, 0.00880891177803278, 0.020787237212061882, -0.04113819822669029, -0.028178254142403603, -0.023905321955680847, 0.026689784601330757, 0.008789665065705776, -0.013563030399382114, -0.006864920724183321, -0.025778738781809807, 0.03402947634458542, -0.02132616564631462, -0.022019073367118835, 0.005973122548311949, 0.03567192330956459, -0.04804161190986633, 0.01195907685905695, -0.01841338537633419, 0.01556476391851902, 0.059384770691394806, 0.0040964968502521515, 0.05481671169400215, 0.016616957262158394, -0.0009190653217956424, 0.00719212694093585, 0.004843939561396837, 0.026240678504109383, 0.02168544940650463, 0.010496270842850208, 0.02712606079876423, 0.014615223743021488, -0.005735737271606922, 0.0381355956196785, 0.015641754493117332, -0.005876885261386633, -0.00860360637307167, 0.025393791496753693, -0.036544475704431534, 0.012234956957399845, 0.006454308517277241, -0.018079763278365135, -0.06395283341407776, -0.006431853398680687, -0.020851394161581993, 0.03179677203297615, 0.004827899858355522, -0.005447025876492262, 0.014602391980588436, 0.020504940301179886, 0.003493410535156727, 0.02774197794497013, 0.005042829550802708, 0.001964842900633812, 0.007006068713963032, -0.007891451008617878, -0.02562475949525833, 0.03338789567351341, 0.01313958689570427, 0.03323391452431679, 0.01598820835351944, 0.00549514451995492, -0.011285415850579739, 0.04711773619055748, -0.012857290916144848, -0.018541701138019562, -0.02181376703083515, 0.023173918947577477, 0.002603216329589486, -0.027331367135047913, 0.014782034792006016, 0.010906883515417576, 0.018374890089035034, 0.006245794706046581, 0.06631384789943695, -0.04634783789515495, 0.012286283075809479, 0.002636899473145604, 0.0003598870534915477, -0.008205825462937355, -0.027203049510717392, -0.025355296209454536, -0.010207559913396835, -0.033285241574048996, 0.021223511546850204, 0.021890755742788315, -0.00758349196985364, 0.0196837168186903, 0.03682677075266838, 0.028845498338341713, -0.0169634111225605, 0.040727585554122925, 0.02567608654499054, 0.004930553026497364, -0.026843763887882233, 0.02318675071001053, 0.03349054604768753, -0.01492318231612444, 0.02840922214090824, -0.01779746636748314, -0.04275498166680336, -0.006717356853187084, 0.025881392881274223, -0.01050910260528326, 0.010246054269373417, -0.01956823095679283, -0.029641060158610344, 0.027664989233016968, -0.013550198636949062, 0.006265041884034872, 0.037878964096307755, 0.007147216238081455, 0.01979920081794262, 0.02235269546508789, 0.00349661847576499, 0.04432044178247452, 0.04616819694638252, 0.045449625700712204, -0.002146089682355523, 0.014050631783902645, 0.028973814100027084, 0.015847058966755867, 0.005402115173637867, 0.0035800240002572536, 0.005860846024006605, -0.037211719900369644, 0.015462110750377178, 0.022006241604685783, -0.011176347732543945, 0.008885902352631092, -0.007910698652267456, 0.002118822420015931, -0.005822350736707449, 0.0007125562988221645, 0.01870851218700409, -0.002473296131938696, 0.011317495256662369, 0.0430116131901741, 0.01217721402645111, 0.018272237852215767, -0.01183717604726553, -0.0008693427662365139, 0.01474353950470686, 0.01398647390305996, -0.008077509701251984, 0.025830065831542015, -0.00971995759755373, -0.01793861575424671, -0.02712606079876423, -0.046655796468257904, 0.02681810036301613, 0.02435442805290222, -0.025894224643707275, 0.05142916366457939, -0.015526269562542439, 0.005533639341592789, 0.004847147036343813, -0.0037500429898500443, -0.029769375920295715, 0.00373079557903111, -0.012844459153711796, 0.009777700528502464, 0.054714057594537735, -0.005886509083211422, -0.011830760166049004, 0.03290029242634773, 0.0051903934217989445, 0.030026007443666458, 0.00875116977840662, 0.035646259784698486, 0.0036794692277908325, 0.02386682666838169, 0.014884687960147858, 0.01569307968020439, -0.03469672054052353, 0.02579157054424286, -0.012671232223510742, 0.019388588145375252, -0.022455347701907158, 0.0078722033649683, -0.043884165585041046, -0.04467972740530968, -0.006896999664604664, -0.005501560401171446, 0.005915380083024502, -0.021852262318134308, -0.021428817883133888, -0.024931851774454117, -0.006290705408900976, 0.002859849017113447, 0.0031918673776090145, 0.04401248320937157, 0.054714057594537735, -0.030128661543130875, 0.020440783351659775, -0.021287670359015465, -0.041754115372896194, -0.05563793703913689, 0.0006572199054062366, -0.03893115743994713, -0.02114652283489704, 0.0769384354352951, -0.02477787248790264, 0.006261833943426609, 0.015821397304534912, -0.03459406644105911, -0.016385987401008606, 0.01779746636748314, 0.03290029242634773, 0.005042829550802708, 0.005116611253470182, 0.0007903480436652899, -0.028845498338341713, -0.035517945885658264, -0.020492108538746834, -0.005370036233216524, -0.0013000041944906116, 0.03918778896331787, 0.017066065222024918, -0.007525749504566193, 0.010220391675829887, 0.008308478631079197, 0.0023610193748027086, 0.017823129892349243, 0.014859024435281754, -0.020877057686448097, 0.00584480632096529, 0.0017948239110410213, -0.01986335963010788, 0.014281601645052433, -0.00023658313148189336, 0.0061174784786999226, -0.0502743162214756, 0.0003145753580611199, -0.006621119566261768, 0.02173677645623684, 0.04221605509519577, 0.008128835819661617, 0.008475289680063725, -0.002859849017113447, -0.05135217308998108, -0.026433153077960014, 0.02676677517592907, 0.010945377871394157, -0.027947284281253815, 0.026381826028227806, -0.011497138068079948, -0.008372636511921883, 0.01732269674539566, -0.00746159115806222, 0.00640298193320632, 0.006287497468292713, -0.009386335499584675, 0.012228541076183319, -0.01156771183013916, -0.005883301142603159, -0.010675913654267788, 0.002853433135896921, -0.04031697288155556, -0.0055593024007976055, -0.022185884416103363, -0.0172585379332304, 0.00090302579337731, 0.008411131799221039, -0.012889369390904903, -0.006736604496836662, 0.015013003721833229, -0.01665545254945755, -0.0017194381216540933, 0.05717772990465164, 0.002208643825724721, 0.01991468481719494, 0.002867868635803461, -0.016013871878385544, 0.03680110722780228, 0.019273104146122932, 0.0042248135432600975, -0.008982139639556408, -0.012979190796613693, 0.015256805345416069, 0.007852955721318722, -0.02004300244152546, -0.013178081251680851, -0.012671232223510742, -0.01371700968593359, -0.007429512217640877, -0.024675220251083374, -0.0333109050989151, 0.006358071230351925, -0.0012855686945840716, 0.008558695204555988, 0.02373851090669632, -0.03705773875117302, -0.01890098676085472, 0.0016616957727819681, 0.03826391324400902, -0.012157967314124107, -0.015782902017235756, -0.02586856111884117, 0.0002722711069509387, 0.027331367135047913, 0.012010402977466583, -0.01992751657962799, -0.005334748886525631, 0.0016632997430860996, 0.0007277938420884311, 0.024508409202098846, 0.0055657182820141315, 0.017540834844112396, 0.03064192645251751, -0.008507369086146355, -0.010393618606030941, -0.03536396473646164, 0.0430116131901741, -0.030718915164470673, 0.006762267556041479, 0.0024235735181719065, -0.0055560944601893425, 0.004523148760199547, 0.000022969114070292562, 0.002304881112650037, -0.011619038879871368, 0.008077509701251984, -0.005501560401171446, -0.030924221500754356, 0.0172585379332304, -0.02403363771736622, -0.009559562429785728, 0.06795629858970642, -0.024200448766350746, 0.0029769374523311853, -0.04113819822669029, 0.01007924322038889, -0.0199788436293602, 0.0010914902668446302, 0.02174960821866989, -0.0026882258243858814, 0.0030282640364021063, -0.025111494585871696, -0.0009246791596524417, -0.002624067710712552, 0.016668284311890602, 0.02730570361018181, 0.005001126788556576, -0.01605236530303955, 0.03477371111512184, -0.026561468839645386, -0.018066931515932083, -0.02368718385696411, -0.013319228775799274, -0.002304881112650037, -0.0035832319408655167, -0.012684063985943794, -0.025663254782557487, 0.009206692688167095, -0.017284201458096504, -0.013729841448366642, 0.04742569476366043, -0.01738685555756092, -0.03246401622891426, -0.018259406089782715, 0.009007802233099937, -0.020325297489762306, -0.023109760135412216, -0.016693947836756706, 0.024906188249588013, 0.020492108538746834, 0.004850354976952076, 0.005767816677689552, 0.003698716638609767, 0.003005808684974909, -0.02889682538807392, -0.021480144932866096, -0.006293913349509239, 0.00907837599515915, 0.016013871878385544, -0.02385399490594864, 0.006444684695452452, -0.04221605509519577, -0.02730570361018181, -0.0035222817678004503, -0.014512570574879646, 0.016013871878385544, 0.0006993237184360623, -0.005809519439935684, 0.030026007443666458, 0.035466618835926056, -0.020184149965643883, -0.0012358460808172822, -0.014910351485013962, -0.042729318141937256, 0.01090046763420105, 0.03313126042485237, -0.009367087855935097, 0.009944511577486992, 0.024264607578516006, -0.02471371367573738, 0.006001993548125029, -0.03882850334048271, -0.0041606551967561245, -0.016604125499725342, 0.002737948438152671, -0.009007802233099937, -0.016668284311890602, -0.020928384736180305, 0.012254204601049423, -0.005090948194265366, -0.028691519051790237, -0.028383560478687286, 0.022570831701159477, 0.018913818523287773, 0.038007281720638275, 0.01004716381430626, 0.0018381306435912848, 0.016514305025339127, -0.015192646533250809, -0.02199340984225273, 0.01955540105700493, -0.01447407528758049, 0.008994970470666885, -0.005036413669586182, 0.044833704829216, 0.006512050982564688, 0.005106987897306681, -0.005366828292608261, 0.0033201836049556732, 0.011708860285580158, -0.015436448156833649, -0.015423616394400597, 0.019221777096390724, 0.03746835142374039, -0.02319958247244358, 0.023995142430067062, 0.04093289002776146, -0.03531263768672943, -0.020928384736180305, -0.013601524755358696, -0.027100397273898125, 0.01864435523748398, 0.010502686724066734, 0.0035800240002572536, -0.0041606551967561245, -0.011137852445244789, 0.016270503401756287, 0.02404646947979927, 0.012465925887227058, 0.0025984046515077353, -0.03184809908270836, 0.016860758885741234, 0.03215605765581131, -0.013081843964755535, -0.023161087185144424, -0.010560429655015469, -0.018092595040798187, 0.003602479351684451, -0.019478410482406616, 0.009411999024450779, 0.0296667218208313, -0.013652851805090904, 0.021634124219417572, 0.017412519082427025, 0.012190045788884163, -0.021467313170433044, 0.0029961850959807634, -0.009213108569383621, -0.017066065222024918, 0.02730570361018181, 0.007698976434767246, -0.013793999329209328, -0.010855556465685368, -0.016450146213173866, -0.0172585379332304, 0.005447025876492262, -0.022378358989953995, -0.015282467938959599, -0.009264434687793255, 0.002287237672135234, 0.004410871770232916, -0.02266065403819084, -0.004202357959002256, 0.016629789024591446, 0.015551932156085968, 0.0024155538994818926, 0.006954742129892111, -0.005004334729164839, 0.025817234069108963, -0.02210889384150505, 0.008180162869393826, 0.024418586865067482, 0.006348447874188423, -0.008616438135504723, -0.00839188415557146, 0.03590289503335953, -0.024790704250335693, -0.00106422312092036, -0.0001790413080016151, -0.033952485769987106, 0.013370555825531483, -0.0022487426176667213, -0.023623026907444, 0.02645881660282612, -0.038854166865348816, -0.04167712479829788, -0.005029997788369656, 0.012793132103979588, -0.019824864342808723, -0.05866619944572449, 0.02585572935640812, 0.01896514557301998, -0.04106120765209198, 0.03972671926021576, 0.016244839876890182, -0.0055689262226223946, 0.007673313375562429, -0.01213871967047453, 0.01695057936012745, 0.00945049338042736, -0.013973642140626907, 0.01036153919994831, -0.02676677517592907, 0.019529737532138824, -0.0011347969993948936, 0.02459822967648506, 0.0169634111225605, -0.014114790596067905, -0.04034263640642166, 0.01585989072918892, -0.003190263407304883, -0.01973504200577736, -0.05712640658020973, 0.02088988944888115, 0.015962544828653336, 0.020812898874282837, 0.0233150664716959, 0.023404888808727264, 0.019208945333957672, 0.012677648104727268, -0.011561295948922634, 0.011497138068079948, 0.00023878856154624373, -0.022724812850356102, -0.009886768646538258, -0.0028406016062945127, 0.04355054348707199, -0.02276330627501011, 0.021056700497865677, -0.010515518486499786, 0.008404715918004513, 0.055329978466033936, -0.020389456301927567, 0.004888850264251232, 0.018631523475050926, 0.0046546729281544685, 0.01529529970139265, 0.04840089753270149, 0.0015823000576347113, -0.007237037643790245, 0.033464882522821426, -0.016989074647426605, -0.018913818523287773, 0.017669150605797768, -0.013409050181508064, -0.03264366090297699, 0.017271369695663452, -0.04704074561595917, 0.005161521956324577, -0.03518432378768921, -0.023841163143515587, 0.006704525090754032, -0.015025835484266281, 0.019029302522540092, -0.0022198716178536415, -0.0015847060130909085, 0.025753075256943703, 0.022391188889741898, -0.005905756726861, -0.020209813490509987, 0.025547770783305168, -0.044474419206380844, 0.020119991153478622, -0.007942777127027512, 0.02162129245698452, -0.007544996682554483, -0.011009536683559418, 0.009181029163300991, -0.03241268917918205, -0.005235304124653339, 0.023828331381082535, -0.04973538592457771, 0.005437402054667473, 0.024790704250335693, -0.008892318233847618, -0.006175220478326082, 0.017733309417963028, -0.02046644501388073, 0.01611652411520481, 0.008180162869393826, -0.023032771423459053, 0.009277266450226307, -0.04970972612500191, 0.00040519871981814504, 0.021646955981850624, 0.004728454630821943, 0.03482503816485405, -0.020145654678344727, -0.024072133004665375, 0.0272543765604496, 0.00379174598492682, -0.003596063470467925, -0.01949124224483967, -0.0056266686879098415, -0.011529217474162579, -0.0363391675055027, 0.0035447371192276478, -0.025765907019376755, 0.013832494616508484, -0.01937575824558735, 0.03577457740902901, 0.02930743619799614, 0.010290965437889099, 0.017104558646678925, 0.005350788589566946, -0.00966221559792757, -0.02053060382604599, -0.024931851774454117, -0.026009708642959595, 0.009598057717084885, -0.036364831030368805, 0.032181721180677414, -0.00019748676277231425, -0.029897691681981087, 0.025907056406140327, -0.008892318233847618, 0.007391017396003008, -0.0065954565070569515, -0.014281601645052433, -0.0018541701138019562, -0.03274631127715111, 0.001868605730123818, 0.014794866554439068, -0.02199340984225273, 0.05584324151277542, 0.0005802301457151771, 0.0015502210007980466, -0.019529737532138824, 0.03410646691918373, -0.0010906882816925645, 0.014589560218155384, -0.003490202594548464, 0.0017290618270635605, 0.00534437270835042, -0.010547597892582417, 0.024213280528783798, -0.007827293127775192, 0.022493842989206314, 0.009559562429785728, 0.014101958833634853, -0.00041221603169105947, -0.01036153919994831, -0.013409050181508064, 0.005430986173450947, 0.00490488950163126, -0.0038142013363540173, -0.022545170038938522, -0.008154499344527721, 0.026073867455124855, -0.0037275878712534904, -0.013036933727562428, 0.01407629530876875, -0.024688052013516426, 0.0028903239872306585, -0.019516905769705772, -0.008314894512295723, 0.001438746228814125, -0.015449278987944126, 0.0239181537181139, -0.039213452488183975, -0.016244839876890182, -0.00749367056414485, -0.019760705530643463, -0.026997743174433708, -0.01295994408428669, 0.036185190081596375, 0.005334748886525631, 0.00860360637307167, -0.003660221816971898, 0.022031905129551888, -0.007917114533483982, -0.01689925417304039, 0.015359457582235336, -0.016552798449993134, 0.00932217761874199, 0.0028758884873241186, -0.0023177126422524452, 0.039701055735349655, -0.021351827308535576, -0.04029130935668945, -0.008186577819287777, 0.016822263598442078, 0.006832841783761978, -0.012363272719085217, 0.005200016777962446, -0.029230447486042976, -0.010008669458329678, 0.024418586865067482, 0.01298560667783022, 0.02640748955309391, -0.012825211510062218, 0.02271198108792305, -0.004311427008360624, -0.005353996530175209, -0.0028037105221301317, 0.008635684847831726, -0.013152417726814747, 0.017348360270261765, -0.0011484306305646896, -0.003981012385338545 ]
12.521312
4.134162
2024-07-01
3
2024A&A...687A..79G
[ "galaxy clusters", "cluster scales", "the large photometric galaxy cluster data", "the cluster profile slope", "dark matter", "6962 galaxy clusters", "the stacked excess surface mass density distribution", "Third Data Release", "the projected matter density distribution", "optically selected clusters" ]
[ "cosmology: observations", "cosmology: theory", "dark matter", "large-scale structure of Universe", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
30
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202449561", "10.48550/arXiv.2402.06717" ]
[ "Giocoli, Carlo", "Palmucci, Lorenzo", "Lesci, Giorgio F.", "Moscardini, Lauro", "Despali, Giulia", "Marulli, Federico", "Maturi, Matteo", "Radovich, Mario", "Sereno, Mauro", "Bardelli, Sandro", "Castignani, Gianluca", "Covone, Giovanni", "Ingoglia, Lorenzo", "Romanello, Massimiliano", "Roncarelli, Mauro", "Puddu, Emanuella" ]
[ "INAF-Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio di Bologna, Via Piero Gobetti 93/3, 40129, Bologna, Italy ; INFN-Sezione di Bologna, Viale Berti Pichat 6/2, 40127, Bologna, Italy", "Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia \"Augusto Righi\" - Alma Mater Studiorum Università di Bologna, via Piero Gobetti 93/2, 40129, Bologna, Italy", "Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia \"Augusto Righi\" - Alma Mater Studiorum Università di Bologna, via Piero Gobetti 93/2, 40129, Bologna, Italy; INAF-Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio di Bologna, Via Piero Gobetti 93/3, 40129, Bologna, Italy", "Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia \"Augusto Righi\" - Alma Mater Studiorum Università di Bologna, via Piero Gobetti 93/2, 40129, Bologna, Italy; INAF-Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio di Bologna, Via Piero Gobetti 93/3, 40129, Bologna, Italy; INFN-Sezione di Bologna, Viale Berti Pichat 6/2, 40127, Bologna, Italy", "Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia \"Augusto Righi\" - Alma Mater Studiorum Università di Bologna, via Piero Gobetti 93/2, 40129, Bologna, Italy; INAF-Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio di Bologna, Via Piero Gobetti 93/3, 40129, Bologna, Italy; INFN-Sezione di Bologna, Viale Berti Pichat 6/2, 40127, Bologna, Italy", "Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia \"Augusto Righi\" - Alma Mater Studiorum Università di Bologna, via Piero Gobetti 93/2, 40129, Bologna, Italy; INAF-Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio di Bologna, Via Piero Gobetti 93/3, 40129, Bologna, Italy; INFN-Sezione di Bologna, Viale Berti Pichat 6/2, 40127, Bologna, Italy", "Zentrum für Astronomie, Universität Heidelberg, Philosophenweg 12, 69120, Heidelberg, Germany; ITP, Universität Heidelberg, Philosophenweg 16, 69120, Heidelberg, Germany", "INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova, vicolo dell'Osservatorio 5, 35122, Padova, Italy", "INAF-Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio di Bologna, Via Piero Gobetti 93/3, 40129, Bologna, Italy; INFN-Sezione di Bologna, Viale Berti Pichat 6/2, 40127, Bologna, Italy", "INAF-Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio di Bologna, Via Piero Gobetti 93/3, 40129, Bologna, Italy", "INAF-Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio di Bologna, Via Piero Gobetti 93/3, 40129, Bologna, Italy", "Dipartimento di Fisica \"E. Pancini\", Università di Napoli Federico II, C.U. di Monte Sant'Angelo, via Cintia, 80126, Napoli, Italy; INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Capodimonte, Salita Moiariello 16, 80131, Napoli, Italy; INFN - Sezione di Napoli, via Cintia, 80126, Napoli, Italy", "Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia \"Augusto Righi\" - Alma Mater Studiorum Università di Bologna, via Piero Gobetti 93/2, 40129, Bologna, Italy", "Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia \"Augusto Righi\" - Alma Mater Studiorum Università di Bologna, via Piero Gobetti 93/2, 40129, Bologna, Italy; INAF-Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio di Bologna, Via Piero Gobetti 93/3, 40129, Bologna, Italy", "INAF-Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio di Bologna, Via Piero Gobetti 93/3, 40129, Bologna, Italy; INFN-Sezione di Bologna, Viale Berti Pichat 6/2, 40127, Bologna, Italy", "INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Capodimonte, Salita Moiariello 16, 80131, Napoli, Italy" ]
[ "2024MNRAS.tmp.1594M", "2024arXiv240318648L", "2024arXiv240513491E" ]
[ "1965TrAlm...5...87E", "1972ApJ...176....1G", "1974ApJ...187..425P", "1976ApJ...203..297S", "1978MNRAS.183..341W", "1984ApJ...281....1F", "1986ApJ...304...15B", "1993MNRAS.262..627L", "1996ApJ...462..563N", "1997ApJ...490..493N", "1998ApJ...495...80B", "1998MNRAS.297..648T", "1999ApJ...511....5E", "1999MNRAS.308..119S", "2000ApJ...536..571B", "2001MNRAS.321..559B", "2001MNRAS.323....1S", "2001MNRAS.328..726S", "2001PhR...340..291B", "2002ApJ...568...52W", "2002MNRAS.331...98V", "2007MNRAS.376..977G", "2007MNRAS.378...55M", "2007MNRAS.381.1450N", "2007MNRAS.382..315M", "2007NJPh....9..444B", "2007arXiv0709.1159J", "2008ApJ...688..709T", "2008MNRAS.386.2135G", "2008MNRAS.387..536G", "2008MNRAS.391.1940M", "2009ApJ...707..354Z", "2009MNRAS.394..929C", "2009MNRAS.399..983A", "2010ApJ...724..878T", "2010MNRAS.401..791S", "2010MNRAS.403.1353C", "2010MNRAS.408..300G", "2011MNRAS.414.1851O", "2011MNRAS.418.2234B", "2011Msngr.146....2C", "2011Msngr.146....8K", "2011PhRvD..83b3008O", "2011arXiv1110.3193L", "2012MNRAS.421..381H", "2012MNRAS.421.2355H", "2012MNRAS.421.3343G", "2012MNRAS.422..185G", "2012MNRAS.426..566C", "2012MNRAS.427..146H", "2013ApJ...766...25D", "2013ExA....35...25D", "2013MNRAS.429.2858M", "2014ApJ...789....1D", "2014MNRAS.445..726C", "2015ApJ...810...36M", "2015MNRAS.450.3675S", "2015MNRAS.452.2087L", "2015MNRAS.452.3529V", "2015MNRAS.454.3500K", "2016A&C....14...35M", "2016ApJ...825...39M", "2016MNRAS.456.2486D", "2016MNRAS.459.1764S", "2017A&A...604A.134D", "2017ApJ...836..231U", "2017ApJ...841...18B", "2017ApJS..231....5D", "2017MNRAS.465.1454H", "2017MNRAS.467.1627F", "2017MNRAS.472.1946S", "2018ApJ...864...83C", "2018ApJS..239...35D", "2018MNRAS.473.5221B", "2018MNRAS.475..624N", "2018MNRAS.475..648P", "2018MNRAS.475..676S", "2018MNRAS.480.2898C", "2018NatAs...2..744S", "2019A&A...627A..23E", "2019ApJ...871..168D", "2019ApJ...874..184Z", "2019MNRAS.482.1352M", "2019MNRAS.484.1598B", "2019MNRAS.485..498M", "2019MNRAS.487.2900S", "2019PhRvD..99f4030C", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020ApJS..251...17D", "2020MNRAS.491.1295D", "2020MNRAS.498.4303R", "2020MNRAS.499.3534X", "2020PASJ...72...64M", "2021A&A...645A...9P", "2021A&A...645A.104A", "2021A&A...653A..19G", "2021ApJ...923...37A", "2021MNRAS.507.5758S", "2022A&A...659A..88L", "2022A&A...662A.112E", "2022A&A...665A.100L", "2022MNRAS.511.1484I", "2022MNRAS.515.4471W", "2022MNRAS.516.4543D", "2023MNRAS.518.2640C", "2023MNRAS.521.2464G", "2023MNRAS.521.5570S", "2023MNRAS.522.4181R", "2023MNRAS.526.4978S", "2024A&A...681A..67E", "2024A&A...682A..72R", "2024A&A...683A..82P", "2024MNRAS.529.2017T" ]
29072519
2404.05725
The MOSDEF survey: properties of warm ionized outflows at z = 1.4-3.8
We use the large spectroscopic data set of the MOSFIRE Deep Evolution Field survey to investigate the kinematics and energetics of ionized gas outflows. Using a sample of 598 star-forming galaxies at redshift 1.4 &lt; z &lt; 3.8, we decompose [O III] and $\rm {H}\,\alpha$ emission lines into narrow and broad components, finding significant detections of broad components in 10 per cent of the sample. The ionized outflow velocity from individual galaxies appears independent of galaxy properties, such as stellar mass, star formation rate (SFR), and SFR surface density (Σ<SUB>SFR</SUB>). Adopting a simple outflow model, we estimate the mass-, energy-, and momentum-loading factors of the ionized outflows, finding modest values with averages of 0.33, 0.04, and 0.22, respectively. The larger momentum- than energy-loading factors, for the adopted physical parameters, imply that these ionized outflows are primarily momentum driven. We further find a marginal correlation (2.5σ) between the mass-loading factor and stellar mass in agreement with predictions by simulations, scaling as η<SUB>m</SUB>$\propto M_{\star }^{-0.45}$. This shallow scaling relation is consistent with these ionized outflows being driven by a combination of mechanical energy generated by supernovae explosions and radiation pressure acting on dusty material. In a majority of galaxies, the outflowing material does not appear to have sufficient velocity to escape the gravitational potential of their host, likely recycling back at later times. Together, these results suggest that the ionized outflows traced by nebular emission lines are negligible, with the bulk of mass and energy carried out in other gaseous phases.
[ 0.04033663123846054, 0.04415450245141983, -0.00816336553543806, -0.028385037556290627, 0.0032813530415296555, 0.03779928758740425, -0.0058068386279046535, -0.016872141510248184, 0.011779671534895897, 0.02208910696208477, 0.003583699930459261, 0.034835103899240494, -0.06189218536019325, 0.010765920393168926, 0.031230654567480087, 0.013315119780600071, -0.010220509953796864, -0.0036074132658541203, -0.035143379122018814, 0.04737953469157219, -0.015212197788059711, -0.006408568471670151, -0.03402884677052498, 0.009094120003283024, -0.08290232717990875, -0.012319153174757957, -0.014797212556004524, 0.01252071838825941, 0.022741228342056274, -0.06274586915969849, 0.02568170055747032, -0.012983131222426891, -0.009971519000828266, -0.0394592322409153, -0.06473780423402786, 0.07090330868959427, -0.0479249469935894, -0.052264511585235596, -0.031610071659088135, -0.03206062689423561, 0.0016925496747717261, 0.001260519726201892, -0.030329542234539986, 0.014714214950799942, -0.004585594404488802, -0.013777532614767551, 0.01301870122551918, -0.0451030395925045, 0.005741626489907503, -0.04194914922118187, -0.05088913068175316, 0.035427939146757126, 0.011044553481042385, -0.03651876002550125, -0.004191357642412186, -0.0010070819407701492, 0.01809338666498661, 0.008501282893121243, -0.024970294907689095, 0.010706637054681778, -0.010013017803430557, -0.04258941113948822, 0.04090575501322746, 0.004683412611484528, -0.010896344669163227, 0.022172104567289352, -0.0002799302455969155, -0.007902517914772034, 0.050414860248565674, 0.01842537522315979, 0.01901821233332157, -0.018306806683540344, 0.008922196924686432, -0.03917467221617699, 0.0407397598028183, -0.03644762188196182, 0.004638949874788523, -0.04635985568165779, -0.06805769354104996, 0.0021016071550548077, 0.05013030022382736, 0.01384867262095213, 0.01368267834186554, -0.026155969128012657, -0.039838649332523346, 0.03526194766163826, 0.01477349828928709, -0.006171433255076408, -0.0515056811273098, -0.018413517624139786, -0.024377457797527313, 0.01921977661550045, -0.030898666009306908, -0.03362571448087692, -0.020227599889039993, -0.01773768477141857, 0.023179927840828896, -0.049086906015872955, 0.05506270378828049, 0.046241287142038345, -0.0030738599598407745, 0.02006160467863083, 0.03175235167145729, -0.0160184558480978, 0.023571200668811798, -0.032250333577394485, 0.002442488446831703, -0.0131965521723032, 0.042399704456329346, -0.013635251671075821, 0.07574085891246796, -0.003889010986313224, 0.026487957686185837, 0.02608482912182808, -0.06748856604099274, 0.007398606278002262, -0.03153892979025841, 0.02111685462296009, -0.04007578268647194, 0.010119727812707424, -0.00684133917093277, 0.025302283465862274, -0.004223963711410761, 0.04289768636226654, 0.010748134925961494, 0.010214582085609436, 0.014820925891399384, -0.023606769740581512, -0.011246118694543839, 0.017559831961989403, 0.018638795241713524, -0.026250824332237244, 0.006295929197221994, -0.024377457797527313, -0.04410707578063011, 0.035451654344797134, 0.03220290690660477, -0.04439163580536842, -0.00353034446015954, 0.01431108545511961, -0.013101697899401188, 0.024922868236899376, 0.006900622975081205, 0.01798667572438717, 0.043727658689022064, 0.012615571729838848, -0.040265489369630814, 0.0018363127019256353, 0.01648086868226528, -0.007493460085242987, 0.005101362708956003, -0.025325998663902283, -0.024946581572294235, -0.06601832807064056, 0.005341461393982172, 0.006272215861827135, 0.019409485161304474, 0.006580491084605455, 0.009503177367150784, -0.02798190712928772, -0.032297760248184204, 0.009503177367150784, -0.05719691514968872, -0.015769464895129204, -0.01176188699901104, 0.012828993611037731, -0.009847022593021393, -0.06658745557069778, -0.0691959410905838, -0.030044980347156525, -0.01256814505904913, 0.007422319613397121, -0.02332220785319805, -0.013919813558459282, 0.021816402673721313, 0.0052851419895887375, 0.019279060885310173, -0.02987898699939251, -0.009147475473582745, 0.021745262667536736, -0.011323187500238419, 0.03016354888677597, -0.011317258700728416, 0.010807419195771217, -0.0076238843612372875, 0.03376799821853638, -0.0020289847161620855, 0.04247084632515907, -0.005821659695357084, -0.006621989421546459, 0.028527317568659782, 0.013789389282464981, -0.03557022288441658, 0.03239261358976364, -0.054493580013513565, -0.025254856795072556, -0.010410218499600887, -0.004306960850954056, -0.04441535100340843, 0.02290722355246544, 0.04681041091680527, 0.025657987222075462, 0.03912724554538727, -0.09234029799699783, -0.04420192912220955, -0.009645458310842514, 0.01397909689694643, -0.02888301946222782, 0.010155298747122288, 0.04296882823109627, 0.04417821392416954, 0.013943526893854141, -0.00048797897761687636, -0.012283583171665668, -0.02672509290277958, -0.043395671993494034, -0.023096930235624313, 0.05463586002588272, 0.07474489510059357, 0.012099803425371647, -0.023559343069791794, 0.011755958199501038, 0.013125412166118622, 0.017026279121637344, 0.03635276481509209, 0.030305828899145126, 0.01445336639881134, -0.04477105289697647, 0.011216476559638977, -0.02221953123807907, 0.0019193098414689302, 0.006787984166294336, -0.05392445623874664, 0.0019267203751951456, -0.006485637277364731, -0.0017859215149655938, 0.024851728230714798, 0.008495355024933815, -0.013730105943977833, -0.03656618669629097, -0.018330520018935204, 0.021152425557374954, 0.005978761240839958, 0.01773768477141857, -0.02275308594107628, 0.015129201114177704, -0.004612272139638662, -0.005219929851591587, 0.0032250334043055773, -0.005397781264036894, 0.032606035470962524, -0.00708440225571394, 0.009764025919139385, -0.037988997995853424, -0.02103385701775551, -0.0247331615537405, -0.02334592305123806, 0.04036034643650055, -0.022741228342056274, 0.02403361350297928, -0.004769373685121536, -0.03428969532251358, -0.021555554121732712, 0.046905264258384705, -0.006580491084605455, 0.059900254011154175, 0.008845128118991852, 0.004585594404488802, -0.041783154010772705, 0.01401466690003872, -0.015805035829544067, -0.018306806683540344, 0.031040946021676064, -0.036400195211172104, -0.06322014331817627, 0.057054635137319565, 0.037325020879507065, 0.04154602065682411, -0.010854845866560936, 0.01809338666498661, 0.0033050663769245148, -0.027507638558745384, 0.0489446260035038, 0.019717760384082794, -0.032606035470962524, 0.004289175849407911, 0.01384867262095213, 0.03599706292152405, -0.014749784953892231, -0.03111208789050579, 0.06108592823147774, -0.027815913781523705, -0.011975307948887348, 0.007428247947245836, -0.02047659084200859, -0.013433687388896942, 0.010267937555909157, 0.03201320022344589, 0.005282178055495024, 0.010463573969900608, 0.06132306158542633, -0.0021431059576570988, 0.044652484357357025, 0.011803384870290756, -0.0011382470838725567, 0.01703813672065735, 0.060279667377471924, 0.04012320935726166, 0.014690501615405083, 0.06654002517461777, 0.02367791160941124, 0.04728468134999275, 0.034835103899240494, 0.028503604233264923, -0.04377508535981178, 0.028717026114463806, -0.015508616343140602, 0.07578828930854797, 0.05838258937001228, -0.038012709468603134, -0.014820925891399384, -0.019634762778878212, 0.01271042600274086, -0.01860322616994381, 0.0005431869067251682, -0.03426598012447357, 0.014050237834453583, -0.002984934486448765, -0.03398142009973526, 0.03632905334234238, -0.009301613084971905, -0.025989975780248642, 0.024282604455947876, 0.010635496117174625, -0.032558608800172806, -0.02098643034696579, -0.004342531319707632, 0.050983984023332596, -0.02272937074303627, -0.00714961439371109, -0.023262925446033478, -0.01288827694952488, -0.011062338948249817, -0.005205109249800444, -0.012627428397536278, 0.01122240535914898, 0.009568389505147934, 0.01459564734250307, 0.04965602979063988, -0.006704986561089754, 0.01683657243847847, 0.046265002340078354, 0.008258219808340073, 0.0007217790698632598, 0.0743180513381958, -0.02003789134323597, -0.010463573969900608, -0.08811929821968079, 0.015591613948345184, 0.005136932712048292, -0.022385526448488235, -0.01586431823670864, 0.0361393466591835, 0.030993519350886345, 0.022966505959630013, 0.009271970950067043, -0.0015072881942614913, 0.03516709432005882, -0.01827123761177063, -0.03452682867646217, 0.04801980033516884, 0.028124189004302025, 0.025349711999297142, 0.018769219517707825, -0.07033418864011765, -0.009538747370243073, 0.028385037556290627, -0.007108116056770086, -0.019433198496699333, 0.0011819688370451331, 0.04937146604061127, 0.03521452099084854, -0.0260136891156435, -0.03049553744494915, -0.005510420072823763, 0.0036311268340796232, -0.014986920170485973, -0.02954699657857418, -0.07498202472925186, 0.05055714026093483, 0.033270012587308884, 0.0034888458903878927, 0.0031894631683826447, 0.02098643034696579, -0.00004826064105145633, 0.0010493214940652251, 0.01926720328629017, 0.07061874866485596, 0.00041165121365338564, 0.004315853584557772, -0.02221953123807907, -0.04574330523610115, -0.006384854670614004, -0.015152914449572563, -0.016160737723112106, -0.009088191203773022, 0.00584240909665823, -0.010309436358511448, 0.02480430155992508, -0.005528205074369907, 0.034835103899240494, -0.005110254976898432, 0.037016745656728745, -0.016694290563464165, -0.006953978445380926, 0.03303287923336029, -0.036091919988393784, 0.05487299710512161, -0.023002076894044876, 0.05975797399878502, 0.020464735105633736, -0.019895611330866814, 0.002224620897322893, -0.0034858817234635353, -0.02516000345349312, -0.011186834424734116, 0.048494067043066025, 0.00794401578605175, -0.0002560314896982163, -0.054825566709041595, -0.0285747442394495, 0.03303287923336029, -0.002423221245408058, 0.01983632706105709, -0.01716856099665165, -0.007617956027388573, 0.0022572269663214684, -0.02632196433842182, 0.012283583171665668, -0.018437230959534645, 0.030139833688735962, -0.011263903230428696, 0.016801001504063606, -0.04289768636226654, 0.04576701670885086, -0.05112626403570175, 0.012028663419187069, 0.009271970950067043, 0.0020186100155115128, -0.07185184955596924, 0.02323921211063862, 0.01431108545511961, -0.007742451503872871, 0.013896100223064423, -0.010303507559001446, -0.03391027823090553, 0.024970294907689095, -0.012983131222426891, -0.00825229100883007, -0.04775895178318024, -0.02508886344730854, 0.006876909639686346, -0.04071604833006859, 0.012497004121541977, -0.03464539721608162, -0.00043351209023967385, -0.008773988112807274, -0.0074993884190917015, 0.004724910948425531, 0.013753819279372692, 0.05273878201842308, -0.06563891470432281, -0.03848697990179062, -0.003239854471758008, -0.009005194529891014, -0.047830089926719666, -0.017974818125367165, -0.004905726294964552, 0.07630997896194458, 0.025586845353245735, 0.03839212656021118, 0.011708531528711319, -0.028171615675091743, -0.008222649805247784, 0.028432464227080345, 0.02769734524190426, -0.02109314128756523, 0.004280283115804195, -0.042447131127119064, -0.017251556739211082, 0.004985759500414133, -0.040810901671648026, 0.05634323135018349, -0.010866702534258366, 0.004736768081784248, -0.040810901671648026, -0.02990270033478737, -0.010576212778687477, -0.01758354716002941, 0.0003901608579326421, 0.10158855468034744, -0.01670614816248417, 0.027080794796347618, 0.003254675306379795, 0.021045714616775513, -0.010712564922869205, -0.0015606434317305684, -0.022990219295024872, -0.007920302450656891, -0.012497004121541977, 0.007742451503872871, 0.015330765396356583, -0.023642340674996376, 0.0012531093088909984, -0.009420180693268776, -0.020429164171218872, -0.010321293026208878, 0.03822613134980202, -0.008602065034210682, 0.016314875334501266, 0.015567900612950325, -0.0002675176947377622, 0.015034346841275692, 0.013469257391989231, 0.00626628752797842, -0.005975797306746244, -0.009930020198225975, -0.07336951047182083, -0.032866884022951126, 0.008898483589291573, -0.005904656834900379, -0.026274537667632103, -0.010860774666070938, 0.006467851810157299, -0.011157193221151829, -0.009538747370243073, -0.03303287923336029, -0.0007366000209003687, 0.0006850973004475236, -0.011329115368425846, 0.0006365587469190359, 0.008661349304020405, -0.03725387901067734, 0.0049264756962656975, 0.03281945735216141, 0.045861873775720596, 0.002485469216480851, 0.02957071177661419, 0.009194902144372463, -0.0015650897985324264, 0.005714948754757643, 0.001538412063382566, 0.023689767345786095, -0.009775882586836815, -0.021069427952170372, 0.028977874666452408, -0.005009472835808992, -0.004935368429869413, 0.000557637307792902, 0.005018365569412708, -0.00004821432230528444, -0.03113580122590065, -0.009841094724833965, 0.04448648914694786, 0.03085123933851719, -0.047877516597509384, 0.0004698233387898654, -0.03376799821853638, -0.03568878769874573, 0.01891150139272213, -0.01446522306650877, -0.01875736378133297, 0.02542085200548172, -0.0018170455005019903, -0.022100964561104774, -0.0244723130017519, -0.019800756126642227, 0.010534713976085186, 0.019492480903863907, -0.0330565944314003, -0.004413671791553497, -0.02957071177661419, 0.016516439616680145, 0.013149125501513481, -0.03623420000076294, -0.01413323450833559, 0.02014460228383541, -0.0033969562500715256, 0.010842989198863506, -0.027412783354520798, -0.024875441566109657, -0.047877516597509384, 0.005460029002279043, -0.009633601643145084, -0.010422075167298317, 0.024946581572294235, 0.0453638881444931, 0.00840642862021923, 0.0006258136127144098, 0.010214582085609436, -0.0133269764482975, -0.034194838255643845, -0.04737953469157219, -0.010902272537350655, 0.012983131222426891, 0.0540667362511158, -0.011056410148739815, -0.04384622722864151, -0.027744773775339127, 0.021591125056147575, -0.001235324190929532, 0.019338343292474747, -0.023535629734396935, -0.017275270074605942, 0.008258219808340073, 0.01348111405968666, -0.012064233422279358, 0.011068267747759819, 0.015342622064054012, 0.02696222811937332, 0.006965835113078356, 0.010392433032393456, 0.008637635037302971, 0.008951839059591293, 0.02124727889895439, 0.025017723441123962, -0.004674519877880812, 0.002186086494475603, 0.0046804482117295265, -0.06137048825621605, 0.014050237834453583, -0.03144407644867897, 0.020132744684815407, -0.004140966571867466, -0.011975307948887348, -0.02045287750661373, -0.021721549332141876, 0.010007089003920555, -0.033198874443769455, -0.0026144112925976515, 0.030092407017946243, -0.019646618515253067, 0.05553697422146797, -0.0031035018619149923, 0.04420192912220955, 0.025942549109458923, -0.036732181906700134, 0.003613341599702835, -0.012900133617222309, -0.0006639774655923247, 0.0027492817025631666, 0.004469991195946932, 0.02101014368236065, 0.0453638881444931, 0.01957547850906849, 0.03526194766163826, 0.03490624576807022, 0.0034651323221623898, -0.04927661269903183, 0.001207164372317493, 0.0022601911332458258, 0.004950189031660557, 0.014714214950799942, 0.01837794855237007, 0.008892555721104145, 0.008305646479129791, 0.011352828703820705, 0.02418775111436844, -0.02480430155992508, 0.05155310779809952, 0.04090575501322746, -0.0011167566990479827, 0.01335068978369236, -0.021662265062332153, -0.023334065452218056, 0.007872875779867172, 0.014192518778145313, -0.019646618515253067, -0.024235177785158157, 0.013860529288649559, -0.0034414189867675304, -0.0012983131455257535, -0.010078229941427708, -0.022812368348240852, -0.011631462723016739, -0.009337183088064194, 0.02036987990140915, -0.010184939950704575, 0.009532819502055645, 0.013931670226156712, 0.017002565786242485, 0.005584524944424629, 0.009040764532983303, -0.00039312505396083, -0.009319397620856762, -0.05378217622637749, -0.011412112973630428, -0.004917582962661982, -0.0018125992501154542, -0.03234518691897392, 0.03215548023581505, 0.0032576394733041525, 0.01287642028182745, -0.03872411325573921, -0.029641851782798767, -0.004953153431415558, -0.033198874443769455, 0.004431456793099642, 0.0013990954030305147, -0.040858328342437744, 0.01413323450833559, 0.03296173736453056, -0.017713969573378563, -0.016919568181037903, -0.01236658077687025, -0.005848337430506945, 0.01352854073047638, -0.007357107475399971, -0.03367314487695694, -0.022006111219525337, 0.010451716370880604, 0.013220265507698059, -0.026132255792617798, 0.000006947308975213673, 0.04617014899849892, -0.049466323107481, 0.0023002077359706163, 0.007718738168478012, -0.003628162667155266, -0.003969043958932161, 0.02760249190032482, -0.00004293437086744234, -0.010712564922869205, -0.03936437889933586, -0.019492480903863907, 0.05563182756304741, -0.0008951839408837259, -0.0068176258355379105, 0.0002354674506932497, 0.04550617188215256, 0.02736535668373108, -0.04322967678308487, 0.02140141651034355, -0.008264148607850075, -0.009627673774957657, -0.018899643793702126, 0.0005220671300776303, 0.0035807357635349035, -0.014654931612312794, -0.026535386219620705, -0.0032131767366081476, 0.008204864338040352, 0.006616061087697744, 0.02400990016758442, 0.009912234731018543, 0.001895596389658749, 0.032914310693740845, 0.003954222891479731, 0.03950665891170502, 0.022990219295024872, 0.022871652618050575, 0.030329542234539986, -0.0015095112612470984, 0.02826646901667118, -0.021970540285110474, 0.02085600607097149, -0.010066372342407703, 0.01429922878742218, 0.015330765396356583, -0.006023223977535963, -0.006461923476308584, 0.015674611553549767, 0.003613341599702835, -0.03391027823090553, 0.006627917755395174, 0.019848182797431946, 0.0023105822037905455, -0.008157437667250633, -0.03303287923336029, 0.006538992282003164, 0.02734164334833622, -0.03251118212938309, 0.0010774813126772642, -0.0448421910405159, -0.018413517624139786, 0.025017723441123962, 0.023428918793797493, 0.015805035829544067, 0.0028130116406828165, -0.05079427734017372, -0.011637390591204166, -0.01591174490749836, -0.0031627854332327843, -0.006728700362145901, -0.013113555498421192, 0.007048832252621651, -0.0064974939450621605, -0.08551081269979477, 0.019848182797431946, -0.00161103461869061, -0.010131584480404854, 0.008957767859101295, 0.05392445623874664, 0.031254369765520096, 0.028977874666452408, 0.008270076476037502, -0.02859845757484436, 0.0348588190972805, -0.022409239783883095, -0.01901821233332157, 0.005113219376653433, -0.006805769167840481, 0.003316923277452588, 0.017132990062236786, 0.022800512611865997, -0.016338588669896126, 0.002263155300170183, -0.028527317568659782, 0.01955176517367363, -0.023867618292570114, -0.028147902339696884, -0.011240189895033836, -0.006061758380383253, -0.03391027823090553, 0.002368384040892124, 0.03236890211701393, 0.0028130116406828165, 0.006242573726922274, -0.03507223725318909, 0.0026529456954449415, 0.008797701448202133, 0.008453856222331524, 0.02252780646085739, -0.004630057141184807, 0.009058550000190735, -0.036068204790353775, 0.01604216918349266, -0.004724910948425531, -0.03649504855275154, 0.00600840337574482, 0.007048832252621651, 0.031230654567480087, -0.0015739822993054986, 0.018769219517707825, 0.012828993611037731, 0.038249846547842026, -0.0080092279240489, 0.013315119780600071, 0.024638306349515915, 0.02923872135579586, -0.011210547760128975, -0.0160184558480978, 0.027128223329782486, -0.0032872813753783703, -0.021508127450942993, -0.02259894832968712, -0.027246790006756783, -0.03440826013684273, 0.0056052738800644875, 0.0025906977243721485, -0.016765430569648743, -0.015947315841913223, -0.029452143236994743, -0.003038289723917842, 0.01878107711672783, -0.010173083283007145, -0.020927147939801216, 0.023772764950990677, 0.027246790006756783, 0.005261428654193878, 0.011999021284282207, 0.022515950724482536, -0.018306806683540344, -0.03471653535962105, -0.019433198496699333, -0.041735727339982986, 0.05605866760015488, -0.01337440311908722, -0.0285747442394495, 0.03179977834224701, -0.029926413670182228, 0.02076115272939205, 0.02731793001294136, 0.004301032517105341, 0.004182465374469757, -0.019231632351875305, 0.004493704531341791, 0.006224788725376129, -0.033862851560115814, 0.03179977834224701, 0.007819520309567451, -0.014500794000923634, -0.008228577673435211, -0.008293789811432362, -0.0283138956874609, 0.019611049443483353, -0.008145580999553204, -0.03528565913438797, -0.02014460228383541, -0.02764991857111454, -0.016445299610495567, 0.025325998663902283, -0.009011122398078442, -0.050699423998594284, -0.015354478731751442, 0.025349711999297142, 0.024685733020305634, 0.029452143236994743, 0.008762131445109844, -0.010570283979177475, 0.058287736028432846, 0.027436498552560806, -0.007368964143097401, -0.026867374777793884, -0.016777288168668747, 0.03675589710474014, -0.016231877729296684, -0.033151447772979736, 0.03262975066900253, -0.050983984023332596, -0.03452682867646217, 0.010860774666070938, 0.03834469988942146, 0.007321537472307682, -0.020950861275196075, -0.05368732288479805, 0.019409485161304474, -0.023073216900229454, -0.0008003299590200186, 0.023843904957175255, -0.030139833688735962, -0.014488937333226204, -0.03210805356502533, -0.008750274777412415, 0.02632196433842182, -0.005228822585195303, 0.03208433836698532, -0.007819520309567451, -0.028053048998117447, 0.01168481819331646, -0.003897903487086296, -0.007410462945699692, 0.00356887886300683, 0.010908201336860657, -0.015591613948345184, 0.05221708491444588, -0.00337620684877038, -0.018484657630324364, 0.01213537435978651, 0.01886407472193241, 0.02070186845958233, -0.016231877729296684, -0.010653281584382057, -0.004111324902623892, 0.014643074944615364, -0.007564600557088852, 0.045885585248470306, 0.05691235512495041, 0.04707125946879387, -0.005587488878518343, -0.03175235167145729, 0.010985270142555237, -0.004935368429869413, -0.006568634416908026, 0.03516709432005882, 0.00611214991658926, -0.027721058577299118, -0.04583815857768059, -0.049703456461429596, 0.04505561292171478, 0.004440349526703358, 0.023073216900229454, -0.004327710252255201, -0.012686712667346, 0.006195147056132555, 0.011323187500238419, -0.006479708943516016, 0.01431108545511961, 0.009651387110352516, -0.0049620456993579865, 0.018437230959534645, 0.013599681667983532, 0.02516000345349312, -0.007795806974172592, 0.014714214950799942, 0.0034799533896148205, 0.012200586497783661, -0.023120643571019173, 0.029143868014216423, -0.02895416133105755, 0.04296882823109627, 0.002703336765989661, 0.028408750891685486, -0.0035244161263108253, 0.006118078250437975, -0.032250333577394485, -0.0005717172170989215, 0.006550848949700594, -0.017073705792427063, 0.02698594145476818, -0.023867618292570114, -0.022776799276471138, 0.006390783004462719, -0.028432464227080345, -0.0006558259483426809, -0.057007208466529846, 0.031230654567480087, 0.01844908855855465, -0.012022734619677067, 0.042091429233551025, 0.021211707964539528, 0.017690256237983704, -0.039601512253284454, 0.018852217122912407, -0.0036459476687014103, -0.01999046467244625, -0.03813127800822258, 0.03931695222854614, -0.037680722773075104, -0.007635741028934717, 0.060516804456710815, 0.01765468716621399, 0.02764991857111454, 0.0065982760861516, 0.001959326444193721, -0.027175650000572205, 0.01986004039645195, 0.006912479642778635, -0.019433198496699333, -0.019587336108088493, -0.03644762188196182, -0.03239261358976364, -0.018591368570923805, -0.01252071838825941, 0.009372753091156483, 0.010700708255171776, 0.010339077562093735, 0.005382960196584463, 0.03210805356502533, 0.00392754515632987, -0.010256080888211727, -0.009639530442655087, -0.02577655389904976, 0.02610854245722294, -0.02039359323680401, -0.005738662555813789, 0.008477569557726383, -0.02954699657857418, 0.02546827867627144, -0.014429653063416481, -0.005139897111803293, 0.0007584608974866569, 0.015615327283740044, -0.01236658077687025, 0.003942366223782301, 0.010789633728563786, -0.014192518778145313, 0.011050482280552387, -0.007345250807702541, -0.04285025969147682, -0.05179024115204811, 0.015650898218154907, 0.02482801489531994, -0.04413078725337982, 0.005175467114895582, 0.015235912054777145, -0.001327213947661221, 0.005187323782593012, 0.001968218944966793, 0.010013017803430557, -0.0010819275630638003, -0.010291650891304016, 0.023464489728212357, 0.0006969540263526142, 0.0021757117938250303, -0.019160492345690727, 0.023535629734396935, -0.012117588892579079, 0.008513139560818672, 0.01955176517367363, -0.007167399860918522, 0.008459784090518951, 0.006005438975989819, -0.01269856933504343, 0.010819275863468647, 0.007600170560181141, 0.0020349130500108004, -0.001963772578164935, 0.022160248830914497, 0.014844639226794243, 0.0027685489039868116, 0.00808629672974348, 0.010570283979177475, -0.016421586275100708, 0.02513629011809826, -0.0033732426818460226, -0.011204619891941547, -0.010920058004558086, 0.0073748924769461155, 0.022587090730667114, -0.013255835510790348, -0.05363989248871803, -0.019717760384082794, -0.021982397884130478, 0.0042002503760159016, -0.03554650768637657, 0.010593997314572334, 0.013611538335680962, -0.006147719919681549, -0.01273413933813572, 0.02006160467863083, 0.022077251225709915, -0.018366090953350067, -0.010137513279914856, 0.011844883672893047, 0.019302774220705032, 0.005214001517742872, -0.007582385558634996, -0.004920547362416983, -0.011026768945157528, 0.009509106166660786, -0.031040946021676064, -0.031942058354616165, 0.019670331850647926, -0.0158880315721035, 0.043656520545482635, 0.011097908951342106, 0.01668243482708931, 0.0024158109445124865, 0.006129934918135405, -0.010410218499600887, -0.004034256096929312, 0.029072728008031845, 0.04472362622618675, 0.005510420072823763, 0.026653952896595, -0.006900622975081205, -0.0065982760861516, -0.0019178277580067515, -0.04965602979063988, -0.0029627031181007624, 0.038984961807727814, -0.0040757544338703156, -0.01273413933813572, -0.004016471095383167, -0.015129201114177704, -0.014334799721837044, 0.053260479122400284, -0.01688399910926819, 0.014560077339410782, -0.042447131127119064, 0.022231388837099075, -0.0016436406876891851, -0.014346656389534473, 0.05311819911003113, -0.004378101322799921, 0.004884976893663406, 0.0027285325340926647, 0.012983131222426891, 0.008975552394986153, -0.014358513057231903, 0.044937048107385635, -0.0009048175415955484, 0.03206062689423561, 0.044581346213817596, 0.0016851392574608326, 0.010759992524981499, 0.0028515460435301065, 0.019741473719477654, -0.030305828899145126, 0.02427074871957302, -0.025634273886680603, -0.026606526225805283, 0.02577655389904976, 0.010291650891304016, -0.010635496117174625, 0.03521452099084854, -0.004876084625720978, -0.029641851782798767, 0.02211282029747963, -0.01716856099665165, 0.021863829344511032, -0.008934053592383862, 0.03367314487695694, 0.01177374366670847, -0.024614593014121056, 0.017488691955804825, 0.009028907865285873, 0.029120154678821564, 0.00580387469381094, 0.011862669140100479, 0.033554576337337494, 0.01701442338526249, -0.006361141335219145, 0.05695978179574013, 0.00004511119186645374, 0.005311819724738598, -0.04277912154793739, -0.0002623303735163063, 0.0051250760443508625, -0.012603715062141418, 0.01193973794579506, 0.015176627784967422, 0.008981481194496155, 0.05050971359014511, 0.01745312288403511, -0.014382226392626762, -0.023642340674996376, -0.05240679159760475, -0.03213176876306534, 0.02952328324317932, 0.03853440657258034, 0.01816452667117119, 0.01988375373184681, 0.012153158895671368, 0.022480379790067673, -0.02124727889895439, -0.002970113418996334, 0.006527135614305735, -0.019800756126642227, 0.009212687611579895, -0.03281945735216141, 0.008744345977902412, 0.008471640758216381, -0.007066617254167795, 0.0024988080840557814, 0.012805279344320297, -0.0330565944314003, -0.003906796220690012, -0.033175159245729446, 0.05188509821891785, -0.018899643793702126, -0.02449602633714676, 0.014998776838183403, -0.028385037556290627, -0.01955176517367363, 0.010511000640690327, -0.006106221582740545, -0.015840604901313782, -0.004490740597248077, 0.003013094188645482, 0.020642586052417755, 0.012064233422279358, -0.0016317839035764337, -0.002611447125673294, 0.004692304879426956, -0.000995966256596148, -0.015544187277555466, 0.023132501170039177, -0.008566495031118393, -0.03900867700576782, 0.016623150557279587, -0.014702358283102512, -0.025302283465862274, -0.054493580013513565, 0.007357107475399971, -0.01237843744456768, 0.03874782845377922, 0.028669599443674088, 0.019634762778878212, 0.010238295421004295, 0.004031291697174311, 0.04237598925828934, 0.054588433355093, -0.044628772884607315, 0.011210547760128975, -0.013741962611675262, -0.03723016381263733, -0.020381737500429153, 0.022693801671266556, -0.028977874666452408, -0.010060444474220276, 0.019077494740486145, -0.011186834424734116, -0.006396711338311434, -0.016267448663711548, -0.012900133617222309, -0.02634567767381668, 0.008050726726651192, -0.017097419127821922, 0.008957767859101295, 0.007938087917864323, -0.02083229273557663, 0.02014460228383541, 0.008862913586199284, 0.036400195211172104, 0.0005980243440717459, -0.01831866428256035, -0.011714459396898746, -0.06582862138748169, -0.015176627784967422, 0.029950127005577087, 0.0012627429096028209, -0.008412357419729233, -0.013967240229249, 0.021768976002931595, 0.018615081906318665, -0.0009581728372722864, 0.01365896500647068, -0.009271970950067043, 0.032866884022951126, -0.03364942967891693, -0.02195868268609047, -0.03718273714184761, -0.029641851782798767, -0.008904412388801575, 0.007232611533254385, 0.0024098826106637716, 0.018674366176128387, -0.0058928001672029495, -0.019895611330866814, 0.0013242496643215418, -0.006876909639686346, -0.00612400658428669, 0.0006184031371958554, -0.029997553676366806, -0.0022468522656708956, -0.03016354888677597, -0.007902517914772034, 0.020417306572198868, -0.05032000690698624, -0.04479476436972618, -0.014109521172940731, 0.010878559201955795, 0.007671311032027006, -0.014085807837545872, -0.0068176258355379105, 0.0006724995328113437, -0.011412112973630428, 0.013706391677260399, -0.00043499417370185256, 0.006776127032935619, -0.016955139115452766, -0.012923846952617168, 0.019516194239258766, 0.03962522745132446, 0.01221244316548109, -0.012485147453844547, -0.011435826309025288, 0.007991443388164043, 0.0016614258056506515, 0.02403361350297928, 0.06388411670923233, -0.0348588190972805, -0.008851056918501854, 0.0064500668086111546, 0.037325020879507065, -0.043964795768260956, -0.03303287923336029, 0.004849406890571117, -0.02045287750661373, 0.003545165527611971, -0.009022979997098446, -0.005504491738975048, 0.01397909689694643, 0.0021445879247039557, 0.023156214505434036, -0.02080857940018177, -0.02762620523571968, -0.02893044613301754, -0.023571200668811798, 0.030922379344701767, 0.02036987990140915, -0.012911990284919739, 0.029784131795167923, 0.006331499665975571, 0.004472955595701933, 0.023132501170039177, 0.0005216965801082551, -0.001741458778269589, 0.002998273354023695, -0.0283138956874609, 0.009864808060228825, 0.01750054955482483, 0.01901821233332157, 0.048494067043066025, 0.0013864976353943348, -0.008139652200043201, 0.001953398110345006, -0.021365845575928688, -0.018413517624139786, 0.016030313447117805, 0.03379170969128609, -0.008957767859101295, 0.010101943276822567, -0.010238295421004295, -0.0025002900511026382, 0.02700965479016304, -0.020559588447213173, -0.021152425557374954, 0.040573764592409134, -0.0029197223484516144, 0.04761667177081108, 0.013232122175395489, 0.007902517914772034, -0.02734164334833622, 0.0027996727731078863, -0.020903432741761208, 0.016267448663711548, -0.008459784090518951, 0.008839200250804424, -0.01868622377514839, -0.014939493499696255, 0.003948294557631016, -0.04633614048361778, -0.024994008243083954, 0.008056655526161194, -0.0071792565286159515, 0.027460211887955666, 0.017559831961989403, 0.017215987667441368, 0.010742207057774067, -0.008833271451294422, -0.047260966151952744, -0.008477569557726383, 0.00714961439371109, 0.022231388837099075, 0.003393992083147168, -0.03348343446850777, -0.011975307948887348, -0.005628987681120634, 0.021745262667536736, -0.0024736125487834215, 0.01400281023234129, -0.028076762333512306, 0.01412137784063816, 0.008607993833720684, 0.021662265062332153, -0.0006550849066115916, 0.02244481071829796, 0.0030412538908421993, -0.0007388231460936368, -0.012639285065233707, 0.003906796220690012, 0.03021097555756569, -0.031230654567480087, 0.026819946244359016, 0.04285025969147682, 0.01868622377514839, -0.008773988112807274, -0.03623420000076294, 0.009775882586836815, -0.022006111219525337, -0.014797212556004524, -0.02323921211063862, 0.010273865424096584, -0.019207919016480446, 0.014204375445842743, -0.01942134089767933, -0.0014865387929603457, -0.0019237562082707882, 0.005584524944424629, 0.006888766307383776, -0.006159576587378979, -0.02332220785319805, 0.025586845353245735, -0.01239029411226511, 0.019717760384082794, -0.008750274777412415, -0.011951594613492489, 0.02802933380007744, -0.0018481694860383868, 0.009455750696361065, -0.0015828749164938927, 0.07223126292228699, 0.004561881069093943, 0.01793924905359745, -0.02001417800784111, 0.01337440311908722, 0.027436498552560806, 0.003859369084239006, 0.0433008149266243, -0.008133724331855774, 0.009977446869015694, 0.026274537667632103, 0.03108837455511093, 0.016872141510248184, 0.009746240451931953, -0.035736214369535446, 0.01176188699901104, 0.04363280534744263, -0.026227110996842384, -0.016777288168668747, 0.007849162444472313, 0.04296882823109627, -0.01893521472811699, -0.0399809293448925, 0.011412112973630428, -0.017109276726841927, 0.010481358505785465, -0.024306317791342735, -0.04121403023600578, -0.014429653063416481, -0.0005806097760796547, -0.013279549777507782, -0.03851069509983063, -0.026132255792617798, 0.014251802116632462, -0.010392433032393456, -0.033530861139297485, -0.015235912054777145, 0.026464244350790977, 0.004976866766810417, 0.015852462500333786, -0.008590208366513252, 0.014844639226794243, -0.00658641941845417, -0.029618138447403908, 0.01752426289021969, 0.004781230818480253, 0.015200341120362282, -0.003930509556084871, -0.02083229273557663, 0.03087495267391205, -0.021413274109363556, 0.015058060176670551, -0.01793924905359745, 0.01901821233332157, 0.026914801448583603, -0.008934053592383862, -0.012817136943340302, -0.054446153342723846, -0.03085123933851719, 0.02546827867627144, 0.0158880315721035, 0.02039359323680401, -0.003743765875697136, 0.039838649332523346, 0.0018111171666532755, -0.021022001281380653, -0.005960976239293814, 0.04984573647379875, 0.0040757544338703156, -0.02705708146095276, 0.009366825222969055, 0.0032991380430758 ]
13.691963
8.025624
2024-07-01
1
2024MNRAS.531.4560W
[ "ionized gas outflows", "stellar mass", "nebular emission lines", "galaxy properties", "individual galaxies", "mechanical energy", "SFR surface density", "broad components", "star formation rate", "galaxies" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
55
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1428", "10.48550/arXiv.2404.05725" ]
[ "Weldon, Andrew", "Reddy, Naveen A.", "Coil, Alison L.", "Shapley, Alice E.", "Siana, Brian", "Price, Sedona H.", "Kriek, Mariska", "Mobasher, Bahram", "Song, Zhiyuan", "Wozniak, Michael A." ]
[ "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California, Riverside, 900 University Avenue, Riverside, CA 92521, USA;", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California, Riverside, 900 University Avenue, Riverside, CA 92521, USA", "Center for Astrophysics and Space Sciences, Department of Physics, University of California, San Diego, 9500 Gilman Dr, La Jolla, CA 92093-0424, USA", "Physics &amp; Astronomy Department, University of California, Los Angeles, 430 Portola Plaza, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California, Riverside, 900 University Avenue, Riverside, CA 92521, USA", "Department of Physics &amp; Astronomy and PITT PACC, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA 15260, USA;", "Leiden Observatory, Leiden University, PO Box 9513, NL-2300 RA Leiden, the Netherlands", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California, Riverside, 900 University Avenue, Riverside, CA 92521, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California, Riverside, 900 University Avenue, Riverside, CA 92521, USA;", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California, Riverside, 900 University Avenue, Riverside, CA 92521, USA;" ]
[ "2024MNRAS.tmp.1666S" ]
[ "1975ApJ...196..107I", "1978MNRAS.183..341W", "1985Natur.317...44C", "1986ApJ...303...39D", "1989ApJ...345..245C", "1989agna.book.....O", "1990ApJS...72..163F", "1991ApJ...379...52W", "1996ApJS..102..161D", "1998ARA&A..36..189K", "2001ApJ...556..121K", "2002ASPC..254..292H", "2003ApJ...588...65S", "2003ApJ...594..279G", "2003MNRAS.344.1000B", "2003MNRAS.346.1055K", "2003PASP..115..763C", "2004ApJ...613..898T", "2005ARA&A..43..769V", "2005ApJ...618..569M", "2007ApJ...658..941D", "2008ApJ...672..765G", "2008ApJS..178...20A", "2008MNRAS.385.2181F", "2008MNRAS.387..577O", "2009ApJ...692..187W", "2010AJ....139.2097P", "2010AJ....140..445C", "2010ApJ...717..289S", "2010ApJ...719.1503R", "2010MNRAS.406.2325O", "2011ApJ...733..101G", "2011ApJ...735...66M", "2011ApJ...742...76G", "2011ApJS..197...35G", "2011ApJS..197...36K", "2011MNRAS.416.1354D", "2012ApJ...754...25R", "2012ApJ...760..127M", "2012ApJ...761...43N", "2012SPIE.8446E..0JM", "2013A&A...553A.106L", "2013A&A...558A..33A", "2013MNRAS.429.1922C", "2013MNRAS.431.3373H", "2013PASP..125..306F", "2014A&A...562A..21C", "2014A&A...568A..14A", "2014ARA&A..52..415M", "2014ApJ...787...38F", "2014ApJ...788...28V", "2014ApJ...794..156R", "2014ApJ...796....7G", "2014MNRAS.444.3894H", "2014MNRAS.445..581H", "2015A&A...580A.102C", "2015ApJ...801...35C", "2015ApJ...802...99K", "2015ApJ...806..259R", "2015ApJ...809..147H", "2015ApJ...811..149C", "2015ApJ...814...83L", "2015ApJS..218...15K", "2015MNRAS.446..521S", "2015MNRAS.452.2712W", "2015MNRAS.454.2691M", "2016ApJ...816...23S", "2016ApJ...820L..23S", "2016ApJ...828..108R", "2016MNRAS.456.3432G", "2016MNRAS.458.1891B", "2016MNRAS.459.3614M", "2016MNRAS.462.1757G", "2017ApJ...835...27A", "2017ApJ...841..101L", "2017ApJ...850...40R", "2017ApJS..229...34S", "2017MNRAS.469.4831C", "2017MNRAS.470.4698A", "2017hsn..book.2431H", "2018A&A...616A..29G", "2018AJ....156..123A", "2018ApJ...853...56R", "2018ApJ...853..173K", "2018ApJ...866...63A", "2018ApJ...869...92R", "2018Galax...6..114Z", "2018Galax...6..138R", "2018MNRAS.473.4077P", "2018MNRAS.479.3042G", "2018MNRAS.480..800H", "2018ascl.soft07005S", "2019ApJ...871..128T", "2019ApJ...873..102F", "2019ApJ...873..122D", "2019ApJ...875...21F", "2019ApJ...886...11L", "2019ApJ...886...74M", "2019MNRAS.483.4586F", "2019MNRAS.487..381S", "2019MNRAS.488.3143B", "2019MNRAS.490.3196P", "2019MNRAS.490.3234N", "2019RMxAA..55..377A", "2020A&A...644A..15M", "2020A&ARv..28....2V", "2020ApJ...894...91P", "2020ApJ...900...61K", "2020MNRAS.491.1427S", "2021A&A...654A.128C", "2021ApJ...923..275P", "2021MNRAS.503.5134A", "2021MNRAS.505.5753F", "2021MNRAS.508.2979P", "2022AJ....164..159P", "2022ApJ...926...31R", "2022ApJ...929..134X", "2022ApJ...935..167A", "2022ApJ...941..163R", "2022MNRAS.511.4223A", "2022MNRAS.511.5782R", "2022MNRAS.513.2535C", "2022MNRAS.515..841W", "2023A&A...670A..92M", "2023A&A...676A..53L", "2023ApJ...951..105D", "2023MNRAS.519.3154H" ]
29163041
2405.19154
Search and analysis of giant radio galaxies with associated nuclei (SAGAN). IV. Interplay with the Supercluster environment
We investigated the prevalence of giant radio galaxies (GRGs), some of the largest structures powered by supermassive black holes, within supercluster environments, and the influence of such environments on their properties. Utilising two large catalogues of superclusters (401) and GRGs (1446), we established the existence of 77 GRGs (5.3%) residing in 64 superclusters (16%) within 0.05 ≤ z ≤ 0.42. Among the 77 GRGs found in superclusters, we identified ∼70% as residing within galaxy clusters. Within the subset of GRGs not located in superclusters, which constitutes 94.7% of the sample, a mere 21% are associated with galaxy clusters, while the remaining majority are situated in sparser environments. We examined the influence of differing environments, such as cluster versus non-cluster and supercluster versus non-supercluster regions, on the size of GRGs, while also exploring the driving factors behind their overall growth. Our findings show that the largest GRGs (≳3 Mpc) grow in underdense environments beyond the confines of dense environments. Moreover, we show that ∼24% of 1446 GRGs reside in galaxy clusters. We conclude that GRGs preferentially grow in sparser regions of the cosmic web and have a significantly larger median size. Finally, we demonstrate the potential of GRGs as astrophysical probes with specific cases where GRGs, exhibiting polarised emissions and located behind superclusters (acting as natural Faraday screens), were used to estimate magnetic field strengths of the supercluster environment at sub-microgauss levels.
[ -0.006932529620826244, -0.0009307269938290119, 0.05424356088042259, 0.020442724227905273, -0.00006044774636393413, 0.026690874248743057, -0.004438973497599363, -0.024739118292927742, -0.06270961463451385, 0.017553115263581276, -0.02172277122735977, 0.021291865035891533, -0.0445101372897625, 0.015994247049093246, 0.020392030477523804, -0.00443263677880168, -0.04116427153348923, -0.012515307404100895, -0.017096860334277153, 0.03748888894915581, 0.005921800155192614, -0.025905102491378784, 0.010658605955541134, -0.020683525130152702, -0.061543628573417664, -0.005284945014864206, 0.019150003790855408, 0.05112582445144653, 0.049098026007413864, 0.027831509709358215, -0.001414705067873001, -0.024396928027272224, -0.047298356890678406, -0.013560890220105648, -0.05001053586602211, 0.07761391997337341, -0.018300864845514297, 0.022939449176192284, 0.00429956242442131, 0.004942754283547401, 0.06788049638271332, 0.031101331114768982, -0.03710867837071419, -0.0024998930748552084, 0.02615857683122158, -0.016095636412501335, -0.04012502729892731, -0.06286169588565826, 0.02210298366844654, -0.009011021815240383, -0.06326725333929062, -0.009372222237288952, -0.0354357473552227, -0.03285030648112297, -0.0426090769469738, 0.00349478074349463, 0.0010329089127480984, -0.0004594226775225252, -0.0202779658138752, -0.004492837004363537, -0.005833083763718605, 0.004879385698586702, 0.054801203310489655, 0.009004684165120125, 0.00956866517663002, 0.005456040147691965, -0.019327437505126, 0.0021307705901563168, 0.03520761802792549, 0.001416289247572422, -0.021139780059456825, -0.026690874248743057, 0.0066980659030377865, -0.0458282046020031, 0.03333190828561783, 0.020911652594804764, 0.019428826868534088, -0.009689065627753735, 0.0032238797284662724, -0.004866711795330048, -0.012230148538947105, 0.011919641867280006, -0.02314222976565361, 0.009106074459850788, 0.006843813695013523, 0.00796543899923563, 0.0623040534555912, -0.006488949526101351, -0.03464997559785843, 0.016741996631026268, 0.014384682290256023, -0.04448479041457176, 0.022229721769690514, -0.00792108103632927, -0.039389949291944504, -0.027071084827184677, 0.03959272801876068, -0.027932899072766304, 0.05865401774644852, 0.0464872382581234, -0.004556205589324236, 0.03776771202683449, -0.010785343125462532, -0.06615686416625977, 0.031608279794454575, -0.0030955583788454533, -0.017515093088150024, 0.02615857683122158, 0.02210298366844654, -0.02993534877896309, 0.027045737951993942, 0.03579061105847359, -0.025246068835258484, 0.05840054526925087, -0.033864203840494156, -0.020632831379771233, -0.0412910096347332, -0.02012588270008564, -0.02021459862589836, 0.0451691709458828, 0.017464399337768555, 0.0017283797496929765, 0.0010463747894391418, -0.003681718371808529, 0.04742509499192238, -0.0281863734126091, 0.029580483213067055, -0.025981144979596138, -0.020949674770236015, -0.00019376943237148225, 0.008351987227797508, -0.0018376907100901008, 0.03059438243508339, -0.0131046362221241, -0.0636221170425415, 0.005189891904592514, -0.005202565807849169, -0.02125384286046028, -0.005956652574241161, 0.01340880524367094, -0.03604408726096153, 0.002019875682890415, 0.03328121080994606, 0.04283720254898071, 0.01871909759938717, 0.02055678889155388, -0.04585355147719383, 0.028161026537418365, -0.014955000020563602, 0.0036120128352195024, 0.007420468609780073, 0.020151229575276375, -0.0374128483235836, -0.00883992575109005, -0.008738536387681961, -0.0060897269286215305, 0.029707221314311028, 0.041367050260305405, -0.0012127174995839596, -0.04281185567378998, 0.015968898311257362, 0.015398580580949783, -0.012901856563985348, -0.009676392190158367, -0.015943551436066628, 0.03229266032576561, -0.0032318008597940207, -0.0007631961489096284, -0.06646103411912918, 0.01645050011575222, -0.0013069782871752977, -0.03766632452607155, -0.050745610147714615, -0.04015037417411804, -0.017603809013962746, 0.03573991730809212, -0.021481970325112343, 0.003276159055531025, -0.0025965303648263216, 0.009346875362098217, 0.00425520446151495, 0.02813567779958248, 0.016273068264126778, -0.03376281261444092, -0.02144395001232624, 0.05046679079532623, 0.0013917338801547885, 0.01136199850589037, -0.001921654213219881, -0.03120272047817707, 0.0005901205004192889, 0.0073064048774540424, 0.018643055111169815, 0.051303256303071976, -0.0001704022433841601, -0.04638584703207016, 0.023167576640844345, 0.01272442378103733, -0.03695659339427948, 0.03708333149552345, 0.02757803536951542, -0.0020182912703603506, 0.03201384097337723, -0.05160742625594139, -0.047577179968357086, -0.05976930633187294, 0.05160742625594139, -0.00005153653182787821, 0.0026107882149517536, -0.018022043630480766, 0.028744017705321312, -0.0340416356921196, 0.0017283797496929765, -0.019821712747216225, 0.001497876364737749, -0.02785685658454895, -0.054750509560108185, 0.015601360239088535, 0.028439847752451897, 0.008092176169157028, 0.010810690931975842, 0.03513157740235329, -0.016285741701722145, 0.023357681930065155, 0.034295111894607544, 0.04374971240758896, 0.014739546924829483, -0.03399094194173813, 0.0733555406332016, 0.014638157561421394, 0.0232436191290617, 0.048236213624477386, -0.015778793022036552, -0.058045677840709686, -0.02069620043039322, -0.005978831555694342, 0.000961619196459651, 0.03579061105847359, -0.00919479038566351, -0.025372805073857307, 0.003932024352252483, 0.02290142886340618, 0.006647370755672455, 0.03305308520793915, -0.010709300637245178, 0.024878529831767082, -0.004594226833432913, 0.019631605595350266, 0.037919797003269196, 0.012946214526891708, 0.001969180768355727, 0.009555991739034653, 0.0012784624705091119, -0.012813139706850052, -0.018833162263035774, -0.02475179359316826, -0.030569033697247505, 0.018655728548765182, -0.019948448985815048, -0.007585227023810148, -0.0003025852784048766, -0.03170967102050781, -0.021659402176737785, 0.012876508757472038, -0.03295169398188591, 0.04083475470542908, 0.010164330713450909, -0.015639381483197212, -0.05774151161313057, 0.01847829669713974, 0.008877946995198727, -0.04035315290093422, 0.04207678139209747, -0.07244303822517395, -0.014916978776454926, 0.03439649939537048, 0.04572681337594986, 0.02413078024983406, 0.01735033467411995, -0.062253355979919434, -0.012287179939448833, 0.04562542587518692, 0.05992139130830765, 0.020252618938684464, -0.020252618938684464, 0.011507745832204819, 0.03120272047817707, 0.02681761048734188, 0.007768996059894562, 0.0006439838325604796, 0.08379869908094406, -0.025208046659827232, 0.011983010917901993, 0.01705884002149105, -0.0471462719142437, -0.030746467411518097, 0.016513869166374207, 0.00586793664842844, -0.04106288403272629, 0.0068818349391222, 0.01809808425605297, 0.04124031588435173, -0.009682728908956051, -0.026513440534472466, -0.03437115252017975, 0.030999941751360893, 0.021748119965195656, 0.032216619700193405, -0.039339255541563034, 0.04717161878943443, 0.006384390871971846, -0.0012832151260226965, 0.025867080315947533, 0.03244474530220032, -0.04374971240758896, 0.015385907143354416, -0.022647954523563385, 0.03421906754374504, 0.006514296866953373, -0.04478896036744118, -0.030391601845622063, -0.03335725516080856, 0.0014226260827854276, -0.014181902632117271, 0.013535542413592339, -0.060022782534360886, -0.017996694892644882, -0.004331246949732304, -0.010848712176084518, -0.04240629822015762, 0.061999883502721786, 0.03343329578638077, 0.04418062046170235, 0.04841364547610283, 0.020442724227905273, -0.06027625501155853, 0.0050409757532179356, 0.04679140821099281, -0.0019264068687334657, -0.04468756914138794, -0.003922519274055958, 0.011913305148482323, 0.03637360408902168, -0.020683525130152702, 0.00111924868542701, 0.07320345938205719, 0.01145071443170309, 0.04643654450774193, 0.02276201732456684, -0.0034757701214402914, 0.03903508558869362, 0.016057614237070084, 0.016627931967377663, -0.0007303236634470522, 0.039237864315509796, -0.019454173743724823, 0.021976245567202568, -0.01612098328769207, -0.007984449155628681, 0.028972145169973373, -0.030670424923300743, 0.028490543365478516, -0.0006792326457798481, 0.002164039295166731, -0.005373660940676928, 0.03449789062142372, -0.04638584703207016, 0.04808412864804268, -0.015119758434593678, -0.031658973544836044, 0.005842589307576418, 0.0032238797284662724, 0.004999786149710417, -0.032267313450574875, -0.058856796473264694, 0.004587890114635229, 0.028744017705321312, 0.006818466354161501, -0.017692524939775467, 0.014397356659173965, 0.015664728358387947, -0.007686616852879524, 0.006007347721606493, -0.07310207188129425, -0.02172277122735977, -0.0030147633515298367, -0.0137636698782444, 0.03911112621426582, -0.1003759354352951, 0.006685391999781132, -0.033306561410427094, 0.00364052876830101, 0.034954145550727844, -0.020683525130152702, -0.009777781553566456, -0.046918146312236786, 0.04836295172572136, 0.03368677198886871, 0.01362425833940506, 0.05500398576259613, -0.015499970875680447, -0.05708247423171997, -0.03328121080994606, -0.027679424732923508, 0.012977899052202702, 0.0014558946713805199, -0.014916978776454926, 0.0647881031036377, 0.01655188947916031, -0.05987069755792618, 0.024916552007198334, 0.03120272047817707, 0.015347885899245739, -0.0010542958043515682, -0.012673729099333286, 0.0511004775762558, -0.07254442572593689, 0.04222886636853218, -0.06367281824350357, 0.04448479041457176, 0.027071084827184677, -0.00826960802078247, -0.00108677230309695, 0.025322111323475838, -0.0347006693482399, 0.04491569474339485, 0.012876508757472038, 0.007376110181212425, -0.012604023329913616, -0.03639895096421242, -0.010449489578604698, 0.035942696034908295, 0.016982797533273697, -0.03779305890202522, -0.008732199668884277, 0.02696969546377659, 0.051962289959192276, 0.002026212401688099, -0.0003952619154006243, -0.04940219596028328, 0.025043288245797157, -0.000008614175385446288, -0.03553713485598564, -0.03690589964389801, 0.040048982948064804, 0.019479522481560707, 0.031658973544836044, 0.03135480731725693, 0.023205598816275597, -0.052824102342128754, -0.0173883568495512, -0.05591649189591408, 0.029073534533381462, 0.0034092331770807505, -0.03822396695613861, 0.0059186313301324844, 0.019631605595350266, -0.035385049879550934, 0.021710097789764404, -0.06392628699541092, 0.025233395397663116, 0.006029526703059673, -0.06448393315076828, 0.012388570234179497, 0.000550515134818852, -0.01253431849181652, -0.0015398580580949783, -0.010177004151046276, 0.0042615411803126335, 0.01899792067706585, 0.042355604469776154, -0.04927545785903931, -0.03269822150468826, 0.014612809754908085, 0.023116881027817726, -0.012432928197085857, -0.0236111581325531, -0.031887102872133255, 0.060124170035123825, 0.010354436933994293, 0.023319661617279053, -0.012851160950958729, 0.00721135176718235, -0.00564614636823535, -0.005804568063467741, 0.00681212916970253, -0.019492195919156075, 0.021608708426356316, 0.003884498029947281, -0.0016903586219996214, -0.047805305570364, 0.02582906000316143, 0.05039074644446373, -0.013396131806075573, 0.006520633585751057, 0.027045737951993942, -0.011932316236197948, -0.02593044936656952, -0.014321314170956612, 0.013966449536383152, 0.03898439183831215, -0.02572767063975334, 0.010753659531474113, -0.017641831189393997, -0.014625483192503452, 0.002823073184117675, -0.02714712731540203, -0.03637360408902168, 0.01029740460216999, 0.022470520809292793, -0.028490543365478516, 0.043622974306344986, -0.0021323550026863813, 0.002024628221988678, 0.023408377543091774, 0.009486285969614983, -0.011476061306893826, 0.033864203840494156, 0.015474623069167137, -0.006507959682494402, 0.022609932348132133, -0.03054368682205677, -0.018883856013417244, 0.0180473905056715, 0.011900631710886955, -0.00042734231101348996, -0.019061287865042686, -0.09733423590660095, -0.03239405155181885, -0.016716647893190384, -0.03804653510451317, -0.03751423954963684, 0.02073422074317932, 0.01378901768475771, -0.029681874439120293, -0.04111357778310776, -0.021760793402791023, -0.023484420031309128, -0.01719824969768524, -0.012059053406119347, 0.014574788510799408, 0.04045454412698746, -0.011970337480306625, -0.0353597030043602, 0.005117018241435289, 0.039618078619241714, 0.019593585282564163, 0.002731188666075468, 0.023902652785182, 0.02073422074317932, 0.052012983709573746, -0.0465632788836956, 0.023509766906499863, -0.01721092499792576, -0.013256720267236233, -0.006419243756681681, 0.01626039482653141, 0.029910000041127205, 0.018972571939229965, -0.0009228059207089245, -0.016513869166374207, -0.007680279668420553, -0.00011871719470946118, 0.024739118292927742, -0.006108737550675869, -0.014904305338859558, 0.010817027650773525, 0.01510708499699831, -0.005706346593797207, 0.015778793022036552, -0.000323180080158636, -0.005002954509109259, 0.02610788121819496, -0.0077753327786922455, 0.030467644333839417, -0.00893497932702303, -0.03492879867553711, -0.005931305233389139, 0.006137253250926733, -0.016894081607460976, -0.02785685658454895, -0.0353597030043602, 0.013244046829640865, 0.03097459301352501, -0.0047082905657589436, -0.04172191768884659, -0.026716221123933792, -0.020354008302092552, 0.041874002665281296, 0.015056390315294266, -0.00313357962295413, -0.01735033467411995, 0.011355660855770111, -0.011355660855770111, -0.014980347827076912, 0.021051064133644104, -0.02757803536951542, 0.009986898861825466, -0.046259112656116486, 0.017046164721250534, 0.0075408685952425, 0.005025133490562439, -0.03756493330001831, -0.03617082163691521, -0.008409019559621811, 0.0025204878766089678, -0.0073064048774540424, -0.011602799408137798, 0.006260822061449289, 0.012927203439176083, -0.004438973497599363, 0.014650830999016762, -0.028059635311365128, -0.04017572104930878, -0.006241811439394951, -0.017553115263581276, 0.003301506396383047, -0.023598482832312584, 0.003669044468551874, 0.00016604564734734595, -0.01645050011575222, -0.0012990572722628713, 0.0006637865444645286, -0.027071084827184677, 0.008377335034310818, 0.006888171657919884, 0.007604237645864487, -0.019580911844968796, -0.006894508842378855, 0.003292001085355878, 0.028338458389043808, -0.05292549356818199, 0.018681077286601067, -0.004527689889073372, -0.003707065712660551, -0.006343201268464327, -0.026234619319438934, 0.039998289197683334, -0.012496297247707844, -0.023623831570148468, 0.04248233884572983, 0.02244517393410206, 0.0025521721690893173, -0.033914897590875626, -0.001820264384150505, 0.026614831760525703, -0.003227048320695758, -0.017033491283655167, -0.002656730357557535, 0.01510708499699831, -0.023484420031309128, -0.027045737951993942, 0.009929866530001163, 0.015119758434593678, 0.007857711985707283, 0.0050789969973266125, 0.022597258910536766, -0.004790669772773981, -0.030011391267180443, 0.06473740935325623, -0.03875626251101494, -0.006641034036874771, -0.0011739041656255722, 0.002484050812199712, -0.027121780440211296, -0.015043716877698898, 0.01686873286962509, 0.0252207200974226, -0.015031042508780956, 0.013941101729869843, 0.06701868027448654, -0.022495869547128677, 0.041645873337984085, 0.045929595828056335, -0.01956823840737343, 0.018934551626443863, -0.0144227035343647, -0.01364960614591837, 0.007971775718033314, 0.006723413243889809, 0.004496005363762379, 0.023953348398208618, -0.01691942848265171, -0.022217046469449997, -0.003707065712660551, -0.0038749927189201117, -0.0067614344879984856, 0.013358110561966896, 0.009011021815240383, -0.005804568063467741, -0.011906968429684639, -0.007477500010281801, 0.02187485620379448, -0.018085410818457603, -0.0037229079753160477, -0.01795867457985878, -0.01655188947916031, -0.013852385804057121, -0.028667975217103958, -0.05160742625594139, 0.03974481299519539, 0.033813510090112686, 0.0199864711612463, -0.019302088767290115, -0.0004994241171516478, 0.01615900546312332, -0.01456211507320404, -0.02342105098068714, 0.01937813125550747, -0.04002363607287407, 0.0543956458568573, 0.04960497468709946, -0.03064507618546486, 0.018820486962795258, 0.01648852229118347, -0.010855048894882202, 0.020468072965741158, -0.012217475101351738, -0.006368549074977636, -0.019961122423410416, -0.005459208972752094, 0.005535250995308161, -0.03639895096421242, 0.01615900546312332, 0.031126677989959717, -0.01093742810189724, -0.00023644426255486906, 0.017781242728233337, -0.047678567469120026, -0.02206496149301529, 0.006235474720597267, 0.009182116948068142, 0.007743648253381252, 0.006270327605307102, -0.002997336909174919, 0.05115117132663727, -0.007198678329586983, -0.020100533962249756, -0.028034288436174393, 0.03903508558869362, 0.03231801092624664, 0.0020040334202349186, -0.02475179359316826, 0.006172106135636568, -0.0036215181462466717, 0.0005338808405213058, 0.04577751085162163, -0.02846519649028778, -0.012369559146463871, -0.01489163190126419, -0.024688424542546272, 0.010056603699922562, 0.022609932348132133, -0.007978112436830997, 0.04174726456403732, -0.007357099559158087, 0.018022043630480766, -0.004366099834442139, 0.00833931379020214, 0.003250811481848359, 0.02563895471394062, 0.04420596733689308, 0.0016539216740056872, 0.009220138192176819, -0.012876508757472038, 0.021456623449921608, -0.04859107732772827, -0.014333987608551979, -0.015284516848623753, -0.0009948877850547433, 0.015474623069167137, 0.024967245757579803, 0.04007432982325554, -0.01579146645963192, -0.007585227023810148, -0.024485643953084946, 0.011247934773564339, -0.012585013173520565, -0.018731771036982536, -0.011647157371044159, 0.00004777401773026213, -0.006102400366216898, 0.014828262850642204, 0.0023192923981696367, -0.003314180066809058, 0.01688140630722046, 0.04478896036744118, -0.02139325439929962, 0.01941615343093872, -0.020708873867988586, -0.005788725800812244, 0.005861599929630756, 0.0044072894379496574, 0.04083475470542908, -0.015677403658628464, 0.03449789062142372, -0.01256600208580494, -0.09900717437267303, -0.002377908444032073, 0.0465632788836956, 0.02291410230100155, -0.01072197500616312, 0.030036738142371178, 0.03992224484682083, 0.00897933728992939, 0.025702321901917458, 0.02572767063975334, 0.031278762966394424, -0.03361073136329651, -0.012616697698831558, 0.034903451800346375, 0.002518903696909547, -0.02040470391511917, -0.022115657106041908, -0.015094411559402943, 0.0334586463868618, 0.02790755219757557, 0.017324987798929214, 0.003732413286343217, -0.006888171657919884, -0.0037862765602767467, 0.024168800562620163, -0.004670269321650267, -0.012299854308366776, -0.0026598989497870207, 0.028820060193538666, -0.010379783809185028, -0.010284731164574623, -0.01053820550441742, 0.006856487598270178, 0.03916182368993759, -0.04149378836154938, -0.057538729161024094, 0.018136106431484222, 0.021621381863951683, -0.02291410230100155, -0.021672077476978302, 0.010715638287365437, 0.0001757489808369428, 0.013129983097314835, -0.0022194867487996817, 0.024967245757579803, 0.0008887452422641218, 0.0064287493005394936, 0.012299854308366776, 0.02960583195090294, 0.033864203840494156, 0.03130410984158516, 0.009448264725506306, 0.0004301146836951375, 0.028769364580512047, 0.022685974836349487, 0.012762445025146008, 0.002279686974361539, -0.03307843208312988, -0.0008142871083691716, -0.019124656915664673, 0.007547205779701471, -0.0033490329515188932, 0.033636078238487244, -0.03310377895832062, -0.03120272047817707, -0.030138127505779266, -0.029073534533381462, 0.010031256824731827, 0.00467660604044795, -0.007883059792220592, 0.047678567469120026, 0.016374457627534866, -0.017147555947303772, 0.03138015419244766, -0.009575001895427704, -0.01612098328769207, -0.006932529620826244, -0.0019802702590823174, -0.051176518201828, 0.01332008931785822, -0.03239405155181885, -0.04732370376586914, 0.0008808241691440344, -0.01065226923674345, 0.02300281822681427, -0.010829701088368893, 0.032216619700193405, -0.016805365681648254, -0.05378730595111847, -0.00536098750308156, 0.010893070138990879, 0.0023224607575684786, 0.033813510090112686, 0.013307415880262852, -0.016387131065130234, -0.0008237924193963408, 0.0199864711612463, -0.03290100023150444, 0.010177004151046276, -0.014536767266690731, -0.03520761802792549, 0.0028151520527899265, -0.03480206057429314, -0.01951754279434681, -0.013370783999562263, -0.06417976319789886, 0.014321314170956612, 0.002975157927721739, 0.023078860715031624, 0.02172277122735977, 0.04884455353021622, 0.03738750144839287, -0.00909340102225542, -0.009042705409228802, 0.051024433225393295, -0.01307928841561079, -0.02371254749596119, -0.003253979841247201, -0.012027368880808353, -0.012642044574022293, -0.0037102343048900366, -0.01620969921350479, 0.002330381888896227, 0.00652697030454874, 0.016247721388936043, -0.014524093829095364, 0.009714413434267044, 0.004074603784829378, 0.0009053795365616679, 0.013028593733906746, 0.007807017304003239, -0.014207250438630581, 0.014131207950413227, 0.007604237645864487, -0.005370492581278086, -0.009803129360079765, -0.006729749962687492, 0.039288561791181564, 0.005592282861471176, 0.012521644122898579, 0.006270327605307102, -0.029250966385006905, 0.046360500156879425, 0.020582135766744614, 0.0004491252766456455, 0.00796543899923563, -0.013041267171502113, -0.02210298366844654, -0.004667100962251425, -0.024244843050837517, -0.01397912297397852, -0.013345437124371529, 0.001265788683667779, 0.0020832442678511143, -0.001758479862473905, 0.001548571279272437, 0.02083561010658741, 0.009606686420738697, -0.020480746403336525, 0.007186004426330328, 0.017844609916210175, 0.015626708045601845, 0.008117523044347763, -0.025233395397663116, -0.023078860715031624, 0.03629755973815918, -0.04506777971982956, -0.01658991165459156, 0.01532253809273243, -0.029631178826093674, -0.024992594495415688, -0.05322966352105141, 0.03158293291926384, 0.04798273742198944, -0.05155672878026962, -0.002325629349797964, 0.006454096641391516, -0.005303955636918545, -0.0022099814377725124, 0.02742595039308071, -0.006672718562185764, -0.00909340102225542, 0.019948448985815048, 0.0249292254447937, 0.022559238597750664, 0.009929866530001163, -0.032495442777872086, -0.0005786349647678435, 0.008592788130044937, 0.01053820550441742, -0.035283662378787994, 0.05153138190507889, 0.012540655210614204, 0.013991797342896461, 0.010126309469342232, 0.011235260404646397, -0.005665156990289688, 0.013611584901809692, -0.017096860334277153, 0.0020911653991788626, -0.03026486560702324, 0.014397356659173965, 0.007135309278964996, -0.016387131065130234, 0.006485780701041222, 0.02489120326936245, 0.01209073793143034, -0.01979636400938034, -0.0642811506986618, -0.0101389829069376, 0.003741918597370386, -0.009467275813221931, 0.01588018238544464, 0.018985245376825333, 0.07056732475757599, 0.016463173553347588, 0.02610788121819496, -0.006945203524082899, 0.0020008650608360767, -0.02276201732456684, -0.007027582731097937, -0.053381748497486115, -0.0183388851583004, 0.026412051171064377, 0.017426377162337303, 0.035182271152734756, 0.0014028233708813787, -0.019023267552256584, 0.006577665451914072, 0.0017774904845282435, 0.0320645347237587, -0.006343201268464327, -0.029352355748414993, -0.019352784380316734, -0.05566301941871643, -0.011064165271818638, -0.030087433755397797, 0.03059438243508339, 0.0019897755701094866, 0.018212148919701576, -0.0018788803135976195, 0.00860546249896288, 0.009473612532019615, -0.0167293231934309, 0.009251821786165237, -0.013446826487779617, 0.026183923706412315, -0.04448479041457176, 0.013472174294292927, 0.005399008747190237, -0.005861599929630756, -0.026741567999124527, -0.017654504626989365, -0.007927417755126953, -0.012445601634681225, 0.03097459301352501, -0.026690874248743057, 0.019403479993343353, 0.004781164228916168, -0.005896452348679304, -0.020670851692557335, -0.015385907143354416, -0.02563895471394062, -0.0321405753493309, 0.03439649939537048, 0.006507959682494402, -0.0037292446941137314, -0.02055678889155388, -0.004549868870526552, -0.031025288626551628, 0.00666004465892911, -0.02591777592897415, -0.017831936478614807, -0.011659830808639526, 0.007547205779701471, -0.012356885708868504, 0.004885722417384386, -0.00509167043492198, -0.0038242978043854237, 0.018326211720705032, -0.023218272253870964, 0.00111924868542701, -0.011045155115425587, 0.012648381292819977, -0.012971561402082443, -0.0014527261955663562, -0.02625996619462967, -0.037919797003269196, 0.025296762585639954, -0.0059249685145914555, -0.02544884756207466, 0.020392030477523804, 0.020113207399845123, 0.007198678329586983, 0.021431276574730873, 0.005256429314613342, 0.00432491023093462, -0.02210298366844654, 0.017147555947303772, -0.03368677198886871, -0.004530858248472214, -0.0219635721296072, 0.010924754664301872, -0.02856658585369587, -0.012027368880808353, -0.0007077485788613558, -0.0432681106030941, -0.02993534877896309, -0.010265721008181572, 0.0006728958105668426, -0.008681504055857658, 0.011577451601624489, -0.031329456716775894, -0.0014289629179984331, -0.009156769141554832, -0.019441500306129456, -0.001693527097813785, 0.0037387500051409006, -0.019999144598841667, -0.010899406857788563, -0.01884583570063114, -0.008763883262872696, 0.037539586424827576, 0.001872543478384614, -0.03323051705956459, 0.002414345508441329, -0.012432928197085857, 0.034193720668554306, 0.004328078590333462, -0.0036246865056455135, 0.028211720287799835, 0.02775546722114086, 0.0028500049374997616, 0.006805792450904846, -0.031278762966394424, 0.026310661807656288, -0.010639595799148083, 0.008117523044347763, 0.006010516081005335, 0.007464826572686434, 0.005969326477497816, -0.0075725531205534935, -0.03211522847414017, 0.003292001085355878, 0.006149927154183388, 0.021938225254416466, 0.00800979696214199, -0.0226226057857275, -0.0029070365708321333, 0.002414345508441329, 0.07208817452192307, 0.005994673818349838, -0.018934551626443863, -0.00009218157356372103, 0.05890749394893646, 0.00985382404178381, 0.008206239901483059, 0.02536013163626194, -0.0036151811946183443, 0.019783690571784973, 0.00273435702547431, -0.015766119584441185, -0.004644921515136957, 0.0071036252193152905, 0.013003245927393436, 0.013383458368480206, -0.009689065627753735, 0.027071084827184677, -0.004644921515136957, -0.0003475374251138419, -0.012629371136426926, 0.00604536896571517, -0.0015477791894227266, 0.018693750724196434, -0.0005477427039295435, -0.0057507045567035675, 0.020569462329149246, -0.003377548884600401, -0.021127106621861458, 0.0018170959083363414, -0.014714199118316174, 0.009777781553566456, 0.0033205170184373856, 0.03097459301352501, -0.0275273397564888, -0.017477072775363922, -0.03031555935740471, -0.0026012829039245844, 0.02539815381169319, 0.01329474151134491, 0.028313111513853073, 0.020189249888062477, 0.00403975136578083, 0.005148702301084995, -0.013370783999562263, 0.002289192285388708, 0.04035315290093422, 0.02055678889155388, -0.03198849409818649, -0.024625055491924286, -0.027780814096331596, -0.032723568379879, -0.01159646175801754, -0.003339527640491724, -0.00666004465892911, 0.007902069948613644, 0.019644280895590782, 0.023218272253870964, 0.0093532120808959, -0.010462163016200066, -0.020911652594804764, -0.015956224873661995, -0.016944775357842445, 0.017274292185902596, 0.005262766033411026, -0.008846262469887733, 0.005278608296066523, 0.007705627474933863, -0.0027993100229650736, -0.016323763877153397, -0.01837690733373165, -0.012794129550457, -0.0024476139806210995, 0.021596034988760948, 0.0017347167013213038, -0.03236870467662811, 0.01253431849181652, 0.017793916165828705, -0.019213372841477394, 0.03784375637769699, -0.0005021964898332953, -0.039567381143569946, -0.01721092499792576, 0.04605633020401001, -0.032723568379879, 0.022736670449376106, 0.03186175599694252, 0.017667178064584732, -0.03432045876979828, 0.04309067875146866, 0.003279327414929867, 0.006248148623853922, 0.007464826572686434, 0.023839283734560013, 0.03170967102050781, 0.017553115263581276, 0.007629584986716509, 0.0031177373602986336, 0.0009331033215858042, -0.0031811059452593327, -0.0011287539964541793, 0.0438511036336422, 0.02610788121819496, -0.013573563657701015, 0.011659830808639526, 0.010810690931975842, 0.012591349892318249, -0.014372008852660656, 0.012616697698831558, 0.008700515143573284, 0.014435377903282642, 0.022407153621315956, 0.004141141194850206, 0.018351560458540916, -0.0009006268810480833, 0.03662707656621933, -0.011526756919920444, -0.000521603156812489, 0.004828691016882658, -0.0399729423224926, 0.04146844148635864, 0.01430863980203867, -0.00985382404178381, -0.0006970550748519599, -0.005899620708078146, -0.024878529831767082, 0.03302773833274841, -0.008732199668884277, 0.03267287462949753, 0.014397356659173965, -0.010081951506435871, 0.016298415139317513, 0.015804139897227287, -0.008231586776673794, 0.014701525680720806, 0.015766119584441185, -0.009087063372135162, -0.01993577554821968, 0.05916096642613411, 0.0031034795101732016, 0.018123432993888855, 0.011026144027709961, -0.04600563645362854, -0.0262092724442482, 0.044712916016578674, -0.00886527355760336, 0.008085839450359344, -0.0045720478519797325, -0.008973000571131706, -0.015411254949867725, -0.029808610677719116, -0.004758985247462988, 0.011190902441740036, 0.015499970875680447, 0.0026899990625679493, 0.02894679643213749, -0.024764467030763626, 0.0007548789726570249, -0.03368677198886871, -0.015601360239088535, -0.03092389926314354, 0.0199864711612463, 0.03059438243508339, -0.015081737190485, 0.06174640730023384, 0.010088288225233555, 0.0058869472704827785, -0.010164330713450909, -0.02591777592897415, 0.028034288436174393, 0.015081737190485, -0.0451691709458828, 0.00576021010056138, -0.047019533812999725, -0.05419286713004112, -0.02681761048734188, 0.01885850913822651, 0.004720964003354311, -0.026893652975559235, 0.06032694876194, -0.021418601274490356, -0.043014638125896454, 0.008662493899464607, -0.0262092724442482, -0.0078513752669096, -0.0003946678480133414, 0.005497230216860771, 0.012889182195067406, 0.03680450841784477, 0.03629755973815918, -0.02729921229183674, -0.03492879867553711, 0.038654875010252, -0.014283292926847935, -0.009936203248798847, 0.03366142511367798, 0.03267287462949753, -0.018820486962795258, 0.004907901398837566, 0.018985245376825333, -0.01003759354352951, -0.036981940269470215, 0.0334586463868618, -0.0006487364880740643, 0.005874273367226124, -0.0275273397564888, 0.004480163101106882, 0.03170967102050781, -0.015499970875680447, -0.029960695654153824, 0.043724365532398224, -0.04179795831441879, -0.0032238797284662724, 0.021329885348677635, -0.022660627961158752, -0.00005886353028472513, -0.007116299122571945, -0.008472387678921223, -0.047298356890678406, -0.0016364952316507697, 0.03776771202683449, -0.005367324221879244, -0.0024998930748552084, -0.0070022353902459145, -0.01354821678251028, 0.002388997934758663, 0.0017901642713695765, 0.007832364179193974, 0.009657382033765316, 0.03723541647195816, -0.019999144598841667, -0.06605547666549683, 0.009112411178648472, -0.02530943788588047, -0.013282068073749542, 0.009460939094424248, -0.017603809013962746, -0.0013339100405573845, -0.03817327320575714, 0.013852385804057121, -0.001037661568261683, 0.008307629264891148, 0.03211522847414017, -0.018959898501634598, 0.0109817860648036, 0.007027582731097937, 0.0027391097974032164, -0.015360559336841106, -0.04489034786820412, 0.016336437314748764, 0.013700300827622414, 0.035334356129169464, -0.0014804500387981534, 0.00043051072861999273, 0.014460724778473377, -0.03295169398188591, -0.0010962776141241193, -0.01988508179783821, -0.0034821070730686188, 0.019251395016908646, -0.021710097789764404, 0.013852385804057121, 0.015677403658628464, 0.005227913148701191, 0.014080513268709183, 0.02879471331834793, -0.03297704458236694, 0.014587461948394775, -0.00008495359361404553, -0.011526756919920444, 0.0010653852950781584, -0.0015343133127316833, -0.027121780440211296, 0.0054908930324018, -0.017274292185902596, 0.01598157174885273, -0.0037672659382224083, -0.007395120803266764, 0.007357099559158087, 0.022369131445884705, -0.009587676264345646, -0.019859733060002327, -0.002555340528488159, -0.031278762966394424, -0.038528136909008026, 0.05429425463080406, 0.008992010727524757, 0.006856487598270178, -0.008567441254854202, 0.003024268662557006, 0.015094411559402943, 0.03130410984158516, -0.009872835129499435, -0.021748119965195656, 0.023154903203248978, -0.0044991737231612206, -0.02140592783689499, 0.002837331034243107, 0.030746467411518097, -0.03870556876063347, -0.003919350914657116, 0.02206496149301529, -0.002785051940008998, -0.01800936833024025, -0.00987917184829712, 0.01204004231840372, -0.025664301589131355, -0.008922304958105087, 0.0011944989673793316, -0.015614034608006477, 0.009030031971633434, 0.010595237836241722, -0.01086772233247757, 0.034624628722667694, 0.02856658585369587, -0.01202103216201067, -0.018465623259544373, 0.041696567088365555, -0.013421478681266308, 0.038528136909008026, 0.0001346583740087226, -0.010880396701395512, -0.020683525130152702, -0.012116084806621075, 0.04108823090791702, -0.002021459862589836, 0.0037007289938628674, 0.0013394547859206796, -0.0029577314853668213, -0.0004934833268634975, 0.0007948804413899779, -0.04042919725179672, 0.05155672878026962, -0.007591563742607832, 0.004283720627427101, 0.00787038542330265, 0.013991797342896461, 0.020759567618370056, -0.0091694425791502, -0.015994247049093246, 0.01093742810189724, 0.008345650508999825, 0.018972571939229965, 0.001523223822005093, 0.006378054153174162, 0.014435377903282642, 0.004115793388336897, -0.012287179939448833, -0.010075614787638187, -0.01631108857691288, -0.007997123524546623, -0.022280415520071983, 0.009226474910974503, 0.00942291785031557, 0.060783203691244125, 0.00959401298314333, 0.0005037807277403772, -0.02808498404920101, 0.023788589984178543, -0.013484847731888294, -0.022495869547128677, 0.0008028015145100653, -0.007629584986716509, 0.014536767266690731, -0.00529128173366189, 0.0011382593074813485, 0.04737440124154091, 0.012078063562512398, -0.00579823087900877, -0.018744444474577904, 0.012882845476269722, 0.012166779488325119, -0.017033491283655167, 0.056017883121967316, -0.02506863698363304, -0.04686744883656502, -0.006162600591778755, 0.02008786052465439, 0.028667975217103958, -0.006416075397282839, 0.021013041958212852, 0.007553542498499155, 0.0072683836333453655, -0.023154903203248978, 0.0024587034713476896, 0.001631742576137185, -0.029352355748414993, 0.009986898861825466, 0.003593002213165164 ]
15.143324
5.851208
2024-07-01
0
2024A&A...687L...8S
[ "GRGs", "supercluster environments", "such environments", "galaxy clusters", "underdense environments", "differing environments", "sparser environments", "dense environments", "supercluster", "superclusters" ]
[ "magnetic fields", "galaxies: active", "galaxies: clusters: general", "large-scale structure of Universe", "radio continuum: galaxies", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
20
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202450011", "10.48550/arXiv.2405.19154" ]
[ "Sankhyayan, Shishir", "Dabhade, Pratik" ]
[ "Tartu Observatory, University of Tartu, Observatooriumi 1, 61602, Tõravere, Estonia", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias, Calle Vía Láctea, s/n, 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain ; Universidad de La Laguna (ULL), Departamento de Astrofisica, La Laguna, 38206, Tenerife, Spain" ]
null
[ "1972MNRAS.156P...1J", "1973A&A....25..303S", "1974MNRAS.167P..31F", "1980MNRAS.193..353E", "1989Natur.342..251R", "1996Natur.380..603B", "1998A&A...329..431M", "2000AJ....120.1579Y", "2003ApJ...588..143R", "2004MNRAS.355..845K", "2006ApJ...637...19X", "2007A&A...475..169M", "2009ARep...53.1086K", "2009MNRAS.393....2S", "2012A&A...539A..80L", "2015ApJ...807..178W", "2015ApJS..219...12A", "2015JKAS...48..213K", "2016A&A...588L...4L", "2017ApJ...844...25B", "2017MNRAS.469.2886D", "2018A&A...620A..19H", "2018Galax...6..126O", "2019A&A...622A..16O", "2019A&A...624A..91K", "2019A&A...627A..23E", "2019AJ....157..126G", "2019Msngr.175....3D", "2019NewA...69....1P", "2020A&A...635A...5D", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020A&A...642A.153D", "2020A&A...643A.111D", "2021A&A...649A..51E", "2021MNRAS.502.5104L", "2022A&A...657A..43H", "2022A&A...659A...1S", "2022A&A...660A..81V", "2022MNRAS.515.2032S", "2023A&A...672A.163O", "2023A&A...672A.178S", "2023ApJ...958...62S", "2023Galax..11...67O", "2023JApA...44...13D", "2023MNRAS.518..240O", "2023MNRAS.519.5723O", "2024A&A...681A..91E", "2024A&A...683A.130L", "2024A&A...686A.137O", "2024AJ....167..226V", "2024AJ....168...58D" ]
29096784
2312.12501
AMICO-COSMOS galaxy cluster and group catalogue up to z = 2: Sample properties and X-ray counterparts
<BR /> Aims: We present the results of a new galaxy cluster search in the COSMOS field obtained using the Adaptive Matched Identifier of Clustered Objects (AMICO). Our aim was to produce a new cluster and group catalogue up to z = 2 by performing an innovative application of AMICO with respect to previous successful applications to wide-field surveys in terms of depth (down to r &lt; 26.7), small area covered (∼1.69 deg<SUP>2</SUP> of unmasked effective area), and redshift extent. This sample and the comparative analysis we performed with the X-rays, allowed for the calibration of mass-proxy scaling relations up to z = 2 and down to less than 10<SUP>13</SUP> M<SUB>⊙</SUB>, and constitutes the basis for the refinement of the cluster model for future applications of AMICO, such as the analysis of upcoming Euclid data. <BR /> Methods: The AMICO algorithm is based on an optimal linear matched filter and detects clusters in photometric galaxy catalogues using galaxy location, photometric redshift and, in the simplest case, one galaxy property. We chose to use a single magnitude as the galaxy property, avoiding the explicit use of galaxy colour for the selection of clusters. We used three different magnitudes by performing three independent runs in the r-, Y-, and H-bands using both COSMOS2020 and COSMOS2015 galaxy catalogues. We created a composite visibility mask and cluster models for the signal to detect, and we estimated the noise directly from the data. <BR /> Results: We performed a matching of the catalogues resulting from the three runs and merged them to produce a final catalogue that contains 1269 and 666 candidate clusters and groups with S/N &gt; 3.0 and &gt; 3.5, respectively. A total of 490 candidates are detected in all three runs. Most of the detections unmatched between runs have S/N &lt; 3.5, which can be set as a threshold for selecting a more robust sample. We assigned X-ray properties to our detections by matching the catalogue with a public X-ray selected group sample and by estimating, for unmatched detections, the X-ray properties at the location of AMICO candidates using Chandra+XMM-Newton data. There are in total 622 candidate clusters and groups with an X-ray flux estimate. This large sample of candidates with X-ray properties allowed the calibration of the scaling relations between two AMICO mass-proxies (richness and cluster amplitude) and X-ray mass and the study of their redshift dependence for the selection of the most stable photometric bands. <P />The AMICO-COSMOS galaxy cluster and group catalogue with members is available at the CDS via anonymous ftp to https://cdsarc.cds.unistra.fr ( ftp://130.79.128.5 ) or via <A href="https://cdsarc.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/cat/J/A+A/687/A56">https://cdsarc.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/cat/J/A+A/687/A56</A>
[ 0.02199280820786953, 0.005004387814551592, -0.000008774427442403976, -0.006678538862615824, 0.016319964081048965, 0.013826804235577583, 0.004679192788898945, -0.006847158540040255, 0.0025774703826755285, -0.015320291742682457, -0.03880658745765686, -0.05848689749836922, -0.03018290176987648, -0.0204752329736948, 0.03239904344081879, 0.044226501137018204, -0.04743027314543724, 0.02832808531820774, -0.0035379996988922358, 0.03584370017051697, -0.01751234568655491, -0.02345016412436962, -0.02669006772339344, 0.0022191538009792566, -0.07395172119140625, -0.0477675125002861, -0.032543573528528214, -0.024052375927567482, 0.0660025104880333, -0.007304840255528688, 0.008196115493774414, -0.03936062380671501, -0.025991501286625862, 0.011797347106039524, -0.08055197447538376, 0.06542439013719559, -0.015525043942034245, 0.014308574609458447, -0.05998038500547409, -0.02924344874918461, 0.0035410106647759676, 0.0015762917464599013, 0.02984566241502762, -0.005359692964702845, -0.03606049716472626, -0.04263665899634361, -0.022318003699183464, -0.05164576321840286, 0.013200502842664719, 0.006883291527628899, -0.04393744096159935, 0.029387980699539185, -0.0010358059080317616, -0.03410932794213295, -0.019644178450107574, -0.03189318627119064, 0.003000524826347828, 0.02229391410946846, 0.008328601717948914, 0.01511553954333067, -0.020643852651119232, -0.003176672151312232, 0.07183193415403366, -0.015500955283641815, -0.023100879043340683, 0.025581996887922287, 0.003703608177602291, 0.00888263713568449, 0.01261033397167921, 0.018644506111741066, 0.002633175114169717, 0.044780537486076355, -0.030592406168580055, -0.007581857964396477, 0.010701320134103298, -0.021197887137532234, -0.03842117264866829, -0.003405513009056449, -0.058535076677799225, 0.0027777061332017183, -0.002018918050453067, 0.027412723749876022, 0.011761214584112167, -0.06075121834874153, 0.007202464155852795, -0.018126603215932846, -0.02358265034854412, -0.013200502842664719, -0.07597515732049942, 0.01784958504140377, -0.029291626065969467, 0.02281181700527668, 0.020210258662700653, 0.028424439951777458, -0.012598290108144283, -0.052368417382240295, 0.0005544120795093477, -0.034952424466609955, 0.05535539239645004, 0.06200382113456726, 0.04759889468550682, -0.010701320134103298, 0.02251071110367775, -0.06585798412561417, 0.01659698225557804, 0.01332094520330429, -0.00022451243421528488, -0.014019511640071869, 0.01983688771724701, 0.015970680862665176, 0.002947831293568015, -0.00683511421084404, -0.02587105892598629, 0.04441921040415764, -0.012790998443961143, 0.027268191799521446, -0.0007478729239664972, 0.01136375404894352, -0.03760216385126114, -0.005115796811878681, -0.0272922795265913, 0.014308574609458447, 0.023341765627264977, 0.02953251078724861, 0.04769524559378624, -0.013405255042016506, 0.030905555933713913, -0.044997334480285645, -0.0665806382894516, -0.024642543867230415, 0.024076463654637337, -0.010701320134103298, 0.0281112901866436, 0.03341076150536537, -0.05217570811510086, -0.011610661633312702, -0.00398664828389883, -0.030375609174370766, -0.030688760802149773, -0.001568764098919928, 0.005477124825119972, -0.0040769800543785095, 0.031628210097551346, 0.03565099462866783, 0.01356183085590601, -0.030688760802149773, -0.04427468031644821, -0.027364546433091164, -0.02376331388950348, -0.01198403351008892, -0.009948554448783398, -0.03398888558149338, -0.028135377913713455, -0.05289836600422859, -0.020113904029130936, -0.02941206842660904, -0.005483146756887436, 0.03215815871953964, 0.0053054941818118095, -0.004609938245266676, -0.009659492410719395, -0.00012966392387170345, -0.019029922783374786, -0.010129217989742756, -0.02664189040660858, 0.05169393867254257, -0.028906211256980896, 0.016548804938793182, -0.08956107497215271, 0.012026187963783741, 0.02251071110367775, -0.00537775969132781, 0.006811026018112898, -0.04793613404035568, -0.019391249865293503, -0.0001949663710547611, 0.008792305365204811, -0.004808668512851, -0.05713794380426407, 0.010677231475710869, 0.004429274704307318, -0.010147284716367722, 0.059835854917764664, -0.018524063751101494, -0.07154287397861481, -0.06537621468305588, -0.008406889624893665, 0.003426590468734503, 0.006515941582620144, 0.023004526272416115, 0.03514513373374939, 0.0067508043721318245, 0.007033844478428364, 0.07086839526891708, -0.04403379559516907, -0.04437103122472763, 0.021077444776892662, 0.02936389297246933, -0.007196441758424044, 0.011315576732158661, -0.01703057624399662, 0.016741514205932617, 0.09963007271289825, -0.026328740641474724, -0.019680311903357506, -0.033651646226644516, 0.01987301930785179, 0.010448390617966652, -0.004025792237371206, -0.03129097446799278, 0.027653608471155167, -0.027605431154370308, 0.018512018024921417, -0.005052564665675163, -0.051308523863554, -0.03155594691634178, -0.052320241928100586, 0.008437000215053558, 0.01140590850263834, 0.035337843000888824, -0.01511553954333067, 0.06470173597335815, 0.03815619647502899, -0.010412258096039295, 0.013658184558153152, 0.015248025767505169, 0.0027957726269960403, -0.04791204258799553, 0.013224591501057148, -0.010243638418614864, 0.022968392819166183, 0.02493160590529442, -0.026328740641474724, -0.0021393606439232826, -0.022233692929148674, -0.005796297453343868, 0.0070278225466609, 0.00044639018597081304, -0.020210258662700653, -0.02707548439502716, -0.014453105628490448, -0.01660902611911297, 0.024690721184015274, 0.004917067009955645, -0.04152859002351761, -0.011978010646998882, 0.002979447366669774, -0.024088509380817413, 0.015175760723650455, -0.008135893382132053, 0.07375901192426682, 0.024389615282416344, -0.022920215502381325, -0.05834236741065979, -0.014838521368801594, 0.02048727683722973, -0.027099572122097015, 0.0327603705227375, -0.027605431154370308, 0.012279117479920387, -0.03454292193055153, -0.022221649065613747, -0.028183555230498314, 0.0206077191978693, -0.05819783732295036, 0.07929936796426773, 0.00877423956990242, 0.05863143131136894, -0.02854488231241703, 0.002012896118685603, -0.0074313050135970116, 0.01751234568655491, 0.07033844292163849, -0.007033844478428364, -0.02734045684337616, 0.05410278961062431, -0.009093412198126316, 0.050778575241565704, 0.04290163516998291, -0.033531203866004944, 0.009822089225053787, -0.0061726802960038185, -0.0016892066923901439, 0.015440734103322029, 0.005477124825119972, -0.0067869373597204685, -0.0013933696318417788, -0.01062905415892601, 0.013501608744263649, -0.026930952444672585, 0.06258194893598557, -0.02220960520207882, -0.015332335606217384, -0.003078812500461936, -0.051501233130693436, -0.0335552915930748, 0.011496241204440594, 0.007346995174884796, -0.02789449319243431, 0.038180287927389145, 0.028954386711120605, 0.03569917008280754, 0.04304616525769234, -0.006967601366341114, -0.015187804587185383, 0.007021800149232149, 0.014886698685586452, -0.0033934686798602343, -0.004420241340994835, 0.013080060482025146, 0.006425609812140465, 0.010984360240399837, -0.01522393710911274, 0.0031826943159103394, -0.01416404265910387, -0.05222388729453087, 0.011303532868623734, -0.015007141046226025, 0.049911390990018845, 0.020174125209450722, -0.01356183085590601, -0.041624944657087326, -0.021270154044032097, 0.011122869327664375, -0.011195134371519089, -0.050730399787425995, -0.006588207092136145, -0.052320241928100586, 0.020679984241724014, -0.05453638359904289, 0.04480462521314621, -0.0034898226149380207, 0.034302037209272385, -0.011478174477815628, -0.00443228567019105, -0.04049278423190117, 0.03596414253115654, 0.03345893695950508, -0.013116193003952503, -0.02608785405755043, -0.01353774219751358, 0.009665514342486858, -0.03565099462866783, 0.0017117896350100636, 0.06128116697072983, 0.021703746169805527, 0.024594366550445557, 0.009828111156821251, 0.024028288200497627, -0.039432886987924576, 0.00806362833827734, -0.013766583055257797, 0.022534800693392754, 0.011767236515879631, 0.04918873310089111, -0.025413377210497856, -0.021053357049822807, -0.015428690239787102, -0.002434444846585393, 0.04104682058095932, -0.017042620107531548, 0.01940329372882843, 0.042757101356983185, 0.0027370566967874765, 0.008756172843277454, 0.02142672799527645, -0.05140487849712372, 0.009418606758117676, 0.005206129048019648, -0.02526884526014328, 0.021113578230142593, 0.018704727292060852, -0.006359366234391928, -0.020728161558508873, -0.056511640548706055, 0.02316110022366047, 0.06051033362746239, 0.01261033397167921, 0.01388702541589737, 0.019656222313642502, 0.08956107497215271, -0.010075018741190434, -0.008370757102966309, -0.0319172739982605, 0.018463842570781708, -0.0018051326042041183, -0.0016967343399301171, 0.016223611310124397, -0.05309107154607773, 0.017319638282060623, -0.0545845590531826, -0.019740533083677292, 0.0043359315022826195, -0.004814690910279751, -0.005471102427691221, -0.014609680511057377, 0.059402260929346085, 0.04791204258799553, 0.020981092005968094, 0.06619521975517273, -0.023341765627264977, -0.03488016128540039, -0.010225571691989899, -0.02526884526014328, -0.05877596139907837, -0.008455066941678524, -0.051115814596414566, 0.05251294746994972, 0.02962886542081833, -0.0313873253762722, 0.00440819701179862, -0.047285743057727814, 0.013682273216545582, -0.031194617971777916, -0.013284812681376934, 0.04278119280934334, -0.03721674531698227, 0.06195564568042755, -0.0283762626349926, 0.02139059640467167, -0.003468745155259967, 0.005477124825119972, 0.011875635012984276, 0.00007678211841266602, -0.0363013818860054, 0.023438118398189545, 0.03225451335310936, -0.02608785405755043, -0.01940329372882843, -0.02979748509824276, -0.0365663580596447, 0.028833944350481033, 0.046370379626750946, 0.03596414253115654, -0.02375127002596855, 0.0015913471579551697, 0.036494091153144836, 0.004381097387522459, 0.011911767534911633, -0.0020821504294872284, 0.009936509653925896, 0.009129544720053673, -0.01560935378074646, -0.06248559057712555, 0.013899069279432297, -0.0015582253690809011, 0.014778300188481808, 0.04593678563833237, 0.012887352146208286, 0.009689603000879288, -0.009370429441332817, -0.0313873253762722, -0.006031160242855549, 0.047020770609378815, -0.03731309995055199, -0.04690032824873924, -0.01020148303359747, -0.042323511093854904, 0.02388375625014305, -0.021763967350125313, -0.03374800086021423, 0.0060432045720517635, -0.02143877185881138, 0.04328704997897148, -0.00879832822829485, 0.020679984241724014, -0.020667940378189087, -0.006449698004871607, 0.022582976147532463, 0.014176087453961372, 0.02531702257692814, -0.055692631751298904, -0.006732738111168146, 0.01336912252008915, -0.004086013417690992, -0.027051394805312157, 0.007931141182780266, -0.028448529541492462, 0.03105008788406849, -0.0058535076677799225, 0.03769851475954056, -0.006949534639716148, 0.0215592160820961, 0.0461294949054718, 0.04634629189968109, 0.035602815449237823, -0.011460107751190662, 0.04022780805826187, 0.03189318627119064, 0.022221649065613747, 0.01958395726978779, -0.00414924556389451, 0.03543419763445854, -0.01168894860893488, 0.01988506317138672, -0.04841790348291397, -0.02979748509824276, -0.003444656729698181, -0.010990382172167301, 0.020932914689183235, 0.027099572122097015, 0.003209793707355857, 0.014681946486234665, 0.03651817888021469, 0.023956021293997765, -0.0018849257612600923, -0.05964314937591553, -0.010364080779254436, 0.014501282013952732, 0.010580877773463726, 0.004986321087926626, 0.06306371837854385, 0.054006434977054596, -0.024196907877922058, 0.00764207961037755, 0.042757101356983185, -0.0005051059415563941, 0.024124640971422195, 0.007756499573588371, 0.0060432045720517635, 0.010617010295391083, -0.007852854207158089, 0.005453036166727543, -0.013995423913002014, -0.009520983323454857, 0.010195461101830006, -0.048273369669914246, -0.1118670329451561, -0.038469348102808, 0.032832637429237366, -0.013441387563943863, -0.020716117694973946, -0.005076653324067593, 0.01280304230749607, -0.01616339012980461, -0.025292934849858284, -0.004519606474786997, 0.009514961391687393, -0.005498202051967382, -0.02030661329627037, 0.02789449319243431, -0.010773585177958012, -0.025630172342061996, -0.0021920541767030954, 0.003643386997282505, 0.02893029898405075, -0.014850565232336521, 0.0018954644910991192, 0.04699667915701866, 0.03601232171058655, -0.00307730701752007, -0.025172492489218712, 0.055644456297159195, 0.00968358013778925, -0.000813739956356585, 0.021763967350125313, 0.0032188270706683397, -0.004486484918743372, 0.0027355512138456106, -0.014236308634281158, -0.021318329498171806, -0.009394518099725246, -0.026111943647265434, 0.030255166813731194, 0.01244171429425478, -0.02505204826593399, 0.028641236945986748, -0.033483028411865234, -0.015802061185240746, 0.01811455935239792, 0.0141881313174963, 0.0043720644898712635, -0.0030953732784837484, -0.00985219981521368, -0.0006146333762444556, -0.0038902941159904003, -0.04605722799897194, -0.019824841991066933, 0.007346995174884796, -0.020210258662700653, -0.035723257809877396, 0.02000550739467144, 0.016633115708827972, 0.03543419763445854, -0.013610007241368294, 0.008051584474742413, -0.002216142835095525, 0.0028153443709015846, 0.021920543164014816, 0.006025138311088085, 0.014248352497816086, -0.0004377333680167794, -0.001975257648155093, -0.009454739280045033, -0.026834597811102867, 0.010689275339245796, 0.026280563324689865, 0.011134913191199303, 0.002871049102395773, -0.008870593272149563, 0.027268191799521446, 0.0035379996988922358, -0.004338942468166351, -0.027798138558864594, -0.02267933078110218, 0.026617802679538727, -0.0022899138275533915, -0.0005984489107504487, -0.012038231827318668, 0.03143550455570221, 0.007672190200537443, 0.0017855607438832521, -0.005579500924795866, -0.021486949175596237, 0.008707995526492596, 0.03507286682724953, -0.00272200140170753, -0.028087200596928596, -0.011213201098144054, -0.021354462951421738, -0.007702300790697336, -0.028858033940196037, -0.012188785709440708, 0.00764207961037755, 0.03548237308859825, 0.01301983930170536, 0.006588207092136145, -0.03471153974533081, -0.007262685336172581, 0.023835578933358192, 0.010942204855382442, -0.018307266756892204, 0.017488257959485054, 0.0032639929559081793, -0.007178375497460365, 0.000640980142634362, -0.00933429691940546, 0.05790877342224121, -0.008479154668748379, 0.017488257959485054, 0.008521310053765774, 0.06417178362607956, 0.037529896944761276, -0.05945044010877609, 0.017945939674973488, 0.0024178840685635805, 0.047117121517658234, 0.027268191799521446, -0.03991466015577316, -0.018524063751101494, -0.01129751093685627, -0.02099313586950302, -0.011159001849591732, 0.018620416522026062, 0.04109499603509903, 0.00860561989247799, 0.022956348955631256, 0.03449474275112152, -0.022113250568509102, 0.02815946750342846, -0.03514513373374939, -0.01962009072303772, -0.008286447264254093, -0.02284795045852661, -0.024606412276625633, 0.02281181700527668, -0.02777405083179474, 0.04333522543311119, -0.04726165533065796, 0.05468091368675232, 0.042323511093854904, -0.007648101542145014, -0.009822089225053787, 0.03584370017051697, 0.01875290460884571, 0.02190849930047989, 0.03394071012735367, -0.010056952014565468, -0.018644506111741066, 0.006792959291487932, -0.013742494396865368, 0.008099760860204697, -0.027003217488527298, -0.0015145649667829275, 0.012068342417478561, -0.0008890165481716394, 0.029484335333108902, 0.019945284351706505, 0.002788244979456067, 0.01686195656657219, 0.03553054854273796, -0.006184724625200033, 0.004889967385679483, -0.00761196855455637, 0.013224591501057148, -0.029893839731812477, -0.01616339012980461, -0.015753883868455887, -0.002216142835095525, -0.060654863715171814, 0.011959944851696491, 0.01336912252008915, 0.0033784133847802877, 0.016271786764264107, -0.03401297330856323, -0.005573478527367115, -0.0156936626881361, -0.010454412549734116, 0.03126688301563263, 0.007575836032629013, 0.0475025400519371, 0.011580550111830235, -0.04677988216280937, -0.02100517973303795, 0.007991362363100052, 0.013441387563943863, 0.01416404265910387, 0.02570243924856186, -0.021667612716555595, -0.04812883958220482, 0.0021995820570737123, 0.026328740641474724, -0.05410278961062431, 0.019078098237514496, 0.02734045684337616, -0.035337843000888824, 0.02582288160920143, 0.01880108192563057, -0.026714155450463295, 0.016657203435897827, 0.0033302363008260727, -0.023570606485009193, -0.018042292445898056, -0.04155267775058746, -0.016789689660072327, 0.03618093952536583, 0.010695298202335835, -0.0007565297419205308, 0.010906072333455086, 0.02832808531820774, 0.04971868172287941, 0.015476866625249386, 0.01172508206218481, 0.00019120253273285925, 0.004429274704307318, -0.01315232552587986, 0.0010501084616407752, -0.014501282013952732, -0.007154287304729223, 0.030158812180161476, -0.01459763664752245, 0.008382800966501236, 0.013465476222336292, 0.004167311824858189, 0.022932259365916252, -0.0016033913707360625, 0.021161755546927452, 0.023173145949840546, -0.007672190200537443, 0.02341403067111969, 0.03389253094792366, 0.038565702736377716, -0.007744455710053444, 0.04027598723769188, -0.016970355063676834, 0.010948226787149906, -0.03324214369058609, 0.0009688097052276134, 0.0010561305098235607, -0.0032248490024358034, 0.008147938176989555, 0.004420241340994835, 0.003643386997282505, -0.00004911797441309318, -0.0022853973787277937, -0.002691890811547637, 0.017440080642700195, -0.038180287927389145, -0.0071121323853731155, 0.007593902293592691, 0.022715464234352112, -0.006979645229876041, -0.012429670430719852, -0.012875308282673359, 0.012170718982815742, -0.0033603468909859657, 0.02311292476952076, -0.008406889624893665, 0.017789363861083984, -0.009081367403268814, -0.008003407157957554, 0.01871677115559578, -0.0011750676203519106, 0.02859305962920189, -0.011369775980710983, 0.02233004756271839, 0.004043858498334885, -0.12053889781236649, -0.036205027252435684, 0.027870405465364456, 0.019776666536927223, -0.02630465105175972, -0.018078425899147987, 0.012839174829423428, 0.03232678025960922, -0.021234020590782166, -0.015308246947824955, -0.011767236515879631, -0.05270565673708916, 0.025196580216288567, 0.0016440406907349825, -0.0014136943500488997, 0.0007301829173229635, -0.01803024858236313, 0.025991501286625862, -0.0037668405566364527, 0.0038360951002687216, -0.008629708550870419, -0.011044581420719624, 0.017283504828810692, 0.02346220798790455, 0.01586228236556053, -0.006425609812140465, -0.023534473031759262, 0.026449183002114296, 0.047622982412576675, -0.013284812681376934, 0.00890672579407692, 0.007503570523113012, -0.015440734103322029, 0.029942017048597336, 0.02431735023856163, -0.003387446515262127, -0.03851752728223801, 0.027099572122097015, -0.04405788332223892, 0.001279702060855925, -0.00812987145036459, -0.017957983538508415, 0.013031883165240288, 0.005934806540608406, 0.031796831637620926, -0.006082348525524139, 0.0037186634726822376, 0.0267382450401783, -0.01142999716103077, 0.04138405621051788, -0.008972969837486744, 0.009123522788286209, 0.002712968271225691, 0.02854488231241703, 0.008334623649716377, 0.02897847630083561, 0.004284743685275316, 0.0034536898601800203, -0.008738106116652489, -0.023474251851439476, -0.02522066794335842, 0.015597308985888958, 0.01612725667655468, -0.02664189040660858, -0.035554639995098114, -0.01506736222654581, -0.06884495913982391, 0.06089574843645096, 0.011134913191199303, -0.00440819701179862, -0.00367650855332613, 0.012562157586216927, -0.0077083227224648, 0.005606600549072027, 0.012586246244609356, -0.0015717751812189817, -0.002225175965577364, -0.003492833813652396, -0.03916791453957558, 0.005733064841479063, -0.02013799361884594, -0.019764620810747147, 0.014838521368801594, -0.023474251851439476, -0.05044133588671684, 0.012038231827318668, -0.015464822761714458, -0.0028544883243739605, 0.0018231989815831184, 0.008274402469396591, 0.033699825406074524, 0.004492506850510836, 0.0297493077814579, 0.011568506248295307, -0.001559730968438089, 0.013658184558153152, 0.0349283367395401, 0.00019760105351451784, -0.015007141046226025, 0.01166485995054245, 0.022920215502381325, -0.00391438277438283, 0.007967274636030197, -0.052368417382240295, 0.010177395306527615, -0.027412723749876022, -0.011707015335559845, -0.008123849518597126, 0.002541337627917528, 0.035988230258226395, 0.015681618824601173, 0.052320241928100586, -0.026617802679538727, 0.028785767033696175, 0.032712195068597794, 0.006594229489564896, -0.049140557646751404, -0.01183347962796688, 0.009816067293286324, -0.000983112258836627, 0.038830675184726715, -0.0016003802884370089, -0.0073409732431173325, -0.02531702257692814, 0.01724737137556076, -0.0039173937402665615, 0.007346995174884796, 0.003026118967682123, -0.0026286584325134754, 0.023727180436253548, -0.003956537693738937, 0.03208589181303978, 0.004390130750834942, 0.0027250126004219055, 0.007780588231980801, -0.0011359237832948565, 0.010213527828454971, 0.027268191799521446, -0.0073409732431173325, 0.011411931365728378, -0.021149709820747375, 0.0035109000746160746, 0.013911114074289799, -0.015597308985888958, 0.005320549476891756, -0.004700270481407642, -0.04261257126927376, 0.014272441156208515, -0.013405255042016506, 0.03410932794213295, 0.00024935370311141014, 0.02478707581758499, 0.03242313116788864, 0.004317865241318941, -0.013899069279432297, 0.008141916245222092, -0.013405255042016506, -0.026328740641474724, 0.00812987145036459, 0.02608785405755043, 0.05140487849712372, -0.00325495982542634, -0.01006899680942297, -0.012550112791359425, 0.014031556434929371, -0.0012932517565786839, -0.026834597811102867, -0.009484849870204926, 0.026280563324689865, -0.018475886434316635, 0.001112587982788682, -0.01114695705473423, 0.035602815449237823, 0.026930952444672585, -0.004004714544862509, 0.008894681930541992, -0.009647447615861893, -0.004420241340994835, 0.021221976727247238, 0.02251071110367775, -0.04834563657641411, -0.0073409732431173325, -0.011321598663926125, -0.0008423450635746121, 0.0013391704997047782, -0.03237495571374893, -0.047622982412576675, -0.021956676617264748, 0.005130852572619915, 0.006606273353099823, 0.023943977430462837, 0.025341110303997993, -0.016753558069467545, 0.012405581772327423, -0.013116193003952503, 0.046033140271902084, -0.018909478560090065, 0.03136323764920235, -0.0191021878272295, 0.006829092279076576, -0.007961251772940159, 0.015452777966856956, -0.015934549272060394, -0.020595675334334373, -0.013357077725231647, -0.022691374644637108, 0.004480462521314621, -0.005516268312931061, -0.05627075582742691, -0.04933326691389084, -0.03531375527381897, -0.03268810734152794, -0.002738562412559986, -0.008954903110861778, 0.03733718767762184, -0.02695504203438759, 0.009328274987637997, -0.012899396009743214, -0.0152841592207551, -0.02936389297246933, 0.03292899206280708, -0.02233004756271839, -0.025341110303997993, 0.05169393867254257, -0.006293123122304678, 0.031628210097551346, 0.0003982131602242589, -0.040685489773750305, -0.025124315172433853, 0.005227206274867058, 0.030688760802149773, 0.016018858179450035, -0.003276037285104394, -0.013429343700408936, -0.025292934849858284, -0.017391903325915337, -0.018391575664281845, -0.01407973375171423, 0.0005047295126132667, -0.006184724625200033, 0.03242313116788864, 0.01577797345817089, -0.0038451282307505608, 0.011809390969574451, -0.0015973692061379552, 0.01101447083055973, 0.03133914992213249, 4.381332701086649e-7, 0.029604777693748474, -0.003652420127764344, 0.000365279644029215, -0.03170047700405121, 0.019933240488171577, 0.001150979078374803, -0.004417230375111103, 0.014693990349769592, 0.007274729665368795, 0.037626251578330994, 0.03232678025960922, 0.03967377543449402, -0.006534007843583822, 0.005311516113579273, 0.0047544692642986774, -0.01871677115559578, 0.043311137706041336, -0.014429016970098019, -0.03324214369058609, 0.0014355245511978865, -0.005751131568104029, -0.0009409573976881802, 0.019812798127532005, -0.03854161500930786, 0.0032128049060702324, -0.0154166454449296, -0.012200829572975636, -0.0036704866215586662, -0.01334503386169672, 0.0024148731026798487, 0.011381820775568485, -0.0010493556037545204, -0.024558234959840775, 0.022534800693392754, -0.01181541383266449, 0.0013572368770837784, -0.014693990349769592, 0.012754864990711212, -0.01803024858236313, -0.02493160590529442, 0.015151672065258026, -0.018813125789165497, -0.004838779103010893, 0.022619109600782394, -0.005227206274867058, -0.004188389517366886, 0.01285121962428093, 0.0006884044269099832, 0.03148368000984192, 0.0025398321449756622, 0.02389580011367798, -0.0008423450635746121, -0.0021529104560613632, 0.014862610027194023, 0.004161289893090725, 0.005106763914227486, -0.012971661984920502, 0.026111943647265434, -0.009081367403268814, -0.026665979996323586, -0.01915036514401436, -0.030086547136306763, 0.00014961222768761218, -0.0029433146119117737, -0.012513980269432068, -0.022366181015968323, 0.014525370672345161, -0.027629518881440163, -0.030640583485364914, 0.0141881313174963, -0.024811163544654846, -0.011165023781359196, -0.020981092005968094, 0.008726062253117561, 0.02254684455692768, 0.020932914689183235, -0.03777078166604042, 0.01356183085590601, -0.005850496701896191, 0.024811163544654846, -0.030929645523428917, -0.0014709045644849539, -0.004257644060999155, -0.014669901691377163, 0.028617149218916893, -0.023257454857230186, -0.00959324836730957, 0.040589138865470886, 0.010207505896687508, 0.03755398467183113, -0.0064376541413366795, -0.014031556434929371, -0.005531323608011007, 0.036927685141563416, -0.030809203162789345, 0.0026768355164676905, -0.003146561561152339, 0.013682273216545582, 0.013682273216545582, -0.02151103876531124, -0.007744455710053444, -0.05010409653186798, 0.06214835122227669, -0.018210912123322487, 0.01020148303359747, -0.005293449852615595, 0.01741599105298519, -0.01183347962796688, -0.001579302828758955, 0.03608458489179611, 0.025774704292416573, -0.02941206842660904, 0.00860561989247799, -0.03403706103563309, -0.003057735040783882, 0.003486811649054289, -0.00405289139598608, -0.02789449319243431, -0.014248352497816086, 0.024738898500800133, -0.022221649065613747, 0.007316884584724903, -0.026786422356963158, -0.008352690376341343, 0.030520141124725342, 0.010617010295391083, 0.03044787421822548, -0.008153960108757019, 0.026810510084033012, -0.014971008524298668, 0.0021995820570737123, 0.014007467776536942, 0.014103821478784084, -0.007232574746012688, 0.0008664335473440588, 0.006780915427953005, -0.034133415669202805, -0.028906211256980896, -0.035723257809877396, 0.012026187963783741, 0.02423303946852684, -0.0056939213536679745, 0.01918649673461914, 0.0005675854627043009, 0.013706361874938011, -0.009153633378446102, -0.04591269791126251, -0.00019223759591113776, 0.014127910137176514, -0.020704073831439018, -0.018993789330124855, -0.020932914689183235, -0.019547825679183006, -0.008629708550870419, 0.001319598639383912, -0.012279117479920387, -0.028568971902132034, 0.03777078166604042, 0.007925119251012802, 0.06369001418352127, 0.06580980867147446, 0.012574201449751854, -0.0015333840856328607, -0.03989056870341301, -0.03596414253115654, -0.003547032829374075, 0.03618093952536583, -0.004227533470839262, -0.0033814243506640196, -0.010857895016670227, -0.0013391704997047782, -0.0004998365766368806, -0.01185756828635931, 0.026160120964050293, -0.015790017321705818, 0.010442368686199188, 0.03350711613893509, -0.03928835690021515, -0.005413892213255167, 0.023811491206288338, 0.013453432358801365, 0.023088835179805756, -0.011110824532806873, 0.017102841287851334, 0.004847812466323376, 0.03256766498088837, -0.023486295714974403, 0.005507235415279865, 0.027412723749876022, -0.005437980871647596, -0.040589138865470886, 0.0551145076751709, 0.003396479645743966, -0.013043927028775215, -0.0054349699057638645, 0.03280854970216751, 0.029821574687957764, 0.012706688605248928, -0.008123849518597126, -0.029869750142097473, 0.01828317902982235, -0.009328274987637997, 0.008629708550870419, 0.01712692901492119, -0.005344637669622898, -0.020174125209450722, -0.01591045968234539, -0.0026994184590876102, 0.003754796227440238, -0.009243965148925781, -0.004001703578978777, -0.009207832626998425, 0.028424439951777458, 0.00860561989247799, 0.009400540962815285, 0.0008009428856894374, -0.022691374644637108, 0.016103168949484825, 0.023088835179805756, -0.00803953967988491, -0.028882121667265892, -0.023173145949840546, 0.007292795926332474, 0.004369053058326244, 0.013357077725231647, -0.018993789330124855, -0.0010900050401687622, -0.022522754967212677, 0.009400540962815285, -0.02147490531206131, 0.006088370457291603, 0.038782499730587006, -0.03117053024470806, 0.00518505135551095, 0.03290490433573723, -0.005874584894627333, 0.03153185918927193, 0.013140281662344933, -0.003920404706150293, -0.015235981903970242, 0.03885476291179657, 0.013007794506847858, -0.01489874254912138, -0.01721123978495598, -0.024124640971422195, -0.007949207909405231, 0.01168894860893488, -0.029604777693748474, -0.02880985662341118, -0.008304513059556484, 0.016789689660072327, -0.018259089440107346, -0.035554639995098114, -0.02493160590529442, 0.013971335254609585, 0.014332662336528301, 0.0011035548523068428, -0.020969046279788017, -0.02393193356692791, 0.0005830171867273748, -0.0077083227224648, 0.015561176463961601, -0.008153960108757019, -0.00532657140865922, -0.007599924691021442, 0.008093738928437233, 0.05101945996284485, -0.01030385959893465, -0.014151998795568943, -0.006256990134716034, -0.021414684131741524, 0.02134241908788681, -0.010635077022016048, -0.00719041982665658, 0.022631153464317322, -0.0023802458308637142, -0.02635282836854458, -0.021149709820747375, 0.00667251693084836, 0.03497651591897011, -0.025148402899503708, 0.0033483027946203947, -0.01793389394879341, -0.06287100911140442, 0.028737591579556465, 0.02717183716595173, -0.0015115538844838738, -0.021161755546927452, 0.006570140831172466, 0.017693009227514267, 0.006238923873752356, -0.01539255678653717, 0.004200433846563101, 0.000531829078681767, 0.01470603421330452, 0.005173007026314735, 0.03832481801509857, 0.02048727683722973, -0.005073642358183861, -0.017957983538508415, -0.013296856544911861, 0.014742167666554451, -0.04408197104930878, -0.010827784426510334, 0.009960598312318325, 0.003908360376954079, 0.04372064396739006, 0.029267538338899612, 0.034302037209272385, 0.02276364155113697, 0.007437326945364475, 0.017524389550089836, 0.014019511640071869, -0.010851873084902763, -0.030471963807940483, 0.030688760802149773, -0.031025998294353485, 0.014344707131385803, 0.010960271582007408, 0.012020166032016277, 0.011032536625862122, 0.04415423795580864, 0.04579225555062294, -0.03314578905701637, 0.008274402469396591, -0.03488016128540039, -0.006091381423175335, 0.018620416522026062, -0.0010019313776865602, 0.0007497548358514905, -0.00693146837875247, 0.023293588310480118, 0.010508611798286438, -0.018620416522026062, 0.002830399665981531, 0.003495844779536128, 0.005675855092704296, 0.00985219981521368, -0.018247045576572418, -0.002429928397759795, -0.006823069881647825, 0.016548804938793182, -0.03748171776533127, -0.004357009194791317, 0.002046017674729228, -0.007389150094240904, 0.0019451470579952002, 0.03300125524401665, 0.011177067644894123, 0.0012247500708326697, -0.025413377210497856, -0.02832808531820774, -0.01172508206218481, 0.05699340999126434, -0.031122352927923203, -0.012477847747504711, 0.003176672151312232, -0.010490546002984047, 0.023606738075613976, -0.04971868172287941, -0.004317865241318941, 0.03027925454080105, -0.0016244688304141164, 0.023570606485009193, 0.011875635012984276, -0.004064935725182295, 0.007750477641820908, 0.012327294796705246, -0.009388496167957783, 0.008135893382132053, -0.02199280820786953, -0.032712195068597794, -0.020764295011758804, -0.03420568257570267, -0.012983705848455429, -0.017283504828810692, 0.01509145088493824, 0.03902338445186615, -0.02224573865532875, -0.040420517325401306, 0.0029824585653841496, -0.01806638203561306, -0.005290438886731863, 0.006455720402300358, 0.024979783222079277, -0.0218241885304451, -0.02436552569270134, 0.01607907935976982, -0.002868038136512041, 0.02488342858850956, -0.029436158016324043, 0.017488257959485054, 0.04682806134223938, 0.031628210097551346, -0.023137012496590614, -0.020595675334334373, -0.007304840255528688, 0.011243311688303947, -0.023956021293997765, -0.010785629972815514, 0.010881983675062656, -0.016115212813019753, 0.03478380665183067, -0.007509592454880476, -0.014766255393624306, -0.0064316317439079285, 0.021679658442735672, 0.005200106650590897, -0.02237822487950325, -0.002682857681065798, -0.0070458888076245785, -0.01332094520330429, 0.020125949755311012, 0.025557907298207283, -0.018512018024921417, 0.002762650838121772, 0.012327294796705246, 0.028424439951777458, -0.013092104345560074, 0.06788142025470734, 0.01162270549684763, 0.007082021329551935, -0.0025187546852976084, 0.01511553954333067, -0.0019300917629152536, 0.0042425887659192085, 0.021318329498171806, -0.0026753300335258245, 0.00023392200819216669, 0.03509695827960968, 0.04160085320472717, 0.007443349342793226, 0.016223611310124397, -0.0409504659473896, -0.019234674051404, 0.016717424616217613, 0.001997840590775013, 0.0007904042140580714, -0.04282936826348305, 0.01798207126557827, 0.021679658442735672, -0.00764207961037755, 0.0175966564565897, -0.01604294590651989, 0.00188643136061728, -0.010936182923614979, -0.012887352146208286, 0.026160120964050293, -0.007569813635200262, 0.0037005972117185593, -0.03367573395371437, -0.014754211530089378, 0.007274729665368795, -0.0031616168562322855, 0.01871677115559578, 0.020162081345915794, 0.04205853492021561, 0.01707875356078148, 0.010936182923614979, 0.023727180436253548, -0.0004377333680167794, 0.0016741513973101974, -0.011357732117176056, -0.0009989202953875065, -0.015814105048775673, 0.017428036779165268, -0.02570243924856186, 0.040589138865470886, 0.005401847884058952, -0.008220203220844269, -0.025196580216288567, -0.0038481391966342926, 0.0045015402138233185, -0.00594082847237587, 0.012550112791359425, 0.0018924534088000655, -0.02777405083179474, -0.005582511890679598, 0.013236635364592075, 0.05704158917069435, -0.027870405465364456, -0.027870405465364456, 0.03536193072795868, 0.013585918582975864, 0.025292934849858284, 0.001719317282550037, 0.0349283367395401, 0.017319638282060623, -0.014669901691377163, 0.013826804235577583, -0.010677231475710869 ]
12.622607
4.878383
2024-07-01
1
2024A&A...687A..56T
[ "X-ray properties", "X-ray mass", "cluster models", "AMICO candidates", "photometric galaxy catalogues", "galaxy catalogues", "group catalogue", "clusters", "AMICO", "a public X-ray selected group sample" ]
[ "galaxies: clusters: general", "galaxies: evolution", "galaxies: groups: general", "galaxies: luminosity function", "mass function", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
22
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202348832", "10.48550/arXiv.2312.12501" ]
[ "Toni, G.", "Maturi, M.", "Finoguenov, A.", "Moscardini, L.", "Castignani, G." ]
[ "Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia \"A. Righi\", Alma Mater Studiorum Università di Bologna, Via Gobetti 93/2, 40129, Bologna, Italy ; INAF - Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio di Bologna, Via Gobetti 93/3, 40129, Bologna, Italy; Zentrum für Astronomie, Universität Heidelberg, Philosophenweg 12, 69120, Heidelberg, Germany", "Zentrum für Astronomie, Universität Heidelberg, Philosophenweg 12, 69120, Heidelberg, Germany; ITP, Universität Heidelberg, Philosophenweg 16, 69120, Heidelberg, Germany", "Department of Physics, University of Helsinki, Gustaf Hällströmin katu, 2, 00560, Helsinki, Finland", "Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia \"A. Righi\", Alma Mater Studiorum Università di Bologna, Via Gobetti 93/2, 40129, Bologna, Italy; INAF - Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio di Bologna, Via Gobetti 93/3, 40129, Bologna, Italy; INFN - Sezione di Bologna, Viale Berti Pichat 6/2, 40127, Bologna, Italy", "Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia \"A. Righi\", Alma Mater Studiorum Università di Bologna, Via Gobetti 93/2, 40129, Bologna, Italy; INAF - Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio di Bologna, Via Gobetti 93/3, 40129, Bologna, Italy" ]
[ "2024ApJ...966...18T" ]
[ "1970CoASP...2...66S", "1976ApJ...203..297S", "1980ApJ...236..351D", "1996A&AS..117..393B", "1996AJ....111..615P", "1997ApJ...490..493N", "1998ApJ...502..558V", "2001A&A...368..776R", "2002ARA&A..40..539R", "2002MNRAS.329..355A", "2002Sci...295...82K", "2004A&A...425..367B", "2004AJ....127.2484H", "2005A&A...442..851M", "2005astro.ph.10346T", "2006A&A...457..841I", "2006MNRAS.366..499D", "2007A&A...474L...5Z", "2007ApJ...660..239K", "2007ApJS..172....1S", "2007ApJS..172...29H", "2007ApJS..172...70L", "2007ApJS..172..182F", "2007ApJS..172..196K", "2007ApJS..172..295S", "2007ApJS..172..468Z", "2008ApJ...686.1503B", "2009A&A...497..635C", "2009ApJ...690.1236I", "2009ApJ...692.1060V", "2009ApJ...697.1842K", "2009ApJS..184..158E", "2009MNRAS.396..462K", "2010ApJ...708..645R", "2010ApJ...709...97L", "2010MNRAS.403.2063F", "2010SPIE.7735E..08B", "2011ARA&A..49..409A", "2011ApJ...741....8C", "2011ApJ...742..125G", "2011MNRAS.413.1145B", "2011MNRAS.417.1402F", "2011arXiv1110.3193L", "2012A&A...544A.156M", "2012ApJ...753...44S", "2012ApJ...753..121K", "2013A&A...556A..55I", "2013ApJ...767..118C", "2013ApJ...779...86S", "2013ApJ...779..138B", "2013MNRAS.429.3079M", "2014ApJ...785..104R", "2014ApJ...792..114C", "2014MNRAS.442.3275V", "2014MNRAS.443.2679B", "2015A&A...575A..40C", "2015ApJS..216...27B", "2015PASJ...67..104T", "2016A&A...592A..78I", "2016A&A...595A.111C", "2016ApJ...819...62C", "2016ApJ...825...72A", "2016ApJ...825..113D", "2016ApJ...826..130H", "2016ApJ...833L..20S", "2016ApJS..224...24L", "2016MNRAS.455.2149S", "2016MNRAS.462..830Z", "2016ascl.soft04008L", "2017A&A...602A...1S", "2017A&A...604A..54K", "2017A&A...604A.134D", "2017MNRAS.467.4015H", "2018A&A...616A...1G", "2018A&A...619A..49C", "2018A&A...620A...1M", "2018A&A...620A.186P", "2018ApJ...858...77H", "2018ApJS..234...21D", "2018ApJS..235...20H", "2018MNRAS.473.5221B", "2018MNRAS.474.5437L", "2018PASJ...70S...7C", "2019A&A...627A..23E", "2019ApJ...877...81M", "2019ApJS..241...10K", "2019MNRAS.482.1824S", "2019MNRAS.483.3545G", "2019MNRAS.484.1598B", "2019MNRAS.485..498M", "2019MNRAS.488.4779C", "2019PASJ...71..114A", "2019SSRv..215...25P", "2020A&A...633A.159R", "2020MNRAS.494.3728S", "2020MNRAS.498.4303R", "2020PASJ...72...78H", "2021A&A...645A...9P", "2021A&A...647A.152A", "2021A&A...653A..19G", "2021ApJS..256...44V", "2021MNRAS.506.2136S", "2021PhRvL.126n1301T", "2021essp.confE..77E", "2022A&A...659A..88L", "2022A&A...665A.100L", "2022A&A...667A..52C", "2022ApJS..258...11W", "2022MNRAS.511.1484I", "2022PASJ...74..247A", "2023A&A...672A.139C", "2023AJ....165..248G", "2023ApJS..269...20W", "2023yCat.2373....0M", "2024A&A...682A..72R", "2024A&A...683A.205E", "2024AJ....168...58D", "2024ApJ...966...18T" ]
29031740
2405.06018
Correcting for the overabundance of low-mass quiescent galaxies in semi-analytic models
We compare the L-GALAXIES semi-analytic model to deep observational data from the UKIDSS Ultra Deep Survey (UDS) across the redshift range 0.5 &lt; z &lt; 3. We find that the overabundance of low-mass, passive galaxies at high redshifts in the model can be attributed solely to the properties of 'orphan' galaxies, i.e. satellite galaxies where the simulation has lost track of the host dark matter sub-halo. We implement a simple model that boosts the star formation rates in orphan galaxies by matching them to non-orphaned satellite galaxies at a similar evolutionary stage. This straightforward change largely addresses the discrepancy in the low-mass passive fraction across all redshifts. We find that the orphan problem is somewhat alleviated by higher resolution simulations, but the preservation of a larger gas reservoir in orphans is still required to produce a better fit to the observed space density of low-mass passive galaxies. Our findings are also robust to the precise definition of the passive galaxy population. In general, considering the vastly different prescriptions used for orphans in semi-analytic models, we recommend that they are analysed separately from the resolved satellite galaxy population, particularly with JWST observations reigniting interest in the low-mass regime in which they dominate.
