instruction
stringlengths
147
1.1k
output
stringclasses
2 values
generator
stringclasses
3 values
<question> A passenger was boarding a train at a high-level platform and misjudged the gap, causing their leg to enter the space between the train and the platform. The passenger sustained a minor injury and required first aid. Is this injury reportable, and if so, how should it be coded on Form FRA F 6180.55a? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the purpose of the "N/A" entry option on Form FRA F 6180.55, and how does it impact the accuracy of the reported data? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What specific codes and information should be entered in Block 5j (Physical Act), Block 5k (Location), and Block 5l (Event) for a passenger who was injured while stepping down from a standing passenger car at a passenger terminal due to slipping on the platform gap? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do the specific requirements for Group I and II accidents/incidents ensure comprehensive reporting and improve railroad safety? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What constitutes 'personal grooming' for the purpose of the reporting exception under § 225.15? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What specific codes should I use for an injury that occurred when a passenger was stepping down from a passenger car at a high-level platform, and slipped due to the platform gap? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If an accident involves both a derailment and a collision, which type of accident should be reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do I determine if an employee's hearing loss is work-related and must be reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> An employee slipped and fell on ice in the company parking lot while walking to the office to report for work, sustaining a back injury that resulted in multiple days away from work. The company believes the injury is non-work-related because the employee had not yet clocked in. Is this injury reportable to the FRA? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a passenger railroad contracts with a freight railroad to operate its trains, and a freight railroad employee is injured while performing these duties, who is responsible for reporting the injury to the FRA? How should the hours worked by the freight railroad employees be reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What constitutes an 'activation failure' in the context of grade crossing signal systems, as mentioned in 49 CFR 234.7? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In the context of Form FRA F 6180.56, what is the significance of the term 'casualty,' and how does it differ from other classifications of incidents or injuries? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> Under what circumstances is it mandatory to complete and attach Form FRA F 6180.81 (Employee Human Factor Attachment) to the Rail Equipment Accident/Incident Report? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What specific protocols or guidelines must railroads follow when reporting accidents/incidents to the FRA via telephone, and how do these protocols ensure the accuracy and completeness of the information provided? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> In cases of joint operation, what specific criteria or guidelines are used to identify the responsible railroad for reporting casualties, and how does this impact the overall safety and accountability of railroad operations? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a highway-rail grade crossing impact occurs, and the railroad responsible for the on-track equipment is different from the railroad responsible for the track maintenance, which railroad is responsible for reporting the crossing impact to FRA? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the classification of employees (railroad vs. contract) impact the railroad's reporting obligations under Part 225 when operations are contracted out? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How does the FRA guide clarify the determination of work-relatedness in cases of acts of violence, especially regarding the boundaries of the employer's premises and establishment? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How should a railroad handle a late or amended Form FRA F 6180.55 submission? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How should a passenger railroad report injuries to contractors performing safety-sensitive functions versus those performing non-safety-sensitive functions? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a rail equipment accident occurred in December 2023 and the damage exceeded the reporting threshold, which forms need to be completed and submitted, and by what deadlines? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A rail equipment accident occurred in December 2010, and the initial estimate of damages was $9,000. However, after a detailed assessment, the final cost of repairs was determined to be $8,500. Do we still need to report this accident on Form FRA F 6180.54, or can we withdraw the report? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Are injuries or illnesses that occur in the company parking lot or on the company's sidewalks before or after work hours considered work-related? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In a scenario where a train consist is involved in a collision while switching within a yard, what classification should be used for the accident report, and what additional information should be included to ensure a comprehensive understanding of the incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a rail equipment accident resulted in damages totaling $9,000, which forms must be completed and submitted to the FRA, and by what deadline? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What constitutes 'rail equipment accidents/incidents' that are not reportable under § 225.15(e)? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What specific changes did FRA implement to enhance the quality of information available for railroad casualty analysis, and how do these changes affect the reporting of highway-rail grade crossing casualties and trespasser incidents? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the significance of the "Type of Equipment Consist" codes, and how do they contribute to the overall safety assessment of an incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How might the use of alternative record formats impact the consistency and accuracy of accident/incident reporting across different railroads, and what measures could be implemented to ensure standardization? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How do the Special Case Codes affect the reporting of nonfatal cases, and what are the potential risks to railroad safety if these codes are misinterpreted or misused? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What about highway-rail grade crossing accidents? Would these events qualify for the Initial Rail Equipment Accident/Incident Record? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
Yes
human
