Datasets:
tensorkelechi
/
arxiv-cstext

Dataset card Data Studio Files Community
1
text
stringlengths
0
89.3k
Prompt Generating Indicator States
In point AnswerAlgorithm Correctness you mentioned above each review mentions some
reason for a positive or negative opinion on that point Clus ter the reasons in point An
swerAlgorithm Correctness into similar meanings
Response 1 Correctness of Answers
R1 P The answers are all correct
R2 P The answers are all correct
R3 P The answers are all correct
R4 P The answers are correct
R6 P The answers are perfectly correct
R7 P Part A is correct
R8 P The answers are all correct
2 Presentation of Answers
R1 P The answers are clearly presented
R2 P The answers are clearly presented
R3 P The answers are clearly presented though there is a t ypo in part 1
R8 P The answers are clearly presented
3 Incorrect Answers or Misinterpretation of Questions
R5 N For part 1 According to the rubric you get 0 by claimi ng an incorrect result
as correct and give a proof for it The claim proved in part 2 is not what the problem
asks However it is correct and is some merit in the steps tha t close to the correct
problem
26Prompt Revise summarization
In the cluster of detailed reasons you summarized above are there repeated reasons that have
similar meanings Revise your answer and combine repeated reasons if any
Response 1 Correct and Clear Presentation of Answers
R1 P The answers are all correct and clearly presented
R2 P The answers are all correct and clearly presented
R3 P The answers are all correct and clearly presented th ough there is a typo in part
1
R4 P The answers are correct
R6 P The answers are perfectly correct
R7 P Part A is correct
R8 P The answers are all correct and clearly presented
2 Incorrect Answers or Misinterpretation of Questions
R5 N For part 1 According to the rubric you get 0 by claimi ng an incorrect result
as correct and give a proof for it The claim proved in part 2 is not what the problem
asks However it is correct and is some merit in the steps tha t close to the correct
problem
Next we parse peer review into reports on indicator states We first ask GPT to summarize
a peer review Then for each topic we ask GPT to match each pee r review with the indicator
states Note that for each matching task we append the same s ummarization history from all the
instructor reviews and one particular peer review without g enerating new histories
Prompt Summarizing peer review
Here is a student review on the same submission as R2 Summari ze the following student
review into pros and cons
Review
AnswerAlgorithm
Answers for both questions are correct and use proper proofs from the course
ProofAnalysis
Proof and analysis for both questions are correct with prope r runtime analysis and notations
Clarity
Maybe a little bit too much notations used on part b but still c orrect overall
Response Pros
Answers for both questions are correct and use proper proofs from the course
Proof and analysis for both questions are correct with prope r runtime analysis and
notations
Cons
27There might be a bit too much notation used in part b but its s till correct overall
Prompt Matching indicator states in each topic
For the reasons in rubric point AnswerAlgorithm Correc tness does the student have the
same reason as R2 If they both mention that reason or both do not mention this reason
they have the same reason If R2 mentions but the student does not mention they have
different reasons Separate each reason point with a line For each reason point start with
reasoning first then conclude your answer with Y for same or N for different Your output
format should be the following
1 Correct and Clear Presentation of Answers some reasonin g Y or N
2 Incorrect Answers or Misinterpretation of Questions so me reasoning Y or N
Response 1 Correct and Clear Presentation of Answers Both R2 and the student mention
that the answers are correct and clearly presented Y
2 Incorrect Answers or Misinterpretation of Questions R2 does not mention any incorrect
answers or misinterpretation of questions and neither doe s the student Y
Prompt for other topic
B2 Prompts in Direct GPT Query
When directly querying GPT we first provide the peer review then the instructor review and
finally a scoring rubric
Prompt Your task is to compare a students review of a homework submi ssion to the instructors
review of the same homework submission Here is the student s review
Answer The answer is not provided
Argument The answer is not provided
Clarity You wrote Note that for any b b Prmax jnotIbj bPrmax jnotIbj b
and I do not understand why this is true I dont know if y ou meant Note that IF
That part is very confusing Everything else is clear enough
Here is the instructors review
Answer See Argument
Argument Proof is incomplete Parts of the proof that are gi ven are not clearly correct
Clarity You should state that your proof is incomplete at th e beginning
Your output should be a score for the students review The ra nge of score is 0 to 10 The
rubric for scoring is
0 for a totally wrong or meaningless review
2 for a wrong review but you see the student made some effort in w riting the review
284 for mostly wrong but some points are correct
6 for mostly correct but some points are wrong
8 for almost the same as the instructors review
10 for an extraodinarily good review even better than the in structors
Start with reasoning first then conclude your response with a single line of a score between
0 and 10
29JOURNAL OF L ATEX CLASS FILES VOL 14 NO 8 AUGUST 2021 1
A Survey on Large Language Models from General