[ 0.010368558578193188, 0.031237399205565453, 0.01867971383035183, 0.015794331207871437, 0.0015493248356506228, 0.01120281033217907, 0.012043334543704987, -0.013473480939865112, 0.01844135671854019, 0.0030453328508883715, -0.036656901240348816, -0.026746239513158798, -0.03296862915158272, -0.002777180401608348, 0.0308359544724226, 0.018792619928717613, 0.026244433596730232, -0.0058460356667637825, -0.0523885078728199, 0.027599308639764786, 0.020172586664557457, 0.017839189618825912, 0.006987643428146839, 0.002747385762631893, -0.07005206495523453, -0.028427287936210632, 0.004124214872717857, -0.033018808811903, 0.017312293872237206, -0.01807754673063755, 0.024124305695295334, -0.009433945640921593, -0.05765746533870697, -0.010180381126701832, -0.06894809007644653, 0.09188061207532883, -0.0055010439828038216, 0.02995779551565647, -0.0046417019329965115, -0.02616916224360466, 0.008210794068872929, -0.01307203620672226, 0.004023853689432144, 0.00841778889298439, 0.0028728372417390347, 0.03590419143438339, -0.0014270097017288208, -0.042502935975790024, 0.007897165603935719, -0.0286531001329422, -0.03668199107050896, 0.015957418829202652, 0.02584298886358738, 0.0027567946817725897, -0.021427100524306297, -0.047194819897413254, -0.0001709275384200737, -0.002946539781987667, -0.040044087916612625, -0.00451625045388937, -0.03050978109240532, 0.00040007237112149596, 0.025767719373106956, 0.012752135284245014, -0.024161940440535545, -0.009289676323533058, -0.03838812932372093, 0.01839117519557476, -0.008317427709698677, 0.03023378923535347, -0.05053182691335678, -0.024713926017284393, -0.009220678359270096, -0.010525372810661793, 0.028502559289336205, -0.0018237497424706817, 0.00638547632843256, 0.011183992959558964, -0.036907803267240524, 0.01741265505552292, 0.0004237905377522111, 0.0008342518121935427, 0.008543240837752819, -0.028101114556193352, -0.011347079649567604, -0.007357724942266941, 0.026595698669552803, 0.004742063116282225, -0.041649866849184036, 0.022995242848992348, 0.05289031192660332, 0.00608125701546669, -0.032291192561388016, -0.020975474268198013, -0.026595698669552803, -0.012783498503267765, 0.03838812932372093, -0.050958361476659775, 0.08962248265743256, 0.039140839129686356, 0.013360574841499329, 0.01750047132372856, -0.008047707378864288, -0.05800873041152954, -0.002392985625192523, -0.06347841024398804, 0.027950573712587357, -0.03653144836425781, 0.03239155188202858, 0.010343468748033047, 0.02118874154984951, -0.013059491291642189, -0.015455612912774086, -0.02275688387453556, -0.034172963351011276, -0.021063290536403656, -0.0938878282904625, 0.04491160437464714, -0.00233339611440897, 0.012532595545053482, -0.009571942500770092, -0.011786159127950668, 0.05690475553274155, 0.0311119481921196, 0.026369884610176086, -0.008656146936118603, 0.02433757297694683, -0.04646719992160797, -0.036556538194417953, 0.0075584473088383675, 0.05130962282419205, -0.02308305911719799, -0.01462763361632824, -0.011466258205473423, -0.03625545650720596, -0.006554835941642523, -0.016421588137745857, -0.03181447461247444, 0.011723433621227741, 0.028552738949656487, -0.013962741009891033, -0.0049835569225251675, -0.007690171245485544, 0.02304542250931263, 0.02273179404437542, 0.010563008487224579, -0.009026228450238705, 0.008875686675310135, -0.019470058381557465, 0.04370727017521858, 0.002407098887488246, -0.021966541185975075, -0.01834099553525448, -0.03261736407876015, -0.0017751373816281557, -0.022016720846295357, 0.022543616592884064, -0.026068801060318947, 0.017651012167334557, -0.035703469067811966, -0.014339095912873745, 0.0005523781874217093, -0.0012160945916548371, 0.014389276504516602, -0.06227407604455948, 0.013310394249856472, -0.012984219938516617, -0.015769241377711296, -0.07456831634044647, -0.006441929843276739, 0.0009424536838196218, 0.02332141622900963, -0.02117619663476944, -0.03086104616522789, -0.03959246352314949, 0.004591521341353655, -0.02337159588932991, -0.044660698622465134, -0.02335905097424984, -0.007382815238088369, 0.005874262191355228, 0.006661469582468271, -0.026595698669552803, -0.039416830986738205, -0.04363199695944786, 0.0026156618259847164, 0.009371220134198666, 0.022894881665706635, 0.002852451289072633, -0.022681614384055138, -0.0027662033680826426, -0.012262875214219093, 0.0410727895796299, 0.03389696776866913, 0.008424061350524426, -0.022982697933912277, -0.010161563754081726, 0.050356194376945496, -0.0009542147745378315, 0.04117315262556076, 0.01589469239115715, 0.020486215129494667, 0.040320079773664474, -0.08590912073850632, -0.03495076298713684, -0.044986873865127563, 0.03700816258788109, -0.02862801030278206, 0.0165094044059515, -0.0005414012121036649, 0.05013038218021393, 0.01965823583304882, -0.009904388338327408, -0.004215167369693518, 0.010632006451487541, 0.004287301562726498, -0.05143507570028305, 0.02338414266705513, 0.0687473714351654, 0.040018998086452484, -0.018491536378860474, 0.013034400530159473, 0.020185131579637527, -0.0070566413924098015, 0.02682151086628437, 0.007583537604659796, 0.04967875778675079, -0.039090659469366074, -0.025742627680301666, 0.003992490936070681, 0.009107772260904312, 0.015530884265899658, -0.01810263842344284, -0.013184942305088043, 0.004964739549905062, -0.008066525682806969, 0.0034875490237027407, 0.015342706814408302, -0.006517200265079737, -0.034800220280885696, -0.026369884610176086, 0.01339820958673954, -0.01806500181555748, -0.0015587337547913194, 0.009628395549952984, 0.0013133194297552109, -0.019783686846494675, 0.005005510989576578, 0.015016533434391022, -0.016772853210568428, 0.04767153412103653, -0.027649490162730217, -0.009546851739287376, -0.02146473526954651, -0.031965017318725586, 0.008543240837752819, 0.00747690349817276, 0.04636684060096741, -0.028552738949656487, -0.035653289407491684, -0.05153543874621391, -0.004923967644572258, 0.004952194169163704, 0.011027178727090359, -0.04962857440114021, 0.04275383800268173, 0.0567542165517807, -0.016045235097408295, 0.008380154147744179, 0.044083625078201294, -0.008342518471181393, -0.005259550176560879, 0.04885077849030495, -0.03841321915388107, -0.037886325269937515, 0.04882568493485451, -0.00841778889298439, 0.015330161899328232, 0.005657858215272427, -0.029731983318924904, -0.013523661531507969, -0.011252990923821926, 0.02933053858578205, 0.06965062022209167, -0.006015394814312458, 0.018930617719888687, -0.014364185743033886, 0.0036380907986313105, 0.005582587327808142, -0.031337760388851166, 0.04947803542017937, -0.03776087239384651, 0.005949533078819513, -0.005394410341978073, -0.03271772712469101, 0.0023773040156811476, 0.024124305695295334, 0.022104537114501, -0.01840372197329998, 0.019871503114700317, 0.06101956218481064, 0.0375099703669548, -0.02526591345667839, -0.017864279448986053, -0.012451051734387875, -0.03457440808415413, 0.03512639179825783, 0.009233223274350166, 0.011748524382710457, 0.04987948015332222, -0.016283592209219933, 0.0010451669804751873, -0.006225525867193937, 0.07185856252908707, -0.02427484653890133, -0.030058156698942184, -0.043506547808647156, 0.012501232326030731, 0.03831285983324051, -0.024224666878581047, -0.0523885078728199, -0.056302592158317566, -0.07055386900901794, -0.011403532698750496, -0.001986836548894644, -0.0375099703669548, -0.003826267784461379, -0.04388290271162987, -0.01965823583304882, 0.01837863028049469, -0.0020213357638567686, -0.017964640632271767, 0.030459601432085037, -0.026570606976747513, -0.011554074473679066, -0.08390189707279205, 0.0055292705073952675, 0.062173716723918915, 0.023609954863786697, -0.028126204386353493, -0.023446867242455482, 0.029481079429388046, 0.008210794068872929, -0.006724195089191198, 0.005441454704850912, 0.022857245057821274, 0.011077359318733215, 0.05911270156502724, 0.02677132934331894, -0.01184261217713356, 0.012438506819307804, -0.01371183805167675, 0.03668199107050896, -0.012551412917673588, 0.06423112004995346, -0.03447404503822327, 0.04305492341518402, -0.04616611823439598, 0.0007378110894933343, 0.03517657518386841, -0.004026989918202162, 0.02525336854159832, 0.05193687975406647, 0.014038012363016605, -0.006837101653218269, 0.03826268017292023, -0.014715449884533882, 0.021063290536403656, -0.023873401805758476, -0.02241816557943821, -0.010387375950813293, 0.009095226414501667, -0.06729213148355484, -0.004064625594764948, -0.03821249678730965, 0.01648431457579136, 0.03148830309510231, 0.015957418829202652, -0.03645617887377739, -0.020072225481271744, 0.010701004415750504, 0.05364302173256874, 0.01741265505552292, -0.07507012039422989, 0.026696057990193367, 0.03171411529183388, -0.06889791041612625, -0.03991863876581192, -0.10839001089334488, -0.020360762253403664, -0.025441544130444527, 0.014201099053025246, 0.02895418368279934, -0.009390037506818771, 0.025993531569838524, -0.04205131158232689, -0.0005186631460674107, 0.0704033300280571, 0.02116365171968937, 0.06528490781784058, -0.014527272433042526, -0.04300474002957344, -0.027825120836496353, -0.06026685610413551, -0.006793193519115448, 0.016772853210568428, 0.02807602472603321, 0.05208742246031761, 0.021013110876083374, -0.029054544866085052, 0.041298601776361465, -0.02147728018462658, 0.03374642878770828, -0.02895418368279934, 0.015342706814408302, 0.04062116518616676, -0.05901234224438667, 0.021979086101055145, -0.040947336703538895, 0.06663978844881058, 0.033520616590976715, -0.022970153018832207, 0.05228814482688904, -0.0199844092130661, -0.021351829171180725, 0.027197863906621933, 0.027925482019782066, 0.014589997939765453, -0.011246718466281891, -0.04609084501862526, -0.02652042731642723, 0.04586503282189369, 0.00397994602099061, -0.040972430258989334, 0.0070566413924098015, -0.03768560290336609, 0.005033737514168024, -0.044058531522750854, 0.004958466626703739, -0.048148248344659805, 0.024513203650712967, 0.006281978916376829, -0.03673217073082924, -0.03552783653140068, -0.007639990653842688, -0.012601593509316444, 0.022568708285689354, 0.06071848049759865, -0.01244477927684784, -0.021364374086260796, -0.030484691262245178, -0.0024431662168353796, 0.03364606574177742, -0.007809349801391363, -0.047244999557733536, -0.018591897562146187, -0.04210149124264717, -0.04270365834236145, 0.03153848275542259, -0.04604066535830498, -0.025140460580587387, 0.0276996698230505, -0.027047323063015938, 0.033144261687994, 0.00994829647243023, 0.062173716723918915, -0.016434134915471077, 0.02584298886358738, -0.015267436392605305, 0.015430523082613945, 0.04651737958192825, -0.06924917548894882, 0.018190452829003334, 0.004030126146972179, -0.003199010854586959, 0.004346891306340694, -0.006291388068348169, 0.029531260952353477, 0.0499296598136425, -0.000009537491678202059, 0.018315905705094337, -0.011917883530259132, 0.024475568905472755, 0.00458524888381362, 0.01653449423611164, 0.04139896482229233, 0.01152898371219635, 0.025441544130444527, -0.022104537114501, -0.011654435656964779, -0.03924119845032692, -0.021364374086260796, 0.05479717254638672, -0.012814860790967941, 0.008317427709698677, -0.02185363508760929, -0.05038128420710564, -0.00403953529894352, 0.008775325492024422, 0.050632186233997345, 0.06829574704170227, -0.055650241672992706, -0.0053034583106637, 0.03542747721076012, -0.0005198392318561673, -0.016095414757728577, -0.05359283834695816, -0.0034342322032898664, 0.010431284084916115, 0.02960653230547905, -0.024851923808455467, 0.03236646205186844, 0.028176385909318924, -0.00616280036047101, 0.007257363758981228, 0.040922246873378754, -0.03981827571988106, 0.02870328165590763, 0.029506171122193336, 0.004246530123054981, 0.012187603861093521, -0.0016606629360467196, -0.027975663542747498, -0.009007411077618599, 0.0233966875821352, -0.011591710150241852, -0.0356031097471714, -0.09393801540136337, -0.03266754746437073, 0.0336962454020977, 0.033520616590976715, -0.02584298886358738, 0.04430943727493286, 0.02862801030278206, -0.020335672423243523, -0.027022233232855797, 0.009634668007493019, 0.010907999239861965, -0.019470058381557465, -0.024701381102204323, 0.01262668427079916, 0.004255938809365034, -0.015806876122951508, 0.01384983491152525, 0.008762780576944351, 0.01776391826570034, -0.006266297772526741, 0.016383953392505646, 0.014702904969453812, 0.01844135671854019, 0.028226565569639206, -0.00826724711805582, 0.012651774100959301, -0.012777225114405155, -0.0014568044571205974, 0.0014168168418109417, 0.0015603018691763282, 0.013824745081365108, 0.0025968439877033234, -0.03126249089837074, -0.0013940787175670266, 0.0021311056334525347, -0.02332141622900963, 0.021715637296438217, -0.03339516371488571, -0.034072600305080414, -0.0008373880991712213, -0.012482414953410625, -0.01589469239115715, 0.020988019183278084, -0.03590419143438339, 0.008016345091164112, 0.029832344502210617, -0.03339516371488571, -0.011045996099710464, 0.010192926973104477, -0.02342177741229534, 0.010462647303938866, 0.019758597016334534, -0.03856376186013222, -0.02958144061267376, -0.025378819555044174, -0.006084393244236708, 0.0144645469263196, -0.054696813225746155, -0.001623027492314577, -0.0010122359963133931, 0.013423300348222256, 0.02337159588932991, 0.017851734533905983, 0.024989919736981392, -0.01510434877127409, -0.005156052764505148, -0.009929479099810123, -0.005287776701152325, -0.0036443632561713457, 0.054445911198854446, 0.016045235097408295, -0.0034279595129191875, -0.0252408217638731, 0.025090280920267105, 0.007897165603935719, -0.01686066947877407, -0.021966541185975075, -0.023258689790964127, 0.015693970024585724, -0.0047796983271837234, -0.017864279448986053, -0.022493436932563782, 0.021953996270895004, -0.00858714897185564, -0.007088004145771265, -0.02304542250931263, -0.023258689790964127, -0.008681236766278744, -0.014201099053025246, 0.0006037348648533225, 0.007702716160565615, 0.02147728018462658, 0.007376542780548334, -0.00021914792887400836, -0.01709902659058571, -0.01263922918587923, 0.005946396384388208, 0.04636684060096741, 0.009120317175984383, -0.0029841752257198095, -0.00021130721142981201, -0.01958296447992325, -0.06443183869123459, 0.004077170509845018, -0.03743470087647438, 0.009139134548604488, -0.01682303287088871, 0.008562058210372925, -0.008593421429395676, -0.0046417019329965115, 0.03452422469854355, -0.018629534170031548, -0.012996765784919262, -0.010964453220367432, 0.010782548226416111, 0.010581825859844685, -0.038538672029972076, 0.007006460800766945, 0.025968439877033234, -0.0063729314133524895, 0.007639990653842688, -0.015606154687702656, -0.017237022519111633, -0.02677132934331894, -0.037535060197114944, 0.0008013208280317485, 0.02802584320306778, 0.03121230937540531, 0.005290912929922342, 0.009891843423247337, 0.029129816219210625, -0.01775137335062027, 0.03183956816792488, -0.01934460736811161, -0.011930428445339203, 0.01741265505552292, 0.006479565054178238, -0.015041623264551163, -0.01477817539125681, 0.0025403909385204315, 0.021427100524306297, -0.0099608413875103, 0.010029839351773262, 0.06809502094984055, -0.02241816557943821, 0.03025887906551361, -0.009804027155041695, -0.023747950792312622, -0.028477469459176064, 0.00536304758861661, -0.05073254927992821, -0.04062116518616676, 0.011629344895482063, -0.002231466816738248, -0.006711650174111128, -0.0110522685572505, 0.011754796840250492, -0.008148068562150002, -0.012814860790967941, 0.009760119020938873, -0.01711157150566578, 0.0021781499963253736, -0.02584298886358738, 0.008913322351872921, 0.004431570880115032, 0.023133238777518272, 0.006341568659991026, -0.011096176691353321, -0.0036663173232227564, -0.018002277240157127, -0.01371183805167675, -0.019507693126797676, -0.03828777000308037, 0.009873025119304657, 0.023622499778866768, 0.01965823583304882, -0.021402008831501007, 0.006749285385012627, 0.012745862826704979, -0.007570992223918438, -0.007019006181508303, -0.040044087916612625, -0.030158517882227898, 0.04320546239614487, 0.04711954668164253, -0.005598268937319517, -0.017701193690299988, -0.02056148461997509, -0.013247668743133545, -0.01717429794371128, 0.0042528025805950165, 0.003572228830307722, 0.0006229446153156459, -0.02802584320306778, 0.004403344355523586, -0.04548867791891098, 0.004836151842027903, 0.024701381102204323, -0.035678379237651825, -0.012538868002593517, 0.029179995879530907, -0.028151296079158783, -0.022807065397500992, -0.0030469009652733803, 0.013448390178382397, -0.017274659126996994, -0.044986873865127563, -0.0005159188876859844, -0.00631334213539958, -0.016772853210568428, 0.010506555438041687, 0.02492719329893589, 0.04109787940979004, 0.021088380366563797, 0.011447440832853317, 0.0035565472207963467, 0.0073702698573470116, 0.019432421773672104, -0.012451051734387875, -0.0005300322081893682, 0.013799654319882393, 0.012557685375213623, -0.009390037506818771, -0.001712411642074585, 0.010086293332278728, 0.03151339292526245, 0.006200435571372509, 0.0155559740960598, -0.0386139415204525, 0.02399885281920433, -0.015192165039479733, 0.02772475965321064, 0.010393648408353329, 0.031337760388851166, 0.013975286856293678, 0.03585401177406311, 0.023522138595581055, -0.024550840258598328, 0.006266297772526741, -0.055951327085494995, -0.025040101259946823, 0.04917695000767708, -0.03891502693295479, -0.025642266497015953, 0.0027458176482468843, 0.007909711450338364, 0.011303171515464783, 0.026043711230158806, -0.01495380699634552, 0.03236646205186844, -0.030936315655708313, 0.006191026885062456, -0.007790532428771257, -0.007282454054802656, 0.008085343055427074, 0.027172774076461792, -0.009208133444190025, -0.012808588333427906, 0.01075745839625597, 0.03058505244553089, -0.0012027653865516186, -0.0020103587303310633, 0.0032303736079484224, -0.00592130608856678, 0.009076409041881561, -0.007570992223918438, 0.03708343580365181, 0.001997813582420349, 0.0009675439796410501, -0.008505605161190033, -0.10307087749242783, 0.02212962694466114, 0.012231511995196342, 0.023484503850340843, 0.0023271236568689346, 0.03625545650720596, 0.04583994299173355, 0.026620788499712944, 0.01750047132372856, -0.00296535762026906, -0.011641890741884708, -0.04388290271162987, 0.006137710064649582, 0.024864468723535538, 0.03118721954524517, -0.03823758661746979, -0.0424276664853096, 0.006423112004995346, -0.034072600305080414, -0.017876824364066124, -0.03304389864206314, 0.00265172915533185, 0.009879298508167267, -0.027649490162730217, 0.003675726242363453, -0.02397376298904419, -0.01811518333852291, -0.00770898861810565, 0.01962059922516346, -0.008505605161190033, 0.021138561889529228, -0.021627822890877724, -0.02239307574927807, 0.025002464652061462, -0.00809161551296711, 0.0036788624711334705, 0.001415248611010611, 0.02457593008875847, -0.028853822499513626, 0.013009310699999332, -0.023145783692598343, -0.004509977996349335, 0.04541340842843056, 0.025002464652061462, 0.027649490162730217, -0.010569280944764614, 0.0004222223942633718, -0.0033432799391448498, 0.006376067642122507, 0.00762744527310133, -0.02800075337290764, 0.016459224745631218, -0.0019789959769695997, 0.021314194425940514, -0.012984219938516617, 0.018228089436888695, 0.012080970220267773, -0.009634668007493019, -0.027524037286639214, -0.003798041259869933, -0.030710503458976746, 0.02028549276292324, -0.002625070745125413, -0.0233966875821352, -0.05605168640613556, -0.010243107564747334, -0.0056139505468308926, 0.0511590838432312, 0.014665269292891026, -0.023547228425741196, -0.005109008401632309, 0.04548867791891098, 0.03206538036465645, 0.009597032330930233, 0.000741339405067265, -0.024237211793661118, -0.029832344502210617, -0.0010820183670148253, -0.003769814735278487, 0.03146321326494217, -0.010318377986550331, -0.04445997625589371, -0.015643790364265442, -0.0243501178920269, 0.020624211058020592, 0.03572855889797211, -0.006749285385012627, 0.004459797404706478, 0.0020574030932039022, 0.04930240288376808, 0.017575742676854134, -0.011591710150241852, -0.005604541394859552, 0.0051591889932751656, -0.011227901093661785, 0.003587910206988454, 0.0047514718025922775, -0.013034400530159473, -0.002946539781987667, -0.0060938019305467606, -0.013322939164936543, -0.0016371408710256219, -0.034122783690690994, -0.04681846499443054, 0.04016954079270363, -0.02367267943918705, -0.005864853039383888, 0.0010490873828530312, 0.02245580218732357, 0.011227901093661785, 0.037911415100097656, 0.02619425393640995, -0.018767530098557472, 0.003744724439457059, 0.039692822843790054, 0.02182854525744915, -0.004459797404706478, -0.0011690502287819982, 0.0069186449982225895, 0.007840712554752827, -0.013636567629873753, 0.002995152259245515, -0.016283592209219933, -0.006053030490875244, 0.01989659294486046, 0.022041812539100647, 0.007909711450338364, 0.009208133444190025, 0.0006448986241593957, 0.03796159476041794, 0.006335295736789703, 0.02217980846762657, 0.06744267791509628, 0.008028890006244183, -0.00483928807079792, -0.012839951552450657, -0.004867514595389366, 0.05278995260596275, -0.013410755433142185, 0.007846985012292862, -0.022919971495866776, 0.0002411019231658429, -0.020373307168483734, 0.021138561889529228, 0.007978709414601326, 0.007175820413976908, 0.013812199234962463, -0.04732026904821396, 0.02744876779615879, -0.0026862281374633312, 0.022581253200769424, -0.00513096246868372, -0.018466446548700333, -0.002407098887488246, 0.02371031604707241, -0.01262041088193655, -0.01262041088193655, -0.037183795124292374, 0.02363504469394684, 0.025027554482221603, 0.038488492369651794, 0.028853822499513626, 0.003920356277376413, -0.013435845263302326, 0.027047323063015938, -0.010374831035733223, -0.001670071855187416, 0.01230678241699934, 0.004578976426273584, -0.019858958199620247, -0.004964739549905062, -0.008800416253507137, 0.016409043222665787, 0.010312105529010296, 0.022292714565992355, 0.024851923808455467, -0.006567380856722593, 0.029681801795959473, 0.021703092381358147, 0.015806876122951508, 0.002278511179611087, 0.01588214747607708, 0.016383953392505646, 0.007508266717195511, 0.04370727017521858, 0.0032742817420512438, 0.00039752412703819573, 0.005112144630402327, 0.040646255016326904, 0.006956280209124088, -0.022016720846295357, 0.02342177741229534, -0.017061391845345497, 0.02240562066435814, 0.017550650984048843, 0.01936969719827175, -0.015693970024585724, 0.03326971083879471, -0.027524037286639214, -0.002871269127354026, -0.02398630790412426, -0.03640599921345711, -0.003169216215610504, -0.013410755433142185, 0.017575742676854134, -0.005008647218346596, 0.012068425305187702, -0.013272758573293686, -0.04704427719116211, -0.039768096059560776, -0.013360574841499329, -0.0106069166213274, 0.022669069468975067, 0.012720772065222263, 0.0487002357840538, -0.02619425393640995, 0.010801365599036217, -0.024187030270695686, -0.03826268017292023, -0.024425389245152473, 0.004246530123054981, -0.03936665132641792, -0.03811213746666908, 0.042804017663002014, 0.0014920876128599048, 0.003431095974519849, 0.00005218974547460675, -0.00552613427862525, -0.017625922337174416, 0.012777225114405155, 0.041599687188863754, 0.009270858950912952, -0.00553554343059659, -0.006410566624253988, -0.02332141622900963, 0.009684848599135876, -0.02186618000268936, 0.007489448878914118, -0.009942024014890194, 0.012149968184530735, 0.02807602472603321, 0.001588528393767774, 0.0018707941053435206, -0.03836303949356079, 0.004083443433046341, 0.002631343202665448, 0.022957606241106987, -0.0009691120940260589, 0.005651585757732391, 0.014489637687802315, -0.0013689884217455983, 0.004453524947166443, -0.03678235039114952, -0.01510434877127409, 0.028276747092604637, 0.010130200535058975, -0.01653449423611164, 0.03542747721076012, -0.017901916056871414, -0.02737349644303322, -0.007414177991449833, 0.008486787788569927, -0.038187406957149506, -0.03186465799808502, -0.0076023549772799015, 0.012814860790967941, -0.02586807869374752, 0.012764680199325085, -0.0026297750882804394, -0.035026032477617264, 0.0036506359465420246, -0.01586960256099701, 0.019821321591734886, -0.010073747485876083, -0.01510434877127409, 0.009452763013541698, -0.007144457660615444, 0.00653601810336113, 0.010807638056576252, 0.0342482328414917, -0.039768096059560776, -0.0033589613158255816, -0.02679641917347908, 0.018905526027083397, 0.013912560418248177, 0.0053254119120538235, -0.02308305911719799, -0.014715449884533882, -0.010563008487224579, 0.0035440020728856325, -0.011416077613830566, 0.060969382524490356, 0.0013454663567245007, 0.009026228450238705, -0.00885686930269003, -0.02496482990682125, 0.008976047858595848, -0.020511304959654808, -0.015029078349471092, -0.03121230937540531, -0.019419876858592033, 0.005316003225743771, 0.0030876726377755404, -0.03251700475811958, -0.004776562098413706, -0.051259443163871765, 0.012896404601633549, -0.0040677618235349655, -0.02061166614294052, -0.013837289996445179, 0.04144914448261261, -0.008687510155141354, 0.00906386412680149, -0.00001416228769812733, -0.012030789628624916, -0.01810263842344284, -0.012112333439290524, 0.010537917725741863, 0.001712411642074585, -0.030785774812102318, -0.013122216798365116, 0.012651774100959301, 0.023835767060518265, -0.02369777113199234, -0.02621934376657009, -0.0036380907986313105, 0.010149018839001656, -0.008035162463784218, 0.02275688387453556, 0.039416830986738205, 0.034097690135240555, 0.02928035706281662, 0.010569280944764614, -0.02933053858578205, -0.040320079773664474, 0.01103972364217043, 0.0008060252876020968, 0.008649874478578568, 0.038162317126989365, -0.017575742676854134, -0.03901538625359535, -0.017299748957157135, -0.03342025354504585, 0.012745862826704979, 0.0007832872215658426, 0.007815622724592686, -0.023622499778866768, -0.006924917455762625, -0.022681614384055138, 0.028176385909318924, 0.06367913633584976, -0.04461051896214485, -0.028477469459176064, -0.042277123779058456, -0.010989543050527573, -0.040646255016326904, 0.034147873520851135, -0.004604066722095013, -0.007514539174735546, 0.00155559740960598, -0.009672303684055805, 0.01057555340230465, -0.007420450448989868, 0.03151339292526245, 0.02774985134601593, -0.008060252293944359, 0.035352203994989395, 0.01898079738020897, -0.0208751130849123, 0.0028806778136640787, -0.012871313840150833, 0.01290894951671362, -0.011146357282996178, -0.0056139505468308926, 0.01802736707031727, -0.014514727517962456, 0.036932893097400665, 0.0014058398082852364, -0.017876824364066124, 0.04759626463055611, 0.00631334213539958, -0.011648163199424744, -0.028853822499513626, 0.01137844193726778, -0.01844135671854019, -0.007182092871516943, -0.0013634999049827456, 0.005334821064025164, 0.019231699407100677, -0.012526323087513447, 0.0046417019329965115, -0.009421400725841522, 0.02433757297694683, 0.006975098047405481, -0.0012490255758166313, -0.006341568659991026, -0.011390987783670425, 0.017588287591934204, 0.0029151770286262035, 0.011654435656964779, -0.003989354707300663, 0.0016873213462531567, 0.011158902198076248, -0.01590723730623722, 0.010004749521613121, 0.017011210322380066, 0.008204521611332893, 0.02652042731642723, -0.0003283298574388027, -0.018792619928717613, -0.02028549276292324, -0.02807602472603321, -0.03462458774447441, 0.029706893488764763, 0.03931647166609764, 0.005817808676511049, 0.005482226610183716, 0.018478991463780403, 0.017513016238808632, 0.01622086577117443, -0.016672492027282715, 0.018328450620174408, -0.02677132934331894, 0.0199844092130661, 0.0007574128685519099, -0.00840524397790432, -0.027298225089907646, -0.0075584473088383675, 0.015003987587988377, -0.018165362998843193, -0.0106069166213274, -0.022618887946009636, -0.0098228445276618, 0.028552738949656487, -0.011660708114504814, -0.008060252293944359, 0.017563195899128914, 0.01586960256099701, -0.011867702938616276, 0.01353620644658804, -0.028527649119496346, -0.03550274670124054, 0.020950384438037872, 0.007414177991449833, 0.000482595874927938, -0.0154179772362113, -0.018177907913923264, 0.008367608301341534, -0.005874262191355228, 0.020134950056672096, -0.02895418368279934, 0.020812388509511948, 0.005833490286022425, -0.013310394249856472, 0.027248045429587364, 0.013624022714793682, -0.04333091527223587, -0.028552738949656487, 0.014828355982899666, -0.00716327503323555, -0.005196824204176664, 0.012714499607682228, -0.006291388068348169, 0.02614407241344452, -0.002291056327521801, 0.04947803542017937, 0.026344794780015945, 0.008342518471181393, 0.0005167029448784888, -0.02088765799999237, 0.01713666133582592, 0.02589317038655281, 0.0038513580802828074, -0.011127539910376072, -0.013724383898079395, -0.01368674822151661, -0.007426723372191191, 0.014978897757828236, 0.008010072633624077, 0.018579352647066116, -0.037560150027275085, -0.0022471481934189796, 0.03394715115427971, 0.02054893970489502, 0.010249380022287369, 0.015342706814408302, -0.01872989535331726, -0.03838812932372093, 0.004622884094715118, -0.004005036316812038, 0.007746624294668436, -0.012080970220267773, -0.030384330078959465, -0.006203571800142527, -0.006542290560901165, 0.00693118991330266, 0.021063290536403656, -0.023208510130643845, 0.030936315655708313, -0.004572703503072262, -0.006724195089191198, 0.005563769955188036, 0.003062582341954112, -0.0004923967644572258, 0.009082681499421597, -0.0005170950316824019, -0.00287910969927907, -0.025692448019981384, -0.020737117156386375, -0.010299560613930225, -0.011441168375313282, 0.03555292636156082, -0.01777646318078041, 0.02248089201748371, 0.021339284256100655, -0.014602543786168098, -0.02022276632487774, 0.0043657086789608, -0.021953996270895004, 0.010017294436693192, -0.02031058259308338, -0.028502559289336205, 0.012482414953410625, -0.033796608448028564, -0.02900436520576477, -0.005008647218346596, 0.02372286096215248, -0.0199216827750206, -0.029731983318924904, 0.03921610862016678, 0.02275688387453556, -0.030158517882227898, 0.015192165039479733, 0.010964453220367432, -0.008260974660515785, 0.01277095265686512, -0.016057780012488365, 0.024513203650712967, 0.015355251729488373, -0.021264012902975082, -0.013636567629873753, -0.0015062008751556277, 0.007909711450338364, 0.0018896118272095919, 0.024513203650712967, 0.028577830642461777, -0.0031676478683948517, -0.042854201048612595, 0.0014756221789866686, 0.023271234706044197, -0.024450479075312614, -0.04418398439884186, 0.011014632880687714, 0.0027426814194768667, -0.01447709184139967, -0.0006837101536802948, 0.04195094853639603, 0.023885946720838547, -0.0020762206986546516, 0.008292337879538536, -0.002027608221396804, -0.020962929353117943, -0.026921872049570084, 0.02492719329893589, 0.017525561153888702, 0.013611477799713612, 0.02677132934331894, 0.03339516371488571, -0.03141302987933159, -0.00388899352401495, 0.05474699288606644, -0.022305259481072426, 0.008185704238712788, 0.00466679222881794, 0.008342518471181393, 0.005488499067723751, 0.0498042069375515, -0.006212980952113867, 0.03394715115427971, 0.043456368148326874, -0.012413416057825089, -0.0573062002658844, 0.01618323102593422, -0.04942785203456879, -0.029355628415942192, 0.01386237982660532, -0.02404903434216976, 0.028452377766370773, -0.005842898972332478, 0.016597220674157143, -0.00034303119173273444, 0.009339856915175915, 0.01995931938290596, 0.026068801060318947, 0.013611477799713612, 0.040646255016326904, 0.02334650605916977, -0.0065485634841024876, -0.04922712966799736, 0.007282454054802656, -0.007244818843901157, 0.015041623264551163, -0.0012513777473941445, -0.011077359318733215, -0.007734078913927078, -0.00037419801810756326, 0.01933206059038639, -0.03266754746437073, -0.04237748309969902, 0.03482531011104584, -0.01215624064207077, 0.007226001005619764, 0.019746050238609314, 0.03053487278521061, 0.04026990011334419, 0.017952095717191696, -0.02902945503592491, 0.0019068613182753325, -0.006975098047405481, -0.047847166657447815, 0.0067806486040353775, -0.03525184467434883, 0.012463596649467945, -0.02031058259308338, 0.02933053858578205, -0.009502943605184555, 0.0075584473088383675, -0.01806500181555748, 0.013900015503168106, 0.024676291272044182, 0.00997338630259037, 0.03050978109240532, -0.0014262256445363164, -0.004764017183333635, -0.025441544130444527, 0.012413416057825089, -0.020360762253403664, -0.000334994459990412, -0.0379365049302578, 0.010512827895581722, -0.004971012007445097, 0.00981029961258173, 0.008229612372815609, -0.02083747833967209, 0.021590186282992363, -0.0199216827750206, -0.020473668351769447, -0.03211556002497673, -0.007639990653842688, 0.011610527522861958, -0.00214208266697824, -0.01716175302863121, -0.0022659660317003727, 0.006366658955812454, -0.005356775131076574, 0.003688271390274167, -0.01781409978866577, -0.019570419564843178, -0.012206421233713627, -0.005635904148221016, 0.013598931953310966, 0.017312293872237206, -0.01900588721036911, 0.037886325269937515, 0.013611477799713612, 0.011855158023536205, -0.001572062959894538, 0.047169726341962814, 0.007552174385637045, 0.04837406054139137, -0.008486787788569927, 0.03113703802227974, 0.008819233626127243, 0.03868921473622322, 0.004488023929297924, -0.0019946773536503315, 0.01563124544918537, 0.0006711650057695806, 0.0029967203736305237, 0.007909711450338364, -0.011510166339576244, -0.01803991198539734, -0.01684812270104885, 0.052187785506248474, -0.015355251729488373, 0.015606154687702656, -0.009358675219118595, 0.0010271334322169423, -0.02243071049451828, -0.02867819182574749, -0.009283403865993023, -0.0387393943965435, 0.015455612912774086, 0.0027442495338618755, -0.024864468723535538, -0.0031190356239676476, 0.003164511639624834, -0.01772628352046013, -0.020410943776369095, -0.0436570905148983, 0.017901916056871414, -0.017073936760425568, -0.026068801060318947, -0.010776275768876076, 0.019382242113351822, -0.03271772712469101, -0.01400037668645382, -0.03512639179825783, 0.018140273168683052, -0.0349256694316864, -0.025102825835347176, -0.013925106264650822, 0.0026078210212290287, 0.004701291210949421, 0.013975286856293678, 0.020649300888180733, 0.017237022519111633, -0.029079634696245193, -0.00999220460653305, -0.005046282894909382, 0.012275420129299164, 0.057808008044958115, 0.00021013109653722495, 0.0023569182958453894, -0.021364374086260796, -0.04594030603766441, 0.015593609772622585, 0.016107959672808647, 0.023747950792312622, -0.01354875136166811, 0.038789574056863785, 0.023271234706044197, 0.028301836922764778, 0.010192926973104477, 0.0027426814194768667, 0.00645447475835681, -0.006498382892459631, -0.0004900445346720517, -0.02057402953505516 ]
12.136291
6.472429
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.532L..61H
[ "orphan galaxies", "non-orphaned satellite galaxies", "semi-analytic models", "orphans", "low-mass passive galaxies", "high redshifts", "higher resolution simulations", "the resolved satellite galaxy population", "the passive galaxy population", "deep observational data" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
15
[ "10.1093/mnrasl/slae043", "10.48550/arXiv.2405.06018" ]
[ "Harrold, Jimi E.", "Almaini, Omar", "Pearce, Frazer R.", "Yates, Robert M." ]
[ "School of Physics &amp; Astronomy, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, NG7 2RD, UK;", "School of Physics &amp; Astronomy, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, NG7 2RD, UK;", "School of Physics &amp; Astronomy, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, NG7 2RD, UK", "Centre for Astrophysics Research, University of Hertfordshire, Hatfield, AL10 9AB, UK;" ]
null
[ "1991ApJ...379...52W", "2000ApJ...539..718C", "2001MNRAS.328..726S", "2001NewA....6...79S", "2003MNRAS.344.1000B", "2004ApJ...600L.171S", "2004Natur.430..184C", "2005Natur.435..629S", "2006A&A...453L..29C", "2006RPPh...69.3101B", "2007ApJ...655...51W", "2007MNRAS.375....2D", "2007MNRAS.378L...6B", "2007MNRAS.379.1599L", "2008ApJ...686.1503B", "2008ApJS..176....1F", "2008MNRAS.383..593M", "2009MNRAS.394.1213W", "2009MNRAS.397.1776F", "2009MNRAS.398.1150B", "2010A&A...523A..13P", "2010ApJ...708...58C", "2010ApJ...712..833C", "2010ApJ...724..915H", "2010MNRAS.405..143A", "2011MNRAS.413..101G", "2012MNRAS.426.2797W", "2013A&A...556A..55I", "2013ApJ...766...38L", "2013ApJ...769...80A", "2013ApJ...770...57B", "2013ApJ...777...18M", "2013MNRAS.428.1281J", "2013MNRAS.431.3045H", "2013MNRAS.433.2647S", "2013MNRAS.436..150S", "2014MNRAS.440.1880W", "2015ARA&A..53...51S", "2015MNRAS.451.2663H", "2015MNRAS.451.4029K", "2016ApJS..222...22C", "2016MNRAS.458..366L", "2016MNRAS.459L.114M", "2016MNRAS.463..832W", "2017ApJ...847..134K", "2017MNRAS.464.1077W", "2017MNRAS.471.1401C", "2017MNRAS.472.1401A", "2018MNRAS.479....2C", "2018MNRAS.480.1197A", "2020ARA&A..58..661F", "2020MNRAS.491.5795H", "2020MNRAS.498.4327X", "2021MNRAS.504.4533W", "2021MNRAS.506.4760D", "2021PASA...38...35C", "2022MNRAS.510.1945M", "2023MNRAS.522.2297T", "2024A&A...687A..68D", "2024MNRAS.531.3551L" ]
29184420
2407.04096
Strong nebular emissions associated with Mg II absorptions detected in the SDSS spectra of background quasars
We present long-slit spectroscopic observations of 40 Galaxy On Top Of Quasars (GOTOQs) at 0.37 ≤ z ≤ 1.01 using the South African Large Telescope. Using this and available photometric data, we measure the impact parameters of the foreground galaxies to be in the range of 3-16 kpc with a median value of 8.6 kpc. This is the largest sample of galaxies producing Mg II absorption at such low impact parameters. These quasar-galaxy pairs are ideal for probing the disk-halo interface. At such impact parameters, we do not find any anti-correlation between rest equivalent width (REW) of Ca II, Mn II, Fe II, Mg II and Mg I absorption and impact parameter. These sight lines are typically redder than those of strong Mg II absorbers, with the color excess, E(B - V) for our sample ranging from -0.191 to 0.422, with a median value of 0.058. In the E(B - V) vs. W<SUB>3935</SUB> plane, GOTOQs occupy the same region as Ca II absorbers. For a given E(B - V), we find larger W<SUB>3935</SUB> than what has been found in the Milky Way, probably due to a smaller dust-to-gas ratio in GOTOQs. Galaxy parameters could be measured for twelve cases, and their properties seem to follow the trends found for strong Mg II absorbers. Measuring the host galaxy properties for the full sample using HST photometry or AO-assisted ground-based imaging is important to gain insights into the relationship between the stellar mass of galaxies and the metal line REW distributions at low impact parameters.
[ -0.009211155585944653, 0.031714677810668945, 0.026635276153683662, 0.003225167980417609, -0.05332109332084656, -0.00018143544730264693, -0.05428137630224228, -0.026761628687381744, -0.028758011758327484, 0.0005654310225509107, -0.013128108344972134, -0.0029929939191788435, -0.06064958497881889, -0.02142952010035515, 0.03843667358160019, 0.0008497259696014225, -0.012502659112215042, 0.0006242642994038761, -0.010695806704461575, 0.05923442915081978, -0.03168940916657448, 0.0007364028133451939, -0.04573989659547806, 0.005569021683186293, -0.09385523200035095, -0.048519667237997055, 0.0030735440086573362, 0.027216501533985138, 0.04126698896288872, -0.006538783200085163, 0.015566726215183735, -0.021505331620573997, -0.035783253610134125, -0.047887902706861496, -0.06186257675290108, 0.05129944160580635, 0.028480034321546555, 0.0011490252800285816, -0.01872555911540985, -0.02015335112810135, 0.010417829267680645, 0.04379405453801155, -0.0036326574627310038, -0.015907879918813705, 0.003078282345086336, -0.005309997592121363, 0.02482842281460762, 0.007492750883102417, -0.023286912590265274, -0.05483733117580414, -0.025043224915862083, 0.005050973035395145, -0.028606386855244637, 0.030552228912711143, -0.0026360456831753254, -0.02338799647986889, -0.0008402494713664055, 0.026913253590464592, 0.02172013185918331, -0.0023233212996274233, -0.05018753185868263, -0.014138934202492237, 0.03841140493750572, 0.012325764633715153, -0.012906990014016628, 0.020658764988183975, -0.0008757862960919738, -0.012060422450304031, 0.010910607874393463, 0.019167795777320862, -0.027014335617423058, 0.03277604654431343, 0.00211010011844337, -0.02969302609562874, 0.031032370403409004, -0.023969221860170364, 0.002269621239975095, -0.02027970552444458, 0.011889845132827759, -0.05832468345761299, 0.02155587263405323, 0.04958103597164154, -0.014770700596272945, -0.016552282497286797, -0.05281567946076393, 0.03692043572664261, 0.024247199296951294, -0.038335591554641724, -0.05640411376953125, 0.04371824115514755, -0.0069178431294858456, -0.01357034407556057, -0.0028113608714193106, -0.024600988253951073, -0.0026865871623158455, -0.03580852597951889, 0.03444391116499901, -0.020292339846491814, 0.025119036436080933, -0.009021625854074955, 0.0062197414226830006, 0.02318583056330681, 0.027570290490984917, -0.06671454012393951, 0.059335511177778244, 0.003503145184367895, 0.02455044537782669, -0.0022143416572362185, 0.040660493075847626, -0.04134279862046242, 0.050718214362859726, 0.017221955582499504, -0.026079321280121803, 0.035631630569696426, -0.016792353242635727, -0.005846999119967222, -0.04187348484992981, -0.01772736757993698, -0.019508950412273407, 0.0009065849590115249, -0.010569453239440918, 0.013886227272450924, 0.02638256922364235, -0.009893462993204594, 0.03196738660335541, -0.021454790607094765, -0.044729068875312805, -0.053472716361284256, -0.03924533352255821, 0.01013985276222229, 0.02741866558790207, -0.022048650309443474, 0.0237923264503479, 0.00907848495990038, -0.03166413679718971, -0.001980588072910905, 0.015869975090026855, -0.019180431962013245, -0.010967466048896313, 0.011302302591502666, -0.01608477532863617, 0.003958017099648714, -0.019382596015930176, 0.0075685628689825535, 0.010487323626875877, 0.015617268159985542, -0.04649801552295685, 0.03161359578371048, 0.002275938866659999, 0.020810388028621674, -0.01127703208476305, -0.03712259978055954, -0.026559464633464813, -0.07065676897764206, 0.02318583056330681, -0.025119036436080933, 0.00679780775681138, -0.0006992865237407386, -0.025485461577773094, -0.008269823156297207, 0.0077201868407428265, -0.03765328228473663, 0.013279732316732407, 0.0035852747969329357, -0.02534647285938263, 0.03113345243036747, -0.0035821159835904837, 0.019647939130663872, -0.08667836338281631, -0.013747239485383034, -0.012818542309105396, -0.014252652414143085, -0.007397985551506281, -0.05696006864309311, -0.0023991332855075598, 0.04336445406079292, -0.012742730788886547, -0.012363670393824577, -0.038815733045339584, -0.020507140085101128, -0.014606441371142864, 0.007050514221191406, 0.022857312113046646, 0.010803206823766232, -0.05721277371048927, 0.030602769926190376, -0.025005318224430084, 0.016830259934067726, -0.009280649945139885, -0.027241772040724754, 0.0201154462993145, 0.01768946275115013, 0.009451227262616158, 0.04849439859390259, -0.023173196241259575, -0.0625196099281311, -0.013418720103800297, 0.036061231046915054, -0.02618040330708027, 0.030552228912711143, 0.025523366406559944, 0.01084111351519823, 0.0926927849650383, -0.09911152720451355, -0.05145106464624405, -0.03740057721734047, 0.07096001505851746, -0.022099193185567856, -0.015048678033053875, -0.016754448413848877, 0.028909634798765182, 0.028075702488422394, -0.023249007761478424, 0.03747639060020447, 0.008749966509640217, -0.01791689731180668, -0.06989864259958267, 0.026003509759902954, 0.06914052367210388, 0.013797780498862267, -0.03755220025777817, 0.06075066700577736, 0.02782299742102623, 0.004393936134874821, 0.03320564702153206, 0.03181575983762741, 0.01612268202006817, 0.0045961011201143265, 0.046927616000175476, -0.0132291903719306, -0.017891626805067062, 0.009634438902139664, -0.041014280170202255, -0.015137125737965107, -0.0009673924650996923, -0.0014127878239378333, 0.052866220474243164, -0.0009326452855020761, -0.03638974949717522, -0.06757374852895737, -0.03093128837645054, -0.005490051116794348, 0.02850530482828617, -0.0015438793925568461, 0.0028208375442773104, -0.00015527635696344078, -0.008907907642424107, -0.037299495190382004, 0.009596533142030239, 0.034620802849531174, 0.0005204176413826644, -0.0006842821021564305, -0.01129598543047905, -0.045209210366010666, -0.0017831609584391117, 0.004697184078395367, -0.018346499651670456, 0.002159062074497342, -0.042100921273231506, -0.010493641719222069, 0.009350144304335117, -0.02734285406768322, -0.014808607287704945, 0.020532410591840744, 0.009653392247855663, 0.03603596240282059, 0.024499904364347458, -0.007082102354615927, -0.0529167614877224, 0.024689434096217155, -0.012666918337345123, -0.009381732903420925, 0.06474342942237854, -0.04988428205251694, -0.06671454012393951, 0.0017294607823714614, 0.016021598130464554, -0.026963794603943825, 0.0289349053055048, -0.02850530482828617, 0.01588260941207409, 0.02343853749334812, 0.04063522070646286, 0.0003510252572596073, -0.041848212480545044, -0.0289349053055048, -0.04874710366129875, 0.02347644232213497, -0.02941504865884781, 0.005619563162326813, 0.06332827359437943, -0.032548610121011734, 0.01565517485141754, -0.010929560288786888, -0.06368206441402435, -0.019711114466190338, 0.0005271301488392055, 0.01199724618345499, 0.0019426819635555148, -0.006210264749825001, 0.04639693349599838, 0.038183968514204025, 0.04136807098984718, -0.031158724799752235, -0.011580280028283596, 0.00019347849593032151, 0.09865665435791016, 0.031512513756752014, -0.022137098014354706, 0.03780490905046463, 0.010455735959112644, 0.018624477088451385, 0.005745916161686182, 0.04050887003540993, -0.02994573302567005, -0.014328463934361935, -0.02279413491487503, 0.06474342942237854, -0.0009650233550928533, -0.04586624726653099, 0.0020406057592481375, -0.044602714478969574, -0.024600988253951073, 0.006207105703651905, -0.003661086782813072, -0.021581143140792847, -0.01616058684885502, -0.037501659244298935, 0.01979956217110157, -0.013823051005601883, 0.03161359578371048, -0.01074003055691719, 0.02318583056330681, 0.004750884138047695, -0.052866220474243164, 0.021454790607094765, -0.0004746145859826356, 0.05089510977268219, -0.013734604232013226, 0.008743648417294025, -0.027368124574422836, -0.0009958219015970826, 0.026079321280121803, -0.02196020446717739, 0.016135316342115402, 0.031841032207012177, 0.033584706485271454, 0.008907907642424107, 0.014379005879163742, -0.021745402365922928, 0.014265287667512894, 0.008617294952273369, 0.036465562880039215, -0.0017515725921839476, 0.09951586276292801, -0.022490886971354485, -0.005979669746011496, -0.03196738660335541, -0.05529220402240753, 0.03719841316342354, -0.012805907055735588, -0.008295094594359398, -0.00010177363583352417, 0.003201476763933897, 0.01944577321410179, 0.020532410591840744, -0.03828505054116249, -0.003316774033010006, -0.024638893082737923, -0.020772483199834824, 0.0076759629882872105, 0.02837895043194294, -0.0626712366938591, -0.0374511182308197, -0.06186257675290108, -0.02016598731279373, 0.025131670758128166, -0.001653648796491325, 0.0022633036132901907, -0.002726072445511818, 0.013001754879951477, 0.007360079791396856, 0.0015557250007987022, -0.022212909534573555, 0.010866384021937847, 0.010127217508852482, -0.01867501810193062, -0.0021669589914381504, -0.06110445782542229, 0.013406084850430489, -0.02671108767390251, 0.016350116580724716, -0.010594724677503109, -0.01724722608923912, 0.02946558967232704, -0.018687652423977852, 0.059133343398571014, 0.06969647854566574, -0.008825778029859066, 0.04710451140999794, -0.010133534669876099, -0.05584815889596939, -0.0574149414896965, -0.04675072059035301, -0.05165322870016098, -0.02051977626979351, -0.031841032207012177, 0.04060995206236839, 0.04083738848567009, -0.02741866558790207, 0.024487270042300224, 0.020380787551403046, 0.025687625631690025, 0.021138906478881836, 0.016855530440807343, 0.031866300851106644, -0.04599260166287422, 0.05407921224832535, -0.02148006111383438, 0.03932114690542221, 0.0427832268178463, 0.042378898710012436, -0.006254488602280617, 0.03318037837743759, -0.03757747262716293, 0.012591106817126274, -0.008036069571971893, -0.00555006880313158, 0.00788444560021162, -0.03156305477023125, 0.00044815934961661696, -0.01815696991980076, 0.011902481317520142, -0.0250684954226017, -0.037425845861434937, -0.020646128803491592, 0.009615486487746239, -0.007012607995420694, 0.023640703409910202, 0.04192402586340904, 0.028808552771806717, -0.04215146228671074, 0.041494425386190414, -0.028480034321546555, 0.021088365465402603, 0.006721995770931244, 0.05392758920788765, 0.010910607874393463, 0.031032370403409004, -0.045638810843229294, 0.008434082381427288, 0.023729149252176285, 0.02235189825296402, -0.018750829622149467, -0.03113345243036747, 0.00016949110431596637, -0.011245443485677242, -0.06322719156742096, 0.04937886819243431, -0.07404303550720215, -0.012325764633715153, -0.008610977791249752, -0.020772483199834824, 0.025599177926778793, -0.01848548837006092, 0.018017981201410294, -0.012193093076348305, 0.003462080378085375, -0.014366370625793934, 0.006336618214845657, 0.010007181204855442, -0.04675072059035301, 0.014795971103012562, 0.003620021976530552, -0.014783335849642754, -0.012458435259759426, 0.006576689425855875, -0.008055022917687893, 0.027039606124162674, -0.007751774974167347, 0.031790491193532944, -0.02885909378528595, -0.007208455819636583, 0.024765247479081154, 0.01784108579158783, 0.04422365501523018, 0.006267123855650425, 0.00904057826846838, 0.00792235229164362, -0.04611895605921745, -0.04965684562921524, -0.016868164762854576, 0.0399276427924633, -0.012818542309105396, 0.01405048742890358, 0.024651529267430305, 0.004735089838504791, 0.002256985753774643, 0.00514889694750309, 0.003680039895698428, 0.05908280238509178, -0.031638868153095245, 0.004735089838504791, 0.02323637157678604, 0.010973784141242504, 0.012477388605475426, -0.014240017160773277, 0.003490509930998087, -0.0010558398207649589, 0.032472796738147736, -0.025776073336601257, 0.015200302004814148, -0.006308188661932945, -0.040938470512628555, 0.010064040310680866, 0.009855557233095169, 0.006200788076967001, 0.004482383374124765, 0.024575717747211456, 0.01484651304781437, -0.02575080282986164, 0.008143470622599125, -0.018536029383540154, 0.0013464523945003748, -0.006241852883249521, 0.0016117943450808525, -0.006153405643999577, -0.10032451897859573, -0.02671108767390251, -0.008768918924033642, -0.02207392081618309, -0.03932114690542221, -0.03366051986813545, 0.01518766675144434, -0.018030615523457527, -0.03780490905046463, -0.01305229589343071, -0.02151796780526638, -0.02190966159105301, -0.05081929638981819, -0.003834822680801153, 0.0007324542966671288, -0.0006325562135316432, -0.04308647662401199, 0.02319846674799919, 0.052714597433805466, 0.007429574150592089, 0.0019189907470718026, 0.0072210910730063915, 0.03780490905046463, 0.015263478271663189, -0.013128108344972134, 0.039776019752025604, 0.038739923387765884, -0.005193120799958706, 0.012862766161561012, -0.0024638893082737923, 0.011074867099523544, 0.011447609402239323, -0.013077566400170326, -0.0046403249725699425, 0.015958422794938087, -0.013936769217252731, 0.01129598543047905, 0.017133507877588272, -0.011131726205348969, 0.016918707638978958, -0.0424041673541069, 0.010285158641636372, -0.000009655415851739235, -0.021568508818745613, -0.013999945484101772, 0.008459353819489479, -0.0176010150462389, -0.011163313873112202, -0.01835913397371769, -0.028606386855244637, 0.03216955065727234, -0.004324441775679588, -0.04058467969298363, -0.029996274039149284, -0.010512595064938068, 0.01580679789185524, 0.012666918337345123, -0.017474660649895668, -0.020620858296751976, -0.02726704254746437, 0.016918707638978958, 0.01772736757993698, 0.02586452104151249, 0.014555900357663631, -0.026155132800340652, -0.004712977912276983, -0.003503145184367895, -0.0028066227678209543, -0.02407030388712883, 0.051400523632764816, 0.011605550535023212, -0.007663327734917402, 0.01377250999212265, 0.015516185201704502, -0.037981800734996796, -0.03224536404013634, -0.008175058290362358, -0.022465616464614868, 0.037905991077423096, 0.0008378803031519055, -0.03747639060020447, 0.005695375148206949, 0.013305002823472023, 0.01161818578839302, 0.016350116580724716, -0.02590242587029934, -0.02671108767390251, -0.021656956523656845, -0.007126326207071543, -0.005477415397763252, -0.016653364524245262, 0.04642220214009285, 0.031866300851106644, -0.007492750883102417, -0.020140716806054115, 0.020128080621361732, 0.011416020803153515, 0.019660573452711105, 0.03820923715829849, 0.0035442099906504154, -0.012110963463783264, 0.0007715448155067861, -0.035151489078998566, 0.00270396051928401, -0.04058467969298363, 0.036339208483695984, -0.00800448190420866, 0.0009650233550928533, 0.013305002823472023, -0.005490051116794348, 0.01669127121567726, 0.009716568514704704, -0.0174114853143692, 0.022288722917437553, 0.0026471016462892294, 0.03348362445831299, -0.006677771918475628, 0.019534220919013023, -0.026812169700860977, -0.0003652400046121329, 0.008168741129338741, -0.040079265832901, -0.011479197070002556, -0.00015488150529563427, -0.00001774375414242968, 0.00572696328163147, 0.01979956217110157, 0.0175631083548069, 0.018624477088451385, 0.02187175676226616, 0.019016170874238014, -0.03333200141787529, 0.04033197462558746, -0.03765328228473663, -0.012768001295626163, 0.004441318567842245, -0.009489133022725582, -0.013456626795232296, 0.026129862293601036, -0.018738195300102234, -0.0032535975333303213, -0.01067685429006815, 0.005073084961622953, 0.06059904396533966, -0.027519749477505684, 0.00878155417740345, -0.002617092803120613, 0.03932114690542221, -0.018750829622149467, -0.00816242303699255, -0.048241689801216125, -0.05256297439336777, 0.04323809966444969, 0.008851048536598682, -0.005900699179619551, -0.025055859237909317, -0.0003184498054906726, -0.015326655469834805, -0.004144388251006603, 0.025485461577773094, 0.008806824684143066, 0.018687652423977852, -0.011156996712088585, 0.005919652059674263, -0.0029929939191788435, 0.04887345805764198, -0.005701692774891853, 0.013279732316732407, -0.04179767146706581, -0.014227381907403469, -0.016388023272156715, -0.0077265044674277306, -0.03457026183605194, 0.025359107181429863, 0.007897080853581429, 0.008996355347335339, -0.036263398826122284, -0.03649083152413368, -0.0005022543482482433, 0.005884904880076647, -0.001215360825881362, 0.01153605617582798, -0.009621803648769855, 0.04035724326968193, 0.057617105543613434, -0.0353536531329155, -0.028480034321546555, 0.004678230732679367, -0.034393370151519775, -0.0031714679207652807, 0.008667835965752602, -0.02969302609562874, -0.014682253822684288, -0.006583007052540779, 0.02586452104151249, -0.04124171659350395, 0.0039043170399963856, -0.00692416075617075, -0.02989519014954567, 0.020304976031184196, 0.017588378861546516, -0.02366597391664982, -0.0010558398207649589, 0.01772736757993698, 0.004867760930210352, -0.029288694262504578, 0.010323064401745796, 0.007467479910701513, 0.035227298736572266, 0.007998163811862469, -0.024057667702436447, 0.042252544313669205, 0.025119036436080933, 0.017310401424765587, -0.0031461971811950207, -0.007397985551506281, 0.007094737607985735, 0.00842144712805748, -0.020406058058142662, -0.003550527850165963, -0.025599177926778793, -0.008061341010034084, -0.031183995306491852, 0.029996274039149284, 0.010645265690982342, 0.022680416703224182, -0.0059101758524775505, 0.03305402398109436, -0.029516130685806274, 0.016956612467765808, -0.025258025154471397, 0.001999540952965617, -0.0009279070654883981, 0.03585906699299812, 0.02706487663090229, 0.0011964078294113278, 0.01820751093327999, -0.030678581446409225, 0.048797644674777985, -0.02390604466199875, -0.004362347535789013, 0.005853316746652126, -0.01597105711698532, 0.02196020446717739, 0.005224708933383226, 0.03560636192560196, 0.006576689425855875, 0.020128080621361732, -0.008175058290362358, 0.0006594063015654683, -0.004634007345885038, 0.007979211397469044, 0.03148724138736725, -0.0026802693028002977, -0.03831031918525696, 0.010240934789180756, 0.010980102233588696, -0.001238262397237122, 0.00759383337572217, -0.010070358403027058, 0.00669672479853034, 0.005180485546588898, 0.01976165547966957, -0.008945813402533531, 0.00039781545638106763, 0.002715016482397914, 0.021859120577573776, 0.007454844657331705, 0.00969761610031128, -0.021846486255526543, -0.09865665435791016, 0.00736639741808176, 0.02578870952129364, 0.022175004705786705, 0.0138483215123415, 0.03449445217847824, 0.012313129380345345, 0.026812169700860977, 0.024120844900608063, -0.01271114218980074, 0.029010718688368797, -0.04874710366129875, 0.005862792953848839, 0.01305229589343071, 0.004125435370951891, -0.024575717747211456, -0.031108181923627853, 0.002918761223554611, 0.02913707122206688, 0.011529739014804363, -0.008579389192163944, 0.012932260520756245, -0.007638057228177786, -0.02933923713862896, -0.0002148006169591099, -0.014404276385903358, 0.013380814343690872, 0.011283350177109241, 0.038183968514204025, -0.00731585593894124, -0.017386214807629585, -0.005073084961622953, -0.013734604232013226, 0.06716941297054291, -0.03565690293908119, -0.037703823298215866, -0.005439509637653828, 0.012963848188519478, -0.0005520060076378286, 0.002282256493344903, -0.02115154266357422, -0.01552882045507431, 0.03320564702153206, 0.01704506017267704, 0.06757374852895737, 0.002132212044671178, 0.0038822051137685776, -0.006466130260378122, 0.015225572511553764, -0.006049164105206728, -0.002917181933298707, 0.0188771840184927, -0.009432273916900158, 0.011283350177109241, -0.02418402209877968, -0.0070189256221055984, 0.03444391116499901, 0.005338427145034075, -0.019749021157622337, -0.04993482306599617, -0.01401258073747158, 0.010847430676221848, -0.002116417745128274, -0.042050380259752274, -0.061609867960214615, -0.04627057909965515, -0.028833823278546333, 0.03045114502310753, -0.0062987119890749454, -0.013709332793951035, 0.034873511642217636, 0.044173114001750946, 0.012679553590714931, 0.007277950178831816, 0.008105563931167126, -0.020545046776533127, 0.006444018334150314, -0.009830286726355553, -0.043414995074272156, 0.048646021634340286, -0.03676880896091461, -0.02214973419904709, 0.03510094806551933, -0.012919625267386436, 0.02347644232213497, 0.029035989195108414, 0.014758065342903137, 0.01900353655219078, -0.007227408699691296, -0.01199724618345499, -0.013532438315451145, -0.00697470223531127, 0.014972866512835026, 0.029162341728806496, -0.01099905464798212, -0.000597809033934027, 0.009969275444746017, -0.03525257110595703, -0.018750829622149467, -0.004681389778852463, -0.04675072059035301, -0.05579761788249016, 0.002757660811766982, -0.052866220474243164, 0.016653364524245262, -0.044729068875312805, -0.012363670393824577, 0.04189875349402428, 0.008301411755383015, 0.025611814111471176, 0.005272091366350651, 0.018902454525232315, 0.0004813270934391767, 0.019167795777320862, 0.027873538434505463, 0.007120008580386639, -0.005749075207859278, -0.01010194607079029, 0.051678501069545746, -0.020469235256314278, 0.005853316746652126, -0.00890159048140049, 0.002923499559983611, -0.01235103514045477, -0.006583007052540779, 0.006074435077607632, 0.01983746886253357, 0.003034058725461364, -0.024638893082737923, 0.02858111634850502, 0.02024179883301258, 0.0025128512643277645, 0.03388795629143715, -0.047483570873737335, 0.006418747827410698, -0.017815815284848213, -0.01688080094754696, 0.04670017957687378, -0.007991846650838852, 0.03532838448882103, -0.004128593951463699, 0.013747239485383034, 0.031360890716314316, 0.009590215981006622, -0.03891681507229805, -0.015907879918813705, -0.0026439428329467773, -0.004374983254820108, 0.0449565052986145, -0.021770672872662544, 0.010291476733982563, -0.019824832677841187, 0.011946704238653183, 0.02218763902783394, -0.014341099187731743, -0.00035852749715559185, -0.0029345552902668715, -0.020064903423190117, -0.003954858519136906, 0.014606441371142864, 0.016754448413848877, 0.01744939014315605, 0.004403412342071533, 0.001996382139623165, 0.02455044537782669, 0.011675044894218445, -0.024095574393868446, 0.03209373727440834, 0.003525257110595703, 0.011902481317520142, -0.014126298949122429, -0.009495450183749199, 0.04374351352453232, 0.001527295564301312, -0.012212046422064304, 0.02774718403816223, -0.02238980494439602, -0.03262442350387573, 0.03252333775162697, 0.014922324568033218, -0.002763978438451886, 0.005840681493282318, -0.03735003620386124, 0.007732822094112635, 0.04798898473381996, -0.03204319626092911, -0.009792380966246128, -0.017714733257889748, 0.019016170874238014, 0.016034234315156937, -0.005325791426002979, 0.016590189188718796, -0.015566726215183735, 0.0049720024690032005, -0.014998137019574642, -0.01640065759420395, 0.006671454291790724, 0.006200788076967001, -0.03479769825935364, -0.023501714691519737, -0.00427074171602726, -0.015554090961813927, 0.013999945484101772, -0.017537837848067284, -0.008175058290362358, 0.00010878229659283534, -0.010784254409372807, -0.03671826794743538, -0.03596014901995659, -0.033155106008052826, 0.025447554886341095, -0.015503549948334694, 0.00782126933336258, -0.00608707033097744, 0.00844040047377348, -0.03967493772506714, -0.00808029342442751, -0.009722886607050896, -0.015705715864896774, -0.02658473514020443, -0.011466561816632748, -0.047559380531311035, -0.00047579914098605514, 0.018902454525232315, 0.01552882045507431, 0.03285185992717743, 0.02941504865884781, -0.038739923387765884, -0.038461945950984955, 0.02020389214158058, 0.0425557903945446, 0.004760360810905695, -0.001043994096107781, -0.05807197839021683, -0.011826668865978718, -0.021442154422402382, -0.02693852409720421, -0.0002023627021117136, -0.0071136909537017345, 0.04412257298827171, 0.010897972621023655, 0.008370906114578247, 0.0032978211529552937, 0.004052781965583563, -0.009299603290855885, -0.02235189825296402, 0.045765165239572525, -0.01075898390263319, -0.01656491681933403, 0.022579334676265717, -0.01604686863720417, -0.018017981201410294, -0.0001660361303947866, -0.0008244552882388234, -0.005104673560708761, -0.020936742424964905, 0.006459812633693218, 0.008471989072859287, -0.007638057228177786, 0.009002672508358955, -0.0017136665992438793, 0.002866640454158187, -0.025674991309642792, -0.019888009876012802, 0.01245211809873581, 0.01763891987502575, -0.01604686863720417, -0.012635329738259315, 0.011447609402239323, -0.010910607874393463, 0.01279327180236578, -0.018308592960238457, 0.029364507645368576, 0.007688598241657019, -0.03828505054116249, -0.020406058058142662, 0.012698506936430931, 0.0019205701537430286, 0.008206646889448166, 0.013759874738752842, -0.0424799807369709, 0.01063894759863615, -0.001994802849367261, -0.012881718575954437, -0.007657010108232498, 0.03896735608577728, -0.0163248460739851, -0.007871810346841812, 0.0043813008815050125, -0.009103755466639996, 0.0014341099886223674, 0.05332109332084656, 0.011927751824259758, 0.004845649003982544, 0.020140716806054115, 0.007170549593865871, -0.001347242039628327, 0.008693107403814793, -0.010392558760941029, -0.02172013185918331, 0.011163313873112202, 0.009533356875181198, 0.010601041838526726, -0.0451081283390522, -0.02399449236690998, -0.015819434076547623, -0.01187720987945795, -0.009015307761728764, 0.011491832323372364, 0.003995923325419426, 0.007966575212776661, 0.006639866158366203, -0.01305229589343071, 0.006557736080139875, 0.027165960520505905, 0.030046815052628517, -0.010095628909766674, 0.013203919865190983, -0.003032479202374816, 0.013620886020362377, -0.048646021634340286, -0.01669127121567726, -0.005704851355403662, 0.005960716865956783, -0.03644029051065445, -0.025776073336601257, -0.035707443952560425, 0.009268014691770077, 0.006930478382855654, 0.013102836906909943, 0.04344026371836662, 0.02442409284412861, 0.021821215748786926, -0.029768837615847588, -0.01057577133178711, 0.02913707122206688, 0.038183968514204025, -0.009217473678290844, -0.0035473688039928675, 0.005354220978915691, -0.019572125747799873, 0.014593806117773056, -0.022806771099567413, -0.007448527030646801, 0.029718296602368355, 0.011523420922458172, 0.013443991541862488, -0.01456853561103344, -0.0021811737678945065, -0.006892572622746229, 0.06433910131454468, -0.027797726914286613, -0.008288776502013206, -0.0002852820616681129, 0.008023434318602085, 0.0009579159668646753, 0.01911725476384163, 0.024285104125738144, 0.017588378861546516, -0.011131726205348969, 0.015364561229944229, -0.003812710754573345, -0.0011948284227401018, 0.0014862306416034698, 0.011567644774913788, 0.0012809066101908684, -0.03555581718683243, 0.025055859237909317, -0.015718350186944008, -0.000612813513725996, -0.016628094017505646, -0.012464753352105618, -0.008067658171057701, 0.044526904821395874, -0.018750829622149467, -0.01736094430088997, -0.005054132081568241, 0.015377196483314037, 0.011188584379851818, 0.004365506581962109, -0.0032630739733576775, -0.009331190958619118, -0.0010392558760941029, -0.010929560288786888, -0.02969302609562874, -0.008806824684143066, 0.016666000708937645, 0.000913692289032042, 0.014555900357663631, -0.008168741129338741, 0.03889154642820358, 0.022655146196484566, 0.02578870952129364, -0.006684089545160532, -0.011314937844872475, -0.006879937369376421, 0.014871783554553986, 0.042454708367586136, -0.02693852409720421, -0.0030166851356625557, -0.02530856616795063, -0.026357298716902733, 0.013140743598341942, -0.013999945484101772, 0.033711060881614685, -0.0026186720933765173, 0.011131726205348969, 0.02726704254746437, 0.038815733045339584, -0.02115154266357422, -0.013140743598341942, -0.04940414056181908, -0.03876519203186035, -0.0005567442276515067, 0.005575339309871197, -0.013582980260252953, 0.025245388969779015, 0.01824541576206684, 0.01377250999212265, -0.045967329293489456, -0.007846539840102196, 0.0016117943450808525, -0.00888263713568449, 0.016135316342115402, 0.00025112717412412167, 0.012508977204561234, -0.019546855241060257, -0.006526147946715355, -0.010954830795526505, -0.0027244931552559137, -0.000604916422162205, -0.030425874516367912, -0.0024907393380999565, 0.03676880896091461, -0.023893408477306366, -0.00896476674824953, 0.013241825625300407, -0.01928151398897171, -0.03820923715829849, 0.006860984023660421, 0.004883555229753256, -0.020696669816970825, -0.0008749965927563608, 0.029591942206025124, 0.012041469104588032, 0.022806771099567413, -0.01235103514045477, -0.0015983692137524486, 0.03318037837743759, 0.01867501810193062, -0.000905795197468251, 0.01684289425611496, 0.013532438315451145, -0.012749047949910164, 0.007916034199297428, 0.03148724138736725, 0.000608470116276294, -0.039295878261327744, -0.008219282142817974, -0.00762542150914669, 0.022642511874437332, 0.0237923264503479, -0.010651582852005959, -0.008655200712382793, 0.003913793712854385, 0.035909608006477356, 0.017272496595978737, -0.00043670859304256737, 0.016817623749375343, -0.01991328038275242, 0.008813142776489258, 0.007202138192951679, 0.02486632950603962, -0.020052269101142883, 0.00009599889745004475, -0.011731904000043869, -0.000603337015490979, -0.011144361458718777, -0.018649747595191002, -0.003989605698734522, -0.008111882023513317, 0.007454844657331705, 0.025611814111471176, 0.003468398004770279, 0.020532410591840744, 0.008560435846447945, 0.005370015278458595, -0.014934959821403027, 0.04738248884677887, 0.01075898390263319, -0.011308620683848858, 0.02295839414000511, -0.04381932318210602, -0.035631630569696426, -0.0031367207411676645, -0.028631657361984253, -0.007379032671451569, 0.005929128732532263, 0.029238153249025345, 0.0034557627514004707, -0.032952941954135895, 0.009457544423639774, 0.01652701199054718, 0.0009492291719652712, 0.005629039369523525, -0.0049941143952310085, -0.013646156527101994, 0.02578870952129364, -0.04450163245201111, -0.005603768862783909, -0.010348334908485413, 0.0028113608714193106, -0.02870747074484825, 0.03131034970283508, 0.025725532323122025, -0.03320564702153206, 0.00011460639507276937, -0.005565863102674484, -0.03848721459507942, -0.012136234901845455, -0.03325618803501129, 0.008048704825341702, -0.006734631024301052, 0.003182523651048541, -0.05016225948929787, -0.0012816962553188205, 0.017790544778108597, 0.002479683607816696, -0.016425929963588715, -0.012123599648475647, -0.017777908593416214, -0.04882291704416275, 0.021846486255526543, -0.020368151366710663, -0.0005697744200006127, 0.017184048891067505, -0.0053668562322855, 0.014808607287704945, 0.024815788492560387, -0.006106023211032152, -0.01021566428244114, -0.01518766675144434, 0.0012919624568894506, -0.016906071454286575, 0.04568935185670853, 0.06833186745643616, -0.015149760991334915, -0.02994573302567005, -0.005941763985902071, 0.033989038318395615, -0.0070189256221055984, -0.03105764091014862, 0.019888009876012802, -0.004668754525482655, 0.016956612467765808, 0.015377196483314037, -0.02906125970184803, 0.01815696991980076, -0.005436350591480732, 0.033711060881614685, -0.011573961935937405, -0.010430464521050453, 0.009988228790462017, 0.018814006820321083, 0.012736412696540356, 0.027999890968203545, -0.019685843959450722, 0.027772454544901848, -0.021581143140792847, 0.03727422282099724, 0.045360833406448364, -0.03747639060020447, 0.007897080853581429, 0.01915515959262848, 0.0003508278459776193, 0.0174114853143692, 0.015996327623724937, 0.007739139720797539, -0.004084370564669371, 0.0010487324325367808, -0.025283295661211014, -0.039978183805942535, -0.016716541722416878, -0.011169631965458393, 0.006267123855650425, 0.023564890027046204, -0.04351607710123062, -0.04311174526810646, -0.02562444843351841, 0.009444909170269966, 0.006466130260378122, -0.013456626795232296, 0.00029989166068844497, 0.0006834923988208175, 0.01955949142575264, 0.023501714691519737, 0.036187585443258286, -0.020772483199834824, -0.012047787196934223, -0.0018447581678628922, -0.006860984023660421, 0.02650892175734043, 0.0037368987686932087, -0.03312983363866806, -0.00022486939269583672, 0.016590189188718796, -0.0023880773223936558, -0.021770672872662544, -0.029162341728806496, 0.008029752410948277, -0.04296012222766876, -0.00019584762048907578, 0.009451227262616158, 0.010923243127763271, 0.0011766650713980198, -0.024171385914087296, -0.017752638086676598, 0.018295958638191223, -0.009868192486464977, 0.01732303760945797, 0.00022407967480830848, -0.022971030324697495, 0.004308647476136684, 0.0019095143070444465, 0.023880774155259132, 0.02338799647986889, 0.002762399148195982, -0.00952072162181139, 0.006949431728571653, 0.013987310230731964, 0.03555581718683243, -0.02650892175734043, 0.04571462422609329, -0.009849240072071552, -0.024575717747211456, -0.003787440247833729, -0.0026771104894578457, -0.008219282142817974, -0.024057667702436447, 0.027292313054203987, 0.019369961693882942, 0.014416911639273167, -0.0025586544070392847, -0.048039525747299194, -0.010443100705742836, 0.0032535975333303213, -0.02295839414000511, -0.028404222801327705, 0.007758092600852251, -0.028530575335025787, 0.020658764988183975, 0.023286912590265274, -0.0039832876063883305, -0.03229590505361557, 0.016274305060505867, 0.011864574626088142, -0.0225540641695261, -0.0188013706356287, 0.01225627027451992, -0.024841058999300003, 0.017790544778108597, -0.009899781085550785, 0.009798698127269745, 0.040053997188806534, 0.015933150425553322, 0.012723777443170547, 0.008844731375575066, 0.08607187122106552, 0.01075898390263319, 0.021252624690532684, -0.013886227272450924, 0.005259456112980843, 0.025397013872861862, 0.0008212964748963714, 0.06615858525037766, 0.03863883763551712, 0.010645265690982342, 0.029162341728806496, 0.012300494126975536, -0.033711060881614685, -0.004213882610201836, -0.017424119636416435, 0.01225627027451992, 0.03093128837645054, -0.01311547216027975, 0.012218364514410496, -0.00038320585736073554, 0.0037211047019809484, -0.030425874516367912, -0.02271832339465618, -0.01525084301829338, -0.004558195360004902, 0.0014964969595894217, -0.01484651304781437, -0.005401603411883116, 0.010013499297201633, -0.018232781440019608, 0.012218364514410496, -0.027949349954724312, -0.01972375065088272, 0.005291044246405363, 0.009640756994485855, -0.008787872269749641, -0.012540564872324467, 0.0578698106110096, 0.025776073336601257, 0.012919625267386436, -0.023249007761478424, 0.027721913531422615, 0.0009555468568578362, 0.0012050946243107319, 0.000027664462322718464, -0.0009705512784421444, 0.007151596713811159, -0.003809551941230893, -0.01552882045507431, 0.02292048931121826, -0.025321202352643013, -0.0026486811693757772, -0.013254460878670216, -0.012647964991629124, 0.022680416703224182, 0.005464780144393444, 0.005581656936556101, -0.03785545006394386, -0.03649083152413368, 0.018573936074972153, -0.006466130260378122, 0.02179594524204731, 0.0016204810235649347, 0.023463808000087738, 0.02734285406768322, -0.010980102233588696, -0.009261696599423885, 0.011675044894218445, -0.00960285123437643, -0.02551073208451271, 0.04932832717895508, 0.003790599061176181 ]
13.970444
8.298431
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.tmp.1655G
[ "strong Mg II absorbers", "Mg II absorption", "Mg II", "low impact parameters", "such low impact parameters", "such impact parameters", "impact parameter", "Ca II", "Galaxy parameters", "Mn II" ]
[ "galaxies: evolution", "galaxies: groups: general", "galaxies: haloes", "galaxies: high-redshift", "quasars: absorption lines", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
8
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1675", "10.48550/arXiv.2407.04096" ]
[ "Guha, Labanya Kumar", "Srianand, Raghunathan" ]
[ "Inter-University Centre for Astronomy &amp; Astrophysics, Pune 411007, India", "Inter-University Centre for Astronomy &amp; Astrophysics, Pune 411007, India" ]
null
[ "1986SPIE..627..733T", "1991A&A...243..344B", "1991PASP..103..923S", "1995qal..conf..139S", "1998ARA&A..36..189K", "2003ApJ...594..279G", "2005MNRAS.361L..30W", "2006MNRAS.367..211W", "2007CSE.....9...90H", "2010ApJ...714.1521C", "2010MNRAS.403..906N", "2010SPIE.7737E..25C", "2011MNRAS.416.1871B", "2012ApJ...760...49L", "2012ApJ...760L...7K", "2012MNRAS.423.3692Y", "2012MNRAS.426..801B", "2013A&A...558A..33A", "2013ApJ...770..130Z", "2013ApJ...776..115N", "2013ApJ...777L..11K", "2015A&A...580A...8L", "2015MNRAS.447.3856S", "2015MNRAS.451.1806D", "2015MNRAS.452..511M", "2015MNRAS.452.3192S", "2016A&A...585A..87S", "2016MNRAS.461.1076C", "2016MNRAS.463..980R", "2017MNRAS.471.1910J", "2018AJ....156..123A", "2018MNRAS.476..210J", "2018MNRAS.480.4379C", "2019AJ....157..168D", "2019ApJ...873...44C", "2019ApJ...882...76B", "2019ApJ...885..160B", "2019MNRAS.490.4368S", "2020MNRAS.498.1140H", "2020MNRAS.499.5022D", "2020Natur.585..357H", "2021ApJ...913...50L", "2021JOSS....6.3001B", "2021MNRAS.502.4743H", "2022ApJ...929..150K", "2022ApJ...936..171R", "2022MNRAS.513.3836G", "2023MNRAS.518.5590F", "2023MNRAS.519.3319G", "2024ApJ...962..176W", "2024MNRAS.527.5075G" ]
29184258
2401.11997
PAC. V. The Roles of Mass and Environment in the Quenching of Galaxies
The roles that mass and environment play in galaxy quenching are still under debate. Leveraging the Photometric objects Around Cosmic webs method, we analyze the excess surface distribution of photometric galaxies in different colors (rest-frame u ‑ r) within the stellar mass range of 10<SUP>9.0</SUP> ∼ 10<SUP>11.0</SUP> M <SUB>⊙</SUB> around spectroscopic massive central galaxies (10<SUP>10.9</SUP> ∼ 10<SUP>11.7</SUP> M <SUB>⊙</SUB>) at the redshift interval of 0 &lt; z <SUB> s </SUB> &lt; 0.7, utilizing data from the Hyper Suprime-Cam Subaru Strategic Program and the spectroscopic samples of Slogan Digital Sky Survey (i.e., Main, LOWZ, and CMASS samples). We find that both mass and environmental quenching contribute to the evolution of companion galaxies. To isolate the environmental effect, we quantify the quenched fraction excess (QFE) of companion galaxies encircling massive central galaxies within 0.01h <SUP>‑1</SUP> Mpc &lt; r <SUB>p</SUB> &lt; 20h <SUP>‑1</SUP> Mpc, representing the surplus quenched fraction relative to the average. We find that the high-density halo environment affects star formation quenching up to about three times the virial radius, and this effect becomes stronger at lower redshift. We also find that even after being scaled by the virial radius, the environmental quenching efficiency is higher for more massive halos or for companion galaxies of higher stellar mass, though the trends are quite weak. We present a fitting formula that comprehensively captures the QFE across central and companion stellar mass bins, halo-centric distance bins, and redshift bins, offering a valuable tool for constraining galaxy formation models. Furthermore, we have made a quantitative comparison with IllustrisTNG that underscores some important differences, particularly in the excessive quenching of low-mass companion galaxies (&lt;10<SUP>9.5</SUP> M <SUB>⊙</SUB>) in the simulation.
[ 0.021483812481164932, 0.04291604459285736, 0.02371472492814064, 0.010870860889554024, 0.01828574202954769, 0.039460062980651855, 0.020039523020386696, 0.039460062980651855, -0.0026129395700991154, 0.0435866080224514, -0.010825726203620434, 0.009304064325988293, -0.06447722762823105, -0.01448158547282219, 0.05761685222387314, 0.005867427680641413, -0.0085819186642766, 0.01548743061721325, -0.015564803034067154, 0.04662993177771568, 0.013682067394256592, 0.013772335834801197, -0.0200911033898592, 0.033760275691747665, -0.07649578154087067, -0.008014519698917866, 0.00599638232961297, 0.02713201753795147, 0.06406457722187042, -0.025197701528668404, 0.03917636349797249, -0.006460618227720261, -0.05060172826051712, -0.02194804884493351, -0.04789368435740471, 0.08753428608179092, 0.011696169152855873, -0.007331060711294413, -0.051684945821762085, 0.006750765722244978, -0.000007020713837846415, -0.004107199609279633, 0.010703220032155514, -0.008942991495132446, -0.02255413495004177, -0.008388487622141838, -0.010355043224990368, -0.02456582337617874, 0.005338714458048344, -0.027003062888979912, -0.0418844074010849, 0.003626844147220254, -0.0003463636094238609, -0.0004763255128636956, 0.0007205330184660852, -0.02478504739701748, -0.03752574697136879, 0.020826144143939018, 0.004381227772682905, -0.005238774698227644, 0.00715697230771184, -0.013591799885034561, -0.002110017230734229, 0.052871327847242355, -0.011515633203089237, 0.0230441614985466, -0.007350403815507889, -0.022154375910758972, -0.018724186345934868, 0.011831571348011494, -0.0159129798412323, -0.017782820388674736, 0.01584850251674652, 0.005680443719029427, 0.03564301133155823, -0.03082011453807354, 0.04755840450525284, -0.02865367941558361, -0.027338344603776932, -0.0030642803758382797, 0.03719046339392662, -0.002100345678627491, -0.02036190778017044, 0.009368541650474072, -0.050859637558460236, 0.006154351402074099, 0.009652241133153439, -0.0060221729800105095, -0.07345245778560638, 0.03791261091828346, 0.02648724615573883, 0.0025968204718083143, -0.0011992764193564653, -0.039279527962207794, 0.0028031475376337767, -0.036442529410123825, 0.040801189839839935, -0.05462510883808136, 0.04203915223479271, 0.043792933225631714, -0.012689118273556232, 0.0023292398545891047, -0.00911707989871502, -0.05462510883808136, 0.04343185946345329, -0.0351787768304348, -0.02612617239356041, 0.01658354327082634, 0.024372391402721405, 0.005741697270423174, 0.0511433370411396, 0.003423740854486823, -0.013449950143694878, 0.046346232295036316, -0.058390576392412186, 0.0003929081140086055, -0.0511433370411396, 0.013282309286296368, -0.013514427468180656, 0.017138047143816948, -0.002890191739425063, -0.028911588713526726, -0.005867427680641413, 0.0031609961297363043, 0.027596253901720047, -0.03285759687423706, 0.017795715481042862, -0.03084590658545494, -0.024527138099074364, -0.013005057349801064, 0.05596623569726944, -0.0023663141764700413, -0.0048454636707901955, -0.012386075221002102, -0.047506820410490036, -0.004764867015182972, -0.004681046586483717, -0.03969218209385872, -0.010496892966330051, -0.04221968725323677, -0.0343792587518692, 0.023082846775650978, -0.007763058412820101, 0.038634754717350006, 0.024411078542470932, 0.01993635855615139, -0.03832526504993439, -0.0009945612400770187, 0.02380499243736267, 0.008646395988762379, -0.020413490012288094, -0.01761517859995365, -0.041961781680583954, -0.05962853878736496, 0.009110632352530956, -0.007840431295335293, 0.028860006481409073, 0.038763709366321564, -0.029607942327857018, -0.04407663270831108, -0.009897254407405853, -0.013785230927169323, -0.028395771980285645, -0.02219306118786335, 0.0014491257024928927, -0.002193837659433484, -0.008833380416035652, 0.04340606927871704, -0.09604527801275253, 0.0025726414751261473, -0.009639346040785313, 0.013604694977402687, 0.005599847063422203, -0.06060859560966492, 0.03502403199672699, 0.026409871876239777, -0.02715780772268772, -0.00832401029765606, -0.0049840896390378475, 0.03332183137536049, 0.013952871784567833, 0.02127748541533947, 0.009046155028045177, -0.013179145753383636, -0.023856574669480324, 0.025623250752687454, -0.04526301473379135, 0.016622228547930717, 0.007008674554526806, -0.011096530593931675, -0.020581131801009178, 0.019046572968363762, -0.027879953384399414, 0.008988125249743462, -0.03118118830025196, -0.004645584151148796, 0.005980262998491526, 0.036803603172302246, -0.022296225652098656, 0.008285324089229107, 0.034121349453926086, -0.005200088489800692, 0.021690139546990395, -0.06617942452430725, -0.005609518848359585, -0.04407663270831108, 0.031568050384521484, -0.013166249729692936, 0.002417895942926407, -0.014765284955501556, 0.04389609768986702, 0.03749995678663254, 0.0007318165153264999, 0.0007148912409320474, -0.026745153591036797, 0.014842658303678036, -0.07334929704666138, 0.02621644176542759, 0.011077187955379486, 0.06638575345277786, -0.010961128398776054, 0.0352303571999073, 0.051504410803318024, 0.018891828134655952, -0.00040439312579110265, -0.0115220807492733, 0.020039523020386696, -0.01856944151222706, 0.033270251005887985, -0.021896466612815857, 0.020980890840291977, 0.02277335710823536, -0.028602099046111107, -0.028885798528790474, -0.00462624104693532, -0.041961781680583954, -0.020594026893377304, 0.06844902783632278, 0.008143474347889423, -0.02594563737511635, -0.0485384576022625, 0.0036107248160988092, 0.03713888302445412, 0.024772150442004204, 0.005948024336248636, 0.016132201999425888, -0.017602283507585526, -0.02411448396742344, -0.01600324735045433, -0.002081002574414015, 0.04905427619814873, 0.0008357860497198999, -0.017331479117274284, -0.04031116142868996, -0.01752491109073162, -0.003655858803540468, 0.01364338118582964, 0.03265126794576645, -0.017176734283566475, 0.007763058412820101, -0.02746729925274849, -0.03904740884900093, -0.006215604953467846, -0.01835021935403347, -0.011541423387825489, 0.03504982218146324, 0.011141665279865265, -0.009684479795396328, -0.03832526504993439, 0.0721113309264183, -0.0007406821823678911, -0.03907319903373718, 0.019227109849452972, -0.05679154396057129, -0.06463197618722916, 0.029195288196206093, 0.02898896113038063, 0.011715512722730637, 0.012611745856702328, -0.030072178691625595, 0.00525811780244112, -0.015268207527697086, 0.017666760832071304, 0.003073951927945018, -0.024436868727207184, 0.005132387392222881, 0.020748771727085114, 0.031568050384521484, -0.0038557383231818676, 0.000681846693623811, 0.07742425799369812, -0.05080805718898773, 0.007698581088334322, 0.017821505665779114, -0.04335448890924454, -0.007705028634518385, -0.015306893736124039, 0.01118679903447628, -0.038454219698905945, 0.019833195954561234, 0.05307765305042267, 0.050833847373723984, -0.02572641335427761, 0.033270251005887985, -0.014223676174879074, -0.0045037344098091125, 0.06886167824268341, -0.027003062888979912, -0.032444942742586136, 0.044979315251111984, 0.008169264532625675, 0.009439466521143913, 0.008420726284384727, 0.04972483962774277, -0.02493979223072529, -0.058235831558704376, -0.05462510883808136, 0.05606939643621445, 0.025404028594493866, -0.018466278910636902, -0.026899900287389755, -0.03806735575199127, -0.03621041029691696, 0.005138834938406944, 0.018827350810170174, -0.04490194097161293, -0.05813266709446907, 0.018130997195839882, -0.04152333363890648, -0.036958348006010056, 0.02965952455997467, 0.0017038107616826892, 0.04492773115634918, -0.009884359315037727, -0.0005311311688274145, -0.03497244790196419, 0.00782108772546053, 0.03218703344464302, -0.003626844147220254, 0.0028982514049857855, 0.00034515466541051865, -0.00849165115505457, 0.007002227008342743, -0.015100566670298576, 0.0037590223364531994, 0.01039372943341732, 0.02749308943748474, 0.02901475317776203, 0.06473513692617416, -0.01498450804501772, -0.00882693286985159, 0.012308702804148197, 0.01531978975981474, -0.03520456701517105, 0.09181557595729828, -0.0318775400519371, 0.019923463463783264, -0.03646831959486008, -0.03572038561105728, 0.02563614584505558, 0.03904740884900093, -0.008543232455849648, 0.028550516813993454, -0.01920131780207157, -0.040646445006132126, 0.0352303571999073, -0.012134614400565624, 0.02932424284517765, -0.010193849913775921, -0.02552008628845215, -0.023792097344994545, 0.034766122698783875, -0.01856944151222706, -0.0047326283529400826, -0.0586484856903553, -0.005287132691591978, 0.012089480645954609, 0.0061898138374090195, -0.01054847426712513, -0.012598850764334202, 0.04090435430407524, -0.013398367911577225, 0.0038363949861377478, -0.04185861721634865, 0.0035559190437197685, 0.03198070451617241, -0.047016795724630356, -0.011206142604351044, -0.11368624866008759, 0.020465072244405746, 0.012437657453119755, -0.014546062797307968, 0.007743715308606625, -0.0031932347919791937, 0.027750998735427856, 0.006847481708973646, 0.029092125594615936, 0.07252398878335953, 0.01167682558298111, 0.032264403998851776, 0.0013556337216868997, -0.011231932789087296, -0.03234177827835083, -0.020594026893377304, -0.023817887529730797, 0.004903492983430624, -0.031748585402965546, 0.023147324100136757, -0.001794078852981329, -0.03690676391124725, 0.03904740884900093, -0.01600324735045433, -0.00972316600382328, -0.00364618725143373, 0.012334493920207024, 0.010335699655115604, -0.05227813497185707, 0.020387699827551842, -0.03396660462021828, 0.0460883229970932, -0.04118805378675461, -0.04291604459285736, 0.045675668865442276, 0.02581668272614479, -0.032444942742586136, 0.011180351488292217, 0.013694963417947292, 0.01148984208703041, -0.029917433857917786, -0.06958382576704025, -0.04454087093472481, 0.022089898586273193, 0.03100065141916275, 0.022760462015867233, 0.004974418319761753, -0.030768534168601036, -0.01615799404680729, -0.0246947780251503, 0.000038585592847084627, -0.024501346051692963, 0.021651452407240868, -0.058235831558704376, 0.00782108772546053, -0.010084238834679127, 0.016299843788146973, 0.00712473364546895, 0.04454087093472481, 0.022657297551631927, 0.0205166544765234, -0.020168477669358253, -0.0318259596824646, -0.025404028594493866, 0.02947898954153061, 0.029556361958384514, -0.04559829458594322, -0.037938401103019714, 0.02984006144106388, -0.006131784524768591, 0.019613971933722496, -0.05328398197889328, -0.0205166544765234, 0.007892012596130371, -0.005042119417339563, 0.027544671669602394, -0.0013910961570218205, 0.02067139931023121, 0.009194452315568924, 0.033734485507011414, 0.007833982817828655, 0.03355395048856735, 0.030716951936483383, -0.03406976908445358, 0.01908526010811329, -0.018066519871354103, -0.014881344512104988, -0.02335365116596222, -0.0024291796144098043, 0.03481770306825638, 0.05735894292593002, 0.007505149580538273, 0.037783656269311905, -0.012708461843430996, -0.0006165634840726852, 0.01951080933213234, -0.0060221729800105095, 0.03180016949772835, -0.017963355407118797, 0.012637536972761154, 0.006834586150944233, -0.016480378806591034, -0.019485019147396088, -0.00792425125837326, 0.05560516193509102, -0.013669172301888466, 0.02996901609003544, -0.0008938155951909721, -0.007911356166005135, 0.013295204378664494, -0.013875499367713928, 0.023495502769947052, 0.025894055142998695, 0.0005887576844543219, 0.013217831961810589, -0.04038853570818901, 0.00871732085943222, -0.005138834938406944, 0.01211527083069086, -0.024797942489385605, 0.005506355315446854, 0.018092310056090355, -0.003504337277263403, -0.00732461316511035, 0.005370953120291233, -0.003127145580947399, -0.008910752832889557, 0.02331496588885784, -0.004490838851779699, 0.031129606068134308, 0.02867947146296501, 0.01054847426712513, 0.02154828980565071, -0.026899900287389755, -0.0018811231711879373, 0.01929158717393875, 0.02800890803337097, 0.0360298752784729, -0.024307915940880775, -0.07319454848766327, -0.009549077600240707, -0.05937063321471214, 0.0035269043873995543, -0.04557250440120697, 0.019987940788269043, -0.0011275454889982939, -0.02646145410835743, -0.03404397517442703, -0.001467662863433361, -0.00891720037907362, 0.00018889813509304076, -0.05088542774319649, 0.04211652651429176, -0.015706652775406837, -0.0062736342661082745, 0.01168972160667181, 0.02259282022714615, 0.07763057947158813, -0.012508582323789597, 0.0013032460119575262, 0.019472122192382812, 0.0029917433857917786, 0.02713201753795147, -0.01685434766113758, 0.016506170853972435, 0.02295389398932457, 0.025507191196084023, 0.008188608102500439, -0.014803971163928509, -0.001245216466486454, -0.022747566923499107, 0.012276464141905308, -0.024282123893499374, -0.010129372589290142, 0.0048454636707901955, 0.013159802183508873, -0.01649327576160431, -0.05227813497185707, 0.03587513044476509, -0.0026500141248106956, -0.015229521319270134, 0.0014265587087720633, -0.031593840569257736, -0.0019730031490325928, -0.013566008768975735, -0.024423973634839058, 0.02539113163948059, -0.021264590322971344, -0.001304051955230534, 0.041652288287878036, 0.01381102204322815, -0.03922794386744499, -0.0188402459025383, -0.00005193439210415818, 0.003562366822734475, 0.02393394708633423, -0.053696636110544205, -0.01021319255232811, -0.009632897563278675, -0.017911773175001144, 0.005867427680641413, 0.014030245132744312, 0.018711291253566742, -0.019613971933722496, -0.016132201999425888, 0.01036149077117443, -0.016222471371293068, 0.025507191196084023, 0.04376714304089546, 0.005664324387907982, -0.0011388290440663695, -0.002045540139079094, -0.009155766107141972, -0.006686288397759199, -0.05617256090044975, -0.020258745178580284, -0.035127192735672, 0.016635125502943993, 0.01252792589366436, -0.029762689024209976, -0.043663978576660156, 0.013875499367713928, 0.006060859654098749, -0.012714909389615059, -0.04495352506637573, -0.007698581088334322, 0.024759255349636078, -0.007724371738731861, 0.029427407309412956, -0.02109694853425026, 0.0013620815007016063, 0.018801560625433922, -0.019897673279047012, 0.012463448569178581, 0.0007467268733307719, 0.005396743770688772, 0.06612784415483475, 0.018311532214283943, -0.01399155892431736, -0.014339735731482506, 0.007943594828248024, -0.03992430120706558, 0.003800932550802827, -0.047661565244197845, -0.00044892271398566663, 0.005516027100384235, -0.015809817239642143, 0.01689303293824196, 0.02219306118786335, 0.01953659951686859, 0.005509579088538885, -0.006628259085118771, 0.05426403507590294, -0.013553113676607609, 0.011064291931688786, -0.024411078542470932, -0.007118286099284887, 0.020748771727085114, -0.020581131801009178, 0.0010090685682371259, -0.02916949801146984, -0.0023598666302859783, -0.0019246452720835805, -0.03350236639380455, -0.024617405608296394, -0.017138047143816948, 0.024668987840414047, 0.013030847534537315, -0.004004036076366901, 0.009200900793075562, -0.044979315251111984, 0.029762689024209976, 0.004107199609279633, -0.0100455516949296, 0.005042119417339563, 0.018272846937179565, -0.004016931168735027, -0.0063510071486234665, 0.008646395988762379, 0.020245850086212158, -0.011064291931688786, 0.018066519871354103, 0.07515465468168259, 0.008420726284384727, 0.009329854510724545, 0.040465909987688065, 0.016867242753505707, -0.010277669876813889, 0.008465860038995743, -0.029556361958384514, -0.013346786610782146, 0.015306893736124039, -0.031052233651280403, -0.003304457990452647, -0.005670772399753332, -0.004249049350619316, 0.0064058126881718636, 0.0036687543615698814, 0.011534975841641426, -0.0014394541503861547, 0.004439257085323334, 0.02867947146296501, -0.0012895445106551051, 0.023276278749108315, 0.04544354975223541, -0.006692736409604549, -0.0238952599465847, 0.0022018973249942064, -0.003375382861122489, 0.01597745716571808, 0.019472122192382812, -0.03334762156009674, -0.009484600275754929, 0.02503005973994732, 0.021470917388796806, -0.03143909573554993, -0.031568050384521484, -0.029762689024209976, -0.027570461854338646, 0.018582336604595184, 0.013134011067450047, -0.012463448569178581, 0.04219389706850052, 0.04691363126039505, -0.0318775400519371, -0.02230912074446678, 0.016725393012166023, -0.020619817078113556, 0.003241592552512884, 0.016570648178458214, -0.01148984208703041, -0.004474719520658255, -0.007401985581964254, -0.008040310814976692, -0.06401298940181732, 0.00649285688996315, 0.028782634064555168, -0.021715929731726646, 0.0343792587518692, -0.004477943293750286, 0.01795046031475067, -0.003671978134661913, 0.01765386573970318, -0.009304064325988293, -0.005641757510602474, -0.006666945293545723, 0.02478504739701748, 0.028421562165021896, 0.027338344603776932, -0.0263711865991354, 0.0268225260078907, 0.02715780772268772, -0.006228500045835972, 0.00011757019819924608, 0.020439282059669495, -0.016222471371293068, 0.017383061349391937, 0.013772335834801197, 0.012005659751594067, -0.0008704425999894738, -0.0014886179706081748, -0.034405048936605453, 0.0030997428111732006, 0.010799936018884182, 0.01541005726903677, 0.01749911904335022, 0.02152249962091446, -0.05885481461882591, 0.019652659073472023, -0.0007991146412678063, 0.024888209998607635, 0.024862419813871384, 0.02060692198574543, 0.0050066569820046425, -0.017731238156557083, 0.021780407056212425, -0.03866054490208626, 0.0351787768304348, -0.042658135294914246, -0.013114668428897858, 0.026770945638418198, -0.019007887691259384, -0.005254894029349089, 0.003623620141297579, 0.0010945009998977184, -0.006180142518132925, 0.014107617549598217, -0.010174506343901157, 0.0068926154635846615, 0.008085444569587708, -0.003172279568389058, 0.006815243046730757, 0.007363299373537302, -0.04639781266450882, 0.0016070948913693428, -0.035462476313114166, -0.03703571856021881, 0.02072298154234886, -0.0016070948913693428, -0.03466295823454857, 0.0013056638417765498, 0.0054870122112333775, -0.00882693286985159, 0.004506958182901144, -0.01618378423154354, 0.028447352349758148, -0.007563178893178701, 0.03891845420002937, -0.002445298945531249, -0.10625847429037094, 0.008485203608870506, 0.0033076817635446787, 0.018130997195839882, 0.02201252616941929, 0.05395454540848732, -0.033115506172180176, 0.022567030042409897, 0.026899900287389755, -0.001388678327202797, 0.016905929893255234, -0.007518044672906399, 0.024578718468546867, 0.010993367061018944, 0.025068746879696846, -0.04389609768986702, -0.010890203528106213, 0.033089712262153625, 0.026899900287389755, -0.007679237984120846, 0.0063510071486234665, 0.0014507375890389085, -0.00729237450286746, -0.011476946994662285, 0.009645793586969376, -0.01525531243532896, -0.0334765762090683, 0.008510993793606758, 0.00845941249281168, -0.012631089426577091, 0.01232804637402296, -0.03252231329679489, -0.02862788923084736, 0.032444942742586136, -0.021960943937301636, 0.0034463077317923307, 0.015616384334862232, 0.017447538673877716, -0.04995695501565933, -0.0115220807492733, 0.003588157705962658, -0.018788663670420647, 0.03167121484875679, 0.01874997839331627, 0.009626450017094612, -0.0034817703999578953, -0.004210363142192364, 0.01942054182291031, 0.003739679232239723, 0.006341335363686085, -0.015293998643755913, 0.029582152143120766, 0.01068387646228075, 0.02261861227452755, 0.022450970485806465, 0.012869655154645443, 0.012772939167916775, 0.006686288397759199, -0.002890191739425063, -0.00779529707506299, -0.021251695230603218, 0.009175109677016735, -0.02243807539343834, -0.06989331543445587, -0.030613787472248077, -0.018827350810170174, -0.030123760923743248, 0.010812831111252308, -0.014262363314628601, -0.009155766107141972, 0.009697374887764454, 0.03868633508682251, 0.03048483282327652, 0.029040543362498283, -0.009407227858901024, -0.014017349109053612, -0.007034465670585632, -0.022205958142876625, -0.042993415147066116, 0.023663142696022987, -0.04209073632955551, -0.012044345960021019, 0.0006459812284447253, -0.00569333927705884, -0.006537991110235453, 0.0351787768304348, 0.0014273646520450711, -0.016686705872416496, -0.008137025870382786, 0.011483394540846348, 0.012895445339381695, -0.014610540121793747, 0.01582271233201027, 0.003849290544167161, -0.02862788923084736, 0.01761517859995365, -0.01975582353770733, -0.03574617579579353, 0.015190835110843182, -0.022077003493905067, -0.03399239480495453, -0.03466295823454857, -0.00712473364546895, -0.03651990368962288, 0.0009381436975672841, -0.0026806406676769257, -0.01148984208703041, 0.010845069773495197, 0.042735505849123, 0.0032448165584355593, 0.04134279862046242, 0.014610540121793747, -0.005161402281373739, 0.038789499551057816, 0.03463716804981232, 0.0007668760372325778, -0.01685434766113758, 0.008401382714509964, 0.008942991495132446, -0.015461639501154423, 0.017112256959080696, 0.018298637121915817, -0.016815660521388054, -0.0027064315509051085, 0.022631507366895676, -0.009632897563278675, 0.008440068922936916, 0.04309657961130142, -0.010135820135474205, 0.05447036400437355, -0.0021567633375525475, 0.006770108826458454, 0.030949069187045097, -0.002622611355036497, -0.004987313412129879, -0.0033689350821077824, 0.01734437420964241, 0.02898896113038063, -0.004294183570891619, 0.022902311757206917, -0.00040257969521917403, 0.020864831283688545, 0.022360702976584435, 0.0005375788896344602, -0.04209073632955551, -0.011850914917886257, 0.017305688932538033, -0.026770945638418198, 0.05539883300662041, -0.03303813189268112, -0.010477549396455288, -0.010909547097980976, 0.015281102620065212, 0.04534038528800011, -0.0007688909536227584, -0.01962686888873577, -0.0007451149867847562, -0.03734521195292473, 0.008981677703559399, 0.031258560717105865, 0.04588199406862259, 0.03703571856021881, 0.006853929255157709, -0.02581668272614479, -0.013075982220470905, 0.012914788909256458, -0.020039523020386696, 0.01902078278362751, -0.009542630054056644, -0.018724186345934868, -0.035926710814237595, -0.05171073600649834, 0.03146488592028618, -0.0011090083280578256, -0.010032656602561474, 0.00011283515050308779, -0.017782820388674736, 0.019343167543411255, 0.0477389395236969, 0.008285324089229107, -0.017241211608052254, 0.0019230333855375648, -0.004539196845144033, -0.007743715308606625, 0.05447036400437355, -0.0034849941730499268, 0.009039707481861115, -0.007215001620352268, 0.02121300809085369, -0.01098691951483488, -0.0036945452447980642, 0.027080435305833817, -0.004387675318866968, 0.036236200481653214, 0.024075796827673912, 0.026899900287389755, -0.04085277020931244, 0.0129857137799263, -0.006692736409604549, -0.02230912074446678, -0.022734669968485832, -0.0468878410756588, 0.020993785932660103, -0.0335281603038311, -0.011779990047216415, -0.016235366463661194, -0.020594026893377304, -0.018672605976462364, -0.026164859533309937, -0.03030429780483246, -0.003730007680132985, -0.017447538673877716, 0.008388487622141838, 0.012321597896516323, 0.045134060084819794, -0.028550516813993454, 0.01295347511768341, -0.014571853913366795, -0.026113277301192284, -0.013198488391935825, 0.01431394461542368, -0.039795346558094025, 0.006215604953467846, 0.03133593127131462, -0.001017934293486178, -0.006531543098390102, 0.015474534593522549, -0.022940997034311295, -0.018272846937179565, 0.019639763981103897, 0.01908526010811329, -0.017473328858613968, 0.0009631285793147981, -0.040981724858284, -0.03466295823454857, -0.0036494110245257616, -0.0025710295885801315, -0.006305872928351164, -0.008923647925257683, 0.016789870336651802, 0.03270284831523895, 0.016544856131076813, 0.007337508723139763, -0.02503005973994732, 0.0005919815739616752, -0.01597745716571808, 0.029711106792092323, -0.024307915940880775, 0.03280601277947426, -0.04216810688376427, -0.011457603424787521, -0.003291562432423234, -0.0401822067797184, -0.012463448569178581, 0.023998424410820007, 0.00005994367165840231, -0.0037686938885599375, 0.02963373437523842, 0.033579740673303604, -0.00432964600622654, 0.01121903769671917, 0.004210363142192364, -0.027544671669602394, -0.003543023718520999, 0.006402588915079832, 0.02377920225262642, -0.020503759384155273, 0.012708461843430996, 0.03615882992744446, -0.051194917410612106, 0.005035671405494213, -0.02393394708633423, 0.023921051993966103, 0.0041974675841629505, -0.0201168954372406, 0.01682855747640133, -0.032444942742586136, 0.0069699883460998535, -0.0006911152740940452, -0.017602283507585526, -0.0142494672909379, -0.003829947439953685, -0.03641673922538757, 0.016789870336651802, -0.011373783461749554, -0.002712879329919815, -0.028215235099196434, -0.012366732582449913, 0.015951666980981827, 0.01009068638086319, -0.03231598809361458, 0.03265126794576645, 0.005428982432931662, -0.011709064245223999, 0.02335365116596222, -0.00876245554536581, -0.039305318146944046, 0.01222488284111023, -0.02015558071434498, -0.03584934026002884, 0.008214399218559265, -0.03739679232239723, 0.00048438517842441797, 0.005741697270423174, -0.019149737432599068, -0.014945821836590767, -0.0025178357027471066, -0.01707356981933117, -0.0012726192362606525, -0.0037525747902691364, 0.020490862429142, 0.011244828812777996, -0.02355998009443283, 0.014391317032277584, 0.0004952657036483288, -0.0003197667538188398, -0.0031497126910835505, 0.024501346051692963, -0.007808192167431116, -0.010806383565068245, -0.03835105523467064, -0.020374804735183716, 0.008575471118092537, 0.0007209359901025891, -0.05952537804841995, -0.02505585178732872, -0.016506170853972435, -0.011335096322000027, 0.028369979932904243, 0.0318775400519371, 0.015126357786357403, 0.034611377865076065, 0.025468505918979645, 0.00008991551294457167, -0.019459227100014687, 0.012998608872294426, -0.0035849339328706264, -0.004987313412129879, 0.03435346856713295, 0.018208369612693787, -0.04711996018886566, -0.0030304298270493746, -0.03118118830025196, -0.0006741899996995926, 0.004300631117075682, 0.014623435214161873, -0.014197885990142822, -0.015564803034067154, -0.02456582337617874, -0.008846275508403778, 0.07015122473239899, -0.029582152143120766, -0.003765470115467906, -0.04056907072663307, 0.018466278910636902, -0.015513220801949501, 0.003707440569996834, 0.04258076101541519, -0.000038938200304983184, -0.03234177827835083, 0.0024743136018514633, 0.014868448488414288, 0.009774748235940933, 0.016286948695778847, 0.012837416492402554, 0.0031851751264184713, -0.015216626226902008, 0.029195288196206093, -0.011044949293136597, -0.00732461316511035, -0.0326254777610302, -0.034766122698783875, -0.005055014509707689, 0.030097970739006996, -0.007898460142314434, 0.00619626184925437, 0.022876519709825516, -0.019046572968363762, -0.011509185656905174, 0.041136473417282104, 0.01658354327082634, -0.018208369612693787, -0.01365627720952034, -0.024836627766489983, -0.00035240835859440267, -0.011393126100301743, 0.022399388253688812, 0.021084053441882133, 0.012476343661546707, 0.022786252200603485, 0.036081455647945404, -0.0020149133633822203, 0.019214214757084846, -0.011741302907466888, 0.003804156556725502, 0.010967576876282692, 0.0003262144746258855, 0.023121533915400505, 0.010935338214039803, 0.04172966256737709, -0.037474166601896286, 0.0008543232688680291, 0.005238774698227644, -0.011399573646485806, 0.008285324089229107, 0.021483812481164932, 0.009877911768853664, 0.03198070451617241, 0.04319974407553673, 0.017292791977524757, -0.006924854125827551, -0.03231598809361458, -0.03252231329679489, 0.051349665969610214, 0.009458809159696102, -0.012063689529895782, 0.007917803712189198, 0.03285759687423706, 0.0015829158946871758, -0.01018095389008522, -0.01397866290062666, -0.017125152051448822, -0.023186011239886284, 0.0069699883460998535, -0.00013137234782334417, -0.003385054413229227, -0.007376194931566715, 0.0019649434834718704, 0.0036300679203122854, -0.023057056590914726, 0.0027580135501921177, -0.012792281806468964, -0.017292791977524757, 0.04472140595316887, -0.009594211354851723, 0.01877576857805252, 0.009091288782656193, 0.02279914729297161, -0.012018555775284767, 0.027854163199663162, -0.009013916365802288, -0.03734521195292473, -0.002425955608487129, 0.0510401725769043, 0.012173300608992577, 0.0015289162984117866, -0.036287784576416016, -0.006215604953467846, 0.020826144143939018, -0.0011235156562179327, -0.04376714304089546, 0.01374654471874237, 0.023057056590914726, -0.009684479795396328, 0.037448372691869736, 0.015048985369503498, 0.01673828810453415, -0.05039540305733681, 0.03641673922538757, 0.009781195782124996, -0.001863391837105155, 0.011902496218681335, 0.006705631501972675, -0.006931302137672901, -0.005951248109340668, 0.04727470502257347, 0.02172882668673992, 0.002930490067228675, -0.022902311757206917, 0.008478755131363869, 0.01248279120773077, 0.023998424410820007, -0.014017349109053612, -0.010542026720941067, -0.011161007918417454, -0.016325633972883224, 0.006199485622346401, -0.005912561900913715, -0.007331060711294413, 0.02072298154234886, -0.025249281898140907, 0.023843679577112198, -0.006354230921715498, 0.011651035398244858, 0.0004106393607798964, -0.00011515230289660394, -0.0008180548320524395, -0.004548868630081415, 0.033760275691747665, -0.00519041670486331, -0.010490445420145988, -0.00762765621766448, -0.016016144305467606, -0.021690139546990395, 0.02210279367864132, -0.02603590488433838, -0.0018553322879597545, -0.005554713308811188, 0.024926897138357162, -0.03131014108657837, -0.01776992343366146, 0.02624223195016384, 0.02731255441904068, 0.031206978484988213, -0.011090083047747612, 0.00036993809044361115, -0.02103247120976448, 0.021483812481164932, -0.01515214890241623, -0.008001623675227165, -0.0027660729829221964, 0.012566612102091312, -0.00174894486553967, 0.034250304102897644, 0.017847295850515366, -0.01347574032843113, -0.022721774876117706, -0.021690139546990395, -0.03417292982339859, 0.015216626226902008, -0.015771130099892616, -0.0007293986272998154, 0.013037295080721378, -0.04856424778699875, -0.055037762969732285, -0.027931535616517067, 0.011148112826049328, -0.01664802059531212, -0.027750998735427856, 0.017331479117274284, 0.0033366966526955366, -0.032264403998851776, 0.0036655303556472063, -0.008214399218559265, -0.00865929201245308, 0.011064291931688786, 0.005225879140198231, 0.007086047437041998, 0.00745356734842062, -0.015887189656496048, 0.009690927341580391, -0.03213544934988022, 0.009697374887764454, -0.009433018043637276, 0.0327286422252655, 0.03631357476115227, 0.030433252453804016, -0.04105909913778305, -0.0011372171575203538, 0.003517232835292816, -0.03368290513753891, -0.042993415147066116, -0.006737870164215565, -0.03956322744488716, -0.03798998147249222, 0.012076584622263908, -0.006486409343779087, 0.02426922880113125, -0.000343542720656842, 0.002540402812883258, -0.00815636944025755, 0.010554921813309193, 0.010806383565068245, 0.041471753269433975, 0.034920867532491684, 0.0003147294628433883, 0.000602862099185586, 0.019123945385217667, -0.0318775400519371, -0.02901475317776203, 0.02916949801146984, -0.0009566808585077524, 0.006276858039200306, 0.020735876634716988, 0.010374385863542557, 0.008859171532094479, 0.05165915563702583, -0.007318165618926287, 0.027879953384399414, -0.0005536982207559049, -0.014301049523055553, -0.013082429766654968, -0.008330457843840122, -0.022476762533187866, -0.004278064239770174, 0.015139252878725529, -0.03486928343772888, -0.015371371060609818, -0.03051062487065792, 0.014945821836590767, -0.006731422618031502, 0.005615966394543648, 0.0015329461311921477, 0.0117219602689147, -0.033450786024332047, 0.03316708654165268, 0.03798998147249222, 0.004822896793484688, -0.02072298154234886, -0.005519250873476267, -0.010200297459959984, 0.04562408849596977, -0.0021406440064311028, -0.001191216753795743, -0.011225485242903233, -0.014210781082510948, -0.006763661280274391, -0.05225234478712082, -0.030794324353337288, 0.005293580237776041, 0.002562969923019409, 0.015784025192260742, 0.011141665279865265, 0.009439466521143913, 0.020413490012288094, 0.019033677875995636, -0.05777159705758095, 0.01703488454222679, 0.02279914729297161, 0.014068931341171265, -0.00519686471670866, -0.0071311816573143005, -0.0040588416159152985, 0.024243438616394997, 0.008285324089229107, 0.023521292954683304, 0.024423973634839058, -0.014043140225112438, 0.007350403815507889, 0.00040237820940092206, 0.02847314439713955, -0.01789887808263302, 0.017757028341293335, -0.027441509068012238, -0.03063957951962948, 0.0077566104009747505, -0.01492003072053194, 0.009078393690288067, -0.027389926835894585, 0.01786019280552864, 0.01022608857601881, 0.004484391305595636, 0.0038170518819242716, -0.021380648016929626, -0.025919845327734947, -0.014829762279987335, -0.03915057331323624, -0.03884108364582062, 0.012237777933478355, -0.038299474865198135, -0.006750765722244978, 0.02270887978374958, -0.01009068638086319, 0.0020874503534287214, 0.034585583955049515, -0.023908156901597977, 0.004500510636717081, -0.005977039225399494, 0.03551405668258667, -0.005889995023608208, 0.03448242321610451, -0.008452964946627617, -0.0024823732674121857, 0.017705446109175682, 0.02371472492814064, 0.01231515035033226, -0.01365627720952034, 0.06432248651981354, 0.003420516848564148, 0.026255127042531967, -0.02594563737511635, 0.041652288287878036, 0.0292984526604414, -0.028782634064555168, 0.032909177243709564, 0.01996215060353279, 0.0146492263302207, -0.017447538673877716, 0.014494480565190315, -0.011044949293136597, -0.01531978975981474, -0.04286446049809456, -0.02331496588885784, 0.03734521195292473, 0.00908484123647213, 0.001818257849663496, 0.04459245130419731, 0.03716467320919037, -0.008736664429306984, -0.017086464911699295, 0.008382040075957775, -0.03084590658545494, -0.0005323401419445872, -0.02161276713013649, -0.0056256381794810295, -0.005738473497331142, 0.011573662050068378, 0.021935153752565384, -0.012521477416157722, -0.04585620388388634, -0.004236153792589903, -0.019472122192382812, -0.028034698218107224, -0.0021084053441882133, 0.053026072680950165, 0.006428379565477371, 0.030123760923743248, -0.029607942327857018, 0.04928639158606529, 0.0005158178391866386, 0.005419311113655567, 0.016815660521388054, -0.019497914239764214, 0.007247240282595158, -0.003820275655016303, 0.0029675643891096115, 0.016286948695778847, -0.028241025283932686, 0.005132387392222881, -0.007176315411925316, 0.02393394708633423, 0.025558773428201675, -0.0035462474916130304, -0.00891720037907362, -0.030768534168601036, -0.05581148713827133, 0.022141480818390846, -0.007356851827353239, 0.019046572968363762, 0.01252792589366436, 0.026409871876239777, 0.0025178357027471066, -0.00529680447652936, -0.02648724615573883, 0.0022099569905549288, 0.008601262234151363, -0.05978328734636307, 0.03765470162034035, -0.00845941249281168 ]
12.023436
6.449382
2024-07-01
2
2024ApJ...969..129Z
[ "companion galaxies", "galaxy quenching", "massive central galaxies", "spectroscopic massive central galaxies", "photometric galaxies", "galaxy formation models", "higher stellar mass", "redshift bins", "low-mass companion galaxies", "Slogan Digital Sky Survey" ]
[ "Galaxy formation", "Galaxy evolution", "Galaxy quenching", "595", "594", "2040", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
16
[ "10.3847/1538-4357/ad47f7", "10.48550/arXiv.2401.11997" ]
[ "Zheng, Yun", "Xu, Kun", "Jing, Y. P.", "Zhao, Donghai", "Gao, Hongyu", "Luo, Xiaolin", "Han, Jiaxin", "Yu, Yu", "Li, Ming" ]
[ "Department of Astronomy, School of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, 200240, People's Republic of China", "Department of Astronomy, School of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, 200240, People's Republic of China; Institute for Computational Cosmology, Department of Physics, Durham University, South Road, Durham DH1 3LE, UK", "Department of Astronomy, School of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, 200240, People's Republic of China; Tsung-Dao Lee Institute, and Shanghai Key Laboratory for Particle Physics and Cosmology, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, 200240, People's Republic of China", "Key Laboratory for Research in Galaxies and Cosmology, Shanghai Astronomical Observatory, Shanghai, 200030, People's Republic of China; Department of Astronomy, School of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, 200240, People's Republic of China", "Department of Astronomy, School of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, 200240, People's Republic of China", "Department of Astronomy, School of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, 200240, People's Republic of China", "Department of Astronomy, School of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, 200240, People's Republic of China", "Department of Astronomy, School of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai, 200240, People's Republic of China", "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, 100101, People's Republic of China" ]
[ "2024ApJ...966...18T", "2024arXiv240516484X" ]
[ "1972ApJ...176....1G", "1974MNRAS.169..229L", "1980ApJ...237..692L", "1981ApJ...243...32F", "1982jbor.book.....E", "1986ApJ...303...39D", "1993ApJ...412...64L", "1996Natur.379..613M", "1998ApJ...495...80B", "1999MNRAS.304..465M", "2000ApJ...533..682C", "2000ApJ...540..113B", "2003ApJ...594..186B", "2003ApJ...597L...9Z", "2003MNRAS.341...54K", "2003MNRAS.344.1000B", "2003PASP..115..763C", "2004ApJ...600..681B", "2004MNRAS.349..115H", "2004MNRAS.351.1151B", "2004MNRAS.353..713K", "2005AJ....129.2562B", "2006MNRAS.365...11C", "2007ApJ...660L..11N", "2007ApJ...664..791B", "2008A&A...483L..39C", "2008MNRAS.387.1391S", "2008MNRAS.387.1431D", "2009ApJ...707..354Z", "2009ApJS..182..543A", "2010ApJ...721..193P", "2010MNRAS.402.1942C", "2011ApJ...732...17N", "2011ApJ...734...88W", "2011MNRAS.411..675S", "2012AJ....144..144B", "2012ARA&A..50..455F", "2012ApJ...746..188M", "2012ApJ...757....4P", "2012ApJ...760...16J", "2012ApJS..203...21A", "2012MNRAS.422..804K", "2012MNRAS.424..232W", "2012MNRAS.427.2437H", "2013ApJ...776...63F", "2013ApJ...777...18M", "2013PASP..125..306F", "2014A&A...562A..21C", "2014ApJ...788...28V", "2014ApJ...789..164T", "2014MNRAS.440..762O", "2014Natur.509..177V", "2015A&C....13...12N", "2015MNRAS.452..575S", "2015Natur.521..192P", "2016A&A...594A..13P", "2016ApJ...825..113D", "2016MNRAS.456.4364B", "2016MNRAS.457.4360Z", "2017ApJ...844...48P", "2017ApJS..233...25A", "2017MNRAS.464..121S", "2017MNRAS.466.1275B", "2017MNRAS.467..179G", "2018ApJ...857...71B", "2018MNRAS.474..604H", "2018MNRAS.475..523L", "2018MNRAS.475..624N", "2018MNRAS.475..648P", "2018MNRAS.475..676S", "2018MNRAS.476...12B", "2018MNRAS.480.5113M", "2018PASJ...70S...7C", "2019A&A...622A.103B", "2019ApJ...873...52O", "2019ComAC...6....2N", "2019MNRAS.483.2851S", "2019MNRAS.483.5444D", "2019MNRAS.488..847P", "2019PASJ...71..114A", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020ApJ...889..156C", "2020ApJ...890....7C", "2020MNRAS.495.4570M", "2021ApJ...919...25W", "2021MNRAS.500.3776W", "2021MNRAS.503.4250F", "2021MNRAS.506.3364R", "2021PASA...38...35C", "2022A&A...666A.131S", "2022A&A...668A..69E", "2022ApJ...925...31X", "2022ApJ...933...47C", "2022ApJ...939..104X", "2023ApJ...944..200X", "2023ApJ...953...37G", "2023MNRAS.519.4499P", "2023MNRAS.522.5946E", "2024ApJ...966...18T" ]
29097450
2401.10024
Towards including super-sample covariance in the unbinned likelihood for cluster abundance cosmology
The measurement of the abundance of galaxy clusters in the Universe is a sensitive probe of cosmology, which depends on both the expansion history of the Universe and the growth of structure. Density fluctuations across the finite survey volume add noise to this measurement, this is often referred to as super-sample covariance (SSC). For an unbinned cluster analysis, such noise has not been included in the cluster likelihood, since the effect of SSC was small compared to the Poisson shot-noise for samples of a few hundred clusters. For upcoming large cluster surveys such as the Rubin LSST, which will deliver catalogues of tens of thousands of clusters, this effect will no longer be negligible. In this paper, we propose a new hybrid likelihood based on the Gauss-Poisson Compound model (GPC), by using infinitesimal mass bins and standard redshift bins. This likelihood has the advantages of an unbinned Poisson likelihood while successfully incorporating the effects of SSC. Using a simulated dark matter halo catalogue, we find that the hybrid likelihood, accounting for both Poisson noise and SSC, increases the dispersion of the parameter posteriors by 20 per cent when using 100 000 clusters compared to the standard unbinned likelihood, based on Poisson statistics only.
[ 0.015534468926489353, -0.01399258617311716, 0.04204200208187103, 0.022794166579842567, -0.00819767639040947, 0.009129230864346027, 0.017474671825766563, -0.009752408601343632, -0.03613145276904106, 0.028756113722920418, -0.020545586943626404, 0.0034082033671438694, -0.03620854765176773, 0.033330366015434265, -0.0008488385938107967, 0.029989618808031082, 0.0009556461009196937, 0.01793723553419113, -0.026224855333566666, -0.016613787040114403, -0.04456041008234024, 0.007394612766802311, 0.002619594568386674, -0.012277241796255112, -0.04453471302986145, -0.06337138265371323, 0.03844427689909935, -0.0017474670894443989, 0.04068000614643097, -0.02139362320303917, 0.009193476289510727, -0.031120333820581436, -0.041245363652706146, 0.019479118287563324, -0.0530407652258873, 0.09765257686376572, -0.027188532054424286, 0.029989618808031082, -0.006790708750486374, -0.00862811878323555, -0.030837655067443848, 0.01162194088101387, -0.024631576612591743, 0.0005207869689911604, 0.03700518608093262, -0.00910995714366436, 0.004211267456412315, -0.09184481203556061, -0.02007017284631729, 0.005213491152971983, -0.05463404580950737, -0.00011865269334521145, 0.00808203499764204, -0.035309113562107086, -0.000812700716778636, -0.03230244293808937, 0.00819767639040947, 0.028910301625728607, 0.011397083289921284, -0.019954532384872437, 0.01258561760187149, -0.013440078124403954, 0.03440968319773674, 0.0003029558574780822, -0.018669629469513893, -0.004969359375536442, 0.039420802146196365, 0.005091425497084856, -0.025839384645223618, 0.06383394449949265, 0.004018532112240791, -0.006238200701773167, 0.0029841854702681303, 0.0019932046998292208, -0.012039534747600555, 0.03846997395157814, -0.02834494411945343, 0.019903136417269707, -0.04011464864015579, 0.041450947523117065, -0.011763280257582664, 0.027368418872356415, 0.035309113562107086, -0.0074010370299220085, -0.029758337885141373, -0.0222031120210886, 0.011923893354833126, 0.0006006918265484273, -0.04800394922494888, 0.02560810185968876, 0.01834840513765812, 0.018721025437116623, 0.012425005435943604, -0.0023128241300582886, -0.019581910222768784, -0.026019271463155746, 0.0345124751329422, -0.013581417500972748, 0.05039386823773384, 0.0034788730554282665, 0.020083023235201836, 0.023770691826939583, 0.047310102730989456, -0.0771455317735672, 0.06897355616092682, -0.04103977978229523, -0.03900963440537453, 0.009341239929199219, 0.002828391268849373, 0.012829748913645744, 0.01855398900806904, 0.03811020031571388, -0.06588979065418243, 0.04623078554868698, -0.03790461644530296, -0.026931552216410637, -0.03682529926300049, 0.03690239414572716, -0.03320187330245972, 0.01654954068362713, -0.03911242634057999, -0.03877834975719452, 0.039395105093717575, 0.016575239598751068, 0.03818729519844055, -0.06059599295258522, 0.021637754514813423, -0.06059599295258522, -0.009874474257230759, 0.02058413438498974, 0.0329962894320488, -0.0019498391775414348, 0.006501605734229088, -0.005846305284649134, -0.02636619471013546, -0.01811712235212326, -0.01793723553419113, -0.011538422666490078, 0.01012502983212471, 0.004776624031364918, 0.007034840062260628, -0.007176179438829422, 0.021021001040935516, 0.04497158154845238, -0.029861129820346832, 0.01409537810832262, -0.055918946862220764, 0.006816406734287739, -0.022498639300465584, 0.01728193648159504, -0.008660241030156612, -0.0008271558326669037, -0.037596240639686584, -0.013099579140543938, -0.022113168612122536, -0.04309562221169472, -0.027239928022027016, 0.029141584411263466, -0.03572028502821922, -0.04404645040631294, -0.003331109182909131, 0.03487224876880646, 0.0012977513251826167, -0.01301605999469757, -0.01121719740331173, 0.02649468556046486, -0.014750678092241287, 0.011069432832300663, -0.0639367401599884, -0.025441065430641174, -0.013851246796548367, 0.013273040764033794, -0.0014977141981944442, -0.04265875741839409, 0.0031881637405604124, 0.009835926815867424, -0.014467999339103699, -0.04916036128997803, -0.022138865664601326, -0.00500469421967864, -0.017551764845848083, 0.021984677761793137, 0.015084752812981606, -0.03307338431477547, -0.020879661664366722, 0.007278971374034882, 0.002966518048197031, 0.03183987736701965, 0.010182850994169712, -0.01399258617311716, 0.0008584753377363086, 0.0018615021836012602, 0.0380588062107563, 0.04692463204264641, -0.020083023235201836, -0.047695573419332504, 0.03913812339305878, 0.04635927453637123, -0.041425250470638275, 0.0041566588915884495, -0.033407460898160934, 0.03387002274394035, -0.009533975273370743, -0.03839287906885147, -0.0449201837182045, -0.03320187330245972, 0.02413046546280384, -0.006964170373976231, -0.0031737086828798056, 0.0026645660400390625, -0.008416109718382359, -0.031171729788184166, 0.004407214932143688, -0.011075858026742935, -0.009450456127524376, 0.00752952741459012, -0.049648623913526535, 0.027162835001945496, 0.03885544463992119, 0.03225104883313179, 0.023886334151029587, 0.028961697593331337, 0.027060043066740036, 0.00354954251088202, 0.02560810185968876, -0.03471805900335312, 0.0428900383412838, -0.05463404580950737, 0.00003370358899701387, -0.002540894318372011, 0.022190261632204056, 0.018284158781170845, -0.0388297475874424, -0.00538695277646184, 0.010195699520409107, -0.006064738612622023, 0.010908820666372776, 0.02339807152748108, -0.021714849397540092, -0.01280405092984438, -0.014583640731871128, 0.022588582709431648, 0.013530021533370018, 0.0031785271130502224, 0.03263651952147484, 0.02646898664534092, -0.015354582108557224, 0.016806522384285927, 0.027034344151616096, 0.016716578975319862, -0.02819075621664524, 0.012971088290214539, -0.031403012573719025, -0.02641759067773819, -0.04402075335383415, -0.029681243002414703, -0.037544846534729004, 0.010992338880896568, -0.024875707924365997, 0.01821991428732872, -0.03672250732779503, -0.03307338431477547, -0.01590709015727043, -0.012174448929727077, -0.035334814339876175, -0.020391399040818214, 0.031325917690992355, -0.049725718796253204, -0.02847343496978283, -0.0046641952358186245, -0.02113664336502552, -0.02636619471013546, 0.02545391395688057, -0.05884852632880211, -0.01717914268374443, 0.010966640897095203, -0.012315788306295872, 0.00959179550409317, 0.03793031722307205, -0.012489249929785728, -0.053657520562410355, -0.02329527772963047, 0.022807015106081963, 0.04854360967874527, 0.03076056018471718, -0.003427476854994893, 0.03371583670377731, -0.022717071697115898, 0.022845562547445297, -0.021457867696881294, 0.053606122732162476, -0.041450947523117065, -0.023205336183309555, 0.029475659132003784, -0.0360286608338356, -0.02616061083972454, -0.008281195536255836, 0.0220746211707592, -0.02821645513176918, 0.016151221469044685, 0.01728193648159504, 0.0017233751714229584, 0.010536198504269123, -0.019864588975906372, -0.028704717755317688, -0.0018518654396757483, 0.03903533145785332, 0.005149245727807283, -0.02644328959286213, 0.05412008613348007, 0.00432048412039876, 0.022241659462451935, -0.03404990956187248, 0.03422979637980461, 0.003170496318489313, 0.02308969385921955, -0.023179637268185616, 0.021046699956059456, 0.027548305690288544, -0.001357981120236218, -0.022344451397657394, -0.06686631590127945, -0.023565107956528664, -0.009418333880603313, 0.004233752842992544, -0.039215218275785446, -0.007420310750603676, -0.023410920053720474, 0.01002223789691925, -0.04838941991329193, -0.004381516948342323, 0.029295772314071655, 0.04854360967874527, 0.005062514916062355, 0.01933777891099453, -0.09600789844989777, 0.05273238942027092, 0.04641067236661911, -0.01902940310537815, -0.03466666489839554, -0.017693104222416878, 0.00912280660122633, -0.012257968075573444, -0.009399060159921646, 0.05214133486151695, 0.02811366133391857, 0.011409932747483253, 0.06121274456381798, 0.045819614082574844, -0.004889053292572498, 0.018232762813568115, -0.0031688902527093887, 0.03464096412062645, -0.005730664357542992, 0.05000839754939079, -0.016099825501441956, 0.041553739458322525, -0.045382749289274216, -0.0062157148495316505, 0.0015298367943614721, 0.005663206800818443, 0.00045373113243840635, 0.03487224876880646, 0.04612799361348152, 0.00921274907886982, -0.008358289487659931, -0.05093352496623993, -0.009238447062671185, -0.01527748815715313, 0.002849270822480321, -0.05674128606915474, 0.027805285528302193, -0.03880405053496361, -0.05314355716109276, -0.08223374933004379, 0.02246009185910225, 0.0282935481518507, 0.023719295859336853, 0.04625648260116577, 0.020108720287680626, 0.041630834341049194, 0.005258462391793728, 0.019826041534543037, -0.007863601669669151, 0.018129970878362656, 0.00997084192931652, -0.016536692157387733, -0.02210032008588314, -0.07015566527843475, -0.027085740119218826, -0.021586358547210693, 0.006206077989190817, 0.05242401361465454, 0.04014034569263458, -0.025286877527832985, -0.02811366133391857, -0.004416851792484522, 0.06023621931672096, 0.04671904817223549, 0.031120333820581436, -0.04181072115898132, -0.02111094444990158, -0.02664887346327305, -0.04299283027648926, -0.03001531772315502, 0.008917221799492836, 0.006437360309064388, 0.06830540299415588, 0.0464363694190979, 0.02558240480720997, 0.03466666489839554, 0.0014085741713643074, 0.04432912915945053, -0.07401037216186523, 0.017590312287211418, 0.03839287906885147, -0.022819865494966507, 0.05458264797925949, 0.008698788471519947, 0.07113219052553177, 0.033330366015434265, -0.0005456819199025631, -0.010902395471930504, -0.017975782975554466, -0.01532888412475586, 0.005981219932436943, -0.005955521948635578, 0.02001877687871456, -0.008358289487659931, -0.04052581638097763, -0.010908820666372776, 0.051447488367557526, 0.04065430909395218, -0.01318309735506773, -0.011120829731225967, -0.02192043326795101, 0.04790115728974342, -0.005688904784619808, 0.012739806436002254, -0.01603558100759983, 0.035489000380039215, 0.039729177951812744, -0.0423760786652565, -0.045434143394231796, 0.005091425497084856, -0.010574745945632458, 0.0563301146030426, 0.02603211998939514, 0.017577463760972023, -0.0016213860362768173, -0.0076194703578948975, -0.016588088124990463, 0.003154435195028782, -0.013594266027212143, -0.03271361067891121, -0.005049665924161673, 0.019826041534543037, -0.04918605834245682, 0.06666073203086853, -0.04224758595228195, 0.003014701884239912, 0.022241659462451935, -0.018335554748773575, 0.039215218275785446, -0.011416357010602951, 0.024040522053837776, -0.013889793306589127, -0.013388682156801224, 0.02438744530081749, 0.029629847034811974, 0.008152704685926437, -0.09318111091852188, 0.0738561823964119, 0.020134419202804565, 0.024091918021440506, -0.024425992742180824, 0.004657770972698927, 0.0029584874864667654, 0.02123943530023098, -0.004696317948400974, 0.057409435510635376, -0.022819865494966507, -0.014185321517288685, 0.0482095330953598, 0.0077929324470460415, 0.037724729627370834, 0.005579688120633364, 0.021123792976140976, -0.015611562877893448, 0.0010118605569005013, -0.045177165418863297, -0.027111439034342766, 0.017089201137423515, -0.013414380140602589, -0.00003553558053681627, 0.00794069655239582, -0.047669876366853714, 0.0029873978346586227, -0.018566837534308434, 0.022215960547327995, 0.059825051575899124, -0.06254903972148895, -0.010928094387054443, 0.014789225533604622, 0.0028621198143810034, 0.0214450191706419, -0.04987990856170654, -0.03608005493879318, -0.018746724352240562, 0.020288607105612755, -0.033304668962955475, 0.07478131353855133, 0.029809733852744102, 0.0017667406937107444, 0.0214450191706419, -0.010645415633916855, -0.03872695565223694, -0.0017249813536182046, 0.01324734278023243, -0.029475659132003784, 0.018682479858398438, 0.015187544748187065, -0.045459844172000885, 0.0006111316615715623, -0.0030548551585525274, -0.030914749950170517, -0.018284158781170845, -0.10366591811180115, -0.02831924706697464, -0.047567084431648254, -0.0317113883793354, -0.01702495478093624, -0.009617493487894535, 0.008872250095009804, -0.035334814339876175, -0.0015499134315177798, 0.004975784104317427, -0.015457374975085258, -0.00530343409627676, -0.01532888412475586, -0.018078574910759926, 0.01302890945225954, -0.011474177241325378, -0.0017972571076825261, 0.009135655127465725, 0.014583640731871128, 0.015791449695825577, -0.004002470523118973, 0.029938222840428352, 0.037596240639686584, 0.02454163320362568, -0.037621937692165375, -0.0032524089328944683, -0.007388188038021326, -0.023025449365377426, 0.004940449260175228, 0.037159375846385956, 0.014326660893857479, 0.01717914268374443, -0.006591548677533865, -0.009167777374386787, -0.0039574988186359406, -0.022241659462451935, 0.03834148496389389, -0.009585371240973473, -0.02506844326853752, 0.013928340747952461, 0.0012656287290155888, 0.006585124414414167, 0.04697602614760399, -0.0527837872505188, 0.033356063067913055, 0.015919938683509827, -0.03561749309301376, -0.023834938183426857, -0.015020507387816906, -0.01403113268315792, -0.03183987736701965, -0.008114158175885677, -0.008538175374269485, 0.010594019666314125, -0.025286877527832985, 0.013440078124403954, 0.006771435029804707, -0.06835680454969406, 0.02048134244978428, 0.014069680124521255, 0.061469726264476776, -0.007272547110915184, -0.014300962910056114, 0.0005677661974914372, -0.03926661238074303, 0.010420557111501694, 0.01684506982564926, -0.003886829363182187, 0.005081788636744022, 0.004102050326764584, 0.03407561033964157, -0.018309857696294785, -0.008004941046237946, 0.010683962143957615, 0.05080503597855568, -0.027419814839959145, -0.0256338007748127, -0.029629847034811974, 0.019915984943509102, -0.014930564910173416, 0.018862364813685417, -0.011249319650232792, 0.013632813468575478, -0.004175932612270117, 0.0016912526916712523, -0.005981219932436943, -0.05545638129115105, -0.043558187782764435, -0.019761797040700912, 0.010632566176354885, -0.047541383653879166, 0.027008645236492157, -0.04014034569263458, 0.0152903376147151, -0.010940942913293839, -0.0053451936691999435, -0.0011034097988158464, 0.019774645566940308, 0.011859647929668427, -0.01660093665122986, -0.04229898378252983, -0.043995052576065063, -0.013504322618246078, 0.0008219359442591667, -0.025106990709900856, 0.0243617482483387, -0.007253273390233517, 0.008814429864287376, 0.014069680124521255, 0.015316035598516464, 0.07077241688966751, 0.008827278390526772, 0.026019271463155746, 0.03394711762666702, 0.05090782791376114, 0.012238694354891777, -0.06337138265371323, 0.0194148737937212, -0.011872497387230396, 0.002773782704025507, -0.009341239929199219, -0.031248822808265686, -0.017089201137423515, 0.012264392338693142, -0.021175188943743706, 0.0116733368486166, -0.02852483093738556, 0.01913219504058361, -0.017783047631382942, -0.003517420031130314, -0.007780083455145359, -0.00890437327325344, 0.009296268224716187, -0.02798517234623432, 0.016125524416565895, 0.013658511452376842, 0.012469977140426636, 0.002598714781925082, -0.01603558100759983, 0.00480232248082757, 0.018965158611536026, -0.01733333244919777, -0.012823324650526047, 0.04312131926417351, 0.0644506961107254, 0.01408252865076065, -0.001951445359736681, -0.05412008613348007, 0.03420409932732582, -0.003832221031188965, -0.002340128179639578, -0.014635036699473858, 0.012469977140426636, -0.006977019365876913, 0.02397627755999565, -0.013478624634444714, -0.035591792315244675, 0.0090071652084589, 0.006687916349619627, 0.02293550595641136, -0.0020237211138010025, 0.004619223531335592, -0.0035206321626901627, -0.00033808991429395974, -0.02025005966424942, 0.03795601427555084, 0.017577463760972023, -0.01926068589091301, -0.00873091071844101, -0.01938917487859726, 0.013568568043410778, -0.0019128982676193118, -0.03582307696342468, 0.021869037300348282, -0.0021200887858867645, -0.007786507718265057, -0.019222138449549675, -0.01923498697578907, 0.017885839566588402, -0.02344946749508381, -0.006662218365818262, 0.027548305690288544, -0.0006006918265484273, 0.0200444757938385, 0.03885544463992119, -0.0261349119246006, -0.0022020014002919197, 0.023153938353061676, -0.0014936989173293114, -0.019864588975906372, -0.023488013073801994, -0.018965158611536026, -0.005158882588148117, 0.004641709383577108, -0.025081291794776917, -0.057306643575429916, -0.008852976374328136, 0.02256288379430771, -0.008480355143547058, -0.02634049765765667, 0.003014701884239912, -0.039523594081401825, -0.011557696387171745, 0.010028662160038948, 0.023757843300700188, 0.004195205867290497, -0.007722262758761644, 0.008120582439005375, -0.006511242128908634, 0.010529774241149426, 0.010812452994287014, -0.022794166579842567, 0.020558437332510948, 0.020931057631969452, 0.027676794677972794, 0.006190016865730286, 0.00792784709483385, 0.03674820438027382, 0.024066219106316566, 0.03433258831501007, 0.011230045929551125, 0.025942176580429077, 0.013619964011013508, 0.014866319485008717, 0.010992338880896568, -0.014352358877658844, -0.007394612766802311, 0.006408450193703175, 0.006604397669434547, 0.011544846929609776, 0.0256338007748127, 0.03217395395040512, 0.012881145812571049, 0.01329873874783516, 0.04245316982269287, 0.017821595072746277, 0.014789225533604622, -0.023757843300700188, -0.0024284652899950743, -0.04625648260116577, -0.017114898189902306, 0.014300962910056114, -0.04232468083500862, -0.004420063924044371, 0.0076194703578948975, -0.00269347638823092, 0.01318309735506773, 0.01733333244919777, 0.012469977140426636, 0.011210772208869457, -0.01409537810832262, -0.018888063728809357, 0.013812699355185032, 0.011435630731284618, -0.010767481289803982, 0.016909314319491386, -0.007195452693849802, -0.02811366133391857, 0.0069898683577775955, 0.00713120773434639, -0.00023188471095636487, 0.043378300964832306, 0.002454163273796439, -0.014467999339103699, 0.04499727860093117, -0.011859647929668427, 0.00969458743929863, -0.0023337036836892366, 0.06553001701831818, -0.004545341711491346, -0.08084604889154434, 0.0027721766382455826, 0.024682972580194473, 0.03829008713364601, -0.00508821289986372, -0.005210278555750847, 0.027368418872356415, 0.03893253952264786, 0.005865579005330801, -0.006784284021705389, -0.001576414448209107, -0.03307338431477547, 0.0022742771543562412, 0.059979237616062164, -0.012810476124286652, -0.023256732150912285, -0.023899182677268982, 0.018438348546624184, -0.020841114223003387, 0.02659747749567032, -0.0038257965352386236, -0.00305806752294302, -0.016703730449080467, 0.045279957354068756, 0.014583640731871128, -0.006466270890086889, -0.03204546123743057, -0.0038482823874801397, 0.02837064303457737, -0.0016960710054263473, 0.007490980438888073, -0.005810970440506935, -0.009977266192436218, 0.01644674874842167, -0.006379540078341961, -0.022138865664601326, -0.007831479422748089, 0.018489744514226913, -0.029038792476058006, -0.02413046546280384, -0.009996539913117886, -0.029398564249277115, 0.02522263117134571, 0.00565356994047761, 0.01837410219013691, -0.01061971765011549, -0.0022357299458235502, 0.013221644796431065, 0.009315541945397854, 0.04887768253684044, -0.01082530152052641, 0.011872497387230396, -0.019324930384755135, 0.010202123783528805, 0.004535704851150513, 0.016729427501559258, -0.002770570572465658, 0.020815417170524597, 0.022691374644637108, 0.014943413436412811, -0.020468493923544884, 0.002637261990457773, 0.04042302444577217, -0.04255596548318863, -0.039652083069086075, -0.023205336183309555, -0.0489804744720459, 0.03625994175672531, -0.008467505685985088, -0.02357795648276806, -0.004786260891705751, 0.02860192582011223, -0.003117494285106659, 0.01913219504058361, -0.006488756742328405, 0.01158339437097311, 0.008133431896567345, -0.011943167075514793, -0.05262959748506546, 0.019170742481946945, -0.0033182601910084486, -0.017397576943039894, 0.020057324320077896, -0.001524215331301093, 0.013876944780349731, 0.05047096312046051, 0.005110698752105236, -0.01163479033857584, -0.03461526706814766, 0.0502396784722805, -0.00633135624229908, -0.007709413766860962, 0.022370148450136185, 0.0019257472595199943, 0.011018036864697933, -0.02319248579442501, 0.02438744530081749, -0.03189127519726753, 0.00536767952144146, -0.005425499752163887, 0.019324930384755135, -0.0033696561586111784, 0.00268383976072073, -0.0484665147960186, -0.005046453792601824, -0.04068000614643097, 0.011339263059198856, 0.011782553978264332, 0.006013342645019293, 0.005306646227836609, 0.02803656831383705, 0.01056832168251276, -0.02007017284631729, 0.024747218936681747, 0.05139609053730965, 0.014853470027446747, -0.01512330025434494, 0.0021827276796102524, 0.027419814839959145, 0.005801334045827389, 0.02103384956717491, -0.022691374644637108, -0.013350134715437889, 0.010863848961889744, 0.012026685290038586, -0.005987644661217928, -0.008101308718323708, -0.006247837562114, -0.00445218663662672, -0.0003796484670601785, -0.012881145812571049, 0.008139856159687042, 0.020815417170524597, 0.012245118618011475, -0.018078574910759926, 0.01892661117017269, 0.008698788471519947, 0.008788731880486012, 0.0049340249970555305, 0.04024314135313034, 0.011107980273663998, -0.006575487554073334, 0.003122312482446432, 0.005598961841315031, 0.005406226497143507, 0.009514701552689075, 0.023462316021323204, -0.010947367176413536, 0.01730763353407383, 0.02405337058007717, -0.019633306190371513, 0.009064985439181328, -0.01938917487859726, -0.00018651159189175814, -0.034769456833601, 0.015727203339338303, 0.008859401568770409, -0.008428959175944328, -0.010247095488011837, 0.0007853965507820249, 0.005322707816958427, 0.05797479301691055, 0.0014390905853360891, -0.029115885496139526, 0.006745737046003342, 0.020417097955942154, -0.03070916421711445, 0.0030837655067443848, -0.02098245359957218, -0.002099208999425173, -0.0004477081529330462, -0.09189621359109879, -0.00264208042062819, 0.0035623915027827024, -0.045819614082574844, 0.013375832699239254, -0.005020755808800459, 0.02098245359957218, 0.005146033596247435, -0.0018197428435087204, -0.010857424698770046, -0.021907584741711617, -0.006508029997348785, 0.0018695328617468476, 0.04106547683477402, 0.009309116750955582, -0.010645415633916855, -0.0013603903353214264, 0.005065727047622204, 0.010317765176296234, 0.006093649193644524, 0.023706447333097458, -0.005714602768421173, 0.04042302444577217, 0.028781810775399208, 0.029295772314071655, -0.058026187121868134, 0.021509263664484024, -0.01780874654650688, -0.004420063924044371, -0.011352111585438251, -0.01000938843935728, -0.02855052798986435, -0.0003914936678484082, -0.013260191306471825, 0.018579687923192978, -0.000801859307102859, -0.026700269430875778, -0.02529972605407238, -0.03870125859975815, 0.0062157148495316505, 0.009366937913000584, 0.026777364313602448, 0.02095675654709339, 0.03872695565223694, -0.06244625151157379, 0.051858656108379364, -0.0038900417275726795, -0.02824215218424797, -0.01816851831972599, 0.03040078841149807, -0.002051025163382292, -0.019903136417269707, 0.03697948902845383, -0.0028942422941327095, 0.024708671495318413, -0.005965158808976412, -0.010889546945691109, -0.016536692157387733, 0.011956015601754189, 0.024605879560112953, 0.006196441128849983, 0.004275512415915728, -0.009880898520350456, -0.03389572352170944, -0.03697948902845383, -0.0282935481518507, -0.025569556280970573, 0.01521324273198843, -0.004962935112416744, 0.027959473431110382, -0.015662958845496178, 0.016022730618715286, 0.012849022634327412, 0.003395354375243187, -0.005647145677357912, 0.019800344482064247, -0.029064489528536797, 0.00349814654327929, -0.010028662160038948, -0.0020076597575098276, 0.006951321382075548, -0.006938472390174866, 0.00952755007892847, -0.029784034937620163, -0.0023834938183426857, -0.03183987736701965, 0.035489000380039215, 0.0281650573015213, 0.014223868027329445, -0.02352656051516533, 0.007278971374034882, -0.04006325453519821, 0.017705952748656273, 0.03063207119703293, -0.005537929013371468, -0.010613292455673218, 0.009816653095185757, -0.0048087467439472675, -0.027959473431110382, 0.01408252865076065, -0.016305409371852875, 0.01409537810832262, -0.013388682156801224, -0.03669681027531624, -0.0213165283203125, 0.009366937913000584, -0.004609587136656046, -0.031120333820581436, 0.011300715617835522, -0.0214450191706419, -0.0006625277455896139, -0.04859500378370285, -0.011358535848557949, -0.01130713988095522, -0.005695329513400793, 0.012656287290155888, 0.014583640731871128, 0.04255596548318863, 0.019453421235084534, 0.00035214354284107685, 0.031146030873060226, 0.007009142078459263, 0.004593525547534227, 0.0013644056161865592, -0.03572028502821922, 0.02238299697637558, 0.01824561320245266, 0.012958239763975143, -0.009244872257113457, -0.02141932025551796, 0.003308623330667615, 0.025646649301052094, -0.02646898664534092, -0.0051235477440059185, 0.008037064224481583, -0.02048134244978428, -0.0027191743720322847, -0.0449201837182045, -0.04402075335383415, 0.020005928352475166, 0.0032845314126461744, -0.0000673569884384051, 0.014660734683275223, -0.002378675388172269, -0.012354335747659206, 0.0004549357108771801, 0.023128241300582886, -0.0030034591909497976, -0.006010130513459444, -0.03980627283453941, -0.016048429533839226, 0.02860192582011223, -0.0158556941896677, -0.01850259304046631, 0.015740053728222847, 0.004015319515019655, 0.001956263789907098, 0.00439115334302187, 0.04312131926417351, 0.02844773605465889, 0.03520632162690163, 0.0008624906768091023, -0.019697552546858788, -0.03643982857465744, 0.051884353160858154, -0.020108720287680626, -0.005820607300847769, 0.020892512053251266, 0.014917715452611446, 0.015187544748187065, 0.0034949341788887978, -0.012932541780173779, -0.0020124781876802444, -0.017166294157505035, 0.02306399680674076, -0.0029103036504238844, -0.011178649961948395, 0.0012118234299123287, 0.02469582110643387, 0.053811706602573395, -0.012572769075632095, -0.018913760781288147, -0.035771679133176804, 0.028987396508455276, 0.0013764515751972795, -0.016755126416683197, 0.009546823799610138, 0.0097074368968606, 0.0035142076667398214, 0.012810476124286652, 0.0033375336788594723, -0.019607609137892723, 0.010105756111443043, 0.02595502696931362, 0.01436520740389824, -0.000019976214389316738, 0.005158882588148117, -0.0005308252293616533, -0.03404990956187248, -0.004715591203421354, 0.011281441897153854, -0.017448972910642624, -0.007201877422630787, 0.014506546780467033, -0.027496909722685814, -0.013876944780349731, 0.004429700784385204, -0.0007789719966240227, 0.03240523487329483, 0.014133925549685955, 0.02042994648218155, -0.0005087410099804401, 0.019196439534425735, -0.010047935880720615, -0.009977266192436218, -0.02405337058007717, 0.03713367506861687, 0.027368418872356415, 0.010394859127700329, 0.030734863132238388, -0.003774400567635894, 0.012097354978322983, -0.00960464496165514, -0.00640202546492219, 0.02808796428143978, -0.005621447693556547, 0.018386952579021454, 0.005891276989132166, -0.015829995274543762, 0.006732888054102659, -0.02001877687871456, -0.01008648332208395, -0.017693104222416878, -0.0013322830200195312, 0.033433157950639725, 0.015778599306941032, 0.01629256084561348, 0.01699925772845745, -0.01956906169652939, -0.022974053397774696, -0.015200394205749035, -0.018798120319843292, 0.0243617482483387, 0.00959179550409317, -0.0041084750555455685, -0.004259451292455196, 0.025723744183778763, -0.005377315916121006, -0.015624411404132843, -0.01821991428732872, 0.028010869398713112, -0.027856681495904922, 0.02116234041750431, -0.013414380140602589, 0.007330367341637611, -0.047849759459495544, 0.03723646700382233, 0.005210278555750847, -0.024554483592510223, -0.0077158380299806595, -0.00538695277646184, 0.0013322830200195312, 0.04700172692537308, 0.013709907419979572, -0.009977266192436218, -0.005823819432407618, -0.007054113782942295, -0.024169012904167175, 0.04235037788748741, -0.041219666600227356, 0.03916382044553757, 0.00008141060243360698, 0.018078574910759926, 0.007343216799199581, -0.015534468926489353, -0.0009548430098220706, 0.008004941046237946, 0.012502099387347698, -0.035463303327560425, -0.02529972605407238, 0.028858905658125877, 0.011364961043000221, 0.027471210807561874, -0.00629923352971673, 0.006398813333362341, -0.02608351595699787, -0.015611562877893448, -0.012135902419686317, -0.01999307982623577, 0.010992338880896568, 0.01600988209247589, 0.01699925772845745, 0.02806226536631584, -0.002865332178771496, 0.043763771653175354, -0.008242648094892502, -0.01415962353348732, -0.021072397008538246, -0.02519693411886692, 0.02256288379430771, 0.016755126416683197, -0.025710895657539368, 0.009090683422982693, -0.025184085592627525, -0.05083073303103447, 0.014647886157035828, -0.03482085093855858, 0.02451593615114689, 0.027676794677972794, -0.041271060705184937, 0.029963921755552292, 0.0010094513418152928, 0.01994168385863304, 0.0017779835034161806, 0.0010704841697588563, 0.012720532715320587, -0.00947615411132574, 0.015585864894092083, 0.027368418872356415, -0.02123943530023098, 0.00025798429851420224, -0.008859401568770409, 0.009630342945456505, -0.031043238937854767, 0.019928835332393646, -0.024914255365729332, -0.030863352119922638, 0.027317022904753685, -0.026674572378396988, -0.018990855664014816, 0.014018284156918526, 0.015238940715789795, 0.004603162407875061, 0.007278971374034882, 0.013581417500972748, -0.020314306020736694, 0.008127006702125072, -0.010465528815984726, 0.009713861159980297, 0.03063207119703293, 0.029758337885141373, 0.011075858026742935, -0.015200394205749035, 0.04664195328950882, 0.004975784104317427, 0.01073535904288292, -0.03422979637980461, -0.013748454861342907, 0.006463058292865753, 0.005174944177269936, -0.043635282665491104, 0.014223868027329445, -0.04402075335383415, -0.020712625235319138, -0.03849567100405693, -0.010478378273546696, 0.0011523967841640115, -0.016382504254579544, 0.049545831978321075, -0.02042994648218155, -0.027419814839959145, 0.023834938183426857, 0.009501852095127106, 0.0002447337319608778, -0.023436617106199265, 0.00003274995106039569, 0.0037133675068616867, 0.03258512169122696, 0.02053273841738701, 0.009977266192436218, -0.018181366845965385, 0.01938917487859726, -0.012527797371149063, 0.019646156579256058, 0.0304521843791008, 0.023462316021323204, -0.05314355716109276, -0.011943167075514793, 0.010041511617600918, -0.020764021202921867, -0.03219965100288391, 0.005473683588206768, -0.01624116487801075, 0.04188781604170799, -0.0063377805054187775, 0.0406029112637043, 0.009784530848264694, 0.009611069224774837, 0.017744500190019608, 0.051524583250284195, -0.010279218666255474, -0.015714354813098907, 0.016562391072511673, -0.012193722650408745, 0.003453174838796258, -0.018027178943157196, 0.026725968345999718, -0.0005095440428704023, 0.007413886021822691, 0.0766315758228302, -0.0012704471591860056, 0.013889793306589127, 0.012572769075632095, -0.015778599306941032, 0.011917469091713428, 0.0469503290951252, -0.021791942417621613, 0.007658017799258232, 0.03836718201637268, -0.00008833703031996265, -0.020699776709079742, 0.018284158781170845, -0.010234246961772442, -0.02449023723602295, 0.008075610734522343, -0.037082280963659286, 0.01125574391335249, -0.03898393362760544, -0.018592536449432373, -0.0013981342781335115, -0.02813936024904251, 0.04494588077068329, 0.01419817004352808, 0.023436617106199265, 0.04109117388725281, 0.012360760010778904, -0.01060686819255352, -0.02040424756705761, -0.004962935112416744, -0.005663206800818443, 0.06085297092795372, -0.025890780612826347, 0.005380528513342142, -0.0033857175149023533, -0.011911043897271156, 0.005287372972816229, -0.051473185420036316, 0.013555719517171383, 0.02860192582011223, -0.014879168942570686, 0.02511983923614025, 0.029552752152085304, 0.003790461691096425, 0.0009444031747989357, 0.005618235096335411, -0.00851247739046812, 0.011165800504386425, 0.03168569132685661, -0.01926068589091301, -0.015238940715789795, -0.015046205371618271, 0.019247835502028465, 0.013337286189198494, 0.018656780943274498, 0.03464096412062645, -0.0003623825905378908, 0.006726463325321674, 0.03988336771726608, -0.012251542881131172, 0.007144056726247072, 0.006376327481120825, -0.01639535278081894, -0.018785271793603897, -0.024605879560112953, 0.017783047631382942, 0.02040424756705761, 0.012508523650467396, -0.012405731715261936, 0.031120333820581436, -0.0021730910521000624, 0.007773658726364374, 0.018052877858281136, -0.008332591503858566, 0.02246009185910225, -0.012694834731519222, -0.004130960907787085, -0.025787988677620888, 0.006421299185603857, -0.000967692059930414, 0.03063207119703293, -0.02326958067715168, -0.03291919827461243, 0.022948354482650757, -0.00026019272627308965, 0.035771679133176804, 0.006919198669493198, -0.004901902284473181, -0.0042530265636742115, -0.019620457664132118, 0.025286877527832985, 0.02862762287259102, -0.015431676059961319, 0.0011379416100680828, -0.009257720783352852, 0.014737829566001892, -0.015264639630913734, 0.03037508949637413, -0.01684506982564926, 0.020031627267599106, -0.014699282124638557, 0.0015458980342373252, -0.005020755808800459, 0.000994193134829402, -0.0222031120210886, -0.009187051095068455, 0.0072853961028158665, -0.007156905718147755, -0.005888064857572317, 0.004921175539493561, 0.023963427171111107, -0.017140597105026245, 0.013954038731753826, 0.014005434699356556, -0.008204100653529167, 0.0011138496920466423, 0.00851247739046812, -0.008383987471461296, -0.009861624799668789, -0.026905853301286697, 0.029758337885141373, -0.02451593615114689, 0.011403507553040981, -0.024400293827056885, -0.014223868027329445, -0.010195699520409107, -0.01329873874783516, 0.0034339013509452343, -0.01517469622194767, 0.02118803933262825, -0.02803656831383705, -0.02103384956717491, -0.04294143617153168, 0.022678526118397713, 0.03261081874370575, 0.01819421723484993, 0.008281195536255836, -0.008364713750779629, 0.017667407169938087, 0.00078097969526425, -0.03846997395157814, 0.005888064857572317, -0.014352358877658844, 0.011705460026860237, 0.013093153946101665, 0.014930564910173416, 0.009945143945515156, 0.004696317948400974, -0.010748207569122314, -0.01500765886157751, 0.022896958515048027, 0.017641708254814148, -0.004577464424073696, 0.023590806871652603, -0.010214973241090775, -0.008756608702242374, 0.01521324273198843, 0.0007685321616008878, 0.0043493942357599735, -0.02824215218424797, 0.013517172075808048, 0.009450456127524376, 0.007947120815515518, -0.02012157067656517, 0.010638991370797157, 0.018592536449432373, -0.006340992636978626, -0.0031576473265886307, 0.004696317948400974 ]
12.249501
3.189401
2024-07-01
1
2024MNRAS.532..381P
[ "upcoming large cluster surveys", "galaxy clusters", "clusters", "such noise", "Poisson statistics", "Poisson", "noise", "super-sample covariance", "SSC", "standard redshift bins" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
10
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1504", "10.48550/arXiv.2401.10024" ]
[ "Payerne, C.", "Murray, C.", "Combet, C.", "Penna-Lima, M." ]
[ "Université Paris-Saclay, CEA, IRFU, F-91191 Gif-sur-Yvette, France; Université Grenoble Alpes, CNRS-IN2P3, LPSC, F-38000 Grenoble, France", "Université Grenoble Alpes, CNRS-IN2P3, LPSC, F-38000 Grenoble, France; Université Paris Cité, CNRS-IN2P3, APC, F-75013 Paris, France", "Université Grenoble Alpes, CNRS-IN2P3, LPSC, F-38000 Grenoble, France", "Instituto de Física, Universidade de Brasília, 70910-900, Brasília, DF, Brazil; Centro Internacional de Física, Instituto de Física, Universidade de Brasília, 70910-900, Brasília, DF, Brazil; Departamento de Física, Universidade Estadual de Londrina, Rod. Celso Garcia Cid, Km 380, 86057-970, Londrina, Paraná, Brazil" ]
[ "2024arXiv240309589Z" ]
[ "1950PhRv...80..268W", "1979ApJ...228..939C", "1989MNRAS.237.1127C", "1991ApJ...382..377M", "1991MNRAS.248....1C", "1992MNRAS.254..729B", "1993Sci...260.1769T", "1995A&A...296..575B", "1995ApJ...439..520E", "1996ApJS..103....1B", "1996MNRAS.282..347M", "1997ASPC..126..365B", "1997MNRAS.287..753M", "2000AJ....120.1579Y", "2002MNRAS.331..587M", "2003ApJ...584..702H", "2003qftn.book.....Z", "2004PhRvD..70d3504L", "2005astro.ph.10346T", "2006PhRvD..73f7301H", "2007ApOpt..46.3444F", "2009arXiv0912.0201L", "2010A&A...520A...1T", "2010ApJ...708..645R", "2010ApJ...724..878T", "2010MNRAS.406.1759M", "2011ApJ...732...44S", "2011MNRAS.418..729S", "2011PASP..123..568C", "2011arXiv1110.3193L", "2012arXiv1209.3114M", "2013ApJ...767..116M", "2013ExA....35...25D", "2013JCAP...07..008H", "2013MNRAS.434..684M", "2013SSRv..177..119E", "2014A&A...571A..16P", "2014A&A...571A..20P", "2014JCAP...05..039P", "2014MNRAS.441.2456T", "2014MNRAS.441.3562E", "2015ApJ...799..214B", "2015MNRAS.446.2205M", "2016A&A...592A...1P", "2016A&A...594A..24P", "2016ApJ...832...95D", "2016MNRAS.456.2486D", "2017MNRAS.465.4658M", "2018A&A...611A..83L", "2018A&A...614A..13S", "2018A&A...620A..10P", "2019A&A...624A..61L", "2019ApJ...878...55B", "2019ApJS..242....2C", "2019MNRAS.488.4779C", "2019MNRAS.489..401Z", "2019SSRv..215...25P", "2020A&A...643A..20S", "2020ApJ...890..160W", "2020ApJ...901...90A", "2020PhRvD.101l3520P", "2020PhRvD.102b3509A", "2021A&A...652A..21F", "2021PhRvD.103d3522C", "2021PhRvL.126n1301T", "2022A&A...659A..88L", "2022A&A...659A.128G", "2022A&A...663A...3G", "2022ApJ...931..139C", "2022ApJ...934..129S", "2022EPJWC.25700004A", "2022MNRAS.512.4785M", "2023A&A...671A..28M", "2023A&A...671A.115L", "2023MNRAS.518.5171P", "2023MNRAS.520.6223P", "2023MNRAS.522.1601C", "2023arXiv230913025S", "2023arXiv231012213B", "2024A&A...682A.148F", "2024A&A...686A..15G", "2024arXiv240102075B", "2024arXiv240204006A", "2024arXiv240208458G", "2024arXiv240319542L" ]
29096755
2404.13629
The Lockman-SpReSO project. Main properties of infrared-selected star-forming galaxies
<BR /> Aims: In this work, we carry out a comprehensive study using galaxy data from the Lockman Spectroscopic Redshift Survey using Osiris (Lockman-SpReSO) project, a far-infrared (FIR) selected sample of galaxies observed using optical spectroscopy. We analyse a sub-sample of star-forming galaxies (SFGs) with secure spectroscopic redshifts, mostly in the luminous infrared (IR) galaxy domain. From these galaxies, parameters such as the extinction, star formation rate (SFR), and metallicity have been derived. The present paper examines how these properties evolve in relation to each other and in comparison with low-redshift FIR and non-FIR-selected samples of galaxies. <BR /> Methods: We applied distinct selection criteria to attain an SFG sample with minimal AGN contamination. Multiple approaches were used to estimate the intrinsic extinction, SFR, and gas-phase metallicity for the SFGs. In conjunction with findings in the literature, we examined the correlation between SFRs and stellar masses (M<SUB>*</SUB>), as well as the metallicity evolution depending on M<SUB>*</SUB>. Finally, we also studied the 3D relationship between M<SUB>*</SUB>, SFR, and metallicity. <BR /> Results: From the initial spectroscopic sample of 409 FIR-selected objects from the Lockman-SpReSO catalogue, 69 active galactic nuclei (AGNs) were identified and excluded (17%), which is nearly double the percentage found in local studies, leaving us with a sample of 340 SFGs. The analysis of the M<SUB>*</SUB>-SFR relationship revealed that Lockman-SpReSO IR-selected SFGs show signs of evolution at redshifts z &gt; 0.4, shifting above the main sequence (MS), with a mean value of ∼0.4 dex. They are located within the starburst galaxy region since 78% of the galaxies fall into this category. In addition, no evident flattening was found in the relation to specific SFR with redshift for log M<SUB>*</SUB> (M<SUB>⊙</SUB>)≳10.5. In line with the M<SUB>*</SUB>-metallicity relation (MZR) outcomes published in previous studies for optically selected SFGs; however, during the analysis of the MZR, it was found that IR-selected SFGs exhibit lower metallicities than the values anticipated on the basis of their M<SUB>*</SUB> and redshift. During the investigation of the 3D M<SUB>*</SUB>-SFR-metallicity relation (FP), it was established that the research sample is consistent with relations published in the existing literature, with an average scatter of ∼0.2 dex. However, a re-calibration of the FP when using the SFR obtained from the IR luminosity is required and, in this case, no attenuation in the correlation for log M<SUB>*</SUB> (M<SUB>⊙</SUB>)≳10.5 was observed. This result points to a possible evolution of the more massive fraction of the sample in the sense that the present-day star formation rate is lower with respect to the average rate of star formation in the past.
