instruction
stringlengths
147
1.1k
output
stringclasses
2 values
generator
stringclasses
3 values
<question> In the scenario where an employee slips on ice in the company parking lot before clocking in, what factors determine whether this injury is considered work-related and reportable? How does this differ from an employee who slips on ice while on a personal break during assigned working hours? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the potential consequences for a railroad if they fail to file the required forms with the FRA, and how might this impact overall safety regulations and procedures? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> A railroad employee is involved in a slip and fall incident at a maintenance facility and is taken to a clinic for an evaluation. The doctor recommends that the employee take two days off to recover and prescribes a non-prescription pain reliever. Does this case meet the criteria for reporting on Form FRA F 6180.55a, and if so, which criteria are met? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In an incident where a train crewmember is found deceased in the cab of a locomotive, and the coroner determines the cause of death to be a suicide, what cause code should be entered on Form FRA F 6180.54, and how should the report reflect any contributing factors, such as alcohol or drug use? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Explain the concept of "consist responsibility" and its significance in accident reporting. </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a train is standing on the tracks and a vehicle collides with it, how should the 'Equipment' and 'Speed' fields be reported on Form FRA F 6180.55a? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do I determine if a rail equipment accident/incident is reportable based on the damage threshold? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the special case codes used to classify certain injuries and illnesses for FRA and/or OSHA purposes, and when should they be used? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the threshold for reporting a rail equipment accident or incident on Form FRA F 6180.54? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do I calculate and report the labor costs for repairing equipment damage in an accident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Can you explain the purpose of Form FRA F 6180.98 and its alternative record-keeping options for railroad employee injuries and illnesses? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> Does a small railroad that operates exclusively off the general system and has 10 employees need to comply with the Internal Control Plan requirements and the recordkeeping requirements for accountable injuries and illnesses? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a formal investigation is in progress, how should a railroad handle the submission of Form FRA F 6180.81? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How should railroad operators utilize the "Remarks" section to provide context for unusual fluctuations or contradictory data in their accident/incident reports? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> A train derailment on a section of track maintained by a different railroad. The derailment then causes a collision with another train on an adjacent track. How should the report be filed, and which railroad is responsible for reporting the incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the "personal tasks" exception impact the reportability of injuries sustained during breaks or personal activities? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What is the difference between fixed blocks and variable blocks in Direct Train Control systems? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A train derailment caused by a landslip results in damage to both the train and the track. A second train, operated by a different railroad, is also damaged as a result of this derailment. How should the second railroad report this incident, and what information must be exchanged between the two railroads? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> An employee was bending over to pick up a tool at work and felt a sharp pain in their back. The employee continued working but reported the incident to their supervisor the next day. There were no visible hazards or other contributing factors in the work environment. Is this injury considered work-related? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Is an injury that occurs while an employee is walking from their car to the office on company-owned property reportable as a work-related injury? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A train strikes a car that has stalled on the tracks at a location that is not a designated highway-rail grade crossing. How should this incident be classified and reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A highway user was involved in an accident at a grade crossing and was injured. The railroad has sent the Highway User Injury Inquiry Form (Form FRA F 6180.150) to the injured party. If the highway user does not return the completed form, is the railroad required to submit a report to the FRA without the additional information? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What should I do if I discover a math error or contradictory information on my submitted Form FRA F 6180.55a, and how do I correct it? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the significance of the contributing cause code in the context of accident reporting, and how is it determined? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If an employee gets food poisoning from a meal provided by the railroad during a work event, is this injury reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A person was injured at a highway-rail grade crossing when they disregarded the flashing lights and warning bells and was struck by a train. Is this person classified as a trespasser or a nontrespasser, and what class should the injury be reported under? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a railroad has no reportable accidents or incidents during a reporting month, how should the railroad complete and submit Form FRA F 6180.55, 'Railroad Injury and Illness Summary'? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do I determine if an injury that occurs in the company parking lot or on the company's private sidewalks is work-related and reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What steps must a railroad take to ensure the consistency of information across different accident/incident report forms, and how should they handle contradictions? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a highway user involved in a highway-rail grade crossing accident refuses to provide information about their injuries, is the railroad still required to report the injury as reportable and how should the railroad proceed? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is meant by 'permanent or semi-permanent coupling' in the context of articulated cars? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How should I code an injury that occurred while a passenger was stepping down from a passenger car at a high-level boarding platform? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> When must a railroad report a train accident that results in the evacuation of a passenger train, and what information must be included in the report? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a train accident results in the derailment of both locomotives and cars, how do I report the number of derailed units on Form FRA F 6180.54? Specifically, if there were 3 locomotives and 10 cars in the consist, and all of them derailed, what should be entered in lines 2 of items 34 and 35? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In cases where an employee sustains an injury during a work-related activity, but the exact cause remains unclear, what specific steps should employers take to determine the work-relatedness of the injury, and how might this impact reporting and safety protocols? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a train strikes a pedestrian who was walking on a railroad trestle that is not designated as a highway-rail grade crossing, how should this incident be classified and reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How have FRA's regulations been amended to require the reporting and recording of suicide data, and what specific information must railroads now document regarding suicides? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What does 'discernable cause' mean in the context of work-related injuries or illnesses? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> With the addition of suicide data reporting, how can railroads ensure the ethical and responsible collection and analysis of this sensitive information, and what impact might this have on safety initiatives and overall railroad safety culture? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What is the significance of differentiating between various types of train-miles (freight, passenger, yard switching, other) in FRA reporting? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> A person was injured at a highway-rail grade crossing when they attempted to go around the lowered gates. Is this person classified as a trespasser or a nontrespasser, and what is the appropriate class for reporting this injury? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the key factors that determine whether a collision is classified as a "raking collision," and how does this classification affect the reporting process? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> In a scenario where a railroad's investigation identifies a primary cause code different from FRA/NTSB, how should the railroad proceed to ensure regulatory compliance and maintain safety standards? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a railroad company identifies a pattern of platform gap incidents at a specific station due to misalignment, what steps should they take to address the issue and improve safety? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> In a collision involving multiple trains, how does the FRA guide ensure the correct determination of the responsible railroad(s), and what measures are in place to prevent misattribution? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> Which injuries or illnesses are explicitly excluded from reporting requirements for railroad employees? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the requirements for submitting forms and reports to the FRA via optical media or electronic submission, and what are the consequences of non-compliance? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How should a passenger injury be reported if the driver of a vehicle involved in a collision with a train committed suicide? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A truck driver swerved to avoid a train at a grade crossing and collided with a car parked on the shoulder, causing the car to be pushed into the path of the train, which then struck the car. The truck driver sustained minor injuries, and the car occupants were unharmed. How should this incident be reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How should I classify and report an incident where a passenger's arm is caught in the door while alighting from a train at a high-level passenger boarding platform, but the arm does not enter the passenger station platform gap? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the potential consequences for railroads that fail to maintain proper records of employee injuries and illnesses, and how does this impact safety and compliance? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If an employee chooses to submit a Supplement to FRA, and it is later discovered that some of the information in the Supplement is false, what penalties can be imposed on the employee? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the concept of 'controlled access points' influence the reportability of incidents, and what are the potential safety implications for employees and facilities? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How do the investigation policies outlined in § 225.31 contribute to railroad safety and ensure accountability for incidents? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a railroad employee is found dead on the railroad tracks and the local coroner determines the cause of death to be suicide, is the railroad required to report this incident to the FRA? If so, on which form should this be reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do the cause codes and amended report regulations impact the railroad's ability to learn from accidents and improve safety procedures? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a Form FRA F 6180.54 is required for a rail equipment accident/incident, under what circumstances must a Form FRA F 6180.81 (Employee Human Factor Attachment) also be completed? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If an employee who was previously injured in a reportable incident commits suicide several months later, should the railroad report this to the FRA, and if so, how should it be reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do I calculate the reportable damage for a broken train collision where parts of the train collide with each other or with a structure? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a train accident involves multiple railroads, how should the information be reported on Form FRA F 6180.54? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What should I do if I realize I made a math error on a previously submitted Form FRA F 6180.55a? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How should the 'Consist Speed' be reported if the consist was not moving at the time of the accident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In the context of the Hours of Service Act's repeal, how do current railroad regulations address the management of employee working hours to prevent fatigue-related incidents, and what specific measures are in place to ensure compliance? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What are the implications of using vague cause codes like M599 for railroad safety and accident prevention efforts? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> In the scenario where an employee slipped and fell on ice in the company parking lot before clocking in, the company initially deemed the incident non-work-related. However, the company parking lot and sidewalks are privately owned and within the property line. Is this incident reportable as a work-related injury? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In a case where an accident report is excluded from the file, what steps should a railroad take to ensure compliance with FRA regulations and avoid penalties, and what are the potential consequences if these steps are not followed? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> A passenger train derailment occurred on a main line that is used for scheduled passenger service. The preliminary estimate of damage is $180,000. What are the immediate reporting requirements for this incident, and how should the railroad proceed with the initial and subsequent reports? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a train derails on a main track while traveling at a speed that is within the maximum speed limit for that track class, and there are no other reportable damages or injuries, do we still need to file an FRA Form F 6180.54? If so, what specific information must be included in the form regarding the track type, speed, and other relevant details? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How should a highway-rail grade crossing accident be reported if it involves a suicide by the highway vehicle driver, and there are also injuries to passengers on the train? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Explain the difference between "damaged/derailed" HAZMAT cars and those "releasing HAZMAT" and its impact on safety procedures. </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If an employee is conducting a pre-trip inspection of a locomotive and slips on a patch of ice on the ground, resulting in a sprained ankle, is the injury considered work-related and reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> An employee was injured while playing in a company-sponsored softball game after work hours. Is this injury reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A volunteer (Class H) was helping to inspect and repair tracks during a maintenance event. The volunteer was injured while performing these safety-sensitive functions. Is this injury reportable, and if so, how should it be reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the definition of "day of restricted work activity" impact the reporting of work-related injuries, and what potential challenges might railroads face in implementing this regulation? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> A freight train derailment caused significant damage to the tracks, signals, and nearby structures. The direct labor costs for the railroad to repair the damage are estimated to be $50,000. Additionally, a contractor was hired to assist with the cleanup and repairs. The contractor charged a total of $30,000 in labor hours, including fringe benefits and other costs. How should the labor costs be reported for the purposes of the FRA Form F 6180.54? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a highway-rail grade crossing accident occurs on a track maintained by Railroad A, but the train involved is operated by Railroad B, which railroad is responsible for completing and submitting Form FRA F 6180.57, and what information must Railroad A provide? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> An employee sprained their ankle while walking down a level, seamless hallway at work. There were no visible defects or hazards in the hallway. Is this injury considered work-related and reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is considered a 'preliminary gross estimate' of property damage for the purposes of reporting a train accident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do the specific reporting requirements for accidents and incidents contribute to overall railroad safety and incident investigation? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How should suicides and attempted suicides be reported in the casualty counts on Form FRA F 6180.57? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the classification of casualties as fatal or non-fatal impact the railroad's response and investigation procedures? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What are the requirements for a railroad to ensure that its policy against intimidation and retaliation is effectively communicated and enforced? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the FRA ensure accurate reporting of accident/incident data when multiple railroads are involved in an operation? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What is meant by 'establishment' in the context of posting injury and illness reports? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How should labor costs for contractors be calculated when estimating the damage costs for a rail equipment accident/incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A group of non-railroad employees were working on industrial tracks and accidentally derailed a few cars. No railroad employees were involved in the incident. The cost of repairing the damage exceeds the reporting threshold. Is this incident reportable to the FRA? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What specific information should be included in the Employee Human Factor Attachment (Form FRA F 6180.81) to ensure compliance with regulations and provide a comprehensive report of the accident/incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What are the federal standards for track classification, and how do they contribute to railroad safety and accident prevention? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What does 'RCL' stand for in the context of railroad equipment, and what is its significance? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the difference between 'right-of-way,' 'off the right-of-way,' and 'on on-track equipment' in the context of reporting the location of a casualty? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A track worker stumbled on a rotten tie near the right-of-way and rolled down the embankment. Two other railroad employees observed the event. The worker was taken to a local PLHCP. After the examination, the PLHCP declared the employee fit for full duty; no medical treatment was provided. The employee chose not to report to work the next day, and took a day "sick" leave as provided for under the collective bargaining agreement. The railroad completed the Form FRA F 6180.98–Railroad Employee Injury and/or Illness Record. However, since the employee did not report to work the next day, does this qualify as an FRA-reportable event? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
Yes
human
<question> A highway user was involved in a grade crossing accident and sustained injuries that required medical treatment beyond first aid. The railroad sent the Form FRA F 6180.150 and a cover letter to the highway user. The highway user did not respond. What are the railroad's responsibilities in this scenario to ensure compliance with FRA reporting requirements? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In what circumstances is a day away from work not charged, and how does this impact the overall reporting process? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a passenger misjudges the gap while boarding a train at a high-level platform and falls, but does not enter the gap between the train and the platform, and only sustains minor injuries treated with first aid, is this incident reportable on Form FRA F 6180.55a? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a railroad contracts with another company to provide track maintenance services, and an employee of the contractor is injured on the job, is the injury reportable by the railroad, or is it the responsibility of the contractor to report the injury to the FRA? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a highway user who was injured in a highway-rail grade crossing accident/incident refuses to provide information, is the railroad still required to report the injury, and if so, how should the railroad proceed with the reporting requirements? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What specific criteria determine whether an injury is classified as a "passenger station platform gap incident"? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a highway-rail grade crossing accident/incident occurs at a crossing that has not been assigned a U.S. DOT Grade Crossing Identification Number, what steps must be taken to obtain a valid number and properly complete Form FRA F 6180.57? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> During breaks and commuting, when does an employee transition from being considered part of the workforce to becoming a member of the general public, and how does this impact accident/incident reporting and safety regulations? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> Is an injury that occurs in the company parking lot or on the sidewalk leading to the office considered to be in the work environment and thus reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b