article
stringlengths 0
745k
| abstract
stringlengths 0
92.7k
|
|---|---|
the experimental evidence of the theoretically predicted skyrmions in non - centrosymmetric compounds with dzyloshinskii - moriya interaction has intrigued many scientists over the last years.@xcite recently , the preparation of thin films of b20 type mnsi on silicon substrates @xcite has offered promising prospects with regard to possible applications in future spintronic devices . on the one hand mnsi films
offer a variety of interesting magnetic phases and on the other hand they are easy to integrate into devices due to the use of silicon as substrate material being well established in technology .
the benefit of thin films compared to bulk material is the existence of the skyrmion phase in an extended region of the magnetic phase diagram due to the uniaxial anisotropy.@xcite this pioneers new opportunities for data storage devices .
the drawback using mnsi films is the low magnetic ordering temperature , which is considerably below liquid nitrogen temperature .
therefore , it is the aim to find compounds with similar spin order at higher temperatures .
a suitable candidate is the b20 compound mnge ( bulk lattice constant of 4.795 ) with a magnetic ordering temperature @xmath0 of 170k.@xcite the magnetic ground state of mnge is a helical spin structure with a helix length between 3 nm at lowest temperatures and 6 nm near @xmath0.@xcite the helix axis is due to magnetic anisotropy pinned along @xmath1001@xmath2,@xcite but rotates into field direction in an applied field .
recently , a large topological hall effect exceeding by 40 times that of mnsi was observed in mnge which was attributed to a skyrmion phase in analogy to mnsi.@xcite .
further evidence for the existence of skyrmions was given by small angle neutron scattering experiments.@xcite unfortunately , the synthesis of mnge is considerably laborious , since it forms only under high pressure and temperatures between 600 and 1000@xmath3c.@xcite however , molecular beam epitaxy ( mbe ) allows for thin film growth under strong non - equilibrium conditions .
nevertheless , there has been no successfull attempt to grow mnge on ge , since mn and ge tends to form mn@xmath4ge@xmath5.@xcite the use of si(111 ) as substrate offers the opportunity to prepare a seedlayer of mnsi , which realizes the b20 crystal structure for mnge growth .
the lattice constant of mnge within the ( 111 ) plane matches that of si with a misfit of only 2@xmath6 , thus , compressively strained mnge films may be grown on si(111 ) substrates . in this paper
we show a preparation method for mnge thin films on si substrates with the aid of a mnsi seedlayer .
the structure and morphology of the films have been investigated by reflection high - energy electron diffraction ( rheed ) , atomic force microscopy ( afm ) and x - ray diffraction ( xrd ) . to determine the physical properties of the samples magnetization and magnetoresistance measurements
have been performed .
for the growth of mnge thin films p - doped si(111 ) substrates were used , which possess a resistivity between 1 and 10 @xmath7 cm at room temperature . prior to film deposition the substrates
were heated to 1100@xmath3c under uhv conditions in order to remove the oxide layer and to achieve a clean and flat surface with 7@xmath87-reconstruction , which was verified by in - situ rheed investigations .
the depostion of mn and ge directly on the si(111 ) surface does not produce b20 mnge films but results in a mn@xmath4ge@xmath5 layer . in order to establish the b20 crystal structure
a 5mn layer was deposited onto the si surface and heated to 300@xmath3c subsequently .
this procedure provides for the formation of a thin mnsi seedlayer with a thickness of 10 . in a second step
, mnge is codeposited by simultanoeus evaporation of mn and ge from an effusion cell and an electron beam evaporator , respectively . during film growth with a rate of 0.15 /
s the substrate is held at a temperature of 250@xmath3c .
$ ] crystal direction and b ) line scans across the rheed streaks for the mnge film in comparison with the si substrate .
the scans were taken parallel to the shadow edge.,scaledwidth=35.0% ] the mnge films have been investigated by in - situ rheed in order to determine their structure and morphology .
the rheed pattern of a 135 mnge film observed along the @xmath9 $ ] direction of the si substrate indicates two - dimensional film growth [ fig .
[ fig : rheed](a ) ] .
the arrangement of the streaks is very similar to the pattern of mnsi thin films,@xcite and suggests that mnge sustains the b20 crystal structure provided by mnsi seedlayer .
the uniformity of the intensity of the detected streaks implies a flat surface of a size comparable to the area contributing to the rheed pattern of around 100 nm in diameter .
line scans across rheed patterns of a 135 mnge film [ fig .
[ fig : rheed](b ) ] compared to the si substrate reveal a nearly pseudomorphic growth of the mnge layer .
however , a small deviance of the mnge streaks from the corresponding si reflections indicates that the mnge lattice has at least partly relaxed from the compressive strain imposed by the substrate .
+ afm images of films with thicknesses of 45 , 90 and 135 give evidence that island growth of vollmer - weber type is the predominant growth mode [ fig .
[ fig : afm ] ] .
the thinnest film of 45 thickness [ fig .
[ fig : afm](a ) ] consists of islands with a typical diameter of 100 nm separated by valleys of similar size . with increasing film thickness
the islands are enlarged and gradually fill the space between them .
for the 135 film only very thin valleys of a few nm can be observed [ fig .
[ fig : afm](c ) ] , and the morphology has transformed into elongated islands with a length of up to 2@xmath10 m and a width of around 200 nm . $ ] and @xmath11 $ ] crystal directions .
inset : intensity plot along the @xmath12 $ ] direction.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] x - ray diffraction measurements were performed using synchrotron radiation with @xmath13 at the swiss - norwegian beamline bm1a of the esrf ( grenoble , france ) with the pilatus@snbl diffractometer . the investigation of the 135 film confirms the b20 crystal structure of the mnge . in fig .
[ fig : xray ] the ( 111 ) and ( 333 ) peaks of the si substrate and the mnge thin film are clearly resolved as single crystal peaks .
the inset shows an integrated diffraction pattern along the [ 111 ] direction . from the position of the mnge(111 )
peak the lattice parameter of the mnge film of ( 4.750 @xmath14 0.004) is obtained , which is 1% smaller than the value for bulk mnge due to compressive strain .
the magnetic characterization of the mnge films was carried out using a quantum design mpms-5s squid magnetometer . for films of different thickness
the temperature dependence of the magnetic susceptibility has been measured in the range from 5k to 300k in an applied magnetic field of 10mt [ fig .
[ fig : susceptibility ] ] .
below 40k the susceptibility slightly increases due to the mnsi seedlayer , that orders magnetically in this temperature range .
the measurements were normalized with respect to the saturation magnetization of the mnsi seedlayer , because this layer is the same for all three films .
the susceptibility of mnge films exhibits an ordering temperature of @xmath15k indicated by a broad peak .
regarding mnge bulk material , the susceptibility shows a qualitatively similar behavior with a lower @xmath16k.@xcite an enhancement of the ordering temperature has also been observed for mnsi thin films.@xcite in contrast to mnsi thin films , no thickness dependence of @xmath0 can be detected for films between 45 and 135 .
possibly , the spin - spin correlation length is shorter than the value for mnsi films ( 7 monolayers ) @xcite , i.e. the thickness dependence may occur for mnge when the films are thinner than investigated in this work .
both materials belong to the b20 compounds , which possess a helical spin structure , since their magnetic properties are governed by the interplay of ferromagnetic exchange and dzyaloshinskii - moriya interactions .
nevertheless , the susceptibility of mnge shows a behavior which is typical for antiferromagnetic order , whereas for mnsi an increase to a constant value of magnetization towards low temperature is observed .
the helix length in mnsi is very long ( 18 nm ) and , thus , the local magnetic structure is related to ferromagnetism .
a small field easily deforms the soft helix and induces a net magnetization . in the case of mnge
the helix is more rigid .
therefore , at low temperature no net magnetic moment is induced by a field as small as 10mt .
the helix wavelength is connected to the dzyaloshinskii constant @xmath17 via @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the magnetic stiffness.@xcite since the helix in mnge is extremely short ( @xmath20nm)@xcite the dzyaloshinskii constant is expected to be large , and the magnetic structure is very close to an antiferromagnet .
field dependent magnetization measurements at @xmath21k were carried out on the same three samples as in fig .
[ fig : susceptibility ] .
for all samples the magnetization increases in fields up to 1 t [ fig .
[ fig : magnetization ] ] .
the inset of fig .
[ fig : magnetization ] shows a magnetization measurement on the 135 film in fields up to 5 t , which reveals that saturation is reached around 1 t .
this is in agreement with measurements performed on bulk mnge at temperatures close to @xmath0.@xcite since the helix length is much shorter than the size of the mnge islands , the magnetization behavior is not expected to be different from the bulk .
the magnetic moment per mn atom was calculated assuming that the complete amount of mn deposited during growth has reacted to mnge . however , since the magnetic moment is only half of the bulk value , some part of the deposited mn did not form mnge .
furthermore , we observe an apparently larger magnetic moment for thicker films .
this can be explained by the fact that especially in the beginning of mnge growth not every mn atom is incorporated into the mnge crystal .
evidence for this is also given by magnetization measurements at 5k , where mainly the ordering of the mnsi seedlayer is observed , since mnge only gives a linear contribution in the considered field range .
we observe a moment of the mnsi layer that is about twice as large as expected for 10 mnsi .
thereby , we conclude that some part of the deposited mn has reacted with si from the substrate to form mnsi . +
resistivity measurements were performed on the 135 film using the van - der - pauw method .
the sample was found to be metallic , and the residual resistivity at 3k was determined as 83 @xmath22 cm .
the field dependence of the resistivity was measured in magnetic fields up to 5 t for several temperatures . in fig .
[ fig : mr ] three curves are depicted , which represent the magnetoresistivity defined by @xmath23 .
the data were obtained at temperatures between 60k and 100k , where the sample is in a magnetically ordered state .
the mr effect is negative for all temperatures and fields and exhibits no remarkable features in the investigated field range . for comparison
the equivalent data for a 19 nm film mnsi is shown in the inset of fig .
[ fig : mr ] . in the case of mnsi
the critical magnetic field , where the spins align ferromagnetically , occurs around 1 t . at this field
a clear kink accompanied by a change in curvature is observed .
furthermore the size of the mr effect is considerably larger for mnsi .
regarding mnge the absence of magnetic phase transitions in moderate magnetic fields and the smallness of the magnetoresistivity evidences that the helical structure is more rigid than in mnsi . as discussed in the previous paragraph
this can be ascribed to a stronger dzyaloshinskii - moriya interaction .
in this work we have proved that we succeeded in growing crystalline mnge as a thin film on a si(111 ) substrate .
the film adopts the b20 structure from a thin seedlayer of mnsi prepared prior to mnge growth .
morphological investigations using rheed and afm give evidence that the mnge thin films consist of islands with a flat surface , which enlarge during growth .
the b20 structure was confirmed by xrd and the lattice parameter was determined to be 1% smaller than in bulk mnge due to compressive strain imposed by the si substrate .
+ although the magnetic properties of mnge thin films are found to be qualitatively similar to bulk , the ordering temperature is enhanced to 200k . in magnetoresistivity measurements no critical fields
were observed up to 5 t .
compared to mnsi , the helix in mnge is shorter and more rigid than in mnsi .
therefore , the magnetic structure is related to antiferromagnetism rather than to ferromagnetism .
we would like to thank dmitry chernyshov for his support with the x - ray measurements at the european synchrotron radiation facility .
the afm measurements were performed at the institute of semiconductor technology in braunschweig . we thank alexander wagner for his help with the equipment .
99 s. mhlbauer , b. binz , f. jonietz , c. pfleiderer , a. rosch , a. neubauer , r. georgii , and p. bni , science * 323 * , 915 ( 2009 ) .
a. neubauer , c. pfleiderer , b. binz , a. rosch , r. ritz , p. g. niklowitz , and p. bni , phys .
* 102 * , 186602 ( 2009 ) .
u. k. rler , a. n. bogdanov , and c. pfleiderer , nature * 442 * , 797 ( 2006 ) .
j. engelke , t. reimann , l. hoffmann , s. gass , d. menzel , and s. sllow , j. phys .
. jpn . * 81 * , 124709(2012 ) .
e. a. karhu , u. k. rler , a. n. bogdanov , s. kahwaji , b. j. kirby , h. fritzsche , m. d. robertson , c. f. majkrzak , and t. l. monchesky , phys .
b * 85 * , 094429 ( 2012 ) .
m. n. wilson , e. a. karhu , a. s. quingley , u. k. rler , a. b. butenko , a. n. bogdanov , m. d. robertson , and t. l. monchesky , phys .
b * 86 * , 144420 ( 2012 ) .
a. b. butenko , a. a. leonov , u. k. rler , and a. n. bogdanov , phys . rev .
b * 82 * , 052403 ( 2010 ) .
y. li , n. kanazawa , x. z. yu , a. tsukazaki , m. kawasaki , m. ichikawa , x. f. jin , f. kagawa , and y. tokura , phys .
* 110 * , 117202 ( 2013 ) .
h. takizawa , t. sato , t. endo , and m. shimada , j. solid state chem . * 73 * , 40 ( 1988 ) . n. kanazawa , y. onose , t. arima , d. okuyama , k. ohoyama , s. wakimoto , k. kakurai , s. ishiwata , and y. tokura , phys .
lett . * 106 * , 156603 ( 2011 ) .
o. l. makarova , a. v. tsvyashchenko , g. andre , f. porcher , l. n. fomicheva , n. rey , and i. mirebeau , phys . rev .
b. * 85 * , 205205 ( 2012 ) . n. kanazawa , j .- h .
kim , d. s. inosov , j. s. white , n. egetenmeyer , j. l. gavilano , s. ishiwata , y. onose , t. arima , b. keimer , and y. tokura , phys .
b * 86 * , 134425 ( 2012 ) . s. olive - mendez , a. spiesser , l. a. michez , v. le thanh , a. glachant , j. derrien , t. devillers , a. barski , and m. jamet , thin solid films * 517 * , 191 ( 2008 ) .
r. gunnella , l. morresi , n. pinto , r. murri , l. ottaviano , m. passacantando , f. dorazio , and f. lucari , surf .
sci . * 577 * , 22 ( 2005 ) .
e. karhu , s. kahwaji , and t. l. monchesky , phys . rev .
b * 82 * , 184417 ( 2010 ) . | mnge has been grown as a thin film on si(111 ) substrates by molecular beam epitaxy .
a 10 layer of mnsi was used as seedlayer in order to establish the b20 crystal structure .
films of a thickness between 45 and 135 have been prepared and structually characterized by rheed , afm and xrd .
these techniques give evidence that mnge forms in the cubic b20 crystal structure as islands exhibiting a very smooth surface .
the islands become larger with increasing film thickness .
a magnetic characterization reveals that the ordering temperature of mnge thin films is enhanced compared to bulk material .
the properties of the helical magnetic structure obtained from magnetization and magnetoresistivity measurements are compared with films of the related compound mnsi . the much larger dzyaloshinskii - moriya interaction in mnge results in a higher rigidness of the spin helix . |
piecewise isometries have rich dynamical phenomena and they sometimes produce fractal - like pictures . to define these maps ,
let @xmath5 be a subset of @xmath6 with a finite partition @xmath7 .
a piecewise isometry @xmath8 is a map such that the restriction of @xmath9 to each @xmath10 is a euclidean isometry .
the map is not defined on the boundaries @xmath11 for @xmath12 . in this paper
, we introduce a one - parameter family of piecewise isometries called the _
tetrahedral twists_. the intuitive definition is the following : let @xmath13 be the surface of a regular tetrahedron of side length 1 .
pick one pair of the opposite edges of @xmath13 and cut them open , then @xmath13 becomes a cylinder intrinsically .
rotate the cylinder by amount @xmath1 counterclockwise .
glue the opposite edges so that @xmath13 becomes the surface of a tetrahedron again .
apply this procedure on the other two pairs of opposite edges of @xmath13 .
the entire process defines a piecewise isometry on @xmath13 which is called the tetrahedral twist .
a polytope exchange transformation ( pet ) is a piecewise isometry @xmath8 on a polytope @xmath5 with two conditions : 1 .
the restriction on each @xmath14 is a translation .
the image @xmath15 has the full area in @xmath5 .
the tetrahedral twist maps are not piecewise translations .
however , there exist double covers @xmath16 of @xmath13 such that the liftings of the tetrahedral twists produce pets which we call the tetrahedral pets .
we will discuss this construction in section 2.1 .
let @xmath17 be a subset of @xmath5 . given a map @xmath18 , the _ first return _
@xmath19 is a map assigns every point @xmath20 to the first point in the forward orbit of @xmath21 lies in @xmath17 under @xmath22 , i.e. @xmath23 a _ renormalization _ of a pet @xmath8 is the choice of a subset @xmath17 of x such that the first return map @xmath24 is also a pet .
the existence of renormalization scheme in a dynamical system allows us to study the acceleration of the orbits .
if a renormalization scheme exists , we say that the system is _
renormalizable_. the family of tetrahedral pets is renormalizable in the parameter space @xmath2 . out main goal is to show the following theorem : the family of tetrahedral pets has a renormalization scheme when the input parameter lies in the subintervals @xmath25 and @xmath26 $ ] .
the subinterval @xmath27 of @xmath2 is a neighborhood of the irrational number @xmath28 .
the interval exchange transformations ( iets ) are the examples of piecewise isometries in dimension 1 , see @xcite , @xcite for surveys .
the paper @xcite introduces rectangle exchanges which are the products of iets .
another important class of piecewise isometries is piecewise rotation on polygons , which is studied in papers such as @xcite , @xcite .
we know that piecewise rotations are closely related to the study of pets in the following sense : let @xmath29 be a polygon together with a finite partition @xmath30 . if the piecewise rotation map @xmath9 performs a translation or rotation by a rational multiple of @xmath31 restricted on each element of @xmath30 , then there is a pet @xmath32 conjugate to @xmath9 by a covering map @xmath33 . the outer billiard maps on a convex polygon @xmath34 also give rise to piecewise isometries , see @xcite for reference .
the square of the outer billiards map is a piecewise translation outside @xmath34 . in the paper @xcite ,
@xcite , a higher dimensional pet is constructed from the compactification of the outer billiard outside a kite . for work concerning renormalization of piecewise isometries
, the rauzy induction @xcite introduces a renormalization theory for iets . in the paper @xcite , a general theory of renormalization of piecewise rotations is developed .
the paper @xcite shows that the renormalization scheme exists for pets arising from the outer billiards on penrose kites .
the tetrahedral twists are very similar to the pets described in @xcite , @xcite by hooper . in @xcite ,
the map is defined on four copies of torus , which we denote by @xmath5 . for every point @xmath35 , the map performs a translation in either horizontal direction parametrized by @xmath36 or in the vertical direction parametrized by @xmath37 , respectively .
this is the first example of pets in 2-dimensional parameter space which is invariant under renormalization .
hooper describes the renormalization procedure in terms of the renormalization of the truchet tilings , see @xcite .
let @xmath38 be reflections about the points @xmath39 , @xmath40 and @xmath41 , respectively .
let @xmath42 be the group generated by @xmath38 . define the space @xmath43 .
a fundamental domain for the action of @xmath42 by reflection is the union of four equilateral triangles @xmath44 of side length 1 where @xmath45 has the vertices @xmath46 and @xmath47 is the reflection of @xmath45 by the line connecting the points @xmath48 and @xmath49 for @xmath50 . in fact , these four triangles are the faces of a regular tetrahedron
. for the action of @xmath42.,width=134 ] fix three parameters @xmath51 .
let @xmath52 , @xmath53 , @xmath54 be the unit vectors in the directions of cube roots of unity .
for each @xmath55 or @xmath56 , we define the map @xmath57 as follows : @xmath58 where @xmath59 and @xmath60 from top to bottom . ]
the maps @xmath61 are illustrated in figure @xmath56 . now , suppose @xmath62 for @xmath63 .
a family of tetrahedral twists @xmath64 is defined as @xmath65 let @xmath66 be the lattice generated by two vectors @xmath67 and @xmath68 and @xmath69 be the torus @xmath70 .
let @xmath71 be the projection given by @xmath72 and @xmath16 is a double cover of @xmath13 .
let @xmath73 be the reflection about the origin .
define @xmath74 for @xmath75 , so @xmath76 for each @xmath77 . for fixed parameters @xmath78 , the lifting @xmath79 of the map @xmath80
is given by the following equation : @xmath81 where @xmath82 , @xmath83 and @xmath60 ] on @xmath69 .
for each @xmath85 , @xmath69 is divided into halves by a line @xmath86 through the origin in direction @xmath87 . on one half of @xmath69 ,
the map @xmath79 translates every point @xmath88 by amount @xmath89 ( mod @xmath90 ) in direction @xmath87 . in the other half ,
every point is translated by the same amount but in the opposite direction @xmath91 .
therefore , @xmath79 is a pet , for each @xmath63 .
as mentioned in previous section , we set @xmath62 for all @xmath63 .
the composition @xmath92 is defined as @xmath93 for @xmath94 , the map @xmath95 is a pet .
we call @xmath95 a
_ tetrahedral pet_. more precisely , for every point @xmath96 , there is some translation vector @xmath97 such that @xmath98 where @xmath97 is in the form of @xmath99 for some @xmath100 .
fix @xmath101 .
the partition @xmath102 of @xmath69 associated to the tetrahedral pet @xmath95 is obtained by the following fact : suppose that @xmath103 and @xmath104 are pets and @xmath105 , @xmath106 are the partitions of @xmath107 determined by the maps @xmath108 and @xmath109 , respectively .
then , @xmath110 is a finer partition of @xmath5 determined by the pet @xmath111 where @xmath112 the following figures show an example of the tetrahedral pet @xmath95 when @xmath113 .
the figure on the left shows the partition @xmath102 determined by a tetrahedral pet @xmath95 .
the figure on the right shows the image of every element in @xmath102 under @xmath95 . to be clear ,
we assign a number to each element in the partition @xmath102 in the left figure whose image is the shape with the same number in the right figure . for @xmath113 ] let @xmath115 be a periodic point with period @xmath116 of the map @xmath95 . a periodic tile @xmath117 of @xmath95 is a maximal subset containing @xmath118 such that @xmath95 is entirely defined on @xmath117 and all points in @xmath117 have the same period as @xmath118 . for a given point @xmath119 , we provide a pseudo - code algorithm to produce a periodic tile @xmath117 containing @xmath118 of @xmath95 . 1
. let @xmath120 be a polygon in the partition @xmath102 such that @xmath121 .
2 . if @xmath122 , then let @xmath123 where @xmath124 is some element in the partition @xmath102 and @xmath125 .
set @xmath126 3 .
else , return @xmath127 . by construction , every periodic tile @xmath117 is convex since it is the intersection of convex polygons .
a periodic tiling @xmath128 is the union of all periodic tiles @xmath117 for all @xmath119 . for @xmath129,width=268 ] for @xmath130,width=268 ] define the renormalization map @xmath131 by the formula .
@xmath132 for any subset @xmath133 , we write @xmath134 as the first return map of @xmath95 on @xmath135 .
let @xmath101 and @xmath136 be the reflection about the line @xmath137 .
define @xmath138 as the semi - regular hexagon with vertices : @xmath139 @xmath140 figure 6 shows an example of @xmath141 for @xmath142 .
define the subsets @xmath143 of @xmath69 as follows : @xmath144 suppose @xmath145 $ ] and @xmath146 .
there exists a set @xmath147 such that @xmath148 where @xmath149 is a similarity with the scale factor @xmath150 .
let @xmath151 be the upper half plane in of @xmath152 and @xmath153 be the lower half .
define @xmath154 if @xmath155 , then @xmath95 is conjugate to @xmath156 by a piecewise translation map @xmath149 where @xmath157 the theorem above says that the periodic tiling of @xmath158 and @xmath156 are same up to the interchange of @xmath159 and @xmath160 . for any @xmath161
, there exists a set @xmath147 such that @xmath162 is conjugate to @xmath163 via a similarity @xmath149 with the scale @xmath164 .
a space @xmath5 has a mostly self - similar structure if there is a disjoint union @xmath165 such that each @xmath166 is self - similar .
let @xmath167 $ ] that is a fixed point under the renormalization map @xmath168 .
the periodic tiling @xmath128 is mostly self - similar .
the proofs will be provided in section 5 . on the left and @xmath169 on the right ] on the left and @xmath169 on the right , title="fig:",width=264 ] on the left and @xmath169 on the right , title="fig:",width=275 ] for @xmath170,title="fig:",width=288 ] for @xmath170,title="fig:",width=249 ]
in this section , we explore the properties of the renormalization map @xmath168 and its connection to continued fraction expansions . recall that @xmath131 is given by the formula : @xmath171 each fixed point @xmath172 of @xmath168 in @xmath173 is in the form of @xmath174 moreover , all fixed points @xmath172 have continued fractions expansion in the following form : @xmath175 let @xmath176 in @xmath2 .
there exists some integer @xmath177 such that @xmath178 .
we have @xmath179 write @xmath180 .
when we apply the square map @xmath181 , the denominators have the fact that @xmath182 .
thus , the @xmath183 drops to a value of @xmath184 or @xmath56 for some @xmath177 .
it means that @xmath185 must be @xmath186 or @xmath187 for some @xmath177 . for every @xmath188
, we can define a coding map @xmath189 as follows : @xmath190 let @xmath101 .
a coding sequence @xmath191 for @xmath172 is a sequence of finite or infinite length such that every element @xmath192 in the sequence is given by the formula @xmath193 for @xmath177 . if @xmath194 , then the sequence terminates at step at step @xmath195 . if @xmath196 , then the sequence terminates at step @xmath197 . by lemma 3.1
, the coding sequence for a rational number terminates after a finite number of steps . for example , the coding sequence of @xmath198 is @xmath199 now , we define @xmath200 as the set of all sequence @xmath201 of finite or infinite length satisfying the following condition : 1 .
@xmath202 can not appear consecutively in the sequence 2 . for a finite sequence @xmath203 , the last element @xmath204 .
let @xmath205 be a sequence in @xmath200 . 1 .
if @xmath205 is infinite , there is a unique @xmath1 determined via the formula @xmath206 moreover , the coding sequence of @xmath172 is @xmath207 .
if the sequence @xmath208 is finite of length @xmath209 and @xmath210 , then there is a unique @xmath1 determined by @xmath211 3 .
if @xmath212 is finite and @xmath213 , then there is a unique @xmath101 determined by the formula ( * ) but without @xmath214 .
let @xmath215 be a sequence of elements in @xmath200 and @xmath1 is determined by the formula ( * ) .
we want to show that @xmath172 has the coding sequence @xmath77 . 1 .
suppose the first element in the sequence @xmath216 is @xmath217 for @xmath218 .
write @xmath146 i.e. , @xmath219 by computation , we have @xmath220 2 .
suppose @xmath221 .
similarly , we set @xmath146 so that @xmath222 .
therefore , @xmath223 repeat this argument by substituting @xmath224 .
if there exists some element @xmath225 or @xmath226 in the sequence , then the sequence terminates at the length @xmath197 .
we obtain the desired statement .
let @xmath101 and @xmath227 be the coding sequence of @xmath172 .
a splitted expansion of @xmath172 is defined as follows : * @xmath228 , * @xmath229 for @xmath230 . *
if @xmath172 is rational and the coding sequence of @xmath172 has length @xmath231 , then the splitted expansion terminates at @xmath232 if @xmath233 or at @xmath234 if @xmath235 . for example , the splitted sequence for @xmath236 is @xmath237 here are several observations of the splitted expansion : * if @xmath172 is a fixed point by @xmath168 , then the splitted expansion is same as the continued fraction expansion of @xmath172 which is in the form of @xmath238 * the splitted expansion is shifted by 2 digits to the left under the renormalization map @xmath168 .
* to translate between the splitted expansion and the signed continued fraction expansion , we have to replace the fragment @xmath239 with @xmath240 .
+ for example , @xmath241 has the splitted fraction expansion @xmath242 and its signed continued fraction expansion is @xmath243 .
suppose @xmath172 has a splitted expansion @xmath244 of inifite length .
we set the @xmath197th convergent @xmath245 of @xmath172 as @xmath246 the recurrent formulas for @xmath247 and @xmath183 are same to the ones of the continued fraction expansion , i.e. * @xmath248 . * if @xmath249 , then we set @xmath250 and @xmath251 * if @xmath252 , then @xmath253
. we can set @xmath254 and @xmath255 .
then @xmath256 and @xmath257 are obtained by the same formula as above for all integer @xmath258 .
the theorem below says that the splitted expansion gives us a good approximation of irrationals .
let @xmath1 be irrational with infinite splitted expansion @xmath259 . if @xmath260 as @xmath261 , then @xmath262 .
the proof is same as theorem 11.4 in @xcite by passing to the signed continued fraction expansion of @xmath172 .
the motivation of this section is to construct convex polyhedra and reduce all the calculations to the polyhedra , which is very similar to schwartz s construction in @xcite .
recall that @xmath69 obtained by gluing the parallelogram with vertices @xmath263 we define @xmath264\}.\ ] ] as a fiber bundle over @xmath265 $ ] .
the fiber above @xmath172 is the parallelogram @xmath69 .
define the fiber bundle map @xmath266 as @xmath267 define @xmath268 as the set @xmath269 it is useful to split the fiber bundle @xmath270 as @xmath271 \cup \mathcal x[1/2 , 1].\ ] ] a maximal domain of @xmath273 is a maximal subset of @xmath273 such that the bundle map @xmath274 is entirely defined and continuous . for @xmath275 , every cross section of the union of maximal domains in @xmath273 at the plane @xmath276 is the partition of @xmath69 determined by the tetrahedral pet @xmath95 . by the assistant of computer , we know that @xmath273 is partitioned into 22 maximal domains . each maximal domain is a convex polyhedron which has rational vertices .
experimentally , we obtain the fact that every maximal domain in @xmath273 has vertices in the form of @xmath277 for @xmath278 and integers @xmath279 .
let @xmath281 be subsets of @xmath282 $ ] whose fiber over @xmath172 are the sets @xmath283 and @xmath141 , respectively .
define the reflection @xmath284 as @xmath285 let @xmath286 be the sets @xmath287 the set @xmath288 is defined similarly as @xmath268 , which is a fiber bundle over @xmath289 such that the fiber above @xmath290 is @xmath291 .
now , we consider the maximal domains in @xmath268 for @xmath292 .
let @xmath293 be a subinterval of @xmath294 $ ] .
let @xmath135 be any one of the six polyhedra in @xmath288 .
a maximal domain in @xmath288 is a maximal subset where the first return @xmath295 on @xmath135 is entirely defined and continuous .
$ ] at the plane @xmath296 for any subinterval @xmath297 $ ] , if the number of maximal domains in @xmath288 is finite , we can apply the calculation on the vertices of the maximal domains to show the conjugacy of the first return maps . however , the number of maximal domains is not always finite on each arbitrary subintervals of @xmath294 $ ] .
the next experimental result provides a classification of subintervals @xmath293 of @xmath298 $ ] such that the number of maximal domains in @xmath288 is finite .
let @xmath293 be a subinterval of @xmath299 .
if @xmath293 is in one of the following form of continued fraction expansion indexed by @xmath300 , then number of maximal domains in @xmath288 is fixed .
furthermore , none of the maximal domains vanishes in the interval @xmath293 .
1 . @xmath301$],@xmath302 2 . @xmath303 $ ] , @xmath304 3 . @xmath305 $ ] , @xmath306 odd , @xmath307 4 .
@xmath308$],@xmath309 even , @xmath310 5 .
@xmath311 $ ] , @xmath312 even , @xmath313 .
for convenience , we introduce some notation in this section .
define @xmath314 and the interval @xmath315 as follows : @xmath316 @xmath317 , \quad \bar a_{m , n}=[t_{m , n},t_{m , n-1}].\ ] ] then , we denote @xmath318 to be the union @xmath319 , \quad \bigcup_{n\geq 3 } a_{2,n } = [ \frac{12}{29},\frac{29}{70}],\ ] ] respectively .
similarly , denote @xmath320 as @xmath321 , \quad \bigcup_{n\geq 3 } \bar a_{2,n}= [ \frac{2}{5},\frac{5}{12}],\ ] ] respectively .
note that @xmath323 \quad \mbox{and } \quad \bar a_{2,3}=r(a_{2,3})=[\frac{7}{17},\frac{5}{12}].\ ] ] @xmath322 is partitioned into 176 maximal domains , each of which is a convex polytope .
figure 10 shows cross sections of the union maximal domains in @xmath324 $ ] at the plane @xmath325 . by calculation ,
the vertices of every maximal domain are in the form of @xmath326 where @xmath327 are end points of the interval @xmath293 and @xmath328 are integers . for each connected component @xmath329
, @xmath295 is a piecewise affine map . for each point @xmath330
, we have @xmath331 where @xmath100 .
if we vary the point @xmath332 in a neighborhood of @xmath332 , the integers @xmath333 do not change .
since @xmath322 is partitioned into finitely many maximal domains , @xmath295 is a piecewise affine map on @xmath135 .
a maximal domain @xmath34 in @xmath334 is a permanent maximal polyhedron if @xmath34 satisfies the following condition : * at least one vertex of @xmath34 has @xmath335-coordinate @xmath336 , * at least one vertex of @xmath34 has @xmath335-coordinate @xmath337 . a maximal domain @xmath34 in @xmath338 is called resident maximal polyhedron if @xmath34 satisfies the following condition : * at least one vertex of @xmath34 has @xmath335-coordinate @xmath336 , * at least one vertex of @xmath34 has @xmath335-coordinate @xmath339 , * all the vertices @xmath340 of @xmath34 has @xmath341 .
it s equivalent to say that if a maximal domain @xmath34 in @xmath342 does not vanish between the plane @xmath343 and @xmath344 , then @xmath34 is a permanent polyhederon .
note that @xmath345 are two end points of the interval @xmath346 .
moreover , if a maximal domain @xmath347 lies between the plane @xmath343 and @xmath348 and the intersection of @xmath34 with each plane is non - empty , then @xmath34 is a resident maximal polyhedron in @xmath349 .
these notations help us to classify the maximal domains restricting to the smaller intervals @xmath350 .
if a maximal domain @xmath351 is obtained by chopping from a resident maximal domain @xmath352 in @xmath353 , we say @xmath34 is a primary maximal domain in @xmath322 .
more precisely , @xmath34 is primary if @xmath354 for some resident maximal domain @xmath352 in @xmath355 .
in @xmath322 , there are 176 maximal domains , where 150 are primary .
let @xmath356 be the set of resident maximal polyhedra in @xmath349 and @xmath357 be the set of primary maximal domains in @xmath322 .
denote @xmath358 to be the set of rest 26 maximal polyhedra in @xmath338 which also produce maximal domains in @xmath322 .
these are the polyhedra lying strictly above the plane @xmath343 .
we list them in the last section of the paper .
before going to the proof , we provide the explicit formula of the similarity @xmath149 which appeared in the renormalization theorem 2.1 .
@xmath359 where the scalar @xmath150 .
then , we can define the set @xmath360 in theorem 2.1 as @xmath361 and @xmath362 be the fiber bundle over @xmath293 such that the fiber above @xmath363 $ ] is @xmath360 .
a maximal domain in @xmath362 is defined in the same way as the maximal in @xmath288 . moreover ,
a maximal domain @xmath352 in @xmath364 is a permanent maximal polyhedron if @xmath352 satisfies the following properties : * @xmath352 has at least one vertex with @xmath335-coordinate @xmath365 , * @xmath352 has at least one vertex with @xmath335-coordinate @xmath339 .
we say @xmath352 a resident maximal polyhedron in @xmath366 , if * @xmath352 has at least one vertex with @xmath335-coordinate @xmath365 * @xmath352 has at least one vertex with @xmath335-coordinate @xmath367 .
* the @xmath335-coordinates of all vertices of @xmath352 should satisfy @xmath368 .
let @xmath369 be the collection of resident maximal polyhedron in @xmath370 . by direct computation , there are 162 maximal domains in @xmath371 , 136 of which are chopped from resident maximal domains in @xmath372 .
let us denote the set of primary maximal domains by @xmath373 .
moreover , there are @xmath374 maximal polyhedra in @xmath364 from which the non - primary maximal domains in @xmath371 can be obtained .
denote the set of these 26 non - resident maximal polyhedra in @xmath375 by @xmath376 .
the goal in this section is to show that for all @xmath378 , @xmath379 and @xmath380 are conjugate by the similarity map @xmath381 .
to prove this , we ve attached 1-dimensional parameter space to the planar torus @xmath69 and want to apply the calculation in @xmath382 . for calculation
, we always refer to open polyhedra .
first , we piece together the similarities @xmath381 on @xmath69 to construct a piecewise affine map @xmath383 on the fiber bundle which is defined as @xmath384 fix a parameter @xmath385 $ ] .
let @xmath146 .
the first return map @xmath163 satisfies @xmath386 _ step 1 . _ for every non - resident maximal polyhedron @xmath387 , @xmath388 in @xmath356 , we check that @xmath387 satisfies the following properties : 1
. there exists a non - resident maximal domain @xmath389 in @xmath376 such that @xmath390 it follows that there is a one - to - one correspondence between the elements in @xmath358 and the ones in @xmath376 . for computation , it is sufficient to check that the set of vertices of @xmath389 are @xmath391 where @xmath392 are the vertices of @xmath387 .
2 . let @xmath135 be a polyhedra in @xmath393 such that @xmath394 , then @xmath395 .
moreover , the maximal domains satisfy the following condition : @xmath396 3 .
we denote the polyhedra @xmath397 by @xmath398 if @xmath387 satisfies the inclusion above .
we check the fact : @xmath399 4 .
@xmath400 _ step 2 .
_ next , we consider the points in resident maximal polyhedra .
we apply the calculation on the set of resident maximal polyhedra because if the conjugacy is satisfied , then it follows that the renormalization scheme exists for all points in @xmath360 when @xmath378 .
since there is no one - to - one correspondence between the resident maximal domains in @xmath356 and the ones in @xmath369 , we can not apply the same calculation as before .
however , by computer assistance , we find that each element in @xmath356 is a subpolyhedron of a resident maximal polyhedron in @xmath376 up to a similarity .
we apply the similar calculations as in step 1 and check the following properties : 1 . for every resident maximal polyhedron @xmath401 in @xmath402
, there exists a resident maximal polyhedron @xmath403 such that @xmath404 for some @xmath405 .
2 . let @xmath135 be the connected component of @xmath349 such that @xmath394 .
denote @xmath406 as the polyhedron @xmath407 @xmath406 satisfies that @xmath408 3 .
@xmath409 4 .
@xmath410 hence , we ve shown that the map @xmath95 is renormalizable when @xmath411 $ ] .
since the size of the data is too large to include in this paper , i provide the code on my website and one can check the data of all the resident maximal polyhedra from my website .
the url is : @xmath412 .
lemma 4.4 holds for parameter @xmath414 $ ] .
we want to apply the same method as used in the previous case .
therefore , we need to classify the maximal domains in @xmath415 and @xmath416 first .
the primary maximal domains in @xmath415 are the maximal domains chopped from the resident maximal polyhedera defined in section 4.4 .
the non - primary maximal domains of @xmath417 are either obtained by chopping from the elements in @xmath358 or they are the newly - appeared maximal domains defined as follows : a maximal domain @xmath34 in @xmath393 is newly - appeared at the parameter @xmath172 if it satisfies the following : * @xmath418 . *
the number of vertices in @xmath34 with @xmath335-coordinate being @xmath172 is less than 3 .
if a maximal domain @xmath34 is newly - appeared , then @xmath34 lies below the plane @xmath276 and it can only touches the plane @xmath276 at a point or a line segment .
the primary and newly - appeared maximal domains of @xmath372 at @xmath172 are defined similarly by replacing @xmath419 with @xmath420 . by computation
, @xmath415 is partitioned into 178 maximal domains and 150 of them are primary .
then the set @xmath416 has 136 primary and 28 non - primary maximal domains .
since we ve shown that the renormalization exists for all points in every resident maximal polyhedron , we are left to check the points in non - primary maximal domains . among the 28 non - primary maximal domains in @xmath416 ( or @xmath415 ) , there are 12 of them are obtained by chopping from non - resident maximal domains in @xmath375 ( or @xmath393 ) , which we have already done the calculation .
if @xmath34 is a non - primary maximal domain in @xmath415 but does not belong to the above case , then @xmath34 must be chopped from a newly - appeared polyhedron at the parameter @xmath421 .
this is because the maximal z - coordinate of all points in @xmath34 must be @xmath421 .
moreover , if @xmath34 has more than 2 vertices with @xmath422 , then @xmath34 is either primary or inherited from a maximal polyhedron appeared in @xmath423 .
the same argument works for the case of @xmath416 .
the lists of all newly - appeared maximal domains in @xmath415 and @xmath416 are provided in section 6 .
there is a one - to - one correspondence between the newly - appeared maximal polyhedra in in @xmath424at @xmath419 and the ones in @xmath364 .
we apply the same calculation as in lemma 5.1 .
therefore , we show that when the parameter @xmath425 $ ] , it is true that @xmath426 we want to show that @xmath95 is conjugate to @xmath156 when @xmath427 by a piecewise translation @xmath381 . recall that @xmath381 is the map interchanging the upper half and lower half of the torus @xmath69 . therefore , we can piece together the map @xmath381 for @xmath275 to get an affine map @xmath383 in @xmath382 :
@xmath428 it is easy to see that the affine map @xmath429 is an involution as well . as discussed in section 4.1 , there is a partition @xmath430 of @xmath272 such that each @xmath387 is a maximal domains in @xmath272 determined by the fiber bundle map @xmath431 @xmath267 there is a partition @xmath432 of @xmath282 $ ] such that each @xmath389 is a maximal subset of @xmath282 $ ] where @xmath274 is entirely defined and continuous .
next , we construct a finer partition @xmath433 of @xmath434)$ ] as follows : * if there exists some @xmath435 such that @xmath436 , then the polyhedron @xmath437 is an element in @xmath433 .
* if there exists some @xmath438 such that @xmath439 , then the polyhedron @xmath440 is an element in @xmath433 .
@xmath433 is partitioned into 26 elements and the bundle map @xmath274 is well - defined on each @xmath441 .
then , we check that the following properties hold : 1 . for each @xmath442 , there exists some @xmath443 such that @xmath444 2 .
@xmath445 3 .
@xmath446 4 .
@xmath447 thus , we show that the tetrahedral pet @xmath95 on @xmath69 is renormalizable when @xmath275 .
the 26 non - secondary maximal polyhedron of @xmath322 are listed as follows : 10 r. adler , b. kitchens . and c. tresser , _ dynamics of non - ergodic piecewise affine maps of the torus _
, ergodic theory dyn .
syst 21 ( 2001 ) , no.4 , 959 - 999 .
a. goetz , _ dynamics of piecewise isometries _ , ill . j. math .
44(2000 ) , no . 3 , 465 - 478 ( english ) .
yoccoz , _ continued fraction algorithms for interval exchange maps : an introduction _ , frontiers in number theory , physics , and geometry vol . 1 ,
p. cartier , b. julia , p. moussa , p.vanhove ( ed . )
springer - verlag 4030437 ( 2006 ) . | we introduce a family of piecewise isometries @xmath0 parametrized by @xmath1 on the surface of a regular tetrahedron , which we call the tetrahedral twists .
this family of maps is similar to the pets constructed by patrick hooper .
we study the dynamics of the tetrahedral twists through the notion of renormalization . by the assistance of computer
, we conjecture that the renormalization scheme exists on the entire interval @xmath2 . in this paper , we show that this system is renormalizable in the subintervals @xmath3 $ ] and @xmath4 . |
many complex systems in various areas of science exhibit a spatio - temporal dynamics that is inhomogeneous and can be effectively described by a superposition of several statistics on different scales , in short a superstatistics @xcite .
the superstatistics notion was introduced in @xcite , in the mean time many applications for a variety of complex systems have been pointed out @xcite .
essential for this approach is the existence of sufficient time scale separation between two relevant dynamics within the complex system .
there is an intensive parameter @xmath1 that fluctuates on a much larger time scale than the typical relaxation time of the local dynamics . in a thermodynamic
setting , @xmath1 can be interpreted as a local inverse temperature of the system , but much broader interpretations are possible .
the stationary distributions of superstatistical systems , obtained by averaging over all @xmath1 , typically exhibit non - gaussian behavior with fat tails , which can be a power law , or a stretched exponential , or other functional forms as well @xcite .
in general , the superstatistical parameter @xmath1 need not to be an inverse temperature but can be an effective parameter in a stochastic differential equation , a volatility in finance , or just a local variance parameter extracted from some experimental time series .
many applications have been recently reported , for example in hydrodynamic turbulence @xcite , for defect turbulence @xcite , for cosmic rays @xcite and other scattering processes in high energy physics @xcite , solar flares @xcite , share price fluctuations @xcite , random matrix theory @xcite , random networks @xcite , multiplicative - noise stochastic processes @xcite , wind velocity fluctuations @xcite , hydro - climatic fluctuations @xcite , the statistics of train departure delays @xcite and models of the metastatic cascade in cancerous systems @xcite . on the theoretical side , there have been recent efforts to formulate maximum entropy principles for superstatistical systems @xcite . in this paper
we provide an overview over some recent developments in the area of superstatistics .
three examples of recent applications are discussed in somewhat more detail : the statistics of lagrangian turbulence , the statistics of train departure delays , and the survival statistics of cancer patients . in all cases the superstatistical model predictions are in very good agreement with real data .
we also comment on recent theoretical approaches to develop generalized maximum entropy principles for superstatistical systems .
in generalized versions of statistical mechanics one starts from more general entropic measures than the boltzmann - gibbs shannon entropy .
a well - known example is the @xmath2-entropy @xcite @xmath3 but other forms are possible as well ( see , e.g. , @xcite for a recent review ) .
the @xmath4 are the probabilities of the microstates @xmath5 , and @xmath2 is a real number , the entropic index .
the ordinary shannon entropy is contained as the special case @xmath6 : @xmath7 extremizing @xmath8 subject to suitable constraints yields more general canonical ensembles , where the probability to observe a microstate with energy @xmath9 is given by @xmath10 one obtains a kind of power - law boltzmann factor , of the so - called @xmath2-exponential form .
the important question is what could be a physical ( non - equilibrium mechanism ) to obtain such distributions .
the reason could indeed be a driven nonequilibrium situation with local fluctuations of the environment .
this is the situation where the superstatistics concept enters .
our starting point is the following well - known formula @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the @xmath0 ( or @xmath13 ) probability distribution .
we see that averaged _ ordinary _ boltzmann factors with @xmath0 distributed @xmath1 yield a _
generalized _ boltzmann factor of @xmath2-exponential form .
the physical interpretation is that tsallis type of statistical mechanics is relevant for _ nonequilibrium _ systems with temperature fluctuations .
this approach was made popular by two prls in 2000/2001 @xcite , which used the @xmath0-distribution for @xmath14 .
general @xmath14 were then discussed in @xcite . in @xcite
it was suggested to construct a dynamical realization of @xmath2-statistics in terms of e.g. a linear langevin equation @xmath15 with fluctuating parameters @xmath16 . here
@xmath17 denotes gaussian white noise .
the parameters @xmath18 are supposed to fluctuate on a much larger time scale than the velocity @xmath19 .
one can think of a brownian particle that moves through spatial cells with different local @xmath20 in each cell ( a nonequilibrium situation ) .
assume the probability distribution of @xmath1 in the various cells is a @xmath0-distribution of degree @xmath21 : @xmath22 then the conditional probability given some fixed @xmath1 in a given cell is gaussian , @xmath23 , the joint probability is @xmath24 and the marginal probability is @xmath25 .
integration yields @xmath26 i.e. we obtain power - law boltzmann factors with @xmath27 , @xmath28 , and @xmath29 . here
@xmath30 is the average of @xmath1 .
the idea of superstatistics is to generalize this example to much broader systems .
for example , @xmath1 need not be an inverse temperature but can in principle be any intensive parameter .
most importantly , one can generalize to _ general probability densities @xmath14 _ and _ general hamiltonians_. in all cases one obtains a superposition of two different statistics : that of @xmath1 and that of ordinary statistical mechanics
. superstatistics hence describes complex nonequilibrium systems with spatio - temporal fluctuations of an intensive parameter on a large scale .
the _ effective _ boltzmann factors @xmath31 for such systems are given by @xmath32 some recent theoretical developments of the superstatistics concept include the following : * can prove a superstatistical generalization of fluctuation theorems @xcite * can develop a variational principle for the large - energy asymptotics of general superstatistics @xcite ( depending on @xmath14 , one can get not only power laws for large @xmath33 but e.g. also stretched exponentials ) * can formally define generalized entropies for general superstatistics @xcite * can study microcanonical superstatistics ( related to a mixture of @xmath2-values ) @xcite * can prove a superstatistical version of a central limit theorem leading to @xmath2-statistics @xcite * can relate it to fractional reaction equations @xcite * can consider superstatistical random matrix theory @xcite * can apply superstatistical techniques to networks @xcite * can define superstatistical path integrals @xcite * can do superstatistical time series analysis @xcite ... and some more practical applications : * can apply superstatistical methods to analyze the statistics of 3d hydrodynamic turbulence @xcite * can apply it to atmospheric turbulence ( wind velocity fluctuations @xcite ) * can apply superstatistical methods to finance and economics @xcite * can apply it to blinking quantum dots @xcite * can apply it to cosmic ray statistics @xcite * can apply it to various scattering processes in particle physics @xcite * can apply it to hydroclimatic fluctuations @xcite * can apply it to train delay statistics @xcite * can consider medical applications @xcite
while in principle any @xmath14 is possible in the superstatistics approach , in practice one usually observes only a few relevant distributions .
these are the @xmath0 , inverse @xmath0 and lognormal distribution . in other words , in typical complex systems with time scale separation one usually observes 3 physically relevant universality classes @xcite * \(a ) @xmath0-superstatistics ( @xmath34 tsallis statistics ) * \(b ) inverse @xmath0-superstatistics * \(c ) lognormal superstatistics what could be a plausible reason for this ?
consider , e.g. , case ( a ) .
assume there are many microscopic random variables @xmath35 , @xmath36 , contributing to @xmath1 in an additive way .
for large @xmath37 , the sum @xmath38 will approach a gaussian random variable @xmath39 due to the ( ordinary ) central limit theorem .
there can be @xmath21 gaussian random variables @xmath40 of the same variance due to various relevant degrees of freedom in the system .
@xmath1 should be positive , hence the simplest way to get such a positive @xmath1 is to square the gaussian random variables and sum them up . as a result
, @xmath41 is @xmath0-distributed with degree @xmath21 , @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the average of @xmath1 .
\(b ) the same considerations can be applied if the temperature @xmath44 rather than @xmath1 itself is the sum of several squared gaussian random variables arising out of many microscopic degrees of freedom @xmath35 .
the resulting @xmath14 is the inverse @xmath0-distribution : @xmath45 it generates superstatistical distributions @xmath46 that decay as @xmath47 for large @xmath33 .
\(c ) @xmath1 may be generated by multiplicative random processes .
consider a local cascade random variable @xmath48 , where @xmath37 is the number of cascade steps and the @xmath35 are positive microscopic random variables . by the ( ordinary ) central limit theorem , for large @xmath37 the random variable @xmath49 becomes gaussian for large @xmath37 .
hence @xmath39 is log - normally distributed .
in general there may be @xmath21 such product contributions to @xmath1 , i.e. , @xmath50 .
then @xmath51 is a sum of gaussian random variables , hence it is gaussian as well .
thus @xmath1 is log - normally distributed , i.e. , @xmath52 where @xmath53 and @xmath54 are suitable parameters .
we will now discuss examples of the three different superstatistical universality classes .
our first example is the departure delay statistics on the british rail network .
clearly , at the various stations there are sometimes train departure delays of length @xmath55 . the 0th - order model for the waiting time would be a poisson process which predicts that the waiting time distribution until the train finally departs is @xmath56 , where @xmath1 is some parameter .
but this does not agree with the actually observed data @xcite .
a much better fit is given by a @xmath2-exponential , see fig . 1 . )
.,width=302 ] what may cause this power law that fits the data ?
the idea is that there are fluctuations in the parameter @xmath1 as well .
these fluctuations describe large - scale temporal or spatial variations of the british rail network environment .
examples of causes of these @xmath1-fluctuations : * begin of the holiday season with lots of passengers * problem with the track * bad weather conditions * extreme events such as derailments , industrial action , terror alerts , etc . as a result ,
the long - term distribution of train delays is then a mixture of exponential distributions where the parameter @xmath1 fluctuates : @xmath57 for a @xmath0-distributed @xmath1 with @xmath21 degrees of freedom one obtains @xmath58 where @xmath59 and @xmath60 .
the model discussed in @xcite generates @xmath2-exponential distributions of train delays by a simple mechanism , namely a @xmath0-distributed parameter @xmath1 of the local poisson process .
this is an example for @xmath0 superstatistics .
our next example is an application in turbulence . consider a single tracer particle advected by a fully developed turbulent flow .
for a while it will see regions of strong turbulent activity , then move on to calmer regions , just to continue in yet another region of strong activity , and so on .
this is a superstatistical dynamics , and in fact superstatistical models of turbulence have been very successful in recent years @xcite .
the typical shape of a trajectory of such a tracer particle is plotted in fig . 2 .
this is lagrangian turbulence in contrast to eulerian turbulence , meaning that one is following a single particle in the flow . in particular , one is interested in velocity differences @xmath61 of the particle on a small time scale @xmath62 . for @xmath63
this velocity difference becomes the local acceleration @xmath64 .
a superstatistical lagrangian model for 3-dim velocity differences of the tracer particle has been developed in @xcite .
one simply looks at a superstatistical langevin equation of the form @xmath65 here @xmath66 and @xmath67 are constants . note that the term proportional to @xmath67 introduces some rotational movement of the particle , mimicking the vortices in the flow .
the noise strength @xmath68 and the unit vector @xmath69 evolve stochastically on a large time scale @xmath70 and @xmath71 , respectively , thus obtaining a superstatistical dynamics .
@xmath70 is of the same order of magnitude as the integral time scale @xmath72 , whereas @xmath73 is of the same order of magnitude as the kolmogorov time scale @xmath74 .
one can show that the reynolds number @xmath75 is basically given by the time scale ratio @xmath76 .
the time scale @xmath77 describes the average life time of a region of given vorticity surrounding the test particle . in this superstatistical turbulence model
one defines the parameter @xmath1 to be @xmath78 , but it does _ not _ have the meaning of a physical inverse temperature in the flow .
rather , one has @xmath79 , where @xmath80 is the kinematic viscosity and @xmath81 is the average energy dissipation , which is known to fluctuate in turbulent flows .
in fact , kolmogorov s theory of 1961 suggests a lognormal distribution for @xmath82 , which automatically leads us to lognormal superstatistics : it is reasonable to assume that the probability density of the stochastic process @xmath83 is approximately a lognormal distribution @xmath84 for very small @xmath62 the 1d acceleration component of the particle is given by @xmath85 and one gets out of the model the 1-point distribution @xmath86 this prediction agrees very well with experimentally measured data of the acceleration statistics , which exhibits very pronounced ( non - gaussian ) tails , see fig . 3 for an example . )
( see @xcite for more details).,width=302 ] it is interesting to see that our 3-dimensional superstatistical model predicts the existence of correlations between the acceleration components .
for example , the acceleration @xmath87 in @xmath88 direction is not statistically independent of the acceleration @xmath89 in @xmath90-direction .
we may study the ratio @xmath91 of the joint probability @xmath92 to the 1-point probabilities @xmath93 and @xmath94 .
for independent acceleration components this ratio would always be given by @xmath95 .
however , our 3-dimensional superstatistical model yields prediction @xmath96 this is a very general formula , valid for any superstatistics , for example also tsallis statistics , obtained when @xmath14 is the @xmath0-distribution .
the trivial result @xmath95 is obtained only for @xmath97 , i.e. no fluctuations in the parameter @xmath1 at all .
4 shows @xmath91 as predicted by lognormal superstatistics : ) , @xmath14 being the lognormal distribution.,width=302 ] the shape of this is very similar to experimental measurements @xcite .
our final example of application of superstatistics is for a completely different area : medicine .
we will look at cell migration processes describing the metastatic cascade of cancerous cells in the body @xcite .
there are various pathways in which cancerous cells can migrate : via the blood system , the lymphatic system , and so on .
the diffusion constants for these various pathways are different . in this way
superstatistics enters , describing different diffusion speeds for different pathways ( see fig .
5 ) .
but there is another important issue here : when looking at a large ensemble of patients then the spread of cancerous cells can be very different from patient to patient . for some patients the cancer spreads in a very aggressive way , whereas for others it is much slower and less aggressive .
so superstatistics also arises from the fact that all patients are different . a superstatistical model of metastasis and cancer survival has been developed in @xcite .
details are described in that paper .
here we just mention the final result that comes out of the model : one obtains the following prediction for the probability density function of survival time @xmath55 of a patient that is diagnosed with cancer at @xmath98 : @xmath99 or @xmath100 , \label{eq7}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath101 is the modified bessel function .
note that this is inverse @xmath0 superstatistics .
the role of the parameter @xmath1 is now played by the parameter @xmath102 , which in a sense describes how aggressively the cancer propagates . the above formula based on inverse @xmath0 superstatistics is in good agreement with real data of the survival statistics of breast cancer patients in the us .
the superstatistical formula fits the observed distribution very well , both in a linear and logarithmic plot ( see fig.6 ) .
one remark is at order .
when looking at the relevant time scales one should keep in mind that the data shown are survival distributions _ conditioned on the fact that death occurs due to cancer_. many patients , in particular if they are diagnosed at an early stage , will live a long happy life and die from something else than cancer .
these cases are _ not _ included in the data . ,
both in a linear and double logarithmic plot . only patients that die from cancer are included in the statistics .
the solid line is the superstatistical model prediction @xcite .
, title="fig:",width=302 ] , both in a linear and double logarithmic plot .
only patients that die from cancer are included in the statistics .
the solid line is the superstatistical model prediction @xcite .
, title="fig:",width=302 ]
we finish this article by briefly mentioning some other recent interesting theoretical developments .
one major theoretical concern is that a priori the superstatistical distribution @xmath14 can be anything .
but perhaps one should single out the really relevant distributions @xmath14 by a least biased guess , given some constraints on the complex system under consideration .
this program has been developed in some recent papers @xcite .
there are some ambiguities which constraints should be implemented , and how . a very general formalism is presented in @xcite , which contains previous work @xcite as special cases .
the three important universality classes discussed above , namely @xmath0 superstatistics , inverse @xmath0 superstatistics and lognormal superstatistics are contained as special cases in the formalism of @xcite . in principle , once a suitable generalized maximum entropy principle has been formulated for superstatistical systems , one can proceed to a generalized thermodynamic description , get a generalized equation of state , and so on .
there is still a lot of scope of future research to develop the most suitable formalism .
but the general tendency seems to be to apply maximum entropy principles and least biased guesses to nonequilibrium situations as well .
in fact , jaynes @xcite always thought this is possible .
another interesting development is what one could call a superstatistical path integral .
these are just ordinary path integrals but with an additional integration over a parameter @xmath1 that make the wiener process become something more complicated , due to large - scale fluctuations of its diffusion constant .
jizba et al .
investigate under which conditions one obtains a markov process again @xcite .
it seems some distributions @xmath14 are distinguished as making the superstatistical process simpler than others , preserving markovian - like properties .
these types of superstatistical path integral processes have applications in finance , and possibly also in quantum field theory and elementary particle physics . in high energy physics ,
many of the power laws observed for differential cross sections and energy spectra in high energy scattering processes can also be explained using superstatistical models @xcite .
the key point here is to extend the hagedorn theory @xcite to a superstatistical one which properly takes into account temperature fluctuations @xcite .
superstatistical techniques have also been recently used to describe the space - time foam in string theory @xcite .
superstatistics ( a statistics of a statistics ) provides a physical reason why more general types of boltzmann factors ( e.g. @xmath2-exponentials or other functional forms ) are relevant for _ nonequilibrium _ systems with suitable fluctuations of an intensive parameter .
let us summarize : * there is evidence for three major physically relevant universality classes : @xmath0-superstatistics @xmath34 tsallis statistics , inverse @xmath0-superstatistics , and lognormal superstatistics .
these arise as universal limit statistics for many different systems . *
superstatistical techniques can be successfully applied to a variety of complex systems with time scale separation . *
the train delays on the british railway network are an example of @xmath0 superstatistics = tsallis statistics @xcite . * a superstatistical model of _ lagrangian turbulence _
@xcite is in excellent agreement with the experimental data for probability densities , correlations between components , decay of correlations , lagrangian scaling exponents , etc .
this is an example of lognormal superstatistics @xcite .
* cancer survival statistics is described by inverse @xmath0 superstatistics @xcite . *
the long - term aim is to find a good thermodynamic description for general superstatistical systems .
a generalized maximum entropy principle may help to achieve this goal .
99 c. beck and e.g.d .
cohen , physica a * 322 * , 267 ( 2003 ) c. beck , e.g.d .
cohen , and h.l .
swinney , phys .
e * 72 * , 056133 ( 2005 ) c. beck and e.g.d .
cohen , physica a * 344 * , 393 ( 2004 ) h. touchette and c. beck , phys .
e * 71 * , 016131 ( 2005 ) c. tsallis and a.m.c .
souza , phys .
e * 67 * , 026106 ( 2003 ) p. jizba , h. kleinert , phys .
e * 78 * , 031122 ( 2008 ) c. vignat , a. plastino and a.r .
plastino , cond - mat/0505580 c. vignat , a. plastino , arxiv 0706.0151 p .- h .
chavanis , physica a * 359 * , 177 ( 2006 ) g. wilk and z. wlodarczyk , phys .
lett . * 84 * , 2770 ( 2000 ) c. beck , phys .
* 87 * , 180601 ( 2001 ) k. e. daniels , c. beck , and e. bodenschatz , physica d * 193 * , 208 ( 2004 ) c. beck , physica a * 331 * , 173 ( 2004 ) m. baiesi , m. paczuski and a.l .
stella , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 051103 ( 2006 ) y. ohtaki and h.h .
hasegawa , cond - mat/0312568 a.y .
abul - magd , physica a * 361 * , 41 ( 2006 ) s. rizzo and a. rapisarda , aip conf . proc . * 742 * , 176 ( 2004 ) ( cond - mat/0406684 ) t. laubrich , f. ghasemi , j. peinke , h. kantz , arxiv:0811.3337 a. porporato , g. vico , and p.a .
fay , geophys . res
. lett . * 33 * , l15402 ( 2006 ) a. reynolds , phys .
* 91 * , 084503 ( 2003 ) h. aoyama et al .
, arxiv:0805.2792 e. van der straeten , c. beck , arxiv:0901.2271 a.y .
abul - magd , g. akemann , p. vivo , arxiv 0811.1992 c. beck , europhys . lett . * 64 * , 151 ( 2003 ) c. beck , phys .
* 98 * , 064502 ( 2007 ) g. wilk , z. wlodarczyk , arxiv:0810.2939 c. beck , arxiv:0902.2459 m. ausloos and k. ivanova , phys .
e * 68 * , 046122 ( 2003 ) j .- p .
bouchard and m. potters , _ theory of financial risk and derivative pricing _ , cambridge university press , cambridge ( 2003 ) a.y .
abul - magd , b. dietz , t. friedrich , a. richer , phys .
e * 77 * , 046202 ( 2008 ) s. abe and s. thurner , phys .
e * 72 * , 036102 ( 2005 ) slvio m. duarte queirs , braz .
* 38 * , 203 ( 2008 ) k. briggs , c. beck , physica a * 378 * , 498 ( 2007 ) l. leon chen , c. beck , physica a * 387 * , 3162 ( 2008 ) s. abe , c. beck and g. d. cohen , phys .
e * 76 * , 031102 ( 2007 ) g. e. crooks , phys .
e * 75 * , 041119 ( 2007 ) j. naudts , aip conference proceedings * 965 * , 84 ( 2007 ) e. van der straeten , c. beck , phys .
e * 78 * , 051101 ( 2008 ) c. tsallis , j. stat .
phys . * 52 * , 479 ( 1988 ) c. tsallis , r.s .
mendes , a.r .
plastino , physica a * 261 * , 534 ( 1998 ) c. beck , arxiv:0902:1235 , to appear in contemporary physics ( 2009 ) a.m. mathai and h.j .
haubold , physica a * 375 * , 110 ( 2007 ) r. d. rosenkrantz , _ e.t .
jaynes : papers on probability , statistics and statistical physics , _ kluwer ( 1989 ) r. hagedorn , suppl .
nuovo cim .
* 3 * , 147 ( 1965 ) c. beck , physica a * 286 * , 164 ( 2000 ) n.e .
mavromatos and s. sarkar , arxiv:0812.3952 | we provide an overview on superstatistical techniques applied to complex systems with time scale separation .
three examples of recent applications are dealt with in somewhat more detail : the statistics of small - scale velocity differences in lagrangian turbulence experiments , train delay statistics on the british rail network , and survival statistics of cancer patients once diagnosed with cancer .
these examples correspond to three different universality classes : lognormal superstatistics , @xmath0-superstatistics and inverse @xmath0 superstatistics . |
the leading models for gamma - ray bursts ( grb ) , bursts of 0.1 - 1 mev photons typically lasting for 0.1 - 100 seconds ( fishman & meegan 1995 ) , involve a relativistic wind emanating from a compact central source .
the ultimate energy source is rapid accretion onto a newly formed stellar mass black hole .
observations suggest that the prompt @xmath1-ray emission is produced by the dissipation ( perhaps due to internal shocks ) of the kinetic energy of a relativistically expanding wind , i.e. a `` fireball '' .
both synchrotron and inverse compton emissions from the shock - accelerated electrons have been proposed as the grb emission mechanism . in this paper , we study in detail the production of neutrinos by protons accelerated along with electrons .
we assume that equal energy of the fireball is dissipated in protons and electrons ( or photons ) .
this is the case in models where grbs are the sources of the highest energy cosmic rays .
the basic idea is that the protons produce pions decaying into neutrinos in interactions with the fireball photons , or with external photons surrounding the newly formed black hole .
where previous calculations have estimated the universal diffuse flux of neutrinos produced by all grbs over cosmological time , we estimate the flux from individual grbs observed by the batse ( burst and transient source experiment ) experiment on the compton gamma - ray observatory . the prediction can be directly compared with coincident observations performed with the amanda detector . having these observations in mind
, we specialize on neutrino emission coincident in time with the grb .
opportunities for neutrino production exist after and , in some models , before the burst of @xmath1-rays , e.g. when the fireball expands through the opaque ejecta of a supernova .
the calculations are performed in two models chosen to be representative and rather different versions of a large range of competing models .
the first is generic for models where an initial event , such as a merger of compact objects or the instant collapse of a massive star to a black hole , produces the fireball ( waxman & bahcall 1997 ; guetta , spada & waxman 2001a , gsw hereafter ) .
we calculate the neutrino production by photomeson interactions of relativistic protons accelerated in the internal shocks and the synchrotron photons that are emitted in these shocks .
the neutrinos produced via this mechanism have typical energies of @xmath2 ev , and are emitted in coincidence with the grbs , with their spectrum tracing the grb photon spectrum . for an alternative model , we have chosen the supranova model where a massive star collapses to a neutron star with mass @xmath3 , which loses its rotational energy on a time scale @xmath4 of weeks to years , before collapsing to a black hole , thus triggering the grb . following guetta and granot ( guetta & granot 2002a )
, we calculate the neutrino flux from interactions of the fireball protons with external photons in the rich radiation field created during the spindown of the supra - massive pulsar .
production on external photons turns out to be dominant for a wide range of parameters , @xmath5yr for a typical grb and @xmath6yr for x - ray flashes .
the neutrinos produced via this mechanism have energies @xmath7ev for typical grb ( x - ray flashes ) and are emitted simultaneously with the prompt @xmath1-ray ( x - ray ) emission .
their energy spectrum consists of several power law segments and its overall shape depends on the model parameters , especially @xmath4 .
if the mass of the supernova remnant is of the order of @xmath8 , and if the supernova remnant shell is clumpy , then for time separation @xmath9 yr the snr shell has a thomson optical depth larger than unity and obscures the radiation emitted by the grb .
therefore , for @xmath10yr , the @xmath11 s would not be accompanied by a detectable grb providing us with an example of neutrino emission not coinciding with a grb display . as previously mentioned , to realistically estimate the neutrino fluxes associated with either of these models , we turn to the grb data collected by batse .
the batse records include spectral and temporal information which can be used to estimate neutrino spectra for individual bursts .
we will perform these calculations for two version of each of the two models previously described .
the two versions correspond to alternative choices of important parameters .
the wide variety of grb spectra results , not surprisingly , in a wide range of neutrino spectra and event rates . for approximately 800 bursts in the batse catalog , and for four choices of models
, we have calculated the neutrino spectra and the event rates , coincident with grbs , for a generic neutrino telescope . with 800 bursts ,
the sample should also be representative for data expected from much larger next - generation neutrino observatories .
neutrino telescopes can leverage the directional and time information provided by batse to do an essentially background - free search for neutrinos from grbs .
individual neutrino events within the batse time and angular window are a meaningful observation
. a generic detector with 1km@xmath12 effective telescope area , during one year , should be able to observe 1000 bursts over @xmath13 steradians . using the batse grbs as a template , we predict order 10 events , muons or showers , for both models .
the rates in the supranova model depend strongly on @xmath4 . in this model
we anticipate @xmath14 events per year assuming @xmath15 yr , but only one event per ten years for @xmath16 yr
. we will present detailed tabulated predictions further on .
they can be accessed at http://www.arcetri.astro.it/@xmath0dafne / grb/. short duration grbs , characterized by lower average fluences , are less likely to produce observable neutrino fluxes .
we find that grbs with lower peak energies , x - ray flash candidates , yield the largest rates in the supranova model .
for instance , for @xmath17 yr , we predict one event ( muon or shower ) for every 1000 bursts .
if only 100 , or so , x - ray flashes occur per year , as observations suggest , this will be difficult to observe .
however , such events may be considerably more common and may contribute significantly to the diffuse high energy neutrino flux .
observations of neutrinos from this class of grbs would be strong evidence for a supranova progenitor model .
the amanda collaboration has collected neutrino data in coincidence with batse observations ( barouch & hardtke 2001 ) .
it operated the detector for 3 years ( 1997 - 1999 ) with an effective area of approximately 5,000m@xmath12 for grbs events . in early 2000
the expanded detector reached an effective area of roughly 50,000m@xmath12 .
unfortunately , only @xmath0100 coincident bursts could be observed with the completed detector before batse operations ceased in june 2000 . with effective areas significantly below the canonical square kilometer discussed in this paper ,
amanda is not large enough to test the grb models considered here .
we estimate only 0.08 events in 1997 - 1999 and 0.3 in 2000 . our estimate of 110 events in 1 year for a telescope with 1 kilometer square telescope area is consistent with previous , burst - averaged , determinations of the grb neutrino flux ( alvarez , halzen & hooper 2000 , dermer & atoyan 2003 ) .
note that the effective area of icecube for grb will significantly exceed this reference value ( pdd ) .
the rate can be understood by a back - of - the - envelope estimate .
a typical grb produces a photon fluence on the order of @xmath18 , which we assume to be equal to the energy in protons .
if @xmath19 of the proton energy is converted into pions , half to charged pions , and one quarter of the charged pion energy to muon neutrinos in the @xmath20 decay chain , then @xmath21 neutrinos are generated . for a typical neutrino energy of @xmath22 ,
this yields @xmath23 neutrinos per square kilometer . at this energy
the probability that a neutrino converts to a muon within range of the detector is @xmath24 ( gaisser , halzen , stanev 1995 ) .
therefore @xmath25 muons are detected in association with a single grb .
with over 1000 grbs in one year , we estimate a few muons per year in a kilometer - square detector .
fluctuations in fluence and other burst characteristics enhance this estimate significantly ( see figure [ figevn ] , for instance ) , however , absorption of neutrinos in the earth can reduce this number .
these effects are included in the calculations of actual event rates throughout this paper .
our estimates , while observable with future kilometer - scale observatories , may be conservative .
we already mentioned bursts with no counterpart in photons .
also , occasional nearby bursts , much like supernova , could exceptionally provide higher event rates than our calculations reflect .
we would like to point out the fact that the aim of the paper is not to do more precise calculations than the ones already done in the literature . we just want to generate results that can be compared with experiments that do coincidents observations with satellites .
the outline of the paper is somewhat unconventional .
the detailed results are collected in a data archive at http://www.arcetri.astro.it/@xmath0dafne/grb .
the details of the calculations of the neutrino fluxes in the two models are described in appendices a and b. in appendix c we collected the methods used to evaluate the rates of neutrino - induced muons , taus and showers in a generic detector with a given effective telescope area .
the main body of the paper is organized as follows . in 2 , we review grb models and describe the mechanisms for neutrino production in grbs . in 3 and 4
we describe the batse catalog of grbs and we identify subclasses of events : long duration grbs with and without measured redshift , short duration grbs and x - ray flash candidates . in
5 we summarize our simulation of the response of a generic high energy neutrino telescope to the predicted neutrino fluxes . in 6 we analyse some anomalous bursts . results and conclusions
are collected in 7 .
progenitor models of grbs are divided into two main categories .
the first category involves the merger of a binary system of compact objects , such as a double neutron star ( eichler et al .
1989 ) , a neutron star and a black hole ( narayan , pacyski & piran 1992 ) or a black hole and a helium star or a white dwarf ( fryer & woosley 1998 ; fryer , woosley & hartmann 1999 ) .
the second category involves the death of a massive star .
it includes the failed supernova ( woosley 1993 ) or hypernova ( pacyski 1998 ) models , where a black hole is created promptly , and a large accretion rate from a surrounding accretion disk ( or torus ) feeds a strong relativistic jet in the polar regions .
this type of model is known as the collapsar model . an alternative model within this second category
is the supranova model ( vietri & stella 1998 ) , where a massive star explodes in a supernova and leaves behind a supra - massive neutron star ( smns ) , of mass @xmath3 .
it subsequently loses its rotational energy on a time scale @xmath4 of order weeks to years until it collapses to a black hole .
this triggers the grb .
long grbs ( with a duration @xmath26 ) are usually attributed to the second category of progenitors , while short grbs are attributed to the first category .
we select two models to investigate the opportunities for neutrino production in a grb .
the analysis can be easily extended to other models ( see for example razzaque , mszros & waxman 2002 ; dermer & atoyan 2003 ) . the first model is based on the standard fireball phenomenology where electrons and protons are shock accelerated in the fireball .
pions and neutrinos are produced by photoproduction interactions when the protons coexist in the fireball with photons .
these are produced by synchrotron radiation of accelerated electrons . for a second model we turn to the supranova scenario where the supra - massive pulsar loses its rotational energy through a strong pulsar wind
this pulsar wind creates a rich external radiation field before the collapse to the final black hole and the creation of the grb fireball .
it is referred to as the pulsar wind bubble ( pwb ) ( knigl & granot 2002 ; inoue , guetta & pacini 2002 ; guetta & granot 2003 ) and provides a target for the photoproduction of neutrinos by fireball protons .
let s note in passing that the supranova model has several advantages compared to other collapsar models : ( i ) the jet does not have to penetrate the stellar envelope ( vietri & stella 1998 ) , ( ii ) it can naturally explain the x - ray line features observed in several afterglows ( piro et al . 2000 ;
lazzati , et al . 2001 ; vietri et al .
2001 ) , and ( iii ) the large fraction of the internal energy in the magnetic field and in electrons observed in the afterglow emission arise naturally ( knigl & granot 2002 ; guetta & granot 2003 ) . in all of the different scenarios mentioned above , the final stage of the process consists of a newly formed black hole with a large accretion rate from a surrounding torus , and involve a similar energy budget ( @xmath27 ) .
observations suggest that prompt @xmath1-ray emission is produced by the dissipation of the kinetic energy within the fireball , due to internal shocks within the flow that arise from variability of the lorentz factor , @xmath28 , on a time scale @xmath29 .
the afterglow emission is thought to arise from an external shock that is driven into the ambient medium as it decelerates the ejected matter ( rees & mszros 1994 ; sari & piran 1997 ) . in this
so called ` internal - external ' shock model , the duration of the prompt grb is directly related to the time during which the central source is active .
the emission mechanism is successfully described by synchrotron radiation from relativistic electrons that radiate in the strong magnetic fields .
these are close to equipartition values within the shocked plasma . an additional radiation mechanism that may also play some role
is synchrotron self - compton ( ssc ) ( guetta & granot 2002b ) , which is the upscattering of the synchrotron photons by relativistic electrons to higher energy .
protons are expected to be accelerated along with the electrons in the region where the wind kinetic energy is converted into internal energy due to a dissipation mechanism like internal shocks .
the conditions in the dissipation region allow proton acceleration up to @xmath30ev ( waxman 1995 ; vietri 1995 ) .
the energy in @xmath1-rays reflect the fireball energy in accelerated electrons and afterglow observations indicate that accelerated electrons and protons carry similar energy ( freedman & waxman 2000 ) .
our basic assumption in calculating neutrino emission from grbs is that equal amounts of energy go into protons and photons . in models where grb protons are the source of the highest energy cosmic rays ,
this assumption is supported by the approximate equality of the @xmath1-ray fluence of all grbs and the total energy in extragalactic cosmic rays .
both internal shocks , responsible for the prompt grb emission , and the external shock , responsible for the afterglow emission , have been proposed as possible sources of the highest energy cosmic rays ( waxman 1995 and vietri 1995 , respectively ) .
a comparison between the two mechanisms has been done by vietri , de marco and guetta ( 2003 ) , but it is not easy to conceive , at this point , an observational test capable of distinguishing between the two models .
the only hope appears to observe the production of high energy neutrinos which must accompany the _ in situ _ acceleration of particles .
occasionally , ultra - high energy protons will produce pions and neutrinos in collisions with photons in photon rich environment provided by the post shock shells or by the pulsar wind bubble .
if the protons are accelerated in internal shocks , the neutrinos produced will arrive at earth simultaneously with the photons of the burst proper and will have an energy @xmath31 ( waxman and bachall 1997 ; gsw ; guetta & granot 2002a ) .
if accelerated in external shocks , they will arrive at earth simultaneously with the photons of the afterglow and will have a higher energy , @xmath32 ev ( vietri 1998a , 1998b , waxman & bahcall 2000 ) .
general phenomenological considerations indicate that gamma - ray bursts are produced by the dissipation of the kinetic energy of a relativistic expanding fireball .
internal shocks that are mildly relativistic are believed to dissipate the energy .
therefore , the proton energy distribution should be close to that for fermi acceleration in a newtonian ( non - relativistic ) shock , @xmath33 .
moreover , the power law index of the electron and proton energy distributions are expected to be the same , and the values inferred for the electron distribution from the observed photon spectrum are @xmath34 with @xmath35 .
we shall , therefore , adopt @xmath33 .
plasma parameters in the dissipation region allow proton acceleration to energies greater than @xmath36 ev ( waxman 1995 , vietri 1995 ) .
we will assume that the fireball is spherically symmetric .
note , however , that a jet - like fireball behaves as if it were a conical section of a spherical fireball as long as @xmath37 , where @xmath38 is the jet opening angle and @xmath39 is the wind lorentz factor .
therefore , our results apply without modification to a jet - like fireball . for a jet - like wind
, the luminosity , @xmath40 , in our equations should be understood as the luminosity of the fireball inferred by assuming spherical symmetry .
we have relegated all details of the calculation of neutrino production via photomeson interaction with grb photons and pwb photons to appendices a and b , respectively . throughout the paper
, we will refer to the models by the following convention : * model 1 : neutrino flux from the interaction of high - energy protons with grb photons .
the fraction of proton energy transfered to pion energy is set to 0.2 as indicated by simulations of gsw ( see apppendix a ) .
* model 2 : neutrino flux from the interaction of high - energy protons with grb photons .
the fraction of proton energy transfered to pion energy is calculated as described in appendix a ( see appendix a ) .
* model 3 : neutrino flux from the interaction of high - energy protons with pwb photons , as in the supranova progenitor model .
the time scale between supernova and grb is set to @xmath41 yr ( see appendix b ) .
* model 4 : neutrino flux from the interaction of high - energy protons with pwb photons , as in the supranova progenitor model .
the time scale between supernova and grb is set to @xmath42 yr ( see appendix b ) .
batse , the burst and transient source experiment , was a high energy astrophysics experiment launched on the compton gamma - ray observatory in 1991 .
batse , between its launch and the termination of its orbit in 2000 , has observed and recorded data from over 8000 events including gamma - ray bursts , pulsars , terrestrial gamma - ray flashes , soft gamma repeaters and black holes .
the data batse recorded from gamma - ray bursts is publically available in the current batse catalog at http://f64.nsstc.nasa.gov / batse / grb / catalog/. for a description see paciesas et al .
the catalog includes information on the spectrum , time and location of each triggered burst .
each triggered event has been assigned a batse trigger number ( between 105 and 8121 for grbs ) which we use to identify individual bursts .
spectral information is recorded in four energy channels , 20 - 50 kev , 50 - 100 kev , 100 - 300 kev and above 300 kev . using these four fluence measurements ,
we have fitted the spectrum of each grb to a broken power law , treating the break energy , both spectral slopes and the normalization as free parameters ; see eq.([eq : fnu ] ) .
we determine the lorentz factor of the relativistic expanding ejecta using the break energy through eq.([eq : epeak ] ) . for bursts with an observed break energy above 300 kev , or below 50 kev , it is difficult to determine both the break energy and the power law slope . for high energy breaks , the impact on this ambiguity is not critical .
as explained in appendix a , the lorentz factor is not dependent on the fit because it is fixed by the observed high energy of the event and the requirement that the fireball be optically thin .
for very low spectral breaks ( below 50 kev ) , for instance in events we classify as x - ray flash candidates , we acknowledge a significant degree of uncertainty in the lorentz factor calculation and resulting neutrino spectra . in this case
, the spectral break is only uncertain to about a factor of 2 or 3 .
detailed temporal information is available in the batse catalog , in the form of light curves .
the batse time resolution varies between 2.048 seconds and 0.016 seconds .
a resolution of 0.064 seconds is available for all bursts during the time following the trigger . in the framework of the internal shock model
, we need a variability time , @xmath29 , @xmath43 in order to get the 1mev @xmath44 ( guetta , spada & waxman 2001b , waxman 2001 ) .
in fact with a value of the lorentz factor larger than the minimal value needed to be optically thin up to 100 mev ( @xmath45 see eq.[eq : gamma ] ) the variability time , @xmath29 , has to be @xmath46 to get the 1 mev @xmath1-rays .
how well the data support the model is still controversial and a detailed analysis on this issue is out of the aim of our paper . since we refer to this model for our analysis we consider a value of @xmath47 ms for long duration grbs in the rest of the paper . for short duration
bursts we take @xmath48 ms and 0.050 seconds for x - ray flash candidates .
we have divided the list of batse grbs into four different classes : 1 ) long duration bursts ( duration @xmath26 ) with measured redshfit , 2 ) long duration bursts without measured redshift , 3 ) short duration bursts and 4 ) x - ray flashes .
major differences in temporal and spectral properties of long duration grbs , short duration grbs and x - ray flashes has lead to some speculation that they may involve different progenitors or mechanisms . by observing the optical afterglow of grbs , it is possible to measure spectral lines and , therefore , the redshift of an individual burst .
although to date the x - ray afterglow of on the order of 100 long duration grbs have been observed , only 31 of them have been observed in the optical making a determination of the redshift possible .
( no redshift has been identified for short grbs ) .
we first consider 13 of these that have a complete batse record .
the relationship between the comoving distance to an object and its redshift is given by : @xmath49 where @xmath50 and @xmath51 are the fractions of the critical density of the universe in dark energy and matter , respectively .
@xmath52 is hubble s constant .
once the distance to a grb is known , and its fluence ( or flux ) has been measured , the isotropic - equivalent @xmath1-ray luminosity can be calculated . from this and the value of @xmath53 , together with the break energy of the grb photon spectrum , we estimate the bulk lorentz factor using eqs.([eq : gamma ] , [ eq : epeak ] ) . setting the efficiency for pion production @xmath54 for model 1 and using eq.([eq : fpi2 ] ) for model 2
, we estimate the fraction of proton energy transfered into pions .
using eqs.([eq : synclos ] , [ eq : synclos2 ] ) the energy scale of synchrotron losses , @xmath55 , is determined . from these informations
we can determine the neutrino flux at earth for each of the four models .
for a more detailed discussion see appendices a and b. for the majority of the long duration bursts in the batse catalog no redshift is available . in this case , the @xmath1-ray luminosity of long duration bursts , and , therefore , the distance , can be estimated by assuming a relationship between the observed variability and the luminosity of a grb ( lloyd - ronning & ramierz - ruiz 2002 ; zhang & meszaros 2002 ; kobayashi , ryde & macfadyen 2002 ) .
note that the variability of a grb is not the same as its variability time , @xmath29 , previously introduced .
the variability of burst is a measure of fluctuations in the temporal structure of the burst .
it is defined such that pure noise should have a variability of zero , while the most variable bursts have very sudden and distinctive temporal features .
we use the following definition of variability ( fenimore & ramirez - ruiz 2000 ) : @xmath56 where @xmath57 , @xmath58 is the background subtracted fluence in a time bin @xmath59 , @xmath60 is the average background in a single time bin , @xmath61 is the maximum fluence and @xmath62 is the average fluence over a time period centered at time bin @xmath59 of length 30% of the @xmath63 time ( duration ) of the burst .
the grbs with observed redshifts have been used to empirically derive a relationship between the variability and the luminosity of the burst ( fenimore & ramirez - ruiz 2000 ; reichart et al .
2001 , reichart & lamb 2001 ) : @xmath64 a relationship between luminosity and the time lag between the peaks for light curves in different energy bands , has been observed in the grb redshift data ( norris , marani & bonnell 2000 ) , but appears to be less reliable .
therefore , we will only consider the luminosity - variability relationship .
together with the fluence ( flux ) of a burst , the distance of a burst can be determined by the luminosity .
note that the variability , and therefore luminosity , of a burst depends on the redshift or distance to the burst .
therefore , we must do this calculation by iteration .
the end result is a value of the luminosity and redshift for each burst .
we would like to enphasize the fact that there are a lot of uncertainties in this way to estimate the redshift , however the knoweledge of the redshift is not so important in our analysis since the minimum variability time scales and the fluence are the most important quantities .
it is difficult to reliably calculate the variability of bursts with low flux .
for this reason , we only consider bursts with a peak flux greater than 1.5 photons/@xmath65 ( over a 0.256 s time scale ) and with at least 30 time bins ( of 0.064 s width ) of 5 sigma or more above the average background .
the grbs which do not meet these requirements have low fluence and are therefore likely to yield a low neutrino flux anyway .
after these criteria were applied , 566 long duration bursts without measured redshift are left , making it our largest class . even for bursts which meet the above criteria ,
the luminosity estimated is only accurate to an order of magnitude .
this corresponds to uncertainties of a factor of 2 or 3 in the fraction of proton energy transfered into pions and in the synchrotron loss energy .
short duration grbs , with no observation of an optical afterglow and , therefore , no measurement of redshift , can not have a relationship between variability and luminosity empirically established .
additionally , variability is difficult to measure for short duration bursts . left with no way to measure the @xmath1-ray luminosity of , or distance to , a short duration grbs
, we choose to set @xmath66 for each burst .
this introduces greater uncertainty than in the long duration grbs case but , given the ambiguities in the burst characteristics , it is the best that can be done at this time . to be consistent , we considered only short bursts with a peak flux greater than 1.5 photons/@xmath67 ( over a 0.256 s time scale ) , as we did with for long duration grbs .
after this criteria was applied , 199 short duration bursts remained in this category .
temporal structure and variations appear to occur on shorter time scales for short compared to long grbs ( mcbreen et al .
we therefore use a time scale of temporal fluctuations of @xmath68 for all short duration bursts , as opposed to the value of @xmath69 used for long duration bursts .
it is also interesting to note that short duration bursts generally have a somewhat harder spectrum and higher peak energy than long duration grbs ( paciesas et al .
2001 ) .
x - ray flashes are a newly discovered class of fast transient sources .
the bepposax experiment s wide field cameras have observed such events at a rate of about four per year ( heise et al .
2001 , kippen et al .
2002 ) , implying a total rate on the order of @xmath70 per year .
these events typically have peak energies as low as 2 - 10 kev and durations of 10 - 100 seconds .
the bepposax experiment discriminates x - ray flashes from standard grbs by the non - detection of a signal above 40 kev with the bepposax grb monitor .
more generally , a large ratio of x - ray to @xmath1-ray fluence is the differentiating characteristic of x - ray flashes from grbs .
it has been suggested , however , that x - ray flashes are a low peak energy extension of gamma - ray bursts ( heise et al .
2001 , kippen et al .
2002 ) .
the final class considered here consists of batse events which may be x - ray flashes .
we identify 15 events in this class with spectra that peak below 50 kev , although it is difficult to determine accurately where the peak occurs because the sensitivity of batse is somewhat poor in this energy range .
these are long duration bursts , and typically have a hard spectrum ; several have @xmath71 in eq.([eq : fnu ] ) larger than 1.5 , and no observed flux in batse s fourth energy channel ( above 300 kev ) . again , with no measured redshift , and limited temporal information , we can not deduce the luminosities of these events .
we set @xmath66 for each event and calculate its luminosity accordingly .
it is thought that the radius of collisions in x - ray flashes is typically larger than in other grbs and , therefore , the time scale of fluctuations will generally be larger ( guetta , spada & waxman 2001b ) .
we therefore choose @xmath72 .
for some x - ray flashes the peak energy is very low ( 20 - 30 kev ) and the lorentz factor accordingly very high . increasing the time scale of fluctuations has the additional effect of lowering the lorentz factor to a reasonable value in these extreme cases ( see eq.([eq : epeak ] ) ) . for x - ray flashes , with a very large lorentz factor and a long time scale of fluctuations , we expect that a very small fraction of proton energy converted to pions ; see eqs.([eq : fpi1],[eq : fpi2 ] ) .
we therefore expect low neutrino fluxes from proton interactions with grb photons .
for the models involving proton interactions with photons in a surrounding pulsar wind bubble , however , the rates can be quite high ( guetta & ganot 2002a ) .
there is another class of objects that are the non - triggered bursts .
they are found in the batse data in off - line analysis ; see e.g. stern and tikhomirova + ( http://www.astro.su.se/groups/head/[email protected] ) .
they are not energetic enough to trigger in real time .
these can be grbs with low kinetic luminosity and will be very weak neutrino sources for all the four models , therefore we have decided to neglect them in our analysis .
we have constructed a database publicly accessible online with a complete list of all of the grb characteristics and associated neutrino event rates for the approximately 800 bursts we have considered in this analysis .
the data was populated in a mysql database , interacting through a user - friendly web interface developed with perl .
the database is searchable by grb number and/or by grb class , and is capable of searching for only bursts included in the amanda analysis or all bursts in this work .
the rates are for a generic neutrino telescope provided the threshold is sufficiently low for observing the neutrino fluxes predicted .
how we transform the grb neutrino fluxes into observed event rates is the topic of the next section .
representative results are tabulated in tables 1 through 12 .
the database also contains the predicted neutrino spectra for each burst ; these can be directly combined with the simulation of a specific detector .
the database is accessible at http://www.arcetri.astro.it/@xmath0dafne/grb .
large volume neutrino telescopes are required to observe and measure the neutrino flux from grbs .
current experiments , such as amanda ( andres et al .
2001 ) at the south pole , or future ( aslanides et al . 1999 ) and next generation experiments , including icecube ( see http://icecube.wisc.edu/ ) with a full cubic kilometer of instrumented detector volume , i.e. with @xmath74 telescope area , are designed to observe high energy cosmic neutrinos with energies expected from grbs .
neutrino telescopes detect the cherenkov light radiated by showers ( hadronic and electromagnetic ) , muons , and taus that are produced in the interactions of neutrinos inside or near the detector .
muons are of particular interest because , at the energies typical for grb neutrinos , they travel kilometers before losing energy .
the dominant signal is , therefore , through - going muons .
icecube can measure the energy and direction of any observed muon .
the angular resolution is less than @xmath75 while the energy resolution is approximately a factor of three .
signal and background muons may , therefore , be differentiated with a simple energy cut . for shower events the energy measurement improves significantly ,
being better than 20% , but reconstructing their direction is challenging , the angular resolution being of order 10 degrees . for high energies ,
when tau decay is sufficiently time dilated , taus have a range similar to or larger than muons , and so the dominant tau signal is from through - going taus .
these events have a characteristic signature consisting of a `` clean '' minimum - ionizing track despite its long range inside the detector .
we will therefore consider all events in which a tau track passes through the detector in the direction and at the time of a grb .
we assume that taus and muons are distinguishable at all energies when specializing to rare events in coincidence in time and direction with a grb .
we realize that , in general , it may be difficult to distinguish a muon of energy @xmath76 gev , that is expected to lose relatively little energy from catastrophic processes , from a very high energy tau .
tau signatures however become dramatic when they decay inside the detector ( lollipop events ) , or when the tau neutrino interacts and the produced tau decays into showers inside the detector ( double bang events ) . to evaluate the prospects for grb neutrino observations , it is essential to determine the rate of muon , shower and tau events .
these calculations are each described in appendix c. for a review of high energy neutrino astronomy ; see ( halzen & hooper 2002 ; learned & mannheim 2000 ) .
there are a few grbs we have considered in this analysis which are anomalous for a variety of reasons .
we briefly mention these in this section . *
grb 6707 is a burst with a measured redshift of 0.0085 , yet a relatively low fluence of @xmath77 .
together , this implies a luminosity on the order of @xmath78erg / s , well below the normal range considered .
our calculation of the lorentz factor , which depends on the luminosity of the grb , yields a value of about 25,000 , much larger than the normally allowed range .
results in model 2 are , therefore , not particularly realistic for this particular burst ( the rates are actually very low for this model ) .
the other models are only affected by this in the calculation of the synchrotron energy loss scale . *
grbs 7648 , 6891 and 1997 each have lorentz factors below 100 . in all three cases ,
the burst has been found to have a low luminosity , @xmath79erg / s , which contributes to this result .
the results of models 2 , 3 or 4 are only affected by this in their low synchrotron energy loss scales , and are , therefore , conservative .
results for model 1 should be interpreted with caution for these three grbs . *
grbs 1025 and 8086 , both long duration bursts , have been found to have very low variabilities and , therefore , low luminosities .
this results in very high lorentz factors in our calculation ( 20,000 and 5,000 , respectively ) . given the uncertainties involved in the variability calculation and the variability - luminosity relationship , we feel that these luminosities and lorentz factors are unlikely to accurately represent these bursts .
as already mentioned , our results are summarized in a series of tables .
they summarize our fits to the batse data that provide the input spectrum for calculating the neutrino emission .
the neutrino event rates for the 4 classes and the 4 models are also tabulated ( see tables 1 through 8) . in tables 9 - 12 , we summarize the event rates for a generic kilometer - scale telescope , such as icecube , for the 4 classes of grbs . for the duration and in the direction of a grb
, the background in a neutrino telescope should be negligible .
therefore individual events represent a meaningful observation when coincident with a grb .
we next evaluate the prospects for such observations .
the amanda experiment has operated for approximately four years ( 1997 - 2000 ) that overlap with the batse mission ( barouch & hardtke 2001 ) .
data has been collected for several hundred grbs with an effective telescope area of order 5,000 m@xmath12 .
amanda - ii , the completed version of the experiment , with approximately 50,000 m@xmath12 effective area for the high energy neutrinos emitted by grbs , was commissioned less than half a year before the end of the batse mission .
nevertheless , of order 100 bursts occurred during that period for which coincident observations were made . with effective areas significantly below the reference square kilometer of future neutrino telescopes
, amanda is not expected to test the grb models considered here . for long duration grbs , the most common classification
, we anticipate on the order of 0.01 events ( muons+showers ) per square kilometer per grb for models 1 and 2 . for amanda - ii , with one twentieth of this area , and only capable of observing northern hemisphere grbs ( @xmath80/yr ) , we predict on the order of .3 events ( muons+showers ) per year of observation .
amanda - b10 , with smaller area , should observe one tenth of this rate .
it is interesting , however , to note that such experiments are on the threshold of observation at this time .
icecube with a square kilometer of effective area , now under construction , will likely cross this threshold . for the high energies considered here
, icecube should be able to make observations of 1000 bursts over @xmath13 steradians during one year .
where models 1 and 2 are concerned , we expect that an event ( muon or shower ) will be observed from roughly 10 grbs . for models 3 and 4
we predict @xmath14 events per year for models with @xmath17 yr ( model 4 ) , but only around one event per ten years if @xmath81 is somewhat larger , such as 0.4 yr ( model 3 ) .
the prospects for observation depends strongly on @xmath81 , as expected .
we expect that classes of grbs with lower average fluence , such as short duration grbs and x - ray flash candidates , will be more difficult to observe .
x - ray flash candidates , although unlikely to be observable in models 1 and 2 , could possibly be observed in models 3 and 4 . if @xmath17 yr ( model 4 ) , we predict order one event ( muon or shower ) for every 1000 bursts . with only @xmath82 x - ray flashes thought to occur per year , such an observation will be unlikely . if such events are more common , however , they may contribute significantly to the diffuse high energy neutrino flux .
observations of neutrinos from low peak energy grbs would be strong evidence for a supranova progenitor model .
it is interesting to note that the majority of the neutrino events from grbs come from a relatively small fraction of the grb population ( alvarez , halzen & hooper 2000 ; halzen & hooper 1999 ) . in figure [ figdist ]
we show some of the factors which go into this conclusion .
the occasional nearby ( low redshift ) , large @xmath83 , high fluence and/or near horizontal burst can dominate the event rate calculation .
the distribution of the number of events per burst ( or x - ray flash candidate ) is shown in figure [ figevn ] . in summary
, taking advantage of the large body of grb statistics available in the batse catalog , we have attempted to estimate the neutrino fluxes and event rates in neutrino telescopes associated with grbs for a variety of theoretical models .
our analysis has yielded several conclusions : * gamma - ray bursts with high fluence , most often long duration bursts , provide the best opportunity for neutrino observations . * for typical gamma - ray bursts , proton interactions with fireball photons
provides the largest neutrino signal .
we have also shown that the rates are relatively model independent . * for gamma - ray bursts with very low peak energies ,
possibly associated with x - ray flashes , very little energy is transfered into pions ( and , therefore , neutrinos ) in interactions with fireball photons .
interactions with a surrounding pulsar wind bubble , however , can yield interesting neutrino fluxes .
this is an illustration that observation of neutrinos is likely to help decipher the progenitor mechanism . * while our calculations indicate that existing neutrino telescopes , such as amanda , are not likely to have the sensitivity to observe gamma - ray burst neutrinos , next generation , kilometer - scale observatories , such as icecube , will be capable of observing on the order of ten bursts each year
. we would like to thank jonathan granot , rellen hardtke , robert preece , ricardo vzquez and eli waxman for valuable discussions .
this research was supported by the u.s .
department of energy under grant de - fg02 - 95er40896 and by the wisconsin alumni research foundation .
m . is supported by mcyt ( fpa 2001 - 3837 ) .
.characteristics for grbs with redshifts measured from optical afterglow observations .
the fluence and zenith angle of each burst are taken from the batse catalog , whereas the luminosity is derived from the redshift and fluence .
the break energy is obtained by a fit to the batse data and the lorentz factor is calculated as described in appendix a. note that grb 6707 is an anomalous burst ( see 6 ) . [
table : i ] [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
in this appendix , we describe the production of neutrinos in interactions of protons and photons in the grb fireball .
protons predominantly produce the parent pions via the processes @xmath84 and @xmath85 which have very large cross sections of @xmath86 .
the charged @xmath87 s subsequently decay producing charged leptons and neutrinos , while neutral @xmath87 s decay into high - energy photons . for the center - of - mass energy of a proton - photon interaction to exceed the threshold energy for producing the @xmath88-resonance
, the comoving proton energy must meet the condition : @xmath89 throughout this paper , primed quantities are measured in the comoving frame and unprimed quantities in the observer frame . in the observer s frame ,
@xmath90 resulting in a neutrino energy @xmath91 where @xmath92 is the plasma expansion ( bulk ) lorentz factor and @xmath93 is the photon energy .
@xmath94 is the average fraction of energy transferred from the initial proton to the produced pion .
the factor of 1/4 is based on the estimate that the 4 final state leptons in the decay chain @xmath95 equally share the pion energy .
these approximations are adequate given the uncertainties in the astrophysics of the problem .
for each proton energy , the resulting neutrino spectrum traces the broken power law spectrum of photons which we fit to the batse data using the broken power law parameterization @xmath96 summing over proton energies results in a neutrino spectrum with the same spectra slopes , @xmath97 and @xmath71 , as for the gamma - ray spectra in the batse data , but with a break energy of order 1pev in the observer frame : @xmath98 we here explicitly introduce the dependence on source redshift , z. the highest energy pions may lose some energy via synchrotron emission before decaying , thus reducing the energy of the decay neutrinos .
the effect becomes important when the pion lifetime @xmath99s becomes comparable to the synchrotron loss time @xmath100 where @xmath101 is the energy density of the magnetic field in the shocked fluid .
@xmath102 , the fraction of the internal energy carried by the magnetic field , is defined by the relation @xmath103 , where @xmath104 is the collision radius .
the collision radius @xmath105 is obtained from the consideration that different shells in the shocked fireball have velocities differing by @xmath106 , where @xmath28 is an average value representative of the entire fireball .
different shells emitted at times differing by @xmath29 therefore collide with each other after a time @xmath107 , i.e. at a radius @xmath108 .
a detailed account of the kinematics can be found in halzen & hooper 2002 .
we can now compare the synchrotron loss time with the time over which the pions decay : @xmath109 here @xmath110 is the fraction of internal energy converted to electrons , @xmath111s is the time scale of fluctuations in the grb lightcurve , @xmath112erg / s is the @xmath1-ray luminosity of the grb and @xmath113ev , is the pion energy . in deriving eq.([t_syn ] ) we have assumed that the wind luminosity carried by internal plasma energy , @xmath114 , is related to the observed @xmath1-ray luminosity through @xmath115 .
this assumption is justified because the electron synchrotron cooling time is short compared to the wind expansion time and hence electrons lose all their energy radiatively .
the radiative losses become important for @xmath116 , which corresponds to @xmath117 , where @xmath118 neutrinos from muon decay have a lifetime 100 times longer than pions , the energy cutoff will therefore be 10 times smaller : @xmath119 above this energy , the slope of the neutrino spectrum steepens by two to ( @xmath120 ) . to normalize the neutrino spectrum to the observed grb luminosity , we must calculate the fraction , @xmath83 , of fireball proton energy lost to pion production .
the fraction of energy converted to pions is estimated from the ratio of the size of the shock , @xmath121 , and the mean free path of a proton for photomeson interactions : @xmath122 here , the proton mean free path is given by @xmath123 where @xmath124 is the number density of photons .
the photon number density is given by the ratio of the photon energy density and the photon energy in the comoving frame : @xmath125 using these equations , and recalling that @xmath126 , we obtain that @xmath127 and the fraction of proton energy converted to @xmath87 s is @xmath128 this derivation was performed for protons at the break energy . in general , @xmath129 where @xmath130 is given by eq.([eq : epb ] ) . as we can see from eq.([eq : fpi1 ] ) , @xmath83 strongly depends on the bulk lorentz factor @xmath28 .
it has been pointed out by halzen & hooper ( 1999 ) and alvarez , halzen & hooper ( 2000 ) that , if the lorentz factor @xmath28 varies significantly between bursts , then the resulting neutrino flux will be dominated by a few bright bursts with @xmath83 close to unity .
however , guetta , spada & waxman ( 2001a ) have shown that burst - to - burst variations in the fraction of fireball energy converted to neutrinos are constrained .
first , the observational constraints imposed by @xmath1-ray observations , in particular the requirement @xmath131 mev , imply that wind model parameters @xmath132 ) are correlated ( guetta , spada & waxman 2001b ) and that @xmath28 is restricted to values in a range much narrower than @xmath133 .
for instance , for values of @xmath1 much smaller than average the fireball becomes very dense with abundant neutrino production .
such fireballs will also produce a thermal photon spectrum which is not the case for the events considered here .
second , for wind parameters that yield @xmath83 values significantly exceeding 20% , only a small fraction of pion energy is converted to neutrinos because of pion and muon synchrotron losses as can be seen from e q.([eq : synclos ] ) .
we will use two methods to determine the value of the bulk lorentz factor , @xmath28 . for bursts with high break energies , @xmath134 kev ,
@xmath28 can not differ significantly from the minimum value for which the fireball pair production optical depth is @xmath135 near the maximum energy of @xmath1-rays produced , @xmath136 .
egret has observed @xmath1-rays with energies in excess of 1 gev for six bursts , although the maximum @xmath1-ray energy should be lower for the majority of grbs .
we choose 100 mev as the default value , therefore , @xmath137^{1/6}. \label{eq : gammamin}\ ] ] note that in the end , the value of the lorentz factor depends weakly on luminosity , time structure and maximum @xmath1-ray energy . for bursts with lower break energies
eq.([eq : gamma ] ) may not be reliable because the lorentz factor of these grbs may be larger than estimated .
guetta spada & waxman ( 2001b ) have argued that the x - ray flashes identified by bepposax could be produced by relativistic winds where the lorentz factor is larger than the minimum value given in eq.([eq : gamma ] ) required to produce a grb with the characteristic photon spectrum . for grbs with low break energy
we , instead , relate the lorentz factor to the peak energy of the @xmath1-ray spectrum .
the characteristic frequency of synchrotron emission is determined by the minimum electron lorentz factor @xmath138 and by the strength of the magnetic field given above , before eq.([t_syn ] ) .
the characteristic energy of synchrotron photons , @xmath139 , at the source redshift is @xmath140 for bursts with @xmath141 kev we will evaluate @xmath28 from the break photon energy given above . at present
no theory allows the determination of the values of the equipartition fractions @xmath110 and @xmath102 .
eq.([eq : epeak ] ) implies that fractions not far below unity are required to account for the observed @xmath1 ray emission and this is confirmed also by simulations ( guetta spada & waxman 2001b ) . for bursts with very large values of @xmath28 ,
the peak energy is shifted to values lower than @xmath142 kev .
this could be the x - ray bursts detected by bepposax ( guetta spada & waxman 2001b ) . from eq.([eq : fpi1 ] ) , we estimate that the neutrino flux from such events is expected to be small .
we have now collected all the information to derive the neutrino from the observed @xmath1-ray fluency @xmath143 : @xmath144 batse detectors measure the grb fluence @xmath143 over two decades of photon energies , @xmath145 mev to @xmath0 2 mev , corresponding to a decade of energy of the radiating electrons .
the factor 1/8 takes into account that charged and neutral pions are produced with roughly equal probabilities , and each neutrino carries @xmath146 of the pion energy .
using eq.([eq : fpi2 ] ) , @xmath147 where @xmath148 and @xmath149 are given by eq.([eq : enub ] ) , eq.([eq : synclos ] ) and eq.([eq : synclos2 ] ) .
this spectrum is shown in fig.([fig2a ] ) .
this result depends on a number of somewhat tenuous assumptions .
simulations ( gsw ) actually suggest that one can simply fix @xmath150 at the break energy and derive the @xmath11 flux directly from the @xmath1-flux .
doing better may require a better understanding of the fireball phenomenology than we have now .
first , the variability time may be shorter than what is observed ; in most cases variability is only measured to the smallest time scale that can be detected with adequate statistics .
second , the parameters @xmath151 and @xmath152 are uncertain .
third , the luminosity - variability relation used to derive the luminosity for bursts with no measured redshift ( see [ zknown ] ) is uncertain , and in addition may have large fluctuations around the prediction .
we have therefore decided to do the detailed analysis described above as well as an alternative analysis that assumes @xmath54 , at the break energy , for all bursts and determines the neutrino flux directly from the observed gamma - ray fluence . for this alternative approach ,
@xmath153 we refer to the models based on eq.([eq : nuflux2 ] ) and eq.([eq : nuflux1 ] ) as models 1 and 2 , respectively . in fig .
[ fig2a ] we show the muon neutrino spectrum for our fiducial parameters in models 1 and 2 .
in this section , we consider the neutrino photoproduction on external photons in supranova grbs ( guetta & granot 2002a ) . the external radiation field surrounding the final black hole
is referred to as the pulsar wind bubble ( pwb ) .
a pulsar wind bubble is formed when the relativistic wind ( consisting of relativistic particles and magnetic fields ) that emanates from a pulsar is abruptly decelerated ( typically , to a newtonian velocity ) in a strong relativistic shock , due to interaction with the ambient medium .
fractions of the post - shock energy density go to the magnetic field , the electrons and the protons , respectively .
the electrons will lose energy through synchrotron emission and inverse - compton ( ic ) scattering . in
( guetta & granot 2003 ) a deep study of the characteristic features of the plerion emission has been carried out . as shown in ( guetta & granot 2003 )
, the electrons are in the fast cooling regime for relevant values of @xmath4 , and therefore most of the emission takes place within a small radial interval just behind the wind termination shock .
the mechanism for neutrino production through photomeson interaction with the external photons dominates when the lifetime of the supramassive neutron star , @xmath5yr ( or @xmath6yr for x - ray flashes ) .
neutrinos generated in this way have typical energies @xmath7ev ( @xmath154ev for x - ray flashes ) . as in models 1 and 2 ,
these neutrinos are emitted simultaneously with the prompt @xmath1-ray ( x - ray ) emission . for even shorter lifetimes @xmath10yr , the @xmath11 s would not be accompanied by a detectable grb because the thomson optical depth on the pwb is larger than unity .
as before , protons of energy @xmath155 interact mostly with photons that satisfy the @xmath88-resonance condition , @xmath156 , where , in this case , @xmath157 is the pwb photon energy .
the minimum photon energy for photomeson interactions corresponds to the maximum proton energy @xmath158ev . for reasonable model parameters ( @xmath159yr )
this energy exceeds self absorption frequency of the pwb spectrum ( guetta & granot 2003 ) .
moreover , for @xmath160 yr the electrons are in fast cooling and emit synchrotron radiation .
therefore the relevant part of the spectrum consists of two power laws , @xmath161 for @xmath162 and @xmath163 for @xmath164 , where @xmath165hz is the peak frequency of the pwb spectral energy distribution @xmath166 , @xmath124 is the number density of photons and @xmath167 is the power law index of the pwb electrons .
the normalization factor of the target photon number density is determined by equating the pulsar wind luminosity in pairs , @xmath168 ( @xmath169 is the fraction of the pulsar wind energy in the @xmath170 component and @xmath171 is the total energy of the pulsar wind ) to the total energy output in photons , which is @xmath172 at @xmath173 , where @xmath174 is the radius of the pulsar wind termination shock , which is a factor , @xmath175 , smaller than the pwb radius , @xmath176 . at @xmath177 , which is relevant for our case , the photons are roughly isotropic and
@xmath178 becomes roughly constant , and assumes the value @xmath179 . as we mentioned above
, the relevant target photons for photomeson interaction with high energy protons are the synchrotron photons and the fraction of the total photon energy that goes into the synchrotron component is @xmath180 , where @xmath181 and @xmath182 are the fractions of the pwb energy in the electrons and in magnetic field , respectively .
this spectrum is consistent with the spectrum of known plerions like the crab , that can be well fit by emission from a power law distribution with a power law index value @xmath183 . in our case ,
the only difference is that there is a fast cooling synchrotron spectrum , rather than a slow cooling one .
there are no observations of the spectrum from very young plerions where there is a fast cooling spectrum ( as they are more rare ) .
this radiation will be typically hard to detect ( for @xmath184 yr and @xmath185 ) , but might be detected for closer ( though rarer ) pwbs .
the proton energy satisfying the @xmath88-resonance condition with pwb photons of energy @xmath186 , is @xmath187 where @xmath188yr , @xmath189 is the velocity of the snr shell ( in units of @xmath190 ) , @xmath191erg , @xmath192 is the lorentz factor of the pulsar wind , @xmath193 , @xmath194 , @xmath195 , and @xmath196 is the fraction of the wind energy that remains in the pwb .
the latter is the fraction that goes into the proton component and is , unlike the electron component , not radiated away .
the corresponding neutrino energy is @xmath197 . for @xmath198yr ,
this energy is similar to those obtained in interactions with grb photons in the previous section .
photon emission is only detected in coincidence with these neutrinos if the thompson optical depth is @xmath199 , which is the case for @xmath198yr and a clumpy snr ( guetta & granot 2003 ; inoue , guetta & pacini 2003 ) . in the case of a uniform shell
the condition is @xmath200yr , corresponding to @xmath201ev . as before ,
the internal shocks occur over a distance @xmath202 .
thus , the optical depth for photo - pion production by protons of energy @xmath155 , is @xmath203 where @xmath92 , @xmath204s , @xmath205 , @xmath206 , @xmath207 and @xmath71 is the spectral slope of the seed pwb synchrotron photons with @xmath208 ( @xmath209 ) for @xmath210 ( @xmath211 ) .
the fraction of the proton energy that is lost to pion production is given by @xmath212 \approx\min\left[1,\tau_{p\gamma}(\varepsilon_p)/5\right]\ .\ ] ] the factor of 5 , as before , takes into account that the proton loses @xmath213 of its energy in a single interaction .
we denote @xmath214 for which @xmath215 by @xmath216ev [ i.e. @xmath217 , and obtain @xmath218 as before , the decay of charged pions created in interactions between pwb photons and grb protons , produces high energy neutrinos , @xmath219 , where each neutrino receives @xmath220 of the proton energy .
the total energy of the protons accelerated in the internal shocks is expected to be similar to the @xmath1-ray energy produced in the grb ( waxman 1995 ) .
this implies a @xmath221 fluence , @xmath222 @xmath223 where @xmath224erg is the isotropic equivalent energy in @xmath1-rays , @xmath225 , while @xmath226 is given in eq.([f_pg_grb ] ) and @xmath227 is the fraction of the original pion energy , @xmath228 , that remains after decay .
the pions may lose energy via synchrotron or inverse compton ( ic ) emission .
if these energy losses are significant , then the energy of the neutrinos will be reduced as well .
following arguments already presented in appendix a , we find that @xmath229 , where @xmath230s is the lifetime of the pion , and @xmath231 is the time for radiative losses due to both synchrotron and ic losses .
the time , @xmath232 , is given by eq.([t_sync ] ) and @xmath233 where @xmath234 is the energy density of photons below the klein - nishina limit , @xmath235 .
ic losses due to scattering of the grb photons were shown to be unimportant ( waxman & bahcall 1997 ) .
we therefore only consider the ic losses from the upscattering of the external pwb photons , and find @xmath236 where @xmath110 and @xmath102 are the equipartition parameters of the grb , and @xmath113ev .
the radiative losses become important for @xmath237 , which corresponds to @xmath238 , where @xmath239 the protons may also lose energy via @xmath240 interactions with the grb photons ( waxman & bahcall 1997 ) .
however @xmath241 for this process is typically @xmath242 , so that it does not have a large effect on @xmath243 interactions with the pwb photons , on which we focus .
because the lifetime of the muons is @xmath244100 times longer than that of the pions , they experience significant radiative losses at an energy of @xmath245 .
this causes a reduction of up to a factor of @xmath246 in the total neutrino flux in the range @xmath247 , since only @xmath221 that are produced directly in @xmath248 decay contribute significantly to the neutrino flux .
note that since both ratios in eqs .
( [ t_syn ] ) and ( [ t_ic ] ) scale as @xmath249 , we always have @xmath250 , and therefore , the spectrum steepens by a factor of @xmath251 for @xmath252 .
this is evident because @xmath253 . in figure [ fig1 ]
we show the proton energies that correspond to the neutrino break energies @xmath254 , @xmath255 and @xmath256 , as a function of @xmath4 . from eq .
( [ tau_pg_grb ] ) , ( [ e_syn ] ) and ( [ e_ic ] ) , we conclude that @xmath257 , while @xmath258 and @xmath259 . for a fixed value of @xmath260
, @xmath261 implies @xmath262 and @xmath263ev , while @xmath264 implies @xmath265 .
this implies increased neutrino emission reaching higher energies for larger values of @xmath28 .
since large @xmath28 implies lower synchrotron frequency for the prompt grb , this may be relevant to x - ray flashes , assuming that they are indeed grbs with relatively large lorentz factors and/or a large variability time , @xmath29 ( guetta , spada & waxman 2001b ) .
as can be seen from figure [ fig1 ] , depending on the relevant parameters , there are four different orderings of these break energies : ( i ) @xmath266 , ( ii ) @xmath267 , ( iii ) @xmath268 and ( iv ) @xmath269 .
each of these results in a different spectrum consisting of 3 or 4 power laws .
analytically these spectra are : @xmath270^{2 } } } = \left\{\begin{array}{lll } ( \varepsilon_{\nu}/ \varepsilon_{\nu\tau})^{s/2 } & \ \ \varepsilon_{\nu}<\varepsilon_{\nu\tau}\\ 1 & \ \
\varepsilon_{\nu\tau}<\varepsilon_{\nu}<\varepsilon_{\nu s}\\ ( \varepsilon_{\nu}/\varepsilon_{\nu s})^{-2 } & \ \
\varepsilon_{\nu}>\varepsilon_{\nu s } \end{array}\right .
\ , \ ] ] @xmath271^{2 } } } = \left\{\begin{array}{lll}\sqrt{\varepsilon_{\nu b}\over\varepsilon_{\nu\tau } } \left({\varepsilon_{\nu}\over\varepsilon_{\nu b}}\right)^{s\over 2 } & \ \
\varepsilon_{\nu}<\varepsilon_{\nu b}\\ ( \varepsilon_{\nu}/\varepsilon_{\nu\tau})^{1/2 } & \ \ \varepsilon_{\nu b}<\varepsilon_{\nu}<\varepsilon_{\nu\tau}\\ 1 & \ \
\varepsilon_{\nu\tau}<\varepsilon_{\nu}<\varepsilon_{\nu s}\\ ( \varepsilon_{\nu}/\varepsilon_{\nu s})^{-2 } & \
\ \varepsilon_{\nu}>\varepsilon_{\nu s}\end{array}\right .
\ , \ ] ]
@xmath272 @xmath273(\varepsilon_{\nu s}/\varepsilon_{\nu b})^{s/2 } \sqrt{\varepsilon_{\nu b}/\varepsilon_{\nu\tau}}}= \left\{\begin{array}{lll } ( \varepsilon_{\nu}/\varepsilon_{\nu s})^{s/2 } & \ \
\varepsilon_{\nu}<\varepsilon_{\nu s}\\ ( \varepsilon_{\nu}/\varepsilon_{\nu s})^{(s-4)/2 } & \ \
\varepsilon_{\nu s}<\varepsilon_{\nu}<\varepsilon_{\nu b}\\ \left({\varepsilon_{\nu b}\over\varepsilon_{\nu s}}\right)^{(s-4)/2 } \left({\varepsilon_{\nu}\over\varepsilon_{\nu b}}\right)^{-3/2 } & \ \ \varepsilon_{\nu b}<\varepsilon_{\nu}<\varepsilon_{\nu\tau}\\ \left({\varepsilon_{\nu b}\over\varepsilon_{\nu s}}\right)^{s-4\over 2 } \left({\varepsilon_{\nu b}\over\varepsilon_{\nu\tau}}\right)^{3\over 2 } \left({\varepsilon_{\nu\tau}\over\varepsilon_{\nu}}\right)^{2 } & \ \
\varepsilon_{\nu}>\varepsilon_{\nu\tau } \end{array}\right .
\ .\ ] ] for our analysis we consider two characteristic values of @xmath4 , 0.07 yr and 0.4 yr , and refer to the models as 3 and 4 , respectively . in the case of model 3 , the grb is seen only if the shell is sufficiently clumpy while in model 4 the grb should always be detectable .
the muon neutrino spectrum is shown in figure [ fig2 ] for our fiducial parameters and @xmath274yr .
the spectrum of the other neutrino flavors is the same .
a compilation of the probability that a grb neutrino is actually detected as a muon , a tau or a shower by an underground detector is shown in fig.4 as a function of the neutrino energy .
these are required to convert neutrino spectra from grbs to event rates .
we present in this appendix the formalism for doing this conversion .
the number of shower events in an underground detector from a neutrino flux @xmath275 produced by a single grb with duration @xmath276 is given by @xmath277 where @xmath278 is the zenith angle ( @xmath279 is vertically downward ) .
the sum is over neutrino ( and anti - neutrino ) flavors @xmath280 and interactions @xmath281 ( charged current ) and nc ( neutral current ) .
@xmath282 is the detector s cross sectional area with respect to the @xmath11 flux , and @xmath283 is the differential neutrino flux that reaches the earth . for @xmath284 , [ rate ]
is modified to include the effects of regeneration of neutrinos propagating through the earth , as will be discussed further on .
@xmath285 is the probability that a neutrino reaches the detector , i.e. is not absorbed by the earth .
it is given by @xmath286 \ , \label{survival}\ ] ] where @xmath287 , and the total neutrino interaction cross section is @xmath288 this is somewhat conservative because it neglects the possibility of a neutrino interacting via a nc interaction and subsequently creating a shower in the detector .
@xmath289 is the column density of material a neutrino with zenith angle @xmath278 must traverse to reach the detector .
it depends on the depth of the detector and is given by @xmath290 the path length along direction @xmath278 weighted by the earth s density @xmath291 at distance @xmath292 from the earth s center . for the earth s density profile
we adopt the piecewise continuous density function @xmath293 of the preliminary earth model ( dziewonski 1989 ) .
@xmath294 is the probability that the neutrino interacts in the detector .
it is given by @xmath295 \
, \ ] ] where , for showers , @xmath40 is the linear dimension of the detector , and @xmath296 is the mean free path for neutrino interaction of type @xmath297 . for realistic detectors , @xmath298 , and so @xmath299 .
to an excellent approximation the event rate scales linearly with detector volume @xmath300 .
the inelasticity parameter @xmath301 is the fraction of the initial neutrino energy carried by the hadronic shower ( rather than the primary lepton ) .
the limits of integration depend on the type of interaction and on the neutrino flavor . for nc @xmath302 interactions and all @xmath221 and @xmath303 interactions , @xmath304 and @xmath305 , where @xmath306 is the threshold energy for shower detection . for cc @xmath302 interactions , the outgoing electron also showers , therefore @xmath304 and @xmath307 .
energetic muons are produced in @xmath221 cc interactions . for a muon to be detected
, it must reach the detector with an energy above its threshold @xmath308 .
the expression of eq.([rate ] ) then also describes the number of muon events after the replacement @xmath309 \ , \ ] ] where @xmath310 is the range of a muon with initial energy @xmath311 and final energy @xmath308 .
we will assume that muons lose energy continuously according to @xmath312 where @xmath313 and @xmath314 ( dutta et al . 2001 ) .
the muon range is then @xmath315 \ . \label{murange}\ ] ] in this case , @xmath316 and @xmath317 .
the event rate for muons is enhanced by the possibility that muons reach the detector , even if produced in neutrino interactions kilometers from its location . note , however , that this enhancement ( i.e. @xmath310 ) is @xmath278-dependent : for nearly vertical down - going paths , the path length of the muon is limited by the amount of matter above the detector , not by the muon s range .
this is taken into account in the simulations .
fig.[fig5 ] shows the probability of detecting a muon generated by a muon neutrino as a function of the incidence zenith angle .
the figure illustrates the effect of the limited amount of matter above the detector , as well as the neutrino absorption in the earth .
absorption is not important at @xmath318 tev , and the muon range at this energy ( for a muon energy threshold of 500 gev as we adopted in the figure ) is not limited by the amount of matter above the detector . as a consequence the probability at 1 tev is weakly dependent on zenith angle .
absorption in the earth starts to be important for upgoing neutrinos of energy above @xmath82 tev - 1 pev , and restricts the neutrino observation to the horizontal and downward directions at extremely high energy ( eev range ) as can be seen in the figure .
the large muon range at pev and eev energies , much larger than the depth at which the detector is located ( 1.8 km vertical depth ) , reduces considerably the detection probability of downgoing neutrinos . the largest background to a grb signal consists of muons from atmospheric neutrinos .
however , for grb observations , the time and angular windows are very small and this background can be easily controlled , as we will illustrate .
following ( dermer & atoyan 2003 ) , the number of background events is approximately given by @xmath319 where @xmath320 and @xmath321 are the solid angle and time considered , respectively , and @xmath322 is the probability of a muon neutrino generating a muon in the detector volume .
icecube is designed to have angular resolution smaller than 1 degree at the relevant energies .
we consider a 1 degree cone for the solid angle calculation . considering a long burst of duration @xmath82 seconds , and using the following approximate atmospheric neutrino spectrum @xmath323 we find that for a natural threshold ( minimum energy ) of @xmath324gev , we expect @xmath325 background events per burst .
more practically , an energy threshold in the range of 1 - 10 tev could be imposed which would reduce this background by an addition factor of 50 to 2500 , respectively . for a naive illustration ,
consider one years of observation , with 1000 bursts , each of duration of 10 seconds and a 1 tev energy threshold imposed .
for such a example , less than 0.01 total background events are predicted .
taus are produced only by cc @xmath303 interactions .
this process differs significantly from the muon case because tau neutrinos are regenerated by the production and subsequent tau decay through @xmath326 ( halzen & saltzberg 1998 ) . as a result , for tau neutrinos , cc and nc interactions in the earth do not deplete the @xmath303 flux , they only reduce the neutrino energy down to a value where , eventually , the earth becomes transparent .
we implement this important effect using a dedicated simulation that determines @xmath327 , the average energy of the @xmath303 when reaching the detector .
it depends on the initial energy @xmath328 and zenith angle @xmath278 .
the tau event rate is then given by @xmath329 @xmath294 depends on the geometry of the neutrino tau induced event . for events consisting on a minimum - ionizing track going through the detector it is given by : @xmath330 \label{eq : pint_tau}\ ] ] where @xmath331 is the range of the produced tau evaluated at the energy of the tau after regeneration .
@xmath332 is given by eq.([murange ] ) with @xmath333 ( dutta et al .
the last factor takes into account the requirement that the tau track be long enough to be identified in the detector .
we require @xmath334gev so that the tau decay length is larger than the 125 m string spacing in icecube .
it is not clear with what efficiency through - going tau events can be separated from low energy muons . those tau events that include one shower ( lollipop events ) or two showers ( double bang events ) inside the detector volume will be identifiable .
for these cases we use @xmath294 obtained by a dedicated simulation that determines the probabilities for double bang and lollipop geometries shown in fig.([fig4 ] ) .
the rate of downgoing lollipop events in a km@xmath335 neutrino telescope is expected to be of the order of the rate of down - going shower events , probably slightly smaller .
double bang events will be mostly observed for neutrino energies in a limited range between roughly 10 and 100 pev .
finally , those events in which the tau decays into muons that reach the detector are counted as muon events .
@xmath294 is given by eq.([eq : pint_tau ] ) where we use as range the sum of the range of the tau evaluated at the regeneration energy and the range of the muon at the energy that carries in the decay of the tau .
as with muons , at very high energies taus can travel several kilometers before decaying or suffering significant energy loss .
the enhancement to tau event rates from this effect is @xmath278-dependent as discussed above for muons .
heise , j. , zand , j. j. , kippen , m. & woods , p. , gamma - ray bursts in the afterglow era , proceedings of the international workshop held in rome , cnr headquarters , 17 - 20 october , 2000 . edited by enrico costa , filippo frontera , and jens hjorth .
berlin heidelberg : springer , 2001 , p. 16 .
astro - ph/0111246 .
paciesas , w. s. , preece , r. d. briggs , m. s. & mallozzi , r. s. , gamma - ray bursts in the afterglow era , proceedings of the international workshop held in rome , cnr headquarters , 17 - 20 october , 2000 . edited by enrico costa , filippo frontera , and jens hjorth .
berlin heidelberg : springer , 2001 , p. 13 .
astro - ph/0109053 .
reichart d. e. & lamb , d. q. , gamma - ray bursts in the afterglow era , proceedings of the international workshop held in rome , cnr headquarters , 17 - 20 october , 2000 . edited by enrico costa , filippo frontera , and jens hjorth .
berlin heidelberg : springer , 2001 , p. 233 .
astro - ph/0103254 .
gamma - ray bursts in the afterglow era , proceedings of the international workshop held in rome , cnr headquarters , 17 - 20 october , 2000 . edited by enrico costa , filippo frontera , and jens hjorth .
berlin heidelberg : springer , 2001 , p. 263 .
the distribution of ( a ) redshifts , ( b ) lorentz factors , ( c ) fluences and ( d ) zenith angles ( for muon events : dotted line corresponds to model 1 , solid line to model 2 ) for long duration grbs . in ( a ) , the decrease at large redshift is due to sampling bias .
the lorentz factors in ( b ) were calculated as described by eqs .
[ eq : gamma ] and [ eq : epeak ] . frame ( d ) demonstrates the advantages of long muon range and poor absorption near the horizon for muon track detection.,width=529 ] the distribution of the estimated number of muon events from individual ( a ) long duration grbs ( the dotted line corresponds to model 1 and the solid line to model 2 ) and ( b ) x - ray flash candidates ( dotted line corresponds to model 3 and the solid line to model 4 ) .
note that the majority of events result from a relatively small number of grbs.,width=529 ] the muon neutrino spectrum , @xmath336 , for our fiducial parameters in models 1 and 2 ( interactions with grb photons ) .
the solid line is for a typical grb with @xmath337 and @xmath47 ms , while the dashed line is for a x - ray flash candidate with @xmath338 ( calculated from eq .
[ eq : epeak ] ) and @xmath339 ms.,width=529 ] the muon neutrino spectrum , @xmath336 , for our fiducial parameters in models 3 and 4 ( interactions with pwb photons ) .
four choices of @xmath274yr are used , which correspond to the 4 different orderings of the break energies .
this figure is taken from guetta & granot 2002a , width=529 ] the probabilities of a neutrino generating various types of events when traveling through the effective area of a neutrino telescope .
curves are shown for various choices of zenith angle , which reflects enhancements due to long muon range and the effect of absorption in the earth.,width=529 ] the probability of a muon neutrino generating a detectable muon as a function of zenith angle .
the curves show the probabilities for three representative neutrino energies : @xmath341 ev , @xmath342 ev and @xmath343 ev.,width=529 ] | we estimate the neutrino emission from individual gamma - ray bursts observed by the batse detector on the compton gamma - ray observatory .
neutrinos are produced by photoproduction of pions when protons interact with photons in the region where the kinetic energy of the relativistic fireball is dissipated allowing the acceleration of electrons and protons .
we also consider models where neutrinos are predominantly produced on the radiation surrounding the newly formed black hole . from the observed redshift and photon flux of each individual burst ,
we compute the neutrino flux in a variety of models based on the assumption that equal kinetic energy is dissipated into electrons and protons . where not measured , the redshift is estimated by other methods . unlike previous calculations of the universal diffuse neutrino flux produced by all gamma - ray bursts , the individual fluxes ( compiled at http://www.arcetri.astro.it/@xmath0 dafne / grb/ ) can be directly compared with coincident observations by the amanda telescope at the south pole . because of its large statistics , our predictions are likely to be representative for future observations with larger neutrino telescopes . |
in a typical instance of a combinatorial optimization problem the underlying constraints model a static application frozen in one time step . in many applications
however , one needs to solve instances of the combinatorial optimization problem that changes over time . while this is naturally handled by re - solving the optimization problem in each time step separately , changing the solution one holds from one time step to the next often incurs a transition cost .
consider , for example , the problem faced by a vendor who needs to get supply of an item from @xmath10 different producers to meet her demand . on any given day
, she could get prices from each of the producers and pick the @xmath10 cheapest ones to buy from .
as prices change , this set of the @xmath10 cheapest producers may change .
however , there is a fixed cost to starting and/or ending a relationship with any new producer .
the goal of the vendor is to minimize the sum total of these two costs : an `` acquisition cost '' @xmath11 to be incurred each time she starts a new business relationship with a producer , and a per period cost @xmath12 of buying in period @xmath2 from the each of the @xmath10 producers that she picks in this period , summed over @xmath13 time periods . in this work
we consider a generalization of this problem , where the constraint `` pick @xmath10 producers '' may be replaced by a more general combinatorial constraint .
it is natural to ask whether simple combinatorial problems for which the one - shot problem is easy to solve , as the example above is , also admit good algorithms for the multistage version .
the first problem we study is the _ multistage matroid maintenance _ problem ( ) , where the underlying combinatorial constraint is that of maintaining a base of a given matroid in each period . in the example above , the requirement the vendor buys from @xmath10 different producers could be expressed as optimizing over the @xmath14uniform matroid . in a more interesting case
one may want to maintain a spanning tree of a given graph at each step , where the edge costs @xmath12 change over time , and an acquisition cost of @xmath11 has to paid every time a new edge enters the spanning tree .
( a formal definition of the problem appears in section [ sec : formal - defs ] . )
while our emphasis is on the online problem , we will mention results for the offline version as well , where the whole input is given in advance . a first observation we make
is that if the matroid in question is allowed to be different in each time period , then the problem is hard to approximate to any non - trivial factor ( see section [ sec : time - varying ] ) even in the offline case .
we therefore focus on the case where the same matroid is given at each time period .
thus we restrict ourselves to the case when the matroid is the same for all time steps . to set the baseline , we first study the offline version of the problem ( in section [ sec : offline ] ) , where all the input parameters are known in advance .
we show an lp - rounding algorithm which approximates the total cost up to a logarithmic factor .
this approximation factor is no better than that using a simple greedy algorithm , but it will be useful to see the rounding algorithm , since we will use its extension in the online setting .
we also show a matching hardness reduction , proving that the problem is hard to approximate to better than a logarithmic factor ; this hardness holds even for the special case of spanning trees in graphs .
we then turn to the online version of the problem , where in each time period , we learn the costs @xmath12 of each element that is available at time @xmath2 , and we need to pick a base @xmath15 of the matroid for this period . we analyze the performance of our online algorithm in the competitive analysis framework : i.e. , we compare the cost of the online algorithm to that of the optimum solution to the offline instance thus generated . in section [ sec : online ] , we give an efficient randomized @xmath16-competitive algorithm for this problem against any oblivious adversary ( here @xmath17 is the universe for the matroid and @xmath6 is the rank of the matroid ) , and show that no polynomial - time online algorithm can do better .
we also show that the requirement that the algorithm be randomized is necessary : any deterministic algorithm must incur an overhead of @xmath18 , even for the simplest of matroids . our results above crucially relied on the properties of matriods , and
it is natural to ask if we can handle more general set systems , e.g. , @xmath19-systems . in section [ sec : matchings ] , we consider the case where the combinatorial object we need to find each time step is a perfect matching in a graph .
somewhat surprisingly , the problem here is significantly harder than the matroid case , even in the offline case . in particular
, we show that even when the number of periods is a constant , no polynomial time algorithm can achieve an approximation ratio better than @xmath20 for any constant @xmath21 .
we first show that the problem , which is a packing - covering problem , can be reduced to the analogous problem of maintaining a spanning set of a matroid .
we call the latter the _ multistage spanning set maintenance _ ( ) problem .
while the reduction itself is fairly clean , it is surprisingly powerful and is what enables us to improve on previous works .
the problem is a covering problem , so it admits better approximation ratios and allows for a much larger toolbox of techniques at our disposal .
we note that this is the only place where we need the matroid to not change over time : our algorithms for work when the matroids change over time , and even when considering matroid intersections .
the problem is then further reduced to the case where the holding cost of an element is in @xmath22 , this reduction simplifies the analysis . in the offline case , we present two algorithms . we first observe that a greedy algorithm easily gives an @xmath23-approximation .
we then present a simple randomized rounding algorithm for the linear program .
this is analyzed using recent results on contention resolution schemes @xcite , and gives an approximation of @xmath24 , which can be improved to @xmath25 when the acquisition costs are uniform .
this lp - rounding algorithm will be an important constituent of our algorithm for the online case .
for the online case we again use that the problem can be written as a covering problem , even though the natural lp formulation has both covering and packing constraints . phrasing it as a covering problem ( with box constraints )
enables us to use , as a black - box , results on online algorithms for the fractional problem @xcite
. this formulation however has exponentially many constraints .
we handle that by showing a method of adaptively picking violated constraints such that only a small number of constraints are ever picked .
the crucial insight here is that if @xmath26 is such that @xmath27 is not feasible , then @xmath26 is at least @xmath28 away in @xmath29 distance from any feasible solution ; in fact there is a single constraint that is violated to an extent half .
this insight allows us to make non - trivial progress ( using a natural potential function ) every time we bring in a constraint , and lets us bound the number of constraints we need to add until constraints are satisfied by @xmath27 .
our work is related to several lines of research , and extends some of them .
the paging problem is a special case of where the underlying matroid is a uniform one .
our online algorithm generalizes the @xmath30-competitive algorithm for weighted caching @xcite , using existing online lp solvers in a black - box fashion .
going from uniform to general matroids loses a logarithmic factor ( after rounding ) , we show such a loss is unavoidable unless we use exponential time .
the problem is also a special case of classical metrical task systems @xcite ; see @xcite for more recent work .
the best approximations for metrical task systems are poly - logarithmic in the size of the metric space . in our case
the metric space is specified by the total number of bases of the matroid which is often exponential , so these algorithms only give a trivial approximation . in trying to unify online learning and competitive analysis , buchbinder et al .
@xcite consider a problem on matroids very similar to ours .
the salient differences are : ( a ) in their model all acquisition costs are the same , and ( b ) they work with fractional bases instead of integral ones .
they give an @xmath31-competitive algorithm to solve the fractional online lp with uniform acquisition costs ( among other unrelated results ) .
our online lp solving generalizes their result to arbitrary acquisition costs .
they leave open the question of getting integer solutions online ( seffi naor , private communication ) , which we present in this work . in a more recent work , buchbinder , chen and naor @xcite use a regularization approach to solving a broader set of fractional problems , but once again can do not get integer solutions in a setting such as ours .
shachnai et al .
@xcite consider `` reoptimization '' problems : given a starting solution and a new instance , they want to balance the transition cost and the cost on the new instance .
this is a two - timestep version of our problem , and the short time horizon raises a very different set of issues ( since the output solution does not need to itself hedge against possible subsequent futures ) .
they consider a number of optimization / scheduling problems in their framework .
cohen et al .
@xcite consider several problems in the framework of the stability - versus - fit tradeoff ; e.g. , that of finding `` stable '' solutions which given the previous solution , like in reoptimization , is the current solution that maximizes the quality minus the transition costs .
they show maintaining stable solutions for matroids becomes a repeated two - stage reoptimization problem ; their problem is poly - time solvable , whereas matroid problems in our model become np - hard .
the reason is that the solution for two time steps does not necessarily lead to a base from which it is easy to move in subsequent time steps , as our hardness reduction shows .
they consider a multistage offline version of their problem ( again maximizing fit minus stability ) which is very similar in spirit and form to our ( minimization ) problem , though the minus sign in the objective function makes it difficult to approximate in cases which are not in poly - time . in dynamic steiner tree maintenance @xcite where the goal is to maintain an approximately optimal steiner tree for a varying instance ( where terminals are added ) while changing few edges at each time step . in dynamic load balancing
@xcite one has to maintain a good scheduling solution while moving a small number of jobs around .
the work on lazy experts in the online prediction community @xcite also deals with similar concerns .
there is also work on `` leasing '' problems @xcite : these are optimization problems where elements can be obtained for an interval of any length , where the cost is concave in the lengths ; the instance changes at each timestep .
the main differences are that the solution only needs to be feasible at each timestep ( i.e. , the holding costs are @xmath32 ) , and that any element can be leased for any length @xmath33 of time starting at any timestep for a cost that depends only on @xmath33 , which gives these problems a lot of uniformity . in turn , these leasing problems are related to `` buy - at - bulk '' problems .
given reals @xmath34 for elements
@xmath35 , we will use @xmath36 for @xmath37 to denote @xmath38 .
we denote @xmath39 by @xmath40 $ ] .
we assume basic familiarity with matroids : see , e.g. , @xcite for a detailed treatment . given a matroid @xmath41 ,
a _ base _ is a maximum cardinality independent set , and a _ spanning set _ is a set @xmath42 such that @xmath43 ; equivalently , this set contains a base within it .
the _ span _ of a set @xmath44 is @xmath45 .
the _ matroid polytope _
@xmath46 is defined as @xmath47 .
the _ base polytope _ @xmath48 . we will sometimes use @xmath5 to denote @xmath49 and @xmath6 to denote the rank of the matroid .
an instance of the _ multistage matroid maintenance _ ( ) problem consists of a matroid @xmath41 , an _ acquisition cost _
@xmath50 for each @xmath35 , and for every timestep @xmath51 $ ] and element @xmath35 , a _ holding cost _ cost @xmath12 .
the goal is to find bases @xmath52}$ ] to minimize @xmath53 where we define @xmath54 .
a related problem is the _ multistage spanning set maintenance _
( ) problem , where we want to maintain a spanning set @xmath55 at each time , and cost of the solution @xmath56}$ ] ( once again with @xmath57 ) is @xmath58 the following lemma shows the equivalence of maintaining bases and spanning sets .
this enables us to significantly simplify the problem and avoid the difficulties faced by previous works on this problem .
[ lem : pack - cover ] for matroids , the optimal solutions to and have the same costs . clearly , any solution to is also a solution to , since a base is also a spanning set .
conversely , consider a solution @xmath59 to .
set @xmath60 to any base in @xmath61 .
given @xmath62 , start with @xmath63 , and extend it to any base @xmath64 of @xmath15 .
this is the only step where we use the matroid properties indeed , since the matroid is the same at each time , the set @xmath63 remains independent at time @xmath2 , and by the matroid property this independent set can be extended to a base .
observe that this process just requires us to know the base @xmath65 and the set @xmath15 , and hence can be performed in an online fashion .
we claim that the cost of @xmath66 is no more than that of @xmath67 .
indeed , @xmath68 , because @xmath69 .
moreover , let @xmath70 , we pay @xmath71 for these elements we just added . to charge this , consider any such element @xmath72 , let @xmath73 be the time it was most recently added to the cover i.e .
, @xmath74 for all @xmath75 $ ] , but @xmath76 .
the solution paid for including @xmath77 at time @xmath78 , and we charge our acquisition of @xmath77 into @xmath64 to this pair @xmath79 .
it suffices to now observe that we will not charge to this pair again , since the procedure to create @xmath80 ensures we do not drop @xmath77 from the base until it is dropped from @xmath15 itself the next time we pay an addition cost for element @xmath77 , it would have been dropped and added in @xmath81 as well .
hence it suffices to give a good solution to the problem .
we observe that the proof above uses the matroid property crucially and would not hold , e.g. , for matchings .
it also requires that the _ same _ matroid be given at all time steps . also , as noted above , the reduction is online : the instance is the same , and given an solution it can be transformed online to a solution to .
we will find it convenient to think of an instance of as being a matroid @xmath82 , where each element only has an acquisition cost @xmath83 , and it has a lifetime @xmath84 $ ] .
there are no holding costs , but the element @xmath77 can be used in spanning sets only for timesteps @xmath85 . or one can equivalently think of holding costs being zero for @xmath86 and @xmath87 otherwise .
_ an offline exact reduction . _
the translation is the natural one : given instance @xmath88 of , create elements @xmath89 for each @xmath90 and @xmath91 , with acquisition cost @xmath92 , and interval @xmath93 $ ] .
( the matroid is extended in the natural way , where all the elements @xmath89 associated with @xmath77 are parallel to each other . ) the equivalence of the original definition of and this interval view is easy to verify .
_ an online approximate reduction .
_ observe that the above reduction created at most @xmath94 copies of each element , and required knowledge of all the costs .
if we are willing to lose a constant factor in the approximation , we can perform a reduction to the interval model in an _ online _ fashion as follows . for element @xmath35 ,
define @xmath95 , and create many parallel copies @xmath96 of this element ( modifying the matroid appropriately ) .
now the @xmath97 interval for @xmath77 is @xmath98 $ ] , where @xmath99 is set to @xmath100 in case @xmath101 , else it is set to the _ largest _ time such that the total holding costs @xmath102 for this interval @xmath103 $ ] is at most @xmath11 .
this interval @xmath104 is associated with element @xmath105 , which is only available for this interval , at cost @xmath106 .
a few salient points about this reduction : the intervals for an original element @xmath77 now partition the entire time horizon @xmath40 $ ] .
the number of elements in the modified matroid whose intervals contain any time @xmath2 is now only @xmath107 , the same as the original matroid ; each element of the modified matroid is only available for a single interval .
moreover , the reduction can be done online : given the past history and the holding cost for the current time step @xmath2 , we can ascertain whether @xmath2 is the beginning of a new interval ( in which case the previous interval ended at @xmath108 ) and if so , we know the cost of acquiring a copy of @xmath77 for the new interval is @xmath109 .
it is easy to check that the optimal cost in this interval model is within a constant factor of the optimal cost in the original acquisition / holding costs model .
given the reductions of the previous section , we can focus on the problem .
being a covering problem , is conceptually easier to solve : e.g. , we could use algorithms for submodular set cover @xcite with the submodular function being the sum of ranks at each of the timesteps , to get an @xmath23 approximation . in section [ sec : greedy ] , we give a dual - fitting proof of the performance of the greedy algorithm . here
we give an lp - rounding algorithm which gives an @xmath110 approximation ; this can be improved to @xmath25 in the common case where all acquisition costs are unit .
( while the approximation guarantee is no better than that from submodular set cover , this lp - rounding algorithm will prove useful in the online case in section [ sec : online ] ) .
finally , the hardness results of section [ sec : hardness - offline ] show that we can not hope to do much better than these logarithmic approximations .
we now consider an lp - rounding algorithm for the problem ; this will generalize to the online setting , whereas it is unclear how to extend the greedy algorithm to that case .
for the lp rounding , we use the standard definition of the problem to write the following lp relaxation . @xmath111
it remains to round the solution to get a feasible solution to ( i.e. , a spanning set @xmath15 for each time ) with expected cost at most @xmath31 times the lp value , since we can use lemma [ lem : pack - cover ] to convert this to a solution for at no extra cost .
the following lemma is well - known ( see , e.g. @xcite ) .
we give a proof for completeness .
[ lem : alon ] for a fractional base @xmath112 , let @xmath113 be the set obtained by picking each element @xmath35 independently with probability @xmath114
. then @xmath115 \geq r(1 - 1/e)$ ] .
we use the results of chekuri et al .
@xcite ( extending those of chawla et al .
@xcite ) on so - called contention resolution schemes . formally , for a matroid @xmath82 , they give a randomized procedure @xmath116 that takes the random set @xmath113 and outputs an independent set @xmath117 in @xmath82 , such that @xmath118 , and for each element @xmath77 in the support of @xmath119 , @xmath120 \geq ( 1 - 1/e)$ ] .
( they call this a @xmath121-balanced cr scheme . )
now , we get @xmath122 & \geq { { \mathbf{e } } } [ { \textsf{rank}}(\pi_z(r(z ) ) ) ] = \sum_{e \in \text{supp}(z ) } \pr [ e \in \pi_z(r(z ) ) ] \\ & = \sum_{e \in \text{supp}(z ) } \pr [ e \in \pi_z(r(z ) ) \mid e \in r(z ) ] \cdot \pr [ e \in r(z ) ] \\ & \geq \sum_{e \in \text{supp}(z ) } ( 1 - 1/e ) \cdot z_e = r(1 - 1/e ) .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first inequality used the fact that @xmath117 is a subset of @xmath113 , the following equality used that @xmath117 is independent with probability 1 , the second inequality used the property of the cr scheme , and the final equality used the fact that @xmath119 was a fractional base . [
thm : lp - round ] any fractional solution can be randomly rounded to get solution to with cost @xmath24 times the fractional value , where @xmath6 is the rank of the matroid and @xmath13 the number of timesteps .
set @xmath123 . for each element @xmath35 , choose a random threshold @xmath124 independently and uniformly from the interval @xmath125 $ ] .
for each @xmath126 , define the set @xmath127 ; if @xmath128 does not have full rank , augment its rank using the cheapest elements according to @xmath129 to obtain a full rank set @xmath15 . since @xmath130 = \min\ { l\cdot z_t(e ) , 1\}$ ] , the cost @xmath131 .
moreover , @xmath132 exactly when @xmath124 satisfies @xmath133 , which happens with probability at most @xmath134 hence the expected acquisition cost for the elements newly added to @xmath128 is at most @xmath135 .
finally , we have to account for any elements added to extend @xmath128 to a full - rank set @xmath15 .
[ lem : rand - round ] for any fixed @xmath51 $ ] , the set @xmath128 contains a basis of @xmath82 with probability at least @xmath136 .
the set @xmath128 is obtained by threshold rounding of the fractional base @xmath137 as above . instead ,
consider taking @xmath138 different samples @xmath139 , where each sample is obtained by including each element @xmath35 independently with probability @xmath140 ; let @xmath141 .
it is easy to check that @xmath142 \leq \pr [ { \textsf{rank}}(\widehat{s}_t ) = r]$ ] , so it suffices to give a lower bound on the former expression . for this
, we use lemma [ lem : alon ] : the sample @xmath143 has expected rank @xmath144 , and using reverse markov , it has rank at least @xmath145 with probability at least @xmath146 . now focusing on the matroid @xmath147 obtained by contracting elements in @xmath148 ( which
, say , has rank @xmath149 ) , the same argument says the set @xmath150 has rank @xmath151 with probability at least @xmath152 , etc . proceeding in this way , the probability that the rank of @xmath13 is less than @xmath6 is at most the probability that we see fewer than @xmath153 heads in @xmath154 flips of a coin of bias @xmath152 . by a chernoff bound ,
this is at most @xmath155 .
now if the set @xmath128 does not have full rank , the elements we add have cost at most that of the min - cost base under the cost function @xmath156 , which is at most the optimum value for ( [ eq : lp2 ] ) .
( we use the fact that the lp is exact for a single matroid , and the global lp has cost at least the single timestep cost . )
this happens with probability at most @xmath157 , and hence the total expected cost of augmenting @xmath128 over all @xmath13 timesteps is at most @xmath158 times the lp value .
this proves the main theorem .
again , this algorithm for works with different matroids at each timestep , and also for intersections of matroids . to see this observe that the only requirements from the algorithm are that there is a separation oracle for the polytope and that the contention resolution scheme works .
in the case of @xmath14matroid intersection , if we pay an extra @xmath30 penalty in the approximation ratio we have that the probability a rounded solution does not contain a base is @xmath159 so we can take a union bound over the multiple matroids .
0 we can replace the dependence on @xmath13 by a term that depends only on the variance in the acquisition costs .
let us divide the period @xmath160 into `` epochs '' , where an epoch is an interval @xmath161 for @xmath162 such that the total fractional acquisition cost @xmath163 .
we can afford to build a brand new tree at the beginning of each epoch and incur an acquisition cost of at most the rank @xmath6 , which we can charge to the lp s fractional acquisition cost in the epoch . by theorem [ thm : lp - round ] , naively applying the rounding algorithm to each epoch independently gives a guarantee of @xmath164 , where @xmath165 is the maximum length of an epoch .
now we should be able to use the argument from the online section that says that we can ignore steps where the total movement is smaller than half .
thus @xmath165 can be assumed to be @xmath166 .
more details to be added once we consistentize notation .
in fact , if we define epoch to be a period of acquisition cost @xmath167 , then the at least half means movement cost at least @xmath168 .
thus the epoch only has @xmath169 relevant steps in it , so we get log of that . for the special case where all the acquisition costs @xmath11 are all the same , this implies we get rid of the @xmath13 term in the lp rounding , and get an @xmath25-approximation . when the ratio of the maximum to the minimum acquisition cost is small , we can improve the approximation factor above .
more specifically , we show that essentially the same randomized rounding algorithm ( with a different choice of @xmath138 ) gives an approximation ratio of @xmath170 .
we defer the argument to section [ sec : just - logr ] , as it needs some additional definitions and results that we present in the online section .
[ [ an - improvement - avoiding - the - dependence - on - t.-1 ] ] an improvement : avoiding the dependence on @xmath13 .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + when the ratio of the maximum to the minimum acquisition cost is small , we can improve the approximation factor above . more specifically , we show that essentially the same randomized rounding algorithm ( with a different choice of @xmath138 ) gives an approximation ratio of @xmath170 .
we defer the argument to section [ sec : just - logr ] , as it needs some additional definitions and results that we present in the online section .
we defer the hardness proof to appendix [ app : offline ] , which shows that the and problems are np - hard to approximate better than @xmath171 even for graphical matroids .
an integrality gap of @xmath172 appears in appendix [ sec : int - gap - matroids ] .
[ thm : matr - hard ] the and problems are np - hard to approximate better than @xmath173 even for graphical matroids .
we give a reduction from set cover to the problem for graphical matroids .
given an instance @xmath174 of set cover , with @xmath175 sets and @xmath176 elements , we construct a graph as follows . there is a special vertex @xmath6 , and @xmath5 set vertices ( with vertices @xmath177 for each set @xmath178 ) .
there are @xmath5 edges @xmath179 which all have inclusion weight @xmath180 and per - time cost @xmath181 for all @xmath2 .
all other edges will be zero cost short - term edges as given below .
in particular , there are @xmath182 timesteps . in timestep
@xmath183 $ ] , define subset @xmath184 to be vertices corresponding to sets containing element @xmath185 .
we have a set of edges @xmath186 for all @xmath187 , and all edges @xmath188 for @xmath189 .
all these edges have zero inclusion weight @xmath11 , and are only alive at time @xmath190 .
( note this creates a graph with parallel edges , but this can be easily fixed by subdividing edges . ) in any solution to this problem , to connect the vertices in @xmath191 to @xmath6 , we must buy some edge @xmath192 for some @xmath193 .
this is true for all @xmath190 , hence the root - set edges we buy correspond to a set cover .
moreover , one can easily check that if we acquire edges @xmath194 such that the sets @xmath195 form a set cover , then we can always augment using zero cost edges to get a spanning tree . since the only edges we pay for are the @xmath194 edges , we should buy edges corresponding to a min - cardinality set cover , which is hard to approximate better than @xmath196 . finally , that the number of time periods is @xmath182 , and the rank of the matroid is @xmath197 for these hard instances .
this gives us the claimed hardness .
we now turn to solving in the online setting . in this setting , the acquisition costs @xmath11 are known up - front , but the holding costs @xmath12 for day @xmath2 are not known before day @xmath2 . since the equivalence given in lemma [ lem : pack - cover ] between and holds even in the online setting , we can just work on the problem .
we show that the online problem admits an @xmath198-competitive ( oblivious ) randomized algorithm . to do this ,
we show that one can find an @xmath199-competitive fractional solution to the linear programming relaxation in section [ sec : offline ] , and then we round this lp relaxation online , losing another logarithmic factor .
again , we work in the interval model outlined in section [ sec : intervals ] .
recall that in this model , for each element @xmath77 there is a unique interval @xmath200 $ ] during which it is alive . the element @xmath77 has an acquisition cost @xmath11 , no holding costs .
once an element has been acquired ( which can be done at any time during its interval ) , it can be used at all times in that interval , but not after that . in the online setting
, at each time step @xmath2 we are told which intervals have ended ( and which have not ) ; also , which new elements @xmath77 are available starting at time @xmath2 , along with their acquisition costs @xmath11 . of course
, we do not know when its interval @xmath201 will end ; this information is known only once the interval ends
. we will work with the same lp as in section [ sec : lp - round ] , albeit now we have to solve it online .
the variable @xmath202 is the indicator for whether we acquire element @xmath77 . @xmath203
\notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that this is not a packing or covering lp , which makes it more annoying to solve online .
hence we consider a slight reformulation .
let @xmath204 denote the _ spanning set polytope _ defined as the convex hull of the full - rank ( a.k.a .
spanning ) sets @xmath205 .
since each spanning set contains a base , we can write the constraints of ( [ eq:3 ] ) as : @xmath206 here
we define @xmath207 to be the vector derived from @xmath208 by zeroing out the @xmath202 values for @xmath209 .
it is known that the polytope @xmath204 can be written as a ( rather large ) set of covering constraints .
indeed , @xmath210 , where @xmath211 is the dual matroid for @xmath82 .
since the rank function of @xmath212 is given by @xmath213 , it follows that ( [ eq:4 ] ) can be written as @xmath214 thus we get a covering lp with `` box '' constraints over @xmath17 .
the constraints can be presented one at a time : in timestep @xmath2 , we present all the covering constraints corresponding to @xmath215 .
we remark that the newer machinery of @xcite may be applicable to [ eq : coveringconstraints ] .
we next show that a simpler approach suffices will be useful in improving the rounding algorithm . ] .
the general results of buchbinder and naor @xcite ( and its extension to row - sparse covering problems by @xcite ) imply a deterministic algorithm for fractionally solving this linear program online , with a competitive ratio of @xmath216 . however , this is not yet a polynomial - time algorithm , the number of constraints for each timestep being exponential .
we next give an adaptive algorithm to generate a small yet sufficient set of constraints .
[ [ solving - the - lp - online - in - polynomial - time.-1 ] ] solving the lp online in polynomial time .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + given a vector @xmath217^e$ ] , define @xmath218 as follows : @xmath219 clearly , @xmath220 and @xmath221^e$ ] .
we next describe the algorithm for generating covering constraints in timestep @xmath2 .
recall that @xcite give us an online algorithm @xmath222 for solving a fractional covering lp with box constraints ; we use this as a black - box .
( this lp solver only raises variables , a fact we will use . ) in timestep @xmath2 , we adaptively select a small subset of the covering constraints from ( [ eq : coveringconstraints ] ) , and present it to @xmath222 .
moreover , given a fractional solution returned by @xmath222 , we will need to massage it at the end of timestep @xmath2 to get a solution satisfying all the constraints from ( [ eq : coveringconstraints ] ) corresponding to @xmath2 .
let @xmath208 be the fractional solution to ( [ eq : coveringconstraints ] ) at the end of timestep @xmath108 . now given information about timestep @xmath2 , in particular the elements in @xmath215 and their acquisition costs
, we do the following . given @xmath208
, we construct @xmath218 and check if @xmath223 , as one can separate for @xmath204 .
if @xmath223 , then @xmath218 is feasible and we do not need to present any new constraints to @xmath222 , and we return @xmath218 . if not , our separation oracle presents an @xmath42 such that the constraint @xmath224 is violated .
we present the constraint corresponding to @xmath42 to @xmath222 to get an updated @xmath208 , and repeat until @xmath218 is feasible for time @xmath2 .
( since @xmath222 only raises variables and we have a covering lp , the solution remains feasible for past timesteps . )
we next argue that we do not need to repeat this loop more than @xmath225 times .
[ lem : farfromfeasible ] if for some @xmath208 and the corresponding @xmath218 , the constraint @xmath226 is violated .
then @xmath227 let @xmath228 and let @xmath229 .
let @xmath230 denote @xmath231 .
thus @xmath232 since both @xmath233 and @xmath234 are integers , it follows that @xmath235 . on the other hand , for every @xmath236 , and thus @xmath237 .
consequently @xmath238 finally , for any @xmath239 , @xmath240 , so the claim follows .
the algorithm @xmath222 updates @xmath208 to satisfy the constraint given to it , and lemma [ lem : farfromfeasible ] implies that each constraint we give to it must increase @xmath241 by at least @xmath28 .
the translation to the interval model ensures that the number of elements whose intervals contain @xmath2 is at most latexmath:[$|e_t| \leq time @xmath2 is at most @xmath243 .
we summarize the discussion of this section in the following theorem .
[ thm : lp - solve ] there is a polynomial - time online algorithm to compute an @xmath244-approximate solution to ( [ eq:3 ] ) .
we observe that the solution to this linear program can be trivially transformed to one for the lp in section [ sec : lp - round ] .
finally , the randomized rounding algorithm of section [ sec : lp - round ] can be implemented online by selecting a threshold @xmath245 $ ] the beginning of the algorithm , where @xmath246 and selecting element @xmath77 whenever @xmath247 exceeds @xmath248 : here we use the fact that the online algorithm only ever raises @xmath202 values , and this rounding algorithm is monotone .
rerandomizing in case of failure gives us an expected cost of @xmath24 times the lp solution , and hence we get an @xmath249-competitive algorithm .
the dependence on the time horizon @xmath13 is unsatisfactory in some settings , but we can do better using lemma [ lem : farfromfeasible ] . recall that the @xmath251-factor loss in the rounding follows from the naive union bound over the @xmath13 time steps .
we can argue that when @xmath252 is small , we can afford for the rounding to fail occasionally , and charge it to the acquisition cost incurred by the linear program .
the details appear in appendix [ sec : just - logr ] .
the dependence on the time horizon @xmath13 is unsatisfactory in some settings , but we can do better using lemma [ lem : farfromfeasible ] . recall that the @xmath251-factor loss in the rounding follows from the naive union bound over the @xmath13 time steps .
we now argue that when @xmath252 is small , we can afford for the rounding to fail occasionally , and charge it to the acquisition cost incurred by the linear program .
let us divide the period @xmath253 $ ] into disjoint `` epochs '' , where an epoch ( except for the last ) is an interval @xmath161 for @xmath162 such that the total fractional acquisition cost @xmath254 .
thus an epoch is a minimal interval where the linear program spends acquisition cost @xmath255 $ ] , so that we can afford to build a brand new tree once in each epoch and can charge it to the lp s fractional acquisition cost in the epoch . naively applying theorem [ thm : lp - round ] to each epoch
independently gives us a guarantee of @xmath256 , where @xmath165 is the maximum length of an epoch .
however , an epoch can be fairly long if the lp solution changes very slowly .
we break up each epoch into phases , where each phase is a maximal subsequence such that the lp incurs acquisition cost at most @xmath257 ; clearly the epoch can be divided into at most @xmath258 disjoint phases .
for a phase @xmath259 $ ] , let @xmath260}$ ] denote the solution defined as @xmath260}(e ) = \min_{t\in [ t_1,t_2 ] } z_t(e)$ ] .
the definition of the phase implies that for any @xmath261 $ ] , the @xmath262 difference @xmath263 } - z_t\|_1 \leq \frac{1}{4}$ ]
. now lemma [ lem : farfromfeasible ] implies that @xmath264}$ ] is in @xmath265 , where @xmath266 is defined as in ( [ eq:5 ] ) .
suppose that in the randomized rounding algorithm , we pick the threshold @xmath267 $ ] for @xmath268 .
let @xmath269}$ ] be the event that the rounding algorithm applied to @xmath260}$ ] gives a spanning set .
since @xmath264 } \leq 2z_{[t_1,t_2]}$ ] is in @xmath270 for a phase @xmath259 $ ] , lemma [ lem : rand - round ] implies that the event @xmath269}$ ] occurs with probability @xmath271 .
moreover , if @xmath269}$ ] occurs , it is easy to see that the randomized rounding solution is feasible for all @xmath272 $ ] .
since there are @xmath273 phases within an epoch , the expected number of times that the randomized rounding fails any time during an epoch is @xmath274 .
suppose that we rerandomize all thresholds whenever the randomized rounding fails .
each rerandomization will cost us at most @xmath275 in expected acquisition cost .
since the expected number of times we do this is less than once per epoch , we can charge this additional cost to the @xmath275 acquisition cost incurred by the lp during the epoch .
thus we get an @xmath276-approximation .
this argument also works for the online case ; hence for the common case where all the acquisition costs are the same , the loss due to randomized rounding is @xmath25 .
we can show that any polynomial - time algorithm can not achieve better than an @xmath277 competitive ratio , via a reduction from online set cover .
details appear in appendix [ app : sec : hardness - online ] . in the online set cover problem ,
one is given an instance @xmath278 of set cover , and in time step @xmath2 , the algorithm is presented an element @xmath279 , and is required to pick a set covering it .
the competitive ratio of an algorithm on a sequence @xmath280}$ ] is the ratio of the number of sets picked by the algorithm to the optimum set - cover of the instance @xmath281\},{{\mathcal{f}}})$ ] .
korman ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2.3.4 ) shows the following hardness for online set cover : there exists a constant @xmath282 such that if there is a ( possibly randomized ) polynomial time algorithm for online set cover with competitive ratio @xmath283 , then @xmath284 .
recall that in the reduction in the proof of theorem [ thm : matr - hard ] , the set of long term edges depends only on @xmath285 .
the short term edges alone depend on the elements to be covered .
it can then we verified that the same approach gives a reduction from online set cover to online .
it follows that the online problem does not admit an algorithm with competitive ratio better than @xmath286 unless @xmath284 .
in fact this hardness holds even when the end time of each edge is known as soon as it appears , and the only non - zero costs are @xmath287 .
we next consider the _ perfect matching maintenance _ ( ) problem where @xmath17 is the set of edges of a graph @xmath288 , and the at each step , we need to maintain a perfect matchings in @xmath289 .
* integrality gap . *
somewhat surprisingly , we show that the natural lp relaxation has an @xmath290 integrality gap , even for a constant number of timesteps .
the lp and the ( very simple ) example appears in appendix [ sec : match - int - gap ] .
the natural lp relaxation is : @xmath291 the polytope @xmath292 is now the perfect matching polytope for @xmath289 .
[ lem : int - gap ] there is an @xmath290 integrality gap for the problem .
consider the instance in the figure , and the following lp solution for 4 time steps . in @xmath293
, the edges of each of the two cycles has @xmath294 , and the cross - cycle edges have @xmath295 . in @xmath296
, we have @xmath297 and @xmath298 , and otherwise it is the same as @xmath293 .
@xmath299 and @xmath300 are the same as @xmath293 . in @xmath301
, we have @xmath302 and @xmath303 , and otherwise it is the same as @xmath293 .
for each time @xmath2 , the edges in the support of the solution @xmath304 have zero cost , and other edges have infinite cost .
the only cost incurred by the lp is the movement cost , which is @xmath158 .
consider the perfect matching found at time @xmath305 , which must consist of matchings on both the cycles .
( moreover , the matching in time 3 must be the same , else we would change @xmath290 edges . )
suppose this matching uses exactly one edge from @xmath306 and @xmath307 .
then when we drop the edges @xmath308 and add in @xmath309 , we get a cycle on @xmath310 vertices , but to get a perfect matching on this in time @xmath311 we need to change @xmath290 edges . else
the matching uses exactly one edge from @xmath306 and @xmath312 , in which case going from time @xmath313 to time @xmath314 requires @xmath290 changes . * hardness .
* moreover , in appendix [ app : sec : match - hard ] we show that the perfect matching maintenance problem is very hard to approximate : for any @xmath315 it is np - hard to distinguish instances with cost @xmath316 from those with cost @xmath317 , where @xmath318 is the number of vertices in the graph .
this holds even when the holding costs are in @xmath22 , acquisition costs are @xmath319 for all edges , and the number of time steps is a constant . in this section
we prove the following hardness result : for any @xmath315 it is np - hard to distinguish instances with cost @xmath316 from those with cost @xmath317 , where @xmath318 is the number of vertices in the graph .
this holds even when the holding costs are in @xmath22 , acquisition costs are @xmath319 for all edges , and the number of time steps is a constant .
the proof is via reduction from @xmath313-coloring .
we assume we are given an instance of @xmath313-coloring @xmath288 where the maximum degree of @xmath289 is constant .
it is known that the @xmath313-coloring problem is still hard for graphs with bounded degree ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2 ) .
we construct the following gadget @xmath320 for each vertex @xmath321 .
( a figure is given in figure [ fig : gadget ] . )
there are two cycles of length @xmath322 , where @xmath33 is odd .
the first cycle ( say @xmath323 ) has three distinguished vertices @xmath324 at distance @xmath33 from each other .
the second ( called @xmath325 ) has similar distinguished vertices @xmath326 at distance @xmath33 from each other .
there are three more `` interface '' vertices @xmath327 .
vertex @xmath328 is connected to @xmath329 and @xmath330 , similarly for @xmath331 and @xmath332 .
there is a special `` switch '' vertex @xmath333 , which is connected to all three of @xmath334 .
call these edges the _ switch _ edges . due to the two odd cycles ,
every perfect matching in @xmath320 has the structure that one of the interface vertices is matched to some vertex in @xmath323 , another to a vertex in @xmath325 and the third to the switch @xmath333 .
we think of the subscript of the vertex matched to @xmath333 as the color assigned to the vertex @xmath335 . at every odd time step @xmath126 ,
the only allowed edges are those within the gadgets @xmath336 : i.e. , all the holding costs for edges within the gadgets is zero , and all edges between gadgets have holding costs @xmath87 .
this is called the `` steady state '' . at every even time step @xmath2 , for some matching @xmath337 of the graph
, we move into a `` test state '' , which intuitively tests whether the edges of a matching @xmath338 have been properly colored .
we do this as follows . for every edge @xmath339 ,
the switch edges in @xmath340 become unavailable ( have infinite holding costs ) .
moreover , now we allow some edges that go between @xmath320 and @xmath341 , namely the edge @xmath342 , and the edges @xmath343 for @xmath344 and @xmath345 .
note that any perfect matching on the vertices of @xmath346 which only uses the available edges would have to match @xmath342 , and one interface vertex of @xmath320 must be matched to one interface vertex of @xmath341 .
moreover , by the structure of the allowed edges , the colors of these vertices must differ .
( the other two interface vertices in each gadget must still be matched to their odd cycles to get a perfect matching . ) since the graph has bounded degree , we can partition the edges of @xmath289 into a constant number of matchings @xmath347 for some @xmath348 ( using vizing s theorem ) . hence , at time step @xmath349 , we test the edges of the matching @xmath350 .
the number of timesteps is @xmath351 , which is a constant . .
the test - state edges are on the right . ]
suppose the graph @xmath289 was indeed @xmath313-colorable , say @xmath352 is the proper coloring .
in the steady states , we choose a perfect matching within each gadget @xmath320 so that @xmath353 is matched . in the test state @xmath354 ,
if some edge @xmath355 is in the matching @xmath338 , we match @xmath342 and @xmath356 .
since the coloring @xmath357 was a proper coloring , these edges are present and this is a valid perfect matching using only the edges allowed in this test state .
note that the only changes are that for every test edge @xmath358 , the matching edges @xmath359 and @xmath360 are replaced by @xmath342 and @xmath361 .
hence the total acquisition cost incurred at time @xmath354 is @xmath362 , and the same acquisition cost is incurred at time @xmath363 to revert to the steady state .
hence the total acquisition cost , summed over all the timesteps , is @xmath364 .
suppose @xmath289 is not @xmath313-colorable .
we claim that there exists vertex @xmath365 such that the interface vertex not matched to the odd cycles is different in two different timesteps
i.e . , there are times @xmath366 such that @xmath367 and @xmath185 ( for @xmath345 ) are the states
. then the length of the augmenting path to get from the perfect matching at time @xmath368 to the perfect matching at @xmath369 is at least @xmath33 .
now if we set @xmath370 , then we get a total acquisition cost of at least @xmath371 in this case .
the size of the graph is @xmath372 , so the gap is between @xmath373 and @xmath374 .
this proves the claim .
in this paper we studied multistage optimization problems : an optimization problem ( think about finding a minimum - cost spanning tree in a graph ) needs to be solved repeatedly , each day a different set of element costs are presented , and there is a penalty for changing the elements picked as part of the solution .
hence one has to hedge between sticking to a suboptimal solution and changing solutions too rapidly .
we present online and offline algorithms when the optimization problem is maintaining a base in a matroid .
we show that our results are optimal under standard complexity - theoretic assumptions .
we also show that the problem of maintaining a perfect matching becomes impossibly hard .
our work suggests several directions for future research .
it is natural to study other combinatorial optimization problems , both polynomial time solvable ones such shortest path and min - cut , as well np - hard ones such as min - max load balancing and bin - packing in this multistage framework with acquisition costs .
moreover , the approximability of the _ bipartite _ matching maintenance , as well as matroid intersection maintenance remains open .
our hardness results for the matroid problem hold when edges have @xmath375 acquisition costs . the unweighted version where all acquisition costs are equal may be easier ; we currently know no hardness results , or sub - logarithmic approximations for this useful special case .
an extension of /problems is to the case when the set of elements remain the same , but the matroids change over time . again
the goal in is to maintain a matroid base at each time .
[ thm : diff - matrs - wpb ] the problem with different matroids is np - hard to approximate better than a factor of @xmath376 , even for partition matroids , as long as @xmath377 .
the reduction is from 3d - matching ( 3 dm ) .
an instance of 3 dm has three sets @xmath378 of equal size @xmath379 , and a set of hyperedges @xmath380 .
the goal is to choose a set of disjoint edges @xmath381 such that @xmath382 . first , consider the instance of with three timesteps @xmath383 .
the universe elements correspond to the edges . for @xmath384 , create a partition with @xmath10 parts , with edges sharing a vertex in @xmath385 falling in the same part .
the matroid @xmath386 is now to choose a set of elements with at most one element in each part . for @xmath387
, the partition now corresponds to edges that share a vertex in @xmath388 , and for @xmath389 , edges that share a vertex in @xmath390 .
set the movement weights @xmath391 for all edges .
if there exists a feasible solution to 3 dm with @xmath10 edges , choosing the corresponding elements form a solution with total weight @xmath10 . if the largest matching is of size @xmath392 , then we must pay @xmath393 extra over these three timesteps .
this gives a @xmath10-vs-@xmath394 gap for three timesteps . to get a result for @xmath13 timesteps , we give the same matroids repeatedly , giving matroids @xmath395 at all times @xmath396
$ ] . in the `` yes '' case
we would buy the edges corresponding to the 3d matching and pay nothing more than the initial @xmath10 , whereas in the `` no '' case we would pay @xmath397 every three timesteps .
finally , the apx - hardness for 3 dm @xcite gives the claim .
the time - varying problem does admit an @xmath24 approximation , as the randomized rounding ( or the greedy algorithm ) shows .
however , the equivalence of and does not go through when the matroids change over time .
the restriction that the matroids vary over time is essential for the np - hardness , since if the partition matroid is the same for all times , the complexity of the problem drops radically .
[ thm : partition ] the problem with partition matroids can be solved in polynomial time .
the problem can be solved using min - cost flow .
indeed , consider the following reduction .
create a node @xmath398 for each element @xmath77 and timestep @xmath2 .
let the partition be @xmath399 .
then for each @xmath400 $ ] and each @xmath401 , add an arc @xmath402 , with cost @xmath403 .
add a cost of @xmath12 per unit flow through vertex @xmath398 .
( we could simulate this using edge - costs if needed . ) finally , add vertices @xmath404 and source @xmath405 . for each @xmath406 ,
add arcs from @xmath177 to all vertices @xmath407 with costs @xmath408 .
all these arcs have infinite capacity .
now add unit capacity edges from @xmath405 to each @xmath177 , and infinite capacity edges from all nodes @xmath409 to @xmath2 . since the flow polytope is integral for integral capacities , a flow of @xmath6 units will trace out @xmath6 paths from @xmath405 to @xmath2 , with the elements chosen at each time @xmath2 being independent in the partition matroid , and the cost being exactly the per - time costs and movement costs of the elements .
observe that we could even have time - varying movement costs .
whereas , for graphical matroids the problem is @xmath410 hard even when the movement costs for each element do not change over time , and even just lie in the set @xmath375 . moreover , the restriction in theorem [ thm : diff - matrs - wpb ] that @xmath411 is also necessary , as the following result shows .
[ thm : two ] for the case of two rounds ( i.e. , @xmath412 ) the problem can be solved in polynomial time , even when the two matroids in the two rounds are different .
the solution is simple , via matroid intersection .
suppose the matroids in the two timesteps are @xmath413 and @xmath414 .
create elements @xmath415 which corresponds to picking element @xmath77 and @xmath416 in the two time steps , with cost @xmath417 .
lift the matroids @xmath386 and @xmath418 to these tuples in the natural way , and look for a common basis .
we note that deterministic online algorithms can not get any non - trivial guarantee for the problem , even in the simple case of a @xmath319-uniform matroid .
this is related to the lower bound for deterministic algorithms for paging .
formally , we have the 1-uniform matroid on @xmath5 elements , and @xmath419 .
all acquisition costs @xmath11 are 1 . in the first period , all holding costs are zero and the online algorithm picks an element , say @xmath420 .
since we are in the non - oblivious model , the algorithm knows @xmath420 and can in the second time step , set @xmath421 , while leaving the other ones at zero .
now the algorithm is forced to move to another edge , say @xmath422 , allowing the adversary to set @xmath423 and so on . at the end of @xmath419 rounds ,
the online algorithm is forced to incur a cost of 1 in each round , giving a total cost of @xmath13 .
however , there is still an edge whose holding cost was zero throughout , so that the offline opt is 1 . thus against a non - oblivious adversary , any online algorithm must incur a @xmath424 overhead . in this section ,
we show that if the aspect ratio of the movement costs is not bounded , the linear program has a @xmath426 gap , even when @xmath13 is exponentially larger than @xmath5 .
we present an instance where @xmath426 and @xmath427 are about @xmath6 with @xmath428 , and the linear program has a gap of @xmath425 .
this shows that the @xmath429 term in our rounding algorithm is unavoidable .
the instance is a graphical matroid , on a graph @xmath289 on @xmath430 , and @xmath431 .
the edges @xmath432 for @xmath433 $ ] have acquisition cost @xmath434 and holding cost @xmath435 for all @xmath2 .
the edges @xmath436 for @xmath437 $ ] have acquisition cost @xmath438 and have holding cost determined as follows : we find a bijection between the set @xmath40 $ ] and the set of partitions @xmath439 of @xmath440 with each of @xmath441 and @xmath442 having size @xmath443 ( by choice of @xmath13 such a bijection exists , and can be found e.g. by arranging the @xmath441 s in lexicographical order . ) . in time
step @xmath2 , we set @xmath181 for @xmath444 , and @xmath445 for all @xmath446 .
first observe that no feasible integral solution to this instance can pay acquisition cost less than @xmath443 on the @xmath432 edges .
suppose that the solution picks edges @xmath447 for some set @xmath448 of size at most @xmath443 .
then any time step @xmath2 such that @xmath449 , the solution has picked no edges connecting @xmath450 to @xmath442 , and all edges connecting @xmath441 to @xmath442 have infinite holding cost in this time step .
this contradicts the feasibility of the solution .
thus any integral solution has cost @xmath290 .
finally , we show that on this instance , ( [ eq : lp2 ] ) from section [ sec : lp - round ] , has a feasible solution of cost @xmath158 .
we set @xmath451 for all @xmath452 $ ] , and set @xmath453 for @xmath454 .
it is easy to check that @xmath455 is in the spanning tree polytope for all time steps @xmath2 . finally , the total acquisition cost is at most @xmath456 for the edges incident on @xmath450 and at most @xmath457 for the other edges , both of which are @xmath158 .
the holding costs paid by this solution is zero .
thus the lp has a solution of cost @xmath158 the claim follows .
the greedy algorithm for is the natural one .
we consider the interval view of the problem ( as in section [ sec : intervals ] ) where each element only has acquisition costs @xmath11 , and can be used only in some interval @xmath201 .
given a current subset @xmath458 , define @xmath459 .
the benefit of adding an element @xmath77 to @xmath385 is @xmath460 and the greedy algorithm repeatedly picks an element @xmath77 maximizing @xmath461 and adds @xmath77 to @xmath385 .
this is done until @xmath462 for all @xmath51 $ ] .
phrased this way , an @xmath23 bound on the approximation ration follows from wolsey @xcite .
we next give an alternate dual fitting proof .
we do not know of an instance with uniform acquisition costs where greedy does not give a constant factor approximation .
the dual fitting approach may be useful in proving a better approximation bound for this special case .
using lagrangian variables @xmath465 for each @xmath77 and @xmath466 , we write a lower bound for @xmath467 by @xmath468 which using the integrality of the matroid polytope can be rewritten as : @xmath469 here , @xmath470 denotes the cost of the minimum weight base at time @xmath2 according to the element weights @xmath471 , where the available elements at time @xmath2 is @xmath472 .
the best lower bound is : @xmath473 it is useful to maintain , for each time @xmath2 , a _ minimum weight base _ @xmath64 of the subset @xmath479 according to weights @xmath480 .
hence the current dual value equals @xmath481 .
we start with @xmath482 and @xmath483 for all @xmath2 , which satisfies the above properties .
suppose we now pick @xmath77 maximizing @xmath461 and get new set @xmath484 .
we use @xmath485 akin to our definition of @xmath486 . call a timestep @xmath2 `` interesting '' if @xmath487 ; there are @xmath488 interesting timesteps .
how do we update the duals ?
for @xmath489 , we set @xmath490 .
note the element @xmath77 itself satisfies the condition of being in @xmath491 for precisely the interesting timesteps , and hence @xmath492 .
for each interesting @xmath86 , define the base @xmath493 ; for all other times set @xmath494 .
it is easy to verify that @xmath495 is a base in @xmath496 .
but is it a min - weight base ?
inductively assume that @xmath64 was a min - weight base of @xmath479 ; if @xmath2 is not interesting there is nothing to prove , so consider an interesting @xmath2 .
all the elements in @xmath491 have just been assigned weight @xmath497 , which by the monotonicity properties of the greedy algorithm is at least as large as the weight of any element in @xmath479 . since @xmath77 lies in @xmath491 and
is assigned value @xmath498 , it can not be swapped with any other element in @xmath496 to improve the weight of the base , and hence @xmath499 is an min - weight base of @xmath496 .
it remains to show that the dual constraints are approximately satisfied .
consider any element @xmath500 , and let @xmath501 .
the first step where we update @xmath502 for some @xmath503 is when @xmath500 is in the span of @xmath486 for some time @xmath2 .
we claim that @xmath504 .
indeed , at this time @xmath500 is a potential element to be added to the solution and it would cause a rank increase for @xmath505 time steps .
the greedy rule ensures that we must have picked an element @xmath77 with weight - to - coverage ratio at most as high .
similarly , the next @xmath2 for which @xmath502 is updated will have @xmath506 , etc .
hence we get the sum @xmath507 since each element can only be alive for all @xmath13 timesteps , we get the claimed @xmath23-approximation . note that the greedy algorithm would solve @xmath508 even if we had a different matroid @xmath509 at each time @xmath2
. however , the equivalence of and no longer holds in this setting , which is not surprising given the hardness of theorem [ thm : diff - matrs - wpb ] . | this paper is motivated by the fact that many systems need to be maintained continually while the underlying costs change over time .
the challenge then is to continually maintain near - optimal solutions to the underlying optimization problems , without creating too much churn in the solution itself .
we model this as a multistage combinatorial optimization problem where the input is a sequence of cost functions ( one for each time step ) ; while we can change the solution from step to step , we incur an additional cost for every such change .
we first study the multistage matroid maintenance problem , where we need to maintain a base of a matroid in each time step under the changing cost functions and acquisition costs for adding new elements .
the online version of this problem generalizes onine paging , and is a well - structured case of the metrical task systems .
e.g. , given a graph , we need to maintain a spanning tree @xmath0 at each step : we pay @xmath1 for the cost of the tree at time @xmath2 , and also @xmath3 for the number of edges changed at this step .
our main result is a polynomial time @xmath4-approximation to the online multistage matroid maintenance problem , where @xmath5 is the number of elements / edges and @xmath6 is the rank of the matroid .
this improves on results of buchbinder et al .
@xcite who addressed the _ fractional _ version of this problem under uniform acquisition costs , and buchbinder , chen and naor @xcite who studied the fractional version of a more general problem .
we also give an @xmath7 approximation for the offline version of the problem .
these bounds hold when the acquisition costs are non - uniform , in which case both these results are the best possible unless p = np .
we also study the perfect matching version of the problem , where we must maintain a perfect matching at each step under changing cost functions and costs for adding new elements .
surprisingly , the hardness drastically increases : for any constant @xmath8 , there is no @xmath9-approximation to the multistage matching maintenance problem , even in the offline case . |
our work is concerned with the kinetics of electrons in a stellar atmosphere , modelled as a parallel - plane slab irradiated on a face .
our models of atmospheres start in the deep layers of stars , where the radiative field can be described in the diffusion approximation , and end with the layers of minimal temperature , before the chromospheric raise whose effects are ignored .
the free electrons are characterized by their velocity distribution function : the electron distribution function ( edf ) , which is calculated with the other thermodynamical quantities of the atmosphere . our main objective is to understand the mechanism leading to the thermalisation of electrons , where the edf tends toward the maxwell - boltzmann distribution .
it is accepted , in stellar atmospheres theory , that the thermalisation of electrons is effective as long as elastic collisions dominate inelastic interactions of electrons with the plasma , a rather well verified hypothesis for electrons having energies greatly below the first excitation energies of atoms and ions composing the atmosphere .
this hypothesis is not necessarily correct for faster electrons .
our work follows the line drawn by some plasma physicists at the beginning of the 70s ( peyraud 1968 , 1970 ; peyraud 1969 ; oxenius 1970 , 1974 ; shoub 1977 ) .
their work demonstrated the important role played by inelastic ( collisional or radiative ) processes in the equilibrium reached by electrons , which can deviate considerably from the maxwellian equilibrium at high energies .
we present below a stellar atmosphere model which is not in local thermodynamical equilibrium ( lte ) , confirming the results anticipated in the 70s on the basis of mainly theoretical developments .
this problem consists in solving the equations generally used to model a non - lte stellar atmosphere ( equation of radiative transfer , equations of statistical equilibrium , pressure equation , equation of energy , conservation of charge ) , coupled with the kinetic equation of electrons .
this non - linear system is difficult to solve numerically because it contains two coupled kinetic equations : one for photons , the other for electrons .
therefore we have used the simplest model of non - lte atmosphere : homogeneous ( constant density of heavy particles @xmath0 ) , isotherm ( constant temperature @xmath1 ) , and composed with hydrogen atoms with only two energy levels .
the deviation from lte is then due to the escape of photons by the free surface . on the other hand we have included in our model the main collision processes existing in a stellar atmosphere ( elastic collisions , collisional or radiative inelastic interactions ) .
the elastic collision term of the kinetic equation of electrons is written in a bgk model with a velocity dependent collision frequency .
this model accuratly fits the main properties of the usual landau term ( fokker - planck ) . to solve the equation of radiative transfer
, we used the codes of the transfer group in cral ( rutily 1992 ) .
in our model , we choosed @xmath2 and @xmath3 , which are typical values in the solar photosphere .
the plasma is optically thick at all frequencies ( optical thickness greater than 100 ) , leading to a high geometrical thickness @xmath4 since there is no temperature or heavy particles density gradient .
finally the atmosphere is irradiated on its internal boundary layer by a planck radiation of temperature @xmath1 .
the figure [ fig1]a is a classical diagram showing the superficial regions where the non - lte effects are important .
figure [ fig1]b shows that the edf is not a maxwell - boltzmann distribution in the non - lte region of the atmosphere ( see @xmath5 ) , the deviation from a maxwellian distribution being important very close to the surface ( @xmath6 , corresponding to an optical depth @xmath7 in the ly@xmath8 spectral line ) . in figure [ fig1]c , we drawn the superficial edf at @xmath9 as a function of the electronic velocity . the edf tail of fast electrons is strongly depleted when electron energies are greater than the minimum excitation energy of the hydrogen atom ( @xmath10 , @xmath11 , @xmath12 ) .
the edf tail shows successive platforms centered on @xmath13 and @xmath14 .
these features were already described by the authors at the origin of this work , referenced at the beginning of this article .
the mechanism responsible for this effect is very well explained in oxenius s monograph ( 1986 ) , where the author outlines an interesting _ feedback effect _ tending to amplify the deviation of the edf from a maxwellian distribution .
this mechanism starts when elastic and inelastic collision frequencies become comparable at high electronic velocities , which is the case for a weak ionization degree .
a ) deviations of the populations from their lte values as a function of the reduced geometrical depth @xmath15 .
coefficients @xmath16 , where @xmath17 are the saha densities of the hydrogen atom in energy states @xmath18 , are used to characterize non - lte regions ( @xmath19 ) .
b ) deviation of the edf to the maxwellian distribution @xmath20 as a function of the reduced geometrical depth @xmath15 .
both curves are drawn for a given velocity @xmath21 , where @xmath22 is the velocity corresponding to the rydberg energy @xmath23 .
c ) deviation of the edf to the maxwellian distribution as a function of the electronic velocity @xmath24 , at the surface of the atmosphere @xmath9.,width=472,height=377 ]
astrophysical consequences of this work are numerous . in general the deviation of the edf from a maxwellian distribution
has a direct effect on all thermodynamic quantities involving the edf , _
e.g. _ collisional transition rates or spectral lines profiles .
it has an indirect effect on all other characteristics of the atmosphere , because of the coupling of all equations .
transition rates are used to solve the equations of statistical equilibrium , which lead to the populations and ionization degree of the atmosphere .
inversion techniques of spectral lines observed by spectroscopy are also sensitive to the edf shape , so that temperatures or densities calculated with these techniques are affected by deviation of the edf from a maxwellian distribution ( shoub 1983 , owocki 1983 , salzmann 1995 ) .
finally the non thermodynamical equilibrium of electrons may be at the origin of physical processes which are still not very well understood at present , for example the heating of the sun corona ( scudder 1992,1994 ) .
the results presented in this article are based on a very simple atmosphere model , which guarants a numerically stable solution . in non - lte regions close to the surface ,
the edf shows important deviations from the maxwellian distribution in the fast electrons tail .
our model confirm , by means of numerical codes accurate enough to handle this complex problem , most of the physical ideas advanced thirty years ago .
our main contribution consists in the construction of a selfconsistent model of a stellar atmosphere with non thermalized electrons .
also we have used very accurate radiative transfer codes .
it remains to make this model more realistic for comparison with observations .
peyraud , n. 1968 , le journal de physique , 29 , 201 ; 29 , 747 ; 29 , 997 .
peyraud , n. , peyraud j. 1969 , le journal de physique , 30 , 773 .
peyraud , n. 1970 , le journal de physique , 31 , 565 .
owocki , s. p. , scudder , j. d. 1983 , astrophys .
j. , 270 , 758 .
oxenius , j. 1970 , z. naturforsch . , 25 , 101 ; 25 , 1302 .
oxenius , j. 1974 , j. quant .
transfer , 14 , 731 .
oxenius , j. 1986 , kinetic theory of particles and photons , springer - verlag ( berlin ) , vol . 20 .
rutily , b. 1992 , solutions exactes de lquation de transfert et applications astrophysiques , thse de doctorat detat , universit claude bernard lyon i. salzmann , d. , lee , y. t. 1995 , j. quant .
transfer , 54 , 339 .
scudder , j. d. 1992 , astrophys .
j. , 398 , 299 ; 398 , 319 .
scudder , j. d. 1994 , astrophys .
j. , 427 , 446 .
shoub , e. c. 1977 , astrophys .
, 34 , 259 ; 34 , 277 .
shoub , e. c. 1983 , astrophys .
j. , 266 , 339 . | we are interested in electrons kinetics in a stellar atmosphere to validate or invalidate the usually accepted hypothesis of thermalisation of electrons . for this purpose
, we calculate the velocity distribution function of electrons by solving the kinetic equation of these particles together with the equations of radiative transfer and statistical equilibrium .
we note that this distribution can deviate strongly from a maxwell - boltzmann distribution if non - lte effects are important .
some results and astrophysical consequences are examined . |
in the textbooks of quantum mechanics the solution of schrdinger equation and the consequent results are illustrated through simple one - dimensional potentials . for discrete bound states the square well@xcite and double wells@xcite are studied .
square well , square barrier and semi - infinite step potentials are used for studying continuous energy ( scattering ) states.@xcite a well with two side barriers is studied for understanding resonances and meta - stable states.@xcite an overlapping well adjacent to a finite barrier is a well known model for discussing discrete complex energy gamow - seigert meta - stable states @xcite in alpha decay .
students may wonder as to what happens if a non - overlapping well ( at negative energies ) is adjacent to a finite barrier ( at negative energies ) ( see figs . 1 ) . perhaps for the want of an application this system has gone undiscussed , however , interesting queries do arise for this kind of potentials
. one may wonder as to whether the well ( at negative energies ) can change ( increase / decrease ) the transmitivity of the barrier ( at positive energies ) quantitatively and significantly .
one may like to know whether there can be qualitative changes in the transmitivity of the barrier @xmath0 due to the presence of the well in some class of cases . in this article we would like to show that a well near a barrier can change the transmitivity of the barrier both quantitatively and qualitatively .
in fact a scattering potential well ( vanishing at @xmath4 ) can give rise to a non - overlapping well adjacent to a finite barrier ( nwafb ) as @xmath5 where @xmath6 see figs .
however in this case , a change in the depth of the well or its distance from the barrier would also change the height of the barrier .
consequently , the effect of the well on the transmission property of the original barrier can not come up explicitly .
we , therefore , consider wells of zero - range or finite range .
else , if they are scattering wells of infinite range on one side they ought to be joined to the barrier continuously or dis - continuously . in the following
we discuss the various possibilities for nwabf .
we construct various models of nwafb using three parameters @xmath7 and @xmath8 . here
@xmath9 is the depth of the well , @xmath10 is height of the barrier and @xmath8 denotes the separation between the well and the barrier . in these models
a change in @xmath8 does not change the depth of the well or the height of the barrier .
first let us consider both the well and the barrier of zero range .
using the zero range dirac delta potentials we construct a simple solvable model of nwafb as @xmath11 using finite range well , we construct a more general model of nwafb ( see figs .
1(b ) ) @xmath12 where @xmath13 may be chosen as constant ( square or rectangular well ) , @xmath14 ( parabolic well ) , @xmath15 ( triangular well ) , @xmath16 ( gaussian well ) or @xmath17 ( exponential well ) . it may be mentioned that in some cases @xmath10 may not represent the effective barrier height ( @xmath18maximum of @xmath19 ) .
for instance in this article we shall be choosing @xmath20 where for @xmath21 we get @xmath22 . using asymptotically converging profiles @xmath23 and @xmath24 , we construct two - parameter @xmath25 models of nwabf wherein a well of infinite range is juxtaposed to a barrier of infinite range continuously as ( see solid curve in figs
. 1(c ) ) @xmath26 and discontinuously as ( see dashed curve in figs .
1(c ) ) @xmath27 here the functions @xmath23 may be chosen as rectangular profile or as @xmath28 , @xmath29 , @xmath30 ... , and @xmath24 may be taken as @xmath31 , @xmath32 , @xmath33 , ... .
it may be mentioned that the finite range potential like @xmath34 would rather be a nwafb of type ( 3 ) with @xmath35 than of the type ( 4 ) .
next we have to solve the schrdinger equation @xmath36 for finding the transmitivity , @xmath2 , of the various potential models discussed above . when the potentials are real and hermitian the time reversal symmetry ensures that the transmitivity and reflectivity are independent of the direction of incidence of particle whether it is from left or right .
due to this symmetry , in transmission through nwafb it does not matter whether the incident particle sees the well or the barrier first .
the zero range delta potential model of nwafb is exactly solvable .
we solve the schrdinger equation ( 6 ) for this potential , @xmath37 given in eq .
( 1 ) using just plane waves : @xmath38 as usual .
let the direction of incidence of the particle at the potential be from the left hand , we can write @xmath39 the wavefunction ( 7 ) has to be continuous at @xmath40 and 0 . however , due the point singularity at @xmath41 in delta functions in eq .
( 2 ) , there occurs a mis - match in the first derivative ( see problem no . 20 and 21 in ref.@xcite ) of the wavefunction we get @xmath42-ik[c e^{-ikd } - d e^{ikd } ] = -{2 m \over \hbar^2 } v_w [ c e^{-ikd } + d e^{ikd } ] , \nonumber \\ & & c+d = f,\nonumber \\ & & ik[(c - d)-f]={2 m \over \hbar^2 } v_b f.\end{aligned}\ ] ] by eliminating @xmath43 and @xmath44 from eq .
( 8) , we get @xmath45 these ratios give us the reflectivity @xmath46 and the transmitivity @xmath47 . when @xmath48 the numerator of @xmath49 in eq .
( 9 ) becomes @xmath50 which gives rise reflectivity zeros when @xmath51 these are the positions of transmission resonances with @xmath52 when either of @xmath9 and @xmath10 is zero , from eq .
( 9 ) we get ( see problem no . 21 in @xcite ) @xmath53 this is a particular feature of the delta potential well or barrier that their transmission co - efficients are identical . for all our calculations we choose @xmath54 , so that energies and lengths are in arbitrary units . in figs .
2(a ) , both @xmath2 and @xmath1 are plotted as a function of energy , @xmath55 , when @xmath56 .
see the interesting energy - oscillations in solid curve that represent the transmitivity of the total potential @xmath37 : a perturbed barrier . when compared with the transmitivity of the dirac delta barrier ( see the dotted curve ) these energy oscillations in @xmath2
can be seen to be riding around @xmath1 even at large energies ( @xmath57 ) .
we find that the smaller values of @xmath9 ( than 1 ) create only small excursions ( ripples ) around the smooth variation of @xmath1 .
the depth of the well @xmath9 governs the amplitude of these oscillations . in figs .
2(c ) see that the frequency of these energy - oscillations remain the same but their amplitudes are larger as @xmath9 is increased and made equal to 5@xmath58 .
compare figs .
2(a ) with figs . 2(c ) and figs .
2(b ) with figs .
2(d ) to appreciate the effect of the increase in the depth of the well resulting in the increase of amplitude of oscillations .
we find that the frequency of these oscillations is governed by the value of @xmath8 .
larger the value of @xmath8 , more is the frequency of oscillations .
compare figs .
2(a ) with figs . 2(b ) and figs .
2(c ) with figs . 2(d ) to appreciate the effect of the increase in @xmath8 .
this simple and exactly solvable model of nwafb suggests that a well near a barrier neither increases nor decreases the transmitivity of the barrier .
most interestingly , it does both and hence energy oscillations in @xmath2 .
increase in the frequency of these oscillations due to increase in @xmath8 ( perturbation moving away ) is paradoxical .
the question arising here is whether energy oscillations in @xmath2 is the essence of nwafb of some type or a particular feature of extremely thin delta potentials making up @xmath37 ( 2 ) .
we therefore need to study the other models given eqs .
( 1,3 - 5 ) . as the other models of nwafb
are not solvable analytically , in the following we discuss a numerical procedure to find @xmath2 .
when the potentials vanish asymptotically one can calculate its transmission co - efficient by solving the schr " odinger equation numerically for scattering solutions .
we propose to solve eq .
( 6 ) using runge - kutta method@xcite of step by step integration ( see appendix ) .
this method consists of solving two first order , linear , one dimensional coupled differential equations @xmath59 , \quad { dz(x)\over dx}=g[x , y(x),z(x ) ] , \quad y(0)=c_1 , \quad z(0)=c_2.\ ] ] in this setting , we introduce @xmath60 and @xmath61 and split the schrdinger equation in two first order coupled linear differential equations as @xmath62y(x).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the schr " odinger equation which is a second order differential equation will have two linearly independent solutions as @xmath63 and @xmath64 .
we start the numerical integration from @xmath65 using the two sets of initial values as ( see problem no . 22 in ref.@xcite and ref.@xcite )
@xmath66 such that the wronskian function @xmath67=\psi_1(x ) \psi_2^\prime(x)- \psi_1^\prime(x ) \psi_2(x)=1 $ ] which is known to be a constant of motion . here
the prime denotes first differentiation with respect to @xmath68 . on the right
, the rk - integration is carried up to ( say ) @xmath69 for the case of a finite range barrier @xmath70 in @xmath71 ( 3 ) . for infinite range cases like @xmath72 ( 4 ) and @xmath73 ( 5 ) rk - integration
is to be carried up to ( say ) @xmath74 such that @xmath75 is very small .
similarly , on the other side , the rk - integration is to be carried up to @xmath76 in case of @xmath71 . in case of @xmath72 ( 4 ) and @xmath73 ( 5 )
we integrate up to ( say ) @xmath77 .
let us denote the end values @xmath78 as @xmath79 , respectively .
the end values @xmath80 are denoted as @xmath81 , respectively .
as rk - integration is step by step method wherein the calculated value of the function , @xmath82 , and its slope ( momentum ) @xmath83 at one step serve as initial values for the next step .
this suits quantal calculations wherein the wavefunction and its derivative must match everywhere in the domain of the potential .
importantly , then it does not matter whether or not the potential is continuous or has a finite jump discontinuity at one or more number of points in the domain of the potential .
we finally write the solution of eq .
( 6 ) as @xmath84 in case of @xmath72 ( 4 ) and @xmath73 ( 5 ) , the distances @xmath85 and @xmath86 will be replaced by @xmath87 and @xmath88 , respectively .
next by matching @xmath82 and @xmath89 at these points we get @xmath90 solving eqs .
( 15 ) , we get @xmath91 here we have used the constancy of the wronskian @xmath92=w[\phi_1,\phi_2]=1 $ ] .
the transmitivity ( transmission probability ) of the total the nwafb is given by @xmath2 as in above equation .
this may be denoted fully as @xmath93 where @xmath1 denotes the transmitivity of the ( unperturbed ) barrier and @xmath94 and @xmath8 may be taken to act as perturbation parameters .
using the eq . ( 16 ) , we calculate the transmitivity of various analytically intractable models given in section iii .
let us discuss the nwafb represented by @xmath71 in eq .
3 presents @xmath2 and @xmath1 when @xmath13 is a rectangular well in @xmath71 ( see dotted well in figs .
the form of the barrier is fixed as @xmath95 and its parameter @xmath21 this gives @xmath96 as about 5 units . in figs .
3(a ) , we see only marginal excursions in @xmath2 when the well is shallow , wide and distant . when the well is deeper but juxtaposed to the barrier ( @xmath35 ) the frequency of oscillations decreases ( see figs .
when the well is away from the barrier , @xmath2 is more oscillatory compare figs .
3(b ) with figs .
when the depth of the well is increased to 10 units ( @xmath97 ) the amplitude of the oscillations increases ( see figs .
3(d ) ) . in nwabf
the essence is that the oscillations in @xmath2 are seen riding around @xmath1 . in other words
the well induces oscillations in the transmitivity of the adjacent barrier .
we would like to remark that a piecewise constant potential mentioned in ref.@xcite ( see eq . ( 22 ) there ) can now be seen as a nwafb of the type ( 3 ) , wherein both the well and the barrier are square ( rectangular ) and @xmath2 is oscillatory ( see fig . 5 there ) .
next we study parabolic well in @xmath71 ( 3 ) . in figs .
4(a ) , this time we find that the well - depth has to be comparable to the barrier height of 5 units for changing @xmath2 appreciably when compared to @xmath1 .
the effect of increase in the depth of the well can be seen to enhance the amplitude of of oscillations in @xmath2 by comparing figs .
4(a ) with figs .
@xmath2 in figs .
4(b ) is less oscillatory as compared to that in figs .
4(c ) because the well and barrier are juxtaposed to each other with @xmath35 .
so in this model too the energy oscillations occurring in @xmath2 are due to increase in the width or depth of the well or its distance from the barrier
. however , these oscillations are less prominent than those of rectangular potential model seen in figs .
the general feature of the nwabf of the type @xmath71 ( 3 ) that the transmitivity is more oscillatory when a thinner barrier is away from the well is well demonstrated when one compares figs .
4(c ) and figs .
. the oscillations in the transmitivity of rectangular and parabolic models of nwafb ( 3 ) may be attributed @xcite to their finite range ( finite support ) and also to the distance @xmath8 over which the potential being zero allows the interference of plane waves .
further , the prominence of oscillations in @xmath2 of rectangular model lies in the fact that rectangular potential well or barriers are most localized profiles between two points than any other profile of finite support@xcite .
5 , displays the qualitatively similar oscillatory transmitivity when quite thin wells ( @xmath98 ) are used in nwafb of the type given by @xmath71 in eq .
the depths of the wells and their distances from the barrier are fixed as @xmath99 and @xmath100 , respectively .
these wells taken here are rectangular , parabolic , gaussian , and triangular ( see the line below eq .
( 3 ) ) . from this fig . 5
we conclude that quite thin wells despite being away from the barrier can induce prominent oscillations in @xmath2 provided they are sufficiently deep .
if not so deep the amplitude of oscillations will be small .
now we study two more modifications of nwafb which are made up of scattering potentials of infinite range
. these are @xmath72 ( 4 ) and @xmath73 ( 5 ) . in the case of @xmath72 ( see solid curve in figs . 1(c ) ) when the well and the barrier are juxtaposed continuously at @xmath65 , we find ( see figs .
6(a ) ) that if the well is strong it reduces the transmitivity and then increases it only marginally at energies below the barrier . at energies above the barrier height the changes are inappreciable . in the dis - continuous case
( see dashed curve in figs .
1(c ) ) , we find that the hidden well reduces @xmath2 over all ( below and above the barrier ) energies ( see figs
. 6(b ) ) .
this is the characteristic feature of the potential being discontinuous at a point ( @xmath65 ) as the well and the barrier are juxtaposed there in a discontinuous way as in the case of a simple potential step@xcite .
also the well reduces transmitivity of the barrier in an appreciable way only if it is strong ( e.g. , @xmath101 ) .
we have confirmed absence of energy oscillations in these two models by varying @xmath9 and @xmath10 high and low abundantly .
moreover , in this regard the exact analytic expression @xcite @xmath2 of the scarf ii potential ( @xmath102 ) readily testifies to a non - oscillatory behaviour of nwafb of the type ( 4 ) as a function of energy @xmath103},\ ] ] with @xmath104 , @xmath105 , @xmath106 , and @xmath107 .
however , in the above models @xmath72 ( 4 ) and @xmath73 ( 5 ) if the well and barrier are separated by a distance , @xmath8 , the transmitivity will again acquire oscillations .
we would like to emphasize that it is the separation between the well and the barrier that plays a crucial role in causing energy - excursions ( oscillations ) in @xmath2 with respect to @xmath1 .
6(c , d ) demonstrate that in case of single piece nwafb ( 1 ) when @xmath108 and @xmath109 it requires a very deep well @xmath110 to get even small excursions in @xmath2 with respect to @xmath1 .
appreciable energy oscillations can be seen in @xmath2 only if the well is much deeper ( @xmath111 ) .
this feature is surprising in view of the fact that the nwafb of the types ( eqs .
( 2,3 ) ) in figs .
2 - 5 have displayed good energy oscillations even if @xmath9 is twice of @xmath10 or even less than @xmath10 .
in all the results presented in figs . 2 - 6 ( see the dotted curve ) , in nwabf the general trend of @xmath2 is determined by the barrier is irrespective of the strength of the well .
broadly , three ( eqs .
( 1 - 3 ) ) types of nwafb ( see figs .
1 ) entailing single well and a single barrier are possible . however , one has choices of the profiles for the well and the barrier in them .
apart from the results of various profiles presented here in figs .
( 2 - 6 ) we have also studied several other profiles and explored various parametric regimes in all three types of nwabf to confirm our findings presented here .
the transmission through a barrier is the phenomenon of positive energy continuum , we conclude that the well ( at negative energies ) essentially causes energy - excursions ( ripples or oscillations ) in the transmitivity of the barrier .
howsoever strong the well is the trend of transmitivity as a function of energy is determined only by the barrier .
ordinarily , the finite support(range ) of the well may also be attributed@xcite to cause energy oscillations in the transmitivity . in this regard ,
the energy - oscillations in the transmitivity of one - piece smooth potential ( 1 ) of infinite range found here are unexpected .
however , it has required the well depth to be extremely large ( see figs .
the separation between the well and the barrier is _ sufficient _ if not the _ necessary _ condition in giving rise to oscillations in transmitivity .
when the well and the barrier are separated away , the potential in the intermediate region is zero .
this gives a scope for destructive and constructive interference of plane waves and hence the frequency of energy - oscillations in the transmitivity increases .
however , if one views the well as a perturbation to the barrier then the enhanced oscillations in @xmath2 despite the well being distant is paradoxical .
the infinite range well and barrier if joined at a point with no separation ( @xmath35 ) between them do not seem to have energy - oscillations in transmitivity until they are separated .
the energy - oscillations in transmitivity at energy below the barrier suggests a novelty because usually transmitivity is found@xcite to be oscillatory at energies above the barrier .
the transmitivity of various potential systems which converge asymptotiacally @xmath112 to zero or to a constant value and which are either continuous or entail finite jump discontinuities can be found using eq .
( 16 ) presented here . in this article
we have presented the first and hopefully an exhaustive study of transmission through non - overlapping well adjacent to a finite barrier .
we hope that this investigation will be found pedagogically valuable .
[ [ section ] ] the runge - kutta@xcite solution of the coupled first order equations @xmath113 are obtained as @xmath114 and @xmath115 starting with the initial values @xmath116 using the following equations .
@xmath117 , \quad z_{n+1}=z_n+{h \over 6}[m_1 + 2m_2 + 2m_3+m_4],~ n \ge 0,~h={d \over n}\nonumber \\ & & k_1=f(x_n , y_n , z_n ) , \quad m_1=g(x_n , y_n , z_n)\nonumber \\ & & k_2=f(x_n+h/2,y_n+h k_1/2,z_n+h k_1/2 ) , \quad m_2=g(x_n+h/2,y_n+h m_1/2,z_n+h m_1/2 ) \nonumber \\ & & k_3=f(x_n+h/2,y_n+h k_2/2,x_n+h k_2/2 ) ,
\quad m_3=g(x_n+h/2,y_n+h m_2/2,x_n+h m_2/2 ) \nonumber \\ & & k_4=f(x_n+h , y_n+h k_3 , z_n+h k_3 ) , \quad m_4=g(x_n+h , y_n+ h m_3 , z_n+h m_3).\end{aligned}\ ] ] when we solve ( 11 ) for @xmath118 , we get @xmath63 and @xmath119 and we get @xmath64 and @xmath120 when the starting values are @xmath118 .
l. i. schiff,_quantum mechanics _
( mcgraw hill , sydney , 1968 ) ch . 2 and 5 .
e. merzbacher , _ quantum mechanics _ ( john wiely and sons , inc .
, new - york , 1970 ) ch . 5 and 6 .
d. rapp , _ quantum mechanics _ ( holt , rinehart and winston , inc .
, new - york , 1970 ) ch . 6 , 7 and 8 .
s. flugge , _ practical quantum mechanics _
( springer - verlag , berlin , 1971 ) ch .
a. bhom , m. gadella , g.b .
mainland , ` gamow vectors and decaying states ' , am j , phys .
* 57 * 1989 1103 - 1108 .
john a. jacquez , a first course in computing and numerical methods ( addison wesley publishing company , london , 1070 ) 340 . j. d. chalk , ` a study of barrier penetration in quantum mechanics ' am
. j. phys .
* 56 * ( 1988 ) 29 - 32 .
a. uma maheswari , p. prema , and c. s. shastry , ` resonant states and transmission co - efficient oscillations for potential wells and barriers ' , am .
* 78 * , ( 2009 ) 412 - 417 .
z. ahmed , ` comment on : ` resonant states and transmission co - efficient oscillations for potential wells and barriers ' by a. uma maheswari , p. prema , and c. s. shastry am .
* 78 * , ( 2009 ) 412 - 417 ' am .
79 ( 2011 ) 682 - 683
. m. v. berry , semi - classically weak reflection above analytic and non - analytic potential barriers , " j. phys .
a : math . gen . * 15 * , 36933704 ( 1982 ) .
+ l. v. chebotarev , transmission spectra for one - dimensional potentials in semi - classical approximation , " phys .
a * 52 * , 107124 ( 1995 ) .
+ z. ahmed ,
reflectionlessness , kurtosis and top - curvature of potential barriers , " j. phys .
gen . * 39 * , 73417348 ( 2006 ) .
+ z. ahmed , c. m. bender , and m. v. berry , reflectionless potentials and pt - symmetry , " j. phys .
a : math . gen . * 38 * , l627l630 ( 2005 ) .
+ ( 3 ) : parabolic well ( dashed line ) , rectangular well ( dotted line ) and very thin rectangular well near a barrier , ( c ) @xmath121 ( 4 ) : a smooth well continuously juxtaposed to a barrier ( solid line ) and @xmath122 ( 5 ) : a smooth well discontinuously juxtaposed to the a barrier . ] , of the delta potential model @xmath123 of nwafb ( 2 ) .
the dotted curve represent the transmitivity , @xmath1 , of the barrier only .
we have a fixed barrier height @xmath124 and take(a ) : @xmath125 , ( b ) : @xmath126 , ( c ) @xmath127 , ( d ) @xmath128 . ] ( 3 ) . here
the barrier @xmath129 is perturbed by a rectangular ( square ) well .
the effective height of the barrier @xmath130 is approximately 5 units .
we have taken ( a ) : @xmath131 , ( b ) : @xmath132 , ( c ) : @xmath133 , ( d ) : @xmath134 . ] ( 3 ) . here in general the energy - oscillations in @xmath2
are present but these are less prominent than those in figs . 2 . the same barrier(@xmath70 )
is now perturbed by a parabolic well of finite range .
we take ( a ) : @xmath135 , ( b ) : @xmath132 , ( c ) : @xmath133 , ( d ) : @xmath134 ] ( solid lines ) and @xmath1 ( dotted curve ) for various nwafb of the type @xmath71 ( 3 ) when the wells are quite thin(@xmath98 ) .
we have @xmath137 .
these wells are rectangular , parabolic , gaussian , and triangular used in eq .
( 3 ) ( see the text below eq ( 3 ) ) .
thin wells away from the barrier give rise to qualitatively similar transmitivity which is oscillatory .
this is an essential feature of the nwafb of the type in eqs .
( 2,3 ) . ] for ( a ) : the continuous ( 4 ) and ( b ) : the discontinuous ( 5 ) models ; the dotted line @xmath138 , thin solid line @xmath139 and thick solid line @xmath140 . figs . ( c ,
d ) represent the transmitivities for the single piece smooth nwafb ( 1 ) . for a fixed distance ( @xmath109 ) between the well and the barrier and @xmath108 figs .
( c ) shows only small excursions in @xmath2 only when the well is very deep ( @xmath141 ) . in figs .
( d ) , significant oscillations in @xmath2 have required even higher value @xmath142 ) . ] | we point out that a non - overlapping well ( at negative energies ) adjacent to a finite barrier ( at positive energies ) is a simple potential which is generally missed out while discussing the one - dimensional potentials in the textbooks of quantum mechanics .
we show that these systems present interesting situations wherein transmitivity @xmath0 of a finite barrier can be changed both quantitatively and qualitatively by varying the depth or width of the well or by changing the distance between the well and the barrier . using delta ( thin ) well near a delta ( thin ) barrier
we show that the well induces energy oscillations riding over @xmath1 in the transmitivity @xmath2 at both the energies below and above the barrier .
more generally we show that a thick well separated from a thick barrier also gives rise to energy oscillations in @xmath2 .
a well joining a barrier discontinuously ( a finite jump ) reduces @xmath2 ( as compared to @xmath3 over all energies .
when the well and barrier are joined continuously , @xmath2 increases and then decreases at energies below the barrier . at energy above the the barrier the changes are inappreciable . in these two cases
if we separate the well and the barrier by a distance , @xmath2 again acquires oscillations .
paradoxically , it turns out that a distant well induces more energy oscillations in @xmath2 than when it is near the barrier . |
core collapse of massive stars which lead to supernovae ( sne ) of type ib , c and ii are in some cases associated with long duration ( @xmath0-@xmath1 s ) gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) , as evidenced by observed correlations of grb 980425/sn 1998bw , grb 021211/sn 2002lt , grb 030329/sn 2003dh and grb 0131203/sn 2003lw.@xcite a relativistic jet with bulk lorentz factor @xmath2 , powered by a black hole and an accretion disc which form after the core collapse in the most likely scenario , is believed to lead to the grb event.@xcite observational evidence of only a small fraction of detected sne associated with grbs hints that the frequency of highly relativistic jets in core collapse sne is at best 1 in 1000 , roughly the ratio of grb to sn rates.@xcite however , a significantly larger fraction ( @xmath3 of type ib / c rate@xcite ) of sne ( also called _ hypernovae _ ) may have mildly relativistic jets associated with them.@xcite one or more of the following observations support the jetted sn hypothesis : high expansion velocity ( 30 - 40 @xmath4 km / s ) first observed in sn 1998bw.@xcite radio afterglow not associated with @xmath5-ray
emission.@xcite asymmetric explosion supported by polarimetry observations of sn type ib / c.@xcite numerical simulations of core collapse sne , carried out over the last three decades have failed to produce a successful explosion by a prompt shock wave created due to the collapse of its iron core.@xcite the deposition of bulk kinetic energy in a jet form into the stellar envelope may help disrupt and blow it up making the sn possible.@xcite the presence of a jet is also conducive to shock acceleration of particles . in case of a grb , internal shocks of plasma material along the jet accelerate protons and electrons which radiate observed @xmath5-rays.@xcite high energy protons may escape as cosmic rays and/or produce 100 tev neutrinos by interacting with @xmath5-rays _ in situ_.@xcite while the grb jet is making its way out of the collapsing stellar progenitor it is expected to produce 10 tev neutrio precursor burst.@xcite these neutrinos are emitted even in the cases when the jets do not manage to burrow through the stellar envelope and choke inside without producing observable @xmath5-rays .
the jets in core collapse sne or hypernovae which is the topic of this review are slow with @xmath6 few and choke inside the stellar envelope.@xcite neutrinos produce from such jets are typically of a hundred gev to tev energy.@xcite as opposed to 10 mev thermal neutrinos produced by the core collapse sn shocks which have been detected from sn 1987a in our own galaxy,@xcite high energy neutrinos from the jets may be detected from a longer distance because of an increasing detection prospect with neutrino energy .
kilometer scale ice and water cherenkov detectors such as icecube@xcite and antares@xcite which are currently being built in antarctica and in the mediterranean will have an excellent chance to detect these neutrinos from sne within the nearest 20 mpc .
the organization of this brief review is as follows : in sec .
[ sec : core - collapse ] a basic core collapse sn picture is outlined and a particular slow jet model in sec .
[ sec : jet - model ] . shock acceleration and the maximum energy reachable by protons are discussed in sec .
[ sec : proton - acc ] .
neutrino flux on earth from a point source and diffuse sources is calculated in sec .
[ sec : nu - flux ] and their detection prospects in sec .
[ sec : events ] .
conclusions are given in sec .
[ sec : summary ] .
nuclear fusion reactions , similar to the ones which take place in our sun , constantly enrich the interior of a star forming an iron core as the end product .
burning up all fusion materials causes hydrodynamic instability due to lack of radiation pressure from inside the star .
the immense gravitational pressure of the stellar envelope and/or overlying material causes the core of stars with mass @xmath7 to collapse at this point .
the density of the compressed core material reaches a few times the nuclear density and a rising temperature helps iron dissociate into nucleons and alpha particles .
infall of stellar material onto the core produces @xmath8 mev neutrinos by the process of electron capture on protons ( @xmath9 ) .
the density of neutrons in the core exceeds that of protons in this process , called _ neutronization_.
initially the neutrinos are trapped within a radius called _ neutrinosphere _ because of a density @xmath10 g-@xmath11 . for progenitors of mass @xmath12 , the increasing degeneracy pressure of the neutrons leads to a rebound , which sends a shockwave through the core .
while traversing through the core , the shockwave heats up material , dissociates more iron atoms and releases trapped @xmath13 from the neutrinosphere .
neutrinos carry away @xmath14 erg of energy or roughly @xmath15 of the total gravitational binding energy in this bursting phase which lasts for a few milliseconds .
the shockwave , however , does not reach the envelope to drive it away because of heavy energy loss and the star fails to explode into a supernova .
the mechanisms envisaged to produce a successful supernova explosion , such as observed in nature , may be divided into two main categories despite many uncertainties such as the mass loss rate of the pre - supernova star and neutrino transport in the core , to name a few .
the first is a _ revived shock _ model , for stars initially less massive than @xmath16 , where the core collapses to make a neutron star . in this case , the above - mentioned stalled supernova shock is re - energized by neutrino absorption on nucleons outside the stellar core ( @xmath17 ; @xmath18 ) , re - energizing them .
the shock wave then reaches the envelope and expels it away . after the supernova explosion ,
the stellar core cools down in next 10 s of seconds by emitting @xmath19 erg of energy in neutrinos of all flavors created by lepton pair annihilation ( @xmath20 ) , neutrino pair annihilation ( @xmath21 ) and nucleon bremsstrahlung ( @xmath22 ) .
these neutrinos are thermal with a typical energy @xmath8 mev .
a neutron star is left over after the stellar core cools down , following ejection of the envelope and outer core . in the second scenario , which is the relevant case for the current review , a star initially more massive than @xmath23 undergoes core collapse .
( a ) if the initial mass is @xmath24 , the core collapses initially to a neutron star , but after fall - back of additional core gas which did not reach ejection velocity , it collapses further to a black hole ( bh ) of mass in excess of the chandrasekhar mass ( the neutron degeneracy pressure not being sufficient to counteract gravity for this mass ) .
( b ) if the initial mass @xmath25 , the core collapses directly to a black hole of mass @xmath26 ( see ref .
thermal neutrinos of @xmath27 mev are also produced in the neutronized core , before it falls into the black hole .
this neutrino luminosity , of order several solar luminosities , may or may not be able to eject ( via absorption in re - energization ) the outer envelope , which is needed in order for it to appear as supernova detectable by its photon emission . as in the case of stars of mass @xmath28 , numerical simulations have not yet been able to prove whether stars in this mass range eject their envelope ; and , observationally , it is unclear whether any observed supernova can be ascribed to progenitors in this mass range .
however , stars more massive than @xmath16 are certainly observed , and from well understood physics , they must core - collapse to a black hole .
this is the gist of what happens to stars of mass @xmath29 if the stellar core is rotating slowly .
a black hole , and possibly a temporary small accretion disk is formed after core collapse , which may not greatly affect the symmetry of the collapse and/or envelope ejection .
the situation is thought to be drastically different for stars in the range @xmath30 whose core is fast - rotating.@xcite in particular , for a core angular momentum in the range ( 3 - 20)@xmath31 @xmath32 s@xmath33 for this model , the black hole and disk accretion can serve as an energy source for powering a long grb , and may be able to eject a stellar envelope with kinetic energies possibly 10 - 100 times higher ( at least in an isotropic - equivalent sense ) than the energy of typical type ib / c or type ii sne .
fast core rotation also helps in forming low density channels along the rotation axis , by centrifugal evacuation .
part of the material accreting from the disc onto the black hole can then be ejected as narrow jets along the axes , collimated by the gas pressure of the envelope .
the jets are powered by neutrino annihilation or magnetohydrodynamic stresses .
the pressure and energy deposition from the jet helps eject the star s envelope and thus the sn explosion happens . in the case of a highly relativistic jet which manages to break through the stellar envelope , the grb event takes place outside the star in an optically thin environment . a slow jet , which is modelled in the next section ,
may never break through , but the ejected material can give rise to an `` orphan '' radio afterglow which is not associated with @xmath5-ray emission .
however , non - thermal high energy ( @xmath34 tev ) neutrinos are produced ubiquitously in both cases .
the pre - supernova star , after losing its outermost envelope , is typically a wolf - rayet star of radius @xmath35 cm in the case of a type ib or larger in the case of a type ii supernova .
the mildly relativistic sn jet may be modelled inside the pre - supernova star ( see fig .
[ fig : slowjet ] ) with a bulk lorentz factor @xmath36 and a total jet kinetic energy @xmath37 ergs which is @xmath38 of the total energy released in the sn explosion .
because of its relativistic motion , the jet is most likely beamed with an opening half angle @xmath39 which is much wider compared to a grb jet of @xmath40 . assuming a duration @xmath41 s , the isotropic equivalent kinetic luminosity of the jet is @xmath42 . with a jet variability time scale @xmath43 s at the base , internal shocks between plasma materials moving along the jet occur at a radius @xmath44 cm , which is below the stellar surface .
[ t ] = 3.in internal shocks convert a fraction @xmath45 of the bulk kinetic energy ( @xmath46 ) into random electron motion analogous to the grb fireball models . in the case of grbs
, these relativistic electrons would emit synchrotron photons in an optically thin environment , which are observed as @xmath5-rays on earth .
the density of these electrons and baryons ( since they are coupled to the baryons ) in the jet may be estimated as n_e n_p 10 ^ 20.5 cm^-3 , [ particle - density ] in the comoving jet frame .
the opacity to thomson scattering by photons _th 10 ^ 6.6 [ thomson - opacity ] in the comoving frame is then very high .
the magnetic fields in the jet , built up by turbulent motions in the shock region , have an energy characterized as a fraction @xmath47 of the total jet energy , @xmath48 .
the corresponding magnetic field strength in the jet is given by b ( ) ^1/2 10 ^ 9 ( ) ^1/2 g. [ b - field ] electrons and protons are expected to be accelerated to high energies in the internal shocks , via the fermi mechanism .
the electrons cool down rapidly by synchrotron radiation in the presence of the magnetic field in eq .
( [ b - field ] ) .
however , due to the large thomson optical depth in eq .
( [ thomson - opacity ] ) , these photons thermalize and the corresponding black - body temperature is e _ ( ) ^1/4 4.3 ( ) ^1/4 kev .
[ bb - phot - energy ] the volume number density of these thermal photons may be roughly calculated as n _ 10 ^ 24.8 ( ) ^1/4 cm^-3 .
[ bb - phot - density ] it may be noted that photons from the shocked stellar plasma do not diffuse into the jet due to the high optical depth @xmath49 in eq .
( [ thomson - opacity ] ) , and the number density in eq .
( [ bb - phot - density ] ) is roughly constant .
the shock acceleration time for a proton of energy @xmath50 is proportional to its larmor s radius and may be estimated as t_acc 10 ^ -12 ( ) ( ) ^1/2 s , [ proton - acc - time ] where @xmath51 and the magnetic field in eq .
( [ b - field ] ) was used .
the maximum proton energy is limited by requiring this time not to exceed the dynamic time scale for the shock to cross plasma material : @xmath52 , or any other possible proton cooling process time scale which we discuss next .
the cooling time scale for protons by synchrotron radiation in the same magnetic field which is responsible for its acceleration is given by t_syn 3.8 ( ) ^-1 ( ) s , [ proton - syn - cool ] with @xmath53 .
inverse compton ( ic ) scattering of thermal electron synchrotron photons is another cooling channel for high energy protons .
the ic cooling time scale in the thomson and klein - nishina ( kn ) regimes , valid for @xmath50 much less or greater than @xmath54 gev respectively , as t_ic , th = 3.8 ( ) ^-1 ( ) s + t_ic , kn = 10 ^ -10.5 ( ) ( ) ^1/2 s. [ proton - ic - cool ] here we used the thermal photons with peak energy and density given in eqs .
( [ bb - phot - energy ] ) and ( [ bb - phot - density ] ) respectively as targets . because of a high density of thermal photons in the sn jet in eq .
( [ bb - phot - density ] ) , protons may produce @xmath55 pairs by interacting with them , a process known as bethe - heitler ( bh ) . the cross - section for bh
interaction : @xmath56 is given by @xmath57 - 106/9 \}$ ] .
the logarithmic increase of the cross - section with incident proton energy implies that this is a very efficient cooling mechanism for high energy protons .
the @xmath58 pairs are produced at rest in the center of mass ( c.m . )
frame of the collision and acquire an energy @xmath59 each in the comoving frame . here
@xmath60 is the lorentz boost factor of the c.m . in the comoving frame .
the energy lost by the proton in each bh interaction is thus the energy of the created pairs in the comoving frame , and is given by @xmath61 .
the energy loss rate of the proton is proportional to the bh scattering rate as given by @xmath62 , and the corresponding proton cooling time is t_bh = = , [ proton - bh - cool]in the comoving frame .
photomeson ( @xmath63 ) and proton - proton ( @xmath64 ) interactions which are responsible for producing high energy neutrinos may also serve as a cooling mechanism for the shock accelerated protons .
the @xmath63 at the @xmath65 resonance and the average @xmath64 cross - sections are @xmath66 @xmath32 and @xmath67 @xmath32 respectively .
the corresponding optical depths , given by _p & = & 10 ^ 7.8 ( ) ^1/4 and + _pp & = & 10 ^ 5.5 ( ) , [ p - opacities ] are very high . the threshold proton energy for @xmath65 production against the target thermal photons of energy @xmath68 in eq .
( [ bb - phot - energy ] ) is e_p , ^+ & = & 10 ^ 4.8 ( ) ^1/4 gev .
[ pg - energy ] adopting the energy loss by a proton @xmath69 and @xmath70 respectively for each @xmath63 and @xmath64 interaction , the hadronic cooling time scales are t_p & = & 10 ^ -7.3 ( ) ^1/4 s + t_pp & = & 10 ^ -5.6 ( ) s , [ proton - had - cool ] using eqs .
( [ bb - phot - density ] ) and ( [ particle - density ] ) .
the photomeson cooling time scale @xmath71 above is roughly valid at @xmath72 and one needs to use the thermal photon spectrum to calculate it for different proton energies . the shock acceleration time in eq .
( [ proton - acc - time ] ) for protons in the sn jet ( solid line ) and the different cooling time scales are plotted in fig .
[ fig : proton - cool - time ] as functions of the comoving proton energy .
the dashed lines are hadronic cooling time scales in eq .
( [ proton - had - cool ] ) cooling with a delta - function approximation . ] and the dot - dashed lines are electromagnetic cooling time scales in eqs .
( [ proton - syn - cool ] ) , ( [ proton - ic - cool ] ) and ( [ proton - bh - cool ] ) .
note that the hadronic cooling time ( @xmath73 ) , the bh cooling time ( @xmath74 ) and the synchrotron cooling time ( @xmath75 ) are first longer and then shorter than the maximum proton acceleration time ( @xmath76 ) .
the hadronic ( @xmath71 ) and ic scattering ( @xmath77 ) are not efficient cooling mechanisms for protons
. the maximum proton energy can be roughly estimated , by equating the @xmath75 to @xmath76 , from eqs .
( [ proton - acc - time ] ) and ( [ proton - syn - cool ] ) as e_p , max = ( ) ^1/2 10 ^ 6.3 ( ) ^1/4 gev , [ max - proton - energy ] since @xmath78 at this energy .
[ t ] = 3.75 in
shock accelerated protons in the sn jet can produce non - thermal neutrinos by photomeson ( @xmath63 ) interactions with thermal synchrotron photons and/or by proton - proton ( @xmath64 ) interactions with cold protons present in the shock region . as shown in fig .
[ fig : proton - cool - time ] , the @xmath63 process is dominant in the energy range @xmath79 - @xmath80 gev and the @xmath64 process is dominant at other energies . in the case of @xmath63 interactions at the @xmath65 resonance ,
neutrinos are produced from charged pion ( @xmath81 ) decay as @xmath82 .
the @xmath64 interactions also produce charged pions ( @xmath83 ) and kaons ( @xmath84 ) and their decay modes are the same as above with @xmath85 and @xmath86 branching ratios respectively .
and @xmath87 decay modes are charge conjugate of @xmath81 and @xmath88 decay modes . ]
the total pion ( kaon ) multiplicity in each @xmath64 interaction is @xmath89 ( @xmath90 ) in the energy range considered here.@xcite the energy of the shock accelerated protons in the sn jet is expected to be distributed as @xmath91 , following the standard shock acceleration models .
charged mesons , produced by @xmath64 and @xmath63 interactions , are expected to follow the proton spectrum with @xmath92 of the proton energy for each pion or kaon .
high - energy pions , kaons and muons produced by @xmath63 and @xmath64 interactions do not all decay to neutrinos as electromagnetic ( synchrotron radiation and ic scattering ) and hadronic ( @xmath93 and @xmath94 interactions ) cooling mechanisms reduce their energy .
muons are severely suppressed by electromagnetic energy losses and do not contribute much to high - energy neutrino production .
suppression factors for pion and kaon decay neutrinos are discussed next .
the synchrotron and ic cooling times may be combined into a single electromagnetic cooling rate as @xmath95 . for ic cooling in the thomson regime @xmath96 and in the kn regime @xmath97 .
the electromagnetic cooling time scales for mesons may be estimated assuming @xmath98 for simplicity as t_em ( ) s. [ meson - emcool - time ] the hadronic energy losses for mesons is similar to the proton energy losses by @xmath64 interactions in eq .
( [ proton - had - cool ] ) with the same @xmath93 and @xmath94 cross - section of @xmath99 @xmath32 .
the corresponding hadronic cooling time scales for mesons are t_had 10 ^ -5.4 ( ) s , [ meson - hadcool - time ] with @xmath100 the electromagnetic ( @xmath101 ) and hadronic ( @xmath102 ) cooling time scales for mesons along with their decay times boosted by the respective lorentz factors , @xmath103 , are plotted in fig .
[ fig : meson - cool - time ] .
the total cooling time scale @xmath104 is first dominated by the hadronic and then by the electromagnetic cooling channel .
the ratio @xmath105 determines the suppression of mesons before they decay to neutrinos .
[ t ] = 3.75 in from the condition @xmath106 , one may roughly define a break energy as e_br = [ meson - break - energy ] above and below which the mesons cool by electromagnetic and hadronic interactions respectively .
the corresponding suppression factor may be defined from the ratios @xmath107 and @xmath108 as = ; = [ suppression - factor ] another break energy may be defined from the condition @xmath109 below which mesons decay to neutrinos without any suppression . however
, this energy : @xmath110 and @xmath111 gev respectively for pions and kaons in the comoving frame is low .
the observed energy on earth in both cases is below the detection threshold energy as will be discussed shortly .
if the shock accelerated protons could travel unimpeded from the sn jet at a luminosity distance @xmath112 , then their isotropic equivalent fluence on earth would be _ p , ob = .
[ proton - flux ] here @xmath113 and @xmath114 are the energy and time related in the observer s and local rest frames for the source location at redshift @xmath115
. of course , defelction by magnetic fields as well as other interactions along the way prevent such direct arrivale of the protons .
nearly all protons are expected to convert into @xmath81 ( @xmath83 ) by @xmath63 ( @xmath64 ) interactions in the sn jet because @xmath116 ( @xmath117 ) in eq .
( [ p - opacities ] ) and assuming the charged pion multiplicity is @xmath89 from @xmath64 interactions as a conservative estimate . with a @xmath85 branching ratio for pion decay to neutrinos
, one may define a multiplicative factor @xmath118 for protons which will produce neutrinos via pions . a similar factor @xmath119
may be defined for kaons as a product of @xmath84 multiplicity of @xmath90 from @xmath64 interactions and @xmath86 branching ratio for kaon decay to neutrinos .
protons produce neutral pions ( kaons ) and charged pions ( kaons ) with equal probability in both the @xmath63 and @xmath64 interactions .
interactions only . ] for simplicity one may also assume that a @xmath120 carries 1/4 of the charged pion ( kaon ) energy : @xmath121 , from roughly equipartition of energy between the final decay products of @xmath83 and @xmath84 .
from these considerations one may estimate the neutrino ( of one flavor ) fluence on earth as _ , ob & = & ( ) ^- , [ nu - fluence - formula ] per sn burst using eqs .
( [ suppression - factor ] ) and ( [ proton - flux ] ) . here
@xmath122 ( @xmath123 ) for @xmath124 greater ( less ) than @xmath125 from eq .
( [ meson - break - energy ] ) .
the pre - factors in eq .
( [ suppression - factor ] ) are represented by the parameters @xmath126 and @xmath127 respectively for pions and kaons . for a typical ice cherenkov detector such as icecube ,
the threshold neutrino detection energy is @xmath128 gev .
the neutrino energy range is then @xmath129 - @xmath130 - @xmath131 - @xmath132 gev in the observer s frame on earth .
as mentioned earlier , @xmath81 s are produced by @xmath64 or @xmath63 interactions by shock accelerated protons of all energies . in this case @xmath81
decay @xmath120 fluence from a sn at a distance @xmath133 mpc ( @xmath134 cm , @xmath135 ) , e.g. from the virgo cluster , would be _ , , ob^ * & & 10 ^ -5 ( ) ^-4 gev^-1cm^-2 ; + & & 10 ^ 2.5 e_,ob / gev 10 ^ 5.5 , [ nuflux - pi - numbers ] from eq .
( [ nu - fluence - formula ] ) with @xmath136 . the neutrino break energy from pion decay : @xmath137 gev in this case .
a similar expression may be derived for neutrino fluence from kaon decays . however , @xmath64 interactions are overwhelmed by @xmath63 interactions in the energy range @xmath79-@xmath80 gev ( fig .
[ fig : proton - cool - time ] ) . hence kaon and the corresponding decay neutrino production
is expected to be suppressed in the energy range @xmath138-@xmath139 gev . the neutrino break energy from eq .
( [ meson - break - energy ] ) is @xmath140 gev and the fluence is _ , k , ob^ * & & 10 ^ -11.7 ( ) ^-(+2 ) gev^-1cm^-2 ; + & & = [ nuflux - k - numbers ] on earth from kaon decays in a sn jet at a distance @xmath141 mpc .
the diffuse neutrino flux is calculated by summing over fluences from all slow - jet endowed sne distributed over cosmological distances in hubble time .
the sne rate follows closely the star formation rate ( sfr ) which can be modeled , as a function of redshift per unit comoving volume,@xcite as _ * ( z ) = m
_ yr^-1 mpc^-3 .
[ sfr ] here @xmath142 km s@xmath33 mpc@xmath33 is the hubble constant .
for a friedmann - robertson - walker universe , the comoving volume element is = | cosmic time @xmath143 is ( dt / dz)^-1 = -h_0 ( 1+z ) .
[ redshift - time ] for the standard @xmath144cdm cosmology , @xmath145 and @xmath146 .
the number of sne per unit star forming mass ( @xmath147 ) depends on the initial mass function and the threshold for stellar mass to produce sn ( @xmath148 m@xmath149 ) .
a salpeter model @xmath150 with different power - law indices can generate different values for @xmath147 , e.g. @xmath151 m@xmath152 for @xmath153 and @xmath154 m@xmath152 for @xmath155.@xcite we adopt the model in ref .
which corresponds to the local type ii sne rate @xmath156 yr@xmath33 mpc@xmath157 agreeing with data.@xcite the distribution of sne per unit cosmic time @xmath143 and solid angle @xmath158 covered on the sky can be written as = = | | .
[ sn - dist ] we assume a fraction @xmath159 of all sne involve jets and a fraction @xmath160 of all such jets are pointing towards us .
the observed diffuse sne neutrino flux , using eqs .
( [ nu - fluence - formula ] ) and ( [ sn - dist ] ) , is then _ , ob^diff & = & _ 0^ dz f_,ob ( e_,ob ) + & = & _ 0^ dz | | ( ) ^- + & & ( e _ , th e_,ob e _ , ob , max ) .
[ diff - nu - flux ] with @xmath161 specified as before .
the diffuse @xmath120 flux from all cosmological slow - jet sne is plotted in fig .
[ fig : nuflux ] by numerically integrating eq .
( [ diff - nu - flux ] ) , assuming the maximal fraction @xmath162 .
the pion ( kaon ) decay flux is plotted with thick solid ( dashed ) line(s ) .
the exponential suppression in the kaon decay @xmath120 flux curves is due to the lack of kaon production by @xmath64 interactions , as @xmath63 interactions , which do not produce kaons , are dominant in the particular proton energy range corresponding to this neutrino energy range , @xmath163-@xmath139 gev .
the light dashed curve corresponds to the kaon decay @xmath120 flux if @xmath64 interaction dominates over the whole proton energy range for comparison .
the kaon decay neutrino fluxes are first smaller and then larger than the pion decay neutrino flux .
this is because of the kaon s heavier mass and shorter decay time compared to pions ( see fig .
[ fig : meson - cool - time ] ) .
[ t ] = 3.75 in the atmospheric @xmath120 , @xmath164 flux from pion and kaon decays ( conventional flux ) compatible with amanda data@xcite is plotted with the following parametrization@xcite _ , ob^atm = [ atmo - nu - flux ] also shown are the cosmic ray bounds ( wb limits ) on the diffuse neutrino flux.@xcite it is unlikely that neutrino detectors can measure the sne diffuse fluxes plotted in figure [ fig : nuflux ] , as they are below the atmospheric background .
however , individual sne in nearby galaxies may be detectable , as discussed in the next section .
there are approximately 4000 galaxies known within 20 mpc distance . at the standard rate of 1 snu = @xmath165/yr/@xmath166 blue solar luminosity for average galaxies ,
the estimated sn rate is @xmath167/yr . the sn rate in the starburst galaxies , such as m82 and ngc253 ( at distances 3.2 and 2.5 mpc in the northern and southern sky ,
respectively ) is @xmath90/yr , much larger than in the milkyway or in the magellanic clouds.@xcite very strong neutrino signals in future kilometer scale neutrino detectors are expected from these nearby sne , over a negligible atmospheric background , using temporal and positional coincidences with optical detections .
the directional sensitivity of the cherenkov detectors is best for muon neutrinos , which create muons by charge current neutrino - nucleon ( @xmath168 ) interactions .
muons carry @xmath169 of the incident neutrino energy .
it emits cherenkov light as it travels faster than the speed of light in the detection media .
photo multiplier tubes ( pmts ) buried in the medium ( ice , e.g. in the case of icecube ) can detect muons by gathering their cherenkov light .
the effective detection area of a cherenkov detector depends on the arrival direction of the neutrino and the energy of the muon . in principle
it can be larger than the geometrical area ( @xmath170 in the case of icecube e.g. ) as muons can be produced outside the instrumented volume and travel inside . to achieve a good pointing resolution a muon
should _ hit _ at least 4 pmts , for reconstructing its track unamiguously , strung on different vertical _ strings_. the pmt spacing is 17 m vertically and 125 m horizontally . with a muon energy loss of @xmath171 gev / m and a pmt efficiency of @xmath172 ,
the threshold energy for muon detection is @xmath173 gev as a conservative estimate .
this corresponds to a neutrino threshold energy @xmath174 gev as used before .
the icecube detector is expected to have an angular sensitivity of @xmath175 for muon tracks of energy @xmath176 tev coming from a zenith angle @xmath177 and it gets better at higher energy.@xcite the number of muon events from a nearby jetted sn may be calculated as n _ = a_det _ e_,th^e_,max p ( e _ , ) f_,;k^ * ( e _ ) de _ , [ event - rate ] where the neutrino fluences are given in eqs .
( [ nuflux - pi - numbers ] ) and ( [ nuflux - k - numbers ] ) .
the full detection probability @xmath178 depends on the source s angular position ( @xmath179 ) and hence on the earth s shadowing effect , as well as the energy dependent @xmath180 cross section.@xcite the cumulative number of muon events from m82 and ngc253 are plotted in fig .
[ fig : nuevents ] per individual sn with its jet pointing towards earth .
the @xmath120 flux models are from pion ( solid lines ) and kaon ( dashed lines ) decays in the sn jet as in fig .
[ fig : nuflux ] .
the two kaon decay models are due to the protons in the sn jet producing kaons in their whole ( thick dashed lines ) and partial ( thin dashed lines ) energy range ( see fig . [
fig : proton - cool - time ] ) .
the lower and upper sets of lines at @xmath181 gev correspond to the sn in m82 and ngc253 respectively .
the timing uncertainty in the optical detection of sn is @xmath89 day .
the corresponding atmospheric background events within @xmath175 angular resolution is 0.07 for both m82 and ngc253 in the same energy range as in fig .
[ fig : nuevents ] .
[ t ] = 3.75 in neutrino fluxes of all three flavors ( @xmath120 , @xmath182 , @xmath183 ) on earth should be equal because of oscillations over astrophysical distances .
however , only @xmath120 s are emitted from the sources under consideration and the total number of neutrino events ( including @xmath182 and @xmath183 ) will remain the same as the @xmath120 events calculated here . the lack of good directional sensitivity for the @xmath182 and @xmath183 events may prevent obtaining their positional coincidence with the sn .
timing coincidences of @xmath182 and @xmath183 events with @xmath120 events , however , may still be useful to verify the neutrino oscillations at these energies and test their common origin . at the quoted rate for m82 and ngc253 , a sn from one of these galaxies would be expected within five years .
however , only 1/5 of them would be _ visible _ in neutrinos due to the @xmath184 beaming effect of the jet .
icecube may detect one such sn in 25 years of its operation .
the real situation is not as pessimistic as for the brightest neutrino events expected from m82 and ngc253 .
other nearby spiral galaxies ( m31 , m74 , m51 , m101 , etc , and the virgo cluster ) will also have sne .
for a hypothetical sn at 20 mpc with its jet pointing towards earth , the number of neutrino events is @xmath185/km@xmath186 from pion and kaon decay fluxes combined . with the suggested rate of @xmath187 sn
/ yr within 20 mpc , icecube may detect @xmath188 muon events / yr after beaming correction from the jetted sne .
while a core collapse sn in a typical galaxy is a rare event , their rate of occurence within 20 mpc could be more than 1/yr , and the physics and astrophysics one can learn from such an explosion is enormous . a buried slow jet from the collapsing core of the supernova progenitor star is an attractive possibility for solving the long standing problem of how to understand the ejection of the envelope in sn explosions , by re - energizing the shock wave through energy deposition by the jet .
alternatively it could be that only a fraction of core collapses leads to such jets .
these hypothetical mildly relativistic jets in sne may be related to the ultra relativistic jets thought to be responsible for long duration grbs , which are thought to originate from the core collapse of massive progenitor stars , some of which have been positively associated with observed envelope ejection supernova events . while all typical core collapses should produce 10 mev thermal neutrinos , the presence of a jet would allow proton acceleration by shocks , and produce 1 tev non - thermal neutrinos .
detection of these high energy neutrinos by upcoming cherenkov detectors would be a smoking gun signal of a sn jet , and would allow one to study the conditions inside a collapsing star which may not be possible otherwise .
work supported by an nsf grant ast0307376 and nasa grant nag5 - 13286 .
k. nomoto , p. a. mazzali , t. nakamura , k. iwamoto , i. j. danziger , f. patat , in supernovae and gamma - ray bursts : the greatest explosions since the big bang , may , 1999 , eds .
m. livio , n. panagia and k. sahu .
stsci symposium series , vol .
13 , pg 144 ( 2001 ) . | it has been hypothesized recently that core collapse supernovae are triggered by mildly relativistic jets following observations of radio properties of these explosions .
association of a jet , similar to a gamma - ray burst jet but only slower , allows shock acceleration of particles to high energy and non - thermal neutrino emission from a supernova .
detection of these high energy neutrinos in upcoming kilometer scale cherenkov detectors may be the only direct way to probe inside these astrophysical phenomena as electromagnetic radiation is thermal and contains little information .
calculation of high energy neutrino signal from a simple and slow jet model buried inside the pre - supernova star is reviewed here .
the detection prospect of these neutrinos in water or ice detector is also discussed in this brief review . jetted core collapse supernovae in nearby galaxies may provide the strongest high energy neutrino signal from point sources . |
the shape of the stellar body of a galaxy reflects its formation process .
reconstructing the intrinsic , three - dimensional shapes of spiral galaxies from their shapes projected on the sky has a long tradition , and proved to be an exquisitely accurate and precise approach , especially once sample size increased ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
these results provided us with the general notion that the stellar bodies of present - day star - forming galaxies over a wide range in luminosity can be described as thin , nearly oblate ( therefore , disk - like ) systems with an intrinsic short - to - long axis ratio of @xmath10 .
such global shapes encompass all galactic components , including bars and bulges .
the disk component is generally thinner ( @xmath11 , e.g. , * ? ? ?
analogous information about the progenitors of today s galaxies is scarcer . among faint , blue galaxies in deep hubble space telescope imaging
, @xcite found a substantial population of elongated ` chain ' galaxies , but several authors argued that chain galaxies are edge - on disk galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) .
however , @xcite demonstrated that the ellipticity distribution of a large sample of @xmath12 lyman break galaxies is inconsistent with randomly oriented disk galaxies , lending credence to the interpretation that a class of intrinsically elongated ( or , prolate ) objects in fact exists at high redshift . by modeling ellipticity distributions
, @xcite and @xcite concluded that the intrinsic shapes of @xmath13 star - forming galaxies are strongly triaxial . on the other hand ,
regular rotation is commonly seen amongst @xmath14 samples @xcite , and the evidence for the existence of gaseous disks is ample among massive systems @xcite .
one possible explanation for the seeming discrepancy between the geometric and kinematic shape inferences is a dependence of structure on galaxy mass . indeed , for lower - mass galaxies ( @xmath15 )
the evidence for rotation is less convincing ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and in rare cases rotation is convincingly ruled out ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
the prevailing view is that the gas and hence presumably the stars that form from it in those galaxies is supported by random motions rather than ordered rotation . however , the kinematic measurements for low - mass galaxies probe only a small number of spatial resolution elements signs of rotation may be smeared out @xcite and the observed motions may have a non - gravitational origin such as feedback . here
we aim to provide the first description of the geometric shape distribution of @xmath4 star - forming galaxies and its dependence on galaxy mass .
we examine the projected axis ratio distributions ( @xmath16 ) of large samples of star - forming galaxies out to @xmath17 drawn from the candels @xcite and 3d - hst @xcite surveys .
a low - redshift comparison sample is drawn from the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) .
the methodology developed by @xcite and @xcite will be used to convert @xmath16 into 3-dimensional shape distributions of star - forming galaxies and its evolution from @xmath17 to the present day .
we construct volume - limited samples of star - forming galaxies over a large range in stellar mass ( @xmath1 ) and redshift ( @xmath0 ) with @xmath18 measured at an approximately fixed rest - frame wavelength of @xmath19 .
@xcite provide wfc3/f125w+f140w+f160w - selected , multi - wavelength catalogs for the candels fields , as well as redshifts , stellar masses and rest - frame colors using the 3d - hst wfc3 grism spectroscopy in addition to the photometry .
36,653 star - forming galaxies with stellar masses @xmath20 and up to redshift @xmath17 are selected based on their rest - frame @xmath21 and @xmath22 colors as described by @xcite , 35,832 of which have @xmath18 measurements . the typical accuracy and precision is better than 10% @xcite . for the @xmath23 galaxies we use the f160w - based values , for the @xmath24 galaxies we use the f125w - based values , such that all @xmath4 galaxies have their shapes measured at a rest - frame wavelength as close as possible to @xmath19 ( and always in the range @xmath25 ) .
this avoids the effects due the shape variations with wavelength seen in local galaxies @xcite . below @xmath26
our f125w shape measurements probe longer wavelengths .
we compared the f125w - based shapes with hst / acs f814w - based shapes for 1,365 galaxies ( see * ? ? ? * ) .
the median f125w - based axis ratio is 0.014 larger than the median f814w - based shape , with a scatter of 0.06 .
this is consistent with the measurement errors .
we conclude that using f125w axis ratios at @xmath27 does not affect our results .
sdss photometry - based stellar masses from @xcite are used to select 36,369 star - forming galaxies with stellar masses @xmath20 and in the ( spectroscopic ) redshift range @xmath28 .
the distinction between star - forming and passive galaxies is described by @xcite and is based on the rest - frame @xmath29 and @xmath30 colors , analogous to the use of @xmath21 and @xmath22 colors at higher redshifts . for the sdss sample we use the @xmath18 estimates from fitting the exponential surface brightness model to the @xmath31-band imaging as part of the dr7 photometric pipeline @xcite .
these measurements have been verified by @xcite , who showed that systematic offsets and scatter with respect to our galfit -based measurements are negligible .
the very pronounced change of the projected shape distribution with redshift ( figure [ hist ] ) immediately reveals that galaxy structure evolves with cosmic time . especially at low stellar masses
we see that a larger fraction of galaxies have flat projected shapes than at the present day .
this observation underpins the analysis presented in the remainder of the letter . here
we provide a brief description of the methodology to infer the intrinsic , 3-dimensional shapes of galaxies , outlined in detail by @xcite .
we adopt the ellipsoid as the general geometric form to describe the shapes of galaxies .
it has three , generally different , axis lengths ( @xmath32 ) , commonly used to define ellipticity ( @xmath33 ) and triaxiality ( @xmath34 ) . in order to facilitate an intuitive understanding of our results
we define three broad geometric types , shown in figure [ class ] : _ disky _ ( @xmath35 ) , _ elongated _ ( @xmath36 ) , and _ spheroidal _ ( @xmath37 ) .
the goal is to find a model population of triaxial ellipsoids that , when seen under random viewing angles , has the same @xmath16 as an observed galaxy sample .
our model population has gaussian distributions of the ellipticity ( with mean @xmath38 and standard deviation @xmath39 ) and triaxiality ( with mean @xmath40 and standard deviation @xmath41 ) .
such a model population has a known @xmath16 which we adjust to include the effect of random uncertainties in the axis ratio measurements these are asymmetric for nearly round objects .
then , given that each observed value of @xmath18 corresponds to a known probability , we calculate the total likelihood of the model by multiplying the probabilities of each of the observed values .
we search a grid of the four model parameters to find the maximal total likelihood . in figure [ hist ]
we show observed axis ratio distributions ( histograms ) , and the probability distributions of the corresponding best - fitting model populations ( smooth lines ) .
the models generally match the data very well . even in the worst case ( bottom - right panel ) the model and data distributions are only marginally inconsistent , at the @xmath42 level .
a triaxial model population with parameters @xmath43 corresponds to a cloud of points in figure [ class ] and , hence , with certain fractions of the three geometric types .
the colored bars in figure [ hist ] represent these fractions for the best - fitting triaxial models .
this illustrates the connection between projected shapes and intrinsic shapes : a broad @xmath16 reflects a large fraction of _ disky _ objects , whereas a narrow distribution with a peak at small @xmath18 is indicative of a large fraction of _ elongated _ objects . a narrow distribution with a peak at large @xmath18 would indicate a large fraction of _ spheroidal _ objects . in figure [ res ]
we provide the modeling results for the full redshift and mass range probed here : for each stellar mass bin we show the redshift evolution of the four model parameters , including the uncertainties obtained by bootstrapping the samples .
finally , in figure [ frac ] we show the full set of results in the form of the color coding defined in figure [ class ] .
the small values of @xmath40 and the large values of @xmath38 for present - day star - forming galaxies ( figure [ res ] ) imply that the vast majority are thin and nearly oblate .
indeed , according to our classification shown in figure [ hist ] between 80% and 100% are _ disky _ , as is generally known and was demonstrated before on the basis of similar axis - ratio distribution analyses by @xcite and @xcite .
importantly , the intrinsic shape distribution of star - forming galaxies does not change over a large range in stellar mass ( @xmath1 ) . toward higher redshifts
star - forming galaxies become gradually less disk - like ( figures [ hist ] , [ res ] and [ frac ] ) .
this effect is most pronounced for low - mass galaxies .
already in the @xmath44 redshift bin in figure [ res ] we see evolution , mostly in the scatter in triaxiality ( @xmath41 ) .
that is , there is substantial variety in intrinsic galaxy shape . beyond @xmath26 ,
galaxies with stellar mass @xmath5 typically do not have a _ disky _
geometry , but are most often _ elongated _ ( figure [ res ] ) .
galaxies with mass @xmath6 show similar behavior , but with evolution only apparent at @xmath13 .
this geometric evidence for mass - dependent redshift evolution of galaxy structure is corroborated by the analysis of kinematic properties of @xmath45 galaxies by @xcite .
_ disky _ objects are the most common type ( @xmath46 ) among galaxies with mass @xmath47 at all redshifts @xmath3 .
a population of _ spheroidal _ galaxies is increasingly prominent among massive galaxies at @xmath48 .
a visual inspection of such objects reveals that at least a subset are mergers , but an in - depth interpretation of this aspect we defer to another occasion .
it is interesting to note that ellipticity hardly depends on mass and redshift ( figure [ res ] ) .
that is , despite strong evolution in geometry , the short - to - long axis ratio remains remarkably constant with redshift , and changes little with galaxy mass .
a joint analysis of galaxy size and shape is required to explore the possible implications .
note that our definition of geometric shape is unrelated to the common distinction between disks and spheroids on the basis of their concentration parameter or srsic index . as a result
we distinguish between the observation that most low - mass star - forming galaxies at @xmath8 have exponential surface brightness profiles ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) and our inference that these galaxies are not , generally , shaped like disks in a geometric sense .
this illustrates that an approximately exponential light profile can correlate with the presence of a disk - like structure but can not be used as a definition of a disk .
star formation in the present - day universe mostly takes place in @xmath49 galaxies and in non - starburst galaxies .
since essentially all such star - forming galaxies are _ disky _ and star formation in disk galaxies occurs mostly over the full extent of the stellar disk , it follows immediately that essentially all current star formation takes place in disks .
the analysis presented in this _
letter _ allows us to generalize this conclusion to include earlier epochs .
at least since @xmath8 most star formation is accounted for by @xmath50 galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
figures [ res ] and [ frac ] show that such galaxies have disk - like geometries over the same redshift range .
given that 90% of stars in the universe formed over that time span , it follows that the majority of all stars in the universe formed in disk galaxies .
combined with the evidence that star formation is spatially extended , and not , for example , concentrated in galaxy centers ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) this implies that the vast majority of stars formed in disks . despite this universal dominance of disks
, the elongatedness of many low - mass galaxies at @xmath51 implies that the shape of a galaxy generally differs from that of a disk at early stages in its evolution .
according to our results , an elongated , low - mass galaxy at @xmath52 will evolve into a disk at later times , or , reversing the argument , disk galaxies in the present - day universe do not initially start out disks . as can be seen in figure [ res ] ,
the transition from _ elongated _ to _ disky _ is gradual for the population .
this is not necessarily the case for individual galaxies .
hydrodynamical simulations indicate that sustained disks form quite suddenly , on a dynamical time scale , after an initial period characterized by rapidly changing dynamical configurations ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
this turbulent formation phase may include the subsequent formation and destruction of short - lived disks ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) , associated with rapid changes in orientation and resulting in a hot stellar system of rather arbitrary shape .
our observation that at @xmath4 the low - mass galaxy population consists of a mix of _ disky _ and _ elongated _ objects in this picture , the latter represent the irregular phase without a sustained disk can be interpreted as some fraction of the galaxies having already transformed into a sustained disk .
the probability for this transition is , then , a function of mass which may or may not depend on redshift . given the various estimates of the stellar mass evolution of milky way - mass galaxies as a function of redshift ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , we suggest that the milky way may have first attained a sustained stellar disk at redshift @xmath53 .
our analysis rests on the assumption that stellar light traces the mass distribution of a galaxy .
potential spoilers include obscuration by dust , dispersion in age among stars , and large gas fractions .
dust has a viewing angle - dependent effect on the measured @xmath18 .
massive galaxies at all redshifts are dusty , and a large variety of dust geometries could disturb axis ratio measurements , hiding the disk - like structure of the population when traced by the axis ratio distribution . perhaps this plays a role at @xmath48 where we see an increased fraction of round objects .
however , the reverse to create a disk - like axis ratio distribution for a population of dusty non - disks requires unlikely fine tuning .
we prefer the more straightforward interpretation that massive , star - forming galaxies truly are disks , at least up to @xmath54 .
this is supported by the observed correlation between axis ratio and color ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , also seen in our sample : galaxies with smaller @xmath18 are redder than those with larger @xmath18 , as expected from a population on inclined , dusty disks .
dust is also unlikely to affect @xmath16 of low - mass galaxies . at @xmath4 galaxies with stellar masses @xmath15
are generally very blue . for these young
, presumably metal - poor galaxies dust is of limited relevance to the shape measurements .
this also implies that completeness of our sample is not affected by strong dust obscuration .
age variations in the stellar population and large gas fractions both potentially present challenges to our assumption that the rest - frame optical light traces the underlying mass distribution .
perhaps the luminous regions are young , bright complexes embedded in disks consisting of cold gas or fainter , older stellar populations .
we can not immediately discard this possibility as dynamical masses exceed stellar masses by an average factor of @xmath55 in the stellar mass range @xmath56 galaxies at @xmath4 ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
it is implausible that this difference between stellar mass and dynamical mass is entirely made up of undetected , older stars in a disk - like configuration .
the different spatial distributions of the young and old stars would lead to wavelength - dependent shapes , which is not observed .
if such a population of older stars is present , it must be spatially coincident with the young population , and not , generally , in a disk .
we can not exclude the existence of cold gas disks that are @xmath573@xmath58 more massive than the ( young ) stellar population .
hydrodynamical simulations show that low - mass , high - redshift systems can produce elongated stellar bodies embedded in more extended , turbulent gaseous bodies with ordered rotation ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
at the moment there is little observational evidence for such extended gaseous disks . for the mass range @xmath59 gas masses in excess of the stellar mass
have been inferred based on the star - formation rate and the inverse kennicutt - schmidt relation ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , but this inversion relies on the assumption of a disk - like geometry , weakening the argument .
furthermore , even if these cold gas mass estimates are correct it is not clear that the gas should be organized in a disk .
generally , gas ionized by star formation and cold gas share global kinematic traits , and in these cases the ionized gas does not generally show rotation .
deep alma observations will settle this issue , and for now we will leave this as the main caveat in our analysis .
we have analyzed the projected axis ratio distributions , @xmath16 , measured at rest - frame optical wavelenghts , of stellar mass - selected samples of star - forming galaxies in the redshift range @xmath0 drawn from sdss and 3d - hst+candels .
the intrinsic , 3-dimensional geometric shape distribution is reconstructed under the assumption that the population consists of triaxial objects view under random viewing angles . in the present - day universe
star - forming galaxies of all masses are predominantly oblate and flat , that is , they are disks .
massive galaxies ( @xmath2 ) typically have this shape at all redshifts @xmath60 .
given the dominance of @xmath61 galaxies in terms of their contribution to the cosmic stellar mass budget and the star formation rate density it follows that , averaged over all cosmic epochs , the majority of all stars formed in disks .
lower - mass galaxies have shapes at @xmath4 that differ significantly from those of thin , oblate disks . for galaxies with stellar mass @xmath5 ( @xmath6 )
there exists a mix of roughly equal numbers of elongated and disk galaxies at @xmath7 ( @xmath8 ) . at @xmath4
the @xmath5 galaxies are predominantly elongated .
our findings imply that low - mass galaxies at high redshift had not yet formed a regularly rotating , sustained disk . given a range of plausible mass growth rate of milky way - mass galaxies
we infer the disk formation phase for such galaxies at @xmath53 . | we determine the intrinsic , 3-dimensional shape distribution of star - forming galaxies at @xmath0 , as inferred from their observed projected axis ratios . in the present - day universe
star - forming galaxies of all masses @xmath1 are predominantly thin , nearly oblate disks , in line with previous studies .
we now extend this to higher redshifts , and find that among massive galaxies ( @xmath2 ) disks are the most common geometric shape at all @xmath3 .
lower - mass galaxies at @xmath4 possess a broad range of geometric shapes : the fraction of elongated ( prolate ) galaxies increases toward higher redshifts and lower masses .
galaxies with stellar mass @xmath5 ( @xmath6 ) are a mix of roughly equal numbers of elongated and disk galaxies at @xmath7 ( @xmath8 ) .
this suggests that galaxies in this mass range do not yet have disks that are sustained over many orbital periods , implying that galaxies with present - day stellar mass comparable to that of the milky way typically first formed such sustained stellar disks at redshift @xmath9 .
combined with constraints on the evolution of the star formation rate density and the distribution of star formation over galaxies with different masses , our findings imply that , averaged over cosmic time , the majority of stars formed in disks . |
dependence logic @xcite is an extension of first - order logic which adds _ dependence atoms _ of the form @xmath0 to it , with the intended interpretation of `` the value of the term @xmath1 is a function of the values of the terms @xmath2 . ''
the introduction of such atoms is roughly equivalent to the introduction of non - linear patterns of dependence and independence between variables of branching quantifier logic @xcite or independence friendly logic @xcite : for example , both the branching quantifier logic sentence @xmath3 and the independence friendly logic sentence @xmath4 correspond in dependence logic to @xmath5 in the sense that all of these expressions are equivalent to the skolem formula @xmath6 as this example illustrates , the main peculiarity of dependence logic compared to the others above - mentioned logics lies in the fact that , in dependence logic , the notion of _ dependence and independence between variables _ is explicitly separated from the notion of quantification .
this makes it an eminently suitable formalism for the formal analysis of the properties of _ dependence itself _ in a first - order setting , and some recent papers ( @xcite ) explore the effects of replace dependence atoms with other similar primitives such as _ independence atoms _ @xcite , _ multivalued dependence atoms _
@xcite , or _ inclusion _ or _
atoms @xcite .
branching quantifier logic , independence friendly logic and dependence logic , as well as their variants , are called _ logics of imperfect information _ : indeed , the truth conditions of their sentences can be obtained by defining , for every model @xmath7 and sentence @xmath8 , an imperfect - information _ semantic game _
@xmath9 between a _ verifier _ ( also called eloise ) and a _ falsifier _ ( also called abelard ) , and then asserting that @xmath8 is true in @xmath7 if and only if the verifier has a winning strategy in @xmath9 . as an alternative of this ( non - compositional ) _ game - theoretic semantics _ , which is an imperfect - information variant of hintikka s game - theoretic semantics for first order logic @xcite , hodges introduced in @xcite _ team semantics _ ( also called _ trump semantics _ ) , a compositional semantics for logics of imperfect information which is equivalent to game - theoretic semantics over sentences and in which formulas are satisfied or not satisfied not by single assignments , but by _ sets _ of assignments ( called _ teams _ ) . in this work
, we will be mostly concerned with team semantics and some of its variants .
we refer the reader to the relevant literature ( for example to @xcite and @xcite ) for further information regarding these logics : in the rest of this section , we will content ourselves with recalling the definitions and results which will be useful for the rest of this work .
let @xmath7 be a first order model and let @xmath10 be a finite set of variables .
then an _ assignment _ over @xmath7 with _ domain _ @xmath10 is a function @xmath11 from @xmath10 to the set @xmath12 of all elements of @xmath7 .
furthermore , for any assignment @xmath11 over @xmath7 with domain @xmath10 , any element @xmath13 and any variable @xmath14 ( not necessarily in @xmath10 ) , we write @xmath15 $ ] for the assignment with domain @xmath16 such that @xmath17(w ) = \left\{\begin{array}{l l } m & \mbox{if } w = v;\\ s(w ) & \mbox{if } w \in v \backslash \{v\ } \end{array } \right.\ ] ] for all @xmath18 .
let @xmath7 be a first - order model and let @xmath10 be a finite set of variables .
@xmath19 over @xmath7 with _ domain _ @xmath20 is a set of assignments from @xmath10 to @xmath7 .
let @xmath19 be a team over @xmath7 , and let @xmath10 be a finite set of variables . and
let @xmath21 be a finite tuple of variables in its domain .
then @xmath22 is the relation @xmath23 .
furthermore , we write @xmath24 for @xmath25 . as is often the case for dependence logic , we will assume that all our formulas are in negation normal form : let @xmath26 be a first - order signature .
then the set of all dependence logic formula with signature @xmath26 is given by @xmath27 where @xmath28 ranges over all relation symbols , @xmath29 ranges over all tuples of terms of the appropriate arities , @xmath30 range over all terms and @xmath14 ranges over the set @xmath31 of all variables .
the set @xmath32 of all _ free variables _ of a formula @xmath8 is defined precisely as in first order logic , with the additional condition that all variables occurring in a dependence atom are free with respect to it .
[ dl - ts ] let @xmath7 be a first - order model , let @xmath19 be a team over it , and let @xmath8 be a dependence logic formula with the same signature of @xmath7 and with free variables in @xmath33 .
then we say that @xmath19 _ satisfies _ @xmath8 in @xmath7 , and we write @xmath34 , if and only if ts - lit : : : @xmath8 is a first - order literal and @xmath35 for all @xmath36 ; ts - dep : : : @xmath8 is a dependence atom @xmath37 and any two assignments @xmath38 which assign the same values to @xmath2 also assign the same value to @xmath1 ; ts-@xmath39 : : : @xmath8 is of the form @xmath40 and there exist two teams @xmath41 and @xmath42 such that @xmath43 , @xmath44 and @xmath45 ; ts-@xmath46 : : : @xmath8 is of the form @xmath47 , @xmath48 and @xmath49 ; ts-@xmath50 : : : @xmath8 is of the form @xmath51 and there exists a function @xmath52 such that @xmath53 } \psi$ ] , where @xmath54 = \{s[f(s)/v ] : s \in x\}\ ] ] ts-@xmath55 : : : @xmath8 is of the form @xmath56 and @xmath57 } \psi$ ] , where @xmath58 = \{s[m / v ] : s \in x , m \in { \texttt{dom}}(m)\}.\ ] ] the disjunction of dependence logic does not behave like the classical disjunction : for example , it is easy to see that @xmath59 is not equivalent to @xmath60 , as the former holds for the team @xmath61 and the latter does not .
however , it is possible to define the classical disjunction in terms of the other connectives : [ defin : classic_or ] let @xmath62 and @xmath63 be two dependence logic formulas , and let @xmath64 and @xmath65 be two variables not occurring in them
. then we write @xmath66 as a shorthand for @xmath67 [ propo : classic_or ] for all formulas @xmath62 and @xmath63 , all models @xmath7 with at least two elements whose signature contains that of @xmath62 and @xmath63 and all teams @xmath19 whose domain contains the free variables of @xmath62 and @xmath63 @xmath68 the following four proportions are from @xcite : [ propo : emptyteam ] for all models @xmath7 and dependence logic formulas @xmath8 , @xmath69 .
if @xmath34 and @xmath70 then @xmath71 . if @xmath34 and @xmath72 then @xmath73 . [ dltosigma ]
let @xmath74 be a dependence logic formula with free variables in @xmath21 .
then there exists a @xmath75 sentence @xmath76 such that @xmath77 for all suitable models @xmath7 and for all nonempty teams @xmath19 .
furthermore , in @xmath76 the symbol @xmath28 occurs only negatively . as proved in @xcite
, there is also a converse for the last proposition : [ sigmatodl ] let @xmath76 be a @xmath75 sentence in which @xmath28 occurs only negatively . then there exists a dependence logic formula @xmath74 , where @xmath78 is the arity of @xmath28 , such that @xmath77 for all suitable models @xmath7 and for all nonempty teams @xmath19 whose domain contains @xmath21 .
because of this correspondence between dependence logic and existential second order logic , it is easy to see that dependence logic is closed under existential quantification : for all dependence logic formulas @xmath79 over the signature @xmath80 there exists a dependence logic formula @xmath81 over the signature @xmath26 such that @xmath82 for all models @xmath7 with domain @xmath26 and for all teams @xmath19 over the free variables of @xmath8 . therefore , in the rest of this work we will add second - order existential quantifiers to the language of dependence logic , and we will write @xmath81 as a shorthand for the corresponding dependence logic expression
. _ game logics _ are logical formalisms for reasoning about games and their properties in a very general setting . whereas the game theoretic
semantics approach attempts to use game - theoretic techniques to _ interpret _ logical systems , game logics attempt to put logic to the service of game theory , by providing a high - level language for the study of games .
they generally contain two different kinds of expressions : 1 .
_ game terms _ , which are descriptions of games in terms of compositions of certain primitive _ atomic games _ , whose interpretation is presumed fixed for any given game model ; 2 .
_ formulas _ , which , in general , correspond to assertions about the abilities of players in games . in this subsection
, we are going to summarize the definition of a variant of dynamic game logic @xcite . from our formalism .
in this , we follow @xcite . ] then , in the next subsection , we will discuss a remarkable connection between first - order logic and dynamic game logic discovered by johan van benthem in @xcite .
+ one of the fundamental semantic concepts of dynamic game logic is the notion of _ forcing relation : _
let @xmath83 be a nonempty set of _ states_. a _ forcing relation _ over @xmath83 is a set @xmath84 , where @xmath85 is the powerset of @xmath83 . in brief
, a forcing relation specifies the abilities of a player in a perfect - information game : @xmath86 if and only if the player has a strategy that guarantees that , whenever the initial position of the game is @xmath11 , the terminal position of the game will be in @xmath19 .
a ( two - player ) _ game _ is then defined as a pair of forcing relations satisfying some axioms : let @xmath83 be a nonempty set of states .
a _ game _ over @xmath83 is a pair @xmath87 of forcing relations over @xmath83 satisfying the following conditions for all @xmath88 , all @xmath89 and all @xmath90 : monotonicity : : : if @xmath91 and @xmath92 then @xmath93 ; consistency : : : if @xmath94 and @xmath95 then @xmath96 ; non - triviality : : : @xmath97 .
determinacy : : : if @xmath98 then @xmath99 , where @xmath100 .
, this implies that the other player can force it to belong to the complement of @xmath19 . ]
let @xmath83 be a nonempty set of states , let @xmath101 be a nonempty set of _ atomic propositions _ and let @xmath102 be a nonempty set of _ atomic game symbols_. then a _ game model _ over @xmath83 , @xmath101 and @xmath102 is a triple @xmath103 , where @xmath104 is a game over @xmath83 for all @xmath105 and where @xmath10 is a valutation function associating each @xmath106 to a subset @xmath107 .
the language of dynamic game logic , as we already mentioned , consists of _ game terms _ , built up from atomic games , and of _ formulas _ , built up from atomic proposition .
the connection between these two parts of the language is given by the _ test _
operation @xmath108 , which turns any formula @xmath8 into a test game , and the _ diamond _ operation , which combines a game term @xmath109 and a formula @xmath8 into a new formula @xmath110 which asserts that agent @xmath111 can guarantee that the game @xmath109 will end in a state satisfying @xmath8 .
let @xmath101 be a nonempty set of _ atomic propositions _ and let @xmath102 be a nonempty set of _ atomic game formulas_. then the sets of all game terms @xmath109 and formulas @xmath8 are defined as @xmath112 for @xmath113 ranging over @xmath101 , @xmath114 ranging over @xmath102 , and @xmath111 ranging over @xmath115 .
we already mentioned the intended interpretations of the test connective @xmath108 and of the diamond connective @xmath110 .
the interpretations of the other game connectives should be clear : @xmath116 is obtained by swapping the roles of the players in @xmath109 , @xmath117 is a game in which the existential player @xmath118 chooses whether to play @xmath119 or @xmath120 , and @xmath121 is the _ concatenation _ of the two games corresponding to @xmath119 and @xmath120 respectively . let @xmath122 be a game model over @xmath83 , @xmath102 and @xmath101 .
then for all game terms @xmath109 and all formulas @xmath8 of dynamic game logic over @xmath102 and @xmath101 we define a game @xmath123 and a set @xmath124 as follows : dgl - atomic - game : : : for all @xmath105 , @xmath125 ; dgl - test : : : for all formulas @xmath8 , @xmath126 , where + * @xmath127 iff @xmath128 and @xmath36 ; + * @xmath129 iff @xmath130 or @xmath36 + for all @xmath89 and all @xmath19 with @xmath131 ; dgl - concat : : : for all game terms @xmath119 and @xmath120 , @xmath132 , where , for all @xmath88 and for @xmath133 , @xmath134 , + * @xmath135 if and only if there exists a @xmath136 such that @xmath137 and for each @xmath138 there exists a set @xmath139 satisfying @xmath140 such that @xmath141 dgl-@xmath142 : : : for all game terms @xmath119 and @xmath120 , @xmath143 , where + * @xmath127 if and only if @xmath144 or @xmath145 , and * @xmath129 if and only if @xmath146 and @xmath147 + where , as before , @xmath133 and @xmath134;[multiblock footnote omitted ] dgl - dual : : : if @xmath148 then @xmath149 ; dgl-@xmath150 : : : @xmath151 ; dgl - atomic - pr : : : @xmath152 ; dgl-@xmath153 : : : @xmath154 ; dgl-@xmath39 : : : @xmath155 ; dgl-@xmath156 : : : if @xmath148 then for all @xmath8 , @xmath157 if @xmath128 , we say that @xmath8 is _ satisfied _ by @xmath11 in @xmath158 and we write @xmath35 . we will not discuss here the properties of this logic , or the vast amount of variants and extensions of it which have been developed and studied .
it is worth pointing out , however , that @xcite introduced a _ concurrent dynamic game logic _ that can be considered one of the main sources of inspiration for the transition logic that we will develop in subsection [ subsect : tdl ] . in this subsection
, we will briefly recall a remarkable result from @xcite which establishes a connection between dynamic game logic and first - order logic . in brief , as the following two theorems demonstrate , either of these logics can be seen as a special case of the other , in the sense that models and formulas of the one can be uniformly translated into models of the other in a way which preserves satisfiability and truth : [ theo : repfo1 ]
let @xmath122 be any game model , let @xmath8 be any game formula for the same language , and let @xmath89 .
then it is possible to uniformly construct a first - order model @xmath159 , a first - order formula @xmath160 and an assignment @xmath161 of @xmath159 such that @xmath162 [ theo : repfo2 ] let @xmath7 be any first order model , let @xmath8 be any first - order formula for the signature of @xmath7 , and let @xmath11 be an assignment of @xmath7 .
then it is possible to uniformly construct a game model @xmath163 , a game formula @xmath164 and a state @xmath165 such that @xmath166 we will not discuss here the proofs of these two results .
their _ significance _ , however , is something about which is necessary to spend a few words . in brief
, what this back - and - forth representation between first order logic and dynamic game logic tells us is that it is possible to understand first order logic as a _ logic for reasoning about determined games _ ! in the next sections , we will attempt to develop a similar result for the case of dependence logic .
we will now define a variant of dynamic game logic , which we will call _ transition logic_. it deviates from the basic framework of dynamic game logic in two fundamental ways : 1 .
it considers _
one - player _ games against nature , instead of _ two - player games _ as is usual in dynamic game logic ; 2 .
it allows for _ uncertainty _ about the initial position of the game .
hence , transition logic can be seen as a _ decision - theoretic logic _ , rather than a _ game - theoretic _ one : transition logic formulas , as we will see , correspond to assertions about the abilities of a single agent acting under uncertainty , instead of assertions about the abilities of agents interacting with each other . in principle , it is certainly possible to generalize the approach discussed here to multiple agents acting in situations of imperfect information , and doing so might cause interesting phenomena to surface ; but for the time being , we will content ourselves with developing this formalism and discussing its connection with dependence logic .
our first definition is a fairly straightforward generalization of the concept of forcing relation : let @xmath83 be a nonempty set of _
states_. a _ transition system _ over @xmath83 is a nonempty relation @xmath167 satisfying the following requirements : downwards closure : : : if @xmath168 and @xmath169 then @xmath170 ; monotonicity : : : if @xmath168 and @xmath171 then @xmath172 ; non - creation : : : @xmath173 for all @xmath174 ; non - triviality : : : if @xmath175 then @xmath176 . informally speaking , a transition system specifies the abilities of an agent : for all @xmath90 such that @xmath168 , the agent has a strategy which guarantees that the output of the transition will be in @xmath177 whenever the input of the transition is in @xmath19 .
the four axioms which we gave capture precisely this intended meaning , as we will see : a _ decision game _ is a triple @xmath178 , where @xmath83 is a nonempty set of _ states _ , @xmath118 is a nonempty set of possible _ decisions _ for our agent and @xmath179 is an _ outcome function _ from @xmath180 to @xmath85 . if @xmath181 , we say that @xmath182 is a _ possible outcome _ of @xmath11 under @xmath183 ; if @xmath184 , we say that @xmath183 _ fails _ on input @xmath11 .
let @xmath178 be a decision game , and let @xmath90 .
then we say that @xmath102 _ allows _ the transition @xmath185 , and we write @xmath186 , if and only if there exists a @xmath187 such that @xmath188 for all @xmath36 ( that is , if and only if our agent can make a decision which guarantees that the outcome will be in @xmath177 whenever the input is in @xmath19 ) .
a set @xmath167 is a transition system if and only if there exists a decision game @xmath178 such that @xmath189 let @xmath167 be any transition system , let us enumerate its elements @xmath190 , and let us consider the game @xmath191 , where @xmath192 suppose that @xmath168 .
if @xmath193 , then @xmath194 follows at once by definition .
if instead @xmath175 , by * non - triviality * we have that @xmath177 is nonempty too , and furthermore @xmath195 for some @xmath196 .
then @xmath197 for all @xmath198 , as required .
now suppose that @xmath186 .
then there exists a @xmath196 such that @xmath199 for all @xmath36 . if @xmath175 , this implies that @xmath200 and @xmath201 .
hence , by * monotonicity * and * downwards closure * , @xmath168 , as required .
if instead @xmath193 , then by * non - creation * we have again that @xmath168 . conversely , consider a decision game @xmath178 .
then the set of its abilities satisfies our four axioms : downwards closure : : : suppose that @xmath202 and that @xmath169 .
by definition , there exists a @xmath187 such that @xmath188 for all @xmath36 .
but then the same holds for all @xmath203 , and hence @xmath204 .
monotonicity : : : suppose that @xmath202 and that @xmath171 . by definition , there exists a @xmath187 such that @xmath188 for all @xmath36 .
but then , for all such @xmath11 , @xmath205 too , and hence @xmath206
. non - creation : : : let @xmath174 and let @xmath187 be any possible decision .
then trivially @xmath188 for all @xmath207 , and hence @xmath208 .
non - triviality : : : let @xmath209 , and suppose that @xmath186 .
then there exists a @xmath183 such that @xmath188 for all @xmath36 , and hence in particular @xmath210 .
therefore , @xmath177 is nonempty .
what this theorem tells us is that our notion of transition system is the correct one : it captures precisely the abilities of an agent making choices under imperfect information and attempting to guarantee that , if the initial state is in a set @xmath19 , the outcome will be in a set @xmath177 .
let @xmath83 be a nonempty set of states .
a _ trump _ over @xmath83 is a nonempty , downwards closed family of subsets of @xmath83 . whereas a transition system describes the abilities of an agent to transition from a set of possible initial states to a set of possible terminal states , a trump describes the agent s abilities to reach _ some _ terminal state from a set of possible initial states : let @xmath211 be a transition system and let @xmath212 .
then @xmath213 forms a trump .
conversely , for any trump @xmath214 over @xmath83 there exists a transition system @xmath211 such that @xmath215 for any nonempty @xmath174 .
let @xmath211 be a transition system
. then if @xmath168 and @xmath169 , by downwards closure we have at once that @xmath170 .
furthermore , @xmath173 for any @xmath177 .
hence , @xmath216 is a trump , as required .
conversely , let @xmath217 be a trump , and let us enumerate its elements as @xmath218 .
then define @xmath211 as @xmath219 it is easy to see that @xmath211 is a transition system ; and by construction , for @xmath220 we have that @xmath221 , where we used the fact that @xmath214 is downwards closed .
we can now define the syntax and semantics of transition logic : let @xmath101 be a set of _ atomic propositional symbols _ and let @xmath222 be a set of _ atomic transition symbols_. then a _ transition model _ is a tuple @xmath223 , where @xmath83 is a nonempty set of states , @xmath224 is a transition system over @xmath83 for any @xmath225 , and @xmath10 is a function sending each @xmath106 into a trump of @xmath83 .
let @xmath101 be a set of atomic propositions and let @xmath222 be a set of atomic transitions .
then the _ transition terms _ and _ formulas _ of our language are defined respectively as @xmath226 where @xmath227 ranges over @xmath222 and @xmath113 ranges over @xmath101 .
let @xmath228 be a transition model , let @xmath229 be a transition term , and let @xmath90 .
then we say that @xmath229 _ allows _ the transition from @xmath19 to @xmath177 , and we write @xmath230 , if and only if tl - atomic - tr : : : @xmath231 for some @xmath225 and @xmath232 ; tl - test : : : @xmath233 for some transition formula @xmath8 such that @xmath234 in the sense described later in this definition , and @xmath92 ; tl-@xmath235 : : : @xmath236 , and @xmath237 for two @xmath238 and @xmath239 such that @xmath240 and @xmath241 ; tl-@xmath242 : : : @xmath243 , @xmath244 and @xmath245 ; tl - concat : : : @xmath246 and there exists a @xmath247 such that @xmath248 and @xmath249 .
analogously , let @xmath8 be a transition formula , and let @xmath250 .
then we say that @xmath19 _ satisfies _ @xmath8 , and we write @xmath234 , if and only if tl-@xmath251 : : : @xmath252 ; tl - atomic - pr : : : @xmath253 for some @xmath106 and @xmath254 ; tl-@xmath39 : : : @xmath255 and @xmath256 or @xmath257 ; tl-@xmath46 : : : @xmath258 , @xmath256 and @xmath257 ; tl-@xmath156 : : : @xmath259 and there exists a @xmath177 such that @xmath230 and @xmath260 . for any transition model @xmath261 , transition term @xmath229 and transition formula @xmath8 ,
the set @xmath262 is a transition system and the set @xmath263 is a trump . by induction .
we end this subsection with a few simple observations about this logic .
first of all , we did not take the negation as one of the primitive connectives .
indeed , transition logic , much like dependence logic , has an intrinsically _ existential _ character : it can be used to reason about which sets of possible states an agent _ may _ reach , but not to reason about which ones such an agent _ must _ reach .
there is of course no reason , in principle , why a negation could not be added to the language , just as there is no reason why a negation can not be added to dependence logic , thus obtaining the far more powerful _ team logic _
@xcite : however , this possible extension will not be studied in this work .
the connectives of transition logic are , for the most part , very similar to those of dynamic game logic , and their interpretation should pose no difficulties . the exception is the _ tensor operator _ @xmath264 , which substitutes the game union operator @xmath117 and which , while sharing roughly the same informal meaning , behaves in a very different way from the semantic point of view ( for example , it is not in general idempotent ! ) the decision game corresponding to @xmath264 can be described as follows : first the agent chooses an index @xmath265 , then he or she picks a strategy for @xmath266 and plays accordingly .
however , the choice of @xmath111 may be a function of the initial state : hence , the agent can guarantee that the output state will be in @xmath177 whenever the input state is in @xmath19 only if he or she can split @xmath19 into two subsets @xmath238 and @xmath239 and guarantee that the state in @xmath177 will be reached from any state in @xmath238 when @xmath267 is played , and from any state in @xmath239 when @xmath268 is played .
it is also of course possible to introduce a `` true '' choice operator @xmath269 , with semantical condition tl-@xmath142 : : : @xmath270 iff @xmath244 or @xmath245 ; but we will not explore this possibility any further in this work , nor we will consider any other possible connectives such as , for example , the iteration operator tl-@xmath271 : : : @xmath272 iff there exist @xmath273 and @xmath274 such that @xmath275 , @xmath276 and @xmath277 for all @xmath278 .
this subsection contains the central result of this work , that is , the analogues of theorems [ theo : repfo1 ] and [ theo : repfo2 ] for dependence logic and transition logic .
+ representing dependence logic models and formulas in transition logic is fairly simple : [ defin : dl2tl - mod ] let @xmath7 be a first - order model .
then @xmath279 is the transition model @xmath280 such that * @xmath83 is the set of all teams over @xmath7 ; * the set of all atomic transition symbols is @xmath281 , and hence @xmath222 is @xmath282 ; * for any variable @xmath14 , @xmath283 \subseteq y \}$ ] and @xmath284 \subseteq y\}$ ] ; * for any first - order literal or dependence atom @xmath285 , @xmath286 .
[ defin : dl2tl - form ] let @xmath8 be a dependence logic formula .
then @xmath287 is the transition term defined as follows : 1 .
if @xmath8 is a literal or a dependence atom , @xmath288 ; 2 . if @xmath255 , @xmath289 ; 3 . if @xmath258 , @xmath290 ; 4 .
if @xmath291 , @xmath292 ; 5 .
if @xmath293 , @xmath294 .
[ theo : tl - rep1 ] for all first - order models @xmath7 , teams @xmath19 and formulas @xmath8 , the following are equivalent : * @xmath34 ; * @xmath295 ; * @xmath296 ; * @xmath297 .
we show , by structural induction on @xmath8 , that the first condition is equivalent to the last one .
the equivalences between the last one and the second and third ones are then trivial . 1 . if @xmath8 is a literal or a dependence atom , @xmath298 if and only if @xmath299 , that is , if and only if @xmath34 ; 2 .
@xmath300 if and only if @xmath237 for two @xmath301 such that @xmath302 and @xmath303 . by induction hypothesis
, this can be the case if and only if @xmath304 and @xmath305 , that is , if and only if @xmath306 .
3 . @xmath307 if and only if @xmath308 and @xmath309 , that is , by induction hypothesis , if and only if @xmath310 .
4 . @xmath311 if and only if there exists a @xmath177 such that @xmath312 $ ] for some @xmath313 and @xmath314 . by induction hypothesis and downwards closure
, this can be the case if and only if @xmath53 } \psi$ ] for some @xmath313 , that is , if and only if @xmath315 ; 5 .
@xmath316 if and only if @xmath317 for some @xmath318 $ ] , that is , if and only if @xmath57 } \psi$ ] , that is , if and only if @xmath319 .
one interesting aspect of this representation result is that dependence logic _
formulas _ correspond to transition logic _
transitions _ , not to transition logic _
formulas_. this can be thought of as one first hint of the fact that dependence logic can be thought of as a logic of transitions : and in the later sections , we will explore this idea more in depth .
representing transition models , game terms and formulas in dependence logic is somewhat more complex : let @xmath320 be a transition model .
furthermore , for any @xmath225 , let @xmath321 , and , for any @xmath106 , let @xmath322 .
then @xmath323 is the first - order model with domain for the _ disjoint union _ of the sets @xmath324 and @xmath325 . ]
@xmath326 whose signature contains * for every @xmath225 , a ternary relation @xmath327 whose interpretation is @xmath328 ; * for every @xmath106 , a binary relation @xmath329 whose interpretation is @xmath330 . for any transition formula @xmath8 and variable @xmath331 ,
the dependence logic formula @xmath332 is defined as 1 .
@xmath333 is @xmath251 ; 2 . for all @xmath106
, @xmath334 is @xmath335 ; 3 .
@xmath336 is @xmath337 , where @xmath338 is the classical disjunction introduced in definition [ defin : classic_or ] ; 4 . @xmath339 is @xmath340 ; 5 .
@xmath341 is @xmath342 , where for any transition term @xmath229 , variable @xmath331 and unary relation symbol @xmath343 , @xmath344 is defined as 1 . for all @xmath225
, @xmath345 is @xmath346 ; 2 . for all formulas @xmath8 ,
@xmath347 is @xmath348 ; 3 .
@xmath349 ; 4 .
@xmath350 ; 5 .
@xmath351 for a new and unused variable @xmath352 .
[ theo : tl - rep2 ] for all transition models @xmath320 , transition terms @xmath229 , transition formulas @xmath8 , variables @xmath331 , sets @xmath353 and teams @xmath19 over @xmath323 with @xmath354 , is a set of states of the transition model . ]
@xmath355 and @xmath356 the proof is by structural induction on terms and formulas .
let us first consider the cases corresponding to formulas : 1 . for all teams @xmath19 , @xmath357 and @xmath358 , as required
suppose that @xmath359 .
then there exists a @xmath360 such that @xmath361 } v_p(j , x)$ ] .
hence , we have that @xmath362 ; and , by downwards closure , this implies that @xmath363 , and hence that @xmath364 as required .
+ conversely , suppose that @xmath364 .
then @xmath363 , and hence @xmath365 for some @xmath366
. then we have by definition that @xmath361 } v_p(j , x)$ ] , and finally that @xmath367 .
3 . by proposition
[ propo : classic_or ] , @xmath368 if and only if @xmath369 or @xmath370 .
by induction hypothesis , this is the case if and only if @xmath371 or @xmath372 , that is , if and only if @xmath373 .
4 . @xmath374 if and only if @xmath369 and @xmath375 , that is , by induction hypothesis , if and only if @xmath376 .
@xmath377 if and only if there exists a @xmath343 such that @xmath378 and @xmath379 } \lnot py \vee ( \psi)^{dl}_y$ ] . by induction hypothesis
, the first condition holds if and only if @xmath380 . as for the second one
, it holds if and only if @xmath381 = y_1 \cup y_2 $ ] for two @xmath41 , @xmath42 such that @xmath382 and @xmath383 .
but then we must have that @xmath384 and that @xmath385 ; therefore , by downwards closure , @xmath386 and finally @xmath387 .
+ conversely , suppose that there exists a @xmath343 such that @xmath380 and @xmath388 ; then by induction hypothesis we have that @xmath389 and that @xmath379 } \lnot py \vee ( \psi)^{dl}_x$ ] , and hence @xmath390 .
now let us consider the cases corresponding to transition terms : 1 .
suppose that @xmath391 .
if @xmath193 then @xmath392 , and hence by * non - creation * we have that @xmath393 , as required
. + let us assume instead that @xmath175 .
then , by hypothesis , there exists a @xmath360 such that * there exists a @xmath313 such that @xmath394[f / y ] } r_t(i , x , y)$ ] ; * @xmath394[t^{dl}/y ] } \lnot r_t(i , x , y ) \vee py$ ] .
+ from the first condition it follows that for every @xmath395 there exists a @xmath396 such that @xmath397 : therefore , by the definition of @xmath327 , every such @xmath113 must be in @xmath398 .
+ from the second condition it follows that whenever @xmath397 and @xmath399 , @xmath400 ; and , since @xmath401 , this implies that @xmath402 by the definition of @xmath327 .
+ hence , by * monotonicity * and * downwards closure * , we have that @xmath403 and that @xmath404 , as required .
+ conversely , suppose that @xmath405 for some @xmath406 .
if @xmath392 then @xmath193 , and hence by proposition [ propo : emptyteam ] we have that @xmath407 , as required . otherwise , by * non - triviality * , @xmath408
let now @xmath409 be any of its elements and let @xmath410 for all @xmath411 $ ] : then @xmath412[f / y ] } r_t(i , x , y)$ ] , as any assignment of this team sends @xmath331 to some element of @xmath398 and @xmath352 to @xmath413 .
furthermore , let @xmath414 , and let @xmath396 be such that @xmath415 : then @xmath416 , and hence @xmath412[t^{dl}/y ] } \lnot r_t(i , x , y ) \vee py$ ] .
so , in conclusion , @xmath417 , as required .
2 . @xmath418 if and only if @xmath419 and @xmath420 , that is , if and only if @xmath421 .
3 . @xmath422 if and only if @xmath237 for two @xmath423 such that * @xmath237 , and therefore @xmath424 ; * @xmath425 , that is , by induction hypothesis , @xmath426 ; * @xmath427 , that is , by induction hypothesis , @xmath428 ; + hence , if @xmath429 then @xmath430 .
+ conversely , if @xmath431 for two @xmath324 , @xmath325 such that @xmath432 and @xmath433 , let @xmath434 clearly @xmath237 , and furthermore by induction hypothesis @xmath425 and @xmath427 .
hence , @xmath429 , as required .
@xmath435 if and only if @xmath436 and @xmath437 , that is , by induction hypothesis , if and only if @xmath438 . 5 .
@xmath439 if and only if there exists a @xmath440 such that @xmath441 and there exists a @xmath442 such that @xmath443 . by downwards closure , if this is the case then @xmath444 too , and hence @xmath445 , as required .
+ conversely , suppose that there exists a @xmath440 such that @xmath441 and @xmath444 .
then , by induction hypothesis @xmath446 ; and furthermore , @xmath381 $ ] can be split into @xmath447 : s(y ) \not \in q\}\ ] ] and @xmath448 : s(y ) \in q\}\ ] ] it is trivial to see that @xmath449 ; and furthermore , since @xmath450 and @xmath444 , by induction hypothesis we have that @xmath451 . thus @xmath379 } \forall y ( \lnot qy \vee ( \tau_2)^{dl}_y(p))$ ] and finally @xmath452 , and this concludes the proof .
hence , the relationship between transition logic and dependence logic is analogous to the one between dynamic game logic and first - order logic . in the next sections
, we will develop variants of dependence logic which are syntactically closer to transition logic , while still being first - order : as we will see , the resulting frameworks are expressively equivalent to dependence logic on the level of satisfiability , but can be used to represent finer - grained phenomena of _ transitions _ between sets of assignments .
now that we have established a connection between dependence logic and a variant of dynamic game logic , it is time to explore what this might imply for the further development of logics of imperfect information . if , as theorems [ theo : tl - rep1 ] and [ theo : tl - rep2 ] suggest , dependence logic can be thought of as a logic of imperfect - information decision problems , perhaps it could be possible to develop variants of dependence logic in which expressions can be interpreted directly as transition systems ? in what follows , we will do exactly that , first with _ transition dependence logic _ a variant of dependence logic , expressively equivalent to it , which is also a quantified version of transition logic and then with _ dynamic dependence logic _
, in which _ all _ expressions are interpreted as transitions ! but why would we interested in such variants of dependence logic ?
one possible answer , which we will discuss in this subsection , is that transitions between teams are _ already _ a central object of study in the field of dependence logic , albeit in a non - explicit manner : after all , the semantics of dependence logic interprets quantifiers in terms of transformations of teams , and disjunctions in terms of decompositions of teams into subteams .
this intuition is central to the study of issues of interdefinability in dependence logic and its variants , like for example the ones discussed in @xcite . as a simple example , let us recall definition [ defin : classic_or ] : @xmath453 where @xmath64 and @xmath65 are new variables . as we said in proposition
[ propo : classic_or ] , @xmath454 if and only if @xmath48 or @xmath49 .
we will now sketch the proof of this result , and as we will see this proof will hinge on the fact that the above expression can be read as a specification of the following algorithm : 1 .
choose an element @xmath455 and extend the team @xmath19 by assigning @xmath456 as the value of @xmath64 for all assignments ; 2 .
choose an element @xmath457 and further extend the team by assigning @xmath458 as the value of @xmath65 for all assignments ; 3 .
split the resulting team into two subteams @xmath41 and @xmath42 such that 1 .
@xmath62 holds in @xmath41 , and the values of @xmath64 and @xmath65 coincide for all assignments in it ; 2 .
@xmath63 holds in @xmath42 , and the values of @xmath64 and @xmath65 differ for all assignments in it . since the values of @xmath64 and @xmath65 are chosen to always be respectively @xmath456 and @xmath458 , one of @xmath41 and @xmath42 is empty and the other is of the form @xmath459 $ ] , and since @xmath64 and @xmath65 do not occur in @xmath62 or @xmath63 the above algorithm can succeed ( for some choice of @xmath456 and @xmath458 ) only if @xmath48 or @xmath49 . as another , slightly more complicated example , let us consider the following problem . given four variables @xmath460 , @xmath461 , @xmath462 and @xmath463 ,
let @xmath464 be an _ exclusion atom _ holding in a team @xmath19 if and only if for all @xmath38 , @xmath465 that is , if and only if the sets of the values taken by @xmath466 and by @xmath467 in @xmath19 are disjoint .
by theorem [ sigmatodl ] , we can tell at once that there exists some dependence logic formula @xmath468 such that for all suitable @xmath7 and @xmath19 , @xmath469 if and only if @xmath470 ; but what about the converse ? for example , can we find an expression @xmath471 , in the language of first order logic augmented with these exclusion atoms ( but with no dependence atoms ) , such that for all suitable @xmath7 and @xmath19 @xmath472 if and only if @xmath473 ?
as discussed in @xcite in a more general setting , the answer is positive , and one such @xmath471 is @xmath474 , where @xmath475 is some variable other than @xmath331 and @xmath352 . in the second disjunct can be removed , but for simplicity we will keep it . ] why is this the case ?
well , let us consider any team @xmath19 with domain containing @xmath331 and @xmath352 , and let us evaluate @xmath476 over it .
as shown graphically in figure [ fig : f1 ] , the transitions between teams occurring during the evaluation of the formula correspond to the following algorithm : 1 .
first , assign all possible values to the variable @xmath475 for all assignments in @xmath331 , thus obtaining @xmath477 = \{s[m / z ] : s \in x , m \in { { \texttt{dom}}}(m)\}$ ] ; 2 . then , remove from @xmath477 $ ] all assignments @xmath11 for which @xmath478 , keeping only the ones for which @xmath479 ; 3 . then , verify that for any possible fixed value of @xmath331 , the possible values of @xmath352 and @xmath475 are disjoint .
this algorithm succeeds only if @xmath352 is a function of @xmath331 .
indeed , suppose that instead there are two assignments @xmath38 such that @xmath480 , @xmath481 and @xmath482 for three @xmath483 with @xmath484 .
now we have that @xmath485 , s[c / z ] , s'[b / z ] , s'[c / z]\ } \subseteq x[m / z]$ ] : and since @xmath484 , we have that the assignments @xmath486 $ ] and @xmath487 $ ] are not removed from the team in the second step of the proof .
but then @xmath486(xz ) = a c = s'[b / z](xy)$ ] , and therefore it is not true that @xmath488 . and , conversely ,
if in the team @xmath19 the value of @xmath352 is a function of the value of @xmath331 then by splitting @xmath477 $ ] into the two subteams @xmath489 : s \in x , s(y ) = s(z)\}$ ] and @xmath490 : s(y ) \not = s(z)\}$ ] we have that @xmath491 , @xmath492 and @xmath493 ( since for all @xmath494 , @xmath495 ) . on the other hand ,
one dependence logic expression corresponding to @xmath464 is @xmath496 where @xmath497 , @xmath498 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 are new variable .
we encourage the interested reader to verify that this is the case by examining the transitions between teams corresponding to the formula : in brief , the intuition is that first we extend our team by picking all possible pairs of values for @xmath497 and @xmath498 , then for any such pair we flag through our choice of @xmath64 and @xmath65 whether @xmath499 is different from @xmath466 or from @xmath467 .
this implies that no such pair is equal to both @xmath466 and @xmath467 , or , in other words , that @xmath466 and @xmath467 have no value in common .
more and more complex examples of definability results of this kind can be found in @xcite ; but what we want to emphasize here is that all these examples , like the one we discussed in depth here , have a natural interpretation in terms of algorithms which transform teams and apply simple tests to them , as the above one .
hence , we hope that the development of variants of dependence logic in which these transitions are made explicit might prove itself useful for the further study of this interesting class of problems .
as stated , we will now define a variant of dependence logic which can also be seen as a quantified variant of transition logic .
we will then prove that the resulting transition dependence logic is expressively equivalent to dependence logic , in the sense that any dependence logic formula is equivalent to some transition dependence logic formula and vice versa .
let @xmath26 be a first - order signature .
then the sets of all _ transition terms _ and of all _ formulas _ of dependence transition logic are given by the rules @xmath500 where @xmath14 ranges over all variables in @xmath31 , @xmath28 ranges over all relation symbols of the signature , @xmath29 ranges over all tuples of terms of the required arities , @xmath501 ranges over @xmath502 and @xmath30 range over the terms of our signature . let @xmath7 be a first - order model , let @xmath229 be a first - order transition term of the same signature , and let @xmath19 and @xmath177 be teams over @xmath7 .
then we say that the transition @xmath503 is _ allowed _ by @xmath229 in @xmath7 , and we write @xmath504 , if and only if tdl-@xmath50 : : : @xmath229 is of the form @xmath505 for some @xmath506 and there exists a @xmath313 such that @xmath507\subseteq y$ ] ; tdl-@xmath55 : : : @xmath229 is of the form @xmath508 for some @xmath506 and @xmath509 \subseteq y$ ] ; tdl - test : : : @xmath229 is of the form @xmath108 , @xmath34 in the sense given later in this definition , and @xmath92 ; tdl-@xmath235 : : : @xmath229 is of the form @xmath264 and @xmath237 for some @xmath238 and @xmath239 such that @xmath510 and @xmath511 ; tdl-@xmath242 : : : @xmath229 is of the form @xmath512 , @xmath513 and @xmath514 ; tdl - concat : : : @xmath229 is of the form @xmath515 and there exists a team @xmath136 such that @xmath516 and @xmath517 .
similarly , if @xmath8 is a formula and @xmath19 is a team with domain @xmath31
. then we say that @xmath19 _ satisfies _ @xmath8 in @xmath7 , and we write @xmath34 , if and only if tdl - lit : : : @xmath8 is a first - order literal and @xmath35 in the usual first - order sense for all @xmath36 ; tdl - dep : : : @xmath8 is a dependence atom @xmath37 and any two @xmath38 which assign the same values to @xmath2 also assign the same value to @xmath1 ; tdl-@xmath39 : : : @xmath8 is of the form @xmath518 and @xmath519 or @xmath520 ; tdl-@xmath46 : : : @xmath8 is of the form @xmath521 , @xmath519 and @xmath520 ; tdl-@xmath156 : : : @xmath8 is of the form @xmath522 and there exists a @xmath177 such that @xmath504 and @xmath71 .
as the next theorem shows , in this semantics formulas and transitions are interpreted in terms of trumps and transition systems : for all transition dependence logic formulas @xmath8 , all models @xmath7 and all teams @xmath19 and @xmath177 , we have that downwards closure : : : if @xmath34 and @xmath70 then @xmath73 ; empty team property : : : @xmath69 .
furthermore , for all transition dependence logic transition terms @xmath229 , all models @xmath7 and all teams @xmath19 , @xmath177 and @xmath136 , downwards closure : : : if @xmath504 and @xmath523 then @xmath524 ; monotonicity : : : if @xmath504 and @xmath525 then @xmath526 ; non - creation : : : for all @xmath177 , @xmath527 ; non - triviality : : : if @xmath175 then @xmath528 . the proof is by structural induction over @xmath8 and @xmath229 , and presents no difficulties whatsoever . also , it is not difficult to see , on the basis of the results of the previous section , that this new variant of dependence logic is equivalent to the usual one : for every dependence logic formula @xmath8 there exists a transition dependence logic transition term @xmath529 such that @xmath530 for all first - order models @xmath7 and teams @xmath19 .
@xmath529 is defined by structural induction on @xmath8 , as follows :
1 . if @xmath8 is a first - order literal or a dependence atom then @xmath531 ; 2 . if @xmath8 is @xmath518 then @xmath532 ; 3 . if @xmath8 is @xmath521 then @xmath533 ; 4 .
if @xmath8 is @xmath51 then @xmath534 ; 5 . if @xmath8 is @xmath56 then @xmath535
it is then trivial to verify , again by induction on @xmath8 , that @xmath34 if and only if @xmath536 , as required . this representation result associates dependence logic _ formulas _ to transition dependence logic _
transition terms_. this fact highlights the dynamical nature of dependence logic operators , which we discussed in the previous subsection : in this framework , quantifiers describe _ transformations _ of teams , the dependence logic connectives are operations over games , and the literals are interpreted as tests .
in fact , one might wonder what is the purpose of transition dependence logic formulas : could we do away with them altogether , and develop a variant of transition dependence logic in which _ all _ formulas are transitions ?
later , we will explore this idea further ; but first , let us verify that transition dependence logic is no more expressive than dependence logic . for every transition dependence logic formula @xmath8
there exists a dependence logic formula @xmath537 such that @xmath538 for all first - order models @xmath7 and teams @xmath19 .
furthermore , for every transition dependence logic transition term @xmath229 and dependence logic formula @xmath211 there is a dependence logic formula @xmath539 such that @xmath540 again for all first - order models @xmath7 and teams @xmath19 .
we prove the two claims together , by structural induction over @xmath8 and @xmath229 .
first , let us consider the cases corresponding to formulas : 1 .
if @xmath8 is a first order literal or a dependence atom , let @xmath537 be @xmath8 itself .
as the interpretation of these expressions is the same in dependence logic and in transition dependence logic , there is nothing to prove .
2 . if @xmath8 is of the form @xmath40 , let @xmath537 be @xmath541 .
this expression holds in a team if and only if @xmath542 or @xmath543 hold , that is , by induction hypothesis , if and only if @xmath62 or @xmath63 do .
if @xmath8 is of the form @xmath47 , let @xmath537 be @xmath544
. then @xmath537 holds if and only if @xmath62 and @xmath63 do , that is , if and only if @xmath8 does .
4 . if @xmath8 is of the form @xmath522 , let @xmath21 be the tuple of all variables occurring in @xmath545 , let @xmath28 be a new @xmath78-ary relation , and let @xmath537 be @xmath546 . indeed , suppose that @xmath547 : then for some relation @xmath28 , there exists a @xmath177 such that @xmath504 and @xmath548 .
furthermore , @xmath549 , and therefore for the set @xmath550 we have that @xmath551 .
but then , by downwards closure and locality , @xmath552 , and therefore @xmath553
. + conversely , suppose that @xmath554 : then there exists a @xmath177 such that @xmath504 and @xmath71 .
now let @xmath28 be @xmath555 : clearly @xmath556 , since @xmath557 , and furthermore @xmath558 , by locality and by the fact that ( by induction hypothesis ) @xmath552 .
now let us consider the cases corresponding to transitions : 1 .
if @xmath229 is of the form @xmath505 for some variable @xmath14 , let @xmath559 be @xmath560 . indeed , suppose that @xmath561 : then @xmath53 } \theta$ ] for some @xmath313 , and by choosing @xmath562 $ ] we have that @xmath563 and @xmath564 , as required .
conversely , suppose that for some @xmath177 , @xmath563 and @xmath564 : then for some @xmath313 , @xmath507 \subseteq y$ ] , and by downwards closure we have that @xmath53 } \theta$ ] .
2 . if @xmath229 is of the form @xmath508 for some variable @xmath14 , let @xmath559 be @xmath565 . indeed , suppose that @xmath566 : then @xmath57 } \theta$ ] , and if we choose @xmath567 $ ] we have at once that @xmath568 and @xmath564 .
conversely , if for some @xmath177 @xmath568 and @xmath564 then @xmath509 \subseteq y$ ] and , by downwards closure , @xmath57 } \theta$ ] .
3 . if @xmath229 is of the form @xmath108 , let @xmath559 be @xmath569 . indeed , suppose that @xmath570 : then by induction hypothesis @xmath34 , and , for @xmath571 , we have that @xmath572
. furthermore , @xmath564 , as required .
conversely , suppose that for some @xmath177 , @xmath572 and @xmath564 .
then @xmath34 , and therefore @xmath547 ; and furthermore @xmath92 , and hence by downwards closure @xmath573 .
hence , @xmath574 .
4 . if @xmath229 is of the form @xmath264 and @xmath21 is the tuple of all free variables of @xmath211 then let @xmath559 be @xmath575 , where @xmath28 is a new @xmath576-ary relation symbol . indeed
, suppose that @xmath577 : then there exists a relation @xmath28 and two subteams @xmath238 and @xmath239 of @xmath19 such that @xmath237 , @xmath578 and @xmath579 .
hence , there are two teams @xmath41 and @xmath42 such that @xmath580 , @xmath581 , @xmath582 and @xmath583 .
now , let @xmath177 be @xmath584 : by monotonicity , we have that @xmath510 and @xmath511 , and furthermore @xmath557 too ( that is , for all @xmath585 , @xmath586 is in @xmath28 ) .
since @xmath587 , this implies that @xmath564 , by locality and downwards closure .
+ conversely , suppose that there is a @xmath177 such that @xmath588 and @xmath564 .
then let @xmath28 be @xmath589 .
now @xmath237 for two @xmath238 and
@xmath239 such that @xmath510 and @xmath511 , and by induction hypothesis we have that @xmath590 and @xmath591 .
but then @xmath592 ; and furthermore , by locality we have that @xmath587 .
hence , @xmath593 , as required .
if @xmath229 is of the form @xmath512 and @xmath21 is the tuple of all variables of @xmath211 then let @xmath559 be @xmath594 . indeed , suppose that @xmath577 : then for some relation @xmath28 , by induction hypothesis , there exist teams @xmath41 and @xmath42 such that @xmath595 , @xmath596 , @xmath582 and @xmath583 .
now let @xmath177 be @xmath584 : as before , by monotonicity we have that @xmath513 and @xmath597 , and hence @xmath598 . finally ,
since @xmath587 we have that @xmath599 , as required .
+ conversely , suppose that there is a @xmath177 such that @xmath598 and @xmath564 . since @xmath598 , @xmath513 and @xmath597 .
now let @xmath28 be @xmath555 .
by induction hypothesis , @xmath600 and @xmath601 ; and furthermore , since @xmath564 we have that @xmath587 .
if @xmath229 is of the form @xmath515 let @xmath559 be @xmath602 .
indeed , @xmath603 if and only if there is a @xmath177 such that @xmath604 and @xmath605 , that is , if and only if there are a @xmath177 and a @xmath136 such that @xmath513 , @xmath606 and @xmath607 .
however , in a sense , transition dependence logic allows one to consider subtler distinctions than dependence logic does .
the formula @xmath608 , for example , could be translated as any of * @xmath609 ; * @xmath610 ; * @xmath611 ; * @xmath612 .
the intended interpretations of these formulas are rather different , even though they happen to be satisfied by the same teams : and for this reason , transition dependence logic may be thought of as a proper refinement of dependence logic even though it has exactly the same expressive power .
_ dynamic semantics _ is the name given to a family of semantical frameworks which subscribe to the following principle ( @xcite ) : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the meaning of a sentence does not lie in its truth conditions , but rather in the way it changes ( the representation of ) the information of the interpreter . _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ in various forms , this intuition can be found prefigured in some of the later work of ludwig wittgenstein , as well as in the research of philosophers of language such as austin , grice , searle , strawson and others ( @xcite ) ; but its formal development can be traced back to the work of groenendijk and stokhof about the proper treatment of pronouns in formal linguistics ( @xcite ) .
+ we refer to @xcite for a comprehensive analysis of the linguistic issues which caused such a development , as well as for a description of the ways in which this framework was adapted in order to model presuppositions , questions / answers and other phenomena ; here we will only present a formulation of _ dynamic predicate semantics _ , the alternative semantics for first - order logic which was developed in the above mentioned paper by groenendijk and stokhof .
let @xmath8 be a first - order formula , let @xmath7 be a suitable first - order model and let @xmath11 and @xmath182 be two assignments .
then we say that the transition from @xmath11 to @xmath182 is _ allowed _ by @xmath8 in @xmath7 , and we write @xmath613 , if and only if dpl - atom : : : @xmath8 is an atomic formula , @xmath614 and @xmath35 in the usual sense ; dpl-@xmath153 : : : @xmath8 is of the form @xmath615 , @xmath616 and for all assignments @xmath617 , @xmath618 ; dpl-@xmath46 : : : @xmath8 is of the form @xmath47 and there exists an @xmath617 such that @xmath619 and @xmath620 ; dpl-@xmath39 : : : @xmath8 is of the form @xmath40 , @xmath614 and there exists an @xmath617 such that @xmath619 or @xmath621 ; dpl-@xmath622 : : : @xmath8 is of the form @xmath623 , @xmath614 and for all @xmath617 it holds that @xmath624 dpl-@xmath50 : : : @xmath8 is of the form @xmath625 and there exists an element @xmath626 such that @xmath627 \rightarrow s ' } \psi$ ] ; dpl-@xmath55 : : : @xmath8 is of the form @xmath628 , @xmath614 and for all elements @xmath626 there exists an @xmath617 such that @xmath627 \rightarrow h } \psi$ ] . a formula @xmath8 is _ satisfied _ by an assignment @xmath11 if and
only if there exists an assignment @xmath182 such that @xmath613 ; in this case , we will write @xmath35 . we will discuss neither the formal properties of this formalism nor its linguistic applications here .
all that is relevant for our purposes is that , according to it , formulas are interpreted as _
transitions _ from assignments to assignments , and furthermore that the rule for conjunction allows us to bind occurrences of a variable of the second conjunct to quantifiers occurring in the first one . : by the rules given , it is easy to see that @xmath629 if and only if @xmath630 , that is , if and only if @xmath631 , differently from the case of tarski s semantics . ] the similarity between this semantics and our semantics for transition terms should be evident .
hence , it seems natural to ask whether we can adopt , for a suitable variant of dependence logic , the following variant of groenendijk and stokhof s motto : + _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the meaning of a formula does not lie in its satisfaction conditions , but rather in the team transitions it allows .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ from this point of view , _ transition terms _ are the fundamental objects of our syntax , and formulas can be removed altogether from the language although , of course , the tests corresponding to literals and dependence formulas should still be available . as in groenendijk and stokhof s logic , satisfaction becomes then a derived concept : in brief , a team @xmath19 can be said to satisfy a term @xmath229 if and only if there exists a @xmath177 such that @xmath229 allows the transition from @xmath19 to @xmath177 , or , in other words , if and only if _ some _ set of non - losing outcomes can be reached from the set @xmath19 of initial positions in the game corresponding to @xmath229 .
in the next section , we will make use of these intuitions to develop another , terser version of dependence logic ; and finally , we will discuss some implications of this new version for the further developments and for the possible applications of this interesting logical formalism .
we will now develop a formula - free variant of transition dependence logic , along the lines of groenendijk and stockhof s dynamic predicate logic .
let @xmath26 be a first - order signature .
the set of all formulas of dynamic dependence logic over @xmath26 is given by the rules @xmath632 where , as usual , @xmath28 ranges over all relation symbols of our signature , @xmath29 ranges over all tuples of terms of the required lengths , @xmath501 ranges over @xmath502 , @xmath30 range over all terms , and @xmath14 ranges over @xmath31 .
the semantical rules associated to this language are precisely as one would expect : [ ddl - tts ] let @xmath7 be a first - order model , let @xmath229 be a dynamic dependence logic formula over the signature of @xmath7 , and let @xmath19 and @xmath177 be two teams over @xmath7 with domain @xmath31 .
then we say that @xmath229 _ allows _ the transition @xmath185 in @xmath7 , and we write @xmath504 , if and only if ddl - lit : : : @xmath229 is a first - order literal , @xmath633 in the usual first - order sense for all @xmath36 , and @xmath92 ; ddl - dep : : : @xmath229 is a dependence atom @xmath37 , @xmath92 , and any two assignments @xmath38 which coincide over @xmath2 also coincide over @xmath1 ; ddl-@xmath50 : : : @xmath229 is of the form @xmath505 for some @xmath506 , and @xmath507 \subseteq y$ ] for some @xmath52 ; ddl-@xmath55 : : : @xmath229 is of the form @xmath508 for some @xmath506 , and @xmath509 \subseteq y$ ] ; ddl-@xmath235 : : : @xmath229 is of the form @xmath264 and @xmath237 for two teams @xmath238 and @xmath239 such that @xmath510 and @xmath511 ; ddl-@xmath242 : : : @xmath229 is of the form @xmath512 , @xmath513 and @xmath597 ; ddl - concat : : : @xmath229 is of the form @xmath515 , and there exists a @xmath136 such that @xmath516 and @xmath517 . a formula @xmath229 is said to be _ satisfied _ by a team @xmath19 in a model @xmath7 if and only if there exists a @xmath177 such that @xmath504 ; and if this is the case , we will write @xmath634 .
it is not difficult to see that dynamic dependence logic is equivalent to transition dependence logic ( and , therefore , to dependence logic ) .
let @xmath8 be a dependence logic formula .
then there exists a dynamic dependence logic formula @xmath635 which is equivalent to it , in the sense that @xmath636 for all suitable teams @xmath19 and models @xmath7 we build @xmath635 by structural induction : 1 . if @xmath8 is a literal or a dependence atom then @xmath637 ; 2 . if @xmath8 is @xmath40 then @xmath638 ; 3 . if @xmath8 is @xmath47 then @xmath639 ; 4 . if @xmath8 is @xmath625 then @xmath640 ; 5 . if @xmath8 is @xmath628 then @xmath641 .
let @xmath229 be a dynamic dependence logic formula .
then there exists a transition dependence logic transition term @xmath642 such that @xmath643 for all suitable @xmath19 , @xmath177 and @xmath7 , and such that hence @xmath644 build @xmath642 by structural induction : 1 . if @xmath229 is a literal or dependence atom then @xmath645 ; 2 . if @xmath229 is of the form @xmath505 or @xmath508 then @xmath646 ; 3 . if @xmath229 is of the form @xmath264 then @xmath647 ; 4 . if @xmath229 is of the form @xmath512 then @xmath648 ; 5 . if @xmath229 is of the form @xmath515 then @xmath649 .
dynamic dependence logic is equivalent to transition dependence logic and to dependence logic follows from the two previous results and from the equivalence between dependence logic and transition dependence logic .
in this work , we established a connection between a variant of dynamic game logic and dependence logic , and we used it as the basis for the development of variants of dependence logic in which it is possible to talk directly about transitions from teams to teams .
this suggests a new perspective on dependence logic and team semantics , one which allow us to study them as a special kind of _ algebras of nondeterministic transitions between relations_. one of the main problems that is now open is whether it is possible to axiomatize these algebras , in the same sense in which , in @xcite , allen mann offers an axiomatization of the algebra of trumps corresponding to if logic ( or , equivalently , to dependence logic ) .
furthermore , we might want to consider different choices of connectives , like for example ones related to the theory of database transactions .
the investigation of the relationships between the resulting formalisms is a natural continuation of the currently ongoing work on the study of the relationship between various extensions of dependence logic , and promises of being of great utility for the further development of this fascinating line of research .
the author wishes to thank johan van benthem and jouko vnnen for a number of useful suggestions and insights .
furthermore , he wishes to thank the reviewers for a number of highly useful suggestions and comments .
hintikka , j. and g. sandu : 1989 , ` informational independence as a semantic phenomenon ' . in : j. fenstad ,
i. frolov , and r. hilpinen ( eds . ) : _ logic , methodology and philosophy of science_. elsevier , pp .
571589 .
kontinen , j. and v. nurmi : 2009 , ` team logic and second - order logic ' .
in : h. ono , m. kanazawa , and r. de queiroz ( eds . ) : _ logic , language , information and computation _ , vol .
5514 of _ lecture notes in computer science_. springer berlin / heidelberg , pp .
230241 .
parikh , r. : 1985 , ` the logic of games and its applications ' . in : _ selected papers of the international conference on `` foundations of computation theory '' on topics in the theory of computation_. new york , ny , usa , pp .
111139 .
vnnen , j. : 2007b , ` team logic ' . in : j. van benthem , d. gabbay , and b. lwe ( eds . ) : _ interactive logic .
selected papers from the 7th augustus de morgan workshop_. msterdam university press , pp . | we examine the relationship between dependence logic and game logics .
a variant of dynamic game logic , called _ transition logic _ , is developed , and we show that its relationship with dependence logic is comparable to the one between first - order logic and dynamic game logic discussed by van benthem .
this suggests a new perspective on the interpretation of dependence logic formulas , in terms of assertions about _ reachability _ in games of imperfect information against nature .
we then capitalize on this intuition by developing expressively equivalent variants of dependence logic in which this interpretation is taken to the foreground . |
this work was supported by the singapore - mit alliance under the hpces program .
10 c. cercignani , _ the boltzmann equation and its applications _ , springer - verlag , new york , 1988 .
g. chen , _ nanoscale energy transport and conversion _ , oxford , new york , 2005 . v.
l. gurevich , _ transport in phonon systems _ , north - holland , new york , 1986 .
m. lundstrom , _ fundamentals of carrier transport _ , 2nd ed . , cambridge university press , cambridge , 2000 .
b. davidson , j.b .
sykes , _ neutron transport theory _ , clarendon press , 1957 .
m. f. modest , _ radiative heat transfer _
, academic press , usa , 2003 .
g. chen , `` ballistic - diffusive heat - conduction equations '' , _ physical review letters _ , * 86 * , 22973000 , 2001
. a. majumdar , `` microscale heat conduction in dielectric thin films '' , _ journal of heat transfer _ , * 115 * , 716 , 1993 . l. l. baker and n. g. hadjiconstantinou , `` variance reduction for monte carlo solutions of the boltzmann equation '' , _ physics of fluids _ , * 17 * , 051703 , 2005 . g. a. bird , _ molecular gas dynamics and the direct simulation of gas flows , _ clarendon press , oxford , 1994
. n. g. hadjiconstantinou , a. l. garcia , m. z. bazant and g. he , `` statistical error in particle simulations of hydrodynamic phenomena , '' _ journal of computational physics _ , * 187 * , 274 - 297 , 2003 .
l. l. baker and n. g. hadjiconstantinou , `` variance - reduced particle methods for solving the boltzmann equation '' , _ journal of computational and theoretical nanoscience _ , * 5 * , 165174 , 2008 . t. m. m. homolle and n. g. hadjiconstantinou , `` low - variance deviational simulation monte carlo '' , _ physics of fluids _ , * 19 * , 041701 , 2007 . t. m. m. homolle and n. g. hadjiconstantinou , `` a low - variance deviational simulation monte carlo for the boltzmann equation '' , _ journal of computational physics _
, * 226 * , 2341 - 2358 , 2007 .
k. xu , `` a gas - kinetic bgk scheme for the navier - stokes equations and its connection with artificial dissipation and godunov method '' , _ journal of computational physics _ , * 171 * , 289335 , 2001 . y. sone , _ kinetic theory and fluid dynamics _ , birkhauser , 2002 .
p. bassanini , c. cercignani and c. d. pagani , `` comparison of kinetic theory analyses of linearized heat transfer between parallel plates '' , _ international journal of heat and mass transfer _ , * 10 * , 447460 , 1967 . n. g. hadjiconstantinou , `` the limits of navier - stokes theory and kinetic extensions for describing small - scale gaseous hydrodynamics '' , _ physics of fluids _ , * 18 * , 111301 , 2006 .
c. cercignani and a. daneri , `` flow of a rarefied gas between two parallel plates '' , _ journal of applied physics _ , * 34 * , 35093513 , 1963 . g. a. radtke and n. g. hadjiconstantinou , `` variance - reduced particle simulation of the boltzmann transport equation in the relaxation - time approximation '' , to appear in _ physical review e_. | we present and discuss a variance - reduced stochastic particle method for simulating the relaxation - time model of the boltzmann transport equation .
the present paper focuses on the dilute gas case , although the method is expected to directly extend to all fields ( carriers ) for which the relaxation - time approximation is reasonable .
the variance reduction , achieved by simulating only the deviation from equilibrium , results in a significant computational efficiency advantage compared to traditional stochastic particle methods in the limit of small deviation from equilibrium .
more specifically , the proposed method can efficiently simulate arbitrarily small deviations from equilibrium at a computational cost that is independent of the deviation from equilibrium , which is in sharp contrast to traditional particle methods . the boltzmann transport equation @xmath0 _ { \textrm{coll}}}}\ ] ] where @xmath1 is the single - particle distribution function @xcite , @xmath2 _ { \textrm{coll}}}}$ ] denotes the collision operator , @xmath3 is the acceleration due to an external field , @xmath4 is the position vector in physical space , @xmath5 is the molecular velocity vector , and @xmath6 is time , is used to describe ( under appropriate conditions ) transport processes in a wide variety of fields @xcite including dilute gas flow @xcite , phonon @xcite , electron @xcite , neutron @xcite and photon transport @xcite .
recently , it has received renewed attention in connection to micro- and nano - scale science and technology where transport at lengthscales of the order of , or smaller than , the carrier mean free path is frequently considered ( e.g. nanoscale solid - state heat transfer @xcite ) numerical solution of the boltzmann equation remains a formidable task due to the complexity associated with the collision operator and the high dimensionality of the distribution function .
both these features have contributed to the prevalence of particle solution methods , which are typically able to simulate the collision operator through simple and physically intuitive stochastic processes while employing importance sampling , which reduces computational cost and memory usage @xcite .
another contributing factor to the prevalence of particle schemes is their natural treatment of the advection operator , which results in a numerical method that can easily handle and accurately capture traveling discontinuities in the distribution function @xcite .
an example of a particle method is the direct simulation monte carlo ( dsmc ) @xcite which has become the prevalent simulation method for dilute gas flow .
one of the most important disadvantages of particle methods for solving the boltzmann equation derives from their reliance on statistical averaging for extracting field quantities from particle data .
when simulating processes close to equilibrium , thermal noise typically exceeds the available signal .
when coupled with the slow convergence of statistical sampling ( statistical error decreases with the square root of the number of samples ) , this often leads to computationally intractable problems @xcite .
for example , to resolve a flow speed of the order of 1 m / s to 1% statistical uncertainty in a dilute gas , on the order of @xmath7 independent samples are needed @xcite . in a recent paper , baker and hadjiconstantinou
have shown @xcite that this rather severe limitation can be overcome with a form of variance reduction achieved by simulating only the deviation from equilibrium . by adopting this approach
, it is possible to construct monte carlo simulation methods that can capture arbitrarily small deviations from equilibrium at a computational cost that is independent of the magnitude of this deviation .
this is in sharp contrast to regular monte carlo methods , such as dsmc , whose computational cost for the same signal - to - noise ratio increases _ sharply _ @xcite as the deviation from equilibrium decreases .
the work in refs @xcite focused on the boltzmann equation for hard spheres and the associated hard - sphere collision operator .
the complexity associated with this collision operator , as well as others in related fields , has prompted scientists to search for simplified models ; one particularly popular model is the relaxation - time approximation @xcite @xmath8 _ { \textrm{coll}}}}=-\frac{1}{\tau } \left(f - f^{loc}\right)\ ] ] where @xmath9 is the _ local equilibrium _
distribution function and @xmath10 is a relaxation time . despite the approximation involved , this collision model has enjoyed widespread application in a variety of disciplines concerned with transport processes @xcite . in response to this widespread use ,
in the present paper , we present a variance - reduced particle method for simulating the boltzmann equation under the relaxation - time approximation . to focus the discussion
, we specialize our treatment to the dilute gas case ; however , we hope that this exposition can serve as a prototype for development of similar techniques in all fields where the relaxation - time approximation is applicable . within the rarefied gas dynamics literature
, the relaxation - time approximation is known as the bgk model @xcite . in the interest of simplicity , in the present paper
we assume @xmath11 and that no external forces are present . the first assumption can be easily relaxed , as discussed below .
external fields also require relatively straightforward modifications to the algorithm presented below .
as discussed in previous work @xcite , a variance - reduced formulation is obtained by simulating only the deviation @xmath12 from an _ arbitrary _ , but judiciously chosen , underlying equilibrium distribution @xmath13 .
in other words , computational particles represent the deviation from equilibrium and , as a result , they may be positive or negative , depending on the sign of the deviation from equilibrium at the location in phase space where they reside . as in other particle schemes
@xcite , in the interest of computational efficiency , each _ computational _ deviational particle represents an _ effective number _
@xmath14 of physical deviational particles .
a dilute gas in equilibrium is described by a maxwell - boltzmann distribution , leading to a local equilibrium distribution @xmath15 that is parametrized by the local number density @xmath16 , the local flow velocity @xmath17 , and the most probable speed @xmath18 based on local temperature @xmath19 . here
, @xmath20 is boltzmann s constant and @xmath21 is the molecular mass . in the work that follows
, the underlying equilibrium distribution ( @xmath13 ) will be identified with absolute equilibrium @xmath22 where @xmath23 is a reference ( equilibrium ) number density and @xmath24 is the most probable molecular speed based on the reference temperature @xmath25 .
this choice provides a reasonable balance between generality , computational efficiency and simplicity .
other choices are of course possible and , depending on the problem , perhaps more efficient .
however , care needs to be taken if a spatially varying or time dependent underlying equilibrium distribution is chosen since this results in a more complex algorithm @xcite .
particle methods typically solve the boltzmann equation by applying a splitting scheme , in which molecular motion is simulated as a series of collisionless advection and collision steps of length @xmath26 .
in such a scheme , the collisionless advection step integrates @xmath27 by simply advecting particles for a timestep @xmath26 , while the collision step integrates @xmath28 _ { \textrm{coll}}}}\label{collision}\ ] ] by changing the distribution by an amount @xmath2 _ { \textrm{coll}}}}({\bf r},{\bf c},t)\delta t$ ] .
spatial discretization is introduced by treating collisions as spatially homogeneous within ( small ) computational cells of volume @xmath29 .
our approach retains this basic structure ; the particular form of these steps can be summarized as follows .
_ advection step : _ it can be easily verified that when the underlying equilibrium distribution is not a function of space or time , as is the case here , the advection step for deviational particles is identical to that of physical particles [ i.e. @xmath30 is also governed by equation ( [ advection ] ) during the advection step ] .
boundary condition implementation , however , differs somewhat because the mass flux to boundaries is now split into a deviational contribution and an equilibrium contribution .
a more extensive discussion , as well as algorithmic details can be found in @xcite .
_ collision step : _ the variance - reduced form of ( [ collision ] ) can be written as @xmath8 _ { \textrm{coll}}}}= \frac{1}{\tau } \left(f^{loc}-f\right)-\frac{1}{\tau } f^d \label{start}\ ] ] _ within each computational cell _ we integrate equation ( [ start ] ) using a two - part process .
this integration requires local ( cell ) values of various quantities , denoted here by hats , which are updated every timestep by sampling the instantaneous state of the gas . in the first part we remove a random sample of particles by deleting particles with probability @xmath31 to satisfy @xmath32 in our implementation , this
is achieved through an acceptance - rejection process which can also treat the case @xmath33 . in the second part
, we create a set of positive and negative particles ( using an acceptance - rejection process ) to satisfy @xmath34\ , \delta t \label{add}\ ] ] this step can be achieved by the following procedure .
let @xmath35 be a ( positive ) value such that @xmath36 is negligible for @xmath37 , where @xmath38 is an @xmath39-norm .
furthermore , let @xmath40 bound @xmath41 from above
. then , repeat @xmath42 times : 1 . generate uniformly distributed , random velocity vectors @xmath43 with @xmath44 .
2 . if @xmath45 , create a particle with velocity @xmath46 , at a randomly chosen position within the cell and sign @xmath47 $ ] . here
, @xmath48 is a random number uniformly distributed on [ 0,1 ] . to find @xmath49 we note that the number of particles ( of all velocities and signs ) that should be generated in a cell to obtain the proper change in the distribution function is @xmath50 where @xmath51 is the cell volume .
the ( expected ) total number of particles ultimately generated by the above algorithm is @xmath52 by equating the two expressions we obtain @xmath53 . we have verified the above algorithm using a variety of test cases ; some representative results are presented below .
figure [ heat ] shows a comparison between numerical solution of the bgk model of the boltzmann equation @xcite and our simulation results for the heat flux , @xmath54 , between two parallel , infinite , fully - accommodating plates at slightly different temperatures ( @xmath25 and @xmath55 ) and a distance @xmath56 apart .
the figure compares the heat flux normalized by the free - molecular ( ballistic ) value @xmath57 as a function of a knudsen number @xcite @xmath58 , where @xmath59 is the equilibrium gas pressure .
the agreement is excellent .
the simulations used approximately 50,000 particles yielding a relative statistical uncertainty of less than 0.5% .
these simulations were performed at @xmath60k , although as shown below , the cost is expected to be independent of the magnitude of @xmath61 in the limit of small deviation from equilibrium .
we also performed dsmc simulations of the bgk model using @xmath62k and otherwise identical discretization and sampling parameters ; @xmath62k was chosen as a compromise between best performance and a deviation from equilibrium that is small enough for the linearized conditions , and thus the benchmark results of @xcite , to be valid .
figure [ poi ] shows a comparison between a numerical solution of the linearized bgk model of the boltzmann equation @xcite and our simulation results for pressure - driven flow ( for small pressure gradients ) . under linear conditions ,
pressure - driven flow can be described @xcite by @xmath63 _ { \textrm{coll}}}}- \kappa c_z f\ ] ] where @xmath64 is the normalized pressure gradient ( here assumed to be in the @xmath65direction ) , and @xmath66 is the channel transverse direction . for @xmath67
, the term @xmath68 can be included in our formulation as a source of @xmath69 positive and an equal number of negative deviational physical . ] particles per unit volume drawn from the distribution @xmath70 for @xmath71 and @xmath72 , respectively .
figure [ poi ] shows the normalized flowrate @xmath73 as a function of @xmath74 , where @xmath75 is the gas density and @xmath76 is the average flow velocity ( averaged across the channel width ) .
excellent agreement is observed . as stated above and shown in @xcite , this class of deviational methods exhibit statistical uncertainties that scale with the local deviation from equilibrium thus allowing the simulation of arbitrarily low deviations from equilibrium at a cost that is independent of this deviation .
here we demonstrate this feature by studying the statistical uncertainty of the temperature in a problem involving heat transfer .
specifically , figure [ fluct ] shows the relative statistical uncertainty in the temperature ( @xmath77 ) as a function of the normalized wall temperature difference @xmath78 in the heat transfer problem discussed above , for @xmath79 and @xmath80k ; in evaluating @xmath77 , the characteristic value for temperature was taken to be the difference @xmath81 .
the standard deviation is measured from two computational cells in the middle of the computational domain , each containing approximately 950 particles .
the figure shows that , for small @xmath81 , the relative statistical uncertainty remains independent of this quantity in sharp contrast to `` non - deviational '' methods .
moreover , the variance reduction achieved is such that significant computational savings are expected for @xmath82 .
the algorithm described above imposes no restrictions on the magnitude of @xmath30 , although it is expected that the deviational approach will be significantly more efficient than traditional approaches when @xmath30 is small .
if @xmath30 is sufficiently small for linearization to be appropriate , under some conditions , significant gains in computational efficiency can be achieved by taking the following into consideration . under linear conditions , for the present model , we can write @xmath83 \label{lin}\ ] ] where @xmath84 and @xmath85
. this representation can be very useful for improving the computational efficiency of update ( [ add ] ) .
for example , for isothermal constant density flows , particles can be generated from a combination of a normal distribution and analytic inversion of the cumulative distribution function , which is significantly more efficient than acceptance - rejection .
alternatively , ( [ lin ] ) provides a means of obtaining tight bounds for @xmath86 and thus reducing the number of rejections if the acceptance - rejection route is followed .
we have presented an efficient variance - reduced particle method for solving the boltzmann equation in the relaxation - time approximation .
the method combines simplicity with a number of desirable properties associated with particle methods , such as robust capture of traveling discontinuities in the distribution function and efficient collision operator evaluation using importance sampling @xcite , without the high relative statistical uncertainty associated with traditional particle methods in low - signal problems .
in particular , the method presented here can capture arbitrarily small deviations from equilibrium for constant computational cost .
more sophisticated techniques with spatially variable underlying equilibrium distribution @xcite are expected to increase computational efficiency by reducing the number of deviational particles required to describe the local state of the gas .
one such technique is described in @xcite . |
if one combines today s standard model of particle physics ( sm ) and that of cosmology , one finds inevitably that particles and their antiparticles annihilate at a very early moment in the evolution of the universe , leaving just radiation behind .
the absence of a sizable matter - antimatter asymmetry at this epoch would imply that the universe as we know it could never form .
the question about the origin of the observed asymmetry therefore represents a major challenge for modern physics . in the sm baryon and lepton number
are ( accidental ) global symmetries .
if baryon number was also conserved in the early universe a dynamical emergence of the asymmetry would have been impossible . in grand - unified extensions ( guts ) of the sm baryon number ( and also lepton number )
is explicitly broken . according to past reasoning
, this could provide a solution to the apparent discrepancy . in the class of `
gut - baryogenesis ' scenarios the matter - antimatter imbalance is generated by asymmetric decays of new super - heavy bosons .
anomalous electroweak processes @xcite ( sphalerons ) which violate baryon and lepton number but conserve their difference essentially eliminated the prospects for gut - baryogenesis @xcite . at the same time , it inspired the now widely appreciated scenarios of ` electroweak baryogenesis ' @xcite and ` baryogenesis via leptogenesis ' @xcite . according to the latter scenario , the asymmetry is initially generated in the leptonic sector by the decay of heavy majorana neutrinos at an energy scale far above the electroweak scale .
subsequently it is converted into the observed baryon asymmetry by sphalerons .
the mass scale of the heavy majorana neutrinos required for leptogenesis @xcite fits together very well with the mass - differences inferred from observations of solar- , atmospheric- and reactor - neutrino oscillations .
we focus here on the conventional , but most popular , high - energy ( type - i ) seesaw extension : @xmath0 where @xmath1 are the heavy majorana fields , @xmath2 are the lepton doublets , @xmath3 is the conjugate of the higgs doublet , and @xmath4 are the corresponding yukawa couplings .
the majorana mass term violates lepton number and the yukawa couplings can violate _
therefore the model fulfills essential requirements for baryogenesis @xcite .
they can also be realized for more complicated sm extensions and a wide range of values for couplings and neutrino masses @xcite . in general the right - handed neutrinos
do not necessarily get into thermal equilibrium and _ cp_-violating oscillations between them can contribute to the asymmetry .
this effect of leptogenesis through neutrino oscillations @xcite is crucial for neutrino - minimal extensions of the sm ( @xmath5msm ) @xcite and poses interesting questions for non - equilibrium quantum field theory @xcite . in the considered scenario of thermal leptogenesis the heavy majorana neutrinos experience only a moderate deviation from thermal equilibrium at the time when the bulk of the asymmetry is produced .
also , for a hierarchical mass spectrum , effects related to oscillations are negligible .
the amount of the generated asymmetry is determined by the out of equilibrium evolution of the heavy majorana neutrinos .
therefore , statistical equations for the abundance of the neutrinos and the generated asymmetry are needed .
the conventional approach here follows the lines developed for gut - baryogenesis @xcite .
cp_-violating amplitudes for the decay and scattering processes involving the heavy majorana neutrinos are computed in terms of feynman graphs at lowest loop order .
they are used to build generalized boltzmann collision terms for these processes .
each of them contributes to the evolution of the distributions of majorana neutrinos and leptons or , upon momentum integration , their entire abundances .
however this approach is plagued by the so - called double - counting problem which manifests itself in the generation of a non - vanishing asymmetry even in thermal equilibrium .
this technical issue is expression of the fact that the ` naive ' generalization of the collision terms is quantitatively inexact , and inconsistent in the presence of _ cp_-violation . after a real intermediate state ( or ris )
subtraction procedure and a number of approximations , it can be made consistent with fundamental requirements .
nevertheless this pragmatic solution remains unsatisfactory .
the requirement of unitarity guarantees a consistent approximation for the amplitudes , realized by the ris subtraction , if the statistical system is in thermal equilibrium .
however , the deviation from equilibrium is a fundamental requirement for leptogenesis and it is not obvious how the equations have to be generalized for a system out of equilibrium .
furthermore , the _ cp_-violation arises from one - loop contributions due to the exchange of virtual quanta . as such they seem to be beyond a boltzmann approximation .
but the relevant imaginary part is due to intermediate states in which at least some of the particles are on - shell .
these can also be absorbed or emitted by the medium and it is not obvious how such contributions enter the amplitudes .
it is , however , clear that the influence of medium effects on the one - loop contributions enters directly the _ cp_-violating parameter and therefore the source for the lepton asymmetry .
their size can be of the same order as that of the vacuum contributions .
those questions can be addressed within a first - principle approach based on non - equilibrium quantum field theory ( neqft ) .
several aspects of leptogenesis have already been investigated within this approach @xcite .
the influence of medium effects on the generation of the asymmetry has been studied e.g. in @xcite , and an analysis with special emphasis on off - shell effects was performed in @xcite .
the role of flavor effects as well as the range of applicability of the conventional approach to the analysis of flavored leptogenesis has been investigated in @xcite .
the resonant enhancement of the lepton asymmetry has been addressed within a first - principle approach in @xcite .
in addition , steps towards a consistent inclusion of gauge interactions have been taken @xcite . in this work
we use the 2pi - formalism of neqft to derive boltzmann - like quantum kinetic equations for the lepton asymmetry .
in particular , we show how two - body scattering processes that violate lepton number by two units and contribute to the washout of the asymmetry emerge within the 2pi - formalism .
this approach treats quantum field theory and the out of equilibrium evolution on an equal footing and allows to overcome the conceptional difficulties inherent in the conventional approach .
it allows us to obtain quantum - generalized boltzmann equations which include medium effects and which are free of the double - counting problem . in other words
, the structure of the obtained quantum kinetic equations automatically ensures that the asymmetry vanishes in thermal equilibrium and no need for ris subtraction arises .
the resulting equation for the lepton asymmetry @xmath6 is given by @xmath7 together with the ` effective amplitudes ' @xmath8 this is the main result of this paper . in eq .
we introduced @xmath9 { { \ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath10 for fermions ( bosons ) .
note that @xmath11 vanishes in equilibrium due to detailed balance .
this ensures that the asymmetry vanishes in thermal equilibrium as mentioned before .
the effective amplitudes contain medium effects ignored in the corresponding canonical expressions .
we find that , in the amplitudes of the scattering processes medium effects are sub - dominant and can be neglected .
the total decay amplitude of the majorana neutrino is barely affected as well .
however , at high temperatures the available phase space shrinks when taking gauge interactions in the form of effective thermal masses of higgs and leptons into account .
this leads to a suppression of the decay and scattering rates . since the _ cp_-violation appears as loop effect it is more sensitive to influences of the surrounding medium . even though there is a partial cancellation of the fermionic and bosonic contributions , the _
cp_-violating parameter is enhanced by medium effects .
however , the thermal masses reduce the enhancement and turn it into suppression at high temperatures .
we review the conventional approach to leptogenesis based on ris subtraction in section[conventionalapproach ] . in section [ risquantstat ]
we demonstrate explicitly that _ in thermal equilibrium _ the success of this procedure is guaranteed by the requirement of unitarity . in section[rateequations ] we review the derivation of rate equations for total abundances and discuss in how far quantum statistical and medium corrections can be incorporated in the reaction densities . in section[neqftapproach ] we review the application of the 2pi approach of neqft to leptogenesis .
equation and explicit expressions for the effective in - medium decay and scattering amplitudes are derived within this framework in section[majorana ] .
we compare the results obtained within the 2pi - formalism to those of a conventional analysis with manual ris subtraction . in section[higgsdecay ] we derive rate equations and the _ cp_-violating amplitudes for higgs decay within the framework of neqft .
finally , we summarize the results and present our conclusions in sec.[summary ] .
the amount of produced asymmetry depends on the details of the non - equilibrium evolution of the majorana neutrinos as well as on the strength of _ cp_-violation .
the latter is usually quantified by _ cp_-violating parameters@xcite : @xmath12 where @xmath13 and @xmath14 are the vacuum decay rates to a particle or anti - particle pair respectively.for a hierarchical mass spectrum @xmath15 can be computed perturbatively as the interference tree - level , one - loop self - energy and one - loop vertex contributions to the decay of the heavy majorana neutrino . ] of the tree - level , one - loop vertex @xcite and one - loop self - energy @xcite amplitudes in fig.[treevertexself ] .
the contribution of the loop diagrams can be accounted for by effective yukawa couplings @xcite : [ effective couplings ] @xmath16 where the loop function @xmath17 is defined as @xmath18{{\ , .}}\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first term in eq .
is related to the self - energy and the second term to the vertex contribution .
the decay widths are proportional to the absolute values of the effective couplings , @xmath19 and @xmath20 respectively , where we have summed over flavors of the leptons and @xmath21 indices ( hence the factor @xmath22 ) in the final state .
since the phase space for the decay into particles and antiparticles is the same , one gets for the _ cp_-violating parameter : @xmath23 let us note in passing that the divergence of the loop function for @xmath24 is not physical and can be removed by a resummation of the self - energy contribution @xcite .
here we work in a regime where the mass splittings @xmath25 are large enough to render effects related to the enhancement of the self - energy contribution irrelevant ( non - resonant leptogenesis ) .
we do not require a strictly hierarchical mass - spectrum , however . to describe the statistical evolution of the lepton asymmetry one usually employs generalized boltzmann equations for the one - particle distribution functions of the different species @xcite .
taking into account decay and inverse decay processes one writes for the distribution function of the leptons ( for a single flavor ) : @xmath26{{\ , , } } \label{eqn : collision terms decay}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath27 $ ] is the invariant phase space element , @xmath28 denotes spin degrees of freedom of @xmath29 , and @xmath30 is the covariant derivative .
the corresponding equation for antileptons may be obtained by interchanging @xmath31 and @xmath32 .
_ cpt_-invariance implies that @xmath33 and @xmath34 .
furthermore , in _ thermal equilibrium _ detailed balance requires that @xmath35 . subtracting the two relations we find for the contribution of the ( inverse ) decay terms : @xmath36{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ]
if the decay amplitudes in square brackets differ , the right - hand side of eq .
represents the ( non - zero ) _
cp_-violating source term for the asymmetry generation .
the total asymmetry is given by the sum over all flavors and @xmath21 components : @xmath37 .
neglecting the quantum - statistical terms , @xmath38 , and integrating eq . over the lepton phase space we obtain for its time derivative : @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the modified bessel function of the second kind
, @xmath41 is the total tree - level decay width of @xmath29 , and the factor @xmath42 emerges from the sum over the majorana spin degrees of freedom in , see appendix[kinematics ] for more details .
this implies that the source - term for the lepton asymmetry differs from zero even in equilibrium . on the other hand , combined with time translational invariance of an equilibrium state , _
cpt_-invariance requires the asymmetry to vanish in thermal equilibrium .
thus , we arrive at an apparent contradiction .
the generation of an asymmetry in equilibrium within the @xmath43-matrix formalism is a manifestation of the so - called double - counting problem . in vacuum
an inverse decay immediately followed by a decay is equivalent to a scattering process where the intermediate particle is on the mass shell ( real intermediate state or ris )
. two - body scattering process @xmath44 .
both graphs contribute with all @xmath29 as intermediate states .
note that we read ( b ) as t - channel contribution . ]
thus , the same contribution is taken into account twice : once by the amplitude for ( inverse ) decay processes , and once by that for the @xmath45 scattering processes , see fig.[lhbarlbarh].(a ) .
let us convince ourselves that this is indeed the case . including scattering processes we have for the distribution function of the leptons : @xmath46{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the dots denote the contribution of the ( inverse ) decay processes
, the sum is over flavors and @xmath21 components of the antileptons and we have introduced @xmath47 to shorten the notation . in the unflavored regime , to which we restrict our analysis , the distribution functions of leptons of all flavors are equal .
if the majorana neutrinos are close to equilibrium the difference between the distribution functions of the two spin degrees of freedom can be neglected as well . therefore , in the expression for the total asymmetry @xmath48 the summation over spin , flavor and @xmath21 components reduces to summation of the corresponding decay and scattering amplitudes .
we will denote these sums over internal degrees of freedom by @xmath49 and call them effective amplitudes in the following .
for the effective amplitude of @xmath50 scattering one obtains @xcite @xmath51\nonumber{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath52 are the momenta of initial and final leptons respectively , and @xmath53 and @xmath54 are the usual mandelstam variables . the amplitude @xmath55 is obtained by interchanging @xmath56
. note that the loop corrections to the yukawas vanish for negative momentum transfer , i.e. in the @xmath54-channel .
for this reason the above scattering amplitude contains combinations of the yukawa couplings and their one - loop corrected counterparts .
the propagators @xmath57 are given by @xmath58 where @xmath59 is the heaviside step function .
the ris contribution appears for the flavor diagonal ( @xmath60 ) terms in the product of the @xmath53-channel amplitudes since only in this case the @xmath61 terms vanish simultaneously in both @xmath57 and @xmath62 . in other words : @xmath63 and a similar result for @xmath64 . using the definitions of the effective couplings and the expression for the _ cp_-violating parameter
we find that @xmath65 .
furthermore , for a small decay width , we can approximate the breit - wigner propagator by a delta - function using , @xmath66 ^ 2}= 2\pi\delta(\omega){{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath67 and @xmath68 in the considered case .
the ris contribution to the scattering amplitude then takes the form @xmath69 where @xmath70 is the decay amplitude squared summed over all internal degrees of freedom ( and a similar expression for anti - particles ) . just as one would expect , it is proportional to the product of the corresponding inverse decay and decay amplitudes .
the additional momentum dependence ( momenta of the leptons ) arises because the initial and final states contain fermions .
close to thermal equilibrium @xmath71 and @xmath72 . neglecting the quantum - statistical terms we can write the ris contribution to the source - term as : @xmath73{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] taking into account that with maxwell - boltzmann distributions @xmath74 in the presence of the dirac - delta and performing the phase space integration using eq .
we obtain a result _ identical _ to eq .. to correct the double - counting _ in equilibrium _ we may therefore subtract the ris contribution from the scattering amplitude : @xmath75 and similarly for the conjugate process @xmath76 . at first sight
it might seem that the ris subtracted scattering amplitudes @xmath77 do not contribute to the generation of the lepton asymmetry in equilibrium , @xmath78{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] but also can not compensate the asymmetry generated in equilibrium by the decay processes , see eq .. however , upon phase space integration the difference of the unsubtracted scattering amplitudes vanishes at leading order in @xmath4 .
the remaining difference of the ris - amplitudes precisely compensates the contribution of the ( inverse ) decay processes .
the ris subtracted scattering amplitude can be conveniently rewritten in terms of a ` ris subtracted propagator ' @xmath79 . motivated by eq .
we define its diagonal components such , that they vanish upon integration over @xmath53 in the vicinity of the mass pole : @xmath80 ^ 2}{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] since the second of the expressions approaches the delta - function faster than the first it is common to write eq . in the form @xmath81 for @xmath82
there is no need to perform the ris subtraction and therefore @xmath83 . in the following
we will also need the sum of the ris subtracted tree - level scattering amplitudes .
it does not contribute to the generation of the asymmetry but plays a role for its washout .
it is defined as @xmath84\nonumber\\ & = 4({{r}}_1 { { r}}_2 ) \textstyle\sum_{ij } m_i m_j\,\re ( h^\dagger h)^2_{ij } \nonumber\\ & \times \left[\,2{\cal p}_{ij}(s)+2p^{*}_i(t)p_j(t)\right.\nonumber\\ & + \left.p^{*}_i(s)p_j(t)+p^*_i(t)p_j(s)\,\right]{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] since it contains only the real part of @xmath85 this process is _ cp_-conserving . two - body scattering process @xmath86 . ]
a further important washout process is @xmath87 scattering which receives the @xmath54- and @xmath88-channel contributions , see fig.[llbarhbarh ] . by analogy with eq .
it is convenient to introduce @xmath89
\nonumber\\ & = 2({{r}}_1 { { r}}_2)\textstyle\sum_{ij } m_i m_j\,\re(h^\dagger h)^2_{ij } \nonumber\\ & \times \left[2 p^{*}_i(t)p^{*}_j(t)+2 p^{*}_i(u)p^{*}_j(u)\right.\nonumber\\ & + \left .
p^{*}_i(u ) p_j(t)+p^{*}_i(t ) p_j(u)\,\right]{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] since the intermediate majorana neutrino can not go on - shell in the @xmath54- and @xmath88-channel , there is no need to use the ris subtracted propagator in eq .. above we have briefly reviewed the canonical approach to the computation of the lepton asymmetry , which is based on generalized boltzmann equations .
boltzmann equations , according to conventional reasoning , describe scattering processes of particles which propagate freely over timescales large compared to the duration of individual interactions .
this picture seems to be consistent with the use of @xmath43-matrix elements which are intended to describe transitions between asymptotically free initial and final states .
however , in leptogenesis the crucial processes ( _ cp_-violating decays ) involve unstable particles which spoils this picture . in vacuum
the amplitudes for such processes can be computed in terms of their feynman graphs .
however the ` naive ' way of generalizing the boltzmann equation by multiplying the obtained amplitudes by the one - particle distributions of the initial states and integrating over phase space leads to inconsistent equations .
the origin of this problem is that the obtained collision terms for particle decay and inverse decay in eq .
miscount the rate of particle generation . in a short time - interval
a finite number of unstable majorana neutrinos - formed by inverse decay of particles and antiparticles - decays immediately back to either particles or antiparticles .
these contributions to particle generation are not included in eq . where the amplitudes are defined in terms of feynman graphs . for leptogenesis , in the presence of _
cp_-violation , it leads to inconsistent equations and must be corrected . since the missing contribution can be constructed as the rate of a two - body scattering process with on - shell intermediate state this issue can be addressed by the ris - subtracting procedure presented above .
it modifies the amplitudes for two - body scattering in order to cure the problem which appears due to the collision terms for particle decay
. however the corresponding correction appears at order @xmath90 , which is usually neglected . ]
it is well known that unitarity has important consequences for baryogenesis and leptogenesis @xcite as it implies restrictions for the _ cp_-violating amplitudes .
the issue of ris subtraction is as well tightly related to unitarity as has been mentioned in e.g. @xcite . as noted in section[conventionalapproach ] , the use of ` naive ' boltzmann equations of the kind for unstable particles leads to problems such as the spurious asymmetry generation in the presence of _ cp_-violation in the decay of the heavy neutrinos . in this section
we show explicitly that the success of the ris subtraction _ in thermal equilibrium _ is guaranteed by the unitarity of the @xmath43-matrix and how it can be generalized to include quantum - statistical terms .
the approach to ris subtraction differs slightly from the one discussed in the previous section . to illustrate it we work in thermal equilibrium , @xmath91 and @xmath92 , where @xmath93 subtracting from the boltzmann equation the corresponding equation for antiparticles , summing over internal degrees of freedom of the leptons and integrating with @xmath94 $ ] we obtain in thermal equilibrium : contribution which describes the dilution due to the expansion of the universe . ]
@xmath95 { ( 1-{{f}_{{{\ell}}}^{eq}})}{(1+{{f}_{{\phi}}^{eq}})}{{f}_{{n}_i}^{eq}}\nonumber\\ & + 2 \int { { { \,d}\pi_{{{\ell}}{\phi}{{\ell}}{\phi}}^{{{r}}_1 k_1 p_2 k_2 } } } ( 2\pi)^4\ , \delta({{r}}_1 + k_1 - p_2 - k_2 ) \nonumber\\ & \times \bigl [ { \xi^{'}_{\bar{{{\ell}}}\bar{{\phi}}\rightarrow{{\ell}}{\phi } } } - { \xi^{'}_{{{\ell}}{\phi}\rightarrow\bar{{{\ell}}}\bar{{\phi}}}}\bigr ] { ( 1-{{f}_{{{\ell}}}^{eq}})}{(1+{{f}_{{\phi}}^{eq}})}{{f}_{{{\ell}}}^{eq}}{{f}_{{\phi}}^{eq}}\nonumber{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can exploit the unitarity of the @xmath43-matrix and _ cpt_-symmetry to obtain a requirement for a consistent approximation of the decay and scattering amplitudes . to this end
we multiply eq . , which follows from the generalized optical theorem at order @xmath96 , by @xmath97 and integrate over @xmath98 . assuming maxwell - boltzmann equilibrium distributions we may use @xmath99 in the presence of the energy conserving dirac - delta on the right - hand - side : @xmath100{{f}_{{n}_i}^{eq}}\nonumber\\ & = -\int { { { \,d}\pi_{{{\ell}}{\phi}{{\ell}}{\phi}}^{{{r}}_1 k_1 p_2 k_2 } } } ( 2\pi)^4{\delta({{r}}_1 + k_1 - p_2 - k_2 ) } \nonumber\\ & \hspace{15mm}\times\big [ { \xi^{'}_{\bar{{{\ell}}}\bar{{\phi}}\rightarrow{{\ell}}{\phi } } } - { \xi^{'}_{{{\ell}}{\phi}\rightarrow\bar{{{\ell}}}\bar{{\phi}}}}\big]{{f}_{{{\ell}}}^{eq}}{{f}_{{\phi}}^{eq}}{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we see that imposing this as a condition for the scattering amplitudes will correctly yield @xmath101 if we neglect the quantum - statistical terms in .
equation represents the zeroth - order term in an expansion about equilibrium . using eq .
we can therefore obtain consistent equations at this order without the need to specify the detailed form of @xmath102 and @xmath103 . at higher order ( for washout contributions )
we also need to know the sum @xmath104 , see section[rateequations ] .
we know from section[conventionalapproach ] that relation can be satisfied by subtracting ris contributions from the tree - level two - body scattering amplitudes and taking the zero width limit : [ eqn : matrix element ris subtracted ] @xmath105 note that , strictly speaking , the ris terms in eq .
include @xmath106 factors . however , upon the phase space integration in eq .
the two expressions give identical results and are therefore equal in an average sense .
it is obvious from comparison of eqs . and that the above definition of the ris subtracted scattering amplitudes is not sufficient to guarantee zero asymmetry in equilibrium if quantum - statistical terms are included .
however this can be achieved if we replace the vacuum decay width in eq . by the thermal one @xcite : @xmath107 ( 1-{{f}_{{{\ell}}}^{eq}}+{{f}_{{\phi}}^{eq}}){{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] using the identity @xmath108 and the fact that the ( inverse ) decay amplitudes are related by _
cpt_-symmetry we can rewrite the ris - contribution to the second term of eq . in the form : @xmath109\nonumber\\ & \times \int
{ { \,d}\pi^{{{\ell}}}_{{{r}}_2 } } { { \,d}\pi^{{\phi}}_{{{k}}_2}}(2\pi)^4\delta(q-{{r}}_2-{{k}}_2)\nonumber\\ & \hspace{5 mm } \times ( 1-{{f}_{{{\ell}}}^{eq}})(1+{{f}_{{\phi}}^{eq}})\bigl [ { \xi^{}_{{n}_i\rightarrow{{\ell}}{\phi } } } - { \xi^{}_{{n}_i\rightarrow\bar{{{\ell}}}\bar{{\phi}}}}\bigr]{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the integration over @xmath53 is trivial .
the @xmath110 term ensures that after integration over @xmath111 the intermediate majorana neutrino is on - shell , @xmath112 . using @xmath113 together with the definition we can rewrite the second term of eq . as @xmath114 which cancels the factors coming from ris subtraction .
the resulting expression reads @xmath115 { ( 1-{{f}_{{{\ell}}}^{eq}})}{(1+{{f}_{{\phi}}^{eq}})}{{f}_{{n}_i}^{eq}}{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and cancels the first term on the right - hand side of eq .. since @xmath116 at @xmath117 the new ris subtracted source - term for the asymmetry vanishes in equilibrium . the thermal width @xmath118 defined in eq .
would also be obtained if one computes it using thermal cutting rules instead of the optical theorem ( which applies in vacuum ) , see appendix[generalizedoptth ] .
we have seen that the unitarity of the @xmath43-matrix can be employed to generalize the concept of ris subtraction to rate equations which include quantum - statistical factors . as we shall see in section[higgsdecay ] , the majorana neutrino decay is at high temperature replaced by higgs decay if the higgs acquires a large effective thermal mass . in this case
thermal cutting rules enforce relations between the amplitudes which can be used to obtain consistent equations , analogous to the optical theorem , see appendix[generalizedoptth ] .
note again that in eq .
we had to assume that the majorana neutrinos are in exact thermal equilibrium .
for leptogenesis this is an inconsistent assumption since the deviation of their distribution from equilibrium realizes the third sakharov condition and drives the generation of the asymmetry . not surprisingly , the neqft approach leads to a ( slightly ) different result for the kinetic equations .
however the differences between the two approaches enter only at an order beyond the usual approximation as we will discuss in the next section .
in this section we review the derivation of rate equations , discuss in how far quantum - statistical and medium corrections can be incorporated , and compare the structure obtained when starting from the neqft result with the conventional form . solving a system of boltzmann - like equations in general requires the use of numerical codes capable of treating large systems of stiff differential equations for the different momentum modes a cumbersome task if one wants to study a wide range of model parameters . in the context of baryogenesis ,
a commonly employed simplification is to approximate the boltzmann equations by the corresponding network of ` rate equations ' for number densities @xmath119 or abundances @xmath120 , where @xmath53 is the comoving entropy density .
the resulting equations correspond to the hydrodynamical limit of the boltzmann kinetic equations , in the comoving frame of _ homogeneous _ frw space - time . to obtain evolution equations for @xmath121 in the conventional approach ,
i.e. from eq . , we therefore integrate the corresponding boltzmann equations over @xmath122 $ ] to obtain , on the left - hand sides : @xmath123 where we have introduced the dimensionless inverse temperature @xmath124 and the hubble rate @xmath125 . in the homogeneous and isotropic universe the derivative of the quantity @xmath126 can be related to the divergence of the lepton - current @xmath127 a quantity which is particularly easy to access in the first - principles computation by @xmath128 on the right - hand sides we get sums of integrated collision terms representing the effect of the different interactions .
we separate contributions attributed to decays and scattering : @xmath129 the decay contributions @xmath130 to @xmath131 are very similar to the decay contributions @xmath132 to @xmath133 and we can treat them in the same way . reordering the contributions to @xmath134
we find @xmath135{{\ , , } } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the upper ( lower ) signs and arrows correspond to the rate equations for @xmath136 ( @xmath29 ) abundance and we defined @xmath137\nonumber{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] which corresponds to eq .
, as well as @xmath138{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we used _
cpt_-symmetry of the amplitudes in the derivation of eqs . and .
later we will see that the second term in eq
. appears also in the first - principle approach , compare eq . , while the terms in eqs . and
are absent .
this motivates the separation into ` regular ' and ` extra ' terms performed in eq .. for the contributions attributed to scattering we get : @xmath139{{\ , , } } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath140{{\ , , } } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] corresponding to eq .. again , eq .
does not appear in the first - principle approach .
since in equilibrium the regular terms in each of eqs . and vanish by detailed balance we retain eq . in the sum of decay and scattering contributions .
the latter vanishes as well in equilibrium if we adopt e.g. eq . with thermal width for the ris subtracted amplitudes @xmath141 .
out of equilibrium the last terms constitute a structural difference compared to the results obtained from first - principles .
this difference carries over to the rate equations .
we will therefore analyze these contributions separately .
the computational advantage of rate equations over full boltzmann equations is maximized by a number of common approximations . in particular , assuming that all species are close to equilibrium and that the majorana neutrino distribution function @xmath142 is proportional to its equilibrium distribution for all values of the momentum @xmath143 .
the temperature for all kinetic equilibrium distributions is set to a common value @xmath144 while finite deviations of the chemical potential with small @xmath145 are permitted .
these approximations result for @xmath146 in a closed network of rate equations for the abundances of the form ( compare with @xcite ) : [ rateequations1 ] @xmath147 where we have introduced [ amplsqandepsdef ] @xmath148 the factor @xmath149 ( we neglect the thermal lepton masses here ) relates the chemical potential of the leptons to their number density , @xmath150 and the coefficient @xmath151 takes into account that in the sm the chemical potentials of leptons and higgs are related by @xmath152 with @xmath153 through equilibrium gauge , yukawa and sphaleron interactions @xcite .
hence , the evolution of the abundances close to equilibrium is roughly governed by a few average quantities called _ reaction densities _ which describe decay and scattering processes .
we will refer to @xmath154 , @xmath155 , @xmath156 as _ cp_-violating decay reaction density , decay reaction density and washout reaction density respectively . for comparison with standard results
we want to maintain the form of eqs . and repeat their derivation from eqs . and to obtain expressions for the reaction densities which take the quantum statistical factors of the boltzmann equation into account .
this is important in the present context because the thermal corrections to the _ cp_-violating parameter , to be derived later , are of a similar kind . to this end
we use that the sm gauge and yukawa interactions keep the higgs and leptons very close to kinetic equilibrium : @xmath157 with a common temperature @xmath158 and chemical potentials @xmath159 , @xmath160 .
we shall also use @xmath161 for the equilibrium distribution functions with zero chemical potential defined in eq .. since a chemical potential with positive sign will appear for either the higgs or its antiparticle , we need to include at least the thermal mass of the higgs to be consistent . in the dense plasma gauge- , yukawa- and
higgs self - interactions induce a large thermal higgs mass of about @xmath162 . with @xmath163
, the higgs can not acquire a condensate component .
it is then safe to use a bose - einstein equilibrium distribution function to describe the distribution of the higgs particles . using that @xmath164 and hence ,
for a general decay collision term @xmath165 in the presence of the energy conserving dirac - delta , , @xmath166 and @xmath167 can be any species for which the above conditions apply .
here we identify @xmath168 , @xmath169 , @xmath170 . ]
@xmath171 , we may write : @xmath172\nonumber\\ & \times{(1-\xi^{n}{f^{}_{n}})}\frac{{{f}_{n}^{eq}}}{{(1-\xi^{n}{{f}_{n}^{eq}})}}{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can now expand the exponential in square brackets in the small quantity @xmath173 .
if this quantity is tiny at all times the integral will not change much if we neglect quadratic and higher order terms . as well . ] for the zeroth - order ( first ) term in square brackets we use the linear expansion @xmath174 $ ] of the prefactor .
the linear order ( second ) term in square brackets will appear preceded by just the zeroth - order factor @xmath175 with @xmath176 to write the results in a compact form we introduce decay reaction densities with quantum - statistical factors included : @xmath177 and @xmath178 where @xmath179 is the total majorana decay amplitude .
similarly we define the scattering reaction densities as @xmath180 since @xmath181 refers here to a cp - symmetric ( tree - level ) amplitude squared we have @xmath182 if @xmath183 is symmetric as well . with help of eq .
we may separate the contributions to @xmath184 into terms proportional to @xmath185 , terms proportional to @xmath186 , or just proportional to @xmath187 ( see appendix[rateequationsapp ] for details ) : [ eqn : quantum corrected boltzmann equation li result ] @xmath188 in addition we get with eq . for the extra term in eq . :
@xmath189 equations describe the generation of a net asymmetry due to out of equilibrium decays of heavy majorana neutrinos .
once @xmath187 has a non - zero value , there will be a slight difference in the decay rates to particles and antiparticles respectively which is not due to _ cp_-violation in the decay amplitude , but due to the presence of slightly different occupation numbers of leptons and higgs in the final states of the decays . at linear order this combined effect of blocking and stimulated emission
is accounted for by eq .. depending on the ` typical ' sign of @xmath190 it can add to or diminish an existing asymmetry .
finally , eq . describes washout due to inverse decays . in section[neqftapproach ] we will see that the functional dependence on @xmath191 in the integrated collision terms is the same as that encountered in the _ cp_-violating parameter @xmath15 itself .
considering the last two terms in eq .
we find for the scattering contributions : @xmath192 { { \ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we defined the ` ris subtracted reaction density ' @xmath193 . if we adopt the amplitudes defined in eq . in the framework of ris subtraction ,
it is given by @xmath194 \gamma^{{{\ell}}{\phi}}_{\bar{{{\ell}}}\bar{{\phi}}}\bigg > { { \ , .}}\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the contribution proportional to @xmath90 is of higher order in @xmath195 .
furthermore , we get for the extra term : @xmath196 here we used @xmath197 we have written eq .
schematically in order to show how it compares to other washout terms .
note that the extra terms indicate that there will be a slight difference between the equations obtained in the 2pi approach and those obtained with ris subtraction at finite temperature . comparing eqs .
and we see that the first term in the former equation will cancel the latter contribution in thermal equilibrium ( @xmath198 ) if the decay contributions are summed up . the second term in eq .
is due to quantum statistics .
since it is proportional to @xmath199 it can be large only if @xmath15 is large ( as in the case of resonant leptogenesis ) .
anticipating our knowledge about the structure obtained within neqft , we will ignore the extra term in what follows . at the time being
, everything is still exact with respect to deviations of @xmath200 from equilibrium .
this distribution is necessarily distorted due to the fact that it is subject to conflicting equilibrium conditions corresponding to the decay into particles and antiparticles , by the effects of the expansion and , possibly , due to non - equilibrium initial conditions . in order to obtain the full momentum - dependent distribution function we would have to solve the corresponding full kinetic equations however @xcite . to proceed we shall as usual
assume that the deviation of the majorana neutrinos from equilibrium is small .
this allows us to neglect the @xmath201 contribution and to replace @xmath202 in eq .. the extra terms cancel at this level of approximation up to the quantum - statistical term . in order to bring the remaining source - term eq . into the conventional form
, we need to assume that the non - equilibrium distribution of the majorana neutrino is proportional to its equilibrium value ( with momentum independent prefactor ) @xmath203 with this approximation we can write @xmath204 the total contribution to the evolution equations for the lepton asymmetry is then given by @xmath205 i.e. we obtain eq .. we see that , at this level of approximation , there are no contributions due to extra terms apart from those which cancel due to the ris - subtraction .
quantitative differences can arise if the deviation of the majorana neutrinos from equilibrium is large or @xmath15 is of order @xmath206 . for the evolution of the majorana neutrino we obtain with appendix[rateequationsapp ] , similar to eq . , the decay contributions [ eqn : quantum corrected boltzmann equation ni result ] @xmath207 and for the extra term in eq .
: @xmath208 neglecting again @xmath201 and @xmath209 contributions we obtain
@xmath210 i.e. eq .. if higher order contributions are taken into account , we get a difference between the conventional equations and those derived in the 2pi - formalism . ignoring the contribution and the second term in eq . , which are due to quantum statistics
, we obtain a contribution @xmath211 to @xmath133 . here
the upper sign applies if the extra terms are included and the lower sign if not .
this can therefore result in the inclusion of this term with wrong sign even if quantum statistics are neglected , compare e.g. @xcite . the reaction densities for decay , @xmath154 , @xmath212 , @xmath156 , and scattering , @xmath193 , @xmath213 , represent the hydrodynamical coefficients which govern the evolution of the number densities ( abundances ) .
we will compute them numerically once the additional medium dependence of the amplitudes ( in particular the _ cp_-violating parameters ) has been derived .
in addition , it is useful to define a thermally averaged _
cp_-violating parameter as @xmath214 which equals @xmath15 if it is momentum independent , such as in the zero temperature case , but will differ once thermal effects are included .
this quantity is meaningful for the comparison with conventional results because it takes into account that the deviation of the majorana neutrino abundance from equilibrium , which appears in the source - term for the lepton abundance , is influenced by the ( _ cp_-conserving ) decay reaction density in the denominator . inserting conventional vacuum amplitudes in eqs .
with eqs . and and dropping quantum - statistical factors one obtains the conventional results for the reaction densities . for the readers convenience
we quote them here .
for the decay reaction density we obtain @xmath215 and @xmath216 , see appendix[kinematics ] .
for the two - body scattering the reaction density is given by @xmath217 where @xmath218 is so - called reduced cross section : @xmath219 for the @xmath87 process it reads @xmath220 where we have replaced @xmath53 by @xmath221 and introduced dimensionless quantities @xmath222 and @xmath223 . the case @xmath60 is included in this expression in the limiting sense @xmath224 .
note that eq . only contains the real part of @xmath225 .
the contribution of the imaginary part vanishes because @xmath226 is antisymmetric with respect to @xmath227 whereas the sum in the curly brackets is symmetric under this transformation .
the integration of eq .
yields for the reduced ` ris subtracted cross section ' of the @xmath228 process : @xmath229 \left[(x - a_j)^2+(a_jc_j)^2\right ] } \right.\nonumber\\ & + 2\frac{x+a_i}{a_j - a_i}\ln\left(\frac{x+a_i}{a_i}\right)+ 2\frac{x+a_j}{a_i - a_j}\ln\left(\frac{x+a_j}{a_j}\right)\nonumber\\ & + \frac{x - a_i}{(x - a_i)^2+(a_ic_i)^2}\left[x-(x+a_j)\ln\left(\frac{x+a_j}{a_j } \right)\right]\nonumber\\ & + \left.\frac{x - a_j}{(x - a_j)^2+(a_jc_j)^2}\left[x-(x+a_i)\ln\left(\frac{x+a_i}{a_i } \right)\right]\right\}\nonumber{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the reduced ` cross section ' is _ _ negative _ _ is not a physical cross section but denotes the contribution to the reaction density arising from the difference of the full and the ris term .
we stress that all physical rates are manifestly positive , e.g. the washout term , to which @xmath230 yields a sub - leading correction that is relatively suppressed by yukawa couplings . see also @xcite . ] in the vicinity of the mass shells , @xmath231 .
this is due to the @xmath232 term in the numerator of the ris subtracted propagator .
note that because we have not approximated this term by the dirac - delta the structure of eq .
is slightly different from the one usually used in the literature @xcite .
in this section we briefly review the description of leptogenesis within non - equilibrium quantum field theory @xcite .
this framework has been shown recently to be suitable for the derivation of quantum dynamic equations for the lepton asymmetry within a first - principle approach , and to incorporate medium , off - shell , coherence and possibly further quantum effects in a self - consistent way @xcite .
we continue these efforts by deriving consistent quantum corrected boltzmann equations that describe the generation and washout of the lepton asymmetry and include the ( inverse ) decay as well as scattering processes mediated by majorana neutrinos .
the lepton asymmetry is given by the @xmath233-component of the expectation value of the lepton - current operator : @xmath234 it can be expressed in terms of the leptonic two - point function .
we define the two - point functions for the higgs , lepton and majorana fields with time arguments attached to the closed time path ( ctp ) shown in fig.[fig : ctp ] by [ twopointfunctions ] @xmath235 where the sub- and superscripts refer to @xmath21 and flavor indices and @xmath236 denotes time - ordering with respect to the ctp . closed time path . ]
we will frequently use matrix notation for the flavor indices , where e.g. @xmath237 denotes the flavor - matrix @xmath238 , etc . using the definition we find for the lepton - current : @xmath239{{\ , .}}\ ] ] two - point functions @xmath240 ( where @xmath241 stands for @xmath242 , @xmath243 or @xmath244 ) defined on the ctp can be decomposed into a _ spectral function _ @xmath245 and _ statistical propagator _
@xmath246 : @xmath247 the signum function is either @xmath248 or @xmath249 depending on whether @xmath250 or @xmath251 occur ` later ' on the contour @xmath252 . @xmath246 and @xmath245 encode information on the state and the spectrum of the system , respectively .
for example , for the leptons they are given by @xmath253_- \rangle { { \ , , } } \\
{ s^{\alpha\beta}_{ab\,\rho}}(x , y ) & = i \langle \left [ { { \ell}}_{\alpha}^a(x ) , \bar { { \ell}}_{\beta}^b(y ) \right]_+ \rangle { { \ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath254_\pm$ ] denote ( anti-)commutators . statistical and spectral functions of majorana neutrino and higgs can be expressed similarly , with @xmath255 and @xmath256 exchanged for bosons .
although there are only two independent two - point functions for each species , it is convenient to introduce additional combinations of them , namely the _ wightman _
functions @xmath257 as well as _
retarded _ and _ advanced _ functions , [ retadvdef ] @xmath258 from the above definitions one can see that the difference of the retarded and advanced propagators gives the spectral one , whereas the sum yields the _ hermitian _ propagator @xmath259 : [ hermdef ] @xmath260 finally , we will also need the _ cp _ conjugated propagators on the ctp : [ cpconjugates ] @xmath261 here @xmath262 , @xmath263 and @xmath264 are the charge conjugation and parity matrices , respectively , and the transposition refers to spinor indices .
_ cp _ conjugated statistical and spectral functions immediately follow from the above definition by inserting the decomposition .
the time - evolution of the two - point functions is described self - consistently by the kadanoff - baym ( kb ) equations .
these equations can be obtained from a variational principle using the so - called 2pi effective action @xcite .
the resulting equations of motion have the form of schwinger - dyson equations for the non - equilibrium propagators formulated on the ctp : @xmath265 here @xmath266 is the inverse of the _ full _ lepton propagator in coordinate space , and @xmath267 is the inverse of the _ free _ lepton propagator , @xmath268 the information about the interaction processes is encoded in the self - energies @xmath269
. they can be obtained by cutting one line of the 2pi contributions to the effective actions .
the two- and three - loop contributions are presented in fig.[fig:2pi contributions ] .
two- and three - loop contributions to the 2pi effective action and the corresponding contributions to the lepton self - energy .
note that the propagator lines used here denote full resummed propagators in contrast to those employed in the previous feynman graphs .
the contributions ( a ) and ( c ) to the 2pi effective action are known as ` setting - sun ' and ` mercedes ' diagrams respectively.,title="fig : " ] + two- and three - loop contributions to the 2pi effective action and the corresponding contributions to the lepton self - energy . note that the propagator lines used here denote full resummed propagators in contrast to those employed in the previous feynman graphs .
the contributions ( a ) and ( c ) to the 2pi effective action are known as ` setting - sun ' and ` mercedes ' diagrams respectively.,title="fig : " ] the kb equations can be obtained by convoluting the schwinger - dyson equation with the full propagator , which yields : @xmath270 here @xmath271 .
after decomposing the resulting equation into statistical and spectral components , one obtains : [ kblepton ] @xmath272 the equations for majorana and higgs propagators have a similar structure , with the klein - gordon instead of the dirac operator for the latter . the schwinger - dyson equations and the corresponding kadanoff - baym equations are formally very similar to the schwinger - dyson equation in vacuum .
however , out of equilibrium the propagators depend not only on the relative coordinate @xmath273 , but also on the central coordinate @xmath274 , which makes their solution much more involved .
in contrast to the schwinger - dyson equation in vacuum , the kb equations determine the spectral properties of the system including medium corrections , as well as the non - equilibrium dynamics of the statistical propagator self - consistently .
since the latter represents the quantum field theoretical generalization of the classical particle distribution functions , kb equations can be seen as the quantum field theoretical generalizations of boltzmann equations . as pointed out above , an equation of motion for the lepton asymmetry
can be derived by considering the divergence of the lepton - current @xmath275 . using the kb equations one obtains and using the covariant derivative @xmath30 .
as has been demonstrated in @xcite , this is the case for scalar fields .
a manifestly covariant generalization of center and relative coordinates @xmath183 and @xmath53 to curved space - time can be found in @xcite .
] : @xmath276 \nonumber\\ & = g_w\ , i\int_0^{x^0 } { \mathscr{d}}^4z \ , { { \rm tr}}\bigl [ { \sigma^{\alpha\beta}_{\rho}}(x , z ) { s^{\beta\alpha}_{f}}(z , x ) \nonumber\\ & - { \sigma^{\alpha\beta}_{f}}(x , z ) { s^{\beta\alpha}_{\rho}}(z , x ) - { s^{\alpha\beta}_{\rho}}(x , z ) { \sigma^{\beta\alpha}_{f}}(z , x ) \nonumber\\ & + { s^{\alpha\beta}_{f}}(x , z ) { \sigma^{\beta\alpha}_{\rho}}(z , x ) \bigr ] { { \ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here summation over repeated indices is implicitly assumed .
the two equations above represent the quantum generalization of the boltzmann equation for the lepton asymmetry .
thus , they may be considered as the master equations for a quantum field theoretical treatment of leptogenesis @xcite .
the dependence of the two - point functions on the relative coordinate @xmath53 is characterized by the hard scales like the majorana neutrino mass @xmath277 or the temperature @xmath144 of the surrounding plasma .
in contrast to that , the variation with the central coordinate @xmath183 is given by the macroscopic time - evolution of the system , e.g. the hubble rate @xmath278 or the majorana decay rate @xmath279 .
therefore , it is possible to perform an expansion in slow relative to fast time - scales , i.e. in powers of e.g. @xmath280 or @xmath281 .
technically , this can be realized by a so - called gradient or derivative expansion with respect to @xmath183 , and a fourier transformation with respect to @xmath53 , known as wigner transformation , see appendix[selfenergy ] for more details .
then , to leading order in the gradients , the evolution equation for the lepton asymmetry becomes markovian , and after some straightforward algebra , can be written as @xmath282\nonumber\\ & - \bigl[{\bar{\sigma}^{\beta\alpha}_{<}}(t,{{r } } ) { \bar{s}^{\alpha\beta}_{>}}(t,{{r } } ) - { \bar{\sigma}^{\beta\alpha}_{>}}(t,{{r } } ) { \bar{s}^{\alpha\beta}_{<}}(t,{{r } } ) \bigr]\bigr\}{{\ , .}}\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that it is possible to investigate higher orders in the derivative expansion systematically @xcite . in eq .
all two - point functions are evaluated in wigner space , where @xmath283 is the _ physical _ momentum @xcite that corresponds to @xmath53 . for a spatially homogeneous system ( like frw ) the two - point functions depend only on the time coordinate @xmath284 , and on the momentum @xmath283 , because of spatial translational invariance . strictly speaking ,
this is true only in the rest frame of the medium ( comoving frame ) . in a general frame
the two - point functions depend on @xmath285 , where @xmath286 is the four - velocity of the medium .
the latter satisfies the normalization condition @xmath287 , and is given by @xmath288 in the medium rest frame . in order to allow for a physical interpretation of eq
we have written it such that the integration is over positive frequencies only , and expressed the lepton propagator and self - energy in terms of the wigner transformed wightman functions eq .. in thermal equilibrium , the wightman functions depend only on the momentum @xmath283 and satisfy the kubo - martin - schwinger ( kms ) relation @xmath289 for fermions / bosons , respectively . when inserting the kms relations for propagators and self - energies into eq .