<question> In the context of railroad safety, what is the purpose of the "U.S. DOT Grade Crossing Identification Number," and how does it facilitate a coordinated response to incidents at grade crossings? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How does the FRA's guide ensure consistent reporting of accidents/incidents, especially when multiple forms are required? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What is the definition of 'railroad employee' for the purpose of Form FRA F 6180.56, and how does it affect the inclusion of hours worked and casualties reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How can railroad companies ensure the safety of pedestrians at highway-rail grade crossings, given the potential for obstruction accidents? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a highway user is injured in a highway-rail grade crossing accident and the railroad cannot contact the injured party, what steps must the railroad take to fulfill its reporting responsibilities? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In what ways can the reporting of accountable injuries or illnesses be used to identify and address underlying safety issues or trends within a railroad organization? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> Can you explain the significance of the grade crossing identification number and how it aids in railroad safety and incident management? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> In a joint operation scenario, where an employee from Railroad A was injured while working on Railroad B's property, who is responsible for reporting the injury to the FRA? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> An employee was on duty and participating in a company-organized fitness class when he experienced chest pain. He was taken to a hospital and diagnosed with a non-work-related heart condition. Is this injury reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the potential consequences for railroads that fail to submit late reports, and how might this impact safety regulations and investigations? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> When one railroad's equipment is operated by a different railroad's crew, how does the reporting process change, and why is this important for safety regulations? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If an employee is injured while bending down to pick up a tool at work, is the injury considered work-related and reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In a joint operation scenario, if a fatality occurs and the deceased is not an employee of any of the railroads involved, which railroad is responsible for reporting the fatality to the FRA on Form FRA F 6180.55a? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A commuter rail operator contracts with a private company to perform maintenance on its rolling stock. During a routine inspection, an employee of the private company is injured while working on the train. Is this injury reportable, and if so, which form should be used to report it? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the Employee Human Factor Attachment (FRA F 6180.81) contribute to the investigation and prevention of rail equipment accidents/incidents? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> In a scenario where an accident occurs in a major terminal with no applicable subdivision, how should the report be completed, and what implications does this have for understanding the incident and assigning responsibility? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If an employee injures their knee while walking down a hallway at work, is this injury considered work-related? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the FRA guide's standardized reporting system accommodate the challenges of documenting incidents involving various train types and operational methods, and what potential benefits does this have for railroad safety and incident analysis? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How does the voluntary nature of the highway user's response to the cover letter and Form FRA F 6180.150 impact railroad safety and compliance with Part 225's accident/incident reporting requirements? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a train derailment occurs on a section of track that is jointly operated by two railroads, which railroad is responsible for reporting the incident and how should the costs be allocated between the two railroads for the purposes of the report? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What factors determine which railroad is responsible for reporting casualties to non-railroad employees involved in an accident/incident, and how does this impact the overall safety reporting process? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How does the FRA's review process impact the accuracy and fairness of reporting, especially in cases where facts are disputed? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> In the context of joint operations, what is the legal definition of "directly involved" when determining which railroads must report an accident/incident on Form FRA F 6180.54, and how does this terminology impact the safety reporting process? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How does the FRA guide ensure that critical safety information, such as the absence of warning devices or proper crossing illumination, is accurately captured and reported, and what potential consequences could arise from inaccurate reporting? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What is the difference between 'direct labor costs' and 'loaded rate' when calculating damage costs for equipment and track repairs? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do I determine and report the number of locomotives and cars derailed in an accident, and what specific information should be included if the consist includes articulated cars? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In the context of FRA reporting, when are employees considered part of the general public? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What does 'voluntary participation in a wellness program or in a medical, fitness, or recreational activity' in the context of reporting exceptions include? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How long must a modification to a job last before it can be considered a permanent modification? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
Yes
human
<question> If a pedestrian is struck by a train at a highway-rail grade crossing and is transported to a medical facility via ambulance, but the pedestrian was not injured and only received a medical examination as a precaution, is this case reportable on Form FRA F 6180.55a? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the definition of 'hours worked' for the purpose of Form FRA F 6180.56? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a highway user involved in a highway-rail grade crossing accident/incident refuses to provide information about their injuries, is the railroad still required to report the injury as reportable if the user was transported to a medical facility via ambulance? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the time limit for a railroad to re-evaluate a claimed occupational illness after receiving additional information? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a rail equipment accident results in damages totaling $9,000 and involves two different railroads, each with $4,500 in damages, does this accident need to be reported to the FRA? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a passenger train collides with another train on the main line, resulting in damages exceeding $150,000, and some passengers are evacuated, is this incident reportable immediately to the National Response Center (NRC)? If so, what information must be included in the report? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a highway user is transported to a medical facility after a highway-rail grade crossing accident, is the injury presumed to be reportable? How should the railroad proceed to determine the nature and severity of the injury? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the deadline for an employee to submit a Supplement to the FRA, and what are the penalties for submitting a willfully false Supplement? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a passenger train operates a 150-mile route and carries 300 passengers, how many passenger-miles and passenger train-miles should be reported in Items 12 and 16, respectively? Additionally, how many passengers should be reported in Item 17? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What distinguishes a 'closed crossing' from a 'temporary barricaded crossing'? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What should I do if I notice a math error in the total number of casualties reported on Form FRA F 6180.55a after the report has been submitted? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How should I report and code an incident where a non-employee, such as a passenger, was injured, and the train crew was tested for alcohol or drug use, but there were no positive results? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Is an injury sustained by an employee after they have 'timed out' but are still on the railroad premises (e.g., locking up personal items) considered work-related and reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A contractor's crew was hired to repair a section of track damaged in a derailment. The contractor provided the labor and materials, and the railroad reimbursed the contractor for the costs. When calculating the direct labor costs for the damage report, should the railroad use the contractor’s hourly wage rate for the workers or the loaded rate, which includes labor, fringe benefits, and other costs and fees? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the purpose of Form FRA F 6180.150, and how does it contribute to railroad safety and accident investigation? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a joint operation is involved in an accident, how do we determine which railroad is responsible for reporting the casualties and the accident/incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Which forms are required to be submitted monthly to the FRA for reporting railroad injuries and illnesses? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A train derailment occurred, and it was determined that a mechanical failure on the second car of the consist caused the accident. How should the 'Principal Car/Unit' section (Item 31) of Form FRA F 6180.54 be completed for this incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Do all needlestick or sharps injuries, regardless of the severity or outcome, need to be reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Does a small industrial railroad that operates exclusively within a private facility and has no public crossings, bridges over public roads, or common corridors with other railroads need to comply with the internal control plan requirements of § 225.33? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In cases of joint operations, what specific challenges might arise in identifying and notifying implicated employees across different railroads, and how can these be effectively managed to ensure compliance with regulations? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a train was standing still at the time of the accident/incident, how should the 'Consist Speed' in Item 30 be reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Is a fire in a boxcar caused by a short circuit in the car's electrical system, which results in significant damage, considered a 'fire or violent rupture' and therefore reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the correct classification for an incident where a control cab locomotive collides with a DMU locomotive during a train makeup operation? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What are the reporting responsibilities of a railroad whose involvement in a highway-rail grade crossing accident is limited to track maintenance? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a highway user was involved in a hit-and-run accident at a grade crossing and the age and gender are unknown, how should this be reported on Form FRA F 6180.54? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If an employee reports a minor injury that did not require medical treatment beyond first aid, is the railroad required to record this injury on Form FRA F 6180.98 or an alternative railroad-designed record, even though it is not reportable to FRA? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a passenger railroad contracts out its train operations to a freight railroad, who is responsible for reporting accidents and incidents to the FRA, and under whose name and code/identifier should the reports be filed? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a hazardous material car releases fumes but no liquid or solid material, is it still considered a release and must it be reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the key differences between the Railroad Employee Injury and/or Illness Record (Form FRA F 6180.98) and an alternative railroad-designed record, and why are these options provided? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How do I correctly report passenger-miles and the number of passengers transported to ensure consistency in the data? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What does the code "E" in Item 17 represent, and how does it impact the understanding of the rail consist's movement at the time of the impact? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How do I determine the latitude and longitude for a reportable incident, and what format should I use for these coordinates on Form FRA F 6180.54? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the immediate reporting requirements for train accidents involving passenger service main lines? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the definition of an 'establishment' in the context of posting reportable injuries and illnesses? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What steps should a railroad take to ensure compliance with the requirement to submit late reports for improperly omitted or reported accident/incident information, and what are the potential consequences of non-compliance? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a highway-rail grade crossing accident occurs and the warning devices were activated, but the warning time was less than 20 seconds due to the train operating counter to the track circuit design direction, which status code should be appended to the report? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If an accident results in the evacuation of a nearby community due to a potential hazardous material release, but it is later determined that no actual release occurred, should the number of people evacuated still be reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the narrative portion of the report contribute to accident prevention analysis, and what types of information should be included to enhance safety measures? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How do the reporting requirements for Volunteers (Classes H and I) differ, and what are the safety implications of these differences? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r