[ 0.01937330700457096, 0.031572211533784866, 0.022344525903463364, -0.018974728882312775, 0.013491262681782246, 0.023105448111891747, 0.022574009373784065, -0.010568357072770596, -0.013587887398898602, 0.017803151160478592, -0.021825166419148445, -0.015013106167316437, -0.04679064452648163, -0.0036475928500294685, 0.053675174713134766, 0.05604248493909836, -0.008478841744363308, -0.012355918996036053, -0.031161554157733917, 0.011377590708434582, 0.025798868387937546, -0.00041669519850984216, -0.022960510104894638, 0.007101935800164938, -0.09121397882699966, -0.026209525763988495, -0.003717042040079832, 0.029832961037755013, 0.026330305263400078, -0.027658900246024132, 0.011655387468636036, -0.017078464850783348, -0.016498714685440063, 0.015242589637637138, -0.09382285177707672, 0.07647866755723953, 0.00277343881316483, -0.017211323603987694, -0.007748115342110395, -0.04867483302950859, -0.015399605967104435, 0.00732538104057312, -0.029325680807232857, -0.023395322263240814, -0.007796427700668573, -0.02985711768269539, 0.03473667800426483, -0.042659927159547806, 0.0025756594259291887, -0.019095510244369507, -0.08821860700845718, -0.03480914607644081, 0.027658900246024132, -0.03664502128958702, 0.007887013256549835, 0.003218819620087743, -0.02409585379064083, -0.002693421207368374, -0.041911084204912186, -0.015423761680722237, -0.01629338599741459, -0.000817537889815867, 0.07585060596466064, 0.006606732960790396, -0.02664433792233467, -0.0004895413876511157, -0.024905087426304817, 0.032393522560596466, 0.024711837992072105, 0.061839986592531204, 0.016945606097579002, -0.015508309006690979, 0.016232995316386223, 0.007132131140679121, 0.028987493366003036, -0.03099246136844158, 0.018974728882312775, -0.055172860622406006, -0.043022271245718, -0.009976528584957123, -0.0007628088933415711, 0.025050025433301926, 0.001651683240197599, -0.018407057970762253, -0.005247944034636021, -0.009801396168768406, 0.009807434864342213, -0.008955927565693855, -0.057153671979904175, 0.015472074039280415, 0.0016969761345535517, -0.031040772795677185, -0.013334246352314949, -0.02652355656027794, 0.006023963447660208, -0.06483536213636398, 0.012682028114795685, -0.0601007342338562, 0.03775620833039284, 0.02274310402572155, 0.013756981119513512, 0.013660356402397156, 0.012839043512940407, -0.07768648117780685, 0.0031040774192661047, 0.012633715756237507, 0.04659739509224892, -0.038649991154670715, 0.0041518546640872955, -0.04367448762059212, 0.053481925278902054, -0.01004295889288187, -0.00010606100840959698, 0.04002689570188522, -0.03360133618116379, 0.0092699583619833, -0.08232448250055313, -0.01041738037019968, 0.0017936010845005512, 0.012718262150883675, 0.0020668685901910067, 0.011546684429049492, 0.004795014392584562, 0.05773342400789261, 0.03816686570644379, -0.01880563609302044, 0.027634743601083755, -0.056332360953092575, -0.022416993975639343, -0.004423612263053656, 0.04005105420947075, -0.030364397913217545, 0.026571867987513542, -0.025533150881528854, -0.024929244071245193, 0.011365512385964394, 0.017018074169754982, -0.057685110718011856, -0.008792872540652752, -0.003753276541829109, -0.03814271092414856, -0.003780452301725745, 0.0012878297129645944, 0.004722545854747295, 0.03398783504962921, -0.01138966903090477, -0.045993488281965256, 0.007548826280981302, 0.034857459366321564, 0.047297924757003784, -0.006042080465704203, -0.010296599008142948, -0.024156244471669197, -0.03432602435350418, 0.015943121165037155, -0.0015897827688604593, -0.0065644592978060246, 0.0012772614136338234, 0.0021755716297775507, 0.013612043112516403, -0.021112557500600815, 0.00914313830435276, -0.042732395231723785, 0.008641896769404411, 0.00514226034283638, -0.026257837191224098, -0.009523599408566952, -0.037418022751808167, -0.086044542491436, 0.011776168830692768, -0.0005031292675994337, -0.018527839332818985, -0.007905131205916405, -0.028117869049310684, -0.0077783106826245785, 0.032321054488420486, 0.032731711864471436, 0.013358402997255325, 0.027369024232029915, 0.02008591778576374, -0.01750119961798191, 0.033021584153175354, -0.02611289918422699, -0.002340136095881462, 0.00010256967652821913, -0.01851576194167137, -0.00654634227976203, -0.001000974327325821, 0.03311821073293686, -0.03019530512392521, 0.014203871600329876, 0.024409884586930275, 0.013587887398898602, 0.037635426968336105, -0.05121123790740967, -0.022622322663664818, -0.008104420267045498, 0.022731024771928787, -0.03601695969700813, 0.022272057831287384, 0.040220145136117935, 0.028649305924773216, 0.048167549073696136, -0.05797498673200607, -0.0194095429033041, -0.028600992634892464, 0.00957191176712513, -0.02008591778576374, -0.005492526106536388, 0.0005095457891002297, 0.067589171230793, -0.016390010714530945, 0.015013106167316437, 0.022090885788202286, -0.0031312531791627407, -0.028504367917776108, -0.046742331236600876, 0.024228712543845177, 0.028600992634892464, 0.030750898644328117, -0.012911512516438961, 0.011262848973274231, 0.05319204926490784, 0.027489805594086647, 0.04828833043575287, 0.02611289918422699, 0.02161983773112297, -0.02611289918422699, 0.016909370198845863, -0.04176614433526993, -0.004088444169610739, 0.03778036683797836, -0.01028452068567276, 0.003550967900082469, -0.0021921792067587376, -0.02712746150791645, -0.0006601448403671384, 0.034156929701566696, -0.014022699557244778, -0.0492304265499115, -0.0325143039226532, 0.03821517899632454, 0.009722888469696045, 0.018709011375904083, -0.019349152222275734, 0.007071740459650755, 0.01257332507520914, -0.02363688498735428, 0.019023042172193527, 0.011202458292245865, 0.011311161331832409, -0.0016984859248623252, -0.006226271856576204, -0.045727770775556564, -0.021511135622859, -0.002642089268192649, -0.03352886810898781, 0.019131746143102646, -0.02618536911904812, -0.00016805574705358595, -0.06517354398965836, -0.06155011057853699, -0.0009405837627127767, 0.01910758949816227, -0.05053486302495003, 0.044568270444869995, 0.019059276208281517, 0.02225997857749462, 0.0006590125267393887, 0.013358402997255325, 0.012464622035622597, 0.005353627726435661, 0.027103306725621223, -0.04413345828652382, -0.026740962639451027, 0.027924617752432823, 0.036548398435115814, 0.05237073823809624, 0.0014116305392235518, -0.007458240259438753, -0.011915067210793495, -0.010091271251440048, 0.05811992287635803, -0.010127505287528038, -0.037490490823984146, 0.017138855531811714, 0.014868168160319328, -0.011437981389462948, -0.008394294418394566, 0.0035570068284869194, 0.054834675043821335, -0.061501797288656235, 0.010061075910925865, 0.01465076208114624, -0.024337416514754295, -0.021535292267799377, 0.020810604095458984, 0.018986808136105537, -0.057008735835552216, 0.04952029883861542, 0.058844611048698425, 0.02577471174299717, 0.02693421207368374, 0.012084160931408405, -0.007168365642428398, -0.008907615207135677, 0.06729929894208908, 0.007409927900880575, -0.02094346284866333, 0.05473804846405983, 0.05280555039644241, 0.004408514592796564, 0.02457897923886776, 0.023334931582212448, -0.03874661400914192, -0.018479526042938232, -0.008829107508063316, 0.04323967546224594, 0.021631916984915733, -0.008569427765905857, -0.03454342857003212, -0.03814271092414856, 0.010761606507003307, 0.007796427700668573, -0.0137690594419837, -0.03768374025821686, -0.015435840003192425, -0.041307177394628525, 0.002380899852141738, 0.01787562109529972, 0.03949546068906784, -0.03229689970612526, 0.018008479848504066, -0.0013082115910947323, -0.02341947890818119, -0.01730794832110405, 0.03135480359196663, 0.06498029828071594, -0.0037321397103369236, -0.03106492944061756, -0.007995717227458954, -0.012851121835410595, -0.028238648548722267, 0.011081676930189133, -0.001692446880042553, 0.015170121565461159, 0.016245074570178986, 0.011504411697387695, 0.030340243130922318, 0.01448166836053133, 0.013865684159100056, 0.05536611005663872, 0.01614844985306263, -0.011214536614716053, 0.05609079822897911, -0.04154874011874199, 0.03608942776918411, -0.08217953890562057, 0.0029395129531621933, 0.001274996786378324, -0.010061075910925865, -0.00533853005617857, 0.015206355601549149, -0.00846676342189312, -0.005468369927257299, 0.01716301217675209, -0.010785763151943684, 0.030847523361444473, -0.011371552012860775, -0.0693284198641777, 0.005694834515452385, 0.001156480167992413, 0.02869761735200882, 0.0063712093979120255, -0.055800922214984894, 0.023093368858098984, 0.0158464964479208, 0.003638534341007471, 0.007887013256549835, 0.034567587077617645, 0.021825166419148445, 0.05328867584466934, -0.021511135622859, -0.03712814673781395, 0.014433356001973152, -0.032949116080999374, -0.016245074570178986, -0.010314716026186943, -0.08797704428434372, 0.039737019687891006, -0.02188555710017681, -0.008231240324676037, 0.019614869728684425, 0.017489120364189148, 0.016921449452638626, -0.05652561038732529, 0.011160184629261494, 0.09812266379594803, 0.030364397913217545, 0.04444748908281326, -0.045800238847732544, -0.018636541441082954, -0.03350470960140228, -0.022115040570497513, -0.010797841474413872, -0.01219286397099495, -0.006914725061506033, 0.047152988612651825, -0.005332490894943476, -0.02326246351003647, 0.03222442790865898, -0.035992804914712906, 0.04072742909193039, -0.022731024771928787, 0.010737450793385506, 0.04493061453104019, -0.022211667150259018, 0.05121123790740967, -0.04819170758128166, 0.025533150881528854, 0.02094346284866333, -0.01629338599741459, 0.020097995176911354, -0.00936658401042223, 0.0016592319589108229, 0.04222511500120163, 0.029494773596525192, -0.004795014392584562, -0.030823366716504097, -0.03727308288216591, -0.035461366176605225, 0.03210364654660225, 0.0032369366381317377, 0.0050546941347420216, -0.024905087426304817, -0.004157893359661102, 0.019023042172193527, -0.026837587356567383, 0.00013229317846708, -0.02645108662545681, 0.041790302842855453, 0.006793943699449301, 0.007911169901490211, -0.058168236166238785, 0.01764613576233387, -0.004656116012483835, 0.014191793277859688, 0.03278002142906189, 0.020387869328260422, -0.022284135222434998, -0.022984666749835014, -0.0031191750895231962, 0.007077779620885849, 0.023407399654388428, -0.03275586664676666, 0.005057713482528925, -0.00722271716222167, -0.05174267664551735, 0.0179480891674757, -0.054979611188173294, 0.020001370459794998, 0.015315058641135693, -0.008539232425391674, 0.043481238186359406, -0.021028010174632072, -0.004487022291868925, 0.004330006893724203, 0.01779107376933098, 0.020218776538968086, -0.023129602894186974, 0.03311821073293686, -0.043022271245718, -0.02768305502831936, 0.013406715355813503, -0.0024141145404428244, -0.03193455561995506, -0.031789615750312805, -0.01519427727907896, 0.04101730138063431, 0.036137741059064865, 0.03447096049785614, 0.006685240659862757, 0.03860167786478996, 0.04343292862176895, 0.022996744140982628, 0.05270892381668091, 0.02341947890818119, 0.05778173729777336, -0.03698321059346199, 0.016365855932235718, 0.012072082608938217, -0.049061331897974014, 0.023769743740558624, -0.011703699827194214, 0.012464622035622597, -0.053143735975027084, 0.0021755716297775507, -0.01686105877161026, 0.0018841869896277785, 0.024035463109612465, 0.08164810389280319, 0.011057520285248756, 0.01570155844092369, 0.025653930380940437, -0.008980083279311657, 0.01996513642370701, -0.04241836443543434, -0.03408446162939072, 0.012090200558304787, 0.000759411952458322, 0.0016954663442447782, 0.0634826123714447, 0.0035419093910604715, -0.0019038140308111906, 0.012210980989038944, 0.0007031731656752527, -0.014058934524655342, 0.010828036814928055, -0.00953567773103714, -0.013527496717870235, 0.017018074169754982, -0.028987493366003036, 0.004933912772685289, 0.03125818073749542, -0.005060733295977116, 0.0031735266093164682, -0.0018555015558376908, -0.12300359457731247, -0.027417337521910667, -0.011836559511721134, 0.00030195305589586496, -0.03128233551979065, 0.0050244987942278385, 0.00934846606105566, 0.008931770920753479, -0.053481925278902054, -0.0015052359085530043, -0.006244388874620199, -0.04024430364370346, -0.01350334007292986, 0.01016977895051241, 0.01118434127420187, -0.004924854263663292, 0.00292290560901165, 0.0037653546314686537, 0.03555799275636673, 0.0009134080028161407, 0.02596796303987503, -0.001170068047940731, -0.012911512516438961, 0.030485179275274277, -0.017066385596990585, 0.02761058695614338, 0.023093368858098984, -0.022755181416869164, -0.0029863156378269196, 0.0013165152631700039, -0.007120052818208933, 0.003886135760694742, -0.008943849243223667, 0.01138966903090477, -0.020858917385339737, -0.025267431512475014, 0.018382901325821877, 0.011238692328333855, -0.07338666915893555, 0.032659243792295456, -0.02529158815741539, -0.04855405166745186, 0.015049340203404427, -0.01176409050822258, -0.009191450662910938, 0.0023114506620913744, -0.0035056748893111944, -0.004459846764802933, -0.019530324265360832, -0.034640055149793625, 0.005513662938028574, 0.02686174400150776, -0.045462049543857574, -0.03140311688184738, -0.02105216681957245, 0.013322168961167336, -0.011607075110077858, -0.025750556960701942, -0.019735651090741158, -0.014264262281358242, 0.004179030191153288, 0.04065495729446411, -0.04488230124115944, -0.010761606507003307, 0.00015154268476180732, -0.012742418795824051, -0.012875278480350971, 0.010520044714212418, -0.0032308977097272873, 0.025484837591648102, 0.03604111447930336, -0.024482352659106255, 0.029132429510354996, 0.0033154445700347424, -0.009916137903928757, -0.04311889410018921, -0.015013106167316437, -0.008303709328174591, 0.04413345828652382, 0.005797498393803835, -0.0463075190782547, -0.011214536614716053, 0.011540645733475685, -0.02509833686053753, 0.008563388139009476, -0.021511135622859, -0.01202377025038004, -0.009583990089595318, 0.02195802517235279, 0.02143866755068302, 0.00016531928849872202, -0.008333904668688774, 0.022803494706749916, -0.04294980317354202, 0.01431257463991642, -0.0009390739724040031, 0.00923372432589531, 0.07758985459804535, 0.0062685455195605755, 0.007548826280981302, -0.021825166419148445, -0.032804179936647415, 0.0016909370897337794, 0.02056904137134552, -0.020738136023283005, -0.004345104563981295, -0.022429073229432106, -0.024699758738279343, -0.010036919265985489, 0.011190379969775677, 0.007548826280981302, -0.02570224367082119, 0.01603974588215351, 0.05575261265039444, -0.0035086944699287415, 0.029470616951584816, -0.04108976945281029, 0.0175374336540699, 0.007162326481193304, 0.0137690594419837, 0.0200496818870306, -0.02450650930404663, -0.02076229266822338, -0.01659533940255642, -0.028721773996949196, -0.0047829365357756615, 0.016051823273301125, 0.02686174400150776, 0.030002055689692497, 0.019626948982477188, 0.014409199357032776, -0.02618536911904812, 0.015206355601549149, -0.01798432320356369, 0.017404573038220406, 0.02076229266822338, 0.01809302717447281, -0.0009035944822244346, -0.0015082554891705513, -0.0037925303913652897, 0.01876940205693245, 0.0037019443698227406, 0.039133116602897644, 0.051307860761880875, -0.02773136831820011, 0.007114013656973839, 0.017634058371186256, -0.010501926764845848, -0.009843669831752777, 0.027972931042313576, -0.029325680807232857, -0.03377043083310127, 0.01896265149116516, 0.022465307265520096, -0.004583647474646568, -0.0044900416396558285, -0.021414510905742645, -0.030919993296265602, 0.018986808136105537, 0.0006152293644845486, -0.0013112311717122793, 0.011377590708434582, 0.0044115339405834675, -0.003113135928288102, 0.004671213682740927, 0.03106492944061756, -0.03611358627676964, -0.0057099321857094765, -0.02472391538321972, -0.021668151021003723, 0.007512591779232025, -0.018201729282736778, -0.05792667344212532, 0.04058248922228813, 0.02222374454140663, 0.0029666887130588293, -0.020967619493603706, -0.009825551882386208, -0.01746496371924877, -0.038384273648262024, 0.004695369862020016, -0.010942778550088406, -0.03828764706850052, 0.019977213814854622, 0.02120918221771717, -0.015218433924019337, 0.034301865845918655, 0.00675167003646493, -0.01346710603684187, -0.00030780339147895575, 0.0015686460537835956, 0.005075830966234207, -0.0060511389747262, -0.009372622705996037, -0.01498894952237606, -0.0081285759806633, -0.007856818847358227, 0.020689822733402252, -0.03550967946648598, 0.0508730486035347, 0.04990680143237114, -0.013020215556025505, -0.011027325876057148, 0.0258954931050539, 0.0031342727597802877, -0.012633715756237507, -0.008098380640149117, -0.005423076916486025, 0.026620181277394295, -0.01884187012910843, -0.017452886328101158, 0.004375299904495478, 0.04437502101063728, 0.02439780719578266, -0.017030151560902596, -0.007011349778622389, 0.035799555480480194, 0.0003106342046521604, -0.004245460033416748, 0.005891104228794575, 0.028504367917776108, 0.00859962310642004, 0.0183587446808815, -0.008714364841580391, 0.008913653902709484, 0.0036445732694119215, 0.0009473777026869357, 0.04770858213305473, -0.014264262281358242, 0.005574053153395653, -0.011758051812648773, 0.014493746683001518, 0.015580777078866959, 0.032876648008823395, 0.01850368268787861, 0.028915023431181908, 0.03060596063733101, -0.01869693212211132, 0.03956792876124382, -0.02300882339477539, -0.014493746683001518, 0.008068185299634933, -0.005281158722937107, -0.007717920001596212, -0.011208496987819672, 0.013901918195188046, -0.03128233551979065, -0.012766575440764427, 0.019771885126829147, 0.0006797718233428895, -0.024591056630015373, -0.01798432320356369, 0.022755181416869164, 0.023576494306325912, -0.04447164386510849, 0.0054985652677714825, 0.004028053488582373, -0.008400334045290947, 0.018636541441082954, -0.024663524702191353, 0.003928409423679113, -0.008188966661691666, -0.03183792904019356, 0.015097652561962605, 0.024603134021162987, -0.024591056630015373, 0.019010964781045914, -0.025678087025880814, 0.02956724353134632, -0.003692885860800743, -0.10261572152376175, 0.009118982590734959, 0.028117869049310684, 0.009789317846298218, 0.01618468388915062, 0.04282902181148529, 0.012633715756237507, 0.030557649210095406, 0.016800668090581894, -0.009426974691450596, 0.02158360369503498, -0.04770858213305473, -0.003197682788595557, 0.023878447711467743, 0.015894807875156403, -0.0032520343083888292, 0.004266596399247646, 0.019578635692596436, -0.010121466591954231, -0.0005431380704976618, -0.01663157343864441, 0.028166180476546288, -0.02112463489174843, 0.017803151160478592, 0.0002819486544467509, -0.007953443564474583, -0.05459311231970787, 0.013744902797043324, 0.005782400723546743, 0.004662155173718929, -0.0021619838662445545, -0.015556621365249157, 0.003276190720498562, 0.016124293208122253, -0.0024065657053142786, -0.02349194698035717, -0.016655730083584785, 0.008980083279311657, -0.0258471816778183, 0.02787630632519722, -0.009336388669908047, -0.026571867987513542, 0.02075021341443062, 0.03427771106362343, 0.06454548239707947, 0.0006582576315850019, 0.005646522156894207, 0.04703220725059509, 0.030630117282271385, 0.019095510244369507, 0.012343840673565865, 0.02263440005481243, 0.02686174400150776, 0.024784306064248085, -0.005679736845195293, 0.027997087687253952, -0.00850299745798111, -0.0029727278742939234, -0.03435017913579941, -0.003387913340702653, -0.02199426107108593, 0.016776511445641518, -0.007458240259438753, -0.03154805302619934, -0.027175774797797203, -0.016015589237213135, -0.055849235504865646, -0.014421277679502964, -0.01058647409081459, -0.02896333672106266, 0.019916823133826256, 0.012343840673565865, 0.02071397937834263, 0.03176546096801758, 0.024554822593927383, 0.007524670101702213, -0.014880246482789516, -0.0010643844725564122, -0.036620866507291794, 0.01746496371924877, -0.008496958762407303, -0.04910964518785477, 0.03584786504507065, -0.042659927159547806, -0.009620224125683308, 0.01682482473552227, 0.016607418656349182, 0.01951824501156807, -0.0037110031116753817, 0.029277367517352104, 0.02128165028989315, -0.022380759939551353, 0.061356861144304276, 0.025170806795358658, 0.012899434193968773, 0.010018802247941494, 0.018793558701872826, -0.04558283090591431, 0.0025620716623961926, -0.007361615542322397, -0.031644679605960846, -0.008551310747861862, -0.029591398313641548, -0.034374333918094635, 0.00953567773103714, -0.03420524299144745, -0.0006544832140207291, 0.038384273648262024, 0.00725895119830966, 0.018648620694875717, 0.0081285759806633, 0.006806021556258202, 0.009354505687952042, 0.024675603955984116, 0.023274540901184082, -0.010870309546589851, -0.020351635292172432, -0.021945947781205177, 0.00046953698620200157, -0.005718990694731474, 0.010387185029685497, -0.001692446880042553, -0.03664502128958702, 0.011848637834191322, 0.013708668760955334, 0.0219217911362648, 0.013382559642195702, -0.02454274334013462, 0.00442965142428875, 0.04268408194184303, -0.02154736965894699, 0.0051513188518583775, 0.016921449452638626, 0.002258608816191554, 0.0015225982060655951, -0.021631916984915733, 0.007107974961400032, 0.029615554958581924, 0.00957191176712513, 0.03659670799970627, 0.0059273382648825645, 0.026885898783802986, 0.0156653244048357, 0.04111392796039581, -0.01570155844092369, -0.010206012986600399, 0.01091862190514803, -0.02176477573812008, 0.03038855455815792, -0.0007246872992254794, 0.006552381440997124, -0.0200496818870306, 0.03099246136844158, 0.016196761280298233, 0.014771543443202972, 0.012108317576348782, -0.008345982059836388, -0.011745973490178585, -0.04195939749479294, 0.008617740124464035, 0.050341613590717316, 0.026088744401931763, 0.007397849578410387, -0.022694790735840797, 0.0022601184900850058, 0.014433356001973152, -0.0013391617685556412, 0.0034573625307530165, -0.002628501271829009, -0.023818057030439377, -0.02461521327495575, -0.058651361614465714, 0.0350748673081398, 0.009879903867840767, -0.01873316802084446, 0.0035147336311638355, -0.013189309276640415, 0.017114698886871338, -0.0058186352252960205, 0.03193455561995506, -0.007011349778622389, 0.00994633324444294, 0.003964643459767103, 0.012150591239333153, 0.011564801447093487, 0.014542059041559696, -0.03398783504962921, -0.0007628088933415711, 0.014771543443202972, 0.03135480359196663, -0.014252183958888054, 0.03079921193420887, -0.009239763021469116, 0.022054651752114296, -0.025823025032877922, 0.0542549230158329, -0.013756981119513512, -0.003550967900082469, -0.017247557640075684, -0.00968665350228548, 0.0021816107910126448, -0.04519633203744888, 0.004698389675468206, -0.013140996918082237, 0.02671680599451065, -0.02693421207368374, 0.015061418525874615, -0.007077779620885849, -0.0316929928958416, -0.005963572766631842, 0.026402775198221207, -0.013998543843626976, 0.027586430311203003, -0.018600307404994965, 0.03570292890071869, -0.015290902927517891, -0.007313302718102932, -0.011981497518718243, -0.0404617078602314, -0.019228370860219002, 0.0004819925525225699, -0.04761195555329323, -0.008792872540652752, 0.025871338322758675, 0.0033124249894171953, 0.035050708800554276, 0.008780795149505138, -0.017658215016126633, -0.010048997588455677, 0.0015278824139386415, 0.032127805054187775, 0.00480407290160656, -0.0015241079963743687, -0.05473804846405983, 0.0010809919331222773, 0.009759122505784035, 0.0017815229948610067, 0.0239750724285841, -0.011884871870279312, 0.010006723925471306, 0.02149905636906624, 0.0012772614136338234, 0.008074224926531315, -0.0077239591628313065, -0.013189309276640415, -0.008496958762407303, 0.021064244210720062, -0.00829766970127821, -0.004873522091656923, -0.01485608983784914, -0.00800175592303276, 0.004725565202534199, -0.01985643245279789, -0.01536337099969387, 0.016812745481729507, 0.0421043336391449, -0.05256398767232895, 0.03983364626765251, 0.026475243270397186, -0.024482352659106255, -0.007591099478304386, -0.007446162402629852, -0.025871338322758675, -0.03442264720797539, 0.01641416735947132, 0.0038499014917761087, -0.015520386397838593, 0.00867209117859602, -0.007446162402629852, -0.04990680143237114, 0.002580188913270831, -0.02877008728682995, 0.024977555498480797, 0.0026194427628070116, -0.011570841073989868, -0.0016803686739876866, -0.019276682287454605, 0.005746166687458754, 0.02322622947394848, 0.026016274467110634, -0.024458197876811028, -0.012766575440764427, 0.024905087426304817, 0.011993574909865856, -0.030146991834044456, 0.020846838131546974, 0.0010998640209436417, -0.024264946579933167, 0.023202072829008102, -0.005341549403965473, 0.01054420042783022, 0.026499399915337563, 0.013696590438485146, -0.01570155844092369, 0.02431325986981392, -0.045993488281965256, 0.019228370860219002, 0.011208496987819672, -0.023093368858098984, -0.01933707296848297, 0.0012795260408893228, -0.024699758738279343, 0.02008591778576374, 0.008774755522608757, -0.04563114419579506, -0.04766026884317398, -0.016873136162757874, -0.026499399915337563, -0.011099793948233128, 0.005915260408073664, 0.02465144731104374, -0.01805679313838482, -0.028045399114489555, 0.01326177828013897, 0.0008771736174821854, -0.015254667960107327, -0.002495642052963376, 0.009100864641368389, 0.019977213814854622, -0.015411683358252048, -0.008104420267045498, -0.024120010435581207, 0.022574009373784065, 0.015206355601549149, -0.031982868909835815, -0.003578143659979105, -0.003958604298532009, -0.001088540768250823, -0.004194127861410379, 0.01595519855618477, 0.014095168560743332, 0.02480846270918846, -0.0030225501395761967, -0.009288076311349869, 0.006190037354826927, 0.020786447450518608, 0.034156929701566696, 0.01611221395432949, 0.015484152361750603, 0.004622901324182749, -0.022392839193344116, -0.008557349443435669, -0.04051002115011215, 0.012633715756237507, -0.0010553259635344148, 0.001915892120450735, 0.008629818446934223, -0.02015838585793972, -0.03154805302619934, 0.0078085060231387615, 0.06411067396402359, 0.011057520285248756, 0.027175774797797203, -0.01108771562576294, -0.004653096664696932, -0.009082747623324394, -0.006854334380477667, 0.031113242730498314, 0.006576537620276213, -0.007319341879338026, -0.011697661131620407, 0.004480983130633831, -0.01741665229201317, -0.002383919432759285, 0.034156929701566696, -0.002784007228910923, -0.01887810416519642, 0.03193455561995506, -0.0211004801094532, 0.02076229266822338, -0.010683098807930946, 0.011739934794604778, 0.005954514257609844, 0.0185399167239666, -0.00889553688466549, -0.02288804203271866, 0.015520386397838593, 0.0027689095586538315, 0.0065040686167776585, 0.004749721381813288, 0.008980083279311657, -0.0051513188518583775, 0.017621980980038643, 0.013587887398898602, -0.016619496047496796, -0.02971217967569828, 0.018455371260643005, 0.022791415452957153, 0.023214150220155716, -0.00795948226004839, 0.010012763552367687, 0.012241176329553127, 0.04720130190253258, 0.014928558841347694, -0.017694449052214622, 0.019759807735681534, 0.02577471174299717, 0.04099314659833908, 0.009813474491238594, -0.0006057933205738664, -0.040002740919589996, -0.04193523898720741, 0.013793215155601501, -0.01611221395432949, 0.009982568211853504, 0.00514226034283638, 0.020375791937112808, 0.021450744941830635, 0.006938881240785122, -0.026209525763988495, -0.00501242047175765, -0.05362686142325401, -0.008231240324676037, 0.01764613576233387, 0.02480846270918846, -0.008225200697779655, 0.0032580734696239233, 0.021740619093179703, 0.022658556699752808, -0.032538462430238724, 0.012355918996036053, 0.0037864912301301956, -0.029832961037755013, 0.03357717767357826, -0.01172785647213459, -0.0018570112297311425, -0.011250770650804043, 0.025243274867534637, 0.0025560325011610985, -0.0014214440016075969, -0.00863585714250803, -0.011437981389462948, -0.025823025032877922, 0.013901918195188046, -0.028794242069125175, -0.023987149819731712, 0.013793215155601501, 0.0010960896033793688, -0.030509335920214653, 0.016390010714530945, -0.022875962778925896, -0.014240105636417866, 0.010840114206075668, 0.018974728882312775, -0.008345982059836388, 0.010598552413284779, -0.015653247013688087, 0.00803798995912075, 0.006262506358325481, -0.004704428371042013, -0.005966592114418745, 0.006419521756470203, 0.02240491658449173, -0.029663868248462677, 0.016124293208122253, -0.013491262681782246, -0.008515075780451298, -0.03125818073749542, 0.00607831496745348, -0.007283107377588749, 0.02281557209789753, 0.025243274867534637, -0.012851121835410595, 0.005513662938028574, 0.012754497118294239, 0.06285455077886581, 0.004589686170220375, -0.0005269080866128206, -0.014131402596831322, -0.011202458292245865, -0.0021665131207555532, -0.002242001472041011, 0.040002740919589996, -0.04819170758128166, -0.026765119284391403, -0.023238306865096092, -0.03645177185535431, -0.02930152416229248, -0.004622901324182749, 0.012790731154382229, -0.00985574722290039, -0.027513962239027023, -0.011848637834191322, 0.007059662137180567, 0.0014274830464273691, -0.004242440219968557, -0.01648663729429245, -0.020327478647232056, 0.034229397773742676, 0.001888716360554099, -0.014735308475792408, -0.019614869728684425, -0.012802809476852417, -0.022078806534409523, 0.024156244471669197, -0.008708326146006584, 0.0021936888806521893, -0.014385043643414974, 0.010501926764845848, 0.012500856071710587, -0.010815958492457867, 0.0035388898104429245, -0.0025243274867534637, 0.02383013442158699, -0.01899888552725315, 0.027900461107492447, -0.02802124246954918, 0.002272196812555194, -0.032345209270715714, 0.006413482595235109, -0.016088059172034264, 0.004055229481309652, -0.029204899445176125, -0.0017347203101962805, 0.027827993035316467, 0.0010115427430719137, -0.008176888339221478, 0.004607803653925657, -0.016691964119672775, 0.0031282335985451937, -0.024675603955984116, -0.04106561467051506, 0.011848637834191322, -0.029736336320638657, -0.04894055053591728, -0.015786105766892433, 0.004462866112589836, 0.006781865376979113, -0.02413208782672882, 0.013479184359312057, 0.004290753044188023, -0.044713206589221954, 0.03079921193420887, 0.00275381188839674, -0.022284135222434998, 0.009112942963838577, -0.009499442763626575, 0.019192136824131012, 0.025074182078242302, 0.005885065067559481, -0.000010031681995315012, 0.005586131475865841, -0.0027085188776254654, 0.0000444201250502374, 0.04108976945281029, 0.0651252344250679, -0.0017211324302479625, -0.02199426107108593, 0.007772271521389484, -0.0023914682678878307, -0.06473873555660248, 0.00041292081004939973, 0.01367243379354477, -0.023950915783643723, 0.013455027714371681, 0.008031951263546944, -0.0021348081063479185, 0.033287305384874344, 0.014505825005471706, 0.04485814645886421, -0.004795014392584562, -0.024591056630015373, -0.016643652692437172, 0.0011300592450425029, 0.0006174939917400479, 0.024627290666103363, 0.008201044984161854, 0.021342040970921516, 0.0030784113332629204, 0.03106492944061756, 0.035461366176605225, -0.0010394733399152756, -0.005755225196480751, -0.014904402196407318, -0.004314909223467112, 0.009553794749081135, 0.019699417054653168, 0.02495340071618557, 0.021535292267799377, 0.0017785034142434597, 0.026064587756991386, -0.030340243130922318, -0.027658900246024132, -0.029470616951584816, 0.005423076916486025, 0.05154942348599434, -0.02889086864888668, 0.009336388669908047, -0.024071697145700455, 0.002886671107262373, -0.00277343881316483, -0.03949546068906784, -0.003436225699260831, 0.01512180920690298, 0.025871338322758675, 0.03990611433982849, 0.027175774797797203, 0.016812745481729507, -0.05444817245006561, -0.009360544383525848, -0.016691964119672775, -0.014215949922800064, 0.022429073229432106, -0.022731024771928787, -0.02495340071618557, -0.02862514927983284, 0.03290080279111862, -0.02529158815741539, -0.028117869049310684, 0.02244115062057972, 0.01444543432444334, 0.006310818716883659, 0.011335317976772785, 0.013491262681782246, -0.005673697683960199, 0.0033335615880787373, -0.03191039711236954, -0.009662497788667679, -0.012500856071710587, 0.002255589235574007, 0.0139743871986866, -0.05256398767232895, -0.02806955575942993, -0.019506167620420456, 0.022151276469230652, -0.011679544113576412, -0.009420935064554214, -0.018817713484168053, 0.014071011915802956, 0.01549623068422079, 0.025581462308764458, -0.0010198464151471853, 0.02184932306408882, 0.00290327868424356, -0.007844740524888039, 0.023576494306325912, -0.0006488216458819807, 0.02855268120765686, -0.01926460489630699, 0.006938881240785122, 0.04224926978349686, 0.003351678838953376, 0.0014456001808866858, -0.026281993836164474, -0.00681809987872839, -0.008509037084877491, 0.005263041704893112, -0.014300496317446232, 0.010387185029685497, -0.006576537620276213, -0.014034777879714966, -0.0035962609108537436, -0.005613307002931833, 0.015085574239492416, 0.021897634491324425, 0.038722459226846695, -0.03099246136844158, 0.004788975231349468, 0.006256467197090387, -0.0079232482239604, 0.026233680546283722, 0.024832619354128838, -0.017283793538808823, 0.03534058481454849, 0.026233680546283722, 0.04519633203744888, -0.019469933584332466, 0.08449853956699371, -0.008919693529605865, -0.003928409423679113, -0.02181308902800083, 0.004209225531667471, 0.0225136186927557, -0.01959071308374405, 0.02664433792233467, 0.028915023431181908, 0.007114013656973839, 0.0033184639178216457, 0.02992958575487137, -0.02985711768269539, 0.0005861663375981152, -0.04889223724603653, -0.0016773492097854614, 0.04522049054503441, -0.01380529347807169, 0.020689822733402252, 0.000987386447377503, 0.05319204926490784, -0.029808804392814636, -0.028359429910779, -0.005350607912987471, -0.018141338601708412, 0.026837587356567383, -0.028745930641889572, -0.023431556299328804, 0.0015671363798901439, 0.013853605836629868, -0.01944577693939209, -0.019010964781045914, -0.04468905180692673, 0.007095896638929844, 0.012138512916862965, -0.01787562109529972, 0.0027824973221868277, 0.017295870929956436, 0.008907615207135677, 0.028093712404370308, -0.02956724353134632, -0.0020170463249087334, 0.0058488305658102036, -0.01573779247701168, 0.0038197061512619257, -0.0137690594419837, 0.028842555359005928, 0.007989677600562572, -0.004432670772075653, 0.033021584153175354, -0.023504026234149933, -0.01682482473552227, 0.00759713863953948, 0.012301567010581493, 0.013165152631700039, -0.0010115427430719137, 0.0021544350311160088, -0.028456054627895355, -0.042321737855672836, 0.02664433792233467, 0.019397463649511337, -0.0014169147470965981, -0.016208840534090996, 0.023612728342413902, -0.000055436692491639405, 0.0016999957151710987, 0.005320412572473288, 0.03258677199482918, -0.012307606637477875, -0.022247901186347008, 0.014058934524655342, -0.006975115276873112 ]
12.803917
7.28135
2024-07-01
0
2024A&A...687A..19G
[ "selected sample", "sample", "galaxy data", "star formation rate", "galaxies", "star formation", "relation", "relations", "secure spectroscopic redshifts", "SFGs" ]
[ "techniques: spectroscopic", "galaxies: evolution", "galaxies: fundamental parameters", "galaxies: general", "galaxies: star formation", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
29
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202449238", "10.48550/arXiv.2404.13629" ]
[ "González-Otero, Mauro", "Cepa, Jordi", "Padilla-Torres, Carmen P.", "Lara-López, Maritza A.", "Jesús González, J.", "Bongiovanni, Ángel", "Cedrés, Bernabé", "Cerviño, Miguel", "Cruz-González, Irene", "Elías-Chávez, Mauricio", "Herrera-Endoqui, Martín", "Ibarra-Medel, Héctor J.", "Krongold, Yair", "Nadolny, Jakub", "Alenka Negrete, C.", "María Pérez García, Ana", "de Diego, José A.", "Ignacio González-Serrano, J.", "Hernádez-Toledo, Héctor", "Pérez-Martínez, Ricardo", "Sánchez-Portal, Miguel" ]
[ "Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias, 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain , ; Departamento de Astrofísica, Universidad de La Laguna (ULL), 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Asociación Astrofísica para la Promoción de la Investigación, Instrumentación y su Desarrollo, ASPID, 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias, 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Departamento de Astrofísica, Universidad de La Laguna (ULL), 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Asociación Astrofísica para la Promoción de la Investigación, Instrumentación y su Desarrollo, ASPID, 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain", "Instituto de Astrofísica de Canarias, 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Departamento de Astrofísica, Universidad de La Laguna (ULL), 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Asociación Astrofísica para la Promoción de la Investigación, Instrumentación y su Desarrollo, ASPID, 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain; Fundación Galileo Galilei-INAF Rambla José Ana Fernández Pérez, 7, 38712, Breña Baja, Tenerife, Spain", "Departamento de Física de la Tierra y Astrofísica, Instituto de Física de Partículas y del Cosmos, IPARCOS. Universidad Complutense de Madrid (UCM), 28040, Madrid, Spain", "Instituto de Astronomía, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Apdo. Postal 70-264, 04510, Ciudad de México, Mexico", "Institut de Radioastronomie Millimétrique (IRAM), Av. Divina Pastora 7, Núcleo Central, 18012, Granada, Spain; Asociación Astrofísica para la Promoción de la Investigación, Instrumentación y su Desarrollo, ASPID, 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain", "Institut de Radioastronomie Millimétrique (IRAM), Av. Divina Pastora 7, Núcleo Central, 18012, Granada, Spain; Asociación Astrofísica para la Promoción de la Investigación, Instrumentación y su Desarrollo, ASPID, 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain", "Centro de Astrobiología (CSIC/INTA), 28692, ESAC Campus, Villanueva de la Cañada, Madrid, Spain", "Instituto de Astronomía, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Apdo. Postal 70-264, 04510, Ciudad de México, Mexico", "Instituto de Astronomía, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Apdo. Postal 70-264, 04510, Ciudad de México, Mexico", "Instituto de Astronomía, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Apdo. Postal 70-264, 04510, Ciudad de México, Mexico", "Instituto de Astronomía, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Apdo. Postal 70-264, 04510, Ciudad de México, Mexico", "Instituto de Astronomía, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Apdo. Postal 70-264, 04510, Ciudad de México, Mexico", "Astronomical Observatory Institute, Faculty of Physics, Adam Mickiewicz University, ul. Słoneczna 36, 60-286, Poznań, Poland", "Instituto de Astronomía, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Apdo. Postal 70-264, 04510, Ciudad de México, Mexico", "Centro de Astrobiología (CSIC/INTA), 28692, ESAC Campus, Villanueva de la Cañada, Madrid, Spain; Asociación Astrofísica para la Promoción de la Investigación, Instrumentación y su Desarrollo, ASPID, 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain", "Instituto de Astronomía, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Apdo. Postal 70-264, 04510, Ciudad de México, Mexico", "Instituto de Física de Cantabria (CSIC-Universidad de Cantabria), 39005, Santander, Spain; Asociación Astrofísica para la Promoción de la Investigación, Instrumentación y su Desarrollo, ASPID, 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain", "Instituto de Astronomía, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Apdo. Postal 70-264, 04510, Ciudad de México, Mexico", "ISDEFE for European Space Astronomy Centre (ESAC)/ESA, PO Box 78, 28690, Villanueva de la Cañada, Madrid, Spain; Asociación Astrofísica para la Promoción de la Investigación, Instrumentación y su Desarrollo, ASPID, 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain", "Institut de Radioastronomie Millimétrique (IRAM), Av. Divina Pastora 7, Núcleo Central, 18012, Granada, Spain; Asociación Astrofísica para la Promoción de la Investigación, Instrumentación y su Desarrollo, ASPID, 38205, La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain" ]
null
[ "1981PASP...93....5B", "1983ApJ...266..713O", "1988ApJ...326..680M", "1989agna.book.....O", "1991ApJS...76..813S", "1994ApJ...429..582C", "1998PASP..110..761F", "2000ApJ...533..682C", "2000SPIE.4008..623C", "2001A&A...371..833L", "2001ApJ...556..121K", "2001MNRAS.322..231K", "2003ApJ...593..258B", "2003ApJ...599..971H", "2003MNRAS.344.1000B", "2003MNRAS.346.1055K", "2003PASP..115..763C", "2004ApJ...613..898T", "2004ApJ...617..240K", "2004ApJS..154..166L", "2004ApJS..155..271S", "2004MNRAS.348L..59P", "2004MNRAS.351.1151B", "2005ApJ...631..163S", "2005ApJ...635..260S", "2005MNRAS.360.1413B", "2006ApJ...644..813E", "2006MNRAS.371..972S", "2006MNRAS.372..961K", "2007A&A...468...33E", "2008ApJ...672L.107E", "2008ApJ...674..172R", "2010A&A...521L..53L", "2010MNRAS.403.1036C", "2010MNRAS.408.2115M", "2011A&A...533A.119E", "2011ApJ...730..137Z", "2011ApJ...739L..40R", "2011ApJ...741..124H", "2011ApJS..195...10X", "2011ApJS..195...13O", "2011MNRAS.414.1263M", "2012ARA&A..50..531K", "2012ApJ...748..142D", "2012ApJ...754..120M", "2012MNRAS.427..906H", "2013ApJ...764..178L", "2013ApJ...774L..10K", "2013ApJ...778...23G", "2013MNRAS.430.2047H", "2013MNRAS.431.1956G", "2013MNRAS.434..451L", "2014ApJ...791..130Z", "2014ApJ...797...54K", "2014ApJ...797..126S", "2014ApJS..211...17A", "2014ApJS..214...15S", "2016Ap&SS.361...61D", "2016MNRAS.457.3678P", "2017ApJS..228....2L", "2017MNRAS.471.2124L", "2017PASJ...69...70O", "2018A&A...620A..50M", "2018ApJ...861...95H", "2018ApJ...869...92R", "2018MNRAS.473.2493M", "2018MNRAS.478.2132C", "2018MNRAS.479L..34M", "2019A&A...622A..17S", "2019A&A...622A.103B", "2019A&A...627A..42C", "2019A&A...631A..11R", "2019A&ARv..27....3M", "2019MNRAS.486.5621P", "2019MNRAS.490..634S", "2020A&A...636A..84N", "2021ApJ...914...19S", "2021ApJ...915L..17C", "2021ApJ...919...18E", "2021ApJ...919..143H", "2022A&A...663A.162P", "2022A&A...666A.186D", "2022A&A...667A..29F", "2022NatAs...6..844C", "2022yCat.9065....0W", "2023A&A...669A..85G", "2023ApJ...952..125N", "2023MNRAS.519.1526P" ]
29071990
2404.18999
CO Observations of Early-mid Stage Major Mergers in the MaNGA Survey
We present a study of the molecular gas in early-mid stage major mergers, with a sample of 43 major-merger galaxy pairs selected from the Mapping Nearby Galaxies at Apache Point Observatory survey and a control sample of 195 isolated galaxies selected from the xCOLD GASS survey. Adopting kinematic asymmetry as a new effective indicator to describe the merger stage, we aim to study the role of molecular gas in the merger-induced star formation enhancement along the merger sequence of galaxy pairs. We obtain the molecular gas properties from CO observations with the James Clerk Maxwell Telescope, Institut de Radioastronomie Milimetrique 30 m telescope, and the MaNGA-ARO Survey of CO Targets survey. Using these data, we investigate the differences in molecular gas fraction ( ), star formation rate (SFR), star formation efficiency (SFE), molecular-to-atomic gas ratio ( /M <SUB>H I </SUB>), total gas fraction (f <SUB>gas</SUB>), and the SFE of total gas (SFE<SUB>gas</SUB>) between the pair and control samples. In the full pair sample, our results suggest the of paired galaxies is significantly enhanced, while the SFE is comparable to that of isolated galaxies. We detect significantly increased and /M <SUB>H I </SUB> in paired galaxies at the pericenter stage, indicating an accelerated transition from atomic gas to molecular gas due to interactions. Our results indicate that the elevation of plays a major role in the enhancement of global SFR in paired galaxies at the pericenter stage, while the contribution of enhanced SFE in specific regions requires further explorations through spatially resolved observations of a larger sample spanning a wide range of merger stages.
[ 0.010451233014464378, 0.05538732931017876, -0.031708285212516785, 0.0026218232233077288, -0.04322327300906181, 0.03502575680613518, 0.02155153639614582, -0.011977750808000565, 0.018919195979833603, -0.015493547543883324, -0.014339645393192768, -0.0324535146355629, -0.03293430805206299, -0.029448559507727623, 0.0015385369770228863, 0.02706863358616829, -0.01432762574404478, 0.0024355161003768444, 0.008161458186805248, 0.024051658809185028, 0.001927678589709103, 0.00729002058506012, -0.014183387160301208, 0.03334297984838486, -0.04519452154636383, -0.034064169973134995, 0.009970440529286861, 0.011905631981790066, 0.06389736384153366, -0.019844722002744675, 0.022609280422329903, 0.00015344051644206047, -0.006124098319560289, -0.014868517406284809, -0.08490800857543945, 0.08529264479875565, -0.028054259717464447, -0.017657116055488586, -0.049040865153074265, -0.036732569336891174, -0.017621055245399475, 0.026251286268234253, -0.025409899652004242, 0.0013740157010033727, 0.008119388483464718, -0.02278957888484001, 0.037261441349983215, -0.044954124838113785, 0.021046705543994904, -0.009958420880138874, -0.05807977169752121, -0.004795907996594906, 0.03298238664865494, -0.06894568353891373, 0.022477062419056892, -0.021575577557086945, -0.0015715914778411388, 0.001745878835208714, 0.021275080740451813, 0.0024009591434150934, 0.0008128402987495065, -0.024255996569991112, 0.03339105844497681, -0.017969630658626556, -0.02497718669474125, 0.013750674203038216, -0.018185988068580627, 0.031347692012786865, 0.05000245198607445, 0.03404013067483902, 0.016455134376883507, 0.028727369382977486, 0.00966393481940031, 0.006574841681867838, 0.017344599589705467, -0.02985723316669464, -0.003921466413885355, 0.011184442788362503, -0.06630132347345352, -0.0016752623487263918, 0.041131824254989624, -0.025890691205859184, 0.03053034283220768, -0.0028517022728919983, -0.031227491796016693, -0.02039763517677784, -0.019039394333958626, 0.019087474793195724, -0.0586567223072052, 0.0395452082157135, 0.024688709527254105, 0.011569077149033546, -0.010565421544015408, -0.03976156562566757, 0.030963055789470673, -0.04500220715999603, 0.020517833530902863, -0.05697394534945488, 0.02550605870783329, 0.053079523146152496, 0.03209291771054268, 0.020806308835744858, -0.005246651358902454, -0.03264583274722099, 0.03488151729106903, -0.0483437143266201, 0.0264916829764843, -0.0025286695454269648, 0.07086885720491409, 0.03194868192076683, 0.08365795016288757, -0.0018510522786527872, -0.0070676542818546295, 0.023174213245511055, -0.033487219363451004, 0.021719815209507942, -0.03394396975636482, 0.03593926131725311, -0.038463424891233444, -0.011466908268630505, -0.031227491796016693, -0.001834525028243661, 0.006664989981800318, 0.05336800217628479, 0.009832212701439857, -0.013438158668577671, 0.022801598533988, -0.03173232451081276, -0.015878181904554367, 0.02066207118332386, -0.010673600248992443, -0.0037832383532077074, 0.0454108789563179, -0.0027525387704372406, -0.05923367291688919, -0.028823528438806534, -0.0016346955671906471, -0.04194917157292366, -0.018943237140774727, 0.009748074226081371, 0.011611145921051502, -0.028991805389523506, 0.06500318646430969, 0.0211909431964159, -0.018630720674991608, -0.041300103068351746, -0.05985870212316513, 0.033535297960042953, -0.02896776609122753, -0.025385860353708267, -0.035434428602457047, -0.020601971074938774, 0.01840234361588955, -0.0471176952123642, -0.004095753654837608, -0.012320315465331078, -0.06221458688378334, -0.036780647933483124, -0.01897929608821869, -0.024784868583083153, -0.03565078601241112, 0.01015674788504839, -0.020385615527629852, 0.002878746949136257, 0.023510767146945, 0.025361819192767143, -0.04154049605131149, 0.01573394425213337, -0.08207133412361145, -0.014543982222676277, -0.018690820783376694, -0.045122403651475906, -0.03137173131108284, -0.02186405286192894, 0.0007332090171985328, -0.023426629602909088, -0.013858851976692677, -0.06553205847740173, -0.0037772285286337137, 0.011508977971971035, -0.0037772285286337137, 0.04860815033316612, 0.01215203758329153, -0.003233331488445401, -0.05024284869432449, 0.028342735022306442, -0.0409635454416275, 0.0732247456908226, 0.01914757303893566, -0.03533827140927315, 0.015493547543883324, 0.007987170480191708, 0.021539516746997833, 0.035169992595911026, -0.012206126935780048, -0.035001713782548904, 0.017188342288136482, 0.012620811350643635, -0.011605136096477509, 0.056589312851428986, 0.04880046844482422, -0.030025510117411613, 0.03430456668138504, -0.04341559112071991, -0.05798361077904701, -0.07812882959842682, 0.023354509845376015, -0.013942991383373737, -0.006232276558876038, 0.01875091902911663, 0.050194766372442245, 0.02186405286192894, 0.01800568960607052, 0.025265661999583244, -0.021671734750270844, -0.04865623265504837, -0.0396413654088974, 0.039449047297239304, 0.09279301017522812, 0.005063348915427923, 0.00810736883431673, 0.01591424085199833, 0.030506303533911705, 0.01552960742264986, 0.00906294398009777, 0.008449933491647243, 0.03569886460900307, -0.02916008234024048, 0.03391993045806885, -0.025650296360254288, -0.004191912245005369, 0.02916008234024048, -0.02528970129787922, 0.01552960742264986, -0.01942402869462967, -0.01364249549806118, -0.012945345602929592, 0.00955575704574585, 0.010499312542378902, -0.0029809153638780117, -0.012801107950508595, 0.0469253771007061, 0.025097383186221123, -0.0010412168921902776, -0.005565176717936993, 0.04185301437973976, -0.005390889011323452, -0.0055862111039459705, -0.020553892478346825, 0.0146641805768013, 0.016551291570067406, -0.005760498810559511, -0.02839081548154354, -0.021924151107668877, -0.005847642198204994, -0.015589706599712372, -0.003963535651564598, 0.054906535893678665, -0.02458053268492222, 0.027260951697826385, -0.015325270593166351, 0.010030539706349373, -0.051829464733600616, 0.012596771121025085, -0.04916106536984444, 0.04557915776968002, 0.020950546488165855, 0.01564980484545231, -0.01782539300620556, 0.021827993914484978, -0.025698374956846237, -0.015926260501146317, 0.019303830340504646, -0.009988470003008842, -0.04887258633971214, 0.03360741585493088, -0.0026098033413290977, 0.04303095489740372, 0.017140263691544533, -0.012837167829275131, 0.012332335114479065, -0.006803218275308609, 0.03839130327105522, -0.013498257845640182, -0.006779178511351347, 0.024640630930662155, 0.025409899652004242, -0.0018675795290619135, -0.03452092409133911, -0.018582642078399658, 0.0647147074341774, -0.029136043041944504, 0.03101113624870777, -0.013161703012883663, -0.024195898324251175, -0.023354509845376015, 0.01330594066530466, -0.001058495370671153, -0.025121424347162247, 0.022152528166770935, 0.03288622573018074, -0.020553892478346825, -0.007951110601425171, 0.023342490196228027, 0.009080974385142326, -0.003425648668780923, 0.03774223476648331, -0.03053034283220768, -0.01763307675719261, 0.03634793683886528, -0.0036600350867956877, -0.0439925417304039, 0.04557915776968002, 0.005372859537601471, -0.015721924602985382, -0.003912451211363077, 0.022597260773181915, 0.04440121352672577, -0.00009831837087403983, -0.008101359009742737, -0.050819799304008484, -0.034064169973134995, -0.028198497369885445, -0.01622675731778145, 0.02008511871099472, 0.003581906436011195, -0.04346366971731186, -0.06380120664834976, -0.02853505313396454, -0.012945345602929592, -0.0033595396671444178, 0.01119646243751049, 0.0117553835734725, 0.009231221862137318, 0.024808907881379128, -0.0336795337498188, 0.030987095087766647, 0.05346415936946869, -0.006286365911364555, 0.034857477992773056, -0.020782269537448883, -0.02141931839287281, -0.013269880786538124, 0.008053279481828213, 0.029184123501181602, 0.028270617127418518, 0.05529117211699486, 0.03394396975636482, 0.04180493205785751, -0.021575577557086945, -0.007187852170318365, 0.021623656153678894, 0.03586714342236519, 0.006707059685140848, 0.030097629874944687, -0.003326485166326165, 0.04670901969075203, -0.03656429052352905, 0.04829563573002815, 0.0072058821097016335, 0.0021335179917514324, -0.013257861137390137, 0.02284967713057995, 0.012488593347370625, 0.013870872557163239, 0.014015110209584236, -0.04368002712726593, 0.034641120582818985, -0.020097138360142708, -0.033174704760313034, 0.0293283611536026, 0.04038659483194351, -0.02283765748143196, 0.04322327300906181, -0.046901337802410126, -0.02497718669474125, -0.004804923199117184, 0.008233577013015747, 0.01229026634246111, -0.012753029353916645, 0.04723789170384407, -0.0013334488030523062, -0.027188831940293312, -0.009946401230990887, 0.02031349577009678, 0.010871927253901958, -0.025530098006129265, -0.01573394425213337, -0.07284010946750641, 0.0069053866900503635, -0.02123902179300785, 0.008209536783397198, 0.03649217262864113, 0.018726879730820656, -0.01950816810131073, -0.016731590032577515, 0.05466614291071892, 0.04353578761219978, 0.011256561614573002, 0.001896126545034349, -0.027116714045405388, -0.03300642594695091, -0.012476572766900063, -0.031443849205970764, -0.013221802189946175, -0.015589706599712372, -0.02728499099612236, 0.04062699154019356, 0.026371484622359276, -0.004540487192571163, 0.017921552062034607, -0.008395844139158726, 0.03666045144200325, -0.0022146517876535654, -0.00600089505314827, 0.0235588476061821, -0.06053181365132332, 0.055435407906770706, -0.04009811952710152, 0.04562723636627197, -0.005862667225301266, 0.004931130912154913, 0.013005444779992104, -0.03524211049079895, -0.047261931002140045, -0.006274345796555281, 0.014676200225949287, 0.025698374956846237, 0.009459597989916801, -0.0767345279455185, -0.04435313493013382, 0.058560561388731, 0.019856741651892662, -0.040242355316877365, 0.024412253871560097, 0.02791002206504345, -0.005883702076971531, 0.007987170480191708, -0.04420889914035797, -0.03742972016334534, 0.009411519393324852, 0.01631089486181736, 0.016719570383429527, -0.05173330381512642, 0.015541627071797848, -0.022945836186408997, 0.03706912323832512, 0.018811017274856567, 0.022777559235692024, -0.01324584148824215, -0.01665947027504444, -0.018426384776830673, 0.03351125866174698, 0.06255114078521729, -0.021407298743724823, -0.01539738941937685, 0.024340135976672173, -0.018474463373422623, 0.041756853461265564, -0.03057842142879963, 0.028727369382977486, 0.03327086195349693, -0.018726879730820656, -0.00013390831009019166, -0.04372810572385788, 0.01631089486181736, -0.01384683232754469, -0.013113623484969139, 0.007025584578514099, 0.0005562923033721745, 0.049665894359350204, -0.09269685298204422, 0.027140753343701363, -0.0088225482031703, -0.0020178272388875484, -0.026251286268234253, 0.009736054576933384, -0.009477628394961357, 0.04771868512034416, 0.03026590682566166, 0.02431609481573105, 0.04656478390097618, 0.013870872557163239, 0.0734170600771904, 0.015433448366820812, 0.028102338314056396, -0.01937595009803772, 0.010162757709622383, -0.031876564025878906, -0.03399205207824707, 0.00810736883431673, -0.044232938438653946, 0.0499543733894825, -0.011466908268630505, 0.006316415499895811, -0.007127752993255854, 0.006496712565422058, -0.024508412927389145, 0.005087388679385185, -0.017873471602797508, 0.05327184125781059, -0.007115733344107866, 0.04478584975004196, -0.009525706991553307, 0.024808907881379128, 0.0015896211843937635, -0.032597750425338745, -0.035434428602457047, -0.022813618183135986, 0.021924151107668877, -0.002151547698304057, 0.01201981958001852, 0.011761393398046494, -0.023534808307886124, -0.013402098789811134, 0.006172177381813526, -0.002988427644595504, 0.01066759042441845, 0.029616836458444595, 0.012278245761990547, 0.007921061478555202, -0.030770739540457726, 0.000544648093637079, 0.0033114603720605373, -0.016959965229034424, -0.01066759042441845, -0.02084236778318882, -0.11942893266677856, -0.029977431520819664, -0.04173281416296959, 0.021395279094576836, 0.006298385560512543, 0.0019607332069426775, 0.009856251999735832, -0.01827012561261654, -0.016383014619350433, 0.006496712565422058, -0.014856497757136822, -0.02528970129787922, -0.0248810276389122, 0.012037849985063076, -0.006202226970344782, -0.034016091376543045, -0.0005671852268278599, 0.029232202097773552, 0.053656477481126785, -0.0005743220099247992, 0.025650296360254288, 0.02759750746190548, 0.032237157225608826, 0.013402098789811134, -0.014736299403011799, 0.011316660791635513, 0.0058927168138325214, -0.020145218819379807, 0.030410144478082657, -0.0380307100713253, -0.025313740596175194, 0.003915456123650074, -0.020722169429063797, -0.013029485009610653, 0.002907293848693371, -0.036900848150253296, -0.0037051094695925713, 0.014483883045613766, -0.01763307675719261, 0.022921796888113022, -0.02298189513385296, -0.04303095489740372, -0.002838179934769869, -0.010992125608026981, -0.012981405481696129, 0.02066207118332386, -0.03012166917324066, 0.0059588258154690266, -0.0183542650192976, -0.028198497369885445, 0.02052985318005085, 0.01426752656698227, -0.020914487540721893, -0.002166572492569685, -0.015457488596439362, 0.04327135160565376, 0.03288622573018074, -0.020962566137313843, 0.022368885576725006, 0.004489402752369642, 0.003206287045031786, 0.03613157942891121, -0.020193297415971756, -0.017873471602797508, -0.04514644294977188, 0.023967521265149117, 0.00023325963411480188, 0.012302285991609097, -0.00906294398009777, 0.02577049471437931, -0.0031491927802562714, -0.02639552392065525, -0.005481037776917219, -0.0028652246110141277, -0.010823847725987434, -0.03639601543545723, -0.008516042493283749, -0.03942500799894333, 0.011647205799818039, -0.006103063467890024, -0.053800713270902634, -0.008137417957186699, 0.02519354224205017, -0.0026593850925564766, 0.013101603835821152, -0.003488752758130431, -0.016959965229034424, -0.021142862737178802, 0.0011140870628878474, -0.0038763920310884714, -0.023979540914297104, 0.01795761100947857, -0.020902466028928757, -0.017428738996386528, 0.015481527894735336, 0.014459843747317791, -0.013762693852186203, 0.04728597030043602, -0.00009085293277166784, -0.0059167565777897835, -0.002094453666359186, 0.0002574870886746794, -0.009243241511285305, 0.0019607332069426775, -0.001691789599135518, 0.013366039842367172, -0.011124343611299992, -0.020938526839017868, -0.017308540642261505, -0.0003519553574733436, 0.05625275894999504, -0.04981013387441635, -0.02639552392065525, 0.018390323966741562, -0.0006028690841048956, 0.0036990996450185776, -0.022645341232419014, 0.022549182176589966, 0.008101359009742737, 0.03084285743534565, 0.01804175041615963, -0.025265661999583244, -0.015721924602985382, 0.0017669135704636574, -0.023835303261876106, -0.0396413654088974, -0.006851297337561846, 0.027044594287872314, -0.008642250671982765, 0.0022837657015770674, -0.00893072597682476, -0.023270372301340103, 0.010751728899776936, 0.013089584186673164, -0.002124503254890442, -0.025265661999583244, -0.017849432304501534, 0.006024934817105532, 0.03418436646461487, -0.0005202328320592642, 0.03807878866791725, 0.011112323962152004, 0.006863316986709833, 0.07630182057619095, -0.03892017528414726, 0.04067507013678551, 0.009525706991553307, -0.010138718411326408, 0.0029583782888948917, -0.009129052981734276, -0.005045319441705942, -0.031660206615924835, 0.005084383767098188, 0.03985772281885147, 0.011292620562016964, -0.00025673583149909973, -0.0033355001360177994, -0.023931462317705154, -0.013438158668577671, 0.023306431248784065, -0.011653215624392033, 0.017164302989840508, 0.005213596858084202, 0.0021770899184048176, 0.004026639740914106, 0.026419565081596375, 0.009597825817763805, 0.00948363821953535, -0.03504979610443115, 0.015517587773501873, 0.012969385832548141, -0.0025677341036498547, -0.042598240077495575, 0.022813618183135986, -0.0010675102239474654, -0.009417529217898846, 0.019363930448889732, -0.020061079412698746, -0.03918461129069328, -0.0020418670028448105, 0.012837167829275131, 0.014003090560436249, -0.0241237785667181, 0.023174213245511055, 0.01024689618498087, -0.006923416163772345, 0.019075455144047737, -0.0006115083233453333, 0.0066770100966095924, -0.030145708471536636, 0.011875581927597523, -0.030650541186332703, -0.04593975096940994, -0.024424273520708084, -0.0034827429335564375, -0.05283913016319275, -0.0037712184712290764, 0.0030830837786197662, -0.03461708128452301, 0.017885491251945496, 0.029232202097773552, -0.040458712726831436, -0.026203207671642303, 0.056589312851428986, 0.04341559112071991, -0.04536280035972595, -0.019231712445616722, 0.02164769545197487, 0.04807927832007408, 0.00565532548353076, -0.03173232451081276, -0.02324633114039898, 0.027741745114326477, 0.030674580484628677, -0.028631210327148438, 0.002119995653629303, 0.029881272464990616, -0.008636240847408772, -0.019616346806287766, -0.003332494990900159, 0.0016587350983172655, 0.009183142334222794, 0.0021846021991223097, -0.0025316744577139616, 0.008918706327676773, -0.003789248177781701, -0.005673354957252741, 0.04271844029426575, -0.013053524307906628, -0.00019400739984121174, -0.008762449026107788, 0.015048814937472343, 0.0279581006616354, 0.014628120698034763, 0.005526112392544746, -0.01830618642270565, 0.030386105179786682, -0.012993425130844116, 0.041300103068351746, -0.014471863396465778, -0.0013800255255773664, 0.014027129858732224, -0.02964087575674057, -0.01604645885527134, -0.01697198487818241, 0.020950546488165855, -0.046636901795864105, 0.030554382130503654, 0.026587842032313347, 0.0007388432859443128, -0.01191164180636406, -0.004083734005689621, -0.02039763517677784, 0.02026541717350483, -0.01647917367517948, -0.02702055498957634, 0.008684319444000721, -0.019339891150593758, 0.01990482211112976, -0.017849432304501534, -0.024688709527254105, 0.006322425324469805, -0.010457243770360947, -0.010571431368589401, 0.0011869572335854173, 0.007368149701505899, -0.0004796659341081977, -0.011220501735806465, 0.03807878866791725, -0.003569886554032564, -0.08385026454925537, -0.0013815280981361866, 0.04581955447793007, -0.0034977674949914217, -0.013317960314452648, 0.02048177272081375, 0.0028366774786263704, 0.042814597487449646, 0.017801353707909584, -0.01432762574404478, -0.0003549602988641709, -0.01794559136033058, -0.013822793029248714, 0.013810773380100727, -0.010487292893230915, -0.01635897532105446, -0.022717459127306938, -0.008455943316221237, -0.02252514287829399, 0.016743609681725502, -0.01563778519630432, 0.027309030294418335, 0.0007857957389205694, -0.004017625004053116, 0.01170730497688055, 0.011238531209528446, -0.02138325944542885, 0.0176450964063406, -0.0010209335014224052, 0.020205317065119743, -0.014952655881643295, -0.0037021045573055744, 0.02916008234024048, 0.04216552898287773, -0.006322425324469805, -0.00878047849982977, -0.0041618626564741135, 0.026780158281326294, -0.02733307145535946, -0.004221961833536625, -0.0007516143377870321, -0.006604891270399094, 0.017669135704636574, 0.04865623265504837, 0.030289946123957634, -0.019880782812833786, 0.019724523648619652, 0.010697639547288418, 0.024856988340616226, -0.016587352380156517, 0.0005367600824683905, 0.016719570383429527, 0.023570867255330086, 0.01149094756692648, 0.02995339035987854, 0.036732569336891174, 0.014652160927653313, -0.007602536119520664, -0.004303095396608114, -0.02639552392065525, -0.024328116327524185, 0.026155129075050354, 0.018330225721001625, -0.008371804840862751, -0.02492910623550415, -0.02458053268492222, -0.025674335658550262, 0.02049379236996174, -0.010781778022646904, -0.01290928665548563, -0.009922361001372337, 0.009123043157160282, 0.027405189350247383, 0.02283765748143196, 0.01204385980963707, 0.005685374606400728, -0.03199676051735878, 0.0046666949056088924, -0.05524309352040291, 0.010325025767087936, -0.016070500016212463, -0.034544963389635086, 0.04262228310108185, -0.026010889559984207, 0.0036209707614034414, -0.008834567852318287, -0.005595226306468248, -0.014435803517699242, -0.02217656746506691, -0.016611391678452492, 0.00596483564004302, -0.031756363809108734, 0.004600585903972387, -0.008696340024471283, 0.03307854384183884, 0.016058478504419327, -0.010403154417872429, -0.013113623484969139, 0.02301795594394207, 0.005024284590035677, -0.00879850797355175, -0.016118578612804413, 0.0040927487425506115, -0.015721924602985382, 0.045314721763134, -0.005300740711390972, 0.0007579998928122222, 0.036684490740299225, 0.0176450964063406, 0.0022176566999405622, 0.013137662783265114, 0.022477062419056892, -0.030073588714003563, -0.016827747225761414, 0.01379875373095274, -0.023931462317705154, -0.04497816786170006, -0.007055634167045355, -0.0006242793751880527, -0.0365162119269371, -0.005520102102309465, 0.000544648093637079, -0.036468133330345154, 0.010523352771997452, 0.025385860353708267, -0.002119995653629303, -0.007644605357199907, 0.028006181120872498, -0.022428983822464943, 0.008750428445637226, -0.01046325359493494, -0.010192807763814926, 0.01144286897033453, -0.010751728899776936, 0.004874037113040686, -0.012981405481696129, -0.007380169350653887, 0.049209143966436386, 0.03976156562566757, 0.026563802734017372, 0.006154147908091545, 0.0036600350867956877, 0.004249006509780884, 0.007704704534262419, -0.00600089505314827, -0.005114433355629444, -0.0034466832876205444, -0.03728548064827919, 0.02497718669474125, 0.0005885955761186779, -0.0033865843433886766, 0.01526517141610384, 0.01586616225540638, -0.007698694709688425, -0.0205779317766428, -0.024508412927389145, 0.0044353133998811245, 0.017488837242126465, 0.006833267863839865, -0.0015550642274320126, 0.035169992595911026, 0.016298875212669373, -0.004327135160565376, -0.013991069979965687, 0.025361819192767143, 0.024147817865014076, -0.00476585840806365, 0.003942500799894333, 0.003302445635199547, -0.014519942924380302, -0.007109723519533873, -0.050819799304008484, 0.013113623484969139, 0.007578496355563402, -0.024099739268422127, 0.027885982766747475, 0.013269880786538124, -0.009946401230990887, 0.00742223858833313, 0.00942353904247284, -0.05173330381512642, -0.030145708471536636, -0.017969630658626556, 0.004125803243368864, 0.0088225482031703, -0.03031398542225361, -0.019135553389787674, -0.02528970129787922, 0.020109158009290695, 0.0322611965239048, -0.013991069979965687, 0.03154000639915466, 0.03504979610443115, 0.04497816786170006, 0.012957366183400154, 0.020866407081484795, -0.013113623484969139, 0.01817396841943264, -0.046684980392456055, 0.007404209114611149, -0.005889711901545525, -0.051444828510284424, 0.006454643327742815, -0.0396413654088974, 0.027982139959931374, -0.032189078629016876, -0.017500856891274452, -0.039833683520555496, -0.036852769553661346, -0.004363194573670626, 0.016984006389975548, 0.010000490583479404, 0.02822253666818142, -0.008455943316221237, 0.05692586675286293, -0.044425252825021744, 0.031035175547003746, -0.006106068380177021, -0.004086738917976618, -0.008522052317857742, 0.029544716700911522, -0.03577098250389099, -0.022897757589817047, 0.036900848150253296, 0.02021733671426773, 0.033126622438430786, -0.012536671943962574, -0.012704949826002121, -0.02387136220932007, 0.00501226494088769, -0.0007775321137160063, -0.016647450625896454, -0.025890691205859184, -0.03394396975636482, -0.03084285743534565, -0.002826160052791238, -0.0015227609546855092, 0.010264926590025425, -0.027837902307510376, -0.00004178765448159538, 0.015986360609531403, 0.00712174316868186, 0.0025827588979154825, 0.03723740205168724, 0.018282145261764526, -0.04274247959256172, 0.016022419556975365, -0.0051504927687346935, 0.011076264083385468, 0.004221961833536625, -0.009681965224444866, 0.020854387432336807, 0.0025046300143003464, 0.009255261160433292, 0.017260462045669556, 0.0264916829764843, -0.01432762574404478, 0.018426384776830673, 0.029785113409161568, -0.008299686014652252, 0.0008241088944487274, -0.028294656425714493, -0.01843840442597866, -0.034376684576272964, 0.012368394993245602, -0.011923661455512047, -0.04303095489740372, 0.01959230564534664, 0.01808982901275158, -0.03843938559293747, -0.011695284396409988, -0.014832457527518272, 0.010078619234263897, 0.005946805700659752, -0.02896776609122753, -0.001054739230312407, 0.004660685081034899, -0.0009420533897355199, -0.002193617168813944, -0.005255666095763445, -0.012464553117752075, -0.01822204701602459, -0.017452778294682503, 0.0015745963901281357, 0.0013845330104231834, 0.01652725227177143, -0.008816538378596306, 0.0367085300385952, 0.03932885080575943, -0.022032329812645912, 0.0060279397293925285, 0.0005927273887209594, 0.027669625356793404, 0.023715104907751083, -0.0021710798610001802, -0.036732569336891174, -0.017356619238853455, 0.02132316119968891, -0.00944156851619482, -0.028294656425714493, 0.0026443602982908487, 0.006598880980163813, 0.018318206071853638, -0.01215203758329153, -0.005285715684294701, -0.007326080463826656, 0.000438347808085382, -0.03247755393385887, 0.0009420533897355199, 0.005553156603127718, 0.004489402752369642, 0.023667026311159134, -0.01608251966536045, 0.016034439206123352, -0.001591123640537262, -0.002303298097103834, -0.012548691593110561, 0.02875140868127346, 0.00904491450637579, -0.014616101048886776, -0.010992125608026981, 0.006148138083517551, 0.0005442724796012044, 0.019339891150593758, -0.03154000639915466, -0.0366123728454113, 0.014940636232495308, -0.016611391678452492, 0.016599372029304504, 0.020013000816106796, 0.011346709914505482, 0.032910268753767014, 0.029184123501181602, -0.01990482211112976, -0.0010802813339978456, 0.028198497369885445, -0.006430603563785553, -0.001989280106499791, -0.010138718411326408, -0.03620369732379913, 0.014363684691488743, 0.007644605357199907, -0.04620418697595596, 0.0074102189391851425, -0.004567531403154135, 0.011238531209528446, 0.008095349185168743, -0.03512191399931908, -0.006833267863839865, -0.029087964445352554, 0.06341657042503357, -0.017260462045669556, 0.0021680749487131834, -0.02430407516658306, 0.031131332740187645, 0.016322916373610497, -0.0069053866900503635, 0.016863808035850525, 0.025626255199313164, -0.01604645885527134, 0.021395279094576836, 0.003984570503234863, 0.04346366971731186, 0.010811828076839447, 0.04235784709453583, -0.005285715684294701, -0.0049461559392511845, 0.04017023742198944, 0.017476817592978477, -0.0211909431964159, 0.022921796888113022, 0.008702349849045277, -0.0005953566869720817, 0.046781137585639954, -0.01453196257352829, -0.002935840981081128, 0.03923269361257553, -0.002193617168813944, -0.020589951425790787, 0.019303830340504646, 0.0030274922028183937, 0.03827110677957535, -0.016383014619350433, 0.006995534989982843, -0.0015159997856244445, -0.0012695934856310487, 0.003750183852389455, 0.00819751713424921, 0.01657533086836338, -0.012037849985063076, 0.0352901928126812, -0.019003335386514664, 0.05283913016319275, -0.008473972789943218, 0.029208162799477577, -0.044593531638383865, -0.0011786936083808541, 0.04368002712726593, -0.015409409068524837, -0.021791933104395866, -0.027357110753655434, -0.0074102189391851425, 0.019219692796468735, 0.009621866047382355, 0.026996515691280365, 0.015709904953837395, -0.0010464756051078439, 0.01564980484545231, 0.011208482086658478, -0.015457488596439362, -0.029039885848760605, -0.03742972016334534, -0.013918951153755188, 0.014832457527518272, 0.012728989124298096, -0.0013109116116538644, -0.02132316119968891, -0.0013199264649301767, 0.022416964173316956, -0.006466662976890802, 0.004780883435159922, 0.005685374606400728, -0.013570376671850681, 0.015974340960383415, -0.001494213822297752, -0.007241941522806883, -0.02853505313396454, 0.01484447717666626, -0.016767648980021477, -0.015673846006393433, 0.007722734473645687, -0.006091043818742037, -0.012488593347370625, 0.04327135160565376, -0.03798263147473335, -0.03156404569745064, -0.002919313730672002, -0.021575577557086945, -0.031083254143595695, 0.0062082367949187756, -0.019051413983106613, -0.027405189350247383, -0.03204483911395073, 0.029785113409161568, 0.015301230363547802, 0.01875091902911663, -0.00442028883844614, 0.02275351993739605, 0.0045525068417191505, -0.0139069315046072, -0.03858362138271332, 0.034857477992773056, 0.012945345602929592, 0.013293921016156673, 0.012560712173581123, -0.03372761607170105, -0.03836726397275925, -0.002537684515118599, 0.0074102189391851425, 0.027164792641997337, 0.004831967409700155, 0.0250252652913332, 0.03875190019607544, 0.02430407516658306, -0.0029523682314902544, 0.05827208608388901, 0.03404013067483902, 0.005694389808923006, -0.013546337373554707, -0.019832702353596687, 0.013137662783265114, 0.022693419829010963, 0.023498747497797012, -0.03105921484529972, 0.015613745898008347, -0.025626255199313164, -0.020734189078211784, -0.02697247639298439, -0.010132708586752415, 0.008672299794852734, -0.019207673147320747, -0.019219692796468735, 0.011629175394773483, 0.017657116055488586, 0.0051324632950127125, 0.02013319917023182, 0.00334451487287879, 0.012140017934143543, 0.043704066425561905, 0.011857552453875542, -0.010481283068656921, -0.012332335114479065, -0.03293430805206299, -0.032237157225608826, 0.015577686950564384, 0.01848648302257061, -0.02440023422241211, -0.005183547269552946, 0.013197761960327625, 0.009736054576933384, -0.0023303425405174494, -0.011611145921051502, 0.00235588476061821, 0.022068388760089874, -0.02613108791410923, -0.01848648302257061, -0.050194766372442245, -0.009603836573660374, 0.013486238196492195, -0.0018375299405306578, -0.012656870298087597, -0.0020208321511745453, -0.02244100347161293, -0.01937595009803772, 0.025169502943754196, 0.002591773634776473, -0.023703085258603096, -0.018594661727547646, -0.004236986394971609, 0.0034737279638648033, 0.0023048005532473326, -0.053175684064626694, 0.0045525068417191505, -0.003491757670417428, -0.031972721219062805, -0.011773413978517056, 0.020421674475073814, 0.03048226423561573, 0.016635430976748466, 0.024640630930662155, 0.012500612996518612, -0.049569737166166306, 0.018943237140774727, -0.027934061363339424, -0.03466515988111496, -0.06952264159917831, 0.0040687089785933495, -0.009008854627609253, 0.03767011687159538, -0.029232202097773552, 0.028919687494635582, 0.006725089158862829, 0.009904331527650356, 0.04132414236664772, 0.03836726397275925, 0.03567482531070709, -0.024508412927389145, -0.03269391134381294, -0.010475273244082928, -0.014556001871824265, -0.03204483911395073, -0.022032329812645912, 0.010367094539105892, -0.015096893534064293, -0.00540891895070672, 0.03394396975636482, 0.0025361820589751005, -0.005607245955616236, -0.0036900846753269434, 0.020061079412698746, 0.0027014545630663633, -0.020097138360142708, 0.003383579198271036, -0.026155129075050354, -0.004561521578580141, 0.016647450625896454, -0.03307854384183884, 0.035482507199048996, 0.03137173131108284, 0.01827012561261654, 0.03718932345509529, -0.00793308112770319, 0.012765049003064632, 0.023294411599636078, -0.019135553389787674, 0.047526367008686066, 0.008714369498193264, 0.012753029353916645, 0.007848942652344704, 0.006082029081881046, 0.007993180304765701, -0.024953145533800125, -0.00356087158434093, 0.004540487192571163, -0.006310405675321817, 0.04567531496286392, -0.03408820927143097, 0.009922361001372337, 0.005913751199841499, 0.013870872557163239, -0.0013064041268080473, -0.019928861409425735, 0.016503212973475456, 0.04293479770421982, 0.030626501888036728, 0.04211745038628578, -0.0018976291175931692, -0.002778080990538001, -0.03639601543545723, -0.03293430805206299, -0.010144728235900402, 0.013017465360462666, -0.0036029410548508167, -0.017032084986567497, -0.0017368639819324017, -0.02004905976355076, 0.03858362138271332, -0.033174704760313034, -0.05043516308069229, 0.012945345602929592, 0.007566476706415415, -0.004702754318714142, -0.01088995672762394, 0.01794559136033058, 0.0072239115834236145, 0.019087474793195724, -0.05048324540257454, -0.04675709828734398, 0.02000098116695881, 0.009345410391688347, 0.01772923395037651, -0.024905066937208176, -0.014135308563709259, -0.01662341132760048, 0.011581096798181534, -0.014255505986511707, -0.007608545944094658, -0.005856657400727272, -0.01424348633736372, 0.004489402752369642, 0.055531568825244904, -0.011641195975244045, 0.04300691559910774, 0.012837167829275131, -0.009862261824309826, -0.0061902073211967945, 0.03418436646461487, 0.008299686014652252, -0.0021395280491560698, 0.023979540914297104, 0.029785113409161568, 0.0072058821097016335, -0.010895966552197933, -0.019976940006017685, -0.02417185716331005, 0.01870284043252468, -0.00006718891381751746, -0.014039149507880211, 0.020517833530902863, 0.0003547724918462336, 0.030722659081220627, 0.005360839888453484, -0.0006982763879932463, -0.003197272075340152, 0.0307947788387537, -0.036636412143707275, 0.004958175588399172, 0.02608300931751728, 0.020854387432336807, -0.004708764608949423, 0.02315017394721508, -0.011527007445693016, -0.009724033996462822, 0.03214100003242493, 0.02346268855035305, 0.042550161480903625, -0.008047269657254219, 0.05216601863503456, -0.006394544150680304, 0.015156992711126804, -0.01564980484545231, 0.026996515691280365, 0.006006904877722263, 0.025530098006129265, 0.04182897508144379, 0.020553892478346825, 0.02138325944542885, 0.011983760632574558, 0.020770248025655746, 0.02048177272081375, 0.0021575577557086945, -0.012055879458785057, 0.014411764219403267, -0.003581906436011195, -0.02191213145852089, 0.008636240847408772, 0.02311411313712597, 0.027741745114326477, -0.015493547543883324, -0.029496638104319572, -0.0066950395703315735, 0.0036930895876139402, 0.0059167565777897835, -0.02071014977991581, -0.011346709914505482, 0.0029418510384857655, 0.00826963596045971, 0.03329490125179291, -0.006030944641679525, -0.024784868583083153, 0.025890691205859184, -0.030770739540457726, 0.0175970159471035, -0.03279006853699684, -0.0038343225605785847, 0.028102338314056396, -0.00008127464388962835, -0.023342490196228027, 0.030097629874944687, -0.015493547543883324, -0.007512387353926897, -0.007963130250573158, -0.004747828934341669, 0.03262178972363472, -0.011845532804727554, 0.02176789380609989, 0.022825637832283974, 0.006418583914637566, 0.005300740711390972, 0.00221014441922307, -0.0035127922892570496, 0.00869033019989729, -0.008281655609607697, -0.0055231074802577496, -0.015325270593166351, -0.034544963389635086, 0.039088454097509384, 0.032501593232154846, -0.01795761100947857, -0.036420054733753204, 0.027765784412622452, -0.005571186542510986, -0.017116224393248558, -0.002085438696667552, 0.006340454798191786, -0.0006002397858537734, -0.04012215882539749, 0.0033595396671444178, 0.006779178511351347 ]
12.057079
7.206712
2024-07-01
0
2024ApJS..273....2Y
[ "molecular gas fraction", "molecular gas", "merger stages", "galaxy pairs", "total gas fraction", "atomic gas", "paired galaxies", "total gas", "isolated galaxies", "gas" ]
[ "Galaxy pairs", "Galaxy mergers", "Molecular gas", "Star formation", "610", "608", "1073", "1569", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
19
[ "10.3847/1538-4365/ad4547", "10.48550/arXiv.2404.18999" ]
[ "Yu, Qingzheng", "Fang, Taotao", "Xu, Cong Kevin", "Feng, Shuai", "Feng, Siyi", "Gao, Yu", "Jiang, Xue-Jian", "Lisenfeld, Ute" ]
[ "Department of Astronomy, Xiamen University, Xiamen 361005, People's Republic of China", "Department of Astronomy, Xiamen University, Xiamen 361005, People's Republic of China", "Chinese Academy of Sciences South America Center for Astronomy, National Astronomical Observatories, CAS, Beijing 100101, People's Republic of China; National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, 20A Datun Road, Chaoyang District, Beijing 100101, People's Republic of China", "College of Physics, Hebei Normal University, 20 South Erhuan Road, Shijiazhuang, 050024, People's Republic of China; Hebei Key Laboratory of Photophysics Research and Application, Shijiazhuang 050024, People's Republic of China", "Department of Astronomy, Xiamen University, Xiamen 361005, People's Republic of China", "Department of Astronomy, Xiamen University, Xiamen 361005, People's Republic of China", "Research Center for Astronomical Computing, Zhejiang Laboratory, Hangzhou 311100, People's Republic of China", "Dept. Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Campus de Fuentenueva, Edificio Mecenas, Universidad de Granada, E-18071 Granada, Spain; Instituto Carlos I de Fśica Tórica y Computacional, Facultad de Ciencias, Granada E-18071, Spain" ]
null
[ "1972ApJ...178..623T", "1977egsp.conf..401T", "1984ApJ...279L...5K", "1985ApJ...293..192F", "1987AJ.....93.1011K", "1988ApJ...334..613S", "1989ApJ...340L..53M", "1991ApJ...370L..65B", "1991ApJ...374..407X", "1992ARA&A..30..705B", "1993A&A...269....7B", "1993AJ....106.1771K", "1993ApJ...411..170E", "1993PASJ...45...43S", "1994A&A...281..725C", "1996AJ....111..655H", "1996ARA&A..34..749S", "1996ApJ...464..641M", "1996ApJ...471..115B", "1997ApJ...478..144S", "1997ApJ...484..702S", "1999ApJ...512L..99G", "2000ApJ...530..660B", "2001ApJ...561..218R", "2001PASJ...53..757N", "2002ApJS..143..315V", "2004A&A...422..941C", "2004ApJ...616..199I", "2004MNRAS.355..874N", "2006AJ....131.2004K", "2007A&A...468...61D", "2007AJ....134...71S", "2008AJ....135.1877E", "2008AJ....136.2782L", "2008ApJS..178..189W", "2008MNRAS.384..386C", "2008MNRAS.385.1903L", "2009AJ....137.4670L", "2009ApJ...691.1168H", "2009ApJ...695.1537I", "2010ApJ...713..330X", "2010ApJ...723.1255R", "2011A&A...534A.102L", "2011AJ....141..100H", "2011MNRAS.418.2043E", "2012A&A...538A...8S", "2012ApJ...746..108T", "2012MNRAS.421..872C", "2012MNRAS.426..549S", "2012msma.book.....F", "2013A&A...558A..33A", "2013ARA&A..51..207B", "2013MNRAS.430.1901H", "2013MNRAS.430.3128E", "2013MNRAS.433L..59P", "2013ascl.soft05010G", "2014A&A...564A..66B", "2014ASPC..485..391C", "2014ApJS..214....1U", "2014MNRAS.441.1297S", "2014MNRAS.442L..33R", "2015A&A...582A..21B", "2015ApJ...798....7B", "2015MNRAS.448.1107M", "2016ApJ...816...99H", "2016MNRAS.462.2418S", "2016PASJ...68...96M", "2017A&A...604A..53C", "2017ApJ...836...66S", "2017ApJ...844...96Y", "2017ApJS..233...22S", "2017PASJ...69...66K", "2018AJ....155...81S", "2018ApJ...861...49H", "2018ApJ...868..132P", "2018ApJS..237....2Z", "2018MNRAS.475.1160H", "2018MNRAS.476.2339B", "2018MNRAS.476.2591V", "2018MNRAS.478.3447E", "2018PASJ...70S..37G", "2019A&A...627A.107L", "2019ApJ...870..104S", "2019ApJ...880..114F", "2019ApJ...881..119P", "2019MNRAS.482L..55T", "2019MNRAS.485.1320M", "2019MNRAS.488.3396M", "2020ApJ...892L..20F", "2020ApJ...893L...3Z", "2020NatMe..17..261V", "2021ApJ...918...55X", "2021MNRAS.503.1345S", "2022ApJ...934..114Y", "2022ApJS..262....6F", "2022MNRAS.510.3119W", "2022MNRAS.515.3406M", "2022MNRAS.516.1462T", "2023ApJ...943...50H", "2023ApJ...953...91L" ]
29184285
2405.14668
Discovery of a 100 kpc Narrow Curved Twin Jet in the S-shaped Giant Radio Galaxy J0644+1043
We report the discovery of an S-shaped morphology of the radio galaxy J0644+1043 imaged with a 30 μJy beam<SUP>‑1</SUP> sensitive 525 MHz broadband (bands 3 + 4) uGMRT map. Dedicated spectroscopic observations of the host galaxy carried out with the 2 m Rozhen telescope yielded a redshift of 0.0488, giving a projected linear size of the peculiar radio structure of over 0.7 Mpc. This giant radio galaxy is powered by a black hole of mass M <SUB>⊙</SUB>, from the vicinity of which emanate well-collimated and knotty jets, each ∼100 kpc long. The entire radio structure, presumably due to the effective jet precession, is less than 50 Myr old, has a power of ∼6 × 10<SUP>24</SUP> W Hz<SUP>‑1</SUP> at 1.4 GHz, and has observed morphological characteristics that do not strictly conform to the traditional Fanaroff–Riley (FR) FR I or FR II categories.
[ -0.016321375966072083, 0.023307735100388527, 0.009120417758822441, -0.01709631271660328, -0.05446022003889084, 0.02994835376739502, -0.020255673676729202, -0.001691450015641749, -0.019743023440241814, -0.042824238538742065, -0.02723011001944542, -0.009907277300953865, -0.05283881351351738, -0.011570412665605545, 0.02389191836118698, 0.011308126151561737, -0.04554247856140137, -0.014890721999108791, 0.008631611242890358, 0.022449342533946037, 0.00839316938072443, -0.0386991873383522, -0.017775872722268105, -0.0019641683902591467, -0.05355414003133774, -0.02182939276099205, -0.03583787754178047, 0.008101076819002628, 0.015534515492618084, -0.006741955876350403, 0.007904361933469772, -0.016452519223093987, -0.03555174544453621, -0.028255412355065346, -0.07997354865074158, 0.03474104404449463, -0.011445230804383755, -0.011761166155338287, -0.010014576837420464, 0.017668575048446655, 0.0038001742213964462, 0.01438999269157648, -0.04330112040042877, -0.016202153638005257, 0.02913764864206314, -0.038794562220573425, -0.03643398359417915, 0.03247584030032158, 0.01343622338026762, -0.016524052247405052, -0.03388265147805214, 0.03841305524110794, -0.02873229794204235, -0.0011676221620291471, 0.0056421407498419285, -0.014282694086432457, 0.026037899777293205, 0.012720896862447262, -0.028517698869109154, 0.006783683318644762, 0.0013546503614634275, -0.023260045796632767, 0.03610016405582428, -0.015081475488841534, -0.006169694475829601, -0.005466289818286896, -0.009436354041099548, 0.014533057808876038, 0.04487483948469162, 0.042275819927453995, 0.001150484080426395, -0.038341522216796875, -0.038651496171951294, -0.01815738156437874, 0.05660620331764221, -0.003892570501193404, 0.04299114644527435, 0.011129294522106647, -0.015236463397741318, -0.025036441162228584, 0.010932579636573792, -0.014521135948598385, -0.01567758060991764, -0.027110889554023743, 0.019778788089752197, 0.02017221786081791, 0.011433308012783527, 0.019623801112174988, -0.0484037883579731, 0.004715196322649717, 0.0054901340045034885, -0.0020953116472810507, -0.017573198303580284, -0.01593986712396145, -0.016154466196894646, -0.04678237810730934, 0.030592147260904312, -0.02954300120472908, 0.06237650662660599, 0.01567758060991764, 0.017382442951202393, 0.058561429381370544, 0.009782095439732075, -0.0606120340526104, 0.05116971954703331, -0.022270511835813522, 0.039652954787015915, 0.01033647358417511, 0.008840247988700867, -0.027206266298890114, 0.02591867744922638, 0.011439269408583641, 0.011051801033318043, 0.029423780739307404, -0.06390253454446793, -0.010145720094442368, -0.029376091435551643, -0.00021217639732640237, -0.00625314936041832, 0.04623396322131157, 0.023713087663054466, 0.031736671924591064, 0.009877472184598446, -0.02243741974234581, 0.058513741940259933, -0.030115263536572456, 0.016166387125849724, -0.020398739725351334, -0.051598913967609406, 0.014401914551854134, 0.014831110835075378, -0.03457413241267204, -0.0008606276824139059, -0.0291853379458189, -0.03862765431404114, -0.018717721104621887, 0.010396084748208523, -0.038341522216796875, 0.004628761205822229, 0.011391581036150455, -0.010753748007118702, 0.011111411266028881, 0.04036828130483627, 0.005975960288196802, 0.04997750744223595, 0.06881444901227951, -0.03962910920381546, 0.02399921789765358, -0.010717981494963169, -0.0232958123087883, 0.0036988360807299614, -0.016464440152049065, -0.004452909808605909, -0.023105058819055557, 0.007659959141165018, -0.033811118453741074, 0.017382442951202393, 0.001962678274139762, -0.023426955565810204, -0.015570282004773617, -0.03090212307870388, -0.02823156863451004, -0.036124009639024734, 0.007773219142109156, -0.004548287019133568, 0.02309313602745533, -0.008178571239113808, 0.01250629872083664, -0.07119887322187424, -0.035575591027736664, -0.0008516861125826836, -0.010694136843085289, -0.014199239201843739, 0.007642075885087252, -0.020863700658082962, 0.050597455352544785, 0.025417950004339218, -0.04423104599118233, -0.0179904717952013, 0.001710823504254222, -0.003168302122503519, 0.008232220076024532, 0.03307194635272026, 0.013925030827522278, -0.02551332674920559, 0.020386816933751106, 0.021161753684282303, 0.02868460863828659, 0.031188253313302994, -0.009138301014900208, -0.026610160246491432, 0.012017492204904556, -0.0065512023866176605, 0.0484037883579731, -0.005692809820175171, -0.020804090425372124, 0.002372500952333212, 0.002250299323350191, -0.021841315552592278, 0.0355040580034256, 0.026920136064291, 0.004181681666523218, 0.000474276632303372, -0.06271032243967056, -0.06519012153148651, -0.06638233363628387, 0.02279508486390114, -0.016619428992271423, -0.02808850258588791, -0.011987687088549137, 0.04570939019322395, -0.0030505710747092962, 0.02949531190097332, 0.02506028674542904, 0.00968075729906559, -0.013686588034033775, 0.00917406752705574, 0.034264158457517624, 0.005031132604926825, -0.017573198303580284, 0.006628695875406265, 0.04342034459114075, 0.03683933615684509, -0.008589884266257286, 0.02178170345723629, 0.0199099313467741, 0.04332496598362923, -0.03574250265955925, 0.020601414144039154, -0.011081606149673462, 0.01905154064297676, 0.011272359639406204, 0.003457413287833333, -0.04079747945070267, -0.00525467237457633, 0.019146917387843132, 0.004688371904194355, 0.03502717241644859, -0.007242684718221426, -0.03035370446741581, -0.02339118905365467, 0.01628560945391655, 0.006083259359002113, 0.010348395444452763, -0.015582204796373844, 0.007922245189547539, -0.019027695059776306, 0.011457152664661407, 0.05355414003133774, 0.014759578742086887, 0.05832298845052719, 0.012840118259191513, -0.03266659379005432, 0.004485695622861385, -0.018777331337332726, 0.043682631105184555, -0.03729237616062164, 0.008035505190491676, -0.033048104494810104, -0.019945697858929634, 0.001019340823404491, -0.013650821521878242, -0.043491873890161514, 0.06600082665681839, -0.02026759646832943, 0.049739062786102295, 0.03538483753800392, -0.032499685883522034, -0.006515435874462128, 0.030115263536572456, -0.05465097725391388, -0.03509870544075966, 0.03359651938080788, -0.00917406752705574, -0.019623801112174988, 0.032785817980766296, -0.0025751767680048943, 0.03040139377117157, 0.02172209322452545, -0.0682898759841919, -0.003722680499777198, -0.011624062433838844, 0.029519157484173775, 0.0024008159525692463, -0.024631090462207794, -0.0027048299089074135, 0.013400456868112087, 0.01316201500594616, -0.004590014461427927, -0.011856543831527233, 0.05560474470257759, 0.0031414772383868694, 0.015808723866939545, -0.01667903922498226, -0.05531861260533333, -0.03323885798454285, 0.062185753136873245, -0.00043739259126596153, -0.026133276522159576, 0.007844751700758934, 0.026037899777293205, 0.023820385336875916, 0.04911911487579346, -0.018944241106510162, -0.03376343101263046, 0.06056434288620949, 0.07315409928560257, 0.0038359405007213354, 0.0016601545503363013, 0.029066115617752075, 0.0011244044872000813, -0.016261765733361244, 0.016369063407182693, 0.023331578820943832, -0.0445648655295372, -0.016392908990383148, -0.022270511835813522, 0.04442179948091507, 0.04306267946958542, -0.001576699665747583, 0.005102665163576603, -0.006378331687301397, -0.0026094529312103987, 0.0012950397795066237, -0.013090481981635094, -0.022175133228302002, -0.018240835517644882, -0.05965826287865639, 0.014127706177532673, -0.014163472689688206, 0.05732152983546257, 0.005892505403608084, 0.045661699026823044, 0.0005815756740048528, -0.02475031092762947, -0.054269466549158096, -0.03316732496023178, 0.0814518928527832, -0.015582204796373844, -0.01248245406895876, -0.05031132698059082, 0.02168632671236992, -0.011785010807216167, 0.011779049411416054, -0.02016029693186283, 0.052409619092941284, 0.03140285238623619, 0.029161494225263596, -0.016297530382871628, -0.004771826323121786, 0.023486565798521042, 0.0151530085131526, 0.01065837126225233, 0.015808723866939545, 0.06461786478757858, -0.03457413241267204, 0.04537557065486908, -0.017573198303580284, -0.033858805894851685, 0.013519678264856339, -0.03135516121983528, -0.01905154064297676, 0.051455847918987274, 0.02056564763188362, -0.023486565798521042, 0.02168632671236992, -0.005931252148002386, 0.05131278187036514, -0.07558620721101761, -0.03242815285921097, -0.0074036335572600365, 0.04618627205491066, 0.00866737775504589, 0.004503578878939152, -0.06189962103962898, -0.012673208490014076, 0.050597455352544785, 0.006110083777457476, -0.022926228120923042, 0.015761036425828934, 0.060182835906744, -0.027587775141000748, -0.03850843012332916, -0.036887023597955704, -0.05360182747244835, -0.01560604851692915, -0.013626977801322937, 0.004262156318873167, -0.06323489546775818, -0.0008606276824139059, -0.04685391113162041, -0.007898401468992233, 0.06523781269788742, -0.010270901955664158, -0.01789509505033493, -0.018884630873799324, 0.05016826093196869, 0.05913368985056877, -0.014056174084544182, 0.07382173836231232, -0.00443502701818943, -0.04656778275966644, -0.015999479219317436, -0.02203206904232502, -0.02868460863828659, -0.0057077123783528805, 0.013209703378379345, 0.048976048827171326, -0.007051931228488684, 0.003859784686937928, 0.023808464407920837, -0.047116197645664215, 0.024917220696806908, -0.0019447950180619955, -0.00041392093407921493, 0.04167971387505531, -0.062138061970472336, 0.002759969560429454, -0.04747386276721954, 0.04647240415215492, -0.0019611879251897335, -0.003493179799988866, -0.016667116433382034, 0.04959600046277046, 0.0006993065471760929, -0.005791167262941599, 0.034717198461294174, 0.03633860498666763, -0.0018509083893150091, -0.003260698402300477, 0.006890982389450073, 0.0012913141399621964, -0.023808464407920837, -0.00574943982064724, -0.011790972203016281, 0.06361640244722366, 0.026395563036203384, -0.028016969561576843, -0.03745928406715393, -0.0012421354185789824, 0.0010759709402918816, 0.011767127551138401, 0.0011758186155930161, 0.014199239201843739, 0.03850843012332916, -0.010056303814053535, 0.06752686202526093, 0.050549767911434174, 0.03772157058119774, -0.0710558071732521, -0.009418470785021782, -0.02899458445608616, 0.005192080978304148, 0.010598760098218918, -0.0373162217438221, 0.018073925748467445, 0.00038337052683345973, -0.03767388314008713, -0.0012942946050316095, -0.06175655499100685, -0.0019149897852912545, -0.0019582074601203203, -0.05636775866150856, 0.017382442951202393, -0.032189711928367615, 0.01794278249144554, -0.0009090612875297666, -0.006282954476773739, -0.02434495836496353, 0.028851518407464027, 0.019790710881352425, -0.07310640811920166, 0.019123071804642677, 0.0199099313467741, 0.00012909415818285197, 0.012697052210569382, -0.0669545978307724, -0.04263348504900932, 0.0583706758916378, 0.04437411203980446, 0.031474385410547256, 0.010205330327153206, 0.027754683047533035, -0.02021990716457367, -0.0027286740951240063, 0.03071136772632599, 0.010390123352408409, 0.01981455460190773, 0.009644990786910057, -0.003224932122975588, -0.02390384115278721, -0.0002885524299927056, 0.04482715204358101, -0.010849124751985073, -0.000538357999175787, -0.01096238475292921, -0.0303060170263052, -0.03080674447119236, 0.022175133228302002, 0.009877472184598446, 0.05450791120529175, 0.004813553765416145, 0.04461255297064781, 0.0018628304824233055, -0.0017778853652998805, 0.018836941570043564, -0.055223237723112106, -0.010884891264140606, -0.019552268087863922, -0.00020323479839134961, 0.03376343101263046, 0.060278214514255524, -0.011117372661828995, 0.0026064724661409855, 0.0167386494576931, 0.0011855053016915917, -0.028899207711219788, 0.031688980758190155, 0.0025572937447577715, 0.011659828945994377, 0.00875083263963461, -0.019802633672952652, -0.022759318351745605, -0.0036124009639024734, 0.0166313499212265, 0.008893897756934166, 0.002637767931446433, -0.0769214853644371, -0.017823562026023865, -0.008709104731678963, -0.021662482991814613, -0.0232958123087883, -0.016261765733361244, 0.019373437389731407, -0.027802372351288795, -0.038198456168174744, -0.019945697858929634, -0.013543522916734219, -0.00296264560893178, 0.0336918979883194, -0.012387077324092388, -0.0024201893247663975, -0.03397802636027336, -0.021805549040436745, 0.02999604120850563, 0.025441793724894524, -0.036982402205467224, -0.02259240858256817, 0.03729237616062164, 0.036124009639024734, 0.04301499202847481, -0.018383901566267014, -0.00034853557008318603, 0.004956619348376989, -0.019850321114063263, 0.0017570217605680227, -0.005236789118498564, -0.016404829919338226, 0.015761036425828934, -0.01393695268779993, -0.02904227189719677, -0.009710562415421009, 0.006861177273094654, 0.0409405417740345, -0.010413967072963715, -0.05899062380194664, 0.004667507950216532, -0.0039015121292322874, -0.008101076819002628, 0.010807396844029427, -0.008595844730734825, -0.025370260700583458, 0.0007525834953412414, 0.0029313501436263323, 0.02601405419409275, -0.0038687263149768114, -0.036481671035289764, 0.02253279834985733, 0.027850061655044556, -0.016571739688515663, -0.01870579831302166, -0.022711629047989845, 0.009418470785021782, 0.015844490379095078, -0.022902382537722588, -0.018216991797089577, -0.036982402205467224, -0.00031612234306521714, 0.019278060644865036, 0.025131817907094955, -0.01474765595048666, -0.006831372156739235, 0.003716719336807728, 0.00009612205030862242, -0.034955643117427826, -0.030162950977683067, 0.012887806631624699, 0.0008218808216042817, -0.0015722289681434631, -0.02460724487900734, -0.00009449207573197782, 0.005230828188359737, -0.046710845082998276, -0.018681954592466354, 0.0006024393951520324, 0.004238312132656574, 0.012232090346515179, -0.0063544875010848045, -0.02877998538315296, 0.009114457294344902, -0.01260167546570301, -0.003970064222812653, -0.027468552812933922, -0.0016020342009142041, -0.007451321929693222, 0.014032329432666302, 0.026920136064291, -0.03765003755688667, -0.007361906114965677, 0.023260045796632767, 0.0004165288992226124, -0.0004955129115842283, 0.04063056781888008, 0.011159099638462067, 0.030234484001994133, 0.03502717241644859, -0.009156184270977974, -0.010449733585119247, 0.041918154805898666, -0.020279517397284508, 0.038842249661684036, -0.027540085837244987, 0.026490939781069756, 0.03323885798454285, -0.00312061351723969, 0.002539410488680005, 0.0038031546864658594, 0.00864353310316801, -0.011588295921683311, -0.017763951793313026, 0.04280039295554161, 0.03574250265955925, 0.03447875753045082, -0.04058288037776947, 0.01232746709138155, -0.005320244003087282, -0.005815011449158192, -0.02632403001189232, -0.015474905259907246, -0.01146907452493906, -0.0016839987365528941, -0.008989274501800537, -0.019027695059776306, 0.019540347158908844, 0.02167440578341484, 0.03207048773765564, 0.02863692119717598, 0.028827674686908722, -0.018741564825177193, 0.023570021614432335, 0.007224801927804947, 0.014378070831298828, -0.022652018815279007, -0.01719168946146965, 0.005397737491875887, 0.0021146852523088455, -0.009060807526111603, -0.009263483807444572, -0.012267856858670712, 0.037530817091464996, 0.09900124371051788, -0.0382223017513752, 0.025847146287560463, -0.004044577479362488, 0.010872968472540379, -0.05488941818475723, 0.008738910779356956, -0.00816664844751358, -0.02278316207230091, -0.0003938023583032191, -0.009239639155566692, -0.028827674686908722, -0.011737322434782982, -0.006509474944323301, -0.010747786611318588, -0.015868335962295532, 0.006259110290557146, 0.011814815923571587, 0.0017495703650638461, 0.017477821558713913, -0.017012858763337135, 0.015188775025308132, 0.0022458285093307495, -0.007022125646471977, -0.0015252855373546481, -0.033548831939697266, 0.002965626074001193, -0.007677841931581497, -0.006664462387561798, -0.023450801149010658, 0.028708452358841896, 0.03135516121983528, 0.030234484001994133, -0.019528424367308617, -0.00625314936041832, -0.006741955876350403, -0.018312368541955948, -0.018884630873799324, -0.006849254947155714, -0.012661286629736423, 0.03352498635649681, 0.02385615184903145, 0.0008501958218403161, -0.01427077129483223, 0.020184140652418137, 0.003293484216555953, -0.008786599151790142, 0.00110950181260705, -0.013770042918622494, -0.01703670248389244, 0.003490199102088809, -0.016047166660428047, -0.01759704202413559, -0.018324291333556175, 0.013293158262968063, -0.04063056781888008, 0.01194595918059349, -0.00929924938827753, -0.029256870970129967, -0.026133276522159576, 0.01719168946146965, 0.011099489405751228, 0.027444709092378616, -0.012047297321259975, -0.002238376997411251, 0.05798916891217232, -0.00970460195094347, -0.0059491354040801525, -0.008709104731678963, 0.018324291333556175, 0.023629631847143173, -0.00656908517703414, -0.006926748901605606, 0.010676253587007523, 0.013710432685911655, 0.005436484236270189, 0.03831767663359642, -0.04518481716513634, -0.018109692260622978, 0.02168632671236992, 0.006083259359002113, 0.008732949383556843, 0.029423780739307404, -0.04482715204358101, 0.044588711112737656, -0.016524052247405052, 0.0303060170263052, 0.02610943280160427, -0.004417143762111664, 0.017072468996047974, 0.02610943280160427, 0.01709631271660328, 0.01134389266371727, 0.015892179682850838, 0.0018345154821872711, 0.012208245694637299, -0.03590941056609154, -0.01164790615439415, -0.00476586539298296, -0.02343887835741043, -0.0077314916998147964, 0.014449603855609894, 0.028422322124242783, -0.009567497298121452, 0.029352247714996338, -0.040463659912347794, -0.012446688488125801, -0.02198437973856926, -0.043897226452827454, -0.024821843951940536, 0.02591867744922638, -0.029781443998217583, 0.0022696726955473423, -0.004405221436172724, -0.012434765696525574, 0.04785536974668503, -0.002627336187288165, 0.016357142478227615, -0.021519416943192482, -0.01602332293987274, 0.005502056330442429, -0.028756141662597656, 0.010783553123474121, -0.012637441977858543, 0.017430132254958153, 0.035265617072582245, 0.0029522136319428682, -0.11483380943536758, 0.0047777877189219, 0.03943835571408272, 0.011403502896428108, -0.0050192102789878845, 0.04311036691069603, 0.017275145277380943, 0.022926228120923042, -0.003162340959534049, 0.00985362846404314, -0.001284607918933034, -0.03536099195480347, -0.0052934191189706326, 0.04859454184770584, 0.02470262162387371, -0.0014366148971021175, -0.013710432685911655, 0.017418209463357925, 0.009484042413532734, 0.004563189577311277, 0.00864353310316801, 0.014854955486953259, 0.018920397385954857, 0.004351572133600712, -0.0088223647326231, 0.0028300120029598475, -0.032094333320856094, -0.009215794503688812, 0.0472831092774868, -0.019599957391619682, 0.016726726666092873, 0.012816273607313633, 0.003487218637019396, 0.08746063709259033, -0.018276602029800415, -0.018729642033576965, -0.01593986712396145, 0.0232958123087883, -0.0008233710541389883, -0.003293484216555953, -0.016273686662316322, -0.03896147385239601, -0.0007458773325197399, 0.01459266897290945, 0.032595060765743256, -0.005731557030230761, -0.00772553076967597, -0.0014559882692992687, 0.041107453405857086, -0.020184140652418137, 0.04089285433292389, -0.001612466061487794, -0.00704596983268857, 0.01316201500594616, -0.007111541461199522, 0.005975960288196802, 0.041512805968523026, -0.019242294132709503, -0.019778788089752197, -0.03474104404449463, -0.0095019256696105, 0.018515044823288918, 0.02813619188964367, -0.030186794698238373, -0.020839856937527657, 0.00011605433974182233, -0.03094981051981449, -0.0009053355897776783, 0.008333558216691017, -0.043730318546295166, 0.0386991873383522, -0.004029674921184778, -0.011731361038982868, 0.028422322124242783, -0.0030088438652455807, -0.015558360144495964, -0.054126400500535965, 0.001309197279624641, -0.02596636675298214, 0.010717981494963169, -0.006384292617440224, -0.012971261516213417, 0.014831110835075378, -0.02076832391321659, -0.007034047972410917, 0.04125051945447922, 0.009579419158399105, 0.011200827546417713, 0.0004429810796864331, 0.005657043773680925, -0.009060807526111603, 0.0020029153674840927, 0.032857347279787064, 0.013030871748924255, -0.00907869078218937, 0.02610943280160427, -0.027397019788622856, -0.009114457294344902, -0.017203612253069878, -0.0036064398009330034, -0.011725400574505329, -0.007820907048881054, -0.01734667830169201, -0.0364101380109787, 0.02148365043103695, -0.03452644497156143, -0.00038523334660567343, 0.033000413328409195, 0.02072063647210598, 0.003683933522552252, 0.020231829956173897, 0.003850843058899045, 0.00362432305701077, -0.01230362243950367, 0.02873229794204235, -0.011236593127250671, -0.03564712405204773, -0.013340846635401249, -0.02323620207607746, -0.0057404981926083565, -0.005561666563153267, 0.032547373324632645, -0.033906497061252594, -0.02182939276099205, -0.0016005439683794975, -0.01774010807275772, 0.01653597317636013, 0.007946089841425419, -0.011898270808160305, 0.03872302919626236, 0.017716262489557266, 0.017525508999824524, -0.006300837732851505, -0.01931382715702057, -0.0026824758388102055, -0.017275145277380943, -0.006992320530116558, 0.031784359365701675, -0.010562993586063385, -0.018515044823288918, 0.0167386494576931, -0.010819319635629654, 0.02123328670859337, 0.02056564763188362, -0.03328654542565346, -0.010425889864563942, -0.021185599267482758, 0.007934167981147766, 0.035861723124980927, 0.015951789915561676, -0.004980463534593582, -0.003227912588045001, -0.00940654892474413, -0.009251561015844345, 0.03595709800720215, -0.00043962799827568233, -0.00542158167809248, 0.02849385514855385, -0.018371978774666786, 0.0355040580034256, 0.013853497803211212, 0.01992185413837433, 0.004452909808605909, -0.007361906114965677, 0.025179507210850716, 0.024213815107941628, -0.031784359365701675, 0.0015647775726392865, -0.015510671772062778, 0.02858923189342022, -0.0193495936691761, -0.006724073085933924, 0.05641544982790947, -0.01562989316880703, -0.0127805070951581, -0.010503383353352547, -0.023081215098500252, -0.004703274462372065, -0.0025110954884439707, 0.023713087663054466, 0.004312824923545122, -0.0032219516579061747, 0.010777591727674007, 0.002064016181975603, 0.004676449578255415, 0.04280039295554161, -0.04694928973913193, -0.03836536779999733, 0.014163472689688206, 0.019826477393507957, -0.02248510904610157, 0.02218705601990223, 0.002818089909851551, 0.023975374177098274, 0.04175124689936638, 0.0037435442209243774, -0.03881840780377388, 0.036124009639024734, -0.0359809435904026, 0.004706254694610834, -0.018693875521421432, 0.0034782770089805126, 0.00592529121786356, -0.021304819732904434, -0.010169563814997673, 0.007165191229432821, 0.03075905703008175, 0.008953507989645004, -0.06619158387184143, -0.032642751932144165, 0.029352247714996338, -0.017310911789536476, 0.014485369436442852, -0.0036064398009330034, 0.044445645064115524, 0.0010536168701946735, 0.04337265342473984, -0.0167386494576931, -0.0030788863077759743, -0.0073380619287490845, 0.02768315188586712, -0.04783152416348457, -0.022914305329322815, 0.08025968074798584, 0.011409464292228222, 0.03004373051226139, 0.0015364625724032521, -0.013698509894311428, 0.003892570501193404, 0.009728445671498775, 0.031116720288991928, -0.026705536991357803, -0.04108360782265663, -0.027945438399910927, -0.045900143682956696, -0.03984370827674866, -0.00019727375183720142, -0.0012428804766386747, -0.005075840279459953, 0.003165321657434106, -0.01623792015016079, -0.0018717721104621887, 0.019647644832730293, 0.010974306613206863, -0.0015103829791769385, -0.015617970377206802, 0.03176051378250122, -0.011939997784793377, -0.011612139642238617, -0.0027629502583295107, -0.004685391206294298, -0.00819049309939146, -0.034264158457517624, -0.012792429886758327, -0.0029760580509901047, 0.022401655092835426, -0.04439795762300491, 0.03238046541810036, 0.010878929868340492, -0.020935233682394028, -0.009865550324320793, -0.03645782917737961, -0.02877998538315296, -0.055032484233379364, 0.026657849550247192, 0.016726726666092873, -0.05355414003133774, -0.016655195504426956, 0.009877472184598446, -0.02168632671236992, 0.013376613147556782, -0.04747386276721954, -0.017072468996047974, -0.030329860746860504, -0.013424301519989967, -0.0036749918945133686, 0.025751767680048943, -0.012542065232992172, -0.013853497803211212, 0.07592003047466278, -0.032189711928367615, -0.0157252699136734, -0.0038687263149768114, 0.0017093332717195153, -0.016702882945537567, 0.02560870349407196, 0.009251561015844345, -0.030544457957148552, 0.023426955565810204, -0.02374885231256485, 0.008941586129367352, 0.02212744578719139, 0.02763546258211136, 0.017668575048446655, 0.04270501434803009, -0.03202280029654503, 0.013233548030257225, 0.019898010417819023, -0.0023546176962554455, -0.0255610141903162, -0.02737317606806755, 0.0027733820024877787, 0.0007659958791919053, -0.047926902770996094, -0.00023825601965654641, -0.013829653151333332, -0.0016497226897627115, 0.0014843032695353031, -0.025084130465984344, -0.008452779613435268, 0.0021579028107225895, -0.013925030827522278, -0.017310911789536476, -0.0033471337519586086, 0.027611618861556053, -0.0004265881725586951, -0.016547895967960358, 0.015653736889362335, 0.004867203533649445, -0.04053519293665886, -0.0074036335572600365, -0.025084130465984344, 0.01683402620255947, -0.012589753605425358, -0.017632808536291122, -0.020136453211307526, -0.011373697780072689, 0.01262552011758089, -0.005964037962257862, 0.004816534463316202, -0.002858327003195882, -0.0035676928237080574, -0.0028285218868404627, -0.009537692181766033, -0.02320043556392193, 0.02627634070813656, 0.013448146171867847, 0.013579289428889751, 0.007278451230376959, -0.0010416947770863771, -0.006217382848262787, -0.0015617971075698733, -0.011391581036150455, -0.0020625258330255747, -0.009668835438787937, 0.009370782412588596, 0.001959697576239705, -0.04649624973535538, -0.012375155463814735, -0.013007027097046375, 0.05364951863884926, -0.002201120601966977, 0.00985958892852068, -0.0060922009870409966, 0.029328402131795883, -0.0029522136319428682, -0.012089024297893047, 0.025775613263249397, -0.0027793431654572487, 0.0000177667461684905, 0.0003094161511398852, 0.017620885744690895, 0.015284151770174503, 0.007445360999554396, 0.08035505563020706, 0.0157252699136734, 0.014544980600476265, 0.027397019788622856, -0.00690886564552784, 0.018741564825177193, 0.008804482407867908, 0.000248687865678221, 0.013114326633512974, 0.004563189577311277, -0.021149832755327225, -0.012697052210569382, 0.01800239458680153, -0.010103992186486721, -0.04058288037776947, 0.0020371912978589535, -0.012339388951659203, 0.010580876842141151, 0.01602332293987274, 0.023665398359298706, -0.034955643117427826, -0.0068015665747225285, 0.005868661217391491, -0.0035825956147164106, 0.04642471671104431, 0.01986224390566349, 0.02627634070813656, 0.026347873732447624, -0.015069553628563881, 0.020196063444018364, -0.010670293122529984, 0.02455955743789673, -0.02515566349029541, -0.0055765691213309765, -0.019635723903775215, -0.036267075687646866, -0.0055765691213309765, -0.03180820122361183, 0.004837398417294025, -0.009209834039211273, 0.023224279284477234, 0.007719569373875856, -0.009573458693921566, 0.005385815631598234, 0.00295668444596231, 0.0008166648913174868, -0.029161494225263596, -0.01116506103426218, -0.000920983380638063, 0.011242554523050785, 0.04165586829185486, -0.000789840123616159, -0.003528946079313755, 0.004581072833389044, -0.012708975002169609, -0.011326009407639503, 0.0018181225750595331, 0.010723942890763283, -0.012935495004057884, -0.0018270640866830945, 0.010640488006174564, -0.007028087042272091, -0.02420189417898655, -0.013495834544301033, -0.02349848859012127, 0.015653736889362335, -0.029233025386929512, -0.003014804795384407, 0.0036660502664744854, 0.044541023671627045, -0.033095791935920715, -0.004938736092299223, 0.00875083263963461, 0.006825410760939121, -0.006235266104340553, 0.012971261516213417, 0.0065512023866176605, 0.004160818178206682, 0.006229305174201727, 0.026085587218403816, 0.0035676928237080574, 0.02999604120850563, 0.017465898767113686, -0.0170843917876482, -0.0030416296795010567, 0.004199564922600985, 0.010998151265084743, 0.027253955602645874, 0.01325739175081253, -0.003716719336807728, 0.02318851463496685, 0.020196063444018364, -0.0008583922754041851, -0.019731100648641586, 0.024166127666831017, 0.02813619188964367, 0.009561535902321339, 0.0018956162966787815, -0.011701555922627449, -0.022115522995591164, 0.015212618745863438, 0.01232746709138155, 0.01648828573524952, -0.01698901318013668, -0.014914565719664097, -0.027492396533489227, -0.0034395302645862103, 0.013901186175644398, 0.013567366637289524, -0.05374489352107048, 0.002523017581552267, -0.020243750885128975, 0.01197576429694891, -0.03292888030409813, 0.03378727287054062, -0.0006948357913643122, -0.001030517858453095, -0.0066823456436395645, 0.007546698674559593, 0.0022368868812918663, 0.011862504296004772, -0.008625649847090244, -0.013269313611090183, -0.033906497061252594, 0.036720115691423416, 0.013269313611090183, 0.010479538701474667, -0.016667116433382034, -0.03080674447119236, -0.020792169496417046, 0.03815076872706413, -0.04117898643016815, 0.010914696380496025, 0.011349853128194809, -0.0021877081599086523, -0.012279778718948364, -0.026157120242714882, -0.019230371341109276, -0.01562989316880703, 0.000724268495105207, 0.0014820679789409041, 0.023772697895765305, -0.027945438399910927, 0.03984370827674866, -0.04823687672615051, 0.017430132254958153, -0.019242294132709503, 0.015367606654763222, 0.02596636675298214, 0.003654128173366189, 0.040105994790792465, -0.008387207984924316, 0.01754935272037983, 0.02999604120850563, 0.017608964815735817, -0.003883628873154521, -0.0010655390797182918, -0.01253014337271452, 0.035670969635248184, -0.02106637693941593, -0.02701551280915737, -0.02365347556769848, 0.02026759646832943, 0.0017152943182736635, -0.035313304513692856, 0.049834441393613815, -0.04225197434425354, -0.062233440577983856, 0.008756793104112148, -0.003129555145278573, 0.020243750885128975, 0.018371978774666786, 0.005984901916235685, 0.010175525210797787, 0.006837333086878061, 0.0022786143235862255, -0.009251561015844345, 0.006053453776985407, 0.03943835571408272, 0.01593986712396145, 0.0036809530574828386, 0.03202280029654503, 0.0010811868123710155, -0.016154466196894646, 0.0071294247172772884, -0.013007027097046375, -0.042228132486343384, -0.020458349958062172, 0.00875083263963461, 0.0030788863077759743, 0.0009746329160407186, -0.01840774528682232, 0.006753878202289343, 0.026395563036203384, -0.03288119286298752, 0.014378070831298828, -0.007826868444681168, -0.007856673561036587, -0.04246657341718674, 0.0032875232864171267, 0.022866616025567055, 0.029018428176641464, 0.01613062247633934, 0.008333558216691017, -0.03228508681058884, 0.009245600551366806, 0.042728859931230545, 0.01456882432103157, -0.023355422541499138, 0.0069982814602553844, -0.006431980989873409, 0.011886348947882652, -0.0016571739688515663, 0.006294876802712679, -0.01830044575035572, -0.016476362943649292, 0.005054976791143417, -0.04783152416348457, 0.01598755642771721, -0.01965956762433052, 0.015176852233707905, 0.0011035407660529017, -0.003463374450802803, 0.03533715009689331, -0.011129294522106647, 0.014425759203732014, 0.019647644832730293, 0.026634005829691887, 0.023760775104165077, 0.020351050421595573, 0.025417950004339218, 0.04935755580663681, 0.03896147385239601, 0.018741564825177193, -0.044445645064115524, -0.02496490813791752, -0.009346937760710716, 0.032547373324632645, 0.0012130752438679338, -0.010533188469707966, -0.01524838525801897, -0.008250103332102299, 0.0013889264082536101, -0.03428800404071808, -0.0033471337519586086, 0.031736671924591064, -0.012232090346515179, -0.0072724903002381325, 0.024988753721117973, 0.010956423357129097, 0.001216055708937347, -0.010086108930408955, -0.01598755642771721, -0.000010076748367282562, 0.03276197239756584, 0.021412119269371033, 0.007493049371987581, -0.023713087663054466, -0.013114326633512974, 0.02037489414215088, -0.002175786066800356, 0.008685261011123657, -0.022115522995591164, -0.021435962989926338, 0.014711890369653702, 0.019695334136486053, -0.009346937760710716, -0.003561731893569231, 0.004792690277099609, 0.000675089773721993, -0.029924508184194565, 0.04139358177781105, -0.022318199276924133, 0.030067574232816696, -0.0111948661506176, 0.01061068195849657, 0.03502717241644859, -0.0017823561793193221, 0.0017778853652998805, -0.05722615122795105, 0.01936151459813118, -0.0061458502896130085, -0.009060807526111603, 0.019933776929974556, 0.015820646658539772, -0.015284151770174503, 0.014151550829410553, -0.012935495004057884, -0.047664616256952286, 0.009639030322432518, -0.0014477918157353997, -0.0013837105361744761, -0.007761296816170216, -0.0015916023403406143, 0.02434495836496353, -0.026705536991357803, 0.05207579955458641, 0.008142804726958275, -0.0056093549355864525, 0.033095791935920715, 0.027110889554023743, -0.00006254453182918951, -0.010783553123474121, 0.011445230804383755, -0.0075347768142819405, 0.028899207711219788, 0.014986098743975163, 0.017513586208224297, 0.01996954344213009, 0.025179507210850716, 0.025775613263249397, -0.022294355556368828, 0.009686718694865704, 0.017406288534402847, 0.030782900750637054, -0.0012883335584774613, -0.0004940226208418608, -0.010193408466875553, 0.02320043556392193, 0.0024857609532773495, -0.020291440188884735, 0.043229587376117706, -0.030186794698238373, 0.04342034459114075, -0.03977217525243759, -0.029256870970129967, -0.009454237297177315, -0.02727779932320118, 0.003037158865481615, -0.03714931011199951, -0.016464440152049065, 0.010115914978086948, 0.008774676360189915, -0.007552660070359707, -0.019540347158908844, -0.04764077067375183, 0.015772957354784012, 0.010998151265084743, -0.01343622338026762, 0.002038681646808982, 0.05226655304431915, 0.005475231446325779, -0.006646579131484032, -0.0016333297826349735, -0.008989274501800537, 0.006032590288668871, -0.045041751116514206, -0.006825410760939121, 0.03760235011577606, 0.008738910779356956, 0.013197781518101692, 0.03085443377494812, 0.0020237790886312723, 0.05183735489845276, -0.014866877347230911, -0.047068510204553604, 0.030735213309526443, 0.02959068864583969, -0.006282954476773739, -0.012553987093269825, -0.03850843012332916, -0.033405765891075134, 0.011832699179649353, 0.008625649847090244, 0.035170238465070724, -0.01789509505033493, 0.025727923959493637, 0.030329860746860504, -0.010527228005230427, 0.005141411907970905, 0.019027695059776306, 0.01560604851692915, -0.024118438363075256, 0.007278451230376959, 0.0069446321576833725 ]
15.312737
5.89984
2024-07-01
0
2024ApJ...969..156S
[ "morphological characteristics", "Rozhen telescope", "Dedicated spectroscopic observations", "This giant radio galaxy", "FR", "the peculiar radio structure", "the radio galaxy", "The entire radio structure", "∼6", "SUB>⊙</SUB" ]
[ "Giant radio galaxies", "Active galaxies", "Non-thermal radiation sources", "654", "17", "1119", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
14
[ "10.3847/1538-4357/ad500e", "10.48550/arXiv.2405.14668" ]
[ "Sethi, Sagar", "Kuźmicz, Agnieszka", "Jamrozy, Marek", "Slavcheva-Mihova, Lyuba" ]
[ "Astronomical Observatory, Jagiellonian University, ul. Orla 171, 30-244 Krakow, Poland", "Astronomical Observatory, Jagiellonian University, ul. Orla 171, 30-244 Krakow, Poland; Queen Jadwiga Astronomical Observatory in Rzepiennik Biskupi, 33-163 Rzepiennik Strzyżewski, Poland", "Astronomical Observatory, Jagiellonian University, ul. Orla 171, 30-244 Krakow, Poland", "Institute of Astronomy and NAO, Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, 72 Tsarigradsko Chaussee Blvd., 1784 Sofia, Bulgaria" ]
null
[ "1962SvA.....6..317K", "1970ranp.book.....P", "1973A&A....26..423J", "1974MNRAS.167P..31F", "1976ApJ...203L.107R", "1977A&A....61...99B", "1977MNRAS.179..433B", "1979AJ.....84.1511T", "1979MNRAS.188...25H", "1980ApJ...237..418F", "1980Natur.287..307B", "1982MNRAS.199..883B", "1982MNRAS.200.1067O", "1984AJ.....89..979B", "1984ARA&A..22..319B", "1984ApJ...278...37E", "1984ApJ...285L..35P", "1984ApJS...54..291P", "1986SPIE..627..733T", "1987A&AS...71...75J", "1990A&A...229..424L", "1990Ap&SS.164..131F", "1991ApJS...75.1011G", "1992MNRAS.256..186B", "1993ASPC...52..173T", "1994AJ....108..766B", "1995ARA&A..33..581K", "1996A&AS..117..369L", "1997MNRAS.286..425W", "1997MNRAS.288..859H", "1997MNRAS.291...20L", "1998A&A...329..431M", "1998AJ....115.1693C", "1998MNRAS.296..445H", "1999MNRAS.309..100I", "2000AJ....120.1579Y", "2000ApJ...539L..13G", "2000KFNTS...3...13J", "2001A&A...368..398S", "2002AJ....123.2985L", "2002MNRAS.336..328L", "2003PASA...20...16M", "2004MNRAS.349..560H", "2004MNRAS.351..845G", "2004MNRAS.352..112B", "2005MNRAS.358..363C", "2006MNRAS.372..113M", "2007ASPC..376..127M", "2007ApJ...670L..85B", "2007CSE.....9...90H", "2008MNRAS.390..595M", "2008MNRAS.391..521L", "2009A&A...501.1185I", "2009MNRAS.398.1989M", "2010A&A...523A...9H", "2010AJ....140.1868W", "2011ApJ...737..103S", "2011hea..book.....L", "2012ApJ...758L..27G", "2012ApJS..199...34W", "2012MNRAS.421.1569B", "2012MNRAS.423L..30S", "2012ascl.soft08017R", "2013ARA&A..51..511K", "2014ApJS..210....9B", "2014MNRAS.437..748F", "2014MNRAS.437.3405L", "2014MNRAS.444..606O", "2014ascl.soft08006I", "2015ApJS..219...12A", "2015PASA...32...25W", "2015ascl.soft02007M", "2015aska.confE.107L", "2016A&A...594A..13P", "2016ApJS..224...18P", "2016arXiv161205560C", "2017A&A...598A..78I", "2017ApJ...838L..10B", "2017CSci..113..707G", "2017MNRAS.467.1586I", "2017MNRAS.471..301O", "2018ApJS..238....9K", "2018MNRAS.474.3361T", "2018MNRAS.475.2768H", "2019MNRAS.486.1377D", "2019MNRAS.486.3975K", "2019MNRAS.488.2701M", "2019RAA....19..127L", "2020A&A...635A...5D", "2020A&A...642A.153D", "2020PASA...37...48M", "2020PASP..132c5001L", "2021A&ARv..29....3O", "2021MNRAS.508.2910M", "2021PASA...38...58H", "2022A&A...660A...2O", "2022A&A...668A..64D", "2022ApJ...935..167A", "2022JApA...43...97S", "2022MNRAS.511.3250M", "2023Galax..11...67O", "2023JApA...44...13D" ]
29163227
2309.12048
Cosmology with Multiple Galaxies
Recent works have discovered a relatively tight correlation between Ω<SUB>m</SUB> and the properties of individual simulated galaxies. Because of this, it has been shown that constraints on Ω<SUB>m</SUB> can be placed using the properties of individual galaxies while accounting for uncertainties in astrophysical processes such as feedback from supernovae and active galactic nuclei. In this work, we quantify whether using the properties of multiple galaxies simultaneously can tighten those constraints. For this, we train neural networks to perform likelihood-free inference on the value of two cosmological parameters (Ω<SUB>m</SUB> and σ <SUB>8</SUB>) and four astrophysical parameters using the properties of several galaxies from thousands of hydrodynamic simulations of the CAMELS project. We find that using properties of more than one galaxy increases the precision of the Ω<SUB>m</SUB> inference. Furthermore, using multiple galaxies enables the inference of other parameters that were poorly constrained with one single galaxy. We show that the same subset of galaxy properties are responsible for the constraints on Ω<SUB>m</SUB> from one and multiple galaxies. Finally, we quantify the robustness of the model and find that without identifying the model range of validity, the model does not perform well when tested on galaxies from other galaxy formation models.