, one immediately finds that the divergence of the lepton - current vanishes in thermal equilibrium as it should ( see also @xcite ) . in other words ,
the quantum equation for the lepton asymmetry is in accordance with the third sakharov condition .
we emphasize that it is _ not _ necessary to apply ris subtraction to obtain this result within the ctp approach @xcite .
the four terms on the right - hand side of eq . may be interpreted as gain and loss terms of leptons and anti - leptons respectively @xcite . in particular
, one may define generalized lepton distribution functions @xmath290 via the so - called kadanoff - baym ansatz @xmath291 thus the contribution on the right - hand side of eq .
that contains @xmath292 corresponds to the lepton loss term , while the contribution proportional to @xmath293 represents the lepton gain term .
analogous definitions relate the _ cp _ conjugate propagators with the anti - lepton distribution .
note that the kms relations ensure that in equilibrium @xmath294 approaches the fermi - dirac distribution @xmath295 .
the flavor off - diagonal components encode coherent flavor correlations @xcite . in the unflavored regime
considered here @xmath296 and @xmath297 . in the quasiparticle ( qp )
approximation , the spectral function is given by @xmath298 where we assume that leptons obey conventional dispersion relation and @xmath299 is the effective thermal mass .
these assumptions might be modified in the presence of a medium @xcite . due to the presence of the dirac - delta - function in eq .
the integration over @xmath300 in eq .
is trivial and leaves only the integration over spatial momenta of on - shell leptons .
therefore the right - hand side of eq . can be interpreted as a difference of two ( integrated ) boltzmann - like equations
one for the particles and one for the antiparticles @xcite .
according to the physical interpretation of eq . in terms of gain and loss terms , the wightman components of the lepton self - energy and of its _ cp
_ conjugate are the analogs of the collision integrals .
since we limit our analysis to the unflavored regime , it is convenient to perform the summation over the flavor indices : @xmath301 . then the one - loop contribution , see fig.[fig:2pi contributions ] ( b ) , takes the form : @xmath302 where @xmath303 .
the explicit expression for the two - loop contribution is rather lengthy and it is convenient to split it into three distinct terms : @xmath304 the first term on the right - hand side reads @xmath305\nonumber { { \ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have introduced two functions containing loop corrections : @xmath306{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath307 to shorten the notation . comparing eqs .
and we see that they have a very similar structure .
first , the integration is over momenta of the higgs and majorana neutrino and the delta - function contains the same combination of the momenta .
second , both self - energies include one wightman propagator of the higgs field and one wightman propagator of the majorana field . upon the use of the kadanoff - baym ansatz
the wightman propagators can be interpreted as cut - propagators which describe on - shell particles created from or absorbed by the plasma @xcite . on the other hand ,
the retarded and advanced propagators can be associated with the off - shell intermediate states .
we therefore conclude that eqs . and describe ( inverse ) decays of the heavy neutrino into a lepton - higgs pair .
the second term on the right - hand side of eq . contains two wightman propagators of the higgs field and one wightman propagator of the lepton field .
the majorana propagator appears only in the intermediate state : @xmath308{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we therefore conclude that this term describes lepton number violating scattering processes mediated by the heavy neutrino .
finally the last term in eq .
contains two wightman propagators of the majorana field and one of the lepton field , whereas the higgs field is in the intermediate state : @xmath309{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore it can be identified with the higgs mediated scattering processes .
these conserve lepton number and do not contribute to generation of the lepton asymmetry .
the _ cp _ conjugate of the wigner transforms can be obtained using eq .. in practice this amounts to replacing the propagators by their _
conjugate and the couplings by their complex conjugate in the above expressions .
for instance for the _ cp _ conjugate of the one - loop self - energy we find : @xmath310 expression for the _ cp _ conjugate of the two - loop lepton self - energy can be obtained in a similar way . for the higgs propagators in the above self - energies we can also use the kadanoff - baym ansatz , @xmath311 and the simple quasiparticle approximation for the spectral function , @xmath312 where @xmath313 is the effective thermal mass .
effects of the finite thermal higgs mass will be studied in section[higgsdecay ] .
in this section we will analyze the lepton number and _ cp_-violating ( inverse ) decay of the majorana neutrino as well as the two - body scattering processes mediated by the heavy neutrino .
in particular , we will derive expressions for the in - medium _ cp_-violating parameters , decay widths and scattering amplitudes .
we will also explicitly demonstrate that the obtained equation for the lepton asymmetry is free of the double - counting problem . in the previous section we have used the kadanoff - baym ansatz and quasiparticle approximation for the higgs and lepton fields .
let us now assume that similar approximations also hold for majorana neutrinos .
that is , we assume that in eqs . and the spectral function @xmath314 is diagonal in flavor space and can be approximated by @xmath315 and that it is related to the wightmann components via the kadanoff - baym ansatz : @xmath316 substituting eqs . and in eq . and making the above approximations we find after some algebra that the lepton - current can be represented in the form : @xmath317{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath318 have been introduced in eq .
and we have defined : [ effectivedecayamplitudestree ] @xmath319{{\ , , } } \\
\label{effamplsebarlbarh } { \xi^{t}_{\bar { { \ell}}\bar { \phi}\leftrightarrow { n}_i}}&\equiv g_w ( h^\dagger h)_{ii } { { \rm tr}}[(\slashed{{{q}}}+m_i)p_l\slashed{{{r}}}\,]{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the superscript ` t ' stands for ` tree - level ' .
the expression strongly resembles the boltzmann equation .
therefore the functions @xmath320 and @xmath321 can be interpreted as effective in - medium amplitudes squared , summed over internal degrees of freedom , for the decays into leptons and antileptons respectively . tree - level contribution . ]
the two effective amplitudes can be replaced by the total decay amplitude and the _ cp_-violating parameter .
we find that within the used approximations the resulting decay amplitude coincides with the outcome of the vacuum calculation , @xmath322 , and that @xmath323 . in the presence of a nonzero lepton asymmetry @xmath324 and @xmath325 .
therefore @xmath326 and this leads to a washout of the asymmetry .
despite the fact that eq . correctly describes the ( leading - order ) washout processes , it fails to describe processes which generate lepton asymmetry : in the considered approximation @xmath323 because the _ cp_-violating effects , which are required to produce the asymmetry , are of fourth order in the yukawa couplings of the majorana neutrino . in eq .
we have taken into account only terms quadratic in the coupling . in other words , this approximation corresponds to the tree - level approximation in the canonical approach .
terms of higher order in the couplings emerge from three- and higher - loop contributions to the lepton self - energy , see eqs.- , as well as from expansion of the full majorana propagators entering the self - energies . in order to define an effective cp - violating parameter and decay width that incorporate medium corrections we have to identify the quasiparticle excitations in the system . to perform this analysis
we follow the discussion of the self - energy contribution within a toy - model as presented in @xcite . as has been demonstrated there , it is important to take the matrix structure of the majorana propagator in flavor space into account .
our starting point is the schwinger - dyson equation for the majorana two - point function : @xmath327 let us split the self - energy into diagonal and off - diagonal components in flavor space and introduce a diagonal propagator @xmath328 defined by the equation : @xmath329 where @xmath330 is the free propagator and @xmath331 denotes the diagonal components of the self - energy .
the poles of the diagonal propagator define the quasiparticle excitations .
it can be shown that the dynamics of these is described by a boltzmann - like quantum kinetic equation . inserting this decomposition into the schwinger - dyson equation we find , using matrix notation : @xmath332 where @xmath333 denotes the off - diagonal components of the self - energy and @xmath237 the full neutrino propagator including flavor - diagonal and flavor off - diagonal contributions . multiplying eq . by @xmath237 from the left , by @xmath334 from the right and integrating over the contour @xmath335 we obtain a formal solution for the full non - equilibrium propagator : @xmath336 after decomposing the propagators and self - energies into the spectral and statistical components , we can rewrite eq . in the form : @xmath337{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here we are using the retarded and advanced propagators defined by eq .
, so that the integration can be extended to the whole @xmath338-plane . using their definitions and eq . , we can also derive formal solutions for the retarded and advanced propagators : @xmath339 next we wigner transform eqs . and and perform the leading order gradient expansion as has been outlined in section[neqftapproach ] . combining both results
, we find for the full statistical and spectral propagators and the corresponding causal two - point functions of the system in to equilibrium : [ fullpropagator ] @xmath340 where all propagators and self - energies are evaluated at the same point @xmath341 in configuration space .
we can express the full statistical and spectral propagators in terms of the diagonal ones and the off - diagonal self - energies , @xmath342 { \hat{\theta}^{}_{a}}{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath343 and @xmath344 are defined by @xmath345 and @xmath346 respectively , with @xmath347 being the @xmath348 unit matrix in the dirac and flavor space of the @xmath349 generations .
solution eq . reduces the dynamics of the full statistical and spectral propagators to the dynamics of two quasiparticle excitations .
their masses , decay widths and _ cp_-violating parameters are determined by the medium and the abundances are described by the corresponding one - particle distribution functions .
strictly speaking , the solution is valid only in thermal equilibrium .
however , we assume that it also holds for small deviations from equilibrium . to consistently analyze processes of the fourth order in the coupling one
has to use so - called extended quasiparticle approximation ( eqp ) for the statistical propagator and spectral function @xcite .
the eqp approximation represents the diagonal propagator as a sum of two terms : @xmath350 the first describes decay processes , whereas the second can be associated with scattering processes . inserting eq . into eq
we get a solution for the resummed majorana propagator consistent up to the fourth order in the couplings : @xmath351{\hat{\theta}^{}_{a}}{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first term in the above formula describes majorana decay , see section[cpviolationindecay ] , whereas the remaining three terms describe the two - body scattering processes mediated by the majorana neutrino .
these are discussed in section[majoranamediatedscattering ] . using definition of the retarded and advanced two - point functions , eq . , and the schwinger - dyson equation for the diagonal propagators , eq .
, we find that the causal propagators in eq . are given by @xmath352 splitting the retarded and advanced self - energies into the vector and scalar components we can write the solution of eq . in the form : @xmath353 where we have omitted flavor indices to shorten the notation and introduced @xmath354 from eq .
we can extract the spectral and hermitian propagators . to leading order in the yukawas they read [ shrhoapprox ] @xmath355 the on - shell condition
is defined by @xmath356 .
expanding @xmath357 to linear order in the yukawas we find : @xmath358 where @xmath359 is the medium - induced component of the hermitian self - energy in the on - shell renormalization scheme . in vacuum
the on - shell condition is fulfilled for @xmath360 , i.e. @xmath361 is the physical vacuum mass . at non - zero temperatures the mass receives medium - induced corrections .
to linear order in the yukawas the effective mass is given by @xmath362 .
for a hierarchical mass spectrum , which we consider here , the contributions of the hermitian self - energy are always negligible and we will use @xmath363 and @xmath364 in the following . from eq .
we can also deduce the effective width . to leading order in the yukawas
it is given by @xmath365 .
the minus sign in this definition ensures that the effective decay width is positive .
one - loop contribution to the majorana self - energy is derived in appendix[selfenergy ] . in a _
cp_-symmetric medium it is given by @xmath366 l_{\rho}{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore we can write the effective decay width in the form @xmath367 , where @xmath368 is the total vacuum decay width . for positive @xmath369 and @xmath370 the loop integral
@xmath371 takes the form : @xmath372{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for massless final states @xmath373 .
therefore the definition of the effective decay width inferred in section[risquantstat ] from the requirement of successful ris subtraction is consistent with that implied by eq .. for the eqp wightman propagators we can use the kadanoff - baym ansatz . as can be inferred from eq .
, the corresponding spectral function reads @xmath374 substituting eq . into eq .
we obtain @xmath375 where we have again omitted the flavor indices . the second and the third terms in eq .
vanish on the mass shell and can be neglected .
commuting @xmath376 and @xmath377 in the first term and again neglecting contributions which are tiny on the mass shell we finally obtain for the eqp spectral function : @xmath378 ^ 2 } { { \ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that structures of eqs . and
are very similar .
furthermore , as follows from eq .
, in the limit of vanishing decay width both of them approach the delta - function . however , for a small but _ finite _ decay width the eqp spectral function is a better approximation to the delta - function than eq .. therefore , we can approximate it by the usual expression , @xmath379 and at the same time keep finite - width terms in the diagonal propagators .
to go beyond the tree - level approximation and take into account _ cp_-violating
effects we need to consider contributions to the lepton self - energy that are of the fourth order in the yukawa couplings .
one of them comes from expansion of the majorana propagator in the one - loop self - energy . substituting the decay term of eq . into eq .
we can write it in the form : @xmath380 substituting eq . and
its _ cp _ conjugate into eq .
we find that the resulting contribution to the divergence of the lepton - current has precisely the form . however , the corresponding effective amplitudes are no longer equal : [ effectivedecayamplitudesse ] @xmath381{{\ , , } } \\
\label{effamplsecpbarlbarh } { \xi^{t}_{\bar{{\ell}}\bar{\phi}\leftrightarrow { n}_i } } & + { \xi^{s}_{\bar{{\ell}}\bar{\phi}\leftrightarrow { n}_i}}\equiv g_w { \textstyle\sum}_{mn}(h^\dagger h)^*_{mn}\nonumber\\ \times&{{\rm tr}}[{\bar{\theta}^{ni}_{r}}(t,{{q}})(\slashed{{{q}}}+m_i ) { \bar{\theta}^{im}_{a}}(t,{{q}})p_l\slashed{{{r}}}p_r\,]{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the matrices @xmath343 and @xmath344 are evaluated on the mass shell of the @xmath382th majorana neutrino .
the bar denotes _
cp_-conjugation and the trace is over dirac indices .
interference of tree - level and one - loop self - energy corrections . ]
as compared to tree - level result it additionally contains interference of the tree - level and one - loop self - energy contributions to the majorana decay amplitude , see fig.[tpluss ] . for a hierarchical mass spectrum we can use the approximation @xmath383 and a similar approximation for @xmath344 . using furthermore eqs .
and we find for the _ cp_-violating parameter : @xmath384 where @xmath283 and @xmath385 are on - shell momenta of the outgoing lepton and decaying majorana neutrino respectively . in vacuum @xmath386 and
the _ cp_-violating parameter takes the form : @xmath387 the ` regulator ' in the denominator of eq .
differs from the result @xmath388 found in @xcite by the ratio of the masses .
for a hierarchical neutrino mass spectrum the ` regulator ' term is sub - dominant and this difference is numerically small .
note also that although eq . does not diverge in the limit of vanishing mass difference the approximations made in the course of its derivation are not applicable for a quasidegenerate mass spectrum @xcite . for a consistent treatment of resonant enhancement within neqft
we refer to @xcite .
the two - loop lepton self - energy is of the fourth order in the couplings to begin with .
therefore , for a hierarchical mass spectrum one can safely neglect the off - diagonal components of the majorana propagators and replace @xmath244 by the eqp one : @xmath389 { { \ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] substituting eq . and
its _ cp _ conjugate into eq .
we again find that the resulting contribution to the divergence of the lepton - current has the form .
the corresponding effective amplitudes read [ majoranavertexamplitudes ] @xmath390\\ & -g_w(h^{\dagger}h)_{ji}^{2}\,m_i\ , { { \rm tr}}\bigr [ c v_{jj}(q , k)p_l\slashed p p_r\bigr]{{\ , , } } \nonumber\\ \label{effamplvertbarlbarh } { \xi^{v}_{n_i \leftrightarrow \bar { { \ell}}\bar { \phi } } } \equiv & -g_w(h^{\dagger}h)_{ij}^2\ m_i\ , { { \rm tr}}\bigr [ c v_{jj}(q , k)p_l\slashed p p_r\bigr]\\ & -g_w(h^{\dagger}h)_{ji}^{2}\,m_i\ , { { \rm tr}}\bigl[\varlambda_{jj}(q , k ) c p_l\slashed pp_r\bigr]\nonumber{{\ , .}}\hphantom{aa}\end{aligned}\ ] ] they describe interference of the tree - level and one - loop vertex contributions to the majorana decay amplitude , see fig.[interferencev ] . interference of tree - level and one - loop vertex corrections . ] to account for the contribution of the vertex correction to the decay width and the _ cp_-violating parameter we have to substitute the sum of @xmath391 and @xmath392 and a similar sum for the antiparticles into eq .. the vertex contribution to the decay amplitude is of fourth order in the coupling and is negligible compared to the tree - level term . since we assume the medium to be almost _
cp_-symmetric we can use , at leading order , _ cp_-symmetric two - point functions in the loop integrals @xmath393 and @xmath394 . then , at leading order in the yukawa couplings , we find for the vertex contribution to the _ cp_-violating parameter : @xmath395\nonumber{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the quasiparticle approximation and the kb - ansatz enforce two of the intermediate lines of the vertex loop to be on - shell whereas the remaining line described by the hermitian part of the retarded and advanced propagators remains off - shell .
the three lines in square brackets in eq . therefore correspond to different cuts through two of the three internal lines of the loop diagram fig.[treevertexself].(c ) .
note also that only for one of the three internal lines the corresponding distribution function enters the result .
the first possible cut described by the first line in square brackets corresponds to cutting the propagators of higgs and lepton .
one can interpret this cut as decay of the majorana neutrino into a lepton - higgs pair which is followed by a subsequent @xmath54-channel scattering mediated by a virtual majorana neutrino .
introducing @xmath396 m_i^2 { \boldsymbol{\mathcal{s}}^{ii}_{h}}({{k}}-{{r}}_2 ) { { \ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] we can rewrite the first term in eq . in a form which strongly resembles the form of the self - energy _ cp_-violating parameter : @xmath397 in vacuum @xmath398 can be computed explicitly and we recover the well - known result @xcite : @xmath399{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] adding up eqs .
and we obtain the canonical expression for the vacuum _ cp_-violating parameter , eq .. if the intermediate majorana neutrino is much heavier than the decaying one then @xmath400 and therefore @xmath401 . in this case
we can also neglect the ` regulator ' term in the denominator of eq .. in this approximation the two _ cp_-violating parameters have the same structure and their sum can be written in the form : @xmath402 note that the combination of the distribution functions that enters the self - energy and vertex _ cp_-violating parameters , see eqs . and
, is the same as that of @xmath403 encountered in the derivation of the rate equations , see eq .. this result is in agreement with the findings of @xcite using neqft and of @xcite based on imaginary - time thermal qft .
note that older results featured a different dependence on the distribution functions , with an additional term quadratic in the one - particle distribution functions which is absent in eq . as well as in eq .
: @xmath404 in @xcite it was demonstrated that the result obtained using thermal field theory can be reconciled with the result of neqft calculation once causal green s functions are used in the former .
the two other cuts in eq .
are proportional to @xmath405 and to @xmath406 respectively .
they vanish in the zero temperature limit and are usually boltzmann - suppressed at finite temperatures , but can be relevant in specific cases @xcite .
the quantities that enter the rate equations are the decay , washout and _ cp_-violating decay reaction densities . in the canonical approximation ,
i.e. when the quantum - statistical effects and effective masses of the higgs and leptons are neglected , they are given by eq .. if the thermal masses are neglected but the quantum - statistical effects are taken into account , there is an enhancement of the decay and washout reaction densities at high temperature , see fig.[gammadratio ] .
decay and _ cp_-violating reaction densities with thermal lepton and higgs masses , @xmath407 , and with zero masses , @xmath408 , for the two majorana neutrinos @xmath409 and @xmath410 .
the values are normalized to the corresponding reaction density in the conventional approximation @xmath411 .
the thermal enhancement due to quantum - statistical factors is overcompensated by the phase space suppression due to thermal masses at high temperatures .
note that we show only the self - energy contribution to the _ cp_-violating reaction densities .
] however , the inclusion of the thermal masses turns this enhancement into a suppression at high temperatures .
it is explained by the decrease of the decay phase space . at intermediate temperatures
the thermal masses become small relative to the majorana mass and we observe a minor enhancement . for the _ cp_-violating reaction density we observe a very similar behavior .
given that for a hierarchical mass spectrum most of the asymmetry is typically generated by the lightest majorana neutrino at @xmath412 , where @xmath40 is the washout parameter ( see appendix[numericalparameters ] ) , we expect the medium effects to induce a moderate enhancement of the total generated asymmetry .
two - body scattering processes mediated by majorana neutrinos violate lepton number by two units and play an important role in the washout of the generated asymmetry . in this section
we derive the effective scattering amplitudes using neqft .
this is an important part of our results .
the last three terms in eq . contain the wigner - transformed one - loop majorana self - energy : @xmath413 { { \ , , } } \hphantom{a}\end{aligned}\ ] ] see appendix[majoranaselfen ] for more details . combining them with eq .
we find that their contribution to the divergence of the lepton - current contains two wightman propagators of leptons and two of the higgs field . as we have argued above , these correspond to initial and final states in the kinetic equations .
therefore , we conclude that these terms describe scattering processes depicted in fig.[lhbarlbarh ] and fig.[llbarhbarh ] . as higgs and leptons
are maintained close to equilibrium we can safely use the kadanoff - baym ansatz for their propagators in the majorana self - energy . inserting eq . into the scattering terms of eq .
we can then split the majorana propagator into a lepton number conserving and lepton number violating part : [ propmajapsp ] @xmath414 { { \ , , } } \\ \label{propmajapsp < } { \mathscr{s}^{ij}_{<}}({{q}})&=- g_w\int { { \,d}\pi^4_{{{k } } } } { { \,d}\pi^4_{{{r}}}}(2\pi)^4 \delta(q - p - k){\delta^{}_{\rho}}({{k } } ) { \mathbf{s}^{}_{\rho}}({{r } } ) \nonumber \\ & \times \bigl[f_{{\ell}}^{{r}}f_{\phi}^{{k}}{\mathscr{s}^{ij}_{lc}}({{q}},{{r } } ) + f_{\bar { { \ell}}}^{{r}}f_{\bar { \phi}}^{{k}}{\mathscr{s}^{ij}_{lv}}({{q}},{{r } } ) \bigr ] { { \ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have defined : [ lvlc ] @xmath415{{\ , , } } \nonumber \\ \label{lv } & { \mathscr{s}^{ij}_{lv}}=(h^\dagger h)_{ji } \bigl [ ( 1-\delta^{ij}){\mathcal{s}^{ii}_{r}}(q)p_r\slashed{{{r } } } p_l { \mathcal{s}^{jj}_{a}}({{q } } ) \\ & + \frac{\delta^{ij}}{2 } \big({\mathcal{s}^{ii}_{r } } ( q)p_r\slashed{{{r } } } p_l { \mathcal{s}^{jj}_{r}}({{q } } ) + { \mathcal{s}^{ii}_{a}}(q)p_r \slashed{{{r } } } p_l
{ \mathcal{s}^{jj}_{a}}({{q}})\big ) \bigr]{{\ , .}}\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] here we neglected higher order terms coming from the matrices @xmath416 and @xmath417 .
the first terms in eqs . and corresponds to the second term in eq . , whereas the remaining terms correspond to the last two terms in eq .. substituting the majorana propagators into the lepton - current together with the one - loop lepton self - energy we finally obtain @xmath418{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the zeroth component of the momenta in the above equation can have both signs .
the effective amplitudes of the lepton number conserving and lepton number violating processes read [ traceap ] @xmath419{{\ , , } } \hphantom{aaaa}\\ \label{traceaplc } a^{lc}({{q}},{{r}}_1,{{r}}_2)\equiv & ( h^\dagger h)_{ji}\ , { { \rm tr}}\bigl[{\mathscr{s}^{ij}_{lc}}(q,{{r}}_2 ) p_l \slashed{{{r}}}_1p_r\bigr]{{\ , .}}\hphantom{aaaa}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the functions @xmath420 and @xmath421 are symmetric under the exchange of the momenta @xmath422 and @xmath423 .
this implies that the contribution of @xmath424 in eq .
the terms of @xmath425 diagonal in flavor space correspond to the ris - propagator .
substituting eq . into eq . and taking the trace we find that it contains only the scalar components of the retarded and advanced propagators and is proportional to : @xmath426 ^ 2}\nonumber\\ & \approx 2m^2\frac{(q^2-m^2)^2-(m{{\boldsymbol \gamma}^{}_{}})^2}{\left[(q^2-m^2)^2 + ( m{{\boldsymbol \gamma}^{}_{}})^2\right]^2}{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] equation differs from the canonical result only in that the vacuum masses and decay widths are replaced by thermal ones . for a hierarchical mass spectrum this difference can be safely neglected .
introducing an analogue of the ris subtracted propagator , @xmath427 we can rewrite the lepton number violating effective amplitude in a compact form : @xmath428 next we perform the trivial integrations over the frequencies using the dirac - deltas in the quasiparticle spectral functions and .
each dirac - delta can be decomposed into two terms , one with positive and one with negative frequency . therefore
, the integration over the four frequencies gives rise to @xmath429 terms , but only six of them satisfy energy conservation ensured by the remaining delta - function . in a homogeneous and isotropic medium
the one - particle distribution functions satisfy @xmath430 and the diagonal majorana propagators have the properties @xmath431 upon substitution of the resulting self - energy into eq . and the use of eqs . and
the remaining six contributions in the lepton - current can be conveniently written as @xmath432{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have defined the effective scattering amplitudes : [ m1 ] @xmath433 the momenta of the majorana neutrinos are related to the momenta of the initial and final states by @xmath434 and @xmath435 . from eq .
we see that the obtained amplitudes contain only @xmath436 and @xmath437 interference terms . indeed , in the products of the majorana propagators in eq .
both of them depend on the same momentum .
the missing cross terms emerge from the two - loop ( vertex ) contribution to the lepton self - energy . as we have mentioned in section[neqftapproach ] , within the discussed assumptions and approximations the second and third terms on the right - hand side of eq .
describe scattering processes .
since they are of the fourth order in the yukawas , we can replace the full majorana propagators by the diagonal propagators .
the third term , eq . , corresponds to lepton number conserving processes and does not need to be discussed further .
the second one , eq .
, is given by @xmath438{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we substitute eq . into the equation for
the lepton - current and perform the steps preceding eq .. using furthermore relations we find @xmath439{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have introduced [ m2 ] @xmath440 and @xmath441 .
the combinations of the momenta appearing in the products of the majorana propagators clearly indicate that the above amplitudes correspond to the interference terms of the @xmath53- , @xmath54- , and @xmath88-channel contributions . combining eqs .
and we obtain for the effective amplitude of @xmath442 scattering : @xmath443{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] whereas the effective amplitude of @xmath444 scattering reads @xmath445{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] to compare the obtained expressions with the vacuum results of the canonical computation eqs . and
, we evaluate the retarded and advanced propagators at zero temperature . in vacuum @xmath446 .
therefore for positive @xmath447 it follows from eq . that @xmath448^{-1}{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the vicinity of the mass shell of the respective majorana neutrino @xmath112 and we find @xmath449 for @xmath54- and @xmath88-channels the imaginary parts of eqs . and vanish , so that in the vacuum limit @xmath450 and @xmath451 is symmetric with respect to @xmath227 .
the squares of the @xmath54- and @xmath88-channel propagators in eq . give identical contributions to the reduced cross section of @xmath87 process .
therefore , upon substitution of eq . into eq . and the use of the @xmath227 symmetry , we recover for the reduced cross section the canonical result .
relations imply that the off - diagonal components of @xmath452 and @xmath451 coincide . for the @xmath53-channel
the diagonal components of @xmath453 are given in the vacuum limit by @xmath454 ^ 2}{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , in the vicinity of the mass shell , @xmath455 , the canonical expression for the ris - subtracted propagator , eq .
, coincides with the expression obtained from first principles .
this justifies results of the earlier calculations . for the reduced cross section of @xmath228 scattering we recover eq .. at finite temperatures
@xmath456 is not zero even for @xmath54- and @xmath88-channels . in other words ,
the medium effects induce additional contributions to the effective decay amplitudes . however , these contributions are proportional to the coefficients @xmath457 .
numerical analysis shows that for the two chosen sets of parameters , see appendix[numericalparameters ] , the additional correction typically do not have any sizable impact on the reaction densities . a quantity relevant for the numerical analysis is the ratio @xmath458 .
the dependence of this ratio on the dimensionless inverse temperature is presented in fig.[blzmnvsfdbe1 ] and fig.[blzmnvsfdbe2 ] .
if the approximate expression is used , then the reaction density of @xmath228 scattering becomes negative for @xmath459 for the first set of the parameters whereas for the second set of the parameters it turns negative for @xmath460 .
a qualitatively similar behavior has also been observed in @xcite .
washout reaction densities due to @xmath87 and @xmath228 scattering processes for benchmark point 1 in the approximation of massless leptons and higgs . shown
are the reaction densities computed using the boltzmann approximation ( [ reactdenscanon ] ) ( thin lines ) , and taking into account the quantum - statistical effects , ( [ reactdensexact ] ) ( thick lines ) .
the ( ris subtracted ) reaction densities @xmath193 may be negative as they are not the physical rates for the @xmath461 scattering process . ]
this rather counter - intuitive result can be traced back to the behavior of the ris part of the effective amplitude which is negative in the vicinity of the mass shell .
its sign is not fixed by physical requirements , since it constitutes a sub - leading contribution to the washout rate .
washout reaction densities due to @xmath87 and @xmath228 scattering processes for benchmark point 2 .
compare fig.[blzmnvsfdbe1 ] . ] as can be inferred from fig.[blzmnvsfdbe1 ] , for the first set of model parameters the quantum - statistical corrections render the ris subtracted reaction density of @xmath228 scattering positive in the whole range of temperatures .
however , this is merely a numerical coincidence . for the second set of parameters ,
see fig.[blzmnvsfdbe2 ] , the reaction density of @xmath228 scattering remains negative for @xmath462 .
it is nevertheless important to note that even in the region where the reaction density is negative the quantum - statistical corrections shift it upwards as compared to the result of the canonical computation . as far as @xmath463 scattering
is concerned , the quantum - statistical corrections enhance the reduced reaction density at high temperatures by about 50% .
as the temperature decreases , the reaction density computed using eq . approaches the one computed using eq . as one would expect .
a similar behavior is also observed for the reaction density of @xmath228 scattering . in figs.[blzmnvsfdbe1 ] and
[ blzmnvsfdbe2 ] we neglected the thermal masses of initial and final states .
ratio of the reaction density computed using thermal masses with ( thick lines ) and without ( thin lines ) the quantum - statistical terms to the canonical one for the two sets of parameters . ] to estimate the size of the mass corrections , in fig.[scatteringwithmasses ] we plot ratio of the reaction density of the @xmath87 scattering computed using thermal masses of the higgs and leptons with and without the quantum - statistical terms to the canonical one for the two sets of parameters . if the quantum - statistical effects are neglected , the thermal masses lead to a @xmath464 suppression of the reaction densities . on the other hand ,
an enhancement induced by the quantum - statistical terms to a large extent compensates the mass - induced suppression . as a result
, the deviation from the canonical reaction density does not exceed @xmath465 in the whole range of temperatures . to compare the relative importance of the ( inverse ) decay and scattering processes in fig.[washoutrdbm1 ] and fig.[washoutrdbm2 ] we also present the uniformly normalized reaction densities .
washout reaction densities due to @xmath87 and @xmath228 scattering processes for benchmark point 1 in the approximation of massless leptons and higgs . for comparison
the washout reaction densities for @xmath409 and @xmath410 ( inverse ) decays are shown as well . note that the normalization differs from the one used in fig.[blzmnvsfdbe1 ] and fig.[blzmnvsfdbe2 ] for the present choice of parameters contributions by @xmath461 scatterings are strongly suppressed by the smallness of the couplings . ] in both cases we observe a qualitatively similar picture : for the chosen sets of parameters reaction densities of the scattering processes are strongly suppressed by the smallness of the yukawa couplings as compared to those of the decay processes .
washout reaction densities due to @xmath87 and @xmath228 scattering processes as well as ( inverse ) decays for benchmark point 2 .
compare fig.[washoutrdbm1 ] . ] in the rate equation for the lepton asymmetry , see eq .
, the total washout rate is given by a sum of reaction densities for decays and scattering .
whereas @xmath156 and @xmath466 are positive , the ris subtracted reaction density @xmath467 can be negative at some temperatures .
if the total washout rate would turn negative , it would lead to a spurious self - enhanced generation of the asymmetry . in figs.[washoutrdbm1 ] and [ washoutrdbm2 ] we show the sum of the reactions densities . for both parameter sets it
is positive .
this sum should always be positive .
if the quantum - statistical terms are neglected this can be demonstrated explicitly . in the absence of the quantum - statistical corrections ,
the results of this section revert to the ones discussed in section[conventionalapproach ] . using the expression for the ris - propagator , eq .
, we can rewrite the ris subtracted scattering amplitude as a difference of the unsubtracted one and the ris term . since the latter is proportional to @xmath468 the integration in eqs . and is trivial and we obtain after some algebra : @xmath469 the total washout rate is then given by @xmath470 and is positive as a sum of two positive functions .
in other words , even though @xmath467 can be negative at some temperatures , the total washout rate is always positive .
the form of the unsubtracted scattering reaction density that can be inferred from eq .
is another manifestation of the double - counting .
if we had not subtracted the ris contribution , we would have counted contributions of the inverse decay processes twice and ended up with an incorrect prediction for the generated asymmetry .
in the preceding section we have approximately taken the gauge interactions into account in the form of effective masses of the higgs and leptons .
the thermal masses are of order of @xmath471 and large enough to influence the values of the reaction densities quantitatively .
in particular , the majorana neutrino decay can become kinematically forbidden when the sum of the masses of lepton and higgs exceeds the heavy majorana neutrino mass . for even higher temperatures ( with @xmath472 ) the higgs decay channel into a lepton - majorana pair
becomes kinematically allowed instead and can contribute to the asymmetry since it violates _
cp_. for simplicity we do not take modified dispersion relations into account here , see @xcite , but use the simple picture of temperature dependent thermal masses as an estimate : @xmath473 where we use the temperature dependent values of the @xmath21 , @xmath474 , top yukawa and higgs self - couplings @xmath475 , @xmath476 , @xmath477 and @xmath478 assuming a higgs mass of @xmath479 @xcite .
we also ignore that the thermal mass of leptons might be better approximated by the ` asymptotic thermal mass ' @xmath480 in a kinematic regime in which their momentum is such that @xmath481 @xcite .
we do also not take into account , in our quantitative analysis , the thermal corrections to the majorana neutrino masses as they are negligible compared to their vacuum masses . as they can influence the resonance in this case . ]
tree level contribution and one - loop corrections to the ( anti-)higgs decay amplitude .
the additional arrows illustrate the direction of momentum flow . ]
the _ cp_-violating decay of the higgs arises from the interference of the tree - level , self - energy and vertex graphs depicted in fig.[higgsdecayplot ] .
although in this case the decaying particle the higgs doublet is very close to thermal equilibrium due to the yukawa and gauge interactions of the standard model , the majorana neutrino in the final state may deviate from equilibrium , so that the third sakharov condition is fulfilled . using the expression for the divergence of the lepton - current , eq .
, we can extract the corresponding _ cp_-violating parameter . to calculate the self - energy contribution
it is convenient to rewrite the one - loop lepton self - energy in the form : @xmath482 where the transposition is only in dirac space and we have used one of the properties of majorana propagator : @xmath483 in its _ cp _ conjugate the yukawa couplings are replaced by their complex conjugates and the propagators by the _
cp _ conjugate ones .
similar to the case of the majorana decay , substituting eq . into eq .
we can define effective higgs decay amplitudes : [ higgsdecayamplitides ] @xmath484{{\ , , } } \hphantom{aa}\\ \label{higgsdecayamplitidesbarln } { \xi^{}_{{\phi}\leftrightarrow \bar { { \ell}}{n}_i}}&\equiv g_w\sum_{mn } ( h^\dagger h)^*_{mn}\nonumber\\ & \times { { \rm tr}}\left[{\bar{\theta}^{mi}_{r}}({{q } } ) ( \slashed{{{q}}}+m_i){\bar{\theta}^{in}_{a}}({{q } } ) p_r\slashed{{{r}}}p_l\right]{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the overall factor @xmath485 in eqs .
comes from summation over the doublet components of the ( decaying ) higgs particle . to leading order in the couplings : [ higgsamplitudes ] @xmath486{{\ , , } } \\
\label{antihiggsamplitude } { \xi^{}_{{\phi}\leftrightarrow \bar{{\ell}}{n}_i } } & \approx 2g_w\bigl[(h^\dagger h)_{ii}({{r}}\cdot { { q}})\nonumber\\ & - { \textstyle\frac{g_w}{16\pi } } \im ( h^\dagger h)_{ij}^2 m_i m_j { \boldsymbol{\mathcal{s}}^{jj}_{h } } ( { { r}}\ , l_\rho)\bigr]{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] which , up to the relative sign in square brackets , coincides with the amplitudes .
the corresponding _ cp_-violating parameter reads @xmath487 where @xmath283 and @xmath385 are the momenta of the on - shell final lepton and majorana neutrino with positive zeroth components respectively .
the direction of momentum flow is as defined in fig.[higgsdecayplot ] .
although @xmath371 in eqs . and
is one and the same function , because of the different kinematic regimes the explicit result in terms of the distribution functions differs for the higgs decay : @xmath488{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] see appendix[majoranaselfen ] .
note that our result is different from the one presented in @xcite . instead of the @xmath489 dependence ,
it is proportional to a sum , @xmath490 , of the two distribution functions .
this dependence can also be obtained in the framework of real time thermal field theory using causal @xmath349-point functions , compare @xcite .
the derivation within the kadanoff - baym formalism gives certainty concerning the sign of the contribution by higgs decay .
cp_-violating parameter has an opposite sign relative to that for majorana neutrino decay .
however , it is canceled by the relative sign in eq .. to calculate the vertex contribution we use eq . and represent the two - loop self - energy in the form @xmath491 \nonumber{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] its _ cp _ conjugate again differs by the conjugation of the yukawas and propagators . substituting eq . and its _ cp _ conjugate into eq .
we obtain for the corresponding effective amplitudes : [ higgsvertexamplitudes ] @xmath492\nonumber\\ & \hspace{3mm}+g_w(h^{\dagger}h)_{ji}^{2}\,m_i\ , { { \rm tr}}\bigr[c v_{jj}(-q ,- k)p_l\slashed{{{r } } } p_r\bigr]{{\ , , } } \\
\label{effamplbarhbarln } & { \xi^{v}_{{\phi}\leftrightarrow \bar { { \ell}}n_i } } \equiv g_w(h^{\dagger}h)_{ij}^2\ m_i { { \rm tr}}\bigr[c v_{jj}(-q ,- k)p_l\slashed{{{r } } } p_r\bigr]\nonumber\\ & \hspace{3mm}+g_w(h^{\dagger}h)_{ji}^{2}\ , m_i { { \rm tr}}\bigl[\varlambda_{jj}(-q ,- k ) c p_l\slashed{{{r } } } p_r\bigr]{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] just like for the self - energy contribution we observe that the overall sign of the vertex contribution to the higgs decay amplitude is opposite to that in the majorana decay , compare eqs . and .
the corresponding _ cp_-violating parameter reads @xmath493\nonumber{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the last three lines of eq .
correspond to the three possible cuts of the vertex graph .
similarly to the majorana decay only two of the intermediate states can be on - shell and for only one of them the corresponding distribution function enters the result .
the value of the vertex _ cp_-violating parameter depends on the temperature as well as on masses of the majorana neutrinos . for definiteness ,
let us assume a strongly hierarchical mass spectrum , @xmath494 . in this case contribution of the last two lines in eq .
is strongly suppressed .
integrating out the delta - functions we find for the contribution of the first cut : @xmath495 where the loop function @xmath496 is now defined as : @xmath497 m_i^2 { \boldsymbol{\mathcal{s}}^{ii}_{h}}({{k}}-{{r}}_2 ) { { \ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the vertex _
cp_-violating parameter has an opposite sign relative to that for majorana neutrino decay .
similarly to the self - energy contribution we observe that the @xmath498 combination is replaced in by @xmath499 . for a milder mass hierarchy the two other cuts can become important .
their contributions are proportional to @xmath500 and @xmath501 respectively .
the first - principle computation gives for the higgs decay contribution to the evolution of the lepton current an expression similar to eq .
: @xmath502{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we do not discuss ` extra ' terms here which would arise from ` naive ' boltzmann equations . to write this as a rate equation we need to repeat the steps in section[rateequations ] which lead to eq .. for a general process @xmath503 ( where we allow for deviations from equilibrium in @xmath504 ) we have eq .. therefore we obtain , for higgs decay , the following contributions to the rate equations for lepton number and majorana neutrino abundance ( see appendix[rateequationsapp ] ) : @xmath505 we introduced the decay and washout reaction densities , @xmath506 and @xmath507 , for higgs decay : @xmath508 where now @xmath509 . in complete analogy to eq . the total amplitude and the _ cp_-violating parameter for ( anti-)higgs decay are defined as [ amplsqandepsdefhiggs ] @xmath510 similarly to the majorana neutrino decays we also define an averaged _ cp_-violating parameter as @xmath511 by comparing eqs . and we observe that , ignoring @xmath512 contributions , the difference to the majorana neutrino decay contributions amounts to the replacements @xmath513 and @xmath514 .
we therefore obtain eq . with an opposite sign for the _ cp_-violating source term .
this sign cancels the relative sign of the _ cp_-violating parameter such that majorana neutrino decay and higgs decay contribute effectively with same sign .
similarly , for the contribution to the majorana neutrino rate equation : @xmath515 to compute the thermally averaged _ cp_-violating parameter we take into account the temperature dependent evolution of the lepton and higgs masses @xcite . the averaged _ cp_-violating parameter in the higgs decay and in the majorana decay as functions of the inverse temperature
are presented in fig.[epsilongammahiggsbm1 ] and fig.[epsilongammahiggsbm2 ] . averaged self - energy _ cp_-violating parameters for majorana neutrino and higgs decay for benchmark point 1 as a function of the inverse temperature .
thin lines represent the value in the zero temperature limit . with conventional dispersion relations ,
the decay @xmath516 is active at @xmath517 but replaced at high temperatures ( @xmath518 ) by @xmath519 .
the decay @xmath520 is active at @xmath521 but replaced at high temperatures ( @xmath522 ) by @xmath523 . ] at very high temperatures the magnitude of @xmath524 can be much larger for higgs decay .
averaged self - energy _ cp_-violating parameters for majorana neutrino and higgs decay for benchmark point 2 .
see caption of fig.[epsilongammahiggsbm1 ] . ] as the temperature decreases the _ cp_-violating parameter for the higgs decay approaches zero .
this is explained by the shrinking of the available phase space in the loop integrals and .
in this paper we have studied leptogenesis in the type - i seesaw extension of the standard model using the 2pi - formalism of non - equilibrium quantum field theory .
the asymmetry generation can , in the case of thermal leptogenesis , be approximately described by rate equations .
usually these statistical equations are treated as a ` black - box ' in the sense that their form is assumed given and model specific amplitudes are inserted by hand .
indeed , this approach is supported by the observation that it describes the free decay in the zero temperature limit correctly and inherent inconsistencies ( namely the ` double - counting problem ' ) can be resolved in exact equilibrium . however , out of equilibrium it is not obvious whether the subtraction of real intermediate states works to all orders and how amplitudes computed in thermal field theory enter kinetic equations .
these issues can be completely avoided in a systematic treatment within non - equilibrium quantum field theory . only in recent years
fundamental questions related to the non - equilibrium statistical description received more attention .
the progress here is mainly based on the 2pi - formalism which is known to yield consistent quantum kinetic equations without double - counting .
these equations can be reduced to a system of boltzmann - like kinetic equations for quasiparticles which can easily be compared to the conventional results .
in the course of the derivation necessary approximations and the related physical assumptions have to be specified explicitly .
therefore , this approach enables a deeper insight into the dynamics of the asymmetry generation . in the conventional analysis
the minimal set of interactions is obtained at order @xmath117 of the perturbative expansion .
we have complemented existing analyses based on the 2pi - formalism by the computation of further processes which appear at this order .
starting from a system of kadanoff - baym and ( equivalent ) schwinger - dyson equations for leptons and heavy majorana neutrinos we have derived boltzmann - like quantum - kinetic equations for the lepton asymmetry .
they include ( inverse ) decays of the heavy majorana neutrinos as well as two - body scattering processes mediated by the heavy neutrinos : @xmath525 because all terms in this equation are proportional to @xmath318 , a combination of the distribution functions which vanishes in equilibrium , the obtained equations are free of the double - counting problem and no need for the real intermediate state subtraction arises .
together with the systematic derivation of the effective decay and scattering amplitudes @xmath49 this is the main result of the present work .
the individual amplitudes arise as combinations of different 2pi contributions .
the vertex contribution to the _ cp_-violating decay amplitude is obtained as cut of the 2pi ` mercedes ' diagram .
the same graph yields also the @xmath526 contributions to @xmath228 and the @xmath527 contribution to @xmath87 process . to extract the self - energy contribution
, the off - diagonal elements of the majorana neutrino propagator have to be taken into account .
in addition , an extended quasiparticle approximation needs to be employed in order to obtain the @xmath436 and @xmath437 contributions to @xmath228 as well as @xmath528 and @xmath437 contributions to @xmath87 scattering from the ` setting - sun ' diagram . in the zero temperature limit
the effective amplitudes reduce to the canonical ones . in particular , the form of the resulting amplitudes for @xmath228 scattering coincides with the ris subtracted amplitudes encountered in existing calculations . at finite temperatures
the effective amplitudes receive thermal corrections .
medium corrections to the majorana decay amplitudes into leptons and antileptons are @xmath117 .
they are small compared to the tree - level vacuum contribution and are therefore negligible for the total decay width . on the other hand , they play an important role for the _ cp_-violating source - terms , which are proportional to the difference of the two amplitudes .
we find that medium corrections to the _ cp_-violating parameter are linear in the particle number densities .
although there is a partial cancellation of the bosonic and fermionic contribution , the
_ cp_-violating parameter is enhanced . in the effective scattering amplitudes
the medium corrections affect only the ` regulator ' term in the denominator of the breit - wigner propagators .
due to the smallness of the majorana decay width , which is constrained by the light neutrino masses , numerically these corrections are very small in the case of non - degenerate majorana neutrinos . taking sm interactions into account in the form of thermal lepton and higgs masses results in a suppression of the phase space for the majorana neutrino decay and the enhancement of the _ cp_-violating parameters is overcompensated . at even higher temperatures ,
when the effective higgs mass exceeds the majorana masses , the _ cp_-violating decay of the higgs into a lepton - majorana pair can become kinematically allowed instead . at these temperatures the averaged _ cp_-violating parameters for higgs decay exceeds that obtained for majorana decay in vacuum by orders of magnitude .
the signs of the corresponding _ cp_-violating parameters are opposite but their contribution to the lepton asymmetry has the same sign ( at least in the limit of hierarchical majorana masses ) .
these results are in qualitative agreement with earlier studies based on thermal field theory and may ultimately be compared to a full treatment of _ cp_-violating decays out of equilibrium , including gauge interactions .
we have also derived the corresponding rate equations for abundances of the participating species .
they are obtained as expansion in small deviations from equilibrium ( @xmath145 and @xmath529 ) and represent the hydrodynamical approximation of the boltzmann kinetic equations . as compared to the standard ( zero temperature )
result they are improved in that the obtained coefficients include medium corrections to the quasiparticle properties and take into account quantum - statistical effects .
we compare with the result obtained if the amplitudes are computed in thermal quantum field theory and the ris subtraction is performed manually .
we find that there are differences at higher order in the expansion parameters .
the coefficients reaction densities reflect the interplay between the medium enhancement of the effective amplitudes and the phase space suppression induced by the thermal masses of higgs and leptons . at very low temperatures
the reaction densities approach their canonical limit . since for a hierarchical mass spectrum most of the asymmetry is typically generated by the lightest majorana neutrino at temperatures of the order and smaller than its mass , we expect a moderate enhancement of the total generated asymmetry is possible for a typical average to strong washout scenario . for a detailed phenomenological analysis
it is necessary to include further phenomena such as flavour effects and @xmath530 scattering processes which contribute to the washout at @xmath531 .
additional quantum effects beyond the present analysis are relevant for non - standard scenarios in which the majorana neutrinos have degenerate masses or if they are not as close to thermal equilibrium .
this work has been supported by the german science foundation ( dfg ) under grant ka-3274/1 - 1 `` systematic analysis of baryogenesis in non - equilibrium quantum field theory '' and the collaborative research center 676 `` particles , strings and the early universe '' .
t.f . acknowledges support by the imprs - ptfs .
we thank s. blanchet and m. shaposhnikov for useful discussions .
the reaction densities contain distribution functions of the initial and final states , which depend on the corresponding energies .
therefore to compute the reaction densities we need to analyze the kinematics of the decay and scattering processes . to compute the _
cp_-violating reaction density and the decay reaction density we need to evaluate the integral : @xmath532{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the washout reaction densities or reaction densities for higgs decay we have similar expressions .
the integration over @xmath533 can be performed trivially and yields @xmath534 . using latexmath:[$|\vec
k|=(\vec q\,^2 + \vec p\,^2 - @xmath59 we remove the remaining dirac - delta and obtain @xmath536 the integration limits are given by @xmath537{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath538 , @xmath539 and @xmath540 is the usual kinematical function .
for an on - shell heavy neutrino @xmath360 .
if @xmath541 then @xmath542 and the above expression simplifies to @xmath543 . on the other hand , if @xmath544 then @xmath545 and therefore @xmath546 .
since the integration limits coincide in this case , the integral vanishes . combining it with the integration over @xmath547 and using the isotropy of the medium we find @xmath548 { { \ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ]
if quantum - statistical effects are neglected then both the _ cp_-violating parameter and the total tree - level decay amplitude are momentum independent and the integration can be performed analytically .
we get : @xmath549 where @xmath42 is the number of the majorana spin degrees of freedom .
similar results are obtained for higgs decay and washout reaction densities . for @xmath461 scattering
processes the reaction density is defined by @xmath550 to reduce it to a form suitable for the numerical analysis we insert an identity : @xmath551 into eq .. the resulting expression can be interpreted as a product of the inverse decay and decay amplitudes integrated over the ` mass ' and energy of the intermediate state : @xmath552 for the third line we will use eq .. for the last line it is more convenient to us a different representation . integrating out the delta - function we obtain for the last line in eq . :
@xmath553 note that not all angles are kinematically allowed , see eq .
below . as a product of lorentz - invariant
quantities the integral is also lorentz - invariant .
we can therefore boost to the center - of - mass frame where @xmath554 and @xmath555 . by energy - momentum conservation @xmath556 ,
where @xmath557 now .
the angle integration can be partially reduced to integration over the mandelstam variable @xmath558 using the relation @xmath559 .
note that the azimuthal angle @xmath560 is lorentz - invariant by itself .
therefore , boosting back to the rest frame of the medium we can write the left - hand side of eq . in the form @xmath561 integrating furthermore over @xmath562 and using the fact the the integrand is independent of the orientation of @xmath563 , we finally obtain @xmath564 where @xmath565 . just like for particle decay , the integration limits @xmath566 are given by eq .
but with @xmath567 and @xmath568 replaced by @xmath569 and @xmath570 respectively and the three - momentum given by @xmath571 .
the range of integration over @xmath54 is given by @xmath572{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in particular , for massless initial and finial states it reduces to @xmath573 and @xmath574 . if the quantum - statistical effects are neglected then @xmath575 .
the integration over @xmath576 can be easily performed in this case and , combined with the @xmath577 prefactor , gives @xmath578 . in the same approximation
the last line of does not depend on the distribution functions and gives so - called ` reduced cross section ' : @xmath579 using eq . and integrating over @xmath580 we recover the usual expression for the scattering reaction density : @xmath581 to take the quantum - statistical effects into account we need to express energies of initial and final states in terms of the integration variables . by energy conservation @xmath582 .
therefore @xmath576 and @xmath583 as well as the related momenta @xmath584 and @xmath585 are completely fixed by the second and third integration variables .
next we consider the final states . by energy conservation @xmath586 .
it remains to express @xmath587 in terms of the integration variables .
let us choose the coordinates such that @xmath588 points along the @xmath589-axis and @xmath590 lies in the @xmath591-plane .
then the momentum transfer @xmath592 also lies in the same plane .
its components are given by @xmath593 where : @xmath594 the components of @xmath595 can be written in the form @xmath596 .
then the angle between the vectors @xmath595 and @xmath592 is given by @xmath597 using energy - momentum conservation we can express @xmath587 in terms of this angle and the integration variables : @xmath598{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that for @xmath599 the difference under the square root in eq . can become negative for some angles .
this means that such scattering angles are forbidden kinematically and should not be integrated over . since eq .
implicitly depends on @xmath600 it is convenient to use this angle as an integration variable instead of @xmath54 . the integration measure in eq .
is then modified according to @xmath601 . to calculate the scattering amplitudes we need the three mandelstam variables .
@xmath53 is an integration variable .
@xmath54 is given by @xmath602 the remaining one , @xmath88 , can be inferred from the mandelstam relation @xmath603 .
the generalized optical theorem is a consequence of the unitarity of the @xmath43-matrix and can be seen as a consistency condition for the amplitudes to ensure conservation of probability .
it can also be seen as a consequence of the cutkosky cutting rules @xcite for the computation of the discontinuities of feynman diagrams . as such
it can be applied to unstable particles at any given order of perturbation theory .
we may write it as @xmath604=\nonumber\\ & = \sum_{i}\left ( \prod_{i_l } \int { { { \,d}\pi^{}_{i_l}}}\right)(2\pi)^4{\delta(\sum_j k_j -\sum_{i_l } q_{i_l})}\nonumber\\ & \times{{\mathcal{m}}_{{a}\rightarrow{i}}}(\{k_i\},\{q_{i_l}\}){{\mathcal{m}}_{{b}\rightarrow{i}}}^*(\{p_i\},\{q_{i_l}\}){{\ , .}}\label{eqn : generalized optical theorem}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the amplitudes @xmath605 include all contributing diagrams ( at a given order of perturbation theory ) and the sum on the right - hand side is over all possible real intermediate states @xmath382 which contribute to @xmath605 .
the generalized optical theorem can be exploited to see explicitly why the ris subtraction works .
scattering at @xmath606 .
the cuts through the internal lepton and higgs lines yield the @xmath436 , @xmath526 and @xmath437-contributions to @xmath76 .
the cuts through single internal majorana lines yield the interference terms which contribute to the _ cp_-violating parameter .
[ fig : gneral diagram bb - bb ] ] to this end , we apply it to the forward scattering processes @xmath607 and @xmath608 , see fig.[fig : gneral diagram bb - bb ] , above the energy thresholds @xmath609 ( the contribution by @xmath410 real intermediate states etc . can be addressed analogously ) and @xmath610 .
we include all possible graphs up to @xmath606 .
furthermore , we sum eq . over all internal degrees of freedom of initial and final states and absorb these in the ` effective amplitudes ' defined in section[conventionalapproach ] .
we get for the process involving particles @xmath611 the amplitudes squared on the right - hand side contain the relevant graphs including the vertex and self - energy contributions , see fig.[treevertexself ] , whose interference terms lead to _ cp_-violation in the particle decay . in the same way one finds for @xmath612 : @xmath613 as a consequence of _ cpt _ we have @xmath614 .
therefore the difference of the left - hand sides of eqs . and as well as that of the third terms on the right - hand - sides vanish .
subtracting the right - hand sides we obtain @xmath615=\nonumber\\ & -\int { { { \,d}\pi^{{n}_1}_{{q}}}}(2\pi)^4{\delta({k}+{p}-{q } ) } \big [ { \xi^{}_{{{\ell}}{\phi}\rightarrow{n}_1 } } - { \xi^{}_{\bar{{{\ell}}}\bar{{\phi}}\rightarrow{n}_1}}\big ] , \label{eqn : generalized optical theorem applied at order four difference}\end{aligned}\ ] ] as a requirement for a consistent approximation of the amplitudes compatible with unitarity and _ cpt_. it is obvious that this can not be satisfied if the scattering amplitudes are in tree - level approximation meanwhile the decay amplitudes violate _
cp_. we show in section[risquantstat ] how eq .
can be satisfied by replacing the two - body scattering amplitudes @xmath616 .
the solution for @xmath617 amounts to subtracting the real intermediate state contributions from @xmath8 . in order to obtain an equivalent result for the higgs decay at high temperature ( i.e. for @xmath618 ) we need to consider different processes since the amplitude @xmath619 can not be obtained as cut of the graphs in fig.[fig : gneral diagram bb - bb ] .
one could try to draw and to cut graphs for @xmath620 scattering , but the obtained cuts are lepton number conserving and would drop out in the difference @xmath621 .
instead the relevant contributions appear as ` thermal cuts ' of the @xmath54-channel contributions to @xmath622 depicted in fig.[fig : diagram bb - bb contribution ] .
scattering at @xmath606 .
due to medium effects the particles in the loop can be on - shell.[fig : diagram bb - bb contribution ] ] since they exist only at finite density we need to use finite temperature ` circling rules ' , which can be seen as a generalization of eq .
, to compute the imaginary part of causal @xmath349-point functions in the real time formalism @xcite : @xmath623 where ` not all ' means that not all @xmath624 should be circled at the same time .
it was shown in @xcite that causal @xmath349-point functions are the ones relevant for the computation of _ cp_-violating parameters .
the vertex @xmath625 with largest or smallest time is always circled .
we can use this equation together with the circling rules given in @xcite to compute the imaginary parts of the graphs in fig.[fig : diagram bb - bb contribution ] and the _ cpt_-conjugated process @xmath626 . taking the difference of both
we obtain , similar to eq . :
@xmath627=\nonumber\\ & -\int { { { \,d}\pi^{{\phi}}_{{q}}}}(2\pi)^4{\delta({k}+{p}-{q})}\big [ { \xi^{}_{{{\ell}}{n}_1\rightarrow\bar{{\phi } } } } - { \xi^{}_{\bar{{{\ell}}{n}_1}\rightarrow{\phi } } } \big]{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can also use eq . to compute the thermal widths which cutoff the @xmath53- and @xmath54-channel resonances by cutting the self - energy graphs as shown in fig.[rate through thermal cutting ]
. the thermal width can be obtained using ( causal ) finite temperature cutting rules . ] furthermore , the thermal _ cp_-violating parameters can be obtained using thermal cutting rules , see e.g. fig.[fig : selfenergy loop corrections imaginary part causal products ] and @xmath628 can not be on - shell simultaneously for @xmath629 .
contributions by graphs ( c - e ) are suppressed if the cut is through an internal majorana neutrino line.[fig : selfenergy loop corrections imaginary part causal products],title="fig : " ] + and @xmath628 can not be on - shell simultaneously for @xmath629 .
contributions by graphs ( c - e ) are suppressed if the cut is through an internal majorana neutrino line.[fig : selfenergy loop corrections imaginary part causal products],title="fig : " ] and @xmath628 can not be on - shell simultaneously for @xmath629 .
contributions by graphs ( c - e ) are suppressed if the cut is through an internal majorana neutrino line.[fig : selfenergy loop corrections imaginary part causal products],title="fig : " ] and @xcite .
altogether , the concept of ris subtraction can be generalized to include quantum - statistical effects using thermal quantum field theory in the real time formalism and a complete set of reaction densities can be computed .
note however that inconsistencies are inherent out of equilibrium and arise e.g. at higher order in the expansion performed in section[rateequations ] .
similar computations where performed in @xcite in the imaginary time formalism of thermal quantum field theory .
in this appendix we present some detailed intermediate steps in the derivation of rate equations with quantum - statistical terms . to obtain
these we need to assume that the system is close to thermal equilibrium . under certain conditions
it is then possible to reduce boltzmann - like equations to a set of rate equations for the systems evolution . assuming that the detailed conditions given in section[rateequations ] are fulfilled and using eq .
, we get for the integrated boltzmann equations with quantum - statistical terms : @xmath630 \\ = \int { { { \,d}\pi_{{n}_i{{\ell}}{\phi}}^{{{q}}{{r}}{{k } } } } } ( 2\pi)^4\,{\delta({{q}}-{{r}}-{{k } } ) } \big\ { \pm & { \xi^{}_{{n}_i\rightleftarrows{{\ell}}{\phi } } } ( 1-{f^{}_{{{\ell}}}})(1+{f^{}_{{\phi}}})\big [ \frac{{f^{}_{{n}_i } } -{{f}_{{n}_i}^{eq}}}{{(1-{f^{}_{{n}_i}})}{{f}_{{n}_i}^{eq } } } - ( e^{+\frac{\mu_{{{\ell}}}+\mu_{{\phi}}}{t}}-1)\big]\nonumber\\ - & { \xi^{}_{{n}_i\rightleftarrows\bar{{\ell}}\bar{\phi } } } ( 1-{f^{}_{\bar{{{\ell}}}}})(1+{f^{}_{\bar{{\phi } } } } ) \big [ \frac{{f^{}_{{n}_i } } -{{f}_{{n}_i}^{eq}}}{{(1-{f^{}_{{n}_i}})}{{f}_{{n}_i}^{eq } } } - ( e^{-\frac{\mu_{{{\ell}}}+\mu_{{\phi}}}{t}}-1)\big]\big\ } { ( 1-{f^{}_{{n}_i } } ) } \frac{{{f}_{{n}_i}^{eq}}}{{(1-{{f}_{{n}_i}^{eq}})}}{{\ , .}}\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] this expression is still exact with respect to deviations from equilibrium and , taking into account results before eq . , it has an obvious expansion in @xmath145 .
we can see that there will be contributions proportional to @xmath631 , to @xmath145 and proportional to @xmath632 at linear order .
the coefficients of these terms were introduced in section[rateequations ] ( eqs . and ) and dubbed reaction densities .
we find for the @xmath633 expansion of each of the two terms in eq .
, i.e. for the general collision term of @xmath634 in eq .
: @xmath635 where we defined the decay reaction densities as @xmath636 with @xmath637 . for a general process @xmath503 ( where we allow again for deviations from equilibrium in @xmath504 ) we find in the same way : @xmath638 where @xmath639 with , now , @xmath640 .
note that these reaction densities will tend to zero in the zero temperature limit because of their dependence on the distribution functions . using the general result
we obtain the contributions to eq . , and therefore to eq . ,
proportional to @xmath529 , @xmath641 contributions proportional to @xmath186 , @xmath642 or just proportional to @xmath187 : @xmath643 this leads immediately to the result in eq .. similarly , we get using eq . for the contributions by ( anti-)higgs decay to the rate equations : @xmath644 in addition we get for the extra terms in eqs . and : @xmath645 this means that for @xmath646 only the first term and for @xmath133 the last two terms contribute .
the terms proportional to the difference of @xmath647 and @xmath648 lead to contributions proportional to the _ cp_-violating parameter . to reduce the two - body scattering terms in eq .
we can use the same methods to find for the general expression , @xmath649{{\ , , } } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the @xmath633 expansion : @xmath650\nonumber\\ = & \frac{\mu_c + \mu_d \pm ( \mu_a + \mu_b)}{t}\langle\gamma^{ab}_{ij}\rangle + ( 1\pm 1)\langle\gamma^{ab}_{ij}\rangle\nonumber\\ - & ( 1\pm 1)\langle ( \xi_a\frac{\mu_a}{t}{{f}_{a}^{eq}}+\xi_b\frac{\mu_b}{t}{{f}_{b}^{eq}}-\xi_i\frac{\mu_i}{t}{{f}_{i}^{eq}}-\xi_j\frac{\mu_j}{t}{{f}_{j}^{eq}})\gamma^{ab}_{ij}\rangle{{\ , , } } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the two - body scattering reaction density was introduced in eq .. the last expression results after first order expansion in @xmath145 .
in this appendix we derive one - loop contribution to the self - energy of the majorana field as well as one and two - loop contributions to the self - energy of leptons .
the 2pi effective action is defined as a functional of the one- and two - point functions consisting of an infinite sum of all 2pi vacuum diagrams @xcite . in practice
, its expansion can be characterized in terms of the number of loops appearing in each diagram : @xmath651=\sum_{n } i\gamma_{2{\ensuremath{\,\mathrm{pi}}}}^{(n)}[{s^{}_{}},{\mathscr{s}^{}_{}},{\delta^{}_{}}]{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the two lowest order contributions , @xmath652 and @xmath653 , relevant for leptogenesis are shown in fig.[fig:2pi contributions ] .
their contributions to the 2pi action read [ 2picontrib ] @xmath654{{\ , , } } \hphantom{aa}\\ \label{g3 } i\gamma_{2{\ensuremath{\,\mathrm{pi}}}}^{(3)}= & \frac{1}{2}\int_{\cal c } d^4u\ d^4w\ d^4\eta\ d^4\xi \ { { \rm tr}}\big[h p_r { \mathscr{s}^{}_{}}(u , w)\nonumber\\ & \times cp_r h^t { s^{t}_{}}(\eta , w)\epsilon { \delta^{*}_{}}(w,\xi)\epsilon h^ * p_lc \nonumber\\ & \times { \mathscr{s}^{}_{}}(\eta,\xi)p_l h^{\dagger } { s^{}_{}}(\xi , u)\ \epsilon { \delta^{*}_{}}(u,\eta ) \epsilon \big]{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in eq .
the trace is taken over flavor , dirac and @xmath21 indices whereas the transposition only acts in flavor and dirac space . by functional differentiation of the 2pi
effective action with respect to the two - point function we obtain the corresponding self - energy which enters the schwinger - dyson equation : @xmath655}{\delta { s^{\ , t}_{\beta \alpha}}(y , x)}{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , flavor indices are shown explicitly whereas the @xmath21 and dirac structure is embodied implicitly in matrix notation . the resulting self - energy is given by a combination of the majorana , lepton and higgs propagators . since we do not consider the flavor effects and the early universe was in an @xmath21-symmetric state : @xmath656 since @xmath657 the lepton self - energy also becomes diagonal : @xmath658 .
furthermore , in the unflavored approximation it is convenient to sum over lepton flavors : @xmath659
. then the one- and two - loop order contributions to the lepton self - energy , see fig.[fig:2pi contributions ] , take the form : @xmath660 eventually , it is the wightman components that we are interested in since they enter the gain- and loss terms on the right - hand side of eq .. therefore , we insert the usual decomposition of the propagators @xmath661 into the spectral and statistical parts , eq . , into the self - energies and . a formal decomposition of the self - energy in analogy to allows us to identify its spectral and statistical part and define the wightman components in coordinate space as @xmath662 . for the one - loop self - energy they read @xmath663 in the case of the two - loop contribution , eq . , the computation becomes slightly elaborate .
the complication is due to the appearance of 32 different terms after inserting the decomposition for each of the five propagators into eq . as well as due to the two remaining integrations over the internal space - time arguments @xmath664 and @xmath665 .
the decomposition makes the path - ordering explicit and allows us to convert the integration along the ctp into an integration along the positive branch .
the 32 terms contain different combinations of the @xmath666-functions .
these can be rewritten by using relations given in appendix c of @xcite . after some simple but lengthy algebra we obtain for the wightman components : @xmath667{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] specific approximations will allow us to interpret both expressions , eq . and
, as describing decay , inverse decay and scattering processes of quasiparticles in the medium . the expressions for the one- and two - loop self - energies given by eqs .
and depend explicitly on two coordinates in four dimensional space - time
. however , the self - energies which govern the gain- and loss term on the right - hand side of eq . are expressed in terms of phase space coordinates .
let us therefore exchange the pair of space - time arguments @xmath668 for an equivalent set of center and relative coordinates , @xmath669 and @xmath670 .
in contrast to thermal equilibrium , the out of equilibrium propagators depend not only on the relative coordinate @xmath53 but also on the center coordinate @xmath183 . performing a so - called wigner transformation @xcite , i.e. a fourier transformation with respect to the relative coordinate @xmath53 , we can trade the latter for a momentum space variable : [ wt ] @xmath671 where we have used @xmath672 and @xmath673 , @xmath674 according to the various combinations appearing in eqs . and .
note that the factor @xmath675 in the definition is conventional and makes the wigner transform of the spectral propagator a hermitian matrix .
definitions of the wigner transforms of the advanced and retarded propagators coincide with that for the statistical propagator .
the wigner transform of eq .
is obtained straightforwardly : @xmath676 note that motivated by the homogeneity and isotropy of the early universe we only indicate time - dependence of the propagators and self - energy , @xmath677 . to obtain the wigner transform of eq .
we will use an additional approximation : each of the wigner transforms of the propagators we replace by @xmath678 .
this means that we neglect the variations of @xmath679 from the center coordinate @xmath680 at which the self - energy is evaluated .
technically , it corresponds to a gradient expansion to lowest order and therefore disregards all memory effects .
this can be compared to the ` stozahlansatz ' within the usual approach to the boltzmann equation .
it is convenient to represent the resulting expression as a sum of three terms : @xmath681 the first term on the right - hand side of eq
. corresponds to the wigner transform of lines one to three and four to six in eq . :
@xmath682\nonumber { { \ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have introduced two functions containing loop corrections : @xmath683{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath684 .
as we will see , describes _
cp_-violating decay of the heavy majorana neutrino .
the second term on the right - hand side of eq .
is given by the wigner transform of the seventh line of eq . and describes lepton number violating scattering processes : @xmath685{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally the last term in eq .
corresponds to the last line of eq .
, @xmath686{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and can be identified with lepton number conserving processes which do not contribute to generation of the lepton asymmetry .
differentiating eq .
with respect to the two - point function of the majorana neutrino and using definitions of the _ cp_-conjugate two - point functions we obtain for the majorana self - energy @xmath687{{\ , , } } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have assumed the @xmath21 symmetry of the medium and neglected flavor effects .
the factor @xmath22 in eq . comes from the summation over the @xmath21 indices .
conjugate self - energy differs from eq . only in the propagators replaced by their _
conjugate counterparts and the couplings replaced by their complex conjugates . from eq .
we can read off the wightman components of the self - energy : @xmath688{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] its _ cp_-conjugate can be obtained by complex conjugating the couplings and replacing the two - point functions by their _ cp_-conjugates . to calculate amplitudes of the scattering processes
we will need its wigner transform : @xmath689 { { \ , .}}\hphantom{aaaa}\end{aligned}\ ] ] from eq .
we can deduce the wigner transform of the corresponding spectral self - energy : @xmath690{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have introduced @xmath691{{\ , , } } \\ { \pi^{}_{\rho}}(t,{{q } } ) & \equiv 16\pi{\textstyle\int}{{\,d}\pi^4_{{{k } } } } { { \,d}\pi^4_{{{r } } } } ( 2\pi)^4{\delta({{q}}-{{k}}-{{r}})}\nonumber\\ & \times p\bigl[{\bar{\delta}^{}_{f}}(t,{{k}}){\bar{s}^{}_{\rho}}(t,{{r } } ) + { \bar{\delta}^{}_{\rho}}(t,{{k } } ) { \bar{s}^{}_{f}}(t,{{r}})\bigr]p{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath692 . in the quasiparticle approximation
the wigner transforms of the two - point functions of leptons and the higgs are given by eqs. and eqs. respectively . in a _
cp_-symmetric medium , which the early universe was to a very good approximation , @xmath693 and @xmath694 .
the homogeneity and isotropy of the early universe furthermore imply , that there is no dependence on the momentum direction and the spatial central coordinate so that @xmath695 and @xmath696 . just like for scalars , in a _
cp_-symmetric medium the fermion two - point functions are related by @xmath697 and @xmath698 . as for the @xmath699 transformation , the terms in the lepton propagators which carry spinor structure are not invariant under it : @xmath700 since @xmath701 , eq .
implies that in a homogeneous , isotropic and _ cp_-symmetric medium @xmath702 and @xmath703 are left and right projections of the same ` vector ' integral @xmath704 : @xmath705 l_{\rho}{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] explicit form of @xmath371 depends on the kinematic regime and is presented below . to evaluate the decay amplitudes as well as amplitudes of the @xmath53-channel scattering processes we need to evaluate it for positive @xmath360 and @xmath706 .
if @xmath707 is also positive then @xmath371 takes the form : @xmath708{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] to obtain eq .
we have used the quasiparticle approximation for the two - point functions and integrated over the zeroth components of the momenta . integrating out the energy - momentum conserving delta - function we obtain for its lorentz components : [ sigmavtherm ] @xmath709{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ]
where @xmath710 and @xmath711 .
the integral functions @xmath712 are defined by @xmath713 where , in complete analogy with eq .
, the integration limits are given by @xmath714{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for positive @xmath369 and negative @xmath715 the components of @xmath371 are related to the ones above by @xmath716 and @xmath717 respectively .
to evaluate amplitudes of the @xmath54- and @xmath88-channel processes we also need to calculate @xmath371 for negative square of the momentum transfer . in this case momentum - energy conservation
ensures that @xmath718 and @xmath719 can not be positive or negative simultaneously .
if they have different signs then , assuming homogeneity and isotropy of the medium and using relations , we find @xmath720\nonumber\\ + & { \delta({{q}}-{{k}}+{{r}})}[f_{\phi}(t,{{k } } ) + f_{\bar{{\ell}}}(t,{{r}})]\bigr\}{{\ , .}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] eq .
implies that for negative square of the momentum transfer @xmath371 vanishes in vacuum .
although it is in principle possible to retain the thermal masses of leptons and the higgs in the calculation , the resulting expressions are quite lengthy in this case . neglecting the thermal masses we obtain for the lorentz components of @xmath371 in this regime : [ lrhonegmom ] @xmath721{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the integral functions are given by @xmath722 note that in this regime @xmath723 and therefore the lower integration limit is positive . to compute the scattering amplitude we need to calculate the product @xmath724
for the @xmath53-channel we find : @xmath725 whereas the corresponding expression for the @xmath54- and @xmath88-channels reads @xmath726 at low temperatures eq . is exponentially small and vanishes in the vacuum limit . to analyze the higgs decay we need to evaluate the spectral loop integral in a region of the phase space where the effective higgs mass exceeds the sum of the majorana and lepton masses .
using properties of the distribution functions under the @xmath727 transformation we find after some algebra from eq . :
@xmath728.\end{aligned}\ ] ] just like in eq .
, the integration is over the ( on - shell ) momenta of the higgs and lepton and the majorana momentum serves as a constraint .
note that in this case we are interested only in the on - shell majorana momenta and therefore @xmath360 . after integrating out the delta - function
we obtain a result similar to eq .
: @xmath729{{\ , , } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the integral function is defined as : @xmath730 the integration limits are given by an expression similar to eq .
but with @xmath731 replaced by @xmath732 . when the effective higgs mass approaches the kinematic limit , @xmath733 the upper integration limit approaches the lower one , and the integral vanishes
to perform the quantitative analysis we need to specify the yukawa couplings . for simplicity
we focus on the case of a very heavy third majorana neutrino @xmath734 ( msm ) . in this limit
the yukawa couplings can be expressed in terms of the observed active neutrino masses and mixing angles and only one complex additional free parameter @xmath735 .
where @xmath740 gev is the higgs vev and we have assumed normal hierarchy . in this case
the physical neutrino masses are given by @xmath741 for illustration we choose the benchmark points @xmath742 and @xmath743 denoted by bm1 and bm2 in the plots .
as masses of the right - handed neutrinos we choose @xmath744 gev and @xmath745 respectively .
this choice of parameters is such that effects related to the resonant enhancement will be unimportant but contributions from both heavy majorana neutrinos can be relevant .
note however that there are lower bounds on the washout parameters @xmath746 ( with ` equilibrium neutrino mass ' @xmath747 ) , see figs.[m1tildevsreomegaimomega ] and [ m2tildevsreomegaimomega ] .
the freeze - out of the asymmetry will therefore typically occur late ( i.e. @xmath752 ) which renders medium effects in general small .
however for the qualitative issues discussed in this paper our preference is to specify a consistent set of parameters for which we can discuss the generation of the lepton asymmetry in terms of two heavy majorana neutrinos .
this is of course not a general restriction for the employed techniques . | in this work we study thermal leptogenesis using non - equilibrium quantum field theory . starting from fundamental equations for correlators of the quantum fields we describe the steps necessary to obtain quantum kinetic equations for quasiparticles .
these can easily be compared to conventional results and overcome conceptional problems inherent in the canonical approach . beyond _
cp_-violating decays we include also those scattering processes which are tightly related to the decays in a consistent approximation of fourth order in the yukawa couplings .
it is demonstrated explicitly how the s - matrix elements for the scattering processes in the conventional approach are related to two- and three - loop contributions to the effective action .
we derive effective decay and scattering amplitudes taking medium corrections and thermal masses into account . in this context
we also investigate _
cp_-violating higgs decay within the same formalism . from the kinetic equations we derive rate equations for the lepton asymmetry improved in that they include quantum - statistical effects and medium corrections to the quasiparticle properties . |
most biopolymers , such as rnas @xcite , proteins @xcite and genomic dna @xcite , are found in folded configurations .
folding involves the formation of one or more intramolecular interactions , termed contacts .
proper folding of these molecules is often necessary for their function .
intensive efforts have been made to measure the geometric and topological properties of protein and rna folds , and to find generic relations between those properties and molecular function , dynamics and evolution @xcite .
likewise , topological properties of synthetic molecules have been subject to intense research , and their significance for polymer chemistry @xcite and physics @xcite has been widely recognized .
topology is a mathematical term , which is used to describe the properties of objects that remain unchanged under continuous deformation @xcite .
different approaches have been discussed in the literature to describe the topology of branched @xcite or knotted polymers @xcite . however , many important biopolymers , such as proteins and nucleic acids , are unknotted linear chains .
the circuit topology approach has recently been introduced to characterize the folded configuration of linear polymers .
circuit topology of a linear chain elucidates generically the arrangement of intra - chain contacts of a folded - chain configuration @xcite ( see fig . [ fig1 ] ) .
the arrangement of the contacts has been shown to be a determinant of the folding rates and unfolding pathways of biomolecules , @xcite and has important implications for bimolecular evolution and molecular engineering @xcite .
topology characterization and sorting of polymers has been the subject of intense research in recent years ; bulk purification of theta - shaped and three - armed star polymers is performed using chromatography @xcite ; linear and circular dna are separated in nano - grooves embedded in a nano - slit @xcite ; and star - branched polymers with different number of arms are shown to travel with different speeds through a nano - channel @xcite . in the context of characterization , linear and circular dna molecules are probed by confining them in a nano - channel and using fluorescence microscopy @xcite . we know
little about how to sort folded linear polymers based on topology .
this is in contrast to size sorting of folded linear polymers which has been studied extensively in the literature @xcite .
nano - pore technology represents a versatile tool for single - molecule studies and biosensing .
a typical setting involves a voltage difference across the nano - pore in an ionic solution containing the desired molecule .
the ion current through the nano - pore decreases as the molecule enters the pore .
the level of current reduction and its duration reveals information about the molecule @xcite . prior to the current project
, different properties of nucleic acids and proteins have been studied using nano - pore technology , for example : dna sequencing @xcite , unzipping of nucleic acids @xcite , protein detection @xcite , unfolding of proteins @xcite , and interactions between nucleic acids and proteins @xcite . in our study , we used simple models of polymer chains and molecular dynamic simulations to determine how the circuit topology of a chain influences its passage through a nano - pore .
we investigated whether nano - pores can be used for topology - based sorting and characterization of folded chains .
two scenarios were considered : ( 1 ) passage through pores large enough to permit the chain to pass through without breaking its contacts , and ( 2 ) passage of chains through small nano - pores , during which contacts were ripped apart . in the first scenario ,
nano - pore technology enabled purification of chains with certain topologies and allowed us to read the topology of a folded molecule as it passed through the pore . in the second scenario
, we used the nano - pore to read the circuit topology of a single fold .
we also asked if translocation time and chain topology are correlated .
this technology has been subject to intense research for simple - structured polynucleotides @xcite ; however , the current study is the first to use nano - pores to systematically measure contact arrangements of folded molecules @xcite ( fig . [ fig1 ] ) .
the polymer is modeled by beads connected by fene bonds @xmath0 $ ] .
@xmath1 and @xmath2 are the strength and the maximum extension of the bonds , respectively .
the fene potential is used to eliminate unrealistic extension of the bonds due to the pulling event . the short - range repulsive interaction between monomers
is taken into account by the shifted - truncated lennard - jones potential @xmath3 $ ] at @xmath4 .
@xmath5 is the energy scale of the simulations .
@xmath6 is the monomer size and the length scale of the simulations .
all simulations were performed by espresso @xcite as detailed below .
initially , the first monomer is fixed inside the nano - pore .
after the whole polymer is equilibrated , the first monomer is unfixed and force , @xmath7 , is applied to pull it through the nano - pore . for pore diameters smaller than two monomers , passage of
the polymer inevitably leads to breakage of the contacts . in this case
, the bond between the contact sites is replaced with a simple lennard - jones potential @xmath8 $ ] after equilibration .
the depth of the attraction well , @xmath9 , is a measure of the strength of the bond between the contact sites .
number of passed monomers and position of the first monomer versus time are studied in simulations .
these quantities are averaged over different realizations . for longer passages ,
the averages are again window - averaged over intervals equal to 10 time units .
window - averaging is used to reduce the data points and the noise in the plots . to minimize the effect of determinants other than topology
, we take equal spacing , @xmath10 , between the contact sites ( connected monomers ) and two tails on the sides equal to the spacings .
the total length of the polymer is @xmath11 . if the monomers are numbered consecutively from one end , then
, the position of the contact sites along the chain would be @xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath14 and @xmath15 .
the spacing is taken equal to 12 monomers , unless otherwise stated .
some chains become knotted when the bonds are formed in the chain or when the chain is pulled suddenly with a strong force .
passage times of these knotted chains are extremely long .
the data related to these unusual passages is removed before averaging .
consider translocation of 2-contact chains through a nano - pore with an internal diameter equal to @xmath16 .
first we assume contacts are permanent and unbreakable .
two different strengths for the pulling force , @xmath17 and @xmath18 , are examined .
50 realizations are performed for each of the three topologies ( fig . [ fig1](a ) ) and the two forces . the average number of monomers passed through the nano - pore versus time is shown in figs . [ fig2](a ) and [ fig2](b ) .
shoulders in the curves correspond to pauses during the passage of the polymer when the contacts encounter the nano - pore .
we first examine the passage dynamics under stronger force , @xmath19 ( fig . [ fig2](a ) ) .
one shoulder is observed during the passages of the cross and the parallel topologies , while the series topology is markedly different with two clear shoulders during its passage .
the average number of passed monomers at the shoulders coincides with the position of the contact sites ( shown with horizontal lines in the plot ) .
this confirms interpretation of the shoulders as the pauses related to the passage of the contacts . the average number of monomers inside the nano - pore versus time is also significantly different for the series topology ( inset of fig . [ fig2](a ) ) .
two distinct peaks are observed for the series topology , while only one peak is seen for the cross and the parallel topologies .
the peaks in the inset plot occur simultaneously with the shoulders in the main plot
. force has a dramatic effect on the passage dynamics of chains .
[ fig2](b ) plots the average number of monomers passed through the nano - pore versus time under @xmath17 . here
, the maximum passage time for the chain with parallel topology is larger relative to other topologies , while the one with the series topology had the largest maximum passage time under the stronger force . by reducing the force
, the passage time gets much longer and the entropic effects become dominant . as a result , the shoulders in the number of passed monomers are not as clear as before .
one shoulder is observed for all topologies at the position of the first contact site .
two other shoulders are observed during the passage of the chain with parallel contact arrangemenet .
the second shoulder corresponds to the time when the large loop of the chain is midway inside the nano - pore .
furthermore , the third shoulder is due to the second contact and the pause caused by the entropy of the second small loop in the parallel topology ( shown schematically in the inset ) .
additionally , two peaks are seen in the time profile of the average number of monomers inside the nano - pore .
these peaks appear simultaneously with the described shoulders in the time profile of the number of passed monomers ( inset of fig . [ fig2](b ) ) .
we note that the first and the third shoulders are also seen in the average position of the first monomer versus time ( fig .
s2 ) . and ( b ) @xmath17 .
the shoulders correspond to pauses in the passage process and can be used to read the chain topology .
the series topology shows two shoulders under the strong force ( a ) and the parallel topology shows three shoulders under the weak force ( b ) .
insets : average number of monomers inside the nano - pore versus time .
the peaks in the inset plots occur at the same time with the shoulders in the main plots .
schematics shows the parallel topology and the arrow points to the smaller loop .
entropy of the smaller loop causes the last pause in the passage of the parallel topology under the weak force . ]
the results show that it is possible to distinguish the series and parallel from other topologies using nano - pores with strong and weak forces , respectively .
the number of passed monomers and the number of monomers inside the nano - pore can be readily measured in experiments .
the former can be measured by pulling the end of the polymer using optical tweezers @xcite , while the latter is readable by measuring the ion current through the nano - pore .
the ion current has been shown to take discrete values with the number of monomers in the nano - pore @xcite . finally , the maximum passage time in each pulling force is also different for the three topologies and can be used alternatively for identifying the topology of a 2-contact unbreakable chain . to generalize the obtained results to molecules of various sizes ( chain lengths ) ,
we investigate the passage of a chain with two unbreakable contacts and double spacing between the contact sites under weak and strong pulling forces .
position of the shoulders and the peaks are in agreement with the above descriptions ( fig .
also , it is seen that the maximum passage time is longer for the series topology under the strong force and for the parallel topology under the weak force .
( see esi section 1 ) next , we consider folded molecules with more than two intramolecular contacts .
nano - pores of various sizes are needed to pass these complex unbreakable topologies under usual pulling forces .
this gives the opportunity to use the nano - pore for purifying topologies or for enrichment of a certain topology from a mixture of different topologies .
to test this idea , we examine the passage of 3-contact chains through a pore with an internal diameter equal to @xmath16 under the pulling force @xmath19 .
there are 15 topologically different configurations for a 3-contact chain . among these ,
three configurations have two parallel relations in their topologies , shown in fig 1(b ) .
two of them ( among all 15 configurations ) do not pass the nano - pore in usual time intervals .
this is in agreement with the expectation that chains with a higher number of parallel topologies tend to interlock more , and do not pass through smaller pores .
the three chains shown in fig .
[ fig1](b ) behave similarly when they enter the nano - pore from either end .
this means that the chain direction is not important in purifying the topologies using a nano - pore . .
for the smaller nano - pores , 150 random configurations are averaged . however , up to 700 random configurations are tested for the nano - pores with @xmath20 .
all the chains can pass through the nano - pore when the nano - pore diameter is larger than or equal to @xmath21 . ]
we then extended the simulations to 5-contact chains as a representation of real chains with increasing complexities .
there are ( 2 * 5 - 1)!!=1500 topologically different configurations for a 5-contact chain , so we chose configurations at random and passed them through the nano - pore under the pulling force @xmath19 .
the chains are examined to see whether they pass through the nano - pore in a reasonable time .
a first - order measure of the circuit topology of a chain is the number of contact pairs that are in series , cross , or parallel arrangements .
3 shows the average numbers of the three topological arrangements versus the internal diameter of the nano - pore , @xmath22 , for chains that pass and do not pass through the nano - pore .
the average number of series topology is higher in the passed chains compared to the chains that do not pass .
the average number of parallel topology is smaller in the passed chains , for pore diameters smaller than four times the monomer size .
average number of cross topology is smaller for passed chains . in a realistic setting , when a mixture of randomly connected chains are allowed to pass through a nano - pore ( smaller than @xmath23 ) , we predict that the flow through would be enriched in series topology .
however , the fraction of the mixture that fails to pass through the pore would contain chains with high number of parallel and cross topologies .
this can be justified by the fact that in parallel and cross topologies , the contact sites are relatively far from each other along the chain .
thus , chains with a high number of contacts with parallel and cross arrangements are bulkier and have more interlocking configurations .
in contrast , in series topology , the contacts are local and do not connect distant points along the chain . as a result , the chains with a high number of contacts with series arrangements are more extended in configuration and can pass through the nano - pore more easily .
as it is evident from our study , the excluded volume interaction is the main deriving force behind separation in a narrow nano - pore ; this interaction has not been considered in previous theoretical works @xcite . finally , simulations with a four times stronger pulling force @xmath24 shows that no purification is possible under higher forces even with the smallest nano - pore , @xmath25 , reflecting the importance of tuning the applied force to its optimal values .
there are two parameters that determine the time needed for the passage of a chain coupled to bond breakup ; the bond strength and the pulling force .
we first studied pulling of 2-contact chains through a nano - pore with internal diameter equal to @xmath26 , under a force comparable to the bond strength ( see esi section 2 for a theoretical description ) .
for very weak bonds , with a bond strength equal to @xmath27 , the contacts break before reaching the pore .
this is due to the tension propagated along the chain from the pulled end @xcite . for medium to strong bonds between @xmath28 , it is possible to see shoulders in the time profile of the position of the first monomer , using suitable pulling forces ( figs .
4(a ) and 4(b ) ) . for shoulders
to become prominent , a large pulling force is required to dominate the entropic fluctuations . however
, it should not be too strong to completely eliminate the effect of topology .
as the leading end of the chain is stretched completely with large pulling forces , the shoulders can be used to find position of the contact sites along the chain ( horizontal lines in figs .
4(a ) and 4(b ) ) . and @xmath29 .
the pulling force should be chosen carefully : large enough to minimize the effect of entropy but not too large to eliminate the effect of topology .
the shoulders are due to the pauses at the contact sites .
position of the shoulders can give information about the position of the connected monomers along the chain ( horizontal lines ) .
insets : position of the contact sites can not be tracked in smaller pulling forces . ] for large forces , there is no difference between the passage times of the three topologies .
the difference increases by decreasing the pulling force . for very weak forces , however , the entropic effects become significant and hide the effect of topology on the translocation time . moreover , the simulation time becomes very large and simulations ( experiments ) are not cost - effective .
the results indicate that moderately weak forces can be used to discriminate the three topologies . for this purpose ,
we calculate the average passage times of the three topologies using a suitable pulling force ( considering the bond strength ) .
then , the maximum and the minimum average passage time is found among the three topologies . figs . [ fig5](a ) and [ fig5](b ) show the topologies that have the minimum and the maximum of the average passage times , respectively .
we note that changing the dataset used for averaging does not alter the order of the average passage times of the three topologies for all bond strengths and the corresponding suitable forces ( fig .
s7 and table s1 ) .
therefore , the average translocation time can be regarded as a tool for reading the chain topology .
( see esi section 3 ) to generalize our findings , we investigate translocation of 5-contact chains to find a correlation between topology of the chain and its average passage time . in three sets of simulations , one of the cross , parallel , and series relations
is taken to be dominant in the topology of the chain , meaning that the majority of the contact pairs have the dominant arrangement .
we call such states as pure states .
more specifically , 8 out of 10 total binary relations are taken the same ; however , the numbers of the other two relations are not determined .
the average passage time in each set is calculated over 150 randomly chosen chains that fulfill the mentioned conditions ; @xmath30 , @xmath31 or @xmath32 . for each bond energy and pulling force , we also calculate the average passage time for a fourth set which contains 150 completely random chains .
again , we calculate the average passage times for the three pure states
. then , the maximum and the minimum passage times are found between the three sets .
pure states that have the maximum and the minimum of the average passage times are shown in figs . [ fig5](c ) and [ fig5](d ) .
extremely large passage times , which occur due to chain knotting , are removed from the data prior to averaging .
the order of the average passage time among pure states does not depend on the data set used , while the data set contains enough data points ( table s2 ) .
this shows that the dominant topology in pure states can be recognized by using the passage time through a nano - pore .
( see esi section 4 )
in summary , we studied translocation of folded polymers through nano - pores using molecular dynamics simulations .
we found settings that are required for a nano - pore setup to be able to read and sort molecules based on their molecular topology .
we showed that nano - pores can be used to efficiently enrich certain topologies from mixtures of random 5-contact chains and that this purification is not sensitive to chain orientation in the nano - pore .
we also showed that nano - pores can be used to determine the chain topology for 2-contact chains when the intact folded chains pass through the pore .
when the chain unfolds upon passing through the nano - pore , we showed that the nano - pore enables determining the position of the contacts along a 2-contact chain in large pulling forces . in this condition , by using moderate forces
, we could discriminate between pure states ( i.e. , states for which the majority of contacts were arranged identically ) by using the average passage time .
the authors thank mahdieh mikani for technical help and fatemeh ramazani for careful reading of the paper .
vakhrushev a. v. ; gorbunov a. a. ; tezuka y. ; tsuchitani a. ; oike h. liquid chromatography of theta - shaped and three - armed star poly ( tetrahydrofuran)s : theory and experimental evidence of topological separation .
chem . _ * 2008 * , 80 , 8153 - 8162 .
mikkelsen m. b. ; reisner w. ; flyvbjerg h. ; kristensen a. pressure - driven dna in nanogroove arrays : complex dynamics leads to length - and topology - dependent separation .
_ nano lett . _ * 2011 * , 11 , 1598 - 1602 .
dorfman k. d. ; king s. b. ; olson d. w. ; thomas j. d. ; tree d. r. beyond gel electrophoresis : microfluidic separations , fluorescence burst analysis , and dna stretching .
rev . _ * 2012 * , 113 , 2584 - 2667 . oukhaled g. ; mathe j. ; biance a. l. ; bacri l. ; betton j. m. ; lairez d. ; pelta j. ; auvray l. unfolding of proteins and long transient conformations detected by single nano - pore recording . _
lett . _ * 2007 * , 98 , 158101 .
langecker m. ; ivankin a. ; carson s. ; kinney s. r. ; simmel f. c. ; wanunu m. nano - pores suggest a negligible influence of cpg methylation on nucleosome packaging and stability .
_ nano lett . _ * 2014 * , 15 , 783 - 790 . | here we report on the translocation of folded polymers through nano - pores using molecular dynamic simulations .
two cases are studied ; one in which a folded molecule unfolds upon passage and one in which the folding remains intact as the molecule passes through the nano - pore .
the topology of a folded polymer chain is defined as the arrangement of the intramolecular contacts , known as circuit topology . in the case where intramolecular contacts remain intact ,
we show that the dynamics of passage through a nano - pore varies for molecules with differing topologies : a phenomenon that can be exploited to enrich certain topologies in mixtures .
we find that the nano - pore allows reading of topology for short chains .
moreover , when the passage is coupled with unfolding , the nano - pore enables discrimination between pure states , i.e. , states for which the majority of contacts are arranged identically . in this case , as we show here , it is also possible to read the positions of the contact sites along a chain .
our results demonstrate the applicability of nano - pore technology to characterize and sort molecules based on their topology . |
the identification of the physical mechanisms responsible for the dissipation of turbulence in the solar wind , and for the resulting heating of the solar wind plasma , remains an important and unsolved problem of heliospheric physics .
an important clue to this problem is the observed non - zero fluctuating magnetic helicity signature at scales corresponding to the dissipation range of solar wind turbulence .
@xcite first proposed the `` fluctuating '' magnetic helicity as a diagnostic of solar wind turbulence , defining the `` reduced fluctuating '' magnetic helicity spectrum derivable from observational data ( see [ sec : red ] below ) . a subsequent study
, corresponding to scales within the inertial range , found values that fluctuated randomly in sign , and suggested an interpretation that `` a substantial degree of helicity or circular polarization exists throughout the wavenumber spectrum , but the sense of polarization or handedness alternates randomly '' @xcite .
based on a study of the fluctuating magnetic helicity of solutions to the linear vlasov - maxwell dispersion relation , @xcite suggested instead that , at inertial range scales , all eigenmodes have a very small _ intrinsic _ normalized fluctuating magnetic helicity , eliminating the need to invoke an ensemble of waves with both left- and right - handed helicity to explain the observations .
subsequent higher time resolution measurements , corresponding to scales in the dissipation range , exhibited a non - zero net reduced fluctuating magnetic helicity signature , with the sign apparently correlated with the direction of the magnetic sector @xcite . assuming dominantly anti - sunward propagating waves , the study concluded that these fluctuations had right - handed helicity .
the proposed interpretation was that left - hand polarized alfvn / ion cyclotron waves were preferentially damped by cyclotron resonance with the ions , leaving undamped right - hand polarized fast / whistler waves as the dominant wave mode in the dissipation range , producing the measured net reduced fluctuating magnetic helicity .
we refer to this as the _ cyclotron damping interpretation_. a subsequent analysis of more solar wind intervals confirmed these findings for the dissipation range @xcite .
@xcite argued that a comparison of the normalized cross - helicity in the inertial range ( as a proxy for the dominant wave propagation direction in the dissipation range ) to the measured normalized reduced fluctuating magnetic helicity provides evidence for the importance of ion cyclotron damping , which would selectively remove the left - hand polarized waves from the turbulence ; using a simple rate balance calculation , they concluded that the ratio of damping by cyclotron resonant to non - cyclotron resonant dissipation mechanisms was of order unity . a recent study performing the same analysis on a much larger data set concurred with this conclusion @xcite . in this letter , we demonstrate that a dissipation range comprised of kinetic alfvn waves produces a reduced fluctuating magnetic helicity signature consistent with observations .
a dissipation range of this nature results from an anisotropic cascade to high perpendicular wavenumber with @xmath0 ; such a cascade is consistent with existing theories for low - frequency plasma turbulence @xcite , numerical simulations @xcite , and observations in the solar wind @xcite .
our results imply that no conclusions can be drawn about the importance of ion cyclotron damping in the solar wind based on the observed magnetic helicity signature alone .
the magnetic helicity is defined as the integral over the plasma volume @xmath1 , where @xmath2 is the vector potential which defines the magnetic field via @xmath3 .
this integral is an invariant of ideal magnetohydrodynamics ( mhd ) in the absence of a mean magnetic field @xcite .
@xcite chose to set aside the complications associated with the presence of a mean magnetic field , defining the _ fluctuating magnetic helicity _ by @xmath4 , where the fluctuating quantities denoted by @xmath5 do not include contributions from the mean field . modeling the turbulent magnetic field by @xmath6 in a periodic cube of plasma with volume @xmath7
, we obtain @xmath8 , where the _ fluctuating magnetic helicity density _ for each wave vector @xmath9 is defined by @xmath10 . here
@xmath11 and @xmath12 are reality conditions and @xmath13 is the complex conjugate of the fourier coefficient . specifying the coulomb gauge @xmath14 , we obtain @xmath15 where the components @xmath16 arise from the eigenfunctions of the linear wave mode .
it is easily shown that this result is invariant to rotation of the wave vector @xmath9 , along with its corresponding linear eigenfunction , about the direction of the mean magnetic field .
the _ normalized fluctuating magnetic helicity density _ is defined by @xmath17 where @xmath18 .
this normalized measure has values within the range @xmath19 $ ] , where negative values denote left - handed helicity and positive values denote right - handed helicity .
we numerically calculate @xmath20 over the @xmath21@xmath22 plane for the eigenmodes of the linear vlasov - maxwell dispersion relation @xcite for a proton and electron plasma with an isotropic maxwellian equilibrium distribution function for each species and no drift velocities ( see * ? ? ?
* for a description of the code ) .
the dispersion relation depends on five parameters @xmath23 , for ion larmor radius @xmath24 , ion plasma beta @xmath25 , ion to electron temperature ratio @xmath26 , and ion thermal velocity to the speed of light @xmath27 .
we specify plasma parameters characteristic of the solar wind at 1 au : @xmath28 , @xmath29 , and @xmath30 .
figure [ fig : mhel ] is a contour plot of @xmath20 obtained by solving for the alfvn wave root over the @xmath21@xmath22 plane , then using the complex eigenfunctions to determine @xmath20 .
the mhd regime corresponds to the lower left corner of the plot , @xmath31 and @xmath32 ; here , the alfvn wave with @xmath33 is linearly polarized with @xmath34 . as one moves up vertically on the plot to the regime @xmath35 , the solution becomes left - handed with values of @xmath36 . in this regime of nearly parallel wave vectors , the solution represents alfvn waves in the limit @xmath37 and ion cyclotron waves in the limit @xmath38 .
the linear wave mode becomes strongly damped via the ion cyclotron resonance at a value of @xmath38 @xcite .
this is precisely the behavior supporting the cyclotron damping interpretation of the measured magnetic helicity in the solar wind .
but the alfvn wave solution does not always produce left - handed magnetic helicity .
if one moves instead from the mhd regime horizontally to the right , the solution becomes right - handed with @xmath39 as @xmath40 , a behavior previously found by @xcite . in this regime of
nearly perpendicular wave vectors with @xmath41 , the solution represents alfvn waves in the limit @xmath32 and kinetic alfvn waves in the limit @xmath42 . thus ,
if the dissipation range is comprised of kinetic alfvn waves , as suggested by theories for critically balanced , low - frequency plasma turbulence @xcite , one would expect to observe a positive normalized fluctuating magnetic helicity signature in that regime .
unfortunately , due to the limitations of single - point satellite measurements , equations ( [ eq : hm ] ) and ( [ eq : sigm1 ] ) can not be used directly to calculate the fluctuating magnetic helicity from observations ; approximations must be introduced to define a related measurable quantity . in this section , we calculate the reduced fluctuating magnetic helicity density , as defined by @xcite and used by subsequent authors , for the magnetic field defined by equation ( [ eq : b ] ) , but without assuming the taylor hypothesis .
the two - point , two - time magnetic field correlation function is @xmath43 where the angle brackets specify an ensemble average , defined here by @xmath44 .
we find @xmath45 where the reality conditions ensure that this quantity is real .
we choose to sample this correlation function at a moving probe with position given by @xmath46 ; this corresponds to satellite measurements of the solar wind , where the probe is stationary and the solar wind is streaming past the probe at velocity @xmath47 .
thus , we may determine the reduced magnetic field correlation function , @xmath48 , obtaining the form @xmath49 the reduced frequency spectrum , defined by @xmath50 , is then given by @xmath51 .
\label{eq : sr}\ ] ] this demonstrates that the frequency @xmath52 of the fluctuations sampled by the moving probe is the doppler shifted frequency @xmath53 .
note that adopting the taylor hypothesis @xcite , as often done in studies of solar wind turbulence , corresponds to dropping @xmath54 in equation ( [ eq : sr ] ) .
the _ reduced fluctuating magnetic helicity density _ is defined by @xmath55/k_1 .
\label{eq : mhr}\ ] ] where the effective wavenumber is calculated from the measured frequency using @xmath56 , assuming the taylor hypothesis is satisfied @xcite , and we have chosen an orthonormal basis with direction 1 along the direction of sampling @xmath57 and directions 2 and 3 in the plane perpendicular to @xmath58 .
the _ normalized reduced fluctuating magnetic helicity density _ is given by @xmath59 , where @xmath60 is the trace power .
the relation between the reduced fluctuating magnetic helicity density @xmath61 and the fluctuating magnetic helicity density @xmath62 can be seen by writing the spectrum in terms of the doppler - shifted frequency @xmath52 instead of @xmath63 , @xmath64/(\omega'/v)$ ] . using equation ( [ eq : sr ] ) and @xmath65=i(ab^ * - a^*b)$ ] ,
the reduced fluctuating magnetic helicity density can be written as @xmath66}{\omega'/v } \right ) \nonumber \\ & \times&\delta[\omega'- ( { \mathbf{k}}\cdot { \mathbf{v}}+\omega ) ] \label{eq : hmrom}\end{aligned}\ ] ] equation ( [ eq : hmrom ] ) , the experimentally accessible quantity , is in terms of the magnetic field measurements in a frame defined by the solar wind velocity @xmath47 . to write this in terms of the theoretically calculable @xmath62 ( eq . [ eq : hm ] ) , we express the magnetic field components @xmath67 and @xmath68 in the @xmath69 coordinate system .
to do so , define the probe velocity in spherical coordinates about the direction of the mean magnetic field : @xmath70 . the orthonormal basis specified with respect to @xmath58
can be written as @xmath71 finally , we exploit the fact that the solutions of the vlasov - maxwell dispersion relation depend only on the perpendicular and parallel components of the wave vector @xmath21 and @xmath22 with respect to the mean magnetic field , and not on the angle about the field ; thus the eigenfunction for a wave vector @xmath72 can be rotated by an angle @xmath73 about the mean magnetic field to yield the solution for any wave vector @xmath74 . using the above ,
the reduced fluctuating magnetic helicity density @xmath75 in equation ( [ eq : hmrom ] ) becomes @xmath76 , \label{eq : hmr}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have specified the azimuthal angle of the probe velocity @xmath77 without loss of generality .
it is clear from this equation that all possible wave vectors @xmath78 that give the same doppler shifted frequency @xmath52 will contribute to the sum for the reduced fluctuating magnetic helicity density at the frequency @xmath52 .
predicting the values of @xmath79 for solar wind turbulence based on equation ( [ eq : hmr ] ) requires understanding three issues : the scaling of the magnetic fluctuation spectrum with wavenumber , the imbalance of alfvn wave energy fluxes in opposite directions along the mean magnetic field , and the variation of the angle @xmath80 between the solar wind velocity @xmath47 and the mean magnetic field .
the 1-d magnetic energy spectrum in the solar wind typically scales as @xmath81 in the inertial range and @xmath82 in the dissipation range , where @xmath83 @xcite and the effective wavenumber is @xmath84 .
it is clear from equation ( [ eq : hmr ] ) that , when the plasma frame frequency @xmath54 is negligible , the doppler - shifted observed frequency always results in an effective wavenumber @xmath85 , with equality occurring only when the velocity @xmath47 is aligned with the wave vector @xmath9 .
we assume that , for homogeneous turbulence at the dissipation range scales , turbulent energy at fixed @xmath21 and @xmath22 is uniformly spread over wave vectors with all possible angles @xmath73 about the mean magnetic field .
because the fluctuation amplitude deceases for larger effective wavenumbers , the contribution to @xmath79 is maximum at angle @xmath86 ; for angles @xmath73 yielding a doppler shift to lower effective wavenumbers @xmath87 , the higher amplitude fluctuations at those lower wavenumbers will contribute more strongly to @xmath79
. an accurate calculation of the magnetic helicity signature based on equation ( [ eq : hmr ] ) must take into account the scaling of the magnetic energy spectrum . to compare to @xmath88 derived from observations ( for example , see figure 1 of @xcite )
, we construct the normalized quantity @xmath89 } { \sum_{{\mathbf{k } } } [ |{\mathbf{b}}({\mathbf{k}})|^2/k ] \delta[\omega'- ( { \mathbf{k}}'\cdot { \mathbf{v}}+\omega)]}. \label{eq : numsigm}\ ] ] in evaluating equation ( [ eq : numsigm ] ) , we assume a model 1-d energy spectrum logarithmic gridpoints over @xmath90 $ ] , the model weights @xmath91 as a function of @xmath92 using @xmath93/[1+(k \rho_i)^{2}]\}^2 $ ] . ] that scales as @xmath94 for @xmath95 and @xmath96 for @xmath97 , consistent with theories for critically balanced turbulence @xcite and solar wind observations @xcite . in figure
[ fig : mhelr ] , we plot @xmath98 vs. effective wavenumber @xmath84 for a turbulent spectrum filling the mhd alfvn and kinetic alfvn wave regimes ( @xmath99 and @xmath100 ) for @xmath28 , @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath101 , and @xmath102
. the contributions to @xmath98 for all angles @xmath73 of each wave vector are collected in 120 logarithmically spaced bins in doppler - shifted frequency .
the results are rather insensitive to the scaling of the 1-d magnetic energy spectrum over the range from @xmath103 to @xmath104 .
the solid line in figure [ fig : mhelr ] corresponds to the model spectrum assumed above , while the dashed line corresponds to a @xmath103 energy spectrum .
figure [ fig : mhelr ] demonstrates that turbulence consisting of alfvn and kinetic alfvn waves produces a positive ( right - handed ) magnetic helicity signature in the dissipation range at @xmath105 .
the analysis presented in figure [ fig : mhelr ] considers only waves with @xmath106 , so all of the waves in the summation in equation ( [ eq : hmr ] ) are traveling in the same direction . if there were an equal alfvn wave energy flux in the opposite direction a case of balanced energy fluxes , or zero cross helicity the net @xmath98 would be zero due to the odd symmetry of @xmath62 in @xmath22 .
it is often observed , at scales corresponding to the inertial range , that the energy flux in the anti - sunward direction dominates , leading to a large normalized cross helicity @xcite .
if this imbalance of energy fluxes persists to the smaller scales associated with the dissipation range , a non - zero value of @xmath98 is expected .
however , theories of imbalanced mhd turbulence ( * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) predict that the turbulence is `` pinned '' to equal values of the oppositely directed energy fluxes at the dissipation scale .
this implies that , at sufficiently high wavenumber @xmath63 , the value of @xmath98 should asymptote to zero .
thus , @xmath98 in figure [ fig : mhelr ] would likely drop to zero more rapidly than shown , leaving a smaller positive net @xmath98 around @xmath107 , consistent with observations @xcite .
we defer a detailed calculation of the effects of imbalance to a future paper .
the angle @xmath80 between @xmath108 and @xmath47 is likely to vary during a measurement ; this angle does not typically sample its full range @xmath109 , but has some distribution about the parker spiral value .
calculations of @xmath98 over @xmath110 yield results that are qualitatively similar to figure [ fig : mhelr ] , so this averaging will not significantly change our results . taken together , we have demonstrated that a solar wind dissipation range comprised of kinetic alfvn waves produces a magnetic helicity signature consistent with observations , as presented in figure [ fig : mhelr ] .
the underlying assumption of the cyclotron damping interpretation of magnetic helicity measurements , an interpretation that dominates the solar wind literature @xcite , is the slab model , @xmath111 and @xmath112 , i.e. , purely parallel wave vectors . as shown in figure [ fig : mhel ] , only in the limit @xmath113 does the alfvn wave root generate a left - handed helicity @xmath36 as @xmath114 ; in the same limit , the fast / whistler root generates a right - handed helicity @xmath39 in a quantitatively similar manner ( see figure 9 of @xcite ) .
strong ion cyclotron damping of the alfvn / ion cyclotron waves as @xmath115 @xcite would leave a remaining spectrum of right - handed fast / whistler waves , as proposed by cyclotron damping interpretation .
however , only if the majority of the turbulent fluctuations have @xmath116 is the slab limit applicable , and only if significant energy resides in slab - like fluctuations are the conclusions drawn about the importance of cyclotron damping valid .
there is , on the other hand , strong theoretical and empirical support for the hypothesis that the majority of the energy in solar wind turbulence has @xmath0 ( see @xcite and references therein ) . in this case
, there is a transition to kinetic alfvn wave fluctuations at the scale of the ion larmor radius .
this letter demonstrates that a dissipation range comprised of kinetic alfvn waves produces a reduced fluctuating magnetic helicity signature consistent with observations .
g. g. h. thanks ben chandran for useful discussions .
g. g. h. was supported by the doe center for multiscale plasma dynamics , fusion science center cooperative agreement er54785 .
e. q. and g. g. h. were supported in part by the david and lucille packard foundation .
e. q. was also supported in part by nsf - doe grant phy-0812811 and nsf atm-0752503 . | measurements of small - scale turbulent fluctuations in the solar wind find a non - zero right - handed magnetic helicity .
this has been interpreted as evidence for ion cyclotron damping .
however , theoretical and empirical evidence suggests that the majority of the energy in solar wind turbulence resides in low frequency anisotropic kinetic alfvn wave fluctuations that are not subject to ion cyclotron damping .
we demonstrate that a dissipation range comprised of kinetic alfvn waves also produces a net right - handed fluctuating magnetic helicity signature consistent with observations .
thus , the observed magnetic helicity signature does not necessarily imply that ion cyclotron damping is energetically important in the solar wind . |
block copolymers , constructed by linking together chemically distinct subchains or blocks , spontaneously assemble into exquisitely ordered soft materials@xcite . the self - assembled order structures , spanning length scales from a few nanometers to several micrometers , offer a diverse and expanding range of practical applications in , for example , optical materials , microelectronic materials , drug delivery , advanced plastics , and nanotemplates@xcite .
the development of nanotechnology using block copolymers requires a good understanding of the phase behavior of the block copolymers .
the self - assembling mechanism of block copolymers sensitively depends on block types , the number of blocks , block - block interactions , architecture , and topology of the block polymers .
the equilibrium ordered patterns can be formed due to the delicate balance between these competing factors . in abc triblock copolymers ,
the number of controlled parameters is at least five , including three interaction parameters @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 , and two independent block compositions @xmath5 and @xmath6 .
@xmath7 is the degree of polymerization and @xmath8 is the flory - huggins interaction parameter characterizing the interaction between two chemically different blocks @xmath9 and @xmath10 .
compared with linear copolymers , the star - shaped copolymers have complicated phase behavior or physical properties induced by different molecular architecture . in the ordered phases of abc star triblock copolymers ,
the most distinct feature is the arrangement of the junction points .
if the chain lengths of three blocks are comparable , junction points are aligned on a one - dimensional ( 1d ) straight line , then cylindrical morphologies can be formed naturally .
their cross sections tend to show two - dimensional ( 2d ) patterns since polymer / polymer interfaces can be flat surfaces due to the repulsion forces between `` unconnected '' branches .
these factors lead to the formation of 2d polygonal tiling patterns , or archimedean tiling .
the tiling patterns can be encoded by a set of integers @xmath11 $ ] , indicating that a @xmath12-gon , an @xmath13-gon , and an @xmath14-gon , etc .
, meet consecutively at each vertex .
if some asymmetry , to the contrary , is introduced to the compositions , the junction points are mostly aligned on the curved trails .
consequently three - dimensional ( 3d ) structures can be formed .
furthermore , when the interactions are strong enough , the abc star triblock copolymers can self - assemble into hierarchical structures@xcite .
owing to the rich phase behavior , a number of experiments have been carried out on the phase and phase transition of abc star triblock copolymers in past decades@xcite . in particular , matsushita and co
- workers have conducted systematic studies on the morphologies formation of ( polyisoprene - polystyrene - poly(2-vinylpyridine ) ) ( isp ) star triblock copolymers .
several ordered tiling patterns , such as [ 6.6.6 ] , [ 8.8.4 ] , [ 12.6.4 ] , [ 3.3.4.3.4 ] , and even a dodecagonal symmetric quasicrystalline tiling@xcite , have been observed in the isp star triblock copolymers@xcite .
meanwhile , several hierarchical structures including cylinders - in - lamella , lamellae - in - cylinder , lamellae - in - sphere , and hierarchical double gyroid structures are also discovered with the asymmetries of composition@xcite .
recently , nunns et al . used polyisoprene ( i ) , polystyrene ( s ) and poly-(ferrocenylethylmethylsilane ) ( f ) to synthesize isf star triblock copolymers@xcite .
three 2d patterns , including [ 8.8.4 ] , [ 12.6.4 ] , and lamellae with alternating cylinders , were observed .
both of the experimental systems satisfy asymmetrical interaction between different blocks , i.e. , @xmath15 . in particular , in isp star triblock copolymers , the interaction strengths are known to follow the order @xmath16@xcite , while in isf star - shaped triblock copolymers , @xmath17@xcite .
besides experimental works , theoretical studies provide a good understanding of phase behavior of abc star triblock copolymers .
bohbot - raviv and wang@xcite used a coarse - grained free energy functional to numerically investigate some morphologies of abc star triblock copolymers . in 2002 ,
gemma and co - workers@xcite carried out monte carlo ( mc ) simulations on abc star triblock copolymers with equal interactions between the three components .
the phase behavior of abc star triblock copolymers with composition ratio of , @xmath18 , was investigated in detail in strong segregation region .
five kinds of 2d cylindrical phases , three kinds of lamellar - type phases and two kinds of continuous matrix phases were obtained from the mc simulations .
huang and co - workers@xcite studied the effects of composition and interaction parameter on the phase behavior of abc star copolymers with equal interactions among the three components using dissipative particle dynamics ( dpd ) simulations .
several efforts have also been made to study the phase behavior of abc star triblock copolymers using the scft@xcite . in 2004 , tang et al.@xcite started to use a 2d scft simulation to study the phase behavior of abc star triblock copolymers .
based on the scft , zhang et al.@xcite and li et al.@xcite examined the weak and intermediate segregation cases of mainly 2d structures with equal interactions .
zhang et al.@xcite also chose @xmath19 , @xmath20 to model the isp star triblock copolymer system of the type @xmath21 . accordingly , a 1d phase diagram was obtained as a function of @xmath22 from @xmath23 to @xmath24 .
the stability of the different lamellar morphologies formed from abc star triblock copolymers has been examined by xu et al.@xcite .
these scft studies mainly focus on the symmetrically interacting systems and the phase behavior of 2d structures . despite these previous experimental and theoretical studies ,
a comprehensive understanding of abc star triblock copolymers is still lacking , especially for the asymmetric interaction systems . in this work
, we will explore the phase behavior of abc star triblock copolymers , including 2d and 3d structures , with asymmetric interaction parameters between chemically different blocks .
theoretical approaches to investigating the phase behavior of block copolymers , often involve minimizing an appropriate free energy functional of the system , and comparing the free energies of different candidate structures .
therefore a systematic examination of the emergence and stability of ordered phases requires the availability of suitable free energy functionals and accurate methods to compute the free energy of ordered phases .
owing to a large number of studies , it has been well proven that the scft provides a powerful theoretical framework for the study of the phase behavior of block copolymers@xcite .
in particular , the scft can be used to determine the relative stability of different phases because it provides an accurate estimate of the free energy .
the essence of the scft is that the free energy of the system can be written as a functional of the spatially varying polymer densities and a set of conjugate fields . minimizing the free energy functional with respect to the densities and conjugate fields leads to a set of equations , encoded as scft equations .
the scft equations are a set of highly nonlinear equations with multi - solutions which correspond to the different ordered phases of block copolymers .
the equations also have a strong nonlocality that emerges from the connection of propagators and densities , conjugate fields .
solving the scft equations requires iterative techniques . owing to the nature of iterative methods , the solutions sensitively depend on the initial configuration at the start of the iteration .
a series of efficient strategies of screening initial conditions are developed based on the fact that all periodic structures belong to one of @xmath25 space groups@xcite . in each iterative step ,
efficient numerical schemes are required to solve the propagator equations . in the past years , two complementary methods , including spectral methods@xcite and real - space methods@xcite to solve the scft equations have been developed . in recent years
, an efficient pseudospectral method has been introduced to solve propagator equations@xcite .
this algorithm takes advantage of the best features of real- and fourier - space with the computational effort scale of @xmath26 based on the fast fourier transformation ( fft ) .
@xmath7 is the number of spectral modes or discrete points in real - space . to obtain the solutions of the scft equations corresponding to the saddle points of the scft free energy functional ,
the iterative methods are required to make the iteration convergent .
the quasi - newton methods were employed in the fully spectral approach to the scft by matsen and schick@xcite .
a simple mixing method by a linear combination of two consecutive fields was introduced by drolet and fredrickson@xcite for the scft simulations .
recently the anderson mixing method@xcite has been proven by itself to greatly reduce the number of scft iterations . from the perspective of nonlinear optimization ,
ceniceros and fredrickson@xcite devised a class of efficient semi - implicit schemes for solving the scft equations using the asymptotic expansion technology .
later , jiang et al.@xcite have extended these algorithms to the scft calculations for multicomponent polymer systems .
a generic strategy of theoretical studying phase behavior of complex block copolymer systems includes two steps@xcite .
the first step involves an efficient strategy to produce a library of possible candidate structures . in the second step ,
the candidate structures are used as initial conditions in the more accurate methods to compute free energies , which are used to construct phase diagrams of the systems . in this work
, we apply this strategy to examine the phase behavior of abc star triblock copolymers using the scft .
specifically , the strategies developed in our previous work@xcite are used as a screening technique to obtain candidate structures as many as possible .
these strategies include ( 1 ) knowledge from previous experiments and theories ; ( 2 ) knowledge from related systems , for example , diblock copolymers ; ( 3 ) combination and interpolation of known structures ; and ( 4 ) random initial configurations .
using these candidate structures as initial conditions , a fourth - order pseudospectral method combined with anderson mixing method is employed to study the stability of ordered phases .
to model the asymmetric interacting experimental systems of isp and isf , the interaction parameters of @xmath27 are used in our study .
it should be emphasized that , to broaden the scope of the research , the 2d and 3d ordered phases are included in our calculations .
the resulting free energies of the different ordered phases are used to construct phase diagrams .
there are two main steps in studying the phase behavior of block copolymers .
the first step is to obtain possible candidate structures as many as possible .
several strategies of exploring ordered phases have been proposed in our previous works@xcite . beyond the random initial values ,
these approaches include ( 1 ) knowledge from experiments and theories , such as small - angle x - ray scattering images , space group theory for periodic structures ; ( 2 ) knowledge from related systems ; ( 3 ) combination and interpolation of known structures . using these diverse strategies of initialization ,
a large number of ordered phases can be generated as the solutions of the scft equations .
in addition , the possible candidate structures from previous theoretical and experimental studies are considered in our calculations .
the second step is to identify the stability of these phases by comparing their free energies using efficient numerical methods . in this work ,
we combine an improved pseudosepectral method with anderson mixing algorithm to solve the scft equations for periodic block - copolymer morphologies .
a fourth - order accurate adams - bashford scheme@xcite is used to discretize the mdes .
the initial values required to apply this formula are obtained using a special extrapolation method@xcite , based on the second - order operator - splitting scheme@xcite .
a modified integral formula for closed interval is chosen to solve the integrated equations - that can guarantee fourth - order precision in @xmath46-direction whether the number of discretization points is even or odd@xcite . to ensure the accuracy , we require that these substeps of contour length @xmath46 are smaller than @xmath53 in the fourth - order accurate scheme
. the fft is used to translate the data between real- and fourier - space in the pseudospectral method . to obtain the equilibrium morphologies of scft equations
, iterative methods shall be required to update the conjugate fields .
for this step we choose the anderson mixing algorithm , firstly proposed by anderson@xcite , then introduced into polymer theoretical calculations by schmid and mller@xcite , thompson et al.@xcite owing to the local convergence of this method , we use the simple mixing method alone at the start of the algorithm to obtain better initial values for the fields , followed by anderson mixing approach alone to accelerate the convergent procedure to the prescribed accuracy in the fields .
the anderson mixing method requires the fields of previous @xmath28 steps when update new fields . using the previous @xmath28 step fields
, the anderson mixing method produces an @xmath28-order linear equations system from a least square problem
. then the new fields will be obtained by a combination of the fields of previous @xmath28 steps , with the solution of linear system being the weight factors .
for relatively simpler systems , such as diblock copolymers , the anderson mixing algorithm can significantly reduce the required number of iterations with few histories@xcite . for more complex situation , a larger @xmath28
shall be taken to update fields to accelerate the convergent procedure .
we find that assembling the @xmath28-order linear system spends more computation time than solving this linear system .
when @xmath28 becomes too large , it will slow the iteration . here
we overcome this problem by rearranging the elements of the @xmath54 matrix .
the technical details can be found in the appendix section . by using our approach ,
the anderson mixing method can robustly converge without slowing the scft iterations . in practice , we use the available histories of @xmath55 steps . here
we only consider the periodic structures , therefore , periodic boundary conditions are imposed on each direction . in our calculations ,
all spatial functions are all expanded in terms of plane waves . for 2d morphologies ,
a square box is simulated .
@xmath56 plane - wave basis functions are used to discretize the 2d box . for 3d structures
, we use a cubic unit cell in most of our calculations .
the number of plane - wave basis functions is @xmath57 .
the size of computation box plays an important role in determining the stability of ordered phases . for a given phase ,
its free energy is minimized with respect to the box sizes by the steepest descent approach coupled with solving the scft equations@xcite . based on the discussion above
, we summarize the iteration procedure by sketching the numerical recipes : step 1 : : starting from the given initial conditions and computational box , the fourth - order pseudosepectral method combined with anderson mixing method is applied to obtain the ordered phases when the field s change is smaller than the prescribed error @xmath58 .
step 2 : : optimizing the size of unit cell by minimizing the free energy with the steepest descent method .
step 3 : : goto * step 1 * until the free energy change is smaller than a given error @xmath59 . to ensure enough accuracy , in our implementation , each calculation
is terminated until the field s change ( defined in appendix ) at each iteration is reduced to @xmath60 ( corresponding to a free energy change of about @xmath61 ) , and @xmath62 . for the cases of @xmath63 , @xmath64 in the current work , the relative values of free energy among different phases in determining the phase boundary are from @xmath65 to @xmath66 .
therefore our numerical resolution is adequately accurate for constructing phase diagrams .
the previously theoretical studies mainly focus on the equally interacting abc star triblock copolymer systems , i.e. , @xmath67@xcite .
however , under experimental circumstances as mentioned above , many abc star triblock copolymers with asymmetric interactions have been synthesized to observe their phase behaviors , such as isp@xcite and isf@xcite star triblock copolymers . in particular
, the interaction parameters of the above systems satisfy the relationship @xmath68 . in order to make a meaningful comparison of the theoretical study and experimental investigation , the interaction parameters are chosen in the calculations so that they are appropriate for these experimental systems .
although accurate values of the flory - huggins parameters are not available in the literatures , qualitative interaction strengths are known to follow the order @xmath69@xcite , @xmath70@xcite . in what follows
we choose asymmetric interaction parameters , @xmath63 , @xmath64 , and equal statistical segment lengths .
this is a rough approximation to isp and isf copolymers , with the important difference that , in the idealized system , we neglect the small differences between @xmath2 and @xmath4 . as mentioned above , there are two main steps in studying the phase behavior of block copolymers .
the first step is to obtain as many possible candidate structures as possible .
the second step is to identify the stability of these patterns by comparing their free energies and construct the phase diagrams . in order to further analyse the stability of candidate patterns , it is helpful to split the free energy into two parts : internal ( @xmath71 ) and entropic ( @xmath72 ) .
the internal and entropic contributions to the free energy can be expressed as@xcite @xmath73 where @xmath37 are the block labels . using different initialization procedures , a large number of candidate structures have been obtained in our previous work@xcite . here
we only present the stable phases in the case of @xmath63 , @xmath64 , as shown in fig.[fig : phases ] . among these candidate phases , several polygon tiling patterns , or the cylindrical structures , with translation invariant along the third direction
are found as 2d phases .
these polygon patterns include [ 6.6.6 ] , [ 8.8.4 ] , [ 12.6.4 ] , [ 3.3.4.3.4 ] , [ 8.6.6;8.6.4 ] , [ 10.6.6;10.6.4;8.6.6;8.6.4 ] . the first pattern is designated as [ 6.6.6 ] because each vertex in this tiling is surrounded by three hexagonal polygons .
similarly the second and third patterns are named [ 8.8.4 ] and [ 12.6.4 ] , respectively .
the fourth pattern looks more complex .
there are two types of vertices : one is surrounded by 10-gon , 8-gon and 4-gon , whereas the other is formed by a decagon , a hexagon and a tetragon . from our naming convention ,
it should be named [ 10.8.4;10.6.4 ] . however , with the help of triangles and squares of hypothetical tiling , as fig.[fig : phases ] shows the superimposed tiling on a schematic drawing , it is noted all the meeting vertices are surrounded by three regular triangles and two squares , which is one of the archimedean tilings . in order to compare with experimental results ,
we encode it as [ 3.3.4.3.4]@xcite .
the fifth pattern also possesses two kinds of vertices : one is surrounded by 8-gon , 6-gon , and 4-gon , whereas the other is formed by an 8-gon and two 6-gons .
consequently , this pattern is designated as [ 8.6.4;8.6.6 ] .
similarly , the fifth pattern has four kinds of vertices , therefore , it is named [ 10.6.6;10.6.4;8.6.6;8.6.4 ] . besides these polygonal phases , additional three 2d structures , i.e. , three color lamellae ( lam ) , the core - shell cylinders ( hc ) , and
hierarchical cylinders - in - lamella phases ( l+c ) are also obtained in our simulations . at the same time , a series of 3d structures are obtained . from the morphology of patterns , these 3d patterns can be classified into core - shell phases and hierarchical structures .
the former includes core - shell spheres in body - centered - cubic lattice ( bcc ) and core - shell double - gyroid phases ( dg ) .
the hierarchical patterns consist of two kinds of hierarchical cylinders packed hexagonally ( hhc ) , two kinds of cylinders - in - lamella phases , with the cylinders being packed hexagonally ( hpl ) and tetragonally ( tpl ) , and hierarchical gyroid phases ( hdg ) .
note that due to the equal interaction parameters of @xmath74 , these structures have their mirror phases along the phase path of isopleth @xmath75 .
( @xmath77 ) .
note that in the @xmath78 ^ 1 $ ] phase , the minority c blocks form the 4-coordinated domains , and blocks a and b alternatively form 8-coordinated microdomains . while in the @xmath78 ^ 2 $ ] morphology , the a and c blocks form the 8-coordinated polygons , and b blocks form the domains with 4-coordinations . in one periodicity
, the @xmath79 phase has the cacb lamellar sequence , whereas the @xmath80 structure has the babc layers . ] in a series of experiments@xcite , two of the three arms are kept to be of equal length and the arm - length ratio is expressed as @xmath81 .
motivated by these experiments , we start with the calculation of the phase stability along this phase path . here
we assume that a and b arms have equal length and the c arm holds the arm - length ratio of @xmath82 .
the free energy differences of candidate phases from the value of the homogeneous phase as a function of the volume fraction of @xmath83 are given in fig.[fig:11x](a ) .
the phase stability regions as a function of @xmath22 are presented in fig.[fig:11x](b ) . in fig.[fig:11x](a ) , the free energies of some metastable phases along this path are not shown , such as that of [ 10.6.6;10.6.4;8.6.6;8.6.4 ] in the region of @xmath84 , where it has higher free energy than [ 6.6.6 ] , or @xmath78 ^ 2 $ ] , or [ 3.3.4.3.4 ] . with the increase of @xmath22 ,
the phase sequence is @xmath79 @xmath85 @xmath78 ^ 1 $ ] @xmath85 [ 8.6.6;8.6.4 ] @xmath85 [ 6.6.6 ] @xmath85 @xmath78 ^ 2 $ ] @xmath85 [ 3.3.4.3.4 ] @xmath85 [ 12.6.4 ] @xmath85 tpl @xmath85 @xmath80 .
the corresponding stable regions are @xmath86 ( @xmath79 ) , @xmath87 ( @xmath78 ^ 1 $ ] ) , @xmath88 ( [ 8.6.6;8.6.4 ] ) , @xmath89 ( [ 6.6.6 ] ) , @xmath90 ( @xmath78 ^ 2 $ ] ) , @xmath91 ( 3.3.4.3.4 ) , @xmath92 ( [ 12.6.4 ] ) , @xmath93 ( tpl ) , and @xmath94 ( @xmath80 ) , respectively .
when @xmath83 is small , in one period , the lamellar structure of @xmath95 of cacb type includes two thick a and b layers , and two thin c layers .
the symbols of @xmath78 ^ 1 $ ] and @xmath78 ^ 2 $ ] are used to distinguish the 4-coordinated polygons segregated by different block . in the @xmath78 ^ 1 $ ] phase ,
the minority c - arms form the 4-coordinated domains , and blocks a and b alternatively form 8-coordinated polygons .
while the unit cell of @xmath78 ^ 2 $ ] contains one 4-coordinated b - domain , 8-coordinated and 4-coordinated microdomains formed by blocks a and c , respectively . from the phase path , in tiling patterns ,
the coordination number of c - domains is proportional to the volume fraction of @xmath83 . with the increment of @xmath83 from @xmath96 to @xmath97 , the coordinations of c - domains change from @xmath98 , to @xmath99 , to @xmath100 , then to @xmath101 ( in the [ 3.3.4.3.4 ] phase ) , finally to @xmath102 .
further increasing @xmath83 , the asymmetry of a ( b ) arm and c arm results in arrangement of junctions on a curve line .
then a 3d structure of tpl appears when @xmath103 .
and ( b ) entropic energy of @xmath104 of various structures as a function of @xmath83 on the phase path of @xmath77 . the morphologies of @xmath78 ^ 1 $ ] , @xmath78 ^ 2 $ ] , @xmath79 and @xmath80 are explained in fig.[fig:11x ] . ]
when @xmath105 , the lamellar phase @xmath106 is stable in which the arrangement manner is babc type in one period , including one thick c layer and three thin bab layers .
we can analyze the stability of these ordered phases after splitting the scft energy functional into the internal and entropic parts ( see eq . ) .
fig.[fig : energysplit11x ] gives the internal energy @xmath107 , subtracted by that of the homogeneous phase@xcite , together with the entropic energy of @xmath108 , as a function of @xmath83 .
from fig.[fig : energysplit11x](a ) , we can find that @xmath79 ( cacb layers ) has very high internal energy at small @xmath83 which is induced by the penetrations of a and b arms through c domains@xcite . at the same time
, the lamellae of @xmath79 is favorable from the aspect of entropic energy , because the a and b blocks can get the largest entropy in the lamellar structure when they have equal large lengths compared with the c blocks .
the combination of the two contributions makes the @xmath79 be the stable phase when @xmath109 . when increasing @xmath83 , the internal energy becomes dominant and the stable phase transfers from @xmath79 to the cylindrical structures where the arm penetrations in dissimilar phase regions are diminished .
when the stable phase transfers from @xmath78 ^ 2 $ ] to [ 3.3.4.3.4 ] ( also termed as [ 10.8.4 ; 10.6.4 ] ) , the entropic energy plays a dominant role on the stability .
it is attributed to the increment of c arm which tends to form large c - domains .
the enlarged c - domains have an opportunity to meet much more a - domains which will increase the internal energy due to the largest interaction parameter @xmath3 .
on the other hand , as the arm c increases , the a and b arms become shorter .
the a and b arms can freely stretch in their rich domains which can greatly reduce the entropic energy .
the explanation is also available to the appearance of [ 12.6.4 ] , tpl as stable phases .
further increasing @xmath83 to @xmath110 , the lamellar phase of @xmath80 ( babc layers ) is stable again .
the reason is similar to that of the stability of @xmath79 phase when @xmath83 is smaller than @xmath96 .
along this phase path , matsushita and co - workers@xcite synthesized a set of @xmath111 copolymers and observed a number of ordered structures .
four isp star triblock copolymers with volume ratios of 1.0:1.0:0.7 , 1.0:1.0:1.2 , 1.0:1.0:1.3 , and 1.0:1.0:1.9 were investigated .
the cylindrical structures of @xmath112 , @xmath113 , @xmath114 , and @xmath115 are @xmath116 $ ] , @xmath78 $ ] , @xmath117 $ ] , and @xmath118 $ ] , respectively . from our simulations ,
the resulting phase behavior is in good agreement with these experimental measurements when @xmath119 . at higher asymmetries ,
takano et al.@xcite observed an l+s phase in @xmath120 system , and an l+c phase in @xmath121 and @xmath122 copolymers .
however , in our calculations , the lam phase dominates the regions .
this might be attributed to the relatively weak interaction parameters of @xmath2 or @xmath4 in our simulations so that a further segregation between components a and b ( or b and c ) can not occur . in 2007 , hayashida et al.@xcite have discovered a cylinders - in - lamella phase in which the stacking manner of the cylinders seems to be random in the experiments of isp star triblock copolymer melts . in our calculations , the cylinders - in - lamella , tpl ,
is found to be stable when @xmath123 , in which the cylinders are stacking tetragonally .
the discrepancy is attributed to the thermodynamic fluctuations which may affect the arrangement of cylinders under experimental circumstances . while within the mean - field level theory , the fluctuations have been neglected . along the similar phase path ,
nunns et al.@xcite synthesized a set of isf star triblock copolymers and observed the polygonal tilings [ 8.8.4 ] and [ 12.6.4 ] .
our resulting phase behavior is generally consistent with the isf experiments .
a deviation between our theoretical results and experiments is that the [ 12.6.4 ] was observed in @xmath124 system .
the discrepancy can be attributed to the different interactions , and different monomer sizes .
our computational results also agree with the previous theoretical calculations@xcite . among these works ,
zhang et al.@xcite considered 2d tiling patterns and chose the asymmetric flory - huggins interaction parameters of @xmath125 , @xmath126 to model the system of abc star triblock copolymers .
a 1d phase diagram of the star triblock copolymers @xmath76 was obtained . with the increase of @xmath22 , the phase transition changes from @xmath78 ^ 1 $ ] to @xmath78 ^ 2 $ ] , then to [ 8.6.6;8.6.4 ] and finally to [ 12.6.4 ] .
the corresponding stable regions are @xmath127 , @xmath128 , @xmath129 and @xmath130 , respectively .
the phase behaviors of @xmath78 ^ 1 $ ] , @xmath78 ^ 2 $ ] , and [ 12.6.4 ] are qualitatively consistent with our results .
there are some discrepancies between their results and our computer simulations . in their phase diagram
, the archimedean tiling of [ 3.3.4.3.4 ] is not included in their simulations , the order pattern [ 6.6.6 ] is metastable , and the stable area of [ 8.6.6;8.6.4 ] is different from ours .
the discrepancies can be attributed to two aspects .
the first one is that more candidate structures are involved in our simulations .
the second one is the difference of the flory - huggins interaction parameters . on the above phase path
, many candidate structures , such as 2d polygonal phases [ 10.6.6;10.6.4 ; 8.6.6;8.6.4 ] and 3d hierarchical structures of hhc , hdg , do not appear . to obtain the stability regions of the 2d and 3d phases which have been observed in experiments
, we turn to another phase path of isopleth @xmath75 , i.e. , by fixed equal length of arms a and c and the arm - length ratio of @xmath132 with an increment of volume fraction @xmath6 of @xmath53 . the free energy difference from the value of the homogeneous phase as a function of @xmath6 varying from @xmath133 to @xmath134
is plotted in fig.[fig:1x1](a ) .
the phase stability regions as a function of @xmath22 are presented in fig.[fig:1x1](b ) . for abc star triblock copolymers with symmetric a and c arms .
( b ) phase stability regions as a function of the arm - length ratio of @xmath135 ( @xmath75 ) of abc star triblock copolymers with asymmetric interactions , @xmath63 , @xmath64 as a function of the arm - length ratio of @xmath135 . ] along this phase path , the phase sequence with increasing @xmath6 is lam @xmath85 [ 8.8.4 ] @xmath85 [ 6.6.6 ] @xmath85 [ 10.6.6;10.6.4;8.6.6;8.6.4 ] @xmath85 [ 12.6.4 ] @xmath85 l+c @xmath85 hdg @xmath85 hhc
. the stable region of lam phase is @xmath136 . at the center part of the phase path , the chain lengths of three arms are close to one another , junction points are aligned on a straight line , and hence 2d tiling patterns can be formed .
the stability regions of 2d cylindrical phases are @xmath137 ( [ 8.8.4 ] ) , @xmath138 ( [ 6.6.6 ] ) , @xmath139 ( [ 10.6.6;10.6.4;8.6.6;8.6.4 ] ) , @xmath140 ( [ 12.6.4 ] ) , respectively . from the phase path
, we can also find that , in polygonal patterns , the coordinations of b - domains are proportional to the volume fraction of @xmath6 . with the increase of @xmath6 from @xmath141 to @xmath142 , the coordination number of b - domains goes through a gradual change from @xmath98 ( @xmath143 ^ 1}$ ] ) , @xmath99 ( [ 6.6.6 ] ) , @xmath100 or @xmath101 ( [ 10.6.6;10.6.4;8.6.6;8.6.4 ] tiling ) , to @xmath102 ( [ 12.6.4 ] ) . further increasing @xmath6 ,
the a and c arms become shorter .
also , owing to the largest interaction parameter @xmath3 , a further segregation between two minority blocks a and c occurs within the large - length - scale phase , and the system can form some hierarchical morphologies .
the interesting hierarchical patterns include 2d l+c phase , and 3d patterns of hdg , hhc , and their stability regions are @xmath144 ( l+c ) , @xmath145 ( hdg ) , @xmath146 ( hhc ) , respectively . and ( b ) entropic energy of @xmath104 of various structures as a function of @xmath6 on the phase path of @xmath75 . ] after splitting the scft energy functional into internal energy and entropic energy as expressed in eqn .
( see fig.[fig : energysplit1x1 ] ) , the stability of 3d hierarchical structures hhc and hdg along the phase path can be understood more readily .
when the ratio of @xmath135 ( @xmath75 ) is large enough , the asymmetric abc star triblock copolymers will exhibit similar phase behavior of asymmetric diblock copolymer .
the longest b arm plays an equal role as the long block in an asymmetric diblock copolymer , whereas the short a arm , together with c arm , are just like the short block in the diblock copolymer . in asymmetric diblock copolymers ,
the systems tend to curve the interface towards the minority domain .
it requires the minority block to stretch , and the cost is more than compensated for by relaxation of the longer blocks , which increases the internal energies@xcite . besides the asymmetry of blocks ,
the segregation power between arms a and c , @xmath3 , is sufficiently large to separate the a- , and c - domains , leading to the formation of hierarchical structures . in particular , for the asymmetric abc star copolymers , the blocks a and c have shorter chains than the short block in ab diblock when the curve interface can be formed .
the a and c arms can freely relax in their packing frustration domains which greatly reduces the entropic energy of the system .
although the internal energies of 3d hierarchical structures are higher than that of l+c structure , their entropic energies are much lower than that of the 2d cylinders - in - lamella phase . as a consequence ,
the combination of the two competing energies makes 3d hierarchical structures stable rather than l+c when @xmath147 . at higher asymmetries ,
block copolymers prefer to form structures with a higher interfacial curvature@xcite .
therefore hhc phase with larger spontaneous curvature than that of hdg phase , has lower free energy when @xmath148 .
the phase transition sequence for systematically varying volume fractions can be obtained by repeating the free energy comparison among the candidate structures .
the results of the phase transition sequences can be summarized in terms of phase diagrams . for the case of asymmetric interaction parameters of @xmath149 ,
the triangular phase diagram is mirror symmetric with the axes of @xmath75 .
therefore one - half of the whole triangular phase diagram should be calculated . the triangular phase diagram obtained by our scft simulations
is presented in fig.[fig : phasediagram ] .
sixteen structures , including 2d , 3d ordered phases and disordered phase ( d ) , are predicted to be stable in the phase diagram . besides the [ 6.6.6 ] , [ 8.8.4 ] , [ 8.6.6 ; 8.6.4 ] , [ 3.3.4.3.4 ] , [ 10.6.6;10.6.4;8.6.6;8.6.4 ] , [ 12.6.4 ]
, l+c , tpl , hhc , hdg and lam phases discussed above , four more ordered structures , hpl , core - shell structures of hc , dg , and bcc , and disordered phase are included in the triangular phase diagram .
the regions of stability of the different phases are obtained by comparing the free energy of these candidate structures .
the phase boundaries are determined by calculating the cross over point of the free energies of the two neighbouring phases .
the most significant feature of the triangular phase diagram is the rich phase behavior with a large number of stable ordered phases .
it should be noted that the ordered structures emerging in diblock copolymers , i.e. , no core - shell cylinders , spheres , gyroid , two - color lamella , are not included in our calculations .
that is , near the boundary of the triangular phase diagram , simulations are not carried out in our study .
, @xmath64 . the ordered structures emerging in diblock copolymers , i.e. , no core - shell cylinders , spheres , gyroid , two - color lamella , are not included in our calculations .
that is , near the boundary of the triangular phase diagram , simulations are not carried out in our study . ]
when the chain lengths of three arms are close to each other , junction points are aligned on a straight line , and hence the system tends to form polygonal tilings to get smaller internal energy . as a consequence , the central region of the phase map is dominated by the 2d tiling patterns .
the coordination number of each domain is proportional to the composition of corresponding block .
for example , as discussed above , along the phase path of @xmath150 = @xmath81 , the coordination number of c - domains changes from @xmath98 , to @xmath99 , to @xmath100 , then to @xmath101 , and finally to @xmath102 with increasing of @xmath22 from @xmath151 to @xmath152 . besides the cylindrical structures observed by experiments , two tilings of [ 8.6.6 ; 8.6.4 ] and [ 10.6.6;10.6.4;8.6.6;8.6.4 ] are predicted as the stable phases in our theoretical calculations .
the stability has been analyzed in the above context .
it is very different from the phase behavior of abc linear triblock copolymer melt in which the lamellar phase occupies the large central region@xcite . the reason is attributed to the topology of the star copolymer chain for which the junction points tend to be aligned on a straight line when the chain lengths of three arms are comparable . as the compositions of star copolymer become asymmetric , more 2d and 3d phases , including lam , hc , dg , bcc , hpl , tpl and cylinders - in - lamella of l+c , appear and surround these 2d tilings in the triangular phase diagram . among these phases , lam phase has the following phase transitions .
near the ab edge , cacb layers can be formed whereas abac layers formed near the bc edge , and babc layers formed near the ac edge .
consider the structural evolution that starts from the central 2d tilings region , toward the a- and c - rich corners of the triangular phase diagram .
the phase transition sequence is the cylinders - in - lamella structures ( including hpl and tpl ) , l+c , lam , dg , hc , bcc and disordered phase .
near the a - rich corner , in the cylinders - in - lamellar structure , the c arms form internal cylinders in the b perforated lamellar , then blocks b and c form lamellar together with a - layers .
the packed manners of the cylinders determine the morphologies of hpl and tpl , as shown in fig.[fig : phases ] .
the 2d hierarchical pattern , l+c , where arms b and c form alternating cylinders in the lamellar - based phase , has a stable region between cylinders - in - lamellar structures and lam phase .
the prediction of stability region of l+c phase is generally consistent with the recent experiment in which nunns et al .
observed the phase in @xmath153 star copolymer system@xcite . because of the smallness of @xmath154 , a further segregation between the minority components b and c (
a and b ) will not occur , which implies that the 3d hierarchical structures will not be global stable in this region . instead , the lam phase dominates this area . owing to @xmath155 ,
there is similar phase behavior near the c - rich corner when exchanging the position of arms a and c. the bcc , hc , and dg phases form continuous areas across the a- and c - rich corners of the triangular phase diagram , where a or c block is the largest arm .
the continuous areas formed by these phases in the triangular phase diagram reflect a continuous evolution in the compositions of the core and shell blocks . for example , consider the evolution of structure along a path within the bcc phase in the a - rich corner , starting from the ab edge , where the structure contains b spheres in an a matrix , to the ac edge .
as the c arm increases its length , a spherical `` shell '' of c grows in the middle of each b - sphere , while the composition of the surrounding shell of b shrinks , until a structure of c spheres in an a matrix is obtained at the ac edge .
an analogous change in the volume fractions of the `` shell '' and `` core '' components occurs in the hc and dg phases in both the a- and c - rich corners .
the phase behavior in the b - rich corner is more complicated .
owing to the largest value of @xmath156 , the minority components a and c tend to a further segregation near the b - rich corner , which leads to the formation of the hierarchical structures . from the cylindrical regions to b - rich corner , the phase sequence of hierarchical morphologies is l+c @xmath85 hdg @xmath85 hhc . near the @xmath75 line ,
the stable regions of hc and dg are separated by hierarchical structures of hhc , hdg , l+c and three archimedean tilings of [ 12.6.4 ] , [ 3.3.4.3.4 ] , [ 8.8.4 ] .
the stable region of bcc phase in the b - rich corner is continuous above that of hhc structure .
consider the structural evolution along a path that starts from the ab edge , where the length of arms satisfies the relationship @xmath157 , toward the @xmath158 isopleth . along this path , for example , in the bcc phase , a arms segregate into spherical domains , surrounded by c - rich pockets shell within the b matrix .
the core - shell hc and dg phases have similar phase behavior with a - core , c - shell and b - matrix .
similarly , structures , such as dg , hc , and bcc , evaluating along a path that starts from bc edge toward the @xmath75 isopleth , are of the c - core , a - shell and b - matrix patterns . in addition
, the disordered phase emerges in the b - rich corner of the triangular phase diagram . in general ,
the theoretical phase behavior is in agreement with the experimental observations .
however , there are some discrepancies between our theoretical computationus and experimental observations .
some structures observed by experiments in isp star triblock copolymers , such as l+s phase@xcite , zinc - blende type structure@xcite are not obtained in our simulations .
the stable regions of some structures obtained by experiments are not exactly located in the predicted phase regions of our phase diagram .
our theoretical phase diagram predicted [ 8.6.6 ; 8.6.4 ] and [ 10.6.6;10.6.4;8.6.6;8.6.4 ] as stable phases which have been not observed in the experiments .
there are three main possible reasons for these discrepancies .
the first one is that in the experiments many star triblock copolymers are obtained by blending two kinds of copolymers , or adding additional homopolymers .
for example , the zinc - blende type structure was observed in the @xmath159 system which was realized by blending the s homopolymer to @xmath160 .
the homopolymer s can definitely affect the phase stabilities .
the second one is that the predicted phases in the theoretical calculation , such as the [ 8.6.6;8.6.4 ] and [ 10.6.6;10.6.4;8.6.6;8.6.4 ] , may be metastable in the recent experimental systems .
the third one is that there are many differences between theoretical systems and experimental conditions , such as the different interactions , different monomer sizes . in our calculations
, we neglect the differences between @xmath2 and @xmath4 .
the difference is small , however , it might influence the self - assembling behavior . at the same time
, the values of interaction may be different from the experimental systems .
in this work , we have investigated the phase behavior of abc star triblock copolymers with asymmetric interaction parameters using the scft .
based on the previous work of screening initialization strategies@xcite , we can obtain a large number of ordered phases in studying the complex polymer systems .
then we used a fourth - order pseudospectral method , combined with the anderson mixing algorithm to calculate the free energy of the observed phases .
motivated by previously experimental studies , the flory - huggins interaction parameters of @xmath161 , @xmath63 are used to model the experimental systems of isp and isf star copolymers in bulk . to extend the scope of theoretical study , a large number of 2d and 3d ordered structures have been involved in our calculations . in order to shed light on the phase behavior of the abc star triblock copolymers , we first determined the phase stability along the phase path @xmath162 .
our results agree with those of isp star triblock copolymers for cylindrical phases well .
then we calculated the phase regions along the phase path @xmath163 . on this phase path , besides the cylindrical structures , we emphatically analyzed the stability of hierarchical structures of l+c , hdg , hhc .
the phase stability has been analyzed by splitting the scft energy functional into internal and entropic parts in detail .
finally we constructed a very complicated triangular phase diagram with these candidate structures .
owing to the case of interactions @xmath164 , the phase diagram has only one mirror symmetric axis @xmath75 .
fifteen ordered structures and the inhomogeneous phase constitute the triangular phase diagram . in general , the phase regions predicted by our scft calculations are consistent with previous theoretical studies of either scft calculations or mc , dpd simulations which mainly focus on the equal interaction systems .
however , in our calculations , the interaction parameters are more closely related to experimental systems , such as isp and isf star triblock copolymers , i.e. , the asymmetric interaction parameters @xmath27 .
it has been found that the asymmetry of the interaction parameters plays a profound role in the complex phase formation .
furthermore , our predicted phase diagram involves more phases , especially 3d structures , and presents more comprehensive phase behavior .
our calculations and analysis can be helpful to understand the self - assembling mechanism of complex structures .
the resulting phase behavior extends the theoretical study to the asymmetrically interacting abc star triblock copolymers . and
the presented phase diagram will be a useful guide for further study of abc star triblock copolymers .
10 bates , f. s. ; hillmyer , m. a. ; lodge , t. p. ; bates , c. m. ; delaney , k. t. ; fredrickson , g. h. multiblock polymers : panacea or pandora s box ?
, 336 , 434 - 440 .
hamley , i. w. , wiley ; new york , 2004 .
park , c. ; yoon , j. ; thomas , e. l. enabling nanotechnology with self assembled block copolymer patterns .
, 44 , 6725 - 6760 .
meng , f. ; zhong , z. ; feijen , j. stimuli - responsive polymersomes for programmed drug delivery . , 10 , 197 - 209 .
ruiz , r. ; kang , h. ; detcheverry , f. a. ; dobisz , e. ; kercher , d. s. ; albrecht , t. r. ; de pablo , j. j. ; nealey , p. f. density multiplication and improved lithography by directed block copolymer assembly . , 321 , 936 - 939 . matsushita , y. ; hayashida , k. ; takano , a. jewelry box of morphologies with mesoscopic length scales abc star - shaped terpolymers .
, 31 , 1579 - 1587 .
matsushita , y. ; hayashida , k. ; dotera , t. ; takano , a. kaleidoscopic morphologies from abc star - shaped terpolymers .
, 23 , 284111 .
okamoto , s. ; hasegawa , h. ; hashimoto , t. ; fujimoto , t. ; zhang , h. ; kazama , t. ; takano , a. ; isono , y. morphology of model three - component three - arm star - shaped copolymers . , 38 , 5275 - 5281 .
sioula , s. ; hadjichristidis , n. ; thomas , e. l. direct evidence for confinement of junctions to lines in an 3 miktoarm star terpolymer microdomain structure . , 31 , 8429 - 8432 .
sioula , s. ; hadjichristidis , n. ; thomas , e. l. novel 2-dimensionally periodic non - constant mean curvature morphologies of 3-miktoarm star terpolymers of styrene , isoprene , and methyl methacrylate .
, 31 , 5272 - 5277 .
takano , a. ; wada , s. ; sato , s. ; araki , t. ; hirahara , k. ; kazama , t. ; kawahara , s. ; isono , y. ; ohno , a. ; tanaka , n. ; matsushita , y. observation of cylinder - based microphase - separated structures from abc star - shaped terpolymers investigated by electron computerized tomography .
, 37 , 9941 - 9946 .
takano , a ; kawashima , w. ; noro a. ; isono , y. ; tanaka , n. ; dotera , t. ; matsushita , y. a mesoscopic archimedean tiling having a new complexity in an abc star polymer .
, 43 , 2427 - 2432 .
hayashida , k. ; kawashima , w. ; takano , a. ; shinohara , y. ; amemiya , y. ; nozue , y. ; matsushita , y. archimedean tiling patterns of abc star - shaped terpolymers studied by microbeam small - angle x - ray scattering .
, 39 , 4869 - 4872 .
matsushita , y. creation of hierarchically ordered nanophase structures in block polymers having various competing interactions .
, 40 , 771 - 776 .
hayashida , k. ; saito , n. ; arai , s. ; takano , a. ; tanaka , n. ; matsushita , y. hierarchical morphologies formed by abc star - shaped terpolymers .
, 40 , 3695 - 3699 .
hckstdt , h. ; gpfert , a. ; abetz , v. synthesis and morphology of abc heteroarm star terpolymers of polystyrene , polybutadiene and poly(2-vinylpyridine ) . , 201 , 296 - 307 . nunns , a. ; ross , c. a. ; manners , i. synthesis and bulk self - assembly of abc star terpolymers with a polyferrocenylsilane metalloblock . , 46
, 2628 - 2635 . park , j. ; jang , s. ; kim , j. k. morphology and microphase separation of star copolymers .
, 53 , 1 - 21 .
hayashida , k. ; dotera , t. ; takano , a. ; matsushita , y. polymeric quasicrystal : mesoscopic quasicrystalline tiling in abc star polymers .
, 98 , 195502 .
bohbot - raviv , y. ; wang , z .- g . discovering new ordered phases of block copolymers .
, 85 , 3428 - 3431 .
gemma , t. ; hatano , a. ; dotera , t. monte carlo simulations of the morphology of abc star polymers using the diagonal bond method .
, 35 , 3225 - 3237 .
huang , c. i. ; fang , h. k. ; lin , c. h. morphological transition behavior of abc star copolymers by varying the interaction parameters .
, 77 , 031804 .
tang , p. ; qiu , f. ; zhang , h. ; yang , y. morphology and phase diagram of complex block copolymers : abc star triblock copolymers .
, 108 , 8434 - 8428 .
zhang , g. ; qiu , f. ; zhang , h. ; yang , y. ; shi , a .- c .
scft study of tiling patterns in abc star terpolymers .
, 43 , 2981 - 2989 .
li , w. ; xu , y. ; zhang , g. ; qiu , f. ; yang , y. ; shi , a .- c . real - space self - consistent mean - field theory study of abc star triblock copolymers . , 133 , 064904 .
xu , y. ; li , w. ; qiu , f. ; zhang , h. ; yang , y. ; shi , a .- c .
stability of hierarchical lamellar morphologies formed in abc star triblock copolymers .
, 48 , 1101 - 1109 .
xu , w. ; jiang , k. ; zhang , p. ; shi , a .- c . a strategy to explore stable and metastable ordered phases of block copolymers . , 117 , 5296 - 5305 .
matsen , m. w. the standard gaussian model for block copolymer melts .
, 14 , r21-r47 .
fredrickson , g. h. ; oxford university press : new york , 2006 .
jiang , k. ; huang , y. ; zhang , p. spectral method for exploring patterns of diblock copolymers . , 229 , 7796 - 7805 .
jiang , k. ; wang , c. ; huang , y. ; zhang , p. discovery of new metastable patterns in diblock copolymers .
, 14 , 443 - 460 .
matsen , m. w. ; schick , m. stable and unstable phases of a diblock copolymer melt . , 72 , 2660 - 2663 .
guo , z. ; zhang , g. ; qiu , f. ; zhang , h. ; yang , y. ; shi , a .- c .
discovering ordered phases of block copolymers : new results from a generic fourier - space approach .
, 101 , 28301 .
drolet , f. ; fredrickson , g. h. combinatorial screening of complex block copolymer assembly with self - consistent field theory .
, 83 , 4317 - 4320 .
rasmussen , k. .
; kalosakas , g. improved numerical algorithm for exploring block copolymer mesophases . , 40 , 1777 - 1783 .
cochran , e. w. ; garcia - cervera , c. j. ; fredrickson , g. h. stability of the gyroid phase in diblock copolymers at strong segregation .
, 39 , 2449 - 2451 .
ranjan , a. ; qin , j. ; morse , d. c. linear response and stability of ordered phases of block copolymer melts .
, 41 , 942 - 954 . ceniceros , h. d. ; fredrickson , g. h. numerical solution of polymer self - consistent field theory . , 2 , 452 - 474 . jiang , k. ; xu , w. ; zhang p. analytic structure of the scft energy functional of multicomponent block copolymers . , 17 , 1360 - 1387 .
schmid , f. ; mller m. quantitative comparison of self - consistent field theories for polymers near interfaces with monte carlo simulations .
, 28 , 8639 - 8645 .
thompson r. b. ; rasmussen k. .
; lookman t. improved convergence in block copolymer self - consistent field theory by anderson mixing . , 120 , 31 - 34 . see the formula ( 4.1.14 ) on p.160 in _ numerical recipes : the art of scientific computing _ , 3rd edition , press , w. h. ; teukolsky , s. a. ; vetterling , w. t. ; flannery , b. p. , ed .
; cambridge university press ; new york , 2007 .
anderson , d. g. iterative procedures for nonlinear integral equations . , 12 , 547 - 560
. matsen , m. w. fast and accurate scft calculations for periodic block - copolymer morphologies using the spectral method with anderson mixing . , 30 , 361 - 369 .
v. abetz , block copolymers , ternary triblocks , in : _ encyclopedia of polymer science and technology _
, 3rd edition , kroschwitz , j. i. ed . ; john wiley & sons , inc , vol . 1 , 2003 . takano a. ; kawashima w. ; wada s. ; hayashida k. ; sato s. ; kawahara s. ; isono y. ; makihara m. ; tanaka n. ; kawaguchi d. ; matsushita y. composition dependence of nanophase - separated structures formed by star - shaped terpolymers of the @xmath165 type . , 45 , 2277 - 2283 .
matsen , m. w. ; bates , f. s. origins of complex self - assembly in block copolymers .
, 29 , 7641 - 7644 .
tyler , c. a. ; qin , j. ; bates , f. s. ; morse , d. c. scft study of nonfrustrated abc triblock copolymer melts . , 40 , 4654 - 4668
the @xmath12 iteration in the anderson mixing method begins with the evaluation of new fields from eqns.- @xmath166 in the above expressions , @xmath167 , @xmath168 , are the old fields , @xmath169 , @xmath170 , @xmath171 .
next we evaluate the deviation , @xmath172 where @xmath173 , @xmath174 , @xmath175 @xmath176 . from the deviation we can specify an error tolerance through the inner product @xmath177 where @xmath178 and @xmath179 are arbitrary functions .
the error tolerance is defined by @xmath180^{1/2 } \label{}\end{aligned}\ ] ] as a measure of the numerical inaccuracy in the field eqns.- .
the simple mixing method is performed until a certain tolerance is reached where a morphology has begun to develop . from our experience , @xmath181 , is sufficient in most cases .
we then switch to the anderson mixing procedure by the previous @xmath28 steps to update fields .
we assemble the symmetric matrix in this way @xmath182 for @xmath183 , and vector @xmath184 from these , we calculate the coefficients @xmath185 and combine the previous histories as @xmath186 finally , the new fields are obtained from @xmath187 where @xmath188@xcite . in our implementation ,
the used previous steps are usually much less than the number of basis functions or grid points . therefore assembling the @xmath28-order linear system spends more computation time than solving this system . to save computational amount
, we decompose eqn . into @xmath189 in @xmath12 iteration ,
only the terms related to @xmath190 in the right term of eqn . are required to calculate , but the last terms @xmath191 , @xmath192 , should be not computed repeatedly which will save the main computational cost in assembling matrix @xmath71 . in practical calculations , we store the following inner product matrix @xmath193 then we can assemble the matrix @xmath71 and vector @xmath29 according to the expressions of eqns . and using the elements of matrix @xmath194 . note that the inner product matrix is symmetric , therefore only a row ( or a column , equivalently ) of @xmath194 is required to update in each iteration . | the phase behavior of asymmetrically interacting abc star triblock copolymer melts is investigated by the self - consistent field theory ( scft ) .
motivated by the experimental systems , in this study , we focus on the systems in which the flory - huggins interaction parameters satisfy @xmath0 . using various initialization strategies ,
a large number of periodic structures have been obtained in our calculations . a fourth - order pseudospectral algorithm combined with anderson mixing method
is used to compute the free energy of candidate structures carefully .
the stability has been detailedly analyzed by splitting the free energy into internal and entropic parts .
a complete and complex triangular phase diagram is presented for a model with @xmath1 in which fifteen ordered phases , including two- , and three - dimensional structures , have been predicted to be stable from the scft calculations . generally speaking , with the asymmetrical interactions , the hierarchical structures tend to be formed near the b - rich corner of the triangular phase diagram .
this work broadens the previous theoretical results from equal interaction systems to unequal interaction systems .
the predicted phase behavior is in good agreement with experimental observations and previous theoretical results . |
the possibility of altering and controlling the spin - state of a single magnetic ion or of a small magnetic cluster with an external probe represents a unique opportunity towards the understanding and the exploitation of the magnetic interaction at the most microscopic level .
possible areas of application for such ability may include spin - based quantum logic , where one necessitates to prepare , manipulate and read spin - qubits .
it is then crucial to develop tools capable of addressing the single spin - limit .
low - temperature scanning tunneling microscopy provides one of such tools . in general the method exploits a scanning tunneling microscope ( stm ) operated in spectroscopical mode , by which the inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy ( iets ) at the spin - excitations of a given system is measured @xcite .
this scheme is known as spin - flip iets ( sf - iets ) .
the same stm can also be used to position and manipulate the magnetic atoms on a non - magnetic substrate @xcite , so that stm appears both as a fabrication and subtle characterization tool .
transition metal magnetic atoms on insulating surfaces , in particular mn@xcite , co@xcite and fe@xcite , have been the focus of intensive research in the last few years .
these have all partially filled @xmath0-shells , which are highly localized and responsible for the magnetic moment , and extended @xmath1-like electrons , which are responsible for the electron conduction .
in general @xmath1 and @xmath0 electrons interact via exchange coupling so that the magnetic structure is coupled to the conducting electrons .
the magnetic atoms are usually deposited on carefully prepared cun - decorated cu surfaces , where the typical electronic coupling is weak enough that the magnetism is preserved , but it is sufficiently strong to break the atomic central symmetry so that magnetic anisotropy develops .
stm experiments are then conducted and the fingerprint of a magnetic excitation is a step in the differential conductance , @xmath2 , as a function of bias , @xmath3 ( @xmath4 is the stm current ) .
these appear at the critical voltage necessary to open a new inelastic transport channel , i.e. at voltages corresponding to the given magnetic excitation energy .
several methods aimed at modeling sf - iets have been recently developed .
early theoretical work has focused on second order perturbation theory to describe the experimental conductance spectra of equilibrium spins by either using a master equation approach @xcite or a non - equilibrium green s function one @xcite . more recently
this scheme has been extended to third order , which allows us to describe additional features in the @xmath5 line - shape that can not be accounted for at the second order level @xcite .
these works have been very successful in describing conductance profiles , which appear symmetric with the external bias polarity , i.e. that they can not distinguish whether the current flows from the sample to the tip or in the opposite direction .
however , recent experiments have shown that regardless on whether a non - spin - polarized @xcite or a spin - polarized @xcite tip is used the iets profiles exhibit an intrinsic asymmetry with respect to the applied voltage , i.e. @xmath6 . in the case of a spin - polarized stm tip , where the tip density of states is spin split between majority ( spin up ) and minority ( spin down ) carriers , the asymmetry has been theoretically well explained @xcite .
it has been shown that spin selection rules enforce a suppression of the inelastic scattering , which depends on the direction of the electrons flow .
this results in a asymmetric conductance profile , where the magnitude of the asymmetry depends directly on the spin - polarization of the tip .
it is also well understood that by driving spins out of equilibrium ( e.g. by decreasing the tip - sample distance ) the conductance line - shape changes @xcite . in this case
we must assume that the tunneling electrons influence the spin - state of the atom as the time between inelastic events is small compared to the spin relaxation time .
a tunneling electron can then encounter the local spin in an excited state far from the ground state .
the non - equilibrium population of the various accessible spin - states then becomes bias - dependent and , for spin - polarized tips , this enhances the asymmetry of the @xmath5 line - shape .
also in the case of a non - spin - polarized tip a bias asymmetry has been revealed experimentally @xcite . in particular this
appears to be quite prominent for both single mn atoms and mn mono - atomic chains .
this feature has been previously ascribed to a shift in the magnetic atom on - site energy , i.e. to an effect arising from the details of the density of states of the atom producing scattering .
such a density of state effect produces a non - trivial slope in the conductance as a function of bias @xcite .
the on - site energy shift however does not account for the asymmetry seen in the inelastic step heights , which also depends on bias . here
we provide an alternative theoretical description , which allows us to better fit the experimentally found conductance line - shape . in our previous works @xcite
we have combined the non - equilibrium green s function ( negf ) @xcite formalism with a perturbative expansion of the electron - spin interaction in order to describe sf - iets spectra in a manner , which is fully amenable to an implementation within density functional theory ( dft)@xcite .
the scheme essentially consists in constructing an electron - spin interaction self - energy , which describes the inelastic tunneling events .
the interacting self - energy was previously expanded first up to second order @xcite and then to the third order @xcite , with this latter describing the logarithmic decays of @xmath5 at each conductance step . although both non - equilibrium effects and spin - polarized iets have been well described up to the second order by the master equation approach , in this work we extend our formalism to include the extra line - shape features that can be ascribed to the third order self - energy .
we also propose that the real part of the interacting self - energy , which has been well studied in the case of electron - phonon interactions @xcite , is a necessary addition to the negf formalism in order to account for asymmetric features in non - spin polarized systems .
the layout of the paper is as follows . in the next section
we extend our negf formalism to account for spin polarized leads . in the same section
we also derive a second - order electron - spin self - energy , which includes a second order expansion of the spin propagator .
this provides the means to study non - equilibrium effects that result from high current densities .
furthermore , in the case of non - spin polarized tips we derive an expression for the real part of the scattering self - energy up to second order .
all of the above is combined with the third order contribution to the electron propagator .
then we move to the results .
first we study the non - equilibrium effects arising from an increase in current density for the case of a mn dimer .
then we recreate the spin - polarized experiments of loth et al . on single mn and fe atoms @xcite .
finally we test how the inclusion of the real part of the scattering self - energy modifies the sf - iets for a non - polarized tip probing mn monomers and trimers .
we consider here the same single - orbital tight - binding model used in our previous works @xcite to describe a magnetic system ( s ) coupled to two non - interacting electrodes representing respectively the stm tip ( tip ) and the substrate ( sub ) .
the scattering region containing the magnetic nanostructure consists of a one - dimensional chain of @xmath7 magnetic atoms .
each of the @xmath8-th atoms carries a quantum mechanical spin @xmath9 and it is characterized by an on - site energy @xmath10 .
we assume that the tip and the substrate can only couple to one atom at a time in the scattering region thus to broaden the electronic level @xmath10 through the interaction with the electrode by @xmath11 .
the hamiltonian in the scattering region is then described by @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the tight - binding electronic part , @xmath14 is the spin part and @xmath15 describes the electron - spin interaction .
the various terms can be written explicitly as @xmath16\big\}\:,\\ \label{eq:3 } & { h}_\mathrm{e - sp}=j_\mathrm{sd}\sum_{\lambda\:\alpha,\alpha'}(c_{\lambda\alpha}^{\dagger}[\boldsymbol{\sigma}]_{{\alpha}{\alpha'}}c_{\lambda\alpha'})\cdot\mathbf{s}_\lambda\ : \\
\nonumber & + j_\mathrm{0}\sum_{\lambda\:\alpha}c_{\lambda\alpha}^{\dagger}c_{\lambda\alpha}\:,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the electron ladder operator @xmath17 ( @xmath18 ) creates ( annihilates ) an electron at site @xmath8 with spin @xmath19 ( @xmath20 ) and on - site energy @xmath10 .
we model the spin - spin interaction between the localized @xmath21 spins by a nearest neighbour heisenberg hamiltonian with coupling strength @xmath22 . furthermore we include interaction with an external magnetic field @xmath23 ( @xmath24 is the bohr magneton and @xmath25 is the gyromagnetic ratio ) and both uni - axial and transverse anisotropy of magnitude @xmath26 and @xmath27 respectively @xcite .
the electron - spin interaction hamiltonian is constructed within the @xmath1-@xmath0 model @xcite where the transport electron , @xmath1 , are locally exchanged coupled to quantum spins , @xmath21 ( @xmath0 indicates that the local moments originating from the atomic @xmath0 shell ) . in equation ( [ eq:3 ] ) the interaction strength is @xmath28 and
@xmath29 is a vector of pauli matrices . the second term in eq . ( [ eq:3 ]
) represents the potential scattering elastic contribution to the @xmath1-@xmath0 interaction given by the exchange parameter @xmath30 ( note that this enters as a shift of the on - site potential of a given atom ) .
the ratio , @xmath31 , is typically in the range 1 - 2 @xcite .
this term was not included in our previous works @xcite as it only becomes important for spin - polarized electrodes . in order to construct an electron - spin interacting self - energy
we must first consider the keldysh @xcite contour - ordered single - body green s functions ( propagators ) for both the electronic ( @xmath32 ) and the spin ( @xmath26 ) sub - systems in the electron - spin many - body ground state @xmath33 @xmath34_{\sigma\sigma'}=-i{\langle}|t_c\{c_{\sigma}(\tau)c^{\dagger}_{\sigma'}(\tau')\}|{\rangle}\:,\ ] ] @xmath35_{nm}=-i{\langle}|t_c\{d_{n}(\tau)d^{\dagger}_{m}(\tau')\}|{\rangle}\:.\end{aligned}\ ] ] these propagators describe a non - equilibrium system at zero - temperature . here
@xmath36 is a quasi - particle creation operator defined by the relation @xmath37 where @xmath38 and @xmath39 are eigenstates of @xmath40 of energy @xmath41 .
the matrix elements @xmath42 determine the transition rates from the initial state @xmath43 to the final state @xmath44 .
the quasi - particle operators are assumed fermionic in nature@xcite .
therefore the equilibrium population of a given state @xmath44 is given by @xmath45 where @xmath27 is the energy , @xmath46 the temperature and @xmath47 the boltzmann constant .
in the non - interacting case ( @xmath48 ) the electronic system is not in equilibrium as the interaction with the electrodes establishes a steady state current .
in contrast the spin system is in thermal equilibrium at the temperature @xmath46 . in this case
the energy resolved lesser and greater green s functions take the form @xmath49_{\sigma\sigma'}=\frac{[\sigma^{\lessgtr}_{\mathrm{tip - s}}(e)]_{\sigma\sigma'}+[\sigma^{\lessgtr}_{\mathrm{sub - s}}(e)]_{\sigma\sigma'}}{(e-\varepsilon_0)^2+\gamma^2}\:,\\ \label{eq:72 } & [ d_0^{\lessgtr}(e)]_{mn}=\frac{[\pi^{\lessgtr}_{0}(e)]_{mn}+[\pi_0^{\lessgtr}(e)]_{mn}}{(e-\varepsilon_m)^2+(k_\mathrm{b}t)^2}\:.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the electronic non - interacting green s function [ see eq .
( [ eq:71 ] ) ] the coupling of the sample to the tip and the substrate causes a broadening of the bare on - site level @xmath10 of magnitude @xmath50_{\sigma\sigma'}$ ] , where @xmath51 . the non - interacting self - energies take the form @xmath52_{\sigma\sigma'}=[1-f_{\eta}(e , v)][\gamma_{{\eta}-s}]_{\sigma\sigma'}$ ] and @xmath53_{\sigma\sigma'}=f_{\eta}(e , v)[\gamma_{{\eta}-s}]_{\sigma\sigma'}$ ] , where @xmath54 is the fermi function in each of the @xmath55-th leads at a bias @xmath3 .
in contrast the local spin green s function of equation ( [ eq:72 ] ) describes a system , which is adiabatically coupled to a heat - bath of temperature @xmath46 .
this provides a very weak broadening of the single spin states @xmath56 of magnitude @xmath57 .
such a heat bath keeps the spin - system in equilibrium and in the non - interacting case the population then resides mostly in the ground state [ see eq .
( [ eq:7 ] ) ] . for a ground state population of the spin system
@xmath58 we have @xmath59_{mn}=\delta_{mn}(1-p^0_m)k_\mathrm{b}t$ ] and @xmath60_{mn}=\delta_{mn}p^0_mk_\mathrm{b}t$ ] . in order to evaluate the effects that the interaction has on the electronic motion we must calculate the electron - spin self - energy . here
we take a perturbative approach and formally expand equation ( [ eq:4 ] ) up to the @xmath43-th order in the interaction hamiltonian , @xmath61 , as @xmath62_{\sigma\sigma'}=\sum_n\frac{(-i)^{n+1}}{n!}\int\limits_c{d}\tau_1\dots\int\limits_c{d}\tau_n\ \times \nonumber \\ & \frac{{\langle}0|t_c\{{h}_\mathrm{e - sp}(\tau_1)\dots{h}_\mathrm{e - sp}(\tau_n)c_{\sigma}(\tau)c_{\sigma'}^{\dagger}(\tau')\}|0{\rangle}}{u(-\infty,-\infty)},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath63 is the time - evolution unitary operator and the time - averages are performed over the known non - interacting @xmath64 ground state @xmath65 . the time integration over @xmath66 is ordered on the contour @xmath67 going from @xmath68 to @xmath69 and then returning from @xmath69 to @xmath68 , since the ground state of the non - equilibrium system can only be defined at @xmath68 @xcite . in the following we consider the tip to have a spin polarization @xmath55 ( @xmath70 ) .
this is defined as the spin asymmetry in the electronic coupling between the tip and the sample .
an such the spin resolved electronic broadening is given by @xmath71_{\uparrow\uparrow}=\frac{(1+\eta)}{2}\gamma_\mathrm{tip - s}$ ] and @xmath71_{\downarrow\downarrow}=\frac{(1-\eta)}{2}\gamma_\mathrm{tip - s}$ ] , where @xmath72 is the non - spin - polarized broadening .
the substrate is assumed to remain non - magnetic . as a result @xmath73_{\uparrow\uparrow}\neq[g^{\lessgtr}_0(e)]_{\downarrow\downarrow}$ ] so that we now must retain the spin indexes when constructing the self - energy .
the self - energy for the majority ( @xmath74 ) and minority ( @xmath75 ) spins writes respectively as @xmath76_{\uparrow\uparrow}^{(2)}=-j^2_\mathrm{sd}\sum_{mn}[g^{\lessgtr}_0(e\pm\omega_{mn})]_{\uparrow\uparrow } \times\nonumber \\ & \big(\delta_{nm}\chi p_ns_{mn}^z+ p_n(1-p_m)|s_{mn}^z|^2\big)\nonumber \\ & -j^2_\mathrm{sd}\sum_{mn}[g^{\lessgtr}_0(e\pm\omega_{mn})]_{\downarrow\downarrow}p_n(1-p_m)|s^+_{mn}|^2\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath77_{\downarrow\downarrow}^{(2)}=-j^2_\mathrm{sd}\sum_{mn}[g^{\lessgtr}_0(e\pm\omega_{mn})]_{\downarrow\downarrow } \times\nonumber \\ & \big(-\delta_{nm}\chi p_ns_{mn}^z+p_n(1-p_m)|s_{mn}^z|^2\big)\nonumber \\ & -j^2_\mathrm{sd}\sum_{mn}[g^{\lessgtr}_0(e\pm\omega_{mn})]_{\uparrow\uparrow}p_n(1-p_m)|s^-_{mn}|^2\:.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the lesser ( greater ) self - energy describe an incoming ( outgoing ) electron that excites ( relaxes ) the spin system by @xmath78 , with a probability that depends on the occupation of the spin levels @xmath79 and @xmath80 and on the spin selection rules @xmath81 ( note @xmath82 and @xmath83 ) .
the first term in both the equations ( [ eq:10a ] ) and ( [ eq:10b ] ) , proportional to @xmath84 , corresponds to the magnetoresistive elastic term of the @xmath1-@xmath0 hamiltonian of equation ( [ eq:3 ] ) .
the remaining contributions are inelastic in nature and depend on the spin orientation of the electron transferred from the tip . when is magnetic and the tunneling current tip carries a finite spin - polarization the spin system can be dragged out of equilibrium , in particular if the current density is intense .
this means that the equilibrium conditions employed previously @xcite , namely @xmath85 and @xmath86 is no longer valid . as a consequence
we must now derive also an expression for the propagator and thus for the self - energy associated to the local spins .
the derivation , up to second order in the electron - spin interaction is described in details in the appendix .
in particular the total spin - self - energy also includes a zeroth - order contribution , which accounts for the non - interacting ( @xmath48 ) case .
this is approximated by @xmath87_{kk}=p_k^0k_\mathrm{b}t$ ] and @xmath88_{kk}=(1-p_k^0)k_\mathrm{b}t$ ] where @xmath89 is the ground state population .
therefore , in absence of inelastic scattering , the spin system will remain in thermal equilibrium with the heat bath and only the ground state will be occupied . by combining the zeroth and second order contributions to self - energy we can write down a master equation , describing the non - equilibrium spin - population , in terms of the total self energy @xmath90@xcite @xmath91_{nm}[d_0^<(e)]_{mn } \nonumber \\ & -\pi^{<}(e)]_{nm}[d_0^>(e)]_{mn}\big\}\:.\end{aligned}\ ] ] after some rearrangement this can be written in more compact form as @xmath92\nonumber \\ & + ( p_n^0-p_n)k_\mathrm{b}t\:,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the bias dependent transition rate from an initial state @xmath93 to a final state @xmath94 is calculated after evaluating the integral described in equation ( [ eq:14 ] ) of the appendix .
this finally writes @xmath95_{\uparrow\uparrow}[\gamma_{\eta'}]_{\uparrow\uparrow}-[\gamma_{\eta}]_{\downarrow\downarrow}[\gamma_{\eta'}]_{\downarrow\downarrow}\big ) + \nonumber \\ & + |s^z_{nl}|^2[\gamma_{\eta}]_{\uparrow\uparrow}[\gamma_{\eta'}]_{\uparrow\uparrow}+|s^z_{nl}|^2[\gamma_{\eta}]_{\downarrow\downarrow}[\gamma_{\eta'}]_{\downarrow\downarrow } + \nonumber \\ & + |s^+_{nl}|^2[\gamma_{\eta}]_{\downarrow\downarrow}[\gamma_{\eta'}]_{\uparrow\uparrow}+|s^-_{nl}|^2[\gamma_{\eta}]_{\uparrow\uparrow}[\gamma_{\eta'}]_{\downarrow\downarrow}\big\}\:,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath96 and @xmath97 is the chemical potential in lead @xmath51 .
note that @xmath98 is such that for @xmath99 the resulting transition rates @xmath100 are bias independent and do not contribute to the current .
however , they do contribute to the spin relaxation time i.e. to the time taken by the localized spin system to relax back to its equilibrium state .
such a relaxation time is reduced if the coupling between the sample and the leads is increased .
furthermore , the smaller is the inelastic energy transition @xmath78 , the longer the spins will remain in the excited state before relaxing back to equilibrium .
finally , we note that the above expression is based on the assumption that the on - site energy is large enough for the density of states of the spin system to remain constant in the small energy window of interest .
therefore @xmath101 . returning to equation ( [ eq:17 ] ) note that we are only interested in the steady state non - equilibrium population of the spin states at a given bias
. therefore we can set @xmath102 and reduce eq .
( [ eq:17 ] ) to system of linear equations , which can be solved self - consistently . for an initial guess of the populations ( @xmath103 ) we can iterate eq .
( [ eq:17 ] ) , which define @xmath80 , with equation ( [ eq:14 ] ) of the appendix , which define the self - energy @xmath104 , until self - consistency is reached .
we can then combine the resulting non - equilibrium population with the second order electronic self - energy calculated in eq .
( [ eq:4 ] ) to obtain the current .
in order to provide an explanation to the inherent asymmetry that has been observed in most of the stm experiments on magnetic atoms using a non - magnetic tip we return to the expression for the full retarded self - energy .
this is defined by the hilbert transform ( note we will only consider the non - spin polarized case for simplicity ) @xmath105 by using the expressions derived in section [ spse ] for the 2@xmath106 order lesser and greater self - energies we can find an analytic expression for the real contribution to the retarded self energy @xmath107=2\rho j^2_\mathrm{sd}\sum_{i , m , n}|s^i_{mn}|^2p_n(1-p_m)\times \\ \nonumber & \frac{1}{\gamma}\big\{2\pi\varepsilon_0+\sum_{\eta}\gamma_{\mathrm{\eta - s}}\:\mathrm{ln}\big[\frac{(e+\omega_{mn}-\mu_{\eta})^2+(k_bt)^2}{(e-\omega_{mn}-\mu_{\eta})^2+(k_bt)^2}\big]\big\}\:.\end{aligned}\ ] ] such a final expression is heavily dependent on the on - site energy @xmath10 but is also an odd function of the energy and the bias via its logarithmic dependence on the spin level eigenvalues with opposite polarity for @xmath108 and @xmath109 .
we will show in the results section that this is at the origin of the conductance asymmetry found in experiments .
we can finally unveil the effects that a non - equilibrium spin - population bares on the conductance profile of a magnetic nanostructure by taking the derivative of the current with respect to the bias voltage @xmath3 .
the current , @xmath110 , flowing at the electrode @xmath111 can be written as @xmath112-[\sigma_{\eta}^{<}(e)g^{>}(e)]\}\:,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath113 are the full many - body lesser / greater electronic green s functions .
these are finally defined as @xmath114=\frac{[\sigma^{\lessgtr}_{\mathrm{tip - s}}(e)]+[\sigma^{\lessgtr}_{\mathrm{sub - s}}(e)]+[\sigma^{\lessgtr}_{\mathrm{int}}(e)]}{(e-\varepsilon_0-\mathrm{re}[\sigma_{\mathrm{int}}(e)])^2+(\gamma-\mathrm{im}[\sigma_{\mathrm{int}}(e)])^2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath115=[\sigma^{\lessgtr}_{\mathrm{int}}(e)]^{(2)}+[\sigma^{\lessgtr}_{\mathrm{int}}(e)]^{(3)}$ ] where the third order self - energies are calculated following ref .
here for simplicity we take the expression for the third order contribution to @xmath116 obtained by neglecting any explicit spin - polarization .
such approximation is justified by the fact that the effects due to spin - polarization are small at the third order and that in doing so we avoid a rather cumbersome formulation .
we do however consider the combination of non - spin polarized 3rd order effects with 2nd order spin - polarized self energies to highlight subtle differences in the spectra .
we start our analysis by first looking at the effects originating from driving the spin system out of equilibrium with an electronic current .
this attempts at explaining the experiments reported in ref .
[ ] , in which a stm tip ( non - magnetic ) is positioned above a mn dimer deposited onto a cun substrate .
the conductance spectra are measured for different tip to sample distances .
varying the stm tip height is equivalent to changing both the current density and the electronic coupling between the tip and the sample .
non - equilibrium effects then appear as variations of the conductance profiles as a function of the stm tip height .
many of the parameters needed by our model can be extrapolated from a similar experiment carried on over mn linear atomic chains deposited on cun @xcite .
the five unpaired electrons in the mn 3@xmath0 shell suggest a @xmath117 ground state , as confirmed both by experiments and theory @xcite .
the spin - spin exchange interaction between two mn atoms is antiferromagnetic and has an estimated value of @xmath118 mev . as a result
the ground state of the dimer is a singlet ( total spin @xmath119 ) .
the first excited state is a triplet with total spin @xmath120 and the energy splitting between the ground state and such first excited state is exactly @xmath22 .
the next excited level is the quintuplet with total spin @xmath121 and it is separated from the first excited state by @xmath122 .
this pattern continues throughout the spin manifold ( see figure [ fig1 ] ) .
the axial and transverse anisotropies are found to be @xmath123 mev and @xmath124 mev respectively .
these cause the lifting of the spin multiplets degeneracy .
the temperature is set at @xmath125 k. the value of @xmath28 is estimated from density functional theory ( dft ) to be of the order of 500 mev @xcite , while @xmath126 is also found from dft to be approximately 100 mev .
in contrast @xmath72 remains an adjustable parameter with the chosen values ranging from 0.125 mev to 200 mev . finally , in order to ensure a nearly constant density of states around the fermi energy ( @xmath127 )
we set the on - site energy of the atom under the stm tip to be @xmath128 ev .
figure [ fig2 ] shows the conductance spectra obtained by simply taking the numerical derivative of the current [ eq . ( [ eq:23 ] ) ] with respect to the bias .
we consider three different tip to sample distance , corresponding respectively to weak ( @xmath129 mev ) , intermediate ( @xmath130 mev ) and strong ( @xmath131 mev ) electronic coupling .
the evolution of the conductance lineshape as a function of @xmath72 is a direct consequence of the spin system being driven out of equilibrium . for @xmath129 mev
the stm tip is far enough from the sample to ensure that the spin system is always in its ground state between two subsequent electron tunneling events .
therefore the only transition detected in the @xmath5 profile is that between the @xmath119 ground state and the first excited state with @xmath120 .
this has an excitation energy equal to @xmath22 and it does manifest itself as a conductance step at a voltage @xmath132 , with @xmath133 being the electron charge . as the tip is brought closer to the sample ( @xmath130 mev )
the first excited triplet level ( @xmath120 ) starts to populate .
now an incoming electron with sufficiently large energy ( @xmath122 ) can induce a second transition from from the first to the second excited state .
note that the @xmath121 state is not accessible with a single electron tunneling process from the ground state and it can be reached only if the spin system does not have enough time between tunneling events to relax back to the ground state . for this case
the transition appears as a reduction of the conductance at the critical voltage @xmath134 .
the same spectroscopical feature is further enhanced at an even larger current density ( @xmath135 200 mev ) , when a third conductance step appears at @xmath136 .
this is associated to a transition from the @xmath121 to the @xmath137 spin state and it becomes possible only if the occupation of the @xmath121 level is not zero , i.e. if the system is driven to this highly excited state .
these results are in almost perfect quantitative agreement with the experimental data ( see fig . 2 of ref . [ ] ) .
the evolution of the population of the various spin states ( up to @xmath121 ) as a function of bias is presented in figure [ fig3 ] .
this is calculated in the case of strong tip to sample electronic coupling @xmath135 200 mev . in the figure
one can note the strong spin - pumping from the ground state into both the first and the second excited state .
the excitation to the @xmath138 excited state occurs at approximately 18 mev but is too weak to be observed on this scale .
we now move on to consider the situation where the tip is magnetic , i.e. when the injected current is spin - polarized .
again we use as guide the experimental work of loth _
et al._@xcite .
the stm tip is now spin - polarized by placing an additional mn atom at its apex , while also applying a strong magnetic field perpendicular to the substrate of 3 t. in this case the spectrum is collected from a single mn or fe ion on the surface ( not from a dimer ) . in the case of mn , the atom exhibits a weak anisotropy on cun ( see previous section ) and the strong magnetic field effectively produces a zeeman split of the six levels of the @xmath117 mn spin manifold . the direction of the magnetic field in these experiments is chosen so that the ground state of the mn spin corresponds to the magnetic quantum number @xmath139 . since the same magnetic field is applied to the mn atom on the tip s apex , the tip and atom are both spin - polarized and collinear .
figure [ fig4 ] shows the calculated spectra for the system described above .
in particular we consider magnetic field strength of 3 t and either weak ( @xmath140 mev ) , intermediate ( @xmath141 mev ) or strong ( @xmath142 mev ) tip to sample couplings .
the on - site energy is fixed at @xmath143ev and the value of @xmath144mev is infered from the work of lucignano _ _ et al.__@xcite .
the tip spin - polarization constant and the inelastic ratio that best fit the experimental data are respectively @xmath145 and @xmath146 . in the weak coupling regime (
when the local spin remains always close to equilibrium ) the local spin resides almost entirely in its @xmath139 ground state . due to the spin - exchange selection rules and to the collinearity of the tip and the sample , only the minority carriers can excite the local spin out of the ground state . for a tip spin - polarization of @xmath145 ,
there are more minority electrons coming from the tip than those coming from the substrate . as a result ,
the intensity of the inelastic interaction will change depending on the direction of the current .
this creates an asymmetry in the conductance spectrum with respect to the applied bias .
the additional lineshape features appearing in the weak coupling case ( the conductance decay following a conductance step ) are due to the third order kondo - like self - energy , which produces a logarithmic decay at the conductance steps .
this result is in good agreement with experiments ( see fig . 4 of ref . ) .
when the spin of the mn ion is driven further out of equilibrium , in particular in the strong coupling case , the bias asymmetry becomes more pronounced .
such spin - pumping phenomenon can be appreciated by looking at figure [ fig5](a ) , where we show the populations of the six spin states of the mn atom as a function of bias for strong tip to sample coupling ( @xmath142 mev ) . from the figure
one can see that as the bias increases the @xmath139 ground state gets depleted in favour of populating the other five excited states .
in particular already at @xmath147 mv the population of the @xmath148 level is larger than that of the ground state .
[ fig5 ] in th figure we also plot the average magnetization , which is defined as @xmath149 [ see panel ( b ) ] .
intriguingly we find that for negative biases the spin is effectively flipped from @xmath139 to @xmath150 over 25mev range .
such spin flipping results in a large dip in the conductance for negative biases as the tip is no longer collinear to the sample . in fig [ fig6 ]
we present the calculated spectra for the fe atom in the spin polarized case .
we choose parameters in this case that conform with the experimental data of loth _
the fe atom is assumed to carry a quantum mechanical spin of @xmath121 and it also exhibits a transverse easy axis anisotopy of @xmath151mev and an axial anisotropy of @xmath152mev .
we again assume a large value of the onsite energy , @xmath153ev , and we examine the spectra in the strong coupling case of @xmath142mev with a tip polarisation of @xmath154 and magnetic field strength 3 t as used in experiments . in fig 6(a )
we present the conductance spectra for the two cases when the magnetic field is parallel and perpendicular to the easy axis of the atom ( the @xmath155axis in this model ) . as previously
, we present this for both second and third order calculations .
firstly , we notice that the spin polarized tip affects the spectra only in the case of parallel magnetic field where a clear bias assymetry is produced .
no significant assymetry is found in the perpendicular case .
this conforms with the experimental findings and is due to the fact that electron spins in the tip are no longer colinear with localised spin of the fe atom .
as found in previous works @xcite the inclusion of third order effects is vital in reproducing the corresct logarithmic decay at each of the conductance steps , which is particularly noticable for the perpendicular magnetic field .
more significantly , experimental spectra for the parallel case exhibit a zero bias conductance dip which is absent in the 2nd order spectra but appears strongly when third order effects are included .
this can also be seen the calculation of the second derivative of the current in fig 6(b ) where a clear zero bias anomaly is evident in the third order case .
we finally move to discuss the inherent asymmetry measured in the conductance profile , which is usually observed even if the tip is not spin - polarized @xcite .
we model this lineshape feature by including the real part of the full interacting electron - spin self - energy in the description [ see equation ( [ eq:22 ] ) ] .
the structure of this contribution to the self - energy shows an explicit dependence on the on - site energy , @xmath10 , and also a logarithmic peak of width @xmath57 at the onset of an inelastic transition ( @xmath156 ) .
the asymmetry arises from the difference in polarity of the logarithmic peak for @xmath157 .
the self - energy is thus an odd function of both energy and bias .
this results in the conductance profile having a decrease of the step heights for @xmath158 and a increase of them for @xmath159 .
we test this approach by considering the case of a non - spin - polarized tip and a single mn atom .
we use the same anisotropy parameters as for the mn dimer but , for the sale of simplicity , we keep the spin always its equilibrium state and choose @xmath140mev .
figure [ fig7 ] shows the resulting conductance spectra for three different choices of the on - site energy @xmath160 .
it is cear that the closer @xmath160 is to the fermi energy ( 0 ev ) , the greater is the bias asymmetry , while as @xmath160 is increased , the conductance profile becomes more symmetric . in this respect ,
the formalism outlined here is in agreement with the fano lineshape argument @xcite where the degree of asymmetry for electrons tunneling through a single impurity is given by a ratio of the real to the imaginary contributions to the interacting green s function@xcite . as an additional test we consider the case of a mn trimer
, whose spectrum was shown first by hijibehedin _ _ et al.__@xcite to exhibit a large bias asymmetry when measured with a non - magnetic tip .
we model this system by choosing an antiferromagnetic nearest neighbour exchange coupling @xmath1612.3 mev .
furthermore , in order to accurately describe the position of the principle conductance steps in the conductance profile , we also include a ferromagnetic second - nearest - neighbour interaction between the local spins of magnitude @xmath162 - 1.0 mev @xcite .
we again choose to keep the spin system in equilibrium and therefore consider weak coupling between the stm tip and the second atom in the trimer chain ( @xmath140 mev ) .
the best fit to the experimental data is found with @xmath163ev .
figure [ fig8 ] shows the model fit to the experimental data ( from ref . [ ] ) ) . whereas previous calculations did not predict any conductance asymmetry @xcite it is clear from the figure that the inclusion of the real part of the self - energy in the description produces a significant conductance asymmetry
this is most prominent at the principle step height @xmath164 for each bias polarity . although the step height for the negative bias is not as small as that found experimentally , the qualitative trends are similar .
in particular we notice the logarithmic conductance increase ( reduction ) that occurs before ( after ) the onset of the step at @xmath165mev , which also originates from the third order contribution to the self - energy . in this work , based on a perturbative approach of the s - d model
, we have shown that the entire lineshape description can be re - conciliated with experiments by considering an expansion of the self - energy to the third order , which also includes its real part .
as such we have shown that the conductance asymmetry can be described also if the electronic orbitals forming the sample s spin are not explicitly taken into account as also suggested by delgado and fernandez - rossier @xcite .
in conclusion we have studied the lineshape details of the conductance profile of mn atoms deposited on cun and probed with a stm tip either or not carrying spin - polarization .
in particular we have looked closely at the asymmetry of the conductance with the bias polarity .
firstly , we have extended our perturbative approach to spin - scattering to the spin - polarized case and considered an expansion of the complex part of the electronic propagator up to the third order .
this allows us to reproduce the logarithmic decay of the conductance subsequent a conductance step , which is observed in experiments but could not be explained by a second order theory . when the current density is increased and the tip is spin - polarized the conductance profile starts to develop a significant asymmetry with respect to the bias polarity .
these are indicative of the spin system being driven out of equilibrium .
we have then derived a second order expansion of the spin - propagator capable of evaluating the non - equilibrium population of the various spin energy levels .
this was put favorably to the test against a series of experiments probing a single mn and fe ions with a spin - polarized stm tip in an intense magnetic field .
furthermore the same formalism was capable of describing excitations occurring away from the ground state for a mn dimer probed by a non - magnetic tip .
also in this case the agreement with experiments is very satisfactory .
finally , in an attempt to describe the bias asymmetry in the case of non - spin - polarized stm tips we have derived an analytic expression for the real part of the electron - spin interacting self - energy .
this contains logarithmic peaks at the excitation energies that are odd with respect to energy and voltage .
such parity results in an asymmetry in the conductance profiles .
such a scheme was tested for the case of a mn monomer and a mn trimer and compares reasonably well with experiments .
this work is sponsored by the irish research council for science , engineering & technology ( ircset ) .
nb and ss thank science foundation of ireland ( grant no .
08/era / i1759 ) and crann for financial support .
computational resources have been provided by the trinity centre for high performance computing ( tchpc ) .
we wish to thank cyrus hirjibehedin for making the experimental data shown in figures [ fig7 ] available to us .
here we wish to derive a method for calculating the steady - state non - equilibrium distribution of the spin energy levels populations , @xmath166 , due to the coupling with the electrodes . in order to do so we expand equation ( [ eq:5 ] ) up to the @xmath43-th order in the interaction hamiltonian @xmath167_{nm}=\sum_n\frac{(-i)^{n+1}}{n!}\int\limits_c{d}\tau_1\dots\int\limits_c{d}\tau_n\ \times \nonumber \\ & \frac{{\langle}0| t_c\{{h}_\mathrm{e - sp}(\tau_1)\dots{h}_\mathrm{e - sp}(\tau_n)d_{n}(\tau)d_{m}^{\dagger}(\tau')\}|0{\rangle}}{u(-\infty,-\infty)}\:,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath63 is the time - evolution unitary operator and the time - averages are over the known non - interacting @xmath64 ground state @xmath65 . as in equation ( [ eq:8 ] ) the time integration over @xmath66
is ordered on the contour @xmath67 going from @xmath68 to @xmath69 and then returning from @xmath69 to @xmath68 @xcite . by inserting the expression for @xmath61 from equation ( [ eq:3 ] ) into the equation above and by expanding up to the second order
we obtain [ note for the ease of the description we omit the elastic contribution of @xmath168 , which is then included in the final expression in equation ( [ eq:12 ] ) ] @xmath169^{(2)}_{nm}=\frac{(-i)^{3}}{2!}j^2_\mathrm{sd}\sum_{\alpha,\alpha',\beta,\beta'}\int\limits_c{d}\tau_1\int\limits_c{d}\tau_2\ \times \nonumber \\ & { \langle}0|t_c\{c_{\alpha}^{\dagger}(\tau_1)c_{\alpha'}(\tau_1)c_{\beta}^{\dagger}(\tau_2)c_{\beta'}(\tau_2)d_{n}(\tau)d_{m}^{\dagger}(\tau')\}|0{\rangle } \nonumber \\ & \times \sum_{i , j}{\langle}0|t_c\{{s^{i}}(\tau_1){s^{j}}(\tau_2)\}|0{\rangle}[{\sigma}^i]_{{\alpha}{\alpha'}}[{\sigma}^j]_{{\beta}{\beta'}}\:,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the indices @xmath8 and @xmath170 run over the cartesian coordinates @xmath171 , @xmath172 and @xmath173 for the given spin coupled to the tip ( the tip make electronic contact with one spin only ) .
we now substitute into equation ( [ eq:9 ] ) the operator breakdown of the spin from equation ( [ eq:6 ] ) @xmath174^{(2)}_{nm}=\frac{(-i)^{3}}{2!}j^2_\mathrm{sd}\sum_{k , k',l , l'}\int\limits_c{d}\tau_1\int\limits_c{d}\tau_2 \nonumber \\ & \times { \langle}0|t_c\{d_{n}(\tau)d_{k}^{\dagger}(\tau_1)d_{k'}(\tau_1)d_{l}^{\dagger}(\tau_2)d_{l'}(\tau_2)d_{m}^{\dagger}(\tau')\}|0{\rangle } \nonumber \\ & \times \sum_{\alpha,\alpha',\beta,\beta'}{\langle}0|t_c\{c_{\alpha'}(\tau_1)c_{\beta}^{\dagger}(\tau_2)c_{\beta'}(\tau_2)c_{\alpha}^{\dagger}(\tau_1)\}|0{\rangle } \nonumber \\ & \times \sum_{i , j}s_{kk'}^is_{ll'}^j[{\sigma}^i]_{{\alpha}{\alpha'}}[{\sigma}^j]_{{\beta}{\beta'}}\:.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the time - ordered contractions of the two brackets in equation ( [ eq:10 ] ) can be re - written in terms of their respective non - interacting green s functions , @xmath175 and @xmath176 as follows @xmath177^{(2)}_{nm}=-j^2_\mathrm{sd}\sum_{k , k',l , l'}\int\limits_c{d}\tau_1\int\limits_c{d}\tau_2 \nonumber \\ & \times \delta_{nk}\delta_{lk'}\delta_{ml'}[d_0(\tau,\tau_1)]_{nn}[d_0(\tau_1,\tau_2)]_{ll}[d_0(\tau_2,\tau')]_{mm } \nonumber \\ & \times \sum_{\alpha,\alpha',\beta,\beta'}\delta_{\alpha'\beta}\delta_{\alpha\beta'}[g_0(\tau_1,\tau_2)]_{\beta\beta}[g_0(\tau_2,\tau_1)]_{\alpha\alpha } \nonumber \\ & \times \sum_{i , j}s_{kk'}^is_{ll'}^j[{\sigma}^i]_{{\alpha}{\alpha'}}[{\sigma}^j]_{{\beta}{\beta'}},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the extra factor of 2 emerges from the fact that a second contraction of the time - ordered bracket merely exchanges @xmath178 and @xmath179 .
then , by using dyson s equation @xcite , one can write the second order contribution to the interacting spin self - energy ( @xmath180 ) . this reads @xmath181^{(2)}_{nm}=-2j^2_\mathrm{sd}\sum_{\alpha,\beta}[g_0(\tau_1,\tau_2)]_{\beta\beta}[g_0(\tau_2,\tau_1)]_{\alpha\alpha } \nonumber \\ & \times \sum_{l}[d_0(\tau_1,\tau_2)]_{l , l}\sum_{i , j}s^i_{nl}s^j_{lm}[{\sigma}^i]_{{\alpha}{\beta}}[{\sigma}^j]_{{\beta}{\alpha}}\:,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have evoked the assumption that the electrons are spin degenerate thus omitting the spin index on @xmath182 and including a factor of 2 .
we now calculate the real - time quantities , such as the lesser ( greater ) self - energies , by using langreth s theorem for the time ordering over the defined contour @xcite . after including the elastic contribution we obtain @xmath183^{(2)}_{nm}=-2j^2_\mathrm{sd}\sum_{\alpha,\beta}[g^{\lessgtr}_0(t_1,t_2)]_{\beta\beta}[g^{\gtrless}_0(t_2,t_1)]_{\alpha\alpha } \nonumber \\ & \times \sum_{l}[d^{\lessgtr}_0(t_1,t_2)]_{ll}\nonumber \\ & \times\sum_{i , j}\big(s^i_{nl}s^j_{lm}[{\sigma}^i]_{{\alpha}{\beta}}[{\sigma}^j]_{{\beta}{\alpha}}+\delta_{ij}\delta_{\alpha\beta}\chi s^i_{nm}[{\sigma}^i]_{{\alpha}{\beta}}\big)\:.\end{aligned}\ ] ] on computing the fourier transform we note the two different expressions for the lesser and greater green s functions are @xmath184^{(2)}_{nm}=-\frac{j^2_\mathrm{sd}}{\pi}\sum_lp^{\lessgtr}_l\times \nonumber \\ & \sum_{\alpha,\beta}\int\limits_{-\infty}^{+\infty}{d}{\omega}[g_0^{<}(\omega)]_{\beta\beta}[g_0^{>}(\omega\pm(e-\varepsilon_l))]_{\alpha\alpha}\times\nonumber \\ & \sum_{i , j}\big(s^i_{nl}s^j_{lm}[{\sigma}^i]_{{\alpha}{\beta}}[{\sigma}^j]_{{\beta}{\alpha}}+ \delta_{ij}\delta_{\alpha\beta}\chi s^i_{nm}[{\sigma}^i]_{{\alpha}{\beta}}\big),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have defined @xmath185 and @xmath186 and @xmath187 $ ] . by assuming that the spin system is in thermal contact with a heat bath kept at the temperature @xmath46
, the energy levels @xmath188 should be broadened by the factor @xmath189 .
this can be neglected for the ease of the calculation since in general @xmath190 .
however we do not disregard the broadening in the electronic green s function due to contact to tip and substrate as this is pivotal to the calculation of the non - equilibrium spin populations .
j. j. parks , a. r. champagne , t. a. costi , w. w. shum , a. n. pasupathy , e. neuscamman , s. flores - torres , p. s. cornaglia , a. a. aligia , c. a. balseiro , g. k .- l .
chan , h. d. abrua and d. c. ralph1 _ et al .
_ , science * 328 * , 1370 ( 2010 ) . | the conductance profiles of magnetic transition metal atoms , such as fe , co and mn , deposited on surfaces and probed by a scanning tunneling microscope ( stm ) , provide detailed information on the magnetic excitations of such nano - magnets .
in general the profiles are symmetric with respect to the applied bias .
however a set of recent experiments has shown evidence for inherent asymmetries when either a normal or a spin - polarized stm tip is used . in order to explain such asymmetries here we expand our previously developed perturbative approach to electron - spin scattering to the spin - polarized case and to the inclusion of out of equilibrium spin populations . in the case of a magnetic stm tip
we demonstrate that the asymmetries are driven by the non - equilibrium occupation of the various atomic spin - levels , an effect that reminds closely that electron spin - transfer .
in contrast when the tip is not spin - polarized such non - equilibrium population can not be build up . in this circumstance
we propose that the asymmetry simply originates from the transition metal ion density of state , which is included here as a non - vanishing real component to the spin - scattering self - energy . |
recall a polynomial @xmath0 is _ postcritically finite _ if the forward orbits of its critical points are finite .
then the filled julia set of @xmath1 contains a forward invariant , finite topological tree , called the _ hubbard tree _ @xcite .
the _ core entropy _ of @xmath1 is the topological entropy of the restriction of @xmath1 to its hubbard tree .
we shall restrict ourselves to quadratic polynomials .
given @xmath2 , the external ray at angle @xmath3 determines a postcritically finite parameter @xmath4 in the mandelbrot set @xcite .
we define @xmath5 to be the core entropy of @xmath6 .
the main goal of this paper is to prove the following result : [ t : main ] the core entropy function @xmath7 extends to a continuous function from @xmath8 to @xmath9 .
the theorem answers a question of w. thurston , who first introduced and explored the core entropy of polynomials .
as thurston showed , the core entropy function can be defined purely combinatorially , but it displays a rich fractal structure ( figure [ f : core ] ) , which reflects the underlying geometry of the mandelbrot set .
[ f : core ] the concept of core entropy generalizes to complex polynomials the entropy theory of real quadratic maps , whose monotonicity and continuity go back to milnor and thurston @xcite : indeed , the invariant real segment is replaced by the invariant tree , which captures all the essential dynamics .
on the topological side , hubbard trees have been introduced to classify postcritically finite maps @xcite , @xcite , and their entropy provides a new tool to study the parameter space of polynomials : for instance , the restriction of @xmath5 to non - real veins of the mandelbrot set is also monotone @xcite , which implies that the lamination for the mandelbrot set can be reconstructed by looking at level sets of @xmath10 . note by comparison that the entropy of @xmath11 on its julia set is constant , independent of @xmath3 , hence it does not give information on the parameter .
furthermore , the value @xmath5 equals , up to a constant factor , the hausdorff dimension of the set of biaccessible angles for @xmath11 ( @xcite , @xcite ) . for dendritic julia sets , the core entropy also equals the asymptotic stretch factor of @xmath11 as a rational map @xcite .
a rational external angle @xmath3 determines a postcritically finite map @xmath11 , which has a finite hubbard tree @xmath12 .
the simplest way to compute its entropy is to compute the markov transition matrix for the map @xmath11 acting on @xmath12 , and take ( the logarithm of ) its leading eigenvalue : however , this requires to know the topology of @xmath12 , which changes wildly after small perturbations of @xmath3 . in this paper , we shall by - pass this issue by leveraging an algorithm , devised by thurston , which considers instead a larger matrix , whose entries are _ pairs _ of postcritical angles ( see section [ s : algo ] ) ; no knowledge of the topology of the hubbard tree is required . in order to prove @xmath10 is continuous , we develop an infinite version of such algorithm , which is defined for _ any _ angle @xmath13 .
in particular , instead of taking the leading eigenvalue of a transition matrix , we shall encode the possible transitions in a directed graph , which will now have countably many vertices . by taking the _ spectral determinant _ of such graph ( see section [ s : spectral ] for a definition ) , for each angle @xmath13 , we construct a power series @xmath14 which converges in the unit disk and such that its smallest zero " @xmath15 is related to the core entropy by @xmath16 we then produce an algorithm to compute each coefficient of the taylor expansion of @xmath14 , and show that essentially these coefficients vary continuously with @xmath3 : the result follows by rouch s theorem . as a corollary of our method
, we shall prove that the entropy function is actually hlder continuous at angles @xmath3 such that @xmath17 ( using renormalization , it can be proven that @xmath10 is not hlder continuous where @xmath18 ) . on the way to our proof
, we shall develop a few general combinatorial tools to deal with growth rates of countable graphs , which may be of independent interest .
we define a countable graph @xmath19 with bounded ( outgoing ) degree to have _ bounded cycles _ if it has finitely many closed paths of any given length . in this case
, we define the _ growth rate _ of @xmath19 as the growth rate with @xmath20 of the number of closed paths of length @xmath20 ( see definition [ d : growth ] ) ; as it turns out ( theorem [ t : rootofp ] ) , the inverse of the growth rate equals the smallest zero of the following function @xmath21 , constructed by counting the multi - cycles in the graph : @xmath22 where @xmath23 is the number of components of the multi - cycle @xmath24 , and @xmath25 is its length .
( for the definition of multi - cycle , see section [ s : graphs ] ; note that our graphs have finite outgoing degree but possibly infinite ingoing degree , hence the adjacency operator has infinite @xmath26-norm and the usual spectral theory ( see e.g. @xcite ) does not apply ) .
we then define a general combinatorial object , called _ labeled wedge _ , which consists of pairs of integers which can be labeled either as being _ separated _ ( representing two elements of the postcritical set which lie on opposite sides of the critical point ) or _ non - separated _ ; to such object we associate an infinite graph , and prove that it has bounded cycles , hence one can apply the theory developed in the first part ( see theorem [ t : zero ] ) .
finally , we shall apply these combinatorial techniques to the core entropy ( section [ s : core ] ) ; indeed , we associate to any external angle @xmath3 a labeled wedge @xmath27 , hence an infinite graph @xmath28 , and verify that : 1 .
the growth rate of @xmath28 varies continuously as a function of @xmath3 ( theorem [ t : newmain ] ) ; 2 .
the growth rate of @xmath28 coincides with the core entropy for rational angles ( theorem [ t : coincide ] ) .
let us remark that , as a consequence of monotonicity along veins and theorem [ t : main ] , the continuous extension we define also coincides with the core entropy for parameters which are not necessarily postcritically finite , but for which the julia set is locally connected and the hubbard tree is topologically finite . the core entropy of polynomials has been introduced by w. thurston around 2011 ( even though there are earlier related results , e.g. @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) but most of the theory is yet unpublished ( with the exception of section 6 in @xcite ) .
several people are now collecting his writings and correspondence into a foundational paper @xcite .
in particular , the validity of thurston s algorithm has been proven by tan l. , gao y. , and w. jung ( see @xcite , @xcite ) .
continuity of the core entropy along principal veins in the mandelbrot set is proven by the author in @xcite , and along all veins by w. jung @xcite .
note that the previous methods used for veins do not easily generalize , since the topology of the tree is constant along veins but not globally .
after @xcite , alternative proofs of monotonicity and continuity of entropy for real maps are given in @xcite , @xcite ( the present proof independently yields continuity ) .
biaccessible external angles and their dimension have been discussed in @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite .
the method we use to count closed paths in the graph bears many similarities with the theory of _ dynamical zeta functions _
@xcite , and several forms of the spectral determinant are used in thermodynamic formalism ( see e.g. @xcite , @xcite ) . moreover , the spectral determinant @xmath21 we use is an infinite version of the _ clique polynomial _ used in @xcite to study finite directed graphs with small entropy . the motivation for our combinatorial construction is thurston s algorithm to compute the core entropy for rational angles , which we shall now describe .
let @xmath2 a rational number @xmath29 .
then the external ray at angle @xmath3 in the mandelbrot set lands at a misiurewicz parameter , or at the root of a hyperbolic component : let @xmath1 denote the corresponding postcritically finite quadratic map . we shall call @xmath30 the critical point of @xmath1 , and for each @xmath31 , @xmath32 the @xmath33 iterate of the critical point .
recall that the _ hubbard tree _ of @xmath1 is the union of the regulated arcs @xmath34 $ ] for all @xmath35 ( for more details , see @xcite ) . in the postcritically finite case , it is a finite topological tree , and it is forward - invariant under @xmath1 ( see figure [ f : tree ] ) .
it is possible to compute the core entropy of @xmath1 by writing the markov transition matrix for the action of @xmath1 on the tree , and take the logarithm of its leading eigenvalue .
however , given the external angle @xmath3 it is quite complicated to figure out the topology of the tree : the following algorithm by - passes this issue by looking at pairs of external angles . in order to explain the algorithm in more detail ,
let us remark that a rational angle @xmath3 is eventually periodic under the doubling map @xmath36 ; that is , there exist integers @xmath37 and @xmath38 such that the elements of the set @xmath39 are all distinct modulo @xmath40 , and @xmath41 .
the elements of @xmath42 will be called _ postcritical angles _ ; the number @xmath43 is called the _ period _ of @xmath3 , and @xmath44 is the _ pre - period_. if @xmath45 , we shall call @xmath3 _
purely periodic_. denote @xmath46 the partition of the circle @xmath47 in the two intervals @xmath48 moreover , for each @xmath49 let us denote @xmath50 , which we see as a point in @xmath51 .
let us now construct a matrix @xmath52 which will be used to compute the core entropy . denote @xmath53 the set of unordered pairs of ( distinct ) elements of @xmath42 : this is a finite set , any element of which will be denoted @xmath54 .
we now define a linear map @xmath55 by defining it on its basis vectors in the following way : * if @xmath56 and @xmath57 belong to the same element of the partition @xmath46 , or at least one of them lies on the boundary , we shall say that the pair @xmath54 is _ non - separated _ , and define @xmath58 * if @xmath56 and @xmath57 belong to the interiors of two different elements of @xmath46 , then we say that @xmath54 is _ separated _ , and define @xmath59 ( in order to make sure the formulas are defined in all cases , we shall set @xmath60 whenever @xmath61 ) . by abuse of notation , we shall also denote @xmath52 the matrix representing the linear map @xmath52 in the standard basis . as suggested by thurston in his correspondence ,
the leading eigenvalue of @xmath52 gives the core entropy : [ t : algo ] let @xmath3 a rational angle.then the core entropy @xmath5 of the quadratic polynomial of external angle @xmath3 is related to the largest real eigenvalue @xmath62 of the matrix @xmath52 by the formula @xmath63 the explanation of this algorithm is the following .
let @xmath64 be a complete graph whose vertices are labeled by elements of @xmath42 , and which we shall consider as a topological space .
( more concretely , we can take the unit disk and draw segments between all possible pairs of postcritical angles on the unit circle : the union of all such segments is a model for @xmath64 ( see figure [ f : chords_algo ] ) ) .
let us denote by @xmath65 the hubbard tree of @xmath1 .
we can define a continuous map @xmath66 which sends the edge with vertices @xmath56 , @xmath57 homeomorphically to the regulated arc @xmath34 $ ] in @xmath65 ( except in the case @xmath67 , where we map all the edge to a single point ) . finally , we can lift the dynamics @xmath68 to a map @xmath69 such that @xmath70 . in order to do so ,
note that : * if the pair of angles @xmath54 is non - separated , then @xmath1 maps the arc @xmath34 $ ] homeomorphically onto @xmath71 $ ] ; hence to define @xmath72 we have to lift @xmath1 so that it maps the edge @xmath73 $ ] homeomorphically onto @xmath74 $ ] ; * if instead @xmath54 is separated , then the critical point @xmath30 lies on the regulated arc @xmath34 $ ] in the hubbard tree ; thus , @xmath1 maps the arc @xmath75 = [ c_i , c_0 ] \cup [ c_0 , c_j]$ ] onto @xmath76 \cup [ c_1 , c_{j+1}]$ ] ; so we define @xmath72 by lifting @xmath1 and so that it maps @xmath73 $ ] continuously onto the union @xmath77 \cup [ x_1 , x_{j+1}]$ ] .
the map @xmath72 is a markov map of a topological graph , hence its entropy is the logarithm of the leading eigenvalue of its transition matrix , which is by construction the matrix @xmath52 . in case @xmath3
is purely periodic , one can prove that the map @xmath78 is surjective and finite - to - one , and semiconjugates the dynamics @xmath72 on @xmath64 to the dynamics @xmath1 on @xmath65 , hence @xmath79 more care is needed in the pre - periodic case , since @xmath78 can collapse arcs to points ( for details , see @xcite , @xcite , or @xcite ) .
in the following , by _ graph _ we mean a directed graph @xmath19 , i.e. a set @xmath80 of vertices ( which will be finite or countable ) and a set @xmath81 of edges , such that each edge @xmath82 has a well - defined _ source _ @xmath83 and a _ target _ @xmath84
( thus , we allow edges between a vertex and itself , and multiple edges between two vertices ) . given a vertex @xmath85 ,
the set @xmath86 of its _ outgoing edges _ is the set of edges with source @xmath85 .
the _ outgoing degree _ of @xmath85 is the cardinality of @xmath86 ; a graph is _ locally finite _ if the outgoing degree of all its vertices is finite , and has _ bounded outgoing degree _ if there is a uniform upper bound @xmath87 on the outgoing degree of all its vertices .
note that we do _ not _ require that the ingoing degree is finite , and indeed in our application we will encounter graphs with vertices having countably many ingoing edges . we denote as @xmath88 the set of vertices of @xmath19 , and as @xmath89 its set of edges .
moreover , we denote as @xmath90 the number of edges from vertex @xmath85 to vertex @xmath91 .
a _ path _ in the graph based at a vertex @xmath85 is a sequence @xmath92 of edges such that @xmath93 , and @xmath94 for @xmath95 .
the _ length _ of the path is the number @xmath20 of edges , and the set of vertices @xmath96 visited by the path is called its _ vertex - suppoert _ , or just _ support _ for simplicity .
similarly , a _ closed path _ based at @xmath85 is a path @xmath92 such that @xmath97 .
note that in this definition a closed path can intersect itself , i.e. two of the sources of the @xmath98 can be the same ; moreover , closed paths with different starting vertices will be considered to be different . on the other hand , a _
simple cycle _ is a closed path which does not self - intersect , modulo cyclical equivalence : that is , a simple cycle is a closed path @xmath92 such that @xmath99 for @xmath100 , and two such paths are considered the same simple cycle if the edges are cyclically permuted , i.e. @xmath92 and @xmath101 designate the same simple cycle .
finally , a _
multi - cycle _ is the union of finitely many simple cycles with pairwise disjoint ( vertex-)supports . the length of a multi - cycle is the sum of the lengths of its components . given a countable graph with bounded outgoing degree , we define the _ adjacency operator _
@xmath102 on the space of summable sequences indexed by the vertex set @xmath80 .
in fact , for each vertex @xmath103 we can consider the sequence @xmath104 which is @xmath40 at position @xmath49 and @xmath105 otherwise , and define for each @xmath106 the @xmath107 component of the vector @xmath108 to be @xmath109 equal to the number of edges from @xmath49 to @xmath110 .
since the graph has bounded outgoing degree , the above definition can actually be extended to all @xmath111 , and the operator norm of @xmath112 induced by the @xmath113-norm is bounded above by the outgoing degree @xmath114 of the graph .
note moreover that for each pair @xmath115 of vertices and each @xmath20 , the coefficient @xmath116 equals the number of paths of length @xmath20 from @xmath49 to @xmath110 .
we say a countable graph @xmath19 has _ bounded cycles _ if it has bounded outgoing degree and for each positive integer @xmath20 , @xmath19 has at most finitely many simple cycles of length @xmath20 . note that , if @xmath19 has bounded cycles , then for each @xmath20 it has also a finite number of closed paths of length @xmath20 , since the support of any closed path of length @xmath20 is contained in the union of the supports of simple cycles with length @xmath117 .
thus , for such graphs we shall denote @xmath118 the number of closed paths of length @xmath20 .
note that in this case the trace @xmath119 is also well - defined for each @xmath20 , and equal to @xmath120 .
[ d : growth ] if @xmath19 is a graph with bounded cycles , we define the _ growth rate _ @xmath121 as the exponential growth rate of the number of its closed paths : that is , @xmath122{c(\gamma , n)}.\ ] ] if @xmath19 is a finite graph with adjacency matrix @xmath112 , then is well - defined its characteristic polynomial @xmath123 , whose roots are the eigenvalues of @xmath112 . in the following
we shall work with the related polynomial @xmath124 which we call the _ spectral determinant _ of @xmath19 .
we shall now extend the theory to countable graphs with bounded cycles .
it is known that the spectral determinant @xmath21 of a finite graph @xmath19 is related to its multi - cycles by the following formula ( see e.g. @xcite ) : @xmath125 where @xmath25 denotes the length of the multi - cycle @xmath24 , while @xmath23 is the number of connected components of @xmath24 .
if @xmath19 is now a ( directed ) graph with countably many vertices and bounded cycles , then the number of multi - cycles of any given length is finite , hence the formula above is still defined as a formal power series .
note that we include also the empty cycle , which has zero components and zero length , hence @xmath21 begins with the constant term @xmath40 .
now , let @xmath126 denote the number of multi - cycles of length @xmath20 in @xmath19 , and let us define @xmath127{k(\gamma , n)}\ ] ] its growth rate .
then the main result of this section is the following : [ t : rootofp ] suppose we have @xmath128 ; then the formula defines a holomorphic function @xmath129 in the unit disk @xmath130 , and moreover the function @xmath129 is non - zero in the disk @xmath131 ; if @xmath132 , we also have @xmath133 .
the proof uses in a crucial way the following combinatorial statement .
[ l:1/pt ] let @xmath19 be a countable graph with bounded cycles , and @xmath112 its adjacency operator .
then we have the equalities of formal power series @xmath134 where @xmath21 is the spectral determinant .
note that , since @xmath21 is a power series with constant term @xmath40 , then @xmath135 is indeed a well - defined power series .
the second equality is just obtained by expanding the exponential function in power series . to prove the first equality ,
let us first suppose @xmath19 is a finite graph with @xmath20 vertices , and let @xmath136 be the eigenvalues of its adjacency matrix ( counted with algebraic multiplicity ) .
then @xmath137 hence @xmath138 hence the claim follows since @xmath139 .
now , let @xmath19 be infinite with bounded cycles , and let @xmath140 .
note that both sides of the equation depend , modulo @xmath141 , only on multi - cycles of length @xmath142 , which by the bounded cycle condition are supported on a finite subgraph @xmath143 .
thus by applying the previous proof to @xmath143 we obtain equality modulo @xmath141 , and since this holds for any @xmath144 the claim is proven . by the root test
, the radius of convergence of @xmath145 is @xmath146 .
thus , since the exponential function has infinite radius of convergence , the radius of convergence of @xmath147 is at least @xmath146 , and since @xmath148 where @xmath149 has positive coefficients , then the radius of convergence of @xmath147 is exactly equal to @xmath146 .
hence , by lemma [ l:1/pt ] , the radius of convergence of @xmath135 around @xmath150 is also @xmath146 . on the other hand , since @xmath128 , then by the root test the power series @xmath21 converges inside the unit disk , and defines a holomorphic function ; thus , @xmath135 is meromorphic for @xmath151 , and holomorphic for @xmath152 , hence @xmath153 if @xmath152 . moreover ,
if @xmath154 , then the radius of convergence of @xmath135 equals the smallest modulus of one of its poles , hence @xmath146 is the smallest modulus of a zero of @xmath21 .
finally , since @xmath135 has all its taylor coefficients real and nonnegative , then the smallest modulus of its poles must also be a pole , so @xmath133 .
[ l : perroneig ] if @xmath19 is a finite graph , then its growth rate equals the largest real eigenvalue of its adjacency matrix .
note that , by the perron - frobenius theorem , since the adjacency matrix is non - negative , it has at least one real eigenvalue whose modulus is at least as large as the modulus of any other eigenvalue . moreover , if @xmath62 is the largest real eigenvalue , then @xmath155 is the smallest root of the spectral determinant @xmath21 , hence the claim follows from theorem [ t : rootofp ] .
let @xmath156 two ( locally finite ) graphs .
a _ graph map _ from @xmath157 to @xmath158 is a map @xmath159 on the vertex sets and a map on edges @xmath160 which is compatible , in the sense that if the edge @xmath82 connects @xmath85 to @xmath91 in @xmath157 , then the edge @xmath161 connects @xmath162 to @xmath163 in @xmath158 .
we shall usually denote such a map as @xmath164 .
weak cover _ of graphs is a graph map @xmath164 such that : * the map @xmath159 between the vertex sets is surjective ; * the induced map @xmath165 between outgoing edges is a bijection for each @xmath166 .
note that the map between outgoing edges is defined because @xmath167 is a graph map , and @xmath167 also induces a map from paths in @xmath157 to paths in @xmath158 . as a consequence of the definition of weak cover , you have the following _ unique path lifting _ property : let @xmath164 a weak cover of graphs . then given @xmath166 and @xmath168 , for every path @xmath24 in @xmath158 based at @xmath91
there is a unique path @xmath169 in @xmath157 based at @xmath85 such that @xmath170 .
let @xmath166 and @xmath168 , and let @xmath171 be a path in @xmath158 based at @xmath91 . since the map @xmath172 is a bijection , there exists exactly one edge @xmath173 such that @xmath174 . by compatibility , the target @xmath175 of @xmath176 projects to the target of @xmath177 ,
hence we can apply the same reasoning and lift the second edge @xmath178 uniquely starting from @xmath175 , and so on .
an immediate consequence of the property is the following [ l : easyineq ] each graph map @xmath164 induces a map @xmath179 for each @xmath180 and each @xmath181 .
moreveor , if @xmath167 is a weak cover , then @xmath182 is injective .
a general way to construct weak covers of graphs is the following .
suppose we have an equivalence relation @xmath183 on the vertex set @xmath80 of a locally finite graph , and denote @xmath184 the set of equivalence classes of vertices .
such an equivalence relation is called _ edge - compatible _ if whenever @xmath185 , for any vertex @xmath91 the total number of edges from @xmath186 to the members of the equivalence class of @xmath91 equals the total number of edges from @xmath187 to the members of the equivalence class of @xmath91 .
when we have such an equivalence relation , we can define a quotient graph @xmath188 with vertex set @xmath184 .
namely , we denote for each @xmath189 the respective equivalence classes as @xmath190 $ ] and @xmath191 $ ] , and define the number of edges from @xmath190 $ ] to @xmath191 $ ] in the quotient graph to be @xmath192 \to [ w ] ) : = \sum_{u \in [ w ] } \#(v \to u).\ ] ] by definition of edge - compatibility , the above sum does not depend on the representative @xmath85 chosen inside the class @xmath190 $ ] .
moreover , it is easy to see that the quotient map @xmath193 is a weak cover of graphs .
let us now relate the growth of a graph to the growth of its weak covers .
[ l : growthcover ] let @xmath164 a weak cover of graphs with bounded cycles , and @xmath194 a finite set of vertices of @xmath157 . 1 .
suppose that every closed path in @xmath157 passes through @xmath194 .
then for each @xmath20 we have the estimate @xmath195 which implies @xmath196 2 .
suppose that @xmath197 is a set of closed paths in @xmath158 such that each @xmath198 crosses at least one vertex @xmath91 with the property that : the set @xmath199 is non - empty , and any lift of @xmath24 from an element of @xmath200 ends in @xmath200 .
then there exists @xmath201 , which depends on @xmath194 , such that for each @xmath20 we have @xmath202 \(1 ) let @xmath24 be a closed path in @xmath157 of length @xmath20 , based at @xmath85 .
let now @xmath203 be the first vertex of @xmath24 which belongs to @xmath194 ( by hypothesis , there is one ) .
if we call @xmath204 the cyclical permutation of @xmath24 based at @xmath203 , the projection of @xmath204 to @xmath158 now yields a closed path @xmath205 in @xmath158 which is based at @xmath206 . now note that for each such pair @xmath207 , there are at most @xmath208 possible choices for @xmath209 ; then , given @xmath203 there is a unique lift of @xmath205 from @xmath203 , and @xmath20 possible choices for the vertex @xmath85 on that lift , giving the estimate .
\(2 ) recall first that in every directed graph we can define an equivalence relation by saying @xmath210 if there is a path from @xmath85 to @xmath91 and a path from @xmath91 to @xmath85 .
the equivalence classes are known as _ strongly connected components _ , or @xmath211 for short .
moreover , we can form a graph @xmath212 whose vertices are the strongly connected components and there is an edge from the s.c.c .
@xmath213 to @xmath214 if in the original graph there is a path from an element of @xmath213 to an element of @xmath214 .
note that by construction this graph has no cycles .
moreover , let us consider a pair @xmath215 of distinct elements of @xmath194 ; then either there is no path from @xmath186 to @xmath187 , or we can pick some path from @xmath186 to @xmath187 , which will be denoted @xmath216 .
then the set @xmath217 of such paths is finite , and let @xmath72 be the maximum length of an element of @xmath218 .
let now @xmath24 be a closed path in @xmath158 based at @xmath219 . by hypothesis
, @xmath24 passes through some @xmath91 such that @xmath220 , and each lift of @xmath24 from @xmath200 ends in @xmath200 .
let us now consider the set @xmath221 of all s.c.c . of @xmath157 which intersect @xmath200 :
since the graph @xmath212 constructed above has no cycles , there is a component @xmath222 which has the property that there is no path from @xmath223 to some other component of @xmath200 .
thus , if we pick @xmath224 and lift @xmath24 from @xmath85 to a path @xmath169 in @xmath157 , the endpoint @xmath175 of @xmath169 must lie inside @xmath200 by hypothesis .
thus , by the property of @xmath223 , the vertex @xmath175 lies in @xmath223 , hence there is a path @xmath225 from @xmath175 to @xmath85 in the previously chosen set @xmath218 , hence if we take @xmath226 , this is a closed path in @xmath157 of length between @xmath20 and @xmath227 .
thus we have a map @xmath228 given by @xmath229 .
now , given @xmath85 we can recover @xmath230 , and given @xmath205 we can recover @xmath24 , since @xmath24 is the path given by the first @xmath20 edges of @xmath231 starting at @xmath91 . finally , we have at most @xmath20 choices for the starting point @xmath219 on @xmath24 , hence the fibers of the above map have cardinality at most @xmath20 , proving the claim . an immediate corollary of the lemma is the following , when @xmath157 and @xmath158 are both finite .
[ l : sameentro ] let @xmath156 be finite graphs , and @xmath164 a weak cover .
then the growth rate of @xmath157 equals the growth rate of @xmath158 .
apply the lemma with @xmath232 , and @xmath197 equal to the set of all closed paths in @xmath158 .
let us consider the set @xmath233 of pairs of disjoint positive integers .
the set @xmath234 will be sometimes called the _ wedge _ and , given an element @xmath235 , the coordinate @xmath49 will be called the _ height _ of @xmath85 , while the coordinate @xmath110 will be called the _ width _ of @xmath85 .
the terminology becomes more clear by looking at figure [ f : wedge ] .
@xmath236 we call a _ labeled wedge _ an assignment @xmath237 of a label @xmath238 ( which stands for _ non - separated _ ) or @xmath194 ( which stands for _ separated _ ) to each element of @xmath234 .
now , to each labeled wedge @xmath239 we assign a graph @xmath240 in the following way .
the vertex set of @xmath240 is the wedge @xmath234 , while the edges of @xmath240 are labeled by the set @xmath241 and determined according to the following rule . *
if @xmath242 is non - separated , then @xmath243 has as its ( unique ) successor the vertex @xmath244 ; we say that the edge @xmath245 is an _ upward edge _ and we label it with @xmath246 ; * if @xmath247 is separated , then @xmath247 has two successors : * * first , we add the edge @xmath248 , which we call _ forward edge _ and label it with @xmath249 . * * second , we add the edge @xmath250 , which we call _ backward edge _ and label it with @xmath251 . in order to explain the names , note that following an upward or forward edge increases the width by @xmath40 , while following a backward edge ( weakly ) decreases it . moreover , following an upward edge increases the height by @xmath40 , while the targets of both backward and forward edges have height @xmath40 .
@xmath252\txt{(2,4 ) } & ( 2,5 ) & \cdots \\ * + [ f]\txt{(1,2 ) } & ( 1,3 ) & * + [ f]\txt{(1,4 ) } & ( 1,5 ) & \cdots \\ } \ ] ] @xmath253^u & ( 3,5 ) & \cdots \\ & ( 2,3 ) \ar[ur]^u & * + [ f]\txt{(2,4 ) } \ar[dr]^f \ar@/_/[dl]_b & ( 2,5 ) & \cdots \\ * + [ f]\txt{(1,2 ) } \ar@(u , l)_b \ar[r]^f & ( 1,3 ) \ar[ur]_u & * + [ f]\txt{(1,4 ) } \ar[r]^f \ar@/^/[ll]^b & ( 1,5 ) & \cdots \\ } \ ] ] [ p : properties ] let @xmath240 the graph associated to the labeled wedge @xmath239
. then the following are true : 1 .
each vertex of a closed path of length @xmath20 has height at most @xmath20 ; 2 .
the support of each closed path of length @xmath20 intersects the set @xmath254 ; 3 .
each vertex of a closed path of length @xmath20 has width at most @xmath255 ; 4 . for each @xmath256
, there exists at most one separated vertex in the @xmath257 diagonal @xmath258 which is contained in the support of at least one closed path ; 5 . there are at most @xmath259 multi - cycles of length @xmath20 .
note that ( 1 ) , ( 2 ) , ( 3 ) are sharp , as seen by the simple cycle @xmath260^u & 25 \ar@/^/[r]^u & * + [ f]\txt{36 } \ar@/^/[ll]^b } \ ] ] \(1 ) let us first note that every closed path contains at least one backward edge , since the upward and forward edges always increase the height .
moreover , the endpoint of a backward edge has always height @xmath40 , and each edge increases the height by at most @xmath40 , hence the height of a vertex along the closed path is at most @xmath20 .
\(2 ) since the target of each backward edge is @xmath261 , where @xmath49 is the height of the source of the edge , which is at most @xmath20 by the previous point , then the target of each backward edge along the closed path belongs to the set @xmath262 .
\(3 ) by the previous point , there is at least a vertex along the closed path with width at most @xmath263 .
since every move increases the width by at most @xmath40 , then the largest possible width of a vertex along the path is @xmath264 .
\(4 ) let @xmath265 be the separated vertex in @xmath266 with smallest height , if there is one .
we claim that no vertex @xmath267 of @xmath266 with @xmath268 belongs to any closed path . note by looking at the rules that , if a vertex @xmath269 of height @xmath270 is the target of some edge , then it must be the target of an upward edge , more precisely an edge from the vertex @xmath271 immediately to the lower left of @xmath85 , which then must be non - separated .
thus , since @xmath272 is separated , the vertex @xmath273 does not belong to any closed path ; the claim then follows by induction on @xmath274 , since , by the same reasoning , if @xmath275 belongs to some closed path , then also @xmath276 must belong to the same path .
\(5 ) let @xmath277 the backward edges along a multi - cycle @xmath24 of length @xmath20 , and denote @xmath278 the source of @xmath98 , and @xmath279 the height of @xmath278 .
note that the set @xmath280 determines @xmath24 , as you can start from @xmath186 , follow the backward edge , and then follow upward or forward edges until you either close the loop or encounter another @xmath278 , and then continue this way until you walk along all of @xmath24 .
moreover , we know that for each @xmath278 there are at most @xmath255 possible choices , as each @xmath278 is separated and by ( 4 ) there is at most one for each diagonal @xmath266 , and by ( 3 ) it must lie on some @xmath266 with @xmath281 .
we now claim that @xmath282 which is then sufficient to complete the proof .
let us now prove the claim . by definition of multi - cycle , then the targets of the @xmath98 must be all distinct , and by the rule these targets are precisely @xmath283 with @xmath284 , hence all @xmath279 must be distinct . moreover , let us note that each @xmath98 must be preceded along the multi - cycle by a sequence @xmath285 of upward edges of length @xmath286 , and all such sequences for distinct @xmath49 must be disjoint .
hence we have that all @xmath279 are distinct and their total sum is at most the length of the multi - cycle , i.e. @xmath20 . thus we have @xmath287 which proves the claim .
[ t : zero ] let @xmath239 be a labeled wedge . then its associated graph @xmath19 has bounded cycles , and its spectral determinant @xmath21 defines a holomorphic function in the unit disk .
moreover , the growth rate @xmath288 of the graph @xmath19 equals the inverse of the smallest real positive root of @xmath129 , in the following sense : @xmath289 for @xmath131 and , if @xmath132 , then @xmath133 . by construction ,
the outgoing degree of any vertex of @xmath19 is at most @xmath290 .
moreover , by proposition [ p : properties ] ( 5 ) the graph has bounded cycles , and the growth rate of the number @xmath126 of multi - cycles is @xmath291 , since @xmath292{(2n)^{\sqrt{2n } } } = \limsup_{n } e^{\frac{\sqrt{2 } \log(2n)}{\sqrt{n } } } = 1.\ ] ] the claim then follows by theorem [ t : rootofp ] .
we shall sometimes denote as @xmath293 the growth rate of the graph associated to the labeled wedge @xmath239 .
we say that a sequence @xmath294 of labeled wedges converges to @xmath239 if for each finite set of vertices @xmath295 there exists @xmath238 such for each @xmath296 the labels of the elements of @xmath194 for @xmath297 and @xmath239 are the same .
[ l : contwedge ] if a sequence of labeled wedges @xmath294 converges to @xmath239 , then the growth rate of @xmath297 converges to the growth rate of @xmath239 .
let @xmath298 and @xmath21 denote respectively the spectral determinants of @xmath297 and @xmath239 .
then for each @xmath256 , the coefficient of @xmath299 in @xmath298 converges to the coefficient of @xmath299 in @xmath21 , because by proposition [ p : properties ] ( 1 ) and ( 3 ) the support of any multi - cycle of length @xmath300 is contained in the finite subgraph @xmath301 .
thus , since the modulus of the coefficient of @xmath299 is uniformly bounded above by @xmath302 , then @xmath303 uniformly on compact subsets of the unit disk .
thus , by rouch s theorem , the smallest real positive zero of @xmath298 converges to the smallest real positive zero of @xmath21 , hence by theorem [ t : zero ] we have @xmath304 .
given integers @xmath37 and @xmath38 we define the equivalence relation @xmath305 on @xmath306 by saying that @xmath307 if : * either @xmath308 and @xmath309 ; * or @xmath310 and @xmath311
. note that if @xmath45 the equivalence relation @xmath312 is simply the congruence modulo @xmath43 .
a set of representatives for the equivalence classes of @xmath312 is the set @xmath313 .
the equivalence relation induces an equivalence relation on the set @xmath314 of ordered pairs of integers by saying that @xmath315
if @xmath316 and @xmath317 . moreover , it also induces an equivalence relation on the set of _ unordered pairs _ of integers by saying that the unordered pair @xmath318 is equivalent to @xmath319 if either @xmath320 or @xmath321 .
a labeled wedge is _ periodic _ of period @xmath43 and pre - period @xmath44 if the following two conditions hold : * any two pairs @xmath247 and @xmath322 such that @xmath323 have the same label ; * if @xmath307 , then the pair @xmath247 is non - separated .
if @xmath324 , the labeled wedge will be called _ purely periodic_. a pair @xmath247 with @xmath325 will be called _ diagonal _ ; hence the second point in the definition can be rephrased as every diagonal pair is non - separated " .
@xmath326 & \dots \\ & & ( 3,4 ) \ar[ur ] & ( 3 , 5 ) \ar[ur ] & \dots\\ & * + [ f]\txt{(2,3 ) } \ar[d ] \ar[dr ] & * + [ f]\txt{(2,4 ) } \ar[dl ] \ar[dr ] & * + [ f]\txt{(2 , 5 ) } \ar[dll ] \ar[dr ] & \dots \\ ( 1,2 ) \ar[ur ] & * + [ f]\txt{(1,3 ) } \ar[r ] \ar[l ] & * + [ f]\txt{(1 , 4 ) } \ar[r ] & * + [ f]\txt{(1 , 5 ) } \ar[r ] & \dots}\ ] ] @xmath327\txt{(2,3 ) } \ar@<0.5ex>[d ] \ar@<-0.5ex>[d ] \\ ( 1,2 ) \ar[ur ] & * + [ f]\txt{(1,3 ) } \ar[l ] \ar@(d , r ) } \ ] ] given a periodic wedge @xmath239 of period @xmath43 and pre - period @xmath44 , with associated ( infinite ) graph @xmath19 , we shall now construct a finite graph @xmath328 which captures the essential features of the infinite graph @xmath19 , in particular its growth rate .
the set of vertices of @xmath328 is the set of @xmath312-equivalence classes of non - diagonal , unordered pairs of integers .
a set of representatives of @xmath329 is the set @xmath330 the edges of @xmath328 are induced by the edges of @xmath19 , that is are determined by the following rules : if the unordered pair @xmath318 is non - separated , then @xmath318 has one outgoing edge , namely @xmath331 ; while if @xmath318 is separated , then @xmath318 has the two outgoing edges @xmath332 , and @xmath333 . the main result of this section is the following . [
p : finiteinfinite ] let @xmath239 be a periodic labeled edge , with associated ( infinite ) graph @xmath19
. then the growth rate of @xmath19 equals the growth rate of its finite model @xmath328 . in order to prove the proposition
, we shall also introduce an intermediate finite graph , which we call the _
finite 2-cover _ of @xmath328 , and denote @xmath334 .
the set of vertices of @xmath334 is the set of @xmath305-equivalence classes of non - diagonal , ordered pairs of integers , and the edges are induced by the edges of @xmath19 in the usual way .
the reason to introduce the intermediate graph @xmath334 is that @xmath328 does not inherit the labeling of edges from @xmath19 , as backward and forward edges in @xmath19 may map to the same edge in @xmath328 , while @xmath334 naturally inherits the labels .
let @xmath19 be the graph associated to a periodic labeled wedge . 1 .
first , let us observe that no diagonal vertex is contained in the support of any closed path of @xmath19 : in fact , every diagonal vertex is non - separated , and its outgoing edge leads to another diagonal vertex with larger height , hence the path can never close up .
thus , we can construct the subgraph @xmath335 by taking as vertices all pairs which are non - diagonal , and as edges all the edges of @xmath19 which do not have either as a source or target a diagonal pair . by
what has been just said , the growth rate of @xmath19 and @xmath335 is the same , @xmath336 2 . since
the maps @xmath337 are given by quotienting with respect to equivalence relations , they are both weak covers of graphs . thus ,
since both @xmath334 and @xmath328 are finite , by lemma [ l : sameentro ] , the growth rates of @xmath334 and @xmath328 are the same .
we are now left with proving that the growth rate of @xmath335 is the same as the growth rate of @xmath334 .
since the cardinality of the fiber of the projection @xmath338 is infinite , the statement is not immediate .
note that the finite @xmath290-cover @xmath334 is a graph with labeled edges : indeed , if @xmath320 , then @xmath339 , and so on , thus the labeling of @xmath334 inherited from @xmath19 is well - defined , and the graph map @xmath338 preserves the labels .
4 . let us call _ backtracking _ a path in @xmath19 or @xmath334 such that at least one of its edges is labeled by @xmath251 (= backward ) , and _ non - backtracking _ otherwise . now let us note the following : 1 .
every closed path in @xmath19 is backtracking ; in fact , following any edge which is upward or forward increases the height , thus a path in @xmath19 made entirely of @xmath246 and @xmath249 edges can not close up .
2 . every closed path in @xmath19 passes through the finite set @xmath340 in order to prove this , we first prove that any element in the support of any closed path in @xmath19 has height at most @xmath341 . in order to do so ,
let us fix a diagonal @xmath342 .
by periodicity , either there is a separated pair @xmath247 in @xmath266 of height @xmath343 , or all elements of @xmath266 are non - separated ; in the latter case , no element of @xmath266 is part of any closed path , since any path based at an element of @xmath266 is non - backtracking . in the first case ,
let @xmath344 be the separated pair with smallest height in @xmath266 ; then , only the elements with height less than @xmath345 can be part of any closed path , and @xmath346 , so the first claim is proven . as a consequence ,
the target of any @xmath251-labeled edge which belongs to some closed path is of type @xmath347 , where @xmath348 is the height of the source , hence the target belongs to @xmath194 . by the same reasoning ,
if @xmath24 is any path in @xmath19 based at a vertex of height @xmath40 , then the target of any @xmath251-labeled edge along @xmath24 lies in @xmath194 .
3 . every backtracking closed path in @xmath334 has at least one @xmath251-labeled edge , hence the target of such @xmath251-labeled edge lies in the set @xmath349 , and every lift to @xmath19 starting from an element of @xmath194 must end in the target of a @xmath251-labeled edge in @xmath19 , hence must end in @xmath194 .
5 . finally , let us note that for each @xmath20 , the number of non - backtracking paths of length @xmath20 in @xmath334 is at most the cardinality of @xmath350 ; indeed , from each vertex there is at most one edge labeled @xmath246 or @xmath249 , thus for each vertex of @xmath334 there is at most one non - backtracking path of length @xmath20 based at it .
let us now put together the previous statements .
indeed , by ( 4)(a)-(b ) every closed path in @xmath19 passes through @xmath194 , hence we can apply lemma [ l : growthcover ] ( 1 ) and get that @xmath351 to prove the other inequality , let us note that by ( 4)(b)-(c ) we know that lemma [ l : growthcover ] ( 2 ) applies with @xmath197 the set of backtracking closed paths in @xmath334 .
moreover , by point ( 5 ) above we have that the number of non - backtracking paths is bounded independently of @xmath20 : thus we can write @xmath352 @xmath353 from which follows @xmath354 as required . when dealing with purely periodic external angles , we shall also need the following lemma .
[ l : twoperiodics ] let @xmath355 and @xmath356 be two labeled wedges which are purely periodic of period @xmath43 .
suppose moreover that for every pair @xmath247 with @xmath357 the label of @xmath243 in @xmath355 equals the label in @xmath356
. then the finite models @xmath358 and @xmath359 are isomorphic graphs . as a consequence ,
the growth rates of @xmath355 and @xmath356 are equal .
let @xmath360 an equivalence class of unordered pairs .
if neither @xmath49 nor @xmath110 are divisible by @xmath43 , then the label of @xmath318 is the same in @xmath355 and @xmath356 , hence the outgoing edges from @xmath318 are the same in @xmath358 and @xmath359 .
suppose on the other hand that @xmath361 ( hence , @xmath362 because the pair is non - diagonal ) .
then , if the pair @xmath363 is non - separated , then its only outgoing edge goes to @xmath364 in @xmath365 .
on the other hand , if @xmath363 is separated , then its two possible outgoing edges are @xmath366 and @xmath367 . however , the pair @xmath366 is diagonal , hence no vertex in the graph has such label
. thus , independently of whether @xmath363 is separated , it has exactly one outgoing edge with target @xmath367 , proving the claim .
we shall now apply the theory of labeled wedges to the core entropy . as we have seen in section [ s : algo ]
, thurston s algorithm allows one to compute the core entropy for periodic angles @xmath3 ; in order to interpolate between periodic angles of different periods , we shall now define for _ any _ angle @xmath13 a labeled wedge @xmath27 , and thus an infinite graph @xmath368 as described in the previous sections .
recall that for each @xmath31 we denote @xmath50 , which we see as a point in @xmath51 . for each pair @xmath247 which belongs to @xmath234 , we label @xmath247 as _ non - separated _
if @xmath369 and @xmath370 belong to the same element of the partition @xmath46 , or at least one of them lies on the boundary of the partition .
if instead @xmath369 and @xmath370 belong to the interiors of two different intervals of @xmath46 , then we label the pair @xmath247 as _ separated_. the labeled wedge just constructed will be denoted @xmath27 , and its associated graph @xmath28 .
the main quantity we will work with is the following : let @xmath3 have period @xmath43 and pre - period @xmath44 . by definition of the equivalence relation @xmath312 , we have @xmath325 if and only if @xmath373 , which proves the first condition in the definition of periodic wedge . moreover , if @xmath247 is a diagonal pair , then @xmath374 , hence the pair @xmath247 is non - separated , verifying the second condition . using the results of the previous section , we are now ready to prove that the logarithm of the growth rate of @xmath28 coincides with the core entropy for rational angles , proving the first part of theorem [ t : newmain ] .
let @xmath3 a rational angle , @xmath28 the infinite graph associated to the labeled wedge @xmath27 , and @xmath376 the finite model of @xmath28 as described in section [ s : finitemodel ] by unraveling the definitions , the matrix @xmath52 constructed in section [ s : algo ] is exactly the adjacency matrix of the finite model @xmath376 . by proposition [ p : finiteinfinite ] , the growth rate of @xmath28 coincides with the growth rate of its finite model @xmath376 .
moreover , by lemma [ l : perroneig ] , the growth rate of @xmath376 coincides with the largest real eigenvalue of its adjacency matrix , that is the largest real eigenvalue of @xmath52 .
thus , by theorem [ t : algo ] its logarithm is the core entropy @xmath5 . as @xmath379 , the labeled wedge @xmath380 stabilizes .
in fact , for each @xmath49 consider the position of @xmath50 with respect to the partition @xmath46 . if @xmath381 , then , for all @xmath382 in a neighborhood of @xmath3 , @xmath383 lies on the same side of the partition . otherwise , note that for any @xmath384 and @xmath385 , the functions @xmath386 and @xmath387 are both continuous and orientation preserving but have different derivative : thus , for all @xmath388 close enough to @xmath3 , the point @xmath383 lies on one side of the partition , and for @xmath389 close enough to @xmath3 lies on the other side .
thus , the limits @xmath390_^+ : = _ ^+ _ , _ ^- : = _ ^- _ @xmath390 exist , and are both equal to @xmath380 if @xmath3 is not purely periodic , because then no @xmath369 with @xmath31 lies on the boundary of the partition .
the claim then follows by lemma [ l : contwedge ] .
this proves continuity of @xmath371 at all angles which are not purely periodic .
we shall now deal with the purely periodic case , where for the moment we only know that the left - hand side and right - hand side limits of @xmath371 exist .
[ l : diffpairs ] let @xmath3 be purely periodic of period @xmath43
. then @xmath27 , @xmath391 and @xmath392 are purely periodic of period @xmath43 , and differ only in the labelings of pairs @xmath247 with either @xmath361 or @xmath393 .
let @xmath3 be purely periodic of period @xmath43 .
note that @xmath369 lies on the boundary of the partition @xmath46 if and only if @xmath361 .
thus , for all the pairs @xmath247 for which neither component is divisible by @xmath43 , the label of @xmath247 is continuous across @xmath3 , proving the second statement .
now we shall show that if for all @xmath388 and close enough to @xmath3 one has @xmath394 on one side of the partition , then also @xmath395 is on the same side for each @xmath256 .
this will prove that @xmath396 is purely periodic of period @xmath43 .
the proof for @xmath397 is symmetric , and @xmath27 is purely periodic of period @xmath43 by lemma [ l : periodic ] . in order to prove the remaining claim ,
let us denote @xmath398 , @xmath399 ; since @xmath3 is purely periodic , there exists @xmath400 such that @xmath401 for all @xmath256 .
now , note that for each @xmath256 the derivatives satisfy the inequality @xmath402 , thus for each @xmath256 there exists @xmath403 such that for each @xmath404 one has @xmath405 , hence the points @xmath406 all belong to the same side of the partition independently of @xmath300 , as required .
[ p : bothsides ] if @xmath3 is purely periodic of period @xmath43 , then the ( infinite ) graphs @xmath28 , @xmath407 and @xmath408 , associated respectively to @xmath27 , @xmath391 and @xmath392 have the same growth rate , i.e. we have the equality @xmath409 by lemma [ l : diffpairs ] and lemma [ l : twoperiodics ] , the graphs @xmath28 , @xmath407 and @xmath408 have the same finite form , hence by proposition [ p : finiteinfinite ] they have the same growth rate , proving the claim .
let @xmath2 , and denote by @xmath413 the smallest real zero of @xmath14 .
the proof is a simple quantitative version of rouch s theorem . for simplicity ,
let us assume that @xmath3 is pre - periodic , and let @xmath414 be the minimum distance , in @xmath51 , between ( distinct ) elements of the set @xmath415 .
given another angle @xmath416 , denote @xmath417 the smallest real zero of @xmath418 , and choose @xmath20 such that @xmath419 then , by looking at how @xmath369 moves with respect to the partition @xmath46 , we realize that , for @xmath420 , the pair @xmath247 is separated for @xmath3 if and only if it is separated for @xmath416 . by construction , the @xmath421 coefficient of @xmath14 depends only on multi - cycles of total length @xmath20 , and by proposition [ p : properties ] ( 3 ) all such multi - cycles live on the subgraph @xmath422 , hence the first @xmath20 coefficients of @xmath14 and @xmath418 coincide .
thus we can write @xmath423 for some @xmath424 and @xmath425 , where we used that @xmath426 by proposition [ p : properties ] ( 5 ) .
now , using @xmath427 we have @xmath428 where @xmath256 is the order of zero of @xmath46 at @xmath429 and @xmath430 is a holomorphic function , with @xmath431 . by combining , and , we get @xmath432 with @xmath433 , which implies the claim as @xmath434 . in the periodic case
the proof the same , except one should argue separately for @xmath435 and @xmath436 , and use proposition [ p : bothsides ] .
a. douady , _ topological entropy of unimodal maps : monotonicity for quadratic polynomials _ , in _ real and complex dynamical systems ( hillerd , 1993 ) _ , nato adv .
sci . * 464 * , 6587 . | the core entropy of polynomials , recently introduced by w. thurston , is a dynamical invariant which can be defined purely in combinatorial terms , and provides a useful tool to study parameter spaces of polynomials .
the theory of core entropy extends to complex polynomials the entropy theory for real unimodal maps : the real segment is replaced by an invariant tree , known as hubbard tree , which lives inside the filled julia set .
we prove that the core entropy of quadratic polynomials varies continuously as a function of the external angle , answering a question of thurston . |
solving the motion of a system of @xmath0 particles interacting through their mutual gravitational forces has long been one of the important themes in physics @xcite .
though an exact solution is known in the @xmath1 case in newtonian theory , in the context of the general theory of relativity the motion of the @xmath0 bodies can not be solved exactly due to dissipation of energy in the form of gravitational radiation , even when @xmath1 .
hence analysis of a two body system in general relativity ( e.g. binary pulsars ) necessarily involves resorting to approximation methods such as a post - newtonian expansion @xcite .
however in the past decade lower dimensional versions of general relativity ( both in ( 1 + 1 ) and ( 2 + 1 ) dimensions ) have been extensively investigated from both classical and quantum perspectives .
here the reduced dimensionality yields an absence of gravitational radiation .
although this desirable physical feature is lost in such models ( at least in the vacuum ) , most ( if not all ) of the remaining conceptual features of relativistic gravity are retained .
hence their mathematical simplificity offers the hope of obtaining a deep understanding of the nature of gravitation in a wide variety of physical situations .
it is with this motivation that we consider the @xmath0-body problem in lower dimensional gravity .
specifically , we consider the gravitational @xmath0-body problem in two spacetime dimensions . such lineal theories of gravity have found widespread use in other problems in physics .
the simplest such theory ( sometimes referred to as jackiw - teitelboim ( jt ) theory @xcite ) sets the ricci scalar equal to a constant , with other matter fields evolving in this constant - curvature two - dimensional spacetime .
another such theory ( sometimes referred to as @xmath2 theory ) sets the ricci scalar equal to the trace of the stress - energy of the prescribed matter fields and sources in this manner , matter governs the evolution of spacetime curvature which reciprocally governs the evolution of matter @xcite .
this theory has a consistent newtonian limit @xcite ( a problematic issue for a generic @xmath3-dimensional gravity theory @xcite ) , and reduces to jt theory if the stress - energy is that of a cosmological constant .
the @xmath0-body problem , then , can be formulated in relativistic gravity by taking the matter action to be that of @xmath0 point - particles minimally coupled to gravity . in previous work
we developed the canonical formalism for this action in @xmath2 lineal gravity @xcite and derived the exact hamiltonian for @xmath1 as a solution to a transcendental equation which is valid to infinite order in the gravitational coupling constant @xcite . in the slow motion , weak field limit
this hamiltonian coincides with that of newtonian gravity in @xmath3 dimensions , and in the limit where all bodies are massless , spacetime is flat .
more recently we have extended this case to include a cosmological constant @xmath4 , so that in the limit where all bodies are massless , spacetime has constant curvature ( ie the jt theory is obtained ) , and when @xmath5 vanishes the situation described in the previous paragraph is recovered @xcite . for @xmath1
, we derived an exact solution for the hamiltonian as a function of the proper separation and the centre - of - inertia momentum of the bodies . in the equal mass case an exact solution to the equations of motion for the proper separation of the two point masses as a function of their mutual proper time was also obtained .
the trajectories showed characteristic structures depending on the values of a cosmological constant @xmath5 .
the purpose of this paper is to more fully describe these results and to expand upon them .
specifically , we generalize our previous formalism with @xmath6 @xcite to a system of @xmath0 particles in ( 1 + 1 ) dimensional gravity with cosmological constant . when @xmath1 we obtain exact solutions for the motion of two bodies of unequal ( and equal ) mass .
since the einstein action is a topological invariant in ( 1 + 1 ) dimensions , we must incorporate a scalar ( dilaton ) field into the action @xcite . by a canonical reduction of the action
, the hamiltonian is defined as a spatial integral of the second derivative of the dilaton field , which is a function of the canonical variables of the particles ( coordinates and momenta ) and is determined from the constraint equations . for a system of two particles an equation which determines the hamiltonian in terms of the remaining degrees of freedom of the system
is derived from the matching conditions of the solution to the constraint equations .
we refer to this equation as the determining equation ; it is a transcendental equation which allows one to determine the hamiltonian in terms of the centre of inertia momentum and proper separation of the bodies .
the canonical equations of motion are derived from the hamiltonian . for the equal mass case
they can be transformed so that the separation and momentum are given by differential equations in terms of the proper time . in this latter form
they can be solved exactly in terms of hyperbolic and/or trigonometric functions .
corresponding to the values of the magnitudes ( and signs ) of the energy and other parameters ( e.g. gravitational coupling constant , masses , cosmological constant ) several different types of motion are expected in the 2 body case .
broadly speaking , the two particles could remain either bounded or unbounded , or else balanced between these two conditions .
we shall analyze these various states of motion , and discuss the transitions which occur between them .
we find several surprising situations , including the onset of mutual repulsion for a range of values of negative @xmath7 and the masses , and the diverging separation of the two bodies at finite proper time for a range of values of positive @xmath7 .
we shall also consider the unequal mass case .
in this situation the proper time is no longer the same for the two particles , and so a description of the motion requires a more careful analysis .
we find that we are able to obtain phase space trajectories from the determining equation .
we also can obtain explicit solutions for the proper separation in terms of a transformed time coordinate which reduces to the mutual proper time in the case of equal mass . in sec.ii
we describe the canonical reduction of the theory and define the hamiltonian for the @xmath0-body system . in sec.iii
we solve the constraint equations for the two - body case and get the determining equation of the hamiltonian , from which the canonical equations of motion are explicitly derived .
we investigate the motion for @xmath8 in sec.iv , by using the exact solutions to the canonical equations .
the motion of equal masses for @xmath9 are analyzed in sec.v where a general discussion on the structure of the determining equation , the plots of phase space trajectories , the analysis of the explicit solutions in terms of the proper time are developed .
we treat the unequal mass case in sec.vi .
sec.vii contains concluding remarks and directions for further work .
the solution of the metric tensor , a test particle approximation in the small mass limit of one of the particles and the causal relationships between particles in unbounded motion are given in appendices .
the action integral for the gravitational field coupled to @xmath0 point masses is @xmath10{}\left.+\sum_{a}\int d\tau_{a}\left\ { -m_{a}\left(-g_{\mu\nu}(x)\frac{dz^{\mu}_{a}}{d\tau_{a } } \frac{dz^{\nu}_{a}}{% d\tau_{a}}\right)^{1/2}\right\ } \delta^{2}(x - z_{a}(\tau_{a } ) ) \right]\;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath11 is the dilaton field , @xmath7 is the cosmological constant , @xmath12 and @xmath13 are the metric and its determinant , @xmath14 is the ricci scalar , and @xmath15 is the proper time of @xmath16-th particle , respectively , with @xmath17 .
the symbol @xmath18 denotes the covariant derivative associated with @xmath19 .
the field equations derived from the action ( [ act1 ] ) are @xmath20{}r - g^{\mu \nu } \nabla _ { \mu } \nabla _ { \nu } \psi = 0\ ; , \label{eq - r } \\ & & \frac{1}{2}\nabla _ { \mu } \psi \nabla _ { \nu } \psi -\frac{1}{4}g_{\mu \nu } \nabla ^{\lambda } \psi \nabla _ { \lambda } \psi + g_{\mu \nu } \nabla ^{\lambda } \nabla _ { \lambda } \psi -\nabla _ { \mu } \nabla _ { \nu } \psi = \kappa t_{\mu \nu } + \frac{1}{2}g_{\mu \nu } \lambda \ ; , \label{eq - psi } \\ & & \frac{d}{d\tau
_ { a}}\left\ { g_{\mu \nu } ( z_{a})\frac{dz_{a}^{\nu } } { d\tau _ { a}}\right\ } -\frac{1}{2}g_{\nu \lambda , \mu } ( z_{a})\frac{dz_{a}^{\nu } } { % d\tau _ { a}}\frac{dz_{a}^{\lambda } } { d\tau _ { a}}=0\ ; , \label{eq - z}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the stress - energy due to the point masses is @xmath21 eq.([eq - psi ] ) guarantees the conservation of @xmath22 . inserting the trace of eq.([eq - psi ] ) into eq.([eq - r ] ) yields @xmath23 eqs .
( [ eq - z ] ) and ( [ rt ] ) form a closed sytem of equations for the matter - gravity system .
the evolution of the dilaton then follows from inserting the solutions to these equations into([eq - r ] ) , and then solving for its motion , the traceless part of ( [ eq - psi ] ) being identities once the other equations are satisfied .
alternatively , one can solve the independent parts of equations ( [ eq - r ] ) , ( [ eq - psi ] ) , and ( [ eq - z ] ) for the metric , dilaton and matter degrees of freedom , which is the approach we shall take in this paper .
if the masses of all particles are taken to be zero then the field equations reduce to those of constant curvature lineal gravity , or jt theory @xcite .
consider next the transformation of the action ( [ act1 ] ) to canonical form .
we decompose the scalar curvature in terms of the extrinsic curvature @xmath24 via @xmath25 where @xmath26 , and the metric is @xmath27 so that @xmath28 and @xmath29 , and then rewrite the particle action in first - order form . after some manipulation we find that the action ( [ act1 ] ) may be rewritten in the form @xmath30 where @xmath31 and @xmath32 are conjugate momenta to @xmath33 and @xmath34 , respectively , and @xmath35 with the symbols @xmath36 and @xmath37 denoting @xmath38 and @xmath39 , respectively . the action ( [ act2 ] ) leads to the system of equations @xmath40{}\left .
-\sum_{a}\frac{p^{2}_{a}}{2\gamma^{2}\sqrt{\frac{% p^{2}_{a}}{\gamma } + m^{2}_{a}}}\;\delta(x - z_{a}(t))\right\ } \nonumber \\ & + & n_{1}\left\{-\frac{1}{\gamma^{2}}\pi\psi^{\prime } + \frac{\pi^{\prime}}{% \gamma } + \sum_{a}\frac{p_{a}}{\gamma^{2}}\;\delta(x - z_{a}(t))\right\ } + n^{\prime}_{0}\frac{1}{2\kappa\sqrt{\gamma}\gamma}\psi^{\prime } + n^{\prime}_{1}\frac{\pi}{\gamma}=0\;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath41{}+n_{1}\frac{p_{a}}{\gamma^{2}}\frac{\partial\gamma}{% \partial z_{a}}=0\ ; , \label{e - p } \\ & & \dot{z_{a}}-n_{0}\frac{\frac{p_{a}}{\gamma}}{\sqrt{\frac{p^{2}_{a}}{\gamma% } + m^{2}_{a } } } + \frac{n_{1}}{\gamma}=0 \;.
\label{e - z}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the equations ( [ e - p ] ) and ( [ e - z ] ) , all metric components ( @xmath42 , @xmath43 , @xmath44 ) are evaluated at the point @xmath45 and @xmath46 this system of equations can be shown to be equivalent to the set of equations ( [ eq - r ] ) , ( [ eq - psi ] ) and ( [ eq - z ] ) .
since @xmath42 and @xmath43 are lagrange multipliers , equations ( [ e - r0 ] ) and ( [ e - r1 ] ) are constraints ; specifically they are the energy and momentum constraints of the @xmath3 dimensional gravitational system we consider .
we may solve them for @xmath47 and @xmath48 in terms of the dynamical and gauge ( _ i.e. _ co - ordinate ) degrees of freedom , since these are the only linear terms in these constraints .
we identify these coordinate degrees of freedom by writing the generator arising from the variation of the action at the boundaries in terms of @xmath47 and @xmath48 , and then finding which quantities serve to fix the frame of the physical space - time coordinates in a manner similar to the @xmath49-dimensional case . carrying out the same procedure as in the @xmath50 case @xcite
we find that we can consistently choose the coordinate conditions @xmath51 { } \mbox{and } \makebox[2em ] { } \pi=0 \;.\ ] ] eliminating the constraints , the action reduces to @xmath52 and the reduced hamiltonian for the @xmath0-body system is @xmath53 where @xmath11 is a function of @xmath54 and @xmath55 , determined by solving the constraints which are under the coordinate conditions ( [ cc ] ) @xmath56 @xmath57 the expression for the hamiltonian ( [ ham1 ] ) is analogous to the reduced hamiltonian in @xmath49 dimensional general relativity . in @xmath3 dimensions
it is determined by the dilaton field at spatial infinity .
the consistency of this canonical reduction may be demonstrated in a manner analogous to that employed in the @xmath50 case : namely the canonical equations of motion derived from the reduced hamiltonian ( [ ham1 ] ) are identical with the equations ( [ e - p ] ) and ( [ e - z ] ) .
the methodology at this point is then as follows .
first we must solve ( [ psi ] ) and ( [ pi ] ) for @xmath11 and @xmath58 in terms of the @xmath59 and the @xmath60 , consistently matching solutions across the boundaries of the particles .
then we compute from ( [ ham1 ] ) the hamiltonian in terms of the independent momenta and coordinates of the particles .
this expression is sufficient to obtain the phase - space trajectories for a given set of initial conditions .
finally we solve equations ( [ e - pi ] [ e - z ] ) to obtain a complete solution for the @xmath0 body system .
throughout the remainder of this paper we shall consider only @xmath1 , i.e. 2-body dynamics .
the standard approach for investigating the dynamics of particles is to derive an explicit expression of the hamiltonian , from which the equations of motion and the solution of trajectories are obtained . in this section
we explain how to derive the hamiltonian from the solution to the constraint equations ( [ psi ] ) and ( [ pi ] ) and get the explicit hamiltonian for two particles in a spacetime with a cosmological constant .
we first express the equations ( [ psi ] ) and ( [ pi ] ) as @xmath61 @xmath62 where we set @xmath63 . rewriting ( [ psi1 ] ) as @xmath64 and using ( [ chi1 ] ) , we can rewrite ( [ ham1 ] ) as @xmath65 which can also be obtained by inserting ( [ psi1 ] ) and ( [ chi1 ] ) into ( [ ham1 ] ) and iterating by partial integration ( assuming convergence ) .
we shall refer to this formula later when we consider boundary conditions .
defining @xmath66 by @xmath67 the constraints ( [ psi1 ] ) and ( [ chi1 ] ) for a two - particle system become @xmath68 @xmath69 the general solution to ( [ chi - eq ] ) is @xmath70 the factor @xmath71 ( @xmath72 ) has been introduced in the constants @xmath73 and @xmath74 so that the t - inversion ( time reversal ) properties of @xmath75 are explicitly manifest . by definition , @xmath71 changes sign under time reversal and so , therefore , does @xmath75 .
consider first the case @xmath76 , for which we may divide space into three regions : @xmath77 ( ( + ) region ) , @xmath78 ( ( 0 ) region ) and @xmath79 ( ( - ) region ) .
in each region @xmath80 is constant : @xmath81{}\mbox{(+ ) region } , \\ -\epsilon x+\frac{1}{4}(p_{1}-p_{2 } ) & \makebox[3em]{}\mbox{(0 ) region } , \\
-\epsilon x+\frac{1}{4}(p_{1}+p_{2 } ) & \makebox[3em]{}\mbox{(- ) region}\;. \end{array } \right.\ ] ] general solutions to the homogeneous equation @xmath82 in each region are @xmath83 where @xmath84 for these solutions to be the actual solutions to eq.([phi - eq ] ) with delta function source terms , they must satisfy the following matching conditions at @xmath85 : @xmath86 the conditions ( [ match1 ] ) and ( [ match3 ] ) lead to @xmath87 @xmath88 yielding @xmath89 { } + \frac{\kappa\sqrt{p^{2}_{1}+m^{2}_{1}}-2k_{0}+2k_{+}}{4k_{+ } } e^{-\frac{1}{2}(k_{0}+k_{+})z_{1}}b_{0}\ ; , \label{a+ } \\
b_{+}&=&-\frac{\kappa\sqrt{p^{2}_{1}+m^{2}_{1}}+2k_{0}-2k_{+}}{4k_{+ } } e^{\frac{1}{2}(k_{0}+k_{+})z_{1}}a_{0 } \nonumber \\ & & \makebox[10em ] { } -\frac{\kappa\sqrt{p^{2}_{1}+m^{2}_{1}}-2k_{0}-2k_{+}}{4k_{+ } } e^{-\frac{1}{2}(k_{0}-k_{+})z_{1}}b_{0 } \;.
\label{b+}\end{aligned}\ ] ] similarly from ( [ match2 ] ) and ( [ match4 ] ) we have @xmath90 @xmath91 and then @xmath92 { } -\frac{\kappa\sqrt{p^{2}_{2}+m^{2}_{2}}+2k_{0}-2k_{-}}{4k_{- } } e^{-\frac{1}{2}(k_{0}+k_{-})z_{2}}b_{0}\ ; , \label{a- } \\
b_{-}&=&\frac{\kappa\sqrt{p^{2}_{2}+m^{2}_{2}}-2k_{0}+2k_{-}}{4k_{- } } e^{\frac{1}{2}(k_{0}+k_{-})z_{2}}a_{0 } \nonumber \\ & & \makebox[10em ] { } + \frac{\kappa\sqrt{p^{2}_{2}+m^{2}_{2}}+2k_{0}+2k_{-}}{4k_{- } } e^{-\frac{1}{2}(k_{0}-k_{-})z_{2}}b_{0}\;. \label{b-}\end{aligned}\ ] ] since the magnitudes of both @xmath66 and @xmath75 increase with increasing @xmath93 , it is necessary to impose a boundary condition which guarantees that the surface terms which arise in transforming the action vanish and simultaneously preserves the finiteness of the hamiltonian .
a consideration of ( [ ham2 ] ) implies that we may choose the boundary condition @xmath94 with @xmath95 being constants to be determined .
this boundary condition means @xmath96x
+ \epsilon c_{\chi}+\frac{1}{4}(p_{1}z_{1}+p_{2}z_{2})\right\}^{2 } \nonumber \\ & & \makebox[1em]{}+2\lambda x^{2}=c_{+}x \ ; , \label{cond2 } \\ & & \left\{2k_{-}x-4\mbox{log}|b_{-}|\right\}^{2 } -4\kappa^{2}\left\{-\left[\epsilon x-\frac{1}{4}(p_{1}+p_{2})\right]x + \epsilon c_{\chi}-\frac{1}{4}(p_{1}z_{1}+p_{2}z_{2})\right\}^{2 } \nonumber \\ & & \makebox[1em]{}+2\lambda x^{2}=c_{-}x \;. \label{cond3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it may seem that instead of ( [ cond1 ] ) we could have made the alternate choices @xmath97 or @xmath98 .
however the definitions ( [ k+-0 ] ) imply that @xmath99 are positive quantities , which in turn leads to a negative hamiltonian for the choice @xmath100 . for the choices @xmath101 and @xmath98 the hamiltonian identically vanishes .
the terms quadratic in @xmath102 from ( [ cond2 ] ) and ( [ cond3 ] ) merely recapitulate the definitions of @xmath99 . equating terms linear in @xmath102
yield the relations @xmath103
\left[\epsilon c_{\chi}+\frac{1}{4}(p_{1}z_{1}+p_{2}z_{2})\right]&=&c_{+}\ ; , \label{cond4 } \\
-16k_{-}\mbox{log}|b_{-}|+8\kappa^{2 } \left[\epsilon x-\frac{1}{4}(p_{1}+p_{2})\right ] \left[\epsilon c_{\chi}-\frac{1}{4}(p_{1}z_{1}+p_{2}z_{2})\right]&= & c_{- } \;. \label{cond5}\end{aligned}\ ] ] equating the constant terms of ( [ cond2 ] ) and ( [ cond3 ] ) leads to @xmath104 ^{2}=0\ ; , \label{cond6 } \\ & & 16\left(\mbox{log}|b_{-}|\right)^{2 } -4\kappa^{2}\left[\epsilon c_{\chi}-\frac{1}{4}(p_{1}z_{1}+p_{2}z_{2})\right ] ^{2}=0 \;.
\label{cond7}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we choose the solutions @xmath105\ ; , \nonumber \\
\\ \mbox{log}|b_{-}|&=&\frac{\kappa}{2}\left[c_{\chi } -\frac{\epsilon}{4}(p_{1}z_{1}+p_{2}z_{2})\right]\;. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] before proceeding , we add a remark to ( [ a+b-1 ] ) . in solving ( [ cond6 ] ) and
( [ cond7 ] ) , there are actually four combinations @xmath106 of sign choices for @xmath107 and @xmath108 .
however the choices @xmath109 and @xmath110 do not lead to any relations among the coefficients and gives us an unphysical hamiltonian .
the choices @xmath111 and @xmath112 lead to identical physical results once the signs of the momenta @xmath113 and the coefficient @xmath74 are reversed .
the condition ( [ cond1 ] ) leads to @xmath114 and @xmath115 from ( [ a / b-1 ] ) and ( [ a / b-2 ] ) we obtain @xmath116{}=\left(\kappa\sqrt{p^{2}_{1}+m^{2}_{1}}+2k_{0}-2k_{+}\right ) \left(\kappa\sqrt{p^{2}_{2}+m^{2}_{2}}+2k_{0}-2k_{-}\right ) e^{k_{0}(z_{1}-z_{2})}\ ; , \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] which we shall refer to as the determining equation for @xmath73 .
the @xmath11 fields in @xmath117 regions are @xmath118 and the hamiltonian is @xmath119^{\infty}_{-\infty } \nonumber \\ & = & \frac{2(k_{+}+k_{-})}{\kappa}\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] once the solution for @xmath73 is obtained from ( [ x ] ) , the hamiltonian is explicitly determined from ( [ ham1 ] ) in terms of the degrees of freedom of the system ( i.e. the coordinates and momenta of the particles ) .
> from ( [ a+ ] ) , ( [ b- ] ) , ( [ a / b-1 ] ) and ( [ a / b-2 ] ) , @xmath120 and @xmath121 are expressed in terms of @xmath122 as @xmath123 and from ( [ a+b-1 ] ) and ( [ a+b-2 ] ) the coefficients @xmath122 and @xmath74 ( and hence @xmath120 , @xmath121 and @xmath124 ) are also determined @xmath125 the parameters @xmath95 are determined from ( [ cond4 ] ) and ( [ cond5 ] ) . from ( [ a / b-1 ] ) , ( [ a / b-2 ] ) and ( [ a+b-2 ] ) it is evident that an overall common sign of @xmath126 and @xmath124 has no physical meaning , and so we can choose all these coefficients to be positive .
the previous expressions are somewhat cumbersome .
we can express them more compactly by making use of the following notation : @xmath127\ ; , \nonumber \\ y_{0}&\equiv & \kappa\left[x-\frac{\epsilon}{4}(p_{1}-p_{2})\right]\ ; , \nonumber \\ y_{-}&\equiv & \kappa\left[x-\frac{\epsilon}{4}(p_{1}+p_{2})\right]\;\;. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the coefficients @xmath126 and @xmath124 can then be rewritten as @xmath128 and the solution for @xmath66 is then @xmath129 repeating the analysis for @xmath130 yields a similar solution with @xmath131 .
hence the full solution is obtained from the preceding expressions by replacing @xmath113 and @xmath132 by @xmath133 and @xmath134 , respectively . the determining equation ( [ x ] ) of the hamiltonian
is then expressed as @xmath135 or @xmath136 [ \kappa\sqrt{p_{2}^{2}+m^{2}_{2}}-2k_{-}]\right ) \mbox{tanh}\left(\frac{1}{2}k_{0}|z_{1}-z_{2}|\right ) \nonumber \\ & & \makebox[5em]{}=-2k_{0 } \left([\kappa\sqrt{p_{1}^{2}+m^{2}_{1}}-2k_{+ } ] + [ \kappa\sqrt{p_{2}^{2}+m^{2}_{2}}-2k_{-}]\right)\;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the momentum @xmath113 is replaced by @xmath137 . for the expression ( [ ham2 ] ) to have a definite meaning as the hamiltonian , @xmath99 should be real .
this imposes the restriction @xmath138 .
however @xmath139 need not be real . if @xmath7 takes a sufficiently large positive value @xmath139 will be imaginary and the above analysis must be repeated . in the ( 0 ) region
the soluton to the @xmath66 equation ( [ phi - eq ] ) becomes @xmath140 where @xmath141 under the same matching conditions ( [ match1]-[match4 ] ) and the boundary condition ( [ bound ] ) we get , instead of ( [ h2 ] ) , a new determining equation for the hamiltonian @xmath142 [ \kappa\sqrt{p_{2}^{2}+m^{2}_{2}}-2k_{-}]\right ) \mbox{tan}\left(\frac{1}{2}\tilde{k}_{0}|z_{1}-z_{2}|\right ) \nonumber \\ & & \makebox[5em]{}=2\tilde{k}_{0 } \left([\kappa\sqrt{p_{1}^{2}+m^{2}_{1}}-2k_{+ } ] + [ \kappa\sqrt{p_{2}^{2}+m^{2}_{2}}-2k_{-}]\right)\;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is just the equation derived from ( [ h2 ] ) by formally replacing @xmath139 with @xmath143 .
similarly , the solution for @xmath66 for imaginary @xmath139 is also identical with that obtained from ( [ phi - sol2 ] ) by the same replacement .
hence equation ( [ h2 ] ) is valid for all values of @xmath139 , and may be regarded as a transcendental equation which determines @xmath144 as a function of the independent coordinates and momenta of the system .
we have previously shown that in the case of zero cosmological constant the solution for @xmath144 can be expressed in terms of the lambert @xmath145 function . in this more general case with @xmath146 the solution for @xmath144 from ( [ h2 ] ) can not expressed in terms of known functions .
rather we must regard @xmath144 as being implicitly determined in terms of the coordinates and momenta via ( [ h2 ] ) .
finally , the components of the metric may be computed from the equations ( [ e - pi ] ) , ( [ e - gamma ] ) , ( [ e - pi ] ) and ( [ e - psi ] ) under the coordinate conditions ( [ cc ] ) . the derivation and
the explicit solutions of the metric are given in appendix a. the canonical equations for the 2-body system can be derived by differentiating the determining equation ( [ h1 ] ) with respect to the variables @xmath147 and @xmath113 . for the variables @xmath148 and @xmath149 this yields @xmath150 @xmath151 where @xmath152 similarly , for particle 2 the equations are @xmath153 it is straightforward to show that these canonical equations guarantee the conservation of the hamiltonian ( i.e. @xmath154 ) and the total momentum @xmath155 ( i.e. @xmath156 ) . alternatively , the equations of motion ( [ e - p ] ) and ( [ e - z ] ) derived from the action ( [ act2 ] ) become @xmath157 under the coordinate conditions ( [ cc ] ) .
insertion of the solutions of the metric components given in the appendix a into ( [ pa ] ) and ( [ za ] ) reproduces the canonical equations of motion ( [ p1 ] ) , ( [ z1 ] ) , ( [ p2 ] ) and ( [ z2 ] ) when the partial derivatives at @xmath158 are defined by @xmath159 thus consistency between the geodesic equations and the canonical equations of motion is explicitly verified , while the formal proof of the consistency in the case of @xmath50 @xcite can be easily generalized to the @xmath160 case .
in a previous paper @xcite we showed that in the @xmath50 case the determining equation ( [ h1 ] ) can be solved explicitly and the hamiltonian for the equal mass is expressed in the center of inertia ( c.i . ) system @xmath161 as @xmath162}{\kappa |r|}\;,\ ] ] where @xmath163 is the lambert @xmath145 function defined via @xmath164 the @xmath163 has two real branches @xmath165 and @xmath166 for real @xmath102 @xcite .
the hamiltonian ( [ ham-0 ] ) is exact to infinite order in the gravitational constant and for arbitrary values of @xmath167 and @xmath168 .
we can view the whole structure of the theory from the weak field to the strong field limits . by setting @xmath169
we can draw a phase space trajectory in @xmath170 space .
this phase space trajectory should be , as a matter of course , obtainable directly from the solution @xmath171 to the canonical equations by eliminating the time variable @xmath172 .
indeed , this can be verified by numerically solving the equations @xmath173 which are obtained in the case of @xmath50 from ( [ p1 ] ) , ( [ z1 ] ) , ( [ p2 ] ) and ( [ z2 ] )
. however for certain values of the parameters , superficial singularities appear in @xmath174 and @xmath175 due to the zero points of the denominator @xmath176 .
these singularities correspond to @xmath177 representing the transit point between two branches @xmath165 and @xmath166 . in a spacetime description
the singularities are coordinate singularities and are a consequence of @xmath172 being a coordinate time .
we can deal with this problem by describing the trajectories of the particles in terms of some invariant parameter .
the natural candidate is the proper time @xmath178 of each particle . from the metric components given in appendix a and the canonical equations ( [ za ] )
, the proper time is @xmath179 for the equal mass case it is common for both particles @xmath180 and the canonical equations ( [ p - eq0 ] ) and ( [ r - eq0 ] ) become @xmath181\sqrt{p^2 + m^2}}{h - 2\epsilon\tilde{p } } - 1\right\}\mbox{sgn}(r ) \;.
\label{r - eqtau0}\end{aligned}\ ] ] remarkably , the equations ( [ p - eqtau0 ] ) and ( [ r - eqtau0 ] ) have an exact solution
. we can obtain it in the following way .
first we solve eq.([p - eqtau0 ] ) for @xmath182 . from this @xmath183
can be extracted by directly solving ( [ r - eqtau0 ] ) after substituting the solution for @xmath168 or by solving ( [ h1 ] ) for @xmath184 .
this yields an exact expression for the proper separation @xmath184 of the two bodies as a function of their mutual proper time .
note that since @xmath185 , at a fixed time @xmath186 ( and hence a fixed @xmath187 ) , the separation @xmath188 is the proper distance between the two particles . in the @xmath189 region
the solution is @xmath190\ ; , \label{r - exact00}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath191\;,\ ] ] where @xmath192 is the initial momentum at @xmath193 . in the @xmath194 region
the solution is @xmath195\ ; , \label{r - exact01}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath196\;.\ ] ] in fig.1 and 2 we show the typical plots of @xmath183 and phase space trajectories for various values of @xmath197 with @xmath198 .
( in all plots in this paper we choose @xmath199 . ) in fig.1 it is seen that as @xmath197 increases , not only the amplitude and the period of the bounded motion become large , but also the shape of @xmath183 deforms from the parabolic ( newtonian ) shape .
this deformation is also present in the phase space trajectories shown in fig.2 . at higher energy
the trajectories become more and more @xmath200 shaped .
this is due to the fact that the trajectory smoothly moves over the two branches @xmath165 and @xmath166 @xcite .
we see in fig.3 the striking distinction between the separations of the particles in the non - relativistic and relativistic cases once the value of the energy becomes large relative to the mass ( here @xmath201 and @xmath198 ) .
the maximal separation of the particles is much smaller than in its newtonian counterpart ( the dashed curve ) , and is achieved far more quickly .
after maximal separation , the particles move toward each other at a slower velocity until they are very close together . at this point
( less than 10% of their maximal separation ) , they accelerate toward the same point , after which the motion repeats with the particles interchanged .
fig.1 _ the exact @xmath184 vs @xmath202 curves in the case of @xmath50 for @xmath198 and four different values of @xmath197 .
_
fig.2 _ phase space trajectories corresponding to the @xmath183 curves in fig.1 .
_
fig.3 _ the exact @xmath184 vs @xmath202 curve for @xmath201 with @xmath198 and the newtonian curve for the same @xmath197 .
_
in this section we consider a system of two particles with equal mass for the @xmath160 case . in the c.i .
system , depending upon the sign of @xmath203 the determining equations ( [ h2 ] ) and ( [ h2new ] ) become @xmath204 and @xmath205 respectively , where @xmath206 equation ( [ deteq-1 ] ) may be further divided into two types : @xmath207 or @xmath208 when @xmath50 the tanh - type b equation is excluded because @xmath209 exceeds 1 .
when a cosmological constant is introduced , this equation has solutions in some restricted range of the parameters . likewise , eq.([deteq-2 ] ) may also be divided into @xmath210 or @xmath211 for all of these four types of determining equations the canonical equations of motion are identical : @xmath212 where @xmath213 for a given value of @xmath7 the equations ( [ deteq-1 ] ) or ( [ deteq-2 ] ) describe the surface in @xmath214 space of all allowed phase - space trajectories , from which the @xmath170 trajectory is obtained by setting @xmath169 .
fig.4 shows phase - space plots for a small @xmath215 and three different values of @xmath7 under identical initial conditions .
first we note that the trajectories of the relativistic motion ( solid curve ) are are slightly distorted compared to the newtonian motion ( dashed curve ) .
second , a trajectory with @xmath216 ( dash - dot curve ) is expanded , reflecting the repulsive effect of the cosmological constant , while a trajectory of @xmath217 ( dotted curve ) shrinks , due to the additional attractive effect . the relativistic plots in fig.4
correspond to the choice of @xmath218 .
plots for @xmath219 ( the time - reversed solutions ) are obtained by reflection in the @xmath220 axis .
the phase space plots for a large @xmath221 are shown in fig.5 .
the trajectories for @xmath222 become extremely @xmath200-shaped , while for @xmath217 the trajectory is still a distorted oval due to the attractive effect of @xmath7 .
the effects of the cosmological constant ( @xmath216 repulsive ; @xmath217 attractive ) are precisely analyzed in terms of the exact @xmath183 plots in the next subsection .
fig.4 _ non - relativistic ( newtonian ) and relativistic trajectories for @xmath223 and three different values of @xmath7 .
the undistorted oval ( which is really a pair of parabolas intersecting at the @xmath224 axis ) is the newtonian trajectory .
_
fig.5 _ relativistic trajectories for @xmath225 and three different values of @xmath7 .
_ the phase - space trajectories discussed in the previous subsection can be obtained from the solution to the canonical equations ( [ can - p ] ) and ( [ can - z ] ) . for the equal mass case
there is a common proper time for both particles @xmath226 via which the canonical equations ( [ can - p ] ) and ( [ can - z ] ) may be expressed in the form @xmath227 first we solve eq.([p - tau ] ) for @xmath168 and then ( [ tanha])-([tanb ] ) for @xmath184 . in the @xmath228 region eq.([p - tau ] ) leads to @xmath229 provided the condition @xmath230 is satified .
hence for @xmath231 the motion is allowed as long as @xmath144 satisfies @xmath232 we perfom the integration of the lhs of ( [ p - int ] ) for three separate cases which depend on the value of @xmath7 relative to @xmath167 and @xmath144 .
the solution @xmath182 is @xmath233 with @xmath234 } { \frac{m^2}{h}\sqrt{-\gamma_m } -\sigma \tan\left[\frac{\epsilon\kappa m}{8}\sqrt{-\gamma_m}(\tau-\tau_{0})\right ] } } & \qquad \gamma_{m } < 0 \ ; , \end{array } \right.\ ] ] where @xmath235 with @xmath236 being the initial momentum at @xmath237 .
similarly the solution in @xmath238 region is @xmath239 with @xmath240 } { \frac{m^2}{h}\sqrt{-\gamma_m } -\bar{\sigma } \tan\left[\frac{\epsilon\kappa m}{8}\sqrt{-\gamma_m}(\tau-\tau_{0})\right ] } } & \qquad \gamma_{m } < 0 \ ; , \end{array } \right.\ ] ] where @xmath241 the solution for @xmath183 for each of the determining equations ( [ tanha])- ( [ tanb ] ) is obtained as follows tanh - type a : @xmath242 & \qquad r>0\ ; , \\ & \\
\frac{-16}{\sqrt{\left(\sqrt{\kappa^2 h^2 + 8\lambda } -m\kappa({\bar f}(\tau)-\frac{1}{{\bar f}(\tau)})\right)^{2 } -8\lambda } } \ ; \mbox{tanh}^{-1}\left[\frac{\kappa\left(h- m\left|{\bar f}(\tau)+\frac{1 } { { \bar f}(\tau)}\right|\right ) } { \sqrt{\left(\sqrt{\kappa^2 h^2 + 8\lambda } -m\kappa({\bar f}(\tau)-\frac{1}{{\bar f}(\tau)})\right)^{2 } -8\lambda } } \right ] & \qquad r<0 \ ; , \end{array } \right.\ ] ] tanh - type b : @xmath243 & \qquad r>0\ ; , \\ & \\ \frac{-16}{\sqrt{\left(\sqrt{\kappa^2 h^2 + 8\lambda } -m\kappa({\bar f}(\tau)-\frac{1}{{\bar f}(\tau)})\right)^{2 } -8\lambda } } \ ; \mbox{tanh}^{-1}\left[\frac{\sqrt{\left(\sqrt{\kappa^2 h^2 + 8\lambda } -m\kappa({\bar f}(\tau)-\frac{1}{{\bar f}(\tau)})\right)^{2 } -8\lambda } } { \kappa\left(h - m\left|{\bar f}(\tau)+\frac{1}{{\bar f}(\tau)}\right|\right ) } \right ] & \qquad r<0 \ ; , \end{array } \right.\ ] ] tan - type a : @xmath244+n\pi\right ) & \quad r>0\ ; , \\ & \\ \frac{-16}{\sqrt{8\lambda - \left(\sqrt{\kappa^2 h^2 + 8\lambda } -m\kappa({\bar f}(\tau)-\frac{1}{{\bar f}(\tau)})\right)^{2 } } } \ ; \left(\mbox{tan}^{-1}\left[\frac{\kappa\left(m \left|{\bar
f}(\tau ) + \frac{1}{{\bar
f}(\tau)}\right|-h\right ) } { \sqrt{8\lambda - \left(\sqrt{\kappa^2 h^2 + 8\lambda } -m\kappa({\bar f}(\tau)-\frac{1}{{\bar f}(\tau)})\right)^{2 } } } \right]+n\pi\right ) & \quad r<0 \ ; , \end{array } \right.\ ] ] tan - type b : @xmath245+n\pi\right ) & \quad r>0\ ; , \\ &
\\ \frac{-16}{\sqrt{8\lambda - \left(\sqrt{\kappa^2 h^2 + 8\lambda } -m\kappa({\bar f}(\tau)-\frac{1}{{\bar f}(\tau)})\right)^{2 } } } \ ; \left(\mbox{tan}^{-1}\left[\frac{\sqrt{8\lambda - \left(\sqrt{\kappa^2 h^2 + 8\lambda } -m\kappa({\bar f}(\tau)-\frac{1}{{\bar f}(\tau)})\right)^{2 } } } { \kappa\left(h - m \left|{\bar f}(\tau)+\frac{1}{{\bar f}(\tau)}\right|\right ) } \right]+n\pi\right ) & \quad r<0 \;\;.
\end{array } \right.\ ] ] the exact @xmath183 solutions corresponding to the phase space trajectories in fig.4 are given by tanh - type a solution ( [ sol - tanha ] ) and are plotted in fig.6 .
the motions are bounded and periodic .
comparison of three curves in fig.6 indicates that a negative cosmological constant @xmath246 acts effectively as an attractive force : for the same value of @xmath197 , the particles do not achieve as wide a proper separation , and the frequency of oscilliation is more rapid . as well , a positive @xmath247 acts as a repulsive force : the frequency of oscillation decreases and the particles achieve a wider proper separation .
fig.6 _ the exact @xmath184 vs @xmath202 curves corresponding to the phase space trajectories in fig.4 .
_ the period @xmath248 for the bounded motion is obtained from tanh - type a solution with the condition @xmath224 and @xmath249 : @xmath250 in figure 7 we plot @xmath183 for fixed @xmath251 and @xmath252 for several different values of @xmath167 .
though the attractive effect of a negative @xmath7 is common in all cases , a special ( and rather surprising ) situation arises .
as the motion becomes more relativistic ( i.e. @xmath167 gets smaller ) we find that a second maximum develops in the curve ( see @xmath253 curve ) .
the description of the motion is as follows .
the two particles start at @xmath224 depart in opposite directions , reaching a maximum separation .
they then go back toward one another for a certain period of proper time .
however at some point they each reverse direction , reaching a second maximal separation .
they then reverse direction again , finally returning to their starting point where the motion then repeats itself . as the mass becomes very small ,
the second maximum prevails .
this peculiar behavior @xcite is due to a subtle interplay between the gravitational attraction , cosmological constant and relativistic motion of the particles . to our knowledge
it has never been previously observed .
the changes of the peaks are clearly grasped in the phas@xmath254e space trajectories in fig.8 .
( in fig.7 the first maximum of @xmath255 curve could not be drawn due to plotting precision . )
fig.7 _ a sequence of equal mass curves for @xmath251 and @xmath252 .
+ note the presence of the second maximum for @xmath253 .
_
fig.8 _ change of peaks for @xmath251 and @xmath252 as @xmath167 gets smaller .
_ as the negative value of @xmath7 approaches its lower bound of @xmath256 , the form of the phase space trajectories transforms from an @xmath200-shaped curve to a double peaked one and then to a diamond shape .
figure 9 illustrates these characteristics for the case of @xmath198 and @xmath257 , in which a double peak structure appears for @xmath258 . for each trajectory in
fig.9 the corresponding @xmath183 plot is shown in fig.10 .
fig.9 _ phase space trajectories for @xmath259 and different values of negative @xmath7 . _
fig.10 _ the @xmath184 vs @xmath202 curves corresponding the phase space trajectories in fig.9 .
_ the double - peak structure shown in figs.7 - 10 is a consequence of having a momentum - dependent potential .
we can gain some insight into this behaviour by computing a perturbative hamiltonian .
the structure of the determining equations ( [ deteq-1 ] ) and ( [ deteq-2 ] ) suggests that we can carry out a 2-parameter expansion of the hamiltonian in terms of @xmath260 and @xmath261 .
to the third order the result is @xmath262 it is straightforward to show that the terms in @xmath263 have the form @xmath264 to arbitrary order in @xmath261 , where the @xmath265 are positive integers and @xmath266 .
one of the characteristics common to all such terms is that they vanish as @xmath267 , since in this case the determining equation of the hamiltonian becomes @xmath268 which is @xmath7-independent .
another important characteristic is that they have a single maximum at @xmath269 if @xmath270 in the case of @xmath231 .
consider the situation depicted in figs.7 - 10 , that of two particles initially at the origin , each having initial momentum @xmath192 , with @xmath271 . in this case
@xmath272 , @xmath273 , and the particles initially move apart as though they were free . from ( [ p - exact1 ] ) the momentum is a monotonically decreasing function of time .
for @xmath274 sufficiently small , the particles will execute a motion which is a perturbation of that described in section [ exactl0 ] since the momentum never becomes large enough to cross the maximum in @xmath275 .
however if @xmath274 is sufficiently large , the terms in @xmath275 will grow as @xmath168 decreases , and the @xmath5-dependent part of the potential will continue to increase . the terms in @xmath276 will decrease as @xmath168 decreases , even though @xmath184 is increasing .
eventually a maximum in @xmath184 is reached , after which both @xmath184 and @xmath168 are decreasing . in the generic case
@xmath184 will continue to decrease toward zero .
however a second extremum will appear if the @xmath275 terms get too small too rapidly before @xmath220 , which can happen for @xmath5 within a certain range . since @xmath277 is a constant of the motion , the only way to preserve the constancy of @xmath144
will be for @xmath184 to increase again .
essentially the particles are repelled due to their kinetic energy within this range of @xmath5 . of course @xmath184
can not increase too much , because @xmath168 continues to get small eventually @xmath184 must reach a 2nd maximum , and then turns around again until @xmath220 , after which the motion continues to @xmath224 whereupon the particles interchange roles .
we can see this effect in a simple non - relativistic model with @xmath278 where in the latter equation @xmath168 and @xmath184 have been rescaled in units of @xmath167 .
the potential has been chosen so that @xmath279 in terms of ( [ general ] ) above . since @xmath280 is a constant of the motion , we can write @xmath281 which has extrema at @xmath282 . for @xmath283 ,
the extreme values of @xmath284 are not real , and so there will be no double peak structure in the phase - space trajectory .
however for @xmath285 two extrema appear , and the particle gets a bounce .
this motion is viewed qualitatively in a potential diagram shown in fig.11 .
as the momentum decreases from a initial value @xmath192 to zero , the potential curve ( which is linear in @xmath284 ) changes from @xmath286 to @xmath287 .
accordingly the particle moves from points @xmath288 to @xmath289 in numerical order .
the equations of motion for the hamiltonian ( [ nonrelmod ] ) are easily solved , yielding @xmath290 where @xmath163 is the lambert - w function ( [ lambertw ] ) .
the function @xmath175 is monotonically decreasing .
provided @xmath291 the particle gets a bounce at @xmath292 before moving out to infinity , as illustrated in figs . 12 and 13 for the case of * @xmath293 . * in these figures the numbers on the curves denote the corresponding numbers in the potential diagram of fig.11 .
fig.11 _ a schematic view of the motion with a large @xmath236 in a potential diagram .
_
fig.12 _ the @xmath175 and @xmath174 curves in the non - relativistic model for @xmath293 .
+ a bounce occurs at @xmath294 . _
fig.13 _ the phase space trajectory in the non - relativistic model for @xmath293 .
_ the expansion ( [ happrox ] ) has similar features , except that there is an additional gravitational and cosmological attraction which prevents the separation from diverging .
to order @xmath7 the potential is a sum of two terms of the form in ( [ general ] ) , with @xmath295 in the first term and @xmath296 in the second term .
the latter provides the bounce effect described above , but is always overwhelmed by the first term for small @xmath284 .
however the @xmath297 term has @xmath298 and is a pure bounce term . hence there exists a range of @xmath7 which can provide a bounce .
fig.14 shows the phase space trajectories in @xmath228 region for @xmath299 and two different masses ( @xmath300 ) , in which the dotted curves represent the motions to the first order of @xmath7 in the hamiltonian ( [ happrox ] ) and the solid curves do the motions corresponding to the second order of @xmath7 .
we see that to order @xmath7 , as the motion becomes relativistic ( @xmath167 gets smaller ) the trajectory simply expands and changes from @xmath200-shape to a diamond shape .
when the @xmath297 term is included , the double peak structure ( a solid curve with @xmath301 ) appears .
fig.14 _ phase space trajectories for the perturbative hamiltonian + for @xmath299 and @xmath302 .
_ this perturbative analysis indicates that the bounce effect is a result of the negative cosmological constant inducing a momentum dependent potential with positive coefficients . for @xmath303 , odd powers of @xmath261 are strongly repulsive , and suppress the attractive effects of even powers of @xmath261 , eliminating the double peak structure . more generally , a positive cosmological constant acts effectively as a repulsive force .
figure 15 shows @xmath183 plots for fixed @xmath304 and several different values of @xmath167 .
the motion becomes unbounded between @xmath305 and @xmath306 .
the @xmath183 plots in fig.16 are for fixed @xmath307 and different values of @xmath7 , showing also the transition from bounded to unbounded motion .
this transition occurs at @xmath308 and the critical value of @xmath7 is given by @xmath309 . as @xmath310
the particles rapidly separate , remaining nearly stationary for an increasingly large period of proper time before coming together again . at @xmath311
this separation time becomes infinite , and for @xmath312 , the separation diverges at finite @xmath202 .
fig.15 _ a sequence of curves of equal mass for @xmath313 .
_
fig.16 _ a sequence of curves near @xmath314 for @xmath315 .
_ though all the above solutions are derived from tanh - type equations ( [ tanha ] ) and ( [ tanhb ] ) , for a positive cosmological constant there exist also a countably infinite set of unbounded motions specified by tan - type a , b equations ( [ tana ] ) and ( [ tanb ] ) .
then for @xmath316 , both bounded and unbounded motions are realized for a fixed value of @xmath144 , as shown in fig.17 . in the unbounded motion
two particles simply approach one another at some minimal value of @xmath284 and then reverse direction toward infinity . in the trajectories
the dotted curves come from tan - type a solution ( [ sol - tana ] ) and the dashed curves do from tan - type b solution ( [ sol - tanb ] ) .
as @xmath7 approaches @xmath317 , two bulges of the solid curve ( tanh - type a ) and the dotted curve ( tan - type a : n=0 ) come close and contact .
when @xmath7 exceeds @xmath317 two curves switch to the unbounded trajectories as shown in the solid curves in fig.18 .
the particles cross one another before receding toward infinity .
the upper solid curve represents the motion in which @xmath168 approaches the asymptotic values @xmath318 as @xmath319 . as noted previously , one peculiar feature of this motion is that the two particles diverges to infinite separation at finite proper time .
the time @xmath320 for @xmath321 is @xmath322}\right)\;\;.\ ] ] the lower solid curve represents the motion in reversed direction . for @xmath312 only unbounded motions are realized .
fig.17 _ phase space trajectories of the bouned and the unbounded motions + for @xmath323 and @xmath324 .
_
fig.18 _ phase space trajectories of the unbounded motions + for @xmath325 and @xmath324 .
_ we discuss in appendix c the causal relationship between the two particles in the unbounded case .
for the unequal masses the proper time ( [ tau-0 ] ) of each particle is @xmath326 where @xmath327 and @xmath328 . in this situation ,
choosing the time coordinate to be the proper time of one particle introduces an asymmetry into the description of the motion .
instead we seek a time variable which is symmetric with respect to @xmath329 and reduces to the proper time ( [ tau ] ) when @xmath330 . from ( [ tau-2 ] )
we choose @xmath331 in terms of this variable the canonical equations are expressed as @xmath332{}\times\left\{\frac{\epsilon j}{8k_{0 } } + \frac{k_{1}}{m_{1}}\left(\frac{p}{\sqrt{p^2+m_{1}^{2 } } } -\epsilon\frac{y}{k}\right ) + \frac{k_{2}}{m_{2}}\left(\frac{p}{\sqrt{p^2+m_{2}^{2 } } } -\epsilon\frac{y}{k}\right)\right\}\;. \label{unequal - r}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that @xmath184 still describes the proper distance between the particles at any fixed instant .
unlike the equal mass case , the integration @xmath333 can not be performed within the framework of elementary calculus .
hence we solve ( [ unequal - p ] ) numerically .
in the case of a negative cosmological constant the @xmath183 plots in fig.19 show the trajectories for various mass ratios @xmath334 in the fixed @xmath335 and @xmath336 . compared with the equal mass case @xmath337 , as the mass ratio gets larger , the gravitational attraction is stronger and the proper distance between two particles as well as the period become shorter .
when the mass ratio gets a small value than unity , the gravity becomes weak .
however , for quite a small mass ratio a strong attractive effect of the cosmological constant prevails and the period changes to become shorter . at the same time the double peak structure ( the second maximum ) appears and finally the first maximum fades out .
these characteristics are very clear in the unequal mass case .
fig.19 _ @xmath183 plots for the different values of the mass ratio @xmath334 + for @xmath338 and @xmath339 .
_ for a positive cosmological constant
the situation is simple . as shown in fig.20 ,
as the mass ratio becomes small , the particles separate with an increasingly larger period of bounded motion .
this is due to a repulsive effect of the cosmological constant and beyond the critical value the motion bocomes unbounded .
fig.20 _ @xmath183 plots for the different values of the mass ratio @xmath334 + for @xmath340 and @xmath339 . _
in general relativity the relationship between the motion of a set of @xmath0 bodies and the structure of space - time is non - linear and quite complicated , even for @xmath1 .
expanding upon the solution presented in @xcite , we have obtained an exact solution to the 2-body problem in @xmath3 dimensions with a cosmological constant . to our knowledge
this is the first non - perturbative relativistic curved - spacetime treatment of this problem , providing new avenues for investigation of one - dimensional self - gravitating systems .
we recapitulate the main results of our paper : ( 1 ) we formulated the canonical formalism for a system of @xmath0 bodies in a lineal theory of gravity with a cosmological constant @xmath5 .
the system is described by a conservative hamiltonian .
the effect of @xmath5 is incorporated into the potential .
( 2 ) for @xmath1 the determining equation of the hamiltonian is a transcendental equation derived from the matching conditions and appropriate boundary conditions at infinity . from these the canonical equations of motion
may be derived .
the metric components are also completely determined .
( 3 ) for the equal mass case we obtained explicitly the exact solutions to the canonical equations in terms of the mutual proper time of the particles . using the solutions we analyzed the motion in both @xmath341 plots and phase - space trajectories . ( 4 )
as expected , a positive cosmological constant yields a repulsive effect on the motion relative to their mutual gravitational attraction . for @xmath342 both bounded and unbounded motions are realized , while for @xmath343 only the unbounded motions are allowed . as @xmath344 the particles separate to an infinite proper distance in infinite proper time . for @xmath345
this infinite separation occurs in finite proper time.(5 ) a negative cosmological constant has an additional attractive effect , and the motion of the particles is bounded .
however for a certain range of the parameters , a repulsive effect sets in , resulting the double - peaked structures of figs.7 - 10 .
this effect is due to a subtle interplay between the momentum - dependent @xmath5 potential and the gravitational attraction .
( 6 ) in the unequal mass case the same basic features also occur ; indeed the double peak behavior shows up more clearly than in the equal mass case .
although eq .
( [ unequal - p ] ) can not be integrated in terms of elementary functions , it is straightforward to numerically integrate .
an exact solution in the small mass limit of the particle 1 was also obtained .
several interesting features of the motion remain to be explored .
the divergent separation of the bodies at finite proper time needs to be better understood .
another issue concerns the condition ( [ h - bound ] ) which means that for a given value of @xmath346 the motion is allowed for the total energy larger than @xmath347 .
what is the physical meaning of this condition ?
it seems to suggest that as the attractive effect of @xmath246 exceeds a critical value the two particle system is no longer stable and transforms into some other system ( probably making a black hole ) . to formulate the canonical formalism to treat this problem
is our next subject .
under the coordinate conditions ( [ cc ] ) the field equations ( [ e - pi ] ) , ( [ e - gamma ] ) , ( [ e - pi ] ) and ( [ e - psi ] ) become @xmath348 the solution to ( [ eq - n0 ] ) is @xmath349 @xmath286 being an integration constant .
eq.([eq - n1 ] ) is @xmath350 the solution in each region is @xmath351 + 2ay_{0}a_{0}b_{0}x+d_{0}\right\ } & \qquad \mbox{(+ ) region}\ ; , & \\
n_{1(-)}=-\epsilon\left\{a\;\frac{y_{-}}{k_{-}}\phi_{-}^{2}-d_{-}\right\ } & \qquad \mbox{(+ ) region}\ ; , & \end{array } \right.\ ] ] where @xmath352 and @xmath353 are integration constants .
the matching conditions @xmath354 and @xmath355 lead to @xmath356 \right .
\nonumber \\ & & \left.-2\left[\left(\frac{y_{0}}{k_{0}}-\frac{y_{+}}{k_{+}}\right ) \frac{1}{{\cal m}_{1}}-\left(\frac{y_{0}}{k_{0}}-\frac{y_{-}}{k_{-}}\right ) \frac{1}{{\cal m}_{2}}\right]k_{1}k_{2 } -\frac{y_{0}}{k_{0}}k_{1}k_{2}(z_{1}+z_{2})\right\}\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in deriving these relations the expressions ( [ ab+-0 ] ) for @xmath357 and the determining equation ( [ h1 ] ) were used . as for the equation ( [ eq - pi1 ] ) , first take the @xmath358 function at @xmath359 : @xmath360 where @xmath361 and the canonical equation were inserted . then the integration constant @xmath362 should be @xmath363 and similary @xmath364 now the metric tensor is completely determined : @xmath365^{2}\ ; , \nonumber \\
n_{0(-)}(x)&=&\frac{8}{j}\left(\frac{y_{+}}{k_{+}}+\frac{y_{-}}{k_{-}}\right ) \frac{k_{0}k_{2}}{{\cal m}_{2}}\;e^{-k_{-}(x - z_{2})}\ ; , \nonumber \\
\\ n_{1(+)}&=&\epsilon\frac{y_{+}}{k_{+ } } \left\{\frac{8}{j}\left(\frac{y_{+}}{k_{+}}+\frac{y_{-}}{k_{-}}\right ) \frac{k_{0}k_{1}}{{\cal m}_{1}}\;e^{k_{+}(x - z_{1})}-1\right\}\ ; , \nonumber \\
n_{1(0)}&=&\epsilon\left\{\frac{y_{0}}{2jk_{0}^{2 } } \left(\frac{y_{+}}{k_{+}}+\frac{y_{-}}{k_{-}}\right ) \left[k_{2}m_{2}\;e^{k_{0}(x - z_{2})}-k_{1}m_{1}\;e^{-k_{0}(x - z_{1 } ) } \right.\right .
\nonumber \\ & & \makebox[5em]{}\left.\left.+2k_{0}(k_{1}k_{2}m_{1}m_{2})^{1/2 } \;e^{\frac{1}{2}k_{0}(z_{1}-z_{2})}\;x\right]+d_{0}\right\}\ ; , \nonumber \\
n_{1(-)}&=&-\epsilon\frac{y_{-}}{k_{- } } \left\{\frac{8}{j}\left(\frac{y_{+}}{k_{+}}+\frac{y_{-}}{k_{-}}\right ) \frac{k_{0}k_{2}}{{\cal m}_{2}}\;e^{-k_{-}(x - z_{2})}-1\right\}\;. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] with this solution and the canonical equations , the field equation ( [ eq - pi1 ] ) can be proved to hold in a whole @xmath102 space . as we showed in the previous paper , to satisfy ( [ eq - psi1 ] )
the dilaton field @xmath11 needs an extra function @xmath366 , which has no effect on the dynamics of particles .
after lengthy calculation eq.([eq - psi1 ] ) leads to @xmath367 thus @xmath366 is uniquely determined .
for a single static source @xmath368 the solution to the field equations ( [ e - pi ] ) -([e - psi ] ) under the coordinate conditions ( [ cc ] ) is @xmath369 \ ; , \nonumber \\ & & \\
\pi & = & -\frac{\epsilon m}{4}\sqrt{1+\frac{8\lambda } { \kappa ^{2}m^{2}}}\;,\qquad \psi = -\frac{\kappa m}{2}\;|x|+\frac{\kappa \epsilon m}{2}\sqrt{1+\frac{8\lambda } { \kappa ^{2}m^{2}}}\;\;t\;. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] \{}from ( [ e - p ] ) and ( [ e - z ] ) the canonical equations for a test particle ( mass @xmath370 ) under the gravity of a static source are @xmath371 the hamiltonian leading to these equations is @xmath372 \;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this hamiltonian is also derived from the determining eq .
( [ h1 ] ) by setting @xmath373 and retaining only the linear terms of @xmath374 and @xmath375 . in terms of the proper time of the test particle @xmath376 the canonical equations
( [ test - can - p ] ) and ( [ test - can - z ] ) are expressed as @xmath377 eq.([test - p2 ] ) can be integrated and in @xmath378 region the solution @xmath182 is @xmath379 with @xmath380 } { \frac{\sqrt{p_{0}^{2}+\mu^2}-\epsilon p_{0}}{\mu } + \frac{\sqrt{1-\gamma_{m}}}{1+\sqrt{\gamma_m } } \;\mbox{tan}\left[\epsilon\sqrt{-\frac{\lambda}{8 } } ( \tau-\tau_{0})\right ] } & \qquad \lambda < 0 \ ; , \end{array } \right.\ ] ] where @xmath381 with @xmath236 being the initial momentum at @xmath237 . in @xmath382 region
the solution is @xmath383 with @xmath384 } { \frac{\sqrt{p_{0}^{2}+\mu^2}+\epsilon p_{0}}{\mu } + \frac{\sqrt{1-\gamma_{m}}}{1+\sqrt{\gamma_m } } \;\mbox{tan}\left[\epsilon\sqrt{-\frac{\lambda}{8 } } ( \tau-\tau_{0})\right ] } & \qquad \lambda < 0 \ ; , \end{array } \right.\ ] ] where @xmath385 when @xmath386 and @xmath387 at @xmath237 , the total energy is @xmath388 . the solution for @xmath389 is obtained from ( [ test - ham ] ) and @xmath182 as @xmath390 for the test particle solution the critical value of @xmath7 is @xmath391 .
fig.21 and 22 show typical trajectories of the test particle @xmath392 for @xmath393 and @xmath394 and @xmath395 .
the characteristics of these plots are common to those of the unequal mass case .
fig.21 _ phase space trajectories of a test particle for different values of @xmath7 .
_
fig.22 _ the @xmath184 plots corresponding to the trajectories in fig.21 . _
we can explicitly verify that the particles lose causal contact with one another for @xmath396 .
consider the unbounded motion of tan - type @xmath397 with @xmath398 and @xmath399 .
the path @xmath400 of light emitted from particle 2 at time @xmath248 is governed by @xmath187 , which reads @xmath401 and so the equation of the light signal directed to particle 1 is @xmath402 the light emitted in the opposite direction is described by @xmath403 numerically solving ( [ eq1light ] ) and ( [ eq2light ] ) yields the solutions shown in figs.23 and 24 , where the trajectories of light signals emitted from particle 2 at various times @xmath248 are plotted . for small @xmath404 ,
the particles are in causal contact ( a dotted curve in ( + ) direction in fig.23 ) , but for @xmath405 the signal just barely catches up with particle 1 , which is almost in light - like motion ( a dashed curve in ( + ) direction in fig.23 ) . for @xmath406
the world line @xmath400 in the ( + ) direction is parallel to @xmath407 at large @xmath172 and in the ( - ) direction it goes nearly on the same trajectory with the particle 2 . for large @xmath248 ( @xmath408 ) the particles are out of causal contact with each other ( fig.24 ) : a light ray sent from particle 2 toward particle 1 receives a strong repulsive effect and ultimately reverses direction , following behind particle 2 . in fig.24 the trajectories of the light signal emitted to ( - ) direction can not be discriminated from those of the particle 2 . a flat - space model of these effects
can be constructed as follows .
consider the following expression for the 2-velocity @xmath413 where @xmath414 is some function and @xmath415 is the flat metric .
we have @xmath416 , @xmath417 and so @xmath418 the general expression for the acceleration of a particle with 2-velocity ( [ eq2v ] ) is @xmath419 where @xmath420 .
we have @xmath421 and @xmath422 and @xmath423 for the magnitude of the acceleration . in general
we have the following possibilites : \2 ) the function @xmath427 as @xmath426 . in this case
the particle becomes lightlike , but it takes an infinite proper time ( and coordinate time ) for this to happen .
the standard example is @xmath428 , the constant acceleration example .
\3 ) the function @xmath427 as @xmath429 , where @xmath430 is finite . in this case
the particle becomes lightlike in a finite amount of proper time , but an infinite amount of coordinate time .
an example would be @xmath431 .
the acceleration is not constant , but increases as a function of proper time , diverging at @xmath237 .
this last situation is realized by our exact solutions ( [ sol - tana][sol - tanb ] ) with @xmath432 . | we develop the canonical formalism for a system of @xmath0 bodies in lineal gravity and obtain exact solutions to the equations of motion for @xmath1 .
the determining equation of the hamiltonian is derived in the form of a transcendental equation , which leads to the exact hamiltonian to infinite order of the gravitational coupling constant . in the equal mass case
explicit expressions of the trajectories of the particles are given as the functions of the proper time , which show characteristic features of the motion depending on the strength of gravity ( mass ) and the magnitude and sign of the cosmological constant .
as expected , we find that a positive cosmological constant has a repulsive effect on the motion , while a negative one has an attractive effect
. however , some surprising features emerge that are absent for vanishing cosmological constant . for a certain range of the negative cosmological constant
the motion shows a double maximum behavior as a combined result of an induced momentum - dependent cosmological potential and the gravitational attraction between the particles . for a positive cosmological constant ,
not only bounded motions but also unbounded ones are realized .
the change of the metric along the movement of the particles is also exactly derived .
* exact solutions of relativistic two - body motion in lineal gravity * + r.b .
mann and d. robbins + dept . of physics ,
university of waterloo waterloo , ont n2l 3g1 , canada + and + t. ohta + department of physics , miyagi university of education , aoba - aramaki , sendai 980 , japan + pacs numbers : 13.15.-f , 14.60.gh , 04.80.+z + + |
a central open question in classical fluid dynamics is whether the incompressible three - dimensional euler equations with smooth initial conditions develop a singularity after a finite time .
a key result was established in the late eighties by beale , kato and majda ( bkm ) .
the bkm theorem @xcite states that blowup ( if it takes place ) requires the time - integral of the supremum of the vorticity to become infinite ( see the review by bardos and titi @xcite ) . many studies have been performed using the bkm result to monitor the growth of the vorticity supremum in numerical simulations in order to conclude yes or no regarding the question of whether a finite - time singularity might develop .
the answer is somewhat mixed , see _
e.g. _ references @xcite and the recent review by gibbon @xcite .
other conditional theoretical results , going beyond the bkm theorem , were obtained in a pioneering paper by constantin , fefferman and majda @xcite .
they showed that the evolution of the direction of vorticity posed geometric constraints on potentially singular solutions for the 3d euler equation @xcite .
this point of view was further developed by deng , hou and yu in references @xcite and @xcite .
an alternative way to extract insights on the singularity problem from numerical simulations is the so - called analyticity strip method @xcite . in this method the time is considered as a real variable and the space - coordinates
are considered as complex variables .
the so - called `` width of the analyticity strip '' @xmath5 is defined as the imaginary part of the complex - space singularity of the velocity field nearest to the real space .
the idea is to monitor @xmath1 as a function of time @xmath6 .
this method uses the rigorous result @xcite that a real - space singularity of the euler equations occurring at time @xmath7 must be preceded by a non - zero @xmath1 that vanishes at @xmath7 . using spectral methods @xcite , @xmath1
is obtained directly from the high - wavenumber exponential fall off of the spatial fourier transform of the solution @xcite .
this method effectively provides a `` distance to the singularity '' given by @xmath1 @xcite , which can not be obtained from the general bkm theorem .
note that the bkm theorem is more robust than the analyticity - strip method in the sense that it applies to velocity fields that do not need to be analytic .
however , in the present paper we will concentrate on initial conditions that are analytic . in this case
, there is a well - known result that states : _ in three dimensions with periodic boundary conditions and analytic initial conditions , analyticity is preserved as long as the velocity is continuously differentiable _ ( @xmath8 ) _ in the real domain _ @xcite .
the bkm theorem allows for a strengthening of this result : analyticity is actually preserved as long as the vorticity is finite @xcite .
the analyticity - strip method has been applied to probe the euler singularity problem using a standard periodic ( and analytical ) initial data : the so - called taylor - green ( tg ) vortex @xcite .
we now give a short review of what is already known about the tg dynamics .
numerical simulations of the tg flow were performed with resolution increasing over the years , as more computing power became available .
it was found that except for very short times and for as long as @xmath1 can be reliably measured , it displays almost perfect exponential decrease .
simulations performed in @xmath9 on a grid of @xmath10 points obtained @xmath11 ( for @xmath6 up to @xmath12 ) @xcite .
this behavior was confirmed in @xmath13 at resolution @xmath14 @xcite .
more than @xmath15 years after the first study , simulations performed on a grid of @xmath16 points yielded @xmath17 ( for @xmath6 up to @xmath18 ) @xcite .
if these results could be safely extrapolated to later times then the taylor - green vortex would never develop a real singularity @xcite .
the present paper has two main goals .
one is to report on and analyze new simulations of the tg vortex that are performed at resolution @xmath0 .
these new simulations show , for the first time , a well - resolved change of regime , leading to a faster decay of @xmath1 happening at a time where preliminary @xmath3 visualizations show the collision of vortex sheets .
that was reported in mhd for the so - called imtg initial data at resolution @xmath16 in reference @xcite . ]
the second goal of this paper is to answer the following question , motivated by the new behavior of the tg vortex : how fast does the analyticity - strip width have to decrease to zero in order to sustain a finite - time singularity , consistent with the bkm theorem ?
to the best of our knowledge , this question has not been formulated previously . to answer this question
we introduce a new bound of the supremum norm of vorticity in terms of the energy spectrum .
we then use this bound to combine the bkm theorem with the analyticity - strip method .
this new bound is sharper than usual bounds .
we show that a finite - time blowup exists only if the analyticity - strip width goes to zero sufficiently fast at the singularity time .
if a power - law behavior is assumed for @xmath1 then its exponent must be greater than some critical value .
in other words , we provide a powerful test that can potentially rule out the existence of a finite - time singularity in a given numerical solution of euler equations .
we apply this test to the data from the latest @xmath0 taylor - green numerical simulation in order to see if the change of behavior in @xmath1 can be consistent with a singularity .
the paper is organized as follows : section [ sec : theo ] is devoted to the basic definitions , symmetries and numerical method related to the inviscid taylor - green vortex . in sec .
[ sec : numerics_classical ] , the new high - resolution taylor - green results are presented and are analyzed classically in terms of analyticity - strip method and bkm . in sec .
[ sec : as_bkm ] , the analyticity - strip method and bkm theorem are bridged together .
the section starts with heuristic arguments that are next formalized in a mathematical framework of definitions , hypotheses and theorems . in sec .
[ sec : newanal ] , our new theoretical results are used to analyze the behavior of the decrement .
section [ sec : conclusion ] is our conclusion .
the generalization to non tg - symmetric periodic flows of the results presented in sec .
[ sec : as_bkm ] are described in an appendix .
let us consider the 3d incompressible euler equations for the velocity field @xmath19 defined for @xmath20 and in a time interval @xmath21 : @xmath22 the taylor - green ( tg ) flow @xcite is defined by the @xmath23-periodic initial data @xmath24 , where @xmath25 the periodicity of @xmath26 allows us to define the ( standard ) fourier representation @xmath27 the kinetic energy spectrum @xmath28 is defined as the sum over spherical shells @xmath29 and the total energy @xmath30 is independent of time because @xmath26 satisfies the 3d euler equations ( [ eq : euler ] ) .
a number of the symmetries of @xmath31 are compatible with the equation of motions .
they are , first , rotational symmetries of angle @xmath32 around the axis @xmath33 and @xmath33 ; and of angle @xmath34 around the axis @xmath35 .
a second set of symmetries corresponds to planes of mirror symmetry : @xmath36 , @xmath37 and @xmath38 . on the symmetry planes , the velocity @xmath31 and
the vorticity @xmath39 are ( respectively ) parallel and perpendicular to these planes that form the sides of the so - called impermeable box which confines the flow .
it is demonstrated in reference @xcite that these symmetries imply that the fourier expansions coefficients of the velocity field in eq . @xmath40
vanishes unless @xmath41 are either all even or all odd integers .
this fact can be used in a standard way @xcite to reduce memory storage and speed up computations .
the euler equations are solved numerically using standard @xcite pseudo - spectral methods with resolution @xmath42 .
time marching is done with a second - order runge - kutta finite - difference scheme .
the solutions are dealiased by suppressing , at each time step , the modes for which at least one wave - vector component exceeds two - thirds of the maximum wave - number @xmath43 ( thus a @xmath0 run is truncated at @xmath44 ) .
the simulations reported in this paper were performed using a special purpose symmetric parallel code developed from that described in @xcite .
the workload for a timestep is ( roughly ) twice that of a general periodic code running at a quarter of the resolution .
specifically , at a given computational cost , the ratio of the largest to the smallest scale available to a computation with enforced taylor - green symmetries is enhanced by a factor of @xmath45 in linear resolution .
this leads to a factor of @xmath46 savings in total computational time and memory usage .
the code is based on fftw and a hybrid mpi - openmp scheme derived from that described in @xcite .
the runs were performed on the idris bluegene / p machine . at resolution @xmath0 we used @xmath47 mpi processes , each process spawning @xmath45 openmp threads .
( see eq . ) at @xmath48 and b ) maximum of vorticity @xmath49 .
results from runs performed at different resolutions are displayed together : @xmath50 ( brown triangles ) , @xmath51 ( blue squares ) , @xmath16 ( green diamonds ) and @xmath0 ( red circles).,height=377 ] runs were performed at resolutions @xmath50 , @xmath51 , @xmath16 and @xmath52 .
the behavior of the energy spectra and the spatial maximum of the norm of the vorticity @xmath53 are presented in fig .
[ fig : energy_spectra_maxvort ] . visualization of tg vorticity @xmath54 at resolution @xmath0 : a ) full impermeable box @xmath55 , @xmath56 and @xmath57 at @xmath58 .
zooms over the subbox marked near @xmath59 , @xmath60 are displayed in b ) at @xmath61 , in c ) at @xmath58 and in d ) at @xmath62.,height=359 ] it is apparent in fig .
[ fig : energy_spectra_maxvort](a ) that resolution - dependent even - odd oscillations are present , at certain times , on the tg energy spectrum .
note that this behavior is produced when the tail of the spectrum rises above the round - off error @xmath63 .
this phenomenon can be explained in terms of a _ resonance _
@xcite , along the lines developed in reference @xcite . in practice
we will deal with this problem by averaging the spectrum over shells of width @xmath64 .
apart from this it can be seen that spectra computed using different resolutions are in good agreement for all times .
in contrast , it is visible in fig .
[ fig : energy_spectra_maxvort](b ) that the maximum of vorticity @xmath49 computed at different resolutions are in agreement only up to some resolution - dependent time ( see the inset ) . the fact that @xmath49 at a given time @xmath65 decreases if one truncates the higher wavenumbers of the velocity field ( see fig .
[ fig : energy_spectra_maxvort](b ) ) strongly suggests that @xmath49 has significant contributions coming from high - wavenumbers modes .
this forms the basis of the heuristic argument presented below in sec .
[ subsec : heur ] .
figure [ fig : vort_3d_viz ] shows @xmath3 visualizations ( using the vapor software ) of the high vorticity regions in the impermeable box , corresponding to the @xmath0 run at late times .
a thin vortex sheet is apparent in fig.[fig : vort_3d_viz](a ) on the vertical faces @xmath66 , @xmath32 and @xmath67 , @xmath32 of the impermeable box . the emergence of this thin vortex sheet is well understood by simple dynamical arguments about the flow on the faces of the impermeable box that were first given in reference @xcite .
we now briefly review these arguments .
the initial vortex on the bottom face is first forced by centrifugal action to spiral outwards toward the edges and then up the side faces .
a corresponding outflow on the top face and downflow from the top edges onto the side faces leads to a convergence of fluid near the horizontal centreline of each side face , from where it is forced back into the centre of the box and subsequently back to the top and bottom faces .
the vorticity on the side faces is efficiently produced in the zone of convergence , and builds up rapidly into a vortex sheet ( see figs . 1 and 2 of reference @xcite and fig
. 8 of reference @xcite ) .
while these considerations explain the presence of the thin vortex sheet in fig.[fig : vort_3d_viz](a ) , the dynamics presented in fig.[fig : vort_3d_viz](b - d ) also involves the collision of vortex sheets happening near the edge @xmath59 , close to @xmath60 .
note that , as stated above in sec .
[ subsec : symm ] , the vortex lines are perpendicular to the faces of the impermeable box .
thus , because the collision takes place near an edge , the corresponding vortex lines must be highly curved , with strong variations of the direction of vorticity .
the geometric constraints on potential singularities posed by the evolution of the direction of vorticity developed in references @xcite could be applied to the situation described in fig .
[ fig : vort_3d_viz ] .
however , such an analysis goes beyond the bkm theorem and involves extensive post - processing of very large datasets .
this task is thus left for further work and we concentrate here on simple bkm diagnostics for the vorticity supremum and analyticity strip analysis of energy spectra .
the analyticity - strip method @xcite is based on the fact that when the velocity field is analytic in space the energy spectrum satisfies @xmath68 in the asymptotic ` ultraviolet region ' @xmath69 with a proportionality factor that may contain an algebraic decay in @xmath70 a multiplicative function of time and , depending on the complexity of the physical flow , even an oscillatory ( in @xmath71 ) modulation @xcite .
( red markers ) ; times and fit intervals are indicated in the legend . ]
the basic idea is thus to assume that @xmath28 can be well approximated by a function of the form @xmath72 in some wave numbers interval between @xmath73 and @xmath74 ( the maximum wavenumber permitted by the numerical resolution @xmath42 ) . the common procedure to determine @xmath75 is to perform a least - square fit at each time @xmath6 on the logarithm of the energy spectrum @xmath28 , using the functional form @xmath76 the error on the fit interval @xmath77 ,
@xmath78 is minimized by solving the equations @xmath79 , @xmath80 and @xmath81 .
note that these equations are linear in the parameters @xmath82 , @xmath83 and @xmath84 the transient oscillations of the energy spectrum observed at the highest wavenumbers ( see above fig .
[ fig : energy_spectra_maxvort](a ) are eliminated by averaging the tg spectrum on shells of width @xmath64 before performing the fit @xcite .
we present in fig .
[ fig : fit_comp ] , examples of tg energy spectra fitted in such a way on the intervals @xmath85 , where @xmath86 denotes the beginning of round off noise .
it is apparent that the fits are globally of a good quality .
the time evolution of the fit parameters @xmath87 , @xmath88 and @xmath89 computed at different resolutions are displayed in fig .
[ fig : fit_evolution ] .
the measure of the fit parameters is reliable as long as @xmath1 remains larger than a few mesh sizes , a condition required for the smallest scales to be accurately resolved and spectral convergence ensured .
thus the dimensionless quantity @xmath90 is a measure of spectral convergence .
it is conventional @xcite to define a ` reliability time ' @xmath91 by the condition @xmath92 and to say that the numerical simulation is reliable for times @xmath93 .
this reliability time can be extended only by increasing the spatial resolution available for the simulation , so the more computer power is available the larger is the reliability time .
the resolution - dependent reliability condition is marked by the horizontal lines in fig .
[ fig : fit_evolution](c ) . the exponential law @xmath94 that was previously reported at resolution @xmath16 in reference @xcite is also indicated in fig .
[ fig : fit_evolution](c ) by a dashed black line .
it is thus apparent that our lower - resolution results well reproduce the previous computations that were discussed above in sec .
[ sec : intro ] ( see text preceding references @xcite ) . in table [ tab : table_rel ] , the reliability time obtained from the fit parameter @xmath88 of fig .
[ fig : fit_evolution ] is compared with the reliability time stemming from the exponential behavior .
.reliability time deduced from the exponential behavior compared with the reliability time obtained from the fit parameter @xmath88 of fig .
[ fig : fit_evolution ] . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] the results for exponent and predicted singular time of table [ tab : table_dels ] have to be read carefully . because of the local @xmath95-point method used to derive them from the data in table [ tab : table_int ] , they use the values of @xmath88 at @xmath96 , the last one being marginally reliable ( see sec.[sec : numefits ] ) . in fact , they amount to linear @xmath97-point extrapolation of the data in fig .
[ fig : delta1 ] ( see the inset ) : @xmath7 is the intersection of the straight line extrapolation with the time axis and @xmath98 is the inverse of the slope .
one can guess that there is room for a power - law type of behavior , with exponent @xmath99 if we consider the data at @xmath100 and @xmath101 if we include the data at @xmath102 .
we now use corollary 11 ( see sec . [
sec : as_bkm ] ) to test if these estimates of power - law are consistent with the hypothesis of finite - time singularity .
there , the product @xmath103 must be greater than or equal to one if finite - time singularity is to be expected . with the conservative estimate @xmath104 obtained by inspection of fig .
[ fig : fit_evolution](b ) ( or equivalently using the values of @xmath89 in table [ tab : table_int ] ) , we obtain that @xmath105 for the data at @xmath106 and @xmath58 , but @xmath107 for the data at @xmath102 .
these results are insensitive to the fit interval , see table [ tab : table_dels ] .
therefore , if the latest data is considered , corollary 11 can not be used to negate the validity of the hypothesis of finite - time singularity .
however , there is no sign that the data values of @xmath98 and @xmath7 in table [ tab : table_dels ] are settling down into constants , corresponding to a simple power - law behavior .
another piece of analysis consists of comparing the singular time predicted from the data for the decrement @xmath1 with the singular time predicted from the direct data for the vorticity supremum norm .
they seem both to be close to @xmath108 ( compare table [ tab : table_dels ] to table [ tab : table_omegasup ] ) . in this context
, we should perhaps mention feynman s rule : `` never trust the data point furthest to the right '' , a comment attributed to richard feynman , saying basically that he would never trust the last points on an experimental graph , because if the people taking data could have gone beyond that , they would have .
higher - resolution simulations are clearly needed to investigate whether the new regime is genuinely a power law and not simply a crossover to a faster exponential decay .
our conclusion for this section is thus similar to that of sec .
[ subsec : fit_methods_omegas ] : although our late - time reliable data for @xmath1 shows @xmath109 and is therefore not inconsistent with our corollary 11 , clear power - law behavior of @xmath1 is not achieved .
in summary , we presented simulations of the taylor - green vortex with resolutions up to @xmath0 .
we used the analyticity strip method to analyze the energy spectrum .
we found that , around @xmath110 , a ( well - resolved up to @xmath111 ) change of regime is taking place , leading to a faster decay of the width of the analyticity strip @xmath1 . in the same time - interval
, preliminary @xmath3 visualizations displayed a collision of vortex sheets . applying the bkm criterium to the growth of the maximum of the vorticity on the time - interval @xmath2 we found that the occurrence of a singularity around @xmath112 was not ruled out but that higher - resolution simulations were needed to confirm a clear power - law behavior for @xmath113 .
we introduced a new sharp bound for the supremum norm of the vorticity in terms of the energy spectrum .
this bound allowed us to combine the bkm theorem with the analyticity - strip method and to show that a finite - time blowup can exist only if @xmath1 vanishes sufficiently fast .
applying this new test to our highest - resolution numerical simulation we found that the behavior of @xmath1 is not inconsistent with a singularity .
however , due to the rather short time interval on which @xmath1 is both well - resolved and behaving as a power - law , higher - resolution studies are needed to investigate whether the new regime is genuinely a power law and not simply a crossover to a faster exponential decay .
let us finally remark that our formal assumptions of section [ subsec : main_results ] are motivated and to some extent justified by the fact that , in systems that are known to lead to finite - time singularity , the analogous of the working hypothesis ( [ eq : fit_bound ] ) is verified .
for the analogy to apply , a version of the bkm theorem must be available .
this is the case of the @xmath73-d inviscid burgers equation for a real scalar field @xmath114 defined on the torus : @xmath115 , \,\forall \ , t \in [ 0,t_*),\ ] ] which admits a bkm - type of theorem @xcite , with singularity time @xmath7 defined by @xmath116 . in the 1-d case ,
the analogous of our bound is @xmath117 using the simple trigonometric initial data @xmath118 , the energy spectrum can be expressed in terms of bessel functions that admit simple asymptotic expansions .
it is straightforward to show ( see @xcite for details ) that , for @xmath119 , one has the large-@xmath71 asymptotic expansion @xmath120 with @xmath121 while , at @xmath122 , @xmath123 in fact , the @xmath124 power law appears already before @xmath7 ( see the remark following eq .
( 3 - 10 ) of reference @xcite ) .
it is easy to check that the analytical solution admits , for all @xmath71 and for all @xmath6 sufficiently close to @xmath7 , a working hypothesis ( [ eq : fit_bound ] ) of the form @xmath125 with analytically - obtainable functions @xmath126 and @xmath127 with @xmath128 .
the analogous of corollary [ cor : beta ] gives the inequality @xmath129 which is saturated by the analytically - obtained exponents @xmath130 , @xmath128 .
we acknowledge useful scientific discussions with annick pouquet , uriel frisch and giorgio krstulovic who also helped us with the visualizations of fig . [
fig : vort_3d_viz ] .
the computations were carried out at idris ( cnrs ) .
support for this work was provided by ucd seed funding projects sf304 and sf564 , and ircset ulysses project `` singularities in three - dimensional euler equations : simulations and geometry '' .
here we provide the generalization to non tg - symmetric periodic flows of the results presented in section [ subsec : main_results ] . definition [ defn : spectrum ] and the working hypothesis ( hypothesis [ hypo : working ] ) are modified slightly in the general case .
accordingly , the new bounds leading to lemma [ lem : main ] and theorem [ thm : main ] need to be modified slightly to accommodate the general case .
the crucial derived relations between @xmath131 and @xmath132 in lemma [ lem : strong ] and corollaries [ cor : finite - time - sing ] and [ cor : beta ] will apply directly to the general periodic case and will not be discussed .
the main technical difference is that the new bounds presented in section [ subsec : main_results ] apply for a flow with tg symmetries ( see section [ subsec : symm ] ) which imply that only modes with even - even - even and odd - odd - odd wavenumber components are populated .
the general periodic case does not follow this restriction , which slightly modifies the bounds .
we will assume , to simplify matters , that the so - called zero - mode of the velocity field is identically zero : @xmath133 + notice that all remaining wave numbers are populated .
this means that all sums involving the scalar @xmath71 in equations ( [ eq : ineq_1 ] ) and ( [ eq : ineq_2_tyg ] ) will start effectively from @xmath134 also , because modes with mixed even - odd wavenumber components are allowed , the definitions of @xmath135 in lemma 2 and constant @xmath136 in equation ( [ eq : ineq_2_tyg ] ) must be replaced by more appropriate quantities .
therefore , the corresponding general periodic versions of lemma [ lem : main ] ( equation ( [ eq : ineq_1 ] ) ) and practical bound ( equation ( [ eq : ineq_2_tyg ] ) ) are : + * lemma [ lem : main] ( general periodic version of lemma [ lem : main ] ) . *
_ let @xmath137 be a velocity field with energy spectrum defined by equation ( [ eq : spectrum ] ) and let @xmath138 be its vorticity , defined on the periodicity domain @xmath139 ^ 3.$ ] then the following inequality is verified for all times @xmath21 when the sum in the rhs is defined , and independently of any evolution equation that @xmath140 might satisfy : _
@xmath141 _ where @xmath142 is the number of lattice points in a spherical shell of width 1 and radius @xmath143 . _ + * practical bound , general case . *
@xmath144 where @xmath145 .
we can easily check that the bounds for taylor - green , equations ( [ eq : ineq_1 ] ) and ( [ eq : ineq_2_tyg ] ) , are sharper ( by a factor close to 2 ) to their respective general bounds , equations ( [ eq : ineq_1_gp ] ) and ( [ eq : ineq_2_gp ] ) . finally , theorem [ thm : main ] is replaced by + * theorem [ thm : main]. * _ let a solution of the 3d euler equations satisfy the working hypothesis ( [ eq : fit_bound ] ) with @xmath146 included .
then the maximal regularity time @xmath7 of the solution must satisfy _ @xmath147 | numerical simulations of the incompressible euler equations are performed using the taylor - green vortex initial conditions and resolutions up to @xmath0 .
the results are analyzed in terms of the classical analyticity strip method and beale , kato and majda ( bkm ) theorem .
a well - resolved acceleration of the time - decay of the width of the analyticity strip @xmath1 is observed at the highest resolution for @xmath2 while preliminary @xmath3 visualizations show the collision of vortex sheets .
the bkm criterium on the power - law growth of supremum of the vorticity , applied on the same time - interval , is not inconsistent with the occurrence of a singularity around @xmath4 .
these new findings lead us to investigate how fast the analyticity strip width needs to decrease to zero in order to sustain a finite - time singularity consistent with the bkm theorem .
a new simple bound of the supremum norm of vorticity in terms of the energy spectrum is introduced and used to combine the bkm theorem with the analyticity - strip method .
it is shown that a finite - time blowup can exist only if @xmath1 vanishes sufficiently fast at the singularity time .
in particular , if a power law is assumed for @xmath1 then its exponent must be greater than some critical value , thus providing a new test that is applied to our @xmath0 taylor - green numerical simulation .
our main conclusion is that the numerical results are not inconsistent with a singularity but that higher - resolution studies are needed to extend the time - interval on which a well - resolved power - law behavior of @xmath1 takes place , and check whether the new regime is genuine and not simply a crossover to a faster exponential decay . |
most elementary treatments of reflecting surfaces restrict their attention to the spherical case . in this standard case , and assuming the paraxial approximation ( all angles are small and all rays are close to the optical axis ) , the resulting equation relating the _ axial _ object and image positions and the radius of curvature of the reflecting spherical surface is @xmath0 where all parameters are one dimensional coordinates which locate the image ( @xmath1 ) , object ( @xmath2 ) , and center of curvature ( @xmath3 ) with respect to the vertex ( the intersection of the surface with the optical axis ) @xcite . a convention is typically assumed in which light rays travel from left to right in all figures . the origin of the one dimensional coordinate system employed coincides with the vertex , and locations to the right ( left ) of the vertex are positive ( negative ) .
[ ptbh ] the paraxial approximation is equivalent to a first order approximation in the height ( @xmath4 ) of the incidence point ( on the surface ) of a reflecting ray . to higher order , it is found that @xmath5 consequently , spherical mirrors are aberrant at higher order since the image location is not independent of the height , @xmath4 .
this paper represents a more general treatment of a mirror than is typically found in the literature .
the reflecting surface is assumed to be a conicoid , the surface of revolution generated by a conic .
equation ( [ gauss ] ) is then derived as the special case of a spherical surface and to first order in @xmath4 .
special cases are analyzed as a function of asphericity , or departure from the spherical , of the reflecting surface .
the parabolic surface is shown to be uniquely special in that @xmath6 to all orders for objects at infinity ( @xmath7 ) .
[ ptbh ] in fig .
[ fig02 ] , a conicoid reflecting surface is depicted with equation @xmath8 where @xmath3 is the radius of curvature of the surface at the vertex , and @xmath9 is the shape factor and is related to the standard eccentricity ( see appendix i or , for example , @xcite ) . for a sphere , @xmath10 , whereas for a paraboloid @xmath11 .
note that the @xmath12 coordinate system is set on its side so that @xmath13 coincides with the negative direction on the optical axis ( o.a . ) as defined in fig .
[ fig01 ] of the introduction .
consequently , the radius of curvature , @xmath3 , at the origin for any concave conicoid ( _ i.e. _ , opening to the left ) will be considered negative . in fig .
[ fig02 ] , a representative case is depicted with @xmath14 , the location of the object , and @xmath15 , the location of the image .
the figure displays an incident ray , @xmath16 , emanating from the object at @xmath17 and a reflected ray , @xmath18 , passing through the image at @xmath19 . from the figure
, the line @xmath16 has equation in the @xmath12-plane @xmath20 similarly , the line @xmath18 has equation @xmath21 consequently , @xmath22 where @xmath23 is the point of reflection , @xmath24 , on the surface . from the figure
, it follows that @xmath25 where @xmath26 and @xmath27 therefore @xmath28 substituting for the tangents from above yields @xmath29 -\left ( \frac{1}{uv}\right ) \frac{2y_{0}\left [ 1 + 2\left ( 1-\sigma\right ) ay_{0}\right ] } { \left ( 1 - 2\sigma ay_{0}\right ) ^{2}}=-\frac{4a}{1 - 2\sigma ay_{0 } } \label{eq09a}\]]@xmath30 -\left ( \frac{1}{uv}\right ) & 2y_{0}\left [ 1 + 2\left ( 1-\sigma\right ) ay_{0}\right ] \hspace{0.45in}\nonumber\\ & \hspace{0.6in}=-4a\left ( 1 - 2\sigma ay_{0}\right ) .
\label{eq09b}\ ] ] now let @xmath31 be the height of the incidence point @xmath24 for a particular ray from the source object at @xmath17 , then in the paraxial approximation ( @xmath32 ) , @xmath33 equation ( [ eq09b ] ) can then be rewritten to fourth order as @xmath34 h^{2}\nonumber\\ & \hspace{0.5in}+\left [ 4\sigma a^{4}\left ( \frac{1}{v}+\frac{1}{u}\right ) + 2\left ( 3\sigma+2\right ) a^{3}\left ( \frac{1}{uv}\right ) -24\sigma ^{2}a^{5}\right ] h^{4}. \label{eq11}\ ] ] note that there is aberration in imaging a finite axial point since there is no confluence in the rays from @xmath17 .
also note that there is no fixed shape factor @xmath35 that eliminates aberration to second order and higher . to first order
, all conicoids obey the same relation @xmath36 which coincides , of course , with the gaussian ( first order approximation ) equation for a spherical mirror with focal length @xmath37 . from eq .
( [ eq09b ] ) it follows that for objects at infinity ( @xmath38 ) and a parabolic shape ( @xmath11 ) , the image forms at @xmath39 regardless of the height of the incidence ray , therefore , there is no aberration for such imaging .
it is desirable to know to what extend the results of the previous section are pathological to conicoids . with this in mind consider the most general axi - symmetric surface of revolution ( about the y - axis ) as a reflector @xmath40 equation ( [ eq08b ] ) is easily generalized to @xmath41 where @xmath42 . in general , for a given axial object location , the image location ( or intersection point of the reflected ray with the optical axis ) is a function of the object location and the reflection point @xmath43 a reflecting surface is free of aberration if @xmath44 equation ( [ eq14 ] ) can be implicitly differentiated to yield @xmath45 } { y^{\prime}}\right\ } _ { 2}. \label{eq17}\ ] ] the aberration - free surface must satisfy @xmath46 .
however , it is evident from eq .
( [ eq17 ] ) that this can not be obtained trivially . for the special case
in which the object is at infinity though , the aberration - free surface must only satisfy @xmath47 , and this leads to a defining equation for the surface @xmath48 this is a linear differential equation whose general solution can most easily be found by the reduction in order method to give the general solution @xmath49 .
this further reduces to the particular solution of eq .
( [ eq32 ] ) , found by another method , after the two needed boundary conditions are invoked .
most elementary treatments of mirrors lack a discussion of the first order equation relating object and image locations in the case of arbitrary mirror shape .
the default reflecting surface is always the spherical one .
in fact , a simple analysis yields that all axi - symmetric , conic , reflecting surfaces of revolution ( conicoids ) in the first order , paraxial approximation satisfy the same ( gaussian ) equation @xmath50 where @xmath3 is the radius of curvature of the surface at its vertex .
aberrations enter at second order and can not be eliminated for finite object locations by any fixed shape .
however , for objects at infinity , or specifically , for incoming light parallel to the optical axis , there is a unique reflecting shape that is free of aberration the parabolic one .
starting with the general form of a conic section in cartesian coordinates , @xmath51 assume @xmath52-reflection symmetry , so that the equation reduces to @xmath53 next the curve is shifted so the vertex coincides with the origin , @xmath54 with @xmath55 . if the form is further constrained so that the curve lies in @xmath56 half - plane , then the positive root is required , and this yields @xmath57 or in terms of new parameters @xmath58 where @xmath59 .
the signed curvature of this curve at the origin is @xmath60 given the optics conventions adopted here as described in the introduction and depicted in figures 1 and 2 , the radius , @xmath3 , of the osculating circle at the origin for a concave conicoid is considered negative .
the radius of curvature is therefore related to the parameter @xmath61 @xmath62 and @xmath63 from eq .
( [ eq22 ] ) it follows that @xmath11 corresponds to a parabola . by putting eq .
( [ eq22 ] ) into canonical form @xmath64 it becomes clear that @xmath10 corresponds to a circle with radius @xmath65 .
the equation describes a hyperbola when @xmath66 . for @xmath67 ,
the equation describes an oblate ellipse ( with respect to the y - axis ) , and it describes a prolate ellipse for @xmath68 .
in fact , from eq .
( [ eq26 ] ) , the shape factor , @xmath35 , can be related to the standard eccentricity @xmath69
an alternate solution ( to that of section iii ) is presented for the exact conicoid shape in the limit that the object distance approaches infinity ( @xmath70 ) . applying the law of reflection ( based on fermat s principle of stationary optical path ) to a parallel ( to the optical axis ) ray ( from a distant object ) incident on an unknown conicoid surface , results in the optical path displayed in fig .
[ fig03 ] . applying eq .
( [ eq04b ] ) to the present special case , it follows that @xmath71 if the notation is changed and the @xmath72 variable is shifted for convenience , @xmath73 , then eq . ( [ eq29 ] ) can be reduced to either a homogeneous nonlinear ordinary differential equation ( ode ) of the form @xmath74 or to a nonlinear clairaut ode @xcite of the form @xmath75 recall that clairaut solutions are of the form @xmath76 and have envelopes that are also exact singularity solutions . solving eq .
( [ eq30 ] ) or ( [ eq31 ] ) yields the final form for the unknown conicoid ( and shifting back @xmath77 ) @xmath78 which is the equation for the ( meridional ) cross section of a paraboloid with focus at @xmath79 .
it is also of note that eq .
( [ eq30 ] ) with @xmath80 can be used to model various and sundry airplane , ship , and predator / prey pursuit problems @xcite .
foreman , `` the conic sections revisited , '' am .
* 59 * , 1002 - 1005 ( 1991 ) ; d.m .
watson , _ astronomy 203/403 : astronomical instruments and techniques on - line lecture , _ university of rochester ( 1999 ) , * http://www.pas.rochester.edu/dmw/ast203/lectures.htm . * | the first order equation relating object and image location for a mirror of arbitrary conic - sectional shape is derived .
it is also shown that the parabolic reflecting surface is the only one free of aberration and only in the limiting case of distant sources . |
in spite of being iso - structural and iso - valent to the cubic perovskite @xmath8k superconductor @xmath5 @xcite , @xmath4 remains in the normal metal state down to @xmath9k @xcite .
the specific heat measurements indicate that the absence of superconductivity in @xmath4 may be due to a substantial decrease in the density of states at the fermi energy @xmath10 resulting from its relatively low unit cell volume in comparison with @xmath5 @xcite .
however , electronic structure calculations show that the decrease in @xmath10 is not sizable enough to make @xmath4 non - superconducting @xcite . for both @xmath5 @xcite and @xmath4 @xcite the density of states spectra display similar characteristics , particularly in the distribution of electronic states near the fermi energy @xmath11 .
the electronic states at @xmath11 are dominated by @xmath12 @xmath13 states with a little admixture of @xmath2 @xmath14 states .
there exists a strong van hove singularity - like feature just below @xmath11 , which is primarily derived from the @xmath12 @xmath13 bands . to account for the lack of superconductivity in @xmath4
, the density - functional based calculations emphasize that the material subjected to the specific heat measurements may be non - stoichiometric in the @xmath2 sub - lattice @xcite .
this would then make it similar to the @xmath15 phase of @xmath5 , which has a low unit cell volume and remains non- superconducting @xcite .
it has been shown earlier that exact @xmath2 content in @xmath1 depends on the nature of synthesis and other experimental conditions @xcite . according to johannes and pickett @xcite , the arguments that favor non - stoichiometry are the following : ( i ) total energy minimization en - route to equilibrium lattice constant within the local - density approximation ( lda ) finds an overestimated value for @xmath4 in comparison with the experimental values .
in general , overestimation is not so common in lda .
meanwhile , when one uses similar technique for @xmath5 , the calculations find a slightly underestimated value which is consistent within the limitations of the density - functional theory @xcite .
( ii ) the authors also find @xmath10 in @xmath5 estimated as @xmath16 states / ry atom , while for @xmath4 , under similar approximations , it was found to be @xmath17 states / ry atom .
note that it has been shown both experimentally as well as from first - principles calculations that a decrease in the lattice constant or a decrease in the @xmath2 occupancy would lead to a decrease in @xmath10 @xcite .
( iii ) a decrease in the unit cell dimensions can induce phonon hardening .
this is well supported by the experiments which find the debye temperature approximately 1.6 times higher for @xmath4 in comparison to @xmath5@xcite .
earlier synthesis of @xmath0 @xcite finds the lattice constant to be @xmath18 a.u . ,
for which the occupancy in the @xmath2 sub - lattice was just @xmath19% .
the authors have employed similar preparation technique for @xmath5 @xcite and have found that the @xmath2 occupancy ranges between @xmath20-@xmath21 which is consistent with the recent reports @xcite .
lattice constant for @xmath4 , as high as @xmath22 a.u . has also been reported elsewhere @xcite , which then becomes consistent with the recent total energy minimized value using density - functional based methods .
hence , it seems that @xmath4 which was subjected to specific heat experiments @xcite may indeed suffer from non - stoichiometry . to understand and compare the effects of @xmath2 stoichiometry on the structural and electronic properties of @xmath1 and @xmath0
, we carry out a detail study using the korringa - kohn - rostoker ( kkr ) green s function method @xcite formulated in the atomic sphere approximation ( asa ) @xcite . for disorder
, we employ the coherent - potential approximation ( cpa ) @xcite .
characterization of @xmath1 and @xmath0 with @xmath23 mainly involves the changes in the equation of state parameters viz . , the equilibrium lattice constant , bulk modulus and its pressure derivative .
the electronic structure is studied with the help of total and sub - lattice resolved density of states .
the propensity of magnetism in these materials is studied with the help of fixed - spin moment method @xcite in conjunction with the landau theory of phase transition @xcite .
the hopfield parameter @xmath24 which generally maps the local `` chemical '' property of an atom in a crystal is also calculated as suggested by skriver and mertig @xcite , and its variation as a function of lattice constant has also been studied . in general , we find that both @xmath5 and @xmath4 display very similar electronic structure .
evidences point that the non - superconducting nature of @xmath4 may be related to the crystal structure characteristics , namely phonon spectra .
the ground state properties of @xmath1 and @xmath0 are calculated using the kkr - asa - cpa method of alloy theory . for improving alloy energetics ,
the asa is corrected by the use of both the muffin - tin correction for the madelung energy @xcite and the multi - pole moment correction to the madelung potential and energy @xcite .
these corrections have brought significant improvement in the accuracy of the total energy by taking into account the non - spherical part of polarization effects @xcite .
the partial waves in the kkr - asa calculations are expanded up to @xmath25 inside atomic spheres , although the multi - pole moments of the electron density have been determined up to @xmath26 which is used for the multi - pole moment correction to the madelung energy . in general , the exchange - correlation effects are taken into consideration via the local - density approximation with perdew and wang parametrization @xcite , although a comparison in the equation of state parameters has been made in this work with the generalized gradient approximation ( gga ) @xcite .
the core states have been recalculated after each iteration .
the calculations are partially scalar - relativistic in the sense that although the wave functions are non - relativistic , first order perturbation corrections to the energy eigenvalues due to the darwin and the mass - velocity terms are included .
the atomic sphere radii of @xmath6 ( @xmath7 ) , @xmath2 and @xmath12 were kept as @xmath27 , @xmath28 , and @xmath29 of the wigner- seitz radius , respectively .
the vacancies in the @xmath2 sub - lattice are modeled with the help of empty spheres , and their radius is kept same as that of @xmath2 itself .
the overlap volume resulting from the blow up of the atomic spheres was less than @xmath30% , which is legitimate within the accuracy of the approximation @xcite .
the electron - phonon coupling parameter @xmath31 can be expressed as @xmath24/@xmath32 , where @xmath24 is the hopfield parameter , expressed as the product of @xmath10 and the mean square electron - ion matrix element @xmath33 , with @xmath34 and @xmath35 being the ionic mass and average phonon frequency @xcite .
however , one may note that the above decomposition of the problem into electronic and phonon contributions is only approximate since in principle @xmath35 is also determined by the electronic states .
it follows that the hopfield parameter is the most simple basic quantity which one may obtain from first - principles as suggested by gaspari and gyorffy @xcite . the latter assumes a rigid muffin - tin approximation ( rmta ) in which the potential enclosed by a sphere rigidly moves with the ion and the change in the crystal potential , caused by the displacement , is given by the potential gradient . within the rmta the spherically averaged part of the hopfield parameter
may be calculated as , @xmath36 where @xmath10 is the total density of state per spin at the fermi energy , and @xmath37 the @xmath38 partial density of state calculated at the fermi energy @xmath11 , on the site considered .
the term @xmath39 is the electron - phonon matrix element given as @xcite , @xmath40 which are obtained from the gradient of the potential and the radial solutions @xmath41 and @xmath42 of the schrodinger equation evaluated at @xmath11 .
the special form of the eqs.[eq-123d ] and [ eq-123 m ] stems from the asa in which the radial wave functions are normalised to unity in the atomic sphere of radius @xmath43 , i.e. , @xmath44=@xmath45 . in asa
, @xmath46 is expressed in terms of logarithmic derivatives @xmath47=@xmath48/@xmath41 evaluated at the sphere boundary .
skriver and mertig derive the expression for @xmath39 as @xmath49\left[d_{l+1}+l+2)\right]+\left[e_{f}-v(s)\right]s^{2}\right\ } \end{array}\label{eq-234r}\ ] ] where @xmath50 is the one - electron potential and @xmath51 the sphere boundary amplitude of the @xmath52 partial wave evaluated at @xmath11 . numerical estimate to the magnetic energy are carried out using the fixed - spin - moment method @xcite . in the fixed - spin - moment method
the total energy is obtained for a given magnetization @xmath34 , i.e. , by fixing the numbers of electrons with up and down spins . in this case , the fermi energies in the up and down spin bands are not equal to each other because the equilibrium condition would not be satisfied for arbitrary @xmath34 . at the equilibrium @xmath34 two fermi energies will coincide with each other . the total magnetic energy becomes minimum or maximum at this value of @xmath34 .
note that the two approaches , i.e. , the self - consistent , floating - spin - moment method as well as the fixed - spin moment - method are equivalent in the sense that for a given lattice constant the magnetic moment calculated by the standard floating - spin moment approach is the same as the magnetic moment for which the fixed - spin moment total energy has its minimum @xcite . in practice
, the floating - spin moment approach sometimes runs into some convergence problem . from experience , to avoid such predicaments in convergence , one may carefully monitor the mixing of the initial and final charges during the iterations and increase the number of @xmath53 points .
thus , for a better resolution to determine the change in the total energy with respect to the input magnetization , the @xmath54- mesh had @xmath55 @xmath53 points in the irreducible wedge of the cubic brillouin zone . by the fixed - spin - moment method the difference @xmath56 ( = @xmath57 ) for given values of @xmath34 is calculated .
the calculated @xmath56 is fitted to the phenomenological landau equation of phase transition which is given as @xmath58 for @xmath59 , where the sign of the coefficient @xmath60 for @xmath61 determines the nature of the magnetic ground state , i.e. , @xmath62>0 refers to a paramagnetic ground state while @xmath63 refers to a ferromagnetic phase .
we have applied the approach described above to the study of carbon vacancy in @xmath5 @xcite and @xmath13 transition - metal-@xmath5 alloys @xcite .
both x - ray and neutron diffraction techniques unambiguously report @xmath5 and @xmath4 as cubic perovskites with their lattice constants determined as @xmath64 and @xmath65 a.u . , respectively .
assuming an underlying rigid cubic lattice , with @xmath6(@xmath7 ) at cube corners , @xmath12 at the faces and @xmath2 at the octahedral interstitial site , the total energy minimization were carried out to determine the equation of state parameters .
the total energies calculated , self - consistently , for six lattice constants close to equilibrium were fed as input to a third - order birch - murnaghan equation of state @xcite .
note that the birch - murnaghan equation is derived from the theory of finite strain , by considering an elastic isotropic medium under isothermal compression , with the assumption that the pressure - volume relation remains linear .
hence , in the optimization procedure we have restricted the choice close to the equilibrium .
.[tab - zncni3mg - eos]comparison of the equation of state parameters of cubic perovskite @xmath4 with that of @xmath66 using the kkr - asa method as described in the text . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ] the reported values of @xmath10 for @xmath5 are at variance with the existing reports @xcite .
it appears that the value is sensitive to the basic approximations made in each type of the electronic structure method , and also to the parameters like that of the choice of wigner - seitz radii , choice of the exchange - correlation potential and others .
however , under similar approximations , it is clear that for @xmath4 the @xmath10 reduces by @xmath67% in comparison with @xmath5 .
this is consistent with the earlier first - principles fp - lapw calculations @xcite .
the reduction in @xmath10 may be largely due to the smaller lattice constant of @xmath4 , in comparison with @xmath5 .
the change in the density of states , as well as in the @xmath10 as a function of lattice constant is shown in fig.[pressure - dos ] . approximating the variation of @xmath10 to be linear with respect to the lattice constant
, we find @xmath68/@xmath69 to be @xmath70 and @xmath71 st / ry atom / a.u for @xmath5 and @xmath4 , respectively . to understand the changes in the electronic structure upon the introduction of @xmath2 vacancies , we in figs.[cxtotdos ] , [ c2pdos ] , [ ni3ddos ] and [ c2pni3ddos ] show the changes in the total and sub - lattice resolved @xmath2 @xmath14 and @xmath12 @xmath13 partial densities of states of @xmath0 and @xmath1 alloys calculated at their equilibrium lattice constants .
it follows from the figures that the change in the distribution of states is more or less insignificant near the fermi energy , but states lower in energy undergo substantial changes . upon creation of vacancies , a few of the @xmath2 2@xmath72 - @xmath12 @xmath13 bonds break , and result in charge redistribution .
note that the @xmath73 octahedral is a covalently built complex to which the cations at the cube corners ( @xmath7 and @xmath6 ) are thought to have donated their outermost valence electrons .
the crystal geometry suggests six @xmath12 atoms as the first nearest neighbors to @xmath2 and eight @xmath6/@xmath7 atoms as its second nearest neighbors . for @xmath12
the second nearest coordination shell carries four @xmath6/@xmath7 atoms .
the charge redistribution arising due to the breaking of the @xmath72-@xmath74 bonds would be proportional to the electro - positivity of the cation- @xmath6/@xmath7 .
since @xmath6 is more electro - positive than @xmath7 , charge redistribution to the @xmath6/@xmath7 sub - lattices , as a function of vacancies would be more significant in @xmath5 when compared to @xmath4 .
this is consistent with the fact that a larger fraction of the charge would be transferred back to the @xmath6 sub - lattice , in @xmath5 in comparison with that of the @xmath12 sub - lattice .
the change in the @xmath10 as a function of lattice constant in @xmath75 alloys is shown in fig.[znxmg - latdos ] .
one may find that @xmath10 decreases for all values of @xmath76 , with respect to lattice constant .
however , @xmath10 as a function of @xmath76 , at the equilibrium lattice constant , was found to deviate a little , as is evident from fig.[znxmg - latdos ] .
this clearly suggests that the electronic structure properties are mainly governed by the @xmath73 octahedra .
the atoms occupying the cube corners i.e. , @xmath6 and @xmath7 , however , play a non - trivial role in determining the structural properties .
the hopfield parameter @xmath24 has been regarded as a local `` chemical '' property of an atom in a crystal .
it has been emphasized earlier that the most significant single parameter in understanding the @xmath77 of a conventional superconductor is the hopfield parameter @xcite . for strong - coupling systems ,
the variation in @xmath24 is more important than the variation of @xmath35 in changing @xmath77 .
softening @xmath35 often does enhance @xmath77 , but a significant change in the magnitude of @xmath77 depends largely on a significant change in the @xmath24 value rather than a small change in the corresponding @xmath35 . as a matter of fact , we look for the changes in the @xmath24 from the three sub - lattices of these perovskites as a function of lattice constant as well as @xmath78 in @xmath1 and @xmath0 alloys .
note that for @xmath5 , it has been reported that the superconducting transition temperature @xmath77 increases upon application of external pressure @xcite .
besides , experiments remain controversial on the strength of the electron - phonon interaction in @xmath5 @xcite . it has been suggested that @xmath5 may be a strongly - coupled superconductor , however , the magnitude of @xmath77 being marginally reduced due to the paramagnon interactions @xcite . in fig.[hopeta ]
we show the changes in the @xmath24 of @xmath5 and @xmath4 as a function of lattice constant .
it is clear from fig.[hopeta ] that the @xmath79 and @xmath80 linearly increase as a function of decreasing volume in either alloys . if the change in the average phonon frequency remains small , then either of these alloys could enhance the transition temperature with respect to external pressure . for @xmath5
this view is consistent with the previous experimental results .
similar characteristic feature holds for the vacancy - rich disordered alloys , the variation of which is shown in fig.[mgcxeta00 ] and [ zncxeta00 ] to have an understanding in the variation of @xmath79 , @xmath81 and @xmath80 where @xmath81 can be considered as the local chemical property of the electrons in the empty sphere , we show in fig.[cxeta ] the change in these parameters as a function of @xmath78 in both @xmath1 and @xmath0 alloys .
one may find that the variation of @xmath24 remains similar for both the alloys as a function of decreasing @xmath2 content .
total energies from both the self - consistent , spin polarized and spin unpolarized calculations remain degenerate for @xmath5 and @xmath4 alloys at their equilibrium lattice constants .
this unambiguously shows that the materials are non - magnetic in nature .
however , having suggested that @xmath5 is on the verge of a ferromagnetic instability @xcite , and also that incipient magnetism in the form of spin - fluctuations reside in the material , we attempt to compare the magnetic properties of @xmath5 and @xmath4 alloys using the fixed - spin moment approach of alloy theory @xcite . numerical calculations of magnetic energy @xmath56 for @xmath5 and @xmath4 are carried out at over a range of lattice constants .
the calculated results of @xmath56 in the fixed - spin - moment method are shown in fig.[fsm - de ] .
the calculated @xmath56 curves are fit to the form of a power series of @xmath82 up to @xmath59 , for the polynomial as mentioned above .
the variations of the coefficients , @xmath62 in units of @xmath83 , @xmath84 in @xmath85 , and @xmath86 in @xmath87 as a function of lattice constant are shown in fig.[fsm - coeff ] .
the propensity of magnetism can be inferred from the sign of the coefficient which is quadratic in @xmath34 , i.e. , @xmath62 .
the coefficient @xmath62 is the measure of the curvature and is positive definite when the total energy minimum is at @xmath88 , thus referring to a paramagnetic ground state . in general ,
when @xmath62 becomes negative , it infers that there would exist a minimum in the @xmath89 curve at a value other than @xmath88 referring to a ferromagnetic phase at that value of @xmath34 .
the higher - order coefficients @xmath84 and @xmath86 however are significant and they control the variation of @xmath90 with respect to @xmath34 . for example , for larger values of @xmath34 , @xmath84 and successively @xmath86 would dominate , and if @xmath84(@xmath86 ) tends to be negative it would show a dip in the @xmath89 variation pointing towards a magnetic transition at a higher value of @xmath34 .
this , in the first - principles characterization of the magnetic properties of a material would refer to a possibility of a metastable phase at relatively large values of external magnetic fields .
however , it has to be noted that calculations for large values of @xmath34 can result in ambiguous results .
hence , it is suggested to carry out calculations for smaller values of @xmath34 and use the above mentioned polynomial function up to the minimum order , where the curve fits with sufficient accuracy .
[ fsm - coeff ] shows that for smaller values of lattice constant , the alloys show an enhanced paramagnetic character .
one may also note that the variation in @xmath84 and @xmath86 coefficients are oppositely complimented and hence in the renormalized approach to include corrections due to spin - fluctuations , as suggested by yamada and terao @xcite , they would cancel out in proportion preserving the trend in the variation of @xmath62 .
thus , it becomes likely that the incipient magnetic properties associated with @xmath5 and @xmath4 would decrease as a function of decreasing lattice constant .
first - principles syudy of the electronic properties of @xmath5 and @xmath4 , and also their non - stoichiometric alloys are carried out using the density - functional - based kkr - asa method .
we find that the lattice constant for @xmath4 is overestimated , while for @xmath5 it is underestimated .
this suggests that the material @xmath4 subjected to experiments may be non - stoichiometric . as a function of decreasing @xmath2 content in @xmath1 and @xmath0 alloys
, one finds an opposite trend in the variation of pressure derivative of the bulk modulus , which is proportional to the averaged phonon frequency . with electronic structure remaining essentially the same for @xmath1 and @xmath0 , the results hint that non - stoichiometry may have opposite effects .
note that for @xmath91 , @xmath1 alloys are feebly superconducting , while according to the conjecture that has been made @xmath0 is not .
it can thus be inferred that the associated phonon modes in @xmath4 and its disordered alloys may be characteristically different when compared to the @xmath5 counterparts .
a comparison of the phonon spectra of these alloys thus become quite necessary to understand the absence of superconductivity in @xmath4 , although it is iso - structural and iso - valent with @xmath5 .
1 t. he , k.a .
regan , m.a .
hayward , a.p .
ramirez , y. wang , p. khalifah , t. he , j.s .
slusky , n. rogado , k. inumaru , m.k .
haas , h.w .
zandbergen , n.p .
ong , and r.j .
cava , nature , 411 , 54 ( 2001 ) m.- s. park , j. giim , s. h. park , h. c. ri , s. i. lee , and e. j. choi , supercond .
17 , 274 ( 2004 ) .
m. d. johannes and w. e. pickett , phys . rev .
b 70 , 060507 ( 2004 ) d. j. singh and i. i. mazin , phys . rev .
b 64 , 140507 ( 2001 ) h. rosner , r. weht , m. d. johannes , w. e. pickett , and e. tosatti , * * * * phys .
88 , 027001 ( 2002 ) s. b. dugdale and t. jarlborg , * * * * phys . rev .
b 64 , 100508 ( 2001 ) szajek a , j. phys . :
matter 13 , l595 ( 2001 ) a. ren , g. c. che , s. l. jia , h. chen , y. m. ni , g. d. liu and z. x. zhao , * * * * physica c 371 , 1 ( 2002 ) j. q. li , l. j. wu , l. li , and y. zhu , phys . rev .
b 65 , 052506 ( 2002 ) j. h. kim , j. s. ahn , j. kim , m .- s .
park , s. i. lee , e. j. choi , and s .- j .
oh , phys .
b 66 , 172507 ( 2002 ) g. kinoda , m. nishiyama , y. zhao , m. murakami , n. koshizuka and t. hasegawa , japan . j. appl
40 l1365 , ( 2001 ) l. shan , k. xia , z. y. liu , h. h. wen , z. a. ren , g. c. che and z. x. zhao , * * * * phys . rev .
b 68 024523 ( 2003 ) p. j. t. joseph and p. p. singh , phys .
b 72 , 064519 ( 2005 ) p. j. t. joseph and p. p. singh , phys . rev .
b 72 , 214206 ( 2005 ) h. h. stadelmaier and l. j. huetter , z. metallk 50 , 199 ( 1959 ) h. h. stadelmaier and l. j. huetter , acta metall .
, 7 , 415 ( 1959 ) h. h. stadelmaier and f. h. hammad , metall 15 , 124 ( 1961 ) t.g .
amos , q. huang , j.w .
lynn , t. he , r.j .
cava , solid state commun 121 , 73 ( 2002 ) h. h. stadelmaier and t. s. yun , z. metallk 52 , 477 ( 1961 ) j. b. goodenough and j. m. longo , landolt- bornstein series , vol iiia j. korringa , physica 13 , 392 ( 1947 ) w. kohn and n. rostoker , phys . rev 94 , 1111 ( 1954 ) i. turek , v. drchal , j. kudrnovsky , m. sob and p. weinberger , electronic structure of disordered alloys , surfaces andinterfaces , kluwer academic publishers , 1997 .
p. soven phys .
156 , 809 ( 1967 ) k schwarz and p mohn , j. phys .
14 , l129 ( 1984 ) statistical physics , l. d. landau and e. m. lifshitz , pergamom press london ( 1962 ) h. l. skriver and i. mertig , phys
b 32 , 4431 ( 1985 ) n. e. christensen and s. satpathy , phys .
55 , 600 ( 1985 ) .
a. v. ruban and h. l. skriver phys .
b 66 , 024201 ( 2002 ) a. v. ruban , s. i. simak , p. a. korzhavyi , and h. l. skriver phys .
b 66 , 024202 ( 2002 ) a. v. ruban and h. l. skriver computational materials science , 15 , 119 ( 1999 ) j. p. perdew and y. wang , phys . rev .
b 45 , 13244 ( 1992 ) .
j. p. perdew , k. burke , and y. wang , phys . rev .
b 54 , 16533 ( 1996 ) hans .
l. skriver , the lmto method , muffin tin orbitals and electronic structure , springer- verlag ( 1984 ) superconductivity in @xmath92 and @xmath93 band metals , edited by d. h. douglass , plenum press newyork ( 1976 ) g. d. gaspari and b. l. gyorffy , phys .
28 , 801 ( 1972 ) r. hayn and v. drchal phys . rev . b 58 , * * * * 4341 ( 1998 ) f. birch , j. geophys .
57 , 227 ( 1952 ) f. d. murnaghan , wiley , new york , 140 pp .
( 1951 ) r. heid , b. renker , h. schober , p. adelmann , d. ernst , and k .-
bohnen , phys . rev .
b 69 , 092511 ( 2004 ) a. yu .
ignatov , s. y. savrasov , and t. a. tyson , phys . rev .
b 68 , 220504 ( 2003 ) s. -h .
park , y. w. lee , j. giim , sung - hoon jung , h. c. ri and e. j. choi , * * * * physica c 400 , 160 ( 2004 ) i. r. shein , a. l. ivanovskii , e. z. kurmaev , a. moewes , s. chiuzbian , l. d. finkelstein , m. neumann , z. a. ren , and g. c. che , phys .
b 66 , 024520 ( 2002 ) i. g. kim , j. i. lee and a. j. freeman , phys . rev .
b 65 , 064525 ( 2002 ) x. zheng , y. xu , z. zeng and e. baggio - saitovitch , physica c 408 - 410 , 154 ( 2004 ) m. q. tan , x. m. tao , x. j. xu , j. h. he and g. x. ye , physica b 337 , 95 ( 2003 ) j. l. wang , y. xu , z. zeng , q. q. zheng , h. q. lin , j. appl .
phys 91 , 8504 ( 2002 ) h. d. yang , s. mollah , w. l. huang , p. l. ho , h. l. huang , c. j. liu , j. y. lin , y. l. zhang , r. c. yu and c. q. jin , phys . rev .
b 68 092507 ( 2003 ) t. g. kumary , j. janaki , a. mani , s. m. jaya , v. s. sastry , y. hariharan , t. s. radhakrishnan , and m. c. valsakumar , phys .
b 66 , 064510 ( 2002 ) j .- y .
lin , p. l. ho , h. l. huang , p. h. lin , y .- l .
zhang , r .- c .
yu , c .- q .
jin , and h. d. yang phys . rev .
b 67 , 052501 ( 2003 ) a. walte , g. fuchs , k .- h .
muller , a. handstein , k. nenkov , v. n. narozhnyi , s .- l .
drechsler , s. shulga , l. schultz , and h. rosner phys . rev .
b 70 , 174503 ( 2004 ) z. q. mao , m. m. rosario , k. d. nelson , k. wu , i. g. deac , p. schiffer , y. liu , t. he , k. a. regan , and r. j. cava phys . rev .
b 67 , 094502 ( 2003 ) l. shan , z. y. liu , z. a. ren , g. c. che , and h. h. wen , phys . rev .
b 71 , 144516 ( 2005 ) p. m. singer , t. imai , t. he , m. a. hayward , and r. j. cava , * * * * phys . rev . lett .
87 , 257601 ( 2001 ) h. yamada and k. terao , phys .
b 59 , 9342 ( 1999 ) | first - principles , density - functional - based electronic structure calculations are employed to study the changes in the electronic properties of @xmath0 and @xmath1 using the korringa - kohn - rostoker coherent - potential approximation method in the atomic sphere approximation ( kkr - asa cpa ) . as a function of decreasing @xmath2 @xmath3%
, we find a steady decrease in the lattice constant and bulk modulus in either alloys .
however , the pressure derivative of the bulk modulus displays an opposite trend .
following the debye model , which relates the pressure derivative of the bulk modulus with the average phonon frequency of the crystal , it can thus be argued that @xmath4 and its disordered alloys posses a different phonon spectra in comparison to its @xmath5 counterparts .
this is further justified by the marked similarity we find in the electronic structure properties such as the variation in the density of states and the hopfield parameters calculated for these alloys .
the effects on the equation of state parameters and the density of states at the fermi energy , for partial replacement of @xmath6 by @xmath7 are also discussed . |
owing to typical astronomical timescales , a galaxy s spiral arms are often considered as a fixed pattern .
so , too , for the numerous , tightly wound spiral waves detected in saturn s rings .
in fact , both systems are dynamically active , with waves traveling away from resonant sites .
this is manifest only in saturn s case , where a pair of moons janus and epimetheus occupy nearly identical orbits that are interchanged every 4 years , causing the resonance locations in the rings to skip back and forth by tens of km . since spiral density waves are initiated in saturn s rings at locations where ring particle orbits are in a lindblad resonance with a perturbing moon , the starting points of waves jump as well , allowing wave trains to interfere in complex ways @xcite .
high - resolution images of the rings were obtained by the cassini spacecraft s imaging science subsystem ( iss ) on 2004 july 1 and on 2005 may 20/21 .
the calibration and image processing of these data , resulting in a series of brightness scans with orbital radius , along with a catalog of important satellite gravitational resonances falling within the rings , are presented by ( * ? ? ? * hereafter ) .
further analysis of these data , employing techniques derived from the wavelet transform , is presented by ( * ? ? ? * hereafter ) .
examination of the cassini images to date shows that density waves raised by the co - orbitals are both unusual and variable in their morphology . in this paper , we describe a model that accounts for much of the observed structure . we proceed to use this model to predict the future morphology of selected waves at the times and locations of planned cassini observations , which we expect will test our predictions .
, width=302 ]
the orbits of janus and epimetheus about saturn constitute a form of the three - body problem of celestial mechanics that is unique in the solar system ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
when viewed in a rotating frame of reference , whose angular velocity equals the mass - weighted average of the mean motions of the two moons , epimetheus executes a modified `` horseshoe orbit '' encompassing janus slowly drifting @xmath0 , @xmath1 , and @xmath2 lagrange points ( fig .
[ janepiorb ] ) .
however , since epimetheus mass is not negligible compared to janus the mass ratio is 0.278 @xcite janus executes its own libration about the average orbit . because the orbits of the two moons are so similar ( @xmath3 km ) , they are commonly known as the `` co - orbital satellites '' ( or , more briefly , the `` co - orbitals '' ) .
every 4.00 years , they execute their mutual closest approach and effectively `` trade '' orbits , the inner moon moving outward and vice versa .
the most recent reversal event occurred on 2006 january 21 , at which time janus became the inner satellite and epimetheus the outer .
spiral density waves are raised in the rings at locations where ring - particle orbits are in a lindblad resonance with a perturbing saturnian moon .
the density perturbations propagate outward from the resonance location .
as reviewed in ( see also * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , five parameters characterize the idealized functional form of the perturbation : 1 ) the background surface density @xmath4 , which fixes the wavelength dispersion , 2 ) the resonance location @xmath5 , specifying a linear translation of the wave , 3 ) the wave s initial phase @xmath6 , 4 ) the damping parameter @xmath7 , indicating a characteristic distance over which the wave propagates before damping away , and 5 ) the wave s amplitude @xmath8 , which is proportional to the perturbing moon s mass . considering only co - planar motions ,
the pattern speed of the resonant perturbation is described by positive integers @xmath9 and @xmath10 + 1 ; the first giving the number of spiral arms , and the second the order of the resonance ( first - order being strongest ) . a ( @xmath10 + 1)th - order lindblad resonance is generally labeled as @xmath11:@xmath12 . at a given ring longitude @xmath13 ,
the initial phase of a particular density wave is @xmath14 where @xmath15 and @xmath16 are the perturbing moon s mean longitude and longitude of periapse , respectively .
although previous authors have usually analyzed spiral density waves in saturn s rings as static phenomena , in fact they propagate with a finite group velocity @xcite @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the radial ( epicyclic ) frequency of ring particle orbits , and @xmath19 is newton s gravitational constant .
this is the speed at which information ( e.g. , effects of any change in the resonant forcing ) propagates . in the a ring
, @xmath20 is on the order of 10 - 20 km / yr . since spiral density waves commonly propagate over many tens of km , and the forcing from the co - orbital satellites changes every 4 yr , discontinuities resulting from reversal events should be observable in density waves raised by the co - orbitals .
in the radial scans of ring brightness taken from cassini iss images ( ) , spiral density waves due to the co - orbitals can be discerned at first - order , second - order , and third - order resonances .
first - order waves ( e.g. , 2:1 , 4:3 , 5:4 , 6:5 ) were seen by voyager , and are some of the strongest waves in the ring system .
however , non - linear effects , which occur when the density perturbations are comparable to the background surface density , greatly complicate their analysis @xcite .
not only does the wavelength dispersion deviate significantly from linear theory , but simple superposition of multiple wave segments is not valid .
second - order waves ( e.g. , 7:5 , 9:7 , 11:9 , 13:11 ) were first clearly resolved in the present cassini data set ( fig .
[ jewaveimages ] ) .
since the density perturbations comprising these weaker waves are much smaller than the background surface density , they remain well - described by linear theory , and overlapping wave segments can be simply superposed . accordingly , second - order waves are best - suited for comparison with our simple model , and we will focus exclusively on them . additionally , several third - order co - orbital waves can be discerned through wavelet analysis of the radial scans ( ) ; however , these are too weak for much detailed structure to be resolved .
our model is based on a simple assumption : when the co - orbital satellites are in a given configuration ( we ll call the janus - inward configuration `` je '' and the janus - outward configuration `` ej '' ) , spiral density waves propagate outward from the current lindblad resonance locations at the group velocity @xmath20 . when a reversal occurs ( e.g. , the satellites changing configurations from je to ej ) , the je resonance locations become inactive ; however , the waves previously generated there continue to propagate outwards , resulting in a `` headless '' wave .
meanwhile , new `` tailless '' spiral density waves begin to propagate outward at a speed @xmath20 from the ej lindblad resonance locations . , and from ej to je at @xmath21 yr ) .
parameters are based on the 9:7 density wave , but here @xmath22 for all wave segments . in the right - hand column
are wave segments created by janus in its inner ( purple ) and outer ( red ) configurations , and epimetheus in its inner ( blue ) and outer ( green ) configurations . only amplitudes larger than 1% are shown .
dotted lines show the resonance locations , with the same color coding .
the left - hand column shows the sum of the wave segments , which is the model prediction .
[ jemodeldemo],width=604 ] at any given time , the locations of `` headless '' and `` tailless '' wave segments can be easily calculated from @xmath20 and the elapsed interval since a reversal event .
we simply superpose these wave segments atop one another to arrive at a predicted wave morphology ( fig .
[ jemodeldemo ] ) .
this time - domain approach to the problem is an alternative to the frequency - domain treatment of @xcite .
we set the relative amplitude to unity for janus , and to the moons mass ratio of 0.278 for epimetheus .
the relevant resonance locations are easily derived from the moons orbital parameters @xcite .
the absolute navigation of iss images is not simple ( see ) ; nonetheless , all that is necessary for wave morphology is to know the separations among the resonance locations .
the phase of each wave segment ( eq . [ dwphase ] ) is determined by what the orbital parameters of the perturbing moon _ would have been _ had no reversal taken place .
this is calculated using high - precision numerically - integrated orbits @xcite .
we make a linear fit to @xmath15 and to @xmath16 over a single inter - reversal time period , then extrapolate forward to the observation time . at the end of this process ,
the only remaining free parameters in our model are the background surface density @xmath4 and the damping parameter @xmath7 , which respectively control the wavelength dispersion and the propagation distance .
we manually adjust these parameters to find the optimum agreement of feature locations between model and data . for locations at which a wave segment begins or ends
, an unrealistically sharp cutoff can occur .
we soften such discontinuities by using a half - gaussian , with a characteristic width of 1 km , to bring the perturbation back to zero . , and damping parameter @xmath7
are given in each figure .
radial traces were taken from the following images : a ) n1467345385 , b ) n1495327885 , c ) n1467345916 , d ) n1495326975 , e ) n1495326431 .
image resolutions are 250 m / pixel ( a , c ) and 1.4 km / pixel ( b , d , e ) .
model resolution has been degraded to correspond to image resolution .
[ jemodelresults],width=604 ]
our model results are shown , along with corresponding cassini image traces , in fig .
[ jemodelresults ] .
we find good qualitative agreement between the two , especially in the `` upstream '' ( left - hand ) regions .
there is also good agreement between model values of @xmath4 and @xmath7 and values for nearby waves in the a ring ( 9:7 , 11:9 ) and cassini division ( 7:5 ) ( ) .
we assume that image n1467345916 ( fig .
[ jemodelresults]c ) is in the reverse - contrast regime ( see ) .
the most glaring failure of the model occurs in regions where the predicted perturbation is zero ( figs .
[ jemodelresults]c and [ jemodelresults]d ) .
in such regions , the data instead show an oscillatory mode for which we can not account .
it is possible that such oscillations could be raised in the several months during which the resonance locations are migrating from one configuration to the other , which we neglect in treating the reversals as instantaneous events .
another potentially interesting explanation for such oscillations is that a leading spiral density wave may be propagating back towards the resonance location @xcite .
this mode is allowed by the mathematical formalism , but has never been observed and has been considered impossible to excite ; however , it is conceivable that a `` headless '' wave could send such a mode into an otherwise undisturbed region . , width=604 ]
predictions of our model for the times and locations of cassini iss observations designed to image the co - orbital waves @xcite are shown in fig .
[ jemodelpredict ] . owing to the spacecraft s low orbital inclination so far this year ,
the main rings have not been observed at high resolution since the last reversal event ( from ej to je ) on 2006 january 21 , so the wave patterns in the new configuration have yet to be observed .
we predict that the innermost wavecycles ( due to epimetheus in the ej configuration ) will become headless and shift outwards , while a blank gap ( possibly containing oscillations as in figs . [ jemodelresults]c and [ jemodelresults]d ) will appear between the new inner janus perturbation and the headless perturbation from the outer resonance location .
the next reversal event , expected on 2010 january 21 , will be observable only if the cassini mission is extended beyond the current plan .
saturn s rings are a nearby and accessible natural laboratory @xcite , in which we can observe phenomena of broader interest , such as how a disk responds to variable forcing .
our model is a first step towards a new understanding of the observed complex and time - variable waveforms .
we will revisit this topic in more detail , after the accuracy of our predictions ( at least for data that will be obtained this year ) becomes apparent .
, c. c. , west , r. a. , squyres , s. , mcewen , a. , thomas , p. , murray , c. d. , delgenio , a. , ingersoll , a. p. , johnson , t. v. , neukum , g. , veverka , j. , dones , l. , brahic , a. , burns , j. a. , haemmerle , v. , knowles , b. , dawson , d. , roatsch , t. , beurle , k. , & owen , w. 2004 , space sci .
rev . , 115 , 363 | we describe a model that accounts for the complex morphology of spiral density waves raised in saturn s rings by the co - orbital satellites , janus and epimetheus .
our model may be corroborated by future cassini observations of these time - variable wave patterns . |
( anti-)strangeness enhancement was first observed at cern - sps energies by comparing anti - hyperons , multi - strange baryons , and kaons to @xmath10-data .
it was considered a signature for quark gluon plasma ( qgp ) because , using binary strangeness production and exchange reactions , chemical equilibrium could not be reached within a standard hadron gas phase , i.e. , the chemical equilibration time was on the order of @xmath11 whereas the lifetime of a fireball in the hadronic stages is only @xmath12 @xcite .
it was then proposed that there exists a strong hint for qgp at sps because strange quarks can be produced more abundantly by gluon fusion , which would account for strangeness enhancement following hadronization and rescattering of strange quarks .
later , however , multi - mesonic reactions were used to explain secondary production of @xmath13 and anti - hyperons @xcite . at sps
they give a chemical equilibration time @xmath14 using an annihilation cross section of @xmath15 and a baryon density of @xmath16 , which is typical for evolving strongly interacting matter at sps before chemical freeze - out .
therefore , the time scale is short enough to account for chemical equilibration within a cooling hadronic fireball at sps .
a problem arises when the same multi - mesonic reactions were employed in the hadron gas phase at rhic temperatures where experiments again show that the particle abundances reach chemical equilibration close to the phase transition @xcite . at rhic at @xmath17 mev , where @xmath18 and @xmath19 , the equilibrium rate for ( anti-)baryon production is @xmath20 .
moreover , @xmath20 was also obtained in ref .
@xcite using a fluctuation - dissipation theorem . from hadron cascades a significant deviation was found from the chemically saturated strange ( anti-)baryons yields in the @xmath21 most central au - au collisions @xcite .
these discrepancies suggest that hadrons are born " into equilibrium , i.e. , the system is already in a chemically frozen out state at the end of the phase transition @xcite . in order to circumvent such long time
scales it was suggested that near @xmath22 there exists an extra large particle density overpopulated with pions and kaons , which drive the baryons / anti - baryons into equilibrium @xcite .
but it is not clear how this overpopulation should appear , and how the subsequent population of ( anti-)baryons would follow . moreover
, the overpopulated ( anti-)baryons do not later disappear @xcite .
therefore , it was conjectured that hagedorn resonances ( heavy resonances near @xmath23 with an exponential mass spectrum ) could account for the extra ( anti-)baryons @xcite .
hadrons can develop according to @xmath24 where @xmath25 can be substituted with @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath2 , or @xmath3 .
( [ eqn : decay ] ) provides an efficient method for producing of @xmath25 pairs because of the large decay widths of the hagedorn states . in eq .
( [ eqn : decay ] ) , @xmath26 is the number of pions for the decay @xmath27 and @xmath28 is the number of pions that a hagedorn state will decay into when a @xmath25 is present . since hagedorn resonances are highly unstable
, the phase space for multi - particle decays drastically increases when the mass increases .
therefore , the resonances catalyze rapid equilibration of @xmath25 near @xmath23 and die out moderately below @xmath29 @xcite . unlike in pure glue @xmath30 gauge theory where the polyakov loop is the order parameter for the deconfinement transition ( which is weakly first - order ) , the rapid crossover seen on lattice calculations involving dynamical fermions indicates that there is not a well defined order parameter that can distinguish the confined phase from the deconfined phase . because of this it is natural to look for a hadronic mechanism for quick chemical equilibration near the phase transition .
one such possibility could be the inclusion of hagedorn states .
recently , hagedorn states have been shown to contribute to the physical description of a hadron gas close to @xmath29 .
the inclusion of hagedorn states leads to a low @xmath31 in the hadron gas phase @xcite , which nears the string theory bound @xmath32 @xcite .
calculations of the trace anomaly including hagedorn states also fits recent lattice results well and correctly describe the minimum of the speed of sound squared , @xmath33 near the phase transition found on the lattice @xcite .
estimates for the bulk viscosity including hagedorn states in the hadron gas phase indicate that the bulk viscosity , @xmath34 , increases near @xmath29 , which agrees with the general analysis done in @xcite .
furthermore , it has been shown @xcite that hagedorn states provide a better fit within a thermal model to the hadron yield particle ratios .
additionally , hagedorn states provide a mechanism to relate @xmath29 and @xmath35 , which then leads to the suggestion that a lower critical temperature could possibly be preferred , according to the thermal fits @xcite .
previously , in ref . @xcite we presented analytical results , which we will derive in detail here .
moreover , we saw that both the baryons and kaons equilibrated quickly within an expanding fireball .
the initial saturation of pions , hagedorn states , baryons , and kaons played no significant role in the ratios such as @xmath7 and @xmath36 . here
we consider the effects of various initial conditions on the chemical freeze - out temperature and we find that while they play a small role on the total particle number , they still reproduce fast chemical equilibration times .
additionally , we assume lattice values of the critical temperatures ( @xmath4 mev @xcite and @xmath5 mev @xcite ) and find that chemical equilibrium abundances are still reached close to the temperature given by thermal fits ( @xmath37 mev ) .
this paper is structured in the following manner . in section [ sec : model ]
we discuss the details of our statistical model that calculates the chemical equilibrium values of the hagedorn states and other hadrons . furthermore in this section
, fits are shown to thermodynamical properties calculated in lattice qcd , which are used to determine the mass spectrum of the hagedorn states and the rate equations are discussed in detail . in section [ tau ]
we are able to extract the chemical equilibration time of an @xmath25 pair when the pions and hagedorn states are held constant . in section [ ar ]
we derive an analytical result of the rate equations when we consider only the decay @xmath38 .
we then discuss the case of an expanding fireball and the results for the various @xmath25 pair production in section [ expansion ] .
the production of @xmath39 particles will also be considered in section [ omega ] .
we summarized and discussed our results in section [ conclusions ] . in appendix [ app ]
we present some analytical and numerical results for the various equilibration stages in the hadron and hagedorn states gas mixture .
hagedorn resonances have an exponentially growing mass spectrum @xcite .
their large masses open up the phase space for multi - particle decays .
recent analysis involving hagedorn states is given in @xcite .
moreover , thoughts on observing hagedorn states in experiments are given in @xcite and their usage as a thermostat in @xcite .
hagedorn states can also explain the phase transition _ above _ the critical temperature and , depending on the intrinsic parameters , the order of the phase transition @xcite .
for the following discussion , the overall density of hagedorn states in our extended hagedorn gas model are straightforwardly described by , @xmath40^{\frac{5}{4}}}e^{\frac{m}{t_{h}}}dm.\ ] ] where @xmath41 gev and @xmath42 gev .
we note that in this work we consider only mesonic hagedorn states with no net strangeness .
the exponential in eq .
( [ eqn : fitrho ] ) arises from hagedorn s original idea that there is an exponentially growing mass spectrum .
thus , as @xmath43 is approached , hagedorn states become increasingly more relevant and heavier resonances appear " . the factor in front of the exponential
has various forms @xcite .
while the choice in this factor can vary , it was found in @xcite that the present form gives lower values of @xmath43 , which more closely match the predicted lattice critical temperature @xcite .
returning to eq .
( [ eqn : fitrho ] ) , its parameters ( a , m , and @xmath43 ) are dependent on the critical temperature .
we assume that @xmath44 , and then we consider the two different different lattice results for @xmath29 : @xmath5 mev @xcite , which uses an almost physical pion mass , and @xmath4 mev @xcite .
furthermore , we need to take into account the repulsive interactions and , therefore , we use the following volume corrections ( as also seen in @xcite ) : @xmath45 which ensure that the our model is thermodynamically consistent . note that @xmath46 is a free parameter that is based upon the idea of the mit bag constant . in order to find the maximum hagedorn state mass @xmath47 and the degeneracy " a
, we fit our model to the thermodynamic properties of the lattice . in the rbc - bielefeld collaboration the thermodynamical properties
are derived from the quantity @xmath48 , the so called interaction measure , which is what we fit in order to obtain the parameters for the hagedorn states .
thus , we obtain @xmath49 mev , @xmath50 , @xmath51 gev , and @xmath52 .
the fit for the trace anomaly @xmath53 is shown in fig .
[ fig : et4 ] .
we also show the fit for the entropy density in fig .
[ fig : st4 ] .
both fits are within the error of lattice and mimic the behavior of the lattice results . as discussed in @xcite , a hadron resonance gas model with hagedorn states uniquely fits the lattice data whereas a hadron resonance gas without hagedorn states completely misses the behavior .
mev . ] mev . ]
bmw calculates the thermodynamical properties separately and , therefore , we fit only the energy density as shown in fig .
[ fig : et4_173 ] . from that
we obtain @xmath54 mev , @xmath55 , @xmath51 gev , and @xmath56 .
we also show a comparison to the entropy density in fig .
[ fig : st4_173 ] our results with the inclusion of hagedorn states are able to match lattice data near the critical temperature but do not match as well at lower temperatures in fig .
[ fig : et4 ] and fig .
[ fig : st4 ] . mev . ] mev . ]
our idea is that these very massive hagedorn states exist , as pictured in fig .
[ fig : bag ] , and are so large that they decay almost immediately into multiple pions and @xmath25 pairs . while it can be argued that hagedorn states are more likely to decay into a pair of particles : a lighter hagedorn state and another particle , these reactions are so quick that we can consider the end results , which would be multiple particles ( mostly pions ) .
that being said , it would be possible to put hagedorn states into a transport approach such as urqmd @xcite using binary reactions with possible cross - sections as described in @xcite .
we leave this as a challenge for the future . moreover , we need to consider the back reactions of multiple particles combining to form a hagedorn state in order to preserve detailed balance .
rate equations provide us with a perfect tool for this because there is a loss and gain term that describe both the forward and back reactions .
moreover , the state of chemical equilibrium is a fixed point of the rate equations . pair . ]
the rate equations for the hagedorn resonances @xmath57 , pions @xmath58 , and the @xmath25 pair @xmath59 , respectively , are given by @xmath60\nonumber\\ & + & \gamma_{i , x\bar{x}}\left [ n_{i}^{eq } \left(\frac{n_{\pi}}{n_{\pi}^{eq}}\right)^{\langle n_{i , x}\rangle } \left(\frac{n_{x\bar{x}}}{n_{x\bar{x}}^{eq}}\right)^2 -n_{i}\right]\nonumber\\ \dot{n}_{\pi } & = & \sum_{i } \gamma_{i,\pi } \left[n_{i}\langle n_{i}\rangle - n_{i}^{eq}\sum_{n } b_{i , n}n\left(\frac{n_{\pi}}{n_{\pi}^{eq}}\right)^{n } \right]\nonumber\\ & + & \sum_{i } \gamma_{i , x\bar{x } } \langle n_{i , x}\rangle\left[n_{i}- n_{i}^{eq } \left(\frac{n_{\pi}}{n_{\pi}^{eq}}\right)^{\langle n_{i , x}\rangle } \left(\frac{n_{x\bar{x}}}{n_{x\bar{x}}^{eq}}\right)^2\right ] \nonumber\\ \dot{n}_{x\bar{x}}&=&\sum_{i}\gamma_{i , x\bar{x}}\left [ n_{i}- n_{i}^{eq}\left(\frac{n_{\pi}}{n_{\pi}^{eq}}\right)^{\langle n_{i , x}\rangle } \left(\frac{n_{x\bar{x}}}{n_{x\bar{x}}^{eq}}\right)^2\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] the decay widths for the @xmath61 resonance are @xmath62 and @xmath63 , the branching ratio is @xmath64 ( see below ) , and the average number of pions that each resonance will decay into is @xmath65 .
the equilibrium values @xmath66 are both temperature and chemical potential dependent .
however , here we set @xmath67 .
( [ eqn : setpihsbb ] ) can also be rewritten in terms of fugacities ( @xmath68 , @xmath69 , and @xmath70 ) , which are found by dividing each total number by its respective equilibrium value , for example , @xmath71 ( as seen for the baryon anti - baryon pairs in @xcite ) .
additionally , a discrete spectrum of hagedorn states is considered , which is separated into mass bins of 100 mev .
each bin is described by its own rate equation .
the branching ratios , @xmath64 , are the probability that the @xmath61 hagedorn state will decay into @xmath26 pions .
since we are dealing with probabilities , then @xmath72 must always hold . in order to include a distribution for our branching ratios
we assume that they follow a gaussian distribution for the reaction @xmath38 @xmath73 which has its peak centered at @xmath65 and the width of the distribution is @xmath74 . assuming a statistical , micro - canonical branching for the decay of hagedorn states
, we can take a linear fit to the average number of pions in fig . 1 in ref .
@xcite ( multiplying @xmath75 by three to include all pions ) to find @xmath76 such that @xmath77 is the average pion number that each hagedorn state decays into . within the microcanonical model a hagedorn state is defined by its mass and corresponding volume where the volume is taken as @xmath78 .
the mean energy density of a hagedorn state is @xmath79 ( taken as @xmath80 ) .
further discussions regarding this can be found in @xcite .
the width of the distribution is @xmath81 .
both our choice in @xmath82 and @xmath83 roughly match the canonical description in @xcite .
furthermore , we have the condition that each hagedorn resonance must decay into at least 2 pions .
because of the nature of a gaussian distribution there is a non - zero probability that a hagedorn state can decay into less than 2 pions .
therefore , we calculate the percentage of the distribution that falls below 2 pions and redistribute that over @xmath84 so that @xmath72 .
this in turn leads to a new @xmath65 and @xmath85 , which we find by calculating @xmath86 and @xmath87 .
thus , we after normalize for the cutoff @xmath84 , we have @xmath88 and @xmath89
. for the average number of pions when a @xmath25 pair is present , we again refer to the micro - canonical model in @xcite .
we use @xmath76 but then readjust it to the average pion number according to fig . 2 in ref .
@xcite for when a baryon anti - baryon pair is present ( there the distribution is for a resonance of mass @xmath90 gev ) .
thus , @xmath91 where @xmath92 is in gev . in this paper we do not consider a distribution but rather only the average number of pions when a @xmath25 pair is present .
we assume that @xmath93 for when a kaon anti - kaon pair , @xmath2 , or @xmath3 pair is present .
ideally , @xmath94 , @xmath95 , and @xmath96 should be derived separately and will be done in a future paper using a canonical model @xcite .
we used a linear fit for the total decay width similar to that used in ref .
the total decay width @xmath97 ( @xmath98 and @xmath92 in terms of gev ) , which ranges from @xmath99 mev , is a linear fit extrapolated from the data in ref .
however , in eq .
( [ eqn : setpihsbb ] ) the total decay width is separated into two parts : one for the reactions @xmath38 , @xmath62 , and one for the reaction in eq .
( [ eqn : decay ] ) , @xmath63 , whereby @xmath100
. then relative decay width @xmath63 is the average number of @xmath25 in the system @xmath101 multiplied by the total decay width @xmath102 . essentially , a fraction of the decay of the @xmath61 hagedorn state goes into @xmath25 ( set by the number of @xmath25 the @xmath61 hagedorn state on average decays into ) and the remainder goes into pions .
s and @xmath103 s .
the @xmath103 s are calculated within our canonical ensemble and the @xmath104 s are calculated both in our canonical ensemble and a micro - canonical ensemble . ]
we find @xmath105 by linearly fitting the proton in fig . 2 in ref .
@xcite so that @xmath106 where @xmath92 is in gev and @xmath107 .
thus , @xmath108 is between @xmath109 and @xmath110 mev .
clearly , @xmath62 is then @xmath111 .
analogously for the kaons , the decay width is @xmath112 where @xmath113 where @xmath92 is in gev , which is also taken from fig . 2 in ref .
we find that @xmath114 to @xmath115 @xcite .
thus , @xmath116 is between @xmath117 and @xmath118 mev .
for @xmath104 we use a canonical model assuming that the baryon number @xmath119 , the strangeness @xmath120 , and the electrical charge @xmath121 in order to calculate the average lambda number .
the results of this are shown in fig .
[ fig : lamom ] .
we find that our @xmath122 is lower than that from the micro - canonical ensemble in @xcite , which is also shown in fig .
[ fig : lamom ] .
this corresponds to a decay width of @xmath123 mev .
furthermore , the average number of @xmath103 s is also shown in fig . [
fig : lamom ] from our canonical model again assuming that the baryon number @xmath119 , the strangeness @xmath120 , and the electrical charge @xmath121 . in fig .
[ fig : lamom ] we multiple @xmath124 in order to better view the results .
the resulting decay width is @xmath125 mev .
the equilibrium values are found using a statistical model @xcite , which includes 104 particles from the the pdg @xcite ( only light and strange particles ) . as in @xcite
, we also consider the effects of feeding ( the contributions of higher lying resonances such as the @xmath126 or @xmath127 resonances on the number of `` pions '' in our system , i.e. , @xmath128 includes all " the pions from resonances from the pdg @xcite ) .
feeding is also considered for the protons , kaons , and lambdas .
additionally , throughout this paper our initial conditions are the various fugacities at @xmath129 ( at the point of the phase transition into the hadron gas phase ) @xmath130 which are chosen by holding the contribution to the total entropy from the hagedorn states and pions constant i.e. @xmath131 and the corresponding initial condition configurations we choose later can be seen in tab . [ tab : ic ] .
@xmath132 is the entropy density at the initial temperature , i.e. , the critical temperature multiplied by our choice in @xmath133 .
because the hadron resonance is dominated by pions we can assume that @xmath133 represents the initial fraction of pions in equilibrium .
@xmath134 represents the entropy contribution from the hagedorn states at @xmath29 multiplied by the initial fraction of hagedorn states in equilibrium .
we hold @xmath133 constantly and then find the appropriate @xmath135 . the volume expansion ,
@xmath136 is discussed in detail following section entitled expanding fireball.
as a starting point of our analysis , we first estimate the chemical equilibration time of the @xmath25 by looking at the fugacity of the @xmath25 rate equation , i.e. , eq .
( [ eqn : setpihsbb ] ) can be rewritten in terms of @xmath137 as shown for @xmath138 in eq .
( 3 ) in @xcite , when both the pions and hagedorn states are held constant . and
@xmath139 where @xmath54 mev ( top ) and @xmath49 mev ( top ) .
the gray band is the range of chemical equilibrium times for the hagedorn states ( see tab .
[ tab : tau ] ) .
, title="fig : " ] + and @xmath139 where @xmath54 mev ( top ) and @xmath49 mev ( top ) .
the gray band is the range of chemical equilibrium times for the hagedorn states ( see tab .
[ tab : tau ] ) .
, title="fig : " ] the @xmath25 rate equation then becomes @xmath140 which we can integrate @xmath141\ ] ] where @xmath142 @xmath143 , and @xmath144 .
substituting in @xmath145 and @xmath139 when the pions and hagedorn states are in chemical equilibrium , we rederive eq . ( 7 ) in ref .
@xcite @xmath146 which is shown in fig . [
fig : taubb ] . from eq .
( [ eqn : ateqbb ] ) we see that the time scale has an indirect dependence on the decay width .
since the decay width has a linear dependence on the mass , the time scale decreases when more hagedorn states are included .
however , @xmath147 also decreases with increasing mass so above a certain point very many hagedorn states need to be included in order to see an effect in the time scale .
furthermore , the chemical equilibrium values have a dependence on the temperature , which makes the time scale shortest for the highest temperatures . + + + + in fig . [ fig : hspireineq176 ] and fig . [
fig : hspireineq196 ] we hold the hagedorn states and pions and let the @xmath25 pairs reach chemical equilibrium .
that means that in eq .
( [ eqn : setpihsbb ] ) we set @xmath148 and @xmath149 in the @xmath150 equation . fig .
[ fig : hspireineq176 ] shows the results for @xmath0 , @xmath1 , and @xmath2 , respectively , for @xmath54 mev and fig .
[ fig : hspireineq196 ] shows the same for @xmath49 mev . in all cases the temperature
is held constant while the rate equations are solved over time . at @xmath151
all @xmath25 reach chemical equilibrium almost immediately ( on the order of @xmath152 ) . as t
is decreased the chemical equilibrium time obviously increases , which is clear from fig .
[ fig : taubb ] .
even as the temperature is lowered we still see quick chemical equilibrium times . for the @xmath0 and @xmath2 pairs at @xmath153 the chemical equilibrium time is still about @xmath154 .
the @xmath1 pairs do have a slower chemical equilibrium time due to their larger chemical equilibrium abundances , which is directly related to the chemical equilibration time through eq .
( [ eqn : setpihsbb ] ) .
this again represents the main idea , which is the importance of potential hagedorn states in understanding fast chemical equilibration of hadrons close and below @xmath29 .
the hagedorn states increase dramatically in number close to the critical temperature and , thus , by its subsequent decay and re - population they will quickly produce the various hadronic particles .
the equilibration of @xmath25 pairs then shown in fig . [ fig : hspireineq176 ] and fig .
[ fig : hspireineq196 ] where the analytical result in eq .
( [ eqn : lambba1 ] ) matches the numerical result exactly . from fig .
[ fig : hspireineq176 ] and fig .
[ fig : hspireineq196 ] it can be seen that all @xmath25 pairs equilibrate quickly close to the critical temperature @xmath155 .
clearly , though , as the temperature decreases the chemical equilibration time lengthens .
however , at @xmath49 mev chemical equilibrium is still reached quickly , @xmath155 .
while the chemical equilibration time derived in the previous section is a good estimate , it can only be strictly applied when the pions and hagedorn states are assumed to stay in chemical equilibrium at a constant temperature ( fig .
[ fig : hspireineq176 ] and fig .
[ fig : hspireineq196 ] ) .
otherwise , non - linear effects that appear when the pions and hagedorn states are allowed to equilibrate appear . to understand the dynamics in more detail , we consider the simplified case when the hagedorn resonances decay only into pions @xmath38 , which gives @xmath156 \nonumber\\ \dot{n}_{\pi}&=&\sum _ { i } \gamma_{i } \left[n_{i}\langle n_i\rangle- n_{i}^{eq } \sum _ { n=2 } b_{i , n}n\left(\frac{n_{\pi } } { n_{\pi}^{eq}}\right)^{n } \right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] assuming that the pions and the hagedorn states described in eq .
( [ eqn : setpihs ] ) are then allowed to equilibrate near @xmath22 in a static system , we are able to derive analytical solutions , the derivation of which is shown in detail in appendix [ app ] . for the analytical solutions we divide the chemical equilibration into three stages , the chemical equilibration times of which
are shown in tab .
[ tab : tau ] . the first stage ( described by @xmath157 in tab .
[ tab : tau ] ) of the evolution is dominated by the chemical equilibration of the pions when the pions are still far away from their chemical equilibrium values .
after the pions are close to chemical equilibrium , new dynamics take over , which are described by @xmath158 in tab .
[ tab : tau ] and fig .
[ fig : taupi ] .
.chemical equilibration times from analytical estimates where qe is quasi - equilibrium at @xmath159 of each respective @xmath43 .
[ cols="^,^,^,^ " , ] + + and @xmath160 . along the top axis of each graph the corresponding time
is shown in @xmath161.,title="fig : " ] + and @xmath160 .
along the top axis of each graph the corresponding time is shown in @xmath161.,title="fig : " ] more interestingly , we consider the case when the pions , hagedorn states , and @xmath25 all are allowed to chemical equilibrate .
we then vary the initial conditions and observe their effects . the results for @xmath0 pairs
are shown in fig .
[ fig : pp176 ] and fig .
[ fig : pp196 ] . in fig .
[ fig : pp176 ] and fig .
[ fig : pp196 ] we show the evolution of both the @xmath0 pairs and the pions for the reaction @xmath162 .
note that in all the following figures the effective numbers are shown so that the contribution of the hagedorn states is included .
one can see that the chemical equilibration time does depend slightly on our choice of @xmath163 , i.e. , a larger @xmath163 means a quicker chemical equilibration time . for instance , if the hagedorn states were overpopulated coming out of the qgp phase than chemical equilibrium times would be slightly shorter . however , even when the hagedorn resonances start underpopulated the @xmath0 pairs are able to reach chemical equilibrium immediately
. additionally , when the @xmath0 pairs start at about half their chemical equilibrium values , it only helps the @xmath0 pairs to reach equilibrium at a slightly higher temperature ( on the order of a couple of mev ) .
additionally , we see a greater dependence on @xmath163 for @xmath54 mev than for @xmath54 mev . throughout the evolution
we see from the pions that they remain roughly in chemical equilibrium .
thus , our initial analytical approximation appears reasonable . in fig .
[ fig : pppi ] the ratio of protons s to @xmath164 s is shown .
we also compare our results to that of experimental data .
we see that for @xmath54 mev that our results enter the band of experimental data before @xmath17 mev and remain there throughout the entire expansion regardless of the initial conditions
. however , for @xmath54 mev the results are slightly different . in this case
, the ratios match the experimental data early on at around @xmath165 mev .
however , they become briefly overpopulated around @xmath166 mev but then quickly return to the experimental values , except for the case when we have the initial conditions such that the pions are overpopulated .
this could imply that there are a few too many hagedorn states and a fit for the hagedorn states with a lower @xmath167 ( degeneracy of the hagedorn states ) may produce better results .
+ + and @xmath168 . along the top axis of each graph the corresponding time
is shown in @xmath161.,title="fig : " ] + and @xmath168 .
along the top axis of each graph the corresponding time is shown in @xmath161.,title="fig : " ] as with the protons , the total number of kaons are also slightly dependent on our chosen initial conditions , more specifically , our choice in @xmath163 . in fig .
[ fig : kk176 ] and fig .
[ fig : kk196 ] the temperature of the evolving system after the phase transition at which chemical equilibrium among standard hadrons is basically reached and maintained is between @xmath166 for @xmath54 mev and they have also already reached chemical equilibrium by @xmath17 for @xmath49 mev , below which the hagedorn states basically die out . the one exception is when the hagedorn states begin underpopulated i.e. that @xmath169 . in this case , the kaon pairs take longer to reach chemical equilibrium . however , when we look at @xmath7 in fig .
[ fig : kkpi ] , lower @xmath163 actually fits the data better .
moreover , the pions again remain roughly at chemical equilibrium throughout the expansion as seen in fig .
[ fig : kk176 ] and fig .
[ fig : kk196 ] . while the pion graphs look roughly similar in figs .
[ fig : pp176]-[fig : kk196 ] , they are not .
the difference is how the pions are affected in the presence of a @xmath0 pair compared to a decay that includes a kaon anti - kaon pair . in fig .
[ fig : kkpi ] the ratio of kaons to pions is shown for @xmath54 mev and for @xmath49 mev .
for @xmath54 mev our results are roughly at the upper edge of the experimental values .
however , for @xmath49 mev our results are slightly higher than the experimental values .
although , the results at @xmath170 mev are almost exactly those of the uppermost experimental data point .
+ + s with various initial conditions .
note that for star @xmath171 and @xmath172 . along the top axis of each graph the corresponding time
is shown in @xmath161.,title="fig : " ] + s with various initial conditions .
note that for star @xmath171 and @xmath172 . along the top axis of each graph the corresponding time
is shown in @xmath161.,title="fig : " ] we can also observe the affects of the expansion on the @xmath2 pairs as seen in fig . [
fig : ll176 ] and fig .
[ fig : ll196 ] .
we see that both reach the experimental values almost immediately ( @xmath173 for @xmath54 mev and around @xmath165 for @xmath49 mev ) .
the one exception is again for an underpopulation of hagedorn states , which reaches chemical equilibrium at @xmath174 for @xmath54 mev and already by @xmath17 for @xmath49 mev ) .
the ratio of @xmath8 s is shown in fig .
[ fig : llpi ] . in both cases the @xmath8 s match the experimental values extremely well .
for @xmath54 mev our results reach the equilibrium values at @xmath175 mev and for @xmath49 mev the experimental values are reached already by @xmath175 mev . .
the points show the ratios at @xmath170 mev for the various initial conditions ( circles are for @xmath54 mev and diamonds are for @xmath49 mev ) .
the experimental results for star and phenix are shown by the gray error bars . ]
a summary graph of all our results is shown in fig . [
fig : summary ] .
the gray error bars cover the range of error for the experimental data points from both star and phenix .
the points show the range in values for the various initial conditions at @xmath170 mev .
we see in our graph that our freezeout results match the experimental data well .
what the graphs in figs .
[ fig : pp176]-[fig : llpi ] show us is that a dynamical scenario is able to explain chemical equilibration values that appear in thermal fits by @xmath176 mev . in general , @xmath54 mev and @xmath49 give chemical freeze - out values in the range between @xmath166 mev .
these results agree well with the chemical freeze - out temperature found in @xcite .
moreover , the initial conditions have little effect on the ratios and give a range in the chemical equilibrium temperature of about @xmath177 mev , which implies that information from the qgp regarding multiplicities is washed out due to the rapid dynamics of hagedorn states .
lower @xmath135 does slow the chemical equilibrium time slightly .
however , as seen in fig .
[ fig : summary ] they still fit well within the experimental values .
furthermore , in @xcite we showed the the initial condition play pretty much no roll whatsoever in the ratios of @xmath178 and @xmath179 .
thus , strengthening our argument that the dynamics are washed out following the qgp .
while the variance in the chemical equilibration time arising from the initial conditions may seem contradictory to the @xmath178 and @xmath179 ratios in @xcite , it can be explained with the pion populations . in figs .
[ fig : pp176]-[fig : kk196 ] quicker chemical equilibration times and , thus , larger total baryon / kaon numbers translated into a larger number of pions in the system .
thus , the @xmath178 and @xmath179 ratios do not depend on the initial conditions .
+ + s with various initial conditions .
note that for star @xmath180 and @xmath181 . along the top axis of each graph the corresponding time
is shown in @xmath161.,title="fig : " ] + s with various initial conditions .
note that for star @xmath180 and @xmath181 . along the top axis of each graph the corresponding time
is shown in @xmath161.,title="fig : " ] we can also use our model to investigate the possibility of @xmath103 s . in @xcite , they discussed the possibility of @xmath103 s being produced from the following decay channels : @xmath182 the first decay channel of a mesonic non - strange hagedorn state we can implement straightforwardly with our model by employing the canonical branching ratio via fig . [ fig : lamom ] .
the results are shown in fig .
[ fig : oo176 ] for @xmath54 mev , in fig .
[ fig : oo196 ] for @xmath49 mev , and the @xmath183 ratio is shown in fig .
[ fig : oopi ] .
we are able to find the average number of @xmath103 s from @xcite as seen in fig .
[ fig : lamom ] .
we see that , using only the first reaction , we are still impressively able to adequately populate the @xmath3 pairs so that they roughly match the experimental data . on the other hand , from fig .
[ fig : taubb ] we see that for the @xmath39 particle the equilibration time are short only very close to @xmath29 .
the scenario is thus more delicate . if one would take eg one half , or one fourth , respectively , of the decay width of that of eq .
[ hsdecaywidth ] , the total production of @xmath39 is not sufficient up to 25 % , or up to 50% , respectively , to meet the experimental yield ( the other ratios are not significantly affected by such a change of the decay width ) . in a future work , it would be interesting to observe the other decay channels as given in eq .
[ omdecay ] and advertised in @xcite .
the second reaction includes a mesonic , three times strange hagedorn state whereas the third decay channel includes a baryonic , strange hagedorn state .
both states are much more likely to directly decay into a @xmath39 .
these are , admittedly , exotic states , but should also occur in the spirit of hagedorn states . in order to observe these decay channels a method ,
e.g. a microscopic quark model , must be found to find the appropriate hagedorn spectrum for strange mesonic / baryonic hagedorn states .
in this paper we found that hadronic matter , at rhic or sps energies , can reach chemical equilibrium within a dynamical scenario using hagedorn states close to the critical temperature .
these states were able to produce quick chemical equilibration times in ( anti-)proton , ( anti-)kaons , and ( anti-)lambdas close to the critical temperature due to their strong increase in their abundancy .
the existence of such a mixture of standard hadrons and hagedorn states just below the phase transition can explain dynamically the chemical equilibration of the hadronic species at around temperatures of 160 mev to 170 mev as seen within the thermal models . from our analytical results we found that the chemical equilibration time depends on the temperature , decay widths , and branching ratios , but not the initial conditions .
while this changes slightly when an expanding fireball is considered , the initial condition still only play a small role and only minimally affect the ` freeze - out ' temperature at which chemical equilibrium is reached .
this demonstrates that regardless of the population of hadrons coming out of the qgp phase , the initial conditions are washed out and everything can reach abundances which correspond to those of chemical equilibrium by the chemical freezeout temperatures found in @xcite .
moreover , from our previous paper @xcite we showed that particle ratios ( @xmath178 and @xmath179 ) are not affected by the initial conditions and here we showed that @xmath6 , @xmath7 , @xmath8 and also @xmath9 match the experimental values regardless of the initial conditions . specially , fig .
[ fig : summary ] demonstrates this nicely and summarizes our findings : regardless of the initial conditions , our dynamical scenario can match experimental data .
we do find , however , that @xmath49 fits within the experimental data box for @xmath7 whereas @xmath54 is slightly above .
this appears to reconfirm the findings in @xcite .
our results imply that both lattice temperature can ensure that the hadrons reach their chemical equilibrium values by @xmath166 mev .
although the ratios for @xmath54 do fit the data somewhat better , both math the experimental values reasonably well .
this implies that independent of the critical temperature the hadrons are able to reach chemical freeze - out .
we see sufficiently short time scales for the chemical equilibrium of hadrons .
the protons , kaons , and lambdas reach chemical equilibrium on the order of @xmath184 .
moreover , hagedorn states states provide a very efficient way for incorporating multi - hadronic interactions ( with parton rearrangements ) . in an upcoming paper
we will use a canonical model to derive all the branching ratios included in our calculations .
we can then look at reactions that include a mixture of strange and non - strange baryons ( for instance , @xmath185 ) and multi - strange baryons .
however , considering that our initial results produce quick chemical equilibration times for the baryons , kaons , and lambdas , it is reasonable to believe that this will occur for mixed reactions and multi - strange baryons as well .
in addition , the machinery of standard hadronic reactions , i.e. binary scattering processes and resonance production processes , help also to equilibrate the various hadronic degrees of freedom .
still , our work indicates that the population and repopulation of potential hagedorn states close to phase boundary can be the key source for a dynamical understanding of generating and chemically equilibrating the standard and measured hadrons .
jnh would like to thank j. noronha , b. cole , and m. gyulassy for productive discussions .
this work was supported by the helmholtz international center for fair within the framework of the loewe program ( landes - offensive zur entwicklung wissenschaftlich - konomischer exzellenz ) launched by the state of hesse .
thanks the members of the institut fr theoretische physik of johann wolfgang goethe
universitt for their hospitality during the final stages of this work .
the work of i.a.s . was supported in part by the start - up funds from the arizona state university .
if our initial conditions are such that both the pions and hagedorn states begin far out of chemical equilibrium , we can find an analytical solution by subdividing the analysis into three distinct stages .
initially , during stage 1 the pions are underpopulated such that we can say that they approximately begin at @xmath186 ( we can also start the pions above zero and the approximation works well ) .
because the pions reach chemical equilibrium much quicker than the hagedorn states due to all the hagedorn states decaying quickly into pions , then we can make the approximation that the hagedorn states are held at their initial value of @xmath163 .
one can see this from the difference in the time scales from tab .
[ tab : tau ] where @xmath187 and @xmath188 . since @xmath189 we let @xmath190 , then substituting this into eq .
( [ eqn : setpihs ] ) we obtain which is the fugacity of the pions in stage 1 and gives @xmath192 . again using the approximation @xmath189 and substituting eq .
( [ eqn : npia2 ] ) into the hagedorn state rate equation in eq .
( [ eqn : setpihs ] ) , with the solution @xmath193,\nonumber\\ \lambda_{i}&= & \left[1-\langle n_i\rangle\left(\frac{-t}{\tau_{i}}\right)^{-\langle n_i\rangle } e^{- \left(\frac{t}{\tau_{i}}\right ) } \int_{0}^{-\frac{t}{\tau_{i}}}x^{\langle n_i\rangle-1}e^{-x}dx \right]\nonumber\\ & \cdot & \left(\frac{t}{\tau_{\pi}^{0}}\right)^{\langle n_i\rangle}+\beta_{i}e^{-\left(\frac{t}{\tau_{i}}\right ) } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] substituting @xmath194 into the integral in eq .
( [ eqn : s1nipre ] ) , expanding the exponential inside the integral so @xmath195 , and integrating over @xmath196 , provides us with the fugacity of the hagedorn states in stage 1 @xmath197\nonumber\\ & + & \beta_{i}e^{- \left(\frac{t}{\tau_{i}}\right)}\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore , eq .
( [ eqn : npia2 ] ) and eq .
( [ eqn : hsstage1 ] ) describe the behaviour of the pions and hagedorn states during the initial stage of the evolution towards chemical equilibrium .
they are then compared to the numerical results in fig .
[ fig : pifree ] . as the pions near equilibrium our approximation of @xmath198 no longer holds and we switch to stage 2 where we assume @xmath199 at time @xmath200 . here
@xmath200 is a time when the pions are almost in chemical equilibrium , which is normally taken when the pions reach about @xmath201 of their chemical equilibrium value .
returning to the pion equation in eq .
( [ eqn : setpihs ] ) , we can substitute in @xmath202 and use the approximation @xmath203 @xmath204 additionally , we substituted in @xmath135 for @xmath205 as an approximation since the hagedorn states do not change significantly in stage 1 ( the majority of the evolution is done by the pions ) . recall that @xmath206 and it is a constant . in its present form , eq .
( [ eqn : hsineqsub ] ) can be integrated .
we also define @xmath207 where @xmath208 is close to 1 ( @xmath208 is the measurement of how close the pions are to their equilibrium value when we switch from stage 1 to stage 2 ) .
then , after integration @xmath209 where @xmath210 and @xmath211 . analogously to stage 1 , we substitute the pion equation , i.e. , eq .
( [ eqn : npi ] ) into the hagedorn resonance equation in eq .
( [ eqn : setpihs ] ) and integrate @xmath212\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath213 and @xmath214 .
thus , our equations for the evolution of the pions and hagedorn states are eq .
( [ eqn : npi ] ) and eq .
( [ eqn : nallep1 ] ) , respectively . as with stage 1 ,
the evolution equation for the hagedorn states is dictated by that of the pions . at @xmath215 mev for @xmath54 mev when @xmath216 and @xmath217 ( top ) and the numerical results for the same initial conditions including @xmath1 pairs with @xmath218.,title="fig : " ] + at @xmath215 mev for @xmath54 mev when @xmath216 and @xmath217 ( top ) and the numerical results for the same initial conditions including @xmath1 pairs with @xmath218.,title="fig : " ] stage 3 i.e. quasi - equilibrium begins once the pions and at least one species of hagedorn resonances ( @xmath219 is the shortest chemical equilibration time ) has surpassed its equilibration time ( @xmath220 and @xmath221 , respectively ) . to understand quasi - equilibrium we must use the effective pion number @xmath222 because we need a variable that can observe the effects of both the pions and resonances .
the effective pion number essentially includes the number of effective pions that each hagedorn state could decay into .
thus , we start by taking the derivative of eq .
( [ eqn : effpions ] ) in terms of its fugacity @xmath223\nonumber\\ & = & \frac{\sum_{i}\gamma_{i}n_{i}^{eq}}{\tilde{n}_{\pi}^{eq}}\left[\langle n_i\rangle\sum_{n}b_{i , n}\lambda_{\pi}^n-\sum_{n}b_{i , n}n\lambda_{\pi}^n\right]\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] once again we make the substitution @xmath202 so that where @xmath225 in the gaussian distribution of our branching ratios . to relate @xmath226 and @xmath227 we return to eq .
( [ eqn : effpions ] ) and separate @xmath68 into a sum over the resonances in quasi - equilibrium and one over the
freely " equilibrating resonances @xmath228.\ ] ] since the pions reach quasi - equilibrium first , i.e. , @xmath229 near @xmath22 , we set the @xmath164 rate equation in eq .
( [ eqn : setpihs ] ) equal to zero , which gives @xmath230 , so @xmath231 eq . ( [ eqn : eptil ] ) then has the form @xmath232 where @xmath233 we can then solve for @xmath226 in eq .
( [ eqn : e2etil ] ) and substitute @xmath226 into eq .
( [ eqn : needep ] ) , which in turn can be integrated . this leads us to the solution @xmath234 where @xmath235 stands for the latest resonance to reach chemical equilibrium at that point in time and @xmath236 is the quasi - equilibrium time . clearly , once all the hagedorn states have reached chemical equilibrium than @xmath235 symbolizes the resonance of @xmath237 gev , since it is the slowest hagedorn state to equilibrate .
the sums over free " is the sum over the hagedorn states that have not yet surpassed their respective chemical equilibrium time , @xmath238 . once @xmath239 is reached those sums equal zero .
therefore , after @xmath239 all that remains is @xmath240 where @xmath241 is shown in tab .
[ tab : tau ] .
finally , we rewrite eq .
( [ eqn : remaine ] ) in terms of the pion evolution equation @xmath242 where @xmath243 . because the resonance equation depends on the population of the pions we substitute eq .
( [ eqn : piinqe ] ) into the hagedorn resonance rate equation in eq .
( [ eqn : setpihs ] ) , assuming the pions are near equilibrium ( i.e. , we use the approximation @xmath244 and @xmath203 ) @xmath245 where @xmath246 .
thus , for stage 3 the population equations for the pions and the hagedorn states are eq .
( [ eqn : piinqe ] ) and eq .
( [ eqn : nimostinqe ] ) so long as @xmath247 . fig .
[ fig : pifree ] reveals a remarkable close fit with our numerical results for @xmath215 mev i.e. @xmath248 .
thus , the quasi - chemical equilibrium time , @xmath249 , depends only on @xmath102 , @xmath82 , @xmath250 , and @xmath66 , which is temperature dependent , but not on our initial conditions .
as mentioned in the text , though , @xmath249 includes many non - linear affects that only occur close to the chemical equilibrium .
thus , the more appropriate time scale is @xmath157 in order to describe the dynamics .
we also see from fig .
[ fig : pifree ] that when @xmath1 pairs are included that the pions and hagedorn resonances equilibrate in roughly the same amount of time , which implies that our analytical solution can still be approximately applied when @xmath1 pairs are present . 99 p. koch , b. muller and j. rafelski , phys .
* 142 * , 167 ( 1986 ) .
r. rapp and e. v. shuryak , phys .
lett . * 86 * ( 2001 ) 2980 .
c. greiner , aip conf .
proc . * 644 * , 337 ( 2003 ) ; heavy ion phys .
* 14 * , 149 ( 2001 ) ; c. greiner and s. leupold , j. phys . g * 27 * , l95 ( 2001 ) .
braun - munzinger _
b * 344 * ( 1995 ) 43 ; phys .
b * 365 * ( 1996 ) 1 ; eur .
j. c * 2 * , 351 ( 1998 ) p. braun - munzinger , i. heppe and j. stachel , phys .
b * 465 * ( 1999 ) 15 .
j. i. kapusta and i. shovkovy , phys .
c * 68 * ( 2003 ) 014901 ; j. i. kapusta , j. phys .
g * 30 * ( 2004 ) s351 .
p. huovinen and j. i. kapusta , phys .
c * 69 * ( 2004 ) 014902 .
r. stock , phys .
b * 456 * ( 1999 ) 277 ; arxiv : nucl - th/0703050 .
u. heinz and g. kestin , arxiv : nucl - th/0612105 .
braun - munzinger , j. stachel and c. wetterich , phys .
b * 596 * ( 2004 ) 61 .
c. greiner _ et al .
_ j. phys .
g * 31 * , s725 ( 2005 ) .
j. noronha - hostler , c. greiner and i. a. shovkovy , phys .
lett . * 100 * , 252301 ( 2008 ) .
j. noronha - hostler , j. noronha , h. ahmad , i. shovkovy and c. greiner , arxiv:0907.4963 [ nucl - th ] , to appear in nucl .
a ; j. noronha - hostler , c. greiner and i. shovkovy , eur .
j. st * 155 * , 61 ( 2008 ) ; arxiv : nucl - th/0703079 .
j. noronha - hostler , j. noronha and c. greiner , arxiv:0811.1571 [ nucl - th ] , to appear in phys . rev .
p. kovtun , d. t. son and a. o. starinets , phys .
lett . * 94 * , 111601 ( 2005 ) .
d. kharzeev and k. tuchin , arxiv:0705.4280 [ hep - ph ]
. j. noronha - hostler , h. ahmad , j. noronha and c. greiner , arxiv:0906.3960 [ nucl - th ] .
y. aoki , z. fodor , s. d. katz and k. k. szabo , jhep * 0601 * , 089 ( 2006 ) ; phys .
b * 643 * , 46 ( 2006 ) m. cheng _ et al .
_ , phys .
d * 77 * , 014511 ( 2008 ) .
a. bazavov _ et al .
_ , arxiv:0903.4379 [ hep - lat ] .
r. hagedorn , nuovo cim
. suppl .
* 6 * 311 ( 1968 ) ; nuovo cim . suppl .
* 3 * , 147 ( 1965 ) .
w. broniowski , w. florkowski and l. y. glozman , phys .
d * 70 * , 117503 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0407290 ] .
k. a. bugaev , v. k. petrov and g. m. zinovjev , arxiv:0801.4869 [ hep - ph ] .
l. g. moretto , l. phair , k. a. bugaev and j. b. elliott , pos c * pod2006 * ( 2006 ) 037 ; l. g. moretto , k. a. bugaev , j. b. elliott and l. phair , arxiv : nucl - th/0601010 ; arxiv : hep - ph/0511180 . i. zakout , c. greiner and j. schaffner - bielich , nucl .
a * 781 * , 150 ( 2007 ) ; i. zakout and c. greiner , phys . rev .
c * 78 * , 034916 ( 2008 ) ; l. ferroni and v. koch , arxiv:0812.1044 [ nucl - th ] .
j. i. kapusta and k. a. olive , nucl .
a * 408 * , 478 ( 1983 ) .
d. h. rischke , m. i. gorenstein , h. stoecker and w. greiner , z. phys .
c * 51 * , 485 ( 1991 ) .
s. a. bass _ et al .
. part . nucl .
phys . *
41 * , 255 ( 1998 ) [ prog . part .
phys . * 41 * , 225 ( 1998 ) ] [ arxiv : nucl - th/9803035 ] .
m. bleicher _ et al .
_ , j. phys .
g * 25 * , 1859 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9909407 ] .
s. pal and p. danielewicz , phys .
b * 627 * , 55 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : nucl - th/0505049 ] .
f. m. liu , k. werner and j. aichelin , phys .
c * 68 * ( 2003 ) 024905 ; f. m. liu , et .
al . , j. phys .
g * 30 * ( 2004 ) s589 ; phys .
c * 69 * ( 2004 ) 054002 .
f. becattini and l. ferroni , eur .
j. c * 38 * , 225 ( 2004 ) m. beitel , j. noronha - hostler , and c. greiner , diplomthesis , to appear . i. senda , phys .
b * 263 * , 270 ( 1991 ) ; f. lizzi and i. senda , nucl .
b * 359 * , 441 ( 1991 ) ; f. lizzi and i. senda , phys . lett .
b * 244 * , 27 ( 1990 ) .
s. eidelman _ et al .
b * 592 * ( 2004 ) 1 . c. spieles , h. stoecker and c. greiner , eur .
j. c * 2 * , 351 ( 1998 ) ; c. greiner , d. h. rischke , h. stoecker and p. koch , phys . rev .
d * 38 * , 2797 ( 1988 ) ; c. greiner and h. stoecker , phys . rev .
d * 44 * , 3517 ( 1991 ) .
i. g. bearden _ et al . _
[ brahms collaboration ] , phys .
* 94 * ( 2005 ) 162301 .
c. greiner , c. gong and b. muller , phys .
b * 316 * , 226 ( 1993 ) .
f. becattini and l. ferroni , eur .
j. c * 38 * , 225 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0407117 ] . | quick chemical equilibration times of hadrons ( specifically , @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath2 , and @xmath3 pairs ) within a hadron gas are explained dynamically using hagedorn states , which drive particles into equilibrium close to the critical temperature . within this scheme ,
we use master equations and derive various analytical estimates for the chemical equilibration times .
we compare our model to recent lattice results and find that for both @xmath4 mev and @xmath5 mev , the hadrons can reach chemical equilibrium almost immediately , well before the chemical freeze - out temperatures found in thermal fits for a hadron gas without hagedorn states .
furthermore the ratios @xmath6 , @xmath7 , @xmath8 , and @xmath9 match experimental values well in our dynamical scenario . |
in the case of small antiferromagnetic correlation lengths @xmath48 , corresponding to the overdoped regime , the rpa should be a reasonable approximation for the spin susceptibility . the dashed line in fig .
1 shows the imaginary part of @xmath49 for @xmath50 using the parameters tb2 in table i of ref.@xcite and a chemical potential corresponding to the doping @xmath51 .
the energy unit is 1 ev in the following and lengths are measured in units of the lattice constant a of the square lattice .
the superconducting order parameter is @xmath52 with @xmath53 , @xmath3 equal to 0.135 and @xmath54 . the dashed line in fig .
1 illustrates that most of the spectral weight resides in the bound state at the energy 0.038 and that only a small part of it has been left in the continuum at higher energies . away from @xmath55 the dashed curve in fig .
1 does not change dramatically as long as the bound state lies still in the gapped region .
entering the particle - hole continuum by going further away from @xmath55 destroys the bound state and most of the spectral weight shifts to high energies of the order of @xmath2 .
@xmath56 without ( dashed line ) and with ( solid line ) memory function @xmath30 for a doping @xmath57 and @xmath58 .
the dashed curve corresponds to the rpa .
inset : real part @xmath59 and imaginary part @xmath43 of @xmath60 . ,
width=302 ] the parameters used in fig . 1 yield @xmath61 .
for such a small @xmath48 practically all momenta in the sum over momenta in eq.([m ] ) contribute substantially which means that @xmath43 is mainly determined by contributions away from the small region around @xmath55 so that the bound state and its low - energy scale is rather irrelevant for @xmath30 .
this is confirmed by an explicit calculation of @xmath30 using rpa results for the various quantities in eq.([m ] ) .
the result is shown in the inset of fig . 1 for t=0 .
@xmath43 ( solid line ) is structureless except at small energies where it vanishes rapidly due to the smallness of @xmath46 in this region and the cutoff @xmath62 for the integration over @xmath63 in eq.([d ] ) due to the bosonic factors .
taking @xmath30 into account in eq.([phi1 ] ) yields the solid line in fig . 1 which differs only marginally from the dashed line
this shows that at short correlation lengths the rpa result for @xmath64 is essentially correct and that the correction @xmath30 to @xmath36 is rather small .
the underlying physical picture is that the momentary local axis of preferred spin directions fluctuates very rapidly due to the random forces induced by @xmath23 .
the spectrum of these forces is given by @xmath65 and characterized by the large energy scale @xmath2 in agreement with the inset of fig .
for large @xmath48 the spectral function @xmath66 is strongly peaked at @xmath67 .
this means that the integration over @xmath68 in eq.([m ] ) is restricted to momenta near @xmath69 or near @xmath1 .
since we are interested in external momenta @xmath70 the momentum of one of the two spectral functions in eq.([d ] ) is small .
due to spin conservation this spectral function describes spin diffusion and is mainly restricted to small values of @xmath63 . as a result one may neglect the small frequency transfer in the second spectral function in eq.([d ] ) . taking also the real part of @xmath30 into account we obtain from eqs.([m ] ) and ( [ d ] ) , @xmath71 with @xmath72 and the equal - time correlation function @xmath73 in deriving eq.([m ] ) we used the fact that the two memory functions in eq.([phi1 ] ) depend for our parameters only slowly on momentum around the wave vector @xmath74 so that the combination @xmath75 on the right - hand side of eq.([m ] ) may be evaluated at @xmath1 .
the sum over @xmath76 in eq.([omega ] ) runs over half of the brillouin zone centered around @xmath1 .
the evaluation of the above expressions using the rpa encounters a problem : @xmath48 , calculated in the rpa , is in the optimal and moderately underdoped region around one or smaller and increases substantially only near the transition to the antiferromagnetic state in disagreement with the experiment .
for instance , we have for @xmath77 @xmath78 , ref.@xcite @xmath79 using quite different parameter values , whereas the experimental values for @xmath48 are larger by about a factor 5 or more@xcite . since this large discrepancy would affect severely the momentum sum in eq.([omega ] )
we prefer to use a realistic @xmath27 as input in calculating @xmath30 and write @xmath80 for @xmath81 considering @xmath48 as a parameter to be determined from experiment .
it is instructive to study the frequency dependence of the denominator of eq.([phi1 ] ) . in order to describe a slightly underdoped case we choose the same parameters as in fig .
1 , a chemical potential corresponding to @xmath85 , @xmath86 , and the cutoff @xmath87 for the sum over @xmath88 in eq.([omega ] ) . the solid and dotted line in fig . 2
show @xmath89 for h=0.5 and 0.38 , respectively , writing @xmath90 .
this quantity is practically independent of momentum , increases monotonically with @xmath62 and is zero at the rpa resonance energy @xmath91 . the dashed and dash - dotted lines in fig .
2 show @xmath92 for the same momenta .
these curves resemble the real part of an oscillator located at @xmath93 with an oscillator strength being very small at @xmath94 and strongly increasing with @xmath95 .
the poles of eq.([phi1 ] ) are given by the common points of the two curves denoted by squares and circles . since the common point at @xmath96 ( not shown in fig .
2 ) has vanishing pole strength there are two branches of collective spin excitations . for vanishing damping @xmath97 their dispersion is shown in fig . 3 by solid lines .
they approximately touch each other at @xmath98 and disperse up- and downwards with increasing @xmath95 . for not too large @xmath95
both branches lie below the continuum in agreement with experiment@xcite . performing the calculation in the normal state at @xmath99 the solid and dotted lines in fig .
2 lie everywhere above zero but the solid and dashed and also the dotted and dash - dotted lines have still one common point at larger frequencies . in this case only the upper but not the lower branch exists in agreement with experiment@xcite .
at very low dopings @xmath100 due to the constraint and the pole condition @xmath101 yields in the presence of long - range order the correct spin wave dispersion@xcite .
several prerequisites are necessary to obtain the above hourglass dispersion for spin excitations .
there must exist two different kinds of spin excitations to account for the two branches .
the first one are rpa spin fluctuations where all induced spin moments have the same direction .
they may be characterized by the fact that the internal fields induced by the heisenberg interaction conserves frequency , momentum and spin direction which is a direct consequence of the one - mode behavior of @xmath22 in eq.([l1 ] ) .
the second one are local rotations of spins under the influence of @xmath23 in eq.([l2 ] ) . in this case
a spin in z direction acquires in its time evolution also a component in x direction due to the presence of a spin fluctuation in y direction .
the pure form of the two kind of spin excitations are obtained for @xmath102 and @xmath103 , respectively , and are realized approximately at large and small dopings . in the hourglass regime @xmath30 and @xmath36
are of similar magnitude .
another prerequisite for hourglass behavior is that @xmath48 is substantially larger than 1 .
only then is the momentum integration in eq.([m ] ) restricted to the resonance and the spin diffusion modes yielding oscillator - like behavior of @xmath30 near @xmath93 .
the up- and downwards dispersion and their approximate degeneracy at @xmath1 is mainly determined by @xmath104 , which according to eq.([omega ] ) is roughly proportional to @xmath105 .
the first factor tends to zero at low temperatures for @xmath106 and saturates at large @xmath107 . as a result @xmath104 is very small at @xmath98 causing the approximate touching of the two branches at @xmath108 and @xmath109 . with increasing @xmath107 @xmath104 increases strongly leading to a downward dispersion of the lower branch even if @xmath93 was practically dispersionless as in our case . according to fig .
3 the upper branch increases at large @xmath95 roughly as @xmath110 , i.e. , with an effective spin wave velocity which is reduced by about a factor 2 - 3 compared to spin wave theory similar as in experiment@xcite . using the same parameters as in figs . 2 and 3 fig . 4 shows @xmath64 as a function of @xmath4 with the frequency as a parameter . as suggested by fig .
3 @xmath64 exhibits a hourglass dispersion with intensities which are largest near @xmath93 and decay rather fast and slow towards lower and higher frequencies , respectively . fig .
5 shows @xmath64 as a function of @xmath62 for a fixed @xmath4 as a parameter . in agreement with fig .
4 the strong peak at @xmath111 splits into two peaks with decreasing @xmath4 which disperse up- and downwards in frequency . the curve for @xmath111 calculated for the small damping @xmath112 has the shape of a lorentzian . at smaller dampings
this peak splits into a double peak due to the small gap between upper and lower branch shown in fig .
3 . for @xmath102 only the lower , weaker peak is obtained . in conclusion , we have shown that the memory function of the spin susceptibility contains in general two distinct contributions due to rpa - like and due to rotational spin fluctuations .
the first one dominates at large , the second one at small dopings . at intermediate dopings both
are of similar magnitude which leads to one upwards and one downwards dispersing branch of excitations . at low temperatures
the two branches are approximately degenerate at @xmath1 which explains , at least qualitatively , the observed hourglass dispersion at intermediate dopings . | a theory for the dispersion of collective magnetic excitations in superconducting cuprates is presented with the aim to cover both high and low doping regimes . besides of spin fluctuations describable in the random phase approximation ( rpa ) we allow for local spin rotations within a mode - coupling theory . at low temperatures and moderately large correlation lengths
we obtain two branches of excitations which disperse up- and downwards exhibiting the hourglass behavior observed experimentally at intermediate dopings . at large and small dopings our theory essentially reduces to the rpa and spin wave theory , respectively .
the low - temperature magnetic response of many high - t@xmath0 superconductors is characterized by a resonant mode inside the superconducting gap around the antiferromagnetic wave vector @xmath1 .
this collective mode manifests itself as a single peak at @xmath1 which splits into two peaks dispersing up- and downwards in frequency away from @xmath1 .
this unusual dispersion resembles the shape of a hourglass@xcite .
theories to explain this phenomena use either a more local@xcite or an itinerant@xcite description of the magnetism .
the second approach considers particle - hole excitations with spin flips which interact within the random phase approximation ( rpa ) forming a dispersing bound state in the superconducting gap .
this approach yields only one branch of excitations below the stoner continuum whereas it has been established recently that the lower branch , the center of the hourglass as well as part of the upper branch lie below this continuum in the gapped region@xcite .
a more theoretical argument for the incompleteness of a rpa description comes from the fact that different spin directions do not mix as a function of time in this approximation which excludes local rotations of spins known from spin wave theory .
below we will present a theory which contains both spin wave theory and rpa as special cases . at intermediate dopings
we will show that both rpa and spin wave like spin fluctuations are important and produce the two branches of the hourglass dispersion .
we consider the @xmath2-@xmath3 model@xcite with the hamiltonian @xmath4 , @xmath5 @xmath6 are creation and annihilation operators , respectively , for electrons with momentum @xmath7 and spin projection @xmath8 excluding any double occupancies of sites .
@xmath9 are spin operators in momentum space , @xmath10 and @xmath11 are the bare electron dispersion and the fourier transform of the heisenberg coupling , respectively .
a useful approximation for @xmath4 , used in the following , is obtained by taking the large @xmath12 limit of the @xmath2-@xmath3 model , where @xmath10 describes a renormalized dispersion of quasi - particles and the fermionic operators can be treated as usual creation and annihilation operators . in the following we are interested in the time evolution of the spin operator @xmath13 , @xmath14 where @xmath8 denotes the vector of the three pauli matrices .
it obeys the equation of motion @xmath15 with @xmath16 @xmath17 @xmath18 is equal to @xmath19 , where @xmath20 denotes the thermodynamic expectation value , and @xmath21 stands for the vector product .
since we are only interested in the spin response we have dropped terms on the right - hand side of eq.([l2 ] ) which involve fluctuations in the density .
we also dropped an overall prefactor denoting the number of primitive cells .
the unperturbed liouville operator @xmath22 describes the time evolution of the system in the rpa . from its explicit expression in eq.([l1 ] ) follows that it does not mix different cartesian components of the spin operators .
in contrast to that the time evolution described by @xmath23 involves product states of spin operators , mixes different spin components and thus can describe rotations of spins due to fluctuating fields .
the spin susceptibility @xmath24 can conveniently be calculated from the associated kubo relaxation function @xmath25 where @xmath26 is a complex frequency and @xmath27 is equal to @xmath28 . due to the rotational invariance in spin space
we may assume that @xmath29 , @xmath30 etc .
always refer to the z - direction . using the mori formalism @xmath31
can be written as@xcite @xmath32 the first memory kernel @xmath33 describes the time evolution of spin operators by @xmath22 .
according to eq.([l1 ] ) the direction of the spin operators is conserved and they remain always linear in the operators @xmath34 . eliminating the @xmath34 operators in the equation of motion in favor of the orginal @xmath35 operators yields an explicit expression for @xmath36 which may be expressed in terms of the rpa spin susceptibility @xmath37 , @xmath38 with @xmath39 @xmath40 is the free susceptibility .
the second memory contribution @xmath41 is due to the time evolution of single spin operators @xmath35 into product states of spin operators described by @xmath23 . using the mode - coupling assumption and performing the analytic continuation @xmath42
, we obtain for the imaginary part of @xmath30 , denotd by @xmath43 , @xmath44 @xmath45 @xmath46 is the spectral function of the spin propagator and @xmath47 the bose function . |
consider supercritical bond - percolation on @xmath0 , @xmath1 , and the simple random walk on the ( unique ) infinite cluster . in @xcite
sidoravicius and sznitman asked the following question : is it true that for a.e .
configuration in which the origin belongs to the infinite cluster , the random walk started at the origin exits the infinite symmetric slab @xmath2 through the `` top '' side with probability tending to @xmath3 as @xmath4 ?
sidoravicius and sznitman managed to answer their question affirmatively in dimensions @xmath5 but dimensions @xmath6 remained open . in this paper
we extend the desired conclusion to all @xmath1 . as in @xcite , we will do so by proving a quenched invariance principle for the paths of the walk . random walk on percolation clusters is only one of many instances of `` statistical mechanics in random media '' that have been recently considered by physicists and mathematicians .
other pertinent examples include , e.g. , various diluted spin systems , random copolymers @xcite , spin glasses @xcite , random - graph models @xcite , etc . from this general perspective , the present problem is interesting for at least two reasons : first , a good handle on simple random walk on a given graph is often a prerequisite for the understanding of more complicated processes , e.g. , self - avoiding walk or loop - erased random walk .
second , information about the scaling properties of simple random walk on percolation cluster can , in principle , reveal some new important facts about the structure of the infinite cluster and/or its harmonic properties .
let us begin developing the mathematical layout of the problem .
let @xmath0 be the @xmath7-dimensional hypercubic lattice and let @xmath8 be the set of nearest neighbor edges .
we will use @xmath9 to denote a generic edge , @xmath10 to denote the edge between @xmath11 and @xmath12 , and @xmath13 to denote the edges from the origin to its nearest neighbors .
let @xmath14 be the space of all percolation configurations @xmath15 . here
@xmath16 indicates that the edge @xmath9 is occupied and @xmath17 implies that it is vacant .
let @xmath18 be the borel @xmath19-algebra on @xmath20defined using the product topology and let @xmath21 be an i.i.d .
measure such that @xmath22 for all @xmath23 .
if @xmath24 denotes the event that the site @xmath11 belongs to an infinite self - avoiding path using only occupied bonds in @xmath25 , we write @xmath26 for the set @xmath27 by burton - keane s uniqueness theorem @xcite , the infinite cluster is unique and so @xmath28 is connected with @xmath21-probability one . for each @xmath29 , let @xmath30 be the `` shift by @xmath11 '' defined by @xmath31 . note that @xmath21 is @xmath32-invariant for all @xmath29 .
let @xmath33 denote the percolation threshold on @xmath0 defined as the infimum of all @xmath34 s for which @xmath35 .
let @xmath36 and , for @xmath37 , define the measure @xmath38 by @xmath39 we will use @xmath40 to denote expectation with respect to @xmath38 . for each configuration @xmath41
, let @xmath42 be the simple random walk on @xmath43 started at the origin .
explicitly , @xmath42 is a markov chain with state space @xmath0 , whose distribution @xmath44 is defined by the transition probabilities @xmath45 and @xmath46 with the initial condition @xmath47 thus , at each unit of time , the walk picks a neighbor at random and if the corresponding edge is occupied , the walk moves to this neighbor .
if the edge is vacant , the move is suppressed .
our main result is that for @xmath38-almost every @xmath41 , the linear interpolation of @xmath48 , properly scaled , converges weakly to brownian motion . for every @xmath49 ,
let @xmath50,{\mathscr{w } } _ t)$ ] be the space of continuous functions @xmath51\to{\mathbb r}$ ] equipped with the @xmath19-algebra @xmath52 of borel sets relative to the supremum topology .
the precise statement is now as follows : [ thm : mainthm ] let @xmath1 , @xmath53 and let @xmath41 .
let @xmath42 be the random walk with law @xmath44 and let @xmath54 then for all @xmath49 and for @xmath38-almost every @xmath25 , the law of @xmath55 on @xmath50,{\mathscr{w } } _ t)$ ] converges weakly to the law of an isotropic brownian motion @xmath56 whose diffusion constant , @xmath57 , depends only on the percolation parameter @xmath34 and the dimension @xmath7 .
the markov chain @xmath42 represents only one of two natural ways to define a simple random walk on the supercritical percolation cluster .
another possibility is that , at each unit of time , the walk moves to a site chosen uniformly at random from the _ accessible _ neighbors , i.e. , the walk takes no pauses . in order to define this process ,
let @xmath58 be the sequence of stopping times that mark the moments when the walk @xmath42 made a move .
explicitly , @xmath59 and @xmath60 using these stopping times which are @xmath44-almost surely finite for all @xmath41we define a new markov chain @xmath61 by @xmath62 it is easy to see that @xmath61 has the desired distribution .
indeed , the walk starts at the origin and its transition probabilities are given by @xmath63 a simple modification of the arguments leading to theorem [ thm : mainthm ] allows us to establish a functional central limit theorem for this random walk as well : [ thm:2ndmainthm ] let @xmath1 , @xmath53 and let @xmath41 .
let @xmath64 be the random walk defined from @xmath42 as described in and let @xmath65 be the linear interpolation of @xmath66 defined by with @xmath67 replaced by @xmath68 .
then for all @xmath49 and for @xmath38-almost every @xmath25 , the law of @xmath69 on @xmath50,{\mathscr{w } } _ t)$ ] converges weakly to the law of an isotropic brownian motion @xmath56 whose diffusion constant , @xmath70 , depends only on the percolation parameter @xmath34 and the dimension @xmath7 .
de gennes @xcite , who introduced the problem of random walk on percolation cluster to the physics community , thinks of the walk as the motion of `` an ant in a labyrinth . ''
from this perspective , the `` lazy '' walk @xmath48 corresponds to a `` blind '' ant , while the `` agile '' walk @xmath71 represents a `` myopic '' ant .
while the character of the scaling limit of the two `` ants '' is the same , there seems to be some distinction in the rate the scaling limit is approached , cf @xcite and references therein . as we will see in the proof , the diffusion constants @xmath72 and @xmath73 are related via @xmath74 , where @xmath75 is the expected degree of the origin normalized by @xmath76 , cf .
there is actually yet another way how to `` put '' simple random walk on @xmath28 , and that is to use continuous time . here
the corresponding result follows by combining the clt for the `` lazy '' walk with an appropriate renewal theorem for exponential waiting times .
the subject of random walk in random environment has a long history ; we refer to , e.g. , @xcite for recent overviews of ( certain parts of ) this field . on general grounds ,
each random - media problem comes in two distinct flavors : _ quenched _ , corresponding to the situations discussed above where the walk is distributed according to an @xmath25-dependent measure @xmath44 , and _ annealed _ , in which the path distribution of the walk is taken from the averaged measure @xmath77 . under suitable ergodicity assumptions , the annealed problem typically corresponds to the quenched problem averaged over the starting point .
yet the distinction is clear : in the annealed setting the slab - exit problem from sect . [ sec1.1 ] is trivial by the symmetries of the averaged measure , while its answer is _ a priori _ very environment - sensitive in the quenched measure .
an annealed version of our theorems was proved in the 1980s by de masi _ et al _
@xcite , based on earlier results of kozlov @xcite , kipnis and varadhan @xcite and others in the context of random walk in a field of random conductances .
( the results of @xcite were primarily two - dimensional but , with the help of @xcite , they apply to all @xmath1 ; cf @xcite . )
a number of proofs of quenched invariance principles have appeared in recent years for the cases where an annealed principle was already known .
the most relevant paper is that of sidoravicius and sznitman @xcite which established theorem [ thm:2ndmainthm ] for random walk among random conductances in all @xmath78 and , using a very different method , also for random walk on percolation in @xmath5 .
( thus our main theorem is new only in @xmath6 . )
the @xmath5 proof is based on the fact that two independent random walk paths will intersect only very little something hard to generalize to @xmath6 . as this paper shows ,
the argument for random conductances is somewhat more flexible .
another paper of relevance is that of rassoul - agha and sepplinen @xcite where a quenched invariance principle was established for _ directed _ random walks in ( space - time ) random environments .
the directed setting offers the possibility to use independence more efficiently every time step the walk enters a new environment but the price to pay for this is the lack of reversibility .
the directed nature of the environment also permits consideration of distributions with a drift for which a clt is not even expected to generally hold in the undirected setting ; see @xcite for an example of `` pathologies '' that may arise . finally , there have been been a number of results dealing with harmonic properties of the simple random walk on percolation clusters .
grimmett , kesten and zhang @xcite proved via `` electrostatic techniques '' that this random walk is transient in @xmath79 ; extensions concerning the existence of various `` energy flows '' appeared in @xcite . a great amount of effort has been spent on deriving estimates on the heat - kernel i.e .
, the probability that the walk is at a particular site after @xmath80 steps .
the first such bounds were obtained by heicklen and hoffman @xcite . later mathieu and
remy @xcite realized that the right way to approach heat - kernel estimates was through harmonic function theory of the infinite cluster and thus significantly improved the results of @xcite .
finally , barlow @xcite obtained , using again harmonic function theory , gaussian upper and lower bounds for the heat kernel .
we refer to @xcite for further references concerning this area of research .
_ note _ : at the time a preprint version of this paper was first circulated , we learned that mathieu and piatnitski had announced a proof of the same result ( albeit in continuous - time setting ) .
their proof , which has in the meantime been posted @xcite , is close in spirit to that of theorem 1.1 of @xcite ; the main tools are poincar inequalities , heat - kernel estimates and homogenization theory .
let us outline the main steps of our proof of theorems [ thm : mainthm ] and [ thm:2ndmainthm ] .
the principal idea which permeates in various disguises throughout the work of papanicolau and varadhan @xcite , kozlov @xcite , kipnis and varadhan @xcite , de masi _ et al _
@xcite , sidoravicius and sznitman @xcite and others is to consider an embedding of @xmath43 into the euclidean space that makes the corresponding simple random walk a martingale .
formally , this is achieved by finding an @xmath81-valued discrete harmonic function on @xmath28 with a linear growth at infinity .
the distance between the natural position of a site @xmath82 and its counterpart in this _ harmonic embedding _ is expressed in terms of the so - called _ corrector _ @xmath83 which is a principal object of study in this paper .
see fig .
[ fig1 ] for an illustration .
it is clear that the corrector can be defined in any finite volume by solving an appropriate discrete dirichlet problem ( this is how fig .
1 was drawn ) ; the difficult part is to define the corrector in infinite volume while maintaining the natural ( distributional ) invariance with respect to shifts of the underlying lattice . actually , there is an alternative , probabilistic definition of the corrector , @xmath84 however , the only proof we presently have for the existence of such a limit is by following , rather closely , the constructions from sect .
[ sec2.3 ] .
once we have the corrector under control , the proof splits into two parts : ( 1 ) proving that the martingale i.e . , the walk on the deformed graph converges to brownian motion and ( 2 ) proving that the deformation of the path caused by the change of embedding is negligible . the latter part ( which is the principal contribution of this work ) amounts to a sublinear bound on the corrector @xmath83 as a function of @xmath11 . here
, somewhat unexpectedly , our level of control is considerably better in @xmath85 than in @xmath79 . in particular ,
our proof in @xmath85 avoids using any of the recent sophisticated discrete - harmonic analyses but , to handle all @xmath1 uniformly , we need to invoke the main result of barlow @xcite .
the proof is actually carried out along these lines only for the setting in theorem [ thm : mainthm ] ; theorem [ thm:2ndmainthm ] follows by noting that the time scales of both walks are comparable .
here is a summary of the rest of this paper : in sect .
[ sec : defcor ] we introduce the aforementioned corrector and prove some of its basic properties .
[ sec : erg ] collects the needed facts about ergodic properties of the markov chain `` on environments . ''
both sections are based on previously known material ; proofs have been included to make the paper self - contained .
the novel parts of the proof sublinear bounds on the corrector appear in sects .
[ sec : sec4]-[sec : sublin ] .
the actual proofs of our main theorems are carried out in sect .
[ sec : invprnp ] . the appendix ( sects .
[ appa ] and [ appb ] ) contains the proof of an upper bound for the transition probabilities of our random walk , further discussion and some conjectures .
in this section we will define and study the aforementioned corrector which is the basic instrument of our proofs .
the main idea is to consider the markov chain `` on environments '' ( sect .
[ sec2.1 ] ) .
the relevant properties of the corrector are listed in theorem [ thm2.1 ] ( sect .
[ sec2.2 ] ) ; the proofs are based on spectral calculus ( see sect . [ sec2.3 ] ) . as is well known , cf kipnis and varadhan @xcite , the markov chain @xmath42 in ( [ e:1.3][e:1.4 ] ) induces a markov chain on @xmath86 , which can be interpreted as the trajectory of `` environments viewed from the perspective of the walk . ''
the transition probabilities of this chain are given by the kernel @xmath87 $ ] , @xmath88 our basic observations about the induced markov chain are as follows : [ lemma1.1 ] for every bounded measurable @xmath89 and every @xmath13 with @xmath90 , @xmath91 where @xmath92 is the bond that is opposite to @xmath13 .
as a consequence , @xmath38 is reversible and , in particular , stationary for markov kernel @xmath93 .
proof first we will prove . neglecting the normalization by @xmath94 , we need that @xmath95 this will follow from @xmath96 and the fact that , on @xmath97 we have @xmath98 .
indeed , these observations imply @xmath99 and then follows by the shift invariance of @xmath21 .
from we deduce that for any bounded , measurable @xmath100 , @xmath101 where @xmath102 is the function @xmath103 indeed , splitting the last sum into two terms , the second part reproduces exactly on both sides of .
for the first part we apply and note that averaging over @xmath13 allows us to neglect the negative sign in front of @xmath13 on the right - hand side .
but is the _ definition _ of reversibility and , setting @xmath104 and noting that @xmath105 , we also get the stationarity of @xmath38 .
lemma [ lemma1.1 ] underlines our main reason to work primarily with the `` lazy '' walk . for the `` agile '' walk , to get a stationary law on environments , one has to weigh @xmath38 by the degree of the origin a factor that would drag through the entire derivation .
next we will adapt the construction of kipnis and varadhan @xcite to the present situation .
let @xmath106 be the space of all borel - measurable , square integrable functions on @xmath20 . abusing the notation slightly , we will use `` @xmath107 '' both for @xmath108-valued functions as well as @xmath81-valued functions .
we equip @xmath107 with the inner product @xmath109with `` @xmath110 '' interpreted as the dot product of @xmath111 and @xmath112 when these functions are vector - valued .
let @xmath93 be the operator defined by .
note that , when applied to a vector - valued function , @xmath93 acts like a scalar , i.e. , independently on each component . from we know @xmath113 and so @xmath93 is symmetric .
an explicit calculation gives us @xmath114 and so @xmath115 .
in particular , @xmath93 is self - adjoint and @xmath116 $ ] .
let @xmath117 be the local drift at the origin , i.e. , @xmath118 ( we will only be interested in @xmath119 for @xmath41 , but that is of no consequence here . ) clearly , since @xmath120 is bounded , we have @xmath121 . for each @xmath122 ,
let @xmath123 be the solution of @xmath124 since @xmath125 is a non - negative operator , @xmath126 is well - defined and @xmath127 for all @xmath122 .
the following theorem is the core of the whole theory : [ thm2.1 ] there is a function @xmath128 such that for every @xmath29 , @xmath129 moreover , the following properties hold : 1 .
( shift invariance ) for @xmath38-almost every @xmath41 , @xmath130 holds for all @xmath131 .
( harmonicity ) for @xmath38-almost every @xmath41 , the function @xmath132 is harmonic with respect to the transition probabilities ( [ e:1.3][e:1.3b ] ) .
( square integrability ) there exists a constant @xmath133 such that @xmath134{\operatorname{\sf 1}}_{\{x\in{\mathscr{c}}_\infty\}}{\operatorname{\sf 1}}_{\{\omega_{e}=1\}}\circ\tau_x\bigr\vert_2<c\ ] ] is true for all @xmath29 and all @xmath13 with @xmath90 .
the rest of this section is spent on proving theorem [ thm2.1 ] . the proof is based on spectral calculus and it closely follows the corresponding arguments from @xcite .
alternative constructions invoke projection arguments , cf @xcite .
let @xmath135 denote the spectral measure of @xmath136 associated with function @xmath120 , i.e. , for every bounded , continuous @xmath137\to{\mathbb r}$ ] , we have @xmath138 ( since @xmath93 acts as a scalar , @xmath135 is the sum of the `` usual '' spectral measures for the cartesian components of @xmath120 . ) in the integral we used that , since @xmath139 $ ] , the measure @xmath135 is supported entirely in @xmath140 $ ] .
the first observation , made already by kipnis and varadhan , is stated as follows : [ lemma2.2 ] @xmath141 proof with some caution concerning the infinite cluster , the proof is a combination of arguments right before theorem 1.3 of @xcite and those in the proof of theorem 4.1 of @xcite .
let @xmath142 be a bounded real - valued function and note that , by lemma [ lemma1.1 ] and the symmetry of the sums , @xmath143 hence , for every @xmath144 we get @xmath145 the first term on the right - hand side equals a constant times @xmath146 , while lemma [ lemma1.1 ] allows us to rewrite the second term into @xmath147 we thus get that there exists a constant @xmath148 such that for all bounded @xmath142 , @xmath149 applying for @xmath111 of the form @xmath150 , summing @xmath151 over coordinate vectors in @xmath81 and invoking , we find that for every bounded continuous @xmath152\to{\mathbb r}$ ] and @xmath153 , @xmath154 substituting @xmath155 for @xmath156 and noting that @xmath157 , we get @xmath158 and so @xmath159 the monotone convergence theorem now implies @xmath160 proving the desired claim . using spectral calculus we will now prove : [ lemma2.3 ] let @xmath126 be as defined in
. then @xmath161 moreover , for @xmath13 with @xmath90 let @xmath162 .
then for all @xmath29 and all @xmath13 with @xmath90 , @xmath163 proof the main ideas are again taken more or less directly from the proof of theorem 1.3 in @xcite ; some caution is necessary regarding the containment in the infinite cluster in the proof of . by the definition of @xmath126 , @xmath164 the integrand
is dominated by @xmath165 and tends to zero as @xmath166 for every @xmath167 in the support of @xmath135
. then follows by the dominated convergence theorem .
the second part of the claim is proved similarly : first we get rid of the @xmath11-dependence by noting that , due to the fact that @xmath168 enforces @xmath82 , the translation invariance of @xmath21 implies @xmath169 next we square the right - hand side and average over all @xmath13 . using that @xmath170 also enforces @xmath171 and applying , we thus get @xmath172
now we calculate @xmath173 the integrand is again bounded by @xmath165 , for all @xmath174 , and it tends to zero as @xmath175 .
the claim follows by the dominated convergence theorem .
now we are ready to prove theorem [ thm2.1 ] : proof of theorem [ thm2.1 ] let @xmath176 be as in lemma [ lemma2.3 ] . using
we know that @xmath176 converges in @xmath107 as @xmath166 .
we denote @xmath177 .
since @xmath176 is a gradient field on @xmath28 , we have @xmath178 and , more generally , @xmath179 whenever @xmath180 is a closed loop on @xmath28 .
thus , we may define @xmath181 where @xmath182 is a nearest - neighbor path on @xmath43 connecting @xmath183 to @xmath184 . by the above `` loop '' conditions , the definition is independent of this path for almost every @xmath185 .
the shift invariance now follows from this definition and @xmath186 . in light of shift invariance ,
to prove the harmonicity of @xmath187 it suffices to show that , almost surely , @xmath188{\operatorname{\sf 1}}_{\{\omega_e=1\}}=v.\ ] ] since @xmath189 , the left hand side is the @xmath166 limit of @xmath190{\operatorname{\sf 1}}_{\{\omega_e=1\}}= ( 1-q)\psi_{\epsilon}.\ ] ] the definition of @xmath126 tells us that @xmath191 . from here
we get by recalling that @xmath192 tends to zero in @xmath107 . to prove the square integrability in part ( 3 ) we note that , by the construction of the corrector , @xmath193{\operatorname{\sf 1}}_{\{x\in{\mathscr{c}}_\infty\}}{\operatorname{\sf 1}}_{\{\omega_{e}=1\}}\circ\tau_x = g_{x , x+e}.\ ] ] but @xmath194 is the @xmath107-limit of @xmath107-functions @xmath176 whose @xmath107-norm is bounded by that of @xmath195 . hence follows with @xmath196 .
here we will establish some basic claims whose common feature is the use of ergodic theory .
modulo some care for the containment in the infinite cluster , all of these results are quite standard and their proofs ( cf sect .
[ sec3.2 ] ) may be skipped on a first reading .
readers interested only in the principal conclusions of this section should focus their attention on theorems [ thm3.1 ] and [ thm3.2 ] .
our first result concerns the convergence of ergodic averages for the markov chain on environments .
the claim that will suffice for our later needs is as follows : [ thm3.1 ] let @xmath197 .
then for @xmath38-almost all @xmath198 , @xmath199 similarly , if @xmath200 is measurable with @xmath201 , then @xmath202 for @xmath38-almost all @xmath25 and @xmath44-almost all trajectories of @xmath203 . the next principal result of this section will be the ergodicity of the `` induced shift '' on @xmath86 . to define this concept ,
let @xmath13 be a vector with @xmath90 and , for every @xmath41 , let @xmath204 by birkhoff s ergodic theorem we know that @xmath205 has positive density in @xmath206 and so @xmath207 almost surely .
therefore we can define the map @xmath208 by @xmath209 we call @xmath210 the _ induced shift_. then we claim : [ thm3.2 ] for every @xmath13 with @xmath90 , the induced shift @xmath208 is @xmath38-preserving and ergodic with respect to @xmath38 .
both theorems will follow once we establish of ergodicity of the markov chain on environments ( see proposition [ prop3.5 ] ) . for finite - state ( irreducible )
markov chains the proof of ergodicity is a standard textbook material ( cf @xcite ) , but our state space is somewhat large and so alternative arguments are necessary . since we could not find appropriate versions of all needed claims in the literature , we include complete proofs .
we begin by theorem [ thm3.2 ] which will follow from a more general statement , lemma [ claim : genergd ] , below .
let @xmath211 be a probability space , and let @xmath212 be invertible , measure preserving and ergodic with respect to @xmath213 .
let @xmath214 be of positive measure , and define @xmath215 by @xmath216 the poincar recurrence theorem ( cf ( * ? ? ?
2.3 ) ) tells us that @xmath217 almost surely .
therefore we can define , up to a set of measure zero , the map @xmath218 by @xmath219 then we have : [ claim : genergd ] @xmath220 is measure preserving and ergodic with respect to @xmath221 .
it is also almost surely invertible with respect to the same measure .
proof ( 1 ) @xmath220 is measure preserving : for @xmath222 , let @xmath223
. then the @xmath224 s are disjoint and @xmath225 .
first we show that @xmath226 to do this , we use the fact that @xmath227 is invertible . indeed , if @xmath228 for @xmath229 , then @xmath230 for some @xmath231 with @xmath232 and @xmath233 .
but the fact that @xmath227 is invertible implies that @xmath234 , which means @xmath235 , a contradiction . to see that @xmath220 is measure preserving
, we note that the restriction of @xmath220 to @xmath224 is @xmath236 , which is measure preserving .
hence , @xmath220 is measure preserving on @xmath224 and , by , on the disjoint union @xmath237 as well .
( 2 ) @xmath220 is almost surely invertible : @xmath238 is a one - point set by the fact that @xmath227 is itself invertible .
( 3 ) @xmath220 is ergodic : let @xmath239 be such that @xmath240 and @xmath241 .
assume that @xmath242 is @xmath220-invariant .
then @xmath243 for all @xmath244 and all @xmath245 .
this means that for every @xmath244 and every @xmath246 such that @xmath247 , we have @xmath248 . if follows that @xmath249 is ( almost - surely ) @xmath227-invariant and @xmath250 , a contradiction with the ergodicity of @xmath227 .
proof of theorem [ thm3.2 ] we know that the shift @xmath251 is invertible , measure preserving and ergodic with respect to @xmath21 . by lemma [ claim : genergd ] the induced shift
@xmath208 is @xmath38-preserving , almost - surely invertible and ergodic with respect to @xmath38 . in the present circumstances ,
theorem [ thm3.2 ] has one important consequence : [ lemma3.3 ] let @xmath252 be a subset of @xmath86 such that for almost all @xmath253 , @xmath254 then @xmath242 is a zero - one event under @xmath38 .
proof the markov property and imply that @xmath255 for all @xmath245 and @xmath38-almost every @xmath253 .
we claim that @xmath256 for @xmath38-almost every @xmath253 .
indeed , let @xmath253 be such that @xmath257 for all @xmath245 , @xmath44-almost surely .
let @xmath258 be as in and note that we have @xmath259 .
by the uniqueness of the infinite cluster , there is a path of finite length connecting @xmath260 and @xmath261 . if @xmath262 is the length of this path , we have @xmath263 .
this means that @xmath264 , i.e. , @xmath242 is almost surely @xmath210-invariant . by the ergodicity of the induced shift ,
@xmath242 is a zero - one event .
our next goal will be to prove that the markov chain on environments is ergodic .
let @xmath265 and define @xmath266 to be the product @xmath19-algebra on @xmath267 ; @xmath268 .
the space @xmath267 is a space of two - sided sequences @xmath269the trajectories of the markov chain on environments .
( note that the index on @xmath25 is an index in the sequence which is unrelated to the value of the configuration at a point . )
let @xmath213 be the measure on @xmath270 such that for any @xmath271 , @xmath272 where @xmath93 is the markov kernel defined in .
( since @xmath38 is preserved by @xmath93 , these finite - dimensional measures are consistent and @xmath213 exists and is unique by kolmogorov s theorem . ) clearly , @xmath273 has the same law in @xmath274 as @xmath275 has in @xmath213 .
let @xmath212 be the shift defined by @xmath276 .
then @xmath227 is measure preserving .
[ prop3.5 ] @xmath227 is ergodic with respect to @xmath213 .
proof let @xmath277 denote expectation with respect to @xmath213 .
pick @xmath278 that is measurable and @xmath227-invariant .
we need to show that @xmath279 let @xmath280 be defined as @xmath281 .
first we claim that @xmath282 almost surely . indeed , since @xmath283 is @xmath227-invariant , there exist @xmath284 and @xmath285 such that @xmath283 and @xmath286 differ only by null sets from one another .
( this follows by approximation of @xmath283 by finite - dimensional events and using the @xmath227-invariance of @xmath283 . )
now conditional on @xmath287 , the event @xmath288 is independent of @xmath289 and so lvy s martingale convergence theorem gives us @xmath290 & = e_\mu({\operatorname{\sf 1}}_{a_-}|\omega_0,\omega_{-1},\ldots,\omega_{-n})\,\underset{n\to\infty}\longrightarrow\ , { \operatorname{\sf 1}}_{a_-}={\operatorname{\sf 1}}_a , \end{aligned}\ ] ] with all equalities valid @xmath213-almost surely .
next let @xmath291 be defined by @xmath292 . clearly , @xmath242 is @xmath18-measurable and , since the @xmath287-marginal of @xmath213 is @xmath38 , @xmath293 hence , to prove , we need to show that @xmath294 but @xmath283 is @xmath227-invariant and so , up to sets of measure zero , if @xmath295 then @xmath296 .
this means that @xmath242 satisfies condition of lemma [ lemma3.3 ] and so holds .
now we can finally prove theorem [ thm3.1 ] : proof of theorem [ thm3.1 ] recall that @xmath273 has the same law in @xmath274 as @xmath275 has in @xmath213 .
hence , if @xmath297 then @xmath298 the latter limit exists by birkhoff s ergodic theorem and ( by proposition [ prop3.5 ] ) equals @xmath299 almost surely .
the second part is proved analogously .
equipped with the tools from the previous two sections , we can start addressing the main problem of our proof : the sublinearity of the corrector . here
we will prove the corresponding claim along the coordinate directions in @xmath0 .
fix @xmath13 with @xmath90 and let @xmath258 be as defined in . define a sequence @xmath300 inductively by @xmath301 and @xmath302 .
the numbers @xmath303 , which are well - defined and finite on a set of full @xmath38-measure , represent the successive `` arrivals '' of @xmath28 to the positive part of the coordinate axis in direction @xmath13 .
let @xmath304 be the corrector defined in theorem [ thm2.1 ] .
the main goal of this section is to prove the following theorem : [ thm4.1 ] for @xmath38-almost all @xmath41 , @xmath305 the proof is based on the following facts about the moments of @xmath306 : [ lemma : next_corrector ] abbreviate @xmath307
. then 1 .
2 . @xmath309 .
the proof of this proposition will in turn be based on a bound on the tails of the length of the shortest path connecting the origin to @xmath310 .
we begin by showing that @xmath311 has exponential tails : [ lemma - tails ] for each @xmath37 there exists a constant @xmath312 such that for all @xmath13 with @xmath90 , @xmath313 proof the proof uses a different argument in @xmath85 and @xmath79 . in @xmath79 , we will use the fact that the slab - percolation threshold coincides with @xmath314 , as was proved by grimmett and marstrand @xcite .
indeed , given @xmath37 , let @xmath315 be so large that @xmath316 contains an infinite cluster almost surely . by the uniqueness of the percolation cluster in @xmath0 , this slab - cluster is almost surely a subset of @xmath28 .
our bound in is derived as follows : let @xmath317 be the event that at least one of the sites in @xmath318 is contained in the infinite connected component in @xmath316 . then @xmath319 . since the events @xmath320 , @xmath321
, are independent , letting @xmath322 we have @xmath323 from here follows by choosing @xmath151 appropriately . in dimension @xmath85 , we will instead use a duality argument .
let @xmath324 be the box @xmath325 .
on @xmath326 , none of the boundary sites @xmath327 are in @xmath28 .
so either at least one of these sites is in a finite component of size larger than @xmath80 or there exists a dual crossing of @xmath324 in the direction of @xmath13 . by the exponential decay of truncated connectivities ( theorem 8.18 of grimmett @xcite ) and dual connectivities ( theorem 6.75 of grimmett @xcite )
, the probability of each of these events decays exponentially with @xmath80 .
our next lemma provides the requisite tail bound for the length of the shortest path between the origin and @xmath310 : [ claim : pathlen ] let @xmath328 be the length of the shortest occupied path from @xmath260 to @xmath310 .
then there exist a constant @xmath133 and @xmath329 such that for every @xmath245 , @xmath330 proof let @xmath331 be the length of the shortest path from @xmath260 to @xmath11 in configuration @xmath25 .
pick @xmath122 such that @xmath332 is an integer . then @xmath333 in light of lemma [ lemma - tails ]
, the claim will follow once we show that the probability of all events in the giant union on the right - hand side is bounded by @xmath334 with some @xmath335 ( independently of @xmath336 ) .
we will use the following large - deviation result from theorem 1.1 of antal and pisztora @xcite : there exist constants @xmath337 such that @xmath338 once @xmath339 is sufficiently large .
unfortunately , we can not use this bound in directly , because @xmath340 can be arbitrarily close to @xmath260 ( in @xmath341 distance on @xmath0 ) . to circumvent this problem ,
let @xmath342 be the site @xmath343 such that @xmath344 and let @xmath345 .
then , on @xmath346 , either @xmath347 or at least one site `` between '' @xmath348 and @xmath349 is connected to either @xmath260 or @xmath340 by a path longer than @xmath350 . since on @xmath351
we must have @xmath352 for at least one @xmath353 , we have @xmath354 now all events in the first giant union have the same probability , which is exponentially small by lemma [ lemma - tails ] . as to the second union , by we know that @xmath355 whenever @xmath356 is so small that @xmath357 , and a similar bound holds for @xmath358 as well ( except that here we need @xmath359 ) .
the various unions then contribute a linear factor in @xmath80 , which is absorbed into the exponential once @xmath80 is sufficiently large .
it is possible that a proper merge of the arguments in the previous two proofs might yield the same result without relying on antal and pisztora s bound .
( indeed , the main other `` external '' ingredient of our proofs is grimmett and marstrand s paper @xcite which lies at the core of @xcite as well . )
however , we find the argument using conceptually cleaner and so we are content with the present , even though not necessarily optimal , proof . next we state a trivial , but interesting technical lemma : [ claim : caucschwa ] let @xmath360 and @xmath361 .
suppose that @xmath362 are random variables such that @xmath363 and let @xmath364 be a random variable taking values in positive integers such that @xmath365 for some @xmath366 satisfying @xmath367 then @xmath368 .
explicitly , @xmath369}},\ ] ] where @xmath370 is a finite constant depending only on @xmath34 , @xmath371 and @xmath366 .
proof let us define @xmath372 by @xmath373 . from the hlder inequality and the uniform bound on @xmath374 we get @xmath375 under the assumption that @xmath364 has @xmath366 moments , we get @xmath376 by invoking the hlder inequality one more time .
the first term on the right - hand side is finite whenever @xmath366 obeys the bound .
proof of proposition [ lemma : next_corrector ] let @xmath83 be the corrector .
by theorem [ thm2.1 ] , on the set @xmath377 , @xmath378 is an @xmath107-limit of functions @xmath379 , as @xmath166 . to prove that @xmath380 , recall the notation @xmath381 from lemma [ lemma2.3 ] and let as in lemma [ claim
: pathlen]@xmath328 be the length of the shortest path from @xmath260 to @xmath310 . then @xmath382
but theorem [ thm2.1 ] ensures that @xmath383 for all @xmath11 and @xmath13 and all @xmath122 , while the number of terms in the sum does not exceed @xmath384 . by lemma [ claim : pathlen ] ,
@xmath364 has all moments and so , by lemma [ claim : caucschwa ] , @xmath385 for all @xmath386 . in particular , @xmath380 .
in order to prove part ( 2 ) , we first note that a uniform bound on @xmath387-norm of @xmath388 for some @xmath389 implies that the family @xmath390 is uniformly integrable .
since @xmath391 in probability , @xmath391 in @xmath392 and it thus suffices to prove @xmath393 this is implied by theorem [ thm3.2 ] and the fact @xmath394 with @xmath126 absolutely integrable .
proof of theorem [ thm4.1 ] let @xmath395 , and let @xmath210 be the induced shift in the direction of @xmath13
. then we can write @xmath396 by proposition [ lemma : next_corrector ] we have @xmath397 and @xmath398 .
since theorem [ thm3.2 ] ensures that @xmath210 is @xmath38-preserving and ergodic , the claim follows from birkhoff s ergodic theorem .
here we will prove the principal technical estimates of this work .
the level of control is different in @xmath85 and @xmath79 , so we treat these cases separately .
( notwithstanding , the @xmath79 proof applies in @xmath85 as well . )
we begin with an estimate of the corrector in large boxes in @xmath399 : [ thm5.1 ] let @xmath85 and let @xmath304 be the corrector defined in theorem [ thm2.1 ] .
then for @xmath38-almost every @xmath41 , @xmath400 the proof will be based on the following concept : [ def5.6 ] given @xmath401 and @xmath122 , we say that a site @xmath29 is @xmath402-_good _ ( or just _ good _ ) in configuration @xmath198 if @xmath403 and @xmath404 holds for every @xmath405 of the form @xmath406 , where @xmath407 and @xmath13 is a unit coordinate vector
. we will use @xmath408 to denote the set of @xmath402-good sites in configuration @xmath25 . on the basis of theorem [ thm4.1 ]
it is clear that for each @xmath122 there exists a @xmath409 such that the @xmath410 .
our first goal is to estimate the size of the largest interval free of good points in blocks @xmath411 $ ] on the coordinate axes : [ lemma5.3d ] let @xmath13 be one of the principal lattice vectors in @xmath399 and , given @xmath122 , let @xmath412 be so large that @xmath410 . for all @xmath245 and @xmath198 , let @xmath413 be the ordered set of all integers from @xmath411 $ ] such that @xmath414 . let @xmath415 ( if no such @xmath416 exists , we define @xmath417 . )
then @xmath418 proof since @xmath21 is @xmath419 invariant and @xmath419 is ergodic , we have @xmath420 @xmath21-almost surely .
a similar statement applies to the limit @xmath421 .
but if @xmath422 does not tend to zero , at least one of these limits would not exist .
proof of theorem [ thm5.1 ] fix @xmath423 and let @xmath424 be such that @xmath425 for all @xmath426 ( we are using that @xmath427 increases with @xmath412 ) .
let @xmath428 be the set of configurations such that the conclusion of lemma [ lemma5.3d ] applies for both @xmath11 and @xmath12-axes , and that shift - invariance holds for all @xmath429 in the infinite cluster .
we will show that for every @xmath430 the limsup in is less than @xmath431 almost surely .
let @xmath432 and @xmath433 denote the coordinate vectors in @xmath399 .
fix @xmath430 and adjust @xmath426 so that @xmath434 .
( this is possible by the definition of @xmath435 . )
then we define @xmath436 to be the increasing two - sided sequence of all integers such that @xmath437 exhausts all @xmath402-good points on the @xmath432-axis , i.e. , @xmath438 if @xmath439 be the maximal gap between consecutive @xmath440 s that lie in @xmath411 $ ] , cf , we define @xmath441 be the least integer such that @xmath442 for all @xmath443 .
similarly we identify a two - sided increasing sequence @xmath444 of integers exhausting the sites such that @xmath445 and let @xmath446 be the quantity corresponding to @xmath441 in this case .
let @xmath447 .
we claim that for all @xmath448 , @xmath449 of _ good lines _ @xmath450 and @xmath451 see fig .
[ fig3 ] . as a first step we will use the harmonicity of @xmath187 to deal with @xmath452 .
indeed , any such @xmath11 is enclosed between two horizontal and two vertical grid lines and every path on @xmath28 connecting @xmath11 to `` infinity '' necessarily intersects one of these lines at a point which is also in @xmath28 . applying the maximum ( and minimum ) principle for harmonic functions we get @xmath453 apart and , in particular , they all intersect the block @xmath454\times[-2n,2n]$ ] . to estimate the maximum on the grid , we pick , say ,
a horizontal grid line with @xmath12-coordinate @xmath455 and note that , by , for every @xmath82 on this line , @xmath456 by and the fact that @xmath457 we have @xmath458 whenever @xmath11 is such that @xmath459 . applying the same argument to the vertical line through the origin , and @xmath11 replaced by @xmath460
, we get @xmath461 for every @xmath462 with @xmath463 . combining this with ,
the estimate and the whole claim are finally proved .
interestingly , a variant of the above strategy for controlling the corrector in @xmath85 has independently been developed by chris hoffman @xcite to control the geodesics in the first - passage percolation on @xmath399 . in @xmath79
we have the following weaker version of theorem [ thm5.1 ] : [ thm5.4 ] let @xmath79 .
then for all @xmath122 and @xmath38-almost all @xmath25 , @xmath464 here we fix the dimension @xmath7 and run an induction over @xmath465-dimensional sections of the @xmath7-dimensional box @xmath466 .
specifically , for each @xmath467 , let @xmath468 be the @xmath465-dimensional box @xmath469 the induction eventually gives for @xmath470 thus proving the theorem .
since it is not advantageous to assume that @xmath471 , we will carry out the proof for _ differences _ of the form @xmath472 with @xmath473 .
for each @xmath198 , we thus consider the ( upper ) density @xmath474 note that the infimum is taken only over sites in one - dimensional box @xmath475 .
our goal is to show by induction that @xmath476 almost surely for all @xmath467 .
the induction step is encapsulated into the following lemma : [ lemma5.5 ] let @xmath477 .
if @xmath476 , @xmath21-almost surely , then also @xmath478 , @xmath21-almost surely . before we start the formal proof , let us discuss its main idea : suppose that @xmath476 for some @xmath479 , @xmath21-almost surely .
pick @xmath122 .
then for @xmath21-almost every @xmath25 and all sufficiently large @xmath80 , there exists a set of sites @xmath480 such that @xmath481 and @xmath482 moreover , @xmath80 sufficiently large , @xmath483 could be picked so that @xmath484 and , assuming @xmath485 , the non-@xmath402-good sites could be pitched out with little loss of density to achieve even @xmath486 ( all these claims are direct consequences of the pointwise ergodic theorem and the fact that @xmath487 converges to the density of @xmath28 as @xmath488 . ) as a result of this construction we have @xmath489 for any @xmath490 and any @xmath491 of the form @xmath492 .
thus , if @xmath493 are of the latter form , @xmath494 and @xmath495see fig .
[ fig4 ] for an illustration then implies @xmath496 , implying a bound of the type but one - dimension higher . unfortunately , the above is not sufficient to prove for all but a vanishing fraction of all sites in @xmath497 .
the reason is that the @xmath371 s and @xmath366 s for which holds need to be of the form @xmath492 for some @xmath498 .
but @xmath28 will occupy only about @xmath499 fraction of all sites in @xmath468 , and so this argument does not permit us to control more than fraction about @xmath500 of @xmath501 . to fix this problem , we will have to work with a `` stack '' of translates of @xmath468 at the same time .
( these correspond to the stack of horizontal lines on the left of of fig .
[ fig4 ] . )
explicitly , consider the collection of @xmath465-boxes @xmath502 here @xmath503 is a deterministic number chosen so that , for a given @xmath504 , the set @xmath505 is so large that @xmath506 once @xmath80 is sufficiently large .
these choices ensure that @xmath507-fraction of @xmath468 is now `` covered '' which by repeating the above argument gives us control over @xmath508 for nearly the same fraction of all sites @xmath509 .
proof of lemma [ lemma5.5 ] let @xmath479 and suppose that @xmath476 , @xmath21-almost surely .
fix @xmath510 with @xmath511 and let @xmath503 be as defined above . choose @xmath122 so that @xmath512 for a fixed but large @xmath412 , and @xmath21-almost every @xmath25 and @xmath80 exceeding an @xmath25-dependent quantity , for each @xmath513 , we can find @xmath514 satisfying the properties ( [ 5.19][5.21])with @xmath468 replaced by @xmath515 .
given @xmath516 , let @xmath517 be the set of sites in @xmath501 whose projection onto the linear subspace @xmath518 belongs to the corresponding projection of @xmath519 .
note that the @xmath520 could be chosen so that @xmath521 . by their construction , the projections of the @xmath520 s , @xmath513 , onto @xmath522 `` fail to cover '' at most @xmath523 sites in @xmath524 , and
so at most @xmath525 sites in @xmath468 are not of the form @xmath526 for some @xmath527 .
it follows that @xmath528 i.e. , @xmath517 contains all except at most @xmath529-fraction of all sites in @xmath497 that we care about .
next we note that if @xmath412 is sufficiently large , then for every @xmath530 , the set @xmath522 contains at least @xmath531-fraction of sites @xmath11 such that @xmath532 since we assumed , once @xmath533 , for each pair @xmath534 with @xmath530 such @xmath535 and @xmath536 can be found so that @xmath537 and @xmath538 .
but the @xmath520 s were picked to make true and so via these pairs of sites we now show that @xmath539 for every @xmath540 ; see again ( the left part of ) fig .
[ fig4 ] . from and
we now conclude that for all @xmath541 , @xmath542 provided that @xmath543 . if @xmath544 denotes the right - hand side of before taking @xmath166 , the bounds and and @xmath521 yield @xmath545 for @xmath21-almost every @xmath25 . but
the left - hand side of this inequality increases as @xmath166 while the right - hand side decreases .
thus , taking @xmath166 and @xmath546 proves that @xmath547 holds @xmath21-almost surely .
proof of theorem [ thm5.4 ] the proof is an easy consequence of lemma [ lemma5.5 ] .
first , by theorem [ thm4.1 ] we know that @xmath548 for @xmath38-almost every @xmath25 . invoking appropriate shifts , the same conclusion applies @xmath21-almost surely .
using induction on dimension , lemma [ lemma5.5 ] then tells us that @xmath549 for @xmath38-almost every @xmath25 .
let @xmath41 .
by theorem [ thm4.1 ] , for each @xmath122 there is @xmath550 with @xmath551 such that for all @xmath448 , we have @xmath552 for all @xmath553 . using this to estimate away the infimum in , the fact that @xmath554 now immediately implies for all @xmath122 .
here we will finally prove our main theorems .
first , in sect . [ sec6.1 ] , we will show the convergence of the `` lazy '' walk on the deformed graph to brownian motion and then , in sect .
[ sec6.2 ] , we use our previous results on corrector growth to extend this to the walk on the original graph .
this separation will allow us to treat the parts of the proof common for @xmath85 and @xmath79 in a unified way .
theorem [ thm:2ndmainthm ] , which concerns the `` agile '' walk , is proved in sect .
[ sec6.3 ] .
we begin with a simple observation that will drive all underlying derivations : [ lemma6.2 ] fix @xmath41 and let @xmath555 be the corrector . given a path of random walk @xmath42 with law @xmath44 ,
let @xmath556 then @xmath557 is an @xmath107-martingale for the filtration @xmath558 .
moreover , conditional on @xmath559 , the increments @xmath560 have the same law as @xmath561 . proof since @xmath562 is bounded , @xmath563 is bounded and so @xmath564 is square integrable with respect to @xmath44 . since @xmath187 is harmonic with respect to the transition probabilities of the random walk @xmath48 with law @xmath44 , we have @xmath565 @xmath44-almost surely .
since @xmath564 is @xmath566-measurable , @xmath567 is a martingale .
the stated relation between the laws of @xmath560 and @xmath561 is implied by the shift - invariance and the fact that @xmath567 is a simple random walk on the deformed infinite component .
next we will establish the convergence of the above martingale to brownian motion .
the precise statement is as follows : [ thm6.1 ] let @xmath1 , @xmath37 and @xmath41 .
let @xmath42 be the random walk with law @xmath44 and let @xmath557 be as defined in .
let @xmath568 be defined by @xmath569 then for all @xmath49 and @xmath38-almost every @xmath25 , the law of @xmath570 on @xmath50,{\mathscr{w } } _ t)$ ] converges weakly to the law of an isotropic brownian motion @xmath56 with diffusion constant @xmath72 , i.e. , @xmath571 , where @xmath572 proof without much loss of generality , we may confine ourselves to the case when @xmath573 .
let @xmath574 and fix a vector @xmath144 .
we will show that ( the piece - wise linearization ) of @xmath575 scales to one - dimensional brownian motion . for @xmath576
, consider the random variable @xmath577 ^ 2{\operatorname{\sf 1}}_{\{|a\cdot(m_{k+1}^{(\omega)}-m_k^{(\omega)})|\ge\epsilon\sqrt n\}}\big|{\mathscr{f}}_k\bigr).\ ] ] in order to apply the lindeberg - feller functional clt for martingales ( theorem 7.7.3 of durrett @xcite ) , we need to verify that for @xmath38-almost every @xmath25 , 1 .
@xmath578 in @xmath44-probability for all @xmath579 $ ] and some @xmath580 .
2 . @xmath581 in @xmath44-probability for all @xmath122 . both of these conditions will be implied by theorem [ thm3.1 ] . indeed , by the last conclusion of lemma [ lemma6.2 ] we may write @xmath582 where @xmath583 ^ 2{\operatorname{\sf 1}}_{\{|a\cdot m_1^{(\omega)}|\ge k\}}\bigr).\ ] ] now if @xmath584 , theorem [ thm3.1 ] tells us that , for @xmath38-almost every @xmath25 , @xmath585 ^ 2\bigr)\bigr)= \frac1d d|a|^2,\ ] ] where we used the symmetry of the joint expectations under rotations by @xmath586 .
from here condition ( 1 ) follows by scaling out the @xmath587-dependence first and working with @xmath588 instead of @xmath80 . on the other hand , when @xmath122 , we have @xmath589 once @xmath80 is sufficiently large and so , @xmath38-almost surely , @xmath590
^ 2{\operatorname{\sf 1}}_{\{|a\cdot m_1^{(\omega)}|\ge k\}}\bigr)\bigr ) \,\underset{k\to\infty}\longrightarrow\,0,\ ] ] where to apply dominated convergence we used that @xmath591 .
hence , the above conditions ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) hold in fact , even with limits taken @xmath44-almost surely . applying the martingale functional clt and the cramr - wold device ( theorem 2.9.2 of @xcite ) ,
we conclude that , for @xmath38-almost every @xmath25 , the linear interpolation of the sequence @xmath592 converges to isotropic brownian motion with covariance matrix @xmath593 . to make the proof complete , we need to show that @xmath594 .
here the finiteness is immediate by the square - integrability of @xmath304 .
the positivity can be shown in many ways : either by a direct computation from using that @xmath595 [ which in turn is implied by @xmath596 for every coordinate vector @xmath13 ] or by invoking the sublinearity of the corrector proved in theorems [ thm5.1][thm5.4 ] , or by an appeal to the lower ( or , alternatively , upper ) bound in ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1 ) . it remains to estimate the influence of the harmonic deformation on the path of the walk .
as already mentioned , while our proof in @xmath85 is completely self - contained , for @xmath79 we rely heavily on ( a discrete version of ) the sophisticated theorem 1 of barlow @xcite .
let us first dismiss the two - dimensional case of theorem [ thm : mainthm ] : proof of theorem [ thm : mainthm ] ( @xmath85 ) we need to extend the conclusion of theorem [ thm6.1 ] to the linear interpolation of @xmath48 . since the corrector is an additive perturbation of @xmath564 , it clearly suffices to show that , for @xmath38-almost every @xmath25 , @xmath598 by theorem [ thm5.1 ] we know that for every @xmath122 there exists a @xmath599 such that @xmath600 if @xmath601 , then this implies @xmath602 but the above clt for @xmath603 tells us that @xmath604 converges in law to the maximum of a brownian motion @xmath605 over @xmath579 $ ] . hence
, if @xmath606 denotes the probability law of the brownian motion , the portmanteau theorem ( theorem 2.1 of @xcite ) allows us to conclude @xmath607 the right - hand side tends to zero as @xmath166 for all @xmath504 . in order to prove the same result in @xmath79 , we will need the following upper bounds on the transition probability of our random walk : [ thm6.3a ] ( 1 ) there is a random variable @xmath608 with @xmath609 such that for all @xmath41 and all @xmath403 , @xmath610 \(2 ) there are constants @xmath611 and random variables @xmath612 such that for all @xmath41 , all @xmath403 , all @xmath613 , and all @xmath614 , @xmath615 moreover , the random variables @xmath616 have stretched - exponential tails , i.e. , there exist constants @xmath617 and @xmath618 such that for all @xmath29 , @xmath619 for a continuous - time version of our walk , these bounds are the content of theorem 1 of barlow @xcite .
( in fact , the continuous - time version of the bound was obtained already by mathieu and remy @xcite . ) unfortunately , to derive theorem [ thm6.3a ] from barlow s theorem 1 , one needs to invoke various non - trivial facts about percolation and/or mixing of markov chains . in appendix [ appa ]
we list these facts and show how to assemble all ingredients together to establish the above upper bounds .
proof of theorem [ thm : mainthm ] ( @xmath79 ) we will adapt ( the easier part of ) the proof of theorem 1.1 in sidoravicius and sznitman @xcite . first we show that the laws of @xmath620 on @xmath50,{\mathscr{w } } _ t)$ ] are tight . to that end it suffices to show ( e.g. , by theorem 8.6 of ethier - kurtz @xcite ) that if @xmath621 is the class of all stopping times of the filtration @xmath622 , then @xmath623 as in @xcite , we replace @xmath624 by its integer - valued approximation .
explicitly , let @xmath625 and let @xmath510 be a number such that @xmath626 . since @xmath627 differs from @xmath628 by a constant of order unity , and similarly for @xmath629 and @xmath630 , we have @xmath631 for some constant @xmath632 .
this allows us to estimate by means of the second moment of @xmath633 .
recalling that @xmath634 , we may assume that @xmath635 . by
we know that there exists an almost - surely finite random variable @xmath636 such that @xmath637 once @xmath638 , where @xmath639 .
since @xmath640 , this implies that @xmath641^\zeta$ ] .
theorem [ thm6.3a](2 ) and the strong markov property@xmath627 is a stopping time of the random walk tell us that , for some constant @xmath642 ( depending only on @xmath643 and the dimension ) , @xmath644 here we used @xmath645 and let @xmath646 be such that @xmath647^\zeta$ ] for all @xmath648 .
the bound is now proved by combining ( [ e:6.18a][e:6.19a ] ) and taking the required limits .
once we know that the laws of @xmath620 are tight , it suffices to show the convergence of finite - dimensional distributions . in light of theorem [ thm6.1 ]
( and the markov property of the walk ) , for that it is enough to prove that for all @xmath649 and @xmath38-almost every @xmath25 , @xmath650 without loss of generality , we need to do this only for @xmath651 . by theorem [ thm6.3a ]
, the random variable @xmath562 lies with probability @xmath652 in the block @xmath653^d\cap{\mathbb z}^d$ ] , provided @xmath654 sufficiently large ( with `` large '' depending possibly on @xmath25 ) . using theorem [ thm6.3a](1 ) to estimate @xmath655 for @xmath11 inside this block , we have @xmath656 but theorem [ thm5.4 ] tells us that , for all @xmath657 and @xmath38-almost every @xmath25 , the second term tends to zero as @xmath658 .
this proves and the whole claim .
it remains to prove theorem [ thm:2ndmainthm ] for the `` agile '' version of simple random walk on @xmath28 . since the proof is based entirely on the statement of theorem [ thm : mainthm ]
, we will resume a unified treatment of all @xmath1 .
first we will make the observation that the times of the two walks run proportionally to each other : [ lemma6.3 ] let @xmath58 be the stopping times defined in .
then for all @xmath659 and @xmath38-almost every @xmath25 , @xmath660 where @xmath661 proof this is an easy consequence of the second part of theorem [ thm3.1 ] and the fact that for @xmath38-almost every @xmath25 we have @xmath662 once @xmath663 .
indeed , let @xmath664 .
for @xmath665 the statement holds trivially so let us assume that @xmath649 .
if @xmath80 is so large that @xmath666 , we have @xmath667 since @xmath668 as @xmath658 , by theorem [ thm3.1 ] the right hand side converges to the expectation of @xmath669 in the annealed measure @xmath274 .
a direct calculation shows that this expectation equals @xmath670 .
proof of theorem [ thm:2ndmainthm ] the proof is based on a standard approximation argument for stochastic processes .
let @xmath671 be as in theorem [ thm : mainthm ] and recall that @xmath65 is a linear interpolation of the values @xmath672 for @xmath673 .
the path - continuity of the processes @xmath671 as well as the limiting brownian motion implies that for every @xmath122 there is a @xmath504 such that @xmath674 once @xmath80 is sufficiently large .
similarly , lemma [ lemma6.3 ] , the continuity of @xmath675 and the monotonicity of @xmath676 imply that for @xmath80 sufficiently large , @xmath677 on the intersection of these events , the equality @xmath678 yields @xmath679 in light of piece - wise linearity this shows that , with probability at least @xmath680 , the paths @xmath681 and @xmath682 are within a multiple of @xmath356 in the supremum norm of each other . in particular , if @xmath683 denotes the weak limit of the process @xmath684 , then @xmath685 converges in law to @xmath686 .
the latter is an isotropic brownian motion with diffusion constant @xmath74 .
let @xmath687 denote the continuous - time random walk which attempts a jump to one of its nearest - neighbors at rate one ( regardless of the number of accessible neighbors ) .
let @xmath688 denote the probability that @xmath689 started at @xmath11 is at @xmath12 at time @xmath587 . in his paper @xcite ,
barlow proved the following statement : there exist constants @xmath690 and , for each @xmath29 , a random variable @xmath691 such that for all @xmath692 and all @xmath693 , @xmath694 moreover , @xmath695 has uniformly stretched - exponential tails , i.e. , @xmath696 barlow provides also a corresponding , and significantly harder - to - prove lower bound which requires the additional condition @xmath697 .
however , for , this condition is redundant . in the remarks after his theorem 1 , barlow mentions that appropriate modifications to his arguments yield the corresponding discrete time estimates . here
we present the details of these modifications which are needed to make our proof of the invariance principles in theorems [ thm : mainthm ] and [ thm:2ndmainthm ] complete .
notice that we do not re - prove barlow s bounds in their full generality , just the absolute minimum necessary for our purposes
. there will be two kinds of bounds on the heat - kernel as a function of the terminal position of the walk after @xmath80 steps : a uniform bound by a constant times @xmath698 and a non - uniform , gaussian bound on the tails .
we begin with the statement of the uniform upper bound : [ propa.1 ] let @xmath1 and let @xmath53 .
there exists a random variable @xmath608 with @xmath699 such that for all @xmath41 and all @xmath82 , @xmath700 the proof will invoke the isoperimetric bound from barlow @xcite : [ lemmaa.2 ] there exists a constant @xmath701 such that for @xmath38-almost every @xmath25 and all @xmath702 sufficiently large , @xmath703 for all @xmath704^d$ ] such that @xmath705 .
proof this is a consequence of proposition 2.11 on page 3042 , and lemma 2.13 on page 3045 of barlow s paper @xcite .
this isoperimetric bound will be combined with the technique of _ evolving sets _ , developed by morris and peres @xcite , whose salient features we will now recall . consider a markov chain on a countable state - space @xmath120 , let @xmath706 be the transition kernel and let @xmath707 be a stationary measure .
let @xmath708 and for each @xmath709 , let @xmath710 .
for each set @xmath711 with finite non - zero total measure @xmath712 we define the _ conductance _ @xmath713 by @xmath714 for sufficiently large @xmath371 , we also define the function @xmath715 the following is the content of theorem 2 in morris and peres @xcite : suppose that @xmath716 for some @xmath717 $ ] and all @xmath718 .
let @xmath122 and @xmath719 .
if @xmath80 is so large that @xmath720}^{4/\epsilon}\frac4{u\phi(u)^2}{\text{\rm d}\mkern0.5mu}u,\ ] ] then @xmath721 equipped with this powerful result , we are now ready to complete the proof of proposition [ propa.1 ] : proof of proposition [ propa.1 ] first we will prove the desired bound for even times .
fix @xmath198 and let @xmath722 be the random walk on @xmath43 observed only at even times . for each @xmath131 ,
let us use @xmath706 to denote the transition probability @xmath723 .
let @xmath724 denote the degree of @xmath11 on @xmath43 .
then @xmath707 is an invariant measure of this chain .
moreover , by our restriction to even times we have @xmath725 and so ( [ a.5][a.6 ] ) can be applied . by lemma [ lemmaa.2 ]
we have that @xmath726 for some @xmath727 and all sets @xmath220 of the form @xmath728^d$ ] for @xmath729 .
hence @xmath730 for some finite @xmath731 .
plugging into the integral and using that @xmath707 is bounded , we find that if @xmath732 , then holds . here
@xmath733 is a positive constant that may depend on @xmath25 .
choosing the minimal @xmath80 possible , and applying @xmath734 , the bound proves the desired claim for all even times . to extend the result to odd times
, we apply the markov property at time one .
next we will attend to the gaussian - tail bound .
given the random variables @xmath735 from ( [ a.10][sxtail ] ) , define random variables @xmath612 by @xmath736 here is a restatement of the corresponding bound from theorem [ thm6.3a ] : [ propa.3 ] let @xmath1 and @xmath53 .
there exist constants @xmath611 such that for all @xmath41 , all @xmath403 , all @xmath613 and all @xmath737 , @xmath738 proof the proof is an adaptation of barlow s theorem 1 to the discrete setting .
let @xmath48 be the discrete time random walk , and let @xmath687 be the continuous time random walk with jumps occurring at rate @xmath739 , both started at @xmath11 .
we consider the coupling of the two walks such that they make the same moves .
we will use @xmath606 and @xmath740 to denote the coupling measure and the corresponding expectation , respectively .
let @xmath741 and let @xmath742 be the event that @xmath743 .
pick @xmath744 and let @xmath745 be the amount of time in @xmath746 $ ] that the walk @xmath747 spends at distance larger than @xmath748 from @xmath11 . by the inequality
@xmath749 it suffices to derive an appropriate upper bound on @xmath750 and a matching lower bound on @xmath751 .
note that we may assume that @xmath752 because otherwise we have @xmath753 and there is nothing to prove . to derive an upper bound on @xmath750
, we note that for @xmath754 , our choice @xmath741 implies @xmath693 .
the expectation can then be bounded using : @xmath755 where @xmath756 and @xmath757 are constants ( possibly depending on @xmath412 ) .
it thus remains to prove that , for some constant @xmath758 , @xmath759 to derive this inequality , let us recall that the transitions of @xmath689 happen at rate one , and they are independent of the path of the walk . hence ,
if @xmath760 is the event that @xmath689 attempted at least @xmath80 jumps by time @xmath761 , then @xmath762 is bounded away from zero for all @xmath245 .
therefore , it suffices to prove that @xmath763 .
let @xmath227 be the first time when the walk @xmath747 is farther from @xmath11 than @xmath702 .
on @xmath764 , this happens before time @xmath761 , i.e. , @xmath765 .
let @xmath766^d\cap{\mathbb z}^d$ ] and @xmath767^d\cap{\mathbb z}^d$ ] .
then for values @xmath768 on the external boundary of @xmath769which are those that @xmath770 can take the bound tells us @xmath771 provided that @xmath772 . but our assumptions @xmath741 and @xmath752 imply @xmath773 , and so in light of the fact that @xmath774 on @xmath764 , actually holds for all @xmath587 such that @xmath775 $ ] .
plugging @xmath770 for @xmath768 on the left - hand side and taking expectation gets us an upper bound on @xmath776with @xmath587 now playing the role of @xmath777 .
hence , @xmath778 choosing @xmath412 sufficiently large , the right - hand side grows linearly in @xmath80 .
proof of theorem [ thm6.3a ] part ( 1 ) is a direct consequence of proposition [ propa.1 ] , while part ( 2 ) follows from proposition [ propa.3 ] and the fact that if the @xmath695 have stretched exponential tails ( uniformly in @xmath11 ) , then so do the @xmath779 s .
while our control of the corrector in @xmath79 is sufficient to push the proof of the functional clt through , it is not sufficient to provide the _ conceptually correct _ proof of the kind we have constructed for @xmath85 . however , we do not see any reason why @xmath79 should be different from @xmath85 , so our first conjecture is : [ conj : cor_small ] theorem [ thm5.1 ] is true in all @xmath1 .
our proof of theorem [ thm5.1 ] in @xmath85 hinged on the fact that the corrector plus the position is a harmonic function on the percolation cluster . of interest is the question whether harmonicity is an essential ingredient or just mere convenience .
yuval peres suggested the following generalization of conjecture [ conj : cor_small ] : [ ques : yuval ] let @xmath780 be a shift invariant , ergodic process on @xmath0 whose gradients are in @xmath392 and have expectation zero .
is it true that @xmath781^d}\,\bigl|f(x)\bigr| = 0\ ] ] almost surely ?
_ update _ : the above question , while obviously true in @xmath782 , has a negative answer in all @xmath1 . the first counterexample , based on constructions in @xcite and @xcite , was provided to us by martin zerner .
later tom liggett pointed out the following , embarrassingly simple , counterexample : let @xmath783 be i.i.d . with distribution function @xmath784 for @xmath785 .
then @xmath786 is shift - invariant , ergodic , with @xmath397 and the gradients of @xmath111 having zero mean , yet @xmath787 has a non - trivial distributional limit as @xmath658 . the harmonic embedding of @xmath28 has been indispensable for our proofs , but it also appears to be a very interesting object in its own right .
this motivates many questions about the corrector @xmath83 .
unfortunately , at the moment it is not even clear what properties make the corrector unique .
the following question has been asked by scott sheffield : is it true that , for a.e .
@xmath41 , there exists only one vector - valued function @xmath555 on @xmath43 such that @xmath187 is harmonic on @xmath43 , @xmath788 and @xmath789 as @xmath790 ?
if this question is answered in the affirmative , we could generate the corrector by its finite - volume approximations ( this would also fully justify fig . [ fig1 ] ) .
if we restrict ourselves to functions that have the shift - invariance property , uniqueness can presumably be shown using the `` electrostatic methods '' from , e.g. , @xcite .
however , it is not clear whether holds for the corrector defined by the thermodynamic limit from finite boxes . as to the more detailed properties of the corrector , for the purposes of the present work one would like to know how @xmath83 scales with @xmath11 and whether it has a well - defined scaling limit .
we believe that , in sufficiently high dimension , the corrector is actually tight : [ conj4 ] let @xmath791 .
then for each @xmath122 there exists @xmath409 such that @xmath792 for all @xmath29 .
it appears that one might be able to prove conjecture [ conj4 ] by using barlow s heat - kernel estimates . to capture the behavior in low dimensions ,
we make a somewhat wilder guess : [ conj5 ] let @xmath78
. then the law of @xmath793 on compact subsets of @xmath81 converges weakly ( as @xmath166 ) to gaussian free field , i.e. , a multivariate gaussian field with covariance proportional to @xmath794 , where @xmath483 is the dirichlet laplacian on @xmath81 and @xmath795 is the @xmath7-dimensional unit matrix .
here is a heuristic reasoning that led us to these conjectures : consider the problem of random conductances to avoid problems with conditioning on containment in the infinite cluster . to show the above convergence , we need that for any smooth @xmath796 with compact support , @xmath797 where @xmath798 and @xmath483 denote the ( continuous ) gradient and laplacian , respectively , and where @xmath799 is a mean - zero , covariance-@xmath370 multivariate normal random variable .
next we note that the corrector is defined , more or less , as the solution to the equation @xmath800 , where @xmath120 is the local drift and @xmath801 is the relevant generator , which is basically a discrete laplacian on @xmath0 . thus
, if @xmath802 is smooth with compact support and @xmath803 , then @xmath804 the convergence statement would then follow from provided we can replace the `` discretized '' laplacian @xmath805 by its continuous counterpart @xmath806 .
note that for @xmath782 and conductances bounded away from zero , conjecture [ conj5 ] is actually a theorem .
indeed , the corrector is a random walk with increments given by reciprocal conductances and so the convergence follows by the invariance principle for random walks .
conjecture [ conj5 ] suggests that conjecture [ conj4 ] applies for @xmath79 . despite the emphasis on the harmonic embedding of @xmath28 ,
our proofs used , quite significantly , the underlying group structure of @xmath0 ; e.g. , in sect .
[ sec : sec4 ] .
presumably this will not prevent application of our method to other regular lattices , but for more irregular graphs , e.g. , voronoi percolation in @xmath81 , significant changes may be necessary .
a similar discussion applies to various natural subdomains of @xmath0 ; for instance , it is not clear how to adapt our proof to random walk on the infinite percolation cluster in the half - space @xmath807 .
a different direction of generalizations are the models of _ long - range _ percolation with power - law decay of bond probabilities . here
we conjecture : [ conj : stable ] let @xmath78 and consider long - range percolation obtained by adding to @xmath0 a bond between every two distinct sites @xmath808 independently with probability proportional to @xmath809 .
if @xmath810 , then the corresponding random walk scales to a symmetric @xmath811-stable levy process in @xmath81 .
note that , according to this conjecture , in @xmath782 , the interval @xmath810 of `` interesting '' exponents is larger than the interval for which an infinite connected component may occur even without the `` help '' of nearest neighbor connections . on the other hand , in dimensions @xmath79 , the interval conjectured for stable convergence is strictly smaller than that of `` genuine '' long - range percolation behavior , as defined , e.g. , in terms of the scaling of graph distance with euclidean distance ; cf @xcite .
the research of m.b . was supported by the nsf grant dms-0306167 .
part of the research was performed while n.b .
visited eth - fim and m.b .
visited microsoft research in redmond .
we wish to thank these institutions for their hospitality and financial support .
we are also grateful to g.y .
amir , a. de masi , a. dembo , p. ferrari , t. liggett , s. olla , y. peres , o. schramm , s. sheffield , v. sidoravicius , a .- s .
sznitman and m.p.w .
zerner for interesting and useful discussions at various stages of this project .
a. de masi , p.a .
ferrari , s. goldstein and w.d . wick ( 1985 ) .
invariance principle for reversible markov processes with application to diffusion in the percolation regime . in : _
particle systems , random media and large deviations ( brunswick , maine ) _ , pp . 7185 , _ contemp . math .
_ , * 41 * , amer .
soc . , providence , ri .
a. de masi , p.a .
ferrari , s. goldstein and w.d . wick ( 1989 ) .
an invariance principle for reversible markov processes .
applications to random motions in random environments .
_ j. statist .
* 55 * , no . 3 - 4 , 787855 .
r. durrett ( 2005 ) .
_ probability : theory and examples _ ( third edition ) , brooks / cole thomson learning , belmont , ca .
ethier and t.g .
kurtz ( 1986 ) .
_ markov processes
. characterization and convergence_. wiley series in probability and mathematical statistics .
john wiley & sons , inc .
, new york .
d. levin and y. peres ( 1999 ) .
energy and cutsets in infinite percolation clusters . in : _ random walks and discrete potential theory ( cortona , 1997 ) _ , pp .
265278 , sympos .
xxxix , cambridge univ . press ,
cambridge .
g. papanicolau and s.r.s .
varadhan ( 1979 ) .
_ boundary value problems with rapidly oscillating random coefficients_. colloquia mathematica sociatatis jnos bolay , vol
random fields , esztergom ( hungary ) , pp . 835 - 873 . | we consider the simple random walk on the ( unique ) infinite cluster of super - critical bond percolation in @xmath0 with @xmath1 .
we prove that , for almost every percolation configuration , the path distribution of the walk converges weakly to that of non - degenerate , isotropic brownian motion .
our analysis is based on the consideration of a harmonic deformation of the infinite cluster on which the random walk becomes a square - integrable martingale .
the size of the deformation , expressed by the so called corrector , is estimated by means of ergodicity arguments .
= 1 |
the validity of the optically thin approximation for coronal plasma has been discussed in the literature since the beginnings of solar x - ray and euv spectroscopy ( pottasch 1963 , and references therein ) .
resonance scattering of @xmath015.01 ( @xmath1 , known as `` 3c '' ) , in particular , has been the subject of a long - standing controversy .
observations of the ratio of the 3c flux to that of @xmath015.26 ( @xmath2 , known as `` 3d '' ) gave ratios in the range 1.6 to 2.3 ( rugge & mckenzie 1985 ; schmelz 1997 ; saba 1999 ) , whereas collisional radiative models predicted a ratio of about four ( smith 1985 ; loulergue & nussbaumer 1973 ; bhatia & doschek 1992 ; cornille 1994 ) .
schmelz and saba also found , using the flat crystal spectrometer ( fcs ) on the _ solar maximum mission _ , that the lowest values were preferentially at the solar limb .
this center - to - limb effect bolstered the argument for resonance scattering of @xmath015.01 , given that the limb photons traverse a longer path ( _ cf , _ phillips 1996 ) .
significant new results have recently come to light : laboratory measurements from the electron beam ion trap ( ebit ) at lawrence livermore national laboratory found the 3c/3d flux ratio to be 3.04 @xmath3 0.12 ( brown et al .
1998 ) . using the national institute of standards and technology ebit , laming et al .
( 2000 ) confirmed the value to be close to three .
individual measurements at different beam energies from the two groups span a range from 2.50 to 3.15 .
these measurements imply that the amount of resonance scattering was overestimated in the solar analyses described above .
furthermore , new theoretical models are converging toward a ratio closer to three ( e.g. doron & behar 2002 ; chen & pradhan 2002 ; gu 2003 ) , though all published models continue to exceed the measurements by at least 10% .
new dirac r - matrix calculation show excellent agreement with the ebit measurements ( chen 2005 ; chen & pradhan 2005 ) .
brown ( 2001 ) have also reported on experiments in which a steady stream of neutral iron was injected into the ebit , producing an underionized plasma with both and .
they found 3c/3d flux ratios as low as 1.9 @xmath3 0.11 , and argued that contamination of @xmath015.26 by the inner - shell line ( @xmath4 ) could account for the discrepancy between the laboratory ratio for a pure fe xvii plasma and the solar spectra .
blending as an explanation for the solar results presumably implies that the center - to - limb effect in the solar data is due to chance .
new observations of stellar coronae have not confirmed the solar line ratios .
spectra for many stars observed with _
chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ yield a 3c/3d ratio of about three ( ness et al . 2003 ; audard et al .
2004 ; gdel et al . 2004 ) , suggesting that stellar coronae do _ not _ generally show resonance scattering ( but see testa 2004 and matranga 2005 ) .
full - star observations can not rule out resonance scattering in individual active regions , however , since the number of photons scattered out of the line of sight could be offset by a similar number of photons scattered into the line of sight .
furthermore , the sample of stars does not include stars with coronae in the solar coronal temperature range ( 24 mk ) , such as @xmath5 centauri or procyon , for which blending with might be expected .
these new experimental , theoretical , and observational results motivate us to re - investigate solar observations from the flat crystal spectrometer on the _ solar maximum mission . _
the reanalysis of these data , using new atomic data , is presented in 2 . in
3 we consider the implications of our results . in particular , we find that resonance scattering is not responsible for the fuzziness seen in the solar images obtained with the 284 passband of the _ transition region and coronal explorer _ ( ) and the euv imaging telescope ( eit ) on the _ solar and heliospheric observatory _ ( ) .
the data analyzed here were obtained with the fcs ( acton 1980 ) and are discussed in detail in earlier papers ( schmelz 1997 ; saba 1999 ) . the instrument had a 15 arcsec field - of - view and could scan the soft x - ray resonance lines of prominent ions in the range of 1.5 to 20.0 with a spectral resolution of 0.015 at 15 . in this letter , we reanalyze the lines from 31 of the 33 spectral scans from quiescent active regions ( i @xmath014.21 could not be measured in two of these spectra
see below ) .
figure 1 shows the portion of a typical fcs spectrum containing the lines of interest .
spectra where plasma conditions were changing significantly with time were excluded from the sample .
the top panel of figure 2 shows the observed 3c/3d line ratio as a function of temperature .
the flux ratio of i @xmath014.21 to @xmath016.78 provides a good temperature diagnostic , with its high signal - to - noise ratio and abundance - insensitivity .
calculations using the astrophysical plasma emission code ( apec ) version 1.3 ( smith et al .
2001 ) give the temperatures for each of the individual measured flux ratios .
the apec emissivities incorporate the ionization balance models of mazzotta et al .
models for the other strong lines , @xmath017.05 and @xmath017.10 , are less certain than for @xmath016.78 , since these lines have a larger contribution from dielectronic recombination and resulting cascades ( see gu 2003 ) , and hence are more dependent on the ionization state model . the and g - ratios ( i.e. the ratios of the sum of the forbidden plus intercombination line fluxes to the flux of the resonance line ) are also temperature - dependent , but are of lower signal - to - noise ratio due to the weakness of the intercombination lines .
most of the observed 3c/3d ratios are clustered , with significantly less than the average laboratory value of 2.9 ; however , two of the three highest temperature measurements also give higher 3c/3d ratios , within 1@xmath6 of 2.9 .
moreover , the best - fit line to these data shows a strong temperature - dependence , inconsistent with calculations ( gu 2003 ) , while the flux ratio of 3c to @xmath016.78 ( middle panel ) shows only modest temperature - dependence as expected from calculations
. these results strongly suggest blending of @xmath015.26 . in the underionized ebit plasma , brown et al .
( 2001 ) also measure a second inner - shell line at 15.21 ( @xmath7 ) .
we identify this line for the first time in an active region spectrum , and use it to estimate the strength of the blend at 15.26 .
calculations from the hebrew university lawrence livermore atomic code ( hullac ) , which will be available in the next apec release , give a scaling factor of 0.83 ( d. liedahl , private communication ) .
we note that this scaling factor is significantly higher than the factor of 0.5 recommended by brown et al .
( 2001 ) based on multiconfigurational dirac - fock calculations , primarily due to a large difference in the branching ratio between radiative decay and autoionization for @xmath015.21 .
the bottom panel of figure 2 shows the line ratios that result after subtracting the @xmath015.26 blend , using @xmath015.21 as a proxy to determine its flux .
the weighted mean of this distribution is 2.76 @xmath3 0.23 , statistically indistinguishable from the laboratory ratio .
while the @xmath015.21 proxy is , to our knowledge , unblended at temperatures below 5 @xmath8 k , its use for hotter plasmas is complicated by the presence of @xmath015.20 ( e.g. the _ chandra _ spectrum of capella , desai et al . 2005 ) .
it seems likely that the line tentatively identified in the flare spectrum by phillips et al .
( 1982 ) as may be dominated by as well . in light of this new analysis
, we reconsider other examples of full - sun x - ray spectra which include @xmath015.01 and @xmath015.26 . in particular
, we expect active region measurements to show lower line ratios and flare spectra to approach the laboratory value .
indeed active region measurements show lower 3c/3d values ( blake 1965 ; evans & pounds 1968 ; walker 1974 ) , whereas flare spectra ( e.g. neupert 1973 ) give higher values .
these results are thus consistent with blending at 15.26 in the low - temperature active region spectra .
they also suggest that a reduced ratio might be observed also in high signal - to - noise ratio , high resolution spectra of stars with cooler coronae .
resonance scattering has been suggested as one of the reasons for the fuzzy appearance of the images obtained from the 284 passband of and -eit , illustrated in figure 3 . in this section ,
we discuss possible explanations of the 284-fuzziness and estimate the upper limit for the resonance scattering contribution to this fuzziness .
a common explanation for the fuzzy appearance of the and eit 284 images is instrument scattering ; however , measurements of the 284 point spread function are identical to those of the 171- and 195 passbands , which show much cleaner images ( golub et al .
furthermore , prominences seen in absorption have sharp edges in the 284 images ( fig . 3 , lower panel ) , demonstrating that the instrument can resolve fine structures .
a second candidate explanation is contamination of @xmath0304 photons in the passband .
this contamination certainly exists for coronal holes , which do not appear dark ( as they do , for example , in the thin aluminum images from the soft x - ray telescope on ) ; however , there should be no significant @xmath0304-contribution in active region areas because of the higher temperatures , or above the solar limb where the scale height of @xmath0304 is too small .
resonance scattering has also been suggested as the cause of the 284 fuzziness .
the @xmath015.01 result allows us to estimate the contribution of resonance scattering to @xmath0284.2 . using chen s ( 2005 )
calculated 3c/3d ratio of 2.85 at @xmath9 6.4 , and the observed fcs ratio of 2.76 @xmath3 0.21 gives an escape probability of 2.76/2.85 , corresponding to @xmath10 .
following acton ( 1978 ) , @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is the oscillator strength , @xmath13 is the ionization fraction ( which is a function of temperature ) , and @xmath0 is the wavelength . solving for @xmath14 , with the ionization balance at @xmath9 6.4 , gives this corresponds to an escape probability of 92% , which indicates that very few photons are available to contribute to the 284 - image fuzziness . for possible uncertainties of 10 to 15 % in experimental and theoretical 3c/3d ratios , the escape probability ranges from 0.84 to 1.0 , for @xmath17 .
using the same argument , with the relative coronal abundances of fludra & schmelz ( 1999 ) , we find that the @xmath018.97 opacity is comparable to that of @xmath015.01 , while the opacities of @xmath013.46 and @xmath09.17 are 2 to 3 times lower , confirming the findings of schmelz et al .
( 1997 ) that these important diagnostics are not contaminated for use in emission measure distribution analysis .
the assumed temperature @xmath18 , estimated from the measured ratios of @xmath014.21 to @xmath016.78 , can be further constrained by the laboratory measurements .
the experimental 3c/3d ratio was measured as a function of the abundance ratio of to , providing a good fit to the theoretical predictions .
the experimental plasma is not in collisional ionization equilibrium , due to the continuous ionization from neutral iron up to the charge states of interest , and moreover , the collisional processes are excited by a narrow beam rather than a maxwellian distribution as assumed for the solar coronal plasma .
thus , an interpretation of the experimental line ratio in terms of an ionization equilibrium temperature is not strictly valid , since the resonance excitation contributions will not be identical .
nevertheless , this estimate can give a consistency check on the population .
for the laboratory value where the populations of and are equal , the 3c/3d ratio is 1.90 @xmath3 0.11 ( brown et al .
2001 ) , slightly below the average of the cluster .
thus the diagnostics all appear consistent with each other in the blending scenario . in collisional ionization equilibrium
, such a ratio corresponds to @xmath19 6.32 . for this lower temperature , @xmath20 is about 3 times larger ; however , chen s ( 2005 ) predicted line ratio is about 5% less , such that our average value puts @xmath21 essentially at zero , with an upper limit below 0.2 .
meanwhile , loop differential emission measure ( dem ) distributions tend to be fairly flat - topped between @xmath9 6.3 and 6.4 ( e.g. schmelz et al .
2001 ) , such that an intermediate value seems most reliable for estimating the @xmath20 ratio .
we then find @xmath22 0.12 , with a plausible range from 0.0 to @xmath23 0.2 . for opacities in this range , the model images of wood & raymond ( 2000 ) still retain the appearance of loops with sharp rather than blurred boundaries .
we refer to the last candidate explanation for the 284 - fuzziness as the `` filling - factor '' model , which is related to the observational result that coronal structures appear fuzzy if they are not resolved by the instrument ( see fig . 3 of deluca et al . 2005 ) .
it is well established that the dem of active region and quiet sun plasma peaks between 2 and 3 mk .
in other words , more higher temperature ( 284 ) plasma exists along the line of sight than cooler ( 171 ) plasma , such that the piling up of structures along the line of sight may contribute to the fuzziness factor . in the 171- band ( @xmath241 mk ) , the 0.5-arcsec resolution of revealed substantial substructure that had never been seen before ; in the 284- band ( @xmath2423 mk ) , the spatial resolution does not appear to be quite sufficient .
an additional factor of two improvement in spatial resolution may be adequate , but 0.1-arcsec pixel size is technically feasible and seems preferable .
we conclude , therefore , that the filling - factor model provides the most likely explanation for the 284-image fuzziness , and thus future instruments with higher spatial resolution may be able to resolve the active region plasma into its component structures .
efforts to understand the coronal heating process should benefit from resolved images closer to the temperature at which the dominant heating occurs .
we would like to thank j. saba , k. nasraoui , d. liedahl , l. golub , and j. cirtain .
solar physics research at the university of memphis is supported by nsf atm-0402729 and nasa nng05ge68 g .
n. b. was supported by nasa contract nas8 - 39073 to the smithsonian astrophysical observatory for the chandra x - ray center .
acton , l. w. 1978 , , 225 , 1069 acton , l. w. 1980 , , 65 , 53 audard , m. , telleschi , a. , gdel , m. , skinner , s. l. , pallavicini , r. , & mitra - kraev , u. 2004 , , 617 , 531 bhatia , a. k. & doschek , g. a. 1992 , atomic data nuclear data , 52 , 1 blake , r. l. , chubb , t. a. , friedman , h. , unzicker , a. e. 1965 , , 142 , 1 brown , g. v. , beiersdorfer , p. , chen , h. , chen , m. h. , reed , k. j. 2001 , , 557 , l75 brown , g. v. , beiersdorfer , p. , liedahl , d. a. , widmann , k. , kahn , s. m. 1998 , , 502 , 1015 chen , g .- x .
2005 , submitted chen , g. x. , & pradhan , a. k. 2002 , , 89 , 13202 chen , g. x. , & pradhan , a. k. 2005 , mnras , submitted cornille , m. , dubau , j. , faucher , p. , bely - dubau , f. , & blancard , c. 1994 , , 1 , 1 deluca , e.e . , weber , m.a . , sette , a.l . , golub , l. , shibasaki , k. , sakao , t. & kano , r. 2005 , adv .
space res .
, in press desai , p. et al .
2005 , , 625 , l59 doron , r. & behar , e. 2002 , , 574 , 518 evans , k. & pounds , k. a. 1968 , , 152 , 319 fludra , a. & schmelz , j. t. ( 1999 ) , a&a , 348 , 286 golub , l. et al . 1999 , phys .
plasmas , 6 , 2205 gu , m .- f .
2003 , , 582 , 1241 gdel , m. , audard , m. , reale , f. , skinner , s. l. , linsky , j. l. 2004 , , 416 , 713 laming , j. m. 2000 , , 545 , l161 loulergue , m. & nussbaumer , h. 1973 , , 45 , 125 matranga , m. , mathioudakis , m. , kay , h. r. m. , & keenan , f. p. 2005
, , 621 , l125 mazzotta , p. , mazzitelli , g. , colafrancesco , s. , & vittorio , n. 1998 , , 133 , 403 ness , j .- u . , schmitt , j. h. m. m. , audard , m. j. , gdel , m. , & mewe , r. 2003 , , 407 , 347 neupert , w.m . , swartz , m. , kastner , s o. 1973 , , 31 , 171 phillips , k. j. h. , greer , c. j. , bhatia , a. k. , keenan , f. p. 1996
, , 469 , l57 phillips , k. j. h. et al .
1982 , , 256 , 774 pottasch , s. r. 1963 , , 137 , 945 rugge , h. r. & mckenzie , d. l. 1985 , , 297 , 338 saba , j. l. r. , schmelz , j. t. , bhatia , a. k. , & strong , k. t. 1999 , , 510 , 1064 schmelz , j. t. , saba , j. l. r. , chauvin , j. c. , & strong , k. t. 1997 , , 477 , 509 schmelz , j. t. , scopes , r. t. , cirtain , j. w. , winter , h. d. , & allen , j. d. 2001 , , 556 , 896 smith , b. w. , raymond , j. c. , mann , j. b. , & cowan , r. d. 1985 , , 298 , 898 smith , r. k. , brickhouse , n. s. , liedahl , d. a. , & raymond , j. c. 2001 , , 556 , l91 testa , p. , drake , j. j. , peres , g. , & deluca , e. e. 2004 , , 609 , l79 walker , a. b. c. , rugge , h. r. , weiss , k. 1974 , , 194 , 471 wood , k. , & raymond , j. c. 2000 , , 540 , 563 14.21 to @xmath016.78 ) . the dotted line shows the best flat fit and the dashed line shows the best linear fit ; ( _ upper _ ) 3c/3d ratio with flat ( @xmath25 ) and linear ( @xmath26 ) fits ; ( _ middle _ ) @[email protected] ratio with flat ( @xmath27 ) and linear ( @xmath28 ) fits ; ( _ lower _ ) same as ( _ upper _ ) except that 0.83 times the @xmath015.21 flux has been subtracted from @xmath015.26 flux for all but the three hottest spectra with flat ( @xmath29 ) and linear ( @xmath30 ) fits.,width=288 ] | resonance scattering has often been invoked to explain the disagreement between the observed and predicted line ratios of @xmath015.01 to @xmath015.26 ( the `` 3c/3d '' ratio ) . in this
process photons of @xmath015.01 , with its much higher oscillator strength , are preferentially scattered out of the line of sight , thus reducing the observed line ratio .
recent laboratory measurements , however , have found significant inner - shell lines at 15.21 and 15.26 , suggesting that the observed 3c/3d ratio results from blending . given our new understanding of the fundamental spectroscopy
, we have re - examined the original solar spectra , identifying the @xmath015.21 line and measuring its flux to account for the contribution of to the @xmath015.26 flux .
deblending brings the 3c/3d ratio into good agreement with the experimental ratio ; hence , we find no need to invoke resonance scattering .
low opacity in @xmath015.01 also implies low opacity for fe xv @xmath0284.2 , ruling out resonance scattering as the cause of the fuzziness of and -eit 284 images .
the images must , instead , be unresolved due to the large number of structures at this temperature .
insignificant resonance scattering implies that future instruments with higher spatial resolution could resolve the active region plasma into its component loop structures . |
hadronic properties at finite temperature and baryon density are of great importance in the phenomenology of heavy ions collisions , star interior and the early universe .
moreover , the theoretical expectation of transitions to a chirally symmetric phase and , perhaps , to a quark - gluon plasma phase contributes to the interest in studying the effect of matter and temperature on the quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) vacuum .
our present understanding of qcd at finite temperature ( @xmath0 ) and baryon density ( or chemical potential @xmath1 ) is mainly limited in the euclidean realm , due to the lack of non - perturbative and systematic calculating tools directly in the minkowski space .
typical methods , with qcd lagrangian as the starting point , are the ope and lattice simulations . because these two formulations are intrinsically euclidean , only static quantities are conveniently studied . in order to gain dynamical informations , which are more accessible
experimentally , the analytic structure implemented through dispersion relations often have to be invoked within the theory of linear response . in principle
, dispersion relations allow the determination of the spectral function ( sf ) , which carries all the real - time information , from the corresponding correlator in the euclidean region . in practice ,
realistic calculations , e.g. ope or lattice simulations , yield only partial information on the correlators , making impossible a direct inversion of the dispersion relation .
therefore , the standard approach assumes a phenomenological motivated functional form with several parameters for the sf , and uses the information from the approximate correlator , mediated by the dispersion relation , only to determine the value of parameters by a fit .
this approach has been quite successful at zero temperature and density , thanks to the fortuitous situation that we roughly know how to parameterize the sf s in many cases .
two important examples are the qcd sum rules pioneered by shifman , vainshtein and zakharov @xcite , and the analysis of lattice qcd data @xcite .
so far , standard parameterizations have included poles plus perturbative continuum @xcite .
the success of such approaches heavily rests on our good understanding of the qualitative behavior of sf s at zero @xmath2 .
we can find other such favorable examples in the low-@xmath0 regime @xcite , where the shape of the sf has the same qualitatively features of the zero @xmath2 case , or even in the high-@xmath0 regime for simple models @xcite , for which the functional form of the sf is known .
the qcd sum rules approach has been extended also to systems at finite temperature @xcite .
the lack of experimental data , and of reliable nonperturbative calculations has prompted people to use the same kind of parameterizations that have worked so well at zero temperature with , at most , perturbative corrections .
we believe that physical results at finite @xmath2 can be strongly biased by this assumption .
in fact , recent interpretations of lattice simulation data @xcite appear to indicate the existence of such problems .
the purpose of this work is to derive exact sum rules that constrain the variation of sf s with @xmath2 .
in addition , we apply these sum rules to the chiral phase transition , and demonstrate that sf s in some channels are drastically modified compared to both their zero @xmath2 and their perturbative shapes .
this result confirm our worries about non - trivial effect of finite @xmath0 or baryon density on the shape of the sf .
our derivation of these exact sum rules , based on the ope and the rge , has a closer relation with the derivation of sum rules for deep inelastic scatterings than with the qcd sum rule approach of svz @xcite . in fact
, we establish relationships between moments of the sf and corresponding condensates as functions of @xmath2 , without assuming any functional form of the sf . in the derivation process
, we find that the logarithmic corrections are essential to establish the exact sum rules .
in contrast , the qcd logarithmic corrections are only marginally relevant in the finite energy sum rules , and hence are rarely discussed in the literature . to properly take into account the logarithmic corrections , a repeated partial integration method is used to match the relevant asymptotic expansions .
since no further assumptions other than the validity of the ope and rge are involved in the derivation , our sum rules are very general and can be applied anywhere in the @xmath2-plane , even near or at the boundary of a phase transition .
the paper is organized as follows . in section
ii we present the general derivation of exact sum rules in asymptotically free theories .
the matching of asymptotic behaviors of the correlator and the dispersion integral , including explicitly their logarithmic corrections , are carefully discussed . in section iii
we illustrate each single step of the derivation in a soluble model , the gross - neveu model in the large-@xmath3 limit .
in this model we can calculate exactly all the relevant quantities ( spectral functions , wilson coefficients , condensates , anomalous dimensions and correlators in space - like region , etc . ) , and , therefore , give a concrete example of how our method works .
the application of our method to the derivation of exact sum rules for the mesonic channels in qcd is presented in section iv . in the same section
, we also discuss the phenomenological consequences of the exact sum rules near chiral restoration phase transitions .
finally , in section v we summarize our work , draw some conclusions , and discuss possible future directions .
we start this section with a short review of the linear response theory , the ope and the rge .
next we introduce a convenient subtraction in the dispersion relation for studying the dependence of sf s on @xmath0 and @xmath1 . then , we present in detail a crucial part of our method : how to match the asymptotic ope expansion with a corresponding asymptotic expansion of the sf and its dispersion integral .
this approach is necessary for properly taking into account the logarithmic corrections , and studying the convergence properties of the relevant moments of the sf .
more naive approaches not only yield , in general , incorrect sum rules , but might also fail to recognize that a given sum rule does not exist in the first place , since the integral of the sf involved is divergent . finally , a comparison of the two asymptotic expansions leads to the desired exact sum rules .
we end this section with some general comments on the derivation and meaning of these sum rules .
the real - time linear response @xcite to an external source , @xmath4 , coupled to a renormalized current @xmath5 in the form of @xmath6 is given by the retarded correlator : @xmath7\rangle_{t,\mu}\ , , \label{corr}\ ] ] where the average is on the grand canonical ensemble specified by temperature @xmath0 and chemical potential @xmath1 .
disregarding possible subtraction terms , which are @xmath2-independent since they are related to short distance properties of the theory , we can write the following dispersion relation for the frequency dependence of the retarded correlation function : @xmath8 for convenience , we discuss only the uniform limit ( @xmath9 ) and , from now on , drop the momentum label .
we wish to emphasize that , even if the derivation of the sum rules requires the analytic continuation of eq .
( [ disp ] ) into the euclidean region ( @xmath10 ) , the dispersion integral is , nevertheless , determined by the singularities of @xmath11 in the minkowski region .
one should keep clearly in mind the distinction between these real - time singularities with the ones related to screening phenomena . in asymptotically free theories ,
the correlator @xmath12 is calculable in terms of the ope @xcite asymptotic series in the limit of @xmath13 . for a given renormalization prescription
, the asymptotic expansion reads @xmath14_\kappa\rangle_{t,\mu } \
, , \ ] ] where @xmath15 , @xmath16 , the @xmath17_\kappa$ ] s and the @xmath18 s are , respectively , the current quark mass , the coupling constant , the renormalized composite operators , and their corresponding wilson coefficients at the subtraction scale @xmath19 . here and in the following , we use the symbol @xmath20 to denote asymptotic equality .
we explicitly singled out the perturbative term @xmath21 , which corresponds to the identity operator and , being independent of @xmath0 and @xmath1 , is calculated at @xmath22 .
this term is the only one that is not suppressed by powers of @xmath23 and can depend on an overall subtraction scale , which we identify , for simplicity , with the same subtraction scale @xmath19 used in the renormalization of the operators .
it is important to note that the information of the ensemble average is encoded in the matrix elements of composite operators , while the wilson coefficients , including @xmath24 , are independent of @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
although the matrix elements @xmath25_\kappa\rangle_{t,\mu}$ ] can not be determined perturbatively , the @xmath26-dependence of the wilson coefficient @xmath18 is controlled by the following renormalization group equation @xcite @xmath27 c_n(q^2,m^2(\kappa),g^2(\kappa),\kappa)=0 \ , , \ ] ] where @xmath28 [ rge ] and @xmath29 , @xmath30 and @xmath31 are the anomalous dimensions for the current @xmath32 , the operator @xmath33 and the current quark mass @xmath34 respectively . for the purpose of illustration , we are only considering operators that do not mix under renormalization , but the mixing will be properly taken into account when necessary .
the standard approach @xcite to the renormalization group equation is the introduction of a running coupling @xmath35 and a running mass @xmath36 . in asymptotically free theories @xmath35 vanishes
logarithmically at large @xmath26 .
it is therefore meaningful to consider , in this limit , a perturbative expansion of the renormalization group equation functions @xmath37 where @xmath38 , @xmath39 , @xmath34 , while @xmath40 , @xmath41 are pure numbers determined by a one - loop calculation . within this perturbative context , eq .
( [ rge ] ) can be solved @xcite : @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the canonical dimension of the composite operator @xmath33 minus the dimension of @xmath44 in units of a mass , and the @xmath45 s are calculable perturbatively .
corrections to this result coming from nonleading powers of @xmath46 in the expansions of the renormalization group equation functions , see eq .
( [ rgef ] ) , are analytic in @xmath47 and hence can be absorbed into @xmath48 .
therefore , the leading term in the large-@xmath26 limit is totally characterized by the one - loop structure of the theory . to study the temperature and chemical potential dependence of @xmath44 , we only need to consider the difference @xmath49 : @xmath50 where @xmath51 .
this subtraction is crucial to remove @xmath21 , which contains terms not suppressed by powers of @xmath23 and is explicitly dependent on the renormalization point .
the ope asymptotic expansion of @xmath49 is then @xmath52_\kappa\rangle \ , \label{dope}\ ] ] where @xmath53_\kappa\rangle$ ] denotes the difference of the expectation values of @xmath17_\kappa$ ] in the ensembles specified by @xmath2 and @xmath54 , respectively .
since the current quark mass only runs logarithmically in asymptotically free theories , we can safely ignore the corrections to the @xmath48 s due to their dependence on @xmath55 when in deep euclidean limit .
notice that the subtraction has made @xmath49 independent of the renormalization point @xmath19 , i.e. @xmath49 satisfies a homogeneous rge . since @xmath45 is perturbative and hence can be expanded in power of @xmath35 ( and denoting the first non - vanishing power as @xmath56 ) , the left - hand side of eq .
( [ ddisp ] ) can be expressed as a double ( in @xmath23 and @xmath35 ) asymptotic expansion of the form : @xmath57_\kappa\rangle}{q^{d_n } } [ g^2(q)]^{\nu+\eta_n}\ , , \label{asyope}\ ] ] where the exponents @xmath58 and the @xmath26-independent coefficients @xmath59 are again known perturbatively .
it is important to emphasize here that the leading term in @xmath35 for a given power of @xmath23 is controlled by the relevant anomalous dimensions .
we proceed by making an analogous asymptotic expansion of @xmath60 valid for @xmath61 with @xmath62 suitably large but otherwise arbitrary : @xmath63 with @xmath64^{-\xi_n}}{u^{2(n+1 ) } } \sum_{\nu=0}^\infty a_{n}^{(\nu)}(t,\mu ) [ \ln(u^2)]^{-\nu } \ , , \label{rholn}\ ] ] where we have explicitly isolated in @xmath65 all terms that vanish exponentially when @xmath66 , such as the pole contributions to @xmath60 or terms containing the factor @xmath67 . to simplify the notation we have chosen the units such that the running coupling has the form at one - loop level @xmath68 ( or equivalently , energy scales are measured in units of the relevant @xmath69-parameter ) .
this ansatz is sufficient to produce an asymptotic series of the form of eq .
( [ asyope ] ) to one - loop level .
more generally , one could replace @xmath70 with the full running coupling @xmath71 in the asymptotic sequence and generalize the method we are going to describe ; the general strategy involved in this generalization can be found , for example , in ref . @xcite .
since we are presently only interested in one - loop calculations , we can regard @xmath35 and @xmath72 to be proportional .
it is easy to recognize that the sum over `` @xmath39 '' is meant to match the sum over mass dimension in eq .
( [ asyope ] ) , while the sum over `` @xmath73 '' will match the sum over the order in perturbation series .
the existence of anomalous dimensions in the ope makes it necessary to introduce @xmath74 in the expansion for the spectral function . in the following
we ignore the dependence of @xmath74 on `` @xmath39 '' , as we have already ignored the fact that there generally exist more than one operator at a given dimension , and write @xmath75 to avoid a too cumbersome notation .
the complete notation will be restored when necessary .
before we proceed further , we wish to discuss whether it is possible that additional terms might appear in the expansion of @xmath76 in eq .
( [ rholn ] ) .
in general , our asymptotic expansion procedure is powerful enough to exclude this possibility within the framework of the ope .
in fact , it allows to verify unambiguously that terms different from the ones already present generate , when substituted in the dispersion integral , terms that are missing in the ope .
let us examine two specific examples that might be suspected to exist otherwise .
first , dimensional arguments could suggest terms like @xmath77 .
our procedure shows that any @xmath78 term in @xmath60 would generate a @xmath79 term in @xmath49 , which does not correspond to any known condensate , and it is therefore excluded .
the second example is given by terms such as @xmath80 , which are naturally produced by elementary perturbative calculations of the spectral function : are such terms present in eq .
( [ rholn ] ) ?
it is indeed true that such terms appear in the high-@xmath0 expansion of the spectral function at fixed @xmath81 .
however , the expansion of the spectral function that is relevant for comparing to the ope is a high-@xmath81 expansion at fixed @xmath0 . in the next section an explicit calculation in the gross - neveu model
will illustrate the general fact that , contrary to the high-@xmath0 expansion , the high-@xmath81 expansion does not generate terms like @xmath80 . at this stage , we can already recognize a fundamental , and often overlooked , characteristic of the spectral function .
if we insert the term @xmath65 in the dispersion integral , we only obtain pure powers of @xmath23 , since the exponential convergence allows a naive expansion of the factor @xmath82 ( watson s lemma @xcite ) .
therefore logarithmic corrections , i.e. powers of @xmath35 , come solely from the @xmath76 term . because we know that the running coupling @xmath35 is always present in the ope series , the term @xmath76 must be present in the subtracted sf , and it obviously dominates the asymptotic regime ( @xmath66 ) .
this fact immediately implies that only a finite number of moments of the subtracted sf can possibly be finite , i.e. the naive expansion of the factor @xmath82 is generally wrong , and that logarithmic corrections play a important role . a standard method to tackle the dispersion integral in the large-@xmath26 limit is the mellin transform .
however , the use of mellin transform methods @xcite is extremely cumbersome when logarithms appear in the denominator .
since inverse logarithms can not be avoided in the spectral function , we need to resort to other means .
we carry out the dispersion integral of the @xmath76 term by splitting the integral in eq .
( [ ddisp ] ) into three intervals : @xmath83 , @xmath84 and @xmath85 .
the integral over the first interval can be naively expanded in powers of @xmath23 , since there are no convergence problems : @xmath86 in particular , the leading term in @xmath23 is @xmath87 in the second interval , we use the asymptotic form of @xmath88 given in eq .
( [ rholn ] ) and obtain ( for instance by repeatedly integrating by parts ) @xmath89 where @xmath90 , and @xmath91 $ ] is the incomplete gamma function . notice that when @xmath92 the correct result for the term with @xmath93 is @xmath94 , which also corresponds to its limiting value : @xmath95/\alpha = \ln\frac{\ln q^2}{\ln\lambda^2}$ ] .
we then substitute in the second incomplete gamma function that appears in eq .
( [ int2 ] ) the following asymptotic expression which is valid for @xmath96 and @xmath97 : @xmath98\equiv\int_z^\infty dx\ , x^{\alpha-1 } e^{-x } \sim\ , z^{\alpha-1 } e^{-z}\sum_{m=0}^\infty { ( -1)^m\gamma(1-\alpha+m)\over
z^m\gamma(1-\alpha)}\ , .
\label{asygamma}\ ] ] the resulting expression for @xmath99 is @xmath100 \label{dk2asym } \\ & -&{1\over q^2}\sum_{n,\nu=0}^\infty { a_n^{(\nu)}\over q^{2n}}\biggl [ \sum_{l=0\atop l\neq n}^\infty \sum_{m=0}^\infty \frac{(-1)^{l+m } } { ( n - l)^{m+1}[\ln q^2]^{m+1-\alpha } } \frac{\gamma(m+1-\alpha)}{\gamma(1-\alpha)}- \frac{(-1)^n [ \ln q^2]^{\alpha}}{\alpha } \biggr]\ , , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where again @xmath101 and @xmath102 should be understood as @xmath103 and @xmath104 when @xmath105 .
let us notice that in the first line of eq .
( [ dk2asym ] ) any term with @xmath106 such that the integral @xmath107 is finite can be formally identified as @xmath108= \int_{\lambda^2}^\infty du^2\,u^{2l}\delta\rho_{\text{power}}(u)\ , .
\label{formom}\ ] ] in particular , the leading @xmath23 term in eq .
( [ dk2asym ] ) is @xmath109\\ & + & { 1\over q^2}\sum_{\nu=0}^\infty a_0^{(\nu)}\biggl [ \sum_{l=1}^\infty \sum_{m=0}^\infty \frac{(-1)^{l } } { l^{m+1}[\ln q^2]^{m+1-\alpha } } \frac{\gamma(m+1-\alpha)}{\gamma(1-\alpha)}+ \frac { [ \ln q^2]^{\alpha}}{\alpha } \biggr ] \label{int2asym } + { \cal o}\left(\frac{1}{q^4}\right ) \ , .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can similarly expand the integral over the third interval @xmath110^{m+1-\alpha } } { \gamma(m+1-\alpha)\over\gamma(1-\alpha ) } \nonumber \\ & \sim&\mbox{}-{1\over q^2 } \sum_{\nu=0}^\infty a_0^{(\nu ) } \sum_{l=1}^\infty \sum_{m=0}^\infty \frac{(-1)^{l+m } } { l^{m+1 } [ \ln q^2]^{m+1-\alpha } } { \gamma(m+1-\alpha)\over\gamma(1-\alpha ) } + { \cal o}\left(\frac{1}{q^4}\right ) \ , .
\label{int3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the end we add the leading @xmath23 contributions from eqs .
( [ int1asym ] ) , ( [ int2asym ] ) and ( [ int3 ] ) to the corresponding contribution from the naive expansion of @xmath111 and obtain @xmath112^{1-\xi}}{q^2 } \sum_{\nu=0}^\infty \frac{a_0^{(\nu)}}{[\ln q^2]^{\nu}}\biggl [ \frac{1}{1-\xi-\nu } \nonumber \\ & & \,\,\,\,\ , + 2\sum_{l=1\atop m=0}^\infty\frac{(-1)^l } { [ l\ , \ln q^2]^{2m+2 } } \frac{\gamma(2m+1+\nu+\xi)}{\gamma(\nu+\xi)}\biggr ] + { \cal o}\left(\frac{1}{q^4}\right)\ , , \label{leadqrho}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath113 is defined by @xmath114 since the integral @xmath115 can be finite only if @xmath116 , we can use eq .
( [ formom ] ) to identify @xmath113 as the zeroth moment of the subtracted spectral function , only when the asymptotic expansion of the subtracted sf in eq .
( [ rholn ] ) yields @xmath116 . otherwise , if @xmath117 , the zeroth moment is infinite , though @xmath113 as defined by eq .
( [ drhobar ] ) still exists .
we derive the sum rules by comparing the coefficient of @xmath23 in eq .
( [ leadqrho ] ) @xmath118^{1-\xi } } { \textstyle ( 1-\xi ) } \\[0.6 cm ] \ln(\ln q^2 ) \end{array } + { \cal o}\left({1\over q^2},{1\over[\ln q^2]^\xi}\right ) \quad \begin{array}{l } \mbox{if $ \xi\neq 1 $ } \\[0.6 cm ] \mbox{if $ \xi=1 $ } \end{array}\right . \label{leadingrh}\ ] ] and the corresponding coefficient in eqs .
( [ asyope ] ) @xmath119_\kappa\rangle [ g^2(q)]^{\eta } + { \cal o}\left(\frac{1}{q^2},[g^2(q)]^{\eta+1}\right ) \
, , \ ] ] where we are only considering cases with @xmath120 and @xmath121
. furthermore , we are presently interested in exact sum rules that can be derived with one - loop calculations and , therefore , we only compare leading orders in @xmath72 .
then there exist three possibilities , depending on the value of @xmath122 , which can be calculated using the ope .
\(1 ) if @xmath123 , then @xmath124 ( or a bigger integer ) and @xmath125_\kappa\rangle \ , .
\label{cons}\ ] ] this is the result one would get by naively expanding @xmath126 without worrying about the convergence of the moments and disregarding logarithmic corrections in the ope .
\(2 ) if @xmath127 , then @xmath128 and @xmath129 \(3 ) if @xmath130 ( positive powers of @xmath131 in eq .
( [ dope ] ) ) or if the term @xmath132 appears in eq .
( [ dope ] ) , then @xmath133 or @xmath134 , respectively .
this implies that @xmath135 we remark that , even in this case when the moment is not finite , the asymptotic expansion is still well defined .
it is nice to see that whether the zeroth moment of the subtracted sf exists is reflected directly through the leading power of @xmath35 in the ope series . our main results , eq .
( [ cons ] ) and eq .
( [ nonc ] ) , can be expressed in physical terms as follows .
the zeroth moment of a sf for a current @xmath32 whose ope series yields @xmath136 is independent of @xmath0 and @xmath1 , while the same moment for a current with @xmath123 changes with @xmath0 and @xmath1 proportionally to the corresponding change(s ) of the condensate(s ) of the leading operator(s ) .
although @xmath137 and @xmath138_\kappa\rangle$ ] can separately depend on @xmath19 , their product must be independent of @xmath19 , since the zeroth moment is independent of @xmath19 . at this point
several general comments are appropriate : \(1 ) our derivation relies on the fact that an asymptotically free theory allows a perturbative expansion at short distances , making practical the use of the ope and of the rge .
we understand why only short distance physics is involved if we realize that the integral over frequencies reduces eq .
( [ corr ] ) to the ensemble average of the equal - time commutator of the currents .
therefore , results such as eq .
( [ cons ] ) and eq .
( [ nonc ] ) are completely determined by the one - loop structure of the theory and the particular current under exam .
\(2 ) flavor , or other non - dynamical quantum numbers , does not change the expansions at the one - loop level in an essential way .
therefore , one can derive analogous sum rules by using other kind of subtractions , instead of the one we adopted .
one such example is given by the exact weinberg sum rules @xmath139 in the chiral limit @xcite .
\(3 ) the derivation of sum rules for higher moments of the sf requires the complete cancelation of all the lower dimensional operator terms , not just the leading @xmath35 .
in particular , one also needs current quark mass corrections to the wilson coefficients . without appropriate subtractions , higher moments do not even converge @xcite .
\(4 ) it is essential to properly take into account the logarithmic corrections when deriving exact sum rules , since the logarithmic corrections not only dictate whether @xmath113 satisfy eq .
( [ cons ] ) or eq .
( [ nonc ] ) but they also control the very existence of @xmath113 @xcite .
this procedure is in sharp contrast with the usual qcd sum rule approach , where the convergence issue is by - passed by applying the borel improvement by explicitly introducing a cut - off parameter ( the borel mass ) .
\(5 ) we believe that the @xmath2-dependent part of the leading condensate appearing in eq .
( [ cons ] ) does not suffer from the infrared renormalon ambiguity .
in fact , only the perturbative term @xmath24 can generate contributions to the leading condensate that are dependent on the prescription used to regularize these renormalons .
but @xmath24 is independent of @xmath0 and @xmath1 : any prescription dependence cancels out when we make the subtraction in eq .
( [ ddisp ] ) . on the contrary , unless we generalize eq .
( [ ddisp ] ) and make other subtractions , sum rules that involve non - leading condensates are , in principle , ambiguous .
\(6 ) it is well - known that conserved operators are not renormalized and , barring anomalous violations , verify the same `` classical '' identities that can be derived at the tree level .
this fact is also verified in the sum rules .
in fact when both the currents and the operators are conserved ( @xmath123 ) and we obtain the result of eq .
( [ cons ] ) , i.e. one can use the `` naive asymptotic expansion '' to derive the sum rule .
conservation of the current alone is not enough to warrant a `` classical '' identity .
in the preceding section we have derived sum rules valid for any asymptotically free theory . in this section
we illustrate the procedure in the 1 + 1 dimensional gross - neveu model @xcite in the infinite-@xmath3 limit .
on one hand , we can derive the sum rules in eqs .
( [ cons ] ) and ( [ nonc ] ) by explicitly calculating wilson coefficients , @xmath140- and @xmath141-functions in the vector and pseudoscalar channels , following the general procedure discussed in section ii . on the other hand , since this model is soluble , we can obtain the exact spectral function at arbitrary @xmath2 , and then explicitly verify both that the sum rules are satisfied and that the asymptotic expansion of the spectral function has the form given in eq .
( [ rholn ] ) .
moreover , we can also calculate the condensates , and therefore explicitly check that the ope really matches the asymptotic expansion of the exact spectral integral .
the lagrangian of the gross - neveu model is @xmath142\ , , \ ] ] where @xmath143 is a two - component dirac spinor and has @xmath3-component in the internal space .
equivalently , we can write @xmath144 where @xmath145 and @xmath146 are auxiliary fields .
the coupling constant @xmath46 is independent of @xmath3 and held fixed in the limit @xmath147 .
this model is asymptotically free when @xmath148 , and the chiral symmetry is dynamically broken at @xmath149 and @xmath150 to the leading order in @xmath151 @xcite . in the following
we give the exact solution at @xmath152 with finite @xmath2 .
although formulas are explicitly considered in the symmetry breaking phase , they are also valid in the symmetric phase provided that the vanishing limit of certain condensates ( such as the dynamical fermion mass ) is properly taken .
we wish to remark on the well - known fact that the limit @xmath147 here should not be interpreted as a starting point for an expansion of the model at finite @xmath3 , but rather as different model in itself , which is in fact the model we decided to use for the purpose of illustration .
moreover , there exist arguments @xcite suggesting that this model in the limit @xmath147 is actually more relevant to @xmath153 phenomenology than the model with finite @xmath3 .
since the procedure to obtain the exact solution in the large-@xmath3 limit is rather standard and some of the intermediate steps can be found in the literature , see for instance refs .
@xcite , we only give the definitions and final results . the gap equation and the phase diagram can be derived from the first derivative of the effective potential @xmath154 we introduce a momentum cutoff @xmath69 and add the counterterm @xmath155 , where @xmath19 is the subtraction point . then the renormalized effective potential becomes @xmath156 where we have defined @xmath157 and , in the second equality , we have eliminated the subtraction point by introducing the dynamical fermion mass at @xmath22 , i.e. @xmath158 . the effective potential is then obtained by integrating eq .
( [ effpotp ] ) : @xmath159\right\}\ , .
\label{effpot}\ ] ] the gap equation is simply given by @xmath160 the system possesses `` metastable states '' at those values of @xmath2 for which the gap equation has more than one minimum solutions : the solution with lowest @xmath161 selects the true ground state .
when @xmath2 s are such that @xmath162 is the only minimum solution to the gap equation , these points in the @xmath2-plane defines a second order phase transition line , which separate the symmetry - broken phase , i.e. @xmath163 , from the symmetric phase , i.e. @xmath162 . taking the limit @xmath164 in eq .
( [ effpotp ] ) , after some suitable rewriting , this critical line obeys the following equation @xmath165 \cosh[(k-\mu)/2 t ] } - \int_m^\infty { dk\over k}\ , f(k;t,\mu)\ , , \label{gap0}\ ] ] whose numerical solutions are plotted in fig .
[ fig1 ] in full line .
the full line turns into a dotted line at the heavy dot , where another minimum ( dash line ) appears and becomes lower than the minimum given by eq .
( [ gap0 ] ) .
since the mass gap is finite on the dash line ( given by the solution of @xmath166 with @xmath167 , where prime denote a derivative with respect to @xmath168 ) , the dash line is a first order phase boundary .
the critical temperature at @xmath150 is given by @xmath169 .
the `` tricritical point '' ( the heavy dot in fig . [ fig1 ] ) can be found by imposing that @xmath170 : @xmath171 @xcite . when @xmath149 the chemical potential at which the first order phase transition takes place is @xmath172 @xcite .
the basic ingredient to build up the correlator is the fermion bubble graph . in the euclidean region
the pseudoscalar bubble , i.e. the free bubble graph between two @xmath173 currents , can be conveniently expressed as @xmath174 where @xmath175 and @xmath176 here and in the following @xmath19 is always the renormalization subtraction point , @xmath177 is the dynamically generated fermion mass , and @xmath178 .
we shall also use the short - hand notation @xmath179 for instance , the use of this notation makes possible to write the gap equation as @xmath180 in the large-@xmath3 limit , the correlator in pseudoscalar channel is given by the geometric sum of the bubble graph : @xmath181 in the euclidean region , we can then expand this correlator in the @xmath13 limit as @xmath182 where we have introduced the running coupling constant @xmath183 and used the gap equation eq .
( [ gapsh ] ) .
we can recognize the first term in eq .
( [ corrq ] ) as the perturbative contribution at @xmath22 , @xmath184 , which corresponds to the term @xmath185 in the generic ope expansion shown in section [ general ] .
the other two terms in eq .
( [ corrq ] ) can be interpreted as contributions from the condensates . as we will verify later , in fact , @xmath186\rangle_{t,\mu}$ ] , while @xmath187\rangle_{t,\mu}$ ] is the condensate of the energy - momentum tensor .
we shall see that the perturbative contribution and the coefficients of the condensates are indeed the ones obtained by the ope of @xmath188 , and therefore the expansion of the correlator shown in eq .
( [ corrq ] ) is of the form of the ope .
note that in defining the condensates we have absorbed factors of @xmath3 in order to simplify the notation . to obtain the spectral function
we need the bubble graph in the time - like region @xmath189 : @xmath190 and @xmath191 where @xmath192 stands for the principle value of the integral .
the complete spectral function has the form @xmath193 the pole contribution comes from the bound state ( the pion ) , whose mass is the solution to the equation @xmath194 in the region @xmath195 .
this equation has in fact solution @xmath196 , and the coupling constant of this massless pion to its constituents is given by @xmath197 the continuum part of the spectral function is related to the bubble @xmath198 in the time - like region through @xmath199 in order to get an idea of the dependence of the spectral function on @xmath2 , we plot @xmath200 for several typical values of @xmath2 , which are indicated in the phase diagram in fig .
[ fig1 ] . in fig .
[ fig2 ] we show @xmath200 for values of @xmath2 that go from the symmetry - broken phase to the symmetric phase through the second order line , while in fig . [ fig3 ] we show @xmath200 as @xmath2 go through the first order boundary .
we immediately notice that the behavior of the spectral function changes drastically near the second order phase boundary .
this is a clear reflection of the low energy critical phenomena related to the continuous phase transition .
in fact , the pseudoscalar correlator ( in the symmetric phase only , since it is then degenerate with the scalar correlator ) at @xmath201 can be regarded as the chiral susceptibility , and should diverge as @xmath202 ( with @xmath203 in this model ) . at the boundary of the first order phase transition ( fig .
[ fig3 ] ) , but still relatively close to the `` tricritical point '' , the same qualitative deformation is present , since a weak first order transition shares certain qualitative features of a second order transition , even if we do not expect any real divergence .
it is this kind of dramatic behavior of the spectral function near phase transitions that makes practical parameterizations nearly impossible .
the chiral restoration in qcd is expected to be either continuous , or at least a smooth crossover , and the spectral functions in scalar and pseudoscalar channels should show a behavior qualitatively similar to the gross - neveu model , i.e. strong peak right above the origin near the phase transition . we shall comment more on this issue after we derive the sum rules for qcd in section [ qcd ] .
it is instructive to expand @xmath200 in the limit @xmath204 .
we shall see that this asymptotic expansion is of the form assumed in section [ general ] .
furthermore , once substituted in the dispersion integral , it generates the ope series of eq .
( [ corrq ] ) according to the procedure developed in section [ general ] .
to the leading order in @xmath205 , we find @xmath206 and @xmath207\rangle_{t,\mu}\bigr ] + { \cal o}\bigl({1\over\omega^4}\bigr)\biggr\ } \ , , \ ] ] which leads to the following asymptotic form for the continuum part of the spectral function @xmath208\rangle_{t,\mu } \nonumber \\ & + & { 4g^2(\omega)\over\omega^2}\bigl({g^2(\omega)\over g^2}\bigr)^2 \langle[\theta_{00}]\rangle_{t,\mu } \bigl\{1+{\cal o}\bigl(g^2(q)\bigr)\bigr\}\ , .
\label{rho_asym}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here we only concern with the @xmath35-dependent terms and postpone the pure @xmath23 terms ( related to @xmath111 ) to a later subsection .
we recognize again the first term in eq .
( [ rho_asym ] as the asymptotic perturbative spectral function .
moreover , the @xmath2-dependent part of eq .
( [ rho_asym ] ) has indeed the general form of eq .
( [ rholn ] ) . in connection with the comments we made after eq .
( [ rholn ] ) , we point out that eq .
( [ rho_asym ] ) has been obtained by expanding the spectral function in the limit @xmath209 at fixed @xmath0 .
had we made instead a high-@xmath0 expansion ( @xmath210 ) at fixed @xmath26 , we would have obtained , for instance , @xmath211 from the third term of eq .
( [ repi ] ) . upon substituting eq .
( [ rho_asym ] ) in the dispersion integral , and using the identity @xmath212 where @xmath213 and we have kept only the @xmath35-dependent part , we find the following series to the leading order in @xmath35 , @xmath214\rangle_{t,\mu}\over q^2 } + 4\bigl({g^2(q)\over g^2}\bigr)^2 { \langle[\theta_{00}]\rangle_{t,\mu}\over q^2}+\cdots \label{gndisint}\ ] ] this result is in agreement with the ope series of eq .
( [ corrq ] ) , which has been directly expanded from the correlator in the euclidean region .
the fact that no pure @xmath23 term appears in eq .
( [ gndisint ] ) implies that the zeroth moment of the subtracted spectral function vanishes : @xmath215 .
the zeroth moment of the spectral function without the subtraction is not convergent , because of the contribution from the perturbative term , even if one can define it through a proper analytic continuation that yields @xmath216 .
we have just verified that in the gross - neveu model the exact correlation function can indeed be expanded in an asymptotic series precisely in the form of the ope .
now we shall calculate the wilson coefficients , @xmath140-function and appropriate anomalous dimensions for the ope , and verify that they match the coefficients and exponents of this asymptotic series .
furthermore , though it is beyond the scope of the ope and rge , we shall also calculate the condensates . in this way
, we explicitly verify that the asymptotic expansion of the exact correlation function is identical to the ope .
the one - loop @xmath140-function of the 1 + 1 dimensional gross - neveu model has already been calculated in the original paper @xcite : @xmath217 , i.e. according to our notation @xmath218 .
the anomalous dimensions for pseudoscalar current @xmath173 and four - quark operator @xmath219 can be calculated using the feynman diagrams shown in fig .
[ fig4]a and fig .
[ fig4]b , respectively .
according to the notation of eq .
( [ rgef ] ) we find @xmath220 , and @xmath221 .
the energy - momentum conservation makes the anomalous dimension for @xmath222 vanish , i.e. @xmath223 . the relevant wilson coefficients corresponding to operators @xmath224 and @xmath222 can be calculated , to leading order in @xmath35 , using the feynman diagrams shown in fig .
[ fig5]a and fig . [ fig5]b , respectively .
the resulting coefficient are @xmath225 ( @xmath226 according to notation in eq .
( [ asyope ] ) ) and @xmath227 ( @xmath228 ) .
these results lead to the exponents @xmath229 and @xmath230 , which are precisely what we found in eq .
( [ gndisint ] ) .
these explicit one - loop calculations exactly match the solution in eq .
( [ gndisint ] ) . at last
a comment on the one - loop calculation : this result is exact to the leading order in @xmath151 and only involves insertion of the quark - bubble chain . since the quark - bubble behaves like @xmath231 , this insertion is equivalent to substituting the coupling constant @xmath46 with the running coupling constant @xmath35 .
so one can easily identify those sets of feynman graphs whose sum leads to the solution of the rge in eq .
( [ rge ] ) .
the ope itself does not specify how the relevant condensates are calculated , since the ope is only a rge - improved perturbative procedure .
the calculation of the condensates can be done only in a non - perturbative context . here , we carry out this calculation using the @xmath151 expansion . the bare quark condensate @xmath232 is given by the dynamical quark tadpole graph @xmath233 using the standard contour integral technique to carry out the matsubara frequency sum
, we obtain @xmath234 the renormalized quark condensate is obtained by replacing @xmath235 with the subtraction point @xmath19 in the above equation @xmath236\rangle_{t,\mu } = m\langle\!\langle e_k^0\rangle\!\rangle -{m\over\pi}\ln\bigl({\kappa\over m}\bigr)=-{m\over g^2}\ , .\ ] ] in the last step we have used the gap equation eq .
( [ gapsh ] ) .
notice that the renormalization of this condensate is not independent of the one carried out for the effective potential .
in fact , the @xmath145-field is just an auxiliary field : @xmath237 .
therefore , the gap equation gives us not only the expectation value of the @xmath145-field , but also of @xmath238 : @xmath239\rangle_{t,\mu}$ ] .
so the renormalizations of @xmath238 and @xmath46 are related .
the four - quark condensate factorizes in the large-@xmath3 limit , and we find @xmath240\rangle_{t,\mu}= \langle[\bar{\psi}\psi]\rangle_{t,\mu}^2=m^2/g^4 $ ] .
the bare kinetic energy expectation value is given by @xmath241 after removing the @xmath2-independent volume and quadratic divergences , and introduced a subtraction point for the logarithmic divergence the renormalized kinetic energy becomes @xmath242\rangle_{t,\mu } = \langle\!\langle e_k^2 \rangle\!\rangle -{m^2\over 2\pi}\ln\bigl({\kappa\over m}\bigr)\ , .\ ] ] after subtracting the trace term from the kinetic energy , we finally obtain the expectation value of the traceless energy - momentum tensor @xmath243\rangle_{t,\mu } \equiv \langle[\bar{\psi}i\gamma_0\partial_0\psi -{1\over 2}m\bar{\psi}\psi]\rangle_{t,\mu } = \langle\!\langle e_k^2\rangle\!\rangle -{m^2\over 2}\langle\!\langle e_k^0\rangle\!\rangle\ , .\ ] ] in the symmetric phase ( @xmath244 ) , the expectation value of the energy - momentum tensor has the very simple form at @xmath150 @xmath243\rangle_{t,\mu=0}={\pi\over 6}t^2\ , .\ ] ] one can verify that inserting these condensates in the ope , whose coefficients and exponents we have already calculated , reproduces the asymptotic expansion of the exact correlator in eq .
( [ corrq ] ) .
let us first notice that the sum rule @xmath245 converges very slowly .
in fact , the subtracted spectral function has the leading behavior @xmath246 where @xmath247\rangle_{t,\mu})\over g^4(\omega)+4}\biggr\}\ , .
\label{drho2}\ ] ] since @xmath248 , the leading behavior in eq .
( [ drho2 ] ) is @xmath249^{-1}$ ] , and it is clear that the sum rule only converges logarithmically , i.e. @xmath250 .
moreover , it is only thanks to the the logarithmic corrections that the sum rule is finite . had we disregarded this corrections , we would have found @xmath251 , and the zeroth moment of the subtracted spectral function would not exist .
since the exact spectral function can not be integrated analytically , we verify the exact sum rule numerically .
we take advantage of the fact that the integral of @xmath252 in eq .
( [ drho2 ] ) can be done analytically to improve the numerical convergence of the integral .
we rewrite the sum rule as @xmath253 where the integral of @xmath252 can be done analytically and we obtain @xmath254\rangle_{t,\mu})\over ( \ln a)^2+\pi^2/4}\biggr\}+{\cal o}\bigl({1\over a^2}\bigr)\ , .\ ] ] this formula can be easily verified numerically with high accuracy , since the error is now @xmath255 , rather than @xmath256 .
it is reminded that @xmath257 in the above equation should be obtained from the complete sf in eq .
( [ rho_full ] ) , including both @xmath88 and @xmath111 .
there are several reasons to study the correlator in the vector channel in the gross - neveu model .
first , the vector channel gives us an example where the zeroth moment of the subtracted sf does not exist , but the asymptotic procedure can still be carried out .
moreover , in connection with the fact that the vector current is conserved , this spectral function is not affected by logarithmic corrections , and we can use it to illustrate the use of the mellin transform method to obtain the asymptotic expansion . in addition , very much like in the qcd case , we shall see that the baryon number susceptibility changes drastically near the chiral restoration transition , even if we do not expect any real singularity associated with critical phenomena in the vector channel . for convenience
, we only consider the case of @xmath150 .
the feynman graphs that contribute to the vector correlator are depicted in fig .
note that if there were no mixing between vector and pseudoscalar channel , which in fact is only present in 1 + 1 dimensions , the sole contribution would come from the first graph .
the total contribution from all the graphs in fig .
[ fig6 ] is @xmath258 we define the spectral function in vector channel as @xmath259 then we find the following explicit expression for @xmath260 @xmath261 it is clear that leading asymptotic behavior of the spectral function is @xmath262 , which implies that the zeroth moment of the spectral function does not exist ( it is divergent ) . in the section [ general ] we have shown that , corresponding to this divergence , we must find negative powers of @xmath35 ( positive power of @xmath263 ) in the ope series .
when there are no explicit logarithms in @xmath264 , it is easier to make the asymptotic expansion by using the mellin transform method , and in particular the convolution property of the mellin transform @xcite , @xmath265m[f;1-z]\ , , \label{convolut}\ ] ] where @xmath266 $ ] is the mellin transform of @xmath267 , defined by @xmath268\equiv\int_0^\infty dt\ , t^{z-1}h(t)\ , .\ ] ] the value of @xmath269 in eq.([convolut ] ) depends on the asymptotic behaviors of @xmath267 at @xmath270 and @xmath271 at @xmath272 respectively ; details can be found , for instance , in chapter 4 of ref .
@xcite .
now let us illustrate how to use this method to expand the power part of the spectral function ( the part containing exponential dumping factors can be expanded naively ) @xmath273 whose mellin transform is @xmath274= ( 4m^2)^z\sqrt{\pi}\gamma(1-z)/\gamma(3/2-z ) \ , .\ ] ] using the convolution , eq .
( [ convolut ] ) , and the mellin transform of @xmath82 @xmath275=\pi(q^2)^{-z}/\sin\pi(1-z ) \ , , \ ] ] we find ( in this case @xmath269 in eq.([convolut ] ) obeys @xmath276 ) @xmath277_{z = n } \nonumber \\ & = & { 4m^2\over q^2}\ln\bigl({q^2\over m^2}\bigr ) -{8m^4\over q^4}\bigl[1+\ln\bigl({q^2\over m^2}\bigr)\bigr ] + { \cal o}\bigl({1\over q^6}\bigr)\ , .
\label{asymmell}\end{aligned}\ ] ] similarly to the pseudoscalar correlator , it is possible to check this result in two ways .
we can directly expand the power part ( temperature independent part ) of eq .
( [ vvceucl ] ) , and we can derive the ope ( @xmath278 and @xmath279 for the @xmath23 term ) . as promised , there indeed appears a positive power of @xmath263 in the ope series . at the same time , the singularities of @xmath280 $ ] at @xmath281 positive integer hints the fact that all the non - negative integer moments of @xmath282 do not exist . on the other hand , the asymptotic expansion in eq .
( [ asymmell ] ) is well defined . even though the vector current is conserved , due to the fact that the anomalous dimension of @xmath224 is not zero ,
the correct result can not be obtained by a naive asymptotic expansion in this case , in accordance with the remark number ( 6 ) at the end of section ii .
this same result could have been obtained also by the general method developed in section [ general ] , but it should be clear by now that the use of the mellin transform , when possible , is more straightforward and require less labour .
the baryon number susceptibility ( @xmath283 ) is defined as the vector correlator in the limit @xmath284 . from eq .
( [ vvceucl ] ) we find @xmath285 notice that since we have contracted the lorentz indices when defining our vector correlator , @xmath283 is nonpositive definite .
it is also possible that our definition of @xmath283 differs from others by an additive constant , which is irrelevant to the temperature dependence we are considering . in the symmetric phase , the limit @xmath286 should be take with some care : the result is @xmath287 , when @xmath288 .
the complete temperature dependence of @xmath283 is displayed in fig .
as expected , there is no divergence or critical phenomena in this channel .
nevertheless , we do see a sudden rising of @xmath283 in correspondence to the relatively rapid drop of the dynamical quark mass , which we show in fig .
[ fig7]a for comparison , near the phase transition region .
after a lengthy detour to the gross - neveu model let us now back to the main interest of our work , to derive exact sum rules and to explore the corresponding phenomenological consequences in qcd .
as we will see , qcd shares many of the qualitative features observed in the gross - neveu model , implying the simple fact that any drastic change induced by a phase transition or rapid crossover would necessarily be reflected through the spectral function in proper channels at low frequencies , independent of the details of the model .
let us consider four correlators of mesonic currents in qcd .
the correlation between scalar currents and the one between pseudoscalar currents involve non - conserved operators , @xmath289 and @xmath290 , whose anomalous dimensions are @xmath291 .
one the other end , correlators between vector currents and axial - vector currents involve conserved quantities , @xmath292 and @xmath293 , whose anomalous dimensions vanish ( @xmath294 )
. in qcd there exist several dimension - four operators , but all of them have non - positive anomalous dimensions , therefore the two correlators between nonconserved currents have @xmath295 and eq .
( [ nonc ] ) applies , _
i.e. _ the zeroth moments of their sf s are independent of @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
on the other hand , the two conserved currents have , in correspondence with conserved operators @xmath296 and a generalization of eq .
( [ cons ] ) applies . in this case in fact there are three dimension - four operators with zero anomalous dimension .
two of these operators are lorentz scalars : @xmath297 and @xmath298 , while the third is the energy - momentum tensor : @xmath299 the sum rules for the vector and axial - vector currents ( with the lorentz indices contracted ) are : @xmath300\rangle + { \delta\langle[\alpha_s g^2]\rangle\over 2\pi } + 8\delta\langle [ \theta_{00}]\rangle\ , , \label{va}\ ] ] with @xmath301 and @xmath302 for vector and axial - vector cases , respectively .
obviously , the general remarks at the end of section ii apply to the sum rules derived above . however , there is a new feature of qcd which may not be shared by all asymptotically free theories .
it is known that qcd ope series has explicit instanton induced corrections that can not be related to condensates of some local operators .
but these exact sum rules are not explicitly affected by this problem , although the value of the condensates certainly have instanton contributions .
the reason is that the instanton singularities in the borel - plane are located on the positive axis starting at @xmath303 , which in turn implies that the explicit contribution of instantons to correlation functions are of higher order than @xmath23 @xcite in the ope series .
finally , let us discuss some of the phenomenological consequences of these exact sum rules .
the power of these exact sum rules rests on their generality , in the sense that there is no assumptions on the functional form of the sf s and they can be applied anywhere in the @xmath2-plane .
first let us consider the pseudoscalar channel .
the sum rule @xmath215 implies that , in the broken - chiral - symmetry phase , the change of the pion pole induced by @xmath0 or @xmath1 is exactly compensated by a corresponding change of the continuum part of the sf .
next let us consider the scalar correlation function at zero frequency , i.e. the chiral susceptibility ( a measure of the fluctuation of the chiral order parameter ) , @xmath304\rangle_{t,\mu } = \int_0^\infty\!\ ! du^2\ , { \rho(u;t,\mu)\over u^2}\ , , \label{chisus}\ ] ] which diverges when @xmath2 approaches the phase boundary , provided the chiral restoration is a continuous transition .
the divergence of the chiral susceptibility near the phase transition can only be produced in eq .
( [ chisus ] ) by singularities very close to the origin ; singularities not near the origin are not compatible with the sum rule @xmath215 .
thus , when approaching the phase boundary in the @xmath2 plane , the threshold of the spectral function vanishes ( since there is no massless pole in the chirally symmetric phase ) , and a strong peak develops right above threshold . in the chirally symmetric phase
the pseudoscalar and scalar channels are degenerate , therefore we expect the same behavior for the pseudoscalar sf .
this strong peak in the pseudoscalar and scalar sf s , which is intimately connected with critical phenomena of a diverging susceptibility and correlation length near the phase transition , can be interpreted as some kind of quasi - particle , thus confirming the qualitative picture , originally proposed in the context of the nambu - jona - lasinio model @xcite , of the appearance of soft modes near the chiral phase transition .
we wish to remark that the sum rule has been used only to exclude the logical possibility of the sf developing singularities at finite energies .
but the sum rule is not a necessary condition for the appearance of a peak .
the presence of a second order phase transition ( infinite correlation length ) is the real physical cause of the peak .
nevertheless , one should not assume that if the phase transition is not second order the zero-@xmath0 or perturbative spectral function is a good approximation to the real spectral function .
even if the chiral restoration turns out to be a cross - over or weak first order transition ( finite but large correlation ) , as the lattice data seem to indicate @xcite , we still expect the same qualitative features , though less pronounced : a peak develops but it does not actually diverge at the transition . our calculation in the gross - neveu model is a clear illustration of this situation . while fig .
( [ fig2 ] ) shows the divergent peak of the spectral function near the second order boundary , we see in fig .
( [ fig3 ] ) that the spectral function is also strongly peaked near the first order transition as long as we are not too far away from the `` tricritical point '' .
we believe that similar results hold in the vector and axial - vector channels , even if our conclusions can not be as strong as in the previous case , because of two main differences .
the first is that now @xmath305 .
this problem is not very serious , since we only need that @xmath113 is not singular crossing the phase boundary . and
this can still be argued by means of the sum rule in eq .
( [ va ] ) and the fact that , for a continuous phase transition , the changes of the thermal energy @xmath306\rangle$ ] , and of both condensates @xmath307\rangle$ ] and @xmath308\rangle$ ] should behave smoothly across the critical line .
the most serious difference is that , in these channels , we can not argue on physical grounds that the corresponding susceptibility diverges . nonetheless , there exist lattice simulations @xcite showing that the so - called quark number susceptibility rapidly increases in the transition .
thus it is plausible that also in the vector channel the sf has a vanishing threshold , and accumulates strength just above it .
a similar argument in the context of the nambu - jona - lasinio model can be found in ref .
we used the operator product expansion and the renormalization group equation to derive exact sum rules at finite @xmath0 and @xmath1 valid for asymptotically free theories .
our derivation explicitly show that logarithmic corrections can not be neglected .
we found that , depending on the theory and on the current under study , the zeroth moment of a spectral function is either independent of @xmath0 and @xmath1 , or its change is related to the corresponding changes of the condensates of operators of lowest dimension .
in particular the zeroth moment of the scalar and pseudoscalar mesonic currents in qcd are independent of @xmath0 and @xmath1 . as a consequence
any change in the strength of the pion pole must be exactly compensated by a change in the continuum contribution .
we also infer that spectral functions in the scalar and pseudoscalar channel should dramatically change near phase transition .
we also find that the zeroth moment of the vector and axial - vector mesonic currents in qcd changes with @xmath0 and @xmath1 , and these changes are related to the corresponding changes of the condensates .
due to their generality , these exact sum rules strongly constrain the qualitative shape of sf s , in particular , near phase transitions . since it appears that a strong deformation of the spectral function from its counter part at @xmath22 and perturbative cases is the most likely scenario near phase transitions , the information carried by these exact sum rules is particularly welcome .
we urge whoever parameterizes a spectral function , e.g. in qcd sum rule type of calculations or to interpret lattice simulation data , to incorporate these exact constraints .
we have also illustrated in great detail the derivation of the sum rules , and confirmed their validity , in the gross - neveu model , where we can also calculate the exact spectral function . even if this model calculation is meant mostly as an illustration of many delicate issues of the derivation ( such as convergence , asymptotic expansion , mellin transform , high momentum expansion vs. high temperature expansion , etc . ) , it is nevertheless comforting to find that all our general expectations about the spectral function are explicitly verified in the model . | within the framework of the operator product expansion ( ope ) and the renormalization group equation ( rge ) , we show that the temperature and chemical potential dependence of the zeroth moment of a spectral function ( sf ) is completely determined by the one - loop structure in an asymptotically free theory , and in particular in qcd .
logarithmic corrections are found to play an essential role in the derivation .
this exact result constrains the shape of sf s , and implies striking effects near phase transitions .
phenomenological parameterizations of the sf , often used in applications such as the analysis of lattice qcd data or qcd sum rule calculations at finite temperature and baryon density must satisfy these constraints .
we also explicitly illustrate in detail the exact sum rule in the gross - neveu model . |
the last decade brought a dynamic evolution of the computing capabilities of graphics processing units ( gpus ) . in that time , the performance of a single card increased from tens of gflops in nvxx to tflops in the newest kepler / maxwell nvidia chips @xcite .
this raw processing power did not go unnoticed by the engineering and science communities , which started applying gpus to accelerate a wide array of calculations in what became known as gpgpu general - purpose computing on gpus .
this led to the development of special gpu variants optimized for high performance computing ( e.g. the nvidia tesla line ) , but it should be noted that even commodity graphics cards , such as those from the nvidia geforce series , still provide enormous computational power and can be a very economical ( both from the monetary and energy consumption point of view ) alternative to large cpu clusters .
the spread of gpgpu techniques was further facilitated by the development of cuda and opencl
parallel programming paradigms allowing efficient exploitation of the available gpu compute power without exposing the programmer to too many low - level details of the underlying hardware .
gpus were used successfully to accelerate many problems , e.g. the numerical solution of stochastic differential equations @xcite , fluid simulations with the lattice boltzmann method @xcite , molecular dynamics simulations @xcite , classical @xcite and quantum monte carlo @xcite simulations , exact diagonalization of the hubbard model @xcite , _
etc_. parallel computing in general , and its realization in gpus in particular , can also be extremely useful in many fields of solid state physics . for a large number of problems , the ground state of the system and its free energy
are of special interest .
for instance , in order to determine the phase diagram of a model , free energy has to be calculated for a large number of points in the parameter space . in this paper
, we address this very issue and illustrate it on a concrete example of a superconducting system with an oscillating order parameter ( op ) , specifically an iron - based multi - band superconductor ( fesc ) .
our algorithm is not limited to systems of this type and can also be used for systems in the homogeneous superconducting state ( bcs ) .
the discovery of high temperature superconductivity in fesc @xcite began a period of intense experimental and theoretical research .
@xcite all fesc include a two - dimensional structure which is shown in fig . [ fig.feas].a . the fermi surfaces ( fs ) in fesc are composed of hole - like fermi pockets ( around the @xmath1 point ) and electron - like fermi pockets ( around the @xmath2 point ) fig .
[ fig.feas].b .
moreover , in fesc we expect the presence of @xmath3 symmetry of the superconducting op .
@xcite in this case the op exhibits a sign reversal between the hole pockets and electron pockets . for one @xmath4 ion in the unit cell
, the op is proportional to @xmath5 .
layers in fesc are built by @xmath4 ions ( red dots ) forming a square lattice surrounded by @xmath6 ions ( green dots ) which also form a square lattice .
@xmath6 ions are placed above or under the centers of the squares formed by @xmath4 .
this leads to two inequivalent positions of @xmath4 atoms , so that there are two ions of @xmath4 and @xmath6 in an elementary cell .
( panel b ) true ( folded ) fermi surface in the first brillouin zone for two @xmath4 ions in unit cell .
the colors blue , red and green correspond to the fs for the 1st , 2nd , and 3rd band , respectively . ]
fesc systems show complex low - energy band structures , which have been extensively studied .
@xcite a consequence of this is a more sensitive dependence of the fs to doping .
@xcite in the superconducting state , the gap is found to be on the order of 10 mev , small relative to the breadth of the band .
@xcite this increases the required accuracy of calculated physical quantities needed to determine the phase diagram of the superconducting state , such as free energy .
@xcite in this paper we show how the increased computational cost of obtaining thermodynamically reliable results can be offset by parallelizing the most demanding routines using cuda , after a suitable transformation of variables to decouple the interacting degrees of freedom . in section [ sec.theory_ph ]
we discuss the theoretical background of numerical calculations . in section [ sec.algorithm ]
we describe the implementation of the algorithm and compare its performance when executed on the cpu and gpu .
we summarize the results in section [ sec.summary ] .
many theoretical models of fesc systems have been proposed , with two @xcite , three @xcite , four @xcite and five bands @xcite .
most of the models mentioned describe one ` fe ` unit cell and closely approximate the band and fs structure ( fig [ fig.feas].b ) obtained by lda calculations .
@xcite in every model the non - interacting tight - binding hamiltonian of fesc in momentum space can be described by : @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the creation ( annihilation ) operator for a spin @xmath9 electron of momentum @xmath10 in the orbital @xmath11 ( the set of orbitals is model dependent ) .
the hopping matrix elements @xmath12 determine the model of fesc . here , @xmath13 is the chemical potential and @xmath14 is an external magnetic field parallel to the ` feas ` layers . for our analysis
we have chosen the minimal two - band model proposed by raghu _
et al . _
@xcite and the three - band model proposed by daghofer _
_ @xcite ( described in [ app.twoband ] and [ app.threeband ] respectively ) .
the band structure and fs of the fesc system can be reconstructed by diagonalizing the hamiltonian @xmath15 : @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the creation ( annihilation ) operator for a spin @xmath9 electron of momentum @xmath18 in the band @xmath19 .
[ [ superconductivity - in - multi - band - iron - base - systems - in - high - magnetic - fields ] ] superconductivity in multi - band iron - base systems in high magnetic fields + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + fesc superconductors are layered @xcite , clean @xcite materials with a relatively high maki parameter @xmath20 .
@xcite all of the features are shared with heavy fermion systems , in which strong indications exist to observe the fulde
ovchinnikov ( fflo ) phase @xcite a superconducting phase with an oscillating order parameter in real space , caused by the non - zero value of the total momentum of cooper pairs .
in contrast to the bcs state where cooper pairs form a singlet state @xmath21 , the fflo phase is formed by pairing states @xmath22 . these states can occur between the zeeman - split parts of the fermi surface in a high external magnetic field ( when the paramagnetic pair - breaking effects are smaller than the diamagnetic pair - breaking effects ) .
@xcite in one - band materials , the fflo can be stabilized by anisotropies of the fermi - surface and of the unconventional gap function , @xcite by pair hopping interaction @xcite or , in systems with nonstandard quasiparticles , with spin - dependent mass .
@xcite this phase can be also realized in inhomogeneous systems in the presence of impurities @xcite or spin density waves @xcite . in some situations , the fflo can be also stable in the absence of an external magnetic field .
@xcite in multi - band systems , the experimental @xcite and theoretical @xcite works point to the existence of the fflo phase in fesc . through the analysis of the cooper pair susceptibility in the minimal two - band model of fesc ,
such systems are shown to support the existence of an fflo phase , regardless of the exhibited op symmetry .
it should be noted that the state with nonzero cooper pair momentum , in fesc superconductors with the @xmath3 symmetry , is the ground state of the system near the pauli limit .
@xcite this holds true also for the three - band model ( e.g. [ app.suscept ] and ref .
@xcite ) . [ [ free - energy - for - intra - band - superconducting - phase ] ] free energy for intra - band superconducting phase
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + in absence of inter - band interactions , the bcs and the fflo phase ( with cooper pairs with total momentum @xmath23 equal zero and non - zero respectively ) can be described by the effective hamiltonian : @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the amplitude of the op for cooper pairs with total momentum @xmath26 ( in band @xmath19 with symmetry described by the form factor @xmath27 for more details see ref .
@xcite ) . using the bogoliubov transformation we can find the eigenvalues of the full hamiltonian @xmath28 : @xmath29 in this case we formally describe two independent bands .
the total free energy for the system is given by @xmath30 , where latexmath:[\[\begin{aligned } \label{eq.freeene } \omega_{\varepsilon } = - \frac{1}{\beta } \sum_{\alpha \in \{+ , -\ } } \sum_{\bm k } \ln \left ( 1 + \exp ( - \beta \mathcal{e}_{\varepsilon{\bm k}}^{\alpha } ) \right ) + \sum_{\bm k } \left ( e_{\varepsilon{\bm k } \downarrow } - \frac { 2 | \delta_{\varepsilon } the free energy in @xmath19-th band , where @xmath32 is the respective interaction intensity and @xmath33 .
for different parameters @xmath32 in @xmath34 results for @xmath35 ( panels a , c and e ) and @xmath36 ( panels b , d and f ) . ] [ [ historical - and - technical - note ] ] historical and technical note + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the historically basic concept of the fflo phase was simultaneously proposed by two independent groups , fulde - ferrell @xcite and larkin - ovchinnikov @xcite in 1964 .
the first group proposed a superconducting phase where cooper pairs have only one non - zero total momentum @xmath37 , and the superconducting order parameter in real space @xmath38 . in the second case ,
cooper pairs have two possible momenta : @xmath37 and the opposite @xmath39 , with an equal amplitude of the order parameter .
thus in real space the superconducting order parameter is given by @xmath40 .
however , the most general case of fflo is a superconducting order parameter given by a sum of plane waves , where the cooper pairs have all compatible values of the momentum @xmath41 in the system : @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the cardinality of the first brillouin zone ( in the square lattice it is equal to @xmath44 ) . for the historical reasons described above , whenever @xmath45 ( @xmath46 and @xmath47 ) we can speak about the fulde ferrell ( ff ) phase , whereas for @xmath48 ( and @xmath49 , @xmath50 ) about the larkin
ovchinnikov ( lo ) phase .
larger @xmath43 impose a more demanding spatial decomposition of the order parameter , both in the theoretical and computational sense .
however , every time it can be reduced to the diagonalization of the ( block ) matrix representation of the hamiltonian . using the translational symmetry of the lattice , the problem for the ff phase ( @xmath51 ) in one - band systems corresponds to the independent diagonalization of @xmath52 matrices ( with eigenvalues given like in eq .
[ eq.enequasiparticle ] with the number of bands @xmath53 ) for each of the @xmath44 different momentum sectors . in case of the lo phase ( @xmath54 )
, the calculation can be similarly decomposed in momentum space or using other spatial symmetries of the system ( an example of this procedure can be found in ref .
@xcite ) , with a much greater computational effort due to the lower degree of symmetry , leading to @xmath55 independent diagonalization problems of size @xmath56 . in
the _ full _ fflo phase ( i.e. in a system with impurities @xcite or a vortex lattice @xcite ) , the spatial decomposition is determined in real space using the self - consistent bogoliubov - de gennes equations , which require the full diagonalization of a hamiltonian of maximal rank @xmath57
@xcite at every self - consistent step . to work around these limitations , iterative methods @xcite or the kernel polynomial method @xcite can be used .
these methods are based on the idea of expressing functions of the energy spectrum in an orthogonal basis , e.g. chebyshev polynomial expansion .
@xcite by doing so , it becomes possible to conduct self - consistent calculations in the superconducting state without performing the diagonalization procedure .
the time expense of iterative methods can also be reduced by a careful gpu implementation , which is currently a work in progress . in the present work ,
we describe how the calculation of the free energy can be accelerated in the ff phase , which due to its greater symmetry allows optimal parallelization on a gpu architecture .
parallel programing can be realized in cpus and gpus in many different ways . in this section
we compare the performance of the same algorithm implemented using openmp @xcite , pgi cuda / openacc fortran @xcite , and directly in cuda c @xcite .
the first two are generic extensions of fortran / c++ that make it easy to , respectively , use multiple cpu cores , and compile a subset of existing fortran / c++ code for a gpu .
they take the form of annotations which can be added to existing code , and as such , enable the use of additional computational power with very little overhead by the programmer .
typically , much better efficiency can be achieved by the third option
i.e. a specifically optimized implementation targeting the gpu architecture directly .
this requires more work on the part of the programmer , both in adjusting the algorithms and in rewriting the code , but it makes it possible to fully utilize the available resources . the global ground state for a fixed magnetic field strength @xmath14 and temperature @xmath58 is found by minimizing the free energy over the set of @xmath59 and @xmath23 . in case of @xmath60 independent bands
this corresponds to global minimization of the free energy @xmath61 in every band separately , for every @xmath26 in the first brillouin zone ( fbz )
algorithm [ alg.1 ] . for the calculation of the free energy @xmath61 , we must know the eigenvalues @xmath62 reconstructing the band structure of our systems . in the case of the two - band model
, it can simply be found analytically ( see [ app.twoband ] ) .
however , for models with more bands ( such as the three - band model [ app.threeband ] ) the band structure has to be determined numerically ( e.g. using a linear algebra library , such as lapack ( cpu ) or magma ( gpu ) @xcite ) . with this approach ,
the calculation of @xmath63 and @xmath64 becomes a computationally costly procedure , and if it were to be repeated inside the inner loop of algorithm [ alg.1 ] , it would significantly impact the execution time . for this reason ,
we propose to precalculate the eigenvalues for every momentum vector @xmath65 and store them in memory for models with more than two bands .
the main downside of this approach is the large increase in memory usage . while algorithm [ alg.1 ] is simple to realize on a cpu , its execution time is proportional to the system size @xmath44 , and as such scales quadratically with @xmath55 for a square lattice ( @xmath55 and @xmath66 are the number of lattice sites in the @xmath67 and @xmath68 direction , respectively ) .
generate matrices @xmath63 and @xmath69 for @xmath65 calculate matrices @xmath70 for @xmath65 eq .
[ eq.enequasiparticle ] calculate @xmath61 find and save @xmath59 corresponding to a fixed @xmath23 and minimal value @xmath61 find and save @xmath23 and @xmath59 corresponding to minimum of @xmath61 sometimes the physical properties of the system make it possible to reduce the amount of computation for instance when it is known that the minimum of the energy is attained for values of momentum @xmath23 in specific directions fig .
[ fig.minene ] .
@xcite in this case , the outer loop of algorithm [ alg.1 ] can be restricted to @xmath71 , where @xmath72 is a set of @xmath73 vectors .
such reductions are not unique to linear systems with translational symmetry but are also the case for systems with rotational symmetry . @xcite in the case of bcs - type superconductivity where cooper pairs have zero total momentum ( @xmath74 ) , algorithm [ alg.1 ] can be further simplified by taking into account the following property of the dispersion relation : @xmath75 in eq .
[ eq.enequasiparticle ]
. this can be particularly useful in determining the system energy in the presence of the bcs phase
i.e. either in complete absence of external magnetic fields or when only weak fields are present .
a more general approach to the reduction of the execution time of our algorithm is to exploit the large degree of parallelism inherent in the problem .
in fact , algorithm [ alg.1 ] can be classified as , , embarrassingly parallel since the vast majority of computation can be carried out independently for all combinations of @xmath76 . for simplicity , in this paper
we concentrate on optimizing the inner loop , as all the presented methods apply to the outer loop in a similar fashion .
we present two approaches to this problem .
the first is to parallelize the execution of the serial loop over @xmath59 with openmp to fully utilize all available cpu cores .
this has the advantage of simplicity , as the implementation requires minimal changes to the original ( serial ) code .
the second approach is to implement algorithm [ alg.1 ] on a gpu using the cuda environment .
modern gpus are capable of simultaneously executing thousands of threads in simt ( same instruction , multiple threads ) mode . from a programmer s point of view
, all the threads are laid out in a 1- , 2- or 3-dimensional grid and are executing a _ kernel function_. the grid is further subdivided into blocks ( groups of threads ) , which are handled by a physical computational subunit of the gpu ( the so - called streaming multiprocessor ) .
threads within a block can exchange data efficiently during execution , but cross - block communication can only take place through global gpu memory , which is significantly slower .
mapped to gpu hardware . ] to fully utilize the gpu hardware , we split algorithm [ alg.1 ] into three steps . in the first step , we execute the ` computefreeenergy ` kernel ( algorithm [ alg.2 ] ) on a 3d grid @xmath77 . to take advantage of the efficient intra - block communication
, we also carry out partial sums within the block ( corresponding to a subset of values spanning @xmath78 ) using the parallel sum - reduction algorithm .
@xcite in the second step , we execute the sum - reduction algorithm again on the partial sums that were generated by algorithm [ alg.2 ] . in the third and last step ,
we copy the output of step 2 from gpu memory to host memory , and look for the value of @xmath79 corresponding to the lowest free energy with a linear search . depending on the exact configuration of the kernels in step 1 and 2
, the summation might not be complete at the beginning of step 3 .
if this is the case , we carry out the remaining summation within the serial loop computing @xmath79 . with block sizes of 128 and 1024 used for the kernels in steps 1 and 2
, we can sum up to @xmath80 terms in parallel on the gpu .
we found that the remaining summation was not worth the overhead of carrying it out on the gpu .
should this not be the case for some larger problems , further parallel execution can be trivially achieved by repeating step 2 one more time .
compute @xmath81 and @xmath18 corresponding to the current thread load @xmath82 and @xmath83 from global memory ( precomputed by a separate kernel ) compute @xmath84 and @xmath85 sum @xmath85 for a range of @xmath18 corresponding to one block of threads save the partial sum from the previous step in global gpu memory to test our approach , we executed algorithms [ alg.1 ] and [ alg.2 ] on linux machines with the following hardware : * cpu : intel(r ) core(tm ) i7 - 3960x cpu @ 3.30ghz 6 cores / 12 threads , * gpu : nvidia tesla k40 ( gk180 ) with the sm clock set to 875 mhz .
the programs were run for a single value of @xmath86 and 200 values of @xmath79 .
calculations were done for a square lattice of size @xmath87 for various values of @xmath88 .
the execution times ( including only the computation part of the code , and excluding any time spent on startup or input / output ) are presented in figure [ fig.scaling ] . and
[ alg.2 ] for one vector @xmath89 .
right panel : speedup factors for all configurations at @xmath90 .
the last 3 case names correspond to runs of the same cuda c code in double precision ( dp ) , single precision ( sp ) , and single precision with fast intrinsic functions ( spfm ) .
all versions of the fortran code used double precision calculations . ] comparing the best cpu execution time ( with openmp ) to the gpu fortran code using openacc , we find a speedup factor of @xmath91 in the limit of large lattices .
the custom gpu code shows slightly better performance , with a @xmath92x speedup for the double precision version , and additional speedup factors of @xmath93 for single precision , and @xmath94 for intrinsic functions .
when taken together , the fastest gpu version is @xmath95 times faster than the openmp code and @xmath96 times faster than the serial cpu code utilizing only a single core .
it is remarkable that the original fortran code enhanced with openacc annotations provides performance comparable to a manual implementation in cuda c. this result shows the power of appropriately used annotations marking parallelizable regions of the code . while still requiring explicit input from the programmer and a good understanding of the structure of the code , this approach is in practice significantly faster than writing the program from scratch in cuda c and dealing with low level details of gpu programming and resource allocation .
this conclusion however only applies in the limit of large lattices ( see the left panel in figure [ fig.scaling ] ) . for smaller ones ,
the cuda c code can be seen to be noticeably faster than openacc , which is likely caused by the automatically generated gpu code introducing unnecessary overhead .
it should be noted that the last two speedup factors were achieved by trading off precision of calculations for performance
e.g. intrinsic functions are faster , but less precise implementations of transcendental functions . in our tests
, we obtained the same results with all three approaches .
this might not be true for some other systems though , so we advise careful experimentation . with a factor of 2.8x between the most and least precise method
, it might also be worthwhile to run larger parameter scans at lower precision and then selectively verify with double precision calculations .
the rich phenomenology and the subtle competing and interplaying phenomena of high-@xmath97 materials such as fesc ( section [ sec.intro ] ) , require us to probe fine regimes and precisely determine possible experimental signatures of exotic phases such as fflo ( section [ sec.theory_ph ] ) . by conducting our calculations in momentum space , and by fully exploiting the symmetries of the system , we are able to increase the size of the studied system by two orders of magnitude compared to previously reported results and
practically eliminate finite size effects .
the cost is borne by the increased complexity of the efficient custom - tailored gpu implementation , described in section [ sec.algorithm ] . our method shown here on the example of an iron - based multi - band superconductor exhibiting a fflo phase ,
can also be used in calculations of the ground state in standard bcs - type superconductors .
overall , we achieved a 19x speedup compared to the cpu implementation ( 119x compared a single cpu core ) . in the spectrum of gpu - accelerated results in physics ,
this puts us towards the higher end , with the highest speedups being @xmath98x for compute - bound problems with large inherent parallelism .
d.c . is supported by the forszt phd fellowship , co - funded by the european social fund .
is supported by the ncn project dec-2011/01/n / st3/02473 .
the authors would like to thank nvidia for providing hardware resources for development and benchmarking .
the model of fesc proposed by raghu _
et al . _ in ref .
@xcite , is a minimal two - band model of iron - base pnictides describing the @xmath99 and @xmath100 orbitals with hybridization : @xmath101 where @xmath102 , @xmath103 , @xmath104 , @xmath105 .
@xmath106 is the energy unit .
half - filling , a configuration with two electrons per site requires @xmath107 .
the model is exactly diagonalizable , with eigenvalues : @xmath108 the spectrum @xmath109 reproduces the band structure and fermi surface of fesc for @xmath110 we get the electron - like ( hole - like ) band .
this model of fesc was proposed by daghofer _ et al . _ in ref .
@xcite and improved in ref .
@xcite . beyond the @xmath99 and @xmath100 orbitals
, the model also accounts for the @xmath111 orbital : @xmath112 in ref .
@xcite the hopping parameters in electron volts are given as : @xmath113 , @xmath114 , @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath117 , @xmath118 , @xmath119 , @xmath120 , @xmath121 , @xmath122 , @xmath123 , @xmath124 and @xmath125 .
the average number of particles in the system @xmath126 is attained for @xmath127 .
the fs for this model is shown in fig .
[ fig.fsdag ] .
the static cooper pair susceptibility indicates the possible formation of the fflo phase : @xcite @xmath128 where @xmath129 is the retarded green s function and @xmath130 is the op in band @xmath19 .
the operator @xmath131 in real space corresponds to the operator @xmath132 in momentum space .
the factor @xmath133 defines the op symmetries for @xmath3 pairing , @xmath134 is equal to @xmath135 for next nearest neighbors and zero otherwise .
@xcite in momentum space : @xmath136 @xmath137 where @xmath138 is the structure factor corresponding to the @xmath3-wave symmetry , and @xmath139 is the fermi function . this quantity can be calculated numerically similarly to the procedure used for free energy in section [ sec.theory_ph ] .
j. a. anderson , c. d. lorenz , a. travesset , general purpose molecular dynamics simulations fully implemented on graphics processing units , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jcp.2008.01.047[j .
* 227 * ( 2008 ) 5342 ] t. preis , p. virnau , p. wolfgang and j. j. schneider , gpu accelerated monte carlo simulation of the 2d and 3d ising model , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jcp.2009.03.018[j .
comput . phys .
* 228 * ( 2009 ) 4468 ] y. kamihara , t. watanabe , m. hirano , h. hosono , iron - based layered superconductor @xmath142feas$ ] ( x = 0.05 - 0.12 ) with @xmath143 = 26 k , http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/ja800073m[j .
chem . soc .
* 130 * ( 2008 ) 3296 ] i.i .
mazin , d.j .
singh , m.d .
johannes , m.h .
du , unconventional superconductivity with a sign reversal in the order parameter of @xmath144 , http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevlett.101.057003[phys .
* 101 * ( 2008 ) 057003 ] j. kunes , r. arita , p. wissgott , a. toschi , h. ikeda , k. held , wien2wannier : from linearized augmented plane waves to maximally localized wannier functions , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cpc.2010.08.005[comput .
* 181 * ( 2010 ) 1888 ] d. j. singh , m .- h .
du , density functional study of @xmath145 : a low carrier density superconductor near itinerant magnetism , http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevlett.100.237003[phys .
* 100 * ( 2008 ) 237003 ] s. graser , t. a. maier , p. j. hirschfeld , d. j. scalapino , near - degeneracy of several pairing channels in multiorbital models for the fe pnictides , http://stacks.iop.org/1367-2630/11/i=2/a=025016[new j. phys .
* 11 * ( 2009 ) 025016 ] k. kuroki , s. onari , r. arita , h. usui , y. tanaka , h. kontani , h. aoki , unconventional pairing originating from the disconnected fermi surfaces of superconducting @xmath145 , http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevlett.101.087004[phys .
* 101 * ( 2008 ) 087004 ] l. pan , j. li , y. y. tai , m. j. graf , j. x. zhu , c. s. ting , evolution of the fermi surface topology in doped 122 iron pnictides , http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevb.88.214510[phys .
b * 88 * ( 2013 ) 214510 ] h. ding , p. richard , k. nakayama , k. sugawara , t. arakane , y. sekiba , a. takayama , s. souma , t. sato , t. takahashi , z. wang , x. dai , z. fang , g. f. chen , j. l. luo , n. l. wang , observation of fermi - surface dependent nodeless superconducting gaps in @xmath146 , http://stacks.iop.org/0295-5075/83/i=4/a=47001[europhys . lett .
* 83 * ( 2008 ) 47001 ] y. y. tai , j. x zhu , m. j. graf , c. s. ting , calculated phase diagram of doped bafe2as2 superconductor in a c4-symmetry breaking model , http://dx.doi.org/10.1209/0295-5075/103/67001[europhys
* 103 * ( 2013 ) 67001 ] a. ptok , influence of @xmath3 symmetry on unconventional superconductivity in pnictides above the pauli limit two - band model study , http://dx.doi.org/10.1140/epjb/e2013-41007-2[eur .
j. b * 87 * ( 2014 ) 2 ] s. raghu , x. l. qi , c. x. liu , d. j. scalapino , s. c. zhang , minimal two - band model of the superconducting iron oxypnictides , http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevb.77.220503[phys .
b * 77 * ( 2008 ) 220503(r ) ] t. kondo , a. f. santander - syro , o. copie , c. liu , m. e. tillman , e. d. mun , j. schmalian , s. l. budko , m. a. tanatar , p. c. canfield , a. kaminski , momentum dependence of the superconducting gap in @xmath147 single crystals measured by angle resolved photoemission spectroscopy , http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevlett.101.147003[phys .
* 101 * ( 2008 ) 147003 ] v. cvetkovic , z. tesanovic , valley density - wave and multiband superconductivity in iron - based pnictide superconductors , http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevb.80.024512[phys .
b * 80 * ( 2009 ) 024512 ] c. liua , t. kondoa , a.d .
palczewskia , g.d .
samolyuka , y. leea , m.e .
tillmana , ni nia , e.d .
muna , r. gordona , a.f .
santander - syrob , c , s.l .
budkoa , j.l .
mcchesneyd , e. rotenbergd , a.v .
fedorovd , t. vallae , o. copief , m.a .
tanatara , c. martina , b.n .
harmona , p.c .
canfielda , r. prozorova , j. schmaliana , a. kaminskia , electronic properties of iron arsenic high temperature superconductors revealed by angle resolved photoemission spectroscopy ( arpes ) , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.physc.2009.03.050[physica c * 469 * ( 2009 ) 491 ] h. kim , m. a. tanatar , y. j. song , y. s. kwon , r. prozorov , nodeless two - gap superconducting state in single crystals of the stoichiometric iron pnictide lifeas , http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevb.83.100502[phys .
b * 83 * ( 2011 ) 100502(r ) ] s. khim , b. lee , j.w .
kim , e.s .
choi , g.r .
stewart , k.h .
kim , pauli - limiting effects in the upper critical fields of a clean lifeas single crystal , http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevb.84.104502[phys .
b * 84 * ( 2011 ) 104502 ] k. cho , h. kim , m.a .
tanatar , y.j .
song , y.s .
kwon , w.a .
coniglio , c.c .
agosta , a. gurevich , r. prozorov , anisotropic upper critical field and possible fulde - ferrel - larkin - ovchinnikov state in the stoichiometric pnictide superconductor lifeas , http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevb.83.060502[phys .
b * 83 * ( 2011 ) 060502(r ) ] j. l. zhang , l. jiao , f. f. balakirev , x. c. wang , c. q. jin , and h. q. yuan , upper critical field and its anisotropy in lifeas , http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevb.83.174506[phys . rev .
b * 83 * ( 2011 ) 174506 ] n. kurita , k. kitagawa , k. matsubayashi , a. kismarahardja , e .- s .
choi , j. s. brooks , y. uwatoko , s. uji , t. terashima , determination of the upper critical field of a single crystal lifeas : the magnetic torque study up to 35 tesla , http://jpsj.ipap.jp/link?jpsj/80/013706/[j .
* 80 * ( 2011 ) 013706 ] t. terashima , k. kihou , m. tomita , s. tsuchiya , n. kikugawa , s. ishida , c .- h .
lee , a. iyo , h. eisaki , s. uji , first - order superconducting resistive transition in @xmath148 , http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevb.84.184513[phys .
b * 87 * ( 2013 ) 184513 ] y. matsuda , k. izawa and i. vekhter , nodal structure of unconventional superconductors probed by angle resolved thermal transport measurements , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0953-8984/18/44/r01[j .
phys . : condens .
matter * 18 * ( 2006 ) r705 ] a. ptok , m. m. maka , m. mierzejewski , the fulde - ferrell - larkin - ovchinnikov phase in the presence of pair hopping interaction , http://stacks.iop.org/0953-8984/21/i=29/a=295601[j .
phys . : condens .
matter * 21 * ( 2009 ) 295601 ] j. kaczmarczyk , and j. spaek , superconductivity in an almost localized fermi liquid of quasiparticles with spin - dependent masses and effective - field induced by electron correlations , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevb.79.214519 [ phys .
b * 79 * ( 2009 ) 214519 ] j. kaczmarczyk and j. spaek , unconventional superconducting phases in a correlated two - dimensional fermi gas of nonstandard quasiparticles : a simple model , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0953-8984/22/35/355702[j . phys . : condens .
matter * 22 * ( 2010 ) 355702 ] m. m. maka , m. mierzejewski , j. kaczmarczyk and j. spaek , superconducting bardeen - cooper - schrieffer versus fulde - ferrell - larkin - ovchinnikov states of heavy quasiparticles with spin - dependent masses and kondo - type pairing , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevb.82.054509 [ phys .
b * 82 * ( 2010 ) 054509 ] j. kaczmarczyk , m. sadzikowski , j. spaek , conductance spectroscopy of correlated superconductor in magnetic field in the pauli limit : evidence for strong correlations , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevb.84.094525[phys . rev .
b * 84 * ( 2011 ) 094525 ] q. wang , c. r. hu , c. s. ting , impurity effects on the quasiparticle spectrum of the fulde - ferrell - larkin - ovchinnikov state of a d - wave superconductor http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevb.74.212501[phys . rev .
b * 74 * ( 2006 ) 212501 ] q. wang , c. r. hu , c. s. ting , impurity - induced configuration - transition in the fulde - ferrell - larkin - ovchinnikov state of a d - wave superconductor http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevb.75.184515[phys . rev .
b * 75 * ( 2007 ) 184515 ] f. loder , a. p. kampf , and t. kopp , superconducting state with a finite - momentum pairing mechanism in zero external magnetic field http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevb.81.020511[phys . rev .
b 81 , ( 2010 ) 020511(r ) ] c. tarantini , a. gurevich , j. jaroszynski , f. balakirev , e. bellingeri , i. pallecchi , c. ferdeghini , b. shen , h.h .
wen , d.c .
larbalestier , significant enhancement of upper critical fields by doping and strain in iron - based superconductors , http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevb.84.184522[phys .
b * 84 * ( 2011 ) 184522 ] p. burger , f. hardy , d. aoki , a. e. bhmer , r. eder , r. heid , t. wolf , p. schweiss , r. fromknecht , m. j. jackson , c. paulsen , c. meingast , strong pauli - limiting behavior of hc2 and uniaxial pressure dependencies in @xmath150 , http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevb.88.014517[phys . rev .
b * 88 * , ( 2013 ) 014517 ] d. a. zocco , k. grube , f. eilers , t. wolf , h. v. lhneysen , pauli - limited multiband superconductivity in @xmath150 , http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevlett.111.057007[phys . rev .
lett . * 111 * , ( 2013 ) 057007 ] m. takahashi , t. mizushima , k. machida , multiband effects on fulde - ferrell - larkin - ovchinnikov states of pauli - limited superconductors , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevb.89.064505[phys .
b * 89 * ( 2014 ) 064505 ] d. crivelli , a. ptok , unconventional superconductivity in iron - based superconductors in a three - band model , http://przyrbwn.icm.edu.pl/app/abstr/126/a126-4a-3.html[acta physica polonica a * 126 * ( 2014 ) a16 ] m. mierzejewski , a. ptok , m. m. maka , mutual enhancement of magnetism and fulde - ferrell - larkin - ovchinnikov superconductivity in @xmath151 , http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevb.80.174525[phys . rev .
b * 80 * ( 2010 ) 174525 ] f. loder , a. p. kampf , t. kopp , crossover from hc / e to hc/2e current oscillations in rings of s - wave superconductors , http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevb.78.174526[phys . rev .
b. * 78 * ( 2008 ) 174526 ] t. zhou , d. zhang , and c. s. ting , spin - density wave and asymmetry of coherence peaks in iron pnictide superconductors from a two - orbital model , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevb.81.052506[phys .
b * 81 * ( 2010 ) 052506 ] g. litak , p. miller and b.l .
gyffy , a recursion method for solving the bogoliubov equations for inhomogeneous superconductors , http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0921453495004386[phys .
c * 251 * ( 1995 ) 263 ] l. covaci , f. m. peeters , and m. berciu , efficient numerical approach to inhomogeneous superconductivity : the chebyshev - bogoliubov21de gennes method http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevlett.105.167006[phys . rev .
* 105 * ( 2010 ) 167006 ] y. nagai , n. nakai and m. machida , direct numerical demonstration of sign - preserving quasiparticle interference via an impurity inside a vortex core in an unconventional superconductor , http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/physrevb.85.092505[phys .
b * 85 * ( 2012 ) 092505 ] y. nagai , y. ota and m. machida , efficient numerical self - consistent mean - field approach for fermionic many - body systems by polynomial expansion on spectral density , http://dx.doi.org/10.1143/jpsj.81.024710[j . phys .
. jpn . * 81 * ( 2012 ) 024710 ] y. nagai , y. shinohara , y. futamura , y. ota and sakurai , tetsuya , numerical construction of a low - energy effective hamiltonian in a self - consistent bogoliubov - de gennes approach of superconductivity , http://journals.jps.jp/doi/pdf/10.7566/jpsj.82.094701[j .
* 82 * ( 2013 ) 094701 ] b. cloutier , b. k. muite , and p. rigge , performance of fortran and c gpu extensions for a benchmark suite of fourier pseudospectral algorithms , http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/saahpc.2012.24[proceedings of saahpc ( 2012 ) 145148 ] | obtaining a thermodynamically accurate phase diagram through numerical calculations is a computationally expensive problem that is crucially important to understanding the complex phenomena of solid state physics , such as superconductivity . in this work
we show how this type of analysis can be significantly accelerated through the use of modern gpus .
we illustrate this with a concrete example of free energy calculation in multi - band iron - based superconductors , known to exhibit a superconducting state with oscillating order parameter ( op ) .
our approach can also be used for classical bcs - type superconductors . with a customized algorithm and compiler tuning
we are able to achieve a 19x speedup compared to the cpu ( 119x compared to a single cpu core ) , reducing calculation time from minutes to mere seconds , enabling the analysis of larger systems and the elimination of finite size effects .
fflo , pnictides , nvidia cuda , pgi cuda fortran , superconductivity * program summary * _ manuscript title : _ gpu - based acceleration of free energy calculations in solid state physics + _ authors : _ micha januszewski , andrzej ptok , dawid crivelli , bartomiej gardas + _ journal reference : _ + _ catalogue identifier : _
+ _ licensing provisions : lgplv3 _ + _ programming language : _ fortran ,
cuda c + _ computer : _ any with a cuda - compliant gpu + _ operating system : _ no limits ( tested on linux ) + _ ram : _ typically tens of megabytes .
+ _ keywords : _ superconductivity , fflo , cuda , openmp , openacc , free energy + _ classification : _ 7 , 6.5 + _ nature of problem : _ gpu - accelerated free energy calculations in multi - band iron - based superconductor models .
+ _ solution method : _ parallel parameter space search for a global minimum of free energy .
+ _ unusual features : _
+ the same core algorithm is implemented in fortran with openmp and openacc compiler annotations , as well as in cuda c. the original fortran implementation targets the cpu architecture , while the cuda c version is hand - optimized for modern gpus . + _ running time : _ problem - dependent , up to several seconds for a single value of momentum and a linear lattice size on the order of @xmath0 . |
galactic winds are observed to be ubiquitous in galaxies that have recently experienced significant amounts star formation ( see e.g. , * ? ? ? * for a review ) .
these outflows represent a fundamental part of galaxy formation models , because the absence of outflows galaxy star formation rates ( sfrs ) are much higher than those observed ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) and baryon fractions in the disk are close to the universal value ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , much higher than inferred from observations . in contrast , models that include a variety of feedback effects predict much lower sfrs and baryon fractions . additionally , outflows are required to drive metal - enriched gas out of galaxies , as suggested by both observational ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) and theoretical ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) work .
however , despite their key role in galaxy formation , the exact processes driving winds remain an open question .
plausible driving mechanisms include core collapse supernovae ( sn , * ? ? ?
* ) and radiation pressure @xcite .
sn - driven winds are now routinely included in semi - analytic and numerical simulations .
however , it has long been known that in the disk of the galaxy there is a rough equipartition of the magnetic and cosmic ray ( cr ) energy densities ( e.g * ? ? ?
this indicates that crs play a significant role in dynamics of interstellar medium .
only relatively recently have the effects of crs have been considered in the context of galaxy formation ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and galaxy cluster @xcite simulations .
a tight link between crs and star formation is evidenced by the correlation between a galaxy s infra - red luminosity , closely related to its sfr , and the luminosity of its radio halo ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the relationship is almost linear , has very little scatter , and does not evolve with redshift @xcite , indicating that the coupling between star formation and crs is robust over a wide variety of conditions .
although the energy injection rate of crs is small when compared to the other sources of energy from star formation , the rate at which they inject momentum is not @xcite .
this is because the crs that supply most of the pressure in the galaxy generate alfvn waves in the ism @xcite , which then scatter the crs with a mean free path of @xmath3pc .
crs are self - confined ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , and it takes @xmath4myr for a typical cr to escape its parent galaxy .
theoretical models of dynamical haloes in which crs diffuse and are advected out in a galactic wind predict steady , supersonic galaxy - scale outflows driven by a combination of cr and thermal pressure @xcite . in this letter we present high - resolution hydrodynamical simulations of isolated disk galaxies , including a model for the injection , transport and decay of crs , to investigate how outflows are driven by crs and the properties of the outflowing gas .
our simulations are performed with the adaptive - mesh - refinement ( amr ) code ramses , described in @xcite .
the detailed description of physical processes included in our simulations star formation , radiative cooling , and metal enrichment from type ia sne , type ii sne and intermediate mass stars can be found in @xcite .
sn feedback is modelled by injecting a total of @xmath5ergs of thermal energy per sn into the cells neighbouring the star particle .
we do not employ any delay of dissipation for the injected energy in these runs ( the runs are equivalent to the energy only run in * ? ? ?
a full description of the cr field would require modelling the distribution function of crs as a function of position , momentum and time .
however , if the cr mean free path is shorter than the length scale of the problem , the cr field can be described as a fluid @xcite .
we thus take the approach of modelling the cr energy density , @xmath6 , as an additional energy field that advects passively with the gas density ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) and exerts a pressure @xmath7 .
thus , the total pressure entering the momentum and energy equations governing gas evolution is @xmath8 .
we assume throughout that the cr fluid is an ultra relatavistic ideal gas with @xmath9 .
as described above , crs undergo a random walk through the ism after their injection .
their evolution is thus a combination of advection with the ambient gas flow and diffusion , which we parametrize by the diffusion coefficient , @xmath10 .
the evolution of baryon and cr fluids is thus governed by the standard continuity and momentum equations and the following energy equations : @xmath11 @xmath12 where @xmath13 is gas velocity , @xmath14 , @xmath15 and @xmath16 , @xmath17 are the pressure and internal energy of gas and crs , respectively . the @xmath18 indicates energy injection by sn , and @xmath19 is the fraction of this energy that is injected in the form of crs .
@xmath20 indicates radiative cooling of gas , while @xmath21 indicates the heating of gas by both crs and uv radiation .
finally , @xmath22 corresponds to energy losses by crs both due to decays and coulomb interactions with gas mediated by magnetic fields ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
following @xcite we assume that the cr cooling rate is : @xmath23 where @xmath24 is the local electron number density .
the ratio of the catastrophic cooling rate to the couloumb cooling rate for our cr population is 3.55 .
some fraction of the energy lost by the cr population heats the thermal gas ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) at a rate given by @xcite @xmath25 equations [ eq : crcool ] and [ eq : crheat ] are solved on every timestep to calculate the rate of decay of the cr energy density along with the corresponding gain in the gas thermal energy .
we have tested our cr implementation using a standard shock - tube test involving gas and cr fluids @xcite and found that results accurately match the analytic solution .
results of this and other tests will be presented in a forthcoming paper .
strong shock waves associated with sn explosions have long been recognized as a likely source of galactic crs ( e.g. * ? ? ?
empirically , in order to match the galactic energy density in crs , sne must be capable of transferring a fraction @xmath26 of the explosion kinetic energy into the form of cr energy @xcite . in our models
we make the assumption that a certain fraction , @xmath27 , of the sn energy is injected to the cr fluid energy density . the remaining fraction @xmath28 is injected thermally into the gas field .
we note that the assumptions that the diffusion of crs is isotropic and that the diffusion coefficient is a constant are necessary simplification in our models , which track neither the direction nor the strength of the magnetic field . on small scales ( @xmath29100 pc ) ,
the strength of the random component of the galactic magnetic field is several times higher than the average field strength ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) because galaxy formation processes ( e.g. supernovae and hydrodynamical turbulence ) in the disk @xcite and the turbulent dynamo effect and cr buoyancy in the halo @xcite tangle the magnetic field to the extent that isotropic diffusion is a good approximation(e.g .
codes that assume isotropic diffusion are able to predict cr - emitted spectral data down to the few percent level ( e.g * ? ? ?
for the purposes of this exploratory work we employ the isotropic diffusion model , but note that investigation of complex models represents an interesting future direction for this work .
we simulate isolated , model galaxies of two different masses representing an smc - sized dwarf galaxy and mw - sized disk galaxy with three different feedback models : no feedback , thermal feedback only , and thermal plus cr feedback .
the thermal feedback runs inject @xmath30 of the energy released by each sn blast into the gas thermal energy .
the cr feedback runs inject @xmath31 of the sn energy into the gas thermal energy and the remaining @xmath32 into the cr energy density field .
every simulation models radiative cooling , star - formation and metal enrichment .
all runs are evolved for 0.5gyr and throughout this letter we report results for this time . following @xcite and @xcite the galaxy model consists of a dark matter halo , a stellar bulge and an exponential disc of stars and gas .
the dark matter halo is modelled as an nfw halo @xcite .
the gas and stars are then initialized into an exponential disk , and the bulge is assumed to have a @xcite profile with a scale length that is 10% of the disk scale length .
the relevant parameters for each set of initial conditions are given in table [ tab : ics ] .
each simulation is run with a maximum spatial resolution of 75pc ( 37.5pc ) for the mw ( smc ) runs .
[ cols= " > , < , > , > , > , > , < , < , < , > , > " , ] + notes : from left to right the columns contain : ( 1 ) simulation set name ; ( 2 ) spherical overdensity dm halo mass defined relative to the 200 times the critical density at @xmath33 ; ( 3 ) circular velocity at the virial radius ; ( 4 ) concentration of nfw halo ; ( 5 ) halo spin parameter ; ( 6 ) disk gas fraction ; ( 7 ) mass of gas in the disk ; ( 8) mass of stars in the disk ; ( 9 ) mass of stars in the bulge ; ( 10 ) scale length of exponential disk ; ( 11 ) scale height of gas disk . + [ tab : ics ]
the solid curves show the mass loading factor , @xmath34 , of the galactic wind , defined as the ratio of the sfr to the gas outflow rate , as a function of time ( left - hand axis ) .
the dotted curves show the galaxy sfr ( right - hand axis ) .
the color of each curve denotes the feedback model and the top ( bottom ) panel shows results for the smc ( mw ) simulation . the no - feedback model ( black curves )
is not shown on the mass - loading plot because there is a net inflow of gas at all times .
both feedback models predict mass loadings of @xmath35 for the mw galaxy , but the cr feedback is capable of suppressing the sfr by a larger fraction than the thermal feedback model . in the smc galaxy
the cr feedback model is capable of driving galactic winds with large ( @xmath36 ) mass loadings and suppresses the sfr significantly more than thermal feedback alone .
+ ] we begin by considering the sfrs of the simulated galaxies in fig .
[ fig : ml ] .
the sfr in simulations without feedback is higher than in simulations with feedback and is higher than typically observed sfrs of galaxies of these sizes .
simulations with crs suppress sfr compared to simulations with thermal sn feedback only , especially in the smc - sized galaxy .
this is because crs act as a source of pressure in the galaxy disk .
this significantly changes the density pdf of the gas in the disk reducing the fraction of mass in star forming regions .
outflow efficiency can be parametrized by the mass loading factor , @xmath34 , defined as the ratio of the gas outflow rate to the sfr .
the solid curves in fig .
[ fig : ml ] show @xmath34 as a function of time for different simulations .
outflow rates are measured as the instantaneous mass flux through the plane parallel to the galactic disk at a height of 20kpc . in the mw simulation
the mass loading is approximately 0.5 in both simulations , whereas in the smc simulation the mass loading is @xmath37 in the simulation with crs and only @xmath38 in the simulation with thermal feedback only .
this indicates that crs greatly enhance efficiency of outflows from dwarf galaxies .
velocity of the outflowing gas ( @xmath39 ) as a function of halo circular velocity .
the gray points show the observations of @xcite ( downward pointing triangles ) and @xcite ( upward pointing triangles ) .
the solid points show simulation predictions .
the squares ( circles ) show the mw ( smc ) simulations and the colors denote the feedback model . in both galaxies ,
the outflows in the cr feedback models ( blue points ) have velocities comparable to the obserations , whereas the thermal feedback models ( red points ) overestimate the wind velocity by a large factor .
+ ] figure [ fig : vz ] shows velocity of the outflowing gas , @xmath40 , as a function of the circular velocity of the halo , @xmath41 , compared to observations of cool wind gas around dwarf galaxies @xcite and @xmath42 starburst dominated galaxies @xcite .
we measure outflow velocities by projecting the gas field perpendicular to the disk and calculating the velocity that contains 90% of the cool ( @xmath43k ) gas . in each galaxy
the thermal feedback simulation predicts outflow velocities that are significantly larger than those observed whereas the cr runs are comparable to the observations . finally , fig .
[ fig : im ] shows the temperature of the outflowing gas in a thin slice through the centre of the simulated galaxies ( left ) .
the notable difference between simulations is that wind in the cr simulation is considerably cooler , especially in the smc simulation .
the panels to the right of this figure show the profiles of velocity and outward pressure gradient .
the thermal feedback run has winds that accelerate abruptly from the galactic disk up to @xmath44km / s and thereafter have a constant velocity .
the cr simulations , however show a wind that accelerates smoothly into the halo .
the reason for this is revealed in the right - hand panels , where it is immediately apparent that the pressure gradient in the halo with crs is a factor of 3 - 10 larger in the cr simulation than in the thermal feedback simulation ( the difference is particularly striking in the smc simulation ) .
these results illustrate that the wind properties in the simulations with crs are qualitatively different properties to the wind driven by thermal sn feedback .
our simulations show that energy injection in the form of crs is a promising feedback process that can substantially aid in driving outflows from star - forming galaxies .
first , we find that cr injection can suppress the sfr by providing an extra source of pressure that stabilizes the disk .
turbulent and cr pressure are in equipartition in the disk , thus the cr pressure can significantly affect most of the volume of the disk , but will be sub - dominant inside supersonic molecular clouds , where turbulent pressure dominates over both cr and thermal presure , particularly in the dwarf galaxy .
the sfrs measured in our galaxies with cr feedback are comparable to observed sfrs for both the mw and the smc .
second , we find that addition of the cr feedback increases the mass loading factor , @xmath34 , in the dwarf galaxy by a factor of ten compared to the simulation with sn only feedback . as a result ,
the smc and mw - sized galaxies ( circular velocities of @xmath45 and @xmath46 km / s , respectively ) have mass loading factors that differ by a factor of @xmath47 , depending on the stage of evolution .
this is in rough agreement with expectations from theoretical models based on simulations and semi - analytic models , which show that dependence @xmath48 with @xmath49 is needed to reproduce the observed faint end of the galaxy stellar mass function and other properties of the galaxy population ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
. moreover , the wind velocities in the smc and mw - sized simulated galaxies are consistent with the observed trend for galaxies in this mass range @xcite both in normalization and slope .
although we have reported only two models , these results are encouraging , especially because simulation parameters have not been tuned to reproduce these observations .
perhaps the most intriguing difference of the cr - driven winds compared to the winds driven by thermal sn feedback is that they contain significantly more `` warm '' @xmath2 k gas .
this is especially true for the dwarf galaxy , which develops a wind strikingly colder than in the sn - only simulation ( see fig . [
fig : im ] ) .
the cr - driven wind has a lower velocity , and is accelerated gradually with vertical distance from the disk .
the reason for these differences is that the gas ejected from the disk is accelerated not only near star - forming regions , as is the case in sn - only simulations , but is continuously accelerated by the pressure gradient established by crs diffused outside of the disk ( see fig .
[ fig : im ] ) .
the diffusion of crs is thus a key factor in ejecting winds and in their resulting colder temperatures .
the cooler temperatures of the ejected gas may be one of the most intriguing new features of the cr - driven winds , as this may provide a clue on the origin of ubiquitous warm gas in gaseous halos of galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * and references therein ) .
detailed predictions of cgm properties will require cosmological galaxy formation simulations incorporating cr feedback , which we will pursue in future work .
several studies have explored effects of cr injection on galaxies .
@xcite found that crs suppress the sfr in dwarf galaxies by an amount comparable to our simulations , but have almost no effect on the sfr of mw - sized systems .
we find significant sfr suppression for both masses . additionally , @xcite found that crs did not generate winds with diffusion alone and in a recent study using a similar model @xcite argued that to launch winds cr streaming is crucial .
in contrast , we find that cr - driven winds are established with cr diffusion alone .
these differences likely arise due to assumption of equilibrium between the sources of crs ( star formation @xmath50 ) and the sinks ( catastrophic losses @xmath51 ) in the subgrid model of @xcite .
the subgrid model thus predicts that cr pressure scales as @xmath52 and is subdominant to the thermal ism pressure at densities @xmath53@xmath54 ( see fig .
7 of * ? ? ?
this assumption of equilibrium , which is likely true only in the deepest parts of the galaxy potential well ( see e.g. the discussion in * ? ? ?
* ) , breaks down in lower density gas . in our simulations
we do not assume such equilibrium and we find significant pressure contributions from crs up to much higher densities .
our results thus indicate that crs , even in the diffusion limit , not only suppress star formation but also drive outflows efficiently .
thus , the effects of cr feedback on the properties of galaxies of different masses should be significantly stronger and span a wider range of masses than simulations that use the @xcite model ( e.g. * ? ? ?
while this manuscript was in a late stage of preparation @xcite appeared as a preprint .
these authors have presented simulations of a mw - sized galaxy , similar to the model presented here , albeit without accounting for cr cooling losses and with a much larger sfr in their model galaxy ( up to @xmath55 . where our results overlap ( e.g. , mass - loading factor ) with those of @xcite we find remarkably good agreement .
these authors also find that outflows are efficiently generated with cr diffusion alone .
our study extends the results of @xcite by presenting the differences between wind properties in dwarf and mw - sized systems .
the results of @xcite and our study indicate that crs can significantly suppress star formation in galaxies and efficiently drive outflows with significant mass loading factors and velocities comparable to observed outflows .
a detailed exploration of the effects of such feedback on the galaxy population in a full cosmological setting is therefore extremely interesting .
ng and ak were supported via nsf grant oci-0904482 .
ak was supported by nasa atp grant nnh12zda001n and by the kavli institute for cosmological physics at the university of chicago through grants nsf phy-0551142 and phy-1125897 and an endowment from the kavli foundation and its founder fred kavli . | we present results from high - resolution hydrodynamic simulations of isolated smc- and milky way - sized galaxies that include a model for feedback from galactic cosmic rays ( crs ) .
we find that crs are naturally able to drive winds with mass loading factors of up to @xmath0 in dwarf systems .
the scaling of the mass loading factor with circular velocity between the two simulated systems is consistent with @xmath1 required to reproduce the faint end of the galaxy luminosity function .
in addition , simulations with cr feedback reproduce both the normalization and the slope of the observed trend of wind velocity with galaxy circular velocity .
we find that winds in simulations with cr feedback exhibit qualitatively different properties compared to sn driven winds , where most of acceleration happens violently in situ near star forming sites .
the cr - driven winds are accelerated gently by the large - scale pressure gradient established by crs diffusing from the star - forming galaxy disk out into the halo .
the cr - driven winds also exhibit much cooler temperatures and , in the smc - sized system , warm ( @xmath2 k ) gas dominates the outflow .
the prevalence of warm gas in such outflows may provide a clue as to the origin of ubiquitous warm gas in the gaseous halos of galaxies detected via absorption lines in quasar spectra . |
x - ray emission is a major contributor to the observed spectrum of seyfert galaxies , and yet the physics of the emitting region is still not well understood .
the most common and ( thus far ) successful approach to this problem , to which we shall refer as the ` spectral approach ' ( sa ) , makes very simple assumptions about the geometry and/or the particle heating mechanisms , but uses a detailed microphysical approach to account for the particle - photon interactions and to derive the spectrum .
this spectrum is then compared with the observations in order to place constraints on the parameters of the emitting regions .
the early models assumed a non - thermal pair dominated plasma .
( for a comprehensive review of non - thermal models see svensson 1994 . )
however , with the more recent substantial progress made in the x - ray observation of seyfert galaxies ( e.g. , jourdain et al .
1992 ; johnson et al .
1993 ) , it is now evident that thermal models are strongly favored by the data .
accordingly , much of the current attention is focused on thermal models ( svensson 1996a ) . aside from the question concerning the nature of the particle distribution
, there is also the issue regarding the emitter s geometry .
haardt & maraschi ( 1991 , 1993 ) argued that if most of the energy is dissipated in a hot corona overlying a cold accretion disk , then the resulting spectrum naturally explains many of the observed features in these sources .
in particular , roughly half of the coronal x - ray emission is directed towards the cold disk , where it gets absorbed and re - emitted as uv radiation , which then re - enters the corona and contributes to the cooling of the electrons .
thus , the lepton cooling rate becomes proportional to the heating rate . in this case
, the inverse compton up - scattering of the uv radiation leads to an almost universal x - ray spectral index , consistent with the observations ( e.g. , according to nandra & pounds 1994 , @xmath2 for a sample of seyfert galaxies ) .
the hardening of the spectrum above about 10 kev ( nandra & pounds 1994 ) and a broad hump at @xmath3 50 kev ( e.g. , zdziarski et al 1995 ) are accounted for by reflection of the hard x - rays in the cold disk .
however , observationally the hard x - ray luminosity , @xmath4 , can be a few times smaller than the luminosity , @xmath5 , in the soft uv - component .
this is inconsistent with the uniform two - phase disk coronal model , because the latter predicts about the same luminosity in both x - rays and uv ( due to the fact that all the uv radiation arises as a consequence of reprocessing of the hard x - ray flux , which is about equal in the upward and downward directions ) . to overcome this apparent difficulty ,
haardt , maraschi & ghisellini ( 1994 ) introduced a patchy disk - coronal model , which assumes that the x - ray emitting region consists of separate active regions(ar ) independent of each other . in this case , a portion of the reprocessed as well as intrinsic radiation from the cold disk escapes to the observer directly , rather than entering ars , thus allowing for a greater ratio of @xmath6 .
recently , stern et al . ( 1995 ) and poutanen & svensson ( 1996a ) carried out state of the art calculations of the radiative transport of the anisotropic polarized radiation , for a range of ar geometries .
they showed that this type of model indeed reproduces the observed x - ray spectral slope , the compactness , and the high - energy cutoff .
the model has very few parameters , namely , the compactness and the temperature of the intrinsic / reprocessed radiation from the cold disk .
therefore , it appears that the model is very robust in its predictions . on the other hand , another somewhat less common approach to explaining the x - rays from galactic black hole candidates ( gbhc ) and seyfert galaxies , which we shall call the ` magnetic flare ' ( mf ) approach , is being developed by analogy with the strong , energetic ( x - ray emitting ) flares observed on the sun .
a pioneering paper in this field was that of galeev , rosner & vaiana ( 1979 ) , who showed that the physical conditions in an accretion disk surrounding a black hole are such that magnetic fields are likely to grow to equipartition values .
this magnetic field is then transported to the surface of the disk by buoyancy forces where its energy is released in a flare - like event .
the magnetic flare approach is , in a sense , complementary to the spectral approach , in that it attempts to include all the relevant physics self - consistently ( e.g. , de vries & kuijpers 1992 ; van oss , van den oord & kuperus 1993 ; volwerk , van oss & kuijpers 1993 ) .
unfortunately , the physics involved is quite complex and still somewhat open to debate .
the resulting spectrum is a combination of time - averaged components from many different flares , and is subject to many uncertainties clearly the mf model must invoke many more parameters , or assumptions about the magnetic field reconnection , than does the sa approach .
therefore , no detailed spectra from these events ( in the case of seyfert galaxies ) have yet been computed .
one may argue that to make substantial progress , these two approaches need to find an overlap of self - consistency .
in particular , the sa model does not specify the mechanism by which the gravitational energy dissipated within the cold disk is transported out to the optically thin corona .
it is _ assumed _ that some process can provide the needed electron heating , and often a reference is made to magnetic fields .
moreover , the particle dynamics is ignored , imposing instead the artificial constraint that the particles are confined to a closed box .
thus , even though the sa model can reproduce the observed spectrum quite well , the situation is unsatisfactory from a broader theoretical perspective .
correspondingly , it appears that the most important results obtained within the framework of the sa model have not been fully incorporated into the magnetic flare scenarios .
for example , it is well known that the universal x - ray spectral index in seyfert galaxies is best explained by the inverse comptonization of soft uv photons .
this requires a relatively high value of the compactness parameter ( see discussion below ) in the emitting region .
as far as we can tell , no work has yet been done to show ( based on the physics of reconnection or some other mechanism for the transfer of energy from the magnetic field to the particles ) that a specific mf model can indeed provide the needed high compactness during the active phase , though haardt , maraschi & ghisellini ( 1994 , hereafter hmg94 ) did use the physics of magnetic flares to account for the heating rates and the required confinement of the ars .
they showed that the compactness can be high enough during the active phase if one assumes that the entire magnetic field energy is transfered to the particles during a few light - crossing time scales .
they did not , however , explicitly consider the question of how the spectrum from these highly transient phenomena is formed .
more recently , nayakshin & melia ( 1997b ) considered the issue of pressure balance within the plasma trapped inside the flare during the active phase .
they found that under certain conditions , a pressure equilibrium can be maintained in the source if its thomson optical depth is @xmath7 .
they also showed that the current data can not distinguish between a spectrum comprised of a single flare component and one formed from many different flares with a range @xmath8 in @xmath9 . in other words , one can always find a @xmath9 for the spectrum assuming a single flare that represents the composite spectrum quite well out to about 100 kev , where the quality of the data deteriorates .
in addition , nayakshin & melia ( 1997c ) have considered the implications of a time - dependent x - ray reflection and reprocessing by the cold disk underneath the flare .
they find that due to the short lived , but very intense x - ray flux from the ar , the upper layer of the disk is compressed to a density in excess of that found in the disk s mid - plane . under these conditions
, the x - ray reprocessing leads to a temperature of the emitted uv radiation that is roughly independent of the x - ray luminosity and the overall bolometric luminosity of the source , as suggested by the euv - soft x - ray observations ( walter & fink 1993 ; fink et al .
1994 ; zhou et al .
1997 ) . due to the increased gas density in the compressed layer ,
the ionization parameter is smaller than that arising in time - independent x - ray reflection ( i.e. , when the x - ray source is assumed to be stationary a condition that is clearly violated in magnetic flares ) .
this may explain those observations of seyfert galaxies that suggest the presence of a nearly neutral reflector ( zdziarski et al .
1996 ) .
these results strengthen the mf model and motivate us here to attempt to assemble the various components of this picture .
we first discuss the different physical constraints imposed on the ars by both the spectral observations and the physics of the corresponding processes , without necessarily confining our discussion to the mf model .
we will then show that magnetic flares above the cold disk are probably the best candidates for producing these ars , and we discuss the physics of the mf model in greater depth .
we conclude by listing some of the unresolved issues .
our first task here will be to assemble the various constraints imposed on the ars in seyfert galaxies from observations and theoretical considerations . in so doing
, we shall first summarize the better known results , and then discuss the additional constraints that follow from various attempts to construct realistic ars based on the idea that these may be magnetic structures , characterized by a well - defined confinement and energy supply .
the most important parameter of the ar is the compactness @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is the radiation energy flux at the top of the ar and @xmath12 is its typical size .
note that this definition is for the local compactness , i.e. , the one that characterizes the local properties of the plasma , unlike the global compactness @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is the total luminosity of the object and @xmath15 is the typical size of the region that emits this luminosity .
it is the latter that should be compared to the observed compactness rather than the former .
consider the following example .
assume that the emitting region is a full disk - like corona .
in this case the local and global compactnesses are related in this way : @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the coronal scale height , which is unlikely to be larger than the accretion disk scale height , @xmath18 , and so the local compactness @xmath19 can be much smaller than the global one . at the same time , as suggested by the frequently observed large ratio @xmath6 ( e.g. , hmg94 ; svensson 1996a ) , the emitting region can consist of a large number of small localized areas . since the total x - ray luminosity from these ars should be the same as that in the model with a full corona , it is clear that the local compactness of each region must be larger than that of the full corona . in particular , depending on the ratio of the total active area @xmath20 covered by the ars to @xmath21 , the local compactness can be either larger or smaller than the global one .
therefore , even though the observed values of global compactness for seyfert galaxies lie in the range @xmath22 ( done & fabian 1989 ; but see also fabian 1994 ) , one can not argue that the local compactness @xmath19 should be larger than these values based on observations alone . however , a large local compactness is strongly preferred in current pair - dominated two - phase models ( e.g. , svensson 1996a ; zdziarski et al .
1996 ) . to produce the correct spectrum
, @xmath23 should be relatively large ( @xmath1 ) . in the context of the pair - dominated two - phase model ,
the only mechanism for fixing the optical depth is by pair equilibrium , and thus one needs @xmath24 in order to create them , in which case the optical depth of the ars becomes a function of compactness .
however , as we show in 3.3 below , the optical depth of the x - ray emitting regions may be dominated by electrons rather than pairs . for the purposes of setting theoretical limits on the compactness parameter
, this nevertheless implies the same result since both cases require @xmath0 .
in addition , radiation mechanisms put their own limitations on the local compactness .
the fact that the x - ray spectral index for seyfert galaxies lies in a rather narrow range ( nandra & pounds 1994 ) is most naturally explained by the approximately constant compton @xmath25-parameter ( defined in , e.g. , rybicki & lightman 1979 ) .
fabian ( 1994 ) shows that in order for the compton emissivity to dominate over the bremsstrahlung one , the compactness of the plasma should be larger than @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the electron temperature in the units of @xmath28 . for the typical value @xmath29
, this requires that @xmath30 .
note that the gas does not necessarily need to be maxwellian , as long as the optical depth is sufficiently large ( e.g. , ghisellini et al .
1994 ; nayakshin & melia 1997a ) , since then the comptonized spectrum looks very much the same for different electron distributions having the same @xmath25-parameter . moreover , in the presence of a strong magnetic field , the synchrotron self - absorption is an efficient mechanism for thermalizing the electrons , to the extent that it becomes a more important thermalization mechanism than coulomb collisions ( svensson 1996b ; nayakshin & melia 1997a ) .
thus , constraints imposed on the compactness by the coulomb thermalization process ( fabian 1994 ) can be violated . to summarize this section
, we note that all current explanations for the x - ray emission from seyfert galaxies require a large local compactness parameter @xmath0 . as already discussed in the introduction , observational evidence
very strongly favors the geometry of localized x - ray sources above the accretion disk .
we note that this immediately requires the active regions to be transient with a lifetime comparable to ( or less than ) the disk thermal time scale , @xmath31 , where @xmath32 in terms of the sound speed @xmath33 . an integral assumption of the two - phase model is that the internal disk emission is negligible compared with the x - ray flux of the ar , at least during the active phase ( poutanen & svensson 1995 ) . assuming that a fraction ( @xmath1 ) of the total energy content in the surface area of the disk immediately below the ar is transferred into the ar , the time scale for the release of this energy
must then be much shorter than @xmath34 , during which time the disk s internal energy is radiated .
our calculations show that if this condition is not satisfied , then the localized ars actually produce a _
steeper _ spectrum than that of a full corona , due to the enhanced internal emission from regions of the disk that surround the ar .
this is an effect that is neglected in the two - phase corona - disk model .
physically , the internal disk emission provides too much cooling in this case , unless the x - ray emitting region somehow snatches heating power even from disk regions that are not directly below it , which appear to be unrealistic .
the plasma in the ars should be confined during the active phase , otherwise the energy will be lost to the expansion of the plasma rather than producing the x - rays .
not confined , the source would expand at the sound speed ( which turns out to be a fraction of @xmath35 for these conditions ) .
the lifetime of the ar would then be limited to a few light crossing times .
it is not clear that the spectrum from such an expanding and short lived source can resemble anything studied thus far in the literature .
the familiar gravitational confinement , operating in the main part of the accretion disk , does not work here due to several reasons .
first of all , the _ locally _ limited eddington compactness @xmath19 is at most @xmath36 for ars with a roughly semi - spherical shape , where @xmath37 is the positron number density @xmath38 divided by that of the protons @xmath39 , while the relatively large thomson optical depth @xmath40 obtained by zdziarski et al . ( 1996 ) requires a compactness of a few hundred ( if no magnetic field is involved and the particles are confined to a rigid box ) .
second , there is no mechanism for counter balancing a side - ways expansion of the plasma .
therefore , since there seems to be no other reasonable possibility for confinement of the ar plasma , it may be argued that a magnetic field is required to provide the bounding pressure .
any confinement mechanism will fail to confine the plasma for a time longer than about one dynamical time scale for the disk , since adjacent points with slightly different radii are torn apart on this time scale due to the disk s differential rotation .
in addition , if the pairs are important for the model , then the lifetime of the ar should be large enough to allow establishment of the pair equilibrium . to put it another way
, there should be enough time to create enough pairs if the plasma is initially optically thin and proton - dominated .
we experimented with time - dependent codes in which radiation transfer is treated in the frequency - dependent eddington approximation , and found that this condition leads to the requirement that the lifetime of the region should be roughly an order of magnitude longer than the light crossing time for the ar . in the thin disk approximation
one can always satisfy both requirements as long as the size @xmath12 of the ar is of the order of the disk scale height @xmath41 , since @xmath42 , where @xmath33 is the local sound speed .
we should also note that there can be other than pair creation mechanisms for the plasma to adjust its optical depth ( see 3.3 ) , so this constraint is only important when the optical depth is dominated by pairs . to be consistent with the observations and the physics of the two - phase accretion disk - corona model
, one needs very short lived phenomena to occur above the disk s atmosphere .
in fact , the whole evolution of the ar should happen faster than the disk s hydrostatic time scale . to confine the plasma with a high compactness parameter @xmath0
, one needs mechanisms other than gravitational confinement .
we suggest that this points to magnetic flares as the most likely mechanism for the ar formation .
galeev , rosner & vaiana ( 1979 ) showed that magnetic flares are likely to occur on the surface of an accretion disk , since the internal dissipative processes are ineffective in limiting the growth of magnetic field fluctuations .
as a consequence of buoyancy , magnetic flux should be expelled from the disk into a corona , consisting of many magnetic loops , where the energy is stored .
it has also been speculated that just as in the solar case , the magnetically confined , loop - like structures ( which we shall collectively call magnetic flares ; see , e.g. , priest 1982 ) produce the bulk of the x - ray luminosity .
the x - rays are assumed to be created by upscattering of the intrinsic disk emission . since then
, several solar magnetic flare workers have elaborated on this subject ( e.g. , kuperus & ionson 1985 ; burm 1986 ; burm & kuperus 1988 ; stepinski 1991 ; de vries & kuijpers 1992 ; volwerk , van oss & kuijpers 1993 ; van oss , van oord & kuperus 1993 ) .
unfortunately , these models are very much more complicated than simpler plasma models that take into account the detailed interaction of particles and radiation but leave out the question of how the plasma is confined and energy is supplied . thus , although the models invoking magnetic flares above the cold accretion disk have been viable , the detailed spectrum from such a flare could not be computed , and the model has remained somewhat of an abstraction .
an important step forward was that by haardt , maraschi & ghisellini ( 1994 ) , who for the first time attempted to connect the physics of magnetic flares with the observational need for localized active regions above the disk .
however , the actual consideration of the magnetic field structure that confines the plasma to the ar was still missing . furthermore , the amount of energy stored in the magnetic field has been treated as just a parameter , depending on how long and at what rate the energy is supplied to the ar . in reality
, the field value is limited by the equipartition field in the disk ( galeev , rosner & vaiana 1979 ) .
the question of how the pressure equilibrium in the ar ( important when discussing @xmath9 of the source ) is set up has not been discussed .
one of the purposes of this paper is to pay more attention to the magnetic flare model for the x - ray emission from accretion disks in black hole systems in general , and in seyfert galaxies in particular . in the rest of the paper ,
we point out that the mf model can account for many , if not all , of the observed x - ray and uv spectral features of seyfert galaxies .
very importantly , we shall also demonstrate that these flares are physically consistent with the constraints imposed on the ars discussed above . in the standard accretion disk theory
, the gas density has an approximately gaussian vertical profile , and thus it decreases very fast with increasing height .
let us also assume that the magnetic flux tube is rooted in the midplane of the disk .
the `` flare region '' , i.e. , that part of the flux tube above the accretion disk surface , is then dominated by magnetic field pressure .
it is well known that a magnetic field , left to its own devices , tends to fill all the available space ( e.g. , parker 1979 ,
8.4 ) . for the magnetic flux tube rooted in the midplane of the disk
, this means that the tube cross section expands ; the tube is thick in the sense that the cross sectional radius is of the order of the tube length .
the whole structure has a roughly semi - spherical shape ( fig .
1 ) . we note that the observations actually require the magnetic flux tubes to be thick if they are to explain the x - ray emission from seyferts . indeed ,
if the tubes are slim , then most of the photons reflected from the disk will not re - enter the ar , but leave system .
the amount of cooling of the ar due to these photons is then not enough to explain the x - ray indexes of seyfert galaxies from spectral modeling , it is known that the fraction of photons re - entering the ar should be relatively large , @xmath43 ( e.g. , svensson 1996a ) . 0.2 in we
will now assume that by some process ( e.g. , by magnetic reconnection or dissipation of magnetic waves ) the magnetic field energy is being transferred to the particles .
we can estimate the maximum compactness of the ar by the following considerations .
the magnetic field is limited by the equipartition value in the midplane of the disk .
the size of the ar , @xmath12 , is of the order of one turbulent cell , which is at best of the order of the disk scale height @xmath41 .
let us assume that the field annihilation ( which provides the energy transfer to the particles ) occurs on a time scale @xmath44 equal to the light crossing time @xmath45 times some number @xmath46 a few .
we will also assume that the flare occurs at 6 gravitational radii , where most of the bolometric luminosity is produced .
using the results of sz94 , we obtain : @xmath47 here , the ` critical ' column energy density is @xmath48 , where @xmath49 is the thomson cross section and @xmath50 is the midplane energy density . using the results of sz94 , we obtain @xmath51 where @xmath52 is the radius in units of 3 gravitational radii , @xmath53 ( @xmath54 is the mass of the black hole ) , @xmath55 is the standard viscosity parameter , and @xmath56 is the dimensionless luminosity , @xmath57 , where @xmath58 is the eddington luminosity . finally , @xmath59 accounts for the assumed stress - free boundary condition at the disk s inner edge .
the constant @xmath60 has the value @xmath61 if the disk is gas pressure dominated , and it is @xmath62 if the dominant pressure is due to radiation . taking @xmath63 as an example , we get @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the magnetic energy density @xmath66 .
hmg94 suggested that plausible values for @xmath67 and @xmath55 are 10 and 0.1 , respectively .
we can also assume that @xmath68 .
it is then seen that @xmath0 , but it is not likely to be as high as a few hundred .
the two - phase model is often criticized for a lack of self - consistency : one of the most important quantities determining the spectrum the thomson optical depth of the ar is either fixed in an ad hoc manner , or is said to be given by pair equilibrium
. the latter may be viable if the pairs are strongly confined inside the ar and if the compactness of the region is @xmath3 several hundred .
however , a physical description of how this happen is needed in order to validate the basic assumptions of the model .
haardt , maraschi & ghisellini ( 1994 ) have made an attempt in this direction , but their description of magnetic flares was rather simplistic and did not provide an explanation for the observed optical depth . to address this issue in greater depth , nayakshin & melia ( 1997b ) considered the role played by pressure balance in establishing an equilibrium optical depth during the active phase of a magnetic flare .
the main difference with the solar case is that here the compactness of the flare is much larger than unity , and thus radiation pressure dominates over particle pressure ( if the proton temperature is the same as that of the electrons ) .
the conditions providing a pressure balance are therefore drastically different from those in the sun , where the particles dictate the nature of the equilibrium .
nayakshin & melia ( 1997b ) assumed that the energy is supplied to the gas by magnetohydrodynamic waves . under the conditions typical for seyfert galaxies , the group velocity of these waves ( @xmath69 ) is expected to be close to the speed of light @xmath35 . because momentum is transferred to the gas , as well as energy , a compressional force is imposed on the plasma .
the radiation pressure within the active region is approximately @xmath70 , where @xmath71 is the x - ray flux leaving the source . in quasi - equilibrium
the energy influx is equal to the energy outflux , and radiation pressure is equal to the momentum influx due to the magnetic waves .
this then requires that the thomson optical depth @xmath9 be in the range @xmath72 , depending on the actual geometry of the flare .
the alfvn velocity can be used as an estimate for the group velocity of the magnetohydrodynamic waves . taking the disk structure to be that of a standard shakura - sunyaev model in its radiation pressure dominated region
, one can show that the alfvn velocity @xmath69 ( at a distance of @xmath73 gravitational radii from the black hole ) is @xmath74^{1/2}\;.\ ] ] it is evident that for @xmath75 and @xmath56 not too small , @xmath69 can be quite close to @xmath35 ( if it exceeds @xmath35 , the relativistic corrections will permit it to saturate at @xmath35 only ) . in this estimate , we assume that the thomson optical depth @xmath9 of the plasma within the flare region is entirely due to the accreting electrons . if in addition pairs are produced , then equation ( 6 ) should be used with @xmath76 instead , where @xmath76 is the thomson optical depth of the ar due to the electrons accreting with the protons , which further increases @xmath77 .
we conclude from this that @xmath69 must be close to @xmath35 for quite a broad range of the @xmath55-parameter , @xmath78 , and it is _ completely independent _ of the black hole mass @xmath54 . as already noted by haardt , maraschi & ghisellini ( 1994 )
, the spectrum of a magnetic flare should be similar to that of a static active region of the same size and compactness , as long as the lifetime of the flare exceeds several light - crossing time scales .
this is certainly true if pairs are not important , since the time scales for other processes that may influence the spectrum ( e.g. , poutanen & svensson 1996a ) are of the order of a light crossing time .
however , the life time of one single flare is short compared with the typical integration time of current x - ray instruments .
moreover , it is very likely that there are many magnetic flares present at any given moment of time . therefore , it becomes clear that if magnetic flares are responsible for the x - ray emission from seyfert galaxies , the spectrum must be a composite of the contributions from many different flares .
nayakshin & melia ( 1997b ) tested this possibility , assuming that the energy balance is fixed by requiring the compton @xmath25-parameter to be constant for all the flares ( which is reasonable , given that @xmath25 is fixed by the geometry of the two - phase model ) , and they summed over the spectra from flares with different @xmath9 .
for illustrative purposes , the distribution of flares was taken to be a gaussian over @xmath9 , centered on @xmath79 with a dispersion of @xmath80 .
the resulting spectrum is practically indistinguishable from that of a single flare with @xmath81 up to a photon energy of about a hundred kev .
the osse error bars are much larger than the deviations of the composite and single flare spectra , and so the current observations can not distinguish between these two possibilities . thus , magnetic flares can conceivably account for the observed x - ray/@xmath82-ray spectra of seyfert galaxies .
nayakshin & melia ( 1997c ) considered the x - ray reflection / reprocessing due to a transient , energetic flare above the accretion disk to compare with other studies reported in the literature that assume a stationary state .
the main difference between the two is the structure of the emitting ( i.e. , reprocessing ) layer . in particular , since the flare lifetime is shorter than the disk thermal time scale , a pressure and energy equilibrium between the incident x - ray flux and the underlying disk is not established .
a typical photon does not have sufficient time to diffuse to the mid plane of the disk during one lifetime of the flare .
however , the x - ray skin , i.e. , the layer that absorbs and reprocesses the x - rays , is only a tiny fraction of the whole disk , and thus a quasi - equilibrium is established within it . as a result of the incident flux ,
the x - ray skin is compressed to much higher densities than the density of the undisturbed accretion disk .
it turns out that the pressure and energy equilibrium of this x - ray skin yields a unique temperature @xmath83 few @xmath84k _ independently _ of the mass of the central engine .
this seems to account well for the observed independence of the big blue bump temperature on the luminosity of the source ( walter 1994 ; zhou et al .
1997 ) . by comparison , a stationary
, time independent reflection can not easily explain these observations .
an additional attractive feature of the mf model is that due to a much larger gas density in the reflecting layer , the ionization parameter ( @xmath85 ) remains relatively small , in which case the reflected / reprocessed spectrum is indistinguishable from that of a neutral reflector , which appears to be favored by current observations ( zdziarski et al .
static x - ray reflection / reprocessing , on the other hand , may have difficulties complying with the observed low ionization parameter of the reflecting matter , since in this case the x - ray skin density is much lower . summarizing ,
many of the attractive features of reflection / reprocessing in a static layer below the ar are preserved in the case of a time - dependent , short - lived magnetic flare , but the latter has the additional advantage of being able to account for the approximate universality of the bbb temperature and the low ionization fraction in the reflector .
one of the central questions in the modeling of seyfert galaxies has always been whether a pair equilibrium is established within the source , since this has some serious observational consequences .
however , pairs have successfully eluded detection in seyfert galaxies . with the discovery of a high - energy break above @xmath3 100 kev and the non - detection of a predicted annihilation line
, it has become apparent that the non - thermal power in seyfert galaxies , if at all present , is quite small ( e.g. , svensson 1996a ; zdziarski et al . 1996 , and references therein ) .
thus , it was concluded that the plasma is mostly thermal ( e.g. , haardt & maraschi 1991 ; fabian 1994 ) .
this inference was supported by the finding that an annihilation line would not be observed from a thermal plasma because it is always hidden in the broad comptonized spectrum ( zdziarski & coppi 1995 )
. recent work by ( zdziarski et al .
1996 ) suggests that in the context of a thermal pair equilibrium , an optical depth of roughly unity is then the consequence of a large compactness ( @xmath3 several hundred ) .
we , however , suggest that this situation is achieved by pressure equilibrium , as discussed in 3.3 . in this case , the plasma consists primarily of the electrons and protons stripped from the disk , at least at the beginning of the flare , since during the magnetic energy storage phase the plasma is not sufficiently hot to provide enough hard photons that would create electron - positron pairs .
thus , in this framework , the pairs are not important in determining the spectrum from the flare , and this is again consistent with the lack of any observed pair signature . of course , a detailed modeling of a magnetic flare event must take into account the pair creation process which continuously produces new pairs when @xmath86 .
it is the total optical depth ( i.e. , the sum of the thomson optical depths of electrons and pairs ) that matters for the pressure equilibrium .
if this pressure balance fixes the optical depth to some particular value @xmath1 , then clearly , compared to the no - pair case , the plasma must expand to accommodate the new particles .
let us assume that the total energy supplied to the plasma is a constant , which means that the luminosity @xmath14 remains constant .
then , as the plasma expands , its compactness decreases as @xmath87 since @xmath88 .
since the pair creation rate is proportional to @xmath89 , an equilibrium is reached at some @xmath12 such that the pairs are now responsible for a fraction of the total optical depth @xmath9 .
this fraction turns out to be quite small unless the initial compactness is as high as several hundred .
it is interesting to note that even flares with an initial value of @xmath19 that would lead to a pair runaway ( e.g. , svensson 1982 ) find an equilibrium configuration with a source compactness below this critical value .
we intend to quantify the character of the pair equilibrium in this situation in a future publication , but we may already anticipate that a compactness as high as several hundred is only barely permitted by equation ( 5 ) , and that therefore pairs should be of relatively low importance to the dynamics and energetics of magnetic flares .
several authors have suggested that magnetic flares above the accretion disk are responsible for the observed variations in the agn and gbhc luminosity ( e.g. , galeev , rosner & vaiana 1979 ; de vries & kuijpers 1992 ; volwerk , van oss & kuijpers 1993 ; van oss , van den oord & kuperus 1993 , and others ) .
the power density spectrum ( pds ) from these sources is typically a power - law ( lawrence et al .
1987 ; mchardy & czerny 1987 ; krolik et al .
1991 ) . in the case of the sun , dmitruk & gomez ( 1997 ) have shown that magnetic flares can naturally account for a power - law shape in the pds with an index @xmath90 . since in principle
the flares in black hole systems may have different spatial sizes , and thus different durations and overall power , one can reasonably expect that a similar pds may be produced by these transient events above the accretion disks in agns and gbhcs .
we note here that the power - law pds should be explained by local variations of the magnetic flare properties , rather than variations occurring systematically with a changing location of the flare ( compare with the rotating bright - spots model , e.g. , abramovicz et al .
the observed x - ray pds spans a wide range in frequencies , typically @xmath91-@xmath92 hz .
this range corresponds to the range in radius @xmath93 , since @xmath94 , where @xmath95 is the rotational frequency of the keplerian disk .
but the local contribution to the overall luminosity goes as @xmath96 , and thus the smallest frequencies contribute less than the largest ones , in contradiction to the observed power spectrum . only if one assumes that the luminosity of the flare is independent of its location
does one obtain the right power spectrum .
however , such an assumption is unphysical , since we know that the x - ray luminosity is a major component of the bolometric luminosity , and thus it should scale in the same way as the local gravitational dissipation in the disk . therefore , since the emission comes from a relatively narrow range in radii , it should be the flare size that varies and produces the observed pds .
alternatively , since disturbances propagate along magnetic field lines in a strong magnetic field , and since the magnetic flux tube is thick , there can be a wide range in characteristic scales @xmath97 even in one source ( @xmath97 is essentially the length of the given magnetic field line [ see fig . 1 ] ) .
moreover , the energy density of the magnetic field will scale roughly as @xmath98 ( that would be so for a potential field that has no currents even at the boundary , i.e. in the footpoints ) .
thus , one might expect to see a power - law pds even from a _ single _ event in this case .
we intend to investigate this question in future work , but we caution that the analysis of the pds is unlikely to provide any valuable information about one single magnetic flare , since at any given instant of time there should be a number of such events .
these flares occur roughly at random , and thus information about a single flare is washed out .
the complete annihilation of the magnetic field energy @xmath65 ( @xmath99 ) within a volume @xmath100 during a time @xmath101 provides an estimate of the single flare luminosity : @xmath102 where we have used the sz94 accretion disk parameters with their @xmath103 set equal to @xmath104 .
based on similar considerations , hmg94 estimated the required number of magnetic flares to be about 10 .
we are therefore in agreement with this estimate , although in principle the number of less energetic or smaller flares may still be larger , since equation ( 7 ) is only an upper limit on @xmath105 .
an implicit assumption thus far has been that the magnetic flare can indeed sustain a sufficient number of protons roughly one disk height @xmath18 above the disk . for this to be viable , we need to demonstrate that the gravitational energy of the protons trapped inside the flux tube is very much smaller than the magnetic field energy .
the latter is at most the total thermal energy of the disk immediately below the flare , while the former may be estimated as @xmath106 . using expressions from sz94 for @xmath107
, we see that @xmath108 which satisfies the constraint . as before , @xmath109 is the thomson optical depth of the material trapped inside the flux tube .
the nature of accretion disk instabilities has received a great deal of attention ( for recent references , see chen 1995 ) .
while not attempting to consider this question in detail here , we can make several comments on the stability of the mf model .
magnetic flares may be viewed as an additional channel by which energy can be transported out of the disk . of course
, in the standard disk model , the dissipated gravitational energy is lost directly to radiation .
since the time taken by a photon to diffuse outward from the midplane to the disk s surface is a very strongly increasing function of the optical depth , it is conceivable that under some conditions the energy transported by the magnetic field is greater than that due to the radiation .
the total energy content of the disk plus corona system is then expected to be lower than that of the standard theory , though with the same luminosity , and such a situation leads to greater stability ( e.g. , sz94 ) .
although it is not clear what role advection would have in such a model , it is expected that magnetic flares may help to quench some of the disk instabilities encountered in standard models .
we have seen that magnetic flares are physically consistent with the multi - wavelength spectra of seyfert galaxies .
very importantly , the mf model seems to account for several observed characteristics that can not be easily reconciled with a picture in which the ars are static .
however , a host of unanswered questions and problems remain .
first , accretion disk flares have been considered only in a highly schematic fashion thus far .
unfortunately , the physics of magnetic energy release in a non - static and turbulent gas is not well known , other than the fact that it must happen , as is seen in the sun .
in addition , a detailed model of the magnetic flare should also include a consideration of all the relevant aspects of magnetic flux tube formation in the underlying turbulent disk , a problem that also has not been solved .
this , however , does not mean we can ignore the magnetic flare model for the x - ray emission in seyferts . instead , additional studies are called for , especially in view of the fact that very recent observations of solar flares seem to support much of the current theoretical thinking in this area and are generating enthusiasm among solar theorists ( e.g. , innes et al .
1997 , klimchuk 1997 ) .
another major unresolved issue is how the disk viscosity is connected to the magnetic field .
if we knew this relationship , we would be able to eliminate @xmath55 or @xmath65 from equation ( 5 ) , and thus get better constraints on the maximum compactness of a magnetic flare .
this follows from the fact that the structure of a cold disk is quite sensitive to the viscosity law .
in addition , viscosity figures very prominently in the physics of magnetic flux tubes ( e.g. , vishniac 1995 ) .
in this paper we have attempted to address the problems that arise when physical constraints are imposed on the active regions thought to exist in the two - phase corona - accretion disks in seyfert galaxies .
we showed that these regions should necessarily be highly transient , i.e. , evolve faster than one thermal disk time scale due to spectrum formation constraints .
a consideration of the plasma confinement lead us to require an overall magnetic field with a stress much larger than the x - ray radiation pressure .
furthermore , putting these constraints together , we concluded that the magnetic flare model appears to be consistent with the type of transient active regions required by the observations .
we then proceeded to show that the model is probably capable of explaining the observed optical depth , x - ray reflection and uv reprocessing implied by the data , and the observed power - law power density spectra .
finally , we discussed the unresolved issues that need to be investigated in future work .
this work was partially supported by nasa grant nag 5 - 3075 .
we have benefitted from many discussions with randy jokipii and eugene levy .
burm , h. 1986 , a&a , * 165 * , 120 burm , h. & kuperus , m. 1988 , a&a , * 192*,165 dmitruk , p. & gomez , d.o .
1997 , apjl , in press ( also astro - ph/9705050 ) johnson et al .
1993 , bull .
american astron .
, 183 , # 64.03 jourdain et al .
1992256l38 nayakshin & melia 1997a , submitted to apj ( available at astro - ph/9705011 ) nayakshin & melia 1997b , submitted to apj letters nayakshin & melia 1997c , apj letters , in press ( also astro - ph/9705010 ) .
van oss , r.f . ,
van den oord , g.h.j . , & kuperus , m. 1993 , a&a , * 270 * , 275 parker , e.n .
1979 , cosmical magnetic fields , clarendon press , oxford .
priest , e.r . ,
solar magneto - hydrodynamics , kluwer academic publishers , 1984 .
rybicki , g. b. , & lightman , a.p . , 1979 , radiative processes in astrophysics , john wiley and sons : new york .
shakura & sunyaev 1973 , a&a , 24 , 337 svensson , r. 1996b , invited review at relativistic astrophysics , available at astro - ph/9612081 volwerk , m. , van oss , r.f . , & kuijpers , j. , 1993 , a&a , * 270 * , 265 de vries , m. , & kuijpers , j. , 1992 , a&a , * 266 * , 77 walter , r. , & fink , h.h .
1993 , a&a , * 274 * , 105 walter , r. , et al .
1994 , a&a , * 285 * , 119 | we discuss several physical constraints on the nature of the active regions ( ar ) in seyfert 1 galaxies , and show that a plausible model consistent with these constraints is one in which the ars are magnetically confined and `` fed '' .
the unique x - ray index of these sources points to a large compactness parameter ( @xmath0 ) .
this , together with the conditions required to account for the observed optical depth being close to unity , suggests that the magnetic energy density in the ar should be comparable to the equipartition value in the accretion disk , and that it should be released in a flare - like event above the surface of the cold accretion disk .
we consider the various issues pertaining to magnetic flares and attempt to construct a coherent picture , including a reason for the optical depth in the ar being @xmath1 , and an understanding of the characteristics of the x - ray reflection component and the power density spectra associated with this high - energy emission .
#1#2#3#1 , a&a , # 2 , # 3 # 1#2#3#1 , a&as , # 2 , # 3 # 1#2#3#1 , aj , # 2 , # 3 # 1#2#3#1 , _ apj _ , * # 2 * , # 3 .
# 1#2#3#1 , _ apj ( letters ) _ , * # 2 * , # 3 .
# 1#2#3#1 , apjs , # 2 , # 3 # 1#2#3#1 , ara&a , # 2 , # 3 # 1#2#3#1 , baas , # 2 , # 3 # 1#2#3#1 , icarus , # 2 , # 3 # 1#2#3#1 , _
mnras _ , * # 2 * , # 3 .
# 1#2#3#1 , _ nature _ , * # 2 * , # 3 .
# 1#2#3#1 , pasj , # 2 , # 3 # 1#2#3#1 , pasp , # 2 , # 3 # 1#2#3#1 , qjras , # 2 , # 3 # 1#2#3#1 , science , # 2 , # 3 # 1#2#3#1 , soviet astr . ,
# 2 , # 3 # 1#2#3#1 , soviet astr .
lett . ,
# 2 , # 3 # 1#2#3#4#1 , # 2 , # 3 , # 4 # 1#1 submitted to the astrophysical journal |
recent years have seen a great expansion of topological quantum materials beyond time - reversal - invariant topological insulators @xcite , driven by the search for symmetry - protected topological ( spt ) states of matter that are distinct from trivial states only in the presence of certain symmetry .
this underlying symmetry can be associated with conservation of internal quantum numbers such as charge and spin @xcite , or with spatial operations such as rotation and reflection @xcite . since spatial symmetry is a common property of all crystals , a wide array of topological band insulators protected by various crystal symmetries , commonly referred to as topological crystalline insulators ( tcis ) @xcite , has been theorized .
the hallmark of a tci is the existence of topologically protected gapless excitations on surfaces that preserve the relevant crystal symmetry .
a notable class of tcis protected by reflection symmetry was predicted and observed in the iv - vi semiconductors sn@xmath3pb@xmath4(te , se ) @xcite , and the symmetry protection of the topological surface states has been demonstrated @xcite .
more recently , tcis have been generalized to band insulators with magnetic point group symmetries @xcite , nonsymmorphic symmetries @xcite , and with both glide reflection and time - reversal symmetry @xcite .
in addition , topological insulators protected by translation @xcite and magnetic translation symmetry @xcite were studied in early works .
the interplay between topology and crystallography is continuing to knit together abstract mathematics and real materials .
recently , a new type of electronic tcis protected by reflection symmetry has been theoretically constructed @xcite , which is enabled by electron interactions and do not exist in free fermion systems . in a broader context , interaction - enabled topological crystalline phases were also been found in fermion superconductors @xcite and boson insulators @xcite .
such phases are now attracting wide attention , and it is of great interest to find their material realizations and experimental signatures . in this work ,
we find a new class of interaction - enabled topological crystalline insulators in two and three dimensions , which are protected by time - reversal ( @xmath0 ) and reflection / rotation symmetry ( @xmath1 ) , or simply the combined symmetry @xmath5 .
this phase exists in systems of spin-@xmath6 electrons with spin - orbit interaction , and can not be adiabatically connected to any slater insulator in the presence of @xmath5 symmetry .
instead , this phase admits a natural description in terms of a magnetic system of interacting spins , hence is termed `` topological crystalline magnets '' ( tcms ) .
a distinctive feature of tcms is the presence of gapless spin excitations on the edge parallel to the axis of reflection .
these edge states exhibit strongly anisotropic response to magnetic fields in directions parallel and perpendicular to edge . our model for two- and three - dimensional tcms
is adiabatically connected to an array of _ decoupled _ one - dimensional symmetry - protected topological ( spt ) states , on which the @xmath5 symmetry acts as an internal anti - unitary @xmath7 symmetry .
this stacking approach provides a unifying description of all previously known topological crystalline insulators @xcite , both with @xcite and without @xcite interactions .
the one - dimensional spt state serving as the building block of our higher dimensional tcms apparently looks similar to , but , in fact , is remarkably different from the affleck , kennedy , lieb , and tasaki ( aklt ) state @xcite .
the aklt state belongs to the haldane phase , which is a _
bosonic _ spt phase protected , for example , by the dihedral ( @xmath8 ) symmetry or the time - reversal symmetry @xcite . however , the haldane phase is not a _ fermionic _ spt phase and is hence trivial as an electronic phase @xcite .
namely , when we decompose the @xmath9 spins of the aklt model into _ mobile _ electrons with spin-@xmath10 , the ground state is adiabatically deformable into a trivial band insulator @xcite while keeping the dihedral and the time - reversal symmetry .
in contrast , our 1d tcm state is a robust fermionic spt phase protected by @xmath5 as we shall see now .
s and orange dots illustrate the edge degrees of freedom .
a gapless edge state appears on each edge of a finite - size system .
the edge degrees of freedom satisfy @xmath11 , which is distinct from physical electrons or edge states of noninteracting topological insulators .
our 1d model is composed of a four - dimensional hilbert space @xmath12 on each site arising from the spin and orbital degrees of freedom of an _ even _ number of spin-@xmath6 electrons .
the time - reversal operator @xmath13 thus satisfies @xmath14 on @xmath12 . as the simplest realization of such anti - unitary symmetry
we take the complex conjugation @xmath15 .
we also assume that states in @xmath12 are all even or all odd under a spatial symmetry @xmath1 , which is either the reflection about @xmath16 plane @xmath17 or the @xmath18-rotation about @xmath19-axis @xmath20 . the operator @xmath21 is hence represented by the identity operator @xmath22 on @xmath12 . in one dimension
@xmath1 is essentially an internal symmetry , but will become a true spatial symmetry in higher dimensional cases to be studied later . as an explicit example , @xmath12 can be identified as a subset of the states of two spin-@xmath6 electrons occupying two orbitals . assuming each orbital is invariant under reflection or rotation , the operator @xmath21 only acts on the spin part of the two - electron wavefunction .
there are in total six two - electron states , consisting of spin - singlet states formed by two electrons on the same orbital , as well as spin - singlet and spin - triplet states formed by two electrons on different orbitals .
we denote the electron operators associated with these two orbitals by @xmath23 and @xmath24 respectively , where @xmath25 is the spin projection along the @xmath26 axis . then , out of the six two - electron states , the following four satisfy @xmath27 and @xmath28 ( @xmath29 ) and span the desired hilbert space @xmath12 : @xmath30 reads @xmath31 where both @xmath32 and @xmath33 are a set of three hermitian operators that generate the @xmath34 algebra and mutually commute , i.e. , @xmath35&=&i \epsilon^{abc}\hat{\gamma}^{\mu c } , \;\ ; [ \hat{\gamma}^{1 a } , \hat{\gamma}^{2 b } ] = 0\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath36 and @xmath37 .
the components of these @xmath38 operators are explicitly given by the following @xmath39 matrices in the basis of @xmath40 @xmath41 note that @xmath42 are pure imaginary and are hence odd under time - reversal symmetry @xmath0 .
the hamiltonian consists of bilinears of @xmath38 s and is therefore time - reversal invariant .
it is also invariant under @xmath1 since @xmath1 does not transform @xmath38 at all . to analyze the topological nature of the ground state of @xmath43 , it is more convenient to switch the basis of @xmath12 from @xmath44 to @xmath45 by the local linear transformation @xmath46 : @xmath47 is nothing but the spin operator acting on @xmath48 , @xmath49 for example , the usual spin algebras such as @xmath50 and @xmath51 hold .
therefore , @xmath43 in eq .
is just an antiferromagnetic spin chain whose exchange coupling is nonzero every other bond .
the ground state is the valence - bond solid ( vbs ) state : @xmath52 and @xmath53 ( @xmath54 ) .
the nontrivial topology of the model is encoded in the symmetry property of the edge states .
although the auxiliary field @xmath55 apparently behaves like an electronic spin , its transformation under @xmath56 is in fact quite distinct from the physical spin . in the @xmath57 basis , @xmath13 and @xmath21
are represented by @xmath58 and @xmath59 , respectively .
namely , @xmath55 transforms under @xmath0 in the same way as the physical spins , while it does not change under @xmath1 ( @xmath60 ) unlike electrons .
this peculiar transformation property of the auxiliary field @xmath55 can be summarized as @xmath61 on the two dimensional hilbert space spanned by @xmath48 .
equation must be compared to @xmath62 and hence @xmath63 of a physical spin-@xmath6 electron .
one may think one can redefine @xmath64 to get @xmath65 , but even after that @xmath66 remains unchanged since @xmath13 is anti - unitary . although the hamiltonian @xmath43 is invariant under @xmath13 and @xmath21 separately , we can add arbitrary symmetry - breaking perturbations keeping only the combined symmetry @xmath56 and the bulk gap . since @xmath56 is an anti - unitary symmetry that squares into @xmath67
, it protects the kramers degeneracy on each edge .
the fact that the value of @xmath68 of our edge state is different from that of physical electrons has two important implications .
( i ) the edge state of any ( noninteracting ) topological insulator satisfies @xmath63 .
therefore , the vbs state in eq . can not be adiabatically connected to electronic topological insulators . in other words ,
the vbs state is an interaction - enabled topological phase protected by @xmath56 .
( ii ) the edge state of the vbs state is robust against the perturbation of attaching physical spin-@xmath6 electrons to the edge . in the case of the standard aklt model , for example
, the edge spin-@xmath6 can be gapped by attaching an electron , since both of them fall into the same class of projective representations @xmath69 . on the other hand
, the edge state of our model can not be gapped this way , since even after attaching an electron , the anti - unitary symmetry @xmath56 remains @xmath11 . to summarize ,
we have presented a simple 1d model of interacting electrons that realizes an interaction - enabled topological phase protected by the combined symmetry @xmath56 .
the edge degrees of freedom satisfies @xmath11 and are stable against attaching additional electrons to the edge . ]
now we move onto 2d tcm models .
this time the reflection / rotation symmetry is truly a spatial symmetry and the 2d tcm phases are hence protected purely by non - local symmetries .
we will discuss two models .
the first one is stacked 1d chains shown in fig .
[ fig2 ] ( a ) .
the hamiltonian is @xmath70 where @xmath71 and @xmath72 in the basis of @xmath73 .
the second one is a square - lattice model depicted in fig .
[ fig2 ] ( b ) .
@xmath74 where @xmath75 , @xmath76 , @xmath77 , and @xmath78 in the basis of @xmath79
. for both models , each auxiliary field @xmath80 ( @xmath81 ) transforms as @xmath82 so that @xmath83 satisfies @xmath84 the first transformation in eq .
is again distinct from that of spin-@xmath6 electrons . as a consequence
, @xmath85 satisfies @xmath11 unlike electrons as before .
although both @xmath86 and @xmath87 themselves are invariant under @xmath21 and @xmath13 separately , arbitrary perturbations can be added to these hamiltonians as long as the combined symmetry @xmath56 is respected and the bulk gap is not closed .
note that the reflection / rotation symmetry @xmath1 here needs to be site - centered [ @xmath88 and can not be bond - centered [ @xmath89
. the bond - centered one does not protect gapless edge states as we discuss below . to break the body - centered symmetry without affecting the site - centered one
, one can introduce a - b sublattice structure [ gray shadows in fig .
[ fig](b ) ] by modifying the spin hamiltonian by weak perturbation . of the 2d models in fig .
the color represents the nonuniform perturbation @xmath90 with @xmath91 , for example , which respects the @xmath56 symmetry .
the edge state in the region @xmath92 and @xmath93 opens a gap proportional to @xmath94 , while there will be a residual gapless edge state protected by @xmath11 on the domain wall .
[ fig3 ] ] the ground state of these 2d hamiltonians is the vbs state illustrated in fig .
[ fig2 ] , analogous to eq . .
there is a 1d edge state formed by @xmath95}$ ] along the line @xmath96 , and another 1d edge state formed by @xmath97}$ ] along @xmath98 . to see the gaplessness of the edge states ,
we add a @xmath56-symmetric perturbation @xmath90 along the line @xmath96 as shown in fig .
[ fig3 ] , where @xmath99 is an odd function of @xmath100 that approaches to a constant @xmath101 for @xmath102 .
note that @xmath99 must flip sign at @xmath103 to be consistent with the @xmath56 symmetry , forming a domain wall around @xmath103 .
all @xmath104 s along the edge away from the domain wall open a gap proportional to @xmath94 .
however , the edge state at the domain wall @xmath103 must remain gapless .
this is protected , again , by the anti - unitary symmetry @xmath56 with @xmath11 .
this unavoidable gaplessness of the edge state signals the topological nature of our 2d models .
essentially , @xmath105 s on the @xmath106 line plays the role of the 1d spin chain discussed above .
in contrast , when @xmath1 is bond - centered , there will be an even number of @xmath107 s at the domain wall and @xmath108 and the edge may be completely gapped .
an experimental signature of tcms is the anisotropic response of the edge state to the external magnetic field @xmath109 .
we start with the case where @xmath1 is the reflection @xmath110 about the @xmath16 plane .
recall that the @xmath111 under @xmath110 , while @xmath104 does not react to @xmath110 .
both @xmath109 and @xmath104 flips sign under @xmath0 .
the familiar form of the coupling to the external field @xmath112 is thus not allowed by symmetry @xmath113 . instead , arbitrary linear coupling to @xmath114 , i.e. , @xmath115 , is allowed . when @xmath114 is set to a constant value ,
this term breaks the @xmath113 symmetry and the edge states will be gapped and the gap should be proportional to @xmath116 .
on the other hand , @xmath117 and @xmath118 do not couple linearly to @xmath119 .
we therefore expect anisotropic response of the edge state towards the external magnetic field . when @xmath1 is the @xmath18-rotation @xmath120 around @xmath19 axis , the magnetic field @xmath121 changes to @xmath122 under @xmath120 .
thus , arbitrary linear coupling between @xmath123 and @xmath124 is allowed . thus a constant @xmath123 can induce a gap to the edge , while @xmath114 and @xmath125 can not .
we thus expect similar anisotropic response in this case too . ]
one can readily construct a 3d tcm model in the same way as we did for the 2d models .
the 3d model is a 2d array of the 1d tcm chains , illustrated in fig .
[ fig4 ] . for this 3d model
, @xmath1 must be the site - centered @xmath18-rotation about the @xmath19-axis .
namely , the rotation axis must coincide with one of the 1d chain .
the gapless 2d surfaces at @xmath96 and @xmath98 are protected by the combined symmetry @xmath126 . to see this , let us again add a @xmath126-symmetric perturbation @xmath127 . to be consistent with the @xmath126 symmetry ,
@xmath128 should satisfy @xmath129 , meaning that @xmath130 .
therefore , there will be a residual zero mode at the `` vortex core '' of the perturbed surface , protected by @xmath11 .
in this paper we introduced tcm phases protected by non - local symmetry @xmath126 in two and three dimension .
they are interaction - enabled and are robust against attaching physical electrons to the edge .
they can be detected in experiment from their anisotropic response of the edge state towards external magnetic fields .
xu , c. liu , n. alidoust , m. neupane , d. qian , i. belopolski , j.d .
denlinger , y.j .
wang , h. lin , l. a. wray , g. landolt , b. slomski , j.h .
dil , a. marcinkova , e. morosan , q. gibson , r. sankar , f.c .
chou , r.j .
cava , a. bansil , and m. z. hasan , nat . commun . * 3 * , 1192 ( 2012 ) . | we introduce a novel class of interaction - enabled topological crystalline insulators in two- and three - dimensional electronic systems , which we call `` topological crystalline magnet . ''
it is protected by the product of the time - reversal symmetry @xmath0 and a mirror symmetry or a rotation symmetry @xmath1 .
a topological crystalline magnet exhibits two intriguing features : ( i ) it can not be adiabatically connected to any slater insulator and ( ii ) the edge state is robust against coupling electrons to the edge .
these features are protected by the anomalous symmetry transformation property @xmath2 of the edge state .
an anisotropic response to the external magnetic field can be an experimental signature . |
the general solution for an asymptotically flat black hole in the einstein - maxwell theory is given by the kerr - newman solution .
it describes an electrically charged rotating black hole with its three parameters : mass , charge and angular momentum .
a systematic study of the fields dynamic in the vicinity of a black hole is essential for understanding black - hole evaporation , quasinormal modes and stability .
the linear dynamics of a charged massive scalar field in the background of a charged black hole is characterized by the two dimensionless parameters @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
a black hole is not believed to be formed possessing considerable electric charge , and , once it is formed , it undergoes a rather quick discharging @xcite . yet , even if a black hole has a very small charge of order @xmath7 , the parameter @xmath1 need not be small .
in addition , a charge induced by an external magnetic field , may be formed at the surface of an initially neutral , but rotating black hole @xcite .
thus , the complete analysis of a massive charged scalar field dynamics should include consideration of the whole range of values @xmath8 and @xmath0 .
in this work we shall study the stability and evolution of perturbation of a massive charged scalar field in the kerr - newman background in terms of its _ quasinormal modes _ and _ asymptotic tails _ at late times .
it is believed that if the quasinormal modes are damped , the system under consideration is stable , though a rigorous mathematical proof of stability is usually complicated and sometimes includes a nontrivial analysis of the initial value problem . by now , quite a few papers have been devoted to scalar field perturbations in the black - hole background , yet , while the behavior of the massless neutral scalar field is indeed very well studied , the quasinormal modes of charged fields was studied only in the regime @xmath9 , @xmath10 @xcite , except for @xcite , where the wkb estimation for quasinormal modes ( qnms ) of a massless charged scalar field around the reissner - nordstrm black hole was given in the regime @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is the multipole number . the complete analysis of quasinormal modes ( allowing also to judge about stability ) for a massive charged scalar field _ for arbitrary values _ @xmath8 and
@xmath0 has been lacking so far not only for the kerr - newman , but even for reissner - nordstrm solutions .
here we shall solve this problem by adopting the two numerical methods of computation ( the frobenius method and the time - domain integrations ) based on convergent procedures , which allow us to find quasinormal modes accurately and with no restriction on the parameters of the system .
perturbation of a charged massive field in the background of a rotating charged black hole has rich physics , because there are a number of phenomena which must be taken into consideration : * _ superradiance _ , that is the amplification of waves with particular frequencies reflected by a black hole , if it is rotating @xcite or electrically charged @xcite .
thus , there will be the two regimes of superradiance for kerr - newman black holes , owing to charge and rotation @xcite . * _ superradiant instability _ of bound states around black holes owing to the massive term , which creates a local minimum far from the black hole , so that the wave will be reflected repeatedly and can grow .
it is essential that this instability occurs under the bound states boundary condition , which differ from the quasinormal modes ones @xcite . * _ quasiresonances .
_ when a field is massive , quasinormal modes with arbitrarily long lifetimes , called quasiresonances , appear , once some critical value of mass of the field is achieved @xcite .
when the damping rate goes to zero , the quasinormal asymptotically approach the bound state , but still remain quasinormal modes for whatever small but nonzero damping . @xcite . *
_ instability of the extremal black holes _ that apparently occurs for fields of any spin and both for extremal reissner - nordstrm and kerr black holes @xcite , and therefore , must be expected for the extremal kerr - newman solution as well .
however , in the linear approximation this instability develops only on the event horizon and can not be seen by an external observer . * _ mode branching_. quasinormal modes of kerr black holes
were believed to be completely studied until a few months ago when an interesting observation has been made @xcite .
it was shown that , for the near - extremal rotation there are two distinct sets of damped quasinormal modes , which merge to a single set in the exactly extremal state @xcite . here ,
through the numerical analysis of quasinormal modes and asymptotic tails we have shown that a massive charged scalar field is stable in the vicinity of the kerr - newman black hole , in spite of the instability of the corresponding bound states .
we found that at some values of the field s charge @xmath3 quasinormal modes may behave qualitatively differently from those of the neutral field : the fundamental mode ( dominating at late times ) may have arbitrarily small real part ( real oscillation frequency ) which appears in the time domain as a very short period of quasinormal ringing consisting of damped oscillations and the quick onset of asymptotic power - law tails .
in addition , we generalized earlier results on mode branching of massless fields around nearly extremal kerr black holes to the massive fields and kerr - newman solutions .
an analytic formula has been obtained for large @xmath1 .
the paper is organized as follows . in sec
ii the basic formulas for a charged massive scalar field in the kerr - newman background is given .
the wave equation is reduced to the schrdinger - like form with an effective potential .
sec iii describes the numerical methods which we used : the frobenius methods , two schemes of time - domain integration ( for neutral and charged fields ) together with the method for extraction of frequencies from the time - domain profiles , called the prony method , and the wkb approach .
we have related separately perturbations of nonextremal black holes ( sec iv ) and nearly and exactly extremal ones ( sec .
v ) , as near extremal black holes shows new phenomena , such as mode branching . in sec .
vi we discuss some technical difficulties which appear when one considers higher overtones of a charged scalar field or approach closely to the extremal state , keeping @xmath3 non zero . in sec vii
we summarize the results obtained .
in the boyer - lindquist coordinates the kerr - newman metric has the form @xmath13 ^ 2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath14 @xmath15 and @xmath5 is the black - hole charge , @xmath4 is its mass .
the electromagnetic background of the black hole is given by the four - vector potential , @xmath16 we shall parameterize the metric by the following three parameters : the event horizon @xmath17 , the inner horizon @xmath18 , and the rotation parameter @xmath19 , @xmath20 the black hole s mass and charge are then @xmath21 a massive charged scalar field satisfies the klein - gordon equation , @xmath22 where @xmath3 and @xmath2 are the field s charge and mass respectively .
one separates variables by the following ansatz @xmath23 where @xmath24 obeys the following equation @xmath25 and @xmath26 is the separation constant .
this equation can be solved numerically for any value of @xmath27 in the same way as the equation for a massive scalar field in the kerr black - hole background @xcite .
let us note that , when @xmath28 , eq .
( [ angularpart ] ) can be reduced to the well - known equation for the spheroidal functions . in this case , for any fixed value of @xmath27 the separation constant @xmath26 can be found numerically using the continued fraction method @xcite . when the effective mass is not zero , the separation constant @xmath29 can be expressed , in terms of the eigenvalue for spheroidal functions @xmath30 @xcite , as @xmath31 when @xmath32 , one has @xmath33 . for nonzero values of @xmath19 ,
the separation constant can be enumerated by the integer multipole number @xmath34 .
the radial function satisfies a schrdinger equation , @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the tortoise coordinate , @xmath37 and the effective potential is @xmath38 the asymptotics of the effective potential near the event horizon and at spatial infinity are @xmath39 where we fix the sign of @xmath40 such that @xmath41 is of the same sign as @xmath42 .
note , that @xmath43 and @xmath42 can have different signs .
this corresponds to the superradiant regime in which one has @xmath44 by definition , quasinormal modes ( qnms ) are proper oscillation frequencies which correspond to purely incoming wave at the event horizon and purely outgoing wave at infinity , so that no incoming waves from either of the `` infinities '' are allowed .
thus , the boundary conditions for the qnms can be written as follows @xmath45
here , we shall briefly relate the three numerical methods used for finding quasinormal frequencies : * leaver method , which is based on a convergent procedure and , thereby , allowing one to find qn modes accurately , * wkb method ( accurate in the regime of high multipole numbers ) , * time - domain integration which includes contribution of all modes , and , together with the prony method , usually allows extracting a few lower dominant frequencies from a time - domain profile .
we shall see that in some ranges of parameters , when one method becomes slowly convergent or inapplicable , the other can be used , so that the use of a few alternative methods is necessary here not only for an additional checking , but also for getting the complete picture of quasinormal modes and stability in the full range of parameters .
equation ( [ radialpart ] ) has an irregular singularity at spatial infinity and four regular singularities at @xmath46 , @xmath47 and @xmath48 .
the appropriate frobenius series is determined as @xmath49 where @xmath50 and @xmath51 is the hawking temperature @xmath52 the function @xmath53 must be regular at the horizon and spatial infinity , so that the series in the vicinity of the event horizon @xmath54 satisfies both these requirements .
this series converges everywhere outside the event horizon ( @xmath55 ) . when boundary conditions ( [ boundary - conditions ] ) are satisfied , that is when @xmath27 is a quasinormal ( qn ) frequency , the series convergence also at the spatial infinity @xcite .
the coefficients @xmath56 satisfy the three - term recurrence relation .
@xmath57 where @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath60 can be found in an analytic form . by comparing the ratio of the series coefficients @xmath61we
obtain an equation with a convergent _ infinite continued fraction _ on its right side : @xmath62which can be solved numerically by minimizing the absolute value of the difference between its left- and right - hand sides .
equation ( [ continued_fraction ] ) has an infinite number of roots , but the most stable root depends on @xmath63 .
the larger number @xmath63 corresponds to the larger imaginary part of the root @xmath27 @xcite .
as we study qnms with slower decay rate , we usually choose @xmath64 . in order to improve convergence of the infinite continued fraction for nonzero mass of a scalar field
, we use the nollert procedure @xcite . as for the study of mode branching we are also interested in modes with high multipole numbers ,
the wkb approach is useful here , which is accurate in the eikonal regime @xmath65 and usually provides very good accuracy at moderate @xmath66 .
the wkb formula for calculation of qnms has the following form : @xmath67 where @xmath68 and @xmath69 are the values of the effective potential ( [ effective - potential ] ) and its second derivative with respect to the tortoise coordinate @xmath36 at the potential s peak .
the terms @xmath70 depend on higher derivatives of @xmath71 at its maximum , and @xmath63 labels the overtones .
the wkb approach was developed by schutz and will @xcite and later extended to higher orders @xcite . since there is implicit dependence on @xmath27 ( either through the separation constant @xmath26 for nonvanishing rotation or due to the @xmath1 coupling in the effective potential ( [ effective - potential ] ) ) , one has to search for the roots of equation ( [ wkbformula ] ) by minimizing the absolute value of the difference between its left and right sides . for nonrotating black holes we are able to construct a time - dependent profile of the wave function at a fixed @xmath36 .
the recently found instability of the exactly extremal reissner - nordstrm black hole @xcite makes it important to check stability of the nearly and exactly extremal black holes .
even when the frobenius method finds no growing quasinormal modes , one could think that the growing modes were simply missed in the frequency domain at the stage of search for the roots of the equation with continued fractions eq .
( [ continued_fraction ] ) , or , that a different boundary condition should be imposed at the event horizon in the extremal case . in order to eliminate both these suspicions , we will use the numerical characteristic integration method in time domain . here
, two different schemes of integration were used for _ neutral _ and _ charged _ fields . * a scheme for a neutral field . *
the wave equation can be written in time - dependent form as follows : @xmath72 the technique of integration of the above wave equation in the time domain was developed in @xcite .
the method uses the light - cone variables @xmath73 , @xmath74 , so that the wave equation reads @xmath75 the initial data are specified on the two null surfaces @xmath76 and @xmath77 .
acting by the time evolution operator @xmath78 on @xmath79 and taking account of ( [ light - cone ] ) , one finds @xmath80 where one introduced letters to mark the points as follows : @xmath81 , @xmath82 , @xmath83 , and @xmath84 .
equation ( [ integration - scheme ] ) allows us to calculate the values of @xmath79 inside the rhombus , which is built on the two null - surfaces @xmath85 and @xmath86 , starting from the initial data specified on them . as a result we can find the time profile data @xmath87 in each point of the rhombus .
the time - domain integration includes a contribution from all overtones , and , thus , missing some mode is excluded .
this method is based on the scattering of the gaussian wave on the potential barrier and therefore does not specify the boundary condition on the event horizon , so that the potentially missed instability due to possibly different boundary conditions must be also discarded . * a scheme for a charged field .
* when the scalar field is charged , an extra term containing the first derivative in time appears . therefore , a different integration scheme is required .
we shall use the finite difference scheme proposed in @xcite .
first we rewrite the wave - like equation ( [ radialpart ] ) for the reissner - nordstrm black hole ( @xmath32 ) in the time - dependent form @xmath88 where @xmath89 following @xcite , one can derive the evolution of @xmath79 in an isosceles triangle with the base on the axis @xmath36 , where initial conditions are imposed .
then , one has @xmath90 indexes @xmath91 and @xmath92 enumerate , respectively , the coordinates @xmath93 and @xmath36 of the grid : @xmath94 we choose the initial conditions again as a gaussian distribution whose maximum is near the maximum of the effective potential .
since von neumann stability conditions require @xmath95 , in this scheme we chose @xmath96 . in order to achieve convergence
we decrease @xmath97 .
note , that as @xmath1 grows the convergence becomes seemingly slower , requiring smaller @xmath97 , what increases the computation time . when @xmath98 this scheme is reduced to the one above for the neutral field , yet , the codes for both schemes differ , so that letting @xmath98 in the mathematica code for the second scheme leads to a much longer computing than the first scheme .
* prony method for mode extraction .
* once a time domain profile is found , one can extract dominant frequencies from it with the help of the prony method .
we fit the profile data by superposition of damped exponents @xmath99 and look for the convergence of the obtained frequencies at the increasing @xmath100 .
we shall show that although the fit works well for the neutral scalar field , it can not be effectively used once modes with very small @xmath42 dominate in the spectrum at late times .
in the regime of large @xmath1 and nonextremal @xmath5 , the frobenius method allows us to find an approximate analytic expression for the quasinormal frequencies .
when @xmath101 one can observe that @xmath102 , @xmath103 , and @xmath104 .
then , we can rewrite eq .
( [ continued_fraction ] ) as @xmath105 considering @xmath106 , from ( [ continued_fraction_qq ] ) we find that @xmath107 .
we observe that @xmath108 when @xmath109 .
then , we can write down @xmath26 as @xmath110 and find the asymptotic formula for the qnms @xmath111 here @xmath112 is the overtone number . from the data given in fig .
[ figasymptot ] one can find that @xmath113 for @xmath114 . in order to find @xmath115 as a function of @xmath12 and @xmath116 we have analyzed numerically the asymptotic behavior of the eigenvalue of ( [ angularpart ] ) and found that @xmath117 + 2,\ ] ] where the brackets denote the integer part . when @xmath5 is not very close to its extremal value , the above analytical formula ( in the limit of vanishing rotation ) can be verified by the time - domain integration for a few lower modes , as it is shown in fig .
[ figworotation ] .
there one can see that the analytic formula ( [ asymptotical_frequency ] ) works very well already at moderate values of @xmath1 .
nevertheless , even though we are able to obtain a stable time - domain profile for any values of @xmath3 and @xmath5 , the prony method does not converge for high overtones as well as near extremal black holes .
we shall discuss this in detail in the last section .
for @xmath32 ( [ asymptotical_frequency ] ) coincides with the asymptotic formula found in @xcite in the regime @xmath118 with the help of the wkb approximation . unlike @xcite in our calculations
one does not need to be limited by the regime @xmath119 .
it is well known that due to a symmetry of the kerr - newman metric ( @xmath120 , @xmath121 ) quasinormal modes of a neutral scalar field come in within a degenerate pair @xmath122 when the scalar field is charged , in addition to ( [ degeneration ] ) one needs to take @xmath123 for the symmetry to be restored .
that is why we study only qnms with positive real parts .
the degeneration ( [ degeneration ] ) does not exist as soon as the coupling @xmath1 is not zero ( figs . [ figworotation ] and [ figrotation ] )
. then , at negative values of @xmath1 , the mode with a positive real part has slower decay rate than the one with the negative one ( while for positive @xmath1 the situation is opposite ) .
moreover , when the absolute value of @xmath1 increases ( figs .
[ figworotation ] and [ figrotation ] ) , the real oscillation frequency ( given by @xmath42 ) approaches zero and then the mode `` disappears '' from the spectrum at @xmath1 larger than some critical value .
such disappearing of a mode in some range of parameters is not unusual and happens , for example , for arbitrarily long living modes ( quasiresonances ) of a massive neutral scalar field @xcite .
we observe that at asymptotically late times , a neutral massless scalar field decays as @xmath124 in concordance with @xcite , while for the charged massless field , the dominant asymptotical tail is @xmath125 as it was first found in @xcite . "
note , that in the regime of large @xmath8 the correction formula to ( [ chargedtail ] ) was reported in @xcite , which might be correct , and , then , should appear at larger values of @xmath8 than those we considered in the numerical time - domain evolution here .
the late - time tails in the background of the extremally charged black hole obey the same law ( see fig .
[ figtailsextr ] ) . at
intermediately late times , _ a massive charged _ scalar field decay as ( see fig . [ figasympttailsmassive ] ) @xmath126 while at asymptotically late times , the decay law is @xmath127 thus , the power laws of a massive charged scalar field s decay at intermediate and asymptotically late times do not depend on multipole @xmath12 or charges @xmath3 and @xmath5 .
the same law was obtained in @xcite for the massive dirac field .
we suppose thereby that the asymptotic behavior of the charged massive fields does not depend on spin .
the decaying time - domain profiles for various values of the parameters @xmath3 , @xmath5 and @xmath2 show that no instability exist for nonextremal reissner - nordstrm black holes .
the complementary frequency domain data gives no indication of growing modes when the rotation is not vanishing .
therefore , we conclude that there are no signs of instability for a massive charged scalar field in the nonextremal kerr - newman background under the quasinormal modes boundary conditions .
we shall measure all quantities in units of @xmath128 , that is we take @xmath129 . in order to keep staying near the extremal state ,
it is sufficient to keep @xmath130 close to @xmath128 .
here we shall start from the generalization of level plots of @xcite , which show the branching of modes . in @xcite
it was found that , in the near - extremal kerr limit , zero - damped mode ( zdm ) satisfies @xmath131 where @xmath132 , @xmath133 . therefore , in fig .
[ fig1 ] the same multipole @xmath12 and azimuthal @xmath116 numbers were chosen as in @xcite . in fig .
[ fig1 ] it is shown the logarithm of the absolute value of difference between the left and right hand sides of the continued fraction equation ( [ continued_fraction ] ) as a function of real and imaginary parts of @xmath27 . in fig . [ fig1 ]
we can see that at some near - extremal @xmath130 , and @xmath19 , which starts from @xmath134 until its extremal value , the new branch of modes appears : the two branches of modes , which take place for high rotation ( @xmath135 ) , merge into a single one at slower rotation ( @xmath136 ) . as it is expected , for small values of black hole s
charge @xmath5 , the obtained in fig .
[ fig1 ] zero - damped mode is close to the one described by eq .
( [ eqhod2 ] ) .
the mode branching is owing to extremal rotation and not owing to extremal charge .
indeed , a neutral scalar field around the near - extremal reissner - nordstrm black hole shows no mode branching .
we have checked that the time - domain profile of scalar and gravitational perturbations of the exactly extremal reissner - nordstrm black hole consists of damped quasinormal oscillations , what proves stability of the extremal reissner - nordstrm solution from the point of view of an external observer , because 1 ) the profile includes contribution from all the modes , so that none can be missed , 2 ) the method of calculations does not imply any specific boundary conditions at the event horizon .
this does not contradict a special instability of the extremal reissner - nordstrm black holes @xcite as this instability develops only on the event horizon and can not be observed by an external observer @xcite .
.fundamental quasinormal modes ( @xmath114 ) of the scalar field for the extremal kerr - newman black hole ( @xmath137 ) . [ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] we have also showed that the decay of a scalar field ( be it charged or neutral , massive or massless ) is dominated by the power - law tails ( see table ( [ tail - summary ] ) ) which are the same for the nonextremal black hole as for the extremal one .
here we have considered an already formed black hole and the perturbation propagating outside of it , while the modeling of collapse of charged matter leads to different result for the late - time decay of the extremal reissner - nordstrm black hole @xcite .
thus we complement earlier results on late - time tails of neutral massive @xcite and massless fields @xcite in the schwarzschild and reissner - nordstrm backgrounds .
in addition , when @xmath138 the continued fraction equation ( [ continued_fraction ] ) indicates presence of some new roots in the frequency domain , which do not exist for the neutral field , and whose real parts are proportional to @xmath139 .
these roots exist for any value of @xmath5 and @xmath19 ( and nonzero @xmath3 ) , but correspond to higher `` overtones '' for weakly charged black hole ( fig .
[ figimaginarymode ] ) , yet , they become dominant for nearly extremal black holes .
these `` modes '' , if they exist , can not be extracted from a time - domain profile , probably due to the quick onset of asymptotic tails , and , therefore , must be further verified with an alternative method of calculation .
the obtained here conclusion on the stability of a massive charged scalar field around kerr - newman black hole allows us to go on the study of hawking radiation for this case .
using numerical techniques makes it possible to find grey - body factors accurately for the full range of parameters @xcite .
this work was supported by the european commission grant through the marie curie international incoming program .
r. a. k. acknowledges support of his visit to universidade federal do abc by fapesp .
a. z. was supported by conselho nacional de desenvolvimento cientfico e tecnolgico ( cnpq ) .
80 b. carter , phys .
lett . * 33 * , 558 ( 1974 ) .
g. w. gibbons , commun .
phys . * 44 * , 245 ( 1975 ) .
g. w. gibbons , monthly notices of the royal astronomical society , vol .
177 , oct .
1976 , p. 37p-41p .
a. n. aliev and d. v. galtsov , sov .
32 * , 75 ( 1989 ) .
s. hod and t. piran , phys .
d * 58 * , 024017 ( 1998 ) [ gr - qc/9712041 ] .
r. a. konoplya , phys .
d * 66 * , 084007 ( 2002 ) [ gr - qc/0207028 ] .
r. a. konoplya , phys .
b * 550 * , 117 ( 2002 ) [ gr - qc/0210105 ] .
j. jing , q. -y .
pan and x. he , int .
j. mod .
d * 16 * , 81 ( 2007 ) .
r. a. konoplya and a. zhidenko , phys .
d * 76 * , 084018 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv:0707.1890 [ hep - th ] ] .
k. d. kokkotas , r. a. konoplya and a. zhidenko , phys .
d * 83 * , 024031 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1011.1843 [ gr - qc ] ] .
a. flachi and j.
s. lemos , phys . rev .
d * 87 * , 024034 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1211.6212 [ gr - qc ] ] .
s. hod , phys .
b * 710 * , 349 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1205.5087 [ gr - qc ] ] .
a. a. starobinsky , zh .
fiz . , 64 , 48 , 1973 ( transl . in soviet phys .
jetp , 37 , 28 ) ; a. a. starobinsky and s. m. churilov , zh .
fiz . , 65 , 3 , 1973 .
j. bekenstein , phys .
d 7 , 949 ( 1973 ) h. furuhashi and y. nambu , prog .
* 112 * , 983 ( 2004 ) [ gr - qc/0402037 ] .
a. ohashi and m. sakagami , class .
21 , 3973 ( 2004 ) ; r. a. konoplya and a. zhidenko , phys .
b * 609 * , 377 ( 2005 ) [ gr - qc/0411059 ] ; r. a. konoplya , phys .
d * 73 * , 024009 ( 2006 ) [ gr - qc/0509026 ] .
a. zhidenko , phys .
d * 74 * , 064017 ( 2006 ) [ gr - qc/0607133 ] .
r. a. konoplya and a. zhidenko , phys .
d * 73 * , 124040 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/0605013 ] .
h. suzuki , e. takasugi and h. umetsu , prog .
phys . * 100 * , 491 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/9805064 ] .
e. w. leaver , proc .
a * 402 * , 285 ( 1985 ) .
nollert h. -p .
1993 phys . rev .
* d * 47 5253 .
b. f. schutz and c. m. will astrophys .
j. lett * 291 * l33 ( 1985 ) ; s. iyer and c. m. will phys . rev .
d * 35 * 3621 ( 1987 ) ; r. a. konoplya , phys .
rev d * 68 * , 024018 ( 2003 ) ; j. phys .
stud . * 8 * , 93 ( 2004 ) .
+ the 6th - order wkb formula can be downloaded from : ` http://fma.if.usp.br/~konoplya/ ` e. abdalla , c. e. pellicer , j. de oliveira and a. b. pavan , phys .
d * 82 * , 124033 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1010.2806 [ hep - th ] ] .
r. h. price , phys .
d * 5 * , 2419 ( 1972 ) ; phys .
d * 5 * , , 2439 ( 1972 ) . j. bik , gen .
. gravit . * 3 * , 331 ( 1972 ) .
x. he and j. jing , nucl .
b * 755 * , 313 ( 2006 ) [ gr - qc/0611003 ] .
r. a. konoplya and a. zhidenko , rev .
phys . * 83 * , 793 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1102.4014 [ gr - qc ] ] ; a. ishibashi and h. kodama , prog .
suppl . * 189 * , 165 ( 2011 ) .
s. aretakis , commun .
phys . * 307 * , 17 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1110.2007 [ gr - qc ] ] .
s. aretakis , j. funct .
* 263 * , 2770 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1110.2006 [ gr - qc ] ] .
j. lucietti , k. murata , h. s. reall and n. tanahashi , arxiv:1212.2557 [ gr - qc ] .
j. lucietti and h. s. reall , phys .
d * 86 * , 104030 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1208.1437 [ gr - qc ] ] .
h. onozawa , t. mishima , t. okamura and h. ishihara , phys .
d * 53 * , 7033 ( 1996 ) [ gr - qc/9603021 ] .
p. pani , e. berti and l. gualtieri , phys .
lett . *
110 * , 241103 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1304.1160 [ gr - qc ] ] .
h. yang , f. zhang , a. zimmerman , d. a. nichols , e. berti and y. chen , phys .
d * 87 * , 041502 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1212.3271 [ gr - qc ] ] .
s. hod and t. piran , phys .
d bf 75 , 064013 ( 2007 ) . c. gundlach , r. h. price and j. pullin , phys .
d * 49 * , 883 ( 1994 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/9307009 ] .
k. murata , private communication .
h. koyama and a. tomimatsu , phys .
d * 64 * , 044014 ( 2001 ) [ gr - qc/0103086 ] .
r. a. konoplya and a. zhidenko , `` _ _ a massive charged scalar field in the kerr - newman background ii : scattering and hawking radiation _ _ '' , work in progress | so far analysis of the quasinormal spectrum of a massive charged scalar field in the black hole background has been limited by the regime of small @xmath0 and @xmath1 , where @xmath2 , @xmath3 ( @xmath4 , @xmath5 ) are mass and charge of the field ( black hole ) . here
we shall present a comprehensive picture of quasinormal modes , late - time tails and stability of a massive charged scalar field around kerr - newman black holes for any physically meaningful values of the parameters .
we shall show that despite presence of the two mechanisms of superradiance ( owing to black hole s rotation and charge ) and the massive term creating growing bound states , there is no indication of instability under quasinormal modes boundary conditions .
we have shown that for some moderate values of @xmath1 dominant quasinormal modes may have _ arbitrarily small real oscillation frequencies _
@xmath6 .
an analytic formula for the quasinormal modes has been derived in the regime of large @xmath1 . the larger the field s charge , the sooner asymptotic tails dominate in a signal , making it difficult to extract quasinormal frequencies from a time - domain profile .
analytic expressions for intermediate and asymptotically late - time tails have been found for the reissner - nordstrm black hole . for the near extremal kerr - newman black holes we have obtained a more general picture of the _ mode branching _ found recently for massless fields ( arxiv:1212.3271 ) in the kerr background . |
distant powerful radio galaxies are important laboratories for studying the formation and evolution of massive galaxies , because they are among the most luminous and largest known galaxies in the early universe and likely progenitors of dominant cluster galaxies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
they are generally embedded in giant ( cd - sized ) ionized gas halos ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) surrounded by galaxy overdensities , whose structures have sizes of a few mpc @xcite .
the radio galaxy hosts have clumpy optical morphologies @xcite , spectra indicative of extreme star formation ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , and large stellar masses @xcite . because the radio lifetimes ( few times 10@xmath4 yr ) are much smaller than cosmological timescales , the statistics are consistent with every dominant cluster galaxy having gone through a luminous radio phase during its evolution @xcite
hence , distant radio galaxies may be typical progenitors of galaxies that dominate the cores of local clusters .
the radio source mrc 1138262 , identified with a galaxy at @xmath5 , is one of the most intensively studied distant radio galaxies @xcite .
several of its properties are those expected of the progenitor of a dominant cluster galaxy .
the @xmath6-band luminosity corresponds to a stellar mass of @xmath7@xmath8 @xmath2 @xcite , implying that mrc 1138262 is one of the most massive galaxies known at @xmath9 .
the host galaxy is surrounded by a giant ly@xmath10 halo @xcite and the faraday rotation of the radio source is among the largest known @xcite , indicating that the system is embedded in a dense hot ionized gas with an ordered magnetic field .
the radio galaxy is associated with a 3 mpc - sized structure of galaxies , of estimated mass @xmath11 2 @xmath1@xmath12 @xmath2 , the presumed antecedent of a local cluster .
the presence of this
protocluster " has been deduced using three independent selection techniques .
there are overdensities of ly@xmath10 and h@xmath10 emission lines objects and galaxies having 4000 break continuum features at the approximate redshift of the radio galaxy @xcite .
previous observations of mrc 1138262 with the _ hubble space telescope ( hst ) _ indicated that its optical emission is clumpy @xcite , indicative of a merging structure . here
we present a new _ hst _ image of the radio galaxy that reaches 2 mag fainter than previous images and shows the merging processes in unprecedented detail . throughout this letter
we assume a standard cosmology with @xmath13 = 72 km s@xmath3 mpc@xmath3 , @xmath14 = 0.27 , and @xmath15 = 0.73 , implying that at the distance of mrc 1138262 , an angular scale of 1 corresponds to a projected linear scale of 8.3 kpc .
we obtained deep images of mrc 1138262 with the advanced camera for surveys ( acs ; * ? ? ? * ) on the _ hst_. the centre of the 1138262 protocluster was observed with the acs during 2005 1722 may in two 34@xmath134 acs fields that overlapped by 1 in a region that includes the radio galaxy .
the total exposure time in the overlapping region was nine orbits with the f475w ( @xmath16 ) filter and 10 orbits with the f814w ( @xmath17 ) filter .
the filters were selected to sample the continuum radiation with maximum sensitivity and colour discrimination , while minimizing contamination from bright emission lines .
although the @xmath181549 and @xmath181640 lines fall within the @xmath16 passband , their measured rest - frame equivalent widths are 6 and 10 , respectively @xcite , implying that their effect on the continuum image is negligible .
the observations were processed through the acs gto pipeline @xcite to produce registered , cosmic - ray rejected images . a deep 19 orbit composite image of the continuum emission
was then produced by adding the @xmath16 and @xmath17 images .
the @xmath19 depth in the overlapping region is 29.3 and 29.0 mag in the respective @xmath16 and @xmath17 images measured in a square @xmath20 diameter aperture .
the _ hst _ image of the host galaxy and its immediate surroundings is shown in figure 1 , with rest - frame velocities of the ly@xmath10 emission corresponding to several of the acs continuum clumps .
figure 2 illustrates the relation of the continuum optical emission to the associated gaseous halo and relativistic plasma .
the giant gaseous halo extends by at least 25 ( @xmath7200 kpc ) and is one of the largest ly@xmath10 structures known in the universe .
there are several features in the figures that are of interest : \1 .
the optical continuum emission of the galaxy consists of at least 10 distinct clumps .
the clumps are presumably satellite galaxies that are still merging with mrc 1138262 .
they have sizes of typically @xmath70105 , corresponding to @xmath715 kpc , i.e. comparable to the typical sizes of lyman break galaxies @xcite
several of the satellites have elongated structures reminiscent of chain and tadpole galaxies recently found to dominate the resolved population of the hubble ultra deep field ( hudf , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
examples are denoted by numbers 1 , 3 , and 4 in figure 1 .
another linear , distorted galaxy is seen 3 north of the nucleus ( 2 ) , and several galaxies having double ( 6 , 8) or clumpy morphologies embedded in diffuse emission ( 5 , 7 ) lie at slightly larger distances from the main complex .
these objects have @xmath21 colors of between 0.1 and 0.7 magnitudes and @xmath17 magnitudes of between 24.3 and 27.7 , consistent with star formation at rates between 0.5 and 26 @xmath22 yr@xmath3 @xcite . to determine whether there is a concentration of such objects around the radio galaxy
, we analyzed the statistics of tadpole and chain galaxies having @xmath23 in the whole 3@xmath15 acs field around mrc 1138262 . to minimize systematic effects , the morphologies were classified manually by somebody not previously associated with the project ( e. h. ) . in the 10@xmath110 area around the radio galaxy ,
three such objects were found ( objects 1 , 3 , and 4 in fig .
this should be compared with an expected number of 0.22 from our analysis of the whole field , a value consistent with the hudf analysis of @xcite .
taking into account the clustering of these objects , the probability of finding three such galaxies within a 10@xmath110 region was estimated to be parts in 1000 .
this implies that the chain and tadpole galaxies are concentrated at the position of the radio galaxy and connected with the forming massive galaxy at the protocluster centre .
faint diffuse emission is visible between the obvious clumps .
this extended emission is unlikely to be dominated by scattered light of an obscured nuclear quasar , because its morphology is not reminiscent of a scattering cone .
furthermore , its mean color is comparable to that of the star - forming clumps , consistent with the occurrance of ongoing star formation over the whole central 50@xmath140 kpc region .
the total extended luminosity ( comprising 45% of the total emission in @xmath16 ) implies a star formation rate of @xmath24100 @xmath22 yr@xmath3 .
ly@xmath10 was detected from all of the satellite galaxies in the halo that have been studied spectroscopically .
the width of the ly@xmath10 profile in the halo is consistent with the observed velocity dispersion of the associated protocluster , indicating that the galaxies are moving relative to each other with radial velocities of up to a few thousand kilometers per second .
although the optical structure is extended approximately along the radio axis , most of the galaxy is located outside the narrow region occupied by the radio source and is therefore unlikely to be influenced directly by the radio source .
the obvious interpretation of the new _ hst _ image is that it shows hierarchical merging processes occurring in a forming massive cd galaxy .
the morphological complexity and clumpiness observed in the mrc 1138 - 262 system agrees qualitatively with predictions of hierarchical galaxy formation models ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . because of its striking appearance and its probable nature
, we name the host galaxy of mrc 1138262 the `` spiderweb galaxy '' and refer to the small satellite galaxies located within and around it as `` flies . '' with relative velocities of several hundred kilometers per second ( fig .
1 ) , these flies will traverse the 100 kpc extent of the spiderweb many times in the interval between @xmath25 and 0 , consistent with the merger scenario .
vigorous merging also provides a plausible mechanism for fueling the supermassive black hole , which may subsequently quench any ongoing star formation through radio feedback ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) . using recent infrared spectroscopic observations of the gas in mrc 1138 - 262 , @xcite
show that the pressure of the radio source is sufficiently large to expel @xmath26 of the gas during the radio source lifetime .
after the gas available for star formation has been expelled , the growth of such a massive galaxy will proceed primarily through merging @xcite . assuming that the flies are undergoing single @xmath71 gyr starbursts , their star formation rates imply a final stellar mass for each satellite galaxy of several times @xmath27 @xmath2 and a total mass for all the flies of @xmath28 @xmath2 .
this is less than a tenth of the mass of the whole galaxy , derived from its @xmath6-band luminosity @xcite , implying that a large fraction of the galaxy mass has already assembled by @xmath29 .
such a relatively early growth disagrees with the predictions of some models for typical evolution of the dominant galaxies in the most massive clusters @xcite . the most intriguing feature in our _ hst _ image is the association of the linear flies ( chains and tadpole morphologies ) with the merging massive host galaxy . in the hudf
the frequency of such objects increases dramatically at faint magnitudes ( * ? ? ?
* @xmath30 @xmath24 24 ; ) . because such peculiar galaxies dominate the faint resolved galaxy population , they are likely to be an important source of star formation in the early universe .
the nature of these objects is unclear .
there are several possibilities .
1 . they may be spiral galaxies observed edge - on @xcite . however , it is difficult to account for the large numbers of faint linear galaxies observed in the hudf by such selection effects .
their elongated appearance may be due to star formation associated with radio jets @xcite produced by primeval massive black holes @xcite .
radio synchrotron jets are known to occur on varying scales , ranging from the most luminous galactic nuclei to x - ray binaries and jets are sometimes associated with star formation @xcite .
they may be formed as the result of merging , either of galaxies that are formed along filamentary gravitational instabilities @xcite or in major events @xmath70.7 gyr after the merging process has commenced @xcite .
the fact that the spiderweb linear flies are located in an environment where vigorous galaxy interactions are taking place is consistent with a merger hypothesis for their origin
. the motions of the flies with velocities of several hundred kilometers per second through the dense gaseous halo , perturbed by superwinds from the nucleus @xcite and the radio jet , could result in shocks .
the shocks would then lead to jeans - unstable clouds , enhanced star formation along the direction of motion , and chain and tadpole morphologies .
the morphology of the spiderweb galaxy provides a unique new testbed for simulations of forming massive galaxies at the centers of galaxy clusters .
the occurrence of tadpole and chain galaxies in the dense central environment of the protocluster places constraints on ( 1 ) evolution models for dominant cluster galaxies and ( 2 ) the nature of the chains and tadpoles , an important constituent of the early universe .
our results are consistent with a merger scenario for the formation of these peculiar linear galaxies .
deep observations with the _ hst _ of similar objects over a range of redshifts are needed to study whether linear flies are generally present in the vicinity of cd galaxy progenitors and how their luminosity functions in these special regions compare with those of other types of galaxies .
the positions and morphological parameters of flies in spiderweb galaxies at @xmath9 together with hubble data on dominant cluster galaxies at @xmath31 will provide new constraints for models of massive galaxy formation .
future spectroscopic observations will delineate the velocity field and color distributions of mrc 1128262 in more detail , thereby elucidating further how the flies are being captured by the spiderweb galaxy .
g. k. m. acknowledges support from the royal netherlands academy for arts and sciences and the netherlands organization for scientific research ( nwo ) .
j. k. was supported by dfg/ sfb 439 .
the acs was developed under nasa contract nas 5 - 32864 .
the research has been supported by nasa grant nag5 - 7697 and an equipment grant from sun microsystems , inc .
this letter is based partially on observations made with ( 1 ) the acs on the nasa / esa hubble space telescope , obtained via the stsci , which is operated by the aura inc .
, under nasa contract nas 5 - 26555 , ( 2 ) the vlt at eso , paranal , chile , program p63.o-0477(a ) , and ( 3 ) the vla operated by the nrao , which is operated by the aui .
bicknell , g. v. , sutherland , r. s. , van breugel , w. j. m. , dopita , m. a. , dey , a. , & miley , g. k. 2000 , , 540 , 678 blakeslee , j. p. , anderson , k. r. , meurer , g. r. , bentez , n. , & magee , d. 2003 , in asp conf .
295 , astronomical data analysis software and systems xii , ed .
e. payne , r. i. jedrzejewski , & r. n. hook ( san francisco ; asp ) , 257 bouwens , r. j. , illingworth , g. d. , blakeslee , j. p. , broadhurst , t. j. , & franx , m. 2004 , , 611 , l1 carilli , c. l. , rttgering , h. j. a. , van ojik , r. , miley , g. k. , & van breugel , w. j. m. 1997 , , 109 , 1 croton , d. j. , et al .
2006 , , 365 , 11 de lucia , g. , & blaizot , j. 2006 , , submitted ( astro - ph/0606519 ) dey , a. , van breugel , w. , vacca , w. d. , & antonucci , r. 1997 , , 490 , 698 dubinski , j. 1998 , , 502 , 141 di matteo , t. , springel , v. , & hernquist , l. 2005 , , 433 , 604 elmegreen , d. m. , elmegreen , b. g. , rubin , d. s. , & schaffer , m. a. 2005 , , 631 , 85 ferguson , h. c. , et al .
2004 , , 600 , l107 ford , h. c. , et al .
1998 , , 3356 , 234 gao , l. , loeb , a. , peebles , p. j. e. , white , s. d. m. , & jenkins , a. 2004 , , 614 , 17 kurk , j. d. , 2003 , ph.d .
thesis , univ .
leiden kurk , j. d. , pentericci , l. , overzier , r. a. , rttgering , h. j. a. , & miley , g. k. 2004a , , 428 , 817 kurk , j. d. , pentericci , l. , rttgering , h. j. a. , & miley , g. k. 2004b , , 428 , 793 larson , r. 1992 , in star formation in stellar systems , ed . g. tenorio - tagle , m. prieto , & f. sanchez ( cambridge : cambridge univ . press ) , 125 madau , p. , pozzetti , l. , & dickinson , m. 1998 , , 498 , 106 miley , g. 2000 , in from extrasolar planets to cosmology , ed .
j. bergeron & a. renzini ( berlin : springer ) , 32 nesvadba , n. p. h. , et al .
2006 , , in press pentericci , l. , rttgering , h. j. a. , miley , g. k. , carilli , c. l. , & mccarthy , p. 1997
, , 326 , 580 pentericci , l. , rttgering , h. j. a. , miley , g. k. , mccarthy , p. , spinrad , h. , van breugel , w. j. m. , & macchetto , f. 1999 , , 341 , 329 pentericci , l. , rttgering , h. j. a. , miley , g. k. , spinrad , h. , mccarthy , p. j. , van breugel , w. j. m. , & macchetto , f. 1998 , , 504 , 139 pentericci , l. , et al .
2000 , , 361 , l25 rees , m. j. 1989 , , 239 , 1p rttgering , h. j. a. , van ojik , r. , miley , g. k. , chambers , k. c. , van breugel , w. j. m. , & de koff , s. 1997 , , 326 , 505 silk , j. , & rees , m. j. 1998 , , 331 , l1 springel , v. , di matteo , t. , & hernquist , l. 2005a , , 361 , 776 springel , v. , et al . 2005b , , 435 , 629 straughn , a. n. , cohen , s. h. , ryan , r. e. , hathi , n. p. , windhorst , r. a. , & jansen , r. a. 2006 , , 639 , 724 taniguchi , y. , & shioya , y. 2001 , , 547 , 146 van breugel , w. , filippenko , a. v. , heckman , t. , & miley , g. 1985 , , 293 , 83 van ojik , r. , rttgering , h. j. a. , miley , g. k. , & hunstead , r. w. 1997 , , 317 , 358 venemans , b. p. , et al .
2002 , , 569 , l11 venemans , b. p. , et al .
2005 , , 431 , 793 villar - martn , m. , et al .
2006 , , 366 , l1 zirm , a. w. , et al .
2005 , , 630 , 68 | we present a deep image of the radio galaxy mrc 1138262 taken with the _ hubble space telescope ( hst ) _ at a redshift of @xmath0 .
the galaxy is known to have properties of a cd galaxy progenitor and be surrounded by a 3 mpc - sized structure , identified with a protocluster .
the morphology shown on the new deep _ hst _ acs image is reminiscent of a spider s web .
more than 10 individual clumpy features are observed , apparently star - forming satellite galaxies in the process of merging with the progenitor of a dominant cluster galaxy 11 gyr ago .
there is an extended emission component , implying that star formation was occurring over a 50@xmath140 kpc region at a rate of more than 100 @xmath2 yr@xmath3 .
a striking feature of the newly named `` spiderweb galaxy '' is the presence of several faint linear galaxies within the merging structure .
the dense environments and fast galaxy motions at the centres of protoclusters may stimulate the formation of these structures , which dominate the faint resolved galaxy populations in the hubble ultra deep field .
the new image provides a unique testbed for simulations of forming dominant cluster galaxies . |
_ real projective 3-space _ , @xmath2 ,
is defined to be the quotient @xmath3 , where @xmath4 is the antipodal relation @xmath5 and can be thought of as the disk , @xmath6 , with antipodal boundary points identified .
projective space has a non - trivial first homology group , @xmath7 .
the generator for the group , @xmath8 , is the cycle originating from the line in @xmath6 that runs between the north and south poles .
mroczkowski @xcite has shown that every knot in @xmath2 can be transformed into either the trivial cycle or @xmath8 by crossing changes and generalized reidemeister moves on an @xmath9 projection of the knot .
thus , there are two non - equivalent unknots in @xmath2
. cycles that can be unknotted " into a cycle homologous to @xmath8 will be referred to as _ 1-homologous cycles_. cycles that can be unknotted " into a trivial cycle will be referred to as _
0-homologous cycles_. a _ link _ in @xmath2 is _ splittable _ if one of the components can be contained within a sphere , embedded in the space , while the other component remains in the complement of the sphere . otherwise , the link in @xmath2 is _ non - split_. a non - split link can be formed one of three ways in @xmath2 : two 0-homologous cycles , a 0-homologous cycle with a 1-homologous cycle , and two 1-homologous cycles .
note : two disjoint 1-homologous cycles will always form a non - split link .
similarly , a _
non - split triple - link _ is a non - split link of three components . in this paper
we will refer to non - split linked cycles as _ linked cycles _ and an embedding of a graph as _ linked _ if it contains a non - split link
. we will refer to a non - split triple - link as a _
triple - link _ and an embedding of a graph as _ triple - linked _ if it contains a non - split triple - link .
a graph @xmath10 is a _ minor _ of a graph @xmath11 if @xmath10 can be obtained from @xmath11 through a series of vertex removals , edge removals , or edge contractions .
a graph @xmath11 is _ minor - minimal _ with respect to a property @xmath12 if @xmath11 has property @xmath12 but no minor of @xmath11 has property @xmath12 .
if @xmath11 is a graph , define an _ induced subgraph _ , @xmath13 $ ] , of @xmath11 to be the subgraph of @xmath11 on vertices @xmath14 and the set of edges in @xmath11 with both endpoints in the set @xmath15 .
a graph @xmath11 is _ intrinsically linked in _
@xmath16 if and only if @xmath11 contains a non - split link in every spatial embedding .
we define _ intrinsically linked in _
@xmath17 analogously .
it has been shown that the complete set of minor - minimal intrinsically linked graphs in @xmath16 is the set of petersen family graphs @xcite ( including @xmath18 and graphs obtained from @xmath18 by @xmath19 and @xmath20 exchanges ) . however ,
all petersen family graphs except for @xmath21 embed linklessly in @xmath17 @xcite .
while @xcite characterizes several families of graphs that are minor - minimally intrinsically linked in @xmath17 , the complete set of minor - minally intrinsically linked graphs in @xmath17 , which is finite due to the result in @xcite , remains to be found .
a graph @xmath11 is _ intrinsically triple - linked in _ @xmath1 if and only if @xmath11 contains a non - split link of three components in every spatial embedding .
we define _ intrinsically triple - linked in _
an embedding is said to be 3-_linkless _ if and only if it does not contain a triple - link .
while conway , gordon @xcite , and sachs @xcite showed that @xmath18 is intrinsically linked in @xmath1 , @xmath18 can be linklessly embedded in @xmath2 ; it has been shown that 7 is the smallest @xmath22 for which @xmath23 is intrinsically linked in @xmath2 @xcite .
in contrast , while 10 was shown to be the smallest @xmath22 for which @xmath23 is intrinsically triple - linked in @xmath1 @xcite , we have shown that 10 is also the smallest @xmath22 for which @xmath23 is intrinsically triple - linked in @xmath2 .
it remains to be shown whether @xmath0 is minor - minimal with respect to triple - linking in @xmath2 .
additionally , we have shown two other intrinsically triple - linked graphs in @xmath1 can be embedded without a triple - link in @xmath2 .
a complete set of minor - minimal intrinsically triple - linked graphs remains to be found , in both @xmath1 and @xmath2 .
such sets are finite due to the result in @xcite .
we will need the following lemmas : [ k7 ] @xcite _ the graphs obtained by removing two edges from @xmath24 and removing one edge from @xmath25 are intrinsically linked in @xmath2 .
_ [ ohk4 ] @xcite _ given a linkless embedding of @xmath18 in @xmath2 , no @xmath26 subgraph can have all 0-homologous cycles .
_ we also use the following elementary observation .
[ evenk4 ] _ for every embedding into @xmath2 , @xmath26 has an even number of 1-homologous cycles .
_ the following lemma was shown true in @xmath1 by flapan , naimi , and pommersheim @xcite and the proof holds true analogously in @xmath2 .
[ ll ] _ let @xmath11 be a graph embedded in @xmath2 that contains cycles @xmath27 , @xmath28 , @xmath29 and @xmath30 .
suppose @xmath27 and @xmath30 are disjoint from each other and from @xmath28 and @xmath29 and suppose @xmath31 is a simple path . if @xmath32 and @xmath33 , then @xmath11 contains a non - split three - component link .
_ the following proposition is not the main result of this paper .
however , the proof is included because it is concise and since its method does not hold for proving @xmath0 is also triple - linked . _
the graph @xmath34 is intrinsically triple - linked in @xmath2 .
_ let @xmath11 be a complete graph on the vertex set @xmath35 .
embed @xmath11 in @xmath2 .
consider @xmath36 $ ] .
since @xmath24 is intrinsically linked in @xmath2 , this subgraph contains a pair of linked cycles that can be reduced to two linked @xmath37-cycles . without loss of generality ,
let @xmath38 and @xmath39 be the pair of linked cycles in @xmath36 $ ]
. now consider @xmath40 $ ] .
since @xmath24 is intrinsically linked in @xmath2 , this subgraph contains a pair of linked cycles that can be reduced to two linked @xmath37-cycles . in @xmath40
$ ] , one cycle must use @xmath41 and the other cycle must use @xmath42 , or lemma [ ll ] would apply immediately . without loss of generality ,
let @xmath43 and @xmath44 be the pair of linked cycles in @xmath40 $ ] .
consider @xmath45 $ ] . by lemma [ ohk4 ] ,
@xmath46 $ ] must contain a @xmath47-homologous cycle or @xmath45 $ ] contains a pair of linked cycles and lemma [ ll ] applies with @xmath29 and @xmath30 .
thus by lemma [ evenk4 ] , two cycles in @xmath48 must be @xmath47-homologous @xmath37-cycles .
now consider @xmath49 $ ] . by lemma [ ohk4 ] ,
@xmath50 $ ] must contain a @xmath47-homologous cycle or @xmath49 $ ] contains a pair of linked cycles and lemma [ ll ] applies with @xmath27 and @xmath28 .
thus by lemma [ evenk4 ] , two cycles in @xmath51 must be @xmath47-homologous @xmath37-cycles .
since every cycle in @xmath52 is disjoint from every cycle in @xmath53 , and at least two cycles in each set are @xmath47-homologous , there exists a link using one cycle from @xmath52 and one cycle from @xmath53 .
lemma [ ll ] then applies since every cycle in @xmath52 shares at least a simple path with @xmath27 , and @xmath28 and the cycle from @xmath53 are disjoint from each other , @xmath27 , and the cycle from @xmath52 .
thus , @xmath11 contains a triple - link .
-1.5 in in @xmath2.,title="fig : " ] -1.5 in _ if @xmath11 is @xmath18 embedded in @xmath2 and @xmath11 has two disjoint @xmath54-homologous cycles , then @xmath11 contains a non - split link . _
assume @xmath11 can be embedded so that it has two disjoint 0-homologous cycles and so that it does not have a non - split link . without loss of generality ,
let @xmath55 and @xmath56 be @xmath54-homologous cycles in @xmath11 .
consider @xmath57 $ ] .
since @xmath11 is not linked , by lemma [ ohk4 ] and lemma [ evenk4 ] , @xmath57 $ ] must have two @xmath47-homologous cycles . without loss of generality ,
let @xmath58 and @xmath59 be @xmath47-homologous cycles .
similarly , @xmath60 $ ] must also have two @xmath47-homologous cycles . since @xmath56 is @xmath54-homologous by assumption and @xmath61 is disjoint from @xmath59 , @xmath62 and @xmath63 are @xmath47-homologous cycles .
similarly , @xmath64 $ ] has two @xmath47-homologous cycles . since @xmath55 is @xmath54-homologous by assumption and @xmath65 is disjoint from @xmath62 , @xmath66 and @xmath67 are @xmath47-homologous cycles or @xmath11 would contain a pair of linked cycles .
now consider @xmath68 $ ] , which must also have two @xmath47-homologous cycles by lemma 2 and lemma 3 . since @xmath69 is disjoint from @xmath63 , @xmath65 is disjoint from @xmath62 , and @xmath70 is disjoint from @xmath58 , @xmath69 , @xmath65 , and @xmath70 must be @xmath54-homologous .
this forces @xmath71 $ ] to contain only 0-homologous cycles , and thus @xmath11 is linked by [ ohk4 ] .
thus , @xmath11 can not have two disjoint @xmath54-homologous cycles and not be linked . _ up to ambient isotopy and crossing changes , figure
[ linkless ] is the only way to linklessly embed @xmath18 in @xmath2 .
_ let @xmath11 be a complete graph on the vertex set \{1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6}. embed @xmath11 in @xmath2 .
the graph @xmath11 has a @xmath54-homologous 3-cycle , else @xmath11 has disjoint @xmath47-homologous cycles and is thus linked by proposition 6 . without loss of generality ,
let @xmath56 be a @xmath54-homologous 3-cycle .
now consider vertices \{1 , 2 , 3}. if @xmath55 is @xmath54-homologous , @xmath11 is linked ; thus , we assume @xmath55 is a @xmath47-homologous cycle .
mroczkowski @xcite showed that any cycle can be made into an unknotted @xmath54- or @xmath47-homologous cycle by crossing changes , so we can assume after crossing changes and ambient isotopy the embedding has a projection as drawn in figure [ linkless ] ( except the edges between the vertices @xmath72 and @xmath73 may be more complicated than in the figure ) with vertices @xmath72 on the boundary and the edges between them on the boundary .
we may use ambient isotopy and crossing changes so that edges from @xmath72 to @xmath73 connect in the projection without crossing the boundary of @xmath74 .
we now show that we may connect them , without loss of generality , as depicted in figure 1 .
if vertex @xmath75 , @xmath76 must connect to at least one of \{4 , 5 , 6 } from @xmath77 and to at least one of \{4 , 5 , 6 } from @xmath78 , else there would be a @xmath54-homologous @xmath26 and @xmath11 would be linked by lemma 2 . without loss of generality , assume @xmath79 connects to @xmath80 and @xmath81 from @xmath82 and to @xmath83 from @xmath84 . if @xmath85 connects to @xmath80 and @xmath81 from @xmath86 , then @xmath87 $ ] is a @xmath54-homologous @xmath26 and @xmath11 is linked by lemma 2 .
thus , @xmath85 connects to either @xmath80 or @xmath81 from @xmath86 and connects to the other from @xmath88 . without loss of generality ,
let @xmath86 connect to @xmath80 ; so , @xmath88 connects to @xmath81 .
if @xmath86 connects to @xmath83 , then either @xmath89 or @xmath90 must connect to both @xmath83 and @xmath81 and the other to @xmath80 , else @xmath11 has a @xmath54-homologous @xmath26 . without loss of generality ,
let @xmath89 connect to @xmath83 and @xmath81 and @xmath90 connect to @xmath80 .
then , @xmath91 and @xmath92 are disjoint @xmath47-homologous cycles so @xmath11 is linked .
thus , @xmath88 connects to @xmath83 .
now , if @xmath89 connects to either @xmath80 and @xmath81 or @xmath83 and @xmath81 , then @xmath11 has a @xmath54-homologous @xmath26 and is linked by lemma 2 .
so , @xmath89 must connect to @xmath81 and @xmath90 must connect to @xmath80 and @xmath83 .
-1.5 in in @xmath2.,title="fig : " ] -1.5 in signed graphs , that is , graphs with each edge assigned a @xmath93 or a @xmath94 sign , have been studied extensively and were first introduced by harary @xcite , see also @xcite .
an embedding of a graph @xmath11 into @xmath2 induces a signed graph of @xmath11 as follows : deform the embedding so that no vertices touch the line at infinity and all intersections of edges with the line at infinity are transverse . assign @xmath93 edges to be edges that hit the boundary an even number of times and @xmath94 edges to be edges that hit the boundary an odd number of times . if a cycle has an odd number of @xmath94 edges , then the cycle is @xmath47-homologous .
two embeddings , @xmath95 and @xmath96 , of a graph @xmath11 are _ crossing - change equivalent _ if and only if @xmath95 can be obtained from @xmath96 by crossing changes and ambient isotopy .
thus , by proposition 7 , a linkless @xmath18 is crossing - change equivalent to the embedding in figure [ signed ] .
that is , @xmath97 , @xmath98 , @xmath99 , @xmath100 , @xmath101 , and @xmath102 are @xmath94 edges , and the other nine edges are @xmath93 edges . _
the graph @xmath0 is intrinsically triple - linked in @xmath2 .
_ let @xmath11 be a graph isomorphic to @xmath0 on the vertex set @xmath103 .
embed @xmath11 in @xmath2 .
assume the embedding is 3-linkless .
if every subgraph of @xmath11 isomorphic to @xmath18 is linked , then flapan , naimi , and pommersheim s proof @xcite that @xmath0 is intrinsically linked in @xmath1 nearly works , except they do use the fact that @xmath104 is intrinsically linked at the very end and @xmath104 is not intrinsically linked in @xmath2 .
bowlin - foisy @xcite , however , modify @xcite slightly so that only the fact that @xmath18 is intrinsically linked is needed . thus , in the case that every subgraph of @xmath11 isomorphic to @xmath18 is linked , then @xmath11 is triple - linked .
so we may assume there exists a linkless @xmath18 subgraph in @xmath11 .
without loss of generality , assume this linkless @xmath18 is on vertices @xmath105 .
by proposition 7 , this @xmath18 has an embedding crossing - change equivalent to that in drawn in figure [ signed ] .
* claim : * the embedded induced subgraph @xmath106 $ ] is @xmath54-homologous .
assume @xmath50 $ ] has a @xmath47-homologous cycle .
without loss of generality , let @xmath107 be a @xmath47-homologous cycle
. now consider @xmath108 $ ] . if @xmath108 $ ] is not @xmath54-homologous , then two of @xmath109 , @xmath110 , and @xmath111 are @xmath47-homologous by lemma [ evenk4 ] .
then @xmath55 , @xmath107 , and a cycle from @xmath108 $ ] comprise three disjoint @xmath47-homologous cycles , so @xmath11 is triple - linked .
thus , @xmath108 $ ] is @xmath54-homologous and so @xmath112 $ ] has a pair of linked cycles by lemma [ ohk4 ] . since @xmath107 is @xmath47-homologous , and @xmath107 is disjoint from all the @xmath47-homologous cycles in the second column of table 1 , lemma [ ll ] applies and @xmath11 has a triple - link .
thus , @xmath50 $ ] is @xmath54-homologous .
[ cols="^,^ " , ] table @xmath113 .
this list exhausts the possible embeddings with @xmath114 and @xmath115 .
the same argument holds for the embedding has @xmath116 and @xmath117 .
thus , in every embedding of @xmath11 in @xmath2 , @xmath11 has a triple - link .
flapan , naimi , and pommersheim @xcite showed that @xmath118 can be embedded 3-linklessly in @xmath1 , and so @xmath118 can be embedded 3-linklessly in @xmath2 .
thus , 10 is the smallest @xmath22 for which @xmath23 is intrinsically triple - linked in @xmath2 .
_ a graph composed of @xmath22 disjoint copies of an intrinsically @xmath22-linked graph in @xmath1 is intrinsically @xmath22-linked in @xmath2 . in particular , three disjoint copies of intrinsically triple - linked graphs in @xmath1 are intrinsically triple - linked in @xmath2 _ if any of the three copies of the graph has all 0-homologous cycles , then it is crossing - change equivalent to a spatial embedding , and thus triple - linked , as its disjoint cycle pairs would have the same linking numbers as a spatial embedding .
else , all three copies have at least one 1-homologous cycle
. then we have three disjoint 1-homologous cycles , and thus have a triple - link . as shown above
, @xmath0 is an example of a one - component graph that is intrinsically triple - linked in @xmath1 . in the following section , we will exhibit two examples of minor - minimal intrinsically triple - linked graphs , each comprised of two components , that are intrinsically triple - linked in @xmath1 .
the question remains whether there exists a minor - minimal intrinsically triple - linked graph of three components in @xmath2 .
we will use the following theorem : @xcite _ let @xmath11 be a graph containing two disjoint graphs from the petersen family , @xmath95 and @xmath96 as subgraphs .
if there are edges between the two subgraphs @xmath95 and @xmath96 such that the edges form a 6-cycle with vertices that alternate between @xmath95 and @xmath96 , then @xmath11 is minor - minimal intrinsically triple - linked in @xmath1 .
_ -2.1 in connected to @xmath18 along a 6-cycle in @xmath2.,title="fig : " ] -1.7 in if @xmath95 and @xmath96 are isomorphic to @xmath18 , this result does not hold in @xmath2 , as seen in figure [ k6k6 ] . _
if @xmath95 and @xmath96 are disjoint copies of @xmath18 connected to @xmath18 along a @xmath119-cycle with vertices that alternate between the copies of @xmath18 , then @xmath120 is minor - minimal intrinsically triple - linked in @xmath121 . _
embed @xmath11 in @xmath2 .
if @xmath95 or @xmath96 has all @xmath54-homologous cycles , @xmath11 will have a triple - link since @xmath18 connected to @xmath18 along a @xmath119-cycle with vertices that alternate between the copies of @xmath18 is triple - linked in @xmath1 .
thus , @xmath95 and @xmath96 each have a @xmath47-homologous cycle .
let @xmath95 be a graph on the vertex set @xmath122 where @xmath123 $ ] and @xmath124 $ ] are the copies of @xmath18 and the connecting edges are @xmath125 , @xmath126 , @xmath127 , @xmath128 , @xmath129 , and @xmath130 .
up to isomorphsim , there are five @xmath37-cycle equivalence classes in @xmath95 .
consider @xmath131 , which contains one representative from each @xmath37-cycle class .
we assume , without loss of generality , one cycle in @xmath132 is @xmath47-homologous .
consider @xmath124 $ ] .
if there is a one homologous cycle in @xmath133 $ ] then this cycle will link with the cycle in @xmath132 that is @xmath47-homologous .
since the cycle from @xmath132 links with the @xmath47-homologous cycle in @xmath96 , we have a triple - link in @xmath11 .
thus , we assume every cycle in @xmath133 $ ] is @xmath54-homologous and so @xmath124 $ ] has a pair of linked cycles . by the pigeon - hole principle ,
at least two edges connecting vertices from the set @xmath134 are in a linked cycle in @xmath124 $ ] , so , without loss of generality , we may assume @xmath77 and @xmath78 are in one cycle .
if the @xmath47-homologous cycle is in the subset @xmath135 , then there are disjoint edges from the @xmath119-cycle that connect the cycle from @xmath136 to the cycle containing @xmath77 and @xmath78 .
so , by lemma [ ll ] , @xmath11 has a triple - link .
if @xmath137 is the @xmath47-homologous cycle , consider @xmath123 $ ] .
if there is a one homologous cycle in @xmath138 $ ] then this cycle will link with @xmath137 and the @xmath47-homologous cycle in @xmath96 , so @xmath11 will have a triple - link . else
, @xmath123 $ ] has a pair of linked cycles . by the pigeon - hole principle , at least two vertices in the set @xmath73
are in a linked cycle within the embedding of one copy of @xmath18 .
similarly , at least two vertices of @xmath134 are in a linked cycle in the other copy of @xmath18 . as a result of the @xmath119-cycle
, there are two disjoint edges between the cycles and lemma [ ll ] then applies and @xmath11 is triple - linked . to see @xmath11 is minor - minimal with respect to intrinsic triple - linking in @xmath121 , embed @xmath11 so that @xmath95 is embedded as in the drawing in figure [ k6k6 ] and @xmath96 is contained in a sphere that lies in the complement of @xmath95 .
therefore , @xmath95 does not have any triple - links and no cycle in @xmath95 is linked with a cycle in @xmath96 . without loss of generality , if we delete an edge , contract an edge or delete any vertex on @xmath96 , it will have an affine linkless embedding .
thus , we can re - embed @xmath96 within the sphere in each case .
thus , @xmath11 is minor - minimal for intrinsic triple - linking .
-1.5 in connected to @xmath24 along an edge in @xmath2.,title="fig : " ] -1 in @xcite _ let @xmath11 be a graph formed by identifying an edge of @xmath24 with an edge from another copy of @xmath24 .
then @xmath11 is intrinsically triple - linked in @xmath1 . _
if @xmath11 is isomorphic to @xmath24 connected to @xmath24 along an edge , this result does not hold in @xmath2 , as seen in figure [ k7k7 ] .
we will need the following lemma : [ 5v ] @xcite _ let @xmath12 be a petersen - family graph and @xmath76 be a vertex of p. if every cycle of @xmath139 is @xmath54-homologous in an embedding @xmath140 , then @xmath141 contains a non - trivial link . _ _ if @xmath95 and @xmath96 are disjoint copies of @xmath24 connected to @xmath24 along an edge , then @xmath120 is intrinsically triple - linked in @xmath121 . _ if @xmath95 or @xmath96 have all @xmath54-homologous cycles , @xmath11 will have a triple - link since @xmath24 connected to @xmath24 along an edge is triple - linked in @xmath1 . thus , @xmath95 and @xmath96 each have a @xmath47-homologous cycle .
let @xmath95 be a graph on the vertex set @xmath142 where @xmath36 $ ] and @xmath143 $ ] are the copies of @xmath24 and the connecting edge is @xmath144 .
up to isomorphsim , there are three @xmath37-cycle equivalence classes in @xmath95 .
we consider @xmath145 , which contains one representative from each @xmath37-cycle class .
we can assume , without loss of generality , at least one cycle of @xmath132 is @xmath47-homologous .
* case 1 : * let @xmath55 be a @xmath47-homologous cycle in @xmath95 . then @xmath55 links with the @xmath47-homologous cycle in @xmath96 .
consider @xmath146 $ ] .
if @xmath147 $ ] has a @xmath47-homologous cycle , then there are three disjoint @xmath47-homologous cycles , so we assume @xmath146 $ ] must be @xmath54-homologous and so @xmath147 $ ] has a pair of linked cycles .
lemma [ ll ] applies with @xmath148 connecting to the cycle that uses @xmath81 , following the proof in @xcite .
* case 2 : * let @xmath149 be a @xmath47-homologous cycle in @xmath95 .
@xmath149 links with the @xmath47-homologous cycle in @xmath96 .
consider @xmath146 $ ] .
if @xmath147 $ ] has a @xmath47-homologous cycle , then there are three disjoint @xmath47-homologous cycles , so we assume @xmath147 $ ] must be @xmath54-homologous and so @xmath146 $ ] has a pair of linked cycles .
lemma [ ll ] applies with @xmath148 connecting to the cycle that uses @xmath81 , following the proof in @xcite .
* case 3 : * let @xmath150 be a @xmath47-homologous cycle in @xmath95 .
@xmath150 links with the @xmath47-homologous cycle in @xmath96 .
consider @xmath146 $ ] . if @xmath151 $ ] has a @xmath47-homologous cycle , then there are three disjoint @xmath47-homologous cycles , so we assume @xmath151 $ ] must be @xmath54-homologous
. then , by lemma [ 5v ] , @xmath146 $ ] has a pair of linked cycles .
lemma [ ll ] applies with @xmath148 connecting to the cycle with @xmath81 , following the proof in @xcite .
we note that if @xmath24 connected to @xmath24 along an edge is minor - minimal with respect to triple - linking in @xmath1 , then we would also have that two disjoint copies of @xmath24 connected to @xmath24 along an edge is minor - minimal intrinsically triple - linked in @xmath2 . however , the minor - minimality of this graph is still unknown in @xmath1 .
we also note that @xmath152 , as defined in @xcite , is a one - component minor - minimal intrinsically @xmath153-linked graph in @xmath2 , by the same arguement given in @xcite , since @xmath21 is intrinsically linked in both @xmath1 and @xmath2 .
in @xmath2 , there are intrinsically linked graphs for which there exists an embedding in which every pair of disjoint cycles has linking number less than 1 .
work has been done in @xmath1 to find graphs containing disjoint cycles with large linking number in every spatial embedding .
using the fact that @xmath0 is triple - linked in @xmath1 , flapan @xcite showed that every spatial embedding of @xmath0 contains a two - component link @xmath155 such that , for some orientation , @xmath156 a similar argument using theorem 8 yields the following proposition .
h. sachs , _ on spatial representation of finite graphs _ , ( proceedings of a conference held in lagow , february 10 - 13 , 1981 , poland ) , lecture notes in math . ,
1018 , springer - verlag , berlin , heidelberg , new york , and tokyo ( 1983 ) . h. sachs , _ on spatial representations of finite graphs , finite and infinite sets _ , ( a. hajnal , l. lovasz , and v. t. ss , eds ) , colloq .
jnos bolyai , vol .
37 , north - holland , budapest , ( 1984 ) , 649 - 662 . | flapan , _ et al _ @xcite showed that every spatial embedding of @xmath0 , the complete graph on ten vertices , contains a non - split three - component link ( @xmath0 is _ intrinsically triple - linked _ ) .
the papers @xcite and @xcite extended the list of known intrinsically triple - linked graphs in @xmath1 to include several other families of graphs . in this paper , we will show that while some of these graphs can be embedded 3-linklessly in @xmath2 , @xmath0 is intrinsically triple - linked in @xmath2 . |
bose - einstein condensates ( becs ) of trapped alkali atoms have internal degrees of freedom due to the hyperfine spin of the atoms .
when a bec is trapped in a magnetic potential , these degrees of freedom are frozen and the state of the bec is described at a mean - field level by a scalar order parameter . when a bec is trapped in an optical potential , however , the spin degrees of freedom are liberated , giving rise to a rich variety of phenomena such as spin domains @xcite and textures @xcite . here
the order parameter has @xmath0 components that transform under spatial rotation as the spherical tensor of rank @xmath1 , where @xmath2 is the hyperfine spin of bosons .
mean field theories ( mfts ) of spinor becs were put forth for both spin-1
@xcite and spin-2 @xcite cases . according to them
, the @xmath3 magnetic sublevel of an antiferromagnetic bec is not populated in the presence of magnetic field for both spin-1 and spin-2 cases
. however , law et al .
@xcite used many - body theory to show that the @xmath3 sublevel of a spin-1 bec _ is _ macroscopically populated due to the formation of spin - singlet `` pairs `` of bosons .
it was subsequently shown @xcite that the @xmath3 sublevel of a spin-2 bec is also macroscopically occupied due to the formation of spin - singlet `` trios '' of bosons .
the physics common to both cases is that the spin - singlet state is isotropic and therefore each magnetic sublevel shares the equal population .
a question then arises as to what extent and under what conditions mfts are applicable .
it is now understood @xcite that the validity of mfts is quickly restored with increasing an applied magnetic field .
thus for the many - body spin correlations to manifest themselves , the external magnetic field have to be very low .
the spin - singlet pairs of bosons should be distinguished from cooper pairs of electrons or those of @xmath4he due to the statistical difference of constituent particles .
the cooper pairs consist of fermions , so that the state is symmetric only under the permutations that do not break any pair . for the case of spin - singlet pairs of bosons ,
the state is symmetric under any permutation of the constituents .
the bose - einstein statistics leads to a constructive interference among permuted terms , giving rise to a highly nonlinear magnetic response to be discussed later .
in contrast with usual antiferromagnets , where antiparallel spins are alternately aligned ( neel order ) , `` antiferromagnetic " becs do not possess such a long - range spatial order because the system lacks crystal order .
the antiferromagnetic phase of becs is also called polar @xcite . in refs .
@xcite , only spin degrees of freedom are considered by assuming that the spatial degrees of freedom are frozen . in this paper
, we relax this restriction and develop a theory of spin-2 becs that enables us to study many - body ground states and the excitation spectrum thereof on an equal footing . for spin-1 becs
, this program has been carried out in ref .
many - body spin correlations and magnetic response of becs , the results of which were briefly reported in ref .
@xcite , are expounded .
the role of symmetry of the ground state in determining the character of the excitation spectrum is also elucidated .
this paper is organized as follows .
section [ sec : formulation ] derives an effective hamiltonian that enables us to study many - body spin correlations and low - lying excitation spectrum of spin-2 becs on an equal footing .
section [ sec : mft ] reviews mean - field properties of each phase of becs .
section [ sec : mbt ] studies many - body spin correlations and magnetic response of bec .
the energy eigenstate is explicitly constructed using the creation operators of boson pairs and trios .
the degeneracy of the eigenstate is examined and some novel magnetic response such as a huge jump in magnetization and the robustness of the minimum - magnetization state against an applied magnetic field are discussed .
section [ sec : bogoliubov ] derives excitation spectra of becs using the bogoliubov approximation .
all excitation spectra are obtained analytically and the relations of their characters to the symmetry of the ground state are discussed .
section [ sec : conclusions ] summarizes the main results of the present paper .
appendix [ app : characterization ] recapitulates the parametrization of the order parameter of spin-2 becs , and appendix [ app : zeeman ] describes a method of calculating zeeman - level populations .
consider a system of identical bosons with hyperfine spin @xmath1 and let @xmath5 ( @xmath6 ) be the field operator that annihilates at position @xmath7 a boson with magnetic quantum number @xmath8 .
the field operators are assumed to obey the canonical commutation relations @xmath9 = \delta_{mn}\delta(\bbox{r}-\bbox{r } ' ) , \ \ [ \hat{\psi}_m(\bbox{r}),\hat{\psi}_n(\bbox{r}')]=0 , \ \ [ \hat{\psi}_m^\dagger(\bbox{r}),\hat{\psi}_n^\dagger(\bbox{r } ' ) ] = 0 , \label{com}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the kronecker s delta @xmath10 takes on the value of 1 if @xmath11 and 0 otherwise .
the bose - einstein statistics requires that the total spin of any two bosons whose relative orbital angular momentum is zero be restricted to @xmath12 .
we may therefore use @xmath13 as an index for classifying binary interactions between identical bosons : @xmath14 where @xmath15 describes an interaction between two bosons whose total spin is @xmath13 . to construct @xmath15 ,
consider the operator @xmath16 that annihilates at positions @xmath7 and @xmath17 two bosons with total spin @xmath13 and total magnetic quantum number @xmath18 : @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the clebsch - gordan coefficient .
we may use @xmath21 to construct @xmath15 as @xmath22 where @xmath23 describes the dependence of the interaction on the positions of the particles .
because of the completeness relation @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the total density operator and : : denotes normal ordering , that is , annihilation operators are placed to the right of creation operators .
integrating eq .
( [ sum1 ] ) over @xmath26 yields @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the total number of bosons . in the case of
a dilute bose - einstein condensate of neutral atoms , we may to a good approximation assume that @xmath29 , where @xmath30 characterizes the strength of the interaction between two bosons whose total spin is @xmath13 , and is related to the corresponding s - wave scattering length @xmath31 as @xmath32 equation ( [ int2 ] ) then becomes @xmath33 in the following discussions we shall focus on this case and therefore denote @xmath34 simply as @xmath35 .
when @xmath36 , @xmath13 can take on values 0 , 2 , and 4 .
for @xmath37 , we have @xmath38 where @xmath39 . \label{spin2a00}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath40 , we have @xmath41 for @xmath42 we have @xmath43 , \label{spin2f=4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where eq .
( [ sum1 ] ) was used in obtaining the second equality .
summing eqs .
( [ spin2f=0 ] ) , ( [ spin2f=2 ] ) and ( [ spin2f=4 ] ) , we obtain the interaction hamiltonian as @xmath44 .
\label{int}\end{aligned}\ ] ] to eliminate the last term in eq .
( [ int ] ) , we note the following operator identity : @xmath45 where @xmath46 represents the spin density operators defined by @xmath47 with @xmath48 @xmath49 being the @xmath50-components of spin-2 matrices @xmath51 given by @xmath52 we may use eq .
( [ spin2identity ] ) to eliminate the last term in eq .
( [ int ] ) , obtaining @xmath53 , \label{spin2int2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath54 , @xmath55 , and @xmath56 . in the following discussions we shall assume that the external magnetic field is weak enough to ignore the quadratic zeeman effect .
then the total hamiltonian @xmath57 of the system consists of the kinetic energy term @xmath58 , the trapping potential energy term @xmath59 , the linear zeeman term @xmath60 , and the interaction term @xmath61 : @xmath62 where @xmath63 @xmath64 is the product of the gyromagnetic ratio and the external magnetic field which is assumed to be applied in the z - direction . when the system is spatially uniform , i.e. @xmath65 , it is convenient to expand the field operator in terms of plane waves : @xmath66 then the single - particle part of the hamiltonian becomes @xmath67 where @xmath68 , and the interaction hamiltonian becomes @xmath69 where @xmath70
mean field theory ( mft ) of spin-2 bec was discussed in refs .
we present here a brief summary of as much of this theory as is relevant to later discussions .
we shall also present some new results .
when the system is uniform , bec occurs in the @xmath71 state .
we therefore assume the following trial wave function @xmath72 where the complex amplitudes @xmath73 are assumed to satisfy the normalization condition @xmath74 the variational parameters @xmath73 are determined so as to minimize the expectation value of @xmath57 over the state ( [ sps ] ) : @xmath75 where @xmath76 when the external magnetic field is applied in the @xmath77-direction , only the @xmath77-component of @xmath78 is nonzero .
we thus obtain @xmath79 where @xmath80 with @xmath81 .
the mean - field solution should be determined so as to minimize @xmath82 subject to the normalization condition ( [ norm ] ) : @xmath83 where @xmath84 is a lagrange multiplier . multiplying both sides by @xmath85 and summing over @xmath8 yield @xmath86 on the other hand , multiplying both sides of eq .
( [ cond1 ] ) by @xmath87 and summing over @xmath8 yields @xmath88 when @xmath89 , eq .
( [ cond1 ] ) gives @xmath90\zeta_m=0 .
\label{fcond}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for nonzero components @xmath91 , eq .
( [ fcond ] ) gives @xmath92 the case of @xmath93 will be discussed in sec .
[ sec : cbec ] .
when @xmath94 , only one component can be nonzero .
the mean - field solutions , magnetizations , and mean - field energies are therefore given by @xmath95 where @xmath96 is an arbitrary global phase .
the ground state is degenerate with respect to the global phase @xmath96 .
this represents the gauge invariance , i.e. conservation of the total number of particle and leads to a massless goldstone mode , as will be shown in sec .
[ sec : fmb ] .
the conservation of the spin angular momentum does not lead to a new goldstone mode because in ferromagnets all spins are aligned in the same direction and therefore the total spin angular momentum has the same piece of information as the total number of particles .
the antiferromagnetic ( or polar ) phase of a bec is defined as the one having nonzero spin - singlet pair amplitude , @xmath97 . when @xmath97 , eq .
( [ cond2 ] ) gives @xmath98 . substituting this and eq .
( [ cond3 ] ) into eq .
( [ e ] ) yields @xmath99 with @xmath98 , eq .
( [ cond1 ] ) leads to @xmath100\zeta_m=0 . \label{cond4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] when @xmath94 , the solutions of eq .
( [ cond4 ] ) is that only ( @xmath101 , @xmath102 ) or ( @xmath103 , @xmath104 ) or @xmath105 is nonzero .
determining these values using conditions @xmath106 and eq .
( [ norm ] ) , we obtain the mean - field solutions and the corresponding magnetizations as @xcite @xmath107 the mean - field solutions ( [ afspinor ] ) and ( [ afspin2 ] ) are degenerate with respect to two continuous phase variables , that is , the global phase @xmath96 and the relative phase @xmath108 ( @xmath109 ) between the two nonvanishing amplitudes @xmath110 . corresponding to these two continuous degeneracies , we expect to have two goldstone modes , as will be shown in sec .
[ sec : afb ] . when @xmath93 , eq .
( [ cond3 ] ) with @xmath98 gives @xmath111 , which , together with ( [ cond1 ] ) , leads to @xmath112 .
hence we have @xmath113 .
this is possible only when the external magnetic field is zero .
the corresponding order parameter is given by @xmath114 this solution is degenerate with respect to five continuous variables : one global gauge ( @xmath115 ) , two relative gauges ( @xmath116 and @xmath117 ) , and two variables @xmath118 and @xmath119 that specify the amplitudes of the order parameter .
as a consequence of these degeneracies , we expect to have five ( three density - like and two spin - like ) goldstone modes , as will be shown in sec .
[ sec : afb ] .
the remaining possibility is the case in which @xmath89 and @xmath120 .
this phase will be referred to as cyclic phase .
the energy of this phase is given from eq .
( [ e ] ) by @xmath121 let us now parameterize the order parameter of the cyclic phase as it will be needed to find the bogoliubov spectrum .
there are four equations ( six real equations ) that restrict the order parameter of this phase , that is , @xmath122 we use the representation ( [ order ] ) of the order parameter derived in appendix [ app : characterization ] to analyze the cyclic phase .
this representation automatically satisfies the normalization condition ( [ sum ] ) . to meet the condition ( [ s- ] ) , we note that @xmath123 the condition ( [ s- ] ) therefore requires either @xmath124 on the other hand , eq .