[ 0.043795954436063766, 0.037389177829027176, 0.031349197030067444, -0.014977678656578064, -0.010881742462515831, 0.030273251235485077, 0.0013204810675233603, -0.016481559723615646, -0.011976029723882675, 0.03831840306520462, -0.0029160622507333755, 0.0015222212532535195, -0.04039693996310234, 0.006639085244387388, 0.011902669444680214, -0.010759475640952587, -0.027925729751586914, 0.03839176520705223, -0.006614631973206997, 0.01220222283154726, -0.032645225524902344, 0.004548323806375265, 0.0030551408417522907, -0.000001277592218684731, -0.041913047432899475, -0.046241290867328644, -0.016457106918096542, 0.04841763898730278, 0.0595683678984642, -0.0008566314936615527, 0.0011302033672109246, -0.008693167008459568, -0.03797605633735657, 0.020418548956513405, -0.043600328266620636, 0.1087685152888298, 0.0019470981787890196, 0.04555659741163254, -0.03186271712183952, 0.019171427935361862, 0.005673178005963564, -0.028316982090473175, -0.011584775522351265, -0.0019409848609939218, -0.003408186137676239, -0.022876111790537834, -0.014427478425204754, -0.019770536571741104, -0.028439249843358994, 0.008375273086130619, 0.004157070070505142, 0.006706331856548786, -0.004933463875204325, -0.04704825207591057, 0.011016235686838627, -0.010563848540186882, -0.0155401062220335, 0.018719041720032692, -0.019917255267500877, 0.0053797378204762936, -0.04291563481092453, -0.04756177216768265, 0.0550200454890728, 0.011328015476465225, -0.036802295595407486, 0.005746537819504738, 0.00037826280458830297, -0.015552332624793053, 0.011352469213306904, 0.03555517643690109, -0.020553043112158775, -0.012630157172679901, 0.02065085619688034, 0.022558217868208885, 0.024636752903461456, -0.02453893981873989, -0.027852369472384453, 0.03374562785029411, -0.024771247059106827, -0.013840598054230213, 0.054726604372262955, 0.020491909235715866, 0.041717421263456345, -0.008723733946681023, -0.04457846283912659, -0.005153544247150421, 0.015124399214982986, -0.010276521556079388, -0.0971287190914154, 0.007543859537690878, -0.008919360116124153, -0.01714180037379265, -0.027754556387662888, -0.011853762902319431, 0.018156614154577255, -0.021262191236019135, 0.03281639888882637, -0.056927405297756195, 0.02841479703783989, 0.045091982930898666, 0.025064686313271523, 0.04218203201889992, 0.020015070214867592, -0.022301457822322845, 0.033818986266851425, 0.030273251235485077, 0.025529300794005394, -0.022154737263917923, 0.018609002232551575, 0.024062098935246468, 0.028634876012802124, -0.01799766719341278, -0.01754528097808361, 0.03778043016791344, -0.019978389143943787, -0.035946428775787354, -0.05687849968671799, 0.04406494274735451, -0.03653331100940704, -0.01876794919371605, -0.000515430816449225, -0.029099490493535995, 0.016909493133425713, 0.0369001105427742, 0.044896356761455536, -0.008069606497883797, -0.012789103202521801, -0.03995677828788757, -0.020015070214867592, 0.03746253624558449, -0.004609457217156887, 0.026776421815156937, 0.005584534257650375, 0.0016949230339378119, -0.053308308124542236, -0.00264707556925714, -0.006816372275352478, -0.025676021352410316, -0.012355056591331959, 0.017398560419678688, 0.027265489101409912, 0.009934174828231335, 0.018694588914513588, 0.016946174204349518, -0.008949927054345608, -0.012086070142686367, 0.005881031509488821, 0.018156614154577255, -0.00593605125322938, 0.004361866973340511, -0.01200048252940178, -0.005874917842447758, -0.044187210500240326, -0.04743950441479683, 0.006437344942241907, -0.028585970401763916, -0.06103556975722313, 0.01233060285449028, 0.0051138075068593025, -0.04440728947520256, 0.013204810209572315, 0.0465836375951767, -0.026238447055220604, 0.01734965480864048, 0.0009880682919174433, 0.03895419090986252, -0.0362398698925972, 0.02790127508342266, -0.05184110999107361, -0.063383087515831, 0.013926184736192226, 0.04347806051373482, -0.031740453094244, -0.049615852534770966, 0.052427988499403, 0.021665669977664948, -0.027167676016688347, -0.03858739137649536, -0.021017657592892647, -0.006920299027115107, -0.038147229701280594, 0.03533509373664856, -0.0177898146212101, -0.010900082066655159, -0.03489493578672409, 0.015234438702464104, -0.019709402695298195, 0.014867638237774372, 0.04225539416074753, -0.03934544324874878, 0.024844607338309288, 0.018939122557640076, 0.011700929142534733, 0.05580255016684532, 0.0028839672449976206, -0.023658618330955505, 0.0003257263160776347, 0.054139722138643265, -0.026360714808106422, -0.02452671341598034, 0.03866074979305267, 0.0307378638535738, 0.021506723016500473, -0.0945366621017456, 0.0030964058823883533, -0.05237908288836479, 0.0020036466885358095, -0.0123000368475914, -0.03579970821738243, 0.008381386287510395, -0.0053827944211661816, 0.0017636980628594756, -0.01540561206638813, 0.030468877404928207, -0.010362108238041401, -0.047732945531606674, -0.03729136288166046, -0.00567929120734334, 0.016530467197299004, 0.060742128640413284, -0.007812846451997757, 0.016982853412628174, 0.04117944464087486, -0.0013342361198738217, 0.008454746566712856, -0.042157579213380814, 0.027485568076372147, -0.04934686794877052, 0.041203901171684265, -0.04017685726284981, -0.0000524887400388252, -0.005664007738232613, -0.007177059073001146, -0.002926760585978627, 0.02504023350775242, -0.028903862461447716, 0.032009437680244446, 0.013522704131901264, -0.0036435495130717754, -0.04731723666191101, -0.012147203087806702, 0.022301457822322845, -0.0018981915200129151, 0.015051038935780525, -0.030762318521738052, 0.041130539029836655, -0.0006403721636161208, 0.008564786985516548, -0.004196806810796261, -0.022937245666980743, 0.02614063397049904, -0.004964030813425779, -0.019012482836842537, -0.04770849272608757, -0.018670134246349335, -0.027607835829257965, -0.05966618284583092, 0.06181807443499565, -0.026360714808106422, 0.025028007104992867, -0.008265233598649502, -0.00524524413049221, -0.06695327907800674, 0.003295089351013303, -0.04157070070505142, 0.03668002784252167, -0.012189996428787708, 0.008393613621592522, -0.012972503900527954, 0.008723733946681023, -0.0014626161428168416, -0.007409365847706795, -0.0031667090952396393, -0.05883476883172989, -0.03352554515004158, 0.014965452253818512, -0.023536352440714836, 0.05648724362254143, -0.00036145112244412303, -0.020614176988601685, -0.0013472269056364894, 0.0000822435031295754, 0.053748469799757004, 0.013840598054230213, 0.014806505292654037, 0.0037627597339451313, 0.026849782094359398, 0.0005268933600746095, -0.019856123253703117, -0.028463702648878098, 0.055900365114212036, -0.025553753599524498, -0.0005081712151877582, 0.02731439471244812, -0.03521282970905304, -0.010007535107433796, 0.02265603095293045, 0.011603116057813168, -0.006067488342523575, 0.05042281374335289, 0.04318462312221527, 0.02272939123213291, -0.023071737959980965, -0.019183656200766563, -0.05296596139669418, -0.0021870466880500317, 0.03215615823864937, 0.008424179628491402, 0.011468622833490372, 0.03826949745416641, -0.0075927660800516605, 0.016395973041653633, -0.017899854108691216, 0.05008046701550484, -0.049615852534770966, -0.04389376938343048, 0.004936520475894213, -0.0030337441712617874, 0.018425600603222847, -0.011474736034870148, -0.04746395722031593, -0.05262361466884613, -0.03489493578672409, -0.010441581718623638, 0.0060552614741027355, -0.028072448447346687, -0.00585657823830843, -0.017948761582374573, -0.04746395722031593, 0.0010927591938525438, 0.005297207739204168, 0.018071027472615242, 0.06783360242843628, 0.02110324427485466, -0.029368476942181587, -0.04318462312221527, -0.037902697920799255, 0.05580255016684532, 0.019208109006285667, -0.03215615823864937, -0.021641217172145844, 0.007391025777906179, 0.001754528027959168, 0.012666836380958557, 0.038611844182014465, -0.011413602158427238, -0.022179191932082176, 0.05409081652760506, 0.05604708567261696, -0.011089595966041088, 0.029099490493535995, 0.002957327291369438, 0.03215615823864937, -0.029099490493535995, 0.04367368668317795, 0.027974635362625122, 0.012825783342123032, -0.025945007801055908, 0.010955101810395718, 0.012489549815654755, -0.007219852413982153, -0.03765816241502762, 0.034797120839357376, 0.012630157172679901, -0.001870681531727314, 0.005969674792140722, -0.009909721091389656, 0.02497909963130951, -0.05599818006157875, -0.02000284194946289, 0.004526927135884762, 0.029490742832422256, -0.028585970401763916, 0.0013487552059814334, -0.07458272576332092, 0.05144985392689705, -0.028781596571207047, -0.000051485771109582856, 0.006250888574868441, 0.0036252096761018038, 0.03509056195616722, -0.01708066649734974, -0.018865762278437614, -0.028121355921030045, 0.0003807463508564979, 0.01714180037379265, 0.010484375059604645, -0.03269413113594055, -0.0517922006547451, 0.007305439095944166, -0.009011060930788517, 0.004355753306299448, 0.0045850034803152084, 0.014403024688363075, -0.0057771047577261925, -0.001509994501248002, 0.02939292974770069, 0.03340328112244606, 0.0446518212556839, 0.02628735452890396, -0.004728666972368956, -0.03313429281115532, -0.06543717533349991, -0.013253717683255672, -0.02149449661374092, 0.040690381079912186, 0.018939122557640076, 0.030860131606459618, 0.023793112486600876, 0.03760925680398941, 0.022497083991765976, -0.04697488993406296, 0.008167419582605362, -0.007537745870649815, 0.04487190395593643, 0.036215417087078094, -0.03848957642912865, 0.08182092010974884, -0.017692001536488533, 0.04179077968001366, 0.017178479582071304, -0.02924620918929577, 0.04169296845793724, -0.014366344548761845, -0.0012494134716689587, 0.001999061554670334, 0.04873553290963173, -0.008735960349440575, -0.04330688714981079, -0.05448206886649132, -0.03714464232325554, 0.06294292956590652, 0.004704213701188564, -0.02395205944776535, -0.012153316289186478, -0.031936079263687134, 0.024233272299170494, 0.02434331364929676, -0.0063884383998811245, -0.019464869052171707, 0.011835422366857529, -0.028952769935131073, -0.030371064320206642, -0.07208848744630814, 0.05237908288836479, -0.0031850491650402546, -0.009121100418269634, 0.015637919306755066, -0.007806732784956694, -0.026629701256752014, -0.011847649700939655, -0.024636752903461456, -0.004817310720682144, 0.04516534134745598, -0.009280047379434109, -0.01041712798178196, 0.03895419090986252, -0.04900451749563217, 0.015906905755400658, -0.05321049690246582, -0.02027183026075363, -0.002364333486184478, 0.012654609978199005, -0.011627568863332272, 0.025578206405043602, 0.035506267100572586, -0.004135673400014639, -0.015063265338540077, 0.0006690284353680909, 0.019305922091007233, 0.03572634980082512, -0.05668287351727486, 0.02246040478348732, 0.014769825153052807, -0.0018936065025627613, -0.02680087462067604, 0.01612698659300804, -0.01644488051533699, 0.05863913893699646, -0.013278170488774776, 0.012972503900527954, 0.016102533787488937, -0.001754528027959168, 0.04130171239376068, 0.01623702608048916, 0.051303133368492126, 0.022509312257170677, 0.08759190887212753, 0.020039523020386696, -0.0006132442504167557, -0.02013733610510826, -0.04575222358107567, -0.0009376332745887339, -0.012086070142686367, 0.05257470905780792, -0.03792715072631836, -0.006565725430846214, -0.06998549401760101, 0.0025599603541195393, 0.03824504464864731, 0.04959139972925186, -0.01540561206638813, 0.0011875159107148647, 0.019061388447880745, -0.0394677110016346, 0.04259774088859558, -0.031104665249586105, -0.07199066877365112, -0.025553753599524498, 0.03425914794206619, -0.05399300158023834, 0.04291563481092453, 0.014403024688363075, -0.00925559364259243, -0.01252011675387621, 0.013510477729141712, 0.019966162741184235, 0.00013984261022415012, 0.02724103443324566, -0.013608290813863277, -0.0021656500175595284, -0.005670121405273676, -0.03934544324874878, 0.023389631882309914, 0.049615852534770966, -0.013241490349173546, -0.046950437128543854, -0.12031049281358719, -0.013327077031135559, -0.002379616955295205, 0.012251129373908043, -0.010637208819389343, 0.025529300794005394, -0.01617589220404625, -0.04147288575768471, -0.042695555835962296, 0.010857288725674152, -0.020932070910930634, 0.010594415478408337, -0.012110522948205471, 0.0229739248752594, -0.007164832204580307, 0.007812846451997757, 0.03054223768413067, -0.00004697240729001351, 0.01968494988977909, 0.01038656197488308, 0.006247831508517265, 0.02562711387872696, 0.01365719735622406, 0.017814267426729202, -0.00844863336533308, 0.02292501926422119, 0.005147430580109358, -0.035310640931129456, 0.0168239064514637, 0.02738775499165058, -0.004062313120812178, 0.009335067123174667, -0.004802027251571417, -0.013742784038186073, 0.000010023725735663902, -0.011823195964097977, 0.026629701256752014, -0.014843185432255268, -0.024098780006170273, -0.0063823251985013485, -0.03355000168085098, -0.028879409655928612, -0.000936104916036129, -0.008466973900794983, 0.013767237775027752, 0.022668257355690002, 0.026116181164979935, -0.0137550113722682, -0.008240779861807823, -0.008075719699263573, 0.003885026555508375, -0.007611106149852276, -0.053161587566137314, -0.03506610915064812, -0.013278170488774776, 0.00870539341121912, -0.02368307299911976, -0.04626574367284775, 0.003255352610722184, 0.01481873169541359, 0.02577383443713188, -0.008980493992567062, 0.0037994396407157183, 0.007293212693184614, -0.04186414182186127, -0.0028167206328362226, -0.008100173436105251, -0.02084648422896862, 0.0026073388289660215, -0.002744888886809349, 0.030591145157814026, 0.007030338980257511, -0.0037352496292442083, 0.021139923483133316, 0.01852341555058956, 0.015063265338540077, -0.04924905300140381, -0.0076600126922130585, -0.020553043112158775, -0.001179874292574823, 0.02052859030663967, 0.0012784518767148256, 0.01365719735622406, -0.018107708543539047, 0.0023077852092683315, -0.0036924562882632017, -0.0291239432990551, -0.02543148770928383, -0.009695754386484623, 0.033623360097408295, -0.004132616799324751, 0.049028974026441574, -0.0018508131615817547, 0.008515880443155766, -0.01599249243736267, 0.013339304365217686, -0.003564076265320182, 0.06220933049917221, -0.02116437628865242, 0.012385623529553413, -0.021005429327487946, -0.01947709545493126, -0.032645225524902344, -0.012862463481724262, -0.03545736148953438, 0.025260314345359802, -0.03384343907237053, -0.012630157172679901, 0.03139810636639595, -0.018682362511754036, 0.030566690489649773, -0.030199890956282616, -0.016016945242881775, 0.014488611370325089, 0.023658618330955505, 0.009041626937687397, -0.03205834701657295, -0.009506241418421268, 0.002842702204361558, 0.014329664409160614, 0.016872813925147057, -0.049224600195884705, -0.0369001105427742, -0.02577383443713188, -0.021849071606993675, -0.0029389874543994665, 0.01459865178912878, 0.00422431668266654, -0.00935340765863657, 0.0007087651756592095, 0.0014885978307574987, -0.026434075087308884, -0.00815519317984581, -0.04188859462738037, 0.007274872623383999, 0.007904546335339546, -0.03357445448637009, -0.02071199007332325, 0.02208137698471546, -0.003976726438850164, 0.03697346895933151, -0.0003102519258391112, 0.01760641485452652, 0.03675338998436928, 0.011120161972939968, -0.01307031698524952, 0.006547385361045599, -0.028512610122561455, -0.011762063018977642, 0.011083481833338737, -0.0504717193543911, -0.017948761582374573, 0.024881286546587944, -0.013522704131901264, 0.01689726673066616, -0.0063945516012609005, -0.03438141569495201, 0.01644488051533699, 0.021457817405462265, 0.03369671851396561, -0.016799453645944595, -0.011902669444680214, 0.008632033132016659, 0.010472148656845093, -0.01288691721856594, 0.03257186710834503, 0.008919360116124153, -0.004202920012176037, -0.02667860873043537, 0.020308509469032288, 0.007311552297323942, 0.018621228635311127, -0.014928772114217281, 0.027558928355574608, 0.025602661073207855, -0.032205067574977875, -0.026042820885777473, -0.009157780557870865, -0.010307088494300842, -0.018364468589425087, 0.015674598515033722, 0.029295116662979126, -0.017117347568273544, 0.06039978191256523, 0.004490246996283531, 0.006687992252409458, -0.020663082599639893, -0.01207384280860424, -0.005214677657932043, -0.014965452253818512, -0.02200801856815815, -0.03650885447859764, -0.005031277425587177, -0.002364333486184478, -0.005355284083634615, -0.08133184909820557, 0.020675309002399445, 0.035628534853458405, -0.038147229701280594, -0.018156614154577255, 0.043918222188949585, -0.01941596157848835, -0.007757826242595911, 0.010337654501199722, -0.01695840060710907, 0.0005341529031284153, -0.026067273691296577, -0.0063762119971215725, 0.020553043112158775, 0.02143336459994316, -0.01009312178939581, -0.016726093366742134, 0.005975787993520498, 0.02589610032737255, -0.004704213701188564, 0.0033745625987648964, -0.004218203481286764, 0.03125138580799103, 0.007115925662219524, 0.03152037039399147, -0.0036924562882632017, 0.0002836970961652696, 0.02433108538389206, -0.03328101336956024, 0.009310614317655563, 0.0013097827322781086, 0.025578206405043602, -0.025602661073207855, -0.04225539416074753, -0.009451220743358135, 0.0037810998037457466, 0.02983309142291546, 0.013278170488774776, 0.04413830116391182, 0.04455401003360748, 0.03403906896710396, 0.029368476942181587, -0.0381716825067997, 0.004306846763938665, -0.023096192628145218, -0.02316955104470253, 0.020467456430196762, -0.00893158745020628, -0.021849071606993675, 0.00899883359670639, 0.01200048252940178, -0.013828370720148087, 0.009854701347649097, 0.021702351048588753, -0.0037872130051255226, 0.028879409655928612, -0.01507549174129963, 0.029026130214333534, 0.00156959961168468, -0.021017657592892647, 0.030982397496700287, -0.01578463986515999, -0.01882908120751381, -0.0019257015082985163, -0.029295116662979126, -0.03638659045100212, 0.02428217977285385, -0.004398546647280455, -0.042035315185785294, 0.036019787192344666, -0.031813811510801315, 0.02348744496703148, -0.006339531857520342, 0.06377434730529785, -0.022704938426613808, -0.10436691343784332, -0.010777815245091915, 0.017068440094590187, -0.00009623731602914631, 0.0008115456439554691, -0.007177059073001146, 0.025847194716334343, 0.033623360097408295, -0.030835678800940514, -0.010991781949996948, 0.031349197030067444, -0.007085359189659357, -0.017496373504400253, 0.04237766191363335, 0.025260314345359802, -0.029172850772738457, -0.018022121861577034, -0.010227615013718605, 0.005431700963526964, 0.03526173532009125, -0.00670021865516901, 0.00844863336533308, -0.0036252096761018038, 0.00524524413049221, -0.002208443358540535, -0.005575364455580711, -0.010355995036661625, 0.0031330857891589403, 0.0048417639918625355, -0.01928146928548813, -0.01818106882274151, -0.020797576755285263, 0.033941254019737244, 0.026629701256752014, -0.001267753541469574, -0.01365719735622406, 0.004612513817846775, 0.00043710367754101753, -0.05839460715651512, 0.011364695616066456, -0.04154624789953232, -0.03995677828788757, 0.01909806951880455, -0.004704213701188564, -0.0007186993025243282, -0.01285023707896471, 0.025920554995536804, 0.010851175524294376, -0.01161534246057272, -0.021262191236019135, -0.01974608190357685, -0.01852341555058956, -0.015051038935780525, 0.007232079282402992, -0.009170006960630417, 0.0013640385586768389, -0.012569023296236992, 0.06123119592666626, -0.024355540052056313, -0.003946159966289997, -0.011554209515452385, 0.02499132603406906, 0.010539394803345203, -0.01314367726445198, -0.06621968001127243, -0.01459865178912878, -0.016799453645944595, 0.015968039631843567, 0.007800619583576918, -0.02458784729242325, -0.014060677960515022, 0.023829791694879532, 0.00326757924631238, 0.018034348264336586, -0.0063150785863399506, -0.04240211471915245, -0.013437117449939251, 0.028879409655928612, -0.038220591843128204, 0.018731268122792244, -0.0042457133531570435, -0.02719212882220745, 0.01766754686832428, -0.007158719003200531, 0.009371747262775898, 0.04814865067601204, -0.015344479121267796, -0.019134748727083206, -0.013437117449939251, 0.04567886143922806, -0.006553498562425375, -0.006639085244387388, 0.026629701256752014, 0.002627207199111581, -0.03274304047226906, -0.004325186833739281, -0.008717620745301247, -0.02298615127801895, 0.005737368017435074, -0.004640023689717054, -0.006153075024485588, -0.0030979341827332973, 0.004102049861103296, -0.019501548260450363, 0.03015098348259926, -0.021567856892943382, 0.015968039631843567, -0.004163183271884918, 0.0297841839492321, 0.040103498846292496, 0.013706103898584843, -0.000012381898159219418, -0.02562711387872696, -0.003683286253362894, 0.04685262590646744, -0.0067124455235898495, -0.003230899339541793, 0.0029084207490086555, 0.025798287242650986, 0.013522704131901264, 0.034723762422800064, -0.02161676436662674, -0.009763001464307308, -0.034528132528066635, 0.01837669499218464, 0.00799013301730156, -0.01178040262311697, -0.0005471437470987439, -0.003233955940231681, 0.04264664649963379, -0.0020418548956513405, 0.01207384280860424, 0.009952514432370663, 0.00008338975749211386, -0.03345218673348427, 0.01968494988977909, 0.003288975916802883, 0.025847194716334343, 0.0026959821116179228, 0.014500838704407215, 0.0036404929123818874, -0.003677173051983118, 0.002772398991510272, 0.006131678353995085, 0.011994369328022003, 0.026311807334423065, -0.02919730357825756, -0.021983563899993896, 0.019660495221614838, 0.024062098935246468, 0.011217975988984108, 0.019073614850640297, -0.0061072250828146935, 0.029368476942181587, -0.02265603095293045, -0.020406322553753853, 0.013327077031135559, -0.010001420974731445, -0.00828357320278883, 0.01624925248324871, 0.005664007738232613, 0.024172140285372734, -0.015307798981666565, -0.021201057359576225, 0.021078789606690407, 0.019440416246652603, 0.010355995036661625, 0.0006827834877185524, 0.006253945175558329, 0.022692712023854256, -0.026703061535954475, -0.0860758051276207, 0.011156842112541199, -0.0007775402045808733, 0.00035705717164091766, 0.0012746310094371438, -0.0061102816835045815, -0.012569023296236992, 0.05140094831585884, 0.01213497668504715, 0.003857516450807452, -0.0381961390376091, -0.016909493133425713, 0.03648440167307854, 0.029613010585308075, -0.030517784878611565, -0.03100685216486454, -0.006920299027115107, -0.002408655360341072, 0.017398560419678688, -0.026458527892827988, 0.008607580326497555, 0.006926412228494883, 0.04198640584945679, 0.02199579030275345, -0.009842474944889545, -0.04259774088859558, 0.03347663953900337, -0.00879709329456091, -0.01637152023613453, -0.05780772492289543, -0.04880889132618904, -0.010172595269978046, -0.007941226474940777, 0.0022252551279962063, 0.023927606642246246, 0.0054530976340174675, -0.00608582841232419, -0.040225766599178314, -0.03773152455687523, 0.02963746339082718, 0.015271118842065334, 0.030346611514687538, 0.008778753690421581, 0.02990644983947277, -0.009726321324706078, 0.020675309002399445, 0.010802268981933594, -0.007941226474940777, -0.02232591062784195, 0.025455940514802933, -0.009726321324706078, -0.025407033041119576, 0.04809974506497383, 0.009604054503142834, 0.04374704882502556, 0.02433108538389206, -0.0009582657949067652, -0.03501719981431961, -0.014488611370325089, 0.018168840557336807, 0.013473797589540482, -0.0005161950248293579, -0.02214251086115837, 0.0006923355394974351, -0.008601467125117779, -0.03890528529882431, 0.033109840005636215, 0.017814267426729202, -0.011859876103699207, 0.030004264786839485, -0.018951348960399628, -0.003940046299248934, -0.021506723016500473, 0.001506173750385642, -0.009121100418269634, 0.025211406871676445, -0.001985306618735194, 0.0076477862894535065, -0.013865050859749317, -0.020161788910627365, 0.023071737959980965, -0.0006422825972549617, -0.02609172835946083, -0.007678352762013674, 0.034528132528066635, -0.011413602158427238, 0.03068895824253559, 0.021983563899993896, 0.016224799677729607, 0.023866472765803337, 0.012379510328173637, -0.03332991898059845, -0.01371833123266697, 0.023120645433664322, 0.008075719699263573, -0.04025021940469742, -0.016285933554172516, 0.013351530767977238, -0.007177059073001146, 0.011444169096648693, -0.016616053879261017, 0.009512354619801044, 0.02161676436662674, -0.03147146478295326, 0.014965452253818512, -0.02324291132390499, -0.011242428794503212, -0.03254741430282593, 0.03575080260634422, -0.035384003072977066, -0.005926881451159716, -0.013901730999350548, -0.01511217188090086, -0.019403735175728798, 0.007629446219652891, -0.00799013301730156, 0.014904318377375603, 0.028708236292004585, -0.003539622761309147, -0.012251129373908043, 0.004361866973340511, 0.00867482740432024, -0.04318462312221527, -0.011658135801553726, -0.00867482740432024, 0.01252011675387621, -0.007996246218681335, 0.002055610064417124, -0.04161960631608963, -0.024881286546587944, -0.02220364473760128, -0.007984019815921783, -0.01703176088631153, -0.00037043009069748223, 0.006822485476732254, -0.027999090030789375, -0.034846026450395584, -0.012355056591331959, -0.012789103202521801, 0.012899143621325493, -0.017838720232248306, 0.008454746566712856, -0.0012219034833833575, 0.015099945478141308, -0.01365719735622406, 0.016261478886008263, -0.01068000216037035, 0.014439704827964306, -0.02083425596356392, -0.020760897547006607, -0.025676021352410316, 0.0027540589217096567, -0.015637919306755066, -0.04785521328449249, -0.025455940514802933, -0.012838010676205158, -0.03249850496649742, -0.007446045987308025, 0.05144985392689705, 0.015699053183197975, 0.030566690489649773, 0.02128664404153824, -0.03332991898059845, -0.015833545476198196, 0.01980721578001976, 0.007672239560633898, 0.00017146003665402532, 0.018498960882425308, 0.01721516065299511, 0.0220202449709177, 0.029661916196346283, -0.026262901723384857, 0.008350820280611515, -0.017899854108691216, 0.03049333021044731, 0.0038452898152172565, 0.0021992733236402273, -0.03159373253583908, 0.022032471373677254, 0.06866501271724701, -0.0137550113722682, -0.02990644983947277, -0.026507435366511345, 0.006559611763805151, 0.016322612762451172, -0.00598495826125145, 0.025847194716334343, 0.029979810118675232, -0.015491198748350143, 0.0242699533700943, 0.025260314345359802, -0.014207398518919945, 0.03029770404100418, 0.015222212299704552, -0.010172595269978046, -0.004973200615495443, 0.019917255267500877, -0.00057427171850577, 0.03352554515004158, 0.021653443574905396, 0.005636497866362333, -0.013437117449939251, 0.039443258196115494, 0.019257014617323875, -0.02763228863477707, -0.010203161276876926, 0.002060194965451956, -0.00942065380513668, 0.032840851694345474, -0.02711876854300499, 0.0061163948848843575, -0.02019846998155117, 0.004404660314321518, -0.01401177141815424, 0.0036252096761018038, -0.004166239872574806, 0.04117944464087486, -0.010820608586072922, -0.013852824456989765, 0.05702522024512291, -0.021543404087424278, 0.02485683374106884, -0.03797605633735657, 0.0022481800988316536, 0.005419474560767412, 0.027852369472384453, 0.01941596157848835, 0.01701953448355198, 0.006266171578317881, -0.010796155780553818, -0.000666735926643014, -0.007311552297323942, -0.005572307854890823, 0.002937458921223879, 0.03406352177262306, 0.022766072303056717, 0.04861326515674591, -0.0017560564447194338, -0.005019050557166338, -0.025407033041119576, -0.008326366543769836, -0.031153570860624313, 0.036875657737255096, -0.005957447923719883, -0.02369529940187931, -0.0003043296164833009, 0.008589239791035652, 0.03653331100940704, 0.005135204177349806, -0.0006866042967885733, -0.0010423241183161736, -0.00530943414196372, 0.0073298923671245575, 0.002014345023781061, 0.013596064411103725, -0.01252011675387621, 0.021347777917981148, -0.015601239167153835, -0.040030140429735184, -0.010832834988832474, -0.011737609282135963, -0.012397849932312965, -0.002997064031660557, -0.03196053206920624, -0.015320025384426117, -0.016395973041653633, 0.006901958957314491, -0.043453607708215714, 0.030566690489649773, -0.027363302186131477, 0.00003149802068946883, 0.0045788902789354324, 0.011150728911161423, 0.04677926376461983, -0.0000618975464021787, -0.008570900186896324, 0.005988014861941338, 0.005153544247150421, -0.008081832900643349, -0.0249301940202713, 0.028365889564156532, -0.017447467893362045, -0.009200573898851871, -0.018205521628260612, -0.01585800014436245, -0.001388491946272552, -0.032791946083307266, 0.025089140981435776, 0.03068895824253559, 0.008289686404168606, 0.024257726967334747, 0.04232875257730484, 0.021665669977664948, -0.0024239385966211557, 0.029344024136662483, -0.01139526255428791, -0.011016235686838627, -0.01733742654323578, -0.021714577451348305, 0.012960277497768402, 0.004037859849631786, -0.00409593665972352, -0.020357416942715645, -0.05360174924135208, 0.003270635847002268, -0.038807470351457596, 0.0007183172274380922, -0.003952273167669773, 0.008020699955523014, -0.03406352177262306, 0.039003096520900726, -0.012422303669154644, -0.016713866963982582, 0.009683527983725071, 0.010087007656693459, 0.022497083991765976, -0.03973669931292534, 0.002994007430970669, -0.013217037543654442, 0.02277829870581627, 0.004957917146384716, -0.037902697920799255, -0.010783928446471691, 0.018486734479665756, -0.008008472621440887, -0.01281355693936348, -0.007745599374175072, -0.0037566462997347116, 0.000347696099197492, -0.02814580872654915, 0.007109812460839748, -0.002868684008717537, -0.015393385663628578, -0.013339304365217686, -0.0284881554543972, -0.006308964919298887, -0.0003744419664144516, -0.025480393320322037, -0.03154482692480087, 0.041203901171684265, 0.024184366688132286, -0.02640962041914463, 0.05340612307190895, 0.045018624514341354, -0.017838720232248306, -0.0076600126922130585, -0.008204099722206593, -0.012630157172679901, -0.05404191091656685, 0.01116906851530075, -0.019134748727083206, 0.007274872623383999, -0.01216554269194603, -0.03093349188566208, -0.05267252400517464, 0.026629701256752014, -0.004199863411486149, -0.011884329840540886, -0.012923597358167171, 0.022350365296006203, -0.006253945175558329, 0.020932070910930634, 0.0030933490488678217, -0.014782051555812359, -0.010129800997674465, -0.0015161079354584217, -0.007751713041216135, 0.016285933554172516, -0.0010919950436800718, 0.0025844136252999306, -0.012532343156635761, 0.006177528295665979, 0.0063211917877197266, -0.001119505031965673, 0.05042281374335289, 0.011272995732724667, 0.0011217975988984108, 0.006969205569475889, 0.017312973737716675, -0.026556340977549553, -0.008418066427111626, -0.012666836380958557, -0.03159373253583908, 0.010887855663895607, 0.03127583861351013, 0.03836731240153313, 0.036851201206445694, 0.03374562785029411, 0.0343080535531044, 0.025284767150878906, -0.03249850496649742, -0.00005740806591347791, 0.02395205944776535, -0.02861042320728302, 0.0034846027847379446, -0.0034051293041557074, -0.0020357416942715645, -0.01203716266900301, 0.02277829870581627, 0.02187352441251278, -0.006822485476732254, -0.005608987994492054, 0.005492834374308586, -0.02434331364929676, 0.012049390003085136, 0.014439704827964306, -0.015552332624793053, 0.007189285941421986, 0.019269242882728577, -0.00627839844673872, -0.03112911805510521, 0.00241171196103096, -0.030957944691181183, -0.005734311416745186, 0.012379510328173637, -0.011450282298028469, 0.024306632578372955, -0.017716454342007637, 0.021518951281905174, 0.030762318521738052, -0.02083425596356392, 0.021849071606993675, 0.020149562507867813, -0.011976029723882675, 0.04235320910811424, 0.01511217188090086, 0.015833545476198196, -0.026311807334423065, -0.00037558822077699006, 0.0015497312415391207, 0.01612698659300804, -0.013290396891534328, -0.011407488957047462, -0.009701867587864399, -0.005541740916669369, 0.02413545921444893, -0.01754528097808361, -0.020088428631424904, 0.003554906230419874, 0.007843413390219212, 0.02738775499165058, 0.019183656200766563, 0.023731978610157967, 0.0047806305810809135, 0.021763484925031662, -0.00964684784412384, 0.005138260778039694, -0.0336478129029274, -0.036851201206445694, 0.015515652485191822, -0.006296738516539335, 0.0009506241185590625, -0.03178935870528221, 0.015234438702464104, -0.015711279585957527, -0.003322599222883582, -0.009512354619801044, 0.031080212444067, -0.02213028445839882, 0.03049333021044731, 0.007011998910456896, 0.030664505437016487, 0.012948050163686275, -0.017692001536488533, 0.02653188817203045, -0.00832025334239006, -0.013987317681312561, -0.005376680754125118, 0.007366572506725788, 0.007091472391039133, 0.0014664370100945234, 0.005829067900776863, -0.015809092670679092, 0.026360714808106422, -0.031153570860624313, -0.015894679352641106, -0.012703516520559788, 0.0067185587249696255, -0.009035513736307621, 0.015870226547122, 0.026556340977549553, -0.007745599374175072, 0.013486023992300034, 0.018535641953349113, 0.02116437628865242, -0.031887173652648926, 0.020553043112158775, -0.0030215175356715918, -0.01507549174129963, 0.010655548423528671, 0.006822485476732254, 0.007953452877700329, 0.007971793413162231, -0.00198377831839025, 0.031422559171915054, -0.014476384967565536, 0.07712587714195251, -0.023352952674031258, 0.018792401999235153, -0.012318376451730728, 0.003713852958753705, 0.015381159260869026, -0.0014267002698034048, 0.003933933097869158, 0.030371064320206642, 0.020088428631424904, 0.0014007185818627477, 0.027216581627726555, 0.004624740220606327, 0.017423013225197792, -0.02951519750058651, 0.017190707847476006, 0.032009437680244446, 0.018229974433779716, 0.008687053807079792, 0.003955329768359661, 0.040030140429735184, 0.001055315020494163, -0.03792715072631836, 0.02128664404153824, -0.02148227021098137, 0.017850948497653008, -0.01220222283154726, -0.04054366052150726, -0.011425829492509365, -0.008589239791035652, -0.011425829492509365, -0.013033636845648289, 0.01042324211448431, 0.023511899635195732, -0.018816854804754257, -0.007751713041216135, 0.0036985697224736214, 0.018596775829792023, 0.0006862222217023373, -0.002986365696415305, -0.019403735175728798, -0.01161534246057272, -0.014513065107166767, -0.02614063397049904, 0.0013808503281325102, -0.007372685708105564, 0.016200346872210503, -0.018951348960399628, -0.0041784667409956455, 0.03049333021044731, -0.010857288725674152, -0.011132389307022095, -0.011071255430579185, 0.018474508076906204, 0.0013831427786499262, 0.014317438006401062, -0.02614063397049904, -0.04157070070505142, -0.005890201311558485, 0.013730557635426521, 0.017202934250235558, 0.006804145406931639, -0.009756888262927532, 0.013926184736192226, -0.01281355693936348, 0.021127697080373764, -0.0011042216792702675, 0.018792401999235153, 0.019831668585538864, -0.020870937034487724, 0.014072904363274574, 0.00042143824975937605 ]
11.732328
4.182024
2024-07-01
5
2024ApJ...969..105C
[ "galaxy properties", "multiple galaxies", "individual galaxies", "other galaxy formation models", "several galaxies", "individual simulated galaxies", "galaxies", "properties", "other parameters", "astrophysical processes" ]
[ "Cosmological parameters", "Galaxy properties", "Galaxy processes", "Computational methods", "Astronomy data analysis", "339", "615", "614", "1965", "1858", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies", "Astrophysics - Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics" ]
9
[ "10.3847/1538-4357/ad4969", "10.48550/arXiv.2309.12048" ]
[ "Chawak, Chaitanya", "Villaescusa-Navarro, Francisco", "Echeverri-Rojas, Nicolás", "Ni, Yueying", "Hahn, ChangHoon", "Anglés-Alcázar, Daniel" ]
[ "Indian Institute of Science Education and Research (IISER) Tirupati, Tirupati-517507, India", "Center for Computational Astrophysics, Flatiron Institute, 162 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10010, USA; Department of Astrophysical Sciences, Princeton University, Peyton Hall, Princeton, NJ 08544, USA", "Instituto de Fisica, Universidad de Antioquia, A.A.1226, Medellin, Colombia", "Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA; McWilliams Center for Cosmology, Department of Physics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA", "Department of Astrophysical Sciences, Princeton University, Peyton Hall, Princeton, NJ 08544, USA", "Center for Computational Astrophysics, Flatiron Institute, 162 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10010, USA; Department of Physics, University of Connecticut, 196 Auditorium Road, U-3046, Storrs, CT 06269, USA" ]
[ "2023mla..confE..14H", "2024A&A...686A..80W", "2024ApJ...966L..18H", "2024arXiv240117940L", "2024arXiv240504447W" ]
[ "2001MNRAS.328..726S", "2009MNRAS.399..497D", "2010MNRAS.401..791S", "2015MNRAS.450...53H", "2018MNRAS.475..648P", "2019ComAC...6....2N", "2019MNRAS.486.2827D", "2020ApJS..248...32W", "2020arXiv201105991J", "2021ApJ...915...71V", "2022ApJ...929..132V", "2022ApJS..259...61V", "2022MNRAS.512.3703B", "2022MNRAS.513..670N", "2023A&ARv..31....2H", "2023ApJ...944...67J", "2023ApJ...954..125E", "2023ApJ...959..136N", "2023ApJS..265...54V", "2023MNRAS.525.6191B" ]
29096795
2404.09958
From VIPERS to SDSS: Unveiling galaxy spectra evolution over 9 Gyr through unsupervised machine learning
<BR /> Aims: This study aims to trace the chronological evolution of galaxy spectra over cosmic time. Focusing on the VIPERS dataset, we seek to understand the diverse population of galaxies within narrow redshift bins, comparing our findings with the previously mapped diversity of SDSS galaxies. <BR /> Methods: We used Fisher-EM, an unsupervised sub-space model-based classification algorithm to classify a dataset of 79 224 galaxy spectra from the VIMOS Public Extragalactic Redshift Survey (VIPERS). The dataset was divided into 26 samples by bins of redshift ranging from z ∼ 0.4 to z ∼ 1.2, which were classified independently. Classes of subsequent bins were linked through the k-nearest neighbours method to create a chronological tree of classes at different epochs. <BR /> Results: Based on the optical spectra, three main chronological galaxy branches emerged: (i) red passive, (ii) blue star forming, and (iii) very blue, possibly associated with AGN activity. Each of the branches differentiates into sub-branches, discriminating finer properties such as D4000 break, colour, star-formation rate, and stellar masses, and/or disappear with cosmic time. Notably, these classes align remarkably well with the branches identified in a previous SDSS analyses, indicating a robust and consistent classification across datasets. The chronological `tree' constructed from VIPERS data provides valuable insights into the temporal evolution of these spectral classes. <BR /> Conclusions: The synergy between VIPERS and SDSS datasets enhances our understanding of the evolutionary pathways of galaxy spectra. The remarkable correspondence between independently derived branches in both datasets underscores the reliability of our unsupervised machine-learning approach. The three sub-trees show complex branching structures that highlight different physical and evolutionary behaviours. This study contributes to the broader comprehension of galaxy evolution by providing a chronologically organised framework for interpreting optical spectra within specific redshift ranges. <P />The average spectra of Appendix A is available at the CDS via anonymous ftp to <A href="https://cdsarc.cds.unistra.fr">cdsarc.cds.unistra.fr</A> (ftp://130.79.128.5) or via <A href="https://cdsarc.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/cat/J/A+A/687/A76">https://cdsarc.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/cat/J/A+A/687/A76</A>
[ 0.032307691872119904, 0.01547816302627325, 0.016103794798254967, -0.025851158425211906, 0.0013912515714764595, 0.056106775999069214, -0.012500149197876453, -0.0017236191779375076, -0.020433176308870316, 0.027527855709195137, -0.010923553258180618, -0.031456831842660904, -0.010679556988179684, -0.03636179491877556, 0.050426024943590164, 0.03476017341017723, 0.02064589224755764, 0.029579931870102882, -0.05350414291024208, 0.044920455664396286, -0.0011840106453746557, -0.0004750901134684682, 0.004789221100509167, 0.03035571798682213, -0.059360068291425705, -0.06161234527826309, -0.012068462558090687, 0.0514020137488842, 0.08373473584651947, -0.06536614149808884, -0.0036067748442292213, -0.02127152495086193, -0.014814991503953934, 0.021021271124482155, -0.09194304049015045, 0.08258356899023056, -0.01595364324748516, -0.04689745604991913, -0.021346600726246834, -0.0321575403213501, 0.010854734107851982, 0.00034507573582232, -0.03065602108836174, 0.010435559786856174, -0.025187987834215164, -0.029454804956912994, -0.04159208759665489, -0.029204552993178368, 0.0068006315268576145, 0.009709825739264488, -0.030831199139356613, -0.008039385080337524, 0.004535839892923832, -0.0005951334605924785, -0.03616159409284592, -0.029104450717568398, -0.03501042723655701, 0.02507537417113781, -0.0248501468449831, 0.000015738582078483887, -0.007707799784839153, -0.015866054221987724, 0.04657212644815445, 0.002749657491222024, -0.022785557433962822, 0.03065602108836174, -0.05405469983816147, 0.022472741082310677, 0.002605761867016554, 0.009866233915090561, 0.007739081513136625, -0.01222487073391676, -0.02271048165857792, -0.00047313503455370665, 0.05022582411766052, 0.025150449946522713, -0.020308049395680428, 0.013025680556893349, -0.035861287266016006, -0.023486265912652016, 0.022510278970003128, 0.029029374942183495, 0.008971578441560268, 0.0075951856561005116, -0.017905618995428085, -0.03908955678343773, 0.014151819981634617, 0.020620865747332573, -0.010642019100487232, 0.008652505464851856, 0.00452019926160574, 0.015515700913965702, -0.03468509763479233, -0.015928618609905243, 0.03521063178777695, -0.03248286992311478, -0.002895117038860917, -0.08308407664299011, 0.035986416041851044, 0.01627897284924984, 0.007438777480274439, 0.014276946894824505, 0.008033128455281258, -0.08053149282932281, -0.0010839093010872602, -0.022885657846927643, 0.029129477217793465, -0.01775546744465828, -0.023586368188261986, -0.02553834207355976, -0.04146696254611015, -0.009096705354750156, 0.003625543788075447, 0.021096346899867058, -0.00792677141726017, 0.012481380254030228, -0.09479592740535736, -0.023849133402109146, 0.004692248068749905, -0.021309062838554382, -0.0283286664634943, 0.010185306891798973, 0.02842876687645912, -0.014151819981634617, 0.03435976803302765, -0.012406304478645325, 0.0117681585252285, -0.060511231422424316, 0.007019603159278631, -0.013250908814370632, 0.038714174181222916, -0.008790144696831703, 0.03843889757990837, -0.02155931666493416, -0.053153786808252335, -0.015378061681985855, -0.012193588539958, 0.007244830951094627, -0.02107132226228714, 0.009941309690475464, -0.022560328245162964, -0.009240600280463696, 0.01896919496357441, 0.019582316279411316, 0.08203300833702087, -0.0005478199454955757, -0.049575164914131165, 0.01860632747411728, -0.00105262768920511, 0.022297563031315804, -0.024212000891566277, -0.0035598522517830133, -0.013501161709427834, -0.037112556397914886, 0.009641005657613277, 0.031031401827931404, 0.03413454070687294, 0.01733003742992878, -0.012938092462718487, 0.027978312224149704, -0.04226776957511902, 0.02543824166059494, -0.03476017341017723, -0.017617827281355858, -0.038288746029138565, 0.007025859784334898, -0.037663113325834274, 0.0027058632113039494, -0.07797890901565552, -0.010429303161799908, -0.0059622833505272865, -0.02907942607998848, 0.022510278970003128, -0.01722993515431881, 0.010129000060260296, 0.00726985651999712, 0.020433176308870316, 0.008227075450122356, -0.01201215572655201, -0.053153786808252335, 0.013563725166022778, 0.04226776957511902, 0.0283286664634943, -0.006675505079329014, -0.04216767102479935, -0.012543943710625172, 0.00008753975271247327, 0.00326580461114645, -0.010066436603665352, -0.021521778777241707, 0.010842221789062023, 0.03521063178777695, 0.020333075895905495, 0.04722278565168381, -0.04321873188018799, -0.004883066285401583, 0.005959155037999153, 0.023648930713534355, -0.020070308819413185, 0.010673300363123417, 0.0217970572412014, 0.023949233815073967, 0.02234761416912079, -0.04074122756719589, -0.025550855323672295, -0.047072634100914, -0.008389739319682121, -0.012162307277321815, -0.02451230399310589, -0.024862658232450485, 0.03916463255882263, -0.015015194192528725, -0.010022642090916634, 0.04569623991847038, -0.03410951420664787, -0.0663171038031578, -0.04844902455806732, 0.03065602108836174, 0.05595662444829941, 0.023623906075954437, -0.030580945312976837, -0.01821843534708023, 0.025288090109825134, 0.020921170711517334, 0.02845379337668419, 0.004823631141334772, 0.036612048745155334, -0.04036584496498108, -0.02927962876856327, -0.0035316988360136747, 0.022360127419233322, 0.015515700913965702, -0.02475004456937313, -0.004273074213415384, -0.011611750349402428, 0.010804682970046997, -0.00537418806925416, 0.0069695524871349335, 0.0028200410306453705, -0.01745516248047352, -0.02087111957371235, 0.06246320903301239, 0.01235625334084034, 0.02947983145713806, -0.014814991503953934, -0.022935708984732628, -0.02287314645946026, -0.04532086104154587, 0.02905440144240856, 0.015040219761431217, 0.04289340600371361, 0.005549365654587746, -0.052403029054403305, -0.05860930681228638, -0.024737533181905746, 0.015215396881103516, -0.040490973740816116, 0.03108145110309124, -0.018894119188189507, 0.03821367025375366, -0.04306858032941818, -0.03548590838909149, -0.010329201817512512, 0.03873920068144798, -0.019144373014569283, 0.054104749113321304, 0.012631531804800034, -0.010835965164005756, -0.011586724780499935, -0.0034472383558750153, -0.003675594460219145, -0.009659774601459503, 0.03178216144442558, -0.04411964491009712, -0.025350652635097504, 0.021834595128893852, 0.02727760188281536, 0.031231604516506195, 0.03435976803302765, 0.007363701239228249, -0.005424238741397858, -0.011855746619403362, 0.04244294762611389, 0.019719954580068588, -0.03591134026646614, 0.02064589224755764, -0.027978312224149704, 0.007989334873855114, 0.00974736362695694, -0.032908301800489426, 0.01621641032397747, -0.046722277998924255, 0.011173807084560394, -0.0548054575920105, -0.038814276456832886, -0.002261663554236293, 0.03225764259696007, 0.031356729567050934, -0.025951260700821877, 0.0010385509813204408, 0.0660168007016182, -0.02792826108634472, 0.017542751505970955, 0.024599893018603325, -0.013388548046350479, 0.023023298010230064, 0.029029374942183495, 0.0007589711458422244, -0.03643687069416046, 0.005039474461227655, 0.013263421133160591, -0.015290472656488419, 0.02232258766889572, -0.035661086440086365, -0.03410951420664787, -0.06856938451528549, 0.010479354299604893, 0.0028325538150966167, 0.039239708334207535, -0.03488530218601227, -0.05991062521934509, -0.026051361113786697, -0.019019246101379395, 0.032207589596509933, -0.017417624592781067, -0.025675982236862183, -0.015615802258253098, -0.0248501468449831, 0.05320383608341217, 0.016291486099362373, 0.029554907232522964, -0.03413454070687294, 0.03128165379166603, 0.01975749246776104, -0.03203241527080536, -0.009728594683110714, 0.020570816472172737, 0.06496573984622955, -0.014552225358784199, -0.017480188980698586, -0.051351964473724365, -0.0044983020052313805, -0.022272538393735886, -0.016466662287712097, -0.011480366811156273, 0.0291795264929533, 0.007407495751976967, 0.015077757649123669, 0.004416969604790211, 0.013451111502945423, 0.009728594683110714, 0.0013779568253085017, 0.03440982103347778, -0.01763034053146839, 0.021284038200974464, -0.040916405618190765, -0.004729785956442356, -0.044069595634937286, -0.047898467630147934, 0.025751058012247086, 0.02317344956099987, -0.01657927595078945, 0.03403443843126297, 0.021509265527129173, 0.028478818014264107, 0.01579097844660282, -0.0486992783844471, 0.005070756189525127, 0.02426205202937126, -0.049550142139196396, 0.017442651093006134, 0.011492880061268806, -0.034484896808862686, -0.023248525336384773, -0.07597687840461731, 0.03335875645279884, 0.02277304418385029, 0.011048680171370506, -0.031982362270355225, 0.039990466088056564, 0.005330394022166729, 0.045971520245075226, -0.0028481946792453527, -0.03395936265587807, -0.002427456434816122, -0.036186616867780685, -0.03330870717763901, -0.02580110915005207, -0.07402490824460983, 0.03758803755044937, -0.023210987448692322, -0.005077012348920107, 0.013038193807005882, 0.015590776689350605, 0.03541083261370659, -0.03551093488931656, 0.02313591167330742, 0.06251325458288193, 0.03848894685506821, 0.07162247598171234, -0.010823452845215797, -0.025263063609600067, -0.026376690715551376, -0.07062146067619324, -0.024299589917063713, 0.007983078248798847, -0.03521063178777695, 0.03178216144442558, 0.02835369110107422, -0.013075731694698334, 0.048599179834127426, -0.037563011050224304, 0.022497765719890594, -0.011937079019844532, 0.03033069148659706, 0.04326878488063812, -0.04026574641466141, 0.024412203580141068, -0.025650955736637115, 0.021384138613939285, 0.024925222620368004, -0.03248286992311478, -0.0340094156563282, -0.016091283410787582, -0.010529404506087303, 0.005102037917822599, 0.030605969950556755, 0.03263302147388458, -0.010886015370488167, -0.009259369224309921, -0.015302984975278378, 0.023836620151996613, 0.011561699211597443, 0.009528391994535923, -0.0037256451323628426, -0.016166359186172485, 0.035035453736782074, -0.024212000891566277, -0.005887207575142384, -0.022109873592853546, 0.04447000101208687, 0.015903593972325325, -0.029655007645487785, -0.032207589596509933, 0.04527081176638603, -0.021196449175477028, 0.013463623821735382, 0.015440624207258224, 0.022072335705161095, -0.07047130912542343, 0.028929274529218674, 0.0392647311091423, -0.044419948011636734, 0.016253948211669922, -0.029554907232522964, -0.038814276456832886, -0.00945331621915102, -0.06796877831220627, 0.024737533181905746, -0.026401715353131294, -0.015903593972325325, -0.0022976375184953213, -0.027527855709195137, 0.04827385023236275, -0.053253889083862305, -0.017305010929703712, -0.027002323418855667, -0.0020458202343434095, 0.011793184094130993, -0.021747006103396416, 0.012043436989188194, -0.038814276456832886, -0.00033510473440401256, -0.03896442800760269, 0.029104450717568398, -0.013351010158658028, -0.01781802996993065, 0.0038820533081889153, 0.03128165379166603, 0.016404099762439728, 0.030806172639131546, -0.0005751913995482028, 0.004035333637148142, 0.041341833770275116, 0.021609365940093994, 0.03055592067539692, 0.012600250542163849, 0.03863909840583801, -0.0252755768597126, -0.013100757263600826, 0.013501161709427834, -0.023198474198579788, 0.003419084707275033, -0.013238396495580673, 0.029104450717568398, -0.013451111502945423, -0.030781148001551628, -0.010623250156641006, -0.01317583303898573, 0.013388548046350479, 0.09479592740535736, 0.001784618361853063, 0.024524817243218422, 0.011862003244459629, 0.023423703387379646, 0.028403742238879204, -0.054004646837711334, -0.006309509743005037, -0.0019066168460994959, 0.042918428778648376, -0.038914378732442856, 0.03658702224493027, 0.01834356226027012, -0.005780849605798721, 0.02012035995721817, 0.02015789784491062, 0.012005899101495743, 0.0126377884298563, 0.00006051045056665316, -0.028053387999534607, 0.02185961976647377, -0.017217421904206276, 0.0026996068190783262, -0.004401328973472118, -0.008408508263528347, -0.025025323033332825, -0.021621879190206528, -0.11872013658285141, -0.048499077558517456, 0.00617812667042017, -0.01473991572856903, -0.011130012571811676, 0.03128165379166603, 0.02313591167330742, -0.03023059107363224, -0.00413543451577425, 0.014301972463726997, 0.030706072226166725, -0.030405767261981964, -0.022522790357470512, 0.014814991503953934, -0.009709825739264488, -0.01841863803565502, 0.005208395421504974, 0.01317583303898573, 0.02642674185335636, -0.03205743804574013, 0.004038461484014988, 0.026676995679736137, 0.033759161829948425, 0.012988142669200897, -0.0213340874761343, 0.04299350455403328, 0.015565751120448112, -0.0213340874761343, 0.03518560528755188, 0.008934040553867817, -0.007826670072972775, -0.006456533446907997, -0.007726568728685379, -0.02905440144240856, -0.003600518452003598, 0.04161711409687996, 0.03959006071090698, -0.000046311510232044384, -0.027452779933810234, 0.02034558728337288, -0.04779836907982826, -0.022860633209347725, 0.01690460555255413, 0.016166359186172485, -0.002663632854819298, 0.01876899227499962, -0.03781326487660408, 0.007951796986162663, -0.008871477097272873, -0.041667163372039795, -0.008327176794409752, 0.008890246041119099, -0.038063518702983856, -0.024887684732675552, -0.0060248468071222305, 0.010936066508293152, 0.011868259869515896, -0.05155216529965401, -0.00421676691621542, -0.009178037755191326, -0.004213639069348574, 0.022635405883193016, -0.005392957013100386, 0.03193231299519539, -0.010072692297399044, -0.01168682612478733, 0.006450277287513018, 0.016954656690359116, -0.010692069306969643, 0.04066615179181099, 0.004610915668308735, -0.021847106516361237, 0.003104704199358821, 0.003024935955181718, 0.0026135821826756, -0.054405052214860916, -0.03683727607131004, -0.03526068106293678, 0.027252577245235443, -0.004025948699563742, -0.0374879352748394, 0.00009506690548732877, 0.024249538779258728, -0.013526187278330326, 0.0012129461392760277, -0.01452720072120428, 0.02149675227701664, -0.015603289008140564, 0.023749031126499176, 0.001584415789693594, -0.01660430245101452, -0.006109307054430246, -0.010685812681913376, 0.00044459052151069045, -0.007332419976592064, 0.013601263053715229, -0.012068462558090687, 0.03348388150334358, 0.009559673257172108, 0.014314484782516956, -0.04719775915145874, -0.0005837938515469432, 0.009703569114208221, 0.010423047468066216, -0.02468748204410076, 0.017880594357848167, -0.004945629741996527, -0.002635479439049959, -0.0031234731432050467, 0.0028356818947941065, 0.021834595128893852, -0.007782875560224056, 0.039765238761901855, 0.02842876687645912, 0.04024071991443634, 0.024574868381023407, -0.028929274529218674, 0.02990526147186756, 0.0008289638208225369, 0.016003694385290146, 0.0032845737878233194, -0.020095335319638252, -0.009409521706402302, -0.044820353388786316, 0.0007405931828543544, 0.031331706792116165, 0.03896442800760269, 0.039014481008052826, 0.01680450513958931, 0.01690460555255413, 0.002380533842369914, -0.03298337757587433, 0.008790144696831703, 0.001081563183106482, -0.008589942008256912, 0.037137579172849655, 0.0023461240343749523, -0.008064410649240017, 0.01722993515431881, -0.03000536374747753, 0.012531430460512638, -0.013125781901180744, 0.04424477368593216, 0.04069117456674576, 0.03506047651171684, 0.04509563371539116, 0.0283286664634943, -0.015152833424508572, -0.030931299552321434, 0.020595841109752655, -0.017117321491241455, 0.0003259157238062471, 0.02513793669641018, -0.007388726808130741, -0.0068944767117500305, -0.009791158139705658, -0.003176651895046234, 0.008252100087702274, 0.0018722070381045341, 0.012587737292051315, 0.0008156691328622401, 0.019845081493258476, 0.015002681873738766, 0.014777453616261482, 0.028578920289874077, -0.03518560528755188, 0.01417684555053711, 0.004116665571928024, 0.009872490540146828, 0.015102782286703587, 0.00298270583152771, -0.00863373652100563, -0.0348602756857872, 0.05540606752038002, 0.006106178741902113, 0.02543824166059494, -0.017805518582463264, -0.008045641705393791, 0.019119346514344215, -0.018205922096967697, -0.017767978832125664, -0.021484240889549255, -0.06836918741464615, 0.008971578441560268, 0.03098135069012642, -0.05012572184205055, 0.017667878419160843, -0.015803491696715355, 0.0021615622099488974, -0.018894119188189507, -0.01798069477081299, -0.022572841495275497, -0.038814276456832886, -0.044094618409872055, 0.01818089745938778, -0.04311863332986832, -0.028078412637114525, 0.012550199404358864, -0.05295358598232269, 0.019932670518755913, 0.024036822840571404, -0.014514687471091747, 0.03335875645279884, -0.03415956720709801, 0.010085205547511578, 0.015127807855606079, -0.022335100919008255, -0.004920604173094034, 0.01589108072221279, -0.006869451142847538, -0.02294822223484516, -0.0015429676277562976, 0.0365619957447052, 0.024299589917063713, -0.016041232272982597, 0.025025323033332825, 0.006963296327739954, -0.013351010158658028, -0.0024227641988545656, -0.013501161709427834, -0.010892271995544434, -0.04021569341421127, 0.020733481273055077, 0.008827682584524155, 0.009415778331458569, -0.008940297178924084, -0.01527796033769846, 0.03603646531701088, -0.008489840663969517, 0.02540070377290249, -0.0042230235412716866, 0.01243758574128151, 0.001800259226001799, 0.0671679675579071, 0.018130846321582794, 0.025213012471795082, 0.02234761416912079, 0.009572186507284641, 0.0029217065311968327, 0.00830215122550726, -0.01473991572856903, 0.012493892572820187, -0.001009615371003747, -0.014602276496589184, 0.0003949308884330094, -0.017242448404431343, 0.0027168116066604853, 0.03573616221547127, 0.02323601208627224, 0.04161711409687996, -0.023724006488919258, -0.010961092077195644, 0.03390931338071823, 0.018593816086649895, -0.02373651973903179, -0.015803491696715355, -0.022722993046045303, -0.017680391669273376, 0.03801346570253372, -0.0020395638421177864, -0.0309563260525465, -0.022260025143623352, -0.0257010068744421, -0.00763898016884923, 0.023623906075954437, -0.024800095707178116, 0.019807543605566025, -0.013676338829100132, -0.0015593904536217451, -0.012400047853589058, -0.12022165209054947, 0.007664005272090435, 0.022097360342741013, -0.0012457919074222445, 0.01094857882708311, 0.01589108072221279, 0.04371923953294754, 0.04066615179181099, -0.01285050343722105, -0.00030225899536162615, 0.014477149583399296, -0.03320860490202904, 0.022660430520772934, -0.005355419125407934, 0.022660430520772934, -0.0026245308108627796, -0.015403086319565773, 0.0392647311091423, -0.020308049395680428, -0.02107132226228714, -0.025613417848944664, 0.014852529391646385, -0.005690132733434439, 0.02993028610944748, 0.011705595068633556, -0.0033502650912851095, -0.039039503782987595, 0.0024321486707776785, 0.04069117456674576, 0.0075951856561005116, -0.006594172678887844, 0.006372073199599981, -0.01458976324647665, 0.050501104444265366, 0.006340791471302509, -0.0033940596040338278, -0.026927247643470764, -0.0066317105665802956, -0.0031578829512000084, -0.01206220593303442, -0.011949592269957066, -0.017042245715856552, 0.0037131323479115963, 0.02379908226430416, 0.06541619449853897, 0.0043293810449540615, -0.004842400085180998, 0.051026634871959686, 0.025851158425211906, 0.03606149181723595, 0.013188345357775688, 0.027052374556660652, -0.0053679319098591805, 0.006456533446907997, 0.008790144696831703, 0.010942323133349419, 0.006046743597835302, -0.012281177565455437, -0.007376214023679495, -0.008758863434195518, -0.013476137071847916, -0.0006608249386772513, -0.01124262623488903, -0.02897932380437851, -0.06471548974514008, 0.0025306858588010073, -0.06596675515174866, -0.001994205405935645, 0.01343859825283289, -0.02501281164586544, -0.022785557433962822, 0.012925579212605953, -0.01094857882708311, 0.003328368067741394, 0.011761901900172234, 0.02002025954425335, -0.006587916519492865, -0.0075639039278030396, -0.04201751947402954, -0.017442651093006134, -0.01300065591931343, -0.020395638421177864, 0.01779300533235073, -0.02895429916679859, 0.007814156822860241, 0.039439909160137177, 0.010010129772126675, -0.006825657095760107, -0.0070633976720273495, 0.03463504835963249, 0.03128165379166603, 0.015765953809022903, 0.018819043412804604, -0.011880772188305855, -0.0008250536047853529, -0.0231108870357275, 0.012080974876880646, -0.020370613783597946, -0.0002889642782974988, 0.008289637975394726, 0.008051897399127483, -0.003562980331480503, -0.024399690330028534, -0.017179884016513824, -0.03430971875786781, -0.04702258110046387, 0.012581481598317623, -0.008827682584524155, -0.013538699597120285, 0.03263302147388458, 0.019407138228416443, 0.022072335705161095, -0.0082708690315485, 0.017580289393663406, 0.03183221071958542, -0.008458559401333332, 0.01637907512485981, -0.05215277522802353, -0.004942501429468393, -0.01343859825283289, -0.00991002842783928, -0.015991181135177612, -0.04374426603317261, 0.009259369224309921, 0.020733481273055077, -0.014814991503953934, 0.013626288622617722, -0.009847464971244335, -0.032808199524879456, 0.015090269967913628, -0.037112556397914886, 0.018331049010157585, 0.03591134026646614, 0.017179884016513824, -0.024199487641453743, -0.029204552993178368, -0.00134354701731354, 0.013338497839868069, -0.009265625849366188, 0.019419651478528976, 0.0024587379302829504, 0.0261264368891716, -0.015040219761431217, 0.015828516334295273, 0.009440802969038486, 0.0014029821613803506, -0.002968628890812397, 0.01880653016269207, 0.006065513007342815, 0.03838884457945824, -0.046947505325078964, 0.0012340613175183535, -0.0038538998924195766, 0.032933324575424194, 0.012787939980626106, 0.05185246840119362, 0.011317702941596508, -0.015290472656488419, -0.007251087576150894, 0.014101769775152206, 0.07973068207502365, 0.016942143440246582, -0.009803670458495617, -0.02685217186808586, 0.013889054767787457, 0.0025525828823447227, -0.029629983007907867, -0.014439611695706844, -0.003337752539664507, 0.0077015431597828865, -0.006944527383893728, -0.05250312760472298, 0.028203539550304413, 0.003459750907495618, -0.0029373473953455687, 0.051351964473724365, 0.011499135755002499, 0.013401060365140438, 0.038063518702983856, 0.016041232272982597, -0.008108205161988735, -0.022335100919008255, -0.03778823837637901, 0.019982721656560898, 0.02418697439134121, 0.00015631051792297512, -0.0261264368891716, 0.00007996372733032331, 0.01321337092667818, 0.01452720072120428, -0.013901567086577415, 0.020308049395680428, 0.0015038655837997794, 0.036712151020765305, -0.027327653020620346, 0.03190728649497032, -0.004273074213415384, 0.03088124841451645, 0.005655723158270121, 0.009440802969038486, -0.004326252732425928, -0.02018292248249054, -0.01684204302728176, 0.009497109800577164, 0.011079962365329266, 0.0007296446128748357, 0.004554608836770058, -0.026176488026976585, -0.016253948211669922, -0.02491270937025547, 0.005117678549140692, -0.03561103716492653, 0.031381756067276, 0.014402073808014393, -0.024149436503648758, -0.023098373785614967, 0.023949233815073967, -0.01575344055891037, -0.025363165885210037, -0.0015226345276460052, -0.004194869659841061, -0.04824882373213768, 0.0017877465579658747, 0.05530596524477005, -0.0029873980674892664, 0.01644163765013218, 0.019582316279411316, -0.013851516880095005, -0.0010510635329410434, 0.0015304549597203732, 0.021809568628668785, -0.02471250668168068, -0.023411190137267113, -0.02887922339141369, -0.02313591167330742, -0.012781684286892414, -0.0010549738071858883, 0.037863314151763916, -0.006881963927298784, -0.005984180606901646, 0.033859264105558395, 0.0183185376226902, -0.009052910842001438, -0.006569147575646639, -0.005718286614865065, -0.006719299126416445, 0.02097122184932232, -0.008083179593086243, 0.02008282206952572, -0.02930465340614319, -0.023085860535502434, -0.002027051290497184, 0.009497109800577164, 0.004823631141334772, 0.014502175152301788, 0.018105821684002876, -0.015615802258253098, 0.03453494608402252, 0.0028278615791350603, 0.0058653103187680244, -0.018919143825769424, -0.022735506296157837, -0.006587916519492865, -0.05760829523205757, 0.0143770482391119, 0.0014850965235382318, 0.013125781901180744, 0.030781148001551628, 0.02905440144240856, -0.013726389966905117, 0.007739081513136625, -0.028478818014264107, 0.028804147616028786, 0.010141512379050255, -0.03178216144442558, 0.01016028132289648, -0.01549067534506321, 0.005840284749865532, -0.009603467769920826, 0.01193082332611084, -0.004739170428365469, -0.018168384209275246, 0.013839003629982471, -0.011280164122581482, -0.009334445931017399, 0.01025412604212761, 0.015190371312201023, -0.03823869302868843, 0.0010416790610179305, -0.005508699454367161, -0.02468748204410076, 0.018631353974342346, 0.007751593831926584, -0.007213549688458443, 0.02497527375817299, -0.02822856418788433, 0.017092296853661537, 0.0392647311091423, -0.020983733236789703, -0.017042245715856552, 0.0020239229779690504, 0.018881605938076973, 0.023148424923419952, 0.012681582942605019, 0.003146934323012829, -0.027552880346775055, 0.014126795344054699, -0.022397665306925774, -0.030931299552321434, 0.020370613783597946, 0.025613417848944664, -0.010892271995544434, -0.01876899227499962, 0.01841863803565502, 0.013688852079212666, -0.029329679906368256, -0.02468748204410076, 0.0002733234432525933, 0.027152476832270622, -0.01322588324546814, 0.005011321045458317, 0.020395638421177864, 0.0174301378428936, 0.027728058397769928, -0.006562890950590372, -0.035335756838321686, 0.007864207960665226, 0.012055949307978153, -0.014477149583399296, 0.018681403249502182, 0.009296908043324947, 0.025062860921025276, -0.027527855709195137, -0.021934695541858673, -0.011292677372694016, -0.00022366382472682744, 0.03213251382112503, 0.0012653429294005036, 0.015640826895833015, 0.007201036904007196, -0.005905976518988609, -0.020533278584480286, -0.025851158425211906, -0.0002565095783211291, -0.002122460165992379, 0.004864297341555357, 0.0028200410306453705, 0.00427620206028223, -0.05860930681228638, 0.006084281951189041, 0.0775284543633461, -0.023411190137267113, 0.020107846707105637, -0.024787582457065582, -0.029429780319333076, -0.026601918041706085, -0.009985104203224182, 0.0187439676374197, 0.01884406805038452, 0.019031759351491928, -0.0032689329236745834, -0.020358100533485413, 0.013726389966905117, 0.026176488026976585, 0.035986416041851044, -0.010460585355758667, -0.012018411420285702, 0.02169695496559143, 0.015390574000775814, 0.013851516880095005, -0.028078412637114525, 0.010735863819718361, 0.003753798548132181, 0.02511291205883026, -0.008083179593086243, -0.03601143881678581, 0.0066317105665802956, -0.0005094999214634299, 0.013351010158658028, -0.006246946286410093, 0.023210987448692322, -0.021872133016586304, 0.010773401707410812, -0.016491688787937164, -0.021721981465816498, -0.029329679906368256, 0.034484896808862686, 0.015365548431873322, 0.020132873207330704, 0.0038726688362658024, 0.01811833493411541, 0.009741107001900673, -0.0024806351866573095, -0.006494071334600449, 0.0032470356673002243, 0.028078412637114525, 0.02339867688715458, 0.027477804571390152, 0.010810939595103264, 0.005264702253043652, -0.02960495837032795, -0.004451379645615816, 0.008527378551661968, -0.01781802996993065, -0.002807528479024768, 0.012124769389629364, -0.004176100715994835, 0.028704045340418816, 0.016329023987054825, -0.02905440144240856, -0.020333075895905495, -0.018230948597192764, -0.0030437048990279436, 0.018030745908617973, 0.06306381523609161, -0.0067568374797701836, 0.00904039852321148, -0.0020692814141511917, -0.01601620763540268, -0.01755526475608349, -0.018005719408392906, 0.014226896688342094, -0.023936722427606583, 0.03606149181723595, 0.0061312043108046055, 0.004410713445395231, 0.001881591510027647, 0.008358458057045937, -0.020796043798327446, -0.00617187051102519, -0.015265447087585926, -0.03616159409284592, -0.009672287851572037, 0.01858130283653736, -0.027978312224149704, 0.015240422450006008, -0.0010182178812101483, 0.0008711940608918667, -0.00501444935798645, 0.03423464298248291, 0.011223857291042805, -0.013576238416135311, -0.004401328973472118, 0.03948996216058731, -0.01214353833347559, -0.02359887957572937, -0.007313650567084551, -0.002246022690087557, 0.004141691140830517, -0.002868527779355645, 0.020245486870408058, 0.01696716994047165, 0.0011120628332719207, -0.03188226372003555, -0.0002457564987707883, -0.01670440286397934, 0.0016469791298732162, -0.02044568955898285, -0.014865041710436344, -0.014840017072856426, 0.05470535531640053, 0.01417684555053711, -0.010679556988179684, -0.010704582557082176, -0.0024571740068495274, 0.05540606752038002, 0.011711851693689823, -0.03160698339343071, -0.014051719568669796, -0.001801823265850544, 0.021021271124482155, 0.0031719596590846777, 0.01965739205479622, -0.020195435732603073, -0.014414586126804352, -0.01749270036816597, -0.01168682612478733, -0.02284811995923519, -0.000339796970365569, 0.006675505079329014, -0.038413871079683304, -0.01124262623488903, 0.006343919318169355, 0.025613417848944664, 0.03951498493552208, 0.006856938824057579, 0.0005208395305089653, -0.040616098791360855, -0.008909014984965324, 0.004072871524840593, 0.014402073808014393, -0.016529226675629616, 0.011386522091925144, -0.02947983145713806, 0.006556634791195393, -0.013576238416135311, -0.003475391771644354, 0.011624262668192387, 0.010886015370488167, 0.006844426039606333, -0.021284038200974464, 0.002821605186909437, 0.017405113205313683, 0.023085860535502434, 0.01992015726864338, -0.028253590688109398, -0.00710719171911478, 0.0026980426628142595, -0.020520765334367752, 0.007807901129126549, -0.00429184315726161, 0.039039503782987595, -0.04024071991443634, 0.0183185376226902, 0.012362509965896606, -0.031131502240896225, -0.019119346514344215, -0.02885419875383377, 0.0006307163275778294, -0.006456533446907997, -0.021784543991088867, -0.015978669747710228, 0.042943455278873444, -0.020358100533485413, -0.02511291205883026, 0.0030530893709510565, 0.005477417726069689, 0.015428111888468266, -0.0331585519015789, 0.005646338686347008, -0.02254781685769558, -0.03616159409284592, 0.031456831842660904, 0.006368944887071848, -0.03173210844397545, -0.0036818506196141243, -0.01729249767959118, -0.006087409798055887, 0.020620865747332573, -0.015002681873738766, 0.026151463389396667, -0.006512840278446674, 0.015403086319565773, 0.026576893404126167, 0.03425966948270798, 0.03853899985551834, 0.02149675227701664, -0.0033502650912851095, -0.008214562200009823, 0.01211225613951683, -0.06501579284667969, -0.010316689498722553, 0.005837156902998686, -0.0017157987458631396, 0.014489661902189255, 0.012525174766778946, 0.03023059107363224, -0.018130846321582794, -0.0032376511953771114, 0.0231108870357275, -0.004107281100004911, -0.012756658717989922, -0.015703391283750534, -0.0062688435427844524, 0.005264702253043652, 0.03636179491877556, -0.010441816411912441, -0.004833015613257885, 0.018593816086649895, 0.019119346514344215, 0.05370434373617172, 0.007613954599946737, -0.019156884402036667, -0.03721265494823456, 0.01401418074965477, 0.038714174181222916, 0.011211344972252846, -0.013250908814370632, 0.005539981182664633, -0.006575403735041618, 0.003963385708630085, 0.0024008669424802065, 0.004751683212816715, -0.038188643753528595, 0.025650955736637115, 0.028904248028993607, -0.000044112020987086, 0.0257010068744421, -0.014039206318557262, 0.01230620313435793, -0.01490258052945137, -0.007501340936869383, -0.009966335259377956, 0.00269491458311677, -0.013163319788873196, 0.03811356797814369, 0.004197997972369194, 0.007914258167147636, -0.02363641746342182, -0.017542751505970955, -0.0222224872559309, 0.03858904913067818, -0.010441816411912441, -0.005048858933150768, -0.01985759474337101, -0.01155544351786375, 0.027427755296230316, -0.02842876687645912, -0.033659059554338455, 0.018718941137194633, 0.02770303376019001, 0.007920514792203903, 0.014026693999767303, -0.014852529391646385, 0.00508014066144824, -0.01745516248047352, -0.006587916519492865, 0.019744981080293655, -0.015841029584407806, -0.014339510351419449, -0.006475302390754223, -0.021484240889549255, -0.032808199524879456, 0.001090947655029595, 0.003497289028018713, 0.028603944927453995, -0.01824345998466015, 0.005674492102116346, 0.03521063178777695, 0.020720968022942543, 0.022197462618350983, 0.0012817657552659512, 0.007213549688458443, -0.015553238801658154, 0.008177024312317371, 0.0028575791511684656, -0.003085935255512595, 0.022310076281428337, -0.020933683961629868, 0.010354227386415005, 0.061562296003103256, 0.03558601066470146, 0.008946552872657776, -0.046722277998924255, 0.0023695852141827345, 0.013363522477447987, -0.002852886915206909, 0.02103378437459469, 0.011004885658621788, -0.01720491051673889, 0.01621641032397747, -0.026526842266321182, -0.024574868381023407, -0.013150807470083237, -0.0018237204058095813, 0.012575224973261356, -0.0183185376226902, 0.005377316381782293, -0.007182267960160971, -0.02392420917749405, 0.03466007485985756, 0.009603467769920826, -0.006053000222891569, 0.04171721264719963, 0.02386164665222168, 0.02937972918152809, -0.005317881237715483, 0.06586664915084839, 0.01763034053146839, 0.01644163765013218, 0.0013615339994430542, 0.0191693976521492, 0.03188226372003555, -0.002644863910973072, 0.02737770415842533, -0.006644223351031542, 0.0042355358600616455, 0.0046578384935855865, 0.03516057878732681, -0.00019199115922674537, 0.004714145325124264, -0.03390931338071823, -0.00864624883979559, 0.04201751947402954, 0.004567121621221304, -0.014126795344054699, -0.025325627997517586, 0.007144730072468519, -0.0066629922948777676, -0.019832568243145943, 0.006306381430476904, -0.01211225613951683, 0.047247812151908875, -0.026401715353131294, -0.03821367025375366, 0.017142346128821373, 0.015052732080221176, 0.00864624883979559, 0.0014897887594997883, -0.003982154652476311, 0.0067568374797701836, 0.021509265527129173, -0.020633378997445107, 0.012706607580184937, 0.04647202417254448, -0.015565751120448112, 0.014301972463726997, -0.005089525133371353, 0.012162307277321815, 0.013538699597120285, -0.026301614940166473, 0.007807901129126549, -0.006813144311308861, 0.010710838250815868, -0.013864029198884964, 0.012950604781508446, -0.025200501084327698, -0.01607877016067505, -0.029229577630758286, -0.01375141553580761, -0.0021334087941795588, 0.003960257396101952, -0.004904963541775942, 0.010610736906528473, -0.014627301134169102, -0.044920455664396286, -0.0030202437192201614, 0.021083835512399673, -0.002580736530944705, -0.0076264673843979836, 0.01230620313435793, 0.0036849789321422577, 0.05077638104557991, 0.003603646531701088, 0.029780134558677673, -0.01343859825283289, -0.0006287612486630678, 0.009841208346188068, -0.023999284952878952 ]
4.373694
7.95095
2024-07-01
0
2024A&A...687A..76D
[ "galaxy evolution", "SDSS galaxies", "SDSS datasets", "optical spectra", "narrow redshift bins", "galaxies", "datasets", "branches", "VIPERS data", "three main chronological galaxy branches" ]
[ "methods: data analysis", "methods: statistical", "techniques: spectroscopic", "galaxies: general", "galaxies: statistics", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
85
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202349026", "10.48550/arXiv.2404.09958" ]
[ "Dubois, J.", "Siudek, M.", "Fraix-Burnet, D.", "Moultaka, J." ]
[ "Univ. Grenoble Alpes, CNRS, IPAG, Grenoble, France", "Institute of Space Sciences (ICE, CSIC), Campus UAB, Carrerde Can Magrans, s/n, 08193, Barcelona, Spain", "Univ. Grenoble Alpes, CNRS, IPAG, Grenoble, France", "IRAP, Université de Toulouse, CNRS, CNES, UPS, 14, avenue Edouard Belin, 31400, Toulouse, France" ]
null
[ "1926ApJ....64..321H", "1959HDP....53..275D", "1961hag..book.....S", "1981PASP...93....5B", "1992ApJS...79..255K", "1999MNRAS.310..540A", "2003MNRAS.341...33K", "2006A&A...457..841I", "2008MNRAS.389.1791L", "2010ApJ...714..487S", "2011A&A...532A..74B", "2011ApJ...736..104J", "2012A&A...545A..80F", "2012MNRAS.420.1217D", "2013A&A...558A..67A", "2013MNRAS.428.1424M", "2014A&A...562A..23G", "2014A&A...566A.108G", "2014ApJ...780..100L", "2014ApJ...795..165S", "2015ApJS..221....8H", "2015FrASS...2....3F", "2016A&A...586A..23D", "2016A&A...590A.102M", "2016A&A...590A.103M", "2016ApJ...816...23S", "2016SPIE.9904E..0OR", "2017A&A...600A..54M", "2017A&A...605A...4H", "2017ApJ...836..164S", "2017arXiv170804058L", "2018A&A...609A..84S", "2018A&A...617A..70S", "2018ApJ...858...99S", "2018MNRAS.474.1873W", "2018arXiv180509905S", "2019A&A...630A..63F", "2021A&A...649A..53F", "2021MNRAS.503.3010T", "2022A&A...663A..21D", "2022A&A...666A.131S", "2022ApJ...931...51S", "2022arXiv221111792S", "2023A&A...669A..95L", "2023ApJ...947L..31S", "2023MNRAS.518..724S", "2023MNRAS.518.2794C", "2023MNRAS.523.4294S", "2023PASA...40....1H", "2024A&A...685A..48H" ]
29096765
2403.03242
The first high-redshift cavity power measurements of cool-core galaxy clusters with the International LOFAR Telescope
Radio-mode feedback associated with the active galactic nuclei (AGNs) at the cores of galaxy clusters injects a large amount of energy into the intracluster medium (ICM), offsetting radiative losses through X-ray emission. This mechanism prevents the ICM from rapidly cooling down and fueling extreme starburst activity as it accretes onto the central galaxies, and it is therefore a key ingredient in the evolution of galaxy clusters. However, the influence and mode of feedback at high redshifts (z ∼ 1) remains largely unknown. Low-frequency sub-arcsecond-resolution radio observations taken with the International LOFAR Telescope have demonstrated their ability to assist X-ray observations with constraining the energy output from the AGNs (or "cavity power") in galaxy clusters, thereby enabling research at higher redshifts than before. In this pilot project, we tested this hybrid method on a high-redshift (0.6 &lt; z &lt; 1.3) sample of 13 galaxy clusters for the first time with the aim of verifying the performance of this method at these redshifts and providing the first estimates of the cavity power associated with the central AGN for a sample of distant clusters. We were able to detect clear radio lobes in three out of 13 galaxy clusters at redshifts of 0.7 &lt; z &lt; 0.9, and we used these detections in combination with ICM pressures surrounding the radio lobes obtained from standard profiles to calculate the corresponding cavity powers of the AGNs. Combining our results with the literature, the current data appear to suggest that the average cavity power peaked at a redshift of z ∼ 0.4 and slowly decreases toward higher redshifts. However, we require more and tighter constraints on the cavity volume and a better understanding of our observational systematics to confirm any deviation of the cavity power trend from a constant level. <P />The reduced images are available at the CDS via anonymous ftp to <A href="https://cdsarc.cds.unistra.fr">cdsarc.cds.unistra.fr</A> (ftp://130.79.128.5) or via <A href="https://cdsarc.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/cat/J/A+A/687/A31">https://cdsarc.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/cat/J/A+A/687/A31</A>
[ 0.0013305220054462552, 0.05336940288543701, -0.001941633759997785, -0.006244170479476452, -0.011176384054124355, 0.060250986367464066, -0.007023918442428112, 0.007265268824994564, 0.0032180065754801035, 0.009400292299687862, -0.026536177843809128, -0.004288612864911556, -0.07163777947425842, -0.01985262520611286, 0.0063060554675757885, 0.0115476930513978, -0.004746559541672468, -0.003929681144654751, -0.019456563517451286, 0.04737895727157593, -0.030917616561055183, -0.02626388520002365, -0.011659085750579834, -0.025273729115724564, -0.08015311509370804, -0.020186802372336388, 0.008929967880249023, 0.02564503811299801, 0.035521842539310455, -0.02476627379655838, 0.0000036955586892872816, -0.021808182820677757, -0.020520981401205063, -0.010817453265190125, -0.07158827036619186, 0.049260254949331284, -0.02303350158035755, 0.006881583482027054, -0.02237752266228199, -0.031536463648080826, 0.006268924567848444, -0.02068188041448593, -0.014468653127551079, -0.009295088239014149, 0.007345718797296286, -0.04421046003699303, -0.02146162837743759, -0.06960795819759369, -0.023404808714985847, -0.013020549900829792, -0.026486670598387718, 0.03888837248086929, 0.0022990182042121887, -0.021152205765247345, -0.02883828990161419, -0.008273989893496037, 0.005974971689283848, 0.022959239780902863, -0.024159803986549377, 0.012457398697733879, -0.02148638293147087, 0.019790740683674812, 0.07064761966466904, -0.03272465243935585, -0.015582578256726265, -0.0007967660785652697, 0.002671873662620783, 0.016944043338298798, 0.04881468415260315, 0.05445857346057892, 0.015755854547023773, -0.027006501331925392, -0.018726322799921036, -0.0037780634593218565, 0.023776117712259293, -0.004981721751391888, -0.005371595732867718, -0.02148638293147087, -0.026536177843809128, -0.002193814143538475, -0.006535028573125601, 0.024308327585458755, 0.016473717987537384, -0.05203269049525261, 0.026486670598387718, 0.004434041678905487, -0.009257957339286804, 0.017228711396455765, -0.07827182114124298, 0.011751912534236908, 0.0035769380629062653, 0.013404235243797302, 0.013973575085401535, -0.039680495858192444, -0.023392433300614357, -0.017364859580993652, 0.03297219052910805, -0.023800872266292572, 0.0973818302154541, 0.05980541557073593, 0.03809624910354614, 0.04344308748841286, 0.02710551768541336, -0.08322259783744812, 0.04024983569979668, -0.014728568494319916, 0.004127712454646826, 0.013862182386219501, 0.026041099801659584, -0.03589314967393875, 0.029135337099432945, -0.002520256210118532, -0.02479102835059166, -0.0001464927918277681, -0.06876632571220398, -0.017241088673472404, -0.08168786019086838, -0.012723502703011036, -0.025149960070848465, 0.0477750226855278, -0.015137008391320705, 0.019617462530732155, 0.015483562834560871, 0.039507217705249786, 0.029877953231334686, -0.054112017154693604, 0.03755166009068489, -0.040373604744672775, -0.03725461661815643, 0.009443611837923527, 0.028565997257828712, -0.032303836196660995, 0.01483996119350195, 0.01761239767074585, -0.030645323917269707, -0.017921822145581245, 0.025162335485219955, -0.04888894781470299, -0.049903854727745056, -0.013948820531368256, 0.03495250269770622, 0.033987101167440414, 0.026041099801659584, 0.01985262520611286, 0.02246416173875332, 0.04213113337755203, -0.019704101607203484, -0.0038430425338447094, 0.02165965922176838, 0.008688617497682571, 0.00993250124156475, 0.003052464919164777, -0.02005065605044365, -0.04487881436944008, -0.005439668893814087, 0.010074836201965809, 0.01555782463401556, 0.01909763179719448, -0.014654306694865227, -0.037081338465213776, -0.02066950313746929, -0.006516463588923216, -0.07351907342672348, -0.01000676304101944, -0.008645298890769482, 0.010724625550210476, -0.02713027037680149, 0.007061048876494169, -0.06822174042463303, -0.0037873461842536926, -0.04406193643808365, -0.01993926428258419, -0.004149371758103371, -0.01825599931180477, -0.04532438516616821, 0.028565997257828712, 0.016919288784265518, -0.014258245006203651, 0.0107555678114295, 0.013453743420541286, -0.0023454318288713694, 0.03678429126739502, 0.027402563020586967, 0.016374703496694565, -0.04146277904510498, 0.02080564945936203, -0.02227850817143917, 0.021808182820677757, -0.018973862752318382, -0.009517873637378216, -0.015335039235651493, -0.0022232094779610634, 0.008973287418484688, 0.07114270329475403, -0.014988484792411327, -0.02812042646110058, -0.0015811551129445434, 0.03126417100429535, -0.01277301087975502, -0.019741233438253403, 0.013268088921904564, 0.026783715933561325, 0.054805126041173935, -0.0514385960996151, -0.010031516663730145, -0.032328590750694275, 0.016213802620768547, 0.01991450972855091, -0.007203383836895227, 0.0067640021443367004, 0.027823379263281822, -0.006708306260406971, 0.018107475712895393, -0.026214376091957092, -0.03450693190097809, -0.03252661973237991, -0.03822001814842224, 0.06282538920640945, 0.02802141197025776, 0.000019121418517897837, 0.0061822859570384026, 0.045274876058101654, 0.01278538815677166, 0.009183695539832115, 0.041957855224609375, -0.011782854795455933, 0.00015983667981345206, -0.05822116509079933, 0.060250986367464066, 0.011857116594910622, 0.04128950089216232, 0.050077132880687714, -0.014654306694865227, 0.005588192027062178, 0.02167203649878502, 0.01483996119350195, 0.03453168645501137, 0.0012407890753820539, 0.00009142503404291347, -0.035645611584186554, -0.0176742821931839, -0.006863018032163382, 0.01985262520611286, 0.008422513492405415, -0.026486670598387718, 0.00017124669102486223, -0.014951353892683983, -0.011677650734782219, 0.061142124235630035, -0.002761606592684984, 0.03532380983233452, 0.010241924785077572, -0.02392464131116867, -0.032427605241537094, 0.004369062837213278, 0.009016606956720352, -0.006073987577110529, 0.019345169886946678, -0.027650102972984314, 0.0004865687806159258, -0.008069770410656929, -0.05901328846812248, -0.0333930067718029, -0.006333903409540653, -0.0278481338173151, 0.011919001117348671, 0.02318202517926693, 0.012290310114622116, -0.06000344455242157, 0.0036573882680386305, -0.06233031302690506, -0.007054860703647137, 0.09941165149211884, -0.024394964799284935, -0.02407316491007805, 0.053171370178461075, 0.0337643139064312, 0.008137843571603298, 0.0206571277230978, -0.02787288837134838, -0.03698232024908066, -0.004177220165729523, 0.029778938740491867, 0.033244483172893524, -0.020384833216667175, -0.006086364388465881, -0.00516118761152029, 0.02477865107357502, 0.0433935821056366, -0.04703240469098091, 0.057924117892980576, -0.03208104893565178, 0.018949108198285103, 0.002235586289316416, -0.06762764602899551, -0.0206571277230978, 0.02799665741622448, -0.04225490242242813, -0.059458859264850616, 0.010217171162366867, 0.050671227276325226, 0.0013699735281988978, 0.03977951407432556, 0.001311182975769043, -0.010180040262639523, 0.015792986378073692, 0.06936042010784149, 0.02320677787065506, -0.009437423199415207, 0.03215531259775162, 0.013317596167325974, 0.03567036613821983, 0.017736166715621948, 0.01825599931180477, -0.057874612510204315, 0.0014751775888726115, 0.013404235243797302, 0.023479070514440536, 0.03262563794851303, -0.015780609101057053, -0.037229862064123154, -0.025397498160600662, -0.008187351748347282, -0.029803691431879997, -0.015260777436196804, -0.03591790422797203, 0.029976969584822655, -0.042056869715452194, -0.0016507755499333143, -0.03859132528305054, 0.03755166009068489, 0.035645611584186554, 0.06054803356528282, 0.006757813971489668, -0.001621380215510726, -0.021337859332561493, -0.007135310675948858, 0.04074491560459137, -0.05827067419886589, -0.020310573279857635, 0.00915894191712141, 0.012469775974750519, -0.026808470487594604, 0.018899600952863693, 0.010885526426136494, 0.042675718665122986, 0.020186802372336388, 0.0052014123648405075, 0.03596741333603859, 0.015594955533742905, 0.010990730486810207, 0.016622241586446762, 0.0366852767765522, 0.0054272920824587345, 0.057528056204319, -0.015656840056180954, 0.007537561468780041, -0.030892863869667053, -0.020322948694229126, 0.012024205178022385, -0.025372743606567383, -0.02547175996005535, 0.03029876947402954, 0.030991878360509872, 0.0041586547158658504, 0.014183983206748962, -0.006856829393655062, 0.025088073685765266, -0.029259106144309044, -0.04950779303908348, 0.025942083448171616, 0.0069929757155478, -0.031511709094047546, -0.022030968219041824, -0.07035057246685028, 0.008410136215388775, 0.04713141918182373, -0.004452607128769159, 0.015075122937560081, 0.02643716149032116, 0.061043109744787216, -0.026709454134106636, 0.017030680552124977, -0.05767657980322838, -0.027575841173529625, -0.028219442814588547, -0.030026476830244064, -0.026684701442718506, -0.09223301708698273, 0.018590176478028297, -0.052379246801137924, -0.0011711687548086047, 0.027056008577346802, -0.007327153347432613, -0.016176670789718628, 0.008174974471330643, 0.026981746777892113, 0.07208334654569626, 0.012748257257044315, 0.07163777947425842, 0.014852338470518589, -0.03252661973237991, -0.05059696361422539, -0.016374703496694565, -0.00616062618792057, -0.009425045922398567, -0.030100738629698753, 0.05515168234705925, 0.03995278850197792, -0.008354440331459045, 0.04653732478618622, -0.022897355258464813, 0.026932239532470703, -0.005192129872739315, 0.00600282009691, 0.030892863869667053, -0.04468078538775444, 0.0319325253367424, -0.04391341283917427, 0.021300727501511574, 0.011337284930050373, 0.005340653471648693, 0.027476824820041656, 0.02084278129041195, -0.010594667866826057, -0.0026486669667065144, 0.01160957757383585, 0.015669217333197594, 0.0247415192425251, -0.034902993589639664, 0.007624200079590082, 0.021783430129289627, -0.0063988822512328625, 0.015830116346478462, -0.024927174672484398, 0.03856657072901726, 0.02638765424489975, -0.028912551701068878, -0.009375538676977158, 0.0006768643506802619, 0.0001279273710679263, 0.015669217333197594, -0.04817108437418938, -0.04393816739320755, 0.030001722276210785, 0.012129409238696098, 0.03938344866037369, 0.005238543264567852, 0.017352482303977013, -0.0511910580098629, -0.006448389962315559, -0.03923492506146431, 0.01115163043141365, 0.02787288837134838, -0.05109204351902008, -0.01401070598512888, 0.0636175125837326, -0.018998615443706512, 0.010792698711156845, -0.047576989978551865, -0.002398033859208226, -0.0021149110980331898, -0.036338720470666885, 0.013787920586764812, -0.03849231079220772, 0.028095673769712448, -0.005334464833140373, 0.037229862064123154, -0.002246416173875332, 0.002634742995724082, 0.013478497043251991, -0.055646758526563644, -0.030991878360509872, 0.00416174903512001, 0.00994487851858139, -0.021783430129289627, -0.014146852307021618, -0.022773584350943565, 0.04817108437418938, -0.018565421923995018, 0.03576938062906265, -0.015322661958634853, 0.004830104298889637, 0.0006122721824795008, 0.03819526359438896, 0.009907747618854046, -0.009839674457907677, 0.03512578085064888, 0.01684502698481083, -0.01760002039372921, 0.004588753450661898, 0.006055422127246857, 0.0432698130607605, -0.012407890520989895, 0.019629839807748795, -0.011399169452488422, -0.026783715933561325, 0.036462489515542984, 0.010173851624131203, 0.025372743606567383, 0.03938344866037369, 0.008942345157265663, 0.01606527902185917, 0.011956132017076015, -0.020322948694229126, 0.014542913995683193, -0.04403718188405037, -0.006142060738056898, -0.01198707427829504, 0.018887223675847054, -0.008144032210111618, 0.026536177843809128, 0.008886649273335934, -0.01271112635731697, -0.008236858993768692, -0.0005650850362144411, -0.050002872943878174, 0.040373604744672775, 0.009641642682254314, -0.013763166964054108, 0.008051205426454544, -0.025917330756783485, 0.017971329391002655, 0.010545159690082073, 0.01595388725399971, 0.009876804426312447, -0.032501865178346634, -0.09817395359277725, -0.03995278850197792, 0.002627007197588682, -0.004922931082546711, -0.04383915290236473, -0.00011903143604286015, -0.012587356381118298, -0.017117319628596306, -0.024320702999830246, -0.02074376493692398, -0.001125528709962964, -0.015830116346478462, -0.01766190491616726, 0.015718724578619003, 0.018181737512350082, -0.04539864882826805, -0.009245580062270164, -0.0014295375440269709, 0.03678429126739502, -0.006980598904192448, -0.022055722773075104, 0.046636343002319336, 0.05032467097043991, 0.03690806031227112, -0.02162252925336361, 0.02564503811299801, 0.0013367104111239314, -0.0022000025492161512, -0.006126589607447386, 0.01084220688790083, -0.027773872017860413, 0.022179491817951202, -0.021449251100420952, -0.02231563813984394, -0.0006621667416766286, -0.025917330756783485, 0.0365615040063858, 0.00399775430560112, -0.058716244995594025, 0.00839775986969471, -0.024568242952227592, -0.0465620793402195, 0.009951066225767136, -0.020174425095319748, -0.019765986129641533, 0.007587069645524025, 0.0010512670269235969, 0.02406078763306141, 0.006720683071762323, -0.018973862752318382, 0.037205107510089874, 0.05203269049525261, -0.02471676655113697, 0.00009630813292460516, 0.00416484335437417, 0.010210982523858547, 0.03450693190097809, -0.016374703496694565, -0.028293704614043236, 0.011906624771654606, -0.006237981840968132, 0.017352482303977013, -0.0063988822512328625, 0.021139828488230705, -0.022785961627960205, 0.002263434464111924, -0.014802830293774605, -0.013961197808384895, 0.02153589017689228, 0.013948820531368256, 0.029184844344854355, 0.010161474347114563, -0.01084220688790083, 0.004471172578632832, 0.012141786515712738, -0.05510217323899269, -0.022934485226869583, -0.015458808280527592, 0.0223032608628273, -0.02549651451408863, -0.011343473568558693, -0.027600595727562904, 0.038789357990026474, 0.015842493623495102, -0.006055422127246857, -0.02084278129041195, -0.021102696657180786, -0.005931652616709471, -0.010687494650483131, 0.011894247494637966, -0.029754184186458588, 0.021931951865553856, 0.007865550927817822, -0.030868109315633774, 0.014654306694865227, -0.015669217333197594, -0.003129820805042982, 0.017302973195910454, 0.018602553755044937, -0.03175925090909004, -0.03299694508314133, 0.011095934547483921, -0.02162252925336361, 0.030100738629698753, -0.029976969584822655, 0.015137008391320705, -0.02477865107357502, -0.015582578256726265, 0.0030478236731141806, -0.008973287418484688, 0.040324099361896515, -0.02314489334821701, -0.01159720029681921, 0.040299344807863235, 0.042749978601932526, 0.04495307803153992, -0.05455758795142174, 0.021733921021223068, -0.015644462779164314, 0.04453226178884506, -0.020632373169064522, -0.006442201789468527, -0.004752748180180788, -0.009115622378885746, -0.0045516230165958405, 0.029259106144309044, 0.03913591057062149, 0.010241924785077572, 0.011646708473563194, 0.013800297863781452, 0.0036697653122246265, -0.007512807846069336, 0.029308613389730453, -0.02542225271463394, 0.008243047632277012, 0.02149876020848751, 0.006937279831618071, -0.016981173306703568, 0.0013382575707510114, -0.01835501380264759, 0.019790740683674812, -0.023602841421961784, 0.04807206615805626, 0.05589430034160614, -0.0072219492867589, 0.05614183843135834, 0.01674601063132286, -0.0238875113427639, 0.007246703375130892, 0.01678314246237278, 0.0047929733991622925, -0.0052261664532125, -0.011058803647756577, -0.014419144950807095, 0.013515627942979336, -0.006584536749869585, -0.030224507674574852, -0.011529127135872841, 0.021275974810123444, 0.02470438927412033, 0.02720453217625618, 0.014072590507566929, -0.0013312954688444734, -0.013008172623813152, 0.013862182386219501, -0.011046426370739937, 0.018602553755044937, -0.009196072816848755, -0.01314431894570589, -0.030175000429153442, -0.008886649273335934, -0.0029023943934589624, -0.022030968219041824, 0.04633929580450058, 0.01592913269996643, 0.039606235921382904, -0.023491447791457176, -0.0023531673941761255, 0.015260777436196804, -0.00837300531566143, -0.011591012589633465, 0.0008687070803716779, -0.026659946888685226, 0.0414380244910717, 0.02562028355896473, -0.0248034056276083, 0.012500718235969543, 0.005591286346316338, 0.002795643173158169, -0.0182807520031929, 0.015483562834560871, -0.029184844344854355, -0.03416037932038307, 0.015335039235651493, 0.004291706718504429, -0.02314489334821701, -0.0070796143263578415, 0.018837716430425644, -0.029778938740491867, -0.012971041724085808, -0.013057680800557137, -0.021127451211214066, -0.0011688480153679848, -0.02636289969086647, 0.0027739836368709803, 0.025236597284674644, -0.02646191604435444, -0.010607045143842697, 0.030051231384277344, -0.013651774264872074, -0.024283573031425476, -0.01156007032841444, 0.021065566688776016, 0.03500201180577278, -0.015112253837287426, 0.016919288784265518, 0.028169935569167137, 0.0063060554675757885, -0.005458234343677759, 0.0304720476269722, -0.0007658237009309232, -0.03183351084589958, 0.0030555592384189367, -0.010074836201965809, 0.009177506901323795, 0.025187090039253235, -0.018887223675847054, 0.015817740932106972, -0.0026038005016744137, 0.012735879980027676, -0.023305794224143028, 0.0013444459764286876, -0.0021752486936748028, 0.01283489540219307, 0.024432096630334854, -0.0027213816065341234, 0.0006486294441856444, -0.015186515636742115, 0.025867821648716927, -0.039556726813316345, -0.020162049680948257, 0.02397414855659008, -0.018800584599375725, -0.0034036608412861824, -0.022129984572529793, 0.015384547412395477, 0.010365694761276245, 0.013676527887582779, 0.006695928983390331, 0.015718724578619003, -0.028590751811861992, -0.023751365020871162, -0.013193827122449875, 0.039531972259283066, -0.022526046261191368, -0.021350236609578133, -0.022105230018496513, -0.006869206205010414, -0.007017729803919792, 0.01585487090051174, -0.012872026301920414, 0.0013034474104642868, -0.00032818253384903073, -0.0028714521322399378, 0.003521241946145892, 0.0032860797364264727, -0.005711961537599564, 0.009821108542382717, 0.04096769914031029, -0.0061822859570384026, -0.10000574588775635, -0.01475332211703062, 0.005705773364752531, 0.019741233438253403, -0.007308587897568941, 0.0348534882068634, 0.021053189411759377, 0.026041099801659584, 0.012500718235969543, 0.010699871927499771, 0.01198707427829504, -0.0286402590572834, -0.019543200731277466, 0.036462489515542984, -0.015099877491593361, -0.014134475030004978, -0.013639396987855434, 0.02963041514158249, 0.025818314403295517, 0.026214376091957092, -0.00883714109659195, -0.0024722954258322716, 0.009097057394683361, 0.014852338470518589, 0.03458119556307793, -0.02542225271463394, -0.034729719161987305, 0.013676527887582779, 0.03911115601658821, 0.0014620270812883973, 0.0095364386215806, 0.004434041678905487, 0.0010806623613461852, 0.07094466686248779, -0.012562602758407593, -0.02557077631354332, -0.003304645186290145, 0.02559552900493145, -0.026635192334651947, 0.019023369997739792, 0.007908870466053486, -0.011702404357492924, 0.016176670789718628, 0.03128892555832863, 0.04468078538775444, 0.010260490700602531, -0.008472021669149399, 0.040299344807863235, 0.018837716430425644, -0.010879337787628174, 0.032402850687503815, 0.021399743854999542, 0.007636577356606722, 0.019456563517451286, -0.0036357284989207983, 0.03515053540468216, 0.017327727749943733, -0.013453743420541286, 0.009697339497506618, -0.026214376091957092, -0.007871739566326141, 0.04304702579975128, 0.00039760945946909487, -0.033838577568531036, -0.015582578256726265, -0.005065266042947769, -0.05124056711792946, 0.0147780766710639, 0.016312818974256516, -0.05356743186712265, 0.011436300352215767, 0.020149672403931618, 0.0003999301407020539, 0.036264460533857346, 0.0011487355222925544, 0.008954722434282303, -0.008243047632277012, 0.004316460806876421, -0.01674601063132286, 0.008174974471330643, -0.00034887524088844657, -0.007642765529453754, 0.009759224019944668, -0.02958090603351593, 0.014307752251625061, 0.008199728094041348, 0.0005898389499634504, -0.004130806773900986, 0.004418570548295975, -0.01043995562940836, 0.010656552389264107, -0.030942371115088463, 0.03663576766848564, -0.0009019701392389834, 0.006043045315891504, 0.010650363750755787, 0.023058254271745682, -0.024295950308442116, -0.0049879103899002075, -0.00793981272727251, -0.021325482055544853, -0.00699916435405612, -0.01001295167952776, -0.039730004966259, 0.02638765424489975, -0.030175000429153442, -0.006825887132436037, 0.018949108198285103, 0.035422828048467636, 0.002950355177745223, 0.04557192325592041, 0.01750100590288639, -0.0040348852053284645, 0.02720453217625618, 0.026833225041627884, 0.010241924785077572, -0.039556726813316345, 0.0072776456363499165, -0.02084278129041195, -0.014072590507566929, 0.01837976835668087, 0.007902681827545166, -0.0572805181145668, -0.014406767673790455, 0.015396923758089542, -0.01597863994538784, 0.005405632313340902, -0.034729719161987305, -0.016622241586446762, 0.014976107515394688, -0.0021504948381334543, 0.0009692697785794735, 0.01752575859427452, -0.009480742737650871, -0.021969083696603775, -0.02950664423406124, -0.027575841173529625, 0.05584479123353958, -0.017822805792093277, 0.022686947137117386, -0.020384833216667175, 0.00399465998634696, 0.011064992286264896, -0.0011077368399128318, -0.03420988470315933, -0.010922657325863838, -0.016622241586446762, -0.02152351289987564, 0.024469226598739624, 0.01084220688790083, -0.026808470487594604, -0.0037161787040531635, 0.005436574574559927, 0.036412984132766724, 0.014864714816212654, 0.0087752565741539, 0.01606527902185917, 0.009381727315485477, 0.011646708473563194, 0.024419719353318214, 0.04393816739320755, 0.02710551768541336, -0.013131942600011826, -0.00439072260633111, 0.013701281510293484, 0.005139527842402458, -0.0232191551476717, -0.03032352402806282, -0.0026455726474523544, -0.012568791396915913, 0.01232744101434946, -0.02320677787065506, 0.02725404128432274, 0.015099877491593361, -0.015830116346478462, 0.022971617057919502, 0.032204821705818176, 0.006104929838329554, 0.007419980596750975, 0.006466955412179232, -0.003911115694791079, -0.004523774608969688, -0.009115622378885746, -0.014406767673790455, 0.009833485819399357, 0.026536177843809128, -0.0028451511170715094, -0.006448389962315559, 0.019506070762872696, 0.01586724817752838, 0.0018039402784779668, 0.026734208688139915, -0.007135310675948858, 0.044457998126745224, -0.006135872099548578, 0.04737895727157593, -0.04893845319747925, 0.045175861567258835, -0.0238875113427639, 0.008472021669149399, -0.04024983569979668, 0.006832075770944357, 0.012958665378391743, -0.025793559849262238, 0.022724077105522156, -0.013787920586764812, 0.000877989805303514, -0.028219442814588547, -0.041165731847286224, -0.010885526426136494, 0.0030354466289281845, -0.015322661958634853, 0.0008702541817910969, 0.018577799201011658, 0.04933451488614082, -0.01123826950788498, 0.014270621351897717, -0.007846985012292862, 0.001366879208944738, -0.01161576621234417, 0.040497373789548874, -0.06327096372842789, -0.03930918872356415, 0.05138909071683884, 0.012636864557862282, 0.05678543820977211, 0.02401128038764, -0.023021124303340912, -0.008230670355260372, 0.020261064171791077, 0.016968796029686928, -0.02083040401339531, -0.011442488990724087, -0.01206133607774973, -0.03445742279291153, -0.013280465267598629, -0.03277415782213211, -0.0019632934127002954, -0.025224221870303154, -0.0050343237817287445, 0.04802256077528, 0.014406767673790455, -0.00289001758210361, 0.008533906191587448, -0.029828445985913277, 0.012346005998551846, 0.02404841035604477, -0.020558111369609833, 0.016547979786992073, 0.0010172304464504123, -0.0032118181698024273, 0.001004853518679738, -0.0005109359044581652, 0.00798931997269392, -0.00578003516420722, 0.034803979098796844, -0.01684502698481083, 0.012463587336242199, 0.03118991106748581, 0.006801133044064045, -0.01847878471016884, -0.004579470958560705, -0.02626388520002365, -0.04878992959856987, 0.02720453217625618, 0.005554155446588993, -0.040398359298706055, 0.005371595732867718, 0.01672125793993473, -0.019456563517451286, 0.042700473219156265, -0.0278481338173151, 0.022922107949852943, -0.016337571665644646, -0.01847878471016884, 0.000021562964320764877, -0.010873149149119854, -0.021919576451182365, -0.013800297863781452, 0.011015484109520912, -0.03331874683499336, 0.004455701448023319, -0.019592709839344025, 0.007061048876494169, 0.00522307213395834, 0.021511135622859, -0.00516118761152029, -0.028962058946490288, 0.01436963677406311, -0.015669217333197594, -0.023342924192547798, 0.04792354628443718, 0.01747625134885311, 0.006129683926701546, 0.010984541848301888, -0.008150220848619938, 0.021263597533106804, 0.033269237726926804, 0.0006358657265082002, -0.011795232072472572, 0.005677924957126379, 0.007345718797296286, 0.01837976835668087, 0.013008172623813152, -0.033046454191207886, -0.01238932553678751, -0.015335039235651493, -0.020941797643899918, -0.01475332211703062, -0.003428414696827531, -0.014122097752988338, 0.0013506344985216856, -0.003552184207364917, -0.01071843784302473, 0.020632373169064522, -0.0418093316257, 0.021102696657180786, 0.012073713354766369, 0.00600591441616416, -0.027650102972984314, -0.018169360235333443, 0.005266391672194004, -0.011281588114798069, 0.02401128038764, -0.02564503811299801, -0.005696490406990051, -0.011312531307339668, 0.005745998118072748, 0.0000018825289771484677, 0.00839157123118639, 0.0030431821942329407, -0.013367104344069958, 0.008249236270785332, -0.011875682510435581, -0.009654019959270954, 0.0463145412504673, 0.0029735618736594915, 0.044408492743968964, 0.005826448556035757, 0.010613233782351017, -0.0006180738564580679, -0.0024939551949501038, -0.008168785832822323, 0.012086090631783009, 0.009245580062270164, 0.006757813971489668, 0.021832937374711037, -0.02804616466164589, -0.025372743606567383, -0.03203154355287552, 0.07426168769598007, -0.03210580348968506, 0.03027401678264141, -0.008911402896046638, 0.04225490242242813, 0.010347128845751286, 0.005495365243405104, -0.0006528840167447925, 0.005820259917527437, -0.01758764311671257, -0.004820821341127157, 0.004734182730317116, 0.01761239767074585, -0.0047682193107903, 0.020149672403931618, -0.0008068223251029849, -0.007754158228635788, 0.01829312928020954, 0.007543750107288361, 0.014468653127551079, -0.018107475712895393, 0.0022742643486708403, -0.01592913269996643, 0.01475332211703062, -0.00031058405875228345, -0.01768665947020054, 0.016956418752670288, -0.004335026256740093, -0.012909157201647758, 0.027402563020586967, -0.011584823951125145, 0.001381576876156032, -0.013639396987855434, 0.015458808280527592, -0.010866960510611534, -0.01747625134885311, -0.007760346867144108, 0.023788494989275932, 0.023578086867928505, 0.03346727043390274, 0.025818314403295517, -0.004653732758015394, 0.006241076160222292, -0.0224270299077034, -0.043492596596479416, 0.012655429542064667, -0.024506358429789543, 0.008601979352533817, -0.0062317936681210995, 0.00832968670874834, 0.006454578600823879, -0.04000229761004448, -0.0023918452206999063, -0.015446431934833527, 0.005749092437326908, 0.0030555592384189367, 0.014617175795137882, 0.03039778582751751, 0.007785100489854813, -0.009332219138741493, -0.007178630214184523, -0.022055722773075104, -0.04940877854824066, 0.005863579455763102, 0.026164868846535683, -0.02146162837743759, 0.015805363655090332, 0.020211556926369667, -0.00561604043468833, -0.012562602758407593, -0.04953254759311676, 0.020483849570155144, -0.004904365632683039, 0.01600339449942112, -0.02240227721631527, -0.02241465449333191, -0.042774733155965805, 0.017253465950489044, -0.005074549000710249, -0.0011425470001995564, -0.027773872017860413, 0.006479332689195871, -0.0005097755929455161, 0.03943295776844025, -0.033046454191207886, -0.018565421923995018, 0.02089228853583336, -0.02153589017689228, -0.03185826539993286, 0.04458176717162132, -0.010124343447387218, -0.024481603875756264, 0.01482758391648531, 0.027303548529744148, 0.015594955533742905, 0.0063988822512328625, 0.0009174413280561566, -0.01240170281380415, 0.015025615692138672, -0.0042793299071490765, 0.02393701858818531, 0.03977951407432556, -0.0044742668978869915, -0.013305219821631908, 0.02401128038764, 0.0057429042644798756, -0.016337571665644646, -0.029308613389730453, -0.007240514736622572, 0.030694833025336266, 0.0035552785266190767, -0.012649240903556347, 0.007673708256334066, 0.008583413437008858, -0.01601577177643776, 0.04549766331911087, 0.011696216650307178, -0.014703814871609211, -0.03361579030752182, -0.008478209376335144, 0.006708306260406971, 0.005414914805442095, 0.0025991592556238174, -0.019716478884220123, -0.022191869094967842, -0.04495307803153992, 0.02237752266228199, -0.010136720724403858, 0.006516463588923216, 0.027600595727562904, -0.0033572472166270018, -0.018033213913440704, 0.014109721407294273, -0.0054737054742872715, 0.025966838002204895, -0.0069867875427007675, -0.0159662626683712, -0.009004229679703712, 0.023751365020871162, 0.019629839807748795, 0.0039049272891134024, -0.00878144521266222, -0.037205107510089874, -0.04086868464946747, 0.04708191379904747, -0.022488916292786598, 0.005974971689283848, 0.016189048066735268, 0.011844739317893982, 0.0001928096462506801, -0.0034222262911498547, -0.004297895357012749, -0.010978353209793568, 0.03581888973712921, 0.006553594022989273, 0.016968796029686928, -0.037056583911180496, 0.020335325971245766, -0.015780609101057053, 0.00776653503999114, -0.023441940546035767, -0.007525184657424688, -0.007419980596750975, -0.004331931937485933, 0.004174125846475363, -0.01903574727475643, 0.0034160378854721785, 0.008917591534554958, -0.024159803986549377, 0.02404841035604477, 0.007494242396205664, -0.0206571277230978, 0.04329456761479378, -0.016448965296149254, -0.02143687568604946, -0.02489004284143448, 0.014629553072154522, 0.009245580062270164, -0.04076966643333435, 0.05574577674269676, -0.003255137475207448, -0.0509435199201107, 0.045274876058101654, 0.033863332122564316, 0.003518147626891732, -0.0039915656670928, -0.026956994086503983, 0.023763740435242653, 0.06465718150138855, -0.009455988183617592, -0.010050082579255104, 0.015743479132652283, 0.053220879286527634, 0.015273154713213444, 0.01918427087366581, 0.02651142328977585, 0.009524062275886536, -0.034086115658283234, -0.010260490700602531, 0.0013459931360557675, -0.030199754983186722, -0.03569512069225311, 0.014221114106476307, -0.023342924192547798, -0.012253179214894772, 0.02953139878809452, 0.04468078538775444, 0.010706060566008091, -0.020929420366883278, 0.008583413437008858, -0.003818288678303361, -0.046042248606681824, -0.006720683071762323, 0.021288352087140083, -0.028541242703795433, 0.0349772572517395, 0.01672125793993473, 0.0020360080525279045, -0.009839674457907677, 0.027650102972984314, 0.03819526359438896, -0.005260203033685684, 0.01043995562940836, 0.012958665378391743, 0.0011804514797404408, 0.01912238448858261, 0.018689192831516266, 0.01917189359664917, -0.003428414696827531, 0.017847560346126556, -0.013107188045978546, -0.03683380037546158, 0.022810716181993484, -0.002065403386950493, -0.012147975154221058, 0.00883095245808363, -0.018973862752318382, -0.01831788383424282, -0.029184844344854355, 0.00738284969702363, 0.0033015510998666286, -0.008354440331459045, 0.021795805543661118, -0.011250645853579044, 0.0034841110464185476, 0.023602841421961784, -0.004499020986258984, 0.0147780766710639, -0.03903689607977867, -0.022179491817951202, -0.030942371115088463, 0.05193367600440979, -0.0009476101258769631, -0.007642765529453754, -0.018602553755044937, -0.02479102835059166, -0.0020220838487148285, -0.051587119698524475, -0.019815495237708092, 0.019716478884220123, -0.012475963681936264, 0.011454866267740726, 0.013070057146251202, 0.02945713698863983, 0.008973287418484688, 0.006535028573125601, -0.030620571225881577, 0.028095673769712448, 0.002693533431738615, 0.004319555126130581, -0.02883828990161419, -0.013886936008930206, -0.024320702999830246, 0.003443885827437043, 0.015632085502147675, 0.032303836196660995, -0.013800297863781452, -0.03188301995396614, -0.009530249983072281, -0.02080564945936203, 0.013738412410020828, 0.006918714381754398, 0.016176670789718628, -0.0033324933610856533, -0.04799780622124672, 0.025843068957328796, -0.0027198344469070435, 0.023639971390366554, -0.012872026301920414, 0.02412267215549946, 0.018812961876392365, 0.02386275678873062, -0.02084278129041195, -0.004638261627405882, 0.0010582291288301349, -0.027056008577346802, -0.03252661973237991, 0.01206133607774973, 0.02172154374420643, -0.02552126720547676, 0.023528579622507095, 0.012655429542064667, -0.048369113355875015, 0.004217445384711027, 0.015446431934833527, 0.015693970024585724, -0.035521842539310455, 0.015446431934833527, 0.019431808963418007, -0.006405070889741182, 0.018132230266928673, 0.001816317206248641, 0.004443324636667967, 0.034878239035606384, 0.04084393009543419, 0.017711414024233818, -0.02149876020848751, 0.06455816328525543, -0.028442228212952614, 0.003948246594518423, -0.0055201188661158085, 0.0030354466289281845, -0.006757813971489668, 0.009468365460634232, 0.031684987246990204, 0.002560481196269393, 0.012067524716258049, 0.007327153347432613, 0.017934197559952736, 0.008998041972517967, 0.014406767673790455, -0.022637438029050827, 0.029160089790821075, 0.017030680552124977, -0.017909444868564606, 0.03695756942033768, 0.008193539455533028, 0.01591675542294979, -0.027749119326472282, -0.02238989993929863, 0.012723502703011036, -0.05341890826821327, 0.013020549900829792, 0.0034005665220320225, 0.011064992286264896, 0.01607765629887581, 0.0021164582576602697, 0.01071224920451641, -0.04475504532456398, 0.013057680800557137, 0.0055974749848246574, 0.005238543264567852, -0.018119852989912033, 0.03208104893565178, 0.043566860258579254, -0.007475676946341991, -0.014245867729187012, 0.000940648082178086, -0.010136720724403858, 0.0007577012875117362, -0.012748257257044315, -0.013478497043251991, 0.004310272168368101, 0.01993926428258419, -0.0008168785716407001, 0.013565135188400745, -0.00660929037258029, -0.01768665947020054, -0.016535602509975433, -0.008911402896046638, 0.006036856677383184, 0.01084220688790083, 0.00349958217702806, 0.02881353534758091, -0.017129696905612946, -0.03609118238091469, 0.0028915645089000463, 0.03896263241767883, 0.014295375905930996, -0.02148638293147087, 0.017810428515076637, 0.0006389599875546992, 0.011430111713707447, -0.021127451211214066, 0.013305219821631908, 0.0047898790799081326, -0.037922970950603485, 0.018986238166689873, -0.020619995892047882 ]
14.753763
5.810527
2024-07-01
0
2024A&A...687A..31T
[ "galaxy clusters", "high redshifts", "higher redshifts", "X-ray observations", "clear radio lobes", "distant clusters", "redshifts", "X-ray emission", "the average cavity power", "the corresponding cavity powers" ]
[ "methods: observational", "galaxies: active", "galaxies: clusters: general", "large-scale structure of Universe", "radio continuum: galaxies", "X-rays: galaxies: clusters", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
15
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202347974", "10.48550/arXiv.2403.03242" ]
[ "Timmerman, R.", "van Weeren, R. J.", "Botteon, A.", "Röttgering, H. J. A.", "Morabito, L. K.", "Sweijen, F." ]
[ "Leiden Observatory, Leiden University, PO Box 9513, 2300 RA, Leiden, The Netherlands; Centre for Extragalactic Astronomy, Department of Physics, Durham University, Durham, DH1 3LE, UK", "Leiden Observatory, Leiden University, PO Box 9513, 2300 RA, Leiden, The Netherlands", "INAF - Instituto di Radioastronomia, Via P. Gobetti 101, 40129, Bologna, Italy", "Leiden Observatory, Leiden University, PO Box 9513, 2300 RA, Leiden, The Netherlands", "Centre for Extragalactic Astronomy, Department of Physics, Durham University, Durham, DH1 3LE, UK; Institute for Computational Cosmology, Department of Physics, University of Durham, South Road, Durham, DH1 3LE, UK", "Leiden Observatory, Leiden University, PO Box 9513, 2300 RA, Leiden, The Netherlands" ]
null
[ "1987gady.book.....B", "1994ARA&A..32..277F", "1997AJ....114.1293H", "1999AJ....117.2608G", "2000ApJ...534L.135M", "2001ApJ...554..261C", "2002ApJ...568..163N", "2004A&A...417...13E", "2004ApJ...607..800B", "2006ApJ...652..216R", "2006MNRAS.365...11C", "2007ARA&A..45..117M", "2007ApJ...668....1N", "2008A&A...483...35S", "2008ApJ...680.1022H", "2009ApJ...693.1142S", "2009MNRAS.399..715J", "2010A&A...521A..64S", "2010MNRAS.406.1773M", "2011A&A...532A.133M", "2012ARA&A..50..455F", "2012AdAst2012E...6G", "2012MNRAS.421.1360H", "2013A&A...549A..11O", "2013A&A...556A...2V", "2013ApJ...765..117E", "2013ApJ...774...23M", "2013MNRAS.430..174H", "2013MNRAS.432..530R", "2014ApJ...794...67M", "2014MNRAS.444..606O", "2015ApJ...805...35H", "2015ApJS..216...27B", "2015MNRAS.447.3723P", "2015PASA...32....8O", "2016A&A...595A..86J", "2016ApJS..223....2V", "2016MNRAS.460.2385W", "2017A&A...598A..78I", "2017A&A...598A.104S", "2017MNRAS.471..301O", "2018A&A...612A..39R", "2018MNRAS.475..343W", "2019A&A...622A...1S", "2019A&A...622A...5D", "2019A&A...627A..23E", "2019AJ....157..168D", "2019ApJ...878...55B", "2020PASP..132c5001L", "2021A&A...651A.115V", "2021MNRAS.500.1003W", "2022A&A...658A...1M", "2022A&A...658A...2J", "2022A&A...658A...3S", "2022A&A...659A...1S", "2022A&A...668A..65T", "2022MNRAS.513.3946W" ]
29072444
2401.18036
Plasma lensing interpretation of FRB 20201124A bursts at the end of September 2021
When radio photons propagate through a non-uniform electron density volume, the plasma lensing effect can induce an extreme magnification to the observed flux at certain frequencies. Because the plasma lens acts as a diverging lens, it can extremely suppress the observed flux when aligned with the source. These two properties can theoretically cause a highly magnified fast radio burst (FRB) to become faint or even disappear for a period of time. In this paper, we interpret that the significant increase in burst counts followed by a sudden quenching in FRB 20201124A in September 2021 can be attributed to plasma lensing. Based on the one-dimensional Gaussian lens model, we search for double main-peak structures in the spectra just before its extinction on 2021 September 29. After the de-dispersion and de-scintillation procedures, we find eight bursts with double main-peaks at stable positions. There are three parameters in our modelling, the height N<SUB>0</SUB>, width a of the lens and its distance D<SUB>LS</SUB> to the source. We reformulate them as a combined parameter ${P}_0 \propto \left(\frac{a}{\mathrm{au}}\right)\sqrt{\frac{\mathrm{kpc}}{D_{\mathrm{LS}}} \frac{\mathrm{pc}\mathrm{cm}^{-3}}{N_0} }$. The frequency spectra can give an accurate estimation of P<SUB>0</SUB> corresponding to $\left(\frac{a}{\mathrm{au}}\right)\sqrt{\frac{\mathrm{kpc}}{D_{\mathrm{LS}}} \frac{\mathrm{pc}\mathrm{cm}^{-3}}{N_0} } \approx 28.118$, while the time of arrival only give a relatively loose constraint on a<SUP>2</SUP>/D<SUB>LS</SUB>. Comparing with the observation dynamic spectra, we suggest that for a plasma lens in host galaxy, e.g. D<SUB>LS</SUB> ≈ 1 kpc, the width of lens can not be larger than 40 au. At last, we estimate the relative transverse motion velocity between the lens and source, $v\approx 98\left(\frac{a}{\mathrm{au}}\right)\mathrm{km\,s^{-1}}$.
[ -0.0229626651853323, 0.01309496071189642, -0.01603003777563572, -0.017942486330866814, -0.03947081416845322, 0.029483582824468613, -0.02362670935690403, -0.00485416641458869, -0.00803494080901146, 0.011494613252580166, 0.012357871048152447, 0.06937938928604126, -0.02705317921936512, -0.015937071293592453, 0.02406497858464718, 0.046403441578149796, -0.054717279970645905, 0.002400521421805024, -0.04005517438054085, 0.005993003025650978, -0.03824897110462189, -0.014449612237513065, -0.025645405054092407, -0.012723095715045929, -0.06305768340826035, -0.037000566720962524, 0.01120243314653635, 0.0330694243311882, 0.021993158385157585, 0.0073775360360741615, 0.028872661292552948, -0.036442771553993225, -0.01195280347019434, -0.03615058958530426, -0.06528887152671814, 0.04111764580011368, 0.010252849198877811, 0.004767840728163719, -0.023400934413075447, 0.004180161282420158, -0.00217640632763505, -0.03710681572556496, -0.042711351066827774, -0.007948614656925201, 0.023254843428730965, 0.00026582536520436406, -0.0043494924902915955, -0.011866478249430656, 0.0012990373652428389, -0.004409256391227245, -0.03870052099227905, 0.01968228444457054, -0.06667008250951767, 0.021448642015457153, -0.0019589317962527275, 0.010863770730793476, 0.025486033409833908, 0.02260407991707325, -0.019815092906355858, -0.017344847321510315, 0.023215001448988914, 0.0029450380243360996, 0.01370588131248951, -0.0063183847814798355, -0.010777444578707218, 0.04063953459262848, 0.007470502518117428, 0.026946932077407837, 0.009243501350283623, 0.04470348730683327, 0.004920571111142635, -0.0017680189339444041, -0.016242532059550285, -0.0350615568459034, 0.03336160257458687, 0.03601778298616409, 0.04244573414325714, 0.024875113740563393, -0.019283857196569443, -0.019748687744140625, 0.03206007555127144, -0.01591050997376442, -0.038328658789396286, -0.003632324282079935, -0.03221944719552994, 0.01901823841035366, 0.016481587663292885, 0.033733468502759933, -0.03588497266173363, -0.026442257687449455, 0.034981872886419296, -0.012689893133938313, -0.015365993604063988, -0.013573072850704193, -0.03269755840301514, -0.0016642619157209992, 0.04016141965985298, -0.026601629331707954, 0.04212699458003044, 0.028261739760637283, 0.04372069984674454, 0.028208617120981216, -0.0006258620996959507, -0.08908823132514954, 0.05344231426715851, -0.0021166424266994, -0.012490680441260338, -0.02583133801817894, 0.03240538015961647, -0.01183327566832304, 0.08653829991817474, -0.006740053184330463, -0.034105334430933, 0.04836901277303696, -0.06327017396688461, -0.0169331394135952, -0.04621750861406326, 0.007756041828542948, 0.008519693277776241, 0.03830209746956825, -0.016999542713165283, 0.05426573008298874, 0.015698015689849854, 0.02075803652405739, 0.05992339178919792, -0.04897993430495262, 0.015073813498020172, -0.011819995008409023, -0.02622976340353489, -0.03838178142905235, 0.04789090156555176, -0.022338462993502617, 0.014662106521427631, -0.04563314840197563, -0.03200695291161537, -0.014675387181341648, 0.024582933634519577, -0.02741176262497902, 0.013506668619811535, 0.015180060639977455, -0.01083056814968586, 0.03761148825287819, 0.049989283084869385, 0.010319254361093044, 0.005063340533524752, 0.04658937454223633, -0.0168136116117239, -0.0025300101842731237, 0.02953670732676983, -0.016999542713165283, -0.02528681978583336, -0.027000056579709053, -0.0018493643729016185, -0.03564591705799103, 0.009256782941520214, -0.044756609946489334, 0.05075957253575325, 0.02378607913851738, -0.004900649655610323, -0.020505698397755623, -0.010186444967985153, 0.041409824043512344, -0.04587220400571823, -0.009934107773005962, 0.027278954163193703, 0.02197987772524357, -0.02284313552081585, -0.0223251823335886, -0.07139807939529419, -0.04287072271108627, -0.04980335012078285, -0.0033086026087403297, -0.0230423491448164, -0.0342647060751915, 0.01547224074602127, 0.04194106161594391, -0.015883948653936386, -0.03397252410650253, 0.003967666998505592, 0.0020552182104438543, -0.029244527220726013, 0.00883843470364809, 0.0032338974997401237, 0.021674416959285736, -0.0017198756104335189, 0.020213520154356956, -0.0023457377683371305, 0.02583133801817894, 0.01234459038823843, -0.028049245476722717, 0.011793432757258415, 0.03126322105526924, 0.003305282210931182, 0.03320223465561867, -0.024503247812390327, -0.022511113435029984, 0.007603311445564032, -0.008273996412754059, 0.010173164308071136, -0.0164151843637228, -0.0033982484601438046, 0.022139249369502068, 0.032777246087789536, -0.028049245476722717, 0.0057705482468008995, -0.029005471616983414, 0.045580025762319565, 0.005458447150886059, -0.024782147258520126, 0.02677427977323532, 0.06204833462834358, 0.04927211254835129, 0.04897993430495262, -0.033016301691532135, -0.006826378870755434, -0.022139249369502068, -0.01791592501103878, 0.04287072271108627, -0.009336467832326889, -0.037983354181051254, -0.01819482445716858, 0.021886911243200302, 0.009363030083477497, 0.02413138374686241, 0.00801501888781786, 0.024556372314691544, 0.055036019533872604, 0.02452980913221836, 0.028288302943110466, 0.03723962604999542, 0.0032289172522723675, 0.016547992825508118, 0.003705369308590889, -0.037159938365221024, 0.025977427139878273, -0.016667520627379417, -0.010970017872750759, 0.014595701359212399, 0.01159422006458044, -0.06412015110254288, -0.029085155576467514, 0.029005471616983414, -0.00041108514415100217, -0.020851003006100655, -0.0034629928413778543, 0.015060532838106155, -0.020027587190270424, -0.016441745683550835, 0.018911991268396378, -0.007762682158499956, 0.06406702846288681, -0.02306891232728958, -0.029032032936811447, -0.03899270296096802, -0.0161761287599802, 0.025499314069747925, -0.010558309964835644, 0.02945702150464058, -0.05256577581167221, -0.010213007219135761, -0.005564694292843342, -0.021833788603544235, -0.032511625438928604, 0.016547992825508118, 0.0005312357097864151, -0.00909741222858429, 0.018513565883040428, -0.020386170595884323, -0.02775706723332405, -0.0029699397273361683, -0.011062984354794025, -0.011169231496751308, 0.006056087091565132, -0.025605561211705208, -0.05524851381778717, 0.04287072271108627, 0.036920882761478424, -0.00512974476441741, 0.05264545977115631, -0.01195280347019434, 0.0044690207578241825, 0.0010043676011264324, 0.013234410434961319, -0.039284881204366684, -0.026880526915192604, -0.040692657232284546, 0.024436842650175095, -0.002890254370868206, -0.02418450638651848, -0.017942486330866814, 0.024091539904475212, -0.02178066410124302, -0.0013978140195831656, 0.023321248590946198, -0.006159014068543911, -0.020213520154356956, 0.04919242858886719, 0.03524748980998993, -0.04454411566257477, 0.004894009325653315, 0.018579969182610512, -0.012417634949088097, 0.04029422998428345, 0.023201720789074898, -0.038727086037397385, 0.04815651848912239, 0.027863314375281334, 0.03811616450548172, -0.011939522810280323, 0.05753282830119133, 0.025857899338006973, 0.0032322374172508717, -0.01865965500473976, -0.047864340245723724, -0.07129183411598206, 0.017783116549253464, 0.01321448851376772, 0.004933851771056652, 0.026136796921491623, -0.04743935167789459, 0.028580481186509132, -0.03421157971024513, 0.0083271199837327, -0.028766414150595665, -0.014808195643126965, -0.02288297936320305, 0.021249428391456604, 0.0037120096385478973, -0.008672423660755157, 0.00025959996855817735, 0.021913474425673485, 0.02725239284336567, 0.009615366347134113, -0.02921796590089798, -0.02346733771264553, -0.03551310673356056, 0.03944425284862518, 0.014449612237513065, -0.000847902032546699, -0.040692657232284546, -0.008187670260667801, 0.014489454217255116, -0.018088577315211296, 0.015458960086107254, -0.010385658591985703, 0.03190070390701294, 0.043455082923173904, -0.008698984980583191, 0.0653419941663742, 0.01603003777563572, -0.014011342078447342, 0.010120040737092495, 0.03649589419364929, 0.005820351652801037, 0.04773152992129326, -0.035778727382421494, 0.06608572602272034, -0.027079740539193153, -0.029271088540554047, -0.03269755840301514, -0.0027674061711877584, -0.013931657187640667, 0.03556623309850693, -0.03004137985408306, -0.07697605341672897, -0.014887881465256214, -0.015273027122020721, 0.010066917166113853, -0.060029637068510056, -0.022218935191631317, 0.01634877920150757, 0.016880014911293983, 0.008712265640497208, 0.028182055801153183, -0.038966141641139984, -0.002676100004464388, 0.032591313123703, -0.018526846542954445, -0.01685345359146595, 0.0073576150462031364, 0.03997548669576645, -0.028846099972724915, -0.01854012720286846, -0.02260407991707325, -0.020731473341584206, 0.014595701359212399, 0.016056599095463753, -0.01649487018585205, -0.07575421780347824, -0.01835419423878193, -0.03803647682070732, -0.014051184989511967, 0.022537676617503166, -0.021568169817328453, 0.012211780995130539, 0.013692600652575493, 0.03899270296096802, 0.09190378338098526, 0.030492931604385376, 0.03617715463042259, -0.03184758126735687, 0.003917863592505455, -0.010936815291643143, -0.021196305751800537, 0.00016725625027902424, 0.010989938862621784, -0.01460898295044899, 0.029324213042855263, 0.032750681042671204, 0.03166164830327034, 0.026628190651535988, -0.028022684156894684, 0.034158457070589066, -0.024503247812390327, 0.05410635843873024, 0.06358891725540161, -0.017902644351124763, 0.022617360576987267, -0.03320223465561867, 0.060029637068510056, 0.0449691042304039, -0.04196762293577194, -0.005103182978928089, 0.012384433299303055, -0.056629728525877, -0.0032538187224417925, 0.005687542725354433, 0.0055779749527573586, 0.051131438463926315, -0.009980591014027596, 0.008918119594454765, -0.01823466643691063, 0.02480870857834816, -0.01819482445716858, -0.010066917166113853, 0.006959187798202038, -0.00010546897101448849, -0.007656435016542673, -0.027518009766936302, -0.011919601820409298, 0.01606988161802292, 0.02024008147418499, -0.018487002700567245, -0.024357158690690994, 0.027942998334765434, 0.012756298296153545, 0.04844869673252106, 0.031210098415613174, 0.05360168591141701, -0.009548962116241455, -0.012231702916324139, 0.030466368421912193, 0.010106760077178478, -0.03043980710208416, -0.03997548669576645, -0.0007889680564403534, 0.013453545048832893, 0.00041855566087178886, 0.029828885570168495, -0.034158457070589066, 0.0005536472308449447, -0.04265822842717171, -0.02977576293051243, -0.03245850279927254, -0.021900193765759468, 0.023440776392817497, 0.03976299241185188, 0.013513308949768543, -0.024397000670433044, 0.059285908937454224, 0.005548093002289534, -0.020890844985842705, 0.04356132820248604, 0.02500792220234871, 0.0036356444470584393, -0.0024835269432514906, -0.025154011324048042, 0.023480618372559547, 0.061092108488082886, 0.038408342748880386, 0.005040098913013935, -0.0025930944830179214, -0.0014052845072001219, -0.006647087167948484, -0.018965115770697594, 0.027199268341064453, 0.04268478974699974, 0.02342749573290348, -0.05134393274784088, -0.020665070042014122, -0.0337069071829319, -0.018925271928310394, 0.008366962894797325, -0.01472851075232029, 0.023918889462947845, 0.006145733408629894, -0.050547078251838684, -0.017105789855122566, 0.007941974326968193, 0.0053654806688427925, 0.06667008250951767, 0.004359452985227108, 0.04308321699500084, -0.021913474425673485, -0.014927724376320839, 0.03731931000947952, -0.027969561517238617, 0.026256326586008072, -0.044836293905973434, 0.01583082415163517, 0.04055984690785408, 0.021727541461586952, -0.002858712337911129, 0.014250398613512516, -0.011182512156665325, 0.021116619929671288, -0.035619355738162994, 0.03216632455587387, -0.007131839636713266, 0.018672935664653778, 0.04812995716929436, -0.021076777949929237, -0.0017945807194337249, 0.02433059550821781, -0.003522756975144148, -0.003130970522761345, -0.04082546383142471, -0.06959187984466553, -0.02551259659230709, -0.0458456426858902, 0.01925729587674141, -0.007311131805181503, -0.042817600071430206, 0.03445063531398773, -0.028686728328466415, -0.021488485857844353, -0.013573072850704193, 0.01159422006458044, -0.025300102308392525, 0.025326663628220558, 0.018301071599125862, 0.013599634170532227, -0.047784652560949326, -0.019390104338526726, 0.026641471311450005, 0.0030180830508470535, 0.03710681572556496, -0.0342647060751915, 0.02929764986038208, 0.015033971518278122, 0.0115211745724082, 0.00766971567645669, -0.009289984591305256, 0.024981360882520676, 0.012019208632409573, 0.02889922447502613, -0.01148133259266615, 0.017610464245080948, 0.00789549108594656, -0.006886143237352371, -0.011136028915643692, 0.008513052947819233, -0.005803750362247229, 0.016003476455807686, -0.006690249778330326, -0.055461008101701736, 0.020067429170012474, -0.035141244530677795, 0.0008288107346743345, 0.0035758805461227894, -0.04953773319721222, -0.015764420852065086, -0.006457834504544735, 0.017065947875380516, 0.031130414456129074, -0.001516512013040483, -0.025419630110263824, 0.003708689473569393, -0.0045321048237383366, -0.05131737142801285, -0.017384689301252365, -0.01077080424875021, -0.015897229313850403, 0.05779844895005226, -0.03142259269952774, 0.006208817474544048, -0.006570721976459026, -0.002745824633166194, -0.02873985283076763, -0.017198756337165833, 0.01709250919520855, -0.028766414150595665, 0.0069193453527987, 0.039630185812711716, 0.011879758909344673, 0.012364511378109455, 0.021554889157414436, 0.00044698506826534867, -0.011999286711215973, -0.028447672724723816, -0.000092706861323677, -0.03503499552607536, -0.034105334430933, -0.008273996412754059, 0.012298107147216797, 0.0026362573262304068, 0.026588348671793938, 0.012889106757938862, 0.0018145020585507154, -0.011673904955387115, -0.001872605993412435, 0.015352712944149971, -0.03176789730787277, -0.014887881465256214, -0.022936102002859116, 0.005189509131014347, 0.006670328788459301, -0.024795427918434143, 0.03102416731417179, 0.0007138479850254953, -0.04279103875160217, -0.016043318435549736, 0.016043318435549736, 0.00338164740242064, 0.05631098523736, 0.025685247033834457, -0.032272569835186005, -0.016760487109422684, 0.01905808225274086, 0.005883435718715191, 0.02839455008506775, -0.04882056266069412, 0.027000056579709053, 0.007297850679606199, 0.005305716767907143, 0.025578999891877174, -0.0013571413001045585, 0.05118456110358238, -0.03511468321084976, -0.0460846982896328, 0.028527358546853065, -0.01626909337937832, 0.01831435225903988, -0.0350615568459034, -0.008001738227903843, -0.009641928598284721, -0.025725090876221657, -0.011468051001429558, -0.01737140864133835, -0.022033002227544785, -0.008473210036754608, 0.01933697983622551, 0.015206622891128063, 0.04350820556282997, 0.01992134004831314, -0.011043062433600426, 0.020133834332227707, -0.016322217881679535, -0.01614956557750702, -0.008420086465775967, 0.019947901368141174, 0.018752621486783028, -0.027464887127280235, 0.0003108559176325798, 0.0019257295643910766, -0.001982173416763544, 0.03102416731417179, 0.009489198215305805, 0.002360678743571043, 0.014701948501169682, 0.07681668549776077, -0.030147626996040344, 0.0008649181690998375, 0.032591313123703, -0.00988762453198433, -0.011873118579387665, 0.0038647400215268135, 0.009934107773005962, -0.0016127984272316098, 0.024556372314691544, -0.01861981302499771, 0.003980947658419609, -0.006866221781820059, -0.030067943036556244, -0.013759004883468151, 0.014064465649425983, -0.029855448752641678, 0.0032123159617185593, -0.026216482743620872, 0.026243044063448906, -0.014927724376320839, 0.0138386907055974, 0.029988257214426994, -0.0014335063751786947, 0.012928949669003487, -0.009914186783134937, 0.0010616413783282042, -0.015658173710107803, 0.006354907527565956, -0.03020075149834156, 0.02980232425034046, 0.01673392578959465, 0.00766971567645669, -0.016747206449508667, 0.0044690207578241825, -0.030014818534255028, -0.024144664406776428, -0.007643153890967369, 0.03925831988453865, -0.0460050143301487, 0.038567714393138885, 0.027225831523537636, 0.035778727382421494, -0.0036190433893352747, 0.003097768407315016, -0.009867703542113304, 0.011819995008409023, 0.006165654864162207, -0.018101857975125313, -0.008081423118710518, 0.00932982750236988, -0.017065947875380516, -0.0056211380288004875, -0.009170456789433956, 0.02863360568881035, -0.043694138526916504, 0.030306998640298843, 0.013825410045683384, -0.005252593196928501, 0.02988201007246971, 0.026017269119620323, -0.02086428366601467, 0.04438474401831627, -0.019124485552310944, -0.003702048910781741, 0.0009197018807753921, 0.05785157158970833, 0.011368444189429283, -0.03128978610038757, 0.026588348671793938, 0.004127037711441517, -0.018805744126439095, 0.009402872063219547, 0.018247947096824646, 0.02298922650516033, 0.006451193708926439, 0.024636056274175644, -0.0005196149577386677, -0.0037551724817603827, -0.0039045826997607946, -0.02815549261868, 0.01177351176738739, 0.030147626996040344, -0.007968535646796227, 0.047944024205207825, -0.03134290874004364, 0.04071921855211258, 0.0053023966029286385, 0.013108241371810436, 0.013998061418533325, 0.010611433535814285, -0.006278542336076498, 0.008864996023476124, 0.014330083504319191, -0.017384689301252365, 0.034078773111104965, -0.043216027319431305, 0.013001994229853153, 0.005923278164118528, -0.043800387531518936, 0.009608726017177105, 0.020386170595884323, -0.032936614006757736, 0.01228482648730278, 0.06300456076860428, -0.014821477234363556, -0.03405221179127693, 0.01783623918890953, -0.004316290374845266, -0.014051184989511967, -0.025220416486263275, -0.033733468502759933, -0.009163816459476948, -0.034795939922332764, -0.03139603137969971, 0.028102369979023933, 0.025379786267876625, -0.02196659706532955, -0.029085155576467514, 0.006195536814630032, 0.01669408194720745, -0.03059917874634266, 0.0161761287599802, -0.011587579734623432, -0.007829086855053902, 0.03697400540113449, 0.01452929712831974, -0.11304695904254913, 0.01403790432959795, 0.007975175976753235, 0.049165867269039154, -0.025645405054092407, 0.000808889395557344, 0.02653522416949272, 0.052911076694726944, 0.0011371765285730362, -0.006281862501055002, 0.07373552024364471, 0.007350974250584841, -0.002393881091848016, 0.02551259659230709, -0.024994641542434692, 0.0011903000995516777, -0.00513970572501421, 0.03572560101747513, 0.0074638621881604195, -0.00007039910997264087, 0.0026229764334857464, 0.03229913115501404, -0.017849519848823547, 0.02607039362192154, 0.009090770967304707, 0.03296317532658577, -0.06342954933643341, -0.0050600203685462475, 0.0057572671212255955, 0.01819482445716858, 0.016547992825508118, 0.01163406204432249, -0.002923456719145179, 0.047625284641981125, 0.013579713180661201, -0.012231702916324139, -0.003200695151463151, 0.011866478249430656, 0.009615366347134113, -0.011062984354794025, 0.0035725601483136415, -0.024463405832648277, 0.014741791412234306, -0.01157429814338684, 0.055620379745960236, 0.00996067002415657, -0.026203202083706856, 0.011979365721344948, 0.03681463748216629, -0.01214537676423788, -0.03213976323604584, -0.0040938351303339005, -0.01013996172696352, 0.0171721950173378, -0.019469790160655975, 0.03891301527619362, -0.0038580994587391615, 0.033574096858501434, 0.03992236405611038, -0.031210098415613174, -0.019084643572568893, 0.0448097325861454, 0.015246465802192688, -0.03256475180387497, -0.03638964891433716, -0.009402872063219547, -0.04180825129151344, -0.009130613878369331, -0.015352712944149971, -0.05434541404247284, 0.014794914983212948, 0.0049537732265889645, 0.008944681845605373, 0.025897741317749023, -0.008446647785604, 0.018088577315211296, 0.002936737611889839, -0.006759974639862776, -0.025698527693748474, 0.008825153112411499, 0.016959700733423233, -0.022072844207286835, -0.017344847321510315, -0.03312254697084427, -0.009303265251219273, 0.03139603137969971, 0.025897741317749023, 0.00046400120481848717, -0.013148084282875061, 0.00990090612322092, 0.0038879814092069864, -0.021727541461586952, 0.002961639082059264, 0.0138386907055974, -0.0016883335774764419, 0.003592481603845954, -0.022776732221245766, 0.01661439798772335, -0.0003706199349835515, -0.0036190433893352747, 0.01021964754909277, -0.02823517844080925, -0.03221944719552994, -0.031874142587184906, 0.01303519681096077, -0.020133834332227707, 0.024264192208647728, 0.006481075659394264, 0.01771671138703823, 0.0029417178593575954, 0.05362824723124504, 0.03793023154139519, 0.03947081416845322, 0.08951321989297867, 0.026216482743620872, -0.001832763315178454, -0.01634877920150757, 0.021634574979543686, -0.003944425377994776, 0.01315472461283207, 0.0022278698161244392, -0.012470758520066738, -0.024264192208647728, -0.040586408227682114, 0.014874600805342197, -0.01366603933274746, 0.010545029304921627, 0.019828373566269875, -0.019469790160655975, 0.011846556328237057, -0.006846300326287746, 0.020731473341584206, -0.008333760313689709, -0.0034995153546333313, 0.03824897110462189, -0.02587117999792099, -0.0021979878656566143, 0.03445063531398773, 0.03548654541373253, 0.024317314848303795, -0.014741791412234306, 0.008552894927561283, 0.05001584440469742, 0.023693112656474113, -0.007065434940159321, 0.017079228535294533, -0.007145120296627283, -0.01791592501103878, -0.008964602835476398, 0.008393524214625359, 0.004887368530035019, -0.00233245687559247, -0.009907546453177929, 0.022869698703289032, 0.012922309339046478, -0.00579711003229022, 0.010372377932071686, 0.012663331814110279, -0.041330140084028244, 0.038966141641139984, 0.043534766882658005, 0.013732443563640118, 0.006610564421862364, 0.013420342467725277, 0.029111718758940697, 0.010970017872750759, -0.034795939922332764, -0.02642897702753544, -0.04430506005883217, -0.010385658591985703, -0.0056211380288004875, -0.04310977831482887, 0.03763804957270622, 0.01595035195350647, -0.03099760413169861, -0.018287789076566696, -0.021767383441329002, 0.0073775360360741615, 0.005929918959736824, -0.0023490579333156347, -0.007756041828542948, -0.00783572718501091, 0.013134803622961044, -0.005265874322503805, 0.018128419294953346, 0.0032222766894847155, -0.011335242539644241, 0.013772286474704742, 0.01909792423248291, -0.014914442785084248, 0.005249273031949997, 0.04008173570036888, 0.025419630110263824, 0.023334529250860214, 0.0279164370149374, 0.04196762293577194, -0.03572560101747513, 0.022258777171373367, -0.04826276749372482, -0.007238086778670549, 0.007868928834795952, 0.015193342231214046, -0.02318844012916088, -0.013732443563640118, -0.03615058958530426, -0.023082192987203598, 0.014502735808491707, -0.02354702353477478, -0.012537162750959396, -0.016826892271637917, -0.009104052558541298, -0.01949635148048401, 0.00703887315467, 0.0018443840090185404, 0.040187980979681015, -0.05248608812689781, 0.04844869673252106, 0.019908059388399124, -0.04823620244860649, -0.025260258466005325, 0.00990090612322092, -0.045500341802835464, -0.013745724223554134, 0.0448097325861454, 0.0007624062709510326, -0.004708076827228069, -0.008353682234883308, -0.036920882761478424, -0.011242276057600975, 0.0036954085808247328, 0.03429126739501953, -0.018765902146697044, 0.012191860005259514, -0.011501253582537174, -0.032511625438928604, 0.013878533616662025, -0.028208617120981216, -0.008320479653775692, -0.008566176518797874, 0.015737857669591904, -0.020665070042014122, -0.004727997817099094, 0.014635544270277023, -0.02524697780609131, -0.017982330173254013, -0.012337950058281422, -0.003980947658419609, 0.020611945539712906, 0.008028299547731876, 0.011667264625430107, 0.004996935836970806, -0.002923456719145179, -0.02622976340353489, -0.009661849588155746, 0.005342239048331976, -0.00807478278875351, -0.01460898295044899, 0.024144664406776428, 0.022617360576987267, -0.021050214767456055, -0.012490680441260338, -0.02083772048354149, -0.030386684462428093, -0.010624714195728302, 0.005680901929736137, 0.004220003727823496, -0.0330694243311882, 0.018128419294953346, 0.01941666565835476, -0.015618330799043179, -0.014462892897427082, -0.022816574200987816, 0.006328345742076635, -0.024011854082345963, -0.009356388822197914, -0.003907902631908655, -0.004153599496930838, -0.031130414456129074, 0.0033683665096759796, 0.04095827415585518, 0.023932170122861862, 0.008532973937690258, -0.03304286301136017, -0.02146192267537117, -0.006670328788459301, 0.028872661292552948, 0.008685704320669174, -0.008904838934540749, 0.028447672724723816, 0.012743016704916954, -0.0023839203640818596, 0.0460050143301487, 0.012490680441260338, 0.014834757894277573, 0.018951835110783577, -0.02174082212150097, -0.002855391940101981, 0.040108297020196915, 0.04130357876420021, -0.0326709970831871, 0.0029749199748039246, -0.028952347114682198, 0.0221658106893301, -0.014794914983212948, -0.02378607913851738, -0.010332535021007061, -0.016401903703808784, 0.0031840940937399864, -0.035539671778678894, -0.012444197200238705, -0.013865252025425434, -0.021873630583286285, -0.02298922650516033, -0.007032232824712992, 0.015405836515128613, -0.036920882761478424, 0.01988149620592594, -0.00683301966637373, 0.025326663628220558, -0.01843388006091118, -0.015140218660235405, 0.015844104811549187, 0.018062014132738113, -0.004970374051481485, 0.015126937068998814, 0.010671197436749935, -0.02138223871588707, -0.019509632140398026, -0.0018892070511355996, 0.02725239284336567, 0.011760231107473373, 0.03846146538853645, 0.02398529276251793, -0.010870411060750484, -0.03710681572556496, 0.014861319214105606, 0.027650820091366768, 0.03859427571296692, 0.015618330799043179, 0.033335041254758835, -0.025406349450349808, 0.00190248794388026, 0.013579713180661201, 0.014595701359212399, 0.012968792580068111, 0.011195792816579342, -0.017889363691210747, -0.011056344024837017, -0.022497832775115967, -0.00988762453198433, 0.07368239760398865, -0.025818055495619774, 0.010863770730793476, 0.008234153501689434, -0.014927724376320839, 0.022019721567630768, 0.002536650514230132, 0.005491649266332388, 0.0014276959700509906, -0.027597695589065552, -0.001237613265402615, 0.03508811816573143, 0.0031508919782936573, 0.026123516261577606, 0.028367986902594566, 0.05075957253575325, -0.00814782828092575, 0.01460898295044899, -0.004887368530035019, -0.006925985682755709, 0.01177351176738739, -0.029908571392297745, 0.020851003006100655, 0.014954285696148872, -0.04292384535074234, -0.019549474120140076, 0.012165297754108906, -0.0026611590292304754, -0.015724577009677887, -0.00990090612322092, 0.0019854935817420483, -0.016375340521335602, -0.0031475715804845095, -0.006925985682755709, -0.00289855501614511, 0.0025499314069747925, 0.03099760413169861, 0.03184758126735687, 0.02961639128625393, 0.0023042350076138973, 0.0069525474682450294, -0.002357358578592539, -0.012570365332067013, -0.015326150692999363, -0.00035464134998619556, 0.015180060639977455, -0.03158196434378624, 0.028341425582766533, 0.008891558274626732, -0.0033999085426330566, 0.009675130248069763, -0.01913776621222496, 0.0010334195103496313, -0.005886755883693695, -0.005850233603268862, 0.021647855639457703, -0.007138479966670275, 0.013021916151046753, 0.013420342467725277, 0.009223580360412598, -0.03779742121696472, -0.02004086785018444, 0.004870767705142498, -0.0015986874932423234, 0.009987231343984604, -0.020811159163713455, 0.004183481447398663, 0.02248455211520195, -0.015684735029935837, -0.017743272706866264, -0.025419630110263824, -0.011886399239301682, -0.02823517844080925, 0.005441845860332251, -0.019522912800312042, -0.010412219911813736, 0.005973081570118666, 0.02977576293051243, -0.015365993604063988, -0.016720645129680634, -0.022790012881159782, 0.01077080424875021, 0.027730504050850868, 0.04273791238665581, -0.014741791412234306, -0.0033335040789097548, -0.0008591077639721334, 0.00994074810296297, -0.022272057831287384, -0.0029998216778039932, -0.01439648773521185, 0.012537162750959396, 0.023892326280474663, 0.04547377675771713, 0.021554889157414436, 0.02346733771264553, -0.014369926415383816, -0.02693365141749382, 0.019124485552310944, 0.002400521421805024, -0.013420342467725277, 0.022869698703289032, -0.0004835075233131647, -0.008911479264497757, 0.03280380740761757, 0.033414728939533234, -0.009402872063219547, -0.03168820962309837, -0.01352658960968256, -0.002644557738676667, -0.005929918959736824, -0.004090514965355396, -0.00027682361542247236, -0.03437095135450363, 0.00011402891686884686, 0.024383720010519028, 0.03607090562582016, 0.0025831337552517653, 0.012278186157345772, -0.030864795669913292, 0.03296317532658577, 0.014303522184491158, 0.017105789855122566, 0.0004689815395977348, -0.02460949495434761, -0.03583185002207756, 0.01490116212517023, -0.025114169344305992, 0.001513191731646657, 0.027119584381580353, 0.01767686940729618, 0.007875570096075535, 0.005435205530375242, -0.022657204419374466, 0.02102365344762802, 0.02158145047724247, 0.010737601667642593, -0.02913828007876873, 0.040586408227682114, -0.005036778748035431, -0.014183993451297283, -0.005358840338885784, -0.014356645755469799, -0.050068967044353485, 0.02276345156133175, -0.03495531156659126, -0.008433367125689983, -0.010611433535814285, 0.0070587946102023125, 0.004548706114292145, -0.007536906749010086, -0.006295143160969019, 0.002352378098294139, 0.00506998086348176, 0.020665070042014122, 0.03453032299876213, -0.032113198190927505, 0.041170768439769745, -0.02429075352847576, -0.010996579192578793, 0.0033667064271867275, -0.003632324282079935, 0.019230732694268227, 0.016123004257678986, 0.012165297754108906, -0.02873985283076763, -0.0023822602815926075, -0.02863360568881035, -0.004249885678291321, 0.025658685714006424, 0.00003398041008040309, -0.02847423404455185, -0.022550957277417183, -0.07123871147632599, -0.011414927430450916, 0.009455995634198189, 0.01847372204065323, -0.02126270905137062, -0.05801094323396683, 0.0008906499133445323, 0.0009446035255677998, -0.030386684462428093, 0.019987743347883224, 0.018566688522696495, 0.00676329480484128, 0.023374371230602264, 0.015658173710107803, 0.02441028133034706, 0.01346682570874691, -0.028952347114682198, -0.006238699425011873, -0.016362059861421585, 0.031369470059871674, 0.02524697780609131, 0.01807529479265213, 0.034795939922332764, -0.017318284139037132, -0.02142208069562912, 0.0069193453527987, 0.007530266419053078, -0.00881851278245449, -0.018168261274695396, 0.009602085687220097, -0.007085356395691633, 0.008712265640497208, 0.002988200867548585, 0.016508150845766068, 0.021993158385157585, -0.012497320771217346, -0.006623845547437668, -0.023732956498861313, -0.014449612237513065, -0.01957603730261326, 0.007410738617181778, 0.025339944288134575, -0.0032621193677186966, -0.00401747040450573, 0.0345834456384182, -0.03984268009662628, 0.005504930391907692, 0.0664575919508934, 0.0170128233730793, -0.01440976932644844, 0.028686728328466415, 0.009582164697349072, 0.00406727334484458, 0.00976809673011303, 0.009920827113091946, -0.014237117022275925, -0.004136998206377029, -0.02460949495434761, -0.043614454567432404, 0.0162956565618515, 0.006872862111777067, 0.021993158385157585, -0.025525877252221107, -0.0028022683691233397, -0.03617715463042259, -0.019323699176311493, 0.007145120296627283, 0.0460050143301487, 0.028607044368982315, -0.022816574200987816, -0.010784084908664227, -0.023055629804730415, 0.06502325087785721, 0.022856418043375015, -0.016096442937850952, -0.05604536831378937, 0.017464375123381615, -0.045500341802835464, 0.0224447101354599, -0.025964146479964256, 0.005309036932885647, 0.015485521405935287, 0.007317772135138512, 0.012384433299303055, -0.034477200359106064, -0.01815498061478138, -0.006099250167608261, -0.013300814665853977, 0.024144664406776428, 0.009741535410284996, 0.00507994182407856, -0.023852484300732613, 0.01051182672381401, -0.00010469079279573634, -0.008320479653775692, 0.009535681456327438, 0.02047913707792759, 0.018805744126439095, -0.01733156479895115, -0.0015995175344869494, 0.030253874137997627, 0.0009263423271477222, 0.006504317279905081, 0.009210299700498581, -0.04733310267329216, 0.016906576231122017, 0.02649538218975067, -0.018367474898695946, -0.011600860394537449, 0.005392042454332113, -0.014117589220404625, -0.02622976340353489, 0.008712265640497208, 0.02197987772524357, 0.0175307784229517, -0.0341850183904171, 0.01326761208474636, -0.0031874142587184906, 0.0010633014608174562, 0.01633549854159355, -0.023839203640818596, 0.01661439798772335, 0.01063135452568531, -0.013453545048832893, 0.005461767315864563, 0.012138736434280872, 0.0069658285938203335, -0.020333047956228256, 0.01661439798772335, -0.040852028876543045, -0.0033982484601438046, 0.014303522184491158, 0.007430659607052803, -0.028367986902594566, 0.010179804638028145, -0.009814579971134663, -0.005133065395057201, 0.014091027900576591, 0.002891914453357458, -0.008234153501689434, 0.05176892131567001, 0.025725090876221657, -0.011979365721344948, -0.0073576150462031364, 0.004688155371695757, -0.022152530029416084, 0.02725239284336567, 0.021873630583286285, 0.03992236405611038, 0.011959444731473923, -0.008612658828496933, 0.08749452233314514, 0.006245340220630169, 0.01559176854789257, -0.014887881465256214, 0.038328658789396286, -0.007337693590670824, -0.007012311369180679, -0.0004013319849036634, -0.006750014144927263, 0.0075701093301177025, -0.030652301385998726, 0.004153599496930838, -0.03710681572556496, 0.021355675533413887, -0.01452929712831974, -0.025140730664134026, -0.00190248794388026, -0.04658937454223633, -0.010989938862621784, -0.01854012720286846, -0.008181029930710793, 0.012158657424151897, -0.010438782162964344, 0.007908771745860577, -0.005538132507354021, -0.018380755558609962, 0.029749201610684395, -0.007762682158499956, -0.050653327256441116, -0.007795884273946285, 0.022139249369502068, 0.0006661197985522449, 0.0009205319220200181, -0.0012069011572748423, 0.030891356989741325, -0.000011802356311818585, -0.022975945845246315, 0.03830209746956825, 0.01811513863503933, 0.01953619346022606, 0.01897839643061161, -0.0021664455998688936, 0.021209586411714554, -0.01917761005461216, -0.024463405832648277, -0.022232215851545334, -0.005216070916503668, 0.013446904718875885, -0.018287789076566696, 0.017743272706866264, -0.030466368421912193, -0.007370895706117153, -0.0052725146524608135, 0.01358635351061821, 0.016919858753681183, -0.0028105690144002438, 0.005644379649311304, -0.009628647938370705, -0.001055000931955874, -0.006175615359097719, 0.012298107147216797, 0.0027325437404215336, -0.007477142848074436, 0.026176640763878822, 0.015432397834956646 ]
6.622418
3.087533
2024-07-01
2
2024MNRAS.531.4155C
[ "lens", "burst counts", "FRB 20201124A", "radio photons", "a plasma lens", "the plasma lens", "FRB", "SUB>0</SUB", "host galaxy", "double main-peak structures" ]
[ "Astrophysics - High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
25
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1431", "10.48550/arXiv.2401.18036" ]
[ "Chen, Xuechun", "Hu, Bin", "Wang, Pei", "Zheng, Wenwen", "Li, Di", "Er, Xinzhong" ]
[ "Institute for Frontier in Astronomy and Astrophysics, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 102206, China; Department of Astronomy, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 100875, China", "Institute for Frontier in Astronomy and Astrophysics, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 102206, China; Department of Astronomy, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 100875, China", "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China", "Purple Mountain Observatory, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Nanjing 210023, China", "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China", "South-Western Institute for Astronomy Research, Yunnan University, Kunming 650500, China" ]
[ "2024arXiv240612804K", "2024arXiv240705366B" ]
[ "1980poet.book.....B", "1986ApJ...310..737C", "1987Natur.326..675F", "1987Natur.328..324R", "1992grle.book.....S", "1993Natur.366..320C", "1998ApJ...496..253C", "2004PASA...21..302H", "2007Sci...318..777L", "2010vaoa.conf..129P", "2011IJMPD..20..989N", "2012hpa..book.....L", "2013PASJ...65L..12T", "2013Sci...341...53T", "2014MNRAS.437.2180E", "2015ApJ...809...24G", "2015Natur.528..523M", "2016ApJ...822L...7W", "2016ApJ...829...27D", "2016Natur.531..202S", "2017ApJ...842...35C", "2017Natur.541...58C", "2018ApJ...863...48C", "2018NatCo...9.3833L", "2019ARA&A..57..417C", "2019ApJ...876L..23H", "2019ApJ...877L..19G", "2019MNRAS.484.5500C", "2019MNRAS.485.4091M", "2019MNRAS.485.4389R", "2019PhR...821....1P", "2020ApJ...889..158E", "2020ApJ...897L..40D", "2020MNRAS.497.4956J", "2020MNRAS.498.1397L", "2020Natur.587...54C", "2020Natur.587...59B", "2020Natur.587...63L", "2020arXiv200616263W", "2021ATel14933....1M", "2021ApJ...912..134C", "2021ApJ...923..117C", "2021ApJS..257...59C", "2021MNRAS.507.5390J", "2021RNAAS...5..271S", "2021SCPMA..6449501X", "2022A&A...663A.116W", "2022A&ARv..30....2P", "2022ATel15288....1W", "2022ApJ...925..109L", "2022ApJ...927...59L", "2022ApJ...927L...3N", "2022MNRAS.509.3172M", "2022MNRAS.509.5872E", "2022MNRAS.510..197E", "2022MNRAS.512.3400K", "2022MNRAS.516.2218E", "2022Natur.607..256C", "2022Natur.609..685X", "2022RAA....22l4001Z", "2022RAA....22l4002Z", "2022RAA....22l4003J", "2022RAA....22l4004N", "2023MNRAS.520..994S", "2023MNRAS.522.3965E", "2023RvMP...95c5005Z", "2024PhRvD.109b1303G" ]
29184313
2401.08009
Very Long Baseline Interferometry Detection of an Active Radio Source Potentially Driving 100 kpc Scale Emission in the Ultraluminous Infrared Galaxy IRAS F01004–2237
The nearby ultraluminous infrared galaxy (ULIRG) IRAS F01004‑2237 exhibits 100 kpc scale continuum emission at radio wavelengths. The absence of extended X-ray emission in IRAS F01004‑2237 has suggested an active galactic nucleus (AGN) origin for the extended radio emission, whose properties and role in merging systems still need to be better understood. We present the results of multifrequency observations of IRAS F01004‑2237 conducted by the Very Long Baseline Array at 2.3 and 8.4 GHz. Compact 8.4 GHz continuum emission was detected on a 1 pc scale in the nuclear region with an intrinsic brightness temperature of 10<SUP>8.1</SUP> K suggesting that the radio source originated from an AGN, potentially driving the extended emission. In contrast, no significant emission was observed at 2.3 GHz, indicating the presence of low-frequency absorption. This absorption cannot be attributed solely to synchrotron self-absorption; alternatively, free–free absorption due to thermal plasma is mainly at work in the spectrum. From combined perspectives, including mid-infrared and X-ray data, the AGN is obscured in a dense environment. The kinetic power of the nonthermal jet, as inferred from the extended emission, can play a more important role in dispersing the surrounding medium than the thermal outflow in IRAS F01004‑2237. These findings hint that jet activities in ULIRGs may contribute to AGN feedback during galaxy evolution induced by merger events.
[ -0.05600301921367645, 0.02513851225376129, 0.002183617325499654, -0.0025211251340806484, -0.03889486566185951, -0.0004797120636794716, 0.007192407734692097, -0.018178869038820267, 0.0220660287886858, 0.01583958975970745, -0.016060717403888702, -0.008653001859784126, -0.03477494418621063, -0.034728389233350754, 0.018481461331248283, -0.013116251677274704, 0.013174442574381828, 0.003180138301104307, -0.023485887795686722, 0.008007082156836987, -0.03263351321220398, -0.004428335465490818, -0.028746355324983597, 0.004041364882141352, -0.07252926379442215, -0.03931384161114693, -0.025883357971906662, 0.016130546107888222, -0.01037545595318079, 0.001972674857825041, 0.013942563906311989, -0.0036020230036228895, -0.005851105321198702, -0.048414912074804306, -0.06968954205513, 0.045342426747083664, 0.023800119757652283, -0.002787349047139287, -0.042688917368650436, -0.010550028644502163, 0.021169885993003845, -0.014326624572277069, -0.02020391635596752, -0.025650594383478165, 0.0167473703622818, -0.027349770069122314, -0.009240730665624142, 0.00013338468852452934, 0.009589876979589462, -0.01631675660610199, -0.025650594383478165, 0.014431368559598923, -0.013558503240346909, -0.01660771109163761, -0.030515361577272415, -0.02676786109805107, 0.023392783477902412, 0.03970953822135925, -0.032982658594846725, -0.01871422678232193, -0.04145526885986328, -0.032959382981061935, 0.031167101114988327, -0.024184180423617363, -0.03496115282177925, -0.011219224892556667, 0.01923794485628605, 0.017573682591319084, 0.02702390030026436, 0.017759893089532852, -0.02446349710226059, -0.0009616063325665891, -0.041082847863435745, -0.025906633585691452, 0.0798846036195755, -0.00810018740594387, 0.017352556809782982, -0.05851687118411064, -0.04240960255265236, -0.016491329297423363, 0.009892470203340054, 0.010922450572252274, -0.016351671889424324, -0.018725864589214325, 0.004407968372106552, -0.009642248973250389, -0.014815429225564003, 0.003471093252301216, -0.05516507104039192, -0.0008612268138676882, 0.001206735847517848, 0.0325869619846344, 0.0005790004506707191, -0.029048947617411613, -0.0070818448439240456, -0.05037013068795204, 0.018341803923249245, -0.03761466220021248, 0.03996558114886284, 0.04478379338979721, -0.0002009408053709194, 0.006086778827011585, 0.028746355324983597, -0.036986202001571655, 0.03924401104450226, 0.014536112546920776, 0.010532571002840996, -0.002299999352544546, 0.015118022449314594, -0.009962299838662148, 0.07304134219884872, 0.009153444319963455, 0.016468053683638573, 0.07527588307857513, -0.06759466975927353, -0.00914180651307106, -0.05870308354496956, 0.011009737849235535, -0.010288168676197529, 0.042665641754865646, -0.007483362685889006, 0.03435596823692322, -0.0016322575975209475, 0.05786513164639473, 0.034472350031137466, -0.005760909058153629, 0.03477494418621063, -0.03491460159420967, -0.045319151133298874, -0.01213864330202341, 0.055025409907102585, -0.029747240245342255, 0.003241238882765174, 0.05316329747438431, -0.02235698327422142, -0.02837393246591091, 0.05376848578453064, -0.08216569572687149, -0.02199619822204113, -0.03980264440178871, -0.0008895949576981366, 0.04229322075843811, 0.021751796826720238, -0.012662362307310104, -0.0000440751391579397, 0.025604041293263435, -0.042782023549079895, 0.004425425548106432, 0.05874963477253914, -0.011661476455628872, 0.009566600434482098, -0.018341803923249245, -0.004623275250196457, -0.06349802017211914, -0.014024031348526478, -0.012103728018701077, 0.019307773560285568, -0.001539151999168098, 0.012033899314701557, -0.04708815738558769, -0.02170524373650551, -0.005167360883206129, -0.041967350989580154, 0.024021245539188385, 0.023613909259438515, -0.0010903539368882775, 0.010003033094108105, -0.020832378417253494, -0.09589876979589462, 0.00044370637624524534, -0.062380753457546234, -0.026581648737192154, -0.050789106637239456, 0.013884373009204865, -0.027093730866909027, 0.02089056931436062, 0.022147495299577713, -0.02679113671183586, -0.006465020123869181, -0.01945907063782215, -0.012476150877773762, 0.018958628177642822, 0.03268006816506386, -0.003255786607041955, -0.008268941193819046, 0.01059076189994812, -0.028257550671696663, 0.0037853247486054897, 0.02779202163219452, 0.009281464852392673, -0.001769006485119462, 0.022438449785113335, 0.01428007148206234, 0.062380753457546234, -0.025580763816833496, -0.017166346311569214, -0.031330034136772156, -0.053442616015672684, -0.042665641754865646, 0.017026687040925026, 0.04804249107837677, 0.016980133950710297, 0.037940531969070435, -0.023858310654759407, -0.009456037543714046, -0.04948562756180763, 0.034612007439136505, 0.020564699545502663, -0.009665525518357754, 0.05139429122209549, 0.05190637335181236, -0.014117136597633362, -0.013325739651918411, -0.004271219484508038, -0.014221880584955215, -0.02111169509589672, 0.016491329297423363, 0.04210700839757919, 0.042851854115724564, -0.023113466799259186, 0.03989575058221817, -0.0065173921175301075, 0.049997709691524506, 0.04401567205786705, 0.011504361405968666, 0.026209227740764618, 0.04252598434686661, -0.01551372092217207, 0.02441694401204586, 0.010817707516252995, 0.01880733110010624, -0.01213864330202341, -0.03149297088384628, -0.03517064079642296, 0.014117136597633362, 0.008164197206497192, 0.01617709919810295, 0.03421631082892418, 0.010916631668806076, -0.02048323303461075, -0.00633700005710125, 0.01543225347995758, 0.0014627763302996755, 0.016142183914780617, -0.03561289235949516, -0.0076637547463178635, 0.013255910016596317, -0.011312331072986126, 0.043596699833869934, 0.0022214415948837996, 0.018702587112784386, -0.008641364052891731, -0.014920173212885857, -0.04015178978443146, -0.02165869064629078, 0.010032128542661667, -0.017224537208676338, 0.048508018255233765, -0.05958758667111397, -0.010392912663519382, -0.012988231144845486, -0.0107478778809309, -0.06750155985355377, 0.00693054823204875, -0.015257680788636208, 0.04313116893172264, 0.005999492481350899, -0.0019304865272715688, -0.04310789331793785, 0.012511065229773521, -0.04971839115023613, -0.042595814913511276, 0.06745500862598419, -0.06591876596212387, -0.05642199516296387, 0.04906665161252022, 0.01670081727206707, 0.03021276742219925, 0.00244693155400455, -0.022228961810469627, -0.009217455051839352, 0.006313723511993885, 0.028629973530769348, -0.006267170887440443, -0.028304103761911392, -0.015455530025064945, -0.017596958205103874, -0.025813529267907143, 0.004122832324355841, -0.051021870225667953, 0.06279972940683365, -0.011347245424985886, 0.03274989500641823, 0.0010132507886737585, -0.035519786179065704, -0.02693079598248005, 0.051068421453237534, 0.01156255230307579, -0.015967611223459244, 0.01377962902188301, 0.031167101114988327, 0.026558373123407364, 0.01344212144613266, -0.02211258001625538, -0.018027571961283684, 0.07457758486270905, 0.04874078184366226, 0.01830688863992691, -0.0034158118069171906, 0.03719568997621536, 0.04967183992266655, -0.053442616015672684, 0.012406321242451668, 0.003561289282515645, -0.03198177367448807, 0.011172672733664513, 0.005368120037019253, 0.043619975447654724, 0.03244730085134506, -0.014454645104706287, 0.01113193854689598, -0.02427728660404682, -0.00420429976657033, -0.01898190565407276, -0.012406321242451668, -0.018609482795000076, 0.01417532842606306, -0.026209227740764618, -0.028839459642767906, 0.00951422844082117, 0.05916861072182655, 0.03284300118684769, 0.061356592923402786, -0.008309675380587578, -0.006610497832298279, -0.04585450887680054, -0.023160018026828766, 0.02755925804376602, -0.0398259200155735, -0.03605514392256737, -0.037056028842926025, -0.0053361146710813046, -0.020669443532824516, 0.028839459642767906, -0.011422893963754177, 0.03812674432992935, 0.020494870841503143, -0.007623021025210619, 0.044318266212940216, -0.00042079368722625077, 0.0000881502783158794, -0.01547880657017231, 0.012278301641345024, -0.01952889934182167, 0.024766091257333755, -0.039569880813360214, 0.019773302599787712, -0.05223224312067032, -0.010474380105733871, 0.02837393246591091, -0.026325609534978867, 0.02439366839826107, 0.059680692851543427, -0.0002662238257471472, -0.028955843299627304, -0.02597646228969097, -0.010904993861913681, 0.04869423061609268, -0.07164476066827774, -0.0268144141882658, 0.0328197255730629, 0.008420238271355629, 0.01760859787464142, -0.01389601081609726, -0.07439137995243073, -0.014792152680456638, 0.06084451079368591, 0.002954648109152913, -0.01421024277806282, 0.02765236422419548, 0.06000656262040138, 0.011515999212861061, -0.0032761534675955772, -0.02618595026433468, 0.0028324469458311796, 0.00045388980652205646, -0.04508638754487038, -0.042665641754865646, -0.06973609328269958, 0.015827951952815056, -0.02039012685418129, -0.0029662863817065954, 0.04452775418758392, -0.005644527263939381, -0.011929155327379704, -0.009025424718856812, 0.02858342044055462, 0.042037177830934525, -0.0017864637775346637, 0.08593647181987762, -0.02518506534397602, -0.002065780572593212, -0.013663247227668762, -0.014908534474670887, 0.003939530812203884, -0.005141174886375666, -0.0028746353927999735, 0.054234012961387634, 0.008687916211783886, -0.021286267787218094, 0.006267170887440443, -0.02690751850605011, 0.021775072440505028, 0.0038900685030966997, 0.01991296000778675, 0.00542049203068018, -0.04476051777601242, 0.028629973530769348, -0.023439334705471992, 0.030352426692843437, -0.0033925354946404696, -0.025743698701262474, -0.0002965922758448869, -0.01593269594013691, -0.0432242751121521, -0.026721308007836342, 0.033099040389060974, -0.006569764111191034, 0.0029851982835680246, -0.02238025888800621, -0.0035030983854085207, 0.02944464609026909, -0.051813267171382904, 0.0027073363307863474, -0.020122447982430458, 0.02516178973019123, 0.05144084617495537, 0.005307019222527742, -0.050742555409669876, -0.012452874332666397, 0.009723716415464878, 0.015071469359099865, -0.02005261927843094, -0.029700687155127525, -0.012103728018701077, 0.019109925255179405, 0.015606827102601528, 0.03835950791835785, 0.02592991106212139, -0.00752409640699625, -0.032982658594846725, -0.06349802017211914, -0.018900437280535698, 0.02437039092183113, -0.017143068835139275, 0.019063372164964676, 0.02034357376396656, -0.008897404186427593, -0.0026171403005719185, -0.025743698701262474, 0.008932318538427353, -0.01835344173014164, -0.013721438124775887, 0.005769637878984213, -0.059028953313827515, 0.0003316887014079839, -0.005461225286126137, 0.03810346871614456, 0.0179926585406065, 0.01739910989999771, -0.018912075087428093, -0.04785627871751785, -0.0023800120688974857, 0.005999492481350899, 0.015606827102601528, -0.01880733110010624, 0.002858632942661643, -0.01627020351588726, 0.030748125165700912, -0.006028587929904461, -0.008798479102551937, -0.0001525695261079818, 0.023904863744974136, 0.037893980741500854, 0.04145526885986328, 0.022135857492685318, 0.007721946109086275, 0.018539654091000557, -0.010090319439768791, -0.017701702192425728, -0.020646167919039726, -0.020192276686429977, 0.037056028842926025, -0.009508409537374973, 0.01758532039821148, -0.02616267465054989, -0.05949448049068451, -0.007151674013584852, -0.018225422129034996, 0.012383045628666878, 0.03242402523756027, 0.026488544419407845, 0.055025409907102585, -0.033867161720991135, -0.014582664705812931, 0.02611612156033516, -0.008059454150497913, -0.01660771109163761, -0.0167473703622818, -0.037917256355285645, 0.031306758522987366, 0.04622693359851837, -0.0032761534675955772, -0.024044521152973175, -0.0017515491927042603, 0.010689686983823776, -0.030817953869700432, 0.043480318039655685, 0.005176089704036713, 0.004826943390071392, 0.015152936801314354, -0.018225422129034996, 0.0015478807035833597, -0.00013174806372262537, 0.021309545263648033, -0.0017500943504273891, -0.007896519266068935, -0.06428942084312439, -0.04310789331793785, -0.028210997581481934, -0.01670081727206707, -0.013849458657205105, 0.004626184701919556, -0.0030201131012290716, 0.011708029545843601, -0.02688424289226532, 0.007017835043370724, 0.008298036642372608, 0.004704742692410946, -0.0030724848620593548, -0.011271596886217594, 0.01032890286296606, -0.027256665751338005, 0.007413533516228199, 0.019715111702680588, 0.04094319045543671, -0.0008328587282449007, -0.01826033554971218, 0.021577224135398865, 0.04860112443566322, 0.028048062697052956, 0.026698032394051552, 0.02858342044055462, 0.03980264440178871, -0.010276530869305134, 0.0010525297839194536, -0.033750779926776886, -0.013209357857704163, 0.011184310540556908, 0.003904616227373481, -0.012964955531060696, -0.0294213704764843, -0.01964528299868107, 0.039523329585790634, 0.022799234837293625, -0.030561914667487144, 0.004311953205615282, 0.0011747308308258653, -0.0472976453602314, -0.006465020123869181, -0.008088549599051476, -0.02860669605433941, -0.024137627333402634, -0.014163689687848091, 0.008926499634981155, -0.008088549599051476, -0.01544389221817255, 0.014803790487349033, 0.004559264983981848, -0.017771532759070396, -0.007012015674263239, -0.019994428381323814, 0.0019188482547178864, 0.032912831753492355, -0.0041752043180167675, -0.017282728105783463, -0.024579878896474838, 0.019947875291109085, 0.023276399821043015, -0.03600859269499779, -0.00397735508158803, -0.03635773807764053, -0.006063502281904221, -0.020110810175538063, -0.021146610379219055, 0.003523465245962143, 0.016142183914780617, 0.020064257085323334, 0.02075091190636158, 0.009054520167410374, 0.006168246269226074, -0.002558949403464794, -0.05064944922924042, -0.02005261927843094, -0.005717265885323286, -0.01921466924250126, 0.012185195460915565, -0.02113497257232666, -0.023776844143867493, 0.004050093702971935, -0.010584942996501923, -0.003983173985034227, -0.0389181412756443, 0.008897404186427593, -0.013639970682561398, 0.012999869883060455, 0.005103351082652807, -0.00474547641351819, 0.006872357334941626, 0.004151927772909403, -0.012394683435559273, -0.018935352563858032, 0.009648067876696587, -0.007285513449460268, 0.03521719574928284, 0.015257680788636208, -0.03659050166606903, -0.04327083006501198, -0.019703473895788193, -0.018993543460965157, 0.029677411541342735, -0.03389044106006622, 0.027908405289053917, 0.01634003408253193, 0.0010176151990890503, -0.03901124745607376, -0.0065523069351911545, -0.0016409863019362092, -0.017666788771748543, 0.0015027825720608234, 0.0007175678038038313, 0.028862737119197845, 0.04459758475422859, -0.034588731825351715, -0.0008837758214212954, 0.016921943053603172, -0.012871849350631237, -0.031376589089632034, -0.02520834282040596, -0.010776973329484463, -0.017306003719568253, -0.020611252635717392, 0.000980518409051001, 0.026698032394051552, 0.04701833054423332, -0.0036165707278996706, 0.01098646130412817, 0.01428007148206234, -0.014780514873564243, 0.03361112251877785, 0.007768498733639717, 0.0005819100188091397, 0.011230863630771637, -0.0219496451318264, -0.026674754917621613, -0.00428285775706172, 0.027442876249551773, 0.019994428381323814, -0.016491329297423363, 0.027326494455337524, 0.06484805047512054, -0.02353244088590145, 0.015152936801314354, 0.05199947953224182, 0.0045970892533659935, -0.021367736160755157, -0.009031243622303009, 0.04380618780851364, -0.008414418436586857, -0.0008939592516981065, 0.035403404384851456, 0.0010670775081962347, -0.030678296461701393, -0.016828836873173714, -0.041199229657649994, 0.031446415930986404, 0.010148510336875916, -0.028071340173482895, -0.01032890286296606, -0.013837819918990135, 0.017748255282640457, 0.01301150768995285, 0.05544438585639, 0.01823705993592739, -0.01778317056596279, -0.01828361302614212, 0.0009492406970821321, -0.011399617418646812, -0.03989575058221817, 0.013523588888347149, 0.0294213704764843, 0.04981149733066559, 0.027326494455337524, -0.03558961674571037, 0.005760909058153629, -0.011137757450342178, -0.0015667927218601108, -0.014186966232955456, 0.002748070051893592, -0.0047716619446873665, 0.011655657552182674, 0.018318526446819305, -0.005987854208797216, 0.013884373009204865, -0.0003556924930308014, -0.006994558498263359, 0.01260417141020298, 0.009770269505679607, -0.016165459528565407, -0.016526244580745697, 0.013977478258311749, -0.016898667439818382, 0.006069321651011705, -0.010776973329484463, 0.04943907633423805, -0.02611612156033516, 0.023904863744974136, 0.03759138658642769, -0.02618595026433468, 0.018178869038820267, -0.006430105771869421, -0.03577582910656929, -0.004579631611704826, 0.00117545819375664, -0.00630208570510149, 0.0488804429769516, -0.002080328296869993, -0.01636330969631672, -0.0432242751121521, 0.04452775418758392, 0.017620235681533813, -0.03093433566391468, -0.02532472461462021, -0.00019239399989601225, 0.019203031435608864, 0.020692721009254456, 0.028979118913412094, -0.0070352922193706036, -0.024626431986689568, -0.024556603282690048, -0.0010656226659193635, 0.007849966175854206, 0.027931680902838707, -0.018132315948605537, 0.054839201271533966, -0.00798962451517582, 0.015781398862600327, -0.025464382022619247, 0.014396454207599163, 0.038545720279216766, 0.013244272209703922, -0.008926499634981155, 0.028164444491267204, 0.005219732876867056, 0.007559011224657297, 0.035333577543497086, -0.01078279223293066, -0.0015042374143376946, 0.0002022137341555208, -0.00010865351214306429, -0.007559011224657297, 0.00670360354706645, 0.01981985569000244, -0.03398354351520538, 0.005554331000894308, 0.0028789998032152653, -0.03188866749405861, -0.015071469359099865, -0.009339655749499798, 0.011987346224486828, 0.018632758408784866, -0.020157363265752792, -0.001083080074749887, -0.0020381398499011993, -0.003532193833962083, 0.015362424775958061, -0.013314100913703442, 0.014792152680456638, -0.03980264440178871, -0.013546865433454514, -0.022647937759757042, 0.013127890415489674, 0.012103728018701077, -0.013756352476775646, 0.030631743371486664, 0.027512704953551292, 0.01677064597606659, -0.0846329927444458, 0.0178762748837471, 0.0061798845417797565, 0.026488544419407845, 0.00672106072306633, 0.05069600045681, 0.030305873602628708, 0.04420188441872597, -0.0012431052746251225, 0.013267548754811287, 0.018702587112784386, -0.03738189861178398, 0.012999869883060455, 0.02204275131225586, 0.03288955241441727, 0.019796578213572502, 0.010474380105733871, 0.010544209741055965, 0.06545323878526688, 0.026488544419407845, -0.0005200820742174983, 0.02446349710226059, -0.000041165589209413156, 0.026674754917621613, -0.0010074317688122392, -0.019878046587109566, -0.034728389233350754, 0.009269827045500278, 0.0008459516684524715, -0.009950661100447178, 0.014733961783349514, -0.010096138343214989, 0.011126119643449783, 0.03635773807764053, -0.015385701321065426, -0.009822641499340534, -0.005589245818555355, 0.025836804881691933, -0.010899174958467484, 0.03011966310441494, 0.03340163454413414, -0.03563616797327995, -0.010288168676197529, -0.0014838705537840724, 0.014221880584955215, 0.037149135023355484, -0.014547750353813171, 0.033867161720991135, 0.04892699420452118, -0.02002934366464615, 0.02360226958990097, 0.02441694401204586, 0.009601515717804432, -0.0037678673397749662, -0.013453759253025055, 0.025860080495476723, 0.0052400995045900345, 0.008041996508836746, -0.019447432830929756, -0.023613909259438515, -0.024719538167119026, 0.019226307049393654, 0.01727108843624592, -0.026604926213622093, -0.014082222245633602, 0.001620619441382587, -0.03025932051241398, 0.01421024277806282, 0.009688802063465118, -0.06782743334770203, 0.029980003833770752, -0.011929155327379704, -0.023951416835188866, -0.0074891820549964905, 0.03984919935464859, 0.013930926099419594, -0.014128775335848331, 0.006005311384797096, 0.010800249874591827, 0.02350916527211666, -0.010870079509913921, -0.01620037481188774, 0.04103629291057587, -0.0005320839700289071, 0.009822641499340534, -0.0034827315248548985, 0.0097877262160182, -0.0522787943482399, -0.03193522244691849, 0.010689686983823776, 0.04324755072593689, -0.026698032394051552, 0.05372193455696106, 0.009677163325250149, -0.007849966175854206, 0.05111497640609741, 0.001997406128793955, -0.0027073363307863474, -0.010189244523644447, 0.023299677297472954, -0.006709422450512648, -0.02168196812272072, -0.03973281756043434, -0.015699932351708412, 0.010538390837609768, -0.013116251677274704, 0.005138265434652567, 0.0366603322327137, 0.03433269262313843, 0.020157363265752792, 0.032261092215776443, -0.00019930418056901544, 0.007681212387979031, 0.04043110832571983, 0.04152509942650795, -0.010672229342162609, -0.018027571961283684, -0.02045995555818081, -0.02353244088590145, 0.0029270073864609003, -0.006732698995620012, 0.025464382022619247, -0.0699223056435585, -0.01658443547785282, 0.0364275686442852, 0.004294496029615402, -0.014361538924276829, -0.0012962045148015022, 0.018085762858390808, -0.005435039754956961, -0.01156255230307579, -0.006505753844976425, 0.0006906544440425932, 0.014687408693134785, 0.013954202644526958, -0.034565456211566925, -0.02197292260825634, 0.03430941328406334, -0.0008539529517292976, 0.011376340873539448, 0.0026040473021566868, -0.008821755647659302, 0.0134072070941329, 0.016642626374959946, -0.026395438238978386, -0.005807462148368359, -0.04078025370836258, -0.013244272209703922, 0.016502968966960907, -0.0019683106802403927, 0.015327509492635727, -0.032191261649131775, 0.019365966320037842, 0.009182539768517017, 0.000039210732211358845, 0.004626184701919556, 0.015560274012386799, -0.010689686983823776, 0.01828361302614212, 0.03926728665828705, 0.05516507104039192, 0.037102583795785904, 0.002304363762959838, -0.017410747706890106, 0.046971775591373444, 0.03526374697685242, -0.04143199324607849, -0.004140289966017008, -0.030329149216413498, -0.013267548754811287, -0.0000132861878228141, -0.002996836556121707, 0.03596203774213791, 0.014512836001813412, -0.020855655893683434, -0.01421024277806282, -0.03919745981693268, -0.012522703967988491, 0.02781529910862446, -0.006016949657350779, -0.008012901060283184, -0.010084500536322594, -0.01794610545039177, 0.0008357682381756604, 0.012650723569095135, 0.04315444827079773, 0.029118778184056282, 0.032121434807777405, 0.024067798629403114, 0.011207587085664272, 0.008460971526801586, 0.032074879854917526, -0.009147625416517258, 0.010311445221304893, -0.01909828744828701, 0.012871849350631237, -0.016735732555389404, 0.026698032394051552, -0.05316329747438431, 0.022752681747078896, -0.011428712867200375, -0.015199489891529083, 0.014117136597633362, -0.029980003833770752, 0.004835672210901976, -0.0051935468800365925, -0.0043876017443835735, -0.02045995555818081, -0.056561652570962906, -0.029025672003626823, 0.03728879243135452, -0.03994230180978775, 0.02530144713819027, -0.04103629291057587, 0.05507196485996246, -0.01117849163711071, 0.0017864637775346637, -0.0212746299803257, -0.0032354197464883327, -0.010032128542661667, 0.040175069123506546, -0.05921516194939613, -0.0008314039441756904, 0.06079795956611633, 0.02844376116991043, 0.03721896559000015, -0.00795471016317606, 0.0022723586298525333, -0.023346230387687683, 0.016875389963388443, 0.004035545978695154, -0.006657050456851721, -0.01262744702398777, -0.028955843299627304, -0.021740159019827843, -0.009764449670910835, -0.024207456037402153, 0.012045537121593952, 0.0017951923655346036, -0.023392783477902412, 0.022997083142399788, 0.0001285657490370795, -0.008839213289320469, -0.02331131510436535, -0.0063544572331011295, -0.026279056444764137, 0.013220995664596558, 0.004428335465490818, -0.018574567511677742, -0.00447488809004426, -0.007576468400657177, -0.03344818949699402, -0.006750156171619892, 0.00263896188698709, 0.023416059091687202, 0.024975577369332314, -0.03763794153928757, 0.021821625530719757, 0.005400124937295914, -0.014349901117384434, 0.008862489834427834, -0.025045407935976982, -0.030794678255915642, -0.04448120296001434, 0.00033350716694258153, 0.002963376697152853, -0.050789106637239456, -0.01425679586827755, 0.005880200769752264, -0.04061732068657875, -0.009543323889374733, -0.031330034136772156, 0.018109040334820747, -0.01859784498810768, -0.023253124207258224, -0.016805561259388924, 0.012289939448237419, -0.002733522327616811, 0.019354326650500298, 0.03805691376328468, -0.004998607095330954, 0.00020675989799201488, 0.006168246269226074, 0.009013785980641842, 0.010125234723091125, 0.03286627680063248, -0.002170524327084422, -0.04943907633423805, 0.012103728018701077, -0.01801593415439129, -0.025487659499049187, 0.02441694401204586, 0.020622890442609787, 0.018516376614570618, 0.048508018255233765, -0.02523161843419075, 0.033797334879636765, 0.03682326525449753, 0.007867423817515373, -0.031353313475847244, 0.016665901988744736, 0.024230733513832092, -0.00023403693921864033, -0.017364194616675377, -0.024021245539188385, -0.03361112251877785, -0.006441744044423103, 0.00014838705828879029, -0.01921466924250126, 0.0065988595597445965, -0.022822510451078415, 0.02125135436654091, -0.022659575566649437, 0.020622890442609787, 0.03519391641020775, -0.02776874601840973, -0.02027374505996704, -0.0012649268610402942, 0.017573682591319084, -0.03179556503891945, -0.01620037481188774, -0.0203668512403965, 0.009613153524696827, 0.01155091356486082, -0.03014293871819973, -0.007169131189584732, 0.002959012519568205, -0.0014213152462616563, -0.0025167607236653566, 0.017573682591319084, 0.013081337325274944, -0.029514476656913757, -0.005033521447330713, -0.005609612446278334, -0.0043381392024457455, 0.038801759481430054, 0.028117891401052475, 0.04080352932214737, -0.013151166029274464, 0.008053634315729141, 0.0016511697322130203, 0.006662869825959206, -0.005621250718832016, -0.02290397882461548, 0.018341803923249245, -0.03105071932077408, 0.0268144141882658, -0.03263351321220398, -0.006860719062387943, -0.019400879740715027, 0.0400586873292923, -0.01425679586827755, 0.03265678882598877, -0.0057929144240915775, 0.008821755647659302, -0.000518627290148288, 0.05856342241168022, -0.0023771023843437433, 0.0045970892533659935, -0.005013154819607735, 0.0002740432391874492, -0.02683768980205059, 0.014815429225564003, 0.013709800317883492, 0.023613909259438515, 0.014547750353813171, 0.0251152366399765, 0.01966855861246586, -0.003907525911927223, 0.0064708394929766655, 0.019016819074749947, 0.004218847490847111, -0.019587092101573944, 0.0014518655370920897, -0.01871422678232193, 0.0003424176829867065, 0.03405337408185005, 0.01986640878021717, -0.007541554048657417, -0.015711570158600807, 0.017119793221354485, -0.00038260582368820906, 0.0020337754394859076, 0.009939023293554783, -0.020180638879537582, -0.004029727075248957, 0.016479691490530968, -0.014396454207599163, 0.03561289235949516, 0.04098974168300629, 0.0429915115237236, -0.001974129816517234, 0.0016598983202129602, -0.03589221090078354, 0.003249967470765114, 0.00875774584710598, -0.020913846790790558, 0.0008146740146912634, 0.008239845745265484, -0.021775072440505028, -0.011091205291450024, -0.027954956516623497, 0.01670081727206707, -0.0032528769224882126, 0.022682853043079376, -0.0037445910274982452, -0.003718405030667782, -0.0070352922193706036, -0.004105375148355961, -0.007448448333889246, -0.026604926213622093, -0.024160904809832573, 0.01263908576220274, 0.017748255282640457, 0.033680953085422516, -0.013546865433454514, -0.015502083115279675, -0.0009565146174281836, 0.026302332058548927, -0.03498442843556404, 0.009252369403839111, -0.006831623613834381, -0.00654648756608367, -0.002276723040267825, -0.02842048555612564, -0.01082934532314539, -0.010980642400681973, 0.010247435420751572, 0.022182410582900047, 0.02618595026433468, -0.018772417679429054, -0.0013565777335315943, 0.009234911762177944, 0.039523329585790634, -0.024929024279117584, -0.037125859409570694, -0.012092090211808681, -0.012359769083559513, -0.048368360847234726, -0.0025647683069109917, -0.005135355982929468, -0.014070584438741207, 0.004442883189767599, 0.0031946860253810883, 0.021798349916934967, 0.010474380105733871, -0.008053634315729141, 0.00006314632628345862, 0.019831493496894836, -0.0063544572331011295, -0.018493101000785828, 0.014699047431349754, 0.015339148230850697, -0.03084123134613037, 0.022170770913362503, 0.00833877082914114, 0.008379504084587097, -0.04645969718694687, 0.0062729897908866405, 0.020576337352395058, -0.0001246560423169285, -0.005493230652064085, -0.020553061738610268, 0.006430105771869421, 0.014408092014491558, 0.0434570387005806, 0.04981149733066559, 0.0047716619446873665, -0.010276530869305134, -0.004370144102722406, -0.0040471842512488365, 0.0030433894135057926, 0.003366349497810006, -0.026628201827406883, -0.010392912663519382, -0.028979118913412094, -0.007983805611729622, 0.002419290831312537, 0.024975577369332314, -0.009310560300946236, -0.009071976877748966, -0.024952301755547523, 0.006208979990333319, 0.0012874759268015623, 0.026698032394051552, -0.003756229067221284, -0.016305118799209595, -0.03489132598042488, 0.04657607898116112, -0.020262107253074646, 0.034588731825351715, -0.010788612067699432, -0.025348000228405, -0.010893355123698711, 0.026418715715408325, -0.0373353473842144, 0.005865653045475483, 0.021100057289004326, 0.013151166029274464, 0.005205185152590275, -0.0032150528859347105, 0.012476150877773762, -0.022729406133294106, 0.03810346871614456, -0.004469068720936775, 0.04380618780851364, -0.03742845356464386, 0.02846703864634037, -0.01297659333795309, 0.0011427258141338825, -0.013162804767489433, 0.013721438124775887, 0.011300692334771156, -0.022706128656864166, 0.026651479303836823, 0.0075357346795499325, -0.006459201220422983, 0.042688917368650436, 0.0032150528859347105, -0.008158378303050995, -0.018341803923249245, -0.033750779926776886, -0.00441378727555275, 0.009013785980641842, -0.018551291897892952, -0.026698032394051552, 0.020587977021932602, -0.0035176461096853018, -0.04247943311929703, 0.03184211626648903, -0.0027640725020319223, -0.04334065690636635, 0.020599614828824997, 0.01135888323187828, 0.01155091356486082, 0.0018621120834723115, 0.035519786179065704, -0.007238960824906826, 0.035449959337711334, -0.04375963285565376, 0.00014056764484848827, 0.013674885034561157, 0.004149018321186304, 0.028001509606838226, 0.02523161843419075, 0.06284628063440323, -0.017911190167069435, 0.010707144625484943, -0.010660591535270214, -0.021763434633612633, -0.013884373009204865, -0.010887536220252514, 0.018888799473643303, 0.011079566553235054, 0.010340540669858456, -0.0007644842844456434, 0.014140413142740726, 0.016526244580745697, -0.03396026790142059, 0.013884373009204865, -0.013837819918990135, -0.009857555851340294, -0.027489429339766502, -0.0013623968698084354, 0.015874505043029785, 0.0522787943482399, 0.024952301755547523, 0.004832762759178877, -0.020995313301682472, 0.0050655268132686615, 0.019203031435608864, 0.03423958644270897, -0.028909290209412575, 0.007844147272408009, 0.0035060078371316195, 0.014105498790740967, 0.011062109842896461, 0.007751041557639837, -0.0010634405771270394, -0.022485002875328064, 0.006732698995620012, -0.012336492538452148, 0.0015711570158600807, -0.002868816489353776, -0.018248697742819786, -0.0017530039185658097, -0.023043636232614517, -0.002477481961250305, -0.002279632491990924, 0.0032237814739346504, 0.02211258001625538, 0.03600859269499779, 0.002465843688696623, -0.007157493382692337, 0.0007281149155460298, 0.018388357013463974, 0.02513851225376129, 0.012778744101524353, -0.059960007667541504, -0.050137367099523544, -0.036194801330566406, 0.014466282911598682, 0.017073240131139755, 0.037125859409570694, -0.03433269262313843, -0.0014191330410540104, -0.004832762759178877, -0.059866901487112045, -0.023707013577222824, 0.025371277704834938, -0.020471595227718353, 0.03084123134613037, 0.012988231144845486, 0.007634659297764301, 0.030724849551916122, 0.015595188364386559, -0.035310298204422, 0.004119922872632742, 0.031213654205203056, 0.008175835944712162, 0.017434023320674896, -0.011289054527878761, -0.011195948347449303, 0.00918835960328579, 0.006022768560796976, 0.011364703066647053, -0.024742813780903816, -0.03675343841314316, 0.0076521169394254684, -0.00731460889801383, 0.015723207965493202, 0.024207456037402153, 0.019994428381323814, 0.008926499634981155, -0.03414648026227951, 0.011172672733664513, 0.006977101322263479, 0.011649838648736477, -0.018365079537034035, 0.020192276686429977, -0.003954078536480665, -0.009089434519410133, 0.018970265984535217, -0.07616038620471954, -0.034449074417352676, -0.02371865324676037, -0.03165590390563011, 0.005787095054984093, 0.03589221090078354, -0.024579878896474838, -0.005496140103787184, 0.018912075087428093, -0.02154230885207653, 0.0008808663114905357, 0.0030521180015057325, 0.029886897653341293, -0.023020360618829727, 0.017550406977534294, -0.006063502281904221, -0.0033343443647027016, 0.018865521997213364, -0.019109925255179405, -0.010422008112072945, 0.009712078608572483, 0.015118022449314594, 0.02283414825797081, 0.015315871685743332, 0.024184180423617363, -0.025534210726618767, -0.01429171022027731, 0.004329410381615162, 0.022636299952864647, 0.009642248973250389, 0.00938038993626833, 0.04869423061609268, -0.025068683549761772, 0.02307855151593685, 0.010439465753734112, 0.008594810962677002, 0.017503853887319565, -0.009653886780142784, -0.032330919057130814, 0.026395438238978386, -0.030724849551916122, -0.010765335522592068, 0.02312510460615158, 0.001787918503396213, 0.022997083142399788, -0.02616267465054989, -0.015374062582850456, -0.011568371206521988, -0.02604629285633564, -0.005720175337046385, -0.02326476201415062, -0.008943957276642323, 0.024975577369332314, -0.018318526446819305, -0.004826943390071392, -0.020378489047288895, -0.02170524373650551, 0.0032325100619345903, -0.003005565144121647, -0.009822641499340534, -0.02453332580626011, 0.03838278353214264, 0.01262744702398777, -0.0056619844399392605, -0.029677411541342735, -0.0014635036932304502, 0.0013245727168396115, -0.022054389119148254, 0.0033052489161491394, 0.04981149733066559, 0.010497656650841236, 0.03011966310441494, 0.023951416835188866, 0.005813281051814556, 0.018993543460965157, -0.034449074417352676, -0.026651479303836823, 0.0003975172876380384, 0.042665641754865646, 0.007710307836532593, 0.019156478345394135, -0.021868178620934486, -0.031376589089632034, -0.0018097402062267065, 0.01902845688164234, 0.010119414888322353, -0.03994230180978775, 0.027885127812623978, 0.0028237183578312397, 0.005522326100617647, -0.04971839115023613, 0.005437949206680059, -0.02606956847012043, -0.028094615787267685, 0.01381454337388277, 0.038615547120571136 ]
13.920392
7.732371
2024-07-01
0
2024ApJ...970....5H
[ "extended X-ray emission", "IRAS F01004‑2237", "AGN feedback", "AGN", "IRAS", "galaxy evolution", "jet activities", "thermal plasma", "the extended radio emission", "mid-infrared and X-ray data" ]
[ "Ultraluminous infrared galaxies", "Radio continuum emission", "Radio active galactic nuclei", "Low-luminosity active galactic nuclei", "Very long baseline interferometry", "1735", "1340", "2134", "2033", "1769", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies", "Astrophysics - High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena" ]
15
[ "10.3847/1538-4357/ad5012", "10.48550/arXiv.2401.08009" ]
[ "Hayashi, Takayuki J.", "Hagiwara, Yoshiaki", "Imanishi, Masatoshi" ]
[ "National Astronomical Observatory of Japan, 2-21-1 Osawa, Mitaka, Tokyo 181-8588, Japan; Azabu Junior and Senior High School, 2-3-29 Motoazabu, Minato, Tokyo 106-0046, Japan", "Toyo University, 5-28-20 Hakusan, Bunkyo, Tokyo 112-8606, Japan", "National Astronomical Observatory of Japan, 2-21-1 Osawa, Mitaka, Tokyo 181-8588, Japan; Toyo University, 5-28-20 Hakusan, Bunkyo, Tokyo 112-8606, Japan; Department of Astronomy, School of Science, Graduate University for Advanced Studies (SOKENDAI), 2-21-1 Osawa, Mitaka, Tokyo 181-8588, Japan" ]
null
[ "1970ranp.book.....P", "1976MNRAS.174..267C", "1981ARA&A..19..373K", "1985ApJ...295L..13H", "1985ApJ...298L...7H", "1988ApJ...325...74S", "1990AJ.....99.1663L", "1991ApJ...376...95C", "1991ApJ...378...65C", "1991MNRAS.248..528A", "1992ARA&A..30..575C", "1996ARA&A..34..749S", "1996MNRAS.279..477C", "1997ASPC..125...77S", "1998A&A...331L...1S", "1998AJ....115..928C", "1998ApJ...492..116S", "1998ApJ...493L..13L", "1998ApJ...493L..17S", "1998ApJ...498..579G", "1998ApJS..119...41K", "1998RaSc...33..565M", "1999A&A...349..389V", "1999ApJ...516..127U", "1999ApJ...517L..81U", "1999ApJ...519..185T", "1999ApJ...522..113V", "1999ApJ...522..157R", "1999ApJ...524..816R", "1999MNRAS.309.1017W", "2000ApJ...529L..77B", "2000ApJ...532L..95C", "2001ApJ...554..803Y", "2002A&A...394...59D", "2002ApJ...568...99H", "2002ApJS..143..315V", "2003A&A...409...99P", "2003ASSL..285..109G", "2003ApJ...587..160M", "2003ApJ...592..804L", "2004ApJS..154..147A", "2005A&A...435..437U", "2005ApJ...621..123U", "2005ApJ...633..664T", "2005MNRAS.359..827R", "2005MNRAS.361..748B", "2006A&A...452.1099P", "2006A&A...456...97F", "2006ApJ...647..185L", "2006ApJ...651..835D", "2006ApJ...653.1172M", "2006ApJS..163....1H", "2006PASP..118.1711W", "2006asup.book..285L", "2007ASPC..376..127M", "2007ApJ...654L..49S", "2007ApJ...659..314P", "2007ApJS..171...72I", "2008ApJS..175..356H", "2008PASJ...60S.489I", "2009ApJ...693.1223S", "2009ApJ...693.1696H", "2009ApJ...706..851R", "2009ApJS..182..628V", "2010A&A...509A..34B", "2010A&A...519L...5P", "2010ApJ...709..884Y", "2010ApJ...724..779M", "2010MNRAS.405..887C", "2010MNRAS.405.2505N", "2011ApJ...740...95B", "2011MNRAS.415..619N", "2011Natur.477..185H", "2011PASP..123..275D", "2012A&A...537A..44A", "2012A&A...537L...8C", "2012A&A...542L..24B", "2012A&ARv..20...54F", "2012ApJ...757..136W", "2012ApJS..203....9U", "2012MNRAS.422..510R", "2012MNRAS.422.1453N", "2013A&A...558A..33A", "2013ApJ...767...12G", "2013ApJ...775..127S", "2013ApJ...776L..21R", "2013ApJ...779..173N", "2013MNRAS.432..138R", "2013PASJ...65..100I", "2015ApJ...799...82C", "2015ApJ...803....6M", "2016A&A...591A..28C", "2017A&A...598A..78I", "2017A&A...599A.123N", "2017ApJ...836..155R", "2017ApJ...841L...8D", "2017ApJ...843..117B", "2017ApJ...844...37D", "2017MNRAS.464.1146H", "2017MNRAS.469.3468C", "2017NatAs...1E..61T", "2018AJ....156..123A", "2018MNRAS.478.2438S", "2019A&A...623A.173V", "2019ApJ...875...80G", "2019ApJS..241...19I", "2019PASJ...71...28S", "2019SSRv..215...16V", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020ApJ...891...59R", "2021A&ARv..29....2P", "2021MNRAS.503.5746N", "2021MNRAS.504.2675H", "2021MNRAS.504.3823W", "2021MNRAS.504.4377T", "2021PASA...38...58H", "2022A&A...664A..25K", "2022ApJ...934..160L", "2023A&A...673A.159R", "2023ApJ...959..107S", "2023MNRAS.520.5712S", "2024A&A...685A..79W", "2024MNRAS.52710844H", "2024MNRAS.528.3668H" ]
29163280
2406.04761
Simba-C: the evolution of the thermal and chemical properties in the intragroup medium
The newly updated GIZMO and Simba based simulation, Simba-C, with its new stellar feedback, chemical enrichment, and recalibrated AGN feedback, allows for a detailed study of the intragroup medium X-ray properties. We discuss the impact of various physical mechanisms, e.g. stellar and AGN feedback, and chemical enrichment, on the composition and the global scaling relations of nearby galaxy groups. We also study the evolution (z = 2 to 0) of the global properties for the $1\, \mathrm{keV}$ temperature groups. Simba-C shows improved consistent matching with the observations of all X-ray scaling relations compared to Simba. It is well known that AGN feedback has a significant influence on L<SUB>X, 0.5-2.0</SUB>-T<SUB>spec, corr</SUB>, S<SUB>500/2500</SUB>-T<SUB>spec, corr</SUB>, and gas mass fractions, with our Simba-C results consistent with it. Our recalibrated AGN feedback strength also showed an additional improvement in gas entropy, which now aligns with CLoGS observations. The updated stellar feedback and chemical enrichment model is shown to play an important role in our understanding of the chemical abundance ratios and their evolution within galaxy groups. In particular, we find that Simba-C produces an increase in the amount of heavier elements (specifically Si and Fe) relative to O, compared to Simba.