( [ f+ ] ) becomes @xmath125=0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] whence we obtain @xmath126 from conditions ( [ cycond1 ] ) and ( [ cycond2 ] ) , we find the following three solutions and the corresponding magnetization : @xmath127 where a global phase @xmath96 , which is chosen to be a particular value in eq.([re ] ) , is recovered . while these solutions include three parameters , the condition ( [ fz ] ) leaves only two parameters free .
it should be noted that these three solutions give the same ground - state energy , and hence are equally possible unless magnetization exceeds @xmath128 . when it exceeds @xmath128 , only solution ( [ mfs1 ] ) is possible .
a remark is here in order . as the representation ( [ order ] )
is obtained by assuming the full isotropy of space , it does not cover the whole order parameter space in the presence of magnetic field .
we should therefore keep in mind that the solutions ( [ mfs1])-([mfs3 ] ) do not necessarily exhaust the whole order parameter space of the cyclic phase . in the following discussions we shall focus on the solution ( [ mfs1 ] ) . making the absolute square of each amplitude
yields @xmath129 where @xmath130 it follows from this or by direct calculation that @xmath131 because of this restriction , the ground state of the cyclic phase is degenerate with respect to at least two continuous phase variables .
we therefore expect to have at least two goldstone modes , as will be shown in sec.[sec : cb ] . in the absence of external magnetic field ,
the ground - state energies for the three phases are given from eqs .
( [ op_f ] ) , ( [ e2 ] ) , and ( [ cyclic ] ) by @xmath132 it follows that each phase is specified by @xcite .
@xmath133 in the presence of external magnetic field we define each phase as follows : @xmath134 by directly comparing the energies in eqs .
( [ e2 ] ) , ( [ op_f ] ) , and ( [ cyclic ] ) , we find that each phase is specified by the following conditions : @xmath135
in this section we study the case in which the system is so tightly confined that the coordinate part of the ground - state wave function @xmath136 is independent of the spin state and solely determined by @xmath58 , @xmath59 , and the spin - independent part of @xmath61 ; that is , @xmath136 is the solution @xmath96 to the equation @xmath137\phi=\epsilon\phi\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the lowest eigenvalue @xmath138 .
this assumption is justified if the second lowest eigenvalue @xmath139 satisfies @xmath140 where @xmath141 is an effective volume which coincides with @xmath142 in eq .
( [ pwe ] ) for the spatially uniform case ( i.e. , @xmath143 ) .
when the condition ( [ epsi ] ) is met , the field operator @xmath144 may be approximated as @xmath145 , where @xmath146 is the annihilation operator of the bosons that are specified by the spin component @xmath8 and by the coordinate wave function @xmath115 .
the spin - dependent part of the hamiltonian can then be written as @xmath147 where @xmath148 we first make some remarks on the properties of the operators @xmath149 .
the operator @xmath150 , when applied to the vacuum , creates a pair of bosons in the spin - singlet state .
this pair , however , should not be regarded as a single composite boson because @xmath150 does not satisfy the commutation relations of bosons .
the operator @xmath150 instead satisfies the @xmath151 commutation relations together with @xmath152 , namely , @xmath153=\pm\hat{\cal s}_\pm , \ \ [ \hat{\cal s}_+,\hat{\cal s}_-]=-2\hat{\cal s}_z,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the minus sign in the last equation is the only distinction from the usual spin commutation relations . as a consequence ,
the casimir operator @xmath154 that commutes with @xmath155 and @xmath156 is given by @xmath157 consider an eigenspace @xmath158 of @xmath154 with an eigenvalue @xmath159 .
the requirement that @xmath160 must be positive semidefinite means that , in @xmath158 , the eigenvalues of the operator @xmath156 has a minimum value @xmath161 , where @xmath162 is a nonnegative integer . for a state @xmath163 that belongs to the minimum eigenvalue
, the norm of @xmath164 must vanish ; hence @xmath165 with @xmath166 .
we thus obtain the allowed combinations of eigenvalues @xmath167 for @xmath154 and @xmath156 such that @xmath168 and @xmath169 here we have introduced quantum numbers @xmath170 and @xmath162 , where the operator @xmath150 raises @xmath170 by one and the relation @xmath171 holds .
we may thus interpret @xmath170 as the number of spin - singlet ` pairs ' , and @xmath162 as that of the remaining bosons .
exact energy eigenvalues of hamiltonian ( [ h2 ] ) can be obtained as follows .
the operators @xmath172 are invariant under any rotation of the system , namely , they commute with the total spin operator @xmath173 .
the energy eigenstates can thus be classified according to quantum numbers @xmath162 and @xmath170 , total spin @xmath13 , and magnetic quantum number @xmath174 .
we thus denote the eigenstates as @xmath175 , where @xmath176 labels orthonormal degenerate states , that is , @xmath177 the number of degenerate states @xmath178 for a given set of @xmath179 will be referred to as the size of the eigenspaces for @xmath179 .
it will be shown to be independent of @xmath170 and @xmath174 below .
the energy eigenvalue for the state @xmath175 is given by @xmath180 + \frac{c_2}{5v^{\rm eff}}n_{\rm s}(n+n_0
+ 3 ) -pf_z , \label{e2}\ ] ] where the relation @xmath181 is used .
the degeneracy @xmath178 can be calculated as follows .
first we show that @xmath178 is independent of @xmath170 and @xmath174 .
this is seen by the following relations , @xmath182 where @xmath183 , @xmath184 and @xmath185 these relations implies that the sizes of the eigenspaces for @xmath186 are not smaller than the size of the eigenspace for @xmath179 .
the degeneracy thus depends only on @xmath162 and @xmath13 .
next , we introduce a generating function of @xmath178 defined by @xmath187 let @xmath188 be the total number of states with a fixed number of bosons @xmath189 and a fixed magnetic quantum number @xmath174 .
this is given by the total number of combinations of nonnegative integers @xmath190 that satisfy @xmath191 and @xmath192 .
it follows that @xmath193 where we assume @xmath194 and @xmath195 to ensure the convergence of the series .
let @xmath196 be the total number of states for given @xmath189 , @xmath13 , and @xmath174 . because @xmath196 is independent of the value of @xmath174
, we shall denote it simply as @xmath197 .
the quantity @xmath188 is written in terms of the sum of @xmath197 as @xmath198 and hence @xmath199 .
let us extend the definition of @xmath197 to the negative values of @xmath13 through this relation .
it follows then from eq .
( [ gf_h ] ) that @xmath200 the right hand side of this equation can be written as the sum of two fractions @xmath201 , where @xmath202 and @xmath203 making maclaurin expansions of @xmath204 and @xmath205 around @xmath206 and regrouping them in terms of the form @xmath207 , we find that @xmath204 consists only of the terms with @xmath208 , and @xmath205 of those with @xmath209 .
we thus obtain @xmath210 the quantity @xmath197 is written by the sum of the degeneracy @xmath178 as @xmath211 and hence we can write @xmath212 , where we assume that @xmath213 .
it follows then from eq .
( [ gf_tildeh ] ) that @xmath214 and we finally obtain an explicit form of the generating function @xmath215 defined by eq .
( [ gf_def ] ) as @xmath216 the total spin @xmath13 can , in general , take integer values in the range @xmath217 .
however , from eq .
( [ def_gf ] ) we find that there are some forbidden values .
that is , @xmath218 are not allowed when @xmath219 , and @xmath220 are forbidden when @xmath221 . an easier way to find the forbidden values
is discussed at the end of sec .
[ sec : energy eigenstates ] .
the energy eigenstates @xmath175 can be constructed using one- , two- and three - boson creation operators .
let us define the operator @xmath222 such that it creates @xmath223 bosons in the state with total spin @xmath224 and magnetic quantum number @xmath225 when applied to the vacuum .
such states are unique when @xmath226 . among possible operators
@xmath227 , we choose the following five operators for constructing the eigenstates : @xmath228 = \sqrt{\frac{2}{5}}\hat{\cal s}_+ \\ \hat{a}^{(2)\dagger}_2&= & \frac{1}{\sqrt{14 } } [ 2\sqrt{2}\hat{a}_2^\dagger\hat{a}_0^\dagger -\sqrt{3}(\hat{a}_1^\dagger)^2 ] \\
\hat{a}^{(3)\dagger}_0&= & \frac{1}{\sqrt{210 } } [ \sqrt{2}(\hat{a}_0^\dagger)^3 - 3\sqrt{2}\hat{a}_1\dagger \hat{a}_0^\dagger\hat{a}_{-1}^\dagger + 3\sqrt{3}(\hat{a}_1^\dagger)^2\hat{a}_{-2}^\dagger + 3\sqrt{3}\hat{a}_2^\dagger(\hat{a}_{-1}^\dagger)^2 -6\sqrt{2}\hat{a}_2^\dagger\hat{a}_0^\dagger \hat{a}_{-2}^\dagger ] \label{def_a30 } \\ \hat{a}^{(3)\dagger}_3&= & \frac{1}{\sqrt{20 } } [ ( \hat{a}_1^\dagger)^3-\sqrt{6}\hat{a}_2^\dagger\hat{a}_1^\dagger \hat{a}_0^\dagger + 2(\hat{a}_2^\dagger)^2\hat{a}_{-1}^\dagger].\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that @xmath229 and @xmath230 do not exist because of the bose symmetry .
note also that the operators @xmath227 commute with @xmath231 .
consider a set @xmath232 of unnormalized states , @xmath233 with @xmath234 and @xmath235 .
the state @xmath236 has the total number of bosons @xmath237 and the total spin @xmath238 .
when @xmath189 and @xmath13 are given , @xmath239 is uniquely determined through the parity of @xmath13 , namely , @xmath240 if we introduce the following two parameters @xmath241 @xmath242 and @xmath243 are uniquely specified by them , and the remaining @xmath244 and @xmath245 are also determined as @xmath246 the parameter set @xmath247 is thus uniquely specified by the set @xmath248 .
let us consider the two commuting observables @xmath249 with @xmath250 .
let @xmath251 be the projection operator onto the simultaneous eigenspace of @xmath252 and @xmath253 corresponding to eigenvalues @xmath254 and @xmath255 , respectively .
noting that @xmath256 includes the term @xmath257 and @xmath258 includes @xmath259 , it can be seen from eqs .
( [ def_a12])-([def_state_unit ] ) that @xmath260 and also @xmath261 if we order the pair @xmath262 in the lexicographic way , namely , @xmath263 if @xmath264 or @xmath265 and @xmath266 , the above equations imply that a state in @xmath232 specified by @xmath248 is linearly independent of the set of states specified by @xmath267 with @xmath268 .
the set @xmath232 is thus a linearly independent set of states .
let @xmath269 be the total number of states in @xmath232 with @xmath189 bosons , total spin @xmath13 , and magnetic quantum number @xmath270 .
a generating function of @xmath269 is calculated as @xmath271 where @xmath204 is defined by eq .
( [ def_gf1 ] ) . compared to eq .
( [ gf_tildeh ] ) , we have @xmath272 .
this implies that @xmath232 is complete , namely , the set @xmath232 forms a nonorthogonal basis of the subspace @xmath273 in which magnetic quantum number @xmath174 is equal to total spin @xmath13 . the energy eigenstates can be obtained by partially applying the method of schmidt s orthogonalization to the nonorthogonal basis @xmath232 . here by `` partially " we mean that eigenstates corresponding to different energies are orthogonal , but that those corresponding to the same energy are not always so .
let us consider a series of subspaces @xmath274 , where @xmath275 is spanned by the states with quantum number @xmath170 [ see eq .
( [ def_n2 ] ) ] satisfying @xmath276 .
let @xmath277 be the projection operator onto @xmath275 . from the relation @xmath278 , we have @xmath279 . since @xmath280 for any state @xmath281 , we have @xmath282 implying that @xmath275 is spanned by all the states @xmath283 satisfying @xmath284 .
we can then construct a new basis @xmath285 made up of the states of the form @xmath286 is the projection onto the subspace with @xmath287 ( the kernel of @xmath288 ) .
it is easy to see that the states belonging to @xmath285 are simultaneous eigenstates of @xmath289 , and hence energy eigenstates .
the energy eigenstates with @xmath290 can be constructed by applying @xmath291 to the states of @xmath285 . to summarize , the energy eigenstates can be represented as @xmath292 with @xmath234 , @xmath235 , and @xmath293 .
these parameters are related to @xmath179 as @xmath294 and the corresponding eigenenergy is given by eq .
( [ e2 ] ) . note that the states defined in ( [ eigenstates ] ) are unnormalized , and the states having the same energy ( i.e. , those belonging to the same set of parameter values @xmath179 ) are nonorthogonal .
the representation ( [ eigenstates ] ) of the energy eigenstates utilizes the operator @xmath227 that creates correlated @xmath223 bosons having total spin @xmath1 .
it might be tempting to envisage a physical picture that the system is , like in @xmath295he , made up of @xmath296 composite bosons whose creation operator is given by @xmath227 . however , this picture is oversimplified .
first of all , the operator @xmath297 does not obey the boson commutation relation .
in addition , the projection operator @xmath298 in ( [ eigenstates ] ) imposes many - body spin correlations such that the spin correlation between _ any _ two bosons must have vanishing spin - singlet component .
note that two bosons with independently fluctuating spins have a nonzero overlap with the spin - singlet state in general .
the many - body spin correlations of the energy eigenstates are thus far more complicated than what an intuitive picture of composite bosons suggests . on the other hand ,
as long as quantities such as the number of bosons , magnetization , and energy are concerned , the above simplified picture is quite helpful . by way of illustration
, we provide an alternative explanation for the existence of forbidden values for the total spin @xmath13 , which were found earlier using the generating function ( [ def_gf ] ) .
for example , to construct a state with @xmath37 or @xmath299 , composite particles with total spin 2 must be avoided , namely , @xmath300 .
then we have @xmath301 , implying that @xmath37 or @xmath299 is only possible when @xmath219 .
for a state with @xmath40 or @xmath302 , we have @xmath303 and @xmath304 implying that @xmath305 .
the above simplified picture is also helpful when we consider the magnetic response as discussed below .
we consider here how the ground state and the magnetization @xmath174 respond to the applied magnetic field @xmath63 . from eq .
( [ e2 ] ) , we see that the minimum energy states always satisfy @xmath270 when @xmath306 .
the problem thus reduces to minimizing the function @xmath307 + \frac{c_2}{5v^{\rm eff}}n_{\rm s}(2n-2n_{\rm s}+3 ) -pf_z . \label{e3}\ ] ] for this purpose , it is convenient to consider the cases @xmath308 and @xmath309 separately .
let us first consider the case @xmath308 .
when @xmath310 , the energy ( [ e3 ] ) is minimized when @xmath287 , @xmath311 , and @xmath312 , and the ground state is given by @xmath313 , that is , the system is ferromagnetic .
this result is consistent with that obtained from mft .
when @xmath314 , let us rewrite the energy as @xmath315 the energy is thus lower when @xmath174 is closer to @xmath316 and when @xmath170 is smaller . in most of the parameter space , the ground state
is @xmath317 with @xmath13 taking the allowed integer closest to @xmath316 .
since these states satisfy @xmath318 , they belong to the ferromagnetic phase or the cyclic phase .
the separatrix between the two phases is given by @xmath319 .
we thus find that the ground state is ferromagnetic if @xmath320 and cyclic otherwise .
this classification is consistent with the mean - field analysis given in sec .
[ sec : boundaries ] . as seen in sec .
[ sec : spectrum and degeneracy ] , the above ground state is highly degenerated in general ; this may originate from the continuous symmetry that leaves free at least two parameters characterizing the order parameter of the cyclic phase as shown in sec .
[ sec : cbec ] . according to the discussions in sec .
[ sec : spectrum and degeneracy ] , the degeneracy of the states @xmath317 is equal to the number of the combinations of @xmath321 satisfying @xmath322 and @xmath323 .
the number of trios , @xmath243 , can take values in the range @xmath324 .
when the magnetic field is nearly zero and @xmath325 , there is little degeneracy and @xmath326 , namely , almost all bosons form trios .
when @xmath316 is close to the forbidden values of @xmath13 ( @xmath327 if @xmath328 ( mod 3 ) , and @xmath329 otherwise ) for the above state with @xmath287 , @xmath174 may take those values at the cost of increasing @xmath170 to 1 or 2 , since any of the three values ( 0,1,2 ) of @xmath162 mod 3 is realized by setting @xmath170 as 0 , 1 , or 2 [ recall the relation @xmath330 . whether or not the states @xmath331 and @xmath332 can be the lowest - energy state depends on the ratio @xmath333 . in fig [ fig:1 ] ,
we give diagrams of the ground states for small @xmath334 . in this case , it is convenient to introduce a new parameter @xmath335 and consider the energy as a function of @xmath174 and @xmath336 : @xmath337 ^ 2-\frac{c_2}{40v^{\rm eff}}l(l+2f+6)+{\rm const}. \label{e_fz_l}\ ] ] since @xmath309 , we see that @xmath338 is an increasing function of @xmath339 , namely , @xmath340 let us consider the cases @xmath341 and @xmath342 separately . _
( a ) _ @xmath341 in this parameter region , mft predicts that the system is ferromagnetic , namely , the lowest - energy state always shows @xmath343 regardless of the magnitude of magnetic field @xmath63 . in the exact solution considered here ,
the magnetic response is different because of the offset term @xmath344 in eq .
( [ e_fz_l ] ) . since @xmath309
, this term counteracts the applied magnetic field .
it is thus expected that magnetization is suppressed when magnetic field is weak .
the exact ground state is derived as follows .
when @xmath189 is even , the state @xmath345 has energy @xmath346 , and the state @xmath347 has energy @xmath348 .
any other set @xmath349 gives an energy higher than one of these states .
@xmath345 is thus the ground state when @xmath350 , or equivalently , @xmath351 and otherwise the ground state is @xmath347 [ see fig [ fig:2 ] ] . when @xmath189 is odd , @xmath352 is attained only when @xmath353 , @xmath354 is forbidden , and the state @xmath355 has energy @xmath356 . it is easy to confirm that @xmath357 always holds . therefore , @xmath355 is the ground state when @xmath358 , or equivalently , @xmath359 and otherwise the ground state is @xmath347 [ see fig [ fig:2 ] ] .
these results indicate that in the parameter region of @xmath360 , magnetization of the ground state jumps from 0 or 2 to @xmath361 .
such a huge discontinuity does not appear in mft with a linear zeeman effect .
( however , in the presence of a quadratic zeeman effect , such a jump occurs also in mft @xcite . )
@xmath342 given @xmath362 , the minimum allowed value of @xmath339 is determined as follows .
note that @xmath363 is minimized when the number of singlets @xmath364 is maximized . for @xmath365 ( @xmath366 is an integer )
, the state @xmath367 gives @xmath368 . to increase @xmath174 by one ( @xmath369 ) ,
one singlet pair must be broken and the minimum of @xmath339 is @xmath370 given by the state @xmath371 . keeping the singlet part , @xmath174 can be further increased to @xmath372 by the state @xmath373 with @xmath374 .
since @xmath375 is forbidden , @xmath376 requires one more singlet pair to break up , resulting in @xmath377 with the state @xmath378 .
when @xmath379 falls between @xmath380 and @xmath381 , the lowest energy is the minimum of @xmath382 , @xmath383 , @xmath384 , @xmath385 , and @xmath386 . from eq .
( [ e_fz_l ] ) , we expect that when @xmath387 is large , nonzero @xmath339 pushes up the energy significantly and can not be the ground state , so that @xmath174 increases stepwise with @xmath388 .
when @xmath387 is small , @xmath174 will increase with the step size of @xmath389 .
this is confirmed by explicitly calculating @xmath338 using eq .
( [ e_fz_l ] ) , and we obtain the diagrams in fig . [ fig:3 ] . in the region
@xmath390 with @xmath391 ( see broken curves in fig .
[ fig:3 ] ) , @xmath174 increases by taking every integer . when @xmath392 , the values of @xmath376 are suppressed . in the region
@xmath393 with @xmath394 , the values @xmath369 are suppressed , and when @xmath395 with @xmath396 , the values @xmath372 are further suppressed and the step size becomes 4 . while the averaged slope @xmath397 coincides with that in mft , the offset term @xmath344 in eq .
( [ e_fz_l ] ) ( see also the broken lines in fig . [ fig:3 ] ) makes a qualitative distinction from mft , namely , the onset of the magnetization displaces from @xmath398 to @xmath399 .
note that the slope @xmath400 and the offset @xmath401 are determined by independent parameters .
a typical behavior of the magnetic response when @xmath402 is shown in fig .
[ fig:4 ] .
we now calculate the zeeman - level populations of the ground states for @xmath309 . in mft , the lowest - energy states for @xmath309 have vanishing population in the @xmath403 levels .
in contrast , the exact ground states derived in the preceding subsection , @xmath404 with @xmath405 and @xmath235 , have nonzero populations in the @xmath403 levels .
the exact forms for the averaged population @xmath406 are calculated as follows .
the above ground states have the form of @xmath407 with @xmath163 being a state with a fixed number ( @xmath408 ) of bosons satisfying @xmath409 . the average zeeman population for the ground states , @xmath410 is then simply related to the average zeeman populations for the state @xmath163 as @xmath411 where @xmath412 .
the derivation of the formula ( [ formula_zeeman1 ] ) is given in appendix [ app : zeeman ] .
the formula implies that when @xmath413 , the zeeman populations of the ground states is sensitive to the form of @xmath163 . with this formula ,
it is a straightforward task to calculate average zeeman - level populations for four types of ground states , @xmath404 with @xmath405 and @xmath235 .
the exact result will be given in appendix [ app : zeeman ] .
a striking feature appears in the leading terms under the condition @xmath414 .
the results are summarized as @xmath415 and @xmath416 as seen in the preceding subsection , with the increase of magnetic field , the ground state alternates among the four types of states . while this change causes a very small difference in magnetization
, it leads to large changes in the average zeeman - level populations , by a factor of 2 or 3 .
the origin of this drastic change may be explained as follows .
let us first consider the state @xmath417 with @xmath418 .
this state has no population in zeeman levels @xmath419 .
when @xmath420 is applied to this state , the operator @xmath421 that appears in @xmath420 has effectively a large amplitude of the order of @xmath422 .
hence the term @xmath423 is dominant , and it approximately adds one boson to the @xmath424 level and one boson to the @xmath3 level .
hence the @xmath3 population of the state @xmath425 is close to unity .
this change is then amplified by a factor of @xmath426 according to the formula ( [ formula_zeeman1 ] ) , leading to eq .
( [ population_0 ] ) .
similarly , applying @xmath427 effectively results in adding of two bosons to the @xmath424 level and one boson to the @xmath428 level through the dominant term @xmath429 .
in this section we study the low - lying excitation spectrum of spin-2 becs in the thermodynamic limit using the bogoliubov approximation .
we shall see that the symmetry of each ground state discussed in sec .
[ sec : mft ] is reflected in the excitation spectrum
. in the center - of - mass frame of the system bec occurs in the @xmath430 state .
we therefore decompose the operators that appear in eq .
( [ spin2int2 ] ) into the @xmath71 components and the @xmath431 ones . the first term on the right - hand side ( rhs ) of eq .
( [ spin-1v1 ] ) is rewritten as @xmath432 if we ignore the terms that do not include the @xmath71 components , we may approximate @xmath433 as @xmath434 where @xmath435 we thus obtain @xmath436 similarly , we may approximate the second term on the rhs of eq .
( [ spin-1v1 ] ) as @xmath437 where @xmath438 the third term on the rhs of eq .
( [ spin-1v1 ] ) is decomposed into @xmath439 where @xmath440 and h.c .
denotes hermitian conjugates of the preceding terms . substituting eqs .
( [ rhorho ] ) , ( [ ff ] ) and ( [ ss ] ) into eq . ( [ spin-1v1 ] ) , we obtain @xmath441 in the bogoliubov approximation we replace operators @xmath442 by c - numbers @xmath443 , where @xmath73 s denote the complex mean - field amplitudes introduced in sec . [
sec : mft ] and @xmath444 is the number of condensate bosons . since @xmath444 is smaller than the total number of bosons @xmath189 due to the interparticle interactions , we take into account the conservation of the total number of bosons through the relation @xmath445 then eq .
( [ h0 ] ) becomes @xmath446 \hat{n}_{\bbox{k},m } , \label{h00}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and eq .
( [ spin2v ] ) becomes @xmath447 where @xmath448 , and the definitions of @xmath449 , @xmath450 , and @xmath451 are given in eqs .
( [ f])([s- ] ) .
equations ( [ h00 ] ) and ( [ spin2vv ] ) constitute our basic hamiltonian in the following discussions .
we use this hamiltonian to examine low - lying excitation spectra for each phase .
let us first examine the excitation spectrum of a ferromagnetic phase in which bec occurs in the @xmath424 state .
then @xmath452 and eqs . ( [ h00 ] ) and ( [ spin2vv ] ) become @xmath453\hat{n}_{{\bbox{k}},m } , \label{h0f}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath454,\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively , where @xmath455 .
the total hamiltonian is therefore given by @xmath456 \nonumber \\ & & + \sum_{{\bbox{k}}\neq{\bf 0 } } \left[(\epsilon_{\bbox{k}}+p)\hat{n}_{{\bbox{k}},1 } + \left(\epsilon_{\bbox{k}}+2p-4c_1n\right)\hat{n}_{{\bbox{k}},0 } \right .
\nonumber \\ & & \left .
+ \left(\epsilon_{\bbox{k}}+3p-6c_1n\right)\hat{n}_{{\bbox{k}},-1 } + \left(\epsilon_{\bbox{k}}+4p-8c_1n+2c_2n/5 \right)\hat{n}_{{\bbox{k}},-2 } \right ] .
\label{hfm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the second line gives the bogoliubov spectrum @xmath457 while other terms give single - particle spectra : @xmath458 for the bogoliubov excitation energy to be positive , we must have @xmath459 that is , the s - wave scattering length for the total spin-4 channel must be positive .
this condition is the same as that required for the ferromagnetic mean field to be stable , that is , the first term on the rhs of eq .
( [ hfm ] ) being positive . for the single - particle excitation energies to be positive , we must have @xmath460 and @xmath461 .
these conditions are the same as those in ( [ condf ] ) for which the ferromagnetic phase is the lowest - energy mean field ( note that @xmath462 ) .
we note that the bogoliubov spectrum ( [ fbog ] ) is independent of applied magnetic field and remains massless in its presence .
this goldstone mode is a consequence of the global u(1 ) gauge invariance due to the conservation of the total number of bosons , as discussed in sec .
[ sec : mffm ] .
let us next examine the excitation spectrum of an antiferromagnetic phase in which the order parameter is given by ( [ afspinor ] ) . making the replacements @xmath463 and substituting eq .
( [ fsd ] ) into eq .
( [ spin2vv ] ) , together with eq .
( [ h00 ] ) , we obtain the total hamiltonian of an antiferromagnetic bec : @xmath464\hat{n}_{{\bbox{k}},2 } \right .
\nonumber \\ & & \ \ \ + \left[\epsilon_{\bbox{k}}+p(\langle\hat{f}_z\rangle+2)+c_0n|\zeta_{-2}|^2 + c_1n(4|\zeta_{-2}|^2 - 2\langle\hat{f}_z\rangle-\langle\hat{f}_z\rangle^2 ) + \frac{2c_2n}{5}(|\zeta_{2}|^2 - 2|\zeta_{2 } \zeta_{-2}|^2 ) \right]\hat{n}_{{\bbox{k}},-2 } \nonumber \\ & & \left . \ \ \ + \left [ \frac{1}{2}g_4n(\zeta_{2}^{*2}\hat{a}_{{\bbox{k}},2}\hat{a}_{-{\bbox{k}},2 } + \zeta_{-2}^{*2}\hat{a}_{{\bbox{k}},-2}\hat{a}_{-{\bbox{k}},-2 } ) + ( c_0 - 4c_1 + 2c_2/5)n ( \zeta_{2}^*\zeta_{-2}^*\hat{a}_{{\bbox{k}},2}\hat{a}_{-{\bbox{k}},-2}+ \zeta_{2 } \zeta_{-2}^*\hat{a}_{{\bbox{k}},2}^\dagger\hat{a}_{{\bbox{k}},-2 } ) + { \rm h.c.}\right ] \right\ } \nonumber \\ & & + \sum_{{\bbox{k}}\neq{\bf 0}}\left\ { \left[\epsilon_{\bbox{k}}+p(\langle\hat{f}_z\rangle-1 ) + c_1n(2|\zeta_{2}|^2+\langle\hat{f}_z\rangle-\langle\hat{f}_z\rangle^2 ) -\frac{4c_2n}{5}|\zeta_{2 } \zeta_{-2}|^2 \right]\hat{n}_{{\bbox{k}},1 } \right .
\nonumber \\ & & \ \ \ + \left[\epsilon_{\bbox{k}}+p(\langle\hat{f}_z\rangle+1 ) + c_1n(2|\zeta_{-2}|^2-\langle\hat{f}_z\rangle-\langle\hat{f}_z\rangle^2 ) -\frac{4c_2n}{5}|\zeta_{2 } \zeta_{-2}|^2 \right]\hat{n}_{{\bbox{k}},-1 } \nonumber \\ & & \left .
\ + 2(c_1-c_2/5)n(\zeta_{2}^*\zeta_{-2}^*\hat{a}_{{\bbox{k}},1}\hat{a}_{-{\bbox { k}},-1 } + { \rm h.c . } ) \right\ } \nonumber \\ & & + \sum_{{\bbox{k}}\neq{\bf 0}}\left\ { \left[\epsilon_{\bf k}+p\langle\hat{f}_z\rangle - c_1n\langle\hat{f}_z\rangle^2- \frac{4c_2n}{5}|\zeta_{2 } \zeta_{-2}|^2\right ] \hat{n}_{{\bbox{k}},0 } + \frac{c_2n}{5}(\zeta_{2}^*\zeta_{-2}^*\hat{a}_{{\bbox{k}},0 } \hat{a}_{-{\bbox{k}},0}+{\rm h.c . } ) \right\}. \label{hafm1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this hamiltonian may be simplified using the relation @xmath465 , giving @xmath466 \right\ } \nonumber \\ & & + \sum_{{\bbox{k}}\neq{\bf 0}}\left\ { \left[\epsilon_{\bbox{k } } + ( c_1-c_2/5)n+\frac{1}{2}(c_1+c_2/10)n\langle\hat{f}_z\rangle \right]\hat{n}_{{\bbox{k}},1 } + \left[\epsilon_{\bbox{k } } + ( c_1-c_2/5)n-\frac{1}{2}(c_1+c_2/10)n\langle\hat{f}_z\rangle \right]\hat{n}_{{\bbox{k}},-1 } \right .
\nonumber \\ & & \left .
\ + 2(c_1-c_2/5)n(\zeta_{2}^*\zeta_{-2}^*\hat{a}_{{\bbox{k}},1}\hat{a}_{-{\bbox { k}},-1 } + { \rm h.c . } ) \right\ } \nonumber \\ & & + \sum_{{\bbox{k}}\neq{\bf 0}}\left\ { (
\epsilon_{\bbox{k}}-c_2n/5 ) \hat{n}_{{\bbox{k}},0 } + \frac{c_2n}{5}(\zeta_{2}^*\zeta_{-2}^*\hat{a}_{{\bbox{k}},0 } \hat{a}_{-{\bbox{k}},0}+{\rm h.c . } ) \right\}. \label{hafm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this result shows that the eigenmodes are classified into three categories : the @xmath3 mode , the coupled @xmath467 modes , and the coupled @xmath468 modes .
below we analyze each of them .
the hamiltonian ( [ hafm ] ) shows that the @xmath3 mode is decoupled from other modes even in the presence of magnetic field .
this part of the hamiltonian can readily be diagonalized to give @xmath469 we note that the spectrum ( [ af0 ] ) becomes massive in the presence of magnetic field .
the @xmath470 and @xmath428 modes are coupled in the hamiltonian ( [ hafm ] ) , and the eigenenergies can be obtained by diagonalizing the following hamiltonian : @xmath471 where @xmath472 and @xmath473 the dispersion relation can be found by writing down the equations of motion for @xmath474 and @xmath475 and seeking for the solution of the form @xmath476 , with the result @xmath477 the excitation spectra ( [ spin-1 ] ) become massive in the presence of magnetic field .
the positivity of this energy is guaranteed by the conditions @xmath478 and @xmath309 which are required for the antiferromagnetic phase to be the lowest - lying mean field ( see condition ( [ condaf ] ) ) .
the @xmath424 and @xmath479 modes are coupled in the hamiltonian ( [ hafm ] ) , and the relevant part of the hamiltonian reads @xmath480 where @xmath481 by unitary transformations @xmath482 and @xmath483 , eq .
( [ h2af ] ) reduces to @xmath484 where @xmath485 , @xmath486 , and @xmath487 .
this hamiltonian can be diagonalized by writing down the heisenberg equations of motion for @xmath488 and @xmath489 as @xmath490 by assuming that @xmath491 , we obtain the following dispersion relations : @xmath492 ^ 2\left(1-\frac{\langle\hat{f}_z \rangle^2}{4}\right ) } \right ] .
\label{dis2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the positivity of this energy is met if the conditions @xmath493 and @xmath494 are satisfied .
the former condition is met whenever the antiferromagnetic phase is the lowest - energy state ( see ( [ condaf ] ) ) , while the latter condition is required for the antiferromagnetic phase to be mechanically stable , that is , the first term on the rhs of eq .
( [ hafm ] ) is positive .
we note that the dispersion relations ( [ dis2 ] ) are massless even in the presence of the magnetic field .
they are the goldstone modes associated with the u(1 ) gauge symmetry and the relative gauge symmetry ( the rotational symmetry about the direction of the applied magnetic field ) that are manifest in the mean - field solution discussed in sec .
[ sec : mfaf ] . at zero magnetic field ,
( [ af0 ] ) , ( [ spin-1 ] ) and ( [ dis2 ] ) reduces to @xmath495 , \\
( e^{\rm af}_{{\bbox{k}},\pm 1})^2&= & \epsilon_{\bbox{k}}\left[\epsilon_{\bbox{k}}+2(c_1-c_2/5)n\right ] , \\ ( e^{\rm af}_{{\bbox{k}},\pm2})^2&= & \cases { \epsilon_{\bbox{k}}\left[\epsilon_{\bbox{k}}+2(c_0+c_2/5)n\right ] , \cr \epsilon_{\bbox{k}}\left[\epsilon_{\bbox{k}}+8(c_1-c_2/20)n\right ] , \cr}\end{aligned}\ ] ] implying that all the five excitations are goldstone modes .
this reflects the fact that in the absence of the magnetic field the ground state is degenerate with respect to five continuous variables ( see eq . ( [ afspinor2 ] ) ) .
we consider the case of eq .
( [ cyclic_mfs ] ) , namely , @xmath496 where @xmath497 and @xmath498 . because @xmath89 and @xmath499 , the interaction hamiltonian ( [ spin2vv ] ) reduces to @xmath500 substituting eq .
( [ cyclic_mfs2 ] ) into this , performing unitary transformations @xmath501 , where @xmath502 and @xmath503 , and combining the result with eq .
( [ h00 ] ) , we obtain @xmath504 where @xmath505 , @xmath506 , @xmath507 , and @xmath508 it can be seen from the hamiltonian ( [ hcyclic ] ) that there are two separate sets of coupled modes , that is , the @xmath467 modes and the @xmath509 modes .
the equations of motion governing the @xmath467 coupled modes are given by @xmath510 where @xmath511 , @xmath512 , @xmath513 .
the eigenenergies of these modes are given by @xmath514 \right\}^\frac{1}{2}. \label{cyclic1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] these excitation energies are always positive semidefinite and massive in the presence of magnetic field .
we note that eq .
( [ cyclic1 ] ) has one gapless ( but not massless ) mode in the presence of external magnetic field .
taking the limit @xmath515 of eq .
( [ cyclic1 ] ) , we obtain @xmath516^\frac{1}{2 } \epsilon_{\bbox{k}}. \label{cyclic2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] however , both of these modes become massless in the absence of magnetic field . in fact , eq .
( [ cyclic1 ] ) then reduces to @xmath517 the equations of motion governing the @xmath518 coupled modes are given by @xmath519 where @xmath520 , @xmath521 , and @xmath522 .
substituting the expressions for @xmath523 and @xmath524 into those for @xmath525 and @xmath526 , we obtain the equations of motion for the latter set , which reduces to the cubic equation and therefore can be solved analytically .
the result is given by @xmath527\right\}^\frac{1}{2 } , \label{cyclicpm2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we recall that @xmath505 , @xmath506 , @xmath507 .
the second solutions in eq .
( [ cyclicpm2 ] ) are always positive semidefinite .
the positivity of the first solution is guaranteed by the condition @xmath308 .
we note that the first solution is massive and independent of the applied magnetic field and that the second solutions remain massless in the presence of external magnetic field .
the latter is a consequence of the fact that the mean - field solution is degenerate with respect to at least two continuous variables , as discussed in sec .
[ sec : cbec ] . in the absence of external magnetic field
, the results ( [ cyclicpm2 ] ) reduce to @xmath528 it can be shown from the general analytic solutions that these results are valid up to the first order in magnetization @xmath449 . while we have been unable to complete the analysis of the cyclic phase except for the case of eq .
( [ cyclic_mfs2 ] ) , we would like to point out that the excitation spectrum of the cyclic phase always includes the first solution in eq .
( [ cyclicpm2 ] ) , even when the mean - field solution is not given by eq .
( [ cyclic_mfs2 ] ) . this can be seen directly by writing down the equation of motion for @xmath529 and @xmath530 and the corresponding eigenvalue equation .
it can then be seen that @xmath531 is a solution to this equation .
in this paper we have studied quantum spin correlations and magnetic response of spin-2 bose - einstein condensates ( becs ) in a mesoscopic regime , and low - lying excitation spectra of each phase of spin-2 becs in the thermodynamic regime .
the ground states of spin-2 becs have three distinct phases : ferromagnetic ( fm ) , antiferromagnetic ( af ) and cyclic ( c ) phases .
the former two phases appear also in spin-1 becs , while the last phase is unique to spin-2 becs .
the building block of the af phase is spin - singlet pairs and that of the c phase is spin - singlet trios .
these many - body features usually elude mean - field treatments that are based on the order parameter derived from the single - particle density matrix .
bose symmetry restricts possible building blocks of spin-2 becs .
this can be summarized in terms of the annihilation operator @xmath297 of @xmath223-bosons having total spin @xmath1 .
the fundamental building block is not unique , but one minimal set is @xmath532 , @xmath256 , @xmath533 , @xmath258 , and @xmath534 .
bose statistics does not allow units such as @xmath535 and @xmath536 .
the unit @xmath534 is required to represent a state with odd values of the total spin .
we have investigated quantum spin correlations and magnetic response in the mesoscopic regime . under the assumption that the system is so tightly confined that the spatial degrees of freedom are frozen , we derived the exact many - body ground states which are expressed in terms of the minimal set of creation operators @xmath537 , @xmath538 , @xmath420 , @xmath539 , and @xmath427 .
these pairwise and trio - wise units help us understand the complicated response of the magnetization to the applied magnetic field , which stems from the fact that several values of the magnetization can not be constructed from such units and are hence forbidden .
in addition to the quantization of the magnetization to discrete values , several new features which elude mean - field treatments are found , such as a sudden jump from the minimum to the maximum magnetization , and robustness of the minimum - magnetization state against a small increase in the applied magnetic field until it starts to show a linear response .
the average zeeman level populations for the af - phase ground states were calculated , showing that @xmath403 populations , which stay zero in mft , vary sensitively to the applied magnetic field .
we have also examined low - lying excitation spectra using the bogoliubov approximation .
the excitation spectra of fm and af phases are similar to those of the spin-1 case @xcite . in the fm phase , the spectrum consists of one massless mode ( [ fbog ] ) reflecting the global gauge invariance and four single - particle modes ( [ fs1])-([fsm2 ] ) whose energy gaps are generated by the zeeman shifts as well as mean - field interactions . in the af phase ,
the spectrum includes two massless modes ( [ dis2 ] ) due to the global gauge invariance and the rotational symmetry about the spin quantization axis .
the remaining three are also bogoliubov modes , but they all become massive in the presence of magnetic field due to the zeeman shifts . in the c phase ,
the spectrum have at least two massless modes ( the second term in eq . ( [ cyclicpm2 ] ) ) by the same reasons as in the af phase .
the spectrum includes one peculiar single - particle mode ( the first term in eq .
( [ cyclicpm2 ] ) ) whose energy gap depends solely on the spin - dependent interactions and is insensitive to the applied magnetic field .
in addition , the spectrum has one gapless mode ( the second term in eq . ( [ cyclic2 ] ) )
whose mass depends only on magnetization @xmath449 and vanishes at zero magnetic field . the remaining mode ( the first term in eq .
( [ cyclic2 ] ) ) is a bogoliubov mode which becomes massive in the presence of the magnetic field . in the present paper
we have studied only static properties of spin-2 bec . with the very rich phenomena that we have found here
, we may very well expect that much more remains to be revealed in their dynamics .
this work was supported by a grant - in - aid for scientific research ( grant no . 11216204 ) by the ministry of education , science , sports , and culture of japan , and by the toray science foundation . m.u .
acknowledges the hospitality of the aspen center for physics , where part of this work was carried out .
the order parameter @xmath540 of a spin-2 bec has the same structure as that of the d - wave superconductor which was examined by mermin @xcite .
we here recapitulate as much of it as is relevant to the our theory .
the spin part of the order parameter , @xmath541 , of a spin-2 bec is described as a function of the azimuthal angle @xmath118 and the radial angle @xmath96 , and may be expanded in terms of the spherical harmonics of rank 2 @xmath542 as @xmath543 where @xmath73 obeys the normalization condition ( [ norm ] ) .
the angle dependence of @xmath544 may be expressed in terms of components of a three - dimensional unit vector : @xmath545 as follows @xmath546 substituting these into eq .
( [ chi1 ] ) , we obtain @xmath547 where @xmath548 the order parameter is thus characterized by a @xmath549 traceless matrix tr@xmath550 with unit normalization @xmath551 we may exploit the freedom of the gauge invariance to choose the overall phase so that the real part of tr@xmath552 vanishes .
@xmath553 let the real and imaginary parts of @xmath554 be @xmath555 and @xmath556 , respectively .
it follows from eqs .
( [ mm ] ) and ( [ re ] ) that @xmath557 because @xmath558 is traceless , so can be @xmath555 and @xmath559 traceless . @xmath555 and @xmath559 do not commute , so they can not be diagonalized simultaneously .
we follow mermin to take a representation in which @xmath555 is diagonal .
then the diagonal elements of @xmath555 become @xmath560 the matrix elements of @xmath556 are given by @xmath561 substituting eqs .
( [ xx ] ) and ( [ yy ] ) into @xmath562 and comparing it with eq .
( [ m ] ) , we obtain the following characterization of the order parameter . @xmath563
let us first write @xmath406 as @xmath564 with @xmath565 .
what we need is thus a general formula for calculating @xmath566 .
let us first consider the decomposition of @xmath567 into a sum of eigenstates for @xmath568 , such that @xmath569 where @xmath570 is an unnormalized simultaneous eigenstate of @xmath571 with eigenvalues @xmath572 and @xmath573/4 $ ] , respectively .
it follows from eqs .
( [ eigen_s ] ) and ( [ def_n2 ] ) that @xmath574 and @xmath575 . here
@xmath223 is the number of bosons in @xmath567 , and @xmath576 denotes the largest integer that is not larger than @xmath577 .
let us define @xmath578 and @xmath579 such that @xmath580 and @xmath581 where we have used eq .
( [ formula_s_plus ] ) and defined the coefficient @xmath582 as @xmath583 by definition , @xmath584 and @xmath585 . substituting eq .
( [ def_omega ] ) into eq .
( [ decomp_psi_s ] ) yields @xmath586 or equivalently , @xmath587 using this relation recursively , we can calculate @xmath579 as a function of @xmath588 . on the other hand , multiplying @xmath589 on both sides of eq .
( [ decomp_psi_s ] ) and taking norms , we obtain @xmath590 using this formula , we can evaluate eq .
( [ am_by_norms ] ) .
if we apply @xmath591 , @xmath592 , and @xmath593 to the relations ( [ def_omega ] ) , ( [ mu_by_omega ] ) , and ( [ norm_by_mu ] ) , and noting that @xmath409 , we have @xmath594 , @xmath595 , and @xmath596 for @xmath597 , we have @xmath598|\phi\rangle = ( -1)^m\hat{a}_{-m}|\phi\rangle $ ] and @xmath599 . using these when we apply @xmath600 , @xmath601 , and @xmath593 to the relations ( [ def_omega ] ) , ( [ mu_by_omega ] ) , and ( [ norm_by_mu ] ) , we have @xmath602 , @xmath603 , @xmath604 , and @xmath605 combining eqs .
( [ am_by_norms ] ) , ( [ norm_phi ] ) , and ( [ norm_phi_prime ] ) , we obtain @xmath606 where @xmath607 . substituting eq.([coeff_s_plus ] ) , we obtain eq .
( [ formula_zeeman1 ] ) .
\ii ) @xmath618 and @xmath609 .
we take @xmath619^\dagger|{\rm vac}\rangle$ ] and @xmath620 .
then , @xmath621 @xmath622
@xmath623 and @xmath613 for @xmath624 . putting these into the formula ( [ formula_zeeman1 ] ) , we obtain @xmath625 @xmath626 @xmath627 @xmath628 @xmath629 \iii ) @xmath608 and @xmath630 .
we take @xmath631^\dagger|{\rm vac}\rangle$ ] and @xmath632 .
then , @xmath633 @xmath634 @xmath635 @xmath636 and @xmath637 .
putting these into the formula ( [ formula_zeeman1 ] ) , we obtain @xmath638 @xmath639 @xmath640 @xmath641 @xmath642 \iv ) @xmath618 and @xmath630 .
we take @xmath643^\dagger|{\rm vac}\rangle$ ] and @xmath644 .
then , @xmath645 @xmath646 @xmath647 @xmath648 and @xmath637 . putting these into the formula ( [ formula_zeeman1 ] ) ,
we obtain @xmath649 @xmath650 @xmath651 @xmath652 @xmath653 | the ground states of bose - einstein condensates of spin-2 bosons are classified into three distinct ( ferromagnetic , `` antiferromagnetic `` , and cyclic ) phases depending on the s - wave scattering lengths of binary collisions for total - spin 0 , 2 , and 4 channels .
many - body spin correlations and magnetic response of the condensate in each of these phases are studied in a mesoscopic regime , while low - lying excitation spectra are investigated in the thermodynamic regime . in the mesoscopic regime , where the system is so tightly confined that the spatial degrees of freedom are frozen , the exact , many - body ground state for each phase is found to be expressed in terms of the creation operators of pair or trio bosons having spin correlations .
these pairwise and trio - wise units are shown to bring about some unique features of spin-2 becs such as a huge jump in magnetization from minimum to maximum possible values and the robustness of the minimum - magnetization state against an applied magnetic field . in the thermodynamic regime , where the system is spatially uniform ,
low - lying excitation spectra in the presence of magnetic field are obtained analytically using the bogoliubov approximation . in the ferromagnetic phase ,
the excitation spectrum consists of one goldstone mode and four single - particle modes . in the antiferromagnetic phase , where spin - singlet `` pairs '' undergo bose - einstein condensation , the spectrum consists of two goldstone modes and three massive ones , all of which become massless when magnetic field vanishes . in the cyclic phase , where boson `` trios " condense into a spin - singlet state , the spectrum is characterized by two goldstone modes , one single - particle mode having a magnetic - field - independent energy gap , and a gapless single - particle mode that becomes massless in the absence of magnetic field .
= -0.8truecm |
hydromagnetic dynamos can be understood as magnetic instabilities driven by a special flow pattern in fluid conductors .
there are , however , strong restrictions on the characteristics of such flows ( see dudley & james 1989 ) as well as on the geometry of the resulting magnetic fields @xcite . the restrictions even exclude any dynamo activity for a number of flows .
we mention as an example that differential rotation alone can never maintain a dynamo ( elsasser 1946 ) .
an open question is whether magnetic instabilities are able to excite a sufficiently complicated motion that together with a ( given ) background flow can generate magnetic fields .
@xcite suggested that nonuniformly rotating disks can produce a dynamo when magnetorotational ( mri ) and magnetic buoyancy instabilities are active .
later on , numerical simulations of @xcite and @xcite have shown that mri alone may be sufficient for the accretion disk dynamo .
it remains , however , to check ( at least for the case of low magnetic prandtl number ) whether the mri - dynamo has physical or numerical origin @xcite .
another possibility was discussed by @xcite who suggested that differential rotation and magnetic kink - type instability @xcite can jointly drive a dynamo in stellar radiation zones .
the dynamo if real would be very important for the angular momentum transport in stars and their secular evolution .
it taps energy from differential rotation thus reducing the rotational shear .
radial displacements converting toroidal magnetic field into poloidal field are necessary for the dynamo .
the dynamo , therefore , unavoidably mixes chemical species in stellar interiors that may have observable consequences for stellar evolution .
such a dynamo , however , has not yet been demonstrated to exist .
the doubts especially concern the kink - type instability that in contrast to mri exists also without differential rotation .
the tayler instability develops in expense of magnetic energy .
estimations of dynamo parameters are thus necessary to assess the dynamo - effectiveness of this magnetic instability .
the basic role in turbulent dynamos plays the ability of correlated magnetic ( @xmath3 ) fluctuations and velocity ( @xmath4 ) fluctuations to produce a mean electromotive force along the background magnetic field @xmath5 and also along the electric current @xmath6 , i.e. @xmath7 we estimate the @xmath0 effect by tayler instability in the present paper .
we do also find indications for the appearance of the turbulent diffusivity @xmath8 in the calculations but we do not follow them here in detail . for purely toroidal fields we did _ not _ find indication for the existence of the term @xmath9 which can appear in the expression ( [ 1 ] ) in form of a rotationally induced anisotropy of the diffusivity tensor .
the fluctuating fields for the most rapidly growing eigenmodes and the azimuthal averaging are applied in the lhs of eq.([1 ] ) to estimate the @xmath0 effect and its relation to the kinetic and magnetic helicity @xmath10 and @xmath11 .
our linear stability computations do not allow the evaluation of the @xmath0 effect amplitude but its latitudinal profile and its ratio to the product of rms values of @xmath12 and @xmath13 ( i.e. the correlation coefficient ) can be found . as the differential rotation is necessary for dynamo
, we estimate also the influence of differential rotation on tayler instability .
next , a dynamo model with the parameters estimated for the magnetic instability is designed to find the global modes of the instability - driven dynamo .
the model and the stability analysis of this paper are very close to that of @xcite and will be discussed here only briefly . the basic component of the magnetic field inside a star is normally assumed to be the toroidal one
. this toroidal field can be produced by differential rotation from even a small poloidal field .
the background toroidal field of our model consists of two latitudinal belts of opposite polarities , i.e. @xmath14 ( see spruit 1999 ) with @xmath15 as the alfvn frequency of the toroidal field .
spherical coordinates are used with the axis of rotation as the polar axis and @xmath16 as the azimuthal unit vector .
the latitudinal profile of ( [ 2 ] ) peaks in mid - latitudes at @xmath17 and @xmath18 .
the background flow is simply @xmath19 with @xmath20 as the equatorial rotation rate .
the @xmath15 and @xmath20 are radius - dependent but this dependence is not of basic importance for the stability analysis .
the reason is that the stratification of the radiative core is stable with positive @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the entropy and @xmath23 is the specific heat at constant pressure .
the buoyancy frequency @xmath24 is large compared to @xmath20 ( @xmath25 in the upper radiative core of the sun ) .
then the radial scale of unstable disturbances is short and the dependence of the disturbances on radius can be treated in a local approximation , i.e. in the form of @xmath26 .
the parameter controlling the stratification influence on the instability is @xmath27 and the most unstable disturbances have @xmath28 @xcite .
this means that the radial scale of the disturbances , @xmath29 , is short compared to the radial scale @xmath30 of toroidal field or angular velocity variations . in the solar tachocline where @xmath20 strongly varies in radius ,
the scale ratio is smaller than unity , @xmath31 @xcite .
for such small scale ratio the radial derivatives in the linear stability equations are absorbed by the disturbances so that the local approximation in the radial coordinate can be applied .
note that the unstable modes remain global in horizontal dimensions . in the radiation zones of the sun ( _ left _ ) and of a 100 myr old @xmath32 star rotating with 10 days period ( _ right _ ) .
the model of the massive star is computed with the ez code of @xcite for @xmath33 . , title="fig:",width=154,height=170 ] in the radiation zones of the sun ( _ left _ ) and of a 100 myr old @xmath32 star rotating with 10 days period ( _ right _ ) .
the model of the massive star is computed with the ez code of @xcite for @xmath33 .
, title="fig:",width=154,height=170 ] the equation system of the linear stability analysis include @xmath34 as the momentum equation for the velocity fluctuations and the equations @xmath35 for the induction of the magnetic fluctuations and for the disturbances ( @xmath36 ) of the entropy @xmath37 the equations ( [ 6])([8 ] ) were reformulated in terms of scalar potentials for toroidal and poloidal parts of the magnetic and velocity fields to reduce the number of equations , i.e. @xmath38 ( chandrasekhar 1961 ) .
the resulting system of five eigenvalue equations can be found elsewhere @xcite and it will here only be extended to the application of helical background fields .
again the eigenvalue problem is solved numerically .
the equations include finite diffusion in opposition to the otherwise similar equations of cally ( 2003 ) .
the thermal diffusion is especially important because of its destabilizing effect .
the tayler instability requires radial displacements . it does not exist in 2d case of strictly horizontal motion .
the radial displacements in radiation zones are opposed by buoyancy .
the thermal diffusion smooths out the entropy disturbances to reduce the effect of stable stratification .
this largely increases the growth rates for the instability of not too strong , @xmath39 , fields @xcite .
the diffusivities enter the normalized equation via parameters @xmath40 in our computations we used the values @xmath41 , @xmath42 , and @xmath43 characteristic for the upper part of the solar radiation zone .
as it must be the magnetic prandtl number ( @xmath44 ) exceeds the ordinary prandtl number ( @xmath45 ) .
the stability problem allows two types of equatorial symmetry of unstable eigenmodes .
we use the notations sm ( symmetric mode with azimuthal wave number @xmath46 ) and a@xmath46 ( antisymmetric mode ) for these types of symmetry .
s@xmath46 modes have vector field @xmath13 which is mirror - symmetric about equatorial plane ( symmetric @xmath47 and antisymmetric @xmath48 ) and mirror - antisymmetric flow @xmath12 ( symmetric @xmath49 and antisymmetric @xmath50 ) .
am modes have antisymmetric @xmath13 and symmetric @xmath12 .
instability can only be found for nonaxisymmetric disturbances with @xmath51 in agreement with the stability criteria of @xcite when applied to the toroidal field model of eq .
( [ 2 ] ) . of s modes as function of the amplitude of the toroidal background field .
rigid rotation , @xmath51 .
note the slowness of the modes for weak fields with @xmath52 and the jump at @xmath53 .
the wave numbers are always optimized with respect to the maximum growth rates .
@xmath54 , @xmath55.,width=264,height=264 ] the perturbations are considered as fourier modes in time , in azimuth and radius in the form @xmath56 . only the highest - order terms in @xmath57
are used so that in radial direction the theory is a local one ( short - wave approximation ) .
the wave number @xmath58 enters the equations in the normalized form @xmath59 as a ratio of two large numbers .
if only toroidal fields are considered with @xmath60 kitchatinov & rdiger ( 2008 ) found maximal growth rates of order 10@xmath61 ( normalized with the rotation rate ) at radial scales of @xmath62 for s1 modes .
as described in kr08 , the eigenvalue @xmath63 possesses a positive imaginary part for an instability ( the growth rate is @xmath64 ) .
the equations have only be solved for the nonaxisymmetric ( ` kink ' ) modes with @xmath51 .
one can easily show that the equation system possesses a symmetry with respect to the change of sign of the azimuthal wave number @xmath46 .
the equations are invariant under the transformation @xmath65 where the asterisks mean the complex conjugate .
if an eigenmode exists for @xmath66 with a certain growth rate @xmath67 then the same @xmath67 holds for the eigenmode with @xmath68 .
we shall demonstrate the importance of this finding for the generation of helicity and @xmath0 effect .
figure [ f1 ] shows the growth rates for s@xmath69 modes in dependence of field strength .
the results for a@xmath69 modes are very similar . for weak fields , @xmath70 the growth rates are closely reproduced by the parabolic law @xmath71 . for strong fields , @xmath72 , they are proportional to the field strength , @xmath73 and do not depend on the rotation rate . all averaging procedures in the present paper
are realized by integration over the azimuth coordinate .
consider the formation of the kinetic helicity ^kin = u , [ hkin ] ( only the real parts of both factors ) whose definition depends on the handedness of the used coordinate system .
we shall prefer the righthand system .
let the expressions w=
( w_r + i w_i)e^i , v= ( v_r + i v_i)e^i , [ wv ] represent the potential functions @xmath74 and @xmath75
. then the real part of ( [ hkin ] ) after the integration over the azimuth results to @xmath76 .
\label{hkin1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is easy to show with the transformation rules ( [ trans ] ) that this expression for the modes with negative @xmath46 has the opposite sign as for the modes with positive @xmath46 .
hence , ^kin(m=-1 ) = - ^kin(m=1 ) [ hkin2 ] ( see fig .
[ f10 ] , bottom ) .
it means that for every unstable mode with finite helicity there is another unstable mode with the same growth and drift rates but with opposite helicity so that the resulting net helicity should vanish .
obviously , if all modes are excited the instability of a purely toroidal axisymmetric field can not produce finite values of the kinetic helicity .
the same argument leads to the same conclusion for the current helicity ^curr = b. [ hcurr ] there is also a more straightforward argument with the same result .
the mode @xmath68 is identical to the mode @xmath66 but considered in a lefthand coordinate system .
the sign of the helicity is equal in both lefthand systems and righthand systems .
hence , the mode @xmath68 which gives the same helicity in the lefthand system as the mode @xmath66 in the righthand system yields a negative helicity in the righthand system if the mode @xmath66 yields a positive helicity in the righthand system . the net helicity in both the righthand system and the lefthand system , therefore , vanishes
. again the same is true for the current helicity ( [ hcurr ] ) .
we find ( see , however , cally 2003 ) that from symmetry reasons unstable purely toroidal fields do not produce a net helicity
. an additional poloidal component of the background field , however , breaks the symmetry as then , for example , the two modes possess two different growth rates so that a certain sign of helicity will be preferred ( gellert , rdiger & hollerbach 2011 ) . in the short - wave approximation
only the radial component of the poloidal field is important .
we write @xmath77 with @xmath78 . using the notation by kr08 with the operator
@xmath79 the equation for the azimuthal flow reads @xmath80 the equation includes the poloidal background field via its last line .
the parameter measuring the effect of the poloidal field is @xmath81 equation ( [ om_p ] ) shows that the characteristic strength of the field that can influence the tayler instability ( @xmath82 ) is @xmath83 times the toroidal field amplitude .
this factor is of the order @xmath84 . for the latitudinal profile of the radial field component the simplest choice , i.e. @xmath85 , is used .
hence , both the background field components @xmath86 and @xmath87 are antisymmetric with respect to the equator .
the large - scale current helicity @xmath88 , therefore , is also antisymmetric with respect to the equator . for positive amplitudes @xmath89 and @xmath90 it is _ positive _ at the northern hemisphere and negative at the southern hemisphere ( it runs with @xmath91 ) .
we shall see that the pseudoscalar @xmath88 alone determines the behavior of the pseudoscalars @xmath92 and also of @xmath93 .
the basic rotation which via @xmath94 can also form a pseudoscalar does not play here an important role .
the ratio @xmath95 of the toroidal field amplitude and the radial field amplitude is @xmath96 the equation for the meridional flow is @xmath97 the equations for the magnetic fields components are @xmath98 and @xmath99 the entropy equation is not influenced by the poloidal field .
we computed the helicity @xmath92 of the critical modes always for the amplitude @xmath100 and @xmath101 with and without basic rotation .
the results are given in fig .
[ fff ] .
the solid ( dashed ) lines give the helicity profiles for @xmath66 ( @xmath68 ) .
indeed , the helicity of the single modes is antisymmetric with respect to the equator ( as also the current helicity of the background field ) .
the plot at the bottom of fig .
[ fff ] for the two modes s1 is for @xmath102 .
note the extremely small differences to the top plot for the same modes under the influence of rotation .
it is obviously the pseudoscalar @xmath88 directing the formation of the helicities rather than the pseudoscalar @xmath94 formed by the global rotation .
figure [ gr1 ] shows the normalized growth rates @xmath103 vs the normalized wave length @xmath104 for three different poloidal field amplitudes . from top to bottom : @xmath105 , @xmath106 , @xmath107 .
the peaks for the modes with @xmath68 drift from @xmath108 to @xmath109 .
the corresponding peak values of the growth rates dramatically grow from @xmath110 to @xmath111 demonstrating the strong stabilization of the tayler instability for helical fields .
an increase of the poloidal field amplitude by a factor of 6 ( from bottom to top ) leads to a reduction of the growth rate by three orders of magnitude . the main information of fig . [ gr1 ]
is that the growth rates of the modes with @xmath66 and @xmath68 strongly differ .
obviously , they always produce helicity of opposite signs and with different growth rates .
the growth rate for the s1 mode with @xmath68 exceeds the growth rate of @xmath66 by a factor of four .
it is , however , much smaller than the rotation rate .
the unstable tayler modes are thus very slow , their corresponding growth times are much longer than the rotation periods .
the helicity by the @xmath68 mode is _ negative _ at the north pole opposite to the current helicity of the background field .
the small - scale kinetic helicity and the large - scale current helicity are anticorrelated ( cf .
gellert , rdiger & hollerbach 2011 , for a similar result in cylinder symmetry ) .
linear stability computations do not provide the absolute value of @xmath0 . only its latitudinal profile and its relative magnitude can be evaluated .
we computed the normalized electromotive force @xmath112 which in opposition to the helicity ( fig .
[ fff ] ) is symmetric with respect to the equator .
@xmath113 is the rms velocity fluctuation after horizontal averaging ( longitude and latitude ) , @xmath114 is the rms magnetic fluctuation .
the factor @xmath115 is introduced because the horizontal ( velocity and magnetic ) fluctuations are larger than the radial fluctuations by just this factor . with these normalizations the expression ( [ 10a ] )
is of order unity independent of the actual value of @xmath116 .
( bottom ) but for the normalized electromotive force after eq .
( [ 10a ] ) for the modes with @xmath66 ( solid ) and @xmath68 ( dashed ) .
, width=302,height=264 ] figure [ f9 ] gives the main results for purely toroidal fields with ( [ 2 ] ) .
the azimuthal component of the electromotive force i ) vanishes at the equator , ii ) the profile is symmetric with respect to the equator and iii ) it is highly concentrated to the poles .
the first finding is naturally for the @xmath0 effect but it is _ not _ for the term @xmath9 which could appear in the expression of the turbulence - induced electromotive force as a consequence of a rotationally induced anisotropy of the diffusivity tensor .
we find , therefore , this effect not existing due to the tayler instability of toroidal fields . for more complex field pattern
its existence of can not be excluded but it remained small in any case . for purely toroidal fields even the @xmath0 effect does not exist as the modes with opposite sign of @xmath46 ( which have the same growth rates ) do cancel each other not only with respect to their helicities but also with respect to the resulting emf . in the nonlinear regime
a spontaneous parity breaking may happen as it has been described by chatterjee et al .
( 2010 ) and by gellert et al .
( 2011 ) . in this case
, however , it might be impossible to predict the sign and the amplitude of the @xmath0 effect .
the concentration of helicity and emf towards the poles reflects a basic property of the tayler instability , i.e. that the instability pattern is more present in polar regions rather than in equatorial regions ( spruit 1999 ; cally 2003 ) .
figure [ gr1 ] shows the normalized growth rates @xmath118 as a function of the radial scale @xmath119 under the influence of poloidal field components .
the plots shows drastic differences of the growth rates between the modes of @xmath66 ( dotted lines ) and @xmath68 ( solid lines ) .
e.g. , for @xmath106 both modes with @xmath68 possess the maximum growth rates @xmath118 with @xmath120 at a wavelength of @xmath121 .
the figure shows a very strong influence of the poloidal field amplitude on the growth rates .
the growth rates are small for strong poloidal field but they are large for weak poloidal field .
we are thus confronted with the dilemma that only background fields with finite current helicity originate fluctuations with @xmath0 effect but the corresponding poloidal field components suppress the tayler instability ( see rdiger , schultz & elstner 2011 ) .
for the further discussion the quantity @xmath122 is introduced which is antisymmetric with respect to the equator as expected for the ( normalized ) @xmath0 effect .
the @xmath123 in the denominator eliminates the latitudinal profile of the toroidal field and @xmath124 is its amplitude ( see eq .
( [ 2 ] ) ) .
also the resulting @xmath125-profiles are highly concentrated to the poles ( fig .
the plots show the profiles for the weak - field cases @xmath126 with @xmath105 , @xmath127 and @xmath128 .
the modes with the fastest growth produce an @xmath0 effect which is always positive ( negative ) for positive ( negative ) current helicity at the northern ( southern ) hemisphere of the background field .
the result is an @xmath0 effect anticorrelated with the small - scale helicity and positively correlated with the large - scale pseudoscalar @xmath88 .
exactly the same relations have been derived by nonlinear simulations of the kink - type instability for an incompressible fluid in a cylindric setup by gellert et al .
we are thus encouraged to favor the results for the modes with the highest growth rates . for very weak poloidal field ( @xmath129 , not shown )
the @xmath0 effect is already so small ( and its sign fluctuates ) that the @xmath130 seems to form the lower limit of the helicity production by poloidal fields . in the weak - field regime ( @xmath131 )
the instability excites stronger magnetic fluctuations rather than flow fluctuations .
the ratio of fluctuating alfvn velocity @xmath132 to @xmath113 results as @xmath133 for @xmath134 and @xmath135 for @xmath136 .
hence , we find @xmath137 for weak fields . for strong fields ( @xmath138 ) the fluctuations become close to equipartition , i.e. @xmath139 .
on the basis of the obtained informations about the @xmath0 effect ( amplitude and latitudinal profile ) we have to probe the possible existence of a dynamo mechanism . we start to estimate the typical velocity perturbation and the eddy magnetic - diffusivity .
we write @xmath140 and use the growth time @xmath141 as the timescale @xmath142 .
hence , @xmath143 the first step holds for purely toroidal fields ( @xmath144 ) . from fig .
[ f10 ] ( top ) one finds @xmath145 so that with solar values @xmath146 mm / s results .
the estimate @xmath147 leads to @xmath148 @xmath149/s as the order of magnitude of the eddy diffusivity .
the value increases for fast rotating giants by one or two orders of magnitudes .
it perfectly fits the diffusion coefficients for chemicals which are needed to explain the weak lithium depletion of solar type stars ( barnes , charbonneau & macgregor 1999 ) . the same estimate @xmath150 yields @xmath151 the three examples for helical background fields given in fig .
[ gr1 ] lead to a common value of @xmath152 .
hence , @xmath153 @xmath149/s results for the upper radiation zone of the sun .
this value is very close to the above estimation for purely toroidal fields .
it is increased by more than three orders of magnitudes if more massive stars are considered .
figure [ f5 ] shows the details of a model with a mass of @xmath32 and 10 days rotation period .
the @xmath0 effect enters the dynamo theory via the dimensionless dynamo number @xmath154 equation ( [ 10 ] ) together with the heuristic relation @xmath155 directly provides @xmath156 hence , the product @xmath157 determines the effectivity of the @xmath0 effect . with
@xmath158 a value of @xmath159 results for the solar model .
note that the buoyancy frequency linearly enters the equation . also for the @xmath32 star of fig .
[ f5 ] the @xmath160 remains small .
the operation of a ( stationary ) @xmath1 dynamo is thus excluded for radiation stellar zones .
the existence of an ( oscillating ) @xmath2 dynamo , however , remains possible .
all @xmath2 dynamos can work with very small @xmath0 effect if only @xmath161 @xmath162 is high enough and this is always possible for sufficiently small eddy diffusivity @xmath8 .
the only consequences of very small @xmath0 effect are i ) that the ratio of toroidal and poloidal magnetic field components becomes very large and ii ) also the growth time of the dynamo instability becomes large .
the growth time of the weakly supercritical @xmath2 dynamo for @xmath148@xmath149/s is extremely long ( order of gyrs for the sun ) . with ( say ) 3% differential rotation this value of
the eddy diffusivity leads for the sun to @xmath161 of order 10@xmath163 .
there is another possibility to proceed . for
all @xmath2 dynamos the ratio @xmath95 of the toroidal and the radial field amplitudes is @xmath164 the scaling parameter @xmath165 is about 0.05 ( see table [ tab ] ) .
hence , @xmath166 .
the excitation condition for such dynamos can be written as @xmath167 where @xmath168 runs inversely with the shear . with ( [ beta ] )
@xmath169 results as excitation condition .
one finds @xmath170 for fixed shear .
note that the condition ( [ aa ] ) does no longer contain the stellar parameters like @xmath171 and/or the radius .
the following findings are thus valid for all stellar radiation zones . our first example is formed by @xmath172 and @xmath173 .
the condition ( [ aa ] ) then reads @xmath174 . as we shall see below
, a typical value for the dynamo number is @xmath175 so that for dynamo excitation @xmath176 this relation must be read as an equation for the supercritical value of @xmath177 .
the excitation is thus formally more easy for smaller poloidal field .
after the numerical results in the figs .
[ gr1 ] ( top ) and [ f2 ] ( top ) one finds @xmath178 for @xmath173 which is by far too small .
for @xmath179 it is @xmath180 which is also not supercritical .
the comparison of the figs .
[ gr1 ] and [ f2 ] demonstrates that for large poloidal fields the @xmath125 grows but in the same time the growth rate drastically sinks which indicates the stabilizing action of the poloidal fields .
an @xmath2 dynamo in radiation zones can not work , therefore , with too strong poloidal fields .
note that with @xmath181 for @xmath182 the condition ( [ cond ] ) can be fulfilled due to the increase of the growth rate . for smaller @xmath177 the ability of the poloidal field to create a coherent @xmath0 effect sinks . for @xmath183
the function @xmath125 has already two signs at either hemisphere .
however , as the condition ( [ cond ] ) can be fulfilled the existence of an @xmath2 dynamo can not be excluded by the numerical results .
we must thus solve the dynamo equations in order to probe the existence of such dynamos which work with very small values of the @xmath0 effect . the @xmath0 effect plotted in fig .
[ f2 ] shows another complicating characteristics , i.e. its concentration at the poles . in the next section
nonlinear @xmath2 dynamo models are thus constructed with a weak solar - type latitudinal differential rotation and an @xmath0 effect which is concentrated at the poles .
it is known from the theory of @xmath2 dynamos operating with @xmath184 profiles of the @xmath0 effect that they produce too polar butterfly diagrams .
we must thus expect that the existence of @xmath2 dynamos to produce mid - latitude belts like in eq .
( [ 2 ] ) with pole - concentrated @xmath0 effect is unlikely .
the influence of the polar concentration of magnetic - induced @xmath0 effect on a possible @xmath2 dynamo can easily be probed .
the stability of an axisymmetric toroidal background field has been considered so that only the numerical values of an axisymmetric @xmath0 are known .
this scenario is only consistent if the possible @xmath2 dynamo produces axisymmetric toroidal field belts at the latitude of the original background field .
we know that this is true for an @xmath0 effect ( plus solar - type differential rotation ) with the standard @xmath185-profile .
we have to check , therefore , whether this result remains true for the @xmath0 effect concentrated close to the poles . to this end
a simple model is constructed . in a spherical shell between the normalized radii 0.6 and 1 the rotation frequency
is @xmath186 .
the small value of the relative shear allows to consider the fluid as hydrodynamically stable ( see watson 1981 ) .
possible production of hydrodynamic - induced @xmath0 effect in radiative zones such as that by dikpati & gilman ( 2001 ) is therefore excluded .
the shear peaks at 45@xmath187 which is the same latitude as that of the peak of the toroidal field . to model the polar concentration of the magnetic - induced @xmath0 effect the expression @xmath188 is used with the free parameter @xmath189 fixing the latitudinal profile of the @xmath0 effect . the polar concentration presented in fig .
[ f2 ] leads to rather high values of @xmath189 .
a perfect - conductor boundary condition is used at the inner radius .
the outer computing domain is extended to the radius 1.2 . outside the stellar surface
the diffusivity is increased by a factor of 10 . for the outermost boundary
a pseudovacuum condition is used .
the method of a global quenching of the @xmath0 effect is used in order to find the characteristic eigenvalue of marginal dynamo instability ( elstner , meinel & rdiger 1989 ) .
table [ tab ] presents the numerical results for a reference dynamo model with 3% differential rotation and for @xmath190 .
only the numbers are given for marginal dynamo instability .
if the real @xmath191 differs from the reference @xmath191 by a factor @xmath192 then the resulting @xmath95 also differs by the factor @xmath67 , so that @xmath193 this condition is automatically fulfilled for all dynamo models which fulfill the excitation condition ( [ aa ] ) independent on the particular stellar model .
all the dynamos listed in table [ tab ] provide positive ( negative ) values of the large - scale current helicity @xmath88 at the northern ( southern ) hemisphere . as we have assumed the same constellation for the above background field producing the @xmath0 effect
the theory is thus consistent under this aspect .
we have also to probe whether the star rotates fast enough to produce sufficiently large @xmath161 for the required dynamo numbers of the reference values of table [ tab ] .
it is @xmath194 note at first that the excitation is much more easy for massive stars as their @xmath116 is smaller ( fig .
[ f5 ] ) . inserting the characteristic numbers of our models the result is @xmath195 which is fulfilled by both the considered stellar models by their estimated values @xmath196 .
either the sun as the considered hot stars with rotation periods of a couple of days rotate fast enough the excite an @xmath2 dynamo with a very weak shear ( 3% ) . to discuss the influence of the quantity @xmath189 we present models with @xmath197 and @xmath198 .
the latter value describes the strongest concentration of the @xmath0 effect to the poles . for @xmath199 ( i.e. @xmath200 ) the dynamo - generated toroidal field peaks
exactly at @xmath17 so that the presented stability analysis which bases on a toroidal field which also peaks at @xmath17 ( see eq . ( [ 2 ] ) ) would be consistent .
this case together with the excitation condition ( [ cond ] ) which is fulfilled by the magnetic amplitudes @xmath201 and @xmath128 would strongly suggest the existence of an @xmath2 dynamo in magnetized radiation zones of hot stars .
however , the models listed in table [ tab ] provide the result that the induced toroidal field belts become more and more concentrated to the poles for increasing @xmath189 .
this behavior is insofar not trivial as the generation of the toroidal field by the differential rotation does _ not _ depend on @xmath189 .
such polar belts resulting for @xmath202 can never reproduce the mid - latitudinal belts of eq .
( [ 2 ] ) on which the @xmath0 effect bases .
the first example of fig .
[ f6 ] ( top ) is the standard @xmath2 dynamo with the latitudinal profile @xmath200 .
it produces axisymmetric toroidal magnetic belts of dipolar symmetry at the same latitude where the shear @xmath203 has a maximum . for growing @xmath189 the belt position drifts more and more polewards ( the field position becomes @xmath204 ) .
it is thus _ not possible _ to maintain toroidal field belts in mid - latitudes if the @xmath0 effect mainly exists in the polar region ( @xmath205 ) .
ccccccc @xmath189 & @xmath168 & @xmath191 & @xmath95 & @xmath165 & @xmath206 & @xmath207 + + 1 & 118,000 & 0.46 & 56 & 0.07 & 26 & 45@xmath208 + 5 & 347,000 & 1.35&23 & 0.05 & 31 & 38@xmath187 + 15 & 976,000 & 3.8 & 6.3 & 0.02 & 24&23@xmath187 +
it is demonstrated with a linear theory that the tayler instability of a toroidal magnetic field in a density - stratified radiation zone of hot stars does not produce helicity and/or @xmath0 effect .
if , however , a weak poloidal field component is added forming a large - scale current helicity @xmath209 then the instability leads to small - scale helicity , current helicity and also to @xmath0 effect .
if @xmath209 is _ positive _ in the northern hemisphere then the helicity @xmath210 is _ negative _ at the northern hemisphere if only the modes are considered which grow fastest .
hence , the small - scale kinetic helicity and the large - scale current helicity of the background field are anticorrelated .
as it is often the case , the corresponding @xmath0 effect is anticorrelated with the kinetic helicity and , therefore , positively correlated with the large - scale current helicity @xmath209 .
the calculations lead to two basic properties of this @xmath0 effect . it is i ) small
, i.e. the normalized value @xmath191 is only of order @xmath84 and ii ) concentrated at the poles .
the first property excludes the existence of @xmath1 dynamos in radiative zones and the second property makes the existence of @xmath2 dynamos ( with weak differential rotation in mid - latitudes ) unlikely . as we have shown only a dynamo with @xmath200 produces the toroidal fields in mid - latitudes . for @xmath202 , however , the belts are more and more shifted into the polar region .
such fields can not close the loop of field amplification by reproducing the original axisymmetric toroidal field . or
, with other words , the rotation law with the considered profile ( @xmath211 ) mainly induces toroidal fields at mid - latitudes where for high values of @xmath189 almost no @xmath0 effect exists .
hence , an @xmath2 dynamo could only work for very fast rotation . by very fast rotation
the instability is suppressed ( see fig .
this topological problem seems to be the key problem with the magnetic - driven dynamo rather than the excitation conditions for @xmath2 dynamos .
it is , however , not yet clear whether this argumentation also holds with the same power with other than the used rotation laws and/or in fully nonlinear simulations .
all the presented @xmath2 dynamo models working with a weak solar - type differential rotation are reproducing the assumed sign of the large - scale current helicity @xmath88 .
if thus the dynamo produces its own @xmath0 effect by the magnetic instability then the signs will be consistent .
a basic deficit of the presented theory is the fact that both helicity and @xmath0 effect have been computed in rigidly rotating stars while for an @xmath2 dynamo the rotation must be nonrigid
. it might be the case that growth rates and magnetic patterns of the tayler instability are strongly modified by even weak differential rotation .
the discussion of this new subject , however , is not the scope of the present paper .
we have thus considered only cases with a rather weak differential rotation ( 3 % ) .
another deficit is formed by the order - of - magnitude estimation of the eddy diffusivity . using the characteristic scales of the modes with the highest growth rates the typical velocity is of order 1 mm / s and the typical diffusivity value is about @xmath212 @xmath149/s ( both for solar values ) .
estimations of the radial mixing produced by the same instability provide an important test of the theory .
the observed content of light elements at the sun impose restrictions on radial mixing in the upper radiative core ( barnes et al .
1999 , and references therein ) .
the chemical mixing in the deep stellar interior can also be compatible with observations only if its characteristic time is longer than the evolutionary time scale @xcite .
only very slightly supercritical kink - type instability can satisfy this restriction @xcite .
all the material values in the paper are solar values .
the formulation of the dynamo theory is such that the material parameters of the stellar interior do not appear ( see eq .
( [ aa ] ) ) .
the conclusions about the dynamo activity for hot stars do thus not depend on the mass of the star .
this is not true , however , for the above mentioned order - of - magnitude estimations of the characteristic values of velocity and diffusivity which are running with @xmath171 and @xmath213 , resp . from fig .
[ f5 ] one finds that the given solar values increase by factors of 30 or 900 , resp .
, for stars with three solar masses .
only nonlinear simulations can demonstrate whether the system indeed prefers the modes with the highest growth rates . only if not then the radiative - zone dynamo has a chance to work in the solar interior but if it works then it should be only marginally supercritical .
llk is grateful to the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft for the support of the project ( 436 rus 113/839 ) .
99 barnes g. , charbonneau p. , macgregor k.b .
, 1999 , apj , 511 , 466 brandenburg a. , nordlund . ,
stein r.f . , torkelsson u. , 1995 , apj , 446 , 746 cally p.s . , 2003 , mnras , 339 , 957 chandrasekhar s. , 1961 , hydrodynamic and hydromagnetic stability .
clarendon press , oxford chatterjee , p. , mitra , d. , brandenburg a. , rheinhardt , m. , 2010 , pre , ( in press ) cowling t.g .
, 1933 , mnras , 94 , 39 dikpati m. , gilman , p.a . , 2001 , apj , 559 , 428 dudley m.l . , james , r.w . , 1989 ,
royal soc .
london a , 425 , 407 elsasser w.m .
, 1946 , phys .
, 69 , 106 elstner d. , meinel r. , rdiger g. , 1989 , geophys .
fluid dyn . , 50 , 85 fromang s. , papaloizou j. , 2007 , a&a , 476 , 1113 fromang s. , papaloizou j. , lesur g. , heinemann t. , 2007 , a&a , 476 , 1123 gellert m. , rdiger g. , hollerbach r. , 2011 , mnras , 414 , 2696 goossens m. , biront d. , tayler r.j . , 1981 ,
ap&ss , 75 , 521 hawley j.f . , gammie c.f . , balbus s.a . , 1996 ,
apj , 464 , 690 .
kippenhahn r. , weigert a. , 1994 , stellar structure and evolution .
springer , berlin kitchatinov l.l .
, rdiger g. , 2008 , a&a , 478 , 1 ( kr08 ) kitchatinov l.l . , rdiger g. , 2009 , a&a , 504 , 303 paxton b. , 2004 , pasp , 116 , 699 pitts e. , tayler r.j . , 1985 , mnras , 216 , 139 rdiger g. , kitchatinov l.l . , 2010 , geophys .
fluid dyn . , 104 , 273 rdiger g. , gellert m. , schultz m. , hollerbach r. , 2010 , phys .
e , 82 , 016319 rdiger g. , schultz m. , elstner d. , 2011 , a&a , 530 , 55 spruit h.c . , 1999 , a&a , 349 , 189 spruit h.c . , 2002 , a&a , 381 , 923 tayler r.j .
, 1973 , mnras , 161 , 365 tout c.a . , pringle j.e . , 1992 , mnras , 259 , 604 watson m. , 1981 , geophys .
fluid dyn . , 16 , 285 | helicity and @xmath0 effect driven by the nonaxisymmetric tayler instability of toroidal magnetic fields in stellar radiation zones are computed . in the linear approximation
a purely toroidal field always excites pairs of modes with identical growth rates but with opposite helicity so that the net helicity vanishes .
if the magnetic background field has a helical structure by an extra ( weak ) poloidal component then one of the modes dominates producing a net kinetic helicity anticorrelated to the current helicity of the background field .
+ the mean electromotive force is computed with the result that the @xmath0 effect by the most rapidly growing mode has the same sign as the current helicity of the background field .
the @xmath0 effect is found as too small to drive an @xmath1 dynamo but the excitation conditions for an @xmath2 dynamo can be fulfilled for weak poloidal fields . moreover ,
if the dynamo produces its own @xmath0 effect by the magnetic instability then problems with its sign do not arise .
for all cases , however , the @xmath0 effect shows an extremely strong concentration to the poles so that a possible @xmath2 dynamo might only work at the polar regions .
hence , the results of our linear theory lead to a new topological problem for the existence of large - scale dynamos in stellar radiation zones on the basis of the current - driven instability of toroidal fields . [ firstpage ]
magnetohydrodynamics ( mhd ) instabilities stars : magnetic fields stars : interiors . |
like the fundamental plane for early type galaxies @xcite the tully - fisher relation for disc galaxies embodies fundamental implications for the relationship between the mass of the galaxy , its star - formation history , specific angular momentum and dark matter content and distribution . broadly speaking
, there are two competing models to explain the tully - fisher relation .
the first of these is that it is a consequence of self - regulated star formation in discs with different masses ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , i.e. , the competition of disc instability ( which promotes star formation ) with supernovae induced porosity ( which inhibits star - formation ) .
the model is not the complete answer , however , since it does not explain the mass - to - light ratios or the scale - lengths of the discs . in the second model
the tully - fisher relation is a direct consequence of the cosmological equivalence between mass and circular velocity ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
this formalism is part of what has become the standard model for the growth of structure - the hierarchical merging model in which the gravitational effects of dark matter drive the evolution of galaxies and large - scale structure ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
models of this type have the advantage of providing testable predictions about the sizes , surface densities , and rotation curves of galaxies as a function of redshift .
however , as emphasized by @xcite , although the tully - fisher relation can naturally be explained by hierarchical merging models , the normalization and evolution of the tully - fisher relation depend strongly on the prescription used for the star formation and on the cosmological parameters .
it is now well established that massive disc galaxies exist out to redshifts @xmath4 @xcite . for a given size scale ,
the number density of these disc galaxies is approximately the same at @xmath5 as is observed locally .
overall , the results at moderate redshift ( @xmath6 ) are rather mixed . depending on the sample selection , the technique used to estimate the rotation speed , the median redshift of the sample , and the wavelength at which comparisons are made
, there are claims in the literature that the tully - fisher relation either brightens or dims with redshift ( see e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . to help resolve this controversy and to push to higher redshift where evidence for evolution of disc galaxies will likely be stronger and more obvious
, we set out to obtain spatially resolved rotation curves at the highest redshifts where large samples are available .
obtaining spatially resolved rotation curves becomes quite difficult at such high redshifts since [ oii]@xmath73727 is redshifted into a region with many strong night sky lines and the sensitivity of ccds declines rapidly .
instead we have chosen to observe the h@xmath1 line , reshifted to the infrared j - band .
h@xmath1 is typically 2.5 times stronger than [ oii ] @xcite and being at longer wavelength , is less affected by dust extinction .
to gauge the evolution of the tully - fisher relation we compare a local with a high redshift sample of highly inclined , `` normal '' spiral galaxies .
the high redshift sample consists of objects with measured spectroscopic redshifts . to be able to measure h@xmath1 in the near - infrared we required @xmath8 .
targets were selected from the cfrs / ldss redshift surveys , the clusters ms1054 , ac103 and the hawaii deep field ssa22 ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* respectively , and references therein ) .
furthermore , we included two targets from the vlt science archive .
for the majority of these sources we have hst i - band or at least vlt j - band images .
for all of them we have obtained h@xmath1 isaac long - slit spectra to determine spatially resolved rotation curves . for this purpose
we have selected these sources to be spatially extended on the images ( diameters mainly @xmath92 ) and to have high inclination angles ( @xmath10 , @xmath11 ) .
furthermore , we chose only objects with exponential light profiles to ensure that we were observing disc galaxies .
the mean redshift of our high - z sample is @xmath12 ( see tab . [ tbl-1 ] ) . to construct a complementary sample of local galaxies we searched the literature for objects with accessible ccd b - band images ( obtained from the nasa extragalactic database , ned , or eso science archive ) , published distances based on primary distance indicators or mean group velocities and an estimate for the rotation speed based on either an hi or a resolved h@xmath1 rotation curve .
total magnitudes for all local sample galaxies where obtained from rc3 @xcite or leda . as a consistency check , the object magnitudes , sizes , rotation speeds and the resulting tully - fisher relation were compared to the rc3 catalogue and the data from @xcite . from this comparison
, we conclude that our sample of low redshift galaxies is in good agreement with a random subsample of a magnitude limited complete sample from the rc3 .
we obtained j- and h - band spectroscopy during four observing runs with the facility near - infrared spectrometer isaac at the vlt @xcite .
we used the medium resolution spectroscopic mode with a slit - width resolution product of @xmath13 and a spatial pixel scale of 0.1484 . in eso - period 65 and 66 ( april - september 2000 and october 2000 - march 2001 respectively ) we obtained the first set of data in service mode . with total integration times of 3 hours and a 0.6-slit ( @xmath14 ) , which we rotated according to the position angle of the objects , we could successfully observe four targets .
the target selection and successive estimation of position angles for this set we performed on 1 resolution images acquired in the j - band with isaac ( 20min integration time ) before the spectroscopic observations .
in addition to these j - band images , we obtained i - band images taken with the canada france hawaii telescope ( cfht ) from that telescope s archive .
furthermore , we conducted three other runs in visitor mode in february and september 2001 and september 2002 .
this time the set - up included a 1-slit ( @xmath15 ) and integration times varied , depending on the h@xmath1 flux of the targets , between 1 and 3 hours .
moreover , we selected targets on the basis of hst / wfpc2 f814w images , which we also used to orient the slit along the galaxy major axis .
since most of the targets were too faint to be acquired directly we used a blind off - set from a``bright '' star , calculated from the hst images . using this prescription we observed another 17 objects successfully .
the seeing during these four runs ranged from 0.4 to 0.8 .
to reduce the isaac spectra we used standard data reduction packages ( eso eclipse & iraf ) .
the data were flat fielded and dark - subtracted . after dark - subtraction and cosmic ray rejection we checked all frames individually for shifts in the wavelength direction due to flexure and applied a reverse shift if necessary . before combining the frames we calculated a wavelength solution and distortion correction . finally , we subtracted a background and smoothed the spectra with a gaussian of fwhm approximately equal to the number of pixels per resolution element .
firstly , we extracted one dimensional h@xmath1-profiles across the spectral and spatial regions of the array that contained h@xmath1-flux . typically , even with the increased signal - to - noise gained in the continuum by summing up the flux in this way , we could not detect the continuum significantly .
we then fitted the one dimensional h@xmath1-profiles ( typically assuming no galaxy continuum ) by one or two ( in the case of a double horned profile ) gaussians . at the level where
@xmath16 of the total integrated flux was reached we measured the width of the profile . applying the corrections given by @xcite we obtained a first estimate for the terminal rotation velocity of our sample galaxies . in all cases but one , however , we could derive a terminal rotation velocity from a resolved rotation curve model . to extract the data points for the model rotation curve we developed a special adaptive curve tracing algorithm .
we then fitted the resulting position - velocity diagram with a simple model of a flat rotation curve ( which is appropriate for not too - late disc galaxies ) .
this step - function we convolved with a gaussian with a full - width at half maximum of the seeing .
moreover , the convolution included weighting with an exponential function with a scale - length as measured from our disc surface brightness fits on the hst or vlt images assuming that line and continuum have the same light distribution .
tests show that our modeling delivers robust rotation velocities , which are not very sensitive to the exact weighting scheme , the impact of nuclear bulges , the signal - to - noise ratio and in particular , how well the observationally `` flat part '' of the rotation curve is sampled by the data .
we have measured the seeing from the j - band acquisition images taken before the observations , the acquisition images of a subsequent target , and the values from the visible seeing monitor .
given our long integration times and the limited sampling of the seeing at the observing wavelength , the seeing is somewhat uncertain .
we have therefore let it be a free parameter in the fitting process .
the values obtained from an unconstrained fit correlate well with the seeing values estimated from the acquisition images and seeing monitor , though .
some of the final fits to the data are shown in fig .
[ rotation - profile ] .
although only @xmath17 of the data show a clear turn - over or extend out to 2.2 disc scale lengths the remaining data do not exclusively consist of slow rotators only .
in fact , the distributions of rotation speeds of high and low quality data can not be distinguished from each other ( see barden et al . 2003 ) . furthermore , the rotation speeds derived from the two dimensional data are not significantly smaller than the ones from the one dimensional spectra , which have much higher signal - to - noise ( see barden et al . 2003 ) .
moreover , according to the parametric fits to over 2000 local disc galaxies of @xcite at radii varying from @xmath18 one should already measure at least @xmath19 of the asymptotic rotation velocity . since the majority of our high galaxies extend further out we estimate rotation velocities within @xmath20 .
therefore , we are confident that we do not underestimate the rotation velocities significantly . finally , the rotation velocities have to be corrected for the inclination of the galaxies .
we have derived inclinations from surface brightness profile fits to our hst or isaac images . to estimate rest - frame b - band magnitudes we compiled all available photometric information for our sources ( two to five independent measurements ) . for each magnitude
we calculated the corresponding rest - frame wavelength and corrected the magnitudes for galactic foreground extinction @xcite .
then we fitted the extinction corrected magnitudes and corresponding rest - wavelengths with spectra from the atlas of @xcite .
we note that our final rest - frame b - band magnitudes are relatively insensitive to the models used since all of the galaxies had a photometric band available that was very near to the b - band rest wavelength .
finally , we corrected the resulting rest - frame b - band magnitudes for inclination dependent internal extinction according to the method of @xcite and determined a face - on b - magnitude ( table [ tbl-1 ] ) . the parameters for the local comparison sample were determined and corrected in exactly the same manner as for the high redshift galaxies .
rotation speeds were extracted from hi or optical rotation curves .
only one object was included where a spatially - resolved rotation curve was not available .
comparison of the resolved data with the hi line width from rc3 usually agree within @xmath21 km s@xmath22 ( see barden et al . 2003 ) .
we calculated inclination corrections based on inclinations from our own profile fits in agreement with the values from rc3 or leda .
total magnitudes were obtained directly from rc3 or leda and were corrected for galactic foreground extinction and internal extinction . since differences in the isophotal extent between the images of the local and high redshift galaxies can be quite dramatic ( up to two magnitudes ) , the light profiles of the local galaxy sample were fit only out to a characteristic limiting radius , which was approximately the average isophotal depth of the images of the high redshift galaxies ( taking into account cosmic surface brightness dimming ; see barden et al . 2003 ) .
comparing the isophotal - size - culled local ( our comparison sample ) and high redshift galaxy samples ( see barden et al . 2003 ) we find an offset for the high - z data from the tully - fisher relation of @xmath24 magnitudes in a @xmath25-dominated universe ( @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 ; fig .
[ tully - fisher ] ) .
this `` brightening '' of the distant galaxies is significant and holds for any reasonable cosmology ( @xmath29 for @xmath30 and @xmath31 ; @xmath32 for @xmath33 and @xmath31 ) . the limited range in isophotal size makes measuring a slope of the tully - fisher relation impossible .
the observed offset in the tully - fisher relation at @xmath34 for large galaxies is partially a consequence of the fact that we observe an increase of central surface brightness of 1.7 mag arcsec@xmath35 and a slight decrease of @xmath36 in the disc scale lengths of the high redshift sample compared to the local control sample ( see barden et al .
2003 ) . using the relationship between disc magnitude , central surface brightness , and disc scale length , namely , @xmath37 , we find that the differences in average central surface brightness and average disc scale lengths imply an offset in the zero - point of the t - f relation between the two samples of about @xmath38 magnitudes .
in addition , by comparing the rotation speeds of the high redshift galaxies and the local comparison sample , we find an average offset of @xmath39 km s@xmath22 of the high redshift sample ( see barden et al .
thus , between @xmath40 and 0 the mean mass of galaxies has increased by a factor of @xmath41 ( assuming mass @xmath42 , and estimating the total mass out to 2.2 disc scale lengths measured from fitting the light profile ) . therefore , if we use a parameterization of the tully - fisher relation as given by @xcite , adjusting the zero - points by -0.3 mag to account for the average differences in surface brightness and disc scale length and decreasing the average rotation speed by @xmath43 yields an offset from the local tully - fisher relation consistent with that observed ( @xmath44 mag ) .
having the highest redshift sample puts us in a unique position to discuss the evolution of the tully - fisher relation from a new perspective .
all of the studies to date have found a significantly smaller amount of evolution compared to the results presented here . the most obvious way to reconcile
this difference is that the offset in the tully - fisher relation grows with increasing redshift .
the studies with the highest median redshift currently are @xcite and @xcite with a mean redshift of @xmath45 , compared with our mean redshift of @xmath46 .
the time difference is therefore about 2 - 3 gyrs for any reasonable cosmology , clearly sufficient for galaxies to undergo significant evolution .
unfortunately , comparing these results with model predictions is not very straight - forward since the exact offset predicted depends on the assumed physics and phenomenology , such as the details of star - formation ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
recently , within the frame work of galaxy evolution ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , a number of authors have made predictions about the general evolution of the galaxy population .
for example , @xcite predict that from @xmath47 to 1 , using the cosmological parameters we have assumed here , that the overall luminosity function of galaxies in the b - band will brighten by about 1.15 mag and that the characteristic mass of galaxies will decline by about a factor of 2.4 . assuming that the galaxies selected for study here
are a subset of this population , our numbers are in reasonable agreement with the predicted values .
unfortunately , the resolution of the simulations by @xcite are too low to check whether the sizes of discs evolve self - consistently in this context .
we conclude that large disc galaxies have undergone substantial evolution from @xmath40 to the present .
the offset in the tully - fisher relation is about @xmath48 mag in the rest - frame b - band , and is related to an overall increase in the central surface brightnesses of disc galaxies and a decrease in rotation speed .
we also find that the slope of the tully - fisher relation , due to size constraints that inevitably result from needing to obtain spatially - resolved rotation curves , can not meaningfully be estimated .
in a subsequent paper ( barden et al . 2003 ) , we will discuss in detail the change in rotation speeds , disc masses , disc scale lengths , and disc angular momenta of this sample of high redshift galaxies relative to the local comparison sample , and make quantitative comparisons with theoretical models of galaxy evolution . , l. , ford , h. c. , huchra , j. , kennicutt , r. c. , mould , j. r. , sakai , s. , freedman , w. l. , stetson , p. b. , madore , b. f. , gibson , b. k. , graham , j. a. , hughes , s. m. , illingworth , g. d. , kelson , d. d. , macri , l. , sebo , k. , and silbermann , n. a. : 2000 , , 431 , w. l. , madore , b. f. , gibson , b. k. , ferrarese , l. , kelson , d. d. , sakai , s. , mould , j. r. , kennicutt , r. c. , ford , h. c. , graham , j. a. , huchra , j. p. , hughes , s. m. g. , illingworth , g. d. , macri , l. m. , and stetson , p. b. : 2001 , , 47 , a. , cuby , j .-
, biereichel , p. , brynnel , j. , delabre , b. , devillard , n. , van dijsseldonk , a. , finger , g. , gemperlein , h. , gilmozzi , r. , herlin , t. , huster , g. , knudstrup , j. , lidman , c. , lizon , j .- l . ,
mehrgan , h. , meyer , m. , nicolini , g. , petr , m. , spyromilio , j. , and stegmeier , j. : 1998 , , 7 , b. l. , b " ohm , a. , fricke , k. j. , j " ager , k. , nicklas , h. , bender , r. , drory , n. , gabasch , a. , saglia , r. p. , seitz , s. , heidt , j. , mehlert , d. , m " ollenhoff , c. , noll , s. , and sutorius , e. : 2002 , , l69 lcccccccrr cfrs-00.0174&0.7838&12.9&3.58&79&0.11&0.14&23.22&[email protected]&116@xmath5040 + cfrs-00.0308&0.9704&17.8&1.33&43&0.06&0.13&23.72&[email protected]&86@xmath4920 + ms1054 - 1403&0.8133&40.7&3.21&76&0.54&0.15&20.74&[email protected]&232@xmath4950 + ms1054 - 1733&0.8347&14.9&1.88&60&0.22&0.15&22.97&[email protected]&136@xmath4920 + ldss2 - 03.219&0.6024&13.9&1.73&57&0.18&0.34&23.25&[email protected]&101@xmath5050 + cfrs-03.0999&0.7049&30.3&3.53&78&0.62&0.42&21.45&[email protected]&223@xmath5010 + cfrs-03.1393&0.8554&22.6&4.23&83&0.69&0.42&22.26&[email protected]&187@xmath5010 + cfrs-03.1650&0.6341&19.6&2.78&72&0.43&0.42&22.33&[email protected]&165@xmath5040 + cfrs-22.0953&0.9787&23.9&2.41&68&0.34&0.28&22.87&[email protected]&144@xmath5030 + cfrs-22.1313&0.8173&23.9&2.92&74&0.47&0.28&22.29&[email protected]&120@xmath5010 + cn84 - 023&0.6389&25.4&1.47&49&0.12&0.17&20.78&[email protected]&172@xmath5050 + cn84 - 123&0.6776&20.3&1.98&62&0.24&0.17&21.48&[email protected]&212@xmath5040 + csh96 - 68&1.5625&17.5&1.87&60&0.22&0.29&23.56&[email protected] & 96@xmath5050 + hdfs-0620&1.2850 & 3.6&1.49&49&0.12&0.12&28.00&[email protected]&123@xmath5020 + sa68 - 5155&1.0521&25.1&2.35&68&0.33&0.22&22.98&[email protected]&160@xmath5050 + cfrs-00.0137&0.9512&18.1&1.39&45&0.06&0.14&22.37&[email protected]&237@xmath5040 + csh96 - 32&1.0215&13.1&1.49&49&0.12&0.30&22.85&[email protected]&209@xmath5020 + csh96 - 74&1.3633&25.8&3.78&80&0.68&0.29&23.30&[email protected]&112@xmath5030 + cfrs-03.0776&0.8835 & 7.6&1.22&36&0.06&0.42&23.69&[email protected]&144@xmath5010 + cfrs-03.1056&0.9392&13.8&1.50&50&0.13&0.42&22.16&[email protected]&140@xmath5010 + cfrs-03.1284&0.9393 & 8.1&1.18&33&0.04&0.42&23.58&[email protected]&167@xmath4920 + cfrs-22.0599&0.8856&13.9&1.76&57&0.19&0.29&22.29&[email protected]&159@xmath5030 + | we describe the first results of a programme to obtain rotation curves of @xmath0 disc galaxies in the near - infrared using the h@xmath1 emission line in order to study the tully - fisher relationship . to put any observed evolution into perspective and to investigate any possible selection biases
, we constructed a control sample of low redshift galaxies that had rotation velocities and images available for measuring their dynamical , photometric , and morphological properties .
compared to local objects with isophotal sizes similar to the high redshift targets , we find that our sample of galaxies with spatially resolved rotation curves , the most distant sample so far ( @xmath2 ) , clearly reveals a brightening of @xmath3 mag in the rest - frame b - band .
the observed offset can be explained by a combination of increasing surface brightness , decreasing rotation speeds , and slightly smaller disc scale lengths of the high redshift galaxies . |
the nonlinear differential equation @xmath1 appears in the modeling of certain phenomena in plasma physics @xcite . in @xcite , mickens calculates the period of its periodic orbits and also uses the @xmath2-th order harmonic balance method ( hbm ) , for @xmath3 , to obtain approximations of these periodic solutions and of their corresponding periods . strictly speaking
, it can be easily seen that neither equation , nor its associated system @xmath4 which is singular at @xmath5 , have periodic solutions .
our first result gives two different interpretations of mickens computation of the period .
the first one in terms of weak ( or generalized ) solutions . in this work
a weak solution will be a function satisfying the differential equation on an open and dense set , but being of class @xmath6 at some isolated points .
the second one , as the limit , when @xmath7 tends to zero , of the period of actual periodic solutions of the extended planar differential system @xmath8 which , for @xmath9 has a global center at the origin .
[ main1 ] a. for the initial conditions @xmath10 the differential equation has a weak @xmath11-periodic solution with period @xmath12 b. let @xmath13 be the period of the periodic orbit of system with initial conditions
@xmath14 then @xmath15 and @xmath16 recall that the @xmath2-th order hbm consists in approximating the solutions of differential equations by truncated fourier series with @xmath2 harmonics and an unknown frequency ; see for instance @xcite or section [ hbm ] for a short overview of the method . in @xcite the author asks for techniques for dealing analytically with the @xmath2-th order hbm , for @xmath17 . in @xcite it
is shown how resultants can be used when @xmath18 . here
we utilize a more powerful tool , the computation of grbner basis ( ( * ? ? ?
5 ) ) , for going further in the obtention of approximations of the function @xmath19 introduced in theorem [ main1 ] . notice that equation is equivalent to the family of differential equations @xmath20 for any @xmath21 .
hence it is natural to approach the period function , @xmath22 by the periods of the trigonometric polynomials obtained applying the @xmath2-th order hbm to .
next theorem gives our results for @xmath23 here @xmath24 $ ] denotes the integer part of @xmath25 [ main2 ] let @xmath26 be the period of the truncated fourier series obtained applying the @xmath2-th order hbm to equation .
it holds : a. for all @xmath21 , @xmath27 + 1}{2[\frac{m+1}2]+2}}\,a.\ ] ] b. for @xmath28 @xmath29 c. for @xmath30 @xmath31 d. for @xmath32 @xmath33 moreover , the approximate values appearing above are roots of given polynomials with integer coefficients .
whereby the sturm sequences approach can be used to get them with any desirable precision .
notice that the values @xmath34 for @xmath35 given in items ( ii ) , ( iii ) and ( iv ) , respectively , are already computed in item ( i ) .
we only explicite them to clarify the reading .
observe that the comparison of with the value @xmath19 given in theorem [ main1 ] shows that when @xmath36 the best approximations of @xmath19 happen when @xmath37 .
for this reason we have applied the hbm for @xmath38 and @xmath39 to elucidate which of the approaches is better . in the table
[ tperror ] we will compare the percentage of the relative errors @xmath40 the best approximation that we have found corresponds to @xmath41 our computers have had problems to get the grbner basis needed to fill the gaps of the table .
[ ta1 ] @xmath42 the paper is organized as follows .
theorem [ main1 ] is proved in section [ solus ] . in section [ hbm ] we describe the @xmath2-th order hbm adapted to our purposes .
finally , in section [ sec sys ] we use this method to demonstrate theorem [ main2 ] .
@xmath43 we start proving that the solution of with initial conditions @xmath44 , @xmath45 and for @xmath46 is @xmath47 where @xmath48 is the inverse of the error function @xmath49 notice that @xmath50 and @xmath51 . to obtain ,
observe that from system we arrive at the simple differential equation @xmath52 which has separable variables and can be solved by integration .
the particular solution that passes by the point @xmath53 is @xmath54 combining and we obtain @xmath55 again a separable equation .
it has the solution @xmath56 which is well defined for @xmath46 since @xmath57 is defined in @xmath58 . finally , by replacing @xmath59 in we obtain , as we wanted to prove . by using @xmath60 and @xmath59 given by and , respectively , or using
, we can draw the phase portrait of which , as we can see in figure [ figura1].(b ) , is symmetric with respect to both axes .
notice that its orbits do not cross the @xmath61-axis , which is a singular locus for the associated vector field .
moreover , the solutions of are not periodic ( see figure [ figura1].(a ) ) , and the transit time of @xmath60 from @xmath62 to @xmath5 is @xmath63 . [ cols="^,^ " , ] its period function is @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the energy level of the orbit passing through the point @xmath66 .
therefore , @xmath67 where we have used the change of variable @xmath68 and the symmetry with respect to @xmath69 then , @xmath70 if we prove that @xmath71 then @xmath72 and the theorem will follow . therefore , for completing the proof , it only remains to show that holds . for
proving that , take any sequence @xmath73 with @xmath74 tending monotonically to infinity , and consider the functions @xmath75 we have that the sequence @xmath76 is formed by measurable and positive functions defined on the interval @xmath77 .
it is not difficult to prove that it is a decreasing sequence . in particular , @xmath78 for all @xmath79 .
therefore , if we show that @xmath80 is integrable , then we can apply the lebesgue s dominated convergence theorem ( @xcite ) and will follow . to prove that @xmath81 note that for @xmath82 close to 1 , @xmath83 since this last expression is integrable the result follows by the comparison test for improper integrals .
this section gives a brief description of the hbm applied the second order differential equations @xmath84 with @xmath85 , and adapted to our interests .
notice that if @xmath60 is a solution of then @xmath86 also is a solution .
suppose that equation has a @xmath87-periodic solution @xmath60 with initial conditions @xmath44 , @xmath88 and period @xmath89 if @xmath60 satisfies @xmath90 it is clear that its fourier series has no sinus terms and writes as @xmath91 as we have seen in previous section , the weak periodic solutions of equation @xmath92 that we want to approach satisfy the above property .
moreover @xmath93 and @xmath94 does not exist . in any case , if we are searching smooth approximations to this @xmath60 , they should also satisfy @xmath95 and hence @xmath96 for this reason , in this work we will search fourier series in cosinus , not having the even terms @xmath97 , @xmath98 which do not satisfy this property .
this type of a priori simplifications are similar to the ones introduced in @xcite for other problems .
hence , in our setting , the hbm of order @xmath2 follows the next five steps : \1 .
consider a trigonometric polynomial @xmath99 \2 .
compute the @xmath100-periodic function @xmath101 , which has also an associated fourier series , @xmath102 where @xmath103 @xmath104 with @xmath105 .
find all values @xmath106 and @xmath107 such that @xmath108 where @xmath109 is the value such that consists exactly of @xmath2 non trivial equations .
notice also that each equation @xmath110 is equivalent to @xmath111 \4 .
then the expression , with the values of @xmath112 and @xmath113 obtained in point 3 , provide candidates to be approximations of the actual periodic solutions of the initial differential equation .
in particular , the functions @xmath114 give approximations of the periods of the corresponding periodic orbits .
choose , as final approximation , the one associated to the solution that minimizes the norm @xmath115
\(i ) notice that going from order @xmath2 to order @xmath116 in the method , implies to compute again all the coefficients of the fourier polynomial , because in general the common fourier coefficients of @xmath117 and @xmath118 do not coincide .
\(ii ) the above set of equations is a system of polynomial equations which usually is not easy to solve .
for this reason in many works , see for instance @xcite and the references therein , only the values of @xmath3 are considered . for solving system for @xmath119
we use the grbner basis approach @xmath120@xcite@xmath121 . in general
this method is faster that using successive resultants and moreover it does not give spurious solutions .
\(iii ) as far as we know , the test proposed in point 5 to select the best approach is not commonly used .
we propose it following the definition of accuracy of an approximated solution used in @xcite and inspired in the classical works @xcite .
we start proving a lemma that will allow to reduce our computations to the case @xmath122 consider @xmath125 , with @xmath126 given in .
we have to solve the set of @xmath116 non - trivial equations @xmath127 with @xmath116 unknowns @xmath128 and @xmath107 and @xmath129 the lemma clearly follows if we prove next assertion : @xmath130 and @xmath131 is a solution of with @xmath132 if and only if @xmath133 and @xmath134 is a solution of .
this equivalence is a consequence of the fact that the change of variables @xmath135 writes the integral equation in as @xmath136 and from the structure of the right hand side equation of .
hence , @xmath137 as we wanted to prove . @xmath43 following section [ hbm ] , we consider @xmath138 as the first approximation to the actual solution of the functional equation @xmath139 .
then @xmath140 when @xmath141 the above expression writes as @xmath142 using for @xmath143 we get @xmath144 where @xmath145 . by using integration by parts
we prove that @xmath146 combining this equality and we obtain that @xmath147 or equivalently , @xmath148 that in terms of @xmath149 coincides with .
the case @xmath149 odd follows similarly .
the only difference is that instead of condition to find @xmath150 we have to impose that @xmath151 because @xmath152 when @xmath156 , we take an approximation @xmath157 the vanishing of the coefficients of 1 and @xmath158 in the fourier series of @xmath159 provides the nonlinear system @xmath160 by solving it and applying point 5 in the hbm we get that @xmath161 therefore , @xmath162 as we wanted to prove . for the third - order hbm we use as approximate solution @xmath163 imposing that the coefficients of 1 , @xmath164 , and @xmath165 in @xmath166 vanish we arrive at the system @xmath167
since all the equations are polynomial , the searching of its solutions can be done by using the grbner basis approach , see @xcite .
recall that the idea of this method consists in finding a new systems of generators , say @xmath168 of the ideal of @xmath169 $ ] generated by @xmath170 and @xmath171 .
hence , solving @xmath172 is equivalent to solve @xmath173 @xmath174 . in general
, choosing the lexicographic ordering in the grbner basis approach , we get that the polynomials of the equivalent system have triangular structure with respect to the variables and it can be easily solved . when @xmath182 we consider @xmath183 and we arrive at the system @xmath184 the grbner basis of @xmath185 with respect to the lexicographic ordering @xmath186 $ ] is a new basis with five polynomials , being one of them an even polynomial in @xmath187 of degree 16 with integers coefficients . solving it
we obtain that the best approximation is @xmath188 which gives @xmath189 for @xmath190 and @xmath191 we have done similar computations . in the case @xmath190
one of the generators of the grbner basis is an even polynomial in @xmath192 with integers coefficients and degree 32 .
when @xmath191 the same happens but with a polynomial of degree 64 in @xmath193 .
solving the corresponding polynomials we get that @xmath194 and @xmath195 , and consequently , @xmath196 and @xmath197 when @xmath201 doing similar computations that in item @xmath153 , we arrive at @xmath202 again , by searching the grbner basis of @xmath203 with respect to the lexicographic ordering @xmath204 $ ] we obtain a new basis with three polynomials , being one of them @xmath205 notice that the equation @xmath206 can be algebraically solved . nevertheless , for the sake of shortness , we do not give the exact roots .
following again step 5 of our approach we get that the best solution is @xmath207 , or equivalently that @xmath208 computing the grbner basis of @xmath175 with respect to the lexicographic ordering @xmath176 $ ] we get that one of the polynomials of the new basis is an even polynomial in @xmath210 of degree 26 with integer coefficients . by solving it
we obtain that the best approximation is @xmath211 , which produces the value @xmath212 of the statement .
when @xmath182 we arrive at five polynomial equations , that we omit .
once more , using the grbner basis approach we obtain a polynomial condition in @xmath187 of degree 80 . finally , @xmath213 and @xmath214 the two authors are supported by the miciin / feder grant number mtm2008 - 03437 , feder - unab10 - 4e-378 and the generalitat de catalunya grant number 2009-sgr 410 . the first author is also supported by the grant fpu ap2009 - 1189
d. cox , j. little , d. oshea,ideals , varieties , and algorithms : an introduction to computational algebraic geometry and commutative algebra " , third edition .
undergraduate texts in mathematics .
springer , new york , 2007 . | we prove that the differential equation @xmath0 has continuous weak periodic solutions and compute their periods .
then , we use the harmonic balance method until order six to approach these periods and to illustrate how the sharpness of the method increases with the order .
our computations rely on the grbner basis method . |
disk galaxy mergers are believed to be responsible for triggering a variety of global _ and _ nuclear responses in galaxies .
the global effects have been well documented , both with observations , starting with zwicky s extensive work ( 1950 , 1956 , 1964 ) , and with numerical simulations , first convincingly demonstrated by @xcite .
work during the last decades strongly suggests that a fraction of elliptical galaxies has formed as a result of disk galaxy merging ( see * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) .
the morphology of tidal tails has been used to trace the mass distribution in galactic halos @xcite , and the tails themselves are possible birthplaces of some dwarf galaxies @xcite .
mergers have also been closely connected to luminous and ultraluminous infrared galaxies @xcite .
perhaps the most dramatic physical process associated with disk galaxy merging is the inflow of gas into the nuclear region and the consequent excitation of nuclear starburst and agn activity .
this process has been reported from simulations @xcite and from observations @xcite . whether the gas `` hangs up '' and forms stars in the inner kiloparsec , or continues to flow inward towards a putative agn , has a strong impact on the luminosity and evolution of the merger .
the details of the nuclear gasdynamics will depend on the structure of the host galaxies and the dynamical stage of the interaction @xcite .
several scenarios have been suggested in which interactions evolve from starburst - dominated to agn - dominated regimes as the galaxies merge @xcite .
unfortunately , until now , both observations and numerical simulations have lacked the spatial resolution needed to study the evolution of the merging nuclei on scales smaller than a few hundred parsecs .
for this reason , our understanding of how mergers fuel nuclear starburst and agn activity , and drive galaxy evolution from the nucleus out , has remained woefully incomplete .
theoretical arguments suggest that the evolution of the merging nuclei is where the merger hypothesis for the formation of elliptical galaxies through disk galaxy mergers faces its most stringent test .
a wide variety of physical processes may shape the nuclei .
purely stellar dynamical merging alone would tend to produce diffuse nuclei with large cores and a very shallow nuclear surface brightness gradient @xcite unless the progenitor nuclei were dense @xcite . in the case of gas - rich disk galaxies
, the dissipative flow of gas into the nuclei and accompanying star formation would tend to result in a steep luminosity profile @xcite and a large central density , as seen in several young merger remnants ( r. p. van der marel et al .
, in preparation ; see also figure 2 in @xcite @xcite ) . the presence of a central supermassive black hole would also induce a strong nuclear power - law cusp @xcite . yet
if both galaxies contain supermassive central black holes which merge , the resulting black hole binary would act as a dynamical slingshot and eject stars from the center , thus lowering the stellar density there @xcite .
for these reasons we are undertaking a high resolution _
hubble space telescope ( hst ) _ survey of the nuclear regions in a sequence of merging galaxies .
the questions we want to answer include the following : 1 . what is the morphology of the ionized gas distribution around the nucleus ?
is it clumpy , diffuse and extended , ring - like , or compact and disk - like ? does this morphology depend on the interaction stage ?
how is the current star formation , as revealed by the h@xmath0 line emission , distributed with respect to the young stellar populations as revealed by their blue color ( and , eventually , spectra ) ?
3 . how do the nuclear starbursts affect the radial color gradients of the merger remnants ?
the spatial resolution of the _ hst _
( 1050 pc in nearby systems ) is required to investigate these questions , which are the focus of the current paper . in future papers
, we will study the stellar populations , kinematics , and evolution of the merger - induced starbursts of the toomre sequence nuclei , using _
hst _ stis spectra and nicmos imaging .
the toomre sequence @xcite is a sample of 11 relatively nearby ( within @xmath1120mpc ) interacting and merging disk galaxies , which have been arranged into a sequence according to the _ putative _ time before or since merging .
these systems were chosen because they exhibit conspicuous tidal tails and `` main bodies that are nearly in contact or perhaps not even separable '' @xcite .
they span a range of dynamical phases , from galaxies early in the merging process ( e.g. , ngc4038/39 and ngc4676 ) to late - stage merger remnants ( e.g. , ngc3921 and ngc7252 ; see figure [ f : mosaic ] and table [ t : sample ] ) .
we want to emphasize the word `` putative '' , since the placing of a system in this sequence was based on the apparent degree of coalescence of the progenitor main bodies in low - resolution optical photographical plates , assuming that the progenitors resembled normal disk galaxies in the pre - encounter stage .
because of the requirement of well - developed tidal tails , these systems have suffered , or are suffering , encounters that are most likely of prograde sense ( with the disks rotating in the same sense as they orbit each other ) .
in such a scenario , the orbits of interacting galaxies decay as the galaxies lose orbital energy and angular momentum via dynamical friction with their dark halos . ultimately , the galaxies coalesce and form a single merger remnant . on these grounds
we can call the toomre sequence an evolutionary sequence . because it is an _ optically _
selected sample of merging galaxies , it suffers less from dust obscuration than infrared - luminous samples , allowing the nuclei to be studied at optical wavelengths .
the toomre sequence has been widely investigated by ground - based observations @xcite , space - based observations @xcite , and numerical studies @xcite .
ccccccccc sequence number & galaxy & r.a .
( j2000.0 ) & dec .
( j2000.0 ) & @xmath2 & dist .
& @xmath3 & 01 & dynamical + & & ( hh mm ss.ss ) & ( ddmmsss ) & ( km s@xmath4 ) & ( mpc ) & ( ) & ( pc ) & model + 1 . & ngc4038 & 12 01 53.06 & @xmath518 52 01.3 & 1616 & 21.6 & 61.4 & 10 & y + 1 . &
ngc4039 & 12 01 53.54 & @xmath518 53 09.3 & 1624 & 21.6 & 61.4 & 10 & y + 2 . & ngc4676 nuc1 & 12 46 10.06 & + 30 43 55.5 & 6613 & 88.2 & 37.1 & 43 & y + 2 . & ngc4676 nuc2 & 12 46 11.17 & + 30 43 21.2 & 6613 & 88.2 & 37.1 & 43 & y + 3 . & ngc7592 nuc1 & 23 18 21.73 & @xmath504 24 56.7 & 7280 & 97.1 & 13.0 & 47 & n + 3 . & ngc7592 nuc2 & 23 18 22.60 & @xmath504 24 57.3 & 7280 & 97.1 & 13.0 & 47 & n + 4 . & ngc7764a & 23 53 23.74 & @xmath540 48 26.3 & 9162 & 122.2 & 0 & 59 & n + 5 . & ngc6621 & 18 12 55.25 & + 68 21 48.5 & 6191 & 84.4 & 41.7 & 41 & n + 5 . & ngc6622 & 18 12 59.74 & + 68 21 15.1 & 6466 & 84.4 & 41.7 & 41 & n + 6 . & ngc3509 & 11 04 23.59 & + 04 49 42.4 & 7704 & 102.7 & 0 & 50 & n + 7 . & ngc520 nuc1 & 01 24 34.89 & + 03 47 29.9 & 2281 & 30.4 & 40.3 & 15 & y + 7 . & ngc520 nuc2 & 01 24 33.30 & + 03 48 02.4 & 2281 & 30.4 & 40.3 & 15 & y + 8 . & ngc2623 & 08 38 24.11 & + 25 45 16.6 & 5535 & 73.8 & 0 & 36 & n + 9 . & ngc3256 & 10 27 51.17 & @xmath543 54 16.1 & 2738 & 36.5 & 0 & 18 & n + 10 . & ngc3921 & 11 51 06.96 & + 55 04 43.1 & 5838 & 77.8 & 0 & 38 & n + 11 . & ngc7252 & 22 20 44.78 & @xmath524 40 41.8 & 4688 & 62.5 & 0 & 30 & y + all images were taken with the wfpc2 camera onboard the _
hst_. we used the f555w and f814w filters , which mimic the better - known @xmath6- and @xmath7-bands , with integration times of 320 seconds in each band , split into two exposures of 160 seconds to allow for cosmic ray rejection ( see table [ t : expo ] for more information on the exposure times ) .
images in these bands for ngc4038/39 @xcite , ngc3921 @xcite , and ngc7252 @xcite already existed in the _ hst _ archive .
we used those images in our current study .
narrow - band images covering the h@xmath0 + [ ] lines were taken with the f673n narrow - band filter in cases where the line emission from the target fell within the wavelength range covered by this filter ( ngc3509 ; ngc 7592 ) , or otherwise with the linear ramp filter ( lrf ) .
the lrfs have a bandwidth of about 1.3% of the central wavelength .
the position of the galaxy on the ccd chip depends on the central wavelength and limits the field of view to about @xmath8 @xmath9 @xmath8 for the lrf .
the list of the adopted filters , central wavelengths , and fwhm values of the filters together with integration times are given in table [ t : expo ] .
the antennae , ngc4038/39 , was imaged earlier in the _ hst _
f658n h@xmath0 filter by @xcite , and we used these data in our work .
we employed the stsdas task wfixup to interpolate ( in the x - direction ) over bad pixels as identified in the data quality files .
we also used the stsdas task warmpix to correct consistently warm pixels in the data , using the most recent warm pixel tables .
the stsdas task crrej was used to combine the two 160 second exposures .
this step corrects most of the pixels affected by cosmic rays in the combined image . in general , a few cosmic rays remain uncorrected , mostly when the same pixel was hit in both exposures .
also , a small number of hot pixels remain uncorrected because they are not listed even in the most recent warm pixel tables .
we corrected these with the iraf task cosmicrays , setting the `` threshold '' and `` fluxratio '' parameters to values selected by a careful comparison of the images before and after correction , to ensure that only questionable pixels were replaced .
the rest of the reduction was done with the standard wfpc2 pipeline tasks using the best reference files available .
the lrf exposures were flat - fielded using the narrow - band f656n and f673n ( whichever was closer in wavelength ) flat fields .
we also created mosaiced f555w and f814w images with the iraf / stsdas task wmosaic .
color composite mosaics of these images , which show the environment around the nuclei , and tidal tails in some systems , are displayed in figure [ f : mosaic ] .
the photometric calibration , and conversion to johnson @xmath6- and @xmath7-bands was performed according to guidelines in @xcite .
a @xmath10-correction has not been applied to any of our measurements . since the throughput of the narrow - band filters does not vary much at the wavelengths of the lines , it was possible to calibrate the line fluxes by assuming zero width for the lines ( monochromatic ) .
we used the iraf / stsdas synphot task bandpar to compute the conversion from counts sec@xmath4 to ergs sec@xmath4 @xmath11 .
the results were the same within errors to those produced by the synphot task calcpar . using the known relative orientation of the various chips on wfpc2 , we rotated the chips which contained the line emission and the pc - chip @xmath6 and @xmath7 images to the same orientation .
we used stars in the images to register the frames .
the final emission - line images were constructed by accounting for the different scales of images on various chips ( usually the pc chip and wf2 chip ) , and scaling down the @xmath6- and @xmath7-band images to the expected count levels corresponding to the wavelength and band of the line image , with the help of the wfpc2 exposure time calculator .
we then combined the broad - band images by taking their geometric mean and performed a final adjustment to this combined continuum image by selecting areas well outside emission - line regions ( with pure stellar emission ) and comparing fluxes in corresponding areas in the continuum and line images .
finally , we subtracted the scaled continuum image from the line image .
using the combination of @xmath6 and @xmath7 images eliminates the extinction terms in the case of foreground extinction , as explained in detail by @xcite . in some cases ,
the residual image shows negative pixels , which are most likely due to strong color gradients near the nuclei .
we estimate that the final uncertainty in the line fluxes is no better than 50% , based on varying the scaling of the continuum image within acceptable limits and comparing the derived total line fluxes .
color index images were created by dividing the f555w image by the f814w image , taking the logarithm of the result , and correcting for differences in the color terms , using the synthetic calibration from @xcite . for our new imagery ( i.e. , all systems except ngc 4038/39 , ngc 3921 , and ngc 7252 ) , many regions in the raw color index images are of low signal - to - noise .
we therefore constructed smoothed color index maps using an adaptive filtering procedure , as described by @xcite , where areas with lower signal - to - noise ratios were smoothed by a larger boxcar .
these images were then masked so as to only show areas with adequate signal - to - noise ( signal - to - noise greater than two in both @xmath6- and @xmath7-images after being smoothed with an 11@xmath911 pixel boxcar median filter ) .
the resulting smoothed color index images , together with the unsmoothed broad - band images and h@xmath0 + [ ] images , are shown in figures [ f : n4038][f : n7252 ] .
in the following we give a brief description of each system , based on figures [ f : n4038][f : n7252 ] , together with a few references to earlier work .
we use a hubble constant of @xmath12 throughout this paper .
perhaps the best - known system in the sequence is the antennae .
we use the spectacular _ hst _ @xmath13 , and h@xmath0 images of this system from @xcite ( @xcite ; see also @xcite and figure [ f : mosaic ] ) .
these images show the chaotic dust lanes and prevalent star formation in the interface between the two galaxies .
they also reveal the redder color of the underlying population in the bulge component of each galaxy .
the focus of the @xcite papers was on the abundant young star clusters which have apparently formed as the result of the interaction of the two galaxies .
the properties and evolution of such clusters in a merger event have been discussed extensively in a series of papers by whitmore and his collaborators ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the nuclear regions of merging galaxies are potential formation sites of new super star clusters @xcite .
we instead investigate the morphology and star formation activity in the central few hundred parsecs .
the nuclear region of the northern component of the antennae , ngc4038 , is bracketed by star clusters in the @xmath6 and @xmath7 images .
the position of the nucleus is most likely near the knot `` j '' in the classification scheme of @xcite , and close to the nuclear position identified in the radio continuum by @xcite ( @xcite ; using the radio continuum data of @xcite @xcite ) and in the near - infrared by @xcite . in our i - band image , this is located near the center of the frame displayed in fig . [
f : n4038 ] .
there we see an elongated ring - like structure , with an axis ratio of about 0.3 and a diameter of about 25 ( 260 pc ) , pointing north - northeast .
the coordinates of the optical knot that we identified as the nucleus of ngc4038 in the wfpc2 images are given in table [ t : sample ] .
they agree with the radio continuum position to within one arcsecond and they are within about 3 arcseconds of the estimated near - infrared position of the nucleus . the absolute accuracy of the coordinates reported in this paper is @xmath11 .
this is the intrinsic accuracy of the _ hst _ guide star coordinate system . the h@xmath0 image ( see fig .
[ f : n4038 ] ) also shows the elongated ring structure with a peak in the north - northeastern corner at the position of the star clusters seen in the @xmath6- and @xmath7-band images .
the @xmath14 colors of the clusters in the ring - like structure vary from 0.4 to 1.0 , while a typical color outside and inside the ring is 1.5 , reaching up to 1.9 in the dust lanes .
most of the dust is concentrated on the southeastern side of the elongated ring - like structure . near - infrared high resolution _
nicmos observations of the nucleus will be reported in a future paper .
they promise to shed more light on the issue of the true location of the nucleus in ngc4038 .
previous ground - based near - infrared imaging @xcite does not have high enough spatial resolution to indicate the exact location of the nucleus .
the nucleus of ngc4039 , the southern component of the antennae , is much easier to recognize in the @xmath6 and @xmath7 images ( see fig .
[ f : n4039 ] ) .
our identified nuclear position ( the position of the optical peak ) in table [ t : sample ] agrees to within about two arcseconds of the estimated nuclear positions from the radio continuum data @xcite and near - infrared data @xcite .
the nucleus is surrounded by dust patches and dust lanes .
there is also a minor peak of h@xmath0 emission at the location of the nucleus , which could be due to continuum subtraction uncertainties .
much more intense h@xmath0 emission is seen in the arm connecting to the nucleus .
the @xmath14 color of the nucleus of ngc4039 is about 1.0 , and the surrounding area has a color around 1.3 , with values of 1.7 in a dusty region close to the nucleus .
neither ngc4038 nor ngc4039 is classified as a seyfert or liner nucleus .
these nuclei are instead hosts of mild starbursts ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
further evidence for the starburst nature of these nuclei comes from x - ray observations with the rosat high - resolution imager @xcite and with chandra @xcite .
the northern x - ray nucleus ( ngc4038 ) has a soft spectrum , which hints at thermal emission and is probably related to a hot wind , whereas the thermal + power - law spectrum of the southern x - ray nucleus ( ngc4039 ) indicates a hot ism and a contribution from x - ray binaries .
the mice is a pair of spiral galaxies with only moderately active nuclei ( classified as liner - type by @xcite ) .
the nucleus of ngc4676a or nuc 1 ( the northern component of the pair ) is covered by dust in our optical @xmath6 and @xmath7 images ( fig .
[ f : n4676n1 ] ) .
this dust is likely associated with the dense edge - on molecular disk imaged in co(1 - 0 ) by @xcite . adopting standard conversion factors
, the observed peak co flux density suggests that the nucleus of ngc 4676a is hidden beneath @xmath15 60 magnitudes of extinction .
just south of the area of heavy dust obscuration near the base of the northern tail is a v - shaped structure ( with the v being sideways and opening to the east , and the tip of the v at r.a .
12@xmath1646@xmath17101 and dec .
@xmath1843550 ) of brighter emission from young stellar clusters near the center of the main body . about 7 ( 3 kpc ) to the south one can see a triangle - shaped structure of young clusters .
the tip of the central v - shaped cluster lies near the peak emission in a ground - based k image ( j. hibbard , unpublished ; see also @xcite @xcite ) , so we assume that the nucleus lies near this position .
the h@xmath0 emission from ngc4676a is weak . in general , the emission is elongated in the north south direction of the main body .
the v - shaped structure has very red @xmath14 colors above 2.2 . perhaps even more surprisingly , the color of the heavily extinguished dust patch near the base of the tail is actually _ bluer _ than its surroundings , having an average @xmath14 value less than 1 .
we interpret this region as scattered light from young stars which are mostly hidden by the dust .
a hint of this young star population is seen in the @xmath6 image ( not shown here ) .
such a young star forming region can be seen even more clearly in the new , deeper acs images of the mice @xcite .
in contrast to the v - shaped structure , the triangle - shaped structure of clusters near the southern end of the main body has bluer colors than its surroundings , with @xmath14 values around 1 or slightly below it . the nucleus is easily identified in ngc4676b or nuc 2 .
it is surrounded by a rather amorphous disk , and a dust lane that seems to wrap around the whole disk , ending near the location of the nucleus ( fig .
[ f : n4676n2 ] ) .
there is a peak of h@xmath0 emission offset by about 02 from the nucleus of ngc4676b , but in general the h@xmath0 emission is weak and patchy .
the nucleus has @xmath14 colors close to 1.3 .
a dust patch near the nucleus has a @xmath14 color as red as 1.7 . the majority of the disk outside the dust lanes and dust patches has a @xmath14 color of 1.21.3 .
the overall appearance of ngc4676b , particularly the well - defined bulge / nucleus , is consistent with it being of an earlier hubble - type than its interacting partner , ngc4676a @xcite .
this is the third most distant system in the toomre sequence , and the main bodies of both galaxies fit within the pc chip of the wfpc2 .
ngc7592a or nuc 1 , further to the west , has an active seyfert 2 nucleus , whereas ngc7592b or nuc 2 is classified as a starbursting system @xcite .
ngc7592a has a much better defined nucleus or bulge than ngc7592b , consistent with the suggestion of @xcite , who argue that ngc7592a is of an earlier hubble - type than ngc7592b .
@xcite claim that ngc7592a is seen almost face - on , because of its roundish appearance in ground - based optical and @xmath10-band images .
if so , this galaxy appears to possess a bar - like structure in the bulge , although the bar classification is uncertain due to patchy emission and one - sided dust .
similarly , @xcite argued that ngc7592b is more highly inclined to the line - of - sight .
this , together with its later hubble - type , explains why no clear nucleus is seen in this system .
a comparison to the ground - based @xmath10-band image of @xcite suggests that the nucleus of ngc7592b lies near the center of the ring - like structure of bright clumps seen in figure [ f : n7592 ] .
we are not able to identify any specific clump with the nucleus .
the h@xmath0 image shows abundant emission around the nucleus and the `` bar '' of ngc7592a , and emission from the clumps in the ring of ngc7592b , with a strong central depression in emission .
the nucleus of ngc7592a has blue colors with @xmath14 around 0.8 , contrasting to a dust lane lying on one side of the bar with a @xmath14 color close to 2.0 .
the southern side of the ring structure in ngc7592b has very blue colors down to @xmath14 of 0.3 , but there is a region of red colors of @xmath14 up to 1.9 in the northern part of the ring .
although there is dust visible at that location as well , the red color may suggest that the underlying red nucleus lies at this location .
this is the most distant system in our sample at @xmath19 = 122 mpc .
the location of ngc7764a in the toomre sequence , among galaxies with clearly separate nuclei ( fig .
[ f : mosaic ] ) suggests that toomre thought the nuclei of the two systems were still distinct .
however , our _ hst _ images ( figure [ f : n7764a ] ) do not obviously support the presence of two distinct nuclei .
future nicmos near - infrared data will be critical in identifying the likely remains of the interacting galaxies .
for now we only identify one main component from which both the tails are emanating .
there is also a barred spiral galaxy , presumably at a similar redshift , displaced about 40 ( 23.7 kpc in projected distance ) to the southeast of the main system ( imaged on one of our wf chips , see fig .
[ f : mosaic ] ) , and a third system with apparent tidal streamers displaced about 40 to the northwest , just outside our pc image .
our pc image reveals a shred or linear feature about 7 ( 4.1 kpc ) to the northwest of the main body of ngc7764a .
about a dozen bright , blue ( @xmath20 0.60.8 ) star clusters lie within this filament . between this filament and the center of fig .
[ f : n7764a ] is a very bright , very blue ( @xmath20 0.22 ) cluster .
this cluster has associated h@xmath0 emission with a``head - tail '' morphology , with the cluster at the `` head '' , and the `` tail '' pointing to the north - northeast .
following the `` head '' towards the center of the image in fig .
[ f : n7764a ] , there is a string of regions , crossed by dust lanes .
the centralmost region is weaker than the regions to its northwest and southeast , and is associated with two adjacent bright optical clusters .
these two clusters lie near the region of very red colors in the @xmath14 map , with the reddest region ( @xmath202.4 ) associated with the eastern cluster .
this strong dust concentration may indicate that this is the location of one of the nuclei .
the western clump of the double cluster is bluer ( @xmath20 1.5 ) and brighter .
there are more bright hii regions about 3 ( 1.8 kpc ) to the northeast of the double cluster , associated with another bright star cluster embedded in dust .
further to the east of this is an amorphous luminous region with rather blue colors ( @xmath20 0.60.8 ) .
the northern component of this interacting galaxy pair , ngc6621 , has a dusty central region punctuated by patchy star clusters and ionized gas emission ( fig .
[ f : n6621 ] ) .
two major dust lanes lead into the central region .
one of them comes in from the northwest , following the long tidal tail at larger radii .
the other dust lane intersects the nuclear region from the north , cutting a bright ridge of emission regions into two parts .
emission is associated with the bright ridge of emission regions seen in the @xmath6 and @xmath7 images , and also with another emission patch across the dust lane coming in from the northwest .
the emission ridge has @xmath14 colors around 1.0 , but in the surrounding dusty area the @xmath14 colors are as red as 2 .
the southwestern emission region across the dust lane from the emission ridge has a blue @xmath14 color of 0.5 .
the nuclear spectrum of ngc6621 has been classified to be of starburst type @xcite .
the ground - based near - infrared data of @xcite show that the nucleus likely lies near the ridge of bright emission seen in our optical images , but it is not possible to constrain the true nuclear location from these images .
ngc6622 has a well - defined nucleus and either a strong stellar bar , or a close to edge - on orientation to the line - of - sight ( fig .
[ f : n6622 ] ) .
the @xmath21-band infrared image of @xcite shows that the outer isophotes are not too far from being circular , making it unlikely that this is an edge - on galaxy .
there is an obvious dust lane on the northern and northeastern side of the galaxy , most likely signifying perturbations caused by ngc6621 .
there is practically no h@xmath0 emission associated with ngc6622 , suggesting that it is an early hubble - type galaxy .
the nucleus and the bar have red @xmath14 colors up to 2.3 .
the typical color in the remainder of the disk is 1.3 .
there is a star forming region in the area between ngc6621 and ngc6622 which has a blue @xmath14 color with typical values around 0.8 ( near the upper right edge of figure [ f : n6622 ] ) .
the second - most distant galaxy of this sample , ngc3509 , falls in the middle of the toomre sequence .
the sketch of this system by @xcite suggests that he envisioned a large tail curving to the northwest and a shorter tail extending to the southwest .
deep ground - based ccd imagery obtained by one of us ( jeh ) suggests that the southeastern feature is not a tail , but rather the bright ridge of an inclined disk .
there is a very bright rectangular - shaped feature at the head of the southeastern feature , directly south of a central bulge ( see also * ? ? ?
* ) , which may have been interpreted as the bulge of the second system .
our hst / wfpc2 broad - band imagery shows that this region resolves into a number of bright , blue stellar associations ( figure [ f : n3509 ] ) , and we believe it is much more likely to be a collection of bright star forming regions within the perturbed disk than the nucleus of a second system .
the extremely blue colors of this region ( @xmath14 colors around 0.5 ; the tip of this region is seen at the bottom center of figure [ f : n3509 ] ) are in spectacular contrast to the rest of the galaxy ( typical @xmath14 values from 1.1 to 1.4 ) , and indicate active star formation . in our images we can clearly identify a single relatively undisturbed nucleus , surrounded by a swirl of dust lanes ( center of figure [ f : n3509 ] ) .
the h@xmath0 image reveals a peculiar double - peaked h@xmath0 structure straddling the nucleus in an orientation which is perpendicular to the main body of the nuclear region .
h@xmath0 emission , indicating ongoing star formation , is also seen in the blue region south of the nucleus . in the absence of an obvious second tidal tail in the ground - based imagery ,
we find little evidence that ngc 3509 is the obvious result of a major disk - disk merger .
it may instead be the result of a minor merger , or an ongoing interaction with a smaller companion . in support of the minor merger hypothesis ,
we note the appearance of a roughly circular diffuse red concentration just to the north of the nucleus ( 12 @xmath1 6 kpc ; see fig .
[ f : mosaic ] , just off of the pc chip ) which could be the remains of a smaller galaxy . in support of the interaction hypothesis , on a deep r - band ccd image taken by one of us ( jeh )
we note the presence of a compact object lying @xmath1 2 towards southeast , along the minor axis of this system .
this possible companion also has faint low surface brightness features pointing both toward and away from ngc 3509 .
the southeastern component of ngc520 is hidden behind a prominent and intricate dust lane ( figure [ f : n520n1 ] ) .
this dust is likely associated with the dense edge - on molecular disk imaged in co ( 10 ) by @xcite and @xcite . adopting standard conversion factors
, the observed peak co flux density suggests that the nucleus of ngc 520 is hidden beneath @xmath22300 magnitudes of extinction .
it is thus not surprising that the position of the primary nucleus is impossible to determine from our data .
high - resolution future nicmos observations may point out where this nucleus lies , but based on earlier ground - based near - infrared images ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) the nucleus likely lies in the center of the heaviest dust absorption .
radio continuum images ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) show a disk - like morphology coincident with the co disk , suggesting on - going star formation within the central molecular disk .
practically no h@xmath0 emission is seen in our h@xmath0 image at the position of the primary nucleus .
red @xmath14 colors are seen along most of the primary nucleus .
however , at the location of the most dust - affected regions , as seen in the @xmath7 image , we see relatively blue colors of 0.8 in the color index image . again , as in the case of ngc4676a , we interpret this as scattering of emission from young stars , hinted at in the @xmath6-band image ( not shown here ) . the secondary , northwestern nucleus ( fig .
[ f : n520n2 ] ) comes presumably from an earlier hubble - type disk galaxy that is now embedded within an extended atomic gas disk associated with the primary galaxy @xcite .
the secondary nucleus is very well defined , although its surrounding disk seems to have been mostly disrupted in the merger , and probably contributes now to the extended optical tails .
the only significant h@xmath0 emission near the secondary nucleus is in clumps within 1 ( 150 pc ) , and displaced to the northwest .
the secondary nucleus appears to have a bluish color , with @xmath14 of 0.6 .
this nucleus is observed to be in a post - starburst phase @xcite .
the @xmath14 color towards the northwest of the nucleus has bluish values around 0.8 , but dust reddens the color to 1.2 at about 3 ( 450 pc ) southeast of the nucleus .
consistent with its classification as a fairly advanced merger system , only one galaxy body is evident in ngc2623 ( fig .
[ f : n2623 ] ) . again , based on the high spatial resolution optical _ hst _ images it is impossible to tell the exact location of the nucleus or nuclei .
a comparison to the @xmath23 nicmos images published by @xcite suggests that the position of the brightest optical peak in the center of the main body of ngc2623 is the true position of the nucleus , near j2000.0 coordinates of r.a.=8@xmath1638@xmath17241 and dec.=25@xmath2445@xmath25166 .
this nucleus is classified as a liner by @xcite and @xcite .
dust surrounds the nucleus mostly on the southeastern , northern , and northwestern sides , although numerous dust lanes criss - cross the whole nuclear region ( see fig .
[ f : n2623 ] ) .
a study by @xcite confirms the coalescence of two galaxies . based on their near - infrared observations ,
they conclude that the merger is complete , because only one nucleus is visible ( which is surrounded by a single , symmetric nuclear region ) .
this impression is confirmed by co observations , which reveal a single centrally concentrated compact molecular disk with simple rotational kinematics @xcite .
there are also numerous young star clusters scattered around the main body and the surrounding shreds .
most of the h@xmath0 emission comes from a disk around the nuclear position and from a location north of the nucleus , but also from a position in the dust patch southeast of the nucleus .
the nucleus has a very red @xmath14 color at 2.5 , consistent with the reddish near - infrared colors found for the nucleus by @xcite .
the red near - infrared @xmath26 color , together with a relatively large co absorption index value @xcite suggest that there has been a recent starburst in the nuclear region .
the red colors continue for about 2 ( 720 pc ) to the north and northwest .
the main body of ngc2623 has @xmath14 colors close to 1.0 or just below it .
our optical _ hst _
images show one obvious nucleus located in the center of figure [ f : n3256 ] ( see also @xcite ) .
this nucleus is surrounded by a relatively symmetric spiral morphology .
near - infrared , radio continuum , and x - ray observations ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) have discovered a second nucleus about 5 ( 885 pc ) south of the primary nucleus ( marked with an `` x '' in fig . [
f : n3256 ] ) , presumably hidden beneath the dark ( red ) dust feature directly south of the primary nucleus in the @xmath14 image of fig .
[ f : n3256 ] ( see also @xcite ) .
we do not see an optical source at the position of the second near - infrared , radio , and x - ray source .
our data therefore do not shed any new light on the nature of this source .
neither nucleus shows any evidence of being active . studying the question of how many nuclei exist in this system ( even three nuclei
have been suggested by @xcite ) , would benefit from a detailed dynamical simulation of this merger system .
the measurements for ngc3256 in this paper refer only to the one nucleus we see in our wfpc2 images .
archival nicmos near - infrared images suggest that the position of the primary nucleus is close to the location of the brightest emission in our f814w image @xcite .
however , the optical _ hst _ images alone only show that this position is part of a ring - like structure , and there is nothing noticeably different about this location other than that it is the brightest clump in the image .
other bright regions are likely to be young star clusters or globular clusters , as reported by @xcite . the h@xmath0 emission is extended and follows the spiral structure , but the brightest emission occurs at the position of the primary nucleus .
most previous studies regard this nucleus to be of starburst type , although @xcite were unable to resolve its true nature .
while the primary nucleus has a blue @xmath14 color near 0.7 , the dusty region covering the secondary nucleus to the south of the primary nucleus has a @xmath14 color of 2.5 or redder .
in contrast ,
the spiral arms visible in the @xmath6 and @xmath7 images have a blue @xmath14 color between 0.5 and 1.0 .
only one nucleus is visible in ngc3921 ( figure [ f : n3921 ] ) .
this galaxy is a post - merger system that has developed an elliptical - like central region ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , although numerous dust lanes still criss - cross this area ( see fig .
[ f : n3921 ] ) .
the evidence for a recent merger can be seen in the outer region where tails and plumes prevail @xcite .
several compact open star clusters or globular clusters can also be seen in the _ hst _ optical images kindly provided by b. whitmore ( see also * ? ? ?
the h@xmath0 emission is centered in a disk around the nucleus , but extends to larger radii .
the nucleus is classified as a liner by @xcite and @xcite .
it lies in a location where the @xmath14 color gradient is very steep as seen in the @xmath14 image , but the nucleus itself has normal values of @xmath14 around 1.1 . to the southwest of the nucleus
the @xmath14 color increases to @xmath1 1.8 at about 05 ( 190 pc ) distance from the nucleus , and then decreases and stays around 1.11.2 on that side of the galaxy . to the northeast
, the @xmath14 color decreases to values as low as 0.7 at about 05 from the nucleus , then stays around 0.9 for another 15 ( 570 pc ) .
dust extinction is at least partly responsible for this effect .
@xcite noticed that the nucleus lies substantially off - centered from the outer stellar isophotes of the main body .
we use the _ hst _ @xmath6 and @xmath7 images from @xcite to study the most advanced merger in the toomre sequence .
the remnant from the merger is probably between 0.5 and 1 gyrs old @xcite .
it has a single nucleus and is characterized by a @xmath27 profile typical of elliptical galaxies @xcite .
it was quite a surprise , therefore , when _
_ revealed a central spiral disk ( @xcite and fig .
[ f : n7252 ] ) .
the disk extends to a radius of about 6 ( 1.8kpc ) , and is therefore coincident with the molecular disk imaged by @xcite . our new
_ h@xmath0 image of this galaxy shows the disk to be actively forming stars , while the @xmath14 color map shows dust to be intertwined between the arms . in light of the results from recent hydrodynamical simulations @xcite , and the observation of tidal gas streaming back into the central regions of this remnant from the tidal tails @xcite , it seems likely that this central disk structure results from the re - accretion of tidally raised gas into the now - relaxed central potential .
the nucleus appears resolved , and is very bright , as we show in section [ s : mergerstage ] .
h@xmath0 emission largely follows the spiral arms , although there appears to be a central h@xmath0 source as well .
however , our continuum subtraction , unfortunately , is uncertain in this area due to an optically very bright nucleus .
similarly , the central @xmath14 color is difficult to determine reliably due to the same problem , but the color there appears to be close to 1.3 , whereas the surrounding spirals have @xmath14 colors as blue as 0.5 . recent x - ray observations with asca revealed x - ray emission that can be described by a two - component model @xcite , with soft emission ( kt = 0.72 kev ) , and a hard component ( kt @xmath28 5.1 kev ) .
the hard component might indicate the existence of nuclear activity or even an intermediate mass black hole .
we performed aperture photometry of the toomre sequence galaxies to better understand the evolution of the nuclear region of merging galaxies . because the isophotes in the nuclear region of merging galaxies are highly twisted , we did not attempt to fit ellipses and obtain radial surface brightness profiles .
instead we performed aperture photometry within circular apertures , with radii of 100 pc and 1 kpc .
the lower value was dictated by the smallest resolvable physical scale in the most distant of our sample galaxies , whereas the upper value is somewhat arbitrary , but set because of our emphasis on the properties of the nuclear region .
we have already characterized the morphology of the nuclear region at _ hst _ resolution in the individual galaxies above .
here we only report on the bulk photometric nuclear properties of each identified merger component galaxy .
visual inspection of the images quickly reveals that none of the galaxies in the sample possess an extremely bright , point - like active nucleus .
based on spectroscopic evidence , as cited in section [ s : images ] , the only mildly active nuclei are in ngc7592a ( seyfert 2 ) , ngc4676 nuc 1 and nuc 2 ( liner ) , ngc2623 ( liner ) , and ngc3921 ( liner ) .
it is difficult to assess what the exact contribution of the nucleus to the integrated luminosities is .
the photometric measurements , converted to luminosity densities , are presented in figures [ f : iphot][f : haphot ] .
the `` merger stage '' , plotted along the x - axis , refers to the original order of the sequence given by @xcite , where 1 corresponds to ngc4038/39 ( the earliest merger stage ) and 11 to ngc7252 ( the latest merger stage ) .
the exact correspondence is given in the figure caption to figure [ f : iphot ] .
our observations do not suggest an obvious reordering of this sequence , although we are hampered by our inability to unambiguously identify all of the putative nuclei .
our tentative impression is that ngc7764a ( merger stage=4 ) may be interacting with the disturbed galaxy lying off of our image , in which case it belongs near the beginning of the sequence .
and ngc3509 ( merger stage=6 ) is not an obvious merger at all .
however , we will await nicmos observations of this sequence before reaching any firm conclusions on this matter .
we note that none of our conclusions will be affected if these two systems move earlier along or off of the sequence .
apart from the large scatter in figure [ f : iphot ] we see that the three latest merger stage systems ( ngc3256 , ngc3921 , and ngc7252 ) have the highest intrinsic luminosity densities .
this is true for both apertures that we used ( 100 pc and 1 kpc ) .
the range of luminosity density within 100 pc corresponds to a factor of more than 300 . to a large extent
this reflects the varying dust extinction in the central region , but partly also the morphology of the nuclear region ( well - defined nuclei are bright , whereas components with no clearly recognizable nucleus are faint ) . with only @xmath14 colors available
it is difficult to make a meaningful estimate of dust extinction .
but , for example , figure [ f : viphot ] shows that in ngc 2623 the integrated @xmath14 color is very red within a 100 pc radius aperture , with a value around 2.2 . assuming that the true @xmath14 color is 1.4 ( a more typical value seen in the same figure ) , would imply almost @xmath29 = 2 mag of extinction with a typical extinction law of a@xmath30 @xcite . since the extinction in the @xmath10-band is only one tenth of that in the @xmath6-band ,
our future nicmos images offer some hope of revealing the true location of the nucleus . while the @xmath14 colors for the 100 pc aperture attain values anywhere between 0.8 and 2.4 , the majority of the nuclei have rather typical colors for the centers of spiral nuclei and elliptical galaxies , ranging from 1.2 to 1.5 ( cf .
, e.g. , * ? ? ?
the presumably latest stage merger , ngc7252 , has colors even bluer than normal ellipticals .
however , the morphology of the dust lanes we see in the images suggests that dust obscuration is likely to be significant in many systems of the toomre sequence .
the h@xmath0 + [ ] luminosities ( figure [ f : haphot ] ) show a marginal trend of increasing luminosities towards the late - stage mergers , most obviously in the largest 1 kpc aperture . however , the scatter is large , and based on the sample of 15 nuclei it is impossible to establish any definite trends .
since mergers are expected to bring material into the center of galaxies and generate star formation there , we also study the nuclear concentration of light and line emission along the merging sequence .
we measure the nuclear concentration quantitatively by taking the ratio of the luminosities within 100 pc to that within 1 kpc , for both the @xmath7-band ( figure [ f : irat ] ) and the line emission ( figure [ f : harat ] ) .
we discuss the meaning of these ratios briefly in the following section .
the nuclear morphologies and central concentration are expected to be strongly affected by the timing and intensity of induced inflows and star formation during the merger .
numerical models of interacting galaxies have illustrated one mechanism by which interactions trigger these inflows and nuclear activity . shortly after the galaxies first collide
, the self - gravity of each disk amplifies the collisional perturbation into a growing @xmath31 mode @xcite . depending on the structural properties of each galaxy
, this mode can take the form of a strong bar , prominent spiral arms , or a pronounced oval distortion @xcite .
these non - axisymmetric structures drive shocks in the interstellar medium of the galaxies , leading to a spatial offset between the gaseous and stellar components which robs the gas of angular momentum , and can drive it inwards well before the galaxies ultimately merge @xcite .
the onset , strength , and duration of starbursts in interacting pairs can vary widely , depending on the properties of the host galaxies .
ultimately , however , any dynamical stability provided by the presence of a central bulge or diminished disk surface density will be overwhelmed by the strong gravitational torques and dissipative shocks during the final merging of the pair , at which point gaseous inflow and central activity should be ubiquitous .
once the coalescence of the galaxies is complete , the gravitational potential settles down and gas can resettle into nuclear and/or spatially extended disks , supporting an extended period of relatively quiescent star formation .
based on these kinds of models , we might expect to see an evolutionary trend for the nuclear properties of the toomre sequence , from quiescent star formation in the early stages of the sequence to strong nuclear activity in the late stages .
however , we see little evidence for such trends in the morphology , luminosity density , or colors of the stellar component , or in the morphology or intensity of the ionized gas emission , apart possibly from the fact that the latest - stage systems have some of the highest broad - band luminosity densities and hints of starbursting central gaseous disk structures .
this last suggestion is further strengthened by the trend towards bluer colors among the three latest - stage merger systems in figure [ f : viphot ] . a trend towards bluer colors
was also seen in a study of merger remnants by @xcite .
furthermore , the latest - stage merger systems have some of the highest nuclear h@xmath0 luminosities ( figure [ f : haphot ] ) and possess some of the largest concentrations of light in the central region ( figure [ f : irat ] ) .
such a concentration is also seen to a certain extent in the h@xmath0 + [ ] emission ( figure [ f : harat ] ) .
are our observations of the toomre nuclei consistent with the broad picture of interaction - induced nuclear activity in galaxies evidenced in numerical simulations ? in a broad sense , yes , although this consistency is mainly due to the variety of dynamical responses available to interacting systems .
the late stage mergers seem to have settled down , showing evidence for nuclear emission - line disks ( ngc2623 , ngc3256 , ngc3921 , and ngc7252 ) , more concentrated luminosity profiles and a trend towards bluer colors .
toomre sequence objects at earlier stages show very diverse properties , with no clear trends along the sequence .
however , selecting a merging sequence based largely on the large - scale morphology of the tidal tails biases the sample towards a specific type of interaction prograde interactions between disk galaxies but not a specific type of disk galaxy .
the galaxies which make up the toomre sequence likely possess a variety of structural properties so that there is no one - to - one correspondence between observed merger stage and nuclear morphology and activity .
put differently , the toomre sequence is _ not _ a true evolutionary sequence on anything but the largest scales .
instead , it is composed of a variety of galaxies progressing down varied paths of interaction - driven activity . expecting to discern
a clear trend in nuclear properties is likely a naive hope . aside from the variety of physical conditions sampled by the toomre nuclei , searching for trends along the toomre sequence
is also hampered by a number of observational concerns .
first , the orientation of the galaxies with respect to the line - of - sight and to the orbital plane of the merger complicates the interpretation of the images .
second , extinction has a large effect on the observed morphologies , colors , and luminosities , as shown in section [ s : mergerstage ] ( e.g. , ngc520 nuc 1 and ngc4676 nuc 1 ) . in this context
, we hope to improve upon the interpretation of the galaxy morphologies along the sequence through an analysis of nicmos images of the entire toomre sequence
. these images will suffer from much less extinction , and should also reveal the isophotes of the stellar population more clearly , thereby helping us in assessing the inclination of the merger components .
the optical images shown here clearly demonstrate that dust in merging galaxies , even on small scales resolved by the _ hst _
, is not patchy enough to enable the identification of the true nuclei in optical bands . in summary ,
these high - resolution wfpc2 images of the toomre sequence have given us a detailed view of the nuclear regions of interacting and merging galaxies .
we have characterized the broad - band and emission - line morphologies of each member of the sequence , and measured the colors and luminosity densities of the nuclei .
we find little evidence for clear trends in nuclear properties along the merger sequence , other than a suggestive rise in the nuclear luminosity density in the most evolved members of the sequence .
the lack of clear trends in nuclear properties is likely due both to the effects of obscuration and geometry , as well as the physical variety of galaxies involved in the toomre sequence . in subsequent papers
we will combine our optical imaging with nicmos imaging and stis spectroscopy of the toomre nuclei to give a detailed picture of the physical conditions in interacting and merging galaxies .
we are grateful to dr .
brad whitmore for providing us with fully reduced hst wfpc2 @xmath6 and @xmath7 images of ngc3921 , ngc4038/39 , and ngc7252 .
we thank dr .
nick scoville for providing us with his adaptive filtering code .
we are grateful to zoltan levay for help with the mosaiced images , and thank dr .
william keel for providing us with a copy of his hst image of ngc6621/22 for help in planning our observations .
we thank the anonymous referee for constructive comments that improved the clarity of the paper .
support for proposal # 8669 was provided by nasa through a grant from the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc .
, under nasa contract nas 5 - 26555 .
the research described in this paper was carried out , in part , by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , and was sponsored by the national aeronautics and space administration.jcm acknowledges support by the nsf through grant ast-9876143 and by a research corporation cottrell scholarship .
this research has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration .
the leda database , operated by centre de recherche astronomique de lyon , is kindly acknowledged . | we report on the properties of nuclear regions in the toomre sequence of merging galaxies , based on imaging data gathered with the _ hubble space telescope _ wfpc2 camera .
we have imaged the 11 systems in the proposed evolutionary merger sequence in the f555w and f814w broad - band filters , and in h@xmath0 + [ ] narrow - band filters .
the broad - band morphology of the nuclear regions varies from non - nucleated starburst clumps through dust - covered nuclei to a nucleated morphology .
there is no unambiguous trend in the morphology with merger stage .
the emission - line morphology is extended beyond the nucleus in most cases , but centrally concentrated ( within 1 kpc ) emission - line gas can be seen in the four latest - stage merger systems .
we have quantified the intrinsic luminosity densities and colors within the inner 100 pc and 1 kpc of each identified nucleus .
we find little evidence for a clear trend in nuclear properties along the merger sequence , other than a suggestive rise in the nuclear luminosity density in the most evolved members of the sequence .
the lack of clear trends in nuclear properties is likely due both to the effects of obscuration and geometry , as well as the physical variety of galaxies included in the toomre sequence . |
in @xcite , a proof of a formula for the restriction of a discrete series representation ( see @xcite ) of a connected , linear , semisimple lie group to a maximal compact subgroup is given .
this formula was first conjectured by blattner .
we recall the formula and its context briefly , from the point of view of root system combinatorics . throughout the paper
, @xmath3 denotes a semisimple lie algebra over @xmath4 with a fixed cartan subalgebra @xmath5 .
let @xmath6 denote the corresponding root system with weyl group @xmath7 .
choose a set , @xmath8 , of positive roots and let @xmath9 be the simple roots .
let @xmath10 .
we assume that there exists a function @xmath11 such that if @xmath12 and @xmath13 then @xmath14 .
this map provides a @xmath15-gradation on @xmath16 .
we set : @xmath17 given @xmath18 , set @xmath19={\alpha}(h ) x \ ; \forall h \in { \mathfrak}h \}$ ] .
let @xmath20 and + @xmath21 .
then , @xmath22 will be a reductive symmetric subalgebra of @xmath3 with @xmath23 the corresponding cartan decomposition of @xmath3 .
as defined , @xmath5 is a cartan subalgebra for @xmath22 so rank @xmath22 = rank @xmath3 .
each equal rank symmetric pair corresponds to at least one @xmath15-gradation in this manner , and conversely .
we shall refer to the elements of @xmath24 ( resp .
@xmath25 ) as compact ( resp .
noncompact ) .
the compact roots are a sub - root system of @xmath16 .
let @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 , and @xmath29 .
set @xmath30 where @xmath31 and @xmath32 .
if there is no subscript , we mean @xmath33 .
we remark that the @xmath15-gradation @xmath34 is determined by its restriction to @xmath35 .
furthermore , to any set partition @xmath36 there exists a unique @xmath15-gradation on @xmath16 such that @xmath37 and @xmath38 .
we denote the killing form on @xmath3 by @xmath39 , which restricts to a nondegenerate form on @xmath5 . using this form
we may define @xmath40 by @xmath41 ( @xmath42 ) , which allows us to identify @xmath43 with @xmath44 . under this identification ,
we have @xmath45 , where @xmath46 is the simple coroot corresponding to @xmath47 . for each @xmath18 , set @xmath48 ( for @xmath49 ) to be the reflection through the hyperplane defined by @xmath50 . for @xmath51 ,
let @xmath52 , be the simple reflection defined by @xmath53 .
define @xmath54 to be the set of simple roots in @xmath55 and let @xmath56 denote the weyl group generated the reflections defined by @xmath54 .
let @xmath57 be the parabolic subgroup of @xmath7 defined by the compact simple @xmath3-roots .
note that @xmath58 , but we do not have equality in general . for @xmath59 , set @xmath60 .
note that there is also a length function on @xmath7 ( denoted @xmath61 ) but @xmath62 refers to @xmath56 .
a weight @xmath49 is said to be @xmath22-dominant ( resp .
@xmath3-dominant ) if @xmath63 for all @xmath64 ( resp @xmath65 ) .
a weight @xmath66 is @xmath3-regular ( resp .
@xmath22-regular ) if @xmath67 for all @xmath18 ( resp .
@xmath68 ) .
the integral weight lattice for @xmath3 is denoted by the set + @xmath69 similarly we let @xmath70 denote the abelian group of integral weights for @xmath22 corresponding to @xmath54 .
let the set of @xmath22- and @xmath3-dominant integral weights be denoted by @xmath71 and @xmath72 respectively .
to each element @xmath73 ( resp .
@xmath72 ) , let @xmath74 ( resp .
@xmath75 ) denote the finite dimensional representation of @xmath22 ( resp .
@xmath3 ) with highest weight @xmath76 .
next , let @xmath77 denote the @xmath78-partition function .
that is , if @xmath79 then @xmath80 is the number of ways of writing @xmath81 as a sum of noncompact positive roots .
put other way : there exists an algebraic torus , @xmath82 , such that to each @xmath83 there corresponds a linear character of @xmath82 , denoted @xmath84 , with differential @xmath85 .
thus , @xmath86 defines the coefficients of the product : @xmath87 finally , we define the blattner formula . for @xmath88 , @xmath89
it is convenient to introduce the notation @xmath90 for @xmath59 and @xmath49 .
it is easy to see that @xmath91 .
since for all @xmath92 there exists @xmath93 such that @xmath94 , we will assume that @xmath95 .
historically , blattner s formula arises out of the study of the discrete series and its generalizations ( see @xcite ) .
[ thm_hs ] assume @xmath96 is @xmath3-dominant and @xmath3-regular .
then , @xmath97 is the multiplicity of the finite dimensional @xmath22-representation , @xmath74 , in the discrete series representation of @xmath0 with harish - chandra parameter @xmath98 . in this paper
, we do not impose the @xmath3-dominant regular condition on @xmath99 .
this is natural from the point of view of representation theory as it is related to the coherent continuation of the discrete series ( see @xcite , @xcite and @xcite ) . from our point of view , the goal is to understand the blattner formula in as combinatorial fashion as possible .
thus it is convenient to introduce the following generating function : for @xmath95 we define the formal series : @xmath100 the main result of this paper is proposition [ prop_main ] of section [ sec_main ] , which states : for @xmath95 , @xmath101 where @xmath102 denotes the character of @xmath74 . of particular interest
are the cases where @xmath103 , which we address in section [ sec_sym ] . from the point of view of representation theory
these include , for example , the holomorphic and borel - de siebenthal discrete series ( see @xcite ) .
more recently , the latter has been addressed in @xcite .
the blattner formula for the case of @xmath104 is often particularly difficult to compute explicitly when compared to , say , the cases corresponding to holomorphic discrete series .
the @xmath105 case corresponds to the _ generic _ discrete series of the corresponding real semisimple lie group . in section [ sec_g2 ]
we explore this situation in some detail for the lie algebra @xmath2 .
finally , in light of theorem [ thm_hs ] one may observe that if @xmath95 and @xmath99 is @xmath3-dominant regular then @xmath106 .
our goal is to investigate the positivity of blattner s formula using combinatorial methods .
of particular interest is the positivity when we relax the @xmath3-dominance condition on @xmath99 .
some results in this direction are suggested by the recent work of penkov and the second author ( see @xcite ) . in section [ sec_sym ]
we prove the existence of a skew symmetry of blattner s formula that exists whenever @xmath103 .
thus , the condition that @xmath104 is necessary for @xmath106 for all @xmath95 and @xmath83 . in the situation where @xmath107 we introduce the following : we say that a semisimple lie algebra is @xmath108-positive if the blattner formula corresponding to the @xmath15-gradation with @xmath104 has the property that : @xmath109 the terminology stems from the fact that a simple lie algebra is @xmath108-positive if and only if the coefficients of @xmath110 are non - negative for all @xmath95 .
since the character of @xmath74 can be written as a non - negative integer combination of characters of @xmath82 , we have that @xmath110 has non - negative integer coefficients if @xmath111 does .
thus the question of @xmath108-positivity reduces to the case of @xmath112 . in section [ sec_positive ]
, it is shown that the only @xmath108-positive simple lie algebras are of type @xmath113 , @xmath114 , @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath117 , @xmath118 and @xmath2 .
we prove this result by examining the coefficients of @xmath111 .
[ prop_main ] for @xmath95 , @xmath119 where @xmath120 denotes the character of @xmath74 . from the definition of blattner s formula we have : @xmath121 first we make the substitution , @xmath122 , and reorganize the sum : @xmath123 as is well known , the character may be expressed using weyl s formula ( see @xcite ) as in the following : @xmath124 the result allows us to compute the blattner formula as follows : @xmath125 let @xmath126 and we obtain : @xmath127 thus for @xmath95 and @xmath83 we have @xmath128 note that the numbers @xmath129 are weight multiplicities for the representation @xmath130 .
the main result of this section is : [ thm_sym ] for @xmath131 : @xmath132 although this is well known to experts , we include our proof as it requires very little technical machinery . for @xmath133 and @xmath49
let @xmath134 .
[ lemma_q ] if @xmath135 then @xmath136 .
it is enough to show @xmath137 which follows from the following calculation : @xmath138 [ lemma_roots ] for all @xmath139 , @xmath140 .
note that @xmath141 is the weyl group of a reductive levi factor @xmath142 of a parabolic subalgebra @xmath143 .
we have a generalized triangular decomposition @xmath144 with @xmath145 .
the noncompact root spaces contained in @xmath146 are positive .
furthermore , all noncompact positive roots spaces are contained in @xmath146 because @xmath147 .
the lie algebra @xmath148 is an @xmath142-module and therefore the weights are preserved by @xmath141 .
it is this fact that implies that @xmath141 takes positive noncompact roots to positive roots .
we now need to show that @xmath141 takes noncompact roots to noncompact roots . for roots @xmath149 and @xmath68
, we have the formula @xmath150 with @xmath151 an integer .
thus , the reflection of a noncompact root across a hyperplane defined by a compact root is noncompact .
the reflections generate @xmath141 .
we now prove the main proposition of this section .
let @xmath131 : @xmath152 by definition , @xmath153 . combining this with the definition of the dot " action
we obtain : @xmath154 next , we use the fact that @xmath155 using lemmas [ lemma_q ] and [ lemma_roots ] . the rest is a calculation .
the following is a complete calculation of @xmath111 for the case of the lie algebra @xmath157 when @xmath104 .
let @xmath158 and @xmath159 be a choice of noncompact simple roots for @xmath2 with @xmath158 long and @xmath159 short .
the compact positive roots are @xmath160 , while the noncompact positive roots are @xmath161 .
denote the @xmath162-partition function by @xmath163 .
we have : @xmath164 let @xmath165 and @xmath166 . thus
, @xmath167 let the simple reflection corresponding to @xmath158 ( resp .
@xmath159 ) be @xmath168 ( resp .
@xmath169 ) .
we have four terms in blattner s formula for @xmath170 : @xmath171 and our goal will be to close the sum @xmath172 .
we will do this by multiplying by @xmath173 and summing over @xmath85 for each of the four terms .
observe that : @xmath174 thus , @xmath175 .
next consider the sum : @xmath176 we make the substitution @xmath177 so that the above sum becomes : @xmath178 thus the above sum is equal to @xmath179 , which we denote by @xmath180 .
similarly , we set @xmath181 and @xmath182 , and @xmath183 .
thus , @xmath184 now we write the above in terms of @xmath185 and @xmath186 .
note that @xmath187 , @xmath188 , @xmath189 , and from these we can easily see : @xmath190 putting everything together we see @xmath191 . or equivalently , if @xmath192 then the value of @xmath193 is the coefficient of @xmath194 in : @xmath195 note that in the latter expression , it is clear that the coefficients are the series expansion are positive .
the positivity of the coefficients of @xmath196 follows from the positivity of the coefficients of @xmath111
. the question of positivity for a general semisimple lie algebra will be addressed in section [ sec_positive ] .
it is important to note that as we change @xmath197 the @xmath111 changes as well .
for example , when @xmath198 , @xmath199 which we can easily see does _ not _ have non - negative integer coefficients .
we leave it as an exercise to the reader to compute @xmath111 when @xmath200 .
the generating function for other @xmath201 involve multiplying the above product by a polynomial in @xmath202 that represents the character of the corresponding irreducible finite dimensional representation of @xmath203 .
one can plot the coefficients of our formal series , as we do next . in all pictures
we have labeled the scale on the axes and normalized the short root ( @xmath159 ) to have length 1 and be positioned at 3 oclock .
the long root @xmath158 is at 10 oclock .
the first two images ( figures 1 and 2 ) are for the case with @xmath104 ( generic ) and correspond to @xmath112 and @xmath76 the highest weight of the standard @xmath204-dimensional representation of @xmath205 .
we also display the same two @xmath76 s in the case when @xmath206 ( borel - de siebenthal ) in figures 3 and 4 .
these latter two figures clearly display a skew - symmetry addressed section [ sec_sym ] .
we have the following : it is a consequence of the main proposition that for any rank @xmath208 simple lie algebra @xmath3 we may express @xmath111 as a rational function in @xmath209 where @xmath210 ( recall that @xmath53 is the @xmath211-simple root for @xmath3 ) . for any @xmath212
, if we set @xmath213 in @xmath111 then the resulting expression is @xmath111 for a semisimple subalgebra of @xmath3 .
it is not hard to see that this subalgebra is the levi factor of the maximal parabolic of @xmath3 corresponding to @xmath214 .
more generally , let @xmath215 .
if we set @xmath216 in @xmath111 for all @xmath217 then the resulting expression is @xmath111 for the levi subalgebra , @xmath218 , of the corresponding parabolic .
note that the terms in the series expansion for @xmath111 for @xmath218 are also terms in the series expansion of @xmath111 for @xmath3 .
thus a negative coefficient in the former implies a negative coefficient in the latter .
the proof of proposition [ prop_seven ] involves a cases - by - case analysis using the main proposition expressing @xmath111 as a product , lemma [ lem_levi ] and the computer algebra package , maple . recall that the @xmath108-positivity of @xmath2 was proved in section [ sec_g2 ] . for @xmath219
, we have : @xmath220 for @xmath221 : @xmath222 and for @xmath223 : @xmath224 the partial fraction on the right of each of these examples establishes that the coefficients are indeed positive .
next we consider @xmath225 where we have a negative result .
first we note : @xmath226 for @xmath225 .
we expand in a formal power series and observe that the coefficient of @xmath227 is @xmath228 .
this means that @xmath108-positivity fails for this example .
we then also see failure of @xmath108-positivity for any simple lie algebra which has @xmath229 as a levi factor of a parabolic .
thus , we exclude all higher rank type a examples as well as @xmath230 ( @xmath231 ) , @xmath232 ( @xmath233 ) , @xmath234 ( @xmath235 ) , @xmath236 , @xmath237 and @xmath238
. now consider @xmath240 : @xmath242 upon expansion we see that the coefficient of @xmath243 is @xmath228 .
thus , we may exclude this and higher rank type @xmath244 examples as they have @xmath245 as the levi factor of a parabolic .
in particular , we may exclude @xmath246 , which is the only type @xmath244 example that has not been excluded yet .
we also may exclude @xmath247 for the same reason .
we must examine @xmath111 for @xmath248 and @xmath249 as these are the only examples not yet addressed .
for @xmath250 ( ie : @xmath251 ) , we have : @xmath252 the coefficients are positive as the above expression is equal to : @xmath253 | let @xmath0 be a connected , semisimple lie group with finite center and let @xmath1 be a maximal compact subgroup .
we investigate a method to compute multiplicities of @xmath1-types in the discrete series using a rational expression for a generating function obtained from blattner s formula .
this expression involves a product with a character of an irreducible finite dimensional representation of @xmath1 and is valid for any discrete series system .
other results include a new proof of a symmetry of blattner s formula , and a positivity result for certain low rank examples .
we consider in detail the situation for @xmath0 of type split @xmath2 .
the motivation for this work came from an attempt to understand pictures coming from blattner s formula , some of which we include in the paper . |
after many years of pure academic research , the casimir effect @xcite is presently of much interest in connection with applications in nanomechanical devices @xcite , noncontact friction @xcite , carbon nanotubes @xcite , bose - einstein condensation @xcite and for constraining predictions of modern unification theories of fundamental interactions @xcite .
these areas of application were made possible by extensive experimental investigation of the casimir force @xcite and the generalization to real materials of field - theoretical methods which were applicable to only idealized boundaries ( see reviews @xcite ) .
the basic theory of the casimir and van der waals forces at nonzero temperature proposed by lifshitz @xcite allows one to calculate all quantities of physical interest using the dielectric permittivity of boundary materials along the imaginary frequency axis .
this theory was originally developed for the configuration of two semispaces and was later extended for any layer structure @xcite . using the proximity force theorem @xcite , lifshitz - type formulas for the configuration of a sphere or a cylinder above a plate were obtained and successfully used for the interpretation of experimental data @xcite . for a long time , the lack of exact results for these configurations made it possible to question the validity of the comparison of experiment and theory based on the proximity force theorem .
recently , however , both the exact analytical @xcite and numerical @xcite results for the casimir force between a sphere ( cylinder ) and a plate were obtained demonstrating that at small @xmath0 the corrections to the proximity force theorem for both configurations are in fact less than @xmath1 ( @xmath0 is the separation between a cylinder or a sphere of radius @xmath2 and a plate ) , i.e. , less than it was supposed in the comparison of experiment with theory .
thus , the use of the proximity force theorem in refs .
@xcite and below is substantiated on the basis of first principles of quantum field theory .
the vital issue in many applications of the casimir effect is how to control the magnitude of the force by changing the parameters of the system . in this respect
the possibility that the casimir force can change sign from attraction to repulsion depending on system geometry is of much importance .
it may be used to prevent collapse of small mechanical elements onto nearby surfaces in nanodevices @xcite .
however , the casimir repulsion has yet to be observed experimentally .
an alternative method to control the magnitude of the casimir force is to change the material properties of the interacting bodies . in ref .
@xcite the casimir force was measured acting between a plate and a sphere coated with a hydrogen - switchable mirror that become transparent upon hydrogenation . despite expectations ,
no significant decrease of the casimir force owing to the increased transparancy of the plates was observed .
the negative result is explained by the lifshitz theory which requires the change of the reflectivity properties within a wide range of frequencies in order to markedly affect the magnitude of the casimir force .
this requirement is not satisfied by the hydrogenation .
all modern experiments on the measurement of the casimir force mentioned above @xcite used metallic test bodies .
metallic surfaces are necessary to reduce and compensate the effects of residual charges and work function differences .
it is , however , hard to modify their reflectivity properties over a sufficiently wide range of frequencies .
the appropriate materials for the control , modification and fine tunning of the casimir force are semiconductors .
the reflectivity properties of semiconductor surfaces can be changed in a wide frequency range by changing the carrier density through the variation of temperature , using different kinds of doping or , alternatively , via the illumination of the surface with laser light . at the same time ,
semiconductor surfaces with reasonably high conductivity avoid accumulation of excess charges and , thus , preserve the advantage of metals .
in addition as semiconductors are the basic fabrication materials for nanotechnology , the use of semiconductor surfaces for the control of the casimir force will lead to many applications .
the modification of the casimir force between a gold coated plate and sphere , attached to the cantilever of an atomic force microscope ( afm ) , through the variation of temperature was considered in ref .
while changing the temperature to modify the carrier density in semiconductors is a good method in theory , it leads @xcite to large systematic errors in the measurement setup using the afm . in ref .
@xcite the casimir force between a gold coated sphere and a single crystal b - doped si plate was measured in high vacuum .
it was found that the force between a metal and a semiconductor decreases with increase of separation more quickly than between two metals . in ref .
@xcite the experimental data for the casimir force between a gold coated sphere and b - doped si plate were compared with two different theoretical computations , one made for the b - doped si used and another one for high - resistivity si .
it was shown that the computation using the tabulated optical data for high - resistivity si is excluded by experiment at 70% confidence while the theoretical results computed for the plate used in experiment are consistent with data . in ref .
@xcite the difference in the casimir forces between a gold coated sphere and two p - doped si plates with different charge - carrier densities was directly measured at a 95% confidence level .
this demonstrates that the change of carrier density due to doping leads to noticeable modification of the casimir force .
the most suitable method to change the carrier density in semiconductors is through the illumination of the surfaces by laser light ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) .
an early attempt to measure the van der waals and the casimir forces between semiconductors and modify them with light was reported in ref .
attractive forces were measured between a glass lens and a si plate and also between the glass lens coated with amorphous si and the si plate . however
, the glass lens is an insulator and therefore the electric forces such as due to work function potential differences could not be controlled .
this might also explain that no force change occured on illumination at separations below 350 nm @xcite where it should have been most pronounced .
the present paper contains the detailed results of our experiments on the modification of the casimir force by the irradiation of a si membrane with laser pulses .
the first observation of this effect at only one absorbed power was briefly reported in ref .
@xcite . here
we report new measurements performed at different absorbed powers and the theoretical analysis on the accuracy of the obtained results and on the comparison of experiment with theory . in our experiments
the carrier density in the si membrane is changed by the incident light , and the difference in the casimir force acting between that membrane and the gold coated sphere in the presence and in the absence of light is measured .
the experimental error of difference force measurements for the different absorbed powers determined at a 95% confidence level varies between 10 to 20% at a separation of 100 nm and increases with the increase of separation .
the measurement data collected at different powers of the incident light at the laboratory temperature @xmath3k were compared with the lifshitz theory at both zero and at laboratory temperatures .
the data are shown to be consistent with theory at laboratory temperature if in the absence of light the static dielectric permittivity of si is assumed to be finite .
the lifshitz theory at laboratory temperature taking account of the dc conductivity of high - resistivity si in the absence of light is excluded experimentally at a 95% confidence level .
thus , our experiments not only demonstrate the modification of the casimir force through the irradiation of a semiconductor surface , but also lead to the important result that the inclusion of zero - frequency conductivity of high - resistivity si in the model of dielectric response results in a contradiction between the lifshitz theory at laboratory temperature and experiment .
this contradiction is caused by different contributions from the reflection of the transverse magnetic mode on a si surface at zero frequency in the absence and in the presence of conductivity .
the obtained conclusion supports recent theoretical results that the inclusion of dielectric dc conductivity for the dielectric - dielectric @xcite and dielectric - metal @xcite configurations at nonzero temperature leads to contradiction between the lifshitz theory and the nernst heat theorem , and thus such inclusion is impermissible . at the same time , the experimental data are shown to be consistent with the lifshitz theory at zero temperature , irrespective of whether the dc conductivity of high - resistivity si is included or not .
the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
ii the experimental setup and sample preparation are described .
iii contains the description of the measurement procedure and obtained experimental results .
this includes the calibration of the setup , the measurement of the lifetime of excited carriers , the measurement of the difference in the casimir force when the light is on and off , and the analysis of the experimental errors . in sec .
iv the experimental results are compared with the theory . here
the difference in the casimir force with and without incident laser light is calculated and the theoretical errors are analyzed . by combining the experimental and theoretical errors , the quantitative measure of agreement between experiment and theory at 95% confidence is presented .
v analyzes the role of the dc conductivity of high - resistivity si in the casimir force .
vi contains our conclusions and discussion .
here we discuss the experimental setup used to demonstrate the modification of the casimir force through the radiation induced change in the carrier density .
the general scheme of the setup is shown in fig .
[ setup ] .
a high vacuum based afm was employed to measure the change in the casimir force between a gold coated sphere of diameter @xmath4 m and a si membrane ( coloured black ) in the presence and in the absence of incident light .
an oil free vacuum chamber with a pressure of around @xmath5torr was used . the polystyrene sphere coated with a gold layer of @xmath6 nm thickness
was mounted at the tip of a 320@xmath7 m conductive cantilever ( see fig . [ setup ] ) .
the si membrane ( see below for the process of its preparation ) was mounted on top of a piezo which is used to change the separation distance @xmath0 between the sphere and the membrane from contact to 6@xmath7 m .
the excitation of the carriers in the si membrane was done with 5ms wide light pulses ( 50% duty cycle ) .
these pulses were obtained from a cw ar ion laser light at 514 nm wavelength modulated at a frequency of 100hz using an acousto - optic - modulator ( aom ) .
the aom is triggered with a function generator .
the laser pulses were focused on the bottom surface of the si membrane .
the gaussian width of the focused beam on the membrane was measured to be @xmath8 mm .
the cantilever of the afm flexes when the casimir force between the sphere and the membrane changes depending on the presence or the absence of incident light on the membrane .
this cantilever deflection is monitored with a 640 nm beam from an additional laser ( see fig
. [ setup ] ) reflected off the top of the cantilever tip .
an optical filter was used to prevent the interference of the 514 nm excitation light with the cantilever deflection signal .
the transmission of this filter at 514 nm is 0.001% . including the less than 1% transmission through the si membrane and the diode solid angle of @xmath9 , the impact of the 514 nm light leakage leads to less than @xmath10pn changes in the force difference .
these changes are negligibly small as compared with the measured cantilever deflection signal .
the latter leads to a difference signal between the two photodiodes .
the resulting modification of the casimir force in response to the carrier excitation is measured with a lock - in amplifier .
the same function generator signal used to generate the ar laser pulses is also used as a reference for the lock - in amplifier .
the most important part of the setup is the si membrane
. it should be sufficiently thin and of high resistivity to ensure that the density of charge carriers increases by several orders of magnitude under the influence of the laser pulses .
the si membrane should be thick enough to make negligible the photon pressure of the transmitted light , as the illumination is incident on the bottom surface of the membrane ( see sec .
ivb for details ) .
the thickness of the si membrane has to be greater than 1@xmath11 m , i.e. , greater than the optical absorption depth of si at the wavelength of the laser pulses
. fabrication of the few micrometer thick si membrane with the necessary properties is described below .
a commercial si grown on insulator wafer ( soi ) was used as the initial product .
the insulator in this case is sio@xmath12 which is the native oxide of si and thus leads to only small reductions of the excited carrier lifetime in si . a layout of the wafer is shown in fig . 2 .
the wafer consists of a si substrate of 600@xmath7 m thickness and a si top layer of 5@xmath7 m thickness ( both are single crystals and have a @xmath13 crystal orientation ) with the buried intermediate sio@xmath12 layer of thickness 400 nm ( see fig
the si is p - type doped with relatively high nominal resistivity of about 10@xmath14 cm .
the corresponding carrier density is equal to @xmath15 @xcite .
the thickness of the si substrate is reduced to about 200@xmath7 m through mechanical polishing . then , after rca cleaning of the surface , the wafer is oxidized at @xmath16k in a dry o@xmath12 atmosphere for a duration of 72 hours . as a result , in addition to the buried sio@xmath12 layer , a thermal oxide layer with a thickness of about 1@xmath7 m is formed on both ( bottom and top ) sides of the wafer ( fig .
this oxide layer serves as a mask for subsequent tetra methyl ammonium hydroxide ( tmah ) etching of the si .
first , a hole with the diameter of 0.85 mm is etched with hf in the center of the bottom oxidation layer ( fig .
this exposes the si substrate .
next , tmah is used at 363k to etch the si substrate through the hole formed in the oxide mask ( fig .
note that tmah selectively etches si as its etching rate for si is 1000 times greater than for sio@xmath12 .
tmah etching leads to the formation of a hole through the si substrate .
given the selectivity of the etching , the buried 400 nm oxide is the stop etch layer .
finally , all the thermal oxidation layers and buried oxidation layer in the hole are etched away in hf solution to form a clean si membrane over the hole as in fig .
the thickness of this membrane was measured to be @xmath17 m using an optical microscope . in order for voltages to be applied to the si membrane , an ohmic contact is formed by a thin film of au deposited on the edge of the membrane followed by annealing at 673k for 10 min .
the si membrane was cleaned with nanostrip and then passivated by dipping in 49% hf for 10s .
the passivated si membrane was then mounted on top of the piezo as described above .
all calibrations and other measurements are done at the same period of time as the measurement of the difference of casimir forces and in the same high vacuum apparatus .
the calibration of the deflection signal of the cantilever from the photodiodes , @xmath18 , and the determination of the separation on contact and residual potential difference between the gold coated sphere and si membrane is done by measuring the distance dependence of an applied electrostatic force . for this purpose the same function generator ( see fig . [ setup ] ) is used for applying voltages to the membrane . for an attractive force @xmath19 and can be measured either as a current or a voltage .
in addition , a small correction has to be applied to the separation distance between the gold sphere and the si membrane due to the movement of the cantilever .
the actual separation distance @xmath0 between the bottom of the sphere and the membrane is given by @xmath20 here @xmath21 is the distance moved by the piezo , @xmath22 is the deflection coefficient in units of nm per unit deflection signal , and @xmath23 is the average separation on contact of the gold surface and si membrane .
@xmath23 is nonzero due to the stochastic roughness of the surfaces .
the complete movement of the piezo was calibrated using a fiber optic interferometer . to extend and contract the piezo , continuous triangular voltages between 0.010.02hz
are applied to it .
given that the experiment is done at room temperature , applying of static voltages would lead to piezo creep and loss of position sensitivity .
the deflection coefficient @xmath22 can also be measured by the application of electrostatic forces between the sphere and the membrane . in our measurements ,
the gold sphere was kept grounded .
the electric contact to the sphere was accomplished by applying a very thin gold coating to the cantilever .
the electrostatic force between the sphere and the membrane is given by @xcite @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the voltage applied to the si membrane , @xmath26 is the residual potential difference between the grounded sphere and membrane , @xmath27 , and @xmath28 is the permittivity of vacuum . the nonzero value of @xmath0 at contact , @xmath23 , is due to the surface roughness . in the complete measurement range of the electrostatic force from contact to 6@xmath11 m , eq .
( [ eq2 ] ) can be rearranged to the following more simple form within the limits of relative error less than @xmath9 @xcite : @xmath29 where @xmath30 first , 30 different dc voltages between 0.65 to 0.91v are applied to the si membrane .
the cantilever deflection signal is measured as a function of the distance .
the 0.02hz triangular wave was applied to the piezo to change the distance between the sphere and the membrane over a range of 6@xmath11 m .
larger applied voltages lead to more cantilever deflection and , according to eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) , to a contact of the two surfaces at larger @xmath21 .
the dependence of @xmath21 at contact of the sphere and the membrane on the applied voltage can then be used to measure the deflection coefficient @xmath22 . in order to determine the contact of the two surfaces
precisely , 32768 data points at equal time intervals were acquired for each force measurement ( i.e. , the interval between two points was about 0.18 nm ) . in cases , where the contact point was between two neighboring data points ,
a linear interpolation was used to identify the exact value .
the deflection coefficient was found to be @xmath31 nm per unit deflection signal .
the difference in the value of @xmath22 from previous measurements @xcite is due to the use of the 514 nm filter which reduced the cantilever deflection signal .
the obtained value of @xmath22 was used to correct the separation distance in all measurements in accordance with eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) .
the electrostatic force resulting from the application of the dc voltages is also used in the determination of the separation on contact of the two surfaces .
the fit of the experimental force - distance relation to the theoretical eq .
( [ eq3 ] ) is done as outlined in our previous work @xcite .
the separation distance on contact was determined to be @xmath32 nm .
the uncertainty in the quantity @xmath33 from eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) was found to be 1 nm . this leads to the same error in absolute separations @xmath34 nm because the error in piezo calibration is negligibly small . for the calibration of the deflection signal and the determination of the residual potential difference between the two surfaces ,
an improved method , rather than simple application of the dc voltages to the membrane was used .
this was done to avoid systematic errors due to scattered laser light .
in addition to the application of the dc voltage to the membrane , described above , square voltage pulse of amplitudes from 1.2 to 0.6v and time interval corresponding to a separation distance between 1 to 5@xmath11 m was also applied to the membrane . fig .
[ deflsignal ] shows the deflection signal of the cantilever in response to both the applied dc voltage and the square pulse as a function of the separation distance between the gold sphere and si membrane . by measuring only the difference in signal during the pulse
allows one to avoid the need for a background subtraction .
the fit of the difference signal to eq .
( [ eq3 ] ) leads to the value of the signal calibration constant @xmath35nn per unit deflection signal .
the same fit was used to determine the residual potential difference between the sphere and the membrane which was found to be @xmath36v .
the large width of the pulse applied in addition to the dc voltage allowed confirmation of the distance independence of the obtained values of the calibration constant and the residual potential difference .
an independent measurement of the lifetime of the carriers excited in the si membrane by the pulses from the ar laser was performed .
for this purpose a non - invasive optical pump - probe technique was used @xcite .
the same si membrane and ar laser beam modulated by the aom at 100hz to produce 5ms wide square light pulses , as used in the casimir force measurement , were employed as the sample and the pump , respectively .
the diameter of the pump beam on the sample was measured to be @xmath37 mm .
a cw beam with a 1mw power at a wavelength of 1300 nm was used as a probe .
the probe beam photon energy is below the band gap energy of si and is thus not involved in carrier generation .
this beam was focused to a gaussian width size @xmath38 mm .
thus the focal spot size of the probe beam is much smaller than the focal spot size of the pump light .
this allowed one to measure the lifetime in a homogeneous region of excited carriers .
the change in the reflected intensity of the probe beam in the presence and in the absence of ar laser pulse was detected with a ingaas photodiode .
the change in reflected power of the probe beam was monitored as a function of time in an oscilloscope and found to be consistent with the change of carrier density .
near normal incidence for the pump and probe beams was used , with care taken to make sure that the ingaas photodiode was isolated from the pump beam .
the time decay of the reflected probe beam in response to the square ar light pulses is shown in fig .
[ lifetime ] .
the change of the reflectivity of the probe is fit to an exponential of the form @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the effective carrier lifetime . by fitting the whole 5ms decay of the change in reflected power ,
the effective excited carrier lifetime was measured to be @xmath41ms .
note that this time represents both surface and bulk recombination and is consistent with that expected for si .
some dependence of the lifetime of the excited carriers on their concentration was observed . in the first 0.5ms , while the concentration is still high enough , the average value of the excited carrier lifetime was measured to be @xmath42ms .
the measured values of the carrier lifetime will be used in sec .
iva in the theoretical computations of the casimir force differences for the comparison with several measurements having varying power of ar laser . here
we present the determination of the difference in the casimir force resulting from the irradiation of the si membrane with 514 nm laser pulses .
in fact it is the difference in the total force ( casimir and electric ) which is measured .
as was indicated above , even with no applied voltages there is some residual potential difference @xmath26 between the sphere and the membrane .
the preliminary value of @xmath26 was determined during the calibration of the setup in the absence of laser pulses . in the presence of pulses ( even during the dark phases of a pulse train )
the values of the residual potential difference can be different .
we represent these residual potential differences during the bright and dark phases of a laser pulse train ( the latter is not exactly equal to the one determined in calibration ) @xmath43 and @xmath26 , respectively . during the bright phases of the pulse train we apply to the si membrane the voltage @xmath44 and during the dark phases the voltage @xmath25 . using eq .
( [ eq3 ] ) for the electric force , we can represent the difference in the total force ( electric and casimir ) for the states with and without carrier excitation in the following form : @xmath45 + \delta f_c(z ) .
\label{eq4}\ ] ] here @xmath46 is the difference in the casimir force and @xmath47 is the casimir force with ( without ) light .
the difference in the total force in eq .
( [ eq4 ] ) was measured by the lock - in amplifier with an integration time constant of 100ms which corresponds to a bandwidth of 0.78hz .
the measurement procedure is described below .
first we kept @xmath48 and changed @xmath44 .
the parabolic dependence of @xmath49 on @xmath44 in eq .
( [ eq4 ] ) was measured at different separations @xmath0 .
care should be taken to apply only small voltage amplitudes ( up to a few tens of mv ) so as to keep the space charge region negligible .
at every measured separation distance @xmath49 is plotted as a function of @xmath44 . as is seen from eq .
( [ eq4 ] ) , the value of @xmath44 where the parabola reaches a maximum is @xmath43 [ recall that @xmath50 . in this way
the value @xmath51v was found and shown to be independent of the separation from 100 to 500 nm where the difference in the casimir force can be measured .
next we kept @xmath52 , changed @xmath25 and measured the parabolic dependence of @xmath49 on @xmath25 at different separations .
the value of @xmath25 where parabolas reach minima is @xmath53v .
these values of the residual potential difference between the sphere and the membrane in the presence and in the absence of excitation light were substituted in eq .
( [ eq4 ] ) .
the small change of around 78mv in the residual potential difference between the sphere and the membrane in the presence and in the absence of excitation light is primarily due to the screening of surface states by few of the optically excited electrons and holes .
the above small value is equal to the change in band bending at the surface .
it is consistent with the fact that almost flat bands are obtained at the surface with the surface passivation technique used ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) .
then other voltages ( @xmath54 ) were applied to the si membrane and the difference in the total force @xmath49 was measured as a function of separation .
data were collected from contact at equal time intervals corresponding to 3 points per 1 nm ( i.e. , in 1209 points within the separation interval from 100 to 500 nm ) . from these measurement results , the difference in the casimir force @xmath55 was determined from eq .
( [ eq4 ] ) .
this procedure was repeated with some number of pairs ( @xmath56 ) of different applied voltages ( @xmath54 ) and at each separation the mean value @xmath57 was found . in fig .
[ result1 ] the experimental data for @xmath57 as a function of separation are shown by dots for different absorbed laser powers : @xmath58mw ( @xmath59 ) , 8.5mw ( @xmath60 ) , 4.7mw ( @xmath61 ) in figures a , b , and c , respectively .
the corresponding incident powers were 15.0 , 13.7 and 7.6mw , respectively .
as expected , the magnitude of the casimir force difference has the largest values at the shortest separations and decreases with the increase of separation .
it also decreases with the decrease of the absorbed laser powers ( the solid , short- and long - dashed lines in fig .
[ result1 ] are explained in sec .
iv devoted to the comparison with theory ) .
now we proceed with the analysis of the experimental errors .
the variance of the mean difference in the casimir force is defined as @xmath62 ^ 2\right\}^{1/2 } , \label{eq6}\ ] ] where @xmath63 is the number of point in one set of measurements changing from 1 to 1209 , @xmath64 is the number of the pair of the applied voltages . using student s @xmath65-distribution with a number of degrees of freedom @xmath66 ( or 40 and 32 for the measurements with different absorbed powers ) and choosing @xmath67 confidence , we obtain @xmath68 and @xmath69 . thus , the absolute random error in the measurement of the difference casimir force is given by @xmath70 in this experiment the random error is separation dependent .
it is presented in fig .
[ random ] as a function of separation for the three different measurements with different absorbed laser powers ( lines a , b , and c correspond to decreasing power indicated above ) . as is seen from fig .
[ random ] , the random error is rather different for different measurements .
it is the lowest for measurement ( b ) which was done with 8.5mw absorbed power . in this measurement the random error decreases from 0.32pn at @xmath71 nm to 0.23pn at @xmath72 nm and preserves the latter value at larger separations .
the main systematic error is due to the instrumental noise and is equal to @xmath73pn independent of separation .
the systematic error determined from the resolution error in data acquisition , @xmath74pn , also does not depend on separation .
the calibration error , @xmath75 , depends on separation and is equal to 0.6% of the measured difference in the casimir force .
these systematic errors are random quantities characterized by a uniform distribution
. they can be combined at a given confidence probability @xmath76 with the help of statistical criterion @xcite @xmath77 ^ 2}\right\ } , \label{eq7a}\ ] ] where @xmath78 is a tabulated coefficient . in our experiment
there are @xmath79 systematic errors listed above and at @xmath67 ( 95% confidence level ) @xmath80 . as a result , from eq .
( [ eq7a ] ) we arrive at the total systematic error for all three measurements varying from 0.092 to 0.095pn .
the total experimental error of the force difference , @xmath81 , at 95% confidence can be found by the combination of random and systematic errors .
this is done using the statistical rule described in ref .
@xcite and applied to the casimir force measurements in refs .
@xcite . according to this rule ,
the total error is equal to the random one if , as is the case in our experiments , the inequality @xmath82 is satisfied .
thus , the total experimental error in the values of @xmath55 for all three measurements as a function of the separation is presented in fig .
[ random ] . as a result ,
the relative experimental error changes from 10 to 20% at a separation @xmath71 nm and from 25 to 33% at a separation @xmath83 nm for different absorbed laser powers .
this allows us to conclude that the modulation of the dispersion force with light is demonstrated at a high reliability and confidence .
the observed effect can not be due to the mechanical motion of the membrane .
this is because membrane movement due to heating ( in our case less than @xmath84c ) would lead to a different force - distance relationship for both electrostatic force and the casimir force in disagreement with our observation and the confirmation of the distance independence of @xmath26 and @xmath43 .
the temperature rise of less than @xmath85c is estimated based on the net thermal energy increase in the si membrane .
the absorption of photons during the course of the optical pulse increases the thermal energy of the membrane , while conductive and radiative heat outflow to the si around the membrane and surrounding leads to a decrease in its thermal energy .
the net change results in the less than @xmath85c .
the latter would lead to a negligible less than @xmath10 relative expansion in the diameter of the membrane . in order to account for roughness , the surface topography of the sphere and membrane
was characterized using the afm .
images resulting from the surface scan of the gold coating on the sphere demonstrate stochastically distributed roughness peaks with heights up to 32 nm .
table i contains the fractions @xmath86 of the gold coating with heights @xmath87 ( @xmath88 ) .
the surface scan of si surface demonstrates much smoother relief with maximum heights equal to 1.68 nm .
the fractions @xmath89 of the si surface with heights @xmath90 ( @xmath91 ) are presented in table ii .
the roughness data are used in sec .
iv in theoretical computations .
the casimir force acting between a large gold sphere of radius @xmath2 and a plane si membrane can be calculated by means of the lifshitz formula @xcite , along with the use of the proximity force theorem @xcite @xmath92\right .
\nonumber \\ & & \phantom{aaaaaa}\left .
+ \ln\left[1-r_{\bot}^{(1)}(\xi_l , k_{\bot } ) r_{\bot}^{(2)}(\xi_l , k_{\bot})e^{-2q_lz}\right]\right\}. \label{eq8}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath93 is the boltzmann constant .
the reflectivity coefficients for gold ( @xmath94 ) and si ( @xmath95 ) for the two independent polarizations of electromagnetic field ( transverse magnetic and transverse electric modes ) are defined by @xmath96 where @xmath97 are the matsubara frequencies , @xmath98 , @xmath99 are the frequency - dependent dielectric permittivities of gold and si , and the following notations are introduced @xmath100^{1/2}. \label{eq10}\ ] ] the dielectric permittivities of gold and of high - resistivity si in the absence of laser light were computed @xcite by means of the dispersion relation @xmath101 where @xmath102 are taken from the tabulated optical data for the complex index of refraction @xcite .
high - precision results for @xmath103 ( gold ) are presented in ref .
@xcite . for high - resistivity si the behavior of @xmath104 as a function of @xmath105 is shown by the long - dashed line in figs .
[ epsilon]a and [ epsilon]b .
in particular @xmath106 . on irradiation of the si membrane by light , the equilibrium value of the carrier density is rapidly established during a period of time much shorter than the duration of the laser pulse .
therefore , we assume that there is an equilibrium concentration of pairs ( electrons and holes ) when the light is incident .
thus , in the presence of laser radiation , the dielectric permittivity of si along the imaginary frequency axis can be represented in the commonly used form @xcite @xmath107 } + \frac{\omega_p^{(p)}{\vphantom{\omega_p^{(e)}}}^2}{\xi\left[\xi + \gamma^{(p)}\right ] } , \label{eq12}\ ] ] where @xmath108 and @xmath109 are the plasma frequencies and the relaxation parameters for electrons and holes , respectively .
the values of the relaxation parameters @xmath110rad / s and @xmath111rad / s can be found in ref .
the plasma frequencies can be calculated from @xmath112 where the effective masses are @xcite @xmath113 , @xmath114 , @xmath115 is the electron mass , and @xmath116 is the concentration of charge carriers .
the value of @xmath116 for the different absorbed powers can be calculated in the following way .
first , we note that for a membrane of @xmath117 m thickness @xmath116 does not depend on the depth .
the reason is that a uniform concentration in this direction is established even more rapidly than the equilibrium discussed above @xcite .
in fact the assumption on an uniform charge - carrier density in the si membrane is justified due to the long carrier diffusion lengths and the ability to obtain almost defect free surfaces in silicon through hydrogen passivation @xcite .
next , we approximately model the central part of the gaussian beam of diameter @xmath118 by a uniform cylindrical beam of the same diameter .
the power contained in this cylindrical beam , @xmath119 , is equal to the power in the central part of the gaussian beam with a diameter @xmath118 .
elementary calculation using the gaussian distribution leads to @xmath120 .
the power @xmath119 is absorbed uniformly in the central part of the si membrane of diameter @xmath118 having a volume @xmath121 .
incidentally , the central region of the membrane with a diameter @xmath118 contributes almost 100% ( 99.9999% @xcite ) of the total casimir force acting between a membrane and a sphere . at equilibrium ,
the number of created charge carrier pairs per unit time per unit volume @xmath122 , where @xmath123rad / s is the frequency of ar laser light , is equal to the recombination rate of pairs per unit volume @xmath124 .
thus , at equilibrium @xmath125 eqs .
( [ eq13 ] ) and ( [ eq14 ] ) allow us to calculate the densities of charge carriers @xmath126 , @xmath127 , @xmath128 and the respective plasma frequencies @xmath129 in all measurements a , b , and c with different powers of the absorbed laser light . in the calculations of charge carrier densities using eq .
( [ eq14 ] ) we have used @xmath130ms and @xmath131ms in accordance with the measurement results in sec .
iiib , taking into account the fact that @xmath40 decreases when @xmath116 increases .
recall that @xmath132 and @xmath133 were obtained from first 0.5ms of the time decay .
our value for @xmath134 obtained using the whole 5ms decay may lead to a minor underestimation of the carrier density , a fact included in the resulting 21% error in the value of @xmath135 .
note that the above values of the relaxation parameters @xmath136 and @xmath137 do not depend on the absorbed power @xcite and can be used in all measurements . in fig .
[ epsilon]a the dielectric permittivity of si in the presence of laser radiation ( [ eq12 ] ) is shown by solid lines a , b and c as a function of imaginary frequency for the measurements with different absorbed powers a , b and c , respectively . the lines
a and b in fig .
[ epsilon]a almost coincide .
the region around the first matsubara frequency @xmath138 at @xmath3k is shown in fig .
[ epsilon]b on an enlarged scale .
the obtained values of @xmath103 , @xmath104 , and @xmath139 were substituted in the lifshitz formula ( [ eq8 ] ) and the difference of the casimir forces @xmath140 from eq .
( [ eq5 ] ) in the presence and in the absence of laser light was computed at the laboratory temperature @xmath3k .
note that there is discussion in the literature on the correct value of the reflection coefficient for gold @xmath141 at zero frequency ( see , e.g. , refs .
our calculation , however , does not depend on chosen value of @xmath141 because in eq .
( [ eq8 ] ) it is multiplied by @xmath142 for the silicon . in the absence of light the latter equality holds for any true dielectric with finite static dielectric permittivity . in the presence of light the equality @xmath143 also holds true as is seen from the substitution of eq .
( [ eq12 ] ) in eq .
( [ eq9 ] ) . in both cases at zero frequency only the transverse magnetic mode of the electromagnetic field contributes to the result . note that for si in the absence and in the presence of light for the transverse magnetic mode @xmath144 respectively .
finally the lifshitz formula ( [ eq8 ] ) was used to compute the difference in the casimir forces at all experimental separations @xmath145 ( @xmath146 ) and for the three measurements performed at different absorbed powers .
the results of these calculations should be corrected for the presence of surface roughness @xcite .
the stochastic roughness on our test bodies can be taken into account using the procedure presented in detail in refs .
first , the zero roughness levels on both gold ( @xmath147 ) and si ( @xmath148 ) are determined from @xmath149 where the heights @xmath150 and the fractions of the surfaces covered by roughness with these heights are given in tables i and ii , respectively . from eq .
( [ eq16 ] ) it follows @xmath151 nm , @xmath152 nm . the absolute separation @xmath0 between the test bodies is in fact measured between the zero roughness levels .
then the theoretical values of the difference casimir force with account of the surface roughness are calculated as the geometric averaging @xmath153 where @xmath140 was computed by the lifshitz formula for perfectly shaped bodies with and without light on a si membrane . in the present experiments
the contribution from roughness correction is very small .
thus , at @xmath71 nm it contributes only 1.2% of the calculated @xmath154 . at @xmath155
nm the contribution from surface roughness decreases to only 0.5% of the calculated force difference .
similar to refs .
@xcite it is easily seen that the contribution from the nonadditive , diffraction - type effects to roughness correction [ which is not taken into account in eq .
( [ eq17 ] ) ] is negligibly small .
the results of the numerical computations of the difference casimir force between rough surfaces @xmath154 are shown as solid lines in fig .
[ result1],a - c for the measurements with different powers of the absorbed laser light .
they are in a very good agreement with the experimental data shown by dots in the same figures ( see the following subsections for the quantitative measure of agreement between experiment and theory ) . for completeness
, we present also the results of theoretical computations using the lifshitz formula at zero temperature . they are obtained from eq .
( [ eq8 ] ) by changing the discrete matsubara frequencies @xmath156 for continuous @xmath105 and by replacement of the summation for integration @xmath157 following the same procedure as at @xmath3k , we first calculate @xmath158 using the lifshitz formula and then find @xmath159 including the effect of surface roughness with eq . ( [ eq17 ] ) .
the results of these computations are shown as short - dashed lines in fig .
[ result1],a - c .
as is seen from the figure , in all cases the short - dashed lines describe a slightly larger magnitude of the casimir force difference than at @xmath3 in rather good agreement with the experimental data shown as dots ( see the next subsections for further discussion ) .
the theoretical errors in the computation of the casimir force acting between a sphere and a membrane were discussed in detail in refs .
the major source of the theoretical uncertainty in this experiment is the error in the concentration of charge carriers @xmath116 when the light is on . from sec .
iva , this error is of about 20% .
calculations using the lifshitz formula show that the resulting relative error in the difference casimir force , @xmath160 , i.e. , is equal to approximately 12% and does not depend on separation .
the error due to uncertainty of experimental separations @xmath145 , in which the theoretical values @xmath161 should be computed , is equal to @xmath162 and takes the maximum value of 3% of the casimir force at the shortest separation of @xmath71 nm ( recall that according to sec .
iiia @xmath34 nm ) .
this leads to only 2% error in the difference of the casimir force at @xmath71 nm [ so that @xmath163 and to smaller errors at larger separations
. the other sources of theoretical errors , discussed in refs .
@xcite , like sample - to - sample variation of the tabulated optical data in au , use of the proximity force theorem , patch potentials , nonlocal effects and finite thickness of the gold coating on the sphere contribute negligible amounts to the error in @xmath161 .
thus , for example , using the lifshitz formula for a polystyrene sphere covered by a gold layer of 82 nm thickness instead of eq .
( [ eq8 ] ) written for a solid gold sphere , we would get only a 0.03% decrease in the casimir force magnitude .
a specific new uncertainty which is present in this experiment is connected with the pressure of light transmitted through the membrane and incident on the bottom of the sphere ( see sec .
this effect is present only during the light phase of the pulse train and can be easily estimated .
the maximum intensity of the laser light incident on a sphere section with radius @xmath164 parallel to the membrane is @xmath165 where @xmath166 is the fraction of the absorbed power transmitted through the membrane .
the value of @xmath166 is given by @xmath167 where @xmath168 m ( see sec .
ii ) and the transmission coefficient @xmath169 .
the force due to light pressure acting on the sphere in spherical coordinates takes the form @xmath170 substituting eq .
( [ eq19 ] ) in eq .
( [ eq21 ] ) and integrating , one obtains @xmath171 , \label{eq22}\ ] ] where erfi@xmath172 is the imaginary error function . for the absorbed powers used in three experiments ( @xmath173 , 8.5 , and 4.7mw , respectively ) ,
( [ eq22 ] ) leads to the following maximum forces which may act on the sphere due to light pressure : @xmath174 , 0.078 and 0.043pn .
the force due to light pressure can be taken into account as one more error in the theoretical evaluation of the casimir force difference @xmath161 . at a separation @xmath71
nm the respective relative error , @xmath175 , is equal to 2.3 , 2.7 , and 1.5% for the three absorbed powers . at @xmath176
nm the relative theoretical error in @xmath161 due to light pressure increases up to 8.9 , 8.7 , and 5.0% , respectively .
all three errors discussed above can be considered as the random quantities described by the same distribution law which is close to a uniform distribution .
for this reason the statistical criterion @xcite used in sec .
iiic can be applied once more , giving the total relative theoretical error in the difference casimir force @xmath177 ^ 2}\right\ } \label{eq22a}\ ] ] with @xmath79 and @xmath80 .
the resulting total absolute theoretical error , @xmath178 is presented in fig .
[ erth ] as a function of separation for the three experiments with decreasing power of the absorbed laser light ( lines a , b , and c , respectively ) .
as is seen from this figure , the total theoretical errors for the measurements a and b are almost equal , and for the measurement c this error is slightly lower . the relative total theoretical error changes from 13.5 to 13.7% at @xmath71 nm and from 13.7 to 14.4% at @xmath179 nm for the three different absorbed powers . at @xmath176
nm the relative total theoretical error ranges from 14.9 to 17.2% for the different absorbed powers . in the foregoing we have independently found the total experimental ( sec .
iiic ) and theoretical ( sec .
ivb ) errors in the difference of the casimir force in the presence and in the absence of laser light excited carriers at 95% confidence .
to compare experiment with theory , we consider the quantity @xmath180 and determine its absolute error @xmath181 as a function of separation at the confidence of 95% .
this can be done in the same procedure as in refs .
@xcite applying the statistical criterion @xcite and using the data in figs .
[ random ] and [ erth ] @xmath182 ^ 2 + \left[\delta^{\!\rm tot}(\delta f_c^{\rm theor})\right]^2 } \right\}. \label{eq22b}\ ] ] here @xmath183 .
the resulting confidence intervals @xmath184 $ ] are shown in fig .
[ result2],a - c as the solid lines for the three measurements with the largest , intermediate , and smallest powers , respectively . the differences between the theoretical values of @xmath161 ( computed in sec .
iva at @xmath3k ) and experimentally measured @xmath185 are shown in fig .
[ result2 ] by dots labeled 1 ( once again dots in fig .
[ result2],a - c are related to the three measurements with different power ) . as is seen from fig .
[ result2 ] , practically all dots labeled 1 are well inside the confidence intervals at all separation distances .
this means that the lifshitz theory at nonzero temperature , using the dielectric permittivity of high - resistivity si @xmath104 in the absence of laser light and the dielectric permittivity @xmath139 given by eq .
( [ eq12 ] ) in the presence of light , is consistent with experiment .
the consistency of the experiment with the theory is preserved when the theoretical values of @xmath161 are computed at zero temperature ( see the short - dashed lines in fig .
[ result1],a - c and the discussion in sec .
the reason is that the thermal correction to the casimir force in the region of small separations under consideration is practically negligible and the thermal effect can not be resolved taking into consideration the experimental and theoretical errors reported above . for illustrative purposes ,
the agreement between experiment and theory is presented in a more standard form in fig .
[ result3 ] . here a more narrow separation interval from 100 to 150 nm is considered and each third experimental point from the measurement b is plotted together with its error bars @xmath186 $ ] shown as crosses ( there are too many points to present all of them in this form ) . the theoretical force difference @xmath161 computed by the lifshitz formula at @xmath3k is shown by the solid line .
it is seen that the experimental data are in a very good agreement with the theory in confirmation of the conclusion made above using fig .
[ result2 ] .
in sec . iva the dielectric response of high - resistivity si in the absence of excitation laser light was described by the function @xmath104 having a finite static value @xmath106 .
it is common knowledge , however , that dielectrics have some nonzero dc conductivity @xmath187 at any nonzero temperature
. this conductivity decreases with the decrease of temperature as @xmath188 , where @xmath189 can be expressed in terms of the band gap or dopant activation energy . to take the dc conductivity into account in the lifshitz theory , the dielectric permittivity of si along the imaginary frequency axis @xmath104 used in sec .
iva should be replaced with @xmath190}. \label{eq23}\ ] ] the value of the plasma frequency in eq .
( [ eq23 ] ) is found by substituting the concentration of carrier density @xmath15 ( see sec .
ii ) in eq . ( [ eq13 ] ) with the result @xmath191rad / s . note that for @xmath192 the value of the relaxation parameter has an insignificant effect on the magnitude of the casimir force @xcite . because of this in eq .
( [ eq23 ] ) the same value of @xmath137 as in eq .
( [ eq12 ] ) is used . the behavior of @xmath193 as a function of @xmath105 is plotted in fig . [ epsilon]a by the short - dashed line .
the presence of some low dc conductivity in dielectric materials was used in refs .
@xcite to obtain a large effect of the van der waals friction which could bring the observations of ref .
@xcite in agreement with theory . in ref .
@xcite for two dielectric plates and in @xcite for one metal and one dielectric plate it was proved , however , that the inclusion of the dc conductivity for dielectrics into the lifshitz theory leads to the violation of the third law of thermodynamics ( the nernst heat theorem ) .
thus , it is not acceptable from a theoretical point of view .
our experiments on the modification of the casimir force with laser pulses clarify the problem whether or not the dc conductivity of high - resistivity si should be taken into account in the lifshitz theory of the casimir and van der waals forces . for this purpose , we have completely repeated the theoretical computations of the difference casimir force made in sec .
iva replacing the dielectric permittivity of si @xmath194 , used there , for @xmath195 given in eq .
( [ eq23 ] ) .
the obtained theoretical results for @xmath196 versus separation are shown by the long - dashed lines in fig .
[ result1],a - c for all the three measurements with different powers of the absorbed light . as is seen in fig .
[ result1 ] , all the long - dashed lines are far outside both the experimental data shown as dots and from the solid lines calculated using the lifshitz theory disregarding dc conductivity of high - resistivity si at the laboratory temperature . notice that the computational results at @xmath197 ( shown by the short - dashed lines in fig .
[ result1 ] ) do not depend on whether the dc conductivity is included in the dielectric permittivity used to describe the high - resistivity si . to make a quantitative conclusion on the measure of agreement between the data and two models with and without inclusion of dc conductivity of high - resistivity si
, we have plotted in fig .
[ result2],a - c the differences @xmath198 , where @xmath196 was computed including the dc conductivity according to eq .
( [ eq23 ] ) .
these differences are shown as dots labeled 2 in fig . [ result2],a - c . as is seen in fig .
[ result2],a , b , the model with included dc conductivity of high - resistivity si is excluded experimentally at 95% confidence within the region from 100 to 250 nm . from fig .
[ result2],c it follows that this model is excluded at 95% confidence within the separations region from 100 to 200 nm . the same conclusion , that the model of high - resistivity si , which includes dc conductivity , is inconsistent with our experiments on the optically modulated casimir force , is confirmed also in fig
. [ result3 ] , where the quantity @xmath196 versus separation is plotted as the dashed line .
it can be clearly observed that the dashed line is not only far away from the solid line based on theory neglecting the si dc conductivity in the absence of excitation light , but is also distant from all error bars representing the experimental data . the physical explanation for the deviations of the long - dashed lines from the solid lines in figs
. 5,a c and 10 is as follows .
when the dc conductivity of si is taken into account , the equalities @xmath199 follow from the substitution of eqs .
( [ eq12 ] ) and ( [ eq23 ] ) in eq .
( [ eq9 ] ) . once again , at zero frequency only the transverse magnetic mode contributes to the result . here
, however , for si both in the absence and in the presence of light the equations @xmath200 hold .
it is exactly this change in the magnitude of the transverse magnetic reflection coefficient @xmath201 , as given in eq .
( [ eq15a ] ) , with @xmath202 in eq .
( [ eq29 ] ) leads to the deviation of the long - dashed lines from the respective solid lines in figs .
5,a c and 10 .
it seems somewhat surprising that the use of the permittivity @xmath195 in eq .
( [ eq23 ] ) , which can be considered as a more exact than @xmath104 , leads to the discrepancy between experiment and theory .
this is , in fact , one more observation that there are puzzles concerning the applicability of the lifshitz theory to real materials . in the case of metals ,
the drude description of conduction electrons in the thermal casimir force was excluded experimentally in the series of experiments @xcite .
it also leads to the contradiction with the nernst heat theorem for perfect crystal lattices @xcite .
for metals , the deviation of the experimental results from the drude model approach and the violation of the nernst theorem are explained by the vanishing contribution from the transverse electric mode at zero frequency .
the present experiment dealing with semiconductors is not sensitive enough to detect this effect .
the effect reported here is novel and arises due to the difference in the contributions of the zero - frequency transverse magnetic mode . these contributions ,
as was shown above , depend on whether or not the dc conductivity of si in the absence of light is taken into account .
in this paper we demonstrate that it is possible to control the casimir force between the gold coated sphere and si membrane by the irradiation of si with laser pulses . on absorption of light , the carrier density increases leading to an increase in the magnitude of the casimir force .
this change in the casimir forces was investigated as a function of separation between the test bodies and the power of the absorbed light .
the experiments were performed with a specially prepared single crystal si membrane in an oil - free vacuum chamber using an afm . the developed calibration procedure permitted measurement of the difference casimir force of the order of 1pn with a relative experimental error at the shortest separation of 100
nm varying from 10 to 20% for the measurements performed at different absorbed powers . at a separation of 180 nm
the relative experimental error in different measurements varies from 25 to 33% .
all errors were determined at 95% confidence .
the obtained experimental results demonstrate the ability to modulate the van der waals and casimir forces in micro- and nanoelectromechanical devices by irradiation with laser light .
these are pioneering experiments where the modification of the casimir force acting between the test bodies was achieved due to the influence of some external factor other than the change of separation distance .
the experimental results were compared with the results of theoretical computations using the lifshitz theory at both zero and nonzero temperature .
the si membrane in the absence of laser light had a carrier density of approximately @xmath203 .
in the first model , the dielectric permittivity of high - resistivity si was described with a finite static value . in the presence of laser light the si had charge carriers pair densities varying from @xmath204 to @xmath205 depending on the radiation power absorbed by the sample and
was described by the permittivity in eq .
( [ eq12 ] ) .
the total theoretical error varied from 13.5 to 13.7% at @xmath71 nm and from 14.9 to 17.2% at @xmath176 nm depending on the absorbed power . the main contribution to this error
was given by the uncertainty in the number of charge carriers in the presence of laser light .
the experimental and theoretical results were found to be consistent over the whole measurement range taking into account the experimental and theoretical errors both at laboratory temperature @xmath3k and at zero temperature .
the same experimental data were compared with the lifshitz theory using a second model of high - resistivity si which includes the dc conductivity of the si membrane in the absence of laser radiation . in this case the dielectric permittivity of si in the absence of radiation is represented by eq .
( [ eq23 ] ) and goes to infinity when the frequency goes to zero .
the detailed comparison leads to the conclusion that this model is excluded by the experiment at 95% confidence if computations are performed at the laboratory temperature @xmath3k .
the difference in the force magnitudes when conductivity at zero frequency is absent or present arises from different contributions of the transverse magnetic modes of the electromagnetic field reflected from the si surface .
the physical explanation of our results can be understood in fig .
[ epsilon]a .
as is seen from this figure , the short - dashed line representing the dielectric permittivity of high - resistivity si with included dc conductivity is located far to the left of the first matsubara frequency @xmath138 and does not belong to the region of frequencies contributing to the force . at the same time , the lifshitz theory at zero temperature using the model of high - resistivity si with included dc conductivity remains experimentally consistent .
thus , we can infer that the lifshitz theory at nonzero temperature using the model of high - resistivity semiconductors and dielectrics with included conductivity properties at zero - frequency is inconsistent with our experiments .
it is notable that just this theoretical approach was demonstrated @xcite to lead to the violation of the third law of thermodynamics ( the nernst heat theorem ) . to avoid contradictions with thermodynamics and experiment one should follow the originators of the lifshitz theory @xcite who described dielectrics by a model with a finite static dielectric permittivity in computations of the van der waals and casimir forces at nonzero temperature (
the same model was used in the recent paper @xcite on the thermal effect in the casimir - polder force ) .
this suggests that the theory of van der waals and casimir forces between real materials requires further investigation .
although we are still lacking a fundamental explanation of why the lifshitz theory does not admit inclusion of the conductivity properties of high - resistivity materials at zero frequency , this prescription on how to perform computations in an experimentally and thermodynamically consistent way is topical for numerous applications of the van der waals and casimir forces ranging from condensed matter physics and nanotechnology to the theory of fundamental interactions .
the experimentally demonstrated phenomenon of modulation of the casimir force through optical modification of charge - carrier density will be used in the design and function of micro- and nanoelectromechanical devices such as nanoscale actuators , micromirrors and nanotweezers .
g.l.k . and v.m.m . are grateful to the department of physics and astronomy of the university of california ( riverside ) for its kind hospitality .
the instrumentation in this work was supported by the nsf grant phy0653657 .
theoretical calculations and personnel were supported by the doe grant de - fg02 - 04er46131 .
99 h. b. g. casimir , proc .
akad . wet . *
51 * , 793 ( 1948 ) .
e. buks and m. l. roukes , phys . rev .
b * 63 * , 033402 ( 2001 )
. h. b. chan , v. a. aksyuk , r. n. kleiman , d. j. bishop , and f. capasso , science , * 291 * , 1941 ( 2001 ) ; phys .
lett . * 87 * , 211801 ( 2001 ) .
a. a. chumak , p. w. milonni , and g. p. berman , phys .
b * 70 * , 085407 ( 2004 ) . m. kardar and r. golestanian , rev .
phys . * 71 * , 1233 ( 1999 ) .
b. s. stipe , h. j. mamin , t. d. stowe , t. w. kenny , and d. rugar , phys .
lett . * 87 * , 096801 ( 2001 ) .
j. r. zurita - snchez , j .- j .
greffet , and l. novotny , phys .
a * 69 * , 022902 ( 2004 ) .
b. geyer , g. l. klimchitskaya , and v. m. mostepanenko , phys .
d * 72 * , 085009 ( 2005 ) .
g. barton , j. phys . a : math . gen .
* 37 * , 1011 ( 2004 ) ; ibid * 38 * , 2997 ( 2005 ) .
e. v. blagov , g. l. klimchitskaya , and v. m. mostepanenko , phys .
b * 71 * , 235401 ( 2005 ) .
m. bordag , b. geyer , g. l. klimchitskaya , and v. m. mostepanenko , phys .
b * 74 * , 205431 ( 2006 )
. e. v. blagov , g. l. klimchitskaya , and v. m. mostepanenko , phys .
b * 75 * , 235413 ( 2007 ) .
m. antezza , l. p. pitaevskii , and s. stringari , phys .
a * 70 * , 053619 ( 2004 ) .
j. f. babb , g. l. klimchitskaya , and v. m. mostepanenko , phys .
a * 70 * , 042901 ( 2004 ) .
m. bordag , b. geyer , g. l. klimchitskaya , and v. m. mostepanenko , phys .
d * 58 * , 075003 ( 1998 ) ; * 60 * , 055004 ( 1999 ) ; * 62 * , 011701(r ) ( 2000 ) .
j. c. long , h. w. chan , and j. c. price , nucl .
b * 539 * , 23 ( 1999 ) .
r. s. decca , e. fischbach , g. l. klimchitskaya , d. e. krause , d. lpez , and v. m. mostepanenko , phys .
d * 68 * , 116003 ( 2003 ) .
r. s. decca , d. lpez , e. fischbach , g. l. klimchitskaya , d. e. krause , and v. m. mostepanenko , ann .
( n.y . ) * 318 * , 37 ( 2005 )
. r. s. decca , d. lpez , e. fischbach , g. l. klimchitskaya , d. e. krause , and v. m. mostepanenko , phys .
d * 75 * , 077101 ( 2007 ) ; arxiv:0706.3283 , eur .
j. c , 2007 , to appear .
s. k. lamoreaux , phys .
lett . * 78 * , 5 ( 1997 ) ; * 81 * , 5475(e ) ( 1998 ) .
u. mohideen and a. roy , phys .
lett . * 81 * , 4549 ( 1998 ) ; g. l. klimchitskaya , a. roy , u. mohideen , and v. m. mostepanenko , phys .
a * 60 * , 3487 ( 1999 ) .
a. roy and u. mohideen , phys .
lett . * 82 * , 4380 ( 1999 ) .
a. roy , c .- y .
lin , and u. mohideen , phys .
d * 60 * , 111101(r ) ( 1999 ) .
b. w. harris , f. chen , and u. mohideen , phys .
a * 62 * , 052109 ( 2000 ) ; f. chen , g. l. klimchitskaya , u. mohideen , and v. m. mostepanenko , phys .
a * 69 * , 022117 ( 2004 ) .
g. bressi , g. carugno , r. onofrio , and g. ruoso , phys .
. lett . * 88 * , 041804 ( 2002 ) .
f. chen , u. mohideen , g. l. klimchitskaya , and v. m. mostepanenko , phys .
rev . lett . * 88 * , 101801 ( 2002 ) ; phys .
a * 66 * , 032113 ( 2002 ) .
m. bordag , u. mohideen , and v. m. mostepanenko , phys . rep . * 353 * , 1 ( 2001 ) . s. k. lamoreaux , rep . progr
. phys . * 68 * , 201 ( 2005 ) .
e. m. lifshitz , zh .
* 29 * , 94 ( 1956 ) [ sov .
jetp * 2 * , 73 ( 1956 ) ] .
e. m. lifshitz and l. p. pitaevskii , _ statistical physics _
( pergamon press , oxford , 1980 ) , pt.ii . yu . s. barash and v. l. ginzburg , usp
nauk * 116 * , 5 ( 1975 ) [ sov . phys .
usp . * 18 * , 305 ( 1975 ) ] .
f. zhou and l. spruch , phys .
a * 52 * , 297 ( 1995 ) .
g. l. klimchitskaya , u. mohideen , and v. m. mostepanenko , phys .
a * 61 * , 062107 ( 2000 ) .
j. blocki , j. randrup , w. j. swiatecki , and c. f. tsang , ann .
( n.y . ) * 105 * , 427 ( 1977 ) .
t. emig , r. l. jaffe , m. kardar , and a. scardicchio , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 080403 ( 2006 ) .
a. bulgac , p. magierski , and a. wirzba , phys .
d * 73 * , 025007 ( 2006 ) .
m. bordag , phys .
d * 73 * , 125018 ( 2006 ) .
h. gies and k. klingmller , phys . rev .
lett . * 96 * , 220401 ( 2006 ) ; phys . rev .
d * 74 * , 045002 ( 2006 ) .
e. buks and m. l. roukes , nature * 419 * , 119 ( 2002 ) .
d. iannuzzi , m. lisanti , and f. capasso , proc .
usa * 101 * , 4019 ( 2004 ) .
f. chen , g. l. klimchitskaya , u. mohideen , and v. m. mostepanenko , phys .
lett . * 90 * , 160404 ( 2003 ) .
f. chen , u. mohideen , and p. w. milonni , in : quantum field theory under the influence of external conditions , ed .
k. a. milton ( rinton press , princeton , 2004 ) .
f. chen , u. mohideen , g. l. klimchitskaya , and v. m. mostepanenko , phys .
a * 72 * , 020101(r ) ( 2005 ) ; * 73 * , 019905(e ) ( 2006 ) .
f. chen , u. mohideen , g. l. klimchitskaya , and v. m. mostepanenko , phys .
a * 74 * , 022103 ( 2006 ) .
f. chen , g. l. klimchitskaya , v. m. mostepanenko , and u. mohideen , phys .
97 * , 170402 ( 2006 ) .
j. opsal , m. w. taylor , w. l. smith , and a. rosencwaig , j. appl . phys . * 61 * , 240 ( 1987 )
. t. vogel , g. dobel , e. holzhauer , h. salzmann , and a. theurer , appl .
31 * , 329 ( 1992 ) .
w. arnold , s. hunklinger , and k. dransfeld , phys .
b * 19 * , 6049 ( 1979 ) .
f. chen , g. l. klimchitskaya , v. m. mostepanenko , and u. mohideen , optics express * 15 * , 4823 ( 2007 ) .
b. geyer , g. l. klimchitskaya , and v. m. mostepanenko , int .
a * 21 * , 5007 ( 2006 ) .
b. geyer , g. l. klimchitskaya , and v. m. mostepanenko , arxiv:0704.3818 ; doi:10.1016/j.aop.2007.04.005 ; ann .
( n.y . ) , 2007 , to appear . , ed .
e. d. palik ( academic , new york , 1985 ) .
w. r. smythe , _ electrostatics and electrodynamics _
( mcgraw - hill , new york , 1950 ) .
a. j. sabbach and d. m. riffe , phys . rev .
b * 66 * , 165217 ( 2002 ) .
m. nagai and m. kuwata - gonokami , j. phys .
soc . jap . *
71 * , 2276 ( 2002 ) .
h. angermann , analyt .
bioanalyt . chem . * 374 * , 676 ( 2002 ) .
l. kronik and y. shapira , surface and interface analysis * 31 * , 954 ( 2001 ) .
s. g. rabinovich , _ measurement errors and uncertainties . theory and practice
_ ( springer - verlag , new york , 2000 ) .
g. l. klimchitskaya , f. chen , r. s. decca , e. fischbach , d. e. krause , d. lpez , u. mohideen , and v. m. mostepanenko , j. phys .
* 39 * , 6485 ( 2006 ) .
b. geyer , g. l. klimchitskaya , and v. m. mostepanenko , phys .
a * 72 * , 022111 ( 2005 ) .
a. o. caride , g. l. klimchitskaya , v. m. mostepanenko , and s. i. zanette phys .
a * 71 * 042901 ( 2005 ) .
e. yablonovitch , d. l. allara , c. c. chang , t. gmitter , and t. b. bright , phys .
lett . * 57 * , 249 ( 1986 ) .
v. b. bezerra , g. l. klimchitskaya , and c. romero , mod .
a * 12 * , 2623 ( 1997 ) .
m. bostrm and b. e. sernelius , phys .
lett . * 84 * , 4757 ( 2000 ) .
i. brevik , j. b. aarseth , j. s. hye , and k. a. milton , phys .
e * 71 * , 056101 ( 2005 ) .
v. b. bezerra , r. s. decca , e. fischbach , b. geyer , g. l. klimchitskaya , d. e. krause , d. lpez , v. m. mostepanenko , and c. romero , phys .
e * 73 * , 028101 ( 2006 ) .
g. l. klimchitskaya , u. mohideen , and v. m. mostepanenko , j. phys . a : math .
40 * , 339(f ) ( 2007 ) .
a. a. maradudin and p. mazur , phys .
b * 22 * , 1677 ( 1980 ) . k. joulain , j .-
mulet , f. marquier , r. carminati , and j .- j .
greffet , surf .
rep . * 57 * , 59 ( 2005 ) .
g. l. klimchitskaya , b. geyer , and v. m. mostepanenko , j. phys . a : math
. gen . * 39 * , 6495 ( 2006 ) .
j. m. obrecht , r. j. wild , m. antezza , l. p. pitaevskii , s. stringari , and e. a. cornell , phys . rev
. lett . * 98 * , 063201 ( 2007 ) . | the experimental demonstration of the modification of the casimir force between a gold coated sphere and a single - crystal si membrane by light pulses is performed . the specially designed and fabricated si membrane
was irradiated with 514 nm laser pulses of 5ms width in high vacuum leading to a change of the charge - carrier density .
the difference in the casimir force in the presence and in the absence of laser radiation was measured by means of an atomic force microscope as a function of separation at different powers of the absorbed light .
the total experimental error of the measured force differences at a separation of 100 nm varies from 10 to 20% in different measurements .
the experimental results are compared with theoretical computations using the lifshitz theory at both zero and laboratory temperatures . the total theoretical error determined mostly by the uncertainty in the concentration of charge carriers
when the light is incident is found to be about 14% at separations less than 140 nm .
the experimental data are consistent with the lifshitz theory at laboratory temperature , if the static dielectric permittivity of high - resistivity si in the absence of light is assumed to be finite .
if the dc conductivity of high - resistivity si in the absence of light is included into the model of dielectric response , the lifshitz theory at nonzero temperature is shown to be experimentally inconsistent at 95% confidence .
the demonstrated phenomenon of the modification of the casimir force through a change of the charge - carrier density is topical for applications of the lifshitz theory to real materials in fields ranging from nanotechnology and condensed matter physics to the theory of fundamental interactions . |
a mapping @xmath1 , where the dependence on the continuous parameter is smooth , is called a _ semidiscrete surface_. let us connect @xmath2 with @xmath3 by segments for all possible pares @xmath4 .
the resulting piecewise smooth surface is a _ piecewise ruled surface_. in this paper we study infinitesimal and higher order flexibility conditions for such semidiscrete surfaces . by _
flexions _ of a semidiscrete surface @xmath5 we understand deformations that isometrically deform corresponding ruled surfaces and in addition that preserve all line segments connecting @xmath2 with @xmath3 .
many questions on discrete polyhedral surfaces have their origins in classical theory of smooth surfaces .
flexibility is not an exception from this rule .
the general theory of flexibility of surfaces and polyhedra is discussed in the overview @xcite by i. kh .
sabitov . in 1890
@xcite l. bianchi introduced a necessary and sufficient condition for the existence of isometric deformations of a surface preserving some conjugate system ( i.e. , two independent smooth fields of directions tangent to the surface ) , see also in @xcite . such surfaces can be understood as certain limits of semidiscrete surfaces . on the other hand ,
semidiscrete surfaces are themselves the limits of certain polygonal surfaces ( or _ meshes _ ) . for the discrete case of flexible
meshes much is now known .
we refer the reader to @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite for some recent results in this area . for general relations to the classical case
see a recent book @xcite by a. i. bobenko and yu .
b. suris .
it is interesting to notice that the flexibility conditions in the smooth case and the discrete case are of a different nature .
currently there is no clear description of relations between them in terms of limits .
the place of the study of semidiscrete surfaces is between the classical and the discrete cases .
main concepts of semidiscrete theory are described by j. wallner in @xcite , and @xcite .
some problems related to isothermic semidiscrete surfaces are studied by c. mller in @xcite .
we investigate necessary conditions for existence of isometric deformations of semidiscrete surfaces .
to avoid pathological behavior related to noncompactness of semidiscrete surfaces we restrict ourselves to compact subsets of the following type .
an _ @xmath6-ribbon surface _ is a mapping @xmath7\times \{0,\ldots , n\ } \to\r^3 , \qquad ( i , t ) \mapsto f_i(t).\ ] ] we also use the notion @xmath8 while working with a rather abstract semidiscrete or @xmath6-ribbon surface @xmath5 we keep in mind the two - dimensional piecewise - ruled surface associated to it ( see fig . [ part ] ) .
@xmath9 in present paper we prove that any 2-ribbon surface ( as a ruled surface ) is flexible and has one degree of freedom in the generic case ( theorem [ 2-ribbon flex ] ) .
this is quite surprising since generic 1-ribbon surfaces have infinitely many degrees of freedom , see , for instance , in @xcite , theorem 5.3.10 .
we also find a system of differential equations for the deformation of 2-ribbon surfaces ( system a and corollary [ 111c ] ) .
in contrast to that , a generic @xmath6-ribbon surface is rigid for @xmath10 . for the case
@xmath11 we prove the following statement ( see theorem [ inf ] and corollary [ lambdah ] ) .
* infinitesimal flexibility condition . *
+ _ a 3-ribbon surface is infinitesimally flexible if and only if the following condition holds : @xmath12 where @xmath13 and @xmath14 _ _ remark . _ throughout this paper we denote the derivative with respect to variable @xmath15 by the dot symbol . having this condition
, we also show how to construct inductively the variational isometric conditions of higher orders .
finally , we show that an @xmath6-ribbon surface is infinitesimally or finitely flexible if and only if all its 3-ribbon subsurfaces are infinitesimally or finitely flexible ( see theorems [ n - ribbon - infini ] and [ n - ribbon - fini ] ) .
we say a few words in the case of developable semidiscrete surfaces whose flexions have additional surprising properties .
* organization of the paper . * in section 1
we discuss flexibility of 2-ribbon surfaces .
we study infinitesimal flexibility questions for 2-ribbon surfaces in subsections 1.2 and 1.3 . in subsection 1.2
we give a system of differential equations for infinitesimal flexions , prove the existence of nonzero solutions , and show that all the solutions are proportional to each other . in subsection 1.3
we define the variational operator of infinitesimal flexion which is studied further in the context of finite flexibility for 2-ribbon surfaces . in subsection 1.4
we prove that a 2-ribbon surface is finitely flexible and has one degree of freedom if in general position . in section 2
we work with @xmath6-ribbon surfaces .
subsection 2.2 gives infinitesimal flexibility conditions for 3-ribbon surfaces .
subsection 2.3 studies higher order variational conditions for 3-ribbon surfaces .
finally , subsection 2.4 shows the relations between flexibility of @xmath6-ribbon surfaces and infinitesimal and flexibility of 3-ribbon subsurfaces contained in it ( in both infinitesimal and finite cases ) .
we conclude the paper with flexibility of developable semidiscrete surfaces in section 3 . in this case
flexions have additional geometric properties . * necessary notions and definitions . * within this paper we traditionally consider @xmath15 as a smooth argument of a semidiscrete surface @xmath5 .
the time parameter for deformations is @xmath16 .
a _ perturbation _ of a semidiscrete ( @xmath6-ribbon ) surface is a smooth curve @xmath17 in the space of all sufficiently smooth semidiscrete surfaces .
we assume that the curve is parameterized by @xmath18 $ ] for some positive @xmath19 such that @xmath20 .
denote by @xmath21 the _ infinitesimal perturbation _ of a semidiscrete ( @xmath6-ribbon ) surface @xmath5 along the curve @xmath22 , i. e. the tangent vector @xmath23 .
we say that a perturbation is a _ flexion _ if it does not change the inner geometry of the surface obtained by joining all the pairs @xmath24 and @xmath25 by straight segments .
in the case of semidiscrete ( @xmath6-ribbon ) surfaces a surface is flexible if the the following quantities are preserved by the perturbation : @xmath26 ( for all possible @xmath27 and @xmath15 in the case of an @xmath6-ribbon surface ) .
we say that an infinitesimal perturbation is an _
infinitesimal flexion _ if it does not change the inner geometry of the surface infinitesimally . in other words ,
the first derivatives of the quantities listed above are all equal to zero .
in this section we describe flexions of 2-ribbon surfaces .
such surfaces are defined by three curves @xmath28 , @xmath29 , and @xmath30 .
our main goal here is to prove under some natural genericity assumptions that any 2-ribbon surface is flexible and has one degree of freedom .
our first point is to describe the system of differential equations ( system a ) that determines infinitesimal flexions corresponding to finite flexions and find solutions to this system ( see subsections 1.1 and 1.2 ) . further via solutions of system a we define the variational operator of infinitesimal flexion @xmath31 ( in subsection 1.3 ) . finally , to show finite flexibility of 2-ribbon surfaces we study lipschitz properties for @xmath31 ( in subsection 1.4 ) .
in this small subsection we collect some useful relations . for any infinitesimal flexion of a 2-ribbon surface @xmath5
the following properties hold : @xmath32 for a semidiscrete or @xmath6-ribbon surface @xmath5 and a @xmath33-curve @xmath22 the operations @xmath34 , @xmath35 , and @xmath36 commute , so we do not pay attention to the order of these operations in compositions .
the first three equations follow from the fact that infinitesimal flexions preserve the norm of tangent vectors to the curves @xmath29 , @xmath37 , and @xmath30 .
the invariance of the lengths of @xmath38 and @xmath39 implies the fourth and the fifth equations .
equations ( [ e8 ] ) and ( [ e9 ] ) follows from invariance of angles between the vectors @xmath40 and @xmath41 and the vectors @xmath40 and @xmath41 . finally , the last two equations hold since the angles between @xmath38 and @xmath42 and @xmath39 and @xmath42 are preserved by infinitesimal flexions and therefore @xmath43 ( in addition we use equations ( [ e8 ] ) and ( [ e9 ] ) respectively ) . in this subsection
we write down a system of differential equations ( system a ) which describe infinitesimal flexions of a 2-ribbon surface in general position .
we show the existence of infinitesimal flexions and prove that they are proportional to each other ( theorem [ 1-d - inf ] ) .
let @xmath44 denote by _ system a _ the following system of differential equations @xmath45 in proposition [ inner ] below we show an explicit formula for the function @xmath46 , it is @xmath47 in our notation of section 2 .
note also that @xmath48 and @xmath49 in system a. the remaining part of this subsection is dedicated to the proof of theorem [ 1-d - inf ] on the structure of the space of infinitesimal flexions . in proposition
[ condition ] we show that any infinitesimal flexion satisfies system a. then in proposition [ existence ] we prove that any solution of system a with certain initial data is an infinitesimal flexion . finally , in proposition [ 111 ] we show the uniqueness of the solution of system a for a given initial data .
after that we prove theorem [ 1-d - inf ] .
let us show that any infinitesimal flexion satisfies system a. [ condition ] let @xmath50 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 be linearly independent .
then for any infinitesimal flexion @xmath34 the functions @xmath51 satisfy system a. we start the proof with the following general lemma . [ additional ] for any infinitesimal flexion @xmath34 we have the equalities @xmath52 the functions @xmath53 , @xmath54 , and @xmath55 are infinitesimally preserved by infinitesimal flexions , hence @xmath56 , @xmath57 , and @xmath58 vanish . the invariance of angles between @xmath50 and @xmath38 , and @xmath50 and @xmath39 yield the equations @xmath59 and @xmath60 , respectively .
_ proof of proposition [ condition ] .
_ from lemma [ additional ] the functions @xmath56 , @xmath57 , and @xmath58 are equivalent to zero , thus @xmath61 , @xmath62 , and @xmath63 are equivalent to zero as well .
let us prove the expression for @xmath64 and @xmath65 .
note that @xmath66 thus equations ( [ e8 ] ) and ( [ e6 ] ) imply @xmath67 to obtain the expression for @xmath64 rewrite @xmath68 and @xmath69 in the basis consisting of vectors @xmath50 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 . the same strategy works for the functions @xmath65 . now we study expressions for @xmath70 and @xmath71 . from lemma
[ additional ] we know that @xmath72 and @xmath73 and hence @xmath74 and @xmath75 .
therefore , the equations for @xmath70 and @xmath71 are satisfied . in order to get an expression for @xmath76
, we first note that @xmath77 , since the function @xmath78 is an invariant of an infinitesimal flexion .
so we get @xmath79 rewrite @xmath80 second , we have @xmath81 third , we get @xmath82 fourth , @xmath83 after a substitution of the four above expressions and simplifications we have @xmath84 further , we get @xmath85 from the last two identities , by substituting @xmath86 and @xmath72 ( see lemma [ additional ] ) , we obtain the expression for @xmath76 . the expression for @xmath87 is calculated in a similar way .
this concludes the proof .
further we prove that any solution of system a with certain initial data is an infinitesimal flexion .
[ existence ] let @xmath5 be a 2-ribbon surface , @xmath88\to \r^3 $ ] for @xmath89 .
assume that the function @xmath90 has no zeros on @xmath91 $ ] .
then any infinitesimal perturbation @xmath34 of @xmath5 satisfying system a and the boundary conditions @xmath92 is an infinitesimal flexion . by the definition of an infinitesimal flexion
it is enough to check that the following 11 functions are preserved by the infinitesimal perturbation : @xmath26 ( for all possible admissible @xmath27 ) .
_ invariance of @xmath53 , @xmath54 , @xmath55 , @xmath93 , and @xmath94_. from system a we have @xmath95 and hence all five functions under consideration are constants .
so it is enough to show that they vanish at some point : we show this at point @xmath96 .
@xmath97 _ invariance of @xmath98 and @xmath99_. note that @xmath100 hence @xmath101 .
similar reasoning shows that @xmath102 .
_ invariance of @xmath103 and @xmath104_. let us prove that @xmath105 .
first , note that @xmath106 recall that @xmath107 .
let us substitute the expression for @xmath64 from system a and rewrite @xmath69 in the basis of vectors @xmath50 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 .
one obtains @xmath108 hence @xmath109 it follows that @xmath103 is invariant under the infinitesimal perturbation .
the proof of the invariance of @xmath110 is analogous .
_ invariance of @xmath111 and @xmath112_. let us prove that @xmath113 .
@xmath114 we have already shown that @xmath115 and @xmath116 . hence @xmath117 we rewrite the last @xmath118 in the last expression in the basis @xmath119 and get @xmath120 let us rewrite @xmath121 , @xmath122 , and @xmath123 in terms of @xmath124 .
first , we have : @xmath125 the second equality holds since we have shown that @xmath126 .
if we rewrite @xmath68 in the basis @xmath127 , we get the following : @xmath128 second , we have @xmath129 third , with @xmath130 and the expression for @xmath76 from system a we get : @xmath131 finally , we combine these three expressions and arrive at @xmath132 it is clear that the coefficients of @xmath133 and @xmath134 vanish identically . let us study the coefficient of @xmath135 .
consider the following mixed product @xmath136 , it is identical to zero
. let us rewrite @xmath68 in the second position of the mixed product in the basis @xmath137 , @xmath38 , @xmath39 .
we get the relation @xmath138 we apply this identity to the first two summands of the coefficient of @xmath135 and get the following expression for the coefficient of @xmath135 : @xmath139 we rewrite this as @xmath140 let us study the expression in the brackets .
@xmath141 the second equality holds by the jacobi identity .
hence the coefficient of @xmath135 is zero .
therefore , @xmath142 and @xmath111 is invariant under the infinitesimal perturbation .
the proof of the invariance of @xmath143 repeats the proof for @xmath111 .
so we have checked the invariance of all the 11 functions in the definition of an infinitesimal flexion .
hence the infinitesimal perturbation @xmath34 is an infinitesimal flexion . in the following proposition
we prove that system a has a unique solution for any single 2-ribbon surface @xmath5 ( not for a deformation ) and initial data for @xmath144 at one point @xmath145 .
recall that @xmath15 is an argument of @xmath5 .
[ 111 ] let @xmath5 be a 2-ribbon surface , @xmath88\to \r^3 $ ] for @xmath89 . for any collection of initial data @xmath146 there exists a unique solution of system a. this solution is extended for all @xmath147 , where @xmath148 the system of differential equations for @xmath149 is a system of homogeneous linear equations with variable coefficients and hence for any collection of initial data it has a unique solution .
the initial conditions of the last proposition can be reformulated in terms of infinitesimal flexion @xmath150 at a single point @xmath151 itself .
[ 111c ] let @xmath5 be a 2-ribbon surface , @xmath88\to \r^3 $ ] for @xmath89 .
for any collection of initial data @xmath152 there exists a unique solution of system a. this solution is extended for all @xmath147 , where @xmath148 the corollary follows directly from proposition [ 111 ] after obtaining the initial values @xmath153 from the vectors @xmath154 : @xmath155 now we have all the ingredients to prove the general theorem on the structure of the space of infinitesimal flexions .
[ 1-d - inf ] consider a 2-ribbon surface defined by curves @xmath88\to \r^3 $ ] for @xmath89 , where @xmath28 and @xmath30 are @xmath156-smooth and @xmath29 is @xmath33-smooth .
assume that the function @xmath157 has no zeroes on @xmath91 $ ] .
the space of infinitesimal flexions of such surfaces @xmath158up to isometries@xmath159 is one - dimensional .
_ uniqueness . _
any infinitesimal flexion is isometrically equivalent to an infinitesimal flexion which satisfies @xmath92 consider functions @xmath144 defined by equations ( [ g_i ] ) . by proposition [ condition ]
these functions satisfy system a. hence by corollary [ 111c ] , the functions @xmath144 are uniquely defined by @xmath5 and the initial conditions for infinitesimal flexions .
recall that elements of an arbitrary euclidean vector @xmath160 are uniquely determined by its scalar products with an arbitrary basis : @xmath161 therefore , the infinitesimal flexion is uniquely defined by the functions @xmath144 .
hence the dimension of infinitesimal flexions is at most one ( the parameter @xmath22 is the unique parameter of this flexion ) .
_ existence .
_ by corollary [ 111c ] there exists an infinitesimal deformation satisfying system a and the initial values @xmath162 by proposition [ existence ] this infinitesimal deformation is an infinitesimal flexion . since the function @xmath163 has no zeroes , @xmath164 is a nonzero vector and hence the infinitesimal deformation is nonvanishing .
let us fix an orthonormal basis @xmath165 in @xmath166 .
suppose that we know the coordinates of a 2-ribbon surface @xmath167\times \{0,1,2\ } \to\r^3 $ ] in this basis .
denote the coordinate functions for @xmath50 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 as follows @xmath168 denote by @xmath169 the banach space @xmath170)^9 $ ] with the norm latexmath:[\[\|(h_1,\ldots , h_9)\|=\max\limits_{1\le i \le 9}(\max(\sup @xmath5 is defined by the curves @xmath172 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 up to a translation .
so the space @xmath169 is actually the space of all 2-ribbon surfaces with one endpoint fixed , say @xmath173 .
we say that a point @xmath174 is in _ general position _ if the determinant @xmath175 for any point in the segment @xmath91 $ ] .
this condition obviously corresponds to @xmath176 denote by @xmath177\times \omega^1_9 \to \omega^1_9 $ ] the variational _ operator of infinitesimal flexion _ in coordinates @xmath178 : @xmath179 for ( @xmath180 ) . here
@xmath181 is a solution of system a at point @xmath5 with the initial conditions corresponding to @xmath182 i. e. , @xmath183 note that the variational operator of infinitesimal flexion @xmath31 is autonomous , it does not depend on time parameter @xmath16 .
let us show in brief how to find the coordinates of the perturbation @xmath21 in the basis @xmath184 satisfying @xmath185 first , one should solve system a with the above initial data , then substitute the obtained solution @xmath186 to equations ( [ e11 ] ) .
now we have the coordinates of @xmath187 , @xmath188 , and @xmath189 .
having the additional condition @xmath190 one can construct @xmath191 , @xmath192 , and @xmath193 : @xmath194 in previous subsection we showed that any @xmath195-ribbon surface in general position is infinitesimally flexible and the space of its infinitesimal flexions is one - dimensional .
the aim of this subsection is to show that a 2-ribbon surface in general position is flexible and has one degree of freedom .
we start with the discussion of the initial value problem for the following differential equation on the set of all points @xmath169 in general position ( here @xmath16 is the time parameter ) : @xmath196 to solve the initial value problem we study local lipschitz properties for @xmath31 .
consider a banach space @xmath197 with a norm @xmath198 and let @xmath199 be a subset of @xmath200\times e$ ] .
we say that a functional @xmath201 _ locally satisfies a lipschitz condition _
if for any point @xmath202 in @xmath199 there exist a neighborhood @xmath203 of the point and a constant @xmath204 such that for any pair of points @xmath205 and @xmath206 in @xmath203 the inequality @xmath207 holds .
first we verify a lipschitz condition for the following operator .
define @xmath208\times \omega^1_9 \to \omega^1_9 $ ] by @xmath209 where @xmath210 are defined by equations ( [ g_i ] ) .
[ g1 ] the functional @xmath211 locally satisfies a lipschitz condition at any point in general position .
consider a point @xmath212 .
the element @xmath186 itself satisfies a linear system of differential equations ( system a ) .
the coefficients of this system depend only on a point of @xmath213 .
since the point @xmath214 is in general position , there exists an integer constant @xmath204 such that for a sufficiently small neighborhood @xmath215 of @xmath214 the dependence is @xmath204-lipschitz , i.e. , for @xmath216 and @xmath217 from @xmath215 all the coefficients satisfy the inequality @xmath218 hence the solutions for @xmath219 $ ] satisfy the lipschitz condition on @xmath215 as well : for some constants @xmath220 we have @xmath221 from system a we know that the @xmath222 linearly depend on @xmath223 , therefore , we get the lipschitz condition for the derivatives : for some constants @xmath224 we have @xmath225 thus there exists a real number @xmath226 such that for all points @xmath216 and @xmath217 in @xmath215 , @xmath227 therefore , @xmath211 satisfies a lipschitz condition on @xmath215 .
lemma [ g1 ] and expression ( [ e11 ] ) directly imply the following statement .
[ d1 ] the functional @xmath31 locally satisfies a lipschitz condition at points in general position .
now we prove the following theorem on finite flexibility of 2-ribbon surfaces in general position .
[ 2-ribbon flex ] consider a 2-ribbon surface defined by a @xmath33-curve @xmath29 and @xmath156-curves @xmath28 and @xmath30 defined on a segment @xmath91 $ ] .
assume that @xmath90 does not have zeros on @xmath91 $ ] .
then the set of all flexions of such surface @xmath158up to isometries@xmath159 is one - dimensional .
as we show in corollary [ d1 ] , the operator @xmath31 satisfies a lipschitz condition in some neighborhood of the point @xmath216 related to @xmath50 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 . from the general theory of differential equations on banach spaces (
see for instance the first section of the second chapter of @xcite ) it follows that this condition implies local existence and uniqueness of a solution of the initial value problem for the following differential equation @xmath228 in some neighborhood of @xmath214 .
since the 2-ribbon surface @xmath229 with a fixed endpoint @xmath230 is uniquely defined by @xmath231 , we get the statement of the theorem .
in this section we study necessary flexibility conditions of @xmath6-ribbon surfaces .
we find these conditions for 3-ribbon surfaces , and we show how they are related to the conditions for @xmath6-ribbon surfaces . in this subsection
we prove certain relations that we further use in the proof of the statement on infinitesimal flexibility conditions for 3-ribbon surfaces . as we have shown in section 1 the notions of finite flexibility and infinitesimal flexibility
coincide for the 2-ribbon case . still in this subsection
we say _ infinitesimal flexions _ of a 2-ribbon surface to indicate that an infinitesimal flexion of an @xmath6-ribbon surface coincides with finite flexions of all its 2-ribbon surfaces .
consider the following function @xmath232 this function plays a central role in our further description of the flexibility conditions of @xmath0-ribbon and @xmath6-ribbon surfaces ( see theorem [ inf ] and theorem [ n - ribbon - infini ] ) .
let @xmath233 be the infinitesimal flexion of @xmath47 . via this function
we describe monodromy conditions for finite flexibility .
proposition [ inner ] and corollary [ discr ] deliver necessary tools to describe continuous and discrete parts of the monodromy condition on @xmath47 . here
we study the dependence of the infinitesimal flexion @xmath234 on the argument @xmath15 .
[ inner ] * ( on continuous shift . ) * suppose @xmath50 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 are linearly independent on the segment @xmath235 $ ]
. then for an infinitesimal flexion @xmath236 the following condition holds : @xmath237 this is a direct consequence of the next lemma .
[ rel ] let @xmath50 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 be linearly independent , then we have @xmath238 note that @xmath239 let us prove the statement of the lemma for an arbitrary point @xmath151 . without loss of generality
we fix @xmath240 and @xmath241 ( this is possible since any flexion is isometric to a flexion with such properties and isometries of flexions do not change the functions in the formula of the lemma )
. then @xmath242 is proportional to @xmath243 , and hence there exists some real number @xmath244 with @xmath245 thus we immediately get @xmath246 let us express the summands for @xmath247 .
we start with @xmath248 .
first we note that @xmath249 equation ( [ e8 ] ) implies @xmath250 from equation ( [ e4 ] ) we have @xmath251 the function @xmath252 is invariant of an infinitesimal flexion , therefore : @xmath253 and hence @xmath254 now we decompose @xmath255 in the last formula in the basis of vectors @xmath256 , @xmath257 , and @xmath258 : @xmath259 therefore , after substitution ( [ ei ] ) of @xmath260 we apply ( [ eii ] ) , ( [ eiii ] ) , ( [ eiv ] ) , and the last expression and get @xmath261 similar calculations for the summand @xmath262 ( applying equations ( [ e3 ] ) , ( [ e5 ] ) , and ( [ e9 ] ) and the conditions @xmath240 and @xmath241 ) show that @xmath263 further we have @xmath264 therefore , @xmath265 and consequently @xmath266 thus lemma [ rel ] holds for all possible values of @xmath151 .
any 3-ribbon surface contain 2-ribbon surfaces as a subsurfaces .
each of them has an infinitesimal flexion @xmath267 ( @xmath268 ) .
here we show the relation between @xmath269 and @xmath270 for the same values of argument @xmath15 .
first , in proposition [ curvatures ] we show a relation for @xmath271 and @xmath272 .
second , in proposition [ phipsi ] we give a link between @xmath271 and @xmath267 .
this will result in the formula of corollary [ discr ] on the relation between @xmath269 and @xmath270 .
we start with a formula expressing @xmath272 via @xmath271 .
[ curvatures ] we have the following equation : @xmath273 we do calculations at a point @xmath151 again assuming that @xmath274 and @xmath241 ( by choosing an appropriate isometric representative of the deformation ) .
let us show that @xmath275 .
first , note that @xmath276 secondly we show that the inner products of @xmath277 and the vectors @xmath256 , @xmath278 , and @xmath279 are all zero ( this would imply that @xmath280 ) . from equation ( [ e9 ] ) we have @xmath281 further , from equations ( [ e5 ] ) , we get @xmath282 finally , from the equation @xmath283 we obtain @xmath284 therefore , @xmath285 , and hence @xmath286 . from equation ( [ e1 ] ) and
equation ( [ e7 ] ) we get @xmath287 therefore , for some real number @xmath288 we have @xmath289 by a similar reasoning ( since we have shown that @xmath290 ) we get @xmath291 since @xmath292 , at point @xmath151 we have @xmath293 hence , @xmath294 and , therefore @xmath295 .
this implies @xmath296 and @xmath297 the last two formulas imply the statement of proposition [ curvatures ] .
now let us relate @xmath271 and @xmath233 .
[ phipsi ] suppose @xmath50 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 are linearly independent .
then the following equation holds : @xmath298 we restrict ourselves to the case of a point . without loss of generality
we assume that @xmath240 and @xmath299 .
so as we have seen before , there exists @xmath244 such that @xmath300 and hence @xmath301 let us calculate @xmath302 .
decompose @xmath303 since @xmath304 we get @xmath305 by equation ( [ e6 ] ) we have @xmath306 hence after the substitution of @xmath242 in the first summand one gets @xmath307 therefore , we obtain @xmath308 since the statement does not depend on the choice of the basis and invariant under isometries , we get the statement for all the points .
we introduce the abbreviations @xmath309 let us show a formula of a discrete shift .
[ discr]*(on discrete shift . ) * suppose @xmath50 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 are linearly independent .
then the following holds : @xmath310 the statement follows directly from propositions [ curvatures ] and [ phipsi ] . in this subsection
we write down the infinitesimal flexibility monodromy conditions for 3-ribbon surfaces ( via continuous shifts of proposition [ inner ] and discrete shifts of corollary [ discr ] ) . recall that @xmath311 and @xmath312[1111 ] [ inf ] consider a 3-ribbon surface @xmath5 with linearly independent @xmath172 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 at all admissible points .
the surface @xmath5 is infinitesimally flexible if and only if for any @xmath313 and @xmath314 in the interval @xmath315 $ ] we have @xmath316 by corollary [ discr ] we get relations between @xmath317 and @xmath318 for @xmath268 .
on the other hand , proposition [ inner ] relates @xmath319 and @xmath320 for @xmath268 .
these four relations define the monodromy condition for @xmath321 that is the condition in the theorem and , therefore , it holds if a surface is infinitesimally flexible .
suppose now the condition holds .
then the flexion is uniquely defined by the value of @xmath269 at a point @xmath151 .
let us simplify the expressions for @xmath322 and @xmath323 performing the following normalization for a fixed parameter @xmath16 .
denote @xmath324 here the semidiscrete surface @xmath5 is flexible if and only if @xmath325 is flexible .
in addition for the semidiscrete surface @xmath325 we get @xmath326 for all arguments @xmath15 . therefore we get the expressions for @xmath322 and @xmath323 as follows : @xmath327 and @xmath328 notice that this expression holds momentary , i.e. only for a fixed time parameter @xmath16 , so it can not be use for finite deformations . in this subsection
we say a few words about higher order variational conditions of flexibility for 3-ribbon surfaces .
we give an algorithm to rewrite these conditions in terms of the coefficients of the infinitesimal flexion defined by the system of differential equations ( system a ) .
we introduce a further auxiliary function by letting @xmath329 [ lambdah ] a 3-ribbon surface is infinitesimally flexible if and only if the following condition holds : @xmath330 this condition is obtained from the condition of theorem [ inf ] by differentiating w.r.t @xmath314 at the point @xmath313 .
therefore , these conditions are equivalent . from the infinitesimal flexibility condition of corollary [ lambdah ] one constructs many other conditions of flexibility .
if a 3-ribbon surface has a flexion , depending on a parameter @xmath16 , then @xmath331 at all points .
this implies the following statement .
if a 3-ribbon surface is flexible then for any positive integer @xmath332 we have @xmath333 where @xmath334 .
let us briefly describe a technique to calculate @xmath335 . +
* step 1 . * to simplify the expressions we write : @xmath336
further we let @xmath337 here we are interested in derivatives at an arbitrary value of a curve argument @xmath15 but at a fixed parameter of deformation @xmath338 . note that @xmath339 .
the functions @xmath340 and @xmath341 are calculated from the initial data for the @xmath0-ribbon surface @xmath5 .
let us find the expressions for @xmath342 . without loss of generality we fix @xmath343 for a starting point @xmath96 .
we find @xmath244 from corollary [ discr ] ( on discrete shift ) .
first , we have @xmath344 therefore , from corollary [ discr ] we have @xmath345 all the functions @xmath342 are found as the corresponding solutions of two systems of differential equations ( system a for @xmath268 ) according to corollary [ 111c ] . since @xmath346 , these solutions are compatible . for the functions
@xmath347 we have @xmath348 to avoid cross products in the above expression we use lagrange s formula : @xmath349 * step 2 .
* define @xmath350 as before , the functions @xmath351 and @xmath352 are calculated from the initial data for the 3-ribbon surface @xmath5 .
first , let us find the expressions for @xmath353 by induction on @xmath332 .
_ induction base .
_ for @xmath354 we get the formulae from step 1 . _ induction step . _
suppose that we know the expressions for @xmath332 let us find @xmath355 .
we have @xmath356 the expression in the left hand part is a function that is known by induction .
the last two summands of the hand right part are also expressed inductively after rewriting @xmath357 , and @xmath358 in the basis @xmath359 , @xmath360 , @xmath361 . secondly , decomposing @xmath362 in the basis @xmath359 , @xmath360 , @xmath361 we get @xmath363 * step 3 . * note that @xmath364 and @xmath365 [ aalg ] suppose that we get a rational polynomial expression @xmath366 in variables @xmath367 , @xmath368 , @xmath369 , and @xmath370 .
then @xmath371 is also a rational polynomial expression in variables @xmath367 , @xmath368 , @xmath369 , and @xmath370 .
steps 13 give all the tools to write the expression for @xmath371 explicitly . for any positive integer @xmath332
the function @xmath372 is a rational polynomial expression in variables @xmath367 , @xmath368 , @xmath369 , and @xmath370 .
therefore , we can apply steps 13 and proposition [ aalg ] to calculate @xmath373 using induction on @xmath332 .
we conclude this subsection with a few words on sufficient conditions for flexibility .
we start with an open problem .
find a sufficient condition for flexibility of semidiscrete and @xmath6-ribbon surfaces . for the case of @xmath0-ribbon surfaces we have the following conjecture .
consider a @xmath0-ribbon surface @xmath5 .
let @xmath374 for all non - negative integers @xmath332 ( where @xmath375 ) .
then @xmath5 is locally flexible .
we also conjecture that it is enough to take only a finite number of these conditions .
then the following question is actual : _ what is the number of independent conditions of isometric deformation _ ?
let us finally describe a relation between ( finite and infinitesimal ) flexibility of @xmath6-ribbon surfaces and flexibility of all 3-ribbon subsurfaces contained in them .
we start with theorem on infinitesimal flexibility .
[ n - ribbon - infini ] consider an @xmath6-ribbon surface satisfying the genericity condition : @xmath376 , @xmath377 , and @xmath378 are not coplanar at any admissible point @xmath151 and integer @xmath27 .
then this surface is infinitesimally flexible if and only if any 3-ribbon surface contained in the surface is infinitesimally flexible .
the proof is straightforward .
all the conditions for infinitesimal flexion are exactly the conditions for 3-ribbon surfaces of theorem [ inf ] . for the finite flexibility we have the following .
[ n - ribbon - fini ] consider an @xmath6-ribbon surface satisfying the genericity condition : @xmath376 , @xmath377 , and @xmath378 are not coplanar at any admissible point @xmath151 and integer @xmath27 .
then this surface is flexible if and only if any 3-ribbon surface contained in the surface is flexible .
we think of this theorem as of a semidiscrete analogue to the statement of the paper @xcite on conjugate nets and all @xmath379-meshes that they contain . in this paper
we do not study phenomena related to non - compactness and hence we restrict ourselves to the case of compact @xmath6-ribbons surfaces .
the `` only if '' part of the statement is straightforward .
we prove the converse by induction on the number of ribbons in a surface .
_ induction base .
_ by assumption any 3-ribbon subsurface contained in the surface is flexible .
it has one degree of freedom , since by theorem [ 1-d - inf ] any 2-ribbon subsurface of a 3-ribbon surface has at most one degree of freedom , while the genericity condition holds in a certain neighborhood of a starting position .
_ induction step .
_ suppose we know that any @xmath380-ribbon subsurface is flexible and has one degree of freedom in some neighborhood ( for @xmath381 ) .
let us prove the statement for any @xmath382-ribbon subsurface .
we consider a @xmath382-ribbon subsurface as the union of two @xmath380-ribbon subsurfaces that intersect in a @xmath383-ribbon subsurface . by the induction assumption
this @xmath383-ribbon surface has one degree of freedom compatible with the flexions of both @xmath380-ribbon subsurfaces .
therefore , the flexion of the @xmath383-ribbon subsurface is uniquely extended to the both @xmath380-ribbon subsurfaces .
this implies flexibility of the @xmath382-ribbon with one degree of freedom .
suppose that all ribbons of a semidiscrete surface are developable , i.e. the vectors @xmath376 , @xmath384 , and @xmath385 are linearly dependent .
we call such semidiscrete surfaces _ developable_. in this section we describe an additional property for flexions of developable semidiscrete surfaces .
this fact gives a surprising corollary concerning the flexion of a 2-ribbon developable surface .
the degree of freedom for a flexion of a generic 2-ribbon developable surface is 1 , as can easily be seen from the genericity condition for 2-ribbon surfaces .
so a flexion is unique up to the choice of a parameter .
denote by @xmath392 the angle between @xmath38 and @xmath39 .
consider a flexion of a 2-ribbon developable surface @xmath5 .
let us choose the parameter @xmath22 of the flexion such that @xmath393 changes linearly in @xmath22 .
then for any @xmath15 the value @xmath394 changes linearly in @xmath22 . for the surface of @xmath395
we get @xmath397 since @xmath398 and @xmath399 . now
the statement of the corollary for @xmath395 follows from proposition [ inner ] and the inner geometry expression of proposition [ devel ] for the function under integration ( that is actually @xmath400 )
. * acknowledgement . *
the author is grateful to j. wallner for constant attention to this work , a. weinmann for good remarks .
this work has been performed at technische universitt graz within the framework of the project `` computational differential geometry '' ( fwf grant no .
s09209 ) . a. i. bobenko , t. hoffmann , w. k. schief , _ on the integrability of infinitesimal and finite deformations of polyhedral surfaces _ , discrete differential geometry , a. i. bobenko , p. schrder , j. m. sullivan , g. m. ziegler , ( eds . ) , series : oberwolfach seminars , v. 38 ( 2008 ) , pp .
6793 .
mller , j. wallner , _ semi - discrete isothermic surfaces _ , geometry preprint 2010/02 , tu graz , february 2010 .
h. pottmann , j. wallner , _ infinitesimally flexible meshes and discrete minimal surfaces _ , monatshefte math .
, v. 153 ( 2008 ) , pp
. 347365 . | in this paper we study necessary conditions of flexibility for semidiscrete surfaces . for 2-ribbon semidiscrete surfaces
we prove their one - parametric finite flexibility . in particular we write down a system of differential equations describing flexions in the case of existence .
further we find infinitesimal criterions of @xmath0-ribbon flexibility .
finally , we discuss the relation between general semidiscrete surface flexibility and @xmath0-ribbon flexibility . |
the effects of absorption and scattering by interstellar dust grains on the structural parameters of galaxies has been a long - standing and controversial issue . the only way to tackle
this problem is to properly solve the continuum radiative transfer equation , taking into account realistic geometries and the physical processes of absorption and multiple anisotropic scattering . over the years
, many different and complementary approaches have been developed to tackle the continuum radiative transfer problem in simple geometries such as spherical or plane - parallel symmetry .
while one - dimensional radiative transfer calculations have been crucial to isolate and demonstrate the often counter - intuitive aspects of important parameters such as star - dust geometry , dust scattering properties and clumping @xcite , we need more sophisticated radiative transfer models to model complicated systems such as disc galaxies in detail .
thanks to new techniques and ever increasing computing power , the construction of 2d and 3d realistic radiative transfer models is now possible . a complementary and powerful way to study
the content of galaxies is to use the direct emission of dust at long wavelengths .
large dust grains will typically reach a state of local thermal equilibrium ( lte ) in the local interstellar radiation field ( isrf ) and re - radiate the absorbed uv / optical radiation at far - infrared ( fir ) and submm wavelengths .
thanks to the spectacular advances in instrumentation in the fir / submm wavelength region , we have seen a significant improvement in the amount of fir / submm data on both nearby and distant galaxies . in particular , the launch of the herschel space observatory with the sensitive pacs and spire instruments has enabled both the detailed study of nearby , resolved galaxies and the detection of thousands of distant galaxies . whereas large grains typically emit as a modified blackbody at an equilibrium temperature of 15 - 30 k and hence dominate the fir / submm emission of galaxies , small grains and pah molecules are transiently heated by the absorption of single uv photons to much higher temperatures . the nlte emission from very small grains and
pahs dominates the emission of galaxies at mid - infrared wavelengths .
the iso and particularly the spitzer mission have been instrumental in uncovering the mid - infrared emission of nearby galaxies @xcite .
different approaches have been developed to calculate the nlte emission spectrum due to very small grains and pahs , but the integration of nlte emission into radiative transfer codes has proven to be a challenging task .
the main reason is that the computational effort necessary to calculate the temperature distribution of the different dust grains is substantial . in the general case ,
the calculation of the dust emissivity in a single dust cell requires the solution of a large matrix equation for each single dust population , with the size of the matrix determined by the number of temperature or enthalpy bins . in the so - called thermal continuous cooling approximation @xcite
, this matrix equation can be solved recursively , but still the calculation of the emission spectrum remains a significant computational challenge .
indeed , since the temperature distribution of dust grains depends strongly on both the size of the grains and the strength and hardness of the isrf , a large number of temperature or enthalpy bins is necessary to sample the temperature distribution correctly .
moreover , because of this strong dependence on grain size and isrf , the choice of the temperature bins is hard to fix a priori and an iterative procedure is to be preferred . in spite of the high numerical cost , nlte dust emission has been built into several radiative transfer codes , using various approximations and/or assumptions .
the most simple approach is the one followed by e.g. @xcite and @xcite , who use a set of predefined nlte dust emissivities with the simplifying assumption that the emissivity is a function only of strength and not of the spectral shape of the exciting isrf .
a pioneering code in which nlte dust emission was included in a self - consistent way was the 2d ray - tracing code by .
the number of temperature distribution calculations are minimized by the assumptions that grains with a size larger than about 80 are in thermal equilibrium , and by the use of a pre - fixed time dependence of the cooling of pah grains .
a similar approach was adopted in the 3d monte carlo radiative transfer code dirty @xcite .
the trading code by uses a different approach : this code uses a fixed ( and limited ) grid of temperature bins for all isrfs and grain sizes , which allows to precompute and tabulate a significant fraction of the quantities necessary for the calculation of the temperature distribution .
yet a different approach is the work by : driven by the observation that the spectrum of the local isrf is very similar in many places in a dusty medium , they considered the idea of a dynamic library of dust emission spectra .
the idea is that the intensity of the isrf at a very limited number of reference wavelengths ( they typically used only two ) suffices to make a reliable estimate of the total isrf and hence of the dust emission spectrum . in this paper
we present an updated version of the skirt monte carlo radiative transfer code .
this code , of which the name is an acronym to stellar kinematics including radiative transfer , was initially developed to study the effect of dust absorption and scattering on the observed kinematics of dusty galaxies @xcite . in a second stage ,
the skirt code was extended with a module to self - consistently calculate the dust emission spectrum under the assumption of local thermal equilibrium @xcite .
this lte version of skirt has been used to model the dust extinction and emission of various types of galaxies , as well as circumstellar discs @xcite and clumpy tori around active galactic nuclei @xcite . in this present paper
we present a strongly extended version of the skirt code that can perform efficient 3d radiative transfer calculations including a self - consistent calculation of the dust temperature distribution and the associated fir / submm emission with a full incorporation of the emission of transiently heated grains and pah molecules .
in section [ skirt-general.sec ] we present the general characteristics of the skirt code , whereas we highlight a number of particular aspects in section [ particular.sec ] and some implementation details in section [ implementation.sec ] . in section [ applications.sec ]
we describe a number of tests and applications , and section [ conclusions.sec ] we present our conclusions .
skirt is a 3d continuum radiative transfer code based on the monte carlo algorithm .
the key principle in monte carlo radiative transfer simulations is that the radiation field is treated as a flow of a finite number of photon packages .
a simulation consists of consecutively following the individual path of each single photon package through the dusty medium .
the journey or lifetime of a single photon package can be thought of as a loop : at each moment in the simulation , a photon package is characterized by a number of properties , which are generally updated when the photon package moves to a different stage on its trajectory .
the trajectory of the photon package is governed by various events such as emission , absorption and scattering events .
each of these events is determined statistically by random numbers , generated from the appropriate probability distribution @xmath0 .
typically , a photon is emitted by a star , undergoes a number of scattering events and its journey ultimately ends when it is either absorbed by the dust or it leaves the system . a monte carlo simulation repeats this same loop for every single one of the photon packages and analyzes the results afterwards .
the mathematical details and practical implementation of monte carlo radiative transfer have both been described in detail by various authors and will not be repeated here in full detail .
our overall approach is comparable to the dirty @xcite and trading radiative transfer codes and we refer the interested reader to these papers for more details
. we will only give a compact description of the general characteristics of the skirt monte carlo code and not describe all the details .
instead , we will focus our attention to those aspects of the skirt code that are novel and/or different compared to the other codes .
each skirt simulation consists of four phases : the initialization phase , the stellar emission phase , the dust emission phase , and the clean - up phase .
the initialization phase consists of adopting the correct unit system , setting up the random number generator , computing the optical properties of the various dust populations , constructing the dust grid , setting up the stellar geometry and setting up the instruments of the various observers .
once this initialization is finished , the actual simulation can start . in the stellar emission phase , we consider the transfer of the primary source of radiation ( usually stellar sources , but it can also include an accretion disc or nebular line emission ) through the dusty medium .
the stellar emission phase consists of a set of parallel loops , each of them corresponding to a single wavelength . at every single wavelength ,
the total luminosity of the stellar system is divided into a very large number ( typically @xmath1 to @xmath2 ) of monochromatic photon packages , which are launched consecutively through the dusty medium in random propagation directions .
once a photon package is launched into the dusty medium ( either after an emission event or following a scattering event ) , it can be absorbed by a dust grain , it can be scattered by a dust grain , or it can travel through the system without any interaction . in a naive monte carlo routine ,
these three possibilities are possible and it is randomly determined which of the three will happen .
this is generally an inefficient procedure , though , which leads to poor signal - to - noise both in the absorption rates in the different cells and in the scattered light images . to overcome these problems ,
we have set up a combination of continuous absorption and eternal forced scattering ( see section [ forced.sec ] for details ) .
the result is that , contrary to most monte carlo codes where the life cycle of a photon package ends when it either leaves the system or is absorbed , the photon packages in skirt can never leave the system .
the life cycle of a photon package ends when the package contains virtually no more luminosity ( typically we use the criterion that it must have lost 99.99% of its original luminosity ) .
whenever this happens , a different stellar photon package is launched until also this one finishes its life cycle .
this loop is repeated for all stellar photon packages at a given wavelength , and subsequently for all wavelengths ( in a multi - core system , each core can handle the loop corresponding to a different wavelength at the same time ) .
after the stellar emission phase , the code moves to the dust emission phase .
this phase is roughly similar to the stellar phase , except that the sources that emit the radiation are now not the primary , stellar sources but the dust cells . from the stellar emission phase we know the total amount of absorbed radiation at each wavelength in each cell of the dust domain . from this absorption rate
we can calculate the mean intensity of the isrf in each cell , which allows the calculation of the dust emissivity , depending on the physical processes the skirt user is interested in ( see section [ dustemissivity.sec ] ) . with the sources ( the dust cells ) and
their emissivity determined , the simulation now enters a loop that is very similar to the one in the stellar emission phase . at each individual wavelength ,
a huge number of photon packages is generated which are launched and followed consecutively through the dusty medium .
care is taken that all regions of the dusty medium , including those cells where only a small amount of luminosity has been absorbed , are well - sampled .
the dust - emitted photon packages in turn increase the absorption rate in the dust cells where they pass through .
this results in an increase of the mean intensity of the isrf .
the result is that at the end of the dust emission phase , the absorption rates used to calculate the dust emissivity in each cell do not correspond to the mean intensity of the isrf .
this naturally leads to an iterative procedure , in which the absorption rate , the mean intensity and the dust emissivity are updated until convergence is achieved .
we hence repeat the dust emission phase of the code several times .
we typically require a 1% level accuracy in the dust bolometric absorption rate of each cell as a stopping criterion for the iteration .
it is typically reached in only a few iterations ; for all the simulations we have done so far , less then five iterations have been necessary .
the last phase of the monte carlo simulation starts when the last of the photon packages emitted by the dust component has lost 99.99% of its initial luminosity .
it simply consists of calibrating and reading out the instruments ( all output is written to fits files ) and other useful information , such as 3d absorption rate maps and dust temperature distributions .
a critical aspect in monte carlo radiative transfer simulations is the choice of the dust grid .
the dust grid consists of tiny cells , each of which have a number of characteristics that fully describe the physical properties of the dust at the location of the cell .
the choice of the grid has a significant impact on both the run time and the memory requirement of the simulation .
indeed , each photon package typically requires several integrations through the dust ( i.e. the determination of the optical depth along the path and the conversion of a given optical depth to a physical path length ) , and the calculation time of a single optical depth typically scales with the number of grid cells crossed .
different kinds of dust grids can be applied in the skirt code .
the most general grid is a 3d cartesian grid in which each dust cell is a rectangular cuboid . for simulations with a spherical or axial symmetry
, we also have 1d spherical and 2d cylindrical grids ( the elementary dust cells being shells or tori respectively ) .
the distribution of the grid points ( in 1d spherical , 2d cylindrical or 3d cartesian grids ) can be chosen arbitrarily ; linear , logarithmic , or power - law cell distributions have been pre - programmed , but any user - supplied grid cell distribution is possible . the main goal of the dust grid is to discretize the dust density .
we assume that the density of each dust component is uniform within each individual cell . in principle , the density does not need to be constant within each dust cell .
in the first versions of skirt , we have experimented with a more sophisticated kind of dust grid , where the density of the dust within each cell is not uniform but determined by trilinear interpolation of the values of the density on the eight border points of the cell ( in case of a cartesian grid with cubic cells ) . in this case , the computation of optical depths in the dusty medium take more computation time , but the accuracy is increased such that a grid with less cells and less photon packages are needed per simulation . for models in which only absorption and scattering are taken into account , we found that this kind of dust grid is computationally more efficient than a dust grid with uniform density , in particular when the system harbors a large dynamical range of dust densities @xcite .
however , for radiative transfer simulations in which the thermal emission of the dust is taken into account , each dust cell needs to contain an absorption rate counter , which collects the absorbed luminosity at every wavelength .
the size of the dust cells is hence the typical resolution of the simulation , and the advantage of the interpolated grid ( where the dust grid can be coarser because the density is resolved within each cell ) largely disappears .
skirt therefore only uses dust grids with a uniform density in each cell .
the first step in the life cycle of each stellar photon is the random generation of the location where it is emitted .
this means that we have to generate random positions from the three - dimensional probability distribution @xmath3 where @xmath4 is the luminosity density at the wavelength @xmath5 of the photon package .
as skirt is primarily focused towards modeling galaxies , we have done efforts to optimize the generation of random positions from arbitrary 3d probability functions .
the skirt code contains a library with common geometries for which the generation of a random position vector can be performed analytically .
these include spherical @xcite , @xcite or @xcite models , or axisymmetric power - law , exponential , sech or isothermal disc models .
for other frequently used luminosity density profiles , e.g. flattened @xcite or @xcite models , or more general density profiles that can not be described by an analytical function , such a direct analytical inversion is not possible .
two complementary approaches have been included in the skirt code to deal with generating random positions from such density profiles .
the first technique is to expand the density profile into a set of subcomponents .
skirt contains a routine to perform a multi - gaussian expansion ( mge ) of surface brightness distributions .
an mge expansion basically expands any surface brightness distribution as a finite sum of two - dimensional gaussian components .
the mge method has proven to be a very powerful tool for image analysis : even with a relatively modest set of gaussian components , @xmath6 , even complex geometries can be reproduced accurately .
one of the reasons why a mge expansion is very useful for skirt is that this approach enables a straightforward determination of the 3d spatial distribution : if the euler angles of the line of sight are known , the de - projection of a 2d gaussian distribution on the plane of the sky is a 3d gaussian distribution and the conversion formulae are completely analytical . generating random positions from a sum of 3d gaussian probability distributions is straightforward .
an example of this approach can be seen in figure [ sombrero.pdf ] , where we present a radiative transfer model for the sombrero galaxy based on the mge expansion of its surface brightness distribution presented by .
the second approach consists of sampling random positions directly from the stellar density distribution using the so - called stellar foam .
the stellar foam is a skirt structure based on the foam library developed by @xcite and @xcite .
foam is a self - adapting cellular monte carlo tool aimed at monte carlo integration of multi - dimensional functions , including integrands with an arbitrary pattern of singularities .
it achieves a high efficiency thanks to an intelligent division of the integration space into small simplical or hyper - rectangular form , which are created in a self - adaptive way by binary splitting .
it has originally been developed for use in high - energy physics ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , but it can also be adopted as a general - purpose monte carlo event generator .
we use an adapted version of the foam library for the generation of random positions from an arbitrary probability density @xmath7 .
one problem is that the probability density @xmath7 from which we want to generate random positions is typically defined on the entire 3d space , whereas foam requires a probability density on the @xmath8-dimensional unit hypercube @xmath9^n$ ] .
we achieve this through a coordinate transformation from the usual coordinates @xmath10 to new coordinates @xmath11 such that we map each infinite interval @xmath12 $ ] onto the unit interval @xmath9 $ ] .
the probability density @xmath7 , normalized such that @xmath13 is transformed to a new probability density @xmath14 this new density will be defined and normalized to one on the unit cube , @xmath15 there are many possible transformations we can apply to achieve this .
we have chosen the transformation [ barxyz ] @xmath16 with @xmath17 , @xmath18 and @xmath19 three scale parameters , which we can adapt for the specific probability density we are considering .
the inverse transformation is [ xyz ] @xmath20 and the jacobian reads @xmath21 summarizing , if we want to generate random positions @xmath22 from an arbitrary probability density @xmath7 , we first determine representative scale lengths @xmath17 , @xmath18 and @xmath19 along the three dimensions , and subsequently calculate the corresponding probability density @xmath23 using equations ( [ barp ] ) , ( [ xyz ] ) and ( [ jacobian ] ) .
the foam generator is applied to this new probability function to generate the random points @xmath24 , which are converted to the desired positions @xmath22 through the formulae ( [ xyz ] ) .
the construction of the stellar foam takes only a few seconds in two dimensions up to about one minute in three dimensions .
once a photon package has been generated at a random location ( sampled from the stellar density ) and it has been given a random propagation direction ( sampled randomly from the unit sphere ) , it is ready to start its journey through the dusty medium .
it has three possible fates : it can be absorbed by a dust grain at a certain position along its path , it can be scattered by a dust grain at a certain position on its path , or it can travel along its path through the system without any interaction .
the probability for each of these three options are determined by the scattering albedo @xmath25 and the optical depth @xmath26 along the path , defined as @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the extinction coefficient , @xmath29 is the dust density and the integral covers the entire path of the photon package through the dusty medium .
the most straightforward way to model these different physical processes in a monte carlo radiative transfer code is to generate randomly which of these three processes will take place . in case
the photon package leaves the system , its lifetime is terminated and a different package is launched . in the case of a scattering event , the position of the scattering event is determined by choosing a random path length from the appropriate probability distribution and a scattering event is simulated .
finally , in case it is absorbed , the position of the absorption is determined in a similar way , the luminosity of the photon package is stored in a local absorption rate counter attached to the dust cell where the absorption event took place , and the photon package s life is terminated .
these local absorption rates are used in a later stage of the simulation to estimate the local mean intensity of the isrf , necessary to calculate the thermal dust emission .
this traditional method has two significant drawbacks : along paths where the optical depth is modest , many photon packages will escape from the system without interactions , which will result in bad statistics of the scattered intensity and the absorbed luminosity . even if the photon packages do interact
, most interactions will take place on those sections of the path where the density is largest .
many absorption events are necessary in each cell to guarantee a high - quality estimate of the local absorption rate and the corresponding mean intensity . in dust cells with a low density ( such that only few absorptions take place ) and at wavelengths where the absorption rate is low
, this usually requires large numbers of photon packages .
these two problems can be minimized using the efficient combination of two clever monte carlo techniques : forced scattering and continuous absorption .
continuous absorption ( or lucy estimation ) is a technique to estimate the mean intensity of the isrf throughout the dusty medium .
the continuous absorption technique is designed to solve the problem of poor statistics in the absorption rate in low - density regions by spreading the absorption over all cells along the photon package s path instead of concentrating it in one single cell . a different but equivalent way to see
it is that the mean intensity in each cell is estimated using the sum of the path lengths covered by all photon packages that traverse that particular cell .
forced scattering is an old technique that was already implemented in the first monte carlo radiative transfer codes .
when applying forced scattering , photon packages are forced to interact with a dust grain before they leave the system .
this incorrect behavior is corrected for by decreasing the luminosity of the photon package . in most radiative transfer codes ,
forced scattering is considered only after an emission event and subsequent scattering events are unforced . in the skirt code
we always consider forced scattering , such that we have eternal forced scattering .
the combination of eternal forced scattering and continuous absorption results in a very efficient monte carlo routine . instead of determining randomly whether a photon package with luminosity @xmath30 will escape , will be absorbed or will be scattered , we split it into @xmath31 child photon packages ( with @xmath32 the number of dust cells along the path ) : one child photon package that will leave the system without interaction , one child photon package that will be scattered by a dust grain somewhere along the path , and @xmath32 children that will be absorbed , one in each of the @xmath32 cells along the path .
the luminosity of each of these children is easy to calculate : we find @xmath33 with @xmath34 the optical depth to the point on the path where the photon package would leave the @xmath35th dust cell .
obviously , we have @xmath36 in our monte carlo simulation , we now consider each of these @xmath31 child photon packages .
each one of the @xmath32 children with luminosity @xmath37 is absorbed in the @xmath35th cell along the path , which means that its luminosity is added to the absorption rate counter attached to this dust cell . the child photon package with luminosity @xmath38 escapes from the system , which implies that we do nt have to take this one into account anymore .
finally , the child photon package with luminosity @xmath39 is scattered somewhere along the path .
this is basically the only photon package that we need to follow up .
we still have to randomly determine the location of the scattering event along the path .
this is achieved by selecting a random optical depth @xmath40 from an exponential distribution over the finite range @xmath41 , i.e.@xmath42 and translate this randomly generated @xmath40 to a physical path length by solving the equation @xmath43 for @xmath44 .
once this path length has been determined , we can determine the position of the scattering event . if we then also determine a new propagation direction , determined randomly by generating a random direction from the scattering phase function , we are back at the starting point .
this child now becomes the parent , it can be split into children and we can repeat the same loop all over again .
summarizing , the net result of the combination of continuous absorption and eternal forced scattering is that after each emission / scattering event , we distribute a fraction of the photon package s luminosity among all the cells along the path , and we continue the monte carlo loop with a less luminous photon package that is always scattered at some point along the path .
hence , contrary to most monte carlo codes where the life cycle of a photon package ends when it either leaves the system or is absorbed , the photon packages in skirt can never leave the system .
the life cycle of a photon package ends when the package contains virtually no more luminosity .
typically we use the criterion that it must have lost 99.99% of its original luminosity , which immediately is the minimum level of absolute energy conservation of the simulation .
the goal of a monte carlo radiative transfer simulation is to simulate observable properties of a dusty system , i.e. images and spectral energy distributions .
skirt uses the technique of peel - off photon packages to create an arbitrary number of images / seds at different observing positions . peeling off
is a monte carlo technique designed to create high signal - to - noise images ( in particular scattered light images ) , adopted for the first time by @xcite and included in almost all state - of - the - art monte carlo radiative transfer codes .
after every emission or scattering event , the code calculates which fraction of the luminosity contained in the photon package would arrive at the observers locations and at which point on the plane of the sky , if the photon package would be emitted or scattered in the appropriate propagation direction .
repeating this for every photon package at every emission or scattering event implies that the maximum available information is obtained for a fixed set of photon packages and hence strongly increases the signal - to - noise compared to the more simple monte carlo codes where only photon packages that leave the system are recorded .
each skirt detector is basically an integral field detector , i.e. a data cube with two spatial and one wavelength dimension . in most monte carlo
radiative transfer codes the simulated detectors are natural , idealized representations of actual ccd detectors ( or a series of them at each wavelength ) .
they basically consist of a two- or three - dimensional array of pixels , which act as a reservoir for the incoming photon packages .
when a photon package leaves the system and arrives at the location of the observer , the correct pixel is determined and the luminosity of the photon package is added to the luminosity at that pixel . at the end of the simulation , the detector
is read out pixel by pixel and the surface brightness distribution is constructed . while this approach seems the most natural way to simulate the detection of photon packages in a monte carlo simulation , it might not be the most efficient
. we must be aware that , although we are simulating a real detection as closely as possible , we have more information at our disposal than real observers . the maximum information that a real observer can obtain ( in the theoretical limit of perfect noise - free observations and instruments ) when imaging with a ccd detector is the number of photon packages that arrive in each of his pixels . as numerical simulators , we have at our disposal the full information on the precise location of the impact of each photon package on the detector .
in order to use this information , we have considered the concept of smart detectors , which take full advantage of the exact location of the impact of the incoming photon packages @xcite .
the principle of these smart detectors is based on the estimate of the density distribution in smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations .
while preserving the same effective resolution and having virtually no computational overhead , smart detectors realize a noise reduction of about 10 percent .
a crucial aspect of the skirt code is the calculation of the dust emissivity . from the stellar emission phase we know the total amount of absorbed radiation @xmath45 at each wavelength in each cell of the dust domain . from this absorption rate
we can calculate the mean intensity of the isrf @xmath46 in each cell using @xmath47 where @xmath48 is the dust absorption coefficient , @xmath49 is the dust density and @xmath50 is the volume in cell number @xmath51 respectively .
knowledge of the mean intensity and the dust properties in each cell allows the dust emissivity @xmath52 to be determined .
skirt contains three different modules for the calculation of the dust emissivity , depending on the physical processes that are taken into account .
the simplest option is to consider the dust grains as a single species that is in local thermal equilibrium ( lte ) with the local isrf . in this case
, the dust emits as a modified blackbody radiator , @xmath53 where the dust equilibrium temperature @xmath54 of the @xmath51th dust cell is determined by the condition of thermal and radiative equilibrium , @xmath55 the second , somewhat more realistic option is to still consider lte for the dust grains , but taking into account that each species and size of dust grain reaches its own equilibrium temperature .
the skirt code allows to consider dust mixtures with an arbitrary number of grain species and size distributions .
the size distributions of the various dust species are subdivided into different bins , resulting in a dust mixture with @xmath56 populations , each of them corresponding to a dust species and a small size bin .
assuming lte for each individual population , the dust emissivity is given by a sum of modified blackbodies , where the temperature of each population is still determined by the condition of thermal and radiative equilibrium , @xmath57 with @xmath58 is the contribution of the @xmath59th dust population to the total absorption coefficient @xmath48 , and @xmath60 the equilibrium temperature of the @xmath59th population in cell number @xmath51 , determined by @xmath61 the third option , in fact the only realistic option to model the spectral energy distribution of galaxies , is to consider nlte dust emission . in theory ,
the transit from lte to nlte dust emission is not an enormous step .
the main difference is that each dust population is not characterized by a single equilibrium temperature , but by a temperature distribution .
once the temperature distribution function has been determined , the dust emissivity can easily be determined . as argued in the introduction ,
however , the practical inclusion of nlte dust emission in radiative transfer codes is a notoriously tough nut to crack . rather than develop our own routines to calculate the nlte emission for transiently heated grains , we have opted to couple the skirt code to the dustem code .
dustem is a publicly available , state - of - the - art numerical tool designed to calculate the nlte emission and extinction of dust given its size distribution , optical and thermal properties .
the code builds on the work by and uses an adaptive temperature grid on which the temperature distribution of the grains is calculated iteratively .
no lte approximation is made , i.e. even for large grains the temperature distribution is calculated explicitly .
one of the advantages why we have chosen to couple skirt to the dustem code is that the latter code has been designed to deal with a variety of grain types , structures and size distributions and that new dust physics ( ionization of pahs , polarized emission , spinning dust emission , temperature - dependent dust emissivity ) can easily be included . on the other hand ,
a consequence of choosing for a very complete and accurate nlte routine in which basically no simplifications or assumptions have been made , is that the computation load is substantial . for a typical dust model consisting of three or four dust species each with their size distribution , the calculation of the emissivity for a single isrf takes typically of the order of several seconds on a standard desktop / laptop computer .
while this is compatible with 1d or 2d simulations with up to @xmath62 cells , this is excessively long for general 3d simulations for which we have designed skirt . to overcome this problem ,
we have adopted a strategy based on a library of dust emissivity profiles , inspired by the work of .
their approach consists of three steps : they first run an exploratory radiative transfer simulation on a grid with a reduced number of grid cells , without taking dust re - emission into account .
this low - resolution simulation is used to determine the range of isrfs encountered in the simulation .
the second step consists of picking a small number @xmath63 of reference wavelengths @xmath64 ( typically @xmath65 ) .
the different isrfs found in step one are discretized onto logarithmic intervals at each of the reference wavelengths , and at each bin in the @xmath63-dimensional parameter space , the full nlte dust emission spectrum is calculated and stored in a library .
the final step in the simulation consists of running a radiative transfer simulation at the full resolution .
the dust emissivity at any given cell is found by looking at the isrf at the @xmath63 reference wavelengths and interpolating the dust emissivities from the library .
while valuable and inspiring , we see two drawbacks in the method as implemented by . in panchromatic radiative transfer simulations of galaxies , we typically solve the transfer equation at many uv / optical wavelengths , and hence have the isrf at all these wavelengths at our disposal at every grid cell .
it would be a pity not to use this information to determine the dust emissivity and only base our estimate on the value of the isrf at a very small number of reference wavelengths .
in particular , the isrf in monte carlo simulations can be noisy in certain cells ; when the dust emissivity is determined based on the value of the isrf at a small number of reference wavelengths , this noise could lead to a significant error .
using an estimate that exploits the available information at all wavelengths can minimize this error .
the second drawback is that the library method of requires an exploratory , low - resolution simulation in which the parameter space of isrfs is explored and the library of dust emissivities is built .
this extra simulation not only requires a computational overhead , it also creates the danger that it does not cover the entire range of strengths and shapes of the isrf .
for example , one can assume that the strongest isrf in a simulation is found in small dust cells very close to the heating sources .
in a low - resolution simulation , with larger dust cells , this strong isrf will be smoothed over the larger grid cells .
similarly , the weakest isrf ( or equivalently , the coldest dust ) in some simulations could be found in the inner regions of dense cores , and due to smoothing a low - resolution simulation might not reach these weakest isrf levels .
the result is that the low - resolution grid will not cover the full range of isrfs encountered in the high - resolution grid , and hence that the library of dust emissivities must be somehow extended to incorporate this missing part in the parameter space .
are aware of this inconvenience ( they discuss only the coldest spectrum as they concentrate on dark clouds illuminated by an external radiation field ) .
they argue that this problem is not expected to be significant , and that it could be relieved by using a low - resolution simulation with a slightly higher density .
still , it is clear that the use of a low - resolution grid leads to an additional overhead and complication and is a potential source of error , and it would be better to avoid it . to overcome both problems ,
we have taken a slightly different approach to implement our dust emissivity library .
the first step in our library approach is to calculate a number of parameters that characterize the isrf in each dust cell after the stellar emission phase . instead of the value of @xmath66 at a number of wavelengths ,
we use parameters that use combined information at all available wavelengths . from the various range of possibilities ,
we choose the lowest - order moments of @xmath67 , the product of the isrf and the dust absorption coefficient . instead of the actual zeroth - order moment or normalization of this function
, we consider the equivalent would - be equilibrium dust temperature @xmath68 of the dust mixture , found by solving the equation @xmath69 as a second parameter , we take the first - order moment @xmath67 , i.e. the mean wavelength , @xmath70 in skirt we limit ourselves to two parameters , but in principle this procedure can be extended to more parameters . with @xmath68 and @xmath71 calculated in each dust cell ,
we construct a 2d rectangular grid with @xmath72 pixels in the @xmath73 parameter space , based on the range of values encountered in the present simulation . in every parameter space pixel
we construct a reference isrf by averaging all isfrs that correspond to those particular values of @xmath68 and @xmath71 .
we experimented with different ways of averaging , including taking the straight mean , the median or the mean using sigma - clipping , but found no noticeable difference .
the final step of the library construction is to feed the reference isrfs to the dustem routine , and save each of the resulting dust emissivity profiles in the library .
once the library is constructed , finding the correct dust emissivity for a given dust cell is straightforward , as each dust cell is already connected to a certain pixel in the @xmath74 parameter space and hence a dust emissivity profile in the library .
while the very first version of skirt were written in fortran 77 , the code is now completely written in ansi c++ and currently contains some 30000 lines of code .
it uses the object - oriented nature of the c++ language extensively to support a strong modularity .
the use of inheritance and abstract classes renders the inclusion of new components ( such as new density distributions for the stars or dust , or new dust mixtures ) straightforward .
the dustem code is written in fortran 95 and has been slightly adapted to be coupled to skirt .
the entire skirt code is driven by a graphic user interface written in pyqt .
batch jobs can be run using a command line version with xml input files .
an important implementation aspect of skirt is the parallelism .
parallelism can typically work on two domains : data parallelism focuses on distributing the data across different parallel computing nodes , with the principle aim of enabling simulations that need more memory consumption than is available on a single node . task or control parallelism focuses on distributing execution processes ( threads ) across different parallel computing nodes with the principle aim of decreasing the run - time of a program .
ideally , both approaches can be combined .
monte carlo radiative transfer codes are easily parallelized in a task parallelism approach : the different levels of iterations can easily be split over different nodes .
skirt uses the openmp protocol to support task parallelism on shared - memory machines .
one of the advantages of openmp parallelism is the spectacularly low coding cost : less than 100 lines of code ( on a total of 30000 ) have been added to skirt to convert it from a serial into a parallel code .
the main parallelism is situated in the loop over wavelength , which implies that skirt runs both the stellar and dust phases at different wavelengths simultaneously .
one of the planned future developments of skirt is to look into the possibilities of using the mpi interface for data parallelism , in order to allow monte carlo simulations to be run on distributed memory systems .
data parallelism is much harder to achieve for monte carlo simulations than task parallelism .
the main reason is the non - local nature of the physical problem : each photon package in a simulation typically requires data from the entire physical domain ( read access to calculate the optical depth and write access to update the absorption rates ) .
contrary to e.g. grid - based hydrodynamic codes , distributing the dust cells over different parts of memory would imply an enormous overhead in communication between the different nodes . in principle , data parallelism could be achieved by splitting the data in the wavelength dimension , where different nodes contain different parts of the absorption rate counters of the dust grid and different parts of the detectors . however , in this approach a large amount of data ( such as the dust density grid ) would need to be shared / copied between the different nodes and communication overheads would be significant in the dust emission phase .
future work will investigate whether the benefits of distributed - memory parallelism can outweigh the communication overheads and the significant additional coding complexity .
we have run extensive tests to check the accuracy of the skirt code against other radiative transfer codes .
the early versions of the code were already tested against several other results , most importantly the set of spiral galaxy models by @xcite ( see e.g. * ? ? ? * ) .
we have successfully tested the lte version of skirt against the 1d and 2d lte circumstellar benchmark problems of @xcite and .
skirt is also one of the codes used in a new ongoing lte benchmark effort focusing on a disc galaxy environment ( baes et al . 2011 , in preparation ) .
the preliminary results , based on the results from five independent radiative transfer codes indicate excellent agreement , with relative differences in the seds around the 1% level or even below . as a full nlte
radiative transfer benchmark is not ( yet ) available at the moment , we have tested our nlte radiative transfer code , and particularly the library approach , using different models with gradually increasing levels of complexity . in order to run simulations in a realistic setting
, we adopt the sbc galaxy ugc4754 as a template model .
ugc4754 is a edge - on spiral galaxy , which has always been a favorite class of galaxies for radiative transfer modellers , as the dust is clearly visible both in absorption and emission .
this galaxy was one of the first large edge - on galaxies to be observed with the herschel space observatory as part of the herschel astrophysical terahertz large area survey ( h - atlas , * ? ? ? * ) science demonstration phase observations . in , we fitted a radiative model to the observed images of ugc4754 in the sdss and ukidss bands .
we subsequently used the skirt code to predict the galaxy s sed and images at fir wavelengths . while the radiative transfer model used in that paper was sufficient to serve its goal ( investigation of the dust energy balance ) , it suffered from two significant limitations : the assumptions of lte dust emission and of a smooth interstellar medium .
these two assumptions prevented us from making a self - consistent model covering the entire spectral region from the uv to mm wavelengths .
moreover , they also might introduce a significant source of uncertainty , as it has been demonstrated by several authors that the extinction properties of a clumpy interstellar medium can be significantly different from those of a smooth medium . in this section
we will gradually refine our model for ugc4754 from a smooth , 2d , lte model to a fully 3d model that includes nlte dust emission and a clumpy structure of the dusty ism .
the main objectives are to test the accuracy of our approach using a realistic setting , and to demonstrate the ability of skirt to run realistic 3d nlte radiative transfer calculations . for a full investigation of the dust energy balance in spiral galaxies , based on our refined skirt code and multi - wavelength imaging data ,
we refer to future work .
the starting point for our models is the best fitting , smooth 2d model from .
the stellar distribution consists of two components : a double - exponential stellar disc with a scale length of 4.05 kpc and a scale height of 330 pc , and a flattened srsic bulge with a major axis effective radius of 800 pc , a srsic parameter of 0.9 and an intrinsic flattening of 0.6 .
both components have a similar intrinsic sed , corresponding to a population of 8 gyr old with an exponentially decaying star formation rate and an initial burst duration of 0.15 gyr .
the total bolometric luminosity of the system is @xmath75 , of which the bulge contributes 8% .
the dust is also distributed in a double - exponential disc with a scale length of 6.1 kpc and a scale height of 270 pc .
the total amount of dust is characterized by the @xmath76-band edge - on optical depth of 0.73 , which corresponds to a total dust mass of @xmath77 .
contrary to where we used the @xcite model to describe the dust optical properties , we now use the @xcite dust model , as this model is embedded in the dustem library .
simulations are run on a wavelength grid with 181 grid points , with 101 grid points distributed logarithmically beween 0.05 and 5000 @xmath78 m and 80 additional grid points distributed logarithmically between 1 and 30 @xmath78 m to capture the pah peaks . for our 2d simulations , we considered an axisymmetric grid with 51 grid points in the radial direction and 51 grid points in the vertical direction , resulting in a total number of @xmath79 grid cells .
the grid points are chosen to have a power - law distribution , with an extent of 30 kpc ( 2 kpc ) for the radial ( vertical ) distribution and a size ratio of 30 between the innermost and outermost bins . in all skirt
runs discussed here , we used @xmath80 photon packages for each wavelength in both the stellar and the dust emission phase .
figure [ totalsed.pdf ] shows the resulting seds of two different skirt 2d simulations based on this model setup , as well as the observed galex , sdss , ukidss , iras and herschel fluxes for ugc4754 .
the blue curve shows the sed corresponding to a model assuming lte dust re - emission , where we took into account that different grain types and sizes reach different equilibrium temperatures .
the black curve shows the sed of the model that includes nlte dust re - emission using the library approach discussed in section [ dustemissivity.sec ] .
the red curve represents the flux of the model without dust extinction , the yellow line corresponds to the contribution of the dust to the sed in the nlte case .
it is logical that there is no difference between the lte and nlte models in the uv / optical / nir part of the sed , as only the dust emissivity differs between the models .
there is , however , a significant difference between the lte and nlte models in the mir / fir / submm window : in the lte models , all absorbed radiation is re - emitted as modified blackbody emission in the fir / submm region , whereas the nlte models emit part of the absorbed radiation in the mir region . between the dust seds of 2d nlte models for ugc4754 using the brute force ( bf ) approach and the library ( lib ) approach.,scaledwidth=48.0% ] to test the accuracy of our library approach , we ran a second nlte simulation , where we did not use the library approach , but where we calculated the dust emissivity in each cell by an explicit call to the dustem code .
the relative difference between the seds of the skirt nlte models using the library approach and the brute force approach is shown in figure [ bruteforce.pdf ] .
this figure convincingly shows that the library approach is accurate : the relative error is everywhere below 0.2% and in the region where the dust emission dominates even smaller .
the difference in run time between the two approaches is substantial , and this difference is only due to the difference in the number of calls to the dustem routine . in the brute force approach ,
the number of calls is obviously equal to @xmath81 ( or sometimes a bit less if there are empty dust cells ) .
the maximum number of calls to the dustem routine in the library approach is obviously @xmath72 , the number of pixels in the library parameter space . as the intensity of the isrf is the main parameter that drives the shape of the dust emissivity spectrum , it is appropriate to choose @xmath82 somewhat larger than @xmath83 ; the values we propose are @xmath84 and @xmath85 .
this infers a maximum of 250 calls to the dustem routine . in most cases ,
however , not the entire @xmath73 parameter space is covered , such that the number of calls is even further reduced . in the present simulation , we needed to call the dustem routine only 71 times in the library approach , compared to 2500 times in the brute force approach .
given that the average dustem run time is about 7 s ( on a typical desktop computer ) and that the overhead of the construction of the library is negligible , this makes a substantial difference .
it should be noted that 2500 calls is still a very manageable number , but the brute force approach becomes impossible when moving to 3d grids with several million cells .
for example , for a simulation with ten million dust cells , we would need a dustem computation time of more than 2 years on a single core computer , compared to several minutes using the library approach . between the dust seds using the mw isrf template ( tem ) approach and our library ( lib ) approach.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] between the dust seds using the mw isrf template ( tem ) approach and our library ( lib ) approach.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] as a final test and a demonstration of the necessity of our library approach , we ran our 2d simulation again , but now using a set of precomputed template emissivity profiles . in a sense
this mimics the approach taken by e.g. @xcite , although their approach is somewhat different as they calculate the emission by big grains using the lte approximation and only use a template for the small grains .
the basic idea of our template approach is that the dust emissivity from a cell depends only on a single parameter @xmath86 , being the integrated mean intensity of the isrf in the considered cell expressed in terms of the integrated mean intensity of the isrf in the milky way , @xmath87 for the isrf of the mw , the standard parameterization of is adopted .
we constructed a library of 501 dust emissivity profiles , corresponding to values of @xmath86 distributed logarithmically between @xmath88 and @xmath89 .
these dust emissivity profiles can be computed once and for all ( using the dustem routine ) and saved in a file . in the dust emission phase , we simply calculate @xmath86 in every dust cell and determine the dust emissivity profile using logarithmic interpolation between the precomputed library profiles .
this approach definitely has a strong appeal : it is straightforward to implement and very fast , as it requires only the calculation of @xmath86 and a simple interpolation of precomputed values . in this sense
it is more attractive than our library approach , which requires the construction of a library for every simulation .
the disadvantage of the template approach , however , is that only the strength and not the shape or hardness of the isrf is taken into account to calculate the dust emissivity .
as also argued by @xcite , the shape of the isrf can have a significant importance , both because of the differing cross - sections of grains of different sizes and because high - energy photons will excite larger thermal fluctuations than low - energy photons for a given value of @xmath86 . in figure [ milkywaylibrary.pdf ]
we show the comparison of the fixed template approach and our dynamic library approach ( dynamic in the sense that the library is tailored to the specific simulation ) .
the top panel shows the total sed and the dust emission sed for our 2d model for ugc4754 obtained using both approaches . at first sight ,
the seds agree fairly well ( definitely when plotted in log - log scale ) .
looking at the bottom panel , where we plot the relative difference of the dust emission sed corresponding to both approaches , we do see a significant difference , with relative deviations up to more than 40% .
here we have to give an important side note , in the sense that we believe that this 40% difference is actually a underestimate of the error one can make .
the shape of the intrinsic sed of the stellar population in our model is independent of position ; as a result , the variations in the shape of the isrf in different cells in the simulation are only the result of varying levels of absorption and scattering .
since the stellar population model we adopted for ugc4754 ( an 8 gyr old population with an exponentially decaying star formation rate and an initial burst duration of 150 myr ) is not very different from the average stellar population in the milky way , this implies that the shape of the isrf in the different cells in our model will on average be quite close to the shape of the milky way isrf .
as far as the comparison between our library approach and the milky way template approach concerns , we must hence conclude that ugc4754 simulations are not the strongest test . for systems with isrfs
which deviate much more from the average milky way isrf , such as starburst galaxies or circumstellar discs around young hot stars , we expect much larger differences than the 40% we obtained here .
having tested the accuracy of our library approach , we are ready to run full - scale 3d nlte radiative transfer models with skirt .
the first 3d model we consider has exactly the same set - up as the 2d nlte model , except that we now consider a uniform 3d cartesian grid . in the @xmath90 and @xmath91 directions
we consider 401 grid points each and a maximum extent of 30 kpc , in the vertical direction we use 61 grid points with a maximum extent of 2 kpc .
this results in @xmath92 grid cells , each with a dimension of 150 pc in the @xmath90 and @xmath91 directions and 66.7 pc in the vertical direction .
note that we need to store , at each dust grid cell , the entire isrf @xmath66 at each of the wavelength grid points , which basically turns our grid into a 4-dimensional grid structure with @xmath93 grid cells .
the memory required to run such a large - scale skirt radiative transfer simulation is about 23 gb . between the seds of 2d and 3d nlte models for ugc4754 .
the red curve corresponds to a 3d model with a uniform cartesian dust grid in all three dimensions , the blue curve corresponds to a 3d model with a power - law grid in the vertical direction , similar to the vertical grid structure of the 2d model.,scaledwidth=48.0% ] figure [ compare2d3d.pdf ] compares the sed of the smooth 2d and 3d models for ugc4754 .
the relative differences are below 2% in the entire uv - mm domain .
the existing small differences are mainly due to the discretization of the grid in the vertical direction : for the 2d model we used a vertical grid with a power - law distribution , with smaller bins close to the equatorial plane , where the dust density has the strongest gradients .
the innermost grid cell has a height of only 8.75 pc , compared to the 66.7 pc in the case of the 3d grid .
the result is that the discretization of the dust density on the 3d grid is much coarser . to demonstrate that this vertical grid distribution is the origin of this @xmath94 difference , we ran another 3d simulation where we now apply the same power - law distribution for the vertical grid cells as we did for the 2d model .
the relative differences between the sed of this model and the sed of the 2d simulation are also indicated in figure [ compare2d3d.pdf ] .
the reason why we considered a uniform cartesian dust grid is because such a grid forms the basis for a fully 3d model with a clumpy , two - phase dust distribution . to generate such a model
, we followed the strategy outlined by @xcite .
the dusty interstellar medium consists of two phases , a smooth inter - clump component and a clumpy component , and is characterized in terms of two parameters , namely the volume filling factor _
ff _ of the dense clumps and the density contrast @xmath95 between the clump and inter - clump medium .
the practical construction of the two - phase medium consists of randomly assigning a status ( clump or inter - clump ) to each dust cell in the dust medium .
typical values for the parameters @xmath95 and _ ff _ vary widely in the literature .
we use the values @xmath96 and @xmath97 in this work , which are within the range of typical parameters used in other studies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . between the seds of clumpy and smooth 3d nlte models for ugc4754.,scaledwidth=48.0% ] in figure [ clumpysmooth.pdf ]
, we show simulated images corresponding to the clumpy and smooth 3d models for the inner region of ugc4754 at three different wavelengths ( 0.55 , 24 and 500 @xmath78 m ) .
it is important to note that the pixel - to - pixel variations in the images on the bottom row are not due to poisson noise in the monte carlo routine , but represent real intensity variations due to the clumpy nature of the dust in the models .
figure [ compareclumpysmooth.pdf ] compares the total sed of the clumpy and smooth models .
the relative differences are below 6% in the entire uv - mm domain . at uv wavelengths ,
the clumpy model is slightly brighter than the smooth model , or put differently , slightly less uv radiation is absorbed by the dust .
this is in agreement with conclusions found by other authors : for a fixed amount of dust , a clumpy dust medium absorbs radiation less efficiently than a smooth dust medium ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
when moving to longer wavelengths , the difference between the smooth and clumpy models decreases , as the fraction of absorbed versus unattenuated radiation decreases with increasing wavelength . at nir wavelengths , there is virtually no difference anymore between the seds of the smooth and clumpy models . moving to mir and fir wavelengths
, we find that the clumpy model emits significantly less , particularly at wavelengths up to about 100 @xmath78 m .
this is no surprise , as the clumpy model was less efficient in absorbing uv and optical radiation .
the result is that , for the same total mass , the dust in a clumpy model is on average both cooler and less luminous than the dust in a smooth model .
we have presented an updated version of the 3d monte carlo radiative transfer code skirt .
the code uses various advanced optimization techniques , both well - known and novel ones , that make the monte carlo process orders of magnitude more efficient than the most basic monte carlo technique .
these techniques include an optimized combination of eternal forced scattering and continuous absorption , a multi - gaussian expansion technique and an efficient foam generator to generate random positions from the stellar density , and the use of peeling - off and smart detectors to create high signal - to - noise images and seds .
the main novelty of the new skirt code is the possibility to calculate the dust temperature distribution and the associated infrared and submm emission with a full incorporation of the emission of transiently heated grains and pah molecules . to achieve this
, we have chosen to link the skirt code to dustem , a publicly available , state - of - the - art numerical tool designed to calculate the nlte emission of arbitrary mixtures of dust grains .
the advantages of this approach is that no lte approximation is made , even for large grains , and that new physics ( such as spinning dust emission or a temperature - dependent dust emissivity ) can readily be included .
we have implemented a library approach to limit the computational cost of the nlte dust emission calculations inherent in dustem .
our approach is inspired by the work by , but uses a slightly different approach that makes maximum use of all information in the simulation to calculate the dust emissivity and avoids the need for additional low - resolution simulations .
we have tested the accuracy of the skirt code , in particular of our nlte library approach , through a set of simulations based on the edge - on spiral galaxy ugc 4754 , previously modelled by .
the models we ran were gradually refined from a smooth , 2d , lte model to a fully 3d model that includes nlte dust emission and a clumpy structure of the dusty ism .
using 2d models , we demonstrated the accuracy of our library approach : the relative differences in the sed between a model that uses the library approach and a model that uses brute force to calculate the dust emission are less than 0.2% at all wavelengths .
even for this 2d model with only 2500 dust cells , the difference in run time between both approaches are substantial ; for 3d grids with several million dust cells the brute force approach becomes impossible .
we have also explored the possibility to use a fixed set of precomputed dust emission templates instead of a dynamic library as the one we have chosen .
while a template approach has the advantage that it is easier to implement and faster to run , we have demonstrated that it leads to significant deviations due to the fact that it does not take into account the shape of the interstellar radiation field .
this highlights the need for a more advanced approach such as the library approach we propose .
we have subsequently applied the skirt code to calculate full - scale 3d nlte models for ugc 4754 .
we found small differences ( @xmath98% ) between 2d and 3d smooth models that are mainly due to differences in the vertical discretization of the internal grid .
finally , we have compared 3d models with a smooth and a clumpy interstellar dust medium .
we confirm the result found by other authors that , for a fixed amount of interstellar dust , a clumpy dust medium absorbs radiation less efficiently than a smooth dust medium . as a direct consequence ,
the dust in clumpy models is on average both cooler and less luminous , and the observed infrared emission of clumpy models is less than the emission at these wavelengths of smooth models with the same dust mass .
our simulations demonstrate that , given the appropriate use of optimization techniques , it is possible to efficiently and accurately perform monte carlo radiative transfer simulations of arbitrary 3d structures of several million dust cells , including a full calculation of the nlte emission by arbitrary dust mixtures .
this significantly increases the number of applications where detailed radiative transfer modeling can be used .
for example , we have started an investigation of the energy balance crisis in a set of edge - on spiral galaxies : our intention is to fit detailed radiative transfer models to uv / optical / nir images for a set of edge - on spiral galaxies , predict the resulting mir / fir / submm emission and compare these predictions with the available long wavelength data .
many other applications ( agns , circumstellar discs , merging galaxies , ) are possible , and the authors welcome all projects that can make use of skirt . | we present an updated version of skirt , a 3d monte carlo radiative transfer code developed to simulate dusty galaxies
. the main novel characteristics of the skirt code are the use of a stellar foam to generate random positions , an efficient combination of eternal forced scattering and continuous absorption , and a new library approach that links the radiative transfer code to the dustem dust emission library .
this approach enables a fast , accurate and self - consistent calculation of the dust emission of arbitrary mixtures of transiently heated dust grains and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons , even for full 3d models containing millions of dust cells .
we have demonstrated the accuracy of the skirt code through a set of simulations based on the edge - on spiral galaxy ugc4754 .
the models we ran were gradually refined from a smooth , 2d , lte model to a fully 3d model that includes nlte dust emission and a clumpy structure of the dusty ism .
we find that clumpy models absorb uv and optical radiation less efficiently than smooth models with the same amount of dust , and that the dust in clumpy models is on average both cooler and less luminous .
our simulations demonstrate that , given the appropriate use of optimization techniques , it is possible to efficiently and accurately run monte carlo radiative transfer simulations of arbitrary 3d structures of several million dust cells , including a full calculation of the nlte emission by arbitrary dust mixtures . |
our title clearly alludes to the story of columbus landing in what he called the west indies " , which later on turned out to be part of the new world " .
i have substituted antarctica in place of the new world " , following a quip from frank paige after he realized that i was talking all the time about _ penguins_. at the end of the millennium , we are indeed on another discovery voyage .
we are at the dawn of observing cp violation in the b system .
the stage is the emerging penguins .
well , had columbus seen penguins in _ his _ west indies " , he probably would have known he was onto something really new .
the em penguin ( emp ) @xmath0 ( and later , @xmath1 ) was first observed by cleo in 1993 .
alas , it looked and walked pretty much according to the standard model ( sm ) , and the agreement between theory and experiment on rates are quite good .
perhaps the study of cp asymmetries ( @xmath2 ) could reveal whether sm holds fully .
the strong penguins ( p ) burst on the scene in 1997 , and by now the cleo collaboration has observed of order 10 exclusive modes @xcite , as well as the surprisingly large inclusive @xmath3 mode .
the @xmath4 , @xmath5 and @xmath6 modes are rather robust , but the @xmath7 and @xmath8 rates shifted when cleo ii data were recalibrated in 1998 and part of cleo ii.v data were included .
the @xmath9 and @xmath10 modes are still being reanalyzed .
the nonobservation , so far , of the @xmath11 , @xmath12 and @xmath13 modes are also rather stringent .
the observation of the @xmath14 mode was announced in january this year , while the observation of the @xmath15 and @xmath16 modes were announced in march .
cleo ii.v data taking ended in february . with 10 million or so each of charged and neutral b s , new results are expected by summer and certainly by winter .
perhaps the first observation of direct cp violation could be reported soon .
with belle and babar turning on in may , together with the cleo iii detector upgrade all with @xmath17 separation ( pid ) capability !
we have a three way race for detecting and eventually disentangling _ direct _ cp violation in charmless b decays .
we expect that , during 19992002 , the number of observed modes may increase to a few dozen , while the events per mode may increase from 1070 to @xmath18@xmath19 events for some modes , and sensitivity for direct cp asymmetries would go from the present level of order 30% down to 10% or so .
it should be realized that _
the modes that are already observed _ ( @xmath20 ) _ should be the most sensitive probes . _ our first theme is therefore : _ is large @xmath2 possible in @xmath20 processes ? _ and , _
if so , whither new physics ?
_ however , as an antidote against the rush into the brave new world , we point out that the three observed @xmath21 modes may indicate that the
west indies " interpretation is still correct so far .
our second subject would hence be _ whither ewp ? now ! ?
_ that is , we will argue for the intriguing possibility that perhaps we already have some indication for the electroweak penguin ( ewp ) .
it is clear that 1999 would be an exciting landmark year in b physics .
so , work hard and come party at the end of the year / century / millennium celebration called third international conference on b physics and cp violation " , held december 3 - 7 in taipei @xcite .
we shall motivate the physics and give some results that have not been presented before , but refer to more detailed discussions that can be found elsewhere @xcite .
our interests were stirred by a _ rumor _ in 1997 that cleo had a very large @xmath2 in the @xmath6 mode .
the question was : _ how to get large @xmath2 ? _ with short distance ( bander - silverman - soni @xcite ) rescattering phase from penguin , the cp asymmetry could reach its maximum of order 10% around the presently preferred @xmath22 .
final state @xmath23 rescattering phases could bring this up to 30% or so , and would hence mask new physics . but
a 50% asymmetry seems difficult .
new physics asymmetries in the @xmath1 process @xcite and @xmath24 process @xcite are typically of order 10% , whereas asymmetries for penguin dominant @xmath20 transitions are expected to be no more than 1% .
the answer to the above challenge is to _ hit sm at its weakest ! _
* _ weak spot of penguin _ : dipole transition + -0.3 cm 0.8 cm 1.3 cm + note that these two terms are at same order in @xmath25 and @xmath26 expansion .
the effective charge " is @xmath27 which vanishes when the @xmath28 or @xmath29 goes on - shell , hence , only the @xmath30 dipole enters @xmath1 and @xmath31 transitions .
it is an sm quirk due to the gim mechanism that @xmath32 ( the former becoming @xmath33 coefficients in usual operator formalism for gluonic penguin ) .
hence one usually does not pay attention to the subdominant @xmath34 which goes into the variously called @xmath35 , @xmath36 , or @xmath37 coefficients . in particular , @xmath31 rate in sm is only of order 0.2% .
but if new physics is present , having @xmath38 is natural , hence the gluonic dipole could get greatly enhanced . while subject to @xmath1 constraint
, this could have great impact on @xmath39 process . *
_ blind spot of detector ! _ + because @xmath31 leads to _ jetty , high multiplicity _
@xmath20 transitions + -0.3 cm 0.8 cm 0.9 cm + at present , 510% could still easily be allowed .
the semileptonic branching ratio and charm counting deficits , and the strength of @xmath40 rate provide circumstantial _ hints _ that @xmath31 could be more than a few percent . * _ unconstrained new cp phase _ via @xmath41 +
if enhanced by new physics , @xmath34 is likely to carry a new phase + -0.27 cm 0.8
cm 0.9 cm + however , one faces a severe constraint from @xmath1 .
for example it rules out the possibility of @xmath42 as source of enhancement . but
as alex kagan @xcite taught me at last dpf meeting in minnesota , the constraint can be evaded if one has sources for radiating @xmath29 but not @xmath28 . *
uncharted territory of nonuniversal squark masses + susy provides a natural possibility via gluino loops : + -0.35 cm 0.9 cm 1.3 cm + the simplest being a @xmath43@xmath44 mixing model @xcite .
since the first generation down squark is not involved , one evades all low energy constraints .
this is a new physics cp model tailor - made for @xmath20 transitions . with the aim of generating huge cp asymmetries
, we can now take @xmath45 and study @xmath46 transitions at both inclusive and exclusive level @xcite . in both
we have used operator language .
one needs to consider the tree diagram , which carries the cp phase @xmath47 ; the standard penguin diagrams , which contain short distance rescattering phases ; the enhanced @xmath48 dipole ( susy loop induced ) diagram ; finally , diagrams containing @xmath49 loop insertions to the gluon self - energy which are needed to maintain unitarity and consistency to order @xmath50 in rate differences @xcite . at the inclusive level ,
one finds a @xmath31 pole " at low @xmath51 which reflects the jetty @xmath31 process that is experimentally hard to identify .
destructive interference is in general needed to allow the @xmath46 rate to be comparable to sm . but this precisely facilitates the generation of large @xmath2s !
more details such as figures can be found in @xcite .
dominant rate asymmetry comes from large @xmath51 of the virtual gluon . to illustrate this
, table i gives inclusive br ( arbitrarily cutoff at @xmath52 gev@xmath53 ) and @xmath2 for sm and for various new cp phase @xmath54 valus , assuming @xmath31 rate of order 10% .
one obtains sm - like branching ratios for @xmath55 , and @xmath2 also seem to peak . this becomes clearer in table ii where we give the results for @xmath56 , where @xmath57 ( perturbative ) rescattering is fully open .
we see that 2030% asymmetries are achieveable .
this provides support for findings in exclusive processes .
exclusive two body modes are much more problematic .
starting from the operator formalism as in inclusive , we set @xmath58 , take @xmath59 and try to _ fit observed brs _ with @xmath60 .
we then find the @xmath2 preferred by present rate data .
one finds that , analogous to the inclusive case , destructive interference is needed and in fact provides a mechanism to suppress the pure penguin @xmath61 mode to satisfy cleo bound . for the @xmath6 and @xmath7 modes which are p - dominated
, one utilizes the fact that the matrix element @xmath62 could be enhanced by low @xmath63 values ( of order 100120 mev ) to raise @xmath64 , which at same time leads to near degeneracy of @xmath6 and @xmath7 rates .
the upshot is that one finds rather large cp asymmetries , i.e. @xmath65 35% , 45% and 55% for @xmath7 , @xmath6 and @xmath13 modes , respectively , and all of the same sign .
such pattern can not be generated by sm , with or without rescattering .
we expect such pattern to hold true for many @xmath20 modes .
.inclusive br ( in @xmath66)/@xmath2 ( in % ) for sm and for @xmath67 . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] we have left out the prominent @xmath68 modes from our discussion largely because the anomaly contribution -0.35 cm 0.9 cm 1.3 cm to compute such diagrams , one needs to know the @xmath69 fock component of the @xmath70 meson !
this may be at the root of the rather large size of @xmath68 mode .
before we get carried away by the possibility of large cp asymmetries from new physics , there is one flaw ( or two ? ) that emerged after summer 1998 .
because of p - dominance which is certainly true in case of enhanced @xmath31 , @xmath8 is only half of @xmath71 .
the factor of 1/2 comes from @xmath72 , which is just an isospin clebsch factor that originates from the @xmath73 wave function .
although this seemed quite reasonable from 1997 data where @xmath8 mode was not reported , a crisis emerged in summer 1998 when cleo updated their results for the three @xmath21 modes .
they found @xcite @xmath74 instead !
curiously , @xmath75 also , which can not change the situation . in any case the expectation that @xmath76 can not make a factor of 2 change by interference . miraculously , however , this could be the first indication of the last type of penguin , the ewp .
the yet to be observed ewp ( electroweak penguin ) , namely @xmath77 , occurs by @xmath78 followed by @xmath79 .
the strong penguin oftentimes obscure the @xmath46 case ( or so it is thought ) , and to cleanly identify the ewp one has to search for pure " ewp modes such as @xmath80 , @xmath81 which are clearly rather far away .
one usually expects the @xmath82 mode to be the first ewp to be observed , which is still a year or two away , while clean and purely weak penguin @xmath83 is rather far away . with the hint from @xmath74 , however , and
putting back on our sm hat , we wish to establish the possibility that ewp may be operating behind the scene already @xcite .
it should be emphasized that , unlike the gluon , the @xmath84 coupling depends on isospin , and can in principle break the isospin factor of 1/2 mentioned earlier .
3.2 truein 3.2 truein -.2
cm we first show that simple @xmath23 rescattering can not change drastically the factor of two . from fig .
1(a ) , where we have adopted @xmath85 from current best fit " to ckm matrix @xcite , one clearly sees the factor of 2 between @xmath6 and @xmath8 .
we also not that rescattering , as parametrized by the phase difference @xmath86 between i = 1/2 and 3/2 amplitudes , is only between @xmath87 and @xmath88 .
when we put in the ewp contribution , at first sight it seems that the effect is drastic . on closer inspection at @xmath89 ,
it is clear that the ewp contribution to @xmath90 and @xmath6 modes are small , but is quite visible for @xmath8 and @xmath91 modes .
this is because the @xmath8 and @xmath91 modes suffer from @xmath92 suppression in amplitude because of @xmath73 wave function .
however , it is precisely these modes which pick up a sizable @xmath93 penguin contribution via the @xmath73 ( the strength of @xmath94 is roughly a quarter of @xmath95 and @xmath96 ) .
as one dials @xmath86 , @xmath87 and @xmath88 rescattering redistributes this ewp impact and leads to the rather visible change in fig . 1(b ) .
we notice the remarkable result that the ewp reduces @xmath6 rate slightly but raises the @xmath8 rate considerably , such that the two modes become rather close .
we have to admit , however , to something that we have sneaked in .
to enhance the relative importance of ewp , we had to suppress the strong penguin effect .
we have therefore employed a much heavier @xmath97 mev as compared to 100120 mev employed previously in new physics case .
otherwise we can not bring @xmath6 and @xmath8 rates close to each other .
3.2 truein 3.2 truein
-.2 cm having brought @xmath6 and @xmath8 modes closer , the problem now is that @xmath7 lies above them , and the situation becomes worse for large rescattering . to remedy this , we play with the phase angle @xmath28 which tunes the weak phase of the tree contribution t. setting now @xmath89 , again we start without ewp in fig .
the factor of two between @xmath6 and @xmath8 is again apparent .
dialing @xmath28 clearly changes t - p interference . for @xmath28 in first quadrant one has destructive interference , which becomes constructive in second quadrant .
this allows the @xmath6 mode to become larger than the pure penguin @xmath7 mode , which is insensitive to @xmath28 . however ,
nowhere do we find a solution where @xmath74 is approximately true .
there is always one mode that is split away from the other two .
putting in ewp , as shown in fig .
2(b ) , the impact is again quite visible .
as anticipated , the @xmath6 and @xmath8 modes come close to each other .
since their @xmath28 dependence is quite similar , one finds that for @xmath98@xmath99 , the three observed @xmath21 modes come together as close as one can get , and are basically consistent with errors allowed by data .
note that @xmath8 is never larger than @xmath6 .
we emphasize that a large rescattering phase @xmath86 would destroy this achieved approximate equality , as can be seen from fig .
3 , where we illustrate @xmath86 dependence for @xmath100 .
it seems that @xmath86 can not be larger than @xmath101 or so .
3.2 truein -.2 cm 3.2 truein 3.2 truein -.2 cm as a further check of effect of the ewp , we show the results for @xmath89 in fig .
4 . in absence of rescattering ,
the change in rate ( enhancement ) for @xmath8 mode from adding ewp is reflected in a dilution of the asymmetry , which could serve as a further test .
this , however , depends rather crucially on absence of rescattering .
once rescattering is included , it would be hard to distinguish the impact of ewp from cp asymmetries .
however , even with rescattering phase , the @xmath28 dependence of cp asymmetries can easily distinguish between the two solutions of @xmath102 and @xmath103 , as illustrated in fig .
5 , where ewp effect is included . from our observation that a large @xmath86 phase would destroy the near equality of the three observed @xmath21 modes that we had obtained , we find that @xmath104 even with presence of rescattering phase @xmath86 .
3.2 truein 3.2 truein -.2
cm it should be emphasized that the @xmath28 value we find necessary to have @xmath71 is in a different quadrant than the present best
fit " result of @xmath105@xmath106 .
in particular , the sign of @xmath107 is preferred to be negative rather than positive .
an extended analysis @xcite to @xmath108 , @xmath109 and @xmath110 modes confirm this assertion .
intriguingly , the size of @xmath15 and @xmath16 @xcite was anticipated via this @xmath28 value .
perhaps hadronic rare b decays can provide information on @xmath28 , and present results seem to be at odds with ckm fits @xcite to @xmath111 , @xmath112 , @xmath113 mixing , and in particular the @xmath114 mixing bound , which rules out @xmath115 .
e prepared for violation ! !
we first illustrated the possibility of having @xmath116@xmath117 from new physics in _ already observed modes _
, such as @xmath21 , @xmath118 , and @xmath119 mode when seen .
our existence proof " was the possibility of enhanced @xmath31 dipole transition , which from susy model considerations one could have a new cp phase carried by @xmath120 .
note that this is just an illustration .
we are quite sure that nature is smatter .
we then made an about - face and went back to sm , and pointed out that the ewp may have already shone through the special slit " of @xmath74 , where we inferred that @xmath98@xmath99 is preferred , which implies that @xmath115 , contrary to current ckm fit " preference .
see talks by f. w " urthwein and y. gao , these proceedings , hep - ex/9904008 .
please see the web page http://www.phys.ntu.edu.tw / english / bcp3/. g.w.s .
hou , hep - ph/9902382 , expanded version of proceedings for 4th international workshop on particle physics phenomenology , kaohsiung , taiwan , r.o.c .
, june 1998 ; and workshop on cp violation , adelaide , australia , july 1998 .
hou and k.c .
yang , phys .
lett . * 81 * , 5738 ( 1998 ) .
m. bander , d. silverman and a. soni , phys .
lett . * 43 * , 242 ( 1979 ) .
l. wolfenstein and y.l .
wu , phys .
. lett . * 73 * , 2809 ( 1994 ) .
w.s . hou and b. tseng , phys .
* 80 * , 434 ( 1998 ) .
kagan , _ phys .
_ d*51 * , 6196 ( 1995 ) .
x.g . he and w.s .
hou , phys .
* b 445 * , 344 ( 1999 ) .
chua , x.g .
he and w.s .
hou , phys . rev . d*60 * , 014003 ( 1999 ) . j .-
grard and w.s .
hou , phys .
lett . * 62 * , 855 ( 1989 ) ; phys .
rev . d*43 * , 2909 ( 1991 ) .
m. artuso et al .
( cleo collaboration ) , cleo conf 98 - 20 .
deshpande et al . , phys .
. lett . * 82 * , 2240 ( 1999 ) .
f. parodi , p. roudeau and a. stocchi , hep - ph/9802289 .
hou and k.c .
yang , hep - ph/9902256 . | discovery voyage into the age of : |
boutet de monvel s calculus @xcite is a pseudodifferential calculus on manifolds with boundary .
it includes the classical differential boundary value problems as well as the parametrices to elliptic elements .
many operator - algebraic aspects of this algebra ( spectral invariance , noncommutative residues and traces , composition sequence , @xmath14-theory ) have been studied recently @xcite .
the problem of identifying this algebra as the pseudodifferential algebra ( or as an ideal of one ) of a lie groupoid may be the key to an effective application of the methods of noncommutative geometry .
if that is acomplished , one could then seek for extensions of the calculus , and for a better understanding of its index theory @xcite .
basic definitions and certain facts about boutet de monvel s algebra are recalled in section [ bdmc ] .
the groupoid approach to pseudodifferential calculus was developed in noncommutative geometry , following the seminal work of a. connes for foliations @xcite .
the guiding principle in that approach is that the central object in global analysis is a groupoid . to study a particular situation , for a class of singular manifolds for instance
, one needs to define a groupoid adapted to the context and then use the general pseudodifferential tools for groupoids , as developed in @xcite .
this has been applied to the context of manifolds with corners , with the goal of studying melrose s @xmath15-calculus ( see @xcite ) .
groupoids were defined whose pseudodifferential calculi recover the @xmath15-calculus and the cusp - calculus .
basic definitions and certain facts about pseudodifferential calculus on groupoids are recalled in section [ psi ] .
the starting point of this work is the following result ( see @xcite ) : the kernel of the principal symbol map for boutet de monvel s calculus is equal to the norm closure @xmath16 of the ideal of singular green operators . since in the pseudodifferential calculus on a groupoid
, the @xmath6-algebra of the groupoid is the kernel of the principal symbol map , this gives a hint that finding a groupoid whose @xmath6-algebra is @xmath17 could give some insight about the relationship between the boutet de monvel algebra and groupoid pseudodifferential algebras . besides , @xmath16 fits into a short exact sequence ( see ( * ? ? ?
* section 7 ) ) : @xmath18 which is similar to that for pseudodifferential operators on smooth manifolds : @xmath19 in section [ sgoi ] , we show that @xmath2 is actually morita - equivalent to the norm - closure @xmath7 of the algebra of pseudodifferential operators on the boundary . since @xmath2 is a stable , it is thus isomorphic to @xmath20 . on the other hand , we define in section [ gr - sgo ] a groupoid whose @xmath6-algebra contains an ideal @xmath21 which fits in an extension analoguous as that of @xmath20 . by showing in section [ main ] that the @xmath22-theory elements induced by these extensions coincide , we infer from a theorem by voiculescu that @xmath2 and @xmath21 are isomorphic .
let @xmath23 denote a compact manifold of dimension @xmath24 with boundary @xmath25 and interior @xmath26 .
given a pseudodifferential operator @xmath27 , defined on an open neighborhood @xmath28 of @xmath23 , and @xmath29 , one defines @xmath30 as equal to the restriction to @xmath26 of @xmath31 , where @xmath32 is the extension of @xmath33 to @xmath28 which vanishes outside @xmath23 . in general
, singularities may develop at the boundary , and one gets only a mapping @xmath34 .
one says that @xmath27 has the _ transmission property _ if the image of the truncated operator @xmath35 is contained in @xmath36 ( a subspace of @xmath37 ) .
this was defined by boutet de monvel in @xcite , where he proved that the transmission property for a classical ( polyhomogoneous ) pseudodifferential operator is equivalent to certain symmetry conditions for the homogeneous components of the asymptotic expansion of its symbol at the boundary .
later @xcite , he constructed an algebra whose elements are operators of the form @xmath38 where @xmath27 is a pseudodifferential operator on @xmath23 satisfying a condition that ensures the transmission property , @xmath39 is a pseudodifferential operator on @xmath25 , while @xmath1 , @xmath14 and @xmath40 belong to classes of operators he then defined and named , respectively , singular green , poisson and trace operators .
we call an operator as in ( [ bdmo ] ) a boutet de monvel operator . for detailed expositions of his calculus ,
we refer to @xcite .
a boutet de monvel operator has an _ order _ , roughly the usual order of pseudodifferential operators .
the entries @xmath40 and @xmath1 have , moreover , an integer _ class _ assigned to them .
the class of a trace operator is related to the order of the derivatives that appear in the boundary - value conditions it prescribes .
one must assign a class also to singular green operators due to the fact that the composition @xmath41 is a singular green operator .
there exist isomorphisms between suitable sobolev spaces such that the composition of a given operator of arbitrary order and class with one of them has order and class zero .
for index theory purposes it is therefore sufficient to consider operators of order and class zero .
these form an adjoint invariant subalgebra of the algebra @xmath42 of all bounded operators on a suitable hilbert space @xmath43 . adopting the definition of order in @xcite for @xmath14 and @xmath40 , we here choose @xmath44 .
if , as does grubb @xcite , one keeps the original definition ( which makes more sense if one needs general @xmath45 estimates ) then one must take a sobolev space of order @xmath46 over the boundary .
boutet de monvel operators can also be defined as mappings between smooth sections of vector bundles .
if @xmath47 is a bundle of positive rank over @xmath23 , and @xmath48 is an arbitrary bundle over @xmath25 , then the algebra of all boutet de monvel operators of order and class zero acting between sections of @xmath47 and @xmath48 is morita equivalent ( * ? ? ? * section 1.5 ) to the algebra obtained by taking a rank - one trivial bundle over @xmath23 and the zero - bundle over @xmath25 .
this partly justifies , again if one is interested in index theory , to consider only the operators appearing in the upper - left corner of the matrix in ( [ bdmo ] ) and to assume , as we did at the beginning , that the bundle over @xmath23 is @xmath49 .
the problem of computing the fredholm index of a boutet de monvel operator acting between sections of different bundles over each side can be reduced to the case of equal bundles on both sides by a device developed by boutet de monvel @xcite , recalled in ( * ? ? ?
* section 1.1 ) .
let us now explain what a singular green operator @xmath1 is , in the case of order and class zero and of a rank - one trivial bundle over @xmath23 .
its distribution kernel is smooth outside the boundary diagonal ; i.e , if @xmath50 , and if we denote by @xmath51 the operator of mulitiplication by @xmath52 , then @xmath53 and @xmath54 are integral operators with smooth kernels .
the push - forward of @xmath1 by a boundary chart is an operator - valued - symbol pseudodifferential operator on the variables tangential to the boundary , as we describe below .
it is perhaps worth stressing , however , that it is in general not a pseudodifferential operator on all variables , because of its particular way of acting on the normal variable . given @xmath55 , @xmath56 , let @xmath57 denote the vector - valued fourier transform of @xmath33 with respect to the @xmath58 first variables , @xmath59 in local coordinates for which the boundary corresponds to @xmath60 and the interior to @xmath61 , @xmath1 is given by @xmath62 the integrals in ( [ ft ] ) or in ( [ defg ] ) should be regarded , for fixed @xmath63 or @xmath64 , respectively , as @xmath65-valued integrals . for each @xmath66 ,
@xmath67 in ( [ defg ] ) is an integral operator with kernel @xmath68 equal to the restriction to @xmath69 of a function belonging to the schwartz space of rapidly decreasing functions on @xmath70 .
the function @xmath71 ( called by grubb the _ symbol - kernel _ of @xmath1 ) is smooth and satisfies the estimates ( * ? ? ?
* ( 1.2.38 ) ) .
this is invariantly defined ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2.4.11 ) with respect to coordinate changes that preserve the set @xmath72 .
we denote by @xmath73 the set of all polyhomogeneous operators @xmath74 of order and class zero on @xmath23 , and by @xmath75 its subset of all singular green operators .
it follows from the rules of boutet de monvel s calculus that @xmath73 is an algebra and that @xmath75 is an ideal in @xmath73 . in the sequel
, we shall restrict ourselves to coordinate changes which preserve the variable @xmath76 , i.e. , we choose a normal coordinate . then two * -homomorphisms are defined on @xmath73 , the principal symbol and the boundary principal symbol : @xmath77 the principal symbol of a given @xmath74 is , by definition , the usual principal symbol of @xmath27 @xmath78 where @xmath79 is the leading term in the aymptotic expansion of the symbol of @xmath27 . at a point @xmath80 in @xmath13 , the boundary principal symbol of @xmath35 is defined to be the truncated fourier multiplier @xmath81 of symbol @xmath82 .
the boundary principal symbol of @xmath83 is the integral operator @xmath84 with the rapidly decreasing kernel @xmath85 , where @xmath86 denotes the leading term in the asymptotic expansion of @xmath87 , cf .
* ( 1.2.39 ) ) . then @xmath88 maps @xmath75 into @xmath89 , with the ideal @xmath90 of compact operators on @xmath65 .
let @xmath91 and @xmath2 denote the norm closures of @xmath73 and @xmath75 , respectively ; and let @xmath92 denote the set of all compact operators on @xmath93 .
it follows from theorem 1 in @xcite that @xmath94 and @xmath88 can be extended to @xmath6-algebra homomorphisms @xmath95 moreover , by corollary 2 in @xcite and ( * ? ? ?
* theorems 5 and 6 ) , we have that : @xmath96 and @xmath97 maps @xmath2 onto @xmath98 .
in other words , the restriction of the boundary principal symbol to @xmath2 gives rise to the exact sequence of c@xmath99-algebras @xmath100 in section [ sgoi ] we use ( [ pses ] ) to prove that @xmath2 is isomorphic to the tensor product @xmath9 of the @xmath6-closure @xmath7 of the pseudodifferential operators of order zero on @xmath25 by the compacts .
for that we need to use trace and poisson operators .
similarly as for the singular green operators , the trace operators and the poisson operators ( @xmath40 and @xmath14 in ( [ bdmo ] ) ) are , locally , operator - valued - symbol pseudodifferential operators on the variables tangential to the boundary , given by @xmath101 and @xmath102 the mappings @xmath103 and @xmath104 are defined , for each @xmath105 , each @xmath106 and each @xmath107 , by @xmath108 and @xmath109(x_n)= \alpha \tilde k(x^\prime , x_n,\xi^\prime).\ ] ] for each @xmath66 , @xmath110 and @xmath111 are restrictions to @xmath112 of functions in the schwartz class on @xmath113 .
the functions @xmath114 and @xmath115 , called the symbol - kernels of @xmath40 and @xmath14 , are smooth and satisfy certain estimates . in the polyhomogenous case
, they have asymptotic expansions in homogeneous components , whose leading terms we denote by @xmath116 and @xmath117 , respectively . the estimates and expansions for @xmath118 and @xmath119 listed or explained in ( * ? ? ?
* section 1.2 ) are not the right ones for our definition of order ( and consequent choice of hilbert space ) : we need to shift some of the exponents there by @xmath120 .
the boundary - principal symbols of @xmath40 and @xmath14 are @xmath121 defined as in ( [ defst ] ) and ( [ defsk ] ) , except that @xmath116 and @xmath117 replace @xmath118 and @xmath119 .
lastly , the boundary principal symbol of a polyhomogeneous pseudodifferential operator on @xmath25 is simply its usual principal symbol , and we get a * -homomorphism @xmath122 where @xmath123 denotes the set of all polyhomogeneous boutet de monvel operators of order and class zero on @xmath23 .
it has a continuous extension to the norm - closure of @xmath123 , but we will not use this fact .
[ es1 ] there exists a zero - order poisson operator @xmath14 such that @xmath124 is a strictly positive operator on @xmath125 .
_ proof _ : it is well - known that the dirichlet problem @xmath126 defines a bounded invertible operator .
we denote by @xmath127 an order reduction of order 3/2 on @xmath25 and by @xmath128 and order reduction of order @xmath129 on @xmath23 .
this gives us an isomorphism @xmath130 which is an element of order and class 0 in boutet de monvel s calculus .
its inverse therefore also is in boutet de monvel s calculus ; it is of the form @xmath131 with suitable @xmath132 , and @xmath14 of order and class zero . in particular , @xmath14 is a right inverse for the trace operator @xmath133 . for @xmath134
we thus have @xmath135 we then get @xmath136 for some @xmath137 , so that @xmath124 is strictly positive . @xmath138
[ es2 ] there exist a trace operator of order and class zero @xmath139 and a poisson operator of order zero @xmath140 such that @xmath141 is equal to the identity operator on @xmath125 , @xmath142 and @xmath143 .
_ proof _ : let @xmath144 be a zero - order poisson operator such that @xmath145 is a strictly positive operator on @xmath125 , and let @xmath146 .
@xmath147 is a zero - order pseudodifferential operator on @xmath25 .
take @xmath148 and @xmath149 .
@xmath138 we denote by @xmath7 the norm closure of the algebra of all polyhomogeneous pseudodifferential operators of order zero on @xmath25 , and by @xmath150 the continuous extension of the principal - symbol homomorphism .
it is well - known ( this is mentioned in @xcite and follows from ( * ? ? ?
* theorem a.4 ) , or from ( * ? ? ? * theorem 3.3 ) ) that @xmath151 induces the short exact sequence of @xmath6-algebras @xmath152 where @xmath153 denotes the ideal of compact operators on @xmath125 . by lemma [ es2 ]
a @xmath6-homomorphism @xmath154 can be defined by @xmath155 since @xmath156 is compact if @xmath157 is compact , we can use @xmath158 to couple the sequences ( [ pses ] ) and ( [ as ] ) .
together they yield the commutative diagram of exact sequences of @xmath6-algebras @xmath159 [ here ] the homomorphism @xmath158 imbeds @xmath7 as a hereditary subalgebra of @xmath17 . _ proof
_ : we have to prove , that if @xmath160 then @xmath1 is again of the form @xmath161 with @xmath162 . since @xmath41 acts as the identity on @xmath163 it also acts as the identity on @xmath1 and we therefore get @xmath164
. @xmath138 [ full ] let @xmath165 be a commutative diagram of short exact sequences , where @xmath166 and @xmath167 are embeddings .
then @xmath168 is full provided that @xmath169 and @xmath167 are full . _
proof _ : we have to prove that the two - sided ideal generated by @xmath170 is dense in @xmath171 .
we thus have to prove that to a given @xmath172 and a given @xmath173 we can find an element @xmath15 in the twosided ideal generated by the image of @xmath168 such that @xmath174 . since @xmath167 is full we can find an element @xmath175 in the twosided ideal generated by @xmath176 such that @xmath177 .
the element @xmath175 can be lifted to an element @xmath178 in the twosided ideal generated by @xmath179 and we can therefore find an element @xmath180 such that @xmath181 . since @xmath169 is full
there is an element @xmath182 in the twosided ideal generated by @xmath183 with @xmath184 . as the desired @xmath15 we can therefore choose @xmath185.@xmath138 the algebras @xmath17 and @xmath186 are isomorphic .
_ proof _ : by lemma [ here ] , the diagram [ cd ] and lemma [ full ] the imbedding @xmath158 is full and hereditary .
it follows from the remark below theorem 8 on page 155 in @xcite that @xmath17 and @xmath7 are strongly morita equivalent . by the results in @xcite and @xcite we have @xmath187
is isomorphic to @xmath186 .
however @xmath17 is stable since it is the extension of @xmath188 with a stable algebra , namely @xmath189 , ( see proposition 6.12 in @xcite ) .
this gives the isomorphism.@xmath138
groupoids were introduced in the context of global analysis when a. connes showed that in the case of foliations the index takes values in a which is defined as the of the holonomy groupoid of the foliation .
he defined a pseudodifferential calculus on a foliation using the groupoid structure .
in several papers ( @xcite ) , generalizations of this approach to a larger class of groupoids were achieved .
one particular aspect of this theory is that , as a. connes showed in @xcite for smooth manifolds , it is possible to define the analytic index using a groupoid , the _ tangent groupoid_. a groupoid is a small category in which all morphisms are invertible .
this means that a groupoid @xmath1 has a set of units , denoted by @xmath190 , and two maps called _ range _ and _ source _ , @xmath191^{r } \ar@<-.5ex>[r]_{s } & \g0}$ ] .
two elements @xmath192 are composable if and only if @xmath193 : we recall briefly the main aspects of this theory .
let @xmath1 be a lie groupoid , which means that it has a smooth structure .
then one can define an algebra of pseudodifferential operators @xmath194 : a pseudodifferential operator on @xmath1 is a @xmath1-equivariant continuous family of pseudodifferential operators on the fibers of @xmath1 .
for example , if @xmath195 is a manifold without boundary , and @xmath196 , with set of units @xmath197 , and range and source maps @xmath198 , and composition @xmath199 , then @xmath194 is the algebra of pseudodifferential operators on @xmath195 .
if @xmath1 is a lie group , @xmath194 is the algebra of @xmath1-equivariant pseudodifferential operators on @xmath1 . in order to work with singular manifolds ,
the framework of lie groupoids needs to be extended . that was done in @xcite , where the algebras of pseudodifferential operators on continuous family groupoids , which are groupoids whose fibers are smooth manifolds , were defined . on the algebra of pseudodifferential operators
one can define a symbol map , @xmath94 .
the algebra of order 0 operators can be completed as a , denoted by @xmath200 , and the symbol map extends to this algebra .
the `` regularizing operators '' of the calculus , which are the operators with trivial symbol , are the elements of the of the groupoid , and we have the following atiyah - singer exact sequence : @xmath201 where @xmath202 is the cosphere bundle of the lie algebroid @xmath203 , which can be thought of as a tangent space .
we next recall in more detail the construction of the adiabatic groupoid @xmath204 associated with a smooth manifold @xmath25 : @xmath205 with the tangent bundle @xmath206 of @xmath25 .
the groupoid structure is given as follows : @xmath207 @xmath208 this groupoid is endowed with a differential structure , through an exponential , in the following way : * on @xmath209 , the structure is that of a product of manifolds . *
define a map on an open neighborhood @xmath210 of @xmath211 in @xmath212 , with values in @xmath204 , by @xmath213 in other terms , the topology is such that a sequence of terms @xmath214 of @xmath209 converges to @xmath215 , if and only if we have locally @xmath216 note that a. connes tangent groupoid is just the restriction of @xmath204 to @xmath217 $ ] .
the main interest of this groupoid is that it provides a way to define the analytic index .
consider indeed the decomposition of the groupoid as an open and a closed subgroupoid , which gives rise to the exact sequence : @xmath218 this simplifies since @xmath219 , and @xmath220 .
a. connes proved that the boundary map of the 6-terms exact sequence induced by this extension is nothing but the analytic index @xmath221
suppose we could identify the @xmath6-closure of boutet de monvel s algebra with the @xmath6-algebra @xmath0 of pseudodifferential operators on a lie groupoid @xmath1 .
then , as pointed out above , the kernel of the principal symbol map would be isomorphic to @xmath3 .
as the kernel of the principal symbol map in boutet de monvel s calculus consists of the singular green operators , we thus wish to identify these with the of a groupoid . we will actually not identify them with a groupoid , but with an ideal in a groupoid .
let us consider the following action of the group @xmath222 on @xmath204 : * on @xmath206 , @xmath222 acts by dilations : @xmath223 * on @xmath209 , @xmath222 acts by @xmath224 .
this is a continuous action : if @xmath225 converges to @xmath226 ( which means that @xmath227 ) , then @xmath228 since @xmath229 it is thus possible to construct the semi - direct product @xmath230 of the adiabatic groupoid by @xmath231 : as a set , it is @xmath232 , with set of units @xmath233 , such that : * @xmath234 , for @xmath235 ; * @xmath236 , for @xmath237 ; * @xmath238 * @xmath239 note that the action of @xmath240 on the adiabatic groupoid induces an action on its and that j. renault proved in @xcite that for any locally compact groupoid @xmath17 one has @xmath241 the evaluation at @xmath237 provides a map @xmath242 .
also , the evaluation at the zero - section @xmath243 induces a map @xmath244 .
but since the action of @xmath222 on @xmath25 is trivial , the latter algebra is just the algebra of the ( regular ) product : @xmath245 let @xmath246 and @xmath247 .
the kernel of @xmath248 is @xmath249 .
but @xmath250 is directly isomorphic to the pair groupoid @xmath251 : to clarify the proof , let us denote @xmath252 and @xmath253 .
then let @xmath254 be defined by @xmath255 this a morphism of groupoids : the composition of @xmath256 with @xmath257 gives @xmath258 , and @xmath259 while @xmath260 hence the kernel of @xmath248 is just the algebra of compact operators , @xmath188 . to make this clear , here is the commutative diagram describing this : @xmath261 & 0 \ar[d]&\\ 0 \ar[r ] & \mathcal{k } \ar[r ] \ar@{=}[d ] & \mathcal i \ar[r ] \ar[d ] & c \ar[r ] \ar[d]^{j } & 0\\ 0 \ar[r ] & \mathcal{k } \ar[r ] & c^*(g ) \ar[r]^<<<<<{e_0 } \ar[dr ] & c_0(t^*y)\rtimes { \mathbb r}^*_+ \ar[r ] \ar[d]^{r_0 } & 0\\ & & & c_0(y\times { \mathbb r}^*_+ ) & \\ } \ ] ] we will use this diagram and extension theory to prove that @xmath10 is isomorphic to the algebra of singular green operators .
@xmath262 is isomorphic to @xmath263 , where @xmath13 is the sphere bundle in @xmath264 .
first of all notice that @xmath262 is isomorphic to @xmath265 : indeed , the exact sequence @xmath266 induces the exact sequence @xmath267 but @xmath268 , so that @xmath269 and @xmath270 now @xmath271 where we again used renault s result for the second isomorphism and the isomorphism of @xmath272 with the pair groupoid @xmath273 for the third .
this ends the proof .
we have just shown that @xmath10 is an extension of @xmath274 by @xmath188 , and this is also the case for the algebra of s. the main result is the following : it remains to show that the extensions give rise to the same element of @xmath293 .
but since @xmath294 is separable , @xmath295 is isomorphic to the group of invertibles of @xmath296 , thanks to a result of kasparov ( @xcite ) .
the @xmath263 being nuclear , @xmath296 is actually a group , thus it is isomorphic to @xmath295 .
it induces the extension @xmath303 whose class is denoted by @xmath304 .
the relation between @xmath305 and @xmath306 is made clear by considering the following exact sequence @xmath307 where @xmath308 is the ball bundle over @xmath25 .
its class is denoted by @xmath309 , and one has the well - known equality : @xmath310 for the convenience of the reader , we now recall the diagram ( [ diagram ] ) : @xmath311 & \mathcal{k } \ar[r ] \ar@{=}[d ] & \mathcal i \ar[r ] \ar[d ] & c \ar[r ] \ar[d]^{j } & 0 & ( \partial)\\ 0 \ar[r ] & \mathcal{k } \ar[r ] & c^*(g ) \ar[r]^<<<<<{e_0 } \ar[dr ] & c_0(t^*y)\rtimes { \mathbb r}^*_+ \ar[r ] \ar[d]^{r_0 } & 0 & ( \alpha)\\ & & & c_0(y\times { \mathbb r}^*_+ ) & & \\ } \ ] ] let us denote the class of the first sequence by @xmath312 ; it is thus given by the kasparov product : @xmath313 consider the following commutative diagram : @xmath311 & c_0(t^*y\setminus y ) \ar[r ] \ar[d ] & c_0(b^*y\setminus y ) \ar[r ] \ar[d ] & c(s^*y ) \ar[r ] \ar@{=}[d ] & 0\\ \label{eq1 } 0 \ar[r ] & c_0(t^*y ) \ar[r ] \ar[d ] & c(b^*y ) \ar[d ] \ar[r ] & c(s^*y ) \ar[r ] & 0\\ & c(y ) \ar@{=}[r ] & c(y ) & & \\
\label{eq2 } } \ ] ] the first exact sequence actually decomposes as @xmath315 so that its @xmath316-class is the identity of @xmath317 .
there is an action of @xmath222 on each algebra of the previous diagram , which is trivial on @xmath318 and @xmath319 .
this gives the following : @xmath311 & c_0(t^*y\!\setminus\ !
y)\!\rtimes { \mathbb r}^*_+ \ar[r ] \ar[d]^{j } & c_0(b^*y\!\setminus\ !
y)\!\rtimes { \mathbb r}^*_+ \ar[r ] \ar[d ] & c(s^*y\times { \mathbb r}^*_+ ) \ar[r ] \ar@{=}[d ] & 0 & ( \partial_1)\\ \label{eq1a } 0 \ar[r ] & c_0(t^*y)\!\rtimes { \mathbb r}^*_+ \ar[r ] \ar[d ] & c(b^*y)\rtimes { \mathbb r}^*_+ \ar[d ] \ar[r ] & c(s^*y\times{\mathbb r}^*_+ ) \ar[r ] & 0 & ( \varphi)\\ & c(y\times{\mathbb r}^*_+ ) \ar@{=}[r ] & c(y\times{\mathbb r}^*_+ ) & & & \\ \label{eq2a } } \ ] ] denote by @xmath320 ( resp .
@xmath52 ) the class of the first ( resp .
second ) exact sequence of this diagram , and by @xmath321 the element induced by @xmath322 .
one has thus the equality @xmath323 so that @xmath324 but @xmath325 is the image of @xmath326 under the thom - connes isomorphism , and @xmath320 is also a thom - connes element in @xmath22-theory .
hence the classes in @xmath316 of the extensions of @xmath21 and of @xmath186 are the same .
voiculescu s theorem implies that these algebras are isomorphic .
lars hrmander .
pseudo - differential operators and hypoelliptic equations . in
_ singular integrals ( proc
pure math .
x , chicago , ill . , 1966 ) _ , pages 138183 .
soc . , providence , r.i . , 1967 . | can boutet de monvel s algebra on a compact manifold with boundary be obtained as the algebra @xmath0 of pseudodifferential operators on some lie groupoid @xmath1 ? if it could , the kernel @xmath2 of the principal symbol homomorphism would be isomorphic to the groupoid @xmath3 .
while the answer to the above question remains open , we exhibit in this paper a groupoid @xmath1 such that @xmath3 possesses an ideal @xmath4 isomorphic to @xmath2 .
in fact , we prove first that @xmath5 with the @xmath6-algebra @xmath7 generated by the zero order pseudodifferential operators on the boundary and the algebra @xmath8 of compact operators . as both @xmath9 and @xmath10 are extensions of @xmath11 by @xmath12 ( @xmath13 is the co - sphere bundle over the boundary ) we infer from a theorem by voiculescu that both are isomorphic . |
the mixed volume is one of the fundamental notions in the theory of convex bodies .
it plays a central role in the brunn
minkowski theory and in the theory of sparse polynomial systems .
the mixed volume is the polarization of the volume form on the space of convex bodies in @xmath2 .
more precisely , let @xmath7 be @xmath8 convex bodies in @xmath2 and @xmath9 the euclidean volume of a body @xmath10 .
then the mixed volume of @xmath11 is @xmath12 where @xmath13 denotes the minkowski sum of bodies @xmath14 and @xmath15 .
it is not hard to see that the mixed volume is symmetric and multilinear with respect to minkowski addition .
also it coincides with the volume on the diagonal , i.e. @xmath16 and is invariant under translations .
moreover , it satisfies the following _ monotonicity property _
, which is not apparent from the definition , see ( * ? ? ?
* ( 5.25 ) ) .
if @xmath17 are convex bodies such that @xmath18 for @xmath19 then @xmath20 the main goal of this paper is to give a geometric criterion for strict monotonicity in the class of convex polytopes .
we give two equivalent criteria in terms of essential collections of faces and mixed cells in mixed polyhedral subdivisions , see theorem [ t : main2 ] and theorem [ t : main3 ] .
the criterion is especially simple when all @xmath21 are equal ( corollary [ c : mv = v ] ) which is the situation in our application to sparse polynomial systems . in the general case of convex bodies
this is still an open problem , see @xcite for special cases and conjectures .
the role of mixed volumes in algebraic geometry originates in the work of bernstein , kushnirenko , and khovanskii , who gave a vast generalization of the classical bezout formula for the intersection number of hypersurfaces in the projective space , see @xcite . this beautiful result which links algebraic geometry and convex geometry through toric varieties and sparse polynomial systems
is commonly known as the bkk bound . in particular , it says that if @xmath22 is an @xmath8-variate laurent polynomial system over an algebraically closed field @xmath23 then the number of its isolated solutions in the algebraic torus @xmath24 is at most @xmath25 , where @xmath26 are the newton polytopes of the @xmath27 .
( here @xmath28 denotes @xmath29 . ) systems that have precisely @xmath30 solutions in @xmath24 must satisfy a _
non - degeneracy condition _ which means that certain subsystems have to be inconsistent , see theorem [ t : bkk ] .
let @xmath22 be a laurent polynomial system over @xmath23 with newton polytopes @xmath5 . replacing each @xmath27 with a generic linear combination of @xmath31 over @xmath23 produces an equivalent system with the same number of solutions in @xmath24 .
such an operation replaces each individual newton polytope @xmath26 with the convex - hull of their union , @xmath32 .
thus , starting with a system for which @xmath33 , one obtains a system with all newton polytopes equal to @xmath34 and which has less than @xmath35 solutions in @xmath24 , i.e. is degenerate .
the geometric criterion of corollary [ c : mv = v ] allows us to characterize such systems without checking the non - degeneracy condition , which could be hard .
in fact , theorem [ t : ber ] delivers a simple characterization in terms of the coefficient matrix @xmath36 and the augmented exponent matrix @xmath37 of the system ( see section [ s : pol ] for definitions ) . in particular
, it says that if @xmath34 has a proper face such that the rank of the corresponding submatrix of @xmath36 is less than the rank of the corresponding submatrix of @xmath37 then the system has less than @xmath35 isolated solutions in @xmath24 .
here is another consequence of theorem [ t : ber ] .
if no maximal minor of @xmath36 vanishes then the system has the maximal number @xmath35 of isolated solutions in @xmath24 ( corollary [ c : nice ] ) .
this can be thought of as a generalization of cramer s rule for linear systems .
this project began at the einstein workshop on lattice polytopes at freie universitt berlin in december 2016 .
we are grateful to mnica blanco , christian haase , benjamin nill , and francisco santos for organizing this wonderful event and to the harnack haus for their hospitality .
in this section we recall necessary definitions and results from convex geometry and set up notation .
in addition , we recall the notion of essential collections of polytopes for which we give several equivalent definitions , as well as define mixed polyhedral subdivisions and the combinatorial cayley trick . throughout the paper we use
@xmath38 $ ] to denote the set @xmath39 . for a convex body @xmath14 in @xmath2
the function @xmath40 , given by @xmath41 is the _ support function _ of @xmath14 .
we sometimes enlarge the domain of @xmath42 to @xmath43 . for every @xmath44 , we write @xmath45 to denote the supporting hyperplane for @xmath14 with outer normal @xmath46 @xmath47 we use @xmath48 to denote the face @xmath49 of @xmath14 .
let @xmath50 be the @xmath8-dimensional mixed volume of @xmath8 convex bodies @xmath7 in @xmath2 , see ( [ e : mv ] ) above .
we have the following equivalent definition .
* theorem 5.1.7)[t : mv ] let @xmath51 be non - negative real numbers . then @xmath52 is a polynomial in @xmath51 whose coefficient of the monomial @xmath53 equals @xmath50 .
let @xmath54 be convex bodies in @xmath2 , not necessarily distinct .
we say that a multiset @xmath55 is an _ essential collection _ if for any subset
@xmath56 $ ] of size at most @xmath8 we have @xmath57 note that every sub - collection of an essential collection is essential .
also @xmath58 , where @xmath14 is repeated @xmath59 times , is essential if and only if @xmath60 .
the following is a well - known property of essential collections .
* theorem 5.1.8)[t : essential ] let @xmath7 be @xmath8 convex bodies in @xmath2 .
the following are equivalent : 1 .
@xmath61 ; 2 .
there exist segments @xmath62 for @xmath19 with linearly independent directions ; 3 .
@xmath63 is essential .
another useful result is the inductive formula for the mixed volume , see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 5.1.7 , ( 5.19 ) ) .
we present a variation of this formula for convex polytopes .
let @xmath14 be a convex body and @xmath64 convex polytopes in @xmath2 .
given @xmath65 , let @xmath66 denote the @xmath67-dimensional mixed volume of @xmath68 translated to the orthogonal subspace @xmath69 .
then we have @xmath70 note that the above sum is finite , since there are only finitely many @xmath65 for which @xmath71 is essential .
namely , these @xmath46 are among the outer unit normals to the facets of @xmath72 .
let @xmath73 be convex polytopes .
the _ cayley polytope _
@xmath74 is the convex hull in @xmath75 of the union of the polytopes @xmath76 for @xmath77 , where @xmath78 is the standard basis for @xmath79 .
a finite polyhedral subdivision of @xmath80 is called _ mixed _ if it corresponds to a polyhedral subdivision of @xmath74 with vertices in @xmath81 via the map sending a polytope @xmath82 of the subdivision of @xmath74 to the polytope @xmath83 , where @xmath84 is the image by the projection @xmath85 of @xmath86 .
the polytope @xmath82 is determined by @xmath87 ( and vice versa ) and will be denoted @xmath88 .
this correspondence is called the _ combinatorial cayley trick _ , see @xcite for instance .
a mixed polyhedral subdivision of @xmath80 is called _ pure _ if the corresponding subdivision of @xmath74 is a triangulation .
let @xmath83 be a polytope in a pure mixed polyhedral subdivision of @xmath80
. then all @xmath89 are simplices and @xmath90 .
the polytope @xmath87 , as well as the corresponding simplex @xmath88 of the triangulation of @xmath74 , is called _ fully mixed _ if @xmath91 for @xmath92
. when @xmath93 , the polytope @xmath87 is fully mixed if and only if @xmath94 and @xmath95 for @xmath92 so that @xmath87 is an @xmath8-dimensional parallelotope .
the following result is well - known , see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2.4 ) or ( * ? ? ? * theorem 6.7 ) .
we include a proof for reader s convenience .
[ l : key ] for convex polytopes @xmath96 in @xmath2 , the quantity @xmath97 is equal to the sum of the euclidean volumes of the fully mixed polytopes in any pure mixed polyhedral subdivision of @xmath98 .
consider a triangulation @xmath99 of @xmath100 and let @xmath101 . to any simplex @xmath102 of @xmath99 , we associate the simplex @xmath103 ) .
the image of this map is a triangulation of @xmath104
. then we may compute the euclidean volume of @xmath105 as the sum of the euclidean volumes of the polytopes in the corresponding pure mixed subdivision : @xmath106 the latter equality coming from the fact that @xmath99 is a triangulation .
the coefficient of @xmath107 in the last expression is precisely the total euclidean volume of the fully mixed polytopes in our fully mixed subdivision , and by theorem [ t : mv ] coincides with the mixed volume of @xmath5 .
in this section we present our first criterion for strict monotonicity of the mixed volume and its corollaries .
let @xmath14 be a subset of a convex polytope @xmath108 and let @xmath109 be a facet .
@xmath14 touches @xmath110 _ when the intersection @xmath111 is non - empty .
we will often make use of the following proposition , which gives a criterion for strict monotonicity in a very special case , see @xcite .
[ p : mix ] let @xmath112 be convex polytopes in @xmath2 and @xmath113
. then @xmath114 if and only if @xmath115 touches every face @xmath116 for @xmath46 in the set @xmath117 the above statement easily follows from ( [ e : induct ] ) and the observation @xmath118 with equality if and only if @xmath115 touches @xmath119
. see ( * ? ? ?
* sec 5.1 ) for details .
here is the first criterion for strict monotonicity .
[ t : main2 ] let @xmath0 and @xmath1 be convex polytopes in @xmath2 such that @xmath120 for every @xmath121 $ ]
. given @xmath65 consider the set @xmath122 \
|\ p_i \text { touches } q^u_i \}.\ ] ] then @xmath123 if and only if there exists @xmath65 such that the collection @xmath124\setminus t_u\}$ ] is essential .
assume that there exists @xmath65 such that the collection @xmath124\setminus t_u\}$ ] is essential .
note that @xmath125 is a proper subset of @xmath38 $ ] , otherwise @xmath126 is a collection of @xmath8 polytopes contained in translates of an @xmath67-dimensional subspace , hence , can not be essential . without loss of generality
we may assume that @xmath38\setminus t_u=\{1,\dots , k\}$ ] for some @xmath127 .
since @xmath26 does not touch @xmath128 for @xmath92 there is a hyperplane @xmath129 which separates @xmath26 and @xmath128 .
let @xmath130 be the half - space containing @xmath26 .
then the truncated polytope @xmath131 satisfies @xmath132 .
we claim that the collection @xmath133 is essential .
indeed , by assumption there exist @xmath8 segments @xmath134 with linearly independent directions such that @xmath135 for @xmath136 . among the first @xmath137 of these segments no more than one can be parallel to @xmath46 , hence , by projecting them along @xmath46 , translating , and possibly reordering
, we may assume that @xmath138 for @xmath139 .
since the direction vectors of @xmath140 are linearly independent in the orthogonal subspace @xmath69 , the collection in ( [ e : new ] ) is essential . now by proposition [ p : mix ]
we obtain @xmath141 finally , by monotonicity we have @xmath142 and @xmath143 .
therefore , @xmath144 conversely , assume @xmath123 .
then , by monotonicity , for some @xmath145 we have @xmath146 by proposition [ p : mix ] there exists @xmath65 such that @xmath147 is essential and @xmath148 . by choosing a segment in @xmath149 not parallel to @xmath69 ( which exists since @xmath150 , but @xmath151 does not touch @xmath152 ) we see that @xmath153 is essential .
it remains to notice that @xmath154 for @xmath155 and , hence , the collection @xmath124\setminus t_u\}$ ] is essential as well .
[ r : full - dim ] note that if @xmath1 are @xmath8-dimensional then we can simplify the criterion of theorem [ t : main2 ] as follows : @xmath123 if and only if there exists @xmath65 such that the collection @xmath126 is essential .
[ ex:2-dimth ] for @xmath156 theorem [ t : main2 ] says that @xmath157 if and only if , up to reordering , there exists a facet ( i.e. a side ) @xmath119 such that the corresponding face @xmath158 is not touched by @xmath159 .
a particular instance of theorem [ t : main2 ] , especially important for applications to polynomial systems , is the case when @xmath0 are arbitrary polytopes and @xmath160 , where @xmath34 is the convex hull of the union @xmath6 .
we will assume that @xmath34 is @xmath8-dimensional , otherwise @xmath161 is not essential and , hence , both @xmath162 and @xmath163 are zero .
then the strict monotonicity has the following simple geometric interpretation .
[ c : mv = v ] let @xmath0 be polytopes in @xmath2 contained in an @xmath8-dimensional polytope @xmath34
. then @xmath164 if and only if for some @xmath165 $ ] there exist @xmath166 polytopes among @xmath0 that do not touch a codimension @xmath166 face of @xmath34 . by theorem [ t : main2 ] and remark [ r : full - dim ]
, we have @xmath164 if and only if there exists @xmath65 such that the collection @xmath167 , where @xmath168 is repeated @xmath169 times , is essential .
the last condition is equivalent to @xmath170 , which gives @xmath171 where @xmath166 is the codimension of @xmath168 .
this precisely means that there exist @xmath166 polytopes among the @xmath26 which do not touch @xmath168 .
corollary [ c : mv = v ] can be reformulated as follows .
let @xmath0 be polytopes in @xmath2 contained in an @xmath8-dimensional polytope @xmath34 .
then @xmath164 if and only if there is a proper face of @xmath34 of dimension @xmath172 which is touched by at most @xmath172 of the polytopes @xmath0 . in particular , if a vertex of @xmath34 does not belong to any of the polytopes @xmath96 , then @xmath164 . [ ex:2-dimcor ] let @xmath173 be convex polytopes in @xmath174 and @xmath34 be the convex hull of their union
. then corollary [ c : mv = v ] shows that @xmath175 if and only if either @xmath115 or @xmath159 does not touch some side of @xmath34 .
one can obtain a more direct proof of corollary [ c : mv = v ] by modifying the proof of theorem 2.6 in @xcite .
[ ex : first ] let @xmath176 be a finite set in @xmath2 with @xmath8-dimensional convex hull @xmath34 and choose a subset @xmath177 . define @xmath178 for @xmath19 and let @xmath26 be the convex hull of @xmath179
. then corollary [ c : mv = v ] leads to @xmath180 . indeed ,
if @xmath181 $ ] has size @xmath166 and @xmath182 is a face of codimension @xmath166 , then @xmath183 and @xmath184 .
therefore , the subsets @xmath185 and @xmath186 can not be disjoint , i.e. the union of any @xmath166 of the @xmath26 touches every codimension face of @xmath34 .
going back to the statement of corollary [ c : mv = v ] it is natural to ask : if there is a codimension @xmath166 face of @xmath34 not touched by more than @xmath166 polytopes among @xmath5 , can the inequality @xmath164 be improved ?
the answer is clearly no if we do not restrict ourselves to the class of _ lattice polytopes_. recall that for any collection of lattice polytopes @xmath0 the normalized mixed volume @xmath187 is an integer .
we have the following improvement of corollary [ c : mv = v ] in this case .
[ p : stronger ] let @xmath0 be lattice polytopes in @xmath2 contained in an @xmath8-dimensional lattice polytope @xmath34 .
suppose there exists a facet @xmath188 which is not touched by @xmath189 , for some @xmath190 .
moreover , suppose that @xmath191 then @xmath192 . by the essentiality of @xmath191 and
since @xmath193 it follows that for any @xmath194 the collection @xmath195 , where @xmath168 is repeated @xmath196 times , is essential . by proposition [ p : mix ]
we obtain @xmath197 now to obtain @xmath192 we use ( [ e : claim ] ) successively with @xmath198 : @xmath199 multiplying each of the above terms by @xmath200 we get a decreasing sequence of @xmath201 integers , the last being no less than @xmath202 , which provides the required inequality .
we remark that the essentiality conditions above can not be removed .
indeed , let @xmath203 be the standard @xmath8-simplex , @xmath168 one of its facets , and @xmath204 for @xmath19 .
then if @xmath205 equal the vertex of @xmath34 not contained in @xmath168 , then @xmath206 regardless of @xmath59 .
it would be interesting to obtain a more general statement than proposition [ p : stronger ] which deals with faces of larger codimension . given a polytope @xmath34 , corollary [ c : mv = v ] provides a characterization of collections @xmath5 such that @xmath204 for @xmath19 and @xmath207 .
clearly , when @xmath34 and the @xmath26 are lattice polytopes there are only finitely many such collections . describing them explicitly is a hard combinatorial problem . in the case
when @xmath34 is the standard simplex , @xmath203 , this problem was solved by esterov and gusev in @xcite .
in this section we obtain another criterion for the strict monotonicity property ( theorem [ t : main3 ] ) based on mixed polyhedral subdivisions and the combinatorial cayley trick .
recall that for polytopes @xmath208 in @xmath2 , we have @xmath209 if and only if the collection @xmath210 is essential , which is equivalent to @xmath211 for all @xmath181 $ ] , see theorem [ t : essential ] .
we now describe a generalization of this criterion .
consider again polytopes @xmath212 for @xmath213 .
for any non - zero vector @xmath214 consider the convex polytopes @xmath215 [ t : main3 ] let @xmath0 and @xmath1 be convex polytopes in @xmath2 such that @xmath120 for every @xmath121 $ ] .
the following conditions are equivalent : 1 .
@xmath216 , 2 .
there exists a fully mixed simplex with vertices in @xmath217 which is contained in the closure of @xmath218 , 3 . there exists a non - zero vector @xmath214 such that the collection @xmath219 is essential . consider a fully mixed simplex @xmath220 and let @xmath221 be the corresponding fully mixed polytope in the mixed subdivision of @xmath222 .
then @xmath223 is contained in the closure of @xmath218 if and only if there is a supporting hyperplane of @xmath100 which separates the convex sets @xmath100 and @xmath223 .
this is equivalent to the existence of @xmath224 with @xmath225 such that @xmath226 we note that is equivalent to @xmath227 , and so @xmath228 , for @xmath213 .
since @xmath229 have linearly independent directions , this gives that @xmath219 is essential .
this shows the equivalence between @xmath230 and @xmath231 . assuming that @xmath232 is a fully mixed simplex verifying , it is easy to show the existence of a triangulation of @xmath233 with vertices in @xmath217 which contains @xmath223 and restricts to a triangulation of @xmath100 . by the combinatorial cayley trick
, this gives a pure mixed subdivision @xmath234 of @xmath235 restricting to a pure mixed subdivision @xmath236 of @xmath98 and a fully mixed polytope @xmath237 contained in @xmath238 .
therefore , @xmath239 by lemma [ l : key ] .
the implication @xmath240 is proved .
assume now that @xmath239 .
by proposition [ p : mix ] there exists @xmath65 such that @xmath147 is essential and @xmath148 ( see the proof of theorem [ t : main2 ] ) .
thus we may choose a segment @xmath241 , segments @xmath242 for @xmath243 , and segments @xmath244 for @xmath245 such that the corresponding @xmath8 direction vectors are linearly independent .
this shows that @xmath219 is essential since @xmath246 and @xmath247 are contained in @xmath248 for @xmath213 .
we have proved the implication @xmath249 .
note that if @xmath26 touches @xmath128 then @xmath250 and if @xmath26 does not touch @xmath128 then @xmath251 .
therefore , the condition ( 3 ) in the above theorem is equivalent to the condition in theorem [ t : main2 ] .
consider a finite set @xmath252 where @xmath253 .
let @xmath254 be the coordinates of @xmath255 for @xmath256 .
consider a laurent polynomial system with coefficients in an algebraically closed field @xmath23 @xmath257 where @xmath258 and as usual @xmath259 stands for the monomial @xmath260 .
we shall assume that no polynomial @xmath27 is the null polynomial .
call @xmath261 the _ individual support _ of @xmath27 and @xmath262 the _ total support _ of the system .
the _ newton polytope _
@xmath26 of @xmath27 is the convex hull of @xmath179 and the _ newton polytope _
@xmath34 of the system is the convex hull of @xmath176 .
the matrices @xmath263 are the _ coefficient _ and _ exponent _ matrices of the system , respectively .
choose @xmath65 and let @xmath264 .
then the _ restricted system _ corresponding to @xmath46 is the system @xmath265 where @xmath266 with @xmath267 if @xmath268 and @xmath269 , otherwise .
finally , a system ( [ e : system ] ) is called _ non - degenerate _ if for every @xmath65 the corresponding restricted system is inconsistent .
the relation between mixed volumes and polynomial systems originates in the following fundamental result , known as the bkk bound , discovered by bernstein , kushnirenko , and khovanskii , see @xcite .
[ t : bkk ] the system has at most @xmath270 isolated solutions in @xmath24 counted with multiplicity .
moreover , it has precisely @xmath270 solutions in @xmath24 counted with multiplicity if and only if it is non - degenerate .
systems with fixed individual supports and generic coefficients are non - degenerate .
moreover , the non - degeneracy condition is not needed if one passes to the toric compactification @xmath271 associated with the polytope @xmath272 .
namely , a system has at most @xmath270 isolated solutions in @xmath271 counted with multiplicity , and if it has a finite number of solutions in @xmath271 then this number equals @xmath273 counted with multiplicity .
there are two operations on that preserve its number of solutions in the torus @xmath24 .
first , left multiplication of @xmath36 by an invertible matrix of @xmath274 produces an equivalent system .
the second operation consists in multiplying each equation by a given monomial and making a monomial change of coordinates of @xmath24 .
this second operation corresponds to left multiplication of the _ augmented exponent matrix _
@xmath275 ( obtained from @xmath108 by adding a first row of @xmath276 ) by a matrix in @xmath277 . [
r : left ] consider a non - degenerate system with coefficient matrix @xmath36
. left multiplication of @xmath36 by an invertible matrix preserves the total support of the system , but does not preserve the individual supports and newton polytopes in general .
however , since this operation produces an equivalent system , theorem [ t : bkk ] shows that the mixed volumes of the corresponding @xmath8-tuples of newton polytopes are equal .
assume that has precisely @xmath278 solutions in @xmath24 counted with multiplicity and @xmath36 has a non - zero maximal minor .
up to renumbering , we may assume that this minor is given by the first @xmath8 columns of @xmath36 .
left multiplication of by the inverse of the corresponding submatrix of @xmath36 gives an equivalent system with invidual supports @xmath279 for @xmath19 .
thus this new system has precisely @xmath280 solutions in @xmath24 counted with multiplicity . by theorem [ t : bkk ]
this number of solutions is at most @xmath281 , where @xmath282 is the convex hull of @xmath283 . on the other hand , by monotonicity of the mixed volume we have @xmath284 .
we conclude that @xmath285 .
the second equality is also a consequence of corollary [ c : mv = v ] , see example [ ex : first ] .
[ t : ber ] assume @xmath286 . if a system has @xmath287 isolated solutions in @xmath24 counted with multiplicity , then for any proper face @xmath110 of @xmath34 the submatrix @xmath288 of @xmath36 with columns indexed by @xmath289 \ , , \ , a_j \in
f \cap { { \mathcal{a}}}\}$ ] satisfies @xmath290 or equivalently , @xmath291 conversely , if is satisfied for all proper faces @xmath110 of @xmath34 and if the system is non - degenerate , then it has precisely @xmath287 isolated solutions in @xmath24 counted with multiplicity .
first , note that for any proper face @xmath110 of @xmath34 we have @xmath292 . consider a proper face @xmath110 of @xmath34 of codimension @xmath293 and assume that @xmath294 .
then there exist an invertible matrix @xmath15 and @xmath181 $ ] of size @xmath295 such that the submatrix of @xmath296 with rows indexed by @xmath297 and columns indexed by @xmath298 is the null matrix .
the matrix @xmath299 is the coefficient matrix of an equivalent system with the same total support , see remark [ r : left ]
. denote by @xmath300 the individual newton polytopes of this equivalent system .
then the polytopes @xmath282 for @xmath301 do not touch the face @xmath110 of @xmath34 . since @xmath302 and @xmath295
, it follows then from corollary [ c : mv = v ] that @xmath303 .
theorem [ t : bkk ] applied to the system with coefficient matrix @xmath299 gives that it has at most @xmath304 isolated solutions in @xmath24 counted with multiplicity .
the same conclusion holds for the equivalent system . therefore ,
if has @xmath35 isolated solutions in @xmath24 counted with multiplicity , then is satisfied for all proper faces @xmath110 of @xmath34 .
conversely , assume that is non - degenerate and that is satisfied for all proper faces @xmath110 of @xmath34
. then has @xmath305 isolated solutions in @xmath24 counted with multiplicity by theorem [ t : bkk ] .
suppose that @xmath306 .
then by corollary [ c : mv = v ] there exists a proper face @xmath110 of @xmath34 of codimension @xmath293 and @xmath181 $ ] of size @xmath295 such that the polytopes @xmath26 for @xmath301 do not touch @xmath110 .
but then @xmath307 , which gives a contradiction .
thus @xmath308 and has @xmath35 isolated solutions in @xmath24 counted with multiplicity . as an immediate consequence of theorem [ t : ber ] from which we keep the notations , we get the following
. consider any laurent polynomial system with @xmath286 . if there exists a proper face @xmath110 of @xmath34 such that @xmath309 , then the system has either infinitely many solutions , or strictly less than @xmath287 solutions in @xmath24 counted with multiplicity .
assume the existence of a proper face @xmath110 of @xmath34 such that @xmath310 . if has precisely @xmath287 solutions in @xmath24 counted with multiplicity , then it is non - degenerate by theorem [ t : bkk ] and thus @xmath311 by theorem [ t : ber ] , a contradiction .
a very nice consequence of theorem [ t : ber ] is the following result , which can be considered as a generalization of cramer s rule to polynomial systems .
[ c : nice ] assume that @xmath286 and that no maximal minor of @xmath36 vanishes .
then the system has the maximal number of @xmath312 isolated solutions in @xmath24 counted with multiplicity .
note that @xmath313 since @xmath286 ( recall that @xmath314 is the number of columns of @xmath36 ) .
thus a maximal minor of @xmath36 has size @xmath8 and the fact that no maximal minor of @xmath36 vanishes implies that for any @xmath315 $ ] the submatrix of @xmath36 with rows indexed by @xmath38 $ ] and columns indexed by @xmath316 has maximal rank .
this rank is equal to @xmath8 if @xmath317 or to @xmath318 if @xmath319 .
since @xmath320 for any face @xmath110 of @xmath34 , we get that @xmath321 for any proper face @xmath110 of @xmath34 .
moreover , no restricted system is consistent for otherwise this would give a non - zero vector in the kernel of the corresponding submatrix of @xmath36 .
thus is non - degenerate and the result follows from theorem [ t : ber ] .
when the polytope @xmath322 is the standard simplex , the system is linear and it has precisely @xmath323 solution in @xmath24 if and only if no maximal minor of @xmath324 vanishes , in accordance with cramer s rule for linear systems .
we conclude with a few examples illustrating the results of the previous section .
let @xmath325 and @xmath326 be individual supports , and @xmath327 the total support of a system .
the newton polytopes @xmath328 , @xmath329 , and @xmath330 are depicted in figure [ f : ex1 ] , where the vertices of @xmath115 and @xmath159 are labeled by @xmath331 and @xmath332 , respectively .
we use the labeling in figure [ f : ex1 ] to order the columns of the augmented matrix @xmath333 a general system with these supports has the following coefficient matrix @xmath334 where @xmath335 are non - zero .
one can see that each side of @xmath34 is touched by at least one of the @xmath26 and , hence , @xmath336 , see example [ ex:2-dimcor ] . also one can check that the rank conditions @xmath337 are satisfied for every face @xmath110 of @xmath34 .
( in fact , both ranks equal 2 when @xmath110 is a side and 1 when @xmath110 is a vertex . )
the augmented exponent matrix and the coefficient matrix are as follows .
@xmath341 this time the side of @xmath34 labeled by @xmath342 is not touched by @xmath159 and , hence , @xmath343 .
also , the rank condition for @xmath342 fails : @xmath344 and @xmath345 .
the submatrix of @xmath36 corresponding to the edge @xmath110 labeled @xmath349 has rank @xmath276 which is less than @xmath350 . therefore the associated system has less than @xmath351 isolated solutions in @xmath352 .
( in fact , it has two solutions . ) in particular , this is a degenerate system .
assume that @xmath353 with @xmath286 and any proper face @xmath110 of @xmath34 is a simplex which intersects @xmath176 only at its vertices .
assume furthermore that @xmath321 for any proper face @xmath110 of @xmath34 . then is non - degenerate and thus has precisely @xmath312 solutions in @xmath24 counted with multiplicity according to theorem [ t : bkk ] . indeed ,
if @xmath110 is a proper face of @xmath34 , then the corresponding restricted system has total support @xmath354 .
if this restricted system is consistent , then there is a non - zero vector in the kernel of @xmath355 and thus @xmath356 which gives a contradiction . | let @xmath0 and @xmath1 be convex polytopes in @xmath2 such that @xmath3 .
we give criteria describing when the mixed volume is strictly increasing @xmath4 this geometric result allows us to characterize sparse polynomial systems with newton polytopes @xmath5 whose number of isolated solutions equals the normalized volume of the convex hull of @xmath6 .
in addition , we obtain an analog of cramer s rule for sparse polynomial systems . |
ultraluminous infrared galaxies ( ulirgs ) have quasar - like bolometric luminosities ( @xmath5 ) dominated by the far - infrared ( 81000@xmath6 m ) part of the spectrum ( sanders & mirabel , 1996 ) . almost all ulirgs are interacting or merging galaxies ( clements et al .
1996 ) , possibly linking them to the transformation of disk galaxies into ellipticals ( eg .
wright et al , 1990 ; baker & clements , 1997 ) .
the prodigious luminosity of ulirgs is thought to be powered by a massive starburst , a dust buried agn or some combination of the two . despite a decade of work
we still have not been able to decide between these paradigms .
various scenarios have also been suggested linking the evolution of quasars with ulirgs ( eg . sanders et al . , 1988 ) .
these suggest that part of the luminosity we see from some ulirgs originates in a dust obscured agn which later destroys or expels the enshrouding material .
meanwhile , studies of the x - ray background ( mushotzky et al , 2000 ) suggest that dust enshrouded agn make a substantial contribution to its hard component .
such objects may also be linked ( trentham & blain , 2001 ; almaini et al . , 1999 ) to the recently discovered cosmic infrared background ( puget et al .
1996 ; fixsen et al . , 1998 ) and the objects that contribute to it ( puget et al . 1999 ; sanders 2000 and references therein ) . as the most obscured objects in the local universe , and as strong candidates for making the cib , ulirgs are ideal local laboratories for studying many of these issues .
arp 220 is the nearest ulirg , having an 8 - 1000@xmath6 m luminosity of @xmath7 and a redshift of @xmath8 . as such it is an ideal target for ulirg studies .
the consensus since iso is that arp 220 is powered by a massive burst of star formation rather than an agn ( sturm et al 1996 ) , but the possibility of a heavily obscured agn powering the bulk of its emission remains ( haas et al 2001 ) .
the evolutionary scenario linking ulirgs to agn also allows the possibility that a weak , but growing , agn may lie at the centre of arp 220 .
while this may not be energetically significant at the present time , it may grow to prominence at later stages in the object s evolution .
the plausibility of such a scenario has been investigated by taniguchi et al .
( 1999 ) , who show that it is quite possible for a massive black hole ( @xmath9 ) to grow to @xmath10 during the course of a galaxy merger , and thus to be capable of powering a quasar .
signs of agn activity can be sought with x - ray observations .
the current data for arp 220 includes soft x - ray images from rosat ( heckman et al .
these show extended x - ray emission associated with the h@xmath11 nebula ( arribas , colina & clements 2001 ) , which are thought to be produced by a superwind .
however the overall soft x - ray luminosity is small relative to the far - ir luminosity when compared to other starbursts , and might allow room for some agn contribution ( iwasawa , 1999 ) . at higher energies , where an agn would be more prominent ,
data is available from heao-1 ( rieke , 1988 ) , cgro ( dermer et al . , 1997 ) , asca ( iwasawa 1999 ) , and bepposax ( iwasawa et al .
these rule out the possibility of an unobscured energetically significant agn in arp 220 .
the possibility remains , however , of a compton thick agn , with an obscuring column in excess of 10@xmath12@xmath13 , or of a weaker lower luminosity agn that will grow into a quasar .
we have thus undertaken chandra x - ray observations of arp 220 aimed at detecting a weak or obscured agn in its nucleus , and to study the extended superwind emission in detail .
this paper presents the first results from our study of the nuclear regions .
our results on the superwind can be found elsewhere ( mcdowell et al .
2002 , paper ii ) .
we assume a distance of 76 mpc ( kim & sanders 1998 ) to arp 220 throughout this paper .
chandra observed arp 220 with the acis - s instrument for 58 ks on 2000 jun 24 . the acis - s instrument was chosen for its good soft response to allow us to study the low energy x - ray emission of the superwind , as well as the harder emission expected from any nuclear source .
we chose to use the back - illuminated ccd s3 , for maximum soft response and to avoid any charge transfer difficulties arising in the front - illuminated chips .
arp 220 is sufficiently faint that no pile - up issues were expected or found in the data .
the data were reduced by the standard chandra pipeline through level 1 ( calibrated event list ) and further analysed using the ciao package version 2.1 and 2.2 .
the data were taken with the chip at a temperature of -120c and were gain - corrected using acisd2000-01-29gainn0003.fits from the july 2001 recalibration .
the observation was relatively unaffected by background flares and only a small amount of exposure was removed , leaving an effective exposure time of 55756s .
astrometry was corrected using a revised geometry file ( teld1999-07-23geomn0004.fits ) which is believed to provide positions across the full acis field accurate to about 1 arcsecond .
the standard screening ( good time intervals and grade filtering for grades 0,2,4,5,6 ) was applied to generate a cleaned event file .
the x - rays from arp 220 extend over 20 kpc ( paper ii ) , but emission above 2 kev is restricted to the central few kpc .
figure [ fig1 ] is a true x - ray color image of the arp 220 nuclear region .
it was smoothed in separate bands of 0.2 - 1 ( red ) , 1 - 2 ( green ) and 2 - 10 kev ( blue ) using the ciao adaptive smoothing routine _ csmooth_. the image shows that the nuclear region of arp 220 is clearly distinguished from the rest of the object by being the site of much harder emission .
the centroid of the soft emission is displaced 1.5 arcseconds to the northwest of the hard emission .
the hard emission coincides with a dust lane in the galaxy ( joy et al .
1986 ) , and indeed the soft emission is suppressed there .
however , the absence of hard emission away from the nucleus shows that the spectral change is due to a different type of source , and not merely an absorption effect .
figure [ fig2 ] shows an image of the hard emission ( @xmath14 kev ) coming from the nuclear regions of arp 220 , together with circles indicating the area within 1 of the well - studied dual radio and ir nuclei ( see eg .
scoville et al .
the positional match between the radio / ir nuclei and the hard emission is @xmath151 , within the expected pointing accuracy of chandra .
( the surprising lack of detections of usno stars in the field limits our ability to improve the astrometric accuracy , but three galaxies are found within one arcsecond of their published positions . )
previous observations of arp 220 have shown the presence of hard emission , using , for example , beppo / sax ( iwasawa et al .
2001 ) . however , it is only with the angular resolution of chandra that we have been able to localise some of this emission to the region of the nuclei .
the mean off - axis angle of the nucleus during the observation was only 38 arcseconds , so the point spread function ( calculated using the standard ciao tools ) is very close to the on - axis value . to estimate source fluxes
, we generated monochromatic point spread functions for the midpoints of the three energy bands using the ciao tool mkpsf , and subtracted a point source from the raw images at the location of the hard peak , with the maximum amplitude that did not create a dip in the local diffuse flux when the data was then smoothed .
this procedure was repeated at the location of remaining flux peaks .
the central region is consistent ( within the 1 `` absolute astrometric accuracy of the chandra data ) with a pair of hard point sources at the positions of radio nuclei a and b ( scoville et al 1998 ) , with the western nucleus dominant , although the best fit separation for two point sources is only 0.7 '' rather than the 1.1 " of the radio positions and the decomposition of this small region into multiple point sources and diffuse emission is not unique .
we designate the sources in order of total flux .
the hard band image shows emission concentrated around a nuclear source , x-1 , with extended emission around it .
point source subtraction suggests the presence of a much weaker second hard nucleus , x-4 , together with a diffuse component which we denote as the x-1 halo ; its centroid is 0.5 arcseconds east of x-1 .
x-2 , further out from the nucleus , is a hard source detected out to 5 kev ; only 33 net counts are seen .
its luminosity of @xmath16 puts it in the interesting category of non - nuclear ulx ( ultra - luminous x - ray ) sources .
x-3 , the soft peak , is not reliably separated from the extended soft circumnuclear emission , and coincides with the peak of the h@xmath11 emission ( arribas , colina & clements 2001 ; mcdowell et al .
2002 ) . the 210kev luminosity we derive for the nuclear source x-1 and surrounding hard emission ( assuming the spectral model derived in the next section ) is 6.9@xmath17 ergs s@xmath18 , measured from a 3 aperture centred on the nucleus . because of the poorly constrained absorption , here and below we quote observed luminosities rather than absorption - corrected ones unless explicitly stating otherwise .
the hard luminosity found here compares to the 210kev luminosity found by iwasawa et al .
( 2001 ) , in a 3 arcminute aperture , of 11@xmath19 ergs s@xmath18 , assuming a similar distance to arp 220 .
the background in our observation makes us insensitive to hard emission on 3 arcminute scales , and we can not rule out an extended contribution of this magnitude . however , the 3 sigma upper limit to any remaining hard ( 2 - 8 kev ) flux within 1 arcminute of the nucleus is @xmath20 and we speculate that emission from the nearby southern group may be contributing to the iwasawa et al result . deeper observations with xmm / newton would resolve this issue .
we considered two extraction regions : a 5.5 `` radius ` circumnuclear ' region , including x-3 but with the x-1/x-4 region omitted ; a ` nuclear ' region with x-1/x-4 and the hard halo , taking photons within a 3 radius circle , but excluding photons within 0.75 '' of the x-3 location to minimize contamination by the soft source .
the extraction regions are indicated in figure [ fig3r ] . for background we extracted counts from two 50
" radius circular regions 3 away on either side of the galaxy and lying on the same node of the chip .
responses were generated using the ciao tools _ mkwarf _ and _ mkrmf _ ; a pi ( gain - corrected ) spectrum was extracted and grouped by a factor of 10 ( 0.15 kev bins ) .
both xspec and sherpa were used to fit models to the data , and gave similar results .
the circumnuclear emission is fit with a raymond - smith or mekal model with a two - temperature plasma of 0.14 and 0.9 kev and absorption of @xmath21 .
it is probably composed of a mixture of diffuse emission and point sources .
there is no sign of hard emission in this spectrum , confirming the impression from the images that hard emission is restricted to the central kiloparsec of arp 220 .
the data are shown in figure [ fig3 ] .
fitting the region of hard nuclear emission we find a spectrum similar to the soft circumnuclear emission but with an additional power law component .
a representative fit has a power law component of photon index 1.4@xmath221 behind @xmath23 .
the absorbed 0.3 - 10 kev luminosity of the power law component is @xmath24 , and most of the counts are above 2 kev .
the thermal components , assumed to be superimposed circumnuclear emission , have twenty percent of the flux of the power law , so the hard component dominates the energetics of the nuclear emission .
the overall fit , with 9 free parameters , has a reduced chi - squared of 0.84 for 59 d.o.f and the c - statistic is 62.4 ; see figure [ fig4 ] .
if instead of modelling the soft emission directly , we use the off - nuclear circumnuclear emission as a background , we find a fit to the remaining emission consistent with a simple power law of index [email protected] , a lower nh around @xmath25 , and a similar absorbed luminosity of @xmath26 .
however , the remaining emission is also consistent with the slope 1.4 power law plus a modest amount of additional thermal emission at 0.9 kev .
the thermal models are not good at fitting the 2.0 kev ( rest ) si xiv line ; an extra contribution at 1.95 kev ( rest ) with l=@xmath27 reduces the @xmath28 , suggesting a possible slight gain error . there is a high bin near 6.5 kev which could be a weak fe k line . to evaluate this possibility we inspected the raw gain - corrected pulse height data without binning .
there are a mere 10 photons with gain - corrected energies in the 0.4 kev wide bin between 6.3 and 6.7 kev , compared to 7 photons in the 0.8 kev on either side between 5.9 - 6.3 and 6.7 - 7.1 , a 2 sigma ` detection ' .
the distribution of the counts is consistent with the instrumental width at that energy , and their spatial distribution suggests a distribution centered towards the eastern source x-4 ( although a tighter spatial selection only improves the detection significance to 2.6 sigma ) .
if real , this line would have a luminosity of @xmath29 , an equivalent width of 700 ev and a rest energy of @xmath30 kev ; these may be taken as approximate upper limits to any narrow fe k line .
the absorption - corrected luminosity of the nuclear emission , including the hard halo , is @xmath31 .
based on the psf subtraction calculations , we assign 30 percent of this to x-1 , giving @xmath32 which is in the range of both ultra - low luminosity agn and ultra - luminous binaries ( fabbiano 1998 , king et al .
see table 1 for derived source positions and luminosities .
could there be a further hard source at this location , behind a much larger column ? using a canonical photon index of 1.7 , we set limits of l(0.2 - 10 kev ) = @xmath33 for a column of @xmath34 , and @xmath35 for a column of @xmath36 .
however , for a column of @xmath37 , which is entirely plausible in the center of arp 220 , no useful limit can be set by the acis data as even the most luminous quasars would have their x - ray flux absorbed ; one must turn to the harder x - ray limits from the bepposax pds of @xmath38 in 13 - 50 kev ( iwasawa et al .
2001 ) to eliminate this possibility . in general , because of the low sensitivity of chandra above 6 kev , the limits we set as a function of absorbing column are weaker than those in figure 5 of iwasawa et al .
for the range they study ( log @xmath39=24.3 and above ) .
the x - ray emission in arp 220 is clearly divided into two parts the compact , hard nuclear emission , and the diffuse , softer extended emission .
this diffuse emission clearly extends right into the nucleus since the thermal component of the nuclear emission appears very similar to the thermal emission found in the off - nuclear spectrum .
the hard emission is not extended beyond a region @xmath401kpc in size ( 3 at 76 mpc , our adopted distance for arp 220 ) .
this makes an interesting contrast with other starburst and interacting / merging galaxies already studied by chandra .
for example , in the antennae ( fabbiano , zezas & murray 2001 ) hard emission comes from numerous point sources extended over a 10kpc region , and in ngc 3256 ( ward et al . 2000 ) , we see similar clumps spread over 3.5kpc . if such sources existed in arp 220 , we would expect to detect all those above @xmath155@xmath41ergs
s@xmath18 @xmath13 in luminosity .
we only see one such source , x-2 , which lies 7 away from the nucleus .
the hard x - ray emission from arp 220 thus appears to be significantly more concentrated in the nucleus than that of other interacting or merging galaxies observed by chandra .
indeed , the spatial distribution of hard emission in arp 220 would appear to be more similar to that of mrk273 ( xia et al .
2002 ) , a ulirg containing an agn at its core , than ngc3256 or the antennae , neither of which seem to have a significant agn contribution . the x - ray output from the nuclear regions of arp 220 is energetically dominated by an extended hard kpc - scale component , with a significant point source contribution ( @xmath42pc ) , that has a power law spectrum with @[email protected] , with an unabsorbed 2 - 10kev luminosity of 4@xmath19 ergs / s .
the central question is the origin of this radiation does it arise from young supernovae , x - ray binaries , or the result of accretion onto a more massive body , possibly a weak agn .
we consider each of these possibilities in turn : * * young supernovae * young supernovae can be strong x - ray emitters especially if in a dense circumstellar or interstellar environment ( schlegel , 1995 ) .
such objects are also strong radio emitters .
colina et al ( 2001 ) detected a luminous radio supernova in the nuclear starburst of the seyfert galaxy ngc 7469 , a marginally ultraluminous infrared galaxy .
12 candidates for such radio supernovae have been detected by vlbi / vlba observations in the nuclei of arp 220 ( smith et al .
1998 ) , so we know such objects are present .
the x - ray properties of such objects are highly heterogeneous .
sn1986j , for example , had an integrated 0.1 - 2.4kev luminosity of 23@xmath4410@xmath45ergs s@xmath18 @xmath13 , while sn1993j has a luminosity in the same band of 3@xmath4410@xmath46ergs s@xmath18 @xmath13 .
the temporal behaviour of these objects are also different , ranging from relatively constant emission over several years for sn1978k to decay times of a few weeks or months for sn1993j ( schlegel , 1995 ) .
a number of such objects are capable of powering the emission we see in arp 220 , though some long term variability should be detectable , especially since no new radio supernovae appear to have occurred for some years ( lonsdale et al . 2000 ) .
spectrally the emission from young supernovae are best fitted by thermal bremsstrahlung spectra .
attempts to fit the nuclear spectrum of arp 220 with a thermal bremsstrahlung model give an implausibly high temperature of 10.5 kev with a 1.7@xmath47@xmath13 absorbing column ( @xmath28=52.4 with 77 degrees of freedom ) ; supernovae typically have [email protected] . fixing the emission to this temperature
gives a fit with a poorer @xmath28 than other models , with @xmath28 = 83 with 78 degrees of freedom .
* * x - ray binaries and ulx sources * typical galactic x - ray binaries have luminosities up to @xmath1510@xmath48ergs s@xmath18 @xmath13 ( white , nagase & parmar 1995 ) , so several thousand would be required to produce the luminosity seen in arp 220 s nucleus , which is implausible . however , galaxies such as the antennae and ngc3256 , with considerably more active star formation than our own galaxy , have been found to contain ultra - luminous x - ray sources ( ulx ) with luminosity comparable to arp 220 .
a survey of 11 nearby spirals with chandra finds 15 ulx sources ( kilgard et al , in preparation ) .
the ulx sources may be accreting objects with mass @xmath49 , as seen in m82 ( griffiths et al .
2000 , kaaret et al .
2001 ) ; or , the objects may be high - mass x - ray binaries with compact object masses in the stellar range , but with beamed emission ( king et al . 2001 ) .
the m82 source appears to have a 10kev thermal bremsstrahlung spectrum , which can fit the data well ( see above ) , so the presence of several ulx sources in the core of arp 220 is feasible . * * inverse compton emission * moran et al .
( 1999 ) suggested that the hard x - ray emission in ngc3256 is produced through inverse compton scattering of the far - ir photons by relativistic electrons produced by supernova remnants in the starburst .
conditions suitable for inverse compton emission might also exist in the nuclei of arp220 , and give rise to the hard emission seen here .
one test of inverse compton emission is that the radio and x - ray power law indicies should match , and this does indeed prove to be the case .
however , as noted by iwasawa et al . ( 2001 ) , the inverse compton process in arp220 must be quite inefficient or the hard x - ray luminosity would be much greater . * * active galactic nuclei * the restriction of much of the hard x - ray emission to just the central regions of arp 220 is naturally explained if the source is an agn rather than an agglomeration of xrbs . however , whilst the nuclear regions of arp 220 have a high luminosity for an individual xrb , they have a low luminosity for an agn , being about 2 orders of magnitude fainter than typical seyfert 1 s ( george et al . 1998 ) .
however , luminosities this low are not without precedent for suspected agns .
( 2001 ) have conducted a survey of nearby galaxies with chandra , examining the x - ray emission of objects that might contain low luminosity agns .
they find weak agns in a substantial fraction of their sample , with x - ray luminosities ( 2 - 10kev ) as low as @xmath50ergs s@xmath18 @xmath13 .
they also find a correlation between x - ray and h@xmath11 luminosity which arp 220 fits on when only the nuclear h@xmath11 luminosity is considered ( armus , heckman & miley 1990 ) .
if there is a weak agn such as this in arp 220 , it will contribute only about 10@xmath5110@xmath52l@xmath53 to the bolometric luminosity , ie .
less than 1% .
however , the presence of even a weak agn in the dense environment of the nucleus of arp 220 raises the possibility that it will grow and significantly increase in luminosity as the system continues to evolve .
there is also the possibility that we are only seeing a small fraction of the emission from an agn if the source itself is compton obscured .
the tentative detection of an emission line at 6.5kev , with equivalent width @xmath151 kev , raises the possibility that the power - law source seen is just a reflected component from an otherwise obscured source .
harder x - ray observations by beppo / sax ( iwasawa et al .
2001 ) set the best limits to date for any obscured agn .
a moderately compton thick agn , with 2@xmath54 @xmath13 column , according to these limits , could supply a few percent of the bolometric luminosity , assuming standard l@xmath55/l@xmath56 ratios .
absorption by @xmath5710@xmath12 @xmath13 is needed before a substantial fraction of arp 220 s luminosity can come from an agn .
such extinction is not impossible .
haas et al .
( 2001 ) use the 7.7@xmath6m/850@xmath6 m flux ratio to suggest very high extinctions , while the lws spectrum from fischer et al .
( 1999 ) , indicating @xmath58 at 100@xmath6 m , would imply an hi column of 2.7@xmath59@xmath13 .
improved sensitivity spectra for the nuclear regions of arp 220 is clearly needed to confirm whether the 6.5kev line is real and if it is associated with reflected emission .
the presence of _ extended _ hard x - ray emission in the nuclear regions of arp220 can not be easily explained by a simple agn model .
possible explainations would include a mixed nature for the nuclear regions , with unresolved agn emission combining with extended xrb emission in the halo .
such an arrangement would naturally follow from taniguchi et al.s ( 1999 ) model of nuclear black hole growth by accretion of xrbs during a merger .
alternatively , an obscured agn might be associated with extended scattered hard emission .
the acquisition of deeper chandra images to examine any differences in x - ray properties between unresolved and halo hard x - ray emission would be able to address these possibilities .
we have shown that there is a source of hard , power - law - like , x - ray emission in the nuclear regions of arp 220 .
this source is extended ew , consistent with the emission coming from both the radio / ir nuclei .
the central concentration of hard x - ray emission in arp 220 is in contrast to other interacting galaxies , where hard emission comes from clumps distributed across much larger physical distances .
this difference may be associated with the merger in arp 220 being older than in the antennae or ngc3256 , and that compact objects have sunk to its core ( tremaine , ostriker & spitzer , 1975 ) but may also be associated with arp 220 s greater luminosity .
the origin of the hard emission is unclear .
its spectrum is unlikely to be produced by young supernovae , but inverse compton emission , albeit of very low efficiency , accretion onto ultra - luminous x - ray binaries or onto an agn are all possible .
if there is an agn contribution , it has too low a luminosity for it to play a significant role in the energetics of the object , but the presence of even a weak agn in arp 220 would support a connection between ulirgs and quasars ( sanders et al .
if it is not an agn , we can not rule out the presence of a true agn behind a compton screen of column @xmath60 .
if xrbs are responsible for the emission then a large number of conventional xrbs are needed , or a smaller number of ultraluminous ulx sources . in either case
, the concentration of these objects in the very centre of arp 220 might indicate that these objects will later merge together to form a supermassive black hole and agn ( taniguchi et al .
if there is a weak agn already in the nuclear regions , then this process may already have begun .
partial support for this work was provided by the national aeronautics and space administration through chandra award number go1 - 1166 issued by the chandra x - ray observatory center , which is operated by the smithsonian astrophysical observatory for and on behalf of nasa under contract nas8 - 39073 .
s. lamb acknowledges support from the doe , through llnl .
dlc and acb were supported by pparc , cm by the royal society .
we would also like to acknowledge the contributions of bernie peek and charlie baker to this work . | we present the first results from 60ks of observations of arp 220 using the acis - s instrument on chandra .
we report the detection of several sources near the galaxy s nucleus , including a point source with a hard spectrum that is coincident with the western radio nucleus b. this point source is mildly absorbed ( @xmath0 ) and has an estimated luminosity of @xmath1 erg / s .
in addition , a fainter source may coincide with the eastern nucleus a. extended hard x - ray emission in the vicinity raises the total estimated nuclear 2 - 10 kev x - ray luminosity to @xmath2 erg / s , but we can not rule out a hidden agn behind columns exceeding @xmath3 we also detect a peak of soft x - ray emission to the west of the nucleus , and a hard point source 2.5 kpc from the nucleus with a luminosity of @xmath4 erg / s . |
the multiobjective optimization problem ( moop ) is to optimize two or more objective functions simultaneously , subject to given constraints .
the multiobjective optimization can be applied to problems where the final decision should be made considering two or more conflicting objectives .
moop occurs in various fields such as industrial design , finance , management and many engineering areas .
practical goals in these fields can be generalized in such a way that the cost of a process is minimized while the quality of its product is maximized .
the primary goal is to find a set of solutions that any individual objective function can not be improved without deteriorating the other objective functions , and such a set is called a pareto set . for efficient decision making ,
a set of generated solutions ( @xmath0 ) should meet two conditions : it should be as close to the pareto front as possible and the solutions should be distributed as widely as possible
. evolutionary algorithm ( ea ) is one of the most popular and successful approaches to solve moops @xcite .
a number of ea - based algorithms have been suggested including the vector evaluated genetic algorithm ( vega ) @xcite , the niched pareto genetic algorithm ( npga ) @xcite , the nondominated sorting genetic algorithm ( nsga2 ) @xcite , the strength pareto evolutionary algorithm ( spea2 ) @xcite , the mimetic pareto archived evolution strategy ( m - paes ) @xcite and micro genetic algorithm ( micro - ga ) @xcite . among them ,
nsga2 and spea2 are arguably the most widely used methods .
other approaches include simulated annealing ( sa ) @xcite , tabu search @xcite , particle swarm optimization ( pso ) @xcite , immune algorithm ( ia ) @xcite , ant system @xcite and cultural algorithm @xcite .
conformational space annealing ( csa ) is a highly efficient single - objective global optimization algorithm which incorporates advantages of genetic algorithm and sa .
it has been successfully applied to diverse single - objective optimization problems in physics and biology , such as protein structure modeling @xcite , finding the minimum energy solution of a lenard - jones cluster @xcite , multiple sequence alignment @xcite and the community detection problem @xcite on networks . in these studies
, csa is shown to perform more efficient sampling using less computational resources than the conventional monte - carlo ( mc ) and sa methods . here , we introduce a new multiobjective optimization algorithm by using csa , mocsa .
compared to existing eas , mocsa has the following distinct features : ( a ) the ranking system considers the dominance relationship and the distance between solutions in the objective space , ( b ) solutions are updated by using a dynamically varying distance cutoff measure to control the diversity of the sampling in the decision space , and ( c ) a gradient - based constrained minimizer is utilized for local search . the remainder of this paper is organized as follows . in section 2 ,
the definition of moop and related terms are described . in section 3 , details of mocsa
is presented .
numerical results and the comparison between mocsa and nsga2 on various test problems are presented in section 4 .
the final section contains the conclusion .
the mathematical definition of a moop can be defined as follows , @xmath1 where @xmath2 is the decision vector , @xmath3 the decision space , @xmath4 the objective vector and @xmath5 the objective space .
due to the presence of multiple objective functions , a final solution of moop consists of a set of non - dominated solutions instead of a single point .
the notion of _ dominance _ and related terms are defined below . a decision vector @xmath6 is said to dominate another solution @xmath7 ( denoted by @xmath8 ) , if and only if @xmath9 [ paretodominance]definition a solution @xmath2 is said to be non - dominated by any other solutions ( a pareto optimal solution ) if and only if @xmath10 [ paretodominance]definition for a given moop , a pareto optimal set in the decision space , @xmath11 , is defined as @xmath12 [ paretodominance]definition for a given moop , a pareto optimal set in the objective space , @xmath13 , is defined as @xmath14 since the size of pareto optimal front , @xmath13 is infinite in general , which is impossible to obtain in practice , practical algorithms for moop yield a set of non - dominated solutions of a finite size .
it should be noted that @xmath13 is always a non - dominated set by definition while a non - dominated set of solutions generated by an algorithm , which is denoted as a @xmath0 , may not be a subset of @xmath13 .
here , a new multiobjective optimization algorithm based on csa is described .
the csa was initially developed to obtain the protein structure with the minimum potential energy , _
i.e. _ , to solve a single objective optimization problem .
csa has been successfully applied to various kinds of optimization problems with modification .
the general framework of csa is shown in figure [ csa_flow_chart ] , and the description of mocsa is given in algorithm [ csa ] .
initialize the bank , @xmath15 , with @xmath16 random individuals minimize(@xmath15 ) using a constrained local minimizer initialize seed flags of all individuals to zeros : @xmath17 get average distance , @xmath18 , between all pairs of individuals and set @xmath19 as @xmath20 : @xmath21 initialize generation counter to zero : @xmath22 initialize the reserve bank , @xmath23 , to an empty set generate @xmath16 random individuals , @xmath24 minimize(@xmath24 ) @xmath25expand search space evaluate fitness of @xmath15 select @xmath26 seeds among individuals with @xmath27 and set @xmath28 to 1 @xmath29 generate @xmath30 trial solutions by crossover @xmath31 generate @xmath32 trial solutions by mutation @xmath33trial solutions minimize(@xmath34 ) update(@xmath35 ) @xmath36 reduce @xmath19 @xmath37 [ csaendwhile ] csa is a global optimization method which combines essential ingredients of three methods : monte carlo with minimization ( mcm ) @xcite , genetic algorithm ( ga ) @xcite , and sa @xcite . as in mcm , we consider only the solution / conformational space of local minima ; in general , all solutions are minimized by a local minimizer . as in ga
, we use a set of @xmath16 solutions ( called _ bank _ in csa , denoted as @xmath15 ) collectively , and we generate offsprings from the bank solutions by cross - over and mutation . finally , as in sa
, we introduce a distance parameter @xmath19 , which plays the role of the temperature in sa . in csa , each solution is assumed to represent a hyper - sphere of radius @xmath38 in the decision space .
diversity of sampling is directly controlled by introducing a distance measure between two solutions and comparing it with @xmath19 , to prevent two solutions from approaching too close to each other in the decision space .
similar to the manipulation of temperature in sa , the value of @xmath19 is initially set to a large value and is slowly reduced to a smaller value in csa ; hence the name conformational space annealing .
compared to the conventional ea for multiobjective problems , mocsa has three distinct features ; ( a ) a ranking algorithm which considers the dominance relationship as well as the distance between solutions in the objective space , ( b ) an update rule with a dynamically varying distance cutoff measure to control the size of search space and to keep the diversity of sampling in the decision space and ( c ) the usage of a gradient - based constrained minimizer , feasible sequential quadratic programming ( fsqp ) , for local search . in csa , we first initialize the _ bank _ , @xmath15 , with @xmath39 random solutions which are subsequently minimized by fsqp constrained minimizer .
the solutions in the bank are updated using subsequent solutions found during the course of optimization .
the initial value of @xmath19 is set as @xmath40 , where @xmath41 is the average distance in the _ decision _ space between two solutions at the initial stage .
a number of solutions ( 20 in this study ) in the bank are selected as _
seeds_. for each seed , 30 trial solutions are generated by cross - over between the seed and randomly chosen solutions from the bank .
additional 5 are generated by mutation of the seed .
it should be noted that if a solution is used as a seed and not replaced by a offspring , it is excluded from the subsequent seed selection .
the generated offsprings are locally minimized by fsqp which guarantees to improve a subset of objective functions without deteriorating the others and without violating given constraints . to limit the computational usage
, the minimization is performed only once per every five generation steps ( see algorithm [ csa ] ) .
offsprings are used to update the bank , and detailed description on the updating rule is provided in section [ sec : update ] .
once all solutions in the bank are used as seeds without generating better solutions , implying that the procedure might have reached a deadlock , we reset all bank solutions to be eligible for seeds again and repeat another round of the search procedure . after this additional search reaches a deadlock again ,
we expand our search space by adding additional 50 randomly generated and minimized solutions to the bank ( @xmath42 ) , and repeat the whole procedure until a termination criterion is satisfied .
the maximum number of generation is set to @xmath43 .
typically , with @xmath44 in this study , mocsa is terminated before a deadlock occurs with the final bank size of @xmath39 . for a given set of generated solutions , @xmath0 , the fitness of solution @xmath45
is evaluated in terms of @xmath46 , @xmath47 and @xmath48 .
@xmath46 is the number of solutions in @xmath0 which dominate @xmath45 .
@xmath47 is the number of solutions in @xmath0 dominated by @xmath45 .
@xmath48 is the sum of distances from @xmath45 to its nearest and second nearest neighbors in @xmath0 in the objective space .
the relative fitness between two solutions , @xmath45 and @xmath49 , is determined by the comparing function shown in algorithm [ fitness ] . with a set of non - dominated solutions
all values of @xmath46 and @xmath47 become zeros and the solution with the least value of @xmath50 is considered as the worst . the solutions generated by crossover and mutation
are locally minimized by fsqp constrained minimizer and we call them trial solutions . each trial solution @xmath51 ,
is compared with the bank @xmath15 for update procedure as shown in algorithm [ update ] .
first , @xmath52 , the closest solution in @xmath15 from @xmath51 in the _ decision _ space is identified .
if there exist dominated solutions in @xmath15 , the closest conformation search is performed only among them . otherwise , @xmath15 is a set of non - dominated solutions , and all in @xmath15 are considered . once @xmath52 is found , the distance @xmath38 in the decision space between @xmath51 and @xmath52 is calculated . if @xmath53 , the current cutoff distance , which indicates that @xmath51 lies in a newly sampled region in the decision space , remote from the existing solutions in @xmath15 , the dominance relationship between @xmath51 and the worst solution in @xmath15 , @xmath2 , is compared . if @xmath54 , @xmath51 is compared with @xmath52 .
the selection procedure , described in section [ sec : select ] , is performed to determine which solution should be kept in @xmath15 . at each iteration step , @xmath19 is reduced with a pre - determined ratio , @xmath55 .
after @xmath19 reaches to its final value , @xmath56 , it is kept constant . in algorithm
[ update ] , for a given trial solution @xmath51 and a solution @xmath57 in @xmath15 , @xmath15 is updated as follows .
if @xmath51 dominates @xmath57 , @xmath51 replaces @xmath57 . if @xmath51 is dominated by @xmath57 , @xmath51 is discarded and @xmath57 stays in @xmath15 . if there is no dominance relationship between @xmath51 and @xmath57 and if @xmath57 is better than @xmath51 by algorithm [ fitness ] , @xmath51 is discarded and @xmath57 stays in @xmath15 . finally , when @xmath51 is better than @xmath57 without dominance relationship between them , algorithm [ select ] is used . for the selection procedure ,
we introduce an additional set of non - dominated solutions , the reserve bank , @xmath23 . due to the limited size of the bank
, we may encounter a situation where a solution exists in @xmath15 which is not dominated by the current bank , but dominated by a solution eliminated from the bank in an earlier generation . to solve this problem ,
non - dominated solutions eliminated from @xmath15 are stored up to 500 in @xmath23 , which is conceptually similar to an _ archive _ in other eas @xcite .
the difference is that @xmath23 is used only when more than half of the solutions in @xmath15 are non - dominated solutions because csa focuses more on diverse sampling rather than optimization at the early stage of the optimization .
note that @xmath23 keeps only non - dominated solutions .
@xmath58 number of solutions in @xmath15 which dominate @xmath59(@xmath60 ) @xmath61 number of solutions in @xmath15 which are dominated by @xmath59(@xmath60 ) @xmath62 the sum of distances from @xmath45 to the nearest and second nearest neighbors in @xmath15 in the _ objective _ space @xmath59 is better @xmath60 is better @xmath63 @xmath59 is better @xmath60 is better @xmath64 @xmath59 is better @xmath60 is better @xmath65 nearest solution to @xmath51 in @xmath15 in the _ decision _ space @xmath65 nearest solution to @xmath51 among _ dominated _ solutions in @xmath15 in the _ decision _ space distance in the decision space @xmath66 worst solution in @xmath15 @xmath67 @xmath68 @xmath51 dominates @xmath57 @xmath51 replaces @xmath57 @xmath57 dominates @xmath51 @xmath57 stays in @xmath15 and @xmath51 is discarded @xmath57 stays in @xmath15 and @xmath51 is discarded select(@xmath69 ) @xmath70 , @xmath71 , @xmath51 is better than @xmath57 @xmath51 replaces @xmath57 in @xmath15 @xmath57 is non - dominated in @xmath15 and @xmath23 is used @xmath51 replaces @xmath57 in @xmath15 @xmath51 is dominated by @xmath23 @xmath66 nearest dominating solution to @xmath51 in @xmath23 in the _ objective _ space move @xmath2 from @xmath23 to @xmath15 move @xmath57 from @xmath15 to @xmath23 @xmath72 @xmath73 @xmath74 \\ & z_1 , \dotsc , z_k \in [ -5,5 ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath75 @xmath76 \\
\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath77 @xmath78\right ) \\
g & = 1 + 9\sum_{i=1}^{k}z_i / k \\ \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath79
for the benchmark test of mocsa , we have selected 12 widely used test problems in the field .
they consist of zdt @xcite and dtlz @xcite .
each test suite contains several functional forms and can feature various aspects of optimization algorithms .
comprehensive analysis on the characteristics of the two test suites are well documented by huband _
et al . _
@xcite . in both suites , the input vector , @xmath57 ,
is divided into two sets @xmath80 and @xmath81 to construct test problems as follows , @xmath82 , where @xmath83 and @xmath49 are the dimensions of decision and objective spaces respectively and @xmath84 .
the zdt problem suite consists of six test problems and is probably the most popular test suite to access multiobjective optimization algorithms .
the explicit functional forms of five zdt problems are presented in table [ tab : zdt ] .
the zdt test suite has two main advantages : ( a ) the pareto fronts of the problems are known in exact forms and ( b ) benchmark results of many existing studies are available . however , there are shortcomings : ( a ) the problems have only two objectives , ( b ) none of the problems contain flat regions and ( c ) none of the problems have degenerate pareto optimal front @xcite .
.five real - valued zdt problems are described .
the first objective depends only on the first decision variable as @xmath85 and the second objective is given as @xmath86 , where @xmath87 and @xmath88 , where @xmath83 and @xmath49 are the dimensions of the decision space and the objective space . unless the functional forms of @xmath89 and @xmath90 are separately given , they are identical to those of zdt1 . [ cols="^,<,^",options="header " , ]
in this paper , we have introduced a novel multiobjective optimization algorithm by using the conformational space annealing ( csa ) algorithm , mocsa .
benchmark results on 12 test problems show that mocsa finds better solutions than nsga2 , in terms of four criteria tested .
solutions by mocsa are closer to the pareto front , a higher fraction of them are on the pareto front , they cover a wider objective space , and they are more evenly distributed on average .
we note that the efficiency of mocsa arises from the fact that it controls the diversity of solutions in the decision space as well as in the objective space .
the authors acknowledge support from creative research initiatives ( center for in silico protein science , 20110000040 ) of mest / kosef .
we thank korea institute for advanced study for providing computing resources ( kias center for advanced computation linux cluster ) for this work .
we also would like to acknowledge the support from the kisti supercomputing center ( ksc-2012-c3 - 02 ) .
coello coello , c. , corts , n. , 2002 .
an approach to solve multiobjective optimization problems based on an artificial immune system . in : proceedings of first international conference on artificial immune systems 2002
; canterbury , uk .
. 212221 .
coello coello , c. , lechuga , m. , 2002 .
mopso : a proposal for multiple objective particle swarm optimization . in : evolutionary computation , 2002 .
proceedings of the 2002 congress on .
vol . 2 .
ieee , pp .
10511056 .
deb , k. , agrawal , s. , pratap , a. , meyarivan , t. , 2000 . a fast elitist non - dominated sorting genetic algorithm for multi - objective optimization : nsga - ii .
lecture notes in computer science 1917 , 849858 .
deb , k. , thiele , l. , laumanns , m. , zitzler , e. , 2002 .
scalable multi - objective optimization test problems . in : proceedings of the congress on evolutionary computation ( cec-2002),(honolulu , usa ) .
proceedings of the congress on evolutionary computation ( cec-2002),(honolulu , usa ) , pp . 825830 .
doerner , k. , gutjahr , w. , hartl , r. , strauss , c. , stummer , c. , 2004 .
pareto ant colony optimization : a metaheuristic approach to multiobjective portfolio selection .
annals of operations research 131 ( 1 ) , 7999 .
hansen , m. , 1997 .
tabu search for multiobjective optimization : mots . in : proceedings of the 13th international conference on multiple criteria decision making ( mcdm97 ) , cape town , south africa .
citeseer , pp . 574586 .
horn , j. , nafpliotis , n. , goldberg , d. , 1994 . a niched pareto genetic algorithm for multiobjective optimization . in : evolutionary computation , 1994 .
ieee world congress on computational intelligence . , proceedings of the first ieee conference on .
ieee , pp .
8287 .
joo , k. , lee , j. , seo , j. , lee , k. , kim , b. , lee , j. , 2009 .
all - atom chain - building by optimizing modeller energy function using conformational space annealing .
proteins : structure , function , and bioinformatics 75 ( 4 ) , 10101023 .
lee , j. , liwo , a. , ripoll , d. , pillardy , j. , scheraga , h. , jan .
calculation of protein conformation by global optimization of a potential energy function .
proteins structure function and genetics 37 ( s 3 ) , 204208 .
liwo , a. , lee , j. , ripoll , d. r. , pillardy , j. , scheraga , h. , may 1999 .
protein structure prediction by global optimization of a potential energy function .
proceedings of the national academy of sciences of the united states of america 96 ( 10 ) , 54825 .
pillardy , j. , czaplewski , c. , liwo , a. , lee , j. , ripoll , d. r. , kamierkiewicz , r. , oldziej , s. , wedemeyer , w. j. , gibson , k. d. , arnautova , y. a. , saunders , j. , ye , y. j. , scheraga , h. , feb . 2001 .
recent improvements in prediction of protein structure by global optimization of a potential energy function .
proceedings of the national academy of sciences of the united states of america 98 ( 5 ) , 232933 .
schaffer , j. , 1985 .
multiple objective optimization with vector evaluated genetic algorithms . in : proceedings of the 1st international conference on genetic algorithms .
l. erlbaum associates inc . , pp . 93100 .
van veldhuizen , d. , lamont , g. , 2000 . on measuring multiobjective evolutionary algorithm performance . in : evolutionary computation , 2000 .
proceedings of the 2000 congress on .
vol . 1 .
ieee , pp . | we introduce a novel multiobjective optimization algorithm based on the conformational space annealing ( csa ) algorithm , mocsa .
it has three characteristic features : ( a ) dominance relationship and distance between solutions in the objective space are used as the fitness measure , ( b ) update rules are based on the fitness as well as the distance between solutions in the decision space and ( c ) it uses a constrained local minimizer .
we have tested mocsa on 12 test problems , consisting of zdt and dtlz test suites .
benchmark results show that solutions obtained by mocsa are closer to the pareto front and covers a wider range of the objective space than those by the elitist non - dominated sorting genetic system ( nsga2 ) .
conformational space annealing , multiobjective optimization , genetic algorithm , evolutionary algorithm , pareto front |
multipole radiofrequency ion traps @xcite , in particular the 22-pole ion trap @xcite , are versatile devices used in laser spectroscopy @xcite and investigations of chemical reaction processes @xcite of atomic and molecular ions .
high order multipole traps offer a large field free region in the trap center , and therefore provide a reduced interaction time of the ions with the oscillating electric field compared to a quadrupole trap @xcite .
buffer gas cooling down to cryogenic temperatures of the translational @xcite , rotational @xcite , and vibrational degrees of freedom @xcite of trapped molecular ions has been demonstrated .
this enables applications with all the advantages of low temperature experiments , such as a reduced doppler width in spectroscopy studies and a well defined population of internal states .
stable confinement of a single ion in the oscillating quadrupole field of a paul trap is precisely predicted , because the mathieu equations of motion can be solved analytically .
this is different for oscillating high order multipole fields , where the equations of motion have no analytical solution .
however , the movement of the ions in a fast oscillating rf - field justifies the assumption of an effective trapping potential , based on the separation of the ion motion into a smooth drift and a rapid oscillation , called micromotion @xcite .
this effective potential can be expressed as @xmath1 where @xmath2 denotes the electric field at the point @xmath3 , @xmath4 is the mass of a test particle with charge @xmath5 in an electric field oscillating on frequency @xmath6 and @xmath7 is a non - oscillating dc potential . for an ideal cylindrical multipole of the order @xmath8 this effective
potential can be expressed as @xmath9 where @xmath10 denotes the amplitude of the oscillating rf - field . for a high order multipole field ( @xmath8=11 for the 22-pole trap ) this creates an almost box - like trapping volume with steep walls and a large field free region in the center .
this is important to suppress rf heating when cooling ions in neutral buffer gas @xcite .
the number of trapped ions that can be excited with radiation depends on the local density of ions in the interaction volume with the light field . in experiments with trapped ba@xmath11 ions in an octupole trap
the density has been imaged by spatially resolving the fluorescence signal @xcite . in this article
we report on a method based on the photodetachment of trapped anions that allows us to image the density distribution of the trapped ions . in this way we measure the experimental trapping potential of a 22-pole trap with unprecedented accuracy and study its dependence on the radiofrequency field . in the next section
the photodetachment tomography is explained , followed by a presentation of measured density distributions at different temperatures and rf amplitudes .
we find ten unexpected maxima in the density distribution and analyze their origin with the help of numerical simulations in section [ model ] .
the experimental radiofrequency ion trap setup has been described in detail in ref .
its central element is a 22-pole trap @xcite with good optical access along the trap axis . in the present tomography experiments
, we have used an ensemble of stored oh@xmath0 anions cooled to a translational temperature of either 170 or 300 k. the use of negative ions allows us to perform photodetachment measurements , were the anions are depleted by a laser beam propagating parallel to the symmetry axis of the trap @xcite .
the photodetachment process @xmath12 with @xmath13ev yields a depletion rate proportional to the photodetachment cross section and to the overlap of the ion column density with the photon flux . by scanning the position of the laser beam and measuring the depletion rate at each position
the relative ion column density distribution is obtained . for small ion densities , where the coulomb interaction between the ions can be neglected ,
the depletion rate at the transverse position @xmath14 can be expressed as @xmath15 it depends only on the total photon flux @xmath16 , the photodetachment cross section @xmath17 and the single particle column density @xmath18 , reflecting the spatial overlap of the laser beam with the ion distribution @xcite . as the latter is normalized to unity , we can write it as @xmath19 thus , a full two - dimensional tomography scan of the trapped ions can be used to map the entire ion column density in the trap .
if @xmath20 is measured for the whole ion distribution , also the absolute photodetachment cross section can be obtained @xcite .
ions are produced in a pulsed supersonic expansion of a suitable precursor gas , crossed by a 1kev electron beam .
for the oh@xmath0 production we use a mixture of ar / nh@xmath21/h@xmath22o ( 88% , 10% , 2% ) to create nh@xmath23 . a rapid chemical conversion by water forms the oh@xmath0 anions in the source .
a bunch of @xmath24500 mass - selected ions is loaded into the trap , which is enclosed by a copper housing that is temperature - variable between 8 and 300k .
a typical he buffer gas density of @xmath25@xmath26 , employed for all temperatures , is enhanced by a buffer gas pulse during the ion injection .
the trap is operated with @xmath27mhz radiofrequency and different rf amplitudes . along the axial direction ions
are confined by end electrodes biased to -2v . to allow good thermalization of the ions , a storage period of 200ms
is inserted before the laser beam is switched on .
after a given storage and laser interaction time the current signal , proportional to the number of ions that survived the interaction with the photodetachment laser , is detected with a microchannel plate .
the two - dimensional tomography scans are performed under the same experimental conditions as in ref .
@xcite . a free - running continuous wave diode laser at 661.9 nm ( mitsubishi ml1j27 , 100mw , spectral width 0.7 nm fwhm ) has been employed .
it is imaged into the trap and scanned in the @xmath14 plane , perpendicular to the symmetry axis of the trap , by moving the imaging lense on a mesh with 0.25 mm point spacing with a computer - controlled two - dimensional translation stage .
the mesh spacing is comparable to the @xmath28 radius of the laser in the trap of 350@xmath29 m .
for each laser position the photodetachment depletion rate is obtained in a storage time interval of 0.2 - 2s by fitting an exponential decay to the ion current signal , reduced by typically one percent due to the background loss rate .
the data are averaged over typically 4 - 8 scans . within each scan
the mesh points are accessed in random order to avoid systematic drifts .
fig . [ fig1]a shows a tomography scan of oh@xmath0 anions in the 22-pole trap at 300k with the rf amplitude set to 160v .
the figure also contains the sketched arrangement of the trap s copper housing mounted on the coldhead of the cryostat , the position of the 22 rf electrodes and the axial end electrodes .
[ fig1]b is a zoom of the scan which more clearly shows the measured ion density distribution .
every pixel of the histogram here represents a fitted photodetachment depletion rate @xmath20 ( see previous section ) and is proportional to the single - particle probability density @xmath18 along a column parallel to the @xmath30-axis .
as can be seen the ion distribution as a first approximation can be considered circularly symmetric and constant in the center region of the trap , whereas it drops to zero when the ions reach the outer regions of the trapping volume .
this distribution directly visualizes the overall storage properties of a 22-pole ion trap with a flat potential in the center and steep walls .
note that the ion density drops to zero already for smaller radii than the end electrode ( solid line in fig .
[ fig1]b ) , indicating that clipping of the laser at the end electrode is not affecting the measured density distribution . for smaller rf
amplitudes the ion density distribution would extend to larger radii and could not be fully probed by the photodetachment tomography .
for this reason we have restricted ourselves to large enough rf amplitudes in this study . in fig .
[ fig1]c a horizontal cut through the ion distribution is shown .
while in the center the distribution is relatively uniform , the population is locally enhanced by up to 40% near the edge of the ion distribution .
such a behavior has already been observed in previous measurements @xcite . to study this here in more detail ,
the effective potential @xmath31 is extracted from the local ion density @xmath18 assuming a boltzmann distribution for the ions in the trap @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the absolute temperature , @xmath34 is boltzmann s constant , and @xmath35 is the partition function .
since only the column density is measured , the resulting potential @xmath31 is an average over the @xmath30-direction .
fig.[fig1]d shows a cut through the obtained effective potential for the distribution of fig .
overall this potential compares well with the calculated potential of an ideal 22-pole potential ( solid line ) , obtained without any free parameters from eq.([multipole_effective_potential ] ) .
closer inspection reveals interesting features in the potential that deviate from the ideal multipole .
while the potential is relatively flat in the center , it shows a distinct minimum of about 12mev near the left edge of the ion distribution and a weaker minimum of about 5mev near its right edge .
it can be excluded that this change of the distribution is caused by space charge effects , because the experiments are performed with only a few hundred ions in a trap volume of about 1@xmath36 .
the same features of the effective potential are observed in measurements at a lower trap temperature .
[ fig2]a shows a tomography scan at 170k and the same rf amplitude as above .
the ion distribution again looks circular symmetric with a distinct cutoff when the ions reach the steep walls of the trapping potential .
a horizontal cut through the effective potential , obtained in the same fashion as fig .
[ fig1]d , is shown in fig .
[ fig2]b . the same minima as for 300k are observed in the effective potential . at this lower temperature
the two minima are better resolved and appear similar in depth on the left side and slightly deeper on the right side of the potential as compared to the 300k tomography .
further substructure becomes visible in the 170k density distribution .
ten clearly separated maxima in the density distribution appear almost equally spaced in angle at a radial position of about 3 mm . according to eq.([density : eq ] ) they correspond to ten localized minima in the trapping potential at this radius with a typical depth of 10mev . these minima have not been significant in the 300k ion distribution at 160v rf amplitude .
they become visible , however , for larger amplitudes .
fig.[fig3]a shows a 300k ion distribution for an rf amplitude of 270v .
it reveals the same ten density maxima and respective potential minima that could only be resolved at lower temperature at 160v .
we have studied the dependence of the depth of the ten potential minima on the rf amplitude at 300k .
the depth of the deepest minimum is plotted in fig . [ fig3]b . since the effective potential is expected to depend quadratically on the rf amplitude , a fit with only a constant and a quadratic term
is applied to the data ( solid line in fig .
[ fig3]b ) .
it yields an rf - independent offset of about 11mev , which is attributed to the static potential of the end electrodes of the ion trap .
these end electrodes produce a radially repulsive potential inside the trap , as discussed in ref.@xcite .
it compares well with simulations , as shown in the next section .
the ten `` pockets '' in the potential , however , reveal a more complex deviation from the ideal multipole description of eq.([multipole_effective_potential ] ) .
an explanation for them will also be discussed in the next section .
the effective potential of a @xmath37-pole has a @xmath37-fold rotational symmetry , when averaging over one radiofrequency period .
the appearance of the ten observed potential minima is therefore a clear indication for a breaking of the ideal symmetry . to investigate this effect further
, the effective potential of the employed 22-pole trap has been modeled using a numerical simulation package based on a fast multipole solver @xcite for the boundary element problem in combination with accurate field evaluation in free space . with this method the electric field @xmath38 can be calculated at any location inside the trap . it is converted into the effective trapping potential using eq .
( [ effective_potential ] ) .
we have verified that the simulation of the trapping potential of an ideal 22-pole structure reproduces the effective potential of eq .
( [ multipole_effective_potential ] ) on the numerical level of accuracy .
different assumptions have been tested as origin of the observed ten potential minima , such as the influence of the shape and position of the end electrodes and of the copper housing around the trap electrodes , without showing a measurable effect on the potential .
this suggests that imperfections of the trap geometry itself may be responsible . to simulate these imperfections a breaking of the ideal symmetry is introduced by displacing one half of the 22 radiofrequency electrodes by a small angle ( see inset in fig.[fig4]a ) .
such a small tilt of one set of electrodes against the others occurs to be the most likely displacement during the trap assembly . upon tilting one set of electrodes by only a few tenths of a degree the calculated effective potential of a 22-pole trap at 160v
rf amplitude and -2v on the end electrodes immediately shows ten potential minima . in fig .
[ fig4]a the dependence of the maximum pocket depth on the tilt angle , as obtained from a series of simulations , is plotted .
these simulations have been carried out for 160v rf amplitude . here
, an imperfection in the parallelity of only @xmath39 causes a pocket depth of 5mev .
the pocket depth is calculated at each angle with and without a potential of -2v applied to the static end electrodes .
the end electrode voltage produces an overall quadrupole potential that pushes the ion ensemble towards larger radii in the trap in addition to the tilt - induced pockets .
both data sets with and without end electrode potential are described by the same quadratic increase . for the simulations with end electrode potential a constant offset of about 9mev
is obtained , in fair agreement with the experiment value of about 11mev . from the measured depths of the potential minima ( fig .
[ fig3]b ) a value of between 3 and 5mev is extracted for an rf amplitude of about 160v , after subtracting the influence of the static end electrode ( see fig.[fig3]b ) .
such an rf - induced pocket depth is obtained in the simulation for a tilt angle of between @xmath40 and @xmath39 ( see fig.[fig4]a ) .
[ fig4]b shows a simulated density distribution for a tilt angle of @xmath40 .
following eq .
( [ density : eq ] ) , the simulation has been performed for oh@xmath0 ions that are stored at 300k in the 22-pole trap with 270v rf amplitude and -2v potential on the end electrodes .
this simulated density distribution agrees well with the measured distribution of fig .
[ fig3]a , which has been obtained with the same trap parameters .
a larger tilt angle was found to already overestimate the ten potential minima .
note that it is preferable to compare graphs of the density distributions of simulation and experiment instead of effective potentials , because the experimental potential is obtained by a logarithm of the density distribution which suppresses the fine details in the images . when the 22-pole trap was assembled the strong influence of small displacements of the rf electrodes on the effective potential was not known .
a tilt of one set of rf electrodes by a tenth of a degree can therefore not be excluded for our trap .
such small tilt angles already come close to the mechanical tolerances for the assembly of a 22-pole trap in the presently used design .
this shows the need to significantly improve the precision in the rf electrode geometry when a potential with pocket depths in the @xmath29ev range is desired . in searching for an explanation for the observed ten minima
, we have extended the electric field simulations to multipoles of different order @xmath8 .
these calculations have shown that the number of minima observed in the effective potential of a distorted multipole ion trap is directly connected to the multipole order as @xmath41 . besides the above discussed tilt of one set of electrodes , other distortions of the ion trap , such as a parallel displacement of one set of rf electrodes , also introduces @xmath42 minima .
the number of minima therefore seems to be a general consequence of breaking the symmetry of a multipole ion trap .
we expect the minima to be related to the points in space where the superimposed time - dependent electric field of the individual multipole electrodes cancels , because according to eq .
( [ effective_potential ] ) these are the global minima of the effective potential . for a perfectly symmetric multipole trap cancellation
is expected only in the trap center , but for a distorted symmetry several such points are found at larger radii .
in this article we report on a method to directly measure the column density distribution of ions in a 22-pole ion trap using photodetachment of stored oh@xmath0 .
the two - dimensional tomography scans yield the effective potential averaged over the length of the trap . the measurements quantitatively confirm the overall validity of the effective potential of a 22-pole ion trap , which scales as @xmath43 . for large rf amplitudes , however
, new features in the potential have been observed in the form of ten almost equally spaced potential minima .
these minima arise from the breaking of the 22-fold symmetry of the trap .
they can be quantitatively explained by a slight tilt of half of the multipole rf electrodes within their mechanical tolerances . also for other multipole ion traps @xmath42 minima in the effective trapping potential have been found as a consequence of a broken symmetry of the trap .
this observation , which has become possible due to the high sensitivity of our photodetachment tomography scans , has implications for other spectroscopic experiments in 22-pole ion traps .
in particular at cryogenic temperatures , trapped ions will reside predominantly in the ten pockets of the potential .
correspondingly , the ion density along the symmetry axis of the trap would become very small and only a small spectroscopic signal would be detected for a laser beam pointing along the trap axis .
further studies are needed to find out if ions that reside in the ten pockets may be subject to enhanced radiofrequency heating , similar to the influence of the static end electrode potential , which can increase the translational temperature by a few kelvin @xcite .
generally , it is therefore advisable to operate the ion trap at rf amplitudes far below 100v to significantly suppress the pockets . to overcome the pockets a significantly enhanced precision in the manufacturing and assembly of 22-pole traps
is required .
an interesting alternative for precisely controllable multipole ion traps are planar , chip - based traps @xcite .
we thank ferdinand schmidt - kaler for helpful discussions .
this work is supported by the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft under contract no .
we 2592/2 - 1 .
p.h . acknowledges support by the alexander von humboldt foundation . k.s .
acknowledges support by the european commission within emali ( contract no .
mrtn - ct-2006 - 035369 ) and the landesstiftung baden - wrttemberg in the framework atomics ( contract no . pn 63.14 ) and the eliteprogramm postdoktorandinnen und postdoktoranden.
10 url # 1#1urlprefix[2][]#2 gerlich d 1992 _ adv .
phys . _ * 82 * 1 ions at 300k buffer gas temperature with the rf amplitude set to 160v .
the sketched geometry shows the layout of the ion trap , viewed along its symmetry axis .
it includes the copper housing , the 22 rf electrodes ( end - on ) , a surrounding shaping electrode , and the end electrodes .
b ) zoom into the measured ion density distribution , each pixel represents an individual decay rate measurement .
c ) one - dimensional cut through the density distribution along the horizontal axis .
d ) effective potential derived from the density distribution by assuming a boltzmanm distribution of the trapped ions at 300k . ]
a ) . the right wall of the trap together with the 11 implanted rf electrodes has been tilted by an angle of @xmath44 .
b ) calculated ion density distribution for 300k in the effective potential of 270v rf amplitude and -2v static end electrode potential .
a tilt angle of 0.15@xmath45 is chosen , which leads to a good agreement with the measured density distribution shown in fig .
[ fig3]a . ] | the column density distribution of trapped oh@xmath0 ions in a 22-pole ion trap is measured for different trap parameters .
the density is obtained from position - dependent photodetachment rate measurements .
overall , agreement is found with the effective potential of an ideal 22-pole .
however , in addition we observe 10 distinct minima in the trapping potential , which indicate a breaking of the 22-fold symmetry .
numerical simulations show that a displacement of a subset of the radiofrequency electrodes can serve as an explanation for this symmetry breaking . |
experimental investigations of the rheology of concentrated suspensions often involve a vane - in - cup geometry ( see @xcite for a review ) .
the vane tool offers two main advantages over other geometries .
first , it allows the study of the properties of structured materials with minimal disturbance of the material structure during the insertion of the tool [ @xcite ] .
it is thus widely used to study the properties of gels and thixotropic materials [ @xcite ] and for in situ study of materials as e.g. in the context of soil mechanics [ @xcite ] .
second , it is supposed to avoid wall slip [ @xcite ] , which is a critical feature in concentrated suspensions [ @xcite ] ; the reason for this belief is that the material sheared in the gap of the geometry is sheared by the ( same ) material that is trapped between the blades .
consequently , it is widely used to study the behavior of pasty materials containing large particles , such as fresh concrete [ @xcite ] and foodstuff [ @xcite ] .
the constitutive law of materials can be obtained from a rheological study with the vane - in - cup geometry provided one knows the coefficients called `` geometry factors '' that allow the conversion of the raw macroscopic data ( torque , rotational angle or velocity ) into local data ( shear stress , shear strain or shear rate ) .
however , in contrast with other classical geometries , even the _ a priori _ simple linear problem ( for hookean or newtonian materials ) is complex to solve with a vane tool .
this linear problem was studied theoretically by @xcite and @xcite in the general case of a @xmath2-bladed vane tool embedded in an infinite linear medium .
the analytical expression found for the torque vs. rotational velocity is in rather good agreement with macroscopic experimental data [ @xcite ] .
note however two possible shortcomings of this theoretical approach for its use in practice : the blades are infinitely thin and there is no external cylinder .
there is no such approach in the case of nonlinear media ( _ i.e. _ complex fluids ) .
a practical method used to study the flow properties of non - linear materials , known as the couette analogy [ @xcite ] , consists in calibrating the geometry factors with hookean or newtonian materials .
one defines the equivalent inner radius @xmath3 of the vane - in - cup geometry as the radius of the inner cylinder of a couette geometry that would have the same geometry factors for a linear material . for any material , all macroscopic data
are then analyzed as if the material was sheared in a couette geometry of inner cylinder radius @xmath3 .
the nonlinearity ( that affects the flow field ) is sometimes accounted for as it is in a standard couette geometry [ @xcite ] .
this approach may finally provide constitutive law measurements within a good approximation [ @xcite ] .
however , simulations and observations show that @xmath3 is not a universal parameter of the vane tool independent of the properties of the studied material . while the streamlines go into the virtual cylinder delimited by the blades in the case of newtonian media [ @xcite ] , yielding an equivalent radius lower than the vane radius [ @xcite ] , it was found from simulations [ @xcite ] that the streamlines are nearly cylindrical everywhere for shear - thinning fluids if their index @xmath4 is of order 0.5 or less , and thus that @xmath5 in these cases .
moreover , for yield stress fluids , simulations and photographs of the shearing zone around a four - bladed vane rotating in bingham fluids [ @xcite ] , simulations of herschel - bulkley and casson fluids flows in a four - bladed vane - in - cup geometry [ @xcite ] , and simulations of bingham fluids flows in a six - bladed vane - in - cup geometry [ @xcite ] , all show that at yield ( _ i.e. _ at low shear rates ) , the material contained in the virtual cylinder delimited by the blades rotates as a rigid body , and that it flows uniformly in a thin cylindrical layer near the blades .
this is now widely accepted [ @xcite ] and used to perform a couette analogy with @xmath5 ; the yield stress @xmath6 is then simply extracted from torque @xmath7 measurements at low velocity thanks to @xmath8 , where @xmath9 is the vane tool height ( neglecting end effects ) [ @xcite ] .
the flow field in a vane - in - cup geometry and its consequences on the geometry factors have thus led to many studies .
however , only theoretical calculations , macroscopic measurements and simulation data exist in the literature : there are no experimental local measurements of the flow properties of newtonian and non - newtonian materials induced by a vane tool except the qualitative visualization of streamlines made by @xcite for newtonian media , and the photographs of @xcite for yield stress fluids .
moreover , while the main advantage of the vane tool is the postulated absence of wall slip , as far as we know , this widely accepted hypothesis has been neither investigated in depth nor criticized . in order to provide such local data ,
we have performed velocity measurements during the flows of a newtonian medium and of a yield stress fluid in both a coaxial cylinder geometry and a vane - in - cup geometry .
we have also performed particle concentration measurements in a concentrated suspension of noncolloidal particles in a yield stress fluid , which is a good model system for complex pastes such as fresh concrete [ @xcite ] .
our main results are that : 1 . in the newtonian
fluid , the @xmath0-averaged strain rate component @xmath1 decreases as the inverse squared radius in the gap , as in a couette geometry , which allows direct determination ( without end - effect corrections ) of the value of @xmath3 : it is here found to be lower than @xmath10 , but slightly higher than for a vane in an infinite medium ; the flow enters deeply the region between the blades , leading to a significant extensional flow ; 2 . in the yield stress
fluid , in contrast with results from the literature , the layer of material that is sheared near the blades at low velocity does not have a cylindrical shape ; 3 . in the suspension of noncolloidal particles in a yield stress fluid , the noncolloidal particles are quickly expelled from a thin zone near the blades , leading to the development of a thin slip layer made of the pure interstitial yield stress fluid , in sharp contradiction with the common belief that the vane tool prevents slippage . in sec .
[ section_display ] , we present the materials employed and the experimental setup .
we present the experimental results in sec .
[ section_results ] : velocity profiles obtained with a newtonian oil and with a yield stress fluid are presented in sec .
[ section_results][section_oil ] and sec .
[ section_results][section_emulsion ] , while sec .
[ section_results][section_suspension ] is devoted to the case of suspensions , with a focus on the slip layer created by a shear - induced migration phenomenon specific to the vane tool . throughout this paper ,
we use cylindrical coordinates @xmath11 .
all flows are supposed to be @xmath12 invariants ( _ i.e. _ there are no flow instabilities ) .
we define the @xmath0-average @xmath13 of a function @xmath14 as @xmath15 .
we study three materials : a newtonian fluid , a yield stress fluid , and a concentrated suspension of noncolloidal particles in this yield stress fluid . + the newtonian fluid is a silicon oil of 20 mpa.s viscosity .
+ the yield stress fluid is a concentrated water in oil emulsion .
the continuous phase is dodecane oil in which span 80 emulsifier is dispersed at a 7% concentration .
a 100 g / l cacl@xmath16 solution is then dispersed in the oil phase at 6000 rpm during 1 hour with a sliverson l4rt mixer .
the droplets have a size of order 1 @xmath17 m from microscope observations .
the droplet concentration is 75% , and the emulsion density is @xmath18 g@xmath19 .
the emulsion behavior , measured through coupled rheological and mri techniques described in @xcite ( see fig .
[ figure_emulsion_behavior ] ) , is well fitted to a herschel - bulkley behavior @xmath20 with yield stress @xmath21 pa , consistency @xmath22=6.8 pas@xmath23 , and index @xmath24 . + .
the empty squares are local data ; the solid line is a herschel - bulkley fit to the data @xmath20 with @xmath21 pa , @xmath22=6.8 pas@xmath23 , and @xmath24.,width=302 ] + the suspension is a suspension of monodisperse polystyrene beads ( density @xmath25 g@xmath19 , diameter @xmath26 m ) suspended at a 40@xmath27 volume fraction in the concentrated emulsion described above .
the density matching between the particles and the yield stress fluid is sufficient to prevent shear - induced sedimentation of the particles in the yield stress fluid [ @xcite ] ; in all experiments , we check that the material remains homogeneous in the vertical direction by means of mri density measurements .
the rheometric experiments are mainly performed within a six - bladed vane - in - cup geometry ( vane radius @xmath28 cm , outer cylinder radius @xmath29 cm , height @xmath3011 cm ) .
the shaft radius is 1.1 cm and the blade thickness is 6 mm .
other experiments are performed with a wide - gap couette geometry of slightly different inner cylinder radius @xmath31 cm , due to the presence of sandpaper ( the other dimensions were identical ) .
the inner cylinder of the couette geometry , and the outer cylinder of both geometries are covered with sandpaper of roughness equivalent to the size of the largest elements of the materials studied in order to avoid wall slip .
+ in the rheometric experiments presented here , we control the rotational velocity of the inner cylinder , with values ranging from 0.1 to 100 rpm .
proton mri [ @xcite ] was chosen as a non - intrusive technique in order to get measurements of the local velocity and of the local bead concentration inside the sample .
experiments are performed on a bruker 24/80 dbx spectrometer equipped with a 0.5 t vertical superconductive magnet with 40 cm bore diameter and operating at 21 mhz ( proton frequency ) .
we perform our experiments with a home made nmr - compliant rheometer , equipped with the geometries described in the previous section .
this device was already used in a number of previous rheo - nmr studies [ @xcite ] , and is fully described in @xcite .
the volume imaged is a ( virtual ) rectangular portion of 4 cm in the axial ( vertical ) direction with a width ( in the tangential direction ) of 1 cm and a length of 7 cm ( in the radial direction , starting from the central axis ) .
velocity and concentration profiles @xmath32 and @xmath33 , averaged over the vertical and tangential directions in this volume , are obtained with a resolution of 270 @xmath17 m in the radial direction .
this volume is situated at the magnet center ( so as to minimize the effects of field heterogeneities ) and sufficiently far from the bottom and the free surface of the rheometer so that flow perturbations due to edge effects are negligible .
we checked that the velocity and concentration profiles are homogeneous along the vertical direction in this volume , which justifies averaging data over this direction .
details on the sequence used to obtain velocity profiles can be found in [ @xcite ] . while it is possible to get 2d or 3d maps of 2d or 3d velocity vectors [ @xcite ] , such measurements may actually take minutes and require complex synchronization of the mri sequences and of the geometry position
. however , we will show in the following that the azimuthal velocity alone provides a valuable information that can be sufficient for most analyses ; in particular it allows computation of the @xmath0-averaged strain rate component @xmath34 and thus the @xmath0-averaged shear stress @xmath35 ( and the torque @xmath7 ) in the case of the newtonian oil .
that is why we have chosen to limit ourselves to 1d profiles of 1d velocity measurements , namely the azimuthal velocity @xmath36 as a function of the radius @xmath37 and time @xmath38 , for which a single measurement may take as little as 1 s ; this has allowed us to perform a sufficient number of experiments , with various materials , geometries , and rotational velocities .
depending on the time over which this measurement is averaged as compared to @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the number of blades and @xmath41 is the rotational velocity , this measurement may provide either a time ( or @xmath42)-averaged azimuthal velocity @xmath43 or an instantaneous ( transient ) azimuthal velocity @xmath36 . in this latter case , the @xmath42 dependence of the azimuthal velocity @xmath44 at a given radius @xmath37 can then be easily reconstructed by simply replacing the time @xmath38 dependence by an angular @xmath42 dependence with @xmath45 .
it should also be noted that due to incompressibility of the materials we study , the @xmath46 field can be reconstructed thanks to @xmath47 with @xmath48 ; however , this derivation from the experimentally measured values of @xmath44 can not be very accurate . finally , from @xmath46 and @xmath44 , we are also able to evaluate the strain rate components @xmath49 and @xmath50 $ ] .
note that the derivative @xmath51 with respect to coordinate @xmath52 of experimental data @xmath53 measured at regularly spaced positions @xmath54 was computed as : @xmath55/[x_{i+1}-x_{i-1}]$ ] .
the nmr sequence used in this work to measure the local bead concentration is a modified version of the sequence aiming at measuring velocity profiles along one diameter in couette geometry [ @xcite ] , and is described in full detail in @xcite .
the basic idea is that during measurements , only nmr signal originating from those hydrogen nuclei belonging to the liquid phase of the sample ( _ i.e. _ both the oil and water phase of the emulsions ) is recorded : the local nmr signal that is measured is thus proportional to @xmath56 , where @xmath57 is the local particle volume fraction .
a rather low absolute uncertainty of @xmath58 on the concentration measurements values was estimated in @xcite .
all volume fraction profiles are measured at rest , after a given flow history .
this is possible because the particles do not settle in the yield stress fluid at rest : the volume fraction profile induced by shear is gelled by the interstitial yield stress fluid .
in this section , we study successively the flow properties of the newtonian oil , the yield stress fluid , and the suspension . in this section ,
we study the flows observed with a newtonian fluid .
we first present a basic theoretical analysis of the flows in a vane - in - cup geometry as compared to flows in a standard couette geometry , which provides the basis for a couette analogy .
the @xmath42-averaged azimuthal profiles @xmath59 are then shown , and are compared to predictions of the couette analogy . the full velocity field @xmath60 , @xmath46 is finally presented and analyzed .
the stress balance equation projected along the azimuthal axis is : ( 1/r)_r(r^2)+_()-_p=0 [ equation_balance]where @xmath61 is the deviatoric stress tensor and @xmath62 the pressure .
the strain rate tensor component @xmath1 is given by : ( r,)=((1/r)_(v_r)+r_r ( v_/r))[equation_strain_rate ] we recall that the constitutive law of a newtonian fluid of viscosity @xmath63 is : = 2[equation_newtonian ] .
in all the following analysis , we assume a no - slip boundary condition at the walls of the inner tool and of the cup . in a standard coaxial cylinders couette geometry , due to cylindrical symmetry , eq .
[ equation_balance ] becomes @xmath64 which means that the whole shear stress distribution @xmath65 in the gap is known whatever the constitutive law of the material is .
if a torque @xmath66 is exerted on the inner cylinder driven at a rotational velocity @xmath41 , @xmath65 is given by : ( r)=-[equation_tau_couette]for a newtonian fluid of viscosity @xmath63 , it follows that the strain rate component @xmath67 is given by : ( r)=-as eq . [ equation_strain_rate ] becomes @xmath68 with cylindrical symmetry , due to the boundary conditions @xmath69 and @xmath70 , from @xmath71 , one gets alternatively @xmath72 $ ] .
this yields the following azimuthal velocity profile : v_(r)=[equation_velocity_couette]finally , the viscosity @xmath63 of a newtonian fluid is obtained from the measured torque / rotational velocity relationship @xmath66 through = [ equation_visco_couette ] these equations will be used for the comparison with the flows observed in a vane - in - cup geometry , in particular to determine the radius @xmath3 of the equivalent couette geometry . in a vane - in - cup geometry ,
there is _ a priori _ no cylindrical symmetry and all quantities _ a priori _
depend on @xmath0 .
however , averaging eq .
[ equation_balance ] over @xmath42 yields @xmath73 .
this means that what is true in a couette geometry , @xmath74 , is still true on average with a vane - in - cup geometry : @xmath75 independently of the material s constitutive law .
note that this derivation is true only between @xmath10 and @xmath76 ; this is not true for the material between the blades as the unknown @xmath61 distribution in the blades contributes to the @xmath0-average .
the link between this stress distribution and the torque @xmath66 exerted on the vane tool may then seem difficult to build .
however , it can be equivalently computed on the outer cylinder as @xmath77 .
this means that eq .
[ equation_tau_couette ] is still valid for the @xmath42-averaged shear stress in the vane - in - cup geometry , for @xmath78 : _
r(r)=-[equation_tau_vane ] from the @xmath0-averaged eq .
[ equation_newtonian ] , this means that the @xmath0-averaged strain rate distribution in a newtonian fluid , for @xmath78 , is : |d_r(r)=-from the @xmath42-averaged eq .
[ equation_strain_rate ] @xmath79 , this means that the @xmath0-averaged azimuthal velocity profile of a newtonian fluid of viscosity @xmath63 in a vane - in - cup geometry for @xmath78 , with a boundary condition @xmath80 is given by : ( r)=[equation_velocity_vane ] finally , the only difference with a standard couette flow , as regards these @xmath42-averaged quantities , is that we do not know the value of @xmath81 ; we only know that @xmath82 , for @xmath83 integer , where @xmath2 is the number of blades .
this means that @xmath84 and @xmath59 follow the same scaling with @xmath37 and @xmath41 as in the standard couette geometry , but with a different prefactor .
nevertheless , these equations provide a new insight in the couette analogy .
the usual way of performing the couette analogy consists in defining the radius of the equivalent couette geometry @xmath3 as the radius that allows measuring the viscosity @xmath63 of a newtonian fluid with the standard couette formula . from eq .
[ equation_visco_couette ] , @xmath63 should then be correctly obtained from the torque / rotational velocity relationship @xmath66 measured in a vane - in - cup geometry with : = [ equation_visco_vane]from eqs .
[ equation_visco_couette ] and [ equation_visco_vane ] , it means in particular that the torque @xmath85 exerted by the vane tool is decreased by a factor = [ equation_torque_rieq]as compared to the torque @xmath86 exerted by the inner cylinder of a couette geometry of same radius @xmath10 at a same rotational velocity . here , from eqs .
[ equation_velocity_vane ] and [ equation_velocity_couette ] , we see that from the local flow perspective , there is a couette analogy in the sense that the @xmath0-averaged azimuthal velocity ( and shear ) profiles will be exactly the same as in a couette geometry .
this defines a radius @xmath3 of the equivalent couette geometry , such that @xmath59 and @xmath84 for @xmath78 are given by : ( r)=[equation_velocity_vane_eq ] + @xmath3 are equivalent : combining eqs .
[ equation_velocity_vane ] and [ equation_visco_vane ] yields eq .
[ equation_velocity_vane_eq ] .
this point of view provides an additional meaning to the couette analogy , namely the similarity of the average flows , and offers a new experimental mean to determine @xmath3 , which is more accurate than calibration . in rheological measurements ,
the @xmath66 relationship has to be corrected for end effects [ @xcite ] and the couette analogy has to be calibrated on a reference material of known viscosity . here , the @xmath59 or @xmath87 measurements provide the value of @xmath3 directly without any correction , as only shear in the gap is involved in the analysis , and independent of the viscosity of the material .
this will be illustrated in the following .
the only theoretical prediction of the stress field associated with a vane tool is that of @xcite for an infinite @xmath2-bladed vane embedded in an infinite linear medium . in this case
, it is shown that the torque @xmath88 exerted on the vane is well approximated by = 1-[equation_prediction_atkinson ] where @xmath89 is the torque exerted on a cylinder of same radius @xmath10 as the vane in an infinite medium ( _ i.e. _ with @xmath90 ) .
[ equation_prediction_atkinson ] is in agreement with experimental results [ @xcite ] .
@xcite argue that , as the stress distribution varies as @xmath91 in a couette geometry , @xmath92 should be of the order of 1% or less in order to nullify the influence of the outer boundary ; this is clearly the case in their experiments and in field experiments where the vane is embedded e.g. in a soil ; this is clearly not the case in our experiments and in most rheological experiments that make use of a vane - in - cup geometry .
however , when the cup to vane radius ratio @xmath93 is not large , no generic theoretical expression exists in the literature . nevertheless , bounds of the value of the torque @xmath94 can be derived using classical results of linear elasticity [ @xcite ] .
our starting points are the variational approaches to the solution of the stokes equations describing the flow of an incompressible linear material induced by the rotation of an inner tool ( of any shape ) at a rotational velocity @xmath41 within a cup . in this framework
, it can be shown that [ @xcite ] : @xmath95 where @xmath96 denotes the inner tool - fluid interface and @xmath97 the domain occupied by the fluid . in the first inequality ,
@xmath98 is any stress tensor complying with the stress balance equations , @xmath99 is the azimuthal component of the surface forces applied by the tool on the fluid and @xmath100 is the deviatoric stress tensor associated to @xmath98 . in the second inequality , @xmath101 is the strain rate tensor associated with any velocity field @xmath102 complying with the incompressibility constraint and the boundary conditions prescribed on the tool - fluid and cup - fluid interfaces .
[ eq : bounds ] leads in particular to the expected inequalities : @xmath103 the lower bound is obtained by using the velocity field defined by @xmath104 for @xmath105 and @xmath106 for @xmath107 , where @xmath108 is the solution for the @xmath2-bladed vane of radius @xmath10 in a cup of radius @xmath76 .
@xmath102 complies with the boundary conditions for the @xmath2-bladed vane of radius @xmath10 in an infinite domain problem . then , putting this test velocity field within the second inequality ( [ eq : bounds ] ) with @xmath109 and using @xmath110 yields the lower bound of the inequality ( [ eq : expectedbounds ] ) for the quantity @xmath111 . in eq .
[ eq : clapeyron ] , @xmath112 denotes the strain rate tensor associated with @xmath113 while @xmath114 is the domain occupied by the fluid .
the upper bound is obtained using the test velocity field defined by @xmath115 with @xmath116 defined by eq .
[ equation_velocity_couette ] for @xmath117 and by @xmath118 for @xmath119 .
it is easily checked that @xmath102 complies with the velocity boundary conditions for any vane - in - cup geometry with vane radius @xmath10 and cup radius @xmath76 . putting this test velocity field into the second inequality ( [ eq : bounds ] )
then yields the upper bound of inequality ( [ eq : expectedbounds ] ) .
finally , combining inequalities ( [ eq : expectedbounds ] ) , eq .
[ equation_prediction_atkinson ] and eq .
[ equation_visco_couette ] yields @xmath120 of course , it is possible to improve the lower bound by determining admissible test stress fields for the problem under consideration and the inequalities ( [ eq : bounds ] ) .
for example , let us consider the stress field defined between the two blades positioned at @xmath121 by @xmath122 with @xmath123 for @xmath119 and by @xmath124 for @xmath117 .
this stress field complies with the balance equations within the fluid domain .
let us recall that a stress field does not need to be continuous to comply with the balance equations ( of course , this stress field is not the solution of the problem ) .
putting this stress field into the first inequality ( [ eq : bounds ] ) and using a numerical optimization tool to choose the optimal value of the parameter @xmath125 yields a new lower bound for the @xmath2-bladed vane in cup problem , which depends on @xmath2 and @xmath126 . in some cases , this test stress field improves the lower bound of inequality ( [ eq:17dego ] ) : e.g. , for the geometry we use in this study ( @xmath127 ) , the new lower bound is @xmath128 while the lower bound given by inequality ( [ eq:17dego ] ) is @xmath129 .
nevertheless , such an improvement is not obtained for all parameter sets ( @xmath2,@xmath126 ) .
it is thus necessary to compute the two lower bounds for each value of ( @xmath2,@xmath126 ) in order to obtain the more accurate lower estimate of the torque .
although application of variational approaches to the derivation of estimates of the applied torque of a vane - in - cup problem is not classical , it is believed that such a strategy is able to provide useful results when no theoretical prediction of the solution is available for particular geometries .
lower bounds of @xmath130 computed using the approach presented above are displayed in tab .
[ tab_torque_reduction ] and are compared below to our results and to data in the literature .
we first study the @xmath0-averaged azimuthal velocity profiles @xmath59 observed during the flows of a newtonian oil ( fig .
[ figure_mean_velocity_vane ] ) .
as shown above , these profiles can be used to check the validity of the couette analogy and to determine the couette equivalent radius @xmath3 .
the azimuthal dependence of the velocity profiles between two adjacent blades of the vane tool will then be considered . of a newtonian oil in a couette geometry ( @xmath31 cm ) , at various rotational velocities
@xmath41 ranging from 2 to 20 rpm ; the solid line is the theoretical profile for a newtonian fluid .
b ) dimensionless @xmath0-averaged velocity profile @xmath131 of a newtonian oil in a six - bladed vane - in - cup geometry ( @xmath28 cm ) for @xmath41 ranging from 1 to 9 rpm ; the vertical dashed line shows the radius of the vane ; the dotted line is the theoretical profile for a rigid body rotation ( for @xmath132 ) ; the solid lines are the theoretical profiles for a newtonian fluid in couette geometries of radii , from right to left : ( i ) @xmath28 cm , ( ii ) @xmath133 cm , and ( iii ) @xmath134 cm corresponding to the @xcite theory in an infinite medium.,title="fig:",width=298 ] of a newtonian oil in a couette geometry ( @xmath31 cm ) , at various rotational velocities @xmath41 ranging from 2 to 20 rpm ; the solid line is the theoretical profile for a newtonian fluid .
b ) dimensionless @xmath0-averaged velocity profile @xmath131 of a newtonian oil in a six - bladed vane - in - cup geometry ( @xmath28 cm ) for @xmath41 ranging from 1 to 9 rpm ; the vertical dashed line shows the radius of the vane ; the dotted line is the theoretical profile for a rigid body rotation ( for @xmath132 ) ; the solid lines are the theoretical profiles for a newtonian fluid in couette geometries of radii , from right to left : ( i ) @xmath28 cm , ( ii ) @xmath133 cm , and ( iii ) @xmath134 cm corresponding to the @xcite theory in an infinite medium.,title="fig:",width=298 ] in fig .
[ figure_mean_velocity_vane]a we observe that the velocity profiles in the gap of a couette geometry are , as expected , in perfect agreement with the theory for a newtonian flow ( eq . [ equation_velocity_couette ] ) .
this first observation can be seen as a validation of the measurement technique . in the vane - in - cup geometry ( fig .
[ figure_mean_velocity_vane]b ) , we first note that the @xmath0-averaged dimensionless azimuthal velocity profiles @xmath131 measured for several rotational velocities @xmath41 are superposed , as expected from the linear behavior of the material .
we also remark that the material between the blades rotates as a rigid body only up to @xmath135 cm , indicating that the shear flow enters deeply the region between the blades ( the vane radius is 4.02 cm ) .
the whole limit between the sheared and the unsheared material in the ( @xmath136 ) plane will be determined in sec . [ section_results][section_oil][section_theta_profiles ] ( fig .
[ figure_temporal_profiles]b ) .
we finally observe that the theoretical velocity profile for a newtonian fluid in a couette geometry of radius equal to that of the vane lies above the data , as expected from the literature .
this is also consistent with the observation that the shear flow enters the region between the vane blades . in order to test the couette analogy ,
we have chosen to plot the @xmath0-averaged strain rate @xmath137 vs. the radius @xmath37 in fig .
[ figure_mean_gradient_vane ] .
this allows us to distinguish more clearly the difference between the experimental and theoretical flow properties than would the velocity profiles , because the velocity profile always tends to the same limit ( @xmath138 ) at the outer cylinder whereas the strain rate profile does not .
note that velocity measurements could not be performed close to the blades , which explains why strain rate data are missing from 4 to 4.2 cm .
-averaged strain rate @xmath137 vs. radius @xmath37 for a newtonian oil sheared at 1 rpm in a six - bladed vane - in - cup geometry .
the vertical dashed line shows the radius of the vane .
the solid lines are the theoretical strain rate profiles for a newtonian fluid in couette geometries of radii : ( i ) @xmath28 cm ( light grey ) , ( ii ) @xmath133 cm ( black ) , and ( iii ) @xmath134 cm ( dark grey ) corresponding to the @xcite theory in a infinite medium.,width=340 ] in fig .
[ figure_mean_gradient_vane ] , we first note that @xmath139 is zero up to @xmath140 cm , which corresponds to the limit of the rigid motion of the material ; @xmath137 then increases when @xmath37 tends towards @xmath10 as the material is more and more sheared between the blades . in the gap of the geometry , @xmath139 decreases when @xmath37 increases .
as expected , the theoretical strain rate profile for a newtonian material in a couette geometry of radius equal to that of the vane falls well above the data _ at any radius @xmath37 _
( this was less obvious on the velocity profiles ) .
we then observe that the data are well fitted to the theoretical strain rate profile ( eq . [ equation_strainrate_vane ] ) for a newtonian material flowing in an equivalent couette geometry of inner cylinder radius @xmath133 cm ( @xmath141 cm was obtained from a fit of the velocity profile to eq . [ equation_velocity_vane_eq ] ) .
this confirms that the @xmath0-averaged strain rate @xmath137 decreases as the inverse squared radius in the gap , in agreement with the couette analogy . from eq .
[ equation_torque_rieq ] , we find @xmath142 ( let us recall that we do not need to consider end effects here because we determine the shear rate within the gap , and hence only the contribution to the torque from the material sheared in the gap ) .
this value can now be compared to data from the literature . for a six - bladed vane tool in an infinite medium ,
the @xcite theory would imply a theoretical @xmath143 , which is 8% lower than what we measure , and corresponds to a theoretical `` equivalent radius '' @xmath134 cm when the vane is embedded in a cup of radius @xmath29 cm .
[ figure_mean_velocity_vane]b and [ figure_mean_gradient_vane ] show that the flow characteristics predicted with this value of the equivalent radius can be distinguished from our experimental data and fall slightly below the data ( a discrepancy could be expected as @xmath92 is not small in our experiment ) .
.ratio @xmath130 between the torque measured when straining a linear medium ( viscous or elastic ) in a vane - in - cup geometry and that measured in a coaxial cylinder geometry of similar dimensions , obtained in various theoretical , numerical and experimental studies of the literature ; only data corrected for ( or free from ) end effects are shown .
the number @xmath2 of blades , the cup to vane radius ratio @xmath93 , the shaft radius to vane radius ratio @xmath144 , and the blade thickness to vane radius ratio @xmath145 , are displayed when provided in the manuscripts .
the theoretical lower bound computed using variational approaches in sec .
[ section_results][section_oil][section_analogy ] is also provided . [
cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] we have gathered experimental and numerical data from the literature where the cup to vane radius ratio @xmath93 is not large in tab . [ tab_torque_reduction ] ; only data corrected for ( or free from ) end effects are shown .
first , it should be noted that all torque data obey the theoretical inequalities computed using variational approaches in sec .
[ section_results][section_oil][section_analogy ] . however , no clear trends emerge from the comparison of the data .
the relative impact of the various geometrical parameters that may affect the flow field , namely the cup to vane radius ratio @xmath93 , the shaft radius to vane radius ratio @xmath144 , and the blade thickness to vane radius ratio @xmath145 , can not be determined at this stage .
for example , in very similar geometries , @xcite find a torque ratio @xmath130 close to that of @xcite whereas @xcite find a much lower torque ratio .
the only noticeable difference between these two studies ( apart from the numerical method ) is that @xmath144 is higher in @xcite , but our data , with a rather large value of @xmath144 , show different features .
we actually note that our study is the only one to report a torque ratio higher than in an infinite medium ; all other data report torque ratios up to 19% lower than expected in an infinite medium . in the general case of a finite vane - in - cup geometry
, it thus seems that numerical investigations are still needed , and that , at this stage , a calibration has to be performed to get the geometry factors .
we also expect that the bounds obtained using variational approaches in sec .
[ section_results][section_oil][section_analogy ] can be improved . to better characterize the flow field
, we now study the dependence of the velocity profiles on the angular position @xmath0 .
we have performed experiments in which we measure one azimuthal velocity profile per second while the vane tool is rotated at 1 rpm , yielding 10 profiles between two adjacent blades . of a newtonian oil sheared at 1 rpm in a six - bladed vane - in - cup geometry , for various angular positions , @xmath0 , between one blade ( @xmath146 ) and midway between adjacent blades ( @xmath147 ) .
the vertical dashed line shows the radius of the vane .
the dotted line is the profile for a rigid body rotation ( for @xmath132 ) and the theoretical profile for a newtonian fluid in a couette geometry of radius @xmath10 ( for @xmath148 ) .
b ) two - dimensional plot of the limit between rigid motion and shear ( empty circles ) for a newtonian material in the six - bladed vane - in - cup geometry ; the grey rectangles correspond to the blades.,title="fig:",width=328 ] of a newtonian oil sheared at 1 rpm in a six - bladed vane - in - cup geometry , for various angular positions , @xmath0 , between one blade ( @xmath146 ) and midway between adjacent blades ( @xmath147 ) .
the vertical dashed line shows the radius of the vane .
the dotted line is the profile for a rigid body rotation ( for @xmath132 ) and the theoretical profile for a newtonian fluid in a couette geometry of radius @xmath10 ( for @xmath148 ) .
b ) two - dimensional plot of the limit between rigid motion and shear ( empty circles ) for a newtonian material in the six - bladed vane - in - cup geometry ; the grey rectangles correspond to the blades.,title="fig:",width=268 ] in fig .
[ figure_temporal_profiles]a , we plot the velocity profiles @xmath149 measured at different angles @xmath0 .
we first observe that the velocity profile which starts near from a blade tip ( corresponding to @xmath146by definition ) is very different from the velocity profile in a couette geometry of same radius : it starts with a much steeper slope , which means that the blades tip neighborhoods are regions of important shear as already observed by @xcite .
we then observe that , as expected from the @xmath0-averaged velocity profiles , the shear flow enters more and more deeply the region between the blades as @xmath0 tends towards @xmath150(corresponding to midway between two adjacent blades ) ; at this angular position , the rigid rotation stops at @xmath151 cm .
from all the velocity profiles , we finally extract a 2d map of the limit @xmath152 between rigid rotation and shear , which is depicted in fig .
[ figure_temporal_profiles]b .
this provides an idea of the deviation from cylindrical symmetry , and will be compared in the following to the case of yield stress fluids .
note that eddies are likely to be present in the `` rigid '' region [ @xcite ] ; however , we did not observe any signature of their existence : they can thus be considered as second - order phenomena . of a newtonian oil sheared at 1 rpm in a six - bladed vane - in - cup geometry , for various angular positions @xmath0 between two adjacent blades ( from @xmath146to @xmath153).,width=340 ] as explained in sec .
[ section_display ] , from the @xmath149 measurement and from the material incompressibility , we are able to reconstruct the radial velocity profile @xmath154 ( see fig .
[ figure_radial_velocity ] ) .
this also allows us to compute the strain rate components @xmath155 and @xmath156 , which are plotted in fig .
[ figure_temporal_gradients ] .
of course , due to the limited number of profiles between two adjacent blades , this method provides only a rough estimate of these quantities .
in addition to their interest for future comparison with models and simulations , these data allow us to evaluate the contribution of the extensional flow to dissipation ; here , in a newtonian medium , the local power density is given by : @xmath157 .
( left ) and @xmath158 ( right ) vs. radius @xmath37 for various angular positions @xmath0 between two adjacent blades ( from @xmath146to @xmath153).,title="fig:",width=274 ] ( left ) and @xmath158 ( right ) vs. radius @xmath37 for various angular positions @xmath0 between two adjacent blades ( from @xmath146to @xmath153).,title="fig:",width=323 ] in fig .
[ figure_radial_velocity ] , we first observe that @xmath159 for @xmath146and @xmath147 ; there is thus no extensional flow in these regions of space , as seen in fig .
[ figure_temporal_gradients ] .
this is actually expected from the fore - aft symmetry of the flow around these angular positions . @xmath160 and its spatial variations ( @xmath161 ) are maximal at @xmath162 .
meanwhile , we observe that @xmath1 is maximal near the blades : at @xmath163 it is more than 4 times larger at @xmath146than at @xmath147 .
we then find that @xmath1 ( and thus the shear stress @xmath164 ) decreases more rapidly from the blades ( at @xmath146 ) than the @xmath91 scaling of the couette geometry , whereas it does not vary much with @xmath37 midway between adjacent blades ( it even seems to slightly increase with @xmath37 as already observed in simulations by @xcite ) .
it is also worth nothing that at @xmath165 , in contrast with what is observed at @xmath163 , the shear stress value is of order two times lower at @xmath146than at @xmath147 . from the whole set of @xmath1 and @xmath161 measurements ( fig .
[ figure_temporal_gradients ] ) , we finally find that in regions where @xmath161 is maximal , the contribution of the extensional flow to dissipation is of order 25% . over the whole gap
, we then evaluate its average contribution to dissipation to be rather important , of order 5 to 10% .
this significant value may be a reason why the torque that has to be exerted to enforce flow is higher than that predicted by @xcite in an infinite medium . the confinement effect induced by a close boundary at a radius @xmath166
likely increases the contribution of the extensional flow to dissipation as compared to the case of an infinite medium ( although other effects may exist , as appears from the comparison of the data of tab .
[ tab_torque_reduction ] ) . in this section ,
we study the flows induced by the vane tool with a yield stress fluid ( a concentrated emulsion ) .
we focus on the behavior near the yielding transition , _
i.e. _ on low rotational velocities @xmath41
. -averaged velocity profile @xmath131 of a yield stress fluid ( concentrated emulsion ) in a six - bladed vane - in - cup geometry for @xmath41 ranging from 0.1 to 9 rpm ; the vertical dashed line shows the radius of the vane ; the dotted line is the theoretical profile for a rigid body rotation ( for @xmath132).,width=340 ] in fig .
[ figure_average_velocity_yield ] , we plot the @xmath0-averaged azimuthal velocity profiles @xmath59 measured at several @xmath41 values ranging from 0.1 to 9 rpm , corresponding to macroscopic shear rates varying between 0.02 and 2 s@xmath167 .
we first observe that flow is localized : the material is sheared only up to a radius @xmath168 .
@xmath169 is found to increase as @xmath41 increases .
this is a classical feature of flows of yield stress fluids in heterogeneous stress fields .
it has been observed in couette geometries [ @xcite ] , where it is attributed to the @xmath91 decrease of the shear stress @xmath164 , which passes below @xmath6 at some @xmath170 at low @xmath41 . in this case , when @xmath41 tends to 0 , @xmath169 tends to @xmath10 and the torque @xmath7 at the inner cylinder tends to @xmath171 . in the vane - in - cup geometry ,
the same argument holds qualitatively thanks to eq .
[ equation_tau_vane ] .
it implies that the flow has to stop inside the gap at low @xmath41 .
however , in contrast with the case of the couette geometry , as the whole stress field _ a priori _ depends on @xmath0 , this @xmath0-averaged equation does not provide the position of the limit between the sheared and the unsheared material ( which will determined at the end of this section ) .
we then observe that , although this effect is less pronounced than with a newtonian material , the shear flow still enters the region between the blades , even at the lowest studied @xmath41 .
close examination of the profiles shows that the material trapped between the blades rotates as a rigid body only up to @xmath172 cm at @xmath173 rpm , @xmath174 cm at @xmath175 rpm , and @xmath176 cm at @xmath177 rpm .
we recall that @xmath151 cm with a newtonian fluid in the same geometry . of a yield stress fluid ( concentrated emulsion ) sheared at 0.1 rpm in a six - bladed vane - in - cup geometry , for various angular positions @xmath0 between two adjacent blades ( from @xmath146to @xmath153 ) .
the vertical dashed line shows the radius of the vane.,width=340 ] as in sec .
[ section_results][section_oil][section_theta_profiles ] , to better characterize the flow field , we have performed experiments in which we have measured 10 azimuthal profiles between two adjacent blades at 0.1 rpm . in fig .
[ figure_temporal_velocity_yield ] , as for a newtonian fluid , we observe that there is a strong @xmath0-dependence of the velocity profiles .
the velocity profile that starts near from a blade tip ( at @xmath146 ) has a much steeper slope than the profile measured midway between adjacent blades ( at @xmath147 ) ; again , this shows that the blade tip neighborhoods are regions of high shear .
meanwhile the flow stops at a radius @xmath169 which is larger at @xmath147(4.5 cm ) than at @xmath146(4.3 cm ) .
note also that there may be slight fore - aft asymmetry , as sometimes observed with yield stress fluids flows [ @xcite ] , but we did not study this point further . from these velocity profiles , we have reconstructed a 2d map of the flow field ( fig . [ fig_rigid_limit_yield ] ) , indicating both the boundary between the region of rigid body rotation ( between the blades ) and the sheared region , and the boundary between the sheared region and the outer region of fluid at rest ( _ i.e. _ the position where the yield criterion is satisfied ) .
flow is found to occur in a layer of complex shape which is far from being cylindrical even at this very low velocity .
these observations are in contradiction with the usually accepted picture for yield stress fluid flows at low rates [ @xcite ] , namely that the material contained in the virtual cylinder delimited by the blades rotates as a rigid body , and that it flows uniformly in a thin cylindrical layer near the blades .
our results contrast in particular with previous numerical works which showed that the yield surface is cylindrical at low rates for bingham fluids , casson fluids , and herschel - bulkley materials with @xmath178 [ @xcite ] .
with apparently similar conditions to those in some of the @xcite simulations , we find an important departure from cylindrical symmetry .
this means that further investigation on the exact conditions under which this symmetry can be recovered is still needed .
possible difference between our work and that of @xcite is that the blade thickness is zero in this last study .
it is particularly striking and counterintuitive that @xmath169 is largest at the angular position ( @xmath147 ) where shear at @xmath10 is smallest ( similar observation was made by @xcite ) . as in sec .
[ section_results][section_oil][section_theta_profiles ] , this points out the importance of the extensional flow in this geometry , with @xmath0-dependent normal stress differences which have to be taken into account in the yield criterion , and which thus impact the yield surface .
it thus seems that the link between the yield stress @xmath6 and the torque @xmath7 measured at yield with a vane - in - cup geometry is still an open question , although the classical formula probably provides a sufficiently accurate determination of @xmath6 in practice .
the same 2d map as above is plotted for @xmath175 rpm in fig .
[ fig_rigid_limit_yield ] ; the same phenomena are observed , with enhanced departure from cylindrical symmetry , consistent with the observation that @xmath179 decreases when @xmath41 increases .
this result was also unexpected , as simulations find uniform flows for shear - thinning material of index @xmath180 [ @xcite ] ; we would have expected the same phenomenology in a herschel - bulkley material of index @xmath178 ( and thus @xmath179 to tend to @xmath10 when increasing @xmath41 ) .
this observation also shows that a couette analogy can hardly be defined for studying the flow properties of such materials in a vane - in - cup geometry because the equivalent couette geometry radius @xmath3 would probably depend also on @xmath41 ( as recently shown by @xcite ) .
let us finally note that this departure from cylindrical symmetry has important impact on the migration of particles in a yield stress fluid ( see below ) . in this section
, we investigate the behavior of a concentrated suspension of noncolloidal particles in a yield stress fluid ( at a 40% volume fraction ) .
a detailed study of their velocity profiles would _ a priori _ present here limited interest : such materials present the same nonlinear macroscopic behavior as the interstitial yield stress fluid , and their rheological properties ( yield stress , consistency ) depend moderately on the particle volume fraction [ @xcite ] .
on the other hand , noncolloidal particles in suspensions are known to be prone to shear - induced migration , which leads to volume fraction heterogeneities .
this phenomenon is well documented in the case of suspensions in newtonian fluids [ @xcite ] but is still badly known in yield stress fluids ( some studies exist however in viscoelastic fluids [ @xcite ] ) . in the model of @xcite and @xcite ,
migration is related to shear - induced diffusion of the particles [ @xcite ] . in a wide gap couette geometry ,
the shear stress heterogeneity is important ( eq .
[ equation_tau_couette ] ) ; the shear rate gradients then generate a particle flux towards the low shear zones , which is counterbalanced by a particle flux due to viscosity gradients . a steady state , which results from competition between both fluxes , may then be reached , and is characterized by an excess of particles in the low shear zones of the flow geometry ( near the outer cylinder in a wide - gap couette geometry [ @xcite ] ) .
note that there are other models [ @xcite ] in which particle fluxes counterbalance the gradients in the particle normal stresses , and which can be used directly for non - newtonian media . as the development of migration depends on the spatial variations of shear
, one may wonder how the azimuthal heterogeneities of shear introduced by the vane tool affect migration ; a related question is that of the relevance of the couette analogy for this phenomenon . in the following , we thus focus on the particle volume fraction distribution evolution when
the material is sheared .
we first study the behavior at high shear rate , in the absence of shear localization .
we shear the suspension in both the standard couette geometry and the vane - in - cup geometry at a rotational velocity @xmath181 rpm . in this first set of experiments ,
we only study the steady - state of migration . at @xmath181 rpm , this steady - state is reached in less than 30 min ( which corresponds to a macroscopic strain of order 50000 , consistently with strainscale evaluations from data of the literature [ @xcite ] ) . in fig .
[ fig_concentration_profile_omega100 ] we plot the steady state volume fraction profiles observed after shearing the suspension at @xmath181 rpm during 1h .
rpm in both the couette geometry ( empty circles ) and the vane - in - cup geometry ( squares ) . in the vane - in - cup geometry , the volume fraction profile is determined in a 1 cm thick slice situated exactly between two adjacent blades ( see fig . [
fig_image_vane_omega100]b ) .
the inset is a zoom ; the line is a fit of the data measured in the couette geometry to the @xcite model with @xmath182 .
b ) @xmath0-averaged azimuthal velocity profile @xmath59 ; the dotted line is the theoretical rigid motion induced by the rotation of the vane tool ; the vertical dashed line shows the radius of the vane.,title="fig:",width=308 ] rpm in both the couette geometry ( empty circles ) and the vane - in - cup geometry ( squares ) . in the vane - in - cup geometry , the volume fraction profile is determined in a 1 cm thick slice situated exactly between two adjacent blades ( see fig .
[ fig_image_vane_omega100]b ) .
the inset is a zoom ; the line is a fit of the data measured in the couette geometry to the @xcite model with @xmath182 .
b ) @xmath0-averaged azimuthal velocity profile @xmath59 ; the dotted line is the theoretical rigid motion induced by the rotation of the vane tool ; the vertical dashed line shows the radius of the vane.,title="fig:",width=289 ] as expected , we first observe that the material is strongly heterogeneous in the couette geometry : the volume fraction varies between 37% near the inner cylinder and 43% near the outer cylinder ( note that the nmr technique we use do not allow quantitative measurements near the walls ) .
this heterogeneity is quantitatively similar to that observed in couette flows of newtonian suspensions at a same 40% particle volume fraction [ @xcite ] ; the profiles are actually well fitted to the @xcite model ( see eq . 16 of @xcite ) with a dimensionless diffusion constant @xmath182 which is close to that found by @xcite ( @xmath183 ) , although this model is not expected to hold in non - newtonian suspensions . in the vane - in - cup geometry
, the volume fraction profile shows very different features ; note that the profile is measured in a 1 cm thick ( in the azimuthal direction ) slice situated exactly between two adjacent blades ( see fig .
[ fig_image_vane_omega100 ] ) . in fig .
[ fig_concentration_profile_omega100 ] , we first observe that there is a strong particle depletion in a wide zone between the blades .
a homogeneous volume fraction of 40% is observed for radii inferior to 3.1 cm . at a radius @xmath184
cm , there is a strong drop in the volume fraction down to 5% within 1 mm ( corresponding to 4 particle diameters ) .
close inspection of the velocity profile fig .
[ fig_concentration_profile_omega100 ] shows that this radius @xmath179 corresponds to the transition between rigid motion and shear between the blades .
the volume fraction then increases basically linearly with the radius up to a 40.5% volume fraction at a radius @xmath185 cm which is close to the vane radius .
the volume fraction then increases only slightly ( between 40.5% and 42.5% ) in the gap of the geometry : the heterogeneity is here much less important than in a standard couette geometry . to get further insight into the new strong depletion phenomenon we have evidenced , we have performed 2d magnetic resonance images of the material .
such images provide a qualitative view of the spatial variations of the particle volume fraction as only the liquid phase is imaged .
images are coded in grey scales ; a brighter zone contains less particles . in fig .
[ fig_image_vane_omega100]b , we first see an image of the homogeneous material . before any shear
, as expected , the light intensity is homogeneous in the sample ( intensity variations correspond to noise ) . after a 1h shear at @xmath181 rpm , we observe very bright and thin curves on the , @xmath186 cm ) to the edge of another blade ( at @xmath153 , @xmath186 cm ) , and describes a concave @xmath187 curve whose minimum is @xmath188 cm at @xmath147 .
note that as the volume fraction profile is averaged over a slice which is 1 cm thick in the azimuthal direction ( see fig .
[ fig_image_vane_omega100]b ) , the fact that we measure a minimum of 5% at @xmath188 cm in the slice probably means that the volume fraction minimum is actually equal to zero in the depletion zone .
rpm ( corresponding to a macroscopic strain of order 75000 ) , and ( b ) before any shear . the crosses in fig .
[ fig_image_vane_omega100]a correspond to the limit between rigid motion and shear for the newtonian oil of fig .
[ figure_temporal_profiles]b . the white rectangle in fig .
[ fig_image_vane_omega100]b shows the slice in which the volume fraction profiles of figs .
[ fig_concentration_profile_omega100]a and [ fig_concentration_profile_omega1 ] are measured .
( c ) is a zoom of image ( a ) near the edges of a blade .
the images are taken in the horizontal plane of the geometry , at middle height of the vane tool , and correspond to vertical averages over 2 cm .
the vane tool rotates counterclockwise.,title="fig:",width=453 ] + ( a ) + + rpm ( corresponding to a macroscopic strain of order 75000 ) , and ( b ) before any shear .
the crosses in fig .
[ fig_image_vane_omega100]a correspond to the limit between rigid motion and shear for the newtonian oil of fig .
[ figure_temporal_profiles]b . the white rectangle in fig .
[ fig_image_vane_omega100]b shows the slice in which the volume fraction profiles of figs .
[ fig_concentration_profile_omega100]a and [ fig_concentration_profile_omega1 ] are measured .
( c ) is a zoom of image ( a ) near the edges of a blade .
the images are taken in the horizontal plane of the geometry , at middle height of the vane tool , and correspond to vertical averages over 2 cm .
the vane tool rotates counterclockwise.,title="fig:",width=222 ] rpm ( corresponding to a macroscopic strain of order 75000 ) , and ( b ) before any shear . the crosses in fig .
[ fig_image_vane_omega100]a correspond to the limit between rigid motion and shear for the newtonian oil of fig .
[ figure_temporal_profiles]b . the white rectangle in fig .
[ fig_image_vane_omega100]b shows the slice in which the volume fraction profiles of figs .
[ fig_concentration_profile_omega100]a and [ fig_concentration_profile_omega1 ] are measured .
( c ) is a zoom of image ( a ) near the edges of a blade .
the images are taken in the horizontal plane of the geometry , at middle height of the vane tool , and correspond to vertical averages over 2 cm .
the vane tool rotates counterclockwise.,title="fig:",width=223 ] + ( b)(c ) as pointed out above , this curve also likely marks the transition between the unsheared material ( which rotates as a rigid body ) and the sheared material . note in particular the similarity with fig .
[ figure_temporal_profiles]b , the data of which are reported in fig .
[ fig_image_vane_omega100]a for illustration . a first interpretation of the phenomenon
would then simply be that migration is caused by shear and naturally stops at this transition zone .
indeed , as shear is maximum near the blades , particles tends to migrate out of this zone ; moreover , there is no source of particle flux from the unsheared zone between the blades to balance the migration towards the outer cylinder .
however , this does not explain why the volume fraction drops down to zero : heterogeneities observed at steady - state in the literature are usually moderate and do not lead to zones free of particles .
a better understanding of the phenomenon can be gained by zooming on the previous image ( fig.[fig_image_vane_omega100]c ) .
we now see that while the depletion phenomenon seems symmetric around both sides of the blades at a macroscopic scale , it is clearly asymmetric at a local scale near the blades and depends on the direction of rotation : depletion is more pronounced at the back of the blade ( note that the vane tool rotates counterclockwise ) .
this would mean that the noncolloidal particle trajectories are asymmetric around the blade : a particle that is found at a radius @xmath189 cm just before the blade is necessarily found at a radius slightly higher than 4.02 cm after the blade as there are no particles at @xmath186 cm .
this feature is reminiscent of the fore - aft asymmetry that is observed in the bulk of noncolloidal suspensions [ @xcite ] and that leads to their non - newtonian properties [ @xcite ] .
it thus seems that , in addition to the shear - induced migration mechanism intrinsic to suspensions , the vane tool induces a specific migration mechanism which has its origin in the direct interactions between the particles and the blades ; this effects leads to the full depletion that is observed at the transition between the sheared and the unsheared material .
such direct effect of a flow geometry on migration has also been observed in microchannel flows of colloidal suspensions [ @xcite ] , and also led to full particle depletion .
see also @xcite .
the kinetics of the phenomenon will be briefly discussed below .
the rest of the volume fraction profile results from a complex interplay between shear - induced migration and the fore - aft asymmetry around the blades ; this leads to the rapid increase of the volume fraction between 3.1 cm and 4.02 cm .
after 4.02 cm the flow lines do not meet the blade edges , and the phenomenon evidenced above should have basically no effect on the heterogeneity that develops in the gap of the geometry . on the other hand
, the mean volume fraction should be slightly higher due to mass conservation ; it is indeed observed to be equal to around 42% .
nevertheless , as the mean radial shear rate heterogeneity is basically similar to that observed in a standard couette geometry ( see previous sections ) , we would _ a priori _ expect the heterogeneity to be somehow similar .
however , we observe that the volume fraction profile is only slightly heterogeneous : there is less than 5% variation of the volume fraction in the gap , to be compared to the 15% variation observed in the couette geometry .
clearly , this means that the couette analogy is irrelevant as regards this phenomenon , and that the details of shear matter . here ,
the extensional flow that adds to shear may be at the origin of this diminution of migration .
a more detailed analysis is out of the scope of this paper .
let us now study the behavior at low shear rate .
low shear rates are typically imposed with the aim of measuring the yield stress of such materials .
starting from a homogeneous suspension at rest , we apply a rotational velocity @xmath175 rpm ( without any preshear ) , and we measure the evolution of the particle volume fraction in time .
the corresponding volume fraction profiles are depicted in fig .
[ fig_concentration_profile_omega1 ] .
rpm measured in the vane - in - cup geometry after different times of shear : 5min , 1h , 14h . the material is homogeneous at the beginning of shear .
the inset presents the @xmath0-averaged azimuthal velocity profile @xmath59 measured in the first stages of shear ; the dotted line is the theoretical rigid motion induced by the rotation of the vane tool ; the vertical dashed line shows the radius of the vane.,width=340 ] in fig .
[ fig_concentration_profile_omega1 ] , we observe that , although shear is much less important than in the previous experiments , particle depletion also appears between the blades .
comparison of the velocity profile and the volume fraction profile shows that depletion also appears between the blades at the transition zone between the sheared and the unsheared materials .
this phenomenon appears with a very fast kinetics : the lower volume fraction value in the measurement zone is 36% after only a 5 minute shear ( corresponding to a macroscopic strain of order 50 ) .
afterwards , it continues evolving slowly : the minimum observed volume fraction is of order 33% after a 1h shear and of order 32% after a 14h shear ( corresponding to a 10000 macroscopic strain ) .
note that the radial position of the minimum value of the volume fraction slightly decreases in time ; it likely corresponds to progressive erosion of the material between the blades ( we did not measure the velocity profiles to check this hypothesis ) .
we also note that migration is negligible in the rest of the sheared material as expected from the theory of migration briefly described above ( a larger strain would be needed to observe significant migration ) . nevertheless , we note some particle accumulation ( with a volume fraction value of 43% ) at @xmath169=4.7 cm after a very long time .
this corresponds to the yield surface as flow is localized at low velocity ( see velocity profile fig .
[ fig_concentration_profile_omega1 ] ) .
migration profiles usually result from an equilibrium between various sources of fluxes . on the other hand
, the unsheared material does not produce any particle flux while it receives particles from the sheared region .
this particle accumulation is thus the signature that the migration phenomenon is indeed active , although not observable on the profile measured in the sheared zone .
it is probable that this accumulation process would stop only ( after a very long time ) when there are no more particles in the sheared region .
( b ) is a zoom of image ( a ) between two adjacent blades .
the image is taken in the horizontal plane of the geometry , at middle height of the vane tool , and corresponds to a vertical average over 2 cm .
the vane tool rotates counterclockwise.,title="fig:",width=298 ] + ( a)(b ) as above , 2d magnetic resonance images of the material provide an insight in the phenomenon . in fig .
[ fig_image_vane_omega1 ] , we observe again that particle depletion is enhanced at the rear of the blades ; this confirms that this phenomenon is likely due to direct interactions between the blades and the particles , leading to the asymmetry of the particles trajectory around the blades .
this _ a priori _ occurs with any particle whose trajectory is close to the blades , explaining why particle depletion appears so rapidly .
there is probably no way to avoid it .
note that the images are here much brighter very close to the blades than midway between two adjacent blades ; this would mean that the particle volume fraction is probably close to @xmath190 near the blades , although we observe volume fraction of order 32% between two blades .
+ finally , let us note that the bright line provides a good idea of the boundary between the sheared material and the material that moves as a rigid body .
we see as in sec .
[ section_results][section_emulsion ] that this is far from being cylindrical even at this low velocity .
we finally present some consequences of this phenomenon . from the above observations ,
our conclusion is that depletion sets up quickly and is probably unavoidable .
then two situations have to be distinguished .
if linear viscoelastic properties of a suspension of large particles are measured at rest on the homogeneous material in its solid regime , without any preshear , then these measurements pose no other problem than that of the relevant couette analogy to be used ( see sec . [ section_results][section_oil ] ) .
if a yield stress measurement is performed at low imposed rotational velocity , starting from the homogeneous material at rest , then this measurement is likely valid as long as only the peak value or the plateau value at low strain ( of order 1 ) is recorded . on the other hand , any subsequent analysis of the material behavior will _ a priori _ be misleading : irreversible changes have occurred and the material can not be studied anymore . more generally , any measurement performed after a preshear will be incorrect and any flow curve measurement will lead to wrong evaluation of the material properties . in these last cases , the consequence of the new particle depletion phenomenon we have evidenced is a kind of wall slip near the blades , whereas there are no walls . here
the `` slip layer '' is made of the ( pure ) interstitial yield stress fluid in a zone close to the blades , as would be observed near a smooth inner cylinder .
this contrasts with the common belief that the vane tool prevents slippage . in order to illustrate this feature , we present some results of @xcite : mahaut _ et al .
_ performed classical upward / downward shear rate sweeps with a six - bladed vane - in - cup geometry ( @xmath191 cm , @xmath192 cm , @xmath304.5 cm , blade thickness=0.8 mm ) in a pure concentrated emulsion , and in the same emulsion filled with 20% of 140 @xmath17 m ps beads . in these experiments ,
constant macroscopic shear rates steps increasing from 0.01 to 10 s@xmath167 and then decreasing from 10 to 0.01 s@xmath167 were applied during 30s , and the stationary shear stress was measured for each shear rate value .
the results are shown in fig .
[ fig_sweep_suspension ] .
m ps beads ( filled / open circles ) . figure from @xcite.,width=302 ] while the same curve is observed for the upward / downward shear rate sweeps in the case of the pure emulsion ( as expected for a simple non - thixotropic yield stress fluid ) , the shear stress during the upward shear rate sweep differs from the shear stress during the downward shear rate sweep in the case of the suspension .
moreover , any measurement performed on the suspension after this experiment gives a static yield stress equal to the dynamic yield stress observed during the downward sweep .
this means that there has been some irreversible change .
this irreversible change is actually the particle depletion near the blades we have observed in this paper . as the flow of the suspension is localized near the inner tool at low shear rate , it means that after the first upward sweep that has induced the particle depletion , during the downward shear rate sweep only the pure emulsion created by migration near the blades remains in the sheared layer at sufficiently low rotational velocity .
this explains why the same apparent value of the yield stress is found in the suspension during the downward sweep as in the pure emulsion with this experiment . on the other hand ,
the yield stress at the beginning of the very first upward sweep is that of the suspension as migration has not occurred yet .
the conclusion is that the vane tool is probably not suitable to the study of flows of suspensions of large particles .
as a conclusion , let us summarize our main findings : * in the case of newtonian fluid flows , our measurements support the couette equivalence approach : the @xmath0-averaged strain rate component @xmath1 decreases as the inverse squared radius in the gap .
interestingly , the velocity profiles allow determining the couette equivalent radius without end - effect correction and independently of the viscosity of the material . the torque exerted by the vane in our display
is found to be higher ( by 8% ) than the theoretical prediction of @xcite for a vane embedded in an infinite medium , and is thus much closer to the torque exerted by a couette geometry of same radius as the vane than expected from the literature .
a key observation may be that there is a significant flow between the blades which adds an important extensional component to shear , thus increasing dissipation . from a short review of the literature
, it clearly appears that numerical investigations are still needed in the case of finite geometries .
variational approaches are also promising , although they do not yet provide tight bounds .
* in the case of yield stress fluid flows , we find that the thin layer of material which flows around the vane tool at low velocity is not cylindrical , in contrast with what is usually supposed in the literature from simulation results .
consequently , a non negligible extensional component of shear has probably to be taken into account in the analysis . at this stage , there are too few experimental and simulation data to understand the origin of this discrepancy .
it thus seems that progress still has to be made , in particular through simulations , which allow a wide range of parameters to be studied .
this may help understanding how the torque is linked to the yield stress of a material at low velocity , depending in particular on the geometry . *
an important and surprising result is the observation of particle depletion near the blades when the yield stress fluid contains noncolloidal particles .
this phenomenon is thus likely to occur when studying polydisperse pastes like coal slurries , mortars and fresh concrete .
it has to be noted that the phenomenon is very rapid , irreversible , and thus probably unavoidable when studying flows of suspensions of large particles .
it results in the creation of a pure interstitial yield stress fluid layer and thus in a kind of wall slip near the blades .
it contrasts with the classical assumption that is made in the field of concentrated suspension rheology where the vane tool is mainly used to avoid this phenomenon .
consequently , we would say that , in the case of pasty materials with large particles , if accurate measurements are needed , the vane tool may finally be suitable only for the study of the solid ( elastic ) properties of materials and for the static yield stress measurements ; as the yield stress measurement may induce irreversible particle depletion near the blades , any new measurement then requires a new sample preparation .
furthermore , the vane can be used as a very accurate tool without any hypothesis nor any calibration to measure the relative increase of the elastic modulus of materials as a function of their composition [ @xcite ] . in order to study accurately the flows of pasty materials with large particles
, our results suggest that a coaxial cylinders geometry with properly roughened surfaces is preferable when possible
. if the use of a vane tool can not be avoided , one should keep in mind our observations in order to carefully interpret any result .
99 abbott , j. r. , n. tetlow , a. l. graham , s. a. altobelli , e. fukushima , l. a. mondy , and t. s. stephens , `` experimental observations of particle migration in concentrated suspensions : couette flow , '' j. rheol .
* 35 * , 773 - 795 ( 1991 ) .
at - kadi , a. , p. marchal , l. choplin , a .-
chrissemant , and m.bousmina , `` quantitative analysis of mixer - type rheometers using the couette analogy , '' the canadian journal of chemical engineering * 80 * , 1166 - 1174 ( 2002 ) .
atkinson , c. , and j. d. sherwood , `` the torque on a rotating n - bladed vane in a newtonian fluid or linear elastic medium , '' proceedings of the royal society of london series a - mathematical physical and engineering sciences * 438 * , 183 - 196 ( 1992 ) .
corbett , a. m. , r. j. phillips , r. j. kauten , and k. l. mccarthy , `` magnetic resonance imaging of concentration and velocity profiles of pure fluids and solid suspensions in rotating geometries , '' j. rheol . * 39 * , 907 - 924 ( 1995 ) .
hanlon , a. d. , s. j. gibbs , l. d. hall , d. e. haycock , w. j. frith , s. ablett , and c. marriott , `` a concentric cylinder couette flow system for use in magnetic resonance imaging experiments , '' measurement science and technology * 9 * , 631 - 637 ( 1998 ) .
huang , p. y. , and d. d. joseph , `` effects of shear thinning on migration of neutrally buoyant particles in pressure driven flow of newtonian and viscoelastic fluids , '' j. non - newtonian fluid mech .
* 90 * , 159 - 185 ( 2000 ) .
jau , w .- c . , and c .- t .
yang , `` development of a modified concrete rheometer to measure the rheological behavior of fresh concrete , '' cement and concrete composites ( 2010 ) , in press doi:10.1016/j.cemconcomp.2010.01.001 mahaut , f. , s. mokddem , x. chateau , n. roussel , and g. ovarlez , `` effect of coarse particle volume fraction on the yield stress and thixotropy of cementitious materials , '' cem
. concr . res . *
38 * , 1276 - 1285 ( 2008 ) .
ovarlez , g. , f. bertrand , and s. rodts , `` local determination of the constitutive law of a dense suspension of noncolloidal particles through magnetic resonance imaging , '' j. rheol . * 50 * , 259 - 292 ( 2006 ) .
ovarlez , g. , s. rodts , a. ragouilliaux , p. coussot , j. goyon , and a. colin , `` wide - gap couette flows of dense emulsions : local concentration measurements , and comparison between macroscopic and local constitutive law measurements through magnetic resonance imaging , '' phys .
e * 78 * , 036307 ( 2008 ) .
phillips , r. j. , r. c. armstrong , r. a. brown , a. l. graham , and j. r. abbott , `` a constitutive equation for concentrated suspensions that accounts for shear - induced particle migration , '' phys .
fluids * 4 * , 30 - 40 ( 1992 ) .
raynaud , j. s. , p. moucheront , j. c. baudez , f. bertrand , j. p. guilbaud , and p. coussot , `` direct determination by nmr of the thixotropic and yielding behavior of suspensions , '' j. rheol . * 46 * , 709 - 732 ( 2002 ) .
rodts , s. , f. bertrand , s. jarny , p. poullain , and p. moucheront , `` dveloppements rcents dans lapplication de lirm la rhologie et la mcanique des fluides , '' comptes rendus chimie * 7 * , 275 - 282 ( 2004 ) .
shapley , n. c. , r. a. brown , and r. c. armstrong , `` evaluation of particle migration models based on laser doppler velocimetry measurements in concentrated suspensions , '' j. rheol .
* 48 * , 255 - 279 ( 2004 )
. zhu , h. , n. s. martys , c. ferraris , and d. de kee , `` a numerical study of the flow of bingham - like fluids in two - dimensional vane and cylinder rheometers using a smoothed particle hydrodynamics ( sph ) based method , '' j. non - newtonian fluid mech .
* 165 * , 362 - 375 ( 2010 ) . | we study the local flow properties of various materials in a vane - in - cup geometry .
we use mri techniques to measure velocities and particle concentrations in flowing newtonian fluid , yield stress fluid , and in a concentrated suspension of noncolloidal particles in a yield stress fluid . in the newtonian fluid
, we observe that the @xmath0-averaged strain rate component @xmath1 decreases as the inverse squared radius in the gap , in agreement with a couette analogy .
this allows direct comparison ( without end - effect corrections ) of the resistances to shear in vane and couette geometries . here
, the mean shear stress in the vane - in - cup geometry is slightly lower than in a couette cell of same dimensions , and a little higher than when the vane is embedded in an infinite medium .
we also observe that the flow enters deeply the region between the blades , leading to significant extensional flow . in the yield stress fluid , in contrast with the usually accepted picture based on simulation results from the literature , we find that the layer of material that is sheared near the blades at low velocity is not cylindrical . there is thus a significant extensional component of shear that should be taken into account in the analysis . finally and surprisingly , in the suspension
, we observe that a thin non - cylindrical slip layer made of the pure interstitial yield stress fluid appears quickly at the interface between the sheared material and the material that moves as a rigid body between the blades . this feature can be attributed to the non - symmetric trajectories of the noncolloidal particles around the edges of the blades .
this new important observation is in sharp contradiction with the common belief that the vane tool prevents slippage , and may preclude the use of the vane tool for studying the flows of pasty materials with large particles . |
currently a number of intense mid - infrared light sources are being developed @xcite , spurred on by their uses in sub - attosecond pulse generation @xcite , strong - field holography @xcite and laser - induced electron diffraction @xcite .
the low frequency and high intensity of these new sources mean that the tunneling picture is an appropriate framework for describing how these light sources interact with atoms and molecules . in this work we deal with the process of dissociative tunneling ionization in molecules , where a static electric field tunnel ionizes an electron , after which the nuclei dissociate . to our knowledge
this is the first work on the theory of dissociative tunneling ionization . in the theory
we treat the nuclear and electronic degrees freedom on an equal footing and fully quantum mechanically .
the reflection principle @xcite is often used to describe the process of dissociative ionization .
this principle can be applied within the framework of the born - oppenheimer ( bo ) approximation to relate the nuclear kinetic energy release ( ker ) spectrum to the nuclear wave function .
it was formulated as early as 1928 @xcite , and later put on a more rigorous foundation @xcite ( see also references therein for a list of early uses ) . in time - dependent cases where the time - scale of the electric field is shorter than that of nuclear motion
, one assumes that the electrons make an instantaneous frank - condon transition to a dissociative electronic state .
the probability distribution in the new electronic state is then the absolute value squared of the initial nuclear wave function times some dipole coupling factor . in case
this dipole coupling factor is almost constant , the wave packet that enters the dissociative state is practically identical to the initial nuclear wave function .
classical energy conservation then dictates that the nuclear ker spectrum can be obtained by reflecting the nuclear wave function in the dissociative potential curve .
this is the regime considered mostly in the literature . in the time - independent tunneling case , the electronic ionization rate takes the same role as the dipole coupling factor in the time - dependent case , that is , it multiplies the nuclear wave function before it enters the continuum .
however , this electronic rate has an exponential dependence on the internuclear coordinate and can by no means be considered constant ( as was also pointed out in ref .
it is therefore essential to consider the effect of this additional factor on the ker spectrum ; the spectrum can not be found simply by reflection of the nuclear wave function .
imaging of the nuclear wave function is made possible through the reflection principle , by applying it in reverse on a measured ker spectrum @xcite .
this is often referred to as coulomb explosion imaging . in the tunneling case the exponential dependence of the electronic rate on the internuclear
coordinate means that the product of the electronic rate and the nuclear wave function is essentially different from the bare nuclear wave function , and the electronic rate therefore needs to be included to image the nuclear wave function based on the ker spectrum . in ref . @xcite it was demonstrated that the bo approximation breaks down for weak fields . in this case
the weak - field asymptotic theory ( wfat ) @xcite provides us with accurate results for the ker spectrum .
the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ sec : theory ] the theory for dissociative tunneling ionization of homonuclear molecules is outlined .
we derive an exact expression for the ker spectrum and a corresponding expression in the bo approximation .
section [ sec:1d - calculation ] exemplifies the theory with numerical reduced dimensionality calculations .
numerically exact ker spectra are compared to ker spectra obtained in the bo approximation using the reflection principle .
imaging of the nuclear part of the wave function from the ker spectrum is demonstrated .
section [ sec : conclusion - outlook ] concludes the paper .
atomic units @xmath0 are used throughout .
we consider a three - body system consisting of two heavy nuclei with masses @xmath1 and charges @xmath2 , and one electron with mass @xmath3 and charge @xmath4 . in the center - of - mass frame
these have coordinates @xmath5 and @xmath6 fulfilling @xmath7 .
let us introduce the reduced masses @xmath8 effective charge @xmath9 and jacobi coordinates @xmath10 we assume that the orientation of the internuclear axis @xmath11 is fixed in space .
we also assume that the field is directed along the @xmath12-direction , @xmath13 and choose to consider @xmath14 for definiteness . due to the azimuthal symmetry of the molecule only the polar angle @xmath15 between @xmath11 and @xmath16 matters .
this @xmath15 angle takes the role as an external parameter , and we omit explicit reference to it in the following . with these assumptions
we can write the time - independent schrdinger equation ( se ) within the single - active - electron approximation as @xmath17 \psi({\mathbf{r}},r ) & = 0,\label{eq : schrodinger}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the effective @xmath18 potential describes how the nuclei interact with each other and the effective @xmath19 potential describes how the electron interacts with the nuclei . for a system with several electrons
the @xmath18 potential represents the bo potential of the system without the active electron . in this work
, we assume that @xmath18 is monotonically decreasing , i.e. , it corresponds to a purely dissociative bo curve .
we assume that the nuclei can not pass through each other .
this gives the boundary condition @xmath20 and we consider eq .
( [ eq : schrodinger ] ) in the interval @xmath21 .
we also impose outgoing - wave boundary conditions in the electronic coordinate @xmath22 , the exact form of these will be specified below . with these boundary conditions
the wave function we seek as a solution of eq .
( [ eq : schrodinger ] ) is a siegert state @xcite , with a complex energy @xmath23 , where @xmath24 is the ionization rate , and it is normalized by @xmath25 the outgoing - wave boundary condition in the electronic coordinate means that the solution we seek to eq .
( [ eq : schrodinger ] ) describes tunneling of the electron .
this tunneling is followed by dissociation of the nuclei for the considered class of strictly dissociative potentials @xmath18 . in the following
we will describe the energy distribution of the dissociated nuclei .
our aim is to describe the energy distribution of the nuclei , i.e. , the ker spectrum , after the molecule is ionized by tunneling of the electron . to this end
we need to consider the problem in the @xmath26 limit , where the electron is far away from the nuclei . in this limit
we assume that the electron - nuclear interaction potential takes the form @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the total charge of the remaining core system .
this assumption makes our problem separable in electron and nuclear coordinates in this asymptotic region . by seeking the partial solutions in the form @xmath29 , eq .
( [ eq : schrodinger ] ) can be written as the separated equations @xmath30 f({\mathbf{r}},k ) & = 0,\label{eq : as_x_eq}\\ \left[- \frac{1}{2 m } { \frac { d^2 } { d { r } ^2 } } + { u}(r ) - e_{r}\right ] g(r , k ) & = 0,\label{eq : as_r_eq } \end{aligned}\ ] ] with separation constants given by @xmath31 where we assume @xmath32 and @xmath33 is the wave number for the state @xmath34 .
equation ( [ eq : zero_bc ] ) amounts to @xmath35 we choose the continuum solutions of eq .
( [ eq : as_r_eq ] ) to be real and normalized by @xmath36 the conditions eqs .
( [ eq : zero_bc_g])-([eq : g_norm ] ) completely specify the nuclear problem eq .
( [ eq : as_r_eq ] ) . the electronic problem eq .
( [ eq : as_x_eq ] ) has a potential consisting of a coulomb term and a linear field term .
this problem is separable in parabolic coordinates @xcite , which we will therefore use .
first we introduce mass - scaled quantities @xmath37 then the following form of the parabolic coordinates is introduced ( as in ref .
@xcite ) [ eq : parab_coord ] @xmath38 with this choice of coordinates a potential barrier forms in the @xmath39 coordinates and therefore @xmath39 takes the role as the tunneling coordinate. in the asymptotic region @xmath40 eq . ( [ eq : as_x_eq ] ) has a solution that is a linear combination of partial solutions of the form @xcite @xmath41 where the outgoing - wave @xmath42 is given by @xmath43\right),\label{eq : f_eta}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath44 is the ionization channel function defined by @xmath45 \phi_\nu(\xi,\varphi ) & = \beta_\nu \phi_\nu(\xi,\varphi),\label{eq : xi_phi_ad_eq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath46 is a set of parabolic quantum numbers labeling the different ionization channels , see fig .
[ fig : parab_coord ] . with our choice of @xmath14
the potential in eq .
( [ eq : xi_phi_ad_eq ] ) goes to infinity as @xmath47 goes to infinity , so the parabolic channels @xmath48 are purely discrete . .
the gray paraboloid is the same for a smaller value of @xmath39 .
the electron is ionized in the negative @xmath12 direction due to its negative charge , given that the electric field points in the positive @xmath12-direction .
the @xmath44 states [ eq .
( [ eq : xi_phi_ad_eq ] ) ] live in the constant @xmath39 paraboloids . the colors in the blue / red surface illustrates an example of the nodal structure of such a @xmath44 state .
the curvature of the paraboloids means that the @xmath44 states are bound .
this means that @xmath39 is the only coordinate where we have to consider the wave function at infinity , i.e. , @xmath39 is the tunneling coordinate . for large @xmath39
the polar angle @xmath15 , which specifies the orientation of the molecule , does not matter for the asymptotic form of the wave function in parabolic coordinates , though it matters for the size of the coefficients [ eq . ( [ eq : spectrum_ampl_def ] ) ] . ]
the full wave function can be expressed as a linear combination , discrete in @xmath48 , continuous in @xmath49 , of the @xmath50 products , @xmath51 where the asymptotic expansion coefficient @xmath52 can be calculated by @xmath53 @xmath54 indicates integration w.r.t . the coordinates @xmath47 and @xmath55 over their full range .
note that the polar angle @xmath15 , which we suppressed in the notation , only enters eq .
( [ eq : spectrum_ampl_def ] ) through the wave function @xmath56 . the ker dissociation spectrum into the channel @xmath48 is defined in terms of these expansion coefficients by @xmath57 this is the main observable of interest .
by inserting eq .
( [ eq : f_eta ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : spectrum_ampl_def ] ) and assuming @xmath58 to be real , which is approximately the case for small @xmath59 , we obtain @xmath60 the exact ker spectrum in the channel @xmath48 can thus be obtained by projecting the wave function on the channel state @xmath44 , and further projecting this on the continuum states @xmath34 of the @xmath18 potential .
the total ker spectrum can then be obtained by summing over all the channels @xmath61 in the @xmath62 limit the total rate can be obtained by @xmath63 now that we have a recipe for finding the exact ker spectrum , we consider some approximations for ease of predictions and gain in physical insight .
we first consider the bo approximation , which appears in the limit @xmath64 . in this limit @xmath65 , and
the wave function takes the form @xmath66 .
the electronic and nuclear part of bo wave function fulfills the bo equations @xmath67 \psi_e({\mathbf{r}};r ) & = 0,\label{eq : bo_elec_eq}\\ \left[- \frac{1}{2 m } { \frac { d^2 } { d { r } ^2 } } + u(r)+e_e(r;f ) - e_{\text{bo}}(f)\right ] \chi(r ) & = 0.\label{eq : bo_nuc_eq } \end{aligned}\ ] ] we impose zero boundary condition for the nuclear wave function @xmath68 and the following normalizations @xmath69 in the asymptotic limit @xmath40 the electronic eq .
( [ eq : bo_elec_eq ] ) takes the same form as eq .
( [ eq : as_x_eq ] ) , and it can be written in parabolic coordinates in the same manner .
the electronic wave function then takes the outgoing - wave form @xmath70 where @xmath42 is from eq .
( [ eq : f_eta ] ) and @xmath44 are solutions of eq .
( [ eq : xi_phi_ad_eq ] ) , with @xmath58 replaced by @xmath71 in both .
the asymptotic coefficient @xmath72 defines the ionization amplitude in channel @xmath48 @xcite .
the partial electronic ionization rate is given by @xmath73 by considering the flux of the electron probability through a surface at large negative @xmath12 , one can show that in the weak field limit the total electronic rate @xmath74 is given as a sum over @xmath48 of all the partial electronic rates . by inserting the bo wave function into eq .
( [ eq : spec_expr ] ) we obtain @xmath75 the separation of electronic and nuclear coordinates in the bo approximation means that this expression for the ker spectrum does not contain any explicit reference to electronic coordinates , as opposed to the expression for the exact spectrum eq .
( [ eq : spec_expr ] ) .
equation ( [ eq : spec_bo ] ) is similar to a result previously put forward in the literature [ eq .
( 1 ) of ref .
@xcite ] , except that the correct complex ionization amplitude @xmath72 was taken as @xmath76 . in the cases
we have considered , the phase variations of @xmath72 are sufficiently small that they can be safely neglected , explaining the successful use of the aforementioned replacement in ref .
@xcite , but this is not generally true . to evaluate the integral in eq .
( [ eq : spec_bo ] ) we will use the reflection principle @xcite . at the heart of the reflection principle
lies an important mathematical component which we denote the reflection approximation @xcite .
this approximation amounts to setting @xmath77 which is exact in the @xmath78 limit . in eq .
( [ eq : g_as_delt ] ) @xmath79 is the classical turning point potentials , so there is only one classical turning point . ] for the @xmath34 function defined by @xmath80 in order to determine the derivative @xmath81 the form of the dissociative @xmath18 potential must be known . inserting eq .
( [ eq : g_as_delt ] ) in eq .
( [ eq : spec_bo ] ) yields @xmath82 this result shows that using the reflection approximation in conjunction with the bo approximation we obtain a ker spectrum that is expressed as a product of a jacobian factor , the electronic rate and the field - dressed nuclear wave function [ eq . ( [ eq : bo_nuc_eq ] ) ] . this is a lot simpler to calculate than evaluating either integrals in eqs .
( [ eq : spec_expr ] ) or ( [ eq : spec_bo ] ) , and is easily reversed to give a way to image the field - dressed nuclear wave function , and it is applicable to any molecule with a dissociative bo curve . the exact electronic rate @xmath83 is often not available , since finding it requires solving the electronic problem eq .
( [ eq : bo_elec_eq ] ) , which is a highly non - trivial task for many systems . in such cases the weak - field asymptotic theory ( wfat ) @xcite can be employed to obtain the rate .
wfat is an analytic theory which expresses the ionization rate in terms of properties of the field - free state .
it is applicable in the weak - field limit .
let @xmath84 and @xmath85 denote the adiabatic eigenvalues and eigenfunctions solving eq .
( [ eq : xi_phi_ad_eq ] ) for @xmath86 with the field - free electronic energy @xmath87 replacing @xmath58 . ref .
@xcite provides analytic expressions for these quantities . in terms of these the asymptotic field - free electronic wave function can be written @xmath88 where @xmath89 the electronic wfat rate is then given by @xcite @xmath90 where the field factor @xmath91 is defined by @xmath92 and the asymptotic coefficients @xmath93 can be found from the electronic wave function by inversion of eq .
( [ eq : field_free_elec_wf ] ) @xmath94 wfat can also be applied for the exact state , and not just in the bo approximation as above . in this section
we will give the pertaining formulas .
let , as before , @xmath95 and @xmath96 denote the adiabatic eigenvalues and eigenfunctions solving eq .
( [ eq : xi_phi_ad_eq ] ) for @xmath86 now with the field - free energy @xmath97 . in terms of these the asymptotic field - free wave function can be written @xcite @xmath98 where @xmath99 the wfat @xcite yields the following expression for the ker spectrum @xmath100 where the field factor @xmath101 is given by @xmath102 and the field - free asymptotic coefficients @xmath103 can be found by inversion of eq .
( [ eq : field_free_wf ] ) @xmath104
solving eq . ( [ eq : schrodinger ] ) in 3d is a computationally heavy task , so we have used a 1d model to illustrate our central points . in this section
we compare exactly calculated ker spectra with those obtained through the bo approximation , eq .
( [ eq : spec_result_bo ] ) , and the wfat , eq .
( [ eq : spec_wfat ] ) , within this 1d model . in the following
we will consider a model of h@xmath105 as an example .
the potentials we consider are thus @xmath106 with @xmath107 and @xmath108 .
the interaction between the nuclei and the electrons @xmath109 is described by a soft - core coulomb potential .
the function @xmath110 is chosen in such a way that the bo potential of this potential reproduces the bo potential energy curve of 3d h@xmath105 @xcite .
we use the method described in ref .
@xcite to solve the 1d equivalent of eq .
( [ eq : schrodinger ] ) given by @xmath111 \psi(z , r ) & = 0.\label{eq : schrodinger_1d}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the 1d model the index @xmath48 , which describes what happens in the paraboloids of constant @xmath39 transversal to @xmath12 , is of no meaning , and it hence does not appear in any of the 1d equivalents of the 3d equations .
the 1d equivalent of the exact ker spectrum eq .
( [ eq : spec_expr ] ) is @xmath112 equations ( [ eq : spec_bo ] ) and ( [ eq : spec_result_bo ] ) apply to the 1d case with appropriately redefined quantities . the wfat expressions eqs .
( [ eq : rate_wfat_elec ] ) , ( [ eq : field_factor_elec ] ) and ( [ eq : spec_wfat ] ) , ( [ eq : full_field_factor ] ) are the same as in the 1d case , but the asymptotic coefficients are now found from @xmath113 and @xmath114 in eq .
( [ eq:1d_asymp_coeff ] ) , @xmath115 denotes the field - free 1d electronic bo wave function .
( light blue shaded area in the lower @xmath116 bo curve ) is multiplied by the electronic rate @xmath117 ( dashed purple line ) and reflected in the dissociative @xmath18 bo curve to give a ker spectrum ( solid blue line in upper right corner , [ eq . ( [ eq : spec_result_bo ] ) ] ) , using the relation @xmath118 to translate @xmath49 into @xmath119 .
this is compared to the exact ker spectrum @xmath120 ( red dashed line , [ eq . ( [ eq : spec_expr_1d ] ) ] ) . a field strength of @xmath121 was used for this calculation .
the solid gray line in the lower part of the figure shows the field - free nuclear wave function @xmath122 . the surface plot in the upper part of the figure shows the continuum states @xmath34 of the @xmath18 potential , these are solutions of eq .
( [ eq : as_r_eq ] ) . ]
figure [ fig : spec_1d_ground ] illustrates how the bo approximation can be used in conjunction with the reflection principle to determine the ker spectrum .
the figure shows a calculation for the ground state of the h@xmath105 model at @xmath121 .
the field dressed nuclear wave function @xmath123 is multiplied by the electronic rate @xmath117 .
the exponential dependence of the electronic rate @xmath117 on the internuclear coordinate means that the product @xmath124 ( see [ eq . ( [ eq : spec_result_bo ] ) ] ) has its maximum at a value of @xmath125 , which is significantly different from the maximum of the bare nuclear wave function at @xmath126 .
this in turn means that the transition to the continuum which is determined by the product @xmath124 and not the bare nuclear wave function is far from vertical in @xmath119 with respect to the initial nuclear wave function , and the spectrum peaks at a lower energy around @xmath127 and not at @xmath128 . using wfat within the bo approximation
we can make a statement about in which direction the maximum of the spectrum shifts when the field is varied . in these approximations
the main dependence of the electronic rate on the field is contained in the exponent @xmath129 , see eq .
( [ eq : field_factor_elec ] ) .
the electronic energy @xmath87 , in terms of which @xmath130 is defined , generally depends very much on the system considered . in the case of h@xmath105
it is a monotonically increasing function of @xmath119 , since when the two potential wells around each of the nuclei start to overlap the electron is more tightly bound .
this in turn means that the electronic rate is an increasing function of @xmath119 , as can also be seen in fig .
[ fig : spec_1d_ground ] .
when the strength of the field increases the exponent @xmath129 grows , but at the same time the slope of this exponent with respect to @xmath119 decreases , since @xmath131 is multiplied by a smaller number .
the smaller slope means that the location of the maximum of the product @xmath124 is shifted less from the maximum of @xmath123 as the field strength increases , and conversely , as the field strength is decreased the maximum of the product @xmath124 is shifted more towards larger @xmath119 .
these shifts are directly reflected in the spectrum , which is given as the reflection of the @xmath124 product in the bo and reflection approximations .
figure [ fig : spec_1d ] shows ker spectra obtained using as initial state the first vibrationally exited state of h@xmath105 .
we have chosen to show these results as they are for the lowest state with a non - trivial nodal structure in @xmath119 . in the figure two
different field strengths are considered . in the top panel
we see that the nodal structure of the nuclear wave function is reflected in the ker spectrum , although one peak is a lot larger than the other .
this asymmetry can be understood in the bo approximation , see eq .
( [ eq : spec_result_bo ] ) , as due to the fact that the electronic rate @xmath117 has an exponential dependence on @xmath119 . in the wfat
it can be understood as resulting from the exponential dependence of the field factor [ eq . ( [ eq : full_field_factor ] ) ] on @xmath49 . for the lower field strength the structures at @xmath132 are not visible as the ker spectrum falls below the numerical precision limit of our calculation .
( [ eq : spec_expr_1d ] ) ] . dashed dotted ( blue ) line :
bo combined with reflection principle [ eq .
( [ eq : spec_result_bo ] ) ] .
short dashed ( green ) line : wfat [ 1d equivalent of eq .
( [ eq : spec_wfat ] ) ] .
the insets show the normalized ker spectra on a linear scale .
the critical field for use of bo [ eq .
( [ eq : f_bo ] ) ] is for h@xmath105 : @xmath133 .
( a ) @xmath134 and @xmath135 .
( b ) @xmath136 and @xmath137 . ] for the large field strength [ fig .
[ fig : spec_1d](a ) ] we see that the bo ker spectrum has a shape much closer to the exact ker spectrum than for the lower field strength .
also the maximum value of the bo ker spectrum is more than an order of magnitude closer to the maximum value of the exact ker spectrum for the larger field strength .
this can be understood on the basis of the retardation argument provided in ref .
@xcite : the bo approximation is expected to hold as long as the electron is close enough to the nuclei that the time it takes for the electron to go to its present location from the nuclei is shorter than the time it takes for the nuclei to move .
a typical electron velocity can be estimated as @xmath138 , where @xmath139 is the equilibrium internuclear distance , which for h@xmath105 is @xmath140 .
a typical time scale for the nuclear motion can be estimated as @xmath141 , where @xmath142 is obtained by expanding the bo potential around @xmath139 to second order @xmath143 . using these estimates ref .
@xcite defines a critical distance @xmath144 such that for @xmath145 we expect bo to work well , while for @xmath146 we expect it to break down .
since the magnitude of the wave function is essentially unchanged after the tunneling , the bo approximation is expected to work well when the outer turning point is within this @xmath147 distance , so a critical field @xmath148 can be estimated , such that the bo approximation is expected to give good results for larger fields , but fail for smaller fields .
the two field strengths of fig .
[ fig : spec_1d ] lies on either side of this critical field , which for the system under consideration is @xmath133 .
as we increase the field strength further the bo gives even better results .
for the lower field strength where bo fails we can apply the wfat , see sec .
[ sec : full_wfat ] . in fig .
[ fig : spec_1d ] we see that the shape of the wfat ker spectrum indeed is closer to the exact ker spectrum than the bo ker spectrum for the weaker field strength , and it is also closer in magnitude to the maximum value . for the larger field strength
the wfat ker spectrum is further from the exact ker spectrum in both shape and magnitude .
( upper right corner , [ eq . ( [ eq : spec_expr_1d ] ) ] ) at @xmath121 the magnitude of the asymptotic wave function has been found by reversing the reflection principle , giving @xmath149 , using the relation @xmath118 to translate @xmath49 into @xmath119 . from this
, the field - dressed nuclear wave function has been imaged by dividing with the electronic rate @xmath117 and normalizing . in the lowest part of the plot
, the short dashed ( purple ) line shows this imaging using the exact electronic rate @xmath74 , the long dashed ( red ) line shows it using the bo wfat approximation @xmath150 [ eq .
( [ eq : rate_wfat_elec ] ) ] .
the solid gray line shows the field - free nuclear wave function @xmath122 .
the shaded ( light blue ) area shows the field - dressed nuclear wave function @xmath123 .
the surface plot in the upper part of the figure shows the continuum states @xmath34 . ]
the field dressed nuclear wave function can be imaged from a measurement of the ker spectrum by inverting eq .
( [ eq : spec_result_bo ] ) for fields sufficiently large that the bo approximation applies . to demonstrate this
we have taken the exact ker spectrum from our calculation at @xmath121 for the first vibrationally exited state and divided it by the jacobian factor and the electronic rate to obtain an image of the nuclear density . since an experimental ker spectrum is typically not known on an absolute scale ,
we have then normalized this quantity . in a calculation on a more complicated system
than the one considered here the exact electronic rate is often not available , so we also show the result using the wfat approximation for the electronic rate [ eq .
( [ eq : rate_wfat_elec ] ) ] .
the results are compared to the nuclear wave function known from the calculation in our model in fig .
[ fig : reconstructed_chi ] .
they do not agree perfectly , but the nodal structure is correctly reproduced . for smaller field strengths
where the bo is not applicable this type of imaging is not possible .
the ker spectrum , however , does give us access to the asymptotic wave function , as it is the norm square of the expansion coefficients of this , see eq .
( [ eq : wf_expansion ] ) . for the cases we have looked at
, the phase of the asymptotic coefficient @xmath151 varies very little over the range where it has support .
in our model we have access to the full wave function , and this we show in fig . [
fig : wf ] .
the imaging through the 1d equivalent of eq .
( [ eq : wf_expansion ] ) would only give access to the part at large negative @xmath152 .
in the classically allowed region at large negative @xmath152 the maximum of the wave function follows a classical trajectory .
this is a prediction of the wkb theory , which applies as long we are not too close to the turning line .
the classical trajectories can be found using newton s second law @xmath153 [ eq : clas_traj_newton ] a tempting choice of initial condition for the differential eqs .
( [ eq : clas_traj_newton ] ) would be to choose the @xmath154 values at the intersection of the outer turning line and the maximum ridge of the wave function , with zero velocity in both @xmath152 and @xmath119 direction .
however , the wkb fails near the turning line , and therefore we can not expect the wave function to follow a classical trajectory here . instead we have chosen as initial condition some point at the maximum of the wave function at a large negative @xmath152 value away from the turning line .
the influence of the @xmath155 potential can be neglected for sufficiently large negative @xmath152 , in this region we can write the separated energy conservation equations @xmath156 [ eq : clas_traj_energy ] the initial velocities have then been determined from eqs .
( [ eq : clas_traj_energy ] ) , using the real part of the total ( quantum ) energy for @xmath157 and the @xmath49 at which the ker spectrum @xmath120 [ eq . ( [ eq : spec_expr_1d ] ) ] peaks .
the classical trajectories shown in fig . [ fig : wf ] were found using such initial conditions , and then propagated inwards . from fig .
[ fig : wf ] it can be seen that contrary to the exact wave function , the position of the ridge of the bo wave function in @xmath119 does not change with @xmath152 .
this is expected as the bo approximation appears in the limit of infinite nuclear mass , so classical motion in the nuclear coordinate is not possible .
the asymptotic wave function that we can image using eq .
( [ eq : wf_expansion ] ) is therefore a non - bo wave function .
it might seem strange that the bo is able to give the correct ker spectrum when the spectrum is the norm square of the expansion coefficients of the asymptotic wave function , and the bo gives a wrong description of this asymptotic wave function .
however , the fact that the bo wave function does not obtain a probability current ( or velocity in the classical picture ) in the @xmath119-direction does not alter its projection on the continuum states .
the important point is whether the bo wave function is similar to the exact wave function as it emerges at the outer turning line after tunneling , and this is the case if the turning line is within the critical bo distance @xmath147 [ eq . (
[ eq : z_bo ] ) ] . in fig .
[ fig : wf ] we also see that for the larger field strength the tunneling is completed before the critical bo distance is reached , contrary to at the smaller field strength .
we see that for the large field strength the electronic and full turning lines agree quite well in the region where most of the wave function is localized , but for the smaller field strength they do not . for @xmath158 .
solid purple lines : full turning lines @xmath159 .
the long dashed red line shows for each @xmath12 the @xmath119 at which the wave function @xmath160 has its maximum .
the solid pink line shows a classical trajectory [ eq .
( [ eq : clas_traj_newton ] ) ] .
the black dot at the end of the classical trajectory is the exit point @xmath161 determined from the maximum of the spectrum @xmath162 ( see main text ) .
the short dashed lines are the simple straight line estimates for the tunneling and initial classical motion described around eq .
( [ eq : directions ] ) . ]
one can notice that a phenomenon reminiscent of light refraction occurs for the wave function around the turning line in fig .
[ fig : wf ] .
it is evident , that the direction in which the maximum of the wave function moves changes noticeably at the turning line , when the wave function escapes from the classically forbidden tunneling region into the classically allowed region .
the change of direction is due to the two different types of motion involved .
when the wave function emerges from the tunneling region it has essentially zero average velocity in the @xmath119 direction .
this means that we can apply the reflection principle in reverse on the spectrum to find the @xmath163 coordinate at which the maximum of the wave function emerges from the tunneling region by the relation @xmath164 , where @xmath162 is the value of @xmath49 for which the spectrum @xmath120 has its maximum . the @xmath12 value corresponding to this @xmath163 can then by found by considering the turning line @xmath165 . in fig .
[ fig : wf_max ] we see that near the turning line the location of the wave function ridge differs from the classical trajectory .
this is expected , since the prediction that the wave function ridge should follow a classical trajectory comes from wkb theory , which fails near the turning line .
nevertheless , we can roughly describe the dissociative tunneling ionization process in two steps .
first the system tunnels from the central region around @xmath166 to the exit point @xmath161 .
this motion can roughly be described by a straight line from the maximum of the nuclear wave function @xmath123 that has the largest @xmath119 value , since this is the maximum that will dominate the tunneling , to the exit point .
notice that this tunneling is not simply the electron tunneling out , but a correlated process involving both the electronic and nuclear degrees of freedom . in the classically allowed region
the initial direction of the wave function from the exit point can be found from the classical trajectory : the initial slope of the classical trajectory that starts at the exit point @xmath161 with zero velocity in both @xmath12 and @xmath119 directions can be found to be @xmath167 this is not exactly the trajectory that describes the motion of the wave function ridge , but it is quite close .
these two directions are different as they come from different types of motion , and hence we see the refraction - like phenomenon at the turning line .
we have formulated theory for the dissociative tunneling ionization process , and derived exact formulas for the ker spectrum , as well as approximations in the framework of the bo and reflection approximations .
we have demonstrated that the reflection principle can be used in conjunction with the bo approximation to image the field - dressed nuclear wave function from the ker spectrum . for weaker fields ,
where the bo approximation fails , the wfat can be used to find the ker spectrum .
we have also demonstrated a qualitative difference between asymptotic bo and exact wave functions , as the latter shows classical motion in the nuclear coordinate , whereas the former does not move at all due to the infinite nuclear mass of the bo approximation . around the turning line
the wave function exhibits a behavior similar to refraction of light .
this work was supported by the erc - stg ( project no .
277767-tdmet ) , and the vkr center of excellence , quscope .
the numerical results presented in this work were performed at the centre for scientific computing , aarhus http://phys.au.dk / forskning / cscaa/. o. i. t. acknowledges support from the ministry of education and science of russia ( state assignment no .
3.679.2014/k ) . 29ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ]
# 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1218497 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/ncomms7611 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevx.5.021034 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/optica.2.000623 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.98.013901 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.111.033002 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1198450 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.84.043420 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nature10820 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrev.32.858 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.1679721 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.108.073202
[ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.90.063408 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.92.163004 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.82.3416 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.58.426 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.111.153003 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.84.053423 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.89.013421 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrev.56.750 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.79.2026 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.82.023416 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.87.043426 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.53.2562 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.67.043405 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.98.253003 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.91.013408 [ * * , ( ) ] | we present a theoretical study of the dissociative tunneling ionization process .
analytic expressions for the nuclear kinetic energy distribution of the ionization rates are derived .
a particularly simple expression for the spectrum is found by using the born - oppenheimer ( bo ) approximation in conjunction with the reflection principle .
these spectra are compared to exact non - bo _ ab initio _ spectra obtained through model calculations with a quantum mechanical treatment of both the electronic and nuclear degrees freedom . in the regime where the bo approximation is applicable imaging of the bo nuclear wave function
is demonstrated to be possible through reverse use of the reflection principle , when accounting appropriately for the electronic ionization rate . a qualitative difference between the exact and bo wave functions in the asymptotic region of large electronic distances
is shown .
additionally the behavior of the wave function across the turning line is seen to be reminiscent of light refraction . for weak fields , where the bo approximation does not apply ,
the weak - field asymptotic theory describes the spectrum accurately . |
plasma oscillations in solids are possibly the simplest manifestation of collective effects in condensed matter , and their understanding in terms of _ plasmon _ modes one of the earliest triumphs of quantum many - body theory .
@xcite on the experimental side , collective charge - density fluctuations can be probed through electron energy - loss ( eel ) or inelastic x - ray scattering ( ixs ) spectroscopies , two techniques that have been steadily producing a wealth of data since the early 60s and 70s , respectively.@xcite in the present day the engineering of novel materials down to the nanometer scale makes it possible to design devices where electromagnetic fields interact with collective oscillations of structures of sub - wavelength size .
the strong dependence of plasmon dynamics on the size and shape of these nanostructures holds the promise of an extraordinary control over the optical response of the resulting devices , with applications to such diverse fields as photovoltaics,@xcite proton beam acceleration,@xcite or biosensing,@xcite to name but a few .
this is plasmonics , _
i.e _ photonics based on collective electronic excitations in strongly heterogeneous systems , where surface effects play a fundamental role .
plasma oscillations at surfaces have recently aroused a renewed attention by themselves , since it was shown that some metal surfaces unexpectedly exhibit _ acoustic _
plasmons.@xcite these are collective charge excitations localized at the surface , whose frequency vanishes linearly with the wavevector , and are not damped by the bulk electron - hole continuum.@xcite it is thought that these modes may offer the possibility of light confinement at designated locations on the surface , with possible applications in photonics and nano - optics.@xcite most of the theoretical understanding of the optical response in nano - plasmonic systems relies on a classical approach : the nanostructure is usually described as an assembly of components , each characterized by an effective macroscopic dielectric function , and separated from the others by abrupt interfaces . the overall optical response
is then computed by solving maxwell s equation for the resulting heterogeneous system.@xcite when distances between the nanoscale components are themselves nanometric , however , quantum effects must be accounted for , and a fully quantum - mechanical description is called for . early quantum - mechanical approaches to the dynamics of charge - density fluctuations@xcite were based on the random - phase approximation as applied to the jellium model that , albeit exceedingly successful in simple metals and semiconductors , is not suitable for more complex materials , nor can it capture the fine , system - specific , features of even simple ones .
the effects of crystal inhomogeneities on plasmon resonances in semiconductors ( the so called _ local - field _ effects ) were first addressed in the late 70s,@xcite using the empirical pseudopotential method,@xcite along similar lines as previously followed for the optical spectra.@xcite in the present day the method of choice for describing charge dynamics in real materials ( as opposed to simplified models , such as the jellium one ) is time - dependent ( td ) density - functional theory ( dft).@xcite although some attempts to investigate eel and ixs spectra using many - body perturbation theory have been made,@xcite the vast majority of the studies existing to date relies on tddft , which in fact has been successfully used to study plasmons in a number of bulk@xcite and surface@xcite systems .
the conventional tddft approach to plasmon dynamics relies on the calculation of the charge - density susceptibility , @xmath0 ( or , equivalently , inverse dielectric matrix , @xmath1 ) , starting from the independent - electron susceptibility , @xmath2 , via a dyson - like equation.@xcite although successful in ( relatively ) simple systems that can be described by unit cells of moderate size , this methodology can hardly be applied to more complex systems , such as low - index or nano - structured surfaces , because of its intrinsic numerical limitations .
in particular : _ i _ ) the calculation of @xmath2 requires the knowledge of a large number of empty states , which is usually avoided in modern electronic - structure methods ; _ ii _ ) the solution of the dyson - like equation requires the manipulation ( multiplication and inversion ) of ( very ) large matrices , and _
iii _ ) all the above calculations have to be repeated independently for each value of the frequency to be sampled . in this paper
we introduce a new method , based on td density - functional perturbation theory ( dfpt),@xcite that allows to calculate eel and ixs cross sections avoiding all the above drawbacks , and thus lending itself to numerical simulations in complex systems , potentially as large as several hundred independent atoms .
although the new methodology is general in principle , our implementation relies on the pseudopotential approximation , which limits its applicability to valence ( or shallow - core ) loss spectra .
inner - core loss spectra are currently addressed using different methods , as explained _ e.g. _ in refs . .
the salient features of our method are : _ i _ ) the adoption of a representation from time - independent dfpt@xcite allows to avoid the calculation of kohn - sham ( ks ) virtual orbitals and of any large susceptibility matrices ( @xmath0 or @xmath2 ) altogether ; and _ ii _ ) thanks to the use of a lanczos recursion scheme , the bulk of the calculations can be performed only once for all the frequencies simultaneously .
the numerical complexity of the resulting algorithm is comparable , for the _ whole _ spectrum in a wide frequency range , to that of a _ single _ standard ground - state ( or static response ) calculation .
the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ sec : theory ] we describe our basic theoretical and algorithmic frameworks , including the implementation of the newly proposed methodology for the response of a periodic system to a monochromatic perturbation , relevant to the calculation of eel and ixs cross sections ; in sec .
[ sec : applications ] we benchmark our technique on the prototypical examples of bulk silicon and aluminum , for which many experimental and well established theoretical results already exist ; finally , our conclusions are presented in sec .
[ sec : conclusions ] .
electron energy - loss spectroscopy probes the diffusion of a beam of fast electrons through a solid . according to van hove,@xcite the corresponding double - differential cross section for inelastic scattering reads:@xcite @xmath3 where @xmath4 and @xmath5 are the electron charge and mass , @xmath6 , @xmath7 , and @xmath8 are the incoming , outgoing , and transferred momenta , respectively , and @xmath9 is the dynamic structure factor per unit volume .
while eel spectroscopy is not suitable for samples enclosed in high - pressure cells , plasmon dynamics under pressure can be probed by ixs spectroscopy.@xcite the double - differential cross - section reads in this case : @xmath10 where @xmath11 and @xmath12 are the incoming and scattered photon polarization directions , and @xmath13 and @xmath14 are the corresponding frequencies . according to the fluctuation - dissipation theorem@xcite @xmath9 is proportional to the imaginary part of the charge - density susceptibility , @xmath15 : @xmath16 in periodic solids the transferred momentum can be split into a component in the first brillouin zone , @xmath17 , and a reciprocal - lattice vector , @xmath18 , as @xmath19 , and @xmath0 is often expressed in terms of the inverse dielectric matrix , defined as:@xcite @xmath20 where @xmath21 .
the function @xmath22 $ ] is usually referred to as the _ loss function_. in tddft electron dynamics is described by td one - electron equations for the occupied molecular orbitals .
these td ks equations read:@xcite @xmath23 where @xmath24 and @xmath25 are the td ks orbitals and hamiltonian ( quantum mechanical operators are indicated with a caret ) , respectively , the index @xmath26 spans the @xmath27 occupied ( _ valence _ ) states , and atomic units ( @xmath28 are used henceforth .
the ks hamiltonian reads : @xmath29 where @xmath30 and @xmath31 are the external and hartree - plus - exchange - correlation ( hxc ) potentials , respectively .
let us assume that the external potential can be split into a static term , plus a small td perturbation : @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the td strength of the perturbation .
the total ks potential is perturbed accordingly : @xmath34 , @xmath35 being the response hxc potential .
the response of the ks orbitals is defined as @xmath36 @xmath37 and @xmath38 being the unperturbed ground - state ks orbitals and energies , respectively .
the charge - density susceptibility is the response of the electron charge density , which only depends on the projection of the response of the valence ks orbitals onto the empty - state ( conduction ) manifold .
the fourier transforms ( indicated by tilde @xmath39 hereafter ) of such projected response orbitals are obtained from standard first - order perturbation theory via the linear systems : @xmath40 where @xmath41 is the projector over the unperturbed conduction - state manifold .
expressing the latter in terms of valence orbitals ( @xmath42 ) allows one to compute response ks orbitals without making any reference to unoccupied states , much in the same way as it is done in time - independent dfpt.@xcite the solution of eq .
( [ eq : lin - resp_w_eq1 ] ) requires one to express the total response potential , @xmath43 , in terms of its own solutions , through the response charge density , which is the diagonal of the response density matrix , @xmath44 , whose fourier transform is defined as : @xmath45 where the factor two accounts for spin degeneracy in a non - polarized system . note that @xmath46 , as a consequence of the reality of @xmath47 .
the equation for the complex conjugate of @xmath48 reads : @xmath49 where use has been made of the reality of the perturbing potential ( @xmath50 ) .
equations and describe the _ resonant _ and _ anti - resonant _ contributions to charge - density response , respectively .
their left - hand sides just differ by the sign of the frequency , while , by using time - reversal symmetry of the unperturbed system ( @xmath51 ) their right - hand side can be made look alike .
the equations for the resonant and anti - resonant components of the charge - density response are coupled by the hxc potential , which is determined self - consistently by the density response itself , through the relation : @xmath52 where @xmath53 is the hxc kernel , which we assume to be independent of frequency , consistently with the adiabatic dft approximation.@xcite the td ks equations ( [ eq : td - ks_equation ] ) can be equivalently expressed in terms of a quantum liouville equation for the one - particle density matrix , @xmath54:@xcite @xmath55 .
\label{eq : liouville_eq_1}\ ] ] upon linearization and fourier transformation , eq .
( [ eq : liouville_eq_1 ] ) takes the form : @xmath56 , \label{eq : liouville_eq_ft_1_general}\ ] ] where @xmath57 is the unperturbed density matrix and @xmath58 is the liouvillian super - operator , defined by the relation:@xcite @xmath59 + \left [ \hat v'_{\mathrm{hxc}}[\hat{\rho } ' ] , \hat{\rho}^\circ \right ] .
\label{eq : liouvillian_def}\ ] ] the response of an arbitrary one - electron hermitian operator , @xmath60 , to an external perturbation , @xmath61 , is described by the generalized susceptibility : @xmath62 \bigl ) , \label{eq : susceptibility_def_2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath63 indicates a scalar product in an abstract operator manifold.@xcite equation states that , within tddft , the most general susceptibility can be expressed as an off - diagonal element of the resolvent of the liouvillian .
the calculation of susceptibilities from eq . requires the explicit representation of the response density matrix and of the liouvillian super - operator acting on it .
the minimum dimension of such a representation is @xmath64 , where @xmath65 is the number of virtual ( conduction ) orbitals and @xmath66 the dimension of one - electron basis set.@xcite the inversion of the liouvillian appearing in eq . is a formidable task in typical large - scale plane - wave calculations , where the number of occupied states can be as large as several hundreds to a few thousands , and the number of virtual orbitals a hundred times as large .
the recursion method by haydock , heine , and kelly @xcite offers an elegant solution to a similar problem , namely the calculation of a diagonal element of the resolvent of a hermitian matrix , in terms of a continued fraction , whose coefficients are frequency - independent . the _ lanczos bi - orthogonalization algorithm_,@xcite allows one to generalize this procedure to the calculation of _ off - diagonal _ elements of the resolvent of a _ non - hermitian _ matrix . the resulting numerical workload for calculating the full spectrum in a whole wide frequency range is comparable to that of a _ single _ ground - state ( or static response ) calculation .
other flavours of the lanczos - type algorithm can be found in refs . .
we want to calculate matrix elements such as : @xmath67 where @xmath68 is a @xmath69 non - hermitian matrix , and @xmath70 and @xmath26 are generic @xmath71-dimensional arrays . to this end
we define two sets of _ lanczos vectors _ , @xmath72 and @xmath73 , through the recursive relations:@xcite @xmath74 where one defines @xmath75 , @xmath76 , and the @xmath77 , @xmath78 , and @xmath79 _ lanczos coefficients _
are determined by the _ bi - orthogonality _ conditions @xmath80 , and @xmath81 .
the set of vectors and coefficients generated through the recursion relations ( [ eq : lanczos_chain_1]-[eq : lanczos_chain_2 ] ) is often referred to as a _ lanczos chain_. the details of this algorithm are reviewed _
e.g. _ in ref .
[ ] , and its specialization to tddft is presented in refs .
[ ] . for the purposes of the present paper ,
we limit ourselves to observe that the lanczos vectors thus generated have the property that they provide a tridiagonal representation of the @xmath68 matrix . more specifically ,
if we define the @xmath82 matrices @xmath83 and @xmath84 ( @xmath85 being the number of lanczos iterations ) , one has : @xmath86 where @xmath87 is the tridiagonal matrix @xmath88 in this lanczos representation , the matrix element of eq .
can be expressed as:@xcite @xmath89 where @xmath90 and @xmath91 is the @xmath85-dimensional vector defined as:@xcite @xmath92 the right - hand side of eq .
( [ eq : resolvent_g ] ) can be conveniently computed by solving , for any given value of @xmath93 , the equation : @xmath94 and calculating the scalar product : @xmath95 the vector @xmath91 , eq .
( [ eq : zeta_coef_for_g ] ) , can be computed on the fly during the lanczos recursion , through the relation @xmath96 . in practice ,
the procedure outlined above is performed in two steps . in the first step , which is by far the most time consuming , one generates the tridiagonal matrix @xmath87 , eq .
( [ eq : tridiagonal_matrix ] ) , and the vector @xmath97 , eq .
( [ eq : zeta_coef_for_g ] ) . in the second step @xmath98
is calculated from eq .
( [ eq : resolvent_liouvillian_lanczos_2_for_g ] ) upon the solution of eq .
( [ eq : eta_post_processing_for_g ] ) , for different frequencies @xmath93 . in practice
, a small imaginary part @xmath99 is added to the frequency argument , @xmath100 , so as to regularize the function @xmath98.@xcite setting @xmath99 to a non - zero value amounts to broadening each individual spectral line or , alternatively , to convoluting the function @xmath98 with a lorentzian . because of the tridiagonal form and the small dimension of the matrix @xmath87 ( a few hundreds to a few thousands ) , the second step is essentially gratis .
different responses to a same perturbation can be computed simultaneously from a same lanczos recursion , by computing different @xmath101 vectors on the fly .
equation shows that the response density matrix is uniquely determined by the two sets of functions @xmath102 and @xmath103 .
it is convenient to consider a linear combination of these functions , defined as : @xmath104 the two sets @xmath105 and @xmath106 are called respectively the _ upper _ and _ lower _ component of the _ standard batch representation _ ( sbr)@xcite of the response density matrix _ super - vector _ : @xmath107.@xcite the sbr of a hermitian operator , @xmath108 , has vanishing lower component , @xmath109 , while that of its commutator with the unperturbed density matrix [ see eq .
( [ eq : liouville_eq_ft_1_general ] ) ] has vanishing upper component , @xmath110 \sbr \bigl\ { 0 , \ { \hat{p}_c \ , \hat a \ , \varphi_v^\circ(\mathbf{r } ) \ } \bigr\}$ ] .
the sbr of the liouvillian super - operator has the block form:@xcite @xmath111 where the @xmath112 and @xmath113 super - operators are defined by their action on response batches , @xmath114 @xmath115 is the hxc kernel of eq .
( [ eq : hxc_kernel ] ) , and @xmath116 is the hxc potential ( see eq . ) generated by the response charge density distribution whose sbr is ( see eq . ):
@xmath117 according to the above equations , operating with the liouvillian on a test super - vector essentially requires the calculation of the hxc potential response , its application to each valence ks orbital , as well as the operation of the unperturbed hamiltonian onto twice the number of valence ks states . the starting super - vector of the lanczos recursion is the right - hand side of eq .
whose sbr is : @xmath118 because of the special block structure of the liouvillian , eq .
( [ eq : liouvillian_sbr ] ) , the sbr of odd lanczos iterates have vanishing upper components , whereas the even ones have vanishing lower components . as a consequence
, the number of response wavefunctions onto which the unperturbed hamiltonian must operate per lanczos iteration is halved .
also , the diagonal elements of the resulting tridiagonal matrix ( the @xmath119 coefficients ) are all vanishing .
it was previously noted that the components of the vector @xmath97 , eq .
( [ eq : zeta_coef_for_g ] ) , decrease rather rapidly to zero , whereas the @xmath78 ( and @xmath79 ) coefficients oscillate around two distinct values for odd and even iterations , whose average is approximatively equal to one half of the kinetic - energy cutoff ( in a plane - wave implementation ) , and whose difference is approximately twice as large as the excitation gap in insulating or semiconducting materials.@xcite this finding can be used to speed up considerably the calculation by adopting a suitable extrapolation technique . in practice , the lanczos recursion is stoped after @xmath120 iterations , such that the components of the @xmath101 array are small enough .
the dimension @xmath85 of the linear system , eq .
, is then set to a very large ( and to a large extent arbitrary ) value .
the @xmath101 components from @xmath121 to @xmath85 are set to zero , whereas the corresponding @xmath122 and @xmath123 coefficients are set to the average of the values that have been actually computed .
the accuracy of the calculated spectrum is then checked _ a posteriori _ with respect to the value of @xmath120 .
in many applications it turns out that @xmath120 may vary from a few hundreds up to a few thousands ( depending on the plane - wave kinetic energy cutoff ) , and @xmath85 is a ( to a large extent arbitrary ) number reaching up to several thousands . as the solution of tridiagonal systems
can be performed very efficiently via standard factorization techniques , the numerical overhead of this procedure is negligible .
more on lanczos extrapolation can be found in refs . . in a periodic solid the unperturbed ks orbitals are @xmath124 , where @xmath125
, @xmath126 is a band index and @xmath127 a point in the brillouin zone .
these ks orbitals can be cast into the bloch form : @xmath128 where @xmath129 is the lattice - periodic function .
similarly , the total perturbing potential can be conveniently decomposed into _ bloch components _ : @xmath130 where @xmath131 is also lattice - periodic , and the sum extends over the first brillouin zone .
a similar decomposition can be applied to the external and hxc response potentials .
the response of each ks orbital can be correspondingly expressed as a linear combination of the responses to each bloch component of the perturbing potential : @xmath132 where @xmath133 is a lattice - periodic response orbital that satisfies the equation : @xmath134 in eq .
, as well as in the rest of this paper , quantum - mechanical operators bearing a wave - vector subscript ( such as @xmath135 ) or superscript ( such as @xmath136 ) are thought to operate on lattice - periodic functions , and are defined in terms of their coordinate representations as : @xmath137 the projector onto the conduction manifold in eq . can be expressed in terms of the periodic parts of the unperturbed bloch functions as : @xmath138 where the sum extends over all the occupied bands .
a similar decomposition into bloch components holds for the response density matrix , which reads in this case : @xmath139 where @xmath140 the anti - resonant contribution to the density - matrix response in eq . satisfies the equation : @xmath141 which can be obtained from eq . by complex conjugation and simple manipulations deriving from time - reversal invariance of the unperturbed system ( @xmath142 ) and the reality of the perturbing potential ( @xmath143 ) . in analogy with eq .
, eq . shows that the response density matrix of a periodic solid to a perturbation of wave - vector @xmath144 is uniquely determined by the two sets of response orbitals @xmath145 and @xmath146 . note that @xmath126 and @xmath127 are running indices , whereas @xmath144 is fixed .
the sbr can in this case be defined as : @xmath147 the two sets of response orbitals , @xmath148 and @xmath149 satisfy the coupled set of equations : @xmath150 where @xmath151 , and @xmath152 and @xmath153 are the super - operators defined by the relations : @xmath154 and @xmath155 is the hxc potential generated by the response charge density : @xmath156 equations , , and are closely parallel to eqs .
, , and of sec .
[ sec : batch_repr_general ] . in practice ,
the sum over @xmath127 points is limited to the portion of the brillouin zone that is irreducible with respect to the small group of @xmath144 and the resulting function symmetrized accordingly , in close analogy with time - independent dfpt for lattice - dynamical calculations.@xcite more about the exploitation of crystal symmetry in the calculation of dynamical charge - density susceptibilities can be found in ref . .
the @xmath157 component of the charge - density susceptibility is obtained from eq . as the response of the @xmath158 fourier component of the charge - density operator , whose coordinate representation reads @xmath159 , to a monochromatic perturbation , @xmath160 .
the sbr of the periodic part of @xmath161 is @xmath162 .
the final expression for the susceptibility is : @xmath163 where @xmath164 is the solution of eq .
, obtained when the periodic part of the external perturbing potential is @xmath165 . in practice the susceptibility in eq .
is computed following the procedure outlined in sec .
[ sec : lanczos_method ] ( see eq . ):
@xmath166 where @xmath167 is a tridiagonal matrix of dimension @xmath85 of the form ( [ eq : tridiagonal_matrix ] ) , and @xmath168 is an @xmath85-dimensional array whose coefficients @xmath169 are defined as : @xmath170 the liouville - lanczos approach for eel and ixs spectroscopies can be extended to metals by a suitable generalization of the smearing technique introduced by de gironcoli in the static case for lattice - dynamical calculations.@xcite in the smearing approach , each ks energy level is broadened by a smearing function @xmath171 , which is an approximation to the dirac @xmath172-function in the limit of vanishing smearing width @xmath173 .
the monochromatic @xmath144 component of the charge - density response eq .
( [ eq : sbr_charge - density_2 ] ) can then be cast into the form : @xmath174 where the functions @xmath175 and @xmath176 satisfy the equations : @xmath177 ( cf . with eqs . and ) , where @xmath178 @xmath179 $ ] and @xmath180 $ ] being smooth approximations to the step - function , and @xmath181 is the fermi energy .
it can be easily verified that the coefficients @xmath182 vanish when any of its indices refers to an unoccupied state .
therefore , the operator @xmath183 involves only a small number of partially occupied bands , and the first - order variation of the wavefunctions and of the charge density can be computed avoiding any explicit reference to unoccupied states , much in the same way as for insulating materials .
more details about the liouville - lanczos approach for metals can be found in ref . .
the technique described above has been implemented in the quantum espresso suite of computer codes,@xcite and is scheduled to be distributed in one of its future releases .
we now proceed to validate it by calculating the loss function in bulk silicon and aluminum , for which several tddft studies exist , and whose spectra are known to be accurately described within the adiabatic local density ( lda ) and generalized gradient ( gga ) approximations ( see , _
e.g. _ , refs . for si , and for al ) .
all the calculations have been performed within the lda approximation , using the perdew - zunger parameterization of the electron - gas data,@xcite norm - conserving pseudopotentials from the quantum espresso database@xcite and plane - wave basis sets up to a kinetic - energy cutoff of 16 ry .
the first brillouin zone has been sampled with a monkhorst - pack ( mp ) @xmath127 point mesh , supplemented , in the case of al , by the methfessel - paxton smearing technique@xcite with a broadening parameter @xmath184 ry .
the frequency argument of the susceptibility has been assumed to have a small imaginary part , @xmath99 , thus resulting in a lorentzian smearing of the spectra ( see sec . [
sec : lanczos_method ] ) . for
both si and al we have used the experimental lattice parameters ( 10.26 a.u.@xcite and 7.60 a.u.,@xcite respectively ) , which is very close to the theoretical one and resulting in no appreciable difference in the computed spectra .
figure [ fig : si_conv_iter ] shows the convergence of the loss spectrum of si , as calculated for a transferred momentum @xmath185 a.u . along the [ 100 ] direction , as a function of the number of lanczos iterations .
after 400 iterations the spectrum displays spurious wiggles , which disappear by increasing the number of iterations up to 1500 .
also displayed are results obtained by the extrapolation procedure outlined at the end of sec .
[ sec : batch_repr_general ] , performed with @xmath186 lanczos iterations and extrapolating the results up to a linear system of dimension @xmath187 .
we see that the numerical workload can be considerably reduced without any appreciable loss of accuracy . in fig .
[ fig : si_conv_k ] we show the convergence of the loss function with respect to the @xmath127 point sampling of the brillouin zone .
the @xmath188 mp @xmath127 point mesh is not dense enough to obtain a well - converged spectrum , due to the presence of spurious wiggles , which disappear by increasing the size of the mp mesh up to @xmath189 . in fig .
[ fig : si_theor_vs_exp ] we compare our present results with those obtained from the conventional approach based on the dyson - like equation for the susceptibility@xcite and with experiment.@xcite the agreement is excellent in both cases .
all the salient features observed in the experiments at small transferred momentum ( panel ( a ) ) are correctly predicted : the main plasmon peak around 20 ev , a shoulder around 15 ev , and a weak peak around 6.5 ev .
we attribute the slight differences between the two theoretical spectra to the slightly different technical details used in the two works . in particular , the authors of ref . mimicked electron- and hole - lifetime effects with an energy - dependent broadening , in contrast to the constant lorentzian broadening , @xmath190 ry , used in our calculations . at larger momentum transfer ( panel ( b ) )
the interaction of the plasmon with the electron - hole continuum broadens the spectrum.@xcite the agreement with experiment,@xcite remarkable also in this case , is enhanced by increasing the lorentzian broadening up to @xmath191 ry , which allowed us to reduce the size of the mp mesh down to @xmath192 without any appreciable loss of accuracy .
figure [ fig : al_conv_iter ] shows the convergence of the loss function of al , calculated at a transferred momentum @xmath193 a.u . along the [ 100 ] direction , as a function of the number of lanczos iterations .
although the qualitative behavior is similar to that observed in si ( wiggles showing up for a small number of iterations disappear by increasing this number ) , the convergence appears to be faster in the present case . as for the large - iterate behavior of the lanczos coefficient
, we observe that , in contrast to si , in al the odd and even coefficients oscillate around a same value , which is also in this case of the order of one half the plane - wave kinetic - energy cutoff .
this is due to the vanishing of the gap , as discussed in ref . .
figure [ fig : al_conv_k ] shows the convergence with respect to the size of the @xmath127 point mesh : very satisfactory convergence is achieved with @xmath189 mp mesh and a broadening parameter @xmath194 ry . in fig .
[ fig : al_theor_vs_exp ] we compare the loss function of al as calculated by the present method for two different values of the transferred momentum along the [ 100 ] direction , with ixs experiments and with previous theoretical work . at
small transferred momentum ( panel ( a ) ) theoretical predictions agree remarkably well with each other ( the slight discrepancies being attributable to the usual small differences between the technical details of the calculations ) and with experiment . both theoretical spectra display a small blueshift ( @xmath195 ev ) of the plasmon peak with respect to experiments . at larger transferred momentum ( panel ( b ) ) the theoretical spectra display a feature at @xmath196 ev , which is not observed experimentally .
we attribute the remaining discrepancies to the lifetime effects,@xcite which have been treated in our calculations by a constant lorentzian broadening parameter ( @xmath197 ry , requiring a @xmath198 mp mesh ) .
we believe that the liouville - lanczos approach introduced in this paper will open new perspectives in the calculation of loss spectra in extended systems .
its main features are the adoption of a representation for the charge - density response borrowed from density - functional perturbation theory , and of a lanczos recursion scheme for computing selected elements of the inverse of ( very ) large matrices . the combination of these two elements permits to compute the loss spectrum of a given system , for a given transferred momentum , and for an _ entire wide frequency range _ , with a numerical workload of the same order as needed for a standard ground - state calculation for a same system ( the pre - factor being only a few times larger ) . in principle , the convergence of the computed loss spectra with respect to the length of the lanczos chains depends on the spectral range : the lower the frequency , the faster the convergence , as it was already observed for optical spectra in finite systems.@xcite in practice , however , adoption of the extrapolation techniques explained in sec .
[ sec : extrapolation ] substantially alleviates this dependence .
also , the spectral range accessible to eel / ixs spectroscopies is limited by the so - called @xmath199-sum rule:@xcite @xmath200 \omega \ , d\omega = - \frac{\pi}{2 } \ , \omega_p^2 , \label{eq : f_sum_rule}\ ] ] where @xmath201 is the plasma frequency , @xmath202 being the average electron density , _ i.e. _ the number of electrons ( _ valence _ electrons , in a pseudopotential calculation ) per unit volume.@xcite of course , the spectral range that needs to be sampled by lanczos recursion is correspondingly limited .
the liouville - lanczos approach introduced in this paper also lends itself to an easy generalization to those methods ( such as hybrid functionals or the static bethe - salpeter equation
bse ) that require the full density - matrix ( rather than just charge - density ) response , which is in fact as easily accessible to the batch representation utilized here.@xcite further generalization to frequency - dependent xc kernels ( or to the bse with dynamical screening ) may simply require computing the loss function at shifted frequencies ( @xmath203 ) , as proposed _
e.g. _ in ref . , or further methodological developments .
further work is required to clarify this issue .
all in all we believe that the advances presented in this paper will allow for the simulation of complex , possibly nano - structured , surfaces , as well as of systems where valence and shallow - core loss spectra overlap .
examples of the former include low miller index surfaces or plasmonic materials , while bulk bismuth is an example of the latter .
work is in progress on both lines .
we thank s. de gironcoli , a. dal corso , and l. reining for valuable discussions .
support from the anr ( project pnano accattone ) and from dga are gratefully acknowledged .
computer time was granted by genci ( project no .
2210 ) . the work of i.t . and n.v
has been performed under the auspices of the _ laboratoire dexcellence en nanosciences et nanotechnologies labex nanosaclay_. n.v .
thanks marco saitta for discussions about tddfpt at an early stage of the project .
s.b . gratefully acknowledges hospitality at the _ laboratoire des solides irradis _ of the cole polytechnique , where this paper was written . | the liouville - lanczos approach to linear - response time - dependent density - functional theory is generalized so as to encompass electron energy - loss and inelastic x - ray scattering spectroscopies in periodic solids .
the computation of virtual orbitals and the manipulation of large matrices are avoided by adopting a representation of response orbitals borrowed from ( time - independent ) density - functional perturbation theory and a suitable lanczos recursion scheme .
the latter allows the bulk of the numerical work to be performed at any given transferred momentum only once , for a whole extended frequency range .
the numerical complexity of the method is thus greatly reduced , making the computation of the loss function over a wide frequency range at any given transferred momentum only slightly more expensive than a single standard ground - state calculation , and opening the way to computations for systems of unprecedented size and complexity .
our method is validated on the paradigmatic examples of bulk silicon and aluminum , for which both experimental and theoretical results already exist in the literature . |
physical models often involve phenomenological parameters or auxiliary fields characterizing the background spacetime or the background media . in most cases , dynamics of the model depend smoothly ( continuously and differentiably ) on the values of the background parameter .
a non - smooth functional dependence is a rather rare phenomenon , but if it exists , it usually represents a keystone issue of the model .
the examples of such non - smooth behavior are well known in solid state physics as phase transitions at critical points .
another similar issue is the scalar higgs model of spontaneous symmetry breaking . in this paper
, we present a simple phenomenological model of an electromagnetic medium that allows wave propagation only for a sufficiently big value of the medium parameter . for zero values of the parameter ,
our medium is the ordinary sr ( or even gr ) vacuum with the standard dispersion relation @xmath0 .
however even infinitesimally small variations of the parameter modify the dispersion relation in such a way that it does not have real solutions , i.e. , the medium becomes to be completely opaque . for higher values of the parameter
, the dispersion relation is modified once more and once again it has real solutions .
it is well known that the dispersion relation can be treated as an effective metric in the phase space . in our model ,
the vacuum lorentz metric is spontaneously transformed into the euclidean one and returns to be lorentzian for a sufficiently big value of the parameter .
we consider the standard electromagnetic system of two antisymmetric fields @xmath1 and @xmath2 that obey the vacuum maxwell system @xmath3}=0\,,\qquad h^{ij}{}_{,j}=0\,.\ ] ] the fields are assumed to be related by the local linear constitutive relation , @xcite,@xcite , @xmath4 due to this definition , the constitutive tensor obeys the symmetries @xmath5 the electromagnetic model ( [ max ] ) with the local linear response ( [ cons ] ) is intensively studied recently , see @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and especially in @xcite . by using the young diagram technique ,
a fourth rank tensor with the symmetries ( [ sym ] ) is uniquely irreducible decomposed into the sum of three independent pieces .
@xmath6 the first term here is the principal part . in the simplest pure maxwell case
it is expressed by the metric tensor of gr @xmath7 in the flat minkowski spacetime with the metric @xmath8 , it reads @xmath9 in quantum field description , this term is related to the photon .
the third term in ( [ decomp ] ) is completely skew symmetric .
consequently , it can be written as @xmath10 the pseudo - scalar @xmath11 represents the axion copartner of the photon .
it influences the wave propagation such that birefringence occurs @xcite , @xcite .
in fact , this effect is absent in the geometric optics description and corresponds to the higher order approximation , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite .
we turn now to the second part of ( [ decomp ] ) , that is expressed as @xmath12 this tensor has 15 independent components , so it may be represented by a traceless matrix @xcite , @xcite .
this matrix reads @xmath13 the traceless condition @xmath14 follows straightforwardly from ( [ skewon - matr ] ) . in order to describe the influence of the skewon on the wave propagation , it is convenient to introduce a covector @xmath15 consider a medium described by a vacuum principal part ( [ princ - part - m ] ) and a generic skewon .
the dispersion relation for such a medium takes the form , @xcite , @xcite , @xmath16 here the scalar product @xmath17 and the squares of the covectors @xmath18 and @xmath19 are calculated by the use of the metric tensor .
it can be easily checked that eq.([disp ] ) is invariant under the gauge transformation @xmath20 with an arbitrary real parameter @xmath21 .
this parameter can even be an arbitrary function of @xmath22 and of the medium parameters @xmath23 . with this gauge freedom
, we can apply the lorenz - type gauge condition @xmath24 and obtain the dispersion relation in an even more simple form @xmath25 this expression yields a characteristic fact @xcite : the solutions @xmath26 of the dispersion relation , if they exist , are non - timelike , that is , spacelike or null , @xmath27 we will proceed now with the form ( [ disp ] ) and with the skewon covector expressed as in ( [ skewon - cov ] ) .
we can rewrite the dispersion relation as @xmath28 consequently , the real solutions exist only if @xmath29 our crucial observation that the first term here is quartic in the skewon parameters @xmath30 while the second term is only quadratic . under these circumstances , the first term can be small for for sufficiently small skewon parameters and the inequality ( [ ineq ] ) breaks down . for higher values , the first term becomes to be essential and the inequality is reinstated .
we now present a model where this possibility is realized , indeed . consider a symmetric traceless matrix with two nonzero entries @xmath31 we denote the components of the wave covector as @xmath32 .
the skewon covector has two nonzero components @xmath33 consequently , @xmath34 hence the inequality ( [ ineq ] ) takes the form @xmath35 observe that for every choice of the wave covector this expression is of the form @xmath36 with positive coefficients @xmath37 .
quite surprisingly , this functional expression repeats the well known curve of the higgs potential .
.,title="fig:",width=245 ] the dispersion relation as it is given in eq.([disp ] ) reads @xmath38 we rewrite it as @xmath39 consequently : * for @xmath40 , we return to the unmodified light cone @xmath41 . * for @xmath42 , except for the trivial solution @xmath43 , there are no real solutions of eq([disp2 ] ) at all . * for @xmath44 , there are two real solutions : @xmath45 for the numerical images of these algebraic cones , see fig . 3 and fig .
4 . ) with @xmath46 and @xmath47 signs respectively . the parameter @xmath48 .
@xmath49 is directed as @xmath50-axis , @xmath51 are directed as @xmath52 and @xmath53 axes respectively .
@xmath54 . ,
title="fig:",width=170 ] ) with @xmath46 and @xmath47 signs respectively .
the parameter @xmath48 .
@xmath49 is directed as @xmath50-axis , @xmath51 are directed as @xmath52 and @xmath53 axes respectively .
@xmath54 . ,
title="fig:",width=170 ] ) with @xmath46 and @xmath47 signs respectively .
the parameter @xmath48 .
@xmath49 is directed as @xmath50-axis , @xmath55 are directed as @xmath52 and @xmath53 axes , respectively .
@xmath56 . ,
title="fig:",width=170 ] ) with @xmath46 and @xmath47 signs respectively .
the parameter @xmath48 .
@xmath49 is directed as @xmath50-axis , @xmath55 are directed as @xmath52 and @xmath53 axes , respectively .
, title="fig:",width=170 ] in both cones , the skewon interchanges the time axis with the spatial @xmath52-axis .
these 3-dimensional cones are tangential to one another when the discriminant in eq .
( [ sym-15 ] ) is zero .
it gives a 2-dimensional cone @xmath57 the expressions in eq.([sym-15 ] ) can be treated as finlsler metric elements . due to the fact that they have non - compact 2d - sections as in fig . 2 and compact 2d - sections as in fig .
3 , the corresponding finsler metric tensors are of the lorentz signature type . we construct a model of the electromagnetic vacuum with a skewon field that has the following features : * there is a gap for values of the parameters near zero , where the wave propagation is forbidden .
* birefringence of the light propagation . * full interchange between time and spatial direction . * a continuous 2-dimensional variety of optic axes instead of distinct optic axes appearing in anisotropic optics . *
the light cones are non - convex .
electromagnetic media with an additional skewon field provide a rich class of models of wave propagation with rather unusual features , see @xcite , @xcite .
recently the observational restrictions on such models were discussed in @xcite and @xcite . in this paper , we show that higgs - type potential can appear in a simple electromagnetic model by a minimal modification of the vacuum constitutive relation .
my acknowledgments to f. hehl ( cologne / columbia , mo ) , yu .
obukhov ( cologne / moscow ) , v. perlick ( zarm , bremen ) , c. lmmerzahl ( zarm , bremen ) , and y. friedman ( jct , jerusalem ) for valuable discussions .
i acknowledge the gif grant no .
1078 - 107.14/2009 for financial support .
y. n. obukhov , t. fukui and g. f. rubilar , phys . rev .
d * 62 * , 044050 ( 2000 ) .
y. n. obukhov and g. f. rubilar , phys .
d * 66 * , 024042 ( 2002 ) . c. lmmerzahl and f. w. hehl , phys .
d * 70 * ( 2004 ) 105022 .
ni , phys . lett .
a * 378 * , 1217 ( 2014 ) .
s. di serego alighieri , w .- t .
ni and w .- p .
pan , `` new constraints on cosmic polarization rotation from b - mode polarization in cosmic microwave background , '' arxiv:1404.1701 . | in the framework of standard electrodynamics with linear local response , we construct a model that provides spontaneously broken transparency .
the functional dependence of the medium parameter turns out to be of the higgs type . |
.the `` half - split '' @xmath3 magic square of lie algebras . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] an analogous problem has been analyzed for the @xmath4 magic square , which is shown in table [ 2x2 ] ; the interpretation of the first two rows was discussed in @xcite ; see also @xcite .
dray , huerta , and kincaid showed first @xcite ( see also @xcite ) how to relate @xmath5 to @xmath6 , and later @xcite extended their treatment to the full @xmath4 magic square of lie groups in table [ 2x2 ] . in the third row ,
their clifford algebra description of @xmath7 is equivalent to a symplectic description as @xmath8 , with @xmath9 .
explicitly , they represent @xmath10 , where @xmath11 , in terms of actions on @xmath12 matrices of the form @xmath13 where @xmath14 is a @xmath4 hermitian matrix over @xmath15 , representing @xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath18 denotes the @xmath4 identity matrix , and tilde denotes trace - reversal , that is , @xmath19
. the matrix @xmath20 can be thought of as the upper right @xmath12 block of an @xmath21 clifford algebra representation , and the action of @xmath10 on @xmath20 is obtained as usual from ( the restriction of ) the quadratic elements of the clifford algebra .
the generators @xmath22 can be chosen so that the action takes the form @xmath23 where the case - dependent signs are related to the restriction from @xmath21 matrices to @xmath12 matrices .
following sudbery @xcite , we define the elements @xmath24 of the symplectic lie algebra @xmath25 by the condition @xmath26 where @xmath27 solutions of ( [ sp4def ] ) take the form , corresponding to @xmath28 .
such elements can however also be generated as commutators of elements of the form ( [ ablock ] ) , so we do not consider them separately . ]
@xmath29 where both @xmath30 and @xmath31 are hermitian , @xmath32 , and @xmath33 .
but generators of take exactly the same form : @xmath34 represents an element of @xmath16 , @xmath30 and @xmath31 are ( null ) translations , and @xmath35 is the dilation .
direct computation shows that the generators @xmath24 of do indeed satisfy ( [ sp4def ] ) ; the above construction therefore establishes the isomorphism @xmath36 as claimed .
we can bring the representation ( [ pdef ] ) into a more explicitly symplectic form by treating @xmath14 as a vector - valued 1-form , and computing its hodge dual @xmath37 , defined by @xmath38 where @xmath39 is the levi - civita tensor in two dimensions . using the identity
@xmath40 we see that @xmath41 takes the form @xmath42 which is antisymmetric , and whose block structure is shown in figure [ square ] .
the diagonal blocks , labeled @xmath43 and @xmath44 , are antisymmetric , and correspond to @xmath45 and @xmath46 , respectively , whereas the off - diagonal blocks , labeled @xmath47 and @xmath48 , contain equivalent information , corresponding to @xmath37 . note that @xmath37 does not use up all of the degrees of freedom available in an off - diagonal block ; the set of _ all _ antisymmetric @xmath12 matrices is _ not _ an irreducible representation of @xmath25 .
the action of @xmath25 on @xmath49 is given by @xmath50 for @xmath51 , that is , for @xmath24 satisfying ( [ sp4def ] ) . )
can be used if desired to determine the signs in ( [ soact ] ) . ]
when working over @xmath52 or @xmath53 , the action ( [ sp4act ] ) is just the antisymmetric square @xmath54 of the natural representation @xmath55 , with @xmath56 . antisymmetric matrix in terms of @xmath4 blocks .
a binary labeling of the blocks is shown on the left ; on the right , blocks with similar shading contain equivalent information.,title="fig:",height=96 ] antisymmetric matrix in terms of @xmath4 blocks .
a binary labeling of the blocks is shown on the left ; on the right , blocks with similar shading contain equivalent information.,title="fig:",height=96 ]
before generalizing the above construction to the @xmath3 magic square , we first consider the analog of @xmath37 .
let @xmath57 be an element of the albert algebra , which we can regard as a vector - valued 1-form with components @xmath58 , with @xmath59 .
the hodge dual @xmath60 of @xmath61 is a vector - valued 2-form with components @xmath62 where @xmath63 denotes the levi - civita tensor in three dimensions , that is , the completely antisymmetric tensor satisfying @xmath64 and where repeated indices are summed over .
we refer to @xmath60 as a _
cubie_. we also introduce the dual of @xmath63 , the completely antisymmetric tensor @xmath65 satisfying @xmath66 and note the further identities @xmath67 in particular , we have @xmath68 operations on the albert algebra can be rewritten in terms of cubies .
for instance , @xmath69 from which the components of @xmath70 can also be worked out . in the special case where the components of @xmath61 and @xmath71 commute , contracting both sides of ( [ epssq ] ) with @xmath72 yields @xmath73 or equivalently @xmath74 providing two remarkably simple expressions for the freudenthal product , albeit only in a very special case .
we will return to this issue below .
the action of @xmath75 on cubies is given by @xmath76 [ e6lemma ] consider the expression @xmath77 which is completely antisymmetric , and hence vanishes unless @xmath78 , @xmath79 , @xmath80 are distinct .
but then @xmath81 which vanishes , since @xmath82 .
thus , ( [ e6act ] ) becomes @xmath83 as claimed , where we have used both ( [ phiadj ] ) and ( [ trphi ] ) .
a similar result holds for the action of @xmath84 .
antisymmetric tensor in terms of @xmath85 `` cubies '' . a binary labeling of the cubies is shown on the pulled - apart cube on the left ; on the right , cubies with similar shading contain equivalent information.,title="fig:",height=192 ] antisymmetric tensor in terms of @xmath85 `` cubies '' .
a binary labeling of the cubies is shown on the pulled - apart cube on the left ; on the right , cubies with similar shading contain equivalent information.,title="fig:",height=192 ] the representation ( [ thetadef ] ) can be written in block form , which we also call @xmath86 , namely require nested matrix transformations of the form ( [ e7mat ] ) . ]
@xmath87 where @xmath88 denotes the @xmath3 identity matrix . by analogy with section [ sp4 ]
, we would like @xmath86 to act on @xmath60 , which has 3 indices , and the correct symmetries to be an off - diagonal block of a rank 3 antisymmetric tensor @xmath89 , whose components make up a @xmath90 cube , which we divide into @xmath85 cubies , as shown in figure [ cube ] ; compare figure [ square ] .
we identity the diagonal cubies , labeled @xmath91 and @xmath92 , with @xmath93 and @xmath94 , respectively , the cubie labeled @xmath95 with @xmath60 , the cubie labeled @xmath96 with @xmath97 , and then let antisymmetry do the rest .
explicitly , we have @xmath98 where we have introduced the convention that @xmath99 , and where the remaining components are determined by antisymmetry .
is a _ cube _ , and has components @xmath100 with @xmath101 , whereas @xmath63 , @xmath102 , and @xmath103 are the components of _ cubies _ , which are subblocks of @xmath89 , with @xmath104 . ] in the complex case , we could begin with the natural action of @xmath86 on 6-component complex vectors , and then take the antisymmetric cube , that is , we could consider the action @xmath105 with @xmath106 , or equivalently @xmath107 the action of the dilation @xmath108 on @xmath89 is given by ( [ pact ] ) .
[ dilemma ] from ( [ e7mat ] ) , we have @xmath109 with the sign being negative for @xmath110 and positive for @xmath111 .
thus , ( [ pact ] ) becomes @xmath112 where the signs depend on which of @xmath113 , @xmath79 , @xmath80 are `` small '' ( @xmath114 ) or `` large '' ( @xmath115 ) . examining ( [ pblocks ] ) , it is now easy to see that @xmath116 , @xmath117 , @xmath118 , and @xmath119 , exactly as required by ( [ freudx])([qfreud ] ) .
if the elements of @xmath120 commute with those of @xmath89 , then the action of the translations @xmath121 and @xmath122 on @xmath89 is given by ( [ pact ] ) .
[ trlemma ] set @xmath121 and consider the action of @xmath86 on @xmath45 , @xmath61 , @xmath71 , and @xmath46 , needing to verify ( [ freudx])([qfreud ] ) with @xmath123 , @xmath124 , and @xmath125 . from
( [ e7mat ] ) , we have @xmath126 since @xmath127 has one `` small '' index and one `` large '' index , it acts as a lowering operator , e.g. mapping cubie @xmath96 to @xmath91 , and thus maps @xmath128 . in particular , this confirms the lack of a term involving @xmath127 in ( [ qfreud ] ) . considering terms involving @xmath46 , we look at cubie @xmath95 , where the only nonzero term of ( [ pact ] ) is @xmath129 which verifies ( [ freudx ] ) in this case .
we next look at cubie @xmath91 , where ( [ pact ] ) becomes @xmath130 which is clearly antisymmetric , so we can use ( [ eps6 ] ) and ( [ sinv ] ) to obtain @xmath131 which is ( [ pfreud ] ) , where we have used commutativity only in the last equality .
finally , turning to cubie @xmath96 , ( [ pact ] ) becomes @xmath132 or equivalently , using ( [ sinv ] ) and ( [ cfreud ] ) , @xmath133 which is ( [ freudy ] ) .
this entire argument can be repeated with only minor changes if @xmath122 . over @xmath134 or @xmath53 ,
we re done ; lemmas [ e6lemma ] , [ dilemma ] , and [ trlemma ] together suffice to show that the action ( [ pact ] ) is the same as the freudenthal action ( [ freudx])([qfreud ] ) .
unfortunately , the action ( [ pact ] ) fails to satisfy the jacobi identity over @xmath135 or @xmath136 .
however , we can still use lemmas [ e6lemma ] , [ dilemma ] , and [ trlemma ] to reproduce the freudenthal action in those cases , as follows .
the action of @xmath137 on @xmath89 is determined by @xmath138 when acting on elements of the form ( [ pblocks ] ) , which extends to all of @xmath0 by antisymmetry .
[ e6lemma2 ] from ( [ e7mat ] ) , we have @xmath139 inserting ( [ thetaphi ] ) into ( [ cubeact ] ) now yields precisely ( [ e6cact ] ) when acting on @xmath61 ; the argument for the action on @xmath71 is similar .
furthermore , using a argument similar to that used to prove lemma [ e6lemma ] to begin with , ( [ pact ] ) acts on @xmath45 via @xmath140 which is completely antisymmetric in @xmath113 , @xmath79 , @xmath80 , and therefore proportional to @xmath141 . the argument for
the action on @xmath46 is similar , with @xmath142 replaced by @xmath84 .
although ( [ cubeact ] ) itself is only antisymmetric in its last two indices , that suffices to define an action on cubies @xmath91 , @xmath95 , @xmath96 , and @xmath92 ; the action on the remaining 4 cubies is uniquely determined by requiring that antisymmetry be preserved .
we now have all the pieces , and can state our main result .
the lie algebra @xmath0 acts symplectically on cubes , that is , @xmath143 acts on cubes via ( [ cubeact ] ) , as do real translations and the dilation , and all other @xmath0 transformations can then be constructed from these transformations using linear combinations and commutators .
[ thm ] lemmas [ dilemma ] and [ trlemma ] are unchanged by the use of ( [ cubeact ] ) rather than ( [ pact ] ) , since the components of @xmath86 commute with those of @xmath89 in both cases , and lemma [ e6lemma2 ] verifies that @xmath144 acts via ( [ cubeact ] ) , as claimed .
it only remains to show that the remaining generators of @xmath0 can be obtained from these elements via commutators .
using ( [ freudx])([qfreud ] ) , it is straightforward to compute the commutator of two @xmath0 transformations of the form ( [ thetadef ] ) .
letting @xmath145 be a boost , so that @xmath146 and @xmath147 , and using the identity @xmath148 for any @xmath149 , we obtain @xmath150 = ( 0,0,{{\cal a}}\circ{{\cal q}},0)\ ] ] we can therefore obtain the null translation @xmath151 for any _ tracefree _ albert algebra element @xmath152 as the commutator of @xmath153 and @xmath154 ; a similar argument can be used to construct the null translation @xmath155 .
thus , _ all _ generators of @xmath0 can be implemented either as a symplectic transformation on cubes via ( [ cubeact ] ) , or as the commutator of two such transformations .
we have showed that the algebraic description of the minimal representation of @xmath156 introduced by freudenthal naturally corresponds geometrically to a symplectic structure . along the way , we have emphasized both the similarities and differences between @xmath0 and @xmath157 .
both of these algebras are _ conformal _ ; their elements divide naturally into generalized rotations ( @xmath144 or @xmath158 , respectively ) , translations , and a dilation . both act naturally on a representation built out of vectors ( @xmath3 or @xmath4 hermitian octonionic matrices , respectively ) , together with two additional real degrees of freedom ( @xmath45 and @xmath46 ) . in the @xmath4 case ,
the representation ( [ pdef ] ) contains just one vector ; in the @xmath3 case ( [ pcdef ] ) , there are two .
this at first puzzling difference is fully explained by expressing both representations as antisymmetric tensors , as in ( [ squarie ] ) and ( [ pblocks ] ) , respectively , and as shown geometrically in figures [ square ] and [ cube ] . in the complex case
, we have shown that the symplectic action ( [ pact ] ) exactly reproduces the freudenthal action ( [ freudx])([qfreud ] ) .
the analogy goes even further . in @xmath159 dimensions
, there is a natural map taking two @xmath78-forms to a @xmath160 matrix .
when acting on @xmath89 , this map takes the form @xmath161 where @xmath162 now denotes the volume element in six dimensions , that is , the completely antisymmetric tensor with @xmath163 .
it is not hard to verify that , in the complex case , ( [ pstarp ] ) is ( a multiple of ) @xmath164 , as given by ( [ pstarp0])([pstarp4 ] ) .
similarly , the quartic invariant ( [ quartic ] ) can be expressed in the complex case as @xmath165 up to an overall factor .
neither the form of the action ( [ pact ] ) , nor the expressions ( [ pstarp ] ) and ( [ quarticc ] ) , hold over @xmath135 or @xmath136 .
this failure should not be a surprise , as trilinear tensor products are not well defined over @xmath135 , let alone @xmath136 .
nonetheless , theorem [ thm ] does tell us how to extend ( [ pact ] ) to the octonions .
although it is also possible to write down versions of ( [ pstarp ] ) and ( [ quarticc ] ) that hold over the octonions , by using case - dependent algorithms to determine the order of multiplication , it is not clear that such expressions have any advantage over the original expressions ( [ pstarp0])([pstarp4 ] ) and ( [ quartic ] ) given by freudenthal . despite these drawbacks ,
it is clear from our construction that @xmath0 should be regarded as a natural generalization of the traditional notion of a symplectic lie algebra , and fully deserves the name @xmath166
we thank john huerta for discussions , and for coining the term `` cubies '' . this work was supported in part by the john templeton foundation . | we explicitly construct a particular real form of the lie algebra @xmath0 in terms of symplectic matrices over the octonions , thus justifying the identifications @xmath1 and , at the group level , @xmath2 . along the way
, we provide a geometric description of the minimal representation of @xmath0 in terms of rank 3 objects called _ cubies_. |
the interaction of intense laser pulses with overdense plasmas has attracted much interest for the fast ignitor concept in inertial fusion energy @xcite .
the interaction of ultrashort intense laser pulses with thin solid targets have also been of great interest for the application to high energy ion sources @xcite .
ultraintense irradiation experiments using an infrared subpicosecond laser , e.g. , nd : glass ( @xmath3 1,053 nm ) or ti : sapphire ( @xmath3800 nm ) lasers , whose powers and focused intensities exceed 100 tw and @xmath4 w/@xmath5 , are possible using chirped pulse amplification techniques @xcite . in these experiments , the classical normalized momentum of electrons @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is the electron mass , @xmath8 is the speed of light , @xmath0 is the laser intensity in w/@xmath5 , and @xmath9 is the wavelength in @xmath10 m . on the other hand ,
a krf laser ( @xmath3 248 nm ) has an advantage as the fast ignitor in that the critical density is close to the core , and hot electron energies are suitable since the critical density of the krf laser is ten times greater than that of an infrared laser @xcite .
the peak intensities of krf laser systems were only the order of @xmath11 w/@xmath5 , namely @xmath12 @xcite .
therefore , the dependence of the laser plasma interactions on the laser wavelength was not investigated in @xmath13 .
recently , the laser absorption and hot electron generation have been studied by the high intensity krf laser system of which focused intensity is greater than @xmath14 w/@xmath5 @xcite .
however , the production of hot electrons by the high intensity krf laser has not been fully understood yet .
namely , it has been not clear that the effects of laser wavelength on hot electrons produced by ultrashort intense laser pulse on solid - density targets .
the absorption , electron energy spectrum , and hot electron temperature have usually been investigated and scaled using the parameters @xmath1 , @xmath15 , and @xmath16 @xcite , where @xmath17 , @xmath18 , and @xmath19 are the electron density , critical density , and density scale length , respectively .
critical density absorption of the laser light converts laser energy into hot electrons having a suprathermal temperature @xmath20 approximately proportional to @xmath21 for @xmath22 , and @xmath23mc^2 $ ] at moderate densities @xcite , where @xmath24 kev , @xmath7 is an electron rest mass .
the scaling of the hot electron temperature has been supported by experiments of nd : glass and ti : sapphire lasers @xcite . on the other hand , the results of one - dimensional simulation for normal incidence in the density region @xmath25 and the normalized intensity @xmath26 have shown that @xmath27 mc^2 $ ] , where @xmath28 is the electromagnetic fields at the surface of the overdense plasma , @xmath29 and @xmath30 , which depend weakly on @xmath1 and @xmath15 @xcite .
@xmath31 is weakly depend on the angle of incidence , absorption rate , and @xmath32@xcite .
the hot electron temperature is scaled by the amplitude of electromagnetic fields at the plasma surface rather than that in vacuum ; namely , the hot electron temperature is slightly dependent on the wavelength .
in addition , at the interaction of intense laser pulses with solid density plasma which has a sharp density gradient the hot electron temperature is scaled by @xmath33 rather than @xmath1 @xcite . in the present paper , we study the absorption of ultrashort intense laser pulses on overdense plasmas for different laser wavelengths ( @xmath2 = 0.25 , 0.5 , and 1 @xmath10 m ) using a particle - in - cell ( pic ) simulation .
in order to investigate hot electron generation for oblique incidence , we use the relativistic 1 and @xmath34 dimensional pic simulation with the boost frame moving with @xmath35 parallel to the target surface , where @xmath8 and @xmath36 are the speed of light and an angle of incidence@xcite . in the simulation ,
the target is the fully ionized plastic and the electron density @xmath37 .
the density correspond to @xmath38 , @xmath39 , and @xmath40 for @xmath3 0.25 , 0.5 , and @xmath41 m , respectively .
the density profile has a sharp density gradient , @xmath42 for @xmath43 and @xmath44 for @xmath45 . in order to clarify the boundary effect ,
ions are fixed , namely , the boundary does not move all the time .
the laser pulse starts at @xmath46 and propagates towards @xmath47 .
the laser intensity rises in 5 fs and remains constant after that .
the irradiated intensity @xmath48 w/@xmath5 and the angle of incidence @xmath49 and @xmath50 ( p - polarized ) , respectively .
@xmath51 2.3 , 9.2 , and 36 for @xmath3 0.25 , 0.5 , and 1.0 @xmath10 m , respectively .
however , @xmath52 for all wavelength .
normalized electron energy distributions after 50 fs are shown in fig.1(a ) and 1(b ) for @xmath49 and @xmath50 , respectively .
the hot electron temperatures are 140 and 340 kev for @xmath49 and @xmath50 , respectively .
the hot electron temperatures does not depend on the laser wavelength .
the result is well agreement with that of a simple sharp boundary theory . on the other hand ,
the absorption depends on the laser wavelength , @xmath53 0.9 - 1.8% , 2.2 - 3.0% , and 3.6 - 4.3% and @xmath54 2.6 - 4.1% , 5.3 - 6.7% , and 7.8 - 9.0% for @xmath3 1.0 , 0.5 , and 0.25 @xmath10 m , respectively .
the effects of laser wavelength on hot electrons produced by ultrashort intense laser pulse on solid - density targets are studied by the use of a pic simulation . as a result ,
the dependence to the wavelength of hot electron temperature strongly depend on the boundary condition , even in the one dimensional case , namely , all are not determined only by @xmath1
. the density profiles of both preformed plasma @xcite and multi - dimensional effects such as surface deformation @xcite are very important in the actual experiments .
99 m. tabak _ et al . _ , phys .
plasmas * 1 * , 1626 ( 1994 ) ; r. kodama _ et al . _ ,
nature * 412 * , 798 ( 2001 ) .
e.takahashi _ et al .
_ , _ proceedings of the third international conference on inertial fusion sciences and applications ( ifsa2003 ) _ , editors : b. a. hammel d. d. meyerhofer j. meyer - ter - vehn h. azechi , p.406 ( american nuclear society , inc . , 2004 ) .
_ , _ proc . of the seventh international symposium of the graduate university for advanced studies on science of super - strong field interactions , hayama , japan , 2002 _ , editors : k. nakajima and m. deguchi , p.290 ( american institute of physics , 2002 ) | hot electron temperatures and electron energy spectra in the course of interaction between intense laser pulse and overdense plasmas are reexamined from a viewpoint of the difference in laser wavelength . the hot electron temperature measured by a particle - in - cell simulation
is scaled by @xmath0 rather than @xmath1 at the interaction with overdense plasmas with fixed ions , where @xmath0 and @xmath2 are the laser intensity and wavelength , respectively . |
pairing correlations play an essential role in the determination of the ground - state structure of the vast majority of atomic nuclei . among its treatments ,
an easy but still enough accurate one is to consider only single - particle states near the fermi level while the effects of the other states are assumed to be absorbed in the strength of an effective pairing interaction .
in such a treatment , our experiences in hartree - fock(hf)+bcs calculations suggest that at least half of a major shell above the fermi level must be considered for meaningful estimations . as a consequence
, one has to explicitly consider positive - energy states if the fermi level of neutrons is higher than the negative of half of the major shell spacing ( @xmath0 mev ) .
this condition applies to about half of the @xmath1 nuclides which exist between proton and neutron drip lines in the nuclear chart , not only to nuclei near the neutron drip line or outside the s - process path .
thus there are plenty of necessities for theoretical frameworks which can describe pairing correlations involving the continuum states .
if the pairing correlation significantly involves the continuum states , the hf+bcs approximation becomes inadequate because the occupation of unbound hf orbitals leads to the unwanted dislocalization of the nucleon density .
this is a serious problem in coordinate - space treatments , which is more favorable to describe loosely bound systems like drip - line nuclei than expansions in harmonic - oscillator eigenstates ( except the transformed oscillator basis of ref .
the reason why a dislocalized solution becomes the variational minimum is that , in order to separate the variational equations into hf and bcs , one has to neglect the effects that the matrix elements of pair - scattering processes are affected by the changes in the wave functions of the orbitals involved @xcite . to fully take into account these effects
leads to the hartree - fock - bogoliubov ( hfb ) equation , with which the density is localized whenever the fermi levels are negative @xcite . the hfb method in the coordinate space
was first formulated using the quasiparticle states and solved for spherically symmetric states in ref . @xcite .
although spherical solutions can be obtained easily with present computers ( for zero - range forces ) , deformed solutions are still difficult to obtain because there are quite a large number of quasiparticle states even for a moderate size of the normalization box ( i.e. , the cavity to confine the nucleons to discretize the positive - energy single - particle states ) . an orthodox approach to face
this difficulty is the two - basis method @xcite , in which the quasiparticle states are expanded in bound and unbound hf orbitals .
this method requires heavy numerical calculations because there are a pile of unbound hf orbitals below an energy cut - off of even only a few mev .
an alternative approach is the canonical - basis hfb method . according to the bloch - messiah theorem @xcite , every hfb solution obtained as the vacuum of a set of bogoliubov quasiparticles has an equivalent expression in terms of a bcs - type wave function .
the single - particle states appearing in this expression are called the hfb canonical basis . in the canonical - basis hfb method ,
one obtains the solution in the canonical form without using the quasiparticle states .
this method appeared originally in ref .
@xcite to obtain spherical solutions .
however , there are no sever difficulties in obtaining hfb solutions for spherical nuclei using any other methods . applications to deformed nuclei have been done by us @xcite using a three - dimensional cartesian mesh representation@xcite . incidentally , a different line of application is also found in literature @xcite .
let us explain the advantage of the canonical - basis method over the two - basis method concerning the treatment of the pairing in the continuum using fig .
[ fig : two_basis_hfb ] . on both sides of the figure , the ordinate represents the expectation value of the mean - field ( hf ) energy , while the abscissa stands for the radius @xmath2 from the center of the nucleus .
@xmath3 and @xmath4 mean a cut - off energy and the fermi level , respectively . on the left - hand side , the wavy horizontal lines stand for energy levels and their spatial extent for the hf potential denoted by a solid curve .
the wave functions of positive energy states extend to the wall of the box and their level density is much larger than that of negative energy states . in the two - basis hfb method
, one has to mix these positive - energy orbitals to construct localized canonical - basis orbitals , which is a numerically demanding task . on the right - hand side ,
the wavy lines represent the hfb canonical - basis orbitals . unlike hf
orbitals , they are spatially localized for both negative and positive energies . because of this localization , the level density is much smaller than the unbound hf orbitals .
therefore , one needs much less orbitals .
more specifically , the number of necessary single - particle states to describe the hfb ground state of a nucleus is proportional to the volume of the nucleus in the canonical - basis method while it is related to the volume of the normalization box in the other methods .
incidentally , with the dash curve , we suggest the existence of some potential which binds the high - lying canonical - basis orbitals .
the identity of this potential is unveiled in sec . [
sec : canorb ] . in this paper
we formulate the canonical - basis hfb method on a cubic mesh and develop an efficient gradient method to obtain its solutions . in order to decrease unphysical influences of high - momentum components due to zero - range interactions ,
we introduce a momentum dependent term to the pairing interaction and show how it suppresses a problematic behavior of wave functions peculiar to the canonical - basis hfb method . as a byproduct , we show a clear way to understand the nature of high - lying canonical - basis orbitals .
the contents of this paper is as follows . in sections [ sec : cbhfb ]
[ sec : gradientmethod ] , we give the formulation and general considerations .
discussions using results of numerical calculations are collected in section [ sec : results ] .
conclusions are given in section [ conclusions ] . in appendix
[ sec : meshprec ] we examine the errors due to the mesh representation and the box boundary condition .
appendix [ sec : pointcollapse ] gives a model analysis of the problem peculiar to the method , i.e. , a phenomenon that canonical - basis orbitals collapse to a spatial point once their occupation probabilities fall below some critical value when pure delta - function forces are used .
some of the contents of this paper have already been discussed in our earlier reports @xcite .
for example , ref .
@xcite includes the first report on the canonical - basis hfb method on a cubic mesh .
@xcite reported on the discovery of the point - collapse problem and the tests of the state - dependent cut - off factors and pairing - density - dependent forces as the remedies . in this paper
we have rewritten those contents to include the momentum - dependent interaction and , by including the rewritten contents , organized the formalism for consistency and selfcontainedness .
all the numerical calculations shown in this paper have been performed using the renewed form of the interaction .
incidentally , some important parts of those reports are not repeated in this paper .
the examples are an analysis of the spherical two - basis method concerning the precision of density tails @xcite and numerical demonstrations of the point collapses of high - lying orbitals @xcite .
to begin with , let us formulate hf and hfb methods in the coordinate - space representation in order to elucidate the difficulty of the quasiparticle - based hfb method compared with the hf method and to propose its possible solution in terms of the canonical - basis hfb method .
for the sake of simplicity , we consider only one kind of nucleons in this section .
the number of that kind of nucleons are designated by @xmath5 .
the @xmath6-component of the spin of a nucleon is represented by @xmath7 (= @xmath8 ) . in hf
, one should minimize @xmath9 among all the @xmath5-body single slater - determinant states , @xmath10 by varying @xmath11 under orthonormality conditions @xmath12 = @xmath13 .
the operator @xmath14 creates a nucleon with a wave function @xmath15 .
the ket state @xmath16 stands for the state in which no nucleons exist .
the distribution function of the number density of the nucleons is related to the single - particle wave functions as @xmath17 there is arbitrariness in the selection of @xmath18 as for unitary transformations among them .
@xmath19 are called hf orbitals when they diagonalize the hf hamiltonian . in hfb ,
the solution takes the following form , @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the annihilation operator of a positive - energy bogoliubov quasiparticle with two types of amplitudes @xmath22 and @xmath23 for particle - like and hole - like parts of the excitation .
@xmath24 is the number of the basis states of the representation used and is by far larger than @xmath5 .
one should vary @xmath25 under an orthonormality condition @xmath26 and a constraint on the expectation value of the number of nucleons , @xmath27 where the nucleon density for state ( [ eq : vac_hfbq ] ) is expressed as latexmath:[\[\label{eq : dens_hfbq } \rho ( { \bm{r } } ) = \sum_{i=1}^{n_{\rm b } } \sum_{s } and hfb lies in the number of necessary single - particle wave functions .
it is @xmath5 in the former and @xmath29 in the latter .
obviously , the latter is much larger .
owing to the bloch - messiah theorem @xcite , the state ( [ eq : vac_hfbq ] ) can be transformed ( as for the ordinary ground states of even - even nuclei ) into the following form , @xmath30 where @xmath31 and @xmath32 create a nucleon with wave functions @xmath33 and @xmath34 , respectively , which are called the canonical basis of the hfb vacuum @xmath35 .
they may be called the natural orbitals@xcite instead , because they are the eigenstates of the one - body density matrix . in this paper , we often call them canonical - basis orbitals or canonical orbitals
. it is required @xmath36 for the exact equivalence between eqs .
( [ eq : vac_hfbq ] ) and ( [ eq : vac_cbhfb ] ) to hold in general .
in this paper we assume that @xmath35 is invariant under the time reversal operation . in this case ,
@xmath19 and @xmath37 are the time - reversal state to each other and only one of them has to be considered explicitly in the variational procedure .
the nucleon density can be expressed as @xmath38 in the time - reversal invariant case . in order to obtain solutions expressed in the canonical form without using the information of the quasiparticle states
, one should vary @xmath39 under three kinds of constraints ,
i.e , the orthonormality condition , @xmath40 a condition on the expectation value of the number of nucleons , @xmath41 and the normalization of the @xmath42-@xmath43 factors , @xmath44 .
reinhard _ et al .
_ wrote that the advantage of the representation ( [ eq : vac_cbhfb ] ) over ( [ eq : vac_hfbq ] ) is that one has to consider only a single set of wave functions @xmath18 , not a double set @xmath45 @xcite . in our opinion , however , one may expect much greater benefit from the canonical - basis representation .
namely , @xmath46 may be truncated as @xmath47 = @xmath48 @xmath49 @xmath50 to a very good approximation .
the reason is the localization of the density .
the density distribution of hfb solutions can be shown to behave asymptotically for large @xmath2 as @xmath51 as far as the fermi level @xmath52 is negative @xcite , where @xmath53 is the nucleon mass .
consequently , @xmath19 appearing on the right - hand side of eq .
( [ eq : dens_cbhfb ] ) must be a localized function as @xmath54 on the left - hand side .
on the other hand , the orthogonality relation ( [ eq : ortho_cbhfb ] ) restricts the number of wave functions which can exist in the vicinity of the nucleus .
therefore the number of canonical orbitals can not be very large . in mesh representations , @xmath24 is proportional to the volume of the box while @xmath55 is proportional to the volume of the nucleus .
the latter is @xmath56 times as small as the former in typical calculations .
situation is quite different in the quasiparticle formalism : the number of quasiparticle states is proportional to the volume of the box .
this is because the localization of the density demands only that of @xmath57 through eq .
( [ eq : dens_hfbq ] ) while @xmath58 does not have to be localized in general .
the orthogonality condition ( [ eq : norm_qp ] ) involves both @xmath57 and @xmath58 .
this enables many quasiparticle states having similar @xmath57 to be orthogonal to each other by differing their @xmath58 .
in this paper , we employ the skyrme interaction @xcite , which is a density- and momentum - dependent zero - range interaction : @xmath59 where @xmath60 is the spin exchange operator , @xmath61 with @xmath62 and @xmath63 the position vectors of the interacting two nucleons , @xmath64 is the nucleon density at @xmath62 ( @xmath65 ) , and @xmath66 @xmath67 is the relative momentum between the two nucleons . since it is hermitian under the box ( vanishing and periodic ) boundary conditions , we have not specified in which way ( to bra or ket states ) it operates in eq .
( [ eq : mf_int ] ) unlike in , e.g. , ref .
zero - rangeness makes the mean - field potentials local , which is an essential advantage for coordinate - space solutions . among the terms of the skyrme force , those with strength parameters @xmath68 , @xmath69 , and @xmath70
act only on s - wave relative motions .
the term with @xmath69 serves to take into account the effects of the finite - rangeness in terms of the lowest order momentum dependence , while the term with @xmath70 expresses a density dependence . the term with strength @xmath71 acts on relative p - wave states through a different form of momentum dependence .
note that the isospin channel ( @xmath72=0 or 1 ) is uniquely determined through the requirement of the two - body antisymmetry .
owing to the p - wave as well as the s - wave interaction terms , the skyrme force can act on all the four kinds of spin - isospin channels .
the complete skyrme interaction includes a spin - orbit term @xmath73 , which we have excluded from eq .
( [ eq : mf_int ] ) .
this elimination decreases the size of the numerical calculations by a factor of four ( two from spin up and down components , another two from real and imaginary parts of the spatial wave function ) . due to this size reduction
, we can perform very severe tests of the canonical - basis hfb method by , e.g. , taking into account unusually many canonical orbitals or expressing wave functions on a very large mesh . as the parameters of the force
, we choose the siii set @xcite except for the spin - orbit term , i.e. , @xmath68 = @xmath74 mev @xmath75 , @xmath70 = @xmath76 mev @xmath77 , @xmath78 , and @xmath79 . as for the parameters appearing in the momentum dependent terms , the following two combinations are sufficient to treat @xmath80 even - even nuclei , @xmath81 whose values are @xmath82 = 44.375 mev @xmath83 and @xmath84 = @xmath85 mev @xmath83 .
as is usually done , we employ different parameters between the mean - field and the pairing interactions .
we use the following interaction for the pairing channel , @xmath86 , \label{eq : pair_int } \ ] ] where @xmath87 is the strength and @xmath88 is the projector into spin - singlet states .
terms in the braces represent dependences on particle and pairing densities .
the interaction becomes repulsive where @xmath89 or @xmath90 .
for the particle - density dependence , we use @xmath91 = 0.32 @xmath92 to vanish the volume - changing effect@xcite ( this choice , twice of the matter density , is also recommended for a different reason @xcite . )
the dependence on the pairing density @xmath93 ( to be defined by eq .
( [ eq : pairingdensity ] ) ) has been introduced in ref .
@xcite to prevent unphysical behaviors of high - lying canonical orbitals discussed in appendix [ sec : pointcollapse ] .
this term is squared because @xmath93 can become negative in principle . except in appendix
[ sec : pointcollapse ] , we use @xmath94 .
the momentum dependent term acts on s - wave relative motions and quenches interactions between nucleons in high - momentum states .
the interaction vanishes at relative momentum @xmath95 at low - density points .
if @xmath96 , this pairing force is reduced to that introduced in @xcite .
the typical values of the parameters are @xmath97 mev @xmath75 and @xmath95=2 @xmath98 but different values are also used .
the @xmath99=0 and @xmath72=1 part of the skyrme force of eq .
( [ eq : mf_int ] ) may be rewritten as eq .
( [ eq : pair_int ] ) without the pairing density dependent term . using different parameterizations between the two forces
has an advantage of avoiding confusions . when one considers both protons and neutrons , the state of the nucleus is usually assumed to be a product of two bcs - type states of eq .
( [ eq : vac_cbhfb ] ) , one for the protons and the other for the neutrons : @xmath100 where the index q distinguishes between protons ( p ) and neutrons ( n ) .
@xmath101 creates a proton having a wave function @xmath102 while @xmath103 creates a neutron with a wave function @xmath104 .
this product form matches our choice of the pairing interaction of eq .
( [ eq : pair_int ] ) which acts only on @xmath105 pairs . in this paper
we treat only @xmath5=@xmath106 nuclei without coulomb interaction for the sake of simplicity . in this case , the wave functions are the same between protons and neutrons .
moreover , because the potentials are independent of the spin , the wave functions @xmath33 can be factorized into a product of a spin wave function and a real - number function of the position , which we write @xmath107 hereafter . more specifically , we assume @xmath102 = @xmath104 = @xmath108 and @xmath109 = @xmath110 = @xmath111 .
the isoscalar pairing may take over the isovector pairing in @xmath112 nuclei @xcite .
nevertheless , we assume eq .
( [ eq : vac_pn ] ) because the aim of this paper is to examine a method whose most important applications are to the nuclei near the neutron drip line .
our hamiltonian @xmath113 consists of a kinetic energy term and two - body interaction terms .
it should be understood that both are expressed in the second quantized form because hfb states do not have a fixed number of particles .
the kinetic energy term is @xmath114 in the one - body expression , for which we assume the mass of a nucleon @xmath53 to be the average of the proton and the neutron bare masses ( @xmath115 and @xmath116 ) with an approximate correction factor for the center - of - mass motion of a nucleus of mass number @xmath117 : @xmath118 for the interaction terms , we use the interaction ( [ eq : mf_int ] ) for the mean - field type contractions and the interaction ( [ eq : pair_int ] ) for the pairing type contractions in evaluating the matrix elements of the two - body interactions using wick s theorem . the total energy for the state ( [ eq : vac_pn ] ) can be expressed in terms of a single space integral as , @xmath119 where the integrand is given by @xmath120 .
\label{eq : ham_dens } \ ] ] on the right - hand side of the above equation , functions of position @xmath121 are @xmath122 which are called @xcite the ( particle ) density , the kinetic - energy density , the pairing density , and the pairing kinetic - energy density , respectively . there is a set of single - particle operators ( @xmath123 , @xmath124 , and @xmath125 ) which are useful to obtain mean - field solutions . they can be obtained by taking the functional derivative of @xmath126 with respect to a canonical wave function @xmath19 .
this turns out to be equivalent to operating a state - dependent single - particle hamiltonian @xmath123 to the wave function : @xmath127 here , we have taken the familiar point of view that @xmath19 and @xmath128 can be formally regarded as independent variables , although @xmath19 is actually a real function .
one can express @xmath123 , in turn , as a linear combination of state - independent single - particle hamiltonians as , @xmath129 where @xmath124 and @xmath125 are called the mean - field and pairing hamiltonians .
they are given by @xmath130 with @xmath131 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] we call @xmath132 and @xmath133 the mean - field and the pairing potentials , respectively .
when there are no pairing correlations , the mean - field hamiltonian @xmath124 is identical to the hf single - particle hamiltonian . therefore , its expectation value , @xmath134 may be called the single - particle energy of the @xmath46th canonical orbital .
the negative of the expectation value of the pairing hamiltonian , @xmath135 has a meaning of the pairing gap of the orbital .
the pairing gap should be positive or zero .
indeed , @xmath136 could take negative values only if the wave function would consist of very high - momentum components @xcite . a related discussion is given in sec .
[ sec : canorb ] .
the quasiparticle states of eq .
( [ eq : ani_op_qp ] ) are the eigenstates of their own hamiltonian , i.e. , so - called hfb super matrix composed of @xmath124 and @xmath125 : @xmath137 where @xmath52 is the fermi level . in small subspaces like several major shells , the easiest way to obtain an hfb solution is to solve eq .
( [ eq : hfb_matrix ] ) as an eigenvalue problem of a hermitian matrix .
in large spaces like mesh representations , however , it is easier to obtain the canonical orbitals directly , rather than via quasiparticle states .
such a direct method is explained in the next section . incidentally ,
if one considers seriously that @xmath19 is a real function , one may notice that the functional derivative should be doubled since @xmath138 as @xmath139 and @xmath140 .
( [ eq : commentfuncderiv ] ) seems to be a more appropriate expression of what our numerical calculation program actually does .
however , the factor @xmath141 at the beginning of the right - hand side as well as the factor @xmath142 which reflects the spin - isospin degeneracy do not matter because they can be conveniently absorbed into the step - size parameter of the gradient method ( see sec .
[ sec : gradientmethod ] ) .
in this section we discuss on the cut - off schemes for zero - range pairing interactions in relation to the canonical - basis hfb method .
delta function forces without a cut - off lead to a divergence of the strength of the pairing correlation . in order to prevent the divergence ,
one usually takes only those quasiparticles whose excitation energy @xmath143 is lower than some cut - off energy @xmath144 in constructing the ground state @xcite .
namely eq .
( [ eq : vac_hfbq ] ) is modified to @xmath145 where @xmath146 is the heaviside ( step ) function .
in this paper we do not discuss how one should change the strength as a function of @xmath147 for renormalization .
instead , we regard @xmath147 as one of the constants to define the force . in order to implement the cut - off , one should pay attention to the following two peculiarities of the canonical - basis hfb method .
i ) the introduction of @xmath147 causes a serious inconvenience to this method , i.e. , the absence of the quasiparticle hamiltonian . for this reason ,
it is preferable to use the number of canonical orbitals @xmath55 instead of @xmath147 .
ii ) for delta - function pairing interactions , substitution of @xmath147 with @xmath55 leads to a physically meaningless situation , in which canonical orbitals are collapsed to a spatial point ( a point collapse phenomenon , hereafter ) . to overcome this difficulty , we modify the pairing interaction by adding a repulsive momentum - dependent term . in the rest of this section
we discuss these two problems .
\i ) let us explain how the introduction of the cut - off causes the absence of the quasiparticle hamiltonian .
an analogy with the bcs approximation indicates a natural way to introduce an energy cut - off to the canonical - basis method .
namely , the smooth cut - off method@xcite modifies the seniority interaction as @xmath148 where @xmath149 is a function of single - particle energy @xmath150 and takes on @xmath151 well below a chosen cut - off energy and smoothly becomes zero above it .
the smoothness is indispensable to the stability of the solution . in analogy
, we may modify the pairing density as @xmath152 with @xmath153 in eq .
( [ eq : cut_func_k ] ) , we assume a dependence on the kinetic energy ( @xmath154 ) , not on the mean - field energy @xmath150 as in eq .
( [ eq : cut_sen_force ] ) , to avoid a highly complicated expression of the gradient for the latter case .
( in bcs , such complications are simply neglected . )
the gradient is given for @xmath155 by @xmath156 \psi_i .\ ] ] this method works well to prevent the point collapses in numerical tests using @xmath157 fm taken from the gogny force @xcite .
this cut - off scheme has an disadvantage that the hfb super matrix in eq .
( [ eq : hfb_matrix ] ) can not be defined , because in eq .
( [ eq : grad_cutoff ] ) the pairing hamiltonian ( the part proportional to @xmath158 in square brackets ) is dependent on the canonical - orbital index @xmath46 .
this means that there is no common pairing hamiltonian to all the quasiparticles .
consequently one does not have well - defined bogoliubov quasiparticle states and can not utilize them to refine the hfb solution , which is a rather serious drawback as discussed in the next section .
if one can use @xmath55 in place of @xmath147 , however , one can recover a unique quasiparticle hamiltonian .
incidentally , a similar kind of ambiguity arises from the cut - off scheme in terms of the quasiparticle energies according to eq .
( [ eq : vac_hfbq_cut ] ) . in this case
, the canonical orbitals do not have well - defined hamiltonians .
it may not matter , however , because one does not need hamiltonians to define canonical orbitals when they can be obtained by transforming the quasiparticle states .
\ii ) let us discuss the phenomenon of the point collapse . in quasiparticle ( or two - basis )
hfb method , specifying the number of quasiparticle ( hf single - particle ) states to be considered has the same consequences as imposing an energy cut - off because the states to be chosen are anyway the eigenstates of the lowest energies of the quasiparticle ( hf ) hamiltonian .
on the other hand , the canonical - basis hfb method is very peculiar concerning this point .
the canonical orbitals are not the eigenstates of a single operator but each of them has its own hamiltonian @xmath123 as a function of the occupation probability given by eq .
( [ eq : statedependenthamiltonian ] ) .
@xmath123 becomes @xmath124 and @xmath125 in the two extreme situations @xmath159=1 and 0 , respectively .
it is only when one considers a small number of orbitals that all of them are the lowest - energy approximate eigenstates of @xmath124 .
otherwise , some of the orbitals may become the eigenstates of @xmath125 rather than @xmath124 : we show in appendix [ sec : pointcollapse ] that , if the occupation probability of an orbital becomes sufficiently small , it spontaneously decreases the probability further toward zero ( to decrease the total energy of the nucleus ) and change its hamiltonian to @xmath125 .
this occurs when the pairing force is a delta function ( with or without particle - density dependence ) , for which @xmath125 is a local potential and thus its eigenstates are delta functions in the spatial coordinate .
this means that their @xmath160 is infinitely high . on the other hand , the rest of the orbitals
are left in low - energy subspace of @xmath124 .
therefore the restriction on @xmath55 results in utterly different solutions from those obtained by using a cut - off energy explicitly .
this peculiarity of the canonical - basis method is essential to the implementation of the method . in the quasiparticle and the two - basis methods ,
the unphysical divergence of the pairing correlation strength occur only in the limit of @xmath161 ( supposing @xmath55 is used instead of @xmath147 ) . in the canonical - basis method , in addition to this divergence , a different type of unphysical behavior ( the point collapse ) can also happen for @xmath55 fixed at finite numbers .
one has to take special care of the latter problem if one tries to implement the canonical - basis method .
now , if one can suppress the point collapse , one is allowed to use @xmath55 as the control parameter of the cut - off energy .
appendix [ sec : pointcollapse ] shows that this can be achieved , e.g. , by introducing a sufficiently strong repulsive momentum dependence to the delta - function pairing interaction . with this term applied to finite ( small or large ) numbers of canonical orbitals , unphysical situations including the point collapse never happen .
( if it is applied to infinite number of orbitals , not the point collapse but the divergence occurs @xcite . ) in this paper we employ this momentum - dependent force .
in addition to the role to enable a cut - off in terms of @xmath55 , equally important is the byproduct that it also clarifies the nature of high - lying canonical orbitals by providing a kinetic energy term to the pairing hamiltonian @xmath125 .
further explanations using a numerical example are given in sec .
[ sec : canorb ]
. incidentally , appendix [ sec : pointcollapse ] also gives a discussion on an alternative way in terms of a pairing - density dependent force to enable cut - off in terms of @xmath55 . before ending this section ,
we mention the prospect about the renormalization of the pairing force strength . considering the recent quantitative success of the regularization method of delta - function forces based on the thomas - fermi approximation @xcite
, we think it is worth trying in the canonical - basis method in future .
however , it will require a special treatment .
the thomas - fermi approximation makes the interaction strength a decreasing function of the particle density .
one might expect this modification of the interaction would hinder the point collapse .
actually , dependences on particle density can not prevent it because the collapse makes only the pairing density divergent but leaves the particle density unchanged ( because @xmath162 and @xmath163 as shown in appendix [ sec : pointcollapse ] ) .
therefore one has to keep the momentum - dependent term .
this will lead to a modification of the regularization procedure .
we explain in this section the details of a procedure to obtain the canonical - basis solution of the hfb equation directly , not by way of quasiparticle states .
what should be done is to minimize @xmath126 of eq .
( [ eq : tot_eng ] ) under constraints of eqs .
( [ eq : ortho_cbhfb ] ) and ( [ eq : num_cbhfb ] ) .
equivalently , one may introduce a routhian , @xmath164 and minimize it without constraints .
@xmath4 is probably the most familiar lagrange multiplier , whose physical meaning is the fermi level . in the definition ( [ eq : routhian ] ) , @xmath165 lagrange multipliers @xmath166 obeying hermiticity , @xmath167 are introduced instead of @xmath168 independent multipliers . the hermiticity ensures the equality between the number of constraints and the number of independent multipliers .
moreover , it makes @xmath169 real so that two conditions , @xmath170 and @xmath171 , become equivalent and thus one has to consider only one of them .
note that @xmath13 is subtracted from @xmath12 , in contrast to ref .
this subtraction is necessary to treat @xmath166 not as constants like @xmath4 but as functionals of the wave functions . the stationary condition of @xmath169 results in two kinds of equations .
one is @xmath172 , which concerns the occupation amplitudes @xmath173 and is fulfilled by @xcite @xmath174 among the double sign , the minus sign corresponds to the minimum . the relative sign between @xmath173 and @xmath175
= @xmath176 should be plus , i.e. , @xmath177 ( unless @xmath178 ) . the stationary condition for a wave function @xmath107 leads to the following equation : @xmath179 owing to the state dependence of @xmath123 , the orthogonality condition becomes nontrivial to fulfill .
in hf , the orthogonality is automatically satisfied because @xmath19 are eigenstates of the same hermite operator @xmath124 , which are orthogonal to one another .
the orthogonalization procedure is needed only because of the instability for decaying into pauli - forbidden configurations . on the other hand , in the canonical - basis hfb method , the orthogonalization is indispensable and the explicit functional form of @xmath166 is the most important secret of the method .
reinhard _ et al .
_ have proposed @xcite @xmath180 let us give our reasoning on how the above form can be deduced .
this consideration plays the crucial role in order to modify the form for the sake of a faster convergence .
the requirement that eq .
( [ eq : gradient ] ) must hold at the solution ( where @xmath181 ) means , @xmath182 by taking the overlap with @xmath183 , one obtains , @xmath184 eqs .
( [ eq : lambda1 ] ) and ( [ eq : lambda2 ] ) are equivalent at the solution because @xmath166 is defined to be hermite by eq .
( [ eq : hermiticity ] ) .
however , one should employ eq .
( [ eq : lambda1 ] ) rather than eq .
( [ eq : lambda2 ] ) because the former , but not the latter , is hermite at points other than the solution .
one can utilize the gradient method to obtain the hfb solutions in the canonical - basis formalism .
let us describe this method briefly : small variations in @xmath19 and @xmath128 change the routhian as , @xmath185 which indicates the steepest descent direction to be , @xmath186 one takes a small distance movement toward this direction , i.e. , @xmath187 with @xmath188 by repeating the evaluation of @xmath189 and the movement , one eventually reaches the minimum of @xmath169 .
incidentally , in the braces on the right - hand side , the term including @xmath190 in the second member of eqs .
( [ eq : gradient ] ) is dropped because we know empirically that the orthogonality is stable without this term . in eq .
( [ eq : gradstep ] ) , @xmath191 is a parameter introduced to control the size of a movement .
one should regard that the prefactors on the right - hand side of eq .
( [ eq : commentfuncderiv ] ) are included in this parameter .
one may call @xmath191 the imaginary - time - step size because the first order approximation in @xmath191 of the imaginary - time evolution method @xcite becomes essentially the same procedure as the gradient method : @xmath192 in order to justify the negligence of the higher - order terms in eq .
( [ eq : imag_evo ] ) , it must hold@xcite @xmath193 where @xmath194 is the maximum kinetic energy ( used as the upper bound of the single - particle energy ) .
for the cartesian mesh representation with a mesh spacing @xmath195 , @xmath196 where @xmath197 is given by eq .
( [ eq : mf_b ] ) . by choosing @xmath64 between @xmath198 ( free space ) and @xmath64=0.16 @xmath92 ( nuclear matter density ) ,
one obtains @xmath194 = 1254 mev for the siii force with @xmath199 @xmath98 . for the calculations shown in this paper , we have used @xmath200 ,
i.e. , @xmath201 sec .
kinetic energy also arises from the pairing hamiltonian @xmath125 . however , an estimation by replacing @xmath197 of eq .
( [ eq : ekinmax ] ) with @xmath202 of eq .
( [ eq : pair_b ] ) results in an order of magnitude smaller value .
what is presented above may be called a nave version of the gradient method .
the convergence to the hfb solution turns out to be very slow with this nave method .
a numerical example will be given in sec .
[ sec : conv ] .
the origin of this slowness can be traced back to the factor @xmath158 in @xmath123 , which is just a linear combination of @xmath124 and @xmath125 with coefficients @xmath159 and @xmath203 .
the effects of @xmath123 can be very weak for canonical orbitals having small @xmath173 , which leads to the smallness of their changes in a gradient - method step . now , steepest - descent paths depend on the choice of the variables . for example , eq . ( [ eq : gradstep ] )
is obtained when one uses @xmath19 as the variables .
if one uses norm - resized wave functions @xmath204 , where @xmath205 is a scaling factor , a gradient - method step becomes @xmath206 , which is equivalent to @xmath207 thus the path is changed . by choosing @xmath205 to cancel the small factors in @xmath123 , one can accelerate the otherwise slow convergence , which we call the accelerated gradient method . in this paper ,
we take @xmath208 where the factor @xmath209 may be chosen empirically to maximize the speed of convergence .
we choose @xmath210 .
this factor seems to take care of the fact that @xmath125 is smaller than @xmath124 by an order of magnitude . with this choice for the scaling factor , @xmath211 for deeply bound orbitals and @xmath212 for high - lying orbitals .
thus , all the orbitals evolve at roughly the same pace . incidentally , by using the approximate equality symbol in eq .
( [ eq : alphai ] ) , we mean the utilization of some common recipes for numerical calculations like taking a moving average and restricting on the maximum values .
it should be noticed here that one should also modify the form of multipliers @xmath166 when one introduces the acceleration factors @xmath213 . in principle one
may reach the solution by using eq .
( [ eq : lambda1 ] ) because transformations of variables do not change the location of the minimum of @xmath169 .
nevertheless , one should modify eq .
( [ eq : lambda1 ] ) for a practical reason . in calculating the gradient vector
whose exact form is given by the second member of eqs .
( [ eq : gradient ] ) , the last term takes much more computing time than the first two terms due to @xmath214 .
one can drop the last term if the orthogonality relation ( [ eq : ortho_cbhfb ] ) is fulfilled along the path of the evolution . let s suppose that the relation is satisfied before a gradient - method step is taken and require that it is conserved without the dropped term to the first order in @xmath191 after the step , i.e. , @xmath215 with @xmath216 and @xmath217 given by eq .
( [ eq : grad_psi ] ) . substituting @xmath19 and @xmath218 in eq .
( [ eq : orthog_path ] ) and requiring the hermiticity ( [ eq : hermiticity ] ) result in @xmath219 ) , fulfills the requirement that it should agree with the expression ( [ eq : lambda2 ] ) at the solution .
the original form differs from the new form , however , before reaching the solution if @xmath220 .
consequently , only the new form conserves the orthogonality during the course of the evolution .
we have indeed suffered from large errors of orthogonality by using the original form . on the other hand , by using the new form , we have observed that the error does not grow but decreases without performing explicit orthogonalizations .
the reason for this stability will probably be found in the second order terms in @xmath191 neglected in eq .
( [ eq : orthog_path ] ) .
there is an auxiliary method to speedup the convergence .
it is to diagonalize the hfb super matrix given by eq .
( [ eq : hfb_matrix ] ) in the subspace spanned by @xmath55 canonical orbitals .
then one obtains @xmath55 quasiparticle states with positive energy , whose two - component wave functions defined in eq .
( [ eq : ani_op_qp ] ) are expressed as , @xmath221 where @xmath222 is the @xmath46th normalized eigenvector of eq .
( [ eq : hfb_matrix ] ) .
the hfb ground state is constructed as the vacuum of these quasiparticles as in eq .
( [ eq : vac_hfbq ] ) . by diagonalizing the one - body density matrix of this vacuum in this subspace , @xmath223 ,
one obtains a renewed set of canonical orbitals as the eigenvectors and @xmath159 as the eigenvalues .
if the initial set of canonical orbitals are taken from the exact solution , the renewed and the initial sets are identical . however
, if the initial set is taken before the state converges to the solution , the renewed set corresponds to a better solution than the initial set .
it is because the above procedure gives the exact variational minimum @xcite in the subspace spanned by the initial canonical orbitals .
the gradient - step method takes care of both the variation inside this subspace and the optimization of the subspace itself .
the diagonalization performs only the former part but perfectly in a single step .
this diagonalization method is not indispensable but useful to obtain the solutions .
it makes the convergence more robust and somewhat quicker if it is performed after every @xmath224100 gradient - method steps .
its effect seems to saturate with this interval since using shorter periods does not lead to noticeable improvements .
a numerical example is given in sec .
[ sec : conv ] .
incidentally , the idea of this diagonalization method originates in the two - basis formalism of hfb @xcite , in which the quasiparticle hamiltonian is diagonalized in the subspace spanned by low - lying hf orbitals ( eigenstates of @xmath124 ) , not the canonical orbitals as in this paper .
the relation between these quasiparticles and the true quasiparticles defined in the full space is discussed in sec .
[ sec : cbqp ] .
in this section , we show the results of numerical calculations using a newly developed computer program @xcite of the canonical - basis hfb method in a three - dimensional cartesian mesh representation .
the parameters of the model are as follows : for the mean - field interaction , skyrme siii force is employed but its spin - orbit term and the coulomb force are not included . for the pairing interaction , @xmath225 @xmath92 and @xmath226 are used .
the value of @xmath87 is changed depending on @xmath95 (= 1.7 5 @xmath98 ) and @xmath55 (= 14 210 ) to make the average pairing gap to be 2 2.5 mev . unless the values are specified ,
@xmath95=2 @xmath98 , @xmath227 mev @xmath75 , and @xmath228 are used . with @xmath228 ,
the number of orbitals amounts to three times as large as the number of the nucleons , since each orbital can be occupied by four nucleons due to the spin - isospin degeneracy .
the calculated state is the axially symmetric prolate solution of @xmath229si@xmath230 .
the single - particle wave functions are expressed on a cartesian mesh having ( in the default set up ) @xmath231 mesh points with mesh spacing @xmath195=0.8 fm .
as the boundary condition , we assume a cubic box whose infinitely high walls are located at the 0th and the 30th mesh points .
the center of mass of the nucleus is placed at the center of the box .
the 17-point formulae @xcite are employed to calculate the first and second derivatives . in applying these formulae ,
wave functions are assumed to be antisymmetrically extended beyond the walls .
spatial integrals are done using the mid - point ( = trapezoidal ) rule . in fig .
[ fig : conv ] , examples of the convergence curves are shown for several versions of the gradient method .
the calculations are done using the default parameters .
the initial wave functions of the canonical orbitals are taken from the eigenstates of the standard harmonic oscillator potential with a quadruple deformation of @xmath232 and @xmath233 .
the @xmath234 symmetry is conserved to a very good accuracy during the course of the gradient - method evolutions . for the size of an imaginary time step , we use @xmath200 , defined by eq .
( [ eq : delta_tau ] ) , for all the curves .
this value of @xmath235 roughly optimizes the convergence speed for the fastest method . for slower methods
, @xmath235 may be slightly larger but such a small change does not affect our discussions below . in connection with the step size , we also adopt a recipe from the hf+bcs method of ref .
@xcite , according to which the changes of @xmath124 and @xmath125 after each gradient - method step should be further damped compared with the changes of @xmath19 ( by a factor of 0.4 in our case ) .
it is a precaution against occasional instabilities like oscillating behaviors .
this additional damping does not affect our conclusion on the comparison of the methods , either .
si . see text for explanations .
, width=8 ] the top portion of fig .
[ fig : conv ] shows the total energy @xmath126 of eq .
( [ eq : tot_eng ] ) .
the middle portion shows the maximum over @xmath236 of the error of the second equality of eqs .
( [ eq : gradient ] ) ( neglecting the contribution from the error of orthogonality ) , @xmath237 which is an indicator of the accuracy of hfb solutions . as for hf
, this quantity is reduced to the maximum over @xmath238 of @xmath239 which is just the energy width of @xmath240 for @xmath124 .
the bottom portion shows the mass quadrupole deformation parameter @xmath241 defined as the general definition @xcite times @xmath242 disregarding nucleon form factors .
hf result for @xmath241 , converging to 0.44 , is omitted .
the abscissae are common to all the portions and designate the number of gradient - method steps .
thin solid lines in all the three portions are the result of the nave ( i.e. , with @xmath243 ) gradient method .
these curves demonstrate that one can indeed obtain an hfb solution with the canonical - basis hfb method on a mesh , because after a million steps , @xmath126 and @xmath241 appear to reach a plateau and @xmath244 becomes as small as 0.1 kev . we have also obtained similar convergence curves for other quantities like the axial asymmetry @xmath245 and the r.m.s
. radius .
there is a serious problem , however , of the obvious slowness of the convergence .
dot curves show the convergence to an hf solution with pairing interactions turned off .
( with `` w / d '' in the legend in the top portion of the figure we mean that diagonalization of @xmath124 is done in the subspace of occupied @xmath246 hf orbitals to renew the orbitals after every 100 gradient - method steps . without this diagonalization ,
@xmath19 are not hf orbitals and do not satisfy @xmath247 .
this diagonalization also makes the convergence somewhat quicker . )
one can see that the hf energy reaches a plateau by three orders of magnitude faster than the nave hfb method . in the middle portion , while hf can achieve precision of 0.1 kev with only 1400 steps , hfb requires 55000 steps for 10 kev , @xmath248 steps for 1 kev , and @xmath249 steps for 0.1 kev precisions .
a method to improve the convergence speed is the diagonalization of the hfb super matrix in the subspace spanned by @xmath55 canonical orbitals .
dot - dash curves are obtained by performing this diagonalization after every 100 steps .
one can see that the convergence speed is improved by an order of magnitude . however , this progress is not satisfactory yet compared with the hf curve .
dash curves uses the accelerated gradient method ( i.e. , @xmath213 , expressed as `` w / a '' in the legend ) , which brings about a speedup by two orders of magnitude .
a comparison with dot - dash curves suggests that the variation of the canonical - basis subspace itself is a more important factor than a minimization inside the subspace .
using both the diagonalization and the acceleration methods leads to thick solid curves ( expressed as `` w / a , d '' in the legend ) .
steep changes in every 100 steps are due to the diagonalizations .
one can see that these curves converge almost as quickly as the dot curves of the hf method .
these results demonstrate that canonical - basis hfb can be solved without very heavy numerical computations by adopting the two improvements described above .
in this subsection , we use fig . [
fig : canorb ] to discuss the properties of the canonical orbitals in connection with the mean - field and the pairing hamiltonians .
an analysis using these two hamiltonians leads to a comprehensive understanding of the nature of high- as well as low - lying canonical orbitals .
the calculation has been done for @xmath250si with @xmath251 canonical orbitals , which is 30 times as many as the number of the orbitals below the fermi level . for the combination of this @xmath55 and @xmath252 @xmath98 ,
we have adjusted the strength of the pairing force to be @xmath253 mev so that the average pairing gap have a reasonable size , 2.0 mev . the result shown in fig .
[ fig : canorb ] has been obtained after @xmath254 gradient - method steps : because of the slow convergence of very high - lying orbitals ( even using the accelerated method ) , we continued the gradient - method evolution until no changes are going on in any of @xmath150 .
the last change took place during @xmath255th to @xmath256th steps , in which two orbitals gradually increased their energies from @xmath257 mev to @xmath258 mev . during this change
@xmath244 increased slightly up to @xmath259 mev . in the last @xmath260 steps there were no changes and @xmath244
was decreased to @xmath261 mev .
the top - left panel shows the logarithm of the occupation probability @xmath159 .
the abscissa ( common to all the four panels in the left column ) is the label @xmath46 of canonical orbitals , which are sorted in the descending order of @xmath159 .
first seven orbitals have occupation probabilities close to unity . above them ,
the decrease of the probability looks rather steady .
it is in fact a result of a mixing of several sequences : the top - right panel plots the same @xmath159 data versus @xmath150 ( only @xmath262 part is shown ) , in which one can see three sequences .
let us denote the number of the oscillator quanta by @xmath263 .
we have confirmed that the top sequence corresponds to @xmath264 subshells ( @xmath265 are completely seen in @xmath266 region ) . the lower bunch of dots are for @xmath267 . for @xmath268 mev ,
@xmath269 sequence is bifurcated from @xmath270 sequences .
these observations indicate that the canonical orbitals have the same shell structure as that of the harmonic oscillator at least up to several tens of mev .
then , a question arises what generates this shell structure .
the second and third top portions give clues to answer this question .
the panels in the second top row show the mean - field hamiltonian @xmath124 and its expectation value and width for each canonical orbital . in the right panel , the mass term @xmath271 and the potential term @xmath132 of @xmath124 are plotted as functions of the distance from the center of the nucleus .
their profiles in the symmetry ( @xmath6 ) axis as well as those in the equatorial ( @xmath272 ) plane are shown . in the left panel , mean - field energy of each canonical
orbital is designated using a dot and a vertical line .
the dot corresponds to the expectation value @xmath150 while the vertical line connects between @xmath273 with @xmath274 one can see that first seven orbitals , which are below the fermi level , have very narrow widths ( 30 760 kev ) : they are approximate eigenstates of @xmath124 , i.e. , the ( occupied ) hf orbitals . above the fermi level , the width becomes larger with increasing expectation value and thus the wave functions of canonical orbitals begin to diverge from those of ( unoccupied ) hf orbitals . at the crossing point from negative to positive @xmath150 , there seems to be only a smooth continuation of this trend .
this is an essential difference between the hfb canonical and the hf orbitals . concerning the hf orbitals ,
@xmath150 may be estimated in the thomas - fermi approximation , where the number of levels of @xmath124 below @xmath275 is given as , @xmath276 the widths of hf orbitals are always zero .
the solid curve designates the function @xmath277 .
it is owing to the finite volume of the normalization box that @xmath278 is not infinite for positive @xmath275 .
one can see a distinct difference between this curve for the hf orbitals and the dots for the hfb canonical orbitals : the level density is by far sparser in the latter .
( it is indeed the reason to use canonical orbitals as discussed in sec .
[ sec : cbhfb ] . )
it seems difficult to relate the level structure of canonical orbitals to @xmath124 .
incidentally , one can see a bifurcation of the sequence of the dots ( @xmath46 , @xmath150 ) at @xmath279 .
its origin is the subshell structure : upper sequence corresponds to high - angular momentum ( @xmath280 ) subshells while the lower one to @xmath267 subshells .
the third panels from the top show similar graphs to the second top panels but for the pairing hamiltonian @xmath125 . in the right panel
, attention should be paid to the scale of the ordinate , which is smaller by an oder of magnitude than that for @xmath124 .
it is because the expectation value of @xmath125 is nothing but the negative pairing gap ( i.e. , @xmath281 ) and thus its size is only a few mev . in the left panel ,
dots are plotted at @xmath282 and vertical lines connect between @xmath283 , where @xmath284 one can see an opposite trend of the width between @xmath124 and @xmath125 : in the former ( latter ) , the width is smaller for lower ( higher ) expectation values .
it suggests a view that high - lying canonical orbitals are closely related to @xmath125 .
this can be understood in terms of the state dependent hamiltonian , @xmath285 . because of this form , it is close to @xmath124 ( @xmath125 ) for deeply bound ( highly excited ) canonical orbitals .
the solid curve designates the thomas - fermi estimation of @xmath286 , the number of levels of @xmath125 below @xmath287 .
@xmath288 can be obtained by replacing @xmath289 with @xmath290 , respectively , in eq .
( [ eq : thomas_fermi ] ) .
one can see that this curve agrees quite well with the dots .
( sorting the orbitals more appropriately in the ascending order of @xmath282 makes the agreement better . )
it supports the view that @xmath125 roughly determines the level structure of canonical orbitals .
it also guarantees that the application of the thomas - fermi approximation to @xmath125 provides a rather precise method to count the number of canonical orbitals .
one can see another difference between @xmath124 and @xmath125 that @xmath150 becomes positive for @xmath291 while @xmath282 is still negative at @xmath292 .
it means that @xmath125 has by far more number of bound states than @xmath124 .
its origins in the thomas - fermi approximation are the larger ratio @xmath293 than @xmath294 inside the nucleus and the vanishing behavior of @xmath295 as @xmath296 .
it is an interesting question whether there are finite or infinite number of canonical orbitals with @xmath297 .
non - zero occupation probability means @xmath298 and thus @xmath299
. therefore one has to count the number of orbitals with negative @xmath287 . to give a thomas - fermi estimation of this number ,
let us suppose the form of density tails to be , @xmath300 for the kinetic - energy density inside the nucleus , a reasonable estimation is @xmath301 , where @xmath302 is the fermi momentum . using a relation @xmath303 and assuming @xmath304 appropriate in the peripheral region , one can show that @xmath305 is independent of @xmath2 .
consequently , the number of orbitals becomes proportional to the volume of the integral region @xmath306 .
the explicit form of the result is @xmath307 therefore , the number of non - zero - occupation canonical orbitals is infinite .
the bottom panels show the radial distributions of the nucleon density ( right panel ) and that of each canonical orbital ( left panel ) .
the former is shown in two directions while the latter is integrated over the angles as , @xmath308 and thus normalized as @xmath309 .
vertical lines are drawn in the interval of @xmath2 where @xmath310 @xmath98 .
the width of the lines are proportional to @xmath311 , except that the width is saturated at 0.8 ( in the scale of the abscissa ) for @xmath312 @xmath98 .
one can see that the canonical orbitals are localized in the neighborhood of the nucleus and only gradually shifted outward with increasing @xmath46 .
it is not due to the finite box size because even the 210th orbital is located far from the boundary , which is at 12 to 12@xmath313 fm .
the location of the maximum of @xmath311 agrees fairly well with the classical turning point of @xmath133 for energy @xmath282 ( as seen in the third top panel in the right column ) .
this vindicates the view that @xmath125 determines the spatial extent of high - lying canonical orbitals .
let us give another fact to confirm this view .
evaluating eq.([eq : gammazero ] ) using @xmath252 @xmath98 , @xmath314 @xmath98 ( see next subsection ) , and @xmath315 @xmath98 , one obtains @xmath316 = 0.14 @xmath92 . for @xmath317 ,
the value of @xmath306 becomes equal to the volume of a sphere of radius 7.1 fm .
this roughly agrees with the fact that the 210th orbital has the maximum density at @xmath318 fm .
the discussions of this subsection can be summarized into three points : i ) canonical orbitals well below the fermi level are localized by the mean - field potential .
ii ) highly excited canonical orbitals are localized by the pairing potential .
iii ) the pairing hamiltonian can have infinite number of localized orbitals due to the vanishing mass term at large radii .
it should be noted here that we do not insist that @xmath125 alone determines high - lying orbitals to the details .
one has to keep in mind an asymmetry between low- and high - lying orbitals . because lower - lying orbitals have much stronger influences on the total energy of the nucleus , the determinations of their wave functions are hardly affected by the orthogonality conditions with the higher - lying orbitals .
however , the opposite is not true : high - lying orbitals must be orthogonal to the orbitals below the fermi level , which are determined mainly by @xmath124 .
consequently , although the most essential points can be explained by the idea of the change of the hamiltonian from @xmath124 to @xmath125 , there may still remain something delicate in the treatments of high - lying canonical orbitals compared with those of low - lying ones .
wave functions of bound states have an asymptotic form for large radii of @xmath319 in hf , negative energy orbitals have the form ( [ eq : psi_ir ] ) with @xmath320 determined by @xmath150 as @xmath321 . in hfb , the hole component of quasiparticle wave functions ( @xmath322 ) has this form with @xmath323 determined by the excitation energy @xmath324 as @xmath325 @xcite . as for the canonical orbitals of hfb , however
, one can not relate @xmath320 to any sort of energies in a simple manner due to the complex influences of the requirement of orthogonality , which is rooted in the lack of a common hamiltonian to all the orbitals .
the only possible statement is that it is not larger than the smallest value of @xmath323 for quasiparticles , whose lower bound is given by the fermi level as in eq .
( [ eq : density_tail ] ) . in this subsection
, we compute @xmath320 of canonical orbitals numerically using angle - averaged density : @xmath326 . in order to see the behaviors at large radii
, we have used a large box containing @xmath327 mesh points .
the edge of the box is @xmath328=46.4 fm .
the nearest walls from the center of the nucleus is at a distance of 23.2 fm and the farthest ( i.e. , the corners ) at 40.2 fm . for the sake of using the large box , we restrict the number of orbitals to @xmath228 , for which an adequate strength of the pairing interaction is @xmath227 mev .
figure [ fig : wf_tail ] shows @xmath329 of canonical orbitals , all of which have exponentially damping tails .
this result demonstrates that the canonical - basis hfb method can convert gaussian tails of initial wave functions , for which we use eigenstates of a harmonic oscillator , into the correct exponential form .
it is evident that the first orbital changes its slope at around @xmath330 fm . by looking at the other curves minutely
, one can also find such changes in several other orbitals .
therefore , we give two discussions , first on the behaviors near the nucleus and second on those far away .
figure [ fig : wf_kappa ] shows @xmath320 as a function of @xmath150 .
open circles denote @xmath320 determined by the logarithmic derivative of @xmath331 near the nucleus ( @xmath332 fm ) .
one can see less than 21 circles because several pairs of circles overlap exactly due to the degeneracy for the sign of @xmath333 ( @xmath6-component of the orbital angular momentum ) .
the dash and dot curves represent functions @xmath334 , and @xmath335 , respectively .
the open circles seem to agree fairly well with a function @xmath336 which coincides with the dash curve for @xmath337 and the dot curve for @xmath338 . by noting that the dash curve expresses @xmath323 for bound hf orbitals
, one may understand the @xmath337 part of eq .
( [ eq : kappa_i ] ) as indicating that canonical orbitals below the fermi level have approximately the same tails as hf orbitals .
an alternative interpretation is also possible which refers to the full domain of eq .
( [ eq : kappa_i ] ) : canonical orbitals with @xmath150 = @xmath339 have the same @xmath323 as the hole component @xmath322 of a quasiparticle state with @xmath340 .
it may suggest that canonical orbitals below ( above ) the fermi level are related to the hole components of hole - like ( particle - like ) quasiparticle excitations .
however , in order to confirm it , we need quasiparticle states in the full space , which are outside the scope of this paper .
cross symbols plotted in fig .
[ fig : wf_kappa ] are @xmath320 calculated at a farther radius ( @xmath341 fm ) . in this case , concerning the deepest and highest orbitals , @xmath323 drops toward the minimum value at @xmath342 .
this may be ascribed to the fact that the canonical orbitals are constructed by mixing up the hole part of all the quasiparticle states and thus the component having smallest @xmath323 dominates in all the canonical orbitals at large radii .
probably , all the canonical orbitals have the same @xmath323 ( @xmath343 where @xmath344 is the smallest quasiparticle energy ) at sufficiently large radii .
let us discuss on the quasiparticle states defined by eq .
( [ eq : hfb_matrix ] ) in the subspace spanned by @xmath55 canonical orbitals .
these quasiparticles and the true quasiparticles defined in the full space are quite different .
the former are only a set of tools for the minimization in a small subspace , while the latter have physical information on the excitation modes of the nucleus .
the width @xmath345 ( in the full space ) of the excitation energy @xmath143 of the @xmath46th quasiparticle ( in the subspace ) is given by @xmath346 @xmath347 where the operation of @xmath124 and @xmath125 should be evaluated in the full space ( i.e. , in the mesh representation ) , not in the @xmath55-dimensional subspace .
quasiparticles can be characterized by the norms of the particle and hole components as well as by the excitation energy .
these norms are defined as @xmath348 for the particle and hole components , respectively .
they are normalized as @xmath349 according to eq .
( [ eq : norm_qp ] ) .
quasiparticle states are called to be particle - like ( hole - like ) if @xmath350 ( @xmath351 ) @xmath352 .
figure [ fig : cbqpe ] shows @xmath324 and @xmath353 for @xmath251 ( with @xmath253 mev @xmath75 ) .
one can see that hole - like quasiparticles have very small widths .
even the deepest hole state ( 1s ) has a relatively small width ( 1.7 mev ) . on the other hand ,
the widths of particle - like quasiparticles amount to a few tens of mev : they are very different from the true quasiparticles defined in the full space . for the sake of comparison ,
quasiparticle levels obtained in a smaller subspace ( @xmath228 , @xmath227 mev @xmath75 ) are also shown in the top - right window . by comparing the results of two calculations
, one can see that increasing the number of canonical orbitals leads to the addition of high - excitation particle - like quasiparticles , while it does not change very much the hole - like states and low - excitation particle - like states .
thus , enlargement of the canonical - basis subspace is a very inefficient way to decrease the energy widths of particle - like quasiparticle states .
the differences from true quasiparticles become more evident by looking at the wave functions . for @xmath354 , the particle component
@xmath355 should be an oscillating function of @xmath2 @xcite .
however , @xmath355 of quasiparticles defined in the canonical - orbital subspace has an exponentially damping tail .
it is only natural because they are expressed as linear combinations of such functions .
it should be stressed again that the quasiparticles in the canonical - orbital subspace are nevertheless a useful auxiliary tool to obtain the hfb ground state .
however , if one needs true quasiparticle excitation modes , the quasiparticles in the subspace are useless .
one has to calculate with some other method the true eigenstates of the quasiparticle hamiltonian .
a good news is that the hamiltonian ( being composed of @xmath124 and @xmath125 ) is already obtained and thus iterations for self - consistency are not necessary .
this will make the numerical calculations rather inexpensive .
our canonical - basis hfb method has several parameters to specify the pairing force , i.e. , the over - all strength @xmath87 , the parameter for the momentum dependence @xmath95 , the number of canonical orbitals having non - zero occupation probabilities @xmath55 , and parameters for density dependences .
however , available experimental data do not provide sufficient information on the pairing correlation for precise determinations of so many parameters .
therefore we tune only @xmath87 precisely so that the resulting pairing gap has a desired value , while assuming some reasonable values for the other parameters .
however , this does not guarantee that their values may be chosen completely arbitrarily . in this and next subsections we discuss on the choices of the values of @xmath95 and @xmath55 , respectively .
pairing - channel interactions were taken into account when skyrme forces sgii @xcite and skp @xcite were determined .
their values of @xmath95 (= @xmath356 ) are 2.5 @xmath98 and 4.3 @xmath98 , respectively . from this result ,
values from 2 to 5 @xmath98 seem equally reasonable . from a pragmatic point of view to use the force in the canonical - basis method , @xmath95 must be smaller than 6 @xmath98 in order to avoid the point collapse ( see appendix [ sec : pointcollapse ] ) .
values smaller than 1.5 @xmath98 are not preferable , either , because such small @xmath95 makes the solutions very difficult to obtain . if @xmath87 is adjusted for each value of @xmath95 to reproduce the same value of the average pairing gap , which we define @xcite as , @xmath357 resulting properties of the nucleus are almost independent of @xmath95 except the pairing density , which becomes more diffuse when smaller @xmath95 is used .
unfortunately , pairing density is rather difficult to determine experimentally .
incidentally , the properties of each canonical orbital are rather sensitive to @xmath95 : @xmath159 and @xmath358 increase while @xmath150 decreases with decreasing @xmath95 .
only @xmath136 stays roughly constant .
nevertheless , properties of the nucleus ( except the pairing density profile ) are hardly changed , as far as the average pairing gap is kept unchanged . from the allowed interval 1.5 @xmath98 @xmath359 6 @xmath98 ,
we have chosen 2 @xmath98 in this paper .
there is no physical reason for this choice .
however , smaller values of @xmath95 lead to a favorable situation that the dependence on @xmath55 becomes weaker and the determination of @xmath55 can be less precise .
[ fig : nw_gap ] shows the dependence of @xmath360 of eq .
( [ eq : avegap ] ) on @xmath55 .
solid circles , open circles , and triangles are obtained with @xmath95= 5 , 3 , and @xmath361 @xmath98 , respectively .
the values of @xmath87 are given in the legends of the figure in units of mev @xmath75 .
here , @xmath87 is not changed as a function of @xmath55 but is determined for each @xmath95 such that the resulting @xmath360 is roughly the same at @xmath362 .
one can see in the figure that , for @xmath363 @xmath98 , @xmath364 is almost zero around @xmath365 .
the emergence of this plateau is explained by the vanishing of the pairing interaction at relative momentum @xmath95 . for much larger
@xmath55 , @xmath360 will increase again infinitely @xcite .
we next study the dependence on the number of canonical orbitals @xmath55 . here
we adjust the strength @xmath87 for each value of @xmath55 to keep @xmath360 constant .
the used values of @xmath87 are shown in fig .
[ fig : nw_pfs ] . in fig .
[ fig : nw_etot ] we show the total energy of @xmath250si as a function of @xmath55 .
it is obtained as follows : starting from harmonic oscillator eigenstates , we obtain an hfb solution for @xmath366 .
then , we remove the canonical orbital with the smallest @xmath159 and again obtain the hfb solution for @xmath367 by the gradient method . by repeating this procedure ,
we obtain solutions for @xmath368 .
this figure shows that the magnitude of the influence of @xmath55 on the total energy is 300 kev or less when @xmath87 is determined for the average pairing gap .
other bulk properties of the nucleus are also roughly independent of @xmath55 : deformation parameters @xmath241 and @xmath245 are within @xmath369 and @xmath370 , respectively .
r.m.s mass radius is @xmath371 fm . of the canonical orbitals on the number of the orbitals @xmath55 for @xmath250si .
see text for explanations . , width=6 ] such insensitivity can also be seen in the properties of individual canonical orbitals . in fig .
[ fig : nw_spl ] , mean - field energies @xmath150 of canonical orbitals are plotted versus @xmath55 .
one can see that @xmath150 below 5 mev stays almost constant .
higher levels are not so constant but only slightly decreasing . we have also confirmed that other quantities also remain roughly constant . therefore , unlike @xmath95 , the effects of changing @xmath55 is almost canceled by the adjustment of @xmath87 . finally we demonstrate the applicability of the canonical - basis hfb method to nuclei heavier than @xmath250si .
we have encountered no special difficulties at least up to @xmath372 except the increase in the computation time per gradient - method step .
for example , fig .
[ fig : mass_gap ] shows the dependence of the average pairing gap @xmath360 on the mass number @xmath117 . in the calculations ,
the normalization box is gradually expanded with increasing @xmath117 : the edge of the box is at least 2.5 times as large as the liquid - drop - model diameter .
we fix @xmath87 at @xmath373 mev @xmath374 .
instead , we change @xmath55 versus @xmath117 .
when we assume a relation @xmath375 , we can not reproduce the empirical trend that @xmath360 is a decreasing function of @xmath117 .
we can improve the result by using different relations , e.g. , @xmath376 .
however , the goal , a universal pairing force , should be more than an empirical formula expressing @xmath55 as a function of @xmath117
. it will be one of our future challenges .
in this paper we have presented a method to obtain solutions of the hfb equation expressed in the canonical form , i.e. in terms of bcs - type wave functions , without using quasiparticle states .
the method is fit to three - dimensional coordinate space representations and is advantageous to describe simultaneously arbitrary deformations , long and short density tails , and pairing correlations involving states in the continuum of the hf hamiltonian .
we have improved the speed of the convergence to hfb solutions by a few orders of magnitude . for this purpose ,
we have modified the gradient method and derived the appropriate form of the lagrange multiplier functionals for the orthogonality between canonical orbitals .
the two - basis method has also been adapted by replacing the hf basis with the canonical basis to further speedup the convergence . for delta - function pairing interactions ,
the wave functions of canonical orbitals have been shown to shrink infinitely into a spatial point once their occupation probabilities become less than some critical value .
this problem is peculiar to the canonical - basis hfb method . to avoid it
, a repulsive momentum dependent term has been added to the pairing interaction . as a byproduct of the introduction of this term
, the nature of high - lying canonical orbitals has been greatly clarified as approximate eigenstates of the pairing hamiltonian .
we have demonstrated that the level density and the spatial extent of high - lying canonical orbitals can be computed by applying the thomas - fermi approximation to the pairing hamiltonian .
the obtained canonical orbitals have been examined in many aspects .
one of the results is that canonical orbitals closer to the fermi level have wave functions with longer tails . at very large radius , however , all the orbitals seem to change the slope of their tails to that of the orbital closest to the fermi level .
another result is that quasiparticle states can not be efficiently expanded in the canonical basis .
therefore the canonical orbitals perfectly describing the ground state are not sufficient to treat excitations .
the pairing force strength has been adjusted to reproduce the average pairing gap as a function of the number of canonical orbitals , which is used instead of an energy cut - off .
properties of the nucleus have been found to be almost independent of the number of canonical orbitals and rather insensitive to the relative strength of the momentum dependent to independent terms of the pairing force .
although most of our discussions refer to calculations for @xmath250si , we have also checked the applicability of the method to heavy nuclei up to @xmath117=252 .
checks have also been done concerning the precision of the mesh representation in connection with this method .
we believe that the canonical - basis hfb method has the potential to become the standard approach to treat neutron - rich nuclei in hfb . as a next step , we are going to extend the formalism and the computer program concerning the treatment of @xmath377 nuclei and the inclusion of the spin - orbit and the coulomb interactions .
in this appendix , we examine the precision of the cartesian mesh representation when it is applied to the canonical - basis hfb method .
discussions are given concerning the dependencies on i ) the mesh spacing , ii ) the approximation formulae for the derivatives , and iii ) the size of the normalization box .
the pairing force strength used is @xmath378 mev @xmath75 with @xmath228 .
the state is the prolate ground state of @xmath250si .
\i ) we discuss the dependence on the mesh spacing @xmath195 . for this purpose
, we calculate the hf and hfb solutions for various value of @xmath195 while keeping the size of the box constant . for the discrete approximation of the first and second derivatives , we use the 17-point formula @xcite . according to the calculation using the finest mesh ( @xmath379 fm ) , @xmath380 mev , @xmath381 mev , and @xmath382 .
the mesh is changed in the following manner : we use @xmath383 mesh points in @xmath384 , @xmath385 , and @xmath6-directions .
then the length of the edge of the normalization box is @xmath386 = @xmath387 .
we fix @xmath386 at 24 fm so that increasing @xmath383 from 15 to 79 corresponds to decreasing @xmath195 from 1.5 fm to 0.3 fm .
the error is defined as the deviation from the result with @xmath195=0.3 fm .
the center of mass of the nucleus is placed at the center of the box . the top portion of fig .
[ fig : mesh_dep ] shows the error of the total energy @xmath126 as a function of the mesh spacing @xmath195 .
the error of the corresponding hf calculation is also shown for comparison . before obtaining this result
, we suspected that hfb solutions suffer from larger errors than hf solutions because the former involve states above the fermi level while the latter depend on only levels below it .
higher levels contain more amount of high momentum components which are less accurately treated with a finite mesh spacing .
however , this figure shows that the errors are of the same order .
the principal reason may be that errors from high - lying levels are reduced by factors @xmath159 or @xmath158 . the bottom portion of fig .
[ fig : mesh_dep ] shows the error of the quadrupole deformation parameter @xmath241 . unlike @xmath126 ,
the error of @xmath241 takes both positive and negative values . for this quantity ,
the hfb errors are several times as large as the hf errors on the average .
this may be related to the strong influence of the pairing correlation on deformations .
\ii ) we compare some approximation formulae given in ref .
@xcite for the evaluation of the derivatives .
note that the fourier transformation method ( or the lagrange - mesh method @xcite applied to uniform - spacing meshes ) assumes a different boundary condition from the other formulae .
it assumes the periodic boundary condition and the edge of the box is also slightly shortened to @xmath388 .
the error is defined as the deviation from the most precise result , which is obtained with the 17-point formula and @xmath195=0.3 fm .
we have not chosen the fourier method for this purpose because of a large error due to numerical cancellations for more than several tens of mesh points . in fig .
[ fig : fml_dep ] , the error of the total energy is shown for each approximation formula and for three values of the mesh spacing @xmath195 .
this figure tells , e.g. , if one uses the 17-point formula with @xmath199 fm for @xmath250si , the error of the total energy is 70 kev .
one can observe two trends : first , for all the three mesh spacings , the error decreases as the formula involves more number of mesh points ( fourier transformation method uses all the mesh points in the box ) .
second , for every formula , the error decreases when the mesh spacing is decreased .
therefore , one can decrease the error of the total energy either by employing a more precise formula or by diminishing the mesh spacing . on the other hand ,
the other quantities can not always be improved significantly by using more precise formulae .
for example , with @xmath195=1.0 fm , the error of the pairing gap @xmath360 does not continue to decrease but seems to almost saturate around 10 kev for more than 9-point formulae ( including the fourier transformation ) .
we have also found a similar saturation phenomenon in the error of the deformation parameter @xmath241 , which is affected strongly by the pairing gap .
the reason of this saturation is probably that the pairing gap is more sensitive than the total energy to high - lying states having large momentum and thus the lack of momentum larger than @xmath389 in the mesh space becomes the main source of the error , while the change of the formulae can only improve the treatment of momentum components smaller that @xmath389 .
\iii ) we examine the errors due to the finite size of the normalization box .
we consider @xmath250si , which has @xmath390 mev .
naturally the errors depend on the fermi level . in this paper ,
however , we can treat only @xmath80 nuclei , all of which have roughly the same fermi level .
we control the size of the box @xmath386 in terms of @xmath383 while fixing @xmath195 at 0.8 fm .
we define the errors as the deviation from the result obtained with large @xmath386 ( @xmath391 fm ) . here
, the comparison should be made within the same parity of @xmath383 @xcite . on the left- and right - hand sides of fig .
[ fig : box_dep ] , we show the errors of the total energy @xmath126 and the r.m.s . radius , respectively .
we have used @xmath392 fm in most of the calculations shown in this paper .
these figures confirm that this value of @xmath386 leads to sufficiently precise results for both quantities . by comparing the errors of hf ( crosses ) and hfb ( circles ) solutions
, one can see that the effects of the finite box size are of the same order between the two methods .
this is because the density tail is determined by the fermi level , which is roughly the same whether there exist pairing correlations or not .
in this appendix we study the mechanism of `` point collapse '' , a phenomenon that the wave function of a canonical orbital shrinks infinitely into a point in the coordinate space once its occupation probability becomes less than some critical value .
it is a problem peculiar to the canonical - basis hfb method . for this purpose
, we consider only one canonical orbital explicitly while representing all the others in terms of uniform densities , @xmath393 , @xmath394 , @xmath395 , and @xmath396 .
the explicitly considered orbital is assumed to have a wave function whose spatial part is a gaussian wave packet parameterized with a size parameter @xmath397 as , @xmath398 the r.m.s .
values of the coordinates and the wave numbers of this wave packet are , respectively , @xmath399 = @xmath400 = @xmath401 = @xmath402 and @xmath403 = @xmath404 = @xmath405 = @xmath406 .
one can express the densities of the total system as , @xmath407 where @xmath408 is the occupation probability of this orbital and @xmath409 .
the change in the total energy due to the presence of the explicitly considered orbital is given by @xmath410 r^2 dr,\ ] ] where @xmath411 has been defined by eq .
( [ eq : ham_dens ] ) , while @xmath412 by replacing @xmath64 , @xmath413 , @xmath93 , and @xmath414 in the equation with @xmath393 , @xmath395 , @xmath394 , and @xmath396 , respectively . for @xmath95 = @xmath415 = @xmath416 ,
one can obtain the following expression for @xmath417 ( @xmath418 is assumed for the density dependence of the skyrme force ) : @xmath419 where @xmath420 among the nine coefficients , @xmath421 and @xmath422 are negative ( at low density places ) while the others are positive . fig .
[ fig : shrink ] shows @xmath417 as a function of @xmath397 for several values of @xmath408 . in the calculations , we employ a pairing force having @xmath423 mev @xmath424 , @xmath225 @xmath92 , and @xmath425 . this strength @xmath87 would give @xmath426 mev for @xmath427 system with @xmath228 if point collapses would not occur .
the effects of the momentum and the pairing density dependent forces are discussed later .
the mean - field force is siii without the spin - orbit term .
@xmath428 is used in eq .
( [ eq : nucleonmass ] ) for the nucleon reduced mass . for the background densities ,
we employ @xmath429 @xmath92 and @xmath430 @xmath431 , which are typical values at peripheral regions where point collapses occur in actual hfb calculations for finite nuclei .
( a fermi gas relation @xmath432 is assumed to determine @xmath413 from @xmath64 . )
one can see from fig .
[ fig : shrink ] that the total energy becomes minimum at the bottom of a dip for small values of @xmath408 .
the dip emerges at @xmath433 fm when @xmath408= @xmath434 and , as @xmath408 is decreased , its depth increases while the location of the bottom moves to smaller values of @xmath397 .
this minimum in the dip corresponds to hfb `` solutions '' in finite nuclei reported in refs .
@xcite , in which the wave function of a high - lying orbital has shrunken into a mesh point .
hfb states having physically reasonable wave functions turn themselves into such strange states in the following abrupt way : in the course of gradient - method evolutions , suddenly after an almost stationary situation has continued , @xmath275 of a high - lying orbital soars up to a few hundred mev and simultaneously the total energy decreases by a few mev .
the dip is caused by the zero - rangeness of the pairing force and thus does not correspond to physically meaningful states .
physical solutions should be found at @xmath435 fm , where @xmath417 is slightly negative .
therefore one needs to eliminate the effects of such dips in order to obtain well - behaving hfb solutions in the canonical - basis representation .
it is worth pointing out here that a wave packet with @xmath397=0.3 fm can be expressed fairly precisely on a mesh with spacing @xmath195=0.8 fm .
it is because the maximum wave number expressible with the mesh is @xmath436 and thus the minimum size of the wave packet of eq .
( [ eq : wavepacket ] ) can be estimated roughly by a relation @xmath403 = @xmath406 @xmath224 @xmath436 , which leads to @xmath437 fm for @xmath195=0.8 fm .
therefore collapses to wave packets as small as @xmath438 fm are a practical problem even when @xmath195=0.8 fm . before discussing how to remove the dip ,
let us clarify in an analytical way the mechanism which gives rise to the dip .
we consider the limit of @xmath439 , in which the nature of the dip becomes most manifest .
therefore , the following considerations are for the untruncated hilbert space , not for mesh representations . in order to study this limit ,
we assume a scaling behavior @xmath440 where @xmath397 is the location of the bottom of the dip . @xmath441 and @xmath442 are positive constants to be determined .
one can easily confirm that , for @xmath443 , all the nine terms in the right - hand side of eq .
( [ eq : detot ] ) have positive powers of @xmath397 and thus converge to zero as @xmath444 .
consequently , it must be satisfied that @xmath445 for a point - collapse solution to exist . for @xmath446 , @xmath447 + ( lower order terms in @xmath406 ) and
thus the energy diverges to @xmath448 as @xmath444 .
the only possibility for a point - collapse solution to exist is in the case of @xmath449 , for which @xmath450 + ( terms with positive powers in @xmath397 ) . from a condition
@xmath451 , one immediately finds that @xmath417 becomes minimum at @xmath452 .
the minimum value in the limit @xmath444 becomes @xmath453 its numerical value is @xmath454 mev for the parameters used .
the essential points clarified here are i ) the minimum of the total energy is realized in the limit @xmath455 with @xmath162 and ii ) the limiting value of the minimum energy is finite .
one can also derive analytically the location @xmath397 of the barrier top which divides the physical and unphysical regions . from the condition , @xmath456 one can simply obtain the location of the local maximum as , @xmath457 by neglecting terms of @xmath458 . note that it is independent of @xmath43 ( if @xmath43 is sufficiently small ) . with the parameters used , @xmath459 fm . indeed in fig .
[ fig : shrink ] , the location of the top of the barrier ( designated with open circles ) seems to converge to @xmath151 fm as @xmath408 is decreased .
the height of the maximum is @xmath460 , which is @xmath461 and converges to zero as @xmath462 .
therefore , for sufficiently small values of @xmath43 , hfb solutions easily fall into the unphysical dip since the mesh spacing is much smaller than @xmath463 fm .
the first type of the interaction is the momentum dependent term of eq .
( [ eq : pair_int ] ) . with @xmath464 , but with @xmath94 , @xmath417 becomes to have additional terms as , @xmath465 where @xmath417 is given by eq .
( [ eq : detot ] ) and , @xmath466 since @xmath467 , @xmath468 , @xmath469 , and @xmath470 are positive .
the dominant term in the limit @xmath444 is the one having coefficient @xmath469 ( @xmath470 ) for @xmath471 , which behaves as @xmath472 ( @xmath473 ) .
these two terms overwhelm the negative terms in @xmath417 .
consequently wave functions can not shrink to a point .
however , a dip can still emerge with finite @xmath43 .
figure [ fig : shrinkkc ] shows how the local minimum ( the bottom of the dip ) and the local maximum ( the top of the barrier ) of @xmath417 change versus @xmath408 .
the left - hand portion shows the depth and the height ( @xmath417 ) , while the right - hand portion shows the locations ( @xmath397 ) .
the solid curves are obtained with @xmath155 .
the upper solid curve stands for the height of the local maximum , which converges to zero as @xmath474 , as already discussed analytically .
( this curve is almost unchanged when @xmath95 is decreased to finite values . )
the lower solid curve corresponds to the depth of the local minimum , which converges to @xmath454 mev , in accord with eq .
( [ eq : localmin ] ) . with finite values of @xmath95 , the minimum becomes shallower as @xmath408 is decreased and it disappears at some small value of @xmath408 .
this disappearance is clearly seen in the dot curve ( corresponding to @xmath95=15 @xmath98 ) in the right - hand portion of the figure .
a numerical search has shown that the dip exists only for @xmath475 @xmath98 . the result with
this simplified model roughly agrees with realistic hfb calculations : we have observed that point collapses can occur for @xmath476 @xmath98 in calculations like those shown in fig .
[ fig : nw_gap ] .
the difference between 6 @xmath98 and 10 @xmath98 can be partially attributed to the finite - point approximation to the derivatives , which underestimates the kinetic energy by 30% at @xmath477 , as shown in fig .
20 of ref .
@xcite .
incidentally , the requirement of orthogonality among the canonical orbitals does not seem to change the conclusion drawn with this model .
the first reason is that point collapses in light nuclei are not affected by orthogonality if the number of canonical orbitals @xmath55 is relatively small .
this is because of the symmetry ( e.g. , @xmath234 ) of the solution : if a high - lying orbital is the only one in an irreducible representation of the symmetry ( e.g. , in @xmath478=@xmath479 sector when @xmath384-axis is the shortest axis ) , it is automatically orthogonal to the other orbitals . in this case
, it shrinks not to a point but to many points ( e.g. , two points at @xmath480 , @xmath481 , @xmath169 @xmath224 nuclear radius , with opposite - sign amplitudes ) .
indeed , we have experienced that point collapses occur only when @xmath55 is small for relatively small values of @xmath95 .
the second reason is an empirical fact that , with large values of @xmath95 , many orbitals collapse one after another or simultaneously even for large @xmath55 : the process of point collapses under orthogonality condition may not be so complicated as it sounds in such cases .
the second type of the interaction we examine is the pairing density dependent term of eq .
( [ eq : pair_int ] ) . with @xmath482 , but with @xmath483 , @xmath417 has additional terms to eq .
( [ eq : detot ] ) as , @xmath484 where @xmath485 all the added terms are positive . assuming @xmath440 , terms with coefficients @xmath486 and @xmath487 have negative powers of @xmath397 at @xmath449 .
consequently point collapses can be avoided by using finite values of @xmath415 .
figure [ fig : shrinkrp ] shows extrema of @xmath417 versus @xmath408 .
the solid curve corresponds to @xmath94 and is the same as that in fig .
[ fig : shrinkkc ] .
the other types of curves are for finite values of @xmath415 .
one can see that @xmath417 at the local minimum is already very small with @xmath488 @xmath92 ( dot curve ) , which is much larger than the typical values of @xmath93 and thus leads to only physically acceptable small amount of modification of the pairing interaction .
this figure is consistent with the results of actual hfb calculations : from fig . 4 of ref .
@xcite , one can see that point collapses can be avoided with @xmath489 @xmath92
. mathematically speaking , however , the local minimum continues to exist for arbitrary @xmath43 , which is a different behavior from that with finite @xmath95 . in the limit of @xmath462 ,
this minimum behaves as @xmath444 and @xmath490 . because the depth converges to zero from below
, the point - collapse limit is unstable and is not very meaningful .
so , let us give only briefly the result of an analytical consideration . assuming @xmath440
, one can show that the local minimum continues to exist in the limit @xmath444 with @xmath491 and @xmath441 determined by a cubic equation @xmath492 if @xmath493 ( i.e. , @xmath494 for @xmath495 ) . at the local minimum , @xmath496 and @xmath497 .
one can see this scaling behavior with @xmath498 on the right - hand side of fig .
[ fig : shrinkrp ] . in the present paper
we have used the momentum dependent interaction because it has a physical origin , i.e. , the finite - rangeness . however
, the pairing density dependent interaction may also be useful under different circumstances because the momentum dependent interaction leads to a divergence of the pairing energy in unrestricted hilbert space @xcite : the assumption of @xmath499 made in this paper is not adequate for orbitals with @xmath500 . to summarize , assuming a wave function of gaussian form
, we have clarified the mechanism of the point - collapse phenomenon occurring in the canonical - basis hfb method due to delta interactions .
we have also demonstrated the successes of momentum or pairing density dependent interactions in avoiding the collapse .
stoitsov , w. nazarewicz , and s. pittel : phys .
rev . * c58 * , 2092 ( 1998 ) .
d. vautherin and d.m .
brink , phys .
* c5 * , 626 ( 1972 ) . j. dobaczewski , h. flocard and j. treiner : nucl .
* a422 * , 103 ( 1984 ) . j. dobaczewski , w. nazarewicz , t.r .
werner , j.f .
berger , c.r .
chinn , and j.decharg , phys .
rev . * c53 * , 2809 ( 1996 ) b. gall , p. bonche , j. dobaczewski , h. flocard , and p .- h .
heenen , z. phys .
* a348 * , 183 ( 1994 ) . j. terasaki , p .- h .
heenen , h. flocard and p. bonche : nucl .
* a600 * , 371 ( 1996 ) . j. terasaki , h. flocard , p .- h .
heenen and p. bonche : nucl .
a621 * , 706 ( 1997 ) . n. tajima , in _ proceedings of the xvii rcnp international symposium on innovative computational methods in nuclear many - body problems _ , osaka , 1997 , edited by h. horiuchi _ et al .
_ , ( world scientific , 1998 ) , p. 343 ; nucl - th/0002061 .
m. yamagami , k. matsuyanagi , m. matsuo , nucl .
* a693 * , 579 ( 2001 ) c. bloch and a. messiah , nucl .
phys . * 39 * , 95 ( 1962 ) .
reinhard , m. bender , k. rutz , and j.a .
maruhn : z. phys . *
a358 * , 277 ( 1997 ) . n. tajima , in _ high performance computing in riken 1997 _ , riken review * 19 * , 29 ( 1998 ) ; http://www.riken.go.jp/lab-www/library/publication/ review / conts / conts19.html n. tajima , in _ high performance computing in riken 1998 _ , riken review * 25 * , 75 ( 1999 ) ; http://www.riken.go.jp/lab-www/library/publication/ review / conts / conts25.html n. tajima , in _ proceedings of a riken international symposium on models and theories of the nuclear mass _ , 1999 , wako ; riken review * 26 * , 87 ( 2000 ) ; http://www.riken.go.jp/lab-www/library/publication/ review / conts / conts26.html p. bonche , h. flocard , p .- h . heenen , s.j .
krieger , and m.s .
weiss : nucl .
a443 * , 39 ( 1985 ) .
skyrme , phil . mag .
* 1 * , 1043 ( 1956 ) .
m. beiner , h. flocard , nguyen van giai , and p. quentin , nucl.phys .
* a238 * , 29 ( 1975 ) .
s. sakakihara and y. tanaka , nucl .phys . * a691 * , 649 ( 2001 ) . n. tajima , p. bonche , h. flocard , p .- h .
heenen , and m.s .
weiss : nucl .
* a551 * , 434 ( 1993 ) . j. dobaczewski , w. nazarewicz , and m.v .
stoitsov , presented at _
nato advanced research workshop on the nuclear many - body problem _ , brijuni , 2001 ; nucl - th/0109073 .
goodman , adv .
phys . * 11 * , 263 ( 1979 ) .
s. takahara , n. onishi , and n. tajima , phys .
* b331 * , 261 ( 1994 ) . j. decharg and d. gogny , phys . rev . * c21 * , 1568 ( 1980 ) . a. bulgac and y. yu , phys .
lett . * 88 * , 042504 ( 2002 ) .
a. bulgac , phys .
* c65 * , 051305(r ) ( 2002 ) . y. yu and a. bulgac , phys .
* 90 * , 222501 ( 2003 ) .
m. grasso and m. urban , cond - mat/0305588 .
n. tajima , s. takahara , and n. onishi : nucl .
phys . * a603 * , 23 ( 1996 ) . k.t.r .
davies , h. flocard , s. krieger , and m.s .
weiss , nucl .
* a342 * , 111 ( 1980 ) .
p. ring and p. schuck : _ the nuclear many - body problem _
( springer , new york , 1980 ) .
n. tajima , progr .
suppl . * 142 * , 265 ( 2001 ) .
nguyen van giai and h. sagawa , phys .
* b106 * , 379 ( 1981 ) .
d. baye and p .- h .
heenen : j. phys . *
a19 * , 2041 ( 1986 ) .
h. imagawa and y. hashimoto , phys .
rev . * c67 * , 037302 ( 2003 ) | a method is presented to obtain the canonical - form solutions of the hfb equation for atomic nuclei with zero - range interactions like the skyrme force .
it is appropriate to describe pairing correlations in the continuum in coordinate - space representations .
an improved gradient method is used for faster convergences under constraint of orthogonality between orbitals . to prevent high - lying orbitals to shrink into a spatial point ,
a repulsive momentum dependent force is introduced , which turns out to unveil the nature of high - lying canonical - basis orbitals .
the asymptotic properties at large radius and the relation with quasiparticle states are discussed for the obtained canonical basis . |
the detection of x - ray , optical and radio afterglows from some well - localized gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) definitely shows that at least most long grbs are of cosmological origin ( e.g. , costa et al .
1997 ; frail et al . 1997 ; galama et al . 1998 ; akerlof et al . 1999 ; zhu et al . 1999 ) .
the so called fireball model is thus strongly favoured .
however , we are still far from resolving the puzzle of grbs ( piran 1999 ; van paradijs , kouveliotou & wijers 2000 ) .
a major problem is that we do not know whether grbs are due to highly collimated jets or isotropic fireballs , so that the energetics involved can not be determined definitely ( e.g. , pugliese , falcke & biermann 1999 ; kumar & piran 2000 ; dar & rjula 2000 ; wang & loeb 2001 ; rossi , lazzati & rees 2002 ) .
this issue has been extensively discussed in the literature .
generally speaking , three methods may help to determine the degree of beaming in grbs .
first , based on analytic solutions , it has been proposed that optical afterglows from a jetted grb should be characterized by a break in the light curve during the relativistic phase , i.e. , at the time when the lorentz factor of the blastwave is @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the half opening angle ( rhoads 1997 ; kulkarni et al .
1999 ; mszros & rees 1999 ) .
some grbs such as 990123 , 990510 are regarded as good examples ( castro - tirado et al . 1999 ; wijers et al .
1999 ; harrison et al . 1999
; halpern et al . 2000 ; pian et al . 2001 ; castro ceron et al . 2001 ; sagar et al . 2001 ) .
however , detailed numerical studies show that the break is usually quite smooth ( panaitescu & mszros 1998 ; moderski , sikora & bulik 2000 ) , and huang et al .
went further to suggest that the light curve break should in fact occur at the trans - relativistic phase ( huang et al .
2000a , b , c , d ) . additionally , many other factors can also result in light curve breaks , for example , the cooling of electrons ( sari , piran & narayan 1998 ) , a dense interstellar medium ( dai & lu 1999 ) , or a wind environment ( dai & lu 1998a ; chevalier & li 2000 ; panaitescu & kumar 2000 ) .
all these facts combine together to make the first method not so conclusive .
second , gruzinov ( 1999 ) argued that optical afterglows from a jet can be strongly polarized , in principle up to tens of percents .
some positive observations have already been reported ( wijers et al . 1999 ; rol et al .
2000 ) . but
polarization can be observed only under some particular conditions , i.e. , the co - moving magnetic fields parallel and perpendicular to the jet should have different strengths and we should observe at the right time from the right viewing angle ( gruzinov 1999 ; hjorth et al .
1999 ; mitra 2000 ) .
the third method was first proposed by rhoads ( 1997 ) , who pointed out that due to relativistic beaming effects , @xmath2-ray radiation from the vast majority of jetted grbs can not be observed , but the corresponding late time afterglow emission is less beamed and can safely reach us .
these afterglows are called orphan afterglows , which means they are not associated with any detectable grbs . the ratio of the orphan afterglow rate to the grb rate might allow measurement of the grb collimation angle .
great expectations have been put on this method ( rhoads 1997 ; mszros , rees & wijers 1999 ; lamb 2000 ; paczyski 2000 ; djorgovski et al . 2001 ) .
in fact , the absence of large numbers of orphan afterglows in many surveys has been regarded as evidence that the collimation can not be extreme ( rhoads 1997 ; perna & loeb 1998 ; greiner et al .
1999 ; grindlay 1999 ; rees 1999 ) .
recently dalal , griest & pruet ( 2002 ) argued that measurement of the grb beaming angle using optical orphan searches is extremely difficult .
the main reason is that when the afterglow emission from a jet begins to go into a much larger solid angle than the initial burst does , the optical flux density usually becomes very low . generally speaking
, this problem can be overcome by improving the detection limit .
in fact , an interesting result was recently reported by vanden berk et al .
( 2002 ) , who discovered a possible optical orphan at @xmath3 .
they suggested that grbs should be collimated . in this article , we will point out another difficulty associated with the third method : there should be many `` failed gamma - ray bursts ( fgrbs ) '' , i.e. , baryon - contaminated fireballs with initial lorentz factor @xmath4 .
fgrbs can not be observed in gamma - rays , but their long - lasting afterglows are detectable , thus they will also manifest themselves as orphan afterglows .
our paper is organized as follows . in section 2
we explain the concept of fgrbs .
section 3 describes the difficulty in distinguishing an fgrb orphan and a jetted grb orphan .
some possible solutions that may help to overcome the difficulty are suggested .
section 4 is a brief discussion .
occurring in the deep universe , grbs are the most relativistic phenomena ever known . the standard fireball model ( mszros & rees 1992 ; dermer , bttcher & chiang 1999 ) requires that to successfully produce a grb , the initial lorentz factor of the blastwave should typically be @xmath5 1000 during the main burst phase ( piran 1999 ; lithwick & sari 2000 ) . generally speaking
the requirement of ultra - relativistic motion is to avoid the so called `` compactness problem '' .
a modest variation in the lorentz factor will result in a difference of the opacity of the high - energy @xmath2-ray photons by a factor of @xmath6 ( totani 1999 ) .
additionally , assuming synchrotron radiation , the observed peak frequency is strongly dependent on @xmath2 , @xmath7 ( mszros , rees & wijers 1998 ) .
thus a lorentz factor of @xmath8 makes the blastwave very inefficient in emitting @xmath2-ray photons .
so , to successfully produce a grb , we need @xmath5 1000 . however , theoretically it is not easy to construct a model to generate such ultra - relativistic motions .
currently there are mainly two kinds of progenitor models , the collapse of massive stars ( with mass @xmath9 ) , or the collision of two compact stars ( such as two neutron stars or a neutron star and a black hole ) .
since a baryon - rich environment is involved in all these models , some researchers are afraid that the baryon - contamination problem may exist . but this problem maybe is not as serious as we previously expected .
let us first take the collapsar model ( macfadyen & woosley 1999 ) as an example .
we can imagine that the baryon mass and energy released in different collapsar events should vary greatly , then @xmath10 of the resultant fireballs may also vary in a relatively wide range . in most cases , @xmath10 should be very low ( i.e. , @xmath4 ) , but there still could be a few cases ( e.g. , one percent or even one in a thousand ) in which the fireball is relatively clean so that the blastwave can be successfully accelerated to @xmath5 1000 and produces a grb .
since the collapsar rate is high enough in a typical galaxy , there should be no problem that such collapsars can meet the requirement of grb rate ( i.e. , @xmath11 @xmath12 event per typical galaxy per year , under isotropic assumption ) .
cases are similar in the collisions of two compact stars . in short
, we can not omit an important fact : if grbs are really due to isotropic fireballs , then there should be much more failed grbs ( i.e. , fireballs with lorentz factor much less than one hundred , but still much greater than unity )
. these fgrb fireballs can contain similar initial energy as normal grb fireballs , i.e. , @xmath13 @xmath14 ergs , but they are polluted by baryons with mass @xmath15 @xmath16 .
radiation from these fgrbs should mainly be in x - ray bands in the initial bursting phase , not in @xmath2-ray bands .
in fact , bepposax team has reported the discovery of several anomalous events named as fast x - ray transients , x - ray rich grbs , or even x - ray - grbs .
they resemble usual grbs except that they are extremely x - ray rich ( frontera et al .
2000 ; kippen et al .
2001 ; gandolfi & piro 2001 ) .
observational data on this kind of events are being accumulated rapidly .
recent good examples include grbs 011030 , 011130 and 011211 ( gandolfi et al .
2001a , b ; ricker et al . 2001 ) .
we propose that these events are probably just fgrbs .
huang et al . ( 1998 ) and dai , huang & lu ( 1999 ) have pointed out that for afterglow behaviour , the parameter @xmath17 is decisive , while @xmath18 is only of minor importance , especially at late stages .
so , fgrbs should also be associated with prominent afterglows . in figure 1
we compare the theoretical optical afterglows from fgrbs with those from isotropic grbs and jetted grbs .
we can see that the light curve of an fgrb afterglow differs from that of a successful isotropic burst only slightly , i.e. , only notable at early stages . in our calculations , we have used the methods developed by huang et al.(1999a , b , 2000b , d ) , i.e. , for the dynamical evolution of isotropic fireballs we use @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the swept - up mass and @xmath21 is the radiation efficience .
( 1 ) has been proved to be proper in both ultra - relativistic phase and non - relativistic phase ( huang , dai & lu 1999a , b ) .
for jetted ejecta , the following equation is added ( huang et al .
2000b , d ) , @xmath22 where @xmath23 is the blastwave radius , and the co - moving sound speed @xmath24 is given realistically by @xmath25 with @xmath26 the adiabatic index .
in fact , in beamed grb models , there should also be many fgrbs , i.e. , beamed ejecta with @xmath27 .
we call them beamed fgrbs .
afterglow from beamed fgrbs has also been illustrated in figure 1 . in this article
emphasises will be put on isotropic fgrbs , so by using `` fgrbs '' we will only mean isotropic fgrbs unless stated explicitly .
both fgrbs and jetted but off - axis grbs can produce isolated fading objects , i.e. , orphan afterglows .
theoretically , when orphan afterglows are really discovered observationally , it is still risky to conclude that grbs are beamed .
we should study these orphans carefully to determine whether they come from fgrbs or jetted grbs .
however , we will show below that it is not an easy task .
usually the light curve of grb afterglows is plotted as @xmath28 vs. @xmath29 , where @xmath30 is the flux density at observing frequency @xmath31 and @xmath32 is observer s time measured from the burst trigger . in such plots ,
the behaviour of afterglows from isotropic grbs and jetted ones are possibly quite different .
the former is generally characterized by a simple flat straight line with slope @xmath33 @xmath34 and the latter can be characterized by a break in the light curve or by a steep straight line with a slope sharper than @xmath35 ( figure 1 , also see huang et al . 2000a , b , c , d ) .
but for orphan afterglow observations , the derivation of such a @xmath28 @xmath29 light curve is not direct : we do not know the trigger time so that the exact value of @xmath32 for each observed data point can not be determined . as the first step , the best that we can do is to produce a light curve with a linear time axis , which , however , is of little help for unveiling the nature of the orphan .
figure 2 illustrates the matter . in this figure
we plot @xmath28 vs. @xmath32 for the two kinds of orphans theoretically .
the uncerntainty in trigger time means the observed light curve can be shifted along x axis , while the unknown distance results in a shift along y axis .
we see that after some simple manipulations , the segment ab on the dashed curve ( i.e. , from @xmath36 d to @xmath37 d ) can be shifted to a place ( a@xmath38b@xmath38 ) that differs from the solid line only slightly .
it hints that a linear light curve as long as @xmath39 days is still not enough .
note that the solid and the dashed curves in figure 2 are only two examples .
the variation of some intrinsic parameters , such as @xmath17 , @xmath40 , @xmath10 , @xmath41 , @xmath42 , @xmath43 , @xmath44 and @xmath45 as defined in the caption of figure 1 , can change the shape of the two curves notably , thus brings in much more difficulties . in figure 3
, we compare the theoretical @xmath28 @xmath29 light curves of optical afterglows from fgrbs and jetted but off - axis grbs directly . to investigate the influence of the uncertainty in trigger time
, we also shift the light curve of fgrbs by @xmath46 d , @xmath47 d and @xmath48 d intentionally . from the dashed curves
, we can see that the shape of the fgrb afterglow light curve is seriously affected by the uncertainty of the trigger time .
but fortunately , these dashed curves still differ from the theoretical light curve of the jetted grb orphan markedly , i.e. , they are much flatter at very late stages .
this means it is still possible for us to discriminate them . in figure 4 ,
similar results to figure 3 are given , but this time the light curve of the jetted grb orphan is shifted .
again we see that the two kinds of orphans can be discriminated by their late time behaviour .
figures 3 and 4 explain what we should do when an orphan afterglow is discovered .
first , we have to assume a trigger time for it arbitrarily , so that the logarithmic light curve can be plotted .
we then need to change the trigger time to many other values to see how the light curve is affected . in all our plots
, we should pay special attention to the late time behaviour , which will be less affected by the uncertainty in the trigger time . if the slope tends to be @xmath49 @xmath34 , then the orphan afterglow may come from an fgrb event .
but if the slope tends to be steeper than @xmath35 , then it is very likely from a jetted but off - axis grb .
in fact , from figure 1 , we know that for all kinds of grbs , either successful or failed , the optical afterglow approximately follows a simple power - law decay at late stages ( i.e. , @xmath50 ) so that the light curve is a straight line .
in such a relation , if we shift the time by @xmath51 , @xmath52 then the line would become curved .
the slope at each point on the curve is @xmath53 for positive @xmath51 values the lines bend up - ward , while for negative values the lines bend down - ward .
it hints that in plotting the orphan afterglow light curve , we could select the trigger time properly to get a straight line at late stages , then we can determine not only the late time slope , but also the true trigger time .
in other words , we can use @xmath54 as the condition to determine the trigger time and to get the straight line at late stages .
however , we must bear in mind that it is in fact not an easy task .
first , to take the process we need to follow the orphan as long as possible , and the simple discovery of an orphan is obviously insufficient . note that currently optical afterglows from most well - localized grbs can be observed for only less than 100 days .
it is quite unlikely that we can follow an orphan for a period longer than that .
second , since the orphan is usually very faint , errors in the measured magnitudes will seriously prevent us from deriving the straight line . due to all these difficulties , a satisfactory light curve is usually hard to get for most orphans .
we see that measurement of the grb beaming angle using orphan searches is not as simple as we originally expected .
in fact , it is impractical to some extent .
recently it was suggested by rhoads ( 2001 ) that grb afterglows can be effectly identified by snapshot observations made with three or more optical filters .
the method has been successfully applied to grb 001011 by gorosabel et al .
it is believed that this method is also helpful for orphan afterglow searches .
however , please note that a jetted grb orphan and an fgrb one still can not be discriminated directly .
we have shown that the derivation of a satisfactory light curve for an orphan afterglow is difficult .
the major problem is that we do not know the trigger time .
anyway , there are still some possible solutions that may help to determine the onset of an orphan afterglow .
firstly , of course we should improve our detection limit so that the orphan afterglow could be followed as long as possible .
the longer we observe , the more likely that we can get the true late - time light curve slope .
secondly , we know that fgrbs usually manifest themselves as fast x - ray transients or x - ray - grbs . if an orphan can be identified to associate with such a transient , then it is most likely an fgrb one . in this case
, the trigger time can be well determined .
thirdly , maybe in some rare cases we are so lucky that the rising phase of the orphan could be observed . for a jetted grb
orphan the maximum optical flux is usually reached within one or two days and for an fgrb orphan it is even within hours .
then the uncertainty in trigger time is greatly reduced .
additionally , a jetted grb orphan differs markedly from an fgrb one during the rising phase .
the former can be brightened by more than one magnitude in several hours ( see figures 1 4 ) , while the brightening of the latter can hardly be observed .
so , if an orphan afterglow with a short period of brightening is observed , then it is most likely a jetted grb orphan .
of course , we should first be certain that it is not a supernova .
fourthly , valuable clues may come from radio observations . in radio bands
, the light curve should be highly variable at early stages due to interstellar medium scintillation , and it will become much smoother at late times .
so the variability in radio light curves provides useful information on the trigger time . and
fifthly , in the future maybe gravitational wave radiation or neutrino radiation associated with grbs could be detected due to progresses in technology , then the trigger time of an orphan could be determined directly and accurately .
in fact , with the successful detection of gravitational waves or neutrino emission , our understanding on grb progenitors will surely be promoted greatly ( paolis et al .
2001 ) .
sixthly , the redshift of the orphan afterglow can help us greatly in determining the isotropic energy involved , which itself is helpful for inferring the trigger time .
seventhly , the microlensing effect may be of some help .
since the size of the radiation zone of a jetted grb orphan is much smaller than that of an fgrb one , they should behave differently when microlensed .
finally , although a successful detection of some orphan afterglows does not directly mean that grbs be collimated , the negative detection of any orphans can always place both a stringent lower limit on the beaming angle for grbs and a reasonable upper limit for the rate of fgrbs .
to successfully produce a grb , the blastwave should be ultra - relativistic , with lorentz factor typically larger than 100 1000 . however , in almost all popular progenitor models , the environment is unavoidably baryon - rich .
we believe that only in very rare cases can an ultra - relativistic blastwave successfully break out to give birth to a grb , and there should be much more failed grbs , i.e. , fireballs with lorentz factor much less than 100 but still much larger than unity .
in fact , this possibility has also been mentioned by a number of authors , such as mszros & waxman ( 2001 ) .
owing to the existence of fgrbs , there should be many orphan afterglows even if grbs are due to isotropic fireballs .
then the simple discovery of orphan afterglows does not necessarily mean that grbs be highly collimated . to make use of information from orphan afterglow surveys correctly
, we should first know how to discriminate a jetted grb orphan and an fgrb one .
this can be done only by checking the detailed afterglow light curve .
however , we have shown that the derivation of a satisfactory light curve for an orphan afterglow is difficult .
the major problem is that we do not know the trigger time . in section 3.2 ,
some possible solutions to the problem are suggested .
unfortunately many of these solutions are still quite impractical in the foreseeable future , which means measure of grb beaming angle using orphan afterglow searches is extremely difficult currently .
however , special attention should be paid to the second solution .
usually , fgrbs manifested themselves as fast x - ray transients during the main burst phase , while jetted but off - axis grbs went unattended completely . if the fast x - ray transients ( or x - ray - grbs ) observed by bepposax are really due to fgrbs , then afterglows should be detectable .
we propose that this kind of events should be followed rapidly and extensively in all bands , just like what we are doing for grbs .
if observed , afterglows from these anomalous events can be used to check our concept of fgrbs , and even to test the fireball model under quite different conditions ( i.e. , when @xmath4 ) .
also , these fgrbs can provide valuable information for our understanding of grbs , especially on the progenitor models .
note that beamed fgrbs can also give birth to fast x - ray transients if they are directed toward us , but afterglows from such a beamed fgrb and an isotropic fgrb can be discriminated easily from the light curves ( see figure 1 ) .
it is very interesting to note that optical afterglows from two x - ray - grbs , 011130 and 011211 , have been observed ( garnavich , jha & kirshner 2001 ; grav et al .
their redshifts were measured to be @xmath55 0.5 and 2.14 respectively ( jha et al . 2001 ; fruchter et al .
2001 ) , eliminates the possibility that they were ordinary classic grbs residing at extremely high redshifts ( @xmath56 ) .
we propose that they should be fgrbs ( either isotropic or beamed ) or just jetted grb `` orphan '' .
however , the observational data currently available are still quite poor so that we could not determine their nature definitely . as for other x - ray - grbs without a measured redshift ,
the possibility that they were at redshifts of @xmath57 can not be excluded .
finally , the concept of fgrbs is based on the fact that most popular progenitor models for grbs are baryon - rich .
but cases are quite different for another kind of progenitor models where strange stars are involved .
strange stars , composed mainly of u , d , and s quarks , are compact objects which are quite similar to neutron stars observationally ( alcock , farhi & olinto 1986 ) . a typical strange star ( with mass @xmath58 )
can have a normal matter crust of less than @xmath59 ( alcock , farhi & olinto 1986 ) , or even as small as @xmath60 ( huang & lu 1997a , b ) .
then baryon contamination can be directly avoided if grbs are due to the phase transition of neutron stars to strange stars ( cheng & dai 1996 ; dai & lu 1998b ) or collisions of binary strange stars . in these models
, there should be very few fgrbs .
we thank an anonymous referee for valuable comments and suggestions .
yfh thanks l. j. gou and x. y. wang for helpful discussion .
this research was supported by the special funds for major state basic research projects , the national natural science foundation of china ( grants 10003001 , 19825109 , and 19973003 ) , and the national 973 project ( nkbrsf g19990754 ) . note added after acceptance * ( this paragraph might not appear in the published version ) * : the optical orphan at z=0.385 reported by vanden berk et al .
( 2002 ) has recently been proved to be an unusual radio - loud agn ( gal - yam et al .
2002 , astro - ph/0202354 ) , and x - ray grb 011211 was found to be in fact an ordinary classic grb ( frontera et al .
, gcn 1215 ) .
additionally , the optical identification of x - ray grb 011130 might also be incorrect ( frail et al . , gcn 1207 ) .
we sincerely thank nicola masetti for private communication .
alcock c. , farhi e. , olinto a. , 1986 , apj , 310 , 261 akerlof c. et al .
, 1999 , nat , 398 , 400 castro ceron j. m. et al .
, 2001 , a&a , submitted ( astro - ph/0110049 ) castro - tirado a. et al . , 1999 ,
sci , 283 , 2069 cheng k. s. , dai z. g. , 1996 , phys .
lett . , 77 , 1210 chevalier r. a. , li z. y. , 2000 , apj , 536 , 195 costa e. et al . , 1997 , nat , 387 , 783 dai z. g. , huang y. f. , lu t. , 1999 , apj , 520 , 634 dai z. g. , lu t. , 1998a , mnras , 298 , 87 dai z. g. , lu t. , 1998b , phys .
, 81 , 4301 dai z. g. , lu t. , 1999 , apj , 519 , l155 dalal n. , griest k. , pruet j. , 2002 , apj , 564 , 209 dar a. , rjula a. d. , 2001 , astro - ph/0012227 dermer c. d. , bttcher m. , chiang j. , 1999 , apj , 515 , l49 djorgovski s. g. et al . , 2001 , proc . ix marcel grossmann meeting , eds .
v. gurzadyan , r. jantzen , and r. ruffini , singapore : world scientific ( astro - ph/0106574 ) frail d. a. , kulkarni s. r. , nicastro s. r. , feroci m. , taylor g. b. , 1997 , nat , 389 , 261 frontera f. et al . ,
2000 , apj , 540 , 697 fruchter a. et al . , 2001 ,
gcn 1200 galama t. j. et al . , 1998 ,
apj , 500 , l101 gandolfi g. et al . , 2001a , gcn 1118 gandolfi g. et al . , 2001b , gcn 1188 gandolfi g. , piro l. , 2001 , http://www.ias.rm.cnr.it/ias-home/sax/xraygrb.html garnavich p. m. , jha s. , kirshner r. p. , 2001
, gcn 1181 gorosabel j. et al . , 2001 ,
a&a , in press ( astro - ph/0110007 ) grav t. et al . , 2001 , gcn 1191 greiner j. , voges w. , boller t. , hartmann d. , 1999 , a&as , 138 , 441 grindlay j. e. , 1999 , apj , 510 , 710 gruzinov a. , 1999 , apj , 525 , l29 harrison f. a. et al . , 1999 ,
apj , 523 , l121 halpern , j. p. et al . , 2000 , apj , 543 , 697 hjorth j. et al . , 1999 ,
sci , 283 , 2073 huang y. f. , dai z. g. , wei d. m. , lu t. , 1998 , mnras , 298 , 459 huang y. f. , dai z. g. , lu t. , 1999a , mnras , 309 , 513 huang y. f. , dai z. g. , lu t. , 1999b , chin .
lett . , 16 , 775 huang y. f. , dai z. g. , lu t. , 2000a , a&a , 355 , l43 huang y. f. , dai z. g. , lu t. , 2000b , mnras , 316 , 943 huang y. f. , dai z. g. , lu t. , 2000c , chin .
phys . lett . , 17 , 778 huang y. f. , gou l. j. , dai z. g. , lu t. , 2000d , apj , 543 , 90 huang y. f. , lu t. , 1997a , a&a , 325 , 189 huang y. f. , lu t. , 1997b , chin
, 14 , 314 jha s. , kirshner r. p. , matheson t. , garnavich p. m. , monnelly g. p. , vanderspek r. k. , 2001 , gcn 1183 kippen r. m. , woods p. m. , heise j. , int zand j. , preece r. d. , briggs m. s. , 2001 , astro - ph/0102277 kulkarni s. r. et al . , 1999 ,
nat , 398 , 389 kumar p. , piran t. , 2000 , apj , 535 , 152 lamb d. q. , 2000 , phys .
report , 333 , 505 lithwick y. , sari r. , 2001 , apj , 555 , 540 macfadyen a. i. , woosley s. e. , 1999 , apj , 524 , 262 mszros p. , rees m. j. , 1992 , mnras , 257 , 29p mszros p. , rees m. j. , 1999 , mnras , 306 , l39 mszros p. , rees m. j. , wijers r. a. m. j. , 1998 , apj , 499 , 301 mszros p. , rees m. j. , wijers r. a. m. j. , 1999 , new astron , 4 , 303 mszros p. , waxman e. , 2001 , phys rev lett , 87 , 171102 mitra a. , 2000 , a&a , 359 , 413 moderski r. , sikora m. , bulik t. , 2000 , apj , 529 , 151 paczyski b. , 2000 , pasp , 112 , 1281 panaitescu a. , kumar p. , 2000 , apj , 543 , 66 panaitescu a. , mszros p. , 1998 ,
apj , 493 , l31 paolis f. d. , ingrosso g. , orlando d. , perrone l. , 2001 , astro - ph/0107589 perna r. , loeb a. , 1998 , apj , 509 , l85 piran t. , 1999 , phys .
report , 314 , 575 pian e. et al .
, 2001 , a&a , 372 , 456 pugliese g. , falcke h. , biermann p. l. , 1999 , a&a , 344 , l37 rees m. j. , 1999 , a&as , 138 , 491 rhoads j. , 1997 , apj , 487 , l1 rhoads j. , 2001 , apj , 557,943 ricker g. et al . , 2001 ,
gcn 1165 rol e. et al . ,
2000 , apj , 544 , 707 rossi e. , lazzati d. , rees m. j. , 2002 , mnras , in press ( astro - ph/0112083 ) sagar r. , pandey s. b. , mohan v. , bhattacharya d. , castro - tirado a. j. , 2001 , bull .
india , 29 , 1 sari r. , piran t. , narayan r. , 1998 , apj , 497 , l17 totani t. , 1999 , mnras , 307 , l41 vanden berk d. e. et al . , 2002 ,
apj submitted ( astro - ph/0111054 ) van paradijs j. , kouveliotou c. , wijers r. a. m. j. , 2000 , ara&a , 38 , 379 wang x. , loeb a. , 2001 , apj , 552 , 49 wijers r. a. m. j. et al . , 1999 ,
apj , 523 , l33 zhu j. et al . , 1999 , | it is believed that orphan afterglow searches can help to measure the beaming angle in gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) .
great expectations have been put on this method .
we point out that the method is in fact not as simple as we originally expected . due to the baryon - rich environment that is common to almost all popular progenitor models
, there should be many failed gamma - ray bursts , i.e. , fireballs with lorentz factor much less than 100 1000 , but still much larger than unity .
in fact , the number of failed gamma - ray bursts may even be much larger than that of successful bursts .
owing to the existence of these failed gamma - ray bursts , there should be many orphan afterglows even if grbs are due to isotropic fireballs , then the simple discovery of orphan afterglows never means that grbs be collimated . unfortunately , to distinguish a failed - grb orphan and a jetted but off - axis grb orphan is not an easy task .
the major problem is that the trigger time is unknown . some possible solutions to the problem
are suggested .
= -0.5 in stars : neutron ism : jets and outflows gamma - rays : bursts |
the interaction between a movable mirror and the radiation field of an optical cavity has recently been the subject of extensive theoretical and experimental investigations . these optomechanical systems couple the mechanical motion to an optical field directly via radiation pressure buildup in a cavity .
the coupling of mechanical and optical degrees of freedom via radiation pressure has been a subject of early research in the context of laser cooling @xcite and gravitational - wave detectors @xcite .
recently there has been a great surge of interest in the application of radiation forces to manipulate the center - of - mass motion of mechanical oscillators covering a huge range of scales from macroscopic mirrors in the laser interferometer gravitational wave observatory ( ligo ) project @xcite to nano - mechanical cantilevers@xcite , vibrating microtoroids@xcite membranes@xcite and bose - einstein condensates @xcite .
the quantum optical properties of a mirror coupled via radiation pressure to a cavity field show interesting similarities to an intracavity kerr - like interaction @xcite .
recently , in the context of classical investigations of nonlinear regimes , the dynamical instability of a driven cavity having a movable mirror has been investigated @xcite .
theoretical work has proposed to use the radiation - pressure coupling for quantum non - demolition measurements of the light field @xcite .
it has been shown that ground state cooling of micro - mechanical mirror is possible only in the resolved side band regime ( rsb ) where the mechanical resonance frequency exceeds the bandwidth of the driving resonator @xcite .
the cooling of mechanical oscillators in the rsb regime at high driving power can entail the appearance of normal mode splitting ( nms ) @xcite .
recently , it was shown that an optical parametric amplifier inside a cavity considerably improves the cooling of a micro - mechanical mirror by radiation pressure @xcite . in this paper , we consider the dynamics of a movable mirror interacting with a nonlinear optical cavity mode and predict novel properties of the dynamics of the system .
giant optical kerr nonlinearities are obtained by placing a @xmath0 medium inside a cavity@xcite .
this gives rise to a strong nonlinear interactions between photons .
a single photon in a cavity can block the injection of a second photon due to a photon blockade effect .
we show that due to the photon blockade mechanism , as the kerr nonlinearity is increased , the nms progressively decreases .
we consider an optical kerr medium with @xmath0 nonlinearity inside a fabry - perot cavity with one fixed partially transmitting mirror and one movable totally reflecting mirror in contact with a thermal bath in equilibrium at temperature @xmath1 , as shown in fig.1 .
the movable mirror is treated as a quantum mechanical harmonic oscillator with effective mass @xmath2 , frequency @xmath3 and energy decay rate @xmath4 .
the system is also coherently driven by a laser field with frequency @xmath5 through the cavity mirror with amplitude @xmath6 .
it is well known that high - q optical cavities can significantly isolate the system from its environment , thus strongly reducing decoherence and ensuring that the light field remains quantum - mechanical for the duration of the experiment .
we also assume that the induced resonance frequency shift of the cavity and the nonlinear interaction coefficient @xmath7 are much smaller than the longitudinal mode spacing , so that we restrict the model to a single longitudinal mode @xmath8 .
we also assume that @xmath9 ( adiabatic limit ) ; @xmath10 is the speed of light in vacuum and @xmath11 the cavity length in the absence of the cavity field .
the total hamiltonian of the system in a frame rotating at the laser frequency @xmath5 can be written as @xmath12 here @xmath13 and @xmath14 are the annihilation and creation operators for the cavity field respectively .
also @xmath15 and @xmath16 are the position and momentum operators for the movable mirror .
the parameter @xmath17 is the coupling parameter between the cavity field and the movable mirror and @xmath7 is the anharmonicity parameter and is proportional to the third - order nonlinear susceptibility @xmath0 of the kerr medium : @xmath18/2\epsilon_{0}v_{c}$ ] , @xmath19 is the dielectric constant of the medium and @xmath20 is the volume of the cavity .
the input laser field populates the intracavity mode which couples to the movable mirror through the radiation pressure .
the field in turn is modified by the back - action of the cantilever .
it is important to notice the nonlinearity in eqn .
( [ eff ] ) arising from the coupling between the intracavity intensity and the position operator of the mirror .
the system we are considering is intrinsically open as the cavity field is damped by the photon - leakage through the massive coupling mirror and the mirror is connected to a bath at finite temperature . in the absence of the radiation - pressure coupling , the cantilever would undergo a pure brownian motion driven by its contact with the thermal environment .
the motion of the system can be described by the following quantum langevin equations : @xmath21 @xmath22 @xmath23 here @xmath24 is the input vacuum noise operator and it obeys the following correlation functions : @xmath25 @xmath26 the force @xmath27 is the brownian noise operator resulting from the coupling of the movable mirror to the thermal bath , whose mean value is zero , and has the following correlation function at temperature @xmath1 : @xmath28 d\omega,\ ] ] where @xmath29 is the boltzmann constant and @xmath1 is the thermal bath temperature .
the steady state values of @xmath16 , @xmath15 and @xmath13 are obtained as : @xmath30 @xmath31 @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the effective cavity detuning which includes the radiation pressure effects . here
@xmath34 denotes the new equilibrium position of the mirror while @xmath35 denotes the steady state amplitude of the cavity field .
both @xmath34 and @xmath35 displays multistable behaviour due to the nonlinear interaction between the mirror and the cavity field . from the above equations we clearly see how the mirror dynamics affects the steady state of the intracavity field .
the coupling to the mirror shifts the cavity resonance frequency and changes the field inside the cavity in a way to induce a new stationary intensity .
the change occurs after a transient time depending on the response of the cavity and strength of the coupling to the mirror .
here we show that the coupling of the mechanical oscillator and the cavity field fluctuations in the presence of the kerr medium leads to the inhibition of the normal mode splitting ( nms ) .
the optomechanical nms however involves driving two parametrically coupled nondegenerate modes out of equilibrium .
the nms does not appear in the steady state spectra but rather manifests itself in the fluctuation spectra of the mirror displacement . to this end
, we write each canonical operator of the system as a sum of its steady - state mean value and a small fluctuation with zero mean value , @xmath36 , @xmath37 , @xmath38 and linearize to obtain the following heisenberg - langevin equations for the fluctuation operators @xmath39 @xmath40 @xmath41 here we will always assume @xmath42 .
( [ fluc1 ] , [ fluc2 ] , [ fluc3 ] ) and their hermitian conjugates constitute a system of four first order coupled operator equations , for which the routh - hurwitz criterion implies that the system is stable for the following conditions : @xmath43 @xmath44 @xmath45^{2}+[\delta+4 \eta |a_{s}|^{2}]^{2 } \right\rbrace + \dfrac{\hbar g_{m}^{2 } \eta}{m}(a_{s}^{2}+a_{s}^{*2})^{2}-\omega_{m}^{2 } \eta^{2}(a_{s}^{2}+a_{s}^{*2})^{2}-\dfrac{2 \hbar g_{m}^{2 } |a_{s}|^{2}}{m}(\delta+4 \eta |a_{s}|^{2})>0.\ ] ] the study of these conditions reveals the point at which the system enters an unstable regime . here
, we will restrict ourselves to the stable regime .
we now transform to the quadratures : @xmath46 , @xmath47 , @xmath48 and @xmath49 .
the position fluctuations of the movable mirror in fourier space is given by @xmath50 \xi ( \omega)-i \hbar g_{m } \sqrt{2 \kappa}[(\omega+i \kappa+\delta)a_{s}^ { * } \delta a_{in}+(\omega+i \kappa-\delta)a_{s } \delta a_{in}^{\dagger}]\right\rbrace,\ ] ] where @xmath51[(\kappa - i \omega)^{2}+\delta'^{2}]-2
\hbar g'^{2}_{m } \delta''$ ] , @xmath52 , @xmath53 , @xmath54 , @xmath55 , @xmath56 and @xmath57 . in the above equation for @xmath58 ,
the term proportional to @xmath59 arises from thermal noise , while the term proportional to @xmath60 originates from radiation pressure .
the displacement spectrum is obtained from @xmath61 together with the correlation functions : @xmath62 @xmath63 \delta(\omega+\omega).\ ] ] the displacement spectrum in fourier space is finally obtained as : @xmath64 where , @xmath65-i \omega \gamma_{eff},\ ] ] @xmath66 @xmath67 for two values of the nonlinear coefficient : @xmath68(thin line ) and @xmath69 ( thick line ) .
parameters used are : @xmath70 , @xmath71 , @xmath72 and @xmath73 . clearly for a finite value of @xmath7
the nms slowly becomes less prominent . ]
any information about the mirror s modified motion can be obtained from the study of @xmath74 .
an immediate observation reveals that @xmath74 is peaked at a frequency @xmath75 . in the expression for @xmath74 , the first term represents the contribution due to the thermal contact with the bath while the second term is attributed to the contribution due to radiation pressure . in the absence of radiation pressure
any dependence from the effective detuning @xmath76 vanishes and the resulting spectrum is simply that of a harmonic oscillator undergoing brownian motion at temperature @xmath1 . in fig.2
, we show the plot of @xmath74 as a function of @xmath77 for @xmath68(thin line ) and @xmath69(thick line ) . in the absence of kerr nonlinearity
, a clear nms is observed in the displacement spectrum .
the nms is associated to a mixing between the mechanical mode and the fluctuation around the steady state of the cavity field . in the presence of finite kerr nonlinearity ,
we notice the absence of nms .
the absence of nms in the presence of kerr nonlinearity is understood as follows : if @xmath78 , the applied field will couple the vacuum state to the fock state with single photon resonantly .
the higher lying photon - number states may be neglected since they are out of resonance .
now if initially a photon from the driving field is injected in the cavity with a probability determined by the drive strength .
however , injection of a second photon will be blocked , since the presence of two photons in the cavity will require an aditional @xmath79 energy , which can not be provided by the pump laser . only after the first photon leaves the cavity
can a second photon be injected .
the strong interactions between the photons therefore causes a photon ( kerr ) blockade of cavity transmission and this drastically reduces the photon number fluctuation . in any case if @xmath80 , the cavity would contain more than one photon and the above argument is still valid due to the photon - photon repulsion .
we now return to the linearized heisenberg - langevin equations ( [ fluc1 ] , [ fluc2 ] , [ fluc3 ] ) and calculate the corresponding eigenfrequencies that determine the dynamics of nms .
in particular , we focus on the following : ( i ) @xmath81 , ( ii ) @xmath82 , ( iii ) @xmath42 and ( iv ) @xmath83 . the two eigenfrequencies are found to be : @xmath84 where , @xmath85 and @xmath86 .
there is another pair of eigenfrequencies @xmath87 . for @xmath68 , @xmath88 and @xmath89 , the square root term of @xmath90
is real for @xmath91 and shows nms . on the other hand , for @xmath92
, nms is exhibited for @xmath93 .
next we analyze the influence of the kerr nonlinearity on the backaction cooling of the movable mirror .
the effective temperature is defined by the total energy of the movable mirror , @xmath94 @xcite , where @xmath95 , @xmath96 and @xmath97 .
this basically means that the effective temperature is proportional to the displacement spectrum . from fig.2
, we observe that the displacement spectrum for @xmath98 is always more than that for @xmath99 . from this
we conclude that @xmath100 @xmath101 @xmath102 .
we can come to this conclusion also from the fact that there is a reduction in the number of photons ( hence radiation pressure ) in the cavity due to photon - photon repulsion due to the presence of the kerr medium and hence an increase in the temperature of the movable mirror .
an important point to note is that in order to observe the nms , the energy exchange between the two modes(mechanical and photon number fluctuation ) should take place on a time scale faster than the decoherence of each mode .
also the parameter regime in which nms may appear implies cooling . on the negative detuning side ,
the observation of nms is prevented by the onset of parametric instability . to demonstrate that the dynamics investigated here are within experimental reach
, we discuss the experimental parameters from @xcite : from @xcite , the mechanical frequency @xmath103 and @xmath104 . the coupling rate @xmath105 .
from @xcite , the kerr nonlinearity is numerically estimated to be about @xmath106 for extremely strong photon - photon repulsion . here we take @xmath107 .
the energy of the cavity mode decreases due to the photon loss through the cavity mirrors , which leads to a reduced atom - field coupling .
photon loss can be minimized by using high - q cavities .
our proposed detection scheme relies crucially on the fact that coherent dynamics dominate over the losses .
it is important that the characteristic time - scales of coherent dynamics are significantly faster than those associated with losses ( the decay rate of state - of - art optical cavities is typically 17 khz @xcite ) .
in summary we have analyzed the influence of a kerr medium on the dynamics of a micro - mechanical movable mirror .
we have shown that as the kerr nonlinearity increases , the normal mode splitting ( nms ) progressively weakens .
this is attributed to the photon blockade mechanism which decreases the photon fluctuations due to photon - photon repulsion .
further we found that the temperature of the micro - mechanical mirror is enhanced due to the presence of the kerr medium.the present scheme could also be used to detect the photonic repulsion effect .
t. w. hansch and a. l. schawlow , optics comm .
* 13 * , 68 ( 1975 ) .
d. j. wineland , r. e. drullinger and f. l. walls , phy . rev . letts . *
40 * , 1639 ( 1978 ) .
s. chu , l. hollberg , j. e. bjorkholm , a. cable and a. ashkin , phy .
letts . * 55 * , 48 ( 1985 ) .
c m caves , phys . rev .
letts , * 45 * , 75 1980 , r. loudon , phys .
letts , * 47 * , 815 ( 1981 ) .
t. corbitt and n. mavalvala , j. opt .
b : quantum semi - class . opt .
* 6 * , s675 ( 2004 ) .
t. corbitt et al . , phy .
letts . * 98 * , 150802 ( 2007 ) . c. hhberger - metzger and k. karrai , nature * 432 * , 1002 ( 2004 ) .
s. gigan et al .
, nature * 444 * , 67 ( 2006 ) .
o. arcizet et al . ,
nature * 444 * , 71 ( 2006 ) .
d. kleckner and d. bouwmeester , nature * 444 * , 75 ( 2006 ) .
i. favero et al .
* 90 * , 90 , 104101 ( 2007 ) . c. regal , j. teufel and k. lehnert , nature * 4 * , 555 ( 2008 ) .
t. carmon et al . , phys .
letts . * 94 * , 223902 ( 2005 ) .
a. schliesser et al . , phys .
letts . * 97 * , 243905 ( 2006 ) .
j. d. thompson et al . ,
nature * 452 * , 72 ( 2008 ) .
f. brennecke et al . , science * 322 * , 235 ( 2008 ) .
k. w. murch et al . , nature physics * 4 * , 561 ( 2008 ) .
c. fabre et al . , phys .
a , * 49 * , 1337 ( 1994 ) , s. mancini and p. tombesi , phys .
a , * 49 * , 4055 ( 1994 ) . f. marquardt , j. g. e. harris and s. girvin , appl .
lett . , * 96 * , 103901 ( 2006 ) .
braginsky and f. khalili , quantum measurements ( cambridge university press , 1992 ) . j. m. dobrindt , et .
al . , phys .
letts , * 101 * , 263602 ( 2008 ) .
s. huang and g. s. agarwal , phys .
a , * 79 * , 013821 ( 2009 ) .
a. imamoglu , h. schmidt , g. woods and m. deutsch , phys .
letts , * 79 * , 1467 ( 1997 ) .
r. p. stanley , et .
al . , appl .
letts , * 65 * , 2093 ( 1994 ) .
e. k. lindmark , et .
optics letts . , * 21 * , 994 ( 1996 ) .
a. schliesser et al . ,
nature phys . , * 4 * , 415 ( 2008 ) .
j. klinner , m. lindholdt , b. nagorny and a. hemmerich , phys .
letts . , * 96 * , 023002 ( 2006 ) . | we consider the dynamics of a movable mirror ( cantilever ) of a nonlinear optical cavity . we show that a @xmath0 medium with a strong kerr nonlinearity placed inside a cavity inhibits the normal mode splitting ( nms ) due to the photon blockade mechanism .
this study demonstrates that nms could be used as a tool to observe the photon blockade effect .
we also found that the backaction cooling of the movable mirror is reduced in the presence of the kerr medium . |
the searches for the higgs boson and new phenomena beyond the standard model of fundumental interactions are important tasks for the new particle accelerator the large hadron collider . the most popular direction beyond the sm is low energy supersymmetry .
however , it is not clear how supersymmetry is realized .
the simplest case the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm)@xcite is studied in detailes , however possible deviations from it are of great interest as well .
there exists a wide class of models which contain so called @xmath0-parity breaking interactions leading to the violation of lepton and baryon numbers@xcite .
these models have a number of new coupling constants , some of them are badly constrained , for instance , by rare processes , other ones are less restricted .
in this letter we consider the model with the neutrino yukawa interactions and related @xmath0-parity violating term in the superpotential . the interesting consequence of including the @xmath0-parity violating @xmath1 term is the modification of the tree - level expressions for the higgs boson masses and upper bound on the lightest higgs boson mass in the mssm .
in this chapter we consider general features of supersymmetric theories related to the scalar potential , its minima , and masses of the physical higgs boson states .
it is well known that in these theories the scalar potential is not an arbitrary function of the fields but is fixed by supersymmetry .
the sources of the higgs scalar potential are @xmath3-terms coming from gauge - higgs interactions , @xmath2-terms originating from the superpotential , and soft supersymmetry breaking terms : @xmath4 in the mssm based on the @xmath5 symmetry group the @xmath3-term contribution reads @xmath6 where the sum is taken over the gauge groups , their generators , and scalar components of the chiral higgs superfields . from the @xmath0-parity conserving mssm superpotential @xmath7
only the higgs mixing @xmath8-term @xmath9 gives the contribution to the @xmath2-part of the @xmath10 : @xmath11 the higgs doublets are defined as @xmath12 and the `` dot '' operation ( @xmath13 ) denotes the @xmath14 convolution of the ( super)fields doublets with the help of the totally antisymmetric @xmath15-tensor .
soft supersymmetry breaking is parametrized by the mass terms for the corresponding scalar components of the higgs superfields and an analogue of the higgs mixing term @xmath16 @xmath17 the final form of the higgs scalar potential then reads @xmath18 & + & b\mu \left(h^+_{\rm u}h^-_{\rm d}-h^0_{\rm u}h^0_{\rm d}\right ) + { \rm h.c . }
\nonumber \\ & + & \frac{g^2+g^{\prime 2}}{8}\bigl(|h^+_{\rm u}|^2 + |h^0_{\rm u}|^2-|h^0_{\rm d}|^2-|h^-_{\rm d}|^2\bigr)^2 \nonumber \\ & + & \frac{g^2}{2}\left|h^+_{\rm u}h^{0\dagger}_{\rm d}+h^0_{\rm u}h^{-\dagger}_{\rm d}\right|^2 .
\label{eq : vscal_mssm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] to calculate the masses of physical higgs boson states one has to take the second derivatives of the scalar potential ( [ eq : vscal_mssm ] ) with respect to the corresponding real and imaginary components of the higgs fields taken at the minima and then diagonalize the mass - squared matrices .
then one gets the following expressions@xcite for the mass of the @xmath19-odd higgs boson @xmath20 @xmath21 for the heavy and the lightest neutral @xmath19-even higgs bosons @xmath22 and @xmath23 @xmath24 and for the pair of charged higgs bosons @xmath25 @xmath26 three mass eigenstates remain zero corresponding to the goldstone bosons eaten by @xmath27 gauge bosons in the higgs mechanism .
here we have introduced the standard notation @xmath28 the ratio of the vacuum expectation values of the neutral components of the two higgs boson doublets .
the assumption @xmath29 in eqn.([eq : masshh ] ) leads to the well - known tree - level expression for the lightest mssm higgs boson mass @xmath30 and the famous inequality @xmath31 however , radiative corrections coming mainly from the top - stop loops badly violate this inequality@xcite . for the loop corrected lightest higgs mass one has @xmath32 which shift the mass bound upwards@xcite .
renormgroup resummation of all - order leading log contributions using effective potential approach slightly changes the predictions@xcite . besides
, the mssm scenario with @xmath33 is excluded experimentally by non - observation of the higgs boson lighter than 114 gev .
the superpotential of the standard model ( [ eq : wmssm ] ) is constructed under assumption that neutrinos are massless ( there are no yukawa interactions for the neutrinos which can generate dirac neutrino mass terms after the electroweak symmetry breaking ) and the @xmath0-parity is conserved . in this case
it repeats ( up to notations ) the yukawa part of the standard model lagrangian .
however , it is believed nowadays that neutrinos have masses , even tiny , then the neutrino yukawa term @xmath34 in the superpotential is possible and should be included ( @xmath35 here are @xmath14 singlet right - handed neutrino superfields , and @xmath36 are neutrino yukawa couplings ) .
the latter implies that one also has to include a term @xmath37 to the @xmath0-violating part ( recall that @xmath38 and @xmath39 superfields have the same quantum numbers and no symmetries but lepton number are violated ) .
therefore we consider the superpotential of the model in the form : @xmath40 the soft supersymmetry breaking lagrangian also includes the following terms : @xmath41 ( @xmath42 here are scalar components of the corresponding superfields ) . the model with this kind of superpotential has been previously considered and studied@xcite , however the authors were mainly interested in the solution of the @xmath8-problem rather than higgs mass predictions in the model .
note also , that for simplicity we do not consider sneutrino v.e.v .
the @xmath43 term gives the @xmath2-type contribution to the higgs self - coupling , and the higgs scalar potential now reads @xmath44 & = & \left(|\mu|^2 + m^2_{{\rm h}_{\rm u}}\right)\left(|h^+_{\rm u}|^2+|h^0_{\rm u}|^2\right ) + \left(|\mu|^2 + m^2_{{\rm h}_{\rm d}}\right)\left(|h^0_{\rm d}|^2+|h^-_{\rm d}|^2\right ) \nonumber \\[1 mm ] & + & b\mu \left(h^+_{\rm u}h^-_{\rm d}-h^0_{\rm u}h^0_{\rm d}\right ) + { \rm h.c .
} \nonumber \\ & + & \frac{g^2+g^{\prime 2}}{8}\bigl(|h^+_{\rm u}|^2 + |h^0_{\rm u}|^2-|h^0_{\rm d}|^2-|h^-_{\rm d}|^2\bigr)^2 + \frac{g^2}{2}\left|h^+_{\rm u}h^{0\dagger}_{\rm d}+h^0_{\rm u}h^{-\dagger}_{\rm d}\right|^2 \nonumber \\ &
+ & \left|\lambda_\nu^i \lambda_\nu^i \right| \left| h^+_{\rm u } h^-_{\rm d } - h^0_{\rm u } h^0_{\rm d } \right|^2 .
\label{eq : vscalhr}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the minimization conditions for the potential ( [ eq : vscalhr ] ) have an additional term due to new neutrino - higgs interaction ( the notation @xmath45 is introduced ) : @xmath46
now it is easy to calculate the masses of the higgs bosons in our model .
taking the second derivatives of the potential ( [ eq : vscalhr ] ) with respect to @xmath47 and @xmath47 in the minimum one gets for the elements of the @xmath19-odd higgs boson mass - squared matrix : @xmath48 the mass eigenstates are then given by @xmath49 the zero eigenstate of the matrix ( [ eq : a0matrix11 ] ) @xmath50.\ ] ] is the the goldstone boson eaten by the @xmath51 boson in the higgs mechanism , while the combination @xmath52\ ] ] is the @xmath19-odd neutral higgs boson @xmath20 with the mass expression @xmath53 sometimes it is more convenient to use @xmath54 instead of the @xmath55 parameter , they are related via ( [ eq : massa0 ] ) . let us now look at the masses of @xmath19-even higgs boson @xmath56 and @xmath57 , the latter corresponds to the lightest higgs boson in the mssm .
the mass - squared matrix is obtained by differentiating twice the potential ( [ eq : vscalhr ] ) with respect to the @xmath58 and @xmath59 and substituting the expression for the vacuum expectation values ( [ eq : mincon1 ] ) and ( [ eq : mincon2 ] ) .
one has , for instance @xmath60 the neutral @xmath19-even higgs boson mass - squared matrix then reads @xmath61 the masses of physical eigenstates are then given by @xmath62 where the quantity @xmath63 related to the new @xmath0-violating neutrino - higgs interactions considered above reads @xmath64 in the limiting case @xmath65 one gets @xmath66 which reproduces the mssm tree - level upper bound for the lightest mssm higgs boson at @xmath67 @xmath68 thus we conclude that in our model the higgs mass constraint is less stringent .
fig.[fig : hmass_vs_tan ] illustrates the dependence of the upper bound for the lightest supersymmetric higgs mass as a function of @xmath69 for various values of the @xmath70 parameter .
it is easily observed that the bigger the value of @xmath70 , the higher the mass bound . in particular , this takes place for small values of @xmath69 , thus making the parameter space less constrained , and slightly open the scenario with low @xmath69 excluded in the mssm by non - observation of the higgs boson lighter than 114 gev ( fig.[fig : param_space ] ) . for the moderate and large @xmath71
the contribution proportional to @xmath72 is practically negligible , and the higgs mass bound as well as the excluded region in the parameter space practically coincides with those of the mssm .
note , that the modified upper bound on the lightest higgs mass ( [ eq : massh_nu ] ) has the same form as in the next - to - minimal supersymmetric standard model ( nmssm ) @xmath73 where @xmath74 is the coupling of the three @xmath14 singlet higgs superfields . for completeness
we also calculate the charged higgs boson masses which get negative contribution from the @xmath75 term .
the charged higgs mass - squared matrix reads @xmath76 and the physical state mass is @xmath77 the zero mass eigenstate corresponds to the goldstone boson eaten by @xmath78-boson .
we have not considered in this letter the possible bilinear @xmath0-parity violating term @xmath79 in the superpotential , since for our purposes it is practically irrelevant .
its presence leads only to the redefinition of the higgs scalar potential parameters , while the higgs mass relations ( [ eq : massa0 ] ) , ( [ eq : masshh ] ) , and ( [ eq : masshch ] ) remain unchanged .
our goal is to demonstrate the possibility of relaxing the upper bound on the lightest supersymmetric higgs .
in conclusion we summarize the main results of this letter .
we have shown that introducing the yukawa interactions of neutrinos @xmath80 leading to their dirac mass terms and consequently the possible @xmath0-parity violating terms @xmath81 modifies the expressions of the higgs boson masses since the latter gives @xmath2-type contribution to the higgs scalar potential .
the final expressions for the higgs masses in our toy model are ( [ eq : massa0 ] ) , ( [ eq : masshh ] ) , ( [ eq : masshch ] ) and the tree - level bound on the lightest supersymmetric higgs boson @xmath82 gets the noticable shift upwards for small values of @xmath69 . the shift is compatible with the loop corrections to the tree - level mssm expression .
this opens the part of the parameter space excluded by the non - observation of the light higgs .
the situation looks like as in the nmssm ( [ eq : masshnmssm ] ) . including the bilinear @xmath0-parity violating term @xmath79 will not crucially affect our results .
however , the more detailed study is needed , and the analysis of the full @xmath0-parity violating model with the right - handed neutrinos is under study and will be published elsewhere .
authors are grateful to d.i . kazakov and a.v .
bednyakov for fruitful discussions .
financial support from the russian foundation for basic research ( grant # 08 - 02 - 00856 ) and the ministry of education and science of the russian federation ( grant # 3810.2010.2 ) is kindly acknowledged .
nilles , _ phys .
rept . _ * 110 * , 1 ( 1984 ) .
haber , g.l .
kane , _ phys .
rept . _ * 117 * , 75 ( 1985 ) .
gladyshev , d.i .
kazakov , _ phys . atom .
nucl . _ * 70 * , 1553 ( 2007 ) .
aitchison , _ supersymmetry and the mssm : an elementary introduction _ , e - print : hep - ph/0505105 .
r. barbier _ et al .
_ , _ phys .
rept . _ * 420 * , 1 ( 2005 ) , and references therein .
j.r . ellis , g. ridolfi , f. zwirner , _ phys .
* b262 * , 477 ( 1991 ) .
a. brignole , j.r .
ellis , g. ridolfi , f. zwirner , _ phys .
* b271 * , 123 ( 1991 ) .
gladyshev , d.i .
kazakov , w. de boer , g. burkart , r. ehret , _ nucl .
* b498 * , 3 ( 1997 ) .
pierce , j.a .
bagger , k.t .
matchev , r. zhang , _ nucl .
phys . _ * b491 * , 3 ( 1997 ) .
m. carena , m. quiros , c.e.m .
wagner , _ nucl .
* b461 * , 407 ( 1996 ) .
s. heinemeyer , w. hollik , g. weiglein , _ phys .
lett . _ * b455 * , 179 ( 1999 ) . s. heinemeyer , w. hollik , g. weiglein , _ eur
. phys . j. _ * c9 * , 343 ( 1999 ) .
gladyshev , d.i .
kazakov , _ mod .
lett . _ * a10 * , 3129 ( 1995 ) .
lopez - fogliani , c. munoz , _ phys .
lett . _ * 97 * , 041801 ( 2006 ) .
p. ghosh , s. roy , _ neutrino masses and mixing , lightest neutralino decays and a solution to the @xmath8 problem in supersymmetry _ , e - print : arxiv:0812.0084 [ hep - ph ] . | we consider the supersymmetric extension of the standard model with neutrino yukawa interactions and @xmath0-parity violation .
we found that @xmath0-parity breaking term @xmath1 leads to an additional @xmath2-type contribution to the higgs scalar potential , and thus to the masses of supersymmetric higgs bosons .
the most interesting consequence is the modification of the tree - level expression for the lightest neutral supersymmetric higgs boson mass .
it appears that due to this contribution the bound on the lightest higgs mass may be shifted upwards , thus slightly opening the part of the model parameter space excluded by non - observation of the light higgs boson at lep in the framework of the minimal supersymmetric standard model . |
the random - field ising model ( rfim ) @xcite has been extensively studied both because of its interest as a simple frustrated system and because of its relevance to experiments @xcite .
the hamiltonian describing the model is @xmath4 where @xmath5 are ising spins , @xmath6 is the nearest - neighbors ferromagnetic interaction , @xmath7 is the disorder strength , also called randomness of the system , and @xmath8 are independent quenched random - fields ( rf s ) obtained here from a bimodal distribution of the form @xmath9.\ ] ] various rf probability distributions , such as the gaussian , the wide bimodal distribution ( with a gaussian width ) , and the above bimodal distribution have been considered @xcite .
as it is well known , the existence of an ordered ferromagnetic phase for the rfim , at low temperature and weak disorder , follows from the seminal discussion of imry and ma @xcite , when @xmath10 .
this has provided us with a general qualitative agreement on the sketch of the phase boundary separating the ordered ferromagnetic ( * f * ) phase from the high - temperature paramagnetic ( * p * ) phase . a sketch of the phase boundary of the 3d bimodal rfim , where @xmath11 is the critical disorder strength and @xmath12 the critical temperature of the pure 3d ising model .
the question - mark refers to the mean - field prediction of a tricritical point ( tcp ) , where the transition supposedly changes from second - order at low - fields ( solid line ) to first - order at high - fields ( dotted line).,width=12 ] the phase boundary ( see figure [ fig:1 ] ) separates the two phases of the model and intersects the randomness axis at the critical value of the disorder strength @xmath11 .
this value of @xmath11 is known with good accuracy for both the gaussian and the bimodal rfim to be @xmath13 @xcite and 2.21(1 ) @xcite , respectively .
a most recent detailed numerical investigation of the phase boundary of the 3d bimodal rfim appears in reference @xcite . however , the general behavior of phases and phase transitions in systems with quenched randomness is still controversial @xcite , and one such lively example is the 3d rfim , which , despite @xmath14 years of theoretical and experimental study , is not yet well understood .
in particular , the nature of its phase transition remains unsettled , although it is generally believed that the transition from the ordered to the disordered phase is continuous governed by the zero - temperature random fixed - point @xcite .
for the bimodal rfim , the mean - field prediction @xcite of a first - order region separated from a second - order region by a tcp , remains today an open controversy .
this main issue has regained interest after the recent observations @xcite of first - order - like features at the strong disorder regime .
nowadays , this is the main conflict regarding the nature of the phase transition of the 3d bimodal rfim , although other controversies and scenarios exist in the literature , concerning mainly the intermediate regime of the phase diagram and a possible third spin - glass phase @xcite .
thus , the possibility of a first - order transition at the strong disorder regime has been discussed in several papers and has been supported over the years by numerical and theoretical findings .
the extreme sharpness of the transition reflected in some studies in the estimated very small values of the order - parameter exponent @xmath15 @xcite has also been reinforcing such first - order scenarios .
in particular first - order - like features , such as the appearance of the characteristic double - peak ( dp ) structure of the canonical energy probability density function ( pdf ) , have been recently reported for both the gaussian and the bimodal distributions of the 3d rfim .
particularly , wu and machta @xcite , using the wang - landau ( wl ) approach @xcite , reported such properties for the gaussian rfim at a strong disorder strength value @xmath2 below their critical randomness ( @xmath16 ) .
moreover , hernndez and diep @xcite have emphasized that they have found evidence for the existence of a tcp in the phase diagram of the bimodal rfim , in agreement with the early predictions of mean - field theory @xcite .
these authors have also observed , at the disorder strength value @xmath17 , using standard and histogram monte carlo methods @xcite and more recently the wl algorithm @xcite , the same first - order - like characteristic dp structure and concluded that there is a tcp at some intermediate value of the disorder strength .
the existence of a dp structure in the canonical pdf is related to a convex dip in the microcanonical entropy and it is known that for some systems a mere observation of this structure is not sufficient for the identification of a first - order transition . the baxter - wu @xcite and four - state potts models in 2d @xcite
are well - known examples of such systems undergoing , in the thermodynamic limit , second - order phase transitions .
recently , behringer and pleimling @xcite have demonstrated for these two models that , the appearance of a convex dip in the microcanonical entropy can be traced back to a finite - size effect different from what is expected in a genuine first - order transition . in other words ,
the pseudosignatures of a first - order transition are finite - size effects , which can be understood within a scaling theory of continuous phase transitions and such first - order - like features cease to exist in the thermodynamic limit .
similar first - order - like properties have been observed in many other finite systems , such as the well - known examples of the fixed - magnetization versions of the ising model , where it has been also shown that these finite - size effects disappear in the thermodynamic limit @xcite .
the present paper , is the first extensive numerical investigation of this fundamental issue for the 3d bimodal rfim .
we proceed , having in mind that a mere observation of a first - order structure is not sufficient for the identification of the transition .
this is especially true for the present model , since its critical behavior is obscured by strong and complex finite - size effects , involving also the important issue of the lack of self - averaging @xcite .
thus , for a clear identification of the order of the transition , we implement an appropriate version of the lee - kosterlitz ( lk ) free - energy barrier method @xcite .
initially , we used a straightforward one - range ( one - r ) wl sampling on a set of a small number of rf realizations , at two values of the disorder strength , @xmath2 and @xmath3 .
this attempt enabled us to observe the behavior of the free - energy barrier and the latent heat and indicated that the transition remains continuous at the strong disorder regime . by a second substantial attempt , using a combined more efficient numerical scheme , we simulated large numbers of rf realizations and verified that , indeed , the first - order - like transition signatures are finite - size effects that disappear in the thermodynamic limit .
the remainder of the paper is as follows : subsection [ sec:2a ] gives a summary of the wl and lee methods . in particular , we explain , discuss , and give details of two different numerical strategies , called hereafter as one - r approach and high - level one - r approach .
we continue , in subsection [ sec:2b ] , to present the application of the lk free - energy barrier method @xcite on the numerical data , obtained via a straightforward application of the one - r wl implementation on a small ensemble of rf realizations for two values of the disorder strength , @xmath2 and @xmath3 .
the same method is applied in subsection [ sec:2c ] on the numerical data obtained via a new proposal capable to simulate large numbers of rf realizations , at the disorder strength value @xmath2 . as will be explained in subsection [ sec:2a ]
, this latter strategy is an efficient and accurate wl approach , which combines in three stages , the multi - range ( multi - r ) wl algorithm , the high - level one - r wl approach , and a final quite long lee run , to obtain an alternative , and presumably most accurate , density of states ( dos ) .
subtle points behind the necessity of implementing such an elaborate scheme will be discussed appropriately in the sequel .
finally , we summarize our conclusions in section [ sec:3 ] .
several sophisticated simulation techniques , such as cluster algorithms and flat - histogram approaches , have been used to study the rfim @xcite , while graph theoretical algorithms have been used to study properties of the ground - states of this model @xcite .
entropic sampling methods such as the lee @xcite and wl @xcite methods are efficient alternatives for complex systems and systems that undergo first - order transitions .
accordingly , we will implement a combination of such numerical approaches , based mainly on the wl method , to study the nature of phase transition of the 3d bimodal rfim at the strong disorder regime .
the wl algorithm is one of the most refreshing improvements in monte carlo simulation and has been applied to a broad spectrum of interesting problems in statistical mechanics and biophysics @xcite .
to apply the wl algorithm , an appropriate energy range of interest has to be identified . a wl random walk ( single spin flip )
is performed in this energy subspace .
trials from a spin state with energy @xmath18 to a spin state with energy @xmath19 are accepted according to the transition probability @xmath20.\ ] ] during the wl process the dos @xmath21 is modified ( @xmath22 ) after each spin flip trial by a modification factor @xmath23 .
the wl iterative process ( @xmath24 ) is defined as a process in which successive refinements of the dos are achieved by monotonically decreasing the modification factor @xmath25 .
most implementations use an initial modification factor @xmath26 and a rule @xmath27 , while a @xmath28 flatness criterion ( on the energy histogram ) is applied in order to move to the next refinement level ( @xmath29 ) @xcite .
the wl process is terminated in a sufficiently high - level , at which @xmath30 ( typically @xmath31 ) .
note that the detailed balanced condition is satisfied in the limit @xmath32 .
there have been several papers in recent years dealing with improvements and sophisticated implementations of the wl iterative process @xcite
. some of these suggestions appeared in studies of efficiency and convergence of the wl iterative process @xcite , while others were proposed in applications of the wl scheme in simulating several models of statistical mechanics @xcite . in our recent study , of the first - order transition of the triangular saf model @xcite , we also used a final stage of an unmodified ( @xmath33 ) lee entropic simulation @xcite by applying after , a relatively long run , a lee correction to an already good approximation obtained by the wl process .
this final lee entropic stage will be also followed here and it is hoped that through this practice we improve accuracy , but also obtain an idea of the level of approximation , since starting with a very accurate dos and using a sufficiently long run , the lee correction should produce an almost identical dos . in our implementation of this lee entropic stage , we start with a very good approximation of the dos [ @xmath34 , obtained by the wl process after a large number @xmath35 of wl iterations ( we choose @xmath36 ) in which we follow the above described reduction of the modification factor @xmath37 ( @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath38 ) . this good estimate of the dos is used to determine the transition probabilities [ equation ( [ eq:3 ] ) ] for an unmodified ( @xmath33 ) random walk in energy space , as described by lee @xcite , in a process which obeys now the detailed balance condition ( equation ( 5 ) of reference @xcite ) and produces an almost flat energy histogram @xmath39 in the long run . note that , a completely flat histogram ( besides statistical fluctuations ) will be produced in case one is using the exact dos , as pointed out by lee @xcite . however , provided that the monte carlo time is long compared to the ergodicity time , we obtain a better estimate for the dos , i.e. @xmath40 , by the following prescription : @xmath41 the implementation described above is in fact very similar to the suggestion of reference @xcite for a repeated application of the above lee correction scheme , after a first stage of the wl process consisting of @xmath35 wl iterations .
then , the successive lee corrections obtained by repeated applications of our equation equation ( [ eq:4 ] ) ( equation ( 15 ) of reference @xcite ) will improve the original dos , as shown in reference @xcite .
this repeated application was started in @xcite at an early wl iteration level ( @xmath42 ) and was tested favorably compared to the simple wl process .
the multi - r wl approach is the implementation of the method in which one splits the energy range in many subintervals @xcite .
this is almost a necessity for very large lattices and the subintervals used are slightly overlapping .
the dos s of the separate pieces are joined at the end of the process .
this multi - r approach is , of course , a much faster process compared with a straightforward one - r implementation and in many cases has provided very accurate results for very large systems @xcite .
although , several papers have pointed out problems with the accuracy , efficiency and convergence of the wl method @xcite , several important related questions are still unanswered , or at least , not well understood .
possible distortions ( systematic errors ) induced on the dos by using a multi - r wl approach have not been adequately discussed in the literature . of course ,
boundary effects of wl sampling in restricted energy subspaces ( multi - r processes ) were observed , analyzed and successfully resolved in reference @xcite .
however , subtle effects , coming from the inevitable breaking of the ergodicity of phase space , may be inherent in any restricted energy subspace or multi - r method .
below , we will present a novel case coming from our recent studies of the rfim .
an escape from this novel , rather discouraging case , will be proposed by compromising between the multi - r and the one - r approach . a typical sp energy pdf for a rf realization at the temperature corresponding to the specific heat peak .
three almost coinciding energy pdf s are shown , corresponding to the three approaches discussed in the text , i.e. one - r , multi - r , and high - level one - r .
the pdf s are expressed as a function of the energy per site @xmath43.,width=12 ] the wl method has been already applied to the rfim in several previous studies .
two such recent investigations , directly related to this work , have been presented for the gaussian @xcite and the bimodal rfim @xcite . as pointed out in the introduction , both of these studies have observed and discussed first - order - like properties of the rfim at the strong disorder regime .
the wl method was also implemented , in restricted energy subspaces , for the study of the bimodal rfim in our earlier studies @xcite . in these papers , a systematic restriction of the energy space , with increasing the lattice size , was used and explained in detail in order to further improve the efficiency of the wl method .
this approach followed the general spirit of our earlier proposal of estimating the critical behavior of classical statistical systems via entropic simulation in dominant energy subspaces .
this restrictive version , utilizes the so called critical minimum energy subspace ( crmes ) technique @xcite to locate and study finite - size anomalies of systems by carrying out the random walk only in the dominant energy subspaces .
generally , our finite - size scaling studies have shown that this restrictive practice can be followed in systems undergoing second - order @xcite and also first - order transitions @xcite .
furthermore , in our recent study of the phase diagram of the 3d bimodal rfim @xcite we have used a one - r and looser version of this restrictive scheme . in this case
we have used the high - levels of the one - parametric wl method as a convenient entropic vehicle , by which the accumulation of the two - parametric , exchange - energy , field - energy , histograms would provide , via extrapolation , a good approximation for the two - parameter dos necessary to find several points of the phase diagram .
different energy pdf s for two rf realizations estimated by the numerical approaches discussed in the text : one - r , multi - r , high - level one - r , and final lee .
the pdf s are determined at the temperature where the two peaks are of equal height .
note that , only the rf realization of panel ( b ) shows a large distortion of the dp structure in the case of the multi - r approach , when compared to the other ( one - r ) schemes.,width=16 ] since substantial histogram accumulation is necessary to overcome statistical errors in such an application , the faster multi - r approach was not used and for having a reliable extrapolation scheme the energy spectrum for the simulation was restricted only from the high - energy side , while the entire low - energy part of the spectrum down to the ground - state was included .
for the restriction of the high - energy side we used our data from our previous study of the model at the value @xmath2 .
however , for the larger lattice sizes , one can conveniently avoid the ground - state neighborhood . in the present study
, we initially used the data of this last straightforward one - r approach @xcite to observe the behavior of the dp structure of some typical rf realizations at the strong disorder regime ( @xmath2 and @xmath3 ) .
as already pointed out , these results appear in subsection [ sec:2b ] and are obtained by using a final of @xmath44 wl iteration levels for the smaller lattices up to @xmath45 and a final of @xmath46 wl iteration levels for the larger sizes ( @xmath47 ) .
subsequently , and in order to simulate larger numbers of dp rf realizations , we decided to test carefully and then use a multi - r approach .
thus , we compared the ( energy pdf ) dp s of some typical rf realizations obtained by the one - r approach with the dp s obtained by a usual multi - r approach ( corresponding to the same or an even higher level of the wl process ) .
for some rf realizations the energy pdf graphs almost coincided and this was especially true for the single - peak ( sp ) rf realizations .
but also for several dp rf realizations the corresponding graphs were close enough and within statistical errors .
figures [ fig:2 ] and [ fig:3](a ) show two such examples , one corresponding to a sp rf realization and one to a dp rf realization .
however , for some peculiar dp rf realizations the dp graphs resulting form the multi - r approach were dislocated and with a rather large deviation in their depth , when compared with the dp energy pdf graphs obtained for the same rf realizations by the one - r approach .
figure [ fig:3](b ) shows a characteristic case , corresponding to a serious dislocation and underestimation of the dp structure .
furthermore , it was observed that the dp details were very sensitive to the division of the energy range to subintervals , indicating that the distortion errors were due to the application of the multi - r approach . after several tests
, we concluded that this peculiar problem is related to the division of the dp range in subintervals .
it appears that for some rf realizations , the structure of the convex dip in the microcanonical entropy is not well estimated by using the multi - r approach within the dp range .
we concluded that the details of the convex dip are sensitive to possible subtle violations of ergodicity , induced by the multi - r approach .
thus , we tried to find an alternative that will not suffer from this problem and still be efficient enough so that we could simulate large numbers of rf realizations . the developed method will be called high - level one - r wl approach and is a further sophistication in the same spirit of our earlier practice in optimizing the wl entropic sampling .
it combines the multi - r and the one - r approaches in an almost optimum way and seems to meet the needs of a careful estimation of the dp structure of the present model .
the details of this approach , applied here only for @xmath2 , are as follows . for each lattice size , a wide energy subspace restricted mainly from the high - energy side is divided in relatively small subintervals , of the order of @xmath48 energy levels and a multi - r approach is applied up to the @xmath49 wl iteration level .
this completes the first stage of the approach and the dos obtained is used to estimate for each particular rf realization the dp range .
this identification is easily achieved by using our earlier practice for first - order transitions @xcite , by finding the appropriate temperature of equal height for the two peaks of the energy pdf .
the energy pdf at this temperature is normalized so that the height of the two peaks is unity and corresponds to energies @xmath50 and @xmath51 .
the dp range is now identified as follows : the left - end of the dp subspace is the energy @xmath52 , for which the density becomes greater than @xmath53 starting from @xmath54 and respectively the right - end of the dp subspace is the energy @xmath55 , for which also the density becomes greater than @xmath53 starting from @xmath56 .
having this first approximate identification of the dp subspace , a one - r wl walk is again performed at the level @xmath49 in a subspace which is wider than the dp subspace by a factor of @xmath57 at each end . in other words ,
the left - end @xmath52 is shifted to the left by @xmath57 of the dp range and correspondingly the right - end @xmath55 is shifted to the right by the same amount .
after the @xmath49 one - r approach the ends of the dp subspace are re - estimated and fixed .
the one - r wl approach is then carried on only in this dp subspace for the higher levels @xmath58 , and @xmath44 .
this completes the second stage of our approach .
finally , an unmodified lee random walk is performed in this dp subspace , using the last approximation of the wl dos for the transition rates .
the lee correction is applied at the end to produce an alternative estimate for the dos .
the time duration of this last lee run is taken to be equal to the duration of the four last one - r wl iterations .
for some rf realizations , this one - r process was pushed up to @xmath46 to observe differences and estimate statistical errors . in all cases ,
these statistical errors were very small , much smaller than the observed sample - to - sample fluctuations ( see also discussion in subsection [ sec:2c ] below ) .
we give here some details for the sizes of the dp subspaces involved in the above scheme . for @xmath59 , the initial restricted energy subspace used for the multi - r process was of
the order of @xmath60 energy levels , i.e. counting energy levels from the all minus spin state this was the subspace defined by the levels @xmath61 to @xmath62 .
typically the size of the resulting dp subspace was of the order of @xmath63 energy levels , which is about @xmath64 of the initial restricted energy subspace .
the left - end @xmath52 roughly fluctuated , for a sample of @xmath48 rf realizations , between the levels @xmath65 , while the right - end @xmath55 between the levels @xmath66 . respectively , for @xmath67 the initial restricted energy subspace used for the multi - r process was of the order of @xmath68 energy levels , defined by the levels @xmath69 to @xmath70 . typically , the size of the resulting dp subspace was again of the order of @xmath63 energy levels , which is about @xmath71 of the initial restricted energy subspace . in this case , @xmath52 fluctuated , again for a sample of @xmath48 rf realizations , between the levels @xmath72 , while @xmath55 between the levels @xmath73 . to conclude the above remarks ,
let us point out that , for a typical rf realization , when @xmath59 , a safe dp location is established after the @xmath49 one - r level and consists of about @xmath74 energy levels ( @xmath75 ) .
it is quite astonishing that the same energy space requirements are needed also for @xmath67 and this is related to the final conclusion of this paper , that the dp peak width , in units of energy per site , tends to zero in the limit @xmath76 .
the above remarks clarify also the reasons behind the efficiency of the present proposal ( high - level one - r approach ) .
typically , for one rf realization of a lattice size @xmath45 at the disorder strength value @xmath2 ( figure [ fig:3 ] ) , the simulation time @xmath77 for the one - r wl process , in all the energy subspace ( @xmath78 ) , was of the order of @xmath79 hours performed in a pentium iv 3ghz .
the simulation times corresponding to the other cases presented in panel ( b ) of figure [ fig:3 ] are as follows : multi - r approach @xmath80 and high - level one - r wl approach together with the final lee run @xmath81 .
we may also point out , that very recently , fernndez @xcite , have found that the phase space for the first - order transition of the 3d site - diluted four - states potts model is reduced , as compared with the expectations from simulations in small lattice sizes , a behavior very similar to the above observations .
their microcanonical approach @xcite may also be an interesting alternative , not used previously , for the study of the present model . in this subsection
, we present the application of the lk method on the numerical data obtained by the one - r wl method .
as mentioned in the previous subsection , the one - r approach on both values of the disorder strength ( @xmath2 and @xmath3 ) was applied in a wide energy spectrum and we have conveniently avoided a suitable ground - state neighborhood .
the total number of rf realizations simulated ( @xmath82 ) varies from @xmath83 realizations for @xmath84 to @xmath85 realizations for @xmath86 . from a traditional point of view , the nature of a phase transition can be , in principle , determined by examining the finite - size scaling of various thermodynamic quantities , such as the specific heat and susceptibility peaks .
these two quantities , as well as others , are expected , from the general theory of first - order transition , to follow an @xmath87 divergence and may be used as indicators of the order of the transition .
however , this practice is very often inconclusive even for simple systems and may be seriously questioned for random systems in which fundamental and subtle problems exist concerning the averaging process over disorder . for the present rfim , the lack of self - averaging observed by the present authors @xcite
( see also references @xcite ) , may be of crucial importance especially in trying to construct convenient indicators for the nature of the transition at the strong disorder regime .
first - order - like realizations are expected to exhibit sharp specific heat and susceptibility peaks , such as that observed also in the gaussian case studied by wu and machta @xcite .
therefore , according to our previous papers @xcite and as pointed out also in reference @xcite the information concerning an individual first - order - like realization will be washed out - as a result of the strong fluctuation in the pseudocritical temperature - in considering for instance the behavior of the average specific heat curve . from the above discussion
, it is obvious that in order to avoid problems with the lack of self - averaging property , the first - order - like features of each realization must be computed separately and the disorder average should be applied at the end in the proper first - order indicator .
the most convenient approach in this case is to use the free - energy barrier method proposed by lee and kosterlitz @xcite .
( a ) energy pdf at the temperature where the two peaks are of equal height for a first - order - like rf realization of a lattice size @xmath45 at disorder strength @xmath3 .
the inset shows the corresponding sharp specific heat peak .