[ 0.024238822981715202, 0.04222827032208443, 0.0038447787519544363, 0.0057382360100746155, -0.016973605379462242, 0.03672470897436142, 0.027955012395977974, -0.01167578250169754, -0.002179565140977502, -0.007406664080917835, -0.025087501853704453, -0.041379593312740326, -0.059561923146247864, -0.004227327648550272, -0.013630319386720657, 0.00867968425154686, -0.03600461781024933, 0.025010349228978157, -0.00011814014578703791, 0.0180923193693161, -0.01622779481112957, -0.03343285992741585, 0.016973605379462242, 0.03487304225564003, -0.09674955159425735, -0.0392964668571949, -0.03744480013847351, -0.01410609483718872, 0.031401168555021286, -0.03374147042632103, 0.01919817551970482, -0.007130200043320656, -0.027517814189195633, -0.07504390925168991, -0.07031187415122986, 0.043925631791353226, -0.007541681174188852, -0.00776028074324131, -0.023955928161740303, -0.05349257215857506, -0.00919403601437807, 0.02192424051463604, -0.02875225804746151, 0.01823376677930355, 0.0022840427700430155, -0.02562757208943367, -0.013090250082314014, -0.07077478617429733, 0.025434689596295357, -0.002276006154716015, -0.03585031256079674, 0.01074995007365942, 0.01990540884435177, -0.02859795279800892, -0.010074863210320473, 0.009033300913870335, 0.010724232532083988, 0.019185317680239677, -0.02718348614871502, -0.004471644759178162, -0.06125928461551666, -0.02821218967437744, 0.024135952815413475, 0.007110911887139082, -0.045057207345962524, 0.000442422810010612, -0.02589760720729828, 0.001259357901290059, 0.03433297201991081, -0.01707647554576397, -0.0029269824735820293, -0.01779656857252121, 0.011624347418546677, -0.02376304753124714, -0.021679922938346863, -0.02363445982336998, -0.037110473960638046, 0.01111642550677061, 0.01780942641198635, -0.012421593070030212, 0.018748117610812187, -0.0014530434273183346, 0.025833312422037125, -0.024418845772743225, 0.013861777260899544, -0.012627333402633667, 0.016909310594201088, -0.013360284268856049, -0.04004227742552757, 0.02492033876478672, 0.03384434059262276, 0.016034912317991257, -0.050637923181056976, 0.0274920966476202, 0.02504892647266388, -0.040093712508678436, 0.02107555978000164, -0.05071507394313812, 0.05832747742533684, 0.05606433004140854, 0.02862367033958435, -0.008821130730211735, 0.0032002318184822798, -0.0390135757625103, 0.06820303201675415, -0.007458099164068699, -0.024971773847937584, -0.000046663350076414645, 0.0020220449659973383, -0.023891635239124298, 0.025820454582571983, -0.017693696543574333, -0.037650540471076965, 0.04083952307701111, -0.0515894740819931, -0.01303881499916315, -0.06846020370721817, 0.011090707965195179, -0.05606433004140854, 0.024971773847937584, -0.02191138081252575, 0.013148114085197449, 0.014466140419244766, -0.021872805431485176, 0.00931619480252266, -0.014414705336093903, 0.010158445686101913, -0.04132815822958946, -0.06341955810785294, 0.010068434290587902, 0.021525617688894272, -0.00931619480252266, -0.017757991328835487, 0.005005284678190947, -0.016999322921037674, -0.013501731678843498, -0.0409938283264637, -0.03047533705830574, -0.045340098440647125, 0.013141685165464878, -0.012479457072913647, 0.037933435291051865, -0.018568094819784164, -0.021808510646224022, -0.01864524744451046, -0.015623431652784348, -0.05467558279633522, 0.017719414085149765, -0.058738961815834045, -0.0007148684235289693, -0.026797721162438393, 0.013154543936252594, -0.030783947557210922, -0.050329308956861496, -0.028572235256433487, 0.02048405446112156, -0.021988533437252045, 0.01994398608803749, 0.017449380829930305, -0.024393128231167793, 0.013308849185705185, 0.008731119334697723, -0.048631951212882996, -0.0023386927787214518, 0.015199092216789722, 0.01581631414592266, -0.015057644806802273, 0.015597714111208916, -0.08887996524572372, -0.021397029981017113, 0.019172457978129387, 0.0066415658220648766, -0.007310223300009966, -0.04114813357591629, -0.01738508604466915, 0.01991826854646206, 0.033947210758924484, -0.08414793014526367, -0.03312424570322037, 0.024676021188497543, 0.028520800173282623, 0.039219316095113754, -0.0234672948718071, -0.006461543031036854, -0.05750451609492302, -0.04199681431055069, -0.03757338970899582, 0.02903515100479126, 0.030809665098786354, -0.011052131652832031, -0.020265456289052963, 0.021268442273139954, 0.009425493888556957, 0.05122942477464676, -0.0776156634092331, -0.0344872809946537, 0.03178693354129791, 0.026797721162438393, -0.039090726524591446, 0.025280384346842766, 0.04840049147605896, -0.0015350182075053453, 0.09592658281326294, -0.07005469501018524, -0.053029656410217285, -0.008480372838675976, -0.023004379123449326, -0.00010548227874096483, -0.04374561086297035, -0.01323169656097889, 0.023981645703315735, -0.008023886010050774, -0.017616543918848038, -0.02133273519575596, -0.04798901081085205, -0.0004733642563223839, -0.0674315020442009, 0.01316740270704031, -0.03248130902647972, 0.055447109043598175, 0.019982561469078064, -0.02161562815308571, 0.05426410213112831, -0.02774927206337452, 0.008776125498116016, 0.02462458610534668, 0.04657454416155815, -0.021409887820482254, 0.031401168555021286, -0.018709542229771614, 0.009264759719371796, 0.026797721162438393, -0.047346070408821106, 0.013257414102554321, -0.003880140371620655, -0.0274920966476202, 0.00803674478083849, 0.04011942818760872, 0.020869819447398186, -0.003475088393315673, -0.03376718610525131, 0.012974521145224571, 0.0185166597366333, 0.03744480013847351, 0.010074863210320473, 0.02733779139816761, 0.00824891496449709, -0.030835382640361786, -0.028160754591226578, 0.04261403530836105, -0.003780484665185213, -0.02619335800409317, 0.021898522973060608, -0.0212041474878788, -0.003045926336199045, -0.02535753697156906, -0.030938252806663513, 0.020574066787958145, -0.005751094780862331, -0.024123093113303185, -0.04696030542254448, -0.04271690547466278, -0.03497591242194176, -0.022438591346144676, -0.02859795279800892, 0.03970794752240181, -0.006326525472104549, -0.016600700095295906, 0.006316881626844406, -0.0001951924350578338, -0.01994398608803749, 0.01609920710325241, 0.02731207385659218, -0.01849094219505787, -0.016536405310034752, 0.026026194915175438, -0.005484274588525295, 0.06650567054748535, -0.019262470304965973, -0.007593116257339716, 0.010293462313711643, -0.05848178640007973, 0.05961335822939873, 0.0230429545044899, -0.035515982657670975, 0.00803674478083849, 0.02104984223842621, -0.007091623730957508, 0.02648911066353321, -0.004648453090339899, 0.05014928802847862, -0.0018934570252895355, 0.010640650056302547, 0.011875093914568424, -0.030372465029358864, 0.01216441672295332, 0.02134559489786625, 0.01822090707719326, -0.03716190904378891, -0.002235822379589081, 0.030706794932484627, 0.002981632249429822, -0.007078764960169792, -0.006545125041157007, -0.019763963297009468, 0.025164654478430748, 0.04323125630617142, 0.010351327247917652, -0.00714948819950223, 0.03206982463598251, 0.04112241417169571, -0.006075778976082802, 0.026000477373600006, 0.011958676390349865, -0.03803630545735359, -0.011553624644875526, 0.02718348614871502, 0.018465224653482437, 0.04973780736327171, 0.01678072288632393, 0.012865221127867699, -0.04935204237699509, -0.023390142247080803, 0.027132051065564156, -0.02606477029621601, -0.031246863305568695, -0.0006702645332552493, 0.0025958686601370573, -0.0007325492915697396, -0.023454435169696808, 0.027929294854402542, 0.013488872908055782, 0.05863609164953232, 0.022451451048254967, -0.02291436679661274, -0.0039637223817408085, 0.0240330807864666, 0.04516007751226425, -0.03641609847545624, 0.017539391294121742, -0.021538475528359413, -0.011842947453260422, -0.022721484303474426, -0.003237200900912285, 0.030398184433579445, -0.024688880890607834, -0.0015784166753292084, 0.06470543891191483, 0.05678442493081093, 0.011013555340468884, 0.012479457072913647, 0.001679679611697793, 0.025164654478430748, 0.009284047409892082, 0.04657454416155815, 0.0054392688907682896, -0.014003223739564419, -0.018722400069236755, -0.006345813628286123, 0.007342370226979256, 0.03603033348917961, -0.004333412740379572, 0.04032517224550247, 0.0071687763556838036, 0.0025058570317924023, 0.04464572295546532, -0.040350887924432755, 0.044774312525987625, -0.027286356315016747, -0.0217699334025383, 0.003983010537922382, -0.013308849185705185, -0.04554583877325058, -0.011425036005675793, -0.05022643879055977, 0.003439726773649454, 0.04827190563082695, 0.0014361663488671184, -0.014723316766321659, 0.01906958781182766, 0.056167200207710266, -0.011386459693312645, -0.013411719352006912, -0.009052589535713196, 0.0011460398091003299, 0.04287121072411537, -0.030346747487783432, -0.005648224148899317, -0.08090751618146896, 0.03016672469675541, -0.031658343970775604, -0.004895985126495361, 0.006037202663719654, -0.024444563314318657, -0.009020442143082619, 0.04801472648978233, 0.00910402461886406, 0.046188779175281525, 0.04873482137918472, 0.0578131265938282, -0.012125840410590172, -0.04770611599087715, -0.031838368624448776, -0.027132051065564156, -0.02194995805621147, -0.03332998976111412, -0.025267526507377625, 0.043771326541900635, 0.011553624644875526, -0.0336386002600193, 0.03644181415438652, 0.0032388081308454275, 0.020574066787958145, -0.04999498277902603, -0.017025040462613106, 0.008724690414965153, -0.08430223912000656, 0.06491117924451828, -0.009631235152482986, 0.08980580419301987, -0.00048783040256239474, -0.017282215878367424, 0.0415596142411232, -0.02702918089926243, -0.03484732657670975, 0.0016081526409834623, 0.0024608513340353966, -0.00797245092689991, 0.01267876848578453, -0.004667741246521473, 0.0028867986984550953, 0.030321029946208, 0.009926986880600452, 0.010409192182123661, 0.0006224458920769393, 0.007239499595016241, 0.011341454461216927, -0.03173549845814705, 0.00345258554443717, -0.006789442151784897, 0.03371575102210045, -0.005021358374506235, 0.0049827815964818, -0.011437894776463509, 0.02605191245675087, -0.016832157969474792, -0.017050758004188538, 0.018439507111907005, -0.02535753697156906, -0.03803630545735359, -0.02294008433818817, -0.010332039557397366, -0.01111642550677061, 0.06264803558588028, -0.061567895114421844, -0.027389226481318474, 0.022142838686704636, -0.03831920027732849, 0.05338970199227333, -0.06398534774780273, 0.012762350961565971, 0.016883593052625656, 0.004796329420059919, -0.034538716077804565, 0.02702918089926243, -0.01075637899339199, 0.026154782623052597, 0.045622993260622025, 0.013733189553022385, 0.010827102698385715, -0.0006264642579481006, -0.04829762130975723, -0.03718762472271919, 0.0015944901388138533, -0.01994398608803749, -0.004159819334745407, 0.006098282057791948, -0.0424082949757576, 0.06722576171159744, 0.03399864584207535, -0.012254428118467331, 0.01109713688492775, 0.018439507111907005, 0.03304709494113922, 0.029986701905727386, 0.047037459909915924, -0.010878537781536579, -0.009521935135126114, 0.016343524679541588, 0.004722391255199909, -0.013630319386720657, -0.02362160012125969, 0.037367649376392365, -0.0137460483238101, 0.026849156245589256, -0.03927075117826462, -0.03520737215876579, -0.0311697106808424, -0.03075823001563549, 0.01608634926378727, 0.02875225804746151, 0.0055453539825975895, -0.022014250978827477, 0.020715514197945595, 0.005889326799660921, -0.02646339312195778, -0.04173963889479637, -0.005844320636242628, 0.013553166761994362, -0.01594490185379982, -0.029858114197850227, 0.031221145763993263, 0.031272582709789276, -0.032815635204315186, 0.02906086854636669, 0.0004167052102275193, -0.004105169326066971, -0.02052263170480728, 0.011746506206691265, -0.02547326683998108, -0.003545811865478754, 0.00028249158640392125, -0.021692780777812004, -0.018439507111907005, 0.010917114093899727, -0.037882000207901, 0.013488872908055782, -0.06352242827415466, -0.037239059805870056, -0.022605756297707558, 0.014466140419244766, -0.03464158624410629, 0.017693696543574333, -0.020985547453165054, -0.056578684598207474, -0.03502734750509262, -0.027929294854402542, 0.00919403601437807, -0.01981539838016033, -0.023853057995438576, 0.02207854576408863, -0.013122396543622017, 0.001507693319581449, -0.008171762339770794, -0.0024463851004838943, -0.0016153857577592134, -0.017680838704109192, -0.005288178101181984, 0.02249002642929554, 0.02648911066353321, 0.021461322903633118, 0.006567627657204866, 0.04253688454627991, 0.009721246547996998, -0.029832396656274796, -0.014144671149551868, -0.013951788656413555, -0.003523309016600251, 0.02165420539677143, 0.009380488656461239, -0.016626417636871338, -0.007618834264576435, -0.018606672063469887, 0.019146740436553955, -0.02432883344590664, -0.010235598310828209, 0.034230101853609085, -0.02606477029621601, -0.016433535143733025, 0.039090726524591446, -0.011560053564608097, -0.010222739540040493, 0.009219753555953503, -0.012447310611605644, 0.0004359933955129236, -0.02589760720729828, -0.02849508263170719, 0.009206894785165787, 0.009573370218276978, -0.009142600931227207, -0.03217269852757454, -0.016626417636871338, -0.004111598711460829, -0.007798857055604458, -0.06362529844045639, 0.012993808835744858, 0.007265217136591673, 0.0015888644848018885, 0.007850292138755322, 0.011830088682472706, -0.004744894336909056, -0.042768340557813644, 0.005953620653599501, -0.005821818020194769, -0.028289342299103737, 0.028160754591226578, 0.01994398608803749, -0.02137131243944168, 0.0054392688907682896, 0.006107925903052092, -0.0027646401431411505, -0.0007176813087426126, -0.05138373002409935, 0.006815159693360329, -0.002041333122178912, 0.012202993035316467, 0.028109319508075714, -0.027646401897072792, -0.030346747487783432, 0.004966708365827799, -0.016292089596390724, 0.03574744239449501, -0.024315975606441498, -0.021821370348334312, -0.008788984268903732, -0.0203554667532444, 0.0791587233543396, -0.032507024705410004, 0.00473203556612134, -0.032532744109630585, -0.03973366692662239, 0.020535489544272423, -0.00025617124629206955, -0.004722391255199909, 0.047191765159368515, 0.016549265012145042, 0.029858114197850227, -0.02733779139816761, -0.007001611869782209, -0.030218159779906273, -0.00633616978302598, -0.016870735213160515, -0.005712518002837896, -0.008866136893630028, -0.004214468877762556, 0.025267526507377625, 0.012145129032433033, 0.018696682527661324, 0.004722391255199909, 0.017552250996232033, 0.009547652676701546, 0.05210382491350174, 0.012961662374436855, -0.06465400755405426, 0.01666499488055706, 0.012479457072913647, 0.02164134569466114, -0.0015117117436602712, -0.02191138081252575, -0.007869580760598183, -0.023158684372901917, -0.02762068435549736, -0.02435455098748207, 0.006207581609487534, 0.006898741703480482, -0.014556151814758778, 0.03842207044363022, -0.013013097457587719, -0.006519407499581575, 0.022721484303474426, -0.03276420012116432, 0.006802300922572613, -0.0028257195372134447, 0.03379290550947189, -0.040633782744407654, 0.03129829838871956, -0.04310267046093941, 0.008043174631893635, -0.012826644815504551, 0.05022643879055977, 0.06614562124013901, -0.0012497138231992722, -0.00426590396091342, 0.011592200957238674, 0.011482900939881802, -0.008589672856032848, 0.02774927206337452, -0.05030359327793121, -0.028932280838489532, 0.044337112456560135, -0.024444563314318657, 0.008030315861105919, -0.031092558056116104, -0.040222302079200745, 0.04644595459103584, -0.009791970252990723, 0.004330198280513287, 0.0266434159129858, 0.0024399557150900364, -0.03317568078637123, 0.014839045703411102, 0.014041800051927567, 0.009419064968824387, -0.01836235448718071, 0.012511604465544224, -0.033227115869522095, -0.021744215860962868, 0.015983477234840393, -0.014427564106881618, -0.03988797217607498, 0.04312838613986969, -0.013205979019403458, 0.020715514197945595, -0.018619529902935028, -0.03669899329543114, -0.025164654478430748, 0.007580257486552, -0.006085423287004232, 0.047628965228796005, -0.0342043861746788, 0.02165420539677143, 0.011225725524127483, -0.014221823774278164, 0.022387156262993813, 0.03003813698887825, 0.0026794506702572107, -0.010222739540040493, -0.0010118262143805623, 0.013373143039643764, -0.009515506215393543, -0.01259518601000309, 0.007477387320250273, -0.053595442324876785, 0.00534282810986042, 0.020111151039600372, -0.019185317680239677, 0.012202993035316467, 0.026437675580382347, -0.0069951824843883514, -0.00861539039760828, 0.03289278969168663, 0.003857637522742152, 0.004085881169885397, -0.018336636945605278, -0.0087632667273283, 0.041070979088544846, -0.004664526786655188, -0.047757551074028015, -0.005072793457657099, 0.026437675580382347, 0.04914630204439163, -0.0025331820361316204, 0.019828256219625473, 0.012993808835744858, 0.003180943662300706, -0.01621493697166443, -0.006943747401237488, -0.008917571976780891, 0.01834949664771557, -0.028675105422735214, 0.04315410554409027, 0.010878537781536579, 0.016060631722211838, -0.004928132053464651, 0.047603245824575424, -0.007734563201665878, 0.010981407947838306, -0.005722162313759327, -0.01188152376562357, 0.018015166744589806, 0.02846936509013176, 0.016433535143733025, -0.00754811055958271, -0.0027582107577472925, -0.03176121413707733, 0.013694613240659237, 0.0035136649385094643, -0.01365603692829609, 0.03657040372490883, 0.00666085397824645, -0.010647079907357693, -0.008441796526312828, -0.0006316881626844406, -0.012601615861058235, 0.043617021292448044, 0.013553166761994362, 0.015160514973104, -0.039656512439250946, -0.00032548815943300724, 0.050175003707408905, 0.002063835971057415, -0.030089572072029114, 0.016574982553720474, 0.01089782640337944, -0.05138373002409935, 0.020394043996930122, 0.0006276697968132794, -0.01948106847703457, -0.026849156245589256, -0.016047772020101547, -0.0193653404712677, 0.018748117610812187, -0.0469345897436142, 0.018272342160344124, 0.005522850900888443, 0.0415596142411232, -0.008756836876273155, -0.11470042169094086, -0.011688641272485256, 0.04217683523893356, 0.020895536988973618, 0.007258787751197815, 0.01635638251900673, 0.023120107129216194, 0.028546517714858055, 0.012202993035316467, -0.005275319330394268, 0.0011404140386730433, -0.029960984364151955, 0.018902422860264778, -0.009875551797449589, -0.019571080803871155, -0.02236143872141838, -0.004105169326066971, -0.014929057098925114, 0.02023973874747753, 0.016343524679541588, -0.026437675580382347, 0.003777269972488284, -0.0045841592364013195, -0.01429897639900446, 0.032249849289655685, -0.013244555331766605, -0.022850072011351585, 0.0446714423596859, 0.006879453547298908, -0.016767865046858788, 0.021281300112605095, 0.003931575454771519, 0.0260776299983263, 0.041508179157972336, -0.009483358822762966, -0.011277160607278347, -0.0203554667532444, 0.010287033393979073, -0.017706556245684624, 0.038936421275138855, 0.000030790779419476166, -0.02023973874747753, 0.015327679924666882, 0.033947210758924484, 0.02849508263170719, 0.002468887949362397, -0.00981125794351101, 0.01581631414592266, -0.02194995805621147, 0.022425733506679535, 0.0220528282225132, 0.03826776519417763, -0.007856721989810467, 0.006866594776511192, -0.016703570261597633, 0.012389445677399635, 0.01951964572072029, 0.0011926529696211219, -0.017899438738822937, -0.013797483406960964, -0.014414705336093903, 0.04811759665608406, -0.030398184433579445, -0.03757338970899582, -0.026952028274536133, -0.024573151022195816, -0.0763297900557518, 0.008949719369411469, -0.004969922825694084, -0.008846848271787167, -0.028109319508075714, 0.019133882597088814, -0.004134101327508688, 0.005609647836536169, -0.0040505193173885345, 0.01651068776845932, -0.009701957926154137, 0.013553166761994362, -0.04793757572770119, 0.017706556245684624, 0.0007064298843033612, -0.007065906189382076, -0.004966708365827799, -0.008705401793122292, 0.014093236066401005, 0.024676021188497543, 0.015726301819086075, -0.014093236066401005, -0.009573370218276978, 0.025704724714159966, 0.005320325028151274, -0.0027614254504442215, 0.021255582571029663, 0.004854193888604641, -0.005397477652877569, 0.024984631687402725, 0.0032677403651177883, -0.012479457072913647, 0.00039601061143912375, -0.02690059132874012, 0.017449380829930305, 0.009232612326741219, -0.003058785106986761, -0.07386089861392975, 0.013257414102554321, -0.008602531626820564, -0.014504716731607914, 0.015752019360661507, 0.010254886001348495, 0.03047533705830574, 0.008242485113441944, 0.031812649220228195, 0.019738245755434036, 0.0073680877685546875, 0.024534573778510094, 0.016189219430088997, 0.009663381613790989, 0.008113897405564785, 0.014041800051927567, -0.02121700718998909, 0.006667283363640308, 0.008178191259503365, -0.03713618963956833, 0.018850987777113914, -0.003999084234237671, 0.02192424051463604, 0.0003232780727557838, 0.004571300465613604, -0.03371575102210045, 0.022837214171886444, -0.006930888630449772, 0.002965558785945177, 0.02137131243944168, -0.009869122877717018, -0.004664526786655188, 0.009843405336141586, 0.002570150885730982, 0.007785998284816742, -0.026026194915175438, 0.0056932298466563225, 0.008859707042574883, -0.004018372390419245, -0.004603447392582893, -0.010184163227677345, -0.025524701923131943, -0.002653733128681779, -0.008383932523429394, -0.02107555978000164, 0.026669133454561234, 0.02092125453054905, 0.007940303534269333, -0.013977506197988987, 0.019712528213858604, 0.027543531730771065, -0.006487260572612286, -0.009843405336141586, -0.01423468254506588, -0.014401846565306187, -0.008544666692614555, 0.011894382536411285, 0.06887169182300568, -0.012884508818387985, -0.034950196743011475, -0.018889565020799637, -0.02903515100479126, 0.01663927733898163, -0.0398622527718544, 0.0011797940824180841, 0.028829410672187805, -0.001501263934187591, 0.02377590537071228, -0.047783270478248596, 0.02179565280675888, 0.008769695647060871, -0.0089754369109869, 0.0019657877273857594, 0.03284135460853577, -0.007837433367967606, 0.022721484303474426, 0.012498745694756508, -0.007065906189382076, 0.010852820239961147, -0.017603686079382896, 0.0053589013405144215, 0.039656512439250946, -0.016832157969474792, -0.006635136436671019, 0.02318440191447735, 0.0036840438842773438, 0.013604601845145226, -0.04770611599087715, -0.003783699357882142, -0.02447028085589409, 0.02447028085589409, -0.014221823774278164, 0.02366017736494541, -0.0392964668571949, 0.016279229894280434, 0.00215384759940207, -0.03739336505532265, -0.005641794763505459, 0.010145586915314198, 0.009007583372294903, 0.007863150909543037, 0.00812032725661993, 0.005583930294960737, -0.01723078079521656, -0.01481332816183567, -0.000012249756764504127, -0.004561656154692173, -0.0018066602060571313, -0.002081516897305846, -0.011412177234888077, 0.023827340453863144, -0.013488872908055782, -0.005606433376669884, 0.02164134569466114, -0.03785628452897072, -0.009663381613790989, -0.03762482479214668, 0.03885926678776741, -0.035490263253450394, -0.05128085985779762, 0.01032560970634222, -0.00505671976134181, 0.039656512439250946, -0.007966021075844765, 0.003944434225559235, -0.037521954625844955, 0.011476472020149231, -0.006673712749034166, 0.03459015116095543, -0.017693696543574333, -0.036673273891210556, -0.009785540401935577, -0.02591046504676342, -0.012389445677399635, 0.01031918078660965, 0.007258787751197815, 0.019403915852308273, 0.04513435810804367, 0.008949719369411469, -0.020612642168998718, -0.011765794828534126, -0.021872805431485176, 0.0037161908112466335, 0.017333650961518288, -0.011849376372992992, 0.011662923730909824, -0.005673941690474749, -0.004548797383904457, -0.011270730756223202, -0.022888649255037308, 0.006175434682518244, 0.0013959825737401843, 0.026270510628819466, -0.0038479934446513653, 0.03330427035689354, -0.0034911618568003178, -0.006930888630449772, -0.01032560970634222, -0.018465224653482437, -0.04451713711023331, -0.022181415930390358, 0.004259474575519562, 0.014311835169792175, -0.03615892305970192, -0.00008584248280385509, 0.02052263170480728, -0.011785082519054413, 0.016292089596390724, 0.008506090380251408, 0.01724364049732685, 0.015199092216789722, -0.008518949151039124, 0.0019706098828464746, 0.004992425907403231, -0.001318829832598567, -0.004191966261714697, 0.0063200960867106915, 0.004892770200967789, -0.0006316881626844406, -0.00042594748083502054, -0.024598868563771248, 0.023428717628121376, 0.027234921231865883, 0.014800469391047955, -0.012659480795264244, 0.020162586122751236, -0.008538237772881985, -0.004969922825694084, 0.029369480907917023, 0.02408451773226261, -0.01696074567735195, 0.018722400069236755, -0.004494147840887308, 0.008705401793122292, 0.0046773855574429035, 0.013070961460471153, -0.011129284277558327, -0.015327679924666882, -0.019853973761200905, -0.0047706118784844875, -0.009663381613790989, -0.006284734234213829, 0.005831461865454912, -0.018568094819784164, -0.023132966831326485, -0.018182331696152687, 0.047037459909915924, -0.015700584277510643, 0.0051049403846263885, -0.03489876165986061, -0.008698972873389721, -0.014761893078684807, -0.02436741068959236, 0.006410107482224703, 0.0027823210693895817, 0.0024560291785746813, -0.0280578825622797, -0.00040103355422616005, -0.02276006154716015, 0.0005493115168064833, 0.0015133190900087357, -0.018323777243494987, 0.009271188639104366, -0.007901727221906185, -0.018272342160344124, -0.01487762201577425, 0.028520800173282623, 0.0068344478495419025, 0.03983653709292412, -0.002041333122178912, -0.03348429501056671, -0.03932218626141548, 0.04356558620929718, -0.04199681431055069, -0.01082067284733057, 0.016690712422132492, -0.024277398362755775, -0.0008012634352780879, 0.016279229894280434, -0.050637923181056976, -0.0106020737439394, 0.020818384364247322, 0.021448465064167976, -0.014466140419244766, -0.005336398724466562, 0.01577773690223694, -0.008576814085245132, 0.06388247758150101, -0.006705859676003456, -0.005821818020194769, -0.01635638251900673, 0.006885882932692766, 0.009168318472802639, -0.026514828205108643, 0.027569249272346497, 0.010505632497370243, 0.004304480738937855, -0.001292308559641242, -0.011283589527010918, -0.0038190612103790045, -0.023801622912287712, -0.007110911887139082, 0.002382091246545315, -0.016690712422132492, 0.006712289061397314, -0.0006180256605148315, -0.007650981191545725, -0.01295523252338171, 0.023943070322275162, 0.007785998284816742, 0.04924917221069336, -0.00618829345330596, -0.008885425515472889, 0.03999084234237671, -0.014041800051927567, 0.012010111473500729, 0.04032517224550247, 0.012620904482901096, -0.002664984669536352, 0.005622506607323885, 0.016163501888513565, -0.014620446600019932, -0.010833531618118286, -0.007785998284816742, 0.030269594863057137, 0.037933435291051865, 0.006718718446791172, 0.051872365176677704, 0.012826644815504551, 0.03201838955283165, -0.006892312318086624, 0.0260776299983263, -0.00968909915536642, -0.0018548807129263878, 0.009997710585594177, -0.02092125453054905, -0.02178279310464859, -0.00055694644106552, -0.02194995805621147, -0.017732273787260056, -0.001526981475763023, 0.028700822964310646, -0.0055453539825975895, 0.00426590396091342, 0.022027110680937767, -0.004211254417896271, -0.005297821946442127, -0.00629437854513526, -0.017745131626725197, -0.029138021171092987, 0.018992435187101364, 0.02520323172211647, -0.011759364977478981, 0.017719414085149765, 0.01323169656097889, 0.027132051065564156, 0.023287272080779076, -0.032275568693876266, 0.03441012650728226, -0.020329749211668968, 0.009579800069332123, -0.0024624585639685392, -0.035515982657670975, -0.02475317381322384, 0.02862367033958435, 0.015983477234840393, -0.002538003958761692, -0.009161888621747494, 0.03232700377702713, -0.014054659754037857, 0.023981645703315735, -0.019005294889211655, 0.027826424688100815, 0.004208039492368698, -0.02092125453054905, -0.037959154695272446, 0.019159600138664246, -0.008525379002094269, -0.028417930006980896, 0.009804829023778439, 0.0460859090089798, 0.02094697207212448, -0.027672119438648224, 0.0061272140592336655, 0.030526772141456604, 0.02193709835410118, 0.0032500596717000008, -0.01707647554576397, 0.010807814076542854, -0.007477387320250273, -0.02263147383928299, -0.011019984260201454, -0.013160972855985165, -0.011714358814060688, -0.01487762201577425, 0.026669133454561234, 0.003187373047694564, 0.04868338629603386, 0.02107555978000164, 0.012614474631845951, -0.029292328283190727, -0.013784624636173248, 0.048220470547676086, 0.004767396952956915, -0.03801058977842331, -0.0004946616245433688, -0.008364643901586533, 0.006291163619607687, 0.0008920786785893142, 0.019031012430787086, -0.040067993104457855, -0.004757753107696772, -0.04055662825703621, 0.01323169656097889, 0.005182093009352684, -0.01580345444381237, 0.014363270252943039, -0.02859795279800892, 0.0018195189768448472, 0.008544666692614555, -0.001120322267524898, 0.015121938660740852, 0.003999084234237671, 0.031684063374996185, -0.01723078079521656, 0.024701738730072975, 0.031966954469680786, -0.020869819447398186, 0.0020590140484273434, -0.018465224653482437, -0.04557155817747116, 0.0069887530989944935, 0.00033332398743368685, -0.011425036005675793, 0.004609876777976751, 0.008107468485832214, -0.014839045703411102, 0.0202140212059021, 0.014543293043971062, 0.026566263288259506, 0.01624065451323986, -0.0016242261044681072, 0.0010946046095341444, -0.022670049220323563, 0.00647440180182457, -0.006628707051277161, 0.00895614828914404, 0.005783241707831621, 0.0176679790019989, 0.003539382480084896, -0.010441338643431664, 0.06439682841300964, -0.018182331696152687, 0.0023563734721392393, 0.017307933419942856, -0.017693696543574333, 0.012209422886371613, -0.0306039247661829, -0.013887494802474976, 0.014350411482155323, -0.01402894128113985, -0.043771326541900635, -0.015623431652784348, 0.027697836980223656, 0.05791599676012993, -0.016574982553720474, 0.030321029946208, 0.02375018782913685, -0.030269594863057137, -0.024007363244891167, 0.01188795268535614, -0.013720330782234669, -0.038087740540504456, -0.008769695647060871, -0.0006533873383887112, 0.017410803586244583, -0.027543531730771065, 0.00526888994500041, -0.02322297729551792, -0.007657410576939583, 0.043334126472473145, 0.039219316095113754, 0.03456443175673485, 0.0016394959529861808, -0.009361200034618378, -0.0091876070946455, -0.0019400701858103275, -0.03284135460853577, -0.021525617688894272, 0.003161655506119132, -0.024727456271648407, 0.012653050944209099, 0.013308849185705185, 0.011322165839374065, -0.008737549185752869, 0.02076694928109646, 0.028932280838489532, 0.00591182941570878, 0.010094151832163334, -0.012042258866131306, 0.022181415930390358, 0.004507006611675024, 0.002906086854636669, -0.015764879062771797, 0.020856959745287895, 0.028366494923830032, -0.010608503594994545, 0.023814482614398003, -0.004580944310873747, 0.027646401897072792, 0.02291436679661274, -0.005114584229886532, -0.010801385156810284, 0.03474445641040802, -0.01252446323633194, 0.014800469391047955, 0.01881241239607334, 0.02762068435549736, 0.013488872908055782, -0.008872565813362598, 0.008988295681774616, 0.01116143073886633, 0.012145129032433033, -0.011174289509654045, -0.012665909714996815, -0.05364687740802765, -0.02677200362086296, 0.005905400030314922, 0.00022342150623444468, -0.008994724601507187, 0.0003737086371984333, 0.04570014402270317, 0.04431139677762985, -0.01167578250169754, -0.015559137798845768, -0.03178693354129791, -0.036364663392305374, 0.005712518002837896, 0.03397292643785477, 0.011759364977478981, -0.012055117636919022, -0.012627333402633667, -0.015147656202316284, 0.03700760379433632, -0.008358214981853962, 0.0007180831744335592, 0.03639037907123566, -0.010576356202363968, 0.016343524679541588, 0.04485146701335907, 0.004815617576241493, 0.002562114270403981, 0.01737222820520401, -0.03217269852757454, -0.013347425498068333, -0.007098053116351366, -0.02636052295565605, -0.03564457222819328, -0.04878625646233559, -0.009952704422175884, -0.02787785977125168, 0.04130243882536888, 0.037084754556417465, 0.018606672063469887, 0.02292722649872303, 0.008319638669490814, -0.013077391311526299, 0.0356188528239727, 0.00861539039760828, 0.017539391294121742, -0.003552241250872612, -0.025267526507377625, 0.024161670356988907, 0.01494191586971283, 0.02107555978000164, -0.030423901975154877, 0.028803693130612373, 0.032404154539108276, 0.017732273787260056, 0.014954774640500546, -0.022400015965104103, 0.0015551100950688124, 0.005169234238564968, 0.01002985704690218, -0.02066407911479473, 0.012235140427947044, -0.013784624636173248, 0.04474859684705734, 0.004468430299311876, -0.006522621959447861, -0.00840322021394968, 0.03644181415438652, 0.023840200155973434, -0.012202993035316467, 0.033947210758924484, 0.04315410554409027, -0.008268202655017376, 0.024148810654878616, 0.03232700377702713, -0.03587602823972702, 0.016279229894280434, -0.006541910115629435, 0.036801863461732864, 0.01438898779451847, 0.06918030232191086, 0.006439039949327707, 0.014890480786561966, 0.00016555693582631648, 0.029112303629517555, -0.009232612326741219, -0.008660396561026573, 0.03029531240463257, 0.019429633393883705, 0.002562114270403981, 0.027517814189195633, 0.02636052295565605, 0.0017182560404762626, 0.016202077269554138, -0.02507464401423931, 0.008319638669490814, 0.007811715826392174, -0.013501731678843498, 0.004214468877762556, -0.019609658047556877, 0.0189410001039505, -0.004561656154692173, -0.0180923193693161, -0.014067518524825573, -0.022528603672981262, 0.011431465856730938, 0.00776028074324131, -0.041765354573726654, 0.009399776346981525, -0.016484970226883888, -0.00048662489280104637, -0.01750081591308117, -0.005654653534293175, -0.014144671149551868, -0.031941238790750504, -0.004571300465613604, 0.013180261477828026, 0.05477845296263695, -0.023685894906520844, 0.005101725459098816, -0.0004914469318464398, 0.004957064054906368, 0.008351785130798817, 0.0015117117436602712, -0.03572172299027443, -0.011045701801776886, -0.008988295681774616, 0.02493319660425186, 0.023891635239124298, 0.012350869365036488, -0.019686810672283173, 0.0023242265451699495, -0.00459380354732275, -0.007831004448235035, 0.014684740453958511, -0.0016419069143012166, -0.016562122851610184, -0.014131812378764153, 0.014350411482155323, 0.0230429545044899, 0.021409887820482254, -0.001315615139901638, 0.0013606208376586437, 0.015996336936950684, -0.026411958038806915, 0.007110911887139082, -0.019018152728676796, 0.011515048332512379, -0.008859707042574883, -0.016022054478526115, 0.00903973076492548, 0.021152712404727936 ]
13.429914
6.03477
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.532..476H
[ "AGN feedback", "chemical enrichment", "Simba based simulation", "Simba", "gas mass fractions", "nearby galaxy groups", "gas entropy", "various physical mechanisms", "galaxy groups", "consistent matching" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
10
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1435", "10.48550/arXiv.2406.04761" ]
[ "Hough, Renier T.", "Shao, Zhiwei", "Cui, Weiguang", "Loubser, S. Ilani", "Babul, Arif", "Davé, Romeel", "Rennehan, Douglas", "Kobayashi, Chiaki" ]
[ "Centre for Space Research, North-West University, Potchefstroom 2520, South Africa", "Department of Astronomy, School of Physics and Astronomy, and Shanghai Key Laboratory for Particle Physics and Cosmology, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, China", "School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh EH9 3HJ, UK; Departamento de Física Teórica, M-8, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Cantoblanco 28049, Madrid, Spain; Centro de Investigación Avanzada en Física Fundamental (CIAFF), Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain", "Centre for Space Research, North-West University, Potchefstroom 2520, South Africa; National Institute for Theoretical and Computational Sciences (NITheCS), Potchefstroom 2520, South Africa", "Department of Physics &amp; Astronomy, University of Victoria, Victoria BC V8P 5C2, Canada", "School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh EH9 3HJ, UK; Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of the Western Cape, Bellville, 7535, South Africa", "Department of Physics &amp; Astronomy, University of Victoria, Victoria BC V8P 5C2, Canada; Center for Computational Astrophysics, Flatiron Institute, 162 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA", "Centre for Astrophysics Research, Department of Physics, Astronomy and Mathematics, University of Hertfordshire, Hatfield AL10 9AB, UK" ]
null
[ "1952MNRAS.112..195B", "1962ApJS....6..407W", "1986MNRAS.222..323K", "1989GeCoA..53..197A", "1991MNRAS.252..414E", "1997ApJ...488...35R", "1998ApJ...503..518F", "1999ApJ...510L...1P", "1999MNRAS.307..463B", "2000ApJ...536..623L", "2000MNRAS.315..356H", "2000MNRAS.318..889W", "2001ApJ...551L.139V", "2001ApJ...552..473D", "2001ApJ...556L..91S", "2001ApJ...560..599A", "2001Natur.414..425V", "2002ApJ...579...23D", "2002MNRAS.330..329B", "2002MNRAS.335..965Y", "2003ApJ...590..207P", "2003ApJ...594..136F", "2003MNRAS.338...14P", "2003MNRAS.343..331P", "2004A&A...419....7D", "2004ApJ...613..811M", "2004MNRAS.347..740K", "2004MNRAS.354...10M", "2005ApJ...618..569M", "2005ApJ...621..227M", "2005MNRAS.364.1105S", "2006A&A...447..553F", "2006A&A...452..795D", "2006ApJ...640..691V", "2006MNRAS.370.1147E", "2007A&A...465..345D", "2007ARA&A..45..117M", "2007ApJ...669..158G", "2007MNRAS.376.1465K", "2008MNRAS.385.2181F", "2008MNRAS.386.1309M", "2008MNRAS.386L..52K", "2008MNRAS.387.1403S", "2008MNRAS.391..110D", "2009A&A...498..361P", "2009ARA&A..47..481A", "2009ApJ...693.1142S", "2009ApJS..182..608K", "2010ApJ...709..191M", "2011A&A...535A.105E", "2011ApJ...729...16K", "2011ApJ...729...36K", "2011ApJ...733L..16S", "2011ApJ...736...45N", "2011MNRAS.414..129G", "2011MNRAS.415...11D", "2011MNRAS.415.1027H", "2011MNRAS.417.1510D", "2012A&A...538A.104G", "2012MNRAS.420..829O", "2012MNRAS.424.2971O", "2013A&A...555A..66L", "2013ApJ...776...27V", "2013ApJ...778...14G", "2013ApJ...778...74K", "2013MNRAS.433..695C", "2013MNRAS.434.2329K", "2013MNRAS.436.2929H", "2014A&A...563A..31R", "2014MNRAS.440.3202V", "2014MNRAS.441.1270L", "2014MNRAS.442.2751T", "2014MNRAS.445..581H", "2014MNRAS.445..794T", "2015A&A...573A.118L", "2015ARA&A..53...51S", "2015MNRAS.449..685H", "2015MNRAS.450...53H", "2015MNRAS.452L..59T", "2015MNRAS.454...83W", "2016ApJ...825..136D", "2016MNRAS.456.4266L", "2016MNRAS.462.3265D", "2017MNRAS.464..985G", "2017MNRAS.466.2217S", "2017MNRAS.470.4698A", "2017MNRAS.471.1088B", "2017MNRAS.472.1482O", "2017MNRAS.472L.109A", "2017arXiv171201294H", "2018MNRAS.476.2999M", "2018MNRAS.477..335L", "2018MNRAS.479.5385H", "2019MNRAS.483.3810R", "2019MNRAS.486.2827D", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020ApJ...895..138K", "2020ApJ...900..179K", "2020ApJ...903..148L", "2020MNRAS.493.1461L", "2020MNRAS.498.3061R", "2020MNRAS.499..597B", "2021MNRAS.503.4474Y", "2021MNRAS.506.2836R", "2021MNRAS.507.2383A", "2021Univ....7..139L", "2021Univ....7..208G", "2021Univ....7..209O", "2021Univ....7..254L", "2021arXiv210701206R", "2022ApJ...940...47K", "2022MNRAS.510..630H", "2022MNRAS.510.4191K", "2022MNRAS.514..977C", "2022MNRAS.515...22J", "2023ApJ...953..112F", "2023ApJ...956..118P", "2023MNRAS.519..300A", "2023MNRAS.520.3164A", "2023MNRAS.523.1228L", "2023MNRAS.524.2539P", "2023MNRAS.525.1061H", "2023MNRAS.525.5677S", "2023MNRAS.526.1367J", "2023arXiv230207255K", "2024MNRAS.527.1612Y", "2024MNRAS.527.7158L" ]
29059607
2309.16539
SUNBIRD: a simulation-based model for full-shape density-split clustering
Combining galaxy clustering information from regions of different environmental densities can help break cosmological parameter degeneracies and access non-Gaussian information from the density field that is not readily captured by the standard two-point correlation function (2PCF) analyses. However, modelling these density-dependent statistics down to the non-linear regime has so far remained challenging. We present a simulation-based model that is able to capture the cosmological dependence of the full shape of the density-split clustering (DSC) statistics down to intra-halo scales. Our models are based on neural-network emulators that are trained on high-fidelity mock galaxy catalogues within an extended-ΛCDM framework, incorporating the effects of redshift-space, Alcock-Paczynski distortions, and models of the halo-galaxy connection. Our models reach sub-per cent level accuracy down to $1 \, h^{-1}\text{Mpc}$ and are robust against different choices of galaxy-halo connection modelling. When combined with the galaxy 2PCF, DSC can tighten the constraints on ω<SUB>cdm</SUB>, σ<SUB>8</SUB>, and n<SUB>s</SUB> by factors of 2.9, 1.9, and 2.1, respectively, compared to a 2PCF-only analysis. DSC additionally puts strong constraints on environment-based assembly bias parameters.
[ 0.049639299511909485, 0.011918347328901291, 0.05617596209049225, 0.01245897263288498, 0.019609982147812843, 0.032953616231679916, 0.017275460064411163, 0.015788737684488297, -0.034772083163261414, 0.049147821962833405, -0.02085096389055252, 0.010235033929347992, -0.0395885705947876, 0.013515651226043701, 0.0019889508839696646, 0.022386834025382996, 0.01017974317073822, 0.02479507587850094, -0.0002885514695663005, 0.011648033745586872, -0.010474629700183868, -0.012391394935548306, -0.016231069341301918, 0.027866816148161888, -0.05563533678650856, -0.01311018131673336, 0.0558810755610466, 0.005759510677307844, 0.04799284785985947, -0.02244826778769493, 0.00222240318544209, -0.019315093755722046, -0.047747109085321426, -0.013957981951534748, -0.010744942352175713, 0.11677522957324982, -0.03307648375630379, 0.06197540462017059, -0.03283074498176575, 0.020052311941981316, 0.014584616757929325, -0.0003538259188644588, -0.016611963510513306, 0.027670225128531456, 0.019978590309619904, -0.05015535280108452, -0.005135947372764349, -0.05784698575735092, 0.020543789491057396, -0.004665971267968416, -0.018995633348822594, 0.027178745716810226, 0.008256834000349045, -0.050130780786275864, -0.04732935503125191, -0.0216373298317194, -0.0035785757936537266, 0.009166069328784943, 0.00579637149348855, -0.023013468831777573, -0.0020473140757530928, -0.03415773808956146, 0.005922312848269939, 0.0067516821436584, -0.03949027508497238, -0.006487512495368719, -0.015542998909950256, -0.0027630291879177094, -0.024512477219104767, 0.04125959798693657, -0.009245933964848518, -0.003051772713661194, 0.009307368658483028, -0.016403086483478546, 0.02105984278023243, -0.042955197393894196, -0.03125801682472229, 0.015334120951592922, -0.013208477757871151, 0.04506855458021164, -0.007562621030956507, 0.012704712338745594, -0.005888523533940315, -0.003246827982366085, -0.03133173659443855, -0.027399910613894463, 0.00842270813882351, 0.022829163819551468, -0.0500570572912693, 0.024598484858870506, 0.02126871980726719, -0.023013468831777573, -0.025016242638230324, -0.04226712882518768, 0.02139158919453621, -0.03980973735451698, 0.04310264065861702, -0.0552421510219574, 0.03577961400151253, 0.007046569138765335, 0.0027215606532990932, 0.011082833632826805, 0.01844272017478943, -0.06104159727692604, 0.06123818829655647, -0.01153130829334259, -0.029267529025673866, -0.0007180189713835716, -0.00037033652188256383, 0.007630199659615755, 0.05499641224741936, 0.022399120032787323, -0.04548630863428116, 0.025753458961844444, -0.004616823513060808, -0.022263964638113976, -0.04143161326646805, 0.016575103625655174, -0.01786523312330246, 0.04777168482542038, -0.0048533473163843155, -0.03700831159949303, 0.04966387525200844, 0.012563412077724934, 0.04280775412917137, -0.04251286759972572, -0.023775259032845497, -0.041235022246837616, -0.044675372540950775, 0.014068564400076866, -0.007163295056670904, 0.021698763594031334, 0.021661903709173203, -0.009829564951360226, -0.064432792365551, -0.012569556012749672, -0.0005375543260015547, -0.03027505800127983, 0.0007195548387244344, 0.018774468451738358, -0.01286444254219532, 0.028284572064876556, 0.04388900473713875, 0.028751475736498833, -0.002759957453235984, -0.005307964980602264, -0.023934990167617798, -0.00193058792501688, -0.05010620504617691, 0.05917397886514664, -0.03248671069741249, -0.00032886804547160864, -0.03273244947195053, -0.04632182419300079, -0.02253427729010582, -0.027670225128531456, -0.00020772634888999164, 0.021207286044955254, -0.0016648825258016586, -0.027473632246255875, -0.03875305876135826, 0.049516431987285614, -0.015174390748143196, -0.0024773573968559504, -0.023406650871038437, -0.011291712522506714, -0.021858494728803635, 0.04256201535463333, -0.05140862241387367, -0.017730077728629112, -0.019609982147812843, 0.0001842083438532427, -0.021895354613661766, -0.08586124330759048, 0.04583034664392471, 0.012581842951476574, -0.0017524270806461573, -0.03260958194732666, -0.004481667187064886, -0.02371382527053356, -0.012452829629182816, 0.026785563677549362, 0.0006892214296385646, -0.015751877799630165, -0.01679626852273941, 0.009657546877861023, 0.008901899680495262, -0.0038273867685347795, 0.008834321051836014, 0.020015450194478035, -0.02207965962588787, 0.01737375557422638, 0.037180326879024506, 0.017545772716403008, -0.018614737316966057, -0.0008869646117091179, 0.024610772728919983, 0.04845975339412689, -0.03174949437379837, 0.0005809426074847579, 0.0316266231238842, 0.022276250645518303, 0.013122468255460262, -0.07627741992473602, -0.018872763961553574, -0.045093126595020294, 0.02916923351585865, -0.01268013846129179, -0.007108003832399845, -0.016009902581572533, 0.00007300179277081043, -0.013589372858405113, 0.014535469003021717, 0.000983724370598793, -0.05416090041399002, -0.0037966694217175245, -0.030471650883555412, -0.0027553497347980738, 0.044601649045944214, 0.024205302819609642, 0.012508121319115162, 0.03413316234946251, 0.029095511883497238, -0.0009507032227702439, 0.007857508026063442, -0.050327371805906296, 0.041775647550821304, -0.020371772348880768, 0.015715016052126884, -0.010437768884003162, 0.037057459354400635, 0.042463719844818115, -0.01017974317073822, 0.013798250816762447, -0.02281687594950199, -0.004460164811462164, -0.017238598316907883, 0.007126434240490198, -0.017398329451680183, -0.032462138682603836, -0.028898919001221657, 0.015235825441777706, 0.032019805163145065, -0.008576295338571072, 0.008379703387618065, 0.025311129167675972, -0.017668642103672028, 0.02269400656223297, -0.020629798993468285, -0.013441929593682289, 0.010898529551923275, -0.00031658110674470663, 0.007789929863065481, -0.05411175265908241, -0.02335750311613083, 0.006097401957958937, -0.02872690185904503, -0.006843834184110165, -0.0036891584750264883, 0.0030256628524512053, -0.0380895622074604, -0.019388815388083458, -0.018295276910066605, -0.007421321235597134, 0.002380597637966275, 0.013011885806918144, 0.018700746819376945, -0.0435941182076931, -0.050867997109889984, 0.01114426925778389, 0.01011830847710371, -0.013355921022593975, 0.03575504198670387, -0.01311018131673336, -0.04747679829597473, 0.011052116751670837, -0.02429131232202053, 0.0319460853934288, 0.032265543937683105, -0.01892191171646118, -0.0374506413936615, -0.018221555277705193, 0.026367807760834694, 0.019757425412535667, 0.0018906552577391267, 0.02101069502532482, -0.024057859554886818, 0.017766937613487244, -0.018012676388025284, -0.031528327614068985, 0.039883457124233246, -0.06551405042409897, -0.039391979575157166, 0.013429642654955387, -0.03604992851614952, 0.0021532890386879444, -0.0045676757581532, 0.017558060586452484, -0.04654298722743988, 0.025532294064760208, -0.008269120939075947, -0.000772158382460475, 0.007611769251525402, -0.0014798102201893926, -0.008840464986860752, -0.000444634206360206, 0.04059610143303871, 0.04275860637426376, 0.03418231010437012, 0.028284572064876556, -0.011015255935490131, 0.03229011967778206, -0.004226712975651026, 0.03573046624660492, -0.017472051084041595, -0.010751086287200451, 0.00035516981733962893, -0.018184693530201912, 0.03912166878581047, -0.044847387820482254, -0.0540134571492672, -0.05047481507062912, -0.06064841151237488, -0.06664444506168365, -0.01491636410355568, -0.03514069318771362, -0.03260958194732666, 0.02032262459397316, -0.0012932020472362638, -0.021821632981300354, 0.01280300784856081, 0.04968844726681709, 0.06055011600255966, -0.01732460781931877, 0.008176969364285469, -0.04329923167824745, -0.0017232454847544432, 0.06954416632652283, -0.002953476971015334, 0.006487512495368719, -0.03315020725131035, 0.027793094515800476, -0.02077724225819111, -0.00933808647096157, 0.05150691792368889, 0.017312319949269295, 0.0013607803266495466, 0.06472768634557724, 0.02769479900598526, -0.020801816135644913, -0.013540225103497505, -0.014498608186841011, 0.01040705107152462, -0.04261116310954094, 0.0546523779630661, -0.010536064393818378, -0.001236374955624342, -0.0389987975358963, 0.009209073148667812, 0.00495778676122427, 0.0497375950217247, -0.004060838837176561, 0.04438048228621483, 0.05912483111023903, 0.0036215800791978836, 0.013761390000581741, -0.05735550820827484, 0.022313112393021584, -0.0337645560503006, -0.028825197368860245, -0.004156062845140696, 0.004036264959722757, -0.058485910296440125, 0.000944559695199132, -0.07283707708120346, 0.021846206858754158, 0.030913980677723885, 0.036123648285865784, 0.05165436118841171, -0.0010935390600934625, 0.072443887591362, 0.0346737876534462, 0.017582634463906288, -0.03735234588384628, 0.004914782475680113, 0.020617511123418808, -0.001809254172258079, -0.02634323388338089, -0.06900354474782944, -0.0038212432991713285, -0.012311529368162155, -0.007961947470903397, 0.03428060561418533, 0.03015218861401081, -0.022300824522972107, -0.020949259400367737, 0.031356312334537506, -0.002199365058913827, 0.027743946760892868, 0.06959331780672073, -0.021539032459259033, -0.012839868664741516, -0.0448228158056736, -0.043323807418346405, -0.019732851535081863, 0.025163685902953148, 0.018184693530201912, 0.05362027511000633, 0.04607608541846275, 0.011740186251699924, 0.041849371045827866, -0.045166850090026855, 0.03027505800127983, -0.03369083255529404, 0.003830458503216505, -0.016231069341301918, -0.06492427736520767, 0.0552421510219574, 0.032462138682603836, 0.06335154175758362, 0.008262977935373783, 0.004008619114756584, 0.02749820612370968, -0.013663094490766525, 0.002480429131537676, 0.0322163961827755, -0.015076094307005405, 0.013478790409862995, -0.026933006942272186, -0.06408876180648804, -0.013294486328959465, 0.05681488290429115, 0.026244936510920525, 0.01905706897377968, -0.019204512238502502, -0.00038646315806545317, 0.02114585041999817, 0.0025357205886393785, 0.004417160525918007, -0.007028138730674982, 0.030373355373740196, -0.0021425378508865833, -0.031602051109075546, -0.06177881360054016, 0.0509662926197052, 0.003051772713661194, 0.0112057039514184, 0.009608399122953415, 0.0135033642873168, -0.010585212148725986, -0.0047274064272642136, -0.006419934332370758, -0.019536258652806282, -0.009467099793255329, -0.06733251363039017, -0.03479665890336037, 0.0174966249614954, -0.021932216361165047, 0.04452792927622795, -0.057748690247535706, 0.04673957824707031, 0.022067371755838394, -0.04032578691840172, 0.03600078076124191, -0.023283781483769417, 0.020457781851291656, -0.031651198863983154, 0.02781766839325428, -0.008969477377831936, 0.060206081718206406, 0.024598484858870506, -0.05322709307074547, 0.024930233135819435, -0.015665868297219276, 0.021784773096442223, 0.004656756296753883, 0.012465116567909718, -0.024451041594147682, 0.029316676780581474, -0.01707886904478073, 0.03577961400151253, -0.045707475394010544, -0.03666427731513977, 0.03929368406534195, 0.028161702677607536, 0.0091353515163064, -0.006005249451845884, 0.00701585179194808, 0.030913980677723885, 0.01679626852273941, -0.02602377161383629, -0.04066982492804527, 0.053521979600191116, -0.011660320684313774, 0.00876674335449934, -0.01790209487080574, 0.00040854126564227045, 0.010155169293284416, -0.004454021342098713, 0.04076812043786049, 0.05396430939435959, -0.029316676780581474, 0.02502852864563465, -0.004546173382550478, 0.005059154238551855, 0.0377701036632061, -0.023775259032845497, -0.028898919001221657, -0.02683471143245697, -0.02228853851556778, -0.02048235572874546, 0.09588740020990372, 0.011236420832574368, -0.002121035708114505, 0.025532294064760208, 0.008318268693983555, -0.02093697339296341, -0.013405068777501583, 0.03676257282495499, -0.015530711971223354, 0.0254831463098526, 0.0004511616425588727, -0.004552317317575216, 0.015112955123186111, 0.0014076243387535214, -0.03391199931502342, -0.021453024819493294, -0.11009112000465393, -0.02146531082689762, -0.03450177237391472, 0.003784382250159979, -0.036688849329948425, 0.003581647528335452, 0.03369083255529404, -0.03769638016819954, -0.005808658432215452, 0.006524373311549425, -0.017422903329133987, -0.007943516597151756, -0.010923103429377079, 0.029070938006043434, 0.013368207961320877, 0.0016879205359146, -0.014523182064294815, 0.0072861649096012115, 0.013097894378006458, -0.003471065079793334, 0.004306578077375889, 0.04428218677639961, 0.027424484491348267, 0.020396346226334572, -0.03600078076124191, -0.011691038496792316, 0.023197771981358528, -0.026760989800095558, 0.013257625512778759, 0.03538643196225166, -0.00017316927551291883, -0.006097401957958937, -0.020642085000872612, -0.022644858807325363, 0.004039336461573839, 0.00343727576546371, 0.03961314633488655, 0.0026693411637097597, -0.051359474658966064, 0.013736816123127937, -0.008090960793197155, -0.04076812043786049, 0.017103442922234535, -0.02376297302544117, 0.016734832897782326, -0.01390883419662714, -0.07190326601266861, -0.0031224226113408804, -0.001846115104854107, -0.005624353885650635, 0.014523182064294815, 0.012059646658599377, -0.05015535280108452, -0.03673799708485603, 0.027227893471717834, 0.01569044217467308, -0.0013077928451821208, -0.06644785404205322, -0.012839868664741516, 0.0061004734598100185, 0.014240581542253494, 0.0018123260233551264, -0.013613946735858917, 0.016046764329075813, -0.00469976058229804, 0.009356516413390636, -0.012434398755431175, -0.03872848302125931, 0.012225520797073841, 0.013183903880417347, 0.015542998909950256, 0.013147043064236641, -0.020519215613603592, 0.007912799715995789, -0.009270507842302322, -0.03639396280050278, -0.03224097192287445, -0.028038833290338516, -0.007003564853221178, -0.009221360087394714, 0.02749820612370968, -0.02872690185904503, 0.01999087631702423, -0.00011797397019108757, 0.013933408074080944, 0.003593934467062354, -0.0626634731888771, -0.015088381245732307, 0.004540029913187027, 0.007710064761340618, -0.0349932499229908, 0.05632340535521507, -0.01245897263288498, -0.014768920838832855, -0.005188167095184326, -0.0037690235767513514, -0.017349181696772575, 0.043987300246953964, -0.022976607084274292, -0.004755051806569099, -0.027891390025615692, -0.03113514557480812, -0.03069281578063965, -0.008760599419474602, -0.008619299158453941, 0.021575894206762314, 0.005458480212837458, 0.01292587723582983, 0.01695599965751171, 0.008391990326344967, 0.056765735149383545, -0.02560601569712162, -0.02634323388338089, 0.0001548348373034969, 0.05273561552166939, 0.034231457859277725, -0.05593022331595421, 0.019413389265537262, 0.010394764132797718, 0.002137930365279317, -0.009362660348415375, -0.01292587723582983, -0.016439946368336678, 0.005599780008196831, -0.016194207593798637, -0.0017770009580999613, 0.04071897268295288, 0.0015850173076614738, -0.0017493553459644318, -0.0037014454137533903, 0.002546471543610096, -0.033862851560115814, 0.03241299092769623, -0.011174986138939857, 0.025261981412768364, -0.006146549712866545, 0.0005252673290669918, -0.00047842334606684744, 0.004665971267968416, 0.013650807552039623, 0.030422503128647804, -0.02125643379986286, 0.00766091700643301, 0.044183891266584396, 0.0393182598054409, 0.0346737876534462, 0.036074500530958176, -0.028456589207053185, 0.0024773573968559504, -0.019609982147812843, -0.041603632271289825, -0.02995559759438038, 0.03762265667319298, -0.006567377597093582, 0.0328553207218647, -0.00017316927551291883, -0.013245338574051857, 0.025163685902953148, 0.010167456232011318, 0.02934125065803528, 0.006800829898566008, 0.006321638822555542, -0.0041898516938090324, 0.0012263917597010732, -0.03526356443762779, 0.02585175447165966, -0.005117516964673996, -0.006942130159586668, -0.022890597581863403, 0.020764954388141632, 0.01497779879719019, 0.01909392885863781, -0.03445262461900711, 0.02298889495432377, 0.010523777455091476, -0.006997421383857727, -0.01618192158639431, -0.007918942719697952, -0.0066718170419335365, -0.028505736961960793, 0.004469380248337984, 0.03904794529080391, -0.0365414060652256, 0.04047323390841484, 0.021870780736207962, -0.04290604963898659, -0.009866425767540932, 0.0004864866496063769, -0.028825197368860245, -0.0173368938267231, 0.008115534670650959, -0.015801025554537773, -0.0191799383610487, -0.016452234238386154, -0.02351723238825798, -0.057257212698459625, 0.0017923596315085888, 0.020961547270417213, -0.029120085760951042, -0.055537041276693344, -0.0005651999381370842, -0.004091556183993816, -0.005596708506345749, 0.0310122761875391, 0.019880294799804688, -0.005295678041875362, -0.0009115385473705828, 0.00695441709831357, 0.0019014064455404878, 0.01630479097366333, 0.0018415075028315187, -0.006146549712866545, 0.024573910981416702, 0.02262028492987156, 0.023873554542660713, 0.030840259045362473, 0.004512384533882141, 0.00046767224557697773, 0.015137529000639915, 0.01704200729727745, 0.011549738235771656, 0.022718580439686775, -0.0022270106710493565, 0.0010059945052489638, 0.0098971426486969, -0.015825599431991577, -0.0026693411637097597, 0.002789139049127698, -0.02597462385892868, -0.012028929777443409, 0.002821392146870494, 0.04445420578122139, 0.007323025725781918, 0.053816866129636765, 0.03831072896718979, 0.012962738052010536, 0.04646926745772362, -0.044601649045944214, 0.0008938760147430003, -0.04560917988419533, -0.016501381993293762, -0.0011780118802562356, -0.031208867207169533, -0.016857704147696495, 0.01965912990272045, -0.006383073516190052, 0.0182707030326128, 0.01744747720658779, 0.019450251013040543, 0.018663885071873665, 0.006327782291918993, -0.01048691663891077, 0.012372964061796665, -0.00802952516824007, -0.03167577087879181, 0.04199681431055069, -0.013601659797132015, -0.013208477757871151, -0.028038833290338516, -0.01163574680685997, -0.013871973380446434, 0.02142845094203949, 0.01510066818445921, -0.013552512042224407, 0.036688849329948425, -0.03260958194732666, 0.06030437722802162, -0.018897337839007378, 0.019720563665032387, -0.00751961674541235, -0.10026156157255173, -0.020924685522913933, 0.011095120571553707, 0.04170192778110504, -0.0065796650014817715, 0.0071387211792171, 0.002893578028306365, 0.0319460853934288, 0.010972251184284687, 0.01175861619412899, -0.00854557752609253, -0.0340840145945549, 0.0025265051517635584, 0.04907410219311714, 0.03609907627105713, -0.05022907629609108, -0.031602051109075546, 0.0059653171338140965, -0.018160119652748108, -0.007875938899815083, -0.00784522108733654, 0.008054099045693874, 0.0285548847168684, 0.03929368406534195, -0.02413158118724823, -0.01433887705206871, -0.008312125690281391, -0.028628606349229813, 0.009356516413390636, 0.01390883419662714, 0.021035268902778625, -0.011746329255402088, -0.020457781851291656, 0.015297260135412216, -0.008760599419474602, -0.007169438526034355, -0.009989295154809952, -0.0017754650907590985, -0.04966387525200844, -0.008920329622924328, -0.0009361124248243868, -0.03740149363875389, 0.021575894206762314, 0.018541015684604645, 0.017889807000756264, 0.010517634451389313, -0.02053150348365307, -0.005258817225694656, -0.0066656735725700855, 0.04489653557538986, -0.0036553693935275078, -0.0031946084927767515, -0.026760989800095558, -0.001839971635490656, 0.0007656309171579778, 0.008496429771184921, 0.011015255935490131, 0.03457549214363098, 0.012901303358376026, 0.011181130073964596, -0.01888505183160305, 0.004328079987317324, 0.0008117069955915213, -0.003704517148435116, -0.07318110764026642, -0.028087981045246124, -0.04462622478604317, 0.01830756478011608, -0.005108301993459463, -0.01905706897377968, -0.00009517591388430446, 0.026859285309910774, 0.009731268510222435, -0.0035417149774730206, -0.03248671069741249, -0.007181725464761257, -0.0006619597552344203, 0.0033359085209667683, -0.03892507404088974, 0.02634323388338089, -0.017263172194361687, 0.010321042500436306, -0.006794686429202557, -0.006254060659557581, -0.0008739097393117845, 0.03315020725131035, -0.025556867942214012, -0.0002382517559453845, -0.034305181354284286, 0.039146240800619125, 0.004463236778974533, 0.004739693365991116, 0.025655163452029228, -0.021821632981300354, -0.004982360638678074, 0.007163295056670904, 0.0020012378226965666, -0.019523972645401955, 0.03283074498176575, -0.016931425780057907, -0.008004951290786266, 0.007040425669401884, -0.009000195190310478, -0.007224729750305414, 0.019880294799804688, -0.011598885990679264, -0.0024236019235104322, -0.0024297453928738832, -0.005172808188945055, 0.032265543937683105, 0.01585017330944538, 0.015493851155042648, -0.025999197736382484, 0.010763373225927353, 0.029488693922758102, -0.0031946084927767515, 0.005863949656486511, 0.005452336743474007, -0.006794686429202557, 0.010271894745528698, 0.01585017330944538, -0.01847958192229271, -0.03118429332971573, 0.00720015587285161, -0.0032867607660591602, -0.0030917052645236254, -0.0066779605112969875, 0.01565358228981495, -0.021686477586627007, 0.019757425412535667, -0.0402274914085865, 0.0013669237960129976, 0.043078064918518066, 0.032511286437511444, -0.004346510395407677, 0.03538643196225166, 0.041480761021375656, 0.04035036265850067, 0.0004968537832610309, 0.012950451113283634, -0.004401802085340023, -0.0066349562257528305, -0.0017171020153909922, -0.017422903329133987, 0.019278233870863914, 0.005882380064576864, 0.013294486328959465, -0.03356796130537987, 0.04379070922732353, 0.04035036265850067, -0.001972056459635496, 0.010708081535995007, -0.01745976321399212, -0.022730868309736252, 0.004487810656428337, -0.002108748769387603, 0.012778433971107006, -0.008471855893731117, 0.0010505346581339836, 0.017349181696772575, 0.012329960241913795, 0.04364326596260071, -0.009909429587423801, -0.014129999093711376, 0.020887823775410652, 0.022190241143107414, -0.018344424664974213, 0.012667851522564888, -0.032879892736673355, -0.0009622222278267145, 0.009663690812885761, -0.07829248160123825, -0.014756633900105953, 0.009780417196452618, 0.006942130159586668, 0.00733531266450882, -0.01245897263288498, 0.023787546902894974, -0.0060513257049024105, 0.010947677306830883, -0.008060242980718613, -0.008318268693983555, 0.012667851522564888, -0.024328172206878662, 0.06379387527704239, 0.003987117204815149, 0.020126033574342728, 0.00107587652746588, 0.010271894745528698, 0.007052712608128786, -0.024881085380911827, 0.031356312334537506, -0.0016633466584607959, 0.042709458619356155, 0.0383598767220974, 0.01786523312330246, -0.05288305878639221, 0.041038431227207184, 0.004862562753260136, 0.007937373593449593, -0.011082833632826805, -0.010456199757754803, -0.030987702310085297, -0.025655163452029228, -0.007630199659615755, 0.007101860363036394, 0.0011265602661296725, -0.006419934332370758, -0.025163685902953148, -0.05199839547276497, 0.019450251013040543, 0.0031162791419774294, 0.026564398780465126, 0.021993650123476982, 0.032142676413059235, -0.05617596209049225, 0.036516834050416946, 0.01139000803232193, -0.015579859726130962, -0.059960342943668365, 0.0359024852514267, -0.023197771981358528, -0.016734832897782326, 0.023873554542660713, -0.007753069046884775, 0.02216566726565361, 0.02130558155477047, -0.004463236778974533, -0.007169438526034355, 0.013957981951534748, 0.013527938164770603, 0.01589932106435299, 0.02811255492269993, -0.003818171564489603, -0.03233926743268967, -0.030127614736557007, -0.030963128432631493, 0.00405469536781311, 0.00835512951016426, -0.004613752011209726, 0.009448668919503689, -0.014424885623157024, -0.007961947470903397, -0.012950451113283634, -0.0003451866505201906, 0.02179705910384655, 0.01761949434876442, -0.02737533673644066, 0.01169718150049448, -0.0079865213483572, -0.02536027692258358, 0.005661214701831341, -0.016292503103613853, 0.023173198103904724, -0.014326590113341808, 0.03602535277605057, -0.0031577476765960455, 0.03514069318771362, 0.04170192778110504, -0.018418146297335625, -0.009411808103322983, -0.0181109718978405, -0.04243914410471916, -0.018860476091504097, 0.03457549214363098, -0.02191992849111557, -0.01962226815521717, -0.004902495536953211, 0.0009883319726213813, -0.019032495096325874, 0.02339436300098896, -0.012790720909833908, 0.010437768884003162, 0.004014762584120035, -0.005261888727545738, -0.005129803903400898, 0.024561624974012375, -0.013073320500552654, 0.004942427854984999, 0.032019805163145065, -0.012606416828930378, -0.019204512238502502, -0.026048345491290092, -0.004914782475680113, -0.0036768715362995863, 0.015837885439395905, -0.012581842951476574, 0.01589932106435299, 0.031847789883613586, -0.020334912464022636, -0.03575504198670387, 0.011303999461233616, -0.013368207961320877, -0.0014974727528169751, -0.007808360271155834, -0.03211810067296028, 0.035165268927812576, 0.010978395119309425, 0.000901555351447314, -0.03356796130537987, -0.00592845631763339, -0.02769479900598526, -0.0036707280669361353, -0.01589932106435299, 0.01532183401286602, -0.0174966249614954, -0.000046988006943138316, -0.0027445987798273563, -0.02577803283929825, -0.023652389645576477, -0.005037651862949133, -0.02892349287867546, -0.006800829898566008, 0.018577877432107925, 0.013675381429493427, -0.007501186337321997, 0.011347003281116486, 0.011322429403662682, -0.006171123590320349, 0.007525760214775801, -0.013724529184401035, -0.021035268902778625, 0.041357893496751785, -0.029636137187480927, -0.0365414060652256, -0.03924453631043434, 0.013171616941690445, -0.03064366802573204, 0.035214416682720184, 0.02737533673644066, 0.014646051451563835, 0.04170192778110504, 0.0008915722137317061, -0.027719372883439064, -0.02397185005247593, 0.0254831463098526, -0.016869990155100822, -0.004149919375777245, 0.023984137922525406, 0.02499166876077652, -0.015420129522681236, 0.009288938716053963, -0.021416163071990013, -0.024082433432340622, -0.035017821937799454, 0.04600236192345619, 0.02330835536122322, -0.007212442811578512, 0.001858402043581009, 0.0016587390564382076, 0.0656614899635315, -0.03359253704547882, -0.013429642654955387, -0.016157345846295357, 0.04175107553601265, 0.013613946735858917, -0.020789528265595436, 0.012692425400018692, 0.007421321235597134, -0.0003302119439467788, 0.011095120571553707, 0.021735625341534615, -0.01712801679968834, 0.018344424664974213, 0.035214416682720184, -0.009829564951360226, -0.011734042316675186, 0.01679626852273941, -0.014609190635383129, -0.008852751925587654, -0.014805781655013561, -0.006174195092171431, -0.011383864097297192, -0.006407647393643856, 0.018627025187015533, -0.014695199206471443, -0.030545372515916824, -0.022337686270475388, -0.025212833657860756, 0.04125959798693657, -0.012059646658599377, -0.006733251735568047, -0.013122468255460262, 0.001700207474641502, -0.015198964625597, -0.020838676020503044, -0.022976607084274292, 0.022055085748434067, 0.01831985078752041, 0.00023191628861241043, 0.03550930321216583, -0.025950049981474876, -0.003222254104912281, -0.05145777016878128, -0.008981764316558838, 0.0066656735725700855, 0.000989867839962244, -0.005799442995339632, 0.015641294419765472, 0.024487903341650963, -0.004263573791831732, -0.014990085735917091, 0.012594129890203476, -0.025335703045129776, -0.0054738386534154415, 0.03378912806510925, 0.00901248212903738, 0.03428060561418533, 0.031405460089445114, 0.001039015711285174, -0.03393657132983208, 0.0013231515185907483, -0.03875305876135826, 0.0356321707367897, -0.002320698695257306, -0.03602535277605057, 0.0072984518483281136, 0.018123259767889977, -0.0067025343887507915, 0.001706350944004953, -0.008908042684197426, 0.011445298790931702, -0.023898128420114517, -0.029636137187480927, -0.008723738603293896, 0.013896547257900238, -0.03592705726623535, 0.040424082428216934, -0.0008854287443682551, -0.028530310839414597, -0.018258417025208473, 0.00817082542926073, -0.010290325619280338, 0.00520352553576231, -0.020248902961611748, 0.007765355985611677, -0.014768920838832855, -0.0011741721536964178, -0.041038431227207184, 0.023492658510804176, -0.0075994823127985, 0.0033236215822398663, -0.001694064005278051, 0.028014259412884712, 0.026736415922641754, -0.006389216985553503, 0.009202930144965649, 0.013785963878035545, 0.02450018934905529, -0.013294486328959465, -0.02060522511601448, 0.022177955135703087, 0.004340366926044226, -0.0024589269887655973, 0.01867617294192314, 0.010431624948978424, -0.00234527257271111, -0.046936169266700745, -0.004214426036924124, -0.0231854859739542, 0.00222240318544209, 0.017140302807092667, 0.01247740350663662, 0.0033758410718292, -0.012366821058094501, 0.030127614736557007, -0.008287551812827587, 0.011709468439221382, -0.006389216985553503, -0.03093855455517769, 0.017545772716403008, 0.02237454615533352, -0.01298731192946434, -0.004266645293682814, -0.023910416290163994, -0.02491794526576996, -0.003698373679071665, 0.0072984518483281136, -0.014768920838832855, 0.015088381245732307, -0.021981364116072655, 0.014805781655013561, 0.0011488304007798433, 0.018860476091504097, 0.009983151219785213, -0.013454216532409191, 0.03133173659443855, -0.028259998187422752, 0.019192224368453026, 0.006856121122837067, -0.012471260502934456, 0.00856400839984417, -0.050622258335351944, -0.024893371388316154, 0.0030195193830877542, -0.01790209487080574, -0.00463832588866353, 0.001870688982307911, 0.040792692452669144, -0.013233051635324955, 0.011494447477161884, 0.01761949434876442, 0.023468084633350372, 0.004500097595155239, -0.0024404965806752443, -0.012962738052010536, -0.03182321414351463, -0.02069123275578022, -0.007568764500319958, 0.006794686429202557, 0.033125631511211395, 0.005618210416287184, -0.01860245130956173, 0.011955208145081997, 0.008557864464819431, -0.0025203616824001074, -0.016353938728570938, -0.012164086103439331, -0.03897422179579735, -0.018872763961553574, -0.0024051715154200792, -0.013515651226043701, 0.06074671074748039, -0.039269112050533295, -0.017103442922234535, -0.04457707703113556, 0.0008431923342868686, -0.02158818207681179, -0.012704712338745594, 0.00979270413517952, 0.009780417196452618, -0.028579458594322205, 0.024647632613778114, 0.015874747186899185, 0.014523182064294815, 0.0079865213483572, -0.0008977156830951571, 0.0029319748282432556, 0.013417355716228485, 0.0012179444311186671, 0.0002849037991836667, -0.005390901584178209, 0.0060144648887217045, 0.0190447811037302, 0.02769479900598526, 0.024352746084332466, 0.0067271082662045956, -0.04703446477651596, -0.021416163071990013, 0.01409313827753067, -0.005268032196909189, -0.018823616206645966, 0.02044549398124218, -0.004346510395407677, 0.02781766839325428, -0.010308755561709404, 0.03904794529080391, -0.011439155787229538, 0.02044549398124218, 0.005741080269217491, 0.025384850800037384, -0.009030912071466446, 0.017189450562000275, 0.006266347598284483, -0.00893261656165123, 0.005062225740402937, 0.00048763855011202395, 0.006011392921209335, -0.003735234495252371, -0.01725088618695736, 0.06064841151237488, -0.0028536454774439335, 0.010271894745528698, 0.02293974719941616, -0.019757425412535667, -0.003259114921092987, 0.03322392702102661, 0.003102456219494343, 0.0165873896330595, 0.030373355373740196, -0.012403681874275208, -0.01175861619412899, 0.005562919192016125, 0.010591356083750725, -0.03715575486421585, -0.009731268510222435, -0.05937056988477707, 0.013196190819144249, -0.01390883419662714, -0.0013661559205502272, 0.0048533473163843155, -0.026072919368743896, 0.042635735124349594, 0.016869990155100822, -0.006352356169372797, 0.0497375950217247, -0.0020657444838434458, 0.007194012403488159, -0.022952033206820488, -0.007642486598342657, -0.018049538135528564, 0.04035036265850067, -0.005169736687093973, 0.003848888911306858, -0.01202278584241867, -0.026638120412826538, 0.01888505183160305, -0.03464921563863754, 0.018246129155158997, 0.02597462385892868, -0.021563606336712837, 0.03813870996236801, 0.045338865369558334, 0.014179146848618984, 0.011684894561767578, 0.0230257548391819, -0.003100920468568802, 0.015235825441777706, -0.0165873896330595, -0.013773676939308643, 0.008508716709911823, -0.017754651606082916, 0.014842642471194267, -0.0011188809294253588, 0.01851644180715084, 0.016611963510513306, 0.0026401595678180456, -0.0018676172476261854, 0.019769711419939995, -0.02081410214304924, 0.03455092012882233, -0.0016510597197338939, 0.00488713663071394, -0.014179146848618984, -0.014879503287374973, 0.004321936517953873, 0.01009987760335207, 0.018700746819376945, -0.00829983875155449, 0.03639396280050278, 0.014474033378064632, 0.018700746819376945, 0.020224329084157944, -0.024512477219104767, 0.0010466950479894876, -0.006499799434095621, -0.014965511858463287, 0.011224133893847466, 0.024573910981416702, -0.004696688614785671, 0.01292587723582983, 0.01068965159356594, -0.03339594602584839, 0.031405460089445114, -0.0033543389290571213, 0.009288938716053963, 0.018614737316966057, 0.001324687385931611, 0.0059898910112679005, -0.022644858807325363, 0.014510895125567913, 0.031208867207169533, 0.0237998329102993, 0.015788737684488297, -0.011648033745586872, 0.02897264063358307, -0.00979270413517952, 0.04966387525200844, 0.009393377229571342, 0.020519215613603592, -0.02622036263346672, 0.007329169195145369, 0.010278038680553436, 0.02572888508439064, 0.0010889314580708742, 0.00010021548223448917, -0.006469082087278366, 0.008097103796899319, 0.013343634083867073, 0.003464921610429883, 0.04084184020757675, -0.029734432697296143, 0.01024117786437273, 0.02048235572874546, 0.012243951670825481, -0.012704712338745594, 0.0066595301032066345, 0.02995559759438038, -0.003222254104912281, -0.017558060586452484, 0.025433998554944992, -0.011488303542137146, 0.020015450194478035, -0.022755442187190056, 0.013122468255460262, -0.015825599431991577, 0.007771499454975128, -0.002825999865308404, -0.0032191823702305555, 0.00449702562764287, -0.001489025424234569, -0.022976607084274292, -0.030103040859103203, -0.0033512671943753958, 0.011095120571553707, -0.009473242796957493, 0.004091556183993816, -0.006899125408381224, -0.005225027911365032, -0.00238213362172246, -0.01598532870411873, 0.0059468867257237434, 0.0008731418056413531, 0.019966302439570427, -0.026392381638288498, 0.026515251025557518, 0.03113514557480812, -0.009940147399902344, -0.024930233135819435, -0.0006143478094600141, 0.025532294064760208, 0.010996825061738491, 0.020789528265595436, 0.011015255935490131, -0.00823226012289524, -0.01374910306185484, 0.003999404143542051, 0.03020133636891842, 0.019167650490999222, -0.026048345491290092, 0.0021548247896134853, -0.046444691717624664, 0.01233610324561596, -0.017017433419823647, -0.0003908787912223488, 0.0048041995614767075, -0.004656756296753883, 0.00027818436501547694, -0.007212442811578512 ]
11.843121
3.242242
2024-07-01
10
2024MNRAS.531.3336C
[ "access non-Gaussian information", "non-Gaussian", "different environmental densities", "sub-per cent level accuracy", "galaxy clustering information", "intra-halo scales", "cosmological parameter degeneracies", "models", "different choices", "strong constraints" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
31
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1234", "10.48550/arXiv.2309.16539" ]
[ "Cuesta-Lazaro, Carolina", "Paillas, Enrique", "Yuan, Sihan", "Cai, Yan-Chuan", "Nadathur, Seshadri", "Percival, Will J.", "Beutler, Florian", "de Mattia, Arnaud", "Eisenstein, Daniel J.", "Forero-Sanchez, Daniel", "Padilla, Nelson", "Pinon, Mathilde", "Ruhlmann-Kleider, Vanina", "Sánchez, Ariel G.", "Valogiannis, Georgios", "Zarrouk, Pauline" ]
[ "Center for Astrophysics | Harvard &amp; Smithsonian, 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA; The NSF AI Institute for Artificial Intelligence and Fundamental Interactions; Department of Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA", "Waterloo Centre for Astrophysics, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada; Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada", "Kavli Institute for Particle Astrophysics and Cosmology, Stanford University, 452 Lomita Mall, Stanford, CA 94305, USA; Department of Physics, Stanford University, 382 Via Pueblo Mall, Stanford, CA 94305, USA; SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory, 2575 Sand Hill Road, Menlo Park, CA 94025, USA", "Institute for Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, Blackford Hill, Edinburgh, EH9 3HJ, UK", "Institute of Cosmology and Gravitation, University of Portsmouth, Burnaby Road, Portsmouth, PO1 3FX, UK", "Waterloo Centre for Astrophysics, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada; Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada; Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics, 31 Caroline St North, Waterloo, ON N2L 2Y5, Canada", "Institute for Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, Blackford Hill, Edinburgh, EH9 3HJ, UK", "IRFU, CEA, Université Paris-Saclay, F-91191 Gif-sur-Yvette, France", "Center for Astrophysics | Harvard &amp; Smithsonian, 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA", "Institute of Physics, Laboratory of Astrophysics, École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL), Observatoire de Sauverny, CH-1290 Versoix, Switzerland", "Instituto de Astronomía Teórica y Experimental (IATE), CONICET-Universidad Nacional de Córdoba, Laprida 854, X5000BGR, Córdoba, Argentina", "IRFU, CEA, Université Paris-Saclay, F-91191 Gif-sur-Yvette, France", "IRFU, CEA, Université Paris-Saclay, F-91191 Gif-sur-Yvette, France", "Max-Planck-Institut für Extraterrestrische Physik, Postfach 1312, Giessenbachstr., D-85748 Garching, Germany", "Department of Physics, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA, 02138, USA; Department of Astronomy and Astrophysics, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, 60637, USA", "Sorbonne Université, Université Paris Diderot, Sorbonne Paris Cité, CNRS, Laboratoire de Physique Nucléaire et de Hautes Energies (LPNHE), 4 place Jussieu, F-75252, Paris Cedex 5, France" ]
[ "2023arXiv231105848W", "2024ApJ...966...35W", "2024JCAP...07..001F", "2024MNRAS.531..898P", "2024PhRvD.109j3503V", "2024arXiv240213310I", "2024arXiv240502252B", "2024arXiv240605098B", "2024arXiv240703221F", "2024arXiv240707949P" ]
[ "1990MNRAS.242P..43M", "2001MNRAS.327.1297P", "2004ApJ...602...26S", "2004ApJ...609...35K", "2005ApJ...633..560E", "2005MNRAS.362..505C", "2006MNRAS.371.1173V", "2007ApJ...667..760Z", "2007CSE.....9...90H", "2009ApJ...698L..90N", "2009ApJ...705..156H", "2009PASJ...61.1319I", "2010ApJ...717..379B", "2011ApJ...735...32W", "2011ApJ...742...91N", "2011ApJS..192...18K", "2011arXiv1110.3193L", "2012arXiv1208.4012G", "2014MNRAS.441...24A", "2015JCAP...09..028C", "2015MNRAS.446..578G", "2015PhR...568....1J", "2016AJ....151...44D", "2016MNRAS.455.1553R", "2016MNRAS.462.2465C", "2016arXiv161100036D", "2017ApJ...834...37L", "2017JCAP...07..014H", "2017MNRAS.465.1757G", "2017MNRAS.469.2059S", "2017MNRAS.472.4935H", "2017PhRvD..95f3525C", "2018MNRAS.476.3195C", "2018MNRAS.478.2495N", "2018MNRAS.481.4588K", "2018arXiv181103132M", "2019ApJ...875...69D", "2019ApJ...884...29N", "2019BAAS...51c..40P", "2019MNRAS.482.2459N", "2019MNRAS.483.3472N", "2019MNRAS.484..364S", "2019MNRAS.485.3370G", "2019MNRAS.490.5693B", "2019arXiv190906396L", "2019arXiv191013970L", "2019arXiv191211554P", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020JCAP...06..012H", "2020MNRAS.491.3022S", "2020MNRAS.493.5506H", "2020MNRAS.495.4006U", "2020MNRAS.499.4140N", "2020Natur.585..357H", "2020PNAS..11730055C", "2020PhRvD.102l3546J", "2021A&A...652A..94E", "2021JCAP...04..032S", "2021JCAP...07..008G", "2021MNRAS.500..259S", "2021MNRAS.500..911C", "2021MNRAS.500.5479B", "2021MNRAS.501..954J", "2021MNRAS.502.3242X", "2021MNRAS.505.5731P", "2021MNRAS.506.4210I", "2021MNRAS.507.2614E", "2021MNRAS.508..575G", "2021MNRAS.508.3125F", "2021MNRAS.508.4017M", "2021arXiv210801670P", "2021arXiv211006581H", "2022A&A...661A.146B", "2022MNRAS.509..501H", "2022MNRAS.509..586R", "2022MNRAS.510.3301Y", "2022MNRAS.515..871Y", "2022MNRAS.516.2363D", "2022MNRAS.516.4307W", "2022PhRvD.105d3517P", "2022PhRvD.105j3534V", "2022PhRvD.106j3509V", "2023ApJ...948...99Z", "2023ApJ...951...70M", "2023MNRAS.519.1648A", "2023MNRAS.520.6283Y", "2023MNRAS.522..606P", "2023MNRAS.522.3935Y", "2023MNRAS.525.3879O", "2023PNAS..12018810H", "2023Univ....9..302H", "2023arXiv230411911P", "2024ApJ...961..208S", "2024CmPhy...7..130W", "2024MNRAS.528.7236D", "2024MNRAS.531..898P" ]
29184449
2407.08321
Neutral hydrogen lensing simulations in the hubble frontier fields
Cold gas evolution ties the formation of dark matter halos to the star formation history of the universe. A primary component of cold gas, neutral atomic hydrogen (HI), can be traced by its 21-cm emission line. However, the faintness of this emission typically limits individual detections to low redshifts (z ≲ 0.2). To address this limitation, we investigate the potential of targeting gravitationally lensed systems. Building on our prior galaxy-galaxy simulations, we have developed a ray-tracing code to simulate lensed HI images for known galaxies situated behind the massive Hubble Frontier Field galaxy clusters. Our findings reveal the existence of high HI mass, high HI magnification systems in these cluster lensing scenarios. Through simulations of hundreds of sources, we have identified compelling targets within the redshift range z ≈ 0.7 - 1.5. The most promising candidate from our simulations is the Great Arc at z=0.725 in Abell 370, which should be detectable by MeerKAT in approximately 50 hours. Importantly, the derived HI mass is predicted to be relatively insensitive to systematic uncertainties in the lensing model, and should be constrained within a factor of ~2.5 for a 95 per cent confidence interval.
[ -0.0347384549677372, 0.008466174826025963, -0.005235922057181597, -0.008002818562090397, -0.011802338063716888, -0.0017706815851852298, -0.0070363907143473625, 0.027668969705700874, -0.005477529019117355, -0.02430632896721363, -0.00963780377060175, 0.0036671312991529703, -0.029734212905168533, -0.04495876654982567, 0.027404194697737694, 0.0316670686006546, 0.006232137326151133, 0.022783873602747917, -0.0436878465116024, 0.03018433041870594, -0.01707797683775425, 0.029707735404372215, -0.01760752499103546, 0.016561664640903473, -0.052398938685655594, -0.023670868948101997, 0.02239995077252388, 0.007188636343926191, 0.03841882571578026, -0.0034850987140089273, 0.06132184714078903, -0.007314404472708702, -0.03566516935825348, -0.02690112218260765, -0.04114600643515587, 0.07392513006925583, -0.016151264309883118, -0.00062097969930619, -0.04472046718001366, -0.018878445029258728, -0.0020238724537193775, 0.027351239696145058, -0.02177772857248783, -0.03153468295931816, -0.03248786926269531, -0.020520048215985298, 0.006185801699757576, 0.0035446728579699993, -0.008108728565275669, 0.0013040159828960896, -0.019950782880187035, -0.011756001971662045, 0.0021595696453005075, -0.04016634076833725, -0.02676873467862606, 0.003577769733965397, 0.019063787534832954, 0.017183886840939522, 0.007029771339148283, 0.03555925935506821, -0.027801357209682465, -0.013338031247258186, -0.012173022143542767, 0.005732374731451273, 0.005573510192334652, 0.03317628428339958, -0.0019527142867445946, -0.0144037501886487, 0.019712485373020172, 0.02630537934601307, -0.01096829678863287, -0.022227846086025238, -0.0011128816986456513, -0.01523779146373272, -0.0017044879496097565, -0.008439697325229645, -0.03182593360543251, 0.002359805628657341, -0.018203269690275192, 0.019434472545981407, -0.025603724643588066, -0.01665433682501316, -0.0062685441225767136, -0.012093589641153812, 0.011663330718874931, 0.01652194932103157, 0.004256255459040403, -0.0004786632489413023, -0.04477342218160629, -0.0009755297214724123, 0.010273262858390808, 0.008863337337970734, 0.016601381823420525, -0.05544384941458702, -0.022942738607525826, -0.05872705578804016, 0.03894837573170662, -0.0392925851047039, 0.033811744302511215, 0.02029499039053917, 0.00921416375786066, 0.02082454040646553, 0.03773041069507599, -0.06704098731279373, 0.048427313566207886, -0.0038160672411322594, 0.011279407888650894, -0.0008936150115914643, 0.04744764789938927, 0.016932349652051926, 0.04850674793124199, -0.012861437164247036, -0.042019765824079514, 0.030687401071190834, -0.07641401141881943, 0.015979161486029625, -0.04355545714497566, 0.019434472545981407, -0.03659188002347946, 0.030766833573579788, 0.006460505537688732, -0.0027122870087623596, 0.005576819647103548, 0.004094080533832312, -0.0024905381724238396, -0.029310572892427444, -0.004898334387689829, -0.0037598025519400835, -0.033017419278621674, 0.01829594001173973, 0.0045309592969715595, 0.009776810184121132, 0.019527142867445946, 0.005950814113020897, -0.043370116502046585, -0.019765440374612808, 0.01400658767670393, -0.012907772324979305, -0.02006993070244789, -0.00012597489694599062, 0.0003078007430303842, -0.005302115809172392, 0.028224995359778404, 0.020467093214392662, 0.015873251482844353, 0.006784854922443628, -0.06471096724271774, -0.0009060263400897384, 0.030369672924280167, 0.02009640820324421, -0.016601381823420525, -0.03346753865480423, -0.010988155379891396, -0.06820599734783173, -0.03164059296250343, -0.022929498925805092, -0.0005878828233107924, -0.005537103395909071, 0.000579608662519604, -0.028172040358185768, -0.0367242693901062, 0.004514410626143217, -0.018838727846741676, 0.02104959823191166, 0.005043960176408291, 0.028066130355000496, 0.01856071501970291, -0.02666282467544079, -0.07392513006925583, -0.039663270115852356, -0.02364439144730568, -0.01796497218310833, -0.02745714969933033, -0.014191930182278156, 0.04562070220708847, 0.06624665856361389, 0.027536582201719284, -0.03712143003940582, -0.035982899367809296, 0.017978210002183914, 0.024147463962435722, 0.03418242931365967, 0.020837778225541115, -0.035029709339141846, -0.048718567937612534, 0.019593337550759315, -0.05697954073548317, 0.017912017181515694, 0.007334262598305941, 0.010458605363965034, -0.014218407683074474, 0.04490581154823303, 0.0014744647778570652, 0.013675619848072529, -0.023790018633008003, -0.009061918593943119, 0.04403205215930939, 0.026781972497701645, -0.004229777958244085, 0.0004861100169364363, 0.02856920287013054, -0.013834484852850437, 0.044323306530714035, -0.05099562928080559, -0.05682067573070526, -0.0024475122336298227, 0.07196579873561859, 0.01894463784992695, -0.010359315201640129, -0.010339456610381603, 0.04347602650523186, -0.01223259698599577, 0.004345616791397333, 0.021102553233504295, -0.010167352855205536, -0.0033494015224277973, -0.04694457724690437, 0.0256169643253088, 0.036803700029850006, 0.0405370257794857, -0.04442921653389931, 0.029204662889242172, 0.049777667969465256, 0.029548870399594307, 0.009551751427352428, 0.0035314341075718403, 0.03841882571578026, -0.04572661221027374, 0.04154317080974579, 0.020930450409650803, 0.0055801295675337315, -0.0011385317193344235, -0.03577107936143875, -0.00894938874989748, 0.010670425370335579, -0.03780984506011009, -0.016363084316253662, 0.01634984463453293, 0.007003293838351965, -0.060580480843782425, -0.039954520761966705, 0.0020635887049138546, 0.01907702535390854, 0.015714386478066444, -0.016296889632940292, 0.00394845474511385, 0.001682974980212748, -0.007062868215143681, 0.05067789927124977, -0.005123392678797245, 0.026490721851587296, -0.05282257869839668, -0.018017927184700966, -0.031746502965688705, 0.01136545930057764, -0.012861437164247036, -0.0334940142929554, 0.041066575795412064, -0.0366448350250721, -0.012477513402700424, -0.034764934331178665, -0.05393463000655174, -0.011345600709319115, 0.009730475023388863, -0.02581554464995861, 0.03825996071100235, 0.016336606815457344, 0.005715826526284218, -0.06788826733827591, 0.02883397787809372, -0.031216951087117195, -0.015158358961343765, 0.06026275083422661, -0.03651244938373566, -0.034764934331178665, 0.023035408928990364, 0.027271807193756104, 0.023326661437749863, 0.04074884578585625, 0.014562615193426609, -0.03799518570303917, -0.008532368578016758, 0.018534237518906593, 0.031508203595876694, -0.056502945721149445, 0.024226896464824677, -0.00689738430082798, -0.019222652539610863, -0.015065687708556652, -0.047765377908945084, 0.105115607380867, -0.06328118592500687, 0.010915341787040234, -0.007976341992616653, -0.04779185727238655, 0.03741268068552017, 0.01678672432899475, 0.01947418786585331, -0.0386306457221508, -0.016561664640903473, 0.03428833931684494, 0.018904922530055046, 0.03412947431206703, 0.003294791793450713, -0.034367773681879044, 0.03235548362135887, 0.06555824726819992, 0.02124818041920662, 0.0019543692469596863, 0.05973320081830025, 0.03643301501870155, 0.00149018585216254, -0.0032534205820411444, 0.009008963592350483, -0.022850066423416138, -0.03129638358950615, -0.028251472860574722, 0.014655286446213722, 0.017660479992628098, -0.0442703515291214, -0.002250585937872529, -0.012093589641153812, -0.029946032911539078, -0.034923799335956573, -0.02299569360911846, -0.005421264562755823, 0.014642047695815563, -0.030369672924280167, -0.04532944783568382, -0.020864255726337433, -0.004458146169781685, 0.020334705710411072, 0.028092607855796814, -0.037200864404439926, -0.00706948759034276, -0.023538481444120407, -0.01065718661993742, 0.05999797582626343, -0.038312915712594986, -0.020533287897706032, -0.016363084316253662, 0.00834040716290474, -0.007334262598305941, 0.009207544848322868, 0.0173692274838686, 0.04956584796309471, 0.036538925021886826, -0.020864255726337433, 0.03018433041870594, -0.03018433041870594, -0.04307886213064194, 0.018931400030851364, 0.03603585436940193, -0.018679862841963768, 0.030078420415520668, 0.00649360241368413, 0.012583423405885696, -0.07011236995458603, 0.009445841424167156, 0.022704441100358963, -0.044349782168865204, 0.01586001180112362, 0.04667980223894119, 0.0005651287501677871, -0.005202825181186199, 0.002455786569043994, -0.025921454653143883, -0.021592386066913605, -0.016574904322624207, -0.017859062179923058, 0.01891816034913063, -0.0014388856943696737, 0.006774925626814365, 0.018878445029258728, -0.04969823360443115, 0.004464765544980764, 0.04506467655301094, -0.013000443577766418, 0.012755527161061764, 0.00438533304259181, 0.04265522584319115, -0.008962627500295639, 0.019858112558722496, -0.03947792574763298, -0.0011914867209270597, 0.028622157871723175, -0.04985709860920906, -0.04567365720868111, -0.09388915449380875, 0.01139855571091175, 0.03836587071418762, -0.014628808945417404, 0.019778680056333542, -0.00904867984354496, -0.01619097962975502, -0.035585734993219376, 0.02098340541124344, 0.06555824726819992, -0.008836859837174416, 0.0494069829583168, -0.016733769327402115, -0.02535218931734562, -0.05517907440662384, -0.0557086244225502, 0.021354088559746742, -0.035320959985256195, -0.00411393865942955, 0.049248117953538895, 0.027377717196941376, -0.007711566518992186, 0.010226927697658539, -0.010617470368742943, 0.04450864717364311, -0.0006085683708079159, 0.004537578672170639, 0.06105707585811615, -0.06952986866235733, 0.03370583429932594, -0.014615570195019245, -0.0038028284907341003, 0.049248117953538895, 0.029072275385260582, -0.006553176790475845, -0.03034319542348385, -0.06407550722360611, -0.01599239930510521, 0.037518590688705444, 0.01734274998307228, 0.010630709119141102, -0.02614651434123516, -0.03391765430569649, 0.02923114039003849, 0.022929498925805092, 0.03889542073011398, -0.015158358961343765, 0.0033626402728259563, 0.013821246102452278, 0.023829733952879906, 0.008148444816470146, -0.005874691531062126, 0.046520937234163284, 0.024160701781511307, -0.020745107904076576, -0.04985709860920906, 0.02841033786535263, 0.005043960176408291, 0.04538240283727646, 0.01065718661993742, 0.0022985765244811773, -0.03651244938373566, 0.006804713048040867, 0.000007757074854453094, 0.0018037784611806273, 0.00460708187893033, -0.019712485373020172, -0.00980328768491745, -0.007989580743014812, -0.0010251749772578478, 0.0017524783033877611, -0.02841033786535263, -0.04646798223257065, 0.020533287897706032, -0.031905367970466614, 0.024015076458454132, -0.048586178570985794, 0.025643441826105118, 0.008922911249101162, -0.007043010089546442, -0.009373028762638569, -0.039689745754003525, 0.02801317535340786, -0.04276113212108612, 0.020414138212800026, -0.04135782644152641, 0.02153943106532097, -0.004914882592856884, -0.041887376457452774, -0.005437812767922878, 0.055232029408216476, 0.02896636538207531, 0.05163108929991722, -0.03815405070781708, -0.009763571433722973, 0.0018666625255718827, 0.009492177516222, -0.004868546966463327, -0.03712143003940582, 0.018017927184700966, 0.014602331444621086, -0.060315705835819244, -0.003961693495512009, -0.03810109570622444, 0.03725381940603256, -0.014602331444621086, -0.002967132953926921, -0.022651486098766327, -0.053193263709545135, -0.01051156036555767, -0.020414138212800026, 0.006837809924036264, 0.051022108644247055, -0.07254830002784729, 0.05245189368724823, -0.021261418238282204, 0.03309685364365578, 0.003753183176741004, 0.00881700124591589, 0.004094080533832312, -0.0288075003772974, 0.029972510412335396, -0.03701552003622055, 0.03701552003622055, -0.004901643842458725, -0.013569709844887257, 0.009002343751490116, -0.006440647412091494, 0.011630234308540821, 0.047182872891426086, -0.0008307310054078698, -0.009373028762638569, 0.03185241296887398, -0.0002773930027615279, -0.006629299838095903, -0.013053398579359055, 0.005027411971241236, -0.009101634845137596, -0.009015582501888275, -0.1106758788228035, -0.03841882571578026, -0.0005072092753835022, -0.020056692883372307, -0.013622664846479893, 0.015740863978862762, 0.012153164483606815, -0.030237285420298576, -0.046362072229385376, -0.04231101647019386, 0.011656711809337139, 0.001546450424939394, -0.03021080791950226, 0.011345600709319115, 0.022095458582043648, -0.012537088245153427, -0.017448659986257553, 0.027086464688181877, 0.0347384549677372, 0.006222208496183157, 0.03471197932958603, 0.020242035388946533, 0.04710344225168228, 0.01495977770537138, -0.001519972924143076, -0.005169728305190802, 0.01727655716240406, 0.005474219564348459, -0.019990500062704086, -0.0027404194697737694, 0.006546557415276766, -0.004855308216065168, 0.017461899667978287, 0.0006164289079606533, -0.027139419689774513, -0.03823348507285118, 0.057985685765743256, 0.030237285420298576, -0.050333693623542786, 0.007148920092731714, -0.0354798249900341, -0.04209919646382332, 0.0014504696009680629, -0.03444720432162285, -0.025656679645180702, -0.00909501500427723, -0.03521504998207092, 0.017660479992628098, 0.020970165729522705, -0.016270412132143974, 0.03370583429932594, 0.014655286446213722, -0.004822211340069771, -0.006434028036892414, 0.015502565540373325, 0.02521980181336403, 0.0035016469191759825, -0.005394787061959505, 0.0028479842003434896, -0.011504465714097023, 0.020930450409650803, 0.023631153628230095, -0.024716729298233986, -0.008287452161312103, -0.009445841424167156, 0.014920061454176903, 0.011358839459717274, -0.030157852917909622, -0.03500322997570038, 0.032593779265880585, 0.006434028036892414, -0.005156489554792643, -0.008883194997906685, -0.00045632285764440894, 0.024094508960843086, -0.03555925935506821, -0.0290987528860569, -0.016892634332180023, 0.0196065753698349, 0.004236397333443165, 0.0017144170124083757, 0.0013271837960928679, -0.00270897732116282, -0.04149021580815315, 0.0424434058368206, -0.022055743262171745, -0.02003021538257599, -0.03103160858154297, -0.0055834390223026276, 0.022174891084432602, 0.009425983764231205, 0.02040090039372444, 0.00046707934234291315, -0.022280801087617874, -0.015251030214130878, -0.016336606815457344, 0.001574582769535482, 0.031878888607025146, 0.016243934631347656, -0.018600432202219963, -0.03444720432162285, -0.023856211453676224, -0.014456705190241337, 0.017329512163996696, -0.03542686998844147, 0.01756780967116356, 0.002677535405382514, -0.004626940004527569, -0.02801317535340786, -0.029019320383667946, 0.055920444428920746, -0.021459998562932014, -0.020877495408058167, 0.02627890184521675, 0.014747957699000835, 0.03211718425154686, -0.031746502965688705, 0.02925761789083481, 0.048136062920093536, -0.016018876805901527, 0.008512510918080807, -0.036671314388513565, -0.010028346441686153, -0.005980601534247398, -0.00675837742164731, 0.006020317319780588, 0.02200278826057911, 0.03460606932640076, -0.03330867365002632, 0.008956008590757847, 0.02608031965792179, -0.023260468617081642, -0.010729999281466007, -0.007996199652552605, -0.016932349652051926, -0.0032054302282631397, 0.001158389844931662, -0.0018683173693716526, 0.0008530713967047632, 0.015343700535595417, 0.01123307179659605, 0.013556471094489098, -0.0012642997317016125, 0.026067081838846207, -0.015502565540373325, 0.012206119485199451, 0.013424083590507507, 0.0027404194697737694, 0.01944771036505699, 0.009942295029759407, -0.009042060002684593, -0.04180794581770897, 0.0070231519639492035, 0.013424083590507507, 0.00922740250825882, -0.018891682848334312, -0.055920444428920746, 0.007744663394987583, 0.01341746374964714, 0.014430227689445019, 0.020334705710411072, 0.003822686616331339, 0.020837778225541115, -0.0034321437124162912, -0.003961693495512009, 0.007221733219921589, 0.032726168632507324, 0.019434472545981407, -0.024716729298233986, 0.0027983388863503933, 0.00510684447363019, 0.02539190463721752, -0.05560271441936493, 0.01509216520935297, 0.0040510548278689384, 0.015145120210945606, -0.035982899367809296, 0.018984355032444, -0.013172547332942486, 0.008942769840359688, 0.03269968926906586, 0.02745714969933033, 0.020506810396909714, 0.05298144370317459, 0.025921454653143883, 0.017594287171959877, -0.024491671472787857, 0.00908177625387907, 0.00689738430082798, -0.0014173727249726653, 0.003600937547162175, -0.057720910757780075, -0.02716589719057083, 0.006831190548837185, -0.0183621346950531, -0.0518958643078804, 0.038048140704631805, 0.03566516935825348, -0.042390450835227966, 0.004924811888486147, 0.02233375608921051, 0.0026278900913894176, -0.02009640820324421, 0.006837809924036264, 0.00845955591648817, -0.011113923043012619, -0.02262500859797001, 0.01625717431306839, 0.03487084433436394, 0.0019295464735478163, -0.04877152293920517, 0.01062409020960331, 0.01522455271333456, 0.00009494659752817824, -0.006553176790475845, 0.032461393624544144, -0.010240166448056698, 0.03346753865480423, -0.0198978278785944, 0.02962830290198326, -0.009267118759453297, 0.013404224999248981, -0.015317223966121674, 0.015383416786789894, 0.011663330718874931, 0.01110068429261446, -0.0007699155248701572, 0.045567747205495834, -0.027139419689774513, -0.005394787061959505, 0.00804915465414524, 0.0293900053948164, 0.001682974980212748, 0.03365287929773331, 0.04344954714179039, -0.004034506157040596, 0.02239995077252388, -0.0183621346950531, -0.0013081531506031752, -0.04900981858372688, 0.008525749668478966, 0.021499715745449066, -0.02160562574863434, 0.014112497679889202, 0.017117692157626152, 0.03836587071418762, -0.02976069040596485, 0.05311382934451103, -0.004256255459040403, 0.006857668049633503, -0.01878577284514904, -0.03510913997888565, -0.016045354306697845, 0.0016755281249061227, -0.04916868358850479, 0.013040159828960896, -0.028595680370926857, -0.011425033211708069, -0.003974932245910168, 0.0227971114218235, -0.01123307179659605, -0.009909197688102722, -0.005507316440343857, -0.013000443577766418, -0.010829290375113487, 0.012901153415441513, 0.018613670021295547, -0.018282702192664146, 0.0449322871863842, 0.019421232864260674, -0.0828215628862381, 0.020996643230319023, 0.023233991116285324, 0.021552670747041702, 0.006490292958915234, 0.03780984506011009, 0.0034122855868190527, 0.03630062937736511, -0.004011338576674461, -0.019752202555537224, -0.00011263272608630359, -0.035718124359846115, -0.0028033035341650248, 0.008135206066071987, 0.005427883937954903, 0.003739944426342845, -0.0014579163398593664, -0.004742778837680817, -0.04448217153549194, 0.02525951899588108, 0.008863337337970734, 0.01592620648443699, 0.029998987913131714, -0.023339901119470596, 0.0009176102466881275, -0.003839234821498394, -0.021354088559746742, -0.003233562456443906, 0.027642492204904556, -0.02643776684999466, 0.0002788409765344113, -0.029469437897205353, -0.022545576095581055, 0.04061645641922951, -0.025497814640402794, -0.02705998718738556, -0.0009564990759827197, 0.036141764372587204, -0.01364914234727621, -0.0024938478600233793, -0.021433521062135696, -0.026874644681811333, 0.01838861219584942, 0.01661461964249611, 0.036936089396476746, -0.002387937856838107, -0.0086846137419343, 0.03603585436940193, 0.029946032911539078, -0.011047729291021824, -0.03592994436621666, 0.03587698936462402, 0.01714416965842247, 0.01351675484329462, 0.001463708351366222, 0.025246279314160347, 0.012748907320201397, 0.0033642950002104044, -0.036406539380550385, -0.021764490753412247, -0.036538925021886826, 0.00014159247803036124, -0.0021777728106826544, -0.03238195925951004, -0.034923799335956573, -0.027245329692959785, -0.009862862527370453, 0.033017419278621674, 0.0028761164285242558, -0.03457959368824959, -0.006943719927221537, 0.03635358437895775, -0.01110068429261446, 0.04948641359806061, 0.007830715738236904, 0.0013064983068034053, -0.04601786285638809, 0.010028346441686153, -0.04511763155460358, 0.04657389223575592, -0.021076075732707977, -0.022016026079654694, 0.008942769840359688, -0.030952176079154015, -0.007082726340740919, 0.035294484347105026, 0.01685291714966297, -0.0011501156259328127, -0.027642492204904556, -0.02404155395925045, 0.003961693495512009, -0.018613670021295547, 0.030952176079154015, 0.02925761789083481, -0.016296889632940292, -0.009075157344341278, 0.020506810396909714, -0.028622157871723175, -0.01151108555495739, -0.02153943106532097, -0.04464103654026985, 0.010683664120733738, -0.03254082426428795, -0.03661835938692093, 0.016005637124180794, -0.040484070777893066, -0.02719237469136715, 0.009750332683324814, 0.02925761789083481, 0.03510913997888565, 0.02788078971207142, 0.036936089396476746, -0.013900678604841232, 0.025100653991103172, 0.03344105929136276, 0.017263319343328476, -0.046918097883462906, -0.006599512416869402, 0.01964629255235195, -0.0557086244225502, -0.01494653895497322, -0.0017260009190067649, -0.03841882571578026, -0.009267118759453297, 0.018679862841963768, -0.01522455271333456, -0.006956958677619696, 0.007704947143793106, -0.03638006001710892, 0.0043224492110311985, -0.0157938189804554, -0.02322075143456459, 0.03746563568711281, 0.004511101171374321, -0.002278718398883939, -0.0196065753698349, -0.0038127575535327196, 0.06476391851902008, -0.00465672742575407, 0.036247674375772476, 0.04209919646382332, 0.011312504298985004, 0.007552701979875565, 0.006172562949359417, -0.03455311432480812, 0.02627890184521675, 0.0029969201423227787, -0.023922406136989594, 0.008777284994721413, 0.015846773982048035, -0.01605859212577343, 0.0038160672411322594, 0.005318664480000734, -0.00032910684240050614, 0.002497157547622919, 0.006798093672841787, 0.0036505828611552715, 0.0006528354133479297, -0.007744663394987583, 0.05176347866654396, 0.03701552003622055, 0.01119997538626194, -0.006976816803216934, -0.0034586212132126093, 0.0040642935782670975, 0.03103160858154297, 0.014920061454176903, 0.03688313439488411, -0.002925761742517352, -0.012272313237190247, -0.016694052144885063, -0.025034459307789803, 0.011795718222856522, 0.008029296062886715, -0.02078482322394848, 0.03889542073011398, 0.01920941285789013, 0.022942738607525826, 0.018137075006961823, -0.000883685948792845, -0.013040159828960896, 0.0015133535489439964, 0.004193371161818504, 0.004941360093653202, 0.015595236793160439, 0.017912017181515694, -0.004994315095245838, 0.02357819862663746, 0.022016026079654694, 0.030131375417113304, 0.018904922530055046, 0.03701552003622055, -0.005967362783849239, 0.011193355545401573, -0.006930481176823378, 0.030237285420298576, -0.015595236793160439, 0.009558371268212795, -0.033282194286584854, 0.007407075725495815, 0.005312045104801655, -0.014867106452584267, -0.01747513748705387, -0.032461393624544144, -0.008208019658923149, -0.015330461785197258, 0.014350795187056065, -0.025894977152347565, -0.03296446427702904, -0.02657015435397625, 0.001946094911545515, -0.014509660191833973, 0.012755527161061764, 0.03018433041870594, 0.037968710064888, -0.03497675433754921, 0.0347384549677372, 0.0014124081935733557, -0.024716729298233986, -0.03563868999481201, 0.01599239930510521, -0.02036118321120739, 0.01481415145099163, 0.05533793941140175, -0.016204219311475754, 0.04019281640648842, 0.017236841842532158, -0.014867106452584267, -0.014761196449398994, 0.01008130144327879, 0.04601786285638809, -0.01707797683775425, 0.02703350968658924, -0.030978653579950333, -0.03950440511107445, 0.006030246615409851, -0.022413188591599464, -0.02075834572315216, -0.01951390504837036, 0.007923386991024017, 0.03005194291472435, 0.020877495408058167, -0.006811332423239946, 0.02144676074385643, -0.016336606815457344, -0.013622664846479893, -0.00909501500427723, -0.004808972589671612, 0.020175840705633163, 0.009200925007462502, -0.006185801699757576, 0.02732476219534874, -0.029601825401186943, 0.0025484575890004635, -0.025180086493492126, 0.003779660677537322, -0.004137106705456972, 0.02082454040646553, 0.005113463848829269, -0.01907702535390854, 0.006212279200553894, -0.01294086966663599, -0.020745107904076576, -0.011881770566105843, -0.013159308582544327, -0.0022654796484857798, -0.03235548362135887, 0.018150314688682556, 0.0036207956727594137, -0.018348895013332367, 0.012537088245153427, -0.018573954701423645, 0.04358193650841713, -0.03047558292746544, -0.012404700741171837, 0.006288402248173952, -0.017819344997406006, -0.008625039830803871, -0.0017839203355833888, -0.008287452161312103, -0.0038259963039308786, -0.008611801080405712, -0.049671757966279984, -0.01208697073161602, -0.0011302575003355742, 0.02654367685317993, -0.02925761789083481, -0.005037340801209211, -0.005629774648696184, 0.0070496294647455215, -0.0025484575890004635, 0.035850510001182556, 0.0397956557571888, 0.017038259655237198, 0.014205168932676315, 0.002017253078520298, -0.00159940542653203, -0.004461455624550581, 0.006559796165674925, -0.013285077176988125, 0.012490752153098583, 0.02679521217942238, 0.01295410841703415, -0.030104897916316986, -0.009234022349119186, 0.00904867984354496, -0.015542281791567802, -0.006328118499368429, -0.0015100438613444567, 0.01253046840429306, 0.001934511004947126, 0.02745714969933033, 0.004431668668985367, 0.0123517457395792, 0.010154114104807377, -0.02719237469136715, -0.0032368721440434456, 0.028039652854204178, 0.0027387645095586777, -0.023829733952879906, -0.04575308784842491, -0.007718185894191265, -0.020930450409650803, 0.009161208756268024, -0.01364914234727621, 0.013338031247258186, -0.005159799475222826, 0.001091368729248643, 0.03389117866754532, 0.021062837913632393, 0.024293089285492897, 0.042972952127456665, 0.03902781009674072, -0.003408975899219513, -0.017726674675941467, 0.015145120210945606, -0.0009953879052773118, 0.021009882912039757, 0.014708241447806358, 0.012457655742764473, 0.021473238244652748, 0.002197630936279893, -0.015820296481251717, 0.03209070861339569, 0.004448216874152422, -0.027271807193756104, -0.00837350357323885, -0.021009882912039757, 0.0030962105374783278, -0.042125675827264786, 0.06984759867191315, -0.035188574343919754, -0.0046898238360881805, -0.02772192470729351, -0.001380966161377728, -0.033970609307289124, 0.008737568743526936, 0.048136062920093536, -0.010670425370335579, -0.024068031460046768, 0.0032319077290594578, -0.005940885283052921, -0.0032914821058511734, 0.0074865082278847694, 0.01714416965842247, -0.008141825906932354, 0.012325268238782883, 0.01951390504837036, -0.015145120210945606, 0.001215481897816062, 0.023406093940138817, -0.02670253999531269, -0.027245329692959785, 0.009379647672176361, -0.014350795187056065, -0.026530437171459198, 0.01415221393108368, 0.010994774289429188, -0.010193830356001854, 0.011570659466087818, -0.008022677153348923, -0.005897859111428261, -0.007678469642996788, 0.002248931210488081, 0.004928121343255043, -0.00023457394854631275, 0.008545607328414917, 0.025630202144384384, 0.008069012314081192, 0.00639762170612812, 0.03103160858154297, 0.019222652539610863, 0.0253257118165493, -0.02210869826376438, 0.018640147522091866, 0.004166893661022186, -0.0019427852239459753, 0.025378666818141937, 0.0158335343003273, -0.030237285420298576, -0.03945145010948181, 0.011444891802966595, 0.02249262109398842, -0.009035441093146801, 0.01400658767670393, -0.0059706722386181355, 0.009717236272990704, 0.024385761469602585, 0.024888833984732628, -0.016574904322624207, 0.0015836843522265553, -0.048559702932834625, -0.04482637718319893, 0.018573954701423645, 0.030104897916316986, -0.002568315714597702, 0.0007856365409679711, 0.02286330610513687, -0.02798669971525669, -0.04101362079381943, -0.01576734147965908, 0.012556945905089378, -0.017991449683904648, 0.031905367970466614, -0.022439666092395782, 0.02424013428390026, -0.016376322135329247, 0.03344105929136276, -0.022055743262171745, 0.01366238109767437, 0.01605859212577343, 0.014165452681481838, -0.0009399506379850209, 0.06105707585811615, -0.0024243444204330444, 0.0072945463471114635, 0.017091214656829834, -0.025007981806993484, -0.0019510594429448247, 0.02171153575181961, 0.0008112866198644042, -0.0042728036642074585, -0.00865151733160019, 0.023829733952879906, 0.025021221488714218, 0.006774925626814365, -0.03884246572852135, 0.019699247553944588, 0.03484436497092247, -0.010862386785447598, -0.011001394130289555, 0.03526800498366356, 0.04164908081293106, -0.004567365627735853, 0.016204219311475754, 0.028330905362963676, -0.018401850014925003, -0.04180794581770897, -0.022783873602747917, -0.04286704212427139, 0.011762621812522411, 0.02404155395925045, 0.023697346448898315, 0.009816526435315609, 0.01364914234727621, 0.015264268964529037, 0.02991955541074276, -0.0288075003772974, -0.019580097869038582, -0.02204250358045101, -0.003230252768844366, 0.026755494996905327, -0.005719135981053114, -0.013410844840109348, -0.03129638358950615, -0.036962565034627914, 0.007738044019788504, -0.01825622469186783, 0.020453855395317078, 0.011756001971662045, 0.00631487974897027, 0.025603724643588066, 0.008724329993128777, -0.0051267025992274284, 0.017064737156033516, 0.003617485985159874, -0.0036274150479584932, -0.012682713568210602, 0.05454361438751221, 0.00865151733160019, -0.006377763580530882, -0.025961171835660934, -0.025802306830883026, -0.014377272687852383, 0.03526800498366356, 0.016283651813864708, -0.007572560105472803, 0.016932349652051926, -0.0002529840567149222, 0.021618863567709923, -0.04138430580496788, -0.022942738607525826, 0.0005663699121214449, 0.011458130553364754, -0.0070496294647455215, 0.004994315095245838, -0.02772192470729351, 0.0020255274139344692, -0.006079891696572304, 0.03428833931684494, -0.0058151171542704105, 0.02479616180062294, -0.017395704984664917, -0.017872299998998642, 0.026808449998497963, -0.006341356784105301, -0.014575853943824768, -0.006136156618595123, -0.0006594547885470092, 0.01095505803823471, 0.00881700124591589, -0.013053398579359055, -0.004994315095245838, -0.020930450409650803, -0.036009375005960464, -0.01701178215444088, 0.008121967315673828, 0.0003065596101805568, -0.013635903596878052, 0.02000373788177967, -0.0017408945132046938, -0.0633341372013092, 0.042681701481342316, 0.0030118136201053858, 0.005643013399094343, -0.005818426609039307, -0.004180132411420345, 0.007532843854278326, 0.02827795036137104, -0.004276113584637642, -0.007142300717532635, 0.0046898238360881805, 0.0186533872038126, 0.010352695360779762, 0.0053352126851677895, 0.02814556285738945, -0.02335313893854618, -0.009280357509851456, 0.00894938874989748, 0.01754133217036724, -0.03100513108074665, -0.04207272082567215, 0.0035943181719630957, -0.01052479911595583, -0.01658814214169979, 0.0010202104458585382, 0.03833939507603645, 0.019063787534832954, -0.004395261872559786, 0.021724773570895195, 0.0036638216115534306, -0.009915817528963089, -0.04175499081611633, 0.019394755363464355, 0.024054791778326035, 0.023538481444120407, -0.004438288044184446, 0.0212217029184103, 0.012980585917830467, -0.02630537934601307, 0.029813645407557487, 0.01805764250457287, -0.009075157344341278, 0.03169354796409607, -0.007155539467930794, 0.01907702535390854, 0.032037753611803055, 0.003048220183700323, 0.028595680370926857, 0.03630062937736511, 0.001104607479646802, -0.05422588437795639, 0.025166846811771393, -0.010617470368742943, -0.02410774677991867, 0.004458146169781685, -0.030766833573579788, 0.0005423746770247817, -0.011974441818892956, -0.01311959233134985, -0.015184836462140083, -0.021062837913632393, 0.011338981799781322, -0.012325268238782883, -0.007592418231070042, 0.02397536113858223, 0.023128081113100052, -0.01947418786585331, -0.02716589719057083, 0.020837778225541115, -0.02991955541074276, 0.0538022443652153, -0.009320073761045933, -0.011623614467680454, -0.023803256452083588, 0.007903528399765491, 0.028383860364556313, -0.027774879708886147, -0.019791917875409126, 0.015912966802716255, 0.0030945558100938797, 0.015330461785197258, 0.007777760270982981, -0.007387217599898577, 0.014920061454176903, -0.0129739660769701, -0.025802306830883026, 0.012060493230819702, -0.013225502334535122, -0.018865205347537994, -0.0005345141980797052, -0.016363084316253662, -0.005292186979204416, -0.021367328241467476, 0.055920444428920746, 0.030290240421891212, -0.0018947948701679707, -0.04265522584319115, 0.01954038254916668, 0.009260499849915504, 0.015886489301919937, -0.01665433682501316, 0.038577690720558167, 0.019884590059518814, -0.052663713693618774, -0.012901153415441513, 0.018706340342760086, -0.011193355545401573, -0.007843954488635063, 0.02508741430938244, 0.02893988788127899, 0.02893988788127899, 0.030290240421891212, -0.010504941456019878, 0.0035016469191759825, -0.03550630435347557, -0.014337556436657906, 0.007936625741422176, 0.03386469930410385, -0.0020189080387353897, 0.0062155891209840775, -0.009108253754675388, -0.03018433041870594, -0.0016209183959290385, 0.03089922107756138, 0.0099489139392972, -0.03770393505692482, 0.010438747704029083, 0.012881294824182987, -0.026980554684996605, -0.008989105001091957, 0.017779629677534103, -0.004597153048962355, 0.02521980181336403, 0.014562615193426609, 0.020122885704040527, 0.003614176297560334, 0.045144107192754745, 0.027377717196941376, 0.017170647159218788, -0.0020652436651289463, 0.01980515755712986, 0.03113751858472824, -0.0007223387947306037, 0.014390511438250542, 0.008042534813284874, 0.02774840220808983, 0.0322495736181736, 0.038445305079221725, 0.03018433041870594, 0.0099489139392972, -0.008055773563683033, -0.0051267025992274284, 0.022572053596377373, -0.010769715532660484, -0.02774840220808983, 0.0013222192646935582, 0.006017007865011692, -0.019699247553944588, -0.014112497679889202, -0.002528599463403225, -0.01481415145099163, 0.006136156618595123, -0.009531893767416477, -0.03359992429614067, 0.00045590914669446647, -0.017157409340143204, -0.002374699106439948, -0.032990943640470505, -0.019659530371427536, 0.03971622511744499, -0.013953633606433868, -0.015648191794753075, -0.009247261099517345, 0.01849452219903469, 0.010385792702436447, 0.017263319343328476, 0.003461930900812149, 0.02187040075659752, -0.04127839580178261, -0.01776638999581337, 0.010551276616752148, -0.01570114679634571, 0.026874644681811333, -0.03018433041870594, 0.04273465648293495, -0.008810382336378098, -0.029734212905168533, -0.002315124962478876, -0.011504465714097023, 0.019725725054740906, 0.02108931541442871, 0.01065718661993742, -0.0000040498393900634255, -0.02479616180062294, -0.04784481227397919, 0.048983342945575714, 0.015171597711741924, 0.012371603399515152, -0.0022456215228885412, 0.034076519310474396, -0.026914360001683235, 0.003918667323887348, -0.0013611080357804894, 0.03579755499958992, -0.021499715745449066, -0.031216951087117195, -0.006589583586901426, -0.01849452219903469 ]
12.434037
7.696858
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.tmp.1668B
[ "lensed HI images", "high HI magnification systems", "high HI mass", "galaxy clusters", "HI", "known galaxies", "Cold gas evolution", "cold gas", "low redshifts", "dark matter halos" ]
[ "radio lines: galaxies", "gravitational lensing: strong", "galaxies: evolution", "galaxies: high-redshift", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
5
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1706", "10.48550/arXiv.2407.08321" ]
[ "Blecher, Tariq", "Deane, Roger", "Obreschkow, Danail", "Heywood, Ian" ]
[ "Centre for Radio Astronomy Techniques and Technologies, Department of Physics and Electronics, Rhodes University,- Makhanda 6140, South Africa; South African Radio Astronomical Observatory, 2 Fir Street, Observatory, 7925, South Africa", "Centre for Radio Astronomy Techniques and Technologies, Department of Physics and Electronics, Rhodes University,- Makhanda 6140, South Africa; Wits Centre for Astrophysics, University of the Witwatersrand, 1 Jan Smuts Avenue, 2000, Johannesburg, South Africa; Department of Physics, University of Pretoria, Hatfield, Pretoria, 0028, South Africa;", "International Centre for Radio Astronomy Research (ICRAR), M468, University of Western Australia, WA 6009, Australia; ARC Centre of Excellence for All Sky Astrophysics in 3 Dimensions (ASTRO 3D);", "Centre for Radio Astronomy Techniques and Technologies, Department of Physics and Electronics, Rhodes University,- Makhanda 6140, South Africa; South African Radio Astronomical Observatory, 2 Fir Street, Observatory, 7925, South Africa; Astrophysics, University of Oxford, Denys Wilkinson Building, Keble Road, Oxford, OX1 3RH, UK;" ]
null
[ "1978MNRAS.183..341W", "1988A&A...191L..19S", "1993A&A...273..367K", "1996ApJ...471..643K", "1996astro.ph..6001N", "2001astro.ph..2340K", "2007ApJS..172...70L", "2007NJPh....9..447J", "2008AJ....136.2782L", "2008ApJ...686.1503B", "2009ApJ...698.1467O", "2009ApJ...700..221K", "2009MNRAS.392..930O", "2010A&A...519A..90M", "2010MNRAS.402L..44R", "2010Natur.466..463C", "2010ascl.soft10012O", "2011A&ARv..19...47K", "2011MNRAS.411.1628D", "2011ascl.soft02004K", "2012ApJS..199...25P", "2012MNRAS.420L..18H", "2013A&A...558A..84G", "2013A&A...559L...9B", "2013ApJ...763L..20M", "2013ApJS..208....5N", "2013MNRAS.433.1398D", "2013MNRAS.434.3322D", "2013MNRAS.435.2693R", "2013NewAR..57....1L", "2014ApJ...781....2A", "2014ApJ...797...48J", "2014MNRAS.443.1549J", "2014MNRAS.443.3631M", "2014MNRAS.444..268R", "2014MNRAS.444..606O", "2015ApJ...800...38G", "2015ApJ...802L...9B", "2015ApJ...811..124S", "2015MNRAS.447.1610M", "2015MNRAS.452L..49D", "2016A&A...588A..99L", "2016A&A...594A...1P", "2016AJ....152...30H", "2016ApJ...819..114K", "2016ApJ...824L..26O", "2016MNRAS.456..710F", "2016MNRAS.460.2143W", "2016mks..confE..29D", "2017ApJ...837...97L", "2017MNRAS.465.1030P", "2017MNRAS.465.1682H", "2017MNRAS.470.1809A", "2017MNRAS.472.3177M", "2017PASA...34...52M", "2018A&A...609A..84S", "2018ApJ...855....4K", "2018ApJS..235...14S", "2018MNRAS.473..663M", "2018MNRAS.473.4077P", "2018MNRAS.476..875C", "2018MNRAS.479.5184A", "2018PASJ...70S..29S", "2019ApJ...882L...7B", "2019MNRAS.484.3681B", "2019MNRAS.485.3738L", "2019MNRAS.486.2827D", "2020MNRAS.494.3627A", "2020MNRAS.495.1291J", "2020Natur.586..369C", "2021arXiv210710833W", "2022ApJ...935L..13S", "2022ApJ...941L...6C", "2022MNRAS.509.5155R", "2023ApJ...950L..18B", "2023MNRAS.519.4074C", "2024MNRAS.527.3246B" ]
29163265
2312.08792
Generating mock galaxy catalogues for flux-limited samples like the DESI Bright Galaxy Survey
Accurate mock galaxy catalogues are crucial to validate analysis pipelines used to constrain dark energy models. We present a fast HOD-fitting method which we apply to the AbacusSummit simulations to create a set of mock catalogues for the DESI Bright Galaxy Survey, which contain r-band magnitudes and $(g-r)$ colours. The halo tabulation method fits HODs for different absolute magnitude threshold samples simultaneously, preventing unphysical HOD crossing between samples. We validate the HOD fitting procedure by fitting to real-space clustering measurements and galaxy number densities from the MXXL BGS mock, which was tuned to the SDSS and GAMA surveys. The best-fitting clustering measurements and number densities are mostly within the assumed errors, but the clustering for the faint samples is low on large scales. The best-fitting HOD parameters are robust when fitting to simulations with different realizations of the initial conditions. When varying the cosmology, trends are seen as a function of each cosmological parameter. We use the best-fitting HOD parameters to create cubic box and cut sky mocks from the AbacusSummit simulations, in a range of cosmologies. As an illustration, we compare the ${}^{0.1}M_r\lt -20$ sample of galaxies in the mock with BGS measurements from the DESI one-percent survey. We find good agreement in the number densities, and the projected correlation function is reasonable, with differences that can be improved in the future by fitting directly to BGS clustering measurements. The cubic box and cut-sky mocks in different cosmologies are made publicly available.