( b ) ratio @xmath88 of realizations showing a dp energy pdf in an ensemble of @xmath82 number of realizations as a function of the linear system size @xmath89 .
set a : @xmath90 ( open triangles ) and @xmath91 ( filled squares ) .
set b : @xmath92 ( filled circles).,width=16 ] this method has been already successfully applied by chen @xcite for the study of an analogous disordered system , namely the two - dimensional eight - state potts model with quenched bond randomness .
thus , we will proceed now to apply the lk method for the identification of the transition of the bimodal rfim at the strong disorder regime .
the method is well - known and has been widely applied to several spin models @xcite , so we will proceed giving only the necessary definitions adapted to the present disordered system . figure [ fig:4](a ) illustrates , in the main frame , the typical dp energy probability distribution ( seed @xmath93 ) and in the inset the corresponding sharp specific heat peak of a first - order - like realization on a cubic lattice of linear lattice size @xmath45 at the disorder value @xmath3 . with the help of this figure ,
let us define the surface tension @xmath94 for each dp realization , where the definition of the lk free - energy barrier is , using the canonical energy pdf @xmath95 , @xmath96}$ ] ( @xmath97 , as in figure [ fig:2 ] ) .
therefore , with the help of only the generated dp realizations ( @xmath98 is their number , see also the discussion below ) , we define the disorder average of the surface tension , which is proposed as the relevant indicator representing the ensemble of dp realizations , as @xmath99_{av}=\frac{1}{n_{dp}}\sum_{i=1}^{n_{dp}}\sigma_{i}(l).\ ] ] the second important ingredient in the size development of the observed first - order - like properties of the 3d bimodal rfim is the behavior of the width @xmath100 of the individual dp s , representing the latent heat of the transition , in the case of a first - order transition .
again with the help of the illustration in figure [ fig:4](a ) , we define the disorder average over the ensemble of dp realizations of the width of the transition as @xmath101_{av}=\frac{1}{n_{dp}}\sum_{i=1}^{n_{dp}}\delta e_{i}(l).\ ] ] figure [ fig:4](b ) presents the relative number of such first - order - like realizations @xmath98 , in a total number of @xmath82 realizations . set a refers to the straightforward one - r wl approach for the two values @xmath2 and @xmath3 of the disorder strength .
the observed increase with lattice size of the probability for such first - order - like realizations , is in qualitative agreement with the general behavior reported by wu and machta @xcite for the gaussian rfim . from table v of reference @xcite one observes a general tendency of the ratio @xmath88 to increase with the system size and the disorder strength and since we are studying the system at a relatively higher disorder strength value , our ratios are quite comparable with those given in table v of reference @xcite , although the latter refer to the gaussian rfim . clearly , at the strong disorder regime and as the lattice size increases , the percentage of realizations showing a dp in the energy probability distribution increases and approaches unity very rapidly .
@xmath102-behavior of @xmath103_{av}$ ] ( a ) and @xmath104_{av}$ ] ( b ) at @xmath2 ( open circles ) and @xmath3 ( filled circles ) for @xmath105 .
sample - to - sample fluctuations are illustrated by the error bars .
the solid and dotted lines are corresponding linear fits for the larger sizes ( @xmath106 ) . in both panels and for both values of the disorder strength ,
a limiting value very close to zero for the free - energy barrier and the latent heat is obtained , indicating a continuous transition.,width=16 ] thus , in our case for lattice sizes of the order of @xmath107 almost all of the simulated realizations showed a dp energy probability distribution ( in fact for the value @xmath3 the ratio @xmath88 reached unity ) .
this observation explains why we have used only the @xmath98 realizations in the disorder averaging ( equations ( [ eq:5 ] ) and ( [ eq:6 ] ) ) , since it implies that only these realizations are of interest , since for large lattices these will dominate the behavior .
this practice avoids transient effects , coming from the small lattices , and we have further pushed it by applying here a quite rather strict criterion for the definition of the dp realizations : @xmath108 ( note the normalization of the energy pdf : @xmath109 in figure [ fig:4](a ) ) . the behavior of the disorder average of the surface tension @xmath103_{av}$ ] , for both @xmath2 and @xmath3 , as a function of the inverse lattice size , is shown in figure [ fig:5](a ) .
linear fits are applied only for the data corresponding to sizes @xmath106 . from these linear plots ( solid and dotted lines )
it appears that @xmath103_{av}$ ] approaches zero , as expected at a second - order transition .
this observation strongly indicates that , what we are observing from these dp realizations for small sizes is a finite - size effect that will disappear in the thermodynamic limit .
the solid and dotted lines explicitly illustrate this , using a linear extrapolation of the large size data for @xmath2 and @xmath110 , giving an almost zero surface tension in the limit @xmath76 for both values of the disorder strength : @xmath111 and @xmath112 , respectively .
furthermore , figure [ fig:5](b ) depicts an undeniable steady approach to zero of the above representative width , again for both values of the disorder strength @xmath2 and @xmath3 .
the linear extrapolation attempts are shown by the solid and dotted lines and give also an almost zero value for the latent heat of the order of @xmath113 and @xmath114 , respectively .
this is a further strong manifestation in favor of the continuous phase transition scenario .
thus , the evidence presented in this subsection for the 3d bimodal rfim are in agreement with the favored view of most existing theoretical and numerical studies @xcite that the phase transition of the 3d rfim is of second - order . in order to present even stronger numerical evidence of a vanishing ( in the limit @xmath76 ) surface tension we will now attempt to go well beyond the observation of several typical rf realizations . in the next subsection
, numerical evidence will be presented for the finite - size behavior of the free - energy barrier and the latent heat of much larger ensembles of rf realizations , obtained via the efficient high - level one - r entropic scheme described in subsection [ sec:2a ] . in this subsection
, we will apply the lk method on the numerical data obtained by our second numerical strategy , described in subsection [ sec:2a ] . using the high - level one - r wl approach and its final lee correction , we generated numerical data for large number of rf realizations at the disorder strength value @xmath2 . in this case , the number @xmath82 of realizations varied so that for every lattice size @xmath115 , @xmath48 rf realizations showing a dp structure in the energy pdf ( @xmath116 ) were simulated .
for the small sizes @xmath117 and @xmath118 only @xmath85 dp realizations have been identified in respective ensembles of @xmath119 and @xmath120 simulated realizations . set b in figure [ fig:4](b )
refers to the above mentioned large ensembles of realizations simulated at @xmath2 . in the present case , a looser criterion ( @xmath121 ) was applied for the identification of a dp realization .
the corresponding ratios @xmath88 in figure [ fig:4](b ) almost coincide for set a and set b , for the larger sizes .
this is easily explained by observing that for large sizes almost all dp realizations appear to have a quite deep minimum in the energy pdf .
however , as it will be shown below , the scaling of these minima will not support a first - order character of the transition .
@xmath102-behavior of @xmath103_{av}$ ] ( a ) and @xmath104_{av}$ ] ( b ) at @xmath2 and for @xmath105 .
two set of results are shown , corresponding to the high - level one - r wl approach ( open triangles ) and the lee correction ( filled circles ) .
the sample - to - sample fluctuations for the case of the high - level one - r wl results are shown with the larger cap width .
the solid lines are the corresponding linear fits for @xmath106 , giving very small , close to zero , negative values for @xmath122_{av}$ ] and @xmath123_{av}$ ] , thus verifying the scenario of figure [ fig:5].,width=16 ] figure [ fig:6 ] presents our results for the disorder averaged surface tension @xmath124_{av}$ ] and latent heat @xmath125_{av}$ ] over set b of realizations at @xmath2 .
the open triangles refer to the results obtained by the high - level one - r wl approach , whereas the filled circles to those estimated from the final lee correction . in panel
( a ) the values of @xmath126_{av}$ ] are shown for @xmath105 .
although for sizes up to @xmath127 @xmath103_{av}$ ] seems to steadily increase , for sizes @xmath47 a clear approach to zero is observed and this fact is compatible to the behavior of figure [ fig:5](a ) . respectively , panel ( b ) shows the values of @xmath104_{av}$ ] , also for @xmath105 .
the final large size decrease , is explicitly illustrated by the solid line ( in both panels of figure [ fig:6 ] ) , revealing the true asymptotic behavior of these quantities .
specifically , the solid lines are linear fits performed on the data obtained by the high - level one - r wl approach , for the larger lattice sizes studied ( @xmath106 ) , giving : @xmath128 and @xmath129 for @xmath130_{av}$ ] and @xmath123_{av}$ ] , respectively . as it can be seen from this figure
, the data obtained by the lee correction process would practically provide the same limiting values for the surface tension and the latent heat and therefore the corresponding linear fits are not shown .
noteworthy that , a comparison between statistical errors and sample - to - sample fluctuations is quite apparent in this figure .
the values of @xmath103_{av}$ ] and @xmath104_{av}$ ] estimated over the two sets of realizations ( set a and set b ) for @xmath2 estimated via the two different numerical strategies presented in this paper are of the same order .
those of set a are slightly larger as a consequence of the more strict criterion , @xmath108 , used for the identification of the dp rf realizations .
the interesting first - order - like properties of the model , reported by hernndez and diep @xcite and hernndez and ceva @xcite for the bimodal rfim and by wu and machta @xcite for the gaussian rfim , have added more complication and novelty to the rfim .
the first - order - like characteristics of the gaussian rfim found by wu and machta @xcite revealed that the appearance of these strong finite - size effects are independent of the rf distribution and their existence is related to the value of the disorder strength .
this observation is not compatible with mean - field theory , since its first - order prediction for only the bimodal case depends on the existence of a minimum at zero - field of the distribution @xcite .
the present study has illustrated that these characteristics are most likely effects complicating the finite - size behavior of the model but not determining its true asymptotic scaling behavior .
our results clearly indicate that the interface tension @xmath126_{av}$ ] vanishes and the two peaks of the energy pdf move together in the thermodynamic limit and therefore provide convincing evidence that the transition is continuous and that there in no tcp along the phase transition line .
consequently , the coexistence between an ordered phase and a disordered phase will be hardly detectable in the thermodynamic limit .
nevertheless , for large but finite systems , the dip represents a considerable barrier between the ordered phase and the disordered one , so that in some sense , one may speak for a phase coexistence for finite systems .
the results of figures [ fig:5](a ) and [ fig:6](a ) indicate a linear approach of the interface tension to zero in the limit @xmath131 , and therefore an exponential increase of the ratio @xmath132 in @xmath89 , and point to an unconventional continuous transition , in which the energy pdf will approach two delta functions that move together ( see figures [ fig:5](b ) and [ fig:6](b ) ) in the thermodynamic limit . such an unconventional behavior has been first predicted by eichhorn and binder @xcite , for the the order - parameter pdf of the 3d random - field three - state potts model .
these authors have explained such an unusual behavior by presenting in detail the consequences of a scenario ( including leading corrections to scaling ) based on a finite - size scaling statement for the order - parameter universal pdf . according to this scenario ,
the finite - size scaling behavior in rf systems can be recovered and the relative width of the corresponding order - parameter pdf peaks vanishes in the scaling limit as @xmath133 , where @xmath134 is the critical exponent describing the violation of hyperscaling ( @xmath135 ) . in conclusion ,
the results of this paper and the observations of references @xcite are strong indications of a similar unusual scenario for a continuous transition , calling for further investigation , such as the determination of the exponent @xmath134 .
two entropic sampling numerical strategies have been implemented for the study of the first - order - like properties of the 3d bimodal rfim . our experience and comparative studies , using different numerical approaches , revealed the sensitivity of the double - peak structure of the energy probability density function of the model , especially with increasing the system size .
thus , the need for careful implementations of entropic sampling techniques in cases of complex systems has been critically discussed .
an efficient high - level one - range wang - landau approach has been proposed as a quite safe alternative , avoiding subtle problems related to the position and the depth of the minima of the double - peak energy probability density functions .
reliable data were obtained using this high - level one - range wang - landau approach and the corresponding lee correction for large numbers of random - field realizations and quite large lattice sizes , up to @xmath67 . using these data and by a systematic finite - size analysis , implementing the lee - kosterlitz method ,
we have studied the nature of the transition at the strong disorder regime .
our results for both the free - energy barrier and latent heat for the ensemble of double - peak random - field realizations suggest a behavior in accordance with a continuous transition .
these results disclose the open controversy for the existence of a tricritical point in the phase diagram of the 3d bimodal rfim at the strong disorder regime and serve in favor of the unusual scenario for a continuous transition , originally proposed by eichhorn and binder @xcite
. it will be interesting to repeat the present investigation for the wide bimodal distribution ( with a gaussian width ) and even for the gaussian distribution , at the strong disorder regime , since this would provide additional confidence to our conclusions . | two numerical strategies based on the wang - landau and lee entropic sampling schemes are implemented to investigate the first - order transition features of the 3d bimodal ( @xmath0 ) random - field ising model at the strong disorder regime .
we consider simple cubic lattices with linear sizes in the range @xmath1 and simulate the system for two values of the disorder strength : @xmath2 and @xmath3 .
the nature of the transition is elucidated by applying the lee - kosterlitz free - energy barrier method .
our results indicate that , despite the strong first - order - like characteristics , the transition remains continuous , in disagreement with the early mean - field theory prediction of a tricritical point at high values of the random - field .
_ keywords _ : bimodal random - field ising model , wang - landau sampling , free - energy barrier method |
the kuiper belt is a long - lived region of the solar system just beyond neptune where the planetisimals have not coalesced into a planet .
it contains about 80,000 objects with radii greater than 50 km ( trujillo , jewitt & luu 2001 ) which have been collisionally processed and gravitationally perturbed throughout the age of the solar system .
the short - period comets and centaurs are believed to originate from the kuiper belt ( fernandez 1980 ; duncan , quinn & tremaine 1988 ) . physically , the kuiper belt objects ( kbos ) show a large diversity of colors from slightly blue to ultra red ( @xmath8 to @xmath9 , luu and jewitt 1996 ) and may show correlations between colors , inclination and/or perihelion distance ( jewitt & luu 2001 ; trujillo & brown 2002 ; doressoundiram et al . 2002 ; tegler & romanishin 2003 ) .
spectra of kbos are mostly featureless with a few showing hints of water ice ( brown , cruikshank & pendleton 1999 ; jewitt & luu 2001 ; lazzarin et al .
the range of kbo geometric albedos is still poorly sampled but the larger ones likely have values between 0.04 to 0.10 ( jewitt , aussel & evans 2001 ; altenhoff , bertoldi & menten 2004 ) .
time - resolved observations of kbos show that @xmath10 vary by @xmath11 magnitudes , @xmath12 by @xmath13 magnitudes and @xmath14 by @xmath15 magnitudes ( sheppard & jewitt 2002 ; ortiz et al .
2003 ; lacerda & luu 2003 ; sheppard & jewitt 2004 ) .
one object , ( 20000 ) varuna , displays a large photometric range and fast rotation which is best interpreted as a structurally weak object elongated by its own rotational angular momentum ( jewitt & sheppard 2002 ) .
a significant fraction of kbos appear to be more elongated than main - belt asteroids of similar size ( sheppard & jewitt 2002 ) .
the kbo phase functions are steep , with a median of @xmath16 magnitudes per degree between phase angles of 0 and 2 degrees ( sheppard & jewitt 2002 ; schaefer & rabinowitz 2002 ; sheppard & jewitt 2004 ) . about @xmath17 of the kbos are binaries with separations @xmath18 ( noll et al .
2002 ) while binaries with separations @xmath19 may constitute about @xmath20 of the population ( trujillo 2003 , private communication ) .
all the binary kbos found to date appear to have mass ratios near unity , though this may be an observational selection effect .
the mechanism responsible for creating kbo binaries is not clear .
formation through collisions is unlikely ( stern 2002 ) . weidenschilling ( 2002 )
has proposed formation of such binaries through complex three - body interactions which would only occur efficiently in a much higher population of large kbos than can currently be accounted for .
goldreich , lithwick & sari ( 2002 ) have proposed that kbo binaries could have formed when two bodies approach each other and energy is extracted either by dynamical friction from the surrounding sea of smaller kbos or by a close third body .
this process also requires that the density of kbos was @xmath21 to @xmath22 times greater than now .
they predict that closer binaries should be more abundant in the kuiper belt while weidenschilling s mechanism predicts the opposite .
the present paper is the fourth in a series resulting from the hawaii kuiper belt variability project ( hkbvp , see jewitt & sheppard 2002 ; sheppard & jewitt 2002 ; sheppard & jewitt 2004 )
. the practical aim of the project is to determine the rotational characteristics ( principally period and shape ) of bright kbos ( @xmath23 ) in order to learn about the distributions of rotation period and shape in these objects . in the course of this survey we found that 2001 qg@xmath0 had an extremely large light variation and a relatively long period .
we have obtained optical observations of 2001 qg@xmath0 in order to accurately determine the rotational lightcurve and constrain its possible causes .
2001 qg@xmath0 has a typical plutino orbit in 3:2 mean - motion resonance with neptune , semi - major axis at 39.2 au , eccentricity of 0.19 and inclination of 6.5 degrees .
we used the university of hawaii ( uh ) 2.2 m diameter telescope atop mauna kea in hawaii to obtain r - band observations of 2001 qg@xmath0 on three separate observing runs each covering several nights : ut september 12 and 13 2002 ; august 22 , 26 , 27 and 28 2003 ; september 27 , 28 and 30 2003 .
two different ccd cameras were employed . for the september 2002 and september 2003 observations we used a @xmath24 pixel tektronix ccd ( @xmath25 @xmath26 pixels ) camera with a @xmath27 pixel@xmath28 scale at the f/10 cassegrain focus .
an antireflection coating on the ccd gave very high average quantum efficiency ( 0.90 ) in the r - band .
the field - of - view was @xmath29 .
for the august 2003 observations we used the orthogonal parallel transfer imaging camera ( optic ) .
optic has two @xmath30 pixel lincoln lab ccid28 orthogonal transfer ccds developed to compensate for real - time image motion by moving the charge on the chips to compensate for seeing variations ( tonry , burke & schechter 1997 ) .
howell et al .
( 2003 ) have demonstrated that these chips are photometrically accurate and provide routine sharpening of the image point spread function .
there is a @xmath31 gap between the chips .
the total field - of - view was @xmath32 with @xmath33 @xmath26 pixels which corresponds to @xmath34 pixel@xmath28 scale at the f/10 cassegrain focus .
the same r - band filter based on the johnson - kron - cousins photometric system was used for all uh 2.2 m observations .
in addition we used the keck i 10 m telescope to obtain bvr colors of 2001 qg298 at its maximum and minimum light on ut august 30 , 2003 .
the lris camera with its tektronix @xmath35 pixel ccd and @xmath25 @xmath26 pixels ( image scale @xmath36 pixel@xmath28 ) was used ( oke et al . 1995 ) with the facility broadband bvr filter set . due to a technical problem with the blue camera side we used only the red side for photometry at bv and r. the blue filter response
was cut by the use of a dichroic at 0.460 @xmath26 .
all exposures were taken in a consistent manner with the telescope autoguided on bright nearby stars . the seeing ranged from @xmath37 to @xmath38 during the various observations .
2001 qg@xmath0 moved relative to the fixed stars at a maximum of @xmath39 hr@xmath28 corresponding to trail lengths @xmath40 @xmath41 in the longest ( 450 sec ) exposures .
thus motion of the object was insignificant compared to the seeing .
images from the uh telescope were bias - subtracted and then flat - fielded using the median of a set of dithered images of the twilight sky .
data from keck were bias subtracted and flattened using flat fields obtained from an illuminated spot inside the closed dome .
landolt ( 1992 ) standard stars were employed for the absolute photometric calibration . to optimize the signal - to - noise ratio we performed aperture correction photometry by using a small aperture on 2001 qg@xmath0 ( @xmath42 to @xmath43 in radius ) and both the same small aperture and a large aperture ( @xmath44 to @xmath45 in radius ) on ( four or more ) nearby bright field stars .
we corrected the magnitude within the small aperture used for the kbos by determining the correction from the small to the large aperture using the field stars ( c.f .
tegler and romanishin 2000 ; jewitt & luu 2001 ; sheppard & jewitt 2002 ) .
since 2001 qg@xmath0 moved slowly we were able to use the same field stars from night to night within each observing run , resulting in very stable relative photometric calibration from night to night .
the observational geometry for 2001 qg@xmath0 on each night of observation is shown in table 1 .
tables 2 and 3 show the photometric results for 2001 qg@xmath0 .
we used the phase dispersion minimization ( pdm ) method ( stellingwerf 1978 ) to search for periodicity in the data . in pdm ,
the metric is the so - called @xmath46 parameter , which is essentially the variance of the unphased data divided by the variance of the data when phased by a given period .
the best - fit period should have a very small dispersion compared to the unphased data and thus @xmath47 1 indicates that a good fit has been found .
2001 qg@xmath0 showed substantial variability ( @xmath48 magnitudes with a single - peaked period near @xmath49 hr ) in r - band observations from two nights in september 2002 .
we obtained further observations of the object in 2003 to determine the lightcurve with greater accuracy .
pdm analysis of all the apparent magnitude r - band data from the september 2002 and august and september 2003 observations shows that 2001 qg@xmath0 has strong @xmath46 minima near the periods @xmath50 hr and @xmath51 hr , with weaker alias periods flanking these ( figure [ fig : pdmqg ] ) .
we corrected the apparent magnitude data for the minor phase angle effects ( we used the nominal 0.16 magnitudes per degree found in sheppard & jewitt 2003 ) and light travel - time differences of the observations to correspond to the august 30 , 2003 observations .
we then phased the data to all the peaks with @xmath52 and found only the 6.8872 and 13.7744 hour periods to be consistent with all the data ( figures [ fig : phaseqgsingle ] and [ fig : phaseqgdouble ] ) . through a closer look at the pdm plot ( figure [ fig : pdmqgsmall ] ) and phasing the data we find best fit periods @xmath53 hr ( a lightcurve with a single maximum per period ) and @xmath54 hr ( two maxima per period as expected for rotational modulation caused by an aspherical shape )
the double - peaked lightcurve appears to be the best fit with the minima different by about 0.1 magnitudes while the maxima appear to be of similar brightness .
the photometric range of the lightcurve is @xmath55 magnitudes .
the keck bvr colors of 2001 qg@xmath0 show no variation from minimum to maximum light within the photometric uncertainties of a few % ( see figures [ fig : phaseqgsingle ] and [ fig : phaseqgdouble ] ) .
this is again consistent with a lightcurve that is produced by an elongated shape , rather than by albedo variations .
the colors ( @xmath56 , @xmath57 ) show that 2001 qg@xmath0 is red and similar to the mean values ( @xmath58 , @xmath59 , 28 objects ) for kbos as a group ( jewitt and luu 2001 ) .
the absolute magnitude of a solar system object , @xmath60 , is the hypothetical magnitude the object would have if it where at heliocentric ( @xmath61 ) and geocentric ( @xmath62 ) distances of 1 au and had a phase angle ( @xmath63 ) of 0 degrees .
we use the relation @xmath64 to find the absolute magnitude by correcting for the geometrical and phase angle effects in the 2001 qg@xmath0 observations . here
@xmath65 is the apparent red magnitude of the object and @xmath66 is the phase function . using the nominal value of @xmath67 magnitudes per degree for kbos at low phase angles ( sheppard & jewitt 2002 ; sheppard & jewitt 2004 ) and data from table 1 we find that 2001 qg@xmath0 has @xmath68 at maximum light and @xmath69 magnitudes at minimum light .
if attributed to a rotational variation of the cross - section , this corresponds to a ratio of maximum to minimum areas of 2.85:1 .
the effective radius of an object can be calculated using the relation @xmath70 $ ] where @xmath71 is the apparent red magnitude of the sun ( @xmath72 ) , @xmath73 is the red geometric albedo and @xmath74 ( km ) is the effective circular radius of the object . if we assume an albedo of 0.04 ( 0.10 ) this corresponds to effective circular radii at maximum and minimum light of about 158 ( 100 ) km and 94 ( 59 ) km , respectively . at the mean absolute magnitude of 6.85 mag , the effective circular radius is 122 ( 77 ) km .
only three other objects in the solar system larger than 25 km in radius are known to have lightcurve ranges @xmath75 magnitude ( table 4 ) . following jewitt and sheppard ( 2002 )
we discuss three possible models of rotational variation to try to compare the objects from table 4 with 2001 qg@xmath0 . on asteroids ,
albedo variations contribute brightness variations that are usually less than about @xmath76 ( degewij , tedesco & zellner 1979 ) .
rotationally correlated color variations may be seen if the albedo variations are large since materials with markedly different albedos may differ compositionally . as seen in table 4
, saturn s satellite iapetus is the only object in which variations @xmath771 mag .
are explained through albedo .
the large albedo contrast on iapetus is likely a special consequence of its synchronous rotation and the anisotropic impact of material trapped in orbit about saturn onto its leading hemisphere ( cook & franklin 1970 ) .
iapetus shows clear rotational color variations ( @xmath78 0.1 mag . )
that are correlated with the rotational albedo variations ( millis 1977 ) and which would be detected in 2001 qg@xmath0 given the quality of our data .
the special circumstance of iapetus is without obvious analogy in the kuiper belt and we do not believe that it is a good model for the extreme lightcurve of 2001 qg@xmath0 .
pluto shows a much smaller variation ( about 0.3 magnitudes ) thought to be caused by albedo structure ( buie , tholen & wasserman 1997 ) .
pluto is so large that it can sustain an atmosphere which may contribute to amplifying its lightcurve range by allowing surface frosts to condense on brighter ( cooler ) spots .
thus brighter spots grow brighter while darker ( hotter ) spots grow darker through the sublimation of ices .
this positive feedback mechanism requires an atmosphere and is unlikely to be relevant on a kbo as small as 2001 qg@xmath0
. while we can not absolutely exclude surface markings as the dominant cause of 2001 qg@xmath0 s large rotational brightness variation , we are highly skeptical of this explanation .
we measure no color variation with rotation , there appear to be two distinct minima and the range is so large as to be beyond reasonable explanation from albedo alone .
since surface markings are most likely not the cause of the lightcurve , the observed photometric variations are probably caused by changes in the projected cross - section of an elongated body in rotation about its minor axis .
the rotation period of an elongated object should be twice the single - peaked lightcurve period because of the projection of both long axes ( 2 maxima ) and short axes ( 2 minima ) during one full rotation .
if the body is elongated , we can use the ratio of maximum to minimum brightness to determine the projection of the body shape into the plane of the sky .
the rotational brightness range of a triaxial object with semiaxes @xmath79 in rotation about the @xmath80 axis and viewed equatorially is @xmath81 where @xmath82 is expressed in magnitudes .
this gives a lower limit to @xmath83 because of the effects of projection .
using @xmath84 for 2001 qg@xmath0 , we find the lower limit is @xmath85 .
this corresponds to @xmath86 and @xmath87 km for the geometric albedo 0.04 case and @xmath88 and @xmath89 km for an albedo of 0.10 .
it is possible that 2001 qg@xmath0 is elongated and able to resist gravitational compression into a spherical shape by virtue of its intrinsic compressive strength .
however , observations of asteroids in the main - belt suggest that only the smallest ( @xmath70.1 km sized ) asteroids are in possession of a tensile strength sufficient to resist rotational deformation ( pravec , harris & michalowski 2003 ) .
observations of both asteroids and planetary satellites suggest that many objects with radii @xmath77 50 to 75 km have shapes controlled by self - gravity , not by material strength ( farinella 1987 ; farinella & zappala 1997 ) .
the widely accepted explanation is that these bodies are internally weak because they have been fractured by numerous past impacts .
this explanation is also plausible in the kuiper belt , where models attest to a harsh collisional environment at early times ( e.g. davis & farinella 1997 ) .
we feel that the extraordinarily large amplitude of 2001 qg@xmath0 is unlikely to be caused by elongation of the object sustained by its own material strength , although we can not rule out this possibility .
structurally weak bodies are susceptible to rotational deformation .
the 1000-km scale kbo ( 20000 ) varuna ( rotation period 6.3442 @xmath90 0.0002
hr and lightcurve range 0.42 @xmath90 0.02 mag ) is the best current example in the kuiper belt ( jewitt and sheppard 2002 ) . in the main asteroid belt ,
216 kleopatra has a very short period ( 5.385 hr ) and large lightcurve range ( 1.18 mag .
, corresponding to axis ratio @xmath72.95:1 and dimensions @xmath7 217 @xmath91 94 km , table 4 ) .
kleopatra has been observed to be a highly elongated body through radar and high resolution imaging and the most likely explanation is that 216 kleopatra is rotationally deformed ( leone et al .
1984 ; ostro et al . 2000 ; hestroffer et al .
2002 ; washabaugh & scheeres 2002 ) .
is rotational elongation a viable model for 2001 qg@xmath0 ? the critical rotation period ( @xmath92 )
at which centripetal acceleration equals gravitational acceleration towards the center of a rotating spherical object is @xmath93 where @xmath94 is the gravitational constant and @xmath95 is the density of the object . with @xmath95
= @xmath96 kg m@xmath97 the critical period is about 3.3 hr . even at longer periods
, real bodies will suffer centripetal deformation into triaxial aspherical shapes which depend on their density , angular momentum and material strength .
the limiting equilibrium shapes of rotating strengthless fluid bodies have been well studied by chandrasekhar ( 1987 ) and a detailed discussion in the context of the kbos can be found in jewitt and sheppard ( 2002 ) .
we briefly mention here that triaxial `` jacobi '' ellipsoids with large angular momenta are rotationally elongated and generate lightcurves with substantial ranges when viewed equatorially .
leone et al . (
1984 ) have analyzed rotational equilibrium configurations of strengthless asteroids in detail ( see figure [ fig : kboperamp ] ) .
they show that the maximum photometric range of a rotational ellipsoid is 0.9 mag : more elongated objects are unstable to rotational fission .
the 1.14 mag photometric range of 2001 qg@xmath0 exceeds this limit .
in addition , the 13.7744 hr ( two - peaked ) rotation period is much too long to cause significant elongation for any plausible bulk density ( figure [ fig : kboperamp ] ) . for these reasons we do not believe that 2001 qg@xmath0 is a single rotationally distorted object .
a third possible explanation for the extreme lightcurve of 2001 qg@xmath0 is that this is an eclipsing binary .
a wide separation ( sum of the orbital semi - major axes much larger than the sum of the component radii ) is unlikely because such a system would generate a distinctive `` notched '' lightcurve that is unlike the lightcurve of 2001 qg@xmath0 .
in addition , a wide separation would require unreasonably high bulk density of the components in order to generate the measured rotational period .
if 2001 qg@xmath0 is a binary then the components must be close or in contact .
we next consider the limiting case of a contact binary .
the axis ratio of a contact binary consisting of equal spheres is @xmath98 , corresponding to a lightcurve range @xmath82 = 0.75 magnitudes , as seen from the rotational equator . at the average viewing angle
@xmath99 degrees we would expect @xmath82 = 0.45 mag .
the rotational variation of 2001 qg@xmath0 is too large to be explained as a contact binary consisting of two equal spheres .
however , close binary components of low strength should be elongated by mutual tidal forces , giving a larger lightcurve range than possible in the case of equal spheres ( leone et al . 1984 ) .
the latter authors find that the maximum range for a tidally distorted nearly contact binary is 1.2 magnitudes , compatible with the 1.14 mag .
range of 2001 qg@xmath0 ( figure [ fig : kboperamp ] ) .
the contact binary hypothesis is the likely explanation of 624 hektor s lightcurve ( hartmann & cruikshank 1978 ; weidenschilling 1980 ; leone et al . 1984 ) and could also explain 216 kleopatra s lightcurve ( leone et al .
1984 ; ostro et al .
2000 ; hestroffer et al .
2002 ) .
we suggest that the relatively long double - peaked period ( @xmath100 hr ) and large photometric range ( @xmath101 magnitudes ) of 2001 qg@xmath0 s lightcurve are best understood if the body is a contact binary or nearly contact binary viewed from an approximately equatorial perspective .
the large range suggests that the components are of similar size and are distorted by their mutual tidal interactions . using the calculations from leone et al .
( 1984 ) , who take into account the mutual deformation of close , strengthless binary components , we find the density of these objects must be @xmath71000 kg m@xmath97 in order to remain bound in a binary system separated by the roche radius ( which is just over twice the component radius ) .
if we assume that the albedo of both objects is 0.04 , the effective radius of each component is about 95 km as found above .
using this information we find from kepler s third law that if the components are separated , they would be about 300 km apart .
this separation as seen on the sky ( @xmath102 ) is small enough to have escaped resolution with current technology .
further , we point out that the maximum of the lightcurve of 2001 qg@xmath0 is more nearly `` u '' shaped ( or flattened ) than is the `` v '' shaped minimum ( figure [ fig : phaseqgdouble ] ) .
this is also true for 624 hektor ( dunlap & gehrels 1969 ) and may be a distinguishing , though not unique , signature of a contact or nearly contact binary ( zappala 1984 ; leone et al .
1984 ; cellino et al .
1985 ) . in comparison ,
( 20000 ) varuna , which is probably not a contact binary ( see below and jewitt & sheppard 2002 ) , does not show significant differences in the curvature of the lightcurve maxima and minima . in short , while we can not prove that 2001 qg@xmath0 is a contact binary , we find by elimination of other possibilities that this is the most convincing explanation of its lightcurve .
the distribution of measured lightcurve properties is shown in figure [ fig : kboperamp ] ( adapted from figure 4 of leone et al .
( 1984 ) ) . there ,
region a corresponds to the low rotational range objects ( of any period ) in which the variability can be plausibly associated with surface albedo markings .
region b corresponds to the rotationally deformed jacobi ellipsoids while region c marks the domain of the close binary objects .
plotted in the figure are the lightcurve periods and ranges for kbos from the hkbvp ( jewitt & sheppard 2002 ; sheppard & jewitt 2002 ; sheppard & jewitt 2004 )
. we also show large main belt asteroids ( data from http://cfa-www.harvard.edu/iau/lists/lightcurvedat.html updated by a. harris and b. warner and based on lagerkvist , harris & zappala 1989 ) .
once again we note that the measured kbo ranges should , in most cases , be regarded as lower limits to the range because of the possible effects of projection into the plane of the sky . of the 34 kbos in our sample ,
five fall into region c in figure [ fig : kboperamp ] . of these , 2001 qg@xmath0 is by far the best candidate for being a contact or nearly contact binary system since it alone has a range between the @xmath103 0.9 mag .
limit for a single rotational equilibrium ellipsoid and the @xmath1041.2 mag .
limit for a mutually distorted close binary ( table 5 ) .
it is also rotating too slowly to be substantially distorted by its own spin ( figure [ fig : kboperamp ] ) . both ( 33128 ) 1998 bu@xmath105 and 2000
gn@xmath106 are good candidates which have large photometric ranges and relatively slow periods .
kbos ( 26308 ) 1998 sm@xmath107 and ( 32929 ) 1995 qy@xmath108 could be rotationally deformed ellipsoids , but their relatively slow rotations would require densities much smaller than that of water , a prospect which we consider unlikely .
we next ask what might be the abundance of contact or close binaries in the kuiper belt . as a first estimate we assume that we have detected one such object ( 2001 qg@xmath0 ) in a sample of 34 kbos observed with adequate time resolution .
the answer depends on the magnitude of the correction for projection effects caused by the orientation of the rotation vector with respect to the line of sight .
this correction is intrinsically uncertain , since it depends on unknowns such as the scattering function of the surface materials of the kbo as well as on the detailed shape .
we adopt two crude approximations that should give the projection correction at least to within a factor of a few .
first , we represent the elongated shape of the kbo by a rectangular block with dimensions a @xmath3 b = c. the lightcurve range varies with angle from the equator , @xmath109 , in this approximation as @xmath110.\ ] ] for the limiting case of a highly distorted contact binary with @xmath82 = 1.2 mag . at @xmath109
= 0@xmath111 , eq .
( 3 ) gives @xmath83 = 3 .
we next assume that the range must fall in the range 0.9 @xmath112 1.2 mag . in order for us to make an assignment of likely binary structure ( figure [ fig : kbomaghist ] ) .
as noted above , only 2001 qg@xmath0 satisfies this condition amongst the known objects .
we find , from eq .
( 3 ) with @xmath83 = 3 , that @xmath82 = 0.9 mag is reached at @xmath109 = 10@xmath111 .
the probability that earth would lie within 10@xmath113 of the equator of a set of randomly oriented kbos is @xmath114 = 0.17 .
therefore , the detection of 1 kbo with 0.9 @xmath115 1.2 mag implies that the fractional abundance of similarly elongated objects is @xmath116 17% . as a separate check on this estimate
, we next represent the object as an ellipsoid , again with axes a @xmath3 b = c. the photometric range when viewed at an angle @xmath109 from the rotational equator is given by @xmath117sin^2\theta + 1\right]\ ] ] substituting @xmath83 = 3 , the range predicted by eq .
( 4 ) falls to 0.9 mag at @xmath118 17@xmath111 .
given a random distribution of the spin vectors , the probability that earth would lie within 17@xmath113 of the equator is @xmath119 = 0.29 .
therefore , the detection of 1 kbo with a range between 0.9 and 1.2 mag in a sample of 34 objects implies , in this approximation , a fractional abundance of similarly elongated objects near @xmath116 10% .
given the crudity of the model , the agreement between projection factors from eqs .
( 3 ) and ( 4 ) is encouraging .
together , the data and the projection factors suggest that in our sample of 34 kbos , perhaps 3 to 6 objects are as elongated as 2001 qg@xmath0 but only 2001 qg@xmath0 is viewed from a sufficiently equatorial perspective that the lightcurve is distinct .
this is consistent with figure 5 , which shows that @xmath120 of @xmath121 kbos ( @xmath122 ) from the hkbvp occupy region c of the period - range diagram .
our estimate is very crude and is also a lower limit to the true binary fraction because close binaries with components of unequal size will not satisfy the 0.9 @xmath115 1.2 mag .
criterion for detection .
the key point is that the data are consistent with a substantial close binary fraction in the kuiper belt .
figure [ fig : kboperamp ] also shows that there are no large main - belt asteroids ( radii @xmath123 km ) in region c , which is where similar sized component contact binaries are expected to be . to date , no examples of large binary main - belt asteroids with similar sized components have been found , even though the main belt has been extensively searched for binarity ( see margot 2002 and references therein ) .
the main - belt asteroids may have had a collisional history significantly different from that of the kbos .
the contact binary interpretation of the 2001 qg@xmath0 lightcurve is clearly non - unique . indeed ,
firm proof of the existence of contact binaries will be as difficult to establish in the kuiper belt as it has been in closer , brighter populations of small bodies .
nevertheless , the data are compatible with a high abundance of such objects .
it is interesting to speculate about how such objects could form in abundance .
one model of the formation and long term evolution of wide binaries predicts that such objects could be driven together by dynamical friction or three - body interactions ( goldreich et al .
2002 ) . objects like 2001 qg@xmath0 would be naturally produced by such a mechanism .
kuiper belt object 2001 qg@xmath0 has the most extreme lightcurve of any of the 34 objects so far observed in the hawaii kuiper belt variability project .
the double - peaked lightcurve period is @xmath6 hr and peak - to - peak range is @xmath124 mag .
only two other minor planets with radii @xmath77 25 km ( 624 hektor and 216 kleopatra ) and one planetary satellite ( iapetus ) are known to show rotational photometric variation greater than 1 mag .
the absolute red magnitude is @xmath125(1,1,0 ) = 6.28 at maximum light and 7.42 mag . at minimum light . with an assumed geometric albedo of 0.04 ( 0.10 ) we derive effective circular radii at maximum and minimum light of 158 ( 100 ) and 94 ( 59 ) km , respectively .
no variation in the bvr colors between maximum and minimum light was detected to within photometric uncertainties of a few percent .
\4 . the large photometric range
, differences in the lightcurve minima , and long period of 2001 qg@xmath0 are consistent with and strongly suggest that this object is a contact or nearly contact binary , viewed equatorially .
if 2001 qg@xmath0 is a contact binary with similarly sized components , then we conclude that such objects constitute at least 10% to 20% of the kuiper belt population at large sizes .
we thank john tonry and andrew pickles for help with the optic camera and the remote observing system on the university of hawaii 2.2 meter telescope .
we also thank henry hsieh for observational assistance and jane luu for comments on the manuscript .
this work was supported by a grant to d.j . from the nasa origins program . | extensive time - resolved observations of kuiper belt object 2001 qg@xmath0 show a lightcurve with a peak - to - peak variation of @xmath1 magnitudes and single - peaked period of @xmath2 hr . the mean absolute magnitude is 6.85 magnitudes which corresponds to a mean effective radius of 122 ( 77 ) km if an albedo of 0.04 ( 0.10 ) is assumed .
this is the first known kuiper belt object and only the third minor planet with a radius @xmath3 25 km to display a lightcurve with a range in excess of 1 magnitude .
we find the colors to be typical for a kuiper belt object ( @xmath4 , @xmath5 ) with no variation in color between minimum and maximum light .
the large light variation , relatively long double - peaked period and absence of rotational color change argue against explanations due to albedo markings or elongation due to high angular momentum .
instead , we suggest that 2001 qg@xmath0 may be a very close or contact binary similar in structure to what has been independently proposed for the trojan asteroid 624 hektor
. if so , its rotational period would be twice the lightcurve period or @xmath6 hr . by correcting for the effects of projection , we estimate that the fraction of similar objects in the kuiper belt is at least @xmath710% to 20% with the true fraction probably much higher .
a high abundance of close and contact binaries is expected in some scenarios for the evolution of binary kuiper belt objects . |
the ising model is a prototype of a statistical mechanical model for studying order - disorder transitions .
it is also the first statistical model which has led to exact solution in one and two dimensions . since its inception@xcite
this model has triggered an intense effort in investigation of other models resulting in an extensive literature on the subject @xcite .
there are now a large library of statistical and quantum mechanical models , differing in their degrees of freedom , interaction type , the type and dimensions of lattices , and of course methods of solution @xcite .
there are also models which can be called integrable , meaning that they allow sufficient number of conserved quantities , leading to a full determination of their spectra and other observable quantities . among the well - known classical models
, we can mention particularly the @xmath0-state potts model @xcite , which is the simplest generalization of the ising model in that the degrees of freedom take @xmath0 instead of two different values and interact according to the hamiltonian [ hpot ] h=-_i , j ( s_i , s_j ) , where @xmath1 means that interactions are between nearest neighbors and @xmath2 takes @xmath0 different values .
this is a classical model in that every configuration of the so - called spin variables @xmath2 is an energy eigenstate .
the importance of this model , like ising model , is that it can be mapped to many other important models in science , i.e. the famous four - color problem in the case of potts model , @xcite .
the ising model has a @xmath3 symmetry , meaning that the configurations @xmath4 and @xmath5 both have the same energy . ] in the potts model , this symmetry has been elevated to the @xmath6 group , where now due to the form of the hamiltonian ( [ hpot ] ) , one can shift all the spin variables by any integer value @xmath7 $ ] and the energy remains the same . this symmetry can be seen in a better way if we use an identity and write the local energy term as ( s , s)=_n=0^d-1 ^ns^-ns , where @xmath8 is a @xmath9th root of unity . + it is the purpose of this work to generalize the potts and indeed ising model to the case where the symmetry group is a finite ( non - abelian ) group .
such a model , if properly defined will certainly have a very rich structure and will certainly deepen and widen our perspective of exactly solvable models of statistical mechanics and integrable models .
moreover it has the potential of enriching our knowledge of order - disorder transitions in statistical mechanics .
of course the model as defined now is mainly of theoretical interest and it may be difficult to make concrete connections with specific physical problems .
we only hope with hindsight and in view of the experience with other more or less abstract models in statistical mechanics like the face models and vertex models @xcite , this new model will also find a proper place in the library of exactly solvable models , possibly with new applications in the future .
+ we will focus our attention to a one dimensional lattice and show that such a natural generalization is indeed possible and will define the non - abelian potts model .
we determine the full spectrum and show that the ground states and indeed many of the excited states of this model are entangled .
we will determine the amount of this entanglement both for a single site and for a block of finite length .
we also determine the entanglement between two different sites of the lattice . in this sense
the model is a quantum mechanical model , in contrast to classical models where there is no entanglement in their energy eigenstates .
it turns our that the properties of irredudcible representations play an important role in the nature of the spectrum and its entanglement properties .
we will also calculate the partition function of the model in two different ways , that is we follow an algebraic approach where we calculate the trace of the thermal state and a combinatorial approach where we also count the degeneracy of all energy levels .
the results of the two approaches , which correspond respectively to the high and low temperature expansions , agree as they should . in all aspects
the results pertaining to this model reduce to the potts model when the symmetry group @xmath10 reduces to the abelian group @xmath6 .
+ the structure of this paper is as follows : in section [ pre ] we review the preliminary material from theory of finite groups and their representations . in section [ model ] , we define the non - abelian model on a one dimensional lattice , which as we see , is a special case of the kitaev quantum double model @xcite . in two dimensions this correspondence in no longer true , since as is well known the kitaev model entails four - body interactions while our model entails two - body interactions , as it should as a generalization of potts model .
in fact generalization of the potts model to two dimensions is a non - trivial problem as we will discuss in the discussion . in section [ spec ]
we derive the ground states and determine their entanglement properties , and in section [ excited states ] we determine all the excited states , hence the full spectrum . in section [ part ] , we calculate the partition function in closed form , by summing up the terms in both high and low temperature expansions . in all our study
we make contact with the simpler and special case where the group we are considering is the abelian group @xmath6 , and the model is the d - state potts model .
let @xmath10 be a finite group of size @xmath11 .
two elements @xmath12 and @xmath13 of the group @xmath10 are said to be conjugate if there is a @xmath14 , such that @xmath15 .
this is an equivalence relation which partitions the group into conjugacy classes .
the conjugacy class of an element @xmath12 is denoted by @xmath16 . the number of conjugacy classes is denoted by @xmath17 .
this equals the number of irreducible representations of the group .
it is customary to denote the former by latin indices and the latter by greek indices , hence we have @xmath18 as a conjugacy class and @xmath19 as an irreducible representation .
the number of elements in @xmath18 is denoted by @xmath20 , and the dimension of an irreducible representation @xmath19 is denoted by @xmath21 .
we then have @xmath22 .
let @xmath23 be a vector space spanned by orthonormal vectors @xmath24 . on this vector space , two regular representations
called left and right actions respectively , are defined as l(g ) |h= |gh , r(g)|h=|hg^-1 .
obviously the two kinds of actions commute with each other . for an abelian group , @xmath25=[r(g),r(g')]=0 $ ] leading to a simple disentangled spectrum as we will see in sections [ model ] , while for a non - abelian group this is no longer the case . +
both regular representations decompose into a sum of irreducible representations , each representation @xmath19 occurring with a multiplicity equal to its dimension @xmath21 , hence we have the relation @xmath26 the matrix entries of an irreducible representation @xmath27 of an element @xmath14 are denoted by @xmath28 . for each set of labels @xmath29 ,
a @xmath11 dimensional vector @xmath30 is defined as : [ basis ] |d_mn^:= _ gg d^_mn(g ) |g .
this is in fact the fourier transform on the finite group @xmath10 .
it is well known that these vectors provide an orthonormal and complete basis for @xmath31 @xcite .
the orthonormality implies that [ orthonormal ] d^_m , n|d^_p , q=^,_m , p_n , q , or [ orthonormality ] _ g g d^_mi(g ) = ^ _ mn _ ij .
here @xmath32 denotes complex conjugate of @xmath33 .
we will later use a graphical representation for @xmath34 which we depict in figure [ contraction ] .
+ for each representation @xmath19 , the character of a conjugacy class @xmath18 , is defined as @xmath35 , where @xmath36 .
the significance of characters of irreducible representations is that they are orthonormal and complete in the sense that if we define the @xmath17 dimensional formal vectors @xmath37 , where @xmath38 s form a computational basis , then these new vectors form a complete orthonormal basis .
the orthonormality implies that [ ccort ] _
g g ^(g)=|g| ^ , . finally note that the product of irreducible representations decomposes into sum of them in the form d^(g ) d^(g ) = _ f^,_d^(g ) , where @xmath39 are the ( clebsh - gordan ) or fusion coefficients of this group . taking the trace of both sides
, this leads to [ chichi ] ^(g ) ^(g ) = _ f^,_^(g ) .
we are now equipped with almost all the necessary ingredients of group theory to define and study the non - abelian potts model .
s and their contraction : a ) a representation for @xmath34 .
b ) a representation for @xmath40 . ]
consider a periodic chain of length @xmath41 .
let @xmath10 be a finite ( abelian or non - abelian ) group of size @xmath11 .
to each site of the chain , a @xmath11 dimensional hilbert space @xmath23 is assigned with orthonormal basis vectors @xmath42 .
therefore we have @xmath43 and @xmath44 .
the dimensional of the full hilbert space @xmath45 is given by @xmath46 .
+ the hamiltonian of the model is the reduction of the quantum double hamiltonian @xcite , in which only the vertex operators are retained and all the plaquette operators are ignored . since in a one - dimensional lattice , there is a one to one correspondence between vertices and links , we have used this liberty to put the dynamical ( generalized spin ) variables on the vertices instead of the links .
this makes the model much more akin to the other models of statistical mechanics , like the ising , potts and heisenberg models .
to each pair of neighboring sites @xmath47 , we assign the following local hamiltonian [ localh ] h_i=_gg r_i(g ) l_i+1(g ) , where the indices @xmath48 and @xmath49 show that @xmath50 and @xmath51 act on these two sites respectively . it is easily verified that @xmath52 is a projector , namely @xmath53 and @xmath54=0,\ \ \forall \ \ i , j$ ] .
therefore the eigenvalues of @xmath52 are restricted to @xmath55 and @xmath56 .
the total hamiltonian is the sum of all these local hamiltonians , i.e. [ hamiltonian ] h=- _
i=1^n h_i , where periodic boundary condition @xmath57 is implied in all states and operators .
+ consider the special case where @xmath10 is an abelian group , and in particular @xmath6 the finite cyclic group of order @xmath0 , @xmath58 where the group operation is addition modulo @xmath0 .
then we have + l(g ) |h= |h+g , r(g)|h=|h - g h , gz_d , + leading to l(g ) x^g , r(g)x^-g , where @xmath59 is the shift operator or the @xmath9 dimensional generalization of the pauli matrix @xmath60 , and @xmath61 is @xmath62 to the power @xmath63 .
therefore in the @xmath6 case , the local hamiltonian [ localh ] can be written as h_i= _
g=0^d-1 x_i^-g x_i+1^g . to see the relevance of this local hamiltonian to the potts model
, we note that in this abelian case and only in this case , all the operators @xmath64 can be diagonalized in the same basis , since @xmath25=0 $ ] for an abelian group .
this is the basis in which the shift operator @xmath62 is diagonal .
this operator has the property @xmath65 which means that its eigenvalues are @xmath66 , where @xmath8 is the @xmath9th root of unity , @xmath67 .
the eigenvectors of @xmath62 are easily found [ dstates ] |d^s:=_j=0^d-1 ^-js|j , x|d^s=^s|d^s .
now any product state of the form |^*s*:=|d^s_1|d^s_2|d^s_i|d^s_i+1|d^s_n , is an eigestate of all @xmath52 s and hence the total @xmath68 .
in such a basis , @xmath52 can be replaced with its eigenvalues .
then we have h_i & & _ g=0^d-1^(s_i+1-s_i)g= _ s_i , s_i+1 .
hence in the special case @xmath69 , we will have the classical @xmath9state potts model described by [ pottsdelta ] h=-_i=1^n _
s_i , s_i+1 , where @xmath2 s take @xmath0 different values .
we now turn to the spectrum when @xmath10 is a finite non - abelian group .
first we find the ground states and then determine all the excited states .
in order to find the ground states of the hamiltonian [ hamiltonian ] , we first consider the potts model which will act as a guideline for the more complicated non - abelian case . as equation
[ pottsdelta ] indicates , the ground state of the potts model is when all the labels @xmath2 are equal to each other , so there are @xmath0 different ground states , namely @xmath70 in [ dstates ] , we can rewrite this as |^s=_j_1 , j_2 , j_n^-j_1s^-j_2s^-j_ns|j_1 , j_2,j_n .
this can be written as a matrix product state ( mps ) as |^s=_j_1 , j_2 , j_n^s(j_1 , j_2 , j_n)|j_1 , j_2,j_n , where [ mpspotts ] ^s(j_1 , j_2 , j_n)= ( d^s(j_1)d^s(j_2)d^s(j_n ) ) , in which @xmath71 is the @xmath72 representation of element @xmath73 .
+ we now go on to consider the spectrum of the non - abelian case .
motivated by the mps representation of the abelian ( potts ) model in [ mpspotts ] , we form the following states : |^&:= & ( d^(g_1)d^(g_2)d^(g_n))|g_1 , g_2 , g_n&=&^(g_1g_2g_n)|g_1 , g_2 , g_n , where a sum over all group elements @xmath74 is implied .
here @xmath75 is a normalization factor and @xmath76 is the matrix of @xmath63 in the irreducible representation @xmath19 .
it is then obvious that these states are eigenstates of the operators @xmath52 . to see this we note that h_i|^&= & _ ggr_i(g)l_i+1(g)|^&= & _ gg^(g_1g_2g_n)|g_1 , g_2 g_ig^-1 , gg_i+1 , g_n=|^ , where in the last line we have relabeled the group elements @xmath77 to @xmath78 and @xmath79 to @xmath80 and have used the fact that a sum over all group elements is performed .
therefore for each irreducible representation of the group we find one ground state .
thus the ground state is @xmath17-fold degenerate , where @xmath17 is the number of in - equivalent irreducible representations , or equivalently the number of conjugacy classes . to find the normalization
, we use the orthogonality relation of characters which reads from [ ccort ] @xmath81 or @xmath82 .
therefore we find ^|^=_g_1 , g_n |(g_1g_n)|^2=|g|^n-1_gg|(g)|^2=|g|^n , giving the normalized ( in fact orthogonal ) ground states [ gs ] |^=^(g_1g_2g_n)|g_1 , g_2 , g_n .
note that in contrast to the abelian case , the ground states are generally entangled .
moreover consider the following string operators t^=_g_1 , g_2 , g_n ^(g_1g_2g_n ) |g_1 , g_2 , g_ng_1 , g_2 , g_n| .
we may ask what is the effect of this string operator on a given ground state . in view of the relation ( [ chichi ] ) , it turns out that t^|^=_f^,_|^ , implying that the ground space carries a representation of the fusion algebra of the group representation .
+ we now study the entanglement properties of the ground states .
first we determine how much a given site is entangled with the rest of the lattice , when the whole system is in a given ground state .
then we calculate the entanglement of a given block of length @xmath83 .
third we determine the entanglement of two sites which are near each other or are far apart . before proceeding to the proofs , we present the main results .
when the lattice is in a given ground state @xmath84 , + i ) the entanglement of any given site with the rest of the lattice , measured by the von - neumann entropy of the reduced density matrix of this site is @xmath85 .
+ ii ) the entanglement of any given block of length @xmath83 is given by @xmath86 } ) = \log(n^2_\mu)$ ] which is independent of the length of the block and verifies the area law .
+ iii ) any two sites which are not nearest neighbors are separable , their reduced density matrices is a product of those of individual sites .
+ iv ) any two neighboring sites are entangled and their entanglement measured by the negativity of the reduced density matrix of the two sides is given by @xmath87 .
+ these results are proved in appendix a.
using the conventions of figure [ contraction ] and the form of the ground state in [ myground ] , we can graphically depict a ground state as in figure [ gsfig ] .
this is again a generalization of the abelian potts model , where all the sites have been colored by one single color , here a color represents a label of an irreducible representation .
each line between two bulbs means that the two adjacent indices of the matrices have been contracted ( i.e. made equal and summed over ) . to obtain the excited states of [ hamiltonian ] , consider now a cut in such a configuration as shown in figure [ exs ] .
we will see that these cuts which separate connected regions of different colors ( i.e. labels of irreducible representations ) produce excited states . to prove this we remind the reader that local hamiltonians , being projectors , have eigenvalues only equal to @xmath55 or @xmath56 , therefore the exited states are those in which one or more of the vertex operators have @xmath55 eigenvalue
. therefore we want to find states which are common eigenstates of all the local hamiltonians where one or more of these local hamiltonians have zero eigenvalues . to proceed , consider local states like @xmath88 .
we first obtain the action of left and right operators on these states , which is easily verified to be as follows : [ l ] l(h)|d^_m , n= d^_m , p(h^-1)|d^_p , n and [ r ] r(h)|d^_m , n= |d^_m , pd^_p , n(h ) where summation over repeated latin indices are implied . from these two relations
we find the action of @xmath52 on the two neighboring elementary states , @xmath89 .
then from equations [ l ] and [ r ] we obtain : h_i|d^_m , n_i|d^_p ,
q_i+1 = |d^_m , r_i ( _ g d^_r , n(g)d^_p , s(g^-1))|d^_s , q_i+1 . using the orthonormality relation [ orthonormality ] , we find [ local action ] h_i|d^_m , n_i|d^_p , q_i+1 = _ n , p^,_r|d^_m , r_i|d^_r , q_i+1 . let us first consider the special case @xmath90 , where we have : [ exs1 ] h_i|d^_m , n_i|d^_p , q_i+1 = 0 . and @xmath91 are different .
c ) an excited state of the kind [ exs3 ] , where both the colors and matrix indices are the same . ] this means that if the two colors @xmath92 and @xmath93 on the two sides of the cut are different , then the local hamiltonian @xmath52 annihilates the state and so the energy is raised by one unit .
this kind of excited state is depicted in figure [ exs]a .
another special case is when the two colors ( i.e. representation labels ) are the same , but the middle indices are different : [ exs2 ] h_i|d^_m , n_i| d^_p , q_i+1 = 0 np , these kinds of excited states are depicted in figure [ exs]b .
finally we learn from [ local action ] that if @xmath94 and @xmath95 , then the right hand side of [ local action ] , although non - zero , is independent of @xmath96 , this means that for any two matrix indices @xmath97 [ exs3 ] h_i(|d^_m , n_i|d^_n , q_i+1-|d^_m , p_i|d^_p , q_i+1 ) = 0 .
hence the third kind of excitations are depicted as in figure [ exs]c . the number of these new kinds of excitations for a single cut in @xmath84 which are independent is @xmath98 .
using the simple notation @xmath99 for brevity , they can be chosen to be @xmath100 ( @xmath101 ) or if we want to make them orthogonal we can choose them to be @xmath102 , @xmath103 , @xmath104 and so on which are obviously orthogonal .
note that if we form their uniform summation as @xmath105 we will get a state whose eigenvalue for @xmath52 is @xmath56 , which is not an excitation any more .
+ all the excited states are derived by inserting one or more of these different kinds of cuts or excitations in a given ground state .
this again generalizes a feature of the potts model , where only one type of cut exists which separates two different values of spins or colors . in the non - abelian case , where the representations are not one dimensional , the domain walls are more complex .
they are designated by a pair of indices @xmath48 and @xmath91 .
this completes our analysis of the spectrum of the non - abelian potts model .
in this section we calculate the partition function which captures the statistical properties of the model .
we follow two different approaches for calculating the partition function , an algebraic approach in which we calculate the trace of @xmath106 and a combinatorial approach in which we count the number of excited states of any given energy .
the two approaches correspond respectively to high and low temperature expansions .
the reason for this correspondence will be made clear in the derivations .
since the local hamiltonians commute with each other we have z_(g)= e^-h = _ i=1^n e^h_i . noting that the local hamiltonians are projectors @xmath53 ,
we can write the exponentials in the following linear form z_(g)= , where @xmath107 . this parameter , which for high temperatures is small and for @xmath108 approaches @xmath55 , will act as an expansion parameter . at high temperatures
the first few terms of the expansion will be a good approximation of the partition function .
however in the present case , we can exactly determine the partition function by calculating all the terms .
we can write z_(g ) = _ n=0^n ^n z^(n)_(g ) , where @xmath109 is the trace of product of @xmath96 local hamiltonians . in appendix
b we prove that @xmath110 and @xmath111 . using these two results
, we obtain the exact form of the partition function to be [ zg ] z_(g)= ( e^-1+|g|)^n + ( e^-1)^n(k-1 ) .
it is instructive to first consider the abelian potts model .
this will then teach us how to go about the non - abelian case . in the limit @xmath112
, only the ground states contribute to the partition functions . at very low temperatures both the ground states and the low lying excited states
contribute to the partition function .
as we will see the low lying states corresponds to few domain walls in the configuration of spins .
as the temperature rises more domain walls contribute and the low temperature expansion necessitates the counting of contribution of various configurations of domain walls . again in the present context , we can sum all the contributions exactly and obviously the result should be equal to that of the high - temperature expansion . more precisely , we note that the ground state energy of the abelian potts model is equal to @xmath113 ( when all the spins are the same , or when all the spins are colored by one single color ) and the degeneracy of the ground state is equal to @xmath0 .
coming to the excited states , for each neighboring pair where the two labels @xmath2 and @xmath114 are unequal , i.e. for each domain wall , an excited state is created .
so for @xmath115 domain walls , the energy will be @xmath116 .
the degeneracy of this energy is then equal to the total number of different configurations with @xmath115 domain walls .
this degeneracy comes from the different positions of the @xmath115 walls and the different possible spin configurations ( which we call colors ) for each configuration of walls .
the first factor is easy to calculate . with a periodic boundary condition ,
it is simply given by @xmath117 .
note that @xmath115 should be greater than @xmath56 , since in a periodic lattice , there can not be one single wall .
calculation of the second factor , which we denote by @xmath118 , is done as follows .
consider figure [ walls ] which shows @xmath115 different domains , separated by @xmath115 walls .
for domain @xmath56 we have @xmath0 colors to choose . for the second domain
we are left with @xmath119 walls , since the color of this domain has to be different from the first one . for the third domain we have again @xmath119 choices , since the color of this domain has to be different from the second one .
so going around the circle and coming to the last domain @xmath115 we have @xmath120 different choices of colors , but in so counting , we have over - counted the number of colors , since the color of the last region @xmath115 should be different from that of region @xmath56 .
the number of such configurations is simply @xmath121 , since in this case the two domains @xmath115 and @xmath56 merge into one single domain .
thus we arrive at the recursion relation [ rr ] c_k(d ) = d ( d-1)^k-1 - c_k-1(d ) , c_0(d ) = d , the solution of which is [ cd ] c_k(d)=(d-1)^k+(d-1)(-1)^k .
therefore the degree of degeneracy of each energy level @xmath122 is given by , leading to the partition function of the @xmath9 level potts model z _ ( ) = _
k=0^n e^(n - k ) nk = ( e^-1+d)^n + ( e^-1)^n(d-1 ) .
( for abelian group ) is characterized by the position of the walls and different possible colors . for a configuration with @xmath115 fixed walls ,
there are @xmath123 different eigenstates as given in [ cd ] . ]
we now go on to the quantum case . here
the structure or the labels of a domain wall is more complex , since as in figure [ circle ] , each domain is characterized not only by a color ( a representation label @xmath124 ) but also by two matrix indices @xmath48 and @xmath91 . consider the first domain in figure [ circle ] .
the total number of choices for this domain is thus @xmath125 .
what is the number of possible choices for the next domain ? from the structure of excited states in [ exs1 ] , [ exs2 ] and [ exs3 ] , we see that from all the combinations of labels for this wall , only one combination does nt lead to an excitation at the position of the wall , hence there are @xmath126 possible choices for this second domain .
the rest of reasoning is exactly the same as for the abelian case , namely we again have the same recursion relation as in [ rr ] , but with a different initial condition : c_k(g ) = |g| ( |g|-1)^k-1 - c_k-1(g ) , c_0(g ) = k , where we remind the reader that @xmath17 is the number of different irreducible representations or the number of conjugacy classes .
this leads to [ cg ] c_k(g ) = ( |g|-1)^k + ( -1)^k ( k-1 ) , and @xmath127 $ ] and finally to the partition function [ pg ] z_(g)= ( e^-1+|g|)^n + ( e^-1)^n(k-1 ) , in accordance with [ zg ] .
( for a general finite group ) is characterized by the position of the walls and the type of domains separated by them . for a configuration with @xmath115 fixed walls ,
there are @xmath128 different eigenstates as given in [ cg ] . ] in the limit @xmath112 , where @xmath129 , we find from [ pg ] that @xmath130 , as it should be , since in this limit only the ground states contribute to the partition function and there are @xmath17 ground states , each with energy @xmath113 .
conversely in the high temperature limit , where @xmath131 , we find @xmath132 , meaning that all the states contribute equally to the partition function and the thermal density matrix is a completely mixed one . +
we have introduced the non - abelian potts model , and have made a rather detailed study of its properties . in the same way that ising and potts model have led to a large number of applications in physics , it may also be the case that the non - abelian case , in view of its richer structure , may find such applications . on the theoretical side ,
we believe that there are many avenues of research which are opened by this study . here
are a few examples : + i ) the definition of the model on 2d lattices remains to be done .
although in one dimensional lattices the local hamiltonian [ localh ] is the same as the one pertaining to the vertex operators of the quantum double model of kitaev @xcite , one can not simply carry this to 2d lattices since it would lead to a four - body interaction , while a natural generalization of the potts model should include two - body interactions
. it may still be the case that a 2d model with two - body interaction as we have defined , is solvable , in the sense that its ground state and low - lying states can be determined in closed form , although in 2d lattice not all the local hamiltonians will commute with each other anymore .
if this is the case , then the structure of the 2d model will be even more interesting and challenging to determine .
one may even be able to establish a duality relation between the high and low temperature expansions in this case which will then enable one to determine the critical point without an exact solution . to find an exact solution for the 2d case
, the first step may be to define the model on a one - dimensional ladder , where despite the incommutability of the operators , there is still some simplicity in the geometry of the lattice .
this has already been exploited to find the explicit form of the full spectrum of the kitaev model on spin ladders @xcite .
+ ii ) one can also generalize this to lie groups on discrete lattices , or to lie groups on the real line , where a suitable definition of the model hamiltonian should be made . in view of the matrix product structure of the ground states
, it may be the case that the generalization of matrix product formalism for quantum field theories as developed in @xcite will be a natural framework for studying this type of generalization .
+ iii ) one can add terms which pertain to an external magnetic field in the ising model . in the same way that adding an external transverse field to the ising model leads to a rich many - body system which undergoes a quantum phase transition , this may also happen for the non - abelian potts model .
in such case , one anticipates that the solution will be highly non - trivial and technical , if an exact solution exists at all .
moreover the meaning of transversality of the external field should also be clarified in this case .
+ iv ) it will also be interesting to study possible phase transitions between this type of order and other possibly topological orders in models where suitable interaction terms are added to the hamiltonian @xcite .
+ v ) finally it will be interesting to investigate the relation between this 1d quantum mechanical system and the 2d classical model . once
a 2d classical possibly exactly solvable model is at hand , one can obtain the transfer matrix which represents a 1d quantum mechanical model . in the present case ,
knowledge of the complete spectrum of the 1d model means that the 2d classical model , once properly defined , is exactly solvable .
these studies are now underway by the authors .
+ ising , ernst .
`` beitrag zur theorie des ferromagnetismus . ''
zeitschrift fr physik a hadrons and nuclei 31.1 ( 1925 ) : 253 - 258
. binder , k. `` ising model . ''
hazewinkel , michiel , encyclopedia of mathematics .
springer ( 2001 ) .
ashkin , julius , and edward teller .
`` statistics of two - dimensional lattices with four components . '' physical review 64.5 - 6 ( 1943 ) : 178 .
wu , fa - yueh .
`` the potts model . ''
reviews of modern physics 54.1 ( 1982 ) : 235 .
lieb , e. , schultz , t. , mattis , d. `` two soluble models of an antiferromagnetic chain '' . in condensed matter physics and exactly soluble models ( pp . 543 - 601 ) .
springer berlin heidelberg , ( 2004 ) .
potts , renfrey b. , and john c. ward .
`` the combinatrial method and the two - dimensional ising model . ''
progress of theoretical physics 13.1 ( 1955 ) : 38 - 46 .
montroll , elliott w. , renfrey b. potts , and john c. ward .
`` correlations and spontaneous magnetization of the twodimensional ising model . ''
journal of mathematical physics 4.2 ( 1963 ) : 308 - 322 .
dyson , freeman j. `` existence of a phase - transition in a one - dimensional ising ferromagnet . ''
communications in mathematical physics 12.2 ( 1969 ) : 91 - 107 .
onsager , lars .
`` crystal statistics . i. a two - dimensional model with an order - disorder transition . '' physical review 65.3 - 4 ( 1944 ) : 117 . montroll , elliott w. , renfrey b. potts , and john c. ward . `` correlations and spontaneous magnetization of the twodimensional ising model . ''
journal of mathematical physics 4.2 ( 1963 ) : 308 - 322 .
potts , renfrey burnard .
`` some generalized order - disorder transformations . ''
mathematical proceedings of the cambridge philosophical society .
01 . cambridge university press , 1952 .
baxter , r. j. `` exactly solved models in statistical physics . '' academic , new york ( 1982 ) .
baxter , r. j. `` the inversion relation method for some two - dimensional exactly solved models in lattice statistics . ''
journal of statistical physics 28.1 ( 1982 ) : 1 - 41 .
affleck , ian , et al .
`` rigorous results on valence - bond ground states in antiferromagnets . '' physical review letters 59.7 ( 1987 ) : 799 .
majumdar , chanchal k. , and dipan k. ghosh .
`` on nextnearestneighbor interaction in linear chain . i. '' journal of mathematical physics 10.8 ( 1969 ) : 1388 - 1398 .
stanley , h. eugene . `` dependence of critical properties on dimensionality of spins . '' physical review letters 20.12 ( 1968 ) : 589 .
hopfield , john j. `` neural networks and physical systems with emergent collective computational abilities . ''
proceedings of the national academy of sciences 79.8 ( 1982 ) : 2554 - 2558 .
schneidman , elad , et al .
`` weak pairwise correlations imply strongly correlated network states in a neural population . ''
nature 440.7087 ( 2006 ) : 1007 - 1012 .
friedrich , felix , et al .
`` complexity penalized m - estimation : fast computation . ''
journal of computational and graphical statistics 17.1 ( 2008 ) : 201 - 224 .
boykov , yuri , olga veksler , and ramin zabih .
`` fast approximate energy minimization via graph cuts . '' pattern analysis and machine intelligence , ieee transactions on 23.11 ( 2001 ) : 1222 - 1239 .
kitaev , a. y. `` fault - tolerant quantum computation by anyons '' .
annals of physics , 303(1 ) , 2 - 30 , ( 2003 ) .
varadarajan , veeravalli seshadri .
lie groups , lie algebras , and their representations .
102 . springer science business media , ( 2013 ) .
vahid karimipour , a complete characterization of the spectrum of the kitaev model on spin ladders , phys . rev .
b 79 , 214435 ( 2009 ) .
frank verstraete and jose ignacio cirac , continuous matrix product states for quantum fields , physical review letters , 104 , 190405 ( 2010 ) .
vahid karimipour , laleh memarzadeh , parisa zarkeshian , the kitaev - ising model , transition between topological and ferromagnetic order , phys .
a 87 , 032322 ( 2013 ) .
razieh mohseninia , saeed s. jahromi , laleh memarzadeh , and vahid karimipour , quantum phase transition in the @xmath133 kitaev - potts model , phys . rev .
b 91 , 245110 ( 2015 ) .
gabor b. halasz and alioscia hamma , probing topological order with renyi entropy , physical rev .
a. * 86 * , 062330 ( 2012 ) .
m. d. schmidt , s. dusuel , r. orus , j. vidal and k. p. schmidt , breakdown of a perturbed @xmath134 topological phase , new journal of physics , * 14 * , 025005 ( 2012 ) .
wonmin son , luigi amico , rosario fazio , alioscia hamma , saverio pascazio and vlatko vedral , quantum phase transition between cluster and antiferromagnetic states , europhysics letters . * 95 * , 50001 ( 2011 ) .
in this appendix we prove the results in section ( [ entang ] ) on the entanglement properties of the ground states .
we first calculate the reduced density matrix of one site , which due to periodicity we take it to be the first site .
this calculation turns out to be straightforward if we use [ basis ] and cast the ground state [ gs ] into the equivalent form : [ myground ] |^= _ [ i_1 , i_n ] |d^_i_1i_2|d^_i_2i_3 |d^_i_ni_1 , where @xmath135= \lbrace i_1,i_2, ...
,i_n \rbrace$ ] , and the reduced density matrix of the first site is as follows : ^_1 = _
| ^^| . here
@xmath136 means trace over all of the spins , except the first one .
therefore we have ^_1 = _ [ i_1,i_n ] , [ j_1,j_n ] |d^_i_1i_2d^_j_1j_2| ( d^_j_2j_3| d^_i_2i_3 d^_j_nj_1|d^_i_ni_1 ) . then using the orthonormality relation [ orthonormal ] , we find that the terms in parenthesis give a series of kronecker deltas as follows : ^_1= _ [ i_1,i_n ] , [ j_1,j_n ] _ i_1,j_1 _ i_2,j_2 [ _ i_3,j_3 _i_n , j_n ] |d^_i_1i_2d^_j_1j_2| . the sum over indices in the bracket
@xmath137 $ ] produces a factor of @xmath138 leaving us with ^_1= _
i_1,i_2 @xmath139 basis and has @xmath140 eigenvectors with @xmath141 eigenvalue and @xmath142 eigenvectors with 0 eigenvalue .
thus its von - neumann entropy , as a measure of bipartite entanglement between this site and the rest of the system , is equal to : s(^_1 ) = -_n _ n ( _ n)= - n^2 _ ( ) = ( n^2 _ ) .
this means that only the one dimensional representations lead to product ground states and the larger the dimension of a representation , the larger will be the entanglement of the corresponding ground state .
+ to obtain bipartite entanglement between a block and the rest of the system one should obtain the reduced density matrix of a block with length @xmath83 , say the block consisting of sites @xmath56 to @xmath83 .
we denote this density matrix by @xmath143}$ ] and the calculation is done as follows : ^_[1,l ] = _
| ^^| , where @xmath144}}$ ] means trace over all of the spins that are not in this block .
using the same arguments as above one finds that : [ densityl ] ^_[1,l ] & = & _ [ i_1,i_n ] , [ j_1,j_n ] + & = & _ [ i_1,i_n ] , [ j_1,j_n ] _
i_1 , j_1_i_l+1,j_l+1 + & & |d^_i_1i_2d^_i_1j_2|
|d^_i_li_l+1d^_j_l , i_l+1| + & = & _ i_1,i_l+1 |^_i_1,i_l+1(l ) ^_i_1,i_l+1(l)| , where |^_i_1,i_l+1(l ) = _ i_2 , i_3 , i_l|d_i_1 , i_2|d_i_2,i_3|d_i_l , i_l+1 .
these states are not normalized and in fact they satisfy @xmath145 .
the reduced density matrix is diagonal in terms of these new states and has @xmath140 eigenvectors with nonzero eigenvalues equal to @xmath141 and @xmath146 eigenvectors with 0 eigenvalue .
therefore the von - neumann entropy of the reduced density matrix is equal to : s(^_[1,l ] ) = - n^2 _ ( ) = ( n^2 _ ) .
therefore the entanglement of a block of length @xmath83 is independent of the length of the block , depending only on its two end points , which is nothing but a manifestation of area law in this exactly solvable quantum mechanical model .
+ finally we come to the entanglement of two different sites with each other .
first we consider the entanglement of two non - adjacent sites .
following exactly the same calculation which led to the above results , it is not hard to see that the density matrix of two distant sites , say sites @xmath56 and @xmath115 , will be given by ^_(1,k)=_i , j|d^_ijd^_ij|_m , n|d^_mnd^_mn|^_1^_k , which means that there is no entanglement between the two sites .
if there is any entanglement , it is between adjacent sites .
this is indeed true as we can verify .
in fact we have already found the density matrix of a block of length @xmath83 in [ densityl ] .
specializing [ densityl ] to @xmath147 , we find the density matrix of two neighboring sites , say @xmath56 and @xmath148 .
^_(1,2)= _ i , k |^_i , k(2 ) ^_i , k(2)| , where |^_i , k(2 ) = _ j|d^_i , j|d^_j , k . we can find the negativity of @xmath149 by calculating its negativity in the form @xmath150 , where @xmath151 means partial transpose with respect to second subsystem and @xmath152 means the trace - norm of @xmath62 which is equal to @xmath153 .
the partial transpose with respect to the second subsystem is equal to : ( ^_(1,2))^t_2 = _ j , j^ |d^_i , j d^_i , j^| |d^^*_j^,k d^^*_j , k | , where @xmath154 and the negativity of this reduced density matrix is equal to : ( ^_(1,2))= , which means for the higher representations of the group the ground state contains more entanglement between the nearest neighbor spins .
in this appendix we present details of the calculations of the partition function in the high temperature expansion .
we have z_(g ) = _ n=0^n ^n z^(n)_(g ) , where @xmath109 is the trace of product of @xmath96 local hamiltonians .
obviously we have @xmath155 . to calculate the first order term , consider the trace of a single local hamiltonian like @xmath156 on the local hilbert spaces of the first two sites @xmath56 and @xmath148 , where it acts nontrivially .
we write _ 12(h_1)&= & = _ g , h , kg h , k| r(g)l(g)|h , k&=&_g , h , k h , k|hg^-1 , gk=_g , h , k ( g , e)=|g| .
this leads to @xmath157 , hence @xmath158 .
in second order we face two types of terms , those which are adjacent connected like @xmath159 ( which we call connected segments ) or those which are far apart like @xmath160 with @xmath161 , terms like @xmath162 and so forth ( which we call disconnected ) .
consider a disconnected terms first .
for a disconnected term like @xmath162 we note that @xmath163 and therefore @xmath164 . for a connected term like @xmath159
we have _ 123(h_1h_2)&= & & = & _ g_1,g_2,h , k , lg h , k , l| r(g_1)l(g_1)r(g_2)l(g_2)|h , k , l&=&_g_1,g_2,h , k , l h , k ,
l|hg_1 ^ -1 , g_1kg_2 ^ -1,g_2 l. therefore _ 123(h_1h_2)=_g_1,g_2,h ,
k , l ( g_1,e)(g_2,e)=|g| , leading to @xmath165 .
therefore both types of connected and disconnected terms have the same trace which leads to a great simplification .
this gives @xmath166 .
this feature is true for all the terms up to and including the @xmath167-th term .
therefore we have @xmath168 . for the last terms where we have a full cycle of terms , i.e. a closed loop , the situation is a little bit different .
in this case we have @xmath169 or ( h_1h_2h_n)= _ g_1 ,
g_n_h_1(g_2 g_3g_n g_1 h_1g_1 ^ -1 g_n^-1g_2 ^ -1,h_1 ) . using the change of variable @xmath173 and performing the sum over all the other group elements @xmath174 to @xmath175 , we find where z_(g)=_k=0^n-1 ^k nk |g|^n - k + ^n k or [ zg ] z_(g)= ( e^-1+|g|)^n + ( e^-1)^n(k-1 ) . equation ( [ zg ] ) gives the final expression for the partition function of the non - abelian potts model on a ring of @xmath41 sites for a finite group @xmath10 .
apart from the obvious dependence on @xmath41 and @xmath178 , it depends on the size of the group and the number of its conjugacy classes or irreducible representations . | we generalize the classical one dimensional potts model to the case where the symmetry group is a non - abelian finite group .
it turns out that this new model has a quantum nature in that its spectrum of energy eigenstates consists of entangled states .
we determine the complete energy spectrum , i.e. the ground states and all the excited states with their degeneracy structure .
we calculate the partition function by two different algebraic and combinatorial methods .
we also determine the entanglement properties of its ground states . * the quantum ( non - abelian ) potts model and its exact solution * 4em * razieh mohseninia * and * vahid karimipour * 1em department of physics , + sharif university of technology , p.o .
box 111555 - 9161 , tehran , iran .
+ pacs numbers : 05.50.+q , 64.60.de , 75.10.-b , 75.10.hk , 03.65.ud |
the @xmath8-state potts model can be represented as the correlated site - bond percolation in terms of fortuin - kasteleyn clusters @xcite . at the critical point of the second order phase transition ,
the infinite cluster is formed .
this cluster crosses the system connecting the opposite sides of the square lattice . in the last decade
the study of the shape of the crossing probability was performed by conformal methods @xcite as well as numerically @xcite . according to refs .
@xcite the distribution function of the percolation thresholds is gaussian function . following the number of works @xcite
the tails of the distribution function are not gaussian ones .
the authors of the recent work ref .
@xcite are still uncertain to distinguish a stretched exponential behavior from a gaussian .
the aim of this paper is to investigate the shape of the probability of a system to percolate only in horizontal direction @xmath0 .
we perform numerical simulation of correlated site - bond percolation model for @xmath1 ( the percolation model @xmath9 , the ising model @xmath10 and the potts model @xmath11 ) for lattice sizes @xmath12 .
the scaling formulas for a body of the crossing probability at criticality and for tails of the crossing probability were obtained . the final result for the representative case @xmath10 , @xmath13 is immediately presented in fig .
[ fig1]a ) .
details of fitting procedure are described in section [ secapp2 ] . in this figure
we plot ( by crosses ) the numerical data for the absolute value of the logarithm of crossing probability @xmath0 for the ising model ( @xmath10 ) on the lattice @xmath13 as a function of the absolute value of the scaling variable @xmath14 .
here @xmath5 is a probability of a bond to be closed , @xmath15 is the inverse temperature , @xmath4 is the correlation length scaling index . the critical point in the @xmath16 scale for the @xmath8-state potts model
is @xmath17 see ref .
@xcite and we get @xmath18 .
we can see from fig .
[ fig1]a ) that the function @xmath19 consists of two parts : the body @xmath20 and the tails @xmath21 .
the negative logarithm of the body of the crossing probability as a function of @xmath22 is well described by function @xmath23 ( solid line on the fig .
[ fig1]a ) ) . here
@xmath7 is some scaling index
. the value of the crossing probability at the critical point @xmath24 may be computed ( at least for percolation ) by conformal field methods @xcite .
the negative logarithm of the tails of the crossing probability have shape @xmath25 ( dashed line in the fig .
[ fig1]a ) ) .
this line is tangent to the body at the point @xmath26 .
this point is marked by the horizontal line .
let us note that in fig .
[ fig1]a ) we plot two branches of the crossing probability ( for @xmath27 and @xmath28 ) .
the coincidence of this two branches indicate the remarkable symmetry of the crossing probability with respect to the variable @xmath22 . in fig .
[ fig1]b ) we plot the crossing probability by crosses ( bottom ) and the magnetic susceptibility by triangles ( top ) as a functions of the inverse temperature @xmath15 with logarithm scale for the ordinate axis . in fig .
[ fig1]b ) we indicate the position of crossover region of @xmath0 by horizontal solid line on a level @xmath29 . for the magnetic susceptibility we mark the region with critical behavior @xmath30 by horizontal dashed lines .
we see from fig .
[ fig1]b ) that tails of the crossing probability directly correspond to the critical region of the magnetic susceptibility . in this critical region
the correlation length @xmath31 is smaller than the sample size @xmath32 .
as the temperature approaches to the critical point , the correlation length reaches the sample size . at that point the magnetic susceptibility on the finite lattice deviates from the critical behavior eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) and becomes smooth
see the region over the top dashed horizontal line in the fig .
[ fig1]b ) . at the same point
the crossing probability crosses over from tails to body
the region over the solid horizontal line in fig .
[ fig1]b ) ( and the region _ under _ the horizontal line in fig . [ fig1]a ) ) . at the critical point
@xmath33 both the magnetic susceptibility and the crossing probability reach a maximum . the detailed description of the fitting procedure as well as numerical data for @xmath1 are presented below .
the main numerical result of this paper is the proving of the formula @xmath34l^{{\nu}})$ ] for the tails of the crossing probability .
therefore , we pay special attention to fitting procedures .
the paper is organized as follows : in the second section , we describe details of the numerical simulation . in the third section , the method for determining the pseudocritical point @xmath35 on the finite lattice is described .
we use @xmath35 to perform the approximation of the tails . in section [ secapp1 ]
we approximate the double logarithm of the crossing probability @xmath36 tails as a function of the logarithm of deviation from the critical point @xmath37 by the linear function @xmath38 .
we get @xmath39 for this approximation procedure . in section [ secapp2 ]
we describe new fitting procedure using the scaling variable @xmath14 .
results of approximation are discussed in section [ secres ] .
we perform the massive monte - carlo simulation on the square lattice of size @xmath40 to obtain the high - precision data for @xmath0 .
we use the dual lattice shown in fig .
[ fig2 ] . on such lattice
the critical point of the bond percolation ( @xmath9 ) is exactly equal @xmath41 and is not dependent on the lattice size @xcite . to produce the pseudorandom numbers we use the r9689 random number generator with four taps @xcite .
we close each bond with a probability @xmath16 and leave it open with a probability @xmath42 .
then we split the lattice into clusters of connected sites by using the hoshen - kopelman algorithm @xcite .
after that we check the percolation through this configuration .
we average the crossing probability over @xmath43 random bond configurations . to investigate the potts model @xmath44 we use the wolff @xcite cluster algorithm to generate a sequence of thermally equilibrated spin configurations .
for each particular inverse temperature @xmath45 we flip 20000 wolff clusters to equilibrate the system . for the spin model on the finite lattice
the deviation of the pseudocritical point from the position of the critical point on the infinite lattice is smaller for periodic boundary condition ( pbc ) rather than the open boundary condition ( obc ) @xcite .
for this reason we use the pbc for the wolff algorithm .
the monte - carlo algorithm generates spin configurations on a torus . for a generated spin configuration
we create a configuration of bonds .
each bond between sites with equal spin variable @xmath46 is closed with the probability @xmath5 and is open with probability @xmath47 .
bonds between sites with different values of @xmath46 are always open in accordance with fortuin - kasteleyn rule @xcite .
then we split the particular spin and bond configurations into different clusters .
here we use obc .
it means that for each generated configuration we cut the torus and check the crossing on the square with open boundary conditions .
we fix the obc for crossing only in horizontal direction @xmath0 because it implies the vertical crossing is absent and the top and bottom rows must be disjointed .
but we take into consideration the additional raw and column of bonds , as shown in fig .
we check the percolation through an obtained cluster configuration , generate new spin configuration and so on .
we average the crossing probability over @xmath43 configurations for each value of the inverse temperature @xmath15 .
so the resolution of our computations is about @xmath48 . by this way we perform numerical simulation and get a set of data for @xmath49 for the lattice sizes @xmath12 and @xmath44 .
the formal definition of @xmath49 as a sum over different cluster configurations is described in @xcite . for the potts model
we use the dual lattice as we do for the percolation .
it means , that we take into account additional bonds attached to the bottom row of spins . in the same way we take into account additional bonds attached to the right column of the spins . on the lattice with pbc
these bonds have to connect the right and the left columns .
we cut the torus ( because we use obc for crossing probability ) but we keep these additional bonds and take into account the checking of the crossing . in fig .
[ fig2 ] contact points are shown by arrows .
the left contact points are attached to the left column of sites .
the right contact points are attached to additional bonds . in fig .
[ fig2 ] the bond configuration with the horizontally spanning cluster is shown .
then we check the percolation through the obtained cluster configuration . after
that we flip three wolff clusters , check spanning for a new spin configuration and so on .
we investigate the crossing probability as a function of deviation from the critical point .
therefore , we perform the preliminary approximations to obtain the critical points for the finite samples . namely , we : * obtain the pseudocritical point and the shape of the central part of the crossing probability , * determine the shape of the tails of the crossing probability * combine together the information for body and tails , and reconstruct the total shape of the crossing probability .
we need to recall that we consider the crossing probability as a function of the variable @xmath5 ( probability of a bond to be closed ) .
it is easy to understand that we must take the pseudocritical point on the finite lattice @xmath35 as the reference point .
the crossing probability is a symmetric function of the variable @xmath50 .
this fact implies that the high temperature tail @xmath51 ( @xmath52 ) and the low temperature tail @xmath53 coincide @xmath54 . for the bond percolation on the dual lattice
the position of the percolation point does not depend on the lattice size @xmath55 @xcite . for the determination of @xmath35 for the ising and the potts model we use the following procedure .
we can assume @xcite that in the the fitting formula is true @xmath56^{\zeta(l , q)}).\ ] ] therefore we fit the logarithm of the crossing probability @xmath57 by the function @xmath58 namely @xmath59^{\zeta(l , q)},\ ] ] where @xmath60 .
we plot the data for @xmath61 as a function of @xmath16 in fig .
[ fig3]a ) , fig .
[ fig3]b ) , fig .
[ fig3]c ) , fig .
[ fig3]d ) for @xmath1 respectively .
the errorbars in these figures are about the symbol size .
it seems , that behavior of @xmath61 near @xmath2 is parabolic .
results of the approximation are plotted in the same figures by lines .
we shall see that there is a good agreement between the numerical data and the results of the approximation .
but we see deviation at the point @xmath2 especially for @xmath11 . in the vicinity of @xmath2 real graphs
are more smooth than fitting functions . finally for each pair of numbers
@xmath62 we obtain four fitting parameters @xmath63 . here
@xmath64 defines the crossing probability in the critical point , @xmath65 is a scaling variable , @xmath35 is the position of the pseudocritical point on the lattice @xmath40 , and @xmath66 is a scaling index . in table
[ tab1 ] we collect data for the logarithm of critical amplitude @xmath60 .
the fitting parameter @xmath67 defines a vertical shift of graphs in fig .
[ fig3]a)-[fig3]d ) from the zero level .
.results of the approximation for the fitting parameter @xmath60 . [
cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tab11 ]
using the dual lattice ( see fig . [ fig2 ] ) allows us to avoid finite size shift of the critical point for the bond percolation and to diminish it for spin models .
the accuracy of definition of the critical point on the finite lattice play the principal role for the investigation of the tails scaling .
the high quality of our approximation is proved by remarkable symmetry of the crossing probability with respect to the critical point @xmath2 . in fig .
[ fig5 ] and fig .
[ fig7 ] we can observe that the two branches @xmath68 and @xmath69 practically coincide .
the two different scaling region of the crossing probability clearly seen in fig .
[ fig1]a ) can explain the long time uncertainty about its shape . in ref.@xcite the scaling index for the percolation threshold for @xmath70 percolation model
was found @xmath71 .
this result coincides with our approximation of the body of the crossing probability for percolation @xmath72 . in more recent works @xcite the tails region for percolation
was investigated which is described by the scaling formula @xmath73 . the crossover form to gaussian - like behavior to slope @xmath74
is observed in figures of ref.@xcite .
it seems , near the critical point the behavior of the crossing probability is parabolic .
the rounding happens in the interval @xmath75 .
this interval is relatively small in comparison with regions of the body @xmath76 and tails @xmath77 as it can be seen in fig .
[ fig7 ] .
we have five fitting parameters @xmath78 , @xmath79 , @xmath80 , @xmath81 , @xmath82 in expressions ( [ eq10 ] ) and ( [ eq11 ] ) . in fig .
[ fig7]a)-fig .
[ fig7]d ) we see the crossover region between the body and the tails of the crossing probability . in this region
the function @xmath83 touched the line @xmath84 .
it means , that in some point @xmath26 the values of the functions are equal , therefore @xmath85 and first derivatives of this functions are equal too @xmath86 substituting @xmath81 from eq .
( [ eq16 ] ) in eq .
( [ eq15 ] ) we obtain expression for @xmath79 @xmath87 if the crossing probabilities at the critical points @xmath88 ( and logarithms @xmath78 ) can be calculated analytically by conformal field methods ( at least for the percolation it is possible ) @xcite then only four independent parameters @xmath79 , @xmath89 and @xmath80 , @xmath78 remain for the crossing probability . * in accordance with scaling theory the finite size scaling of the crossing probabilities may be eliminated by introducing the scaling variable @xmath90 .
the crossing probability as a function of @xmath22 does not depend on the lattice size @xmath40 . *
the body of the crossing probability scales @xmath91 . *
the tails of the crossing probabilities scales @xmath92 .
the value of parameter @xmath93 is about 1 . *
the finite size scaling for @xmath94 does not describe by the analytical value of the correlation length index @xmath95 .
we obtain some scaling index @xmath96 .
this index @xmath97 for the tails of the crossing probability ( see table [ tab5 ] ) or @xmath98 for the body of the crossing probability ( see table [ tab2 ] ) . | the scaling of the tails of the probability of a system to percolate only in the horizontal direction @xmath0 was investigated numerically for correlated site - bond percolation model for @xmath1 .
we have to demonstrate that the tails of the crossing probability far from the critical point @xmath2 have shape @xmath3^{\nu})$ ] where @xmath4 is the correlation length index , @xmath5 is the probability of a bond to be closed . at criticality
we observe crossover to another scaling @xmath6^{\nu } \right\}^{z } \right)$ ] . here
@xmath7 is a scaling index describing the central part of the crossing probability . |
type ia supernovae ( sne ia ) have proven to be effective standardizable candles and their high peak luminosity has made them excellent cosmological probes . an empirically determined relation between light - curve properties and peak absolute magnitude @xcite has yielded improved estimates of the global hubble constant @xcite .
although the earliest attempts to measure the matter density of the universe preceded these light - curve shape methods @xcite , and the initial efforts by the supernova cosmology project ( scp ) led to incorrect conclusions about the cosmic matter density @xcite , early work by both the scp and the high - z supernova search team @xcite found evidence for low matter density @xcite .
subsequent publications by @xcite and @xcite came to the surprising conclusion that the universe is expanding at an accelerating rate , driven by a mysterious dark energy ; see @xcite , @xcite , or @xcite for reviews .
this surprising result has been confirmed by more - recent supernova observations @xcite and by complementary measurements of the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) anisotropies ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) and large - scale structure ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
focus has now shifted from demonstrating the existence of dark energy to constraining its properties @xcite and sharpening the tools available for its study ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
. analyses of their spectra and light curves have led to the consensus that sne ia are well characterized by a thermonuclear disruption of a carbon - oxygen white dwarf ( wd ) .
the transition from a dynamically stable wd to an explosion capable of outshining an entire galaxy is precipitated by the wd mass approaching the chandrasekhar mass limit through matter accretion from a close binary companion .
the nature of this accretion process is still uncertain , though two scenarios have become the focus of sn ia progenitor modeling .
the first is the single - degenerate ( sd ) model in which a wd accretes matter from a non - degenerate companion @xcite , while the second is the double - degenerate ( dd ) model involving the merger to two wds @xcite .
though promising , our understanding of these models remains incomplete with questions persisting about the nature of the binary companion ( main sequence , asymptotic giant branch , etc . ) and accretion flow in the sd scenario , the apparent likelihood that a wd merger will result in an accretion - induced collapse rather than a sn ia , and the potential for multiple stellar - population - dependent channels leading to sn ia explosions .
differentiating among dark - energy models requires mapping the expansion history of the universe with high precision and a small systematic error . applying sne ia to this problem
is complicated by the uncertain nature of the explosion physics and progenitor stars ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
even with the most basic assumption , that a sn ia results from the thermonuclear disruption of a near - chandrasekhar mass carbon - oxygen wd , there remain potential dangers in blindly applying sne ia to the dark - energy problem . theoretical models @xcite suggest that population age and metallicity may have an effect on the wd composition and influence the sn ia peak luminosity .
since the average age and metal content of stars have evolved over cosmic time , the ensemble character of sn ia explosions may be a function of lookback time .
but the local universe contains a range of stellar ages and metallicities , so an empirical calibration of these effects may be possible .
@xcite were the first to note a correlation between sn ia decline rate and host - galaxy morphology .
the results showed that intrinsically faint events occur in early - type ( e / s0 ) galaxies , while luminous events are often hosted by late - type galaxies .
this correlation with morphology has since been confirmed in larger sn ia samples ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , but the cause of the trend remains unknown .
the existence of a correlation is important because it demonstrates that the sn ia environment imprints itself on some aspect of the progenitor . on average ,
spiral and elliptical galaxies differ in population age , star - formation rate ( sfr ) , and metal content , with significant overlap in these properties across the morphological types .
@xcite measured the metallicity of a small sample of star - forming hosts to test if age or metal content was the factor influencing sn ia luminosity , but the results were ambiguous .
@xcite expanded the number of observed hosts to test the impact of stellar environment on the photometric properties of nearby sne ia .
potential dependencies of sn decline rate on host - galaxy absolute magnitude and star - formation history were investigated in a sample of galaxies with a broad range of properties and across the full hubble sequence .
metallicity was measured from emission lines , limiting this aspect of the study to star - forming hosts .
no significant correlation between metallicity and decline rate was detected , though a tenuous correlation was found between the metal content and hubble residuals .
furthermore , only galaxies without significant star formation were found to host faint , fast - declining sne ia .
the division by star - formation history was more stark than by morphology alone , suggesting that the observed luminosity spread in sne ia results from the influence of population age on the wd progenitors .
the luminosity / star - formation relation has also been seen in a high - redshift sample of sne ia studied by the supernova legacy survey ( snls ) @xcite .
the specific sn ia rate is strongly dependent on the amount of current star formation @xcite .
actively star - forming galaxies host approximately 10 times as many sne ia per unit mass than do their low star - forming counterparts .
@xcite find that the sn ia rate is well described by a combination of two distinct populations of sne ia : a prompt " ( shorter delay time ) sn ia component dependent upon the recent star formation in the galaxy and an delayed " or `` tardy '' ( longer delay time ) component dependent on the number of low - mass stars . assuming the light - curve shape correction methods are perfect , then this will not have an effect on the recent cosmological results . however ,
if the corrected photometric properties of these two sn populations differ ( e.g. , a variation due to age or metallicity ) , then it could have implications for derived cosmological parameters because the short delay time sne are expected to dominate at high redshift whereas the long delay time events are expected to dominate at low redshift . here
we present our study on the luminosity - weighted ages and metal abundances of early - type host galaxies .
early - type galaxies , unlike star - forming spirals , have been shown to host both faint and bright sne ia , thereby allowing us to sample the full diversity of sne ia .
consequently , we focus our study on absorption - line spectra of host galaxies and utilize single age , single metallicity stellar population models to characterize the stellar populations @xcite .
the impact of both age and metallicity on sn peak magnitude is studied and the sample age and metallicity distributions will be compared to absorption - line spectra of field galaxies obtained from the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) .
furthermore , we will infer from our data a measurement of the relative sn ia rate as a function of galaxy age .
finally , we will search for second - order dependencies at the level of the sn ia intrinsic scatter by comparing host - galaxy ages and metallicities to the sn residuals from the hubble diagram .
we detail our observational techniques and data - reduction pipeline in 2 of this paper . in 3 we report the methods for performing emission - line corrections , and for obtaining age and metallicity estimates of our host sample .
our results are presented in 4 , and the summary and conclusions are in 5 .
the objective of this study was to obtain absorption - line spectra of sn ia host galaxies with the intent of estimating their ages and metallicities through a comparison with the simple stellar population ( ssp ) models of alexandre vazdekis @xcite .
to this end , we obtained spectra of a sample of sn ia host galaxies with the 1.5 m tillinghast telescope located at the f. l. whipple observatory .
we employed the fast spectrograph @xcite fitted with the 300 line mm@xmath3 reflection grating and a @xmath4 slit .
the setup gave a resolution of @xmath5 full width at half maximum intensity ( fwhm ) .
the spectra were obtained over the course of 6 nights during april and july of 2005 .
our set was compiled from the host galaxies of sne ia from the samples of @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite .
suitable targets were those classified as having early type ( s0e ) , as well as spiral galaxies containing strong absorption lines in their spectra ( and minimal emission lines ) as determined by @xcite .
in addition to the host galaxies , we also obtained spectra for a set of comparison elliptical galaxies having age and metallicities estimates determined by @xcite .
the slit was aligned along the galaxy s major axis with position angles ( pas ) determined via the digital sky survey ( dss ) plates . in a few cases
the pa was altered to prevent a nearby star from falling on the slit .
exposure times were varied depending on the galaxy brightness , with a target signal - to - noise ratio ( s / n ) of 1020 . for each target
we obtained three spectra that we subsequently combined to improve the s / n and remove cosmic rays .
bias , dark , and dome - flat exposures were taken at the beginning and the end of each night , and a comparison spectrum of a he - ne - ar lamp was acquired before each target for wavelength calibration .
finally , flux standard star spectra were taken each night with the slit oriented along the parallactic angle @xcite .
our full sample of galaxies can be seen in table 1 .
columns ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) give the host - galaxy name and hosted sn , respectively . column
( 3 ) provides the peak magnitudes of the hosted sn ia , determined from the sn light - curve data and employing mlcs2k2 @xcite .
column ( 4 ) gives the morphological classification of each galaxy , while column ( 5 ) reports the pa for the each observation .
column ( 6 ) shows the width of the extracted aperture encompassing all the light out to approximately the effective radius , @xmath6 .
finally , column ( 7 ) gives the source of the sn light - curve : ( 1 ) the cfa sample @xcite , ( 2 ) the katzman automatic imaging telescope ( kait ) @xcite , and ( 3 ) sn 2005bl @xcite .
the majority of data reduction for this study was performed using standard techniques within iraf .
the data were bias and dark - subtracted , and flat - fielded to remove the pixel - to - pixel variations in the ccd ; also , the bad rows and columns of the ccd were interpolated across using the routine fixpix .
following preprocessing , the task was to combine the set of three spectral images that we had for each target .
the first step was the removal of cosmic rays . in the interest of preserving every image in a set , thereby increasing our statistics , we removed each cosmic ray individually using the imedit routine in iraf .
cosmic rays that fell on the galaxy nucleus itself were left alone until after the aperture extraction .
one - dimensional aperture extraction was performed using the apall routine with extraction radii equal to the effective radius ( @xmath6 ) of each galaxy .
the effective radii were determined through an idl code written to integrate over the average profile of 400 centrally located columns along the spatial axis of each image .
each spectrum was then individually checked for cosmic rays landing on one of our relevant absorption - line indices or the surrounding continua . in the event that an interfering cosmic ray was found , steps were taken to either remove it interactively within splot , or to remove the image altogether if the cosmic ray was too disruptive .
the average of each set of images was generated using im - combine , and the resultant spectra were wavelength and flux calibrated .
finally , the spectra were corrected for galactic extinction using the iraf routine deredden @xcite .
a well known and much reviled puzzle in the study of stellar populations is the observed similarity between the effects of age and metallicity on the integrated light of stellar populations ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
astronomers attempt to unravel this age / metallicity degeneracy through the development of stellar population models .
the simplified goal of stellar population synthesis modeling is to find a combination of stars for which the integrated spectrum of the stars matches the observed spectrum of the population under study .
early empirical techniques such as quadratic programming devised by @xcite have given way to evolutionary population synthesis models which have been improving since the 1970s @xcite .
whereas empirical models are constructed from a combination of stellar spectra or the spectra of stellar clusters , evolutionary synthesis models utilize theoretical stellar evolutionary isochrones as the primary constituent . a single isochrone on the hertzsprung - russell ( hr ) diagram gives the locus of luminosities and temperatures at a single moment in time for stars of all masses .
together with an assumed initial mass function ( imf ) , an isochrone can be built to accurately model a single - age stellar population .
the final model is obtained by converting isochrone parameters to observed spectra and finally integrating along the isochrone .
the populations that are modeled using the above techniques are known as simple stellar populations , or ssps .
ssps are , by definition , a population of stars created during a single burst event ( i.e. , all the stars have the same age ) and possessing a single global metallicity . however , early - type galaxies are often comprised of multiple - component stellar populations .
galaxy ages derived through a comparison with these single - component ssps are luminosity weighted , and are typically sensitive to the youngest component in a real early - type galaxy .
consequently , it is appropriate to view the ages derived in studies such as ours as lower - limit estimates @xcite .
the determination of age and metallicity via galactic spectra is fairly simple , in principle .
we can exploit predictions made by population synthesis models to relate physical properties , such as age and metallicity , to observables , such as the absorption - line strengths for the strongest atomic and molecular absorption features in the optical range .
measuring the relative strengths of these absorption features , we can estimate the age and metallicity of the stellar population that created the spectrum . for the age and metallicity estimates of our galaxies ,
we employ the single age , single metallicity stellar population models described by @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite .
the models make use of the empirical stellar spectral library miles @xcite .
miles is a marked improvement over previous libraries ; it has 985 stars , a spectral resolution of 2.3 ( fwhm ) , and a wavelength range of 35257500 .
one advantage of empirical libraries over theoretical stellar libraries is that they are based on actual stellar spectra and are not dependent on the potential inaccuracies and underlying assumptions inherent in any theoretical model .
however , in order for an empirical stellar library to sufficiently cover the parameter space in temperature , gravity , abundance , and [ @xmath7/fe ] , the stellar observations must be of the highest quality .
consequently , empirical stellar libraries have traditionally been restricted to the nearest stars , thereby introducing a bias of atmospheric parameters toward those which are seen in the solar neighborhood .
the miles library acquired atmospheric parameters from the literature and calibrated the set through a subset of reference field stars from @xcite ; for full details see @xcite . in this way
, miles has optimized its stellar atmosphere coverage and improved upon previous libraries . nevertheless ,
because early - type galaxies are generally @xmath7 enhanced and metal rich , the potential bias toward solar abundance ratios should be kept in mind .
the stellar population synthesis models derived from miles consist of single age , single metallicity spectral energy distributions ( seds ) that adopt a standard salpeter imf @xcite .
the seds possess a fwhm resolution of 2.3 and a spectral range similar to our data at 35407410 .
there are 276 models with ages ranging from 0.10 to 17.78 gyr and metallicities ranging from [ m / h ] = @xmath8 to 0.20 . in the past ,
the most widely used method of estimating stellar population age and metallicity has been through a comparison of absorption - line indices with those of the lick / ids system @xcite .
since the stars of the lick / ids stellar library are not flux calibrated , data must be converted to the instrumental response curve of the original data set @xcite . with the advent of improved , flux - calibrated stellar libraries , it became possible to generate complete seds of a single stellar population @xcite , thereby eliminating the need for such a correction .
furthermore , in order to use the lick population models , it is necessary to transform the observational data to match the resolution of the lick spectrograph ( @xmath910 fwhm ) . for our analysis ,
the model seds are at a higher resolution than the data ; consequently , the models were required to be broadened to the resolution of our data rather than the other way around .
thus , the first step in the analysis was to characterize the wavelength - dependent resolution of our spectra .
this was accomplished by measuring the line widths of emission lines in the he - ne - ar lamp across our full spectral range .
a polynomial fit to the resulting scatter plot provided a wavelength - dependent resolution function for the fast spectrograph .
we derived a wavelength - dependent broadening term with a square equal to the difference between the square of the host - galaxy resolution and that of the resolution of the vazdekis models , given as 2.3 .
the next broadening term we considered was from the velocity dispersion of the host galaxies . to determine the velocity dispersion for each galaxy
, we obtained spectra of velocity standard stars hd12623 and hd52071 ; these were taken within a few months of our observing runs on the tillinghast telescope using the fast spectrograph . in total
, we obtained 6 spectra of hd12623 and 14 spectra of hd52071 .
cross - correlation analysis was then performed between these templates and the host - galaxy spectra using the iraf routine fxcor .
a velocity dispersion and redshift estimate were obtained using each template - galaxy combination , with the final result for a given host being the average of the measurements made with each of the twenty templates .
our two broadening terms were summed in quadrature , yielding the final width of our gaussian kernel used in the convolution with the host galaxy .
each host galaxy had a unique final broadening term and the vazdekis model seds were broadened independently according to this term . in this way , we created separate age / metallicity grids for each host galaxy .
the velocity dispersions and heliocentric velocities resulting from this analysis are shown in table [ tbl-2 ] .
these heliocentric velocities were converted to cmb rest frame for the subsequent analysis using the ned velocity calculator .
the age dependent absorption index chosen for this study was h@xmath10 .
h@xmath10 is known to be metallicity insensitive and older stellar populations are known to have relatively strong h@xmath10 absorption , eliminating the need for high s / n @xcite .
although our sample was comprised mostly of older stellar populations , there was a chance for h@xmath10 emission contamination .
consequently , our data were emission - line corrected with the procedure discussed in the next section .
we chose two age - insensitive fe absorption lines for our abundance analysis , fe@xmath115270 and fe@xmath114383 . plotting both of these iron lines against h@xmath10 produces a strongly orthogonal grid well suited for untangling the age - metallicity degeneracy .
our chosen lick / ids indices are summarized in table [ tbl-3 ] .
the presence of h@xmath10 emission superimposed on h@xmath10 absorption poses a significant problem for our index measurements .
the contamination of even weak h@xmath10 emission lines in our galaxy spectra could significantly decrease the strengths of our measured h@xmath10 absorption indices , thus systematically biasing our age distribution toward greater ages .
consequently , an emission correction was performed on our host - galaxy spectra .
the basic procedure is outlined by @xcite .
the method is based on two main assertions .
first , although the underlying absorption - line spectrum at h@xmath10 is highly sensitive to age , the sensitivity to both age and metallicity is negligible at h@xmath7 .
second , the observed hn / fe index @xmath12h@xmath13/fe@xmath114045 + h@xmath14/fe@xmath114325 + h8/fe@xmath113859@xmath15 . ] represents an effective indicator of the true underlying absorption - line spectrum , implying that two galaxies with similar hn / fe indices will likewise possess similar h@xmath7 absorption strengths .
conservatively , we assumed that each galaxy in our sample was contaminated with balmer emission from h ii regions not included in the vazdekis models .
therefore , we predicted the underlying h@xmath7 absorption spectrum for a given contaminated galaxy spectrum by matching that galaxy s hn / fe index with a vazdekis model galaxy displaying a similar hn / fe index .
the matching vazdekis model sed was then treated as our model absorption spectrum .
next , we smoothed this spectrum to the appropriate resolution and velocity dispersion , normalized it to zero , and subtracted it from the host - galaxy spectrum .
this left the h@xmath7 emission free of any contaminating absorption .
the emission - line flux was measured and converted into h@xmath10 emission flux assuming a case b balmer decrement @xcite .
we used a flux - calibrated spectrum of the orion nebula taken with the same instrumental setup to model the emission spectrum intended to be subtracted off the contaminated galaxy .
the orion spectrum was smoothed to the appropriate velocity dispersion and scaled so that the h@xmath10 flux matched the calculated value .
the continuum was removed from the modified orion spectrum , and the result was subtracted from the contaminated host - galaxy spectrum .
in order to measure the h@xmath10 , fe@xmath115270 , and fe@xmath114383 indices , we employed the fortran77 code lector provided by alexandre vazdekis .
the code measures the indices of a one - dimensional input spectrum and calculates an error estimate based on photon statistics @xcite . with the line strengths we generated our index - index diagrams , in which each vertex represents a combination of line - index measurements for a single model of given age and metallicity .
a qualitative comparison between several models and a representative host galaxy are given in figure [ example_specs ] , showing a comparison of the spectrum for host galaxy ngc 4786 ( @xmath16 ) to model seds with similar metallicity ( @xmath16 ) but with varying population age .
quantitative age and metallicity estimates are found through a comparison with these model seds by way of an interpolation of the index - index diagnostic grids .
figure [ fig1 ] shows the fe@xmath115270h@xmath10 and fe@xmath114383h@xmath10 grids . in each case
the non - emission - corrected host - galaxy indices are plotted in the upper frames and the emission - corrected indices are plotted in the lower frames .
although for each galaxy metallicity and age interpolation we broadened the models according to its corresponding velocity dispersion , for the sake of presentation we show the whole sample plotted on a model grid broadened to a velocity dispersion of @xmath17 = 200 km s@xmath3 .
index measurements .
the series shows how the models change with age at a fixed metallicity and gives an alternate illustration of the technique used to realize our galaxy age / metallicity estimates . in this case , the age - sensitive index , h@xmath10 , for ngc 4786 most closely matches that measured for the sed at solar metallicity and a single population age of 7.08 gyr .
[ example_specs ] ] computing ages and metallicities for our galaxy samples required the interpolation , and on occasion extrapolation , of an irregular grid .
this was accomplished using bivariant polynomial transformations of the following form @xcite : @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the order of the polynomial and _ p@xmath20 _ and _ q@xmath20 _ are the coefficients that are solved for a set of nearest - neighbor points ( _ indx_,_indy _ ) indexed by _
i_. we performed a second - degree approximation , thus requiring us to compute at least 12 coefficients by solving two systems of 6 linear equations .
an idl code was written which allowed us to interactively select the nearest 612 grid points ( the number was dependent on the quality of the grid around the host galaxy s grid position ) and the coefficients were computed by solving the above system of equations using the method of least squares . the upper and lower limits for age and metallicity were determined directly from the absorption - line index limits outputted by lector .
the extent of the index limits can be seen from the error bars in figure [ fig1 ] .
the upper and lower limits were treated as unique points for which age and metallicity estimates were made . in the case of large index errors , the grid points chosen by our code were different from those used to determine the age / metallicity of the galaxy .
an assumption was made that the upper and lower h@xmath10 index limits corresponded to the lower and upper limits , respectively , of our galaxy age estimate .
similarly , the upper and lower limit of the fe@xmath115270 index corresponded to the upper and lower limits of the galaxy metallicity estimate .
the final uncertainty was recorded as the magnitude of the difference between the age and metallicity of the limits and those of the galaxy .
furthermore , due to the irregular nature of the grid , a symmetric error in an index measurement translated into an asymmetric error in age and metallicity .
the results from our analyses are shown in table [ tbl-4 ] .
column ( 1 ) gives the galaxy name .
columns ( 2)(7 ) give the ages , metallicities , and corresponding errors determined via the fe@xmath115270h@xmath10 diagram , while columns ( 8)(13 ) give the same results ascertained via the fe@xmath114383h@xmath10 diagram .
, is plotted against the metallicity - sensitive line indices ew , fe@xmath115270 and fe@xmath114383 , before ( top ) and after ( bottom ) emission correction .
the underlying grid reflect the vazdekis model seds broadened to a velocity dispersion , @xmath17 = 200.0 km s@xmath3 .
dashed lines ( near vertical ) are models of common metallicity , and dotted lines ( near horizontal ) are those of common age .
the bold dashed line identifies models of solar metallicity , and the bold dotted line marks models of age 7.08 gyr.[fig1 ] ] aspiring to test the uniqueness of sn ia early - type host galaxies relative to random early - type galaxies , we compared the global properties of our sn ia sample of elliptical host galaxies to those of a general sample of elliptical field galaxies from sdss .
the following steps were taken to generate a comparative sample of field galaxies .
the sdss catalog archive server was queried for galaxy spectra within the redshift range 0 @xmath21 that had a velocity dispersion measured by sdss .
the positions of these galaxies were then cross - referenced against galaxies in the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) , and only those galaxies characterized as e / s0 by ned were accepted .
the galaxy spectra of these elliptical field galaxies were then obtained from the sdss data archive server .
the spectra were emission - line corrected using a synthetic orion spectrum created via the iraf artificial data generation package , artdata . furthermore , rather than broadening the models to the specific velocity dispersion of each galaxy , we broadened the set of models to velocity dispersions in 30 km s@xmath3 intervals from 100 km s@xmath3 to 340 km s@xmath3 .
the set of models used in the analysis for a given sdss galaxy spectrum was the set broadened for a velocity dispersion that most closely matched that of the galaxy .
finally , to speed up the calculation , the grid points to perform the diagnostic interpolations were automatically chosen for the sdss sample by an algorithm designed to mimic the grid - point selection criteria used for the interactive point selection in the host - galaxy analysis .
the quality of our data is assessed via three checks , the results of which are shown in figure [ fig2 ] .
first , we compare the respective age and metallicity estimates obtained from our two index - index diagnostics .
figure [ fig2]a shows the fe@xmath114383 age estimate plotted against the age estimate of fe@xmath115270 .
given that both ages were determined using the same age - sensitive index , namely h@xmath10 , we would expect these data to be consistent with unity .
as the top - left panel shows , we find moderate scatter about unity by virtue of our error estimates .
nevertheless , the data are consistent with unity , with a @xmath22@xmath23 of 0.88 for the fit .
figure [ fig2]b shows the metallicity comparison between our two index - index diagnostics . in this case
we see more significant dispersion ; however , the data are still consistent with unity given the calculated uncertainty .
consequently , as a matter of preference , the galaxy ages and metallicities used in the following analysis will be those determined from the h@xmath10fe@xmath115270 diagnostic .
, respectively .
in both cases we find minor variations that are nonetheless consistent with unity .
panels ( b ) and ( d ) present a comparison showing reasonable agreement between our results and those of @xcite.[fig2 ] ] our second quality check is a comparison of our age and metallicity estimates to those of control galaxies studied by @xcite ( hereafter t00 ) .
our data are plotted against the data of t00 in figure [ fig2]c and [ fig2]d .
t00 made age and metallicity measurements through a central @xmath6/2 aperture and we are reporting the preferred " non - solar abundance ratio ( nsar ) model results ( model 4 ) .
the age - sensitive line index used was h@xmath10 , while the two metallicity - sensitive indices were @xmath12fe@xmath15fe@xmath15 @xmath24 ( @xmath25)(fe@xmath115270 + fe@xmath115335 ) . ] and mg b. figure [ fig2]c shows the age comparison for the two studies with the dotted line shows a model one - to - one relation .
the plot shows fairly good agreement between the two studies .
the @xmath22@xmath23 of the one - to - one fit is 8.55 , though it is improved if we throw out ngc 5813 at ( 8.69 , 24.30 ) , reducing @xmath22@xmath23 to 2.72 .
the agreement is less encouraging for the metallicity comparison in figure [ fig2]d . ignoring the few outlier points , the t00 galaxies seem to be systematically more metal rich than those measured in our study .
this is likely due to the fact that we did not account for nsar in our analysis .
studies have shown that the abundance ratios in early - type galaxies are often non - solar .
in particular , the mg / fe abundance ratio has been shown to be larger in more luminous early - type galaxies @xcite .
given that both mg and fe lines strongly factored into the metallicity measurements of t00 , we should not expect to see a straight 1:1 comparative ratio .
nevertheless , throwing out the points with the two greatest dispersions ( ngc 5813 and ngc 4489 ) , we seem to be measuring the relative metallicities consistently with t00 , thereby enabling us to find potential trends between age / metallicity and sn ia properties .
we also compare our results to those published in @xcite . in their study , they seek to set constraints on the epochs of early - type galaxy formation through an analysis of 124 early - type galaxies in both high and low - density regions .
we have 15 galaxies in common with their study and compare our h@xmath10 index , age , and metallicity measurements to those from their analysis .
similar to the comparison with t00 , we see general agreement between our respective results .
however , the agreement is far from one to one , with broad scatter greater than that seen in our t00 comparison . once again , this not entirely unexpected given our lower s / n and the fact that we did not accounted for potential @xmath7 enhancement in our galaxies .
moreover , they were sampling a significantly smaller fraction of the galactic light with an aperture radius of @xmath6/10 .
overall , our comparisons with both t00 and @xcite show reasonable agreement and confirm the ability of our analysis to measure acceptable relative population ages and metallicities for our sn ia host - galaxy sample .
finally , we compare the @xmath26 colors for the host galaxy and sdss data to the galaxy age ; see figure [ fig3 ] .
the expected average @xmath26 color for a sample of elliptical galaxies is 4.0 @xcite , and we can see that both our host galaxies and the sdss galaxies meet this expectation .
the figure also shows that both of the samples fall within the range predicted by the evolutionary synthesis models of @xcite .
the center line is the predicted trend of @xmath26 color with age for a population of solar metallicity , the top line is the prediction for a metallicity of [ m / h ] @xmath27 , and the bottom line is the prediction for a metallicity of [ m / h ] @xmath28 .
color vs. age .
we see that both of the samples fall within the range predicted by the evolutionary synthesis models of @xcite .
the center line is the predicted trend of @xmath26 color with age for a population of solar metallicity , the top line is the prediction for a metallicity of [ m / h ] @xmath27 , and the bottom line is the prediction for a metallicity of [ m / h ] @xmath28.[fig3 ] ] the host - galaxy age and metallicity vs. sn ia peak @xmath29-band magnitude are plotted in figure [ fig4 ] .
the peak magnitudes were derived from measurements of the light - curve shape parameter , @xmath30 , fitted using mlcs2k2 by the authors of @xcite(peak ) = @xmath31 + 0.182@xmath30@xmath32 + 5 log ( h@xmath33 / 65 km s@xmath3 mpc@xmath3 ) mag . ] . in figure [ fig4]a , the data show that the youngest populations tend to host the brightest sne ia , but with a wide spread . however , the eye has a tendency to gravitate toward large error bars , thereby placing an unwanted amount of attention to those points .
consequently , we have replotted the data in figures [ fig4]b and [ fig4]d with point sizes that are inversely proportional to their uncertainty . in this way
, the data with the smallest uncertainty in age will be represented by the largest points .
when points with the largest uncertainty are de - emphasized , the trend between age and luminosity is very clear , but it is nevertheless difficult to distinguish whether the effect is a smooth transition with age or the result of two distinct populations . = 72 km@xmath3 s@xmath3 mpc@xmath3 ) vs. ( a ) luminosity - weighted host - galaxy age and ( c ) metallicity .
panels ( b ) and ( d ) show the same data with the point size reflecting the average error along the abscissa .
point size is inversely proportional to the average error along the abscissa , with the exception of our young hosts in ( b ) where an upper limit is imposed on the point size .
the data in panel ( b ) show a clear trend between sn ia peak magnitude and host - galaxy age . the behavior could be evidence of either a smooth transition of sn magnitude with age or of two distinct populations of sne ia .
panel ( d ) shows a less convincing correlation likely arising from the degeneracy between age and metallicity .
[ fig4 ] ] @xcite found that only luminous sne ia occur in strongly star - forming hosts while e / s0 galaxies show a wide range of sn ia luminosities .
this is confirmed in figure [ magsfr ] , where we have plotted sn ia peak magnitude vs. host - galaxy specific star formation , i.e. , the sfr per stellar mass .
the sfrs were calculated from the h@xmath7 emission flux using the relation of @xcite , with the distance to each galaxy coming from the sn ia luminosities .
solid circles represent the host galaxies from the current sample of early - type galaxies , while open circles are from the sample studied by g05 .
we eliminated galaxies from g05 if they were in our current sample since the h@xmath7 flux from g05 was uncorrected for underlying absorption .
the points with arrows represent star formation upper limits in which h@xmath7 emission was buried within the noise .
this trend , combined with figure [ fig4]b , suggests that the age of the dominant population in e / s0 galaxies determines the resulting sn ia peak luminosity . a correlation between sn ia peak luminosity and sfr
has also been seen in the high - redshift snls data @xcite , but their type of search is biased against very low - luminosity events .
our `` young '' e / s0 galaxies correspond to their `` passive '' hosts , and the extension to very old populations ( with low specific sfr ) confirms that population age is the major factor that determines the sn ia peak luminosity . .
closed circles are the current sample of early - type hosts while open circles represent the high - sfr hosts of g05 .
the points marked by arrows indicate upper limits . on average ,
our specific sfr distribution is lower than that seen in the sample of high-@xmath34 passive " hosts of @xcite .
however , aside from the expected decrease of sfr over cosmological time , it should be noted that our data only sample half of the galactic light given our extraction radius ( @xmath6 ) , and the sfrs for the passive " galaxies of @xcite were randomly assigned a rate of @xmath00.005 m@xmath35 yr@xmath3.[magsfr ] ] the plots of host metallicity vs. sn ia peak luminosity ( figures [ fig4]c and [ fig4]d ) also show a mild correlation .
this may be due to the `` age / metallicity degeneracy '' shown in figure [ fig5 ] .
there we present measured galaxy age vs. metallicity for both the hosts and sdss field galaxies , showing that the galaxies are not evenly distributed in the diagram but instead concentrated to the lower - left half .
this is simply due to the evolution of the universe which started metal poor , meaning that there were few galaxies that are both old and metal rich and occupy the upper - right of the diagram .
thus , any correlation between age and a supernova property will result in some correlation with metallicity as well . here
, the relationship between host age and sn ia luminosity is so clear that we claim it represents a physical connection .
we attribute mild effect in the metallicity relation to the lack of galaxies in the lower - right quadrant of figure [ fig4]d , which comes from age correlation combined with the fact that there are no old galaxies having high metal abundance in our sample . ]
the distributions of age and metallicity for the two samples are also shown in figure [ fig5 ] , with the cumulative fraction plots shown in figure [ fig6 ] .
a kolmogorov - smirnov test reveals that there is a 63% chance that the host age distribution is drawn from the sdss field galaxy age distribution , and a 44% chance that the host metallicity distribution is drawn from the field galaxy metallicity distribution .
the results suggest that , given the size of the sn ia sample , the abundance and age of early - type galaxies that host sne ia are similar on average to normal early - type field galaxies . assuming this ,
the probability of a sn ia going off in a given early - type galaxy does not strongly depend on the age or metallicity of the galaxy . and 44@xmath36 probability that the sdss age and metallicity distributions , respectively , represent acceptable parent populations from which the host metallicities were drawn.[fig6 ] ] the relation correcting sn ia peak luminosity by the light - curve shape reduces the scatter in the low-@xmath34 hubble diagram to @xmath0 0.18 mag @xcite .
if this residual scatter is purely random , then the evolution of age and metallicity in the universe will not induce a bias in cosmological measurements with sne ia .
however , recent studies such as timmes , brown , & truran ( 2003 ; hereafter tbt03 ) and @xcite have predicted that sn calibration methods should be affected by a cosmic evolution in metallicity . in order to investigate this possible effect for sne ia hosted by early - type galaxies ,
we plot our measurements of age and metallicity against post - corrected sn ia magnitude residual from the best fit to the hubble diagram .
the hubble residual ( hr ) is defined as @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the distance modulus determined from the host - galaxy redshift to decrease uncertainty due to peculiar velocities . ] , and @xmath39 is the distance modulus determined via the mlcs2k2-corrected sn magnitude .
hr is defined in the conventional manner such that overluminous sne ia have a negative hubble residual . the primary component to the uncertainty in hr comes from @xmath40 .
the distance errors estimated from mlcs2k2 were found to be smaller than the scatter about the hubble diagram .
the authors of @xcite attributed this to an intrinsic scatter in sn ia magnitudes and accordingly imposed a constant additive correction to these distances . given that we are probing for systematic changes in this intrinsic scatter with age and metallicity ,
we have not applied this correction to @xmath40 .
the top - left panel of figure [ fig7 ] shows the hubble residual vs. host - galaxy metallicity along with a least - squares fit to the data ( solid line ) .
the data and the linear fit show a correlation between host metallicity and deviation from the hubble diagram such that supernovae in metal - rich galaxies are fainter than average and metal - poor galaxies host brighter than average events .
the dashed line is a representation of the tbt03 relation ( m@xmath41vs@xmath42 metallicity ) showing that , at least qualitatively , the observed trend is consistent with that by expected by tbt03 . with negligible significance .
[ fig7 ] ] to map the tbt03 prediction onto the plot , we converted the @xmath43ni yields from tbt03 into v - band peak magnitude via the models of @xcite as was done in gallagher et al .
( 2005 ) . to avoid an over - dependence on models
, we also converted ni masses to peak magnitudes through an empirically determined relation using ni mass estimated by @xcite and corresponding v - band luminosities given in @xcite .
mapping tbt03 onto figure [ fig7 ] using this conversion yields a qualitatively similar trend to both our data and the tbt03-hflich model .
the top - right panel shows the results of the significance analysis for our linear fit .
for each point ( [ m / h]@xmath44,hr@xmath44 ) , the hubble residual was replaced by a randomly selected hr from a gaussian distribution centered on the actual hr with a standard deviation equal to @xmath30hr .
the same was done for each metallicity using the corresponding [ m / h]@xmath44 and @xmath30[m / h]@xmath44 .
we performed 100,000 iterations , measured the best - fit slope ( @xmath10 ) to the new data each time , and generated the @xmath10 distribution for the test .
the results are seen in the top - right panel and show that a no - correlation result ( @xmath10 = 0 ) is ruled out at the 98% confidence level . a similar correlation between dust / extinction and hubble residual is not seen for our sample , thereby removing the possibility of this correlation being a secondary dust effect .
assuming that the least - squares fit to the top - left panel of figure [ fig7 ] adequately represents the trend of hr with metallicity , we would predict a 0.26 mag increase in intrinsic sn ia magnitude per unit decline in progenitor ( galaxy ) metallicity .
we have looked at several studies , two theoretical and one observational , that seek to characterize cosmic chemical evolution .
the theoretical studies by @xcite and @xcite predict an approximate 0.05 dex and 0.25 dex drop in metallicity per unit redshift , respectively .
the observational study conducted by @xcite find a preliminary result of 0.15 dex/@xmath34 . taking the average of these three studies ( 0.15 dex/@xmath34 ) for the true decline in metallicity with redshift would translate into a 0.039 mag decrease in intrinsic sn ia magnitude per unit redshift .
assuming an ideal sn ia data set out to @xmath45 , a @xmath22@xmath32 minimization of three parameters ( @xmath46@xmath47 , @xmath48 , and h@xmath33 ) applied to a set of model sne ia subject to this 4% systematic error would induce an approximate 9% systematic error on the measurement of the equation - of - state parameter @xmath2 .
@xcite showed that the scatter of sn magnitudes about the hubble diagram is lower in e / s0 galaxies ( @xmath0 0.13 mag ) than for sample as a whole ( @xmath0 0.18 mag ) .
our sample of e / s0 hosts show a scatter of approximately 0.14 mag . by applying a correction to sn magnitudes consistent with our least - squares fit , we reduce the scatter about the hubble diagram to approximately 0.11 mag , illustrating the potential for such a correction to significantly improve sn ia distance measurements .
the bottom - left panel of figure [ fig7 ] shows the age of the parent galaxy vs. the hubble residual of the sn ia . the plot does not reveal a significant trend of hr with host - galaxy age .
indeed , the probability of a zero - correlation result is only ruled out at the 56% confidence level , suggesting that sn ia magnitudes corrected for light - curve shape are likewise being corrected for any age bias .
it should be noted that two galaxies ( cgcg 016 - 058 and mcg+07 - 41 - 001 ) were removed from the age plot because their positions on their respective diagnostic grids required a difficult extrapolation that rendered their age estimates extremely uncertain . since the late 1970s
, observations have shown that sne ia are more prevalent in star - forming late - type galaxies than in early - type galaxies @xcite . this fact has been confirmed again and again with new studies showing that the sn ia rate per unit mass is significantly higher in blue / late - type galaxies than in red / early - type galaxies @xcite .
the current explanation for these observations is that there are prompt " and delayed " ( `` tardy '' ) sn ia explosions .
the prompt component is dependent on the rate of recent star formation , and the delayed component is dependent on the total number of low - mass stars .
the combination of these two components is believed to form the overall observed sn ia rate @xcite .
@xcite investigated the parameters shaping the overall sn ia rate by observing the relative presence of sne ia in high-@xmath34 host galaxies of differing mass and sfr .
our direct age measurement means that we can do a similar analysis at low redshifts by estimating the relative sn ia rate as a function of host - galaxy age .
figures [ fig8 ] and [ fig9 ] summarize the details of our analysis on the relative sn ia rate in elliptical host galaxies of various ages .
-band luminosity .
the left panel shows numbers of host galaxies , or sne , per age bin along with the expected number of stars per age bin derived using the sdss elliptical field galaxies .
the right panel gives the expected relative sn ia rate per age bin , showing a consistency with the dual - component " model .
[ fig8 ] ] ] the panel on the left of figure [ fig8 ] contains two unique histograms . the dotted - line histogram represents the number of host galaxies , or equivalently the number of sne ia , per age bin ( identical to the distribution in figure [ fig5 ] with decreased bin size ) .
the solid - line histogram is the expected number of stars per age bin .
each of the distributions has been normalized such that the bin encompassing 8 gyr contains exactly one element .
the number of stars is derived from the @xmath49-band sdss galaxy distribution , the @xmath49 band being a relatively accurate tracer of stellar mass . @xmath49-band
apparent magnitudes for the sdss sample were compiled from ned and the distances to the galaxies in the sample were calculated from the sdss redshift measurements , where care was taken to exclude those galaxies with @xmath50 km s@xmath3 .
the @xmath49-band absolute magnitudes , @xmath51 , were derived from the distances and apparent magnitudes .
finally , the number of stars per galaxy was approximated by the expression @xmath52}.\ ] ] the variable @xmath53 is the corresponding absolute magnitude of the sun in the @xmath49 band = 3.28 . ] .
the number of stars per age bin was then calculated by summing the stars in each galaxy in each age bin .
the relative sn ia rate per unit stellar mass is defined as the ratio of the number of sne per age bin to the expected number of stars per age bin .
the panel on the right of figure [ fig8 ] shows the expected sn ia rate per unit stellar mass as a function of age . the plot predicts a rate that is high for young galaxies , falls for intermediate - age galaxies , and increases and moderates for older populations .
this result is consistent with the `` dual - component model , '' given that the sn rate at low age could arise from a short delay time population of sne ia predicted to occur in galaxies with high sfr , and the rise in sn rate at late age could likely result from the predicted rise in sn rate with stellar mass @xcite .
however , we take the less general route and suggest the possibility that the rate at low population age is proportional to the rate of wd production following an initial burst of star formation . this function can be seen in figure [ fig9 ] .
similarly , the late - time sn rate can be traced by the cumulative number of wds present in the galaxy ( figure [ fig9 ] ) .
this value is determined for an age , @xmath54 , by integrating the wd production rate from time @xmath55 to @xmath56 .
these components of the sn ia rate are related to those of @xcite , and yet they specifically target the population of stars believed to be the progenitors of sn ia explosions .
an important caveat to this analysis is that we are only sampling the dominant stellar population within a given host galaxy .
it has been shown that a significant portion ( 1530% ) of elliptical and lenticular ( s0 ) galaxies show evidence of recent star formation @xcite , which has the potential to compromise our conclusion that sne ia exploding in old stellar populations possess longer delay times .
we have analyzed a sample of early - type galaxies that have hosted sne ia . comparing the data with stellar population synthesis models , we have measured the global age and metallicity of the sn ia elliptical host galaxies and a general sample of elliptical galaxies from the sdss .
our results indicate that there is likely a significant correlation between age or metallicity and sn ia absolute magnitude . given the mounting evidence of a sn ia rate dependence on specific sfr
, we find it most likely that the sn ia peak magnitudes are correlated with age , and the observed trend with metallicity is merely an artifact brought about by the evolutionary entanglement of age and metallicity .
we find the global distributions of age and metallicity to be similar to those of our sdss elliptical galaxy sample , suggesting that the presence , or absence , of a sn ia in an elliptical galaxy is not dependent on either age or metallicity .
moreover , we detect a trend between early - type host - galaxy metallicity and the residuals from the hubble diagram at the 98% confidence level .
this trend is consistent with the predictions of tbt03 and with a trend observed for late - type galaxies by @xcite ; it suggests that metal - rich galaxies produce underluminous sne ia , even after correcting for their light - curve shapes .
furthermore , we conclude that the failure to apply a metallicity correction to sn ia magnitudes could potentially introduce a 9% error into current and future measurements of @xmath48 .
finally , we find the predicted sn ia rate as a function of age for our sample of early - type galaxies , and determine it to be moderately consistent with the `` dual - component model '' of @xcite . also , we describe our preferred model governing the sn ia rate in which the prompt " component is proportional to the wd production rate and the delayed " component scales with the cumulative wd population . partial funding for this work came through nasa ltsa grant nag5 - 9364 .
supernova research at harvard university is supported by nsf grant ast06 - 06772 .
a.v.f.s supernova group at the university of california , berkeley is supported by nsf grant ast0607485 , as well as by the tabasgo foundation .
kait was made possible by generous donations from sun microsystems , inc .
, the hewlett - packard company , autoscope corporation , lick observatory , the nsf , the university of california , and the sylvia and jim katzman foundation .
we thank sumner starrfield and the arizona state university for granting us access to their computer network that proved invaluable for the completion of this work .
astier , p. , et al .
2006 , , 447 , 31 barris , b. j. , et al . 2004 , , 602 , 571 bennett , c. l. , et al . 2003 , , 148 , 1 blakeslee , j. p. , vazdekis , a. , & ajhar , e. a. 2001 , , 320 , 193 bressan , a. , chiosi , c. , & tantalo , r. 1996 , , 311 , 425 bruzual , g. , & charlot , s. 2003 , , 344 , 1000 buzzoni , a. 1995 , , 98 , 69 caldwell , n. , rose , j. a. , & concannon , k. d. 2003 , , 125 , 2891 cardelli , j. a. , clayton , g. c. , & mathis , j. s. 1989 , 345 , 245c cardiel , n. 2003 , , 409 , 511 cardiel , n. , gorgas , j. , cenarro , j. , & gonzalez , j. j. 1998 , , 127 , 597 cen , r. , & ostriker , j. p. 1999
, , 519 , l109 cen , r. , ostriker , j. p. , prochaska , j. x. , & wolfe , a. m. , 2003 , , 594 , 741 cenarro , a. j. , et al .
2001 , , 326 , 959 cennaro , a. j. , et al .
2007 , , 374 , 664 conley , a. , et al .
2008 , , in press delgado , r. m. g. , cervio , m. , martins , l. p. , leitherer , c. , & hauschildt , p. h. 2005 , , 357 , 945 della valle , m. , & livio , m. 1994 , , 423 , l31 eisenstein , d. j. , seo , h , sirko , e. , & spergel , d. n. 2007 , , 664 , 675 fabricant , d. , cheimets , p. , caldwell , n. , & geary , j. 1998 , , 110 , 79 faber , s. m. 1972 , , 20 , 361filippenko , a. v. 1982 , , 94 , 715 filippenko , a. v. 2005a , in the fate of the most massive stars , ed .
r. humphreys & k. stanek ( san francisco : asp ) , 33 filippenko , a. v. 2005b , in white dwarfs : cosmological and galactic probes , ed .
e. m. sion , s. vennes , & h. l. shipman ( dordrecht : springer ) , 97 filippenko , a. v. , li , w. , treffers , r. r. , & modjaz , m. 2001 , in small - telescope astronomy on global scales , ed .
chen , c. lemme , & b. paczyski ( san francisco : asp ) , 121 fioc , m. , & rocca - volmerange , b. 1997 , , 326 , 950 freedman , w. l. , et al . 2001 , , 553 , 47 frieman , j. a. , et al . 2007 , arxiv:0708.2749 frieman , j. a. , turner , m. , & huterer , d. 2008 , preprint ( arxiv:0803.0982 ) gallagher , j. s. , garnavich , p. m. , modjaz , m. , kirshner , r. p. , & challis , p. 2005a
, iau circ . , 8514 , 3 gallagher , j. s. , garnavich , p. m. , berlind , p. , challis , p. , jha , s. , & kirshner , r. p. 2005
, , 634 , 210 ganeshalingam , m. , et al .
2008 , in prep .
garnavich , p. m. , et al .
1998a , , 493 , 53 garnavich , p. m. , et al . 1998b , , 509 , 74 goldhaber , g. , et al .
2001 , , 558 , 359 gunn , j. e. , stryker , l. l. , & tinsley , b. m. 1981 , , 249 , 48 guy , j. 2007 , , 466 , 11 hamuy , m. , phillips , m. m. , suntzeff , n. b. , schommer , r. a. , maza , j. , & avilles , r. 1996 , , 112 , 2391 hamuy , m. , et al .
2000 , , 120 , 1479 hicken , m. , et al .
2007 , , 669 , l17 hflich , p. , wheeler , j. c. , & thielemann , f. k. 1998 , , 495 , 617 hflich , p. , gerardy , c. l. , fesen , r. a. , & sakai , s. 2002 , , 568 , 791 howell , a. d. , et al . 2006 , , 443 , 308 iben , i. , & tutukov a. v. 1984 , , 54 , 335 jarret , t. h. , chester , t. , cutri , r. , schneider , s. e. , & huchra , j. p. 2003
, , 125 , 525jha , s. 2002 , phd thesis , harvard university jha , s. , riess , a. g. , & kirshner , r. p. 2007
, , 659 , 122 jha , s. , et al . 1999 , , 125 , 73 jones , t. m. 1997 , ph.d .
thesis , university of north carolina , chapel hill kaviraj , s. , et al .
2007 , , 173 , 619 kennicutt , r. c. 1998 , , 36 , 189 kewley , l. , & kobulnicky , h. a. , 2007 , in island universes , astrophysics and space science proceedings ( new york : springer ) , 435 kirshner , r. p. 2002
, the extravagant universe : exploding stars , dark energy , and the accelerating cosmos ( princeton : princeton univ . press ) knop , r. a. , 2003 , , 598 , 102 krisciunas , k. , et al . 2007 , , 133 , 58 leaman , j. , li , w. , & filippenko , a. v. 2008 , in prep mannucci , f. , et al .
2005 , , 433 , 807 maraston , c. 1998 , , 300 , 872 miknaitis , g. , et al .
2007 , , 666 , 674 nomoto , k. 1982 , , 253 , 798 norgaard - neilsen , h. u. , et al .
1989 , , 339 , 523 oconnell , r. w. 1976 , , 206 , 370 oemler , a. , & tinsley , b. m. 1979 , , 84 , 985 osterbrock , d. e. , 1989 , astrophysics of gaseous nebulae and active galactic nuclei ( mill valley , ca : univ .
sci . ) peacock , j. a. , 2001 , , 410 , 169 peletier , r. f. , 1989 , phd thesis , university groningen perlmutter , s. , et al .
1997 , , 483 , 565 perlmutter , s. , et al .
1998 , , 391 , 51p perlmutter , s. , et al .
1999 , , 517 , 565 phillips , m. m. 1993 , , 413 , l105 phillips , m. m. , lira , p. , suntzeff , n. b. , schommer , r. a. , hamuy , m. , & maza , j. 1999 , , 118 , 1766 podsiadlowski , p. , et al .
2006 , submitted ( arxiv:0608324 ) renzini , a. 2006 , , 44 , 141 - 192 riess , a. g. , press , w. h. , & kirshner , r. p. 1996
, , 473 , 88 riess , a. g. , et al .
1998 , , 116 , 1009 riess , a. g. , et al .
2004 , , 607 , 665 riess , a. g. , et al .
2005 , , 627 , 579 riess , a. g. , et al .
2007 , , 659 , 98 salpeter , e. e. 1955 , , 121 , 161 sanchez - blazquez , p. , et al .
2006 , 371 , 703s sandage , a. , tammann , g. a. , saha , a. , reindl , b. , macchetto , f. d. , & panagia , n. 2006 , , 653 , 843 schmidt , b. p. , et al .
1998 , , 507 , 46 scannapieco , e. , & bildsten , l. 2005 , , 629 , l85soubiran , c. , katz , d. , & cayrel , r. 1998 , , 133 , 221 stritzinger , m. , mazalli , p. a. , sollerman , j. , & benetti , s. 2006 , , 460 , 793 sullivan , m. , et al . 2006 , , 648 , 868 taubenberger , s. , et al .
2008 , , 385 , 75 - 96 thomas , d. , maraston , c. , bender , r. , & mendes de oliveira , c. 2005 , , 621 , 673 timmes , f. x. , brown , e. f. , & truran , j. w. 2003 , , 590 , l83 ( tbt03 ) tinsley , b. m. , 1980 , , 5 , 287 tinsley , b. m. , & gunn , j. e. 1976 , , 203 , 52 tonry , j. l. , et al .
2003 , , 594 , 1 trager , s. c. , faber , s. m. , worthey , g. , & gonzales , j. j. 2000 , , 119 , 1645 umeda , h. , nomoto , k. , kobayashi , c. , hachisu , i. , & kato , m. 1999 , , 522 , l43 van den bergh , s. 1990 , , 102 , 1318 vazdekis , a. 1999 , , 513 , 224 vazdekis , a. , & arimoto n. 1999 , , 525 , 144 vazdekis , a. , peletier , r. f. , beckman , j. e. , & casuso , e. 1997 , , 111 , 203 vazdekis , a. , et al .
1996 , , 107 , 306 vazdekis , a. , cenarro , a. j. , gargas , j. , cardiel , n. , & peletier , r. f. 2003 , , 340 , 1317 vazdekis , a. , et al .
2008 , in prep .
vzquez , g. a. , & leitherer , c. 2005 , , 621 , 695 webbink , r. f. 1984 , , 277 , 355 whelan , j. , & iben , i. j. 1973 , , 186 , 1007 wolberg , g. 1994 , digital image warping , ieee computer society press wood - vasey , w. m. , et al .
2007 , , 666 , 694 wood - vasey , w. m. , et al .
2008 , submitted ( arxiv:0711.2068 ) worthey , g. 1994 , , 95 , 107 worthey , g. , faber , s. m. , & gonzalez , j. j. 1992 , , 398 , 69 worthey , g. , & ottaviani , d. l. 1997 , , 111 , 377 yi , s. k. , et al .
2005 , , 619 , l111 lcccccc ngc 4374 & 1991bg & -17.88 & e1 & 90 & 9.63 & 1 + ngc 4526 & 1994d & -18.98 & s0 & 110 & 10.78 & 1 + ngc 4493 & 1994 m & -19.09 & e & 40 & 4.03 & 1 + cgcg 016 - 058 & 1994 t & -18.67 & sa & -30 & 3.01 & 1 + ngc 2962 & 1995d & -19.42 & s0 + & 0 & 6.90 & 1 + ngc 5061 & 1996x & -19.21 & sa & 90 & 4.17 & 1 + ngc 5005 & 1996ai & -19.58 & sbc & -30 & 12.66 & 1 + ngc 5308 & 1996bk & -18.33 & s0- & 60 & 10.78 & 1 + ngc 5490 & 1997cn & -17.87 & e & 0 & 5.17 & 1 + ngc 5440 & 1998d & & sa & 40 & 6.19 & + ugc 11149 & 1998dx & -19.14 & sab & -40 & 6.75 & 1 + ngc 7131 & 1998co & & s0 & -35 & 4.45 & 1 + ngc 6411 & 1999da & -17.81 & e & 70 & 8.19 & 1 + ngc 2841 & 1999by & -17.95 & sab & 50 & 5.88 & 1 + ngc 6038 & 1999cc & -19.00 & sc & 105 & 8.19 & 1 + ngc 2986 & 1999gh & -18.43 & e2;hii & 10 & 6.90 & 1 + ugc 11198 & 2000 dm & -18.94 & sab & 45 & 7.06 & 2 + cgcg 189 - 024 & 2002 g & -19.347 & e & 10 & 4.16 & 2 + ugc 04322 & 2002he & -19.01 & e & 40 & 5.32 & 2 + cgcg 141 - 044 & 2001bf & -19.514 & & 100 & 5.04 & 2 + anon & 2002aw & -19.35 & sb ( f ) & 80 & 13.94 & 2 + ngc 4786 & 2002cf & -17.82 & e+pec & -20 & 6.47 & 2 + ngc 6702 & 2002cs & & e & 55 & 6.31 & + mcg+07 - 41 - 001 & 2002do & -18.48 & e1 & 0 & 20.85 & 2 + ngc 7761 & 2002ef & -19.30 & s0 & 90 & 4.61 & 2 + ngc 6986 & 2002el & -19.11 & sb0- & 5 & 5.89 & 2 + mcg-01 - 25 - 009 & 2003d & -18.31 & e1 & 10 & 5.18 & 2 + ic 0522 & 2003y & & s0 & -20 & 7.34 & + ugc 03787 & 2003ch & & e - s0 & 0 & 4.47 & + ngc 4059 & 2005bl & -17.62 & e & 40 & 4.61 & 3 + ngc 3608 & & & e2 & 80 & 6.19 & + ngc 4472 & & & e2/s0 & -20 & 12.80 & + ngc 4478 & & & e2 & 40 & 6.17 & + ngc 4489 & & & e & 110 & 4.61 & + ngc 4552 & & & e;hii & -30 & 6.31 & + ngc 4649 & & & e2 & 90 & 13.09 & + ngc 5638 & & & e1 & -20 & 8.04 & + ngc 5813 & & & e1 - 2 & -20 & 6.17 & + ngc 5846 & & & e0 - 1 & 50 & 11.35 & + ngc 6127 & & & e & 90 & 5.32 & + ngc 6703 & & & sa0- & 90 & 5.17 & + lccc anon & 7932.43 & 19.66 & 136.91 + cgcg 016 - 058 & 10411.31 & 17.79 & 147.99 + cgcg 141 - 044 & 4665.13 & 23.01 & 109.73 + cgcg 189 - 024 & 10113.14 & 21.01 & 188.70 + ic 0522 & 5092.26 & 19.05 & 170.76 + mcg+07 - 41 - 001 & 4584.86 & 68.68 & 344.72 + mcg-01 - 25 - 009 & 6623.73 & 21.58 & 251.97 + ngc 2841 & 633.49 & 25.43 & 244.72 + ngc 2962 & 1967.99 & 19.01 & 186.61 + ngc 2986 & 2310.81 & 33.56 & 283.67 + ngc 3608 & 1237.80 & 21.24 & 209.54 + ngc 4059 & 7195.99 & 33.21 & 210.88 + ngc 4374 & 1020.48 & 30.57 & 316.56
+ ngc 4472 & 957.20 & 30.95 & 309.86 + ngc 4478 & 1352.18 & 17.67 & 183.09 + ngc 4489 & 948.10 & 11.75 & 106.89 + ngc 4493 & 6957.26 & 20.98 & 214.39 + ngc 4526 & 604.65 & 24.90 & 235.75 + ngc 4552 & 316.64 & 27.18 & 282.82 + ngc 4649 & 1087.03 & 37.32 & 344.45 + ngc 4786 & 4611.97 & 33.49 & 288.86 + ngc 5005 & 932.64 & 23.29 & 207.73 + ngc 5061 & 2059.50 & 22.15 & 218.96 + ngc 5308 & 2014.72 & 22.08 & 241.36 + ngc 5440 & 3697.03 & 27.35 & 238.53 + ngc 5490 & 4965.75 & 37.73 & 338.21 + ngc 5638 & 1640.05 & 20.15 & 172.96 + ngc 5813 & 1948.27 & 28.57 & 248.58 + ngc 5846 & 1692.00 & 27.71 & 238.42 + ngc 6038 & 9399.72 & 32.83 & 183.91 + ngc 6127 &
4715.52 & 29.99 & 264.50 + ngc 6411 & 3726.29 & 23.52 & 186.15 + ngc 6702 & 4721.40 & 32.71 & 209.44 + ngc 6703 & 2384.69 & 20.62 & 199.69 + ngc 6986 & 8534.95 & 25.52 & 267.16 + ngc 7131 & 5409.40 & 36.77 & 185.25 + ngc 7761 & 7192.42 & 19.90 & 211.39 + ugc 11149 & 16137.64 & 92.35 & 146.10 + ugc 11198 & 4518.02 & 19.91 & 145.28 + ugc 03787 & 8612.81 & 57.54 & 140.66 + ugc 04322 & 7376.56 & 23.98 & 248.08 + lccc h@xmath10 & 4847.8754876.625 & 4827.8754847.875 , 4876.6254891.625 & h , ( mg ) , ( cr ) , c + fe5270 & 5245.6505285.650 & 5233.1505248.150 , 5285.6505318.150 & fe , c , ( mg ) , ca + fe4383 & 4369.1254420.375 & 4359.1254370.375 , 4442.8754455.375 & fe , c , ( si ) + lcccccccccccc anon & 0.081 & 0.523 & 0.323 & 1.338 & 0.194 & 0.644 & 0.158 & 0.405 & 0.350 & 1.338 & 0.150 & 0.644 + cgcg
016 - 058 & -0.374 & 0.278 & 0.266 & 23.454 & 13.895 & 17.898 & -0.532 & 0.271 & 0.246 & 26.083 & 15.953 & 22.769 + cgcg 141 - 044 & 0.472 & 0.244 & 0.318 & 1.273 & 0.101 & 0.101 & 0.121 & 0.118 & 0.129 & 1.256 & 0.078 & 0.061 + cgcg 189 - 024 & 0.187 & 0.295 & 0.270 & 2.611 & 0.700 & 0.694 & 0.031 & 0.183 & 0.190 & 2.891 & 0.829 & 2.027 + ic 0522 & -0.072 & 0.112 & 0.110 & 8.200 & 1.858 & 2.849 & 0.157 & 0.089 & 0.082 & 6.583 & 2.828 & 3.035 + mcg+07 - 41 - 001 & -0.185 & 0.058 & 0.072 & 32.651 & 5.932 & 6.483 & -0.432 & 0.043 & 0.132 & 36.121 & 2.281 & 1.886 + mcg-01 - 25 - 009 & -0.174 & 0.116 & 0.107 & 15.698 & 5.170 & 6.809 & 0.041 & 0.100 & 0.081 & 11.856 & 3.307 & 4.690 + ngc 2841 & 0.037 & 0.069 & 0.067 & 12.558 & 1.739 & 2.606 & 0.036 & 0.048 & 0.050 & 12.578 & 1.837 & 3.073 + ngc 2962 & 0.261 & 0.093 & 0.092 & 5.180 & 1.993 & 2.185 & 0.385 & 0.066 & 0.106 & 4.210 & 1.572 & 1.818 + ngc 2986 & 0.052 & 0.086 & 0.076 & 9.652 & 2.003 & 2.108 & 0.014 & 0.058 & 0.059 & 9.667 & 1.988 & 1.998 + ngc 3608 & -0.013 & 0.067 & 0.069 & 11.591 & 2.072 & 2.745 & 0.011 & 0.050 & 0.052 & 10.448 & 1.235 & 3.472 + ngc 4059 & -0.350 & 0.158 & 0.151 & 7.567 & 1.664 & 3.247 & 0.090 & 0.108 & 0.109 & 5.514 & 2.517 & 2.934 + ngc 4374 & 0.102 & 0.055 & 0.052 & 8.667 & 1.195 & 1.389 & 0.081 & 0.045 & 0.048 & 8.851 & 1.369 &
1.700 + ngc 4472 & 0.179 & 0.044 & 0.045 & 8.752 & 1.273 & 1.466 & 0.154 & 0.041 & 0.038 & 9.360 & 1.325 & 1.346 + ngc 4478 & -0.088 & 0.079 & 0.077 & 9.027 & 1.641 & 1.964 & -0.031 & 0.051 & 0.057 & 8.838 & 1.882 & 1.812 + ngc 4489 & 0.428 & 0.186 & 0.200 & 2.539 & 0.719 & 0.753 & 0.167 & 0.099 & 0.104 & 3.350 & 0.808 & 2.099 + ngc 4493 & 0.014 & 0.221 & 0.224 & 7.165 & 3.964 & 5.585 & -0.077 & 0.161 & 0.160 & 7.561 & 4.088 & 6.693 + ngc 4526 & 0.400 & 0.061 & 0.062 & 1.669 & 0.215 & 0.197 & 0.488 & 0.036 & 0.031 & 1.122 & 0.279 & 0.312 + ngc 4552 & -0.040 & 0.024 & 0.063 & 13.481 & 1.762 & 2.532 & 0.056 & 0.047 & 0.041 & 11.834 & 1.136 & 2.511 + ngc 4649 & -0.076 & 0.051 & 0.055 & 21.565 & 2.507 & 2.533 & 0.089 & 0.047 & 0.048 & 16.931 & 2.295 & 2.219 + ngc 4786 & 0.000 & 0.099 & 0.097 & 7.100 & 1.684 & 1.740 & 0.092 & 0.077 & 0.067 & 6.215 & 2.690 & 2.219 + ngc 5005 & & & & & & & & & & & & + ngc 5061 & 0.359 & 0.035 & 0.056 & 1.923 & 0.185 & 0.054 & 0.427 & 0.026 & 0.026 & 1.429 & 0.271 &
0.202 + ngc 5308 & -0.177 & 0.063 & 0.063 & 11.087 & 1.923 & 1.809 & 0.025 & 0.054 & 0.053 & 9.578 & 1.758 & 1.934 + ngc 5440 & 0.057 & 0.107 & 0.102 & 7.415 & 1.957 & 2.536 & 0.248 & 0.076 & 0.080 & 5.453 & 2.151 & 2.645 + ngc 5490 & 0.012 & 0.124 & 0.120 & 9.840 & 2.867 & 3.296 & 0.155 & 0.099 & 0.097 & 8.113 & 3.096 & 3.338 + ngc 5638 & -0.105 & 0.079 & 0.081 & 13.743 & 3.146 & 3.677 & 0.175 & 0.054 & 0.060 & 9.903 & 2.322 & 2.165 + ngc 5813 & 0.027 & 0.086 & 0.074 & 8.692 & 1.891 & 1.996 & 0.369 & 0.068 & 0.050 & 4.921 & 0.737 & 2.135 + ngc 5846 & -0.147 & 0.099 & 0.047 & 14.421 & 2.525 & 4.724 & -0.038 & 0.045 & 0.053 & 13.536 & 2.046 & 3.490 + ngc 6038 & -0.302 & 0.194 & 0.191 & 12.286 & 5.161 & 10.610 & -0.482 & 0.186 & 0.167 & 13.933 & 6.198 & 8.528 + ngc 6127 & -0.178 & 0.121 & 0.066 & 14.917 & 3.711 & 6.099 & -0.122 & 0.097 & 0.050 & 13.975 & 3.287 & 5.596 + ngc 6411 & -0.108 & 0.092 & 0.091 & 14.833 & 3.788 & 5.096 & -0.442 & 0.067 & 0.067 & 19.433 & 4.681 & 5.155 + ngc 6702 & 0.442 & 0.121 & 0.126 & 1.965 & 0.379 & 0.530 & 0.157 & 0.082 & 0.068 & 2.845 & 0.478 &
0.548 + ngc 6703 & 0.078 & 0.069 & 0.063 & 8.186 & 1.451 & 1.695 & 0.213 & 0.052 & 0.052 & 6.829 & 1.805 & 1.727 + ngc 6986 & 0.602 & 0.264 & 0.320 & 1.289 & 0.111 & 0.067 & 0.744 & 0.225 & 0.122 & 1.020 & 2.512 & 0.179 + ngc 7131 & -0.281 & 0.134 & 0.130 & 23.653 & 7.315 & 8.609 & -0.327 & 0.112 & 0.107 & 24.228 & 7.778 & 9.103 + ngc 7761 & 0.164 & 0.186 & 0.192 & 2.907 & 0.613 & 0.803 & 0.268 & 0.128 & 0.085 & 2.670 & 0.652 & 0.864 + ugc 11149 & & & & & & & -0.480 & 0.251 & 0.245 & 9.768 & 5.339 & 12.562 + ugc 11198 & -0.238 & 0.108 & 0.112 & 18.449 & 6.004 & 5.519 & -0.204 & 0.085 & 0.083 & 17.861 & 5.797 & 5.749 + ugc 03787 & 0.446 & 0.291 & 0.419 & 1.284 & 0.076 & 0.082 & 0.422 & 0.186 & 1.729 & 1.172 & 0.235 & 0.190 + ugc 04322 & -0.155 & 0.155 & 0.137 & 11.844 & 3.818 & 6.540 & -0.116 & 0.108 & 0.102 & 11.527 & 3.927 & 6.212 + | we have obtained optical spectra of 29 early - type ( e / s0 ) galaxies that hosted type ia supernovae ( sne ia ) .
we have measured absorption - line strengths and compared them to a grid of models to extract the relations between the supernova properties and the luminosity - weighted age / composition of the host galaxies .
such a direct measurement is a marked improvement over existing analyses which tend to rely on general correlations between the properties of stellar populations and morphology .
our galaxy sample ranges over a factor of ten in iron abundance and shows both old and young dominant population ages .
the same analysis was applied to a large number of early - type field galaxies selected from the sdss spectroscopic survey .
we find no difference in the age and abundance distributions between the field galaxies and the sn ia host galaxies .
we do find a strong correlation suggesting that sne ia in galaxies whose populations have a characteristic age greater than 5 gyr are @xmath0 1 mag fainter at @xmath1 than those found in galaxies with younger populations .
however , the data can not discriminate between a smooth relation connecting age and supernova luminosity or two populations of sn ia progenitors .
we find that sn ia distance residuals in the hubble diagram are correlated with host - galaxy metal abundance , consistent with the predictions of @xcite .
the data show that high iron abundance galaxies host less - luminous supernovae .
we thus conclude that the time since progenitor formation primarily determines the radioactive ni production while progenitor metal abundance has a weaker influence on peak luminosity , but one not fully corrected by light - curve shape and color fitters .
this result , particularly the secondary dependence on metallicity , has significant implications for the determination of the equation - of - state parameter , @xmath2 , and could impact planning for future dark - energy missions such as jdem . assuming no selection effects in discovering sne ia in local early - type galaxies
, we find a higher specific sn ia rate in e / s0 galaxies with ages below 3 gyr than in older hosts .
the higher rate and brighter luminosities seen in the youngest e / s0 hosts may be a result of recent star formation and represents a tail of the prompt " sn ia progenitors . |
the _ egret _ experiment aboard the _ compton gamma ray observatory _ has detected more than 50 blazars extending out to redshifts greater than 2 ( thompson , _ et al . _
it is expected that @xmath0-rays from blazars with energies above the threshold energy for electron - positron pair production through interactions with low energy intergalactic photons will be annihilated , cutting off the high energy end of blazar spectra .
such absorption is strongly dependent on the redshift of the source ( stecker , de jager & salamon 1992 ) .
stecker & de jager ( 1997 ) have calculated the absorption of extragalactic @xmath0-rays above 0.3 tev at redshifts up to 0.54 and presented a comparison with the spectral data for the low redshift blazar mrk 421 .
the study of blazar spectra at energies below 0.3 tev is a more complex and physically interesting subject .
in addition to intergalactic absorption , one must be able to distinguish and to separate out the effects of intrinsic absorption and natural cutoff energies in blazar emission spectra .
initial estimates of intergalactic absorption of 10 to 300 gev @xmath0-rays in blazar spectra at higher redshifts have been given by stecker ( 1996 ) , stecker & de jager ( 1996 ) and madau & phinney ( 1996 ) .
however , in order to calculate such high - redshift absorption properly , it is necessary to determine the spectral distribution of the intergalactic low energy photon background radiation as a function of redshift as realistically as possible .
this calculation , in turn , requires observationally based information on the evolution of the spectral energy distributions ( seds ) of ir through uv starlight from galaxies , particularly at high redshifts .
conversely , observations of high - energy cutoffs in the @xmath0-ray spectra of blazars as a function of redshift , which may enable one to separate out intergalactic absorption from redshift - independent cutoff effects , could add to our knowledge of galaxy formation and early galaxy evolution .
in this regard , it should be noted that the study of blazar spectra in the 10 to 300 gev range is one of the primary goals of a next generation space - based @xmath0-ray telescope , _ glast ( gamma - ray large area space telescope ) _ ( bloom 1996 ) as well as a number of ground - based @xmath0-ray telescopes currently under construction .
our main goal is to calculate the opacity of intergalactic space to high energy @xmath0-rays as a function of redshift .
this depends upon the number density of soft target photons ( ir to uv ) as a function of redshift , whose production is dominated by stellar emission . to evaluate the sed of the ir - uv intergalactic radiation field we must integrate the total stellar emissivity over time
this requires an estimate of the dependence of stellar emissivity on redshift .
previous work has either assumed that all of the background was in place at high redshifts , corresponding to a burst of star formation at the initial redshift ( stecker 1996 ; stecker & de jager 1996 ; macminn and primack 1996 ) or strong evolution ( similar to a burst ) , or no evolution ( madau and phinney 1996 ) . in this paper
, we use a more realistic model which is consistent with recent observational data .
pei & fall ( 1995 ) have devised a method for calculating stellar emissivity which bypasses the uncertainties associated with estimates of poorly defined luminosity distributions of evolving galaxies .
the core idea of their approach is to relate the star formation rate directly to the evolution of the neutral gas density in damped ly@xmath2 systems , and then to use stellar population synthesis models to estimate the mean co - moving stellar emissivity @xmath3 ( erg / s-@xmath4-hz ) of the universe as a function of frequency @xmath5 and redshift @xmath6 ( fall , charlot & pei 1996 ) .
our calculation of stellar emissivity closely follows this elegant analysis , with minor modifications as described below .
damped ly@xmath2 systems are high - redshift clouds of gas whose neutral hydrogen surface density is large enough ( @xmath7 @xmath8 ) to generate saturated ly@xmath2 absorption lines in the spectra of background quasars that happen to lie along and behind common lines of sight to these clouds .
these gas systems are believed to be either precursors to galaxies or young galaxies themselves , since their neutral hydrogen ( hi ) surface densities are comparable to those of spiral galaxies today , and their co - moving number densities are consistent with those of present - day galaxies ( wolfe 1986 ; see also peebles 1993 ) .
it is in these systems that initial star formation presumably took place , so there is a relationship between the mass content of stars and of gas in these clouds ; if there is no infall or outflow of gas in these systems , the systems are `` closed '' , so that the formation of stars must be accompanied by a reduction in the neutral gas content .
such a variation in the hi surface densities of ly@xmath2 systems with redshift is seen , and is used by pei & fall ( 1995 ) to estimate the mean cosmological rate of star formation back to redshifts as large as @xmath9 .
pei & fall ( 1995 ) have estimated the neutral ( hi plus hei ) co - moving gas density @xmath10 in damped ly@xmath2 systems from observations of the redshift evolution of these systems by lanzetta , wolfe , & turnshek ( 1995 ) .
( here @xmath11 is the critical mass density of the universe .
the deceleration parameter is assumed throughout to be @xmath12 , with cosmological constant @xmath13 . )
lanzetta , _ et al .
_ have observed that while the number density of damped ly@xmath2 systems appears to be relatively constant over redshift , the fraction of higher density absorption systems within this class of objects decreases steadily with decreasing redshift .
they attribute this to a reduction in gas density with time , roughly of the form @xmath14 , where @xmath15 is the current gas density in galaxies .
pei & fall ( 1995 ) have taken account of self - biasing effects to obtain a corrected value of @xmath16 ; we have reproduced their calculations to obtain @xmath16 under the assumptions that the asymptotic , high redshift value of the neutral gas mass density is @xmath17 , where @xmath18 km / s - mpc ) . in a `` closed galaxy '' model , the change in co - moving stellar mass density @xmath19 , since the gas mass density @xmath10 is being converted into stars .
this determines the star formation rate and consequent stellar emissivity ( pei & fall 1995 ) . to determine the mean stellar emissivity from the star formation rate
, an initial mass function ( imf ) @xmath20 must be assumed for the distribution of stellar masses @xmath21 in a freshly synthesized stellar population . to further specify the luminosities of these stars as a function of mass @xmath21 and age @xmath22 , fall , charlot , & pei ( 1996 ) use the bruzual - charlot ( bc ) population synthesis models for the spectral evolution of stellar populations ( bruzual & charlot 1993 , charlot & bruzual 1991 ) . in these population synthesis models ,
the specific luminosity @xmath23 ( erg / s - hz ) , of a star of mass @xmath21 and age @xmath22 is integrated over a specified imf to obtain a total specific luminosity @xmath24 per unit mass ( erg / s - hz - g ) for an entire population , in which all stellar members are produced simultaneously ( @xmath25 ) .
following fall , charlot , and pei ( 1996 ) , we have used in our calculations the bc model corresponding to a salpeter imf , @xmath26 , where @xmath27 .
the mean co - moving emissivity @xmath28 is then obtained by convolving over time @xmath29 the specific luminosity @xmath30 with the mean co - moving mass rate of star formation , @xmath31 : @xmath32 note that the star mass formation rate @xmath33 that appears in this equation is not the same as @xmath34 , the change in total stellar mass density . this is because @xmath35 is the rate at which mass is _ permanently _ being converted into stars ; since some stellar mass is continuously being returned to the interstellar medium ( ism ) , the _ instantaneous _ mass rate of star formation @xmath36 is larger than @xmath35 , the two being related by @xmath37 where @xmath38 , provided by the bc models , is the fraction of the initial mass of a generation of stars formed at @xmath25 that has been returned to the ism . the bc models specific luminosities @xmath24 are calculated assuming that the metallicity content _ z _ during star formation is fixed at our current solar metallicity value ( @xmath39 ) .
however , the metallicity content of the universe is not static , but evolves with redshift as early populations of stars return freshly synthesized metals to the interstellar medium during their various phases of mass loss .
for example , in a survey of 1/3 of the known damped lyman - alpha absorbers , pettini _
( 1994 ) found that the typical metallicity is 0.1 that of the present solar value at a redshift of @xmath40 .
since the specific luminosity of a star of a given mass is also a function of its metallicity content ( lower metallicities give bluer spectra ) , the metallicity of a stellar population must be taken into account when integrating the mean emissivity over redshift .
the effect of metallicity content in stellar population models has been examined by worthey ( 1994 ) . using the imf @xmath41 with @xmath42
, worthey has calculated the mass - to - light ratios @xmath43 as a function of population age @xmath22 and metallicity @xmath44 , for the color bands @xmath45 through @xmath21 .
we have plotted his @xmath43 values for the @xmath45 and @xmath46 bands in figures 1 and 2 respectively .
one can see that for a fixed metallicity , the logarithm of the luminosity decreases approximately linearly with the logarithm of population age , and that for a fixed age the @xmath45 and @xmath46 luminosities decrease as the metallicity increases .
we have made a linear fit to each fixed - metallicity @xmath47 computed data set , obtaining a metallicity correction factor factor @xmath48 , where @xmath49 designates the color band .
> from the parallel linear fits made to the computed data for each @xmath50 value , it is seen that a common correction factor , @xmath51 , applied to each @xmath52 data set will bring these data into rough agreement with the @xmath53 values of @xmath47 .
these correction factors are plotted in the inset figures , whose abscissa is @xmath54 and whose ordinate is the correction factor .
our fit to worthey s computed data in figure 1 gives a continuous correction factor @xmath55 for @xmath56 @xmath57 m , the center of the @xmath45 band .
similar fits to the @xmath46 band data ( figure 2 ) and to the @xmath58 , @xmath59 , and @xmath60 band data ( not shown ) result in the relation @xmath61\approx\left[0.33-\frac{0.30}{\lambda } \right]\log\left(\frac{z}{z_{\odot}}\right ) + \left[0.066-\frac{0.063}{\lambda}\right]\left [ \log\left(\frac{z}{z_{\odot}}\right)\right]^{2},\ ] ] for @xmath62 m @xmath63 m .
outside of this wavelength region we take @xmath64 and @xmath65 .
note that increased metallicity gives a redder population spectrum ( bertelli _ et al . _
1994 ) .
limitations to this correction factor include the fact that worthey s calculations only apply to stars with ages greater than @xmath66 gyr , and that the upper mass limit of his imf ( @xmath67 ) is much lower than that of the bc model which we employ ( @xmath68 ) .
additional uncertainty exists below 0.3 @xmath57 m since worthey s calculations extend only to the @xmath45 band .
we have chosen to assume a constant enhancement factor below @xmath69 m .
for all of the above reasons , our enhancement factor @xmath51 is really a conservative lower limit to the corrections to the bc models in the ultraviolet .
population synthesis models in which varying metallicity is included do exist ( bertelli _ et al . _
1994 ) , and efforts to reconcile differences in computed spectra generated by these various models have been made ( charlot , worthey , and bressan , 1996 ) .
the emissivity @xmath70 given in eq .
[ emissivity.eq ] assumes that all stellar emission escapes from the gas system which contains the stars .
however , some absorption of stellar radiation occurs both by dust and gas within the larger damped ly@xmath2 systems . above the lyman limit , this absorption is dominated by dust , while below the lyman limit , absorption by neutral hydrogen and singly - ionized helium dominates .
defining the mean transmission fractions , averaged over the optical depths of damped ly@xmath2 systems , by @xmath71 and @xmath72 , the final expression for the effective stellar emissivity is @xmath73.\ ] ] the distribution of optical depths @xmath74 of ly@xmath2 clouds due to dust is can be adequately represented by @xmath75 , where @xmath76 , @xmath77 being a characteristic ( redshift dependent ) cloud dust opacity , and @xmath78 ( fall _ et al . _ 1996 ) . under the assumption that both dust and stars are uniformly distributed throughout each ly@xmath2 cloud ,
the fraction of radiation @xmath79 produced by stars in a given cloud of optical depth @xmath74 that escapes dust absorption is given by @xmath80,\ ] ] where @xmath81 , and @xmath82 is the average albedo of dust , taken to be the same value as in our galaxy ( @xmath83 to 0.6 ; whittet 1992 ) .
( we have calculated eq .
[ twostream.eq ] using the 2-stream approximation [ chandrasekhar 1950 ] ) .
we note that the dust opacity @xmath74 in eq.[twostream.eq ] is assumed to be proportional to the hi surface column density @xmath84 and metallicity @xmath44 , @xmath85 where @xmath86 is the normalized galactic interstellar dust extinction curve ( savage and mathis 1979 ) . integrating eq.[twostream.eq ] over the ly@xmath2 opacity distribution function @xmath87 of pei & fall ( 1995 ) , we obtain @xmath71 , and find it to have a minor effect on the emissivity , @xmath71 being typically of order unity . below the lyman limit ( @xmath88 m ) , the opacity is dominated by neutral gas absorption : @xmath89 , where @xmath90 and @xmath91 are the hi and hei photoionization cross sections ( osterbrock 1989 ) . with the @xmath92 and @xmath93 distributions of the ly@xmath2 systems being related to the dust opacity distribution @xmath94 through eq.[c ]
, the distribution for @xmath95 can be obtained . integrating eq.[twostream.eq ] ( now with @xmath96 ) , weighted with the @xmath95 distribution , gives @xmath72 .
figure 3 shows the calculated stellar emissivity as a function of redshift at 0.28 @xmath57 m , 0.44 @xmath57 m , and 1.00 @xmath57 m , both with and without the metallicity correction factor @xmath97 .
we have also plotted the observations of the cosmic emissivity by the canada - french redshift survey ( lilly , le fevre , hammer , & crampton 1996 ) at these rest - frame wavelengths for comparison . with a lower mass cutoff of @xmath98 in the imf
, we obtain emissivities which are roughly a factor of 2 higher than those obtained by lilly , _
( 1996 ) . to bring our emissivities down to the observed values
requires that we reduce the lower mass limit in the imf to @xmath99 , which puts a fraction ( 0.45 ) of the mass into effectively nonluminous compact objects .
we note that a similar reduction was achieved by fall , _ et al . _ ( 1996 ) by modifying the power law index in the imf ; a higher index results in a lower emissivity ( pei 1996 , personal communication ) .
overall , our emissivities , both with and without the metallicity corrections , are in reasonable agreement with the data at lower redshifts ( lilly , _
et al . _
although the differences for @xmath70 between the no - metallcity and metallicity cases for @xmath100 are not great , _ they become substantial at larger redshifts for both optical and uv wavelengths_. this has notable effects on the opacity of the radiation background to high energy @xmath0-rays , as will be seen in section 4 .
we note that our dotted - line curves in figure 3 ( no metallicity correction ) are essentially a reproduction of the emissivities calculated by fall , _ et al . _ ( 1996 ) . in all cases as shown in figure 3 , the stellar emissivity in the universe peaks at @xmath101 , dropping off at both lower and higher redshifts .
indeed , madau , _ et al .
_ ( 1996 ) have used observational data from the hubble deep field to show that metal production has a similar redshift distribution , such production being a direct measure of the star formation rate .
( see also the review by madau ( 1996 ) . )
the co - moving radiation energy density @xmath102 ( erg/@xmath4-hz ) is the time integral of the co - moving emissivity @xmath3 , @xmath103 where @xmath104 and @xmath105 is the redshift corresponding to initial galaxy formation .
the extinction term @xmath106 accounts for the absorption of ionizing photons by the clumpy intergalactic medium ( igm ) that lies between the source and observer ; although the igm is effectively transparent to non - ionizing photons , the absorption of photons by hi , hei and heii can be considerable ( madau 1995 ) .
the presence of damped ly@xmath2 and lyman - limit systems ( lanzetta , _ et al . _
1995 ) and the lyman - alpha forest , coupled with the absence of a hi gunn - peterson effect ( gunn & peterson 1965 ; steidel & sargent 1987 ) indicates that essentially all of the hi , hei , and heii exists within intergalactic clouds whose measured hi column densities range from approximately @xmath107 to @xmath108 @xmath8 .
the effective optical depth @xmath109 between a source at redshift @xmath110 and an observer at redshift @xmath6 owing to poisson - distributed intervening lyman - alpha clouds is given by ( paresce , mckee , & bowyer 1980 ) @xmath111 where @xmath112 $ ] , @xmath113 , and @xmath114 is the distribution function of clouds in redshift @xmath6 and column density @xmath92 .
as pointed out by madau & shull ( 1996 ) , when @xmath115 , @xmath109 is just the mean optical depth of the clouds ; when @xmath116 , @xmath109 becomes the number of optically thick clouds between the source and observer , so that the poisson probability of encountering no thick clouds is @xmath106 , as required . for the distribution function of lyman - alpha clouds we use the parameterization of madau ( 1995 )
( see also miralda - escud & ostriker , 1990 , model a2 ) : @xmath117 using eqs .
[ e ] and [ f ] and the stellar emissivity @xmath3 in eq.[b ] , we obtain the background energy density @xmath102 , shown in figures 4 and 5 , calculated with and without the metallicity correction , @xmath51 , respectively .
these also include the contribution to the uv background from qsos ( madau 1992 ) , which are believed to dominate the diffuse background radiation below the lyman limit and to be responsible for the early ( @xmath118 ; see schneider , schmidt , & gunn 1991 ) reionization of the igm .
although it is possible that uv emission from qsos alone may be able to account for the nearly complete reionization of the igm ( meiksin & madau 1993 ; fall & pei 1993 ; madau & meiksin 1994 ) , it has been argued that additional sources of of ionizing radiation are required ( miralda - escud & ostriker 1990 ) , these perhaps being young galaxies which leak a fraction ( up to @xmath119 ) of their ionizing radiation through hii `` chimneys '' ( dove & shull 1994 ; madau & shull 1996 ) .
we have therefore assumed in our calculations that 15% of the stellar emission escapes from the galaxies ( protogalaxies ) through these chimneys , unattentuated by dust or gas .
( we note , however , that recent observations of four starburst galaxies by the hopkins uv telescope ( leitherer _ et al .
_ 1995 ) indicate that less than 3% of lyman continuum photons escape from these sources . )
figures 4 and 5 indicate that in our calculation the @xmath120 m background is indeed dominated by qsos , so that the actual value of the escape fraction we choose is not too significant .
the intergalactic energy densities given in figures 4 and 5 are quite consistent with the present upper limits in the uv ( martin & bowyer 1989 ; mattila 1990 ; bowyer 1991 ; vogel , weymann , rauch & hamilton 1995 ) .
it should be noted that our results as shown in figures 4 and 5 give emissivities _ from starlight only _ and do not include dust emissivities in the mid - infrared and far - infrared .
with the co - moving energy density @xmath102 evaluated , the optical depth for @xmath0-rays owing to electron - positron pair production interactions with photons of the stellar radiation background can be determined from the expression ( stecker , _ et al . _
1992 ) @xmath121\sigma_{\gamma\gamma}[s=2e_{0}h\nu x(1+z)^2],\ ] ] where @xmath122 is the observed @xmath0-ray energy , @xmath123 is the redshift of the @xmath0-ray source , @xmath124 , @xmath125 being the angle between the @xmath0-ray and the soft background photon , @xmath126 is planck s constant , and the pair production cross section @xmath127 is zero for center - of - mass energy @xmath128 , @xmath129 being the electron mass . above this threshold , @xmath130,\ ] ] where @xmath131
. figures 6 and 7 show the opacity @xmath132 for the energy range 10 to 500 gev , calculated with and without the metallicity correction .
extinction of @xmath0-rays is negligible below 10 gev . above 500 gev ,
interactions with photons with wavelengths of tens of @xmath57 m become important , so that one must include interactions from infrared photons generated by dust reradiation ( stecker & de jager 1997 ) , which we have neglected here . for 300 gev @xmath0-rays , at redshifts below 0.5 , our opacities agree with the with the opacities obtained by stecker & de jager ( 1997 ) .
our calculated opacity , even with the metallicity correction , is probably somewhat low in the 10 to 30 gev energy range , because we have underestimated the value of @xmath51 in the uv ( see previous discussion ) .
note that these calculated opacities are _ independent _ of the value chosen for @xmath133 , as seen in eqs . 4 , 7 , and 10 .
the emissivity @xmath70 in eq .
4 scales as @xmath134 , since neither @xmath30 , @xmath51 nor @xmath135 depends on @xmath133 , while @xmath136 scales as @xmath134 . eq .
7 shows then that @xmath137 scales as @xmath133 , and in eq .
10 this @xmath133 factor is cancelled by the integration over time @xmath29 . with the @xmath0-ray opacity @xmath132 calculated out to @xmath138 , the cutoffs in blazar @xmath0-ray spectra caused by extragalactic pair production interactions with stellar photons can be predicted .
figure 8 shows the effect of the intergalactic radiation background on a few of the @xmath0-ray blazars ( `` grazars '' ) observed by _
egret _ , _ viz .
_ , 1633 + 382 , 3c279 , 3c273 , and mrk 421 .
we have assumed that the mean spectral indices obtained for these sources by _ egret _ extrapolate out to higher energies attenuated only by intergalactic absorption . observed cutoffs in grazar spectra may be intrinsic cutoffs in @xmath0-ray production in the source , or may be caused by intrinsic @xmath0-ray absorption within the source itself .
whether cutoffs in grazar spectra are primarily caused by intergalactic absorption can be determined by observing whether the grazar cutoff energies have the type of redshift dependence predicted here .
figure 8 indicates that the next generation of satellite and ground - based @xmath0-ray detectors , both of which will be designed to explore the energy range between 10 and 300 gev , will be able to reveal information about low - energy radiation produced by galaxies at various redshifts and at different stages in their evolution .
our opacity calculations have implications for the determination of the origin of @xmath0-ray bursts , if such bursts are cosmological .
as indicated in figure 6 , @xmath0-rays above an energy of @xmath139 15 gev will be attenuated if they at emitted at a redshift of @xmath139 3 . on 17 february 1994 , the _ egret _ telescope observed a @xmath0-ray burst which contained a photon of energy @xmath139 20 gev ( hurley , _ et al._1994 ) . if one adopts the opacity results which include our conservative metallicity correction ( figure 6 ) , this burst would be constrained to have originated at a redshift less than @xmath1392 .
( an estimated redshift constraint of @xmath139 1.5 was given by stecker and de jager ( 1996 ) , based on a simpler model . )
future detectors may be able to place redshift constraints on bursts observed at higher energies .
in a previous paper ( stecker & salamon 1996 ) , we presented a model for calculating the extragalactic @xmath0-ray background ( egrb ) due to unresolved grazars .
we gave results for @xmath0-ray energies up to 10 gev ( where there is effectively no @xmath0-ray absorption ) which were compared to preliminary _ egret _ data ( kniffen _ et al . _
1996 ) using the intergalactic @xmath0-ray opacities calculated here , we can now extend the results of this egrb model out to an energy of 0.5 tev .
our egrb model assumes that the grazar luminosity function is related to that of flat spectrum radio quasars ( fsrq ) , so that we can use fsrq luminosity and redshift distributions ( dunlop and peacock , 1990 ) to obtain a grazar luminosity function .
the effects of grazar flaring states , @xmath0-ray spectral index variation , and redshift dependence are also been included in this model ; see stecker and salamon ( 1996 ) for details . by integrating the grazar luminosity function weighted by our new opacity results ,
we obtain a grazar background spectrum up to 500 gev which properly includes the effect of @xmath0-ray absorption .
figure 9 shows this egrb spectrum compared with the preliminary _ egret _ data .
note that the spectrum is concave at energies below 10 gev , reflecting the dominance of hard - spectrum grazars at high energies and softer - spectrum grazars at low energies ; it then steepens above 20 gev , owing to extragalactic absorption by pair - production interactions with radiation from external galaxies , particularly at high redshifts .
both the concavity and the steepening are signatures of a blazar dominated @xmath0-ray background spectrum . because the extragalactic @xmath0-ray background in our model is made up of a superposition of _ lower - luminosity , unresolved _ grazars , its intensity is determined by the number of sources in the universe which are below the detection threshhold of a particular telescope .
a telescope with a superior point source sensitivity gives a higher source count , thereby reducing the number of unresolved sources which constitute the diffuse @xmath0-ray background . in figure 9 , the upper spectra which are close to the _ egret _
data are obtained using the _ egret _ threshold ; the lower curves correspond to the projected sensitivity of the proposed next generation _
glast _ satellite detector , which is expected to have a detection threshhold of @xmath140 @xmath8s@xmath141 above 0.1 gev .
it should also be noted that above 10 gev , blazars may have natural cutoffs in their source spectra ( stecker , de jager & salamon 1996 ) and intrinsic absorption may also be important in some sources ( protheroe & biermann 1996 ) .
thus , above 10 gev our calculated background flux from unresolved blazars , shown in figure 9 , may actually be an upper limit .
the nature of the dark matter in the universe is one of the most important fundamental problems in astrophysics and cosmology . the non - baryonic mixed dark matter model with a total @xmath142 ( shafi & stecker 1984 ) gave predictions for fluctuations in the cosmic background radiation ( schaefer , shafi & stecker 1989 ; holtzman 1989 ) which were found to be in good agreement with the later cobe measurements .
the best agreement appears to be found for @xmath139 20% hot dark matter , of which massive neutrinos are the most likely candidates , and @xmath139 80% cold dark matter ( pogosian & starobinsky 1993 , 1995 ; ma & bertchinger 1994 ; klypin , _ et al._1995 ; primack , _ et al . _ 1995 ; liddle , _ et al . _ 1996
; babu , schaefer & shafi 1996 ) . the most popular cold dark
matter particle candidates are the lightest sypersymmetric particles ( lsps ) , the neutralinos ( hereafter designated as @xmath143 particles ) .
cosmologically important @xmath143 particles must annihilate with a weak cross section , @xmath144 10@xmath145 @xmath146s@xmath141 ; calculations show that such cross sections lead to a value for @xmath147 with @xmath148@xmath149@xmath150 .
the fact that supersymmetry neutralinos are predicted to have such weak annihilation cross sections is an important reason why they have become such popular dark matter candidates .
preliminary lep 2 results give a lower limit on the mass of the @xmath143 of @xmath151 gev ( ellis , falk , olive & schmitt 1996 ) . in the minimal supersymmetry model ( mssm ) , @xmath143 can be generally described as a superposition of two gaugino states and two higgsino states .
grand unified models with a universal gaugino mass generally favor states where @xmath143 is almost a pure b - ino ( @xmath152 ) ( _ e.g. _ diehl , _ et al . _
1995 ) , but other states such as photinos and higgsinos are generally allowed by the theory .
kane & wells ( 1996 ) have presented possible accelerator evidence from cdf that @xmath143 may be a higgsino of mass @xmath139 40 gev .
dark matter neutralinos will produce @xmath0-rays by mutual pair annihilation .
this process is expected to occur because neutralinos are majorana fermions , _
i.e. _ , they are their own antiparticles . indeed , most of this mutual annihilation would have occured in the very early universe , a process which determines the present ( `` freeze out '' ) value of @xmath148 and leads to the relation @xmath153 , where the bracketed quantity is the thermal - averaged annihilation cross section times velocity ( ellis , _ et al . _ 1984
this leads to the relation that the @xmath0-ray flux from neutralino annihilation is inversely proportional to @xmath148 .
thus , the annihilation @xmath0-ray flux is limited from below by cosmological constraints on the maximum value of @xmath148 .
there are two types of @xmath0-ray spectra produced by @xmath154 annihilations , _ viz .
_ , ( 1 ) @xmath0-ray continuum spectra from the decay of secondary particles produced in the annihilation process , and ( 2 ) @xmath0-ray lines , produced primarily from the process @xmath155 ( _ e.g. _ , rudaz 1989 ) .
the cosmic @xmath0-ray flux from @xmath154 annihilation is proportional to the line - of - sight integral of the _ square _ of the @xmath143 particle density times @xmath156 .
the continuum @xmath0-ray production spectra from @xmath154 annihilation can be calculated for different types of neutralinos by starting with the appropriate branching ratios for annihilation into fermion - antifermion pairs which produce hadronic cascades leading to the subsequent production and decay of neutral pions ( rudaz & stecker 1988 ; stecker 1988 ; stecker & tylka 1989 ) .
stecker & tylka ( 1989 ) discuss in detail the various channels involved in continuum @xmath0-ray production via @xmath154 annihilation and give the resulting spectra for some lower mass @xmath143 particles .
such continuum fluxes from @xmath154 annihilations would be difficult to observe above the extrapolated cosmic background which we show in figure 9 . however , with good enough sensitivity and energy resolution , it might be possibile to observe a two - photon annihilation line from @xmath154 annihilation .
the general considerations for observability of this line were discussed by rudaz & stecker ( 1991 ) .
we update this discussion here , using ( 1 ) our new calculation of the @xmath0-ray background flux from blazars shown in figure 9 , ( 2 ) recent accelerator limits on supersymmetric particle masses , and ( 3 ) the proposed sensitivity and energy resolution of a next generation space based @xmath0-ray telescope taken from the _ glast _ proposal ( elliot 1996 ) . the energy of the @xmath155 decay line is @xmath157 .
the line width is given by doppler broadening .
for galactic halo particles , this width is roughly @xmath158 @xmath159 , much smaller than the energy resolution proposed for any future @xmath0-ray telescope .
upper and lower limits on @xmath160 yield lower and upper limits on the @xmath0-ray line flux respectively ( see above ) .
other limits can be obtained in flux - energy space ( rudaz & stecker 1991 ) .
accelerator determined lower limits on @xmath161 give lower limits on the line energy .
lower limits on the mass of the sfermion exchanged in the annihilation process give upper limits on @xmath162 since @xmath162 @xmath163 @xmath164 .
in fact , since the particle density @xmath165 and @xmath162 @xmath163 @xmath166 , the predicted annnihilation line flux @xmath167 .
further limits are obtained from the inequality @xmath168 , which is the tautology following from the condition that @xmath143 be the lsp .
if we assume that annihilations occur mainly through slepton exchange , _
i.e. _ , @xmath169 , we can obtain an upper limit on the 2@xmath0 line flux .
this is because lep 1.5 gives a lower limit of @xmath139 70 gev on the slepton mass ( de boer , miquel , pohl & watson 1996 ) , whereas the substantially higher squark mass lower limit of @xmath139 150 gev would imply much lower fluxes , since @xmath170 @xmath171 .
the lower limit on the slepton mass implies an upper limit on the line flux from @xmath172 annihilation such that the event rate for a next generation @xmath0-ray telescope with an aperture of 1 m@xmath173sr would be about 5 photons per year for a line in the energy range between 20 and 100 gev .
( if the @xmath143 particles are higgsinos , the event rate would be much lower . ) using all of these constraints , the allowed region for a neutralino annihilation line in flux - energy space is plotted in figure 10 . in constructing figure 10
, we have used the _
glast _ proposed estimate of the point source sensitivity after a one - year full sky survey to estimate the background from unresolved faint blazars ( see figure 9 and the discussion in the previous section ) .
we then obtain the background photon number for an appropriate exposure factor of 1 m@xmath173yr - sr and energy resolution of 10% , and plot the square root of this number , which represents the natural background fluctuations above which a line must be observed .
of course , a higher exposure factor would reduce the point source background and increase the sensitivity to a line flux , as would a better energy resolution .
it should also be noted that the background above 10 gev shown in figures 9 and 10 may be overestimated ( see previous section ) .
another possible way in which dark matter may produce @xmath0-rays and neutrinos is if the lsp is allowed to decay to non - supersymmetric , ordinary particles .
supersymmetry theories involve a multiplicative quantum number called _ r - parity _ , which is defined so that it is even for ordinary particles and odd for their supersymmetric partners .
thus , if r - parity is conserved , as is usually assumed , the lsp is completely stable , making it a potential dark matter candidate .
however , such may not be the case .
r - parity may be very weakly broken , allowing the lsp to decay with branching ratios involving @xmath0-rays and neutrinos ( _ e.g. _ , berezinsky , masiero & valley 1991 ) . for @xmath143 particles to be the dark matter , their decay time should be considerably longer than the age of the universe
. the possible radiative decay @xmath174 will give a @xmath0-ray line with energy @xmath175 .
such a line has the potential of being more intense than the annihilation line . whereas the @xmath154 annihilation rate and consequent line flux is cosmologically limited by requiring @xmath148 to be a significant fraction near 1 ( see previous discussion ) , the decay - line flux is limited only by the particular physical supersymmetry model postulated and constraints from related accelerator and astrophysical data .
thus , invocation of @xmath143 decay involves a higher order of particle theory model building and speculation .
we only wish to mention here that there is a possibility that a decay line may be sufficiently intense to be observable above the background .
we have calculated the @xmath0-ray opacity as a function of both energy and redshift for redshifts as high as 3 by taking account of the evolution of both the sed and emissivity of galaxies with redshift . in order to accomplish this ,
we have adopted the recent analysis of fall , _ et al .
_ ( 1996 ) and have also included the effects of metallicity evolution on galactic seds .
we have then considered the effects of the @xmath0-ray opacity of the universe on @xmath0-ray bursts , blazar spectra , and on the extragalactic @xmath0-ray background from blazars . in particular , we find that the 17 feb .
1994 _ egret _ burst probably originated at @xmath176 . because the stellar emissivity peaks between a redshift of 1 and 2 , the @xmath0-ray opacity which we derive shows little increase at higher redshifts .
this weak dependence indicates that the opacity is not determined by the initial epoch of galaxy formation , contrary to the speculation of macminn and primack ( 1996 ) .
the extragalactic @xmath0-ray background , which can be accounted for as a superposition of spectra of unresolved blazars , and which we have predicted to be concave between 0.03 and 10 gev ( stecker & salamon 1996 ) , should steepen significantly above 20 gev owing to our estimates of extragalactic @xmath0-ray absorption at moderate to high redshifts .
both the predicted concavity and steepening may be too subtle to detect with present data from _
egret_. however , next generation @xmath0-ray telescopes which are presently being designed , such as _ glast _ , may be able to observe these features and thereby test the blazar background model .
we also discuss the possible observability of dark matter lines in the multi - gev region , given our predicted extragalactic background .
babu , k.s . ,
schaefer , r.k .
& shafi , q. 1996 , phys .
, d53 606 berezinsky , v. , masiero , a. & valle , j.w.f .
1991 , phys .
lett . , b266 , 382 bertelli , g. , _ et al . _ 1994 ,
a&as , 106 , 275 bloom , e.d .
1996 , space sci .
75 , 109 bowyer , s. 1991 , ara&a , 29 , 59 bruzual a.,g . and charlot , s. 1993 , , 405 , 538 chandrasekhar , s. 1950 , _ radiative transfer _ , ( clarendon press , oxford ) charlot , s. , and bruzual a.,g .
1991 , , 457 , 625 charlot , s. , worthey , g. , and bressan , a. 1996 , , 457 , 625 . de boer , w. , miquel , r. , pohl , m. & watson , n. 1996 , _ joint particle physics seminar , lep experiments committee , cern_. diehl , e. _ et al .
_ 1995 , phys .
rev . , d52 , 4223 dove , j.b . and shull , j.m .
1994 , , 430 , 222 dunlop , j.s . and peacock , j.a
. 1990 , mnras , 247 , 19 ellis , j. , _ et al .
_ 1984 , nucl .
b238 , 453 ellis , j. , falk , t. , olive , k.a . & schmitt , m. 1966 , cern preprint .
fall , s.m .
, charlot , s. , and pei , y.c .
1996 , , 464 , l43 fall , s.m . and
pei , y.c .
1993 , , 402 , 479 gunn , j.e . and
peterson , b.a .
1965 , , 142 , 1633 holtzman , j.a .
1989 , , 71 , 1 hurley , k. , _ et al . _
1994 , nature , 372 , 652 .
kane , g.l .
& wells , d. 1996 , phys .
letters , 76 , 4458 klypin , a. , _ et al .
_ 1995 , , 444 , 1 .
kniffen , d.a . , _
et al . _
1996 , a&as , 120 , 615 .
lanzetta , k.m . , wolfe , a.m. , & turnshek , d.a .
1995 , , 440 , 435 liddle , a.r . , _
et al . _ , 1996 ,
mnras , 281 , 531 lilly , s.j . , le fevre , o. , hammer , f. , & crampton , d. 1996 , , 460 , l1 ma , c .- p . & bertschinger , e. 1994 , , 434 , l5 macminn , d & primack , j. 1996 , space sci . rev .
, 75 , 413 .
madau , p. 1992
, , 389 , l1 madau , p. 1995
, , 441 , 18 madau , p. & meiksin , a. 1994 , , 433 , l53 madau , p. 1996 , in _ star formation near and far _ , aip symp .
( new york : amer .
inst . phys . ) , in press madau , p. _ et al._1996 , mnras 283 , 1388 madau , p. & phinney , e.s .
1996 , 456 , 124 madau , p. & shull , j.m .
1996 , , 457 , 551 martin , c. & bowyer , s. 1989 , 338 , 677 mattila , k. 1990 , in iau symp .
139 , the galactic and extragalactic background radiation , d. s. bowyer & c. leinert ( dordrecht : kluwer ) 257 meiksin , a. & madau , p. 1993
, , 412 , 34 miralda - escud , j. & ostriker , j.p .
1992 , , 392 , 15 miralda - escud , j. & ostriker , j.p .
1990 , , 350 , 1 paresce , f. , mckee , c. , & bowyer , s. 1980 , , 240 , 29 pei , y.c . & fall , s.m .
1995 , , 454 , 69 pettini m. , smith , l.j . ,
hunstead , r.w . , & king , d.l .
1994 , , 426 , 79 pogosyan , d.yu .
& starobinsky , a.a .
1993 , mnras , 265 , 507 pogosyan , d.yu .
& starobinsky , a.a .
1995 , 447 , 465 primack , , j. _ et al .
_ 1995 , phys .
74 , 2160 protheroe , r. and biermann , p.l .
1996 , astropart .
phys . , 6 , 45 rudaz , s. 1989 , phys .
rev . , d39 , 3549 rudaz , s. & stecker , f.w . 1991 , , 368 , 40 rudaz , s. & stecker 1988 , f.w . , 325 , 16 salamon , m.h . ,
stecker , f.w . , & de jager , o.c .
1994 , , 415 , l1 savage , b.d . &
mathis , j.s .
1979 , , 17 , 73 schaefer , r.k . , shafi , q. & stecker , f.w .
1989 , 347 , 575 schneider , d.p . , schmidt , m. , & gunn , j.e .
1991 , , 102 , 837 shafi , q. & stecker , f.w . 1984 , phys .
53 , 1292 stecker , f.w .
1988 , phys .
lett . , b201 , 529 stecker , f.w .
1996 _ unveiling the cosmic infrared background ( aip conf .
348 ) _ , ( amer .
inst . of physics , new york ) , p. 181 .
stecker , f.w . &
de jager , o.c .
1996 , space sci .
, 75 , 413 .
stecker , f.w .
& de jager , o.c .
1997 , 476 , 712 .
stecker , f.w . , de jager , o.c , & salamon , m.h .
1992 , , 390 , l49 stecker , f.w . , de jager , o.c , & salamon , m.h .
1996 , , 473 , l75 stecker , f.w . & salamon , m.h .
1996 , , 464 , 600 stecker , f.w . &
tylka , a.j .
1989 , , 343 , 169 steidel , c.c . &
sargent , w.l.w .
1987 , , 318 , l11 thompson , d. , _ et al . _
1996 , , 107 , 227 vogel , s.n . ,
weymann , r.j . , rauch , m. & hamilton , t. 1995 , 441 , 162 whittet , d.c.b .
1992 , _ dust in the galactic environment _ , ( insitute of physics publishing , bristol ) worthey , g. 1994 , , 95 , 107 figure 1 : plot of @xmath45-band mass - to - light ratios @xmath177 versus stellar system age @xmath22 for various values of metallicity @xmath44 , taken from worthey ( 1994 ) , table 5a .
the metallicity values are given on the right - hand side of the figure as @xmath178 , where @xmath179 is solar metallicity .
filled ( open ) squares correspond to the tabulated data for @xmath180 ( @xmath181 ) , filled ( open ) circles for @xmath182 ( @xmath183 ) , filled ( open ) triangles for @xmath184 ( @xmath185 ) , filled inverted triangles for @xmath186 , and open diamonds for @xmath187 .
figure 3 : emissivity as a function of redshift , calculated using eq .
[ atten_emiss.eq ] , for three wavelength values , @xmath1880.28 , 0.44 , and 1.0 @xmath57 m , for a hubble constant value of @xmath189 .
note that the emissivity scales as @xmath134 ( _ cf .
_ eq . 4 and section 3 ) .
solid line curves are for the case where the metallicity correction factor ( @xmath51 from eq . [ worthey.eq ] ) is used ; dashed lines give the emissivity when this correction factor is _ not _ included .
the data from the canada - french redshift survey ( lilly _ et al . _
1996 ) are also plotted .
figure 4 : the intergalactic radiation energy density from stars and qsos as a function of wavelength for redshifts @xmath6 of 0 , 1 , 2 , and 3 , for a hubble constant value of @xmath189 ( the energy density scales as @xmath133 ; see eq . 7 and section 3 )
these densities are calculated with the metallicity correction factor , @xmath51 , included .
figure 6 : the opacity @xmath190 of the universal soft photon background to @xmath0-rays as a function of @xmath0-ray energy and source redshift .
these curves are calculated with the metallicity correction factor included in the expression for stellar emissivity . as discussed in the text ,
these results are independent of the value chosen for @xmath133 .
figure 8 : the effect of intergalactic absorption by pair - production on the power - law spectra of four prominent grazars : 1633 + 382 , 3c279 , 3c273 , and mrk 421 .
the solid ( dashed ) curves are calculated with ( without ) the metallicity correction factor .
figure 9 : the extragalactic @xmath0-ray background energy spectrum from unresolved grazars .
the top and bottom sets of curves correspond to point - source sensitivities of @xmath191 and @xmath192 @xmath8s@xmath141 , respectively , for @xmath0-ray energies above 0.1 gev , corresponding to the approximate point - source sensivities of the _ egret _ and _ glast _ detectors respectively . because the fsrq luminosity fuction that we employ scales as @xmath193 ( dunlop and peacock , 1990 ) , our calculated egrb spectrum scales as @xmath134 ( see eq .
10 in stecker and salamon , 1996 ) .
figure 10 .
the dot - dash polygon shows the allowed region of expected @xmath0-ray photon counts calculated for a bino ( @xmath152 ) annihilation line as a function of @xmath194 .
present accelerator and cosmological constraints are indicated by the labels on the sides of the polygon ( see text ) . in the figure labels ,
the letter `` b '' represents the bino ( @xmath152 ) and the letter `` l '' represents the slepton ( @xmath195 ) . as an illustration of how to read the figure , the arrow within the polygon indicates the line flux upper limit for a bino of mass 100 gev .
an exposure factor of 1 m@xmath173sr yr and an energy resolution of 10% are assumed .
we also show the background fluctuation count rate appropriate to these parameters for the lower set of flux curves ( _ i.e. _ with and without the metallicity correction ) shown in figure 9 ( see text ) . | in this paper , we extend previous work on the absorption of high energy @xmath0-rays in intergalactic space by calculating the absorption of 10 to 500 gev @xmath0-rays at high redshifts .
this calculation requires the determination of the high - redshift evolution of the intergalactic starlight photon field , including its spectral energy distribution out to frequencies beyond the lyman limit . to estimate this evolution ,
we have followed a recent analysis of fall , charlot & pei , which reproduces the redshift dependence of the starlight background emissivity obtained by the canada - france redshift survey group .
we also include the uv background from quasars .
we give our results for the @xmath0-ray opacity as a function of redshift out to a redshift of 3 .
we also give predicted @xmath0-ray spectra for selected blazars and extend our calculations of the extragalactic @xmath0-ray background from blazars to an energy of 500 gev with absorption effects included .
our results indicate that the extragalactic @xmath0-ray background spectrum from blazars should steepen significantly above 20 gev , owing to extragalactic absorption .
future observations of a such a steepening would thus provide a test of the blazar origin hypothesis for the @xmath0-ray background radiation .
we also note that our absorption calculations can be used to place limits on the redshifts of @xmath0-ray bursts ; for example , our calculated opacities indicate that the 17 feb .
1994 burst observed by _
egret _ must have originated at @xmath1 .
finally , our estimates of the high - energy @xmath0-ray background spectrum are used to determine the observability of multi - gev @xmath0-ray lines from the annihilation of supersymmetric dark - matter particles in the galactic halo . |
cosmic bursts of gamma - rays are some of the most elusive and mysterious events in the universe . typical burst lasts less than a minute and disappears thereafter .
however , since the _ bepposax _ s first discovery on 1997 february 28 ( costa et al . 1997 ) it is known that gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) also produce x - ray afterglows , which can be detected with modern x - ray observatories for several hours and sometimes several days after the burst .
more than a few x - ray afterglows have been observed in last five years by _ bepposax , asca and chandra _ satellites .
several afterglow observations were carried out with _ xmm - newton_. in this _
letter _ we report on two of the latter observations .
grb 011211 was detected and localized in _ bepposax _
wfc1 on 2001 december 11 , 19:09:21 ut(gandolfi 2001 ) .
the distinguishing features of grb 011211 were its long duration ( the longest event localized with _ bepposax _ ) and its faintness both in x- and @xmath0-rays ( frontera et al . 2002 ) .
grav et al .
( 2001 ) discovered a new point source in optical r - band ( r@xmath719 ) at r.a.=11@xmath815@[email protected] , dec=@xmath1121@xmath1256@[email protected] ( j2000 , @xmath61@xmath14 ) identified as the afterglow of grb 011211 .
fruchter et al .
( 2001 ) and gladders et al .
( 2001 ) measured the optical spectrum and found an absorption line system corresponding to a redshift of z=2.14 .
later the optical transient was found to be superposed on an apparent host galaxy with r = [email protected] ( burud et al .
2001 ) .
grb 001025 was detected by the _
rxte all - sky monitor _ on 2000 october 25 at about 03:10:05 ut ( smith et al .
. lasted approximately 15 - 20 s and reached a peak 5 - 12 kev flux of @xmath154 crab .
optical afterglow of grb 001025 has never been detected down to r=24.5 for any significantly variable object ( fynbo et al .
the observation of grb 011211 afterglow was started on 2001 december 12 at 06:16:56 ut ( santos - lleo et al .
a source was initially located so close to the edge of ccd#7 in epic - pn detector that some of the source photons were falling in the inter - ccd gap . therefore , the telescope was re - pointed the re - pointing slew started at 08:31:16ut and finished at 08:40:50ut . useful exposure of total observation is @xmath1527 ks .
xmm - newton observed the location of grb 001025 from oct.27.003 to oct.27.46 ut , starting @xmath151.9 days after the burst .
two x - ray sources were detected in the error box ( altieri et al .
below we discuss the brighter source ( r.a.=8@xmath836@[email protected] , decl.=-13@xmath1204@[email protected] , j2000 ) .
we analyzed data products from the two _ xmm - newton _ observations . in all observations the epic instruments ( turner et al .
2001 , strueder et al .
2001 ) were operated in the _ full window mode _ ( @xmath16 diameter fov ) .
the medium optical blocking filter was used with mos detectors for grb 011211 observation .
thin filter was used with pn detector for grb 011211 and with mos detectors in grb 001025 observation .
no pn data were available for grb 001025 .
we reduced epic data with the _ xmm - newton _ science analysis system ( sas v.5.2 ) .
epic detectors data were fit together with common model parameters .
the count rates were converted into energy fluxes using analytical fits to the spectra .
we have used galactic absorption values provided by the heasarc `` nh '' tool ( dickey & lockman , 1990 ) .
central part of mos1 detector ( converted to celestial coordinates ) is shown in fig .
the bright source in the middle of the image corresponds to the position of grb 011211 optical afterglow .
significant x - ray flux decline during the observation ( fig .
1b ) provides an additional evidence for an identification of the x - ray source with the grb .
x - ray light curve can be fit with f@xmath17t@xmath18 ( @xmath19=1.5 - 1.7 ) or with f@xmath17e@xmath20 ( @[email protected] ks ) . average measured flux in 0.2 - 10 kev band was equal to 1.7@xmath2210@xmath23 erg / s/@xmath24 . extrapolating back to t=100 s since the initial detection of the burst we get an x - ray flux f@xmath25=5@xmath2210@xmath26 erg / s/@xmath24 or x - ray afterglow luminosity l@xmath25=2@xmath2210@xmath27 erg / s ( 0.6 - 30 kev ) in the rest frame at z=2.14 and a @xmath28=65 km s@xmath3mpc@xmath3 , @xmath29 , @xmath30 cosmology .
spectrum of the grb 011211 afterglow can be described as a simple power - law with photon index @[email protected] modified by the galactic absorption only ( fig .
no significant spectral evolution has been found in a sequence of 5-ks intervals within the observation ( fig .
2b ) .
we built the spectrum of the brightest source in error box of grb 001025 ( fig .
combined spectrum of two mos detectors can be readily approximated by a power - law with photon index @[email protected] and galactic absorption value n@xmath31=6@xmath2210@xmath32 @xmath2 .
average flux from the source during the observation was 5.3@xmath2210@xmath33erg / s/@xmath24 .
no significant flux variability was detected , but the spectrum is very typical for x - ray afterglows of grb , supporting the identification of this source with grb 001025 .
it is interesting to consider an alternative identification of the x - ray source with a background quasar .
an x - ray bright quasar 3c273 has a r magnitude of @xmath1512.5 ( odell et al .
1978 ) and the 0.5 - 10 kev x - ray flux of 23@xmath2210@xmath34 erg/@xmath24/s ( reeves & turner 2000 ) . neglecting the k - correction and simply scaling the r magnitude to the x - ray flux
we find that if a 3c273-like quasar is a source of the detected x - ray flux of @xmath154.7@xmath2210@xmath33 erg/@xmath24/s ( 0.5 - 10 kev ) then its optical counterpart would have a r magnitude of @xmath1521.7 .
as in fact an optical counterpart for grb 001025 had not been found down to r=24.5 ( fynbo et al . 2000 ) we consider unlikely that the x - ray source is an agn .
we have detected power - law spectra with index @xmath152 from two grb afterglows . in case of grb 011211 an identification of the x - ray source with the grb
is supported by the observation of optical transient and also by the decline of x - ray flux during the _ xmm - newton _ observation . for grb 001025
we do not have such supporting evidence , but the spectral shape itself together with the position of x - ray source inside ipn / rxte error box allows us to suggest that the source is indeed an afterglow of grb 001025 .
power - law fit with slope @xmath152 is very typical for detected x - ray afterglows of grbs ( see e.g. harrison et al . 2001 ,
int zand et al .
2001 , antonelli et al .
we did not detect any significant changes in the x - ray spectrum during the long observation of grb 011211 .
afterglow of grb 001025 was observed significantly later after the burst , and measured x - ray flux was much lower , but the spectrum was almost identical to grb 011211 . conspicuously the x - ray spectra in all or most of the observed afterglows are generated by common physical process and do not depend much on the differences in the burst environments .
overall spectral shape can be fit to popular model of synchrotron emission with possible inclusion of inverse compton scattering ( piran 1999 ; granot & sari 2002 ; sari & esin 2001 ) .
no significant absorption above the galactic values has been detected in the x - ray spectra .
high absorption would be naturally expected if the burst occurs in a high - density star - forming region .
ramirez - ruiz , trentham & blain ( 2002 ) suggested that high absorption in nearby ( relative to the burst birthplace ) interstellar media may be the reason for a lack of optical detections in a significant fraction of grb .
the absorption should be detectable in soft x - rays ( 0.5 - 2 kev ) .
contrary to such expectations , we did not detect any significant absorption above the galactic value in both a grb with optical afterglow ( grb 011211 ) and without it ( grb 001025 ) .
the lack of x - ray absorption in grb 011211 is consistent with the lack of detected reddenning in the spectrum of optical afterglow ( simon et al .
2001 ) .
reeves et al .
( 2002a , hereafter rwo ) reported on the discovery of a blue - shifted line complex in the spectrum of grb 011211 .
the lines have been detected only with pn detector and only during first 5 ks of the observation , with the source located close to the ccd chip boundary ( fig .
we have extracted source and background spectra from the same regions as rwo ( reeves et al .
. the spectrum can be satisfactory fit to power - law with @xmath5=2.4 and n@xmath31 = 8 @xmath22 10@xmath32 @xmath2 ( @xmath35=1.03 for 44 d.o.f .
joint fit of pn , mos1 and mos2 data gives @xmath35=0.92 ( 72 d.o.f . ) for @[email protected] and an absorption fixed at the galactic value .
hence we are able to get the perfect fit using a simple power - law model we do not see much value in adding extra lines to the model .
addition of 5 lines at the energies specified by rwo gives @xmath35=0.93 ( 62 d.o.f . ) for joint fit of the pn and mos data .
the analysis of pn data alone allowed us to reproduce line fluxes reported by rwo with somewhat lower significance ( fig .
4c and table 2 ) .
we note that the pn data should be treated with special caution for the first 5 ks of the observation because of the unfortunate position of the source on the ccd . in their analysis rwo
collected source data from two different pn chips and from the areas near the interchip boundary , which are the least suitable for fine spectroscopy .
our extensive analysis showed that any alternative choice of extraction regions for the source and background leads to further reduction in the lines significance .
we also found that background spectrum collected over the interchip edge is dominated by a strong feature at 0.7 kev , exactly at the energy of the most significant `` line '' reported by rwo ( see fig.4f ) .
though the bulk of the events forming this line are eliminated by the event filtering we are still concerned that some of these bad events may be present in the spectrum of grb 011211 .
our concern is amplified by the lack of any of the rwo `` lines '' in the pn spectrum after the reorientation ( fig.4d ) .
spectral evolution of the source in sync with satellite revolutions looks quite suspicious unless one suggests that presense of the `` lines '' depends on the position of the source on the chip .
such alternative hypothesis is further confirmed by a lack of `` lines '' in the mos data ( fig .
it may therefore be concluded that there is no definitive evidence for the presence of the line complex at a redshift of 1.88 in the x - ray spectrum of grb 011211 .
the existence of such complex is a possibility , but its statistical significance is greatly overestimated by rwo .
our analysis suggests that the spectrum of grb 011211 is featureless and does not contain any significant line emission .
we have used publicly available data obtained with _ xmm - newton _ satellite .
we are grateful to the personnel of the _ xmm - newton _ science operations centre at vilspa , spain for satellite operations and expedited preparation of data products for scientific analysis .
we are thankful to w.priedhorsky and l.titarchuk for encouraging advices , and to anonymous referee for her / his helpful comments .
we acknowledge an interesting discussion of the draft version of our paper with j.osborne .
altieri , b. , schartel , n. , santos , m. , tomas , l. , guainazzi , m. , piro , l. , parmar , a. 2000 , gcn circ .
869 antonelli , a. , piro , l. , vietry , m. , et al .
2000 , apj , 545 , l39 burud , i. , rhoads , j. , fruchter a. , & hjorth j. , on behalf of grace ( gamma - ray afterglow collaboration at eso ) , 2001 , gcn circ .
1213 costa , e. , frontera , f. , heise , j. , et al .
1997 , _ nature _ , 387 , 783 covino , s. , ghisellini , g. , saracco , p. , et al .
, 2002 , gcn circ .
1214 dickey , j. m. , & lockman , f. j. 1990 , araa , 28 , 215 frontera , f. , amati , l. , guidorzi , c. , montanari , e. , costa , e. , feroci , m. , piro , l. , heise , j. , int zand , j.j.m . , 2002 , gcn circ .
1215 fruchter , a. , vreeswijk , p. , rhoads , j. , burud , i. , 2001 , gcn circ .
1200 fynbo , j. p. u. , moller , p. , milvang - jensen , b. , burud , i. , andersen , m. i. , pedersen , h. , jensen , b. l. , hjorth , j. , gorosabel , j. 2000 , gcn circ .
867 gandolfi , g. , on behalf of bepposax mission scientist , 2001 , gcn circ .
1189 gladders , m. , holland , s. , garnavich , p. m. , jha , s. , stanek , k. z. , bersier , d. , barrientos , l.f . , 2001 ,
1209 granot , j. , sari , r. 2002 , apj , 568 , 820 grav , t. , hansen , m.w . , pedersen , h. , hjorth , j. , michelsen , r. , jensen , b.l . ,
andersen , m.i .
, gorosabel , j. , fynbo , j.u . , 2001 ,
1191 harrison , f.a . ,
yost , s.a .
, sari , r. , berger , e. , galama , t. , et al .
2001 , apj , 559 , 123 int zand , j.j.m . ,
kuiper , l.m . , amati , l. , antonelli , l.a . ,
butler , r.c .
, et al . 2001 , apj , 559 , 710 odell , s. l. , puschell , j. j. , stein , w. a. , owen , f. , porcas , r. w. , mufson , s. , moffett , t. j. , ulrich , m .- h .
1978 , apj , 224 , 22 piran , t. 1999 , phys.rep .
, 314 , 575 ramirez - ruiz , e. , trentham , n. , & blain , a. w. 2002 , m.n.r.a.s .
, 329 , 465 reeves , j. n. , & turner , m. j. l. 2000 , mnras , 316 , 234 reeves , j. n. , watson , d. , osborne , j. p. , pounds , k. a. , obrien , p. t. et al .
, 2002a , _ nature _ , 416 , l512 ( rwo ) reeves , j. n. , watson , d. , osborne , j. p. , pounds , k. a. , obrien , p. t. 2002b , astro - ph/0206480 santos - lleo , m. , loiseau , n. , rodriguez , p. , altieri , b. , and schartel , n. , 2001 , gcn circ .
1192 sari , r. , esin , a.a .
2001 , apj , 548 , 787 simon , v. , hudec , r. , pizzichini , g. , masetti , n. , 2001 , gcn circ .
1211 smith , d. a. , levine , a. m. , remillard , r. , hurley , k. , cline , t. 2000 , gcn circ .
861 strueder , l. et al . , 2001 ,
a&a , l18 turner , m. et al . , 2001 ,
a&a , 365 , l27 | we present the _ xmm - newton _ observations of x - ray afterglows of the @xmath0-ray bursts grb 011211 and grb 001025 . for grb 011211
_ xmm _ detected fading x - ray object with an average flux in 0.2 - 10 kev declining from @xmath1 erg @xmath2 s@xmath3 during the first 5 ks of 27-ks observation to @xmath4 erg @xmath2 s@xmath3 toward the end of the observation .
the spectrum of the afterglow can be fit to a power law with @[email protected] modified for the galactic absorption .
no significant evolution of spectral parameters has been detected during the observation .
similar x - ray spectrum with @[email protected] has been observed by the xmm from the grb 001025 .
the non - detection of any extra absorption in these spectra above the galactic value is an interesting fact and may impose restrictions to the favorable grb models involving burst origin in star - forming regions .
finally we discuss soft x - ray lines from grb 011211 reported by reeves et al . and conclude that there is no definitive evidence for the presense of these lines in the spectrum . *
# 1#1 |
the layered organic material 3 ( ai3 ) , which has been studied since the 1980s,@xcite has recently attracted renewed interest because it reveals low - energy massless dirac fermions under hyrdostatic pressure ( @xmath2 gpa).@xcite compared to graphene , certainly the most popular material with low - energy dirac fermions@xcite or electronic states at the surface of three - dimensional topological insulators,@xcite ai3 is strikingly different in several respects .
apart from the tilt of the dirac cones and the anisotropy in the fermi surface,@xcite its average fermi velocity is roughly one order of magnitude smaller than that in graphene .
this , together with an experimentally identified low - temperature charge - ordered phase at ambient pressure,@xcite indicates the relevance of electronic correlations .
indeed , because the effective coupling constant for coulomb - type electron - electron interactions is inversely proportional to the fermi velocity , it is expected to be ten times larger in ai3 than in graphene .
the material ai3 thus opens the exciting prospective to study strongly - correlated dirac fermions that are beyond the scope of graphene electrons.@xcite .
another specificity of ai3 is the presence of additional massive carriers in the vicinity of the fermi level , as recently pointed out in ab - initio band - structure calculations.@xcite however , the interplay between massless dirac fermions and massive carriers has , to the best of our knowledge , not yet been proven experimentally .
finally , one should mention a topological merging of dirac points that is expected for high but experimentally accessible pressure.@xcite here , we present magneto - transport measurements of ai3 crystals under hydrostatic pressure larger than @xmath3 gpa where dirac carriers are present .
we show not only the existence of high - mobility dirac carriers as reported elsewhere,@xcite but we prove also experimentally the presence of low - mobility massive holes , in agreement with recent band - structure calculations.@xcite the interplay between both carrier types at low energy is the main result of our studies .
furthermore , we show that the measured mobilities for the two carrier types hint at scattering mechanisms due to strongly screened interaction potentials or other short - range scatterers .
the remainder of the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ sec:1 ] , we present the experimental set - up and the results of the magneto - transport measurements ( sec .
[ sec:1.1 ] ) under hydrostatic pressure .
the subsection [ sec:1.2 ] is devoted to a discussion of the temperature dependence of the carrier densities , in comparison with the model of ( a ) massless dirac fermions and ( b ) massive carriers .
furthermore thermopower measurements are presented to corroborate the two - carrier scenario .
the measured temperature dependence of the extracted carrier mobilities is exposed in sec .
[ sec:1.3 ] , and a theoretical discussion of the experimental results , in terms of short - range ( such as screened coulomb ) scatterers may be found in sec .
[ sec:2 ] .
we present our conclusions and future perspectives in sec .
[ sec:3 ] .
the single crystals of ai3 used in our study have been synthesized by electro - crystallization .
their typical size is @xmath4 mm@xmath5 ( @xmath6 plane ) x @xmath7 m ( @xmath8 direction ) .
six @xmath9 nm thick gold contacts were deposited by joule evaporation on both sides of the sample , allowing for simultaneous longitudinal and transverse resistivity measurements .
a picture of one of the three samples studied is shown in the inset of figure [ magneto ] .
the resistivities were measured using a low - frequency ac lock - in technique .
the magnetic field @xmath10 , oriented along the @xmath8 axis , was swept between @xmath11 and @xmath12 t at constant temperature between @xmath13 and @xmath3 k. to account for alignment mismatch of patterned contacts , the longitudinal ( transverse ) resistivity has been symmetrized ( anti - symmetrized ) with respect to the orientation of @xmath10 to obtain even [ @xmath14 and odd [ @xmath15 functions respectively .
hydrostatic pressure was applied at room temperature in a nicral clamp cell using daphne 7373 silicone oil as the pressure transmitting medium .
the pressure was determined , at room temperature , using a manganine resistance gauge located in the pressure cell close to the sample .
the values given below take into account the pressure decrease during cooling .
the analysis of our data is based on the study of the magneto - conductivity and is similar to the one presented in ref . for multi - carrier semiconductor systems .
the magneto - conductivity is obtained from the measured resistivity tensor by means of @xmath16 $ ] . for a single carrier system , its analytical expression reads@xcite @xmath17 where @xmath18 , @xmath19 is the electron charge , @xmath20 the mobility , and @xmath21 is the carrier density .
figure [ magneto ] displays a typical magneto - conductivity curve of ai3 under pressure , where two ` plateaus ' can be clearly seen . as conductivity in ai3
has a strong 2d character , conductivity is shown both as 3d conductivity ( @xmath22 ) and as 2d conductivity ( @xmath23 of each bedt - ttf plane ) according to @xmath24 .
as conductivity is additive , in a two - carrier system , the contributions of each carrier type a and b can be added , @xmath25 the two `` plateaus '' , observed in fig .
[ magneto ] , indicate the existence of two different carrier types ( @xmath26 or @xmath27 ) with significantly different mobilities . from this curve
, we can extract the mobilities , @xmath28 , of each carrier type , their zero - field conductivities , @xmath29 , and their carrier densities , @xmath30 , by @xmath31 .
regime at high fields .
the left axis shows the square ( 2d ) conductivity of each bedt - ttf plane while the right axis shows the `` bulk '' ( 3d ) longitudinal conductivity ( see text ) .
inset : photograph of one sample . ]
figure [ sigmaxxt ] shows magneto - conductivity curves of ai3 at a fixed pressure for several temperatures .
the previous analysis has been repeated for each of these magneto - conductivity curves to obtain the densities ( fig .
[ density ] ) and mobilities ( fig . [ mobility ] ) for each carrier type as a function of temperature and for three different pressures , @xmath32 , @xmath33 and @xmath34 gpa .
the strong temperature dependence of the carrier density is a signature that temperature is higher than @xmath35 for both a and b carriers even at the lowest measured temperature , @xmath36 k. this low fermi temperature hints at the absence of charge inhomogeneities that prevent the approach of the dirac point in graphene on si0@xmath37 substrates.@xcite the carrier density can be calculated from @xmath38 , where @xmath39 is the fermi - dirac distribution and @xmath40 is the density of states for massive ( @xmath41 ) and dirac ( @xmath42 ) carriers:@xcite gpa for different temperatures , from bottom to top : @xmath3 , @xmath43 , @xmath34 , @xmath44 , @xmath45 , @xmath46 , @xmath47 , @xmath48 , @xmath49 , @xmath50 and @xmath51 k. the left axis shows the square ( 2d ) conductivity of each bedt - ttf plane while the right axis shows the `` bulk '' ( 3d ) longitudinal conductivity . ]
gpa , triangles @xmath33 gpa and squares @xmath34 gpa ; blue thin symbols for a carriers and red thick symbols for b carriers ) .
the left axis shows the density for each bedt - ttf plane ( @xmath52 ) while the right axis shows the bulk density ( @xmath53 ) .
the lines represent power - law fits of to the a and b carrier densities that yield exponents 0.9 and 2.2 , respectively .
inset : band structure calculations at @xmath54 gpa where both dirac cones ( a ) and parabolic bands ( b ) cross the fermi level ( adapted from ref . ) . ] gpa , triangles : @xmath33 gpa and squares : @xmath34 gpa ; blue thin symbols for a carriers and red thick symbols for b carriers ) .
the continuous lines represent power laws fits for the mobilities dependences with temperature , which gives exponents @xmath55 ( a carriers ) and @xmath56 ( b carriers ) .
the low temperature dispersion of a carriers mobility is due to a decrease of the saturating mobility ( dotted line ) by increasing pressure . ]
@xmath57 @xmath58 where @xmath59 and @xmath60 are valley and spin degeneracies and @xmath61 is the effective mass of massive carriers described by a schrdinger equation . in ai3 under pressure ,
two dirac cones but only one massive band exist at the fermi level.@xcite for large temperatures , @xmath62 , the carrier density depends linearly on temperature for massive carriers and quadratically for dirac carriers : @xmath63 @xmath64 figure [ density ] represents the measured temperature dependence of the mobilities and reveals a power - law behavior , @xmath65 .
indeed one obtains an exponent of @xmath66 for the low - mobility carriers ( b ) , in good agreement with what [ eq .
( [ nmassif ] ) ] expected for massive carriers , whereas one finds @xmath67 for the high - mobility carriers ( a ) , as roughly expected for massless dirac particles [ eq . ( [ ndirac ] ) ] .
besides , the nature of the carriers can be extracted from hall measurements .
furthermore , we have performed thermopower measurements under pressure on a second sample ( figure [ thermopower ] ) .
these data show a sign change for the seebeck coefficient ( s ) around 5k .
thermopower is the voltage per unit of temperature produced by a thermal gradient .
the carrier type determines the sign while the density and mobility of the carriers establish the amplitude .
thus , a sign change of the thermopower indicates that the relevant carriers at low temperature have a different charge than those at high temperature , requiring a two - carrier scenario . in agreement with ref .
, a carriers which dominate the low - field conduction are electrons . on the contrary , at large fields
the conduction is dominated by holes ( b carriers ) .
notice that our results are consistent with ab - initio calculations of the band structure of ai3 under a pressure of @xmath68 gpa ( inset of figure [ density])@xcite and do not depend on pressure ( within the range @xmath69 gpa ) .
this supports the idea that massless and massive particles coexist in a broad pressure range
. however , since @xmath70 in the whole temperature range under study , both dirac electrons and dirac holes are excited .
thus there are indeed not two but three carrier types : dirac holes , dirac electrons and massive electrons . for @xmath62 ,
the electron and hole densities are actually identical ( semimetal with symmetric band structure ) : @xmath71 .
the absence of a third ` plateau ' in the magneto - conductivity data allows us to consider that dirac electrons and holes have roughly the same mobilities : @xmath72 .
therefore , the results obtained in figure [ density ] and [ mobility ] still hold when we consider two types of dirac carriers ( electrons and holes ) in addition to the massive holes .
this analysis allows us to avoid using hall effect measurements for the determination of carrier densities . indeed , hall effect interpretation becomes challenging as dirac electron and hole contributions partially compensate , leading to the determination of only an ` effective ' dirac carrier density , and they are both mixed with massive carriers contribution .
this problem is solved here by analyzing the magneto - conductivity where all carriers contributions are additive .
the effective mass of the massive carriers has been extracted from eq .
( [ nmassif ] ) .
the obtained value is quite small @xmath73 ( @xmath74 is the free electron mass ) .
meanwhile , from eq .
( [ ndirac ] ) , @xmath75 m / s can be extracted , in agreement with previous theoretica@xcite and experimental estimates.@xcite in fig . [ density ] , no significant variation of this argument is observed upon sweeping pressure ( which should appear as a vertical shift of the @xmath76 line ) .
this indicates that @xmath77 does not change with pressure . in principle
, pressure should enhance hopping while reducing the unit cell volume .
thus , an enhancement of the @xmath77 with pressure could be expected according to the approximate expression @xmath78 , where @xmath79 is the hopping integral .
this expression can be simplified by means of harrison s law ( @xmath80 ) into @xmath81 . as pressure slightly modifies the lattice constant ( @xmath82gpa @xcite )
, @xmath77 is expected to vary by the same order of magnitude which is smaller than our current experimental uncertainty .
this accounts for the apparent absence of pressure effects on the carrier density in the range @xmath83 gpa . in fig .
[ mobility ] , the mobility of the dirac carriers ( a ) reaches @xmath84 cm@xmath5/vs at low temperatures ( @xmath86 k ) , a value comparable to already published values.@xcite it is quite high compared to typical graphene on 2 values ( @xmath87 to @xmath88 cm@xmath5/vs ) but similar to suspended graphene and graphene on bn mobilities at very low carrier density.@xcite on the other hand , the mobility for massive carriers is @xmath89 cm@xmath5/vs at @xmath86 k , which is two orders of magnitude smaller than for dirac carriers .
the temperature dependence of the mobility follows power laws for both massive ( exponent @xmath56 ) and dirac carriers ( exponent @xmath55 ) .
moreover , the dirac carrier mobility seems to saturate at @xmath90 .
a similar saturation has been reported in others dirac systems.@xcite table [ tabcomp ] summarizes the main parameters of massive and dirac carriers in ai3 , in comparison with graphene on 2 .
.dirac and massive carriers parameters in ai3 at high pressure , in comparison with graphene electrons . [ cols="<,<,<,<",options="header " , ]
in order to better understand the difference in the mobility , we investigate the ratio @xmath91 , in terms of the scattering times @xmath92 and @xmath93 for the massless dirac and massive carriers , respectively .
furthermore , @xmath94 is the density - dependent cyclotron mass of the dirac carriers , in terms of the fermi energy @xmath95 .
the scattering times may be obtained from fermi s golden rule ( for @xmath96 ) @xmath97 in terms of the impurity density @xmath98 , the matrix element @xmath99 , and the density of states ( [ ddirac ] ) for dirac and ( [ dmassif ] ) for massive carriers .
we consider implicitly that both carrier types are affected by the same impurities , and the matrix element is independent of @xmath100 for short - range impurity scattering .
apart from atomic defects , screened coulomb - type impurities approximately fulfill this condition , as it may be seen within the thomas - fermi ( tf ) approximation .
indeed , the screening length of the coulomb interaction is dominated by the thomas - fermi wave vector @xmath101 m@xmath102 of the massive carriers , for an effective bohr radius @xmath103 , whereas the thomas - fermi wave vector for massless dirac carriers @xmath104 m@xmath102 , for a density @xmath105 cm@xmath102 and a fine - structure constant @xmath107 .
the thomas - fermi wave vector is thus roughly one order of magnitude larger than the fermi wave vector of the massive carriers , which is itself much larger than that of the dirac carriers .
the screened coulomb potential for @xmath100-type carriers may therefore be approximated by its @xmath108 value , @xmath109 , which is thus the same for both carrier types , as mentioned above .
here , @xmath110 is the permittivity of the dielectric environment and @xmath111 is the dielectric function calculated within the thomas - fermi approximation . in view of the above considerations , we thus obtain , for the mobility ratio in the limit @xmath112 @xmath113 which does neither depend on the form of the matrix element nor on the impurity density .
one expects a ratio in the @xmath114 range , whereas the measured ratio is @xmath115 at @xmath116 k. notice that for @xmath62 , that is in the experimentally relevant regime here , one may replace the energy dependence in the density of states of the massless dirac carriers by a linear dependence in temperature , @xmath117 , such that one expects a linear temperature dependence of the mobility ratio ( [ eq : mu ] ) , in agreement with our experimental findings ( @xmath118 for @xmath119 , see fig . [ mobility ] ) .
to conclude , we present an interpretation of magneto - transport in ai3 that indicates that both massive and dirac carriers are present even at high pressures . thermopower measurements performed on one of the three studied samples are also in agreement with this two carrier scenario .
so far in the literature , the conduction in this system has been attributed solely to dirac carriers.@xcite moreover , this coexistence holds with little perturbation in the whole range of pressure under study . as dirac carriers have high mobility , they dominate the conduction at low magnetic field and high temperatures . on the contrary , for high magnetic fields and low temperatures ,
the massive holes drive the conduction properties .
this crossover can be clearly seen from our magneto - conductivity curves and is responsible for their peculiar ` plateau ' shape .
it should also be noted that a proper separation of massive carriers has to be done prior to using any expression that concerns solely dirac carriers . in order to confirm the picture of coexisting dirac and massive carriers , complementary studies , such as spectroscopic measurements ,
are highly desirable but beyond the scope of the present paper .
k. s. novoselov , a. k. geim , s. v. morozov , d. jiang , m. i. katsnelson , i. v. gregorieva , s. v. dubonos , and a. a. firsov , nature * 438 * , 197 ( 2005 ) ; y. zhang , y .- w . tan , h. l. stormer , and p. kim , nature * 438 * 201 , ( 2005 ) .
castro neto , f. guinea , n.m.r .
peres , k.s .
novoselov , and a.k .
geim , rev .
phys * 81 * , 109 ( 2009 ) ; m. o. goerbig rev .
phys * 83 * , 1193 ( 2011 ) ; v. n. kotov , b. uchoa , v. m. pereira , f. guinea , and a. h. castro neto , rev .
* 84 * , 1067 . | transport measurements were performed on the organic layered compound 3 under hydrostatic pressure .
the carrier types , densities and mobilities are determined from the magneto - conductance of 3 .
while evidence of high - mobility massless dirac carriers has already been given , we report here , their coexistence with low - mobility massive holes .
this coexistence seems robust as it has been found up to the highest studied pressure .
our results are in agreement with recent dft calculations of the band structure of this system under hydrostatic pressure .
a comparison with graphene dirac carriers has also been done
. 3 @xmath0 2 @xmath1 |
the unwavering obsession to which the title refers applies only to the first author since the other co - authors are still too young to be obsessed by such a thing as the mass distribution of white dwarf stars . as early as 1976
, it was suggested that below @xmath0 k , convective mixing between the thin superficial hydrogen layer and the more massive underlying helium layer could turn a hydrogen - rich star into a helium - rich star , provided the mass of the hydrogen layer is small enough ( a modern value yields @xmath1 ) .
furthermore , the effective temperature at which this mixing occurs is a function of the mass of the hydrogen layer : for thicker hydrogen layers , the mixing occurs at lower effective temperatures .
since the process of convective mixing is still poorly understood , the exact ratio of helium to hydrogen after the mixing occurs remains unknown .
in particular , it is possible that instead of turning a da star into a featureless helium - rich dc star , convective mixing may simply enrich the hydrogen - rich atmosphere with large quantities of helium , leading to a mixed hydrogen and helium atmospheric composition .
such a hypothesis is difficult to test , however , since helium becomes spectroscopically invisible below @xmath2 k , and its presence can only be inferred through indirect methods . such a method has been proposed by @xcite who showed that the atmospheric helium abundance could be determined from a detailed examination of the high balmer lines , since the presence of helium increases the photospheric pressure , and thus produces a quenching of the upper levels of the hydrogen atom which , in turn , affects the line profiles .
this method has been put forward on a more quantitative basis by @xcite who analyzed 37 cool da stars using the spectroscopic method of fitting high balmer line spectroscopy with the predictions of detailed model atmospheres with mixed hydrogen and helium compositions .
their analysis first showed that the effects produced on the hydrogen lines at high @xmath3 could not be distinguished from those produced by the presence of large amounts of helium .
hence , the problem could only be approached from a statistical point of view by assuming a mean value of @xmath4 for all stars , and then by determining individual helium abundances . under this assumption , the analysis of bergeron et al
. revealed that the atmospheres of most objects below @xmath5 k were contaminated by significant amounts of helium , with abundances sometimes as high as @xmath6 .
we show in figure 1 an update of this result using a sample of 232 da stars analyzed with our most recent grid of model atmospheres . on the left panel
we show the surface gravity as a function of effective temperature for each object .
clearly , the values determined here are significantly higher than the canonical value of @xmath4 for da stars ( shown by the dashed line ) ; the mean surface gravity of this sample is actually @xmath7 .
if we assume instead that our sample is representative of other da stars and adopt @xmath4 for each object , we can determine individual helium abundances .
this is shown on the right panel of figure 1 . as can be seen
, non - negligible amounts of helium in the range @xmath8 at the surface of these da stars can easily account for the high @xmath3 values inferred under the assumption of pure hydrogen compositions .
( right panel).,height=245 ]
the results discussed above rest heavily on the abililty of the models to describe accurately the physical conditions encountered in cool white dwarf atmospheres , but also on the reliability of the spectroscopic method to yield accurate measurements of the atmospheric parameters .
it is with this idea in mind that ( * ? ? ?
* bsl hereafter ) decided to test the spectroscopic method using da white dwarfs at higher effective temperatures ( @xmath9 k ) where the atmospheres are purely radiative and thus do not suffer from the uncertainties related to the treatment of convective energy transport , and where the assumption of a pure hydrogen composition is certainly justified . from the analysis of a sample of 129 da stars
, bsl determined a mean surface gravity of @xmath10 , in much better agreement with the canonical value of @xmath4 for da stars .
k ( solid line ; left axis ) compared with that of 54 db and dba stars above @xmath11 k ( hatched histogram ; right axis ) . the average masses are 0.585 and 0.598 @xmath12 , respectively . ]
more recently , @xcite obtained high signal - to - noise spectroscopy of all 348 da stars from the palomar green survey and determined the atmospheric parameters for each object using nlte model atmospheres .
if we restrict the range of effective temperature to @xmath13 k , the mean surface gravity of their sample is @xmath14 , in excellent agreement with the results of bsl .
the corresponding mean mass for this sample is @xmath15 using evolutionary models with thick hydrogen layers . as part of our ongoing survey aimed at defining more accurately the empirical boundaries of the instability strip ( see gianninas , bergeron , & fontaine , these proceedings ) , we have been gathering for several years optical spectroscopy of da white dwarfs from the mccook & sion catalog using the steward observatory 2.3 m telescope facility .
the mass distribution for the 667 da stars above 13,000 k is displayed in figure 2 , together with the mass distribution for 54 db and dba stars taken from @xcite ; for the latter , uncertainties with the line broadening theory of helium lines limits the accuracy of the spectroscopic method to @xmath16 k. both mass distributions are in excellent agreement .
the results discussed in the last section indicate that the atmospheric parameters of hot ( @xmath13 k ) da stars are reasonable , and that the high @xmath3 values obtained for cool da stars are not related directly to the spectroscopic method itself .
one of the largest uncertainties in cool white dwarf atmospheres is the treatment of convective energy transport . in an effort to parameterize the convective efficiency in da stars
, @xcite studied a sample of 22 zz ceti stars and showed that the so - called ml2/@xmath17 version of the mixing - length theory yields the best internal consistency between optical and uv effective temperatures , trigonometric parallaxes , @xmath18 magnitudes , and gravitational redshift measurements .
the mass vs. temperature distribution for our complete sample of da stars using this parameterization is displayed in figure 3 .
the problem with the high masses or high @xmath3 values towards low effective temperatures is clearly apparent here .
however , this increase in mass begins not only where convective mixing is believed to occur , but even in the temperature range where zz ceti stars are found . if the larger - than - average mass for zz ceti stars is explained in terms of helium enrichment from the deeper helium convection zone , the hydrogen layers in zz ceti stars need to be as thin as @xmath19 ( see fig . 4 of dufour & bergeron , these proceedings ) , in sharp contrast with values determined for zz ceti stars from asteroseismology .
further insight into the problem with high masses at low effective temperatures may be gained by comparing the masses inferred from the spectroscopic method with those obtained from other methods , namely from trigonometric parallax and gravitational redshift measurements .
we have thus secured high signal - to - noise spectroscopy for 129 da stars , 92 of which have parallaxes available , and 49 of which have gravitational redshifts . in figure 4
we reproduce the spectroscopic masses as a function of effective temperature for our complete sample of da stars discussed in the previous section , and we overplot in the top and bottom panels the masses derived from trigonometric parallax and gravitational redshift measurements , respectively .
the parallax method relies on optical @xmath20 and infrared @xmath21 photometric measurements to constrain the effective temperature and the solid angle @xmath22 between the flux received at earth and that emitted at the surface of the star .
given the distance @xmath23 obtained from the parallax , we obtain directly the radius @xmath24 and thus the photometric mass using evolutionary models .
one of the most obvious features of the distribution of photometric masses in the top panel of figure 4 is the large number of low mass ( @xmath25 ) white dwarfs .
most of these objects are probably unresolved double degenerates for which the flux received at earth corresponds to the contribution of both stars . hence the radii
are overestimated and the masses are underestimated .
if we ignore these low mass objects , the photometric masses do exhibit higher than average masses when compared with the spectrocopic masses at higher temperatures , which are closer to the canonical value of @xmath26 , although the dispersion of the photometric masses is also significantly larger . in some , but
not all cases , the photometric mass exceeds the spectrocopic mass .
it is then possible to adjust individually the atmospheric helium abundances until both methods yield consistent masses .
since the parallax method uses broadband energy distributions that are not affected significantly by the presence of helium ( * ? ? ?
* fig . 4 ) ,
the photometric masses are almost completely independent of the assumed atmospheric composition , in sharp contrast with the spectroscopic method .
we finally note that in the case of the massive ( @xmath27 ) da star lhs 4033 @xcite , the parallax and spectrosocpic masses agree to within 0.01 @xmath12 . the gravitational redshift method used in the bottom panel of figure 4
is based on the relation between the measured redshift velocity , the mass @xmath28 , and the radius @xmath24 of the star , @xmath29 .
this method provides mass measurements that are almost completely independent of anything else , although the velocity measurements are intrinsically more difficult to obtain than the other types of measurements used with other techniques . in particular , since the redshift mass measurements scale linearly with velocity , low mass white dwarfs are intrisically more difficult to measure , and the errors are correspondingly larger .
nevertheless , if we take at face value the results shown in figure 4 , the redshift masses do not reveal any particular trend at low effective temperatures .
more accurate trigonometric parallax and gravitational redshift measurements of _ individual _ stars may be required , together with some unwavering obsession , to help us further understand the high mass problem observed at low temperatures . | we discuss some of our current knowledge of the mass distribution of da and non - da stars using various methods for measuring white dwarf masses including spectroscopic , trigonometric parallax , and gravitational redshift measurements , with a particular emphasis on the problems encountered at the low end of the cooling sequence where energy transport by convection becomes important . |
imagine a space craft travelling with constant speed along an unknown and possibly quite irregular closed path @xmath15 in an unexplored territory of the universe .
after some time @xmath16 the loop is completed at least once , and the only data the astronauts can measure at time @xmath17 are the ratios of the squared distance from any previous position @xmath18 , to the distance of the current line of direction @xmath19 from that previous position @xmath18 , i.e. , the quotients @xmath20\quad{\,\,\,\text{for } \,\,}s < t.\ ] ] what can the astronauts say about their path of travel ?
in other words , how much information about a closed curve of finite length in euclidean space is encoded in the relative tangent - point data ?
the answer is : if the astronauts obtain a finite integral mean of some inverse power of all these data ( after time @xmath21 ) they can extract essential topological information as well as explicit smoothness properties of their path of travel ! to make this precise we assume from now on that the path @xmath22 is a rectifiable curve of finite length , parametrized by arclength on the circle @xmath23 of perimeter @xmath24 .
hence , @xmath15 is a ( not necessarily injective ) lipschitz continuous mapping with @xmath25 a.e . on @xmath26 .
geometrically , the tangent - point function @xmath27 involving the tangent line @xmath28 and defined for all @xmath29 and almost all @xmath30 , determines the radius of the unique circle that is tangent to @xmath15 at the position @xmath31 and passes through @xmath18 .
( this radius is set to be zero if @xmath32 , and is infinite if the vector @xmath33 is parallel to the tangent @xmath34 ) .
the only assumption in the result indicated above is finiteness of the _ tangent - point potential _
@xmath35 [ thm:1.1 ]
if @xmath36 for some @xmath5 then the image @xmath37 is a one - dimensional topological manifold ( possibly with boundary ) , embedded in @xmath38 in particular , the image curve has no self - intersections , although there is no chance to deduce injectivity of the arclength parametrization @xmath15 itself , since the integrand depends only on the image @xmath39 take , for example , a @xmath40-times covered circle of length @xmath41 , for which the integrand is constant , @xmath42 for all @xmath43 , so that the energy amounts to @xmath44 so the space craft s course can not be too wild , since it traces a one - dimensional manifold without any non - tangential self - crossings . but without further input the astronauts have no clue of how often they have completed that course . moreover , in case their path forms a manifold with boundary , say , a circular arc , there would be an abrupt ( and for the crew probably quite noticeable ) change of direction at the endpoints of that arc .
mathematically , one can easily reparametrize the manifold to obtain a new injective arclength parametrization , which translates to the additional information that the spacecraft does not pass by any previous position at all , @xmath45 for all @xmath46 which we will assume from now on . in light of theorem [ thm:1.1 ]
the tangent - point potential @xmath0 evaluated on closed curves in @xmath10 may serve as a valid _ knot energy _ as suggested by gonzalez and maddocks in ( * ? ? ?
* section 6 ) , that is , as a functional separating different knot types by infinite energy barriers .
it was shown by sullivan ( * ? ? ?
2.2 ) that for @xmath9 the energy @xmath0 blows up on a sequence of smooth knots converging smoothly to a smooth curve with self - crossings .
( his proof uses the taylor formula up to order two for the converging curves , and a uniform bound for the remainders . ) as a consequence of our analysis we generalize this result to continuous curves replacing smooth convergence by uniform convergence ( see proposition [ self - repulsive ] ) .
thus @xmath0 for @xmath9 is indeed _ self - repulsive _ or _ charge _ , and hence a knot energy according to the definition given by ohara ( * ? ? ?
1.1 ) , which provides an affirmative answer to an open question posed in ( * ? ? ?
* problem 8.1 ) .
it also turns out that @xmath0 is _ strong _ for @xmath9 : among all continuous closed curves @xmath6 of fixed length @xmath24 and @xmath47 there are only finitely many knot types , see proposition [ prop : strong ] .
this gives a partial answer to a conjecture expressed by sullivan in @xcite ( leaving open the case @xmath48 , and we do not consider links with more than one component ) .
both these knot - theoretic results are based on a priori @xmath49-estimates for curves of finite @xmath0-energy , discussed in more detail later on .
we will show in addition that two curves , whose hausdorff - distance is bounded above by an explicit small constant depending only on the energy values , are in fact in the same knot class .
a qualitative version of such an isotopy result is well - known in the smooth category ; see e.g. ( * ? ? ?
* chapter 8) , or @xcite .
here , however , we have explicit quantitative bounds .
notice also that hausdorff - distance alone , no matter how small , does not suffice to separate knot classes ; bounded @xmath0-energy is crucial here .
[ thm:1.2 ] for any @xmath9 there is an explicit constant @xmath50 depending only on @xmath11 such that any two closed rectifiable curves with injective arclength parametrizations @xmath51 @xmath52 , with finite @xmath0-energy , are ambient isotopic if their hausdorff - distance is less than @xmath53 our proof of theorem [ thm:1.2 ] follows closely the arguments of marta szumaska who proved in her ph.d .
thesis a similar result ( * ? ? ?
* chapter 5 ) for a related three - point potential , the _ integral menger curvature _ @xmath54 where @xmath55 denotes the circumcircle radius of three points @xmath56 in euclidean space .
essentially one reduces the isotopy question to that between polygons inscribed in @xmath57 and @xmath52 , whose edge lengths are solely controlled in terms of the energy . for polygonal knots a similar result is contained in the work of millet , piatek , and rawdon ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4.2 ) , where instead of , the polygonal thickness of the polygons together with their edge length determines the smallness condition on the hausdorff distance that guarantees isotopy of two polygonal knots . for general curves ,
thickness was defined by gonzalez and maddocks in @xcite as the smallest possible circumcircle radius @xmath58 when evaluated on all triples of distinct curve points .
this concept of thickness was used as a tool in variational applications involving curves and elastic rods subject to various topological constraints ; see e.g. @xcite , @xcite , @xcite@xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and has been studied numerically , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite .
the inverse of thickness of a curve @xmath15 can be obtained as limits @xmath59 for @xmath60 , or @xmath61 for @xmath62 in our papers @xcite we have studied regularizing , self - avoidance and compactness effects of several integral energies , including @xmath63 , which involve , vaguely speaking , various bounds for @xmath64 understood as a function of three variables , including bounds in @xmath65 , in @xmath66 where @xmath67 and @xmath68 ( or vice versa ) , and in spaces that resemble the classic morrey spaces @xmath69 . in each case
we were able to detect similar phenomena : there is a certain limiting exponent for which an appropriate functional is scale invariant , and above this exponent three sorts of effects take place .
first , curves with finite energy have no self - intersections .
second , these energies serve well as knot energies allowing for valuable compactness results for equibounded families of loops in fixed isotopy classes , which is due to the third , the regularizing effect : curves with finite energy are more regular than initially assumed . for the present tangent - point potential @xmath0
we obtain the following regularity theorem , which shows that the astronauts would not experience any sudden change of direction during their travel .
[ thm:1.3 ] if @xmath9 and the arclength parametrization @xmath70 is chosen to be injective , then @xmath15 is continuously differentiable with a hlder continuous tangent , i.e. , @xmath15 is of class @xmath71 more precisely , for each @xmath9 there exist two constants @xmath50 and @xmath72 depending only on @xmath11 such that each injective arclength parametrization @xmath15 with @xmath36 satisfies @xmath73 . the exponent @xmath48 is a limiting one here .
it is relatively easy to use scaling arguments and check that @xmath74 for each @xmath5 when @xmath15 parametrizes a closed polygonal curve , but polygons have finite energy for all @xmath75 .
the resulting hlder exponent @xmath76 is reminiscent of the classic sobolev imbedding theorem in the supercritical case : the domain of integration is two - dimensional , and the integrand is related to curvature . for @xmath77-curves the behaviour of @xmath78 close to the diagonal of @xmath79 ( where @xmath78 might blow up for curves with low regularity ) encodes some information about curvature , i.e. about second derivatives of the arclength parametrization @xmath15 .
the point is that we need no information about the existence of @xmath80 in order to prove theorem [ thm:1.3 ] .
a priori , we deal with curves that are rectifiable only , and even the existence of @xmath81 at all parameters can not be taken for granted .
note that inequality is qualitatively optimal : for curves of class @xmath82 the integrand @xmath78 is bounded , and yields then @xmath83 . before describing the main ideas of the proof and the structure of the paper we would like to mention that
while working on generalizations of self - avoidance energies to surfaces in @xmath84 , see @xcite , which involved a search for suitable integrands , we have realized that @xmath0 is a model energy that might be the easiest one to extend to the fully general case , i.e. to submanifolds of arbitrary dimension and co - dimension @xcite .
this was one of the motivations to write the present note : to lay out in a simple , relatively easily tractable case all the arguments that should be applicable in much greater generality .
theorem [ thm:1.1 ] is obtained as a corollary of a slightly more general result , see theorem [ beta - mfd ] below .
we first prove a technical lemma ( see section [ beta - section ] ) which shows how @xmath0 can be used to control the behaviour of the so - called p. jones _ @xmath85-numbers _ , @xmath86 for small @xmath87 and closed balls @xmath88 of radius @xmath3 with center @xmath89 .
it turns out that if @xmath90 then @xmath91 as @xmath92 uniformly with respect to @xmath89 , see lemma [ lem:2.3 ] and the remark at the end of section [ beta - section ] . and
this is the key point to prove that @xmath93 is a topological manifold , as we have the following . [ beta - mfd ] if @xmath94 is arclength , and the image @xmath95 satisfies @xmath96 where @xmath97\to { { { \mathbb r}}}$ ] is a continuous nondecreasing function with @xmath98 , then @xmath6 is a one - dimensional submanifold of @xmath99 ( possibly with boundary ) .
the main idea behind the proof of theorem [ beta - mfd ] is simple : if the result were false , then we could find a point @xmath89 in @xmath6 where a _
triple junction _ occurs ; in a small ball @xmath100 centered at @xmath89 we would have ( at least ) three disjoint arcs of @xmath6 in a long narrow tube .
two of them would then be very close ( i.e. , would leave @xmath100 crossing @xmath101 in the same spherical cap at one end of the tube ) . observing points of those two arcs , and using on smaller and smaller scales
, we are able to obtain a contradiction and eventually show that there could be no triple junction at @xmath89
. for details , see section [ image ] . by the preliminary results of section [ beta - section ] , if @xmath36 for some @xmath9 , then the control of @xmath85 numbers is much better than just .
namely , @xmath102 for @xmath103 ; the constant in depends on @xmath104 .
applying iteratively , we find in section [ diff ] suitably defined cones that contain short arcs of @xmath6 and obtain an estimate for their opening angles , proving that @xmath81 exists everywhere and is of class - dimensional set @xmath105 that is _ reifenberg flat with vanishing constant _ uniform estimates of @xmath85-numbers imply that @xmath106 is a @xmath107-manifold , see david , kenig and toro @xcite and preiss , tolsa and toro @xcite . here
, we have no reifenberg flatness a priori in general rectifiable curves do not have to be reifenberg flat ; in fact we prove it by hand , using energy bounds leading to . ]
@xmath108 .
section [ sec:5 ] contains the proof of the isotopy result , theorem [ thm:1.2 ] . in the last section
we show how to bootstrap the initial gain of @xmath107-regularity obtained in section [ diff ] , to the optimal regularity @xmath109 , and we will establish .
we stress the fact that inequality in theorem [ thm:1.3 ] provides a uniform a priori estimate .
this can be used in variational applications and to ensure compactness for infinite families of curves with uniformly bounded energy .
some results of that type have been stated in @xcite ; we do not follow that thread here .
finally , let us say that , at the moment , we have no clue how @xmath81 behaves in the limiting case @xmath48 ( we do not even know if it is defined everywhere for curves with finite @xmath110-energy ) but we are tempted to think that @xmath81 has vanishing mean oscillation for @xmath48 and that local oscillations of the tangent can be controlled by the local energy of the curve .
we write @xmath111 to denote the straight line through two distinct points @xmath112 . if @xmath113 , then , abusing the notation slightly , we write sometimes @xmath114 instead of @xmath115 . for a closed set @xmath116 in @xmath99 we set @xmath117 in some places
, it will be more convenient to work directly with the slabs @xmath118 around appropriately selected lines than to deal with the information expressed only in the language of @xmath85-numbers .
finally , in section [ diff ] we work with cones . for @xmath119 and @xmath120
we denote by @xmath121 the double cone whose vertex is at the point @xmath89 , with cone axis passing through @xmath122 , and with opening angle @xmath123 .
all balls @xmath88 with radius @xmath87 and center @xmath124 are closed balls throughout the paper .
[ beta ] let @xmath104 be finite .
there exists a constant @xmath125 such that if @xmath126 and @xmath127 satisfy @xmath128 then for every two points of the curve such that @xmath129 we have @xmath130 in particular , @xmath131 for @xmath9 we set @xmath132 .
there exists a @xmath133 such that if @xmath134 , then @xmath135 * proof of lemma [ beta ] . * for @xmath136 , @xmath137 and @xmath138 small , we set @xmath139\}\ , , \\ n_d(s , t,{\epsilon } ) & : = & a_d(s,{\epsilon } ) \setminus x_d(s , t,{\epsilon})\ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that @xmath140 .
the proof has two steps : * we use the inequality @xmath141 to show that @xmath142 must be a small subset of @xmath143 , so that @xmath144 ; * we argue by contradiction , using energy estimates again , and show the desired inclusion .
* step 1 . * fix @xmath145 and @xmath146 . we shall show that @xmath147 . since @xmath148 , the triangle inequality yields @xmath149 let @xmath150 then @xmath151 and @xmath152 by the triangle inequality . by definition of @xmath142 , the angle @xmath153 is contained between @xmath154 and @xmath155 .
therefore @xmath156 and @xmath157 ( here we use @xmath126 ) .
combining and , we obtain @xmath158 integration gives @xmath159 as @xmath160 . if @xmath161 , then @xmath162 which gives a contradiction for an appropriate choice of @xmath163 in the lemma .
thus , we have @xmath164 .
fix a @xmath165 .
since then @xmath166 and the ( acute ) angle between the vectors @xmath167 and @xmath168 is very close to @xmath169 or @xmath170 ( the difference is at most @xmath154 ) , one can check that in fact @xmath171 therefore the distance from @xmath172 to @xmath173 is at least @xmath174 . if @xmath175 , then @xmath176 and @xmath177 integrating this inequality , we obtain @xmath178 again , for an appropriate choice of @xmath179 this gives a contradiction with .
@xmath180 since the assumption @xmath9 was not used at all in the proof of the lemma , it is easy to check that the same reasoning that was used to obtain gives in fact the following [ lem:2.3 ] assume that @xmath48 and @xmath90 .
then there exists a constant @xmath181 such that @xmath182 where @xmath183 the supremum being taken over all pairs of subsets @xmath184 with @xmath185 . * remark . * by the absolute continuity of the integral , this lemma implies that every curve with finite @xmath110 energy satisfies the assumptions of theorem [ beta - mfd ] .
this section is devoted to the proof of theorem [ beta - mfd ] .
we will argue by contradiction .
the proof has two steps ; one of them has preparatory topological character and the second one shows how to use the assumption on the uniform decay of @xmath85 s .
* proof of theorem [ beta - mfd ] .
* we recall the assumption of the theorem that the arclength parametrization @xmath70 with image @xmath93 satisfies for some continuous nondecreasing function @xmath186\to{{\mathbb r}}$ ] with @xmath187 in addition , however , we assume that @xmath6 is neither homeomorphic to the unit circle @xmath7 nor to the unit interval @xmath188 $ ] . our goal is to show that this leads to a contradiction . * step 1 .
triple junctions . *
* claim : * _ there exists a triple junction @xmath189 , i.e. there are three closed sets @xmath190 , @xmath191 such that @xmath192 is a continuous image of the unit interval with @xmath193 for @xmath191 and such that @xmath194 _ * remark .
* we allow the @xmath192 to have self - intersections , i.e. we do not require @xmath192 to be a homeomorphic image of the interval .
moreover , more than three arcs of the curve may meet at @xmath89 ; we just need three of them to obtain the desired contradiction in step 2 in order to complete the proof of theorem [ beta - mfd ] .
* proof of the claim .
* we consider two distinct cases . * case 1 . *
suppose that @xmath6 contains a proper closed subset @xmath195 that is homeomorphic to @xmath7 .
take a point @xmath196 , @xmath197 .
suppose w.l.o.g .
that @xmath198 for some @xmath199 , @xmath200 $ ] ( otherwise just reverse the parametrization ) .
let @xmath201 it is easy to see that @xmath202 is a triple junction ; two of the arcs @xmath192 of @xmath6 are contained in @xmath195 and the third one joins @xmath203 to @xmath89 . * case 2 .
* suppose that case 1 fails and @xmath6 contains no proper closed subset homeomorphic to @xmath7 .
consider the family of all proper subarcs of @xmath6 , @xmath204 which is partially ordered by inclusion .
we will prove in detail below that every chain in @xmath205 has an upper bound in @xmath205 , so that by the kuratowski zorn lemma @xmath205 has a maximal element , @xmath206 .
we have @xmath207 , as @xmath6 is not homeomorphic to @xmath8 by assumption .
now , take a point @xmath208 , @xmath197 , and proceed like in case 1 joining @xmath122 with an arc to a point @xmath209 notice that @xmath89 can not be an endpoint of @xmath206 , since this would contradict the maximality of @xmath206 .
it remains to be shown that every chain in @xmath205 indeed has an upper bound in @xmath205 , which is obvious for any finite chain .
for an infinite chain @xmath210 where the index may be chosen to coincide with the length of the respective arc , @xmath211 for @xmath212 , i.e. where the index set @xmath106 is a ( in general uncountable ) subset of @xmath213 $ ] , we can choose a nondecreasing sequence of indices @xmath214 with @xmath215 , @xmath216 and @xmath217 $ ] .
has positive diameter , otherwise the claim is trivially true .
] now continuously extend the corresponding nested injective arclength parametrizations @xmath218\to{{\mathbb r}}^n\quad\textnormal{with $ \gamma_i([-l_i/2,l_i/2 ] ) = \gamma_i$\ , and $ \gamma_{i+1}|_{[-l_i/2,l_i/2]}=\gamma_i$ for all $ i\in{{\mathbb n}}$}\ ] ] by virtue of @xmath219 \end{cases}\ ] ] to all of @xmath220.$ ] since @xmath221 for all @xmath222 $ ] , @xmath223 , we obtain the uniform bound @xmath224,{{\mathbb r}}^n)}\le c$ ] for all @xmath225 which implies by the theorem of arzela - ascoli that some subsequence @xmath226 converges to some curve @xmath227,{{\mathbb r}}^n)$ ] uniformly on @xmath220.$ ] for distinct parameters @xmath228 one can find @xmath229 such that for all @xmath230 we have @xmath231 so that by @xmath232 which means that @xmath15 is injective , hence a homeomorphism on the open interval @xmath233 .
but if @xmath234 were equal to @xmath172 for some @xmath235 then the arc @xmath236)$ ] would be homeomorphic to @xmath7 which would contradict our assumption that @xmath6 is neither homeomorphic to @xmath7 nor contains a proper closed subset homeomorphic to @xmath7 .
the same contradiction would occur if @xmath237 for some @xmath238.$ ] hence @xmath239)$ ] is homeomorphic to the unit interval @xmath8 , that is @xmath240 .
finally @xmath241 is maximal for the chain @xmath242 .
indeed , if @xmath243 then @xmath241 is the desired upper bound because for @xmath244 it can not be that @xmath245 is contained in @xmath246 , so that total ordering in the chain implies that @xmath247 . if @xmath248 , on the other hand , we have @xmath244 for any @xmath249 which implies that the corresponding arc @xmath246 is contained in one of the @xmath250 for @xmath251 sufficiently large , and hence also @xmath252 the proof of our claim on the existence of ( at least one ) triple junction is complete now .
* step 2 . tilting tubes . *
we now fix a point @xmath253 that is a triple junction , and a small distance @xmath254 , @xmath255 where @xmath192 denote the closed , connected subsets of @xmath6 satisfying above .
let @xmath256 for @xmath257 $ ] .
shrinking @xmath254 if necessary , we can ensure the initial smallness condition @xmath258 rotating and translating the coordinate system in @xmath99 , we can assume without loss of generality that @xmath259 and select the three distinct points @xmath260 where @xmath261 .
assumption implies now @xmath262 the intersection of the sphere @xmath263 with the tube @xmath264 consists of two symmetric spherical caps ; by dirichlet s pigeon - hole principle , one of these caps must contain two of the three distinct points @xmath265 .
renumbering the @xmath192 and @xmath265 if necessary , we may assume that @xmath266 is as above and @xmath267 with @xmath268 and @xmath269 , @xmath270 .
let @xmath271 and @xmath272 .
fix a point @xmath273 . from now on
, we will work only with @xmath274 and @xmath275 . proceeding inductively
, we shall define a sequence of distances @xmath276 , unit vectors @xmath277 , linear @xmath278-dimensional subspaces @xmath279 and points @xmath280 such that @xmath281 as @xmath276 and @xmath282 as @xmath283 , this will yield @xmath284 , a contradiction .
the distances @xmath285 , auxiliary vectors @xmath277 and hyperplanes @xmath279 will be defined in such a way that for all @xmath286 @xmath287 for @xmath288 we shall also show that @xmath289 for each @xmath286 .
notice that in connection with the initial smallness condition will yield @xmath276 as @xmath290 we begin the construction for @xmath291 .
select @xmath292 , @xmath293 .
such a point exists since @xmath274 joins @xmath294 to @xmath295 and by continuity must intersect all planes @xmath296 , @xmath297 , while staying in the tube @xmath298 . let @xmath299 , @xmath300 , and @xmath301 .
note that @xmath302 by construction .
set @xmath303 .
we already have for @xmath291 ; condition for @xmath291 follows directly from . to obtain for @xmath291 ,
we just use and continuity .
assume now that @xmath285 , @xmath277 , @xmath304 , @xmath305 , and @xmath306 have already been defined for @xmath307 so that are satisfied for all @xmath308 .
we use for @xmath309 to select a point @xmath310 , @xmath311 clearly , @xmath312 ( the second estimate is a simple application of the triangle inequality ) .
thus , @xmath313 satisfies for @xmath314 , and choosing @xmath315 we also have for @xmath314 .
again , for @xmath314 follows from the assumption on the decay of @xmath85 s .
thus , the intersection @xmath316 , @xmath317 ; combining these inclusions with and with continuity , we obtain for @xmath314 .
this completes the inductive construction .
now , using for @xmath318 , we select for each @xmath319 a point @xmath320 by definition of @xmath321 , does hold .
this completes the whole proof of theorem [ beta - mfd ] .
throughout this section , we fix @xmath9 and consider a rectifiable curve @xmath93 whose arclength parametrization @xmath15 is injective on @xmath26 . the first step towards the proof of theorem [ thm:1.3 ] is to establish the following .
[ prop:5.1 ] let @xmath9 .
assume that @xmath322 is injective and @xmath323 .
then @xmath81 is well defined everywhere and @xmath324 for @xmath325 . moreover there
exist two positive constants @xmath326 , @xmath327 such that whenever @xmath328 and @xmath329 satisfy @xmath330 , then @xmath331 and we have @xmath332 * proof . *
the argument is in fact similar to the proof of corollary 2.6 and theorem 2.10 in @xcite .
we just sketch the main points , leaving ( relatively easy ) computational details as an exercise .
fix @xmath333 with @xmath334 * step 1 . * for @xmath335 set @xmath336 , and select points @xmath337 so that @xmath338 .
let @xmath339 so that condition of lemma [ beta ] is satisfied for @xmath340 and @xmath341 . the lemma yields
@xmath342 so that the lines @xmath343 satisfy @xmath344 thus , @xmath345 . using and summing
a geometric series ( here the assumption @xmath9 is crucial ! ) , we obtain @xmath346 where @xmath347 .
now , to guarantee @xmath348 , one just assumes that @xmath349 is sufficiently small , i.e. @xmath350 with @xmath351 . by induction , @xmath352 passing to the limit @xmath353 , we obtain @xmath354 with @xmath355 defined by .
* step 2 . *
reversing the roles of @xmath89 and @xmath122 we obtain @xmath356 where @xmath357 is defined by ; this is the desired condition . * step 3 . *
assume now that @xmath15 is differentiable at @xmath358 and @xmath17 and recall that @xmath15 was supposed to be injective .
condition yields then @xmath359 ( note that the difference quotients of @xmath15 at @xmath358 and @xmath17 must belong to cones with vertices at @xmath169 , axis parallel to @xmath360 and opening angle given by )
. * step 4 . * since @xmath15 is differentiable everywhere , and @xmath25 a.e .
, gives on a ( dense ) set of full measure .
thus , @xmath81 has a continuous extension @xmath116 to all of @xmath26 ; one easily checks that in fact @xmath361 _ everywhere_. finally , assuming without loss of generality that @xmath362 , we estimate @xmath363 } ( to check the last inequality , let @xmath364 be the closed slab bounded by two planes passing through @xmath89 and @xmath122 , and perpendicular to @xmath365 , i.e. to the common axis of the two cones , and note that for each @xmath366 $ ] we have in fact @xmath367 .
this follows from the bound @xmath368 , injectivity of @xmath15 and .
thus , for each such @xmath369 we also have @xmath370 . )
the bi - lipschitz condition follows .
the proof of proposition [ prop:5.1 ] is complete now .
( see also ( * ? ? ?
* proof of thm .
2.10 ) where a similar scheme of reasoning is used . )
we start this section with the observation that @xmath0 is repulsive ( or charge ) , that is , @xmath0 blows up on a sequence of knots converging uniformly to a limit curve with self - crossings . [ self - repulsive ] if @xmath70 is a closed arclength parametrized curve of length @xmath371 with @xmath372 for different arclength parameters @xmath373 @xmath374 and if there is a sequence of rectifiable closed injective curves @xmath375 converging uniformly to @xmath15 , then @xmath376 as @xmath377 for any @xmath378 proof:1.1emassume to the contrary that ( for a suitable subsequence ) @xmath379 we set @xmath380),{\mathop{\rm diam}\nolimits}\gamma(s_l\setminus [ s , t ] ) , \delta_2(q)e^{\frac{-1}{q-2}}\big\}>0,\ ] ] where @xmath326 is the constant of proposition [ prop:5.1 ] , and choose @xmath381 and @xmath382 $ ] such that @xmath383)\quad{\,\,\,\text{and } \,\,}\quad for sufficiently large @xmath384 we find @xmath385 for all @xmath386 in particular , by , @xmath387)-\frac { \epsilon}5\overset{\eqref{eps}}{\ge}\frac 45 { \epsilon } , \notag\\ \label{lb } \\
\textnormal{and , analagously,\,\ , } & & |\gamma_k(\sigma)-\gamma_k(s)|\ge \frac 45 { \epsilon } , \notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] but @xmath388 hence , we can apply of proposition [ prop:5.1 ] to obtain the inclusion @xmath389 since there is an integer @xmath390 such that @xmath391 for all @xmath392 we know that the corresponding injective arclength parametrizations @xmath393 are continuously differentiable according to proposition [ prop:5.1 ] , so that the points @xmath394 and @xmath395 must be connected by a subarc of @xmath396 that is completely contained in the doubly conical region @xmath397 of diameter @xmath398 ( otherwise , the unit tangent vector of the arclength parametrization @xmath393 would jump at @xmath394 and @xmath395 contradicting @xmath399-smoothness for @xmath392 . ) since all @xmath396 are simple , either the point @xmath400 , or @xmath401 lies on that connecting arc within @xmath402 , thus contradicting the lower bound @xmath403 in .
+ [ prop : strong ] if @xmath9 , then the @xmath0-energy is _ strong _ in the following sense : for each @xmath404 and @xmath16 there are at most finitely many knot types which have a representative @xmath6 such that @xmath405 * remark . *
the length constraint @xmath406 is necessary here , since by rescaling an arbitrary smooth simple curve we can make its @xmath0-energy as small as one wishes .
an alternative would be to consider @xmath407 .
this is a scale invariant energy .
* we argue by contradiction .
assume there are infinitely many knot types of length @xmath24 with the same energy bound , and by translational invariance we can assume moreover that all these knots contain the origin .
take their arclength representatives @xmath226 , @xmath408 and use inequality of proposition [ prop:5.1 ] to conclude that the family @xmath409 is eqicontinuous . invoking the arzela ascoli compactness theorem and passing to a subsequence , we may assume that @xmath226 converges in the @xmath399-topology to some limit @xmath410 .
let @xmath6 be the curve parametrized by @xmath15 .
we next check that @xmath6 is simple , i.e. @xmath15 is injective on @xmath411 . to this end , we shall rely on proposition [ prop:5.1 ] to prove that there exists an @xmath412 such that all @xmath226 satisfy @xmath413 upon passing to the limit @xmath414 , this implies the injectivity of @xmath15 .
all @xmath415 with @xmath416 sufficiently large are contained in a small @xmath399 neighbourhood of @xmath6 .
thus , according to a known isotopy result , see e.g. ( * ? ? ?
* chapter 8) or @xcite , they would all have to be of the same knot type , thereby contradicting the assumption that each @xmath415 is in a different isotopy class . to complete the proof
, it is now enough to prove .
consider @xmath417 given by @xmath418 by proposition [ prop:5.1 ] the @xmath226 are uniformly bounded in @xmath107 , where @xmath419 .
thus , it is easy to show that there is a constant @xmath420 such that @xmath421 since @xmath422 such that @xmath423 now , we either have @xmath424 in which case implies @xmath425 or , by minimality , we have @xmath426 , which is equivalent to @xmath427 fix @xmath416 .
let @xmath428 . if @xmath429 where @xmath326 stands for the constant from proposition [ prop:5.1 ] , then , by and of that proposition , we have @xmath430 and @xmath431 the last condition , however , clearly contradicts .
hence , @xmath432 summarizing , and , we obtain with @xmath433 . @xmath180 now we present the proof of the isotopy result , theorem [ thm:1.2 ] .
the proof consists of two steps .
the first one , see proposition [ poly-1 ] below , is preparatory : we use proposition [ prop:5.1 ] to show that a curve @xmath6 of length @xmath24 and finite energy at most @xmath434 is ambient isotopic to a polygonal line that has roughly @xmath435 vertices , all of them belonging to @xmath6 . in the second step ,
we replace two curves that are close in hausdorff distance by polygonal curves ( staying in the same knot class ) and exhibit a series of @xmath436 and @xmath437-moves transforming one of them into the other one .
( the proof that we present gives a value of @xmath438 which is far from optimal ; we do not know how to obtain a sharp result of that type . ) before passing to the details , let us recall a definition , see e.g. ( * ? ? ?
* chapter 1 ) .
let @xmath439 be one of the segments of a polygonal knot @xmath6 in @xmath10 and let @xmath440 be a triangular surface bounded by the segments @xmath441 such that @xmath442 .
we say that @xmath443 _ results from @xmath6 by a @xmath436-move_. the inverse operation is called a _
@xmath437-move_. let @xmath195 and @xmath444 be two polygonal knots in @xmath445 if @xmath195 can be obtained from @xmath444 by a finite sequence of @xmath436 and @xmath437-moves , then one says that @xmath195 and @xmath444 are _ combinatorially equivalent_. two polygonal knots @xmath195 and @xmath444 are ambient isotopic if and only if they are combinatorially equivalent , see ( * ? ? ? * chapter 1 ) .
[ poly-1 ] let @xmath9 .
assume that @xmath446 is injective and @xmath447 .
let @xmath448 be the constant defined in proposition [ prop:5.1 ] .
then @xmath93 is ambient isotopic to the polygonal curve @xmath449\ ] ] with @xmath450 vertices @xmath451 , whenever the parameters @xmath452 and @xmath453 are chosen on @xmath26 so that @xmath454 we denote the closed halfspace @xmath455 we shall work with ` double cones ' @xmath456 for sake of brevity , set @xmath457 and @xmath458 .
we are going to use proposition [ prop:5.1 ] to verify two properties of @xmath459 .
* claim 1 .
* _ for each @xmath460 the intersection of @xmath6 and the two - dimensional disk @xmath461 contains precisely one point . if @xmath462 , then this point of @xmath6 is in the interior of @xmath459 . _ indeed , note first that @xmath463 is nonempty , as an arc of @xmath6 joining @xmath464 with @xmath465 must be contained in @xmath459 since if this were not the case , then of proposition [ prop:5.1 ] would be impossible for an injective and differentiable @xmath15 .
if there were two distinct points @xmath466 , then could not hold both for the couple @xmath467 , and for the couple @xmath468 , simultaneously .
finally , the second statement of claim 1 follows from the fact that inequality is strict .
* claim 2 . *
_ whenever @xmath469 we find that the sets @xmath470 and @xmath471 are disjoint .
_ suppose to the contrary that @xmath472 and assume without loss of generality @xmath473 if @xmath474 were contained in @xmath470 then we would either find that the disk @xmath475 contains two distinct curve points contradicting claim 1 , or that there is a parameter @xmath476 such that @xmath477 although @xmath15 is injective , which is absurd .
the same reasoning can be applied to @xmath478 so that we conclude from and assumptions and that the two tips @xmath479 @xmath480 of @xmath481 are contained in the set @xmath482 defined as @xmath483,\ ] ] which is just the intersection of the two cones within the balls centered in @xmath464 and @xmath465 but without the slab bounded by the two parallel planes @xmath484 and @xmath485 .
we know that @xmath486 since @xmath487 and @xmath15 is injective . if @xmath488 then , , and enforce @xmath489 and @xmath490 which by leads to @xmath491 contradicting unless @xmath492 .
if in the latter case @xmath493 is contained in @xmath494 then we obtain @xmath495 contradicting our assumption . if , on the other hand , @xmath493 is in @xmath496 , it is by actually contained in @xmath497 , but then can not hold .
finally , @xmath498 in combination with also leading to is a contradictory statement , since @xmath499 by .
we are now in the position to define the ambient isotopy between @xmath6 and @xmath500 .
note that @xmath501 given by @xmath502 \cap d_i(\gamma(t ) ) \qquad\mbox{for \ , $ t\in [ t_i , t_{i+1})$ , $ i=1,\ldots , n$}\ ] ] is a well defined homeomorphism , parametrizing @xmath503 .
the desired isotopy @xmath504 \to { { \mathbb r}}^3\ ] ] is equal to the identity on @xmath505 , and on each ` double cone ' @xmath459 it maps each two - dimensional slice @xmath506 , @xmath460 , homeomorphically to itself , keeping the boundary circle of @xmath506 fixed and moving the point @xmath18 along a straight segment on @xmath507 until it hits @xmath508 $ ] .
@xmath180 * proof of theorem [ thm:1.2 ] .
* abbreviate the maximal energy value @xmath509 of the two simple arclength parametrized curves @xmath510 of respective ( and a priori possibly quite different ) lengths @xmath511 , @xmath512 recall the assumption that the two curves are close in hausdorff - distance : @xmath513 fix @xmath514 so that @xmath515 , set @xmath516 and let @xmath517 for @xmath518 , and @xmath519 . by proposition [ poly-1 ]
, @xmath195 is ambient isotopic to the polygonal line @xmath520\ ] ] where @xmath521 .
now , for @xmath522 we set @xmath523 , @xmath524\bigr)\subset\gamma_1 $ ] , and introduce the half - spaces @xmath525 and @xmath526 , which are bounded by affine planes @xmath527 .
consider the tubular regions @xmath528 their union contains @xmath529 ; we clearly have @xmath530 as @xmath531 .
moreover , @xmath532 also when @xmath533 . to see this , we will use proposition [ prop:5.1 ] to prove @xmath534 before doing so , let us conclude from : if there existed a point @xmath535 with @xmath533 , we could find @xmath536 and @xmath537 such that @xmath538 by triangle inequality , a contradiction to . to verify , we repeat the trick that has already been used in the proof of proposition[prop : strong ] .
notice that applied to @xmath57 implies @xmath539 so that the continuously differentiable function @xmath540 given by @xmath541 attains a positive minimum @xmath542 on the compact set @xmath543 , where we set @xmath544 , i.e. , there is a pair of parameters @xmath545 such that @xmath546 for all @xmath547 if @xmath548 we can apply to find @xmath549 if , on the other hand , @xmath550 then by minimality @xmath551 , which implies that both tangents @xmath552 and @xmath553 are perpendicular to the segment @xmath554 thus the intersection @xmath555 can not be contained in the intersection @xmath556 which according to means that @xmath557 establishing also in this case .
assume now that @xmath558 .
we shall prove that @xmath444 is ambient isotopic to @xmath195 ; by the choice of @xmath123 , this will mean that theorem [ thm:1.2 ] holds with @xmath559 .
* _ for each @xmath522 there is a point @xmath560 _ without loss of generality we can assume that the curve @xmath57 is oriented in such a way that @xmath561 that is , each tangent @xmath562 points into the set @xmath563 which readily implies for the hyperplanes @xmath564 , @xmath522 , @xmath565 and similarly @xmath566 .
indeed , according to @xmath567 \subset k_i,\ ] ] which implies that the tangent direction of the curve @xmath57 at @xmath464 can not deviate too much from the straight line through @xmath464 and @xmath465 .
the inequalities in provide a quantified version of this fact . since @xmath568 we find three points @xmath569 if @xmath570 we set @xmath571 , and we are done .
else we know that @xmath572 or that @xmath573 in the first case we will work with the two points @xmath574 and @xmath575 , in the second with @xmath574 and @xmath576 in the same way , so let us assume the second situation @xmath573 we know that @xmath577 since by @xmath578 on the other hand , @xmath574 and @xmath576 are not too far apart , @xmath579 so that we can infer from applied to the points @xmath580 and @xmath581 that @xmath582 we will show that @xmath583 \subset b(x_i,2{\epsilon}).\ ] ] notice that @xmath584 consists of two components , one containing @xmath585 , and the other one containing @xmath586 which implies that the intersection in is not empty .
since @xmath444 connects @xmath574 and @xmath576 by within the set @xmath587 , the inclusion in yields the desired curve point @xmath588 thus proving the claim .
to prove we first estimate the angle @xmath589 by the largest possible angle between a line tangent to both @xmath590 and @xmath591 and the line connecting the centers @xmath592 @xmath465 : @xmath593 so that @xmath594 now , let @xmath595 be the orthogonal projection of @xmath574 onto @xmath596 . since @xmath597 , it is easy to see that @xmath598 where @xmath599 ( see figure 1 below ) , which establishes @xmath600 and hence .
l[0cm]6.5 cm the intersection of the doubly conical region @xmath587 with the plane @xmath596 is contained in the ball @xmath601 . since @xmath602 ,
the curve @xmath444 is ambient isotopic to the polygonal curve @xmath603 $ ] .
to finish the proof of theorem [ thm:1.2 ] , it is now sufficient to check that @xmath604 and @xmath605 are combinatorially equivalent .
since the sets @xmath606 are pairwise disjoint , we have @xmath607.\ ] ] this guarantees that all steps in the construction that follows involve legitimate @xmath436 and @xmath437-moves .
the first step , taking place in @xmath608 , is to replace @xmath609 $ ] by the union of @xmath610 $ ] and @xmath611 $ ] , and then to replace @xmath611 $ ] by the union of @xmath612 $ ] and @xmath613 $ ] .
next we perform one @xmath437 and one @xmath436-move in each of the @xmath614 for @xmath615 , replacing first @xmath616 $ ] and @xmath617 $ ] by @xmath618 $ ] , and next trading @xmath618 $ ] for the union of @xmath619 $ ] and @xmath620 $ ] .
finally , for @xmath621 we perform two @xmath437-moves : first replace @xmath622 $ ] and @xmath623 $ ] by @xmath624 $ ] , and then replace @xmath625 $ ] and @xmath610 $ ] ( which has been added at the very beginning of the construction ) by @xmath626 $ ] .
this concludes the whole proof .
in this section , we show how to derive theorem [ thm:1.3 ] .
the overall idea is similar to the one in ( * ? ? ?
* section 6 ) but here the proof is a little bit less involved .
assume that @xmath15 is 11 , @xmath324 , @xmath627 .
restricting @xmath15 to a sufficiently short interval @xmath8 in @xmath628 $ ] , and rotating the coordinate system if necessary , we may assume that the first component @xmath629 of the tangent vector satisfies @xmath630 on @xmath8 and @xmath631 on @xmath8 for all @xmath632 .
in fact , to achieve such control of @xmath81 on @xmath8 it is enough to assume that @xmath633 for some @xmath634 sufficiently small ; the desired control of @xmath81 follows then from proposition [ prop:5.1 ] .
let @xmath635 ( here , @xmath636 denotes an arbitrary subinterval of @xmath8 ) .
we shall show that for every @xmath637 , @xmath638 , @xmath639 where @xmath640 , @xmath641 is a large number such that @xmath642 , and @xmath643 once is established , we can iterate it to get rid of the first term on the right hand side of and prove that @xmath644 and set @xmath645 \ , \colon { \mathscr{h}}^1(y_1(s))\ge 2|u - v|/n \}\ , , \\
y_1(s ) & : = & \ { t\in [ u , v ] \ , \colon 1/r(\gamma(s),\gamma(t))\ge k_0 |u - v|^{-2/q } \}\ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the reader should think of the parameters in @xmath646 and @xmath647 as ` bad ' ones . here is a word of informal explanation .
suppose that a curve is just @xmath648 for @xmath640 and not smoother , say like the graph of @xmath649 near zero .
we would then expect that a typical point @xmath650 can be roughly at the distance @xmath651 from the tangent line at @xmath652 when @xmath653 or , equivalently for a flat graph over some interval , @xmath654 . but then @xmath78 at these two points would not exceed a constant multiple of @xmath655 by the explicit formula for the radius @xmath3 .
as we know nothing about the existence of @xmath80 , there are no a priori upper bounds for @xmath78 that we might use .
however , it is illustrative to look at the sets of points where the model bound @xmath656 we have @xmath657 so that @xmath658 now , select @xmath659\setminus y_0 $ ] and @xmath660\setminus y_0 $ ] such that @xmath661 by the triangle inequality , @xmath662 and @xmath19 are parallel , we have @xmath663 and there is nothing more to prove . thus , let us assume that @xmath664 and @xmath19 are not parallel and proceed to estimate @xmath665 .
let @xmath666 \setminus \bigl(y_1(s)\cup y_1(t)\bigr ) $ ] . by definition of @xmath667 and choice of @xmath668
, we have @xmath669 if @xmath670 , then by definition of @xmath647 and of the tangent - point radius ( see )
we obtain @xmath671 a similar inequality is satisfied by the distance of @xmath672 to the other line , @xmath19 .
now , let @xmath673 be the two - dimensional plane spanned by the two tangent vectors @xmath674 and @xmath34 .
choose two points @xmath675 and @xmath676 such that @xmath677 and let @xmath678 .
( if @xmath664 and @xmath19 intersect , @xmath679 is their common point ; otherwise , the segment @xmath680 $ ] is perpendicular to each of these two lines and @xmath89 is its midpoint . )
let @xmath681 .
then @xmath682 and let @xmath683 the lines @xmath684 intersect at @xmath685 . note that since @xmath686 is nonempty by , we have in fact by virtue of @xmath687 and @xmath688 thus , @xmath689 therefore , the projection @xmath690 of @xmath691 onto @xmath692 is contained in a rhombus @xmath693 in @xmath692 .
the center of symmetry of @xmath693 is at @xmath89 ; the sides of @xmath693 are parallel to @xmath694 and @xmath695 ; its height equals @xmath696 and its acute angle @xmath697 ( since @xmath630 on @xmath8 , the angle @xmath698 _ is _ acute ) .
the longer half - diagonal @xmath699 of @xmath693 is given by @xmath700 and @xmath701 since @xmath702 , invoking and the triangle inequality we conclude that @xmath703 now , recall that @xmath630 on @xmath8 .
let @xmath704 and @xmath705 .
we then have @xmath706 thus @xmath707 combining two estimates of @xmath708 , and , we obtain @xmath709 .
the proof of the second part of theorem [ thm:1.3 ] is now complete .
* to see that the exponent @xmath14 is indeed optimal and can not be replaced by any larger exponent , we follow the idea given by m. szumaska in her phd thesis @xcite .
one has to fix an arbitrary @xmath710 $ ] and consider @xmath6 that is the graph of @xmath711 say on @xmath712 $ ] .
it is possible to check that @xmath4 is finite ; however , the derivative of the arclength parametrization of @xmath6 is not hlder continuous with any exponent larger than @xmath713 . since @xmath85 can be an arbitrary number in @xmath714 $ ] , the exponent @xmath14 is indeed optimal .
we do not give here the computational details which are somewhat tedious but routine ; one just has to pass from the graph description of @xmath6 to the arclength parametrization and use taylor s formula in estimates .
the key point is that @xmath715 is not hlder continuous with any exponent larger than @xmath713 , due to its behaviour near to 0 .
carlen , m. ; laurie , b. ; maddocks , j.h . ; smutny , j. biarcs , global radius of curvature , and the computation of ideal knot shapes . in : calvo , millett , rawdon , stasiak ( eds . ) _ physical and numerical models in knot theory _ , pp .
series on knots and everything vol .
36 , world scientific , singapore 2005 .
schuricht , f. ; von der mosel , h. euler - lagrange equations for nonlinearly elastic rods with self - contact .
arch . rat .
168 * ( 2003 ) , 3582 .
schuricht , f. ; von der mosel , h. characterization of ideal knots .
calc . var .
partial differential equations * 19 * ( 2004 ) , 281305 .
sullivan , j.m .
approximating ropelength by energy functions . in : calvo , millet , rawdon ( eds . ) _ physical knots : knotting , linking , and folding geometric objects in @xmath10 _ , pp- 181186 .
304 , ams , providence ri 2002 . | we study a two - point self - avoidance energy @xmath0 which is defined for all rectifiable curves in @xmath1 as the double integral along the curve of @xmath2 . here
@xmath3 stands for the radius of the ( smallest ) circle that is tangent to the curve at one point and passes through another point on the curve , with obvious natural modifications of this definition in the exceptional , non - generic cases .
it turns out that finiteness of @xmath4 for @xmath5 guarantees that @xmath6 has no self - intersections or triple junctions and therefore must be homeomorphic to the unit circle @xmath7 or to a closed interval @xmath8 . for @xmath9
the energy @xmath0 evaluated on curves in @xmath10 turns out to be a knot energy separating different knot types by infinite energy barriers and bounding the number of knot types below a given energy value .
we also establish an explicit upper bound on the hausdorff - distance of two curves in @xmath10 with finite @xmath0-energy that guarantees that these curves are ambient isotopic .
this bound depends only on @xmath11 and the energy values of the curves .
moreover , for all @xmath11 that are larger than the critical exponent @xmath12 , the arclength parametrization of @xmath6 is of class @xmath13 , with hlder norm of the unit tangent depending only on @xmath11 , the length of @xmath6 , and the local energy .
the exponent @xmath14 is optimal . |
diffusion in stationary states may be encountered either in equilibrium , where no macroscopic mass or energy fluxes are present in a system of many diffusing particles , or away from equilibrium , where diffusion is often driven by a density gradient between two open segments of the surface that encloses the space in which particles diffuse . in equilibrium states ,
one is interested in the _ self - diffusion _
coefficient @xmath3 , as given by the mean - square displacement ( msd ) of a tagged particle .
this quantity , also called tracer diffusion coefficient , can be measured using e.g. neutron scattering , nmr or direct video imaging in the case of colloidal particles . in gradient - driven non - equilibrium
steady states , there is a particle flux between the boundaries which is proportional to the density gradient .
this factor of proportionality is the so - called transport or collective diffusion coefficient @xmath4 .
often these two diffusion coefficients can not be measured simultaneously under concrete experimental conditions and the question arises whether one can infer knowledge about the other diffusion coefficient , given one of them .
generally , in dense systems these diffusion coefficients depend in a complicated fashion on the interaction between the diffusing particles . in the case of diffusion in microporous media ,
e.g. in zeolites , however , the mean free path of the particles is of the order of the pore diameter or even larger
. then diffusion is dominated by the interaction of particles with the pore walls rather than by direct interaction between particles . in this
dilute so - called knudsen regime neither @xmath3 nor @xmath4 depend on the particle density anymore , but are just given by the low - density limits of these two quantities .
one then expects @xmath3 and @xmath4 to be equal .
this assumption is a fundamental input into the interpretation of many experimental data , see e.g. @xcite for an overview of diffusion in condensed matter systems . not long ago this basic tenet has been challenged by monte - carlo simulation of knudsen diffusion in pores with fractal pore walls @xcite .
the authors of these ( and further ) studies concluded that self - diffusion depends on the surface roughness of a pore , while transport diffusion is independent of it .
in other words , the authors of @xcite argue that even in the low density limit , where the gas particle are independent of each other and interact only with the pore walls , @xmath5 , with a dependence of @xmath3 on the details of the pore walls that @xmath4 does not exhibit .
this counterintuitive numerical finding was quickly questioned on physical grounds and contradicted by further simulations @xcite which give approximate equality of the two diffusion coefficients .
these controversial results gave rise to a prolonged debate which finally led to the consensus that indeed both diffusion coefficients should agree for the knudsen case @xcite .
it has remained open though whether these diffusion coefficients are generally exactly equal or only approximately to a degree depending on the details of the specific setting . a physical argument put forward in @xcite suggests general equality .
to see this one imagines the following _
gedankenexperiment_. imagine one colours in a equilibrium setting of many non - interacting particles some of these particles without changing their properties . at some distance from this colouring region
the colour is removed .
then these coloured particles experience a density gradient just as `` normal '' particles in an open system with the same pore walls would .
since the walls are essentially the same and the properties of coloured and uncoloured particles are the same , the statistical properties of the ensemble of trajectories remain unchanged .
hence one expects any pore roughness to have the same effect on diffusion , irrespective of whether one consider transport diffusion or self - diffusion .
notice , however , that this microscopic argument , while intuitively appealing , is far from rigorous .
first , the precise conditions under which the independence of the diffusion coefficients on the pore surface is supposed to be valid , is not specified .
this is more than a technical issue since one may easily construct surface properties leading to non - diffusive behaviour ( cf .
second , there is no obvious microscopic interpretation or unique microscopic definition of the transport diffusion coefficient for arbitrary surface structures .
@xmath4 is a genuinely macroscopic quantity and a proof of equality between @xmath4 and @xmath3 ( which is naturally microscopically defined through the asymptotic long - time behaviour of the msd ) requires some further work and new ideas .
one needs to establish that on large scales the knudsen process converges to brownian motion ( which then also gives @xmath3 ) .
moreover , in order to compare @xmath4 and @xmath3 one needs a precise macroscopic definition of @xmath4 which is independent of microscopic properties of the system . the first part of this programme is carried out in @xcite .
there we proved the quenched invariance principle for the horizontal projection of the particle s position using the method of considering the environment viewed from the particle .
this method is useful in a number of models related to markov processes in a random environment , cf .
e.g. @xcite .
the aim of this paper is to solve the second problem of defining @xmath4 and proving equality with @xmath3 . as in @xcite
we consider a random tube to model pore roughness .
in contrast to @xcite , we now have to consider tubes of finite extension along the tube contour and introduce open segments at the ends of the tube .
doing this rigorously then clarifies some of the salient assumptions underlying the equality of @xmath4 and @xmath3 .
naturally , since we are in the dilute gas limit , there is no dependence on the particle density in either of the two diffusion constants .
this obvious point has not been controversial and will not be stressed below .
we note that we define @xmath4 through stationary transport in an open system since this is accessible experimentally as well as numerically in monte carlo simulation .
indeed , in the literature that gave rise to the controversy that we address here , this way of defining @xmath4 is used , albeit in a non - rigorous fashion . sticking to this experimentally motivated setting we shall give below a precise definition that can be used to prove rigorously that under rather generic circumstances @xmath6 , which means that both diffusion constants depend on the pore surface in the same way .
as pointed out above , this equality is expected from independence of the particles and the invariance principle for the process and its time - reversed .
however , we could not find a general result applying here , and moreover , as it turns out , the proof is not entirely trivial .
there are some technical difficulties to overcome because the quenched invariance principle of definition [ def_invariance_principle ] below is not very `` strong '' ( there is no uniformity assumption on the speed of convergence as a function of the initial conditions ) and the jumps of the embedded discrete - time billiard are not uniformly bounded .
let us mention here that it is generally difficult to obtain stronger results in the above sense , since the corrector technique , generally used in the proof of quenched central limit theorems for reversible markov processes in random environment , is still not sufficiently well understood . to further illuminate the contents of our results we point out that in a bulk system the equality of the self - diffusion coefficient and the transport diffusion coefficient for the spread of _ equilibrium _ density fluctuations in an infinite system may be taken for granted in the case of particles that have no mutual interaction . hence another way of stating the main conclusion of our work is the assertion that the transport diffusion coefficient as defined here in a stationary _ far - from - equilibrium _ setting coincides with the usual equilibrium transport diffusion coefficient .
we also address finite - size effects coming from the fact that we are dealing with diffusion in a finite , open geometry .
this causes deviations from bulk results for first - passage - time properties if a tagged particle starts its motion close to one boundary . in particular
, we compute the permeation time and the milne extrapolation length that characterizes the survival time of a particle injected at a boundary . as a final introductory remark
, it is worth noting that the case of knudsen gas with the cosine reflection law ( which is the model considered in this paper ) is particularly easy to analyse because the stationary state can be written in an explicit form , cf.theorem [ t_stat_measure ] .
as explained below , this is related to the following facts : ( i ) there is no interaction between particles , ( ii ) for random billiard ( i.e. , a motion of only one particle in a closed domain ) with the cosine reflection law the stationary measure is quite explicit , as shown in @xcite .
similar questions are much more complicated when the explicit form of the stationary state is not known .
this is the general situation for non - equilibrium steady states .
we refer to e.g. the model of @xcite ( a chain of coupled oscillators ) where one resorts to a bound on the entropy production .
this paper is organized in the following way . in section [ s_defin ]
we define the infinite random tube , and then introduce the process we call random billiard . in section [ s_transport ] , we then consider a gas of independent particles with absorption / injection in a finite piece of the random tube , and we formulate our results on the stationary measure for that gas and on the transport diffusion coefficient . in section [ s_perm ] , we go on to formulate first passage time results that concern exit from and crossing of the finite tube by a tagged particle .
the remaining part of the paper is devoted to the proof of our results . in section [ s_pr_prelim ]
we mainly use the reversibility of the process to obtain several technical facts used later . in section [ s_pr_steady ]
we prove the result on the stationary measure of the knudsen gas in the finite tube .
section [ s_pr_trans ] contains the proofs of the results related to the transport diffusion coefficient , and in section [ s_pr_perm ] we prove the results related to the crossing of the finite tube .
naively the transport diffusion coefficient in tube direction @xmath7 may be defined through the diffusion equation for the probability density @xmath8 , where a possible @xmath7-dependence may originate from a spatial inhomogeneity of the tube .
denote by @xmath9 the particle current in the system ; assuming stationarity with a probability density @xmath10 one has @xmath11 . with fixed external densities @xmath12 at @xmath13 and @xmath14 at @xmath15 one
finds by integration @xmath16 with density gradient @xmath17 and @xmath18 . by measuring the current and the boundary densities one
can thus obtain the transport diffusion coefficient without having to determine the local quantity @xmath19 .
this result , however , implies knowledge of the local coarse - grained boundary densities @xmath20 to be able to make any comparison with @xmath3 . in a real experimental setting as well as for a given microscopic model these boundary densities @xmath20 are difficult to obtain . in particular , there is no well - defined prescription where precisely on a microscopic scale these boundary quantities should be measured .
we circumvent the problem of computing these quantities from microscopic considerations by considering the total number of particles in the tube rather than local properties of the boundary region of the tube . together with proving a large - scale linear density profile in a stationary open random tube , one
may then infer the macroscopic density gradient , see the definition ( [ defdtrans ] ) below .
thus one obtains a macroscopic definition of the transport diffusion coefficient which is independent of microscopic details of the model . in order to fix ideas in a mathematically rigorous form we first recall some notations from @xcite .
let us formally define the random tube in @xmath21 , @xmath22 . in this paper
, @xmath23 will always stand for the linear subspace of @xmath21 which is perpendicular to the first coordinate vector @xmath24 , we use the notation @xmath25 for the euclidean norm in @xmath21 or @xmath23 . for @xmath26
let @xmath27 be the open @xmath28-neighborhood of @xmath29 .
define @xmath30 to be the unit sphere in @xmath21 .
let @xmath31 be the half - sphere looking in the direction @xmath32 .
for @xmath33 , sometimes it will be convenient to write @xmath34 , being @xmath35 the first coordinate of @xmath7 and @xmath36 ; then , @xmath37 , and we write @xmath38 , being @xmath39 the projector on @xmath23 .
fix some positive constant @xmath40 , and define @xmath41 let @xmath42 be an open connected domain in @xmath23 or @xmath21 .
we denote by @xmath43 the boundary of @xmath42 and by @xmath44 the closure of @xmath42 .
the random tube is viewed as a stationary and ergodic process @xmath45 , where @xmath46 is a subset of @xmath47 ; cf .
@xcite for a more detailed definition .
we denote by @xmath48 the law of this process ; sometimes we will use the shorthand notation @xmath49 for the expectation with respect to @xmath48 . with a slight abuse of notation ,
we denote also by @xmath50 the random tube itself , where the billiard lives . intuitively , @xmath46 is the `` slice '' obtained by crossing @xmath51 with the hyperplane @xmath52 .
we will assume that the domain @xmath51 is defined in such a way that it is an open subset of @xmath21 , and that it is connected .
we write also @xmath53 for the closure of @xmath51 . in order to define the random billiard correctly , following @xcite , throughout this paper we suppose that @xmath48-almost surely @xmath54 is a @xmath55-dimensional surface satisfying the lipschitz condition .
this means that for any @xmath56 there exist @xmath57 , an affine isometry @xmath58 , a function @xmath59 such that * @xmath60 satisfies lipschitz condition , i.e. , there exists a constant @xmath61 such that @xmath62 for all @xmath63 ; * @xmath64 , @xmath65 , and @xmath66 roughly speaking , lipschitz condition implies that any boundary point can be `` touched '' by a piece of a cone which lies fully inside the tube .
this in its turn ensures that the ( discrete - time ) process can not remain in a small neighborhood of some boundary point for very long time ; in section 2.2 of @xcite one can find an example of a non - lipschitz domain where the random billiard behaves in an unusual way .
we keep the usual notation @xmath67 for the @xmath55-dimensional lebesgue measure on @xmath47 ( usually restricted to @xmath46 for some @xmath35 ) or haar measure on @xmath68 .
we write @xmath69 for the @xmath70-dimensional lebesgue measure in case @xmath71 , and haar measure in case @xmath72 .
also , we denote by @xmath73 the @xmath55-dimensional hausdorff measure on @xmath54 ; since the boundary is lipschitz , one obtains that @xmath73 is locally finite ( cf .
the proof of lemma 3.1 in @xcite ) .
we assume additionally that the boundary of @xmath48-a.e .
@xmath51 is @xmath73-a.e .
_ continuously _ differentiable , and we denote by @xmath74 the set of boundary points where @xmath54 is continuously differentiable . to avoid complications when cutting a ( large ) finite piece of the infinite random tube , we assume that there exists a constant @xmath75 such that for @xmath48-almost all environments @xmath51 we have the following : for any @xmath76 with @xmath77 there exists a path connecting @xmath78 that lies fully inside @xmath51 and has length at most @xmath75 . for all @xmath79 , let us define the normal vector @xmath80 pointing inside the domain @xmath51 .
we say that @xmath81 is _ seen from _
@xmath82 if there exists @xmath83 and @xmath84 such that @xmath85 for all @xmath86 and @xmath87 .
clearly , if @xmath88 is seen from @xmath7 then @xmath7 is seen from @xmath88 , and we write `` @xmath89 '' when this occurs .
next , we construct the knudsen random walk ( krw ) @xmath90 , which is a discrete time markov process on @xmath54 , cf .
section 2.2 of @xcite .
it is defined through its transition density @xmath91 : for @xmath92 @xmath93 where @xmath94 is the normalizing constant , and @xmath95 stands for the indicator function .
this means that , being @xmath96 the quenched ( i.e. , with fixed @xmath51 ) probability and expectation , for any @xmath79 and any measurable @xmath97 we have @xmath98 = { \int\limits}_b k(x , y)\ , d{\nu^\omega}(y).\ ] ] we also refer to the knudsen random walk as the random walk with cosine reflection law , since it is elementary to obtain from that the density of the outgoing direction is proportional to the cosine of the angle between this direction and the normal vector .
[ rem_not_to_infty ] in fact , in the general setting of @xcite , for unbounded domains , one has to consider the following possibility : at some moment the particle chooses the outgoing direction in such a way that , moving in this direction , it never hits the boundary of the domain again , thus going directly to the infinity .
however , it is straightforward to see that , since @xmath99 , in our situation @xmath100-a.s
. this can not happen .
it is immediate to obtain from that @xmath101 is symmetric ( that is , @xmath102 for all @xmath92 ) ; for both the discrete- and continuous - time processes this leads to some nice reversibility properties , exploited in @xcite .
clearly , @xmath91 depends on @xmath51 as well , but we usually do not indicate this in the notations in order to keep them simple . also , let us denote by @xmath103 the @xmath104-step transition density ; clearly , one obtains that @xmath105 is symmetric too for any @xmath106 .
now , we define the knudsen stochastic billiard ( ksb ) @xmath107 , which is the main object of study in this paper .
first , we do that for the process starting on the boundary @xmath54 from the point @xmath108 .
let @xmath109 be the trajectory of the random walk , and define @xmath110 then , for @xmath111 , define @xmath112 in proposition 2.1 of @xcite it was shown that , provided that the boundary satisfies the lipschitz condition , we have @xmath113 @xmath100-a.s . ,
and so @xmath114 is well - defined for all @xmath115 . the quantity @xmath114 stands for the position of the particle at time @xmath116 ; since it is not a markov process by itself , we define also the cdlg version of the motion direction at time @xmath116 : @xmath117 observe that @xmath118 .
recall also another notation from @xcite : for @xmath119 , @xmath120 , define ( with the convention @xmath121 ) @xmath122 so that @xmath123 is the next point where the particle hits the boundary when starting at the location @xmath7 with the direction @xmath124 . of course , we can define also the stochastic billiard starting from the interior of @xmath51 by specifying its initial position @xmath125 and initial direction @xmath126 : the particle starts at the position @xmath125 and moves in the direction @xmath126 with unit speed until hitting the boundary at the point @xmath127 ; then , the previous construction is applied , being @xmath127 the starting boundary point .
we denote by @xmath128 the ( quenched ) law of ksb in the tube @xmath51 starting from @xmath7 with the initial direction @xmath124 .
consider the rescaled projected trajectory @xmath129 of ksb .
[ def_invariance_principle ] we say that the quenched invariance principle holds for the knudsen stochastic billiard in the infinite random tube if there exists a positive constant @xmath130 such that , for @xmath48-almost all @xmath51 , for any initial conditions @xmath131 such that @xmath132 , the rescaled trajectory @xmath133 weakly converges to the brownian motion as @xmath134 . also , for some of our results we will have to make more assumptions on the geometry of the random tube .
consider the following * condition t. * * there exists a positive constant @xmath135 and a continuous function @xmath136 such that @xmath137 * in the case @xmath138 , we assume that there exist @xmath139 such that for all @xmath140 with @xmath141 there exists @xmath142 such that @xmath143 . * in the case @xmath144 , we assume that @xmath145 [ rem_almost_all ] from the fact that @xmath99 and @xmath73-almost all points of @xmath54 belong to @xmath146 , it is straightforward to obtain that for lebesgue@xmath147haar - almost all @xmath148 we have @xmath149 ( see lemma 3.2 ( i ) of @xcite ) .
[ rem_clt ] in the paper @xcite we prove that , if the second moment of the projected jump length with respect to the stationary measure for the environment seen from the particle is finite ( which is true for @xmath138 , but not always for @xmath144 ) , then under certain additional conditions ( related to condition t of the present paper ) , the quenched invariance principle holds for the knudsen stochastic billiard in the infinite random tube , cf .
theorem 2.2 , propositions 2.1 and 2.2 of @xcite .
let us comment more on the above condition t : * in @xcite , instead of the `` uniform dblin condition '' ( ii ) , we assumed a more explicit ( although a bit more technical ) condition p , which implies that ( ii ) holds ( see lemma 3.6 of @xcite ) .
in fact , in the proof of the quenched invariance principle the technical condition of @xcite is used only through the fact that it implies the uniform dblin condition . *
the assumption we made for @xmath144 may seem to be too restrictive . however , is it only a bit more restrictive that the assumption that the random tube does not contain an infinite straight cylinder .
as it was shown in proposition 2.2 of @xcite , if the random tube contains an infinite straight cylinder , then the averaged second moment of the projected jump length is infinite in dimension @xmath150 , and so the ( quenched ) invariance principle can not be valid .
now , let us introduce the notations specific to this paper . consider a positive number @xmath151 ( which is typically supposed to be large ) ;
denote by @xmath152 the part of the random tube @xmath51 which lies between @xmath153 and @xmath151 : @xmath154\}.\ ] ] denote also @xmath155 so that @xmath156 ( see figure [ f_piece_of_tube ] ) . ] observe that @xmath152 can , in fact , consist of several separate pieces , namely , one big piece between @xmath153 and @xmath151 , and possibly several small pieces near the left and the right ends ( we suppose that @xmath157 , so that there could not be two or more big pieces ) . it can be easily seen that those small pieces have no influence on the definition of the transport diffusion coefficient ; for notational convention , we still allow @xmath152 to be as described above .
then , we consider a gas of independent particles in @xmath152 , described as follows .
there is usual reflection on @xmath158 ; any particle which hits @xmath159 , disappears .
in addition , for a given @xmath160 , new particles are injected in @xmath161 with intensity @xmath162 per unit surface area .
every newly injected particle chooses the initial direction at random according to the cosine law .
in other words , the injection in @xmath161 is given by an independent poisson process in @xmath163 with intensity @xmath164 .
[ rem_cosine_chosen ] the choice of the cosine law for the injection of new particles is justified by theorem 2.9 of @xcite : for the ksb in a finite domain , the long - run empirical law of intersection with a @xmath55-dimensional manifold is cosine .
one may think of the following situation : the random tube is connected from its left side @xmath161 to a very large reservoir containing the knudsen gas in the stationary regime ; then , the particles cross @xmath161 with approximately cosine law ( at least on the time scale when the density of the particles in the big reservoir remains unaffected by the outflow through the tube ) . in section [ s_pr_steady ] ( proof of theorem [ t_stat_measure ] )
we use this kind of argument to obtain a rigorous characterization of the steady state of this gas .
we now consider this gas in the stationary regime .
let @xmath165}:=[a , b]\times\xi$ ] , and let @xmath166 be the mean number of particles in @xmath167}$ ] , in a fixed environment @xmath51
. in theorem [ t_dens_grad ] below we shall see that there exists a constant @xmath168 such that @xmath169 which means that , after coarse - graining , the particle density profile is asymptotically linear .
the above quantity @xmath168 is called the ( rescaled ) density gradient .
we define also the current @xmath170 as the mean number of particles absorbed in @xmath171 per unit of time , and let the rescaled current be defined as @xmath172 then , consistently with the discussion in the beginning of this section , the _ transport diffusion coefficient _
@xmath4 is defined by @xmath173 now , suppose that the quenched invariance principle with constant @xmath174 holds for the stochastic billiard .
our goal is to prove that @xmath4 is equal to the _ self - diffusion coefficient _ @xmath175 . to this end , we prove the following two results .
first , we prove that the coarse - grained density profile is indeed linear : [ t_dens_grad ] suppose that the quenched invariance principle holds
. then , for any @xmath176 there exists @xmath177 such that @xmath48-a.s .
@xmath178 then , we calculate the limiting current : [ t_current ] suppose that the quenched invariance principle holds with constant @xmath174 , and assume also that condition t holds .
then , we have @xmath48-a.s . @xmath179 some remarks are in place that illustrate the significance of the above theorems .
theorem [ t_dens_grad ] means that @xmath180 , and using also theorem [ t_current ] , we obtain that @xmath6 . at the same time
it becomes clear that such a statement can be true only asymptotically since in a finite open tube one has to expect finite size corrections of the mean particle number .
these corrections may , in fact , depend strongly on the microscopic shape of the tube near the open boundaries .
this implies that in experiments on real spatially inhomogeneous systems some care has to be taken as to what is measured as macroscopic density gradient .
notice that with theorem [ t_current ] we also prove fick s law for diffusive transport of matter in the random knudsen stochastic billiard . since the velocity of the particles does not change at collisions with the tube walls , mass transport is proportional to energy transport . in this interpretation theorem [ t_current ] implies fourier s law for heat conduction , see e.g. @xcite for recent work on other processes . for a function @xmath181 and @xmath182 ,
denote @xmath183 as mentioned in the introduction , in the proof of theorems [ t_dens_grad ] and [ t_current ] we use the explicit form of the steady state for the knudsen gas in the random tube with injection from one side .
let us formulate the following theorem : [ t_stat_measure ] * for the knudsen gas with absorption / injection in @xmath184 ( as before , with intensity @xmath162 per unit surface area ) the unique stationary state is poisson point process in @xmath185 with intensity @xmath186 .
* for the gas with injection in @xmath161 only , the unique stationary distribution of the particle configuration is given by a poisson point process in @xmath187 with intensity measure @xmath188 \,d\alpha\ , du\ , dh.\ ] ] also , in both cases , for any initial configuration the process converges to the stationary state described above .
of course , the above result is not quite unexpected .
it is well known that independent systems have poisson invariant distributions ( with the single particle invariant measure for poisson intensity ) , let us mention e.g. @xcite ( section viii.5 ) and @xcite .
still , we decided to include the proof of this theorem because ( as far as we know ) , it does not directly follow from any of the existing results available in the literature .
let us introduce some more notations for the finite random tube .
we denote by @xmath189 the set of points of @xmath190 , from where the particle can reach @xmath171 by a path which stays within @xmath152 and set @xmath191 ( see figure [ f_permeation ] ) , and let @xmath192 be the corresponding finite tube .
since we are going to study now how long a tagged particle stays inside the tube and how it crosses ( i.e. , goes to the right boundary without going back to the left boundary ) , the idea is to inject it in a place from where it can actually do it .
our interest is then in certain first - passage properties , in particular , the total life time of the particle inside @xmath193 ( i.e. , the time until the particle first exits @xmath193 ) and the permeation time which the particle needs to first exit @xmath193 at the end of the tube segment `` opposite '' to that where it was injected , i.e. , after crossing the tube . , and the event @xmath194 ( a trajectory crossing the tube is shown ) ] so ,
suppose that one particle is injected ( uniformly ) at random at @xmath195 into the tube @xmath193 ( that is , the starting location has the uniform distribution in @xmath195 , and the direction is chosen according to the cosine law ) , and let us denote by @xmath194 the event that it crosses the tube without going back to @xmath195 , i.e. , @xmath196 ( here , @xmath197 and @xmath198 are , respectively , entrance and hitting times for the discrete - time process , see and for the precise definitions ) . also , define @xmath199 to be the total lifetime of the particle , i.e. , if @xmath114 is the location of the particle at time @xmath116 , then @xmath200 .
first , we calculate the asymptotic behaviour of the quenched and annealed ( averaged ) expectation of @xmath199 : [ t_exp_perm ] suppose that the quenched invariance principle holds with constant @xmath174 .
we have @xmath201 observe that condition t ( i ) implies that @xmath202 is bounded away from @xmath153 , and so @xmath203 . at this point
we remind the reader that here and in the next theorem the expected `` times '' are actually expected lengths of flight , related through the corresponding times through the trivial generic relation _ _ length__@xmath204__velocity__@xmath147_time_. in our knudsen gas we always assume unit velocity @xmath205 so that times can be identified with the appropriate lengths .
to elucidate the physical significance of theorem [ t_exp_perm ] we observe that for usual brownian motion the expected lifetime @xmath206 of particle in an interval @xmath207 $ ] is given by @xmath208 , where @xmath209 is the starting position and @xmath210 is the diffusion coefficient .
so , in particular , for a particle starting at the boundary @xmath211 ( or at @xmath212 ) the expected life time is @xmath153 .
however , in a microscopic model of diffusion in a finite open system , this result can not be expected to be generally valid because of a positive probability that a particle which starts at @xmath213 would escape through the other boundary at @xmath214 .
often it is found empirically that the expected life time can be approximated by @xmath215 with an effective shifted coordinate @xmath216 and effective interval length @xmath217 .
the empirical shift length @xmath218 is known as milne extrapolation length @xcite , for a recent application to diffusion in carbon nanotubes see @xcite . from the definition ( [ milne ] )
one can see that the life time of a particle starting at the origin @xmath213 allows for the computation of the milne extrapolation length through the asymptotic relation @xmath219 provided the diffusion coefficient @xmath210 is known . in a physical system
the milne extrapolation length depends on molecular details of the gas such as type of molecule or temperature , but in a knudsen gas also on the tube surface . in our model the properties of the gas
are encoded in the unit velocity @xmath205 of the particles .
observe now that the quantity @xmath220 corresponds to @xmath221 in our setting .
hence , by identifying @xmath222 and using @xmath223 , theorem [ t_exp_perm ] furnishes us with the dependence of the milne extrapolation length on the tube properties through @xmath224 interestingly , @xmath218 depends only on very few generic properties of the random tube .
the next result relies on theorem [ t_current ] , so we need to assume a stronger condition on the geometry of the tube .
[ t_perm ] let us suppose that the quenched invariance principle is valid with @xmath174 , and assume that condition t holds .
for the asymptotics of the probability of crossing , we have @xmath225 = \frac{\gamma_d|{{\mathbb s}}^{d-1}|{\hat\sigma}^2{\big\langle |\omega_0| \big\rangle_{\!{}_{{\mathbb p } } } } } { 2|{\tilde\omega}_0| } \qquad \text{${{\mathbb p}}$-a.s .
, } \label{q_perm_prob}\\ \lim_{h\to\infty } h{\big\langle { { \mathtt p}_\omega}[{{\mathfrak c}}_h ] \big\rangle_{\!{}_{{\mathbb p } } } } = \frac{1}{2 } \gamma_d|{{\mathbb s}}^{d-1}|{\hat\sigma}^2{\big\langle |\omega_0| \big\rangle_{\!{}_{{\mathbb p } } } } { \big\langle |{\tilde\omega}_0|^{-1 } \big\rangle_{\!{}_{{\mathbb p}}}}. \label{a_perm_prob}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the quenched behaviour of the conditional expectations , we have , @xmath48-a.s .
@xmath226 and for the annealed ones @xmath227 as one sees from theorems [ t_exp_perm ] and [ t_perm ] , all our annealed results in fact say that one can interchange the limit as @xmath228 with integration with respect to @xmath48 . we still decided to include these results ( even though they are technically not difficult ) because , in models related to random environment , it is frequent that the annealed behaviour differs substantially from the quenched behaviour
. one may find it interesting to observe that , by and @xmath229 to obtain another interesting consequence of our results , let us suppose now that @xmath48-a.s .
the random tube is such that we have @xmath230 .
observe that , by jensen s inequality , it holds that @xmath231 ( and the inequality is strict if the distribution of @xmath232 is nondegenerate ) , so `` roughness '' of the tube makes the quantities @xmath233 and @xmath234 increase . in other words
, these quantities as well as the milne correlation length are minimized on the tubes with constant section ( which , by the way , do not have to be necessarily `` straight cylinders '' ! ) .
the remaining part of the paper is devoted to the proofs of our results , and , as mentioned in the introduction , it is organized in the following way . in section [ s_pr_prelim ]
we obtain several auxiliary results related to hitting of sets by the random billiard . in section [ s_pr_steady ]
we obtain the explicit form of the stationary measure of the knudsen gas in the finite tube @xmath152 by using the corresponding result from @xcite about the stationary distribution of one particle in a finite domain .
then , in section [ s_pr_trans ] , we apply the results of sections [ s_pr_prelim ] and [ s_pr_steady ] to obtain the explicit form of the transport diffusion coefficient .
finally , in section [ s_pr_perm ] we use little s theorem to prove the results related to the crossing time of the random tube .
we need first to prove several auxiliary facts for random billiard in arbitrary finite domains . as in @xcite , let @xmath235 be a bounded domain with lipschitz and a.e . continuously differentiable boundary .
we keep the notation @xmath100 to denote the law of our processes , and we still use @xmath73 to denote the @xmath55-dimensional hausdorff measure on the boundary @xmath236 . consider a markov chain @xmath237 on @xmath236 , which has a transition density @xmath238 with the property @xmath239 for all @xmath240 .
observe that the knudsen random walk @xmath241 has the above property , but we need to formulate the next results in a slightly more general framework , since we shall need to apply them to some other processes built upon @xmath241 .
let us introduce the notations @xmath242 for the entrance and the hitting time of @xmath243 . also , for measurable @xmath244 such that @xmath245 we shall write @xmath246 = \frac{1}{{\nu^\omega}(b)}{\int\limits}_b{{\mathtt p}_\omega}^x[\cdot]\,d{\nu^\omega}(x),\ ] ] so that @xmath247 is the law for the process starting from the uniform distribution on @xmath248 .
taking advantage of the reversibility of the process @xmath241 , we prove the following [ l_hitting_revers ] consider two arbitrary measurable sets @xmath249 such that @xmath250 .
* suppose that @xmath251 .
for any @xmath252 , we have @xmath253 } \nonumber\\ & = \frac{1}{{\nu^\omega}(b){{\mathtt p}_\omega}^b[\tau(f)<\tau^+(b ) ] } { \int\limits}_{f'}{{\mathtt p}_\omega}^y[\tau(b)<\tau^+(f)]\ , d{\nu^\omega}(y ) \nonumber\\ & = \frac{1}{{\nu^\omega}(f){{\mathtt p}_\omega}^f[\tau(b)<\tau^+(f ) ] } { \int\limits}_{f'}{{\mathtt p}_\omega}^y[\tau(b)<\tau^+(f)]\ , d{\nu^\omega}(y ) . \label{hitting_rev1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] * suppose that @xmath254 .
for any @xmath255 , we have @xmath256 \,d{\nu^\omega}(x ) } \nonumber\\ & = { \int\limits}_{b '' } { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^x[\xi_{\tau^+(b)}\in b ' , \tau^+(b)<\tau(f ) ] \,d{\nu^\omega}(x ) .
\label{hitting_rev2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] one immediately obtains the following consequence of lemma [ l_hitting_revers ] ( ii ) : [ c_trans_dens ] for any @xmath249 such that @xmath257 and @xmath254 , we have the following . * for @xmath258 ,
let us define the conditional ( on the event @xmath259 ) transition density @xmath260 : @xmath261 = { \int\limits}_{b '' } { \bar k}_{b , f}(x , y)\,d{\nu^\omega}(y).\ ] ] then , we have @xmath262 { \bar k}_{b , f}(x , y ) = { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^y[\tau^+(b)<\tau(f ) ] { \bar k}_{b , f}(y , x),\ ] ] that is , the random walk conditioned to return to @xmath248 without hitting @xmath263 is reversible with the reversible measure @xmath264 defined by @xmath265.\ ] ] * in particular ( take @xmath266 in the previous part ) the random walk observed at the moments of successive visits to @xmath248 is reversible with the reversible measure @xmath73 .
_ proof of lemma [ l_hitting_revers ] .
_ abbreviate for the moment @xmath267 .
first , write using the fact that @xmath268 is symmetric @xmath269 & = \sum_{n=1}^\infty { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^b[\tau(f)=n,\tau^+(b)>n]\\ & = \sum_{n=1}^\infty { \int\limits}_b \frac{d{\nu^\omega}(x_0)}{{\nu^\omega}(b ) } { \int\limits}_{u^{n-1 } } d{\nu^\omega}(x_1 ) \ldots d{\nu^\omega}(x_{n-1 } ) \\ & \qquad\qquad\times { \int\limits}_f d{\nu^\omega}(x_n ) { \bar k}(x_0,x_1)\ldots { \bar k}(x_{n-1},x_n)\\ & = \frac{{\nu^\omega}(f)}{{\nu^\omega}(b)}\sum_{n=1}^\infty { \int\limits}_f \frac{d{\nu^\omega}(x_n)}{{\nu^\omega}(f ) } { \int\limits}_{u^{n-1 } } d{\nu^\omega}(x_{n-1 } ) \ldots d{\nu^\omega}(x_1 ) \\ & \qquad\qquad\times { \int\limits}_b d{\nu^\omega}(x_0 ) { \bar k}(x_n , x_{n-1})\ldots { \bar k}(x_1,x_0)\\ & = \frac{{\nu^\omega}(f)}{{\nu^\omega}(b ) } \sum_{n=1}^\infty { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^f[\tau(b)=n,\tau^+(f)>n]\\ & = \frac{{\nu^\omega}(f)}{{\nu^\omega}(b ) } { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^f[\tau(b)<\tau^+(f)].\end{aligned}\ ] ] then , similarly @xmath253 } \\ & = \frac{1}{{{\mathtt p}_\omega}^b[\tau(f)<\tau^+(b ) ] } \sum_{n=1}^\infty { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^b[\tau(f)=n,\xi_{\tau(f)}\in f ' , \tau^+(b)>n]\\ & = \frac{{\nu^\omega}(b)}{{\nu^\omega}(f){{\mathtt p}_\omega}^f[\tau(b)<\tau^+(f ) ] } \sum_{n=1}^\infty { \int\limits}_b \frac{d{\nu^\omega}(x_0)}{{\nu^\omega}(b ) } { \int\limits}_{u^{n-1 } } d{\nu^\omega}(x_1 ) \ldots d{\nu^\omega}(x_{n-1 } ) \\ & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\times { \int\limits}_{f ' } d{\nu^\omega}(x_n ) { \bar k}(x_0,x_1)\ldots { \bar k}(x_{n-1},x_n)\\ & = \frac{1}{{\nu^\omega}(f){{\mathtt p}_\omega}^f[\tau(b)<\tau^+(f ) ] } { \int\limits}_{f'}{{\mathtt p}_\omega}^y[\tau(b)<\tau^+(f)]\ , d{\nu^\omega}(y),\end{aligned}\ ] ] so is proved .
let us prove .
analogously to the previous computation , we write @xmath270 \,d{\nu^\omega}(x)}\\ & = { \int\limits}_{b'}d{\nu^\omega}(x ) \sum_{n=1}^\infty { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^x[\xi_{\tau^+(b)}\in b '' , \tau^+(b)=n,\tau(f)>n]\\ & = \sum_{n=1}^\infty { \int\limits}_{b ' } d{\nu^\omega}(x_0 ) { \int\limits}_{u^{n-1 } } d{\nu^\omega}(x_1 ) \ldots d{\nu^\omega}(x_{n-1 } ) \\ & \qquad\qquad\times { \int\limits}_{b '' } d{\nu^\omega}(x_n ) { \bar k}(x_0,x_1)\ldots { \bar k}(x_{n-1},x_n)\\ & = \sum_{n=1}^\infty { \int\limits}_{b '' } d{\nu^\omega}(x_n ) { \int\limits}_{u^{n-1 } } d{\nu^\omega}(x_{n-1 } ) \ldots d{\nu^\omega}(x_1 ) \\ & \qquad\qquad\times { \int\limits}_{b ' } d{\nu^\omega}(x_0 ) { \bar k}(x_n , x_{n-1})\ldots { \bar k}(x_1,x_0)\\ & = { \int\limits}_{b '' } { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^x[\xi_{\tau^+(b)}\in b ' , \tau^+(b)<\tau(f ) ] \,d{\nu^\omega}(x),\end{aligned}\ ] ] and is proved .
this concludes the proof of lemma [ l_hitting_revers ] .
next , we recall the dirichlet s principle : [ p_dirichlet ] consider @xmath271 with @xmath272 and @xmath254 , and denote @xmath273 $ ] ( so that , in particular , @xmath274 for all @xmath275 and @xmath276 for all @xmath277 ) .
define @xmath278 , h(x)=0 \text { for all } x\in b , h(x)=1 \text { for all } x\in f\}.\ ] ] then @xmath279 = { { \mathcal e}}({\hat h},{\hat h } ) = \min_{h\in { { \mathcal h}}}{{\mathcal e}}(h , h),\ ] ] where @xmath280 _ proof .
_ for the proof , we refer to the discrete case , e.g. proposition 3.8 in @xcite , and observe that the proof applies to the space - continuous case , using that , on general spaces , harmonicity in the analytic sense and in the probabilistic sense are equivalent notions by @xcite .
indeed , minimizers @xmath32 of the dirichlet form are harmonic in the analytic sense , i.e. , there are in the kernel of the form ( see ( 2.10 ) in @xcite ) , though the left - hand side of ( 24 ) is the value of @xmath281 when @xmath32 is harmonic in the probabilistic sense , i.e. , the expectation of the process at some exit time ( see theorem 2.7 in @xcite ) with the appropriate boundary conditions .
now , we go back to the knudsen random walk in the random tube @xmath51 .
recall that @xmath105 stands for the the @xmath104-step transition density of krw , and that we have @xmath282 for all @xmath78 .
let us define for an arbitrary @xmath283 @xmath284 in case @xmath42 is an interval , say , @xmath285 , we write @xmath286 instead of @xmath287 .
there is the following apriory bound on the size of the jump of the random billiard : there exists a constant @xmath288 , depending only on @xmath289 and the dimension , such that for @xmath48-almost all @xmath51 @xmath290 \leq { \tilde\gamma}_1 u^{-(d-1)},\ ] ] for all @xmath56 , @xmath291 , see formula ( 54 ) of @xcite .
moreover , using , for any @xmath292 it is straightforward to obtain that , for some @xmath293 @xmath294 \leq { \tilde\gamma}^{(n)}_1 u^{-(d-1)},\ ] ] for all @xmath56 , @xmath291 ( also , without restriction of generality , we can assume that @xmath295 is nondecreasing in @xmath104 ) .
now , with the help of the above formula we prove the following result : [ l_separated ] for any @xmath106 there exists @xmath296 such that for all @xmath291 and @xmath182 we have @xmath297 _ proof .
_ abbreviate @xmath298 .
the main idea is the following : if at some step the knudsen random walk jumped from some point of @xmath299 to @xmath300 , it must cross @xmath301 , so the probability of such a jump is the same as the probability of the jump to @xmath301 in the semi - infinite tube with the boundary @xmath302 .
so , we obtain @xmath303}d{\nu^\omega}(x ) { \int\limits}_{{\tilde f}^\omega[a+u,\infty)}d{\nu^\omega}(y ) k^n(x ,
y)}\qquad\\ & = { \int\limits}_{{\tilde f}^\omega(-\infty , a ] } { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^x[\xi_n\in { \tilde f}^\omega[a+u,\infty)]\,d{\nu^\omega}(x)\\ & \leq { \int\limits}_{{\tilde f}^\omega(-\infty , a ] } { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^x\big[\bigcup_{k=1}^n\{\xi_k\cdot{\mathbf{e}}\geq a+u , \xi_j\cdot{\mathbf{e } } < a+u \text { for all } j
< k\}\big]\ , d{\nu^\omega}(x)\\ & \leq { \int\limits}_{{\tilde f}^\omega(-\infty , a]}d{\nu^\omega}(x_0 ) \sum_{k=1}^n { \int\limits}_{({\tilde f}^\omega(-\infty , a+u))^{k-1 } } d{\nu^\omega}(x_0)\ldots d{\nu^\omega}(x_{k-1})\\ & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad { \int\limits}_{{\tilde f}^\omega[a+u,\infty)}d{\nu^\omega}(x_k ) k(x_0,x_1)\ldots k(x_{k-1},x_k)\\ & \leq { \int\limits}_{{\tilde f}^\omega(-\infty , a]}d{\nu^\omega}(x ) { \int\limits}_v d{\nu^\omega}(y ) \big(k(x , y)+k^2(x , y)+\cdots+k^n(x , y)\big).\end{aligned}\ ] ] by symmetry of @xmath91 , we have for any @xmath177 @xmath304\ , d{\nu^\omega}(y),\ ] ] so lemma [ l_separated ] now follows from .
let us consider a sequence of i.i.d .
random variables @xmath305 with uniform distribution on @xmath306 ( where @xmath307 is from condition t ( ii ) ) , independent of everything . also , let us define @xmath308 .
then , it is straightforward to obtain that , for any @xmath56 and @xmath309 , we have @xmath310 \geq n^{-1}r_1{\nu^\omega}(b)\ ] ] for some @xmath311 .
let @xmath312 be the transition density of the process @xmath313 .
observe that this process is still reversible with the reversible measure @xmath73 , so that @xmath314 for all @xmath92 .
similarly to @xcite , let us define @xmath315 and @xmath316 we suppose that @xmath317 and @xmath318 are defined as in but with @xmath241 instead of @xmath237 , and let @xmath319 and @xmath320 be the corresponding quantities for the process @xmath321 . [ l_escape_upper ] suppose that @xmath322 with @xmath323 .
moreover , assume that @xmath324 for all @xmath275 , and @xmath325 for all @xmath326 ( of course , the same result is valid if we assume that @xmath324 for all @xmath277 , and @xmath325 for all @xmath327 ) .
then , there exist positive constants @xmath328 , @xmath329 , such that @xmath330 \leq { \tilde\gamma}_3u^{-(d-1 ) } + \frac{1}{u^2}{\int\limits}_{{\tilde f}^\omega[a , a+u]}b(x)\ , d{\nu^\omega}(x),\ ] ] and @xmath331 \leq { \tilde\gamma}_4u^{-(d-1 ) } + \frac{1}{u^2}{\int\limits}_{{\tilde f}^\omega[a , a+u]}{\hat b}(x)\ , d{\nu^\omega}(x).\ ] ] moreover , and are valid also in the finite tube @xmath152 ( in this case we assume that @xmath332 and @xmath333 ) .
we now work in finite tube @xmath152 .
let us use the abbreviations @xmath339 , and @xmath340 .
observe that , by condition t ( i ) , we have that for some @xmath341 @xmath342 for all @xmath104 and for @xmath48-a.a .
@xmath51 . to distinguish between the seconds moments of the projected jump length in finite and infinite tubes , we modify our notations in the following way . for @xmath343 ,
let @xmath344 and @xmath345 be the quantities defined as in and , but in the finite tube @xmath152 .
let us use the notations @xmath346 and @xmath347 for the corresponding quantities in the infinite tube .
now , we need an estimate on the integrals appearing in the right - hand sides of and , for the case of the finite tube : [ l_int_b ] suppose that @xmath348 and assume that @xmath138 and condition t holds .
then , we have @xmath349}b_h(x)\ , d{\nu^\omega}(x ) < \infty \qquad { { \mathbb p}}\text{-a.s.},\ ] ] and the same is valid with @xmath350 on the place of @xmath351 .
_ let us recall some notations from @xcite .
define @xmath352 define the probability measure @xmath353 on @xmath354 by @xmath355 where @xmath356 is the @xmath357-dimensional hausdorff measure on the boundary of @xmath190 , @xmath358 is the scalar product of the normal vectors pointing inside the section and inside the tube ( see section 2 of @xcite for details ) , and @xmath359 is the normalizing constant . in lemma 3.1 of @xcite it is shown that @xmath353 is the invariant law of the environment seen from the walker , that is @xmath360 \big\rangle_{\!{}_{{\mathbb q}}}}={\big\langle f \big\rangle_{\!{}_{{\mathbb q}}}}.\ ] ] using also that @xmath361 and , it is straightforward to obtain that @xmath362 implies @xmath363 .
so , using the notations of @xcite , by the ergodic theorem we obtain @xmath364}b_\infty(x)\ , d{\nu^\omega}(x ) & = \frac{1}{h } { \int\limits}_0^h d\alpha { \int\limits}_{\xi}d{\mu^\omega}_\alpha(v)\kappa^{-1}_{\alpha , v } b_\infty(\theta_\alpha\omega , v)\nonumber\\ & \to { \big\langle b_\infty \big\rangle_{\!{}_{{\mathbb q } } } } \qquad \text{as $ h\to\infty$ } , \label{conv_b}\end{aligned}\ ] ] a.s . and in @xmath365 , and the same with @xmath366 on the place of @xmath367 . then , follows from the fact that , for all @xmath151 , @xmath368 for all @xmath369 .
now , with @xmath366 instead of @xmath367 , the previous inequality is not necessarily valid .
so , to prove for @xmath350 instead of @xmath351 , consider @xmath56 such that @xmath370 $ ] , and write ( note that for all @xmath343 we have @xmath371 ) @xmath372\\ & \leq c_1 h^{-(d-3)}\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( recall that @xmath138 ) , and then we obtain for @xmath350 as well . next , we obtain a lower bound for certain escape probabilities : [ l_dirichlet_lower ] suppose that @xmath373 , and @xmath374 .
also , assume that @xmath138 and condition t holds .
then , there exist positive constants @xmath375 , @xmath376 , such that @xmath377 \geq \frac{{\tilde\gamma}_7}{n - m},\ ] ] and @xmath378 \geq \frac{{\tilde\gamma}_8}{h}.\ ] ] _ proof .
_ let @xmath379 be the dirichlet form corresponding to @xmath380 ( cf . ) .
first , let us prove . as in proposition [ p_dirichlet ]
, we use the notation @xmath381 $ ] ; observe that @xmath274 for all @xmath382 and @xmath383 for all @xmath384 ( and hence for all @xmath385 ) .
using this fact together with and cauchy - schwarz inequality , we write ( abbreviating @xmath386 ) @xmath387}\\ & = { \hat{{\mathcal e}}}({\hat h},{\hat h})\\ & \geq \sum_{j=0}^u { \int\limits}_{u_{m+j}}d{\nu^\omega}(x_j ) { \int\limits}_{u_{m+j+1}}d{\nu^\omega}(x_{j+1 } ) { \hat k}(x_j , x_{j+1 } ) ( { \hat h}(x_j)-{\hat h}(x_{j+1}))^2\\ & = \big(\prod_{j=0}^{u+1}{\nu^\omega}(u_{m+j})\big)^{-1 } { \int\limits}_{u_m}d{\nu^\omega}(x_0)\ldots { \int\limits}_{u_{m+u+1}}d{\nu^\omega}(x_{u+1})\\ & \qquad\qquad\qquad \sum_{j=0}^{u}{\nu^\omega}(u_{m+j}){\nu^\omega}(u_{m+j+1 } ) { \hat k}(x_j , x_{j+1 } ) ( { \hat h}(x_j)-{\hat h}(x_{j+1}))^2\\ & \geq n^{-1}r_1{\tilde\gamma}_5 ^ 2 \big(\prod_{j=0}^{u+1}{\nu^\omega}(u_{m+j})\big)^{-1 } { \int\limits}_{u_m}d{\nu^\omega}(x_0)\ldots\\ & \qquad\qquad\qquad \ldots { \int\limits}_{u_{m+u+1}}d{\nu^\omega}(x_{u+1})\sum_{j=0}^{u } ( { \hat h}(x_j)-{\hat h}(x_{j+1}))^2\\ & \geq \frac{n^{-1}r_1{\tilde\gamma}_5 ^ 2}{u+1 } \big(\prod_{j=0}^{u+1}{\nu^\omega}(u_{m+j})\big)^{-1 } { \int\limits}_{u_m}d{\nu^\omega}(x_0)\ldots{\int\limits}_{u_{m+u+1}}d{\nu^\omega}(x_{u+1})\\ & = \frac{n^{-1}r_1{\tilde\gamma}_5 ^ 2}{n - m+1},\end{aligned}\ ] ] and this proves . by denoting @xmath388 $ ] and writing @xmath389}\\ & \geq \sum_{j=1}^{n+1 } { \int\limits}_{u_j}d{\nu^\omega}(x_j ) { \int\limits}_{u_{j+1}}d{\nu^\omega}(x_{j+1 } ) { \hat k}(x_j , x_{j+1 } ) ( { \hat h}(x_j)-{\hat h}(x_{j+1}))^2\\ & \quad + { \int\limits}_{{{\hat d}_\ell}}d{\nu^\omega}(x_0 ) { \int\limits}_{u_1}d{\nu^\omega}(x_1 ) { \hat k}(x_0,x_1 ) ( { \hat h}(x_0)-{\hat h}(x_1))^2\end{aligned}\ ] ] in exactly the same way one can show .
this concludes the proof of lemma [ l_dirichlet_lower ] .
next , we need ( pointwise ) estimates on the probabilities of exiting the tube at the left boundary : [ l_gamblers_ruin ] assume condition t and @xmath138 .
suppose also that @xmath390 , and @xmath391 $ ] .
then , there exists @xmath392 such that for all @xmath382 we have @xmath393 \leq \frac{{\tilde\gamma}_9(n - m+1)}{h}.\ ] ] _ proof .
_ from now on , we assume for technical reasons that @xmath394 ( in any case , otherwise the upper bound @xmath395 is good enough for us ) .
first , by lemmas [ l_escape_upper ] and [ l_int_b ] , we obtain that @xmath396 \leq \frac{c_1}{h}.\ ] ] next , lemma [ l_dirichlet_lower ] implies that @xmath397 \geq \frac{c_2}{n - m+1}.\ ] ] also , from it is clear that for any @xmath382 we have @xmath398 \geq { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^x[{\hat\xi}_1\in u_m ] \geq c_3\ ] ] for some @xmath399 .
now , denote @xmath400 , @xmath401 to be the successive times when the set @xmath402 is visited . by corollary [ c_trans_dens ]
( i ) and , we obtain that , conditional on not hitting @xmath403 , the process of successive returns to @xmath402 is reversible with the reversible density @xmath404 , such that for all @xmath382 @xmath405 for some positive constants @xmath406 . using also and
, we obtain that there are constants @xmath407 such that for any @xmath70 @xmath408 & \leq \frac{c_6}{h},\\ { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^{u_m}[{\hat\tau}(v_n)<{\hat\tau}^+(u_m ) \mid { \hat\tau}({{\hat d}_\ell}\cup v_n)>\sigma_k ] & \geq \frac{c_7}{n - m+1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] so , we can write @xmath409 & = \sum_{k=1}^\infty { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^{u_m}\big[{\hat\tau}({{\hat d}_\ell})<{\hat\tau}(v_n ) \mid { \hat\tau}({{\hat d}_\ell}\cup v_n)\in(\sigma_{k-1},\sigma_k]\big ] \nonumber\\ & \qquad\qquad \times { { \mathtt
p}_\omega}^{u_m}\big[{\hat\tau}({{\hat d}_\ell}\cup v_n ) \in(\sigma_{k-1},\sigma_k]\big ] \nonumber\\ & \leq \sum_{k=1}^\infty \frac{c_6/h}{c_7/(n - m+1 ) } { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^{u_m}\big[{\hat\tau}({{\hat
d}_\ell}\cup v_n ) \in(\sigma_{k-1},\sigma_k]\big ] \nonumber\\ & = \frac{c_6c_7^{-1}(n - m+1)}{h}. \label{bound_set}\end{aligned}\ ] ] now , the `` pointwise '' version of is substantially more difficult to prove . consider a sequence of i.i.d .
random variables @xmath410 with @xmath411 = n^{-1}r_1{\tilde\gamma}_5\ ] ] ( recall and ) .
then , one can couple the random sequences @xmath412 with @xmath413 in such a way that when the event @xmath414 occurs , @xmath415 has the stationary distribution on @xmath416}$ ] .
we denote by @xmath417 and @xmath418 the probability and expectation with fixed @xmath51 and @xmath419 , and let @xmath420 be the expectation with respect to @xmath419 .
one can formally define @xmath417 in the following way . for any @xmath421 ,
define the transition density @xmath422 by @xmath423 let @xmath424 be the distribution on @xmath54 with the density @xmath422 , and let @xmath425 be the uniform distribution on @xmath426 .
then , given @xmath427 , the law of @xmath415 under @xmath417 is given by @xmath428 also , let us define @xmath429 .
now , observe that @xmath430 = [ { \hat\xi}_{j-1}\cdot{\mathbf{e } } ] \text { on } \{j={\hat\kappa}\}\ ] ] and , for @xmath431 such that @xmath432 , @xmath433 \mid { \hat\kappa}=j \big ) } \nonumber\\ & = e^{\zeta } \big({{\mathtt p}_{\omega,\zeta}}^x\big[|({\hat\xi}_i- { \hat\xi}_{i-1})\cdot{\mathbf{e}}| \geq u \big ] \mid \zeta_i=0 \big ) \nonumber\\ & \leq \frac{1}{p^{\zeta}[\zeta_i=0 ] } { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^x\big[|({\hat\xi}_i- { \hat\xi}_{i-1})\cdot{\mathbf{e}}| \geq u \big ] \nonumber\\ & \leq c_8h^{-(d-1 ) } , \label{<j}\end{aligned}\ ] ] recall .
then , write using and @xmath434
e^{\zeta}\big({{\mathtt p}_{\omega,\zeta}}^{u_0}\big [ \max_{\ell\leq{\hat\kappa } } |({\hat\xi}_\ell-{\hat\xi}_0)\cdot{\mathbf{e}}| \geq s\big]\mid { \hat\kappa}=j\big ) \nonumber\\ & \leq \sum_{j=1}^\infty p^{\zeta}[{\hat\kappa}=j ] e^{\zeta}\big({{\mathtt p}_{\omega,\zeta}}^x\big[\text{there exists } i\leq j \text { such that } \nonumber\\ & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad \geq s / j\big]\mid { \hat\kappa}=j\big ) \nonumber\\ & \leq \sum_{j=1}^\infty p^{\zeta}[{\hat\kappa}=j ] jc_9\big(\frac{s}{j}\big)^{-(d-1 ) } \nonumber\\ & = c_9 s^{-(d-1 ) } \sum_{j=1}^\infty j^d p^{\zeta}[{\hat\kappa}=j ] \nonumber\\ & = c_{10 } s^{-(d-1)}. \label{oc_kappa_1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] now , using , we have for an arbitrary @xmath382 @xmath435 } \nonumber\\ & = e^{\zeta}{{\mathtt p}_{\omega,\zeta}}^x[{\hat\tau}({{\hat d}_\ell})<{\hat\tau}(v_n ) ] \nonumber\\ & \leq e^{\zeta } { { \mathtt p}_{\omega,\zeta}}^x\big[\max_{j\leq { \hat\kappa } } { \hat\tau}({{\hat d}_\ell})<{\hat\tau}(v_n)\big ] \nonumber\\ & \qquad + e^{\zeta } { { \mathtt p}_{\omega,\zeta}}^x\big[\max_{j\leq { \hat\kappa } } \nonumber\\ & \leq e^{\zeta } { { \mathtt p}_{\omega,\zeta}}^x\big[\max_{j\leq { \hat\kappa } } { \hat\tau}({{\hat d}_\ell})<{\hat\tau}(v_n)\big ] + c_{11}h^{-(d-1)}. \label{i+ii}\end{aligned}\ ] ] let us deal with the first term in .
we have , taking advantage of and ( recall that @xmath138 ) @xmath436}\\ & \leq \sum_{\ell\geq h/16 } e^{\zeta}{{\mathtt p}_{\omega,\zeta}}^x\big[[{\hat\xi}_{{\hat\kappa}}]=\ell\big ] { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^{u_\ell}[{\hat\tau}({{\hat d}_\ell})<{\hat\tau}(v_n ) ] \\ & \leq \frac{c_{12}(n - m+1)}{h}\sum_{\ell\geq m } e^{\zeta}{{\mathtt p}_{\omega,\zeta}}^x\big[[{\hat\xi}_{{\hat\kappa}}]=\ell\big]\\ & \quad + \sum_{\frac{h}{16}\leq\ell < m } \frac{c_{12}\big((n - m+1)+(m-\ell)\big)}{h } e^{\zeta}{{\mathtt p}_{\omega,\zeta}}^x\big[[{\hat\xi}_{{\hat\kappa}}]=\ell\big]\\ & \leq \frac{c_{13}(n - m+1)}{h},\end{aligned}\ ] ] and this concludes the proof of lemma [ l_gamblers_ruin ] .
next , we prove a result which shows that it is unlikely that a particle crosses the tube @xmath152 `` too quickly '' .
suppose that one particle is injected ( uniformly ) at random at @xmath161 into the tube @xmath152 , and we still denote by @xmath194 the event that it crosses the tube without going back to @xmath161 , i.e. , @xmath437 ( one can see that there is no conflict with the notation of section [ s_perm ] ) . also , recall that @xmath199 stands for the total lifetime of the particle as defined in section [ s_perm ] , i.e. , if @xmath114 is the location of the particle at time @xmath116 , then @xmath438 .
[ l_cross ] for any @xmath439 there exists ( large enough ) @xmath177 with the following property : there exists large enough @xmath440 such that for all @xmath441 @xmath442 \leq \frac{{\varepsilon}}{h}.\ ] ] _ proof . _ for @xmath443 , we say that @xmath56 is @xmath444-good if @xmath445 \geq 1-{\varepsilon}_1.\ ] ] let @xmath446 be a large positive parameter to be specified later ; for @xmath447 denote @xmath448 ; denote also @xmath449 now , consider first the case @xmath138 . from now on we suppose that @xmath177 is sufficiently large to assure the following : @xmath450 \geq 1-\frac{{\varepsilon}_1}{2},\ ] ] where @xmath451 is the standard brownian motion and @xmath452 is the corresponding probability measure . in this case , if the invariance principle holds , then for any fixed @xmath453 every @xmath7 is @xmath444-good for all large enough @xmath151 . using the monotone convergence theorem ,
it is straightforward to obtain that for fixed @xmath454 there exists large enough @xmath455 such that for all @xmath441 @xmath456 > \frac{3}{4}.\ ] ] then , by the ergodic theorem , there exists large enough @xmath455 such that for all @xmath441 there exists @xmath457 such that @xmath458 , and @xmath459 .
now , let us consider also the event @xmath460 ( that is , with respect to the process @xmath461 , the particle enters @xmath462 before coming back to @xmath161 ) .
then , write @xmath463 & \leq { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^{{{\hat d}_\ell}}[{\hat{{\mathfrak c}}}_h , { { \mathcal t}}_h\leq m^{-1}h^2 ] + { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^{{{\hat d}_\ell}}[{\hat{{\mathfrak c}}}_h^c,{{\mathfrak c}}_h ] \nonumber\\ & = { { \mathtt
p}_\omega}^{{{\hat d}_\ell}}[{\hat{{\mathfrak c}}}_h]{{\mathtt p}_\omega}^{{{\hat d}_\ell}}[{{\mathcal t}}_h\leq m^{-1}h^2\mid { \hat{{\mathfrak c}}}_h ] \nonumber\\ & \quad + { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^{{{\hat d}_\ell}}[{{\mathfrak c}}_h]{{\mathtt p}_\omega}^{{{\hat d}_\ell}}[{\hat{{\mathfrak c}}}_h^c\mid{{\mathfrak c}}_h ] . \label{cross_decompose}\end{aligned}\ ] ] now , by lemmas [ l_escape_upper ] and [ l_int_b ] , we can write for some @xmath464 @xmath465,{{\mathtt p}_\omega}^{{{\hat d}_\ell}}[{\hat{{\mathfrak c}}}_h]\ } \leq \frac{c_1}{h}.\ ] ] then , from we obtain that @xmath466 \leq \sup_{x\in{{\hat d}_r } } { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^x\big[\max_{j\leq n}|\xi_j\cdot{\mathbf{e}}-h|\geq h/4\big ] \leq c_2 h^{-(d-1)}\ ] ] for some @xmath467 .
so , to complete the proof of , it remains to prove that the term @xmath468 $ ] in is small . to do this ,
let us recall that , by lemma [ l_hitting_revers ] ( i ) , for any @xmath469 , we have @xmath470 = \big({\nu^\omega}({{\hat d}_\ell}){{\mathtt p}_\omega}^{{{\hat d}_\ell}}[\hat{{\mathfrak c}}_h]\big)^{-1 } { \int\limits}_{f'}{{\mathtt p}_\omega}^y[{\hat\tau}({{\hat d}_\ell})<{\hat\tau}^+(v_{ln_0})]\,d{\nu^\omega}(y).\ ] ] by lemma [ l_dirichlet_lower ] , we have that for some @xmath399 @xmath471\big)^{-1 } \leq c_3 h.\ ] ] for @xmath472 denote @xmath473 . using lemma [ l_gamblers_ruin ] ,
we can write for any @xmath474 @xmath475 & = { \int\limits}_{\partial\omega}{\hat k}(y , z ) { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^z[{\hat\tau}({{\hat d}_\ell})<{\hat\tau}(v_{ln_0})]\,d{\nu^\omega}(z ) \nonumber\\ & \leq { \int\limits}_{{{\hat d}_\ell}}{\hat k}(y , z)\,d{\nu^\omega}(z ) \nonumber\\ & \qquad + \sum_{j=1}^{ln_0 } \frac{{\tilde\gamma}_9(ln_0-j+1)}{h } { \int\limits}_{u_j}{\hat k}(y , z)\,d{\nu^\omega}(z)\nonumber\\ & \leq \frac{{\tilde\gamma}_9}{h}\sum_{j=1}^{ln_0 } { \int\limits}_{s_j}{\hat k}(y , z)\,d{\nu^\omega}(z ) .
\label{upper_py}\end{aligned}\ ] ] so , by , in the case @xmath138 , we obtain from that for some positive constant @xmath476 @xmath477 \leq \frac{c_4}{h}\ ] ] and , by , , and the construction of @xmath478 we obtain that @xmath479 \leq c_3c_4{\varepsilon}_2.\ ] ] next , integrating over @xmath480 , we obtain from lemma [ l_separated ] that @xmath481\,d{\nu^\omega}(y ) & \leq \frac{{\tilde\gamma}_9}{h}\sum_{j=1}^{ln_0 } { \int\limits}_{v_{n_0}\setminus i_{n_0}}d{\nu^\omega}(y ) { \int\limits}_{s_j}d{\nu^\omega}(z){\hat k}(y , z)\\ & \leq \frac{c_5{\tilde\gamma}_9}{h } \sum_{j=1}^{ln_0 } ( ln_0+l - j)^{-(d-1)}\\ & \leq \frac{c_6}{h } l^{-(d-2)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] again using , , we obtain that @xmath482 \leq c_3c_6 l^{-(d-2)}.\ ] ] so , and imply that for any @xmath483 there exists large enough @xmath214 such that for all large enough @xmath151 we have @xmath484 \geq 1-{\varepsilon}_3.\ ] ] but then , since all @xmath485 are @xmath444-good , from we obtain that @xmath486 \leq 1-(1-{\varepsilon}_1)(1-{\varepsilon}_3).\ ] ] using , , and in , we conclude the proof of in the case @xmath138 .
let us prove the lemma in the case @xmath144 .
take @xmath487 note that @xmath488 , so lemma [ l_escape_upper ] implies that @xmath489\leq c_7h^{-1}$ ] for some @xmath490 . by condition
t ( iii ) we obtain that @xmath491 = 0,\ ] ] and , since for any @xmath492 , @xmath493 we have @xmath494 , we then obtain @xmath495 \geq 1-{\varepsilon}_4\ ] ] for a small @xmath496 .
the proof of in the case @xmath144 then follows in the same way .
in this section we prove the theorem that characterizes the stationary regime for the knudsen gas in a finite tube .
_ proof of theorem [ t_stat_measure ] .
_ in order to prove item ( i ) , we consider the process with absorbing / injection boundaries in _ both _ @xmath161 and @xmath171 ( that is , the injection is given by two independent poisson processes in @xmath497 and @xmath498 with intensities @xmath499 in both cases ) .
fix a sequence of positive numbers @xmath500 such that @xmath501 for all @xmath70 . for each @xmath70 , consider a domain @xmath502 with the following properties * @xmath503 , @xmath504 , @xmath505 ; * @xmath506 ; * any segment @xmath507 with @xmath508 , @xmath509 has length at least @xmath510 ] ( one may construct such a domain e.g. as shown on figure [ f_reservoir ] ) .
now , let us consider @xmath511 independent particles in @xmath502
. by theorem 2.4 of @xcite , the unique invariant measure of this system is product of uniform measures in location and direction .
we are going to compare this process ( observed only on @xmath152 ) with the process with absorbing / injection boundaries in both @xmath161 and @xmath171 ( naturally , we assume that the injection is with the cosine law and with the same intensity mentioned in theorem [ t_stat_measure ] .
let @xmath512 be the expectation for the above process in @xmath502 with @xmath511 particles , with respect to the invariant measure . also , we denote by @xmath513 the expectation with respect to the process with absorbing / injection boundaries in @xmath514 at time @xmath116 , with the initial configuration chosen from the poisson point process in @xmath185 with intensity @xmath186 .
let @xmath515 be a function on @xmath187 , taking values on the interval @xmath516 $ ] .
for a configuration @xmath517 in @xmath187 ( which means that we have @xmath518 particles with positions @xmath519 and vector speeds @xmath520 ) , write @xmath521 denote also by @xmath522 the mean value of @xmath515 on @xmath187 . clearly , we have @xmath523 also , it is straightforward to obtain that @xmath524 since , as @xmath525 , the binomial distribution with parameters @xmath511 and @xmath526 converges to the poisson distribution with parameter @xmath527 , for any @xmath515 we have @xmath528 now , let us fix @xmath529 and prove that for any @xmath439 @xmath530 for all large enough @xmath70 . for this , denote by @xmath531 the total number of particles which entered @xmath152 through the right boundary @xmath171 up to time @xmath529 .
for the process with absorption / injection , an elementary calculation shows that @xmath531 has poisson distribution with parameter @xmath532 .
let us suppose without restriction of generality that @xmath533 and denote @xmath534 \text { such that } x+vt\in{{\hat d}_r}\};\ ] ] observe that @xmath535 .
now , a particle starting in @xmath536 with the direction @xmath124 will cross @xmath171 by time @xmath529 iff @xmath537 .
so , it is straightforward to obtain that , for the process in @xmath502 , the random variable @xmath531 has the binomial distribution with parameters @xmath511 and @xmath538 as @xmath525
. then , conditioned on @xmath539 , for both processes the @xmath104 entering particles to @xmath171 ( seen as a point process on @xmath540 $ ] ) are independent , each having density @xmath541 . observe that the same considerations apply also to the particles which enter through @xmath161 . to obtain , we use now the following coupling argument .
first of all , as we already know , the initial configurations restricted to @xmath152 for both processes can be successfully coupled with probability that converges to @xmath395 as @xmath525 .
then , by the argument we just presented , the same applies for the process of particles entering through @xmath514 .
this shows that , with large probability , both processes can be successfully coupled .
now , combining with and using the fact that a point process is uniquely determined by its characteristic functional ( cf .
e.g. section 5.5 of @xcite ) , we obtain that the poisson point process in @xmath185 with intensity @xmath186 is invariant for the knudsen gas with absorption / injection in @xmath184 . as for the convergence to the stationary state and the uniqueness , this follows from an easy coupling argument .
indeed , consider one process starting from the invariant measure defined above , and another process starting from an arbitrary ( fixed ) configuration .
the initial particles are independent , but the newly injected particles are the same for both processes .
then , since any fixed particle will eventually disappear , the coupling time is a.s.finite , and so the system converges to the unique stationary state .
( using theorem 2.1 of @xcite , with some more work one can show that , for _ fixed _ tube , this convergence is exponentially fast ; however , we do not need this kind of result in the present paper . )
this concludes the proof of the part ( i ) .
let us prove the part ( ii ) .
still considering the process with absorption and injection in @xmath184 , suppose that the particles entering through @xmath171 are coloured red , and the particles entering through @xmath161 are coloured green .
so , we need to compute the stationary measure for green particles . using the ( quasi ) reversibility of knudsen stochastic billiard
( see theorem 2.5 of @xcite ) , we obtain that , given that there is a particle in @xmath34 with the vector speed @xmath32 , the probability that it is green equals @xmath542.\ ] ] using also the part ( i ) , we obtain that , for the gas with injection only in @xmath161 , the stationary measure is that of poisson point process with intensity @xmath543 \,d\alpha\ , du\ , dh.\ ] ] note also that convergence and uniqueness follow from the same coupling argument as in part ( i ) .
this concludes the proof of theorem [ t_stat_measure ] .
let us observe also that theorem [ t_stat_measure ] allows us to characterize the stationary measure for knudsen gas where the injection takes place from both sides , but with different intensities ( which are constant on @xmath161 and @xmath171 ) .
we have [ cor_different ] consider now knudsen gas with injection from both sides , with respective intensities @xmath162 and @xmath544 on @xmath161 and @xmath171 ( without restriction of generality , let us suppose that @xmath545 ) .
then , a poisson point process with intensity measure @xmath546\big ) \,d\alpha\ , du\ , dh\ ] ] is the steady state of the knudsen gas .
indeed , one may imagine that particles of type @xmath395 are injected from both sides with intensity @xmath544 and particles of type @xmath150 are injected only from the left with intensity @xmath547 , and use theorem [ t_stat_measure ] .
for integers @xmath548 define @xmath549 let @xmath550 be a brownian motion with diffusion constant @xmath174 , starting from the origin ; we define ( being @xmath551 the expectation with respect to the probability measure on the space where the brownian motion is defined ) @xmath552 to be the probabilities of the corresponding events for this brownian motion .
fix an integer @xmath177 . for @xmath553 and @xmath453
define @xmath554 intuitively , @xmath555 is the scaling factor one needs to use in order to assure that the rescaled ( and projected on @xmath556 ) trajectory of the knudsen stochastic billiard stays sufficiently close to the brownian motion . by the portmanteau theorem ,
observe that , if the knudsen stochastic billiard starting from @xmath557 satisfies the quenched invariance principle , this means that for any @xmath453 it holds that @xmath558 .
since , for @xmath48-almost every @xmath51 , the invariance principle holds for a.a .
starting points @xmath557 , we have @xmath559 by the monotone convergence theorem , we obtain that for all @xmath560 there exists @xmath561 such that @xmath562 so , using the ergodic theorem , we obtain for almost all @xmath51 and all @xmath151 large enough @xmath563 then , by theorem [ t_stat_measure ] ,
we can write @xmath564.\ ] ] now , let us prove that the rescaled density gradient is given by @xmath565 . _ proof of theorem [ t_dens_grad ] .
_ fix an arbitrary @xmath176 and suppose that @xmath177 is a ( large ) integer .
consider the quantity @xmath566 defined by , and suppose that @xmath567 is large enough to assure that ( recall ) @xmath568 abbreviate @xmath569 and consider any integer @xmath570 $ ] .
suppose that @xmath571 , @xmath572 are such that @xmath573 $ ] , and @xmath574 .
then , since @xmath575 , from we obtain that @xmath576 & \leq { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^{z , h}[\wp_{-(m - j)}({\hat z}^{(\phi)})<\wp_j({\hat z}^{(\phi ) } ) ] \nonumber\\ & = { { \mathtt e}_\omega}^{z , h } \big(1-r_{m - j , j}({\hat z}^{(\phi)})\big)\nonumber\\ & \leq \frac{j}{m } + m^{-2}\nonumber\\ & \leq \frac{j+1}{m},\label{upper_b_gambler}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath576 & \geq { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^{z , h}[\wp_{-(m - j+1)}({\hat z}^{(\phi)})<\wp_{j-1}({\hat z}^{(\phi ) } ) ] \nonumber\\ & = { { \mathtt e}_\omega}^{z , h } \big(1-r_{m - j+1,j-1}({\hat z}^{(\phi)})\big ) \nonumber\\ & \geq \frac{j-1}{m } - m^{-2}\nonumber\\ & \geq \frac{j-2}{m}. \label{lower_b_gambler}\end{aligned}\ ] ] also , by the ergodic theorem , we can choose @xmath151 large enough so that for all @xmath577 @xmath578 } \big| -{\big\langle |\omega_0| \big\rangle_{\!{}_{{\mathbb p}}}}\big| = \bigg|\frac{m}{h}{\int\limits}_{\frac{(j-1)h}{m}}^{\frac{jh}{m } } - { \big\langle |\omega_0| \big\rangle_{\!{}_{{\mathbb p}}}}\bigg| \leq m^{-1}.\ ] ] so , by , , , , @xmath579 analogously , using instead of , we obtain @xmath580 then , we obtain from and , and so the proof of theorem [ t_dens_grad ] is concluded . at this point ,
let us formulate an additional result which will be used in section [ s_pr_perm ] .
[ p_1/6 ] define @xmath581\nonumber\\ & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad \times { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^{(\alpha , u),h}[\wp_{h-\alpha}(x\cdot{\mathbf{e } } ) < \wp_{-\alpha}(x\cdot{\mathbf{e } } ) ] , \label{def_m*}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and suppose that the quenched invariance principle holds .
then , for any @xmath176 there exists @xmath177 such that @xmath48-a.s .
@xmath582 _ proof . _
the proof is quite analogous to the proof of theorem [ t_dens_grad ] .
now , we calculate the limiting rescaled current
. _ proof of theorem [ t_current ] .
_ first , we obtain an upper and a lower bounds for @xmath583 , where @xmath584 . by e.g. the formula * 1*.2.0.2 of @xcite
, we have @xmath585 = { \int\limits}_0^t\frac{|a|}{\sqrt{2\pi}{\hat\sigma}s^{3/2 } } \exp\big(-\frac{a^2}{2{\hat\sigma}^2s}\big)\ , ds.\ ] ] so , for @xmath586 @xmath587 - p[\wp_{-j}(b^{({\hat\sigma } ) } ) < \wp_i(b^{({\hat\sigma})})]\nonumber\\ & \geq -m^{-2/5 } + { \int\limits}_0^m\frac{i}{\sqrt{2\pi}{\hat\sigma}s^{3/2 } } \exp\big(-\frac{i^2}{2{\hat\sigma}^2s}\big)\ , ds . \label{gtil_lower}\end{aligned}\ ] ] also , for any @xmath588 , @xmath589\nonumber\\ & = { \int\limits}_0^m\frac{i}{\sqrt{2\pi}{\hat\sigma}s^{3/2 } } \exp\big(-\frac{i^2}{2{\hat\sigma}^2s}\big)\ , ds . \label{gtil_upper}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in particular , for @xmath590 , we obtain after some elementary computations that there exists a positive constant @xmath591 such that @xmath592 next , we employ the same strategy as in the proof of theorem [ t_dens_grad ] . fix a large @xmath177 , and suppose that @xmath593 is such that holds .
now , let @xmath594 be the expected number of particles that were absorbed in @xmath161 up to time @xmath595 , in the stationary regime . clearly , we have then @xmath596 .
so , one can write @xmath597\nonumber\\ & \qquad { } \times { { \mathtt p}_\omega}^{(\alpha , u),h}\big[\wp_{h-\alpha } ( x\cdot{\mathbf{e}})\leq \frac{h^2}{m } , \wp_{h-\alpha}(x\cdot{\mathbf{e } } ) < \wp_{-\alpha } ( x\cdot{\mathbf{e}})\big]\nonumber\\ & + { { \mathtt e}_\omega}{\widetilde w}_{h , m},\label{calc_current}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath598 is the mean number of particles that were injected in @xmath161 , successfully crossed the tube , and then hit @xmath171 before time @xmath595 . to obtain the corresponding upper bound ,
fix an arbitrary @xmath439 and suppose that @xmath177 is large enough so that of lemma [ l_cross ] holds for those @xmath610 .
the term @xmath611 of can be estimated in the following way : @xmath612 \leq c_4 \frac{h^2}{m}\times\frac{{\varepsilon}}{h},\ ] ] so @xmath613
. then , analogously to , using also , we have for some @xmath614 @xmath615 now , observe that @xmath616 with this observation , theorem [ t_current ] follows from and .
observe that , since the particles are independent , the knudsen gas in the finite tube @xmath193 can be regarded as a @xmath617 queueing system ; moreover , using e.g.theorem 2.1 of @xcite it is straightforward to obtain that the service time ( which is the lifetime of a newly injected particle ) is a random variable with exponential tail .
then , let us recall the following basic identity of queuing theory ( known as little s theorem ) : [ prop_little ] suppose that @xmath618 is the arrival rate , @xmath619 is the mean number of customers in the system , and @xmath620 is the mean time a customer spends in the system , then @xmath621 . _
_ see e.g. section 5.2 of @xcite . to understand intuitively why this fact holds true
, one may reason in the following way : by large time @xmath116 , the total time of all the customers in the system would be ( approximately ) @xmath622 on one hand , and @xmath623 on the other hand .
_ proof of theorem [ t_exp_perm ] .
_ this result almost immediately follows from theorem [ t_dens_grad ] by using proposition [ prop_little ] .
first , for the gas of independent particles the arrival rate is @xmath624 recall that the particles are injected in @xmath195 only .
then , from theorem [ t_dens_grad ] it is straightforward to obtain that for the mean number of particles @xmath625 in the system , we have @xmath626 then , proposition [ prop_little ] implies . to prove the corresponding annealed result , note that @xmath627 by theorem [ t_stat_measure ] ( ii ) .
so , applying the bounded convergence theorem , we obtain .
_ proof of theorem [ t_perm ] .
_ first , observe that in the stationary regime the particles leave the system at the right boundary with rate @xmath628 , and this should be equal to the entrance rate @xmath629 $ ] of the particles which cross the tube , with @xmath618 from .
so , follows from theorem [ t_current ] . to prove ,
observe that , by using lemma [ l_escape_upper ] with @xmath630 and @xmath631 , we obtain that for some positive constants @xmath632 which do not depend on @xmath51 @xmath633 \leq c_1 + \frac{c_2}{h } { \int\limits}_{{\tilde f}^\omega(0,h)}b(x)\ , d{\nu^\omega}(x).\ ] ] by , the collection of random variables @xmath634,h>1)$ ] is uniformly integrable , and this implies . in order to prove , denote by @xmath635 the mean number of particles in the stationary regime that _ will exit _ at @xmath171 .
observe that , by theorem [ t_stat_measure ] ( ii ) and proposition [ p_1/6 ] , @xmath636 so , using and proposition [ prop_little ] , we obtain .
the relations and follow from and . now , observe that and immediately follow from , , and , so now it remains only to prove .
let @xmath637 , @xmath638 be the moments of successive visits to @xmath195 for the process in the finite tube . by corollary [ c_trans_dens ] ,
@xmath639 is uniformly distributed in @xmath195 for all @xmath70 , and so we can write @xmath640
\leq k{{\mathtt p}_\omega}[{{\mathfrak c}}_h].\ ] ] then , using , lemma [ l_dirichlet_lower ] , and the fact that the random variables @xmath641 are independent of everything , we obtain @xmath642\\ & \leq \sum_{k=1}^\infty { { \mathtt p}_\omega}[{\hat\tau}({{\hat d}_r})<{\hat\tau}({{\tilde d}_\ell } ) , \sigma_{k-1}<z_1+\cdots+z_{{\hat\tau}({{\hat d}_r})}<\sigma_k]\\ & \leq { { \mathtt p}_\omega}[z_1+\cdots+z_j\neq \sigma_\ell \text { for all $ \ell < k$ and all~$j$ } \mid \tau({{\hat d}_r})<\sigma_k]\\ & \qquad \times { { \mathtt p}_\omega}[\tau({{\hat d}_r})<\sigma_k]\\ & \leq { { \mathtt p}_\omega}[{{\mathfrak c}}_h ] \sum_{k=1}^\infty k(1-n^{-1})^{\lceil\frac{k-1}{n}\rceil},\end{aligned}\ ] ] and this implies that @xmath643\geq c_4/h$ ] for some @xmath644 not depending on @xmath51 . since @xmath645 , one obtains from the bounded convergence theorem .
we thank takashi kumagai for pointing us reference @xcite . the work of f.c .
was partially supported by cnrs ( umr 7599 `` probabilits et modles alatoires '' ) and anr polintbio .
s.p.was partially supported by cnpq ( 300886/20080 ) .
thanks dfg ( priority programme spp 1155 ) for financial support .
the work of m.v . was partially supported by cnpq ( 304561/20061 ) .
s.p . and m.v .
also thank fapesp ( 2009/523798 ) , cnpq ( 471925/20063 , 472431/20099 ) , and capes / daad ( probral ) for financial support .
f. comets , s. popov , g.m .
schtz , m. vachkovskaia ( 2010 ) quenched invariance principle for knudsen stochastic billiard in random tube . to appear in : _ ann .
cooper ( 1981 ) _ introduction to queueing theory _
( 2nd ed . ) .
north holland .
s. zschiegner , s. russ , r. valiullin , m .- o .
coppens , a .-
dammers , a. bunde , j. krger ( 2008 ) normal and anomalous diffusion of non - interacting particles in linear nanopores .
. phys .
j. _ * 161 * ( 109 ) . | we consider transport diffusion in a stochastic billiard in a random tube which is elongated in the direction of the first coordinate ( the tube axis ) . inside the random tube , which is stationary and ergodic ,
non - interacting particles move straight with constant speed . upon hitting the tube walls ,
they are reflected randomly , according to the cosine law : the density of the outgoing direction is proportional to the cosine of the angle between this direction and the normal vector .
steady state transport is studied by introducing an open tube segment as follows : we cut out a large finite segment of the tube with segment boundaries perpendicular to the tube axis .
particles which leave this piece through the segment boundaries disappear from the system . through stationary injection of particles at one boundary of the segment a steady state with non - vanishing stationary particle current
is maintained .
we prove ( i ) that in the thermodynamic limit of an infinite open piece the coarse - grained density profile inside the segment is linear , and ( ii ) that the transport diffusion coefficient obtained from the ratio of stationary current and effective boundary density gradient equals the diffusion coefficient of a tagged particle in an infinite tube .
thus we prove fick s law and equality of transport diffusion and self - diffusion coefficients for quite generic rough ( random ) tubes .
we also study some properties of the crossing time and compute the milne extrapolation length in dependence on the shape of the random tube . +
* keywords : * cosine law , knudsen random walk , random medium , self - diffusion coefficient , transport diffusion coefficient , random walk in random environment + * ams 2000 subject classifications : * 60k37 .
secondary : 37d50 , 60j25 @xmath0universit paris 7 , ufr de mathmatiques , case 7012 , 2 , place jussieu , f75251 paris cedex 05 , france + e - mail : ` [email protected] ` , url : ` http://www.proba.jussieu.fr/\simcomets ` @xmath1department of statistics , institute of mathematics , statistics and scientific computation , university of campinas unicamp , rua srgio buarque de holanda 651 , cep 13083859 , campinas sp , brazil + e - mails : ` [email protected] ` , ` [email protected] ` + urls : ` http://www.ime.unicamp.br/\simpopov ` , ` http://www.ime.unicamp.br/\simmarinav ` @xmath2forschungszentrum jlich gmbh , institut fr festkrperforschung , d52425 jlich , deutschland + e - mail : ` [email protected] ` , + url : ` http://www.fz-juelich.de/iff/staff/schuetz_g/ ` |
microscopic _ ab - initio _ many - body approaches have significantly progressed in recent years @xcite .
nowdays , due to increased computing power and novel techniques , _ ab - initio _ calculations are able to reproduce a large number of observables for atomic nuclei with mass up to a=14 .
the light nuclei have also served as a crucial site to recognize the important role of three - body forces and three - body correlations .
approaches like the no - core shell model ( ncsm ) @xcite , the green s function monte carlo ( gfmc ) @xcite and the coupled - cluster theory with single and double excitations ( ccsd ) @xcite can be formally extended for heavier nuclei .
however , the explosive growth in computational power , required to achieve convergent results , severely hinders the detailed _ ab - initio _ studies of heavier , a@xmath3 , nuclei . in the case of the ncsm ,
the slow convergence of the calculated energies is caused by the adoption of a two - body cluster approximation , which does not take many - body correlations into account .
straightforward employment of the three - body and higher - body interactions dramatically complicates the problem , even for light nuclei .
an alternative approach is to construct a small - space effective two - body interaction , which would account for the many - body correlations for the a - body system in a large space .
attempts to include many - body correlations approximately modifying the one - body part of the effective two - body hamiltonian and employing a unitary transformation have been reported recently @xcite . in this paper
we derive a valence space ( @xmath1 ) effective two - body interaction that accounts for all the core - polarization effects available in the _ ab - initio _ ncsm wavefunctions .
first , in the framework of the ncsm , we construct the effective hamiltonians on the two - body cluster level for a=6 systems in the @xmath4 space .
@xmath5 represents the limit on the total oscillator quanta ( n ) above the minimum configuration .
we take @xmath5 values from 2 to 12 .
second , following the original idea of ref .
@xcite , we employ an unitary many - body transformation and obtain the effective two - body hamiltonian in the @xmath6 space ( p - shell space ) , which exactly reproduces the lowest , @xmath6 space dominated , eigenstates of the 6-body hamiltonian in the large @xmath4 space .
third , we perform ncsm calculations for a=4 and a=5 systems with the effective hamiltonian constructed on the two - body cluster level for the a=6 system and determine the core and one - body parts of the effective two - body hamiltonian for a=6 in the p - shell space .
finally , the procedure is generalized for arbitrary mass number a. we analyze the properties of the constructed two - body hamiltonians , investigate their efficiency to reproduce the observables of different a - body systems calculated in large @xmath4 spaces and study the role of the effective p - shell space three - body interaction .
the starting point of the no core shell model ( ncsm ) approach is the bare , exact a - body hamiltonian constrained by the harmonic oscillator ( ho ) potential @xcite : @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the one - body ho hamiltonian @xmath9 and @xmath10 is a bare nn interaction @xmath11 modified by the term introducing a- and @xmath12-dependent corrections to offset the ho potential present in @xmath8 : @xmath13 the eigenvalue problem for the exact a - body hamiltonian ( [ homa ] ) for @xmath14 is very complicated technically , since an extremely large a - body ho basis is required to obtain converged results .
however , the @xmath15 problem is considerably simpler . for many realistic nn interactions its solution in the relative ho basis with
@xmath16 accounts well for the short range correlations and is a precise approximation for the infinite space ( @xmath17 ) result .
this allows one to adopt the two - body cluster approximation to construct the ncsm effective two - body hamiltonian @xmath18 for an a - body system in an @xmath19 space of tractable dimension , where the lower index @xmath20 stands for the number of particles in the cluster .
this approximation consists of solving eq.([homa ] ) for the @xmath21 body subsystem of a leading to @xmath22 the information about the total number of interacting particles a enters the bare @xmath23 hamiltonian through the second term in the right hand side of ( [ voma ] ) .
next , we find the unitary transformation @xmath24 which reduces the bare @xmath23 hamiltonian in the `` infinite space '' ( @xmath25 ) to the diagonal form : @xmath26 where , for the sake of simplicity , we omit the index @xmath27 for @xmath24 and keep only the index @xmath20 indicating the order of cluster approximation .
the matrix @xmath24 can be split into 4 blocks : @xmath28 where the square @xmath29 @xmath30 matrix corresponds to the p - space ( or model space ) of dimension @xmath31 , characterized by the chosen @xmath5 value .
taking into account that the @xmath32 matrix has a diagonal form @xmath33 one can calculate the effective @xmath34 hamiltonian using the following formula : @xmath35 it is easy to show by inserting eq.([homa2e ] ) into the eq.([heff1 ] ) , and taking into account eq.([udec ] ) that the unitary transformation ( [ heff1 ] ) is equivalent to the commonly used unitary transformation @xcite and that eq.([heff1 ] ) is identical to the eqs.(15,16 ) from @xcite .
we note , that , by using eq.([heff1 ] ) one does not need to calculate and store a large number of matrix elements of the @xmath36-operator ( i.e. , @xmath37 ) . furthermore , the decoupling condition @xmath38 is automatically satisfied , which is obvious from the diagonal form of the @xmath32 matrix .
we note that our treatment of center - of - mass motion remains the same as in the ncsm ( ref .
we initiate all effective interaction developments at the a - body level , and , through a series of steps , arrive at a smaller space effective interaction appropriate for the a - body system . for this reason ,
our derived effective hamiltonians have their first subscript as `` a '' .
the next step of the traditional ncsm prescription is to construct the full a - body hamiltonian using the effective two - body hamiltonian ( [ heff1 ] ) and to diagonalize it in the a - body @xmath5 model space .
as we increase the number of nucleons , the dimension of the corresponding @xmath5 model space increases very rapidly . for instance , up - to - date computing resources allow us to go as high as @xmath39 for the lower part of the p - shell ( a=5,6 ) @xcite , while already for the upper part of the p - shell ( a@xmath4015 ) , we are limited to @xmath41 .
the computational eigenvalue problem for many - body systems is complicated because of the very large matrix dimensions involved .
the largest dimension of the model space that we encountered in this study for @xmath42li with @xmath43 exceeds @xmath44 . to solve this problem
we have used the specialized version of the shell - model code antoine @xcite , recently adapted for the ncsm @xcite .
in fact , the ncsm calculation for the a=6 system in the @xmath43 space yields nearly converged energies for the lowest states dominated by the @xmath45 components , while there is incomplete convergence for @xmath46 in @xmath41 space .
therefore , considering the @xmath43 ncsm results as exact solutions for the lowest @xmath45 dominated 6-body states , we may construct the @xmath47 space hamiltonian for the a=6 system , which exactly reproduces those @xmath43 eigenvalues @xcite .
moreover , if it is possible to solve the 6-body problem for a=6 , then it is possible to solve the 6-body problem for arbitrary a , using the corresponding effective hamiltonian @xmath34 obtained in the two - body cluster approximation .
this means that we can determine for any a - body system the effective hamiltonian in the @xmath47 space , which accounts for 6-body cluster dynamics in the large @xmath43 space .
to generalize , we start by defining the procedure for determining the effective hamiltonian matrix elements for the @xmath48-body cluster in the a - nucleon system .
we do this by constructing the full @xmath48-body hamiltonian using the effective 2-body hamiltonian ( [ heff1 ] ) and diagonalizing it in the @xmath5 model space . in the spirit of eq.([homa2 ] ) , this yields the eigenenergies @xmath49 of the @xmath48-body system and their corresponding @xmath48 eigenvectors which make up the unitary transformation matrix @xmath50 .
these @xmath48-body results can then be projected into a smaller , secondary @xmath51-space , given by @xmath52 with @xmath53 , where , similar to eqs.([udec ] ) and ( [ edec ] ) , @xmath49 and @xmath50 can be split into parts related to the two spaces , @xmath51 and @xmath54 , where @xmath55 .
the new secondary effective hamiltonian then takes the following general form : @xmath56 where the @xmath12 superscript on the left - hand side is omitted for the sake of simplicity . as stated earlier
, the new index @xmath48 determines the order of the cluster approximation in the smaller @xmath51 space , _ i.e. _ , @xmath53 .
because the @xmath51 space has @xmath53 , the projection into this space `` freezes '' some number of the @xmath48 nucleons into fixed single particle configurations , which can be thought of as the `` inert core '' states in the standard shell model ( ssm ) approach .
consequently , it is possible to write @xmath48 as @xmath57 , where @xmath58 is the number of nucleons making up the core configuration , while @xmath59 refers to the size of valence cluster .
for instance , in the case of p - shell nuclei , @xmath60 , so , if @xmath61 ( _ i.e. _ the 5-body cluster approximation ) , then the effective hamiltonian @xmath62 is simply a one - body hamiltonian ( @xmath63 ) appropriate for the a - nucleon system .
similarly , for the 6-body cluster approximation , _
i.e. _ , @xmath64 , we obtain the effective hamiltonian @xmath65 , which is a two - body hamiltonian ( @xmath66 ) for the a - body system , and , so on for larger values of @xmath48 .
whatever the value of @xmath59 is , the effective hamiltonian @xmath67 contains the information about the @xmath48-body dynamics in the original large @xmath19 space , since it reproduces exactly the lowest @xmath68 eigenvalues @xmath69 of the @xmath48-body hamiltonian in the @xmath19 space , where @xmath68 is a dimension of the @xmath51 space . in the case of a doubly magic
closed shell with two extra nucleons i.e. , @xmath70 , _ etc .
_ , the dimension of the effective hamiltonian @xmath71 is a 2-body ( @xmath66 ) hamiltonian in the p- , sd- , pf - spaces , _ etc .