[ -0.011518901214003563, 0.013209004886448383, 0.04847043752670288, -0.006127406843006611, -0.0032991329208016396, -0.012229867279529572, -0.013396102003753185, -0.016227493062615395, 0.00608375109732151, 0.009504497051239014, 0.005382139701396227, -0.047248076647520065, -0.028912628069519997, -0.06186654046177864, 0.059671275317668915, 0.06520932912826538, -0.0083008436486125, 0.02576940879225731, -0.038791317492723465, 0.02100468799471855, -0.03677067905664444, 0.0009806968737393618, -0.01083288062363863, 0.01507996954023838, -0.053983546793460846, -0.03484982252120972, 0.012809866108000278, -0.006542137358337641, 0.05423300713300705, -0.01836039312183857, 0.00228101690299809, -0.027715211734175682, -0.062165893614292145, -0.020393505692481995, -0.042932383716106415, 0.10427505522966385, -0.01927092857658863, 0.06620717793703079, -0.041285935789346695, 0.003589132335036993, 0.0051888064481318, -0.017212867736816406, 0.010396323166787624, 0.04435431584715843, 0.015628784894943237, -0.008993099443614483, 0.030509185045957565, -0.0250709168612957, 0.03262960910797119, 0.0024540810845792294, -0.09424668550491333, 0.033827029168605804, 0.03647132217884064, -0.04255819320678711, -0.028538435697555542, -0.029860584065318108, -0.017998673021793365, 0.012959543615579605, 0.01932082138955593, -0.018909208476543427, -0.02933671325445175, -0.02490876615047455, -0.010552236810326576, -0.03943992033600807, 0.005060957279056311, 0.011026213876903057, -0.008157402276992798, -0.009354819543659687, 0.017312653362751007, 0.016027923673391342, 0.019607702270150185, 0.048096247017383575, 0.00835697166621685, -0.028064457699656487, -0.00964170042425394, -0.01379524078220129, 0.006791599094867706, -0.008095037192106247, -0.018098456785082817, -0.005955901928246021, -0.02101716212928295, 0.030359508469700813, 0.024434788152575493, -0.020630495622754097, -0.023935865610837936, -0.0035953689366579056, 0.0026739193126559258, -0.017225341871380806, -0.04265797883272171, 0.006046331487596035, 0.03614702448248863, -0.031282518059015274, 0.01374534796923399, -0.0050516026094555855, -0.0418098084628582, -0.07154566049575806, -0.014107068069279194, -0.03574788197875023, 0.038816265761852264, 0.033901866525411606, 0.037119925022125244, 0.03477498143911362, 0.032305311411619186, -0.044578831642866135, 0.05153881758451462, 0.02669241838157177, -0.008550304919481277, -0.011088578961789608, -0.014967711642384529, 0.05937192216515541, 0.00002706563645915594, -0.019345765933394432, -0.05318526551127434, -0.017736738547682762, -0.006358159240335226, -0.019495444372296333, -0.01544168870896101, 0.031082946807146072, -0.052985697984695435, -0.024821454659104347, -0.040512606501579285, -0.04654958099126816, 0.06316374242305756, 0.0015263947425410151, 0.026043817400932312, -0.03981411084532738, -0.014967711642384529, -0.05253666639328003, -0.06850222498178482, -0.0056440746411681175, -0.008444284088909626, -0.02833886630833149, 0.061217937618494034, 0.006339449435472488, -0.03849196434020996, 0.004038163926452398, -0.03816766291856766, -0.021266622468829155, 0.032978858798742294, -0.015529000200331211, -0.0072780498303473, -0.01005954947322607, 0.04682398959994316, 0.03407648950815201, 0.015354377217590809, -0.007003641687333584, -0.028837790712714195, 0.02180296555161476, 0.0024868228938430548, 0.021977588534355164, -0.01574104279279709, -0.025719517841935158, -0.024384895339608192, -0.03452552109956741, 0.00877482071518898, -0.015154807828366756, -0.0065546100959181786, -0.006320739630609751, 0.022214578464627266, -0.023162532597780228, 0.014132014475762844, -0.00521063432097435, 0.026118656620383263, 0.013221478089690208, -0.013757821172475815, 0.03003520704805851, -0.015304484404623508, -0.008413100615143776, -0.07114651799201965, -0.03223047032952309, 0.016950933262705803, 0.04667431116104126, 0.017312653362751007, -0.0415603443980217, 0.03672078624367714, 0.042233891785144806, -0.005656547378748655, -0.009591808542609215, -0.06321363151073456, -0.007889230735599995, -0.008057617582380772, 0.03904078155755997, 0.013445993885397911, -0.03093327023088932, -0.052037741988897324, -0.01837286539375782, -0.027216289192438126, 0.007583640515804291, -0.0023465005215257406, -0.022825758904218674, 0.02596897818148136, 0.001584862358868122, 0.020443398505449295, 0.03243004158139229, -0.02079264633357525, -0.03163176402449608, 0.006579556502401829, 0.03916551172733307, -0.019433079287409782, 0.02095479518175125, -0.0014125776942819357, 0.01205524429678917, 0.015516526997089386, -0.052287206053733826, -0.057126764208078384, 0.0032804233487695456, 0.04318184778094292, 0.01666405238211155, 0.04707345366477966, -0.005060957279056311, 0.037094976752996445, 0.023898445069789886, 0.0083819180727005, 0.030234776437282562, -0.03006015345454216, -0.008943207561969757, -0.06515944004058838, 0.003205584827810526, 0.018734585493803024, 0.04832076281309128, -0.030209830030798912, 0.03684551641345024, 0.03731949254870415, 0.003938379231840372, -0.020331140607595444, -0.006305148359388113, 0.027839943766593933, -0.018135877326130867, 0.009460840374231339, -0.012685135006904602, 0.03739433363080025, 0.015067496336996555, -0.032854124903678894, 0.006411169655621052, 0.01134427823126316, -0.007221920881420374, 0.011836964637041092, 0.007820629514753819, -0.004480958450585604, -0.03527390584349632, -0.004493431653827429, 0.007334178313612938, 0.004446657374501228, -0.023935865610837936, -0.023561671376228333, 0.013882552273571491, -0.008332026191055775, -0.025332851335406303, 0.042957331985235214, -0.0032928965520113707, -0.009105357341468334, 0.01757458783686161, -0.01675136387348175, -0.048071298748254776, -0.041285935789346695, -0.0023854789324104786, -0.012479329481720924, 0.028862737119197845, -0.017961254343390465, -0.004275152459740639, -0.06925061345100403, 0.00456203380599618, -0.03919045627117157, 0.041211098432540894, -0.03926529735326767, 0.054831717163324356, -0.011880620382726192, -0.010583419352769852, -0.0418098084628582, 0.019433079287409782, 0.00019995926413685083, 0.01763695292174816, 0.04607560485601425, -0.031033053994178772, -0.016190074384212494, 0.00022665948199573904, 0.00916148629039526, 0.050540972501039505, 0.005248053930699825, -0.04263303056359291, 0.004025690723210573, 0.0004856710438616574, 0.017848996445536613, -0.008282133378088474, 0.006829018238931894, 0.03427605703473091, -0.002232683589681983, -0.004733538720756769, -0.010982558131217957, -0.010439978912472725, -0.001121019246056676, -0.05947170779109001, -0.006716760341078043, -0.009909871965646744, -0.029885530471801758, 0.020206410437822342, -0.0010383849730715156, 0.014194379560649395, -0.010146860964596272, -0.0073404149152338505, 0.04345625638961792, 0.04263303056359291, 0.00023289602540899068, -0.004727302119135857, -0.015292011201381683, -0.008581487461924553, 0.04532722011208534, 0.024796508252620697, 0.0050110649317502975, 0.06570824980735779, -0.002341823186725378, 0.018909208476543427, -0.02926187589764595, 0.047946568578481674, 0.010209226049482822, -0.059521596878767014, -0.03816766291856766, 0.008631380274891853, -0.006167944520711899, -0.023861026391386986, -0.06925061345100403, -0.026916934177279472, -0.05498139187693596, 0.0001288236671825871, -0.010539763607084751, -0.05937192216515541, -0.002136017195880413, -0.014693303033709526, -0.04537711292505264, -0.035523369908332825, 0.003978916443884373, 0.054731931537389755, 0.032005954533815384, 0.006610739044845104, 0.00055115477880463, -0.03247993439435959, 0.012809866108000278, 0.024372423067688942, -0.011737179942429066, -0.01172470673918724, -0.033901866525411606, 0.009672882966697216, -0.00385418557561934, -0.0415852926671505, 0.032879073172807693, -0.008169875480234623, 0.008531595580279827, 0.0503164567053318, 0.06790351867675781, -0.023648982867598534, -0.01831050030887127, -0.030184883624315262, 0.04343130812048912, 0.007359124720096588, 0.045427002012729645, -0.02499607764184475, -0.017861468717455864, -0.05488160625100136, -0.02177801914513111, -0.001366583164781332, 0.0008668799418956041, 0.02669241838157177, 0.028837790712714195, -0.004555797204375267, 0.019807271659374237, 0.047896675765514374, -0.022314362227916718, 0.01929587498307228, -0.02174060046672821, -0.005229344125837088, 0.018622327595949173, 0.04497797414660454, -0.08636369556188583, -0.02347435988485813, -0.031282518059015274, 0.011213310062885284, 0.06091858446598053, 0.011032450944185257, 0.016264913603663445, 0.010826644487679005, 0.04612549766898155, -0.012416963465511799, 0.0015271742595359683, -0.029636068269610405, 0.057925041764974594, 0.014331583864986897, -0.029461445286870003, -0.0013595671625807881, -0.019744906574487686, -0.03098316304385662, 0.001908383215777576, 0.02167823538184166, 0.014830507338047028, 0.010246645659208298, -0.010433741845190525, -0.023162532597780228, 0.0005472569609992206, 0.04480334743857384, 0.0207053329795599, 0.083220474421978, -0.031157786026597023, -0.03811777010560036, -0.06381234526634216, -0.0332283191382885, -0.02679220400750637, -0.0027674674056470394, 0.03617196902632713, 0.0501667782664299, 0.04026314243674278, -0.03185627982020378, 0.04225883632898331, -0.034500572830438614, 0.03781841695308685, -0.059820953756570816, -0.002870370401069522, -0.003364616772159934, -0.04587603360414505, 0.04819602891802788, -0.01289717759937048, 0.05677751824259758, -0.014481260441243649, -0.03270445019006729, 0.010340194217860699, -0.03160681575536728, -0.04118615388870239, 0.02169070765376091, 0.007851812057197094, -0.0018039210699498653, -0.017250286415219307, -0.0033895629458129406, -0.03692035377025604, 0.02268855646252632, 0.014680829830467701, -0.011082342825829983, -0.03829239308834076, -0.042283784598112106, 0.032904017716646194, 0.013707929290831089, 0.048121191561222076, -0.0026520914398133755, 0.006872673984616995, 0.0124668562784791, -0.03557325899600983, -0.05071559548377991, -0.018622327595949173, -0.00749009195715189, 0.033827029168605804, 0.02008167840540409, -0.021491138264536858, -0.030384453013539314, -0.01591566577553749, -0.019545337185263634, -0.003523648716509342, -0.01175589021295309, -0.0027113384567201138, -0.0002991593210026622, 0.0007421490154229105, -0.021353933960199356, 0.03614702448248863, -0.022863179445266724, 0.01503007672727108, 0.014867926947772503, -0.03203090280294418, 0.026542741805315018, 0.01829802617430687, 0.05697708576917648, -0.0022654253989458084, 0.016863621771335602, 0.027041664347052574, 0.007359124720096588, -0.0005492058699019253, -0.029785744845867157, 0.05992073565721512, 0.02177801914513111, 0.0014141368446871638, -0.02091737650334835, 0.01007825881242752, -0.02411048859357834, 0.03015993908047676, 0.01917114295065403, 0.047198183834552765, -0.021391354501247406, -0.002672360045835376, 0.01577846147119999, 0.04425453394651413, 0.056328486651182175, -0.014655884355306625, 0.006442352198064327, -0.0001536724012112245, 0.00999094732105732, -0.04527732729911804, -0.03003520704805851, 0.025320379063487053, -0.012504275888204575, 0.025495002046227455, 0.001752469572238624, -0.0005071091582067311, -0.0037419279105961323, -0.0016464482760056853, 0.017811575904488564, 0.033103588968515396, -0.04752248153090477, 0.04669925943017006, -0.018946627154946327, 0.04487818852066994, 0.014718249440193176, -0.04956807196140289, -0.035523369908332825, 0.008444284088909626, -0.016314804553985596, -0.02175307460129261, 0.048944417387247086, -0.017038244754076004, 0.01743738353252411, 0.02435995079576969, 0.0062989117577672005, -0.02266361005604267, -0.006754179485142231, 0.02005673386156559, -0.015691149979829788, -0.016002977266907692, -0.00998471025377512, -0.025407690554857254, 0.022127266973257065, 0.024497153237462044, 0.022763393819332123, -0.019395658746361732, -0.12962037324905396, -0.02100468799471855, 0.002352737123146653, 0.010589655488729477, -0.010770515538752079, 0.023773714900016785, 0.007109662983566523, -0.008163639344274998, -0.02083006501197815, 0.024609411135315895, -0.00870621856302023, -0.014780614525079727, -0.043007224798202515, 0.007259340025484562, 0.020381033420562744, -0.007409017067402601, -0.0009136540465988219, 0.031107893213629723, 0.0332782119512558, 0.028713058680295944, 0.022189632058143616, 0.02513328194618225, 0.011256965808570385, 0.01905888505280018, -0.005070312414318323, 0.05692719668149948, 0.0167763102799654, 0.0070971897803246975, 0.01742491126060486, 0.02581930160522461, -0.01133804116398096, 0.03243004158139229, -0.008213531225919724, 0.009947291575372219, -0.003296014852821827, -0.01575351692736149, 0.06530911475419998, 0.012348362244665623, -0.0251582283526659, -0.0010056430473923683, -0.03667089343070984, -0.017375018447637558, 0.02167823538184166, -0.023624038323760033, 0.015454161912202835, 0.019370712339878082, -0.015603839419782162, -0.011412879452109337, 0.017125556245446205, 0.019383186474442482, -0.003355261869728565, 0.015366850420832634, -0.03831734135746956, -0.018784478306770325, -0.03577283024787903, 0.005746977403759956, -0.010521053336560726, -0.07663468271493912, 0.0024026294704526663, 0.033727243542671204, 0.020692860707640648, -0.002914026379585266, -0.03143219277262688, -0.03891604766249657, -0.03896594047546387, 0.021915223449468613, -0.004069346468895674, 0.023561671376228333, -0.01927092857658863, 0.019695013761520386, 0.04687388241291046, 0.010633311234414577, -0.016302332282066345, 0.03739433363080025, 0.004003862850368023, -0.005341602023690939, -0.01498018391430378, -0.023661457002162933, -0.0007877537864260375, -0.019607702270150185, -0.024659303948283195, -0.02596897818148136, 0.0030340799130499363, -0.03003520704805851, 0.01999436691403389, 0.006423642858862877, -0.037294548004865646, -0.027016717940568924, 0.027839943766593933, -0.006386223249137402, -0.019844690337777138, 0.029436498880386353, -0.008806003257632256, -0.006947512738406658, -0.022925544530153275, 0.012629006057977676, -0.01289717759937048, 0.038891103118658066, 0.008263424038887024, -0.022052427753806114, -0.030234776437282562, -0.02933671325445175, -0.028787897899746895, -0.02926187589764595, -0.030708754435181618, 0.02171565406024456, -0.008581487461924553, -0.014281691052019596, 0.011163418181240559, -0.013919971883296967, 0.02517070062458515, -0.011082342825829983, 0.0011249170638620853, 0.03402659669518471, 0.01131933182477951, 0.00998471025377512, -0.03519906848669052, 0.03098316304385662, -0.008812240324914455, 0.0335526205599308, -0.006267729215323925, -0.057026978582143784, -0.021877804771065712, -0.02843865193426609, -0.025594785809516907, 0.007571167312562466, 0.012872232124209404, 0.0419844314455986, -0.02004425972700119, 0.013558251783251762, 0.018073512241244316, -0.040637336671352386, 0.006959985941648483, -0.024746615439653397, -0.002725370693951845, -0.00281268241815269, -0.009454604238271713, 0.011213310062885284, 0.006454825401306152, -0.007633532863110304, 0.023798661306500435, -0.01915867067873478, 0.005092140287160873, 0.0666562095284462, -0.0029452089220285416, 0.01749974861741066, 0.03270445019006729, 0.003414509119465947, 0.011437825858592987, 0.015553946606814861, -0.04265797883272171, -0.047148291021585464, 0.006604502443224192, -0.019757378846406937, 0.014793087728321552, -0.028189189732074738, -0.015017603524029255, -0.00023679387231823057, 0.019869636744260788, 0.04914398491382599, 0.009791377931833267, -0.002644295571371913, 0.0067229969426989555, 0.01252922136336565, -0.02409801445901394, 0.01415695995092392, 0.014880399219691753, 0.009704066440463066, -0.00956062600016594, 0.001761824358254671, -0.0007936005131341517, 0.0003576269664335996, -0.020356087014079094, 0.022002534940838814, 0.024734143167734146, 0.0500420480966568, -0.007646005600690842, -0.0021562858019024134, -0.011088578961789608, -0.007583640515804291, -0.005687730386853218, 0.031157786026597023, 0.005619128234684467, 0.024547046050429344, 0.020455872640013695, -0.03662100061774254, -0.004964291118085384, -0.016876094043254852, 0.0040100994519889355, 0.0023168770130723715, -0.004116120748221874, -0.03771863132715225, -0.026093710213899612, -0.017187921330332756, 0.025644678622484207, -0.04764721542596817, -0.025407690554857254, 0.029411552473902702, -0.0007846354856155813, 0.027141449972987175, 0.00916148629039526, -0.05518096312880516, -0.004431066103279591, 0.007259340025484562, 0.04407991096377373, -0.00923632550984621, -0.028812844306230545, -0.011518901214003563, 0.010433741845190525, 0.004462249111384153, -0.023648982867598534, 0.008151166141033173, 0.0416351817548275, -0.007589877117425203, 0.02411048859357834, -0.0031058001331984997, 0.002823596354573965, 0.009922345168888569, -0.01461846474558115, 0.013146639801561832, -0.004864505957812071, 0.029586175456643105, 0.029087252914905548, 0.015204699710011482, 0.010022129863500595, -0.024347476661205292, -0.022763393819332123, 0.021141892299056053, -0.006102460436522961, 0.008126219734549522, 0.029586175456643105, 0.014830507338047028, 0.043082062155008316, 0.03891604766249657, 0.018110930919647217, -0.0011358310002833605, 0.02666747197508812, -0.06775383651256561, -0.0005355633911676705, -0.03829239308834076, -0.005082785151898861, 0.0165393203496933, -0.012934597209095955, 0.002558543113991618, 0.0027191343251615763, 0.029486391693353653, -0.011394170112907887, 0.043805502355098724, 0.006155471317470074, 0.020468344911932945, -0.03694530203938484, -0.034799929708242416, 0.028787897899746895, -0.018784478306770325, -0.013907498680055141, 0.025245539844036102, 0.02594403363764286, -0.040487658232450485, 0.012285996228456497, -0.02413543500006199, 0.0011288148816674948, 0.0416351817548275, 0.002773704007267952, -0.008737401105463505, 0.05672762542963028, -0.0023652100935578346, 0.01214255578815937, 0.006878910586237907, -0.003208703128620982, -0.013645563274621964, -0.10377613455057144, 0.009273744188249111, 0.042982276529073715, 0.055580101907253265, 0.005226226057857275, 0.03986400365829468, -0.009585571475327015, 0.02846359834074974, 0.014780614525079727, 0.01423179917037487, -0.017399964854121208, -0.031407248228788376, -0.008207295089960098, 0.07299254089593887, 0.04537711292505264, -0.03170660138130188, -0.031058000400662422, -0.0015482226153835654, -0.021104473620653152, -0.030608968809247017, -0.0008879282977432013, 0.002516446402296424, 0.01988210901618004, 0.014655884355306625, 0.0034051542170345783, 0.00499547366052866, -0.019395658746361732, -0.005868589971214533, 0.03861669450998306, -0.010159334167838097, -0.011587503366172314, -0.014718249440193176, -0.02764037437736988, 0.0249337125569582, -0.048071298748254776, -0.001347873592749238, 0.02328726463019848, 0.024397369474172592, -0.021565977483987808, -0.00567213911563158, -0.011381696909666061, -0.03275434300303459, 0.015641259029507637, -0.01379524078220129, 0.03746917098760605, 0.03499949723482132, -0.007203211076557636, 0.0026099947281181812, -0.008986863307654858, 0.01423179917037487, 0.005057839211076498, 0.009248797781765461, 0.017138028517365456, 0.05577966943383217, 0.006139880046248436, 0.00482085021212697, 0.044653672724962234, -0.01581588201224804, -0.036321647465229034, -0.023923391476273537, -0.03173154965043068, 0.020555656403303146, 0.017811575904488564, -0.009822560474276543, -0.05283601954579353, -0.03265455737709999, -0.03267950192093849, 0.02512080781161785, 0.012479329481720924, -0.004437302704900503, -0.002128221560269594, 0.05348462238907814, 0.009922345168888569, -0.016888568177819252, 0.01577846147119999, -0.016252439469099045, -0.009635464288294315, 0.014119541272521019, -0.015304484404623508, 0.01823566108942032, -0.009498259983956814, -0.0500669926404953, 0.009061701595783234, -0.01575351692736149, -0.01507996954023838, 0.0007885333034209907, -0.017237814143300056, 0.010502343997359276, 0.016027923673391342, 0.017200395464897156, -0.0009760194807313383, 0.005715794861316681, -0.0062583740800619125, 0.01500513032078743, -0.009198905900120735, -0.017911361530423164, 0.0251582283526659, -0.02594403363764286, 0.01503007672727108, -0.01847265101969242, -0.041236042976379395, -0.037194762378931046, -0.01507996954023838, -0.005581709090620279, 0.0030933269299566746, -0.007895467802882195, -0.0012278200592845678, 0.007502565160393715, 0.009354819543659687, -0.013109220191836357, 0.023823607712984085, 0.04899430647492409, -0.009654173627495766, -0.030209830030798912, 0.007390307262539864, 0.00923632550984621, -0.019470497965812683, -0.008126219734549522, 0.018809424713253975, 0.016901040449738503, 0.019744906574487686, 0.0035298853181302547, -0.04283260181546211, -0.0028469834942370653, -0.023062748834490776, -0.005366547964513302, 0.0042657977901399136, -0.023150060325860977, -0.03834228590130806, 0.04817108437418938, -0.00882471352815628, 0.006779125891625881, 0.02744080312550068, 0.013682982884347439, -0.021491138264536858, 0.01424427144229412, -0.0020284366328269243, 0.051439035683870316, -0.006361277308315039, 0.0036514978855848312, -0.02326231822371483, -0.016489429399371147, 0.00881847646087408, -0.0209797415882349, -0.0008201058371923864, 0.012560403905808926, 0.01582835428416729, -0.03417627513408661, 0.019869636744260788, 0.01846017688512802, -0.005182569846510887, 0.011612449772655964, -0.002457199152559042, 0.0031915525905787945, 0.031357355415821075, 0.01846017688512802, -0.008650089614093304, -0.03502444550395012, -0.0083881551399827, -0.004795904271304607, 0.014531153254210949, 0.046275172382593155, 0.01166234165430069, -0.008431810885667801, 0.004374937154352665, 0.02001931332051754, -0.023586617782711983, 0.0251582283526659, 0.018547488376498222, 0.010963848792016506, 0.02836381271481514, -0.002783058909699321, 0.00004635995355783962, 0.017736738547682762, 0.00036386350984685123, 0.03769368678331375, -0.04530227184295654, -0.017711792141199112, 0.014892872422933578, 0.0145935183390975, -0.038691531866788864, -0.00826966017484665, 0.023985756561160088, -0.014830507338047028, 0.03614702448248863, -0.010782988741993904, -0.011674814857542515, -0.018759531900286674, 0.012310942634940147, 0.00644858879968524, 0.016002977266907692, 0.034700144082307816, -0.005173215176910162, 0.03826744854450226, 0.0077146077528595924, 0.010178043507039547, -0.024459734559059143, 0.02841370552778244, -0.010645784437656403, -0.018984047695994377, -0.017886415123939514, -0.04744764417409897, -0.045601628720760345, -0.02091737650334835, -0.009417184628546238, 0.016202546656131744, -0.002438489580526948, 0.003283541649580002, -0.027291126549243927, 0.010552236810326576, -0.029411552473902702, 0.0009128744713962078, 0.030758647248148918, -0.0004786549252457917, 0.028039513155817986, -0.060569338500499725, 0.0249212384223938, -0.02162834256887436, -0.02933671325445175, -0.04669925943017006, 0.01575351692736149, -0.0208051186054945, -0.007327942177653313, 0.05153881758451462, 0.013994810171425343, 0.018709639087319374, 0.008500413037836552, -0.0014102390268817544, -0.03090832382440567, 0.010976321995258331, 0.02353672683238983, 0.0059652565978467464, 0.009155250154435635, -0.011412879452109337, -0.009591808542609215, 0.007602349855005741, -0.010913955979049206, -0.019794797524809837, -0.018173296004533768, -0.014281691052019596, 0.051189571619033813, -0.011587503366172314, -0.031008107587695122, -0.011007504537701607, 0.03806787729263306, 0.022339308634400368, 0.032155632972717285, 0.004053755197674036, 0.0336025133728981, -0.00044864154187962413, 0.006392459850758314, -0.01289717759937048, -0.012292233295738697, -0.01090148277580738, -0.012335889041423798, 0.016464482992887497, -0.029461445286870003, 0.04111131280660629, 0.016601687297225, -0.01088277343660593, -0.021890277042984962, 0.010876537300646305, -0.021054580807685852, -0.00955438893288374, 0.027091557160019875, -0.026243386790156364, -0.015279538929462433, 0.008787293918430805, -0.0207676999270916, -0.012560403905808926, 0.008169875480234623, -0.04585108906030655, 0.027989620342850685, 0.007839338853955269, -0.01999436691403389, -0.011051160283386707, 0.001878759590908885, 0.008462993428111076, -0.014917818829417229, 0.027041664347052574, -0.007571167312562466, -0.020443398505449295, -0.02838875912129879, -0.012741263955831528, 0.008001488633453846, -0.009367292746901512, -0.009591808542609215, -0.009111594408750534, 0.03654616326093674, 0.006199127063155174, 0.005095258355140686, 0.021216731518507004, 0.03238014876842499, -0.035398636013269424, 0.002560102380812168, -0.022276943549513817, -0.008887078613042831, 0.0011553202057257295, 0.012685135006904602, 0.013021908700466156, -0.01993200182914734, -0.02684209495782852, -0.0024992958642542362, -0.03854185715317726, 0.027864888310432434, -0.005244935397058725, 0.020455872640013695, -0.032130688428878784, 0.013321262784302235, -0.0016854266868904233, 0.010645784437656403, 0.000010463268154126126, 0.04792162403464317, -0.00879353005439043, 0.01161868590861559, -0.029586175456643105, -0.012884704396128654, 0.013046855106949806, -0.016476955264806747, 0.002095479518175125, -0.007683425210416317, 0.004833323415368795, 0.012735027819871902, -0.002368328394368291, -0.028837790712714195, 0.023748768493533134, -0.008687509223818779, 0.024646831676363945, -0.001280051190406084, 0.00882471352815628, 0.01824813522398472, 0.0209922157227993, 0.023960812017321587, -0.036221861839294434, -0.0005573913222178817, 0.025320379063487053, -0.028762951493263245, 0.013757821172475815, 0.021054580807685852, 0.016501901671290398, 0.00008935801452025771, 0.031232623383402824, -0.037244655191898346, -0.022925544530153275, -0.014605991542339325, 0.008113746531307697, -0.012204920873045921, -0.0017774157458916306, -0.02589414082467556, 0.008943207561969757, 0.06081879884004593, -0.009654173627495766, -0.01581588201224804, -0.030434345826506615, 0.017998673021793365, -0.029586175456643105, 0.047198183834552765, 0.028214136138558388, 0.012005351483821869, -0.02268855646252632, 0.018984047695994377, -0.020543184131383896, -0.029835637658834457, 0.022351782768964767, 0.012373307719826698, -0.017075663432478905, 0.0008544068550691009, 0.020193936303257942, -0.012279760092496872, -0.004593216348439455, 0.002890639239922166, 0.015142334625124931, -0.0025445108767598867, -0.0004751468659378588, 0.018547488376498222, -0.03252982720732689, 0.0025055324658751488, -0.01744985580444336, 0.0011662341421470046, 0.03592250868678093, -0.0065546100959181786, 0.0016776309348642826, -0.01330878958106041, -0.009111594408750534, -0.020343614742159843, -0.028064457699656487, 0.003068380756303668, 0.020493291318416595, 0.016913514584302902, -0.001956716412678361, 0.009067938663065434, 0.005447623319923878, 0.023711349815130234, -0.022052427753806114, -0.0083444993942976, 0.007402780465781689, 0.0022701029665768147, 0.02848854288458824, 0.006442352198064327, -0.00882471352815628, -0.016925986856222153, 0.008606433868408203, 0.016763836145401, -0.007851812057197094, 0.006423642858862877, -0.0005125661264173687, 0.02499607764184475, 0.04662442207336426, 0.04028809070587158, 0.03951475769281387, 0.00788299459964037, -0.03093327023088932, -0.0168137289583683, 0.008063854649662971, 0.022077374160289764, -0.02010662481188774, -0.0003597707545850426, 0.01134427823126316, -0.002458758419379592, -0.0168137289583683, -0.028713058680295944, -0.0011716911103576422, -0.006283320486545563, -0.016464482992887497, 0.0010485193924978375, -0.01753716915845871, -0.020630495622754097, 0.04485324025154114, -0.03667089343070984, -0.00826966017484665, -0.010196752846240997, -0.02424769289791584, -0.01594061218202114, 0.02248898707330227, -0.031132839620113373, 0.020618021488189697, 0.01584082841873169, 0.0051420326344668865, -0.037144869565963745, 0.026368118822574615, 0.009467077441513538, -0.021890277042984962, -0.002784617943689227, 0.012292233295738697, -0.007870521396398544, 0.012130082584917545, -0.021366408094763756, -0.00249773683026433, 0.007758263498544693, 0.004484076984226704, -0.010701913386583328, 0.03255477175116539, 0.024422315880656242, -0.008307079784572124, -0.012011588551104069, 0.031132839620113373, -0.0003778957179747522, -0.029810691252350807, -0.00008258551679318771, -0.024035649374127388, -0.007571167312562466, 0.005637838039547205, -0.004103647544980049, 0.01917114295065403, -0.005909127648919821, 0.01991952955722809, 0.017312653362751007, 0.01581588201224804, -0.025407690554857254, 0.00840686447918415, 0.005316655617207289, 0.011737179942429066, 0.013445993885397911, 0.011493954807519913, -0.015329430811107159, -0.004839560016989708, -0.01085782703012228, -0.01657674089074135, 0.01754964143037796, 0.032130688428878784, -0.047273021191358566, 0.029411552473902702, 0.045427002012729645, 0.00964170042425394, -0.02576940879225731, 0.012772446498274803, 0.029661014676094055, -0.029586175456643105, 0.003060585120692849, 0.032854124903678894, -0.03160681575536728, 0.028089404106140137, -0.016925986856222153, -0.024472208693623543, 0.0009456163388676941, 0.007041060831397772, -0.013732874765992165, -0.007639769464731216, -0.001839781180024147, 0.02331221103668213, -0.0011436266358941793, -0.01754964143037796, 0.0009853743249550462, -0.008113746531307697, -0.0012933037942275405, -0.022114792838692665, 0.002851660829037428, -0.01915867067873478, -0.004518378060311079, -0.0008715573349036276, -0.0019941357895731926, 0.017898887395858765, -0.011674814857542515, 0.03165670856833458, 0.023948337882757187, -0.028164243325591087, 0.0021266622934490442, -0.006548373494297266, -0.01574104279279709, 0.011007504537701607, 0.023673929274082184, -0.04854527860879898, 0.03849196434020996, -0.015292011201381683, -0.020443398505449295, -0.016364697366952896, 0.018796950578689575, 0.004122357349842787, -0.016414590179920197, 0.006529664155095816, -0.006376868579536676, -0.019345765933394432, 0.016439536586403847, 0.019408132880926132, 0.0044341846369206905, -0.01596555858850479, 0.00788299459964037, -0.005260526668280363, 0.01418190635740757, -0.004153539892286062, -0.0029654777608811855, 0.01675136387348175, 0.034750036895275116, 0.0019411250250414014, 0.01582835428416729, 0.028638221323490143, -0.0018834370421245694, -0.050590865314006805, -0.0249212384223938, 0.01910877786576748, 0.005852998699992895, -0.018609853461384773, 0.02008167840540409, -0.02327479049563408, 0.0002147710620192811, 0.0006758857052773237, -0.009760195389389992, 0.006991168484091759, 0.0335027277469635, 0.02996036782860756, 0.03562315180897713, -0.021491138264536858, -0.00010105154069606215, 0.02843865193426609, 0.017674371600151062, 0.016402116045355797, -0.005709558259695768, 0.02240167371928692, 0.010302774608135223, 0.016190074384212494, 0.02500855177640915, -0.0076771886087954044, 0.01757458783686161, 0.018135877326130867, -0.006292675156146288, 0.009267508052289486, 0.054632145911455154, 0.01078922487795353, 0.02016899175941944, 0.03839217871427536, -0.01836039312183857, -0.01747480221092701, -0.009891162626445293, -0.002842305926606059, -0.02761542797088623, 0.009591808542609215, -0.026318226009607315, 0.032854124903678894, -0.03427605703473091, -0.006043213419616222, -0.008450520224869251, -0.0065546100959181786, 0.012666425667703152, -0.033028747886419296, 0.010920193046331406, 0.03492465987801552, 0.002173436339944601, 0.02100468799471855, -0.022962963208556175, 0.008893314749002457, -0.036246806383132935, 0.044553887099027634, -0.005959019996225834, -0.013682982884347439, 0.020268775522708893, 0.028837790712714195, 0.044553887099027634, -0.01744985580444336, -0.022850705310702324, 0.023948337882757187, -0.029835637658834457, 0.052237313240766525, 0.024372423067688942, 0.00872492790222168, 0.028912628069519997, 0.012516748160123825, -0.009342346340417862, 0.001593437627889216, -0.002832951257005334, -0.04021324962377548, 0.006323858164250851, -0.023861026391386986, 0.0037731104530394077, -0.03400165215134621, 0.04398012533783913, 0.027241233736276627, -0.008868369273841381, -0.023948337882757187, 0.013682982884347439, -0.01756211370229721, 0.026118656620383263, -0.016988351941108704, 0.00584364403039217, -0.010533526539802551, -0.007384070660918951, 0.025619732216000557, 0.017711792141199112, 0.005693966988474131, -0.010290301404893398, 0.04707345366477966, 0.0042159054428339005, 0.020206410437822342, -0.0027955318801105022, -0.00790170393884182, 0.009386002086102962, -0.014680829830467701, 0.028064457699656487, -0.018559962511062622, 0.0010664494475349784, 0.009454604238271713, 0.001730641582980752, -0.003324079094454646, -0.02242662012577057, 0.001838222029618919, 0.02664252556860447, 0.021279096603393555, -0.001847576815634966, -0.027989620342850685, -0.02576940879225731, -0.037993039935827255, 0.012348362244665623, 0.04859516769647598, -0.012809866108000278, 0.019794797524809837, 0.010639548301696777, 0.016227493062615395, -0.031157786026597023, 0.0416850745677948, 0.02336210198700428, 0.033253263682127, -0.021279096603393555, 0.01753716915845871, 0.015366850420832634, 0.037244655191898346, -0.005697085056453943, 0.03275434300303459, -0.016938459128141403, -0.008612670935690403, 0.0334777794778347, 0.003193111624568701, 0.017749210819602013, -0.021391354501247406, 0.01338362880051136, 0.03654616326093674, 0.0000746923906262964, -0.013371155597269535, -0.0038292394019663334, 0.01741243712604046, -0.006089987698942423, -0.013109220191836357, 0.025357797741889954, -0.021528558805584908, 0.006679341197013855, 0.009691593237221241, -0.03447562828660011, 0.01927092857658863, -0.005597300361841917, -0.004384292289614677, 0.002942090854048729, -0.01913372427225113, -0.012360834516584873, -0.011182127520442009, 0.009635464288294315, 0.009679120033979416, 0.01754964143037796, -0.0023558554239571095, 0.013695456087589264, 0.01503007672727108, 0.0334777794778347, -0.006164825987070799, -0.002174995606765151, -0.008637616410851479, -0.026068763807415962, -0.011013740673661232, -0.01924598217010498, 0.035523369908332825, -0.009130303747951984, -0.005160741973668337, -0.014369002543389797, -0.0041379486210644245, 0.017923833802342415, 0.026168549433350563, 0.001869404804892838, -0.01253545843064785, 0.010321483947336674, -0.035473477095365524, 0.00794535968452692, 0.028613274917006493, -0.005488160997629166, -0.01833544671535492, 0.03821755573153496, -0.007833101786673069, -0.008912025019526482, -0.030608968809247017, 0.0028766070026904345, 0.005054720677435398, -0.0023246726486831903, 0.0001466562825953588, -0.027091557160019875 ]
11.770843
4.123647
2024-07-01
6
2024MNRAS.532..903S
[ "galaxy number densities", "different absolute magnitude threshold samples", "number densities", "BGS measurements", "sky mocks", "different cosmologies", "Accurate mock galaxy catalogues", "different realizations", "samples", "mock catalogues" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
11
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1503", "10.48550/arXiv.2312.08792" ]
[ "Smith, A.", "Grove, C.", "Cole, S.", "Norberg, P.", "Zarrouk, P.", "Yuan, S.", "Aguilar, J.", "Ahlen, S.", "Brooks, D.", "Claybaugh, T.", "de la Macorra, A.", "Doel, P.", "Forero-Romero, J. E.", "Gaztañaga, E.", "Gontcho, S. Gontcho A.", "Hahn, C.", "Kehoe, R.", "Kremin, A.", "Levi, M. E.", "Manera, M.", "Meisner, A.", "Miquel, R.", "Moustakas, J.", "Nie, J.", "Percival, W. J.", "Rezaie, M.", "Rossi, G.", "Sanchez, E.", "Seo, H.", "Tarlé, G.", "Zhou, Z." ]
[ "Institute for Computational Cosmology, Department of Physics, Durham University, South Road, Durham DH1 3LE, UK", "Institute for Computational Cosmology, Department of Physics, Durham University, South Road, Durham DH1 3LE, UK", "Institute for Computational Cosmology, Department of Physics, Durham University, South Road, Durham DH1 3LE, UK", "Institute for Computational Cosmology, Department of Physics, Durham University, South Road, Durham DH1 3LE, UK; Centre for Extragalactic Astronomy, Department of Physics, Durham University, South Road, Durham DH1 3LE, UK", "Laboratoire de Physique Nucléaire et de Hautes Energies (LPNHE), CNRS/IN2P3 and Sorbonne Université, 4 place Jussieu, F-75005 Paris, France", "SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory, Menlo Park, CA 94305, USA", "Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 1 Cyclotron Road, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA", "Physics Dept., Boston University, 590 Commonwealth Avenue, Boston, MA 02215, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University College London, Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, UK", "Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 1 Cyclotron Road, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA", "Instituto de Física, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, Cd. de México C.P. 04510, México", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University College London, Gower Street, London WC1E 6BT, UK", "Departamento de Física, Universidad de los Andes, Cra. 1 No. 18A-10, Edificio Ip, CP 111711 Bogotá, Colombia; Observatorio Astronómico, Universidad de los Andes, Cra. 1 No. 18A-10, Edificio H, CP 111711 Bogotá, Colombia", "Institut d'Estudis Espacials de Catalunya (IEEC), E-08034 Barcelona, Spain; Institute of Cosmology and Gravitation, University of Portsmouth, Dennis Sciama Building, Portsmouth PO1 3FX, UK; Institute of Space Sciences, ICE-CSIC, Campus UAB, Carrer de Can Magrans s/n, E-08913 Bellaterra, Barcelona, Spain", "Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 1 Cyclotron Road, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA", "Department of Astrophysical Sciences, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ 08544, USA", "Department of Physics, Southern Methodist University, 3215 Daniel Avenue, Dallas, TX 75275, USA", "Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 1 Cyclotron Road, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA", "Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 1 Cyclotron Road, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA", "Departament de Física, Serra Húnter, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, E-08193 Bellaterra, Barcelona, Spain; Institut de Física d'Altes Energies (IFAE), The Barcelona Institute of Science and Technology, Campus UAB, E-08193 Bellaterra, Barcelona, Spain", "NSF's NOIRLab, 950 N. Cherry Ave., Tucson, AZ 85719, USA", "Institut de Física d'Altes Energies (IFAE), The Barcelona Institute of Science and Technology, Campus UAB, E-08193 Bellaterra, Barcelona, Spain; Institució Catalana de Recerca i Estudis Avançats, Passeig de Lluís Companys, 23, E-08010 Barcelona, Spain", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, Siena College, 515 Loudon Road, Loudonville, NY 12211, USA", "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, A20 Datun Rd., Chaoyang District, Beijing 100012, P. R. China", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Waterloo, 200 University Ave W, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada; Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics, 31 Caroline St. North, Waterloo, ON N2L 2Y5, Canada; Waterloo Centre for Astrophysics, University of Waterloo, 200 University Ave W, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada", "Department of Physics, Kansas State University, 116 Cardwell Hall, Manhattan, KS 66506, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, Sejong University, Seoul 143-747, Korea", "CIEMAT, Avenida Complutense 40, E-28040 Madrid, Spain", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, Ohio University, Athens, OH 45701, USA", "Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA", "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, A20 Datun Rd., Chaoyang District, Beijing 100012, P. R. China" ]
[ "2023arXiv230912400M", "2024arXiv240403000D", "2024arXiv240403006L", "2024arXiv240513495E", "2024arXiv240606085P", "2024arXiv240706284M" ]
[ "1985ApJ...292..371D", "1987MNRAS.227....1K", "1989MNRAS.237.1127C", "1994ApJ...426...23F", "1996ApJ...462..563N", "1996MNRAS.282..347M", "1997ApJ...490..493N", "1998AJ....116.1009R", "1999ApJ...517..565P", "1999ApJ...518..533L", "2001MNRAS.325.1288S", "2002ApJ...575..587B", "2002PhR...372....1C", "2003ApJ...592..819B", "2003ApJS..148..175S", "2003MNRAS.339.1057Y", "2004ApJ...614..533T", "2005ApJ...633..560E", "2005ApJ...633..791Z", "2005MNRAS.362..505C", "2005Natur.435..629S", "2006ApJ...647..201C", "2006MNRAS.365...11C", "2006MNRAS.369...68S", "2008Natur.451..541G", "2009ApJS..182..543A", "2009MNRAS.392.1080S", "2011ApJ...736...59Z", "2011MNRAS.416.1486N", "2012MNRAS.420.1239L", "2012MNRAS.426.2046A", "2013ApJ...771...30R", "2013MNRAS.430..725V", "2013MNRAS.430..747M", "2013MNRAS.430..767C", "2013PASP..125..306F", "2014ApJ...784..128S", "2014MNRAS.437.3228G", "2014MNRAS.444.1518V", "2014MNRAS.445.2125M", "2015ApJ...810...35K", "2015MNRAS.447..646C", "2015MNRAS.450.1937C", "2015MNRAS.452.2087L", "2015MNRAS.454.3030P", "2016JOSS....1...46B", "2016MNRAS.458.4015Z", "2016MNRAS.460.2552H", "2016MNRAS.461.3421F", "2016MNRAS.462.3854L", "2016arXiv161100036D", "2016arXiv161100037D", "2017MNRAS.465.2936M", "2017MNRAS.470.4646S", "2017MNRAS.472.1106B", "2018AJ....156..160H", "2018ARA&A..56..435W", "2018MNRAS.478.2019Y", "2019AJ....157..168D", "2019ApJ...874...95Z", "2019MNRAS.484.1285S", "2019MNRAS.488.1220P", "2019NatAs...3..891V", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020MNRAS.491.5795H", "2020MNRAS.495.1511B", "2020MNRAS.498..128M", "2020MNRAS.499.5486A", "2021ApJ...908...11L", "2021ApJ...919...16F", "2021CQGra..38o3001D", "2021MNRAS.503...59A", "2021MNRAS.503.4147P", "2021MNRAS.504.3029L", "2021MNRAS.508..175C", "2021MNRAS.508..575G", "2021MNRAS.508.4017M", "2022AJ....164..207D", "2022MNRAS.509..501H", "2022MNRAS.509.1478Z", "2022MNRAS.509.2194H", "2022MNRAS.510.3301Y", "2022MNRAS.515..871Y", "2022MNRAS.516...57Y", "2022MNRAS.516.1062S", "2022MNRAS.516.4529S", "2023AJ....165..253H", "2023MNRAS.524.3894R", "2023MNRAS.526.4978S", "2023arXiv230606315P", "2024AJ....167...62D", "2024AJ....168...58D", "2024ApJ...963..116P", "2024MNRAS.527.3771A", "2024MNRAS.527.9048T", "2024MNRAS.528.7236D", "2024arXiv240403000D", "2024arXiv240403006L" ]
29163192
2403.10490
Does the Correlation between 2MRS Galaxies and the CMB Indicate an Unmodeled CMB Foreground?
We revisit the claimed detection of a new cosmic microwave background (CMB) foreground based on the correlation between low-redshift Two Micron All Sky Survey Redshift Survey (2MRS) galaxies and CMB temperature maps from the Planck and Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe missions. We reproduce the reported measurements but argue that the original analysis significantly underestimated the uncertainties. We cross-correlate the 2MRS galaxy positions with simulated CMB maps and show that the correlation measured with the real data for late-type spiral galaxies at angular scales θ ≥ 0.°1 and redshift cz &lt; 4500 km s<SUP>‑1</SUP> is consistent with zero at the 1.7σ level or less, depending on the exact CMB map and simulation construction. This was the sample that formed the basis for the original detection claim. For smaller angular separations the results are not robust to galaxy type or CMB cleaning method, and we are unable to draw firm conclusions. The original analysis did not propose a specific, falsifiable physical correlation mechanism, and it is impossible to rule out any contribution from an underlying physical effect. However, given our calculations, the lack of signal from expanding the redshift range, and the lack of corroboration from other galaxy surveys, we do not find the evidence for a new CMB foreground signal compelling.
[ 0.012137494049966335, 0.0002358377823838964, -0.0016186224529519677, -0.006289007607847452, -0.059910766780376434, 0.06821109354496002, 0.023312799632549286, 0.0033068007323890924, -0.006746916566044092, 0.042869582772254944, -0.023695357143878937, -0.030233606696128845, 0.021759385243058205, 0.033734582364559174, 0.01900033839046955, 0.023950394243001938, -0.02733544632792473, 0.012044752947986126, -0.044585295021533966, -0.0014940014807507396, -0.01722666434943676, -0.000871621654368937, -0.022396981716156006, 0.009755207225680351, -0.0409683920443058, -0.03053501434624195, 0.027544112876057625, 0.009256723336875439, 0.008764035999774933, 0.008868370205163956, -0.00611511804163456, -0.029375750571489334, -0.07094696164131165, -0.03385050967335701, -0.05777772143483162, 0.07127155363559723, -0.012821460142731667, 0.0006560710025951266, -0.010195727460086346, -0.04191898927092552, -0.03062775544822216, 0.03382732346653938, 0.016635438427329063, -0.029978567734360695, -0.016681808978319168, -0.039554089307785034, -0.025805218145251274, -0.008230774663388729, -0.046579230576753616, -0.027567299082875252, -0.03551984950900078, 0.024854620918631554, -0.015082024969160557, -0.018571410328149796, -0.02370695024728775, 0.009100222960114479, 0.0011107198661193252, 0.03466199338436127, -0.03046545945107937, -0.00020649390353355557, -0.008259756490588188, -0.010769562795758247, 0.009024870581924915, -0.013517018407583237, -0.010682618245482445, -0.0019939341582357883, 0.005347105208784342, 0.003770506242290139, 0.05402170494198799, 0.035728517919778824, -0.009053852409124374, -0.02548062428832054, -0.0015925390180200338, -0.007917772978544235, 0.007691716775298119, -0.009077037684619427, 0.05847327783703804, -0.014409651979804039, -0.0329926535487175, 0.014664690010249615, -0.006370156072080135, 0.010717395693063736, -0.00594122800976038, -0.002625733148306608, -0.03626177832484245, -0.012983757071197033, 0.02566610649228096, 0.03157835081219673, -0.03665592893958092, 0.024089505895972252, 0.007477253209799528, 0.028958415612578392, 0.035543035715818405, -0.01178971491754055, -0.002406921936199069, -0.045280855149030685, -0.0002356566401431337, -0.04736752808094025, 0.04270728677511215, 0.019046708941459656, -0.01094924844801426, 0.021759385243058205, 0.029793085530400276, -0.02670944295823574, 0.029885826632380486, 0.011998382396996021, 0.024692324921488762, -0.04567500203847885, 0.03150879591703415, 0.021353643387556076, 0.05471726134419441, 0.005242771469056606, -0.028842490166425705, 0.020275527611374855, -0.026778999716043472, 0.011117341928184032, -0.05235236510634422, 0.004712408408522606, -0.023463504388928413, 0.011801308020949364, 0.006949787959456444, 0.026755813509225845, 0.033549100160598755, 0.02687174081802368, 0.021121790632605553, 0.013563388958573341, 0.02041463926434517, -0.04472440853714943, -0.01609058491885662, 0.0605599544942379, 0.009384242817759514, 0.0058281999081373215, 0.017365776002407074, 0.08615650236606598, -0.054253555834293365, 0.034685179591178894, 0.05717490240931511, -0.016171732917428017, 0.0021185551304370165, -0.02348668873310089, -0.007685920689254999, 0.0461387075483799, 0.028912045061588287, 0.01867574453353882, 0.005300734657794237, -0.019069893285632133, -0.005526791326701641, -0.005839792545884848, 0.0327376164495945, 0.0030720497015863657, -0.024066321551799774, -0.013389499858021736, -0.0342678464949131, 0.003944396041333675, -0.010375413112342358, -0.03303902596235275, 0.010282672010362148, -0.0011317315511405468, -0.00578472763299942, -0.0541144460439682, -0.031276945024728775, 0.009998652152717113, -0.025550179183483124, 0.022292647510766983, -0.014676283113658428, 0.018154075369238853, -0.015371841378509998, -0.010381209664046764, -0.07729972898960114, -0.044585295021533966, 0.01728462614119053, 0.01305331289768219, -0.04166394844651222, -0.0332476943731308, 0.007100492250174284, 0.07386830449104309, 0.005407966673374176, -0.04078290984034538, 0.0027242705691605806, -0.02863382175564766, 0.009708836674690247, 0.019730674102902412, 0.055830154567956924, -0.02949167788028717, -0.044933073222637177, 0.004196535795927048, 0.01706436648964882, 0.011227472685277462, 0.03269124776124954, -0.018629373982548714, 0.0013063456863164902, 0.008764035999774933, 0.034406956285238266, 0.04226676747202873, -0.02942212112247944, -0.060791805386543274, -0.007929366081953049, 0.04101476073265076, -0.0694631040096283, 0.022083979099988937, 0.022130349650979042, -0.024089505895972252, 0.03540392220020294, -0.029885826632380486, -0.04892094433307648, -0.03760652616620064, 0.04915279522538185, -0.0023518570233136415, -0.03463881090283394, 0.010276875458657742, 0.05174954608082771, -0.03967001661658287, 0.010978230275213718, 0.018884411081671715, -0.027358630672097206, -0.03549666330218315, -0.06125551089644432, -0.0029532250482589006, 0.03582125902175903, 0.03542710840702057, -0.03793111816048622, 0.07159614562988281, 0.04718204587697983, 0.016820920631289482, -0.0003586473176255822, 0.01024209801107645, 0.04713567718863487, -0.015545730479061604, 0.0161137692630291, -0.016647031530737877, 0.001541821169666946, 0.03143924102187157, -0.006886028219014406, 0.022814316675066948, 0.000024611719709355384, 0.02108701318502426, 0.016194919124245644, -0.009123408235609531, -0.008335108868777752, -0.0073439376428723335, -0.009952281601727009, 0.002463435987010598, -0.0033125970512628555, -0.006074543576687574, -0.019266968593001366, 0.03820934146642685, -0.009900114499032497, -0.02645440585911274, 0.02784552238881588, -0.021736200898885727, 0.038418009877204895, 0.05527370795607567, -0.014212577603757381, -0.014861765317618847, -0.0071352701634168625, 0.020461009815335274, -0.028517896309494972, 0.028378784656524658, -0.021817348897457123, -0.019556785002350807, -0.026129812002182007, -0.040156904608011246, -0.046671971678733826, -0.008607535623013973, -0.02215353585779667, 0.03436058759689331, 0.01643836498260498, -0.029213454574346542, -0.008381479419767857, 0.020785603672266006, -0.0034980792552232742, 0.015719620510935783, 0.03802385926246643, -0.02907434292137623, -0.0143980598077178, 0.04736752808094025, -0.0005890510510653257, 0.043194178491830826, 0.013424277305603027, -0.013088091276586056, 0.008427849970757961, 0.009413223713636398, 0.029862642288208008, -0.022118758410215378, 0.009876929223537445, 0.010752174071967602, 0.009285705164074898, -0.006671564653515816, -0.02942212112247944, -0.007488845847547054, 0.026477590203285217, -0.059400688856840134, -0.0032488375436514616, -0.013041720725595951, -0.06788650155067444, 0.01112313847988844, 0.0530942939221859, 0.0002208035730291158, -0.07076147943735123, 0.003732830286026001, 0.04175668954849243, 0.026570331305265427, 0.00008689951937412843, -0.02032189816236496, -0.0070657143369317055, 0.03387369588017464, 0.019162634387612343, 0.003025679150596261, -0.0203566774725914, 0.03429102897644043, -0.0690457671880722, 0.0046602413058280945, -0.035890813916921616, 0.021863719448447227, 0.024738695472478867, 0.017806295305490494, 0.004616769030690193, 0.029468491673469543, 0.016334030777215958, -0.021643459796905518, -0.04488670453429222, -0.057638607919216156, 0.0020200174767524004, 0.015789175406098366, 0.007100492250174284, -0.009088629856705666, -0.005587652791291475, -0.022860687226057053, 0.026686258614063263, 0.00933787226676941, 0.020774012431502342, 0.027799151837825775, 0.04351877048611641, -0.027891892939805984, -0.0690457671880722, -0.0402032770216465, 0.0040458315052092075, 0.05499548465013504, -0.04887457191944122, -0.02958441898226738, 0.008984296582639217, 0.016855699941515923, 0.05610837787389755, 0.024553213268518448, 0.028517896309494972, 0.025295142084360123, 0.020368268713355064, -0.017493294551968575, 0.0322275385260582, -0.0069266026839613914, 0.0054224575869739056, -0.02032189816236496, 0.07678964734077454, -0.014351689256727695, 0.04827175289392471, 0.008329312317073345, -0.02914389781653881, -0.00516741955652833, 0.026338478550314903, -0.0004510261642280966, 0.029375750571489334, -0.03306221216917038, 0.053557999432086945, 0.008114848285913467, 0.00460807466879487, 0.047297973185777664, -0.06134825199842453, -0.005039900541305542, -0.034847475588321686, -0.043194178491830826, 0.010757970623672009, 0.01187086384743452, -0.03081323765218258, -0.025040103122591972, -0.05406807363033295, 0.0024112691171467304, 0.016867291182279587, 0.03185657411813736, 0.01684410683810711, 0.013250388205051422, 0.05610837787389755, -0.0033328840509057045, 0.01978863775730133, -0.03957727551460266, 0.0020663882605731487, -0.009355260990560055, -0.04479396343231201, -0.05119309946894646, -0.08722302317619324, 0.0062426370568573475, -0.032505765557289124, -0.006532453000545502, 0.008265553042292595, -0.014270540326833725, -0.0024851723574101925, 0.014641504734754562, 0.014502393081784248, 0.04966287314891815, 0.030164049938321114, 0.06881391257047653, -0.02930619567632675, -0.054856374859809875, -0.049291908740997314, -0.0025242974516004324, -0.018026554957032204, 0.004996427800506353, 0.0010592775652185082, 0.07071510702371597, 0.016206510365009308, 0.017945406958460808, 0.01691366173326969, -0.03783837705850601, 0.009053852409124374, -0.006764305755496025, 0.0028445441275835037, 0.008323515765368938, -0.04776167869567871, 0.046602413058280945, -0.019174227491021156, 0.043820179998874664, 0.017725147306919098, 0.01665862463414669, 0.02189849689602852, 0.04222039505839348, -0.03385050967335701, 0.005976005923002958, 0.010757970623672009, 0.04497944563627243, 0.016299253329634666, -0.02645440585911274, -0.048410866409540176, 0.029862642288208008, 0.025295142084360123, -0.02967716008424759, -0.02086675353348255, 0.004071915056556463, 0.008195997215807438, -0.003898025257512927, -0.009720428846776485, 0.00726278917863965, 0.012612792663276196, 0.002217092551290989, -0.057638607919216156, -0.022547686472535133, 0.05916883796453476, 0.023904023692011833, 0.01934811659157276, 0.017817888408899307, 0.0024054727982729673, -0.00041769733070395887, -0.03148560971021652, -0.06630990654230118, 0.0008890106109902263, 0.005764440633356571, -0.04943101853132248, 0.01589350961148739, 0.011326009407639503, -0.04887457191944122, 0.008300330489873886, -0.024483656510710716, 0.0287961196154356, 0.024761879816651344, -0.01283305324614048, 0.029561232775449753, -0.02497054822742939, 0.04080609604716301, 0.015626879408955574, 0.015951473265886307, -0.01905830018222332, 0.007123677525669336, 0.04101476073265076, -0.03605310991406441, 0.03496340289711952, -0.021191347390413284, -0.0003532132541295141, -0.01365613006055355, -0.003425625152885914, -0.035728517919778824, 0.06450144946575165, 0.016867291182279587, 0.05949342995882034, -0.009917504154145718, 0.015522545203566551, 0.010879692621529102, -0.004558805841952562, 0.0018562715267762542, -0.0315551683306694, 0.04994109645485878, -0.01112313847988844, 0.0064223227091133595, 0.0026996361557394266, -0.052769698202610016, -0.011917234398424625, -0.009575520642101765, 0.029653973877429962, -0.05522733926773071, 0.012983757071197033, 0.04073653742671013, -0.029700344428420067, 0.042429063469171524, 0.036841411143541336, -0.013319944031536579, 0.01596306636929512, 0.03378095477819443, 0.005010918714106083, 0.0714106634259224, -0.08263234049081802, -0.029375750571489334, -0.029283009469509125, -0.003272022819146514, -0.0315551683306694, 0.09849107265472412, 0.03169427812099457, 0.004912381526082754, 0.006260025780647993, 0.040666982531547546, -0.013760464265942574, 0.044075217097997665, 0.024854620918631554, -0.024645954370498657, 0.04131617024540901, -0.045188114047050476, -0.014108243398368359, -0.000023298489395529032, 0.00765693886205554, -0.0234519112855196, -0.016322437673807144, -0.09046896547079086, -0.017875852063298225, -0.0270572230219841, 0.01618332602083683, -0.007796050515025854, 0.017620813101530075, -0.017493294551968575, -0.00008608440839452669, -0.027451371774077415, -0.00508047454059124, -0.011326009407639503, -0.012682348489761353, -0.007627957500517368, 0.01830478012561798, -0.021689830347895622, -0.006920806132256985, -0.013992317020893097, 0.009285705164074898, 0.05745312571525574, -0.019290152937173843, 0.021979646757245064, 0.04196535795927048, 0.05532008036971092, 0.044237516820430756, -0.011673788540065289, 0.008821999654173851, 0.046787895262241364, -0.01158104743808508, -0.012844645418226719, 0.04280002787709236, -0.027103593572974205, 0.034499697387218475, -0.02367217093706131, 0.002370694885030389, -0.006694749929010868, -0.016542697325348854, 0.030929164960980415, -0.014803801663219929, -0.043031882494688034, -0.0033386803697794676, 0.016647031530737877, -0.0036487835459411144, 0.01748170144855976, 0.01775992475450039, -0.0070657143369317055, -0.01715710759162903, -0.03929905220866203, 0.012218642979860306, 0.023185281082987785, 0.029723530635237694, -0.014676283113658428, 0.0017707757651805878, -0.043912921100854874, -0.015209544450044632, 0.01706436648964882, 0.03037271834909916, 0.02617618255317211, -0.0010897081810981035, -0.011586843989789486, 0.0035357552114874125, -0.04018009081482887, -0.0010527566773816943, 0.014757431112229824, 0.005891959648579359, -0.01039859838783741, -0.016832513734698296, -0.01713392324745655, 0.021353643387556076, 0.028842490166425705, 0.026083441451191902, 0.029978567734360695, 0.006051358301192522, 0.0019359709694981575, 0.022779539227485657, 0.008775629103183746, -0.0157775841653347, -0.028309227898716927, 0.0062426370568573475, 0.03359547257423401, 0.00367486709728837, 0.000044604494178202, 0.003950192127376795, 0.00367776514030993, 0.016867291182279587, 0.017365776002407074, -0.008271348662674427, -0.02117975428700447, 0.0016157242935150862, 0.008885758928954601, 0.0016780346632003784, -0.04757619649171829, 0.020750826224684715, 0.0008810406434349716, -0.002162027405574918, 0.020518973469734192, 0.019255375489592552, -0.04296232387423515, 0.02626892365515232, -0.0058079129084944725, 0.018385928124189377, -0.003196670673787594, 0.005413763225078583, -0.020646492019295692, 0.0372355617582798, -0.011337602511048317, 0.0187452994287014, 0.011760734021663666, 0.020090045407414436, 0.02714996412396431, 0.004576195031404495, 0.054346296936273575, -0.04646330326795578, -0.02645440585911274, 0.004761677235364914, 0.007454067934304476, 0.013679315336048603, -0.06176558881998062, -0.0060571543872356415, -0.008590146899223328, 0.018188852816820145, -0.01658906787633896, -0.018374335020780563, -0.0017258543521165848, -0.0038458583876490593, -0.025457438081502914, -0.00032984683639369905, 0.03556622192263603, 0.018814856186509132, 0.0011730303522199392, 0.01589350961148739, 0.0449562594294548, 0.013273573480546474, 0.0013027229579165578, -0.007755476515740156, 0.020634900778532028, 0.007013547234237194, -0.030766867101192474, -0.014374874532222748, 0.036586374044418335, -0.00115564139559865, 0.03174065053462982, -0.0074830492958426476, 0.02310413308441639, -0.001074492814950645, -0.0347779206931591, 0.005060187540948391, 0.015592101030051708, -0.003379254601895809, 0.021481161937117577, 0.005976005923002958, -0.02698766626417637, -0.012079531326889992, 0.02696448192000389, -0.026431219652295113, -0.006323785521090031, -0.0067005460150539875, -0.017122330144047737, -0.025434253737330437, 0.01969589665532112, -0.013169239275157452, 0.005909348372370005, -0.01365613006055355, -0.007477253209799528, 0.015105210244655609, 0.011459325440227985, 0.033015839755535126, 0.015105210244655609, 0.0027836826629936695, -0.03208842873573303, 0.0035589407198131084, -0.004932668525725603, 0.0394381619989872, -0.0070946961641311646, 0.011326009407639503, 0.009036462754011154, 0.03255213424563408, -0.0005741979693993926, -0.0070946961641311646, -0.005654310341924429, -0.011824493296444416, 0.0013440217589959502, 0.03097553551197052, -0.017620813101530075, 0.03619222342967987, 0.006793287117034197, 0.02617618255317211, -0.024298174306750298, -0.012763497419655323, -0.009146593511104584, 0.0025300937704741955, 0.01491972804069519, -0.0357053317129612, -0.005292040295898914, 0.007830828428268433, -0.01656588353216648, -0.04882820323109627, 0.003587922314181924, 0.012809867970645428, -0.008984296582639217, -0.0020229157526046038, 0.031184202060103416, -0.028170116245746613, -0.024135876446962357, 0.005263058934360743, 0.028077375143766403, -0.019858192652463913, 0.009019074030220509, -0.0027112287934869528, 0.02645440585911274, 0.018814856186509132, 0.00023710571986157447, 0.012775089591741562, 0.013818426989018917, 0.03730511665344238, -0.0008448136504739523, 0.014664690010249615, 0.010062411427497864, 0.020472602918744087, 0.0461387075483799, 0.012856238521635532, -0.04036557301878929, -0.009001685306429863, -0.002173620043322444, -0.00852059107273817, 0.007929366081953049, -0.014548763632774353, 0.009285705164074898, 0.012763497419655323, -0.0131460539996624, -0.026083441451191902, 0.012218642979860306, -0.010282672010362148, 0.01469946838915348, 0.004051627591252327, 0.042429063469171524, 0.012612792663276196, 0.009088629856705666, 0.021191347390413284, 0.03185657411813736, -0.025805218145251274, -0.013366314582526684, 0.01283305324614048, -0.02654714696109295, 0.019858192652463913, -0.029259825125336647, 0.04402884840965271, -0.010804341174662113, 0.03178701922297478, 0.016102178022265434, 0.006712138652801514, -0.01978863775730133, 0.016890477389097214, 0.01744692400097847, 0.003216957673430443, -0.028262857347726822, 0.0011679584858939052, -0.009894318878650665, -0.020971085876226425, 0.0332476943731308, -0.030419088900089264, 0.011476714164018631, -0.0026387746911495924, -0.02480825036764145, -0.022733168676495552, -0.010624654591083527, 0.003967581316828728, -0.003871941938996315, 0.0030227808747440577, 0.02759048342704773, -0.005747051443904638, -0.0952451303601265, 0.012334569357335567, 0.016902070492506027, 0.045535892248153687, 0.007993125356733799, 0.022107165306806564, -0.01773674041032791, 0.05569104477763176, -0.028262857347726822, -0.003921210765838623, 0.016357215121388435, 0.016426771879196167, -0.01871052198112011, 0.009604502469301224, -0.01709914393723011, -0.014456022530794144, -0.029538048431277275, 0.052166882902383804, -0.01243890356272459, 0.05105398967862129, -0.0046399543061852455, 0.037560153752565384, 0.005132641643285751, 0.016960032284259796, -0.02228105440735817, -0.002640223829075694, -0.023475097492337227, 0.002098267897963524, -0.000533623737283051, -0.03220435604453087, 0.009106018580496311, -0.0036661725025624037, 0.015371841378509998, 0.024738695472478867, -0.02939893677830696, -0.02066967822611332, -0.010931859724223614, 0.0345228835940361, -0.0436810702085495, 0.015719620510935783, -0.017203478142619133, -0.0061035254038870335, -0.0062426370568573475, 0.03922949358820915, 0.02088993787765503, -0.0064223227091133595, 0.018293187022209167, 0.0020229157526046038, 0.026245737448334694, 0.013992317020893097, -0.024854620918631554, -0.0007861259509809315, 0.027799151837825775, 0.009807373397052288, -0.014757431112229824, 0.04887457191944122, 0.025109659880399704, -0.0014664690243080258, -0.004984835162758827, 0.0030865406151860952, -0.05522733926773071, -0.024599583819508553, 0.029561232775449753, -0.02592114359140396, -0.040319204330444336, 0.01449080090969801, -0.05221325159072876, 0.05467089265584946, 0.028054188936948776, -0.01479220949113369, 0.003341578645631671, 0.0391831248998642, -0.001402709516696632, 0.031717464327812195, -0.011430343613028526, -0.009691447019577026, -0.02215353585779667, 0.02436773106455803, -0.03656318783760071, 0.038232527673244476, 0.011517288163304329, -0.03656318783760071, 0.0270572230219841, -0.03357228636741638, -0.018780076876282692, 0.0307900533080101, 0.0019620542880147696, -0.024205433204770088, -0.014966098591685295, -0.008398868143558502, -0.00009527701331535354, -0.03665592893958092, -0.002027262933552265, 0.0019243783317506313, -0.010346431285142899, 0.01883804053068161, -0.001769326743669808, -0.026477590203285217, 0.039368607103824615, 0.0126591632142663, -0.014270540326833725, -0.011679585091769695, -0.02070445567369461, -0.013505426235496998, 0.050172947347164154, -0.02974671497941017, -0.009853743948042393, 0.008248163387179375, 0.013169239275157452, 0.008364089764654636, 0.010184134356677532, -0.02740500122308731, -0.03482429310679436, 0.009824763052165508, 0.03654000163078308, -0.012044752947986126, -0.008126441389322281, -0.01918582059442997, 0.010155153460800648, -0.008514794521033764, 0.017087552696466446, 0.010839118622243404, -0.017864258959889412, -0.00810905173420906, 0.0008745198138058186, -0.02983945608139038, 0.014363281428813934, -0.018200445920228958, -0.007233807817101479, 0.01975385844707489, -0.006219451781362295, -0.0004187841259408742, 0.017875852063298225, 0.00023764913203194737, 0.026315294206142426, -0.009065444581210613, -0.020205972716212273, 0.034940216690301895, -0.018385928124189377, 0.015024062246084213, -0.022524500265717506, 0.005471726413816214, 0.00984794832766056, 0.0007730842335149646, -0.00821918249130249, -0.011720159091055393, -0.02487780712544918, -0.02490099146962166, 0.017725147306919098, 0.019429264590144157, 0.01609058491885662, -0.003770506242290139, 0.021597089245915413, 0.0030604570638388395, -0.006341174244880676, -0.0046602413058280945, -0.019336523488163948, 0.008340904489159584, -0.028216486796736717, 0.021910089999437332, 0.019046708941459656, 0.022930242121219635, -0.019556785002350807, 0.006190469954162836, -0.007541012484580278, 0.025434253737330437, -0.03174065053462982, 0.0364704467356205, -0.019116263836622238, -0.008775629103183746, 0.008735054172575474, -0.03556622192263603, 0.00696138059720397, 0.02215353585779667, -0.03443014249205589, -0.012125901877880096, -0.011256453581154346, -0.01763240620493889, 0.02095949463546276, -0.01738896034657955, 0.01997411996126175, -0.00656723091378808, -0.0332476943731308, -0.015731213614344597, 0.021597089245915413, -0.0006991811096668243, -0.012044752947986126, -0.016264474019408226, -0.00967405829578638, 0.0184902623295784, 0.007106288801878691, 0.02282590977847576, -0.006132506765425205, 0.037884749472141266, 0.026732629165053368, -0.003813978750258684, -0.04370425269007683, 0.012044752947986126, -0.03695733845233917, -0.008451035246253014, -0.03660956025123596, -0.013760464265942574, 0.02200283110141754, -0.01978863775730133, 0.010056615807116032, -0.018154075369238853, 0.014247355051338673, -0.021863719448447227, -0.009755207225680351, -0.05768498033285141, -0.004474759101867676, 0.017678776755928993, -0.004642852582037449, -0.01678614318370819, 0.0684429481625557, -0.030697312206029892, 0.05235236510634422, 0.003506773617118597, -0.05420718714594841, -0.015279100276529789, 0.016334030777215958, -0.026686258614063263, 0.016820920631289482, 0.06348130106925964, -0.0013664824655279517, 0.03967001661658287, 0.016554290428757668, -0.028680192306637764, 0.014966098591685295, -0.009911707602441311, 0.0071352701634168625, -0.0021562310867011547, 0.00008114848606055602, -0.02619936689734459, -0.03062775544822216, -0.015371841378509998, 0.00015948936925269663, -0.022420166060328484, -0.027173148468136787, -0.0017983083380386233, 0.009442205540835857, -0.0327376164495945, -0.005405068397521973, -0.005520994774997234, -0.02453002706170082, -0.0060165803879499435, 0.027775965631008148, -0.009366853162646294, 0.002944530686363578, 0.002695288974791765, -0.016484735533595085, 0.013551796786487103, -0.01109415665268898, -0.005680393893271685, -0.011917234398424625, 0.02983945608139038, -0.025805218145251274, 0.010056615807116032, 0.039275866001844406, 0.009975466877222061, -0.0008259756141342223, 0.0013041720958426595, -0.02548062428832054, -0.008903147652745247, 0.003721237648278475, 0.025016918778419495, -0.026222553104162216, -0.008120644837617874, -0.02983945608139038, -0.042684100568294525, -0.005065984092652798, -0.03194931522011757, 0.03419828787446022, -0.023034576326608658, 0.03913675248622894, -0.04544315114617348, 0.033525917679071426, -0.026732629165053368, -0.008793017826974392, -0.005671699531376362, -0.022582463920116425, -0.02854108065366745, 0.014629912562668324, -0.0002515965315978974, -0.03125375881791115, 0.035102516412734985, -0.027567299082875252, -0.017620813101530075, 0.019522005692124367, -0.0322275385260582, -0.019035115838050842, 0.010705803520977497, 0.021979646757245064, 0.003202466992661357, -0.016600660979747772, -0.02478506602346897, 0.022872280329465866, 0.015812361612915993, -0.005181910470128059, -0.009656669571995735, -0.006207859143614769, -0.010624654591083527, 0.0170064028352499, -0.007842421531677246, -0.012044752947986126, -0.010653636418282986, -0.05082213506102562, -0.0031560964416712523, -0.002392431255429983, 0.015151580795645714, -0.0011092707281932235, -0.024576397612690926, 0.0058079129084944725, -0.019452450796961784, 0.011534676887094975, -0.02189849689602852, -0.014212577603757381, 0.0273122601211071, 0.04358832910656929, -0.03709644824266434, -0.006433915346860886, -0.021481161937117577, 0.03208842873573303, -0.0013751769438385963, 0.010427580215036869, 0.006428119260817766, 0.0031184202525764704, -0.012867830693721771, 0.0008064130670391023, 0.006775898393243551, -0.017458517104387283, 0.03009449504315853, 0.015545730479061604, -0.035890813916921616, -0.028123745694756508, 0.03830208256840706, 0.0233243927359581, 0.008624924346804619, 0.022744759917259216, 0.01343587040901184, 0.01927856169641018, 0.03317813575267792, -0.0157775841653347, 0.005726764444261789, 0.008746647275984287, 0.021852126345038414, 0.017296219244599342, -0.01461831945925951, -0.021643459796905518, -0.02654714696109295, 0.0675155371427536, -0.020971085876226425, 0.028564266860485077, 0.006080340128391981, -0.003915414214134216, -0.0131460539996624, -0.02854108065366745, 0.029514862224459648, 0.012670756317675114, 0.0030227808747440577, 0.013853205367922783, -0.01975385844707489, -0.004808047786355019, 0.007940958254039288, 0.0143980598077178, 0.020901530981063843, -0.010978230275213718, 0.006984565872699022, -0.015429804101586342, 0.01118689775466919, -0.0015939880395308137, -0.003961784765124321, 0.009511761367321014, 0.021260902285575867, -0.014641504734754562, -0.0005789074930362403, 0.005054390989243984, -0.04395929351449013, -0.03454606980085373, 0.0007042529177851975, -0.030697312206029892, 0.049199167639017105, -0.016600660979747772, 0.0017620812868699431, 0.0103058572858572, -0.0017620812868699431, 0.00034162061638198793, 0.03283035755157471, -0.015197951346635818, -0.027613669633865356, 0.039809126406908035, 0.00045573568786494434, -0.03150879591703415, -0.042081285268068314, -0.010375413112342358, 0.007297567091882229, -0.01966111734509468, 0.019603155553340912, 0.02010163851082325, -0.003277819138020277, 0.007146862801164389, -0.007732291240245104, -0.0021460875868797302, -0.0004724001046270132, 0.019649526104331017, 0.015603694133460522, 0.0013099684147164226, 0.02383446879684925, 0.0404583141207695, -0.013157647103071213, 0.0033068007323890924, -0.022907057777047157, -0.02592114359140396, 0.014873357489705086, -0.01627606712281704, -0.007372919470071793, -0.02601388469338417, -0.01362135261297226, -0.0034980792552232742, -0.01883804053068161, 0.0023576533421874046, -0.016125362366437912, -0.04161757975816727, 0.008856777101755142, -0.008178607560694218, -0.012009975500404835, -0.01900033839046955, 0.001812799135223031, 0.015557323582470417, -0.03403599187731743, -0.007581586949527264, 0.023347577080130577, 0.014432837255299091, 0.024414101615548134, -0.01867574453353882, 0.0031560964416712523, -0.008758239448070526, -0.017899036407470703, -0.07025139778852463, -0.011262250132858753, -0.006712138652801514, -0.0019098875345662236, -0.004683426581323147, 0.004071915056556463, 0.045373596251010895, -0.003150300122797489, 0.00846842397004366, 0.018026554957032204, 0.03844119608402252, 0.005622430704534054, -0.003808182431384921, 0.02654714696109295, 0.0034140325151383877, -0.02575884759426117, 0.013505426235496998, 0.014502393081784248, -0.023347577080130577, -0.0357053317129612, -0.0029735122807323933, 0.007297567091882229, 0.01969589665532112, 0.016391994431614876, 0.0035241625737398863, -0.011018804274499416, -0.01139556523412466, 0.02004367485642433, 0.04263773187994957, -0.008908944204449654, -0.02335917018353939, -0.07001955062150955, 0.0476689375936985, 0.020345084369182587, 0.019174227491021156, -0.033804140985012054, -0.02958441898226738, -0.03626177832484245, 0.019835008308291435, 0.006804879754781723, -0.005451438948512077, 0.023811282590031624, -0.019116263836622238, 0.02939893677830696, 0.02010163851082325, 0.004666037857532501, 0.036076296120882034, 0.010294265113770962, -0.00687443558126688, -0.007987328805029392, 0.05026568844914436, -0.045814115554094315, 0.03331724926829338, 0.010166745632886887, -0.013969131745398045, 0.007228011265397072, -0.0006582445930689573, -0.024761879816651344, -0.014653097838163376, -0.0005444918060675263, 0.011952011846005917, 0.007193233352154493, -0.016171732917428017, 0.020820382982492447, -0.0059180427342653275, -0.010346431285142899, -0.03062775544822216, 0.002595302416011691, -0.03507933020591736, -0.008022107183933258, 0.004944261163473129, 0.01621810346841812, -0.01867574453353882, 0.006225247867405415, -0.030998719856142998, 0.010844915173947811, 0.03359547257423401, 0.0026967378798872232, -0.022385388612747192, 0.010300060734152794, -0.022559277713298798, 0.007471456658095121, -0.009523354470729828, -0.025179214775562286, 0.009963874705135822, -0.009726225398480892, -0.031810205429792404, -0.03306221216917038, 0.006515063811093569, 0.010897082276642323, -0.04864272102713585, -0.00004709510176326148, -0.017910629510879517, -0.0394381619989872, -0.0020185685716569424, -0.01163321454077959, 0.0215854961425066, 0.0020997170358896255, -0.021504348143935204, 0.00524566974490881, 0.026686258614063263, -0.020785603672266006, 0.005138437729328871, 0.02759048342704773, -0.02114497683942318, 0.028819303959608078, 0.0037734045181423426, 0.022594057023525238, 0.008862573653459549, -0.016287660226225853, -0.02497054822742939, 0.01430531870573759, -0.04212765395641327, -0.01704118214547634, 0.015545730479061604, -0.0034575050231069326, 0.004040034953504801, 0.023463504388928413, 0.051378581672906876, 0.016554290428757668, -0.00035194531665183604, 0.014560356736183167, -0.031300127506256104, -0.03456925228238106, -0.014977691695094109, 0.012311384081840515, -0.005179012194275856, 0.016380401328206062, -0.0048660109750926495, 0.01658906787633896, -0.020159602165222168, 0.02222309075295925, 0.040759723633527756, 0.007152659352868795, 0.017122330144047737, 0.016009436920285225, -0.02471550926566124, -0.008248163387179375, -0.0069092134945094585, -0.005700680892914534, -0.005720967892557383, 0.02111019752919674, -0.026663072407245636, -0.0461387075483799, 0.00940163154155016, 0.0026068950537592173, 0.02497054822742939, 0.008839388377964497, -0.014780616387724876, 0.00024362657859455794, -0.02939893677830696, 0.019336523488163948, 0.0032604301813989878, -0.0018997439183294773, 0.06032809987664223, 0.02050738036632538, -0.02872656285762787, 0.027613669633865356, 0.00035375668085180223, 0.015858732163906097, -0.03556622192263603, -0.011940419673919678, -0.038603492081165314, 0.013679315336048603, -0.040759723633527756, -0.030674125999212265, -0.002446047030389309, -0.02800781838595867, 0.033711399883031845, -0.03811660036444664, -0.002160578267648816, 0.012601200491189957, 0.0026619599666446447, 0.019707487896084785, -0.0021562310867011547, 0.023475097492337227, 0.008497405797243118, 0.010752174071967602, 0.007100492250174284, -0.011540473438799381, -0.03739785775542259, -0.009720428846776485, 0.01631084457039833, -0.02724270522594452, -0.009268316440284252, 0.021342050284147263, 0.01589350961148739, -0.01181869674474001, -0.022988205775618553, -0.0019533599261194468, -0.019475635141134262, -0.009140796959400177, 0.047297973185777664, -0.023625800386071205, 0.007946754805743694, -0.004561704117804766, -0.04611552506685257, -0.0024677834007889032, 0.028123745694756508, 0.00516741955652833, -0.009175575338304043, 0.026732629165053368, 0.0047964551486074924, 0.009505964815616608, 0.010021837428212166, -0.007680124137550592, -0.001825840910896659, -0.012137494049966335, -0.03551984950900078, 0.029885826632380486, -0.010531913489103317, -0.02559654973447323, 0.013424277305603027, 0.03382732346653938, -0.017841072753071785, 0.004332749173045158, 0.01245049573481083, -0.011714363470673561, -0.0441911444067955, 0.024553213268518448, 0.018953967839479446, -0.004839927423745394, -0.00029959730454720557, 0.022257870063185692, -0.003289411775767803, -0.0013375008711591363, -0.0007114983163774014, 0.02363739348948002, -0.012299791909754276, 0.037629712373018265, 0.008874165825545788, 0.03487066179513931, -0.04854997619986534, 0.00030539362342096865, 0.004813843872398138, 0.007210622541606426, 0.018281593918800354, -0.0018780077807605267, 0.017690369859337807, -0.005465929862111807, 0.01344746258109808, 0.013099683448672295, -0.00025413240655325353, -0.05369710922241211, -0.02376491203904152, 0.019962526857852936, 0.001901193056255579, -0.012972164899110794, -0.03834845498204231, 0.004097998607903719, 0.007071510422974825, -0.0307900533080101, 0.013899575918912888, 0.008798814378678799, 0.01383002009242773, -0.02257087081670761, 0.0015244322130456567, 0.014583542011678219, -0.00641652662307024, -0.0008267001830972731, -0.008103255182504654, 0.002527195494621992, 0.022524500265717506, -0.024506842717528343, -0.032320279628038406, 0.008549571968615055, 0.012879423797130585, -0.0028387478087097406, -0.010155153460800648, -0.013586574234068394, 0.012948979623615742, 0.002785131800919771, 0.0032633282244205475, -0.0014316911110654473, -0.009459594264626503, 0.0037415246479213238, 0.005494911689311266, 0.0399482399225235, 0.021631866693496704, -0.020275527611374855, -0.02749774232506752, -0.0017200580332428217, 0.011824493296444416, 0.012809867970645428, -0.01223023608326912, 0.031207388266921043, -0.01858300343155861, -0.02453002706170082, -0.004031340591609478, 0.011157916858792305, -0.008091663010418415, -0.026037070900201797, 0.04776167869567871, 0.00020993547514081, 0.02019437961280346, -0.019255375489592552, -0.003669070778414607, -0.00523987365886569, -0.039901867508888245, 0.014908135868608952, -0.01384161226451397 ]
12.79198
1.309129
2024-07-01
1
2024ApJ...969...66A
[ "CMB temperature maps", "simulated CMB maps", "CMB cleaning method", "CMB", "other galaxy surveys", "redshift cz", "a new CMB foreground signal", "smaller angular separations", "angular scales", "late-type spiral galaxies" ]
[ "Cosmic microwave background radiation", "Observational cosmology", "322", "1146", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
19
[ "10.3847/1538-4357/ad4d83", "10.48550/arXiv.2403.10490" ]
[ "Addison, Graeme E." ]
[ "The William H. Miller III Department of Physics and Astronomy, Johns Hopkins University , 3400 N. Charles St., Baltimore, MD 21218-2686, USA ; [email protected]" ]
[ "2024arXiv240611543J" ]
[ "1980MNRAS.190..413S", "2004MNRAS.355..747J", "2005ApJ...622..759G", "2006AJ....131.2332G", "2007CSE.....9...90H", "2011ApJS..192...17B", "2012ApJS..199...26H", "2012PhRvL.109d1101H", "2013A&A...558A..33A", "2013ApJS..208...20B", "2016CQGra..33r4001S", "2018AJ....156..123A", "2020A&A...641A...4P", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020A&A...641A...7P", "2020A&A...643A..42P", "2020NatMe..17..261V", "2020Natur.585..357H", "2022ApJ...934L...7R", "2022ApJ...935..167A", "2023A&A...675L...7H", "2023MNRAS.518.5643L", "2024A&A...681A...2L" ]
29163029
2404.15724
Galaxies' properties in the Fundamental Plane across time
Context. Using the Illustris-1 and IllustrisTNG-100 simulations, we investigate the properties of the Fundamental Plane (FP), which is the correlation between the effective radius R<SUB>e</SUB>, the effective surface intensity I<SUB>e</SUB>, and the central stellar velocity dispersion σ of galaxies, at different cosmic epochs. <BR /> Aims: Our aim is to study the properties of galaxies in the FP and its projections across time, adopting samples covering different intervals of mass. We would like to demonstrate that the position of a galaxy in the FP space strongly depends on its degree of evolution, which might be represented by the β and L^\prime<SUB>0</SUB> parameters entering the L = L^\prime<SUB>0</SUB> (t)σ<SUP>β(t)</SUP> law. <BR /> Methods: Starting from the comparison of the basic relations among the structural parameters of artificial and real galaxies at low redshift, we obtain the fit of the FP and its coefficients at different cosmic epochs for samples of different mass limits. Then, we analyze the dependence of the galaxy position in the FP space as a function of the β parameter and the star formation rate (SFR). <BR /> Results: We find that: (1) the coefficients of the FP change with the mass range of the galaxy sample; (2) the low luminous and less massive galaxies do not share the same FP of the bright massive galaxies; (3) the scatter around the fitted FP is quite small at any epoch and increases when the mass interval increases; (4) the distribution of galaxies in the FP space strongly depends on the β values (i.e., on the degree of virialization and the star formation rate). <BR /> Conclusions: The FP is a complex surface that is well approximated by a plane only when galaxies share similar masses and condition of virialization.
[ -0.014196648262441158, -0.0005090819904580712, 0.08540424704551697, -0.002495942870154977, 0.017212968319654465, 0.02522740699350834, -0.004284546244889498, -0.0013157451758161187, 0.00916737038642168, 0.07024785876274109, -0.024828555062413216, 0.023295465856790543, -0.027745163068175316, -0.02351982146501541, 0.03255631774663925, 0.027844876050949097, -0.01774892769753933, 0.006967450957745314, -0.008886927738785744, 0.006699472200125456, -0.0012915958650410175, -0.04803677275776863, -0.022398049011826515, 0.02791965939104557, -0.04968203976750374, -0.060775116086006165, 0.01868373714387417, 0.031334832310676575, 0.017574429512023926, -0.014396075159311295, -0.004639774095267057, -0.03948637470602989, -0.02263486757874489, -0.011061918921768665, -0.03160904347896576, 0.0683533102273941, -0.01639033667743206, 0.036420200020074844, -0.018185172230005264, -0.0032905314583331347, -0.03547292575240135, 0.02494073286652565, -0.053745344281196594, -0.006842809729278088, 0.020653070881962776, -0.008213864639401436, 0.009260851889848709, -0.0385391004383564, -0.0057864743284881115, 0.0009496111888438463, -0.034475795924663544, 0.0085005396977067, 0.0017870451556518674, -0.0020939745008945465, -0.024467095732688904, 0.03851417452096939, -0.05075395479798317, -0.023893745616078377, -0.008911855518817902, 0.022809365764260292, 0.006792953237891197, -0.0017480948008596897, 0.02772023342549801, -0.007621817756444216, -0.04240298271179199, 0.027221668511629105, -0.012937771156430244, 0.012183691374957561, 0.012327028438448906, 0.04703964293003082, 0.01673933118581772, 0.005490451119840145, -0.0003978785243816674, 0.02241051197052002, 0.03936173394322395, 0.014495788142085075, 0.006518742069602013, -0.01277573686093092, -0.03355344757437706, -0.0067306323908269405, 0.013099804520606995, 0.026972385123372078, 0.01003985945135355, 0.006487581878900528, -0.006799185182899237, -0.010769011452794075, 0.016440192237496376, 0.012327028438448906, -0.06830345094203949, 0.028966646641492844, 0.04504537954926491, 0.004755067173391581, -0.04088236019015312, 0.005795822478830814, 0.015380741097033024, -0.022647330537438393, 0.020902352407574654, -0.0453445203602314, 0.036843981593847275, 0.02160034328699112, 0.008943015709519386, 0.051451943814754486, -0.005602627992630005, -0.0586312860250473, 0.046366579830646515, 0.017499644309282303, -0.0184593815356493, -0.010825100354850292, -0.023395178839564323, -0.012002960778772831, 0.01169135794043541, 0.02565118856728077, 0.008082990534603596, 0.021288741379976273, -0.03158411383628845, -0.017574429512023926, -0.05563989281654358, -0.0010882746428251266, -0.00860025268048048, -0.016801653429865837, 0.0286675076931715, -0.011317433789372444, -0.008051830343902111, 0.007746459450572729, 0.028617652133107185, -0.07413666695356369, 0.015380741097033024, -0.021936876699328423, -0.03210761025547981, 0.020914817228913307, 0.027022242546081543, -0.027446022257208824, 0.01204658579081297, -0.013224446214735508, -0.029739422723650932, 0.00220303563401103, 0.017237897962331772, -0.0012534244451671839, 0.009273315779864788, 0.0238064955919981, -0.016888901591300964, 0.005671180784702301, 0.023170825093984604, 0.015542775392532349, 0.05768401175737381, 0.040309008210897446, -0.061622679233551025, 0.03831474855542183, 0.014146791771054268, 0.01963101141154766, 0.005858142860233784, -0.009105050005018711, -0.03519871458411217, -0.04512016475200653, -0.012034120969474316, -0.017873568460345268, -0.00019027279631700367, 0.01736253872513771, -0.016141053289175034, 0.002151621039956808, -0.05165136978030205, 0.0343262255191803, -0.008980408310890198, 0.01762428507208824, 0.011828463524580002, 0.0036114829126745462, -0.01584191434085369, -0.014956960454583168, -0.07697848975658417, -0.018795914947986603, -0.025052908807992935, -0.03961101919412613, -0.0430760458111763, -0.038040537387132645, 0.0346502922475338, 0.04836083948612213, -0.00952259823679924, -0.040433648973703384, -0.021450774744153023, -0.00946027785539627, -0.03494943305850029, 0.05008089169859886, -0.02749587967991829, -0.03258124738931656, -0.008949248120188713, 0.018309812992811203, -0.02202412486076355, 0.03280559927225113, 0.020054791122674942, -0.01574220135807991, 0.010532192885875702, 0.0352984257042408, 0.022236015647649765, 0.029913920909166336, -0.011971800588071346, -0.01920722983777523, 0.0189454834908247, 0.014745070599019527, -0.03340388089418411, 0.04347489774227142, 0.04848548024892807, 0.035572636872529984, 0.005992132239043713, -0.05464276298880577, -0.04698978364467621, -0.021076850593090057, 0.03906259685754776, 0.03106062114238739, -0.02092728018760681, 0.011479467153549194, 0.035996418446302414, 0.0069425227120518684, -0.0020254217088222504, -0.028493009507656097, -0.07229197770357132, -0.013149661011993885, -0.027869803830981255, 0.011367290280759335, 0.027545735239982605, 0.04285169392824173, -0.027346309274435043, 0.014321289956569672, 0.052648503333330154, 0.017923424020409584, 0.03018813207745552, -0.004278313834220171, 0.04148063808679581, -0.03976058587431908, -0.005764661822468042, 0.02555147372186184, 0.026025110855698586, 0.01843445375561714, -0.003234442789107561, -0.018085459247231483, -0.001498812111094594, -0.004913984797894955, -0.033029954880476, 0.005995248444378376, -0.019194766879081726, -0.009728256613016129, -0.022759508341550827, 0.058382004499435425, -0.027346309274435043, 0.003789096837863326, -0.0034930736292153597, 0.02909128926694393, -0.0061697461642324924, -0.0006531985127367079, 0.027421094477176666, -0.009379261173307896, 0.040109582245349884, -0.021076850593090057, -0.026224538683891296, -0.011616572737693787, -0.020004935562610626, 0.011884551495313644, -0.05042988434433937, 0.036519911140203476, -0.002768595702946186, 0.016602225601673126, -0.04536944627761841, -0.03385258838534355, -0.010320303030312061, -0.02781994640827179, -0.018908090889453888, 0.04980668053030968, 0.02196180447936058, -0.019456513226032257, -0.026374107226729393, -0.0168390441685915, 0.055241040885448456, 0.02069046162068844, 0.002290284726768732, -0.010407552123069763, -0.02684774436056614, 0.03385258838534355, -0.0270471703261137, 0.046491220593452454, 0.016801653429865837, -0.024055778980255127, 0.007746459450572729, -0.02040378749370575, 0.021301204338669777, -0.01819763518869877, -0.0031362876761704683, 0.022859221324324608, 0.019381728023290634, 0.0176492128521204, -0.014745070599019527, -0.026374107226729393, 0.07987017184495926, -0.03417665511369705, 0.021176563575863838, -0.010663066990673542, 0.013673154637217522, 0.009578687138855457, 0.041081786155700684, 0.00633177999407053, -0.033678088337183, 0.04025915265083313, 0.02639903500676155, -0.019282015040516853, 0.020154504105448723, -0.00749094458296895, -0.042801834642887115, 0.0109310457482934, 0.07259111851453781, 0.04773763194680214, -0.004512016661465168, 0.032730814069509506, -0.021824698895215988, 0.025152621790766716, 0.019444048404693604, -0.002855844795703888, -0.02575090155005455, 0.02714688330888748, -0.03906259685754776, 0.06361693888902664, 0.027745163068175316, -0.0020846263505518436, -0.05028031766414642, -0.0757819339632988, 0.00796458125114441, 0.01180353481322527, 0.018309812992811203, -0.057833582162857056, -0.018509238958358765, 0.0004966178094036877, -0.0012191480491310358, -0.0013282092986628413, -0.007896028459072113, -0.023233145475387573, 0.01716311275959015, 0.013336623087525368, -0.04803677275776863, -0.01738746650516987, 0.0006185326492413878, 0.09916464984416962, -0.00377663248218596, 0.0036706875544041395, 0.004524480551481247, -0.007328910753130913, 0.0010828216327354312, 0.0037174278404563665, 0.027944589033722878, 0.06441464275121689, 0.0006707262364216149, 0.02674803137779236, 0.029839137569069862, 0.008930551819503307, 0.008058062754571438, 0.026648318395018578, 0.03397722914814949, -0.008058062754571438, 0.0641155019402504, -0.06197167560458183, 0.048435624688863754, -0.06660833209753036, -0.04374910891056061, -0.002418041927739978, 0.002087742555886507, -0.06222095713019371, -0.007029771339148283, 0.01128627359867096, -0.05324678122997284, 0.016377871856093407, -0.008699965663254261, 0.031982969492673874, -0.01959361881017685, -0.06067540496587753, -0.0071918051689863205, 0.019543761387467384, -0.007777619641274214, 0.008625180460512638, -0.06466392427682877, -0.017350073903799057, 0.02520247921347618, -0.005696109030395746, -0.02202412486076355, -0.0005499799153767526, 0.020254217088222504, 0.022136302664875984, -0.018608951941132545, -0.023395178839564323, 0.031135406345129013, 0.020902352407574654, -0.0025520315393805504, -0.04888433218002319, -0.0780753344297409, 0.04068293422460556, 0.0018306697020307183, 0.017636749893426895, 0.01681411638855934, 0.020939745008945465, -0.0005410212907008827, -0.032531388103961945, 0.027969516813755035, 0.08660080283880234, 0.03180846944451332, 0.013984758406877518, -0.03031277470290661, -0.03856403008103371, -0.02192441187798977, -0.048011843115091324, -0.02082756720483303, -0.019319407641887665, 0.004091351758688688, 0.04447203129529953, 0.0450204536318779, 0.017985744401812553, 0.02141338214278221, -0.04252762347459793, 0.04212877154350281, -0.0194315854460001, 0.035871777683496475, 0.04958232492208481, 0.011361057870090008, 0.013448800891637802, -0.04417289048433304, 0.041405852884054184, -0.021911947056651115, 0.008157775737345219, 0.0168390441685915, -0.009728256613016129, -0.016440192237496376, 0.03843938931822777, 0.010301606729626656, 0.040633074939250946, -0.034799862653017044, -0.08071773499250412, 0.017886031419038773, 0.021101778373122215, 0.031758613884449005, 0.01878345012664795, -0.02639903500676155, -0.023108504712581635, 0.04424767568707466, -0.01959361881017685, -0.0023790914565324783, 0.010856260545551777, 0.04898404702544212, -0.00013749497884418815, -0.008780982345342636, -0.05658716708421707, 0.03345373645424843, -0.0009013126837089658, 0.04337518662214279, 0.04716428369283676, -0.019194766879081726, -0.0056306724436581135, 0.02189948409795761, 0.055141329765319824, 0.016689475625753403, 0.012750809080898762, -0.03876345604658127, 0.0017153763910755515, -0.031883254647254944, -0.02403085120022297, 0.05444333702325821, -0.03290531411767006, -0.017399931326508522, 0.0197556521743536, -0.004082004074007273, 0.00876228604465723, -0.013224446214735508, 0.010289142839610577, 0.01730021834373474, 0.005565235856920481, -0.028069229796528816, 0.0010516613256186247, 0.010139573365449905, -0.035871777683496475, 0.05314706638455391, -0.03063684143126011, 0.0013718337286263704, 0.02494073286652565, -0.03906259685754776, -0.014445931650698185, 0.026648318395018578, 0.012059049680829048, 0.06461407244205475, 0.02477869763970375, 0.008569092489778996, -0.004268965683877468, -0.012862985953688622, 0.08276184648275375, -0.018085459247231483, 0.00905519351363182, -0.025414370000362396, -0.0039480142295360565, -0.014707677997648716, -0.05713558942079544, -0.016141053289175034, -0.013049948029220104, 0.007702834904193878, -0.053944770246744156, -0.02791965939104557, 0.014396075159311295, 0.003156541846692562, 0.028393296524882317, 0.09278301149606705, 0.02160034328699112, 0.024467095732688904, 0.010289142839610577, 0.029839137569069862, 0.06950001418590546, -0.007459784392267466, -0.03322938084602356, -0.03602134808897972, 0.013635762967169285, -0.017437323927879333, 0.056637026369571686, 0.013548513874411583, -0.008288648910820484, 0.02548915334045887, 0.009186066687107086, -0.034475795924663544, 0.03637034446001053, 0.01884577050805092, -0.0476129911839962, 0.03514885902404785, -0.020715391263365746, 0.0010649044997990131, 0.024978123605251312, 0.015630023553967476, -0.009491438046097755, -0.027944589033722878, -0.12224822491407394, -0.0359465628862381, -0.02293400652706623, -0.004172368906438351, -0.020216824486851692, -0.007154413033276796, -0.021176563575863838, -0.0184593815356493, -0.014570572413504124, 0.0016078732442110777, -0.008855767548084259, -0.027894731611013412, -0.01612858846783638, 0.026797888800501823, -0.00841952208429575, 0.016502512618899345, 0.012975163757801056, -0.0076841386035084724, 0.040982071310281754, -0.014296361245214939, 0.017375003546476364, 0.03442593663930893, -0.001277573755942285, 0.037292689085006714, -0.014670285396277905, 0.019506368786096573, 0.02133859694004059, -0.005063554272055626, 0.019606083631515503, 0.010189429856836796, -0.03622077405452728, -0.00824502483010292, -0.014358682557940483, -0.009036497212946415, -0.00008199063449865207, 0.02575090155005455, 0.032730814069509506, 0.0032313268166035414, -0.006693239789456129, 0.005979668349027634, -0.03624569997191429, -0.029365500435233116, 0.01965593919157982, -0.02607496827840805, 0.01499435305595398, 0.03385258838534355, 0.004580569453537464, -0.0038483012467622757, -0.02163773588836193, -0.025439297780394554, 0.021874554455280304, 0.018957948312163353, -0.047014713287353516, -0.005194427911192179, 0.00498876953497529, -0.015081602148711681, -0.025190014392137527, 0.006923826411366463, 0.002450760453939438, 0.014607965014874935, 0.013037484139204025, 0.014171720482409, -0.00678672082722187, -0.00010516613110667095, -0.024018386378884315, -0.02986406534910202, 0.010987133719027042, -0.005153919570147991, 0.027446022257208824, 0.005125875119119883, 0.02565118856728077, -0.01337401568889618, 0.0036613394040614367, -0.013922438025474548, -0.020590748637914658, -0.02293400652706623, -0.005250516347587109, -0.00015979408635757864, 0.02409317158162594, -0.03410186991095543, -0.0005507589085027575, -0.03061191365122795, 0.004212877247482538, -0.006849041674286127, 0.012177458964288235, -0.023208217695355415, -0.008699965663254261, -0.009852898307144642, -0.03908752277493477, 0.00703600374981761, 0.0025457993615418673, -0.000317251164233312, 0.011223952285945415, -0.029913920909166336, 0.020241754129529, -0.02467898465692997, -0.0009737604414112866, 0.06645876169204712, -0.001984913367778063, 0.014196648262441158, -0.020715391263365746, 0.0004954493488185108, -0.02747095189988613, 0.02629932202398777, -0.023133432492613792, 0.019356800243258476, 0.013835188932716846, 0.012694720178842545, 0.0024678984191268682, 0.0034494490828365088, 0.03602134808897972, -0.018409525975584984, -0.02684774436056614, 0.05175108462572098, 0.02759559266269207, 0.031235119327902794, -0.0463167205452919, 0.003935550339519978, 0.02092728018760681, -0.011778607033193111, 0.03215746581554413, -0.04130614176392555, -0.027022242546081543, -0.014919568784534931, 0.011136704124510288, 0.019867829978466034, 0.023071112111210823, 0.016564834862947464, 0.010158268734812737, 0.000810947734862566, 0.018795914947986603, -0.0035117696970701218, 0.005066670477390289, 0.009385492652654648, 0.03041248768568039, 0.002651744522154331, -0.01969333179295063, 0.014483323320746422, 0.009154906496405602, -0.003234442789107561, 0.034899573773145676, 0.007135716732591391, 0.012333260849118233, 0.04861012101173401, 0.022983863949775696, -0.0009200088679790497, -0.0023339090403169394, -0.01746225170791149, -0.034376081079244614, -0.021288741379976273, -0.05379520356655121, -0.023532284423708916, 0.0586312860250473, -0.005203776061534882, 0.0005597175331786275, -0.011996729299426079, -0.011847158893942833, 0.0020223057363182306, 0.023183289915323257, -0.052748214453458786, 0.0015985252102836967, 0.012164995074272156, -0.015729736536741257, -0.02001739852130413, 0.03280559927225113, 0.04397346451878548, 0.020840032026171684, -0.022161230444908142, -0.006705704145133495, -0.008562860079109669, 0.019967542961239815, -0.017150647938251495, -0.04427260532975197, 0.0534462071955204, 0.002030095783993602, 0.006537438370287418, -0.02921593002974987, -0.020391322672367096, -0.015567703172564507, -0.01514392253011465, 0.004078887868672609, -0.010195661336183548, -0.033927373588085175, 0.01423404086381197, 0.04130614176392555, -0.006269459612667561, 0.0024694565217942, -0.008643876761198044, 0.0031534258741885424, 0.00006938043225090951, -0.011255113407969475, -0.015654951333999634, 0.011504395864903927, 0.009354332461953163, -0.021463239565491676, -0.023980993777513504, 0.012239779345691204, 0.03637034446001053, -0.048011843115091324, -0.0030786411371082067, 0.03569728136062622, -0.003234442789107561, -0.010407552123069763, 0.004371794871985912, 0.020316537469625473, 0.006998611148446798, -0.007403695490211248, 0.02769530564546585, -0.01801067404448986, 0.017773855477571487, -0.013860116712749004, 0.01567988097667694, 0.040483508259058, 0.006961219012737274, 0.010102180764079094, 0.00744108809158206, 0.009821737185120583, -0.03170875832438469, -0.006581062916666269, 0.011510627344250679, 0.004353098571300507, 0.018322277814149857, 0.0036924995947629213, 0.03298009932041168, 0.009597383439540863, 0.03193311020731926, 0.012202386744320393, 0.02587554231286049, -0.0033840122632682323, 0.007740227039903402, 0.02714688330888748, 0.0013126290868967772, 0.011099311523139477, 0.04459667205810547, 0.019344335421919823, 0.008207632228732109, -0.0056306724436581135, -0.004885940346866846, -0.0003976837615482509, -0.010594514198601246, 0.03514885902404785, 0.051800940185785294, -0.028168942779302597, -0.02649874798953533, 0.015268564224243164, 0.0009924566838890314, -0.01423404086381197, 0.007933421060442924, 0.03786603733897209, 0.00994014646857977, -0.0194315854460001, -0.027121955528855324, 0.019182302057743073, -0.004702094476670027, -0.03450072184205055, 0.004646006040275097, -0.023208217695355415, -0.013598370365798473, 0.006319316104054451, 0.0378909669816494, -0.015605095773935318, 0.004512016661465168, 0.004390491172671318, -0.0030194364953786135, -0.012152530252933502, -0.045095235109329224, 0.013585906475782394, -0.016851508989930153, 0.03507407382130623, 0.004879708401858807, -0.10499786585569382, 0.014034614898264408, 0.01693875715136528, 0.028617652133107185, 0.025090301409363747, 0.029888993129134178, 0.024080706760287285, 0.011361057870090008, 0.02921593002974987, 0.005858142860233784, 0.03861388564109802, -0.012912842445075512, 0.0010384181514382362, 0.02986406534910202, 0.02409317158162594, -0.02966463938355446, -0.028193870559334755, 0.012027889490127563, -0.010825100354850292, -0.012800665572285652, -0.012950235046446323, 0.012862985953688622, -0.003268719185143709, 0.023407643660902977, 0.009285779669880867, 0.018571559339761734, -0.025950327515602112, -0.01748717948794365, 0.025439297780394554, 0.015542775392532349, -0.003648875281214714, -0.004100699909031391, 0.0254268329590559, 0.011485699564218521, -0.005359577480703592, -0.004580569453537464, -0.037816181778907776, 0.013436336070299149, -0.017823711037635803, 0.04352475702762604, -0.01784864068031311, -0.045618731528520584, 0.030013633891940117, 0.03973565995693207, 0.08570338785648346, -0.024629129096865654, 0.002418041927739978, 0.057833582162857056, 0.03450072184205055, 0.03472507745027542, 0.012545150704681873, -0.029564926400780678, -0.002634606324136257, 0.004670934285968542, -0.010532192885875702, 0.012133833952248096, 0.0009644123492762446, -0.019705796614289284, -0.0068988981656730175, 0.015443062409758568, -0.009535062126815319, 0.014433466829359531, 0.02131366916000843, -0.02231079898774624, -0.06242038309574127, -0.0349743589758873, -0.044521886855363846, 0.0071481806226074696, -0.03819010779261589, -0.000003313828528916929, -0.008082990534603596, 0.01914490945637226, 0.01357344165444374, 0.0050448584370315075, -0.01564248837530613, 0.00744108809158206, 0.004636657889932394, -0.03061191365122795, -0.0434001162648201, 0.011504395864903927, 0.016801653429865837, -0.032930243760347366, -0.0008545721648260951, 0.0014427235582843423, 0.014421002939343452, 0.023270538076758385, 0.003623947035521269, -0.020416252315044403, 0.006711936090141535, 0.005590164102613926, 0.013461264781653881, -0.016041340306401253, 0.0365946963429451, 0.010145804844796658, 0.01687643676996231, -0.0008623622707091272, 0.03866374492645264, 0.007696602493524551, 0.0050448584370315075, -0.018484311178326607, -0.010582049377262592, 0.0016997962957248092, -0.007733995094895363, -0.030487271025776863, -0.0063722883351147175, -0.026349179446697235, -0.005842562764883041, 0.02358214184641838, -0.006792953237891197, 0.020029863342642784, 0.022036589682102203, -0.0044123032130301, -0.0052598644979298115, 0.035772062838077545, 0.013760403729975224, -0.004303242079913616, 0.0160288754850626, -0.006624686997383833, -0.003976058680564165, -0.00020059465896338224, -0.01738746650516987, -0.0019802392926067114, 0.00009114397835219279, 0.00012697836791630834, -0.004621077794581652, -0.05484218895435333, 0.0004888277617283165, 0.019232159480452538, -0.014607965014874935, 0.03604627400636673, -0.011753678321838379, -0.0016000831965357065, -0.006481349468231201, -0.020752783864736557, 0.009036497212946415, -0.01639033667743206, 0.003969826735556126, 0.01959361881017685, -0.006948754657059908, 0.024791162461042404, -0.004265849944204092, 0.02587554231286049, -0.015281028114259243, -0.004437231924384832, 0.001383518916554749, 0.02629932202398777, 0.011491931974887848, -0.0030396906659007072, 0.06710689514875412, 0.010314070619642735, 0.007509640883654356, 0.011280041188001633, -0.022236015647649765, 0.03701847791671753, 0.002167201368138194, -0.003334155771881342, 0.010363927111029625, -0.006549902260303497, -0.02451695129275322, 0.04070786014199257, 0.04347489774227142, 0.03741732984781265, -0.007272822316735983, -0.04000987112522125, 0.018671272322535515, 0.003331039799377322, -0.010850029066205025, -0.007235429715365171, -0.007017307449132204, -0.03597148880362511, -0.01713818497955799, -0.037940822541713715, 0.05314706638455391, 0.00790226086974144, -0.0022996326442807913, -0.005047974176704884, -0.0007630386971868575, 0.005291024688631296, 0.0021048805210739374, 0.018309812992811203, -0.0027483415324240923, 0.001138910185545683, 0.0015136132715269923, 0.01677672378718853, -0.0018057414563372731, 0.01738746650516987, -0.02471637725830078, 0.011722518131136894, 0.0036644553765654564, 0.016203373670578003, -0.01276327297091484, 0.022011660039424896, 0.010201893746852875, 0.06027655303478241, 0.02471637725830078, 0.05678659304976463, -0.03622077405452728, 0.027097027748823166, 0.006431492976844311, 0.007896028459072113, -0.04781241714954376, -0.019668404012918472, -0.005063554272055626, -0.028642579913139343, -0.0005982784205116332, 0.00035581208067014813, -0.00019397308642510325, -0.018446918576955795, 0.0004074213793501258, -0.035223644226789474, -0.00678672082722187, 0.008413290604948997, 0.027969516813755035, -0.00994014646857977, 0.02069046162068844, -0.05130237713456154, 0.011392218060791492, -0.011915711686015129, -0.042053986340761185, -0.029166072607040405, 0.025027981027960777, -0.05693616345524788, -0.0025286611635237932, 0.020229289308190346, -0.011554252356290817, 0.028393296524882317, 0.0035491620656102896, -0.023432571440935135, 0.008070526644587517, -0.0038420693017542362, -0.020391322672367096, -0.014844783581793308, 0.0041474406607449055, -0.022535154595971107, -0.014308826066553593, -0.011978032998740673, -0.0161909107118845, 0.004636657889932394, -0.015430597588419914, 0.008986640721559525, 0.028542866930365562, -0.0058768391609191895, 0.017237897962331772, 0.008780982345342636, 0.00024324536207132041, -0.017287753522396088, 0.011454539373517036, -0.0229963269084692, 0.01099336612969637, -0.020977137610316277, -0.0014333754079416394, 0.04168006405234337, -0.0456685870885849, -0.020316537469625473, 0.005157035309821367, 0.04103193059563637, -0.035323355346918106, 0.030337702482938766, 0.015505382791161537, -0.04504537954926491, -0.01250152662396431, -0.011012062430381775, -0.014657821506261826, -0.021587880328297615, 0.005580815952271223, -0.005855027120560408, -0.011897016316652298, -0.007048467639833689, -0.014047078788280487, -0.01904519647359848, 0.003094221232458949, -0.005883071105927229, 0.045294661074876785, -0.008943015709519386, -0.012744576670229435, 0.008226328529417515, 0.0022373120300471783, -0.018933018669486046, 0.013037484139204025, 0.04818634316325188, -0.03502421826124191, -0.027670377865433693, 0.005936043802648783, -0.014695214107632637, -0.022360656410455704, 0.027570664882659912, 0.003648875281214714, -0.010912349447607994, 0.021488167345523834, -0.0030708510894328356, -0.006954986602067947, 0.025601331144571304, 0.00008364602399524301, -0.0003826878673862666, 0.05563989281654358, -0.03377780318260193, 0.013997222296893597, -0.0008958596154116094, -0.0002929071488324553, -0.019830437377095222, -0.005272328853607178, -0.028542866930365562, 0.004197297152131796, 0.01179107092320919, -0.009204762987792492, -0.04402332007884979, -0.0025800757575780153, -0.029564926400780678, -0.03170875832438469, -0.009429117664694786, 0.02769530564546585, -0.028941718861460686, -0.014433466829359531, 0.021002065390348434, 0.017661677673459053, -0.005425014533102512, -0.0077963159419596195, -0.009323172271251678, 0.022049052640795708, -0.012862985953688622, -0.014670285396277905, -0.012682256288826466, 0.016514977440238, -0.0066184550523757935, -0.027545735239982605, -0.022759508341550827, 0.02062814123928547, -0.00946027785539627, 0.007335142698138952, 0.008924320340156555, -0.013560977764427662, 0.046391505748033524, 0.011329897679388523, -0.03410186991095543, -0.013112269341945648, 0.019618546590209007, 0.038788385689258575, 0.004029031377285719, 0.03502421826124191, 0.008201399818062782, -0.0039480142295360565, 0.016789188608527184, -0.03357837721705437, 0.024342453107237816, -0.0018571559339761734, 0.01271341647952795, -0.012414277531206608, -0.0080144377425313, -0.04865998029708862, 0.02312096767127514, 0.06167253479361534, -0.00014275328430812806, 0.017935888841748238, -0.01872112974524498, 0.01774892769753933, 0.007279054261744022, 0.013598370365798473, 0.009273315779864788, 0.012414277531206608, -0.02619960904121399, -0.0061572822742164135, 0.010095948353409767, 0.018608951941132545, 0.016215838491916656, 0.029689567163586617, -0.010968438349664211, -0.009273315779864788, -0.0031440777238458395, 0.010064788162708282, -0.0027078331913799047, -0.018808377906680107, 0.011236417107284069, -0.023943601176142693, -0.0017044703708961606, -0.013760403729975224, -0.009329404681921005, -0.00877474993467331, -0.032406747341156006, -0.012700952589511871, -0.0018493658863008022, -0.0015143923228606582, 0.02287168614566326, -0.01606626808643341, -0.005646252539008856, 0.009379261173307896, -0.01099336612969637, 0.004368679132312536, 0.016203373670578003, 0.03774139657616615, 0.01225847564637661, 0.004159904550760984, -0.011304969899356365, 0.029490141198039055, -0.04521987959742546, -0.02674803137779236, 0.001393646001815796, -0.017674142494797707, 0.052000366151332855, 0.027446022257208824, -0.021039457991719246, 0.005951623897999525, 0.021301204338669777, -0.029415355995297432, 0.003377780318260193, -0.008618948981165886, 0.024654056876897812, 0.03477493301033974, 0.04444710165262222, 0.008643876761198044, -0.013735475949943066, -0.015767129138112068, -0.007883564569056034, -0.039785515516996384, 0.0184593815356493, 0.008107919245958328, -0.014047078788280487, -0.006088729482144117, 0.018795914947986603, -0.019518833607435226, -0.002541125286370516, -0.019095053896307945, -0.0010524402605369687, -0.03831474855542183, -0.014732606709003448, -0.010582049377262592, -0.014059542678296566, -0.024753769859671593, 0.022111373022198677, -0.007677906658500433, -0.02944028377532959, -0.00511652696877718, -0.02439231052994728, -0.022460369393229485, 0.024865947663784027, -0.014570572413504124, -0.017873568460345268, 0.005210008006542921, 0.001577491988427937, -0.017798783257603645, 0.004839200060814619, -0.02674803137779236, 0.04482102394104004, 0.018808377906680107, -0.016153518110513687, -0.0018789682071655989, 0.007210501469671726, -0.017736462876200676, -0.008718661963939667, 0.01266355998814106, 0.024953195825219154, 0.0009651914006099105, 0.040982071310281754, 0.015630023553967476, -0.010289142839610577, 0.03579699248075485, -0.0019101285142824054, -0.009129977785050869, -0.019444048404693604, -0.013934901915490627, -0.009354332461953163, 0.023856353014707565, 0.019967542961239815, 0.027620520442724228, -0.0018275536131113768, 0.017125720158219337, 0.04050843417644501, 0.02609989605844021, 0.017026007175445557, 0.0013897509779781103, -0.005964088253676891, 0.030387558043003082, -0.008874463848769665, 0.02772023342549801, -0.03260617330670357, -0.018633879721164703, 0.003408940741792321, 0.0014528506435453892, 0.007740227039903402, -0.015779593959450722, 0.028966646641492844, -0.04397346451878548, -0.0017216084524989128, -0.011479467153549194, 0.026324251666665077, 0.0218620914965868, -0.006216486915946007, 0.010152037255465984, -0.014807390980422497, 0.018122849985957146, 0.0004927227855660021, -0.005094714928418398, -0.008837071247398853, 0.00881214253604412, -0.04327547177672386, 0.024180419743061066, 0.0008491191547363997, 0.024865947663784027, 0.004614845383912325, -0.014396075159311295, -0.014682750217616558, -0.020802639424800873, -0.03385258838534355, 0.004786227364093065, 0.006830345373600721, 0.009198530577123165, 0.003003856400027871, -0.026274394243955612, 0.005219356156885624, -0.011766142211854458, 0.04751328006386757, -0.010407552123069763, 0.02309603989124298, -0.007422391790896654, -0.00045610941015183926, 0.015056673437356949, -0.01499435305595398, 0.01224601175636053, -0.026797888800501823, -0.050604384392499924, -0.011697589419782162, -0.0005573804955929518, -0.03582192212343216, -0.0010734734823927283, -0.04240298271179199, -0.04521987959742546, -0.009659703820943832, 0.004963841289281845, -0.008008206263184547, -0.016053805127739906, 0.005088482517749071, -0.016539905220270157, -0.05115280672907829, 0.003608366707339883, -0.037392400205135345, -0.015243635512888432, -0.008693733252584934, 0.0009815505472943187, 0.03330416604876518, 0.02050350047647953, -0.051800940185785294, 0.01144830696284771, 0.007659210357815027, 0.02092728018760681, 0.0014528506435453892, 0.0005503694410435855, 0.04676543176174164, -0.007004843093454838, -0.021887019276618958, -0.0039791748858988285, -0.023469964042305946, -0.026448892429471016, -0.029240857809782028, 0.015555239282548428, -0.022460369393229485, -0.01114293560385704, 0.02315836027264595, 0.006116773933172226, -0.0010781475575640798, -0.0018291117157787085, 0.034126799553632736, -0.001780813094228506, -0.005580815952271223, -0.028842005878686905, 0.0019366148626431823, 0.00582075072452426, 0.037816181778907776, 0.015243635512888432, 0.016178445890545845, -0.0029789279215037823, 0.0067306323908269405, 0.04851040989160538, -0.0009137768065556884, -0.011666429229080677, -0.03138468787074089, 0.012582543306052685, -0.0005406318232417107, 0.021974267438054085, 0.016951221972703934, 0.026423964649438858, -0.011099311523139477, -0.03430129587650299, -0.02484101988375187, -0.027421094477176666, 0.006256995256990194, 0.026374107226729393, 0.020877424627542496, -0.01250152662396431, 0.023195752874016762, -0.05868114158511162, 0.0515018031001091, -0.026972385123372078, -0.03223225101828575, 0.021824698895215988, -0.011622805148363113, 0.012277171947062016, 0.008949248120188713, 0.024105634540319443, 0.00860025268048048, -0.020166968926787376, -0.001208242028951645, -0.003870113519951701, -0.00861271657049656, 0.0056306724436581135, 0.02425520494580269, 0.006456421222537756, -0.012545150704681873, 0.03614598885178566, -0.010887420736253262, -0.03711819276213646, 0.016377871856093407, 0.0011591644724830985, 0.016215838491916656, 0.017312681302428246, -0.005390738137066364, 0.007790083531290293, -0.004885940346866846, -0.033802732825279236, -0.024317525327205658, -0.04265226796269417, 0.01606626808643341, 0.01272588036954403, -0.003262487007305026, 0.0035927866119891405, 0.019182302057743073, -0.005942275747656822, -0.015330884605646133, -0.01357344165444374, -0.025950327515602112, 0.046042509377002716, -0.01687643676996231, 0.03158411383628845, 0.003183028195053339, 0.0055060312151908875, 0.022946471348404884, -0.020154504105448723, 0.025800757110118866, -0.01022059004753828, 0.0234824288636446, -0.02192441187798977, -0.01499435305595398, 0.04708949849009514, 0.016539905220270157, -0.0047986917197704315, 0.006085613276809454, -0.003474377328529954, -0.020777711644768715, -0.004963841289281845, -0.009192299097776413, 0.00417860085144639, -0.025302192196249962, 0.005347113590687513, 0.016253231093287468, -0.01574220135807991, 0.017723998054862022, 0.038364604115486145, 0.023332858458161354, -0.0019116865005344152, -0.01003985945135355, 0.004867244511842728, -0.00506043853238225, 0.0434001162648201, -0.014470859430730343, 0.0178112480789423, 0.042602408677339554, 0.0003906727069988847, 0.008344737812876701, -0.035871777683496475, 0.03116033412516117, 0.007279054261744022, 0.03647005558013916, -0.02684774436056614, 0.016851508989930153, 0.015193779021501541, -0.016751796007156372, 0.014109400101006031, 0.015879306942224503, 0.014657821506261826, 0.020241754129529, 0.020428715273737907, 0.011199024505913258, 0.016265694051980972, -0.02309603989124298, 0.0026829049456864595, 0.02545176073908806, -0.009416652843356133, 0.0210519228130579, -0.004873476456850767, 0.028318513184785843, -0.03128497675061226, -0.018160242587327957, 0.007665442302823067, -0.03709326311945915, 0.00246634054929018, -0.03941159322857857, -0.05023045837879181, 0.012900378555059433, 0.015031745657324791, -0.025676116347312927, -0.011710054241120815, -0.009734489023685455, 0.00947274174541235, 0.023794032633304596, -0.03145947307348251, 0.01007102057337761, 0.027246596291661263, -0.018995340913534164, 0.008338505402207375, 0.0035585102159529924, -0.011454539373517036, -0.00024636139278300107, -0.048435624688863754, 0.02739616669714451, -0.023781567811965942, 0.01752457208931446, 0.007696602493524551, -0.02098960243165493, 0.00911751389503479, -0.024055778980255127, -0.02911621704697609, -0.002805988071486354, 0.02360706962645054, 0.0024554342962801456, 0.005714805331081152, 0.0007961465744301677, -0.026548605412244797, -0.033603306859731674, 0.0038140250835567713, 0.028866933658719063, 0.024666521698236465, -0.011404682882130146, 0.011847158893942833, -0.010357695631682873, -0.01584191434085369, -0.018858235329389572, 0.006085613276809454, -0.0018306697020307183, 0.0009831085335463285, 0.014358682557940483, -0.005054206121712923 ]
11.610792
5.973151
2024-07-01
0
2024A&A...687A.126D
[ "galaxies", "FP", "different cosmic epochs", "different mass limits", "different intervals", "the bright massive galaxies", "low redshift", "artificial and real galaxies", "the FP space", "the galaxy sample" ]
[ "galaxies: evolution", "galaxies: fundamental parameters", "galaxies: kinematics and dynamics", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
8
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202449538", "10.48550/arXiv.2404.15724" ]
[ "D'Onofrio, M.", "Chiosi, C." ]
[ "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Padova, Vicolo Osservatorio 3, 35122, Padova, Italy", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Padova, Vicolo Osservatorio 3, 35122, Padova, Italy" ]
null
[ "1976ApJ...204..668F", "1987ApJ...313...42D", "1987ApJ...313...59D", "1987ApJ...317....1D", "1987nngp.proc..175F", "1990ApJ...354...13D", "1991A&A...249...99C", "1991MNRAS.249..755L", "1992ApJ...384...43G", "1992ApJ...384..423B", "1992ApJ...389L..49D", "1992MNRAS.259..323C", "1993ApJ...412L..51C", "1993ApJ...416L..49R", "1993MNRAS.265..731G", "1996A&A...309..749P", "1996ApJ...456L..79P", "1996MNRAS.280..167J", "1996MNRAS.281..985V", "1996MNRAS.282....1C", "1997A&A...321..111P", "1997ASPC..116..292H", "1998A&A...339..355C", "1998ApJ...508L..43F", "1998MmSAI..69..217B", "2002MNRAS.335..335C", "2003MNRAS.341.1109B", "2003MNRAS.342..501N", "2004ApJ...600L..39T", "2005A&A...442..125D", "2005MNRAS.360..693R", "2006A&A...445..805F", "2006ApJ...641...21R", "2006MNRAS.366.1126C", "2007A&A...470..137F", "2007ApJ...655...30V", "2007ApJ...665L.105B", "2008ApJ...684..248B", "2008ApJ...685..875D", "2008ApJ...688..770F", "2008PhDT.........6N", "2009A&A...495..707C", "2009A&A...497..667V", "2009A&A...501..851V", "2009ApJ...702.1275A", "2009MNRAS.396.1132T", "2009MNRAS.396.1171H", "2010ApJ...724..511A", "2010ApJ...724..714H", "2010MNRAS.408.1361L", "2011RMxAC..40...64I", "2012MNRAS.420..926F", "2012MNRAS.427..245M", "2013ApJ...771...85V", "2013ApJ...779L..21B", "2013MNRAS.432.1709C", "2014A&A...564A.138M", "2014A&A...572A..87D", "2014MNRAS.444.1518V", "2014MNRAS.445..175G", "2014Natur.509..177V", "2015A&A...581A..41G", "2015A&C....13...12N", "2015ApJ...803...78T", "2015MNRAS.454.1886S", "2016ASSP...42..183B", "2016ApJ...821..101Z", "2016JAsGe...5..277S", "2017A&A...599A..81M", "2017A&A...607A..81B", "2017ApJ...838..163D", "2017ApJ...846..120B", "2017MNRAS.467.2879B", "2017MNRAS.470.3497O", "2018A&A...609A.133C", "2018MNRAS.473.4077P", "2018MNRAS.475..624N", "2018MNRAS.475..648P", "2018MNRAS.475..676S", "2019ApJ...875..103D", "2019MNRAS.483.4140R", "2019MNRAS.489.1859H", "2020A&A...641A..94D", "2020ApJ...888....4S", "2020MNRAS.492.5930L", "2020MNRAS.494.5148B", "2021ApJ...913..103D", "2021MNRAS.504.5098D", "2021Univ....8....8D", "2022A&A...661A.150D", "2022ApJS..262...36S", "2023A&A...674A.156D", "2023A&A...675A.186D", "2023A&A...678A..12C", "2023MNRAS.518.5376D", "2023MNRAS.519.1526P" ]
29059592
2308.13974
Measuring the dust attenuation law of galaxies using photometric data
Fitting model spectral energy distributions (SEDs) to galaxy photometric data is a widely used method to recover galaxy parameters from galaxy surveys. However, the parameter space used to describe galaxies is wide and interdependent, and distinctions between real and spurious correlations that are found between these parameters can be difficult to discern. In this work, we use the SED fitting code BAGPIPES (Bayesian Analysis of Galaxies for Physical Inference and Parameter EStimation) to investigate degeneracies between galaxy parameters and the effect of the choice of different sets of photometric bands. In particular, we focus on optical to infrared wavelength coverage, and on two parameters describing the galaxies' dust attenuation law: A<SUB>V</SUB> and δ, which characterize dust column density and the slope of a flexible dust attenuation law, respectively. We demonstrate that (1) a degeneracy between the residual (the difference between truth and recovered values) A<SUB>V</SUB> and star formation rate exists, but this is lifted when Wide-Field Infrared Survey Explorer bands are included, and (2) BAGPIPES is able to accurately recover the input A<SUB>V</SUB> and δ distributions and relations (differences in slope of less than 1.7σ for a flat relation and less than 1.2σ for an observationally motivated relation) and is not introducing spurious correlations between these parameters. Our findings suggest that the information needed to constrain A<SUB>V</SUB> and δ well enough individually exists in the data, especially when infrared is added. This indicates that recent works finding a correlation between A<SUB>V</SUB> and δ are not being misled by fitting degeneracies from their SED fitting code.
[ 0.01962033472955227, -0.0065326509065926075, 0.023214412853121758, -0.0014876729110255837, -0.0008697410812601447, 0.04947292059659958, -0.011894987896084785, 0.006766073871403933, 0.0017027100548148155, 0.030057229101657867, 0.003208769019693136, -0.024327170103788376, -0.026706166565418243, -0.01694716140627861, 0.021052850410342216, 0.034610580652952194, 0.022600477561354637, 0.030901389196515083, -0.05146820843219757, 0.006315215490758419, 0.015642549842596054, 0.022830704227089882, -0.02036217413842678, 0.009784587658941746, -0.04775901883840561, -0.0463520847260952, 0.02724336087703705, 0.04105689376592636, 0.07295592874288559, -0.054537881165742874, -0.036784932017326355, -0.021743526682257652, -0.03775699436664581, -0.044407956302165985, -0.03808954358100891, 0.07704883068799973, -0.02520970068871975, 0.031643226742744446, -0.031975775957107544, -0.010564795695245266, -0.019211046397686005, 0.011229892261326313, -0.003357456298545003, 0.002198334550485015, -0.012560084462165833, -0.030926968902349472, -0.010839787311851978, -0.0017506736330688, 0.03345945104956627, -0.015425113961100578, -0.03939415514469147, -0.01322518102824688, 0.027320101857185364, -0.028701456263661385, 0.04850085452198982, 0.031361840665340424, 0.007405589334666729, 0.007181758992373943, -0.023419057950377464, -0.018328513950109482, -0.019044771790504456, -0.006539045833051205, 0.004860317800194025, 0.026322457939386368, -0.06170045584440231, -0.0001310007501160726, 0.016115790233016014, 0.019850561395287514, -0.01423561479896307, 0.0568912997841835, 0.008435209281742573, 0.01541232317686081, -0.0007046661339700222, 0.0025005056522786617, 0.008115451782941818, 0.007066646125167608, 0.031796712428331375, -0.020579608157277107, -0.022357461974024773, -0.005838776472955942, 0.008243354968726635, 0.01956917531788349, -0.010449683293700218, -0.0022111248690634966, -0.0553564615547657, -0.020784253254532814, 0.011370585300028324, -0.03645238280296326, -0.06420736014842987, 0.02055402845144272, 0.004313532263040543, -0.014248405583202839, -0.01507977582514286, 0.005806800909340382, -0.009113095700740814, -0.03576170653104782, 0.02972467988729477, -0.07704883068799973, 0.018264561891555786, -0.0162053219974041, 0.014478631317615509, 0.06083071604371071, 0.021359818056225777, -0.041005734354257584, 0.06221206858754158, -0.0037507584784179926, 0.002220717491582036, 0.015578597784042358, 0.02256210707128048, 0.02472366951406002, 0.054537881165742874, -0.025286443531513214, -0.018111079931259155, -0.0013501771027222276, -0.01679367758333683, -0.026936393231153488, -0.08226727694272995, 0.049856629222631454, 0.008217774331569672, -0.005525413900613785, -0.05259375646710396, -0.017688998952507973, 0.04184989631175995, 0.00672130798920989, 0.04476608335971832, 0.016307644546031952, -0.050342660397291183, -0.08267656713724136, -0.007117807399481535, 0.002273477613925934, 0.038984864950180054, -0.014862339943647385, 0.060114458203315735, 0.00831370148807764, -0.040852248668670654, -0.01930057816207409, -0.011524069122970104, 0.006657356396317482, 0.015105356462299824, 0.0028234608471393585, -0.005074555519968271, 0.03131067752838135, 0.006286437623202801, 0.014951872639358044, 0.010692698881030083, -0.02939213253557682, -0.01500303391367197, 0.031643226742744446, 0.011076408438384533, 0.0460195355117321, -0.007226525340229273, -0.0009616714087314904, -0.016755307093262672, -0.05709594488143921, -0.014094921760261059, -0.032129257917404175, 0.005525413900613785, -0.011402561329305172, 0.009324136190116405, -0.01601346768438816, -0.02552945911884308, 0.023866718634963036, -0.03780815750360489, 0.009618313051760197, -0.06952812522649765, 0.0056533170863986015, -0.034278031438589096, -0.0029593580402433872, -0.05474252626299858, -0.011466513387858868, -0.04215686023235321, 0.01991451345384121, 0.007827669382095337, -0.058886587619781494, 0.02425042726099491, 0.001932935556396842, 0.01974823884665966, -0.011396165937185287, -0.00638236477971077, -0.06420736014842987, -0.0494217574596405, 0.02427600882947445, 0.027754973620176315, 0.02473646029829979, -0.01977381855249405, -0.013052511028945446, -0.012304278090596199, 0.011888593435287476, 0.04558466374874115, -0.024212056770920753, -0.001422122586518526, 0.018609901890158653, 0.06113768368959427, 0.06957928836345673, -0.0731605738401413, -0.024838782846927643, -0.017190176993608475, 0.02969910018146038, -0.039880186319351196, 0.020809834823012352, 0.03046651929616928, 0.003920230083167553, 0.03450825810432434, -0.042080119252204895, -0.038677897304296494, -0.015540226362645626, 0.013007745146751404, -0.03315248340368271, 0.003792326897382736, -0.015911145135760307, 0.014529792591929436, -0.018597111105918884, -0.027294522151350975, 0.03545473888516426, 0.024327170103788376, 0.0035301255993545055, -0.01679367758333683, 0.015527436509728432, 0.04553350433707237, 0.014222824946045876, -0.05770988017320633, 0.009682265110313892, 0.04049412161111832, 0.01679367758333683, 0.0164739191532135, -0.026527103036642075, 0.04402424767613411, -0.03177113085985184, 0.00014199242286849767, -0.03271761164069176, 0.006334401201456785, 0.02568294294178486, -0.03808954358100891, 0.06717471033334732, 0.005349547136574984, -0.003434198210015893, -0.017382031306624413, 0.016550661996006966, -0.02905958518385887, -0.03128509968519211, -0.023546960204839706, 0.05054730549454689, -0.021705156192183495, -0.006024235859513283, -0.034891966730356216, 0.03453383594751358, -0.00039090384962037206, -0.004805958829820156, 0.0043167294934391975, 0.030722325667738914, 0.02098889835178852, -0.010884554125368595, -0.04484282806515694, -0.03698957711458206, -0.024493442848324776, -0.025401555001735687, -0.053156528621912, -0.001458894694224, -0.01616695150732994, 0.023521380499005318, -0.04095457121729851, 0.03588961064815521, -0.036938413977622986, 0.019671496003866196, -0.034764062613248825, 0.011504883877933025, -0.008077080361545086, -0.03778257593512535, -0.03504544869065285, -0.025695733726024628, 0.05085427314043045, 0.003450186224654317, 0.0256445724517107, -0.045507922768592834, -0.01492629200220108, 0.01251531857997179, -0.003215164178982377, 0.07331405580043793, 0.004514979664236307, -0.01786806248128414, -0.022127237170934677, -0.02706429548561573, 0.03637564182281494, 0.026245716959238052, -0.010046788491308689, 0.014939081855118275, -0.02457018569111824, -0.02395625039935112, -0.03276877477765083, -0.022024914622306824, 0.0426173135638237, -0.009560756385326385, 0.034150127321481705, -0.0012958182487636805, -0.022485364228487015, -0.010532820597290993, 0.034636158496141434, -0.00629603024572134, -0.0018066313350573182, 0.015578597784042358, 0.01881454698741436, 0.02100168913602829, -0.008166613057255745, 0.015386742539703846, -0.02936655282974243, -0.005387918092310429, 0.03970112279057503, 0.017228547483682632, -0.033229224383831024, 0.013979809358716011, 0.00972063560038805, 0.02377718687057495, -0.008748572319746017, 0.038805801421403885, -0.023431848734617233, -0.029673518612980843, -0.0001748675131238997, -0.005407103803008795, 0.02054123766720295, -0.059960972517728806, -0.04266847297549248, -0.019019190222024918, -0.01359609980136156, -0.014913501217961311, -0.002852239180356264, -0.046249762177467346, -0.02098889835178852, -0.021129591390490532, 0.007898016832768917, 0.03379200026392937, 0.019991254433989525, 0.008435209281742573, 0.006759678944945335, 0.04087783023715019, -0.04182431474328041, -0.03596635162830353, -0.01727970875799656, 0.05750523507595062, -0.006817235145717859, -0.0076230247505009174, -0.01884012669324875, -0.008806128054857254, 0.007085831835865974, -0.004885898437350988, 0.008627064526081085, 0.017663417384028435, -0.03205251693725586, 0.054230913519859314, 0.04054528474807739, 0.035071030259132385, 0.012042077258229256, 0.028241004794836044, 0.01081420760601759, -0.019377319142222404, 0.01805991865694523, -0.03624773770570755, -0.002153568435460329, -0.06384922564029694, -0.031208356842398643, -0.03095255047082901, 0.03018513135612011, -0.015437903814017773, 0.04404982924461365, -0.00325033743865788, -0.033843159675598145, 0.02893168106675148, 0.007904411293566227, 0.004569338168948889, -0.04277079552412033, -0.05832381546497345, -0.00330629525706172, 0.03913835063576698, -0.06272368133068085, -0.009688659571111202, -0.05205656215548515, -0.005937901325523853, -0.004844329785555601, 0.006996299605816603, -0.002206328557804227, 0.029622357338666916, 0.020131947472691536, 0.02703871577978134, 0.009759007021784782, -0.028675874695181847, 0.04090341180562973, 0.002928981091827154, 0.0006295230705291033, 0.0027643057983368635, -0.0749000534415245, 0.010014812462031841, -0.005589365493506193, -0.006078594829887152, -0.0034565813839435577, 0.017995966598391533, 0.013583309017121792, -0.04202895984053612, 0.01531000155955553, 0.05407743155956268, 0.038319770246744156, 0.032615289092063904, -0.03443151339888573, -0.0147728081792593, -0.02831774577498436, -0.03113161399960518, -0.011850222013890743, 0.038012802600860596, 0.012847866863012314, 0.029954906553030014, 0.04341031238436699, 0.02034938335418701, 0.04949849843978882, -0.03358735516667366, 0.03901044651865959, -0.05300304666161537, 0.015297210775315762, -0.004016157239675522, 0.015425113961100578, 0.03486638516187668, 0.019824979826807976, 0.06124000623822212, 0.026834070682525635, -0.01742040179669857, -0.0033702466171234846, -0.036631446331739426, -0.003670819103717804, 0.001774655538611114, 0.007674186024814844, 0.013979809358716011, -0.04376843944191933, -0.03982902690768242, -0.018788965418934822, 0.05443555861711502, 0.034278031438589096, -0.01300134975463152, -0.03732212632894516, -0.04105689376592636, 0.048910144716501236, -0.04049412161111832, -0.026961972936987877, 0.021052850410342216, 0.021833058446645737, 0.013289132155478, -0.006906767375767231, -0.013301922008395195, 0.025849217548966408, -0.01959475502371788, 0.04801482334733009, 0.024339960888028145, 0.02798519842326641, -0.046889275312423706, -0.003517335280776024, -0.03982902690768242, -0.026501523330807686, 0.01585998386144638, 0.000555179372895509, -0.010884554125368595, -0.00661259051412344, -0.044561441987752914, 0.02459576539695263, -0.048935726284980774, 0.012182770296931267, -0.008985192514955997, -0.012163585051894188, 0.04277079552412033, -0.009458433836698532, 0.01822619140148163, 0.019709868356585503, 0.012726358138024807, -0.007188154384493828, 0.0092537896707654, -0.0035269279032945633, -0.04509863257408142, 0.01757388561964035, -0.03560822457075119, 0.013429825194180012, -0.0006994700524955988, 0.00070906279142946, -0.013903067447245121, 0.007354428060352802, -0.01126826275140047, 0.026936393231153488, -0.00039070399361662567, -0.0036580287851393223, 0.062314391136169434, 0.06323529034852982, 0.05893774703145027, -0.0036292504519224167, 0.0032103678677231073, -0.052798401564359665, -0.008908450603485107, -0.032922256737947464, -0.07633256912231445, 0.019940093159675598, -0.013110067695379257, 0.024045782163739204, 0.0035684965550899506, -0.0015276427147909999, -0.0071625737473368645, 0.021692365407943726, 0.03860115632414818, 0.10211783647537231, 0.003837093012407422, 0.032922256737947464, -0.004470213316380978, 0.03143858164548874, 0.052798401564359665, -0.041287120431661606, -0.023559750989079475, -0.053565818816423416, -0.031822290271520615, -0.020157529041171074, 0.048884566873311996, 0.002471727319061756, -0.010884554125368595, 0.031336259096860886, 0.003178392071276903, -0.034278031438589096, 0.0033702466171234846, -0.007437565363943577, -0.011172335594892502, -0.018251772969961166, -0.03640122339129448, -0.005592563189566135, 0.031975775957107544, 0.021206334233283997, -0.032589711248874664, -0.03565938398241997, -0.07495121657848358, -0.014632115140557289, -0.021423770114779472, 0.025107378140091896, -0.018788965418934822, 0.009880514815449715, 0.0018561937613412738, -0.0108206020668149, -0.036170996725559235, 0.001319000730291009, 0.004978628363460302, -0.0070154848508536816, 0.010673513635993004, -0.014721646904945374, -0.012975769117474556, -0.03642680123448372, 0.030850227922201157, 0.022293509915471077, 0.017778530716896057, -0.0009089114028029144, 0.023546960204839706, 0.019159885123372078, -0.011971729807555676, 0.04133828356862068, -0.014644904993474483, 0.007258500903844833, 0.027806134894490242, -0.03939415514469147, 0.00266677956096828, 0.024825992062687874, 0.007207339629530907, 0.005666107404977083, 0.005848369095474482, -0.010404917411506176, -0.002244699513539672, 0.009669474326074123, 0.03450825810432434, 0.00567250233143568, 0.00910030584782362, -0.0012086842907592654, -0.03348503261804581, -0.009484014473855495, 0.007686976343393326, -0.013039721176028252, 0.022920235991477966, -0.007955572567880154, -0.031515322625637054, -0.015066985040903091, 0.004873108118772507, 0.02004241570830345, 0.009970046579837799, -0.017458774149417877, -0.06835141777992249, -0.019057562574744225, 0.0012326660798862576, -0.0028250596951693296, -0.000058605601225281134, -0.035864029079675674, -0.027294522151350975, 0.03550590202212334, -0.02038775384426117, -0.01681925728917122, -0.018418045714497566, -0.016998322680592537, -0.01695995032787323, 0.00031556093017570674, -0.007610234431922436, 0.026373619213700294, 0.01913430355489254, 0.025951538234949112, 0.03875463828444481, -0.0016787281492725015, 0.027141038328409195, 0.031233936548233032, -0.02178189717233181, -0.013660050928592682, -0.00225269328802824, -0.009049144573509693, 0.0051161241717636585, 0.024148104712367058, 0.0011047630105167627, -0.017535515129566193, 0.011428141966462135, -0.004940257407724857, -0.039880186319351196, 0.012374624609947205, -0.027934037148952484, -0.029750261455774307, -0.002017671475186944, -0.015744872391223907, -0.02908516488969326, 0.018481997773051262, -0.0022510946728289127, -0.02582363598048687, -0.0023949856404215097, 0.019223835319280624, -0.00015398334653582424, 0.03003164753317833, 0.010858973488211632, 0.01835409551858902, -0.056226201355457306, -0.024480653926730156, -0.04282195866107941, -0.007827669382095337, 0.002259088447317481, 0.01662740297615528, -0.009445643983781338, -0.011677552945911884, -0.004364693537354469, -0.010596771724522114, -0.011402561329305172, -0.06313297152519226, -0.023278364911675453, 0.02364928275346756, 0.0043710884638130665, 0.0273456834256649, -0.07147224992513657, -0.009867724031209946, -0.024800410494208336, 0.00517048267647624, 0.022446993738412857, -0.039291832596063614, -0.025171330198645592, -0.03565938398241997, -0.010622352361679077, -0.00019175471970811486, 0.03422686830163002, 0.05494717136025429, 0.020131947472691536, -0.005816393531858921, -0.016294855624437332, -0.01805991865694523, -0.006132953800261021, 0.0007706161704845726, 0.025606200098991394, 0.020170319825410843, -0.05269607901573181, 0.0073736137710511684, -0.001865786500275135, -0.024365540593862534, 0.029801422730088234, -0.025388766080141068, 0.025938749313354492, 0.05898891016840935, -0.004182431381195784, 0.00637277215719223, 0.002494110492989421, -0.03752677142620087, -0.003405420109629631, 0.0033126904163509607, -0.024224847555160522, -0.05990981310606003, 0.028982842341065407, -0.025452716276049614, 0.012892632745206356, -0.01726691797375679, -0.03737328574061394, -0.019211046397686005, 0.010040393099188805, 0.012547294609248638, -0.007188154384493828, -0.01059037633240223, 0.005969877354800701, 0.005905925761908293, 0.021104011684656143, -0.0011375382309779525, -0.0069515337236225605, 0.008646249771118164, 0.0010599968954920769, 0.020630769431591034, 0.010929320007562637, 0.0013973413733765483, -0.019313368946313858, 0.012879841960966587, 0.018149450421333313, 0.029110746458172798, -0.00964389368891716, -0.05113565921783447, 0.0019569173455238342, -0.01678088679909706, 0.040366217494010925, 0.0013461800990626216, -0.03440593555569649, 0.02160283364355564, 0.03890812397003174, -0.03486638516187668, 0.009029959328472614, -0.02055402845144272, -0.01181824691593647, 0.008691015653312206, -0.0037955245934426785, -0.0011023648548871279, -0.006823630537837744, 0.002335830358788371, -0.01174789946526289, -0.060114458203315735, -0.007993943989276886, 0.012713568285107613, -0.03916392847895622, -0.030210712924599648, 0.007207339629530907, 0.018584320321679115, -0.003048890270292759, -0.004770785570144653, 0.015335582196712494, 0.0030297047924250364, -0.03062000311911106, 0.020438915118575096, 0.01143453735858202, 0.0024349552113562822, 0.009304950945079327, 0.01181824691593647, 0.029136326164007187, 0.013046116568148136, -0.0050809504464268684, -0.013065301813185215, 0.004051330499351025, -0.027294522151350975, -0.016461128368973732, 0.0057076760567724705, 0.006957928650081158, 0.026552684605121613, 0.007834064774215221, 0.012246721424162388, 0.010839787311851978, 0.0014005389530211687, -0.03512218967080116, 0.041901055723428726, -0.014299566857516766, 0.016102999448776245, -0.006657356396317482, 0.015041404403746128, -0.0092537896707654, 0.06108652055263519, -0.0023246388882398605, 0.03468732163310051, 0.02488994412124157, -0.009618313051760197, 0.01789364404976368, -0.0475543737411499, -0.0214749313890934, 0.023393476381897926, -0.012483342550694942, -0.009752611629664898, -0.00397139135748148, -0.0022926630917936563, 0.0040673185139894485, 0.023393476381897926, 0.02969910018146038, 0.018456418067216873, -0.024928314611315727, -0.0177401602268219, 0.04028947651386261, -0.032103680074214935, -0.01821340061724186, 0.012617641128599644, 0.005480648018419743, -0.026629425585269928, 0.038345348089933395, -0.013052511028945446, -0.010174691677093506, 0.0074503556825220585, -0.0033382708206772804, -0.03501986712217331, 0.07377450913190842, -0.04399866610765457, 0.01080141682177782, 0.021423770114779472, 0.009036353789269924, -0.01074386015534401, -0.11091756820678711, 0.020617980509996414, 0.042387086898088455, 0.06067723035812378, 0.03333154693245888, 0.021193543449044228, 0.049984533339738846, 0.053616978228092194, -0.022306300699710846, 0.00274352147243917, 0.0228434931486845, -0.020208690315485, -0.0026651809457689524, 0.04558466374874115, 0.02675732783973217, -0.03171996772289276, -0.029750261455774307, -0.001239860663190484, 0.008825314231216908, -0.004940257407724857, 0.00840962864458561, 0.04914037138223648, 0.01740761287510395, 0.0025772475637495518, -0.006545441225171089, 0.027089877054095268, -0.03171996772289276, 0.007514307275414467, 0.05238911136984825, -0.014862339943647385, 0.011249077506363392, -0.032615289092063904, -0.012310673482716084, 0.02335510589182377, 0.00206243759021163, 0.007629420142620802, -0.01089734397828579, 0.040033672004938126, 0.0025069008115679026, 0.035838447511196136, 0.0027323300018906593, -0.030773485079407692, 0.022331882268190384, 0.021986542269587517, 0.058272652328014374, 0.045661408454179764, -0.0031656017526984215, 0.0011950945481657982, -0.020285431295633316, 0.040212735533714294, -0.013493777252733707, 0.013787954114377499, -0.023521380499005318, 0.00505217257887125, 0.010692698881030083, -0.007105017080903053, 0.022114446386694908, 0.015143726952373981, -0.004748402629047632, -0.0273456834256649, -0.05597039684653282, 0.009880514815449715, 0.010526425205171108, -0.013314712792634964, -0.059500522911548615, 0.0074119847267866135, -0.022357461974024773, 0.0010256229434162378, -0.003897846909239888, -0.02627129666507244, -0.023713234812021255, 0.004994615912437439, 0.0005663709016516805, -0.00373157300055027, -0.014734436757862568, -0.011255472898483276, -0.009861328639090061, 0.0054039061069488525, -0.05673781409859657, 0.008230564184486866, -0.005253619980067015, -0.008786942809820175, 0.014657695777714252, -0.01956917531788349, -0.008537531830370426, 0.034457094967365265, 0.0014780801720917225, 0.016589032486081123, -0.013775164261460304, 0.0280107781291008, 0.015987887978553772, 0.006078594829887152, 0.04077550768852234, 0.01727970875799656, -0.0061521390452980995, 0.0024445480667054653, 0.01118512637913227, -0.022766752168536186, 0.023726025596261024, 0.013417035341262817, -0.026220135390758514, -0.003335073357447982, -0.05320768803358078, -0.027627069503068924, 0.003904242068529129, -0.05371930077672005, 0.013417035341262817, -0.008531136438250542, -0.0045821284875273705, 0.0376802533864975, 0.012860656715929508, -0.0048667131923139095, -0.0037507584784179926, -0.019044771790504456, -0.005304781254380941, -0.003980983980000019, -0.010046788491308689, -0.030210712924599648, -0.0028746221214532852, -0.0015931930392980576, 0.004511781968176365, -0.03379200026392937, -0.0441521517932415, -0.00099284783937037, 0.016077419742941856, -0.01928778737783432, -0.014120502397418022, -0.02051565796136856, -0.023866718634963036, 0.053105369210243225, -0.027089877054095268, -0.006823630537837744, 0.03297341987490654, -0.0031799909193068743, 0.008492765948176384, -0.0013174018822610378, 0.04399866610765457, 0.0419522188603878, 0.00839044339954853, 0.011530464515089989, -0.0033542588353157043, 0.0086206691339612, 0.011287448927760124, -0.009228209033608437, -0.017791321501135826, -0.001797038596123457, 0.002193538239225745, -0.022613268345594406, 0.029673518612980843, 0.02178189717233181, -0.03218042105436325, -0.0013429825194180012, -0.02133423648774624, 0.03655470535159111, 0.005186470691114664, 0.010155506432056427, 0.006465501617640257, 0.010986876673996449, 0.01837967522442341, 0.026629425585269928, 0.029468873515725136, 0.030517680570483208, 0.0013541741063818336, 0.016409967094659805, 0.009458433836698532, 0.009189837612211704, -0.008601483888924122, 0.009835748001933098, 0.01665298454463482, -0.0069899046793580055, -0.0203749630600214, -0.03949647769331932, -0.0014564965385943651, 0.01991451345384121, 0.016371596604585648, 0.020656351000070572, -0.004786773584783077, 0.003360653994604945, 0.03246180713176727, 0.0056149461306631565, 0.0005411899765022099, -0.008531136438250542, 0.00003052687316085212, -0.0001319000730291009, 0.05336117371916771, 0.005934704095125198, -0.004940257407724857, 0.020029624924063683, 0.040212735533714294, -0.005509425885975361, -0.024685299023985863, 0.023431848734617233, 0.02905958518385887, 0.036657027900218964, 0.03200135752558708, 0.02737126313149929, -0.012189165689051151, 0.037270963191986084, 0.02303534932434559, 0.032896678894758224, -0.02985258400440216, -0.023291153833270073, 0.022958606481552124, -0.0011439333902671933, -0.019492432475090027, -0.008275330998003483, 0.009170652367174625, -0.03128509968519211, -0.0036356456112116575, -0.050010111182928085, 0.00840962864458561, -0.005650119390338659, 0.04816830903291702, -0.00839044339954853, 0.035991933196783066, -0.05474252626299858, 0.02363649383187294, 0.0017714579589664936, -0.038626737892627716, -0.016051840037107468, 0.014248405583202839, -0.029980486258864403, 0.0020208689384162426, 0.03064558282494545, 0.005889937747269869, 0.040033672004938126, 0.001316602574661374, -0.012790310196578503, -0.04064760357141495, -0.0002661983307916671, 0.00470363674685359, -0.014171663671731949, -0.010014812462031841, -0.047656696289777756, -0.002115197479724884, 0.014337937347590923, -0.006702122278511524, -0.002972148358821869, -0.004636487457901239, -0.0056149461306631565, 0.046684630215168, -0.01632043533027172, 0.03729654476046562, -0.018878497183322906, 0.0017874458571895957, -0.022613268345594406, 0.0006539046298712492, -0.0023022557143121958, 0.04801482334733009, -0.005736453924328089, 0.0004920272622257471, 0.013020535930991173, -0.006970718968659639, 0.004767587874084711, 0.01945406198501587, 0.018443627282977104, -0.03829418867826462, 0.025938749313354492, 0.019326157867908478, -0.01584719493985176, -0.0009576744632795453, 0.005004209000617266, -0.03688725456595421, -0.030568841844797134, -0.008742176927626133, -0.00046204993850551546, -0.01408213097602129, 0.006235276348888874, 0.007431169971823692, -0.004476608708500862, 0.004326322581619024, -0.01600067876279354, 0.033050160855054855, -0.008748572319746017, -0.021845849230885506, 0.01881454698741436, -0.011939754709601402, 0.005905925761908293, 0.006328005809336901, -0.0005068160244263709, -0.0017474761698395014, -0.0370151586830616, 0.000012652913937927224, -0.007469540927559137, -0.0037827342748641968, 0.004588523879647255, -0.032308321446180344, -0.006893977057188749, 0.04126153886318207, 0.0027722998056560755, -0.01251531857997179, 0.003243942279368639, 0.007437565363943577, -0.05087985470890999, -0.00005795609104097821, -0.03440593555569649, 0.010468868538737297, 0.02737126313149929, 0.01960754580795765, 0.010385732166469097, -0.026053860783576965, -0.012943794019520283, 0.012246721424162388, 0.007469540927559137, 0.004732414614409208, -0.016729725524783134, -0.012835076078772545, 0.004742007236927748, -0.0039138346910476685, 0.00540070841088891, 0.02101447992026806, -0.011012457311153412, 0.020131947472691536, 0.033971063792705536, 0.002299058251082897, -0.0007138591608963907, -0.016601823270320892, 0.0248771533370018, 0.010558401234447956, -0.0045405603013932705, 0.004224000032991171, 0.018763385713100433, 0.00792999193072319, 0.012943794019520283, -0.019031981006264687, -0.03297341987490654, -0.006273647304624319, -0.00506176520138979, 0.014491421170532703, 0.02350858971476555, 0.03440593555569649, 0.04077550768852234, -0.0005435881903395057, -0.0358128696680069, -0.02052844688296318, -0.008966007269918919, -0.011223496869206429, 0.018098289147019386, 0.045354440808296204, 0.014504211954772472, -0.003977786283940077, 0.0030584828928112984, -0.01958196423947811, 0.0058643571101129055, -0.0015404329169541597, -0.014478631317615509, -0.0014716850128024817, -0.007111412473022938, -0.035684965550899506, 0.006030631251633167, 0.06098419800400734, -0.0062832399271428585, -0.006433526054024696, -0.01804712787270546, 0.00003889553408953361, -0.011165941134095192, 0.006817235145717859, -0.005848369095474482, 0.009240998886525631, 0.011159545741975307, 0.010596771724522114, 0.02409694343805313, -0.0019936896860599518, 0.01571929082274437, 0.005688490346074104, -0.01973544806241989, -0.022817913442850113, -0.004262370988726616, 0.010628747753798962, 0.02474924921989441, -0.018584320321679115, -0.005426289048045874, -0.03982902690768242, 0.00505217257887125, -0.012029286473989487, -0.024378331378102303, 0.010008418001234531, -0.03970112279057503, -0.016307644546031952, 0.0101874815300107, -0.005774824880063534, -0.002919388236477971, -0.012182770296931267, 0.015540226362645626, -0.012553689070045948, -0.01336587406694889, 0.016256483271718025, 0.025401555001735687, 0.027959618717432022, -0.0021951368544250727, 0.052644915878772736, 0.0005447872681543231, 0.004911479074507952, -0.018162241205573082, 0.02225513942539692, 0.004252777900546789, 0.017139015719294548, 0.02348301000893116, 0.019709868356585503, 0.009132280945777893, 0.0005459863459691405, 0.011850222013890743, -0.0001202089260914363, -0.020758673548698425, -0.0044862013310194016, -0.018558740615844727, 0.0035237304400652647, 0.0020816230680793524, 0.004847527481615543, -0.011530464515089989, -0.016768096014857292, -0.015476275235414505, -0.026578264310956, 0.01852036826312542, 0.028573552146553993, -0.025235282257199287, -0.007053855806589127, 0.0072393156588077545, 0.02783171460032463, -0.029673518612980843, -0.020272642374038696, 0.006957928650081158, 0.011613601818680763, -0.015105356462299824, -0.005893135443329811, -0.010245038196444511, -0.03409896790981293, 0.020477285608649254, -0.029034003615379333, -0.022677220404148102, 0.0004928266280330718, -0.02036217413842678, -0.024825992062687874, 0.014887920580804348, -0.020630769431591034, 0.0037827342748641968, 0.01708785444498062, 0.013813534751534462, -0.038677897304296494, 0.02222955971956253, -0.014887920580804348, -0.02083541452884674, -0.025618990883231163, 0.027601489797234535, 0.036477964371442795, 0.01081420760601759, -0.004224000032991171, 0.003144817426800728, 0.034584999084472656, 0.006443118676543236, -0.010085159912705421, 0.011159545741975307, -0.00043726872536353767, -0.025081798434257507, 0.01213160902261734, 0.012790310196578503, -0.006996299605816603, -0.04530327767133713, 0.01882733590900898, -0.0030872609931975603, 0.026808489114046097, 0.009279370307922363, -0.019530802965164185, -0.008358467370271683, -0.017049483954906464, 0.04179873317480087, 0.015348372049629688, -0.035531479865312576, 0.004297544248402119, 0.002623612293973565, -0.004016157239675522, 0.01958196423947811, 0.034329190850257874, -0.025439927354454994, 0.00030317032360471785, -0.004364693537354469, -0.03550590202212334, 0.0016627402510493994, 0.0084863705560565, 0.02082262560725212, -0.025542249903082848, 0.010635143145918846, 0.03980344533920288, 0.048321790993213654, 0.0033190855756402016, -0.020605189725756645, 0.039752282202243805, -0.03542915731668472, -0.005646921694278717, 0.003968193661421537, -0.0074503556825220585, -0.009272974915802479, -0.015604178421199322, -0.03742444887757301, -0.004281556233763695, -0.006574219558387995, -0.01507977582514286, 0.01926220767199993, -0.0019601150415837765, -0.010948505252599716, -0.026181764900684357, 0.0287781972438097, -0.01569371111690998, 0.004399866797029972, 0.012694383040070534, 0.009381692856550217, -0.026092233136296272, -0.012278697453439236, -0.012291488237679005, 0.0033862346317619085, -0.0008665435016155243, 0.034278031438589096, -0.03890812397003174, 0.03640122339129448, 0.013544938527047634, -0.02066914178431034, -0.03315248340368271, -0.012189165689051151, -0.025414345785975456, 0.0012998152524232864, -0.0066509610041975975, -0.03985460475087166, 0.03391990065574646, 0.00020084783318452537, -0.02175631746649742, -0.013928648084402084, 0.028343327343463898, -0.033203646540641785, -0.010609562508761883, -0.014683276414871216, 0.0006650961004197598, -0.006011445540934801, 0.00408010883256793, 0.0009648689883761108, -0.02303534932434559, 0.035377997905015945, -0.033996645361185074, -0.005464660003781319, 0.002016072627156973, -0.03611983731389046, 0.008435209281742573, -0.00661259051412344, 0.01852036826312542, 0.010903739370405674, 0.034610580652952194, 0.0544867217540741, 0.02239583246409893, -0.04957524314522743, -0.0026252111420035362, -0.016768096014857292, -0.04949849843978882, -0.009151467122137547, 0.025132959708571434, -0.038652315735816956, -0.005371930077672005, 0.00153563660569489, 0.013979809358716011, -0.021653994917869568, -0.005212051328271627, 0.0042016166262328625, 0.011146754957735538, -0.008588693104684353, -0.02098889835178852, 0.018469206988811493, -0.010545610450208187, 0.008358467370271683, -0.004674858413636684, 0.005905925761908293, -0.001766661531291902, 0.01461932435631752, 0.0634910985827446, -0.002163161290809512, 0.012943794019520283, 0.0005180075531825423, 0.0023837939370423555, 0.00800033938139677, 0.026936393231153488, 0.02304813824594021, 0.04885898530483246, 0.016832048073410988, -0.003101650159806013, -0.02161562442779541, 0.001977701671421528, -0.0059027280658483505, -0.039752282202243805, -0.0009201029315590858, -0.009663078933954239, 0.01926220767199993, -0.003622855292633176, 0.005096938461065292, 0.023521380499005318, -0.004844329785555601, 0.004543757531791925, -0.019505223259329796, 0.008959611877799034, 0.03333154693245888, 0.012476947158575058, 0.02118075266480446, -0.013864696025848389, -0.01080141682177782, -0.011223496869206429, 0.009790982119739056, 0.013839115388691425, -0.03698957711458206, 0.0006203300436027348, -0.02300976775586605, 0.03246180713176727, -0.022267930209636688, -0.03223158046603203, 0.02503063715994358, -0.018916867673397064, 0.014785598032176495, 0.039112769067287445, -0.010705489665269852, 0.02289465442299843, -0.0011847025016322732, -0.004476608708500862, -0.0005839575896970928, -0.02024706080555916, -0.04632650315761566, 0.030057229101657867, -0.018750594928860664, -0.03645238280296326, -0.009324136190116405, 0.036631446331739426, 0.007968363352119923, 0.006925953086465597, 0.0063248081132769585, -0.0017170991050079465, 0.009682265110313892, 0.06144465133547783, 0.001185501809231937, -0.0030968538485467434, -0.002502104500308633, 0.000944084778893739, 0.024365540593862534, -0.008633458986878395, -0.009157861582934856, -0.005950691644102335, 0.030875807628035545, 0.007949178107082844, -0.0026124208234250546, 0.005423091351985931, -0.008051499724388123, -0.002638001460582018, 0.0013525752583518624, -0.015246049501001835, 0.02239583246409893, 0.01881454698741436, -0.018456418067216873, -0.008601483888924122, -0.01112756971269846, -0.016102999448776245, 0.022805122658610344, 0.0018689840799197555, 0.018149450421333313, -0.014964662492275238, -0.018725013360381126, 0.001156723708845675, 0.0029321785550564528, 0.010577586479485035, 0.0317455492913723, -0.004991418682038784, 0.026629425585269928, 0.007591049186885357, 0.042233604937791824, -0.012739148922264576, 0.07208618521690369, -0.008121847175061703, 0.0008353671291843057, -0.006139348726719618, 0.008991587907075882, 0.04699159786105156, -0.005931506399065256, 0.051903076469898224, -0.008051499724388123, -0.005979469977319241, 0.00046644662506878376, 0.0344826765358448, 0.00373157300055027, 0.004885898437350988, -0.04057086259126663, 0.024378331378102303, 0.015553017146885395, -0.044100988656282425, -0.03913835063576698, -0.019479641690850258, 0.02408415451645851, -0.03271761164069176, -0.018712224438786507, -0.011799060739576817, -0.02936655282974243, 0.019338948652148247, -0.03750118985772133, -0.024288799613714218, -0.0009984435746446252, 0.009957256726920605, 0.01507977582514286, 0.003753955941647291, -0.016307644546031952, 0.02348301000893116, -0.005100136157125235, 0.0051960633136332035, -0.017023902386426926, -0.0029977289959788322, 0.008166613057255745, 0.0011655170237645507, -0.01251531857997179, 0.03402222320437431, 0.02348301000893116, -0.02503063715994358, -0.002299058251082897, -0.019863352179527283, 0.008722991682589054, 0.027575908228754997, 0.01977381855249405, -0.017676208168268204, -0.033536192029714584, -0.011063618585467339, -0.008448000065982342, 0.007188154384493828, 0.050163596868515015, -0.0009624708327464759, 0.0005240030004642904, -0.0022638849914073944, -0.027908457443118095, 0.0007326449267566204, 0.008607878349721432, 0.028368907049298286, -0.0014357123291119933, 0.024352749809622765, -0.029110746458172798, -0.0037571536377072334, -0.022459784522652626, 0.02270280010998249, 0.004415854346007109, -0.014453050680458546, 0.02739684469997883, -0.004281556233763695 ]
12.424497
7.399651
2024-07-01
1
2024MNRAS.531.3242M
[ "galaxy parameters", "galaxy surveys", "galaxies", "spurious correlations", "fitting degeneracies", "Fitting model spectral energy distributions", "A", "dust column density", "recovered values", "infrared wavelength coverage" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
21
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1373", "10.48550/arXiv.2308.13974" ]
[ "Meldorf, C.", "Palmese, A.", "Salim, S." ]
[ "Department of Astronomy and Astrophysics, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL 60637, USA", "McWilliams Center for Cosmology, Department of Physics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA; Department of Physics, University of California, Berkeley, 366 Physics North MC 7300, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA", "Department of Astronomy, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN 47405, USA" ]
[ "2023arXiv231108065W" ]
[ "1983A&A...128..212M", "1994ApJS...95..107W", "2001ApJ...549..215D", "2001ApJ...556..562C", "2002MNRAS.336.1188K", "2003MNRAS.344.1000B", "2004Msngr.117...27E", "2006ApJ...652...97V", "2007ApJ...657..810D", "2008MNRAS.384..449F", "2009A&A...507.1793N", "2009ApJ...696..348W", "2009MNRAS.398.1601F", "2010AJ....140.1868W", "2011ApJ...737..102S", "2013A&A...558A..67A", "2013ARA&A..51..393C", "2013ApJ...770...64G", "2013ApJ...775L..16K", "2013MNRAS.435...87M", "2014A&A...564A.125B", "2014A&A...568A..22B", "2014arXiv1404.0402S", "2015A&A...579A...2I", "2015AJ....150..150F", "2016A&A...585A..43C", "2016ApJ...827...20S", "2016MNRAS.463.1486P", "2017ApJ...837..170L", "2017ApJ...839...26D", "2017MNRAS.472.1372L", "2018ApJ...854...62L", "2018ApJ...859...11S", "2018MNRAS.480.4379C", "2019AJ....157..168D", "2019ApJ...873...44C", "2019ApJ...876....3L", "2019ApJ...876...62C", "2019MNRAS.486..743D", "2020ARA&A..58..529S", "2020ApJ...888..108B", "2020ApJ...904...33L", "2020MNRAS.493.4591P", "2021A&A...653A.149B", "2022A&A...662A..86P", "2022A&A...663A..50B", "2022ApJ...929...91Z", "2022ApJ...931...14L", "2022MNRAS.511..765Q", "2022MNRAS.517.4291D", "2023MNRAS.518.1985M" ]
29097336
2401.12293
Joint inference of multiplicative and additive systematics in galaxy density fluctuations and clustering measurements
Galaxy clustering measurements are a key probe of the matter density field in the Universe. With the era of precision cosmology upon us, surveys rely on precise measurements of the clustering signal for meaningful cosmological analysis. However, the presence of systematic contaminants can bias the observed galaxy number density, and thereby bias the galaxy two-point statistics. As the statistical uncertainties get smaller, correcting for these systematic contaminants becomes increasingly important for unbiased cosmological analysis. We present and validate a new method for understanding and mitigating both additive and multiplicative systematics in galaxy clustering measurements (two-point function) by joint inference of contaminants in the galaxy overdensity field (one-point function) using a maximum-likelihood estimator (MLE). We test this methodology with Kilo-Degree Survey-like mock galaxy catalogues and synthetic systematic template maps. We estimate the cosmological impact of such mitigation by quantifying uncertainties and possible biases in the inferred relationship between the observed and the true galaxy clustering signal. Our method robustly corrects the clustering signal to the sub-per cent level and reduces numerous additive and multiplicative systematics from $1.5 \sigma$ to less than $0.1\sigma$ for the scenarios we tested. In addition, we provide an empirical approach to identifying the functional form (additive, multiplicative, or other) by which specific systematics contaminate the galaxy number density. Even though this approach is tested and geared towards systematics contaminating the galaxy number density, the methods can be extended to systematics mitigation for other two-point correlation measurements.