_ , respectively .
this means that the secondary effective hamiltonian ( [ heff2 ] ) contains only 1-body and 2-body terms , even after the _ exact _ a - body cluster transformation .
this effective hamiltonian ( [ heff2 ] ) , which now contains the correlation energy of a nucleons , is the correct one - body plus two - body hamiltonian to use in a ssm calculation with inert core .
the @xmath72 nucleon - spectators fully occupy the shells below the valence shell and the total a - body wave - function can be exactly factorized as the @xmath58-body `` core '' and the valence 2-body wave functions .
this considerably simplifies the calculation of the effective hamiltonian , because only the @xmath6 part ( p@xmath73-space part ) of the complete @xmath4 wave function needs to be specified .
utilizing the approach outlined above , we have calculated effective p - shell hamiltonians for @xmath74li , using the 6-body hamiltonians with @xmath75 and @xmath76 mev , constructed from the inoy ( inside nonlocal outside yukawa ) interaction @xcite .
this is a new type of interaction , which has local behavior appropriate for traditional nn interactions at longer ranges , but exhibits a nonlocality at shorter distances .
the nonlocality of the nn interaction has been introduced in order to account effectively for three - nucleon ( nnn ) interactions which correctly describe the nnn bound states @xmath77h and @xmath77he , whereas still reproducing nn scattering data with high precision .
the corresponding excitation energies of p - shell dominated states and the binding energy of @xmath74li are shown in fig.[spectra6li14hw ] as a function of @xmath5 .
the dimension of the configurational space for the @xmath43 case considered is 48 million ( m - scheme ) . a two orders of magnitude increase in the size of the model space , as compared to the previous @xmath78 study @xcite , allows us to determine a converged value of 31.681 mev for the @xmath42li binding energy .
furthermore , the excitation energy of the highest lying p - space state , @xmath79 , is lowered by an amount of 2.1 mev in comparison to the @xmath78 case , indicating improved convergence for both the excited states and ground state for @xmath43 . in the ssm an effective two - body hamiltonian for a nucleus with mass number
a is represented in terms of three components : @xmath80 where @xmath81 is the inert core part associated with the interaction of the nucleons occupying closed shells , @xmath82 is the one - body part corresponding to the interaction of valence nucleons with core nucleons , and @xmath83 is the two - body part referring to the interaction between valence particles .
it is usually assumed that the core and one - body parts are constant for an arbitrary number of valence particles and that only the two - body part @xmath83 may contain mass dependence that includes effects of three - body and higher - body interactions . to represent the @xmath84 hamiltonian in the ssm format
, we develop a valence cluster expansion ( vce ) , @xmath85 where the lower index , k , stands for the k - body interaction in the @xmath59-body valence cluster ( @xmath86 ) ; the first upper index a for the mass dependence ; and the second upper index , @xmath87 for the number of particles contributing to the corresponding k - body part .
thus , we consider the more general case of allowing the core ( k=0 ) , one - body ( k=1 ) and other k - body parts to vary with the mass number a. this appears necessary to include the a - dependence of the excitations of the core ( @xmath58 ) nucleons treated in the original n@xmath88 basis space . for the a=6 case the two - body valence cluster ( 2bvc )
approximation is exact : @xmath89 where the core part , @xmath90 , is defined as the ground state @xmath91 energy of @xmath92he calculated in the @xmath19 space with the tbmes of the primary effective hamiltonian , @xmath93 for a=6 .
then the one - body part , @xmath94,is determined as @xmath95 the tbmes of the one - body part , @xmath94 , @xmath96 may be represented in terms of single particle energies ( spe ) , @xmath97 : @xmath98 where the index a ( as well as b , c , and d ) denotes the set of single particle ho quantum numbers @xmath99 , upper index stands for proton ( p ) and neutron ( n ) , and the e(@xmath100li , j ) , e(@xmath100he , j ) are ncsm energies of the lowest @xmath101 and @xmath102 states calculated in the @xmath4 space for the @xmath103-body system using the tbmes of the @xmath104 effective hamiltonian , @xmath105 , which includes coulomb energy .
finally , the two - body part @xmath106 is obtained by subtracting of two hamiltonians : @xmath107 it is worth noting that since the coulomb energy is included in the original hamiltonian , the proton - proton ( pp ) , neutron - neutron ( nn ) and proton - neutron ( pn ) @xmath108 tbmes of the two - body part , @xmath109 , have different values .
the pn tbmes of the core , one - body and two - body parts of the expanded hamiltonian for @xmath42li are listed in the table i. [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^ , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > " , ] obtained results indicate that accounting for the effective 3-body interactions considerably improves the agreement with the exact ncsm for the @xmath110he , does not bring much change for @xmath111he and yields worse results for @xmath112he ( see fig.[he8 - 9 ] ) . performing a similar calculation with the effective interaction obtained in the 3bvc approximation starting from the cd - bonn interaction @xcite , we obtained results which are shown in fig.[he8 - 9cd ] .
note , that the effective cd - bonn interaction constructed in the 2bvc approximation considerably underbinds the he isotopes in comparison to the exact ncsm results .
the subsequent employment of the 3bvc approximation compensates these large differences and yields much better results for @xmath112he .
however , to draw more quantitative conclusion about the 3-body and higher - body effective interactions , one needs to perform exact diagonalization using the 3bmes
. we will evaluate this effect in future studies .
within the ncsm approach we can calculate , by exact projection , full a - nucleon dependent tbmes ( and 3bmes ) . these a - dependent tbmes ( and 3bmes ) can be separated into core , one - body and two - body ( and three - body ) parts , all of which are also a - dependent , contrary to the ssm approach .
when these a - dependent effective one- and two - body ( and three - body ) interactions are employed in ssm calculations , they exactly reproduce full ncsm calculations for a=6 ( a=7 ) isobars and yield results in good agreement with full ncsm calculations for @xmath113 performed in large basis spaces .
our results for @xmath113 , which include the 3-body effective interaction , indicate that 3- and higher - body effective interactions may play an important role in determining their binding energies and spectra .
future investigations will be extended to include effective 3-body interactions exactly and to explore other physical operators , such as transition operators and em moments .
we thank the institute for nuclear theory at the university of washington for its hospitality and the department of energy for partial support during the development of this work .
b.r.b . and a.f.l .
acknowledge partial support of this work from nsf grants phy0244389 and
phy0555396 ; p.n . acknowledges support in part by the u.s .
doe / sc / np ( work proposal n. scw0498 ) and u.s department of energy grant de - fg02 - 87er40371 ; j.p.v . acknowledges support from u.s .
department of energy grants de - fg02 - 87er40371 and de - fc02 - 07er41457 ; and the work of i.s . was performed under the auspices of the u.s .
doe . prepared by llnl under contract de - ac52 - 07na27344 .
thanks the gesellschaft fr schwerionenforschung mbh darmstadt , germany , for its hospitality during the preparation of this manuscript and the alexander von humboldt stiftung for its support .
100 p. navratil , v. g. gueorgiev , j.p .
vary , w. e. ormand , and a. nogga , phys .
. lett . * 99 * , 042501 ( 2007 ) .
a. nogga , p.navratil , b.r.barrett , j.p.vary , phys . rev . c.
* 73 * , 064002 ( 2006 ) .
i. stetcu , b.r.barrett , p.navratil , j.p.vary , phys . rev . c.
* 71 * , 044325 ( 2005 ) .
p. navratil and w.e.ormand , phys .
lett . * 88 * , 152502 ( 2002 ) ; phys .
rev . c. * 68 * , 034305 ( 2003 ) .
p. navratil , j.p.vary , b.r.barrett , phys .
* 84 * , 5728 ( 2000 ) ; phys .
c. * 62 * , 054311 ( 2000 ) .
s. c. pieper , k. varga , and r. b. wiringa , phys .
c 66 , 044310 ( 2002 ) . s. pieper and r. b. wiringa , annu .
nucl . part .
sci . * 51 * , 53 ( 2001 ) .
k.kowalski , d.j.dean , m.hjorth-jensen , t.papenbrock , p.piecuch , phys .
92 , 132501 ( 2004 ) .
s. fujii , t. mizusaki , t. otsuka , t. sebe and a. arima , phys .
b650 * , 9 ( 2007 ) .
p. navratil , m. thoresen , and b. r. barrett , phys .
rev . c. * 55 * , r573 ( 1997 ) .
susumu okubo , prog .
12 , no.5 , 603 ( 1954 ) .
kenji suzuki , prog .
68 , no.1 , 246 ( 1982 ) .
p. navratil and e.caurier , phys .
rev . c. * 69 * , 014311 ( 2004 ) .
e. caurier and f. nowacki , acta .
b30 , ( 1999 ) 705 .
e. caurier , g. martinez - pinedo , f. nowacki , a. poves , j. retamosa , and a. p. zuker , phys .
c * 59 * , 2033 ( 1999 ) .
e. caurier , p. navratil , w. e. ormand , and j.p .
vary , phys .
c * 64 * , 051301(r ) ( 2001 ) .
d. r. entem and r. machleidt , phys .
rev . c. * 68 * , 041001(r ) ( 2003 ) .
p. doleschall , phys .
* 69 * , 054001 ( 2004 ) .
p. doleschall , i. borbely , z. papp , and w. plessas , phys .
rev . c. * 67 * , 0064005 ( 2003 ) .
b. r. barrett and m.w .
kirson , nucl .
a * 418 * , 145 ( 1970 ) .
j. p. vary , p. u. sauer and c. w. wong , phys .
rev . c. * 7 * , 1776 ( 1973 ) .
r. machleidt , f. sammarruca , and y. song , phys . rev . c.
* 53 * , 1483 ( 1996 ) . | we construct effective 2- and 3-body hamiltonians for the p - shell by performing @xmath0 _ ab initio _ no - core shell model ( ncsm ) calculations for a=6 and 7 nuclei and explicitly projecting the many - body hamiltonians onto the @xmath1 space .
we then separate these effective hamiltonians into 0- , 1- and 2-body contributions ( also 3-body for a=7 ) and analyze the systematic behavior of these different parts as a function of the mass number a and size of the ncsm basis space .
the role of effective 3- and higher - body interactions for @xmath2 is investigated and discussed . |
we will start by recalling from @xcite how to define intersection numbers in the algebraic setting .
we will connect this with the natural topological idea of intersection number already discussed in the introduction .
consider two simple closed curves @xmath1 and @xmath2 on a closed orientable surface @xmath0 . as in @xcite , it will be convenient to assume that @xmath1 and @xmath2 are shortest geodesics in some riemannian metric on @xmath0 so that they automatically intersect minimally .
we will interpret the intersection number of @xmath1 and @xmath2 in suitable covers of @xmath28 , exactly as in @xcite and @xcite .
let @xmath12 denote @xmath29 , let @xmath13 denote the infinite cyclic subgroup of @xmath12 carried by @xmath1 , and let @xmath30 denote the cover of @xmath0 with fundamental group equal to @xmath13 .
then @xmath1 lifts to @xmath30 and we denote its lift by @xmath1 again .
let @xmath31 denote the pre - image of this lift in the universal cover @xmath32 of @xmath0 .
the full pre - image of @xmath1 in @xmath33 consists of disjoint lines which we call @xmath1lines , which are all translates of @xmath31 by the action of @xmath12 .
( note that in this paper groups act on the left on covering spaces . )
similarly , we define @xmath11 , @xmath34 , the line @xmath35 and @xmath2lines in @xmath32 .
now we consider the images of the @xmath1lines in @xmath34 .
each @xmath1line has image in @xmath34 which is a line or circle
. then we define @xmath36 to be the number of images of @xmath1lines in @xmath37 which meet @xmath2 .
similarly , we define @xmath38 to be the number of images of @xmath2lines in @xmath30 which meet @xmath1 .
it is shown in @xcite , using the assumption that @xmath1 and @xmath2 are shortest closed geodesics , that each @xmath1line in @xmath34 crosses @xmath2 at most once , and similarly for @xmath2lines in @xmath30 .
it follows that @xmath36 and @xmath38 are each equal to the number of points of @xmath39 , and so they are equal to each other . we need to take one further step in abstracting the idea of intersection number .
as the stabiliser of @xmath31 is @xmath13 , the @xmath1lines naturally correspond to the cosets @xmath40 of @xmath13 in @xmath12 .
hence the images of the @xmath1lines in @xmath41 naturally correspond to the double cosets @xmath42 .
thus we can think of @xmath36 as the number of double cosets @xmath42 such that @xmath43 crosses @xmath35 .
this is the idea which we generalise to define intersection numbers in a purely algebraic setting .
first we need some terminology .
two sets @xmath44 and @xmath45 are _ almost equal _ if their symmetric difference @xmath46 is finite .
we write @xmath47 if a group @xmath12 acts on the right on a set @xmath48 , a subset @xmath44 of @xmath48 is _ almost invariant _ if @xmath49 for all @xmath50 in @xmath12 . an almost invariant subset @xmath44 of @xmath48 is _ non - trivial _ if @xmath44 and its complement @xmath51 are both infinite .
the complement @xmath51 will be denoted simply by @xmath52 , when @xmath48 is clear from the context for finitely generated groups , these ideas are closely connected with the theory of ends of groups via the cayley graph @xmath53 of @xmath12 with respect to some finite generating set of @xmath12 .
( note that @xmath12 acts on its cayley graph on the left . ) using @xmath54 as coefficients , we can identify @xmath55cochains and @xmath3cochains on @xmath53 with sets of vertices or edges .
a subset @xmath44 of @xmath12 represents a set of vertices of @xmath53 which we also denote by @xmath44 , and it is a beautiful fact , due to cohen @xcite , that @xmath56 is an almost invariant subset of @xmath12 if and only if @xmath57 is finite , where @xmath58 is the coboundary operator . now @xmath53 has more than one end if and only if there is an infinite subset @xmath44 of @xmath12 such that @xmath59 is finite and @xmath52 is also infinite . thus @xmath53 has more than one end if and only if @xmath12 contains a non - trivial almost invariant subset . if @xmath13 is a subgroup of @xmath12 , we let @xmath26 denote the set of cosets @xmath60 of @xmath13 in @xmath12 , ie , the quotient of @xmath12 by the left action of @xmath13
of course , @xmath12 will no longer act on the left on this quotient , but it will still act on the right .
thus we also have the idea of an almost invariant subset of @xmath26 , and the graph @xmath61 has more than one end if and only if @xmath26 contains a non - trivial almost invariant subset .
now the number of ends @xmath62 of @xmath12 is equal to the number of ends of @xmath53 , so it follows that @xmath63 if and only if @xmath64 contains a non - trivial almost invariant subset .
similarly , the number of ends @xmath65 of the pair @xmath66 equals the number of ends of @xmath67 , so that @xmath68 if and only if @xmath26 contains a non - trivial almost invariant subset .
now we return to the simple closed curves @xmath1 and @xmath2 on the surface @xmath0 . pick a generating set for @xmath12 which can be represented by a bouquet of circles embedded in @xmath0 .
we will assume that the wedge point of the bouquet does not lie on @xmath1 or @xmath2 .
the pre - image of this bouquet in @xmath32 will be a copy of the cayley graph @xmath53 of @xmath12 with respect to the chosen generating set .
the pre - image in @xmath30 of the bouquet will be a copy of the graph @xmath61 , the quotient of @xmath53 by the action of @xmath13 on the left . consider the closed curve @xmath1 on @xmath30 .
let @xmath44 denote the set of all vertices of @xmath61 which lie on one side of @xmath1 .
then @xmath44 has finite coboundary , as @xmath57 equals exactly the edges of @xmath61 which cross @xmath1 .
hence @xmath44 is an almost invariant subset of @xmath26 .
let @xmath69 denote the pre - image of @xmath44 in @xmath70 , so that @xmath69 equals the set of vertices of @xmath53 which lie on one side of the line @xmath31 .
now finally the connection between the earlier arguments and almost invariant sets can be given .
for we can decide whether the lines @xmath31 and @xmath35 cross by considering instead the sets @xmath69 and @xmath71 .
the lines @xmath31 and @xmath35 together divide @xmath12 into the four sets @xmath72 , @xmath73 , @xmath74 and @xmath75 , where @xmath76 denotes @xmath77 , and @xmath31 crosses @xmath35 if and only if each of these four sets projects to an infinite subset of @xmath78 now let @xmath12 be a group with subgroups @xmath13 and @xmath11 , let @xmath44 be a non - trivial almost invariant subset of @xmath26 and let @xmath45 be a non - trivial almost invariant subset of @xmath79 .
we will define the intersection number @xmath80 of @xmath44 and @xmath45 .
first we need to consider the analogues of the sets @xmath81and @xmath71 in the preceding paragraph , and to say what it means for them to cross .
if @xmath12 is a group and @xmath13 is a subgroup , then a subset @xmath69 of @xmath12 is @xmath13__-almost invariant _ _
if @xmath69 is invariant under the left action of @xmath13 , and simultaneously @xmath82 is an almost invariant subset of @xmath83 .
in addition , @xmath69 is a _ non - trivial _
@xmath13almost invariant subset of @xmath12 , if the quotient sets @xmath82 and @xmath84 are both infinite . note that if @xmath13 is trivial , then a @xmath13almost invariant subset of @xmath64 is the same as an almost invariant subset of @xmath12 .
let @xmath69 be a @xmath13almost invariant subset of @xmath12 and let @xmath71 be a @xmath11almost invariant subset of @xmath12 .
we will say that @xmath69 _ crosses _ @xmath71 if each of the four sets @xmath72 , @xmath85 , @xmath74 and @xmath86 projects to an infinite subset of @xmath78 we will often write @xmath87 instead of listing the four sets @xmath72 , @xmath85 , @xmath74 and @xmath88 if @xmath12 is a group and @xmath13 is a subgroup , then we will say that a subset @xmath89 of @xmath12 is @xmath13_finite _ if it is contained in the union of finitely many left cosets @xmath60 of @xmath13 in @xmath12 , and we will say that two subsets @xmath90 and @xmath89 of @xmath12 are @xmath13_almost equal _ if their symmetric difference is @xmath13finite . in this language , @xmath69 crosses @xmath71 if each of the four sets @xmath91 is not @xmath11finite .
this definition of crossing is not symmetric , but it is shown in @xcite that if @xmath12 is a finitely generated group with subgroups @xmath13 and @xmath11 , and @xmath69 is a non - trivial @xmath13almost invariant subset of @xmath12 and @xmath71 is a non - trivial @xmath11almost invariant subset of @xmath12 , then @xmath69 crosses @xmath71 if and only if @xmath71 crosses @xmath69 .
if @xmath69 and @xmath71 are both trivial , then neither can cross the other , so the above symmetry result is clear .
however , this symmetry result fails if only one of @xmath69 or @xmath71 is trivial .
this lack of symmetry will not concern us as we will only be interested in non - trivial almost invariant sets .
now we come to the definition of the intersection number of two almost invariant sets .
[ defnofintersectionnumber]let @xmath13 and @xmath11 be subgroups of a finitely generated group @xmath12 .
let @xmath44 denote a non - trivial almost invariant subset of @xmath26 , let @xmath45 denote a non - trivial almost invariant subset of @xmath92 and let @xmath69 and @xmath71 denote the pre - images of @xmath44 and @xmath45 respectively in @xmath12 .
then the intersection number @xmath80 of @xmath44 and @xmath45 equals the number of double cosets @xmath42 such that @xmath93 crosses @xmath94 [ almostequalsetshavesameintersectionnumber]the following facts about the intersection number are proved in @xcite . 1
. intersection numbers are symmetric , ie @xmath95 .
@xmath80 is finite when @xmath12 , @xmath13 , and @xmath11 are all finitely generated .
if @xmath96 is an almost invariant subset of @xmath26 which is almost equal to @xmath44 or to @xmath52 and if @xmath97 is an almost invariant subset of @xmath79 which is almost equal to @xmath45 or to @xmath98 , then @xmath99 we will often be interested in situations where @xmath69 and @xmath71 do not cross each other and neither do many of their translates .
this means that one of the four sets @xmath87 is @xmath11finite , and similar statements hold for many translates of @xmath81and @xmath71 .
if @xmath100 and @xmath101 do not cross , then one of the four sets @xmath102 is @xmath103finite , but probably not @xmath11finite .
thus one needs to keep track of which translates of @xmath69 and @xmath71 are being considered in order to have the correct conjugate of @xmath11 , when formulating the condition that @xmath104 and @xmath90 do not cross .
the following definition will be extremely convenient because it avoids this problem , thus greatly simplifying the discussion at certain points .
let @xmath104 be a @xmath13almost invariant subset of @xmath12 and let @xmath90 be a @xmath11almost invariant subset of @xmath12 .
we will say that @xmath105 is _ small _ if it is @xmath13finite .
as the terminology is not symmetric in @xmath104 and @xmath90 and makes no reference to @xmath13 or @xmath11 , some justification is required . if @xmath104 is also @xmath106almost invariant for a subgroup @xmath106 of @xmath12 , then @xmath106 must be commensurable with @xmath13 .
thus @xmath105 is @xmath13finite if and only if it is @xmath106finite .
in addition , the fact that crossing is symmetric tells us that @xmath105 is @xmath13finite if and only if it is @xmath11finite .
this provides the needed justification of our terminology .
finally , the reader should be warned that this use of the word small has nothing to do with the term small group which means a group with no subgroups which are free of rank @xmath107 . at this point
we have the machinery needed to define the intersection number of two splittings .
this definition depends on the fact , which we recall from @xcite , that if a group @xmath12 has a splitting over a subgroup @xmath13 , there is a @xmath13almost invariant subset @xmath69 of @xmath12 associated to the splitting in a natural way .
this is entirely clear from the topological point of view as follows .
if @xmath108 , let @xmath109 denote a space with fundamental group @xmath12 constructed in the usual way as the union of @xmath110 , @xmath111 and @xmath112 . if @xmath113 , then @xmath109 is constructed from @xmath110 and @xmath112 only . now let @xmath114 denote the based cover of @xmath109 with fundamental group @xmath13 , and denote the based lift of @xmath115 into @xmath114 by @xmath112
. then @xmath69 corresponds to choosing one side of @xmath112 in @xmath114 .
we now give a purely algebraic description of this choice of @xmath69 ( see @xcite for example ) .
if @xmath108 , choose right transversals @xmath116 , @xmath117 of @xmath118 in @xmath119 , @xmath120 , both of which contain the identity element .
( a right transversal for a subgroup @xmath13 of a group @xmath12 consists of one representative element for each right coset @xmath40 of @xmath13 in @xmath121 each element of @xmath12 can be expressed uniquely in the form @xmath122 with @xmath123 , @xmath124 , @xmath125 , where only @xmath126 , @xmath127 and @xmath128 are allowed to be trivial .
then @xmath69 consists of elements for which @xmath127 is non - trivial . in the case of a hnn
extension @xmath18 , let @xmath129 , @xmath130 , @xmath107 , denote the two inclusions of @xmath13 in @xmath119 so that @xmath131 , and choose right transversals @xmath132 of @xmath133 in @xmath119 , both of which contain the identity element .
each element of @xmath12 can be expressed uniquely in the form @xmath134 where @xmath135 lies in @xmath119 and , for @xmath136 , @xmath137 or @xmath138 , @xmath139 if @xmath137 , @xmath140 if @xmath141 and moreover @xmath142 if @xmath143 . in this case , @xmath69 consists of elements for which @xmath127 is trivial and @xmath144 . in both cases ,
the stabiliser of @xmath69 under the left action of @xmath12 is exactly @xmath13 and , for every @xmath145 , at least one of the four sets @xmath146 is empty .
note that this is equivalent to asserting that one of the four inclusions @xmath147 , @xmath148 , @xmath149 , @xmath150 holds
. the following terminology will be useful .
a collection @xmath151 of subsets of @xmath12 which are closed under complementation is called _ nested _ if for any pair @xmath104 and @xmath90 of sets in the collection , one of the four sets @xmath102 is empty .
if each element @xmath104 of @xmath151 is a @xmath152almost invariant subset of @xmath12 for some subgroup @xmath152 of @xmath12 , we will say that @xmath151 is _ _ almost nested _
_ if for any pair @xmath104 and @xmath90 of sets in the collection , one of the four sets @xmath102 is small .
the above discussion shows that the translates of @xmath69 and @xmath153 under the left action of @xmath12 are nested .
note that @xmath69 is not uniquely determined by the splitting . in both cases
, we made choices of transversals , but it is easy to see that @xmath69 is independent of the choice of transversal .
however , in the case when @xmath108 , we chose @xmath69 to consist of elements for which @xmath127 is non - trivial whereas we could equally well have reversed the roles of @xmath119 and @xmath120 .
this would simply replace @xmath69 by @xmath154 .
also either of these sets could be replaced by its complement .
we will use the term _ standard almost invariant set _ for the images in @xmath26 of any one of @xmath69 , @xmath155 , @xmath153 , @xmath154 . in the case when @xmath113 , reversing the roles of the two inclusion maps of @xmath13 into @xmath119 also replaces @xmath69 by @xmath154 .
again we have four standard almost invariant sets which are the images in @xmath83 of any one of @xmath69 , @xmath155 , @xmath153 , @xmath154 .
there is a subtle point here . in the amalgamated free product case
, we use the obvious isomorphism between @xmath17 and @xmath156 . in the hnn case ,
let us write @xmath157 to denote the group @xmath158 .
then the correct isomorphism to use between @xmath159 and @xmath160 is not the identity on @xmath119 .
instead it sends @xmath161 to @xmath162 and @xmath119 to @xmath163 . in all cases
, we have four standard almost invariant subsets of @xmath164 [ defnofintersectionnumberofsplittings]if a group @xmath12 has splittings over subgroups @xmath13 and @xmath11 , and if @xmath44 and @xmath45 are standard almost invariant subsets of @xmath26 and @xmath79 respectively associated to these splittings , then the _ intersection number _ of this pair of splittings of @xmath12 is the intersection number of @xmath44 and @xmath165 [ xgisequivalenttox]as any two of the four standard almost invariant subsets of @xmath26 associated to a splitting of @xmath12 over @xmath13 are almost equal or almost complementary , remark [ almostequalsetshavesameintersectionnumber ] tells us that this definition does not depend on the choice of standard almost invariant subsets @xmath44 and @xmath166 .
if @xmath69 and @xmath71 denote the pre - images in @xmath12 of @xmath167and @xmath45 respectively , and if we conjugate the first splitting by @xmath168 and the second by @xmath169 , then @xmath170 is replaced by @xmath171 and @xmath172is replaced by @xmath173 . now @xmath174 is @xmath13almost equal to @xmath69 and @xmath175 is @xmath11almost equal to @xmath71 , because of the general fact that for any subset @xmath89 of @xmath12 and any element @xmath50 of @xmath12 , the set @xmath176 lies in a @xmath31neighbourhood of @xmath89 , where @xmath31 equals the length of @xmath50 .
this follows from the equations @xmath177 .
it follows that the intersection number of a pair of splittings is unchanged if we replace them by conjugate splittings .
now we can state two easy results about the case of zero intersection number . recall that if @xmath69 is one of the standard @xmath13almost invariant subsets of _ _ _ _ @xmath12 determined by a splitting of @xmath12 over @xmath13 , then the set of translates of @xmath81and @xmath153 is nested .
it follows at once that the self - intersection number of @xmath82 is zero . also if two splittings of @xmath12 over subgroups @xmath13 and @xmath11 are compatible , and if @xmath170 and @xmath71 denote corresponding standard @xmath13almost and @xmath11almost invariant subsets of @xmath12 , then the set of all translates of @xmath69 , @xmath153 , @xmath71 , @xmath178 is also nested , so that the intersection number of the two splittings is zero .
the next section is devoted to proving converses to each of these statements . before going further
, we need to say a little more about splittings .
recall from the introduction that a group @xmath12 is said to split over a subgroup @xmath13 if @xmath12 is isomorphic to @xmath18 or to @xmath17 , with @xmath179 .
we will need a precise definition of a splitting .
we will say that a _ splitting _ of @xmath12 consists either of proper subgroups @xmath119 and @xmath120 of @xmath12 and a subgroup @xmath13 of @xmath180 such that the natural map @xmath181 is an isomorphism , or it consists of a subgroup @xmath119 of @xmath182 and subgroups @xmath183 and @xmath184 of @xmath119 such that there is an element @xmath185 of @xmath12 which conjugates @xmath183 to @xmath184 and the natural map @xmath186 is an isomorphism .
recall also that a collection of @xmath23 splittings of a group @xmath12 is _ compatible _ if @xmath12 can be expressed as the fundamental group of a graph of groups with @xmath23 edges , such that , for each @xmath24 , collapsing all edges but the @xmath24-th yields the @xmath24-th splitting of @xmath25 we note that if a splitting of a group @xmath12 over a subgroup @xmath13 is compatible with a conjugate of itself by some element @xmath50 of @xmath12 , then @xmath50 must lie in @xmath13 .
this follows from a simple analysis of the possibilities . for example
, if the splitting @xmath187 is compatible with its conjugate by some @xmath145 , then @xmath12 is the fundamental group of a graph of groups with two edges , which must be a tree , such that collapsing one edge yields the first splitting and collapsing the other yields its conjugate by @xmath50 .
this means that each of the two extreme vertex groups of the tree must be one of @xmath119 , @xmath188 , @xmath120 or @xmath189 , and the same holds for the subgroup of @xmath12 generated by the two vertex groups of an edge .
now it is easy to see that @xmath190 and @xmath191 , or the same inclusions hold with the roles of @xmath119 and @xmath120 reversed . in either case
it follows that @xmath50 lies in @xmath13 as claimed .
the case when @xmath192 is slightly different , but the conclusion is the same .
this leads us to the following idea of equivalence of two splittings .
we will say that two amalgamated free product splittings of @xmath12 are equivalent , if they are obtained from the same choice of subgroups @xmath119 , @xmath120 and @xmath13 of @xmath12 .
this means that the splittings @xmath17 and @xmath156 of @xmath12 are equivalent .
similarly , a splitting @xmath18 of @xmath12 is equivalent to the splitting obtained by interchanging the two subgroups @xmath183 and @xmath184 of @xmath119 .
also we will say that any splitting of a group @xmath12 over a subgroup @xmath13 is equivalent to any conjugate by some element of @xmath13 .
then the equivalence relation on all splittings of @xmath12 which this generates is the idea of equivalence which we will need . stated in this language
, we see that if two splittings are compatible and conjugate , then they must be equivalent .
note that two splittings of a group @xmath12 are equivalent if and only if they are over the same subgroup @xmath13 , and they have exactly the same four standard almost invariant sets . next we need to recall the connection between splittings of groups and actions on trees .
serre theory , @xcite or @xcite , tells us that if a group @xmath12 splits over a subgroup @xmath13 , then @xmath12 acts without inversions on a tree @xmath193 , so that the quotient is a graph with a single edge and the vertex stabilisers are conjugate to @xmath119 or @xmath120 and the edge stabilisers are conjugate to @xmath13 . in his important paper @xcite ,
dunwoody gave a method for constructing such a @xmath12tree starting from the subset @xmath69 of @xmath12 defined above .
the crucial property of @xmath170 which is needed for the construction is the nestedness of the set of translates of @xmath69 under the left action of @xmath12 .
we recall dunwoody s result : [ dunwoodytreeconstruction]let @xmath151 be a partially ordered set equipped with an involution @xmath194 , where @xmath195 , such that the following conditions hold : 1 . if @xmath196 , @xmath197 and @xmath198 , then @xmath199 .
2 . if @xmath196 , @xmath197 , there are only finitely many @xmath200 such that @xmath201 .
3 . if @xmath196 , @xmath197 , at least one of the four relations @xmath198 , @xmath202 , @xmath203 , @xmath204 holds .
if @xmath196 , @xmath197 , one can not have @xmath198 and @xmath205 then there is an abstract tree @xmath193 with edge set equal to @xmath151 such that the order relation which @xmath151 induces on the edge set of @xmath193 is equal to the order relation in which @xmath198 if and only if there is an oriented path in @xmath193 which begins with @xmath196 and ends with @xmath206 one applies this result to the set @xmath207 with the partial order given by inclusion and the involution by complementation .
there is a natural action of @xmath12 on @xmath151 and hence on the tree @xmath193 . in most cases , @xmath12 acts on @xmath193 without inversions
and we can recover the original decomposition from this action as follows .
let @xmath196 denote the edge of @xmath193 determined by @xmath69 .
then @xmath69 can be described as the set @xmath208 or @xmath209 .
if the action of @xmath12 on @xmath193 has inversions , then the original splitting must have been an amalgamated free product decomposition @xmath210 , with @xmath13 of index @xmath107 in @xmath119 . in this case , subdividing the edges of @xmath193 yields a tree @xmath211 on which @xmath12 acts without inversions .
if @xmath212 denotes the edge of @xmath211 contained in @xmath196 and containing the terminal vertex of @xmath196 , then @xmath69 can be described as the set @xmath213 or @xmath214 .
now we will prove the following result .
this implies part 2 ) of remark [ almostequalsetshavesameintersectionnumber ] .
we give the proof here because the proof in @xcite is not complete , and we will need to apply the methods of proof later in this paper . [ finitenumberofdoublecosets]let @xmath12 be a finitely generated group with finitely generated subgroups @xmath13 and @xmath11 , a non - trivial @xmath13almost invariant subset @xmath69 and a non - trivial @xmath11almost invariant subset @xmath71 .
then @xmath215 and @xmath71 are not nested } consists of a finite number of double cosets @xmath216 let @xmath53 denote the cayley graph of @xmath12 with respect to some finite generating set for @xmath12 .
let @xmath44 denote the almost invariant subset @xmath217 of @xmath26 and let @xmath45 denote the almost invariant subset @xmath218 of @xmath79 . recall from the start of this section , that if we identify @xmath44 with the @xmath219cochain on @xmath220 whose support is @xmath44 , then @xmath44 is an almost invariant subset of @xmath83 if and only if @xmath57 is finite .
thus @xmath57 is a finite collection of edges in @xmath61 and similarly @xmath221 is a finite collection of edges in @xmath222 .
now let @xmath223 denote a finite connected subgraph of @xmath61 such that @xmath223 contains @xmath224 and the natural map @xmath225 is onto , and let @xmath151 denote a finite connected subgraph of @xmath222 such that @xmath151 contains @xmath221 and the natural map @xmath226 is onto .
thus the pre - image @xmath227 of @xmath223 in @xmath53 is connected and contains @xmath228 , and the pre - image @xmath0 of @xmath151 in @xmath53 is connected and contains @xmath229 let @xmath230 denote a finite subgraph of @xmath227 which projects onto @xmath223 , and let @xmath231 denote a finite subgraph of @xmath0 which projects onto @xmath151 . if @xmath232 meets @xmath0 , there must be elements @xmath126 and @xmath4 in @xmath13 and @xmath11 such that @xmath233 meets @xmath234 .
now @xmath235 meets @xmath236 is finite , as @xmath12 acts freely on @xmath53 .
it follows that @xmath237 meets @xmath238 consists of a finite number of double cosets @xmath239 the result would now be trivial if @xmath69 and @xmath71 were each the vertex set of a connected subgraph of @xmath53 . as this need not be the case
, we need to make a careful argument as in the proof of lemma 5.10 of @xcite .
consider @xmath50 in @xmath12 such that @xmath232 and @xmath0 are disjoint .
we will show that @xmath93 and @xmath71 are nested .
as @xmath227 is connected , the vertex set of @xmath232 must lie entirely in @xmath71 or entirely in @xmath240 suppose that the vertex set of @xmath232 lies in @xmath71 . for a set @xmath2 of vertices of @xmath53 , let @xmath241 denote the maximal subgraph of @xmath53 with vertex set equal to @xmath2 .
each component @xmath89 of @xmath242 and @xmath243 contains a vertex of @xmath227 .
hence @xmath244 contains a vertex of @xmath232 and so must meet @xmath71 .
if @xmath244 also meets @xmath178 , then it must meet @xmath0 .
but as @xmath0 is connected and disjoint from @xmath232 , it lies in a single component @xmath244 .
it follows that there is exactly one component @xmath244 of @xmath245 and @xmath246 which meets @xmath178 , so that we must have @xmath247 or @xmath248 .
similarly , if @xmath232 lies in @xmath178 , we will find that @xmath249 or @xmath250 .
it follows that in either case @xmath93 and @xmath71 are nested as required . in theorem 2.2 of @xcite
, scott used dunwoody s theorem to prove a general splitting result in the context of surfaces in @xmath9manifolds .
we will use the ideas in his proof a great deal .
the following theorem is the natural generalisation of his result to our more general context and will be needed in the proofs of theorems [ disjointsplittings ] and [ splittingsexist ] .
the first part of the theorem directly corresponds to the result proved in @xcite , and the second part is a simple generalisation which will be needed later .
@xmath251 [ algebrafromtorustheorem ] 1 .
let @xmath13 be a finitely generated subgroup of a finitely generated group @xmath12 .
let @xmath69 be a non - trivial @xmath13almost invariant set in @xmath12 such that @xmath207 is almost nested and if two of the four sets @xmath252 are small , then at least one of them is empty
. then @xmath12 splits over the stabilizer @xmath106 of @xmath69 and @xmath27 contains @xmath13 as a subgroup of finite index .
further , one of the @xmath106almost invariant sets @xmath71 determined by the splitting is @xmath13almost equal to @xmath253 2 .
let @xmath254 be finitely generated subgroups of a finitely generated group @xmath12 .
let @xmath255 , @xmath256 , be a non - trivial @xmath257almost invariant set in @xmath12 such that @xmath258 is almost nested .
suppose further that , for any pair of elements @xmath104 and @xmath90 of @xmath151 , if two of the four sets @xmath259 are small , then at least one of them is empty .
then @xmath12 can be expressed as the fundamental group of a graph of groups whose @xmath24-th edge corresponds to a conjugate of a splitting of @xmath12 over the stabilizer @xmath260 of @xmath255 , and @xmath261 contains @xmath257 as a subgroup of finite index .
further , for each @xmath24 , one of the @xmath261almost invariant sets determined by the @xmath24-th splitting is @xmath257almost equal to @xmath255 .
most of the arguments needed to prove this theorem are contained in the proof of theorem 2.2 of @xcite , but in the context of @xmath9manifolds .
we will present the proof of the first part of this theorem , and then briefly discuss the proof of the second part .
the idea in the first part is to define a partial order on @xmath207 , which coincides with inclusion whenever possible .
let @xmath104 and @xmath90 denote elements of @xmath151 .
if @xmath262 is small , we want to define @xmath263 .
there is a difficulty , which is what to do if @xmath104 and @xmath90 are distinct but @xmath264 and @xmath265 are both small .
however , the assumption in the statement of theorem [ algebrafromtorustheorem ] is that if two of the four sets @xmath102 are small , then one of them is empty .
thus , as in @xcite , we define @xmath263 if and only if @xmath262 is empty or the only small set of the four .
note that if @xmath266 then @xmath263 .
we will show that this definition yields a partial order on @xmath267 as usual , we let @xmath53 denote the cayley graph of @xmath12 with respect to some finite generating set .
the distance between two points of @xmath12 is the usual one of minimal edge path length .
our first step is the analogue of lemma 2.3 of @xcite .
[ smallimpliesinboundednbhd]@xmath262 is small if and only if it lies in a bounded neighbourhood of each of @xmath268 , @xmath90 , @xmath269 as @xmath104 and @xmath90 are translates of @xmath69 or @xmath153 , it suffices to prove that @xmath270 is small if and only if it lies in a bounded neighbourhood of each of @xmath69 , @xmath153 , @xmath93 , @xmath271 .
if @xmath272 is small , it projects to a finite subset of @xmath26 which therefore lies within a bounded neighbourhood of the image of @xmath273 . by lifting paths , we see that each point of @xmath270 lies in a bounded neighbourhood of @xmath273 , and hence lies in a bounded neighbourhood of @xmath69 and @xmath153 . by reversing the roles of @xmath93 and @xmath274
, we also see that @xmath270 lies in a bounded neighbourhood of each of @xmath93 and @xmath275 for the converse , suppose that @xmath270 lies in a bounded neighbourhood of each of @xmath69 and @xmath153
. then it must lie in a bounded neighbourhood of @xmath273 , so that its image in @xmath26 must lie in a bounded neighbourhood of the image of @xmath273 . as
this image is finite , it follows that @xmath270 must be small , as required .
now we can prove that our definition of @xmath276 yields a partial order on @xmath277 our proof is essentially the same as in lemma 2.4 of @xcite .
[ partialorder]if a relation @xmath276 is defined on @xmath151 by the condition that @xmath263 if and only if @xmath262 is empty or the only small set of the four sets @xmath102 , then @xmath276 is a partial order .
we need to show that @xmath276 is transitive and that if @xmath263 and @xmath278 then @xmath279 suppose first that @xmath263 and @xmath280 .
the first inequality implies that @xmath262 is small and the second implies that @xmath265 is small , so that two of the four sets @xmath102 are small .
the assumption of theorem [ algebrafromtorustheorem ] implies that one of these two sets must be empty . as @xmath263
, our definition of @xmath276 implies that @xmath262 is empty .
similarly , the fact that @xmath280 tells us that @xmath265 is empty .
this implies that @xmath281 as required . to prove transitivity ,
let @xmath104 , @xmath90 and @xmath89 be elements of @xmath151 such that @xmath282 .
we must show that @xmath283 our first step is to show that @xmath284 is small . as @xmath285 and @xmath286 are small , we let @xmath287 be an upper bound for the distance of points of @xmath262 from @xmath90 and let @xmath288 be an upper bound for the distance of points of @xmath286 from @xmath89 .
let @xmath289 be a point of @xmath284 .
if @xmath289 lies in @xmath90 , then it lies in @xmath290 and so has distance at most @xmath288 from @xmath89 .
otherwise , it must lie in @xmath262 and so have distance at most @xmath287 from some point @xmath291 of @xmath90 . if @xmath291 lies in @xmath89
, then @xmath289 has distance at most @xmath287 from @xmath89 .
otherwise , @xmath291 lies in @xmath290 and so has distance at most @xmath288 from @xmath89 . in this case
, @xmath289 has distance at most @xmath292 from @xmath89 .
it follows that in all cases , @xmath293 has distance at most @xmath292 from @xmath89 , so that @xmath284 lies in a bounded neighbourhood of @xmath89 as required . as @xmath284
is contained in @xmath294 , it follows that it lies in bounded neighbourhoods of @xmath89 and @xmath294 , so that @xmath284 is small as required .
the definition of @xmath276 now shows that @xmath295 , except possibly when two of the four sets @xmath296 are small .
the only possibility is that @xmath297 and @xmath284 are both small .
as one must be empty , either @xmath298 or @xmath299 .
we conclude that if @xmath300 , then either @xmath295 or @xmath299 .
now we consider two cases .
first suppose that @xmath301 , so that either @xmath295 or @xmath302 . if @xmath299 , then @xmath303 , so that @xmath304
. as @xmath305 and @xmath306 , it follows from the first paragraph of the proof of this lemma that @xmath307 .
hence , in either case , @xmath283 now consider the general situation when @xmath300 .
again either @xmath308 or @xmath299 . if @xmath299 , then we have @xmath309 .
now the preceding paragraph implies that @xmath304 .
hence we again have @xmath305 and @xmath304 so that @xmath307 . hence @xmath295 still holds .
this completes the proof of the lemma .
next we need to verify that the set @xmath151 with the partial order which we have defined satisfies all the hypotheses of dunwoody s theorem [ dunwoodytreeconstruction ] .
[ posatisfiesdunwoody]@xmath151 together with @xmath276 satisfies the following conditions . 1 .
if @xmath104 , @xmath310 and @xmath263 , then @xmath311 .
2 . if @xmath104 , @xmath310 , there are only finitely many @xmath312 such that @xmath313 .
3 . if @xmath104 , @xmath310 , at least one of the four relations @xmath263 , @xmath314 , @xmath315 , @xmath316 holds .
if @xmath104 , @xmath310 , one can not have @xmath263 and @xmath317 conditions ( 1 ) and ( 3 ) are obvious from the definition of @xmath276 and the hypotheses of theorem [ algebrafromtorustheorem ] . to prove ( 4 ) , we observe that if @xmath263 and @xmath318 , then @xmath319 and @xmath105 must both be small .
this implies that @xmath104 itself is small , so that @xmath69 or @xmath153 must be small .
but this contradicts the hypothesis that @xmath69 is a non - trivial @xmath13almost invariant subset of @xmath25 finally we prove condition ( 2 ) .
let @xmath320 be an element of @xmath151 such that @xmath321 .
recall that , as @xmath322 projects to a finite subset of @xmath83 , we know that @xmath322 lies in a @xmath323neighbourhood of @xmath69 , for some @xmath324 . if @xmath325 but @xmath48 is not contained in @xmath69 , then @xmath326 and @xmath69 are not nested .
now lemma [ finitenumberofdoublecosets ] tells us that if @xmath48 is such a set , then @xmath50 belongs to one of only finitely many double cosets @xmath327 .
it follows that if we consider all elements @xmath48 of @xmath151 such that @xmath325 , we will find either @xmath328 , or @xmath322 lies in a @xmath323neighbourhood of @xmath69 , for finitely many different values of @xmath329 hence there is @xmath330 such that if @xmath325 then @xmath48 lies in the @xmath331neighbourhood of @xmath69 .
similarly , there is @xmath332 such that if @xmath333 , then @xmath48 lies in the @xmath288neighbourhood of @xmath334 let @xmath335 denote the larger of @xmath287 and @xmath288 .
then for any elements @xmath104 and @xmath90 of @xmath151 with @xmath263 , the set @xmath262 lies in the @xmath323neighbourhood of each of @xmath104 , @xmath336 , @xmath90 and @xmath337 now suppose we are given @xmath263 and wish to prove condition ( 2 ) .
choose a point @xmath338 in @xmath104 whose distance from @xmath336 is greater than @xmath323 , choose a point @xmath339 in @xmath340 whose distance from @xmath90 is greater than @xmath323 and choose a path @xmath1 in @xmath53 joining @xmath338 to @xmath339 .
if @xmath341 , then @xmath342 must lie in @xmath48 and @xmath339 must lie in @xmath343 so that @xmath1 must meet @xmath344 . as @xmath1 is compact , the proof of lemma [ finitenumberofdoublecosets ]
shows that the number of such @xmath48 is finite .
this completes the proof of part 2 ) of the lemma .
we are now in a position to prove theorem [ algebrafromtorustheorem ] .
to prove the first part , we let @xmath151 denote the set of all translates of @xmath69 and @xmath153 by elements of @xmath12 , let @xmath345 be the involution on @xmath151 and let the relation @xmath276 be defined on @xmath151 by the condition that @xmath263 if @xmath262 is empty or the only small set of the four sets @xmath102 .
lemmas [ partialorder ] and [ posatisfiesdunwoody ] show that @xmath276 is a partial order on @xmath151 and satisfies all of dunwoody s conditions ( 1)(4 ) .
hence we can construct a tree @xmath193 from @xmath151 .
as @xmath12 acts on @xmath151 , we have a natural action of @xmath12 on @xmath346 clearly , @xmath12 acts transitively on the edges of @xmath193 .
if @xmath12 acts without inversions , then @xmath347 has a single edge and gives @xmath12 the structure of an amalgamated free product or hnn decomposition .
the stabiliser of the edge of @xmath193 which corresponds to @xmath69 is the stabiliser @xmath27 of @xmath69 , so we obtain a splitting of @xmath12 over @xmath106 unless @xmath12 fixes a vertex of @xmath193 . note that as @xmath348 is finite , and @xmath106 preserves @xmath273 , it follows that @xmath106 contains @xmath13 with finite index as claimed in the theorem .
if @xmath12 acts on @xmath193 with inversions , we simply subdivide each edge to obtain a new tree @xmath349 on which @xmath12 acts without inversions . in this case
, the quotient @xmath350 again has one edge , but it has distinct vertices .
the edge group is @xmath106 and one of the vertex groups contains @xmath106 with index two . as @xmath13 has infinite index in @xmath12 , it follows that in this case also we obtain a splitting of @xmath12 unless @xmath12 fixes a vertex of @xmath351 suppose that @xmath12 fixes a vertex @xmath339 of @xmath193
. as @xmath12 acts transitively on the edges of @xmath193 , every edge of @xmath193 must have one vertex at @xmath339 , so that all edges of @xmath193 are adjacent to each other .
we will show that this can not occur .
the key hypothesis here is that @xmath69 is non - trivial .
let @xmath89 denote @xmath352 or @xmath353 , and note that condition 3 ) of lemma [ posatisfiesdunwoody ] shows that @xmath354 or @xmath355 .
recall that there is @xmath330 such that if @xmath325 then @xmath48 lies in the @xmath287neighbourhood of @xmath69 .
if @xmath323 denotes @xmath356 , and @xmath357 , it follows that @xmath358 lies in the @xmath323neighbourhood of @xmath69 .
let @xmath359 denote the distance of the identity of @xmath12 from @xmath273
. then @xmath50 must lie within the @xmath360neighbourhood of @xmath69 , for all @xmath357 , so that @xmath89 itself lies in the @xmath360neighbourhood of @xmath69 .
similarly , @xmath294 lies in the @xmath361neighbourhood of @xmath153 .
now both @xmath69 and @xmath153 project to infinite subsets of @xmath26 , so @xmath12 can not equal @xmath89 or @xmath362 it follows that there are elements @xmath363and @xmath90 of @xmath151 such that @xmath364 , so that @xmath363and @xmath90 represent non - adjacent edges of @xmath193 .
this completes the proof that @xmath12 can not fix a vertex of @xmath351 to prove the last statement of the first part of theorem [ algebrafromtorustheorem ] , we will simplify notation by supposing that the stabiliser @xmath106 of @xmath69 is equal to @xmath13 .
one of the standard @xmath13almost invariant sets associated to the splitting we have obtained from the action of @xmath12 on the tree @xmath193 is the set @xmath89 in the preceding paragraph .
we will show that @xmath89 is @xmath13almost equal to @xmath69 .
the preceding paragraph shows that @xmath89 lies in the @xmath360neighbourhood of @xmath69 , and that @xmath294 lies in the @xmath360neighbourhood of @xmath153 .
it follows that @xmath89 is @xmath13almost contained in @xmath69 and @xmath294 is @xmath13almost contained in @xmath365 , so that @xmath89 and @xmath69 are @xmath13almost equal as claimed .
this completes the proof of the first part of theorem [ algebrafromtorustheorem ] . for the second part
, we will simply comment on the modifications needed to the preceding proof .
the statement of lemma [ smallimpliesinboundednbhd ] remains true though the proof needs a little modification .
the statement and proof of lemma [ partialorder ] apply unchanged .
the statement of lemma [ posatisfiesdunwoody ] remains true , though the proof needs some minor modifications .
finally the proof of the first part of theorem [ algebrafromtorustheorem ] applies with minor modifications to show that @xmath12 acts on a tree @xmath193 with quotient consisting of @xmath4 edges in the required way .
this completes the proof of theorem [ algebrafromtorustheorem ] .
in this section , we prove our two main results about the case of zero intersection number .
first we will need the following little result .
[ bignormaliserimpliesnormal]let @xmath12 be a finitely generated group which splits over a subgroup @xmath13 .
if the normaliser @xmath109 of @xmath13 in @xmath12 has finite index in @xmath12 , then @xmath13 is normal in @xmath25 the given splitting of @xmath12 over @xmath13 corresponds to an action of @xmath12 on a tree @xmath193 such that @xmath366has a single edge , and some edge of @xmath367has stabiliser @xmath13 .
let @xmath368 denote the fixed set of @xmath13 , ie , the set of all points fixed by @xmath13 .
then @xmath368 is a ( non - empty ) subtree of @xmath193 . as @xmath109 normalises @xmath13 , it must preserve @xmath368 , ie @xmath369 .
suppose that @xmath370 . as @xmath109 has finite index in @xmath12 , we let @xmath371 denote a set of coset representatives for @xmath109 in @xmath12 , where @xmath372 . as @xmath12
acts transitively on @xmath193 ,
we have @xmath373 . edges of @xmath368 all have stabiliser @xmath13 , and so edges of @xmath374 all have stabiliser @xmath375 .
as @xmath376 does not lie in @xmath109 , these stabilisers are distinct so the intersection @xmath377 contains no edges .
the intersection of two subtrees of a tree must be empty or a tree , so it follows that @xmath377 is empty or a single vertex @xmath378 , for each @xmath24 .
now @xmath109 preserves @xmath368 and permutes the translates @xmath374 , so @xmath379 preserves the collection of all the @xmath378 s . as
this collection is finite , @xmath109 has a subgroup @xmath380 of finite index such that @xmath380 fixes a vertex @xmath339 of @xmath368 .
as @xmath380 has finite index in @xmath12 , it follows that @xmath12 itself fixes some vertex of @xmath193 , which contradicts our assumption that our action of @xmath12 on @xmath193 corresponds to a splitting of @xmath12 .
this contradiction shows that @xmath109 must equal @xmath12 , so that @xmath13 is normal in @xmath381as claimed .
recall that if @xmath69 is a @xmath13almost invariant subset of @xmath12 associated to a splitting of @xmath12 , then the set of translates of @xmath69 and @xmath153 is nested .
equivalently , for every @xmath145 , one of the four sets @xmath382 is empty .
we need to consider carefully how it is possible for two of the four sets to be small , and a similar question arises when one considers two splittings of @xmath25 [ twosmallsets]let @xmath12 be a finitely generated group with two splittings over finitely generated subgroups @xmath13 and @xmath11 with associated @xmath13almost invariant subset @xmath69 of @xmath12 and associated @xmath11almost invariant subset @xmath71 of @xmath25 1 .
if two of the four sets @xmath87 are small , then @xmath383 2 .
if two of the four sets @xmath252 are small , then @xmath50 normalises @xmath384 our first step will be to show that @xmath13 and @xmath11 must be commensurable . without loss of generality
, we can suppose that @xmath72 is small .
the other small set can only be @xmath75 , as otherwise @xmath69 or @xmath385 would be small which is impossible .
it follows that for each edge of @xmath386 , either it is also an edge of @xmath273 or it has ( at least ) one end in one of the two small sets . as the images in @xmath61 of @xmath387 and of each small set is finite , and as the graph @xmath53 is locally finite , it follows that the image of @xmath388 in @xmath67 must be finite .
this implies that @xmath389 has finite index in the stabiliser @xmath11 of @xmath388 . by reversing the roles of @xmath13 and @xmath11
, it follows that @xmath389 has finite index in @xmath13 , so that @xmath13 and @xmath11 must be commensurable , as claimed .
now let @xmath1 denote @xmath389 , so that @xmath1 stabilises both @xmath69 and @xmath71 , and consider the images @xmath44 and @xmath45 of @xmath69 and @xmath71 in @xmath390 .
as @xmath391 has finite index in @xmath13 and @xmath11 , it follows that @xmath57 and @xmath221 are each finite , so that @xmath44 and @xmath45 are almost invariant subsets of @xmath392 .
further , two of the four sets @xmath87 have finite image in @xmath390 , so we can assume that @xmath44 and @xmath45 are almost equal , by replacing one of @xmath69 or @xmath71 by its complement in @xmath12 , if needed .
let @xmath5 denote the intersection of the conjugates of @xmath1 in @xmath13 , so that @xmath5 is normal in @xmath13 , though it need not be normal in @xmath11 .
we do not have @xmath393 , but because @xmath1 has finite index in @xmath13 , we know that @xmath5 has finite index in @xmath13 and hence also in @xmath11 , which is all we need .
let @xmath96 and @xmath97 denote the images of @xmath69 and @xmath71 respectively in @xmath394 , and consider the action of an element @xmath126 of @xmath13 on @xmath395 trivially @xmath396 . as @xmath96 and @xmath97 are almost equal , @xmath397 must be almost equal to @xmath398 .
now we use the key fact that @xmath71 is associated to a splitting of @xmath12 so that its translates by @xmath12 are nested .
thus for any element @xmath50 of @xmath12 , one of the following four inclusions holds : @xmath399 , @xmath400 , @xmath401 , @xmath402 .
as @xmath403 is almost equal to @xmath97 , we must have @xmath404 or @xmath405 but @xmath126 has a power which lies in @xmath1 and hence stabilises @xmath71 .
it follows that @xmath406 , so that @xmath126 lies in @xmath11 .
thus @xmath118 is a subgroup of @xmath407 similarly , @xmath11 must be a subgroup of @xmath13 , so that @xmath408 .
this completes the proof of part 1 of the lemma .
note that it follows that @xmath409 , that @xmath410 and @xmath411 and that @xmath44 and @xmath412 are almost equal or almost complementary . in order to prove part 2 of the lemma
, we apply the preceding work to the case when the second splitting is obtained from the first by conjugating by some element @xmath50 of @xmath12 .
thus @xmath413 and @xmath414 which is @xmath11almost equal to @xmath93 by remark [ xgisequivalenttox ] .
hence if two of the four sets @xmath252 are small , then so are two of the four sets @xmath87 small .
now the above shows that @xmath415 , so that @xmath50 normalises @xmath13 .
this completes the proof of the lemma .
[ equalsplittings]let @xmath12 be a finitely generated group with two splittings over finitely generated subgroups @xmath13 and @xmath11 with associated @xmath13almost invariant subset @xmath69 of @xmath12 and associated @xmath11almost invariant subset @xmath71 of @xmath12 .
if two of the four sets @xmath87 are small , then the two splittings of @xmath12 are conjugate .
further one of the following holds : 1 .
the two splittings are equivalent , or 2 .
the two splittings are of the form @xmath416 , where @xmath13 has index @xmath107 in @xmath1 , and the splittings are conjugate by an element of @xmath1 , or 3 .
@xmath13 is normal in @xmath12 and @xmath26 is isomorphic to @xmath417 or to @xmath418 the preceding lemma showed that the hypotheses imply that @xmath13 equals @xmath11 and also that the images @xmath44 and @xmath45 of @xmath69 and @xmath71 in @xmath26 are almost equal or almost complementary . by replacing one of @xmath69 or @xmath71 by its complement
if needed , we can arrange that @xmath44 and @xmath45 are almost equal .
we will show that in most cases , the two given splittings over @xmath13 and @xmath11 must be equivalent , and that the exceptional cases can be analysed separately to show that the splittings are conjugate . recall that by applying theorem [ dunwoodytreeconstruction ] , we can use information about @xmath69 and its translates to construct a @xmath12tree @xmath419 and hence the original splitting of @xmath12 over @xmath13 .
similarly , we can use information about @xmath71 and its translates to construct a @xmath12tree @xmath420 and hence the original splitting of @xmath12 over @xmath11 .
we will compare these two constructions in order to prove our result .
as @xmath44 and @xmath45 are almost equal subsets of @xmath26 , it follows that there is @xmath421 such that , in the cayley graph @xmath53 of @xmath12 , we have @xmath69 lies in a @xmath58neighbourhood of @xmath71 and @xmath71 lies in a @xmath58neighbourhood of @xmath69 .
now let @xmath422 denote one of @xmath69 or @xmath153 , let @xmath423 denote one of @xmath93 or @xmath271 and let @xmath424 and @xmath425 denote the corresponding sets obtained by replacing @xmath69 with @xmath71 . recall that @xmath426 is small if and only if its image in @xmath26 is finite .
clearly this occurs if and only if @xmath423 lies in a @xmath58neighbourhood of @xmath427 , for some @xmath421 .
it follows that @xmath426 is small if and only if @xmath428 is small . as @xmath69 and @xmath71
are associated to splittings , we know that for each @xmath145 , at least one of the four sets @xmath252 is empty and at least one of the four sets @xmath429 is empty .
further the information about which of the four sets is empty completely determines the trees @xmath419 and @xmath420 .
thus we would like to show that when we compare the four sets @xmath252 with the four sets @xmath430 , then corresponding sets are empty .
note that when @xmath50 lies in @xmath13 , we have @xmath431 , so that two of the four sets @xmath382 are empty .
first we consider the case when , for each @xmath432 , only one of the sets @xmath433 is small and hence empty .
then only the corresponding one of the four sets @xmath429 is small and hence empty .
now the correspondence @xmath434 gives a @xmath12isomorphism of @xmath419 with @xmath420 and thus the splittings are equivalent .
next we consider the case when two of the sets @xmath252 are small , for some @xmath432 .
part 2 of lemma [ twosmallsets ] implies that @xmath50 normalises @xmath13 .
further if @xmath435 , then @xmath167is almost equal to @xmath436 or @xmath437 .
let @xmath438 denote the normaliser of @xmath13 in @xmath12 , so that @xmath438 acts on the left on the graph @xmath61 and we have @xmath439 .
let @xmath1 denote the subgroup of @xmath438 consisting of elements @xmath4 such that @xmath440 is almost equal to @xmath44 or @xmath52 .
now we apply theorem 5.8 from @xcite to the action of @xmath441 on the left on the graph @xmath442 this result tells us that if @xmath443 is infinite , then it has an infinite cyclic subgroup of finite index .
further the proof of this result in @xcite shows that the quotient of @xmath61 by @xmath441 must be finite .
this implies that @xmath61 has two ends and that @xmath1 has finite index in @xmath12 . to summarise , either @xmath443 is finite , or it has two ends and @xmath1 has finite index in @xmath12 .
let @xmath4 be an element of @xmath1 whose image in @xmath441 has finite order such that @xmath444 .
as @xmath69 is associated to a splitting of @xmath64 , we must have @xmath445 or @xmath446 . as @xmath4 has finite order in @xmath443 , we have @xmath447 , for some positive integer @xmath23 , which implies that @xmath448 so that @xmath4 itself lies in @xmath13 .
it follows that the group @xmath441 must be trivial , @xmath54 , @xmath417 or @xmath449 . in the first case , the two trees @xmath419 and @xmath420 will be @xmath12isomorphic , showing that the given splittings are equivalent . in the other three cases , @xmath450 is non - empty and we know that , for any @xmath451 , two of the four sets @xmath252 are small .
thus in these cases , it seems possible that @xmath419 and @xmath420 will not be @xmath12isomorphic , so we need some special arguments .
we start with the case when @xmath441 is @xmath54 . in this case
, the given splitting must be an amalgamated free product of the form @xmath452 , for some group @xmath223 .
if @xmath4 denotes an element of @xmath450 , then @xmath453 .
thus @xmath12 acts on @xmath419 and @xmath420 with inversions .
recall that either the two partial orders on the translates of @xmath170 and @xmath71 are the same under the bijection @xmath434 , or they differ only in that @xmath454 but @xmath455 , for all @xmath456 . if they differ , we replace the second splitting by its conjugate by some element @xmath456 , so that @xmath71 is replaced by @xmath457 and we replace @xmath69 by @xmath458 as @xmath459 is @xmath13almost equal to @xmath460 , the partial orders on the translates of @xmath460 and @xmath459 respectively are the same under the bijection @xmath461 except possibly when one compares @xmath460 , @xmath462 and @xmath459 , @xmath463 , where @xmath464 in this case , the inclusion @xmath454 tells us that @xmath465 , and the inclusion @xmath455 tells us that @xmath466 .
we conclude that the partial orders on the translates of @xmath467 and @xmath459 respectively are exactly the same , so that @xmath468 and @xmath420 are @xmath12isomorphic , and the two given splittings are conjugate by an element of @xmath1 .
now we turn to the two cases where @xmath441 is infinite , so that @xmath1 has finite index in @xmath12 and @xmath61 has two ends .
as @xmath1 normalises @xmath13 , lemma [ bignormaliserimpliesnormal ] shows that @xmath13 is normal in @xmath12 .
as @xmath61 has two ends , it follows that @xmath469 , so that @xmath26 is @xmath417 or @xmath470 .
it is easy to check that there is only one splitting of @xmath417 over the trivial group and that all splittings of @xmath471 over the trivial group are conjugate .
it follows that , in either case , all splittings of @xmath12 over @xmath13 are conjugate .
this completes the proof of lemma [ equalsplittings ] .
[ emptyorconjugate]let @xmath12 be a finitely generated group with two splittings over finitely generated subgroups @xmath13 and @xmath11 with associated @xmath13almost invariant subset @xmath69 of @xmath12 and associated @xmath11almost invariant subset @xmath71 of @xmath12 .
let @xmath472 , and let @xmath473 and @xmath90 denote two elements of @xmath151 such that two of the four sets @xmath474 are small .
then either one of the two sets is empty , or the two given splittings of @xmath12 are conjugate .
recall that @xmath69 is associated to a splitting of @xmath12 over @xmath13 .
it follows that @xmath93 is associated to the conjugate of this splitting by @xmath50 .
thus @xmath104 and @xmath90 are associated to splittings of @xmath12 which are each conjugate to one of the two given splittings .
if @xmath104 and @xmath90 are each translates of @xmath69 or @xmath274 , the nestedness of the translates of @xmath69 shows that one of the two small sets must be empty as claimed .
similarly if both are translates of @xmath71 or @xmath178 , then one of the two small sets must be empty .
if @xmath104 is a translate of @xmath69 or @xmath153 and @xmath90 is a translate of @xmath71 or @xmath475 , we apply lemma [ equalsplittings ] to show that the splittings to which @xmath104 and @xmath90 are associated are conjugate .
it follows that the two original splittings were conjugate as required .
now we come to the proof of our first main result .
[ disjointsplittings]let @xmath12 be a finitely generated group with @xmath23 splittings over finitely generated subgroups .
this collection of splittings is compatible up to conjugacy if and only if each pair of splittings has intersection number zero .
further , in this situation , the graph of groups structure on @xmath12 obtained from these splittings has a unique underlying graph , and the edge and vertex groups are unique up to conjugacy .
let the @xmath23 splittings @xmath476 of @xmath12 be over subgroups @xmath477 with associated @xmath257almost invariant subsets @xmath255 of @xmath12 , and let @xmath478 .
we will start by supposing that no two of the @xmath476 s are conjugate .
we will handle the general case at the end of this proof .
we will apply the second part of theorem [ algebrafromtorustheorem ] to @xmath277 recall that our assumption that the @xmath476 s have intersection number zero implies that no translate of @xmath255 can cross any translate of @xmath479 , for @xmath480 . as each @xmath255
is associated to a splitting , it is also true that no translate of @xmath255 can cross any translate of @xmath481 .
this means that the set @xmath151 is almost nested . in order to apply theorem [ algebrafromtorustheorem ]
, we will also need to show that for any pair of elements @xmath104 and @xmath90 of @xmath151 , if two of the four sets @xmath259 are small then one is empty .
now lemma [ emptyorconjugate ] shows that if two of these four sets are small , then either one is empty or there are distinct @xmath24 and @xmath482 such that @xmath476 and @xmath483 are conjugate .
as we are assuming that no two of these splittings are conjugate , it follows that if two of the four sets @xmath484 are small then one is empty , as required .
theorem [ algebrafromtorustheorem ] now implies that @xmath12 can be expressed as the fundamental group of a graph @xmath53 of groups whose @xmath24-th edge corresponds to a conjugate of a splitting of @xmath12 over the stabilizer @xmath260 of @xmath255 . as @xmath255 is associated to a splitting of @xmath12 over @xmath257 , its stabiliser @xmath261 must equal @xmath257 .
further , it is clear from the construction that collapsing all but the @xmath24-th edge of @xmath53 yields a conjugate of @xmath476 , as the corresponding @xmath12tree has edges which correspond precisely to the translates of @xmath485 now suppose that we have a graph of groups structure @xmath486 for @xmath12 such that , for each @xmath24 , @xmath136 , collapsing all edges but the @xmath487-th yields a conjugate of the splitting @xmath476 of @xmath12 .
this determines an action of @xmath12 on a tree @xmath368 without inversions .
we want to show that @xmath193 and @xmath368 are @xmath12isomorphic . for this
implies that @xmath488 and @xmath486 have the same underlying graph , and that corresponding edge and vertex groups are conjugate , as required .
let @xmath196 denote an edge of @xmath368 , and let @xmath489 denote @xmath490 or @xmath491 .
there are edges @xmath492 of @xmath368 , @xmath136 , such that the set @xmath493 of all translates of @xmath494 and @xmath495 is nested and dunwoody s construction applied to @xmath496 yields the @xmath12tree @xmath368 again
. we will denote @xmath497 by @xmath498 .
the hypotheses imply that there is @xmath499 such that the stabiliser @xmath500 of @xmath492 equals @xmath501 , and that @xmath498 is @xmath500almost equal to @xmath502 , where @xmath255 is one of the standard @xmath257almost invariant subsets of @xmath12 associated to the splitting @xmath476 .
let @xmath503 denote @xmath504 so that @xmath503 is @xmath257almost equal to @xmath505 .
now remark [ xgisequivalenttox ] shows that @xmath506 is @xmath257almost equal to @xmath255 , so that @xmath503 is @xmath257almost equal to @xmath255 .
now consider the @xmath12equivariant bijection @xmath507 determined by sending @xmath255 to @xmath503 .
the above argument shows that if @xmath473 is any element of @xmath151 , and @xmath508 is the corresponding element of @xmath493 , then @xmath363and @xmath508 are @xmath509almost equal .
we will show that in most cases , this bijection automatically preserves the partial orders on @xmath151 and @xmath493 , implying that @xmath193 and @xmath368 are @xmath12isomorphic , as required .
we compare the partial orders on @xmath151 and @xmath496 rather as in the proof of lemma [ equalsplittings ] .
for any elements @xmath104 and @xmath90 of @xmath151 , let @xmath508 and @xmath510 denote the corresponding elements of @xmath493 .
thus @xmath105 is small if and only if @xmath511 is small .
we would like to show that when we compare the four sets @xmath102 with the four sets @xmath512 , then corresponding sets are empty , so that the partial orders are preserved by our bijection .
otherwise , there must be @xmath104 and @xmath90 in @xmath151 such that two of the sets @xmath474 are small .
if @xmath363and @xmath90 are translates of @xmath481 and @xmath479 , then lemma [ equalsplittings ] tells us that the splittings @xmath476 and @xmath513 are conjugate . as we are assuming that distinct splittings are not conjugate
, it follows that @xmath514 .
now the arguments in the proof of lemma [ equalsplittings ] show that either the splitting @xmath476 is an amalgamated free product of the form @xmath515 , with @xmath516 , or @xmath13 is normal in @xmath12 and @xmath26 is @xmath517 or @xmath518 .
if the second case occurs , then there can be only one splitting in the given family , so it is immediate that @xmath53 and @xmath486 have the same underlying graph , and that corresponding edge and vertex groups are conjugate .
if the first case occurs and the partial orders on translates of @xmath255 and @xmath503 do not match , we must have @xmath519 but @xmath520 , for all @xmath521 .
we now pick @xmath521 and alter our bijection from @xmath151 to @xmath493 so that @xmath255 maps to @xmath522 and extend @xmath12equivariantly to the translates of @xmath481 and @xmath523 .
this ensures that the partial orders on @xmath151 and @xmath496 match for translates of @xmath255 . by repeating this for other values of @xmath24 as necessary
, we can arrange that the partial orders match completely , and can then conclude that @xmath193 and @xmath368 are @xmath12isomorphic as required .
we end by discussing the case when some of the given @xmath23 splittings are conjugate .
we divide the splittings into conjugacy classes and discard all except one splitting from each conjugacy class , to obtain @xmath4 splittings .
now we apply the preceding argument to express @xmath12 uniquely as the fundamental group of a graph @xmath53 of groups with @xmath4 edges .
if an edge of @xmath53 corresponds to a splitting over a subgroup @xmath13 which is conjugate to @xmath524 other splittings , we simply subdivide this edge into @xmath525 sub - edges , and label all the sub - edges and the @xmath524 new vertices by @xmath13 .
this shows the existence of the required graph of groups structure @xmath526 corresponding to the original @xmath23 splittings .
the uniqueness of @xmath527 follows from the uniqueness of @xmath53 , and the fact that the collection of all the edges of @xmath486 which correspond to a given splitting of @xmath12 must form an interval in @xmath486 in which all the interior vertices have valence @xmath107 .
this completes the proof of theorem [ disjointsplittings ] .
now we turn to the proof of theorem [ splittingsexist ] that splittings exist . it will be convenient to make the following definitions .
we will use @xmath528 to denote @xmath529 if @xmath69 is a @xmath13almost invariant subset of @xmath381and @xmath71 is a @xmath11almost invariant subset of @xmath12 , and if @xmath69 and @xmath71 are @xmath13almost equal , then we will say that @xmath69 and @xmath71 are equivalent and write @xmath530 .
( note that @xmath13 and @xmath11 must be commensurable . )
if @xmath13 is a subgroup of a group @xmath12 , the commensuriser in @xmath12 of @xmath13 consists of those elements @xmath50 in @xmath12 such that @xmath13 and @xmath531 are commensurable subgroups of @xmath12 .
the commensuriser is clearly a subgroup of @xmath182 and is denoted by @xmath532 or just @xmath533 , when the group @xmath12 is clear from the context .
now we come to the proof of our second main result .
[ splittingsexist]let @xmath12 be a finitely generated group with a finitely generated subgroup @xmath13 , such that @xmath534 . if there is a non - trivial @xmath118almost invariant subset @xmath69 of @xmath12 such that @xmath535 , then @xmath12 has a splitting over some subgroup @xmath106 commensurable with @xmath13 .
further , one of the @xmath106almost invariant sets @xmath71 determined by the splitting is equivalent to @xmath253 this is the best possible result of this type , as it is clear that one can not expect to obtain a splitting over @xmath13 itself .
for example , suppose that @xmath13 is carried by a proper power of a two - sided simple closed curve on a closed surface whose fundamental group is @xmath536 so that @xmath537 there are essentially only two non - trivial almost invariant subsets of @xmath538 each with vanishing self - intersection number , but there is no splitting of @xmath12 over @xmath384 the idea of the proof is much as before .
we let @xmath44 denote the almost invariant subset @xmath82 of @xmath26 , and let @xmath151 denote @xmath539 .
we want to apply the first part of theorem [ algebrafromtorustheorem ] . as before ,
the assumption that @xmath540 implies that @xmath151 is almost nested .
however , in order to apply theorem [ algebrafromtorustheorem ] , we also need to know that for any pair of elements @xmath104 and @xmath90 of @xmath151 , if two of the four sets @xmath541 are small then one is empty . in the proof of theorem [ disjointsplittings ]
, we simply applied lemma [ emptyorconjugate ] .
however , here the situation is somewhat more complicated .
lemma [ kcommensurises ] below shows that if @xmath542 and @xmath543 are both small , then @xmath50 must lie in a certain subgroup @xmath544 of @xmath545 .
thus it would suffice to arrange that @xmath151 is nested with respect to @xmath544 , ie , that @xmath93 and @xmath69 are nested so long as @xmath50 lies in @xmath544 .
now proposition [ almostnestedimpliesnested ] below tells us that there is a subgroup @xmath106 commensurable with @xmath13 and a @xmath106almost invariant set @xmath71 equivalent to @xmath69 such that @xmath546 is nested with respect to @xmath544 .
it follows that if @xmath363and @xmath90 are any elements of @xmath493 and if @xmath319 and @xmath265 are both small , then one of them is empty .
we also claim that , like @xmath151 , the set @xmath493 is almost nested .
this means that if we let @xmath96 denote @xmath547 , we are claiming that @xmath548 .
let @xmath549 denote @xmath550 .
the fact that @xmath71 is equivalent to @xmath69 means that the pre - images in @xmath551 of @xmath44 and of @xmath552 are almost equal almost invariant sets which we denote by @xmath45 and @xmath97 .
if @xmath323 denotes the index of @xmath106 in @xmath13 , then @xmath553 and similarly @xmath554 is an integral multiple of @xmath555 .
as @xmath45 and @xmath97 are almost equal , it follows that @xmath556 , and hence that @xmath548 as claimed .
this now allows us to apply theorem [ algebrafromtorustheorem ] to the set @xmath493 .
we conclude that @xmath381splits over the stabiliser @xmath549 of @xmath71 , that @xmath549 contains @xmath106 with finite index and that one of the @xmath549almost invariant sets associated to the splitting is equivalent to @xmath460 .
it follows that @xmath557 is commensurable with @xmath13 and that one of the @xmath549almost invariant sets determined by the splitting is equivalent to @xmath253 this completes the proof of theorem [ splittingsexist ] apart from the proofs of lemma [ kcommensurises ] and proposition [ almostnestedimpliesnested ] .
it remains to prove the two results we just used .
the proofs do not use the hypothesis that the set of all translates of @xmath69 and @xmath153 are almost nested .
thus for the rest of this section , we will consider the following general situation .
let @xmath12 be a finitely generated group with a finitely generated subgroup @xmath13 such that @xmath534 , and let @xmath69 denote a non - trivial @xmath13almost invariant subset of @xmath25 recall that our problem in the proof of theorem [ splittingsexist ] is the possibility that two of the four sets @xmath252 are small . as this would imply that @xmath558 or @xmath153 , it is clear that the subgroup @xmath544 of @xmath12 defined by @xmath559 or @xmath560 is very relevant to our problem .
we will consider this subgroup carefully . here
is the first result we quoted in the proof of theorem [ splittingsexist ] .
[ kcommensurises]if @xmath559 or @xmath560 , then @xmath561 the first inclusion is clear .
the second is proved in essentially the same way as the proof of the first part of lemma [ equalsplittings ] .
let @xmath50 be an element of @xmath544 , and consider the case when @xmath558 ( the other case is similar ) . recall that this means that the sets @xmath562 and @xmath563 are both small .
now for each edge of @xmath564 , either it is also an edge of @xmath273 or it has ( at least ) one end in one of the two small sets . as the images in @xmath61 of @xmath273 and of each small set is finite , and
as the graph @xmath53 is locally finite , it follows that the image of @xmath564 in @xmath61 must be finite .
this implies that @xmath565 has finite index in the stabiliser @xmath531 of @xmath564 . by reversing the roles of @xmath69 and @xmath93
, it follows that @xmath565 has finite index in @xmath13 , so that @xmath13 and @xmath566 must be commensurable , as claimed .
it follows that @xmath567 , as required .
another way of describing our difficulty in applying theorem [ algebrafromtorustheorem ] is to say that it is caused by the fact that the translates of @xmath69 and @xmath153 may not be nested .
however , lemma [ finitenumberofdoublecosets ] assures us that `` most '' of the translates are nested .
the following result gives us a much stronger finiteness result .
[ finitelymanynonnested ] let @xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath69 , @xmath544 be as above .
then @xmath568 and @xmath69 are not nested@xmath569 consists of a finite number of right cosets @xmath40 of @xmath13 in @xmath25 lemma [ finitenumberofdoublecosets ] tells us that the given set is contained in the union of a finite number of double cosets @xmath570 . if @xmath571 , we claim that the double coset @xmath327 is itself the union of only finitely many cosets @xmath40 , which proves the required result .
to prove our claim , recall that @xmath572 is commensurable with @xmath13 .
thus @xmath572 can be expressed as the union of cosets @xmath573 , for @xmath574 hence @xmath575 so that @xmath327 is the union of finitely many cosets @xmath40 as claimed .
now we come to the key result .
[ kisunionofnormalisers]let @xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath69 , @xmath544 be as above . then there are a finite number of finite index subgroups @xmath576 of @xmath13 , such that @xmath544 is contained in the union of the groups @xmath577 , @xmath578 , where @xmath579 denotes the normaliser of @xmath580 in @xmath25 consider an element @xmath50 in @xmath544 .
lemma [ kcommensurises ] tells us that @xmath13 and @xmath531 are commensurable subgroups of @xmath12 .
let @xmath1 denote their intersection and let @xmath5 denote the intersection of the conjugates of @xmath1 in @xmath13 .
thus @xmath5 is of finite index in @xmath13 and @xmath528 and is normal in @xmath13 . now consider the quotient @xmath581 .
let @xmath44 and @xmath45 denote the images of @xmath69 and @xmath93 respectively in @xmath582 .
as before , @xmath44 and @xmath45 are almost invariant subsets of @xmath582 which are almost equal or almost complementary .
now consider the action of @xmath583 on the left on @xmath582 .
if @xmath126 is in @xmath13 , then @xmath584 , so that @xmath585 if @xmath586 and @xmath93 are nested , there are four possible inclusions , but the fact that @xmath587 excludes two of them .
thus we must have @xmath588 or @xmath45 @xmath589 .
this implies that @xmath590 as some power of @xmath126 lies in @xmath5 and so acts trivially on @xmath591 we conclude that if @xmath126 is an element of @xmath592 such that @xmath586 and @xmath93 are nested , then @xmath126 stabilises @xmath593 and so lies in @xmath531 .
hence @xmath126 lies in @xmath1 .
it follows that for each element @xmath126 of @xmath594 , the sets @xmath586 and @xmath93 are not nested .
recall from lemma [ finitelymanynonnested ] that @xmath568 and @xmath69 are not nested@xmath569 consists of a finite number of cosets @xmath40 of @xmath13 in @xmath12
. it will be convenient to denote this number by @xmath595 .
thus , for @xmath596 , the set @xmath597 and @xmath93 are not nested@xmath569 consists of @xmath595 cosets @xmath598 of @xmath531 in @xmath12 .
it follows that @xmath594 lies in the union of @xmath595 cosets @xmath598 of @xmath531 in @xmath12 . as @xmath599
, it follows that @xmath594 lies in the union of @xmath595 cosets @xmath600 of @xmath1 in @xmath12 and hence that @xmath1 has index at most @xmath323 in @xmath384 a similar argument shows also that @xmath1 has index at most @xmath323 in @xmath531 .
of course , the same bound applies to the index of @xmath601 in @xmath13 , for each @xmath24 . now we define @xmath602 clearly @xmath106 is a subgroup of @xmath13 which is normalised by @xmath50 . now
each intersection @xmath601 has index at most @xmath323 in @xmath13 , and so @xmath603 is an intersection of subgroups of @xmath13 of index at most @xmath323 .
if @xmath13 has @xmath23 subgroups of index at most @xmath323 , it follows that @xmath106 has index at most @xmath604 in @xmath13 .
hence each element of @xmath544 normalises a subgroup of @xmath13 of index at most @xmath604 in @xmath13 .
as @xmath13 has only finitely many such subgroups , we have proved that there are a finite number of finite index subgroups @xmath576 of @xmath13 , such that @xmath544 is contained in the union of the groups @xmath579 , @xmath578 , as required . using this result
, we can prove the following .
let @xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath69 , @xmath544 be as above .
then there is a subgroup @xmath27 of finite index in @xmath13 , such that @xmath544 normalises @xmath605 we will consider how @xmath544 can intersect the normaliser of a subgroup of finite index in @xmath13 . let @xmath184 denote a subgroup of @xmath13 of finite index .
we denote the image of @xmath69 in @xmath606 by @xmath44 .
then @xmath44 is an almost invariant subset of @xmath606 .
we consider the group @xmath607 , which we will denote by @xmath608 .
then @xmath609 acts on the left on @xmath610 , and we have @xmath444 or @xmath52 , for every element @xmath4 of @xmath611 , because every element of @xmath544 satisfies @xmath612 or @xmath153 .
now we apply theorem 5.8 from @xcite to the action of @xmath609 on the left on the graph @xmath613 .
this result tells us that if @xmath609 is infinite , then it has an infinite cyclic subgroup of finite index .
further the proof of this result in @xcite shows that the quotient of @xmath614 by @xmath609 must be finite .
this implies that @xmath613 has two ends and that @xmath608 has finite index in @xmath12 .
hence either @xmath609 is finite , or it has two ends and @xmath608 has finite index in @xmath25 recall that there are a finite number of finite index subgroups @xmath615 of @xmath13 , such that @xmath544 is contained in the union of the groups @xmath579 , @xmath578 .
the above discussion shows that , for each @xmath24 , if @xmath616 denotes @xmath617 , either @xmath618 is finite , or it has two ends and @xmath619 has finite index in @xmath12 .
we consider two cases depending on whether or not every @xmath618 is finite .
suppose first that each @xmath618 is finite .
we claim that @xmath544 contains @xmath13 with finite index . to see this ,
let @xmath620 , so that @xmath549 is a subgroup of @xmath13 of finite index , and note that @xmath544 is the union of a finite collection of groups @xmath616 each of which contains @xmath621 with finite index , so that @xmath544 is the union of finitely many cosets of @xmath549 .
it follows that @xmath544 also contains @xmath549 with finite index and hence contains @xmath13 with finite index as claimed .
if we let @xmath106 denote the intersection of the conjugates of @xmath13 in @xmath544 , then @xmath106 is the required subgroup of @xmath13 which is normalised by @xmath622 now we turn to the case when @xmath609 is infinite and so @xmath609 has two ends and @xmath608 has finite index in @xmath25 define @xmath106 to be @xmath623 . as @xmath544 contains @xmath608 with finite index , @xmath106 is the intersection of only finitely many conjugates of @xmath184 . as @xmath544
is contained in @xmath533 , each of these conjugates of @xmath184 is commensurable with @xmath184 .
it follows that @xmath27 is a subgroup of @xmath13 of finite index in @xmath13 which is normalised by @xmath544 .
this completes the proof of the lemma .
the key point here is that @xmath544 normalises @xmath106 rather than just commensurises it .
now we can prove the second result which we quoted in the proof of theorem [ splittingsexist ] .
[ almostnestedimpliesnested]suppose that @xmath66 is a pair of finitely generated groups and that @xmath69 is a non - trivial @xmath13almost invariant subset of @xmath12 .
then , there is a subgroup @xmath106 of @xmath12 which is commensurable with @xmath13 , and a non - trivial @xmath106almost invariant set @xmath71 equivalent to @xmath69 such that @xmath624 is nested with respect to the subgroup @xmath559 or @xmath560 of @xmath64 .
the previous lemma tells us that there is a subgroup @xmath106 of finite index in @xmath13 such that @xmath544 normalises @xmath106 .
let @xmath44 denote the almost invariant subset @xmath82 of @xmath26 , and let @xmath96 denote the almost invariant subset @xmath625 of @xmath626 suppose that the index of @xmath106 in @xmath544 is infinite .
recall from the proof of the preceding lemma that @xmath627 has two ends and that @xmath544 has finite index in @xmath12 .
we construct a new non - trivial @xmath549almost invariant set @xmath71 as follows .
since the quotient group @xmath628 has two ends , @xmath629 splits over a subgroup @xmath549 which contains @xmath27 with finite index .
thus there is a @xmath630almost invariant set @xmath631 in @xmath544 which is nested with respect to @xmath544 .
further , @xmath549 is normal in @xmath629 and the quotient group must be isomorphic to @xmath417 or @xmath449 .
let @xmath632 be coset representatives of @xmath544 in @xmath12 so that @xmath633 .
we take @xmath634 .
it is easy to check that @xmath71 is @xmath549almost invariant and that @xmath635 is nested with respect to @xmath622 now suppose that the index of @xmath106 in @xmath544 is finite .
we will define the subgroup @xmath636 of @xmath637 .
the index of @xmath638 in @xmath544 is at most two .
first we consider the case when @xmath639 .
we define @xmath640 to be the intersection of the translates of @xmath96 under the action of @xmath628 .
thus @xmath641 is invariant under the action of @xmath627 .
as all the translates of @xmath96 by elements of @xmath642 are almost equal to @xmath96 , it follows that @xmath643 so that @xmath644 is also an almost invariant subset of @xmath645 .
let @xmath71 denote the inverse image of @xmath644 in @xmath12 , so that @xmath71 is invariant under the action of @xmath544 . in particular ,
@xmath624 is nested with respect to @xmath544 , as required .
now we consider the general case when @xmath646 .
we can apply the above arguments using @xmath638 in place of @xmath637 to obtain a subgroup @xmath549 of @xmath12 and a @xmath557almost invariant subset @xmath71 of @xmath12 which is equivalent to @xmath69 , and whose translates are nested with respect to @xmath638 .
we also know that @xmath647 is @xmath638invariant .
let @xmath45 denote the image of @xmath71 in @xmath648 , let @xmath4 denote an element of @xmath649 and consider the involution of @xmath650 induced by @xmath4 .
then @xmath45 is a non - trivial almost invariant subset of @xmath648 and @xmath651 .
define @xmath652 , so that @xmath653 and let @xmath48 denote the pre - image of @xmath436 in @xmath12 .
we claim that the translates of @xmath48 and @xmath343 are nested with respect to @xmath544 .
first we show that they are nested with respect to @xmath654 , by showing that @xmath655 is @xmath638invariant . for @xmath656
, we have @xmath657 as @xmath638 must be normal in @xmath544 .
it follows that @xmath658 . as @xmath659
, we see that @xmath48 is @xmath638invariant as required . in order to show that the translates of @xmath48 and @xmath343 are nested with respect to @xmath544
, we will also show that @xmath660 is empty .
this follows from the fact that @xmath661 which is clearly empty .
this completes the proof of proposition [ almostnestedimpliesnested ] .
let @xmath12 be a finitely generated group and let @xmath13 and @xmath11 be subgroups of @xmath12 .
let @xmath69 be a non - trivial @xmath13almost invariant subset of @xmath12 and let @xmath71 be a non - trivial @xmath11almost invariant subset of @xmath25 in section 1 , we discussed what it means for @xmath69 to cross @xmath71 and the fact that this is symmetric .
as mentioned in the introduction , there is an alternative way to define crossing of almost invariant sets .
recall that , in section 1 , we introduced our definition of crossing by discussing curves on surfaces .
thus it seems natural to discuss the crossing of @xmath69 and @xmath71 in terms of their boundaries .
we call this strong crossing .
however , this leads to an asymmetric intersection number . in this section ,
we define strong crossing and discuss its properties and some applications .
we consider the cayley graph @xmath53 of @xmath12 with respect to a finite system of generators .
we will usually assume that @xmath13 and @xmath11 are finitely generated though this does not seem necessary for most of the definitions below .
we will also think of @xmath273 as a set of edges in @xmath53 or as a set of points in @xmath12 , where the set of points will simply be the collection of endpoints of all the edges of @xmath662 [ strongcrossingimpliescrossing]this definition is independent of the choice of generators for @xmath12 which is used to define @xmath53 .
clearly , if @xmath665 crosses @xmath69 strongly , then @xmath71 crosses @xmath69 .
strong crossing is not symmetric . for an example , one need only consider an essential two - sided simple closed curve @xmath2 on a compact surface @xmath0 which intersects a simple arc @xmath1 transversely in a single point .
let @xmath12 denote @xmath666 , and let @xmath13 and @xmath11 respectively denote the subgroups of @xmath12 carried by @xmath2 and @xmath1 , so that @xmath13 is infinite cyclic and @xmath11 is trivial .
then @xmath2 and @xmath1 each define a splitting of @xmath12 over @xmath10and @xmath11 respectively .
let @xmath69 and @xmath71 denote associated standard @xmath13almost invariant and @xmath11almost invariant subsets of @xmath12 .
these correspond to submanifolds of the universal cover of @xmath0 bounded respectively by a line @xmath667 lying above @xmath2 and by a compact interval @xmath668 lying above @xmath1 , such that @xmath669 meets @xmath668 transversely in a single point . clearly , @xmath69 crosses @xmath71 strongly but @xmath71 does not cross @xmath69 strongly
. however , a strong intersection number can be defined as before .
it is usually asymmetric , but we will be particularly interested in the case of self - intersection numbers when this asymmetry will not arise . the strong intersection number @xmath670 is defined to be the number of double cosets @xmath42 such that @xmath93 crosses @xmath71 strongly . in particular , @xmath671 if and only if at least one of @xmath672 and @xmath673 is @xmath13finite , for each @xmath145 . if @xmath35 and @xmath674 are splittings of a group @xmath12 over subgroups @xmath13 and @xmath11 , with associated almost invariant subsets @xmath69 and @xmath71 of @xmath12 , it is natural to say that @xmath35 crosses @xmath674 strongly if @xmath675 .
it is easy to show that this is equivalent to the idea introduced by sela @xcite that @xmath35 is hyperbolic with respect to @xmath674 .
remark [ strongcrossingimpliescrossing ] shows that @xmath676 .
recall that theorem [ splittingsexist ] shows that if @xmath677 , then @xmath12 splits over a subgroup @xmath106 commensurable with @xmath13 .
thus the vanishing of the strong self - intersection number may be considered as a first obstruction to splitting @xmath12 over some subgroup related to @xmath13 .
we will show in corollary [ canmakenested ] that the vanishing of the strong self - intersection number has a nice algebraic formulation .
this is that when @xmath678 vanishes , we can find a subgroup @xmath11 of @xmath12 , commensurable with @xmath13 , and a @xmath11almost invariant subset @xmath71 of @xmath12 which is nested with respect to @xmath679 .
however , @xmath71 may be very different from @xmath69 .
this leads to some splitting results when we place further restrictions on @xmath13 .
[ conditionforsi=0]let @xmath12 be a finitely generated group with finitely generated subgroup @xmath13 , and let @xmath69 be a non - trivial @xmath13almost invariant subset of @xmath12 .
then @xmath671 if and only if there is a subset @xmath71 of @xmath12 which is @xmath13almost equal to @xmath69 ( and hence @xmath13almost invariant ) such that @xmath680 .
suppose that there exists a subset @xmath71 of @xmath12 which is @xmath13almost equal to @xmath170 , such that @xmath680 .
we have @xmath681 as @xmath69 and @xmath71 are @xmath13almost equal .
so , it is enough to show that for every @xmath145 , either @xmath682 or @xmath683 is @xmath13finite .
suppose that @xmath684 .
consider @xmath685 which is a union of a finite number of right cosets @xmath686 , @xmath136 . since @xmath684 , @xmath687 .
for any @xmath123 , @xmath688 .
thus @xmath689 is at a bounded distance from @xmath71 and hence @xmath683 has finite image in @xmath26 .
similarly , if @xmath690 , @xmath691 projects to a finite set in @xmath26 .
for the converse , suppose that @xmath671 and let @xmath692 denote the projection from @xmath12 to @xmath26 . by hypothesis , @xmath693 or
@xmath694 is finite .
the proof of lemma [ posatisfiesdunwoody ] tells us that there is a positive number @xmath323 such that , for every @xmath145 , the set @xmath695 is contained in a @xmath323neighbourhood of @xmath69 or @xmath153 .
let @xmath696 , the @xmath323neighbourhood of @xmath69 and let @xmath697 . if @xmath684 and @xmath123 , then @xmath698 and thus @xmath699 .
if @xmath684 and @xmath123 , then @xmath700 and thus @xmath701 .
it only remains to show that @xmath71 is @xmath13almost equal to @xmath253 this is essentially shown in the third and fourth paragraphs of the proof of theorem [ algebrafromtorustheorem ] .
we will say that a pair of finitely generated groups @xmath66 is of _ surface type _ if @xmath702 for every subgroup @xmath106 of finite index in @xmath13 and @xmath703 for every subgroup @xmath106 of infinite index in @xmath13 .
this terminology is suggested by the dichotomy in @xcite .
note that for such pairs any two non - trivial @xmath13almost invariant sets in @xmath12 are @xmath13almost equal or @xmath13almost complementary .
we will see that for pairs of surface type , strong and ordinary intersection numbers are equal .
[ crossingiffstrongcrossing]let @xmath66 be a pair of surface type , let @xmath704 be a non - trivial @xmath13almost invariant subset of @xmath12 and let @xmath71 be a non - trivial @xmath11almost invariant subset of @xmath12 for some subgroup @xmath11 of @xmath12
. then @xmath71 crosses @xmath69 if and only if @xmath71 crosses @xmath69 strongly .
let @xmath53 be the cayley graph of @xmath12 with respect to a finite system of generators and let @xmath705 .
as in the proof of lemma [ finitenumberofdoublecosets ] , for a set @xmath2 of vertices in a graph , we let @xmath706 denote the maximal subgraph with vertex set equal to @xmath2
. we will show that exactly one component of @xmath242 has infinite image in @xmath61 .
note that @xmath707 has exactly one infinite component as @xmath61 has only two ends .
let @xmath45 denote the set of vertices of the infinite component of @xmath707 and let @xmath89 denote the inverse image of @xmath45 in @xmath12 .
if @xmath708 has components with vertex set @xmath22 , then we have @xmath709 .
let @xmath1 denote the vertex set of a component of @xmath708 , and let @xmath710 be the stabilizer in @xmath13 of @xmath1 .
since @xmath221 is finite , we see that @xmath711 is finite .
hence @xmath712 has more than one end .
now our hypothesis that @xmath66 is of surface type implies that @xmath710 has finite index in @xmath13 and thus @xmath713 is finite .
if @xmath714 , we see that @xmath713 divides @xmath715 into at least three infinite components .
thus @xmath716 and so @xmath708 is connected .
the other components of @xmath242 have finite image in @xmath717 .
similarly , exactly one component of @xmath718 has infinite image in @xmath61 .
the same argument shows that for any finite subset @xmath227 of @xmath61 containing @xmath57 , the two infinite components of @xmath719 and@xmath720 have connected inverse images in @xmath70 .
recall that if @xmath71 crosses @xmath69 strongly , then @xmath71 crosses @xmath69 .
we will next show that if @xmath71 does not cross @xmath69 strongly , then @xmath71 does not cross @xmath69 .
suppose that @xmath721 projects to a finite set in @xmath67 .
take a compact set @xmath227 in @xmath61 large enough to contain @xmath721 and @xmath57 . by the argument above ,
if @xmath436 is the infinite component of @xmath719 , then its inverse image @xmath48 is connected and is contained in @xmath242 .
any two points in @xmath48 can be connected by a path in @xmath48 and thus the path does not intersect @xmath388 .
thus @xmath48 is contained in @xmath71 or @xmath178 .
hence @xmath722 or @xmath723 is empty .
suppose that @xmath724 is empty
. then @xmath725 . since @xmath726 projects to a finite set , we see that @xmath727 projects to a finite set . similarly , if @xmath728 is empty , then @xmath729 projects to a finite set in @xmath83 .
thus , we have shown that if @xmath721 projects to a finite set , then either @xmath727 or @xmath729 projects to finite set .
thus @xmath71 does not cross @xmath69 .
if @xmath66 and @xmath730 are both of surface type and @xmath69 is a non - trivial @xmath13almost invariant set in @xmath12 , and @xmath71 is a non - trivial @xmath11almost invariant set in @xmath12 then @xmath731 . in particular @xmath677 if and only if @xmath732 .
let @xmath11 be a poincar duality group of dimension @xmath733 which is a subgroup of a poincar duality group @xmath12 of dimension @xmath23 .
thus the pair @xmath730 is of surface type . in @xcite , kropholler and roller
defined an obstruction @xmath734 to splitting @xmath12 over a subgroup commensurable with @xmath11 .
their main result was that @xmath734 vanishes if and only if @xmath12 splits over a subgroup commensurable with @xmath11 . at an early stage in their proof
, they showed that @xmath734 vanishes if and only if there is a @xmath11almost invariant subset @xmath71 of @xmath12 such that @xmath735 . starting from this point , proposition [ conditionforsi=0 ] , the above corollary and then theorem [ splittingsexist ] give an alternative proof of their splitting result .
thus theorem [ splittingsexist ] may be considered as a generalization of their splitting theorem .
we next reformulate in our language a conjecture of kropholler and roller @xcite : [ krconjecture]if @xmath12 is a finitely generated group with a finitely generated subgroup @xmath13 , and if @xmath69 is a non - trivial @xmath13almost invariant subset of @xmath12 such that @xmath671 , then @xmath12 splits over a subgroup commensurable with a subgroup of @xmath13 .
note that theorem [ splittingsexist ] has a stronger hypothesis than this conjecture , namely the vanishing of the self - intersection number @xmath736 , rather than the vanishing of the strong self - intersection number , and it has a correspondingly stronger conclusion , namely that @xmath12 splits over a subgroup commensurable with @xmath13 itself .
a key difference between the two statements is that , in the above conjecture , one does not expect the almost invariant set associated to the splitting of @xmath12 to be at all closely related to @xmath69 .
dunwoody and roller proved this conjecture when @xmath13 is virtually polycyclic @xcite , and sageev @xcite proved it for quasiconvex subgroups of hyperbolic groups .
the paper of dunwoody and roller @xcite contains information useful in the general case .
the second step in their proof , which uses a theorem of bergman @xcite , proves the following result , stated in our language .
( there is an exposition of bergman s argument and parts of @xcite in the later versions of @xcite . )
let @xmath66 be a pair of finitely generated groups , and let @xmath69 be a @xmath13almost invariant subset of @xmath12 .
if @xmath671 , then there is a subgroup @xmath106 commensurable with @xmath13 , and a non - trivial @xmath106almost invariant set @xmath71 with @xmath737 such that the set @xmath635 is almost nested with respect to @xmath738 .
[ canmakenested]with the hypotheses of the above theorem we can choose @xmath27 and a non - trivial @xmath106almost invariant set @xmath71 with @xmath739 such that @xmath740 is almost nested with respect to @xmath532 and is nested with respect to the subgroup @xmath559 or @xmath741 of @xmath532 . if @xmath12 , @xmath13 are finitely generated groups with @xmath68 , if @xmath742 for every subgroup @xmath11 commensurable with a subgroup of infinite index in @xmath13 , and if @xmath69 is a @xmath13almost invariant subset of @xmath12 such that @xmath743 , then @xmath12 splits over a subgroup commensurable with @xmath13 .
observe that corollary [ canmakenested ] shows that , by changing @xmath13 up to commensurability , and changing @xmath69 , we may assume that the translates of @xmath69 are almost nested with respect to @xmath532 and nested with respect to @xmath744 or @xmath560 .
if we do not have almost nesting for all translates of @xmath69 , then there is @xmath50 outside @xmath532 such that none of @xmath252 is @xmath13finite .
in particular , none of these sets is @xmath745finite . but these four sets are each invariant under @xmath565 and the fact that the strong intersection number vanishes shows that at least one of them has boundary which is @xmath745finite . since @xmath50 is not in @xmath532 , we have a contradiction to our hypothesis that @xmath742 with @xmath746 .
this completes the proof .
we note another application of groups of surface type which provides an approach to the algebraic torus theorem @xcite similar to ours in @xcite .
we will omit a complete discussion of this approach , but will prove the following proposition to illustrate the ideas .
[ bigcommensuriserimpliesvirtuallynormal]if @xmath66 is of surface type and if @xmath13 has infinite index in @xmath532 , then there is a subgroup @xmath27 of finite index in @xmath13 such that the normalizer @xmath747 of @xmath106 is of finite index in @xmath12 and @xmath748 is virtually infinite cyclic . in particular ,
if @xmath13 is virtually polycyclic , then @xmath12 is virtually polycyclic .
let @xmath69 be a non - trivial @xmath13almost invariant subset of @xmath12 , let @xmath50 be an element of @xmath532 and let @xmath749 , so that @xmath172has stabiliser @xmath531 .
let @xmath106 denote the intersection @xmath565 which has finite index in both @xmath13 and in @xmath531 because @xmath50 lies in @xmath532 .
thus @xmath750 and @xmath547 are both almost invariant subsets of @xmath645 . as @xmath66 is of surface type , the pair @xmath751 has two ends so that @xmath752 and @xmath547 are almost equal or almost complementary .
it follows that @xmath69 is @xmath13almost equal to @xmath71 or @xmath178 , ie , @xmath753 or @xmath754 .
recall from lemma [ kcommensurises ] , that if @xmath629 denotes @xmath755 or @xmath756 , then @xmath757 .
it follows that in our present situation @xmath629 must equal @xmath532 . by lemma [ kisunionofnormalisers ]
, we see that there are a finite number of subgroups @xmath576 of finite index in @xmath13 such that @xmath544 is contained in the union of the normalizers @xmath579 . as @xmath13 has infinite index in @xmath758 , one of the @xmath257 ,
say @xmath184 , has infinite index in its normalizer @xmath759 .
as @xmath66 is of surface type , the pair @xmath760 has two ends , so we can apply theorem 5.8 from @xcite to the action of @xmath761 on the left on the graph @xmath614 .
this result tells us that @xmath761 is virtually infinite cyclic .
further the proof of this result in @xcite shows that the quotient of @xmath613 by @xmath761 must be finite so that @xmath762 has finite index in @xmath12 .
[ toomanyends ] let @xmath66 be a pair of finitely generated groups with @xmath118 virtually polycyclic and suppose that @xmath12 does not split over a subgroup commensurable with a subgroup of infinite index in @xmath13 .
if for some subgroup @xmath11 of @xmath13 , @xmath763 , then @xmath12 splits over a subgroup commensurable with @xmath13 .
we end this section with an interpretation of intersection numbers in the case when the strong and ordinary intersection numbers are equal .
this corrects a mistake in @xcite .
suppose that a group @xmath12 splits over subgroups @xmath13 and @xmath11 and let the corresponding @xmath13almost and @xmath11almost invariant subsets of @xmath12 be @xmath69 and @xmath71 .
let @xmath193 denote the bass serre tree corresponding to the splitting of @xmath12 over @xmath11 and consider the action of @xmath13 on @xmath193 .
let @xmath368 denote the minimal @xmath13invariant subtree of @xmath193 , and let @xmath764 denote the quotient graph @xmath765 similarly , we get a graph @xmath231 by considering the action of @xmath11 on the bass serre tree corresponding to the splitting of @xmath12 over @xmath13 .
we have : the proof of theorem 3.1 of @xcite goes through because of our assumption that @xmath767 .
the mistake in @xcite occurs in the proof of lemma 3.6 of @xcite where it is implicitly assumed that if @xmath69 crosses @xmath71 , then it crosses @xmath71 strongly .
since we have assumed that the two intersection numbers are equal , the argument is now valid . | we prove algebraic analogues of the facts that a curve on a surface with self - intersection number zero is homotopic to a cover of a simple curve , and that two simple curves on a surface with intersection number zero can be isotoped to be disjoint . in this paper , we will discuss an algebraic version of intersection numbers which was introduced by scott in @xcite .
first we need to discuss intersection numbers in the topological setting .
let @xmath0 denote a surface and let @xmath1 and @xmath2 each be a properly immersed two - sided circle or compact arc in @xmath0 . here `
properly ' means that the boundary of the @xmath3manifold lies in the boundary of @xmath0 .
one can define the intersection number of @xmath1 and @xmath2 to be the least number of intersection points obtainable by homotoping @xmath1 and @xmath2 transverse to each other .
( the count is to be made without any signs attached to the intersection points . )
it is obvious that this number is symmetric in the sense that it is independent of the order of @xmath1 and @xmath2 .
it is also obvious that @xmath1 and @xmath2 have intersection number zero if and only if they can be properly homotoped to be disjoint .
it seems natural to define the self - intersection number of an immersed two - sided circle or arc @xmath1 in @xmath0 to be the least number of transverse intersection points obtainable by homotoping @xmath1 into general position . with this definition ,
@xmath1 has self - intersection number zero if and only if it is homotopic to an embedding .
however , in light of later generalisations , it turns out that this definition should be modified a little in order to ensure that the self - intersection number of any cover of a simple closed curve is also zero .
no modification is needed unless @xmath1 is a circle which can be homotoped to cover another immersion with degree greater than @xmath3 . in this case , suppose that the maximal degree of covering which can occur is @xmath4 and that @xmath1 covers @xmath5 with degree @xmath4 .
then we define the self - intersection number of @xmath1 to be @xmath6 times the self - intersection number of @xmath5 . with this modified definition , @xmath7has self - intersection number zero if and only if it can be homotoped to cover an embedding . in @xcite ,
freedman , hass and scott introduced a notion of intersection number and self - intersection number for two - sided @xmath8injective immersions of compact surfaces into @xmath9manifolds which generalises the preceding ideas .
their intersection number can not be described as simply as for curves on a surface , but it does share some important properties . in particular , it is a non - negative integer and it is symmetric , although this symmetry is not obvious from the definition .
further , two surfaces have intersection number zero if and only if they can be homotoped to be disjoint , and a single surface has self - intersection number zero if and only if it can be homotoped to cover an embedding . these two facts are no longer obvious consequences of the definition , but are non - trivial applications of the theory of least area surfaces .
in @xcite , scott extended the ideas of @xcite to define intersection numbers in a purely group theoretic setting .
the details will be discussed in the first section of this paper , but we give an introduction to the ideas here .
it seems clear that everything discussed in the preceding two paragraphs should have a purely algebraic interpretation in terms of fundamental groups of surfaces and @xmath9manifolds , and the aim is to find an interpretation which makes sense for any group .
it seems natural to attempt to define the intersection number of two subgroups @xmath10and @xmath11 of a given group @xmath12 .
this is exactly what the topological intersection number of simple closed curves on a surface does when @xmath12 is the fundamental group of a closed orientable surface and we restrict attention to infinite cyclic subgroups @xmath13 and @xmath11 .
however , if one considers two simple arcs on a surface @xmath0 with boundary , they each carry the trivial subgroup of @xmath14 , whereas we know that some arcs have intersection number zero and others do not . thus intersection numbers are not determined simply by the groups involved .
we need to look a little deeper in order to formulate the algebraic analogue .
first we need to think a bit more about curves on surfaces .
let @xmath1 be a simple arc or closed curve on an orientable surface @xmath0 , let @xmath12 denote @xmath15 and let @xmath13 denote the image of @xmath16 in @xmath12 .
if @xmath1 separates @xmath0 then , in most cases , it gives @xmath12 the structure of an amalgamated free product @xmath17 , and if @xmath1 is non - separating , it gives @xmath12 the structure of a hnn extension @xmath18 . in order to avoid discussing which of these two structures @xmath12 has ,
it is convenient to say that a group @xmath12 _ splits over a subgroup _
@xmath13 if @xmath12 is isomorphic to @xmath18 or to @xmath17 , with @xmath19 .
( note that the condition that @xmath19 is needed as otherwise any group @xmath12 would split over any subgroup @xmath13 .
for one can always write @xmath20 . ) thus , in most cases , @xmath1 determines a splitting of @xmath14 .
usually one ignores base points , so that the splitting of @xmath12 is only determined up to conjugacy . in @xcite ,
scott defined the intersection number of two splittings of any group @xmath12 over any subgroups @xmath13 and @xmath11 . in the special case
when @xmath12 is the fundamental group of a compact surface @xmath0 and these splittings arise from embedded arcs or circles on @xmath0 , the algebraic intersection number of the splittings equals the topological intersection number of the corresponding @xmath3manifolds .
the analogous statement holds when @xmath12 is the fundamental group of a compact @xmath9manifold and these splittings arise from @xmath8injective embedded surfaces . in general , the algebraic intersection number shares some properties of the topological intersection number .
algebraic intersection numbers are symmetric , and if @xmath12 , @xmath13 and @xmath11 are finitely generated , the intersection number of splittings of @xmath12 over @xmath13 and over @xmath11 is a non - negative integer .
the first main result of this paper is a generalisation to the algebraic setting of the fact that two simple arcs or closed curves on a surface have intersection number zero if and only if they can be isotoped apart .
of course , the idea of isotopy makes no sense in the algebraic setting , so we need some algebraic language to describe multiple disjoint curves on a surface .
let @xmath21 be disjoint simple arcs or closed curves on a compact orientable surface @xmath0 with fundamental group @xmath12 , such that each @xmath22 determines a splitting of @xmath12 .
together they determine a graph of groups structure on @xmath12 with @xmath23 edges .
we say that a collection of @xmath23 splittings of a group @xmath12 is _ compatible _ if @xmath12 can be expressed as the fundamental group of a graph of groups with @xmath23 edges , such that , for each @xmath24 , collapsing all edges but the @xmath24-th yields the @xmath24-th splitting of @xmath25 we will say that the splittings are _ compatible up to conjugacy _ if collapsing all edges but the @xmath24-th yields a splitting of @xmath12 which is conjugate to the @xmath24-th given splitting .
clearly disjoint essential simple arcs or closed curves on @xmath0 define splittings of @xmath12 which are compatible up to conjugacy .
the precise statement we obtain is the following . * theorem [ disjointsplittings ]
* so far , we have not discussed any algebraic analogue of non - embedded arcs or circles on surfaces .
there is such an analogue which is the idea of an almost invariant subset of the quotient @xmath26 , where @xmath13 is a subgroup of @xmath12 .
this generalises the idea of an immersed curve in a surface or of an immersed @xmath8injective surface in a 3manifold which carries the subgroup @xmath13 of @xmath12 .
we give the definitions in section 1 .
there is also an idea of intersection number of such things , which we give in definition [ defnofintersectionnumber ] .
this too was introduced by scott in @xcite .
our second main result , theorem [ splittingsexist ] , is an algebraic analogue of the fact that a singular curve on a surface or a singular surface in a @xmath9manifold which has self - intersection number zero can be homotoped to cover an embedding .
it asserts that if @xmath26 has an almost invariant subset with self - intersection number zero , then @xmath12 has a splitting over a subgroup @xmath27 commensurable with @xmath13 .
we leave the precise statement until section 2 . in a separate paper @xcite
, we use the ideas about intersection numbers of splittings developed in @xcite and in this paper to study jsj decompositions of haken @xmath9manifolds .
the problem there is to recognize which splittings of the fundamental group of such a manifold arise from the jsj decomposition ( see @xcite and @xcite ) .
it turns out that a class of splittings which we call canonical can be defined using intersection numbers and we use this to show that the jsj decomposition for haken @xmath9manifolds depends only on the fundamental group .
this leads to an algebraic proof of johannson deformation theorem .
it seems very likely that similar ideas apply to sela s jsj decompositions @xcite of hyperbolic groups and thus provide a common thread to the two types of jsj decomposition .
thus , the use of intersection numbers seems to provide a tool in the study of diverse topics in group theory and this paper together with @xcite provides some of the foundational material .
this paper is organised as follows .
in section 1 , we recall from @xcite the basic definitions of intersection numbers in the algebraic context . we also prove a technical result which was essentially proved by scott @xcite in 1980 .
however , scott s results were all formulated in the context of surfaces in @xmath9manifolds , so we give a complete proof of the generalisation to the purely group theoretic context .
section 2 is devoted to the proofs of our two main results discussed above .
there is a second natural idea of intersection number , which we discuss in section 3 .
we call it the strong intersection number .
it is not symmetric in general , but this is not a problem when one is considering self - intersection numbers .
we also discuss when the two kinds of intersection number are equal , which then forces the strong intersection number to be symmetric .
we use these ideas to give a new approach to a result of kropholler and roller @xcite on splittings of poincar duality groups .
we also discuss applications of our ideas to prove a special case of a conjecture of kropholler and roller @xcite on splittings of groups in general .
we point out that these ideas lead to an alternative approach to the algebraic torus theorem @xcite .
we end the section with a brief discussion of an error in @xcite . in section 3 of that paper ,
scott gave an incorrect interpretation of the intersection number of two splittings .
his error was caused by confusing the ideas of strong and ordinary intersection .
however , the arguments in @xcite work to give a nice interpretation of the intersection number in the case when it is equal to the strong intersection number . without this condition , finding nice interpretations of the two intersection numbers is an open problem . |
in this paper , the novel statistical problem of deriving asymptotic results for nested random sequences of statistical descriptors for data in a non - euclidean space is considered .
it can be viewed as a generalization of classical pca s asymptotics , e.g. by @xcite , where , as a consequence of pythagoras theorem , nestedness of approximating subspaces is trivially given and thus requires no special attention . for pca analogs for data in non - euclidean spaces , due to curvature
, nestedness considerably complicates design of descriptors and , to the best knowledge of the authors , has hindered any asymptotic theory to date . for dimension reduction of non - euclidean data ,
_ procrustes analysis _ by @xcite and later _ principal geodesic analysis _ by @xcite are approaches to mimic pca on shape spaces and riemannian manifolds , respectively .
both build on the concept of a frchet mean , a minimizer of expected squared distance , around which classical pca is conducted for the data mapped to a suitable tangent space .
asymptotics for such means have been subsequently provided , among others , by @xcite , allowing for inferential methods such as two - sample tests .
asymptotics for these _ tangent space pca _ methods , however , reflecting the _ forward nestedness _ due to random basepoints ( i.e. corresponding means ) of tangent spaces with random pcs therein , remain open to date
. moreover , these tangent space pca methods are in no way canonical
. not only may statistical outcomes depend on specific choices of tangent space coordinates , more severely , given curvature , no tangent space coordinates can correctly reflect mutual data distances . for this reason , among others , _ geodesic principal component analysis _
( gpca ) has been introduced by @xcite , _ iterated frame bundle development _ by @xcite and _ barycentric subspaces _ by @xcite . as the following example teaches ,
nestedness may be lost .
[ intro.ex ] consider data on a two - sphere that is confined to its equator and nearly uniformly spread out on it .
then the best @xmath0 approximating geodesic is the equator and far away there are two ( due to symmetry ) intrinsic frchet means , each close to one of the poles , see @xcite .
let us now detail our ideas , first by elucidating the following .
* classical pca from a geometric perspective . * given data on @xmath1 , for every @xmath2 a unique affine subspace @xmath3 of dimension @xmath4 is determined by equivalently minimizing residual sums of squares or , among those containing the classical mean @xmath5 , maximizing the projected variance .
also equivalently , these subspaces have representations as @xmath6 , the affine translates of spans from an eigenvector decomposition @xmath7 of the data s covariance matrix with descending eigenvalues . in consequence ,
one may either start from the zero dimensional mean and subsequently add most descriptive dimensions ( forward ) or start from the full dimensional space and remove least descriptive dimensions ( backward ) to obtain the same forward and backward nested sequence of subspaces @xmath8 for non - euclidean data , due to failure of pythagoras theorem , this canonical decomposition of data variance is no longer possible . for a detailed discussion see @xcite .
* nestedness of non - euclidean pca * is highly desirable , when due to curvature and data spread , intrinsic frchet means are away from the data .
for instance in example [ intro.ex ] , in order to have a mean on the equator , also in this case , @xcite devised _ principal arc analysis _ with the _ backward nested mean _ confined to the best approximating circle .
this method and its generalization _ backward nested sphere analysis _ ( pns ) by @xcite give a tool for descriptive shape analysis that often strikingly outperforms tangent space pca , e.g. @xcite .
here , the data space is a unit sphere @xmath9 of dimension @xmath10 , say , and in each of the @xmath3 is a @xmath4-dimensional ( small ) subsphere for pns and for _ principal nested great spheres _ ( pngs ) it is a @xmath4-dimensional great subsphere . in passing we
note that pns is _ higher dimensional _ in the sense of having higher dimensional descriptor spaces than classical pca and pngs which are equally high dimensional , cf .
@xcite . to date
, however , there is no asymptotic theory for pns available , in particular there are no inferential tools for backward nested means , say .
asymptotic results for non - data space valued descriptors , geodesics , say , are only available for single descriptors ( cf .
@xcite ) that are directly defined as minimizers , not indirectly as a nested sequence of minimizers . *
challenges for and results of this paper . *
it is the objective of this paper to close this gap by providing asymptotic results for rather general random _
backward nested families of descriptors _ ( bnfds ) on rather general spaces .
the challenge here is that random objects that are constrained by other random objects are to be investigated , requiring an elaborate setup . into this setup
, we translate strong consistency arguments of @xcite and @xcite , and introducing a _ constrained _ m - estimation technique , we show joint asymptotic normality of an entire bnfd . in the special case of nested subspaces , bnfds may terminate at any dimension and @xmath11 is not required . as we minimize a functional under the constraining conditions that other functionals are minimized as well , our approach can be called _ constrained m - estimation_. in the literature , this term _ constrained m - estimation _ has been independently introduced by @xcite who robustify m - estimators by introducing constraining conditions and by @xcite , who consider m - estimators that are confined to closed subsets of a euclidean space with specifically regular boundaries .
it seems that our m - estimation problem , which is constrained to satisfying other m - estimation problems has not been dealt with before .
we solve it using a random lagrange multiplier approach .
furthermore , in order to obtain asymptotic normality of each single sequence element , in particular for the last , we require the rather technical concept of _ factoring charts_. our very general setup will be illustrated , still with some effort , by example of pns , pngs and the _ intrinsic mean on a first geodesic principal component _ ( imo1gpc ) . in order to exploit nested asymptotic normality for a _ nested two - sample test _ , we utilize bootstrapping techniques . while for frchet means
, as they are descriptors assuming values in the data space , one can explicitly model the dependence of the random base points of the tangent spaces as in @xcite , so that suitable statistics can be accordingly directly approximated , this modeling and approximation can be avoided using the bootstrap as in @xcite . for our application at hand , as data space and descriptor space are different , we can not approximate the distribution of random descriptors and we fall back on the bootstrap . * suggestions for live imaging of stem cell differentiation . * after illustrations of our nested two - sample test by simulations for pns and pngs ,
we apply it to a cutting edge application in adult human stem cell differentiation research .
`` rooted in a line of experimentation originating in the 1960s '' ( from @xcite ) , the promise that stem cells taken from a patient s bone marrow may be used to rebuild specific , previously lost , patient s tissue is currently undergoing an abundance of clinical trials .
although the underlying mechanisms are , to date , not fully understood , it is common knowledge that early stem cell differentiation is triggered by biomechanical cues , e.g. @xcite , which result in specific ordering of the cellular _ actin - myosin filament skeleton_. in collaboration with the third institute of physics at the university of gttingen we map fluorescence images of cell structures to two - spheres , where each point stands for a specific ordering . with our 2d pngs two - sample test
we can track the direction of increased ordering over the first 24 hours .
we find , however , a consistent reversal of ordering between hours 16 to 20 which hint toward the effect of cell division .
this effect suggests that the commonly used time point of 24 hours for fixated hmscs imaging , e.g. as in @xcite , may not be ideal for cell differentiation detection .
in fact , our method can be used to direct more elaborate and refined imaging techniques , such as time resolved in - vivo cell imaging , using @xcite , say , to investigate specifically discriminatory time intervals in detail . *
we conclude our introduction * by noting that our setup of bnfds has a canonical form on a riemannian manifold with @xmath3 in ( [ backward - nested - subspaces : eq ] ) being a totally geodesic submanifold , not necessarily of codimension one in @xmath12 , however .
for example for kendall s shape spaces @xmath13 which is a complex projective space of real dimension @xmath14 , cf .
@xcite , we have a sequence of @xmath15 where the numbers below the inclusions denote the corresponding co - dimensions . more generally , we believe that our setup can be generalized to riemann stratified spaces . for example , ( [ nested - shape - spaces : eq ] ) generalizes at once to @xmath16 ( the shape space of @xmath17-dimensional @xmath18 landmark configurations which has dimension @xmath19 ) with @xmath20 , cf .
@xcite , now with @xmath21 indeed , in section [ scn : kendalls - shape - spaces ] we illustrate the generalization to the sequence @xmath22 , giving the imo1gpc for arbitrary @xmath16 .
our setup may also generalize to phylogenetic tree spaces as introduced by @xcite , cf .
also @xcite , or torus - pca and the more general polysphere - pca , cf .
moreover , our setup may be applied to flags of barycentric subspaces as introduced by @xcite . *
our paper is organized as follows . * in the following section we introduce the abstract setup of bnfds and show that the essential assumptions are fulfilled for pns , pngs and imo1gpcs for riemannian manifolds and kendall s shape spaces . in the section to follow we will develop a set of assumptions necessary for the main results on asymptotic strong consistency and normality which are stated in section [ main - results : scn ] . also in section [ main - results : scn ] ,
we give our nested bootstrap two - sample test .
the elaborate proof of asymptotic strong consistency is deferred to the appendix . in section
[ application : scn ] we show simulations and our applications to stem cell differentiation .
in this section we first introduce the general framework including the fundamental assumption of _ factoring charts _ which is essential to prove asymptotic normality of single nested descriptors in section [ main - results : scn ] .
then we give examples : the intrinsic mean on a first geodesic principal component ( imo1gpc ) for riemannian manifolds , principal nested spheres ( pns ) as well as principal nested great spheres ( pngs ) and finally we give an example for the imo1gpcs also on non - manifold kendall s shape spaces .
the first example is rather straightforward , the last is slightly more involved and the second and third are much more involved . the differential geometry used here can be found in any standard textbook , e.g. @xcite .
first , let us quickly sketch the ideas in case of imo1gpcs on a riemannian manifold @xmath23 .
there , we have the space @xmath24 of point sets of geodesics on @xmath23 which is the first non - trivial descriptor space `` below '' the space @xmath25 . in order to show strong asymptotic consistency in theorem [ sc : thm ] ,
on @xmath26 we require the concept of a _ loss function _
@xmath27 that has some properties of a distance between two ( point sets of ) geodesics .
in order to model nestedness , given a geodesic @xmath28 we require the set @xmath29 of lower dimensional descriptors in @xmath30 which lie on @xmath31 .
these are the candidate nested means on @xmath31 , and in this case , @xmath32 .
further , we need the data projection @xmath33 and we measure the distance @xmath34 of the projected data to a candidate nested mean @xmath35 . then every @xmath36 with @xmath37 will be a _
backward nested family of descriptors _ ( bnfd ) and the set @xmath38 with @xmath37 carries a natural manifold structure .
it is the objective of _ factoring charts _ to represent this manifold locally as a direct product of arbitrary variable offsets @xmath39 times a suitable space parametrizing directions of geodesics , parametrized independently from the offset @xmath40 , cf .
figure [ chartfactoring : fig ] .
we will see that is precisely the geometry of the projective bundle .
once we establish asymptotic normality of the backward nested descriptor @xmath38 , asymptotic normality follows at once also for @xmath41 , because , under factoring charts , @xmath41 is given by some coordinates of a gaussian vector as reasoned in the proof of theorem [ clt : thm ] . with a silently underlying probability space @xmath42 , _ random elements _ on a topological space @xmath23
are mappings @xmath43 that are measurable with respect to the borel @xmath44-algebra of @xmath23 . in the following , _
smooth _ refers to existing continuous 2nd order derivatives . for a topological space @xmath23
we say that a continuous function @xmath45 is a _ loss function _ if @xmath46 if and only if @xmath47 .
we say that a set @xmath48 is @xmath49-bounded if @xmath50 .
moreover , we say that @xmath51 is _ @xmath49-heine borel _ if all closed @xmath49-bounded subsets of @xmath52 are compact .
[ bnfd : def ] a separable topological space @xmath23 , called the _ data space _ , admits _ backward nested families of descriptors _ ( bnfds ) if a. there is a collection @xmath53 ( @xmath54 ) of topological separable spaces with loss functions @xmath55 ; b. @xmath56 ; c. every @xmath57 ( @xmath58 ) is itself a topological space and gives rise to a topological space @xmath59 which comes with a continuous map @xmath60 d. for every pair @xmath57 ( @xmath58 ) and @xmath61 there is a measurable map called _ projection _
@xmath62 for @xmath63 and @xmath64 call a family @xmath65 a _ backward nested family of descriptors ( bnfd ) from @xmath53 to @xmath66_. the space of all bnfds from @xmath53 to @xmath66 is given by @xmath67 for @xmath68 , given a bnfd @xmath69 set @xmath70 which projects along each descriptor .
for another bnfd @xmath71 set @xmath72 in case of pns , the nested projection @xmath73 is illustrated in figure [ pns_illustration : fig ] ( a ) .
random elements @xmath74 on a data space @xmath23 admitting bnfds give rise to _ backward nested population _ and _ sample means _ ( abbreviated as bn means ) @xmath75 recursively defined via @xmath76 , i.e. @xmath77 and @xmath78 , & f^j & = \{p^k\}_{k = j}^{m } \\ e^{f_n^{j-1}}_n & = \operatorname*{\mbox{\rm argmin}}_{s\in s_{p^{j}_n } } \sum_{i=1}^n\rho_{p_n^{j}}(\pi_{f_n^{j}}\circ x_i , s)^2 , & f_n^j & = \{p_n^k\}_{k = j}^{m } \ , .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath79 and @xmath80 is a measurable choice for @xmath58 .
we say that a bnfd @xmath81 gives _ unique _ bn population means if @xmath82 with @xmath83 for all @xmath54 .
each of the @xmath84 and @xmath85 is also called a _
generalized frchet mean_. note that by definition there is only one @xmath86 .
for this reason , for notational simplicity , we ignore it from now on and begin all bnfds with @xmath87 and consider thus the corresponding @xmath88 .
[ def : factoring ] let @xmath89 .
if @xmath90 and @xmath91 carry smooth manifold structures near @xmath92 and @xmath93 , respectively , with open @xmath94 , @xmath95 such that @xmath96 , @xmath97 , and with local charts @xmath98 we say that the _ chart @xmath99 factors _ , cf .
figure [ chartfactoring : fig ] ( a ) and ( b ) , if with the projections @xmath100 we have @xmath101 @xmath102{\includegraphics[width=0.27\textwidth , clip = true , trim=8 cm 4 cm 3.5 cm 1.5cm]{"bnfd_illustration_family " } } } } \scalebox{2}{$\stackrel{\psi}{\to}$}~~ \vcenter{\hbox{\subcaptionbox{coordinates}[0.27\textwidth]{\includegraphics[width=0.27\textwidth , clip = true , trim=8 cm 4 cm 3.5 cm 1.5cm]{"bnfd_illustration_chart " } } } } \hspace*{0.02\textwidth } \vcenter{\hbox{\subcaptionbox{projective bundle}[0.35\textwidth]{\includegraphics[width=0.35\textwidth , clip = true , trim=4 cm 2.5 cm 3 cm 1.5cm]{projective_bundle}}}}$ ] suppose that @xmath103 are random variables assuming values on a riemannian manifold @xmath23 with riemannian norm @xmath104 for the tangent spaces @xmath105 ( @xmath106 ) , induced metric @xmath107 , _ projective tangent bundle _ @xmath108 and space of classes of geodesics given by their point sets @xmath109 : ( q,\{v ,- v\})\in pq\ } , ~ [ \gamma_{q , v } ] = \{\gamma_{r , w } : \gamma_{q , v}(t ) = r,~ \dot\gamma_{q , v}(t)= w\mbox { for some } t\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath110 denotes the unique maximal geodesic through @xmath111 with unit speed velocity @xmath112 , @xmath113 . then consider @xmath114 there is a well defined distance between a point @xmath40 and a class of geodesics determined by @xmath115\big )
\mapsto \inf_{t}d\big(s,\gamma_{q , v}(t))\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] then every class of geodesics determined by @xmath116\big)^2\big]\mbox { or } \operatorname*{\mbox{\rm argmin}}_{(q , v)\in tq}\sum_{k=1}^n \rho\big(x_k,[\gamma_{q , v}]\big)^2\end{aligned}\ ] ] is called a _ first population principal component geodesic _ or a _ first sample principal component geodesic _ , respectively , cf .
@xcite .
moreover , given a first population principal component geodesic @xmath117 $ ] and a first sample principal component geodesic @xmath118 $ ] , with the orthogonal projection @xmath119 , q'\mapsto
\operatorname*{\mbox{\rm argmin}}_{\gamma_{q , v}(t ) } d(q',\gamma_{q , v}(t))\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is well defined outside a set of zero riemannian volume , e.g. ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2.6 ) , we have the _ intrinsic population means on @xmath31 _ and _ intrinsic sample means on @xmath120 _ determined by @xmath121\mbox { or } \operatorname*{\mbox{\rm argmin}}_{\gamma_{q , v}(t)}\sum_{k=1}^n \rho_p\big(\pi_{q , p}\circ x_k,\gamma_{q , v}(t)\big)^2\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively , where @xmath122 for @xmath123 in @xmath31 . in particular , we have the space of _ backward nested descriptors _ @xmath124 \in p_1,~ s \in p\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which carries the natural manifold structure of the projective tangent bundle @xmath125 conveyed by the identity @xmath126,s ) \mapsto ( s,\{w ,- w\})\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath127 , @xmath128 , if @xmath129 . recall that the tangent bundle @xmath130 admits _ local trivializations _ , i.e. every @xmath106 has a local neighborhood @xmath131 with a smooth one - to - one mapping @xmath132 where the first coordinate satisfies @xmath133 for all @xmath134 , @xmath135 and the second coordinate @xmath136 is a vector space isomorphism . in consequence , for a given @xmath137 , with local charts @xmath138 of @xmath23 around @xmath139 , and @xmath140 of the real projective space @xmath141 of dimension @xmath142 around @xmath143 , @xmath144 open , and the open set @xmath145 the mapping @xmath146 yields a local chart that factors as in definition [ def : factoring ] .
this scenario is sketched in figure [ chartfactoring : fig ] ( c ) .
the ( nested ) projections detailed below are illustrated in figure [ pns_illustration : fig ] .
* notation . * consider the standard inner product @xmath147 on @xmath148 with norm @xmath149 and the @xmath150-dimensional unit sphere @xmath151 , with interior @xmath152 . for any matrix @xmath153
we have the frobenius norm @xmath154 and the inner product @xmath155 for @xmath156 .
the @xmath157 dimensional unit matrix is @xmath158 and @xmath159 is the orthogonal group .
moreover , e.g. @xcite , @xmath160 denotes the stiefel manifold of orthonormal @xmath4-frames in @xmath161 . for every such orthonormal @xmath4-frame
we have a non - unique _ orthonormal complement _
@xmath162 such that @xmath163 . in pns and pngs ,
for a top sphere @xmath164 a sequence of nested subspheres is sought for . only in the scenario of pngs
it is required that each subsphere is a great subsphere . in general , every @xmath18-dimensional subsphere ( @xmath165 ) is the intersection of a @xmath166 dimensional affine subspace of @xmath148 with @xmath167 . recall that every @xmath166 dimensional affine subspace @xmath168 is determined by a matrix @xmath169 of @xmath170 orthonormal column vectors that are orthogonal to @xmath171 and a vector of signed distances from the origin @xmath172 in particular @xmath173 ensures that @xmath171 intersects with @xmath167 in a @xmath18 dimensional subsphere .
obviously , @xmath171 determines @xmath174 and @xmath175 up to an action of @xmath176 , i.e. with every @xmath177 , @xmath178 and @xmath179 determine the same @xmath171 . in pngs
only great subspheres are allowed as intersections .
hence all affine spaces under consideration above pass through the origin , i.e. @xmath180 above . * the parameter space .
* in consequence we have that the family of @xmath18-dimensional subspheres ( @xmath181 is given by the smooth manifold @xmath182 : z \in m_j\right\}\mbox { with } [ z ] = \left\{z r : r\in o(m - j)\right\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath183 with @xmath184 above , for compatibility , becoming clear in the considerations below . indeed , the smooth action from the right of the compact lie group @xmath185 on @xmath186 is free ( for @xmath187 and @xmath188 , @xmath189 implies that @xmath190 ) , giving rise to a smooth quotient manifold , e.g. ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 7.10 ) , of dimension @xmath191 for pns and of dimension @xmath192 for pngs .
notably , in the latter case , @xmath53 is just a grassmannian . in the above setup
, we had excluded the cases @xmath193 . for @xmath194 , for pns and pngs
it is natural to set , as in definition [ bnfd : def ] , @xmath195 in case of @xmath196 , the setup above would yield pairs of points ( the intersections of suitable lines with @xmath167 give topologically zero - dimensional spheres @xmath197 ) . in order to have a single nested mean as a zero dimensional descriptor only , for pns and pngs ( in order to represent nestedness ) we use the convention @xmath198 * distance between subspheres of equal dimension .
* for pns and pngs , on @xmath186 we have the _ extrinsic metric _
@xmath199 since the extrinsic metric is invariant under the action of @xmath185 it gives rise to the well defined quotient metric , called the _ ziezold metric _ , cf .
@xcite ) on @xmath53 given by @xmath200 for arbitrary representatives @xmath201 of @xmath202 , respectively , as the following lemma teaches .
[ lem : ziezold - metric ] the mapping @xmath203 satisfies the triangle inequality and it is definite , i.e. @xmath204 implies @xmath205 .
suppose that @xmath206 are representatives of @xmath207 with the property , w.l.o.g .
, that @xmath208
. then the usual triangle inequality yields @xmath209
moreover , we have @xmath210 where @xmath211 and @xmath212 with equality if and only if @xmath213 and @xmath214 with @xmath215 , yielding that the above vanishes if and only if this is the case with @xmath216 . * backwards nesting . * in pns , the space of subspheres @xmath217 within a given subsphere @xmath218^t\in p_j$ ] ( @xmath219 )
can be given the following structure .
@xmath220 indeed ,
if @xmath221 , @xmath188 is another representative for @xmath31 , then @xmath222 if and only if @xmath223 . in case of pngs ,
the condition on entries of @xmath175 above is simply @xmath224 because @xmath225 .
according to our convention of @xmath226 , in case of @xmath227 the inequality above needs to be replaced with @xmath228 ( for pns ) and with @xmath229 for ( pngs ) .
* projections .
* for all @xmath230 we have the intrinsic orthogonal projection onto @xmath218^t \in p_j$ ] @xmath231 which is independent of the representative @xmath232 chosen and independent of the specific orthogonal complement @xmath233 of @xmath174 chosen ; and it is well defined except for a set @xmath234 of spherical measure zero . note that we have @xmath235 for @xmath196 and hence the constant mapping @xmath236 .
* nested projections . * more generally , if @xmath237 are from a family of backward nested subspheres @xmath238
, @xmath239 , we may choose representatives @xmath232 of @xmath240 and @xmath241 of @xmath242 such that @xmath243 with ( [ eq : blow - down ] ) and the arbitrary but fixed complement @xmath244 of @xmath174 chosen , embed @xmath240 in @xmath245 ( first a translation , possible in pns , and then a blow up ) , depending on the specific choice of @xmath244 , via @xmath246 now , @xmath247 embeds @xmath242 as a @xmath248-dimensional ( possibly small ) subsphere @xmath249 in @xmath245 , given by @xmath250^t = p'_{j'}$ ] , for suitable @xmath251 , and there is an orthogonal complement @xmath252 of @xmath253 , such that @xmath254 this gives the definition of the projection , independent of the specific orthogonal complements chosen , @xmath255 plugging in ( [ eq : blow - down ] ) into the above equality and taking into account that @xmath256 , cf .
( [ eq : blow - up ] ) , yields at once the following proposition which asserts that projections along nested subspheres only depend on the final subsphere at which it ends .
recall that @xmath225 ( @xmath257 if @xmath258 ) in case of pngs .
[ pns - bnds : prop ] with the above notation @xmath259 .
* distance between projected data and next subsphere . * here , we compute the intrinsic geodesic distance @xmath260 between @xmath261 and @xmath262^t\in s_{p^j}$ ] in a subsphere @xmath263^t \in p_j$ ] ( @xmath264 . note that only in case of @xmath240 being a great subsphere , this distance agrees with the spherical distance @xmath265 in the top sphere @xmath167 . if @xmath240 is a proper subsphere ( @xmath266 ) , assuming w.l.o.g . that @xmath267 and @xmath268 we have @xmath269 indeed with @xmath270 and the notation from ( [ eq : blow - down ] ) to ( [ eq : projections ] ) and orthogonal complements @xmath271 of @xmath174 and @xmath272 of @xmath273 , respectively , we have @xmath274 since @xmath275 due to ( [ eq : blow - down ] ) , @xmath276 and @xmath277 .
* optimal positioning . * on @xmath186 we have the extrinsic metric due to its embedding in @xmath278 , cf .
( [ extrinsic - metric : eq ] ) , and its thus induced riemannian metric .
obviously @xmath185 acts on @xmath186 isometrically w.r.t .
the extrinsic metric .
it also acts isometrically w.r.t .
the riemannian metric because the action also preserves geodesics on @xmath279 , e.g. @xcite . in consequence , for both metrics , we say for given @xmath280 that @xmath188 puts @xmath281 i.o.p .
( _ in optimal position _ ) to @xmath282 , if @xmath283 [ lem : smooth - op ] let @xmath284 and @xmath201 be sufficiently close
. then , there is a unique @xmath285 such that a. @xmath286 puts @xmath281 uniquely i.o.p .
@xmath287 to @xmath282 , b. if @xmath288 is symmetric then @xmath289 . in order that @xmath188 minimizes the r.h.s of ( [ extrinsic - metric : eq ] ) , given by @xmath290 with @xmath291 , it maximizes @xmath292 .
this is so if @xmath293 for a singular value decomposition ( svd ) @xmath294 stemming from a spectral decomposition @xmath295 .
since for @xmath296 we have that @xmath297 is of full rank for all @xmath298 , there is locally a full rank svd , which is unique up to @xmath299 and @xmath300 for any @xmath301 with @xmath302 .
however , @xmath303 is unique under actions of such @xmath304 , yielding ( i ) .
( ii ) : the symmetry @xmath305 allows to choose @xmath306 , i.e. @xmath307 .
this lemma has the following immediate consequence . if @xmath201 are sufficiently close then @xmath308 thus , in further consequence , for every @xmath309 there is @xmath310 such that @xmath311 is a smooth manifold and every @xmath312 has a neighborhood @xmath313 with a smooth diffeomorphism @xmath314 where @xmath315 is a fixed representative of @xmath316 and @xmath317 is an arbitrary representative of @xmath31 , and @xmath281 is a representative i.o .
p to @xmath282 .
this follows from the fact that locally a point is i.o.p to @xmath282 if and only if it can be reached by a _ horizontal _
geodesic from @xmath282 , and from the fact that all geodesics in @xmath53 through @xmath316 lift to horizontal geodesics in @xmath186 through @xmath282 and all horizontal geodesics in @xmath186 project to geodesics in @xmath53 . for a detailed discussion
e.g. @xcite .
* representing spaces of nested subspheres : factoring charts . * for @xmath318 recall @xmath319 and
that if @xmath320 is a representative of @xmath321 , then every @xmath61 is represented by some @xmath322 with suitable choices @xmath323 , @xmath324 and @xmath325 ( for pns , @xmath326 ) , @xmath327 ( for pngs , @xmath326 ) and @xmath328 ( for @xmath227 ) .
vice versa , from every representative @xmath329 of @xmath330 , all of the @xmath57 with @xmath61 are determined by choosing @xmath331 orthonormal vectors from the column span of @xmath253 ( the columns of @xmath332 below ) with suitable @xmath331 distances ( given by the vector @xmath333 below ) , i.e. every such @xmath31 has a representation @xmath334\end{aligned}\ ] ] as @xmath52 ranges over @xmath335 .
in case of pngs and @xmath227 , for compatibility we set @xmath336 .
of course , different @xmath52 may give same the @xmath31 .
more precisely , here is the central observation . given @xmath337\in p^{j-1}$ ] , every @xmath338 with @xmath61 is uniquely determined as @xmath339 $ ] by choice of @xmath340 , where @xmath52 is an arbitrary orthonormal complement of @xmath341 in @xmath342 , i.e. @xmath343 .
this means that @xmath344 uniquely parametrizes @xmath345 .
the reason is the well known fact that the grassmannian @xmath346 is diffeomorphic with @xmath344 .
again , in case of pngs and @xmath227 , for compatibility we set @xmath347 .
this observation gives rise to _ factoring charts _ as introduced in definition [ def : factoring ] . here and below in theorem
[ th : several - nested - subspheres ] , @xmath348 assumes the role of @xmath349 from definition [ def : factoring ] .
[ lem : two - nested - subspheres ] every @xmath350 has a neighborhood @xmath351 and a smooth diffeomorphism @xmath352 where @xmath348 is from ( [ eq : chart - pj ] ) , @xmath353 is a neighborhood of @xmath354 and @xmath355 are representatives of @xmath356 and @xmath316 respectively . in particular , @xmath357\mbox { and } p = [ zb ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] with arbitrary orthonormal complement @xmath52 of @xmath341 .
let @xmath358 $ ] for some @xmath359 be sufficiently close to @xmath356 . then , according to lemma [ lem : smooth - op ] , @xmath41 has a unique representative @xmath360 in optimal position to @xmath282 , varying smoothly in @xmath361 , hence smoothly in @xmath41 .
moreover , as elaborated above , every @xmath57 with @xmath61 depends uniquely upon the choice of @xmath340 and any orthonormal complement @xmath52 , i.e. @xmath362 $ ] .
although @xmath363 determines the same @xmath331 dimensional subspace , a one - to - one mapping is obtained choosing the neighborhood @xmath313 of @xmath364 suitably small not containing antipodals .
the following is a straightforward generalization to spaces of sequences of several nested subspheres .
[ th : several - nested - subspheres ] let @xmath365 and @xmath366 . then every @xmath367 has a neighborhood @xmath94 and a smooth diffeomorphism @xmath368 where @xmath369 is from ( [ eq : chart - pj ] ) , each @xmath370 is a neighborhood of @xmath371 , @xmath372 are representatives of @xmath373 and @xmath374 respectively ( @xmath375 ) . in particular , @xmath376\mbox { and } p^{j - r+1 } = [ zb_k\cdots b_{r } ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] with arbitrary orthonormal complements @xmath377 in @xmath378 of @xmath379 ( @xmath375 ) . * a joint representation . * here we assume that @xmath380 and @xmath381 are two sufficiently close families of backward nested spheres with representatives @xmath382 such that @xmath383 are in o. @xmath384-p .
notably , there are then uniquely determined @xmath385 complements @xmath386 and @xmath387 respectively . for a sufficiently small neighborhood @xmath388 of @xmath389 and neighborhoods @xmath390 of @xmath391 in @xmath392 ( @xmath375 )
we have then a smooth mapping @xmath393 determined by the following algorithm ( here is only the pngs version ) . for arbitrary @xmath394
, @xmath395 denotes the orthogonal projection to the complement of @xmath174 .
* @xmath396 is the unique element such that @xmath397 .
* @xmath398 is the unique element such that @xmath399 . here , @xmath400 is obtained from @xmath401 by removing one column such that @xmath402 is in the span of the rest ( usually @xmath403 ) . *
@xmath404 * @xmath405 is the unique element such that @xmath406 . here
, @xmath407 is obtained from @xmath408 by removing one column such that @xmath409 is in the span of the other two .
* local charts . * for @xmath53 and @xmath90 ,
we have derived in and theorem [ th : several - nested - subspheres ] , respectively , local smooth diffeomorphic representations in a euclidean space of suitable dimension , @xmath17 , say , that can be generically written as @xmath410 with a neighborhood @xmath411 of some @xmath412 and a smooth mapping @xmath413 , @xmath414 , @xmath415 with full rank derivative @xmath416 at @xmath417 . here , the corresponding matrices are viewed as vectorized by stacking their columns on top of one another . with @xmath418 , the orthogonal projection to the row space of the @xmath419 matrix of the derivative at @xmath420 and orthogonal @xmath17-vectors @xmath421
, spanning the kernel of @xmath416 of dimension @xmath422 , obtain the local chart @xmath423 another application is given by the intrinsic mean on a geodesic principal component on a quotient space @xmath424 due to an isometric action of a lie group @xmath425 on a riemannian manifold @xmath426 .
we treat here the prominent application of kendall s shape spaces @xmath427:x\in { \mathbb s}^{m(k-1)-1}\},\quad , [ x]=\{gx : g\in so(m)\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the space @xmath428 of unit size @xmath429 matrices corresponding to normed and centered configuration of @xmath4 landmarks in @xmath150-dimensional euclidean space is taken modulo the group of rotations in @xmath150-dimensional space .
this space models all @xmath150-dimensional configurations of @xmath4 landmarks , not all coinciding , modulo similarity transformations , cf . @xcite . for @xmath430
this space is no longer a manifold but decomposes into strata of manifolds of different dimensions , cf .
geodesics on the unit sphere @xmath428 , i.e. great circles , orthogonal to the the orbits @xmath431 $ ] , called _ horizontal great circles _ , project to geodesics in @xmath432 such that the space @xmath24 of geodesics of @xmath23 can be given the quotient structure of a stratified space @xmath433 with the horizontal stiefel manifold @xmath434 and the orbits @xmath435 = \ { ( gx , gv ) h : g\in so(m ) , h \in o(2)\}\,\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath436 , cf .
* theorem 5.2 ) .
the action of @xmath437 is not free for @xmath430 , giving rise to a non - trivial stratified structure . as before in section [ imo1gpc : scn ] , we set @xmath438 having geodesics , orthogonal projections @xmath439 can be defined , which are unique outside a set of intrinsic measure zero , cf .
* theorem 2.6 ) .
the geodesic distance @xmath49 on @xmath23 gives rise to the geodesic distance @xmath440 between a datum @xmath139 and a geodesic @xmath31 .
similarly the induced intrinsic distance on @xmath31 gives rise to @xmath441 where @xmath442 can be identified with @xmath31 .
for @xmath27 and @xmath443 , for simplicity , not the canonical intrinsic distances on @xmath24 and @xmath444 but quotient distances due to the embedding of @xmath445 and @xmath446 , respectively , can be used , called the ziezold distances , cf .
@xcite .
the generalized frchet mean corresponding to @xmath447 is the first geodesic principal component ( gpc ) @xmath31 , the generalized frchet mean corresponding to @xmath448 is the the intrinsic mean on the first gpc , cf .
the latter is again a nested mean . with the _ horizontal projective bundle _ over the unit sphere @xmath449
we have the space @xmath450,[x ] ) : x\in { \mathbb s}^{m(k-1)-1 } , \{v ,-
v\ } \in p^h_x { \mathbb s}^{m(k-1)-1}\}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the principal orbit theorem ( e.g. @xcite states in particular , that @xmath444 and @xmath24 have open and dense subsets @xmath451 that are manifolds , in our case smooth manifolds .
this gives rise to the manifold @xmath452 with local smooth coordinates near @xmath453 @xmath454 where @xmath455 and @xmath456 is a representative of @xmath31 i.o.p . to @xmath457 , under the action of @xmath458 , with @xmath459 .
here @xmath457 is an arbitrary but fixed representative of @xmath316 such that @xmath417 is a representative of @xmath356 . along the lines of lemma [
lem : smooth - op ] one can show that optimal positioning is unique if @xmath460 has rank @xmath461 , which may be assumed for most realistic data scenarios .
arguing as in section [ imo1gpc : scn ] , with every local trivialization of the horizontal bundle @xmath462 comes a factoring chart .
in this section we are back in the general scenario described in section [ general_framework : scn ] .
we develop a set of assumptions necessary for the general results on asymptotic consistency and asymptotic normality in section [ asymptotics : scn ] .
we then show that they are fulfilled in case of pns / pngs and the imo1gpc of kendall s shape spaces .
for the following assumptions suppose that @xmath463 .
[ ass - meas - exists : as ] for a random element @xmath464 in @xmath23 , assume that @xmath465<\infty$ ] for all bnfds @xmath466 ending at @xmath240 , @xmath467 . in order to measure a difference between @xmath61 and @xmath468 for @xmath469 define the orthogonal projection of @xmath61 onto @xmath470 as @xmath471 in case of pns this is illustrated in figure [ pns_illustration : fig ] ( a ) .
[ projection - unique : as ] for every @xmath61 there is @xmath472 such that @xmath473 whenever @xmath202 with @xmath474 .
[ 0.48 ] [ 0.48 ] for @xmath61 and @xmath202 sufficiently close let @xmath475 be the unique element .
note that in general @xmath476 in the following assumption , however , we will require that they will uniformly not differ too much if @xmath31 is close to @xmath316 . also , we require that @xmath477 and @xmath41 be close . [
projection - close : as ] for @xmath310 there is @xmath472 such that @xmath478 whenever @xmath202 with @xmath474
. we will also require the following assumption , which , in conjunction with assumption [ projection - close : as ] , is a consequence of the triangle inequality , if @xmath479 is a metric .
[ almost - triangle : as ] suppose that @xmath480 and @xmath481 with @xmath482 and @xmath483
. then also @xmath484 moreover , we require uniformity and coercivity in the following senses . [
uniform - link : as ] for all @xmath310 there are @xmath485 such that @xmath486 for all bnfds @xmath487 ending in @xmath202 , respectively , with @xmath488 and @xmath489 with @xmath490 .
[ coercivity : as ] if @xmath491 and @xmath492 with @xmath493 , then for every @xmath494 we have that @xmath495 for every @xmath106 with @xmath496 and bnfds @xmath497 ending at @xmath498 respectively .
[ compact : rm ] due to continuity , assumptions [ ass - meas - exists : as ] and [ uniform - link : as ] hold if @xmath23 is compact and assumption [ coercivity : as ] if each @xmath53 is compact .
assumptions [ ass - meas - exists : as ] [ coercivity : as ] hold for pns and pngs for all @xmath499 . moreover , each @xmath53 is @xmath500-heine borel for @xmath54 .
recall from proposition [ pns - bnds : prop ] that @xmath73 only depends on the final descriptor at which @xmath466 ends .
for pns and pngs we use the notation introduced in section [ setup : scn ] and show first assumption [ projection - unique : as ] .
let @xmath232 and @xmath501 be representatives of @xmath202 in optimal position and @xmath502^t\in s_p$ ] with @xmath503 and @xmath504 .
moreover consider a candidate element @xmath505 and its squared distance to @xmath41 , @xmath506 with @xmath507 with the continuous function @xmath508 , we have @xmath509 , which , by lemma [ lem : ziezold - metric ] , is uniquely assumed for @xmath510 and @xmath511 .
due to continuity , for @xmath512 sufficiently close to @xmath513 all minimizers @xmath514 of @xmath515 are in a neighborhood of @xmath516 and there , @xmath144 is full rank and hence , arguing as in the proof of ( i ) of lemma [ lem : smooth - op ] , the extremal @xmath188 is uniquely determined .
let us write @xmath517 to obtain @xmath518 as @xmath341 is unique , minimizing the above for @xmath519 is equivalent to minimizing @xmath520 under the constraining conditions @xmath521 and @xmath522 which yields the necessary equation @xmath523 right multiplication with @xmath524 yields at once @xmath525 such that @xmath519 is uniquely determined by @xmath526 indeed , @xmath519 is well defined because it is in a neighborhood of @xmath527 and hence @xmath341 in a neighborhood of @xmath391 .
more simply , without lagrange minimization , we obtain @xmath528 . for @xmath529 sufficiently close , this yields a unique @xmath530 minimizing @xmath531 over @xmath532 , yielding at once assumptions [ projection - unique : as ] , [ projection - close : as ] and [ almost - triangle : as ] ( because @xmath500 is a metric ) .
due to remark [ compact : rm ] , assumptions [ ass - meas - exists : as ] , [ uniform - link : as ] and [ coercivity : as ] hold .
because each @xmath53 is a finite dimensional manifold and @xmath500 is a topologically compatible metric , @xmath53 is @xmath500-heine borel . for imo1gpcs on kendall s shape spaces @xmath432 , @xmath533 , assumptions [ ass - meas - exists : as ] [ coercivity : as ] hold for @xmath227
. moreover , @xmath53 is @xmath534 heine - borel for @xmath535 .
assumption [ projection - unique : as ] follows at once from the compactness of @xmath23 , hence the geodesics @xmath536 are also compact and the proof of ( * ? ? ?
* theorem a.5 ) , as there , in claim ii , a neighborhood of a geodesic @xmath31 is constructed , restricted to which the orthogonal projection @xmath537 is well defined and continuous in @xmath31 .
compactness and continuity also imply assumptions [ projection - close : as ] and [ almost - triangle : as ] .
assumptions [ ass - meas - exists : as ] , [ uniform - link : as ] and [ coercivity : as ] follow from remark [ compact : rm ] . again ,
let @xmath538 .
[ as : clt - uniform - derivatives ] assume that @xmath539 carries a smooth manifold structure near the unique bn population mean @xmath540 such that there is an open set @xmath541 , @xmath542 and a local chart @xmath543 further , assume that for every @xmath544 the mapping @xmath545 has first and second derivatives , such that for all @xmath544 , @xmath546\mbox { , and } \mathbb e\big[{\mbox{\rm hess\,}}_\eta \tau^l(\eta',x)\big]\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] exist and are in expectation continuous near @xmath547 , i.e. for @xmath548 we have @xmath549\:\to\:0\ , , \\
{ \mathbb e}\left[\mathop{\sup}_{\|\eta-\eta'\|<\delta}\left\|{\mbox{\rm hess\,}}_\eta \tau^l(\eta , x ) - { \mbox{\rm hess\,}}_\eta \tau^l(\eta',x)\right\|\right]\:\to\:0\ , .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , assume that the vectors @xmath550,\ldots , { \mathbb e}\big[{\mbox{\rm grad}}_\eta \tau^{m}(\eta',x)\big]$ ] are linearly independent . for pns and pngs a global ,
manifold structure has been derived in section [ sec : pns - framework ] with projections ( [ eq : blow - down ] ) ( see also proposition [ pns - bnds : prop ] ) and distances ( [ rho - p - pns : eq ] ) smooth away from singularity sets . for imo1gpcs on kendall s shape spaces , this has been provided in section [ scn : kendalls - shape - spaces ] , cf .
also @xcite . in general
, however , it is unclear under which circumstances ( if the second derivatives are continuous in both arguments where @xmath464 is supported in a compact set , then convergence to zero holds not only in expectation but also a.s . ) the three assumptions above , uniqueness , existence of first and second moments of second and first derivatives and their continuity in expectation are valid .
even for the much simpler case of intrinsic means on manifolds this is only very partially known , cf .
the discussion in @xcite .
it seems that only for the most simple non - euclidean case of intrinsic means on circles the full picture is available ( @xcite ) . recently ,
rather generic conditions for densities have been derived by @xcite , ensuring @xmath551-gaussian asymptotic normality .
the condition on linear independence is rather natural for realistic scenarios where each constraining condition adds a new constraint , not covered by the previous , as introduced after corollary [ cor : lambda - lem2 ] .
for example , if charts factor , then with decreasing @xmath552 , every constraning condition results in conditions on new coordinates .
[ sc : thm ] let @xmath553 and consider random data @xmath554 on a data space @xmath23 admitting bn descriptor families from @xmath555 to @xmath556 , unique bn population means @xmath557 and bn sample means @xmath558 due to a measurable selection @xmath559 giving rise to bnfds @xmath560 , @xmath561 .
if assumptions [ ass - meas - exists : as ] [ coercivity : as ] are valid for all @xmath562 , and every @xmath563 is a.s . @xmath500-heine borel ( @xmath561 ) then @xmath558 converges a.s . to @xmath557 in the sense that @xmath564 measurable with @xmath565 such that for all @xmath561 , @xmath310 and @xmath566 , @xmath567 with @xmath568 we proceed by backward induction on @xmath18 .
the case @xmath194 is trivial and the case @xmath569 has been covered by theorems a.3 and a.4 from @xcite .
now suppose that ( [ bp - sc : eq ] ) have been established for @xmath570 .
set @xmath571 and for an arbitrary bnfd @xmath389 ending at @xmath572 @xmath573,~s\in s_p & f_{n , f'}(s ) & = \frac{1}{n}\sum_{i=1}^n \rho_{p'}(\pi_{f'}\circ x_i , s)^2,~s\in s_{p'}\\ { \mbox{\handw \symbol{96}}}_f & = \inf_{s\in s_p } f_f(s ) , & { \mbox{\handw \symbol{96}}}_{n , f ' } & = \inf_{s\in s_{p ' } } f_{n , f'}(s ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] then , @xmath574 for all @xmath61 , by hypothesis , and with @xmath575 , @xmath576 to complete the proof we first show in the appendix @xmath577 this is ziezold s version of strong consistency ( cf .
further , we show that this implies the bhattacharya - patrangenaru version ( cf .
@xcite ) of strong consistency which takes here the form ( [ bp - sc : eq ] ) .
careful inspection of the proof yields that we have only used that the `` distances '' @xmath500 vanish on the diagonal @xmath578 for all @xmath57 ; they need not be definite , i.e. it is not necessary that @xmath579 . moreover ,
note that the @xmath500-heine borel property holds trivially in case of unique sample descriptors .
[ cor : lambda - lem2 ] suppose that ( [ bp - sc : eq ] ) holds together with assumption [ as : clt - uniform - derivatives ] .
then we have for @xmath580 the following convergence in probability @xmath581\ , , & \frac{1}{n}\sum_{k=1}^n { \mbox{\rm hess\,}}_\eta\tau^l(\eta_n , x_k ) & \:\stackrel{{\mathbb p}}{\to}\ : { \mathbb e}\left [ { \mbox{\rm hess\,}}_\eta\tau^l(\eta',x)\right]\ , . \end{aligned}\ ] ] let @xmath310 .
then by assumption [ as : clt - uniform - derivatives ] , chebyshev s inequality and ( [ bp - sc : eq ] ) , there is a sequence @xmath582 such that @xmath583 and @xmath584\right\| \geq \epsilon \right\ } \\ & \leq { \mathbb p}\left\{\sup_{\|\eta-\eta'\|<\delta_n}\left\| \frac{1}{n}\sum_{k=1}^n{\mbox{\rm grad}}_\eta\tau^l(\eta , x_k ) - { \mathbb e}\big[{\mbox{\rm grad}}_\eta\tau^l(\eta',x)\big]\right\| \geq \epsilon \right\}\\ & \leq \frac{1}{\epsilon}\,{\mathbb e}\left[\sup_{\|\eta-\eta'\|<\delta_n}\left\| \frac{1}{n}\sum_{k=1}^n{\mbox{\rm grad}}_\eta\tau^l(\eta , x_k ) - { \mathbb e}\big[{\mbox{\rm grad}}_\eta\tau^l(\eta',x)\big]\right\| \right]~\to~0 \end{aligned}\ ] ] as @xmath585 .
yielding the first assertion .
the second assertion follows similarly .
we now introduce notation we use for the central limit theorem .
let @xmath586 . by construction
, every measurable selection @xmath587 of bn sample means minimizes @xmath588 under the constraints that it minimizes each of @xmath589 similarly , the bn population mean @xmath590 minimizes @xmath591\end{aligned}\ ] ] under the constraints that it minimizes each of @xmath592 , \quad\ldots\quad , { \mathbb e}\left [ \rho_{p^{j+1}}(\pi_{f^{j+1}}\circ x , p^{j})^2\right]\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in consequence , due to differentiability guaranteed by assumption [ as : clt - uniform - derivatives ] , with the notation of @xmath593 there , suitable random lagrange multipliers @xmath594 and deterministic lagrange multipliers @xmath595 exist such that for @xmath596 and @xmath597 the following hold @xmath598 & & + \sum_{l = j+1}^m \lambda^l \,{\mathbb e}\big[\tau^l(\eta , x)\big ] \label{eq : population - lagrange}\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ lem : lambda - lem1 ] suppose that ( [ bp - sc : eq ] ) holds together with assumption [ as : clt - uniform - derivatives ] . then the random lagrange multipliers @xmath599 in ( [ eq : sample - lagrange ] ) and @xmath600 in ( [ eq : population - lagrange ] ) satisfy @xmath601 by hypothesis , the vector @xmath602 is a linear combination of the vectors @xmath603 conveyed by @xmath599 .
similarly , @xmath604 $ ] is a linear combination of the vectors @xmath605 $ ] , @xmath606 conveyed by @xmath600 .
set @xmath607 , @xmath608 and @xmath609 , @xmath610 . by assumption
[ as : clt - uniform - derivatives ] we have @xmath611 .
we set @xmath612 . since the determinant is continuous , by corollary [ cor : lambda - lem2 ] ,
@xmath613 now consider the function @xmath614 where @xmath615 denotes the moore - penrose pseudoinverse of @xmath341 .
then @xmath616 and @xmath617 . in consequence , for arbitrary @xmath310 and @xmath585
we have that @xmath618 because , for any @xmath619 the first term is smaller than @xmath620 here , due to continuity established by @xcite , the first term vanishes for @xmath621 sufficiently small , and , due to corollary [ cor : lambda - lem2 ] , for any fixed @xmath619 , the second term tends to zero .
this yields the assertion .
[ clt : thm ] let @xmath622 and consider random data @xmath554 on a data space @xmath23 admitting bnfds from @xmath623 to @xmath624 , a unique bn population mean @xmath625 and bn sample means @xmath626 due to a measurable selection @xmath627 , @xmath628 , @xmath629 . * assuming that assumption [ as : clt - uniform - derivatives ] hold as well as ( [ bp - sc : eq ] ) for all @xmath630 , we have that @xmath631 with a chart @xmath99 as specified in assumption [ as : clt - uniform - derivatives ] as well as @xmath632 \mbox { and } \\ b_{\psi } & \:=\ : { \mbox{\rm cov}}\left [ { \mbox{\rm grad}}_{\eta}\tau^j(\eta',x ) + \sum_{l = j+1}^m \lambda^l\ , { \mbox{\rm grad}}_{\eta}\tau^l(\eta',x)\right ] \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] with the notation from assumption [ as : clt - uniform - derivatives ] where @xmath633 are suitable such that @xmath634 + \sum_{l = j+1}^m \lambda^l\,{\mbox{\rm grad}}_\eta \,{\mathbb e}\big[\tau^l(\eta , x)\big]\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] vanishes at @xmath635 .
* if additionally @xmath636 , then @xmath637 satisfies a gaussian @xmath551-clt @xmath638 * if additionally the chart @xmath99 factors as in definition [ def : factoring ] , then also @xmath639 satisfies a gaussian @xmath551-clt @xmath640 with the notation of definition [ def : factoring ] . by taylor expansion we have for @xmath641 defined in ( [ eq : sample - lagrange ] ) , @xmath642{\big)}}\nonumber\\ & = \sqrt{n}\,{\mbox{\rm grad}}_{\eta}g_n(\eta ' ) ~&&+~ { \mbox{\rm hess\,}}_{\eta}g_n(\eta ' ) \sqrt{n}\ , ( \eta_n - \eta ' ) \label{eq : clt - proof-1a}\\ & & & + ~ \big({\mbox{\rm hess\,}}_{\eta}g_n(\widetilde{\eta}_n ) - { \mbox{\rm hess\,}}_{\eta}g_n(\eta ' ) \big ) \sqrt{n}\ , ( \eta_n - \eta ' ) \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] with some random @xmath643 between @xmath644 and @xmath547 . in consequence of corollary [ lem : lambda - lem1 ]
we have with the usual clt for the first term in ( [ eq : clt - proof-1a ] ) that @xmath645 with a zero - mean gaussian vector @xmath646 of covariance @xmath647\ , .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] similarly , we have for the first factor in the second term in ( [ eq : clt - proof-1a ] ) , @xmath648\ , .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , for the first factor in the last the term in ( [ eq : clt - proof-1a ] ) , invoking also corollary [ cor : lambda - lem2 ] , we obtain that @xmath649 this yields assertion ( i ) . if @xmath650 is invertible , as asserted in ( ii )
, joint normality follows at once for @xmath651 .
( iii ) : in case of factoring charts we can rewrite @xmath652 where @xmath653 with @xmath654 and @xmath655 , and @xmath656 is defined by @xmath657 . with @xmath658 in assertion ( ii )
we obtain thus @xmath659 since under projection to the first coordinates @xmath660 , asymptotic normality is preserved , assertion ( iii ) follows at once .
suppose that we have two independent i.i.d .
samples @xmath661 , @xmath662 in a data space @xmath23 admitting bnfds and we want to test @xmath663 using descriptors in @xmath664 . here
, @xmath664 stands either for a single @xmath665 for which we have established factoring charts , or for a suitable sequence @xmath666 .
we assume that the first sample gives rise to @xmath667 , the second to @xmath668 , and that these are unique . under the corresponding assumptions of theorem [ clt : thm ] ,
define a statistic @xmath669 under @xmath670 , up to a suitable factor , this is hotelling @xmath671 distributed if @xmath672 is the corresponding empirical covariance matrix .
therefore , for @xmath672 we use the empirical covariance matrix from bootstrap samples . with this fixed @xmath171
, we simulate that statistic under @xmath670 by again bootstrapping @xmath52 times .
namely from @xmath673 we sample @xmath674 and compute the corresponding @xmath675 ( @xmath676 ) from @xmath677 ( @xmath678 , @xmath58 ) . from these , for a given level @xmath679 we compute the empirical quantile @xmath680 such that @xmath681 arguing as in ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 2.3 and remark 2.6 ) which extends at once to our setup , we assume that the corresponding population covariance matrix @xmath682 or @xmath683 , respectively , from theorem [ clt : thm ] is invertible .
we have then under @xmath670 that @xmath680 gives an asymptotic coverage of @xmath684 for @xmath685 , i. e. @xmath686 as @xmath687 if @xmath688 with a fixed @xmath689 .
to illustrate our clt for principle nested spheres ( pns ) and principle nested great spheres ( pngs ) , we simulate three data sets , each from two paired random variables @xmath464 and @xmath690 , displayed in figure [ simulated_data ] .
a. data on an @xmath691 concentrate on the same proper small @xmath692 and there on segments of orthogonal great circles such that their nested means are antipodal .
b. data on an @xmath691 concentrate on the same proper small @xmath692 and there on segments of orthogonal great circles such that their nested means coincide . c. data on an @xmath692 concentrate on segments of different small circles , have different nested means under pns , but , under pngs , coinciding principal geodesics and nested means . [ 0.3 ] concentrate on a common proper small @xmath692 , their projections to estimated small two - spheres is depicted .
the simulated dataset iii ( right ) is on @xmath692.__,title="fig:",scaledwidth=30.0% ] [ 0.3 ] concentrate on a common proper small @xmath692 , their projections to estimated small two - spheres is depicted .
the simulated dataset iii ( right ) is on @xmath692.__,title="fig:",scaledwidth=30.0% ] [ 0.3 ] concentrate on a common proper small @xmath692 , their projections to estimated small two - spheres is depicted .
the simulated dataset iii ( right ) is on @xmath692.__,title="fig:",scaledwidth=30.0% ] we apply pns and pngs to the simulated data and perform the two - sample test for identical respective nested submanifolds ( means , small and great circles ) and for identical small and great two - spheres .
the resulting p - values are displayed in table [ table ] .
these values are in agreement with the intuition guiding the design of the data . ' '' '' data set & method & @xmath693d & @xmath694d & @xmath695d + ' '' '' i & pns & @xmath696 & @xmath696 & @xmath697 + ' '' '' & pngs & @xmath696 & @xmath696 & @xmath696 + ' '' '' ii & pns & @xmath697 & @xmath696 & @xmath698 + ' '' '' & pngs & @xmath699 & @xmath696 & @xmath696 + ' '' '' iii & pns & @xmath696 & @xmath696 & + ' '' '' & pngs & @xmath700 & @xmath701 & + [ table ] understanding differentiation of adult human stem cells with the perspective of clinical use ( see e.g. @xcite who emphasize their potential for cartilage and bone reconstruction ) is an ongoing fundamental challenge in current medical research , still with many open questions ( e.g. @xcite ) . to investigate
mechanically guided differentiation , _ human mesenchymal stem cells _
( hmscs , pluripotent adult stem cells taken from the bone marrow ) are placed on gels of varying elasticity , quantified by the young s modulus , to mimic different environments in the human body , e.g. @xcite .
it is well known that within the first day the surrounding elasticity measured in kilopascal ( kpa ) induces differentiation through biomechanical cues , cf .
@xcite , where the changes manifest in orientation and ordering of the _ actin - myosin filament skeleton_. in particular , in order to direct future , more focused research , it is of high interest to more precisely identify time intervals in which such changes of ordering occur and to separate changes due to differentiation from changes due to other causes . [
0.48 ] [ 0.48 ] + [ 0.48 ] [ 0.48 ] * experimental setup .
* we compare hmsc skeletons that have been cultured at the third institute of physics of the university of gttingen on gels with young s moduli of 1 kpa mimicking neural tissue , 10 kpa mimicking muscle tissue , and 30 kpa mimicking bone tissue .
the cells have been fixed after multiples of 4 hours on the respective gel and have then been immuno - stained for nmm iia , the motor proteins making up small filaments that are responsible for cytoskeletal tension and imaged ( as described in @xcite )
table_samples ] shows their sample sizes and the data will be published and made available after completion of current research , cf .
because earlier research ( @xcite ) suggests that during the first 24 hours , 10 kpa and 30 kpa hmscs develop rather similarly and quite differently from 1 kpa hmscs , for this investigation , we pool the former . ' '' '' time & 1 kpa & 10 kpa and 30 kpa + ' '' '' 4h & 159 & 321 + ' '' '' 8h & 163 & 317 + ' '' '' 12h & 176 & 344 + ' '' '' 16h & 135 & 274 + ' '' '' 20h & 138 & 253 + ' '' '' 24h & 166 & 304 + [ table_samples ] the actin - myosin filament structure has been automatically retrieved from the fluorescence images using the filament sensor from @xcite .
since neighboring filaments share the same orientation , the 3d structure of the cellular skeleton can be retrieved by separating the filament structure into different orientation fields , cf .
figure [ fig : filament - sensor ] .
* orientation fields * for filament structures are determined via a relaxation labeling procedure , see @xcite .
the source code of our implementation is available as supplementary material .
a detailed description is deferred to a future publication .
the algorithm results in a set of contiguous areas with slowly varying local orientation , and , corresponding to each of these areas , a set of filaments which closely follow the local orientation .
also , these data will be published and made available after completion of current research , cf .
@xcite . * data analysis .
* for each single hmsc image , let @xmath426 be the number of pixels of all detected filaments , @xmath702 the number of all filament pixels of filaments of the largest orientation field and @xmath703 the number of all filament pixels of filaments of all smaller orientation fields .
@xmath704 is then the number of pixels in all `` rogue '' filaments which are not associated to any field , because they are too inconsistent with neighboring filaments .
define @xmath705 where the square roots ensure that @xmath519 does not describe relative areas but rather relative diameters of fields .
this representation is confined to the @xmath706 part in the first octant and every sample shows a distinct accumulation of points in the @xmath707 plane , corresponding to cells with only one orientation field . as common with biological data , especially from primary cells ,
their variance is rather high . in consequence ,
great circle fits are more robust under bootstrapping than small circle fits and we use the nested two - sample tests for pngs with the following null hypothesis .
@xmath670 : : : hmsc orientation and ordering measured by random loci on @xmath706 as above does not change between successive time points . ' '' '' time & & + ' '' '' gel & 1 kpa & 10 kpa and 30 kpa & 1 kpa & 10 kpa and 30 kpa + ' '' '' 4h vs. 8h & @xmath708 & @xmath696 & @xmath709 & @xmath696 + ' '' '' 8h vs. 12h & @xmath696 & @xmath696 & @xmath710 & @xmath696 + ' '' '' 12h vs. 16h & @xmath711 & @xmath696 & @xmath712 & @xmath696 + ' '' '' 16h vs. 20h & @xmath713 & @xmath714 & @xmath715 & @xmath716 + ' '' '' 20h vs. 24h & @xmath696 & @xmath696 & @xmath696 & @xmath717 + [ table_fields ] * results . * as visible in table [ table_fields ] ,
while for hmscs on harder gels ( 10 kpa and 30 kpa ) , nested means and the joint descriptor of nested mean and great circle change over each 4 hour interval until 16 hours for both the null hypothesis is rejected at the highest level possible similar changes are less clearly visible for hmscs on the soft gel ( 1 kpa ) between the intervals between 8 and 16 hours and not at all visible for the first time interval .
strikingly , for hmscs on all gels , no changes seem to occur between 16 and 20 hours .
in contrast , in the final interval between 20 and 24 hours , nested means and great circles clearly change for hmscs on the soft gel rejecting the null hypothesis at the highest level possible .
this effect is also there for the nested mean of hmscs on the harder gels , but not as clearly visible for the joint descriptor including the circle .
[ 0.4]_,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] [ 0.4]_,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] ._displaying p - values of two - sample tests for pngs of filament orientation field distribution data for all time points .
we use @xmath718 bootstrap samples , thus the penultimate p - value is @xmath719 . _ [ cols="<,^,^",options="header " , ] [ 24hrs_table ] visualization in figure [ fig_fields ] reveals further details . as seen from the loci of the nested means , hmscs on the soft gel ( figure [ fields_1kpa ] ) tend to loose minor orientation field filaments with a nearly constant ratio of large orientation field filaments and rogue filaments until the _ critical slot _ , the time interval between 16 and 20 hours . their great circles , indicating the direction of largest spread , change at the beginning of the critical slot , suggesting that the major variation there occurs in the amount of rogue filaments . while , until the critical slot , the temporal motion of nested means for 1 kpa is mainly vertical , the corresponding motion for the hmscs on harder gels ( cf .
figure [ fields_pooled ] ) is horizontal , indicating that the number of rogue filaments decreases in favor of the main orientation field .
curiously for the nested means , there is also a sharp drop in height at the beginning of the critical slot as well as a backward horizontal motion .
after the critical slot , hmscs seem to continue the direction of their previous journey , at a lower smaller fields level , though .
in contrast , for the hmscs on the soft gel , the critical slot seems to represent a true change point since afterward , the nested mean travels not much longer towards reducing the smaller fields , but like hmscs on harder gels , mainly reduces the number of rogue filaments .
indeed , taking into account the auxiliary mesh lines , it can be seen that descriptors are rather close at time 24 hours , cf .
24hrs_table ] , where , in contrast they are rather far away from each other for all other time points . * discussion . *
we conclude that hmscs react clearly distinctly and differently on both gels already for short time intervals , where at the critical time slot some kind of reboot happens . a generic candidate for this effect
is cell division .
as all cells used in the experiments were thawed at the same time ( 72 hours before seeding ) and treated identically , cell division is expected to occur at similar ( at least for each environment ) time points . dividing cells
completely reorganize their cell skeleton which would explain the change point found .
in particular , it seems that due to cell division , the time point 24 hours ( as used in @xcite ) may not be ideal if differences in hmscs differentiation due to different young s moduli are to be detected .
our results clearly warrant further analysis using higher time resolution , in particular time resolved in - vivo imaging , that among others , allow to register cell division times .
we thank rabi bhattacharya and vic patrangenaru for their valuable comments on the bootstrap and our collaborators florian rehfeldt and carina wollnik for their stem cell data .
the authors also gratefully acknowledge dfg hu 1575/4 , dfg crc 755 and the niedersachsen vorab of the volkswagen foundation .
with @xmath724 which , in conjunction with assumption [ projection - close : as ] and the induction hypothesis @xmath725 a.s . can be made arbitrary small a.s . due to assumption [ uniform - link : as ] . in consequence of the usual strong law
the first assertion follows .
the second follows with the same argument . by separability of @xmath53
it follows at once from lemma [ basic - ziezold : lem ] that there is a measurable set @xmath727 with @xmath728 and a dense subset @xmath729 such that @xmath730\end{array}\right\ } \quad \forall s \in \{s_k : k\in
\mathbb n\}\mbox { and } \omega\in \omega'\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order to obtain ( [ dense - as - conv1:eq ] ) for all @xmath61 , consider @xmath731 and the following estimates .
@xmath732 with @xmath733 now , w.l.o.g .
, consider @xmath734 ( which implies that @xmath735 ) for which ( [ dense - as - conv1:eq ] ) is valid
. using twice the first line in ( [ dense - as - conv2:ineq ] ) for @xmath736 and @xmath737 we obtain @xmath738 due to assumption [ uniform - link : as ] and the strong law ( [ dense - as - conv1:eq ] ) ( and the argument applied in the proof of lemma [ basic - ziezold : lem ] ) , for every @xmath739 there is @xmath740 such that for all @xmath741 we have @xmath742 + \epsilon\big)\epsilon & \leq\lim\inf_{n\to \infty } f_{n , f_n}({s}^{p_n})\\ & \leq \lim\sup_{n\to \infty } f_{n , f_n}({s}^{p_n})\\ & \leq f_f(s_k ) + 2\big(\mathbb e[\rho_p(\pi_f\circ x , s_k ) ] + \epsilon\big)\epsilon\end{aligned}\ ] ] for all @xmath743 .
taking into account the continuity of @xmath744 , letting @xmath745 yields @xmath746 similarly we see that @xmath747\quad \forall s \in s_p\mbox { and } \omega\in \omega'\quad\mbox { for } n\to \infty\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] next , we consider a sequence @xmath748 .
note that in consequence of assumption [ almost - triangle : as ] we have that @xmath749 using the bottom line of ( [ dense - as - conv2:ineq ] ) yields that @xmath750 with the same @xmath751 for all @xmath61 due to ( [ as - conv4:eq ] ) .
hence , in consequence of this and ( [ as - conv3:eq ] ) , for all @xmath748 we have that @xmath752 for all @xmath566 . finally let us show @xmath753 note that assertion ( [ ziezold - sc : eq ] ) is trivial in case of @xmath754 .
otherwise , for ease of notation let @xmath755 , @xmath756 , @xmath757 .
then @xmath758 for all @xmath759 .
hence , there is a sequence @xmath760 , @xmath761 .
moreover , there is a sequence @xmath762 such that @xmath763 for a suitable @xmath764
. then @xmath765 by ( [ as - conv5:eq ] ) a.s .. on the other hand , by lemma [ basic - ziezold : lem ] for arbitrary fixed @xmath61 , there is a sequence @xmath766 such that @xmath767 . first letting @xmath585 and then considering the infimum over @xmath61 yields @xmath768 in consequence @xmath769 in particular we have shown that @xmath770 which means that @xmath771 thus completing the proof of ( [ ziezold - sc : eq ] ) * proof of ( [ bp - sc : eq ] ) . * using the notation of the previous proof of ( [ ziezold - sc : eq ] ) , let @xmath772 and consider @xmath773 . if the assertion ( [ bp - sc : eq ] ) was false , there would be a measurable set @xmath774 with @xmath775 such that for every @xmath776 there is @xmath777 and @xmath778 . in consequence of the heine borel property we have thus @xmath785 for all @xmath786 .
since @xmath787 < \infty$ ] for all @xmath61 , there is a @xmath494 such that @xmath788 hence , in consequence of assumption [ coercivity : as ] we have thus a subset @xmath789 with @xmath790 such that for all @xmath791 , due to the usual strong law , @xmath792 this is a contradiction to ( [ lw - lim - sup : ineq ] ) .
this yields ( [ bp - sc : eq ] ) completing the proof of theorem [ sc : thm ] .
bianco , p. , x. cao , p. s. frenette , j. j. mao , p. g. robey , p. j. simmons , and c .- y .
wang ( 2013 ) .
the meaning , the sense and the significance : translating the science of mesenchymal stem cells into medicine . _
19_(1 ) , 3542 .
huckemann , s. , k .-
kim , a. munk , f. rehfeldt , m. sommerfeld , j. weickert , c. wollnik , et al .
the circular sizer , inferred persistence of shape parameters and application to early stem cell differentiation . _
22_(4 ) , 21132142 .
huckemann , s. f. and b. eltzner ( 2015 ) .
polysphere pca with applications . in _ proceedings of the 33th lasr workshop _
, pp . 5155 .
leeds university press .
http://www1.maths.leeds.ac.uk/statistics/workshop/lasr2015/proceedings15.pdf .
pittenger , m. , a. mackay , s. beck , r. jaiswal , r. douglas , j. mosca , m. moorman , d. simonetti , s. craig , and d. marshak ( 1999 ) .
multilineage potential of adult human mesenchymal stem cells . _
284_(5411 ) , 143 .
pizer , s. m. , s. jung , d. goswami , j. vicory , x. zhao , r. chaudhuri , j. n. damon , s. huckemann , and j. marron ( 2013 ) .
nested sphere statistics of skeletal models . in _
innovations for shape analysis _ , pp .
93115 . springer . | for sequences of random backward nested subspaces as occur , say , in dimension reduction for manifold or stratified space valued data , asymptotic results are derived .
in fact , we formulate our results more generally for backward nested families of descriptors ( bnfd ) . under rather general conditions , asymptotic strong consistency holds . under additional ,
still rather general hypotheses , among them existence of a.s .
local twice differentiable charts , asymptotic joint normality of a bnfd can be shown . if charts factor suitably , this leads to individual asymptotic normality for the last element , a principal nested mean or a principal nested geodesic , say .
it turns out that these results pertain to principal nested spheres ( pns ) and principal nested great subsphere ( pngs ) analysis by @xcite as well as to the intrinsic mean on a first geodesic principal component ( imo1gpc ) for manifolds and kendall s shape spaces .
a nested bootstrap two - sample test is derived and illustrated with simulations . in a study on real data , pngs is applied to track early human mesenchymal stem cell differentiation over a coarse time grid and , among others , to locate a change point with direct consequences for the design of further studies . _
keywords : _ frchet means , dimension reduction on manifolds , principal nested spheres , asymptotic consistency and normality , geodesic principal component analysis , kendall s shape spaces , flags of subspaces _ ams subject classifications : _ primary 62g20 , 62g25 .
secondary 62h11 , 58c06 , 60d05 . |
there is almost irrefutible evidence for an increase in the star formation density with redshift , as demonstrated by emission line and continuum star formations tracers in wavebands from the ultraviolet to the submillimeter and radio wavebands .
this evolution appears to be stronger for tracers which are less sensitive to dust obscuration ( e.g. ivison et al .
2006 ) , suggesting that an increasing proportion of the activity in more distant galaxies may be highly obscured ( e.g. blain et al . 1999 , 2002 ) .
indeed , recent results on the mid- to far - infrared emission of luminous but dust obscured galaxies at high redshift ( @xmath103 ) suggests that the origin of their large infrared luminosities is a mix of dust obscured vigorous star formation and/or dust enshrouded active galactic nucleus ( agn ) ( yan et al .
2005 ; houck et al . 2005 ; lutz et al . 2005 ; desai et al.2006 ) .
in many sources it is likely that both agn and star formation contribute to the emission as a result of the close link required between the growth of super - massive black holes and bulges in massive galaxies ( e.g. borys et al.2005 ) .
one of the best - studied populations of high - redshift , far - infrared luminous galaxies is that identified in the submillimeter waveband using the scuba camera ( holland et al .
1999 ) on the james clerk maxwell telescope ( jcmt ) .
although they span less than an order of magnitude in submillimeter flux , these galaxies are responsible for much of the energy density in the submillimeter background ( barger et al . 1998 ;
hughes et al . 1998 ; smail et al . 2002 ; cowie , barger & kneib 2002 ; scott et al .
the faintness of these obscured galaxies in the optical waveband has made it difficult to obtain precise redshifts ( e.g. simpson et al .
2004 ) , although some progress has been made using ultraviolet / blue spectrographs ( chapman et al . 2003a ; 2005 ) .
the median redshift for submillimeter galaxies with 850@xmath11 m fluxes of @xmath12mjy , ( hereafter smgs ) is @xmath13 ( chapman et al . 2003a , 2005 ) .
the submillimeter and radio fluxes of these systems indicate their bolometric luminosities are @xmath14l@xmath15 ( kovacs et al .
2006 ) , confirming that they are examples of high - redshift ultraluminous infrared galaxies ( ulirgs ) .
this population provides critical constraints on models of galaxy formation and evolution .
in particular , if the bolometric emission from smgs is powered solely by star formation , then these galaxies form about half of the stars seen in the local universe ( lilly et al.1999 ) .
however , it appears likely that both agn and star formation activity contribute to the immense far - infrared luminosities of these systems , although it has been difficult to disentangle the precise balance between these two energy sources .
recent sensitive x - ray analysis suggest that star formation is likely to be the dominant source of the bolometric luminosity in smgs ( alexander et al.2005a , b ) .
further evidence suggest it is plausible to identify smgs as the progenitor of massive elliptical galaxies at the present - day , based on their large gas , stellar and dynamical masses ( neri et al .
2003 ; greve et al . 2005
; tacconi et al . 2006 ; smail et al . 2004 ; borys et al . 2005 ; swinbank et al .
2004 , 2006 ) . furthermore
, combining the x - ray constraints on the agn within this population with the typical mass estimates suggests that smgs are the sites of coeval growth of stellar bulges and central black holes ( borys et al .
2005 ) .
rest - frame optical emission lines provide a powerful tool to investigate many fundamental properties of galaxies , such as star formation rates ( sfrs ) , power sources , internal extinction and metallicity .
swinbank et al .
( 2004 ) conducted a systematic near - infrared spectroscopic survey of thirty smgs to investigate their sfrs and metallicities and the kinematics of the emission line gas .
however , the wavelength coverage was limited to the region around h@xmath3 and so they did not include several emission lines at shorter wavelengths , such as h@xmath0 and [ oiii]@xmath1 , which are useful for evaluating internal extinction and metallicity or determining the power source .
we present in this paper the results from a near - infrared spectroscopic survey of redshifted [ oiii]@xmath1 , h@xmath0 and [ oii]@xmath2 lines for a sample of far - infrared luminous galaxies .
the sample is composed of smgs and optically faint radio galaxies ( ofrgs ) , at @xmath103.5 .
chapman et al . ( 2004 ) and blain et al . ( 2004 ) claim that high - redshift ofrgs are ulirgs , with similar bolometric luminosities to smgs but warmer characteristic dust temperature , resulting in them being undetectable in the submillimeter waveband .
we use h@xmath3/h@xmath0 emission line ratios to derive the dust extinction in these systems and then employ these estimates to derive extinction - corrected sfrs from the h@xmath3luminosities .
in addition , we also use x - ray observations of these objects to compare the strength of the [ oiii]@xmath7 emission to their x - ray emission , and so investigate the power of the agn in these galaxies .
we adopt cosmological parameters of h@xmath1672
km sec@xmath17 mpc@xmath17 , and @xmath18 and @xmath190.7 throughout .
our sample was selected from the catalogs of smgs and ofrgs in chapman et al .
( 2005 , 2004 ) .
we chose smgs / ofrgs in the redshift ranges @xmath202.56 and @xmath211.68 , where nebular emission lines such as [ oii ] , h@xmath0 , [ oiii ] and/or h@xmath3 are redshifted into clear parts of the @xmath22 , @xmath23 and @xmath24-bands respectively .
in total 22 targets were observed using the ohs spectrograph on subaru , isaac on the vlt or nirspec on keck .
the log of the observations is given in table 1 .
the majority of our spectroscopic observations were taken with the oh suppression spectrograph ( ohs ; iwamuro et al .
2001 ) with the cooled infrared spectrograph and camera for ohs ( cisco ; motohara et al .
2002 ) attached to the nasmyth focus of subaru telescope ( iye et al .
observations were obtained on the nights of 2004 april 6 , 7 , june 2425 , and 2005 feb 1416 .
sky conditions were photometric on all these nights with typical seeing 0.50.7@xmath25 at 1.6@xmath11 m .
we used a slit width of 0.95@xmath25 , which gives a resolution of @xmath26/@xmath27 ( @xmath28kmsec@xmath17 ) and used the `` sp4 '' dither pattern , which shifts the object along the slit to four positions in one sequence . after completing each observation , we observed bright a- or f - type stars with the same configuration as the science observation to calibrate the extinction and sensitivity variation with wavelength . during each night
we observed at least two photometric standard stars selected from the ukirt faint standards catalog ( hawarden et al .
we used fs27 and fs127 for the observations taken in 2004 april , fs23 and fs30 in 2004 june and fs133 and fs127 in 2005 february .
the data reduction was performed in the standard manner using custom scripts in iraf and some c programs provided by the ohs / cisco instrument teams .
first , we subtracted the sky background using the object frames at different dither positions .
next we fitted the sky line residuals using two dimensional polynomials and subtracted these from the data .
we then shift - and - added the images from the different dithering positions , using a median combine . as the instrument is stable ,
wavelength calibration was performed using the nominal conversion of pixel coordinates to wavelength . to confirm the stability of the wavelength solution , we analysed argon calibration lamp exposures taken during our runs and checked for systematic shifts in wavelength .
we found typical systematic shifts of 79 ( @xmath29% ) which is ignorable in our analysis due to the low resolution of our spectra .
extinction , sensitivity and photometric calibration were performed by dividing the calibrated spectra with those of the bright a- or f - type standard star observations after fitting the stellar spectra with models .
we conducted observations of four smgs and one ofrg using the isaac spectrograph on the 8-m vlt on 2004 november 2223 ( table 1 ) .
isaac was used in medium - resolution mode , which provides spectral resolution of 3000 ( @xmath30 kmsec@xmath17 ) .
seeing was steady at @xmath31 over the course of the observations and the observations were taken with a standard 10@xmath25 abba chop .
preliminary data reduction was performed using the eclipse pipeline , using flat - fields generated from night - calibrations taken after each observation , and wavelength calibration from a solution using the oh sky lines .
the remaining flux - calibration was achieved in iraf , using corresponding hipparcos standard stars observed throughout the observing run and near - infrared fluxes derived from the 2mass catalog .
the observations of smmj09431 + 4700 ( h6/h7 ) and smmj131201.17 + 424208.1 were taken on 2004 april 8 in photometric conditions and 0.8@xmath25 seeing using the nirspec spectrograph on keck .
these observations employed the standard abba configuration to achieve sky subtraction .
each exposure was 600s in length and the total integration time was 2400s .
the data were reduced using the wmkonspec package in iraf .
we remapped the two dimensional spectra using linear interpolation to rectify the spatial and spectral dimensions . after subtracting pairs of nod - positions ( the nod was 20@xmath25 along the slit ) ,
residual sky features were removed in idl using sky regions on either side of the object spectrum . for the wavelength calibration we used an argon arc lamp .
the output pixel scale is 4.3 pix@xmath17 , and the instrumental profile has a fwhm of 15 ( measured from the widths of the sky - lines ) , which corresponds to @xmath32 kmsec@xmath17 .
we used fs27 for photometric calibration .
we show all of our spectra in figure 1 .
we identified emission lines in 20 spectra out of 22 targets which were observed .
most of the smgs show weak h@xmath0 emission , but many show strong ( and sometimes broad and distorted ) profiles in [ oiii]@xmath1 .
some of our spectra show additional emission lines of [ neiii ] , [ nev]and [ oi]@xmath33 , which are common in agn .
five of the smgs from our sample ( smmj09431 + 4700 ( h6 ) , smmj123549.44 + 621536.8 , smmj123716.01 + 620323.3 , smmj163639.01 + 405635.9 , and smmj163650.43 + 405734.5 ) display spatially extended structures ( @xmath341.0 ) in either [ oiii]@xmath7 and/or h@xmath3 emission line ( figure 2 , see smail et al .
2003 ; swinbank et al .
2005 for evidence of the spatial extension in smmj163650.43 + 405734.5 ) .
several of our observations are particularly noteworthy and we discuss them here .
this galaxy is identified as a submillimeter source associated with a spiral galaxy at @xmath36 , which shows features typical of a seyfert 1 ( smail et al .
1997 , 2002 ; soucail et al .
the strong and featureless continuum , together with the spatially compact emission line flux indicates agn activity ; an interpretation which is further supported by the detection of this source in hard x - rays by bautz et al . ( 2000 ) .
our spectrum shows at least two peaks in the h@xmath3 emission line with fwhm@xmath37400kmsec@xmath17 , consistent with these lines arising from independent components within the system .
if we force fit a single gaussian profile to the h@xmath3 emission , we determine fwhm@xmath38kmsec@xmath17 , which if it arises from an agn is narrower than typical seyfert 1 galaxies , although broader than seyfert 2 galaxies ( @xmath39kmsec@xmath17 ) .
this source is also detected by co observation by greve et al .
( 2005 ) with a double peaked profile with a fwhm of @xmath40kmsec@xmath17and a separation between the two peaks of @xmath41kmsec@xmath17 , consistent within the errors with our measurements from h@xmath3 .
we therefore choose to interpret the double - peaked h@xmath3 line as evidence for a merger or interaction in this system , with any agn - produced broad component undetected in our spectrum .
this source was discovered by cowie , barger & kneib ( 2002 ) , and has been identified with two distinct @xmath11jy radio counterparts : h6 and h7 ( ledlow et al .
these are lensed sources , lying behind a massive cluster abell851 at @xmath42 although the amplification is modest : @xmath43 .
the redshift for h6 was measured by ledlow et al .
( 2002 ) as @xmath44 from ly@xmath3 , h7 was not observed .
the restframe ultraviolet properties of h6 suggest it hosts an agn with spectral features similar to a narrow - line seyfert 1 ( ledlow et al .
we placed the nirspec slit across both radio components and detected [ oiii]@xmath7emission from both sources at redshifts of @xmath45 and @xmath46 for h6 and h7 , respectively .
we also detected narrow ( fwhm@xmath47 kmsec@xmath17 ) h@xmath0 emission from h6 .
the [ oiii]@xmath7 emission from h6 is spatially extended(@xmath48 or 14.5kpc ; figure 2 ) , but has no significant velocity gradient across @xmath49kpc in projection .
no hard x - ray emission was detected with the upper limits on f@xmath50 as @xmath5110@xmath52 erg sec@xmath17 @xmath53 ( ledlow et al .
co line emission is also detected by neri et al .
( 2003 ) and tacconi et al .
( 2006 ) based on our restframe optical redshift , originating from h7 at @xmath54 .
millimeter continuum emission has been seen from h6 , but assuming the gas reservoir is at the redshift we find from [ oiii]@xmath7 , the gas mass of the agn - dominated component , h6 , is a factor of a few lower than that of h7 .
this source has apparent double - peaked , narrow ( @xmath55kmsec@xmath17 ) emission lines in [ oii]@xmath2 and [ oiii]@xmath1 , with the two components spatially offset by @xmath56 .
the one dimensional spectra also shows signs of broad h@xmath0emission at @xmath57 with a fwhm of @xmath58 kmsec@xmath17 .
both the [ oiii]@xmath7 and the [ oii]@xmath2 emissions are spatially extended with faint wings on scales of approximately 1@xmath25 ( @xmath49kpc ) , see figure 2 .
there may also be a very weak , broad multiplet of feii@xmath59 ( figure 1 ) , potentially indicating the presence of the narrow line seyfert 1 ( nls1 ) type agn component ( osterbrock & pogge 1985 ; goodrich 1989 ) .
this is consistent with the results of alexander et al .
( 2005b ) , which indicated the presence of a heavily obscured agn with n@xmath60@xmath53 based on their x - ray spectral analysis .
the spatial extension in the bright core of the [ oiii]@xmath7 likely indicates merging components or rotation along the slit , while the extended wings may reflect `` superwind '' activity .
this source is very bright in the optical ( @xmath61 ) with a redshift of @xmath62 and it was classified as a qso by chapman et al .
( 2005 ) based on the broad rest uv emission lines and comparable luminosities in rest optical and far - infrared wavelength , which exceed 10@xmath63 erg sec@xmath17 .
the source has also been detected in hard x - rays by alexander et al .
( 2005b ) .
our spectrum shows several hydrogen balmer lines such as h@xmath0 , h@xmath64 and h@xmath65 with broad fwhm@xmath66 ( @xmath672700kmsec@xmath17 ) and the [ oiii]@xmath1 doublet with fwhm@xmath66 of @xmath67kmsec@xmath17 .
we also detected the [ neiii ] and several feii lines at 34@xmath68 significance .
the restframe optical spectrum is dominated by continuum emission without stellar absorption features , suggesting a large contribution from the agn component to the total rest - frame optical flux .
the [ oiii]@xmath7 emission lines are wide fwhm@xmath69kmsec@xmath17 and spatially extended ( @xmath70 ;
12kpc ) indicating dynamically active gas motion ( figure 2 ) .
the estimated hydrogen column density from the x - ray spectral analysis is relatively low ( n@xmath71@xmath53 ) , which implies the agn does not suffer from large extinction .
it should be noted that the redshift based on the restframe - uv emission lines is @xmath72 , which is blueshifted by @xmath73kmsec@xmath17 from the redshift indicated by the restframe optical nebular emission line .
this velocity offset may arise due to broad ly@xmath3 emission which may be affected by dust extinction and resonance scattering .
this source is another example of a nls1 type agn .
it lies at @xmath74 and our spectrum displays broad h@xmath0 emission , with fwhm@xmath75kmsec@xmath17 and a low [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0 ratio ( @xmath76 ) .
this source has ly@xmath3 [ civ ] and heii emission lines in the rest uv spectrum and was classified as a qso by chapman et al .
the rest - frame optical emission is dominated by very strong continuum emission without stellar absorption lines , supporting the presence of a luminous agn component .
unfortunately , there is no coverage of h@xmath3 emission for this object and so we could not constrain the internal extinction . the [ nev ] line ( which is a very clean indicator of agn activity ;
osterbrock 1989 ) is detected .
furthermore , this source was detected by the x - ray imaging by mushotzky et al .
( 2000 ) , confirming the presence of a luminous agn in the source .
this source is a good example of a heavily extincted starburst in an smg and was recently discussed by swinbank et al .
this @xmath77 galaxy has weak h@xmath0 emission line with h@xmath3/h@xmath0@xmath78 .
the h@xmath3 and [ oiii]@xmath7 emission lines are spatially extended ( @xmath79 or 10 kpc)(figure 2 ) . there is only an upper limit on its x - ray emission , f@xmath80ergsec@xmath17@xmath53 from manners et al.(2003 ) , which does not strongly constrain the presence of a luminous agn given the possibility of substantial absorption ( e.g. alexander et al .
the possible detection of [ oi]@xmath33 emission line may hint at the presence of an agn , although the line ratios of [ oi]@xmath33/h@xmath3@xmath81 and [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0@xmath82 can be explained by a relatively highly ionized starburst nebulae ( osterbrock et al .
1989 ) .
this heavily obscured agn at @xmath83 ) was found in the mambo survey of greve et al .
( 2004 ) ( and is also called n21200.18 ) and was detected in x - ray imaging with _
chandra _ ( manners et al .
it has broad , fwhm@xmath842500kmsec@xmath17 , emission lines of ly@xmath3 , [ civ ] and h@xmath3 in the rest - frame uv and optical wavelengths , with a high [ oi]@xmath33/h@xmath3 ratio ( @xmath85 ) ( willott et al .
2003 ; swinbank et al .
2006 ) which is typical of agn ( osterbrock 1989 ) .
our data also show asymmetric h@xmath0 and [ oiii]@xmath86 emission line profiles , which exhibit `` blue wings '' in their profiles .
such profiles have been interpreted as evidence for wind activity from the agn , although contribution from other components is possible ( swinbank et al .
2006 ) .
our isaac spectrum shows strong , narrow h@xmath3 h@xmath0 [ oiii]@xmath1 and [ nii ] emission lines at a redshift of @xmath87 ( fwhm@xmath88 of h@xmath0 is @xmath89kmsec@xmath17 ) . to investigate the restframe optical properties
, we retrieved an archival @xmath90-band image taken with subaru telescope s prime focus camera ( suprime - cam ) using smoka .
the image shows an elongated structure , @xmath91 , towards the north - west and the spectrum was taken with the slit aligned along the major axis of this source .
we identify two separate h@xmath3 emission lines with a velocity offset of @xmath92kmsec@xmath17and a spatial offset @xmath93@xmath94 ( @xmath95kpc ) .
these suggest the system is a merger .
the h@xmath3 and h@xmath0 emission lines do not show asymmetric profiles or detectable broad line components .
since many of our individual spectra have modest signal - to - noise , we have also constructed several composite spectra to investigate the general properties of subsets of the smg population .
we create the composite spectra by deredshifting each spectrum based on redshifts measured from the [ oiii]@xmath7 lines , subtracting continuum emission using a first order spline fit and averaging all of the spectra with 3-@xmath68 clipping after normalizing by [ oiii]@xmath7flux .
we smoothed the higher resolution spectra taken at keck and vlt to match the low resolution subaru spectra before stacking . either stacking the spectra with weights based on their individual signal - to - noise ratio or an unweighted stack
does not alter any of the conclusions below .
we derive a composite spectrum for those sources which show qso signatures ( `` qso '' ; i.e. , classified as qso ) and for those galaxies that individually show signs of an agn in their optical spectra ( `` opt - agn '' ; i.e. , those classified as agn in the column of `` class '' under `` opt '' category in table 2 ) .
the former is made from only three individual spectra , while the latter comes from nine spectra .
the resulting composite spectra are shown in figure 3 .
we do not make a composite of starburst ( `` sb '' ) sources since there are only two sources in our sample classified as `` sb '' or intermediate ( `` int '' ) from their restframe optical spectra .
the details of the classification will be discussed in 4.1 .
the emission lines of h@xmath0 and [ oiii]@xmath1 lines are clearly seen in both the composite spectra .
in addition in the `` qso '' spectrum , many strong lines are visible , including [ neiii]@xmath96 and several feii lines at @xmath97 , 5167 and 52005360 , although the [ oii]@xmath2 line is only marginally detected . by fitting a gaussian to the h@xmath0 and [ oiii]@xmath1 emission lines
, we measure the fwhm@xmath88 of h@xmath0as @xmath98kmsec@xmath17 after correction for the instrumental resolution .
this is @xmath99kmsec@xmath17 lower than the average fwhm of qsos at @xmath1002.1 ( jarvis & mclure 2006 ) .
the [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0 ratio is @xmath101 .
all these spectral features are typical of type 1 agns studied locally .
on the other hand in the composite `` opt - agn '' spectrum , a gaussian profile fit to the h@xmath0 emission line yields fwhm@xmath88 of @xmath102kmsec@xmath17 ( it should be noted that the h@xmath0 line fit is not improved by including a narrow line component due to the low spectral resolution of our spectra ) and [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0ratio of @xmath103 , in addition the [ oii]@xmath2 line is well - detected . the h@xmath0 line , which is broader than typical type 2 agns , and relatively low [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0 line ratio , is similar to that of local nls1 (
although by definition these should have [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0/@xmath1043.0 ) .
the feii emission lines , which are one of the characteristic features seen in local nls1 s , are marginally detected with @xmath105 features seen around 5200 in the spectrum , and we can see some marginal detections in individual spectra ( smmj123549.44 + 621536.8 , smmj123635.59 + 621424.1 , smmj163650.43 + 405734.5 , and smmj163706.51 + 405313.8 ) , all of which have broad h@xmath0 emission of fwhm@xmath106kmsec@xmath17(figure 1 ) .
the resultant spectrum is consistent with a scenario where the restframe optical spectra classified as `` agn '' in the uv in reality comprise two types : one has relatively broad , @xmath107kmsec@xmath17 , fwhm for the h@xmath0 lines and the other has narrow h@xmath0 lines with a relatively high [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0 ratio , typical of type 2 agns .
there are clearly differences in the extinction of the circumnuclear region of these two types of objects implied by the difference in luminosity and spectroscopic properties of the restframe - uv emission , although there is no systematic difference in the h@xmath3/h@xmath0 ratio we measure for them .
in figure 4 , we plot the observed [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0 versus [ nii]/h@xmath3emission line ratios of the 13 galaxies in our sample for which we have secure h@xmath3 detections and some information about [ nii]/h@xmath3 . this diagnostic plot , termed the bpt diagram , can be used to identify the source of gas excitation ( baldwin et al .
1981 ) . based on this diagram
we classify the spectra into three types , starburst ( sb ) , intermediate ( int ) or non - thermal ( agn ) , as listed in table 2 .
we use the definitions from kauffman et al .
( 2003 ) which are derived for a large sample of local sdss galaxies .
we classify the sources between the boundary of kauffman et al . and the classical definition of veilluex & osterbrock ( 1987 ) as `` int '' .
we also classify galaxies as agn which have h@xmath3 and/or h@xmath0 fwhm@xmath88
greater than 1500kmsec@xmath17 , as it is difficult to understand the formation of such large line widths from gas motions in star - forming regions .
this limit is also greater than the coarse spectral resolution of ohs ( @xmath108kmsec@xmath17 ) .
for comparison we also plot the emission line flux ratios from local ulirgs ( veilleux , kim & sanders 1999 ) and note that the smgs in our sample occupy the same region of the diagnostic diagram as local ulirgs .
the curves show various criteria for separating agns and the star - forming galaxies ( see figure 4 ) .
it is clear that the majority , 8/13 , of sources in our sample ( including all but one , smmj163639.01 + 405635.9 , with all four emission lines detected ) are classified as agn based on these criteria .
we reiterate that this subsample may be biased towards strong line emitters ( due to the requirement to have detected lines in our low - resolution spectra ) and so this is perhaps not a surprising result .
moreover , we must interpret the bpt diagram with caution since `` superwind '' ejecta ( shock - driven line emitting gas ) can occupy a very similar region to agn ( dopita & sutherland 1995 ) . to illustrate this possibility in more detail , we plot the emission line ratio of the wind structure in m82 from a @xmath109kpc region ( shopbell & bland - hawthorn 1998 ) and in a @xmath110kpc@xmath111 area of ngc6240 ( schmitt et al . 1996 ) .
the former is indicative of a wind which is dominated by photoionization , and the latter illustrates the line ratios expected from shocks in a very dense environment .
some smgs show very similar emission line ratios to ngc6240 , although most of them have lower [ nii]/h@xmath3 and higher [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0 ratios .
further support for the wind scenario is that p - cygni features are seen in the rest - uv emission lines ( chapman et al . 2003a , 2005 ) of a significant fraction of the smg population , supporting the presence of `` winds '' arising from the vigorous starburst activity .
indeed , the majority ( 6/8 ) of this subsample ( with four detected emission lines ) are classified as `` sb '' or `` int '' from their rest uv spectroscopic features ( chapman et al . 2005 ; table 2 ) .
the power sources in smgs is discussed further in 4.2 .
looking at the individual sources in figure 4 , we note that smmj123622.65 + 621629.7 has a very low [ nii]/h@xmath3(@xmath112 ) emission line ratio and no detection of [ oiii]@xmath1 and h@xmath0(see also figure 5 in smail et al .
2004 ) with h@xmath3/h@[email protected] and [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath3@xmath114 .
this sources is an interacting system of a relatively blue(@xmath115 ) galaxy with extremely red ( @xmath116 ) companion , where the latter is a hard x - ray source .
whilst the slit was aligned along the major axis of the red x - ray source , it is possible that it also passed through the blue component and the line emission may be contaminated . to avoid biasing our sample ,
we have therefore eliminated this source from our subsequent analysis and discussion .
smgs are dusty systems with large dust masses , @xmath117m@xmath15 , and high bolometric luminosities ( @xmath118 ) .
the presence of large quantities of dust and its associated reddening may also explain the large discrepancies between the sfrs derived for smgs from their far - infrared and h@xmath3luminosities ( swinbank et al .
2004 ) , which imply extinction in h@xmath3 of factors @xmath119100 .
there are of course alternative explanations : that the bulk of the far - infrared emission originates from other sources which are too dusty to see even at restframe optical wavelengths , such as very highly obscured agn , or due to emission which falls outside of the slits used in the h@xmath3 measurements .
although , the latter explanation is unlikely as these observations are based on radio - identified sources with precise positions ( @xmath120 ; chapman et al .
2005 ) , and so it is unlikely that a major source of bolometric emission has been missed by the observations . to investigate the internal reddening of smgs ( at least for those regions which are visible in the restframe optical ) we plot the h@xmath3/h@xmath0 ratios as a function of their far - infrared luminosities in figure 5
to calculate @xmath121 , we use the reddening curve from calzetti et al .
( 2000 ) , and assume an intrinsic h@xmath3/h@xmath0 ratio of 3.0 , which is between the values for typical seyfert 2 galaxies and/or liners ( 3.1 , halpern & steiner 1983 ; gaskel & ferland 1984 ) and star - forming galaxies , 2.85 ( veilleux & osterbrock 1987 ) . the observed h@xmath3/h@xmath0 ratio for the smgs is typically 520 and the derived extinction spans @xmath1224 with a median value of @xmath123 ( where the error comes from bootstrap resampling ) .
this estimate is consistent with the results based on the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) fitting of optical to near - infrared photometric data ( smail et al .
2004 ) , and slightly higher than that derived from optical to mid - infrared seds ( @xmath124 , borys et al.2005 ) where the latter did not include any contribution from thermally pulsed - agb stars in the model seds , which might lead to an underestimation of the reddening ( maraston 206 ) . in figure 6
we compare the extinction corrected sfrs derived from the h@xmath3 and far - infrared luminosities .
the far - infrared luminosities come from chapman et al .
( 2003b ; 2004 ) based on sed model fitting to the observed 850@xmath11 m and 1.4-ghz fluxes at their known redshifts , assuming the local far - infrared - radio correlation holds ( condon et al . 1991 ; garrett 2002 ) .
we also include observations for local _ iras _ galaxies ( kewley et al .
2002 ) and _ iso _ galaxies ( flores et al .
the typical @xmath121 in these samples are @xmath125 and @xmath126 , respectively .
the extinction corrected h@xmath3 luminosities for the _ iras _ and the _ iso _ galaxies are all calibrated in the same manner as for our smg samples based on their h@xmath3/h@xmath0 ratio .
the sfrs from the h@xmath3 and from the far - infrared luminosities are derived using the equations given in kennicutt ( 1998 ) .
the correlation between the far - infrared and reddening - corrected h@xmath3 luminosities ( figure 6 ) appears to be relatively good with a linear relation extending over five orders of magnitude in sfr , although with some scatter , with the most luminous smgs in our sample having sfrs approximately an order of magnitude higher than those of the brightest _ iso _ galaxies . the good agreement between the two sfrs when using the reddening - corrected h@xmath3-estimate confirms that the discrepancies between the sfrs seen in swinbank et al .
( 2004 ) are in large part due to dust extinction and moreover that the bulk of the far - infrared luminosity in these galaxies is probably derived from star formation .
we note that it is likely that slit - losses and placement contribute to the scatter in these measurements as we are combining observations of h@xmath0 and h@xmath3 from different telescopes and instruments .
for example , our brightest far - infrared source , smmj163650.43 + 405734.5 ( n2850.4 ) , has a lower sfr measured from h@xmath3 than from the far - infrared .
however , this galaxy is spatially extended and has a very complex structure in the restframe optical ( smail et al . 2003 ; swinbank et al .
it is therefore likely that our slit covered only a part of the h@xmath3 emitting region .
finally , any remaining systematic offset between the two sfr estimates may be caused by the fact that our a@xmath127 estimates only reflect the reddening to the optically detectable gas and thus are not necessarily a good indicator of the total column towards the bolometric sources in these objects .
smgs are proposed to be the progenitors of present - day massive spheroidal galaxies , because of their high star - formation rates and their large stellar , gas and dynamical masses ( smail et al .
2004 ; neri et al .
2003 ; greve et al . 2005 ; borys et al . 2005
; tacconi et al . 2006 ; swinbank et al .
most massive galaxies in the local universe contain super - massive black holes ( smbhs ) ( e.g. , ferrarese & merritt 2000 ; gebhardt et al .
2000 ; marconi & hunt 2003 ; heckman et al.2004 ) .
equally an agn appears to be almost universally present in smgs : based on the extremely sensitive x - ray observations of the _ chandra _ deep field north ( cdfn ) , alexander et al .
( 2003 ; 2005a , b ) found more than @xmath128% of smgs to be detected in hard x - rays , indicating they contain an accreting smbh .
it is therefore interesting to estimate the mass of , and accretion rates onto , the central black holes of smgs to constrain the coevolution of the smbhs and the stellar masses of their surrounding bulge ( kawakatu et al .
2003 ; granato et al .
2004 ) .
the three sources classified as `` qso '' in our sample have characteristics typical of local nls1 : low [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0 ratios ( @xmath1291.8 ) , and detectable feii emission in their individual and also composite spectra ( figures 1 & 3 ) .
nls1 are commonly interpreted as hosting rapidly growing smbhs ( collin & kawaguti 2004 ) , and hence the spectral similarities of these smg - qsos with local nls1s could imply comparable physical conditions in the accretion disk around the smbh in the smgs .
however , the smgs have fwhm@xmath1302500kmsec@xmath17for their balmer emission lines , and so they are not formally nls1s because these lines width are higher than the definition used for nls1 ( fwhm@xmath88 of h@xmath0 of @xmath131kmsec@xmath17 ) .
nevertheless , it is however worth noting that their h@xmath0 fwhm@xmath88 are close to the minimum for qsos at @xmath1322.1 ( jarvis & mclure 2006 ) , and narrower than the average of radio quiet / loud qsos(@xmath1336500kmsec@xmath17 ) .
although , we caution that with the limited signal to noise in our spectra we may underestimate the line widths , missing weak and broader line components . for instance , in the composite spectrum of smg - qsos we estimate the fwhm@xmath88 of the h@xmath0 line as @xmath134kmsec@xmath17 using a single gaussian fit .
this is 5001000kmsec@xmath17 broader than the mean of the individual spectra , suggesting there may be an undetected broad component present in them .
more secure estimates of the line widths would either need observations of stronger emission lines such as h@xmath3 which are not available for these sources , or much deeper observations .
the fwhm@xmath88 of the balmer emission lines in those smgs with agn - like features ( but omitting the three sources classified as `` qso '' ) , are 10003000 kmsec@xmath17 .
they are at least 10002000 kmsec@xmath17 lower than the average fwhm of qsos at @xmath1322.1 measured from h@xmath0 and/or mgii lines ( jarvis & mclure 2006 ) suggesting that the smgs host lower mass smbhs .
this would support the claims of alexander et al,(2005a , b ; see also borys et al .
2005 ) based on eddington - limited assumptions .
the similarities of the rest - frame optical spectral features of some smgs to nls1s implies rapid growth of the smbh in smg s nuclei .
a total of 5/9 of the smgs classified as `` agn '' in our sample have relatively narrow fwhm@xmath66 ( up to @xmath1353700kmsec@xmath17 ) for their h@xmath3 or h@xmath0 emission lines , and 3/5 show marginal feii emission .
therefore , the eddington - limited accretion determined for local nls1 galaxies may also be appropriate for smgs . assuming this , the measured line - widths are then consistent with the estimate of the central bh masses derived from their x - ray luminosities under the assumption of eddington - limited accretion ( @xmath136 , alexander et al .
2005a ) . however , this conclusion appears to be undermined by the fact that three of these nls1-like smgs display high ( @xmath137 ) [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0 ratios which far exceed the nls1 definition of [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0 @xmath138 , and thus these comparisons may not be appropriate . to further test the claim that smgs have small smbh masses we compare the [ oiii]@xmath7 and hard x - ray luminosities .
there is a well - studied correlation between the hard x - ray and the optical [ oiii]@xmath7 emission line luminosities in local agn ( e.g. mulchaey et al .
this correlation can be used to gauge the black hole masses and the accretion rates of agns within our sample . in figure 7
, we show the hard x - ray versus [ oiii]@xmath7 luminosities of the smgs ( uncorrected for any extinction / absorption ) .
all 22 smgs in our sample have hard x - ray coverage , but of varying depth : cdfn : alexander et al .
( 2003 ) , cfrs03hr : waskett et al .
( 2004 ) , ssa13 : mushotzky et al .
( 2000 ) , ssa22 : basu - zych & scharf ( 2005 ) , and elais n2 : manners et al .
we adopt the hard x - ray fluxes from these observations , although 9/22 of them yield only the upper limits . for comparison
, we also plot observations of local ulirgs ( ptak et al .
2003 ; franceschini et al .
2003 ) , as well as seyfert 1 and seyfert 2 galaxies and the pg qsos , representative of more luminous type 1 agns ( alonso - herrero et al . 1997 ; mulchaey et al .
all of these comparison samples are the _ observed _ luminosities : there are no extinction corrections applied to either the x - ray or [ oiii]@xmath7 measurements .
figure 7 also shows the relation for seyfert 2 galaxies suggested by mulchaey et al .
compared to the qsos and seyfert 1 galaxies , which are selected to represent unabsorbed hard x - ray sources , the majority of our smgs are typically an order of magnitude brighter in [ oiii]@xmath7 for a given hard x - ray luminosity .
we note that a similar excess of [ oiii]@xmath7 emission is also seen in local ulirgs .
could this apparent excess be due to absorption / extinction ?
the typical hydrogen column densities to the agn in smgs have been determined by alexander et al .
( 2005b ) , yielding n@xmath139@xmath53 , with corrections to their hard x - ray luminosities of 2.520@xmath9 . equally ,
the typical [ oiii]@xmath7 luminosity correction , adopting the extinction estimated from the balmer decrement , @xmath140 , is also approximately a factor ten : @xmath141{\lambda5007}}_{corrected } } = { \rm f}_{{[oiii]{\lambda5007}}_{obs}}\cdot((h\alpha / h\beta)/(h\alpha_{0}/h\beta_{0}))^{2.94},$ ] where h@xmath142/h@xmath143 is assumed to be 3.0 ( see bassani et al . 1999 ) .
unfortunately we have only one source ( smmj123549.44 + 621536.8 ) with reliable estimates of the hi column density and reddening correction which has @xmath144 and @xmath145 corrections to the hard x - ray and [ oiii]@xmath7 luminosities respectively and with yields corrected luminosities of @xmath146 ergsec@xmath17 and @xmath147 ergsec@xmath17 respectively ( figure 7 ) . as the extinction corrections for [ oiii]@xmath7 and hard x - ray luminosities run parallel to the trend in figure 7 ,
the [ oiii]@xmath7 excess can not be explained by a simple reddening effect .
we also caution that the reddening corrections applied to the [ oiii]@xmath7 fluxes are uncertain since [ oiii]@xmath7 may arise in external shocks which suffer much less extinction than the h@xmath3/h@xmath0 ratio suggests .
we also note that the apparent [ oiii]@xmath7 excess could arise simply due to the relatively shallow x - ray coverage in several of our fields where the sources only have upper - limits on their hard x - ray fluxes .
however the fact that 3/4 sources with [ oiii]@xmath7 and hard x - ray detections from the cdfn , which has by - far the best x - ray data , show the excess provides good evidence for the reality of this feature .
while some of the [ oiii]@xmath7 flux we see arises from the obscured agn , we suggest that the excess [ oiii]@xmath7 flux arises , at least in part , from shock - induced ( `` superwind '' ) activity .
there are some cases of plausible `` superwind '' driven [ oiii]@xmath7 excesses seen in our smg sample as seen by the structured [ oiii]@xmath7 line profiles ( asymmetric / broad / multi - peaked ) and the spatially extended emission ( figures 1 & 2 ; see also smail et al .
2003 ) . in order to examine the possibility that shock - induced gas causes the excess [ oiii]@xmath7 emission , we first search for the signature of shock - excited nebular emission using the simple criterion of [ nii]@xmath148/h@xmath3@xmath149 and [ sii]@xmath150/h@xmath3@xmath151 . using the line ratios from the stacked spectrum of smgs in swinbank et al .
( 2004 ) we find that they lie outside of this shock induced criterion .
however , this criterion is only valid for the shocks with large outflow velocities and a relatively weak starburst radiation field ( veilleux et al .
2005 ) and therefore may not be applicable to the smgs . another test is to use the line ratios of [ oiii]@xmath1/[oiii]@xmath152 and/or [ nii]@xmath153/[nii]@xmath154 , which can be used to estimate the temperature of the nebular gas .
these ratios will provide robust estimates of electron temperature of the emission nebulae , yielding high ( @xmath155k ) temperatures if the gas is ionized mainly by shocks ( as in the cygnus loop ) and lower temperature ( @xmath156k ) for photoionization - dominated clouds seen in star - forming regions ( osterbrock 1989 ) . as these methods rely on measurements of relatively weak emission lines [ oiii]@xmath152 and [ nii]@xmath154 , only our composite spectra have sufficient signal to noise to be useful . from the composite spectrum in figure 3 and also from the total smg composite spectrum in swinbank et al .
( 2004 ) , we derive an upper limit on [ oiii]@xmath1/[oiii]@xmath152@xmath157 , and [ nii]@xmath153/[nii]@xmath158 . both ratios imply an upper limit to the electron temperature of less than 20,000k .
this is consistent with the expected temperature in photoionization - dominated clouds ( with an electron density of @xmath159@xmath53 ) .
if the electron density is higher than this , collisional de - excitation begins to play a role and the estimated temperature is reduced .
these results would appear to rule out the dominance of shock excitation similar to that seen in galactic supernova remnants . as described in dopita & sutherland ( 1995 ) , the optical line ratios of seyfert 2s
can also be explained by fast ( 300500kmsec@xmath17 ) shocks , if the precursor hii regions in front of the shock absorb most of the uv photons generated by the shocks .
the calculated electron temperature is @xmath160k for this `` shock + precursor '' model from dopita & sutherland ( 1995 ) , which is consistent with the limit on the electron temperatures in smgs estimated from our [ nii ] and [ oiii ] emission line ratios .
thus there is a plausible origin for the [ oiii]@xmath7 excess we see compared to typical agn : shocks associated with supernova explosions in relatively dense gas environments , where the precursor hii clouds are still present .
thus we suggests that those sources with high ( @xmath16110 ) [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0 ratios and broad ( @xmath1622000 kmsec@xmath17 ) fwhm of h@xmath0 lines can be explained by a combination of a nls1-type agn residing in an environment of shocks associated with supernova explosions in relatively dense gas .
this would explain all their observable properties , including the high [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0 ratios ( dopita & sutherland 1995 ) .
using near - infrared spectroscopy we have observed the redshifted h@xmath0 the [ oiii]@xmath1 and [ oii]@xmath2 emission lines in a sample of 22 ultra - luminous infrared galaxies at high redshifts .
twenty of the sources in our sample are submillimeter galaxies at @xmath1633.5 . combining our observations with previous studies of the h@xmath3 and the [ nii ] emission from these galaxies and also with observations of their hard x - ray and far - infrared emission ,
we have placed constraints on the physical properties of this population .
we conclude the following : 1 .
a majority of our sample ( 14/22 ) have spectra which are classified as `` agn '' or `` qso '' based on several restframe optical spectroscopic diagnostics .
specifically , for those sources with detections of the four emission lines necessary to construct a bpt diagram , 8/9 are classified as `` agn '' .
it should be noted that there is no confirmed pure starburst galaxy in our sample , although several sources show intermediate spectral properties .
this is likely to be caused by our sample selection , which is biased towards galaxies with bright near - infrared magnitudes and also to those exhibiting strong line emission .
thus we caution that our results should not be taken as representative of the whole smg population .
2 . using the h@xmath3/h@xmath0 flux ratio we are able to estimate the internal extinction in our smgs .
we measure a median extinction of @xmath164 , which is similar to the extinction measured in local ulirgs .
this value is also consistent with the estimates from the sed fitting in the restframe uv / optical which are derived under the assumption of a dominant dust - reddened young starburst ( smail et al .
we compare the sfrs derived from the dust - extinction - corrected h@xmath3 luminosities with those derived from the far - infrared luminosities , and find reasonable consistency between these for most of the smgs in our sample .
the fact that the corrected h@xmath3-derived sfrs correspond closely to those estimated from the far - infrared suggests that star - formation is the major contributor to the far - infrared luminosities in smgs .
at least 11/19 of the smgs in our sample show a clear excess in the ratio of their [ oiii]@xmath7 to x - ray luminosities relative to values for local agns .
the five sources with the highest [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0 ratios ( @xmath137 ) , which are classified as `` agn '' from our spectral diagnostics , show this [ oiii]@xmath7 excess .
one possible explanation for the [ oiii]@xmath7 excess is that it is produced by `` compton - thick '' agns .
however , this is inconsistent with the column density measurements ( n@xmath165 ) from fitting of the x - ray spectra for the sources in cdfn and we argue that this is unlikely in most smgs . instead , we suggest that the most plausible cause of the [ oiii]@xmath7 excess is shock - induced emission arising from vigorous star formation ( `` super - wind '' activity ) . this scenario is supported in several galaxies by spatially extended and/or distorted / multiple [ oiii]@xmath7 emission line profiles . furthermore ,
using limits on the electron temperatures from [ oiii ] and [ nii ] emission line ratios , we can explain the excess [ oiii]@xmath7 emission as arising from shocks in dense regions within these systems .
the balmer line widths in 9/22 sample galaxies exhibit broad emission components with relatively small fwhms ( @xmath1663700kmsec@xmath17 ) .
three of them are classified as `` qso '' , but have smaller h@xmath0 fwhm ( 21002600kmsec@xmath17 ) than are typical for qsos .
they also have lower [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0 ratios and relatively strong feii emission , both of which are characteristics of local narrow line seyfert 1s . among the other six sources ,
only one shows a low [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0 ratio , and four show high [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0 ratios ( larger than seen in nls1 s ) .
however , the high [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0 ratios may arise from [ oiii]@xmath7 excesses due to shock excitation and hence removing this contribution would yield lower ratios more consistent with nls1 classification .
several of these sources also have tentative evidence for feii emission , again characteristic of nls1s . thus , once
account is taken of the potential contribution from shocks to the excess [ oiii]@xmath7 emission , there appears to be close similarities between smgs and nls1s .
the spectral classification of smgs as nls1s may then indicate ( as has been claimed for local nls1s ) that smgs have small mass black holes which are rapidly growing at high accretion rates ( alexander et al .
2005ab ; borys et al .
deeper spectroscopic observations are essential to search for any obscured broad balmer lines which might indicate larger smbh masses and confirm the presence of feii lines which are common in the nls1s . summarising our results : we conclude that our sample of smgs contains a population of vigorously star - forming galaxies with high sfrs and strong extinction .
the activity in these systems is driving shocks through the dense gas reservoirs they contain and some of this material is being expelled from the galaxies .
in addition , many of our sources show evidence for low - mass , but rapidly growing , super - massive black holes .
these results confirm the critical place of the submillimeter - bright phase in defining the properties of massive galaxies forming at high redshifts .
we are grateful to michael balogh , bob nichol , chris miller and dave alexander for their providing invaluable information and discussions .
tt and ks are also thank to all staffs of subaru telescope , especially to dr .
kentaro aoki and dr .
takuya fujiyoshi for the supports on our subaru / ohs observation .
we also thank to the anonymous referee for the various comments and suggestions to improve our manuscript .
irs acknowledges support from the royal society .
jeg acknowledges support from a pparc postgraduate studentship .
ams acknowledges a pparc fellowship .
alexander , d.m .
2003 , 126 , 539 alexander , d. , smail , i. , bauer , f. , chapman , s.c . ,
blain , a.w .
, ivison , r. 2005a , 434 , 738 .
alexander , d. , smail , i. , bauer , f. , chapman , s.c . ,
blain , a.w .
, ivison , r. 2005b , 632 , 736 alonso - herrero , a. , ward , m.j . , & kotilainen , j.k .
1997 , 288 , 977 baldwin , j.a .
, phillips , m.m . & terlevich , r. 1981 , 93 , 5 barger , a.j . , cowie , l.l . ,
sanders , d.b . , fulton , e. , taniguchi , y. , sato , y. , & okuda , h. 1998 , 394 , 248 bassani , l. , dadina , m. , maiolino , r. , salvati , m. , risaliti , g. , della cesa , r. , matt , g. & zamorani , g. 1999 , 121 , 473 basu - zych , a. , & scharf , c. 2004 , 615 , l85 bautz , m.w .
et al . 2000 , 543 , l119 blain , a. w. , smail , i. , ivison , r. j. , & kneib , j .-
1999 , 302 , 632 blain , a.w . ,
smail , i. , ivison , r.j . ,
kneib , j .-
& frayer , d.t .
2002 , 369 , 111 blain , a.w . , chapman , s.c . , smail , i. & ivison , r.j .
2004 611 , 52 borys , c. , smail , i. , chapman , s.c . , blain , a.w . ,
alexander , d.m . , & ivison , r.j .
2005 , 635 , 853 calzetti , d. , armus , l. , bohlin , r.c . ,
kinney , a.l .
, koornneef , j. & storch - bergmann , t. 2000 , 533 , 682 chapman , s.c . , blain , a.w . , ivison , r.j . & smail , i. 2003a , 422 , 695 chapman , s.c . , windhorst , r. , odewahn , s. , yan , h. & conselice , c. 2003b , 599 , 92 chapman , s.c . , blain , a.w . , smail , i. , & ivison , r. 2004a , 614 , 671 chapman , s.c . , blain , a.w . , smail , i. , & ivison , r. 2005 , 622 , 772 collin , s. & kawaguchi , t. 2004 , 426 , 797 condon , j.j . ,
anderson , m.l .
& helou , g. 1991 , 376 , 95 cowie , l. l. , barger , a. j. , & kneib , j.p . 2002 , 123 , 2197 desai , v. et al .
2006 , 641 , 133 dopita , m.a .
, & sutherland , r.s .
1995 apj 455 , 468 fabian , a.c .
2000 mnras 315 , l8 ferrarese , l. , & merritt , d. 2000 , 539 , l9 flores , h. , hammer , f. , elbaz , d. , cesarsky , c.j . ,
liang , y.c .
, fadda , d. & gruel , n. 2004 , 415 , 885 franceschini , a. et al .
2003 , 343 , 1181 frayer , d.t . ,
armus , l. , scoville , n.z . , blain , a.w . ,
reddy , n.a .
, ivison , r.j . & smail , i. 2003 , 126 , 73 garrett , m.a .
2002 , 384 , l19 gaskell , c.m . &
ferland , g.i .
1984 , 96 , 393 gebhardt , k. , et al .
2000 , 543 , l5 granato , g.l . ,
de zotti , g. , silva , l. , bressan , a. & danese , l. 2004 , 600 , 580 goodrich , r.w .
1989 , 342 , 224 greve , t.m . ,
ivison , r.j . ,
bertoldi , f. , stevens , j.a . ,
dunlop , j.s . , lutz , d. & carilli , c.l .
2004 , 354 , 779 greve , t.m .
2005 , 359 , 1165 halpern , j.p . & steiner , j.e .
1983 , 269 , l37 hawarden , t.g . ,
leggett , s.k . ,
letawsky , m.b . ,
ballantyne , d.r . & casali , m. 2001 , 325 , 563 heckman , t.m . , kauffmann , g. , brinchmann , j. , charlot , s. , tremonti , c. & white , s. 2004 , 613 , 109 hughes , d.h .
1998 , 394 , 241 holland , w.s .
et al . 1999 , 303 , 659 houck , j.r .
2005 , 622 , l105 ivison , r.j .
2006 , in press ( astro - ph/0607271 ) iwamuro , f. , motohara , k. , maihara , t. , hata , r. & harashima , t. 2001 , 53 , 355 iye , m. et al .
2004 , 56 , 381 jarvis , m.j .
& mclure , r.j .
2006 , in press ( astro - ph/0603231 ) kauffmann , g. et al .
2003 , 346 , 1055 kawakatu , n. , umemura , m. & mori , m. 2003 , 583 , 85 kewley , l. , dopita , m. , sutherland , r. , heisler , c. , & trevena , j. 2001 , 556 , 121 kewley , l. , geller , m.j . ,
jansen , r.a & dopita , m.a .
2002 , 124 , 3135 kennicutt , r. c. , jr .
1998 , 36 , 189 kovacs , a. , et al . 2006 , , in press ( astro - ph/0604591 ) ledlow , m.j .
, smail , i. , owen , f.n . ,
keel , w.c . ,
ivison , r.j . & morrison , g.e .
2002 , 577 , l79 lilly , s.j . ,
eales , s.a . ,
gear , w.k.p . ,
hammer , f. , le fevre , o. , crampton , d. , bond , j.r . , & dunne , l. 1999 , 518 , 641 lutz , d. , yan , l. , armus , l. , helou , g. , tacconi , l.j . ,
genzel , r. & baker , a.j .
2005 , 632 , l13 maraston , c. , 2006 , in press manners , j.c .
2003 , 343 , 293 marconi , a. , & hunt , l. k. 2003 , 589 , l21 motohara , k. et al .
2002 , 54 , 315 motohara , k. et al .
2005 , 129 , 53 mulchaey , j.s .
1994 , 436 , 586 mushotzky , r.f . ,
cowie , l.l . ,
barger , a.j .
& arnaud , k.a .
2000 , 404 , 459 neri , r. , et al .
2003 , 597 , l113 osterbrock , d.e . & pogge , r.w .
1985 , 297 , 166 osterbrock , d.e .
1989 , _ `` astrophysics of gaseous nebulae and active galactic nuclei '' _ , university science book ptak , a. , heckman , t. , levenson , n.a . ,
weaver , k. & strickland , d. 2003 , 592 , 782 schmitt , h.r . , bica , e. & pastoriza , m.g .
1996 , 278 , 965 scott , s. , et al .
2002 , 331 , 817 shopbell , p.l .
& bland - hawthorn , j. 1998 , 493 , 129 simpson , c. , dunlop , j.s . , eales , s.a . , ivison , r.j . , scott , s.e . ,
lilly , s.j . , & webb , t.m.a .
2004 , 353 , 179 smail , i. , ivison , r.j . &
blain , a.w .
1997 , 490 , l5 smail , i. , ivison , r.j . ,
blain , a.w .
& kneib , j .-
2002 , 331 , 495 smail , i. , chapman , s.c . ,
ivison , r.j . ,
blain , a.w .
, takata , t. , heckman , t.m . ,
dunlop , j.s . , & sekiguchi , k. 2003 , 342 , 1185 smail , i. , chapman , s.c . ,
blain , a.w .
& ivison , r. 2004 , 616 , 71 soucail , g. , kneib , j .-
p . , bezecourt , j. , metcalfe , l. , altieri , b. & le borgne , j.f .
1999 , 343 , l70 swinbank , m. , smail , i. , chapman , s.c . ,
blain , a.w .
, ivison , r. & keel , w.c .
2004 , 617 , 64 swinbank , m. et al .
2005 , 359 , 401 swinbank , m. chapman , s.c . ,
smail , i. , lindner , c. , borys , c. , blain , a.w . ,
ivison , r. & lewis , g.f .
2006 , in press ( astro - ph/0606372 ) tacconi , l. et al .
2006 , 640 , 228 tecza , m. et al .
2004 , 605 , l109 tremonti , c.a .
2004 , 613 , 898 van dokkum , p.g .
2004 , 611 , 703 veilleux , s. & osterbrock , d.e .
1987 , 63 , 295 veilleux , s. , kim , d .-
& sanders , d.b .
1999 , 522 , 113 veilleux , s. , cecil , g. & bland - hawthorn , j. 2005 , 43 , 769 wandel , a. 2002 , 565 , 762 waskett , t.j.,eales , s.a . , gear , w.k . ,
mccracken , h.j .
, brodwin , m. , nandra , k. , laird , e.s . , &
lilly , s. 2004 , 350 , 785 willott , c. et al .
2003 , 339 , 397 yan , l. , chary , r. , armus , l. , teplitz , h. , helou , g. , frayer , d. , fadda , d. , surace , j. & choi , p. 2005 , 628 , 604 and 2@xmath167 significance respectively .
the upper axis gives the restframe wavelength scale at the source redshift .
the shaded regions are areas effected by strong sky emission or absorption .
[ fig1 ] ] lrrrrrl & & & & & & + + & & & & & & + smmj123549.44 + 621536.8 & 7200 & apr 6 2004 & j&h & 6.8@xmath168 & [email protected] & + smmj123606.85 + 621021.4 & 7200 & feb 15 2005 & j&h & 8.7@xmath170 & [email protected] & + smmj123622.65 + 621629.7 & 7200 & apr 7 2004 & j&h & 9.0@xmath171 & [email protected] & + smmj123635.59 + 621424.1 & 7200 & feb 16 2005 & j&h & 7.5@xmath172 & [email protected] & + smmj123716.01 + 620323.3 & 4000 & feb 16 2005 & j&h & 6.3@xmath173 & [email protected] & + smmj123721.87 + 621035.3 & 7200 & jun 24 2004 & j&h & 0.43@xmath174 & [email protected] & + smmj131215.27 + 423900.9 & 600 & feb 16 2005 & j&h & 13.9@xmath175 & [email protected] & + smmj131222.35 + 423814.1 & 2000 & jun 25 2004 & j&h & 12.7@xmath176 & [email protected] & + smmj163639.01 + 405635.9 & 7200 & jun 24 2004 & j&h & 5.5@xmath177 & @xmath10422.0 & + smmj163650.43 + 405734.5 & 7000 & may 18 2003 & j&h & 50.5@xmath178 & @xmath10422.0 & smail et al .
( 2003 ) + mmj163655 + 4059 & 3600 & apr 7 2004 & j&h & 10.9@xmath179 & [email protected] & + smmj163706.51 + 405313.8 & 7200 & apr 6 2004 & j&h & 7.2@xmath180 & @xmath10422.0 & + smmj221733.02 + 000906.0 & 3000 & jun 24 2004 & j&h & 1.9@xmath181 & @xmath10428.0 & + smmj221733.79 + 001402.1 & 7200 & jun 25 2004 & j&h & 4.9@xmath182 & @xmath10428.0 & + & & & & & & + + & & & & & & + smmj02399 - 0134 & 4500 & nov 24,25 2004 & j & 6.5@xmath183 & [email protected] & + & 2400 & nov 25 2004 & z & & & + smmj030227.73 + 000653.5 & 6000 & nov 23 2004 & j & 5.8@xmath184 & [email protected] & + rgj030257.94 + 001016.3 & 4500 & nov 23 2004 & h & 7.7@xmath185 & [email protected] & + smmj105702.50 - 033602.6 & 4500 & nov 23 2004 & h & 5.0@xmath173 & @xmath10410.0 & + smmj221737.39 + 001025.1 & 9000 & nov 23,24 2004 & k & 21.0@xmath186 & @xmath10428.0 & + & 6000 & nov 25 2004 & h & & & + & & & & & & + + & & & & & & + smmj09431 + 4700(h6 ) & 2400 & apr 8 2004 & k & 15.0@xmath187 & @xmath10413.0 & + smmj09431 + 4700(h7 ) & 2400 & apr 8 2004 & k & 15.0@xmath187 & @xmath10413.0 & + smmj131201.17 + 424208.1 & 2400 & apr 8 2004 & k & 20.2@xmath188 & [email protected] & + & & & & & & + + & & & & & & + smmj04431 + 0210 & & & & 3.5@xmath172 & & frayer et al .
( 2003 ) + smmj14011 + 0252(j1 ) & & & & 6.8@xmath176 & @xmath10444.0 & motohara et al.(2005 ) + smmj163658.19 + 410523.8 & & & & 10.9@xmath179 & @xmath10422.0 & simpson et al.(2004 ) + lrrrrrrcccrl object & @xmath189 & h@xmath3 flux & h@xmath0 flux & [ o iii]@xmath190 flux & [ o iii]@xmath191 flux & [ o ii]@xmath192 flux & & rest fwhm@xmath193 & comment + & & & uv & h@xmath194 & opt & km@xmath195sec@xmath17 & + smmj02399 - 0134 & 1.061 & 75.8@xmath169 15.0 & @xmath10411.0 & @xmath10411.0 & @xmath10411.0 & & agn & agn & & 1530@xmath169500 + smmj030227.73 + 000653.5 & 1.408 & 15.2@xmath169 2.0 & 1.9@xmath169 1.1 & 10.7@xmath169 3.2 & 7.2@xmath169 2.6 & & sb & agn & agn & @xmath104100 & + rgj030258.94 + 001016.3 & 2.239 & 1.8@xmath169 0.5 & @xmath1040.3 & 9.2@xmath169 2.1 & 0.85@xmath169 0.30 & & int & agn & agn & & + smmj09431 + 4700(h6 ) & 3.350 & & 0.3@xmath169 0.2 & 1.7@xmath169 0.3 & 0.7@xmath169 0.4 & & sb & & sb ? & 350@xmath16950 & extended [ oiii]@xmath7 + smmj09431 + 4700(h7 ) & 3.347 & & @xmath1040.15 & 0.5@xmath169 0.1 & @xmath1040.15 & & & & & & + smmj105702.50 - 033602.6 & 2.423 & 0.6@xmath169 0.2 & @xmath1040.19 & @xmath1040.19 & @xmath1040.19 & & & sb & & & van dokkum et al . ( 2004 ) ; miss the slit ? + smmj123549.44 + 621536.8 & 2.195 & 15.0@xmath169 1.0 & 1.6@xmath169 1.0 & 6.4@xmath169 1.3 & 1.9@xmath169 0.8 & 2.9@xmath169 0.8 & sb & int & agn & 2150@xmath169500 & [ oiii]@xmath7 double peaks and extended + smmj123606.85 + 621021.4 & 2.505 & 2.0@xmath169 0.3 & @xmath1040.043 & @xmath1040.043 & @xmath1040.043 & @xmath1040.043 & sb & int & & & slit on companion object ? + smmj123622.65 + 621629.7 & 2.462 & 3.4@xmath169 0.6 & @xmath1040.8 & @xmath1040.8 & @xmath1040.8 & 2.1@xmath169 0.5 & sb & sb & & & + smmj123635.59 + 621424.1 & 2.005 & 11.1@xmath169 1.2 & & 2.0@xmath169 0.6 & 2.4@xmath169 0.5 & & agn & agn & agn ? & & + smmj123716.01 + 620323.3 & 2.053 & & 28.1@xmath169 3.2 & 19.5@xmath169 2.4 & 9.7@xmath169 2.2 & & qso & & agn & 2130@xmath169500 & multiple peaks and extended [ oiii]@xmath7 + smmj123721.87 + 621035.3 & 0.979 & 6.2@xmath169 1.1 & & & & & & sb & & & + smmj131201.17 + 424208.1 & 3.408 & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & agn & & agn ? & & + smmj131215.27 + 423900.9 & 2.555 & 11.8@xmath169 1.0 & 3.1@xmath169 2.6 & 5.6@xmath169 2.2 & 2.2@xmath169 1.6 & @xmath1040.23 & qso & & agn & 2540@xmath169500 & + smmj131222.35 + 423814.1 & 2.560 & & 12.1@xmath169 4.5 & 5.5@xmath169 2.5 & 2.6@xmath169 2.5 & 2.0@xmath169 1.5 & qso & & agn & 2580@xmath1691000 & + smmj163639.01 + 405635.9 & 1.485 & 7.3@xmath169 0.7 & 0.7@xmath169 0.5 & 2.5@xmath169 0.5 & 1.1@xmath169 0.4 & & sb & sb & int & @xmath1041400 & extended h@xmath3 + smmj163650.43 + 405734.5 & 2.380 & 14.2@xmath169 1.5 & 2.3@xmath169 0.6 & 27.0@xmath169 2.1 & 6.8@xmath169 1.3 & 14.0@xmath169 0.8 & int & agn & agn & 3720@xmath169500 & reevaluated after smail et al .
( 2003 ) + mmj163655 + 4059 & 2.605 & 18.4@xmath169 2.4 & 2.7@xmath169 1.0 & 47.1@xmath169 1.6 & 15.7@xmath169 1.6 & 3.6@xmath169 0.9 & agn & agn & agn & 2410@xmath169600 & blue wings in h@xmath0 and [ oiii]@xmath86 + smmj163706.51 + 405313.8 & 2.373 & 7.4@xmath169 1.4 & 0.6@xmath169 0.3 & 5.7@xmath169 0.6 & 1.9@xmath169 0.6 & 1.0@xmath169 0.3 & agn & agn & agn & 1590@xmath169500 & + smmj221733.02 + 000906.0 & 0.926 & 9.6@xmath169 1.2 & & & & & & sb & & & + smmj221733.79 + 001402.1 & 2.551 & 8.5@xmath169 3.5 & 1.2@xmath169 0.6 & 1.2@xmath169 0.2 & @xmath1040.5 & 0.7@xmath169 0.3 & sb & sb & agn ? & 1860@xmath169600 & + smmj221737.39 + 001025.1 & 2.610 & 20.7@xmath169 6.0 & 0.6 @xmath1690.4 & 6.0@xmath169 0.4 & 1.2@xmath169 0.4 & & sb & agn & agn & 290@xmath16950 & + & & & & & & & & & + smmj04431 + 0210 & 2.510 & 1.6@xmath169 0.1 & @xmath1040.3 & 0.4@xmath169 0.1 & & & & agn ? & agn & & frayer et al .
( 2003 ) + smmj14011 + 0252(j1 ) & 2.565 & 1.3@xmath169 0.4 & 0.3@xmath169 0.1 & @xmath1040.2 & @xmath1040.2&[email protected] & sb & sb & sb & & motohara et al .
( 2005 ) + smmj163658.19 + 410523.8 & 2.448 & 1.9@xmath169 0.4 & 0.2@xmath169 0.1 & 0.4@xmath169 0.1 & 0.3@xmath169 0.1 & 0.4@xmath169 0.2 & sb & sb & agn & & simpson et al .
( 2004 ) + & & & & & & & + composite(all ) & & & 1.0 & 0.7@xmath196 & 0.4@xmath196 & 0.3@xmath197 & & & & 3100@xmath169500 & + composite(qso ) & & & 1.0 & 0.36@xmath198 & 0.19@xmath199 & @xmath1040.12 & & & & 3200@xmath1691000 & + composite(opt - agn ) & & & 1.0 & 3.2@xmath200 & 1.2@xmath201 & 1.2@xmath202 & & & & 1730@xmath169500 & + | we report the results of a systematic near - infrared spectroscopic survey using the subaru , vlt and keck telescopes of a sample of high redshift ultra - luminous infrared galaxies ( ulirgs ) mainly composed of submillimeter - selected galaxies .
our observations span the restframe optical range containing nebular emission lines such as h@xmath0 , [ oiii]@xmath1 , and [ oii]@xmath2 , which are essential for making robust diagnostics of the physical properties of these ulirgs . using the h@xmath3/h@xmath0 emission line ratios
, we derive internal extinction estimates for these galaxies similar to those of local ulirgs : @xmath4 . correcting the h@xmath3 estimates of the star formation rate for dust extinction using the balmer decrement , results in rates which are consistent with those estimated from the far - infrared luminosity .
the majority ( @xmath5% ) of our sample show spectral features characteristic of agn ( although we note this partially reflects an observational bias in our sample ) , with @xmath6% exhibiting broad balmer emission lines .
a proportion of these sources show relatively low [ oiii]@xmath7/h@xmath0 line ratios , which are similar to those of narrow line seyfert 1 galaxies suggesting small mass black holes which are rapidly growing . in the subsample of our survey with both [ oiii]@xmath7 and hard x - ray coverage , at least @xmath8% show an excess of [ oiii]@xmath7 emission , by a factor of 510@xmath9 , relative to the hard x - ray luminosity compared to the correlation between these two properties seen in seyferts and qsos locally . from our spectral diagnostics , we propose that the strong [ oiii]@xmath7 emission in these galaxies arises from shocks in dense gaseous regions in this vigorously star - forming population .
we caution that due to sensitivity and resolution limits , our sample is biased to strong line emitters and hence our results do not yet provide a complete view of the physical properties of the whole high - redshift ulirg population . |
_ steganography _ is a scientific discipline within the field known as _ data hiding _ ,
concerned with hiding information into a commonly used media , in such a way that no one apart from the sender and the intended recipient can detect the presence of embedded data .
a comprehensive overview of the core principles and the mathematical methods that can be used for data hiding can be found in @xcite .
an interesting steganographic method is known as _ matrix encoding _ , introduced by crandall @xcite and analyzed by bierbrauer et al .
matrix encoding requires the sender and the recipient to agree in advance on a parity check matrix @xmath2 , and the secret message is then extracted by the recipient as the syndrome ( with respect to @xmath2 ) of the received cover object .
this method was made popular by westfeld @xcite , who incorporated a specific implementation using hamming codes in his f5 algorithm , which can embed @xmath3 bits of message in @xmath4 cover symbols by changing , at most , one of them .
there are two parameters which help to evaluate the performance of a steganographic method over a cover message of @xmath5 symbols : the _ average distortion _
@xmath6 , where @xmath7 is the expected number of changes over uniformly distributed messages ; and the _ embedding rate _
@xmath8 , which is the amount of bits that can be hidden in a cover message . in general , for the same embedding rate a method is better when the average distortion is smaller . following the terminology used by fridrich et al .
@xcite , the pair @xmath9 will be called _
@xmath10-rate_. furthermore , as willems et al . in @xcite
, we will also assume that a discrete source produces a sequence @xmath11 , where @xmath5 is the block length , each @xmath12 , and @xmath13 depends on whether the source is a grayscale digital image , or a cd audio , etc .
the message @xmath14 we want to hide into a host sequence @xmath15 produces a composite sequence @xmath16 , where @xmath17 and each @xmath18 .
the composite sequence @xmath19 is obtained from distorting @xmath15 , and the distortion will be assumed to be a squared - error distortion ( see @xcite ) . in these conditions , if information is only carried by the least significant bit ( lsb ) of each @xmath20 , the appropriate solution comes from using binary hamming codes @xcite , improved using product hamming codes @xcite . for larger magnitude of changes , but limited to @xmath21 , that is , @xmath22 , where @xmath23 , the situation is called
@xmath1-steganography " , and the information is carried by the two least significant bits .
it is known that the embedding becomes statistically detectable rather quickly with the increasing amplitude of embedding changes .
therefore , our interest goes to avoid changes of amplitude greater than one . with this assumption ,
our steganographic scheme will be compared with the upper bound from @xcite for the embedding rate in @xmath1-steganography " , given by @xmath24 , where @xmath25 is the binary entropy function @xmath26 and @xmath27 is the average distortion .
a main purpose of steganography is designing schemes in order to approach this upper bound . in most of the previous papers ,
@xmath1-steganography " has involved a ternary coding problem .
willems et al .
@xcite proposed a schemed based on ternary hamming and golay codes , which were proved to be optimal .
fridrich and lisonk @xcite proposed a method based on rainbow colouring graphs which , for some values , outperformed the scheme obtained by direct sum of ternary hamming codes with the same average distortion .
however , both methods from @xcite and @xcite show a problem when dealing with extreme grayscale values , since they suggest making a change of magnitude greater than one in order to avoid having to apply the change @xmath28 and @xmath29 to a host sequence of value @xmath30 and @xmath31 , respectively .
note that the kind of change they propose would obviously introduce larger distortion and therefore make the embedding more statistically detectable . in this paper
we also consider the @xmath1-steganography .
our new method is based on perfect @xmath0-linear codes which , although they are not linear , they have a representation using a parity check matrix that makes them as efficient as the hamming codes .
as we will show , this new method not only performs better than the one obtained by direct sum of ternary hamming codes from @xcite , but it also deals better with the extreme grayscale values , because the magnitude of embedding changes is under no circumstances greater than one . to make this paper self - contained , we review in section [ sec : additivecodes ] a few elementary concepts on perfect @xmath0-linear codes , relevant for our study .
the new steganographic method is presented in section [ sec : stegoz2z4 ] , whereas an improvement to better deal with the extreme grayscale values problem is given in section [ sec : anomalies ] .
finally , the paper is concluded in section [ sec : conclusions ] .
in general , any non - empty subgroup @xmath32 of @xmath33 is a _ @xmath0-additive code _ , where @xmath34 denotes the set of all binary vectors of length @xmath35 and @xmath36 is the set of all @xmath37-tuples in @xmath38 .
let @xmath39 , where @xmath40 is given by the map @xmath41 where @xmath42 , @xmath43 , @xmath44 , and @xmath45 is the usual gray map from @xmath38 onto @xmath46 .
a @xmath0-additive code @xmath32 is also isomorphic to an abelian structure like @xmath47 .
therefore , @xmath32 has @xmath48 codewords , where @xmath49 of them are of order two .
we call such code @xmath32 a
_ @xmath0-additive code of type @xmath50 _ and its binary image @xmath51 is a _
@xmath0-linear code of type @xmath50_. note that the lee distance of a @xmath0-additive code @xmath32 coincides with the hamming distance of the @xmath0-linear code @xmath39 , and that the binary code @xmath51 does not have to be linear .
the _ @xmath52-additive dual code _ of @xmath32 , denoted by @xmath53 , is defined as the set of vectors in @xmath33 that are orthogonal to every codeword in @xmath32 , being the definition of inner product in @xmath54 the following : @xmath55 where @xmath56 and computations are made considering the zeros and ones in the @xmath35 binary coordinates as quaternary zeros and ones , respectively .
the binary code @xmath57 , of length @xmath58 , is called the _ @xmath52-dual code _ of @xmath51 .
a @xmath0-additive code @xmath32 is said to be _ perfect _ if code @xmath39 is a perfect @xmath0-linear code , that is all vectors in @xmath59 are within distance one from a codeword and the distance between two codewords is , at least , three . for any @xmath60 and each @xmath61 @xmath62 @xmath63 there
exists a perfect @xmath0-linear code @xmath51 of binary length @xmath64 , such that its @xmath0-dual code is of type @xmath50 , where @xmath65 , @xmath66 and @xmath67 ( note that the binary length can be computed as @xmath58 ) .
the above result is due to @xcite and it allows us to write the parity check matrix @xmath2 of any @xmath0-additive perfect code for a given value of @xmath61 .
matrix @xmath2 can be represented taking all possible vectors in @xmath68 , up to sign changes , as columns . in this representation , there are @xmath35 columns which correspond to the binary part of vectors in @xmath32 , and @xmath37 columns of order four which correspond to the quaternary part .
we agree on a representation of the @xmath35 binary coordinates as coordinates in @xmath69 .
take a perfect @xmath0-linear code and consider its @xmath0-dual , which is of type @xmath50 . as stated in the previous section , this gives us a parity check matrix @xmath2 which has @xmath70 rows of order two and @xmath61 rows of order four .
for instance , for @xmath71 and according to @xcite , there are three different @xmath0-additive perfect codes of binary length @xmath72 which correspond to the possible values of @xmath73 . for @xmath74 ,
the corresponding @xmath0-additive perfect code is the usual binary hamming code , while for @xmath75 the @xmath0-additive perfect code has parameters @xmath76 , @xmath77 , @xmath78 , @xmath75 and the following parity check matrix : @xmath79 let @xmath80 , for @xmath81 , denote the @xmath82-th column vector of @xmath2 . note that the all twos vector @xmath83 is always one of the columns in @xmath2 and , for the sake of simplicity , it will be written as the column @xmath84 .
we group the remaining first @xmath35 columns in @xmath2 in such a way that , for any @xmath85 , the column vector @xmath86 is paired up with its complementary column vector @xmath87 , where @xmath88 . to use these perfect @xmath0-additive codes in steganography take @xmath89 and
let @xmath90 be an @xmath5-length source of grayscale symbols such that @xmath91 , where , for instance , @xmath92 for grayscale images .
we assume that a grayscale symbol @xmath20 is represented as a binary vector @xmath93 such that @xmath94 where @xmath95 is the inverse of gray map .
we will use the two least significant bits ( lsbs ) , @xmath96 , of every grayscale symbol @xmath20 in the source , for @xmath97 , as well as the least significant bit @xmath98 of symbol @xmath99 to embed the secret message . each symbol @xmath20
will be associated with one or more column vectors @xmath80 in @xmath2 , depending on the grayscale symbol : 1 .
grayscale symbol @xmath99 is associated with column vector @xmath84 by taking the least significant bit @xmath98 of @xmath99 .
grayscale symbol @xmath20 , for @xmath85 , is associated with the two column vectors @xmath80 and @xmath100 , by taking , respectively , the two least significant bits , @xmath101 , of @xmath20 .
grayscale symbol @xmath102 , for @xmath103 , is associated with column vector @xmath104 by taking its two least significant bits @xmath105 and interpreting them as an integer number @xmath106 in @xmath38 . in this way
, the given @xmath5-length packet @xmath107 of symbols is translated into a vector @xmath108 of @xmath35 binary coordinates and @xmath37 quaternary coordinates .
the embedding process we are proposing is based on the matrix encoding method @xcite .
the secret message can be any vector @xmath109 @xmath62 @xmath47 .
vector @xmath110 indicates the changes needed to embed @xmath109 within @xmath107 ; that is @xmath111 , where @xmath112 is an integer whose value will be described bellow , @xmath113 is the syndrome vector of @xmath108 and @xmath80 is a column vector in @xmath2 .
the following situations can occur , depending on which column @xmath80 needs to be modified : 1 .
if @xmath114 , then the embedder is required to change the least significant bit of @xmath99 by adding or substracting one unit to / from @xmath99 , depending on which operation will flip its least significant bit , @xmath98 .
if @xmath80 is among the first @xmath35 column vectors in @xmath2 and @xmath115 , then @xmath112 can only be @xmath116 . in this case , since @xmath80 was paired up with its complementary column vector @xmath100 , then this situation is equivalent to make @xmath117 or @xmath118 , where @xmath119 and @xmath120 are the least significant bits of the symbol @xmath20 which had been associated with those two column vectors . hence , after the inverse of gray map , by changing one or another least significant bit we are actually adding or subtracting one unit to / from @xmath20 .
note that a problem may crop up at this point when we need to add @xmath21 to a symbol @xmath20 of value @xmath121 or , likewise , when @xmath20 has value @xmath122 and we need to subtract @xmath21 from it .
3 . if @xmath80 is one of the last @xmath37 columns in @xmath2 we can see that this situation corresponds to add @xmath123 to @xmath124 . note that because we are using a @xmath0-additive perfect code , @xmath112 will never be @xmath125 .
hence , the embedder should add ( @xmath116 ) or subtract ( @xmath126 ) one unit to / from symbol @xmath124 .
once again , a problem may arise with the extreme grayscale values .
[ ex : noanomalies ] let @xmath127 be an @xmath5-length source of grayscale symbols , where @xmath128 and @xmath129 , and let @xmath2 be the matrix in ( [ pcm ] ) .
the source @xmath107 is then translated into the vector @xmath130 in the way specified above .
let @xmath131 be the vector representing the secret message we want to embed in @xmath107 .
we then compute @xmath132 and see , by the matrix encoding method , that @xmath126 and @xmath133 . according to the method just described ,
we should apply the change @xmath134 . in this way
, @xmath135 becomes @xmath136 , and then @xmath137 , which has the expected syndrome @xmath138 .
as already mentioned at the beginning of this paper , the problematic cases related to the extreme grayscale values are also present in the methods from @xcite and @xcite , but their authors assume that the probability of gray value saturation is not too large . we argue that , though rare , this gray saturation can still occur . however , in order to compare our proposal with these others we will not consider these problems either until the next section .
therefore , we proceed to compute the values of the average distortion @xmath139 and the embedding rate @xmath140 .
our method is able to hide any secret vector @xmath109 @xmath62 @xmath47 into the given @xmath5 symbols .
hence , the embedding rate is @xmath141 bits per @xmath5 symbols , @xmath142 .
concerning the average distortion @xmath139 , we are using a perfect code of binary length @xmath143 , which corresponds to @xmath144 grayscale symbols .
there are @xmath145 symbols @xmath20 , for @xmath146 , with a probability @xmath147 of being subjected to a change ; a symbol @xmath99 with a probability @xmath148 of being the one changed ; and , finally , there is a probability of @xmath148 that neither of the symbols will need to be changed to embed @xmath109 .
hence , @xmath149 .
the described method has a @xmath10-rate @xmath150 , where @xmath144 and @xmath151 is any integer @xmath60 .
we are able to generate a specific embedding scheme for any value of @xmath151 but not for any @xmath10-rate . with the aim of improving this situation ,
convex combinations of @xmath10-rates of two codes related to their direct sum are extensively treated in @xcite .
actually , it is possible to choose the @xmath139 coordinate and cover more @xmath10-rates by taking convex combinations .
therefore , if @xmath139 is a non - allowable parameter for the average distortion we can still take @xmath152 , where @xmath153 are two contiguous allowable parameters , and by means of the direct sum of the two codes with embedding rate @xmath154 and @xmath155 , respectively , we can obtain a new @xmath10-rate @xmath9 , with @xmath156 and @xmath157 . from a graphic point of view , this is equivalent to draw a line between two contiguous points @xmath158 and @xmath159 , as it is shown in [ fig : graphicwoanom ] .
in the following theorem we claim that the @xmath10-rate of our method improves the one given by direct sum of ternary hamming codes from @xcite . for @xmath160
, the @xmath10-rate given by the method based on @xmath0-additive perfect codes improves the @xmath10-rate obtained by direct sum of ternary hamming codes with the same average distortion .
optimal embedding ( of course , in the allowable values of @xmath139 ) can be obtained by using ternary codes , as it is shown in @xcite .
the @xmath10-rate of these codes is @xmath161 for any integer @xmath162 .
our method , based on @xmath0-additive perfect codes , has @xmath10-rate @xmath150 , for any integer @xmath60 and @xmath144 .
take , for any @xmath60 , two contiguous values for @xmath162 such that @xmath163 and write @xmath164 , where @xmath165 .
we want to prove that , for @xmath160 , we have @xmath166 , which is straightforward .
however , since it is neither short nor contributes to the well understanding of the method , we do not include all computations here .
the graphic bellow compares the @xmath10-rate of the method based on ternary hamming codes with that one based on @xmath0-additive perfect codes .
as one may see in this graphic , for some values of the average distortion @xmath139 , the scheme based on @xmath0-additive perfect codes has greater embedding rate @xmath140 than the one based on ternary hamming codes .
* remark : * the same argumentation can be used and the same conclusion can be reached taking @xmath167 instead of @xmath168 and comparing our method with the method described in @xcite .
-rate @xmath9 , for @xmath92 , of steganographic methods based on ternary hamming codes and on @xmath0-additive perfect codes . ]
in section [ sec : stegoz2z4 ] we described a problem which may raise when , according to our method , the embedder is required to add one unit to a source symbol @xmath20 containing the maximum allowed value ( @xmath121 ) , or to substract one unit from a symbol @xmath20 containing the minimum allowed value , @xmath122 . to face this problem
, we will use the complementary column vector @xmath100 of columns @xmath80 in matrix @xmath2 , where @xmath169 and @xmath80 is among the last @xmath37 columns in @xmath2 . note that @xmath80 and @xmath100 can coincide .
the first @xmath35 column vectors in @xmath2 will be paired up as before , and the association between each @xmath20 and each column vector @xmath80 in @xmath2 will be also the same as in section [ sec : stegoz2z4 ] . however , given an @xmath5-length source of grayscale symbols @xmath90 , a secret message @xmath170 and the vector @xmath110 , such that @xmath171 , indicating the changes needed to embed @xmath109 within @xmath107 , we can now make some variations on the kinds of changes to be done for the specific problematic cases : * if @xmath80 is among the first @xmath35 columns in @xmath2 , for @xmath115 , and the embedder is required to add @xmath21 to a symbol @xmath31 , then the embedder should instead substract @xmath21 from @xmath20 as well as perform the appropiate operation ( @xmath172 or @xmath173 ) over @xmath99 to have @xmath98 flipped . likewise , if the embedder is required to substract @xmath21 from a symbol @xmath30 , then ( s)he should instead add @xmath21 to @xmath20 and also change @xmath99 to flip @xmath98 . *
if @xmath80 is one of the last @xmath37 columns in @xmath2 , and the embedder has to add @xmath21 to a symbol @xmath31 , ( s)he should instead substract @xmath21 from the grayscale symbol associated to @xmath100 and also change @xmath99 to flip @xmath98 . if the method requires substracting @xmath21 from @xmath30 , then we should instead add @xmath21 to the symbol associated to @xmath100 and , again , change @xmath99 to flip @xmath98 .
[ ex : anomalies ] let @xmath174 be an @xmath5-length source of grayscale symbols , where @xmath128 and @xmath129 , and let @xmath2 be the matrix ( [ pcm ] ) . as in example
[ ex : noanomalies ] , the packet @xmath107 is translated into vector @xmath130 , and @xmath131 .
however , note that now we are not able to make @xmath134 because @xmath175 . instead of this , we will add one unit to @xmath176 , which is the symbol associated with @xmath177 , and substract one unit from @xmath99 so as to have its least significant bit flipped .
therefore , we obtain @xmath178 and then @xmath179 , which has the desired syndrome . the method above described has the same embedding rate @xmath180 as the one from section [ sec : stegoz2z4 ] but a slightly worse average distortion .
we will take into account the squared - error distortion defined in @xcite for our reasoning .
as before , among the total number of grayscale symbols @xmath144 , there are @xmath145 symbols @xmath20 , for @xmath146 , with a probability @xmath147 of being changed ; a symbol @xmath99 with a probability @xmath148 of being the one changed ; and , finally , there is a probability of @xmath148 that neither of the symbols will need to be changed .
as one may have noted in this scheme , performing a certain change to a symbol @xmath20 , associated with a column @xmath80 in @xmath2 , has the same effect as performing the opposite change to the grayscale symbol associated with @xmath100 and also changing the least significant bit @xmath98 of @xmath99 .
this means that with probability @xmath181 we will change a symbol @xmath20 , for @xmath146 , a magnitude of @xmath21 ; and with probability @xmath182 we will change two other symbols also a magnitude of @xmath21 .
therefore , @xmath183 and the average distortion is thus @xmath184 .
hence , the described method has @xmath10-rate @xmath185 .
as we have already mentioned , the problem of grayscale symbols with @xmath122 and @xmath121 values was previously detected in both @xcite and @xcite . with the aim of providing a possible solution to this problem
, the authors suggested to perform a change of a magnitude greater than @xmath21 .
the effects of doing this were are out of the scope of @xmath1-steganography .
in the remainder of this section we proceed to compare the @xmath10-rate of our method with the @xmath10-rate that those methods would have if their proposed solution was implemented .
the scheme presented by willems et al .
@xcite is based on ternary hamming codes , which are known to have length @xmath186 , where @xmath162 denotes the number of parity check equations .
let us assume that whenever the embedder is required to perform a change ( @xmath172 or @xmath173 ) that would lead the corresponding symbol @xmath20 to a non - allowed value , then a change of magnitude @xmath125 ( @xmath187 or @xmath188 ) is made instead . while the embedding rate @xmath140 of this scheme would still be @xmath189 , the average distortion @xmath139 would no longer be @xmath190 .
the actual expected number of changes @xmath7 is computed by noting that a symbol will be changed with probability @xmath191 , and will not with probability @xmath192 . among the cases in which a symbol would need to be changed , there is a probability of @xmath181 that a symbol will be changed a magnitude of @xmath21 , and a probability of @xmath182 that it will be changed a magnitude of @xmath125 . by the squared - error distortion ,
@xmath193 and therefore @xmath194 .
fridrich and lisonk propose in their paper to pool the grayscale symbols source @xmath107 into cells of size @xmath195 , then rainbow colour these cells and apply a @xmath167-ary hamming code , where @xmath196 is a prime power .
they measure the distortion by counting the maximum number of embedding changes , thus just considering the covering radius of the @xmath167-ary hamming codes .
however , we will now consider the average number of embedding changes ( see @xcite ) .
as willems et at . , the authors from @xcite also suggest to perform a change of magnitude @xmath197 to solve the extreme grayscale values problem .
if this is done , the embedding rate would still be the same , @xmath198 , but the average distortion would now be @xmath199 .
one can see in [ fig : graphicwanom ] how our steganographic method for @xmath0-additive perfect codes deals with the extreme grayscale values problem , for some values of @xmath139 , better than those using ternary hamming codes ( @xmath200 ) from @xcite and @xcite .
-rates @xmath9 , for @xmath92 , of steganographic methods based on ternary hamming codes and on @xmath0-additive perfect codes , when they are dealing with the extreme grayscale values problem described in section [ sec : anomalies ] . ]
in this paper , we have presented a new method for @xmath1-steganography , based on perfect @xmath0-linear codes .
these codes are non - linear but still there exists a parity check matrix representation that makes them efficient to work with .
as we have shown in sections [ sec : stegoz2z4 ] and [ sec : anomalies ] , this new scheme outperforms the one obtained by direct sum of ternary hamming codes ( see @xcite ) as well as the one obtained after rainbow colouring graphs by using @xmath167-ary hamming codes for @xmath200 .
if we consider the special cases in which the technique might require to substract one unit from a grayscale symbol containing the minimum allowed value , or to add one unit to a symbol containing the maximum allowed value , our method performs even better than those aforementioned schemes .
this is so because unlike them , our method never applies any change of magnitude greater than @xmath21 , but two changes of magnitude @xmath21 instead , which is better in terms of distortion .
therefore , our method makes the embedding less statistically detectable . as for further research , since the approach based on product hamming codes in
@xcite improved the performance of basic lsb steganography and the basic @xmath201 algorithm , we would also expect a considerable improvement of the @xmath10-rate by using product @xmath0-additive codes or subspaces of product @xmath0-additive codes in @xmath1-steganography .
j. bierbrauer and j. fridrich , constructing good covering codes for applications in steganography " , in transactions on data hiding and multimedia security iii , vol .
4920 of lecture notes in computer science , pp . 1 - 22 , springer , berlin , germany , 2008 . | steganography is an information hiding application which aims to hide secret data imperceptibly into a commonly used media .
unfortunately , the theoretical hiding asymptotical capacity of steganographic systems is not attained by algorithms developed so far . in this paper , we describe a novel coding method based on @xmath0-linear codes that conforms to @xmath1-steganography , that is secret data is embedded into a cover message by distorting each symbol by one unit at most .
this method solves some problems encountered by the most efficient methods known today , based on ternary hamming codes .
finally , the performance of this new technique is compared with that of the mentioned methods and with the well - known theoretical upper bound . |
we present new measurements of the @xmath4 and @xmath5 absolute branching fractions , their ratio , and measurements of the semileptonic form factors controlling these decays.@xmath11 modes as @xmath12 decays , and use the clebsch - gordan factor 1.5 to correct for @xmath13 decays , which we do not detect . ]
exclusive charm semileptonic decays provide particularly simple tests of over decay dynamics since long distance effects only enter through the hadronic form factors @xcite . a wide variety of theoretical methods
have been brought to bear on the calculation of these form factors including quark models @xcite , qcd sum rules @xcite , lattice qcd @xcite , analyticity @xcite , and others @xcite . using a technique developed by focus
@xcite , we present non - parametric measurements of the @xmath14 dependence of the helicity basis form factors that give an amplitude for the @xmath15 system to be in any one of its possible angular momentum states where @xmath14 is the invariant mass squared of the lepton pair in the decay .
the ultimate goal of this study is to obtain a better understanding of the semileptonic decay intensity .
cleo - c produces @xmath16 mesons at the @xmath17(3770 ) , which ensures a pure @xmath18 final state with no additional final state hadrons . in events
where the @xmath12 is produced against a fully reconstructed @xmath19 the missing neutrino can be reconstructed with unparalleled precision using energy - momentum balance .
hence , cleo - c data offer unparalleled @xmath14 and decay angle resolution allowing one to resolve fine details in the structure of these form factors without the complications of a deconvolution procedure .
the various helicity basis form factors are distinguished based on their contributions to the decay angular distribution .
, @xmath20 , and @xmath21 angles.,width=307 ] the amplitude @xmath22 for the semileptonic decay @xmath12 is described by five kinematic quantities : @xmath14 ; the kaon - pion mass ( @xmath23 ) ; the kaon helicity angle ( @xmath24 ) , which is computed as the angle between the @xmath25 and the @xmath16 direction in the @xmath15 rest frame ; the lepton helicity angle ( @xmath26 ) , which is computed as the angle between the @xmath27 and the @xmath16 direction in the @xmath28 rest frame ; and the acoplanarity angle between the two decay planes ( @xmath21 ) .
the decay angles are illustrated in fig .
[ fig : kinem - definition ] . the amplitude @xmath22 can be expressed in terms of four helicity amplitudes representing the transition to the vector @xmath10 : @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 , @xmath32 and a fifth form factor , @xmath33 describing a non - resonant , @xmath7-wave @xmath12 contribution .
the diferential decay width for the 4-body semileptonic process is @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the decay intensity , @xmath36 is the @xmath15 momentum in the @xmath37 rest frame , @xmath38 is the momentum of the kaon in the @xmath15 rest frame , and @xmath39 is the momentum of the @xmath40 in the @xmath41 rest frame . upon integration over @xmath21 ,
the differential decay width is proportional to : @xmath42 the @xmath32 form factor , which appears in the second term of eq .
( [ amp1 ] ) , is helicity suppressed by a factor of @xmath43
. the mass - suppressed terms are negligible for @xmath1 but can be measured in @xmath2 .
the @xmath32 form factor can only be effectively measured in @xmath2 decays at low @xmath14 where the mass suppression effects are least severe .
the semimuonic to semielectric branching ratio is sensitive to the magnitude of the @xmath32 form factor .
we study the form factor of the non - resonant , spin zero , @xmath7-wave component to @xmath5 first described in ref .
@xcite . according to the model of ref .
@xcite , 2.4% of the decays in the mass range @xmath44 are due to this @xmath7-wave component@xcite , where @xmath23 is the @xmath15 mass . the underlined term in eq .
( [ amp1 ] ) represents the interference between the @xmath7-wave , @xmath15 amplitude and the @xmath10 amplitude , represented as a simplified , breit - wigner function of the form : @xmath45 where @xmath38 is the kaon momentum in the @xmath15 rest frame , and @xmath46 is the value of @xmath38 when the @xmath15 mass is equal to the @xmath10 mass - wave breit - wigner form with a width proportional to the cube of the kaon momentum in the kaon - pion rest frame .
our breit - wigner intensity is proportional to @xmath47 as expected for a @xmath48-wave breit - wigner resonance .
two powers of @xmath38 come explicitly from the @xmath38 in the numerator of the amplitude and one power arises from the 4-body phase space as shown in eq .
( [ gamma ] ) .
we are not including additional , small corrections such as the blatt - weisskopf barrier penetration factor . ] .
the @xmath7-wave form factor is denoted as @xmath49 in the underlined piece of eq .
( [ amp1 ] ) . following ref .
@xcite we model the @xmath7-wave contribution as an amplitude with a phase ( @xmath50 ) and modulus ( @xmath51 ) that are independent of @xmath23 .
we have dropped the second - order , @xmath7-wave intensity contribution ( @xmath52 ) in eq .
( [ amp1 ] ) since @xmath53 .
the @xmath21 integration significantly simplifies the intensity by eliminating all interference terms between different helicity states of the virtual @xmath54 with relatively little loss in form factor information .
the four helicity basis form factors for the @xmath5 component are generally written @xcite as linear combinations of a vector ( @xmath55 ) and three axial - vector ( @xmath56 ) form factors according to @xmath57 \,,\label{helicity } \\
h_t({\ensuremath{q^2 } } ) & = & { m_d k\over m_{k\pi}\sqrt{{\ensuremath{q^2 } } } } \left [ ( m_d+m_{k\pi})a_1({\ensuremath{q^2 } } ) -{(m^2_d -m^2_{k\pi}+{\ensuremath{q^2 } } ) \over m_d+m_{k\pi}}a_2({\ensuremath{q^2 } } ) \right . \nonumber\\ & & \mbox { } \hspace{2 cm } \left .
+ { 2{\ensuremath{q^2}}\over m_d+m_{k\pi}}a_3({\ensuremath{q^2 } } ) \right ] \,,\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath58 is the mass of the @xmath37 and @xmath36 is the momentum of the @xmath15 system in the rest frame of the @xmath37 . in the spectroscopic pole dominance ( spd ) model @xcite ,
these axial and vector form factors are given by @xmath59 where @xmath60 and @xmath61 .
the spd model allows one to parameterize the @xmath30 , @xmath29 , @xmath31 , and @xmath32 form factors using just three parameters , which are ratios of form factors taken at @xmath62 : @xmath63 and @xmath64 .
there are accurate measurements @xcite of @xmath65 and @xmath66 , but very little is known about @xmath67 , which is an important motivation for this work . in this paper
, we use a _ projective weighting _
technique @xcite to disentangle and directly measure the @xmath14 dependence of these helicity basis form factors free from parameterization .
we provide information on the six form factor products @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath33 , @xmath70 and @xmath71 in bins of @xmath14 by projecting out the associated angular factors given by eq .
( [ amp1 ] ) .
we next describe some of the experimental and analysis details used for these measurements .
the cleo - c detector @xcite consists of a six - layer inner stereo - wire drift chamber , a 47-layer central drift chamber , a ring - imaging cerenkov detector ( rich ) , and a cesium iodide electromagnetic calorimeter inside a superconducting solenoidal magnet providing a 1.0 t magnetic field .
the tracking chambers and the electromagnetic calorimeter cover 93% of the full solid angle .
the solid angle coverage for the rich detector is 80% of @xmath72 .
identification of the charged pions and kaons is based on measurements of specific ionization ( @xmath73 ) in the main drift chamber and rich information .
electrons are identified using the ratio of the energy deposited in the electromagnetic calorimeter to the measured track momentum ( @xmath74 ) as well as @xmath73 and rich information .
although there is a muon detector in cleo , it was optimized for b - meson semileptonic decay , and is ineffectual for charm semileptonic decay since a muon from charm particle decay will typically range out in the first layer of iron in the muon shield . in this paper
, we use 818 pb@xmath75 of data taken at the @xmath3 center - of - mass energy with the cleo - c detector at the cornell electron storage ring ( cesr ) @xmath76 collider , which corresponds to a ( produced ) sample of 1.8 million @xmath77 pair events @xcite .
we select the events containing a @xmath19 decaying into one of the following six decay modes : @xmath78 , @xmath79 , @xmath80 , @xmath81 , @xmath82 , and @xmath83 along with a 4-body semileptonic candidate . to avoid complications due to having two or more @xmath12 decay candidates in the event ,
we select the decay candidate with the smallest @xmath84 value where @xmath85 is the beam - constrained mass .
the beam - constrained mass @xmath85 is defined as @xmath86 where @xmath87 is the beam energy and @xmath88 is the d - tag momentum .
more details on selecting the tagging @xmath19 candidates as well as identifying @xmath89 and @xmath90 candidates are described in ref .
@xcite .
we used extensive monte carlo ( mc ) studies to design efficient , background - suppressing selections .
the @xmath12 reconstruction starts by requiring three well - measured tracks not associated with the tagging @xmath19 decay . in order to select semileptonic decays ,
we require a minimal missing momentum and energy of 50 mev/@xmath91 and 50 mev , respectively . both the minimal missing momentum and energy are calculated using the center - of - mass momentum and energy . in order to reduce backgrounds from charm
decays with missing @xmath89
s , we require an unassociated shower energy of less than 250 mev .
the unassociated shower energy refers to electromagnetic showers , which are statistically separated from all measured , charged tracks .
charged kaons and pions are required to have momenta of at least 50 mev/@xmath91 and are identified using @xmath73 and rich information .
we require that the pion deposits a shower energy , which is inconsistent with the electron hypothesis .
electron candidates are required to have momenta of at least 200 mev/@xmath91 , lie in the good shower containment region ( @xmath92 ) , and pass a requirement on a likelihood variable that combines @xmath74 , @xmath73 , and rich information .
our simulations indicate that contamination of our kaon sample due to pions is less than 0.06% using this likelihood variable .
the only final state particle not detected is the neutrino in the semileptonic decay .
the neutrino four - momentum vector can be reconstructed from the missing energy and momentum in the event .
the @xmath14 resolution , predicted by our monte carlo simulation , is roughly gaussian with an r.m.s .
width of 0.02 @xmath93 , which is negligible on the scale that we will bin our data . for @xmath2 candidates , it is difficult to distinguish the @xmath94 track from the @xmath95 track . because @xmath2 decay is strongly dominated by @xmath96 , which is a relatively narrow resonance , we select the positive track with the smallest @xmath97 as the pion and the other track as the muon .
our monte carlo studies concluded that this @xmath10 arbitration approach was correct 84% of the time and works better than pion - muon discrimination based on the electromagnetic calorimeter response .
we apply a variety of additional requirements to suppress backgrounds in @xmath2 candidates .
we require that the muon is inconsistent with the electron hypothesis according to the electron likelihood variable .
we require that missing momentum ( @xmath98 ) lies within 20 mev of the missing energy ( @xmath99 ) . for @xmath2 candidates
, we also require @xmath100 .
the @xmath101 distributions for muon and @xmath100 .
the @xmath101 distributions for muon and electron candidates are illustrated in fig .
[ mmsq ] . in order to suppress cross - feed from @xmath1 decay to our @xmath2 sample
, we construct the squared invariant mass of the lepton candidate , @xmath102 , where @xmath103 is the reconstructed energy of the @xmath19 produced against the @xmath104 candidate and @xmath105 , @xmath106 , @xmath107 are the reconstructed kaon energy , pion energy , and lepton momentum .
we require @xmath108 to eliminate both @xmath1 cross - feed and @xmath109 decays . in order to suppress backgrounds to @xmath2 from @xmath110
decays with an accompanying bremsstrahlung photon , we require that cosine of the minimum angle between three charged tracks and the missing momentum direction be less than 0.90 . this requirement is illustrated in fig .
[ cone ] .
we obtain 11801 @xmath12 candidates . the @xmath23 distribution for these @xmath12 candidates is shown in fig . [ signal ] .
finally , we require @xmath111 and select 10865 events .
distributions for events satisfying our _ nominal _ @xmath12 selection requirements apart from the @xmath101 requirement .
( a ) shows the @xmath101 distribution for @xmath2 candidates , while ( b ) shows the @xmath101 distribution for @xmath1 candidates . for @xmath2 candidates
, we require that @xmath101 lies between the vertical lines .
this cut is placed asymmetrically on our semimuonic sample to suppress cross - feed from @xmath1 . in each plot , the solid histogram shows the signal plus background distribution predicted by our monte carlo simulation , while the dashed histogram shows the predicted background component .
[ mmsq],width=268 ] two types of monte carlo simulations are used throughout this analysis .
the _ generic _
monte carlo simulation is a large charm monte carlo sample consisting of generic @xmath112 decays , which is primarily used in this analysis to simulate the properties of backgrounds to our @xmath12 signal states .
the _ generic _
monte carlo events are generated by evtgen @xcite and the detector is simulated using a geant - based @xcite program .
in much of the form - factor work , we use an spd monte carlo simulation based on the spd model described in sec .
[ intro ] and summarized by eqs .
( [ amp1][spdpole ] ) .
we use the spd parameters of ref .
@xcite , @xmath65 = 1.504 , @xmath66 = 0.875 , and we set @xmath67=0 . the background shapes in fig .
[ signal ] are obtained using _
monte carlo simulations .
our simulation predicts a 6.5 % background for our @xmath2 sample with 4% due to misidentified @xmath1 cross - feed events and the rest due to various charm decays .
the simulation also predicts a 1% background to our @xmath1 sample with 0.03 % due to @xmath2 cross - feed .
distribution for @xmath2 candidates , while ( b ) shows the @xmath113 distribution for @xmath1 candidates .
we remove all combinations to the right of the vertical line , which removes the major part of remaining @xmath114 background for the semimuonic sample . in each plot
, the solid histogram shows the signal plus background distribution predicted by our monte carlo simulation , while the dashed histogram shows the predicted background component .
[ cone],width=268 ] distributions for events satisfying our nominal @xmath12 selection requirements .
( a ) shows the @xmath23 distribution for @xmath2 candidates , while ( b ) shows the @xmath23 distribution for @xmath1 candidates . over the full displayed mass range ,
there are 11801 ( 6227 semielectric and 5574 semimuonic ) events satisfying our nominal selection . for this analysis
, we use a restricted mass range from 0.8
1.0 @xmath115 , which is the region between the vertical lines . in each plot
, the solid histogram shows the signal plus background distribution predicted by our monte carlo simulation , while the dashed histogram shows the predicted background component . in this restricted region
, there are 10865 ( 5658 semielectric and 5207 semimuonic ) events .
the inserted figures are on a finer scale to better show the estimated background contributions .
[ signal],width=268 ]
we have measured both the semimuonic to semielectric relative branching ratio and the @xmath4 and @xmath5 absolute branching fractions , which we will denote as @xmath116 and @xmath117 , respectively .
the @xmath118 relative branching ratio is expected to be less than 1 due to the reduced phase space available to the semimuonic decay relative to the semielectric decay .
the mass - suppressed terms in eq .
( [ amp1 ] ) will change the relative branching ratio compared to the phase space ratio . in the context of the spd model , eq .
( [ spdpole ] ) , the relative branching fraction will depend on @xmath119 , which controls the strength of the @xmath32 form factor and is essentially unknown .
it is expected that @xmath118 will increase with increasing values of @xmath67 . in order to obtain the semimuonic to semielectric branching ratio
, we write the observed @xmath120 and @xmath121 yields as @xmath122 where @xmath123 are the observed yields , @xmath124 are non - semileptonic backgrounds , and @xmath125 give the number of produced semileptonic decays in our data sample . the cross - feed matrix , which multiplies the @xmath126 and @xmath127 signal vector , is constructed from @xmath128 , which are the @xmath129 and @xmath130 detection efficiencies , and @xmath131 , which are the cross - feed efficiencies .
for example , @xmath132 is the efficiency for reconstructing a @xmath129 event as a @xmath130 candidate .
the @xmath123 yields are obtained by counting the number of semimuonic and semielectric events in our mass range @xmath133 .
the relative branching ratio is given by @xmath134 .
the vector @xmath135 represents parameters that the efficiencies and cross - feeds can depend on such as the spd parameters : @xmath65 , @xmath66 , and @xmath67 and the @xmath7-wave amplitude and phase .
the detection efficiencies , @xmath136 , and the cross - feed efficiencies , @xmath137 , were obtained using our monte carlo simulations .
we will refer to the use of eq .
( [ eq : brratio - yield ] ) to obtain the relative branching ratio , @xmath118 , as the _ cross - feed method_. we used the double - tag technique , described in ref .
@xcite , to measure the @xmath138 and @xmath139 absolute semileptonic branching fractions ( @xmath140 ) .
we define single tag ( st ) events as events where the @xmath141 was fully reconstructed against one of our six tag modes without any requirement on the recoil @xmath142 .
we estimate the number of st events by fitting the @xmath143 distributions , shown in fig .
[ fig : abs - st - data ] , using a binned maximum likelihood fit . here
@xmath144 , where @xmath145 is the energy of the d - tag candidate .
the total number of reconstructed @xmath141 st events is then @xmath146 where @xmath147 is the number of st reconstructed events in the @xmath148-th mode , @xmath149 is the number of produced @xmath150 events in our data sample , @xmath151 is the st detection efficiency , and @xmath152 is the tag mode branching fraction . for double tag ( dt ) events ,
we reconstruct @xmath153 into one of our six tagging modes , and require the presence of either a @xmath120 or @xmath121 candidate .
the dt yields are then @xmath154 and @xmath155 respectively . the yields @xmath156 and @xmath157 represent the number of reconstructed dt events in semielectric and semimuonic decay modes after the background subtraction .
the efficiencies @xmath158 and @xmath159 are the dt event detection efficiencies for the semielectric and semimuonic decay modes .
the cross - feed efficiency @xmath160 describes how often a semimuonic decay is reconstructed as a semielectric candidate , while the cross - feed efficiency @xmath161 describes how often a semielectric decay is reconstructed as semimuonic candidate .
the variables @xmath162 , @xmath163 are the respective @xmath139 and @xmath138 branching fractions , which we wish to measure . dividing eq .
( [ eq : dt - el ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : dt - mu ] ) by eq .
( [ eq : st ] ) , we have : @xmath164 equation ( [ eq : brratio - yield - abs ] ) shows how the branching fractions of @xmath165 and @xmath166 semileptonic modes depend on the ratio of the dt and the st yields , the detection efficiencies , and the cross - feed efficiencies .
figures [ fig : abs - dt - data - el ] and [ fig : abs - dt - data - mu ] shows the @xmath143 distributions for our double tag sample . for both semileptonic decay modes ,
about half of our sample comes from the @xmath167 d - tag mode .
the st yields for this mode are nearly background free .
the cross - feed fraction for the @xmath168 semileptonic mode is less than 0.02% , while , for the @xmath169 semileptonic mode , the cross - feed fraction is 3.7% .
the background level is about 2.5 times smaller for the @xmath168 mode than for the @xmath169 mode .
the semielectric mode is nearly background free because of the effectiveness of the electromagnetic calorimeter , while our semimuonic mode uses a variety of less effective kinematic cuts to suppress background and cross - feed .
our absolute branching fraction results are summarized by tables [ tab - abs - br - cond ] and [ tab - abs - br - comparison ] .
table [ tab - abs - br - cond ] gives a `` conditional '' absolute branching fraction based only on @xmath12 decays into the mass range @xmath170 .
this mass range is required for events entering into figs .
[ fig : abs - dt - data - el ] and [ fig : abs - dt - data - mu ] .
we find that the total systematic error for the semielectric and semimuonic absolute branching fractions , presented in table i , are comparable .
the dominant systematic error for the semielectric decay is due to the 1% uncertainty in the efficiency our electron identification requirements , while the dominant systematic error for the semimuonic branching fraction is due to the 0.8% uncertainty in the background subtraction .
the remaining systematic error , which is 1.2% for both the semielectric and semimuonic branching fractions , includes uncertainties in the final state radiation corrections , as well as uncertainties in the tracking and particle identification efficiencies for the kaon and pion tracks .
table [ tab - abs - br - comparison ] , on the other hand , relies on models for the @xmath10 line - shape to extrapolate outside of the 200 @xmath171 wide mass region where our measurements are made in order to report the conventional @xmath6 absolute branching ratios , which includes events over the entire @xmath23 spectrum .
we include an additional , clebsch - gordan factor of 1.5 in order to correct for the undetected @xmath13 decay mode assume that all of the signal events in the @xmath172 mass region , where our @xmath143 measurements made , are due to @xmath6 decay . ] .
finally , we have included an additional @xmath173 contribution to the quoted systematic error in table [ tab - abs - br - comparison ] based on the difference between the @xmath10 extrapolations made using our generic and spd models .
this @xmath173 systematic error contribution includes both distortions to the @xmath10 line shape as well as uncertainties in level of non - resonant contributions due to the @xmath7-wave amplitude .
.conditional absolute branching fractions .
these branching fractions only represent the @xmath174 spectrum from @xmath175 . [ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] [ summary ] figure [ finite ] illustrates our sensitivity to the pole masses in eq .
( [ helicity ] ) by comparing measurements of the @xmath176 form factor product to a model with spectroscopic axial and vector pole masses versus a model with infinite pole masses , implying _ constant _ axial and vector form factors .
our data favor the spectroscopic pole masses given in eq .
( [ spdpole ] ) , for the high @xmath14 bins of the @xmath177 form factor product .
the other five form factor products are consistent with either pole mass choice .
form factor shown in fig .
[ sixnormz ] overlayed with two models . ( a )
uses the same spd model shown in fig .
[ sixnormz ] while ( b ) overlays the data with a spd model where the axial and vector poles [ @xmath178 and @xmath179 in eq .
( [ amp1 ] ) ] are set to infinity .
we show the data with @xmath2 and @xmath1 combined .
the slight scale difference between the data points in the two plots is an artifact of our @xmath180 as @xmath181 normalization scheme , which is based on the two different pole mass predictions for the @xmath69 form factor product .
[ finite],height=192 ] it is of interest to search for the possible existence of additional non - resonant amplitudes of higher angular momentum .
it is fairly simple to extend eq .
( [ amp1 ] ) to account for potential @xmath8-wave or @xmath9-wave interference with the @xmath10breit - wigner amplitude .
we search specifically for a possible zero helicity @xmath8-wave or @xmath9-wave piece that interferes with the zero helicity @xmath10 contribution .
one expects that such potential @xmath182 and @xmath183 form factors would peak as @xmath184 near @xmath181 as is the case for the other zero helicity contributions @xmath31 and @xmath49 .
if so , the zero helicity contributions should be much larger than potential @xmath8- or @xmath9-wave @xmath185 helicity contributions .
the @xmath8-wave projectors are based on an additional interference term of the form @xmath186 to search for the presence of zero helicity @xmath8-wave amplitude we use the technique of ref .
@xcite to construct a projector which is orthogonal to the projectors for each of the six terms in eq .
( [ amp1 ] ) .
the @xmath9-wave weights are based on an additional interference term of the form @xmath187 averaging over the breit - wigner intensity , the interference should be proportional to @xmath188 and will disappear when the non - resonant amplitude is orthogonal to the average , accepted @xmath10 amplitude .
[ bestfd ] shows the @xmath189 form factor products obtained in the data using projective weights generated assuming a phase of zero .
the projective weights are normalized so that @xmath190 in the limit @xmath191 if the putative @xmath8,@xmath9 -wave amplitude had the same strength as the @xmath7-wave amplitude relative to the @xmath10 breit - wigner amplitude . -wave form factor product ( a ) and @xmath9-wave form factor product ( b ) for an assumed phase of 0 radians relative to the @xmath10 breit - wigner amplitude .
[ bestfd],height=192 ] there is no evidence for either a @xmath8-wave or @xmath9-wave component with this phase . and
@xmath192 represent the phase of possible d and f -wave contributions relative to the phase of the @xmath10breit - wigner amplitude .
they are measured in radians.,height=211 ] figure [ wavelimits ] shows our amplitude and limits for sixteen phase assumptions . as illustrated by fig .
[ phase ] , our ability to measure a non - resonant amplitude can depend critically on its phase relative to the average , accepted @xmath10 phase . in order to maximize our sensitivity to the non - resonant amplitude , for each phase assumption and @xmath14 bin we made our measurement based on three @xmath23 mass regions : @xmath193 , @xmath194 , and @xmath195 , which puts the average @xmath10 reference phase at roughly @xmath196 , @xmath197 , and @xmath198 for these three mass regions , respectively .
we chose the mass region with the smallest expected error according to the monte carlo simulation . under the assumption @xmath199 ,
used in ref .
@xcite , we performed a @xmath200 fit of fig .
[ bestfd ] to the form @xmath201 over the region @xmath202 to find the amplitude and limits shown in fig .
[ wavelimits ] .
figure [ wavelimits ] shows that this `` mass selection '' method produced non - amplitude limits , which are reasonably independent of assumed phase .
if , on the other hand , one used the full @xmath203 mass range for all sixteen phase assumptions , one would get dramatically poorer limits for phase choices orthogonal to the breit - wigner amplitude phase .
it is apparent from fig .
[ wavelimits ] that we have no compelling evidence for either a @xmath8-wave , or an @xmath9-wave component .
we present a branching fraction and form factor analysis of the @xmath12 decay based on a sample of approximately 11800 @xmath1 and @xmath2 decays collected by the detector running at the @xmath3 .
we find @xmath204 and @xmath205 .
our direct measurement of the relative semimuonic to semielectric branching ratio using eq .
( [ eq : brratio - yield ] ) is @xmath206 .
we also present a non - parametric analysis of the helicity basis form factors that control the kinematics of the @xmath12 decays .
we used a projective weighting technique that allows one to determine the helicity form factor products by weighted histograms rather than likelihood based fits .
we find consistency with the spectroscopic pole dominance model for the dominant @xmath207 , @xmath177 and @xmath69 form factors .
our measurement on the @xmath33 form factor product suggests that the @xmath208 form factor falls faster than @xmath209 with increasing @xmath14 .
the form factors determined using @xmath2 decays are consistent with those determined using @xmath1 decays and are consistent with our earlier study @xcite of @xmath1 .
our measured @xmath177 form factor data are more consistent with axial and vector form factors with the expected spectroscopic pole dominance @xmath14 dependence than with constant axial and vector form factors .
our measurements of the @xmath70 and @xmath71 form factor suggests a much smaller @xmath32 form factor than expected in lattice gauge theory models @xcite . within the context of the spectroscopic pole dominance model eq .
( [ spdpole ] ) , our @xmath71 measurements are most consistent with a small @xmath32 form factor contribution implying a very negative value for @xmath119 , such as @xmath210 , which would place the predicted @xmath118 relative branching ratio close to the phase space estimate of 91% .
finally , we have searched for possible @xmath8-wave or @xmath9-wave non - resonant interference contributions to @xmath12 .
we have no statistically significant evidence for @xmath8-wave or @xmath9-wave interference , but are only able to limit these terms to roughly less than 1.0 and 1.5 times the observed @xmath7-wave interference for @xmath8-wave and @xmath9-wave respectively .
we gratefully acknowledge the effort of the cesr staff in providing us with excellent luminosity and running conditions .
d. cronin - hennessy thanks the a.p . sloan foundation .
this work was supported by the national science foundation , the u.s .
department of energy , the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada , and the u.k .
science and technology facilities council .
m. bauer , b. stech , and m. wirbel , z. phys .
c * 29 * , 637 ( 1985 ) ; m. bauer and m. wirbel , z. phys .
c * 42 * , 671 ( 1989 ) ; j.g .
korner and g.a .
schuler , z. phys .
c * 46 * , 93 ( 1990 ) ; f.j .
gilman and r.l .
singleton , phys .
d * 41 * , 142 ( 1990 ) ; d. scora and n. isgur , phys .
d * 52 * , 2783 ( 1995 ) ; b. stech , z. phys .
c * 75 * , 245 ( 1997 ) ; d. melikhov and b. stech , phys .
d * 62 * , 014006 ( 2000 ) .
bernard , a.x .
el - khadra , and a. soni , phys .
d * 45 * , 869 ( 1992 ) ; v. lubicz , g. martinelli , m.s .
mccarthy , and c.t .
sachrajda , phys .
b * 274 * , 415 ( 1992 ) ; a. abada et al .
b * 416 * , 675 ( 1994 ) ; k.c .
bowler et al .
( ukqcd collaboration ) , phys .
d * 51 * , 4905 ( 1995 ) ; t. bhattacharya and r. gupta , nucl
b ( proc . suppl . ) * 47 * , 481 ( 1996 ) ; c.r .
alton et al .
( ape collaboration ) , phys .
b * 345 * , 513 ( 1995 ) ; s. gusken , g. siegert , and k. schilling , prog .
phys . suppl . * 122 * , 129 ( 1996 ) ; a. abada et al .
( spqcdr collaboration ) , nucl .
. supp . * 119 * , 625 ( 2003 ) . c. bourrely ,
b. machet and e. de rafael , nucl . phys .
b * 189 * , 157 ( 1981 ) ; c. g. boyd , b. grinstein and r. f. lebed , phys .
lett . * 74 * , 4603 ( 1995 ) ; l. lellouch , nucl .
b * 479 * , 353 ( 1996 ) ; c. g. boyd , b. grinstein and r. f. lebed , nucl .
b * 461 * , 493 ( 1996 ) ; i. caprini and m. neubert , phys .
b * 380 * , 376 ( 1996 ) ; i. caprini , l. lellouch and m. neubert , nucl .
b * 530 * , 153 ( 1998 ) ; c. g. boyd and m. j. savage , phys .
d * 56 * , 303 ( 1997 ) ; m. fukunaga and t. onogi , phys .
d * 71 * , 034506 ( 2005 ) ; c. m. arnesen , b. grinstein , i. z. rothstein and i. w. stewart , phys .
lett . * 95 * , 071802 ( 2005 ) ; t. becher and r. j. hill , phys .
b * 633 * , 61 ( 2006 ) .
link et al .
( focus collaboration ) , phys .
b * 633 * , 183 ( 2006 ) . j.m .
link et al .
( focus collaboration ) , phys .
lett . b * 535 * , 43 ( 2002 ) .
link et al .
( focus collaboration ) , phys .
lett . b * 544 * , 89 ( 2002 ) .
j.g . korner and g.a .
schuler , z. phys .
c * 46 * , 93 ( 1990 ) ; fredrick j. gilman and robert l. singleton , jr .
rev . d * 41 * , 142 ( 1990 ) y. kubota et al .
( cleo collaboration ) , nucl .
methods a * 320 * , 66 ( 1992 ) ; m. artuso et al . , nucl .
methods a * 554 * , 147 ( 2005 ) ; d. peterson et al . ,
methods a * 478 * , 142 ( 2002 ) .
s. dobbs _ et al .
_ ( cleo collaboration ) , phys .
d * 76 * , 112001 ( 2007 ) .
lange , nucl .
methods a * 462 * , 152 ( 2001 ) .
r. brun et al . , * geant 3.21 * , cern program library long writeup w5013 , unpublished .
. hung _ et al . _
( cleo collaboration ) phys .
lett . * 95 * , 181801 ( 2005 ) . c. amsler
( particle data group ) , phys .
lett . b * 667 * , 1 ( 2008 ) .
shepherd et al .
( cleo collaboration ) , phys .
d * 74 * , ( 2006 ) 052001 . | using a large sample ( @xmath0 11800 events ) of @xmath1 and @xmath2 decays collected by the cleo - c detector running at the @xmath3 , we measure the helicity basis form factors free from the assumptions of spectroscopic pole dominance and provide new , accurate measurements of the absolute branching fractions for @xmath4 and @xmath5 decays .
we find branching fractions which are consistent with previous world averages .
our measured helicity basis form factors are consistent with the spectroscopic pole dominance predictions for the three main helicity basis form factors describing @xmath6 decay .
the ability to analyze @xmath2 allows us to make the first non - parametric measurements of the mass - suppressed form factor .
our result is inconsistent with existing lattice qcd calculations .
finally , we measure the form factor that controls non - resonant @xmath7-wave interference with the @xmath6 amplitude and search for evidence of possible additional non - resonant @xmath8- or @xmath9-wave interference with the @xmath10 . |
the theoretical treatment of the longstanding problem of turbulent flows @xcite has to relate dynamical systems theory with non - equilibrium statistical physics @xcite .
the central notion of physical turbulence theory is the concept of the energy cascade , highlighting the fact that turbulent flows are essentially transport processes of quantities like energy or enstrophy in scale .
although well - established theories due to richardson , kolmogorov , onsager , heisenberg and others ( for reviews we refer the reader to @xcite ) can capture gross features of the cascade process in a phenomenological way , the dynamical aspects are by far less understood , and usually are investigated by direct numerical simulations of the navier - stokes equations .
an exception , in some sense , are inviscid fluid flows in two dimensions . based on the work of helmholtz @xcite ,
it was kirchhoff @xcite who pointed out that the partial differential equation can be reduced to a hamiltonian system for the locations of point vortices , provided one considers initial conditions where the vorticity is a superposition of delta - distributions ( we refer the reader to the works of aref @xcite as well as the monographs @xcite ) . due to onsager @xcite ( for a discussion we refer the reader to @xcite ) a statistical treatment of point vortex dynamics is possible for equilibrium situations because of the hamiltonian character of the dynamics , provided the ergodic hypothesis holds .
extensions to non - equilibrium situations based on kinetic equations have been pursued , e.g. , by joyce and montgomery @xcite , lundgren and pointin @xcite , as well as more recently by chavanis @xcite .
the purpose of the present article is to generalize kirchhoff s point vortex model to a rotor model that exhibits the formation of large - scale vortical structures due to the formation of rotor clusters .
the existence of such a process in two - dimensional flows where a large - scale vorticity field spontaneously emerges from an initially random distribution of vortices was first predicted by kraichnan @xcite and is termed an inverse cascade .
thereby , the energy that is injected into the small scales is transfered to larger scales , whereas the enstrophy follows a direct cascade from large to small scales .
it was also kraichnan @xcite , who gave an intuitive explanation of the possible mechanism of the cascade : he considered a small - scale axisymmetric vortical structure that is exposed to a large - scale strain field .
eventually , the vortex is elongated along the stretching direction of the strain , i.e. to a first approximation drawn out into an elliptical structure .
this thinning mechanism induces relative motions between vortices that have been deformed under their mutual strain , which leads to a decrease of the kinetic energy of the small - scale motion and consequently to an energy transfer upscale .
more recently , it has been pointed out numerically and experimentally by chen et al .
@xcite that the effect of vortex thinning is indeed an important feature of the inverse cascade .
an appropriate vortex model for the inverse cascade therefore has to provide a mechanism similar to that identified in @xcite .
although , several point vortex models have been known for a long time to form large - scale vortical structures from an initially random distribution of point vortices due to the events of vortex merging @xcite or special forcing mechanisms @xcite , an explicit inclusion of the concept of vortex thinning never has been taken into account . in our vortex model ,
the small - scale vortical structure is represented by a rotor consisting of two point vortices with equal circulation that are glued together by a nonelastic bond .
the main observation now is that the two co - rotating point vortices mimic a far - field that is similar to an elliptical vortex , which makes the rotor sensitive to a large - scale strain .
the model is motivated by a representation of the vorticity field as a superposition of vortices with elliptical gaussian shapes along the lines of melander , styczek and zabusky @xcite .
the nonelastic bond in a rotor can be considered as an over - damped spring which models the influence of forcing and viscous damping . however , the main renewal in this model is not the mechanism of how the energy is injected into the system , but how the energy is transfered upscale due to the strain - induced relative motions between the rotors in the sense of vortex thinning .
the efficiency of the cascade in the rotor model is supported by the relatively fast demixing of the system as well as a kolmogorov constant of @xmath0 that is within the range of accepted values @xcite .
this paper is organized as follows : first of all , we consider a decomposition of the vorticity field into localized vortices with different shapes in section [ dec ] . in section [ ans ]
, we make an ansatz for the shapes which corresponds to an elliptical distribution of the vorticity and discuss the interaction of two vortices with like - signed circulation within the point vortex model , the gaussian vortex model and the elliptical model .
it will explicitly be shown that the former two models do not lead to a relative motion between the vortices , and that the thinning mechanism is only taken into account by the elliptical model . a suitable forcing mechanism for the vorticity equation
is introduced in section [ forcing ] and then used within our generalized vortex model , presented in section [ modelsection ] .
as it is known from basic fluid dynamics , the vorticity @xmath1 only possesses one component in two - dimensional flows and obeys the evolution equation @xmath2 here , the advecting velocity field is determined by biot - savart s law according to @xmath3 we consider the two - dimensional vorticity equation in fourier space derived from equation ( [ omega ] ) in the appendix [ fourier - vorticity ] according to @xmath4 with @xmath5 $ ] .
+ in the following the vorticity is decomposed into vortices @xmath6 with the circulation @xmath7 that are centered at @xmath8 and that possess the shapes @xmath9 , namely @xmath10 our ansatz thus reads @xmath11 for @xmath12 , we recover the vorticity field @xmath13 of point vortices @xmath14 that are located at the positions @xmath8 and that are a solution of the ideal vorticity equation ( @xmath15 ) , which conserves the vorticity along a lagrangian trajectory . inserting the vorticity field from ( [ point ] ) into biot - savart s law ( [ biot ] )
immediately yields the evolution equation for the point vortices @xmath16 we now insert our ansatz ( [ ansatz ] ) into the vorticity equation and obtain @xmath17\\ \nonumber & = & i{\bf k } \cdot \sum_{j , l}\gamma_j \gamma_l \int \textrm{d}{\bf k } ' { \bf u}({\bf k } ' ) e^{i({\bf k}-{\bf k}')\cdot { \bf x_j}+i{\bf k}'\cdot { \bf x}_l } \\ & ~&\times e^{w _ j({\bf k}-{\bf k}',t)+w_l({\bf k}',t)}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the left - hand side of this equation contains the sweeping dynamic of the vortices encoded in the temporal change of @xmath8 as well as the temporal change of the shapes @xmath9 due to shearing and vorticity . in the inviscid case ,
the entire dynamic of the @xmath18-th vortex is determined by the nonlinearity on the right hand side of equation ( [ evom ] ) which couples the different fourier modes of the vortices @xmath19 as well as the self - interaction term from @xmath20 in a rather complicated manner .
nevertheless , a separation of the effects becomes possible under the assumption that the overlap of the different vortex structures is negligible , which is valid for widely separated vortices . to this end , we single out the terms in the summations over @xmath18 and get @xmath21 the sweeping dynamic can now be defined via the terms in the evolution equation ( [ evom_neu ] ) which are proportional to @xmath22 .
this immediately yields the evolution equations for the center of the vortices @xmath23 where we have defined the velocity kernels @xmath24 inserting the evolution equation of the vortex centers back into yields the evolution equations for the shapes @xmath25 } e^{w_i(-{\bf k}',t)+w_l({\bf k}',t ) } \nonumber \\ & & \times \left [ e^{w_i({\bf k}-{\bf k}',t)-w_i(-{\bf k}',t)-w_i({\bf k},t)}-1\right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] here the sum includes also the self - interaction term with @xmath20 .
the system of equations ( [ x_j ] ) and ( [ shape ] ) is the extension of the set of evolution equations for the @xmath26-point vortices ( [ point ] ) and takes into account possible changes of the shapes @xmath9 of each vortex .
it is important to stress that up to now we did not impose any restrictions on the shapes @xmath27 .
the vorticity of an elliptical vortex with major and minor semi - axes @xmath28 and @xmath29 can be written according to @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the symmetric matrix of the dyadic products of the semi axes .
a rotation of the coordinate system then turns ( [ elli ] ) into @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the is the ratio of the major to the minor semi axes .
the vorticity in fourier space thus reads @xmath34 which again corresponds to an elliptical distribution of the vorticity .
an elliptical representation of the shapes can thus be obtained via the approximation @xmath35 with the symmetric matrix @xmath36 . in approximating the last term on the right - hand side of equation ( [ shape ] ) by @xmath37\end{aligned}\ ] ] we are able to derive an evolution equation for the matrix @xmath36 , namely @xmath38\\ \nonumber & ~&+ \sum_{l \ne j } \gamma_l [ s_{jl}({\bf x}_j-{\bf x}_l ) c_j+c_j s_{jl}({\bf x}_j-{\bf x}_l)^t ] % \sum_l \gamma_l [ \nabla { \bf u}_{il}({\bf x}_i-{\bf x}_l ) % c_i+c_i % \nabla { \bf u}_{il}({\bf x}_i-{\bf x}_l)]\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , we explicitly have introduced the matrix @xmath39 $ ] and have singled out the term with @xmath20 . the velocity field is now determined from eq .
( [ u ] ) up to the first order in @xmath40 valid for widely separated vortices @xmath41 \frac{{\bf r}}{2\pi|{\bf r}|^2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the evolution equation for the vortex centers then reads @xmath42\nabla_{{\bf x}_j } { \bf e}_z \times \frac{{\bf x}_j-{\bf x}_l } { 4\pi|{\bf x}_j-{\bf x}_l|^2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] a similar system of equations ( [ evolc ] ) and ( [ x_i ] ) has been obtained by melander et al .
@xcite by means of a truncation of the stream function within their second - order moment model for the euler equations .
it is illustrative to consider the interaction of two vortices @xmath43 and @xmath44 at the positions @xmath45 and @xmath46 that possess equal circulation @xmath47 in the realm of the different vortex models considered above , namely the point vortex model , the gaussian shape model , and the elliptical gaussian shape model .
+ + _ i. ) point vortex model : _ + for the case where @xmath48 we recover the evolution equations of two point vortices @xmath49 where we made use of @xmath50 with the inverse laplacian @xmath51 .
+ the evolution equation for the relative coordinate @xmath52 then reads @xmath53 or @xmath54 which is a circular motion of the point vortices around their center @xmath55 with the angular velocity @xmath56 .
gaussian shapes : _ + let us consider the case of gaussian shapes @xmath57 and @xmath58 . the symmetry of the problem imposes that @xmath59 , and we arrive at the following evolution equations for the centers @xmath60 in making use of @xmath61 which is the velocity profile of a lamb - oseen vortex , the evolution equation for the relative coordinate reads @xmath62 the evolution equation for the shapes @xmath63 has to be evaluated in a similar fashion from eq .
( [ evolc ] ) , but for now we invoke the approximation @xmath64 where we have neglected the interaction - terms in ( [ evolc ] .
this yields the evolution equations for two lamb - oseen vortices @xmath65 in comparison to the angular velocity of the point vortex pair from above , the angular velocity of the gaussian vortex pair is thus slowed down by viscosity .
however , if we observe such two vortices in real flows , we would see a deformation of the two vortices due to their mutual strain .
this deformation in turn , leads to an attractive motion of the vortex centers and ultimately to a merging process of the two vortices . at this point
, it is important to notice that a direct consequence of an axisymmetric vorticity profile is that @xmath66 , which means that no relative motion is induced .
furthermore , in this context we want to mention that a recent investigation of the two - point vorticity statistic in two - dimensional turbulence within a gaussian approximation revealed the absence of an energy flux from smaller scales to larger scales @xcite .
the emergence of deformable structures that induce such relative motions in the context of vortex thinning can thus be considered as an important feature of the inverse cascade .
+ + _ iii . ) elliptical shapes : _
+ as we have discussed in _ ii . ) _ , the mutual interaction of gaussian vortices in real flows leads to deformations and subsequently attractive motions of the vortex centers .
such deformations can be considered in a first approximation as elliptical deformations .
+ therefore , the interaction of two elliptical vortices should for the first time lead to non - vanishing relative motions .
+ the evolution equation for two elliptically shaped vortices read @xmath67 { \bf k}'}\\ \dot { \bf x}_2&= & \gamma \int \textrm{d}{\bf k } ' { \bf u}({\bf k } ' ) e^{-i { \bf k } ' \cdot ( { \bf x}_2-{\bf x}_1 ) } e^{-\frac{1}{2 } { \bf k } ' [ c_1+c_2 ] { \bf k}'}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for widely separated vortices the evolution equation for the relative coordinate thus reads @xmath68\nabla_{{\bf r } } \right ) { \bf e}_z \times \frac{{\bf r } } { r^2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which can lead to contributions to the relative motion @xmath69 , provided that the matrices @xmath70 and @xmath71 do not reduce to diagonal matrices as in the case of gaussian shapes . whether the motion is attractive or repulsive , is to a far extend determined by the alignment angle @xmath72 between @xmath73 and the major semi axis @xmath28 of the vortices , which is explicitly derived for the interaction of two rotors in section [ inter ] , for instance in eq .
( [ r_i ] ) .
as it can be seen from eq .
( [ shape ] ) , the viscous contributions causes the broadening of the shape of a vortex . since this effect is more pronounced for smaller vortex structures , thus larger values of @xmath74 in ( [ evolc ] ) , an appropriate forcing mechanism has to counteract this effect and provide an energy input at small scales . the forcing mechanism we want to introduce ,
consists in forcing the semi axes of each elliptical vortex and thus the whole shape of this vortex back to a fixed shape @xmath75 .
it will be seen in section [ modelsection ] that the influence of this kind of forcing makes the two like - signed point vortices of our rotor model to behave as if they were connected by an over - damped spring .
the described forcing mechanism can now be introduced in the following way : @xmath76 \nonumber \\ \label{modelg3 } & + & \sum_l \gamma_l [ s_{il}({\bf x}_i-{\bf x}_l ) c_i+c_i s_{il}({\bf x}_i-{\bf x}_l)^t]\end{aligned}\ ] ] such type of forcing may be obtained from the vorticity equation ( [ vorticity ] ) by just adding a linear damping term , @xmath77 as well as the forcing term @xmath78 , @xmath79 \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the centers @xmath80 as well as the shapes @xmath81 are close to the centers and the shapes of the elliptical vortices . the first contribution in eq .
( [ force ] ) leads to a modulation of the circulation , the second term describes a shift of the rotor center and the third one corresponds to a modification of the width of the gaussian vortex shape that forces the elliptical vortex back to a certain shape @xmath75 .
the stretching of the semi axes of the elliptical vortex due to viscous broadening represented by the first term on the right - hand side in eq .
[ modelg3 ] is thus counteracted by the second term trying to contract the shape of the vortex back to @xmath75 .
a striking analogy to this forcing mechanism can be found in the explanation of the magneto - rotational instability @xcite .
thereby , two elements of an electrically conduct- ing fluid that undergo a rotation around a fixed center are supposed to be connected by an elastic spring repre- senting the magnetic field . as a consequence
the angular momentum of the system is not a conserved quantity anymore and the fluid motion becomes unstable .
although , the introduced forcing mechanism is an ad - hoc forcing , it emerges in a physically plausible way from the basic equations of the elliptical model [ evolc ] and [ x_i ] .
furthermore , it should be mentioned that the system of equations ( [ modelg1 ] ) can be obtained from the instanton equations of two - dimensional turbulence by means of a variational ansatz with gaussian elliptical vortices @xcite .
as we have seen in section [ models ] about the interaction between two point vortices with equal circulation compared to the interaction between two elliptical vortices with equal circulation , the former model fails to describe a relative motion @xmath82 in the direction of @xmath73 . the thinning mechanism mentioned in @xcite
is thus clearly neither captured by onsager s point vortex model nor by a gaussian distribution of the vorticity , in analogy to @xcite .
our vortex model is based on the observation that the point vortex couple considered in section [ models ] under _
i. ) _ generates a far field that is similar to that of one elliptical vortex with circulation @xmath83 .
we therefore consider point vortex couples with equal circulation @xmath84 at the positions @xmath85 and @xmath86 as indicated in fig .
[ vector ] .
the center of this object that we want to term a rotor is then given by @xmath87 . in order to model a forcing and viscous damping mechanism similar to that mentioned in section [ forcing ] , the two point vortices in a rotor are supposed to be glued together by an inelastic spring , such that each rotor possesses an additional degree of freedom and that the size of a single rotor relaxes with relaxation time @xmath88 to @xmath89 .
our model then reads @xmath90 \nonumber \\
\dot { \bf y}_i & = & - \frac{\gamma}{2 } ( d_0-|{\bf y}_i-{\bf x}_i| ) { \bf e}_i + \gamma_i { \bf u}({\bf
y}_i-{\bf x}_i ) \nonumber \\ & + & \sum_j \gamma_j [ { \bf u}({\bf y}_i-{\bf y}_j)+ { \bf u}({\bf y}_i-{\bf x}_j)]\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have defined the unit vector @xmath91 and the velocity field @xmath92 is the velocity field of a point vortex centered at the origin , @xmath93 .
the first two terms on the right - hand side of equation ( [ model ] ) describe the interaction within one rotor , whereas the last two terms describe the interaction with the other rotors . for vortices moving inside a closed regime ,
the velocity field has to be changed based on the introduction of mirror vortices @xcite .
it is important to stress that the above system is not a hamiltonian system anymore due to the inelastic coupling which mimics an energy input to the system on a scale @xmath89 .
furthermore , by the additional degree of freedom the rotor is sensitive with respect to a shear velocity field which can be seen from the multipole expansion of the relative coordinate @xmath94 with respect to the leading terms in @xmath95 , derived in the appendix [ app ] @xmath96 the influence of the forcing can be seen from the first term : if a rotor is subjected to shear , the spring between the point vortices in a rotor pulls back and the rotor relaxes to the size @xmath89 . the shear velocity in the last term is thereby generated by the other rotors .
+ in a similar way , the multipole expansion of the center coordinate of the rotor in appendix [ app ] leads to the evolution equation @xmath97 { \bf u}({\bf r}_{ij})\ ] ] the evolution equation is identical to equation ( [ x_i ] ) , provided that the matrix @xmath98 can be written as @xmath99 , which corresponds to an infinitely thin elliptical vortex oriented in @xmath100-direction .
the relative distance @xmath100 can thus be considered as an elliptical deformation of the velocity field that depends on the shear velocity field induced by the remaining vortices and the effect of the overdamped spring .
furthermore , we again want to emphasize that the last term in eq .
( [ locr ] ) induces relative motions between the rotors as we have seen in section [ models ] .
the usual point vortex dynamics solely represented by the first term on the right hand side of equation ( [ locr ] ) is thus extended to a dynamical system that is sensitive to the effect of vortex thinning .
we have numerically solved the dynamical system ( [ model ] ) in a square periodic domain @xmath101 .
the temporal evolution of 200 rotors with an equal number of positive and negative circulations starting from a random initial condition exhibits the formation of a large scale vortical structure via the formation of rotor - clusters .
a typical time series is exhibited in fig .
[ unequal ] , for the parameter values ( @xmath102 , @xmath103 , @xmath104 , @xmath105 , @xmath101 ) .
the boxes have been continued periodically , with up to 5 layers of neighboring boxes , which guarantees a sufficient degree of homogeneity .
the temporal evolution of the system can be quantified by the introduction of a characteristic time scale of the system which is given as the period that a rotor possesses at a fixed distance @xmath89 and is in the following termed as one rotor turnover time @xmath106 , which follows from equation ( [ phi ] ) .
1= as it can be seen from fig .
[ unequal ] , the clustering of like - signed rotors already occurs within the first 100 rotor turnover times , which means that the separation of the rotors takes place on a relatively short time - scale .
the temporal evolution of 200 rotors with identical circulations starting from random initial positions of the rotors , is exhibited in fig .
[ lattice ] .
a fluctuating lattice of rotor clusters appears and after approximately 1500 rotor turnover times , the system forms a monopole which attracts the remaining rotors .
we have calculated the kinetic energy spectra of the rotor system with @xmath107 at different times in fig .
[ spec1 ] . starting from 20 different initial configurations of the rotors
, we let the systems evolve in time and performed the ensemble average at a specific time @xmath108 . thereby
, the spectrum is calculated from the velocity field in eq .
( [ biot ] ) that has been interpolated on a grid and then transformed into fourier space .
initially , the rotors possess a clear point vortex spectrum following a power law @xmath109 . only at high values of @xmath110 deviations due to the singular structure of the vorticity and corresponding discontinuities in the velocity field manifest themselves in an increase of @xmath111 .
this effect can be observed in the following spectra , too .
however , after a few ( @xmath112 ) rotor turnover times , as the rotor clustering sets in , a more universal energy spectrum can be observed . due to an energy flux from smaller to larger scales ,
the spectra begin to steepen for smaller @xmath110-values , revealing a spectrum that is close to the predicted @xmath113 . as it can be seen from the compensated spectra in fig .
[ spec1 ] , this slope remains constant for nearly @xmath114 and an energy flux into the large scales takes place .
this is also in agreement with the time - averaged spectral energy flux @xmath115 , depicted in fig .
[ flux ] . the inlet plot in fig .
[ flux ] corresponds to the kinetic energy transfer rate @xmath116 , which is related to @xmath115 according to @xcite @xmath117 it is obvious that energy accumulates at small @xmath110-values .
this is not surprising , since the rotor model only provides an energy input on small scales and it will be a task for the future to extend the model in order to achieve a damping at small values of @xmath110 and thus to extract energy at the integral scale .
we now turn to the determination of the kolmogorov constant of the energy spectrum from the binary rotor system ( @xmath107 ) .
the spectrum as it was predicted by kraichnan @xcite reads @xmath118 where @xmath119 is the energy dissipation rate . in the following , @xmath119
is determined from the time - dependence of the total kinetic energy that shows up to be linear in time within @xmath120% . for the sake of completeness
, we have provided the corresponding plot in fig .
[ energy ] in the appendix .
the slope of the fitted line can thus be interpreted as the rate of energy input into the system and we obtain a value of @xmath121 . in order to make an estimate for @xmath122 , we take an average of the compensated spectra in fig .
[ spec1 ] of times between @xmath123 and @xmath124 which yields @xmath125 .
the kolmogorov constant @xmath126 of the rotor system for times t between @xmath123 and @xmath127 thus lies in the range @xmath0 .
the high inaccuracy of our estimate is due to the estimation of @xmath122 .
reported values from direct numerical simulations @xcite and experiments @xcite lie within the range from 5.8 to 7.0 .
the kolmogorov constant of the rotor system thus lies on the lower end of that range . in comparison to the point vortex model of siggia and aref @xcite , who report a kolmogorov constant of @xmath128 which is twice the accepted value , the rotor model thus seems to provide an efficient mechanism for the energy transfer upscale due to the effect of vortex thinning . another important way to determine the distribution and the occuring structures in the rotor model
will be discussed in the following . in order to quantify the emergence of the rotor clusters in fig .
[ unequal ] and [ lattice ] , we make use of the radial distribution function @xmath129 which can be considered as the probability of finding a like - signed rotor at a distance @xmath73 away from a reference - rotor ( for further references see for instance @xcite ) . the radial distribution function is therefore given as @xmath130 where @xmath131 and the prime indicates that summation over @xmath132 is left out .
the averaging is performed in such a way that the number of like - signed rotors populating a concentric segment of radius @xmath133 at a given radius r is divided by its area . in the following the radial distribution function
is assumed to be isotropic , so that @xmath134 . for a disordered state one expects the radial distribution function to be equal to 1 for every @xmath135 . as the formation of the rotor clusters sets in , one should observe an increase of @xmath136 for small @xmath137 , since the probability of finding a like - signed rotor in the neighborhood of a reference - rotor increases .
the radial distribution functions for the two time series are plotted in fig .
[ radial_dis ] and one clearly observes an increase of @xmath136 at small @xmath137 . in order to get smooth curves , @xmath136 was calculated in such a way that it shows no discontinuities for @xmath138 due to a minimum distance between neighboring rotors .
the radial distribution function can thus be used as a qualitative measure for the formation of the clusters and their typical sizes .
furthermore , the radial distribution function is related to the structure factor @xmath139 in a way that @xmath140 where @xmath141 is the bessel function of order zero .
the structure factor @xmath142 can thus be calculated via the hankel transform of @xmath143 , provided that the radial distribution function is isotropic .
the structure factors for the two system are plotted in fig .
[ structure ] . for the case of the mixed system of fig . [ unequal ] , one observes an increase of @xmath142 over time . whether this increase is governed by a power law for intermediate @xmath33 has to be evaluated within further simulations of the model equations ( [ model ] ) .
furthermore , eq . ( [ structurefactor ] ) is of great importance for the investigation of the rotor model , since it relates macroscopic quantities on the left - hand side to microscopic quantites such as the radial distribution function .
it is thus a good starting point for the interpretation of the fluctuations of the rotor clusters in the realm of phase transitions .
the growth rate of the rotor clusters can be determined from the time dependence of the structure factor .
the growth of the largest structures of the system is given by @xmath144 .
in fig . [ temp ] , the temporal evolution of @xmath144 is plotted for the two systems .
the fluctuating rotor lattice below exhibits a pronounced growth rate after @xmath145 , whereas the growth rate of the mixed system above already increases for @xmath146 . for comparison , two power laws @xmath147 and @xmath148
were plotted in the figures .
the growth rate of our rotor clusters can thus be considered as relatively strong compared to typical growth rates from pattern formation , for instance compared to the growth rate of droplets in the cahn - hilliard equation where @xmath149 according to slyozov - lifshitz theory @xcite .
the fact that the rotor vortex system exhibits a pronounced inverse cascade already for moderate numbers of rotors ( 200 rotors have been used for the figures ) on a small time - scale allows us to investigate the inverse cascade using methods of nonlinear dynamics .
although , usual point vortex models such as @xcite , have been known for a long time to possess inverse energy cascades the present model incorporates the aspect of vortex thinning , due to a possible change of the ellipticity of the rotor in much the same way as identified in the experiments of chen et al @xcite .
hence , it is a minimal dynamical model containing the mechanisms of the inverse cascade . in the following
we shall discuss the origin of the formation of clusters of rotors with like - signed circulations .
in the following , we consider the configuration of two rotors with circulations @xmath84 and @xmath7 , depicted in fig . [ vector ] , which can be considered as the interaction of two infinitely - thin elliptical vortices in the same manner as _ iii . ) _ from section [ models ] .
it is straightforward to show that the center of vorticity @xmath150 is a conserved quantity .
the distance vector @xmath151 between the two rotors obeys the evolution equation @xmath152 \\ \nonumber & ~&+ \frac{1}{8}\left .
[ -2 \frac{\bf r}{|{\bf r}|^4 } { \bf r}_j^2- 4 \frac{{\bf r}_j}{|{\bf r}|^4}{\bf r}_j\cdot { \bf r}+8 \frac{{\bf r}}{|{\bf r}|^6 } ( { \bf r}_j\cdot { \bf r})^2 ] \right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] which follows from equation ( [ locr ] ) in calculating the corresponding velocity field gradients , described in the appendix [ app ] .
+ for the following it is convenient to represent the unit vectors according to @xmath153 , as well as @xmath154 , which yields @xmath155({\bf e}_i\cdot { \bf e}_r)=\frac{1}{2 } \sin(2 ( \varphi_i -\varphi_r))\ ] ] we obtain the equation for the relative distance @xmath156\end{aligned}\ ] ] the evolution equation for the relative coordinate of a rotor reads @xmath157\end{aligned}\ ] ] which follows from equation ( [ dipol1 ] ) and the calculation of the velocity field gradients , performed in the appendix [ app ] .
we have to determine the quantities @xmath158 , @xmath159 , which are determined by the evolution equations @xmath160 we can solve iteratively for small deviations of @xmath161 from @xmath89 : @xmath162 a similar treatment applies to @xmath163 . splitting the rotation into its fast ( @xmath164 ) and
slow varying parts @xmath165 , i.e. @xmath166 we obtain after a partial integration @xmath167^{-1}\\ \nonumber & ~&\times e^{2i(\tilde \varphi_i(t')-\tilde \varphi_r(t'))}(\dot{\tilde { \varphi}}_i(t')-\dot { \tilde { \varphi}}_r(t'))\\ ~\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order to proceed with the adiabatic approximation , we neglect the second term in eq .
( [ adiabatic ] ) since it contains time derivatives of the slowly varying parts of the rotations .
assuming that the damping constant @xmath168 is large compared to the rotation frequency of the rotor , we obtain @xmath169 to lowest order in @xmath170 we thus obtain @xmath171 \nonumber \\ r_j^2 & = & d_0 ^ 2\left[1 + \frac{\gamma_i}{\pi \gamma r^2 } \sin(2 ( \varphi_j-\varphi_r))\right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , the last terms on the right - hand side arise due to the change of the size of the rotors , connected with a change of the far field , induced by the mutually generated shear .
it thus mimics the mechanism of vortex thinning , identified in @xcite .
+ the relative motion of the rotors obeys the evolution equation @xmath172 \end{aligned}\ ] ] we now average the evolution equation with respect to the rotations of the vectors @xmath173 and @xmath174 taking into account that the averages @xmath175 vanish .
furthermore , the averages @xmath176 are positive . as a consequence , the relative distance behaves according to @xmath177 two rotors approach each other , except for @xmath178 .
it is important to stress that this attractive relative motion arises only if we include the irreversible effect of the strain induced stretching of the rotors .
furthermore , the symmetry breaking of @xmath179 in equation ( [ r ] ) can be considered as an important feature of the rotor model in comparison to the point vortex model , which conserves this symmetry .
we have presented a generalized point vortex model , a rotor model , exhibiting an inverse cascade based on clustering of rotors .
we have discussed how this rotor model can be derived from the vorticity equation by an expansion of the vorticity field into a set of elliptical vortices at locations @xmath180 and shapes @xmath181 .
an important point has been the inclusion of a forcing term , which prevents the elliptical far field of the rotors from diffusing away .
the added forcing term breaks the symmetry @xmath182 , @xmath183 . this symmetry breaking lies at the origin of cluster formation and the inverse cascade , as can be seen from the two - rotor interaction inducing in average a relative motion proportional to @xmath184 .
the numerical simulations of the model equations [ model ] reveal the formation of rotor clusters on a short time scale .
in addition , the calculated energy spectra and energy fluxes give strong evidence for the important role of vortex thinning during the cascade process in two - dimensional turbulence .
the presented rotor model can be investigated by applying methods from dynamical systems theory like the evaluation of finite time ljapunov exponents and ljapunov vectors .
these and further dynamical aspects are the basis for future work and will be covered in a following paper .
the model system ( [ modelg1 ] ) may also be studied as a stochastic system by considering the velocity @xmath185 to be a white noise force .
the corresponding fokker - planck equation allows one to draw analogies with quantum mechanical many body problems .
furthermore , we emphasize that a continuum version of the model equations ( [ modelg1 ] ) leads to a subgrid model exhibiting analogies with the work of eyink @xcite
. it will be a task for the future to investigate the cluster formation from a statistical point of view , based on the formulation of kinetic equations , along the lines as has been performed for fully developed turbulence @xcite , and rayleigh - bnard convection @xcite . in this respect
we hope to find a relation to the kinetic equation for the two - point vorticity statistics recently derived on the basis of the monin - lundgren - novikov hierarchy , taking conditional averages from direct numerical simulations @xcite .
is very grateful for discussions with michael wilczek and frank jenko about the organization of this paper .
sadly , rudolf friedrich ( 16th august 2012 ) unexpectedly passed away during this work .
he was as much an inspiring physicist as well as a caring father . for the decomposition of the vorticity field into a discrete set of vortices with arbitrary shapes in section [ dec ] , we have made use of the vorticity equation in fourier space ( [ vorticity ] ) .
this equation can be derived from the vorticity equation in real space ( [ omega ] ) in defining the vorticity and the velocity field in fourier space according to @xmath186 and @xmath187 the nonlinearity in eq .
( [ omega ] ) can thus be expressed in terms of the convolution between @xmath188 and @xmath189 which yields @xmath190 furthermore , the velocity field in fourier space can be calculated from biot - savart s law in eq .
( [ biot ] ) according to @xmath191 a substitution @xmath192 in the last integral yields @xmath193 where we have defined the inverse laplacian in @xmath22-space as @xmath194 . inserting the fourier space representation of @xmath195 into ( [ om ] ) yields the evolution equation ( [ vorticity ] ) used for the decomposition of the vorticity field in section [ dec ] .
in this part we calculate the multipole expansion of a rotor , defined by @xmath85 and @xmath86 in fig .
[ vector ] . to this end , we introduce relative and center coordinates , according to @xmath196 as well as the vector @xmath197 . + in using equation ( [ model ] ) , we obtain the evolution equation for the relative coordinate @xmath198 a taylor expansion of the curled bracket yields @xmath199 where we have only retained the leading terms in @xmath95 . the evolution equation for the center coordinate reads @xmath200 again , a taylor expansion yields @xmath201 ^ 2 + [ ( { \bf r}_i + { \bf r}_j ) \cdot \nabla_{{\bf r}_{ij } } ] ^2 \right \ } { \bf u } ( { \bf r}_{ij } ) \bigg ] \\
\nonumber & = & 2 \sum_j \gamma_j { \bf u } ( { \bf r}_{ij})\\ & ~&+ \frac{1}{4 } \sum_j \gamma_j [ ( { \bf r}_i \cdot \nabla_{{\bf r}_{ij}})^2 + ( { \bf r}_j \cdot \nabla_{{\bf r}_{ij}})^2 ] { \bf u } ( { \bf r}_{ij})\end{aligned}\ ] ] the gradients of the velocity fields are now calculated according to @xmath202 which is needed in equation ( [ dipol1 ] ) , and @xmath203 now , this is the counterpart of equation ( [ locr ] ) + + | we generalize kirchhoff s point vortex model of two - dimensional fluid motion to a rotor model which exhibits an inverse cascade by the formation of rotor clusters .
a rotor is composed of two vortices with like - signed circulations glued together by an overdamped spring .
the model is motivated by a treatment of the vorticity equation representing the vorticity field as a superposition of vortices with elliptic gaussian shapes of variable widths , augmented by a suitable forcing mechanism .
the rotor model opens up the way to discuss the energy transport in the inverse cascade on the basis of dynamical systems theory . |
the `` metallic - lined '' or am stars are a - type stars which have strong absorption lines of some metals such as zn , sr , zr and ba and weaker lines of other metals such as ca and/or sc relative to their spectral type as determined by the strength of the hydrogen lines @xcite .
the strong metallic lines are more typical of an f star rather than an a star .
the work of @xcite established radiative diffusion in a strong magnetic field as the likely cause of the chemical peculiarities in ap stars .
when the magnetic field is absent , diffusion leads to the am / fm stars @xcite .
the presence of magnetic fields in am stars has been investigated , but with negative results , ( e.g. @xcite ) .
a peculiarity of am stars is that their projected rotational velocities are generally much smaller than normal a stars and they are nearly always members of close binary systems
. rotational braking by tidal friction in a binary system is regarded as a possible explanation for the low rotational velocities in am stars .
slow rotation further assists the segregation of elements by diffusion .
the abundance anomalies predicted by the diffusion hypothesis are usually much larger than observed .
@xcite developed detailed models of the structure and evolution of am / fm stars using opal opacities , taking into account atomic diffusion and the effect of radiative acceleration .
these models develop a convective zone due to ionization of iron - group elements at a temperature of approximately 200,000 k. in addition to this convective zone , these stars also have a thin superficial convective zone in which h and hei are partially ionized . by assuming sufficient overshoot due to turbulence , these separate convective zones become one large convective zone .
the resulting mixing dilutes the large abundance anomalies predicted by previous model , leading to abundances which closely resemble those observed in am / fm stars .
a detailed abundance analysis of eight am stars belonging to the praesepe cluster @xcite show good agreement with the predictions of @xcite for almost all the common elements except for na and possibly s. the models of @xcite assume a certain ad - hoc parametrization of turbulent transport coefficients which are adjusted to reproduce observations .
other parameterizations of turbulence have been proposed for other types of stars . @xcite
have investigated to what extent these are consistent with the anomalies observed on am / fm stars .
they find that the precision of current abundances is insufficient to distinguish between models .
more recently , @xcite have studied the abundance anomalies of the mild am star sirius a. they find that except for b , n and na , there is good agreement with the predicted anomalies but turbulent mixing or mass loss is required .
it is not clear whether it is turbulence or mass loss which competes with diffusion to lower the abundance anomalies .
for example , @xcite find that diffusion in the presence of weak mass loss can explain the observed abundance anomalies of pre - main - sequence stars .
this is in contrast to turbulence models which do not allow for abundance anomalies to develop on the pre - main - sequence .
most of the pulsational driving in @xmath0 scuti stars is caused by the @xmath1 mechanism operating in the heii ionization zone .
diffusion tends to drain he from this zone and therefore pulsational driving may be expected to be weaker or absent in am / fm stars @xcite .
in fact , for many years it was thought that classical am / fm stars did not pulsate , though claims were made for some stars @xcite .
recently , intensive ground - based observations by super - wasp @xcite , and also from the _ kepler _ mission @xcite have shown that many am / fm stars do pulsate .
@xcite , for example , found that about 200 am / fm stars out of a total of 1600 ( 12.5 percent ) show @xmath0 sct pulsations , but with generally lower amplitudes .
they found that the pulsating am / fm stars are confined between the red and blue radial fundamental edges , in agreement with @xcite .
while there are many @xmath0 sct stars hotter than the fundamental blue edge , this does not seem to be the case for pulsating am / fm stars .
the significance of this result remains to be evaluated .
the effect of draining of he from the heii ionization zone is to reduce the width of the instability strip , the blue edge moving towards the red edge , eventually leading to the disappearance of the instability strip when he is sufficiently depleted @xcite .
@xcite has discussed the effect of diffusion on pulsations in am / fm stars using the models by @xcite .
one significant difference with earlier models is that a substantial amount of he remains in the heii ionization zone .
the blue edge of the instability strip for am / fm stars is sensitive to the magnitude of the abundance variations and is thus indicative of the depth of mixing by turbulence .
@xcite predict that pulsating am / fm stars should lie in a confined region of the hr diagram close to the red edge of the @xmath0 sct instability strip .
however , @xcite show that there is no relationship between the predicted am / fm instability strip and the actual location of these stars in the hr diagram .
a particularly interesting result of the pulsation analysis of @xcite is the prediction of long - period g modes in a - type stars .
as the star evolves , the driving regions shift deeper into the star and the g modes become gradually more and more excited .
whereas p modes are stabilized through diffusion , g modes tend to be excited as a result of that process .
it appears that diffusion may act to enhance driving of long - period g modes due to a significant increase in opacity due to iron - group elements .
this may have a bearing on the fact that nearly all a - type stars observed by _
kepler _ have unexplained low - frequencies @xcite .
when dealing with objects with non - standard chemical composition , such as am stars , it is crucial that the opacities are correctly calculated . this question has been investigated by several authors in recent years .
these studies show that a non - standard chemical composition of the stellar atmosphere alters the flux distribution of the star or modifies the profiles of the balmer lines ( @xcite , @xcite ) . therefore a determination of t@xmath2 and @xmath3 based on a comparison between observed and computed balmer - line profiles will not be correct unless one takes into account the metallicity of the star .
thus , even estimates based on standard analysis of the spectra may be in error when applied to am / fm stars . in this paper
, we investigate the determination of effective temperature and surface gravity of the am star hd27411 ( hr 1353 , a3 m ) using spectra in the eso archives .
the purpose is to determine whether the stellar parameters of this star agree with those obtained from strmgren photometry and hence to test the reliability of the effective temperature calibration applied to am / fm stars .
the star was used by @xcite as a comparison in their study on the calcium stratification in ap stars .
hd27411 is not known to pulsate . however , as we know from _ kepler _ observations , pulsations in a and f stars with amplitudes too low to be detected from the ground are common .
atmospheric models obtained with atlas9 @xcite use precomputed line opacities in the form of opacity distribution functions ( odfs ) .
these are tabulated for multiples of the solar metallicity and for various microturbulent velocities .
this approach allows very fast computation of model atmospheres , but with very little flexibility in choice of chemical profile and microturbulent velocity .
while this is satisfactory for most applications , it fails for chemically peculiar stars where a non - standard chemical composition profile is required .
this can be done with atlas12 @xcite , which is essentially identical to atlas9 , but uses the opacity sampling ( os ) method to evaluate line opacities . in this study
we compare the abundances of hd27411 obtained with both codes to determine if the use of atlas12 is essential .
the result that am stars are not confined to particular region of the @xmath0 sct instability strip depends , to a large extent , on effective temperatures and luminosities estimated from strmgren photometry @xcite .
it is not clear whether the calibration , derived from normal af stars , can be applied to am / fm stars . in this paper
we use synthetic strmgren photometry applied to models of am / fm stars to investigate the reliability of fundamental parameters estimated from the photometry .
finally , we discuss the relative numbers of pulsating and non - pulsating am stars and compare these to the relative numbers of @xmath0 scuti and constant stars in the instability strip . from this comparison
, one can deduce the effectiveness of pulsational driving in the heii ionization zone and compare the he abundance to that expected from diffusion calculations .
.ions used to determine the microturbulent velocity in hd27411 .
the number of spectral lines used , the microturbulent velocity , @xmath4 , the derived abundance and the radial velocity , rv , are listed . [
cols="<,^,^,^,^ " , ]
in fig . [ a12_a9 ]
we compare the lte abundances derived from model atmospheres computed using atlas9 and atlas12 .
it is evident that there is good agreement in the abundances derived with the two different codes .
there are some very small differences for na , v , zr and nd , but these are only 0.1 dex or less
. thus we may use the faster atlas9 code with confidence . in fig .
[ pattern ] we show the abundances relative to solar standard abundances @xcite .
the chemical pattern displayed here is typical of that observed in am stars , i.e. an underabundance of c , n , o , ca and sc and a general increasing overabundance for heavy elements .
the atmospheric abundance of li is interesting in the context of diffusion . @xcite and @xcite
find that , in general , the li abundance in am stars is close to the cosmic value ( @xmath5 dex ) , although some am / fm stars appear to have an underabundance of li .
normal a - type stars in the range @xmath6 k appear to have a higher li abundance , i.e. @xmath7 dex , @xcite .
to determine the li abundance , we used the lii @xmath86707 line , taking into account the hyperfine structure @xcite .
the abundance that gives the best fit is @[email protected]@xmath110.10 , which is closer to the abundance in normal a stars and agrees with the average li abundance of three cluster am / fm stars observed by @xcite .
@xcite predict abundances as a function of stellar age and effective temperature using their models of diffusion .
fig . 14 of their paper allows us to estimate the predicted abundances for a star with a given t@xmath2 up to a maximum age of @xmath12670 myrs .
we find that age of hd27411 to be about @xmath13 myr , which is considerably older than the maximum age of models in @xcite , but we will assume that models of 670 myr still give a fair approximation of the abundances . for t@xmath2=7400 k , which is our best estimate for hd27411 ,
the models by @xcite predicts underabundances ranging from -0.3 dex to -0.1 dex for c , n , o , na , mg , k , and ca . for si and s the abundances are normal , while overabundances of about 0.10.8 dex are found for for li , al , ti , cr , mn , fe , and ni .
inspection of their figure reveals that for na , mg , al , si , s , ca , ti , cr , mn , and fe , the abundance anomaly is approximately constant with age and depends only on the turbulence .
the abundances of li , c , n , and o vary with age .
[ pattern ] shows the abundances of the elements at 670 myr predicted by @xcite compared with our abundances .
there is indeed good agreement for li , c , n , o , mg , k , ca , ti , mn , fe , and ni , but abundances of na , al , si , s , and cr are somewhat discrepant .
similar discrepancies for na and s were found by @xcite for the am star hd73730 . from the nlte analysis of the s abundance by @xcite
, @xcite concluded that nlte effects should be taken into account to determine whether this resolves the discrepancy with diffusion predictions .
following this idea , we performed a nlte analysis on na , al , si , s , and cr , to derive their abundances . we used the same technique of matching predicted and observed line profiles , but in this case the nlte line profiles were computed with version 43 of synspec @xcite .
this code reads the same input model atmosphere previously computed using atlas12 and solves the radiative transfer equation , wavelength by wavelength in a specified spectral range .
synspec also reads the same kurucz list of lines that we used for determining metal abundances .
synspec allows one to compute the line profiles by using an approximate nlte treatment , even for lte models .
this is done by means of second - order escape probability theory ( for details see @xcite ) .
the results of these calculations are shown in table [ abund ] .
all the nlte abundances are lower than the lte abundances by factors ranging from 0.23 dex ( s ) to 0.39 dex ( al ) . as can be seen from fig .
[ pattern ] , the nlte calculations bring the observations closer to the diffusion predictions by @xcite . in fact , there is no longer any discrepancy in abundances within the observational errors .
in order to investigate the effect of line blanketing on the strmgren colour indices , we used the method of synthetic photometry . for this purpose
we computed the spectrum of a star at different effective temperatures with abundances shown in table[abund ] .
we used the abundances given by the atlas12 models modified by nlte where necessary .
the spectra were calculated using spectrum , version 2.76e @xcite .
synthetic spectra with normal and peculiar abundances were calculated for @xmath14 k and @xmath15 . in all cases
the microturbulence velocity was set to @xmath16 km s@xmath17 .
these spectra were convolved with standard @xmath18 transmission functions to calculate synthetic strmgren indices .
it should be noted that not all am / fm stars will have the same abundance anomalies as hd27411 .
hence the results described here are only indicative of what might be typical in am / fm stars .
individual am / fm stars will have different abundances and different line blanketing . in computing these synthetic strmgren indices , it is necessary to identify a particular model with a real star in order to determine the zero points .
we chose a model of vega ( @xmath19 ) for this purpose .
comparison of the synthetic @xmath20 as a function of @xmath21 with the standard relations of @xcite shows that the @xmath21 zero point required a further correction of -0.04 .
the synthetic colours for normal and am / fm stars are listed in table[strom ]
. comparison of indices for models with standard solar abundance and the abundances of table[abund ] are shown in fig.[colcol ] .
rrrrr @xmath22 & @xmath20 & @xmath23 & @xmath24 & @xmath21 + + normal : + 6000 & 0.365 & 0.251 & 0.372 & 2.630 + 6250 & 0.323 & 0.210 & 0.425 & 2.645 + 6500 & 0.296 & 0.183 & 0.482 & 2.663 + 6750 & 0.264 & 0.168 & 0.544 & 2.684 + 7000 & 0.232 & 0.162 & 0.608 & 2.707 + 7250 & 0.200 & 0.163 & 0.677 & 2.733 + 7500 & 0.150 & 0.186 & 0.846 & 2.792 + 7750 & 0.121 & 0.191 & 0.914 & 2.819 + 8000 & 0.092 & 0.196 & 0.976 & 2.841 + 8250 & 0.063 & 0.199 & 1.030 & 2.858 + 8500 & 0.041 & 0.196 & 1.062 & 2.870 + 8750 & 0.026 & 0.189 & 1.076 & 2.875 + 9000 & 0.013 & 0.180 & 1.077 & 2.875 + 9250 & 0.003 & 0.172 & 1.071 & 2.872 + 9500 & -0.005 & 0.163 & 1.058 & 2.866 + 9750 & -0.012 & 0.156 & 1.038 & 2.857
+ + am / fm : + 6000 & 0.434 & 0.351 & 0.202 & 2.637 + 6250 & 0.392 & 0.315 & 0.251 & 2.649 + 6500 & 0.352 & 0.288 & 0.312 & 2.665 + 6750 & 0.312 & 0.268 & 0.382 & 2.683 + 7000 & 0.274 & 0.255 & 0.459 & 2.705 + 7250 & 0.236 & 0.247 & 0.542 & 2.730 + 7500 & 0.183 & 0.267 & 0.705 & 2.786 + 7750 & 0.148 & 0.263 & 0.790 & 2.812 + 8000 & 0.114 & 0.258 & 0.870 & 2.835 + 8250 & 0.079 & 0.251 & 0.944 & 2.852 + 8500 & 0.053 & 0.239 & 0.995 & 2.865 + 8750 & 0.034 & 0.223 & 1.027 & 2.871 + 9000 & 0.019 & 0.207 & 1.042 & 2.872 + 9250 & 0.007 & 0.193 & 1.046 & 2.869 + 9500 & -0.002 & 0.180 & 1.042 & 2.863 + 9750 & -0.010 & 0.168 & 1.027 & 2.855 + [ strom ] various colour colour diagrams derived from the synthetic colours are shown in fig.[red ] together with reddening lines .
the reddening lines are from @xcite : + + @xmath25 , @xmath26 , @xmath27 + + also shown are the locations of hd27411 .
it is clear that the star lies nicely on the synthetic relations given by the enhanced abundances and that the star is unreddened or only very slightly reddened .
it is also clear that in determining the reddenings of am / fm stars it is wise to avoid using @xmath23 and @xmath28 .
the @xmath29 relations for am / fm abundances is almost the same as for normal abundances and it is preferable to use this diagram to deduce the reddening correction .
assuming that hd27411 is unreddened and matching the observed indices with those for modified abundances in table[strom ] gives @xmath30 k. the @xmath21 index is correlated well with effective temperature for @xmath31 k and is practically unaffected by line blanketing .
it is weakly sensitive to surface gravity , particularly for the hotter stars .
@xmath20 is correlated with effective temperature but is affected by blanketing for the cooler stars . as can be seen from fig[colcol ] , the @xmath23 index is severely affected by blanketing .
the @xmath24 index for am / fm stars is nearly always smaller than for normal stars .
this index measures the strength of the balmer discontinuity ( and hence the surface gravity ) , but it is clearly not entirely free of blanketing effects . in estimating the absolute magnitudes , @xmath32 , of f stars , @xcite defines , first of all , a relationship for stars on the zams as a function of @xmath20 , @xmath33 the absolute magnitude for a star above the zams is calculated from the value of @xmath34 , i.e. the difference between the measured @xmath24 and the value of @xmath24 on the zams at the given @xmath20 .
since there are significant line blanketing effects on @xmath24 for am / fm stars , their absolute magnitudes derived in this way are probably not free of systematic errors .
we derived @xmath32 using the data of table[strom ] for stars with solar abundance and with the am abundance using the calibration of @xcite .
we find that on average the am stars are estimated to be about 1.2 magnitudes fainter than normal stars of the same effective temperature and gravity .
this is due to the systematically lower values of @xmath24 in the am star models .
table[groundspec ] lists am stars which have good parallaxes .
the general trend of lower luminosities derived from strmgren photometry is apparent . from this exercise
we conclude that although the effective temperatures of am / fm stars derived from strmgren photometry are probably reliable , the absolute magnitudes may be systematically too faint .
* for example , if we apply the @xcite calibration to hd27411 , assuming no reddening , we obtain @xmath35 or @xmath36 ( using bc = 0.035 derived from @xcite ) , whereas the most reliable estimate ( hipparcos parallax ) gives @xmath37 .
* this effect can be seen in fig[hr ] where many of the am stars are below the line defining the zams .
the luminosities of these stars were derived using the standard calibration and hence have been under - estimated .
( filled circles ) .
the asterisk shows the observed location of hd27411 and the arrows are the reddening lines from @xcite.,width=321 ] rl@ rr@ r@ r & & & & parallax & strmgren + hd & class & @xmath38 & @xmath3 & @xmath39 & @xmath39 + 27411 & a3 m & 3.869 & 4.12 & 1.35 & 0.96 + 27628 & ka5hf0mf2 & 3.864 & 4.00 & 1.04 & 0.82 + 71297 & a5iii - iv & 3.900 & 4.19 & 1.14 & 0.82 + 104513 & a7 m & 3.879 & 4.24 & 0.88 & 0.87 + 204188 & ka6ha9mf0 & 3.898 & 4.34 & 0.89 & 0.74 +
the diffusion models of @xcite are the best models presently available for am / fm stars .
the models seem to be able to predict the abundances in these stars rather well , but we need to bear in mind that this is achieved because of adjustable free parameters to describe the turbulence .
we still do not know if the mechanism competing with diffusion is turbulence , mass loss or some other factor .
what we do know is that the current description of am stars is in trouble because it fails to account for the wide distribution of pulsating am stars in the @xmath0 sct instability strip @xcite .
one question that is of interest is the fraction of am stars that pulsate . to answer this question we have to define what we mean by `` non - pulsating '' .
clearly , a star could be pulsating but with amplitudes too small to be visible from the ground .
@xcite discussed this issue in the context of _ kepler _ observations which , of course , allow pulsations to be detected at the micromagnitude level .
they deduced that the fraction of pulsating stars in the @xmath0 sct instability strip is surprisingly low .
there is clearly some damping mechanism which is currently not understood .
the fraction of @xmath0 sct stars in the instability strip varies with effective temperature , but does not exceed about 50 percent .
we can answer this question for am stars only in part because we do not have a sufficient number of am stars observed at the micromagnitude level . in order to compare these ground - based observations with the extensive _ kepler _ observations of @xmath0 sct stars , we need to degrade the _
data by considering as pulsating only those @xmath0 sct stars with amplitudes over 1.5 mmag .
we chose this minimum amplitude as roughly representative of the detection limit in the catalogue of pulsating am stars in @xcite .
the percentage of _ kepler _
@xmath0 sct stars with this minimum amplitude relative to all stars in a particular temperature range
is shown in table[dsct ] .
lrrr @xmath22 & @xmath40(all ) & @xmath40(@xmath0 sct ) & percent + : + 5500 - 6500 & 1509 & 33 & 2.19 + 6500 - 7000 & 3842 & 174 & 4.53 + 7000 - 7500 & 1412 & 263 & 18.63 + 7500 - 8000 & 811 & 172 & 21.21 + 8000 - 8500 & 512 & 51 & 9.96 + 8500 - 9000 & 297 & 11 & 3.70 + 9000 - 10000 & 263 & 1 & 0.38 + + am stars : + 5500 - 6500 & 16 & 2 & 12.50 + 6500 - 7000 & 75 & 21 & 28.00 + 7000 - 7500 & 307 & 52 & 16.94 + 7500 - 8000 & 489 & 9 & 1.84 + 8000 - 8500 & 185 & 1 & 0.54 + 8500 - 9000 & 32 & 2 & 6.25 + 9000 - 10000 & 7 & 0 & 0.00 + we can now compare this distribution of ordinary @xmath0 sct stars with the distribution of pulsating am stars in @xcite .
we used the catalogue of @xcite and estimated the effective temperatures of the am stars using the @xcite calibrations .
results are shown in table[dsct ] and fig.[distr ] .
it is evident that the pulsating am stars are cooler than normal @xmath0 sct stars , a fact already mentioned by @xcite .
this conclusion still holds even if the amplitude threshold in _ kepler _ data is lowered to a few micromagnitudes .
scuti stars relative to all stars in the given effective temperature range is shown as the solid line histogram .
the dashed line histogram is the percentage of pulsating am stars relative to all am stars in the given temperature range.,width=321 ] from this comparison , we may deduce that there is certainly a tendency for pulsating am stars to be confined more towards the red edge , but that this effect is far smaller than predicted by @xcite .
in fact , table[dsct ] shows that the percentage of pulsating am stars among the am stars is about the same as the percentage of @xmath0 scuti stars in the instability strip .
this tells us that driving in the heii ionization zone is practically unaffected .
we may therefore conclude that there is no significant reduction of he in the ionization zone , contrary to the prediction of current diffusion models .
we analyzed the spectrum of the am star hd27411 from the uves pop archive .
our aim was to investigate if the atlas12 model atmosphere code provides more reliable results than the atlas9 code for chemically peculiar stars .
we found that there is very little difference in the abundances derived from atlas9 and from atlas12 .
since atlas12 demands considerably greater resources , it seems safe to use atlas9 , at least for moderate metallic enhancement .
we find that the derived abundances in hd27411 are in good agreement with the predictions of diffusion models by @xcite .
there were discrepancies for na , al , si , s , and cr , but these are resolved by using nlte model atmospheres .
we investigated the reliability of effective temperatures and luminosities of am / fm stars determined by strmgren photometry by synthesizing spectra having the abundances of hd27411 for a range of effective temperatures .
the resulting synthetic colours indicate that effective temperatures can be reliably determined from photometry , but owing to line blanketing in the @xmath24 passband , the resulting surface gravities are systematically to high , leading to lower luminosities .
this result appears to be verified by comparing luminosities of am / fm stars obtained from their parallaxes and from photometry .
* determination of reliable luminosities for am stars remains a difficult problem . at this stage ,
parallaxes offer the best results , but this can only be done for very few stars .
as we have seen , luminosities obtained from strmgren photometry are subject to a systematic bias which depends on the overabundances of metals .
the error in the surface gravity from high - resolution spectroscopy is typically 0.1 in @xmath3 . for a
f main sequence and giants , this translates into an error of about 0.12 in @xmath41 when using the calibration of @xcite . for hd27411 , for example , we derive @xmath42 from spectroscopy , whereas the value derived from the parallax is @xmath43 ( table2 ) , although the two values only differ by two standard deviations , this is enough to cause a difference of 0.36 in @xmath41 .
although spectroscopic determinations of luminosities may lead to quite large errors in the luminosity , they should at least not be biased . * by far the most serious problem confronting the diffusion model is that there seems to be no appreciable settling of he in the heii ionization zone , as predicted by the models .
this is demonstrated by the fact that pulsating am / fm stars occur throughout the @xmath0 scuti instability strip , though they tend to be cooler than normal @xmath0 sct stars .
in fact , the relative proportions of pulsating am stars to non - pulsating am stars is no different from the proportion of @xmath0 sct stars to constant stars in the @xmath0 sct instability strip .
there is clearly a need to revise current ideas of diffusion to explain the am phenomenon .
lab wishes to thank the national research foundation and the south african astronomical observatory for financial assistance .
kurucz r. l. , 1997 , model atmospheres for individual stars with arbitrary abundances . in : the third conference on faint blue stars , a. g. d. philip , j. liebert , r. saffer and d. s. hayes ( eds . ) , published by l. davis press , p.33 kurucz r.l .
, 1993 , a new opacity - sampling model atmosphere program for arbitrary abundances . in : peculiar versus normal phenomena in a - type and related stars , iau colloquium 138 , m.m .
dworetsky , f. castelli , r. faraggiana ( eds . ) , a.s.p conferences series vol . | we analyze a high - resolution spectrum of the a3 m star hd27411 .
we compare abundances derived from atlas9 model atmospheres with those using the more computationally - intensive atlas12 code .
we found very little differences in the abundances , suggesting that atlas9 can be used for moderate chemical peculiarity .
our abundances agree well with the predictions of diffusion theory , though for some elements it was necessary to calculate line profiles in non - thermodynamic equilibrium to obtain agreement .
we investigate the effective temperatures and luminosities of am / fm stars using synthetic strmgren indices derived from calculated spectra with the atmospheric abundances of hd27411 .
we find that the effective temperatures of am / fm stars derived from strmgren photometry are reliable , but the luminosities are probably too low .
caution is required when deriving the reddening of these stars owing to line blanketing effects .
a comparison of the relative proportions of pulsating and non - pulsating am stars with @xmath0 scuti stars shows quite clearly that there is no significant decrease of helium in the driving zone , contrary to current models of diffusion .
[ firstpage ] stars : chemically peculiar
stars : individual : hd27411 stars : abundances |
fe - based superconductors ( febs ) represent a non - cuprate class of high-@xmath9 systems with the unconventional superconducting state . the origin of the latter is still debated . in general ,
febs can be divided into the two subclasses , pnictides and chalcogenides @xcite , with the square lattice of iron as the basic element , though with orthorhombic distortions in lightly doped materials .
iron is surrounded by as or p situated in the tetrahedral positions within the first subclass and by se , te , or s within the second subclass .
fermi surface ( fs ) is formed by fe @xmath10-orbitals and excluding the cases of extreme hole and electron dopings it consists of two hole sheets around the @xmath11 point and two electron sheets around the @xmath12 and @xmath13 points in the two - dimensional brillouin zone ( bz ) corresponding to one fe per unit cell ( the so - called 1-fe bz ) @xcite . in the 2-fe bz ,
electron pockets are centered at the @xmath14 point .
nesting between these two groups of sheets leads to the enhanced antiferromagnetic fluctuations with the maximal scattering near the wave vector @xmath2 equal to @xmath12 or @xmath13 in the 1-fe bz or to @xmath15 in the 2-fe bz
. different mechanisms of cooper pairs formation result in the distinct superconducting gap symmetry and structure @xcite .
in particular , the rpa - sf ( random - phase approximation spin fluctuation ) approach gives the extended @xmath16-wave gap that changes sign between hole and electron fs sheets ( @xmath17 state ) as the main instability for the wide range of doping concentrations @xcite . on the other hand ,
orbital fluctuations promote the order parameter to have the sign - preserving @xmath6 symmetry @xcite .
thus , probing the gap structure can help in elucidating the underlying mechanism . in this respect , inelastic neutron scattering ( ins )
is a useful tool since the measured dynamical spin susceptibility @xmath18 in the superconducting state carries information about the gap structure .
there are been many reports of a well - defined peak in neutron spectra in 1111 , 122 , and 11 systems appearing only for @xmath19 at or around @xmath20 @xcite .
the common explanation is that the peak is the spin resonance appearing due to the @xmath7 state . indeed , since @xmath2 connects fermi sheets with different signs of @xmath7 gaps , the resonance condition for the interband susceptibility is fulfilled and the spin resonance peak is formed at a frequency @xmath21 below @xmath22 with @xmath23 being the gap size @xcite .
such simple explanation was indirectly questioned by the angle - resolved photoemission spectroscopy ( arpes ) results and recent measurements of gaps via andreev spectroscopy .
latter clearly shows that there are at least two distinct gaps present in 11 , 122 , and 1111 systems @xcite and even three gaps in lifeas @xcite .
larger gap ( @xmath0 ) is about 9mev and the smaller gap ( @xmath1 ) is about 4mev in baco122 materials . from arpes
we know that electron fs sheets and the inner hole sheet are subject to opening the lager gap while the smaller gap is located at the outer hole fs @xcite .
the very existence of the smaller gap rise the question what would be the spin resonance frequency in the system with two distinct gaps ?
naive expectation is that the frequency shifts to the lower gap scale and @xmath24 .
then the observed peak in ins in baco122 system at frequency @xmath25mev @xcite can not be the spin resonance since it is greater than @xmath26mev @xcite .
thus the peak could be coming from the @xmath6 state @xcite , where it forms at frequencies _ above _
@xmath27 due to the redistribution of the spectral weight upon entering the superconducting state and a special form of scattering in the normal state . here we study this question in details and show that the naive expectation is wrong and that the true minimal energy scale is @xmath28 .
latter is consistent with the maximal frequency of the observed peak in ins in baco122 and confirms that it is the true spin resonance evidencing the @xmath7 gap symmetry .
the maximal energy scale is @xmath29 . whether the minimal or maximal energy scale will be realized depends on the relation between the exact band structure of a particular material and the wave vector of the spin resonance @xmath2 .
to describe spin response in normal and superconducting states of febs , we use random phase approximation ( rpa ) with the local coulomb interactions ( hubbard and hund s exchange ) . in the multiband system ,
transverse dynamical spin susceptibility @xmath30 is the matrix in orbital ( or band ) indices .
it can be obtained in the rpa from the bare electron - hole matrix bubble @xmath31 by summing up a series of ladder diagrams : @xmath32^{-1 } \hat\chi_{(0)+-}(\q,\omega ) , \label{eq : chi_s_sol}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath33 is the momentum , @xmath34 is the frequency , @xmath35 and @xmath36 are interaction and unit matrices in orbital ( or band ) space .
exact form of @xmath35 and bare susceptibility @xmath31 depends on the underlying model .
later we use two types of tight - binding models for the two - dimensional iron layer .
first we study the four - band model of ref . with the following single - electron hamiltonian @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the annihilation operator of the @xmath10-electron with momentum @xmath39 , spin @xmath40 , and
band index @xmath41 , @xmath42 are the on - site single - electron energies , @xmath43 is the electronic dispersion that yields hole pockets centered around the @xmath44 point , and @xmath45 is the dispersion that results in the electron pockets around the @xmath46 point of the 2-febz .
parameters are the same as in ref . .
in the superconducting state we assume either the @xmath6 state with @xmath47 or the @xmath7 state with @xmath48 .
physical spin susceptibility @xmath49 obtained by calculating matrix elements @xmath50 via equation ( [ eq : chi_s_sol ] ) with the interaction matrix @xmath51 and with the bare spin susceptibility @xmath52 in the superconducting state ( see ref . for details ) .
we assume here the effective hubbard interaction parameters to be @xmath53 and @xmath54 in order to stay in the paramagnetic phase @xcite .
the model described above is simple enough to gain qualitative description of the spin response of superconductor with unequal gaps .
but it lack for the orbital content of the bands that is important for the detailed structure of the susceptibility .
that is why we also present results for the tight - binding model from ref .
based on the fit to the dft band structure for lafeaso @xcite .
the model includes all five iron @xmath10-orbitals ( @xmath55 , @xmath56 , @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 ) enumerated by index @xmath60 and is given by @xmath61 d_{l \k \sigma}^\dagger d_{l ' \k \sigma } , \label{eq : h0}\ ] ] where @xmath62 is the annihilation operator of a particle with momentum @xmath39 , spin @xmath40 , and orbital index @xmath60 .
later we use numerical values of hopping matrix elements @xmath63 and one - electron energies @xmath64 from ref . .
this model for the undoped and moderately electron doped materials gives fs composed of two hole pockets , @xmath65 and @xmath66 , around the @xmath67 point and two electron pockets , @xmath68 and @xmath69 , centered around @xmath12 and @xmath13 points of the 1-fe bz . similar model for iron pnictides was proposed in ref . .
the general two - particle on - site interaction would be represented by the hamiltonian @xcite : h_int & = & u _ f , m n_f m n_f m + u _ f , m < l n_f l n_f m + & & + j _ f , m < l _ ,
d_f l ^d_f m ^d_f l
d_f m + & & + j _ f , m l d_f l ^d_f l ^d_f m d_f m . [ eq : hint ] where @xmath70 , @xmath71 is the number of particles operator at the site @xmath72 , @xmath73 and @xmath74 are the intra- and interorbital hubbard repulsion , @xmath75 is the hund s exchange , and @xmath76 is the so - called pair hopping .
we choose the following values for the interaction parameters : @xmath77ev , @xmath78 , and make use of the spin - rotational invariance constraint @xmath79 and @xmath80 .
green functions are diagonal in the band basis but not in the orbital basis .
let us introduce creation and annihilation operators @xmath81 and @xmath82 of electrons with band index @xmath83 , in terms of which green functions are diagonal , @xmath84 .
transformation from the orbital to the band basis is done via the matrix elements @xmath85 , @xmath86 , and for the transverse component of the bare spin susceptibility @xcite we have [ eq : chipmmu ] & & ^ll,mm_(0)+- ( , ) = -t _ , _ n , , , where @xmath87 and @xmath88 are matsubara frequencies , @xmath89 and @xmath90 are the normal and anomalous ( superconducting ) green s functions , respectively .
components of the physical spin susceptibility @xmath91 are calculated using eq .
( [ eq : chi_s_sol ] ) with the interaction matrix @xmath92 from ref . .
since calculation of the cooper pairing instability is not a topic of the present study , here we assume that the superconductivity is coming from some other theory and study either the @xmath6 state with @xmath93 or the @xmath7 state with @xmath94 , where @xmath83 is the band index .
here we present results for susceptibilities at the wave vector @xmath95 as functions of frequency @xmath34 obtained via analytical continuation from matsubara frequencies ( @xmath96 with @xmath97 )
. imaginary part of bare and rpa spin susceptibilities in the four - band model ( [ eq : h04band ] ) are shown in fig .
[ fig : imchi4band ] .
first , we discuss result for equal gaps on electron ( @xmath98 , @xmath99 ) and hole ( @xmath100 , @xmath101 ) fss , @xmath102 .
since @xmath103 describes particle - hole excitations and in the superconducting state all excitations are gapped below approximately @xmath104 ( at @xmath105 ) , then @xmath106 becomes finite only after that frequency . for the @xmath6 state
, there is a gradual increase of the spin response for @xmath107 . for the @xmath7 state
, @xmath2 connects fss with different signs of gaps , @xmath108 , and within rpa ( [ eq : chi_s_sol ] ) this results in the spin resonance peak divergence of @xmath109 at a frequency @xmath110 , see fig .
[ fig : imchi4band ] , bottom panel .
( top ) and @xmath109 with @xmath111 in the 2-fe bz for the four - band model in the normal , @xmath6 and @xmath7 superconducting states .
two cases of superconducting states are shown : equal @xmath23 s with @xmath102 , and unequal gaps with @xmath112 and @xmath113 . [
fig : imchi4band],title="fig : " ] ( top ) and @xmath109 with @xmath111 in the 2-fe bz for the four - band model in the normal , @xmath6 and @xmath7 superconducting states .
two cases of superconducting states are shown : equal @xmath23 s with @xmath102 , and unequal gaps with @xmath112 and @xmath113 .
[ fig : imchi4band],title="fig : " ] now let s consider the case of unequal gaps with a small gap scale on outer hole fs , @xmath113 , and a larger gap scale on all other fss , @xmath112 . as seen from fig .
[ fig : imchi4band ] , top panel , for the @xmath7 state the discontinuous jump and , thus , @xmath114 , moved to lower frequencies .
this new energy scale clearly tracked down in the @xmath6 state as the starting point of the susceptibility gradual increase .
it is equal to @xmath115 , where @xmath0 and @xmath1 being the larger and smaller gap scales .
consequently , the spin resonance peak in @xmath7 moved to lower frequencies , @xmath116 , see fig .
[ fig : imchi4band ] , bottom panel .
additional feature is the hump around the @xmath117 energy scale .
note that the susceptibility in the @xmath6 state havent changed much compared to the equal gaps case . in the superconducting state , @xmath118 , as a function of momentum @xmath39 along the @xmath119 direction , i.e. @xmath120 .
scattering wave vector @xmath2 entering the spin susceptibility is also shown .
[ fig:5orbdelta ] ] with @xmath121 in the 1-fe bz for the five - orbital model in the normal , @xmath6 and @xmath7 superconducting states .
two cases of superconducting states are shown : equal gaps with @xmath122 , and unequal gaps with @xmath123 and @xmath124 , where @xmath125 .
latter case is shown in the inset , where gaps at the fs are plotted together with the wave vector @xmath2 .
[ fig:5orbimchi ] ] to demonstrate where the new energy scale is coming from we turn our attention to the five - orbital model ( [ eq : h0 ] ) .
its energy spectrum near the fermi level in the superconducting state , @xmath118 , is shown in fig .
[ fig:5orbdelta ] .
we consider here the case of unequal gaps with the smaller gap @xmath124 on the outer hole fs and larger gaps @xmath123 on inner hole and electron fss . to be consistent with the experimental data , we choose @xmath126 ,
see the inset in fig .
[ fig:5orbimchi ] .
naturally , the two energy scales , @xmath127 and @xmath128 , appear in the energy spectrum @xmath129 and they are connected with hole @xmath66 and electron @xmath130 bands , respectively . on the other hand , the susceptibility @xmath131 contains scattering _ between _ hole and electron bands with the wave vector @xmath2 .
the energy gap that have to be overcome to excite electron - hole pair is the indirect gap with the scale @xmath4 .
that is why spin excitations in the @xmath6 state start with the frequency proportional to the indirect gap @xmath132 , see fig .
[ fig:5orbimchi ] . the same is true for the discontinuous jump in @xmath133 for the @xmath7 state it shifts to frequency @xmath134 .
this , together with the corresponding @xmath135 singularity in @xmath136 , produce the spin resonance peak in rpa at frequency @xmath8 .
such shift of resonance peak to lower frequencies compared to the equal gaps situation is seen in fig .
[ fig:5orbimchi ] , where the spin response @xmath109 for the cases of equal and distinct gaps is shown .
the changes in the band structure and/or doping level can result in the change of the indirect gap . in particular , since for the hole doping hole fss become larger the wave vector @xmath2 may connect states on the electron fs and on the _ inner _ hole fs .
gaps on both these fss are determined by @xmath0 and thus the indirect gap will be equal to @xmath5 .
this sets up a maximal energy scale for the spin resonance , i.e. @xmath29 . thus we conclude that depending on the relation between the wave vector @xmath2 and the exact fs geometry , the indirect gap in most febs can be either @xmath4 or @xmath5 .
the peak in the dynamical spin susceptibility at the wave vector @xmath2 will be the true spin resonance if it appears below the indirect gap scale , @xmath8 .
now we can compare energy scales extracted from arpes , andreev spectroscopy , and inelastic neutron scattering .
latter gives peak frequency @xmath137mev in bafe@xmath138co@xmath139as@xmath140 with @xmath141k @xcite .
for the same system , gap sizes extracted from arpes are @xmath142mev and @xmath143mev @xcite , and for a similar system with @xmath144k , @xmath145mev and @xmath146mev @xcite .
gap sizes extracted from andreev spectroscopy are @xmath147mev and @xmath148mev in bafe@xmath149co@xmath150as@xmath140 with @xmath151k @xcite .
evidently , @xmath152 and we can safely state that the peak in ins is the spin resonance . for the hole doped systems , peak frequency in ins is about @xmath153mev in ba@xmath154k@xmath155fe@xmath140as@xmath140 with @xmath156k @xcite .
there is a slight discrepancy between gap sizes extracted from arpes and andreev spectra .
former gives @xmath157mev and @xmath158mev in the same material with @xmath159k @xcite , thus @xmath152 .
gap sizes from andereev spectroscopy are @xmath160mev and @xmath161mev in ba@xmath162k@xmath163fe@xmath140as@xmath140 with lower @xmath164k @xcite . in this case , @xmath165 but @xmath166 and we still can assume that the peak in ins is the spin resonance .
however , in such a case definitive conclusion can be given only by the calculation of spin response for the particular experimental band structure .
for more extensive review of available experimental data on @xmath167 and gap scales , see the supplemental material @xcite . on the separate note , we would like to mention that the appearance of a hump structure in the superconducting state at frequencies larger than the main peak frequency ( the so - called double resonance feature ) may be related to the @xmath128 energy scale , see fig .
[ fig : imchi4band ] .
such hump structure was observed in nafe@xmath168co@xmath169as @xcite and fete@xmath170se@xmath170 @xcite . somehow similar structure was found in polarized inelastic neutron studies of bafe@xmath171ni@xmath172as@xmath140 @xcite and ba(fe@xmath173co@xmath174)@xmath140as@xmath140 @xcite , but its origin may be related to the spin - orbit coupling @xcite rather than the simple @xmath128 energy scale .
another explanation of the double resonance feature is related to the pre - existing magnon mode , i.e. the dispersive low - energy peak in underdoped materials is associated with the spin excitations of the magnetic order with the intensity enhanced below @xmath9 due to the suppression of the damping @xcite .
we analysed the spin response of febs with two different superconducting gap scales , @xmath175 .
spin resonance appears in the @xmath7 state below the indirect gap scale @xmath3 that is determined by the sum of gaps on two different fermi surface sheets connected by the scattering wave vector @xmath2 . in the @xmath6 state ,
spin excitations are absent below @xmath3 unless additional scattering mechanisms are assumed @xcite . for the fermi surface geometry characteristic to the most of febs materials ,
the indirect gap is either @xmath4 or @xmath5 .
this gives the simple criterion to determine whether the experimentally observed peak in inelastic neutron scattering is the true spin resonance if the peak frequency @xmath21 is less than the indirect gap @xmath3 , then it is the spin resonance and , consequently , the superconducting state has the @xmath7 gap structure .
comparison of energy scales extracted from ins , andreev spectroscopy , arpes and other techniques allowing to determine superconducting gaps , for most materials gives confidence that the observed feature in ins is the spin resonance peak .
however , sometimes it is not always clear experimentally which gaps are connected by the wave vector @xmath2 . even without knowing this exactly
, one can draw some conclusions .
for example , if one of the gaps is @xmath0 , then there are three cases possible : ( 1 ) @xmath176 and the peak at @xmath21 is the spin resonance , ( 2 ) @xmath177 and the peak is definitely not a spin resonance , and ( 3 ) @xmath29 and the peak is most likely the spin resonance but the definitive conclusion can be drawn only from the calculation of the dynamical spin susceptibility for the particular experimental band structure . we would like to thank h. kontani , s.a .
kuzmichev , t.e .
kuzmicheva , v.m .
pudalov , and i.s .
sandalov for useful discussions .
mmk is grateful to b. keimer and max - planck - institut fr festkrperforschung for the hospitality during his visit .
we acknowledge partial support by rfbr ( grant 16 - 02 - 00098 ) , and government support of the leading scientific schools of the russian federation ( nsh-7559.2016.2 ) .
see , e.g. m.v .
sadovskii , physics - uspekhi * 51 * , 1201 ( 2008 ) ; d.c .
johnston , advances in physics * 59 * , 803 ( 2010 ) ; g.r .
stewart , rev .
phys . * 83 * , 1589 ( 2011 ) . p.j .
hirschfeld , m.m .
korshunov , and i.i .
mazin , rep .
. phys . * 74 * , 124508 ( 2011 ) .
mazin , d.j .
singh , m.d .
johannes , and m .- h .
du , phys .
* 101 * , 057003 ( 2008 ) .
s. graser , t.a .
maier , p.j .
hirschfeld , and d.j .
scalapino , new . j. phys .
* 11 * , 025016 ( 2009 ) .
k. kuroki , s. onari , r. arita , h. usui , y. tanaka , h. kontani , and h. aoki , phys .
* 101 * , 087004 ( 2008 ) .
s. maiti , m.m .
korshunov , t.a .
maier , p.j .
hirschfeld , and a.v .
chubukov , phys .
b * 84 * , 224505 ( 2011 ) . m.m .
korshunov , physics - uspekhi * 57 * , 813 ( 2014 ) .
h. kontani and s. onari , phys .
* 104 * , 157001 ( 2010 ) .
christianson , e.a .
goremychkin , r. osborn , s. rosenkranz , m.d .
lumsden , c.d .
malliakas , i.s .
todorov , h. claus , d.y .
chung , m.g .
kanatzidis , r.i .
bewley , and t. guidi , nature 456 , 930 ( 2008 ) .
inosov , j.t .
park , p. bourges , d.l .
sun , y. sidis , a. schneidewind , k. hradil , d. haug , c.t .
lin , b. keimer , and v. hinkov , nature physics * 6 * , 178 ( 2010 ) .
argyriou , a. hiess , a. akbari , i. eremin , m.m .
korshunov , j. hu , b. qian , z. mao , y. qiu , c. broholm , and w. bao , phys .
b * 81 * , 220503(r ) ( 2010 ) . m.d . lumsden and a.d .
christianson , j. physs : condense .
matter * 22 * , 203203 ( 2011 ) .
dai , rev .
* 87 * , 855 ( 2015 ) .
korshunov and i. eremin , phys .
b * 78 * , 140509(r ) ( 2008 ) . t.a . maier and d.j .
scalapino , phys .
b * 78 * , 020514(r ) ( 2008 ) .
maier , s. graser , d.j .
scalapino , and p.j .
hirschfeld , phys .
b * 79 * , 134520 ( 2009 ) .
d. daghero , m. tortello , r.s .
gonnelli , v.a .
stepanov , n.d .
zhigadlo , and j. karpinski , phys .
b * 80 * , 060502(r ) ( 2009 ) .
m. tortello , d. daghero , g.a .
ummarino , v.a .
stepanov , j. jiang , j.d .
weiss , e.e .
hellstrom , and r.s .
gonnelli , phys .
lett . * 105 * , 237002 ( 2010 ) .
ponomarev , s.a .
kuzmichev , t.e .
kuzmicheva , m.g .
mikheev , m.v .
sudakova , s.n .
tchesnokov , o.s .
volkova , a.n .
vasiliev , v.m .
pudalov , a.v .
sadakov , a.s .
usoltsev , t. wolf , e.p .
khlybov , and l.f .
kulikova , j. supercond .
* 26 * , 2867 ( 2013 ) .
m. abdel - hafiez , p.j .
pereira , s.a .
kuzmichev , t.e .
kuzmicheva , v.m .
pudalov , l. harnagea , a.a .
kordyuk , a.v .
silhanek , v.v .
moshchalkov , b. shen , h .- h .
wen , a.n .
vasiliev , and x .- j .
chen , phys .
b * 90 * , 054524 ( 2014 ) .
kuzmichev , t.e .
kuzmicheva , s.n .
tchesnokov , v.m .
pudalov , a.n .
vasiliev , j. supercond .
* 29 * , 1111 ( 2016 ) .
kuzmichev , t.e .
shanygina , i.v .
morozov , a.i .
boltalin , m.v .
roslova , s. wurmehl , and b. bchner , jetp lett . * 95 * , 537 ( 2012 ) .
kuzmichev , t.e .
kuzmicheva , a.i .
boltalin , and i.v .
morozov , jetp lett . * 98 * , 722 ( 2013 ) .
h. ding , p. richard , k. nakayama , k. sugawara , t. arakane , y. sekiba , a. takayama , s. souma , t. sato , t. takahashi , z. wang , x. dai , z. fang , g.f .
chen , j.l .
luo , and n.l .
wang , epl 83 , 47001 ( 2008 ) .
evtushinsky , d.s .
inosov , v.b .
zabolotnyy , a. koitzsch , m. knupfer , b. bchner , m.s .
viazovska , g.l .
sun , v. hinkov , a.v .
boris , c.t .
lin , b. keimer , a. varykhalov , a.a .
kordyuk , and s.v .
borisenko , phys .
b * 79 * , 054517 ( 2009 ) .
s. onari , h. kontani , and m. sato , phys . rev .
b * 81 * , 060504(r ) ( 2010 ) . s. onari and h. kontani , phys
b * 84 * , 144518 ( 2011 ) . c. cao , p.j . hirschfeld , and h .-
cheng , phys .
b * 77 * , 220506(r ) ( 2008 ) . c. castellani , c.r . natoli , and j. ranninger , phys .
b * 18 * , 4945 ( 1978 ) .
a.m. ole , phys .
b * 28 * , 327 ( 1983 ) .
k. terashima , y. sekiba , j. h. bowen , k. nakayama , t. kawahara , t. sato , p. richard , y. m. xu , l. j. li , g. h. cao , z. a. xu , h. ding , and t. takahashi , proc .
usa * 106 * , 7330 ( 2009 ) .
t. kawahara , k. terashima , y. sekiba , j.h .
bowen , k. nakayama , t. sato , p. richard , y .- m .
cao , z .- a .
xu , h. ding , and t. takahashi , physica c * 470 * , s440 ( 2010 ) .
see supplemental material below ( [ suppl ] ) for the review of experimental data on the peak in ins and gaps extracted from various experimental techniques .
c. zhang , r. yu , y. su , y. song , m. wang , g. tan , t. egami , j.a .
fernandez - baca , e. faulhaber , q. si , and p. dai , phys .
* 111 * , 207002 ( 2013 ) . c. zhang , y. song , l .- p .
regnault , y. su , m. enderle , j. kulda , g. tan , z.c .
sims , t. egami , q. si , and p. dai , phys .
b * 90 * , 140502(r ) ( 2014 ) .
mook , m.d .
lumsden , a.d .
christianson , s.e .
nagler , b.c .
sales , r. jin , m.a .
mcguire , a.s .
sefat , d. mandrus , t. egami , and c. dela cruz , phys .
* 104 * , 187002 , ( 2010 ) .
lipscombe , l.w .
harriger , p.g .
freeman , m. enderle , c. zhang , m. wang , t. egami , j. hu , t. xiang , m.r .
norman , and p. dai , phys .
b * 82 * , 064515 ( 2010 ) .
p. steffens , c.h .
lee , n. qureshi , k. kihou , a. iyo , h. eisaki , and m. braden , phys .
. lett . * 110 * , 137001 ( 2013 ) .
korshunov , y.n .
togushova , i. eremin , and p.j .
hirschfeld , j. supercon .
* 26 * , 2873 ( 2013 ) .
m. wang , m. yi , h.l .
sun , p. valdivia , m.g .
kim , z.j .
xu , t. berlijn , a.d .
christianson , s. chi , m. hashimoto , d.h .
li , e. bourret - courchesne , p. dai , d.h .
lee , t.a .
maier , and r.j .
birgeneau , phys .
b * 93 * , 205149 ( 2016 ) .
_ review of experimental data on the peak in inelastic neutron scattering ( ins ) and gaps extracted from various experimental techniques . _ in the article
, we have analysed the spin response of febs with two different superconducting gap scales , @xmath175 .
spin resonance appears in the @xmath7 state below the indirect gap scale @xmath3 that is determined by the sum of gaps on two different fermi surface sheets connected by the scattering wave vector @xmath2 . for the fermi surface geometry characteristic to the most of febs materials ,
the indirect gap is either @xmath4 or @xmath5 .
this gives the simple criterion to determine whether the experimentally observed peak in inelastic neutron scattering is the true spin resonance if the peak frequency @xmath21 is less than the indirect gap @xmath3 , then it is the spin resonance and , consequently , the superconducting state has the @xmath7 gap structure . sometimes it is not always clear experimentally which gaps are connected by the wave vector @xmath2 . even without knowing this exactly , one can draw some conclusions .
for example , if one of the gaps is @xmath0 , then there are three cases possible : ( 1 ) @xmath176 and the peak at @xmath21 is the spin resonance , ( 2 ) @xmath177 and the peak is definitely not a spin resonance , and ( 3 ) @xmath29 and the peak is most likely the spin resonance but the definitive conclusion can be drawn only from the calculation of the dynamical spin susceptibility for the particular experimental band structure . here
we combine data on the peak frequency @xmath21 and maximal and minimal gap sizes @xmath0 and @xmath1 available in the literature .
results are presented in table [ tab ] .
unfortunately , for many materials either the ins data or gaps estimations are absent .
this gives a whole set of tasks for future experiments .
here are some conclusions , which we can make : 1 . in electron - doped bafe@xmath178co@xmath179as@xmath140 system , nafe@xmath178co@xmath179as system , and fese , @xmath116 and ,
thus the peak in ins is the true spin resonance evidencing sign - changing gap .
some hole doped ba@xmath178k@xmath179fe@xmath140as@xmath140 materials satisfy @xmath176 condition , and some satisfy @xmath180 condition .
latter comes especially from newer tunneling @xcite and andreev reflection @xcite data reveling smaller gap values .
the fact that @xmath180 is still consistent with the sign - changing gap , but as we mentioned before , the calculation of the spin response for the particular experimental band structure is required to make a final conclusion .