[ 0.012886861339211464, 0.015582393854856491, 0.029589317739009857, 0.024567503482103348, -0.03948524594306946, 0.03111555427312851, 0.02508445456624031, -0.010763667523860931, -0.019902631640434265, 0.034561898559331894, 0.012813011184334755, 0.0026539918035268784, -0.04824880138039589, -0.02221660502254963, 0.006228034384548664, 0.013489971868693829, 0.008985108695924282, 0.0266353078186512, -0.022721247747540474, 0.019176436588168144, -0.0266353078186512, 0.016419362276792526, -0.0001431809359928593, 0.0105728879570961, -0.027053793892264366, -0.05814472958445549, 0.03537425026297569, -0.026881475001573563, 0.057849328964948654, -0.005338754504919052, 0.0134530458599329, -0.02562602236866951, -0.023595141246914864, -0.015237759798765182, -0.0252813883125782, 0.10092861950397491, -0.013920764438807964, 0.041774600744247437, -0.03786053881049156, -0.0186717938631773, -0.005797241348773241, 0.010425187647342682, -0.005375679582357407, 0.00970514863729477, -0.0013716138200834394, -0.02823539637029171, -0.03485729917883873, -0.04871651902794838, 0.0032186382450163364, -0.02670915797352791, -0.03704818710684776, 0.012517610564827919, -0.02535523846745491, -0.029293915256857872, 0.007588109001517296, -0.02729996107518673, -0.002310896059498191, 0.026142973452806473, 0.008695862255990505, -0.009957469999790192, 0.00789581798017025, -0.027447661384940147, 0.00830199383199215, -0.0042679267935454845, -0.01705939881503582, -0.011422165669500828, 0.005988020915538073, -0.02000109851360321, -0.026856858283281326, 0.03278949111700058, 0.03146018832921982, -0.015754710882902145, -0.02656145766377449, -0.008437386713922024, 0.008498928509652615, 0.010591350495815277, -0.006732677109539509, 0.015693169087171555, -0.023927466943860054, 0.024936754256486893, 0.03237100690603256, 0.0026986096054315567, 0.045664045959711075, 0.009040496312081814, -0.032494090497493744, 0.008117368444800377, 0.002183196833357215, -0.013773064129054546, -0.09078652411699295, 0.036506619304418564, -0.010326720774173737, -0.02349667437374592, -0.000740425253752619, 0.0103021040558815, -0.008055826649069786, -0.05346754938364029, 0.018561018630862236, -0.04952887445688248, 0.03037705272436142, -0.0189425777643919, 0.02535523846745491, 0.023041265085339546, 0.0051756687462329865, -0.06385581195354462, 0.04280850291252136, -0.03520193323493004, 0.0034924994688481092, -0.018302543088793755, -0.015299301594495773, -0.007600417360663414, 0.053369082510471344, 0.012000658549368382, -0.056372325867414474, 0.028407713398337364, -0.017342491075396538, -0.008154293522238731, -0.05720929428935051, 0.021428868174552917, -0.031607888638973236, -0.01900411956012249, -0.017711741849780083, -0.03306027501821518, 0.0892602875828743, 0.003827902488410473, 0.008326610550284386, -0.04076531529426575, 0.00006110912363510579, -0.04423627629876137, -0.06843452900648117, 0.001863179262727499, 0.020493432879447937, -0.028333863243460655, 0.02440749481320381, 0.06277267634868622, -0.03350337967276573, -0.012763777747750282, -0.008812791667878628, -0.0082342978566885, -0.011428319849073887, 0.002397054573521018, -0.008831254206597805, 0.007871201261878014, 0.02075190842151642, 0.0456148125231266, -0.00684345280751586, -0.026881475001573563, -0.019681081175804138, 0.015373151749372482, -0.006991153117269278, 0.03173097223043442, -0.016283970326185226, 0.0069849989376962185, -0.042783886194229126, -0.0118775749579072, 0.003812517039477825, -0.013785372488200665, -0.010671354830265045, 0.029933951795101166, -0.02737381123006344, -0.025379855185747147, -0.016763998195528984, 0.025995273143053055, 0.0034494202118366957, -0.0021508873905986547, -0.010142095386981964, 0.01693631522357464, -0.0018862574361264706, 0.011668332852423191, -0.03968217968940735, -0.04775646701455116, -0.009378976188600063, 0.00362173723988235, -0.03178020566701889, -0.07419484108686447, -0.0016293202061206102, 0.03677740320563316, -0.036703553050756454, -0.033675696700811386, -0.02862926386296749, 0.014560799114406109, -0.01613627001643181, 0.00384636502712965, 0.014523874036967754, -0.012252980843186378, -0.033749546855688095, 0.008418924175202847, 0.011397548951208591, 0.02944161556661129, -0.0026186052709817886, -0.009951315820217133, 0.010203637182712555, 0.009625144302845001, 0.03480806574225426, 0.03251870721578598, -0.012788394466042519, -0.022721247747540474, 0.00436639366671443, 0.0532706156373024, -0.03520193323493004, -0.011582174338400364, -0.0332079753279686, -0.005594153422862291, 0.02890004776418209, -0.02147810161113739, -0.017834825441241264, -0.019779548048973083, 0.010455958545207977, -0.019016427919268608, -0.02656145766377449, -0.013034561648964882, 0.006788065191358328, -0.005114126950502396, 0.021465793251991272, 0.050341226160526276, -0.023607449606060982, 0.017182482406497, -0.0813336968421936, 0.031066320836544037, 0.0034494202118366957, 0.036900486797094345, -0.013145336881279945, 0.027915379032492638, 0.04381779208779335, -0.00026866860571317375, 0.0015554700512439013, -0.04273465275764465, 0.06548051536083221, -0.058784764260053635, 0.0067080603912472725, -0.04576251283288002, 0.015114676207304, 0.024321334436535835, -0.010382108390331268, 0.030155502259731293, -0.03123863786458969, 0.019914939999580383, -0.012191439047455788, 0.023841308429837227, -0.01324380375444889, -0.03835287317633629, -0.04241463541984558, 0.024998296052217484, -0.019385680556297302, -0.010954448021948338, -0.029023131355643272, 0.024124400690197945, -0.02440749481320381, 0.025724489241838455, 0.024985987693071365, 0.01298532821238041, 0.009366667829453945, -0.016087036579847336, 0.009662069380283356, -0.03283872455358505, -0.02135501801967621, -0.013083795085549355, 0.008418924175202847, 0.020911917090415955, 0.009126654826104641, 0.028186162933707237, -0.02161349356174469, -0.020087257027626038, -0.06021253764629364, -0.022672014310956, -0.023915158584713936, 0.023595141246914864, 0.014905434101819992, -0.005563382524996996, -0.04042068123817444, 0.0019939555786550045, -0.01625935360789299, -0.0006350348703563213, 0.007089619990438223, -0.05548612400889397, -0.05031660944223404, 0.021231934428215027, -0.03507884964346886, 0.06799142807722092, 0.019151819869875908, -0.02803846262395382, -0.04115918278694153, -0.018622560426592827, 0.04618099704384804, 0.012486839666962624, 0.022708939388394356, 0.018548710271716118, 0.004606406670063734, 0.015213143080472946, 0.011508324183523655, -0.02702917717397213, 0.0362604521214962, -0.02629067376255989, -0.03827902302145958, 0.0278907623142004, -0.065874382853508, -0.04701796546578407, 0.019705697894096375, 0.006394197233021259, -0.03987911343574524, 0.0029801635537296534, -0.004190999548882246, 0.010209791362285614, -0.020998075604438782, -0.03244485706090927, -0.025170613080263138, -0.0009131270344369113, 0.009612835012376308, 0.016210120171308517, 0.0062588052824139595, 0.047337982803583145, -0.02890004776418209, 0.03096785396337509, -0.006504972465336323, 0.07818275690078735, -0.005751085001975298, -0.03084477037191391, -0.00036232758429832757, 0.034094180911779404, 0.024715203791856766, -0.006154184229671955, -0.05203977972269058, -0.04460552707314491, -0.0321248397231102, -0.032223306596279144, 0.009342051111161709, -0.03564503416419029, -0.02956470102071762, -0.0034648056607693434, 0.02188427932560444, -0.009545139037072659, 0.0117421830072999, 0.040100663900375366, 0.08556777238845825, -0.0064865099266171455, -0.026856858283281326, -0.02944161556661129, 0.004126380197703838, 0.04428550973534584, -0.023508982732892036, -0.019434913992881775, -0.0216873437166214, 0.0037417439743876457, -0.01056673377752304, -0.04719028249382973, 0.05410758778452873, -0.020567283034324646, 0.024875212460756302, 0.03835287317633629, 0.034561898559331894, -0.010579042136669159, -0.0143515570089221, -0.0030263199005275965, 0.030204735696315765, -0.007003461476415396, 0.006246496923267841, 0.0015254684258252382, -0.024838287383317947, -0.005951095838099718, 0.018757952377200127, -0.032617174088954926, 0.02428440935909748, 0.022635089233517647, 0.027644595131278038, 0.04081454873085022, 0.01063442975282669, 0.041208416223526, -0.06267420947551727, -0.038303639739751816, -0.07212703675031662, 0.003987911157310009, -0.01861025206744671, 0.026979943737387657, -0.0620834082365036, -0.019237980246543884, -0.057701628655195236, 0.006326501257717609, 0.04655024781823158, 0.02909698151051998, 0.06036023795604706, 0.015803944319486618, 0.06272344291210175, -0.012216055765748024, 0.022388922050595284, -0.0039109839126467705, 0.011908345855772495, 0.02461673691868782, 0.023730533197522163, -0.01733018271625042, -0.07852739095687866, 0.016234736889600754, 0.0020601130090653896, 0.021761193871498108, 0.03244485706090927, 0.0033817242365330458, 0.004200230818241835, -0.005655695218592882, -0.01699785701930523, 0.053566016256809235, 0.045467112213373184, 0.04216846823692322, 0.023435132578015327, -0.014363865368068218, -0.06853299587965012, -0.01986570656299591, -0.015274684876203537, -0.011532940901815891, 0.025182921439409256, 0.04514709487557411, 0.045393262058496475, 0.044851694256067276, 0.029810868203639984, -0.022315071895718575, 0.045737896114587784, -0.04042068123817444, -0.017834825441241264, 0.01792098395526409, -0.04113456606864929, 0.04817495122551918, 0.013699213974177837, 0.013933072797954082, 0.010197483003139496, 0.015139292925596237, -0.0038155941292643547, 0.013391504064202309, -0.003461728570982814, -0.013428429141640663, 0.0067080603912472725, 0.03136172145605087, -0.0250106044113636, -0.056175392121076584, -0.04704258218407631, 0.041922301054000854, 0.025724489241838455, 0.002357052406296134, -0.008825100027024746, 0.005246441811323166, 0.034561898559331894, -0.015200834721326828, 0.02001340687274933, 0.001917028333991766, -0.021121159195899963, 0.0011800647480413318, -0.04824880138039589, -0.0527290478348732, 0.028481563553214073, 0.003215561155229807, 0.007778888568282127, 0.011416011489927769, 0.05484608933329582, -0.034955766052007675, -0.0433746874332428, -0.026413757354021072, -0.014720807783305645, -0.018290234729647636, -0.03591581806540489, -0.05120281130075455, 0.011022143997251987, -0.05799702927470207, 0.054501455277204514, -0.04275926947593689, 0.0018847188912332058, 0.017428649589419365, -0.030155502259731293, 0.043128520250320435, -0.006954228039830923, 0.07414560765028, -0.01779790036380291, 0.025478322058916092, 0.010732896625995636, 0.03539886698126793, 0.025995273143053055, -0.07547491043806076, 0.038426723331213, -0.001697016297839582, -0.007643496617674828, -0.018548710271716118, 0.0009900543373078108, 0.0031432495452463627, 0.05587999150156975, -0.004181768279522657, 0.05292598158121109, -0.04699334874749184, 0.01865948550403118, 0.0188071858137846, 0.015693169087171555, 0.023262815549969673, -0.0036032747011631727, 0.049676574766635895, -0.001998571213334799, -0.015570085495710373, -0.019841089844703674, -0.04295620322227478, 0.054550688713788986, -0.011699103750288486, 0.02850618027150631, -0.00309401610866189, 0.004040221683681011, 0.007372712250798941, 0.006683443672955036, 0.020887300372123718, 0.053369082510471344, -0.03037705272436142, 0.02729996107518673, 0.014671574346721172, 0.0031094015575945377, 0.026807624846696854, -0.021576568484306335, -0.03434034809470177, -0.010449804365634918, 0.002143194666132331, -0.04849496856331825, 0.031755588948726654, 0.01140370313078165, 0.03037705272436142, 0.015422385185956955, 0.0134530458599329, 0.013428429141640663, 0.011434474028646946, 0.031878672540187836, -0.024567503482103348, 0.037171270698308945, -0.027127644047141075, -0.03758975490927696, 0.012702235952019691, 0.005412604659795761, -0.024875212460756302, -0.043522387742996216, -0.09955008327960968, -0.019188744947314262, -0.021244242787361145, 0.026241440325975418, -0.007538875564932823, -0.0023585909511893988, 0.006474201567471027, -0.03424188122153282, -0.015151601284742355, 0.014770042151212692, -0.01627166196703911, 0.013920764438807964, 0.005668003577739, 0.015126984566450119, -0.013280728831887245, 0.008308148011565208, 0.011902191676199436, -0.0057541620917618275, 0.023336665704846382, 0.01208066288381815, 0.0157916359603405, 0.034955766052007675, 0.023976700380444527, 0.029589317739009857, -0.04844573512673378, -0.011569865979254246, 0.013773064129054546, -0.0056464639492332935, 0.00632034707814455, 0.016813231632113457, -0.008972800336778164, -0.0026093740016222, 0.0018000988056883216, -0.011803724803030491, -0.019656464457511902, -0.013736139051616192, 0.045860979706048965, -0.013871531002223492, -0.07532721012830734, -0.014191548340022564, -0.01415462326258421, -0.004732567351311445, 0.024936754256486893, -0.0025001373142004013, 0.032961808145046234, 0.0035971205215901136, -0.04086378216743469, -0.01571778580546379, 0.018893344327807426, -0.007471179589629173, -0.01778559200465679, 0.03205098956823349, -0.06582514941692352, -0.022844331339001656, 0.0065603600814938545, 0.01838870160281658, 0.002337051322683692, -0.030992470681667328, 0.02629067376255989, -0.0005954172811470926, 0.016874773427844048, 0.007526567205786705, -0.01238221861422062, -0.016480904072523117, -0.01733018271625042, 0.03118940442800522, -0.019373372197151184, 0.0144869489595294, 0.03264179080724716, 0.0224012304097414, 0.0155208520591259, -0.005664926487952471, 0.0020616515539586544, 0.017145557329058647, 0.047534916549921036, -0.0428331196308136, -0.052433647215366364, -0.011576020158827305, 0.03306027501821518, -0.0125053022056818, 0.009662069380283356, -0.01926259696483612, 0.008615857921540737, -0.014031539671123028, -0.009871311485767365, 0.02328743226826191, -0.01806868426501751, -0.01778559200465679, -0.014253090135753155, 0.03411879763007164, -0.029490849003195763, 0.04029759764671326, 0.0027832298073917627, -0.02683224156498909, -0.022265838459134102, 0.006437276490032673, -0.042390018701553345, 0.049282707273960114, 0.007686575874686241, 0.016837848350405693, -0.04460552707314491, -0.009108192287385464, -0.04032221436500549, -0.007938897237181664, -0.020234957337379456, 0.023459749296307564, -0.007046540733426809, 0.013773064129054546, 0.013637672178447247, 0.03237100690603256, 0.07463794201612473, -0.01591471955180168, -0.0177240502089262, 0.009274355135858059, 0.01987801492214203, 0.015151601284742355, -0.05927710235118866, 0.01832715980708599, 0.011329852975904942, 0.012086817063391209, -0.00005851282912772149, -0.04275926947593689, -0.016382437199354172, 0.0058680144138634205, -0.04275926947593689, 0.010074399411678314, 0.00892972107976675, 0.014843892306089401, -0.010800592601299286, -0.0030909390188753605, 0.018831802532076836, -0.03379878029227257, 0.011422165669500828, -0.010966756381094456, 0.005135666579008102, -0.015163909643888474, -0.0144869489595294, -0.0078281220048666, -0.011212923564016819, 0.014671574346721172, 0.015213143080472946, -0.017367107793688774, 0.03754052147269249, 0.03365107998251915, 0.029490849003195763, 0.004787954967468977, 0.023238198831677437, -0.02983548492193222, 0.014757733792066574, -0.006498818285763264, -0.03399571403861046, -0.04354700446128845, 0.010431341826915741, -0.02275817282497883, 0.013108411803841591, -0.020370349287986755, -0.015533160418272018, 0.005963404197245836, -0.01739172451198101, 0.023299740627408028, -0.0024185944348573685, 0.014142314903438091, 0.015077751129865646, 0.008357382379472256, -0.032494090497493744, 0.03219868987798691, 0.008714324794709682, -0.022044287994503975, -0.01003747433423996, -0.013206878677010536, 0.0014677728759124875, -0.005237210541963577, 0.0007869662949815392, 0.02481367066502571, -0.0192133616656065, -0.0044494750909507275, -0.033232592046260834, -0.02300434000790119, 0.0018154842546209693, -0.0027663058135658503, 0.020985767245292664, 0.04142996668815613, -0.008985108695924282, 0.045270178467035294, 0.03749128803610802, -0.025306005030870438, -0.012025275267660618, -0.018782569095492363, -0.03948524594306946, 0.005126435309648514, 0.012751469388604164, -0.005769547540694475, -0.03126325458288193, -0.0032863342203199863, -0.011692949570715427, -0.04076531529426575, 0.0133176539093256, 0.01485620066523552, -0.026389140635728836, -0.03419264778494835, 0.034143414348363876, -0.017957909032702446, -0.013096103444695473, 0.02206890471279621, 0.022967414930462837, -0.012874552980065346, -0.015607010573148727, 0.01577932760119438, 0.03480806574225426, 0.005246441811323166, -0.0006861915462650359, -0.019188744947314262, 0.025072146207094193, -0.025601405650377274, 0.04344853758811951, 0.04748568311333656, -0.004080223850905895, 0.02233968861401081, 0.032494090497493744, 0.0077111925929784775, -0.03180482238531113, 0.023312048986554146, 0.01023440808057785, 0.020862683653831482, 0.009735919535160065, 0.0015039286809042096, 0.0125053022056818, -0.007914280518889427, 0.0019616461358964443, -0.019299522042274475, 0.009668223559856415, 0.02963855117559433, 0.0326664075255394, 0.0156562440097332, 0.040371447801589966, 0.015877794474363327, 0.02784152887761593, -0.03864827752113342, -0.006295730359852314, -0.029540084302425385, -0.02173657715320587, -0.0005627232021652162, -0.031017087399959564, -0.030746303498744965, -0.0036648164968937635, 0.011329852975904942, 0.005831089336425066, 0.017982525750994682, 0.006880377884954214, 0.014499257318675518, -0.021367326378822327, -0.025059837847948074, 0.012825319543480873, 0.013354578986763954, -0.006209571845829487, 0.022093521431088448, 0.010480575263500214, -0.02313973195850849, 0.00326171750202775, -0.012099125422537327, 0.0004607945156749338, 0.01699785701930523, 0.021773502230644226, -0.010259024798870087, 0.026241440325975418, -0.011717566289007664, 0.05519072338938713, -0.027176877483725548, 0.039362162351608276, -0.022770481184124947, -0.07419484108686447, -0.03200175613164902, 0.022388922050595284, 0.04802725091576576, 0.007840430364012718, -0.003357107285410166, 0.004178691189736128, 0.03126325458288193, -0.01485620066523552, -0.022450463846325874, -0.003994065336883068, -0.0155208520591259, 0.010142095386981964, 0.046944115310907364, -0.0014031539903953671, -0.01779790036380291, -0.030992470681667328, 0.03758975490927696, 0.0002929006877820939, -0.006874223705381155, -0.013699213974177837, 0.005517226178199053, 0.028481563553214073, 0.04069146513938904, -0.0024862904101610184, -0.0011039067758247256, -0.008652782998979092, -0.02737381123006344, 0.004391010385006666, -0.006080333609133959, -0.0011700642062351108, -0.00032905652187764645, -0.015607010573148727, 0.05445222184062004, -0.019681081175804138, 0.001998571213334799, -0.003115555737167597, 0.016025494784116745, -0.04463014379143715, -0.025675255805253983, -0.0015739325899630785, -0.03372493013739586, 0.0035509641747921705, 0.008012747392058372, 0.019754931330680847, -0.024973679333925247, -0.000924666179344058, -0.0188071858137846, -0.009926699101924896, 0.01832715980708599, -0.004627946298569441, 0.014093081466853619, -0.014314631931483746, -0.010603658854961395, 0.039436012506484985, 0.0186717938631773, 0.0230781901627779, 0.03210022300481796, 0.0006334963254630566, 0.008745095692574978, -0.03091862052679062, -0.016160886734724045, 0.0073604038916528225, -0.03217407315969467, -0.04645178094506264, -0.02315204031765461, -0.060458704829216, 0.04851958528161049, 0.008855870924890041, -0.012616077437996864, -0.01671476475894451, 0.011385240592062473, -0.006824990268796682, 0.025576788932085037, -0.009742073714733124, 0.006948073860257864, 0.028407713398337364, 0.007920434698462486, -0.03264179080724716, 0.04470399394631386, -0.004609483759850264, -0.011576020158827305, 0.03554656729102135, 0.018511785194277763, -0.020887300372123718, 0.029786251485347748, -0.02435825951397419, -0.026856858283281326, -0.0032524862326681614, 0.03537425026297569, 0.0166039876639843, -0.004221770446747541, 0.017157865688204765, 0.019914939999580383, 0.043645475059747696, -0.008763558231294155, 0.01518852636218071, -0.019508764147758484, -0.005957250017672777, 0.011557557620108128, -0.004658717196434736, -0.02455519512295723, -0.01167448703199625, -0.017896367236971855, 0.012136050499975681, -0.008689708076417446, 0.010615967214107513, 0.0098959282040596, 0.011280619539320469, 0.022893564775586128, 0.04106071591377258, 0.004218693356961012, -0.03123863786458969, 0.03256794065237045, 0.03694972023367882, 0.00886817928403616, -0.037638988345861435, -0.012800702825188637, 0.0368020199239254, 0.03251870721578598, 0.042783886194229126, -0.031090937554836273, -0.051350511610507965, -0.029220065101981163, -0.007581954821944237, -0.010123632848262787, -0.019496455788612366, 0.005975712556391954, -0.0038832901045680046, -0.0025524478405714035, 0.0088620251044631, 0.025256771594285965, 0.03854981064796448, 0.014450023882091045, -0.012665310874581337, 0.035300400108098984, 0.005701851565390825, 0.03874674439430237, -0.0009215890313498676, 0.022179679945111275, 0.0030632452107965946, -0.010425187647342682, -0.00026424528914503753, -0.004471014719456434, -0.0016231660265475512, -0.007846584543585777, -0.0022001208271831274, 0.0033047967590391636, 0.03507884964346886, 0.0118775749579072, -0.012363756075501442, 0.024862904101610184, 0.015077751129865646, 0.015077751129865646, -0.012603769078850746, 0.002715533599257469, 0.007631188258528709, 0.0008823561365716159, -0.011397548951208591, 0.01699785701930523, -0.0034648056607693434, 0.0155208520591259, -0.013145336881279945, 0.0091328090056777, -0.001730864285491407, 0.012628385797142982, -0.012412989512085915, 0.008542007766664028, 0.009268200956285, -0.006135721690952778, 0.01374844741076231, -0.09260816127061844, 0.026118356734514236, -0.01024056226015091, -0.002889389405027032, 0.018991811200976372, -0.005200285464525223, 0.017022473737597466, 0.015742402523756027, -0.003221715334802866, -0.009822078049182892, -0.019914939999580383, -0.013649980537593365, 0.006991153117269278, 0.030426286160945892, 0.008578932844102383, -0.011292927898466587, -0.015373151749372482, 0.02508445456624031, 0.04280850291252136, 0.03406956419348717, 0.0166039876639843, -0.01094213966280222, 0.04952887445688248, 0.025256771594285965, 0.0036586623173207045, -0.06188647449016571, 0.054353754967451096, 0.010511346161365509, 0.023472057655453682, -0.04074069857597351, -0.01094213966280222, -0.024702895432710648, -0.012973019853234291, 0.018844110891222954, 0.019951865077018738, 0.01993955671787262, -0.010474421083927155, -0.032937191426754, -0.03419264778494835, 0.005655695218592882, 0.022598164156079292, 0.03136172145605087, 0.004695642273873091, 0.03170635551214218, -0.0500212088227272, -0.00040348368929699063, -0.006394197233021259, -0.0362604521214962, -0.0307709202170372, -0.009785152971744537, -0.0359896682202816, -0.021711960434913635, 0.08029979467391968, -0.004907961934804916, 0.03980526328086853, 0.01126831118017435, -0.020025715231895447, -0.02803846262395382, 0.0014516181545332074, -0.019853398203849792, -0.007538875564932823, -0.0003044398035854101, -0.022672014310956, -0.041996151208877563, 0.003341721836477518, 0.001917028333991766, 0.002523215487599373, 0.0022139677312225103, 0.004981812089681625, 0.04027298092842102, -0.011360623873770237, -0.0028032308910042048, 0.0016770150978118181, 0.002277048071846366, -0.0071080825291574, 0.018917961046099663, 0.0059387874789536, -0.015976261347532272, -0.026856858283281326, -0.01573009416460991, 0.0024170558899641037, 0.007698884233832359, -0.015286993235349655, -0.049011923372745514, 0.024456728249788284, -0.026462990790605545, 0.033552613109350204, 0.030253969132900238, -0.012800702825188637, 0.0011977580143138766, -0.03909137845039368, -0.04034683108329773, -0.003169404808431864, 0.006271113641560078, -0.02039496600627899, -0.034832682460546494, 0.017342491075396538, -0.006268036551773548, -0.06055717170238495, -0.0088620251044631, -0.02629067376255989, -0.006108027882874012, -0.019496455788612366, -0.0078281220048666, -0.03554656729102135, 0.018031759187579155, 0.008640474639832973, -0.021108850836753845, -0.009551293216645718, -0.03126325458288193, -0.009009725414216518, -0.03805747255682945, 0.0035971205215901136, -0.010400570929050446, 0.006769602652639151, 0.0010523655219003558, 0.007538875564932823, 0.008505082689225674, 0.006369580514729023, -0.00632034707814455, 0.01559470221400261, 0.011305236257612705, 0.008061980828642845, 0.006511126644909382, -0.022056596353650093, -0.003221715334802866, -0.0030047802720218897, -0.00450178561732173, 0.003661739407107234, -0.004612560849636793, -0.01499159261584282, 0.0146223409101367, 0.025256771594285965, -0.01347766350954771, 0.019656464457511902, -0.014228473417460918, 0.0159270279109478, -0.0040986863896250725, -0.014191548340022564, -0.004224847536534071, -0.02341051585972309, 0.012960711494088173, -0.00816660188138485, -0.00042579261935316026, -0.026930708438158035, -0.03640815243124962, 0.009052804671227932, 0.01847486011683941, 0.0038648275658488274, -0.017342491075396538, -0.024235175922513008, 0.03057398647069931, -0.007661959156394005, -0.016148578375577927, -0.019422605633735657, 0.00990208238363266, -0.008806637488305569, 0.009372822009027004, 0.04635331407189369, 0.020431891083717346, 0.0237551499158144, 0.028555413708090782, -0.028826197609305382, -0.02174888551235199, 0.03613736853003502, -0.023533599451184273, 0.004458706360310316, 0.028186162933707237, 0.01167448703199625, -0.011311390437185764, 0.017379416152834892, -0.008689708076417446, -0.015963952988386154, -0.019041044637560844, 0.0046371775679290295, -0.007465025410056114, -0.007218857761472464, -0.030746303498744965, -0.011126765049993992, 0.062132641673088074, -0.004274080973118544, -0.0007550414302386343, -0.007821967825293541, 0.03182943910360336, -0.011366778053343296, -0.006169569678604603, 0.007643496617674828, 0.01859794370830059, -0.008154293522238731, 0.0008546623284928501, 0.03030320256948471, -0.0042679267935454845, 0.0233489740639925, 0.005766470450907946, 0.001437001978047192, -0.014203856699168682, 0.025527555495500565, 0.003861750476062298, -0.0002586680348031223, -0.0204688161611557, -0.00195703050121665, -0.036900486797094345, 0.030475519597530365, 0.01725633256137371, -0.03660508617758751, 0.00469871936365962, 0.006861915346235037, -0.009520522318780422, 0.028186162933707237, 0.005271058529615402, 0.016431670635938644, 0.012419143691658974, -0.006578822620213032, -0.03694972023367882, -0.0023955160286277533, -0.025847572833299637, 0.04918424040079117, 0.01083751767873764, -0.018019450828433037, 0.051892079412937164, -0.010283641517162323, 0.03200175613164902, -0.024173634126782417, -0.02830924652516842, 0.03163250535726547, -0.02188427932560444, 0.0033109509386122227, 0.0007500411593355238, 0.006098796613514423, 0.0012931479141116142, -0.038845211267471313, 0.009951315820217133, -0.0289738979190588, 0.003406340954825282, 0.030327819287776947, -0.003766360692679882, 0.044113192707300186, 0.027743062004446983, -0.006492664106190205, -0.01518852636218071, 0.0019354908727109432, -0.03914061188697815, 0.019028736278414726, 0.01361305546015501, -0.012886861339211464, -0.028456946834921837, 0.020234957337379456, 0.013699213974177837, -0.02281971462070942, -0.007766580209136009, 0.005480301100760698, -0.021761193871498108, -0.016013186424970627, -0.013994614593684673, -0.0027201492339372635, -0.045934829860925674, 0.017108632251620293, -0.018844110891222954, -0.024432111531496048, -0.0026047583669424057, 0.011865266598761082, 0.002703225240111351, 0.0017185559263452888, -0.03813132271170616, -0.0035325016360729933, 0.0006796526722609997, -0.00919435080140829, -0.051547445356845856, 0.03264179080724716, -0.02858003042638302, 0.01954568922519684, -0.0052187480032444, 0.013059178367257118, 0.030623219907283783, -0.005723391193896532, -0.001970877405256033, -0.0039048297330737114, -0.0037817461416125298, 0.002475520595908165, -0.015410076826810837, 0.03342952951788902, 0.02749689482152462, 0.004246387165039778, -0.004997197538614273, 0.01499159261584282, -0.007877355441451073, -0.0313124880194664, 0.003452497301623225, -0.01819176785647869, 0.027718445286154747, 0.022524314001202583, 0.011317544616758823, 0.013145336881279945, -0.024665970355272293, 0.03072168678045273, 0.010203637182712555, 0.0065542059019207954, -0.03975602984428406, -0.020985767245292664, 0.03611275181174278, 0.03505423292517662, -0.013711522333323956, 0.015668552368879318, -0.012763777747750282, -0.04443321004509926, 0.002521676942706108, -0.00983438640832901, 0.00398175697773695, 0.01251145638525486, -0.04898730665445328, 0.021798118948936462, 0.014671574346721172, -0.0054587614722549915, 0.01231452263891697, 0.0022724324371665716, 0.005643386859446764, -0.007181932684034109, 0.017884058877825737, 0.022265838459134102, -0.022893564775586128, 0.01612396165728569, -0.010899059474468231, -0.003975602798163891, -0.015631627291440964, 0.0017939446261152625, -0.0255521722137928, -0.009280509315431118, 0.012222209945321083, -0.008985108695924282, -0.007421946153044701, -0.006280344910919666, -0.0012869937345385551, 0.007809659466147423, -0.01933644711971283, 0.013896147720515728, -0.025798339396715164, -0.04374394193291664, 0.0032463320530951023, 0.023656683042645454, 0.00795735977590084, 0.004461783450096846, -0.020296499133110046, 0.016468595713377, 0.03847596049308777, 0.011859112419188023, 0.0019154897890985012, -0.04423627629876137, -0.018364084884524345, -0.004132534377276897, -0.00893587525933981, -0.007538875564932823, 0.0516459122300148, -0.030894003808498383, -0.0091328090056777, -0.05051354318857193, 0.018105609342455864, 0.0032401778735220432, -0.012653002515435219, 0.03852519392967224, 0.012345293536782265, -0.02976163476705551, 0.017625583335757256, -0.0133176539093256, 0.005689543206244707, -0.033232592046260834, -0.0292446818202734, 0.0035048078279942274, 0.025995273143053055, -0.006689597852528095, 0.01077597588300705, -0.0038986755535006523, -0.007526567205786705, 0.003997142426669598, 0.04128226637840271, 0.01010517030954361, 0.013034561648964882, -0.03286334127187729, -0.011951425112783909, 0.04682103171944618, -0.007532721385359764, -0.05440298840403557, -0.005624924320727587, -0.01347766350954771, 0.0071080825291574, 0.015311609953641891, 0.02021034061908722, 0.009145117364823818, 0.017748666927218437, 0.014191548340022564, 0.0036371226888149977, -0.017674816772341728, 0.01577932760119438, 0.009908236563205719, -0.03232177346944809, 0.014499257318675518, -0.002663223072886467, 0.015065442770719528, -0.008818945847451687, -0.0072434744797647, 0.05538765713572502, -0.0040494529530406, 0.011840649880468845, 0.009545139037072659, -0.013231495395302773, 0.010111324489116669, 0.01577932760119438, 0.013329962268471718, 0.007200395222753286, 0.046131763607263565, -0.016296278685331345, -0.013133028522133827, 0.0076373424381017685, 0.01374844741076231, -0.02174888551235199, 0.0014939281390979886, -0.041257649660110474, 0.004901807755231857, -0.059030935168266296, 0.008154293522238731, 0.022388922050595284, -0.02048112452030182, 0.03173097223043442, 0.015397768467664719, 0.014966975897550583, 0.041208416223526, 0.02936776541173458, 0.0006658057682216167, 0.0017493268242105842, -0.014659265987575054, -0.038771361112594604, 0.034758832305669785, -0.032617174088954926, -0.010868288576602936, 0.024370569735765457, -0.022672014310956, 0.04209461808204651, -0.01740403287112713, -0.026462990790605545, 0.018499476835131645, -0.01545931026339531, 0.06380657851696014, 0.023718224838376045, 0.0009062035824172199, 0.022635089233517647, 0.016739381477236748, 0.0008361997315660119, 0.012739161029458046, -0.01284993626177311, -0.025047529488801956, 0.0420207679271698, -0.018031759187579155, -0.005123358219861984, -0.010314412415027618, 0.023582832887768745, 0.0012116050347685814, -0.0008508159662596881, -0.019225670024752617, 0.012326830998063087, -0.019828781485557556, 0.0433746874332428, -0.021835045889019966, -0.0012793010100722313, -0.015447001904249191, -0.022832022979855537, -0.01324380375444889, -0.010462112724781036, 0.010474421083927155, -0.01906566135585308, 0.024862904101610184, 0.0184010099619627, -0.006086487788707018, 0.0001978954824153334, -0.0032432549633085728, 0.003021704265847802, -0.03155865520238876, -0.015471618622541428, -0.029466232284903526, 0.008849716745316982, -0.017342491075396538, 0.02428440935909748, 0.012197593227028847, -0.03224792331457138, -0.005689543206244707, 0.00515105202794075, 0.007981976494193077, 0.014930050820112228, 0.004827957600355148, -0.008000439032912254, -0.011496015824377537, 0.011526786722242832, 0.021293476223945618, -0.0045233252458274364, -0.0039171380922198296, 0.008492774330079556, 0.018019450828433037, -0.01859794370830059, 0.024210559204220772, 0.016948623582720757, 0.026462990790605545, -0.019890323281288147, 0.006243419833481312, -0.010148249566555023, -0.018573326990008354, 0.027127644047141075, -0.0166039876639843, 0.02341051585972309, -0.029589317739009857, 0.008818945847451687, 0.012800702825188637, 0.011625253595411777, -0.05883399769663811, -0.01725633256137371, 0.0208749920129776, 0.01532391831278801, 0.0047110277228057384, -0.004618715029209852, 0.0039140610024333, 0.0019493377767503262, -0.02369360812008381, 0.0292446818202734, -0.023262815549969673, 0.0035540412645787, -0.03210022300481796, -0.001206989400088787, 0.0009600527118891478, 0.013699213974177837, 0.020554974675178528, 0.007305016275495291, -0.003169404808431864, -0.016837848350405693, -0.030155502259731293, -0.0456148125231266, 0.00326171750202775, 0.02710302732884884, 0.011520632542669773, 0.004280235152691603, 0.008209681138396263, 0.0332079753279686, -0.010339029133319855, -0.023041265085339546, 0.02121962606906891, -0.013342270627617836, -0.00038213637890294194, -0.0208749920129776, 0.03404494747519493, 0.02274586446583271, -0.024370569735765457, -0.022327380254864693, 0.03210022300481796, 0.03564503416419029, 0.013908456079661846, -0.009785152971744537, 0.0077173467725515366, -0.03867289423942566, 0.014388482086360455, 0.004403318744152784, 0.03399571403861046, -0.0031324797309935093, -0.011705257929861546, 0.017047090455889702, -0.005994175095111132, 0.00684345280751586, -0.018253309652209282, 0.010751359164714813, 0.027078410610556602, 0.005766470450907946, -0.031164787709712982, -0.009028187952935696 ]
12.122104
3.201263
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.531.4954B
[ "galaxy clustering measurements", "systematics mitigation", "mock galaxy catalogues", "systematic contaminants", "specific systematics", "systematics", "Galaxy clustering measurements", "precise measurements", "synthetic systematic template maps", "unbiased cosmological analysis" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
12
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1444", "10.48550/arXiv.2401.12293" ]
[ "Berlfein, Federico", "Mandelbaum, Rachel", "Dodelson, Scott", "Schafer, Chad" ]
[ "Department of Physics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA; Department of Physics, McWilliams Center for Cosmology, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA", "Department of Physics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA; Department of Physics, McWilliams Center for Cosmology, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA; NSF AI Planning Institute, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA", "Department of Physics, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA; Department of Physics, McWilliams Center for Cosmology, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA; NSF AI Planning Institute, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA", "Department of Physics, McWilliams Center for Cosmology, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA; NSF AI Planning Institute, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA; Department of Statistics &amp; Data Science, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA" ]
null
[ "1992ApJ...398..169R", "1993ApJ...412...64L", "1998AJ....116.1009R", "1999ApJ...517..565P", "2000ApJ...538..473L", "2004MNRAS.352..338J", "2005ASSL..332...97F", "2005ApJ...622..759G", "2005astro.ph.10346T", "2011MNRAS.417.1350R", "2012ApJ...761...14H", "2013MNRAS.436..540H", "2013Msngr.154...44D", "2013PASP..125..306F", "2013PhR...530...87W", "2015MNRAS.447.2961S", "2015MNRAS.450.2857H", "2015arXiv150303757S", "2016MNRAS.456.2095E", "2016MNRAS.461.1431R", "2017MNRAS.465.1454H", "2017MNRAS.465.1847E", "2017MNRAS.470.4646S", "2018MNRAS.481.1337H", "2018PASJ...70S...4A", "2018PASJ...70S...8A", "2018PhR...733....1D", "2018PhRvD..98d2006E", "2019ApJ...873..111I", "2019ApJS..242....2C", "2019JOSS....4.1298Z", "2019MNRAS.484.4127A", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020MNRAS.495.1613R", "2021A&A...648A..98J", "2021ApJS..254...24S", "2021MNRAS.503.5061W", "2021MNRAS.506.3439R", "2021PhRvD.103d3503P", "2021arXiv210513548K", "2022A&A...662A.112E", "2022AJ....164..207D", "2022MNRAS.511.2665R", "2022PhRvD.105b3520A", "2023JCAP...07..044B", "2024MNRAS.532.1902R" ]
29184188
2311.15261
Tomographic cross correlations between galaxy surveys and the CMB gravitational lensing potential. Effect of the redshift bin mismatch
Context. Upcoming surveys of the large-scale structure of our Universe will employ a large coverage area of about half of the sky and will significantly increase the observational depth. With these surveys, we will be able to cross-correlate cosmic microwave background (CMB) gravitational lensing and galaxy surveys divided into narrow redshift bins to map the evolution of the cosmological parameters with redshift. <BR /> Aims: We study the effect of the redshift bin mismatch of objects that is due to photometric redshift errors in tomographic cross-correlation measurements. <BR /> Methods: We used the code FLASK to create Monte Carlo simulations of the Vera C. Rubin Observatory Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST) and Planck CMB lensing convergence. We simulated log-normal fields and divided galaxies into nine redshift bins with the Gaussian and modified Lorentzian photometric redshift errors. To estimate the parameters, we used angular power spectra of CMB lensing and galaxy density contrast fields and the maximum likelihood estimation method. <BR /> Results: We show that even with simple Gaussian errors with a standard deviation of σ(z) = 0.02(1 + z), the galaxy auto-power spectra in tomographic bins are offset by 2 − 15%. The estimated cross-power spectra between galaxy clustering and CMB lensing are also biased, with smaller deviations &lt; 5%. As a result, the σ<SUB>8</SUB> parameter deviates between 0.2 − 1.2σ due to the redshift bin mismatch of the objects. We propose a computationally fast and robust method based on the scattering matrix approach to correct for the redshift bin mismatch of the objects. <BR /> Conclusions: The estimates of the parameters in tomographic studies such as the linear galaxy bias, the cross-correlation amplitude, and σ<SUB>8</SUB> are biased due to the redshift bin mismatch of the objects. The biases in these parameters are alleviated with our scattering matrix approach.
[ 0.02765912003815174, 0.011175989173352718, 0.035406772047281265, 0.034012194722890854, -0.0367496982216835, 0.030086716637015343, -0.007121384143829346, -0.013945774175226688, -0.053510453552007675, 0.010582001879811287, -0.032979175448417664, -0.005671927239745855, -0.02193876914680004, 0.022171199321746826, 0.009161598980426788, 0.028459711000323296, -0.02261023223400116, 0.03124886564910412, -0.025722205638885498, 0.012344593182206154, 0.00040997995529323816, -0.04710572585463524, -0.00363494036719203, -0.0011847452260553837, -0.0716916099190712, -0.035794153809547424, 0.038428355008363724, 0.02840805985033512, 0.06043168902397156, 0.0005669505917467177, -0.005833336617797613, -0.02587715908885002, -0.06554514169692993, -0.020208459347486496, -0.06761118024587631, 0.08703196048736572, -0.03548424690961838, 0.01707066036760807, 0.000194901876966469, -0.009109947830438614, -0.010420592501759529, 0.03871243819594383, -0.020014768466353416, -0.025463951751589775, -0.01912378892302513, -0.014940056949853897, -0.022300327196717262, -0.039642155170440674, -0.036517269909381866, 0.008935625664889812, -0.03631066530942917, -0.02214537374675274, -0.03641396760940552, -0.06497697532176971, -0.007947799749672413, -0.013480915687978268, -0.0045678867027163506, 0.031016435474157333, -0.0153403514996171, 0.018813882023096085, 0.022171199321746826, -0.0020386010874062777, 0.020867010578513145, 0.0018061714945361018, -0.03199780359864235, 0.016567064449191093, 0.014010338112711906, -0.0016705875750631094, 0.032307710498571396, 0.04984322935342789, -0.0211123526096344, 0.015404915437102318, 0.00839329045265913, 0.023113830015063286, 0.034941911697387695, 0.024133937433362007, 0.01669619046151638, 0.054646775126457214, -0.00767017574980855, 0.00640149787068367, 0.011563370935618877, -0.02851136028766632, 0.01820698380470276, 0.010452874936163425, -0.026677750051021576, -0.002127376152202487, 0.014875493012368679, 0.0005972149083390832, -0.03824757784605026, 0.035690851509571075, -0.006837303284555674, -0.00017523010319564492, 0.003631712170317769, 0.002061198465526104, -0.014940056949853897, -0.03217858448624611, 0.03685300052165985, -0.0706585943698883, 0.05423356592655182, 0.03132634237408638, 0.03246266394853592, 0.0371629074215889, 0.030629053711891174, -0.08899470418691635, 0.045762799680233, -0.019020486623048782, 0.01514666061848402, -0.06239442899823189, 0.01837484911084175, -0.0015148274833336473, 0.007450659293681383, 0.002692309208214283, -0.039719630032777786, -0.014307331293821335, -0.01022044476121664, -0.03574250265955925, -0.07458406686782837, -0.014100727625191212, -0.019743600860238075, -0.01233168039470911, -0.014488110318779945, 0.0006658138590864837, 0.03357316181063652, 0.035019390285015106, 0.035871632397174835, -0.04165654629468918, 0.030887307599186897, -0.059037111699581146, -0.01218963973224163, 0.02053127996623516, 0.030551576986908913, -0.02729756198823452, 0.016489587724208832, 0.007237598765641451, -0.045814450830221176, 0.01687696948647499, 0.007676632143557072, -0.025270259007811546, 0.006181980948895216, 0.0008990505011752248, -0.009897626005113125, 0.03561337664723396, 0.0191367007791996, 0.006888954434543848, 0.016812406480312347, 0.015082096680998802, -0.033805590122938156, 0.01970486342906952, -0.02082827314734459, 0.03243684023618698, -0.006065766327083111, -0.01678658090531826, -0.045633673667907715, -0.04305112361907959, -0.0020724970381706953, -0.04165654629468918, 0.01243498269468546, 0.02015681006014347, -0.0234366487711668, -0.024882877245545387, 0.0029279671143740416, 0.004906846676021814, -0.014346069656312466, -0.0006472517852671444, -0.011163076385855675, -0.0018626648234203458, -0.02204207144677639, 0.03631066530942917, -0.07334444671869278, -0.030809830874204636, -0.04212140291929245, -0.0035897456109523773, 0.011505263857543468, -0.052296653389930725, 0.028640488162636757, 0.04808709770441055, 0.01135031133890152, -0.037679415196180344, 0.008754847571253777, -0.0019498259061947465, -0.029286125674843788, 0.029234474524855614, 0.024430930614471436, 0.0022500474005937576, -0.07076188921928406, -0.004822913557291031, -0.00665652472525835, 0.0021451313514262438, -0.024069374427199364, -0.029105348512530327, 0.006043169181793928, 0.031739551573991776, 0.00018057679699268192, 0.0468732975423336, -0.023656165227293968, -0.037576112896203995, 0.008025276474654675, 0.03698212653398514, -0.045168813318014145, -0.018917184323072433, 0.02174507826566696, 0.023204218596220016, 0.06693971902132034, -0.06771448254585266, -0.028950395062565804, -0.04878438636660576, 0.03047410026192665, 0.005962464027106762, -0.017290178686380386, 0.026380756869912148, 0.022209936752915382, -0.00412885332480073, 0.03532929718494415, 0.018452325835824013, 0.005032746121287346, -0.057177674025297165, -0.05531824007630348, 0.010007384233176708, 0.022455278784036636, 0.03656892105937004, -0.025683468207716942, 0.06311754137277603, 0.05505998432636261, -0.004596940707415342, 0.009232618845999241, 0.0028133662417531013, 0.05722932517528534, -0.04002953693270683, 0.04390336573123932, -0.026290368288755417, 0.006062537897378206, 0.013958686962723732, -0.002697151619940996, 0.016192594543099403, 0.019110877066850662, -0.030448274686932564, -0.016709104180336, -0.0070955585688352585, -0.014875493012368679, -0.042353834956884384, -0.013125814497470856, 0.04584027826786041, -0.0004717190458904952, -0.008302900940179825, -0.0008090647752396762, 0.022016245871782303, -0.028382234275341034, -0.048061270266771317, 0.036620572209358215, -0.0032588562462478876, -0.0031926785595715046, 0.015249962918460369, -0.01922709122300148, -0.06012178212404251, 0.0030038293916732073, 0.018219895660877228, -0.020570017397403717, 0.0034251080360263586, -0.01298377476632595, 0.00020498997764661908, -0.030551576986908913, -0.04664086923003197, -0.03633648902177811, -0.009645827114582062, -0.022726448252797127, -0.003383141476660967, 0.043851714581251144, -0.00863217655569315, -0.0488102100789547, -0.005591222550719976, -0.006288511212915182, 0.011079142801463604, 0.028950395062565804, -0.029415253549814224, -0.03439957648515701, 0.02598046138882637, 0.013190378434956074, 0.039073992520570755, 0.04395501688122749, -0.006876041647046804, -0.018323197960853577, 0.0035316383000463247, 0.024159763008356094, 0.0051360479556024075, 0.01398451253771782, -0.004751893691718578, -0.01361004263162613, -0.006792108528316021, 0.011389048770070076, -0.03876408934593201, 0.03349568322300911, -0.0666298121213913, -0.01745804399251938, 0.004228927195072174, -0.07200151681900024, 0.018219895660877228, 0.02381111867725849, -0.02121565490961075, -0.05521493777632713, 0.020221373066306114, 0.0409076064825058, 0.023023441433906555, 0.011505263857543468, 0.015301614068448544, -0.008425571955740452, 0.013390526175498962, 0.03876408934593201, -0.011382592841982841, -0.014423546381294727, 0.036723874509334564, -0.012079881504178047, 0.01818115822970867, -0.01172478124499321, 0.01567608304321766, -0.01865893043577671, 0.0012146059889346361, -0.017755037173628807, -0.005836565047502518, 0.04031362012028694, -0.030732354149222374, -0.03197197988629341, -0.06699136644601822, -0.015792299062013626, -0.02073788270354271, 0.006346618756651878, -0.025773856788873672, -0.031300514936447144, -0.016360459849238396, 0.02306217886507511, -0.005071484018117189, 0.00712784007191658, -0.01510792225599289, 0.029234474524855614, -0.03186867758631706, -0.022184111177921295, -0.0422247052192688, 0.0291569996625185, 0.07747652381658554, -0.013493828475475311, -0.031894501298666, -0.04447152465581894, 0.012841734103858471, 0.02944107912480831, -0.017987467348575592, 0.04126916080713272, 0.030887307599186897, 0.04163071885704994, 0.02533482387661934, 0.054078616201877594, -0.017600083723664284, -0.0099492771551013, -0.009458592161536217, 0.011330941691994667, -0.009258444420993328, 0.022532755509018898, -0.0007965555414557457, 0.00947796180844307, -0.05996682867407799, -0.014126553200185299, -0.013855385594069958, 0.010491612367331982, -0.01605055294930935, 0.05521493777632713, 0.010840256698429585, 0.003045795951038599, 0.02484413981437683, -0.03509686514735222, -0.009813693352043629, -0.044419873505830765, -0.04475560411810875, 0.017380567267537117, 0.0048261419869959354, -0.04767388850450516, -0.011092055588960648, -0.06291093677282333, 0.015598607249557972, 0.03641396760940552, 0.04537541791796684, 0.02129313163459301, 0.021912943571805954, 0.009155143052339554, -0.0034573900047689676, 0.01379082165658474, -0.024598795920610428, 0.024327628314495087, 0.023514125496149063, -0.025179870426654816, -0.015120835043489933, -0.07215647399425507, -0.01096938457340002, -0.02711678296327591, 0.005888215731829405, 0.04692494869232178, 0.01135031133890152, 0.05270986258983612, -0.02551560290157795, 0.04813874885439873, 0.07546213269233704, 0.023694904521107674, 0.03791184723377228, 0.0005883373669348657, -0.04015866667032242, -0.04509133845567703, -0.054543472826480865, -0.0016496042953804135, 0.018168244510889053, -0.0015535657294094563, 0.030835656449198723, 0.038040973246097565, 0.02120274305343628, 0.028382234275341034, -0.06616495549678802, 0.03783436864614487, -0.003741470631211996, 0.021732164546847343, 0.022184111177921295, -0.033908892422914505, 0.04052022099494934, 0.0016068308614194393, 0.02121565490961075, 0.041785672307014465, 0.03199780359864235, -0.005226437468081713, -0.016024727374315262, -0.023785293102264404, 0.03940972685813904, 0.012267116457223892, 0.010007384233176708, 0.00597860524430871, -0.021086527034640312, -0.020092245191335678, 0.006588732823729515, 0.045168813318014145, -0.0014664046466350555, -0.04287034273147583, 0.007760565262287855, 0.036517269909381866, -0.020389238372445107, 0.009871800430119038, -0.015779385343194008, 0.0030441817361861467, 0.0397971086204052, -0.04305112361907959, -0.05655786395072937, 0.013429264537990093, 0.01059491466730833, 0.030164193361997604, 0.009833062067627907, 0.048990990966558456, 0.022403627634048462, 0.01059491466730833, -0.037007953971624374, 0.0062981960363686085, -0.015095009468495846, -0.036052409559488297, 0.02579968236386776, -0.013713344931602478, -0.07040033489465714, 0.06466707587242126, -0.037472814321517944, -0.03421879932284355, 0.036543093621730804, -0.030448274686932564, 0.06745623052120209, 0.01135031133890152, 0.054543472826480865, 0.00943276658654213, 0.0022791011724621058, -0.0011298659956082702, 0.0018691212171688676, 0.01801329292356968, -0.011511720716953278, 0.041604895144701004, -0.011395505629479885, -0.007553961127996445, -0.005794598255306482, -0.023849856108427048, -0.0420181006193161, 0.03272091969847679, 0.0009692636085674167, 0.04467812925577164, -0.011201813817024231, 0.003334718756377697, 0.017316004261374474, 0.015133747830986977, 0.04622766003012657, -0.009936364367604256, 0.03618153557181358, -0.018826795741915703, 0.032023631036281586, -0.025024916976690292, -0.017393479123711586, -0.008754847571253777, -0.01364878099411726, -0.001668973476625979, -0.019072137773036957, -0.032772570848464966, 0.021654687821865082, 0.0061109610833227634, 0.016709104180336, 0.06487368047237396, -0.04302529618144035, 0.004554973915219307, 0.035974934697151184, 0.0234366487711668, 0.00905829668045044, -0.03641396760940552, -0.03179119899868965, -0.013506741262972355, 0.06451211869716644, -0.042999472469091415, 0.055369891226291656, 0.02204207144677639, 0.0294669046998024, 0.001802943297661841, 0.03773106634616852, -0.03047410026192665, 0.018968835473060608, 0.01219609659165144, 0.015301614068448544, 0.03535512089729309, -0.037576112896203995, -0.045272115617990494, -0.016644539311528206, 0.027710771188139915, -0.015237050130963326, -0.03909981995820999, -0.14245350658893585, -0.015650257468223572, -0.016386285424232483, -0.00927781406790018, -0.034554529935121536, -0.022403627634048462, -0.008025276474654675, -0.017225613817572594, -0.017316004261374474, -0.011492351070046425, 0.006817934103310108, -0.009303639642894268, -0.009768498130142689, 0.011995948851108551, 0.0038770544342696667, -0.0065435380674898624, 0.0077799344435334206, -0.009394028224050999, 0.021835466846823692, -0.017664648592472076, 0.004509779624640942, 0.033263254910707474, 0.02383694425225258, 0.0332116037607193, -0.025722205638885498, -0.007992994971573353, 0.01735474169254303, -0.010414136573672295, 0.01514666061848402, 0.04669252038002014, -0.010614284314215183, 0.029492730274796486, -0.02794319950044155, 0.011511720716953278, -0.01049806922674179, -0.021499736234545708, 0.031765375286340714, 0.009510243311524391, -0.03308247774839401, 0.014746365137398243, -0.03708542883396149, 0.016463762149214745, 0.025489777326583862, -0.043309375643730164, -0.017948728054761887, 0.00518124271184206, -0.03574250265955925, -0.01774212345480919, 0.016437936574220657, 0.0026826246175915003, -0.0292603000998497, -0.012402700260281563, -0.058107394725084305, -0.014901318587362766, 0.017109399661421776, 0.006811477709561586, -0.006375672295689583, -0.06451211869716644, -0.0009127703378908336, -0.015353264287114143, -0.014862580224871635, 0.010962928645312786, 0.0012735204072669148, 0.026600273326039314, -0.004839054774492979, -0.006214262917637825, 0.008102753199636936, 0.034941911697387695, 0.028821267187595367, 0.03995206207036972, 0.016644539311528206, 0.00689541082829237, 0.001977265579625964, 0.02907952293753624, -0.0030861482955515385, -0.03669804707169533, -0.019666124135255814, -0.033805590122938156, 0.022752271965146065, -0.017096485942602158, 0.01753552071750164, -0.010646565817296505, 0.01688988320529461, -0.0069083236157894135, 0.021796729415655136, -0.006817934103310108, -0.008432028815150261, 0.00259062135592103, 0.006746914237737656, 0.011259921826422215, -0.0367496982216835, 0.03421879932284355, -0.0004442794597707689, -0.003337946953251958, -0.015120835043489933, 0.00957480724900961, -0.0047454372979700565, 0.06218782439827919, -0.002375946845859289, 0.0020273025147616863, -0.052477434277534485, -0.0024679501075297594, -0.005303913727402687, 0.012744888663291931, -0.02168051339685917, 0.011466525495052338, -0.00400941027328372, 0.0023727186489850283, 0.04635678604245186, 0.01463015004992485, 0.05883050709962845, -0.03388306871056557, -0.0075926994904875755, 0.030809830874204636, 0.04144994169473648, 0.027168434113264084, -0.05748758092522621, 0.028020676225423813, 0.015443653799593449, 0.002840806031599641, 0.005035974085330963, -0.03933224827051163, 0.01605055294930935, -0.027168434113264084, -0.013842472806572914, 0.01402325090020895, 0.020195547491312027, 0.030629053711891174, 0.0007239212864078581, 0.0033863696735352278, -0.015392002649605274, 0.003860913449898362, -0.007657263427972794, -0.01997603103518486, -0.004032007418572903, -0.0007279565325006843, 0.0002449387975502759, 0.0005007727304473519, 0.011950753629207611, -0.018697667866945267, 0.006837303284555674, 0.006395041476935148, 0.0026906952261924744, 0.007657263427972794, 0.030835656449198723, 0.022481104359030724, 0.01276425737887621, -0.0459694042801857, 0.016825318336486816, 0.022364890202879906, -0.0127061503008008, -0.02758164331316948, 0.0059753768146038055, -0.019433695822954178, -0.014798016287386417, -0.01970486342906952, -0.010769236832857132, -0.0026051481254398823, 0.03370228782296181, -0.004622765816748142, -0.010788606479763985, -0.003751154989004135, 0.008470767177641392, -0.003705960465595126, 0.019833991304039955, 0.015249962918460369, 0.006830846890807152, 0.03491608798503876, 0.009387572295963764, -0.001802943297661841, 0.0007166578434407711, 0.006262685637921095, -0.058778855949640274, 0.035794153809547424, 0.0028424200136214495, 0.015611520037055016, -0.039435550570487976, -0.006159383803606033, -0.027039308100938797, -0.022532755509018898, -0.0007009204127825797, 0.02625162899494171, -0.02099613845348358, 0.036723874509334564, 0.010988754220306873, -0.01942078210413456, -0.01097584143280983, -0.011537546291947365, -0.01532743964344263, -0.012893385253846645, 0.006566135678440332, -0.045814450830221176, -0.014823841862380505, -0.047983795404434204, -0.036543093621730804, -0.06724962592124939, 0.020402152091264725, 0.0067533706314861774, -0.027917373925447464, -0.007708914112299681, 0.0021790273021906614, -0.01951117068529129, 0.002710064174607396, 0.029518555849790573, 0.05157354101538658, 0.009497330524027348, -0.021047789603471756, 0.0053135985508561134, -0.003944846335798502, -0.02512821927666664, -0.015727734193205833, 0.02644531987607479, 0.010162337683141232, -0.004119168501347303, 0.006882498040795326, -0.009600632824003696, 0.03809262439608574, 0.020776621997356415, 0.019485346972942352, 0.02091866172850132, -0.0057784575037658215, -0.005739719141274691, 0.013390526175498962, 0.005475007928907871, 0.011382592841982841, 0.0021935540717095137, -0.02073788270354271, 0.03150711953639984, -0.03403801843523979, -0.010026753880083561, 0.007992994971573353, 0.010013841092586517, -0.01566317118704319, 0.04607270658016205, 0.07034868746995926, 0.008993733674287796, -0.009787867777049541, 0.001238817349076271, 0.005155417136847973, -0.05025643855333328, -0.012041143141686916, 0.01734182797372341, -0.03873826190829277, 0.0045582023449242115, -0.017109399661421776, 0.013739170506596565, 0.010885451920330524, 0.03359898552298546, 0.011008122935891151, 0.004341913387179375, -0.018826795741915703, 0.007586243096739054, 0.004703470505774021, -0.006934149190783501, -0.005749403964728117, 0.02446966990828514, -0.021912943571805954, -0.043309375643730164, 0.01867184229195118, -0.03421879932284355, -0.018710581585764885, 0.012589935213327408, 0.0016294281231239438, -0.0047583500854671, -0.004677645396441221, -0.0005637224530801177, -0.0035768328234553337, 0.006278826855123043, 0.042534612119197845, 0.00920033734291792, -0.10567797720432281, 0.012144445441663265, 0.019950205460190773, 0.03248848766088486, 0.018800970166921616, 0.020763708278536797, 0.007399008143693209, 0.04612435773015022, -0.005849477834999561, 0.005239349789917469, -0.004125624895095825, -0.013597129844129086, -0.030913133174180984, 0.025838421657681465, 0.0035348664969205856, -0.03398636728525162, -0.02747834101319313, 0.04191479831933975, -0.02521860972046852, 0.012654499150812626, 0.005520202219486237, 0.027555817738175392, -0.0015430741477757692, 0.03667222335934639, -0.005194155499339104, -0.008289988152682781, -0.006811477709561586, 0.014178204350173473, 0.03122304007411003, -0.013261398300528526, 0.009071209467947483, 0.018516888841986656, -0.005849477834999561, 0.027168434113264084, -0.01651541329920292, -0.033547334372997284, 0.0005834950716234744, 0.01158274058252573, -0.04116585850715637, -0.016747841611504555, -0.04612435773015022, -0.02569638006389141, 0.024056460708379745, 0.015495304949581623, 0.031171388924121857, 0.00225166161544621, 0.001930456724949181, 0.01820698380470276, 0.008141491562128067, 0.016554150730371475, 0.005668699275702238, 0.009303639642894268, 0.0035348664969205856, 0.0018691212171688676, 0.009962189942598343, 0.026406582444906235, 0.002563181798905134, 0.000754992594011128, -0.0005770386778749526, 0.0022565037943422794, -0.05573144555091858, 0.021835466846823692, 0.012906298041343689, -0.040003713220357895, -0.05335550010204315, -0.005152188707143068, -0.06570009142160416, 0.035303469747304916, 0.009684565477073193, -0.03470948338508606, -0.01612802967429161, 0.04390336573123932, 0.01849106326699257, 0.008645089343190193, -0.012861102819442749, 0.012137988582253456, 0.005917269736528397, -0.0003887949569616467, -0.02128021977841854, -0.0021548159420490265, -0.002700379816815257, -0.01562443282455206, 0.0019465977093204856, -0.004571115132421255, -0.01453976146876812, 0.031377993524074554, 0.0004305596521589905, -0.020892836153507233, -0.020389238372445107, 0.01961447298526764, 0.004151450470089912, -0.0047841751947999, 0.032798394560813904, -0.001993406331166625, -0.002763329306617379, -0.002451809123158455, 0.0005237736040726304, -0.021228568628430367, -0.02195168286561966, 0.0012977317674085498, -0.010885451920330524, -0.014113640412688255, -0.018142418935894966, -0.045556195080280304, 0.003087762277573347, -0.021512648090720177, 0.011214726604521275, -0.01059491466730833, -0.0016205506399273872, 0.011537546291947365, 0.026755226776003838, -0.02570929378271103, -0.02897622063755989, 0.02990593947470188, 0.02822728082537651, 0.022093722596764565, 0.01135031133890152, -0.02552851475775242, 0.046382613480091095, 0.023049267008900642, 0.01416529156267643, -0.008315813727676868, -0.048732735216617584, -0.032126933336257935, -0.012725519016385078, -0.01280945260077715, 0.02494744025170803, -0.001069337478838861, 0.0004281385045032948, 0.018646016716957092, 0.013171008788049221, 0.004800316412001848, 0.009981558658182621, -0.007754108868539333, -0.010478699579834938, 0.022377802059054375, -0.007702457718551159, 0.04418744519352913, 0.016644539311528206, 0.02851136028766632, 0.022661883383989334, -0.004968182183802128, -0.002597077749669552, 0.01135031133890152, 0.030499925836920738, 0.002509916666895151, -0.014707626774907112, -0.03711125627160072, 0.011014578863978386, 0.016166768968105316, 0.010846713557839394, -0.013048337772488594, -0.004425846505910158, 0.02691018022596836, -0.002852104604244232, 0.016941534355282784, -0.008735477924346924, -0.014320244081318378, -0.032591789960861206, 0.006708175875246525, 0.013558391481637955, 0.04083012789487839, -0.03093895874917507, 0.009755585342645645, 0.00018461202853359282, 0.030629053711891174, -0.028098152950406075, 0.009193881414830685, -0.019769426435232162, -0.020092245191335678, 0.010272095911204815, -0.06523523479700089, 0.0072182295843958855, 0.01679949276149273, -0.003518725512549281, 0.03561337664723396, -0.010607827454805374, 0.007179491221904755, 0.008457854390144348, 0.002777856308966875, 0.0099492771551013, -0.007792847231030464, -0.03899651765823364, -0.005336195696145296, 0.03228188678622246, -0.0037737523671239614, -0.030138367787003517, 0.006766282953321934, 0.005742947570979595, 0.025760944932699203, -0.0005455638747662306, 0.04635678604245186, 0.013945774175226688, 0.04196644946932793, 0.021538473665714264, 0.03163624927401543, -0.022661883383989334, 0.046021055430173874, -0.030241670086979866, -0.0354325957596302, -0.018426500260829926, -0.005691296420991421, -0.04997235909104347, -0.020040594041347504, -0.01621842011809349, 0.000023227825295180082, -0.019821077585220337, -0.005584766156971455, -0.01660580188035965, -0.035690851509571075, -0.010995210148394108, 0.007586243096739054, 0.020298849791288376, 0.02918282523751259, 0.03491608798503876, -0.04868108406662941, 0.034735307097435, -0.03628483787178993, -0.041785672307014465, -0.019627386704087257, 0.0054685515351593494, -0.026432408019900322, -0.009064753539860249, 0.053613755851984024, -0.018232809379696846, 0.00747648486867547, 0.02054419182240963, -0.023991897702217102, -0.03416714817285538, 0.0153403514996171, 0.03899651765823364, -0.0018465238390490413, 0.003295980393886566, -0.04635678604245186, -0.03303082659840584, -0.01398451253771782, -0.0016641311813145876, -0.02044088952243328, 0.005797826685011387, -0.011995948851108551, 0.02814980410039425, -0.013351787813007832, -0.014798016287386417, -0.002787540899589658, -0.013816647231578827, -0.008574068546295166, 0.03150711953639984, 0.000449928775196895, 0.027271736413240433, 0.020957399159669876, 0.00980723649263382, 0.027994850650429726, -0.007321531418710947, -0.040003713220357895, 0.013674606569111347, -0.011595653370022774, -0.024495495483279228, 0.03439957648515701, 0.02184838056564331, -0.010665934532880783, -0.03424462303519249, 0.020427977666258812, -0.02475374937057495, -0.009310095570981503, 0.005352336447685957, 0.000257649808190763, -0.01781960017979145, 0.005591222550719976, 0.005884987767785788, -0.03783436864614487, -0.015353264287114143, -0.03920312225818634, 0.03238518908619881, -0.013125814497470856, 0.0012081495951861143, 0.02316548116505146, -0.0036962758749723434, -0.0018158560851588845, -0.019356219097971916, 0.03285004571080208, -0.011795801110565662, -0.0009813692886382341, -0.010672391392290592, -0.0023129971232265234, -0.027917373925447464, 0.0072182295843958855, 0.013674606569111347, -0.0030861482955515385, 0.015456566587090492, 0.010420592501759529, -0.00008035163045860827, 0.04124333709478378, 0.02091866172850132, -0.005126363597810268, 0.04589192941784859, -0.0030264267697930336, -0.013351787813007832, 0.011046861298382282, 0.004893933888524771, -0.01083380077034235, -0.00021951681992504746, -0.008386833593249321, 0.02231323905289173, -0.020027682185173035, -0.005261947400867939, -0.006514484528452158, -0.039177294820547104, 0.0052102962508797646, -0.016450848430395126, -0.018646016716957092, 0.024831226095557213, 0.003573604626581073, 0.002532513812184334, -0.007334444206207991, -0.011033948510885239, -0.02121565490961075, -0.01304188184440136, 0.025954635813832283, 0.02851136028766632, -0.009607088752090931, -0.008064014837145805, 0.019446607679128647, 0.028666313737630844, 0.01744513027369976, -0.006533853709697723, -0.0105561763048172, -0.016902795061469078, -0.0016350775258615613, 0.004738980904221535, 0.022532755509018898, 0.017690472304821014, 0.03207528218626976, 0.00405783299356699, -0.023204218596220016, -0.036259014159440994, 0.03179119899868965, 0.032411012798547745, 0.011492351070046425, 0.033521510660648346, -0.009678109548985958, 0.009400485083460808, 0.0248570516705513, -0.004435530863702297, 0.006227175705134869, 0.02205498330295086, 0.015818124637007713, 0.0040384638123214245, -0.008451397530734539, -0.03171372413635254, 0.00032523999107070267, 0.06079324707388878, -0.051831796765327454, 0.007844498381018639, -0.00304902414791286, -0.012047600001096725, 0.0030248125549405813, -0.012363961897790432, 0.04170819744467735, 0.02073788270354271, -0.007760565262287855, -0.019653212279081345, 0.017690472304821014, -0.0190334003418684, 0.022997615858912468, 0.043567631393671036, 0.019575735554099083, -0.03238518908619881, 0.03243684023618698, -0.01209279429167509, -0.0121509013697505, 0.0015406529419124126, -0.0015115992864593863, -0.00829644501209259, 0.008922712877392769, 0.0025534972082823515, -0.033521510660648346, 0.004709926899522543, -0.011989491991698742, -0.005797826685011387, 0.026096675544977188, -0.00025361456209793687, 0.007637894246727228, -0.019343305379152298, 0.0041611348278820515, -0.018839707598090172, -0.01341635175049305, -0.006998712662607431, 0.04878438636660576, 0.009180968627333641, -0.011705411598086357, 0.02129313163459301, -0.010439962148666382, 0.0010314062237739563, -0.023707816377282143, -0.03114556334912777, 0.006624242756515741, 0.0025486547965556383, 0.017470955848693848, 0.01135031133890152, 0.0008546629105694592, 0.004022323060780764, -0.007431290112435818, -0.010911277495324612, -0.01031729020178318, -0.0017722755437716842, 0.014216942712664604, 0.04813874885439873, 0.0558863990008831, 0.029389427974820137, 0.003441249020397663, 0.007043907418847084, -0.022920139133930206, -0.05526658892631531, 0.02175799012184143, 0.034192971885204315, -0.00288600055500865, -0.02100905030965805, 0.015353264287114143, -0.012628673575818539, -0.019472433254122734, -0.023707816377282143, 0.009413397870957851, -0.02168051339685917, 0.004325772635638714, -0.024973265826702118, 0.012673867866396904, -0.02007933333516121, 0.011324485763907433, -0.012454351410269737, -0.015249962918460369, -0.0029344232752919197, 0.0196919497102499, -0.009968645870685577, 0.026109589263796806, -0.02560599148273468, 0.012273572385311127, 0.008341639302670956, 0.012376874685287476, -0.023488299921154976, 0.029415253549814224, -0.006985799875110388, 0.0015003005973994732, 0.026148326694965363, 0.04266373813152313, 0.0034799871500581503, -0.012202552519738674, -0.00534910848364234, -0.0053232829086482525, 0.025773856788873672, 0.009865344502031803, -0.00597860524430871, 0.008922712877392769, -0.00043419134453870356, 0.010013841092586517, 0.020040594041347504, 0.0026019199285656214, -0.009394028224050999, -0.02063458040356636, -0.009787867777049541, -0.013480915687978268, 0.014681801199913025, 0.010749868117272854, 0.023204218596220016, -0.003922249190509319, -0.011453612707555294, 0.04896516352891922, 0.022442366927862167, -0.03181702643632889, -0.010013841092586517, -0.037007953971624374, 0.04297364503145218, -0.00007339084550039843, 0.004293490666896105, -0.013442177325487137, -0.010007384233176708, -0.013119358569383621, 0.01855562813580036, -0.012757801450788975, 0.0019030171679332852, 0.04083012789487839, -0.013151640072464943, 0.005884987767785788, 0.028950395062565804, 0.015056271106004715, 0.02421141415834427, 0.0024679501075297594, 0.009878257289528847, -0.02589007280766964, 0.02439219318330288, 0.013403438962996006, 0.014061989262700081, 0.019627386704087257, -0.01069821696728468, -0.027994850650429726, -0.010956471785902977, -0.022171199321746826, -0.023010527715086937, -0.009787867777049541, 0.005746175535023212, -0.00774119608104229, 0.0016576747875660658, -0.018878446891903877, -0.0016350775258615613, 0.011053317226469517, 0.020867010578513145, 0.007760565262287855, -0.020027682185173035, -0.021628864109516144, 0.0003147483803331852, 0.025644728913903236, 0.010878995060920715, -0.0018642789218574762, -0.015275788493454456, 0.0005213524564169347, 0.041888974606990814, -0.01876223273575306, -0.018968835473060608, -0.02334626019001007, -0.030164193361997604, 0.015534043312072754, -0.02072497084736824, -0.030809830874204636, 0.007857411168515682, -0.004897161852568388, -0.018064942210912704, -0.029027871787548065, -0.004829369951039553, 0.004464584868401289, -0.0007045521633699536, 0.01097584143280983, -0.013125814497470856, -0.023191306740045547, 0.009703935123980045, 0.007986538112163544, -0.029286125674843788, -0.012867559678852558, 0.0017399935750290751, -0.0030151281971484423, 0.034296274185180664, -0.01087253913283348, -0.00839329045265913, 0.00801882054656744, 0.0005968113546259701, 0.001668973476625979, 0.02128021977841854, 0.03445122763514519, 0.027090957388281822, -0.035122692584991455, -0.023862769827246666, -0.0020741112530231476, -0.0015519516309723258, -0.04336102679371834, -0.01754843257367611, 0.013764996081590652, -0.0026277455035597086, 0.00356392003595829, 0.04015866667032242, 0.011479438282549381, 0.00984597485512495, 0.007960712537169456, 0.009858887642621994, -0.008005907759070396, -0.011963666416704655, 0.03873826190829277, 0.0024727925192564726, 0.02409520000219345, 0.0006730773020535707, 0.001196043798699975, -0.024702098220586777, 0.0075604175217449665, 0.043567631393671036, 0.00255511119030416, -0.0020870238076895475, 0.001573741901665926, 0.008922712877392769, 0.015701908618211746, 0.006278826855123043, -0.028201455250382423, 0.004845511168241501, 0.01611511781811714, -0.02635493129491806, -0.036543093621730804, 0.018052030354738235, -0.03525181859731674, -0.020001856610178947, 0.017897076904773712, -0.02869213931262493, -0.020415063947439194, -0.0461760088801384, 0.011828082613646984, 0.00405783299356699, -0.016205506399273872, 0.027607468888163567, 0.018465237691998482, 0.0002737907343544066, 0.03778271749615669, 0.024534232914447784, 0.013907035812735558, -0.02729756198823452, 0.006959974300116301, -0.034554529935121536, 0.04640843719244003, -0.015921425074338913, -0.033805590122938156, -0.011356767266988754, -0.014643062837421894, 0.042069751769304276, -0.03163624927401543, -0.008774216286838055, 0.01811659336090088, -0.009361746720969677, 0.025102393701672554, 0.00938111636787653, 0.020789533853530884, 0.001133094192482531, -0.010285008698701859, 0.007334444206207991, 0.004115940537303686, -0.01931747980415821, -0.019808165729045868, 0.01893009804189205, -0.028485536575317383, -0.004177276045084, -0.004697014112025499, 0.024172676727175713, 0.02521860972046852, -0.0010887065436691046, -0.0198985543102026, 0.033263254910707474, 0.0063530751504004, 0.04183732345700264, 0.005646101664751768, 0.01840067468583584, 0.006650068331509829, -0.017303090542554855, 0.02889874391257763, 0.01420402992516756, 0.03161042183637619, -0.0292603000998497, 0.034657832235097885, 0.01707066036760807, 0.02344956248998642, 0.013468002900481224, -0.010730498470366001, -0.002187097677960992, -0.025851333513855934, -0.023875681683421135, 0.014010338112711906, 0.019588647410273552, -0.007702457718551159, 0.01576647348701954, -0.006921236403286457, -0.0024227555841207504, 0.005839793011546135, 0.010569089092314243, 0.021525561809539795, -0.03445122763514519, 0.012906298041343689, 0.0010418978054076433, 0.0021548159420490265, 0.0025034602731466293, 0.04382588714361191, -0.009038927964866161, 0.024430930614471436, -0.014746365137398243, -0.0013179079396650195, -0.012673867866396904, 0.013971599750220776, -0.000610531133133918, 0.031300514936447144, -0.034554529935121536, 0.015585694462060928, 0.007237598765641451, 0.0011758676264435053, 0.012176726944744587, 0.0025680239778012037, 0.005923726130276918, -0.011104968376457691, 0.03744698688387871, 0.01120827067643404, 0.013216204009950161, -0.03801514953374863, -0.0085288742557168, 0.040571872144937515, -0.000035711836972041056, -0.00230008433572948, 0.018878446891903877, 0.00027863302966579795, -0.023966072127223015, -0.020027682185173035, 0.014488110318779945, -0.045762799680233, 0.011421331204473972, -0.0021580441389232874, -0.023217132315039635, 0.021357694640755653, -0.013287223875522614, 0.008877518586814404, -0.01874931901693344, -0.003123272443190217, 0.015430741012096405, 0.002377560827881098, -0.031171388924121857, 0.030448274686932564, 0.01774212345480919, 0.014191117137670517, 0.006085135508328676, 0.007263424340635538, 0.02869213931262493, 0.02211954817175865, -0.009193881414830685, -0.001326785539276898, -0.001520476769655943, 0.004061060957610607, 0.004881021101027727, 0.039616331458091736, 0.0079736253246665, -0.02196459472179413, -0.035690851509571075, -0.019214177504181862, 0.014010338112711906, 0.04963662847876549, -0.0003561095509212464, 0.02521860972046852, -0.02897622063755989, -0.05030808970332146, 0.014694713987410069, 0.014810929074883461, -0.009774954989552498, -0.027323387563228607, 0.024495495483279228, -0.0015793911879882216, 0.03486443683505058, 0.0014050690224394202, 0.01552113052457571, 0.0075604175217449665, -0.017044834792613983, 0.0002600709267426282, -0.01743221841752529 ]
12.266723
3.612775
2024-07-01
1
2024A&A...687A.150S
[ "narrow redshift bins", "photometric redshift errors", "modified Lorentzian photometric redshift errors", "redshift", "divided galaxies", "bin mismatch", "tomographic cross-correlation measurements", "galaxy clustering", "angular power spectra", "tomographic bins" ]
[ "gravitational lensing: weak", "methods: numerical", "cosmic background radiation", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
8
[ "10.1051/0004-6361/202348732", "10.48550/arXiv.2311.15261" ]
[ "Shekhar Saraf, Chandra", "Bielewicz, Paweł" ]
[ "Nicolaus Copernicus Astronomical Centre, Polish Academy of Sciences, ul. Bartycka 18, Warsaw, 00-716, Poland ; Korea Astronomy and Space Science Institute, 776 Daedeok-daero, Yuseong-gu, Daejeon, 34055, Republic of Korea", "National Centre for Nuclear Research, ul. L. Pasteura 7, Warsaw, 02-093, Poland" ]
[ "2024arXiv240602857S" ]
[ "1953ApJ...117..134L", "1993ApJ...413..447F", "1996ApJ...461L..65F", "1998MNRAS.299...95M", "2000ApJ...538..473L", "2002AJ....124.1810S", "2002ApJ...567....2H", "2005ApJ...622..759G", "2005MNRAS.359..237P", "2005PhRvD..72d3529L", "2006AJ....131.2332G", "2007PhRvL..99n1302Z", "2009arXiv0912.0201L", "2009woin.book.....M", "2010AJ....140.1868W", "2010MNRAS.403.2137S", "2010MNRAS.405..359Z", "2011arXiv1110.3193L", "2013PASP..125..306F", "2013arXiv1305.5422S", "2014ApJS..210....9B", "2014arXiv1412.4872D", "2015A&A...582A..58S", "2015A&A...582A..62D", "2015ApJ...802...64B", "2016ApJ...825...24B", "2016MNRAS.456.2806B", "2016MNRAS.456.3213G", "2016MNRAS.459.3693X", "2016MNRAS.460.4098P", "2017ApJ...848...44Z", "2017MNRAS.464.2120S", "2018ApJ...862...81B", "2018MNRAS.476.1050B", "2018MNRAS.479.3422A", "2018MNRAS.481.1133P", "2018PhRvD..98d3526A", "2019AJ....157..168D", "2019ApJ...873..111I", "2019ApJS..240...30S", "2019PASJ...71...43H", "2019PhRvD.100b3541A", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020A&A...641A...8P", "2021A&A...646A.140H", "2021A&A...649A.146R", "2021MNRAS.500.2250D", "2021MNRAS.501.1481H", "2022MNRAS.511.3548S", "2022MNRAS.513.1887Y", "2022MNRAS.515.1993S", "2022PhRvD.106d3520P", "2022PhRvL.129f1301M", "2023MNRAS.523.3001W", "2023PhRvD.107b3530C" ]
29163271
2406.18281
Radio continuum emission from a tidal dwarf galaxy
Tidal dwarf galaxies (TDGs) form in the debris of galaxy mergers, making them ideal testbeds for investigating star formation in an extreme environment. We present radio continuum EVLA observations spanning 1-2 GHz of the interacting system Arp 94, which contains the TDG J1023+1952. We detect extended radio continuum emission from the disc of the TDG's putative parent galaxy, the spiral NGC 3227. The TDG lies in front of the spiral disc, partially overlapping in projection. This challenging alignment complicates the separation of the respective contributions of radio emission from the TDG and disc. However, we show that the radio continuum appears more prominent around the TDG's location, suggesting the detection of emission from the TDG. Quantifying this argument, we derive an upper limit of 2.2 mJy for the whole TDG's emission. Our derived inband spectral index map of the system generally shows the expected behaviour of combined thermal and synchrotron radio emission in a galaxy disc, except for a region at the periphery of the disc and the TDG with a flat spectrum (spectral index $\sim$-0.4) unrelated to regions with high H $\alpha$ emission. We speculate that at this location - which coincides with the intersection of faint tidal tails - the collision of gas clouds produces shocks which re-accelerate cosmic ray electrons, and thereby enhance the radio emission. Overall, this study provides new insights about the Arp 94 system and expands the sample of TDGs studied at radio frequencies, with only two confirmed detections so far.
[ -0.009668302722275257, -0.010011517442762852, 0.030073408037424088, -0.0012312029721215367, -0.029063189402222633, 0.05755651369690895, -0.02292417362332344, 0.005086706019937992, -0.0227299015969038, 0.010231693275272846, -0.03268961235880852, 0.015787892043590546, -0.023455185815691948, -0.038155149668455124, 0.018067358061671257, 0.021162768825888634, -0.022302500903606415, -0.027975263074040413, 0.008120597340166569, 0.057919155806303024, -0.029581250622868538, -0.00332206254824996, -0.013534328900277615, 0.0026194429956376553, 0.006268531084060669, -0.040771353989839554, -0.020735368132591248, 0.052039168775081635, 0.004963666666299105, -0.017614055424928665, 0.006754213012754917, -0.021318186074495316, -0.043439365923404694, -0.017911938950419426, -0.04178157448768616, 0.07848615199327469, 0.025618087500333786, -0.012951510958373547, -0.04846455156803131, -0.026291565969586372, -0.00965535081923008, 0.025812361389398575, -0.05424092710018158, 0.02094259299337864, 0.00009506206697551534, -0.02401209995150566, -0.022302500903606415, 0.00238307798281312, 0.012478780932724476, -0.023157300427556038, 0.016422515735030174, 0.07071524858474731, -0.013035695068538189, 0.027146365493535995, -0.048930808901786804, -0.03629013150930405, -0.0066959308460354805, 0.044242359697818756, 0.008288966491818428, -0.04786878451704979, -0.04846455156803131, -0.009713632985949516, 0.021085059270262718, -0.0340883769094944, -0.020476337522268295, -0.013301201164722443, -0.0030630321707576513, 0.03300045058131218, 0.054810792207717896, 0.009694205597043037, -0.016383660957217216, -0.04219602048397064, -0.016590885818004608, -0.038310568779706955, 0.040978580713272095, -0.020735368132591248, -0.026706015691161156, -0.03812924772500992, -0.037326253950595856, -0.021318186074495316, 0.0365750677883625, -0.013223492540419102, -0.03165349364280701, 0.006592318881303072, 0.008586851879954338, 0.0031277898233383894, 0.0070715248584747314, 0.011209532618522644, -0.019699247553944588, 0.01106706541031599, 0.036393746733665466, -0.008211257867515087, 0.004526552744209766, 0.0008232304244302213, -0.002428408246487379, -0.053774673491716385, 0.021162768825888634, -0.020916689187288284, 0.0825270265340805, -0.004316091071814299, 0.0037300351541489363, 0.0331040620803833, 0.00002658601079019718, -0.06071668118238449, 0.05833360552787781, 0.002624299842864275, 0.030461953952908516, 0.020282065495848656, -0.004183338023722172, 0.00027501722797751427, 0.026498790830373764, 0.0070197186432778835, 0.030306534841656685, 0.07154414802789688, -0.006993815768510103, -0.002258419757708907, -0.016383660957217216, 0.03219745680689812, 0.0007722338195890188, -0.005786087363958359, -0.023403380066156387, 0.02984028123319149, -0.012265080586075783, 0.0026825815439224243, 0.02430998533964157, 0.025501525029540062, 0.029710765928030014, -0.062167249619960785, -0.030954111367464066, 0.04766155779361725, 0.036782290786504745, -0.012828471139073372, -0.0010595954954624176, 0.01753634586930275, -0.04921574145555496, -0.03180890902876854, 0.006093685980886221, -0.02355879731476307, -0.009622972458600998, 0.022419065237045288, 0.01600806787610054, -0.0011178773129358888, 0.02193985879421234, 0.019375460222363472, 0.014661110006272793, 0.005993311759084463, -0.04763565585017204, 0.018158018589019775, -0.009098436683416367, 0.02050224132835865, 0.00943517591804266, -0.002402505138888955, 0.026006633415818214, -0.034010667353868484, 0.0010636427905410528, -0.022846464067697525, -0.01792488992214203, 0.026200905442237854, -0.013391861692070961, -0.07118150591850281, -0.04861997067928314, -0.016526127234101295, -0.019388411194086075, 0.05993959307670593, -0.03393295779824257, 0.02350699156522751, -0.0017257888102903962, 0.007563682273030281, -0.08206076920032501, -0.0069873398169875145, -0.04030510038137436, -0.011863583698868752, -0.027586717158555984, -0.005161176901310682, -0.018339339643716812, 0.0002555899554863572, 0.010516626760363579, -0.038310568779706955, -0.00826953910291195, -0.009195572696626186, -0.01348252221941948, 0.012200322933495045, 0.05266084149479866, -0.03434740751981735, -0.05009644478559494, 0.008683987893164158, -0.010782132856547832, -0.007337030954658985, -0.019945327192544937, -0.01183120533823967, -0.0015031846705824137, 0.0331040620803833, 0.04709169268608093, 0.041522543877363205, -0.024297034367918968, -0.001843971316702664, 0.00015582286869175732, 0.028389710932970047, -0.02495756186544895, -0.0005884842830710113, 0.07693197578191757, 0.008748745545744896, -0.007129806559532881, -0.046210989356040955, -0.08314869552850723, -0.056934840977191925, 0.024685578420758247, 0.02357175014913082, 0.009001299738883972, -0.02464672550559044, 0.05605413764715195, -0.0008244445780292153, -0.011585126630961895, 0.0040408712811768055, -0.03665277361869812, 0.012193847447633743, -0.00330425426363945, 0.015671327710151672, 0.062167249619960785, -0.017847182229161263, 0.0035033836029469967, 0.04551160708069801, -0.0009907905478030443, 0.032534193247556686, -0.006472517270594835, 0.009674778208136559, 0.033518508076667786, -0.04921574145555496, 0.04820552095770836, 0.03191252052783966, 0.0013429097598418593, -0.004503887612372637, -0.02405095472931862, -0.03942439705133438, 0.011552747339010239, 0.02831200137734413, 0.0043970379047095776, 0.030617371201515198, 0.0035033836029469967, -0.03349260613322258, -0.014466837048530579, 0.005015472415834665, 0.008023460395634174, 0.015179170295596123, -0.048386842012405396, -0.004371135029941797, -0.024879852309823036, -0.020566998049616814, 0.03486546501517296, 0.02652469463646412, 0.024698531255126, 0.029762571677565575, -0.007589585147798061, 0.003467767033725977, 0.005737519357353449, -0.01101525966078043, -0.02039862982928753, 0.01254353765398264, -0.08185354620218277, 0.010820986703038216, 0.03147217258810997, 0.00946107879281044, -0.04110809415578842, 0.012070807628333569, -0.044242359697818756, 0.04437187686562538, 0.0296330563724041, -0.039942458271980286, -0.025475621223449707, 0.01665564253926277, -0.03957981616258621, -0.04628869891166687, 0.0316275879740715, -0.012103186920285225, -0.022613337263464928, 0.01481652818620205, -0.007524827495217323, 0.013547279872000217, 0.06045765057206154, -0.01709599420428276, 0.002757052890956402, 0.02113686501979828, 0.01832638680934906, -0.015645425766706467, -0.04020148888230324, -0.007861566729843616, -0.03478775918483734, -0.00990790594369173, -0.0037106077652424574, 0.0002719817275647074, 0.09356171637773514, 0.008373151533305645, 0.04525257647037506, -0.022535627707839012, -0.0296330563724041, -0.01595626026391983, 0.06377323716878891, 0.02143475040793419, -0.03294864296913147, -0.03566845878958702, 0.01813211478292942, 0.05032956972718239, 0.0114815142005682, -0.010613762773573399, -0.020735368132591248, 0.031057722866535187, 0.037870217114686966, 0.033958859741687775, -0.02875235304236412, 0.02554037980735302, 0.000200849593966268, -0.021499507129192352, -0.027483105659484863, 0.019997132942080498, -0.04955248162150383, 0.009972663596272469, 0.010212265886366367, 0.05947333574295044, 0.07801990211009979, -0.03434740751981735, -0.020968494936823845, -0.028778256848454475, -0.008910639211535454, 0.01378040760755539, 0.02227659896016121, -0.014648158103227615, 0.022561531513929367, -0.021072108298540115, -0.031005917116999626, 0.01435027364641428, 0.036678679287433624, 0.013417765498161316, 0.06563825905323029, 0.04172976687550545, 0.016267096623778343, -0.03592748939990997, 0.0013752885861322284, 0.055846914649009705, -0.030410146340727806, 0.010017993859946728, -0.004685209132730961, 0.009363941848278046, 0.012588867917656898, 0.0061972979456186295, -0.017821278423070908, 0.03147217258810997, -0.01150741707533598, -0.024685578420758247, 0.04906032234430313, 0.009564690291881561, -0.035254012793302536, -0.027949359267950058, 0.001587369479238987, -0.02633042074739933, 0.014984898269176483, -0.04929345101118088, 0.01848180592060089, -0.02890777215361595, -0.014415031298995018, 0.025074124336242676, -0.008094694465398788, -0.02989208698272705, 0.02336452528834343, 0.010678520426154137, 0.007790333591401577, 0.042170118540525436, -0.028286099433898926, 0.042455051094293594, -0.01571018248796463, -0.061079323291778564, 0.019984180107712746, 0.06346239894628525, 0.007893946021795273, 0.04553751274943352, -0.05465537682175636, -0.004471509251743555, 0.05058860033750534, -0.028519226238131523, 0.010095702484250069, 0.01763995736837387, 0.0513915941119194, -0.04237734153866768, 0.008696939796209335, -0.025372009724378586, -0.009668302722275257, 0.032482389360666275, -0.01986761763691902, -0.04237734153866768, -0.06693340837955475, 0.009312136098742485, -0.010898696258664131, -0.02722407504916191, 0.0005451776669360697, 0.016733352094888687, -0.055898718535900116, -0.018054405227303505, -0.001743597094900906, 0.026939142495393753, 0.00665707653388381, 0.08656789362430573, -0.003315586829558015, -0.024711482226848602, -0.04786878451704979, -0.05605413764715195, -0.005229172296822071, 0.013624989427626133, 0.015697231516242027, 0.09169669449329376, 0.011021735146641731, -0.05771193280816078, 0.03527991473674774, -0.014958994463086128, 0.031446266919374466, -0.012932083569467068, 0.0056759994477033615, 0.03305225446820259, -0.02633042074739933, 0.0276644267141819, -0.04123761132359505, 0.034010667353868484, -0.0024947847705334425, 0.021162768825888634, 0.011811777949333191, -0.014220758341252804, -0.05393008887767792, -0.005620955489575863, -0.013586134649813175, 0.05102895200252533, 0.02411571331322193, -0.03991655632853508, 0.0007090952130965889, 0.029477639123797417, -0.019284799695014954, -0.014013534411787987, 0.014920140616595745, 0.0001451985735911876, 0.01769176311790943, -0.0016885532531887293, -0.03719673678278923, -0.002446216531097889, -0.006708882749080658, 0.0133400559425354, 0.021408846601843834, -0.01862427219748497, 0.023183204233646393, 0.018404096364974976, 0.02831200137734413, 0.026097293943166733, 0.030254729092121124, -0.04061593860387802, 0.005141749512404203, -0.005973884370177984, -0.008884736336767673, 0.022975979372859, -0.00826953910291195, -0.0076867216266691685, 0.010730326175689697, -0.0070197186432778835, -0.0031342655420303345, -0.02836380898952484, 0.019984180107712746, -0.026110244914889336, -0.03818105161190033, -0.004377610515803099, -0.04812781512737274, -0.0002062123385258019, 0.018365241587162018, 0.0375334769487381, 0.011766447685658932, 0.007045621983706951, 0.014557497575879097, -0.05076992139220238, -0.0018115926068276167, -0.005876747891306877, -0.001920061418786645, 0.01980285905301571, 0.005601528566330671, -0.02994389273226261, 0.03167939558625221, -0.000843467132654041, 0.018961012363433838, -0.00155256234575063, 0.009415748529136181, 0.0058540827594697475, 0.021123914048075676, 0.042221926152706146, -0.03245648741722107, 0.009985614567995071, 0.0006107446970418096, 0.0004205193545203656, -0.014596352353692055, -0.0074276914820075035, 0.040486421436071396, -0.01336595881730318, 0.042455051094293594, 0.004507125820964575, -0.01841704733669758, -0.01108649279922247, 0.048050105571746826, -0.010704423300921917, 0.020489290356636047, 0.0345805324614048, 0.07289110124111176, 0.008489714935421944, 0.03191252052783966, 0.06465394049882889, -0.02820838987827301, -0.011552747339010239, -0.003946973010897636, -0.030306534841656685, -0.001970248529687524, 0.02223774418234825, 0.008204782381653786, -0.011118872091174126, 0.01734207198023796, -0.030746886506676674, -0.05439634621143341, 0.03230106830596924, 0.011552747339010239, -0.006980864331126213, 0.017627006396651268, -0.03823285922408104, -0.00261296727694571, 0.03719673678278923, 0.00047880117199383676, -0.006614984013140202, -0.015075558796525002, -0.07278749346733093, -0.061079323291778564, 0.008560949005186558, 0.008133548311889172, -0.011358474381268024, 0.015839697793126106, 0.025605136528611183, -0.036393746733665466, -0.026809627190232277, -0.03426969796419144, 0.009849623776972294, -0.03587568551301956, -0.007032670080661774, 0.0007354029803536832, 0.00005352616426534951, -0.022561531513929367, -0.017652908340096474, 0.05506982281804085, 0.04634050652384758, -0.03577207401394844, -0.015075558796525002, 0.03364802524447441, 0.028881868347525597, 0.0355648472905159, -0.02513888292014599, 0.011986623518168926, 0.03390705585479736, -0.020916689187288284, 0.016629740595817566, 0.009525836445391178, -0.010192838497459888, 0.018002599477767944, -0.047402527183294296, -0.05074401944875717, -0.005627431441098452, 0.00760901253670454, -0.0006042689201422036, -0.004070012364536524, -0.006624697707593441, -0.01146208681166172, 0.010756229981780052, -0.035590752959251404, 0.025410864502191544, -0.01133904792368412, -0.03289683535695076, -0.00845086108893156, -0.02594187669456005, 0.007006767205893993, -0.027975263074040413, -0.01684991456568241, 0.026123197749257088, 0.029917988926172256, -0.00041262703598476946, -0.029270414263010025, -0.018805593252182007, 0.03434740751981735, 0.04377610608935356, -0.03256009891629219, 0.019375460222363472, 0.003548713866621256, 0.0059674084186553955, 0.022393161430954933, -0.025579232722520828, -0.010956978425383568, -0.012414023280143738, 0.0049150981940329075, 0.007544254884123802, -0.016228243708610535, -0.0340883769094944, 0.005481726955622435, 0.013573182746767998, -0.001793784205801785, -0.014570449478924274, -0.005850845016539097, 0.017121898010373116, -0.023105494678020477, -0.02504822239279747, -0.004086201544851065, -0.004788821097463369, 0.006336526479572058, -0.00621348712593317, -0.010108654387295246, -0.0009203667286783457, 0.01469996478408575, 0.0019443455385044217, -0.031446266919374466, -0.014259613119065762, -0.025359058752655983, -0.019789908081293106, -0.023481089621782303, 0.012627722695469856, 0.00899482425302267, 0.009376893751323223, -0.029114995151758194, -0.02890777215361595, 0.005679237190634012, -0.027897553518414497, 0.00238307798281312, 0.027690330520272255, -0.009914381429553032, -0.01635775715112686, -0.03284503147006035, -0.009227951057255268, -0.001304864650592208, -0.008897688239812851, 0.059007082134485245, 0.038802724331617355, -0.014505691826343536, -0.026252711191773415, -0.008133548311889172, 0.03235287219285965, -0.03810334578156471, -0.02548857219517231, 0.0017581675201654434, 0.014104194939136505, 0.04312853142619133, -0.004675495438277721, 0.0030015124939382076, 0.00899482425302267, -0.030202923342585564, 0.012815520167350769, -0.02805297262966633, -0.0041056289337575436, -0.00018000576528720558, 0.0004138412477914244, 0.04670314863324165, 0.024815093725919724, 0.019375460222363472, 0.017769472673535347, -0.011850631795823574, 0.007900421507656574, -0.04659953713417053, 0.051547013223171234, -0.026343373581767082, -0.003150454955175519, 0.01876673847436905, 0.003694418352097273, -0.023325670510530472, 0.021525410935282707, 0.022613337263464928, 0.007712624501436949, -0.038362376391887665, 0.013741552829742432, 0.06874661892652512, -0.02039862982928753, 0.022937124595046043, 0.013624989427626133, 0.03476185351610184, -0.03616061806678772, 0.0001480317150708288, -0.042506858706474304, -0.022198889404535294, 0.013456619344651699, 0.01690172217786312, 0.028130680322647095, -0.019686296582221985, -0.014194855466485023, -0.035642556846141815, -0.017873084172606468, 0.013430716469883919, 0.021901004016399384, 0.01985466666519642, 0.0027084846515208483, 0.011151250451803207, -0.007434166967868805, 0.025514476001262665, 0.024426549673080444, 0.001465139677748084, -0.015917407348752022, -0.01324291992932558, -0.022004617378115654, 0.0020787175744771957, -0.03380344435572624, 0.005452585872262716, 0.04061593860387802, 0.002871997421607375, 0.0005528675974346697, -0.01331415306776762, -0.004601024091243744, 0.038750920444726944, -0.026835530996322632, 0.03230106830596924, -0.00026975569198839366, 0.044734518975019455, 0.007518352009356022, -0.014958994463086128, -0.006093685980886221, 0.000852371274959296, -0.007673770189285278, -0.0034774804953485727, 0.024141615256667137, -0.03201613575220108, -0.0014813289744779468, 0.025061173364520073, 0.03724854439496994, -0.028286099433898926, -0.03230106830596924, 0.02519068866968155, -0.04263637214899063, -0.0025125930551439524, 0.0018213061848655343, -0.02638222649693489, -0.0296330563724041, 0.0002118786214850843, -0.012485256418585777, -0.008340773172676563, -0.008392578922212124, -0.018248679116368294, 0.044838130474090576, 0.0007123330724425614, -0.005828179884701967, -0.002755433786660433, 0.047350723296403885, 0.012925608083605766, -0.015114412643015385, -0.01326234731823206, 0.005196793470531702, 0.014389128424227238, 0.020087793469429016, 0.03644555062055588, -0.01743273250758648, 0.0019751053769141436, 0.0002029744500759989, 0.020722417160868645, 0.011300193145871162, 0.03711903095245361, -0.032042037695646286, 0.0074600703082978725, -0.01743273250758648, 0.05022595822811127, 0.015412298031151295, -0.012679529376327991, 0.0003033486718777567, 0.03087640181183815, -0.0163059514015913, -0.024465404450893402, 0.012206798419356346, -0.005157939158380032, -0.0003193356969859451, -0.044035136699676514, 0.01604692079126835, 0.017329121008515358, 0.012012526392936707, -0.060043204575777054, 0.013132832013070583, 0.016513176262378693, -0.0034159610513597727, 0.037766605615615845, 0.014013534411787987, -0.017950793728232384, 0.01185710821300745, 0.013042171485722065, 0.0064077600836753845, -0.006398046389222145, -0.03942439705133438, -0.032974544912576675, -0.0023474614135921, 0.004581596702337265, 0.014971946366131306, -0.0001583524572197348, 0.034554630517959595, 0.015256879851222038, -0.009849623776972294, -0.0143243707716465, -0.007803285028785467, -0.0053522116504609585, 0.0192588958889246, 0.043594785034656525, 0.013909921981394291, -0.009474029764533043, -0.11293717473745346, -0.002770004328340292, 0.02346813678741455, 0.010924599133431911, -0.0016213672934100032, 0.03217155113816261, 0.05211687833070755, 0.01936250925064087, 0.009124339558184147, 0.013702698051929474, 0.0031342655420303345, -0.017950793728232384, 0.009279757738113403, -0.018106210976839066, 0.003257304895669222, -0.013534328900277615, -0.008735793642699718, -0.008042887784540653, 0.006061307154595852, 0.011008784174919128, 0.004989569541066885, 0.05004463717341423, 0.015969213098287582, 0.011092969216406345, -0.009266805835068226, -0.00896892137825489, -0.007213991601020098, -0.01054900512099266, 0.01906462386250496, 0.001150256022810936, 0.031135432422161102, -0.015684278681874275, 0.004639878869056702, 0.07004176825284958, -0.03201613575220108, -0.03670458123087883, 0.011999574489891529, 0.008360200561583042, -0.011248387396335602, 0.02243201620876789, 0.019504975527524948, -0.01951792649924755, 0.023986198008060455, 0.025035269558429718, 0.005666285753250122, -0.014855382964015007, -0.03812924772500992, -0.013624989427626133, 0.02039862982928753, 0.0013987631537020206, 0.007809760980308056, 0.015490006655454636, 0.001876350142993033, 0.024245228618383408, -0.023377476260066032, -0.014168952591717243, 0.027819843962788582, 0.0014311419799923897, -0.014466837048530579, -0.012284507974982262, -0.020463386550545692, 0.010697947815060616, 0.01887035183608532, -0.029917988926172256, -0.043102625757455826, -0.023791925981640816, -0.010976404882967472, 0.011740544810891151, 0.003307492006570101, -0.031057722866535187, 0.006903155241161585, -0.020579950883984566, -0.0069873398169875145, 0.026058439165353775, 0.022755803540349007, 0.008023460395634174, -0.062063638120889664, 0.011656359769403934, -0.02870054729282856, 0.03033243864774704, -0.006903155241161585, 0.013016268610954285, 0.01995827816426754, 0.014427983202040195, 0.04390561953186989, 0.011656359769403934, -0.010277023538947105, -0.0034839564468711615, 0.008955969475209713, -0.0005144178285263479, 0.015567716211080551, -0.017083043232560158, -0.0028800922445952892, 0.000008366625479538925, -0.012478780932724476, 0.030902303755283356, -0.0026761058252304792, -0.02203051932156086, 0.0042707608081400394, -0.01897396333515644, 0.0024429787881672382, -0.013987631537020206, -0.05667581036686897, -0.017121898010373116, 0.03823285922408104, -0.026006633415818214, 0.0014287135563790798, 0.028778256848454475, -0.00012152159615652636, -0.0004334708792157471, 0.0464182123541832, 0.0375334769487381, 0.006245865952223539, 0.0009721727692522109, 0.04564112424850464, -0.011293717660009861, -0.004610737785696983, -0.006239390466362238, -0.00913729052990675, -0.014311418868601322, 0.01380631048232317, 0.01738092675805092, -0.0518578477203846, -0.010950502008199692, 0.013819261454045773, -0.03616061806678772, -0.009033679030835629, -0.050510890781879425, -0.015049654990434647, -0.00575370853766799, 0.029581250622868538, -0.029866183176636696, 0.011526844464242458, -0.0010069799609482288, 0.019479071721434593, -0.002693914109840989, 0.0016027494566515088, 0.07967769354581833, -0.002876854268833995, 0.03911356255412102, -0.017458636313676834, -0.018196873366832733, 0.015153267420828342, -0.006096923723816872, -0.011870059184730053, 0.0005613670218735933, 0.007382361218333244, -0.027793942019343376, 0.04564112424850464, 0.00993380881845951, -0.017510442063212395, 0.017212558537721634, -0.004005254711955786, 0.026291565969586372, 0.014233710244297981, 0.02292417362332344, -0.008308393880724907, 0.05942153185606003, -0.02376602217555046, 0.010775656439363956, 0.0444495864212513, 0.04175566881895065, -0.012044904753565788, -0.02617500349879265, 0.03486546501517296, -0.01640956476330757, -0.023235009983181953, -0.014039437286555767, -0.018145065754652023, -0.033181771636009216, -0.031239043921232224, -0.02218593843281269, 0.01435027364641428, -0.009318611584603786, -0.027638522908091545, -0.030902303755283356, 0.0051741283386945724, 0.029451735317707062, 0.002464024815708399, 0.005407255608588457, 0.006300909910351038, 0.02039862982928753, -0.015114412643015385, -0.01014750823378563, 0.011080017313361168, 0.012802568264305592, -0.02094259299337864, -0.007991082035005093, 0.011125347577035427, 0.0429731123149395, -0.022160034626722336, 0.010827463120222092, -0.009733060374855995, 0.03724854439496994, -0.018158018589019775, 0.008560949005186558, -0.007783858105540276, 0.03533172234892845, -0.015528861433267593, -0.030591467395424843, -0.008340773172676563, 0.0008620849112048745, 0.020709466189146042, -0.017406830564141273, 0.020787173882126808, -0.01853361167013645, 0.018650176003575325, -0.03652326017618179, -0.028001166880130768, 0.008787600323557854, 0.016577932983636856, 0.023999148979783058, -0.000018896051187766716, -0.03271551430225372, 0.055795107036828995, 0.006410997826606035, 0.0355648472905159, -0.006890203803777695, -0.039243075996637344, -0.023455185815691948, 0.0073435064405202866, -0.08356314897537231, 0.006440138444304466, 0.003934021573513746, 0.018339339643716812, 0.04722120612859726, -0.0020884310360997915, 0.002637251280248165, 0.01690172217786312, 0.0035778547171503305, -0.0031779769342392683, -0.002054433338344097, -0.024271130561828613, 0.01202547736465931, -0.03919127210974693, 0.0016553649911656976, -0.039787039160728455, 0.0046949228271842, -0.036678679287433624, 0.01857246644794941, 0.010238168761134148, -0.007855091243982315, 0.01783422939479351, -0.020230259746313095, -0.028933674097061157, -0.013029219582676888, 0.005540008656680584, -0.002928660251200199, 0.00618758425116539, -0.0065210857428610325, -0.01418190449476242, -0.0064045218750834465, -0.023882586508989334, 0.03844008222222328, -0.007576633710414171, 0.007453594356775284, -0.018986914306879044, 0.04009787738323212, 0.007207515649497509, 0.0025692558847367764, -0.015451151877641678, -0.017497491091489792, -0.02085193246603012, -0.03926898166537285, 0.0069873398169875145, 0.013741552829742432, -0.04758385196328163, -0.009279757738113403, 0.03017701953649521, -0.003029034473001957, 0.020165501162409782, -0.005054327193647623, -0.022457920014858246, 0.020372726023197174, 0.005818466190248728, -0.008807027712464333, 0.01843000017106533, -0.01843000017106533, 0.019090525805950165, 0.028778256848454475, -0.012044904753565788, -0.032974544912576675, -0.027042753994464874, 0.010665569454431534, 0.020126648247241974, -0.0018180683255195618, -0.005310119595378637, -0.01576198823750019, 0.04372429847717285, -0.02826019562780857, -0.026835530996322632, 0.007006767205893993, 0.02361060306429863, -0.016927624121308327, 0.025553330779075623, -0.04880129173398018, -0.003270256333053112, 0.03693770989775658, 0.013508426025509834, -0.025268396362662315, 0.015179170295596123, 0.018701981753110886, -0.012673052959144115, -0.03779250755906105, 0.014143049716949463, -0.01688876934349537, -0.02030796930193901, -0.02717226929962635, -0.01595626026391983, 0.019479071721434593, -0.011494466103613377, 0.01106706541031599, 0.014984898269176483, 0.009720108471810818, 0.00117373070679605, 0.004678733181208372, -0.029114995151758194, 0.0010854984866455197, 0.01141028106212616, -0.007783858105540276, -0.014337322674691677, -0.026835530996322632, 0.019738102331757545, -0.017652908340096474, -0.031783007085323334, 0.02307959273457527, -0.0013453381834551692, -0.016331855207681656, 0.012698955833911896, -0.00867103599011898, 0.0018342577386647463, -0.029710765928030014, 0.019427265971899033, -0.0032556860242038965, -0.00022422302572522312, -0.0019993893802165985, 0.007078000344336033, 0.01679810881614685, 0.018015550449490547, -0.00859332736581564, -0.006689455360174179, -0.007440642919391394, -0.013741552829742432, 0.02589006908237934, 0.006414235569536686, 0.019828762859106064, 0.02361060306429863, -0.04253276064991951, -0.010011517442762852, -0.01486833393573761, 0.055950526148080826, -0.03991655632853508, -0.005533532705157995, -0.0015444676391780376, 0.05506982281804085, 0.007194564212113619, -0.002680962672457099, 0.012983889319002628, -0.00817887857556343, 0.022315453737974167, 0.01660383678972721, -0.015036704018712044, 0.007738527841866016, 0.00857389997690916, 0.016318904235959053, 0.005358687601983547, 0.015088509768247604, -0.008554472588002682, 0.02227659896016121, -0.023545846343040466, -0.017808327451348305, -0.02908909320831299, -0.026071390137076378, 0.02276875637471676, -0.030902303755283356, 0.0165390782058239, 0.025864167138934135, -0.014557497575879097, 0.00287037855014205, -0.030902303755283356, 0.007324079051613808, 0.04284359887242317, 0.00958411768078804, 0.021603120490908623, 0.0027538149151951075, -0.03191252052783966, 0.007589585147798061, -0.017575200647115707, 0.029374025762081146, 0.020579950883984566, 0.009383369237184525, 0.006993815768510103, -0.020877834409475327, -0.030591467395424843, -0.02836380898952484, 0.010782132856547832, -0.008729318156838417, 0.011261338368058205, -0.008839406073093414, 0.010885744355618954, -0.009448126889765263, -0.034710049629211426, 0.005018710158765316, -0.013961728662252426, -0.007576633710414171, 0.015347540378570557, 0.0026016347110271454, 0.020035987719893456, 0.03629013150930405, -0.025747602805495262, -0.014725867658853531, -0.017963744699954987, -0.030151117593050003, 0.01911642961204052, 0.02381782792508602, 0.0011777780018746853, 0.01684991456568241, -0.0005391066079027951, 0.004348469898104668, -0.017717666923999786, 0.004934525582939386, 0.02745720185339451, 0.026990948244929314, -0.036134716123342514, -0.03227516636252403, -0.005251837428659201, -0.036549162119627, 0.001287056365981698, -0.0010223598219454288, 0.04856816679239273, -0.027301784604787827, -0.005860558710992336, 0.015438200905919075, 0.04242914915084839, -0.031731199473142624, 0.0031229329761117697, -0.032922741025686264, -0.04040871188044548, -0.03849188983440399, 0.017277315258979797, 0.0004306377377361059, -0.027379494160413742, -0.00017089923494495451, 0.00480501027777791, -0.006297672167420387, -0.0025708747562021017, 0.0073111276142299175, 0.008884736336767673, 0.014803576283156872, -0.0026145861484110355, 0.006313861347734928, 0.016137583181262016, 0.022975979372859, 0.0014497597003355622, 0.00760901253670454, -0.0007366171921603382, 0.017160750925540924, -0.04330985248088837, -0.017795376479625702, 0.0444754883646965, 0.018158018589019775, 0.0037170834839344025, -0.027897553518414497, -0.0024883090518414974, 0.004652830306440592, 0.051650624722242355, 0.04688446968793869, -0.004380848258733749, -0.015425249002873898, -0.00826953910291195, 0.05069221183657646, 0.018753787502646446, 0.00899482425302267, -0.018948059529066086, 0.013715649954974651, -0.046262796968221664, -0.007220467086881399, 0.0444754883646965, 0.02317025326192379, 0.0035228109918534756, 0.005747233051806688, -0.024737386032938957, 0.0035260487347841263, -0.01521802507340908, 0.026110244914889336, 0.004131531808525324, -0.0034774804953485727, -0.018119163811206818, 0.05558788403868675, 0.01230393536388874, 0.012232702225446701, -0.02455606497824192, -0.02227659896016121, -0.02722407504916191, 0.020489290356636047, -0.017419781535863876, 0.0010102178202942014, 0.010134557262063026, 0.02020435594022274, 0.014466837048530579, -0.019297750666737556, -0.006767164450138807, -0.021551312878727913, 0.005598290357738733, -0.006330050993710756, 0.005404017865657806, -0.03963162377476692, -0.02504822239279747, -0.014466837048530579, 0.017743568867444992, -0.048283230513334274, 0.019932374358177185, -0.005426682997494936, 0.006242628209292889, 0.028027068823575974, -0.03877682238817215, -0.00802993681281805, 0.03147217258810997, -0.0010069799609482288, 0.008884736336767673, 0.011779398657381535, -0.03250829130411148, 0.019077574834227562, -0.005119084380567074, -0.026783723384141922, -0.015774939209222794, 0.01843000017106533, -0.009020727127790451, -0.023403380066156387, 0.062063638120889664, 0.013184637762606144, -0.04763565585017204, 0.02440064586699009, 0.001445712405256927, -0.00849619135260582, 0.02114981599152088, -0.0026081104297190905, -0.0033771065063774586, 0.03481366112828255, -0.04460500180721283, 0.009642399847507477, 0.004856816492974758, 0.01985466666519642, 0.04268817976117134, 0.016331855207681656, 0.05776373669505119, -0.001141351880505681, -0.025903021916747093, -0.03794792667031288, -0.006767164450138807, -0.015321637503802776, -0.021357040852308273, 0.017497491091489792, -0.0035649032797664404, -0.011792350560426712, 0.00012759261881001294, 0.005585338920354843, 0.012504683807492256, -0.019647441804409027, -0.020838981494307518, -0.015425249002873898, -0.01521802507340908, -0.0012991983676329255, -0.017860133200883865, -0.012012526392936707, 0.014207807369530201, 0.003946973010897636, 0.01232983823865652, -0.01467406190931797, -0.01615053415298462, 0.027249978855252266, 0.013689747080206871, -0.012640674598515034, 0.00800403393805027, -0.016720401123166084, -0.034114278852939606, 0.0068124947138130665, 0.040926773101091385, -0.015632472932338715, -0.005711616016924381, 0.015969213098287582, -0.03590158745646477, 0.009195572696626186, 0.013391861692070961, 0.0015582286287099123, -0.020463386550545692, 0.0034062473569065332, 0.027431299909949303, 0.006760688498616219, 0.0133400559425354, 0.01871493272483349, -0.012569441460072994, 0.0046560680493712425, -0.024232275784015656, -0.019699247553944588, 0.038906339555978775, 0.002554685575887561, 0.018248679116368294, -0.04455319792032242, -0.020735368132591248, -0.00332206254824996, 0.009622972458600998, 0.018365241587162018, 0.008386103436350822, -0.006469279527664185, 0.01437617652118206, 0.013702698051929474, -0.030513759702444077, -0.02445245161652565, 0.01881854422390461, -0.011248387396335602, 0.01664269156754017, 0.006307385861873627, 0.0012554870918393135, 0.02652469463646412, 0.02213413082063198, -0.011455611325800419, -0.00009516324644209817, 0.02271694876253605, 0.021020302549004555, 0.01104116253554821, -0.017303219065070152, 0.01951792649924755, 0.014570449478924274, -0.025618087500333786, 0.0008896068902686238, -0.03592748939990997, -0.0018148304661735892, -0.014259613119065762, -0.01469996478408575, -0.017704715952277184, -0.008042887784540653, 0.027509009465575218, -0.0005496297380886972, -0.02271694876253605, -0.001559038064442575, -0.009694205597043037, -0.01010217797011137, 0.017562247812747955, 0.02381782792508602, 0.011099444702267647, 0.015036704018712044, -0.0024251702707260847, -0.0484127476811409, -0.0027732423041015863, 0.001474043820053339, -0.01096345391124487, -0.0035519518423825502, 0.025359058752655983, 0.001704742549918592, -0.018585417419672012, 0.00861923024058342, -0.038414180278778076, 0.03048785589635372, -0.0028865679632872343, 0.003772127442061901, 0.004377610515803099, -0.018248679116368294, 0.0002481023839209229, -0.02238021045923233, 0.030591467395424843, 0.007317603565752506, 0.026602402329444885, 0.02696504443883896, 0.04066774249076843, 0.0320938415825367, -0.001036930363625288, -0.011313144117593765, 0.005047851242125034, -0.011209532618522644, -0.007984606549143791, 0.024789191782474518, 0.013236443512141705, 0.024089809507131577, 0.039553914219141006, 0.014920140616595745, 0.00906605739146471, 0.032534193247556686, 0.008949493989348412, -0.001915204687975347, 0.02267809584736824, -0.0005411303136497736, 0.007155709434300661, 0.0060839722864329815, -0.02262628823518753, 0.020411580801010132, 0.020670611411333084, 0.060146816074848175, -0.007129806559532881, -0.02436179108917713, 0.010367684066295624, 0.002030149335041642, -0.021577216684818268, -0.013728600926697254, -0.004902146756649017, 0.00332206254824996, 0.011190105229616165, -0.02222479321062565, -0.023921439424157143, -0.03856959939002991, 0.005980359856039286, -0.0217326357960701, -0.013624989427626133, -0.037714798003435135, -0.01150741707533598, -0.02276875637471676, 0.023791925981640816, -0.0017533107893541455, 0.026913238689303398, -0.0022098515182733536, -0.008606279268860817, 0.008301918394863605, 0.02010074444115162, -0.0010498818010091782, 0.0005832227179780602, 0.06201183423399925, -0.017911938950419426, 0.009771915152668953, -0.015982164070010185, -0.02248382195830345, -0.0002177472779294476, 0.008088218048214912, -0.017795376479625702, 0.010490723885595798, -0.03175710514187813, -0.05657219886779785, 0.01202547736465931, -0.013987631537020206, 0.017743568867444992, -0.015697231516242027, 0.029607152566313744, 0.005831417627632618, -0.005504392087459564, -0.025372009724378586, 0.00616168137639761, 0.0021078584250062704, -0.0066700279712677, 0.031498074531555176, 0.0007884232327342033 ]
11.89957
8.047694
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.532..496M
[ "radio emission", "extended radio continuum emission", "radio frequencies", "radio", "TDG", "emission", "galaxy mergers", "combined thermal and synchrotron radio emission", "disc", "faint tidal tails" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
4
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1437", "10.48550/arXiv.2406.18281" ]
[ "Moncada-Cuadri, Blanca M.", "Lisenfeld, Ute", "Querejeta, Miguel", "Mundell, Carole" ]
[ "Department of Physics, University of Bath, Claverton Down, Bath, BA2 7AY, UK", "Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Universidad de Granada, E-18071 Granada, Spain; Instituto Carlos I de Física Teórica y Computacional, Facultad de Ciencias, E-18071 Granada, Spain", "Observatorio Astronómico Nacional, Alfonso XII, 3, E-28014 Madrid, Spain", "Department of Physics, University of Bath, Claverton Down, Bath, BA2 7AY, UK; European Space Astronomy Centre (ESAC), Camino Bajo del Castillo s/n, 28692 Villafranca del Castillo, Madrid, Spain" ]
null
[ "1956ErNW...29..344Z", "1968ApJ...154..391R", "1989ApJ...345..245C", "1990ApJ...357...97C", "1993AJ....105.1730C", "1995ApJ...445..642R", "1995MNRAS.275...67M", "1995MNRAS.277..641M", "1997A&A...320...54N", "2000ApJ...542..186N", "2000ApJ...542..197F", "2001A&A...378...51B", "2003ApJ...595..665X", "2004ApJ...614..648M", "2007A&A...470..539B", "2007CSE.....9...90H", "2008ApJ...685..181L", "2009A&A...503..747P", "2010A&A...524A..27L", "2011A&A...529A..94C", "2011A&A...532A..71R", "2011ApJ...737...67M", "2012ASSP...28..305D", "2012MNRAS.422.1812H", "2013ApJ...779...43P", "2013MNRAS.435..149N", "2014ApJ...784L..11Y", "2014ApJ...797..117A", "2015A&A...584A.113L", "2015A&ARv..24....4B", "2015AJ....149...76C", "2015MNRAS.447.2512P", "2017ApJ...836..185T", "2017ApJS..230....7P", "2018MNRAS.474..580P", "2019ApJ...885..107N", "2020Natur.585..357H", "2021A&A...645A..97Q", "2022ApJ...935..167A", "2022PASP..134k4501C" ]
29163244
2308.06206
A multitracer analysis for the eBOSS galaxy sample based on the effective field theory of large-scale structure
We perform a multitracer full-shape analysis in Fourier space based on the effective field theory of large-scale structure (EFTofLSS) using the complete Sloan Digital Sky Survey IV (SDSS-IV) extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey (eBOSS) DR16 luminous red galaxy (LRG) and emission line galaxy (ELG) samples. We study in detail the impact of the volume projection effect and different prior choices when doing the full-shape analysis based on the EFTofLSS model. We show that adopting a combination of Jeffreys prior and Gaussian prior can mitigate the volume effect and avoid exploring unphysical regions in the parameter space at the same time, which is crucial when jointly analysing the eBOSS LRG and ELG samples. We validate our pipeline using 1000 eBOSS EZmocks. By performing a multitracer analysis on mocks with comparable footprints, we find that cosmological constraints can be improved by $\sim 10-35~{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$ depending on whether we assume zero stochastic terms in the cross power spectrum, which breaks the degeneracy and boosts the constraints on the standard deviation of matter density fluctuation σ<SUB>8</SUB>. Combining with the Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) prior and fixing the spectral tilt n<SUB>s</SUB> to Planck value, our multitracer full-shape analysis measures H<SUB>0</SUB> = 70.0 ± 2.3 km s<SUP>-1</SUP>Mpc<SUP>-1</SUP>, $\Omega _m=0.317^{+0.017}_{-0.021}$, $\sigma _8=0.787_{-0.062}^{+0.055}$, and $S_8=0.809_{-0.078}^{+0.064}$, consistent with the Planck 2018 results. In particular, the constraint on σ<SUB>8</SUB> is improved beyond that obtained from the single tracer analysis by 18 per cent, or by 27 per cent when assuming zero stochastic terms in the cross power spectrum.
[ 0.040742263197898865, 0.004475975874811411, 0.03749660402536392, -0.018735108897089958, -0.04045199975371361, 0.017494896426796913, -0.0030527012422680855, -0.006986084394156933, -0.030081722885370255, 0.026651350781321526, -0.025331977754831314, 0.05243191495537758, -0.037971578538417816, -0.0071378122083842754, 0.03915901482105255, 0.03530644252896309, -0.019223276525735855, 0.014183268882334232, -0.03987147659063339, 0.008951951749622822, -0.013107978738844395, -0.0454656220972538, 0.0046804784797132015, -0.0014026592252776027, -0.04467399790883064, -0.030424760654568672, -0.014856149442493916, -0.0032885391265153885, 0.04860573261976242, -0.039027076214551926, -0.010159178636968136, -0.0434601716697216, -0.03161219507455826, -0.04258938506245613, -0.048473794013261795, 0.07805415242910385, -0.020846106112003326, 0.022548098117113113, 0.007230168674141169, -0.04158666357398033, 0.022152286022901535, 0.002579375868663192, -0.025780564174056053, -0.009624832309782505, 0.024896584451198578, -0.004786028526723385, -0.02227102965116501, -0.030292822048068047, 0.01358954980969429, 0.029949786141514778, -0.03314267098903656, 0.045386459678411484, 0.0030856854282319546, -0.046257246285676956, -0.029685910791158676, -0.008813416585326195, 0.020780136808753014, 0.0017976468661800027, 0.013239916414022446, 0.005099379923194647, -0.007098230998963118, -0.024632709100842476, 0.0045518395490944386, -0.027970725670456886, -0.016399815678596497, -0.0005339341005310416, -0.020186418667435646, -0.01812819577753544, 0.037311892956495285, 0.04016174003481865, -0.0068277595564723015, -0.0023056056816130877, -0.013958974741399288, 0.006530900485813618, 0.018735108897089958, -0.03931733965873718, -0.0063527850434184074, -0.001725081237964332, -0.016690079122781754, -0.018814271315932274, -0.026888838037848473, 0.006959696765989065, 0.021492598578333855, -0.021888410672545433, 0.001703641377389431, -0.014697824604809284, 0.028023499995470047, -0.0126264076679945, -0.0737793818116188, 0.014143687672913074, 0.022218255326151848, -0.03596613183617592, 0.01212504506111145, -0.018801076337695122, 0.016650497913360596, -0.042774099856615067, 0.03348570689558983, -0.02971229888498783, 0.0783180296421051, -0.015093636699020863, 0.03873681649565697, 0.05095421522855759, 0.04678499698638916, -0.06454376876354218, 0.042774099856615067, 0.00047621148405596614, 0.01980380155146122, -0.013761068694293499, 0.03380235657095909, 0.037602152675390244, 0.038024354726076126, 0.006468229927122593, -0.008279070258140564, -0.005828334018588066, 0.0018025945173576474, -0.006267025601118803, -0.04536006972193718, 0.042562998831272125, -0.028155436739325523, 0.015370705164968967, 0.01391939353197813, -0.00047291305963881314, 0.04813075810670853, 0.01651855930685997, 0.034937016665935516, -0.005561160389333963, -0.00027748080901801586, -0.041349176317453384, -0.04654750972986221, 0.01250106655061245, -0.004954248666763306, -0.002023589564487338, 0.06728806346654892, 0.020199613645672798, -0.028920674696564674, 0.012837506830692291, 0.016201909631490707, 0.004947651643306017, 0.010218550451099873, 0.00995467510074377, -0.022112704813480377, 0.022825166583061218, 0.007883258163928986, 0.0358869694173336, 0.005472102668136358, 0.040082577615976334, -0.0393965020775795, 0.021545374765992165, 0.010977189987897873, 0.006920115556567907, -0.01757405884563923, -0.009565460495650768, -0.06021622195839882, -0.04939735680818558, 0.04005618765950203, -0.025846533477306366, 0.012032689526677132, 0.005940480623394251, 0.023023072630167007, -0.03512173146009445, 0.009024516679346561, 0.05269578844308853, 0.0010596220381557941, 0.029026223346590996, 0.005524877924472094, 0.03520089387893677, -0.0018372280756011605, -0.01698034070432186, -0.06412156671285629, -0.04992510378360748, -0.03966037556529045, 0.007461058907210827, -0.019869768992066383, -0.050083428621292114, 0.015106829814612865, 0.022864747792482376, 0.004858593922108412, -0.024843808263540268, 0.004802520852535963, -0.02944842353463173, -0.009097082540392876, 0.026097213849425316, 0.04884321987628937, 0.006953099742531776, -0.04174498841166496, 0.012527454644441605, 0.010653943754732609, 0.018682332709431648, 0.031744133681058884, -0.016993533819913864, 0.006342889741063118, 0.04562394693493843, 0.05240552872419357, 0.041956085711717606, -0.018629558384418488, -0.06216889247298241, 0.01787751540541649, 0.04752384498715401, -0.024434803053736687, 0.06702418625354767, 0.04760300740599632, 0.044779546558856964, 0.01636023446917534, -0.05641642585396767, -0.038974303752183914, -0.05066395550966263, 0.07905688136816025, -0.03844655305147171, -0.01798306591808796, -0.0019840083550661802, 0.032008007168769836, -0.009110276587307453, 0.0057821557857096195, 0.0018306311685591936, -0.018801076337695122, -0.034620366990566254, -0.025028521195054054, 0.03277324512600899, 0.07599592953920364, 0.07103508710861206, -0.006369276903569698, 0.0313219353556633, 0.05116531625390053, 0.009994256310164928, 0.01389300636947155, 0.027311038225889206, 0.07863467931747437, -0.041296400129795074, -0.013813843950629234, -0.012395516969263554, 0.03419816866517067, 0.024263285100460052, -0.035543929785490036, 0.01207227073609829, 0.015542223118245602, -0.05462207645177841, -0.025701401755213737, -0.015872066840529442, -0.00414283387362957, -0.043064359575510025, -0.030187273398041725, 0.020278776064515114, 0.03469952940940857, -0.018906626850366592, -0.006428648717701435, 0.02647983282804489, -0.013866618275642395, -0.029026223346590996, 0.02566182054579258, 0.02339249849319458, 0.013424628414213657, -0.025266008451581, -0.023933440446853638, -0.03055669739842415, -0.028313761577010155, 0.0005796998739242554, -0.0434337854385376, 0.015674160793423653, -0.04314352199435234, -0.0038195871748030186, -0.01316075399518013, -0.022996686398983, -0.036098066717386246, 0.018062228336930275, -0.06127171963453293, 0.014605468139052391, 0.039475664496421814, 0.003842676291242242, -0.02110998146235943, 0.010581377893686295, -0.00026552396593615413, -0.005699694622308016, -0.0011396091431379318, -0.040900588035583496, -0.025173652917146683, 0.01682201586663723, -0.010957399383187294, 0.027258262038230896, 0.002051626332104206, -0.02353762835264206, 0.012995831668376923, -0.0030724918469786644, 0.012553841806948185, -0.005808543413877487, -0.00579534936696291, -0.005056499969214201, 0.003291837638244033, 0.003786602756008506, -0.00886619184166193, -0.011610489338636398, 0.05137641727924347, -0.028920674696564674, -0.00992828793823719, -0.004231891594827175, -0.0191968884319067, -0.045439232140779495, 0.04815714433789253, -0.005524877924472094, -0.041797760874032974, 0.018458040431141853, 0.030371984466910362, 0.03403984382748604, 0.033010732382535934, -0.011755621060729027, -0.023207785561680794, 0.02818182483315468, 0.040742263197898865, 0.01753447763621807, 0.006290114484727383, 0.05520259961485863, 0.005637024529278278, 0.020753750577569008, -0.04309074953198433, 0.03121638484299183, -0.030134497210383415, -0.027099937200546265, 0.0063857692293822765, 0.04491148516535759, 0.019276050850749016, -0.008529751561582088, -0.0224821288138628, -0.04865850508213043, -0.04280048608779907, -0.008166924118995667, 0.02085929922759533, -0.020753750577569008, -0.026281926780939102, -0.021228725090622902, -0.008760642260313034, -0.009763366542756557, -0.011683055199682713, -0.0017415734473615885, 0.03475230559706688, -0.016096360981464386, -0.025279201567173004, -0.025701401755213737, 0.014262431301176548, 0.07430713623762131, 0.03111083433032036, -0.002757491311058402, -0.02419731579720974, 0.01672966033220291, 0.00955226644873619, -0.008556138724088669, 0.007527027744799852, 0.05826354771852493, 0.005336867179721594, 0.006573779974132776, 0.0555720254778862, 0.012177820317447186, 0.012296563945710659, -0.01758725196123123, 0.02167731150984764, 0.0063527850434184074, 0.06676031649112701, -0.042906034737825394, -0.0036777544301003218, -0.03691608086228371, -0.020978042855858803, -0.011267452500760555, -0.014816568233072758, -0.03562309220433235, 0.06058564409613609, 0.035649482160806656, -0.005409432575106621, 0.023432079702615738, 0.00021584131172858179, 0.042615775018930435, -0.029738685116171837, -0.06902963668107986, 0.03121638484299183, 0.04583504796028137, -0.005874511785805225, -0.006270323880016804, -0.05546647310256958, -0.010205356404185295, 0.04805159568786621, 0.03863126412034035, 0.03438287973403931, 0.014143687672913074, 0.04380321130156517, -0.0037800059653818607, 0.011379598639905453, -0.025622239336371422, -0.031295545399188995, 0.017402540892362595, -0.0056502181105315685, -0.018708720803260803, -0.030583085492253304, -0.023682760074734688, -0.040082577615976334, 0.04287964850664139, 0.029580360278487206, 0.028366537764668465, 0.0047002690844237804, -0.05061117932200432, 0.01646578498184681, 0.1020667552947998, 0.05551924929022789, 0.047312743961811066, -0.02642705664038658, -0.024474384263157845, -0.040346451103687286, -0.06306606531143188, -0.024764645844697952, 0.017705995589494705, -0.036045294255018234, 0.03396068140864372, 0.03812990337610245, -0.00560733862221241, 0.03662581741809845, -0.04282687231898308, 0.031189996749162674, -0.047207195311784744, 0.015185992233455181, 0.029791461303830147, -0.023418884724378586, 0.047154419124126434, -0.018471233546733856, 0.06992681324481964, -0.01939479447901249, -0.010911221615970135, -0.01818097196519375, 0.002016992773860693, -0.0641743391752243, -0.031691357493400574, 0.02702077478170395, -0.008872788399457932, -0.020423905923962593, -0.01194692961871624, 0.01696714758872986, 0.026598576456308365, 0.025806952267885208, -0.030978897586464882, -0.041401948779821396, -0.011491745710372925, -0.003875660477206111, -0.0007714213570579886, 0.013398241251707077, 0.007922839373350143, -0.00722357165068388, 0.01672966033220291, -0.00225448003038764, -0.05338186398148537, -0.0008382146479561925, -0.002317150356248021, 0.0012608265969902277, -0.002742648357525468, -0.004241786897182465, -0.026770094409585, 0.006596868857741356, -0.010607765056192875, -0.012540647760033607, 0.014658243395388126, -0.0059635695070028305, -0.01063415315002203, 0.030794184654951096, -0.014143687672913074, 0.06739361584186554, -0.018761495128273964, 0.024289671331644058, 0.0038261839654296637, -0.03293156996369362, 0.0174289271235466, -0.026690931990742683, 0.06929351389408112, -0.025529883801937103, -0.0027113130781799555, 0.0036876497324556112, 0.048315469175577164, 0.009308182634413242, -0.07166838645935059, 0.045544784516096115, -0.026954807341098785, -0.006550691090524197, 0.006920115556567907, -0.026202764362096786, -0.018326101824641228, 0.047866880893707275, -0.020278776064515114, 0.03145387023687363, -0.0038723621983081102, 0.0056733074598014355, 0.011716039851307869, 0.04641557112336159, 0.04148111119866371, -0.004119744524359703, 0.020542649552226067, -0.029923398047685623, 0.021492598578333855, 0.0023468362633138895, -0.023009879514575005, 0.033221833407878876, -0.014684630557894707, 0.024368833750486374, -0.056258101016283035, -0.004489169456064701, 0.01783793419599533, -0.0017663117032498121, 0.01356316264718771, 0.0606384202837944, -0.033564869314432144, 0.013048606924712658, 0.002506810240447521, 0.03630916774272919, 0.040953364223241806, -0.05641642585396767, -0.02480422705411911, -0.01052860263735056, 0.022205060347914696, -0.03551754355430603, 0.03148026019334793, 0.009426926262676716, -0.010614362545311451, -0.009961272589862347, -0.004957546945661306, -0.03520089387893677, 0.0404256135225296, 0.004182415083050728, -0.009875512681901455, 0.010996980592608452, -0.016835208982229233, -0.01849762164056301, -0.003911943174898624, 0.018827464431524277, -0.03987147659063339, -0.005637024529278278, -0.1500919610261917, -0.025846533477306366, -0.014143687672913074, 0.026308313012123108, -0.05116531625390053, -0.011979914270341396, 0.0013078292831778526, -0.006646345369517803, -0.010904624126851559, -0.013853425160050392, -0.025068102404475212, -0.01803584024310112, -0.020291969180107117, 0.02355082333087921, 0.01672966033220291, 0.00560733862221241, 0.006689225323498249, 0.028260987251996994, 0.033775970339775085, 0.022152286022901535, 0.01320693176239729, 0.04971400648355484, 0.034725919365882874, 0.03253575786948204, -0.004317650571465492, 0.005719485692679882, 0.04282687231898308, -0.03807712718844414, 0.02308904193341732, 0.028208212926983833, -0.01616232842206955, 0.0040768650360405445, -0.0026189570780843496, -0.012468082830309868, -0.01909133978188038, -0.0015321228420361876, 0.034224554896354675, -0.019487151876091957, -0.031189996749162674, 0.006280219182372093, -0.0303192101418972, 0.0024754751939326525, 0.00864189863204956, -0.025252815335989, 0.032562144100666046, 0.023115430027246475, -0.010020644403994083, 0.014341593720018864, -0.02899983711540699, -0.012976041063666344, -0.008932161144912243, 0.00952587928622961, -0.03359125554561615, -0.022468935698270798, 0.009288392029702663, 0.0051785423420369625, -0.0019411287503316998, -0.04385598376393318, -0.01172263640910387, -0.017653221264481544, 0.03016088530421257, -0.005867915228009224, -0.001303706201724708, -0.018629558384418488, -0.012468082830309868, 0.007876661606132984, 0.014051331207156181, -0.0174289271235466, 0.006920115556567907, 0.024184122681617737, 0.0184448454529047, 0.008318651467561722, -0.02687564492225647, 0.0022165479604154825, 0.0008716112934052944, -0.02439522184431553, -0.0029158161487430334, -0.03512173146009445, 0.026031244546175003, 0.0039680167101323605, -0.002815213752910495, 0.01103656180202961, 0.007513833697885275, 0.02728465013206005, 0.01267918199300766, -0.03010811097919941, -0.011880961246788502, -0.01083865575492382, -0.009882110171020031, 0.010251534171402454, -0.023155011236667633, 0.020489875227212906, -0.019223276525735855, -0.011551117524504662, -0.004805819131433964, 0.026690931990742683, 0.009934884496033192, 0.035438381135463715, -0.017389345914125443, -0.008384620770812035, -0.023524435237050056, 0.008496766909956932, 0.01535751111805439, -0.011313630267977715, -0.026558995246887207, 0.005105976480990648, 0.029078999534249306, 0.0019411287503316998, 0.017468508332967758, 0.018471233546733856, 0.024012602865695953, -0.05237913876771927, -0.02107040025293827, 0.05348741263151169, 0.021096786484122276, 0.07615425437688828, -0.016347041353583336, 0.03203439712524414, -0.007764515001326799, -0.005181840620934963, 0.03055669739842415, -0.04335462301969528, -0.0062769209034740925, -0.010891431011259556, -0.006207653786987066, 0.010244937613606453, 0.03163858503103256, 0.02530558966100216, 0.011610489338636398, 0.0036216811276972294, 0.0036876497324556112, -0.04153388738632202, -0.011353211477398872, 0.0010967294219881296, 0.03253575786948204, -0.00668262830004096, 0.012468082830309868, 0.0006155703449621797, 0.03517450392246246, -0.007362105883657932, 0.007447865325957537, -0.025226427242159843, 0.014486724510788918, 0.025450721383094788, -0.0016920969355851412, 0.015397092327475548, -0.01480337418615818, -0.003489743685349822, -0.002592569449916482, -0.017969870939850807, -0.024382028728723526, -0.012665988877415657, 0.017455315217375755, -0.021136367693543434, -0.007705143187195063, -0.01676924154162407, -0.03150664642453194, -0.0015576856676489115, -0.0060724178329110146, -0.02324736677110195, -0.016201909631490707, 0.007995405234396458, 0.013015622273087502, -0.00046466695494018495, -0.015621385537087917, 0.013708293437957764, 0.009657816030085087, 0.018022647127509117, -0.037813253700733185, -0.008760642260313034, 0.00689372792840004, 0.014856149442493916, -0.04541284590959549, 0.01839207112789154, 0.0219807680696249, -0.015265154652297497, -0.01737615279853344, -0.020120451226830482, -0.010172371752560139, -0.04219357296824455, 0.010733106173574924, 0.051455579698085785, -0.0151596050709486, 0.013813843950629234, 0.00631650211289525, 0.00723676523193717, -0.0009746873984113336, 0.00006117565499152988, 0.003313277382403612, -0.02196757309138775, 0.007922839373350143, -0.019869768992066383, -0.02535836398601532, -0.0184316523373127, -0.021347468718886375, -0.04037283733487129, 0.0014752248534932733, 0.04818353056907654, -0.030424760654568672, -0.02860402502119541, 0.00389545108191669, -0.015238767489790916, 0.00522801885381341, 0.040240902453660965, 0.014196461997926235, 0.007441268302500248, -0.01773238368332386, 0.006742000114172697, 0.02712632529437542, -0.0018965998897328973, -0.008582526817917824, 0.007830483838915825, 0.03248298168182373, 0.018827464431524277, -0.03253575786948204, 0.006926712580025196, 0.016004003584384918, 0.030741410329937935, 0.011049755848944187, 0.024223703891038895, 0.015924841165542603, -0.0017959976103156805, -0.009354360401630402, 0.012177820317447186, 0.011636877432465553, -0.002945502055808902, -0.019539926201105118, 0.015515835955739021, -0.006840953137725592, 0.021532179787755013, -0.003888854291290045, 0.030794184654951096, -0.019223276525735855, 0.010403262451291084, 0.03438287973403931, 0.010851849801838398, 0.029210936278104782, -0.01676924154162407, 0.05520259961485863, -0.037918802350759506, -0.004914667457342148, 0.00597346480935812, -0.024883389472961426, -0.00666943471878767, 0.004548541270196438, 0.05921349674463272, 0.007784305606037378, 0.020793331786990166, 0.0064616333693265915, 0.019513538107275963, -0.013028816320002079, -0.02783878706395626, -0.006781581323593855, 0.010620959103107452, -0.0016607617726549506, 0.030741410329937935, -0.01601719856262207, -0.044330958276987076, 0.033564869314432144, -0.021347468718886375, 0.016149135306477547, 0.02666454389691353, 0.00038406148087233305, -0.015832485631108284, -0.006873937323689461, -0.03557031974196434, -0.012580228969454765, -0.01230316050350666, 0.04171859845519066, 0.00045724547817371786, -0.09821418672800064, 0.007428074721246958, 0.022746004164218903, -0.009783157147467136, 0.004634300712496042, 0.019012177363038063, 0.008879385888576508, 0.07261833548545837, -0.020832912996411324, 0.024012602865695953, 0.010093209333717823, -0.029184548184275627, -0.013424628414213657, 0.017138665542006493, 0.003346261801198125, -0.02126830630004406, -0.023352917283773422, 0.02344527281820774, -0.03272046893835068, -0.010502215474843979, 0.012435098178684711, 0.036599431186914444, 0.014552692882716656, 0.058421872556209564, -0.027601299807429314, 0.005699694622308016, -0.021294692531228065, -0.0023930142633616924, 0.05926627293229103, 0.01447353046387434, -0.005376448389142752, 0.012309757992625237, 0.025397945195436478, 0.017692802473902702, 0.006913518533110619, -0.035385604947805405, -0.0184448454529047, 0.014315205626189709, -0.025450721383094788, -0.02223144844174385, -0.012560438364744186, -0.020371131598949432, 0.04177137464284897, 0.028551248833537102, 0.03221910819411278, 0.00013616349315270782, -0.012712166644632816, 0.008503364399075508, 0.019619088619947433, 0.03868404030799866, 0.011986510828137398, -0.006003150716423988, 0.009367554448544979, 0.019421182572841644, -0.02399940975010395, -0.01482976134866476, 0.004489169456064701, -0.00298673240467906, -0.0013333921087905765, 0.013932587578892708, -0.050188980996608734, 0.007071843836456537, 0.023049460723996162, -0.03475230559706688, -0.05799967423081398, 0.0029702403116971254, -0.04287964850664139, 0.03699524328112602, -0.012547245249152184, -0.0414283387362957, -0.009097082540392876, 0.036493878811597824, 0.0036216811276972294, -0.0166768841445446, -0.002894376404583454, -0.008239489048719406, -0.008516557514667511, -0.0014851201558485627, -0.03575503081083298, 0.014196461997926235, 0.013642325066030025, -0.00396471843123436, 0.05058479309082031, -0.0012171223061159253, 0.015317929908633232, 0.05174583941698074, 0.007823886349797249, -0.01808861456811428, -0.001927934936247766, 0.03000256046652794, 0.013972168788313866, -0.014394368045032024, 0.03770770505070686, 0.022455742582678795, 0.004304456990212202, 0.015291542746126652, 0.033221833407878876, -0.013167350552976131, 0.027099937200546265, -0.012712166644632816, -0.006676031276583672, -0.003003224730491638, -0.004822311457246542, -0.0018306311685591936, -0.011828185990452766, 0.005138961132615805, 0.020450294017791748, 0.005208228249102831, -0.013998555950820446, -0.006111999042332172, 0.028735961765050888, -0.0065869735553860664, 0.009176244959235191, 0.03060947172343731, 0.04879044368863106, 0.00577226048335433, -0.006732104811817408, -0.014763792976737022, 0.024725064635276794, 0.022548098117113113, 0.01778515987098217, 0.00868807639926672, -0.021004430949687958, -0.017996259033679962, 0.011234467849135399, -0.010185565799474716, -0.00850996095687151, -0.018801076337695122, -0.027970725670456886, 0.02258767932653427, -0.01245488878339529, 0.0147769870236516, 0.022244641557335854, -0.024975746870040894, -0.03572864457964897, 0.006748597137629986, -0.014354786835610867, 0.0398978628218174, -0.0035590108018368483, 0.0250021331012249, -0.008542945608496666, -0.016703272238373756, 0.00433084461838007, 0.00919603556394577, 0.03148026019334793, 0.013510387390851974, -0.010211952961981297, -0.02582014538347721, 0.0404256135225296, 0.0062769209034740925, 0.019262857735157013, 0.01696714758872986, -0.02673051320016384, 0.019737832248210907, 0.030187273398041725, -0.0026370983105152845, -0.01260661706328392, -0.004347336478531361, -0.02010725624859333, 0.021941186860203743, 0.009327973239123821, 0.03778686746954918, -0.01626787893474102, -0.02849847450852394, 0.023300141096115112, 0.013081591576337814, -0.01762683317065239, 0.022191867232322693, 0.009842528961598873, -0.0003809691988863051, -0.006082313135266304, -0.06032177060842514, 0.01571374200284481, 0.010066822171211243, -0.011227871291339397, 0.015990810468792915, -0.028735961765050888, 0.017389345914125443, -0.0068079689517617226, 0.004878384526818991, -0.021941186860203743, -0.016558140516281128, -0.00416922103613615, 0.02460632100701332, 0.042404673993587494, -0.01701992191374302, -0.036045294255018234, 0.002858093474060297, 0.01157090812921524, 0.026796482503414154, -0.01045603770762682, 0.03580780699849129, 0.014974893070757389, 0.04601975902915001, 0.02944842353463173, 0.023761922493577003, -0.0015783009584993124, 0.03396068140864372, -0.018867045640945435, -0.03931733965873718, -0.0035194295924156904, 0.0054325214587152, 0.007005874998867512, -0.02035793848335743, -0.021993961185216904, 0.0021340870298445225, -0.004172519780695438, -0.009255407378077507, -0.03469952940940857, -0.033116281032562256, 0.020595425739884377, 0.013761068694293499, 0.006375873927026987, 0.029897009953856468, 0.02178286202251911, -0.08116787672042847, 0.023326529189944267, -0.024236897006630898, -0.03253575786948204, -0.0179434847086668, 0.012441694736480713, -0.026189569383859634, -0.0032951361499726772, 0.07773750275373459, 0.003186287824064493, 0.01935521326959133, 0.009446716867387295, -0.042404673993587494, 0.011452164500951767, -0.0028646904975175858, -0.005505087319761515, -0.0005817614146508276, 0.0048322067596018314, -0.005983360111713409, -0.035491153597831726, -0.020094063133001328, 0.014236043207347393, 0.006428648717701435, -0.015634579584002495, 0.011293839663267136, 0.029897009953856468, -0.012778135016560555, 0.012890282087028027, 0.0042055039666593075, 0.017903903499245644, -0.006243936717510223, 0.036652203649282455, -0.0005850598099641502, 0.033116281032562256, 0.003291837638244033, -0.025622239336371422, 0.005293987225741148, -0.04340739920735359, -0.002648642985150218, -0.018867045640945435, 0.009506088681519032, -0.04274770990014076, 0.03871042653918266, 0.010066822171211243, -0.01369510032236576, -0.02105720527470112, -0.022706422954797745, -0.040082577615976334, -0.007896452210843563, 0.011834783479571342, -0.023986216634511948, -0.005115871783345938, 0.02592569589614868, 0.010033837519586086, -0.0034864451736211777, -0.025806952267885208, -0.030503923073410988, 0.04572949558496475, 0.017349764704704285, -0.005884407088160515, 0.00992828793823719, 0.02860402502119541, -0.026387475430965424, 0.010845252312719822, 0.05652197450399399, -0.012032689526677132, -0.03849932923913002, -0.0033033820800483227, -0.0033775968477129936, -0.006250533275306225, 0.01612274721264839, 0.026902031153440475, -0.02026558108627796, 0.02889428660273552, 0.016756046563386917, -0.002396312775090337, 0.008918967097997665, 0.014038137160241604, -0.000322628126014024, 0.02378831058740616, 0.002016992773860693, 0.0008922265260480344, 0.0018685631221160293, -0.0025364961475133896, -0.029474811628460884, -0.0032539055682718754, -0.019737832248210907, 0.004924562759697437, -0.022389773279428482, -0.008041583001613617, 0.001072815852239728, -0.02182244323194027, -0.024632709100842476, -0.021189143881201744, -0.01303541287779808, 0.018880238756537437, -0.011953527107834816, -0.004561734851449728, 0.0023072550538927317, 0.0042615775018930435, -0.03279963135719299, 0.008219698444008827, 0.015436673536896706, 0.011643473990261555, 0.0036216811276972294, -0.0029834341257810593, -0.0021208934485912323, 0.034488432109355927, -0.018378878012299538, -0.017468508332967758, -0.0027245068922638893, 0.013259707018733025, 0.001568405656144023, -0.013523581437766552, 0.015436673536896706, 0.023128623142838478, 0.004043880850076675, 0.007883258163928986, -0.04047838971018791, -0.029870623722672462, 0.04586143419146538, 0.008523155003786087, 0.005752469878643751, -0.004561734851449728, -0.0004799222224391997, -0.005465506110340357, 0.00396471843123436, -0.029923398047685623, -0.019526733085513115, 0.0010340592125430703, 0.03248298168182373, -0.017389345914125443, -0.012270176783204079, -0.006732104811817408, 0.028656799346208572, 0.07077120989561081, -0.022007154300808907, 0.016742853447794914, -0.024975746870040894, 0.002701417775824666, -0.001500787679105997, 0.009816140867769718, 0.0179434847086668, 0.029474811628460884, 0.0333537682890892, 0.0075600119307637215, -0.00471016438677907, -0.023933440446853638, 0.018735108897089958, 0.03828822821378708, 0.02944842353463173, -0.00882001407444477, 0.026004858314990997, -0.009605041705071926, 0.0016244789585471153, -0.0083384420722723, 0.012969444505870342, -0.017046310007572174, -0.016492173075675964, -0.011537924408912659, -0.012382322922348976, -0.02233699895441532, -0.004525452386587858, -0.0047002690844237804, 0.029078999534249306, -0.01442075613886118, -0.0013597796205431223, -0.0029850832652300596, 0.011003577150404453, 0.005778857506811619, -0.012619810178875923, -0.004103252664208412, 0.05594145134091377, 0.008114148862659931, 0.008034986443817616, 0.0023814698215574026, -0.011267452500760555, 0.012758344411849976, -0.01707269623875618, -0.025780564174056053, 0.018629558384418488, 0.027363812550902367, 0.023313336074352264, -0.02520003914833069, -0.011478552594780922, -0.02702077478170395, -0.004640897270292044, 0.013371853157877922, -0.006306606810539961, -0.01444714330136776, 0.012560438364744186, 0.034989792853593826, 0.035438381135463715, 0.030688634142279625, -0.023722341284155846, -0.024685483425855637, 0.010594571940600872, -0.038472939282655716, 0.021637730300426483, 0.023128623142838478, -0.02712632529437542, -0.001058797468431294, 0.011208080686628819, -0.0015560365281999111, 0.014156880788505077, 0.005920690018683672, 0.019764220342040062, -0.03683691844344139, -0.013048606924712658, -0.0000452503991255071, 0.01189415529370308, -0.0059668682515621185, 0.01989615708589554, -0.009967869147658348, -0.011557715013623238, -0.03066224791109562, 0.018761495128273964, -0.010040435008704662, 0.006375873927026987, -0.012665988877415657, 0.016333848237991333, -0.018827464431524277, -0.01757405884563923, -0.02860402502119541, -0.0013639027019962668, -0.004175818059593439, -0.0028828317299485207, -0.006296711508184671, 0.03451481834053993, 0.012646198272705078, -0.013655519112944603, 0.019526733085513115, -0.009453313425183296, 0.025292396545410156, -0.018115002661943436, -0.0303192101418972, 0.01884065754711628, 0.023629985749721527, -0.010548393242061138, 0.026545800268650055, 0.007784305606037378, 0.009967869147658348, -0.02227102965116501, 0.000058186447859043255, -0.008094358257949352, 0.03055669739842415, 0.029263710603117943, 0.0004840452747885138, 0.008028389886021614, -0.004017493221908808, 0.0328260213136673, -0.001167645794339478, 0.0169275663793087, -0.01333886943757534, -0.011353211477398872, 0.017521284520626068, 0.005742574576288462, 0.026334701105952263, -0.003855869872495532, -0.031955234706401825, -0.025134071707725525, 0.008925563655793667, -0.0014100807020440698, -0.003476549871265888, 0.023352917283773422, -0.017705995589494705, 0.004878384526818991, 0.011373002082109451, 0.02000170759856701, 0.022904329001903534, 0.004848698619753122, 0.026585381478071213, -0.006059224251657724, 0.016544947400689125, 0.0073555088602006435, 0.0018636154709383845, -0.0015222275396808982, -0.035939741879701614, -0.0338551327586174, 0.021664118394255638, -0.01965866982936859, -0.02105720527470112, -0.015674160793423653, 0.024236897006630898, 0.003714037360623479, -0.004631001967936754, -0.0161755234003067, 0.012191014364361763, -0.020041288807988167, -0.010205356404185295, 0.0060394336469471455, -0.048684895038604736, -0.00027809926541522145, 0.011346614919602871, 0.017112277448177338, -0.008417604491114616, 0.002877884078770876, 0.006260428577661514, 0.017468508332967758, 0.07610148191452026, -0.0018685631221160293, -0.0037107388488948345, -0.012547245249152184, -0.026941612362861633, 0.00922242272645235, -0.011709442362189293, -0.05430542677640915, 0.010310905985534191, -0.02521323412656784, -0.029527585953474045, -0.03459398075938225, 0.02010725624859333, 0.00952587928622961, -0.010739702731370926, 0.029316486790776253, 0.012943057343363762, -0.04768216982483864, 0.01950034499168396, 0.006553989369422197, -0.022389773279428482, 0.01712547242641449, 0.012355935759842396, 0.011320226825773716, 0.010423053056001663, 0.009057501330971718, -0.00035891091101802886, -0.00866168923676014, 0.0026733812410384417, 0.006128491368144751, 0.015621385537087917, 0.06528261303901672, -0.01651855930685997, -0.031084446236491203, -0.02783878706395626, 0.01571374200284481, -0.01121467724442482, -0.02789156138896942, 0.018365683034062386, -0.0034996389877051115, -0.014816568233072758, 0.026849256828427315, -0.008899176493287086, -0.017824741080403328, -0.012085463851690292, 0.0184448454529047, -0.017903903499245644, -0.01335866004228592, -0.014763792976737022, 0.0048651909455657005, 0.013352062553167343, 0.020146837458014488, -0.011293839663267136, 0.0363619439303875, -0.02050306834280491, -0.033670417964458466, 0.02723187580704689, 0.0005619708099402487, 0.019276050850749016, 0.01139279268682003, 0.015740130096673965, 0.022165479138493538, 0.007309331092983484, -0.000787913566455245, 0.00325885321944952, 0.0006493792752735317, -0.04351294785737991, -0.02293071709573269, 0.011102530173957348, -0.015212380327284336, 0.02137385495007038, 0.0016624110285192728, -0.029026223346590996, 0.001589020830579102, -0.03203439712524414, 0.01798306591808796, 0.0159116480499506, -0.03567586839199066, -0.009426926262676716, 0.005105976480990648, 0.02314181625843048, 0.04689054563641548, 0.005633726250380278, 0.030952509492635727, 0.0011123970616608858, -0.012943057343363762, -0.022759197279810905, 0.033512093126773834, -0.030635859817266464, -0.00723676523193717, 0.008199907839298248, -0.017244216054677963, 0.025397945195436478, -0.029738685116171837, 0.010244937613606453, 0.01139279268682003, -0.02698119357228279, 0.023075848817825317, 0.015199186280369759, 0.0007322524907067418, -0.013853425160050392, 0.023775115609169006, 0.015106829814612865, -0.011808395385742188, -0.030134497210383415, 0.026598576456308365, 0.008925563655793667, -0.01950034499168396, 0.011999704875051975, -0.002945502055808902, 0.018985789269208908, 0.023352917283773422, -0.009083888493478298, -0.016940759494900703, 0.03580780699849129, -0.013549968600273132, 0.02934287302196026, 0.011933736503124237, -0.001276494120247662, 0.0004030274576507509, -0.023814696818590164, 0.0070124720223248005, 0.024777840822935104, -0.0018025945173576474, -0.00008204855839721859, 0.004347336478531361, 0.021096786484122276, -0.007533624302595854, 0.0184316523373127, -0.033564869314432144, 0.0003949875244870782, -0.031401097774505615, 0.004040582105517387, -0.010271324776113033, 0.004753044340759516, -0.004594719503074884, 0.02516045793890953, -0.004753044340759516, -0.03438287973403931, 0.020014900714159012, 0.00613838667050004, 0.02471187151968479, 0.0028003707993775606, -0.020542649552226067, -0.019526733085513115, -0.03192884474992752, 0.011966720223426819, 0.021584955975413322, -0.02252171002328396, 0.02960674837231636, 0.010792477987706661, -0.002394663402810693, -0.03894791379570961, 0.03343293070793152, 0.025120876729488373, 0.020529456436634064, -0.01596442237496376, 0.011313630267977715, 0.0072499592788517475, 0.016505366191267967, 0.010772687382996082, 0.007863467559218407, 0.03973953798413277, 0.008206505328416824, 0.02789156138896942, -0.012045882642269135, 0.02056903764605522, -0.02696800045669079, 0.00899153295904398, 0.030583085492253304, -0.012045882642269135, -0.010159178636968136, -0.017257409170269966, 0.04330184683203697, -0.018906626850366592, -0.043671272695064545, -0.007091634441167116, -0.029316486790776253, 0.011650070548057556, -0.020925268530845642, -0.042562998831272125, -0.005851422902196646, -0.026347894221544266, -0.0108584463596344, -0.010343890637159348, 0.022205060347914696, 0.03844655305147171, -0.0010612712940201163, -0.03345932066440582, -0.00575906690210104, -0.0161755234003067, 0.005887705832719803, 0.0008501714910380542, -0.0012006302131339908, 0.022706422954797745, -0.01985657587647438, -0.029580360278487206, 0.004449588246643543, 0.037048015743494034, -0.0021505793556571007, -0.01610955409705639, 0.01707269623875618, 0.019777413457632065, -0.005956972949206829, 0.006079014856368303, -0.014750598929822445, 0.02000170759856701, 0.028762349858880043, -0.005244510713964701, -0.019262857735157013, -0.06380491703748703, -0.03414539247751236, -0.004063671454787254, 0.021914798766374588, 0.01280452311038971, -0.01411729957908392, 0.0510069914162159, -0.007151006255298853, 0.00955226644873619, -0.017692802473902702, 0.00042879648390226066, 0.011808395385742188, -0.022442547604441643, -0.0009812843054533005, -0.00689372792840004 ]
12.059443
2.376446
2024-07-01
8
2024MNRAS.532..783Z
[ "Sloan Digital Sky Survey IV", "cosmological constraints", "Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey", "emission line galaxy", "luminous red galaxy", "full-shape analysis measures", "Fourier space", "Planck value", "different prior choices", "ELG samples" ]
[ "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics" ]
7
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1452", "10.48550/arXiv.2308.06206" ]
[ "Zhao, Ruiyang", "Mu, Xiaoyong", "Gsponer, Rafaela", "Donald-McCann, Jamie", "Feng, Yonghao", "Zhang, Weibing", "Wang, Yuting", "Zhao, Gong-Bo", "Koyama, Kazuya", "Bacon, David", "Crittenden, Robert G." ]
[ "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, P.R. China; School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, P.R. China; Institute of Cosmology and Gravitation, University of Portsmouth, Dennis Sciama Building, Portsmouth PO1 3FX, UK", "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, P.R. China; School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, P.R. China", "Institute of Cosmology and Gravitation, University of Portsmouth, Dennis Sciama Building, Portsmouth PO1 3FX, UK", "Institute of Cosmology and Gravitation, University of Portsmouth, Dennis Sciama Building, Portsmouth PO1 3FX, UK", "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, P.R. China; School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, P.R. China", "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, P.R. China; School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, P.R. China", "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, P.R. China; School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, P.R. China", "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, P.R. China; School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, P.R. China; Institute for Frontiers in Astronomy and Astrophysics, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 102206, P.R. China", "Institute of Cosmology and Gravitation, University of Portsmouth, Dennis Sciama Building, Portsmouth PO1 3FX, UK", "Institute of Cosmology and Gravitation, University of Portsmouth, Dennis Sciama Building, Portsmouth PO1 3FX, UK", "Institute of Cosmology and Gravitation, University of Portsmouth, Dennis Sciama Building, Portsmouth PO1 3FX, UK" ]
[ "2023MNRAS.526.3461D", "2023PhRvD.108l3514H", "2023arXiv231104169D", "2023arXiv231202972B", "2023arXiv231215164S", "2024JCAP...06..052E", "2024MNRAS.530.3075G", "2024MNRAS.531.3991M" ]
[ "1970A&A.....5...84Z", "1979Natur.281..358A", "1987MNRAS.227....1K", "1991MNRAS.253..307P", "1992StaSc...7..457G", "1994ApJ...426...23F", "1995AmJPh..63..398C", "1996MNRAS.282..877B", "2000MNRAS.312..257H", "2001Natur.410..169P", "2002PhRvD..66j3511L", "2005ApJ...620..559J", "2005ApJ...633..560E", "2005MNRAS.362..505C", "2005math......2099N", "2006PASJ...58...93Y", "2007A&A...464..399H", "2008JCAP...08..031S", "2008PhRvD..77l3514D", "2009JCAP...08..020M", "2009JCAP...10..007M", "2009MNRAS.397.1348W", "2009PhRvL.102b1302S", "2010MNRAS.407..772G", "2010PhRvD..82f3522T", "2011JCAP...07..034B", "2011MNRAS.416.3009B", "2011arXiv1110.3193L", "2012JCAP...07..051B", "2012JHEP...09..082C", "2012MNRAS.420.2042A", "2013MNRAS.432..318A", "2013MNRAS.436.3089B", "2013PhRvD..87j3529L", "2013PhRvD..88h3507B", "2014A&A...566A..54P", "2014MNRAS.437.1109R", "2014PASJ...66R...1T", "2015JCAP...02..013S", "2015JCAP...07..011A", "2016ApJS..224...34P", "2016MNRAS.455.3230B", "2016MNRAS.455.4046M", "2016MNRAS.460.3624S", "2016arXiv161009321P", "2016arXiv161100036D", "2017JCAP...07..002H", "2017MNRAS.464.3121W", "2017MNRAS.466.2242B", "2017MNRAS.470.2617A", "2017MNRAS.471.3955R", "2017PhRvD..95f3530Y", "2017PhRvD..96d3513H", "2018ApJ...855..102C", "2018JCAP...04..030S", "2018JCAP...09..001V", "2018MNRAS.473.1444A", "2018PhR...733....1D", "2018PhRvD..97f3526L", "2019ApJ...874...95Z", "2019ApJ...884...29N", "2019JCAP...03..040B", "2019JCAP...08..036D", "2019PhRvD.100b3504N", "2019arXiv191013970L", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020JCAP...05..005D", "2020JCAP...05..042I", "2020MNRAS.497..581A", "2020MNRAS.498.2354R", "2020MNRAS.498.2492G", "2020MNRAS.498.3470W", "2020MNRAS.499.5527T", "2020PhRvD.101d3510H", "2020PhRvD.101h3504I", "2020PhRvD.102d3516P", "2020PhRvD.102f3533C", "2020PhRvD.102h3514H", "2020RAA....20..158W", "2021A&A...646A.140H", "2021JCAP...01..006D", "2021JCAP...05..057T", "2021JCAP...11..028A", "2021JCAP...12..054B", "2021MNRAS.500..736B", "2021MNRAS.500.3254R", "2021MNRAS.501.5616D", "2021MNRAS.503.1149Z", "2021MNRAS.504...33Z", "2021PhRvD.103h3533A", "2021PhRvD.104j3514I", "2021PhRvD.104l1301B", "2022ApJ...929L..16H", "2022ApJ...934L...7R", "2022JCAP...01..031Z", "2022JCAP...02..008C", "2022JCAP...04..013A", "2022JCAP...04..021M", "2022MNRAS.511.5492Z", "2022PhRvD.105b3520A", "2022PhRvD.105d3517P", "2022PhRvD.105h3517K", "2022PhRvD.106d3530P", "2022arXiv221208488I", "2023JCAP...01..028C", "2023JCAP...06..005M", "2023JCAP...07..041S", "2023JCAP...08..004S", "2023MNRAS.520.5016L", "2023MNRAS.526.3461D", "2023OJAp....6E..23H", "2023OJAp....6E..36D", "2023PhRvD.107d3518C", "2023PhRvD.107h3515I", "2023PhRvD.107l3530S", "2023PhRvD.108l3517M", "2023PhRvD.108l3520M", "2023PhRvD.108l3521S", "2023arXiv230704992B", "2024CmPhy...7..130W", "2024JCAP...01..008M", "2024JCAP...03..034K", "2024JCAP...05..059D", "2024MNRAS.530.3075G" ]
29184426
2312.03469
Estimation of line-of-sight velocities of individual galaxies using neural networks I. Modelling redshift-space distortions at large scales
We present a scheme based on artificial neural networks (ANN) to estimate the line-of-sight velocities of individual galaxies from an observed redshift-space galaxy distribution. We find an estimate of the peculiar velocity at a galaxy based on galaxy counts and barycenters in shells around it. By training the network with environmental characteristics, such as the total mass and mass center within each shell surrounding every galaxy in redshift space, our ANN model can accurately predict the line-of-sight velocity of each individual galaxy. When this velocity is used to eliminate the RSD effect, the two-point correlation function (TPCF) in real space can be recovered with an accuracy better than 1% at s &gt; 8 h<SUP>-1</SUP> Mpc, and 4% on all scales compared to ground truth. The real-space power spectrum can be recovered within 3% on k&lt; 0.5 Mpc<SUP>-1</SUP> h, and less than 5% for all k modes. The quadrupole moment of the TPCF or power spectrum is almost zero down to s = 10 h<SUP>-1</SUP> Mpc or all k modes , indicating an effective correction of the spatial anisotropy caused by the RSD effect. We demonstrate that on large scales, without additional training with new data, our network is adaptable to different galaxy formation models, different cosmological models, and mock galaxy samples at high redshifts and high biases, achieving less than 10% error for scales greater than 15 h<SUP>-1</SUP> Mpc. As it is sensitive to large-scale densities, it does not manage to remove Fingers of God in large clusters, but works remarkably well at recovering real-space galaxy positions elsewhere. Our scheme provides a novel way to predict the peculiar velocity of individual galaxies, to eliminate the RSD effect directly in future large galaxy surveys, and to reconstruct the 3-D cosmic velocity field accurately.
[ 0.013433504849672318, 0.022041862830519676, 0.050856295973062515, 0.02266206219792366, -0.01223031897097826, -0.0009799139807000756, -0.022339558228850365, -0.00038510464946739376, 0.004418916068971157, 0.050285711884498596, -0.013309464789927006, 0.0029211360961198807, -0.04259524866938591, -0.007113679312169552, 0.025341320782899857, -0.026494890451431274, 0.007355556823313236, 0.021099161356687546, -0.018643174320459366, 0.04686221480369568, 0.014463034458458424, 0.002544365357607603, -0.01161012053489685, -0.020268093794584274, -0.024113327264785767, -0.02850433439016342, 0.039246175438165665, 0.03808020055294037, 0.05636366084218025, -0.05537134408950806, -0.026767777279019356, -0.03994079679250717, -0.023480724543333054, -0.04497681185603142, -0.024907181039452553, 0.1241389811038971, -0.03599633276462555, 0.023741208016872406, -0.05224554240703583, 0.0020327013917267323, -0.018754810094833374, 0.012701669707894325, 0.0011256607249379158, 0.006803580094128847, -0.000461660441942513, -0.02644527330994606, -0.017874127253890038, -0.04616759344935417, -0.026891816407442093, -0.020925505086779594, -0.051054760813713074, 0.04676298424601555, -0.05298978090286255, -0.025800267234444618, -0.02134723961353302, 0.00288237351924181, -0.0020792162977159023, 0.0301168505102396, 0.0065306928008794785, 0.010847276076674461, -0.006766368169337511, -0.023542743176221848, 0.0183330737054348, 0.026867009699344635, -0.016695749014616013, 0.011405454948544502, -0.03210148587822914, 0.01586468331515789, -0.012298541143536568, 0.01900288835167885, 0.017923742532730103, -0.0028374092653393745, 0.022525617852807045, 0.0056252023205161095, 0.02681739255785942, -0.008062583394348621, 0.013582352548837662, 0.055123262107372284, -0.047457605600357056, 0.0100534213706851, 0.02484516054391861, 0.010493762791156769, 0.04495200514793396, -0.01879202201962471, -0.043686799705028534, -0.0017908238805830479, 0.018953273072838783, -0.03450785577297211, -0.05561942234635353, 0.0568598210811615, 0.0056717172265052795, 0.048698004335165024, -0.006437662988901138, -0.004465430974960327, -0.01176516991108656, -0.0032622453290969133, 0.030290506780147552, -0.04083388298749924, 0.09213672578334808, 0.011969835497438908, 0.030761856585741043, 0.026519697159528732, 0.016125166788697243, -0.06906533241271973, 0.054924800992012024, 0.0026125870645046234, 0.0010768200736492872, 0.00921615306288004, 0.003063781652599573, -0.004034392535686493, 0.014773134142160416, 0.0038173231296241283, -0.010667418129742146, -0.04428219050168991, -0.005705828312784433, -0.030761856585741043, -0.03984156623482704, 0.001976883504539728, -0.0014853759203106165, 0.027908943593502045, 0.043215446174144745, 0.023307068273425102, 0.02850433439016342, 0.009265769273042679, 0.019139332696795464, -0.03654211014509201, -0.00016755056276451796, -0.03545055910944939, -0.020813869312405586, 0.004998801741749048, 0.02674296870827675, -0.014984001405537128, 0.012292338535189629, 0.005767848342657089, -0.04639086499810219, 0.007082669530063868, -0.00377701036632061, -0.04986397922039032, -0.004750722087919712, -0.0014512650668621063, -0.033763617277145386, 0.028305869549512863, -0.006499682553112507, 0.0049832966178655624, 0.004335189238190651, 0.019623087719082832, -0.0177500881254673, -0.007119881454855204, 0.0028513637371361256, 0.005572485737502575, -0.03932059928774834, 0.020627809688448906, -0.01161012053489685, -0.06584029644727707, -0.008037775754928589, -0.009687503799796104, 0.0035134258214384317, 0.029719922691583633, -0.029447035863995552, -0.02126041240990162, -0.024535061791539192, 0.015629008412361145, -0.02597392350435257, 0.004732116125524044, -0.02815702185034752, 0.030290506780147552, -0.030067235231399536, 0.002927338005974889, -0.04978955537080765, -0.04889646917581558, -0.017688067629933357, 0.001210937974974513, 0.0056717172265052795, -0.045944321900606155, 0.028727605938911438, 0.02862837351858616, 0.009842554107308388, 0.026842201128602028, -0.017452392727136612, -0.013123405165970325, -0.035847485065460205, 0.025353724136948586, 0.04768087714910507, -0.027933750301599503, -0.024919584393501282, 0.015802662819623947, -0.0020947211887687445, 0.06717992573976517, -0.01804778352379799, 0.0020202973391860723, -0.003029670799151063, 0.013780815526843071, 0.007256325334310532, 0.024869969114661217, -0.0746719241142273, -0.015988722443580627, 0.0029025301337242126, 0.02305898815393448, -0.047358375042676926, -0.053783632814884186, 0.029422227293252945, -0.002508703852072358, 0.006319825071841478, -0.0659395307302475, -0.017725279554724693, -0.03798096999526024, 0.01814701408147812, -0.008564944379031658, -0.0154801607131958, 0.018655577674508095, 0.030067235231399536, -0.03418535366654396, 0.022426385432481766, -0.006884206086397171, -0.009389808401465416, -0.013768412172794342, -0.04969032108783722, 0.05760405957698822, 0.028777221217751503, 0.03815462440252304, -0.029050108045339584, 0.009687503799796104, 0.010872083716094494, 0.010834871791303158, 0.005355415865778923, -0.013048981316387653, 0.04192543402314186, -0.047383181750774384, 0.008422298356890678, -0.02674296870827675, 0.03939502313733101, 0.024237366393208504, 0.003907252103090286, 0.007262527011334896, -0.0006194234592840075, 0.026991048827767372, -0.00029963350971229374, -0.006201987154781818, -0.02567622810602188, -0.02059059776365757, -0.006561702582985163, 0.05003763362765312, 0.03445824235677719, -0.02748720720410347, 0.00850292481482029, 0.011225597001612186, -0.0228729285299778, 0.019685108214616776, 0.05467671900987625, -0.01851913332939148, 0.026271618902683258, 0.01936260424554348, -0.013309464789927006, -0.03912213444709778, -0.033019378781318665, 0.045274507254362106, -0.03713750094175339, 0.0290997251868248, -0.0008357177721336484, 0.010890689678490162, -0.039047710597515106, -0.01614997535943985, -0.01322263665497303, -0.002009443938732147, -0.027834519743919373, 0.005693424493074417, 0.032250333577394485, 0.0008465712890028954, -0.0031289025209844112, 0.03770808130502701, -0.03440862521529198, -0.006815983913838863, 0.008633166551589966, -0.043959684669971466, -0.03825385868549347, 0.06092832237482071, -0.04195024073123932, 0.023009372875094414, 0.01936260424554348, -0.016559306532144547, -0.0075292126275599, -0.018246246501803398, 0.02709028124809265, 0.0237163994461298, -0.005774050019681454, 0.007405173033475876, -0.024721121415495872, 0.028950877487659454, -0.007981957867741585, -0.03770808130502701, 0.04420776665210724, -0.0824120044708252, -0.04100754112005234, -0.02190541848540306, -0.03798096999526024, -0.009048699401319027, 0.04187581688165665, 0.020230881869792938, -0.020094439387321472, 0.022079074755311012, 0.040188878774642944, 0.0025738247204571962, 0.020640213042497635, 0.0045522586442530155, -0.016224399209022522, -0.0010760447476059198, 0.013768412172794342, 0.028578758239746094, 0.023877650499343872, 0.014859961345791817, -0.04249601811170578, 0.07387807220220566, 0.01266445778310299, -0.0009489040821790695, 0.004694904200732708, -0.03927098214626312, -0.019784338772296906, -0.01851913332939148, 0.07109957933425903, -0.042471207678318024, -0.07933582365512848, -0.045373737812042236, 0.014971597120165825, 0.005411233752965927, 0.00891845766454935, -0.0524936206638813, 0.003746000351384282, -0.01663373038172722, -0.0026606526225805283, 0.006174078211188316, -0.006077947560697794, 0.003652970539405942, 0.039345405995845795, 0.027536824345588684, -0.018680386245250702, -0.04656451940536499, -0.012924941256642342, 0.04750722274184227, -0.007665656507015228, -0.015579392202198505, -0.013718795962631702, 0.0324736051261425, 0.017973359674215317, -0.010872083716094494, 0.04403410851955414, 0.04351314157247543, 0.009749524295330048, 0.02078906074166298, 0.060779474675655365, -0.012385368347167969, -0.018742404878139496, 0.0003883994650095701, 0.02957107499241829, -0.00491197407245636, 0.06767608225345612, -0.03619479760527611, -0.0033800830133259296, -0.016782578080892563, -0.010165057145059109, -0.014053703285753727, -0.016087954863905907, -0.03624441474676132, 0.05289054661989212, 0.0290997251868248, 0.016001127660274506, 0.028380293399095535, -0.014537458308041096, 0.02654450573027134, -0.03180379047989845, -0.03738557919859886, -0.014401014894247055, -0.014438226819038391, -0.019040100276470184, 0.021409260109066963, -0.06187102571129799, 0.004338290076702833, 0.03520248085260391, 0.02587469108402729, 0.015430544503033161, 0.0496407076716423, 0.04219832271337509, 0.011492282152175903, -0.01841990277171135, -0.05259285122156143, 0.00722531508654356, 0.01984635926783085, 0.002466840436682105, -0.03626922145485878, -0.04951666668057442, 0.010109239257872105, -0.010270491242408752, -0.020813869312405586, -0.02994319424033165, 0.015331313014030457, 0.005609697662293911, -0.007070265710353851, 0.020069630816578865, 0.02577545866370201, 0.01822143793106079, 0.07447346299886703, -0.025477763265371323, -0.016013531014323235, -0.03748480975627899, -0.051699765026569366, -0.02815702185034752, 0.04331468045711517, -0.026594121009111404, 0.05800098553299904, 0.030141659080982208, 0.02795855887234211, 0.04579547420144081, -0.06549298763275146, 0.020615406334400177, -0.045200083404779434, 0.018196631222963333, 0.011957431212067604, 0.0071632955223321915, 0.043116215616464615, -0.03232475742697716, 0.05909253656864166, 0.026395658031105995, -0.013768412172794342, -0.022463597357273102, 0.0026870109140872955, -0.023952074348926544, 0.013954471796751022, 0.05145168676972389, 0.06345873326063156, -0.013557543978095055, -0.02785932645201683, -0.002859116066247225, 0.05224554240703583, 0.007826907560229301, -0.03865078464150429, -0.01737796887755394, 0.009197547100484371, 0.023555148392915726, -0.002398618496954441, 0.026569314301013947, 0.0095448587089777, 0.014599477872252464, -0.034433431923389435, -0.027338359504938126, -0.060035236179828644, 0.04041215032339096, -0.01784931868314743, -0.015901895239949226, 0.019610684365034103, 0.006211290135979652, -0.02295975759625435, -0.02180618792772293, 0.029447035863995552, -0.0380057767033577, 0.011082950979471207, -0.05735597759485245, -0.017043061554431915, 0.03267206996679306, -0.020131651312112808, 0.02463429421186447, -0.03865078464150429, -0.011107759550213814, 0.043116215616464615, -0.014859961345791817, 0.04259524866938591, -0.022984564304351807, 0.026370849460363388, 0.009234759025275707, -0.007188103161752224, 0.011355838738381863, 0.0277600958943367, 0.01567862369120121, -0.04259524866938591, 0.03190302103757858, -0.010481358505785465, -0.005609697662293911, -0.0028746211901307106, -0.023282259702682495, -0.01812220737338066, 0.03582267835736275, 0.024522658437490463, 0.05740559473633766, -0.0000032675509373802925, 0.004477834794670343, 0.01719190925359726, 0.023592360317707062, 0.029496651142835617, 0.020913101732730865, 0.061325252056121826, -0.031778983771800995, 0.02957107499241829, -0.001577630522660911, -0.014351398684084415, 0.08226315677165985, -0.011976037174463272, -0.0022234125062823296, -0.009513848461210728, 0.003668475430458784, 0.011064345017075539, -0.01283811405301094, 0.020999928936362267, 0.06167256087064743, -0.018345478922128677, 0.04715991020202637, 0.028851645067334175, -0.018928464502096176, 0.019250968471169472, -0.038105010986328125, 0.004970892798155546, -0.02870279736816883, 0.04512565955519676, 0.0019365705084055662, 0.08032813668251038, -0.002314891666173935, -0.01869278959929943, 0.010264288634061813, 0.02021847851574421, -0.013445908203721046, 0.006481076590716839, 0.03296976536512375, 0.00312735210172832, 0.029918387532234192, 0.00991077534854412, -0.005891887936741114, 0.021558107808232307, 0.012497004121541977, -0.01616237871348858, -0.0396927185356617, -0.11362040787935257, -0.050955526530742645, -0.013011769391596317, -0.007783493958413601, -0.01992078311741352, 0.0033862851560115814, -0.002319543156772852, -0.011120162904262543, -0.00986736174672842, -0.01643526554107666, -0.012304742820560932, -0.022426385432481766, 0.011411656625568867, 0.006031432654708624, -0.019325392320752144, 0.016187187284231186, 0.010202269069850445, 0.009842554107308388, 0.036517299711704254, -0.00863936822861433, 0.020900696516036987, 0.029769539833068848, 0.004012685734778643, 0.01747719943523407, -0.023468319326639175, 0.01322263665497303, 0.007802099920809269, 0.0020761152263730764, 0.01113876886665821, 0.013545140624046326, 0.003773909294977784, 0.02444823458790779, -0.04061061143875122, -0.002555218758061528, -0.008180420845746994, -0.0496407076716423, 0.010282894596457481, 0.009185142815113068, -0.011647332459688187, 0.0009116921573877335, -0.035748254507780075, -0.029769539833068848, 0.024894777685403824, -0.02967030741274357, 0.006034533493220806, 0.014487842097878456, -0.04770568758249283, -0.008428500965237617, 0.005876382812857628, 0.0027366268914192915, -0.008533934131264687, 0.027512015774846077, -0.020441750064492226, -0.021173585206270218, 0.00826724898070097, 0.012131087481975555, 0.008074987679719925, -0.05269208550453186, -0.026370849460363388, -0.004642187617719173, -0.020379729568958282, 0.014301782473921776, 0.02343110740184784, 0.0336395800113678, 0.0033149621449410915, -0.007051659747958183, 0.0032157304231077433, -0.026197195053100586, 0.005494960583746433, 0.016683345660567284, 0.007262527011334896, 0.025006413459777832, 0.0075416164472699165, -0.000489569385536015, 0.014053703285753727, -0.023282259702682495, -0.04214870557188988, -0.024026498198509216, -0.0016652336344122887, -0.021781379356980324, 0.013495524413883686, -0.023369088768959045, -0.007963351905345917, -0.0014489393215626478, 0.016460074111819267, -0.022525617852807045, -0.026222001761198044, 0.012676862068474293, -0.022810909897089005, -0.01850672997534275, 0.0065492987632751465, 0.01072323601692915, 0.02350553125143051, -0.01180858351290226, -0.021396856755018234, 0.01727873645722866, -0.02170695550739765, 0.05805060267448425, -0.0004798787704203278, -0.017886530607938766, -0.00803157314658165, -0.021024737507104874, -0.040660228580236435, 0.0027598843444138765, -0.01195122953504324, 0.013160617090761662, -0.02183099463582039, 0.01653449796140194, 0.002299386775121093, 0.006940023973584175, 0.02077665738761425, -0.014140531420707703, -0.03879963234066963, 0.013954471796751022, 0.025477763265371323, 0.007802099920809269, -0.0370134599506855, 0.024497849866747856, 0.002513355342671275, -0.014326591044664383, -0.016013531014323235, -0.019015293568372726, -0.029025301337242126, -0.007002043537795544, -0.024721121415495872, 0.05006244033575058, 0.02340630069375038, 0.013532736338675022, 0.01063020620495081, -0.009668897837400436, -0.00015369299217127264, 0.015145253390073776, -0.01850672997534275, -0.013011769391596317, 0.024956796318292618, 0.01090929564088583, -0.028727605938911438, 0.0027102683670818806, -0.003640566486865282, -0.009240960702300072, 0.02880202978849411, -0.016670942306518555, 0.014190146699547768, 0.03098512813448906, 0.020131651312112808, -0.004843751899898052, 0.015653815120458603, -0.024299386888742447, -0.00590429175645113, 0.019796743988990784, -0.037261538207530975, 0.006251603364944458, 0.0007977306377142668, 0.020851081237196922, -0.0034203960094600916, -0.004970892798155546, -0.0019923883955925703, 0.015591796487569809, 0.038675591349601746, -0.0007628444582223892, -0.007088871672749519, 0.0070268516428768635, 0.013048981316387653, -0.005749242380261421, -0.0011217844439670444, 0.01861836574971676, 0.021843399852514267, -0.009396011009812355, -0.0025691732298582792, -0.003739798441529274, 0.006028331816196442, 0.022141095250844955, -0.024969201534986496, 0.001832687295973301, 0.021979842334985733, 0.02614757791161537, -0.051997460424900055, -0.024770736694335938, -0.023257452994585037, -0.026842201128602028, -0.019945591688156128, 0.012999365106225014, -0.045175276696681976, 0.022438790649175644, 0.03361476957798004, -0.01803537830710411, -0.0017179504502564669, -0.020330114290118217, 0.004217351321130991, -0.0034979209303855896, -0.001251250971108675, -0.030191274359822273, -0.014388610608875751, -0.03902290388941765, 0.02173176407814026, -0.057752907276153564, 0.014351398684084415, 0.02314581722021103, -0.0496407076716423, -0.02416294254362583, 0.00887504406273365, -0.028355486690998077, -0.004902671091258526, 0.0306130088865757, -0.004189442377537489, -0.008341672830283642, -0.03619479760527611, 0.010729437693953514, 0.008391289040446281, -0.020094439387321472, 0.0003790964838117361, -0.02540333941578865, 0.0025831277016550303, 0.00030428500031121075, 0.0016435266006737947, 0.0026544504798948765, 0.012497004121541977, -0.028032982721924782, 0.01114497147500515, 0.05078187212347984, 0.008943265303969383, -0.021768976002931595, 0.01879202201962471, 0.023480724543333054, 0.009656494483351707, -0.007442384958267212, 0.028950877487659454, -0.024609485641121864, 0.01303657703101635, 0.009929381310939789, 0.0027707377448678017, 0.03324265033006668, 0.022054266184568405, 0.007138487417250872, 0.0245598703622818, 0.030240889638662338, 0.011151173152029514, -0.0005163154564797878, -0.0033025583252310753, -0.021409260109066963, 0.00400958489626646, 0.018295861780643463, -0.0014435125049203634, -0.002494749380275607, -0.020181266590952873, 0.010022411122918129, -0.005343012046068907, 0.020007610321044922, 0.008006765507161617, 0.012298541143536568, 0.011132567189633846, -0.006015927530825138, 0.037931352853775024, -0.017167100682854652, -0.03562421351671219, 0.01053717639297247, -0.03316822648048401, -0.006112058646976948, 0.0215332992374897, -0.017328351736068726, -0.0159763190895319, 0.005544576793909073, 0.014004087075591087, 0.004077806603163481, 0.04882204532623291, -0.03979194909334183, -0.011213192716240883, -0.002562971320003271, 0.0334659218788147, -0.0004915074678137898, -0.0696607232093811, -0.005845373030751944, -0.013731200248003006, 0.005938402842730284, 0.03227514028549194, 0.023579955101013184, -0.001489252201281488, 0.028553949669003487, 0.0021396856755018234, -0.02446063794195652, 0.011541898362338543, -0.010369722731411457, -0.032349564135074615, 0.022624850273132324, 0.045845091342926025, -0.05814983323216438, -0.0237163994461298, 0.00008048047311604023, -0.008955669589340687, -0.012738881632685661, -0.013148212805390358, -0.01426457054913044, 0.0014869264559820294, -0.01450024638324976, -0.02088829316198826, 0.022587638348340988, -0.022165901958942413, -0.009898371994495392, 0.04011445492506027, -0.011349637061357498, -0.009116921573877335, -0.0077772922813892365, -0.016670942306518555, 0.06266488134860992, -0.010605398565530777, -0.0025614206679165363, -0.009619282558560371, 0.024224963039159775, -0.0301168505102396, 0.004763126373291016, -0.040015220642089844, -0.05497441440820694, 0.014202550984919071, 0.001854394213296473, 0.01859355717897415, 0.01218070276081562, -0.0007651702035218477, 0.012912537902593613, 0.005501162726432085, 0.010983719490468502, 0.020751848816871643, 0.02681739255785942, -0.016199590638279915, 0.023828035220503807, 0.005361618008464575, 0.028281062841415405, 0.01364437211304903, 0.013805624097585678, -0.008844033814966679, -0.03207667917013168, -0.02087588980793953, 0.037460003048181534, 0.02286052517592907, -0.030191274359822273, -0.06598914414644241, 0.007783493958413601, -0.03954387083649635, 0.01822143793106079, 0.021483683958649635, -0.040660228580236435, -0.01897808164358139, 0.030290506780147552, 0.010456550866365433, 0.011231798678636551, 0.05770329013466835, 0.016559306532144547, 0.017588835209608078, 0.001787722809240222, -0.05328747630119324, -0.014004087075591087, 0.005801958963274956, -0.01616237871348858, -0.012478398159146309, -0.037162307649850845, 0.002632743678987026, 0.0459195151925087, 0.0019830854143947363, -0.006760166026651859, -0.011820987798273563, 0.04214870557188988, -0.0005515892407856882, 0.0004853054997511208, 0.017018252983689308, 0.013123405165970325, -0.009650291875004768, -0.006747762206941843, 0.002485446399077773, -0.038576360791921616, 0.01850672997534275, -0.04088350012898445, -0.01784931868314743, -0.010351116769015789, -0.0169066172093153, -0.03058820217847824, 0.011541898362338543, -0.029769539833068848, -0.0008194375550374389, 0.017030656337738037, 0.02219071052968502, 0.009662696160376072, 0.05120360851287842, -0.013148212805390358, -0.02295975759625435, -0.007981957867741585, 0.012813305482268333, 0.02701585739850998, -0.02340630069375038, -0.00444372370839119, 0.027809711173176765, -0.0020683626644313335, -0.026842201128602028, -0.03296976536512375, -0.02277369797229767, 0.005498061887919903, 0.014711113646626472, -0.02890126034617424, -0.01595151051878929, -0.012497004121541977, -0.024497849866747856, 0.02305898815393448, -0.015467756427824497, -0.008813023567199707, 0.02577545866370201, -0.009805342182517052, -0.020441750064492226, 0.016497286036610603, 0.028752412647008896, 0.01524448487907648, -0.005206568166613579, 0.03579787164926529, -0.033589962869882584, 0.028181830421090126, -0.02709028124809265, -0.0037987171672284603, 0.025254491716623306, 0.0005232926923781633, 0.0096316859126091, -0.04681260138750076, 0.05507364869117737, 0.029447035863995552, -0.006034533493220806, -0.00462978333234787, 0.013557543978095055, -0.01308619324117899, -0.006105856504291296, 0.011064345017075539, 0.005383324809372425, 0.02397688291966915, -0.029968002811074257, 0.02728874422609806, 0.027065472677350044, 0.04723433405160904, -0.025105644017457962, 0.00006037246930645779, -0.00588258495554328, -0.0068904077634215355, -0.0496407076716423, 0.0031754174269735813, -0.02041694149374962, -0.0074857985600829124, -0.005042215809226036, -0.026122771203517914, 0.014537458308041096, 0.021409260109066963, 0.01786172389984131, 0.01269546803086996, -0.020243287086486816, -0.003079286776483059, 0.015901895239949226, 0.02417534589767456, 0.009358799085021019, -0.038601167500019073, -0.0057523432187736034, -0.0028265556320548058, 0.038774825632572174, 0.014128127135336399, -0.02738797664642334, -0.017303545027971268, 0.005420536734163761, 0.013979279436171055, -0.03837789595127106, 0.04711029678583145, -0.01887884922325611, 0.04276890307664871, 0.04418295621871948, 0.030364930629730225, -0.07308422029018402, 0.04105715453624725, -0.03825385868549347, -0.017043061554431915, -0.017415180802345276, -0.05194784700870514, 0.0032653464004397392, -0.047755300998687744, -0.010028613731265068, 0.032647259533405304, 0.0039103529416024685, -0.009892169386148453, -0.030712241306900978, -0.04936781898140907, 0.004282472189515829, 0.014376206323504448, 0.05078187212347984, 0.0353265181183815, 0.06251603364944458, -0.035946719348430634, 0.05229515582323074, -0.02407611533999443, -0.047755300998687744, -0.04460469260811806, 0.0150584252551198, -0.051054760813713074, -0.035649023950099945, 0.06474874913692474, 0.00032172809005714953, 0.030439354479312897, -0.01364437211304903, -0.009892169386148453, -0.03155571222305298, 0.005135245621204376, -0.008701387792825699, -0.013495524413883686, -0.019040100276470184, -0.03138205409049988, -0.06167256087064743, 0.0010582141112536192, -0.001843540696427226, 0.020057227462530136, 0.020441750064492226, -0.009606878273189068, 0.030538585036993027, -0.01746479608118534, -0.017700470983982086, -0.0068904077634215355, -0.002973852911964059, 0.03463189676403999, 0.029868770390748978, -0.01954866386950016, 0.010295298881828785, -0.0062950169667601585, -0.014797941781580448, 0.005535273812711239, -0.0038731410168111324, 0.000904714921489358, -0.007671858184039593, -0.01492198184132576, -0.0321262925863266, 0.0309603214263916, 0.019709914922714233, 0.016224399209022522, -0.02560180425643921, -0.0020931707695126534, -0.02361716702580452, -0.018246246501803398, 0.004294876009225845, -0.03664134070277214, -0.00495538767427206, -0.017439987510442734, 0.00907350704073906, 0.010227076709270477, 0.003556839656084776, -0.030836280435323715, 0.015008809044957161, -0.004806539975106716, -0.006629924289882183, 0.017328351736068726, 0.021123968064785004, 0.0022141095250844955, -0.013855239376425743, 0.030389737337827682, -0.008813023567199707, -0.01596391573548317, -0.03927098214626312, 0.024621888995170593, -0.02350553125143051, 0.012738881632685661, -0.015939107164740562, 0.0025986325927078724, 0.04554739594459534, -0.006933821830898523, -0.01407851092517376, 0.014202550984919071, 0.0017768694087862968, -0.0027567832730710506, -0.006341531872749329, -0.004077806603163481, 0.010797659866511822, -0.003966170828789473, 0.028752412647008896, -0.011231798678636551, 0.002398618496954441, 0.01269546803086996, 0.010493762791156769, -0.0070640635676681995, -0.0034172949381172657, -0.026222001761198044, -0.01605074293911457, -0.009941785596311092, -0.025998730212450027, -0.018395094200968742, 0.028305869549512863, -0.024894777685403824, 0.035103246569633484, 0.022426385432481766, 0.013148212805390358, 0.010357318446040154, -0.005212770309299231, 0.005525970831513405, 0.010481358505785465, -0.004422016907483339, -0.02219071052968502, -0.012862921692430973, 0.006878003943711519, 0.011293819174170494, -0.014959193766117096, -0.015629008412361145, -0.014227358624339104, 0.0015055324183776975, 0.025080837309360504, 0.022165901958942413, 0.022649656981229782, 0.027536824345588684, 0.01167214009910822, -0.022823313251137733, -0.018444709479808807, -0.015070829540491104, 0.02219071052968502, 0.007119881454855204, 0.05073225498199463, 0.007628444582223892, -0.007287335116416216, -0.009023891761898994, -0.005547677632421255, -0.007591232657432556, -0.01849432662129402, 0.019052505493164062, 0.005315103102475405, -0.003944464027881622, -0.00460807653144002, 0.020702233538031578, 0.06201987341046333, -0.024907181039452553, 0.00940221268683672, -0.023294664919376373, -0.00371809140779078, -0.016484882682561874, -0.031009936705231667, 0.03222552686929703, 0.024113327264785767, 0.0028312071226537228, 0.0032591442577540874, 0.02003241889178753, -0.016373246908187866, 0.0021412360947579145, 0.05053379386663437, 0.006313622929155827, 0.0020528577733784914, 0.006341531872749329, -0.005854676011949778, 0.01662132516503334, -0.02560180425643921, 0.019982803612947464, -0.023579955101013184, 0.003668475430458784, 0.019759532064199448, -0.04616759344935417, 0.030067235231399536, 0.008837832137942314, 0.015616604126989841, 0.03155571222305298, 0.001801677281036973, -0.011616322211921215, 0.001159771578386426, 0.006205088458955288, 0.0005201916792429984, -0.0047259144484996796, -0.000780287547968328, 0.00743618281558156, 0.006400451064109802, -0.0070082456804811954, 0.018159419298171997, -0.003547536674886942, -0.0061616743914783, -0.004663894418627024, -0.024299386888742447, -0.0019474240252748132, -0.010692225769162178, 0.02134723961353302, 0.01482274942100048, 0.0075416164472699165, 0.0038576361257582903, 0.025366127490997314, -0.009941785596311092, -0.012255126610398293, 0.004288674332201481, 0.02428698167204857, -0.0022094580344855785, 0.017526816576719284, 0.029794346541166306, 0.004263866227120161, -0.018395094200968742, -0.024150539189577103, -0.03723673149943352, 0.02522968500852585, -0.0009659595089033246, -0.00896807387471199, -0.005724434275180101, -0.0031242510303854942, -0.007101275492459536, -0.023939670994877815, -0.03326746076345444, -0.004332087934017181, -0.004394107963889837, -0.027809711173176765, 0.0013659877004101872, -0.0032405382953584194, -0.019598279148340225, -0.0007798998849466443, -0.04611797630786896, -0.01038212701678276, -0.023542743176221848, 0.010400732979178429, -0.016794981434941292, 0.014165339060127735, -0.037360772490501404, 0.014996405690908432, -0.00581126194447279, 0.019610684365034103, -0.030861089006066322, 0.040263302624225616, -0.03674057126045227, -0.002466840436682105, 0.020727042108774185, -0.018680386245250702, 0.0223767701536417, -0.008298259228467941, -0.03932059928774834, -0.007374162785708904, 0.02181859128177166, -0.0021179786417633295, -0.00741137471050024, 0.004307280294597149, 0.009414616972208023, -0.013433504849672318, 0.0292733795940876, 0.03031531348824501, -0.042545631527900696, -0.05656212568283081, 0.017402775585651398, 0.00018499365251045674, 0.0013776164269074798, 0.005572485737502575, 0.029223764315247536, -0.00944562628865242, 0.00859595462679863, 0.035177670419216156, 0.014959193766117096, 0.009644090197980404, -0.003677778411656618, 0.007932341657578945, 0.010704630054533482, 0.023579955101013184, 0.023121008649468422, -0.004043695516884327, -0.014487842097878456, -0.013185424730181694, -0.009966593235731125, -0.0016714355442672968, -0.0035816477611660957, -0.0026854604948312044, -0.026867009699344635, 0.005981816910207272, 0.01063020620495081, 0.020627809688448906, 0.011200789362192154, 0.013247445225715637, -0.019685108214616776, 0.005249982234090567, -0.011690746061503887, 0.0010148001601919532, 0.04125561937689781, 0.002466840436682105, -0.029893578961491585, -0.02076425403356552, -0.005575586576014757, -0.012676862068474293, 0.01283811405301094, 0.01746479608118534, 0.011727957986295223, -0.0356738306581974, -0.0012566776713356376, 0.00836027879267931, -0.007361758965998888, 0.010344915091991425, -0.010165057145059109, -0.03842751309275627, -0.02862837351858616, -0.050012826919555664, 0.006791176274418831, -0.004412713926285505, -0.02919895574450493, -0.0168197900056839, -0.0020637111738324165, 0.023939670994877815, 0.015517372637987137, -0.03202706202864647, -0.012441186234354973, -0.030761856585741043, -0.044827964156866074, -0.01529410108923912, -0.004043695516884327, -0.011039537377655506, -0.00019187398720532656, 0.004446825012564659, -0.019325392320752144, -0.05393248051404953, -0.004611177369952202, -0.02209147810935974, -0.04316583275794983, 0.015232080593705177, -0.0007857142481952906, -0.026594121009111404, -0.026668544858694077, -0.00845330860465765, 0.013979279436171055, 0.014301782473921776, -0.013706391677260399, 0.02919895574450493, 0.0077772922813892365, -0.011386848986148834, 0.019213756546378136, 0.0016807385254651308, -0.00583607004955411, 0.039618294686079025, -0.011895411647856236, 0.05676058679819107, 0.034706320613622665, -0.02530410885810852, -0.020813869312405586, 0.04921897128224373, -0.030761856585741043, -0.026271618902683258, 0.007076467387378216, -0.02057819440960884, -0.0010194516507908702, 0.016100358217954636, 0.005600394681096077, -0.007963351905345917, 0.022798504680395126, 0.011163577437400818, -0.009315384551882744, -0.02104954421520233, -0.01152949407696724, 0.01849432662129402, -0.001495454227551818, 0.003851434215903282, 0.003941362723708153, 0.008161814883351326, -0.015790259465575218, -0.0014078511158004403, 0.05924138426780701, 0.011851998046040535, -0.0033738811034709215, 0.005377123132348061, -0.004577066749334335, 0.012962153181433678, 0.011312425136566162, -0.012112481519579887, 0.006369440816342831, 0.011870604008436203, -0.00651208683848381, -0.02614757791161537, 0.013569948263466358, -0.028777221217751503, -0.0006698146462440491, 0.007101275492459536, 0.0013225737493485212, 0.0247335247695446, 0.0027211220003664494, 0.006791176274418831, 0.00592909986153245, 0.011349637061357498, 0.05100514367222786, 0.024783141911029816, -0.013954471796751022, 0.061424482613801956, 0.024994008243083954, 0.036418069154024124, -0.04279371351003647, 0.017787300050258636, -0.0551728792488575, 0.03316822648048401, -0.027710478752851486, -0.008391289040446281, 0.01963549107313156, -0.05078187212347984, 0.0413796603679657, -0.035004016011953354, -0.010940305888652802, 0.028653182089328766, 0.016844596713781357, -0.007355556823313236, 0.031034745275974274, -0.02389005571603775, 0.017551623284816742, -0.00502671068534255, -0.01530650444328785, 0.01672055758535862, -0.006462470628321171, -0.003621960524469614, -0.003547536674886942, -0.010028613731265068, -0.02126041240990162, 0.01524448487907648, 0.04058580473065376, -0.011399252340197563, -0.01482274942100048, -0.023914862424135208, 0.010276692919433117, -0.0034265979193150997, 0.04135484993457794, 0.0073183448985219, 0.015629008412361145, -0.020044822245836258, -0.01918894797563553, 0.015405736863613129, -0.013197829015552998, 0.04185101017355919, -0.027983367443084717, 0.05452787131071091, 0.014413418248295784, 0.023914862424135208, 0.004936781711876392, -0.007355556823313236, -0.005851575173437595, -0.02815702185034752, -0.0038266261108219624, -0.00449023861438036, 0.01350792869925499, -0.015926703810691833, 0.028032982721924782, -0.0050112055614590645, -0.0068718018010258675, 0.013631967827677727, 0.009786736220121384, -0.000453907938208431, 0.00035758333979174495, -0.009036295115947723, -0.01529410108923912, 0.005767848342657089, 0.03698865324258804, 0.03334188461303711, -0.008242441341280937, 0.029819155111908913, 0.014773134142160416, 0.003907252103090286, 0.007864119485020638, 0.03842751309275627, 0.002493198961019516, 0.051600534468889236, 0.001817182288505137, 0.007386567071080208, 0.03200225532054901, 0.010524772107601166, 0.036045949906110764, 0.00003602482320275158, -0.0006543096387758851, -0.020640213042497635, 0.039146944880485535, 0.012608639895915985, 0.022327154874801636, -0.040015220642089844, 0.013383888639509678, 0.025428147986531258, 0.028727605938911438, 0.0009271971066482365, 0.010983719490468502, 0.02597392350435257, -0.0021986044012010098, -0.023108605295419693, -0.00038045315886847675, -0.023269856348633766, -0.012255126610398293, -0.01830826699733734, -0.005367820151150227, -0.016460074111819267, -0.003603354562073946, -0.0091665368527174, 0.0028761716093868017, -0.014438226819038391, -0.006716752424836159, -0.010729437693953514, -0.021694552153348923, -0.009569666348397732, 0.021843399852514267, 0.009482838213443756, -0.0032312353141605854, 0.019312988966703415, 0.005988018587231636, -0.004400310106575489, -0.025366127490997314, -0.0009597575408406556, -0.021682146936655045, -0.003646768629550934, -0.02211628668010235, 0.008161814883351326, -0.005160053260624409, -0.020900696516036987, -0.0322999507188797, -0.019126929342746735, 0.03294495493173599, 0.019027696922421455, 0.00004120929952478036, -0.000774085521697998, -0.056909434497356415, -0.05730636417865753, -0.009321587160229683, 0.013148212805390358, 0.01719190925359726, -0.018370285630226135, 0.01832067035138607, 0.003941362723708153, 0.0277600958943367, -0.014698710292577744, 0.0277600958943367, 0.025750651955604553, -0.023443512618541718, 0.0003556451993063092, -0.019796743988990784 ]
11.795493
3.215402
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.tmp.1658C
[ "individual galaxies", "future large galaxy surveys", "different galaxy formation models", "galaxy counts", "large scales", "real space", "redshift space", "large clusters", "artificial neural networks", "different cosmological models" ]
[ "cosmology: large-scale structure of Universe", "cosmology: theory", "methods: data analysis", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies" ]
21
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1682", "10.48550/arXiv.2312.03469" ]
[ "Chen, Hongxiang", "Wang, Jie", "Mao, Tianxiang", "Ma, Juntao", "Meng, Yuxi", "Li, Baojiu", "Cai, Yan-Chuan", "Neyrinck, Mark", "Falck, Bridget", "Szalay, Alexander S." ]
[ "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China; School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China;", "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China; School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China", "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China; School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China;", "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China; School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China", "National Astronomical Observatories, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China; School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China", "Institute for Computational Cosmology, Department of Physics, Durham University, Durham DH1 3LE, UK;", "Institute for Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, Royal Observatory, Blackford Hill, Edinburgh EH9 3HJ, UK", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Denver, Denver, CO 80210, USA; Blue Marble Space Institute of Science, Seattle, WA 98104, USA;", "Independent Researcher, Baltimore, MD 21201, USA", "Department of Physics and Astronomy, The Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA" ]
null
[ "1972CoASP...4..173S", "1972MNRAS.156P...1J", "1979Natur.281..358A", "1980MNRAS.190..413S", "1985ApJ...292..371D", "1987MNRAS.227....1K", "1991ApJ...372..380Y", "1991ApJ...379....6N", "1991MNRAS.251..128L", "1993ApJ...412...64L", "1994MNRAS.267.1020P", "1995MNRAS.272..885F", "1995PhR...261..271S", "1997MNRAS.285..793C", "1998ASSL..231..185H", "1998ApJ...498L...1S", "1999MNRAS.308....1B", "2000MNRAS.316..464K", "2000Natur.405..947H", "2001MNRAS.328..726S", "2002ApJ...579...76L", "2002MNRAS.335...53B", "2004PhRvD..70h3007S", "2005MNRAS.364.1105S", "2006MNRAS.373...45E", "2009ApJS..180..225H", "2009MNRAS.394..398W", "2010PhRvD..82f3522T", "2011JCAP...11..039S", "2011MNRAS.413..101G", "2012MNRAS.420.1809W", "2012MNRAS.425.2880M", "2013ApJS..208...20B", "2013PhRvD..87f3526Z", "2013PhRvD..88j3510Z", "2014arXiv1412.6980K", "2015MNRAS.450..317C", "2015Natur.521..436L", "2016ApJ...833..241S", "2016MNRAS.456.1886S", "2017arXiv170705167S", "2017arXiv171102033R", "2018PhRvD..98l3518F", "2019ApJ...887..265Y", "2019MNRAS.487..104M", "2019PhRvD.100b3508P", "2020MNRAS.497.3451W", "2020MNRAS.498.2703B", "2021MNRAS.501.1499M", "2021MNRAS.506.2659F", "2021MNRAS.507.1557L", "2022A&A...662A..48T", "2022ApJ...929..132V", "2023ApJ...952...69D", "2023ApJ...956..149S", "2023JCAP...06..062Q", "2023MNRAS.522.4748W", "2023MNRAS.522.5291G", "2023PASA...40....1H" ]
29184339
2312.17053
Galaxy–Galaxy Lensing Data: f(T) Gravity Challenges General Relativity
We use galaxy–galaxy lensing data to test general relativity and f(T) gravity at galaxy scales. We consider an exact spherically symmetric solution of f(T) theory, which is obtained from an approximate quadratic correction, and thus it is expected to hold for every realistic deviation from general relativity. Quantifying the deviation by a single parameter Q, and following the post-Newtonian approximation, we obtain the corresponding deviation in the gravitational potential, shear component, and effective excess surface density profile. We used five stellar mass samples and divided them into blue and red galaxies to test the model dependence on galaxy color, and we modeled the excess surface density profiles using the Navarro–Frenk–White profiles. Based on the group catalog from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 7 (SDSS DR7) we finally extract Mpc<SUP>‑2</SUP> at 1σ confidence. This result indicates that f(T) corrections on top of general relativity are favored. Finally, we apply information criteria, such as the Akaike and Bayesian ones, and although the dependence of f(T) gravity on the off-center effect implies that its optimality needs to be carefully studied, our analysis shows that f(T) gravity is more efficient in fitting the data compared to general relativity and the ΛCDM paradigm, and thus it offers a challenge to the latter.
[ 0.008536096662282944, 0.009761697612702847, 0.017601849511265755, -0.016025196760892868, 0.016382407397031784, -0.02421640045940876, -0.03609056770801544, 0.012151312083005905, -0.03352850675582886, 0.014990518800914288, -0.04256962612271309, 0.009576933458447456, -0.0829220786690712, -0.006297372747212648, 0.006645345129072666, 0.02234412543475628, 0.014904296025633812, -0.0077539291232824326, -0.0020970713812857866, 0.024068590253591537, -0.008517620153725147, -0.03557322919368744, 0.02628575824201107, 0.02452434040606022, -0.018451765179634094, -0.01502747181802988, 0.023070864379405975, 0.027566788718104362, 0.04224936664104462, -0.02951296791434288, -0.0064790574833750725, -0.018907515332102776, -0.06833804398775101, -0.02140798792243004, -0.01207740604877472, 0.08553341031074524, 0.04725031182169914, 0.0357949435710907, -0.0033103548921644688, -0.03852945193648338, -0.035671766847372055, 0.012440775521099567, -0.008665431290864944, 0.020348675549030304, -0.005225741770118475, -0.060651861131191254, 0.008258950896561146, -0.016493266448378563, -0.024142496287822723, -0.011523114517331123, -0.02670455537736416, -0.04178129881620407, 0.01597592607140541, -0.017946742475032806, -0.02164202183485031, -0.0029007946141064167, -0.0386279933154583, -0.0031533055007457733, 0.033774856477975845, -0.0003381565911695361, -0.01889519765973091, -0.016271548345685005, 0.00178605190012604, -0.010913393460214138, -0.02877391315996647, -0.0022356442641466856, -0.02138335257768631, -0.018784338608384132, -0.0027529834769666195, 0.0722796767950058, -0.05237443372607231, -0.003144067246466875, 0.01804528385400772, -0.004806943237781525, 0.01179410144686699, -0.03779039531946182, 0.06804241985082626, 0.023970048874616623, -0.016296183690428734, -0.04404773563146591, 0.030720094218850136, 0.015261505730450153, -0.0018029886996373534, 0.016751935705542564, -0.0339965745806694, 0.0002294152945978567, 0.01188032515347004, -0.009564615786075592, -0.06400224566459656, 0.017293909564614296, 0.04749666526913643, -0.019412536174058914, -0.02260279469192028, 0.01390657015144825, -0.008659272454679012, -0.0412885956466198, 0.05754782631993294, -0.009392169304192066, 0.04959065467119217, -0.00675620324909687, 0.006017147563397884, 0.047545935958623886, 0.01045148354023695, -0.049664560705423355, 0.09671778976917267, 0.010118908248841763, 0.0009453757666051388, -0.007840151898562908, 0.017996013164520264, 0.02070588432252407, 0.0703088566660881, 0.009564615786075592, -0.0221470445394516, -0.00489932531490922, -0.03985975310206413, 0.005502887535840273, -0.05976499244570732, -0.010857963934540749, -0.04858061298727989, -0.004449733067303896, 0.009102705866098404, 0.00268369703553617, 0.03921923786401749, 0.006485216319561005, 0.03202575817704201, -0.026359662413597107, 0.01826700009405613, -0.06296756863594055, -0.05917374789714813, 0.04101760685443878, 0.021986914798617363, -0.014707214199006557, 0.015347729437053204, 0.0018414811929687858, -0.027665328234434128, 0.004040172789245844, 0.016407042741775513, -0.005453617312014103, 0.020373309031128883, 0.001137068378739059, -0.019363267347216606, 0.006750044412910938, 0.0046622115187346935, 0.0017352418508380651, 0.025965500622987747, -0.02164202183485031, -0.006257340777665377, 0.015840433537960052, 0.031680867075920105, 0.016493266448378563, -0.03478490188717842, 0.034316834062337875, -0.02877391315996647, -0.041337866336107254, -0.019350949674844742, -0.04552584886550903, 0.024339577183127403, 0.0064790574833750725, -0.010593135841190815, -0.007532212417572737, -0.013610947877168655, 0.03702670335769653, -0.034538548439741135, 0.012921161949634552, 0.006386675406247377, -0.01335227768868208, -0.01645631343126297, -0.02670455537736416, -0.04904868081212044, -0.013500088825821877, -0.0023757570888847113, 0.016074467450380325, -0.0044805267825722694, -0.03976121172308922, 0.05434525012969971, 0.04860524833202362, 0.018119189888238907, -0.011861848644912243, -0.03520369902253151, -0.009312105365097523, -0.039046790450811386, 0.006639186292886734, -0.021851422265172005, 0.0031502260826528072, -0.051142673939466476, -0.016246914863586426, -0.002472758060321212, 0.06981615722179413, 0.028133397921919823, -0.03315897658467293, -0.025251079350709915, 0.024228718131780624, 0.06823950260877609, 0.01937558501958847, -0.057794176042079926, -0.021173954010009766, 0.014707214199006557, 0.0327894501388073, -0.04276670515537262, 0.03673108294606209, 0.02297232300043106, 0.02124786004424095, 0.04505778104066849, -0.047545935958623886, -0.03786430135369301, -0.04141176864504814, 0.042840611189603806, 0.05469014123082161, -0.07124499976634979, -0.025965500622987747, 0.016702665016055107, 0.02569451369345188, -0.013869617134332657, 0.060996752232313156, -0.022762924432754517, 0.01942485384643078, -0.03136060759425163, 0.0010469959815964103, 0.04902404546737671, 0.09750612080097198, -0.027689963579177856, 0.0338241271674633, 0.04715177044272423, 0.03766721859574318, -0.0006266578566282988, 0.020668933168053627, 0.026384297758340836, 0.00008425045962212607, -0.014411591924726963, -0.020459532737731934, 0.019535712897777557, -0.004397382959723473, -0.027098719030618668, 0.0239084605127573, 0.03308507427573204, -0.04670833796262741, 0.015273823402822018, 0.01011274941265583, 0.012225218117237091, -0.04500851035118103, -0.010710152797400951, 0.034735631197690964, -0.03214893490076065, -0.03101571649312973, -0.02401931956410408, 0.017996013164520264, -0.0112028568983078, 0.00020401024085003883, 0.042471084743738174, 0.01032214891165495, 0.0394902229309082, -0.017835883423686028, -0.02007768675684929, -0.046264905482530594, -0.027295801788568497, 0.006217308342456818, 0.003528992412611842, 0.0010023446520790458, -0.03921923786401749, 0.04392455890774727, -0.04855597764253616, -0.05882885679602623, -0.01724463887512684, -0.004606782458722591, -0.027295801788568497, 0.03549932315945625, 0.031335972249507904, -0.007655388209968805, -0.016702665016055107, 0.05089632049202919, 0.006075656041502953, 0.0011493860511109233, 0.01304433774203062, -0.027295801788568497, -0.009958779439330101, 0.015286141075193882, -0.008782448247075081, 0.021703610196709633, 0.017922107130289078, -0.032272111624479294, 0.020065369084477425, -0.018193094059824944, 0.010981139726936817, -0.004360430408269167, -0.02818266861140728, -0.013844981789588928, -0.01048227772116661, 0.04119005426764488, -0.01086412277072668, -0.030966445803642273, 0.06242559477686882, -0.027098719030618668, 0.01776197925209999, -0.02855219691991806, -0.0067993151023983955, 0.008505302481353283, 0.006719250697642565, -0.005712287034839392, -0.046609796583652496, 0.039662670344114304, -0.011831054463982582, 0.010352942161262035, -0.005213424097746611, 0.0031332895159721375, -0.010728629305958748, -0.02722189575433731, 0.04062344506382942, 0.020385626703500748, -0.04141176864504814, 0.05808980017900467, -0.026606015861034393, 0.043579667806625366, 0.015951290726661682, 0.07715744525194168, -0.008061869069933891, -0.034169021993875504, -0.04205228388309479, 0.018143825232982635, -0.009324423037469387, -0.012724080123007298, -0.019153866916894913, -0.06020842865109444, -0.0028068730607628822, 0.01889519765973091, 0.015261505730450153, -0.06237632408738136, -0.02645820379257202, -0.007365924771875143, 0.008536096662282944, 0.0016998287755995989, 0.00617419695481658, 0.004985548555850983, 0.04052490368485451, 0.010556182824075222, 0.0003906988713424653, 0.015261505730450153, -0.01563103310763836, 0.08297134935855865, -0.000618189515080303, 0.009250517003238201, -0.02820730395615101, 0.005850859917700291, 0.008160409517586231, 0.0046221790835261345, 0.0037137563340365887, 0.021346399560570717, 0.030301295220851898, 0.020755155012011528, 0.07213186472654343, 0.012613222002983093, -0.03424292802810669, 0.005213424097746611, 0.061390917748212814, -0.014165239408612251, 0.06897855550050735, -0.02934052236378193, -0.016530219465494156, -0.05882885679602623, -0.05744928494095802, -0.012490046210587025, -0.012520840391516685, -0.0072550661861896515, 0.03173013776540756, -0.004206460434943438, -0.019079962745308876, 0.02144494093954563, -0.016308501362800598, 0.032986532896757126, -0.01619764417409897, -0.04274206981062889, -0.030572282150387764, 0.046806879341602325, 0.012034295126795769, 0.0011324493680149317, -0.023120135068893433, -0.014042063616216183, 0.029783956706523895, 0.010315990075469017, 0.03328215330839157, -0.01654253713786602, 0.02707408368587494, 0.00239731278270483, -0.0164809487760067, -0.01863652840256691, 0.027197260409593582, 0.03611520305275917, -0.02121090702712536, -0.02722189575433731, -0.03771648928523064, -0.0055367611348629, -0.014904296025633812, -0.013832664117217064, -0.013303007930517197, 0.013968157581984997, 0.012797986157238483, -0.006928649730980396, 0.04830962419509888, 0.07917752861976624, 0.04385065659880638, 0.04252035543322563, 0.011319873854517937, -0.02475837618112564, -0.03884970769286156, -0.033553142100572586, 0.004151030909270048, -0.0062142289243638515, -0.03424292802810669, 0.0529656782746315, 0.007384400814771652, -0.01733086258172989, 0.03214893490076065, -0.03217357024550438, 0.016616441309452057, 0.003775344230234623, 0.003581342054530978, 0.00873933732509613, 0.025398891419172287, 0.05671022832393646, -0.02107541263103485, 0.02820730395615101, -0.02759142406284809, -0.004489765036851168, 0.01996682956814766, -0.01353704184293747, -0.06346027553081512, -0.006057179532945156, 0.020939920097589493, 0.025201808661222458, -0.0164809487760067, -0.05281786620616913, 0.011424574069678783, 0.026408933103084564, 0.018784338608384132, 0.004218778107315302, -0.010433007031679153, -0.010821010917425156, 0.054936494678258896, -0.033577777445316315, 0.005250376649200916, 0.0027868568431586027, 0.025620607659220695, -0.008357491344213486, 0.017996013164520264, -0.04917185753583908, 0.053064219653606415, 0.04030318558216095, 0.01505210716277361, 0.010999616235494614, -0.0069902376271784306, -0.005056374706327915, -0.02138335257768631, 0.011221333406865597, 0.00709493737667799, -0.032617002725601196, -0.05094559118151665, -0.018845926970243454, -0.03705133870244026, -0.04158421605825424, 0.07942388206720352, -0.08642028272151947, 0.022171679884195328, -0.0017167654586955905, -0.010827169753611088, 0.012428457848727703, -0.0209029670804739, -0.014436227269470692, 0.053261302411556244, 0.021826786920428276, -0.0015843512956053019, 0.013844981789588928, 0.009724744595587254, -0.00771697610616684, 0.042126189917325974, -0.027542153373360634, 0.0066699800081551075, 0.004295763093978167, -0.01866116374731064, 0.006780838593840599, 0.036829624325037, -0.032986532896757126, 0.06483984738588333, 0.0051179626025259495, 0.006534486543387175, 0.014066698960959911, -0.005222662352025509, 0.02667992003262043, 0.02042257972061634, 0.042126189917325974, -0.019153866916894913, -0.005582951940596104, -0.03801211342215538, -0.05823761224746704, 0.017515627667307854, -0.011750990524888039, -0.008542255498468876, -0.0030486059840768576, 0.00634356401860714, -0.012896526604890823, -0.02229485474526882, -0.011701719835400581, 0.04298842325806618, 0.005087168887257576, 0.00812961533665657, -0.009755538776516914, -0.0167396180331707, 0.04734885320067406, 0.003458166029304266, 0.010229766368865967, -0.0017567976610735059, 0.006774679757654667, -0.034316834062337875, 0.04237254336476326, -0.00805571023374796, -0.007790881674736738, 0.010968822054564953, 0.015360047109425068, -0.02225790172815323, 0.029414428398013115, 0.018772022798657417, 0.004846975672990084, 0.006497533991932869, -0.04165812209248543, -0.0363122820854187, 0.02914344146847725, -0.008486825972795486, -0.04072198271751404, -0.012483887374401093, -0.1225847527384758, -0.012810303829610348, -0.045649025589227676, -0.003316513728350401, -0.0394902229309082, -0.015458587557077408, -0.039613399654626846, -0.014768801629543304, -0.03902215510606766, -0.011264445260167122, -0.000707492115907371, -0.022159362211823463, -0.051142673939466476, 0.02486923336982727, -0.011806419119238853, 0.018008330836892128, 0.002831508172675967, 0.016407042741775513, 0.045649025589227676, 0.0022849147208034992, -0.0019215455977246165, 0.0008399063372053206, 0.0005696889711543918, 0.05010799691081047, -0.007599959149956703, -0.0063928342424333096, 0.041904475539922714, -0.03747013956308365, 0.01946180686354637, 0.03426756337285042, -0.011578544043004513, 0.010513070970773697, -0.020952237769961357, -0.007723134942352772, -0.0004746125196106732, 0.007790881674736738, 0.006583757232874632, -0.009336740709841251, -0.04828499257564545, 0.01353704184293747, -0.02744361199438572, -0.020385626703500748, 0.023354168981313705, 0.0027268086560070515, 0.011424574069678783, -0.008221997879445553, -0.04562439024448395, 0.010673199780285358, 0.005881653632968664, -0.010642406530678272, -0.0038153764326125383, 0.00987255573272705, -0.011282921768724918, -0.03342996537685394, 0.030227389186620712, -0.027147989720106125, 0.014239145442843437, -0.03916996717453003, -0.02911880612373352, 0.011652449145913124, -0.0124469343572855, 0.0032857197802513838, 0.0020631980150938034, 0.02783777564764023, -0.009595409967005253, 0.007193478289991617, -0.0032857197802513838, 0.002271057339385152, -0.0013626344734802842, -0.021617388352751732, 0.007686182390898466, -0.009324423037469387, 0.0026652205269783735, 0.003692200407385826, -0.038677264004945755, 0.007224272005259991, -0.025140220299363136, -0.02860146574676037, 0.009065753780305386, -0.004597544204443693, 0.005505966953933239, 0.005447458475828171, 0.008776289410889149, 0.01569262146949768, 0.0005962488357909024, -0.04165812209248543, -0.03441537171602249, 0.003778423648327589, -0.0236497912555933, 0.011504638008773327, 0.0002346117835259065, 0.032641638070344925, 0.03177940845489502, -0.04254499077796936, -0.02421640045940876, 0.028626101091504097, -0.021605070680379868, 0.06666284799575806, 0.011190539225935936, 0.03259236738085747, -0.02146957628428936, -0.02724653109908104, 0.014214510098099709, 0.016973651945590973, -0.030695458874106407, 0.023970048874616623, 0.009539981372654438, -0.015101376920938492, 0.015667986124753952, 0.009656998328864574, 0.002794555388391018, -0.012342235073447227, -0.03269090875983238, 0.03463708981871605, 0.01284725684672594, 0.029562238603830338, -0.020976873114705086, 0.011516955681145191, 0.009564615786075592, 0.013500088825821877, -0.010599294677376747, -0.052078813314437866, -0.021999232470989227, 0.008505302481353283, -0.006768520921468735, 0.0029331285040825605, -0.0005558317061513662, -0.0025836166460067034, 0.0036829623859375715, -0.01976974681019783, 0.01730622723698616, -0.012169788591563702, 0.007994121871888638, -0.012046612799167633, 0.009687792509794235, -0.00634356401860714, -0.024536658078432083, 0.011424574069678783, -0.02183910459280014, 0.007187319453805685, 0.029611509293317795, -0.009016483090817928, 0.006183435209095478, 0.042274001985788345, 0.023662108927965164, -0.00531812384724617, 0.017737343907356262, 0.015606398694217205, -0.036804988980293274, -0.00979865062981844, -0.07627058029174805, -0.021173954010009766, 0.030202753841876984, -0.03389803320169449, -0.020459532737731934, -0.027098719030618668, -0.05449306219816208, 0.02356356754899025, 0.00634356401860714, -0.026187216863036156, 0.004575988277792931, 0.00033642444759607315, 0.003122511552646756, -0.023834554478526115, 0.0005173392128199339, 0.03892361372709274, -0.0050317393615841866, -0.007193478289991617, -0.012397663667798042, -0.005336599890142679, -0.013093608431518078, 0.0077477702870965, -0.04355503246188164, 0.02059502713382244, 0.00971242692321539, 0.02724653109908104, -0.014510132372379303, -0.02127249538898468, 0.008074186742305756, -0.031089622527360916, 0.031138891354203224, 0.05050215870141983, -0.029044900089502335, -0.006485216319561005, -0.0035875008907169104, -0.010562341660261154, 0.01942485384643078, 0.003124051261693239, 0.0019246248994022608, 0.008394444361329079, 0.022553525865077972, -0.008677748963236809, 0.00883787777274847, -0.021087730303406715, -0.0022679781541228294, -0.025398891419172287, 0.009225882589817047, 0.012089723721146584, -0.028897088021039963, -0.01926472596824169, 0.04106687754392624, -0.014547085389494896, -0.015569445677101612, 0.006663821637630463, 0.017601849511265755, -0.002657522214576602, -0.01008195523172617, -0.005268853157758713, -0.010870281606912613, 0.01634545437991619, -0.004677608609199524, 0.014239145442843437, 0.026064040139317513, 0.012305282056331635, 0.017971377819776535, 0.002221787115558982, 0.020952237769961357, 0.011787942610681057, 0.02231949009001255, 0.036189109086990356, 0.005595269612967968, 0.005598349031060934, -0.024314941838383675, 0.022738289088010788, 0.010057319886982441, 0.007538370788097382, -0.018230047076940536, -0.028330478817224503, -0.015372364781796932, 0.051191944628953934, -0.013376913033425808, -0.016776571050286293, 0.01018049567937851, 0.021420305594801903, 0.021617388352751732, 0.016641076654195786, 0.0052103446796536446, -0.03759331256151199, 0.0336516834795475, -0.02667992003262043, -0.006867061834782362, 0.061538729816675186, -0.046806879341602325, 0.004228015895932913, 0.03384876251220703, 0.03232138231396675, -0.001873814850114286, 0.02798558585345745, 0.028502926230430603, -0.007359765935689211, 0.007322812918573618, 0.01512601226568222, -0.0013326102634891868, -0.0032179728150367737, -0.036041297018527985, 0.02569451369345188, -0.0033011166378855705, -0.003458166029304266, 0.03542541712522507, 0.01946180686354637, 0.007673864718526602, 0.01018049567937851, -0.0018645765958353877, -0.001960037974640727, 0.010913393460214138, -0.04899941012263298, 0.027320435270667076, -0.0005081009585410357, 0.04993554949760437, -0.01719537004828453, -0.10336929559707642, -0.010697835125029087, 0.015766527503728867, 0.01130139734596014, 0.008850195445120335, 0.0049393572844564915, 0.009268993511795998, 0.029217345640063286, 0.013598630204796791, -0.0036860418040305376, 0.04919649288058281, -0.018020648509263992, 0.020545756444334984, 0.05961718410253525, 0.03010421432554722, -0.033380694687366486, -0.0073967184871435165, 0.003609056817367673, -0.01693669892847538, -0.009755538776516914, -0.0018260841025039554, 0.024536658078432083, -0.029981037601828575, 0.002077055163681507, 0.012453093193471432, -0.0037999795749783516, -0.010020367801189423, -0.047767650336027145, 0.033774856477975845, -0.002073975745588541, 0.01728159189224243, -0.007593800313770771, 0.058188341557979584, 0.03764258325099945, -0.01586506888270378, -0.01380802970379591, -0.005638381466269493, 0.0442940890789032, -0.011560067534446716, 0.04732421785593033, -0.02475837618112564, -0.03362704813480377, 0.03384876251220703, 0.04471288621425629, 0.02070588432252407, 0.0031533055007457733, -0.010623930022120476, 0.009595409967005253, 0.005019421689212322, -0.00936137605458498, 0.020471850410103798, -0.003316513728350401, -0.021617388352751732, 0.004357350990176201, -0.0028715403750538826, -0.01988060586154461, 0.028256572782993317, 0.006349722854793072, -0.013881934806704521, -0.015938974916934967, -0.024339577183127403, 0.017811249941587448, 0.020200863480567932, -0.042101554572582245, -0.04641271382570267, -0.023070864379405975, -0.02988249622285366, 0.027689963579177856, 0.017688073217868805, -0.01294579729437828, 0.012409981340169907, 0.0308186337351799, 0.027320435270667076, 0.016419360414147377, -0.032247476279735565, -0.023033911362290382, 0.026064040139317513, -0.008209680207073689, -0.03936704993247986, -0.014448544010519981, -0.020188545808196068, 0.010623930022120476, 0.015557128004729748, -0.003889282001182437, 0.010716311633586884, 0.02687700279057026, 0.01861189305782318, 0.0034858807921409607, -0.007248907350003719, 0.032050393521785736, 0.00363985076546669, 0.00961388647556305, 0.037938207387924194, -0.005010183900594711, 0.021112365648150444, -0.016468631103634834, 0.02704944834113121, -0.024684470146894455, -0.005465934984385967, -0.01182489562779665, -0.03894824907183647, -0.01815614104270935, -0.04367820918560028, -0.014719531871378422, 0.01167092565447092, -0.0013133640168234706, -0.0031040350440889597, 0.03335605934262276, 0.009952620603144169, 0.00184456049464643, 0.02574378252029419, -0.00617419695481658, 0.009804809466004372, 0.010599294677376747, 0.04596928134560585, -0.02667992003262043, -0.0003410435456316918, 0.024314941838383675, 0.037519410252571106, 0.010340624488890171, 0.028995629400014877, 0.019449489191174507, -0.027172625064849854, -0.010229766368865967, -0.019326314330101013, -0.032419923692941666, -0.0233911219984293, -0.017084510996937752, -0.0026975544169545174, 0.04749666526913643, 0.03384876251220703, -0.022356443107128143, 0.025768417865037918, 0.007322812918573618, 0.014251463115215302, 0.01428841520100832, 0.019782064482569695, 0.050255805253982544, 0.010716311633586884, 0.020939920097589493, 0.0026221091393381357, 0.009860238991677761, -0.0013441580813378096, 0.005004025064408779, 0.02892172336578369, -0.01894446834921837, -0.0029392873402684927, -0.021802151575684547, 0.042126189917325974, 0.023046229034662247, 0.02430262416601181, 0.00781551655381918, -0.0027252689469605684, 0.020102322101593018, 0.010907234624028206, 0.015483222901821136, 0.0037291531916707754, 0.018956786021590233, -0.013524724170565605, 0.008228156715631485, -0.003427372081205249, 0.013968157581984997, 0.01739245094358921, -0.022381078451871872, 0.04385065659880638, -0.020090004429221153, -0.025645243003964424, 0.01852566935122013, 0.009841762483119965, 0.007458306383341551, 0.002859222935512662, -0.01029751356691122, 0.01172635518014431, 0.021137000992894173, 0.01559408102184534, -0.005225741770118475, -0.013475454412400723, 0.0032734021078795195, 0.023489663377404213, 0.016616441309452057, -0.0015473985113203526, -0.013549359515309334, 0.015951290726661682, 0.016505584120750427, 0.049270398914813995, -0.02367442660033703, -0.02314477041363716, -0.009620045311748981, -0.01533541176468134, 0.03195185214281082, -0.029241980984807014, 0.011787942610681057, 0.0022294854279607534, 0.026187216863036156, 0.027492882683873177, 0.03062155283987522, -0.0042526512406766415, 0.0327894501388073, -0.0013495470630005002, -0.015298458747565746, -0.035844214260578156, -0.0196588896214962, 0.02305854670703411, -0.048506706953048706, 0.00514875678345561, 0.020126957446336746, 0.011344509199261665, -0.029808592051267624, 0.0000960387842496857, -0.043998464941978455, -0.002140183001756668, 0.003867726307362318, 0.04148567467927933, -0.011159745045006275, 0.03483417257666588, -0.058582503348588943, 0.01804528385400772, 0.01994219422340393, -0.0529656782746315, -0.029266616329550743, 0.005401267670094967, -0.05217735096812248, -0.017601849511265755, 0.026901638135313988, -0.007088778540492058, 0.03143451362848282, 0.03271554410457611, -0.011818736791610718, 0.021334081888198853, 0.004640655592083931, -0.00766770588234067, 0.003057844005525112, -0.026581380516290665, -0.02452434040606022, -0.021986914798617363, 0.0022849147208034992, -0.010599294677376747, 0.0005365854594856501, -0.001197116682305932, 0.030325930565595627, 0.03025202453136444, -0.021802151575684547, 0.010851805098354816, -0.002859222935512662, 0.017380133271217346, -0.0033873398788273335, 0.04015537351369858, -0.00862231943756342, 0.01976974681019783, 0.014633308164775372, -0.017343180254101753, 0.03685425966978073, -0.06444568186998367, 0.0005850860034115613, -0.013081290759146214, 0.008135774172842503, -0.04818645119667053, 0.03710060939192772, 0.026532109826803207, -0.0014465481508523226, 0.0037999795749783516, 0.0035905803088098764, -0.036804988980293274, -0.013032020069658756, 0.0327894501388073, 0.00421261927112937, -0.03303580358624458, -0.02042257972061634, 0.007193478289991617, -0.00709493737667799, 0.010402212850749493, -0.011270604096353054, 0.013709488324820995, 0.026064040139317513, -0.009663157165050507, -0.007532212417572737, 0.021371034905314445, -0.002077055163681507, 0.01639472506940365, 0.01297043263912201, -0.03177940845489502, -0.009539981372654438, -0.0261379461735487, 0.011590861715376377, 0.000977709423750639, 0.003113273298367858, -0.005419743712991476, 0.005407426040619612, 0.03155769035220146, 0.0059309243224561214, -0.04072198271751404, 0.01733086258172989, 0.006552963051944971, -0.027936315163969994, 0.02670455537736416, -0.022812195122241974, -0.003843091195449233, -0.00909038819372654, -0.0182423647493124, -0.03626301512122154, 0.029759321361780167, 0.0015489381039515138, 0.002169437240809202, -0.0388004407286644, 0.004009378608316183, -0.026926273480057716, -0.03439074009656906, -0.011985024437308311, 0.007698499597609043, -0.0063035315833985806, 0.022935369983315468, -0.01942485384643078, -0.03764258325099945, 0.0023234072141349316, -0.0030516854021698236, -0.00538279116153717, -0.027271166443824768, 0.010956505313515663, 0.0032395287416875362, 0.00044112405157648027, -0.0007652308559045196, -0.052472975105047226, 0.0007525283726863563, -0.011683243326842785, -0.027911681681871414, 0.013463136740028858, 0.0042526512406766415, -0.018562622368335724, 0.016554854810237885, -0.015113694593310356, 0.012613222002983093, 0.029020264744758606, 0.0169982872903347, -0.009053436107933521, -0.019412536174058914, 0.00009459531429456547, 0.027936315163969994, -0.015704939141869545, 0.03256773203611374, 0.00042688180110417306, -0.009835603646934032, 0.00923204142600298, -0.029463699087500572, -0.011449208483099937, -0.014152921736240387, 0.020521121099591255, 0.00795716978609562, -0.02594086527824402, -0.037568677216768265, 0.02249193750321865, 0.06745117902755737, -0.0023757570888847113, 0.008911783806979656, 0.0124469343572855, 0.013007385656237602, 0.011011933907866478, -0.0027221895288676023, 0.02704944834113121, 0.0015050567453727126, 0.024918504059314728, -0.006164958700537682, 0.03448927775025368, -0.014571720734238625, 0.015064424835145473, 0.03990902379155159, 0.01552017591893673, -0.02336648665368557, 0.04335794970393181, -0.0030178120359778404, 0.02025013417005539, -0.003028589766472578, -0.014904296025633812, -0.016727300360798836, 0.02356356754899025, 0.014818072319030762, -0.02574378252029419, 0.010796376504004002, -0.020841378718614578, 0.004579067695885897, -0.0049793897196650505, 0.004437415394932032, 0.019338632002472878, -0.03958876430988312, 0.00940448697656393, -0.011689402163028717, -0.0038246146868914366, -0.007790881674736738, -0.0035905803088098764, 0.013376913033425808, -0.021260177716612816, 0.015951290726661682, -0.025990135967731476, 0.006928649730980396, -0.00927515234798193, -0.006007909309118986, 0.016246914863586426, -0.01639472506940365, 0.014534767717123032, 0.019708160310983658, 0.007476782891899347, -0.018303953111171722, -0.02277524210512638, 0.0041140783578157425, -0.009509187191724777, 0.005961718037724495, 0.004200301598757505, -0.01179410144686699, 0.021198589354753494, 0.014990518800914288, -0.01656717248260975, -0.004742275923490524, -0.03195185214281082, -0.0449838750064373, 0.035450052469968796, 0.0028638418298214674, -0.05276859551668167, 0.010155861265957355, 0.004378906916826963, -0.006257340777665377, -0.008819401264190674, -0.00942912232130766, -0.006780838593840599, 0.013426183722913265, -0.019954511895775795, -0.0072057959623634815, 0.0008168108179233968, -0.0339965745806694, 0.014855025336146355, -0.01409133430570364, -0.03670644760131836, 0.008850195445120335, -0.004825419746339321, 0.0021109285298734903, 0.00766770588234067, -0.028650736436247826, -0.005505966953933239, -0.007636911701411009, 0.007162684109061956, -0.02645820379257202, 0.008289744146168232, 0.0018137665465474129, 0.00006558159657288343, 0.010802535340189934, 0.0194002203643322, 0.013413866050541401, 0.008302061818540096, -0.0020339435432106256, -0.015483222901821136, 0.055626280605793, 0.024992410093545914, 0.005194947589188814, 0.01437463890761137, 0.02953760325908661, 0.015187600627541542, 0.0221470445394516, 0.031163526698946953, -0.019449489191174507, -0.059715721756219864, 0.021740563213825226, -0.020324040204286575, -0.012773350812494755, -0.0030609234236180782, -0.0005007873987779021, -0.0006947896326892078, 0.009324423037469387, 0.03626301512122154, 0.022849148139357567, -0.001382650574669242, 0.004588305950164795, -0.02759142406284809, 0.012896526604890823, 0.01521223597228527, -0.019621936604380608, -0.0076615470461547375, -0.021173954010009766, -0.03616447374224663, 0.020016100257635117, -0.002049340633675456, -0.01306897308677435, 0.012724080123007298, -0.004603703040629625, 0.014337685890495777, 0.009946461766958237, 0.0004642195417545736, -0.004994786810129881, -0.017429403960704803, 0.011332191526889801, -0.032617002725601196, 0.02761605940759182, -0.03328215330839157, 0.021605070680379868, 0.03251846134662628, -0.00494859553873539, -0.02336648665368557, -0.00987255573272705, 0.006405151914805174, 0.02704944834113121, -0.014214510098099709, -0.008037233725190163, -0.013586312532424927, -0.0023495820350944996, 0.005271932575851679, 0.015741892158985138, 0.01855030469596386, -0.0013980475487187505, 0.004619099665433168, -0.01665339432656765, -0.034735631197690964, -0.017232321202754974, 0.033380694687366486, -0.009182770736515522, 0.026408933103084564, -0.027394341304898262, 0.04705322906374931, 0.04466361552476883, -0.029783956706523895, 0.004499003291130066, -0.022110091522336006, -0.03345460072159767, -0.003120971843600273, -0.0031902582850307226, -0.03303580358624458, -0.01268712803721428, -0.019646571949124336, -0.04013073816895485, -0.021420305594801903, -0.010697835125029087, -0.015606398694217205, -0.008419079706072807, 0.012003500945866108, 0.01733086258172989, -0.052719324827194214, -0.02291073463857174, -0.003950870130211115, -0.02308318205177784, 0.008616160601377487, 0.0023064706474542618, -0.0005392798921093345, 0.006044861860573292, -0.012200582772493362, -0.000707492115907371, -0.018845926970243454, -0.01101809274405241, 0.014042063616216183, 0.004089443013072014, 0.04559975489974022, 0.021962279453873634, -0.017688073217868805, -0.032617002725601196, -0.008104980923235416, 0.009373693726956844, -0.025423524901270866, 0.01588970422744751, -0.01946180686354637, -0.025164855644106865, 0.024314941838383675, 0.008831718936562538, 0.022898416966199875, -0.006134164519608021, 0.011997342109680176, -0.0076615470461547375, -0.006087973713874817, -0.02971005067229271, 0.02286146581172943, 0.004215698689222336, 0.022418031468987465, 0.027468247339129448, 0.05148756504058838, -0.002796095097437501, -0.042643528431653976, 0.029833225533366203, -0.006362040061503649, -0.018082236871123314, 0.03392266854643822, 0.010710152797400951, -0.006466739811003208, 0.01484270766377449, 0.016924381256103516, -0.005758477840572596, 0.03705133870244026, -0.009392169304192066, -0.03951485827565193, 0.007975645363330841, -0.002890016883611679, 0.0004649893962778151, 0.011831054463982582, -0.04826035723090172, 0.015360047109425068, -0.050403617322444916, 0.014793436974287033, -0.0221470445394516, -0.009182770736515522, 0.0004903944209218025, -0.004656052682548761, 0.015162965282797813, 0.03123743273317814, 0.036607906222343445, 0.014436227269470692, -0.031705502420663834, 0.019437171518802643, 0.0008991847862489522, -0.022356443107128143, -0.00756300613284111, 0.0015620256308466196, 0.023501981049776077, -0.048728425055742264, 0.052078813314437866, -0.008012598380446434, -0.006830108817666769, 0.026556745171546936, -0.019277043640613556, 0.01306897308677435, 0.012958114966750145, -0.0253249853849411, 0.036607906222343445, 0.028034856542944908, -0.03638618811964989, -0.007809358183294535, -0.016012879088521004, -0.018673481419682503, 0.008733178488910198, -0.02852756157517433, 0.006180355791002512, 0.02665528655052185, 0.025472795590758324, -0.00444665364921093, -0.01428841520100832, -0.022787559777498245, 0.030769364908337593, -0.004144872073084116, 0.031483784317970276, -0.011399938724935055, 0.021605070680379868, -0.008616160601377487, -0.0073043364100158215, 0.022097773849964142, -0.0068855383433401585, 0.014707214199006557, -0.025189490988850594, 0.024881551042199135, 0.003981664311140776, 0.019560348242521286, -0.011209015734493732, -0.006131085101515055, -0.010389895178377628, -0.010993457399308681, 0.0004168737505096942, 0.0070764608681201935, -0.000909192836843431, -0.028872454538941383, -0.025448160246014595, -0.002132484456524253, -0.035302240401506424, -0.003984743729233742, 0.021876057609915733, -0.025472795590758324, -0.004911642987281084, 0.0012648635311052203, -0.005234980024397373, -0.0007290479261428118, 0.03271554410457611, 0.015015154145658016, -0.009379852563142776, 0.019621936604380608, -0.0008121917489916086, 0.024598246440291405, -0.013192148879170418, 0.03744550421833992, 0.011929594911634922, 0.014879660680890083, -0.010439165867865086, 0.01322910189628601, 0.001096266321837902, -0.01804528385400772, 0.008351332508027554, 0.02628575824201107, 0.0236497912555933, 0.009884873405098915, 0.01770039089024067, -0.022590477019548416, 0.0018384017748758197, -0.03781503066420555, -0.00642362842336297, 0.01016817893832922, -0.008037233725190163, -0.011609337292611599, -0.011264445260167122, 0.029636144638061523, -0.020459532737731934, -0.022023867815732956, -0.010198972187936306, -0.017010604962706566, 0.0013133640168234706, -0.0036121360026299953, -0.021346399560570717, 0.021605070680379868, -0.010993457399308681, -0.009841762483119965, 0.021518846973776817, 0.0000934405397856608, 0.01101809274405241, -0.004154110327363014, -0.040968336164951324, 0.008474508300423622, 0.0388004407286644, -0.0009014943498186767, 0.04582146927714348, -0.014990518800914288, 0.008462190628051758, 0.004397382959723473, 0.015569445677101612, 0.018119189888238907, 0.016493266448378563, -0.015384682454168797, 0.0004903944209218025, 0.021568117663264275, 0.0007402107585221529, -0.006768520921468735, -0.037544045597314835, -0.02835511416196823, 0.020890649408102036, 0.0008191203814931214, 0.015852751210331917, -0.008080345578491688, -0.027887046337127686, -0.04138713330030441, 0.03554859384894371, -0.030917175114154816, 0.022664383053779602, -0.003997060935944319, 0.02053343877196312, -0.019043009728193283, -0.0003853099187836051, -0.031138891354203224, -0.013660217635333538, -0.015039789490401745, -0.0017198448767885566, 0.03591812029480934, -0.0014157540863379836 ]
10.347946
1.06158
2024-07-01
4
2024ApJ...969..119W
[ "general relativity", "f(T", "effective excess surface density profile", "galaxy color", "galaxy scales", "post-Newtonian", "gravity", "SDSS DR7", "galaxy–galaxy lensing data", "the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release" ]
[ "Weak gravitational lensing", "Cosmology", "Non-standard theories of gravity", "1797", "343", "1118", "Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics", "Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies", "General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology", "High Energy Physics - Phenomenology", "High Energy Physics - Theory" ]
14
[ "10.3847/1538-4357/ad47c0", "10.48550/arXiv.2312.17053" ]
[ "Wang, Qingqing", "Ren, Xin", "Wang, Bo", "Cai, Yi-Fu", "Luo, Wentao", "Saridakis, Emmanuel N." ]
[ "Department of Astronomy, School of Physical Sciences, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei 230026, People's Republic of China; , ,; CAS Key Laboratory for Researches in Galaxies and Cosmology, School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, Anhui 230026, People's Republic of China; Deep Space Exploration Laboratory, Hefei 230088, People's Republic of China", "Department of Astronomy, School of Physical Sciences, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei 230026, People's Republic of China; , ,; CAS Key Laboratory for Researches in Galaxies and Cosmology, School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, Anhui 230026, People's Republic of China; Deep Space Exploration Laboratory, Hefei 230088, People's Republic of China; Department of Physics, Tokyo Institute of Technology, Tokyo 152-8551, Japan", "Department of Astronomy, School of Physical Sciences, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei 230026, People's Republic of China; , ,; CAS Key Laboratory for Researches in Galaxies and Cosmology, School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, Anhui 230026, People's Republic of China; Deep Space Exploration Laboratory, Hefei 230088, People's Republic of China", "Department of Astronomy, School of Physical Sciences, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei 230026, People's Republic of China; , ,; CAS Key Laboratory for Researches in Galaxies and Cosmology, School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, Anhui 230026, People's Republic of China; Deep Space Exploration Laboratory, Hefei 230088, People's Republic of China", "Department of Astronomy, School of Physical Sciences, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei 230026, People's Republic of China; , ,; CAS Key Laboratory for Researches in Galaxies and Cosmology, School of Astronomy and Space Science, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, Anhui 230026, People's Republic of China; Deep Space Exploration Laboratory, Hefei 230088, People's Republic of China", "Department of Astronomy, School of Physical Sciences, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei 230026, People's Republic of China; , ,; National Observatory of Athens, Lofos Nymfon, 11852 Athens, Greece; Departamento de Matemáticas, Universidad Católica del Norte, Avda. Angamos 0610, Casilla 1280 Antofagasta, Chile" ]
[ "2024arXiv240412140Y", "2024arXiv240507215M", "2024arXiv240600242W", "2024arXiv240615526A" ]
[ "1971JMP....12..498L", "1974ITAC...19..716A", "1980PhLB...91...99S", "1985ApJ...292..371D", "1989ApJ...342..635M", "1996astro.ph..6001N", "2000MNRAS.318..625B", "2001PhR...340..291B", "2002IJMPD..11..483C", "2003ApJS..149..289B", "2004ApJ...607..665R", "2004PhRvD..70h3509B", "2005AJ....129.2562B", "2005ApJ...633..560E", "2005MNRAS.362.1451M", "2005PhLB..631....1N", "2005PhRvD..72j4006K", "2006A&A...447...31A", "2006MNRAS.373.1159Y", "2007AN....328..852C", "2007MNRAS.377L..74L", "2007MNRAS.381.1450N", "2007MNRAS.382...29B", "2007PhRvD..75l4014C", "2008ApJ...676..248Y", "2009ApJS..182..543A", "2011PhR...509..167C", "2012MNRAS.427..146H", "2012MNRAS.427.1555I", "2012PhRvD..86d4009T", "2013A&A...558A..33A", "2013AnP...525..339M", "2014ApJ...792...48W", "2014LRR....17....4W", "2014PhRvD..90h4044K", "2015CQGra..32x3001B", "2015PhRvD..91j4014R", "2015PhRvD..92j4042B", "2016A&A...594A..13P", "2016IJMPD..2550073R", "2016PhRvD..94l4025D", "2016RPPh...79j6901C", "2017ARA&A..55..343B", "2017ApJ...836...38L", "2017MNRAS.470.2617A", "2018AJ....156..123A", "2018ApJ...861..137S", "2018ApJ...862....4L", "2018PhRvD..97j3513C", "2018PhRvD..98d4048J", "2019CQGra..36r3001K", "2019PhRvD.100h4064B", "2020A&A...641A...6P", "2020JCAP...10..024B", "2020MNRAS.498.1420W", "2020PhRvD.101l1301Y", "2020PhRvD.102j4044C", "2021APh...13102604D", "2021ApJ...914...96L", "2021JCAP...10..062R", "2021PDU....3200812R", "2021PhLB..82236634A", "2021mgca.book.....S", "2022ApJ...932..131R", "2022JCAP...01..037B", "2022JHEAp..34...49A", "2022NewAR..9501659P", "2022PrPNP.12503948A", "2023JCAP...07..060H", "2023MNRAS.518.6238C", "2023PhRvD.107j4063T", "2023PhRvD.108b3004C", "2023RPPh...86b6901B", "2024JCAP...03..025H" ]
29097302
null
Results of a long-term optical variability study of 11 quasars and VRI photometry of comparison stars
We present the results of a 15-yr long-term optical monitoring of 11 quasars conducted with the 2-m Ritchey-Chretien-Coude and the 50/70 cm Schmidt telescopes at the Rozhen National Astronomical Observatory, Bulgaria. Our observations are performed with standard Johnson-Cousins $VRI$ band filters and for each quasar we present a set of comparison standard stars that can be used for monitoring of objects in these fields (including finding charts for the stars identification). The variability and periodicity of each quasar are analysed individually and discussed. The physical properties of each quasar, such as their classification, redshift, and radio structures, are also discussed based on previous literature. Damped random walk model shows the best or the second best fit to the light curves of all objects. However, in six cases periodic models provide comparably good fits and make these six objects a valuable addition to the growing sample of quasars with periodic flux variation. They will be suitable for further investigation of the hitherto unclear mechanisms that give rise to this variability pattern. Our results provide important insights into the long-term variability and physical properties of quasars, which can further deepen our understanding of the nature and evolution of active galaxy nuclei.
[ -0.03851751238107681, 0.05717096105217934, 0.006658415775746107, -0.014539806172251701, -0.02786898985505104, 0.04568241536617279, -0.006899304687976837, -0.03990108147263527, -0.006880774628371, 0.004493504296988249, -0.022804146632552147, -0.03409504145383835, -0.0420999638736248, -0.005796774756163359, 0.058851007372140884, 0.05064843222498894, -0.03221734240651131, 0.03330443054437637, 0.01036439836025238, 0.060432225465774536, -0.0275478046387434, -0.04074110463261604, -0.024237127974629402, -0.0028335326351225376, -0.052377890795469284, -0.05282260850071907, -0.025423042476177216, -0.0004562991380225867, 0.0616181418299675, -0.0454600565135479, -0.018727567046880722, -0.029697274789214134, -0.033922094851732254, 0.007621971424669027, -0.061815790832042694, 0.06730064749717712, 0.01972818188369274, -0.02460772544145584, -0.04805424436926842, -0.025694813579320908, 0.0162322036921978, 0.02371829003095627, 0.009271133691072464, -0.0008045071153901517, 0.019061105325818062, -0.028980785980820656, -0.02557128109037876, -0.015762779861688614, 0.004311293363571167, 0.007844329811632633, -0.023471225053071976, 0.028041936457157135, -0.001891595427878201, -0.05064843222498894, 0.03990108147263527, -0.006510176230221987, -0.0019657150842249393, 0.026361890137195587, -0.002314695157110691, -0.01313153188675642, 0.010982062667608261, 0.0043607065454125404, 0.030932603403925896, -0.02984551526606083, 0.013551543466746807, -0.009827030822634697, -0.025768933817744255, 0.0129585862159729, 0.006028398405760527, 0.0043576182797551155, 0.016664568334817886, 0.019036397337913513, 0.041062287986278534, 0.016454564407467842, 0.03048788569867611, 0.007418142165988684, 0.014354506507515907, 0.008035806007683277, 0.023483578115701675, 0.00004111324597033672, 0.012359452433884144, 0.0031608943827450275, -0.0037986324168741703, -0.012544752098619938, -0.02037055231630802, 0.002558672334998846, -0.007856683805584908, -0.0388139933347702, -0.008060512132942677, 0.023137684911489487, 0.00875229574739933, 0.022618848830461502, 0.003980843350291252, -0.011043828912079334, -0.0016429857350885868, -0.046151839196681976, 0.06660886108875275, -0.060778118669986725, 0.050747256726026535, -0.012520045042037964, 0.00874611921608448, 0.016331030055880547, 0.002762501360848546, -0.0517849326133728, 0.03703512251377106, 0.02987022139132023, -0.006016045343130827, -0.015243942849338055, 0.002932358765974641, -0.026732489466667175, 0.04733775183558464, 0.027004260569810867, -0.02038290537893772, 0.006571942940354347, -0.028066642582416534, 0.008208751678466797, -0.05124138668179512, -0.001104074064642191, -0.0015765868593007326, -0.010728820227086544, -0.016417503356933594, -0.01214944664388895, 0.053959108889102936, 0.03671393543481827, 0.037133947014808655, -0.014947463758289814, -0.00420011393725872, -0.058208636939525604, -0.03434210643172264, -0.00484866090118885, 0.04573182761669159, -0.05455206707119942, -0.010611464269459248, 0.01819637604057789, -0.039728134870529175, 0.008017276413738728, 0.01712164096534252, -0.05287202075123787, -0.0038202505093067884, 0.031278494745492935, -0.012371805496513844, 0.03347737714648247, 0.015194529667496681, 0.061420489102602005, 0.018962278962135315, 0.029425503686070442, -0.008202575147151947, -0.009116717614233494, 0.011636786162853241, -0.0227053202688694, -0.028437241911888123, -0.02890666574239731, 0.021173514425754547, -0.04303881153464317, -0.021025275811553, -0.001632176572456956, 0.011130301281809807, 0.013736843131482601, -0.035503316670656204, 0.01183443795889616, 0.0035700968001037836, 0.0030311851296573877, -0.03463858738541603, -0.04308822751045227, -0.017096932977437973, -0.006738712079823017, -0.02231001667678356, -0.004388501401990652, -0.08306342363357544, -0.03740571811795235, 0.011692375876009464, 0.0009064216283150017, 0.033180899918079376, -0.050104886293411255, -0.004805424250662327, 0.061124008148908615, 0.009104364551603794, -0.04350823909044266, -0.0486719086766243, -0.006161196157336235, -0.017059873789548874, 0.016998108476400375, 0.028659600764513016, 0.00827051792293787, 0.010592933744192123, -0.022902972996234894, -0.048103656619787216, 0.012365628965198994, 0.021198220551013947, -0.043631769716739655, -0.0024938175920397043, 0.022841207683086395, -0.011754142120480537, 0.055342674255371094, -0.04323646426200867, -0.03999990597367287, -0.0045058573596179485, 0.04639890417456627, -0.03493506461381912, -0.01133413054049015, -0.01978994719684124, 0.023075919598340988, 0.0422234982252121, -0.059147484600543976, -0.014329800382256508, -0.05667683109641075, 0.03686217591166496, 0.03829515352845192, -0.024484192952513695, 0.008702882565557957, 0.021544113755226135, 0.040691692382097244, 0.024570666253566742, 0.04286586865782738, -0.014193913899362087, -0.017442826181650162, -0.007578734774142504, 0.022285310551524162, 0.045904774218797684, -0.0035546552389860153, -0.006751065142452717, 0.028140762820839882, 0.05474971979856491, 0.02298944629728794, 0.05870276689529419, 0.03414445370435715, 0.011284717358648777, 0.012538574635982513, 0.048103656619787216, -0.05608387291431427, 0.03831986337900162, 0.04469415172934532, -0.03431740030646324, 0.01101912185549736, 0.013946848921477795, 0.020358199253678322, 0.03624451160430908, 0.03792455792427063, -0.02011113241314888, -0.0487213209271431, -0.025373628363013268, 0.018912864848971367, -0.012760934419929981, -0.0025864671915769577, 0.029672568663954735, 0.014786871150135994, -0.006411350332200527, -0.030734950676560402, 0.030636124312877655, -0.0015333503251895308, 0.003807897213846445, 0.021136455237865448, -0.028066642582416534, 0.00623840419575572, -0.017430473119020462, 0.03505859524011612, -0.04701656848192215, 0.01688692905008793, -0.03859163448214531, -0.008134632371366024, -0.014552159234881401, -0.004595418460667133, -0.017343999817967415, 0.06067929044365883, -0.023495931178331375, 0.054947372525930405, -0.026806607842445374, -0.055886220186948776, -0.041976433247327805, -0.007492261938750744, -0.0025772021617740393, -0.02143293432891369, 0.05153786763548851, 0.014774518087506294, -0.02077821083366871, 0.04024697467684746, 0.025497160851955414, 0.0011087064631283283, 0.007578734774142504, -0.014712751843035221, 0.03043847158551216, -0.02786898985505104, 0.061420489102602005, 0.05712154880166054, -0.023915942758321762, -0.013675075955688953, -0.016442209482192993, 0.0357009656727314, 0.022779440507292747, 0.023483578115701675, 0.04657185077667236, -0.046151839196681976, 0.016998108476400375, -0.027103086933493614, -0.0454353503882885, -0.01719575934112072, 0.02300179935991764, 0.013366244733333588, -0.022198837250471115, -0.028610186651349068, 0.01002468355000019, 0.015750426799058914, 0.0388139933347702, 0.008177869021892548, -0.0015225412789732218, 0.027004260569810867, 0.049487221986055374, -0.0014144501183182001, -0.0242865402251482, 0.064731165766716, 0.03545390069484711, -0.0040333447977900505, -0.0023301367182284594, 0.010710290633141994, -0.04800482839345932, -0.06038281321525574, -0.015503360889852047, 0.014181560836732388, 0.043285880237817764, -0.07229137420654297, -0.05287202075123787, -0.048844851553440094, -0.012032090686261654, 0.04088934138417244, -0.021198220551013947, -0.05425558611750603, 0.009518198668956757, -0.01787519082427025, -0.01586160622537136, -0.0052347006276249886, 0.045855361968278885, -0.01310682576149702, 0.037158653140068054, 0.03950577601790428, -0.033180899918079376, -0.01909816451370716, -0.01907345838844776, 0.05677565559744835, -0.024854790419340134, -0.04768364503979683, -0.05247671529650688, -0.008474347181618214, 0.012581811286509037, 0.005623828619718552, 0.020629970356822014, 0.060432225465774536, 0.01917228475213051, 0.0012600341578945518, 0.03048788569867611, -0.02368122898042202, 0.014070381410419941, -0.012390336021780968, 0.03345267102122307, 0.014107441529631615, 0.052031997591257095, -0.035528022795915604, 0.009166130796074867, -0.04128464683890343, -0.07046308368444443, 0.01972818188369274, 0.010642346926033497, 0.01326741836965084, 0.0258924663066864, -0.01086470577865839, -0.014156853780150414, -0.0026173503138124943, 0.00445335591211915, 0.000790609628893435, -0.01262504793703556, -0.044595327228307724, -0.01555277407169342, 0.009579965844750404, -0.0178504828363657, 0.010067920200526714, -0.04269292205572128, 0.011692375876009464, 0.042297616600990295, -0.002889122348278761, 0.006460763514041901, 0.01977759413421154, 0.016182791441679, -0.016121024265885353, -0.03360091149806976, -0.03303265944123268, 0.00890053529292345, -0.005518826190382242, -0.015972785651683807, 0.02014819346368313, -0.06295229494571686, -0.01261887140572071, -0.04046933352947235, 0.007739327382296324, 0.012748580425977707, -0.008851122111082077, 0.02653483673930168, 0.0032087634317576885, 0.03285971283912659, 0.07525615394115448, 0.01586160622537136, 0.055589742958545685, 0.021568819880485535, -0.01586160622537136, -0.00938848964869976, 0.008394051343202591, -0.05860394239425659, 0.0062939939089119434, -0.04027168080210686, 0.025126563385128975, 0.029351383447647095, 0.004839395638555288, 0.03705982863903046, -0.032538529485464096, 0.018270494416356087, -0.036417458206415176, -0.010907942429184914, 0.003560831770300865, -0.045880068093538284, 0.007146370131522417, -0.0036720111966133118, 0.052723780274391174, 0.01474981103092432, -0.05316849797964096, 0.026188945397734642, -0.010784409940242767, -0.06072870269417763, 0.010259395465254784, -0.0017989458283409476, -0.009159954264760017, -0.03528095781803131, -0.0389375239610672, 0.00631870049983263, -0.007881389930844307, 0.011235304176807404, 0.03369973599910736, -0.0026621308643370867, -0.020555851981043816, 0.02982080727815628, 0.0018082107417285442, -0.0068745980970561504, -0.027967816218733788, 0.0356515534222126, 0.03478682413697243, -0.03945636376738548, -0.02460772544145584, 0.04714009910821915, -0.018233435228466988, 0.03663981705904007, 0.039085764437913895, 0.02077821083366871, -0.04704127460718155, 0.011358837597072124, 0.007232842966914177, -0.02459537237882614, -0.008851122111082077, -0.010722643695771694, -0.04583065211772919, 0.05124138668179512, -0.03219263628125191, 0.02207530476152897, -0.023730643093585968, -0.0016954870661720634, -0.025200683623552322, -0.013390950858592987, 0.037726905196905136, 0.02492891065776348, 0.04760952666401863, -0.03426798805594444, 0.0027130881790071726, -0.013366244733333588, -0.04595418646931648, -0.006164284888654947, -0.03310677781701088, 0.01917228475213051, -0.005179110914468765, 0.012594164349138737, 0.03271147608757019, 0.0017912250477820635, -0.003009566804394126, 0.028783133253455162, -0.025472454726696014, 0.017578711733222008, 0.01197032444179058, -0.0063063474372029305, 0.051439039409160614, 0.016911635175347328, 0.014379213564097881, -0.006003692280501127, 0.005580592434853315, 0.0015680940123274922, 0.011710905469954014, -0.028610186651349068, -0.001974979881197214, 0.009505845606327057, -0.011890027672052383, 0.008851122111082077, -0.022100010886788368, -0.02564540132880211, 0.02332298457622528, -0.005796774756163359, 0.013168592005968094, 0.05218023806810379, 0.009901151061058044, 0.030907895416021347, 0.018616387620568275, 0.04637419804930687, 0.04511416330933571, -0.03140202909708023, 0.02137116715312004, -0.0051574925892055035, 0.03728218749165535, 0.00404569786041975, 0.005892512388527393, -0.01069793663918972, -0.02338475175201893, -0.03135261312127113, 0.004237173590809107, -0.02851136028766632, 0.008499054238200188, 0.0007655170629732311, -0.0015287179267033935, -0.012699167244136333, -0.05000606179237366, 0.029351383447647095, 0.010160569101572037, 0.007319315802305937, -0.006917834281921387, -0.022186484187841415, -0.07525615394115448, -0.025151269510388374, -0.04029638692736626, -0.008177869021892548, -0.015330415219068527, -0.015676306560635567, -0.014836284331977367, -0.018999338150024414, -0.021951770409941673, -0.024064181372523308, -0.025867760181427002, -0.011729435063898563, -0.042915280908346176, -0.0006547236116603017, -0.025768933817744255, -0.01971582882106304, 0.011877674609422684, 0.019024044275283813, 0.05697330832481384, 0.010574404150247574, -0.002652866067364812, 0.00908583402633667, 0.007992569357156754, 0.019382290542125702, 0.0062229628674685955, -0.030586710199713707, 0.03661511093378067, 0.01361330971121788, 0.021605879068374634, -0.005932660773396492, 0.004468797706067562, 0.006040751934051514, -0.022248249500989914, 0.0012546295765787363, 0.01746753230690956, -0.020234666764736176, 0.033872682601213455, -0.026683075353503227, -0.022952387109398842, 0.01875227317214012, -0.03478682413697243, -0.028017230331897736, 0.016602803021669388, -0.022878266870975494, -0.03110554814338684, -0.007621971424669027, -0.0021185867954045534, -0.0226929672062397, -0.0008207207429222763, -0.0030188318341970444, 0.01067323051393032, 0.007819623686373234, -0.04091405123472214, -0.02008642628788948, -0.022841207683086395, 0.011692375876009464, 0.03822103515267372, -0.04501533880829811, 0.0032334700226783752, -0.008492876775562763, -0.012662108056247234, 0.004268056713044643, 0.0210129227489233, 0.01817166805267334, -0.025175975635647774, -0.027696045115590096, -0.012489162385463715, -0.030660830438137054, -0.0037739258259534836, 0.03394680097699165, -0.0007894515292719007, -0.007961686700582504, -0.001934831845574081, 0.010092626325786114, 0.0011141110444441438, -0.011729435063898563, -0.009820854291319847, -0.016751041635870934, 0.026979554444551468, -0.019579941406846046, -0.044323552399873734, -0.03540448844432831, 0.008011099882423878, 0.007572558242827654, -0.021951770409941673, 0.004879544023424387, -0.012272980064153671, 0.01035204529762268, 0.018554620444774628, -0.03407033532857895, -0.03920929878950119, 0.04447179287672043, 0.0012198860058560967, -0.007794917095452547, 0.00768991420045495, 0.02658424898982048, 0.007628147955983877, 0.051093149930238724, 0.04140818119049072, -0.013699783012270927, -0.02460772544145584, -0.014663338661193848, -0.006880774628371, 0.003261264879256487, -0.05781333148479462, 0.019938187673687935, -0.02888195961713791, -0.015404535457491875, 0.025101857259869576, 0.01182826142758131, 0.0024459485430270433, 0.03530566394329071, 0.004363794811069965, 0.0551450252532959, 0.04642361029982567, 0.02171705849468708, -0.03770219907164574, 0.020222311839461327, -0.029376089572906494, -0.0008593247621320188, -0.01980230212211609, -0.03701041638851166, -0.01684986799955368, -0.014440979808568954, -0.010802939534187317, 0.0008361623622477055, 0.03150085359811783, 0.010308808647096157, 0.010314985178411007, -0.010945002548396587, 0.03537978231906891, -0.039752840995788574, 0.01588631235063076, -0.02789369784295559, -0.0027377947699278593, -0.0055744159035384655, -0.01883874647319317, 0.023100625723600388, 0.01586160622537136, 0.004938222002238035, 0.014292740263044834, -0.005281025543808937, 0.023582404479384422, 0.06586766988039017, -0.02693014219403267, 0.03533037006855011, 0.03155026584863663, -0.01101912185549736, -0.00825198832899332, 0.009369960054755211, -0.03365032374858856, -0.003542301943525672, 0.062458161264657974, 0.015120409429073334, 0.0013905155938118696, -0.029054904356598854, -0.016022199764847755, -0.03315619379281998, -0.00032446649856865406, 0.022767087444663048, -0.008838769048452377, -0.013576250523328781, 0.007016660645604134, 0.014774518087506294, 0.014490392990410328, 0.012340922839939594, 0.01473745796829462, -0.021581172943115234, -0.019678767770528793, -0.0008863475522957742, -0.029178436845541, -0.00876464881002903, -0.001067786244675517, 0.07357610762119293, -0.003702894551679492, 0.025040090084075928, -0.018060488626360893, -0.0029107406735420227, 0.025744227692484856, -0.006260022521018982, -0.0454106405377388, -0.03048788569867611, -0.02045702561736107, 0.044916510581970215, 0.046843621879816055, -0.0054817660711705685, -0.008004922419786453, -0.014366859570145607, -0.0011272364063188434, -0.03150085359811783, 0.005812216084450483, 0.0003020761942025274, -0.03985166922211647, -0.004085845779627562, 0.03673864156007767, -0.023125331848859787, -0.004400854464620352, 0.030907895416021347, -0.04738716781139374, 0.00736255245283246, 0.0037739258259534836, -0.030216112732887268, 0.017430473119020462, 0.013477424159646034, -0.004054962657392025, 0.032242048531770706, 0.00017082264821510762, 0.010660877451300621, 0.03201968967914581, 0.01360095664858818, -0.010945002548396587, 0.019345229491591454, 0.015626894310116768, 0.00843728706240654, -0.01521923579275608, -0.019369937479496002, -0.013736843131482601, 0.032933834940195084, -0.0034403873141855, 0.007387259043753147, -0.023903589695692062, -0.0032118516974151134, -0.011710905469954014, 0.025447748601436615, 0.009437902830541134, 0.014354506507515907, -0.019357582554221153, 0.026090119034051895, -0.03083377704024315, 0.049758996814489365, -0.0033508259803056717, 0.01245827879756689, 0.04242115095257759, -0.002845885930582881, 0.0027609572280198336, 0.02077821083366871, 0.007554028183221817, -0.011519430205225945, 0.0421987920999527, -0.014193913899362087, 0.001067786244675517, 0.0015541964676231146, -0.01083382312208414, -0.019641708582639694, -0.013020352460443974, -0.02458301931619644, -0.004771452862769365, 0.02525009587407112, 0.01214944664388895, 0.01689928211271763, -0.01815931499004364, -0.0121309170499444, 0.011470017023384571, 0.011525606736540794, -0.0323902890086174, 0.009962917305529118, 0.0031037605367600918, -0.01714634709060192, 0.01752929762005806, -0.006442233454436064, -0.009672614745795727, 0.013230358250439167, 0.0034527406096458435, 0.006337230559438467, -0.02268061414361, -0.008214928209781647, -0.00476836459711194, 0.00874611921608448, 0.0137739023193717, -0.009345252998173237, -0.07367493957281113, 0.001588940154761076, -0.011290893889963627, 0.04083992913365364, -0.004459532443434, 0.030586710199713707, 0.0161580853164196, 0.008159338496625423, 0.027350151911377907, 0.007486085407435894, 0.027028968557715416, -0.040691692382097244, 0.00192402268294245, -0.00005047471495345235, 0.030537297949194908, -0.01591101847589016, -0.024224774911999702, 0.04417531564831734, -0.0019224785501137376, -0.011717082001268864, -0.0007203504210337996, 0.024212419986724854, 0.006991954054683447, 0.02528715506196022, -0.00761579442769289, 0.01279799360781908, -0.01750459149479866, -0.027350151911377907, 0.04518828168511391, -0.030858483165502548, 0.00550338439643383, -0.01980230212211609, -0.0023702848702669144, 0.03631862998008728, -0.016034552827477455, -0.021185867488384247, 0.0008546922472305596, 0.015589834190905094, -0.0010886323871091008, 0.001832917332649231, 0.023928295820951462, -0.04083992913365364, 0.017245173454284668, 0.01809754967689514, 0.06774536520242691, -0.0020907919388264418, -0.005626917351037264, 0.010253218933939934, 0.0022498404141515493, -0.0048301308415830135, 0.02399006113409996, 0.016306323930621147, -0.007226666435599327, 0.004203202202916145, -0.01198885403573513, 0.025521868839859962, 0.01883874647319317, -0.02070409059524536, -0.018085196614265442, -0.036145687103271484, -0.00793697964400053, 0.03621980547904968, -0.004805424250662327, -0.004351441282778978, -0.03152555972337723, -0.015182175673544407, -0.07258784770965576, 0.03505859524011612, 0.039110470563173294, -0.010629993863403797, -0.006868421565741301, 0.03683746978640556, -0.00258801132440567, 0.020827623084187508, 0.011297070421278477, -0.028412533923983574, -0.00453982874751091, -0.002612717915326357, -0.03849280625581741, -0.001341102528385818, -0.006034575402736664, 0.013761549256742, -0.008387873880565166, 0.0036967177875339985, -0.01819637604057789, 0.0050771962851285934, -0.0013210284523665905, -0.0194317027926445, 0.027004260569810867, 0.005469413008540869, 0.011636786162853241, 0.0033508259803056717, 0.02791840396821499, -0.01722046732902527, 0.02460772544145584, -0.03789985179901123, -0.005781332962214947, -0.027078380808234215, -0.006584296002984047, 0.004400854464620352, -0.02332298457622528, 0.0013495953753590584, -0.015429241582751274, -0.0486224927008152, 0.03923400491476059, -0.04249526932835579, 0.025373628363013268, 0.029301971197128296, 0.014552159234881401, 0.025472454726696014, 0.014329800382256508, -0.023841822519898415, 0.0291537307202816, 0.042322322726249695, 0.05613328516483307, 0.004598506726324558, 0.031896159052848816, -0.007659031078219414, 0.02523774281144142, 0.005623828619718552, 0.012859759852290154, 0.0043576182797551155, -0.0227053202688694, -0.02400241419672966, -0.012835053727030754, -0.04083992913365364, 0.010419988073408604, -0.02167999930679798, -0.03177262470126152, 0.034860946238040924, 0.018332261592149734, 0.017615770921111107, 0.005688683595508337, 0.001548792002722621, -0.0007164900307543576, -0.055985044687986374, 0.0027717663906514645, 0.017047520726919174, -0.0077516804449260235, 0.0275478046387434, 0.007096956949681044, 0.031229080632328987, 0.0518343448638916, -0.0003439615247771144, -0.024570666253566742, 0.016318676993250847, -0.04123523458838463, -0.03179733082652092, 0.02460772544145584, 0.0015673218294978142, 0.005463236477226019, 0.006182814482599497, 0.004172319080680609, 0.04185289889574051, -0.013020352460443974, 0.012056796811521053, -0.002004319103434682, -0.022865913808345795, 0.011272364296019077, -0.007554028183221817, 0.03115496225655079, 0.03995049372315407, 0.0121309170499444, -0.01278564054518938, 0.043952956795692444, -0.0011596637777984142, -0.004323646426200867, -0.034218575805425644, 0.004595418460667133, 0.01754165254533291, 0.012124740518629551, -0.04778246954083443, 0.042939987033605576, 0.05435441434383392, -0.0076960907317698, -0.00008193695975933224, -0.005197640974074602, 0.00940701924264431, 0.05311908572912216, 0.02816546894609928, -0.0026775726582854986, -0.015095703303813934, -0.0145645122975111, 0.0210623349994421, 0.04333529248833656, 0.0646323412656784, -0.027967816218733788, 0.008122279308736324, 0.0129585862159729, 0.00809757225215435, -0.022594140842556953, 0.026114825159311295, 0.00823963526636362, 0.04669538140296936, 0.019938187673687935, 0.031278494745492935, -0.013699783012270927, 0.013242711313068867, -0.018727567046880722, -0.029894927516579628, 0.017418118193745613, -0.007486085407435894, -0.025719519704580307, 0.004082757513970137, -0.019283464178442955, -0.016911635175347328, 0.031896159052848816, -0.04380471631884575, -0.04899309203028679, -0.01358860358595848, 0.00411981763318181, -0.009512022137641907, 0.01652868278324604, -0.00557750416919589, -0.017689891159534454, -0.06596649438142776, 0.007140193600207567, -0.004746746271848679, -0.045855361968278885, 0.004419384524226189, 0.02397770807147026, -0.03631862998008728, -0.04904250428080559, 0.016269264742732048, 0.010444695129990578, -0.007807270158082247, 0.01018527615815401, -0.023150039836764336, -0.017010461539030075, 0.018332261592149734, 0.018035782501101494, -0.0243235994130373, 0.020321138203144073, -0.03802338242530823, -0.033255018293857574, -0.018937572836875916, 0.016392797231674194, -0.009252604097127914, -0.01003086008131504, 0.012248273007571697, -0.012686814181506634, -0.014836284331977367, 0.0011727891396731138, -0.02759721875190735, -0.02271767519414425, 0.017615770921111107, 0.0067078289575874805, -0.01069176010787487, 0.02529950812458992, 0.019592296332120895, -0.015145116485655308, -0.04583065211772919, 0.015676306560635567, 0.019209343940019608, 0.0005709529505111277, -0.0022606495767831802, -0.025744227692484856, 0.023150039836764336, 0.023780055344104767, 0.022804146632552147, -0.044941216707229614, -0.012402689084410667, -0.030240818858146667, -0.023767702281475067, 0.017764011397957802, 0.0025463190395385027, -0.023162392899394035, -0.011062358506023884, 0.00823963526636362, -0.01876462623476982, -0.024064181372523308, -0.03377385810017586, 0.04079051688313484, 0.003130011260509491, -0.036516282707452774, 0.03285971283912659, -0.016652215272188187, -0.008980831131339073, -0.0014090455370023847, 0.01652868278324604, -0.021507052704691887, 0.0028551509603857994, -0.02112410217523575, 0.0012314672349020839, 0.01687457412481308, 0.018949925899505615, -0.011037652380764484, -0.006924011278897524, 0.037109240889549255, -0.021136455237865448, -0.018072843551635742, 0.04316234588623047, 0.0034496523439884186, -0.005969720426946878, -0.024471839889883995, -0.032909128814935684, 0.011593549512326717, 0.013996261171996593, -0.0005929572507739067, 0.0025463190395385027, -0.0045861536636948586, -0.013366244733333588, 0.029252557083964348, -0.007782564032822847, 0.015935726463794708, -0.02559598721563816, -0.005864717531949282, -0.007479908410459757, 0.024854790419340134, -0.028980785980820656, -0.00890053529292345, 0.012044443748891354, -0.015997491776943207, 0.009746734984219074, 0.013539190404117107, 0.010975885204970837, -0.029969047755002975, -0.013477424159646034, -0.012272980064153671, -0.00541691156104207, -0.03624451160430908, 0.007961686700582504, -0.017714597284793854, 0.005957367364317179, 0.00808521918952465, -0.007646677549928427, -0.029104318469762802, 0.0052347006276249886, 0.006701651960611343, 0.0258924663066864, 0.023174745962023735, 0.023582404479384422, 0.004666449967771769, 0.011414427310228348, -0.03740571811795235, 0.018258141353726387, 0.050450779497623444, 0.034490346908569336, 0.027794871479272842, 0.033255018293857574, 0.012723874300718307, -0.01978994719684124, -0.02044467069208622, -0.017035167664289474, -0.0036720111966133118, -0.002608085284009576, 0.03362561762332916, 0.004966016858816147, -0.04044462367892265, -0.017343999817967415, 0.07100663334131241, 0.0058060395531356335, 0.004490415565669537, -0.03636804595589638, 0.020518790930509567, -0.007436672225594521, -0.016343383118510246, 0.020518790930509567, 0.0051667578518390656, -0.02273002825677395, 0.020592911168932915, 0.007659031078219414, -0.017665185034275055, 0.01907345838844776, 0.008721413090825081, -0.00874611921608448, -0.020617617294192314, 0.000049268339353147894, -0.011680022813379765, -0.004385413136333227, -0.01714634709060192, -0.009339076466858387, 0.012081503868103027, 0.0013619486708194017, -0.010160569101572037, 0.02626306377351284, -0.0024227863177657127, -0.0026111737824976444, 0.023397104814648628, 0.034564465284347534, 0.022149423137307167, -0.0194069966673851, -0.00856699701398611, -0.03434210643172264, -0.029400797560811043, -0.03043847158551216, -0.005605299025774002, 0.021593526005744934, 0.0035731850657612085, -0.027671337127685547, 0.04931427910923958, 0.028659600764513016, -0.00938231311738491, -0.01151325274258852, -0.024237127974629402, -0.0019301993306726217, 0.002070717979222536, 0.05613328516483307, 0.012501515448093414, -0.018319908529520035, 0.006497823167592287, -0.04027168080210686, 0.02688072808086872, -0.016615156084299088, 0.005534267518669367, 0.012699167244136333, 0.005373674910515547, 0.0002758254995569587, 0.02271767519414425, -0.0007809586822986603, -0.010426164604723454, -0.009740558452904224, -0.028634892776608467, 0.00368745275773108, 0.008851122111082077, -0.011735612526535988, -0.003148541087284684, -0.0022066039964556694, 0.005685595329850912, -0.0137739023193717, -0.023792410269379616, 0.0077516804449260235, -0.029104318469762802, 0.0033106778282672167, 0.015985138714313507, 0.003968489822000265, -0.03935753554105759, 0.006757242139428854, -0.005781332962214947, 0.0020985128358006477, 0.03525624796748161, -0.017418118193745613, -0.015429241582751274, 0.00319949840195477, -0.00476836459711194, -0.00336009101010859, 0.0210129227489233, 0.01592337340116501, -0.01885109953582287, 0.0162074975669384, -0.008628763258457184, -0.0038573103956878185, 0.007164900191128254, 0.014613925479352474, -0.001840638113208115, 0.014453332871198654, -0.01101912185549736, 0.0051667578518390656, 0.01908581145107746, 0.014935110695660114, -0.004595418460667133, 0.027053674682974815, -0.011846791952848434, -0.025472454726696014, 0.024212419986724854, 0.010228512808680534, 0.018702859058976173, -0.043310586363077164, 0.0068745980970561504, 0.002811914309859276, 0.03051259182393551, 0.02621365152299404, -0.0162074975669384, -0.020827623084187508, -0.0008971566567197442, 0.03372444212436676, -0.014996876940131187, -0.0040518743917346, -0.004289675038307905, -0.023471225053071976, 0.011253834702074528, -0.02851136028766632, -0.004579977132380009, -0.02174176648259163, -0.016429856419563293, -0.036491576582193375, -0.0022946209646761417, -0.0096973218023777, -0.00873994268476963, 0.00823963526636362, -0.02816546894609928, -0.009524376131594181, 0.014539806172251701, 0.026114825159311295, -0.0001803771301638335, 0.01650397665798664, 0.009271133691072464, -0.00768991420045495, 0.033279724419116974, 0.011365014128386974, 0.015948079526424408, 0.004008638206869364, -0.01166766881942749, -0.04723892733454704, 0.020975861698389053, -0.03636804595589638, -0.00420011393725872, -0.007479908410459757, 0.015342768281698227, -0.008301401510834694, -0.019320523366332054, -0.0022313103545457125, 0.03184674680233002, 0.019345229491591454, 0.03505859524011612, 0.007492261938750744, -0.011599726043641567, 0.003869663691148162, -0.03980225324630737, 0.01523158885538578, -0.016615156084299088, 0.0013526837574318051, -0.03216793015599251, 0.016355738043785095, 0.02564540132880211, -0.007473731879144907, -0.004885720554739237, -0.0027161764446645975, -0.01848050020635128, 0.019283464178442955, -0.006744888611137867, -0.02360711060464382, 0.016281617805361748, -0.022878266870975494, -0.014922757633030415, -0.011686199344694614, 0.004295851569622755, -0.021976478397846222, -0.00360097992233932, 0.018900511786341667, -0.03310677781701088, -0.025793639943003654, -0.0016630598111078143, 0.02663366310298443, -0.015318062156438828, 0.0129462331533432, -0.0000041438966036366764, 0.00239035882987082, 0.008153161965310574, -0.006204432807862759, 0.027004260569810867, 0.008838769048452377, 0.06947482377290726, 0.02596658654510975, 0.034564465284347534, 0.04335999861359596, 0.04770835116505623, -0.041334062814712524, -0.012007384561002254, -0.0010176011128351092, -0.007547851651906967, -0.029178436845541, -0.004567623604089022, 0.014465685933828354, 0.012736227363348007, 0.032365582883358, 0.028931371867656708, 0.020642323419451714, -0.01279799360781908, -0.0003250455774832517, 0.0020490996539592743, -0.0032087634317576885, -0.002980227814987302, 0.025373628363013268, -0.016182791441679, 0.014465685933828354, 0.001468495698645711, 0.02952433004975319, -0.02856077440083027, 0.03799867630004883, 0.03300795331597328, 0.004410119727253914, -0.00810992531478405, 0.007813447155058384, 0.033823270350694656, 0.008301401510834694, 0.052328478544950485, -0.030710244551301003, -0.015046290121972561, -0.005549709312617779, -0.036516282707452774, -0.032266758382320404, 0.01982700824737549, -0.012884466908872128, 0.026139531284570694, 0.011846791952848434, 0.0037368659395724535, -0.0031037605367600918, 0.0064669400453567505, 0.022767087444663048, 0.010080273263156414, -0.015293355099856853, -0.01555277407169342, 0.0145892184227705, 0.028017230331897736, 0.04044462367892265, 0.029376089572906494, 0.0022869003005325794, -0.041334062814712524, -0.02557128109037876, -0.00988879706710577, -0.011093242093920708, -0.014688044786453247, -0.04022226482629776, 0.015256295911967754, -0.0038912820164114237, -0.0005261723417788744, -0.04281645268201828, -0.02434830740094185, 0.0242988932877779, -0.015589834190905094, -0.00509572634473443, 0.03703512251377106, 0.016911635175347328, 0.005253230687230825, -0.008851122111082077, -0.001956450054422021, 0.023780055344104767, -0.04410119354724884, -0.015009230002760887, -0.015342768281698227, -0.05633093789219856, -0.02235942892730236, 0.02360711060464382, -0.0023255040869116783, 0.01326741836965084, 0.006099429912865162, -0.006831361446529627, -0.00018356196233071387, 0.00008512179192621261, 0.011914734728634357, -0.03831986337900162, 0.01018527615815401, -0.01587395928800106, -0.005682507064193487, 0.035478606820106506, 0.010494108311831951, 0.02559598721563816, -0.02494126372039318, 0.014317446388304234, -0.014811578206717968, 0.04276704043149948, 0.011927087791264057, -0.029252557083964348, -0.019567588344216347, -0.0063032591715455055, 0.011883851140737534, -0.019209343940019608, 0.029005492106080055, -0.011852968484163284, -0.015577481128275394, 0.009969093836843967, -0.03500918298959732, -0.01915993168950081, 0.02532421611249447, 0.006148843094706535, -0.016911635175347328, -0.033230312168598175, -0.0056423586793243885, -0.001209848909638822, 0.013897435739636421, -0.009197013452649117, 0.01441627275198698, 0.004394677933305502, 0.021185867488384247, 0.00777021050453186, 0.01975288800895214, 0.039135176688432693, -0.016701629385352135, -0.007467555347830057, -0.011247657239437103, 0.009969093836843967, 0.011365014128386974, -0.017578711733222008, 0.01848050020635128, 0.04375530406832695, -0.0011179714929312468, 0.0016568831633776426, 0.006185902748256922, -0.05114256218075752, -0.012835053727030754, -0.03273618221282959, -0.0016182791441679, 0.028363121673464775, -0.030537297949194908, 0.0161457322537899, 0.041358768939971924, 0.024867143481969833, -0.00011909330351045355, -0.02399006113409996, 0.03172321245074272, -0.04612713307142258, -0.01132177747786045, -0.03693629428744316, -0.013502130284905434, -0.01115500833839178, -0.01003086008131504, -0.006321788765490055, -0.007541675120592117, 0.000951202237047255, 0.01977759413421154, 0.0210376288741827, -0.024385366588830948, 0.045904774218797684, 0.06507705897092819, -0.0030373616609722376, -0.0009048774372786283, -0.007726973854005337, 0.01786283776164055, 0.033255018293857574, -0.0054107350297272205, 0.006025310140103102, -0.0178010705858469, 0.0026621308643370867, 0.005407646298408508, -0.0033539144787937403, 0.0027377947699278593, -0.01881403848528862, -0.024187713861465454, -0.01310682576149702, 0.012087680399417877, -0.010259395465254784, -0.005636182148009539, 0.014502746053040028, -0.0324149951338768, -0.06893128156661987, 0.016763394698500633, 0.0009998432360589504, 0.024867143481969833, -0.026781901717185974, 0.02109939604997635, 0.01686222106218338, 0.015750426799058914, -0.00777021050453186, -0.0009295840281993151, -0.012272980064153671, -0.030685536563396454, 0.04111170396208763, -0.03110554814338684 ]
16.135473
6.7641
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.531.4746M
[ "quasars", "comparison standard stars", "periodic models", "random walk model", "physical properties", "objects", "periodic flux variation", "active galaxy nuclei", "monitoring", "further investigation" ]
[ "None" ]
4
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1479" ]
[ "Minev, Milen", "Trifonov, Trifon", "Ivanov, Valentin D.", "Ovcharov, Evgeni", "Bozhilov, Vladimir", "Valcheva, Antoniya", "Kostov, Andon", "Nedialkov, Petko" ]
[ "Department of Astronomy, Faculty of Physics, Sofia University 'St. Kliment Ohridski', 5 James Bourchier Blvd., BG-1164 Sofia, Bulgaria; Institute of Astronomy and NAO, Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, 72 Tsarigradsko Shose Blvd., BG-1784 Sofia, Bulgaria", "Department of Astronomy, Faculty of Physics, Sofia University 'St. Kliment Ohridski', 5 James Bourchier Blvd., BG-1164 Sofia, Bulgaria; Zentrum für Astronomie der Universität Heidelberg, Landessternwarte, Königstuhl 12, D-69117 Heidelberg, Germany", "European Southern Observatory, Karl Schwarzschildstr. 2, D-85748 Garching bei München, Germany", "Department of Astronomy, Faculty of Physics, Sofia University 'St. Kliment Ohridski', 5 James Bourchier Blvd., BG-1164 Sofia, Bulgaria", "Department of Astronomy, Faculty of Physics, Sofia University 'St. Kliment Ohridski', 5 James Bourchier Blvd., BG-1164 Sofia, Bulgaria", "Department of Astronomy, Faculty of Physics, Sofia University 'St. Kliment Ohridski', 5 James Bourchier Blvd., BG-1164 Sofia, Bulgaria", "Institute of Astronomy and NAO, Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, 72 Tsarigradsko Shose Blvd., BG-1784 Sofia, Bulgaria", "Department of Astronomy, Faculty of Physics, Sofia University 'St. Kliment Ohridski', 5 James Bourchier Blvd., BG-1164 Sofia, Bulgaria" ]
null
[ "1943ApJ....97...28S", "1963Natur.197.1040S", "1973A&A....24..337S", "1982AJ.....87..859P", "1983ApJ...275L..33K", "1986A&A...168...17E", "1986ApJ...302...52K", "1992A&AS...95..249L", "1992ApJ...393..113C", "1992ApJ...400..435K", "1992nrfa.book.....P", "1993A&AS..101..521S", "1993ApJ...411...89C", "1994A&AS..104..473S", "1994AJ....108..374B", "1996A&AS..115...11S", "1996AJ....111.1431B", "1996MNRAS.282.1274H", "1997A&AS..121..119V", "1997ARA&A..35..445U", "1997MNRAS.290..380H", "1997iagn.book.....P", "1998ApJ...503L.109H", "1999PASP..111..661S", "2000A&AS..145....1P", "2000KFNTS...3...13J", "2000MNRAS.316..885R", "2000PASP..112..925S", "2001AJ....121.2843B", "2004A&A...428..847P", "2004AIPC..735..395S", "2004MNRAS.353..133P", "2005A&A...435..839T", "2005MNRAS.358..774B", "2006A&A...455..773V", "2006PASP..118.1711W", "2007A&A...472..763B", "2007ApJS..171...61H", "2008ConPh..49...71T", "2008MNRAS.385.1279B", "2008MNRAS.386..819O", "2009A&A...496..577Z", "2009ApJ...698..895K", "2009MNRAS.393..969B", "2009MNRAS.397.2004A", "2010MNRAS.406..720R", "2010Natur.463E...1G", "2012ApJ...744..147S", "2012MNRAS.423.3083M", "2014MNRAS.443.3795R", "2015ApJ...813L..41A", "2015MNRAS.453.1562G", "2016AN....337..500M", "2016ApJ...830L..35R", "2016ApJ...833....6L", "2016MNRAS.463.2145C", "2017A&A...597A.128K", "2017AJ....154..220F", "2017Natur.552..374R", "2018A&A...615A.118S", "2018A&A...616L...6G", "2018NatAs...2..102L", "2019MNRAS.489.1837R", "2019ascl.soft06004T", "2020ApJS..247....3S", "2020MNRAS.493.3132S", "2020MNRAS.494L..75S", "2021MNRAS.502.1158Z", "2021MNRAS.508.2937M", "2022Natur.609..265J", "2023AJ....165..138F", "2023MNRAS.519.1745H", "2024MNRAS.530.4850H" ]
29184422
null
Automating galaxy morphology classification using K nearest neighbors and non-parametric statistics
Morphology is a fundamental property of any galaxy population. It is a major indicator of the physical processes that drive galaxy evolution and in turn the evolution of the entire universe. Historically, galaxy images were visually classified by trained experts. However, in the era of big data, more efficient techniques are required. In this work, we present a K Nearest Neighbors (KNN) based approach that utilizes non-parametric morphological quantities to classify galaxy morphology in SDSS images. Most previous studies used only a handful of morphological parameters to identify galaxy types. In contrast, we explore 1,023 morphological spaces (defined by up to 10 non-parametric statistics) to find the best combination of morphological parameters. Additionally, while most previous studies broadly classified galaxies into early-types and late-types or ellipticals, spirals and irregular galaxies, we classify galaxies into 11 morphological types with an average accuracy of $\sim 80-90~{{\%}}$ per T-Type. Our method is simple, easy to implement, and is robust to varying sizes and compositions of the training and test samples. Preliminary results on the performance of our technique on deeper images from the Hyper Suprime-Cam Subaru Strategic Survey reveals that an extension of our method to modern surveys with better imaging capabilities might be possible.
[ -0.009109525941312313, 0.03292683884501457, 0.03980984911322594, -0.020521139726042747, 0.025485744699835777, 0.0033949988428503275, -0.0039007605519145727, -0.032019954174757004, -0.021265249699354172, 0.04841361194849014, -0.04201892390847206, -0.05022737756371498, -0.018532972782850266, 0.0022584879770874977, -0.006092395167797804, 0.03041546791791916, 0.02274184115231037, 0.01535888109356165, 0.0408097468316555, 0.016858726739883423, 0.02567177079617977, 0.01669595204293728, -0.03357793390750885, 0.0010863705538213253, 0.003238038159906864, -0.00903976522386074, -0.012452204711735249, 0.018777133896946907, 0.028787730261683464, -0.010022222064435482, 0.005676740314811468, -0.012521964497864246, -0.0555291585624218, -0.01928870938718319, -0.02013745903968811, 0.08320072293281555, 0.009022325277328491, 0.0584590882062912, 0.005641859956085682, -0.008673524484038353, -0.009481580927968025, -0.019067801535129547, -0.017091261222958565, -0.0018442865693941712, -0.008411923423409462, -0.03648461028933525, -0.01984679140150547, -0.03592652827501297, -0.0351126603782177, 0.01414970401674509, -0.09147893637418747, 0.010016408748924732, 0.024695128202438354, -0.016498299315571785, -0.004833803977817297, 0.01287076622247696, -0.028159886598587036, -0.018451586365699768, 0.0021451276261359453, 0.009388566948473454, -0.01430085115134716, -0.032880332320928574, 0.05673833563923836, 0.004569296259433031, -0.04299556836485863, 0.003336865222081542, -0.05059943348169327, -0.008214269764721394, 0.00815613567829132, 0.013952049426734447, 0.03539169952273369, 0.005173885263502598, -0.013370714150369167, 0.00760386697947979, -0.008272402919828892, 0.01341722160577774, -0.01988167129456997, 0.032182727009058, -0.018881773576140404, 0.02069554105401039, 0.04020515829324722, 0.039251767098903656, 0.019218947738409042, 0.029043516144156456, -0.02681118994951248, 0.025811292231082916, 0.01956775039434433, -0.04636731371283531, -0.07701531797647476, -0.006388876121491194, 0.012184790335595608, 0.022427920252084732, -0.02131175622344017, 0.02569502592086792, -0.012115029618144035, 0.0019474736182019114, -0.0011176173575222492, -0.0845494195818901, 0.04780902341008186, 0.019218947738409042, 0.005653487052768469, 0.0758061408996582, -0.011161640286445618, -0.03162464499473572, 0.020521139726042747, -0.06101696565747261, -0.010998865589499474, 0.008667711168527603, 0.005479086190462112, 0.04150734841823578, 0.0018035931279882789, -0.01582394912838936, -0.0034444122575223446, 0.0468323789536953, 0.047483477741479874, -0.00716205220669508, -0.015998350456357002, 0.024183552712202072, -0.01866086572408676, 0.019044548273086548, -0.017707476392388344, 0.01518448069691658, 0.018033023923635483, 0.002312261611223221, 0.021265249699354172, -0.061807580292224884, -0.005011111032217741, 0.001321084680967033, -0.05808703228831291, 0.01633552461862564, 0.005531406495720148, -0.007109731901437044, 0.038391388952732086, -0.009179285727441311, -0.05352936312556267, -0.036042794585227966, -0.006441196426749229, -0.019777029752731323, -0.031113071367144585, 0.023218536749482155, -0.008353790268301964, -0.038693685084581375, 0.06110997870564461, 0.009551340714097023, -0.008388670161366463, -0.02834591455757618, -0.03687991946935654, 0.046041764318943024, -0.0583660751581192, 0.024997422471642494, 0.002065194072201848, -0.0050692446529865265, 0.012742872349917889, -0.023439444601535797, -0.04759974405169487, -0.004505349323153496, -0.011998763307929039, 0.01387066300958395, -0.02157917059957981, 0.018939906731247902, 0.007824774831533432, -0.0174981951713562, 0.0026407160330563784, 0.034019749611616135, -0.04752998426556587, 0.03469409793615341, -0.01546352170407772, -0.006662103813141584, -0.04213519021868706, -0.002395101822912693, -0.001777432975359261, -0.017300542443990707, -0.013231193646788597, -0.054459501057863235, -0.026113586500287056, 0.02248605340719223, 0.004351295530796051, -0.01360324863344431, -0.01667269878089428, -0.012835885398089886, -0.03392673283815384, 0.04490234702825546, -0.00862120371311903, -0.044274505227804184, -0.053296830505132675, 0.0005370085709728301, 0.007789894472807646, 0.033694200217723846, -0.006313302554190159, 0.0069934651255607605, -0.020904820412397385, 0.007330639287829399, 0.016870353370904922, 0.039251767098903656, -0.017323795706033707, -0.016242511570453644, 0.035507965832948685, 0.0023108082823455334, -0.030880536884069443, -0.015533282421529293, 0.01256847195327282, 0.012952152639627457, 0.017335422337055206, -0.056831348687410355, -0.027322763577103615, -0.03278731554746628, -0.0016727925976738334, -0.01341722160577774, -0.04943676292896271, -0.030159680172801018, 0.018451586365699768, 0.016870353370904922, 0.0018806200241670012, 0.06073792278766632, -0.02541598491370678, 0.004912284202873707, -0.046623099595308304, 0.051250528544187546, 0.026462387293577194, 0.05901717022061348, 0.01956775039434433, -0.011783668771386147, 0.0408097468316555, 0.02478814125061035, -0.025811292231082916, -0.030206188559532166, 0.04520464316010475, -0.03629858419299126, -0.024741634726524353, -0.0467626191675663, 0.027880845591425896, 0.012335937470197678, 0.01664944551885128, 0.02543923817574978, -0.010876785963773727, -0.03134560585021973, 0.016719207167625427, -0.012905646115541458, -0.006929518189281225, 0.0019794469699263573, -0.0013268981128931046, 0.05222717300057411, -0.02946207858622074, 0.01433573104441166, -0.02217213250696659, 0.03769378736615181, -0.015568162314593792, 0.017695849761366844, 0.0007615493959747255, 0.0009054298861883581, 0.01692848652601242, -0.013905542902648449, -0.013347460888326168, -0.02892724983394146, -0.027857592329382896, -0.010045476257801056, -0.014068316668272018, 0.04990183189511299, -0.010022222064435482, 0.007237625773996115, -0.02039324678480625, -0.038089096546173096, -0.0006343822460621595, 0.018939906731247902, -0.03620557114481926, -0.0034618524368852377, -0.022044239565730095, -0.03687991946935654, -0.015510029159486294, -0.00207536737434566, -0.04548368230462074, -0.019358469173312187, 0.03174091503024101, -0.034601084887981415, -0.04450703784823418, 0.034880124032497406, -0.016475046053528786, 0.03999587520956993, 0.010429156944155693, -0.07455044984817505, 0.030322454869747162, -0.0057697538286447525, 0.0787825733423233, 0.011434867046773434, -0.01270799245685339, 0.04194916412234306, -0.024578861892223358, -0.026485640555620193, -0.03467084467411041, -0.06929518282413483, 0.0380425900220871, -0.05166909098625183, -0.025881052017211914, -0.0029546371661126614, -0.05948223918676376, -0.060040321201086044, 0.02574153244495392, 0.021451275795698166, -0.007632934022694826, 0.02516019716858864, 0.014126450754702091, -0.024602115154266357, 0.020544392988085747, 0.0010754704708233476, -0.0045256963931024075, 0.016579685732722282, -0.005877301096916199, 0.03092704340815544, 0.017184274271130562, -0.000153054716065526, -0.017579583451151848, -0.02690420299768448, 0.04794854298233986, 0.040739987045526505, -0.0277645792812109, -0.016707580536603928, -0.0065865302458405495, 0.02186983823776245, 0.032578036189079285, -0.04239097982645035, -0.07115545123815536, -0.041670121252536774, 0.034880124032497406, -0.002223607851192355, -0.022683707997202873, -0.035507965832948685, -0.044786080718040466, 0.004612896591424942, -0.025299716740846634, -0.035228926688432693, 0.03901923447847366, -0.040763240307569504, 0.06562113761901855, 0.03092704340815544, -0.026229852810502052, 0.0011372374137863517, -0.008417736738920212, 0.054459501057863235, -0.03239201009273529, -0.020056070759892464, -0.06562113761901855, -0.00350835919380188, 0.019184067845344543, -0.01662619225680828, 0.013824156485497952, 0.04818107932806015, 0.0006561823538504541, 0.050134364515542984, 0.0037641467060893774, 0.007714320905506611, 0.012801005505025387, -0.0028107566758990288, 0.0525527223944664, 0.032089713960886, 0.025322970002889633, 0.0021422209683805704, -0.011347667314112186, -0.028206393122673035, 0.03934478014707565, 0.010272196494042873, 0.03262454271316528, -0.04122830554842949, 0.026113586500287056, 0.03646135702729225, 0.006394689437001944, 0.046297550201416016, -0.021172234788537025, -0.011196520179510117, -0.013963676989078522, -0.02068391442298889, -0.030461976304650307, 0.02370685711503029, -0.0013094580499455333, -0.012475457973778248, -0.044832587242126465, -0.0037844935432076454, -0.011161640286445618, 0.021183861419558525, 0.011574387550354004, 0.048925187438726425, 0.04585573822259903, -0.00685975793749094, -0.005098311696201563, -0.012045269832015038, 0.01560304220765829, -0.01810278557240963, 0.028834236785769463, -0.0060633281245827675, -0.05022737756371498, 0.02571827918291092, -0.01932358928024769, 0.030601495876908302, 0.024020779877901077, 0.02955509163439274, 0.015847202390432358, -0.0038600671105086803, -0.000609675538726151, 0.0670628547668457, -0.0011437773937359452, 0.0438559427857399, -0.014358984306454659, -0.009987342171370983, 0.006923704873770475, -0.010760518722236156, 0.0009090632665902376, 0.022602321580052376, 0.019963057711720467, 0.016870353370904922, 0.03994936868548393, 0.008446803316473961, 0.07027182728052139, -0.06017984077334404, 0.0262763611972332, -0.018044650554656982, -0.014533385634422302, 0.024462593719363213, -0.04257700592279434, 0.010510544292628765, -0.025067182257771492, 0.049808818846940994, 0.023462697863578796, -0.00745853316038847, -0.004450122360140085, -0.014638025313615799, -0.01326607447117567, 0.004275721963495016, 0.021962851285934448, 0.02543923817574978, -0.03471735119819641, -0.02539272978901863, 0.0003028394130524248, 0.046878889203071594, 0.03299659863114357, -0.02068391442298889, -0.008813044987618923, -0.02981087937951088, 0.04873916134238243, 0.009243233129382133, 0.01635877788066864, -0.01783537119626999, -0.03857741877436638, -0.00876653753221035, -0.005107031669467688, -0.026439134031534195, 0.07943367213010788, 0.005932528059929609, 0.012045269832015038, 0.02509043551981449, 0.00817357562482357, -0.06687682867050171, -0.02685769647359848, 0.034949883818626404, 0.012812632136046886, -0.0022018079180270433, 0.021811705082654953, -0.04050745069980621, 0.027950607240200043, -0.06608621031045914, 0.052692241966724396, -0.045367415994405746, 0.02511368878185749, -0.00816776230931282, -0.009958275593817234, 0.0012825712328776717, -0.04197241738438606, 0.029136531054973602, -0.05032039433717728, -0.023730112239718437, 0.01927708275616169, -0.032578036189079285, 0.02511368878185749, -0.04325135424733162, 0.05143655836582184, -0.019439855590462685, 0.024137046188116074, 0.005150631535798311, -0.022602321580052376, -0.03678690642118454, 0.05724991112947464, 0.050971489399671555, 0.02690420299768448, -0.030275948345661163, -0.0038833206053823233, -0.004612896591424942, -0.01837019808590412, 0.022381413727998734, 0.0024328886065632105, 0.010748892091214657, 0.009179285727441311, 0.01924220286309719, -0.027508791536092758, -0.01374276913702488, 0.04755323752760887, -0.009406006895005703, -0.0037525200750678778, -0.024067286401987076, -0.025881052017211914, -0.012731245718896389, 0.01531237456947565, -0.012696364894509315, 0.04155385494232178, -0.03648461028933525, 0.03364769369363785, 0.020369993522763252, -0.0022425013594329357, -0.0006347455782815814, 0.016823846846818924, -0.01782374456524849, -0.03832162916660309, -0.015010080300271511, -0.0145798921585083, 0.05618025362491608, 0.0001450613490305841, 0.01896316185593605, 0.05785449966788292, -0.00022345079923979938, -0.020032817497849464, 0.011336040683090687, 0.0004963151295669377, -0.0033252385910600424, 0.001118344021961093, -0.017021501436829567, -0.009609473869204521, -0.008098002523183823, 0.017474941909313202, -0.04794854298233986, -0.046576593071222305, -0.14770570397377014, -0.05292477458715439, -0.001390844932757318, 0.032554782927036285, -0.020637407898902893, 0.02160242386162281, 0.036345090717077255, -0.03685666620731354, -0.03999587520956993, 0.010458224453032017, -0.030299201607704163, -0.02511368878185749, 0.010568677447736263, 0.013498608022928238, -0.018521346151828766, 0.003240944817662239, 0.003174091223627329, 0.014800799079239368, 0.023474324494600296, 0.010504730977118015, -0.02395101822912693, 0.024439340457320213, 0.01928870938718319, 0.01342884823679924, -0.02336968295276165, 0.0350661501288414, -0.011010492220520973, -0.046855632215738297, 0.018893400207161903, 0.001520192134194076, 0.04827409237623215, -0.015010080300271511, 0.0005068518221378326, -0.029020262882113457, 0.0019314868841320276, 0.01242895144969225, 0.04504186660051346, 0.012312684208154678, -0.02333480305969715, 0.012731245718896389, -0.009057206101715565, -0.008289842866361141, 0.006540023256093264, -0.034949883818626404, -0.008382856845855713, 0.019637510180473328, -0.064411960542202, -0.03653111681342125, -0.023206910118460655, -0.037531014531850815, 0.0174981951713562, 0.03160139173269272, -0.03701943904161453, -0.039600569754838943, -0.028206393122673035, 0.004371642135083675, -0.009295552968978882, -0.042832791805267334, -0.0015434455126523972, -0.0052988724783062935, 0.023532457649707794, 0.014219463802874088, -0.00862701702862978, 0.004874497186392546, -0.048971693962812424, 0.029322557151317596, -0.00415654806420207, 0.031415365636348724, -0.03969358280301094, 0.006202848628163338, 0.015277494676411152, -0.02857844904065132, 0.020323485136032104, 0.006458636373281479, 0.007685254327952862, -0.02099783532321453, -0.049808818846940994, 0.011789482086896896, -0.0011045372812077403, 0.00031155944452621043, -0.009202539920806885, 0.011370920576155186, 0.010150115936994553, -0.010417530313134193, 0.022369787096977234, 0.015370508655905724, 0.0009141499176621437, -0.02802036702632904, 0.019939804449677467, 0.006894637830555439, 0.007237625773996115, 0.03427553549408913, 0.0080224284902215, -0.0028601703234016895, 0.004432682413607836, -0.021125728264451027, -0.013626501895487309, 0.06762093305587769, -0.003022944089025259, -0.011027933098375797, -0.03178742155432701, -0.012638231739401817, -0.02657865546643734, -0.016196005046367645, -0.02077692747116089, 0.05734292417764664, -0.0028340101707726717, -0.012928899377584457, 0.02478814125061035, -0.012149910442531109, -0.007993361912667751, 0.019451482221484184, 0.010981425642967224, -0.001523098791949451, 0.045111626386642456, 0.009754808619618416, -0.0015390855260193348, 0.001870446722023189, 0.0174981951713562, -0.018532972782850266, -0.006883011199533939, -0.04766950383782387, -0.02166055701673031, 0.006028448231518269, -0.03339190408587456, 0.00010209703032160178, -0.008795605041086674, 0.025322970002889633, -0.033461667597293854, 0.0010420436738058925, 0.03013642691075802, -0.03650786355137825, 0.046018511056900024, -0.022892989218235016, 0.009853634983301163, 0.0021102475002408028, -0.0306712556630373, -0.004182708449661732, -0.02681118994951248, -0.019486362114548683, 0.012487084604799747, -0.02250930666923523, 0.010650064796209335, 0.06817901879549026, -0.003583932761102915, 0.013754395768046379, 0.018172545358538628, -0.04180964082479477, -0.045413922518491745, -0.007406213320791721, -0.04139108210802078, -0.04204217717051506, -0.00759224034845829, -0.011748788878321648, 0.007795707788318396, -0.017719103023409843, 0.01473103929311037, 0.034322042018175125, -0.006929518189281225, 0.027276257053017616, 0.020904820412397385, 0.0036595063284039497, 0.028438927605748177, 0.01446362491697073, -0.03297334536910057, -0.0017948730383068323, 0.006760930642485619, -0.0043803621083498, 0.006074955221265554, 0.014696159400045872, 0.038158856332302094, -0.02685769647359848, -0.029578344896435738, 0.04985532537102699, 0.030020160600543022, -0.021137354895472527, -0.03171766176819801, 0.017300542443990707, 0.03185718134045601, -0.0038484404794871807, -0.0010602104011923075, 0.035205673426389694, -0.023265043273568153, 0.012917272746562958, 0.015300747938454151, -0.013940422795712948, -0.002617462771013379, 0.011731348931789398, -0.028717968612909317, -0.0019910738337785006, -0.027020469307899475, -0.006551649887114763, -0.009998968802392483, -0.016289018094539642, -0.009766435250639915, -0.06603970378637314, 0.015417015179991722, 0.0262996144592762, 0.005229112226516008, -0.010673318058252335, -0.0008836298366077244, -0.024113792926073074, -0.0035228924825787544, 0.018928280100226402, 0.01340559497475624, -0.027020469307899475, -0.01663781888782978, -0.007249252405017614, 0.028531942516565323, 0.010278009809553623, -0.03192694112658501, -0.02041650004684925, 0.023183656856417656, 0.016289018094539642, 0.01488218642771244, 0.03678690642118454, -0.002289008116349578, 0.0068771978840231895, 0.009260673075914383, 0.03769378736615181, -0.016835473477840424, -0.008220083080232143, 0.03004341386258602, 0.0160797368735075, 0.00848749652504921, -0.0068365042097866535, -0.004066441208124161, 0.028392421081662178, -0.01956775039434433, 0.01982353813946247, 0.020590899512171745, 0.01519610732793808, 0.06510956585407257, 0.034298788756132126, 0.043646663427352905, 0.0306945089250803, 0.01810278557240963, 0.024299820885062218, -0.006260982248932123, -0.015300747938454151, -0.009150219149887562, -0.019218947738409042, 0.002319528255611658, -0.02246280014514923, 0.01477754581719637, 0.029717866331338882, 0.007859654724597931, 0.0004806917277164757, 0.015265868045389652, 0.011929002590477467, -0.03571724891662598, 0.011184893548488617, 0.04169337451457977, -0.04206543043255806, -0.02191634476184845, 0.04850662499666214, -0.020009564235806465, 0.01360324863344431, 0.026508893817663193, -0.016440166160464287, -0.005830794107168913, 0.01784699782729149, -0.02192797139286995, -0.0014068316668272018, 0.02804362028837204, 0.018637612462043762, -0.011016306467354298, -0.03248502314090729, 0.029299303889274597, -0.009795501828193665, -0.0672488808631897, -0.005452926270663738, 0.041344575583934784, -0.0015623389044776559, 0.024485846981406212, 0.009772248566150665, -0.014498504810035229, 0.005932528059929609, -0.006336555816233158, 0.015521655790507793, -0.02829940803349018, -0.022962749004364014, 0.008580510504543781, 0.05343635007739067, 0.03092704340815544, -0.0277645792812109, 0.009371127001941204, -0.037507761269807816, -0.010958172380924225, -0.02305576205253601, -0.04150734841823578, -0.0032787316013127565, 0.008382856845855713, -0.012208043597638607, -0.006662103813141584, -0.029903894290328026, -0.022672081366181374, -0.040460944175720215, 0.03922851383686066, 0.011423240415751934, -0.05194813385605812, -0.0351126603782177, -0.002659609541296959, 0.03583351522684097, -0.011841801926493645, -0.013080046512186527, -0.002389288507401943, 0.0017498196102678776, -0.029950400814414024, -0.033136118203401566, -0.012254550121724606, -0.006057514809072018, -0.008568883873522282, -0.0008451163303107023, 0.030554989352822304, 0.01924220286309719, 0.03239201009273529, 0.012696364894509315, 0.016009977087378502, 0.045972004532814026, 0.022846480831503868, -0.045995257794857025, -0.003412438789382577, 0.010138489305973053, -0.024392833933234215, -0.029694613069295883, -0.0036653196439146996, -0.00035643126466311514, -0.042832791805267334, 0.004159454721957445, -0.030322454869747162, 0.002960450481623411, 0.003894947236403823, 0.0013327114284038544, -0.057110391557216644, -0.028508689254522324, -0.022590693086385727, 0.032275740057229996, 0.045972004532814026, -0.03176416829228401, -0.01444037165492773, 0.03192694112658501, -0.00196636701002717, 0.029601598158478737, 0.01637040451169014, -0.010086169466376305, -0.03908899426460266, 0.020497886463999748, -0.021997731178998947, -0.025299716740846634, -0.009748994372785091, -0.006778371054679155, 0.009807128459215164, 0.005633139982819557, -0.00394436065107584, 0.002177101094275713, -0.0013486981624737382, -0.00040584479575045407, -0.03943779319524765, 0.008563070558011532, -0.023148775100708008, -0.008522377349436283, 0.022683707997202873, 0.020056070759892464, -0.008382856845855713, -0.005452926270663738, 0.011376733891665936, -0.0009170566336251795, 0.031438618898391724, -0.007830588147044182, 0.0016974994214251637, 0.006976024713367224, -0.013545115478336811, 0.005115751642733812, 0.0014337184838950634, -0.0408330000936985, 0.00685394462198019, 0.009987342171370983, 0.004226308315992355, 0.03162464499473572, 0.03092704340815544, -0.002376208547502756, 0.005682553630322218, -0.03006666712462902, 0.011231400072574615, -0.004705910105258226, 0.005952874664217234, -0.029415572062134743, -0.0017658063443377614, -0.016998248174786568, 0.017951637506484985, 0.017288915812969208, -0.04550693556666374, -0.0046303365379571915, -0.00200851378031075, -0.012905646115541458, -0.0037612400483340025, -0.006906264461576939, -0.03418252244591713, 0.05311080440878868, -0.0029415572062134743, -0.023718485608696938, 0.01954449713230133, -0.017184274271130562, -0.01664944551885128, -0.01662619225680828, -0.007353893015533686, 0.03325238451361656, 0.019370095804333687, -0.0007760827429592609, 0.00037532468559220433, -0.002448875457048416, 0.002303541637957096, 0.009673421271145344, 0.02160242386162281, -0.015835575759410858, -0.01503333356231451, -0.00350254587829113, 0.047762516885995865, -0.005005297716706991, 0.0031304911244660616, 0.007970108650624752, -0.0034763857256621122, 0.006929518189281225, -0.003482199041172862, -0.013638128526508808, 0.02159079723060131, -0.012115029618144035, -0.0029575438238680363, 0.027811085805296898, 0.016207631677389145, 0.006551649887114763, -0.01635877788066864, -0.012521964497864246, -0.014091569930315018, 0.029299303889274597, -0.02278834767639637, 0.055017583072185516, -0.0005555386305786669, 0.01575418934226036, -0.038135603070259094, -0.04504186660051346, 0.028997009620070457, 0.0014591518556699157, 0.012626605108380318, 0.03969358280301094, 0.0025200890377163887, -0.023218536749482155, 0.006487702950835228, 0.011458121240139008, -0.013207940384745598, -0.017463315278291702, 0.00208699400536716, 0.03171766176819801, 0.002864530310034752, -0.006458636373281479, -0.014277597889304161, -0.029694613069295883, -0.002143674297258258, -0.0017033127369359136, -0.039879608899354935, 0.011022119782865047, -0.002336968434974551, 0.04701840877532959, 0.030764270573854446, -0.015300747938454151, -0.01447525154799223, 0.040414437651634216, 0.0035170791670680046, 0.007231812458485365, -0.022020984441041946, -0.020090952515602112, -0.01719590090215206, -0.02574153244495392, -0.0005504519795067608, 0.030857283622026443, 0.005319219082593918, 0.018591105937957764, -0.041925910860300064, -0.014417118392884731, -0.0002786776749417186, 0.011783668771386147, 0.04462330415844917, -0.016579685732722282, 0.03848440572619438, 0.018742254003882408, 0.08120092749595642, -0.02395101822912693, -0.008993258699774742, -0.010708197951316833, -0.006057514809072018, -0.02455560676753521, -0.05111100897192955, 0.057063885033130646, 0.03536844626069069, 0.04255375266075134, 0.03185718134045601, -0.029950400814414024, 0.004915190860629082, -0.0034182521048933268, -0.010772145353257656, -0.0030868910253047943, 0.0032729182858020067, -0.03650786355137825, -0.023241790011525154, -0.004714630078524351, -0.02190471813082695, 0.01433573104441166, 0.0146263986825943, -0.017416808754205704, 0.0075050401501357555, 0.006603970192372799, 0.002950277179479599, 0.017579583451151848, 0.011754602193832397, 0.006167968735098839, 0.009865261614322662, -0.007813148200511932, -0.004604176618158817, 0.011429053731262684, -0.013789275661110878, -0.008964192122220993, 0.012335937470197678, -0.023730112239718437, 0.013928796164691448, 0.01868412084877491, -0.04532090947031975, 0.04032142460346222, 0.040460944175720215, 0.003656599670648575, 0.0146147720515728, -0.02974111959338188, -0.051297035068273544, -0.041019026190042496, 0.01357999537140131, 0.009307179600000381, -0.0174865685403347, 0.0020201406441628933, -0.022660454735159874, 0.006540023256093264, -0.016091363504529, 0.0018021397991105914, -0.001777432975359261, -0.014196210540831089, -0.037228718400001526, -0.013975303620100021, 0.0037525200750678778, 0.03567074239253998, -0.00387169374153018, 0.04060046374797821, -0.024044033139944077, -0.015672802925109863, 0.006679543759673834, 0.008214269764721394, 0.0021930879447609186, 0.029299303889274597, -0.0032060646917670965, 0.004534416366368532, 0.013533487915992737, -0.034880124032497406, -0.054785050451755524, -0.000731755921151489, 0.004258282016962767, -0.018846893683075905, -0.009667607955634594, -0.01578906923532486, 0.01487055979669094, 0.00037060133763588965, 0.02159079723060131, 0.009074646048247814, -0.01547514833509922, -0.00758642703294754, 0.034298788756132126, -0.035787008702754974, 0.04441402480006218, -0.01780048944056034, -0.02950858511030674, -0.04029817134141922, -0.021497784182429314, 0.003630439518019557, 0.018893400207161903, -0.03039221465587616, -0.012010389938950539, 0.03269430249929428, 0.002626182744279504, 0.007917787879705429, -0.011179080232977867, -0.02310226857662201, -0.0055517531000077724, -0.0005791553994640708, -0.0075457338243722916, -0.0022352347150444984, 0.012963779270648956, -0.01984679140150547, -0.027950607240200043, 0.00043890823144465685, 0.0004785117052961141, 0.015219360589981079, 0.0174865685403347, 0.041879404336214066, 0.020614152774214745, 0.03320587798953056, -0.0042204950004816055, -0.03295009210705757, -0.015114720910787582, 0.0014264517230913043, -0.005092498380690813, -0.022334907203912735, 0.023532457649707794, 0.01447525154799223, -0.004615803249180317, 0.015010080300271511, -0.03415926918387413, -0.010155929252505302, -0.0031595579348504543, -0.014103196561336517, -0.024648621678352356, 0.019497988745570183, -0.024113792926073074, -0.02657865546643734, 0.045181386172771454, 0.008435176685452461, -0.0061040217988193035, -0.02193959802389145, 0.013219567015767097, -0.004752417095005512, 0.003560679266229272, -0.002127687679603696, 0.02741577848792076, -0.0009424900054000318, 0.0408795066177845, 0.016196005046367645, 0.01373114250600338, 0.010539610870182514, 0.06771394610404968, 0.007970108650624752, -0.021986104547977448, 0.01777723617851734, -0.018614359200000763, 0.02660190872848034, 0.030182935297489166, 0.011824361979961395, -0.0003357212117407471, 0.016068110242486, 0.011940629221498966, -0.011446494609117508, 0.00773757416754961, 0.05376189947128296, 0.009905955754220486, 0.0016379124717786908, -0.02192797139286995, -0.010010595433413982, -0.04122830554842949, 0.006481889635324478, -0.004362922161817551, -0.010382650420069695, 0.005095405038446188, -0.011382547207176685, 0.026764681562781334, -0.0038804139476269484, 0.03283382207155228, -0.007534106727689505, 0.029973654076457024, 0.0018195798620581627, -0.007051598280668259, 0.029927147552371025, 0.007807334419339895, 0.018556226044893265, 0.011586015112698078, -0.03292683884501457, 0.0017846997361630201, 0.0072143725119531155, -0.03153163194656372, -0.0016800593584775925, 0.006970211397856474, 0.01371951587498188, -0.012405697256326675, 0.020811807364225388, 0.03601954132318497, -0.028857490047812462, -0.0145798921585083, 0.008249149657785892, -0.001411918317899108, 0.027578551322221756, 0.012545217759907246, 0.016440166160464287, -0.0012963779736310244, -0.009336247108876705, 0.01926545612514019, 0.013382340781390667, 0.01662619225680828, 0.021230369806289673, -0.017405182123184204, -0.02748553827404976, 0.012533591128885746, 0.011475561186671257, 0.0014540652045980096, 0.010336143895983696, -0.011562760919332504, -0.01341722160577774, -0.0032787316013127565, -0.033415161073207855, 0.007069038692861795, 0.029648106545209885, -0.023578964173793793, -0.016254138201475143, 0.02743903174996376, -0.016300644725561142, -0.02185821160674095, 0.02836916781961918, -0.016068110242486, -0.0006024088361300528, -0.00003497095894999802, 0.015149600803852081, -0.005025644786655903, 0.014661278575658798, -0.03264779597520828, -0.006388876121491194, 0.023811498656868935, 0.009504834190011024, -0.002270114840939641, 0.039879608899354935, -0.003261291654780507, 0.0025956626050174236, 0.006005194969475269, 0.002286101458594203, -0.021986104547977448, -0.011539507657289505, 0.0006507323123514652, -0.01271961908787489, 0.020090952515602112, 0.02827615477144718, 0.02245117351412773, 0.018207425251603127, 0.01387066300958395, 0.04350714385509491, -0.01692848652601242, -0.0038571604527533054, -0.021986104547977448, -0.0437396764755249, 0.02283485420048237, 0.023532457649707794, 0.027973860502243042, -0.03353142738342285, -0.014672906138002872, -0.011882496066391468, 0.015010080300271511, -0.062365662306547165, 0.007208559196442366, 0.01298703346401453, -0.029392318800091743, 0.02224189229309559, 0.02157917059957981, 0.018242305144667625, 0.006057514809072018, -0.021683810278773308, 0.002259941305965185, -0.016265764832496643, 0.019753776490688324, -0.0005689820391125977, 0.024439340457320213, -0.001777432975359261, 0.004333855584263802, -0.03776354715228081, 0.007377146277576685, -0.010051289573311806, -0.007801521103829145, 0.02278834767639637, -0.0074643464758992195, 0.008685151115059853, -0.03776354715228081, -0.00002611467607493978, -0.003505452536046505, -0.007813148200511932, -0.012347564101219177, -0.0013370714150369167, -0.01489381305873394, 0.0006412856164388359, -0.03683341294527054, 0.0027104762848466635, -0.006923704873770475, 0.012115029618144035, -0.0027206498198211193, -0.002437248593196273, 0.03290358558297157, -0.009028138592839241, 0.00918509904295206, -0.016812220215797424, 0.00168151268735528, -0.010882599279284477, 0.009935022331774235, -0.020951328799128532, 0.009429260157048702, -0.020253725349903107, -0.036647383123636246, -0.044576797634363174, 0.016556432470679283, -0.00803986843675375, -0.038740191608667374, 0.009621101431548595, -0.01560304220765829, -0.02660190872848034, 0.015521655790507793, -0.021404769271612167, 0.0007448359974659979, 0.01342884823679924, 0.0018035931279882789, 0.011423240415751934, 0.006458636373281479, -0.006534209940582514, 0.0010907305404543877, -0.013673008419573307, 0.009068832732737064, 0.006842317990958691, -0.0039036672096699476, 0.03855416551232338, 0.018637612462043762, -0.03894947096705437, 0.019742149859666824, 0.012452204711735249, 0.012359190732240677, -0.02162567712366581, -0.02895050309598446, -0.026718175038695335, -0.0010936371982097626, 0.004142014775425196, 0.024369580671191216, 0.03348492085933685, -0.006202848628163338, 0.020835060626268387, -0.008551443926990032, -0.032182727009058, -0.010562864132225513, 0.00687138456851244, 0.005653487052768469, 0.03922851383686066, -0.012766125611960888, 0.019753776490688324, -0.02597406692802906, 0.012138282880187035, 0.016137870028614998, -0.016126243397593498, 0.004976231139153242, 0.0001621380797587335, -0.029648106545209885, -0.02043975330889225, 0.010260569863021374, 0.0057377805933356285, 0.004982044454663992, 0.005060524679720402, -0.022683707997202873, -0.04039118438959122, -0.023799872025847435, -0.0004908650880679488, -0.009905955754220486, 0.036670636385679245, -0.011475561186671257, 0.022288398817181587, 0.00714461226016283, 0.024648621678352356, 0.011289533227682114, -0.015393761917948723, 0.00714461226016283, 0.029624853283166885, -0.00005286518717184663, 0.007336453069001436, 0.020311858505010605, 0.015637923032045364, -0.005019831471145153, -0.02281160093843937, -0.016289018094539642, 0.0350428968667984, -0.017091261222958565, 0.015521655790507793, 0.041344575583934784, -0.015254241414368153, 0.022613948211073875, -0.007342266384512186, -0.020079325884580612, -0.0011430507292971015, -0.008824671618640423, 0.00006199397466843948, 0.010789585299789906, 0.034601084887981415, 0.013498608022928238, 0.024950915947556496, -0.004711723420768976, 0.01518448069691658, -0.017602836713194847, 0.000015918598364805803, -0.015696056187152863, -0.015637923032045364, -0.027973860502243042, 0.022613948211073875, 0.011330227367579937, -0.02040487341582775, -0.022020984441041946, 0.010022222064435482, 0.009336247108876705, 0.019125934690237045, 0.046576593071222305, -0.005005297716706991, 0.011074439622461796, -0.009092085994780064, 0.010760518722236156, 0.03390347957611084, 0.01418458390980959, 0.027276257053017616, -0.01581232249736786, 0.029345812276005745, 0.02983413264155388, 0.022125625982880592, 0.014800799079239368, -0.017370302230119705, -0.01692848652601242, -0.031113071367144585, -0.00773757416754961, -0.024695128202438354, -0.01535888109356165, -0.0017120328266173601, 0.035228926688432693, -0.03192694112658501, -0.0175214484333992, 0.007830588147044182, 0.021730316802859306, 0.02013745903968811, -0.001191010931506753, -0.015916964039206505, 0.0011016306234523654, 0.0003121044428553432, 0.01413807738572359, 0.020567646250128746, -0.010609371587634087, 0.03092704340815544, -0.011556947603821754, 0.028531942516565323, -0.019451482221484184, 0.023764992132782936, 0.012475457973778248, 0.02862495556473732, -0.003674039850011468, 0.03562423214316368, 0.038414642214775085, 0.04292580485343933, 0.015451895073056221, -0.021765198558568954, -0.029671359807252884, 0.0131498072296381, 0.02103271521627903, 0.01896316185593605, 0.01532400120049715, 0.007795707788318396, 0.02829940803349018, 0.01871900074183941, 0.018521346151828766, 0.0017163928132504225, -0.003842627163976431, 0.015905337408185005, 0.015963470563292503, -0.0292062908411026, -0.017079634591937065, -0.007382959593087435, -0.006417942699044943, -0.039251767098903656, -0.02569502592086792, 0.01331258099526167, -0.001450431882403791, -0.003412438789382577, -0.0075806137174367905, 0.002174194436520338, 0.03427553549408913, -0.010516357608139515, -0.012138282880187035, -0.019788658246397972, 0.08273565769195557, 0.0020666474010795355, 0.014382237568497658, -0.008772351779043674, -0.011963882483541965, -0.0161029901355505, -0.03862392529845238, 0.014661278575658798, -0.015161227434873581, 0.029299303889274597, 0.0017396461917087436, -0.018265558406710625, -0.002475035609677434, -0.00157251232303679, -0.0018806200241670012, 0.012056896463036537, 0.011417427100241184, -0.0018050464568659663, 0.008929312229156494, -0.008667711168527603, 0.006353996228426695, -0.03418252244591713, 0.03562423214316368, 0.013696262612938881, 0.02746228501200676, -0.027880845591425896, 0.011737162247300148, 0.006394689437001944, -0.03250827640295029, -0.005650580395013094, -0.0005617153365164995, 0.041019026190042496, 0.007638747338205576, -0.00859795045107603, -0.036717142909765244 ]
11.680503
5.033332
2024-07-01
0
2024MNRAS.tmp.1656M
[ "galaxy types", "galaxy images", "galaxy evolution", "galaxy morphology", "irregular galaxies", "non-parametric morphological quantities", "galaxies", "morphological parameters", "deeper images", "Most previous studies" ]
[ "galaxies: general", "galaxies: structure", "catalogues" ]
0
[ "10.1093/mnras/stae1684" ]
[ "Mukundan, Kavya", "Nair, Preethi", "Bailin, Jeremy", "Li, Wenhao" ]
[ "Dept. of Physics and Astronomy, The University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa, AL 35487, USA", "Dept. of Physics and Astronomy, The University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa, AL 35487, USA;", "Dept. of Physics and Astronomy, The University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa, AL 35487, USA", "Dept. of Physics and Astronomy, The University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa, AL 35487, USA" ]
null
null