3 . the only case when @xmath181 is fete@xmath170se@xmath170 . according to our analysis , there should be no sign - changing gap structure .
but before concluding this since this is the single case only , gap data coming from @xmath83sr @xcite should be double checked by independent techniques .
interesting to note , that arpes in all cases gives gaps values larger than extracted from other techniques .
natural question arise whether the arpes overestimates or all other methods underestimates superconducting gaps ?
m. wang , m. yi , h.l .
sun , p. valdivia , m.g .
kim , z.j .
xu , t. berlijn , a.d .
christianson , s. chi , m. hashimoto , d.h .
li , e. bourret - courchesne , p. dai , d.h .
lee , t.a .
maier , and r.j .
birgeneau , phys .
b * 93 * , 205149 ( 2016 ) .
park , d.s .
inosov , a. yaresko , s. graser , d.l .
bourges , y. sidis , y. li , j .- h .
kim , d. haug , a. ivanov , k. hradil , a. schneidewind , p. link , e. faulhaber , i. glavatskyy , c.t .
lin , b. keimer , and v. hinkov , phys .
b * 82 * , 134503 ( 2010 ) . m.d .
lumsden , a.d .
christianson , d. parshall , m.b .
stone , s.e .
nagler , g.j .
macdougall , h.a .
mook , k. lokshin , t. egami , d.l .
abernathy , e.a .
goremychkin , r. osborn , m.a .
mcguire , a.s .
sefat , r. jin , b.c .
sales , and d. mandrus , phys .
lett . * 102 * , 107005 ( 2009 ) .
castellan , s. rosenkranz , e.a .
goremychkin , d.y .
chung , i.s .
todorov , m.g .
kanatzidis , i. eremin , j. knolle , a.v .
chubukov , s. maiti , m.r .
norman , f. weber , h. claus , t. guidi , r.i .
bewley , and r. osborn , phys .
lett . * 107 * , 177003 ( 2011 ) .
l. wray , d. qian , d. hsieh , y. xia , l. li , j.g .
checkelsky , a. pasupathy , k.k .
gomes , c.v .
parker , a.v .
fedorov , g.f .
chen , j.l .
luo , a. yazdani , n.p .
ong , n.l .
wang , and m.z .
hasan , phys .
b * 78 * , 184508 ( 2008 ) .
t. shimojima , f. sakaguchi , k. ishizaka , y. ishida , t. kiss , m. okawa , t. togashi , c .- t .
chen , s. watanabe , m. arita , k. shimada , h. namatame , m. taniguchi , k. ohgushi , s. kasahara , t. terashima , t. shibauchi , y. matsuda , a. chainani , and s. shin , science * 332 * , 564 ( 2011 ) .
l. zhao , h. liu , w. zhang , j. meng , x. jia , g. liu , x. dong , g.f .
chen , j.l .
luo , n.l .
wang , w. lu , g. wang , y. zhou , y. zhu , x. wang , z. zhao , z. xu , c. chen , and x.j .
zhou , chin .
. lett . * 25 * , 4402 ( 2008 ) . c. zhang , m. wang , h. luo , m. wang , m. liu , j. zhao , d.l .
abernathy , t.a .
maier , k. marty , and m.d .
lumsden , s. chi , s. chang , j.a .
rodriguez - rivera , j.w .
lynn , t. xiang , j. hu , and p. dai , sci . rep .
* 1 * , 115 ( 2011 ) .
m. abdel - hafiez , p.j .
pereira , s.a .
kuzmichev , t.e .
kuzmicheva , v.m .
pudalov , l. harnagea , a.a .
kordyuk , a.v .
silhanek , v.v .
moshchalkov , b. shen , h .- h .
wen , a.n .
vasiliev , and x .- j .
chen , phys .
b * 90 * , 054524 ( 2014 ) .
evtushinsky , d.s .
inosov , v.b .
zabolotnyy , a. koitzsch , m. knupfer , b. bchner , m.s .
viazovska , g.l .
sun , v. hinkov , a.v .
boris , c.t .
lin , b. keimer , a. varykhalov , a.a .
kordyuk , and s.v .
borisenko , phys .
b * 79 * , 054517 ( 2009 ) .
evtushinsky , d.s .
inosov , v.b .
zabolotnyy , m.s .
viazovska , r. khasanov , a. amato , h .- h .
klauss , h. luetkens , ch .
niedermayer , g.l .
sun , v. hinkov , c.t .
lin , a. varykhalov , a. koitzsch , m. knupfer , b. bchner , a.a .
kordyuk , and s.v .
borisenko , new j. phys . * 11 * , 055069 ( 2009 ) .
q. wang , y. shen , b. pan , y. hao , m. ma , f. zhou , p. steffens , k. schmalzl , t.r
. forrest , m. abdel - hafiez , x. chen , d.a .
chareev , a.n .
vasiliev , p. bourges , y. sidis , h. cao , and j. zhao , nature materials * 15 * , 159 ( 2016 ) .
s. kasahara , t. watashige , t. hanaguri , y. kohsaka , t. yamashita , y. shimoyama , y. mizukami , r. endo , h. ikeda , k. aoyama , t. terashima , s. uji , t. wolf , h. von lhneysen , t. shibauchi , and y. matsuda , proc .
usa * 111 * , 16309 ( 2012 ) .
ponomarev , s.a .
kuzmichev , t.e .
kuzmicheva , m.g .
mikheev , m.v .
sudakova , s.n .
tchesnokov , o.s .
volkova , a.n .
vasiliev , v.m .
pudalov , a.v .
sadakov , a.s .
usoltsev , t. wolf , e.p .
khlybov , and l.f .
kulikova , j. supercond .
* 26 * , 2867 ( 2013 ) .
lee , g. xu , w. ku , j.s .
wen , c.c .
lee , n. katayama , z.j .
xu , s. ji , z.w .
lin , g.d .
gu , h .- b .
yang , p.d .
johnson , z .- h . pan , t. valla , m. fujita , t.j .
sato , s. chang , k. yamada , and j.m .
tranquada , phys .
b * 81 * , 220502(r ) ( 2010 ) .
m. ishikado , y. nagai , k. kodama , r. kajimoto , m. nakamura , y. inamura , s. wakimoto , h. nakamura , m. machida , k. suzuki , h. usui , k. kuroki , a. iyo , h. eisaki , m. arai , and s. shamoto , phys .
b * 84 * , 144517 ( 2011 ) . c. zhang , h .- f .
li , y. song , y. su , g. tan , t. netherton , c. redding , s.v .
carr , o. sobolev , a. schneidewind , e. faulhaber , l.w .
harriger , s. li , x. lu , d .- x .
yao , t. das , a.v .
balatsky , th .
brckel , j.w .
lynn , and p. dai , phys .
b * 88 * , 064504 ( 2013 ) .
liu , p. richard , k. nakayama , g .- f .
chen , s. dong , j .- b .
he , d .- m .
wang , t .- l .
xia , k. umezawa , t. kawahara , s. souma , t. sato , t. takahashi , t. qian , yaobo huang , nan xu , yingbo shi , h. ding , and s .- c .
wang , phys .
b * 84 * , 064519 ( 2011 ) . | we study the spin resonance in superconducting state of iron - based materials within multiband models with two unequal gaps , @xmath0 and @xmath1 , on different fermi surface pockets .
we show that due to the indirect nature of the gap entering the spin susceptibility at the nesting wave vector @xmath2 the total gap @xmath3 in the bare susceptibility is determined by the sum of gaps on two different fermi surface sheets connected by @xmath2 . for the fermi surface geometry characteristic to the most of iron pnictides and chalcogenides , the indirect gap is either @xmath4 or @xmath5 . in the @xmath6 state ,
spin excitations below @xmath3 are absent unless additional scattering mechanisms are assumed .
the spin resonance appears in the @xmath7 superconducting state at frequency @xmath8 .
comparison with available inelastic neutron scattering data confirms that what is seen is the true spin resonance and not a peak inherent to the @xmath6 state . |
the presence of impurities usually deeply modify the nature of the spectrum of a quantum system , and thus its coherence and transport properties . in the absence of interactions , if the impurity distribution is completely random , all states of the spectrum are exponentially localized in dimensions one ( 1d ) and two ( 2d ) , while a mobility edge exists in dimensions three ( 3d)@xcite .
if the impurity positions are correlated , as for instance if it exists a minimum distance between the impurities @xcite , some delocalized states can appear in the spectrum .
this was demonstrated in 1d in the context of the random dimer model ( rdm ) and of the dual random dimer model ( drdm ) @xcite . in 1d
, the effects of correlated disorder was studied in different physical contexts ( see for instance @xcite ) . in 2d ,
the effect of correlations is almost unexplored , except for the case of a speckle potential @xcite , and for the case of pseudo-2d random dimer lattices with separable dimensions @xcite .
correlations in speckle potentials may mimic the presence of a mobility edge @xcite , but in the thermodynamic limit all states are localized @xcite .
random dimers introduce a set of delocalized states in pseudo-2d lattices @xcite as in 1d @xcite . from a statistical point of view
, the main difference between these two models is the decay of the correlation function that is algebraic for the first and exponential for the second .
this `` short - range '' feature of the random dimer model is at the basis of the delocalization mechanism . in interacting systems ,
the presence of disordered impurities gives rise to a remarkable richness of phenomena .
for instance , the condensate and the superfluid fraction are modified by the presence of the disorder @xcite , and this can shift the onset of superfluidity @xcite , and , on lattice systems , can induce exotic phases such as the bose glass @xcite . in this work we study the effect of a short - range correlated disorder on a bose gas confined on a 2d square lattice .
first we introduce a 2d generalization of the drdm ( 2d - drdm ) . in such a model
, impurities can not be first neighbours and each impurity also modifies the hopping with its nearest neighbor sites . using a decimation and renormalization procedure @xcite , we show that , in the non - interacting regime , it exists a resonance energy at which the structured impurity is transparent and the states around this energy are delocalized .
it is remarkable that this resonance energy does not depend on the system dimensionality and it is the same as the drdm in 1d @xcite .
then , we consider the case of a weakly interacting bose gas confined on such a potential . within a gutzwiller approach ,
we show that the effect of the 2d - drdm is to drive the homogeneity of the ground state .
the disorder induces a non - monotonic behavior of the condensate spatial delocalization and of the condensate fraction as a function of the disorder strength , and enhances both in correspondence of the resonance energy of 2d - drdm single - particle hamiltonian .
we show that the dependence of such quantities on the interaction strength can be explained by including the effect of the healing length in the resonance condition discussion .
the manuscript is organized as follows . in sec .
[ sec : model ] , we introduce the 2d - drdm potential and we demonstrate its single - particle delocalization properties in the region of the spectrum around the resonance energy .
the effect of such a potential on a weakly - interacting bose gas is studied in sec .
[ sec : results ] , where we also introduce a suitable inverse participation ratio for our many - body system and study it for the case of the 2d - drdm potential and for an uncorrelated random disorder .
moreover , we compute the density distribution and the condensate fraction as functions of the disorder strength . our concluding remarks in sec .
[ sec : concl ] complete this work .
we consider the tight - binding single - particle hamiltonian @xmath0 where @xmath1 are the on - site energies , @xmath2 the first neighbor hopping terms , @xmath3 the number of sites and @xmath4 denotes the sum over first neighbor sites .
we focus on a 2d square lattice of linear dimension @xmath5 ( @xmath6 lattice sites ) , and compare the ordered lattice with @xmath7 and @xmath8 @xmath9 @xmath10 , as schematized in fig .
[ fig1](a ) with a lattice where we introduce an impurity at the site 0 , @xmath11 that modifies the hopping terms involving this site , @xmath12 [ fig .
[ fig1](b ) ] . schematic representation of ( a ) the unperturbed hamiltonian ; ( b ) the hamiltonian in the presence of a single impurity ; ( c ) the effective hamiltonian after decimation of the site 0 in the hamiltonian ( a ) ; ( d ) the effective hamiltonian after decimation of the site 0 in the hamiltonian ( b ) . ] with the aim of understanding the effect of the impurity , we consider the green s function @xmath13 projected on the subspace @xmath14 , including all sites except the site @xmath15 with coordinates @xmath16 .
using a decimation and renormalization technique @xcite , it can be shown that @xmath17 with @xmath18 & \phantom{bla}{\rm site\;of\;the\;site\;}0\\[1 mm ] h_{aa}&\phantom{bla}{\rm elsewhere } \end{array}\right.\ ] ] where @xmath19 . the effective hamiltonian for the unperturbed case in fig . [ fig1 ] ( a ) ,
is schematically illustrated in fig .
[ fig1 ] ( c ) ; whereas the effective hamiltonian for the case with a single impurity in fig .
[ fig1 ] ( b ) , is illustrated in fig.[fig1 ] ( d ) .
the subspace @xmath14 does not `` feel '' the presence of the impurity if @xmath20 ( @xmath21 ) remains the same in the absence or in the presence of the impurity , namely if @xmath22 the condition ( [ condition ] ) is satisfied if @xmath23 .
if @xmath24 is an allowed energy of the system , namely if @xmath25 , at @xmath26 the impurity will not affect the eigenstate at this energy ( in the subspace @xmath14 ) . if we add other impurities in the system , as the one in fig .
[ fig1 ] ( b ) , with the supplementary condition that on - site impurities can not occupy first neighbor sites ( fig .
[ fig2 ] ) , one can repeat the same argument as above , properly redefining the subspace @xmath14 , and one obtains exactly the same condition ( [ condition ] ) imposing that _ all _ the @xmath27 impurities do not perturb the system ( the subspace @xmath14 ) .
thus at @xmath26 , the impurities are transparent as in the 1d drdm @xcite . indeed , with this procedure , we are defining a 2d - drdm , where at each `` isolated '' impurity correspond a structure of 4 hopping terms forming a cross , as shown in fig .
let us remark that this definition of the model provides the same condition ( [ condition ] ) independently from the dimensionality of the system @xcite .
however our model is fully 2d and the hamiltonian can not be mapped onto two 1d drdm as opposed to ref .
@xcite .
schematic representation of the 2d drdm . ] with the aim of analyzing the localization properties of this model , we consider the inverse participation ratio ( ipr ) @xmath28 the symbol @xmath29 denotes the average over different disorder configurations , and @xmath30 the wavefunction on site @xmath31 and at energy @xmath32 . if @xmath33 is an eigenvalue of the system and @xmath34 is an extended state , then @xmath35 decreases as a function of @xmath5 . on the other side ,
if @xmath36 is a localized state , then @xmath35 does not depend on @xmath5 ( if @xmath5 is larger than the localization length ) . in fig .
[ fig3 ] we show the behavior of @xmath37 and @xmath38 ( column left and right respectively ) , for the hamiltonian illustrated in fig .
[ fig2 ] . [ cols="^,^ " , ] we consider three set of parameters , ( i ) @xmath39 and @xmath40 , ( ii ) @xmath41 and @xmath42 , and ( iii ) @xmath43 and @xmath44 that give the same resonance energy , @xmath45 . in all the three cases , the curves @xmath46 collapse around @xmath26 meaning that the states are delocalized in this energy region .
moreover , due to the large strength of the disorder , the spectrum varies considerably for the cases ( ii ) and ( iii ) , and an energy gap appears in ( iii ) . the inverse participation ratio , eq .
( [ eq : ipr ] ) , in two dimensions has the following asymptotic behavior @xcite @xmath47 thus , the asymptotic behavior of the function @xmath48 is @xmath49 with @xmath50 for localized states , and @xmath51 for extended states . in fig .
[ fig : esponenti ] we have analyzed the exponent @xmath52 as a function of the energy for the set of parameters ( iii ) .
we observe a high - energy band of localized states that has been created by the disorder ; the original ( without noise ) band has been distorted , and the states at its boundaries are localized .
the center of the band , around @xmath24 , is mainly constituted of extended states .
the width of the feature around @xmath24 corresponds to the width of the resonance dip of the inverse participation ratio at this energy value ( fig .
[ fig3 ] ) . ) as a function of the energy for @xmath43 and @xmath44 .
the exponent has been obtained using calculations for lattice - linear dimensions @xmath53 averaged over 20 realizations , the error bars correspond to the standard deviation of the fit of the data to eq .
( [ eq : asympatty ] ) .
the vertical dashed line indicates @xmath24 . ]
these results confirm that our 2d extension of the drdm introduced by dunlap and collaborators in ref .
@xcite for 1d systems introduces a set of delocalized states even at higher dimensions .
we now consider the case of weakly interacting bosons in the presence of the potential defined in sec .
[ sec : model ] .
this system is described by the bose - hubbard hamiltonian in the grand canonical ensemble @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the creation operator defined at the lattice site @xmath31 , @xmath56 , @xmath57 the interparticle on - site interaction strength , and @xmath58 denotes the chemical potential fixing the average number of bosons .
we use a gutzwiller approach to find the ground state wavefunction for a given set of parameters and average number of particles .
the gutzwiller ansatz is given by the site product wavefunction in the occupation number representation @xmath59 where @xmath60 are the probability amplitudes of finding @xmath61 particles on site @xmath31 .
the ansatz provides an interpolating approximation correctly describing both the bose - condensed and mott - insulating phases for low and high @xmath57 , respectively , in dimensions larger than one .
in addition , the approximation becomes exact for all @xmath57 in the limit of infinite dimensions @xcite .
we minimize the average energy given by hamiltonian ( [ eq : bhgw ] ) as a function of the set of amplitudes @xmath60 with the normalization and average number of particle constraint for at least 30 disorder realizations for each set of parameters .
the minimization is done using standard conjugate - gradient and/or broyden - fisher techniques @xcite which provides reasonable performance for moderate lattice sizes . to quantify the extent of delocalization of the ground state @xmath62 in the interacting regime
, we decompose it onto the localized basis @xmath63 , @xmath64 , representing the distribution of a homogeneous condensate with average density @xmath65 on the lattice @xcite .
we define the many - body ground - state ipr @xmath66 with respect to this basis as @xmath67 @xmath66 measures the homogeneity of the ground state in the condensation regime : the smaller @xmath66 the more spatially delocalized is the condensate . in fig .
[ fig : igs_l20 ] we show the behavior of @xmath66 as a function of @xmath68 , by fixing @xmath69 , @xmath70 and @xmath71 , for several values of @xmath72 .
( color online ) @xmath73 as a function of @xmath74 for @xmath69 , @xmath70 and @xmath71 particles per site .
the different curves correspond to different values of @xmath72 as indicated in the figure .
the filled symbols correspond to the 2d - drdm potential and the empty symbols correspond to the un - rand potential . ]
we compare the case of @xmath75 of correlated impurities @xmath27 with the one of the same percentage of uncorrelated impurities , where there is no restriction for the position distribution of the on - site impurities @xmath68 and no correlations between them and the additional hopping @xmath72 ( un - rand ) .
we note that due to the correlations present in the 2d - drdm the maximum percentage of allowed impurities is @xmath76 ( in this limit the system would be an ordered checkerboard ) .
we can observe that , in the case of the 2d - drdm potential , @xmath66 has a minimum as a function of @xmath68 , whose position depends on the value of @xmath72 .
this non - monotonic behavior is a signature of the resonance induced by the correlations of the disordered potential .
indeed , it disappears for the case of the un - rand potential and for large values of @xmath72 ( strong disorder ) .
the dip in the @xmath66 for the un - rand potential and weak disorder ( @xmath40 ) indicates that some drdm impurities may still statistically appear , in the absence of correlations .
the effect of such impurities is not fully destroyed by the other defects only if the strength of the disorder is weak . in the perturbative regime for negligible interactions , one would expect that correlations modify the ground state if @xmath77 , @xmath78 being the ground - state energy per particle , which corresponds to @xmath79 in the weak disorder regime .
this condition , that can be written @xmath80 , \label{cond - pat}\ ] ] determines the location of the minimum of @xmath66 at @xmath81 for @xmath40 , @xmath82 for @xmath42 , and @xmath83 for @xmath44 .
however , in the limit of strong disorder , due to the interactions these values strongly differ from those shown in fig .
[ fig : igs_l20 ] .
in fact , we calculate @xmath66 for smaller values of @xmath65 and verify that the minimum location of @xmath66 depends on @xmath24 and that the shift observed is indeed an effect of the interactions .
the results are illustrated in fig .
[ fig : igs_l20_n ] , where we focus on the case @xmath42 .
( color online ) @xmath73 as a function of @xmath74 for @xmath69 , @xmath84 and @xmath42 .
the different curves correspond to different values of the average density @xmath65 as indicated in the figure .
all the curves correspond to the 2d - drdm potential .
the vertical dashed line indicates the non - interacting resonance condition given in eq .
( [ cond - pat ] ) . ] by decreasing the value of @xmath65 , the minimum position @xmath85 of @xmath66 shifts from @xmath86 to about @xmath87 as expected by the perturbative argument .
this shift can be understood as follows .
the interactions introduce the so - called healing length @xmath88 @xcite that represents a coherence length over which the system feels the effect of an impurity , or in other words , the distance a site affects its neighborhood . for @xmath70 and @xmath65 from 20 to 5 , the value of @xmath89 ranges approximately from @xmath90 to 3 lattice spacing @xmath91 , which shows that , already for this @xmath57 value , the role of the interactions is important , effectively reducing the coherence length . to quantify this effect , we can partition the system into independent boxes of dimension @xmath92 , and use a mode - matching argument to determine their ground states : the condensate is more homogeneous if the lowest eigenvalue of each box is the same despite the presence of an impurity .
( color online)boxes of different sizes , in the presence and in the absence of an impurity . ]
therefore , this mode - matching argument fixes the value of @xmath68 . for the case @xmath70 and @xmath71 , @xmath93 , and this gives @xmath94 while for @xmath95 , @xmath96 , and we expect to find @xmath97 , in good agreement with the results showed in fig .
[ fig : igs_l20_n ] .
namely , the larger is @xmath89 , the better we recover the non - interacting condition eq .
( [ cond - pat ] ) .
this effect is summarized in table [ tab : uloco ] .
ccc @xmath98 & fig . & @xmath68 + + @xmath91 & [ figboxes](a)&@xmath99 $ ] + @xmath100 & [ figboxes](b ) & @xmath101 $ ] + @xmath102 & [ figboxes](c ) & @xmath103 $ ] + we remark that this mode - matching condition is equivalent to match the resonance energy @xmath24 with the lowest eigenvalue of the unperturbed system of size @xmath92 . these simple arguments ,
allow us to understand the shift of @xmath68 as a function of the interaction energy @xmath104 and the role of the structured impurities in the presence of the interactions .
we study the scaling behavior of @xmath73 with respect to @xmath5 .
analogously to the case of the single - particle ipr @xmath105 [ see eq .
( [ eq : asympatty ] ) ] , we expect that @xmath106 with @xmath50 for a condensate localized on few sites , and @xmath51 for a homogeneous extended condensate . the behavior of @xmath73 for different values of @xmath5 is shown in fig .
[ fig : igs_l ] .
( color online ) @xmath73 as a function of @xmath74 for @xmath42 , @xmath70 and @xmath71 particles per site .
the different curves correspond to different values of @xmath5 as indicated in the figure .
the filled symbols correspond to the 2d - drdm potential and the empty symbols correspond to the un - rand potential . ]
we observe that the minima , corresponding to different system sizes , collapse all together , meaning that the ground state corresponds to a spatial homogeneous condensate in the parameter regime where the correlations are dominant . at lower values of @xmath68 , @xmath73 scales as @xmath107 , and larger values of @xmath68 , @xmath73 scales as @xmath108 , with @xmath109 and @xmath110 @xmath111 .
this sort of `` super - delocalization '' , in the low @xmath68 region , is determined by the large value of @xmath72 that compensates , in the structured impurities , the effect of the site defect .
indeed , we observe an analogous behavior for the un - rand potential .
for such a potential , where the effect of @xmath72 is no more dominant , all the curves collapse together .
thus we expect that in this region the effect of the uncorrelated impurities on the ground state density distribution does not depend on the system size . with the aim of characterizing the ground state configurations in the different regions , we show in figs .
[ fig : denlatt2.1][fig : denlatt15.1 ] the spatial density distribution @xmath61 for @xmath69 , @xmath71 at @xmath112 ( fig .
[ fig : denlatt2.1 ] ) , @xmath113 ( fig . [ fig : denlatt6.6 ] ) , and @xmath114 ( fig . [ fig : denlatt15.1 ] ) together with a pattern showing the locations of impurities .
( color online ) lattice density plots together with site and bond impurities locations for @xmath42 , @xmath115 and drdm disorder ( top ) and un - rand ( bottom).,title="fig : " ] + ( color online ) lattice density plots together with site and bond impurities locations for @xmath42 , @xmath115 and drdm disorder ( top ) and un - rand ( bottom).,title="fig : " ] ( color online ) same as fig .
[ fig : denlatt6.6 ] for @xmath116.,title="fig : " ] + ( color online ) same as fig .
[ fig : denlatt6.6 ] for @xmath116.,title="fig : " ] ( color online ) same as fig .
[ fig : denlatt6.6 ] for @xmath117.,title="fig : " ] + ( color online ) same as fig .
[ fig : denlatt6.6 ] for @xmath117.,title="fig : " ] the addition of a hopping term @xmath72 favors the delocalization of the density both for the 2d - drdm and un - rand disorders .
however , in the case of the 2d - drdm , it is more beneficial as it tends to partially compensate the decrease in the density caused by the site impurity , reducing the decrease by means of the structured disorder .
for small values of @xmath68 ( see fig . [
fig : denlatt2.1 ] ) , in the region where the effect of @xmath72 is dominant , the density in the impurity regions is even larger with respect to the density elsewhere . for large values of @xmath68 ( see fig . [
fig : denlatt15.1 ] ) , the effect of both types of disorder is similar as the change in the on - site energies dominates .
this limit gives rise to a strongly depleted density at the impurity location plus a rather uniform background .
the largest differences among the 2d - drdm and un - rand results are seen at the minimum of @xmath66 ( see fig.[fig : denlatt6.6 ] ) , where we can clearly observe a more homogeneous density spread over the lattice ( lower @xmath66 ) , and a consequently larger delocalization for the 2d - drdm than for the un - rand potential .
the density behavior determines the condensate fraction @xmath118 , as shown in fig .
[ fig : n0_l ] .
( color online ) condensate fraction @xmath119 as a function of @xmath74 for @xmath42 , @xmath70 and @xmath71 particles per site .
the different curves correspond to different values of @xmath5 as indicated in the figure .
the filled symbols correspond to the 2d - drdm potential and the empty symbols correspond to the un - rand potential . ] in correspondence of the minimum of the function @xmath66 , we observe that the condensate fraction @xmath119 does not depends of the system size , in the presence of the 2d - drdm potential .
the resonance condition minimizes the fluctuations with respect the chosen homogeneous basis @xmath63 and fixes @xmath119 . at lower value of @xmath68
, we observe a `` super - delocalization '' ( @xmath73 scales as @xmath107 ) , and for both the 2d - drdm and the un - rand potentials , the large value of @xmath72 enhances the coherence and @xmath119 increases with system size . at larger values of @xmath68 , where @xmath73 scales as @xmath108 , the 2d - drdm impurities create holes in the system , and @xmath119 decreases with system size . for the case of the un - rand potential
, one can observe a monotonic behavior of @xmath119 as a function of @xmath68 .
as for the case of the 2d - drdm , the region where all the curves @xmath73 collapse together corresponds to a region where @xmath119 does not depend on the system size .
the difference with the 2d - drdm is a larger decrease of @xmath119 in this region . for 2d - drdm , only one value of @xmath68 has this peculiarity , and the maximum position of the condensate fraction foregoes this point .
let us remark that the minimum of @xmath120 corresponds to the minimum deviation with respect a homogeneous condensate , and , because of border effects , this target state is not necessarily the one that ensures a maximum value of @xmath119 in finite systems .
the predicted condensate fraction enhancement for the drdm at low @xmath68 , being it very small , could be very difficult to be measured .
however the non - diminishing of the coherence in a range of about @xmath121 should be observable , and could be directly compared with the result for the un - rand where the decrease of the coherence should be sizable .
in summary , we introduce a correlated disorder model that is the natural extension of the drdm in 2d .
we show that , in the non - interacting regime , such a disorder introduces some delocalized states if the resonance energy characterizing these structures belongs to the spectrum of the unperturbed system . in the presence of weak interactions
, the 2d - drdm drives the density spatial fluctuations . by means of a mode - matching argument that includes the effect of the interactions ,
we show that the resonance energy is at the origin of these phenomena .
a direct consequence is a non - monotonic behavior of the condensate fraction as a function of the disorder strength , and its enhancement for values close to the resonance condition .
this work shows that short - range correlations in a disordered potential can modify and enhance the coherence of a many - body system in the weak interacting regime .
such effects could be measured in the context of ultracold atoms with an accurate measurement of the density and coherence , via , for instance , a fringes contrast interference experiment .
our results could also be extended to homogeneous systems provided one is able to engineer suitable impurities that are transparent for a given energy . | we introduce a two - dimensional short - range correlated disorder that is the natural generalization of the well - known one - dimensional dual random dimer model [ phys .
rev .
lett * 65 * , 88 ( 1990 ) ] .
we demonstrate that , as in one dimension , this model induces a localization - delocalization transition in the single - particle spectrum .
moreover we show that the effect of such a disorder on a weakly - interacting boson gas is to enhance the condensate spatial homogeneity and delocalisation , and to increase the condensate fraction around an effective resonance of the two - dimensional dual dimers .
this study proves that short - range correlations of a disordered potential can enhance the quantum coherence of a weakly - interacting many - body system . |
the scope of the growing field of complexity science `` ( or complex systems '' ) includes a broad variety of problems belonging to different scientific areas .
examples for complex systems `` can be found in physics , biology , computer science , ecology , economy , sociology and other fields .
a recurring theme in most of what is classified as complex systems '' is that of _ emergence_. emergent properties are those which arise spontaneously from the collective dynamics of a large assemblage of interacting parts .
a basic question one asks in this context is how to derive and predict the emergent properties from the behavior of the individual parts .
in other words , the central issue is how to extract large - scale , global properties from the underlying or microscopic degrees of freedom . in the physical sciences ,
there are many examples of emergent phenomena where it is indeed possible to relate the microscopic and macroscopic worlds .
physical systems are typically described in terms of equations of motion of a huge number of microscopic degrees of freedom ( e.g. atoms ) .
the microscopic dynamics is often erratic and complex , yet in many cases it gives rise to patterns with characteristic length and time scales much larger than the microscopic ones ( e.g. the pressure and temperature of a gas ) .
these large scale patterns often posses the interesting , physically relevant properties of the system and one would like to model them or simulate their behavior . an important problem in physics is therefore to understand and predict the emergence of large scale behavior in a system , starting from its microscopic description .
this problem is a fundamental one because most physical systems contain too many parts to be simulated directly and would become intractable without a large reduction in the number of degrees of freedom .
a useful way to address this issue is to construct coarse - grained models , which treat the dynamics of the large scale patterns .
the derivation of coarse - grained models from the microscopic dynamics is far from trivial . in most cases
it is done in a phenomenological manner by introducing various ( often uncontrolled ) approximations .
the problem of predicting emergent properties is most severe in systems which are modelled or described by _
undecidable _ mathematical algorithms@xcite . for such systems
there exists no computationally efficient way of predicting their long time evolution . in order to know the system s state after ( e.g. ) one million time steps one must evolve the system a million time steps or perform a computation of equivalent complexity .
wolfram has termed such systems _ computationally irreducible _ and suggested that their existence in nature is at the root of our apparent inability to model and understand complex systems @xcite .
it is tempting to conclude from this that the enterprise of physics itself is doomed from the outset ; rather than attempting to construct solvable mathematical models of physical processes , computational models should be built , explored and empirically analyzed .
this argument , however , assumes that infinite precision is required for the prediction of future evolution .
as we mentioned above , usually coarse - grained or even statistical information is sufficient . an interesting question that arises is therefore : is it possible to derive coarse - grained models of undecidable systems and can these coarse - grained models be decidable and predictable ? in this work
we address the emergence of large scale patterns in complex systems and the associated predictability problems by studying cellular - automata ( ca ) .
ca are spatially and temporally discrete dynamical systems composed of a lattice of cells .
they were originally introduced by von neumann and ulam @xcite in the 1940 s as a possible way of simulating self - reproduction in biological systems . since then , ca have attracted a great deal of interest in physics @xcite because they capture two basic ingredients of many physical systems : 1 ) they evolve according to a local uniform rule .
2 ) ca can exhibit rich behavior even with very simple update rules .
for similar and other reasons , ca have also attracted attention in computer science @xcite , biology @xcite , material science @xcite and many other fields . for a review on the literature on ca see refs . .
the simple construction of ca makes them accessible to computational theoretic research methods . using these methods it is sometimes possible to quantify the complexity of ca rules according to the types of computations they are capable of performing .
this together with the fact that ca are caricatures of physical systems has led many authors to use them as a conceptual vehicle for studying complexity and pattern formation . in this work
we adopt this approach and study the predictability of emergent patterns in complex systems by attempting to systematically coarse - grain ca .
a brief preliminary report of our project can be found in ref . .
there is no unique way to define coarse - graining , but here we will mean that our information about the ca is locally coarse - grained in the sense of being stroboscopic in time , but that nearby cells are grouped into a supercell according to some specified rule ( as is frequently done in statistical physics ) . below we shall frequently drop the qualifier `` local '' whenever there is no cause for confusion .
a system which can be coarse - grained is _ compact - able _ since it is possible to calculate its future time evolution ( or some coarse aspects of it ) using a more compact algorithm than its native description .
note that our use of the term compact - able refers to the phase space reduction associated with coarse - graining , and is agnostic as to whether or not the coarse - grained system is decidable or undecidable .
accordingly , we define _ predictable _ to mean that a system is decidable or has a decidable coarse - graining . thus , it is possible to calculate the future time evolution of a predictable system ( or some coarse aspects of it ) using an algorithm which is more compact than both the native and coarse - grained descriptions .
our work is organized as follows . in section [ ca_intro ]
we give an introduction to ca and their use in the study of complexity . in section [ cg_procedure ]
we present a procedure for coarse - graining ca .
section [ cg_results ] shows and discusses the results of applying our procedure to one dimensional ca .
most of the ca that we attempt to coarse - grain are wolfram s 256 elementary rules for nearest - neighbor ca .
we will also consider a few other rules of special interest . in section [ kolmogorov_complexity ]
we consider whether the coarse - grain - ability of many ca that we found in the elementary rule family is a common property of ca .
using computational theoretic arguments we argue that the large scale behavior of local processes must be very simple .
almost all ca can therefore be coarse - grained if we go to a large enough scale .
our results are summarized and discussed in [ conclusions ] .
cellular automata are a class of homogeneous , local and fully discrete dynamical systems
. a cellular automaton @xmath0 is composed of a lattice @xmath1 of cells that can each assume a value from a finite alphabet @xmath2 .
we denote individual lattice cells by @xmath3 where the indexing reflects the dimensionality and geometry of the lattice .
cell values evolve in discrete time steps according to the pre - prescribed update rule @xmath4 .
the update rule determines a cell s new state as a function of cell values in a finite neighborhood .
for example , in the case of a one dimensional , nearest - neighbor ca the update rule is a function @xmath5 and @xmath6 $ ] . at each time step
, each cell in the lattice applies the update rule and updates its state accordingly . the application of the update rule is done in parallel for all the cells and all the cells apply the same rule .
we denote the application of the update rule on the entire lattice by @xmath7 . in early work
@xcite , wolfram proposed that ca can be grouped into four classes of complexity .
class 1 consists of ca whose dynamics reaches a steady state regardless of the initial conditions .
class 2 consists of ca whose long time evolution produces periodic or nested structures .
ca from both of these classes are simple in the sense that their long time evolution can be deduced from running the system a small number of time steps . on the other hand , class 3 and class 4 consist of complex " ca .
class 3 ca produce structures that seem random . class 4 ca produce localized structures that propagate and interact in a complex way above a regular background .
this classification is heuristic and the assignment of ca to the four classes is somewhat subjective .
successive works on ca attempted to improve it or to find better alternatives@xcite . to the best of our knowledge
there is , to date , no universally agreed upon classification scheme of ca . based on numerical experiments ,
wolfram hypothesized that most of class 3 and 4 ca are _ computationally irreducible_@xcite .
namely , the evolution of these ca can not be predicted by a process which is drastically more efficient than themselves . in order to calculate the state of a computationally irreducible ca after @xmath8 time steps , one must run the ca for @xmath8 time steps or perform a computation of equivalent complexity .
this definition is somewhat loose because it is not always clear how to compare computation running times and efficiency on different architectures .
in addition , wolfram recognized that even computationally irreducible systems may have some superficial reducibility `` ( see page 746 in ref . ) and can be reduced to a limited extent .
the difference between superficial '' and true reducibility however is not well defined .
it is nevertheless clear that the asymptotic @xmath9 behavior of a computationally irreducible system can not be predicted by any computation of finite size .
wolfram further argued that computationally irreducible systems are abundant in nature and that this fact explains our inability as physicists to deal with complex systems @xcite .
it is difficult in general to tell whether a ca , behaving in an apparently complex way , is computationally irreducible .
more concrete properties of ca which are related to computational irreducibility are _ undecidability _ and _ universality_. mathematical processes are said to be undecidable when there can be no algorithm that is guaranteed to predict their outcome in a finite time .
equivalently , ca are said to be undecidable when aspects of their dynamics are undecidable .
computationally irreducible ca are therefore undecidable and in the weak asymptotic definition that we gave above , computational irreducibility is equivalent to undecidability . for lack of a better choice
we adopt this asymptotic definition and in the reminder of this work we will use the two terms interchangeably . some ca are known to be universal turing machines@xcite and are capable of performing all computations done by other processes .
a famous two dimensional example is conway s game of life@xcite ; several examples in one dimension are lindgren and nordahl @xcite , albert and culik @xcite and wolfram s rule 110 @xcite .
universal ca are , in a sense , maximally complex because they can emulate the dynamics of all other ca .
being universal turing machines , these ca are subject to undecidable questions regarding their dynamics@xcite .
for example whether an initial state will ever decay into a quiescent state is the ca equivalence of the undecidable halting problem@xcite .
universal ca are therefore undecidable .
wolfram s classification of ca is topological in the sense that ca are classified according to the properties of their trajectories . a different , more ambitious
, approach is to classify ca according to a parameter derived directly from their rule tables .
langton @xcite suggested that ca rules can be parameterized by his @xmath10 parameter which measures the fraction of non - quiescence rule table entries .
he showed a strong correlation between the value of @xmath10 and the complexity found in the ca trajectories . for small values of @xmath10 one
characteristically finds class 1 and 2 behavior while for @xmath11 a class 3 behavior is usually observed .
langton identified a narrow region of intermediate values of @xmath10 where he found class 4 characteristic behavior .
based on these observations langton proposed the _ edge of chaos _ hypothesis@xcite .
this hypothesis claims that in the space of dynamical systems , interesting systems which are capable of computation are located at the boundary between simple and chaotic systems .
this appealing hypothesis however was criticized in later works @xcite .
recently , a different parametrization of ca rule tables was proposed by dubacq et al .
this new approach is based on the information content of the rule table as measured by its kolmogorov complexity .
as we will show below , our results lend support to this notion and indicate that rule tables with low kolmogorov complexity lead to simple behavior and vice versa .
in addition to attempts to find order and hierarchy in the space of ca rules , much research has been devoted to the study of ca classes with special properties .
additive ca ( or linear ) @xcite , commuting ca @xcite and ca with certain algebraic properties @xcite are a few examples .
unsurprisingly , the dynamics of ca which enjoy such special properties can in most cases be understood and predictable at some level . in this work
we will mostly be concerned with the family of one dimensional , nearest neighbor binary ca that were the subject of wolfram s investigations .
these 256 elementary rules are among the simplest imaginable ca and thus present us with the least computational challenges when attempting to coarse - grain them .
we will use wolfram s notation@xcite for identifying individual rules .
the update function of an elementary rule is described by a rule number between 0 and 255 . the eight bit binary representation of the rule number specifies the update function outcome for the eight possible three cell configurations ( where 000 `` is the least significant and 111 '' is the most significant bit ) .
ca are often conveniently visualized with different colors denoting different cell values .
when dealing with binary ca we will use the convention @xmath12 , @xmath13 and use the two notations interchangeably .
we now turn to study the emergence of large scale patterns in ca and the associated predictability problems by attempting to coarse - grain ca .
there are many ways to define a coarse - graining of a dynamical system . in this work
we define it as a ( real - space ) renormalization scheme where the original ca @xmath0 is coarse - grained to a renormlized ca @xmath14 through the lattice transformation @xmath15 . the projection function @xmath16 projects the value of a block of @xmath17 cells in @xmath18 , which we term a _ supercell _ , to a single cell in @xmath19 . by writing @xmath20
we denote the block - wise application of @xmath21 on the entire lattice @xmath22 .
only non - trivial cases where @xmath21 is irreversible are considered because we want @xmath19 to provide a partial account of the full dynamics of @xmath18 . in order for @xmath19 and @xmath21 to provide a coarse - grained emulation of @xmath18
they must satisfy the commutativity condition @xmath23 for every initial condition @xmath24 of @xmath18 .
the constant @xmath25 in the above equation is a time scale associated with the coarse - graining . a repeated application of eq.([coarse - graining_def ] )
shows that @xmath26 for all @xmath8 .
namely , running the original ca for @xmath27 time steps and then projecting is equivalent to projecting the initial condition and then running the renormalized ca for @xmath8 time steps .
thus , if we are only interested in the projected information we can run the more efficient ca @xmath19 .
renormalization group transformations in statistical physics are usually performed with projection operators that arise from a physical intuition and understanding of the system in question .
majority rules and different types of averages are often the projection operators of choice . in this work
we have the advantage that the ca we wish to coarse - grain are fully discrete systems and the number of possible projections of a supercell of size @xmath17 is finite .
we will therefore consider all possible ( at least with small supercells ) projection operators and will not restrict ourselves to coarse - graining by averaging .
in addition , the discrete nature of ca makes it very difficult to find useful approximate solutions of eq.([coarse - graining_def ] ) because there is no natural small parameter that can be used to construct perturbative coarse - graining schemes .
we therefore require that eq .
( [ coarse - graining_def ] ) is satisfied exactly .
we now define a simple procedure for coarse - graining ca .
other constructions are undoubtedly possible .
for simplicity we limit our treatment to one - dimensional systems with nearest neighbor interactions .
generalizations to higher dimensions and different interaction radii are straightforward .
the commutativity condition eq . ( [ coarse - graining_def ] ) implies that the renormlized ca @xmath19 is homomorphic to the dynamics of @xmath18 on the scale defined by the supercell size @xmath17 . to search for explicit coarse - graining rules
, we define the @xmath17th supercell version @xmath28 of @xmath18 .
each cell of @xmath29 represents @xmath17 cells of @xmath18 and accepts values from the alphabet @xmath30 which includes all possible configurations of @xmath17 cells in @xmath18 .
the transition function @xmath31 of the supercell ca can be defined in many ways depending on our choice of the supercells interaction radius .
here we choose @xmath29 to be a nearest neighbor ca and compute @xmath32 by running @xmath18 for @xmath17 time steps on all possible initial conditions of length @xmath33 . in this way
@xmath29 follows the dynamics of @xmath18 and each application of @xmath29 computes the evolution of a block of @xmath17 cells of @xmath18 , for @xmath17 time steps
. this choice will later result in a coarse - grained ca @xmath19 which is itself nearest - neighbor .
this is convenient because it enables us to compare the original and coarse - grained systems .
another convenient feature of this construction is that it renders the coarse - graining time scale @xmath25 equal to the supercell size @xmath17 .
other constructions however are undoubtedly possible .
note that @xmath29 is not a coarse - graining of @xmath18 because no information was lost in the cell translation .
next we attempt to generate the coarse ca @xmath19 by projecting the alphabet of @xmath29 on a subset @xmath34 which will serve as the alphabet of @xmath19 .
this is the key step where information is being lost .
the transition function @xmath35 is constructed from @xmath31 by projecting its arguments and outcome : @xmath36= p\left(f_{a^n}\left[x_1,x_2,x_3\right]\right ) .
\label{fb_mv_construction}\ ] ] here @xmath37 denotes the projection of the supercell value @xmath38 .
this construction is possible only if @xmath39\right)&= & p\left(f_{a^n}\left[y_1,y_2,y_3\right]\right ) , \nonumber \\ & & \forall \left(x , y|p(x_i)=p(y_i)\right ) .
\label{trans_func_projection}\end{aligned}\ ] ] otherwise , @xmath35 is multi - valued and our coarse - graining attempt fails for the specific choice of @xmath17 and @xmath21 .
equations ( [ fb_mv_construction ] ) and ( [ trans_func_projection ] ) can also be cast in the matrix form @xmath40 which may be useful .
here @xmath29 is an @xmath41 matrix which specify the @xmath17 cell block output for every possible combination of @xmath33 cells .
@xmath21 is an @xmath42 matrix that project from @xmath43 to @xmath44 .
@xmath45 is a @xmath46 matrix which projects 3 consecutive super cells and is a ( simple ) function of @xmath21 .
the coarse - grained ca @xmath19 is an @xmath47 matrix and is also a function of @xmath21 .
this is a greatly over determined equation for the projection operator @xmath21 . for a given value of @xmath17 and @xmath44
the equation contains @xmath48 constraints while @xmath21 is defined by @xmath43 free parameters . in cases
where eq .
( [ trans_func_projection ] ) is satisfied , the resulting ca @xmath19 is a coarse - graining of @xmath29 with a time scale @xmath49 . for every step @xmath50 $ ] of @xmath29 , @xmath19 makes the move @xmath51 \\ & = & p\left(f_{a^n}\left[a^n_{n-1}(t),a^n_n(t),a^n_{n+1}(t)\right]\right ) \nonumber \\ & = & p\left(a^n_n(t+1)\right)\ ; , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] and therefore satisfies eq .
( [ coarse - graining_def ] ) . since a single time step of @xmath29 computes @xmath17 time steps of @xmath18 , @xmath19 is also a coarse - graining of @xmath18 with a coarse - grained time scale @xmath52 .
analogies of these operators have been used in attempts to reduce the computational complexity of certain stochastic partial differential equations @xcite .
similar ideas have been used to calculate critical exponents in probabilistic ca @xcite . to illustrate our method
let us give a simple example .
rule 128 is a class 1 elementary ca defined on the @xmath53 alphabet with the update function @xmath54= } \nonumber \\ & & \left\ { \begin{array}{l } \square\;,\;x_{n-1},x_n , x_{n+1}\neq \blacksquare,\blacksquare,\blacksquare \\ \blacksquare\;,\;x_{n-1},x_n , x_{n+1}=\blacksquare,\blacksquare,\blacksquare\\ \end{array } \right . \;.
\label{f128}\end{aligned}\ ] ] figure [ cgof146figure ] b ) shows a typical evolution of this simple rule where all black regions which are in contact with white cells decay at a constant rate . to coarse - grain rule 128
we choose a supercell size @xmath55 and calculate the supercell update function @xmath56= } \nonumber \\ & & \left\ { \begin{array}{l } \blacksquare\blacksquare\;,\;y_{n-1},y_n , y_{n+1}=\blacksquare\blacksquare,\blacksquare\blacksquare,\blacksquare\blacksquare \\
\square\blacksquare\;,\;y_{n-1},y_n , y_{n+1}=\square\blacksquare,\blacksquare\blacksquare,\blacksquare\blacksquare \\
\blacksquare\square\;,\;y_{n-1},y_n , y_{n+1}=\blacksquare\blacksquare,\blacksquare\blacksquare,\blacksquare\square \\ \square\square\;,\;\mbox{all other combinations } \end{array } \right.\;. \label{rule128supercellf}\end{aligned}\ ] ]
next we project the supercell alphabet using @xmath57 namely , the value of the coarse - grained cell is black only when the supercell value corresponds to two black cells .
applying this projection to the supercell update function eq.([rule128supercellf ] ) we find that @xmath58\right)= } \nonumber \\ & & \left\ { \begin{array}{l } \blacksquare\;,\;p(y_{n-1}),p(y_n),p(y_{n+1})=\blacksquare,\blacksquare,\blacksquare \\
\end{array } \right .
\;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is identical to the original update function @xmath59 .
rule 128 can therefore be coarse - grained to itself , an expected result due to the scale invariant behavior of this simple rule .
it is interesting to notice that the above coarse - graining procedure can lose two very different types of dynamic information . to see this ,
consider eq.([trans_func_projection ] ) .
this equation can be satisfied in two ways .
in the first case @xmath60&=&f_{a^n}\left[y_1 , y_2,y_3\right],\nonumber \\ & & \forall \left(x , y|p(x_i)=p(y_i)\right)\ ; , \label{irrelevant_cond}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which necessarily leads to eq .
( [ trans_func_projection ] ) .
@xmath31 in this case is insensitive to the projection of its arguments .
the distinction between two variables which are identical under projection is therefore _ irrelevant _ to the dynamics of @xmath29 , and by construction to the long time dynamics of @xmath18 . by eliminating irrelevant degrees of freedom ( dof ) , coarse - graining of this type
removes information which is redundant on the microscopic scale .
the coarse ca in this case accounts for all possible long time trajectories of the original ca and the complexity classification of the two ca is therefore the same . in the second case eq .
( [ trans_func_projection ] ) is satisfied even though eq .
( [ irrelevant_cond ] ) is violated . here
the distinction between two variables which are identical under projection is _ relevant _ to the dynamics of @xmath18 .
replacing @xmath38 by @xmath61 in the initial condition may give rise to a difference in the dynamics of @xmath18 .
moreover , the difference can be ( and in many occasions is ) unbounded in space and time .
coarse - graining in this case is possible because the difference is constrained in the cell state space by the projection operator .
namely , projection of all such different dynamics results in the same coarse - grained behavior .
note that the coarse ca in this case can not account for all possible long time trajectories of the original one .
it is therefore possible for the original and coarse ca to fall into different complexity classifications .
coarse - graining by elimination of relevant dof removes information which is not redundant with respect to the original system .
the information becomes redundant only when moving to the coarse scale .
in fact , redundant " becomes a subjective qualifier here since it depends on our choice of coarse description .
in other words , it depends on what aspects of the microscopic dynamics we want the coarse ca to capture .
let us illustrate the difference between coarse - graining of relevant and irrelevant dof .
consider a dynamical system whose initial condition is in the vicinity of two limit cycles .
depending on the initial condition , the system will flow to one of the two cycles .
coarse - graining of irrelevant dof can project all the initial conditions on to two possible long time behaviors . now consider a system which is chaotic with two strange attractors .
coarse - graining irrelevant dof is inappropriate because the dynamics is sensitive to small changes in the initial conditions .
coarse - graining of relevant dof is appropriate , however .
the resulting coarse - grained system will distinguish between trajectories that circle the first or second attractor , but will be insensitive to the details of those trajectories . in a sense , this is analogous to the subtleties encountered in constructing renormalization group transformations for the critical behavior of antiferromagnets@xcite .
the coarse - graining procedure we described above is not constructive , but instead is a self - consistency condition on a putative coarse - graining rule with a specific supercell size @xmath17 and projection operator @xmath21 . in many cases the single - valuedness condition eq.([trans_func_projection ] ) is not satisfied , the coarse - graining fails and one must try other choices of @xmath17 and @xmath21 .
it is therefore natural to ask the following questions .
can all ca be coarse - grained ? if not , which ca can be coarse - grained and which can not ? what types of coarse - graining transitions can we hope to find ? to answer these questions we tried systematically to coarse - grain one dimensional ca .
we considered wolfram s 256 elementary rules and several non - binary ca of interest to us .
our coarse - graining procedure was applied to each rule with different choices of @xmath17 and @xmath21 . in this way we were able to coarse - grain 240 out of the 256 elementary ca .
these 240 coarse - grained - able rules include members of all four classes .
the 16 elementary ca which we could not coarse - grain are rules 30 , 45 , 106 , 154 and their symmetries .
rules 30 , 45 and 106 belong to class 3 while 154 is a class 2 rule .
we do nt know if our inability to coarse - grain these 16 rules comes from limited computing power or from something deeper .
we suspect ( and give arguments in section [ kolmogorov_complexity ] ) the former .
the number of possible projection operators @xmath21 grows very fast with @xmath17 . even for small @xmath17 ,
it is computationally impossible to scan all possible @xmath21 . in order to find valid projections , we therefore used two simple search strategies . in the first strategy
, we looked for coarse - graining transitions within the elementary ca family by considering @xmath21 which project back on the binary alphabet . excluding the trivial projections @xmath62 and @xmath63 there are @xmath64 such projections .
we were able to scan all of them for @xmath65 and found many coarse - graining transitions .
figure [ mapfigure ] shows a map of the coarse - graining transitions that we found within the family of elementary rules .
an arrow in the map indicates that each rule from the origin group can be coarse - grained to each rule from the target group .
the supercell size @xmath17 and the projection @xmath21 are not shown and each arrow may correspond to several choices of @xmath17 and @xmath21 . as we explained above , only coarse - grainings with @xmath66 are shown due to limited computing power .
other transitions within the elementary rule family may exist with larger values of @xmath17 .
this map is in some sense an analogue of the familiar renormalization group flow diagrams from statistical mechanics .
several features of fig .
[ mapfigure ] are worthy of a short discussion .
first , notice that the map manifests the left``@xmath67right '' and 0``@xmath671 '' symmetries of the elementary ca family .
for example rules 252 , 136 and 238 are the 0``@xmath671 '' , left``@xmath67right '' and the 0``@xmath671 '' and left``@xmath67right '' symmetries of rule 192 respectively .
second , coarse - graining transitions are obviously transitive , i.e. if @xmath18 goes to @xmath19 with @xmath68 and @xmath19 goes to @xmath69 with @xmath70 then @xmath18 goes to @xmath69 with @xmath71 .
for some transitions , the map in fig . [ mapfigure ] fails to show this property because we did not attain large enough values of @xmath17 .
another interesting feature of the transition map is that the apparent rule complexity never increases with a coarse - graining transition .
namely , we never find a simple behaving rule which after being coarse - grained becomes a complex rule .
the transition map , therefore , introduces a hierarchy of elementary rules and this hierarchy agrees well with the apparent rule complexity .
the hierarchy is partial and we can not relate rules which are not connected by a coarse - graining transition . as opposed to the wolfram classification ,
this coarse - graining hierarchy is well defined and is therefore a good candidate for a complexity measure@xcite .
finally notice that the eight rules 0 , 60 , 90 , 102 , 150 , 170 , 204 , 240 , whose update function has the additive form @xmath72&=&\alpha\cdot x_{n-1}\oplus\beta\cdot x_n \oplus \gamma\cdot x_{n+1}\;,\nonumber \\ & & \alpha,\beta,\gamma\in \{0,1\}\;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath73 denotes the xor operation , are all fixed points of the map .
this result is not limited to elementary rules .
as showed by barbe et.al @xcite , additive ca in arbitrary dimension whose alphabet sizes are prime numbers coarse - grain themselves .
we conjecture that there are situations where reducible fixed points exist for a wide range of systems , analogous to the emergence of amplitude equations in the vicinity of bifurcation points .
when projecting back on the binary alphabet , one maximizes the amount of information lost in the coarse - graining transition . at first glance
, this seems to be an unlikely strategy , because it is difficult for the coarse - grained ca to emulate the original one when so much information was lost . in terms of our coarse - graining procedure
such a projection maximizes the number of instances @xmath74 of eq .
( [ trans_func_projection ] ) . on second examination , however .
this strategy is not that poor .
the fact that there are only two states in the coarse - grained alphabet reduces the probability that an instance @xmath74 of eq.([trans_func_projection ] ) will be violated to 1/2 .
the extreme case of this argument would be a projection on a coarse - grained alphabet with a single state .
such a trivial projection will never violate eq .
( [ trans_func_projection ] ) ( but will never show any patterns or dynamics either ) .
a second search strategy for valid projection operators that we used is located on the other extreme of the above tradeoff .
namely , we attempt to lose the smallest possible amount of information .
we start by choosing two supercell states @xmath75 and @xmath76 and unite them using @xmath77 where the subscript in @xmath78 denotes that this is an initial trial projection to be refined later . the refinement process of the projection operator proceeds as follows .
if @xmath79 ( starting with @xmath80 ) satisfies eq .
( [ trans_func_projection ] ) then we are done .
if on the other hand , eq . ( [ trans_func_projection ] ) is violated by some @xmath81\right)&\neq & p_n\left(f_{a^n}\left[y_1,y_2,y_3\right]\right)\ ; , \nonumber \\ & & p_n(x_i)=p_n(y_i)\;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] the inequality is resolved by refining @xmath79 to @xmath82\;\ ; , r_2=f_{a^n}\left[y_1,y_2,y_3\right]\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this process is repeated until eq .
( [ trans_func_projection ] ) is satisfied .
a non - trivial coarse - graining is found in cases where the resulting projection operator is non - constant ( more than a single state in the coarse - grained ca ) . by trying all possible @xmath83 initial pairs ,
the above projection search method is guaranteed to find a valid projection if such a projection exist on the scale defined by the supercell size @xmath17 . using this method
we were able to coarse - grain many ca .
the resulting coarse - grained ca that are generated in this way are often multicolored and do not belong to the elementary ca family . for this reason it is difficult to graphically summarize all the transitions that we found in a map . instead of trying to give an overall view of those transitions
we will concentrate our attention on several interesting cases which we include in the examples section bellow .
as our first example we choose a transition between two class 2 rules .
the elementary rule 105 is defined on the alphabet @xmath53 with the transition function @xmath84=\overline{x_{n-1}\oplus x_{n } \oplus x_{n+1}}\;,\ ] ] where the over - bar denotes the not operation , and @xmath12 , @xmath13 .
we use a supercell size @xmath55 and calculate the transition function @xmath85 , defined on the alphabet @xmath86 .
now we project this alphabet back on the @xmath53 alphabet with @xmath87 a pair of cells in rule 105 are coarse - grained to a single cell and the value of the coarse cell is black only when the pair share a same value . using the above projection operator we construct the transition function of the coarse ca .
the result is found to be the transition function of the additive rule 150 : @xmath88=x_{n-1}\oplus x_{n } \oplus x_{n+1}\;.\ ] ] figure [ 105to150figure ] shows the results of this coarse - graining transition . in fig .
[ 105to150figure ] ( a ) we show the evolution of rule 105 with a specific initial condition while fig . [ 105to150figure ] ( b ) shows the evolution of rule 150 from the coarse - grained initial condition .
the small scale details in rule 105 are lost in the transformation but extended white and black regions are coarse - grained to black regions in rule 150 .
the time evolution of rule 150 captures the overall shape of these large structures but without the black - white decorations . as shown in fig .
[ mapfigure ] , rule 150 is a fixed point of the transition map .
rule 105 can therefore be further coarse - grained to arbitrary scales . as a second example of coarse - grained - able elementary
ca we choose rule 146 .
rule 146 is defined on the @xmath53 alphabet with the transition function @xmath89= } \nonumber \\ & & \left\ { \begin{array}{l } \blacksquare\;,\;x_{n-1}x_nx_{n+1}=\square\square\blacksquare;\blacksquare\square\square;\blacksquare\blacksquare\blacksquare \\ \square\;,\;\mbox{all other combinations } \\ \end{array}\right . \;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it produces a complex , seemingly random behavior which falls into the class 3 group .
we choose a supercell size @xmath90 and calculate the transition function @xmath91 , defined on the alphabet @xmath92 .
now we project this alphabet back on the @xmath53 alphabet with @xmath93 namely , a triplet of cells in rule 146 are coarse - grained to a single cell and the value of the coarse cell is black only when the triplet is all black . using the above projection operator we construct the transition function of the coarse ca .
the result is found to be the transition function of rule 128 which was given in eq .
( [ f128 ] ) .
rule 146 can therefore be coarse - grained by rule 128 , a class 1 elementary ca . in figure [ cgof146figure ]
we show the results of this coarse - graining .
[ cgof146figure ] ( a ) shows the evolution of rule 146 with a specific initial condition while fig .
[ cgof146figure ] ( b ) shows the evolution of rule 128 from the coarse - grained initial condition .
our choice of coarse - graining has eliminated the small scale details of rule 146 .
only structures of lateral size of three or more cells are accounted for .
the decay of such structures in rule 146 is accurately described by rule 128 .
note that a class 3 ca was coarse - grained to a class 1 ca in the above example .
our gain was therefore two - fold .
in addition to the phase space reduction associated with coarse - graining we have also achieved a reduction in complexity .
our procedure was able to find predictable coarse - grained aspects of the dynamics even though the small scale behavior of rule 146 is complex , potentially irreducible .
rule 146 can also be coarse - grained by non elementary ca .
using a supercell size of @xmath94 we found that the difference between the combinations @xmath95 and @xmath96 is irrelevant to the long time behavior of rule 146 .
it is therefore possible to project these two combinations into a single coarse grained state .
the same is true for the combinations @xmath97 and @xmath98 which can be projected to another coarse - grained state .
the end result of this coarse - graining ( fig .
[ cgof146figure ] ( c ) ) is a 62 color ca which retains the information of all other 6 cell combinations .
the amount of information lost in this transition is relatively small , 2/64 of the supercell states have been eliminated .
more impressive alphabet reductions can be found by going to larger scales . for @xmath17=7,8,9,10 and 11
we found an alphabet reduction of 9/128 , 33/256 , 97/512 , 261/1024 and 652/2048 respectively .
[ cgof146figure ] ( d ) shows the percentage of states that can be eliminated as a function of the supercell size @xmath17 .
all of the information lost in those coarse - grainings corresponds to irrelevant dof .
the two different coarse - graining transitions of rule 146 that we presented above are a good opportunity to show the difference between relevant and irrelevant dof . as we explained earlier , a transition like 146@xmath99128 where the rules has different complexities must involve the elimination of relevant dof .
indeed if we modify an initial condition of rule 146 by replacing a @xmath100 segment with @xmath101 we will get a modified evolution . as we show in figure [ rule146rdoffigure ]
, the difference in the trajectories has a complex behavior and is unbounded in space and time .
however , since @xmath100 and @xmath101 are both projected by eq .
( [ rule146projection ] ) to @xmath102 , the projections of the original and modified trajectories will be identical .
in contrast , the coarse graining of rule 146 to the 62 state ca of fig .
[ cgof146figure ] ( c ) involves the elimination of irrelevant dof only .
if we replace a @xmath97 in the initial condition with a @xmath98 we find that the difference between the modified and unmodified trajectories decays after a few time steps .
the elementary ca rule 184 is a simplified one lane traffic flow model .
its transition function is given by @xmath103= } \nonumber \\ & & \left\ { \begin{array}{l } \square\;,\;x_{n-1}x_nx_{n+1}=\square\square\square;\square\square\blacksquare;\square\blacksquare\square;\blacksquare\blacksquare\square \\ \blacksquare\;,\;x_{n-1}x_nx_{n+1}=\square\blacksquare\blacksquare;\blacksquare\square\square;\blacksquare\square\blacksquare;\blacksquare\blacksquare\blacksquare \\
\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] identifying a black cell with a car moving to the right and a white cell with an empty road segment we can rewrite the update rule as follows .
a car with an empty road segment to its right advances and occupies the empty segment .
a car with another car to its right will avoid a collision and stay put .
this is a deterministic and simplified version of the more realistic nagel schreckenberg model @xcite .
rule 184 can be coarse - grained to a 3 color ca using a supercell size @xmath55 and the local density projection @xmath104{0.4,0.4,0.4}\blacksquare\color{black}}\;,\;x=\square\blacksquare;\blacksquare\square \\ \blacksquare\;,\;x=\blacksquare\blacksquare \\ \end{array}\right.\;.\ ] ] the update function of the resulting ca is given by @xmath105= } \\ & & \left\ { \begin{array}{l } \square\;,\;y_{n-1}y_ny_{n+1}=\square\square\square;\square\square{\color[rgb]{0.4,0.4,0.4}\blacksquare\color{black}};\square\square\blacksquare;\square{\color[rgb]{0.4,0.4,0.4}\blacksquare\color{black}}\square;\square{\color[rgb]{0.4,0.4,0.4}\blacksquare\color{black}}{\color[rgb]{0.4,0.4,0.4}\blacksquare\color{black}}\\ \blacksquare\;,\;y_{n-1}y_ny_{n+1}=\square\blacksquare\blacksquare;{\color[rgb]{0.4,0.4,0.4}\blacksquare\color{black}}{\color[rgb]{0.4,0.4,0.4}\blacksquare\color{black}}\blacksquare;{\color[rgb]{0.4,0.4,0.4}\blacksquare\color{black}}\blacksquare\blacksquare;\blacksquare{\color[rgb]{0.4,0.4,0.4}\blacksquare\color{black}}\blacksquare;\blacksquare\blacksquare\blacksquare \\ { \color[rgb]{0.4,0.4,0.4}\blacksquare\color{black}}\;,\;\mbox{all other combinations } \\
\end{array}\right .. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] figure [ rule184figure ] shows the result of this coarse - graining .
[ rule184figure ] ( a ) shows a trajectory of rule 184 while fig .
[ rule184figure ] ( b ) shows the trajectory of the coarse ca . from this figure
it is clear that the white zero density regions correspond to empty road and the black high density regions correspond to traffic jams .
the density 1/2 grey regions correspond to free flowing traffic with an exception near traffic jams due to a boundary effect . by using larger supercell sizes it is possible to find other coarse - grained versions of rule 184 . as in the above example , the coarse - grained states group together local configurations of equal car densities .
the projection operators however are not functions of the local density alone .
they are a partition of such a function and there could be several coarse - grained states which correspond to the same local car density .
we found ( empirically ) that for even supercell sizes @xmath106 the coarse - grained ca contain @xmath107 states and for odd supercell sizes @xmath108 they contain @xmath109 states .
figure [ rule184figure ] ( c ) shows the amount of information lost in those transitions as a function of @xmath17 .
most of the lost information corresponds to relevant dof but some of it is irrelevant .
rule 110 is one of the most interesting rules in the elementary ca family .
it belongs to class 4 and exhibits a complex behavior where several types of particles `` move and interact above a regular background .
the behavior of these particles '' is rich enough to support universal computation @xcite . in this sense rule 110
is maximally complex because it is capable of emulating all computations done by other computing devices in general and ca in particular . as a consequence
it is also undecidable @xcite .
we found several ways to coarse - grain rule 110 . using @xmath94 , it is possible to project the 64 possible supercell states onto an alphabet of 63 symbols .
figure [ rule110figure ] ( a ) and ( b ) shows a trajectory of rule 110 and the corresponding trajectory of the coarse - grained 63 states ca . a more impressive reduction in the alphabet size is obtained by going to larger values of @xmath17 . for @xmath110 we found an alphabet reduction of @xmath111 , @xmath112 , @xmath113 , @xmath114 , @xmath115 and @xmath116 respectively . only irrelevant dof are eliminated in those transitions .
[ rule110figure ] ( c ) shows the percentage of reduced states as a function of the supercell size @xmath17 .
we expect this behavior to persist for larger values of @xmath17 .
another important coarse - graining of rule 110 that we found is the transition to rule 0 .
rule 0 has the trivial dynamics where all initial states evolve to the null configuration in a single time step .
the transition to rule 0 is possible because many cell sequences can not appear in the long time trajectories of rule 110 .
for example the sequence @xmath117 is a so called garden of eden `` of rule 110 .
it can not be generated by rule 110 and can only appear in the initial state .
coarse - graining by rule 0 is achieved in this case using @xmath118 and projecting @xmath117 to @xmath119 and all other five cell combinations to @xmath102 .
another example is the sequence @xmath120 .
this sequence is a garden of eden '' of the @xmath121 supercell version of rule 110 .
it can appear only in the first 12 time steps of rule 110 but no later .
coarse - graining by rule 0 is achieved in this case using @xmath121 and projecting @xmath120 to @xmath119 and all other 13 cell combinations to @xmath102 .
these examples are important because they show that even though rule 110 is undecidable it has decidable and predictable coarse - grained aspects ( however trivial ) . to our knowledge rule 110 is the only proven undecidable elementary ca and therefore this is the only ( proven ) example of undecidable to decidable transition that we found within the elementary ca family .
it is interesting to note that the number of garden of eden `` states in supercell versions of rule 110 grows very rapidly with the supercell size @xmath17 . as we show in fig.[rule110figure ] ( d ) , the fraction of garden of eden '' states out of the @xmath122 possible sequences , grows almost linearly with @xmath17 . in addition , at every scale @xmath17 there are new garden of eden `` sequences which do not contain any smaller gardens of eden '' as subsequences .
these results are consistent with our understanding that even though the dynamics looks complex , more and more structure emerges as one goes to larger scales .
we will have more to say about this in section [ kolmogorov_complexity ] .
the garden of eden `` states of supercell versions of rule 110 represent pieces of information that can be used in reducing the computational effort in rule 110 .
the reduction can be achieved by truncating the supercell update rule to be a function of only non garden of eden '' states .
the size of the resulting rule table will be much smaller ( @xmath123 with @xmath124 ) than the size of the supercell rule table .
efficient computations of rule 110 can then be carried out by running rule 110 for the first @xmath17 time steps .
after @xmath17 time steps the system contains no garden of eden `` sequences and we can continue to propagate it by using the truncated supercell rule table without loosing any information .
note that we have not reduced rule 110 to a decidable system . at every scale we achieved a constant reduction in the computational effort .
wolfram has pointed out that many irreducible systems have pockets of reducibility and termed such a reduction as superficial reducibility '' ( see page 746 in ref . ) .
it will be interesting to check how much superficial reducibility `` is contained in rule 110 at larger scales
. it will be inappropriate to call it superficial '' if the curve in fig.[rule110figure ] ( d ) approaches 100% in the large @xmath17 limit .
it might be argued that the coarse - graining of rule 110 by rule 0 is a trivial example of an undecidable to a decidable coarse - graining transition .
the fact that certain configurations can not be arrived at in the long time behavior is not very surprising and is expected of any irreversible system . in order to search for more interesting examples we studied other one dimensional universal ca that we found in the literature .
lindgren and nordahl @xcite constructed a 7 state nearest neighbor and a 4 state next - nearest neighbor ca that are capable of emulating a universal turing machine .
the entries in the update tables of these ca are only partly determined by the emulated turing machine and can be completed at will .
we found that for certain completion choices these two universal ca can be coarse - grained to a trivial ca which like rule 0 decay to a quiescent configuration in a single time step .
another universal ca that can undergo such a transition is wolfram s 19 state , next - nearest neighbor universal ca @xcite .
these results are essentially equivalent to the rule 110 @xmath99 rule 0 transition .
a more interesting example is albert and culik s @xcite universal ca .
it is a 14 state nearest - neighbor ca which is capable of emulating all other ca .
the transition table of this ca is only partly determined by its construction and can be completed at will .
we found that when the empty entries in the transition function are filled by the copy operation @xmath125=x_n\ ; , \label{copy_operation}\ ] ] the resulting undecidable ca has many coarse - graining transitions to decidable ca .
in all these transitions the coarse - grained ca performs the copy operation eq .
( [ copy_operation ] ) for all @xmath126 .
different transitions differ in the projection operator and the alphabet size of the coarse - grained ca .
figure [ albertculik_figure ] shows a coarse - graining of albert and culik s universal ca to a 4 state copy ca .
the coarse - grained ca captures three types of persistent structures that appear in the original system but is ignorant of more complicated details .
the supercell size used here is @xmath55 .
in the previous section we showed that a large majority of elementary ca can be coarse - grained in space and time .
this is rather surprising since finding a valid projection operator is equivalent to solving eq.([cg_matrix_form ] ) which is greatly over constrained .
solutions for this equation should be rare for random choices of the matrix @xmath29 . in this section
we show that solutions of eq.([cg_matrix_form ] ) are frequent because @xmath29 is not random but a highly structured object . as the supercell size @xmath17
is increased , @xmath29 becomes less random and the probability of finding a valid projection approaches unity . to appreciate the high success rate in coarse - graining elementary ca consider the following statistics . by using supercells of size @xmath55 and considering all possible projection operators
@xmath127 we were able to coarse - grain approximately one third of all 256 elementary ca rules .
recall that the coarse - graining procedure that we use involves two stages . in the first stage
we generate the supercell version @xmath29 , a 4 color ca in the @xmath55 case . in the second stage
we look for valid projection operators .
4 color ca that are @xmath55 supercell versions of elementary ca are a tiny fraction of all possible ( @xmath128 ) 4 color ca .
if we pick a random 4 color ca and try to project it ; i.e. attempt to solve eq .
( [ cg_matrix_form ] ) with @xmath29 replaced by an arbitrary 4 color ca , we find an average of one solvable instance out of every @xmath129 attempts .
this large difference in the projection probability indicates that 4 color ca which are supercells versions of elementary rules are not random .
the numbers become more convincing when we go to larger values of @xmath17 and attempt to find projections to random @xmath122 color ca . to put our arguments on a more quantitative level
we need to quantify the information content of supercell versions of ca .
an accepted measure in algorithmic information theory for the randomness and information content of an individual@xcite object is its kolmogorov complexity ( algorithmic complexity ) @xcite .
the kolmogorov complexity @xmath130 of a string of characters @xmath38 with respect to a universal computer @xmath131 is defined as @xmath132 where @xmath133 is the length of @xmath38 in bits and @xmath134 is the bit length of the minimal computer program that generates @xmath38 and halts on @xmath131 ( irrespective of the running time ) .
this definition is sensitive to the choice of machine @xmath131 only up to an additive constant in @xmath134 which do not depend on @xmath38 . for long strings this dependency is negligible and
the subscript @xmath131 can be dropped .
according to this definition , strings which are very structured require short generating programs and will therefore have small kolmogorov complexity .
for example , a periodic @xmath38 with period @xmath135 can be generated by a @xmath136 long program and @xmath137 .
in contrast , if @xmath38 has no structure it must be generated literally , i.e. the shortest program is print(x ) " . in such cases
@xmath138 , @xmath139 and the information content of @xmath38 is maximal . by using simple counting arguments
@xcite it is easy to show that simple objects are rare and that @xmath139 for most objects @xmath38 .
kolmogorov complexity is a powerful and elegant concept which comes with an annoying limitation .
it is uncomputable , i.e. it is impossible to find the length of the minimal program that generates a string @xmath38 .
it is only possible to bound it .
it is easy to see that supercell ca are highly structured objects by looking at their kolmogorov complexity .
consider the ca @xmath140 and its @xmath17th supercell version @xmath141 ( for simplicity of notation we omit the subscript @xmath18 from the alphabet size ) .
the transition function @xmath31 is a table that specifies a cell s new state for all @xmath142 possible local configurations ( assuming a is nearest neighbor and one dimensional ) .
@xmath31 can therefore be described by a string of @xmath142 symbols from the alphabet @xmath143 .
the bit length @xmath144 of such a description is @xmath145 if @xmath29 was a typical ca with @xmath146 colors we could expect that @xmath147 , the length of the minimal program that generates @xmath31 , will not differ significantly from @xmath144 .
however , since @xmath29 is a super cell version of @xmath18 we have a much shorter description , i.e. to construct @xmath29 from @xmath18 .
this construction involves running @xmath18 , @xmath17 time steps for all possible initial configurations of @xmath33 cells .
it can be conveniently coded in a program as repeated applications of the transition function @xmath4 within several loops . up to an additive constant@xcite
, the length of such a program will be equal to the bit length description of @xmath4 : @xmath148 note that we have used @xmath149 to indicate that this is an upper bound for the length of the minimal program that generates @xmath31 .
this upper bound , however , should be tight for an update rule @xmath4 with little structure .
the kolmogorov complexity of @xmath31 can consequently be bounded by @xmath150 this complexity approaches zero at large values of @xmath17 .
our argument above shows that the large scale behavior of ca ( or any local process ) must be simple in some sense .
we would like to continue this line of reasoning and conjecture that the small kolmogorov complexity of the large scale behavior is related to our ability to coarse - grain many ca . at present
we are unable to prove this conjecture analytically , and must therefore resort to numerical evidence which we present below .
ideally , in order to show that such a connection exists one would attempt to coarse - grain ca with different alphabets and on different length scales ( supercell sizes ) , and verify that the success rate correlates with the kolmogorov complexity of the generated supercell ca .
this , however , is computationally very challenging and going beyond ca with a binary alphabet and supercell sizes of more than @xmath151 is not realistic .
a more modest experiment is the following .
we start with a ca @xmath18 with an alphabet @xmath152 , and check whether its @xmath17 supercell version @xmath29 contains all possible @xmath146 states .
namely , if there exist @xmath153 such that @xmath154 such a missing state of @xmath29 is sometimes referred to as a garden of eden `` configuration because it can only appear in the initial state of @xmath29 .
note that by the construction of @xmath29 , a garden of eden '' state of @xmath29 can appear only in the first @xmath155 time steps of @xmath18 and is therefore a generalized garden of eden `` of @xmath18 . in cases where a state of @xmath29 is missing
, @xmath18 can be trivially coarse - grained to the elementary ca rule 0 by projecting the missing state of @xmath29 to 1 '' and all other combinations to 0 `` .
this type of trivial projection was discussed earlier in connection with the coarse - graining of rule 110 .
finding a garden of eden '' state of @xmath29 is computationally relatively easy because there is no need to calculate the supercell transition function @xmath31 .
it is enough to back - trace the evolution of @xmath18 and check if all @xmath17 cell combinations has a @xmath33 cell ancestor combination , @xmath17 time steps in the past .
figure [ missing_colors ] ( a ) shows the statistics obtained from such an experiment
. it exhibits the fraction @xmath156 of ca rules with different alphabet sizes @xmath152 , whose @xmath17th supercell version is missing at least one state .
each data point in this figure was obtained by testing 10,000 ca rules . the fraction @xmath156 approaches unity at large values of @xmath17 , an expected behavior since most of the ca are irreversible .
figure [ missing_colors ] ( b ) shows the same data as in ( a ) when plotted against the variable @xmath157 where @xmath152 is the alphabet size , @xmath158 is the upper bound for the kolmogorov complexity of the supercell ca from eq.([upper_bound_kc ] ) and @xmath69 is a constant .
the excellent data collapse imply a strong correlation between the probability of finding a missing state and the kolmogorov complexity of a supercell ca .
this figure also shows that the data points can be accurately fitted by @xmath159 with @xmath160 a constant and @xmath161 ( solid line in fig .
[ missing_colors ] ( b ) ) . having the scaling form @xmath162 we can now study the behavior of @xmath156 with large alphabet sizes .
assuming @xmath163 and @xmath164 to be continuous we define @xmath165 as the point where @xmath166 .
for a fixed value of @xmath152 , the slope of @xmath156 at the transition region can be calculated by @xmath167 where @xmath168 putting together eqs .
( [ rge_slope ] ) and ( [ nh ] ) we find that the slope of @xmath156 at the transition region grows as @xmath169 for large values of @xmath152 .
an indication of this phenomena can be seen in fig .
[ missing_colors ] ( a ) which shows sharper transitions at large values of @xmath152 . in the limit of large @xmath152
, @xmath156 becomes a step function with respect to @xmath17 .
this fact introduces a critical value @xmath170 such that for @xmath171 the probability of finding a missing state is zero and for @xmath172 the probability is one .
the value of this critical @xmath17 grows with the alphabet size as @xmath173 .
note that @xmath170 is an emergent length scale , as it is not present in any of the ca rules , but according to the above analysis will emerge ( with probability one ) in their dynamics .
a direct consequence of the emergence of @xmath174 is that a measure 1 of all ca can be coarse - grained to the elementary rule 0 " on the coarse - grained scale @xmath174 .
generalized garden of eden " states are a specific form of emergent pattern that can be encountered in the large scale dynamics of ca .
is the kolmogorov complexity of ca rules related to other types of coarse - grained behavior ? to explore this question we attempted to project ( solve eq .
( [ cg_matrix_form ] ) ) random ca with bounded kolmogorov complexities . to generate a random ca @xmath175 with a bounded kolmogorov complexity
we view the update rule @xmath4 as a string of @xmath176 bits , denote the @xmath177th bit by @xmath178 and apply the following procedure : 1 ) randomly pick the first @xmath179 bits of @xmath4 .
2 ) randomly pick a generating function @xmath180 .
3 ) set the values of all the empty bits of @xmath4 by applying @xmath181 : @xmath182\;,\ ] ] starting at @xmath183 and finishing at @xmath184 . up to an additive constant
, the length of such a procedure is equal to @xmath185 , the number of random bits chosen .
the kolmogorov complexity of the resulting rule table can therefore be bounded by @xmath186 for small values of @xmath179 this is a reasonable upper bound .
however for large values of @xmath179 this upper bound is obviously not tight since the size of @xmath181 can be much larger than the length of @xmath4 . using the above procedure we studied the probability of projecting ca with different alphabets and different upper bound kolmogorov complexities @xmath187 .
for given values of @xmath152 and @xmath179 we generated 10,000 ( 200 for the @xmath188 case ) ca and tried to find a valid projection on the @xmath189 alphabet .
figure [ projection_probability ] ( a ) shows the fraction @xmath190 of solvable instances as a function of @xmath191 . the constant @xmath69 used for this data collapse is @xmath192 , very close to @xmath193 . as valid projection solutions we considered all possible projections @xmath194 . in doing
so we may be redoing the missing states experiment because many low kolmogorov complexity rules has missing states and can thus be trivially projected . in order to exclude this option we repeated the same experiment while restricting the family of allowed projections to be equal partitions of @xmath195 , i.e. @xmath196
the results are shown if fig .
[ projection_probability ] ( b ) .
it seems that in both cases there is a good correlation between the kolmogorov complexity ( or its upper bound ) of a ca rule and the probability of finding a valid projection . in particular
, the fraction of solvable instances goes to one at the low @xmath187 limit . as shown by the solid lines in fig.[projection_probability ] , this fraction
can again be fitted by @xmath197 where @xmath160 is a constant and in this case @xmath198 .
how many of the ca rules that we generate and project show a complex behavior ? does the fraction of projectable rules simply reflect the fraction of simple behaving rules ? to answer this question we studied the rules generated by our procedure .
for each value of @xmath152 and @xmath179 we generated 100 rules and counted the number of rules exhibiting complex behavior .
a rule was labelled complex " if it showed class 3 or 4 behavior and exhibited a complex sensitivity to perturbations in the initial conditions .
[ projection_probability ] ( c ) shows the statistics we obtained with different alphabet sizes as a function of @xmath187 while the inset shows it as a function of @xmath179 .
we first note that our statistics support dubacq et al .
@xcite , who proposed that rule tables with low kolmogorov complexities lead to simple behavior and rule tables with large kolmogorov complexity lead to complex behavior .
moreover , our results show that the fraction of complex rules does not depend on the alphabet size and is only a function of @xmath179 .
rules with larger alphabets show complex behavior at a lower value of @xmath187 . as a consequence
, a large fraction of projectable rules are complex and this fraction grows with the alphabet size @xmath152 . as we explained earlier , the kolmogorov complexity of supercell versions of ca approaches zero as the supercell size @xmath17
is increased .
our experiments therefore indicate that a measure one of all ca are coarse - grained - able if we use a coarse enough scale .
moreover , the data collapse that we obtain and the sharp transition of the scaling function suggest that it may be possible to know in advance at what length scales to look for valid projections
. this can be very useful when attempting to coarse - grain ca or other dynamical systems because it can narrow down the search domain .
as in the case of garden of eden " states that we studied earlier , we interpret the transition point as an emergent scale which above it we are likely to find self organized patterns .
note however that this scale is a little shifted in fig .
[ projection_probability ] ( b ) when compared with fig .
[ projection_probability ] ( a ) .
the emergence scale is thus sensitive to the types of large scale patterns we are looking for .
in this work we studied emergent phenomena in complex systems and the associated predictability problems by attempting to coarse - grain ca .
we found that many elementary ca can be coarse - grained in space and time and that in some cases complex , undecidable ca can be coarse - grained to decidable and predictable ca .
we conclude from this fact that undecidability and computational irreducibility are not good measures for physical complexity . physical complexity , as opposed to computational complexity should address the interesting , physically relevant , coarse - grained degrees of freedom .
these coarse - grained degrees of freedom maybe simple and predictable even when the microscopic behavior is very complex .
the above definition of physical complexity brings about the question of the objectivity of macroscopic descriptions @xcite .
is our choice of a coarse - grained description ( and its consequent complexity ) subjective or is it dictated by the system ?
our results are in accordance with shalizi and moore @xcite : it is both . in many cases we discovered that a particular ca can undergo different coarse - graining transitions using different projection operators . in these cases
the system dictates a set of valid projection operators and we are restricted to choose our coarse - grained description from this set .
we do however have some freedom to manifest our subjective interest .
the coarse - graining transitions that we found induce a hierarchy on the family of elementary ca ( see fig .
[ mapfigure ] ) .
moreover , it seems that rule complexity never increases with coarse - graining transitions .
the coarse - graining hierarchy therefore provides a partial complexity order of ca where complex rules are found at the top of the hierarchy and simple rules are at the bottom .
the order is partial because we can not relate rules which are not connected by coarse - graining transitions .
this coarse - graining hierarchy can be used as a new classification scheme of ca . unlike wolfram s , classification
this scheme is not a topological one since the basis of our suggested classification is not the ca trajectories . nor is this scheme parametric , such as langton s @xmath10 parameter scheme .
our scheme reflects similarities in the algebraic properties of ca rules .
it simply says that if some coarse - grained aspects of rule @xmath18 can be captured by the detailed dynamics of rule @xmath19 then rule @xmath18 is at least as complex as rule @xmath19 .
rule @xmath18 maybe more complex because in some cases it can do more than its projection .
note that our hierarchy may subdivide wolfram s classes .
for example rule 128 is higher on the hierarchy than rule 0 .
these two rules belong to class 1 but rule 128 can be coarse - grained to rule 0 and it is clear that an opposite transition can not exist
. it will be interesting to find out if class 3 and 4 can also be subdivided . in the last part of this work we tried to understand why is it possible to find so many coarse - graining transitions between ca .
at first blush , it seems that coarse - graining transitions should be rare because finding valid projection operators is an over constrained problem .
this was our initial intuition when we first attempted to coarse - grain ca .
to our surprise we found that many ca can undergo coarse - graining transitions .
a more careful investigation of the above question suggests that finding valid projection operators is possible because of the structure of the rules which govern the large scale dynamics .
these large scale rules are update functions for supercells , whose tables can be computed directly from the single cell update function .
they thus contain the same amount of information as the single cell rule .
their size however grows with the supercell size and therefore they have vanishing kolmogorov complexities .
in other words , the large scale update functions are highly structured objects .
they contain many regularities which can be used for finding valid projection operators .
we did not give a formal proof for this statement but provided a strong experimental evidence .
in our experiments we discovered that the probability to find a valid projection is a universal function of the kolmogorov complexity of the supercell update rule .
this universal probability function varies from zero at large kolmogorov complexity ( small supercells ) to one at small kolmogorov complexity ( large supercells ) .
it is therefore very likely that we find many coarse - graining transitions when we go to large enough scales .
our interpretation of the above results is that of emergence .
when we go to large enough scales we are likely to find dynamically identifiable large scale patterns .
these patterns are emergent ( or self organized ) because they do not explicitly exist in the original single cell rules .
the large scale patterns are forced upon the system by the lack of information .
namely , the system ( the update rule , not the cell lattice ) does not contain enough information to be complex at large scales .
finding a projection operator is one specific type of an over constrained problem .
motivated by our results we looked into other types of over constrained problems .
the satisfyability@xcite problem ( k - sat ) is a generalized ( np complete ) form of constraint satisfaction system . we generated random 3-sat instances with different number of variables deep in the un - sat region of parameter space .
the generated instances however were not completely random and were generated by generating functions .
the generating functions controlled the instance s kolmogorov complexity , in the same way that we used in section [ proj_prob_with_bounded_k ] .
we found@xcite that the probability for these instances to be satisfiable obeys the same universal probability function of eq .
( [ rproj_fit ] )
. it will be interesting to understand the origin of this universality and its implications . in this work ,
we have restricted ourselves to deal with ca because it is relatively easy to look for valid projection operators for them . a greater ( and more practical ) challenge will now be to try and coarse - grain more sophisticated dynamical systems such as probabilistic ca , coupled maps and partial differential equations .
these types of systems are among the main work horses of scientific modelling , and being able to coarse - grain them will be very useful , and is a topic of current research , e.g. in material science@xcite
. it will be interesting to see if one can derive an emergence length scale for those systems like the one we found for garden of eden " sequences in ca ( section [ gardensofeden ] ) .
such an emergence length scale can assist in finding valid projection operators by narrowing the search to a particular scale .
ng wishes to thank stephen wolfram for numerous useful discussions and his encouragement of this research project .
ni wishes to thank david mukamel for his help and advice .
this work was partially supported by the national science foundation through grant nsf - dmr-99 - 70690 ( ng ) and by the national aeronautics and space administration through grant nag8 - 1657 . | we study the predictability of emergent phenomena in complex systems . using nearest neighbor , one - dimensional cellular automata ( ca ) as an example ,
we show how to construct local coarse - grained descriptions of ca in all classes of wolfram s classification .
the resulting coarse - grained ca that we construct are capable of emulating the large - scale behavior of the original systems without accounting for small - scale details .
several ca that can be coarse - grained by this construction are known to be universal turing machines ; they can emulate any ca or other computing devices and are therefore undecidable .
we thus show that because in practice one only seeks coarse - grained information , complex physical systems can be predictable and even decidable at some level of description .
the renormalization group flows that we construct induce a hierarchy of ca rules .
this hierarchy agrees well with apparent rule complexity and is therefore a good candidate for a complexity measure and a classification method .
finally we argue that the large scale dynamics of ca can be very simple , at least when measured by the kolmogorov complexity of the large scale update rule , and moreover exhibits a novel scaling law .
we show that because of this large - scale simplicity , the probability of finding a coarse - grained description of ca approaches unity as one goes to increasingly coarser scales .
we interpret this large scale simplicity as a pattern formation mechanism in which large scale patterns are forced upon the system by the simplicity of the rules that govern the large scale dynamics . |
the first gravitationally lensed quasar @xcite has been discovered more than 30 years ago , turning gravitational lensing from an obscure theoretical field into a mainstream observational one .
more than 100 strongly lensed quasars have been discovered to date , and it has convincingly been demonstrated that these objects provide insights into various topics in astrophysics and cosmology , as well as being a unique tool for studying the dark universe .
applications include the study of the quasar host galaxies at high redshift ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , dark matter substructures and luminous satellites ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , the structure and evolution of massive galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , and microlensing applied in the study of the structure of quasar accretion disk ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , broad line regions(e.g .
? * ; * ? ? ?
* ) , as well as to measure the stellar mass fractions in the lens ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
following early work by e.g. @xcite , analyses of statistically well - defined samples of lensed quasars ( i.e. samples in which lens candidates are selected by a homogeneous method whose completeness is known ) can now constrain the cosmological constant / dark energy by comparing the number and distribution of image separation of lensed quasars with theoretical models ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
time delay measurements between quasar images constrain the hubble constant free of the calibration in the cosmic distance ladder ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
finally , the distribution of lensed image separations , from galaxy to cluster mass scales , reflects the hierarchical structure formation and the effects of baryon cooling ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
the sloan digital sky survey quasar lens search ( sqls ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
* ) is a systematic survey for lensed quasars , aiming to construct a large sample of gravitationally lensed quasars at optical wavelengths .
it relies on the large homogeneous sample of spectroscopically - confirmed quasars from the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ; * ? ? ?
the techniques employed by the sqls to identify lensed quasar candidates are described in the references above .
we followed up all candidates with deeper imaging ( usually with the university of hawaii 2.2 m telescope ; uh88 ) to detect the lensing galaxy .
we then performed follow - up spectroscopy of the most promising candidates , to confirm their lensing nature .
sqls is at present the prominent search for lensed quasars in the optical , comprising of 62 lensed quasars to date ( december 2014 ) , @xmath12/3 of which are new discoveries ( @xcite ) .
it has also produced the largest statistically complete sample of lensed quasars ( 26 objects ; @xcite ) .
a disadvantage of sqls , like other ground - based optical strong lens surveys , is its poor detail in imaging lensed quasars .
even when performing follow - up observations with the uh88 telescope , the pixel scale @xmath2 is large , and the seeing @xmath3 is similar to the image separation of a galaxy - scale strong lens ( @xmath4 ) .
therefore , high - resolution imaging of these quasar lenses is the key to turning each lens into a highly useful astrophysical and cosmological probe .
this is necessary for obtaining accurate relative astrometry and point / surface photometry for the quasar images , lensing galaxy , and quasar host galaxy ( in case the latter is detected ) , which are used to constrain both the light and the mass distribution in these systems . in the following , we highlight three of the applications enabled by the high - resolution images of a large sample of objects , such as the sample provided by our work . _ estimating the hubble constant from high resolution and time delay measurements : _ although monitoring observations , for which only relative fluxes are relevant , can be performed with small telescopes aided by image deconvolution , to determine time delays measurements between multiple images , ( e.g. , * ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , high resolution single epoch observations are still required to construct an accurate lens model ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) . as time delays are currently being measured by the cosmological monitoring of gravitational lenses ( cosmograil ; *
* ) for many of the sqls lenses , high resolution data is in demand .
for example , @xcite obtained high resolution images of a four - image lensed quasar with an early adaptive optics systems , resulting in a relative lens galaxy position three times more precise than before , which allowed to measure the hubble constant two times more precisely than in previous studies .
_ quasar galaxy hosts and the correlation with @xmath5 : _ the tight correlations found between the masses of supermassive black holes @xmath5 and overall properties of the host galaxy bulges , such as velocity dispersion , luminosity and stellar mass ( e.g. , * ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) suggest that the black hole growth is coupled to the galaxy evolution .
these correlations have been established for local galaxies , based on spatially resolved kinematics .
since spatially resolved kinematics are very difficult to obtain at @xmath6 , the most straightforward correlation that can be studied at large redshifts is the one between @xmath5 and the bulge galaxy luminosity . however , in this case agns or quasars must be employed , as the nuclear activity allows the estimation of @xmath5 using the virial technique ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
the difficulty then lies in accurately decomposing the faint quasar host , which is subject to the cosmological surface brightness dimming , from the bright nuclear source .
as was demonstrated by @xcite , this task is facilitated for gravitationally lensed quasars by two effects .
first , strong gravitational lensing produces natural magnification typically by several factors , by increasing the total flux and the apparent size of the host galaxy , while conserving surface brightness .
second , lensing distorts the host into an arc and gives it a dramatically different morphology from that of the point spread function ( psf ) , making it significantly less susceptible to systematic problems in the psf model ( an inaccurately known psf ) .
high - resolution observations are paramount in measuring the surface brightness of the lensed host galaxy . _
the ellipticity and orientation of mass and light in the lensing galaxies : _ an ongoing question is to what extent there are correlations between the azimuthal luminous profile of the lens galaxies and their overall ( dark + luminous ) mass profile .
strong lensing provides a unique tool for testing these correlations .
there exists a known correlation between the mass and light orientation , within @xmath7 deg ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
it is not presently known however if the scatter in the relation is intrinsic , or due to measurement errors . on the other hand ,
there is less consensus on a correlation between the mass and light ellipticity . for example
, such a tight correlation was found by @xcite for the sloan lens acs survey ( slacs ; * ? ? ?
* ) sample of galaxy - galaxy lenses ( i.e. foreground galaxies acting as strong lenses for background galaxies ) , although @xcite did not find a correlation for a selected subsample of the slacs lenses .
a correlation was also found for the sl2s galaxy - galaxy lenses @xcite , but has significantly more scatter .
there are also recent results from different samples ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the difference between the slacs and sl2s lenses is that the former lie in an environment with significantly less average external shear @xmath8 , and also that they have smaller einstein radius @xmath9 relative to the characteristic scale ( effective radius ) of the galaxy @xmath10 , resulting in the more relevant role played by stellar mass in defining the potential within the critical curve ( @xmath11 , 0.5 for sl2s and slacs , respectively ) . for much larger values of @xmath12 , studies based on weak
lensing ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) found that the dark matter haloes , which dominate the mass profile at these radii , are flatter than the luminous profile , in agreement with theoretical expectations .
for the lenses of strongly lensed quasars , initial hubble space telescope ( @xmath13 ) observations have failed to find a correlation between the mass and light ellipticity @xcite .
more recent results employing a uniform analysis technique and deconvolution of @xmath13 data are presented in @xcite and show that there is a correlation for their sample of four - image lensed quasars ( quads ) .
the slacs lenses and the lenses of strongly lensed quasars are known to probe different populations of lenses , with lensed quasars typically lying in richer environments ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
in addition , for most lensed quasars @xmath9 is on the order of a few @xmath10 , therefore probing an intermediate range .
the new correlation found by @xcite , after eliminating the outliers , holds only for ellipticities @xmath14 . for these small ellipticities , as the authors note , one possible bias resulting in the correlation is that the effect of a rounder dark matter halo on the total mass distribution may be harder to detect .
the goal of this work is to enhance the value of the sqls gravitationally lensed quasar sample through the use of high - resolution observations . among the 62 lensed quasars in the sqls sample , only @xmath15 have available high - resolution observations , mainly supplied by @xmath13 .
however , recent progress of adaptive optics ( ao ) , especially the use of laser guide stars ( lgs ) , makes it possible to obtain high - resolution images using ground - based telescopes . due to the smaller diffraction limit , near - infrared imaging with subaru telescope ao
can potentially achieve _ three times _ the spatial resolution of @xmath13 , while also employing a finer pixel scale .
ao has previously been used in the literature in the study of gravitationally lensed quasars .
@xcite , @xcite and @xcite used ao to study galaxy scale two - image lensed quasars ( doubles ) .
@xcite discovered additional lensing galaxies in known lensed quasars , using ao .
@xcite observed a quad in order to look for substructure , which @xcite was successful in detecting for another quad .
in addition , @xcite and @xcite have used ao to study the arcs of strongly lensed galaxies , reconstruct the source , or study in high detail the lensing galaxy . however , these have been isolated studies focused on single systems . the observational campaign described in this paper
is the largest dedicated study of a large sample of lensed quasars with ao . in section
[ section : obsall ] we present our observing strategy and describe acquired data including data reduction . in section [ section : technique ]
we present the morphological modelling technique we employed , and in section [ section : lensmodels ] the mass modelling technique .
we continue with a comparison of our results with those found for the same systems in the literature ( section [ sect : discuss ] ) , and a concluding discussion of the technique we used , in section [ sect : discutionoverall ] .
section [ section : hostfacts ] shows results obtained on the quasar host galaxies .
finally , section [ section : lightmass ] studies the lens environment and the relation between mass and light for the systems in our sample , and section [ sect : concl ] concludes this work . in the main appendix
, we describe in detail the analysis of each individual system . throughout this work
, the concordance cosmology with @xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath18 and @xmath19 is assumed .
for sdss j1001 + 5027 and sdss j1206 + 4332 , where time delay measurements are available , the @xcite result , @xmath20 , is assumed .
magnitudes are given in the vega system .
all object coordinates assume j2000 .
all observed images and residual plots are in logarithmic scale .
sky coverage is a limiting factor when using ao , as all targets must be located close to a tip - tilt ( tt ) star of suitable brightness in order to perform ao correction , even in the case that lgs is used .
subaru telescope however presently has the most relaxed constraints on tt star , among comparable systems on 8 - 10 m telescopes ( section [ section : ircsao ] ) .
this makes it an ideal tool to use in the observational campaign of the sqls quasars .
indeed , 54 of the 62 sqls quasars are accessible to the subaru telescope ao system . the ao correction functions
better at longer wavelengths ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , making @xmath21-band the natural choice among the widely used @xmath22 near - infrared bands . an additional reason to use @xmath21-band in the study of quasars and their host galaxies
is that for redshifts @xmath23 , @xmath21-band falls in a wavelength region where the quasar host galaxy is brightest compared to the nuclear source ( figure [ fig : qsogal ] ) .
moreover , for the purpose of modelling gravitationally lensed quasars , extinction , intrinsic variability and microlensing are all weaker at progressively longer wavelengths , contaminating the true image flux ratio less ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) . however , exposure times in the @xmath21-band are limited by the strong sky background emission . on the other hand
, @xmath24-band provides a good compromise between background level , sensitivity , and ao performance , and we therefore used this band throughout the observation campaign .
band at redshifts 0 and 2.5 marked .
the composite quasar spectrum is from @xcite . for the galaxy template
, the mean spectrum of local galaxies from @xcite is extrapolated using the evolutionary models of @xcite .
[ fig : qsogal],width=321 ] as one of the goals of the campaign is to measure accurate lens galaxy morphologies and potentially resolve the quasar host galaxies from the point - like nuclear source , a good knowledge of the psf is essential . for the majority of the systems , we used the sdss casjobs search query to identify bright psf and guide star pairs .
these were selected such that the guide stars of the psf and the target have similar brightness , and the separations between the target and its guide star , as well as the psf and its respective guide star , are similar .
the psfs are close on the sky to the target ( within @xmath25 ) , and they were observed immediately before or after the target , in the same natural guide star ( ngs ) or lgs mode .
this was done to ensure as much as possible that the atmospherical turbulence characteristics and therefore the ao correction is relatively constant between the psf and the target . however , as we will discuss below , these separately observed psf stars turn out not to be suitable for the accurate characterisation of the target image psfs .
sdss j1515 + 1511 and sdss j1002 + 4449 are the only observed systems that have a bright star in the detector field of view ( fov ) , which can potentially be used as psf .
here we centred the fov , and therefore the lgs , between the star and the target .
this was done , again , so that the ao correction at the location of the target and the psf star is similar .
the ao imaging observations were performed with the infrared camera and spectrograph ( ircs ; * ? ? ?
* ) at the subaru telescope , along with the laser guide star adaptive optics system ( lgs@xmath26ao188 ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
ircs uses two @xmath27 alladin iii arrays for imaging and spectroscopy , and in imaging mode provides two plate scales , of 52 and 20 mas per pixel . after
the distortion correction described in section [ section : distort ] , the pixel scales are @xmath28 and @xmath29 , respectively .
the available fovs are @xmath30 and @xmath31 , respectively .
ao188 uses a curvature sensor with 188 control elements , operating at 2000 hz , and a 188 element bimorph deformable mirror ( bim188 ) .
it operates at the nasmyth focus of the subaru telescope .
both ngs and lgs modes are available . the recommended guide star constraints in ngs mode are brightness larger than @xmath32 mag , within @xmath33 from the target .
the lgs mode uses an artificial sodium laser guide star @xcite for high - order wavefront sensing .
the lgs is typically less bright than @xmath34 mag in @xmath35-band .
the recommended tip - tilt star constraints in lgs mode are brightness larger than @xmath36 mag , within @xmath37 ( acceptable up to @xmath38 ) from the target .
more information about ao188 is provided on the instrument web page .
the observations were performed between 2011 - 2014 . in total ,
@xmath39 nights were assigned for the present campaign , about half of which were lost due to telescope / instrument trouble or cloud coverage .
observation priority was given based on the scientific interest of each target and the degree to which the targets are suitable for ao observations in terms of tt star brightness and separation , and distance to zenith / airmass .
the 28 objects that were successfully observed , the observation modes , exposure times , filters , pixel scales , typical airmass , photometric stars and observation dates are given in table [ tab : followup - data ] .
two of the objects , sdss j0820 + 0812 and sdss j1206 + 4332 , were observed as back - up , without ao .
all observations were performed with 5 or 9-point dithering , in order to remove bad pixels and cosmic rays , and to allow for flat frame and sky frame creation from the data .
although dome flats were obtained for some observations , these have proven to be of inferior quality .
although the targets were chosen to be accessible to ao , many of these border the recommended limit in terms of the tt brightness and separation .
as such , low strehl ratios @xmath40 ( table [ tab : analpsf ] ) were typically obtained .
the 52 mas pixel scale mode was typically used , in order to increase the signal - to - noise ( s / n ) and not to avoid significantly oversampled psfs .
the list of observed tt and psf stars is given in table [ tab : ao ] .
for 12 objects , psf star observations were skipped because of rapidly changing atmospheric conditions .
typical seeing during the observations can be inferred from table [ tab : analpsf ] , and was generally @xmath41 .
data reduction was performed with iraf , using the ircs imgred package designed to reduce data obtained with ircs .
the reduction consisted of the following steps : 1 .
each frame was checked for dark patterns by dividing it to the next observed frame .
also , the number of counts at the location of the target was checked for linearity .
all targets are well inside linearity limit , except for the core of the star inside the fov for sdss j0743 + 2457 ( within 5% ) , and cores of the bright quasar images in sdss j0904 + 1512 ( within 3% ) , sdss j1322 + 1052 ( within 2% ) and sdss j1353 + 1138 ( within 4% ) .
as persistent fringe artifacts were found in the dome flats , sky flats were created by masking bad pixels and bright objects , then median - combining the dithered frames which were divided by the mean count value .
each raw frame was corrected for different pixel sensitivities by division to the sky flat .
the geometric distortion correction map described in section [ section : distort ] was applied .
sky - background frames were generated by median - combining the flat - fielded frames .
as the near - infrared sky is highly time - variable , the sky - background frames were generated for each dither sequence individually .
pixel values for the masked pixels were interpolated from the combined ones . before subtracting the sky frame , each frame was normalized so that their median values match each other .
position offsets between the images were obtained via cross - correlations between regions that contain bright objects , typically the targets .
cosmic rays falling in the regions used to perform the cross - correlations were manually masked .
the full - width at half - maximum ( fwhm ) of star - like objects in each frame was measured by fitting a moffat function to the radial profile with the iraf imexam task , and the frames with significantly different values were discarded .
the frames were average - combined using rejection algorithms ( average sigma clipping or clipping based on the ccd parameters ) .
pixel binning was performed for a few frames with significantly oversampled psf , as mentioned in appendix [ section : objectsdescript ] .
photometric zero - point calibration was performed , typically using standard stars .
all objects were corrected for galactic extinction @xcite , and atmospheric extinction relative to the standard star .
it must be noted that the standard star catalogue magnitudes at @xmath42band were used to calibrate the photometry at @xmath43band .
however , the expected differences based on interpolation are small ( @xmath44 mag ) .
after reducing the data , it became clear that none of the separately - observed psf stars represent suitable psfs to model the corresponding systems .
this was also concluded by other studies employing separately observed psf calibrators ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
the reason is psf variability , both in the science targets and the separately - observed stars .
this is caused by the rapid change of the atmospheric turbulence characteristics , which induce different responses from the ao system .
figure [ fig:0946psf ] shows the time variability of the core component fwhm in the psf for both the target and the separately - observed star in sdss j0946 + 1835 , as well as the outstanding residuals obtained if the star is used as a psf to model the system .
it is imperative that we construct a well - characterised psf for each system , in order to reach the science goal , i.e. obtain an accurate astrometrical , photometrical and morphological characterisation of the multiple components of each observed system . in order to guide the reader
, here we provide a short summary of the following subsections , in which we illustrate in detail our psf reconstruction and modelling technique . in section [ aopsf ]
we give general considerations on the ao psf . in section [ section : newmethod ]
we briefly mention the ao psf modelling techniques encountered in the literature . in section [ hostlens ]
we introduce our technique of modelling analytically all components of a gravitationally lensed quasar simultaneously , as their light profiles overlap , and derive the most suitable analytical profile .
we describe the implementation of this technique , where we take special care to properly explore the parameter space . in section [
subsection : hybrid ] we show that for selected systems we can go beyond an analytical psf , and we derive a hybrid psf that specifically accounts for the non - analytical components . in the next sections ( [ section : hostfit ] and [ section : simulate ] , respectively ) , we describe how we need to modify out technique to model systems where we detect a quasar host galaxy , as its profile fitting requires a mass model .
we then insure that the error estimates for each derived parameter accounts for systematics introduced by our modelling technique .
finally , in section [ section : distort ] we address the issue of how the instrument field distortion impacts our derived astrometry . for a seeing - limited image , spatial resolution
is usually characterised by the fwhm of a point - like stellar profile .
this characterisation becomes unreliable near the diffraction limit , as the fwhm measurement is complicated due to the diffraction rings . in the diffraction limit
, the shape of the psf is described by a two - dimensional airy function ( ignoring the telescope spider ) , with the first diffraction ring at an angular distance of @xmath45 from the centre ; here @xmath46 denotes wavelength , and @xmath47 is the diameter of the telescope mirror . in this case
the strehl ratio @xcite is used , and is defined as the ratio of the intensity at the peak of the observed seeing disc divided by the intensity at the peak of the theoretical airy disc . in general
the ao psf is described as two components : a nearly diffraction - limited core of fwhm @xmath48 , and a seeing limited halo / wing of fwhm @xmath49 , where @xmath50 is fried s parameter @xcite .
the core is typically approximated by a gaussian ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , whereas the halo is approximated by a moffat profile ( * ? ? ?
* section [ hostlens ] ) , which has a more extended wing than a gaussian . as a product of the atmosphere as well as the ao system , the ao psf exhibits both temporal and spatial variability . the spatial variability ( anisoplanatism )
causes the psf to vary across the fov . in lgs
ao , there are three sources of anisoplanatism ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
angular anisokinetism ( or tip - tilt angular anisoplanatism ) results from the difference between the tip - tilt component of the wavefronts of the tt star and the science object , and is radially symmetric around the tt star .
focal anisoplanatism ( the cone effect ) occurs because the lgs ( located at a finite altitude ) samples the cone of turbulence between the lgs and the telescope , while the turbulence experienced by the science object is distributed in a cylinder .
finally , angular anisoplanatism results from the difference in the higher order wavefront terms between lgs and the science object .
in the course of this work , the psf is assumed not to vary spatially for objects in close proximity of each other , such as the multiple components of a gravitationally lensed system .
indeed , these objects are separated by @xmath51 , much less than the isoplanatic angle in the lgs mode .
there are several examples in the literature of modelling ao lensed quasars without an a priori known psf .
these made use of the typical structure of a lensed quasar : two or four point - like images with a lensing galaxy in between . while the quasar point - source is safely unresolved , since it is typically located at high redshift , the quasar host galaxy may or may not be resolved . in all cases , only doubles where the host galaxy is unresolved were modelled in the literature , and in the case of quads , the host was actively removed during modelling , without estimating any of its physical parameters .
@xcite modelled the double sdss j0806 + 2006 with the psf estimated from the more isolated , brighter image , and employing image deconvolution .
they do not mention however if any systematics are introduced by this technique .
@xcite however argued for the use of convolution against deconvolution , since the psf is poorly defined , the s / n is limited , and smooth extended emission ( in the case of hosts ) makes the results uncertain .
when there is a physical model to test , they advise that the best approach is to convolve that model with the best estimate of the psf and then compare the result to the observations .
@xcite took advantage of the cross configuration of the quad sdss j0924 + 0219 , where the host galaxy has a different morphology at the location of each image , and estimated the psf by combining the superposed and normalised images , in an iterative procedure .
@xcite analysed the quad b0128 + 437 by iteratively fitting a psf modelled as three gaussian components , together with the lensing galaxy modelled with a sersic profile .
@xcite modelled the psf for a lensed double by using a hybrid composed of the observed brightness distribution of the bright image at the centre , and analytical wings .
there is enough information ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) in the multiple images of a lensed system to reconstruct the psf . in this paper
, we combined the approach of @xcite and @xcite into a new technique , by adopting an analytical psf model and simultaneously optimising for the global psf parameters as well as the individual objects comprising the system : multiple point sources , and the lensing galaxy modelled as a sersic profile convolved with the psf .
where possible , we take an additional step where we refine this fit by using a hybrid psf ( section [ subsection : hybrid ] ) . the optimisation is performed using a downhill simplex method @xcite to find the minimum goodness - of - fit @xmath52 in parameter space , and is implemented in a new software , hostlens , which was developed by one of us ( m. oguri ) .
hostlens combines the functionality of galfit with that of glafic @xcite . like galfit
, it allows the simultaneous fitting of both point and extended sources , but in addition can simultaneously optimise the parameters of an analytical psf .
like glafic , it can fit an observed lensing configuration with a mass model , while simultaneously fitting analytically the morphology of an extended lensed source , such as a quasar host galaxy ( section [ section : hostfit ] ) .
we note that most of the functionalities of hostlens are currently implemented in glafic .
we considered several analytical psf models to use with hostlens . according to section [ aopsf ] ,
the ao psf consists of two components , one describing the compact psf core , and the other one the extended seeing wings .
@xcite used a single moffat profile , whose wings are more extended than that of a gaussian , to approximate the full ao psf .
@xcite stated that the psf is generally matched quite well by the sum of a narrow gaussian for the core , and either a moffat or another gaussian for the halo .
@xcite used a gaussian for the core and an exponential function for the wings .
@xcite , mentioned above , used three gaussians : one component represents the diffraction - limited core , another represents the seeing - limited diffuse psf , and the third encodes structure in the psf . in order to find the most appropriate model , we fitted the majority of bright stars observed during the observation runs ( i.e. the psf stars ) with analytical profiles .
two of these fits are shown in figures [ fig : starresid2d ] and [ fig : starresid1d ] .
the first figure shows a two - dimensional fit and the subsequent residuals after subtracting elliptical but concentric 1 moffat , 1 gaussian + 1 moffat , 2 moffat , and 3 gaussian profiles , respectively .
the second shows the fitted radial plot corresponding to the same models . as can be seen , both in terms of the formal @xmath53d.o.f .
, as well as in terms of the appearance of residuals , and radial profile matches , the 2 moffat profile provides the best fit .
this is found in the overwhelming majority of fitted stars , although in some cases , such as the second example shown , the 1 gaussian + 1 moffat profile provides a similarly good fit .
the residuals in the other models all show a concentric halo , and do not match the overall radial profiles . on the other hand ,
none of the models ( including 2 moffat ) is able to model the non - analytical components close to the centre .
this entirely empirical analysis resulted in the decision to use the 2 moffat profile as the analytical psf for hostlens .
the better fit of a moffat core , which is more extended than a gaussian , may be due to the very small strehl ratios @xmath54% typically obtained in the observations .
indeed , the typical core fwhm is @xmath55 , about three times that of the diffraction - limited core .
where @xmath57 is the elliptical radial distance , @xmath58 is the distance to the centre along the semimajor ( semiminor ) axis and @xmath59 is the ratio of the semiminor to the semimajor axis ; @xmath60 is a parameter specifying the shape of the profile , related to the core - to - halo flux ratio . the moffat profile results into a gaussian profile as the @xmath61 case . in hostlens ,
the psf is modelled with 9 analytical parameters : two for each of the four components of an individual moffat profile : fwhm , ellipticity , position angle and @xmath60 , as well as one parameter specifying the relative distribution of flux , flux1/(flux1 + flux2 ) .
the two moffat profiles are concentric .
each point source is modelled with three parameters : the positions along x and y , and the total flux .
in addition , every sersic profile has ellipticity , orientation , effective radius and sersic index parameters .
finally , there is a parameter for the sky value .
therefore , a typical two - image lensed system requires 24 parameters to model analytically .
we modelled each system with hostlens , at least at an initial stage .
the derived analytical parameters of all psfs are shown in table [ tab : analpsf ] .
we selected suitably large cut regions ( typically @xmath62 ) around the targets , and masked all objects that were not simultaneously fitted by hostlens , in order to allow reliable sky value estimates and model fitting .
due to the large number of parameters and the possibility that the parameters might get trapped in a local @xmath52 minimum , we chose 500 sets of different initial parameter values from a range of plausible values , e.g. from a flat distribution in the case of position angles , and a gaussian distribution around the iraf imexam - derived value for the core fwhm component .
we chose the model with the lowest value of @xmath52 ( we also checked the second - best model to be similar ) , and in addition we performed a parameter search around it using markov - chain monte carlo ( mcmc ) , for the purpose of both refining the parameter values , and estimating confidence intervals ( error bars ) .
we ran ten mcmc chains , and removed a fraction of @xmath63 of the points from the head of each chain ( the burn - in stage " points ; i.e sensitive to the start values ) . to test the convergence of these chains , we compared the variance of the distribution of points in each chain to the variance of the combined distribution , following @xcite . after applying a smoothing technique , the combined chains provided 68% confidence intervals on the analytical parameters ( @xmath64 in the gaussian approximation ) . throughout this work ,
unless otherwise stated , for all the systems where we did not detect a quasar host galaxy , and which we fitted with a hostlens - produced analytical psf , we also checked the modelling results for consistency , with galfit . in order to produce with
galfit error bars that account for the uncertainties of the analytical psf , we produced 500 realisations of the hostlens - produced psf , by drawing at random from the probability distribution of the analytical parameters of the psf , obtained during the mcmc runs above ; we then ran galfit with each of the 500 psfs , and took the standard deviations of the resulting parameters as an error estimate .
we did not use galfit for the systems with host galaxy detections , as it lacks the functionality to fit this component ( see section [ section : hostfit ] ) .
we note that hostlens and glafic measure the effective radius of a sersic profile using a circularised radius , while galfit measures the radius along the semi - major axis .
the effective radii measured in this paper are reported following the galfit definition . for the lensing galaxies
, we considered both an unconstrained sersic index @xmath65 and @xmath66 ( table [ tab : lensmorphology ] ) , in order to ease comparison with other samples of lenses where the light profile is modelled as a de vaucouleurs profile ( see * ? ? ? * and references therein ) .
the observed systems can be classified into two categories , according to the degree in which the bright image a is separated from the other objects , and the visual appearance of the modelling residuals . for systems with small separation where the non - analytical residuals at the centre clearly overlap with a large fraction of the galaxy light ( e.g. sdss j1254 + 2235 and sdss j1334 + 3315 ) , as well as for objects where , due to the low s / n , no conspicuous core residuals are seen , data modelling stops as described above .
for the other systems , it is possible to model away the faint quasar image and the lensing galaxy using the analytical hostlens profiles , and obtain a clean image a to be used as the `` actual psf '' ( panels a - g in figure [ fig : hybrid ] ) .
the advantage in this approach is that the estimated psf is the `` true '' psf ( accounting for all non - analytical features ) , albeit a noisy one .
next , we tested whether this psf produces better statistical results .
a simple comparison with the analytical fit in terms of @xmath52 can not be used , as image a is fitted perfectly by design .
therefore , we compared the standard deviation of the residual pixel values in a region containing the rest of the objects ( typically b and g ) .
we found that in almost all cases , the analytical psf produced better results .
this is due to large noise in the wing of the `` actual psf '' .
therefore , we used another approach , previously employed by @xcite .
this consists in using the observed brightness distribution of the bright image only in its central regions , and replacing the wings after a certain cut radius with analytical wings from the 2 moffat fit ( panels h - i in figure [ fig : hybrid ] ) .
this `` hybrid psf '' approach succeeded in producing fits at least as good as the analytical psf in terms of the standard deviation of the residuals .
we considered two sources of systematics for the hybrid psf approach .
first , because the contributions from b and g are initially modelled using the analytical psf , they may be improperly subtracted at the location of a , and therefore affect the hybrid psf estimation .
this can be checked by building the hybrid psf in an iterative approach , where in each subsequent step the hybrid psf is used to model away b and g , resulting in a better hybrid psf estimate .
we did this for sdss j1405 + 0959 and obtained that subsequent psfs are virtually identical .
this is expected , as we applied the hybrid psf technique only to systems with isolated bright images .
secondly , the final models may depend on the size of the hybrid cut region .
we chose the original cut radius as the radius at which all non - analytical components disappear , of @xmath7 pixels .
for all hybrid psf systems ( excluding the ones with a quasar host galaxy detection , as described below , or otherwise specified ) , we included into the error budget the scatter between the results obtained from this cut size , and another one @xmath67 larger .
we used the analytical and/or hybrid psf approaches described above for all systems where a quasar host galaxy was not detected .
table [ tab : morphologytechnique ] shows whether the analytical or the hybrid psf was used to model each system .
a novel undertaking in this paper is the fitting of quasar host galaxies , for several systems , without an a - priori known psf .
this is only possible for gravitationally lensed quasars , because the host galaxies are tangentially stretched around the critical curves by the lensing effect , resulting in arcs that are distinct from the psf shape , and can be modelled analytically ( figure [ fig : simulatedsystem ] ) . in order to model the spatially extended flux distribution of the lensed images ,
it is necessary to model both the lens mass distribution and the extended source distribution .
this is done using the approach described in @xcite , and makes use of the fact that gravitational lensing conserves surface brightness .
hostlens was designed with the functionality to fit host galaxies modelled with a sersic profile .
when fitting a host galaxy with hostlens , the parameters typically used to model the individual images are replaced by a single source profile .
this profile consists of the parameters of a sersic model , its flux as well as the flux of the central point source , and the lensing parameters : the einstein radius , shear / ellipticity and their orientation angles , where a singular isothermal mass model is assumed ( section [ section : lensmodels ] ) .
the luminous lens galaxy is fitted simultaneously , as before , with a sersic profile .
there are five cases where the quasar host galaxy was clearly detected and fitted .
we define a clear detection as a system for which there are clear visible arcs similar in orientation to the critical curves of the lensing model , and which are convincingly removed by fitting a host galaxy . in the case of two systems with host detections , sdss j0904 + 1512 and sdss j1322 + 1052 ,
there were outstanding residuals when using an analytical psf , and therefore we employed a hybrid psf .
this was possible through an iterative process , where an analytical psf is initially used to obtain a first rough approximation of the host profile .
the host galaxy is then subtracted from the original observed frame , and subsequently a hybrid psf is created as described in section [ subsection : hybrid ] .
this hybrid psf is used in the next step of the iteration to refit the original system , and refine the host model .
subsequent steps lead to new hybrid psfs .
the iteration stops once the @xmath52 stops decreasing . to summarise , the general approach to the morphological modelling of the imaging data in this paper , whether the quasar host galaxy is detected or not , is described in the flowchart of figure [ fig : flowchart ] .
to test the reliability of the morphological fitting with hostlens using the analytical or hybrid psf methods , we performed a series of simulations for each system . in these simulations , we used a separately observed psf star , or a star in the fov that is the most similar in terms of analytical parameters to the psf of the respective system ( prioritising for the core fwhm parameter ) .
table [ tab : morphologytechnique ] shows which star was used as psf template for each system . with hostlens and/or galfit
, we simulated each system using this corresponding psf template , and the best - fit astrometry / morphology / photometry parameters we derived when modelling that particular observed system .
such a simulated system is shown in figure [ fig : simulatedsystem ] . from the final science frame of each
observed ( i.e. real ) system , we identified 100 blank sky cuts , and added them as noise realisations to the simulated system .
we then remodelled each of the 100 simulated noisy systems in the same way as we did the observed system .
the scatter in the resulting 100 values for each fitted parameter , with respect to the known input value , represents an error estimate .
the only exception is for the case when we simulated the system using the best - fit parameters , but remodelled it using sersic index @xmath68 . in that case
, we considered the scatter around the mean fitted value ( table [ tab : lensmorphology ] ) .
we used two time - saving approximations in remodelling the simulated systems .
first , we did not perform a search starting from random values in the parameter space for each individual simulated system , as we did for the original system , but instead we started the fit from the known ( correct ) values .
second , in cases where we used a hybrid psf , we did not create it in each of the 100 simulations from that very same image , but created it from only one of the simulations , and then used it as the hybrid psf to model all simulated frames .
also , for the few cases when a hybrid psf is used to fit a detected host galaxy , we only performed a small number of simulations , as these are time consuming .
these simulations can account for the systematics introduced by the analytical modelling of a non - analytical psf , or the use of hybrid psfs .
the orientation of the detector was typically the same for the science objects and the psf stars , therefore diffraction patterns due to the telescope spider are similar .
the noise cuts from the actual science frames , previously employed by ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , account for how the model parameters would depend on the existence of background objects , too faint to be visible , and are more realistic than artificially - generated noise . as final errors on astrometry / morphology / photometry
, we used the largest error bars among those resulting from these simulations and all other methods described in the previous subsections .
this is because the methods are not necessarily independent , and one typically dominates the error budget .
this system is reported in @xcite as a two - image lensed quasar at @xmath69 , with an image separation @xmath70 . in the new ao data ,
the inferred image separation is @xmath71 , making this system the smallest - separation lensed quasar in the sqls .
however , the lensing galaxy is undetected in the new observations ( figure [ fig:1128resid ] ) , with the residuals being identical whether a lens galaxy is modelled or not . without visual confirmation of improvement in the residuals ,
the extracted physical parameters of the lens are unreliable , as it is likely that noise is being fitted . considering the very small separation of this system and the fact that there are non - analytical residuals which can not be well fit , we conclude that the faint lensing galaxy , visible in @xcite , can not be reliably resolved from the bright quasar images with the current technique .
the discovery of sdss j1320 + 1644 and subsequent data analysis based on non - ao data is reported in @xcite .
this is a large - separation quasar pair , likely to be images of a lensed quasar source at @xmath72 , by a lensing galaxy group / cluster at @xmath73 .
however the lensing nature of this object is not secure .
@xcite noted that the most efficient way to test the lensing hypothesis is by performing ao observations sensitive enough to detect the quasar host galaxy , and search for evidence of lensed arcs .
the acquired ao data was affected by cloud coverage , and as such did not reach the intended depth , being in fact shallower than the original non - ao data . even after @xmath74 pixel binning to increase s / n , there are no visible signs of a host galaxy detection ( figure [ fig:1320resid ] ) . both an analytical psf and a psf built on image a were used , leading to clean residuals for image b. the only new insight brought by the new ao data is on the quasar flux ratio .
this is a / b @xmath75 , and is significantly larger than the values of 1.4 and 1.0 , considered in @xcite .
while this has little impact on their inferred lens models , since the main model constraints were astrometric , it does impact their discussion on the intrinsic flux ratio .
@xcite argued that , since typical changes due to intrinsic variability and microlensing are small in the near - infrared , the flux ratio @xmath76 observed in the spectra at long wavelengths and in the @xmath77bands is representative of the true flux ratio .
an alternative hypothesis was that the flux ratio @xmath78 found at longer infrared wavelengths is more accurate , and the changes due to microlensing at shorter wavelengths occur on time scales longer than the @xmath79 year spanned by the observations available at that time .
the new flux ratio supports this second hypothesis in the sense that larger flux variations do indeed occur on time scales of @xmath80 years , assuming , of course , that the gravitational lens hypothesis is correct for this system . | we present the results of an imaging observation campaign conducted with the subaru telescope adaptive optics system ( ircs+ao188 ) on 28 gravitationally lensed quasars and candidates ( 23 doubles , 1 quad , 1 possible triple and 3 candidates ) from the sdss quasar lens search .
we develop a novel modelling technique that fits analytical and hybrid point spread functions ( psfs ) , while simultaneously measuring the relative astrometry , photometry , as well as the lens galaxy morphology .
we account for systematics by simulating the observed systems using separately observed psf stars .
the measured relative astrometry is comparable with that typically achieved with the hubble space telescope , even after marginalizing over the psf uncertainty .
we model for the first time the quasar host galaxies in 5 systems , without a - priory knowledge of the psf , and show that their luminosities follow the known correlation with the mass of the supermassive black hole . for each system
, we obtain mass models far more accurate than those previously published from low - resolution data , and we show that in our sample of lensing galaxies the observed light profile is more elliptical than the mass , for ellipticity @xmath0 .
we also identify eight doubles for which the sources of external and internal shear are more reliably separated , and should therefore be prioritized in monitoring campaigns aimed at measuring time - delays in order to infer the hubble constant .
[ firstpage ] adaptive optics gravitationally lensed quasars
quasar host galaxies |
neutrino masses , baryogenesis , dark matter and the acoustic peaks in the power spectrum of the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) radiation require an extension of the standard model of particle physics . the supersymmetric standard model with right - handed neutrinos and spontaneously broken @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 , the difference of baryon and lepton number , provides a minimal framework which can account for all these phenomena @xcite .
@xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 breaking at the grand unification ( gut ) scale leads to an elegant explanation of the small neutrino masses via the seesaw mechanism and explains baryogenesis via leptogenesis @xcite .
the lightest supersymmetric particle is an excellent candidate for dark matter @xcite and the spontaneous breaking of @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 requires an extended scalar sector , which automatically yields hybrid inflation @xcite , explaining the inhomogeneities of the cmb .
recently , we have suggested that the decay of a false vacuum of unbroken @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 symmetry generates the initial conditions of the hot early universe : nonthermal and thermal processes produce an abundance of heavy neutrinos whose decays generate primordial entropy , baryon asymmetry via leptogenesis and gravitino dark matter from scatterings in the thermal bath @xcite . in this context , tachyonic preheating after hybrid inflation @xcite sets the stage for a matter dominated phase whose evolution is described by boltzmann equations , finally resulting in a radiation dominated phase .
it is remarkable that the initial conditions of this radiation dominated phase are not free parameters but are determined by the parameters of a lagrangian , which in principle can be measured by particle physics experiments and astrophysical observations .
our work is closely related to previous studies of thermal leptogenesis @xcite and nonthermal leptogenesis via inflaton decay @xcite , where the inflaton lifetime determines the reheating temperature . in supersymmetric models with global @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 symmetry
the scalar superpartner @xmath5 of the lightest heavy majorana neutrino @xmath6 can play the role of the inflaton in chaotic @xcite or hybrid @xcite inflation models .
one of the main motivations for nonthermal leptogenesis has been that the ` gravitino problem ' for heavy unstable gravitinos @xcite can be avoided by means of a low reheating temperature . in the following
we shall assume that the gravitino is the lightest superparticle .
gravitino dark matter can then be thermally produced at a reheating temperature compatible with leptogenesis @xcite .
the present work is an extension of ref .
we discuss in detail the effect of all supersymmetric degrees of freedom on the reheating process and restrict the parameters of the lagrangian such that they are compatible with hybrid inflation and the production of cosmic strings during spontaneous symmetry breaking .
this implies in particular that @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 is broken at the gut scale .
the consistency of hybrid inflation , leptogenesis and gravitino dark matter entails an interesting connection between the lightest neutrino mass @xmath7 and the gravitino mass @xmath8 .
as we shall see , the final results for baryon asymmetry and dark matter are rather insensitive to the effects of superparticles and details of the reheating process . due to the restrictions on the parameter space
compared to ref . @xcite the lower bound on the gravitino mass increases to about @xmath4 .
the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec_2 ]
we briefly recall field content and superpotential of our model , in particular the froggatt - nielsen flavour structure on which our analysis is based .
we then discuss the time - dependent masses of all particles during the spontaneous breaking of @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 symmetry in the supersymmetric abelian higgs model , the restrictions of hybrid inflation and cosmic strings on the parameters , and the particle abundances produced during tachyonic preheating .
section [ sec_tools ] deals with the time evolution after preheating and the required set of boltzmann equations for all particles and superparticles .
the detailed description of the reheating process is given in section [ sec : example ] with emphasis on the various contributions to the abundance of @xmath6 neutrinos , the lightest of the heavy majorana neutrinos , whose decays eventually generate entropy and baryon asymmetry .
particularly interesting is the emerging plateau of a reheating temperature which determines the final gravitino abundance . in section [ sec_parameterspace ] a systematic scan of the parameter space
is carried out , and relations between neutrino and superparticle masses are determined .
three appendices deal with important technical aspects : the full supersymmetric lagrangian for an abelian gauge theory in unitary gauge , which is used to describe the time - dependent @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 breaking ( appendix [ app_sqed ] ) , @xmath9 violation in all supersymmetric @xmath10 scattering processes ( appendix [ app_cp ] ) and the definition of the reheating temperature ( appendix [ app : trh ] ) .
our study is based on an extension of the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm ) which offers solutions to a series of problems in particle physics and cosmology .
its main features are right - handed neutrinos , a @xmath11 factor in the gauge group and three chiral superfields , needed for @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 breaking and allowing for supersymmetric hybrid inflation . in this section ,
we give a review of this model , presented earlier in ref .
@xcite , thereby focussing on the aspects which are especially relevant for this paper .
a characteristic feature of the model is that inflation ends in a phase transition which breaks the extra @xmath12 symmetry . during this phase transition
the system experiences the decay from the false into the true vacuum . at the same time
, this phase transition is responsible for the production of entropy , matter and dark matter through tachyonic preheating and subsequent leptogenesis . finally , it yields masses for the right - handed neutrinos , thereby setting the stage for the seesaw mechanism , which can explain the observed light neutrino masses .
the superpotential is given by @xmath13 where @xmath14 and @xmath15 are the chiral superfields containing the higgs field responsible for breaking @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 , @xmath16 contains the inflaton , i.e. the scalar field driving inflation , and @xmath17 denote the superfields containing the charge conjugates of the right - handed neutrinos . in the following
, we will refer to the components of @xmath14 , @xmath15 and @xmath16 as the symmetry breaking sector , whereas the components of @xmath17 form the neutrino sector .
@xmath18 is the scale at which @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 is broken .
the @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 charges are @xmath19 , @xmath20 , and @xmath21 .
@xmath22 and @xmath23 denote coupling constants , and @xmath24 represents the mssm superpotential , @xmath25 for convenience , all superfields have been arranged in @xmath26 multiplets , @xmath27 and @xmath28 , and @xmath29 are flavour indices .
we assume that the colour triplet partners of the electroweak higgs doublets @xmath30 and @xmath31 have been projected out .
the vacuum expection values @xmath32 and @xmath33 break the electroweak symmetry . in the following
we will assume large @xmath34 , implying @xmath35 .
for notational convenience , we will refer to @xmath30 as @xmath36 from now on .
in addition to these chiral superfields , the model also contains a vector supermultiplet @xmath37 ensuring invariance under local @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 transformations and the gravity supermultiplet consisting of the graviton @xmath38 and the gravitino @xmath39 .
the flavour structure of the model is parametrized by a froggatt - nielsen flavour model based on a global @xmath40 group , following refs .
@xcite . according to this model
, the couplings in the superpotential can be estimated up to @xmath41 factors as powers of a common hierarchy parameter @xmath42 , with the exponent given by the sum of the flavour charges @xmath43 of the fields involved in the respective operators . setting the charges of all higgs fields to zero ,
this implies @xmath44 the numerical value of the parameter @xmath45 is deduced from the quark and lepton mass hierarchies .
this remarkably simple flavour model can reproduce the experimental data on standard model masses and mixings , while at the same time it remains flexible enough to incorporate the phenomena beyond the standard model mentioned above .
further details on the predictive power of this model can be found in ref .
@xcite , where we recently performed a monte - carlo study to examine the impact of the @xmath41 factors . in the following
, we will restrict our analysis to the case of a hierarchical heavy ( s)neutrino mass spectrum , @xmath46 , where @xmath47 .
furthermore we assume the heavier ( s)neutrino masses to be of the same order of magnitude as the common mass @xmath48 of the particles in the symmetry breaking sector , for definiteness we set @xmath49 . with this ,
the froggatt - nielsen flavour charges are fixed as denoted in tab .
[ tab_flavourcharges ] .
.froggatt - nielsen flavour charge assignments . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] taking the @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 gauge coupling to be @xmath50 , the model can now , up to @xmath41 factors , be parametrized by the @xmath40 charges @xmath51 and @xmath52 .
the @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 breaking scale @xmath18 , the mass of the lightest of the heavy ( s)neutrinos @xmath53 , and the effective light neutrino mass parameter @xmath54 are related to these by @xmath55 here , @xmath56 , the geometric mean of the two light neutrino mass eigenvalues @xmath57 and @xmath58 , characterizes the light neutrino mass scale , which , with the charge assignments above , can be fixed to @xmath59 ev . to obtain this result , we exploited the seesaw formula @xmath60 with @xmath61 .
furthermore , it can be shown that @xmath54 is bounded from below by the lightest neutrino mass @xmath7 @xcite . in the following
, we will study the model in terms of the more physical quantities @xmath18 and @xmath53 instead of the @xmath40 charges . to partly account for the @xmath41 uncertainties in the neutrino mass matrices
, we will additionally vary @xmath54 . apart from this
, we ignore any further uncertainties of the model and simply set the @xmath41 prefactors to one .
furthermore , when considering the production of dark matter in form of gravitinos , cf
. section [ sec_mssm ] , the gravitino ( @xmath62 ) and gluino ( @xmath63 ) masses will be additional parameters . before the spontaneous breaking of @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 ,
supersymmetry is broken by the vacuum energy density @xmath64 , which drives inflation . during this time
, the dynamics of the system is governed by the slowly rolling scalar component @xmath65 of the inflaton multiplet @xmath16 .
the scalar components of the higgs superfields @xmath66 are stabilized at zero .
the right - handed sneutrinos and the scalar mssm particles obtain their masses due to supergravity contributions . as the field value of the inflaton decreases ,
so do the effective masses in the higgs sector , until a tachyonic direction develops in the effective scalar potential .
the subsequent phase transition can best be treated in unitary gauge , in which the physical degrees of freedom are manifest . in particular , performing a super - gauge transformation relates the higgs superfields @xmath66 and the vector superfield @xmath37 to the respective fields @xmath67 and @xmath68 in unitary gauge , @xmath69 note that the chiral superfield @xmath70 playing the role of the gauge transformation parameter is chosen such that @xmath14 and @xmath15 are mapped to the same chiral superfield @xmath67 .
this reflects the fact that one chiral superfield is ` eaten ' by the vector superfield in order to render it massive .
the supermultiplet @xmath67 contains two real scalar degrees of freedom , @xmath71 , where @xmath72 remains massive throughout the phase transition and @xmath73 is the actual symmetry - breaking higgs field .
it acquires a vacuum expectation value proportional to @xmath74 which approaches @xmath18 at large times . in the lagrangian
, we account for symmetry breaking by making the replacement @xmath75 , where @xmath76 denotes the fluctuations around the homogeneous higgs background .
the fermionic component @xmath77 of the supermultiplet @xmath67 pairs up with the fermionic component @xmath78 of the inflaton supermultiplet @xmath16 to form a dirac fermion @xmath79 , the higgsino , which becomes massive during the phase transition . due to supersymmetry , the corresponding scalar fields ( @xmath76 , @xmath72 and inflaton @xmath65 )
end up having the same mass as the higgsino in the supersymmetric true vacuum .
likewise , the gauge supermultiplet @xmath68 ( gauge boson @xmath80 , real scalar @xmath81 , dirac gaugino @xmath82 ) and the ( s)neutrinos @xmath83 ( @xmath84 ) acquire masses . note that the choice of unitary gauge , cf .
eq . , forbids us to use the wess - zumino gauge , so @xmath68 denotes a full massive gauge multiplet with four scalar and four fermionic degrees of freedom .
the capital @xmath85 refers to the physical majorana particle @xmath86 built from the two weyl spinors contained in the superfields @xmath87 and @xmath88 .
@xmath89 denotes the complex scalar superpartner of the left - chiral fermion @xmath88 . for an overview of the particle spectrum , see fig .
[ fig : productiondecay ] . at the end of the phase transition ,
supersymmetry is restored .
an explicit calculation of the lagrangian describing this phase transition is given in appendix [ app_sqed ] .
we can read off the mass eigenvalues during the phase transition , cf .
to : @xmath90 here we have ignored corrections which arise due to thermal effects and due to supersymmetry breaking before the end of inflation in some hidden sector , leading to a mass for the gravitino .
@xmath1@xmath2 breaking .
the higgs field @xmath76 and particles coupled to it are produced during tachyonic preheating , as marked by the red boxes .
the gauge degrees of freedom then decay nearly instantaneously ( black , dashed arrows ) , whereas the decay and production of the other degrees of freedom can be described by boltzmann equations ( blue , solid arrows ) .
the numbers in parentheses denote the respective internal degrees of freedom.,scaledwidth=100.0% ] the spontaneous breaking of @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 discussed in the previous section marks the end of a stage of hybrid inflation , which is governed by the first term in the superpotential in eq . .
as the symmetry breaking proceeds very rapidly and abruptly , it represents what is often referred to as a ` waterfall ' phase transition .
it is accompanied by the production of local topological defects in the form of cosmic strings as well as the nonadiabatic production of particles coupled to the higgs field , a process commonly known as tachyonic preheating @xcite . in the following , we shall first discuss cosmic strings and then tachyonic preheating . due to the nontrivial topology of its vacuum manifold , the abelian higgs model underlying the @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 phase transition gives rise to solitonic field configurations .
these are called cosmic strings ( for a review , cf .
e.g. @xcite ) .
their energy per unit length is @xmath91 with @xmath92 and @xmath93^{-1}$ ] for @xmath94 . according to ref .
@xcite , the characteristic length separating two strings formed during tachyonic preheating is @xmath95 here @xmath96 is the velocity of the radial component of the inflaton field , @xmath97 , at the onset of the phase transition , which can be determined from the scalar potential by exploiting the equation of motion for @xmath98 in the slow - roll approximation , @xmath99 .
according to refs .
@xcite , in the region of parameter space we are interested in , the slope of the scalar potential is determined by the coleman - weinberg one - loop corrections , cf .
e.g. ref .
@xcite for the explicit formulas resulting from the superpotential eq . . with this
, the energy density stored in strings just after the end of the phase transition can be calculated as @xmath100 inserting eqs . and and the expression for the coleman - weinberg one - loop potential from ref .
@xcite , we find that the fraction of energy stored in cosmic strings directly after the phase transition increases strongly with the coupling parameter @xmath23 . this is due to the higher energy density per cosmic string as well as the shorter average distance between two strings .
for instance , for @xmath101 gev and @xmath102 , we find @xmath103 and @xmath104 . for @xmath105 ,
this is reduced to @xmath106 and @xmath107 . as the universe evolves , the cosmic strings intercommute , forming closed loops which are separated from the infinite strings .
these oscillate , loosing energy into gravitational waves as well as into the higgs and gauge degrees of freedom until they eventually decay , cf .
refs . @xcite .
after a relaxation time , which is roughly given by @xmath108 @xcite , there is only @xmath41 cosmic string per hubble volume left and the energy density stored in the cosmic strings scales as @xmath109 .
these relic cosmic strings can in principal be observed today , e.g. via string induced gravitational lensing effects in the cmb .
the nonobservation of these effects implies an upper bound on the energy per unit length @xcite . in the following
, we will work with @xmath110 where @xmath111 is newton s constant with @xmath112 gev denoting the planck mass . inserting this into eq .
puts an upper bound on @xmath18 , which weakly depends on @xmath23 , @xmath113 in ref .
@xcite , the authors discuss hybrid inflation and cosmic string production in a setup very similar to ours .
taking into account current experimental bounds inferred from the spectrum of fluctuations in the cmb @xcite and from the nonobservation of cosmic strings @xcite , they find viable inflation for @xmath114 this significantly constrains the allowed parameter space . with the scale of @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 breaking basically fixed , @xmath115 gev , eq
. implies @xmath116 and a factor of proportionality of about 5 .
this is still consistent with the froggatt - nielsen model , since three @xmath41 factors enter in the calculation of @xmath18 .
the bounds on @xmath23 restrict the second free @xmath40 charge , @xmath117 , cf .
eq . , and therefore @xmath53 . in the following
, we will consider the restricted parameter space @xmath118 here , the variation of @xmath54 accounts for the uncertainties of the froggatt - nielsen model .
the chosen range easily covers the expected values for @xmath54 in this setup , cf .
@xcite for a recent analysis .
the production and decay of cosmic strings can in principle have a large influence on the state of the universe just after the phase transition . however , as we will argue in the following , for our purposes it is not necessary to treat these processes in detail , as long as we restrict ourselves to the parameter space in eq . .
according to eq . , it is possible to have as much as @xmath119 cosmic strings per hubble volume for large values of the coupling parameter @xmath23 . for the maximal value of the coupling constant , @xmath102 , roughly half of the total energy density just after the phase transition is stored in cosmic strings .
however , since in this case the relaxation time of the cosmic strings , @xmath120 , is much smaller than a hubble time , the major component of this energy has been converted back into higgs and gauge degrees of freedom before the processes which we describe by means of boltzmann equations , cf .
section [ sec_mssm ] , become relevant .
since the exact mechanism of energy loss of cosmic strings is not yet fully understood , we will in the following omit the effects from cosmic strings , keeping in mind that at the very most , they will convert about half of the initial energy density of the higgs bosons into particles of the higgs and gauge multiplets .
typically the effects from cosmic strings are much less important , e.g. for @xmath121 their relative energy contribution is at the level of at most @xmath122 . due to supersymmetry
, the extra higgsinos produced will decay into the same supermultiplet as the higgs bosons would have , thus inducing no significant change in the following discussion .
the extra gauge particles will decay predominantly into radiation , which is quickly diluted at this early stage of the matter dominated phase governed by the nonrelativistic higgs bosons .
thus it can be expected that our setup is insensitive to a modification of the contribution from cosmic strings to the initial conditions of the following reheating phase .
we also confirmed this in a numerical study .
considering the case of extremal string production , we shifted half of the energy initially stored in the higgs bosons at the end of preheating into the gauge degrees of freedom and calculated the resulting entropy , baryon asymmetry and gravitino dark matter .
we find no deviations from the results presented in section [ sec : example ] above the percent level .
let us now consider the production of particles coupled to the higgs field . as the value of the inflaton field decreases , the scalar potential develops a tachyonic instability in the direction of the higgs field .
quantum fluctuations of the higgs field @xmath123 with wave number @xmath124 begin to grow exponentially , while its average value remains zero .
the strong population of the long wavelength higgs modes leads to a large abundance of nonrelativistic higgs bosons .
other particles coupled to the higgs field are nonperturbatively produced due to the rapid change of their effective masses @xcite .
the mode equations for the gauge , higgs , inflaton , and neutrino supermultiplets are governed by the time - dependent masses proportional to @xmath125 given by eq . .
according to ref .
@xcite , this leads to particle production , with the energy and number densities for bosons and fermions after tachyonic preheating given by @xmath126 with @xmath127 and @xmath128 , where @xmath129 denotes the mass of the respective particle in the true vacuum ; @xmath130 counts the spin degrees of freedom of the respective particle .
just as the higgs bosons themselves , these particles are produced with very low momentum , i.e. nonrelativistically .
a deviation from this mechanism is found for the imaginary component @xmath72 of the complex field @xmath131 , since fixing the gauge to unitary gauge yields a constant contribution to its mass . neglecting the expansion of the universe , the mode equation for @xmath72 reads @xmath132 we can absorb the constant mass contribution in the momentum @xmath133 . in the language of ref .
@xcite , this is equivalent to a shift in the ` asymptotic _ in _ frequency ' @xmath134 . to excite a given mode more
energy is necessary , the production is thus less efficient . with the ingredients discussed so far , the stage is now set for the emergence of the hot early universe . in other words ,
@xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 breaking after hybrid inflation provides the initial conditions for the successful generation of entropy , matter and dark matter .
before we demonstrate this numerically , we will first introduce the necessary tools , i.e. decay rates and supersymmetric boltzmann equations , in section [ sec_tools ] .
in this section , we will discuss the evolution of the particle abundances from the initial conditions set by @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 symmetry breaking to the radiation dominated era .
a schematic overview of all relevant processes is given in fig .
[ fig : productiondecay ] . during tachyonic preheating ,
most of the vacuum energy is converted into higgs bosons . at the same time , particles coupled to the higgs bosons , i.e. particles of the gauge , higgs , inflaton and neutrino supermultiplets are produced ( cf .
red boxes in fig .
[ fig : productiondecay ] ) , with the resulting abundances given by eq . .
among these particles , the members of the gauge supermultiplet have by far the shortest lifetime . due to their large couplings they decay basically instantaneously into ( s)neutrinos and mssm particles ( cf
. dashed , black arrows in fig .
[ fig : productiondecay ] ) .
this sets the initial conditions for the following phase of reheating , which we will describe with boltzmann equations ( cf .
solid , blue arrows in fig .
[ fig : productiondecay ] ) . due to our choice of a hierarchical ( s)neutrino mass spectrum ,
the decay of particles from the symmetry breaking sector into the two heavier ( s)neutrino generations is kinematically forbidden .
these particles can hence only decay into particles of the @xmath6 supermultiplet .
these ( s)neutrinos , just as the neutrinos produced through gauge particle decays and thermally produced ( s)neutrinos , decay into mssm particles , thereby generating the entropy of the thermal bath as well as a lepton asymmetry .
note that these different production mechanisms for the ( s)neutrinos yield ( s)neutrinos with different energies , which due to relativistic time - dilatation , decay at different rates .
finally , the thermal bath produces a thermal gravitino abundance , which will turn out to be in the right ball - park to yield the observed dark matter abundance . in the following we list the total and partial vacuum decay rates necessary to quantify the processes described above .
the total vacuum decay rates for the particles of the symmetry breaking , gauge and neutrino sectors are @xmath135_{ii } m_{i } = \frac{1}{4 \pi } \ , \frac{\widetilde{m}_i m_i^2}{v_{\text{ew}}^2 } \,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath136 denoting the superfields of the model carrying @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 charges @xmath137 .
the relevant partial decay rates at leading order are given by @xmath138 \gamma^0_{\tau \rightarrow n_1 n_1 \,\ , } & = \gamma^0_{\phi \rightarrow \tilde n_1 \tilde n_1 } = \gamma^0_{\psi \rightarrow \tilde n_1^ * n_1 } = \gamma_s^0 \ , , \nonumber \\[6pt ] \gamma^0_{a \rightarrow \phi_x \phi_x } & = \frac{1}{2 } \ , \gamma^0_{a \rightarrow \psi_x \psi_x } = \frac{1}{3 } \ , \gamma^0_{c \rightarrow \phi_x \phi_x } = \frac{1}{3 } \ , \gamma^0_{\tilde a \rightarrow \phi_x \psi_x } \nonumber \\[6pt ] & = \frac{1}{3 } \ , \frac{q_x^2 \left ( 1 - 4 \frac{m_x^2}{m_s^2 } \right)^{1/2}}{\sum_x q_x^2 \left ( 1 - 4 \frac{m_x^2}{m_s^2 } \right)^{1/2 } } \ , \gamma^0_g\ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath139 and @xmath140 denoting the scalar and fermionic components of a superfield @xmath136 . at tree level
the pseudoscalar @xmath72 decays exclusively into fermionic neutrinos , similar to its scalar partner @xmath76 , whose branching ratio into scalar neutrinos is suppressed by two powers of the mass ratio @xmath141 . the production of @xmath72 particles during tachyonic preheating , cf
. sec .
[ sec_tachyonic_preheating ] , is however negligible compared to the production of @xmath76 particles .
we can thus neglect the contribution from the pseudoscalar @xmath72 in the following . another important consequence of eq .
is that taking into account that the production of the different gauge degrees of freedom during tachyonic preheating is proportional to the respective spin degrees of freedom , cf .
eq . , the decay products of the gauge degrees of freedom consist to equal shares of scalar and fermionic degrees of freedom . in this section
, we present the boltzmann equations describing the evolution of the universe after the decay of the gauge degrees of freedom , as depicted by the blue , solid arrows in fig .
[ fig : productiondecay ] .
this analysis is a supersymmetric extension of the study performed earlier in ref .
@xcite , exploiting the techniques explained there in detail . in general , the evolution of the phase space density @xmath142 of a particle species @xmath136 is determined by @xmath143 with @xmath144 denoting the liouville operator and the @xmath145 denoting the collision operators of all relevant processes involving the particle @xmath136 : @xmath146 \ , , \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath147 denotes the sum over all internal degrees of freedom of the initial and final states and the momentum space element @xmath148 is given by @xmath149 @xmath150 is a statistical factor to prevent double counting of identical particles .
the quantum statistical factors due to bose enhancement and pauli blocking have been omitted , since typically they only yield minor corrections @xcite . in the following
, we will often work with integrated boltzmann equations , which are obtained by integrating eq . over @xmath151 . in a friedmann - lematre - robertson - walker universe
, the resulting equation can be simplified to @xmath152 with @xmath51 denoting the scale factor , @xmath36 the hubble rate , @xmath153 the effective production rate of @xmath136 particles , and @xmath154 the comoving number density , i.e. the number of @xmath136 particles in a volume @xmath155 . performing a rescaling of @xmath51 in eq .
leaves the physical number density @xmath156 invariant . for convenience ,
we will thus set @xmath157 at the end of preheating in the following .
another useful quantity next to the number density @xmath156 is the energy density @xmath158 , @xmath159 * evolution of the gravitational background * the time - dependence of the scale factor @xmath160 is governed by the friedmann equation . for a flat universe and a constant equation of state @xmath161 between some reference time @xmath162 and time @xmath163 , the friedmann equation yields @xmath164 ^{\frac{2}{3(1+\omega ) } } \ , .
\label{eq : scalefac}\ ] ] after preheating , the universe is dominated by nonrelativistic higgs bosons , i.e. @xmath165 . after the end of the reheating process , the universe is radiation dominated , @xmath166 . in the intermediate region , the equation of state changes continuously .
we approximate this by implementing a piecewise constant effective equation of state with coefficients @xmath167 in the intervals @xmath168 $ ] with @xmath169 .
the @xmath167 are determined iteratively by requiring self - consistency of the friedmann equation , @xmath170 in our numerical calculations , we approximate the total energy density by its two dominant components , the energy density of the higgs bosons and the energy density of the neutrinos produced in higgs , higgsino and inflaton decays , @xmath171 , for which we will obtain analytical expressions below , cf . eqs . and .
in the following we will calculate the hubble rate @xmath172 using eq . .
* massive degrees of freedom * the boltzmann equations describing the massive degrees of freedom introduced above are @xmath173 @xmath76 , @xmath65 and @xmath79 , the particles of the symmetry breaking sector , are produced via tachyonic preheating only , hence their initial number densities are given by eq . and their initial phase space distributions are peaked at low momenta , and thus can be taken to be proportional to @xmath174 .
the collision operators on the right - hand side of eqs . to describe the decay of these particles .
the resulting ordinary differential equations are solved by @xmath175 \
, , \qquad x = \sigma , \ , \phi , \ , \psi \ , , \label{eq_fx}\ ] ] with @xmath176
denoting the time at the end of preheating .
we fix the origin of the time axis by setting @xmath177 .
also the abundances of all heavy ( s)neutrinos obtain contributions from tachyonic preheating .
the corresponding phase space distribution functions are of the same form as @xmath178 in eq . .
the collision operators for the lightest ( s)neutrinos are more involved . just as in ref .
@xcite , they can be treated best by separating the phase space density into the contributions due to thermal ( th ) and nonthermal ( nt ) ( s)neutrinos .
introducing @xmath179 , the energy of a particle @xmath136 at time @xmath163 which was produced with energy @xmath180 at time @xmath181 , @xmath182 \left(\frac{m_{x}}{e_0 } \right)^2 \right\}^{1/2 } \,,\ ] ] we find for the comoving number densities of nonthermally produced ( s)neutrinos : @xmath183 \label{eq : nxntsol } \nonumber\\ & + n^{\text{ph}}_{x } ( t_{\text{ph } } ) \ , e^{-\gamma^0_{n_1 } ( t - t_{\text{ph } } ) } + \ , n^{g}_{x } ( t_g ) \
, \exp\left[-\int_{t_g}^t dt ' \frac{m_1 \gamma^0_{n_1 } } { { \cal e}_{x } ( m_g/2 ; t_g , t ' ) } \right ] \ , , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath184 and @xmath185 here @xmath186 denotes the initial @xmath136 abundance from nonperturbative particle production during tachyonic preheating , whereas @xmath187 refers to the initial @xmath136 abundance from the decay of the gauge degrees of freedom .
note that this notation is valid throughout this paper : the lower indices on number densities , decay rates , etc .
indicate the respective particle , whereas the upper index refers to the origin of this particle .
the time @xmath188 denotes the lifetime of the gauge particles after preheating , @xmath189 , cf .
eq . , and corresponds to the value @xmath190 of the scale factor , @xmath191 .
furthermore , also the ( s)neutrinos of the second and third generation are produced in the decays of gauge particles .
the corresponding comoving number densities of these ( s)neutrino species are of the same form as @xmath192 in eq . .
inserting eq .
and eq . into eq .
yields the same time - dependence , @xmath193 , for both neutrinos and sneutrinos .
. hence implies a constant ratio between neutrinos and sneutrinos produced via decays of particles from the symmetry breaking sector throughout the reheating phase .
for instance , @xmath194 the precise value and the dependence on @xmath53 arises due to the initial conditions set by tachyonic preheating , cf .
eq . , and the branching ratios denoted in eq .
for increasing @xmath53 , we find a weak increase of @xmath195 .
unlike the two heavier ( s)neutrino generations , ( s)neutrinos of the first generation are also produced thermally from the bath .
assuming kinetic equilibrium , their comoving number densities are determined by the integrated boltzmann equation @xmath196 with @xmath197 denoting the comoving number density in thermal equilibrium and @xmath198 is the vacuum decay width weighted with the average inverse time dilatation factor , @xmath199 in eq .
we are interested in the decay width of the thermally produced neutrinos , @xmath200 . in this case
eq . can be evaluated to @xmath201 , where @xmath202 denotes the modified bessel function of the second kind of order @xmath88 .
note however that eq .
is not restricted to this case but also allows the calculation of , for example , the decay width of the neutrinos produced by the decay of the higgs bosons , @xmath203 .
* mssm degrees of freedom * the boltzmann equations governing the lepton number asymmetry and the abundance of mssm particles in the thermal bath are @xmath204 with @xmath205 denoting the collision operators responsible for the production , decay and scattering of ( anti)(s)leptons and @xmath206 describing the number of radiation quanta produced in the respective processes .
a subtle but important point concerning the boltzmann equation for the lepton asymmetry is the correct treatment of @xmath207 scattering processes with heavy ( s)neutrinos in the intermediate state .
the collision operator for ( s)neutrino decay takes care of the on - shell contributions to these processes , so we need to add the off - shell contributions . the @xmath9-conserving part is negligible compared to the on - shell contribution , so we shall concentrate on the @xmath9-violating part .
this can be obtained by calculating the @xmath9-violating contribution of the full @xmath208 scattering process and then subtracting the on - shell @xmath9-violating contribution ( reduced collision operator ) . by exploiting unitarity and @xmath209 invariance
, we prove in appendix [ app_cp ] that the @xmath9-violating contribution of the full @xmath208 scattering process vanishes up to corrections of @xmath210 , so that we can replace the @xmath9-violating off - shell contribution by the negative of the @xmath9-violating on - shell contribution . with this
, the integrated boltzmann equation up to @xmath211 obtained from eq .
reads @xmath212 with the washout rate @xmath213 and the effective ( non)thermal production rates for the lepton asymmetry @xmath214 given by @xmath215 in eq .
we have introduced @xmath216 and @xmath217 as the nonthermal and thermal contributions to the total lepton asymmetry @xmath218 , respectively .
the decay rate of the thermally produced ( s)neutrinos , @xmath219 , as well as the decay rates @xmath220 , @xmath221 , and @xmath222 for nonthermally produced ( s)neutrinos , are given by eq . .
note that eq
. relates decay rates @xmath223 and effective production rates @xmath224 .
the latter describe the relative increase of the respective particle species due to a given production process and can directly be compared with the hubble rate @xmath36 in order to determine the efficiency of the respective process .
@xmath225 parametrizes the @xmath9 asymmetry in the @xmath83 and @xmath226 decays , which , in the froggatt - nielsen model , can be estimated as @xcite @xmath227 in the following , we will set @xmath225 to its maximal value , thus obtaining an upper bound for the produced lepton asymmetry .
analogously , this time neglecting terms of @xmath228 , eq .
yields the integrated boltzmann equation for the relativistic degrees of freedom of the mssm , @xmath229 with @xmath230 denoting the effective rates of ( non)thermal radiation production , @xmath231 here @xmath232 denotes the effective increase of radiation quanta in the thermal bath by adding a particle @xmath136 stemming from the production mechanism @xmath233 with energy @xmath234 , @xmath235 another important quantity in this context is the total radiation production rate @xmath236 .
it counts the radiation quanta produced per unit time and is obtained by dividing the right - hand side of the boltzmann equation for radiation , eq . , by @xmath237 , @xmath238 here in the last expression
, @xmath239 denotes the number density of the dominant source for radiation production at a given time . solving eq .
finally yields the temperature @xmath70 of the thermal bath , @xmath240 with @xmath241 counting the effective relativistic degrees of freedom contributing to the number density of the thermal bath @xmath242 , in the mssm @xmath243 .
* gravitinos *
gravitinos are predominantly produced through supersymmetric qcd scattering processes in the thermal bath .
the corresponding integrated boltzmann equation is @xmath244 in qcd , up to leading order in the strong gauge coupling @xmath130 , the effective production rate @xmath245 is given by @xcite @xmath246 \ , , \label{eq : gammag}\ ] ] with the energy dependent thermal gluino mass , gluon mass and strong coupling constant @xmath247^{-1/2 } \
, , \end{split}\ ] ] with the typical energy scale during reheating estimated as the average energy per relativistic particle in the thermal bath , @xmath248 . the gravitino mass @xmath62 and the gluino mass at the electroweak scale @xmath249 remain as free parameters
combining our initial conditions with the boltzmann equations derived in the previous section poses an initial - value problem .
its solution allows us to quantitatively describe the generation of entropy , matter and dark matter due to the production and decay of heavy ( s)neutrinos .
we have numerically solved this problem for all values of the input parameters within the ranges specified in eq . .
in this section we first illustrate our findings for a representative choice of parameter values . in section [ sec_parameterspace ]
we then turn to the investigation of the parameter space . in this paper , we take into account all ( super)particles involved in the reheating process , in particular the gauge degrees of freedom , which were omitted in earlier studies @xcite .
this allows us to give a realistic , time - resolved description of the reheating process .
furthermore , compared to refs .
@xcite , we consider a higher scale of @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 breaking , @xmath250 , which is compatible with hybrid inflation and cosmic strings , cf .
section [ subsec : inflstrs ] .
however , many of the techniques employed when solving the boltzmann equations are very similar to those discussed in detail in refs .
we hence in the following focus on the physical results , referring the reader to these earlier works for more information on the technical aspects .
let us study the evolution of the universe after inflation for @xmath251 as we will see later in section [ subsec : gravitinodm ] , requiring successful leptogenesis as well as the right gravitino abundance to explain dark matter typically forces @xmath53 to be close to @xmath252 . here , we adjust its explicit numerical value such that , given the values for @xmath54 and @xmath8 , the gravitino abundance comes out right in order to account for dark matter .
the choice for @xmath54 represents the best - guess estimate in the context of the froggatt - nielsen flavour model employed in this work , a result we recently obtained in a monte - carlo study , cf .
@xcite . in scenarios of gauge or gravity
mediated supersymmetry breaking the gravitino often acquires a soft mass of @xmath253 , which is why we set @xmath8 to @xmath254 .
a gluino mass of @xmath3 is close to the current lower bounds from atlas @xcite and cms @xcite .
the values in eq . readily determine several further important model parameters : @xmath255 here , we have chosen opposite signs for the @xmath9 parameters @xmath256 and @xmath257 , so that the sign of the total lepton asymmetry always indicates which contribution from the various ( s)neutrino decays is the dominant one .
[ fig : numengden ] presents the comoving number and energy densities of all relevant species as functions of the scale factor @xmath51 . in both panels of this figure
some of the displayed curves subsume a number of closely related species .
these combined curves are broken down into their respective components in the two panels of fig .
[ fig : breakdown ] and in the lower panel of fig .
[ fig : tempasymm ] . the upper panel of fig .
[ fig : tempasymm ] presents the temperature of the thermal bath as function of @xmath51 . in what follows
, we will go through the various stages of the evolution depicted in figs .
[ fig : numengden ] , [ fig : breakdown ] and [ fig : tempasymm ] step by step .
subsequent to that we will , based on the plots in fig .
[ fig : numdenwo ] , discuss the impact of supersymmetry and the particles of the gauge sector on our results . + higgsinos @xmath79 + inflatons @xmath65 ) , ( non)thermally produced ( s)neutrinos of the first generation ( @xmath258 , @xmath259 ) , ( s)neutrinos of the first generation in thermal equilibrium ( @xmath260 , for comparison ) , ( s)neutrinos of the second and third generation ( @xmath261 ) , the mssm radiation ( @xmath262 ) , the lepton asymmetry ( @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 ) , and gravitinos ( @xmath263 ) as functions of the scale factor @xmath51 .
the vertical lines labeled @xmath264 , @xmath265 and @xmath266 mark the beginning , the middle and the end of the reheating process .
the corresponding values for the input parameters are given in eq . .
, width=425 ] + higgsinos @xmath79 + inflatons @xmath65 ) , ( non)thermally produced ( s)neutrinos of the first generation ( @xmath258 , @xmath259 ) , ( s)neutrinos of the first generation in thermal equilibrium ( @xmath260 , for comparison ) , ( s)neutrinos of the second and third generation ( @xmath261 ) , the mssm radiation ( @xmath262 ) , the lepton asymmetry ( @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 ) , and gravitinos ( @xmath263 ) as functions of the scale factor @xmath51 .
the vertical lines labeled @xmath264 , @xmath265 and @xmath266 mark the beginning , the middle and the end of the reheating process .
the corresponding values for the input parameters are given in eq . .
, width=425 ] * initial conditions * tachyonic preheating transfers the bulk of the initial vacuum energy into higgs bosons , @xmath267 , and only small fractions of it into nonrelativistic higgsinos , inflatons , gauge degrees of freedom and ( s)neutrinos @xmath268 . the particles in the gauge multiplet decay immediately afterwards around @xmath269 , giving rise to relativistic ( s)neutrinos @xmath270 and an initial abundance of radiation which thermalizes right away .
initially , this thermal bath neither exhibits a lepton asymmetry , nor are there any gravitinos present in it .
the expansion of the universe between the end of preheating and the decay of the gauge degrees of freedom is practically negligible , @xmath271 .
note that technically all plots in figs .
[ fig : numengden ] , [ fig : breakdown ] and [ fig : tempasymm ] start at @xmath269 .
* decay of the ( s)neutrinos of the second and third generation * among all particles present at @xmath269 , the heavy ( s)neutrinos of the second and third generation have the shortest lifetimes , cf .
due to time dilatation , the relativistic ( s)neutrinos stemming from the decay of the gauge particles decay slower than the nonrelativistic ( s)neutrinos produced during preheating .
the decay of the ( s)neutrinos of the second and third generation is consequently responsible for an increase in the radiation number and energy densities on two slightly distinct time scales .
the gauge particles decay in equal shares into neutrinos and sneutrinos , cf . section [ subsec : ratesratios ] .
their number densities thus behave in exactly the same way , explaining the overlapping curves in fig .
[ fig : breakdown ] .
the production of radiation through the decay of these @xmath272 neutrinos and @xmath273 sneutrinos is efficient as long as the effective rate of radiation production @xmath236 , cf .
eq . , exceeds the hubble rate @xmath36 . at @xmath274
it drops below the hubble rate , which roughly coincides with the value of the scale factor at which the comoving energy density of radiation reaches its first local maximum .
the period between preheating and this first maximum of the radiation energy density can be regarded as the first stage of the reheating process . in the following
we shall refer to it as the stage of @xmath275 reheating . .
the ( s)neutrinos of the second and third generation ( @xmath275@xmath276@xmath277 ) * ( upper panel ) * split into ( s)neutrinos that are produced during preheating ( @xmath278 , @xmath279 ) and in the decay of the gauge degrees of freedom ( @xmath272 , @xmath273 ) . in all four cases the sum of the contributions from both generations is shown .
the ( s)neutrinos of the first generation ( @xmath280@xmath276@xmath281 , @xmath282@xmath276@xmath283 ) * ( lower panel ) * split into ( s)neutrinos that are produced during preheating ( @xmath284 , @xmath285 ) , in the decay of the gauge degrees of freedom ( @xmath286 , @xmath287 ) , in the decay of the particles from the symmetry breaking sector ( @xmath288 , @xmath289 ) , and from the thermal bath ( @xmath290 , @xmath291 ) .
, width=425 ] .
the ( s)neutrinos of the second and third generation ( @xmath275@xmath276@xmath277 ) * ( upper panel ) * split into ( s)neutrinos that are produced during preheating ( @xmath278 , @xmath279 ) and in the decay of the gauge degrees of freedom ( @xmath272 , @xmath273 ) .
in all four cases the sum of the contributions from both generations is shown .
the ( s)neutrinos of the first generation ( @xmath280@xmath276@xmath281 , @xmath282@xmath276@xmath283 ) * ( lower panel ) * split into ( s)neutrinos that are produced during preheating ( @xmath284 , @xmath285 ) , in the decay of the gauge degrees of freedom ( @xmath286 , @xmath287 ) , in the decay of the particles from the symmetry breaking sector ( @xmath288 , @xmath289 ) , and from the thermal bath ( @xmath290 , @xmath291 ) .
, width=425 ] * decay of the particles of the symmetry breaking sector * the production of higgsinos and inflatons during preheating is roughly equally efficient , @xmath292 . taking into account kinematic constraints resulting from the mass spectrum described in section [ subsec : fnmodel ] , all particles from the symmetry breaking sector exclusively decay into relativistic ( s)neutrinos of the first generation @xmath293 .
the majority of higgs bosons , higgsinos and inflatons survives until @xmath294 , cf .
eq . , which corresponds to a scale factor of @xmath295 .
roughly up to this time the main part of the total energy is stored in these particles . at later times ,
i.e. for @xmath296 , the energy budget is dominated by the energy in radiation .
higgs bosons that decay earlier than the average lifetime are responsible for the generation of sizeable abundances of @xmath288 neutrinos and @xmath289 sneutrinos .
the contributions from higgsino and inflaton decays to this process are essentially negligible . *
production and decay of the nonthermal ( s)neutrinos of the first generation * the decay of the particles from the symmetry breaking sector is the most important source for nonthermal ( s)neutrinos . according to our discussion in section [ sec_mssm ] ,
the ratio between the number densities of @xmath288 neutrinos and @xmath289 sneutrinos is fixed to a constant value at all times , cf .
eq . . for our choice of parameters
we find @xmath297 .
moreover , the large hierarchy between the two decay rates @xmath298 and @xmath299 , cf .
eq . , renders the @xmath288 and @xmath289 number densities unable to exceed the number density of the higgs bosons . from the perspective of the rather long - lived higgs bosons
the ( s)neutrinos essentially decay right after their production . as long as they are efficiently fueled by higgs decays , the ( s)neutrino number densities continue to rise . but once the supply of higgs bosons is on the decline , they die out as well
. the overall timescale of our scenario is hence controlled by the higgs lifetime . however , as we will see below , the characteristic temperature of the reheating process is by contrast associated with the lifetime of the @xmath288 neutrinos .
further contributions to the abundances of nonthermal ( s)neutrinos come from preheating as well as the decay of the gauge particles . just as in the case of the second and third ( s)neutrino generation , the nonrelativistic ( s)neutrinos produced during preheating decay at the fastest rate and the number densities of @xmath286 neutrinos and @xmath287 sneutrinos are always the same . * reheating through the decay of @xmath288 neutrinos * the energy transfer from the nonthermal ( s)neutrinos of the first generation to the thermal bath represents the actual reheating process .
it is primarily driven by the decay of the @xmath288 neutrinos which soon have the highest abundance among all ( s)neutrino species .
in analogy to the notion of @xmath275 reheating , we may now speak of @xmath6 reheating .
this stage of reheating lasts as long as @xmath300 , cf .
let us denote the two bounding values of the scale factor at which @xmath301 by @xmath264 and @xmath266 .
in the case of our parameter example we find @xmath302 and @xmath303 . between these two values of the scale factor
the comoving number density of radiation roughly grows like @xmath304 . around @xmath305
the comoving energy density of radiation reaches a local minimum and around @xmath306 a local maximum .
similarly , we observe that the end of reheating nearly coincides with the time at which the energy in radiation begins to dominate the total energy budget , @xmath307 .
* plateau in the evolution of the temperature * the upper panel of fig .
[ fig : tempasymm ] displays the temperature of the thermal bath @xmath70 calculated according to eq . as function of the scale factor @xmath51 . as a key result of our analysis
we find that during @xmath6 reheating the temperature stays approximately constant .
for @xmath51 between @xmath264 and @xmath266 it varies by less than an order magnitude .
we thus conclude that in the first place @xmath264 and @xmath266 represent the limiting values for a plateau in the evolution of the radiation temperature .
the origin of this plateau is the continuous production of @xmath288 neutrinos during reheating .
as long as these neutrinos are produced much faster than they decay , their comoving number density grows linearly in time , @xmath308 , cf .
taking into account that until @xmath309 the expansion of the universe is driven by the energy in the higgs bosons , i.e. nonrelativistic matter , this translates into @xmath310 .
the @xmath288 number density in turn controls the scaling behaviour on the right - hand side of the boltzmann equation for radiation during @xmath6 reheating , cf .
using @xmath311 , we find @xmath312 and * ( lower panel ) * comoving number densities for the nonthermal ( @xmath313 ) and thermal ( @xmath314 ) contributions to the total lepton asymmetry as well as all ( s)neutrino species ( @xmath259 , @xmath258 , @xmath260 for comparison and @xmath261 ) as functions of the scale factor @xmath51 . the vertical lines in the upper panel labeled @xmath264 , @xmath265 and @xmath266 mark the beginning , the middle and the end of the reheating process .
the vertical lines in the lower panel respectively mark the changes in the signs of the two components of the lepton asymmetry .
, width=425 ] and * ( lower panel ) * comoving number densities for the nonthermal ( @xmath313 ) and thermal ( @xmath314 ) contributions to the total lepton asymmetry as well as all ( s)neutrino species ( @xmath259 , @xmath258 , @xmath260 for comparison and @xmath261 ) as functions of the scale factor @xmath51 . the vertical lines in the upper panel labeled @xmath264 , @xmath265 and @xmath266 mark the beginning , the middle and the end of the reheating process .
the vertical lines in the lower panel respectively mark the changes in the signs of the two components of the lepton asymmetry .
, width=425 ] * reheating temperature * the temperature at which the plateau in fig . [ fig : tempasymm ] is located sets the characteristic temperature scale of reheating . in addition , it represents the highest temperature that is ever reached in the thermal bath as long as one restricts oneself to times at which it contains a significant fraction of the total energy budget of the universe , cf .
lower panel of fig .
[ fig : numengden ] .
we define the reheating temperature @xmath315 as the temperature of the thermal bath at @xmath316 , where @xmath265 denotes the value of the scale factor when the decay of the @xmath288 neutrinos into radiation is about to become efficient .
this is the case once the hubble rate @xmath36 has dropped to the effective decay rate @xmath317 , @xmath318 this yields a value which is representative for the temperature plateau , cf .
[ fig : tempasymm ] . for the chosen set of parameters this equation has the following solution , @xmath319 in figs . [
fig : numengden ] and [ fig : numdenwo ] as well as in the upper panel of fig .
[ fig : tempasymm ] the three values of the scale factor marking the initial ( @xmath264 ) , characteristic intermediate ( @xmath265 ) and final ( @xmath266 ) point of the reheating process are indicated by dashed vertical lines .
a comparison of our definition of the reheating temperature with other common approaches can be found in appendix [ app : trh ] .
* evolution of the temperature away from the plateau * during @xmath275 reheating the temperature first increases up to a maximal value and then decreases like @xmath320 .
the initial rise reflects the production of radiation through decays of ( s)neutrinos of the second and third generation while the expansion of the universe is negligible .
the subsequent decrease then follows from the boltzmann equation for radiation , cf .
eq . , using the fact that its right - hand side stays almost constant up to the end of @xmath275 reheating , @xmath321 finally , we note that between the two stages of reheating and after the end of reheating the temperature drops off like @xmath322 .
this is the usual adiabatic behaviour indicating that no radiation , i.e. entropy is being produced , @xmath323 * production and decay of the thermal neutrinos of the first generation * unlike the two heavier ( s)neutrino flavours the ( s)neutrinos of the first generation are also produced thermally @xmath324 .
thanks to supersymmetry the evolution of the @xmath325 and @xmath326 number densities is governed by exactly the same boltzmann equation , cf .
eq . , so that they are identical at all times .
as both species inherit their momentum distribution from the thermal bath , they are always approximately in kinetic equilibrium .
simultaneously , the interplay between decays and inverse decays drives them towards thermal equilibrium .
initially , there are no thermal ( s)neutrinos present in the thermal bath and inverse decays result in a continuous rise of the thermal ( s)neutrino number densities until @xmath327 . around this time
the temperature drops significantly below the mass @xmath53 and the thermal ( s)neutrinos become nonrelativistic . the equilibrium number density @xmath328 begins to decrease due to boltzmann suppression until it almost reaches the actual number density of thermal ( s)neutrinos .
the production of thermal ( s)neutrinos can then no longer compete with the expansion of the universe and their comoving number densities do not continue to grow .
this picture , however , soon changes because reheating sets in .
as the temperature remains almost perfectly constant until @xmath329 , the equilibrium number density @xmath328 is not diminished due to boltzmann suppression any further up to this time .
instead it bends over and starts to increase like the volume , @xmath330 .
the number densities of the thermal ( s)neutrinos subsequently follow this behaviour of the equilibrium number density . during the second phase of @xmath6 reheating the temperature slightly decreases again , thereby reinforcing the boltzmann factor in @xmath328 .
consequently , the equilibrium number density stops growing and shortly afterwards starts declining exponentially .
an instant after it has passed its global maximum , the number densities of the thermal ( s)neutrinos overshoot the equilibrium number density . due to their numerical proximity the two values of the scale factor at which @xmath328 and @xmath331 respectively reach their global maxima can not be distinguished from each other in figs .
[ fig : numengden ] .
both events occur close to @xmath332 .
* generation of the baryon asymmetry * the out - of - equilibrium decays of the heavy ( s)neutrinos violate @xmath2 , @xmath81 , and @xmath9 , thereby generating a lepton asymmetry in the thermal bath .
a first nonthermal asymmetry is introduced to the thermal bath during @xmath275 reheating . for @xmath333 , the decay of the ( s)neutrinos stemming from preheating leads to an increase of the absolute value of the comoving number density @xmath313 . in the interval
@xmath334 the lepton asymmetry is slightly augmented through the decay of the ( s)neutrinos which were produced in the decay of the gauge particles .
the main part of the nonthermal asymmetry is , however , generated during @xmath6 reheating , while the scale factor takes values between @xmath335 and @xmath336 . at all other times
the effective rate at which the nonthermal asymmetry is produced is at least half an order of magnitude smaller than the hubble rate . among all nonthermal ( s)neutrinos of the first generation
only the @xmath288 neutrinos contribute efficiently to the generation of the asymmetry .
their decay results in a positive nonthermal asymmetry that gradually overcompensates the negative asymmetry produced during @xmath275 reheating . at @xmath337
the entire initial asymmetry has been erased and @xmath313 changes its sign .
washout processes almost do not have any impact on the evolution of the nonthermal asymmetry .
the rate @xmath213 at which these processes occur , cf . eq . , is always smaller than the hubble rate @xmath36 by a factor of at least @xmath338 . on top of that , at the time @xmath339 is closest to @xmath36 , which happens around @xmath340 when @xmath341 , the production rate @xmath342 is constantly larger than @xmath213 by a factor of @xmath338 , so that the effect of washout on the nonthermal asymmetry is indeed always negligible .
the decays and inverse decays of thermal ( s)neutrinos of the first generation are responsible for the emergence of a thermal , initially negative asymmetry in the bath . as long as the abundance of thermal ( s)neutrinos is far away from the one in thermal equilibrium , the absolute value of this asymmetry increases rapidly . around @xmath327
this is not the case anymore , causing the production of the thermal asymmetry to stall for a short moment . at @xmath343 the washout rate @xmath344
overcomes the production rate @xmath345 of the thermal asymmetry and its absolute value begins to decline .
note that at this time the rates @xmath345 and @xmath344 are smaller than @xmath36 by roughly a factor @xmath346 . shortly afterwards , at @xmath347 , the number density of thermal ( s)neutrinos overshoots the equilibrium density which results in the asymmetry being driven even faster towards zero . already at @xmath348
the initial thermal asymmetry is completely erased .
meanwhile , washout effects recede in importance . from @xmath349
onwards , @xmath350 permanently dominates over @xmath213 , which is why , once the thermal asymmetry has turned positive , it does not decrease anymore .
instead it freezes out at its maximal value around @xmath351 which corresponds to the time when the ratio of @xmath352 and the hubble rate @xmath36 drops below @xmath353 .
the final values of @xmath354 and @xmath355 allow us to infer the present baryon asymmetry @xmath356 as well as its composition in terms of a nonthermal ( @xmath357 ) and a thermal ( @xmath358 ) contribution , @xmath359 here , @xmath360 denotes the sphaleron conversion factor , @xmath361 and @xmath362 stand for the effective numbers of relativistic degrees of freedom in the mssm that enter the entropy density @xmath363 of the thermal bath in the high- and low - temperature regime , respectively , and @xmath364 is the comoving number density of photons . as final value for the scale factor we use @xmath365 which is the maximal value depicted in the two plots of fig .
[ fig : numengden ] . in our parameter example
we find @xmath366 recall that in section [ sec_mssm ] , we set the @xmath9 asymmetry parameter @xmath256 to its maximal value . in this sense
, the resulting values for the baryon asymmetry must be interpreted as upper bounds on the actually produced asymmetry and are thus perfectly compatible with the observed value for the baryon asymmetry , @xmath367 @xcite .
we also point out that , in fact , the froggatt - nielsen model typically predicts values for @xmath256 that are smaller than the maximal possible value by roughly a factor of @xmath338 , cf . ref .
@xcite . using a generic value for @xmath256 according to the froggatt - nielsen model rather than estimating @xmath256 by means of its upper bound ,
would thus yield an excellent agreement between prediction and observation in the context of this parameter example , @xmath368 .
furthermore , we find that in the case under study it is the nonthermal contribution @xmath357 that lifts the total baryon asymmetry @xmath356 above the observational bound .
the thermal contribution @xmath358 is smaller than @xmath357 by five orders of magnitude .
if we discarded the entire idea of nonthermally produced ( s)neutrinos being the main source of the lepton asymmetry and resorted to standard thermal leptogenesis , we would struggle to reproduce the observed asymmetry .
for the chosen value of @xmath54 , standard leptogenesis would result in @xmath369 which is almost an order of magnitude below the observed value , cf . ref .
@xcite for details .
by contrast , it is still much larger than our result for @xmath358 .
[ page : etabthdilu ] this has mainly two reasons .
first , in our scenario the decays of the nonthermal neutrinos continuously increase the entropy of the thermal bath , cf . figs .
[ fig : numengden ] and [ fig : tempasymm ] , which results in a nonstandard dilution of the thermal asymmetry during and after its production . between , for instance , @xmath370 , which corresponds to the time when the production of the negative asymmetry is reversed and the absolute value of the asymmetry starts to decline , and @xmath371 , the entropy of the thermal bath increases by a factor of @xmath372 .
second , in consequence of the specific reheating mechanism at work the generation of the thermal asymmetry is delayed in time , so that it takes place at a lower temperature than in the standard case .
this implies a correspondingly smaller abundance of thermal ( s)neutrinos , rendering our thermal mechanism for the generation of an asymmetry less efficient . we will resume this comparison of the thermal asymmetry @xmath358 with the expectation from standard leptogenesis @xmath373 in section [ subsec : baryonasym ] , where we will discuss the respective dependence on the neutrino mass parameters @xmath54 and @xmath53 .
* production of gravitino dark matter * inelastic @xmath207 scattering processes in the supersymmetric thermal plasma , mediated predominantly via the strong interaction , are responsible for the production of dark matter in the form of gravitinos . as the right - hand side of the gravitino boltzmann equation , cf .
eq . , scales like @xmath374 , the efficiency of gravitino production in the course of reheating is directly controlled by the interplay between the expansion of the universe and the evolution of the temperature . during @xmath275 reheating the temperature roughly declines as @xmath375 , cf .
eq . , such that in first approximation @xmath376 once the decay of the ( s)neutrinos of the second and third generation has ceased , the temperature decreases adiabatically , @xmath377 or equivalently @xmath378 , cf . eq . .
the rate of gravitino production @xmath379 then begins to decrease much faster than the hubble rate , in fact , initially even slightly faster than @xmath380 , causing the comoving gravitino number density @xmath381 to approach a constant value .
the first stage of gravitino production is completed around @xmath382 which corresponds to the time when @xmath379 is half an order of magnitude smaller than @xmath36 . from this time
onwards , @xmath379 scales like @xmath380 , the production term in the boltzmann equation is negligibly small and @xmath381 is constant .
the decline of @xmath379 is reversed as soon as the temperature plateau characteristic for the phase of @xmath6 reheating is reached such that approximately @xmath383 . while @xmath384 , the gravitino density @xmath381 continues to remain constant and @xmath379 increases almost as fast as @xmath385 . at @xmath386 it
has nearly caught up again with the hubble rate , i.e. the ratio @xmath387 reaches again a value of @xmath353 .
this time marks the beginning of the second stage of gravitino production .
the production term in the boltzmann equation can not be neglected any longer and , assuming for a moment an exactly constant temperature during @xmath6 reheating , we have @xmath388 the gravitino density @xmath381 hence begins to grow again , now even faster than during @xmath275 reheating .
this terminates the rise of the rate @xmath379 , turning it into a decline proportional to @xmath389 .
we thus obtain the interesting result that , although the temperature evolves differently during @xmath275 and @xmath6 reheating , the rate @xmath379 always runs parallel to the hubble rate during these two stages of the reheating process . at the end of @xmath6 reheating gravitino productions
fades away in the same way as at the end of @xmath275 reheating .
around @xmath390 , when @xmath387 drops below @xmath353 , the gravitino abundance freezes out .
the final value of @xmath381 then allows us to calculate @xmath391 , the present energy density of gravitinos @xmath392 in units of @xmath393 , @xmath394 where @xmath395 denotes the critical energy density of the universe , @xmath396 the hubble rate @xmath36 in the units @xmath397 , @xmath398 the number density of the cmb photons , and @xmath399 , @xmath400 , @xmath401 , and @xmath402 are explained below eq . .
recall that after fixing @xmath54 , @xmath8 and @xmath403 we adjusted the heavy neutrino mass , @xmath404 , such that we would obtain the right abundance of gravitinos to account for the observed amount of dark matter @xmath405 @xcite . by construction
, we thus now find in our parameter example @xmath406 in conclusion , we would like to emphasize the intriguing simplicity of this mechanism for the generation of dark matter .
let us in particular focus on the physical picture behind the second stage of gravitino production .
initially , at the onset of @xmath6 reheating , the rate @xmath379 is still very small compared to the hubble rate @xmath36 . but given the constant spacetime density of gravitino production @xmath407 during @xmath6 reheating and the rapid growth of the spatial volume due to the expansion , @xmath379 rapidly grows sufficiently large to get the production of gravitinos going . during the remaining time of @xmath6
reheating this production can then proceed without further hindrance as the universe , although it is expanding , is filled by a thermal bath at a constant temperature .
the continuous production of radiation nullifies the expansion and gravitinos are produced as in a static universe .
in other words , one key feature of our scenario of reheating is that it turns the universe into a chemistry laboratory in which the temperature is fixed at a certain value so that dark matter can be cooked in it just to the right point .
@xmath1@xmath2 vector boson ( * lower panel * ) , to be compared with the result of the full analysis in fig .
[ fig : numengden ] .
the individual curves show the comoving number densities of the higgs bosons ( @xmath76 ) , nonthermally and thermally produced neutrinos of the first generation ( @xmath408 ) , neutrinos from the first generation in thermal equilibrium ( @xmath409 ) , neutrinos of the second and third generation ( @xmath275 ) , the mssm radiation ( @xmath262 ) , the lepton asymmetry ( @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 ) , and gravitinos ( @xmath39 ) as functions of the scale factor a. the vertical lines labeled @xmath264 , @xmath265 and @xmath266 mark the beginning , the middle and the end of the reheating process .
the corresponding values for the input parameters are given in eq . .
, width=425 ] @xmath1@xmath2 vector boson ( * lower panel * ) , to be compared with the result of the full analysis in fig .
[ fig : numengden ] .
the individual curves show the comoving number densities of the higgs bosons ( @xmath76 ) , nonthermally and thermally produced neutrinos of the first generation ( @xmath408 ) , neutrinos from the first generation in thermal equilibrium ( @xmath409 ) , neutrinos of the second and third generation ( @xmath275 ) , the mssm radiation ( @xmath262 ) , the lepton asymmetry ( @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 ) , and gravitinos ( @xmath39 ) as functions of the scale factor a. the vertical lines labeled @xmath264 , @xmath265 and @xmath266 mark the beginning , the middle and the end of the reheating process .
the corresponding values for the input parameters are given in eq . .
, width=425 ] in the previous part of this section we discussed in detail the emergence of the hot thermal universe after inflation . the successful explanation of reheating as well the generation of matter and dark matter by means of our scenario did , however , not rely on any fortunate coincidence between certain particulars but was a direct consequence of the overall setup that we considered .
the essential steps in the evolution after symmetry breaking were the following .
preheating results in an initial state whose energy density is dominated by nonrelativistic higgs bosons .
these decay slowly into nonthermal neutrinos of the first generation which in turn decay into radiation , thereby reheating the universe , generating a lepton asymmetry and setting the stage for the thermal production of gravitinos . at the same time , an additional contribution to the lepton asymmetry is generated by thermally produced ( s)neutrinos .
all further details that we took care of are , of course , important for a complete understanding of the physical picture , but merely have a small impact on the final outcome of our calculation . in particular , as we will illustrate in this subsection , the numerical results for the observables of interest , @xmath315 , @xmath356 , and @xmath410 , remain unaffected if one neglects the superpartners of all massive particles or if one excludes the gauge particles from the analysis , cf .
[ fig : numdenwo ] , in which we plot the corresponding comoving number densities of all remaining species as functions of the scale factor .
this observation renders our scenario of reheating robust against uncertainties in the underlying theoretical framework and opens up the possibility to connect it to other models of inflation and preheating as long as these provide similar initial conditions as spontaneous @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 breaking after hybrid inflation .
in addition to that , the robustness of our scenario justifies to crudely simplify its technical description .
if one is interested in the parameter dependence of the observables and less in the exact evolution during reheating , one may simply omit effects due to the gauge degrees of freedom and supersymmetry as it has been done in refs .
@xcite and @xcite . * nonsupersymmetric analysis including the gauge multiplet * in a first step , in order to assess the impact of supersymmetry on the reheating process in the abelian higgs model , we neglect the superpartners of all massive particles , i.e. the gauge scalar @xmath81 , the gaugino @xmath411 , the higgsino @xmath79 as well as all heavy sneutrinos @xmath226 .
technically , this renders the inflaton @xmath65 stable as it can only decay into a pair of @xmath412 sneutrinos . to avoid overclosure of the universe
we thus also omit the inflaton .
by contrast , we keep the full particle spectrum of the mssm and the gravitino because we still wish to account for dark matter by thermally produced gravitinos .
all in all , these simplifications imply drastically simpler boltzmann equations and induce small changes to the corresponding decay and production rates .
again we solve the set of boltzmann equations in combination with the initial conditions set by preheating and the decay of the gauge degrees of freedom .
for our key observables we obtain @xmath413 with regard to their first two digits , these results for @xmath315 , @xmath356 , @xmath357 and @xmath410 are the same as in the full analysis .
the result for @xmath358 is smaller by a factor @xmath414 reflecting the missing contribution from the thermal sneutrinos of the first generation . in the upper panel of fig .
[ fig : numdenwo ] we present the corresponding comoving number densities .
they behave very similarly to the original densities in the upper panel of fig .
[ fig : numengden ] , the only minor differences being the following . at early times
all densities but the one of the higgs bosons are a bit smaller , at most by a factor of @xmath338 . in turn , the density of the higgs bosons is technically a bit larger .
but the relative change is of @xmath415 and thus not visible in fig .
[ fig : numdenwo ] .
the fact that initially more energy remains in the higgs bosons has two reasons .
first , there are now simply less particle species present into which the initial vacuum energy could be distributed .
second , particles coupling to the gauge sector are produced in smaller numbers after preheating due to the absence of the superpartners of the @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 vector boson .
a direct consequence of the densities being initially slightly smaller is that they become sensitive to the decays of the nonthermal @xmath288 neutrinos a bit earlier .
the onset of reheating and the inversion of the lepton asymmetry , for instance , take place at @xmath416 and @xmath417 , respectively , while these events occur later , at @xmath302 and @xmath337 , if supersymmetry is fully included . however , as soon as the @xmath262 and @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 abundances are dominated by the decay products of the @xmath288 neutrinos , the differences between the two plots in the upper panels of figs .
[ fig : numengden ] and [ fig : numdenwo ] begin to vanish . from @xmath418
onwards , they are , up to a factor 2 between the curves for the thermal ( s)neutrinos , at or below the percent level .
it is easy to understand why the omission of the heavy superparticles does not have any effect on our final results . according to eq .
the initial energy densities of the gauge scalar @xmath81 , the gaugino @xmath411 , the higgsino @xmath79 , the inflaton @xmath65 as well as the heavy sneutrinos @xmath226 are monotonic functions of the higgs - inflaton coupling @xmath23 . setting @xmath23 to its maximal value , @xmath102 , we obtain upper bounds on these densities , @xmath419 we thus conclude that no matter how the dynamics of the above species look like in detail , their influence on the reheating process will always be outweighed sooner or later by the decay of the much more abundant higgs bosons .
ignoring these particles does hence not affect the outcome of our calculation .
similarly , we can show that only the fermionic decays of the higgs bosons are relevant for reheating .
the ratio of @xmath289 sneutrinos to @xmath288 neutrinos increases monotonically with the mass @xmath53 , cf .
our upper bound on this mass , @xmath420 , then translates into @xmath421 the nonthermal @xmath289 sneutrinos can hence also be safely neglected . in conclusion , our numerical results in eqs . and substantiate our introductory comment at the beginning of this subsection .
the essential feature of our scenario of reheating is the higgs boson decay chain , @xmath422 . from the point of view of the final results for the observables ,
the inclusion of the full supersymmetric particle spectrum is rather a matter of theoretical consistency than a numerical necessity .
* nonsupersymmetric analysis neglecting the gauge multiplet * finally , we wish to demonstrate that one is also free to neglect the decay of the gauge particles if one is only interested in numerical results for the observables .
in addition to all massive superparticles we now also exclude the @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 vector boson from our analysis .
consequently , particle production in the decay of gauge particles does not take place any longer , which simplifies our set of boltzmann equations once more .
this time we find for our key observables @xmath423 with regard to their first two digits , these results exactly match those in eq . .
the lower panel of fig .
[ fig : numdenwo ] displays the corresponding comoving number densities , again to be compared with the original densities in the upper panel of fig .
[ fig : numengden ] .
the absence of ( s)neutrinos of the second and third generation produced through the decay of gauge particles now results in a slightly smaller initial lepton asymmetry and , more importantly , in drastically shorter @xmath275 reheating . while this first stage of reheating still lasted until @xmath274 in our complete analysis , cf .
section [ subsec_decay_mp ] , it now comes to an end already at @xmath424 . before the onset of @xmath6 reheating the abundances of radiation , thermal neutrinos and gravitinos are hence significantly reduced . for instance , at @xmath425 the respective comoving number densities are suppressed by factors of the following orders of magnitude , @xmath426 as before , due to this initial suppression these densities are earlier sensitive to the decay of the @xmath288 neutrinos .
now the onset of @xmath6 reheating and the inversion of the lepton asymmetry take place at @xmath427 and @xmath428 , which is even earlier than in our nonsupersymmetric analysis including the gauge multiplet .
however , during @xmath6 reheating the differences between the two plots in the upper panel of fig .
[ fig : numengden ] and the lower panel of fig .
[ fig : numdenwo ] again vanish . from @xmath418
onwards , they are at or below the percent level . in conclusion
, we find that including the gauge degrees of freedom has a great impact on the dynamics at early times shortly after preheating , but turns out be nonessential when calculating the final numerical results .
the value of the boltzmann equations derived in section [ sec_mssm ] is twofold . on the one hand ,
as we have seen in the last section , they are the basis for a detailed time - resolved description of the dynamics during reheating . on the other hand ,
as we will demonstrate in this section , solving them in the entire parameter space allows one to study the quantitative dependence of our key quantities , @xmath315 , @xmath356 , and @xmath410 , on the parameters in the lagrangian . in doing
so we will mainly focus on the physical aspects of our results , referring the interested reader to ref .
@xcite , where we elaborate more comprehensively on the technical details of our approach .
the relevant parameters of our model are the scale of @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 breaking @xmath18 , the heavy neutrino mass @xmath53 , the effective neutrino mass @xmath54 , the gravitino mass @xmath8 , and the gluino mass @xmath403 .
requiring consistency with hybrid inflation and the production of cosmic strings fixes the @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 breaking scale , @xmath429 , and limits the range of possible @xmath53 values , cf .
section [ subsec : inflstrs ] . according to the froggatt - nielsen flavour model
, @xmath54 should be close to @xmath430 .
however , in order to account for the uncertainties of the flavour model , we vary it between @xmath431 and @xmath432 , cf .
eq . . for the gravitino mass
we consider typical values as they arise in scenarios of gauge or gravity mediated supersymmetry breaking , @xmath433 as for the gluino , we stick without loss of generality to the mass that we used in the parameter example discussed in the previous section , @xmath434 .
the generalization to different choices for @xmath403 is straightforward , cf .
appendix d in ref .
@xcite , and simply amounts to a rescaling of all values for the gravitino mass .
notice that gravitino masses as large as @xmath435 are , in fact , inconsistent with unified gaugino masses at the gut scale . if the gluino and the bino had the same mass at the gut scale , the different running of the respective renormalization group equations
would then entail a mass ratio of roughly @xmath436 at low energies .
the gravitino which we assume to be the lightest superparticle would then have to be lighter than the bino , resulting in an upper bound of @xmath437 .
we , however , leave open the question whether gaugino mass unification takes place at the gut scale and work in the following with the full gravitino mass range specified in eq . .
at each point of the parameter space defined by the above restrictions we solve the boltzmann equations and record all important numerical results , which we now discuss in turn . in sections
[ subsec : trh ] and [ subsec : baryonasym ] we study the parameter dependence of the reheating temperature and the final baryon asymmetry , respectively .
in particular , we devote attention to the composition of the asymmetry in terms of a nonthermal and a thermal contribution . by imposing the condition that the maximal possible baryon asymmetry be larger than the observed one
, we identify the region in parameter space that is consistent with leptogenesis , cf . the comment below eq . ,
@xmath438 in section [ subsec : gravitinodm ]
we then turn to the generation of dark matter in the form of gravitinos . requiring the final gravitino abundance to match the observed density of dark matter ,
@xmath439 we are able to derive relations between the neutrino parameters @xmath53 and @xmath54 and the superparticle masses @xmath8 and @xmath403 . combining the two conditions in eqs . and , we are eventually even able to set a lower bound on @xmath8 in terms of @xmath54 .
note that in all plots in this section ( figs .
[ fig : temprh ] , [ fig : asym ] and [ fig : mgbounds ] ) the position of the parameter point which we investigated in section [ sec : example ] is marked by a small white circle .
as a function of the effective neutrino mass @xmath54 and the heavy neutrino mass @xmath53 .
the reheating temperature is calculated according to eq . after solving the boltzmann equations , cf .
appendix [ app : trh ] for a comparison of our definition of the reheating temperature with other common approaches .
the thick horizontal gray lines represent the lower and the upper bound on @xmath53 , respectively , which arise from requiring consistency with hybrid inflation and the production of cosmic strings during the @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 phase transition , cf .
the small white circle marks the position of the parameter point discussed in section [ sec : example ] .
[ fig : temprh ] , width=330 ] the process of reheating after the @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 phase transition is accompanied by an intermediate plateau in the decline of the temperature , which determines the characteristic temperature scale of reheating . in section [ subsec : rhandt ]
we concretized this intuitive notion and defined the reheating temperature @xmath315 as the temperature of the thermal bath at the moment when the decay of the @xmath288 neutrinos into radiation is about to become efficient , cf .
eq . , @xmath440 in appendix [ app : trh ] we argue that this definition is particularly convenient compared to alternative approaches because it is not only representative for the temperature plateau during reheating , but also associated with a physical feature in the temperature curve .
having at hand the solutions of the boltzmann equations for all allowed values of @xmath54 and @xmath53 , eq .
enables us to determine the reheating temperature as a function of these two parameters , @xmath441 .
as the reheating process is solely controlled by higgs and neutrino decays , @xmath315 obviously does not depend on the gravitino or gluino mass . in fig .
[ fig : temprh ] we present the result of our analysis .
we find that , within the considered range of neutrino parameters , the reheating temperature varies by almost five orders of magnitude . for @xmath442 and @xmath443
we have , for instance , @xmath444 , while for @xmath445 and @xmath446 we obtain @xmath447 .
remarkably , the reheating temperature never exceeds the neutrino mass @xmath53 .
instead it is typically smaller than @xmath53 by one or even two orders of magnitude . as the ratio @xmath448 controls the strength of washout process during reheating ,
we conclude that the effect of washout on the generation of the lepton asymmetry is in most cases negligible , cf .
section [ subsec : baryonasym ] where we will come back to this observation .
the reheating temperature increases monotonically with both neutrino parameters , @xmath54 and @xmath53 , with the dependence on @xmath53 being much more pronounced than the dependence on @xmath54 . in the following
we will derive a simple semianalytical approximation for @xmath315 by means of which this behaviour can be easily understood .
a more detailed discussion can be found in appendix c of ref .
@xcite . by definition
, @xmath315 corresponds to the decay temperature of @xmath6 neutrinos decaying with the effective rate @xmath317 .
to first approximation , we may thus write @xmath449 where @xmath450 denotes the average of the relativistic lorentz factor relating @xmath317 to the vacuum decay rate @xmath298 . this first estimate of the reheating temperature fails to accurately reproduce our numerical results because of two imprecisions . first , eq .
is based on the assumption that at @xmath316 the dominant contribution to the total energy is contained in radiation .
this is , however , never the case . at @xmath316
the decays of the @xmath288 neutrinos have just set in , so that at this time a significant fraction of the total energy is hence always still stored in these neutrinos .
on top of that , for @xmath451 , which is the case in almost the entire parameter space , the higgs bosons have not decayed yet at @xmath316 , so that , in the end , they dominate the total energy density at the time of reheating .
to remedy this first imprecision , we have to multiply eq . by @xmath452 , where @xmath453 .
the second imprecision is related to the fact that we do not explicitly solve the friedmann equation to determine the hubble parameter , but rather calculate it as @xmath454 with the scale factor @xmath51 being constructed as described in section [ sec_mssm ] . as a consequence of this procedure ,
@xmath36 does not always exactly fulfill the friedmann equation .
we account for this technical imprecision by multiplying eq .
by @xmath455 , where @xmath456 relates @xmath454 to the exact solution of the friedmann equation at @xmath316 .
for appropriate functions @xmath457 , @xmath458 and @xmath459 , the reheating temperature @xmath315 can then be written as @xmath460 the dependence of @xmath457 , @xmath458 and @xmath459 on @xmath54 and @xmath53 follows from the solutions of the boltzmann equations . restricting ourselves to the region in parameter space in which @xmath461 , we find that @xmath458 and @xmath459 are basically constant .
we obtain @xmath462 and @xmath463 with deviations around these values of a few percent .
the dependence of the correction factor @xmath457 on @xmath54 and @xmath53 is well described by @xmath464 such a behaviour directly follows from the interplay of the decay rates @xmath298 and @xmath299 . for large @xmath298 and small @xmath299
reheating takes place quite early , at a time when most higgs bosons have not decayed yet . for small @xmath298 and large @xmath299
reheating takes place later and not as many higgs bosons are present anymore at @xmath316 .
the magnitude of @xmath457 is hence controlled by the ratio @xmath465 which scales like @xmath466 .
this explains the parameter dependence in eq . .
putting all these results together yields a fitting formula for the reheating temperature that reproduces our numerical results with an error of less than a percent in almost the entire parameter space , @xmath467 as a function of the effective neutrino mass @xmath54 and the heavy neutrino mass @xmath53 .
the baryon asymmetry is calculated according to eq .
after solving the boltzmann equations . in the bright green ( gray green ) region
the nonthermal ( thermal ) asymmetry is consistent with the observed asymmetry . in the red region
the total asymmetry falls short of the observational bound .
below ( above ) the thin blue line the nonthermal ( thermal ) asymmetry dominates over the thermal ( nonthermal ) asymmetry .
the thick horizontal gray lines represent the lower and the upper bound on @xmath53 , respectively , which arise from requiring consistency with hybrid inflation and the production of cosmic strings during the @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 phase transition , cf .
the small white circle marks the position of the parameter point discussed in section [ sec : example ] .
[ fig : asym ] , width=445 ] based on the solutions of the boltzmann equations we calculate the nonthermal and thermal contributions to the final baryon asymmetry , cf .
eq . , for all values of the neutrino parameters @xmath54 and @xmath53 .
we present the result of this analysis in fig .
[ fig : asym ] . the parameter regions in fig .
[ fig : asym ] where the nonthermal and thermal baryon asymmetries @xmath357 and @xmath358 are consistent with the observational bound @xmath468 are shaded in bright green and gray green , respectively .
the overlap of these two regions is coloured in dark green . in the white patch around @xmath469 and @xmath470
the total asymmetry @xmath471 is larger than @xmath468 , but neither of its two contributions is . below the solid blue line in fig .
[ fig : asym ] the nonthermal asymmetry dominates over the thermal one . above the solid blue line it is the other way around .
we conclude that in the part of parameter space that we are interested in , the thermal asymmetry is almost always outweighed by its nonthermal counterpart . especially in the region in which leptogenesis is consistent with gravitino dark matter , where @xmath53 is typically of @xmath472 , cf .
section [ subsec : gravitinodm ] , the thermal asymmetry is negligibly small . in most of the parameter space
the nonthermal asymmetry is insensitive to @xmath54 and thus solely controlled by @xmath53 . only for large values of @xmath54 and
@xmath53 it depends on both neutrino mass parameters .
this behaviour is directly related to the efficiency of the washout processes in the respective parameter regions .
let us suppose for a moment that washout does not take place .
the final nonthermal asymmetry then only depends on the total number of ( s)neutrinos produced during reheating and the amount of @xmath9 violation per ( s)neutrino decay .
neither of these two quantities is , however , affected by changes in @xmath54 , so that the asymmetry , indeed , ends up being a function of @xmath53 only .
from this perspective , the insensitivity of @xmath357 to @xmath54 signals that the effect of washout on the generation of the asymmetry is negligible for most values of the neutrino parameters .
this result is consistent with our findings for the reheating temperature and in particular the ratio @xmath448 as a function of @xmath54 and @xmath53 , cf .
section [ subsec : trh ] . to see this , note that for temperatures @xmath473 the effective washout rate @xmath344 decreases exponentially when raising the ratio @xmath474 , @xmath475 which readily follows from eqs . and .
the fact that @xmath476 is of @xmath338 or even larger for most parameter values then explains why the impact of washout is typically vanishingly small . in turn , eq .
also illustrates the importance of washout at very large values of @xmath54 and @xmath53 , for which the ratio @xmath476 approaches values of @xmath477 .
comparing our results for the reheating temperature and the baryon asymmetry in figs .
[ fig : temprh ] and [ fig : asym ] , respectively , we find that washout only plays a significant role if @xmath478 and @xmath479 .
interestingly , the parameter region defined by these two conditions covers the entire range of parameters in which the thermal asymmetry exceeds the observed asymmetry .
if washout is negligible , the nonthermal asymmetry can be reproduced to good approximation by assuming that all @xmath288 neutrinos decay instantaneously at time @xmath480 into radiation .
the resultant baryon asymmetry is then given by @xmath481 where @xmath482 denotes the average energy per @xmath288 neutrino .
the ratio @xmath483 is proportional to @xmath484 , the number density of @xmath288 neutrinos at the same time when these decay , normalized to the radiation number density .
it directly follows from the solutions of the boltzmann equations and is well described by @xmath485 together with the expression for @xmath256 in eq .
this yields the following fitting formula for the nonthermal asymmetry in the case of weak washout , @xmath486 it reproduces our numerical results for @xmath487 within a factor of 2 for most values of @xmath53 .
the requirement that the maximal possible asymmetry be larger than the observed one constrains the allowed range of @xmath53 values .
[ fig : asym ] implies the following lower bound , @xmath488 where we have averaged out the slight dependence on @xmath54 .
if @xmath53 is chosen below this minimal value , the asymmetry falls below the observational bound for two reasons . on the one hand ,
small @xmath53 implies a small @xmath9 parameter @xmath256 , cf .
eq .. on the other hand , according to eq .
, a small @xmath53 value also entails a small ratio @xmath483 , i.e. a small abundance of ( s)neutrinos at the time the asymmetry is generated .
the combination of both effects then renders the successful generation of the lepton asymmetry impossible .
the thermal asymmetry has , to first approximation , the same parameter dependence as the asymmetry generated in standard leptogenesis .
it increases monotonically with @xmath53 .
if @xmath53 is kept fixed at some value @xmath489 , it is largest for @xmath54 values of @xmath490 .
the monotonic behaviour in @xmath53 is a direct consequence of the fact that the @xmath9 parameter @xmath256 scales linearly with @xmath53 .
the preference for intermediate values of @xmath54 has the same reason as in the standard case .
large @xmath54 corresponds to strong washout , at least for the high values of @xmath53 at which the thermal generation of the asymmetry carries weight .
small @xmath54 results in a low temperature and a small neutrino decay rate @xmath298 such that the thermal production of ( s)neutrinos is suppressed . especially in the parameter region in which the thermal asymmetry dominates over the nonthermal asymmetry , the expectation from standard leptogenesis @xmath491 approximates our numerical results reasonably well , @xmath492 here , @xmath493 denotes the final efficiency factor . in the strong washout regime , @xmath494 ,
it is inversely proportional to @xmath54 and independent of the initial conditions at high temperatures @xcite , @xmath495 combining eqs . and with the expression for @xmath256 in
, we obtain @xmath496 in the region in parameter space where @xmath497 this fitting formula reproduces our numerical results within a factor of 2 . despite these similarities
it is , however , important to note that our thermal mechanism for the generation of the lepton asymmetry differs from the standard scenario in two important aspects .
first , our variant of thermal leptogenesis is accompanied by continuous entropy production , while one assumes an adiabatically expanding thermal bath in the case of standard leptogenesis .
consequently , our thermal asymmetry experiences an additional dilution during and after its generation , cf . the comment on page .
second , our scenario of reheating implies a particular relation between the temperature at which leptogenesis takes place , which is basically @xmath315 in our case , and the neutrino mass parameters , cf . section [ subsec : trh ] , that differs drastically from the corresponding relation implied by standard leptogenesis .
this translates into a different parameter dependence of the ratio @xmath474 as a function of @xmath54 and @xmath53 , which in turn alters the efficiency of washout process and the production of thermal ( s)neutrinos from the bath in the respective regions of parameter space . in the end ,
our thermal asymmetry therefore rather corresponds to a distorted version of the asymmetry generated by standard leptogenesis . as we have remarked above , in the parameter region where the thermal asymmetry is larger than the nonthermal asymmetry @xmath358 hardly deviates from @xmath373 .
but as soon as we go to smaller values of @xmath54 and @xmath53 the difference between the two asymmetries grows .
the minimal value of @xmath53 for which the thermal asymmetry is still able to exceed the observational bound , for instance , turns out to be much larger in our scenario than in standard leptogenesis .
we find an absolute lower bound on @xmath53 of roughly @xmath498 at an effective neutrino mass @xmath499 , while standard leptogenesis only constrains @xmath53 to values larger than @xmath500 .
lowering @xmath53 below @xmath498 either implies a larger ratio @xmath476 or a larger effective neutrino mass @xmath54 , cf .
[ fig : temprh ] . in either case
the thermal asymmetry is reduced so that it drops below the observed value . in conclusion , we emphasize that the generation of the lepton asymmetry is typically dominated by the decay of the nonthermal ( s)neutrinos . only in the parameter region of strong washout , which is characterized by a small ratio @xmath476 , the nonthermal asymmetry is suppressed and the thermal asymmetry has the chance to dominate . related to that
, we find that the viable region in parameter space governed by the nonthermal mechanism is significantly larger than the corresponding region for the thermal mechanism . independently of @xmath54 , the neutrino mass @xmath53 can be as small as @xmath501 , which is an order of magnitude below the bound of @xmath502 , which one obtains in the purely thermal case . *
( upper panel ) * and the reheating temperature @xmath315 * ( lower panel ) * as functions of the effective neutrino mass @xmath54 and the gravitino mass @xmath8 such that the relic density of dark matter is accounted for by gravitinos , cf .
eqs . and .
in the red region the lepton asymmetry generated by leptogenesis is smaller than the observed one , providing us with a lower bound on the gravitino mass in dependence on @xmath54 .
the colour code is the same as in figs .
[ fig : temprh ] and [ fig : asym ] .
the small white circle marks the position of the parameter point discussed in section [ sec : example ] .
[ fig : mgbounds ] , width=442 ] * ( upper panel ) * and the reheating temperature @xmath315 * ( lower panel ) * as functions of the effective neutrino mass @xmath54 and the gravitino mass @xmath8 such that the relic density of dark matter is accounted for by gravitinos , cf . eqs . and .
in the red region the lepton asymmetry generated by leptogenesis is smaller than the observed one , providing us with a lower bound on the gravitino mass in dependence on @xmath54 .
the colour code is the same as in figs .
[ fig : temprh ] and [ fig : asym ] .
the small white circle marks the position of the parameter point discussed in section [ sec : example ] .
[ fig : mgbounds ] , width=442 ] the final abundance of gravitinos @xmath503 depends on three parameters : the reheating temperature @xmath315 as well as the two superparticle masses @xmath8 and @xmath403 . a key result of our reheating scenario is that @xmath315 is determined by the neutrino mass parameters @xmath54 and @xmath53 .
as we keep the gluino mass fixed at @xmath3 , the gravitino abundance thus ends up being a function of @xmath54 , @xmath53 and @xmath8 .
based on the solutions of the boltzmann equations we calculate @xmath503 according to eq . for all values of these three masses . by imposing the condition that gravitinos be the constituents of dark matter we can then eliminate one of the free mass parameters , for instance the neutrino mass @xmath53 , @xmath504 the physical picture behind this step is the following . for given @xmath8 ,
the reheating temperature has to have one specific value so that the abundance of gravitinos comes out right .
each choice for @xmath54 then implies one particular value of @xmath53 for which this desired reheating temperature is obtained . solving eq . for @xmath53 yields this value as a function of @xmath54 and @xmath8 .
the corresponding reheating temperature follows immediately , @xmath505 in summary , combining the requirement that gravitinos make up the dark matter with the fact that the reheating temperature is determined by neutrino parameters allows us to infer relations between these neutrino parameters and superparticle masses .
the lower bound on @xmath53 induced by leptogenesis , cf .
eq . , can then be translated into a constraint on the mass parameters @xmath54 and @xmath8 .
@xmath506 we present our results for the functions @xmath507 and @xmath508 in the two panels of fig .
[ fig : mgbounds ] , respectively .
furthermore , we indicate in both plots the constraint arising from the requirement of successful leptogenesis . we observe the following trends in the two plots of fig . [
fig : mgbounds ] .
both quantities , @xmath53 and @xmath315 , show a stronger dependence on the gravitino mass than on the effective neutrino mass .
for @xmath509 the reheating temperature is almost completely insensitive to @xmath54 .
the neutrino mass @xmath53 slightly increases when lowering the value of @xmath54 . for large values of the effective neutrino mass , @xmath510 ,
exactly the opposite is the case .
@xmath53 does not depend on @xmath54 anymore and @xmath315 slightly rises when increasing @xmath54 . in the following
we will construct semianalytical approximations for @xmath53 and @xmath315 which will allow us to get some intuition for this behaviour .
the final gravitinos abundance @xmath391 can be parametrized in the following way , cf .
appendix d of ref .
@xcite for details , @xmath511 \ , .
\label{eq : omegaanaly}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , the two coefficient functions @xmath512 subsume all factors contributing to @xmath391 that can be taken care of analytically , @xmath513 \ , , \nonumber \\ c_2 = & \ : \frac{3 g_s^4\left(\mu_0\right)}{100 g_s^4\left(t_{\textrm{rh}}\right)}\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] they both depend only very weakly on the reheating temperature , so that for our purposes it will suffice to treat them as constants , @xmath514 and @xmath515 .
the factor @xmath516 parametrizes all effects that can not be accounted for analytically in the derivation of eq . , i.e. the amount of energy in radiation at @xmath316 , the ratio @xmath387 at @xmath316 as well as the increase in the comoving number densities of gravitinos and radiation after @xmath316 . in principle
it depends on all mass parameters , in practice after solving the boltzmann equations we find that it is mainly controlled by @xmath54 , @xmath517 where the exponent @xmath518 is @xmath519 for @xmath510 and @xmath520 for @xmath509 .
we insert our results for @xmath521 and @xmath516 into eq .
, set @xmath410 to @xmath522 and solve for @xmath315 , @xmath523^{-1 } \ , .
\label{eq : trhm1tmgfit}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the corresponding expression for @xmath53 can then be obtained by exploiting eq .
, @xmath524^{-4/5 } \ , , \label{eq : m1m1tmgfit}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the exponent @xmath52 is given as @xmath525@xmath1@xmath526 so that @xmath527 for @xmath510 and @xmath528 for @xmath509 .
these two fitting formulae reproduce our numerical results with deviations of @xmath529 and nicely illustrate the different dependence of @xmath315 and @xmath53 on @xmath54 for small and large values of @xmath54 , respectively . as expected , they show that the dependence on @xmath54 is always very mild and solely stems from the factor @xmath516 , i.e. corrections beyond the purely analytical result for @xmath410 . if we were to omit these corrections and set @xmath516 to @xmath530 , the reheating temperature required for gravitino dark matter would be a function of @xmath8 only , @xmath531 , in accordance with the fact that the only parameters entering the gravitino production rate @xmath532 are the masses of the gravitino and the gluino .
the relation between the gravitino mass and the neutrino parameters @xmath54 and @xmath53 translates the lower bound on @xmath53 imposed by the requirement of successful leptogenesis , cf .
eq . , into a lower bound on @xmath8 .
as we can read off from fig .
[ fig : mgbounds ] , @xmath8 must be at least of @xmath533 to obtain consistency between leptogenesis and gravitino dark matter .
in fact , the bound on @xmath8 slightly varies with @xmath54 . for @xmath54 values between @xmath431 and @xmath534 it monotonically increases from roughly @xmath535 to @xmath536 , from @xmath537
onwards it remains at @xmath538 .
for such low gravitino masses the first term in the brackets on the right - hand side of eq .
is negligibly small , and @xmath315 . ] so that the fitting formula for @xmath53 can be easily solved for @xmath8 , @xmath539 imposing the condition that @xmath53 be larger than @xmath540 , cf .
eq . , provides us with an analytical expression for the lower bound on @xmath8 , @xmath541 this estimate reproduces our numerical results with a precision at the level of @xmath542 .
physically , the connection between the bounds on @xmath8 and @xmath53 is the following . for gravitino masses below @xmath543 ,
a reheating temperature @xmath544 is required to avoid overproduction of gravitinos . according to our reheating mechanism such low reheating temperatures
are associated with comparatively small values of the neutrino mass , @xmath545 .
the low temperature and low mass then entail a small abundance of ( s)neutrinos at the time the asymmetry is generated and a small @xmath9 parameter @xmath256 , cf .
eqs . and , respectively .
both effects combine and result in an insufficient lepton asymmetry , rendering dark matter made of gravitinos with a mass below @xmath543 inconsistent with leptogenesis . in conclusion , we find that our scenario of reheating can be easily realized in a large fraction of parameter space .
the two conditions of successful leptogenesis and gravitino dark matter , in combination with constraints from hybrid inflation , allow us to interconnect parameters of the neutrino and supergravity sector .
in particular , we are able to determine the neutrino mass @xmath53 and the reheating temperature @xmath315 as functions of the the effective neutrino mass @xmath54 and the gravitino mass @xmath8
. furthermore , the consistency between all ingredients of our scenario indicates preferences for @xmath53 and @xmath315 , namely @xmath53 values close to @xmath252 and @xmath315 values close to @xmath546 .
finally , we obtain a lower bound on the gravitino mass of roughly @xmath547 .
a phase of false vacuum of unbroken @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 symmetry at the gut scale can account for the observed acoustic peaks in the cosmic microwave background via hybrid inflation .
subsequent tachyonic preheating , followed by the decay of heavy gauge and higgs particles and heavy neutrinos sets the initial conditions of the hot early universe .
we have studied the @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 breaking phase transition for the full supersymmetric abelian higgs model and given a detailed time - resolved description of the reheating process taking all ( super)particles into account .
the competition of cosmic expansion and entropy production leads to an intermediate plateau of constant temperature , during which baryon asymmetry and gravitino dark matter are produced .
the initial conditions of the thermal phase of the universe are determined by the parameters of the fundamental lagrangian , i.e. the masses and couplings of elementary particles .
likewise , the constant plateau temperature is fixed by neutrino parameters
. the temperature scale of reheating is hence no longer an unknown cosmological parameter , but rather an effective quantity that is determined by mass parameters that can in principle be measured in experiments .
the consistency of hybrid inflation , leptogenesis and gravitino dark matter restricts the parameter space . for a gluino mass of @xmath548
we find a lower bound on the gravitino mass of about @xmath4 .
the order of magnitude of @xmath53 , the mass of the lightest of the heavy neutrinos , is @xmath549 . for a wide range of light neutrino masses
this results in a reheating temperature of order @xmath550 .
we point out that lowering the scale of @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 breaking would significantly weaken the bound on the gravitino mass .
if @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 breaking is unrelated to hybrid inflation and takes place at a scale @xmath551 , the gravitino could have a mass of @xmath552 @xcite .
similarly , for a lower @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 scale reheating would occur at a higher temperature because of faster higgs decays .
this would result in a stronger washout of the lepton asymmetry generated in ( s)neutrino decays .
small @xmath18 hence implies an upper bound on the effective neutrino mass @xmath54 of about @xmath553 @xcite . in this paper
we have demonstrated that , if @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 is broken at the gut scale , this restriction does no longer apply , rendering the proposed reheating mechanism viable for all reasonable masses of the light neutrinos .
tachyonic preheating is a complicated nonequilibrium process , which requires further theoretical investigations .
a remarkable result of this work is that the final baryon asymmetry and dark matter density are rather insensitive to many of the related theoretical uncertainties , such as the details of the production and relaxation of cosmic strings .
for instance , even if 50% of the false vacuum energy density is initially stored in strings , they quickly loose most of their energy and the effect on the final baryon asymmetry and dark matter abundance is negligible .
this robustness is due to the fact that after all most of the vacuum energy density is transferred to heavy higgs bosons whose slow decays , via heavy neutrinos , dominate the reheating process . throughout our analysis
we have assumed that the gravitino is the lightest superparticle .
however , the proposed mechanism for the ignition of the hot early universe also works if the gravitino is very heavy with a neutralino as lsp . in this case
ordinary wimp dark matter can be nonthermally produced from gravitino decays .
consistency of hybrid inflation , leptogenesis and dark matter density then leads to constraints on gravitino and neutralino masses . in ref .
@xcite we give a detailed description of this alternative scenario .
further important questions concern the effect of the inflaton on tachyonic preheating @xcite and possible modifications of superpotential and khler potential of the symmetry breaking sector in connection with the detailed description of the cosmic microwave background , which will be discussed elsewhere .
* acknowledgements * the authors thank g. vertongen for collaboration at the initial stage of this work and k. kamada and f. takahashi for helpful discussions and comments .
this work has been supported by the german science foundation ( dfg ) within the collaborative research center 676 `` particles , strings and the early universe '' .
in this section , we present the full supersymmetric lagrangian of the abelian higgs model in unitary gauge , following the notation of ref . @xcite . our starting point is an arbitrary superpotential @xmath554 , given in terms of chiral fields @xmath555 , whose scalar and fermionic components are denoted by @xmath556 and @xmath557 , and the canonical khler potential @xmath558 where @xmath559 is the gauge coupling and @xmath560 is the @xmath12 gauge charge of @xmath555 .
@xmath37 denotes the @xmath12 vector superfield , @xmath561 containing the scalar degree of freedom @xmath81 , the fermionic components @xmath562 and @xmath563 , the vector @xmath564 as well as the auxiliary fields @xmath565 , @xmath566 and @xmath85 . in the wess - zumino gauge , which we will not use , one has @xmath567 , @xmath568 and @xmath569 .
the supersymmetric lagrangian can be derived in the standard manner by calculating d- and f - terms of khler potential and superpotential and eliminating all auxiliary fields . in order to obtain fields with canonical mass dimension
we perform the rescalings @xmath570 where @xmath571 corresponds to one specific , conveniently chosen @xmath572 and @xmath573 is an arbitrary nonvanishing mass scale . in the following
, we will promote @xmath573 to a time - dependent function .
note , however , that our discussion also applies to the even more general case of a fully spacetime - dependent scalar field @xmath574 . after some calculations , including several integrations by part , one finds the lagrangian , @xmath575 with @xmath576\ , \nonumber\\ \mathcal{l}_{\textrm{wz}}^{\textrm{ferm } } = & \ : \sum_i \exp\left(\frac { p_i \sqrt{2}c}{pv}\right ) \frac{i p_i}{\sqrt{2}}\phi_i^ * \psi_i \xi -\frac{1}{2 } \sum_{i , j } w_{ij } \psi_i\psi_j + \textrm{h.c.}\ , \nonumber \\
v_f = & \ : \sum_i \exp\left(-\frac { p_i \sqrt{2}c}{pv}\right ) w_i^ * w_i\ , \nonumber\\ v_d = & \ : \frac{1}{8 } \sum_{ij } p_i p_j \exp\left(\frac { ( p_i + p_j ) \sqrt{2}c}{pv}\right ) \phi_i^*\phi_i \phi_j^ * \phi_j\ , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath577 \nonumber \\ - & \ : \sum_i \left\{w_i \left(\frac{p_i^2}{2(pv)^2}\phi_i\chi^2 + \frac{i p_i}{p v}\psi_i\chi\right ) + \textrm{h.c . } \right\ } \ , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath578 evaluating the exponential functions in @xmath579 to leading order in @xmath580 yields the familiar lagrangian in wess - zumino gauge ; the remaining terms , collected in @xmath581 , represent additional terms involving the gauge degrees of freedom @xmath81 and @xmath562 . the symmetry breaking sector defined in section [ sec_2 ] , cf .
eq . , contains the superfields @xmath14 , @xmath15 and @xmath16 with @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 charges @xmath582 and @xmath583 . in unitary gauge , cf .
, one has @xmath584 with @xmath585 , @xmath586 , and @xmath587 , one now obtains .
] @xmath588 \nonumber \\ - & \ : \cosh\left(\frac{\sqrt{2}c}{v}\right ) \frac{p_s^2}{4 } s^ * s a_\mu a^\mu \ , , \label{eq : lgauge}\\ \mathcal{l}_{\textrm{wz}}^{\textrm{ferm } } = & \:\sinh\left(\frac{\sqrt{2}c}{v}\right ) \frac{i p_s}{\sqrt{2}}s^ * \tilde s \xi + \frac{1}{2 } \sqrt{\lambda } \phi \tilde s \tilde s + \sqrt{\lambda } s \tilde
\phi \tilde s + \textrm{h.c.}\ , , \label{eq_lferm } \\
v_f = & \ : \frac{\lambda}{4 } |v^2_{b - l } - s^2|^2 + \cosh\left(\frac{\sqrt{2}c}{v}\right ) \lambda \phi^ * \phi \ , s^ * s \ , \\
v_d = & \ : \frac{1}{8 } p_s^2 \sinh^2\left(\frac{\sqrt{2}c}{v}\right ) ( s^ * s)^2 \ , \label{eq_vd } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath589 \nonumber \\ + & \ : \cosh\left(\frac{\sqrt{2}c}{v}\right ) \bigg[- \frac{i } { v } s^*\bar{\chi}\bar{\sigma}^\mu\partial_\mu \frac{s \ , \chi}{v } + \frac { p_s } { \sqrt{2 } v } s^ * s \left(\chi\xi + \bar{\chi}\bar{\xi}\right ) \label{eq_nonwz}\\ + & \ : \left\{\frac{1}{\sqrt{2 } v }
s^*\bar{\chi}\bar{\sigma}^\mu \tilde s \partial_\mu \frac{c}{v } + \frac{i p_s}{2v } s^ * \bar{\chi}\bar{\sigma}^\mu \tilde s a_\mu + \textrm{h.c . } \right\ } \bigg ] + \ : \left\{\sqrt{\lambda } \phi s \frac{1}{2 v^2 } s \chi^2 + \textrm{h.c . }
\right\ } \nonumber \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the ground state of the theory corresponds to @xmath590 . identifying the mass scale @xmath573 with the time - dependent vacuum expectation value of the higgs field in the broken phase , @xmath591 , which approaches @xmath18 at large times , the lagrangian @xmath581 yields kinetic terms for @xmath81 and @xmath562 and a mass term for @xmath562 and @xmath563 .
the mass terms for @xmath564 and @xmath81 are contained in eqs . and , respectively .
as expected , in unitary gauge the vector field @xmath37 describes a massive vector multiplet @xcite .
shifting @xmath592 around its expectation value , @xmath593 , one reads off the masses given in eq . .
note that due to the time - dependence of @xmath573 , the kinetic term for @xmath81 in eq .
yields a contribution to the mass @xmath594 . in the main part of this paper , we omit this term for two reasons .
first , it is much smaller than the contribution to @xmath594 obtained from eq . throughout the preheating process and
hence the latter governs the production during tachyonic preheating .
second , as we show in section [ sec : robust ] , our final results prove insensitive to the dynamics of the gauge sector and we can hence ignore this technically rather complicated contribution .
to calculate the lepton asymmetry consistently to first order in the @xmath9 violation parameter @xmath595 , @xmath208 scattering processes involving an ( anti-)(s)lepton in the initial and final state must be considered .
scatterings with an on - shell neutrino in the intermediate state are already included in decay and inverse decay processes .
we are hence left with the task to calculate the off - shell contribution of these processes . for the nonsupersymmetric case , this
was discussed in refs .
@xcite and @xcite . here
we explain the supersymmetric case .
we first study the @xmath9-violating contribution of the full @xmath208 scattering processes and will see that this vanishes to @xmath596 . hence to this order in the yukawa coupling , the @xmath9-violating off - shell contributions can be added by subtracting the corresponding on - shell contributions .
the right - hand side of the integrated boltzmann equation is given by the interaction density @xmath597 , cf .
eqs and . for distinct final and initial states ,
this is related to the corresponding @xmath598-matrix elements @xmath599 where the summation over the lower case letters on the left - hand side runs over different particle species and the summation over capital letters on the right - hand side additionally includes the summation over all internal degrees of freedom as well as phase space integrals for all initial and final state particles . considering the case of @xmath208 scatterings in the boltzmann equation for the lepton asymmetry , the initial and final states of interest are @xmath600 .
the internal degrees of freedom are helicity , weak isospin and flavour .
@xmath601 denotes the phase space distribution function of particle species @xmath602 . using this notation
, we now consider the @xmath9-violating contributions of the full @xmath208 scattering processes , @xmath603 & = \sum_{i , f } \left[|s_{\bar{f}i}|^2 f_i - |s_{f \bar{i } } |^2 f_{\bar i } \right]\\ & = \sum_{i , f } \left[|s_{\bar f i}|^2 + |s _ { f i}|^2 - |s_{f \bar{i } } |^2 - |s _ { \bar f \bar i}|^2 \right ] f_i \\ & = \sum_i \left[1 - 1\right ] f_i + { \cal o}((h^{\nu})^4 ) = { \cal o}((h^{\nu})^4 ) \ , .
\end{split}\ ] ] the bar indicates @xmath9 conjugation and @xmath604 are the phase space distributions of the light mssm ( anti-)particles in thermal equilibrium . here in the second line of eq .
, we extended the summation over the final states to include the lepton number conserving processes .
these can be grouped in pairs of @xmath209 conjugates and hence , due to @xmath209 invariance , yield a vanishing contribution in total . in the third line , we exploit the unitarity of the @xmath598 matrix , i.e. that the summation over all possible final states yields 1 .
since however in eq .
the sum runs only over all possible two - particle final states , we obtain corrections caused by neglecting multi - particle final states . for
off - shell intermediate states these corrections are of @xmath605 @xcite , however close to the resonance pole they are enhanced to @xmath606 @xcite . concluding , we find that the @xmath9-violating contributions of the @xmath208 scattering processes involved in the production of the lepton asymmetry vanish , with corrections of @xmath596 . hence the on- and off - shell contributions cancel each other and we can use the usual ` recipe ' of replacing the @xmath9-violating contributions of the off - shell ( s)neutrino decays by the negative of the respective on - shell contributions , i.e.@xmath607 where @xmath457 is a flavour index .
note that looking at this line of argument closely , this argument holds separately for neutrinos and sneutrinos because of distinct sets of initial and final states , but the summation over flavour and lepton / slepton is unavoidable .
apart from the definition of the reheating temperature employed in this work , cf .
, there are alternative ways to define the reheating temperature . for instance
, we could use the temperature at the beginning ( @xmath305 ) or the end of reheating ( @xmath306 ) or the temperature when half of the total available energy has been transferred to radiation ( @xmath309 for the parameter example discussed in section [ sec : example ] ) . in either case , although the respective value for @xmath265 may significantly vary , thanks to the temperature plateau during reheating the resulting reheating temperature would not change much . for the parameter point investigated in section [ sec
: example ] , we find @xmath608 our definition of the reheating temperature may hence be regarded as a compromise between several more extreme approaches .
but more important than that , it picks up on a physical feature that other definitions would miss . in fig .
[ fig : tempasymm ] we observe that the temperature declines less during the first part of reheating , @xmath609 , than during the second part , @xmath610 .
the stage of @xmath6 reheating evidently splits up into two phases , during the first of which the temperature is basically constant , whereas during the second one the temperature slightly decreases .
the reason for this substructure in the temperature plateau is the following .
as soon as the @xmath288 neutrinos decay more efficiently their comoving number density starts to grow slower than @xmath611 .
this diminishes the production rate of radiation . according to eq .
, a constant temperature can then no longer be maintained .
the advantage of our definition for @xmath315 now is that we read it off the curve in fig .
[ fig : tempasymm ] at exactly that value of the scale factor at which the transition between these two phases of @xmath6 reheating takes place .
our definition thus yields a temperature that is both representative as it mediates between several more extreme values and especially singled out as it is associated with a prominent feature in the temperature curve . for completeness , we should however mention that for other parameter choices this picture may change
. if the higgs decay rate @xmath299 is , for instance , larger than the neutrino decay rate @xmath317 , which can for example be achieved by going to lower values of the @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 scale , the scaling behaviour of the @xmath288 number density changes when the neutrino production efficiency begins to cease and not when the decays of the neutrinos themselves set in .
the slight kink in the temperature plateau is then located at @xmath309 which is in this case before the decay of the @xmath288 has become fully efficient .
but the definition of the reheating temperature in eq . remains reasonable nonetheless .
after all , if @xmath612 , the bulk of the total energy is first almost entirely accumulated in @xmath288 neutrinos before it is passed on to radiation .
the energy in radiation thus receives its major contribution just when these neutrinos decay with a sufficient efficiency .
the characteristic temperature at the time when this happens is then again obtained from eq . .
further details on the reheating temperature in regions in parameter space in which @xmath612 can be found in ref .
@xcite .
s. raby , eur .
j. c * 59 * , 223 ( 2009 ) , arxiv:0807.4921 [ hep - ph ] .
m. fukugita and t. yanagida , phys .
b * 174 * , 45 ( 1986 ) .
h. pagels and j. r. primack , phys .
lett . * 48 * , 223 ( 1982 ) .
h. goldberg , phys .
* 50 * , 1419 ( 1983 ) [ erratum - ibid .
* 103 * , 099905 ( 2009 ) ] .
j. r. ellis , j. s. hagelin , d. v. nanopoulos , k. a. olive and m. srednicki , nucl .
b * 238 * , 453 ( 1984 ) .
e. j. copeland , a. r. liddle , d. h. lyth , e. d. stewart and d. wands , phys .
d * 49 * , 6410 ( 1994 ) , [ astro - ph/9401011 ] . g. r. dvali , q. shafi and r. k. schaefer , phys .
* 73 * , 1886 ( 1994 ) , [ hep - ph/9406319 ] .
w. buchmuller , k. schmitz and g. vertongen , phys .
b * 693 * , 421 ( 2010 ) , arxiv:1008.2355 [ hep - ph ] .
w. buchmuller , k. schmitz and g. vertongen , nucl .
b * 851 * , 481 ( 2011 ) , arxiv:1104.2750 [ hep - ph ]
. g. n. felder , j. garcia - bellido , p. b. greene , l. kofman , a. d. linde and i. tkachev , phys . rev .
lett . * 87 * , 011601 ( 2001 ) , [ hep - ph/0012142 ] . m. plumacher , nucl .
b * 530 * , 207 ( 1998 ) , [ hep - ph/9704231 ] .
w. buchmuller , p. di bari and m. plumacher , annals phys .
* 315 * , 305 ( 2005 ) , [ hep - ph/0401240 ] .
g. lazarides and q. shafi , phys .
b * 258 * , 305 ( 1991 ) .
t. asaka , k. hamaguchi , m. kawasaki and t. yanagida , phys .
b * 464 * , 12 ( 1999 ) , [ hep - ph/9906366 ] .
t. asaka , k. hamaguchi , m. kawasaki and t. yanagida , phys .
d * 61 * , 083512 ( 2000 ) , [ hep - ph/9907559 ] . f. hahn - woernle and m. plumacher , nucl .
b * 806 * , 68 ( 2009 ) , arxiv:0801.3972 [ hep - ph ] .
h. murayama , h. suzuki , t. yanagida and j. yokoyama , phys .
lett . * 70 * , 1912 ( 1993 ) .
j. r. ellis , m. raidal and t. yanagida , phys .
b * 581 * , 9 ( 2004 ) , [ hep - ph/0303242 ] .
s. antusch , m. bastero - gil , s. f. king and q. shafi , phys .
d * 71 * , 083519 ( 2005 ) , [ hep - ph/0411298 ] . s. antusch , j. p. baumann , v. f. domcke and p. m. kostka , jcap * 1010 * , 006 ( 2010 ) , arxiv:1007.0708 [ hep - ph ] .
s. weinberg , phys .
lett . * 48 * , 1303 ( 1982 ) .
j. r. ellis , d. v. nanopoulos and s. sarkar , nucl .
b * 259 * , 175 ( 1985 ) .
m. kawasaki , k. kohri and t. moroi , phys .
b * 625 * , 7 ( 2005 ) , [ astro - ph/0402490 ] .
m. kawasaki , k. kohri and t. moroi , phys .
d * 71 * , 083502 ( 2005 ) , [ astro - ph/0408426 ] .
k. jedamzik , phys .
d * 74 * , 103509 ( 2006 ) , [ hep - ph/0604251 ] . m. bolz , w. buchmuller and m. plumacher , phys .
b * 443 * , 209 ( 1998 ) , [ hep - ph/9809381 ] . c. d. froggatt and h. b. nielsen , nucl .
b * 147 * , 277 ( 1979 ) .
w. buchmuller and t. yanagida , phys .
b * 445 * , 399 ( 1999 ) , [ hep - ph/9810308 ] . w. buchmuller , v. domcke and k. schmitz , jhep * 1203 * , 008 ( 2012 ) , arxiv:1111.3872 [ hep - ph ] .
m. fujii , k. hamaguchi and t. yanagida , phys .
d * 65 * , 115012 ( 2002 ) , [ hep - ph/0202210 ] . m. hindmarsh , prog . theor . phys
. suppl .
* 190 * , 197 ( 2011 ) , arxiv:1106.0391 [ astro-ph.co ] . e. j. copeland , s. pascoli and a. rajantie , phys .
d * 65 * , 103517 ( 2002 ) , [ hep - ph/0202031 ] .
w. buchmuller , l. covi and d. delepine , phys .
b * 491 * , 183 ( 2000 ) , [ hep - ph/0006168 ] .
r. a. battye , b. garbrecht and a. moss , jcap * 0609 * , 007 ( 2006 ) , [ astro - ph/0607339 ] . k. nakayama , f. takahashi and t. t. yanagida , jcap * 1012 * , 010 ( 2010 ) , arxiv:1007.5152 [ hep - ph ] .
m. hindmarsh , s. stuckey and n. bevis , phys .
d * 79 * , 123504 ( 2009 ) , arxiv:0812.1929 [ hep - th ]
. j. f. dufaux , d. g. figueroa and j. garcia - bellido , phys .
d * 82 * , 083518 ( 2010 ) , arxiv:1006.0217 [ astro-ph.co ] .
r. battye and a. moss , phys .
d * 82 * , 023521 ( 2010 ) , arxiv:1005.0479 [ astro-ph.co ] .
j. dunkley , r. hlozek , j. sievers , v. acquaviva , p. a. r. ade , p. aguirre , m. amiri and j. w. appel _ et al .
_ , astrophys . j. * 739 * , 52 ( 2011 ) , arxiv:1009.0866 [ astro-ph.co ] .
j. urrestilla , n. bevis , m. hindmarsh and m. kunz , jcap * 1112 * , 021 ( 2011 ) , arxiv:1108.2730 [ astro-ph.co ] . c. dvorkin , m. wyman and w. hu , phys
. rev .
d * 84 * , 123519 ( 2011 ) , arxiv:1109.4947 [ astro-ph.co ] .
r. battye , b. garbrecht and a. moss , phys .
d * 81 * , 123512 ( 2010 ) , arxiv:1001.0769 [ astro-ph.co ] .
r. jeannerot and m. postma , jhep * 0505 * , 071 ( 2005 ) , [ hep - ph/0503146 ] .
e. komatsu _ et al . _
[ wmap collaboration ] , astrophys .
j. suppl .
* 192 * , 18 ( 2011 ) , arxiv:1001.4538 [ astro-ph.co ] .
j. garcia - bellido and e. ruiz morales , phys .
b * 536 * , 193 ( 2002 ) , [ hep - ph/0109230 ] .
j. berges , d. gelfand and j. pruschke , phys .
lett . * 107 * , 061301 ( 2011 ) , arxiv:1012.4632 [ hep - ph ] . f. hahn - woernle , m. plumacher and y. y. y. wong , jcap * 0908 * , 028 ( 2009 ) , arxiv:0907.0205 [ hep - ph ] .
l. covi , e. roulet and f. vissani , phys .
b * 384 * , 169 ( 1996 ) , [ hep - ph/9605319 ] w. buchmuller and m. plumacher , phys .
b * 431 * , 354 ( 1998 ) , [ hep - ph/9710460 ] .
m. bolz , a. brandenburg and w. buchmuller , nucl .
b * 606 * , 518 ( 2001 ) [ erratum - ibid .
b * 790 * , 336 ( 2008 ) ] , [ hep - ph/0012052 ] .
g. aad _ et al .
_ [ atlas collaboration ] , phys .
d * 85 * , 012006 ( 2012 ) , arxiv:1109.6606 [ hep - ex ] .
s. chatrchyan _ et al . _
[ cms collaboration ] , phys .
lett . * 107 * , 221804 ( 2011 ) , arxiv:1109.2352 [ hep - ex ] .
w. buchmuller , v. domcke and k. schmitz , arxiv:1203.0285 [ hep - ph ] .
j. martin and v. vennin , arxiv:1110.2070 [ astro-ph.co ] . w. buchmuller , v. domcke , k. schmitz and f. takahashi , in preparation . | the decay of a false vacuum of unbroken @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 symmetry is an intriguing and testable mechanism to generate the initial conditions of the hot early universe .
if @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 is broken at the grand unification scale , the false vacuum phase yields hybrid inflation , ending in tachyonic preheating .
the dynamics of the @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 breaking higgs field and thermal processes produce an abundance of heavy neutrinos whose decays generate entropy , baryon asymmetry and gravitino dark matter .
we study the phase transition for the full supersymmetric abelian higgs model .
for the subsequent reheating process we give a detailed time - resolved description of all particle abundances .
the competition of cosmic expansion and entropy production leads to an intermediate period of constant ` reheating ' temperature , during which baryon asymmetry and dark matter are produced .
consistency of hybrid inflation , leptogenesis and gravitino dark matter implies relations between neutrino parameters and superparticle masses . in particular , for a gluino mass of @xmath3 , we find a lower bound on the gravitino mass of @xmath4 .
desy 11 - 174 + march 2012 * spontaneous @xmath0@xmath1@xmath2 breaking as + the origin of the hot early universe * w. buchmller , v. domcke , k. schmitz + _ deutsches elektronen - synchrotron desy , 22607 hamburg , germany _ . |
because many natural systems are organized as networks , in which the nodes ( be they cells , individuals , populations or web servers ) interact in a time - dependent fashion the study of networks has been an important focus in recent research .
one of the particular points of interest has been the question of how the hardwired _ structure _ of a network ( its underlying graph ) affects its _ function _ , for example in the context of optimal information storage or transmission between nodes along time .
it has been hypothesized that there are two key conditions for optimal function in such networks : a well - balanced adjacency matrix ( the underlying graph should appropriately combine robust features and random edges ) and well - balanced connection strengths , driving optimal dynamics in the system .
however , only recently has mathematics started to study rigorously ( through a combined graph theoretical and dynamic approach ) the effects of configuration patterns on the efficiency of network function , by applying graph theoretical measures of segregation ( clustering coefficient , motifs , modularity , rich clubs ) , integration ( path length , efficiency ) and influence ( node degree , centrality ) .
various studies have been investigating the sensitivity of a system s temporal behavior to removing / adding nodes or edges at different places in the network structure , and have tried to relate these patterns to applications to natural networks .
brain functioning is one of the most intensely studied contexts which requires our understanding of the tight inter - connections between system architecture and dynamics .
the brain is organized as a `` dynamic network , '' self - interacting in a time - dependent fashion at multiple spacial and temporal scales , to deliver an optimal range for biological functioning .
the way in which these modules are wired together in large networks that control complex cognition and behavior is one of the great scientific challenges of the 21st century , currently being addressed by large - scale research collaborations , such as the human connectome project .
graph theoretical studies of empirical empirical data support certain generic topological properties of brain architecture , such as modularity , small - worldness , the existence of hubs and `` rich clubs '' @xcite . in order to explain how connectivity patterns may affect the system s dynamics ( e.g. , in the context of stability and synchronization in networks of coupled neural populations ) , and thus the observed behavior ,
a lot of effort has been thus invested towards formal modeling approaches , using a combination of analytical and numerical methods from nonlinear dynamics and graph theory , in both biophysical models @xcite and simplified systems @xcite .
these analyses revealed a rich range of potential dynamic regimes and transitions @xcite , shown to depend as much on the coupling parameters of the network as on the arrangement of the excitatory and inhibitory connections @xcite .
the construction of a realistic , data - compatible computational model has been subsequently found to present many difficulties that transcend the existing methods from nonlinear dynamics , and may in fact require : ( 1 ) new analysis and book - keeping methods and ( 2 ) a new framework that would naturally encompass the rich phenomena intrinsic to these systems both of which aspects are central to our proposed work . in a paper with dr .
verduzco - flores @xcite , one of the authors of this paper first explored the idea of having network connectivity as a bifurcation parameter for the ensemble dynamics in a continuous time system of coupled differential equations .
we used configuration dependent phase spaces and our probabilistic extension of bifurcation diagrams in the parameter space to investigate the relationship between classes of system architectures and classes of their possible dynamics , and we observed the robustness of the coupled dynamics to certain changes in the network architecture and its vulnerability to others . as expected , when translating connectivity patterns to network dynamics , the main difficulties were raised by the combination of graph complexity and the system s intractable dynamic richness .
in order to break down and better understand this dependence , we started to investigate it in simpler theoretical models , where one may more easily identify and pair specific structural patterns to their effects on dynamics .
the logistic family is historically perhaps the most - studied family of maps in nonlinear dynamics , whose behavior is by now relatively well understood .
therefore , we started by looking in particular at how dynamic behavior depends on connectivity in networks with simple logistic nodes .
this paper focuses on definitions , concepts and observations in low - dimensional networks .
future work will address large networks , and different classes of maps .
dynamic networks with discrete nodes and the dependence of their behavior on connectivity parameters have been previously described in several contexts over the past two decades .
for example , in an early paper , wang considered a simple neural network of only two excitatory / inhibitory neurons , and analyzed it as a parameterized family of two - dimensional maps , proving existence of period - doubling to chaos and strange attractors in the network @xcite .
masolle , attay et al . have found that , in networks of delay - coupled logistic maps , synchronization regimes and formation of anti - phase clusters depend on coupling strength @xcite and on the edge topology ( characterized by the spectrum of the graph laplacian ) @xcite .
yu has constructed and studied a network wherein the undirected edges symbolize the nodes relation of adjacency in an integer sequence obtained from the logistic mapping and the top integral function @xcite . in our present work ,
we focus on investigating , in the context of networked maps , extensions of the julia and mandelbrot sets traditionally defined for single map iterations . for three different model networks ,
we use a combination of analytical and numerical tools to illustrate how the system behavior ( measured via topological properties of the _ julia sets _ ) changes when perturbing the underlying adjacency graph .
we differentiate between the effects on dynamics of different perturbations that directly modulate network connectivity : increasing / decreasing edge weights , and altering edge configuration by adding , deleting or moving edges .
we discuss the implications of considering a rigorous extension of fatou - julia theory known to apply for iterations of single maps , to iterations of ensembles of maps coupled as nodes in a network .
the logistic map is historically perhaps the best - known family of maps in nonlinear dynamics .
iterations of one single quadratic function have been studied starting in the early 19th century , with the work of fatou and julia .
the prisoner set of a map @xmath3 is defined as the set of all points in the complex dynamic plane , whose orbits are bounded .
the escape set of a complex map is the set of all points whose orbits are unbounded .
the julia set of @xmath3 is defined as their common boundary @xmath4 .
the filled julia set is the union of prisoner points with their boundary @xmath4 . for polynomial maps
, it has been shown that the connectivity of a map s julia set is tightly related to the structure of its critical orbits ( i.e. , the orbits of the map s critical points ) .
due to extensive work spanning almost one century , from julia @xcite and fatou @xcite until recent developments @xcite , we now have the following : + * fatou - julia theorem . * _ for a polynomial with at least one critical orbit unbounded , the julia set is totally disconnected if and only if all the bounded critical orbits are aperiodic . _
+ for a single iterated logistic map@xcite , the fatou - julia theorem implies that the julia set is either totally connected , for values of @xmath5 in the mandelbrot set ( i.e. , if the orbit of the critical point 0 is bounded ) , or totally disconnected , for values of @xmath5 outside of the mandelbrot set ( i.e. , if the orbit of the critical point 0 is unbounded ) . in previous work
, the authors showed that this dichotomy breaks in the case of random iterations of two maps @xcite . in our current work ,
we focus on extensions for networked logistic maps .
although julia and mandelbrot sets have been studied somewhat in connection with coupled systems @xcite , none of the existing work seems to address the basic problems of how these sets can be defined for networks of maps , how different aspects of the network hardwiring affect the topology of these sets and whether there is any fatou - julia type result in this context .
these are some of the questions addressed in this paper , which is organized as follows : in section [ logistic_maps ] , we introduce definitions of our network setup , as well as of the extensions of mandelbrot and julia sets that we will be studying . in order to illustrate some basic ideas and concepts , we concentrate on three examples of 3-dimensional networks , which differ from each other in edge distribution , and whose connectivity strengths are allow to vary .
in section [ complex_maps ] , we focus on the behavior of these 3-dimensional models when we consider the nodes as complex iterated variables .
we analyze the similarities and differences between node - wise behavior in each case , and we investigate the topological perturbations in one - dimensional complex slices of the mandelbrot and julia sets , as the connectivity changes from one model to the next , through intermediate stages . in section [ real_maps ] , we address the same questions for real logistic nodes , with the advantage of being able to visualize the entire network mandelbrot and julia sets , as 3-dimensional real objects . in both sections ,
we conjecture weaker versions of the fatou - julia theorem , connecting points in the mandelbrot set with connectivity properties of the corresponding julia sets .
finally , in section [ discussion ] , we interpret our results both mathematically and in the larger context of network sciences .
we also briefly preview future work on high - dimensional networks and on networks with adaptable nodes and edges .
we consider a set of @xmath6 nodes coupled according to the edges of an oriented graph , with adjacency matrix @xmath7 ( on which one may impose additional structural conditions , related to edge density or distribution ) . in isolation , each node @xmath8 , @xmath9 , functions as a discrete nonlinear map @xmath10 , changing at each iteration @xmath11 as @xmath12 . when coupled as a network with adjacency @xmath13 , each node will also receive contributions through the incoming edges from the adjacent nodes . throughout this paper , we will consider an additive rule of combining these contributions , for a couple of reasons : first , summing weighted incoming inputs is one simple , yet mathematically nontrivial way to introduce the cross talk between nodes ; second , summing weighted inputs inside a nonlinear integrating function is reminiscent of certain mechanisms studied in the natural sciences ( such as the integrate and fire neural mechanism studied in our previous work in the context of coupled dynamics ) . the coupled system will then have the following general form : @xmath14 where @xmath15 are the weights along the adjacency edges .
one may view this system simply as an iteration of an @xmath6-dimensional map @xmath16 , with @xmath17 ( in the case of real - valued nodes ) , or respectively @xmath18 ( in the case of complex - valued nodes ) .
the new and exciting aspect that we are proposing in our work is to study the dependence of the coupled dynamics on the parameters , in particular on the coupling scheme ( adjacency matrix ) viewed itself as a system parameter . to fix these ideas , we focused first on defining these questions and proposing hypotheses for the case of quadratic node - dynamics .
the logistic family is one of the most studied family of maps in the context of both real and complex dynamics of a single variable .
it was also the subject of our previous modeling work on random iterations . in this paper in particular
, we will work with quadratic node - maps , with their traditional parametrization @xmath19 , with @xmath20 and @xmath21 for the complex case and @xmath22 and @xmath23 for the real case .
the network variable will be called respectively @xmath24 in the case of complex nodes , and @xmath25 in the case of real nodes .
we consider both the particular case of identical quadratic maps ( equal @xmath5 values ) , and the general case of different maps attached to the nodes throughout the network . in both cases
, we aim to study the asymptotic behavior of iterated node - wise orbits , as well as of the @xmath6-dimensional orbits ( which we will call multi - orbits ) . as in the classical theory of fatou and julia
, we will investigate when orbits escape to infinity or remain bounded , and how much of this information is encoded in the critical multi - orbit of the system .
for the following definitions , fix the network ( i.e. , fix the adjacency @xmath13 and the edge weights @xmath26 ) . to avoid redundancy , we give definitions for the complex case , but they can be formulated similarly for real maps : for a fixed parameter @xmath27 , we call the * filled multi - julia set * of the network , the locus of @xmath28 which produce a bounded multi - orbit in @xmath29
. we call the * filled uni - julia set * the locus of @xmath30 so that @xmath31 produces a bounded multi - orbit .
the * multi - julia set ( or the multi - j set ) * of the network is defined as the boundary in @xmath29 of the filled multi - julia set .
similarly , one defines the * uni - julia set ( or uni - j set ) * of the network as the boundary in @xmath32 of its filled counterparts .
we define the * multi - mandelbrot set ( or the multi - m set ) * of the network the parameter locus of @xmath27 for which the multi - orbit of the critical point @xmath33 is bounded in @xmath29 .
we call the * equi - mandelbrot set ( or the equi - m set ) * of the network , the locus of @xmath21 for which the critical multi - orbit is bounded for * equi - parameter * @xmath34 .
we call the * @xmath35th node equi - m set * the locus @xmath21 such that the component of the multi - orbit of @xmath33 corresponding to the @xmath35th node remains bounded in @xmath32 .
we study , using a combination of analytical and numerical methods , how the structure of the julia and mandelbrot sets varies under perturbations of the node - wise dynamics ( i.e. , under changes of the quadratic multi- parameter @xmath36 ) and under perturbations of the coupling scheme ( i.e. , of the adjacency matrix @xmath13 and of the coupling weights @xmath26 ) . in this paper
, we start with investigating these questions in small ( 3-dimensional ) networks , with specific adjacency configurations . in a subsequent paper , we will move to investigate how similar phenomena may be quantified and studied analytically and numerically in high - dimensional networks . in both cases
, we are interested in particular in observing differences in the effects on dynamics of three different aspects of the network architecture : ( 1 ) increasing / decreasing edge weights , ( 2 ) increasing / decreasing edge density , ( 3 ) altering edge configuration by adding , deleting or moving edges . while a desired objective would be to obtain general results for all network sizes ( since many natural networks are large ) , we start by studying simple , low dimensional systems . in this study
, we focus on simple networks formed of three nodes , connected by different network geometries and edge weights . to fix our ideas
, we will follow and illustrate three structures in particular ( also see figure [ 3d_net ] ) : ( 1 ) two input nodes @xmath37 and @xmath38 are self driven by quadratic maps , and the single output node @xmath39 is driven symmetrically by the two input nodes ; @xmath37 additionally communicates with @xmath38 via an edge of variable weight @xmath40 , which can take both positive and negative values .
we will call this the * _ simple dual model_*. ( 2 ) in addition to the simple dual scheme , the output node @xmath39 is also self - driven , i.e. there is a self - loop on @xmath39 of weight @xmath41 ( which can be positive or negative ) .
we will call this the * _ self - drive model_*. ( 3 ) in addition to the self - driven model , there is also feedback from the output node @xmath39 into the node @xmath38 , via a new edge of variable weight @xmath3 .
we will call this the * _ feedback model_*. unless specified , edges have positive unit weight . notice that the same effect as negative feed - forward edges from @xmath37 and @xmath38 into @xmath39 can be obtained by changing the sign of @xmath41 , etc .
the three connectivity models we chose to study and compare are described by the equations below : + * _ simple dual model : _ * @xmath42 * _ self - drive model : _ * @xmath43 * _ feedback model : _ * @xmath44 for a fixed multi - parameter @xmath45 for example , one can see all three systems as generated by a network map @xmath46 , @xmath47 , @xmath48 , defined as @xmath49_1),f_{c_2}([az]_2),f_{c_3}([az]_3))$ ] , for any @xmath50 .
we try to classify and understand the effects that coupling changes have on the topology of multi - j and multi - m sets for both complex and real networked maps .
we do nt expect all classical topology results on the julia and mandelbrot sets for single maps ( e.g. , fatou - julia theorem , or connectivity of the mandelbrot set ) to carry out for networks of coupled maps .
however , since the topology of the full sets in @xmath51 is somewhat harder to inspect , we study as a first step their equi - slices and node - wise equi - slices , which are objects in @xmath32 .
we will track and compare in particular the differences between the three models , but also the geometric and topological changes produced on the equi - slices within each one model for different values of the parameters @xmath40 , @xmath41 and @xmath3 .
none of these results , however , can be directly extrapolated to similar conclusions on the full sets . to offer some insight into the latter , we study the multi - m and multi - j sets in the context of real maps , for which there objects can be visualized in @xmath52 .
a first intuitive question is when the nodes of the network have similar behavior , and whether if one node - wise orbit is bounded , the others will remain bounded .
this relationship is trivial to establish in some cases , such as for example in the simple dual model with independent input nodes ( i.e. , @xmath53 ) . indeed , in this model , for any fixed @xmath21 , the origin s orbit in @xmath51 under @xmath54 can be described as : @xmath55 the projection of the orbit in any of the three components only depends on the previous states of @xmath37 and @xmath38 , and these three sequences are simultaneously bounded in @xmath32 , hence the node - specific equi - mandelbrot sets are all identical with the traditional mandelbrot set .
some basic connections between node - wise equi - m sets in each of the three models are stated below .
we will prove these incrementally ( recall that the dual model is a particular case of self - drive for @xmath56 , and the self - drive is a particular case of feedback model with @xmath57 ) . , the equi - mandelbrot set for the nodes @xmath38 and @xmath39 are identical ( red ) , but different from the set for the node @xmath37 ( blue ) * b. * for the self - drive model with negative feedback , @xmath58 and @xmath59 , the equi - mandelbrot sets for the three nodes @xmath37 , @xmath38 and @xmath39 ( shown respectively in blue , green and red ) are all different . * c. * for the feedback model with with negative feedback , @xmath58 and @xmath59 , @xmath60 , the equi - mandelbrot set for the nodes @xmath38 and @xmath39 are identical ( red ) , but different from the set for the node @xmath37 ( blue ) . in all panels ,
the computations were generated based on @xmath61 iterations , and for a test radius of @xmath62 . _ _ ] in the simple dual model , the node - wise equi - m sets for the nodes @xmath38 and @xmath39 are identical subsets of the traditional mandelbrot set ( which is the equi - m set for node @xmath37 ) .
[ prop_simple_dual ] an additional self - drive @xmath63 applied to the output node changes the balance of inputs to @xmath39 , in the following sense : in the self - drive model , the node - wise equi - m sets of @xmath38 and @xmath39 remain subsets of the standard mandelbrot set , but the equi - m set of @xmath39 is strictly contained in the equi - m set of @xmath38 ( figure [ node_differences]b ) .
[ prop_self_drive ] finally , introducing any arbitrary feedback @xmath64 re - couples the behavior of nodes @xmath38 and @xmath39 , producing a common equi - mandelbrod set , largely shrunk from the simple dual version : in the feedback model with @xmath63 and @xmath64 , the node - wise equi - m sets for the nodes @xmath38 and @xmath39 are again identical subsets of the traditional mandelbrot set ( figure [ node_differences]c ) .
[ prop_feedback ] for the rest of the section , the term of `` equi - m set '' will be referring to the equi - mandelbrot set of the network , which is the intersection of the three node - specific sets .
we illustrate the equi - m set for the three models and for different levels of cross - talk @xmath40 , @xmath41 and @xmath3 between nodes . starting with the simple dual input version of the model
, we show in figure [ dual_input ] the effects of changing the level @xmath40 of talk between the input nodes , on the shape of the equi - m set .
it is not surprising that , in both positive and negative @xmath40 ranges , increasing @xmath65 gradually shrinks the equi - mandelbrot set .
this can be motivated intuitively by the fact that an additional contribution to the node @xmath38 may cause the critical orbit to increase faster in the @xmath38 , and subsequently the @xmath39 components , hence points in the traditional set will no longer be included in the mutants for @xmath66 . as @xmath40 increases in the positive range , we noticed that the network m sets form nested subsets ( which is not true for the negative range ) , that they remain connected for all values of @xmath40 , and that the hausdorff dimension of the boundary increases with @xmath40 ( in figure [ dual_input ] , notice an increased wrinkling of the boundary as @xmath40 takes larger positive values , and an increase smoothing as @xmath40 takes negative values with increasing absolute value ) .
perturbations of @xmath40 in the positive range seem to have a much more substantial contribution to the size of the equi - m set , while perturbations of @xmath40 in the negative range have a lesser influence on the size , and affect mostly the region close tot the boundary of the equi - m set , and the boundary topological details .
we will track the same changes in @xmath40 in the other network models , and investigate if this trend is consistent .
increases : * a. * @xmath58 ; * b. * @xmath67 ; * c. * @xmath53 ( traditional mandelbrot set ) ; * d. * @xmath68 ; * e. * @xmath69 . _ _ ] figure [ equimand_selfdrive ] illustrates the evolution of the equi - m set in the case of the model with self - drive , for a grid of positive and negative values of the input connectivity @xmath40 and of the self - drive @xmath41 . below are some simple visual observations based on our numerical computations , to be addressed analytically in future work .
decreasing @xmath41 in the negative range produces no alteration of the m sets when @xmath70 .
however , it induces dramatic changes in shape and connectivity when @xmath71 .
if for @xmath72 relatively large , increasing @xmath40 only slightly alters the shape of the set , for small @xmath72 the size of the set is also altered with increasing @xmath40 ( generating smaller and smaller subsets ) , and the complexity of its boundary also seems to increase .
the effects of varying @xmath71 for a fixed value of @xmath41 become more dramatic with decreasing @xmath41 in the negative range .
these effects include changes in shape and topology , the region @xmath71 and @xmath73 allowing the m - set to break into multiple connected components . and @xmath41 . *
the rows show , from bottom to top , increasing values of the self - drive : @xmath74 , @xmath75 ; @xmath76 ; @xmath56 ( this row representing the simple dual model , as shown in figure [ dual_input ] ) ; @xmath59 ; @xmath77 ; @xmath78 .
the columns show , from left to right , increasing values of cross - talk between the two input nodes : @xmath58 , @xmath67 , @xmath53 , @xmath68 and @xmath69 .
all the equi - m sets were generated from @xmath61 iterations , and plotted at the same scale , in the complex square @xmath79 \times [ -1.5,1.5]$].__,scaledwidth=90.0% ] in this section , we will track the changes in the uni - julia set when the parameters of the system change .
one of our goals is to test , first in the case of equi - parameters @xmath21 , then for general parameters in @xmath51 , if a fatou - julia type theorem applies in the case of our three networks .
first , we try to establish a hypothesis for connectedness of uni - j sets , by addressing numerically and visually questions such as : `` is it true that if @xmath5 is in the equi - m set of a network , then the uni - julia set is connected ? ''
`` is it true that , if @xmath5 is not in the equi - m set of the network , then the uni - julia set is totally disconnected ? ''
clearly , this is not simply a @xmath51 version of the traditional fatou - julia theorem , but rather a slightly different result involving the projection of the julia set onto a uni - slice .
notice that a connected uni - j set in @xmath32 may be obtained from a disconnected @xmath51 network julia set , and conversely , that a disconnected uni - j projection may come from a connected julia in @xmath51 .
we will further discuss @xmath51 versions of these objects in the context of iterations of real variables , where one can visualize the full mandelbrot and julia sets for the network as subsets of @xmath52 . here , we will first investigate uni - j sets for equi - parameters @xmath80 , with a particular focus on tracking the topological changes of the uni - j set as the system approaches the boundary of the equi - m set and leaves the equi - m set . and
@xmath74 , for different values of the equi - parameter @xmath5 ( marked with colored dots on the equi - m template in upper left ) : @xmath81 ( red ) ; @xmath82 ( green ) ; @xmath83 ( blue ) ; @xmath84 ( orange ) ; @xmath85 ( purple ) .
all sets were based on @xmath86 iterations .
both equi - m and uni - j sets coincide in this case with the traditional mandebrot and julia sets for single map iterations.__,scaledwidth=65.0% ] and @xmath76 , for different values of the equi - parameter @xmath5 ( marked with colored dots on the equi - m template in upper left ) : @xmath87 ( red ) ; @xmath88 ( green ) ; @xmath84 ( orange ) ; @xmath89 ( blue ) ; @xmath90 ( dark purple ) ; @xmath91 ( cyan ) ; @xmath92 ( magenta ) . for the first four panels ,
@xmath5 is in the equi - m set ; for the last two , @xmath5 is outside of the equi - m set .
all sets were based on 100 iterations.__,scaledwidth=90.0% ] , as the network profile is changed , from * a. * simple dual with @xmath93 , to * b. * self - drive with additional @xmath74 , to * c. * feedback with additional @xmath94.__,scaledwidth=60.0% ] first , we fix the network type and the connectivity profile ( i.e. , the parameters @xmath40 , @xmath41 and @xmath3 ) , and we observe how the uni - j sets evolves as the equi - parameter @xmath5 changes . in figures [ unijulia1 ] and [ unijulia2 ] we illustrate this for two examples of self - driven models : one with @xmath74 and @xmath53 , the other with @xmath76 and @xmath58 .
as the parameter point @xmath95 approaches the boundary of the equi - m set , the topology of the uni - j set if affected , with its connectivity braking down `` around '' the boundary .
second , we look at the dependence of uni - julia sets on the coupling profile ( network type ) . as an example , we fixed the equi - parameter @xmath96 , and we first considered a simple dual network with negative feed - forward and small cross - talk @xmath97 .
we then added self - drive @xmath74 to the output node , then additionally introduced a small negative feedback @xmath98 .
the three resulting uni - julia sets are shown in figure [ unijulia_model_comparison ] .
notice that a very small degree of feedback @xmath3 produces a more substantial difference than a significant change in the self - drive @xmath41 .
third , one can study the dependence of uni - julia sets on the strength of specific connections within the network . as a simple illustration of
how complex this dependence may be , we show in figures [ c2_julia ] and [ c3_julia ] the effects on the uni - j sets of slight increases in the cross - talk parameter @xmath40 , for two different values of the equi - parameter @xmath5 .
an immediate observation is that uni - j sets no not exhibit the dichotomy from traditional single - map iterations no longer stands : uni - j sets can be connected , totally disconnected , but also disconnected into a ( finite or infinite ) number of connected components , without being totally disconnected .
based on our illustrations , we can further conjecture , in the context of our three models , a description of connectedness for uni - j sets , as follows : and equi - parameter @xmath99 , as the input cross - talk @xmath40 is increased .
the panels show , left to right : @xmath100 , @xmath93 , @xmath53 , @xmath101 and @xmath102.__,scaledwidth=90.0% ] and equi - parameter @xmath96 , as the input cross - talk @xmath40 is increased .
the panels show , left to right : @xmath103 , @xmath104 , @xmath105 , @xmath97 , @xmath53 , @xmath106 and @xmath107 , @xmath108.__,scaledwidth=90.0% ] for any of the three models described , and for any equi - parameter @xmath21 , the uni - j set is connected only if @xmath5 is in the equi - m set of the network , and it is totally disconnected only if @xmath5 is not in the equi - m set of the network .
* the conjecture implies a looser dichotomy regarding connectivity of uni - j sets than that delivered by the traditional fatou - julia result for single maps : if @xmath5 is in the equi - m set of the network , then the uni - j set is either connected or disconnected , without being totally disconnected .
if @xmath5 is not in the equi - m set of the network , then the uni - j set is disconnected ( allowing in particular the case of totally disconnected ) .
+ finally , we want to remind the reader that uni - julia sets can be defined for general parameters @xmath45 , as shown in figure [ general_unijulia ] . , with @xmath109 , @xmath110 and @xmath111 .
the panels represent uni - j sets for a self - drive network with @xmath74 , as the cross - talk @xmath40 changes from * a. * @xmath53 , to * b. * @xmath112 , to * c. * @xmath113.__,scaledwidth=70.0% ]
* center . * self - drive network with @xmath114 and @xmath78 .
* right . *
self - drive network with @xmath115 and @xmath78 .
plots were generated with @xmath116 iterations and in resolution @xmath117.__,scaledwidth=90.0% ] the same definitions apply for iterations of real quadratic maps , with the real case presenting the advantage of easy visualization of full julia and mandelbrot sets , rather than having to consider equi - slices , as we did in the complex case . in figures
[ realmand ] and [ realjulia ] , we illustrate a few multi - m and multi - j sets respectively , for some of the same networks considered in our complex case . moving to illustrate the _ relationship _ between the multi - m and the multi - j set in this case ,
consider for example the self - drive real network with @xmath115 and @xmath78 , for different parameters @xmath118 . while more computationally intensive
, higher - resolution figures would be necessary to establish the geometry and fractality of these sets , one may already notice basic properties .
for example , figure [ realjulia ] shows that , if one were to consider complex equi - parameters , the multi - julia set may not only be connected ( figure [ realjulia]a ) , or totally disconnected ( not shown ) , but may also be broken into a number of connected components ( figures [ realjulia]b anc c ) . and
@xmath78 , with equi - parameters respectively : * a. * @xmath119 ; * b. * @xmath120 ; * c. * @xmath96 .
plots were generated with @xmath116 iterations and in resolution @xmath117.__,scaledwidth=90.0% ] this remained true if we returned to our restriction of having real parameters , once we allow arbitrary ( that is , not necessarily equi ) parameters .
the panels of figure [ real_comp ] show the multi - j sets for two different , but close parameters , @xmath121 and @xmath122 respectively , both of which are not in the multi - m set .
the figures suggest a disconnected ( although not totally disconnected ) multi - j set in the first case , and a connected multi - j set in the second case .
this implies that in this case the fatou - julia dichotomy fails in its traditional form and that the statement relating boundedness of the critical orbit with connectedness of the multi - j set does not hold for real networks .
more precisely , we found parameters for which the multi - julia set appears to be connected , although the critical multi - orbit is unbounded . on the other hand ,
the counterpart of the theorem may still hold , in the following form : `` the multi - j set is connected if the parameter belongs to the multi - m set . ''
part of our current work consists in optimizing the numerical algorithm for multi - m and j sets in real networks , with high enough resolution to allow ( 1 ) observation of possible fractal properties of multi - j sets and of multi - m sets boundaries and ( 2 ) computation of the genus of the filled multi - j sets , in attempt to phrase a topological extension of the theorem that takes into account the number of handles and tunnels that open up in these sets as their connectivity breaks down when leaving the mandelbrot set . and @xmath78 . the two multi - parameters @xmath121 ( left panels ) and @xmath122 ( right panels )
are not in the mandelbrot set for the network .
the top row shows the 3-dimensional julia sets , the bottom panels show top views of the same sets .
plots were generated with @xmath116 iterations and in resolution @xmath117.__,scaledwidth=60.0% ]
in this paper , we used a combination of analytical and numerical approaches to propose possible extensions of fatou - julia theory to networked complex maps .
we started by showing that , even in networks where all nodes are identical maps , their behavior may not be `` synchronized : '' the node - wise mandelbrot sets may be identical in some cases , which in others they may differ substantially , depending on the coupling pattern .
we then investigated how specific changes in the network hard - wiring trigger different effects on the structure of the network mandelbrot and julia sets , focusing in particular on observing topological properties ( connectivity ) and fractal behavior ( haussdorff dimension ) .
we found instances in which small perturbations in the strength of one single connection may lead to dramatic topological changes in the asymptotic sets , and instances in which these sets are robust to much more significant changes .
more generally , our paper suggests a new direction of study , with potentially tractable , although complex mathematical questions .
while existing results do not apply to networks in their traditional form , it appears that connectivity of the newly defined uni - julia sets may still be determined by the behavior of the critical orbit .
we conjectured a weaker extension of the fatou - julia theorem , which was based only on numerical inspection , and which remains subject to a rigorous study that would support or refute it .
there are a few interesting aspects which we aim to address in our future work on iterated networks .
for example , we are interested in studying the structure of equi - m and uni - j sets for larger networks , and in understanding the connection between the network architecture and its asymptotic dynamics
. this direction can lead to ties and applications to understanding functional networks that appear in the natural sciences , which are typically large .
the authors previous work has addressed some of these aspects in the context of continuous dynamics and coupled differential equations . however , when translating network architectural patters into network dynamics , the great difficulty arises from a combination of the graph complexity and the system s intractable dynamic richness .
addressing the question at the level of low - dimensional networks can help us more easily identify and pair specific structural patterns to their effects on dynamics , and thus better understand this dependence .
the next natural step is to return to the search for a similar classification in high - dimensional networks , where specific graph measures or patters ( e.g. node - degree distribution , graph laplacian , presence of strong components , cycles or motifs ) may help us , independently or in combination , classify the network s dynamic behavior . *
described schematically on the left , together with their adjacency matrices .
both systems have connectivity parameters @xmath123 , @xmath124 . _ _ ] @xmath125 = @xmath126 $ ] , @xmath127 + + @xmath128 = @xmath129 , @xmath130 * described schematically on the left , together with their adjacency matrices .
both systems have connectivity parameters @xmath123 , @xmath124.__,scaledwidth=90.0% ] + * described schematically on the left , together with their adjacency matrices .
both systems have connectivity parameters @xmath123 , @xmath124 . _
_ ] @xmath125 = @xmath126 $ ] , @xmath127 + + @xmath128 = @xmath131 , @xmath130 * described schematically on the left , together with their adjacency matrices .
both systems have connectivity parameters @xmath123 , @xmath124.__,scaledwidth=90.0% ] of high interest are methods that can identify robust versus vulnerable features of the graph from a dynamics standpoint . as figures [ 4dim_mand ] and [ 10dim_mand ] show , it is clear that a small perturbation of the graph ( e.g. , adding a single edge ) have the potential , even for higher dimensional networks , to produce dramatic changes in the asymptotic dynamics of the network , and readily lead to substantially different m and j sets .
however , this is not consistently true .
we would like to understand whether a network may have a priori knowledge of which structural changes are likely to produce large dynamic effects .
this is a real possibility in large natural learning networks , including the brain where such knowledge probably affects decisions of synaptic restructuring and temporal evolution of the connectivity profile .
nodes * , formed of two cliques @xmath132 and @xmath133 , with @xmath134 nodes in each .
th adjacency matrix is therefore similar to those in figure [ 4dim_mand ] , with square blocks @xmath135 , @xmath136 and @xmath137 of size @xmath134 . the densities ( number of ones in each block , i.e. number of @xmath132-to-@xmath133 and respectively @xmath133-to-@xmath132 connecting edges ) were takes in each panel to be ( out of the total of @xmath138 : * a. * @xmath139 ; * b. * @xmath140 , @xmath141 ; * c. * @xmath142 ; * d. * @xmath143 . in all cases ,
the connectivity parameters ( i.e. , edge weights ) were @xmath144 and @xmath145.__,title="fig:",scaledwidth=24.0% ] nodes * , formed of two cliques @xmath132 and @xmath133 , with @xmath134 nodes in each .
th adjacency matrix is therefore similar to those in figure [ 4dim_mand ] , with square blocks @xmath135 , @xmath136 and @xmath137 of size @xmath134 . the densities ( number of ones in each block , i.e. number of @xmath132-to-@xmath133 and respectively @xmath133-to-@xmath132 connecting edges ) were takes in each panel to be ( out of the total of @xmath138 : * a. * @xmath139 ; * b. * @xmath140 , @xmath141 ; * c. * @xmath142 ; * d. * @xmath143 . in all cases ,
the connectivity parameters ( i.e. , edge weights ) were @xmath144 and @xmath145.__,title="fig:",scaledwidth=24.0% ] nodes * , formed of two cliques @xmath132 and @xmath133 , with @xmath134 nodes in each .
th adjacency matrix is therefore similar to those in figure [ 4dim_mand ] , with square blocks @xmath135 , @xmath136 and @xmath137 of size @xmath134 . the densities ( number of ones in each block , i.e. number of @xmath132-to-@xmath133 and respectively @xmath133-to-@xmath132 connecting edges ) were takes in each panel to be ( out of the total of @xmath138 : * a. * @xmath139 ; * b. * @xmath140 , @xmath141 ; * c. * @xmath142 ; * d. * @xmath143 . in all cases ,
the connectivity parameters ( i.e. , edge weights ) were @xmath144 and @xmath145.__,title="fig:",scaledwidth=24.0% ] nodes * , formed of two cliques @xmath132 and @xmath133 , with @xmath134 nodes in each .
th adjacency matrix is therefore similar to those in figure [ 4dim_mand ] , with square blocks @xmath135 , @xmath136 and @xmath137 of size @xmath134 . the densities ( number of ones in each block , i.e. number of @xmath132-to-@xmath133 and respectively @xmath133-to-@xmath132 connecting edges ) were takes in each panel to be ( out of the total of @xmath138 : * a. * @xmath139 ; * b. * @xmath140 , @xmath141 ; * c. * @xmath142 ; * d. * @xmath143 . in all cases ,
the connectivity parameters ( i.e. , edge weights ) were @xmath144 and @xmath145.__,title="fig:",scaledwidth=24.0% ] our future work includes understanding and interpreting the importance of this type of results in the context of networks from natural sciences .
one potential view , proposed by the authors in their previous joint work , is to interpret iterated orbits as describing the temporal evolution of an evolving system ( e.g. , copying and proofreading dna sequences , or learning in a neural network ) . along these lines ,
an initial @xmath146 which escapes to @xmath147 under iterations may represent a feature of the system which becomes in time unsustainable , while an initial @xmath146 which is attracted to a simple periodic orbit may represent a feature which is too simple to be relevant or efficient for the system .
then the points on the boundary between these two behaviors ( i.e. , the julia set ) may be viewed as the optimal features , allowing the system to perform its complex function .
we study how this `` optimal set of features '' changes when perturbing its architecture .
once we gain enough knowledge of networked maps for fixed nodes and edges , and we formulate which applications this framework may be appropriate to address symbolically , we will allow the nodes dynamics , as well as the edge weights and distribution , to evolve in time together with the iterations .
this process may account for phenomena such as learning , or adaptation a crucial aspect that needs to be understood about systems .
this represents a natural direction in which to extend existing work by the authors on random iterations in the one - dimensional case .
the work on this project was supported by the suny new paltz research scholarship and creative activities program .
we additionally want to thank sergio verduzco - flores , for his programing suggestions , and mark comerford , for the useful mathematical discussions
. 10 rdulescu a , verduzco - flores s , 2015 .
nonlinear network dynamics under perturbations of the underlying graph .
chaos : an interdisciplinary journal of nonlinear science .
25(1 ) : 013116 .
gray rt , robinson pa , 2009 .
stability and structural constraints of random brain networks with excitatory and inhibitory neural populations .
journal of computational neuroscience .
27(1 ) : 81101 .
siri b , quoy m , delord b , cessac b , berry h , 2007 .
effects of hebbian learning on the dynamics and structure of random networks with inhibitory and excitatory neurons .
journal of physiology - paris .
101(1 ) : 136148 .
brunel n , 2000 .
dynamics of sparsely connected networks of excitatory and inhibitory spiking neurons .
journal of computational neuroscience .
8(3 ) : 183208 .
bullmore e , sporns o , 2009 .
complex brain networks : graph theoretical analysis of structural and functional systems .
nature reviews neuroscience .
10(3 ) : 186198 .
sporns o , 2002 .
graph theory methods for the analysis of neural connectivity patterns .
neuroscience databases : a practical guide . 171186 .
sporns o , 2011 . the non - random brain : efficiency , economy , and complex dynamics .
frontiers in computational neuroscience . 5 : 5 .
julia , g. : mmoire sur litration des fonctions rationnelles . journal de mathmatiques pures et appliques , 47246 ( 1918 ) fatou , p. : sur les quations fonctionnelles .
bulletin de la socit mathmatique de france * 47 * , 161271 ( 1919 ) branner , b. , hubbard , j.h . :
the iteration of cubic polynomials part ii : patterns and parapatterns .
acta mathematica * 169*(1 ) , 229325 ( 1992 ) qiu , wy .
, yin , yc . , proof of the branner - hubbard conjecture on cantor julia sets .
science in china series a : mathematics * 52*(1 ) , 4565 ( 2009 ) carleson , l. , gamelin , t.w . : complex dynamics , volume 69 .
springer science & business media ( 1993 ) devaney , r.l .
, look , d.m . : a criterion for sierpinski curve julia sets . in `` topology proceedings , '' volume 30 , 163179 ( 2006 ) fatihcan m atay , jrgen jost , and andreas wende . delays , connection topology , and synchronization of coupled chaotic maps . , 92(14):144101 , 2004 .
c hauptmann , h touchette , and mc mackey .
information capacity and pattern formation in a tent map network featuring statistical periodicity .
, 67(2):026217 , 2003 .
ob isaeva , sp kuznetsov , and ah osbaldestin .
phenomena of complex analytic dynamics in the systems of alternately excited coupled non - autonomous oscillators and self - sustained oscillators . , 2010 .
cm marcus and rm westervelt .
dynamics of iterated - map neural networks . , 40(1):501 , 1989 .
cristina masoller and fatihcan m atay .
complex transitions to synchronization in delay - coupled networks of logistic maps .
, 62(1):119126 , 2011 .
anca rdulescu and ariel pignatelli .
symbolic template iterations of complex quadratic maps . , 1 - 18 , 2016 . xiaoling yu , zhen jia , and xiangguo jian .
logistic mapping - based complex network modeling .
, 4(11):1558 , 2013 .
wang , xin .
period - doublings to chaos in a simple neural network : an analytical proof .
, 5(4 ) : 425444 , 1991 .
the figures show four uni - j sets , for @xmath148 and @xmath149 nodes .
the equi - parameters , adjacency matrices , and connectivity parameters of each network are given below , from left to right : + | many natural systems are organized as networks , in which the nodes interact in a time - dependent fashion .
the object of our study is to relate connectivity to the temporal behavior of a network in which the nodes are ( real or complex ) logistic maps , coupled according to a connectivity scheme that obeys certain constrains , but also incorporates random aspects .
we investigate in particular the relationship between the system architecture and possible dynamics . in the current paper
we focus on establishing the framework , terminology and pertinent questions for low - dimensional networks .
a subsequent paper will further address the relationship between hardwiring and dynamics in high - dimensional networks .
+ for networks of both complex and real node - maps , we define extensions of the julia and mandelbrot sets traditionally defined in the context of single map iterations . for three different model networks ,
we use a combination of analytical and numerical tools to illustrate how the system behavior ( measured via topological properties of the _ julia sets _ ) changes when perturbing the underlying adjacency graph .
we differentiate between the effects on dynamics of different perturbations that directly modulate network connectivity : increasing / decreasing edge weights , and altering edge configuration by adding , deleting or moving edges .
we discuss the implications of considering a rigorous extension of fatou - julia theory known to apply for iterations of single maps , to iterations of ensembles of maps coupled as nodes in a network . *
real and complex behavior for networks of coupled logistic maps * + anca rdulescu@xmath0 , ariel pignatelli@xmath1 + @xmath2 department of mathematics , suny new paltz , ny 12561 @xmath1 department of mechanical engineering , suny new paltz , ny 12561 + |
all authors acknowledge funding from grants erc magreps 267 862 , fp7 grant infernos 308850 , icrea academia 2013 and fis2013 - 47796- p. all data used in this study are included in the main text and in the supplementary materials .
j.c .- s . and a.a .
equally contributed to this work .
[ sec : author ]
* ecori binding to dna . * * ( a ) * unfolding / refolding force - distance curves of a dna hairpin in the absence ( magenta / black ) and presence ( blue / cyan ) of ecori protein .
the bound ( @xmath9 ) and unfolded ( @xmath10 ) states are discriminated at high force by the presence of two distinct force branches . * ( b ) * cyclic pulling curves classified according to their initial ( blue dot ) and final state ( cyan dot ) that start and end at a high force ( @xmath221 pn ) .
work equals the enclosed area between the two curves and is shown in dark / light gray for positive / negative values . *
( c ) * paths of a non - equilibrium cyclic protocol connecting different initial and final states . * ( d ) * partial work distributions of @xmath13 ( green ) and @xmath14 ( magenta ) transitions at different ecori concentrations . * ( e ) * binding energy of ecori ( blue ) and fit to the law of mass action ( red line ) at ( 130 mm @xmath51 , @xmath52c , @xmath53 m ) . *
( f ) * binding energy of ecori at varying [ nacl ] ( 1 nm ecori ) .
error bars were obtained from bootstrap using 1000 re - samplings of size n ( n is total number of pulls for each condition shown in tables s1 and s3 ) .
* oligo binding to dna . * * ( a ) * scheme of native ( @xmath8 ) , unfolded ( @xmath10 ) and oligo bound ( @xmath9 ) states . *
( b ) * cyclic pulling curves that start and end at low forces ( @xmath26 pn ) classified according to their initial ( blue dot ) and final state ( cyan dot ) . * ( c ) * partial work distributions of @xmath54 ( green ) and @xmath55 ( magenta ) transitions . *
( d ) * binding energy of the 10-base oligo ( blue ) and fit to the law of mass action ( red line ) .
the value obtained from hopping equilibrium experiments at [ oligo]=400 nm ( see s1.7 in @xcite ) is shown in cyan .
( inset ) contribution of the ratio @xmath56 to the binding energy .
error bars were obtained from bootstrap as described in fig . 1 .
* binding specificity , allostery and kinetic stabilization of misfolded states for the peptide echinomycin . * * ( a ) * first rupture force distribution of hairpins sp ( red ) and nsp ( blue ) in the absence ( light ) and presence ( dark ) of echinomycin . * ( b ) * binding energy of echinomycin to a specific ( red ) and nonspecific ( blue ) site , and fit to the law of mass action . * ( c ) * hairpins c and nc contain two specific binding sites ( red boxes ) placed contiguously or separated by 2-bp respectively . binding energy per ligand when one ( blue ) or two ligands ( green ) are bound to hairpins
nc or c ( magenta ) ( [ echninomycin]=3 @xmath45 m ) .
gaussian distributions are reconstructed from mean and variance of measurements .
the wider distribution for the single bound state in hairpin nc ( blue ) is due to the lower number of paths reaching this state at high ligand concentration , increasing measurement error . *
( d ) * pulling cycle of hairpin m in the presence of echinomycin .
the unfolding curve ( blue ) shows two force rips at @xmath57 pn corresponding to the unbinding of two ligands bound to specific sites . in the refolding curve ( cyan )
, the hairpin does not fold back to the native state , and misfolds into a kinetically stabilized configuration of longer molecular extension ( @xmath58 of refolding curves at [ echninomycin]=10 @xmath45 m ) .
error bars were obtained from bootstrap as described in fig . 1 .
the ftlb is derived following the same steps as in @xcite . consider a system with a fluctuating number of particles @xmath8 , which correspond to the ligand molecules .
the system evolves under an experimental protocol @xmath59 , where @xmath6 denotes the control parameter and in our case corresponds to the position of the optical trap relative to the pipette .
we discretize in time the protocol as @xmath60 , where @xmath61 ( @xmath62 ) denotes the value of @xmath6 at the time of the protocol @xmath63 ( being @xmath64 the time discretization unit ) , and @xmath65 denotes the duration of the protocol . along the protocol @xmath59 the system follows a given trajectory @xmath66 , where a sequence of configurations @xmath67 are sampled .
the trajectory can be discretized as @xmath68 .
each configuration @xmath69 ( @xmath70 ) is characterized by the number of particles , @xmath71 , and the degrees of freedom of each particle . the equilibrium probability to be in a given configuration @xmath69 at @xmath6
can be written , according to the grand - canonical ensemble , as : @xmath72 where @xmath73 ( being @xmath74 the boltzmann constant and @xmath5 the absolute temperature ) , @xmath75 is the fugacity of the system ( equal to @xmath76 , being @xmath45 the chemical potential of the ligand molecules ) , @xmath77 is the grand canonical partition function , and @xmath78 is the energy of the configuration @xmath69 at @xmath6 . we suppose that the dynamics of the system satisfy the following detailed balance condition : @xmath79 therefore , the probability of the system to follow a given trajectory @xmath66 ( without imposing any initial and final configuration ) , and the probability to follow its time reversed @xmath80 is : [ eq : 1 ] @xmath81 where @xmath82 .
we assume that in the forward protocol @xmath59 the system starts in partial equilibrium at @xmath83 , while in the reversed protocol @xmath84 it starts in partial equilibrium at @xmath85 ( and @xmath86 ) .
the partial equilibrium probability density function of a given configuration @xmath87 , where @xmath88 is a subset of configurations accessible by the system , can be written as @xcite : suppose that the system starts in non - equilibrium conditions .
particularly , the system starts in partial equilibrium at the kinetic state @xmath92 in the forward trajectory and at at the kinetic state @xmath93 in the reversed one .
a kinetic state is a partially equilibrated region of configurational space , meaning that during a finite amount of time the system is confined and thermalized within that region .
this is mathematically described by a boltzmann - gibbs distribution restricted to configurations contained in that region . then : experiments are performed with a highly stable miniaturized dual - beam optical tweezers described in previous studies @xcite .
the dna hairpins are tethered between two beads by using short dsdna handles ( 29-bp ) that are differentially end - labelled with biotin and digoxigenin to attach each handle to a different bead ( see supp .
section [ sec : summary of dna hairpins used in this work ] for hairpin sequences and synthesis details ) @xcite .
pulling speed is set at 190 nm / s in all the experiments . for the ecori experiments , longer dsdna handles ( @xmath2600-bp ) are used to reduce nonspecific interactions mediated by the protein and beads . for these experiments ,
the microfluidics chamber was also coated with poly(ethylene glycol ) ( peg ) to avoid protein loss due to nonspecific absorption on the glass surface @xcite . experimental conditions for each interaction were chosen to be comparable to previous ensemble and single - molecule studies : for ecori ( hepes 10 mm ph7.5 , edta 1 mm , nacl 130 mm , bsa 0.1 mg / ml , 100 @xmath45 m , dtt , 0.01% nan@xmath103 ) and salt titrated in the range 60 - 180 mm nacl ; for the oligonucleotide ( tris 10 mm ph7.5 , edta 1 mm , 100 mm nacl , 0.01% nan@xmath103 ) ; and for echinomycin ( tris 10 mm ph7.5 , edta 1 mm , 100 mm nacl , 2% dmso , 0.01% nan@xmath103 ) .
all ligands were obtained from commercial sources and used without further purification : ecori ( new england biolabs , 100 u/@xmath45l , @xmath2800 nm dimer ) , oligonucleotide ( eurofins mwg operon , hypur grade ) , echinomycin ( merck millipore ) .
concentrations were confirmed using a spectrophotometric analysis for the oligonucleotide ( extinction coefficient 97400 m@xmath104cm@xmath104 at @xmath6=260 nm ) and echinomycin ( extinction coefficient 11500 m@xmath104cm@xmath104 at @xmath6=325 nm ) , whereas for ecori we performed an electrophoretic mobility shift assay using previously described protocols @xcite .
all experiments were performed at 25 . in all the cases , the number of cycles obtained per molecule range between 20 and 1300 .
a minimum of 2 and a maximum of 10 molecules were pulled in each case ( see tables [ tab : ecori n ] , [ tab : ecori n sal ] , [ tab : oligo n ] , [ tab : echi
n ] , [ tab : echins n ] , [ tab : echi c nc n ] [ tab : echi m n ] ) .
m. r. shirts , e. bair , g. hooker , & v. s. pande . equilibrium free energies from nonequilibrium measurements using maximum likelihood methods .
lett . _ * 91 * , 140601 ( 2003 ) .
ultrahigh - resolution optical trap with single - fluorophore sensitivity .
methods _ * 8 * , 335340 ( 2011 ) .
j. camunas - soler , _
et al_. single - molecule kinetics and footprinting of dna bis - intercalation : the paradigmatic case of thiocoraline .
_ nucleic acids res .
_ * 43 * , 27672779 ( 2015 ) .
a. alemany , & f. ritort .
determination of the elastic properties of short ssdna molecules by mechanically folding and unfolding dna hairpins .
_ biopolymers _ * 101 * , 11931199 ( 2014 ) . | thermodynamic bulk measurements of binding reactions rely on the validity of the law of mass action and the assumption of a dilute solution . yet important biological systems such as allosteric ligand - receptor binding , macromolecular crowding , or misfolded molecules may not follow these assumptions and require a particular reaction model . here
we introduce a fluctuation theorem for ligand binding and an experimental approach using single - molecule force - spectroscopy to determine binding energies , selectivity and allostery of nucleic acids and peptides in a model - independent fashion .
a similar approach could be used for proteins .
this work extends the use of fluctuation theorems beyond unimolecular folding reactions , bridging the thermodynamics of small systems and the basic laws of chemical equilibrium .
binding energies are key quantities determining the fate of intermolecular reactions @xcite .
bulk experimental approaches such as surface plasmon resonance , isothermal titration calorimetry and fluorescent ligand binding assays , allow the extraction of binding energies ( @xmath0 ) from measurements of the dissociation constant ( @xmath1 ) with accuracy @xmath21 kcal / mol through the expression : @xmath3~ , \label{eq : masact}\ ] ] where @xmath4 is the boltzmann constant , and @xmath5 the temperature @xcite .
however , many ligands such as dna - binding proteins display different binding modes with varying affinities , or require the concerted action of several subunits , making quantitative measurements challenging @xcite .
force techniques such as optical tweezers can be used to pull on individual ligand - dna complexes allowing detection of binding events one - at - a - time ( figure 1*a * , inset ) @xcite
. however , force - induced ligand unbinding usually takes place in non - equilibrium conditions , and binding energies can not be directly inferred from the measured work values .
the crooks fluctuation theorem and the jarzynski equality @xcite are tools to extract equilibrium free energy differences from work distributions obtained far from equilibrium , allowing the measurement of folding free energies of nucleic acids and proteins , both from fully equilibrated @xcite and kinetic states @xcite .
however , to date the use of fluctuation theorems remains restricted to unimolecular reactions ( e.g. folding ) .
here we introduce a fluctuation theorem for ligand binding ( ftlb ) that allows us to directly extract binding energies of bimolecular or higher - order reactions from irreversible work measurements in pulling experiments ( see s1.1 in @xcite ) .
we first show how cyclic protocols allow an unambiguous classification of experimental pathways in relation to the initial and final state , which is an essential step in the application of these theorems .
we then apply the ftlb to directly verify the validity of the law of mass action for dilute ligand solutions .
next we use the ftlb to accurately measure specific and nonspecific binding energies , as well as allosteric effects due to the cooperative binding of ligand pairs .
finally , we show how the ftlb is also applicable to extract binding energies to non - native structures ( e.g. misfolded states , prions , chaperones ) , a measurement inaccesible to most bulk techniques @xcite . as a proof of principle we investigated the binding of the restriction endonuclease ecori to a 30-bp dna hairpin that contains its recognition site ( gaattc ) ( see s1.2,s1.3 in @xcite ) .
restriction endonucleases , which bind their cognate sequences with high affinity , are a paradigm of protein - dna interactions @xcite . in a typical experiment ,
the hairpin is unfolded ( refolded ) by increasing ( decreasing ) the distance ( @xmath6 ) between the optical trap and the micropipette ( figure 1*a * ) . in the absence of ligand , the hairpin folds and unfolds in the force range @xmath7 pn .
the binding of ecori increases the stability of the hairpin leading to higher unfolding forces ( @xmath223 pn ) . during a pulling experiment , ecori binds dna when the hairpin is folded .
however , since there is no net change in molecular extension upon binding / unbinding , the native ( @xmath8 ) and bound ( @xmath9 ) states can not be distinguished at low forces .
in contrast , at forces above @xmath7 pn the bound state ( @xmath9 ) can be unambiguously distinguished from the unfolded state ( @xmath10 ) , as the hairpin remains folded when the protein is bound but unfolds when it is unbound ( figure 1*a * , empty , blue and cyan dots respectively ) .
we performed experiments at different ecori concentrations , and determined @xmath23 from the work value ( @xmath24 ) at which the partial work distributions cross ( @xmath25 ) by taking @xmath26 ( figure 1*d * , s1.5 in @xcite ) .
the term @xmath23 includes all the energetic contributions involved in going from @xmath9 to @xmath10 ( e.g. binding energy , conformational changes , elastic terms , see s1.6 in @xcite ) . by subtracting the elastic contributions and the energy of formation of the hairpin from the measured @xmath23 value , we extract the binding energy at zero force ( @xmath27 ) at different ecori concentrations ( figure 1*e * and tables s1 , s2 ) . as shown in figure 1*e * ,
@xmath27 follows the law of mass action ( eq . [ eq : masact ] ) , @xmath28 with @xmath29 @xmath30 , providing a direct test of its validity .
this value is independent on the start / end force of the cyclic protocol and relies on a correct classification of paths ( fig .
s2-s3 ) .
we also performed titration experiments with varying nacl concentration showing that ecori binding energy has a pronounced salt - dependency with slope @xmath31}=-11\pm 2 $ ] @xmath30 ( figure 1 * f * and tables s3 , s4 ) , in agreement with previous bulk experiments @xcite .
finally , we repeated experiments with hairpins containing non - cognate dna sequences which did not show binding in the same range of ecori concentrations , proving the specificity of the interaction @xcite . to further test the validity of eq .
[ eq : ft ] , we investigated a model system consisting of a short oligonucleotide of 10 bases that binds a dna hairpin .
the oligonucleotide can bind the substrate by base - pairing complementarity when the hairpin is in the unfolded ( @xmath10 ) state , thereby inhibiting the refolding of the hairpin at low forces . at forces below the critical force range of the hairpin ( @xmath32 pn ) , the oligo - bound state ( @xmath9 ) competes with the formation of the native hairpin ( @xmath8 ) , and states @xmath9 and @xmath8
can be distinguished due to their different molecular extension ( figure 2*a * ) . to apply eq .
[ eq : ft ] , we considered cyclic protocols that start and end at a force lower than the range @xmath33 ( figure 2*b * ) . from the measured partial work distributions and fractions of paths connecting @xmath8 and @xmath9 ( figure 2*c * ) we extracted the binding energies at zero force ( @xmath27 ) ( figure 2*d * and tables s5 , s6 ) .
measured binding energies again follow the law of mass action with @xmath34 @xmath30 ( figure 2*d * ) .
this agrees with theoretical predictions using the nearest - neighbour model ( @xmath35 @xmath36 ) @xcite and equilibrium experiments performed at the coexistence force of the hairpin , where hopping due to binding / unbinding is observed ( figs .
s4-s6 and table s7 ) .
the inclusion of the ratio @xmath37 ( figure 2*d * , inset ) is essential to recover the correct binding energies .
previous attempts to derive binding energies using unidirectional work measurements and the jarzynski equality did not account for concentration - dependent effects in the chemical potential that are essential in equation [ eq : ft ] @xcite . to prove the general power of the method , we studied echinomycin , a small dna bis - intercalator with selectivity for cg steps @xcite that binds contiguous acgt sites cooperatively @xcite .
we performed experiments with a 12-bp dna hairpin containing a single cg - step ( sp hairpin ) that shows rupture forces in the range @xmath38 pn ( figure 3*a * and fig .
s7 ) . in the presence of echinomycin the histogram of rupture forces
is shifted to higher values and shows a bimodal distribution , indicating two binding modes : a high - affinity binding to the specific cg - site ( high - force peak , @xmath39 pn ) , and a low - affinity binding to other non - specific sites ( low - force peak , @xmath40 pn ) . to confirm this , we pulled a hairpin in which we removed the specific binding site by inverting the cg - motif ( nsp hairpin ) . in the presence of ligand only the low affinity peak is observed ( figure 3*a * )
. to extract the binding energy of each mode , we performed cyclic protocols that start at a force high enough to discriminate both binding modes : we used @xmath39 pn ( @xmath41 pn ) for the sp ( nsp ) hairpin in order to extract both the specific and nonspecific binding energy of the ligand . in this way
, we obtained paths connecting states @xmath9 and @xmath10 , and extracted the binding energy of the specific and nonspecific modes ( tables s8-s11 ) . for both binding modes
, @xmath42 follows the law of mass action with @xmath43 @xmath30 and @xmath44 @xmath30 ( figure 3*b * ) , which give affinities of 2 nm and 1.8 @xmath45 m respectively ( eq . [ eq : masact ] ) .
this measurement of an affinity in the nm range for the specific binding is compatible with quasi - equilibrium experiments ( fig .
s8 ) and improves previous studies where accurate measurements could not be obtained due to the concurrent action of both modes @xcite .
the ftlb allows us to go beyond free - energy measurements of single ligands , and measure allosteric effects between ligands binding at nearby positions @xcite . for this
, we designed hairpin @xmath46 which contains two acgt sites separated by 2 bp ( figure 3*c * ) .
the simultaneous binding of two ligands can be distinguished from the binding of a single ligand from the force rips observed in the force - distance curve ( fig .
s9 ) . by applying the ftlb we extracted the binding energy per ligand in the single and double bound states , and found that binding is favoured by the presence of a neighbouring ligand .
the ftlb allows us to quantitatively test the distance - dependence of this allosteric effect by performing a differential measurement of binding energies with hairpin @xmath47 , which contains two contiguous sites ( figure 3*c * , tables s12-s14 ) .
the binding energy per ligand we obtain in the double bound state in hairpin @xmath47 is @xmath48 @xmath30 higher than in hairpin @xmath46 , providing a direct experimental measurement of cooperativity effects in ligand pairs as a function of their distance . single - molecule manipulation is particularly suited to observe the formation of misfolded structures ( e.g. prions , amyloids ) @xcite , but methods to characterize binding to these species are currently lacking . by applying the ftlb it is possible to extract the binding energy to these kinetically stabilized non - native structures . by using a dna hairpin with two binding sites separated by 4bp
, we observe the formation of a misfolded structure consisting of two short ( 4bp ) hairpins in series ( figure 3*d * , hairpin m ) .
such an off - pathway kinetic state is unobservable in the absence of ligand due to its low energy of formation , however it is kinetically stabilized by the binding of the ligand .
we applied eq .
[ eq : ft ] by choosing a starting point of the cyclic protocol where the native - bound and misfolded - bound conformations are distinguishable ( @xmath49 pn ) , and found that the energy of binding to both configurations are equal ( @xmath50 @xmath30 , fig .
s10 and tab .
s15 , s16 ) . in this work ,
we have introduced a fluctuation theorem for ligand binding ( ftlb ) to directly determine binding energies as a function of ligand concentration in single - molecule experiments . using different biomolecular systems of increasing complexity we provide a single - molecule verification of the law of mass action , and show how the ftlb can account for mass exchange between a molecular system and the environment .
we can resolve binding energies to specific and non - specific sites with affinities spanning six orders of magnitude .
the ftlb provides a direct experimental measurement of binding energies without assuming any model or reaction scheme , which is particularly useful in cases where the law of mass action does not hold . to show this
, we applied the ftlb in two situations where this may happen : the cooperative binding of multiple ligands to the same substrate and the stabilization of kinetic structures through ligand binding - both measurements inaccessible to bulk methods and relevant to many interactions between proteins and ligands .
the use of an inherently non - equilibrium method to obtain equilibrium binding energies also grants access to molecular interactions that equilibrate over very long timescales ( e.g. nucleosome assembly ) and that can only be currently measured by indirect techniques such as competition assays @xcite .
the ftlb relates work measurements to binding energies without making any assumption on reaction kinetics or the ideal solution limit .
therefore it might be also used to test the explicit breakdown of the law of mass action in conditions where it is not applicable , for instance in crowded environments , where ligands exhibit compartmentalized dynamics due to steric hindrance interactions @xcite .
lastly , the applicabilty of the ftlb is not restricted to biomolecular reactions , and might be directly applied to other interacting systems that can only be explored through non - equilibrium methods . |
hadrons are the bound states of the strong interaction which is described by the quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) in the framework of yang - mills gauge theory
. one of the main goals of the hadron physics is to understand the composition of hadrons in terms of quarks and gluons .
the quark model is proved successful in classifying the mesons and baryons as @xmath5 and @xmath6 composite systems .
almost all the well established mesons can be described as a quark - antiquark state except some mesons with exotic quantum numbers which are impossible for a @xmath5 system , but no experimental evidence is reported for exotic baryons which are inconsistent with the @xmath6 configuration until the beginning of this century .
theoretically , the qcd does not forbid the existence of the hadrons with the other configurations , such as the glueballs , the hybrids and the multiquarks . in this review ,
we focus on the pentaquarks .
if the pentaquark really exists , it will provide a new stage to test the qcd in the nonperturbative region and to investigate the properties of the strong interaction . in the quark model language ,
the pentaquark is a hadron state with four valence quarks and one valence antiquark as @xmath7 @xcite . because the pentaquark can decay to a three - quark baryon and a quark - antiquark meson , its width was suggested to be wide @xcite , but it was predicted to have a narrow width due to its particular quark structure @xcite . in principle , any baryon may have the five - quark contents , and experiments have revealed the important role of the intrinsic sea quarks in understanding the structure of the proton . on the other hand
, the pentaquark state may also mix with the corresponding three - quark state or hybrid state , so the situation is much more complicated .
the pentaquark is easier to be identified if it has no admixture with any three - quark state , i.e. , if the flavor of the anti - quark @xmath8 in the @xmath7 state is different from any of the other four quarks @xcite .
early experiments in 1960 s and 1970 s were performed to search for a baryon with positive strangeness as the pentaquark candidate referred to as the @xmath9 @xcite , but no enhancements were found .
this field developed rapidly on both the experimental and the theoretical aspects in the last decade since the first report for a positive strangeness pentaquark - like baryon , referred to as the @xmath0 , by the leps collaboration @xcite .
its mass and width are closed to the prediction of the chiral soliton model @xcite .
this particle was quickly reported in subsequent experiments by some groups , and many theoretical models were applied to understanding this particle and to predicting other pentaquarks , such as the diquark cluster model @xcite , the diquark - triquark model @xcite , the constituent quark model @xcite , the chiral quark model @xcite , the bag model @xcite , the meson - baryon binding @xcite , the qcd sum rules @xcite , the lattice qcd @xcite and the chiral soliton model in new versions @xcite .
unfortunately , many experiments found no signals for this particle .
what is worse , the signals observed in the early experiments by some groups disappeared when including the new data with high statistics . however , some groups reconfirmed their observations for this particle with very high statistical significance in their updated experiments .
so even the existence of the pentaquark is a mystery .
the production mechanism and the analysis method should be investigated in details .
recently , a charged charmonium - like meson @xmath10 was observed by bes @xcite and belle @xcite .
it is a suggestive evidence for the existence of the multiquark meson .
this arouses much interest on the study of the multiquark states . in this paper , we review the experimental search for the pentaquark states . in sect .
ii and iii , we concentrate on the searches for the @xmath0 with positive or negative results . in sect .
iv , we focus on a non - strange pentaquark candidate . in sect .
v , the other observed pentaquark candidates are presented .
then we discuss the results in sect .
vi and a brief summary is contained in the last section .
the pentaquark candidate @xmath0 was widely discussed and searched for since the first report on the experimental observation by the leps collaboration @xcite .
the skyrme s idea that baryons are solitons @xcite arouses interesting , and the soliton picture consists with the qcd in the large @xmath11 limit @xcite .
the @xmath0 , if exists , is the lightest member in the predicted antidecuplet @xcite . its mass and width were predicted in the chiral soliton model @xcite . in quark model language ,
the @xmath0 is described as a pentaquark state @xmath12 . unlike the other pentaquark @xmath7 states that the antiquark may have the same flavor with at least one quark , the lowest fock state of the @xmath0 composes of five quarks with the anti - quark being @xmath13 , which is of different flavor from the other four @xmath14 quarks .
therefore it is easy to be identified from other ordinary baryons with minimal @xmath15 configurations @xcite . for the pentaquark
states that the antiquark has the same flavor of some quark , the mixing of the pentaquark state and the corresponding three - quark state and hybrid state makes the situation complicated , because any three - quark baryon may have five - quark components from both perturbative and nonperturbative aspects , such as the baryon - meson fluctuation picture @xcite and the light - cone fock state expansion @xcite .
since the @xmath0 has the same quark constituents as the combination of @xmath16 and @xmath17 , these two modes are expected as the primary decay channel , and thus are usually used in reconstructions in the experiments . after the first report for the @xmath0 , the signals were observed by many groups @xcite , and some groups confirmed their results with new data @xcite .
all these results are briefly listed in table [ thetay ] .
negative results were also reported by many groups , and some early positive results in the photoproduction experiment by clas @xcite and in the proton - proton collision by cosy - tof @xcite were rejected by their high - statistics experiments later @xcite . those are discussed in the next section .
.experiments with positive signals for the @xmath0 . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^,>",options="header " , ] the @xmath3 baryon , if exists , is the lightest charmed pentaquark state like the @xmath0 but the @xmath13 quark replaced with the @xmath18 quark .
its lowest fock state is @xmath19 which has the same constituent quarks with the combination of @xmath20 or @xmath21 .
thus these are estimated as the dominant decay channels .
the signal for the @xmath3 was only observed in the dis experiment by the h1 collaboration @xcite .
the analysis was based on the data at hera in 1996 - 2000 .
the @xmath22 was reconstructed via the decay channal @xmath23 . in the distribution of @xmath24 with opposite - charge combinations ,
a peak was observed at @xmath25 mev/@xmath26 with a gaussian width of @xmath27 mev/@xmath26 .
the background was estimated from the monte carlo simulation .
the number of the signal events is @xmath28 , corresponding to a statistical significance of 5.4@xmath29 .
however this resonance was not observed in any other experiment as listed in the table [ thetac ] .
the @xmath30 baryon , if exists , is a double strangeness @xmath31 pentaquark candidate , having the lowest fock state @xmath32 .
it is recognized as an isospin quartet together with its partners @xmath33 , @xmath34 and @xmath35 .
the primary decay channel of @xmath2 is estimated to be @xmath36 .
the signal for the @xmath2 was only reported by the na49 collaboration at cern @xcite .
the analysis was base on the data of 158 gev/@xmath37 proton beam colliding with the lh@xmath38 target .
the @xmath39 was reconstructed via the decay channel @xmath40 . then 1640 @xmath39 and 551 @xmath41 were selected .
a peak was observed in the @xmath36 mass spectrum .
combined with the @xmath42 data as the antiparticle , the fitted peak is at @xmath43 mev/@xmath26 with 69 signals over the background of 75 events corresponding to a statistical significance of 5.8@xmath29 estimated as @xmath44 .
one of its isospin partners @xmath45 was also observed , and the fitted mass is @xmath46 mev/@xmath26 . unfortunately this resonance was not observed in any other experiment as listed in the table [ xi1860 ] .
among all the experiments in which the @xmath0 was observed , the width was claimed to be narrow . however , the mass position of the signals in different experiments spreads in a large region from 1520 to 1560 mev/@xmath26 as shown in fig . [ mass ] .
this does not consist with a narrow resonance .
the mass values in leps early experiment @xcite , diana experiments @xcite , saphir experiment @xcite and jinr experiments @xcite are around 1540 mev/@xmath26 , while the values in hermes experiment @xcite , svd early experiment @xcite , itep s analysis on the old neutrino experiments @xcite and e522 experiment @xcite are near 1530 mev/@xmath26 . besides , the leps recent experiment @xcite , the svd updated experiment @xcite and the zeus experiment @xcite provide even lower mass values close to 1520 mev/@xmath26 , and the obelix experiment gives a much higher value .
therefore , it is possible that even the observed signals do not correspond to the same particle .
the width of the @xmath0 are not measured as accurate as the mass , and thus the values in almost all the experiments are consistent as shown in fig .
[ width ] .
mass values for the @xmath0 observed in various experiments .
the error bars represent the statistical uncertainties.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] width values for the @xmath0 measured in various experiments .
the error bars represent the statistical uncertainties .
the experiments with only the upper limit on the width are listed in the table [ thetay ] .
the dashed line is the upper limit of the intrinsic width of @xmath0 at 90% c.l . by belle @xcite.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] the statistical significance of the signals was usually estimated as @xmath47 in the early experiments .
this estimator neglects the uncertainty of the background , and thus the significance may be overestimated .
the estimator @xmath44 which assumes a smooth background with a well defined shape and @xmath48 which assumes a statistical independent background with uncertainties are more proper since the production mechanism is still unknown .
if so , the significance of the signals in the svd updated analysis @xcite reduces to 5.6@xmath29 and @xmath49 estimated as @xmath48 for the two samples respectively , but is still large enough as an evidence . in this case
, however , the hermes result decreases to 2.7 - 3.9@xmath29 , the jinr @xmath50 result decreases to 4.1@xmath29 and the jinr @xmath51 result decreases to 3.5@xmath29 .
these are not enough to be claimed as an evidence .
besides , the log - likelihood difference is also a suitable alternative and was used by the leps @xcite and the diana @xcite .
the @xmath52 produced in the inclusive experiments may affect the result of the @xmath0 reconstructed via the @xmath53 mode .
as pointed out by m. zavertyaev @xcite , the decay @xmath54 could lead to a spurious sharp peak at 1540 mev/@xmath26 when the momentum of the @xmath52 is greater than 2 gev/@xmath37 . on the other hand
, the @xmath55 decays of the @xmath52s could enhance the background when the @xmath56 or the proton was paired with a @xmath57 or a @xmath58 . up to now
, no positive result is reported for the @xmath0 production in the @xmath59 experiments .
a possible way to understand these null results with no contradict with the positive ones is to assume that the @xmath0 production cross section is highly suppressed in @xmath59 annihilations . using the quark constituent counting rules , a.i .
titov et al .
estimated the ratio of @xmath0 to @xmath60 production in the fragmentation region and showed the ratio decreases very fast with energy @xcite .
this ratio is often applied to estimate the yield of the @xmath0 , because @xmath60 is a narrow resonance with similar mass to the @xmath0 and is easily reconstructed .
the low value of this ratio implies a very different production mechanism for @xmath0 if it really exists . for the dis experiments performed at hera @xcite , the zeus and the h1 provided opposite conclusions .
these two experiments were almost in the same conditions and with the data collected during the same period , but even using the same cuts the h1 could not produce the @xmath0 signal observed by the zeus .
it is very confused , and probably the signal observed by the zeus is a statistical fluctuation . for the photoproduction experiments ,
there is a contradiction in the @xmath61 experiments between the upper limit on the cross section given by the clas @xcite and the result reported by the saphir @xcite and a contradiction in the @xmath62 experiments between the upper limit on the cross section given by the clas @xcite and the result reported by the leps @xcite . as claimed by the leps ,
the contradiction between the leps and clas results is due to the different measurements .
if the @xmath0 is preferably produced at the forward angles , the clas would possibly not detect the @xmath63 meson associated with the @xmath0 , because the most forward angle for the @xmath63 detection is about @xmath64 for the clas while most acceptance is of forward @xmath64 for the leps @xcite .
it may be a similar case for the contradiction between the clas and the saphir .
if this is true , it will be a suggestion on the angular distribution for the @xmath0 production .
in the experiments at higher energy the @xmath0 productions will be boosted to a much more forward direction and thus escape the coverage of the detectors in most high energy experiments .
this may be a possible explanation for the null results in most high energy experiments .
in the improved analysis by the diana @xcite , a very narrow intrinsic width for the @xmath0 was estimated as @xmath65 mev/@xmath26 .
this result passed the upper limits given by the belle @xcite , the e559 @xcite and the j - parc @xcite .
therefore there is no contradiction between these experiments , although opposite conclusions were reported for the existence of the @xmath0 . among all the experimental search for the @xmath0 pentaquark candidate ,
those with negative results have higher statistics and are consequently more reliable in usual , but it is hard to prove that all the observed peaks are fakes or fluctuations .
especially , the updated results by the leps @xcite , the diana @xcite and the svd @xcite can be claimed as strong evidence for the @xmath0 .
so the existence of the @xmath0 is still debatable .
for the other pentaquark candidates such as @xmath1 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 , the signals are much less reliable since none of them is confirmed in any other experiment .
we reviewed the experimental search for the pentaquark states during the last decade .
both the most widely studied candidate @xmath0 and the other candidates like @xmath1 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 as well as the non - strange pentaquark candidates are included .
since the first observation of the pentaquark - like baryon state @xmath0 , this field has aroused much interest , but even the existence of the pentaquark is debatable up to now . if the pentaquark really exists , it will open a new world of the qcd and hadron physics .
in particular , if the @xmath0 exists , its production mechanism is almost unknown and needs to be investigate , whether it is a pentaquark or not . besides it will imply the existence of a flavor multiplet .
if the pentaquark does not exist , the peaks observed in the experiments with positive results need a reasonable explanation . in addition
, the contradictions between the experiments should be examined in details .
this will improve the analysis method and raise the reliability of the result in future experiments .
in order to confirm or rule out the existence of the pentaquark , particularly the @xmath0 , comparisons between experiments in similar conditions are required . among the experiments , the updated results by the leps @xcite , the diana @xcite and the svd @xcite provide the best positive evidence for the @xmath0 .
therefore more experiments at medium energy may lead to a clear conclusion .
132ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1016/s0031 - 9163(64)92001 - 3 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.15.281 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.17.260 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/0550 - 3213(79)90036 - 1 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.15.267 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.20.748 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/s0375 - 9474(97)81460 - 1 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1007/s002180050406 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1142/s021773239900239x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/0370 - 2693(69)90266 - 4 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.91.012002 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.91.232003 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.69.114017 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2003.11.010 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2003.09.062 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2003.09.061 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2003.08.010 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2003.08.050 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.69.094029 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2003.09.050 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2004.02.016 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2003.07.067 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2004.02.004 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.69.117502 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.69.055203 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.91.232002 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2003.12.018 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop * * , ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.93.152001 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.70.074508 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.72.034505 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.71.034001 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop , ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.69.094011 [ *
* , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.70.097503 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.110.252001 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.110.252002 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1016/0550 - 3213(83)90063 - 9 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/0550 - 3213(84)90584 - 4 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/0550 - 3213(85)90409 - 2 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ , edited by ( ) link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2003.09.049 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/0375 - 9474(92)90647 - 3 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s100500050136 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/0370 - 2693(96)00597 - 7 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/s0370 - 1573(97)00089 - 6 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1134/1.1611587 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1134/1.1954823 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2004.01.079 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2003.08.019 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1134/1.1707127 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.nuclphysbps.2005.01.015 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2004.04.024 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2005.03.041 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2006.02.048 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2006.08.006 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.79.025210 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1134/s106377880701005x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1134/s1063778810070100 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop ( ) , @noop ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.91.252001 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2004.05.067 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.96.212001 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2007.04.023 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.92.032001 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.96.042001 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.74.032001 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.97.032001 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2006.07.013 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1140/epjc / s10052 - 006 - 0080-y [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.70.012004 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.95.042002 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2005.05.008 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.76.092004 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2004.08.021 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2007.08.005 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1140/epjc / s10052 - 006 - 0140 - 3 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2006.06.055 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/0954 - 3899/34/4/002 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.92.042003 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.nuclphysbps.2005.01.062 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.93.212003 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1140/epja / i2004 - 10062 - 4 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/0954 - 3899/30/8/090 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.70.111101 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.72.055201 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.77.045203 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.109.132002 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2005.10.077 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.85.035209 , 10.1103/physrevc.85.049901 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1140/epja / i2003 - 10029-y [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2007.01.041 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1143/ptps.168.90 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.100.252002 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1140/epja / i2011 - 11089 - 0 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/1674 - 1137/33/12/051 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.83.022201 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop ( ) , @noop * * , ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1134/s002136400818001x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.69.077501 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2004.02.029 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.70.094042 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1142/s0217751x06032101 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2005.02.082 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.97.102001 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop , ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.72.051101 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.75.055208 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2004.03.012 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1140/epjc / s2004 - 02042 - 9 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.73.091101 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.74.051101 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2005.07.023 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2005.02.075 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.85.015205 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.71.032004 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1140/epjc / s10052 - 007 - 0407 - 3 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2005.02.016 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.70.022201 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.75.032003 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2008.01.063 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1140/epjc / s2005 - 02281 - 2 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.95.152001 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.70.042202 [ * * , ( ) ] , | it has been ten years since the first report for a positive strangeness pentaquark - like baryon state .
however the existence of the pentaquark state is still controversial .
some contradictions between the experiments are unsolved . in this paper
we review the experimental search for the pentaquark candidates @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 in details .
we review the experiments with positive results and compare the experiments with similar conditions but opposite results . |
frequently it is the case in the study of real - world complex networks that we observe essentially a sample from a larger network .
there are many reasons why sampling in networks is often unavoidable and , in some cases , even desirable .
sampling , for example , has long been a necessary part of studying internet topology @xcite .
similarly , its role has been long - recognized in the context of biological networks , e.g. , protein - protein interaction @xcite , gene regulation @xcite and metabolic networks @xcite .
finally , in recent years , there has been intense interest in the use of sampling for monitoring online social media networks .
see @xcite , for example , for a representative list of articles in this latter domain . given a sample from a network , a fundamental statistical question is how the sampled network statistics be used to make inferences about the parameters of the underlying global network .
parameters of interest in the literature include ( but are by no means limited to ) degree distribution , density , diameter , clustering coefficient , and number of connected components . for seminal work in this direction , see @xcite . in this paper , we propose potential solutions to an estimation problem that appears to have received significantly less attention in the literature to date
the estimation of the degrees of individual sampled nodes .
degree is one of the most fundamental of network metrics , and is a basic notion of node - centrality .
deriving a good estimate of the node degree , in turn , can be helpful in estimating other global parameters , as many such parameters can be viewed as functions that include degree as an argument . while a number of methods are available to estimate the full degree distribution under network sampling ( e.g. , @xcite ) , little work appears to have been done on estimating the individual node degrees .
our work addresses this gap .
formally , our interest lies in estimation of the degree of a vertex , provided that vertex is selected in a sample of the underlying graph .
there are many sampling designs for graphs .
see ( * ? ? ?
* ch 5 ) for a review of the classical literature , and @xcite for a recent survey .
canonical examples include ego - centric sampling@xcite , snowball sampling , induced / incident subgraph sampling , link - tracing and random walk based methods@xcite . under certain sampling designs where one observes the true degree of the sampled node ( e.g. ego - centric and one - wave snowball sampling ) ,
degree estimation is unnecessary . in this paper
, we focus on _ induced subgraph sampling _ , which is structurally representative of a number of other sampling strategies@xcite .
formally , in induced subgraph sampling , a set of nodes is selected according to independent bernoulli(@xmath0 ) trials at each node .
then , the subgraph induced by the selected nodes , i.e. , the graph generated by selecting edges between selected nodes , is observed .
this method of sampling shares stochastic properties with incident subgraph sampling ( wherein the role of nodes and edges is reversed ) and with certain types of random walk sampling @xcite .
the problem of estimating degrees of sampled nodes has been given a formal statistical treatment in @xcite , for the specific case of traceroute sampling as a special case of the so - called _ species problem _ @xcite .
to the best of our knowledge , a similarly formal treatment has not been applied more generally for other , more canonical sampling strategies . however
, a similar problem would be estimating personal network size for a group of people in a survey . some prior works in this direction @xcite consider estimators obtained by scaling up the observed degree in the sampled network , in the spirit of what we term a method of moments estimator below . but
no specific graph sampling designs are discussed in these studies .
we focus on formulating the problem using the induced subgraph sampling design and exploit network information beyond sampled degree to propose estimators that are better than naive scale - up estimators .
key to our formulation is a risk theoretic framework used to derive our estimators of the node degrees , through minimizing frequentist or bayes risks .
this contribution is accompanied by a comparative analysis of our proposed estimators and naive scale - up estimators , both theoretical and empirical , in several network regimes .
we note that when sampling is coupled with false positive and false negative edges , e.g. , in certain biological networks , our methods are not immediately applicable .
sampling designs that result in the selection of a fraction of edges from the underlying global network ( induced and incident subgraph sampling , random walks etc . ) are our primary objects of study .
we use induced subgraph sampling as a rudimentary but representative model for this class and aim to simultaneously estimate the true degrees of all the observed nodes with a precision better than that obtained by trivial scale - up estimators with no network information used .
let us denote by @xmath1 a true underlying network , where @xmath2 .
this network is assumed static and , without loss of generality , undirected .
the true degree vector is @xmath3 .
the sampled network is denoted by @xmath4 where , again without loss of generality , we assume that @xmath5 . write the sampled degree vector as @xmath6 . throughout the paper , we assume that we have an induced subgraph sample , with ( known ) sampling proportion @xmath0 .
it is easy to see from the sampling scheme that @xmath7 .
therefore , the method of moments estimator ( mme ) for @xmath8 is @xmath9 .
thus , @xmath10 is a natural scale - up estimator of the degree sequence of the sampled nodes . in this section
, we propose a class of estimators that minimize the unweighted @xmath11-risk of the sampled degree vector and discuss their theoretical properties .
we aim to demonstrate , under several conditions , that the risk minimizers are superior to the regular scale - up estimators , the former taking into account the inherent relationships inside the network .
we note that although a maximum likelihood approach to estimation is perhaps intuitively appealing , a closed form derivation of the mle in this setting is probitive .
another option is to look at marginal likelihoods .
but the mle based on univariate marginal likelihoods are essentially equivalent to the mme for this sampling scheme .
we will frequently use the the first and second moments of the sampled degree vector in our estimation methods .
the following lemma will be useful .
[ lem : meancovariancedegree ] under induced subgraph sampling , the mean and covariance matrix of the observed degree vector are @xmath12 where the diagonals of @xmath13 are @xmath14 and the @xmath15-th off - diagonal is denoted by @xmath16 , which denotes the number of common neighbors of node @xmath17 and node @xmath18 in the network @xmath19 . adopting the standard definition of ( unweighted ) frequentist @xmath11 risk of an estimator @xmath20 of a parameter @xmath21 , i.e. , @xmath22 ,
the frequentist risks are calculated for a general class of estimators .
we also define @xmath23 , a _ restricted risk function _ assuming the sampled graph @xmath24 is restricted to some class @xmath25 .
our proposed candidates are the elements in the class of linear functions of the observed degree vector that minimize the risk or the restricted risk w.r.t . some class .
it is expected that the optimal estimator will be a function of the parameter and hence another ( naive ) estimator will need to be plugged in . our final estimate will then be a plug - in risk minimizer . here
we estimate the node degrees individually , assuming that the estimate for the @xmath26 node is of the form @xmath27 , where @xmath28 is a scalar and @xmath29 is the observed degree in the sample . since @xmath7 , where @xmath8 is the true degree of the @xmath26 node , @xmath30 differentiating w.r.t . @xmath28 and equating to 0 , we get the optimal @xmath31 . plugging in the mme of @xmath32
, we get the plug - in univariate risk minimizer @xmath33 taylor expanding the above formula ( during taylor expansions of functions of @xmath29 , we will assume that @xmath29 is concentrated around its mean , so that the taylor expanded approximation is close ) and taking expectation , we see that @xmath34 = \frac{1}{p } \mathbb{e}\left [ d^*_i\left(1 + \frac{1-p}{d^*_i}\right)^{-1 } \right ] \approx \frac{1}{p } \mathbb{e}\left [ d^*_i\left(1 - \frac{1-p}{d^*_i}\right ) \right ] = d^0_i - \frac{1-p}{p } \enskip .
$ ] + the above calculation suggests that an adjustment needs to be made to @xmath35 by bias - correction , so that its risk becomes comparable to that of @xmath36 . in fact
, we will show in proposition [ unirisk ] that our bias - corrected plug - in estimator has a lower risk than mme when the true degree is bigger than a lower bound , which can be expressed as a closed form function of the sampling proportion .
ultimately , our proposed univariate risk minimizer is given by @xmath37 note that the proposed estimator @xmath38 can be written as @xmath39 this is almost an additive adjustment to the multiplicative scale - up estimate .
we also have , @xmath40 .
+ from the above discussion , it is obvious to see that when @xmath36 overestimates @xmath41 , @xmath38 can not be any better than @xmath36 .
we first argue that this happens with small probability . to demonstrate this
, we use the erds - rnyi model . + for any node @xmath17 selected in induced subgraph sampling from an erds - rnyi model @xmath42 ( for @xmath43 and @xmath44 denoting the probability of edge formation such that @xmath45 . ) and for any @xmath46 , @xmath47\\ \mathbb{p}\left(\hat{d}^{\rm mme}_i < ( 1-\epsilon)d^0_i\right ) & \leq \exp\left[-np_e\left(1 - e^{-\frac{\epsilon^2p}{2}}\right)\right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath48 \\ & \hspace{-1.5cm}\leq \mathbb{e}_{d^0_i}\left[\exp\left(- \frac{\epsilon^2 p}{2+\epsilon } d^0_i\right)\right ] \intertext{in the above inequality , we use a version of chernoff inequality .
if $ x_1 , x_2 , \cdots , x_n$ are independent with $ 0\leq x_i\leq 1 $ for all $ i$ , $ x = \sum_i x_i$ and $ \mu = \mathbb{e}x$ , then $ $ \mathbb{p}\left[x > ( 1+\epsilon)\mu\right ] \leq \exp\left(-\frac{\epsilon^2}{2+\epsilon}\mu\right)$$ and $ $ \mathbb{p}\left[x < ( 1-\epsilon)\mu\right ] \leq \exp\left(-\frac{\epsilon^2}{2}\mu\right).$$ since $
d^0_i$ approximately follows a poisson$\left(np_e\right)$ , we have } \mathbb{e}_{d^0_i}\left[\exp\left(- \frac{\epsilon^2 p}{2+\epsilon } d^0_i\right)\right ] & = \psi\left(-\frac{\epsilon^2 p}{2+\epsilon}\right ) \\ & \hspace{-1cm}= \exp\left[-np_e\left(1 - e^{-\frac{\epsilon^2p}{2+\epsilon}}\right)\right ] \intertext{where $ \psi$ denotes the moment generating function of poisson distribution .
the other inequality follows similarly when the lower tail chernoff bound is used . }
\end{aligned}\ ] ] we extend the idea presented in the previous section to the multivariate case , in order to minimize the overall @xmath11 sum over all sampled nodes .
the rationale for this extension is to exploit the covariance structure we derived in lemma [ lem : meancovariancedegree ] in estimating the degree vector .
accordingly , we consider all estimates of the form @xmath49 , where @xmath50 is an @xmath51 matrix . using lemma [ lem : meancovariancedegree ] , we get the @xmath11 risk + @xmath52 . + the multivariate risk minimizer is defined as + @xmath53 . + differentiating the objective function w.r.t . @xmath50 and equating it to @xmath54 , we get + @xmath55 + plugging in the mme of @xmath56 and @xmath57 , we get the plug - in multivariate risk minimizer @xmath58 where @xmath59 denotes the number of common neighbors of node @xmath17 and node @xmath18 in the sample , and @xmath60 is given by a matrix whose diagonals are @xmath29 and whose off - diagonals are @xmath59 , @xmath61 . in this section ,
we propose a bayesian solution to our estimation problem , by putting a prior on the degree distribution .
the principal motivation behind this approach is the desire to incorporate additional information on global network structure , where the natural candidate in this context is the degree distribution . in case such
a subjective prior is not available , an estimate of the degree distribution may be used .
we propose and analyze estimators based on both known ( subjective ) and estimated degree distributions below .
first , let us assume that we know the degree distribution @xmath62 of the underlying network
. under the assumption that the true degree of node @xmath17 follows @xmath62 , and under induced subgraph sampling of @xmath63 , the conditional distribution of @xmath64 is @xmath65 .
then it can be easily shown that the bayes estimator under square error loss is @xmath66 if the true degree distribution is not known , then it needs to be estimated , for example using techniques described in or similar to @xcite .
let @xmath67 be a reasonable " estimator for @xmath62 .
then an empirical bayes estimator is given by @xmath68 generally speaking , if @xmath69 denotes the distribution of @xmath29 given @xmath70 , then this empirical bayes estimate can be expressed as @xmath71 these estimators take the form of a weighted mean , as expected for bayes estimates under quadratic loss .
the weights are functionals of both sampling design and the degree distribution . for the latter estimator ,
only the estimated degree distribution comes into play , and thus the proposed empirical bayes estimator incorporates the sampling and sampled network information .
in this section , we present results on the relative performance of our proposed estimators from a risk - theoretic perspective , and we discuss several conditions under which one outperforms the other .
all these estimates will be benchmarked against the regular scale - up estimate @xmath72 .
proofs may be found in the supplementary materials . in the first part of our risk analysis
, we look at the @xmath11 frequentist risk of our proposed univariate and multivariate estimators
. our main results in this section will compare the risk incurred by our proposed estimators to the scale up estimator and discuss conditions under which our proposed estimators perform better .
[ unirisk ] assuming @xmath73 , we have @xmath74 . in other words , the univariate risk minimizer @xmath75 will outperform the mme when the true degree @xmath8 is sufficiently large .
[ multirisk ] let us denote the class of all sampled graphs of size @xmath76 ( where @xmath77 for all @xmath17 , i.e. , there is no isolated node ) as @xmath78 .
also assume that there exists an @xmath79 such that @xmath80 are nonempty .
then we have @xmath81 over sampled graphs belonging to @xmath82 .
scrutiny of the conditions in proposition [ multirisk ] , along with definition of the set @xmath83 , reveals a general characterization of the graphs where the proposed multivariate estimator performs better .
it is to be noticed that @xmath84 shrinks @xmath85 by some factor .
the term on the right side of the inequality in the definition of @xmath86 provides a lower bound on the shrinkage factor and the term on the left decreases as the cardinality of @xmath87 increases , i.e. , the graph becomes less sparse .
hence , the proposed estimator can be expected to work better than the standard scale - up estimator under the assumption of sparsity of the sampled graph .
this will also be demonstrated in the simulation section .
the eigenvector condition imposes a geometric constraint on the sample degree - degree matrix @xmath60 .
what it essentially means is that the angle between the eigenvectors of @xmath88 and @xmath89 should be smaller than @xmath90 . or , in other words , by selecting an @xmath91 sufficiently small but positive , our class of sampled graphs are restricted where the associated matrix @xmath88 has eigenvectors at least @xmath92 angle away from any orthogonal direction to @xmath89 .
thus , our estimator performs better for sparse graph satisfying a mild geometric condition .
the performance of the bayes estimators is evaluated here under several conditions and network paradigms .
note that these estimators are compared to the regular scale - up estimator with respect to their frequentist risk functions .
we start with our estimator in its most general form and state conditions on the prior degree distribution that will ensure lower risk . from that , we assess its risk when the prior degree distribution is replaced with an appropriate estimate .
we also explicitly derive the bayes estimator for the erds - rnyi class of random graphs and state conditions under which the bayes estimator yields lower risk than the scale - up estimator .
[ suffrisk ] let @xmath93 be the true degree of sample node @xmath17 , and @xmath29 , the observed degree .
denote by @xmath94 the class of sampled graphs where the following two conditions hold : @xmath95 where @xmath96 .
then @xmath97 under induced subgraph sampling . the conditions ( [ suffrisk : cond1 ] ) and ( [ suffrisk : cond2 ] ) essentially constrain the tail behavior of the prior degree disbution .
the first condition ensures that the tail decays at a rate such that it is not too `` thick '' and the second condition ensures that it is not too `` thin '' . as @xmath8 becomes bigger , the rhs in condition ( [ suffrisk : cond1 ] ) becomes smaller and that is reminiscent of the sparsity property of the underlying graph , meaning that not a lot of nodes can have very high degree , an observation consistent with sparse graphs . on the other hand , the lhs in the condition ( [ suffrisk : cond2 ] )
can be interpreted as the mean of the tail probabilities weighted by the posterior distribution .
this has to be bounded away from zero in order for the bayes estimate to have lower risk than the mme . in real problems , where the true degree distribution is unknown ,
one either has to choose @xmath98 subjectively or use the data to come up with a reasonable estimate .
estimating @xmath98 for a general case is beyond the scope of this paper and will not be discussed here . for our analysis
, we will just assume that we have an estimate of the degree distribution at our disposal ( e.g. , @xcite ) , denoted by @xmath99 .
using @xmath99 will give us our proposed empirical bayes estimate @xmath100 , the behavior of which can be described as follows .
[ pluginapprox ] let @xmath67 be an estimate of @xmath62 such that @xmath101 then under assumption ( [ suffrisk : cond2 ] ) , with @xmath98 replaced by @xmath99 , we have @xmath102 it is easily seen that with the assumption , the upper bound in can be simplified to @xmath103 assuming a large network , the sum in the denominator can be approximated by @xmath104 .
then the upper bound is @xmath105 from the above discussion , it is evident that if @xmath106 , @xmath107 for all @xmath17 and hence their risk functions will also be close .
thus , using proposition [ suffrisk ] , it is expected that @xmath108 it is well known that the asymptotic degrees in erds - rnyi graph models follow a poisson distribution , under standard conditions . in this section ,
we study the effects of using a poisson prior degree distribution for large erds - rnyi graphs .
the goal is to demonstrate the efficacy of the bayesian approach compared to scale - up estimates as in the last section .
however , studying specific models like erds - rnyi will give us more insight about the performance of the proposed bayes estimate .
in this scenario , the prior @xmath62 is given by @xmath109 where @xmath110 is the prior mean .
for a large erds - rnyi graph with number of nodes @xmath111 and edge probability @xmath44 , @xmath112 .
we denote , by @xmath113 , the shifted poisson distribution on @xmath114 whose p.m.f .
is given by @xmath115 it is easy to check that with a @xmath116 prior on @xmath70 , the posterior distribution is @xmath117 .
hence the bayes estimate with respect to the quadratic loss function is @xmath118 [ erdosbayesrisk ] assuming @xmath119 the quadratic risk of the bayes estimator using a @xmath116 prior is smaller than that of the mme .
the above result shows that if the sampled node is such that its true degree belongs to a neighborhood around the mean of the underlying degree distribution , then the bayes estimator is uniformly better than the mme . in case
the underlying mean is unknown , it can easily be estimated from the sample .
( e.g. , for known @xmath111 , @xmath120 ) if @xmath121 is a consistent estimator of @xmath110 in the sense that @xmath122 when @xmath123 , @xmath124 and @xmath125 , then the empirical bayes estimator @xmath126 will converge in probability to the bayes estimator in the sense that @xmath127 .
hence , the result of prop .
( [ erdosbayesrisk ] ) is expected to hold .
this will also be demonstrated in the simulations .
for our simulation study , we look at two different regimes of network erds - rnyi random graphs and heavy tailed degree distributions . we compare four methods of estimation - the regular mme , univariate risk minimizer , multivariate risk minimizer and the bayes estimate . as priors in bayes estimation
, we use both exponentially decaying ( poisson ) and polynomially decaying degree distribution as priors . table [ ertable ]
records the euclidean distance between the true and estimated degree vectors across some combinations of graph size @xmath111 , edge strength @xmath44 and sampling proportion @xmath0 .
the errors are averaged over 50 different samples from each given graph @xmath63 . from the output ,
it is clear that the bayes estimators with true @xmath110 and estimated @xmath110 outperform other estimators by a very wide margin in terms of @xmath11 risk . also , our theoretical prediction in the discussion following proposition [ multirisk ] was that the multivariate risk minimizer ( mrm ) works better than the mme for sparse graphs .
this is experimentally verified in this simulation , since we see that the relative risk of mrm compared to mme decreases as the sparsity of the underlying graph increases , i.e. , as @xmath44 decreases .
the method with lowest total quadratic loss is shown in red for each condition .
we compared four methods of estimation in simulated scale free networks which follow a power law degree distribution .
as priors in bayes estimation , we compared the true polynomial prior and quadratic prior .
we computed the @xmath128 distances across some combinations of sparsity ( denoted by @xmath129 , given by the ratio of total edges to all possible edges ) , sampling proportion @xmath0 and heaviness of the tail of the degree distribution , controled by @xmath130 .
the results are shown in table [ sftable ] .
the bayes estimators or the multivariate risk minimizers work better than the other estimators .
one important thing to observe here is that for the most sparse graph , the bayes estimator with true prior works the best and as @xmath129 increases , multivariate risk minimizers work better than the rest , but there is hardly any improvement over mme . again , the method with lowest total quadratic loss is shown in red for each condition . [
table : sim1 ] [ table : sim2 ]
in february 2015 , the defense advanced research projects agency ( darpa ) , an agency of the u.s .
department of defense , announced the _ memex _
program in response to the use of the internet in human trafficking , especially chat forums , advertisements and job services sections .
darpa - funded research determined the trafficking industry spent $ 250 m to post more than 60 m advertisements over a two - year time frame@xcite .
indexing and cross - referencing the ads with the same contact number , similar address or zip codes help identify and track the illegal trafficking activities .
this leads to a massive background network structure where each node represents an advertisement and an edge between two nodes are created if they share certain features .
it is not unreasonable to expect that , in surveillance of networks like this , sampling may well arise , either by choice or by circumstance .
we mimic this situation by pretending that this underlying network generated by the _ memex _
program is unknown to us and sampling it using induced subgraph sampling .
the nodes associated with trafficking activities are flagged in the data .
there are 31,248 nodes , of which 12,387 are flagged and there are 10,200,838 edges .
our goal was to estimate the true degrees of flagged nodes that we saw in our sample .
we compared the @xmath11 distance of regular scale - up estimators , and our proposed univariate , multivariate and bayes estimators .
for the bayes estimator , a number of polynomial priors were taken into consideration with varying degree of decay , denoted by @xmath131 .
the results are shown in table [ humantraffic ] .
almost everything works better than the naive scale - up estimator in terms of total @xmath11 loss , although the relative improvement is more modest than in simulation .
[ humantraffic ]
in this paper , we addressed the problem of estimation of true degrees of sampled nodes from an unknown graph .
we proposed a class of estimators from a risk - theory perspective where the goal was to minimize the overall @xmath11 risk of the degree estimates for the sampled nodes .
we considered estimators that minimize both frequentist and bayes risk functions and compared the frequentist @xmath11 risks of our proposed estimator to the naive scale - up estimator .
the basic objective of proposing these estimators was to exploit the additional network information inherent in the sampled graph , beyond the observed degrees .
our theoretical analyses , simulation studies and real data show clear evidence of superior performance of our estimators compared to mme , especially when the graph is sparse and the sampling ratio is low , mimicking the real - world examples .
there are a number of ways our current work could be extended .
firstly , a theoretical analysis of the bayes estimators under priors for random graph models beyond erds - rnyi is desirable , although likely more involved .
secondly , although induced subgraph sampling serves as a representative structural model for a certain class of adaptive sampling designs , the specific details of the sufficiency conditions discussed in this paper can be expected to vary slightly with the other sampling designs ( e.g. , incident subgraph or random walk designs ) .
finally , the success of the bayesian method appears to rely heavily upon appropriate choice of prior distribution , as observed in our theoretical analysis and computational experiments .
it would be of interest to explore the performance of the empirical bayes estimate in conjunction with the nonparametric method of degree distribution estimation proposed in @xcite .
more generally , the method in @xcite can in principle be extended to estimate individual vertex degrees .
but the computational challenge of implementation and the corresponding risk analysis can be expected to be nontrivial .
d. killworth , c. mccarty , h. r. bernard , g.a .
shelley , and e.c .
estimation of seroprevalence , rape , and homelessness in the united states using a social network approach .
, 22(2):289308 , 1998 .
j. leskovec and c. faloutsos . sampling from large graphs . in _ proceedings of the 12th acm sigkdd international conference on knowledge discovery and data mining _ , kdd 06 , pages 631636 , new york , ny , usa , 2006 .
acm .
b. ribeiro and d. towsley . estimating and sampling graphs with multidimensional random walks . in _ proceedings of the 10th acm sigcomm conference on internet measurement _ , imc 10 , pages 390403 , new york , ny , usa , 2010 . | the need to produce accurate estimates of vertex degree in a large network , based on observation of a subnetwork , arises in a number of practical settings .
we study a formalized version of this problem , wherein the goal is , given a randomly sampled subnetwork from a large parent network , to estimate the actual degree of the sampled nodes . depending on the sampling scheme ,
trivial method of moments estimators ( mmes ) can be used . however , the mme is not expected , in general , to use all relevant network information . in this study
, we propose a handful of novel estimators derived from a risk - theoretic perspective , which make more sophisticated use of the information in the sampled network .
theoretical assessment of the new estimators characterizes under what conditions they can offer improvement over the mme , while numerical comparisons show that when such improvement obtains , it can be substantial .
illustration is provided on a human trafficking network . |
in a graph @xmath14 , an independent set @xmath15 is a subset of the vertices of @xmath0 such that no two vertices in @xmath15 are adjacent .
the independence number @xmath2 is the cardinality of a largest set of independent vertices and an independent set of size @xmath2 is called an @xmath16-set .
the maximum independent set problem is to find an independent set with the largest number of vertices in a given graph .
it is well - known that this problem is np - hard @xcite .
therefore , many attempts are made to find upper and lower bounds , or exact values of @xmath2 for special classes of graphs .
this paper is aimed toward studying this problem for the generalized petersen graphs . for each @xmath7 and @xmath8 @xmath17 , a generalized petersen graph @xmath18 , is defined by vertex set @xmath19 and edge set @xmath20 ; where @xmath21 and subscripts are reduced modulo @xmath7 .
an induced subgraph on @xmath22-vertices is called the inner subgraph , and an induced subgraph on @xmath23-vertices is called the outer cycle .
+ in addition , we call two vertices @xmath24 and @xmath25 as twin of each other and the edge between them as a spoke . in @xcite , coxeter introduced this class of graphs .
later watkins @xcite called these graphs `` generalized petersen graphs '' , @xmath18 , and conjectured that they admit a tait coloring , except @xmath26 .
this conjecture later was proved in @xcite . since
1969 this class of graphs has been studied widely .
recently vertex domination and minimum vertex cover of @xmath18 have been studied . for more details
see for instance @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and @xcite . a set @xmath27 of vertices of a graph @xmath28
is called a vertex cover of @xmath0 if every edge of @xmath0 has at least one endpoint in @xmath27 .
a vertex cover of a graph @xmath0 with the minimum possible cardinality is called a minimum vertex cover of @xmath0 and its size is denoted by @xmath29 . in @xcite and @xcite @xmath30 , has been studied . since for every simple graph @xmath0 , @xmath31 @xcite
, their results imply the following results for @xmath3 , and @xmath9 : * @xmath32 * for all @xmath33 , @xmath34 .
* for all @xmath35 , @xmath36 * if both @xmath7 and @xmath8 are odd , then @xmath37 . + also , if @xmath38 , then @xmath39 . * @xmath40 @xmath41 if and only if @xmath7 is even and @xmath8 is odd .
* for all even @xmath8 , we have * * if @xmath42 then @xmath43 . * * if @xmath44 then @xmath45 . * for all odd @xmath7 , we have @xmath46 , where @xmath47 .
recently , fox et al .
proved the following results in @xcite : * for all @xmath48 , @xmath49 * for any integer @xmath50 , we have that @xmath51 * if @xmath52 are integers with @xmath7 odd and @xmath8 even , then @xmath40 @xmath53 , where @xmath47 . * if @xmath52 are even , then @xmath40 @xmath54 , where @xmath47 .
notice that the problem of finding the size of a maximum independent set in the graph @xmath18 is trivial for even @xmath7 and odd @xmath8 , since @xmath18 is a bipartite graph . for odd @xmath7 and @xmath8 ,
@xmath18 is not bipartite but we can remove a set of @xmath55 edges from @xmath18 to obtain a bipartite graph .
thus in this case we have @xmath56 .
so , for odd @xmath8 , we have upper and lower bounds for @xmath40 that are at most @xmath55 away from @xmath7 .
in contrast , for even @xmath8 , @xmath18 has a lot of odd cycles .
in fact , the number of odd cycles in @xmath18 is at least as large as @xmath13 .
this observation shows that for even @xmath8 , the graph @xmath18 is far from being a bipartite graph and as we see in continuation , we need more complicated arguments for finding lower and upper bounds for @xmath40 compared to the case that @xmath8 is an odd number . this paper is organized as follows . in section @xmath57 , we provide an upper bound for @xmath40 for even @xmath58 . in section @xmath59 , we present some lower bounds when @xmath8 is even . in both section @xmath57 and section @xmath59 we compare our bounds with the previously existing bounds . some exact values for @xmath40
are given in section @xmath60 by applying results presented in sections @xmath57 and section @xmath59 .
finally , in section @xmath61 we prove behsaz - hatami - mahmoodian s conjecture for some cases by using known lower bounds .
we checked the conjecture with our table for @xmath11 , and it had no inconsistency .
in this section we present an upper bound for @xmath40 when @xmath62 is even and we will show that the presented upper bound is equal to @xmath40 in some cases . our upper bound is better than the upper bound given by behsaz et.al . in @xcite .
+ for @xmath63 , we call the set @xmath64 a @xmath65-segment and we denote it by @xmath66 . let @xmath67 $ ] be the subgraph of @xmath18 induced by @xmath66 . let @xmath68 be the set of all maximum independent sets of @xmath18 . for every @xmath69 we denote by @xmath70 the number of @xmath65-segments @xmath66 for which @xmath71 . + define @xmath72 . since @xmath68 is nonempty , @xmath73 is also nonempty .
let @xmath74 [ note ] for any @xmath75 , @xmath76 if and only if @xmath77 . [ type ] for any @xmath69 , we say @xmath66 is of type @xmath78 with respect to @xmath79 if @xmath80 , of type @xmath57 with respect to @xmath79 if @xmath81 , and of type @xmath59 with respect to @xmath79 if @xmath82 .
+ let @xmath83 .
for a given @xmath84 , we say @xmath66 is of special type @xmath57 with respect to @xmath79 , if @xmath85 and @xmath86 becomes an independent set for @xmath67 $ ] .
since @xmath67 $ ] has a perfect matching of spokes @xmath87 , @xmath88 . so every @xmath66 is one of the above types .
+ note that @xmath89 .
[ lemma type 1 ] if @xmath8 is an even number then @xmath90 ) = 2k$ ] and @xmath67 $ ] has a unique @xmath16-set shown in figure [ type 1 ] .
+ as a type @xmath78 segment.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] @xmath67 $ ] has a perfect matching @xmath91 .
so @xmath90 ) \leq
\frac{|v(g[i_t])|}{2 } = 2k.$ ] on the other hand , figure [ type 1 ] is an example of an independent set of @xmath67 $ ] of size @xmath65 .
so @xmath90)= 2k$ ] .
+ to show that @xmath67 $ ] has a unique @xmath16-set , let @xmath79 be an @xmath16-set of @xmath92)$ ] . since @xmath90)= 2k$ ] , @xmath93 and @xmath79 must contain precisely one vertex from each edge @xmath94 where @xmath95 .
notice that the set of @xmath23-vertices of @xmath92)$ ] induces a path of length @xmath65 .
therefore @xmath96 the set of @xmath22-vertices of @xmath92)$ ] induces a matching of size @xmath8 .
this means that @xmath97 these two observations show that any @xmath16-set @xmath79 of @xmath67 $ ] has @xmath8 vertices from @xmath23-vertices and @xmath8 other vertices from @xmath22-vertices of @xmath98).$ ] moreover , every such @xmath79 contains precisely one vertex from each edge @xmath99 where @xmath100 and @xmath101 where @xmath102 .
now , consider two cases : + case 1 : @xmath103 .
+ in this case , @xmath104 and @xmath105 are forced not to be in @xmath79 .
so @xmath106 is forced to be in @xmath79 .
then @xmath107 and @xmath108 are forced not to be in @xmath79 and this forces @xmath109 and @xmath110 to be in @xmath79 . since @xmath110 is in @xmath79 , @xmath111 .
therefore @xmath112 , so @xmath113 and thus @xmath114 so , we showed that if @xmath103 then @xmath115 too .
now , if we repeat the same argument for @xmath116 instead of @xmath117 , we can deduce that @xmath118 and by a simple induction , it follows that @xmath119 for any @xmath120 .
particularly , @xmath121 therefore @xmath122 this shows that @xmath123 .
hence @xmath124 and @xmath125 .
so @xmath126 but we already showed that @xmath109 is forced to be in @xmath79 .
this contradiction shows that there is no type @xmath78 @xmath66 for which @xmath127 + case 2 : @xmath128 .
+ in this case , similar to the argument in case 1 , each vertex is either forced to be in @xmath79 or it is forced not to be in @xmath79 .
so , there is a unique pattern for @xmath129 when @xmath130 .
since the pattern shown in figure [ type 1 ] is an instance of an independent set of size @xmath65 for @xmath67 $ ] , it is the unique pattern for such an independent set .
lemma [ lemma type 1 ] guarantees that there is a unique pattern for @xmath131 , if @xmath66 is of special type @xmath57 with respect to @xmath79 .
[ lemma uv ] for every @xmath69 , if @xmath132 then @xmath133 , and @xmath134 also , if @xmath135 is a special type @xmath57 segment with respect to @xmath79 then @xmath136 and @xmath137 .
if @xmath132 then @xmath80 . so by lemma [ lemma type 1 ] , there is a unique pattern for @xmath131 . based on this pattern , @xmath138 and @xmath139 .
therefore @xmath136 and @xmath137 , since @xmath79 is an independent set of vertices of @xmath18 .
a similar argument shows that @xmath140 and @xmath141 .
the proof of the second part of the lemma is similar . [
corollary 1 ] if @xmath132 then @xmath142 notice that if @xmath143 then for any edge @xmath144)$ ] either @xmath145 or @xmath146 . since @xmath132 , lemma [ lemma uv ] implies that @xmath136 and @xmath147 .
on the other hand , @xmath148)$ ] for @xmath149 .
thus @xmath150 [ maintheorem ] @xmath151 for any even number @xmath62 and any integer @xmath152 .
let @xmath153 .
we consider two cases .
+ case @xmath78 : @xmath154 .
+ in this case @xmath155 .
so @xmath156 for any @xmath157 .
if we add all of these @xmath7 inequalities we get : + @xmath158 on the other hand @xmath159 , since every element of @xmath160 is contained in precisely @xmath65 of the sets @xmath66 . thus : @xmath161 case @xmath57 : @xmath162 + in this case @xmath163 . similar to the inequality [ e :
1 ] we have : + @xmath164 so , to prove the theorem , it suffices to show that there exists @xmath165 such that @xmath166 .
+ if we can show that for any @xmath167 , there exists an @xmath168 so that @xmath169 , then it follows that @xmath166 .
+ on the contrary , suppose that there exists @xmath170 in such a way that in the sequence @xmath171 before we see an element of @xmath172 , we see an element of @xmath173 . without loss of generality
we can assume that @xmath174 by lemma [ lemma type 1 ] , @xmath175 is of the form depicted in figure [ type 11 ] .
+ as a type @xmath78 segment.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] since @xmath176 , by corollary [ corollary 1 ] , @xmath177 based on our assumption , @xmath178 in particular , @xmath179 . since @xmath180 , by lemma [ lemma uv ] we have @xmath181 . on the other hand ,
we know that @xmath160 must have one vertex from each edge @xmath182 where @xmath183 since @xmath184 , either @xmath185 or @xmath186 .
but notice that @xmath187 is adjacent to @xmath188 which is in @xmath160 , for @xmath189 .
thus , @xmath190 and @xmath185 must be in @xmath160 .
this means that @xmath191 .
now , define @xmath192 .
one can easily see that @xmath193 .
based on the choice of @xmath153 , @xmath194 .
therefore , there must be an index @xmath195 so that @xmath196 .
since @xmath160 and @xmath197 agree on every element except @xmath198 and @xmath199 , the only candidate for @xmath200 is @xmath201 .
so @xmath202 and @xmath203 .
moreover @xmath204 and @xmath205 . thus @xmath206 . by proposition
[ note ] , @xmath207 .
notice that if any of @xmath208 are of type @xmath209 with respect to @xmath197 , they are of type @xmath209 with respect to @xmath160 , as well .
so , in the sequence @xmath208 , any type @xmath59 segment with respect to @xmath197 appears after an element of type @xmath78 with respect to @xmath197 .
since @xmath202 by corollary [ corollary 1 ] , @xmath210 . then from our assumption @xmath211 .
+ this means that the same argument can be applied to @xmath197 and if we define @xmath212 , then @xmath213 . if we consecutively repeat this argument for @xmath214 where @xmath215 and @xmath216 , then we observe that @xmath217 and @xmath218 for @xmath219 , and none of @xmath220 are of type @xmath78 with respect to @xmath160 . also , @xmath221 for @xmath222 are of special type @xmath57 with respect to @xmath223 .
since @xmath223 and @xmath160 agree on the @xmath224 , then @xmath221 for @xmath222 are of special type @xmath57 with respect to @xmath160 . + in other words ,
if @xmath225 belongs to @xmath226 and the next element of @xmath226 appears before the first element of @xmath227 in the sequence @xmath228 then all of @xmath229 are special type @xmath57 with respect to @xmath160 .
in particular , @xmath230 is of special type @xmath57 with respect to @xmath160 . + as @xmath231 , by lemma [ lemma uv ] , @xmath232 and since @xmath233 and @xmath160 agree on the @xmath234 we conclude that @xmath235 . + now consider three cases : * @xmath236 : + since @xmath230 is of special type @xmath57 with respect to @xmath160 , by lemma [ lemma uv ] , we have @xmath237 .
this is a contradiction as we assumed @xmath180 and therefore @xmath238 .
* @xmath239 : + since @xmath180 , by lemma [ lemma uv ] , @xmath240 .
also we know that @xmath241 .
thus , @xmath242 is of type @xmath59 with respect to @xmath160 and none of @xmath243 are of type @xmath78 with respect to @xmath160 which is a contradiction .
* @xmath244 : + @xmath225 is of type @xmath78 with respect to @xmath160 and for every @xmath245 , @xmath221 is of special type @xmath57 with respect to @xmath160 . in particular
, @xmath230 is of special type @xmath57 with respect to @xmath160 , and therefore @xmath246 , ( see figure [ type 2 ] ) . on the other hand , @xmath247 as @xmath180 , and since @xmath248 , @xmath249 is adjacent to @xmath250 .
this is a contradiction .
so in all the cases , we get a contradiction which means , after any type @xmath78 segment @xmath251 , a type @xmath59 segment @xmath252 will appear before we see another type @xmath78 segment .
this means that @xmath253 and the theorem follows , as we argued earlier .
in this section we introduce some lower bounds for @xmath40 where @xmath8 is even and @xmath189 .
+ here we explain a construction for an independent set in @xmath18 for even numbers @xmath7 and @xmath8 .
it happens that for every even @xmath254 , our lower bound is equal to the actual value , using a computer program for finding the independence number in @xmath18 .
[ nk even ] if @xmath7 and @xmath8 are even and @xmath62 then : @xmath255 where @xmath200 is the remainder of @xmath7 modulo @xmath65 .
we partition the vertices of @xmath18 into @xmath256 @xmath65-segments and one @xmath200-segment .
since @xmath7 and @xmath8 are even numbers , @xmath200 is also an even number and it is straightforward to see that if we choose a subset of the form shown in figure [ type 2 ] , from each @xmath65-segment they form an independent set @xmath160 of size @xmath257 .
then we try to extend this independent set by adding more vertices from the remaining @xmath200-segment . without loss of generality
, we may assume that the @xmath200-segment consists of the vertices @xmath258 .
consider two cases : * @xmath259 : + in this case the set @xmath260 is an independent set of size @xmath261 . * @xmath262 : + in this case the set : + @xmath263 is an independent set of size @xmath264 as a special type @xmath57 segment.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] in the next theorem we establish a lower bound for @xmath12 for odd @xmath7 and even @xmath8 .
+ [ n odd k even ] if @xmath7 is odd and @xmath62 is even then we have : @xmath265 where @xmath200 is the remainder of @xmath7 modulo @xmath65 .
we construct an independent set for the graph @xmath18 .
similar to the proof of theorem [ nk even ] , first we partition the vertices of the graph into @xmath266 @xmath65-segments and a remaining segment of size @xmath200 . without loss of generality , we can assume that the last @xmath65-segment starts from the first spoke and the remaining segment starts from the @xmath267-st spoke and finishes at the @xmath268-th spoke .
we also label the @xmath65-segments with indices @xmath269 . from each of @xmath65-segments
@xmath270 , we choose @xmath271 vertices as shown in figure [ type 2 ] .
we also choose the following vertices from the last @xmath65-segment and the remaining @xmath200-segment : * @xmath272 : + @xmath273 * @xmath274 + @xmath275 * @xmath276 + @xmath277 one can easily check that in each case , the given set is an independent set of size specified in the theorem .
notice that the upper bound given in theorem [ maintheorem ] and the lower bound in theorem [ nk even ] , and theorem [ n odd k even ] are very close to each other for every fixed even @xmath189 .
more precisely , we have the following corollary : if @xmath278 is an even number then @xmath279 notice that our lower bounds are considerably better than the lower bounds obtained in @xcite and @xcite .
in this section , we will find the exact value of @xmath40 for some pairs of @xmath52 .
+ [ k=4 ] if @xmath280 , then : + @xmath281 @xmath282 this result is straight consequence of theorems [ maintheorem ] , [ nk even ] , and [ n odd k even ] .
notice that for @xmath283 and @xmath284 or @xmath285 , the upper bound and lower bound differ by @xmath78 .
in fact , for @xmath286 the exact of @xmath3 is the same as our lower bound as we checked by computer .
if @xmath278 is an even number and @xmath287 or @xmath288 then @xmath289 .
this assertion is trivial consequence of theorems [ maintheorem],[nk even ] and [ n odd k even ] . in fact
the upper bound and lower bounds we have for @xmath3 are identical in these cases .
[ conj 1 ] ( @xcite ) . for all @xmath7 , @xmath8
we have @xmath290 .
+ notice that , since @xmath291 , this conjecture is equivalent to @xmath292 .
the above conjecture is valid in the following cases : * @xmath293 .
* @xmath7 is even and @xmath8 is odd .
* @xmath52 are odd and @xmath294 .
* @xmath52 are even .
* @xmath7 is odd , @xmath8 is even and @xmath295 .
* this case is a straight consequence of ( i ) , ( ii ) , ( iii ) , proposition [ k=4 ] and ( viii ) . * in this case @xmath18 is a bipartite graph and @xmath296 .
* @xmath297 ( @xcite ) . for @xmath298
this lower bound is greater than @xmath299 .
* let @xmath300 where @xmath301 and @xmath302 .
we consider the following subcases : * * if @xmath259 and @xmath303 then by theorem [ nk even ] , @xmath304 for any @xmath305 . for @xmath306 conjecture holds based on the information provided in table @xmath78 . * * if @xmath307 and @xmath308 then by theorem [ nk even ] , @xmath309 for any @xmath310 . for @xmath311 , conjecture follows from @xmath312 . * * if @xmath262 and @xmath303 then by theorem [ nk even ] , @xmath313 for any @xmath314 . for @xmath315 conjecture holds based on the information provided in table @xmath78 .
* * if @xmath316 and @xmath308 then by theorem [ nk even ] , @xmath317 for any @xmath318 . for @xmath319 , conjecture follows from @xmath312 .
* similar to the previous part , let @xmath300 where @xmath301 and @xmath302 .
we consider the following subcases : * * if @xmath320 and @xmath303 then @xmath321 which is isomorphic to @xmath322 .
( for more information about isomorphic generalized petersen graphs see @xcite ) . * * if @xmath320 and @xmath323 then by theorem [ n odd k even ] , @xmath324 for every @xmath325 . * * if @xmath326 then @xmath327 has to be larger than @xmath78 .
in fact if @xmath326 and @xmath303 then @xmath328 . for @xmath326 and @xmath329 then by theorem [ n odd k even ] , @xmath330 for every @xmath331 .
( note that since @xmath7 is odd and @xmath8 is even , @xmath332 implies that @xmath333 ) . * * if @xmath334 then by theorem [ n odd k even ] , @xmath335 for @xmath336 . for @xmath337
then the assertion is concluded from part @xmath312 . if @xmath295 then @xmath338 , and behsaz - hatami - mahmoodian s conjecture holds .
in this section we will prove that the independence number of generalized petersen graphs with fixed @xmath8 can be found in linear time , @xmath13 .
this result is a special case of a deep theorem stating that the problem of finding the independence number of graphs with bounded treewidth can be solved in linear time of the number of vertices of the graph . in the continuation
we will show that for every fixed @xmath8 and any integer @xmath9 the treewidth of @xmath18 is bounded .
first , we need to formally define the concepts of tree decomposition and treewidth of a graph .
let @xmath14 be a graph .
a tree decomposition of @xmath0 is a pair @xmath339 , where @xmath340 is a family of subsets of @xmath341 , and @xmath342 is a tree whose nodes are the subsets @xmath343 , satisfying the following properties : * the union of all sets @xmath343 equals @xmath341 .
* for every edge @xmath344 in the graph , there is a subset @xmath343 that contains both @xmath22 and @xmath345 . *
if @xmath343 is on the path from @xmath346 to @xmath347 in @xmath342 then @xmath348 . in other words , for all vertices @xmath349 all nodes @xmath346 which contain @xmath22 induce a connected subtree of @xmath342 .
the width of @xmath350 is defined to be the size of the largest @xmath346 minus one .
the treewidth , @xmath351 , of the graph @xmath0 is defined to be the minimum width of all its tree decompositions .
the treewidth will be taken as a measure of how much a graph resembles a tree .
( @xcite ) [ alghorithm ] the problem of finding a maximum independent set of a graph @xmath0 with bounded treewidth , @xmath352 can be solved in @xmath353 by dynamic programming techniques , where @xmath7 is the number of vertices of graph . for more details
see for instance @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite . for any fixed @xmath8 ,
the problem of finding independence number of the graphs @xmath18 can be solved by an algorithm with running time @xmath13 . by theorem [ alghorithm ] , we only need to show that for a given number @xmath8 , the treewidth of @xmath18 is bounded .
consider the following tree decomposition of @xmath18 of width @xmath354 . without loss of generality we can only consider the case where @xmath355 .
let @xmath342 be the path of order @xmath356 and define @xmath357 as follows : + @xmath358 + @xmath359 + @xmath360 + @xmath361 + @xmath362 and so on .
+ notice that in each step we remove two elements and add two other elements .
therefore @xmath363 for all @xmath209 .
one can easily see that @xmath350 is a tree decomposition for @xmath18 where @xmath364 .
thus , @xmath365 and by theorem [ alghorithm ] , the proof is complete .
table @xmath78 : independence number of @xmath366 .
the authors would like to thank the referee for careful reading of this paper and very helpful comments . and
the authors like to thank professor e. s. mahmoodian for suggesting the problem and very useful comments .
we also thank nima aghdaei , and hadi moshaiedi for their computer program and algorithm to create presented table of @xmath3 .
hans l. bodlaender .
dynamic programming on graphs with bounded treewidth . in _
automata , languages and programming ( tampere , 1988 ) _ , volume 317 of _ lecture notes in comput .
_ , pages 105118 .
springer , berlin , 1988 . | determining the size of a maximum independent set of a graph @xmath0 , denoted by @xmath1 , is an np - hard problem .
therefore many attempts are made to find upper and lower bounds , or exact values of @xmath2 for special classes of graphs .
this paper is aimed toward studying this problem for the class of generalized petersen graphs .
we find new upper and lower bounds and some exact values for @xmath3 . with a computer program we have obtained exact values for each @xmath4 . in @xcite
it is conjectured that the size of the minimum vertex cover , @xmath5 , is less than or equal to @xmath6 , for all @xmath7 and @xmath8 with @xmath9 .
we prove this conjecture for some cases .
in particular , we show that if @xmath10 , the conjecture is valid .
we checked the conjecture with our table for @xmath11 and it had no inconsistency .
finally , we show that for every fixed @xmath8 , @xmath12 can be computed using an algorithm with running time @xmath13 .
* keywords * : generalized petersen graphs , independent set , tree decomposition |
macroscopic quantum systems such as superconductors and superfluids are the remarkable consequence of many of bosonic particles occupying the same lowest energy state , and thus forming a bose - einstein condensate ( bec ) .
the design of closely spaced two dimensional electron systems ( 2des ) which can be contacted independently is the foundation to create a bec of excitons in semiconductors @xcite . exposed to a strong perpendicular magnetic field @xmath1
, the density of states of each of the 2des will condense into a discrete set of sub - bands , the landau levels . the total number of occupied states is then parameterized by the filling factor @xmath2 . if the electron densities @xmath3 are tuned to be identical in both layers , the filling factors will simultaneously be at @xmath4 at a particular @xmath1 . governed by coulomb interactions
, the bilayer system can then be viewed as a bose condensate of interlayer quasi - excitons by coupling an electron from layer 1 to a vacant state from layer 2 and vice versa .
since these excitons have an infinite life time , their properties can be investigated via electrical transport experiments .
transport experiments in the counter - flow configuration @xcite , where constant currents of equal magnitude but opposite direction are imposed on the two layers have indeed shown that exclusively if @xmath5 ( denoted as total filling factor 1 , or simply @xmath6 ) , the hall and longitudinal voltages across both layers ( nearly ) vanish .
while this by itself can be interpreted as the result of a dissipationless flow of charge - neutral electron - hole pairs in one direction , interlayer tunneling experiments @xcite have shown an i / v characteristic that has an astonishing resemblance to the one of the josephson effect . however
, the bilayer at @xmath6 is only partially analogous to a josephson junction @xcite , and it is important to recognize the experiment as tunneling between two electron systems that _ only as a whole _ form the correlated state @xcite .
this fact might also explain why no true dc supercurrent at zero bias has been observed so far .
suitable bilayer samples are required to be weakly tunneling @xcite , however , they only possess a very small single electron tunnel splitting @xmath7 of up to approximately 100 @xmath8k . even though interlayer phase coherence is completely _ spontaneous _ only for @xmath9 , it has been demonstrated @xcite that single electron tunneling can co - exists with this correlated state which is still dominated by coulomb interactions .
our interlayer tunneling experiments indicate that the bose condensation strongly changes the nature of the tunneling process .
more specifically , we exploit a pure dc tunneling configuration which reveals the existence of critical tunneling currents @xmath0 .
these critical currents terminate the regime of interlayer phase coherence , i.e. , when the total current @xmath10 exceeds the threshold value of @xmath0 , the 4-terminal interlayer resistance abruptly increases by many orders of magnitude .
our data originate from three different samples from the same wafer .
the double quantum well structure consists of two 19 nm gaas quantum wells , separated by a 9.9 nm superlattice barrier composed of alternating layers of alas ( 1.70 nm ) and gaas ( 0.28 nm ) .
the quantum wells have an intrinsic electron density of about @xmath11 m@xmath12 and a low - temperature mobility which exceeds 40 m@xmath13/vs .
while sample a is a standard hall bar geometry with a length of 880 @xmath8 m and a width of 80 @xmath8 m , samples b and c are patterned into a quasi - corbino ring @xcite , both with an outer diameter of 860 @xmath8 m and a ring width of 270 @xmath8 m . a commonly used selective depletion technique @xcite was used to provide separate contacts to the layers .
the densities in the two layers are balanced with a front and back gate which cover the entire region of the structures including the edges .
the modulation of a tunable dc bias @xmath14 with a low amplitude ac sine wave @xmath15 which is applied between the two layers ( i.e. , the interlayer bias ) is a convenient and commonly used method to determine the differential conductance @xmath16 . while a @xmath17 counter - shifts the fermi energies of both systems , @xmath15 is used to induce an ac ( tunneling ) current which can be detected via a sensitive lock - in technique . in the zero magnetic field case ,
if both layers have identical densities and @xmath18 , the fermi energies of both layers align , and owing to momentum and energy conservation , electron tunneling becomes possible . under the application of a magnetic field , however , it generally requires a finite energy e@xmath14 to add / extract an electron to / from one of the correlated 2des @xcite .
this means that no peak in @xmath19 centered around @xmath14=0 is expected under application of a ( strong ) perpendicular magnetic field .
figure [ fig:1 ] shows the results of the common tunneling experiment as previously described .
the tunable dc bias was modulated with a small ( @xmath20v ) ac voltage .
the current was detected by measuring the voltage drop across a 10 k@xmath21 resistor connected towards common ground .
these measurements were performed on sample a ( hall bar ) at @xmath22 mk and @xmath6 with balanced carrier densities in the two layers leading to three different @xmath23 .
this ratio of the center - to - center distance @xmath24 between the layers ( here @xmath25 nm ) and the magnetic length @xmath26 characterizes the strength of the @xmath6 state due to coulomb interactions . for figure [ fig:1 ]
we use the common notation where we plot the 2-point ( 2pt ) differential conductance @xmath19 versus the 2pt voltage @xmath14 , i.e. , the curve illustrates the measured @xmath27 induced by the ac modulation of 7 @xmath8v versus the variable dc interlayer bias .
the peaks centering @xmath28 can be identified as the familiar enhanced tunneling anomaly @xcite of the @xmath6 state . from high to low values of @xmath29 , the full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) in these three cases is about 60 @xmath8v , 160 @xmath8v and 200 @xmath8v .
while an increase of the tunneling amplitude upon decreasing @xmath29 was to be expected based on earlier reports , it is yet remarkable that its fwhm appears to increase as well . as we will show next ,
the answer to this apparent inconsistency is hidden in the modality of a two - terminal tunneling experiment where the interlayer resistance becomes much smaller than other series resistances .
( dotted line ) , @xmath30 ( dashed line ) , @xmath31 ( solid line ) .
in addition to its amplitude , also the width increases with decreasing @xmath29 .
these data were produced on sample a at @xmath22 mk.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] using a sufficiently sensitive dc measurement setup , the tunneling experiment can be simplified by measuring the dc current directly .
in addition , with a separate pair of contacts , a 4-point ( 4pt ) setup is possible to probe the dc voltage that drops across the barrier as well .
figure [ fig:2 ] illustrates these 4pt measurements , performed again on sample a at @xmath6 for a single @xmath29 of 1.44 .
the current was again detected by measuring the voltage drop across a resistor connected towards the common ground .
the top panel thus illustrates this dc current as a function of the 2pt dc voltage .
consistent with the prior observation of an enhanced tunneling conductance at small bias voltages , the dc current displays a relatively steep slope around @xmath28 which abruptly terminates when the current exceeds values of approximately -1.5 na or + 1.25 na.v in figure [ fig:2 ] can not be directly compared to the results in figure [ fig:1 ] which are measured at a different value of @xmath29 .
in addition , we observed a hysteretic behavior which may lead to a smearing of the curves in ac modulated measurement . ]
the existence of such a critical current had already been predicted @xcite but had not been clearly demonstrated .
most strikingly , the 4pt measurements on the bottom panel reveal a plateau in the probed dc voltage close to zero which accompanies the region where the current flow is enhanced . .
clearly visible are critical currents below which the characteristic has a steeper slope .
bottom panel : 4pt voltage @xmath32 which was measured simultaneously versus @xmath33 .
a plateau exists around zero bias where the 4pt voltages is nearly zero .
the plateau terminates at exactly the same 2pt voltages where the critical currents occur .
the inset shows a schematics of the experiment with the source ( s ) and drain ( d ) contacts and the location of the voltage probes @xmath34 .
shaded contacts connect to the lower layer .
these data were produced on sample a at a @xmath29 of 1.44 and @xmath22 mk.,scaledwidth=85.0% ] we emphasize that the unexpected increase in width of the differential tunneling conductance curves in figure [ fig:1 ] is now explainable in terms of a strongly reduced 4pt dc voltage . in view of this reduction , which affects the 4pt ac modulation as well , the @xmath19 curves would rescale to a very narrow peak with a very high amplitude if plotted versus @xmath32 and with @xmath35 .
please note that at no other ( total ) filling factor is such a behavior observable , i.e. , the strong reduction of the 4pt interlayer voltages is a peculiarity of the @xmath6 state .
we associate the range in which @xmath32 is small with a state in which interlayer coherence is established .
its width apparently depends on the sum of all series resistances @xmath36 in the system , such as contact arms and the series resistance for the current measurement .
if @xmath36 is large compared to the 4pt interlayer resistance , the experiment is essentially performed by controlling the current so that the existence of critical currents can be resolved . in a voltage - controlled experiment on the other hand ,
critical currents are concealed in the limit of vanishing ( interlayer ) resistances . for a set of six different @xmath29=\{1.99 , 1.92 , 1.85 , 1.78 , 1.70 ,
1.44}. the mid panel shows the probed 4pt voltage @xmath32 which was not measured simultaneously , and the bottom panel illustrates the calculated 4pt interlayer resistance .
the enhanced noise around @xmath37 originates from the noise in detecting small voltages.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] figure [ fig:3 ] demonstrates how the tunneling process evolves upon reducing the ratio @xmath29 from high to low values , i.e. , upon reducing the electron densities in both layers simultaneously and adjusting the magnetic field .
these data were produced on sample b ( corbino geometry ) where the voltage @xmath33 was applied between the two outer circumferences of the upper and lower layer .
moving from high to low values of @xmath29 , plateaus in the 4pt voltage appear which progressively take on lower values .
at the same time the critical currents grow .
the resulting 4pt interlayer resistance has , at the lowest @xmath29 , a value of only about 200 ohms at @xmath38 mk .
once the critical current is exceeded , the 4pt interlayer resistance is nearly of the same magnitude for all @xmath29 , which suggests that the condensate is destroyed and the current is maintained by bare electron tunneling .
the observed asymmetry which is particularly pronounced in sample b for low @xmath29 is owing to a strong hysteresis .
the question of the lowest obtainable 4pt resistance and/or its accuracy is directly related to the question which factors influence the 4pt voltage .
in addition to a temperature - activated behavior , it is relevant where exactly the potential is probed ( see insets in figures [ fig:2 ] and [ fig:4 ] ) because residual resistances come into play .
more precisely , _ any _ current @xmath10 that crosses the boundary of a two - dimensional electron system under quantum hall conditions will produce a voltage difference across the contact of the order of the hall voltage h / e@xmath39 ( @xmath4025 @xmath8v at @xmath41 a ) .
since the sign of the hall voltage depends on the sign of the magnetic field @xmath1 , it should be possible to account for its influence by inverting the magnetic field . and indeed , the inversion from @xmath42 to @xmath43 also inverted the slope of @xmath32 around @xmath37 in figure [ fig:2 ] .
the mean value calculated from the curves at @xmath44 and @xmath45 , however , did not completely cancel out @xmath32 within the plateau region .
this might be caused by longitudinal resistance components , if the current flows through dissipative regions @xcite .
nevertheless , as we have shown , this ( residual ) voltage and the resulting 4pt interlayer resistance was a lot smaller for sample b ( corbino ) . for this sample , the voltage was probed in a `` longitudinal '' configuration , i.e. , the voltage was probed ( across the barrier ) at contacts that lie between the source and drain and at the same side of the current flow . for @xmath46 ( sample b ) .
only red dots are actual data points , the black dashed lines are used to guide the eye . the inset shows a simplified schematics of the experiment where the contacts to probe the voltage and the source and drain contacts are marked .
shaded contacts connect to the lower layer .
unused ohmic contacts are disregarded.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] figure [ fig:4 ] finally shows the current plotted versus the 4pt voltage for @xmath46 . in this representation
our data resemble earlier reports @xcite where however the maximal current was of order 20 pa , or about 1000 times smaller .
note that in @xcite the i / v characteristic was deduced from integrating the differential tunneling conductance data which may have masked the critical current behavior reported here . even though the sample characteristics differ only marginally ( qw / barrier / qw width in @xcite is 18 nm/9.9 nm/18 nm ) which yields a comparable value of @xmath7 , the effective single particle tunneling amplitude in our samples appears to be larger .
hence , we assume that the different magnitudes of the maximal currents can be attributed to a different bare interlayer tunneling which strongly influences the tunneling anomaly at @xmath6 @xcite . for reasons of completeness
, we would like to elaborate on an experimental detail .
generally , the application of an interlayer bias will imbalance the electron densities of both layers , while the total density @xmath47 remains constant .
this has the consequence that the regular quantum hall ( qh ) states will shift to lower / higher fields , owing to a higher / lower density in the respective single layer .
the @xmath6 qh state on the other hand depends only on @xmath48 and thus does not shift to a different magnetic field . using the shubnikov - de haas oscillations in transport experiments in the low field regime , we were able to adjust front and back gate voltages while sweeping the interlayer bias to keep the density in each of the two layers constant .
however , interlayer tunneling experiments did not significantly differ from unadjusted measurements .
the bias - induced imbalance for the electron bilayer system in question is @xmath49 for @xmath50=500 @xmath8v , but might become irrelevant as the ( effective ) 4pt interlayer bias nearly vanishes for @xmath51 . in a different experiment ,
sample c ( corbino ring ) was set up in a drag experiment as described in @xcite , where a voltage is applied across only one layer ( drive layer ) , while the other ( drag ) layer is kept as an open circuit . only at a total filling factor of one
has this been shown to produce a voltage drop of equal sign and magnitude across the adjacent drag layer . at the same time , the conductance through the drive layer vanishes , i.e. , the bulk is in a gapped state .
in this situation we applied a variable resistor @xmath52 between the inner and outer circumference of the drag layer as shown in the inset of figure [ fig:5 ] . for @xmath53
the system behaves as before .
however , upon decreasing @xmath52 from @xmath54 to @xmath55 ohms , a current begins to flow through the bridge connecting inner and outer circumference of the drag layer .
simultaneously , a current of equal magnitude in the circuit of the drive layer can be measured . in the light of the strongly reduced 4pt interlayer resistance we demonstrated with figure [ fig:2 ] through [ fig:4 ] ,
these results can be explained in terms of parallel - tunneling at both sample edges carried by quasiparticles @xcite . .
as soon as @xmath52 is sufficiently reduced , the drive current @xmath10 increases , even though the bulk is in a gapped state . meanwhile , a current @xmath56 with the same sign and magnitude through the load resistance can be measured .
the inset shows a schematics of the experiment in a pseudo-3d view .
bottom panel : 4pt drive voltage @xmath33 as a function of @xmath52 .
these data were produced on sample c at a @xmath57 and @xmath58 mk.,scaledwidth=90.0% ] the observables in any of these transport geometries are the currents and voltages _ in the leads _
@xcite , so we have no direct access to what is happening within the bulk
. the ground state of our bilayer system in the correlated regime can be described by the halperin ( 111 ) state @xcite , as the laughlin wave function describes the ground state of the fractional quantum hall effect ( fqhe ) . and like in the fqhe , it is convenient to introduce the _ quasiparticle _ concept
. these quasiparticles experience enhanced interlayer tunneling , just as the quasiparticle hamiltonian of a superconductor has pair creation and annihilation terms .
the quasiparticles in our system arise at the interface where the single particle electron current from the leads meets the correlated @xmath6 phase .
since for @xmath6 the bulk of the drive layer is in a gapped state , it prohibits any regular single electron current flow across the annulus .
however , in a process which is analogous to andreev reflection @xcite , the injection of a single electron leads to a condensate current , or an excited state from the condensate ground state , respectively . to put it simply , every incident single electron in the top layer excites an exciton in the bulk . to conserve total charge in both layers , or to counter for this sudden net flow of excitons in the bulk , respectively ,
an electron must exist into the leads in the bottom layer .
the bose condensate thus changes the single electrons into quasiparticles which are easily transferred .
this constant flow of quasiparticles is the process we would like to refer to as _ quasiparticle tunneling _ @xcite .
if the inner and outer circumference of the bottom layer are physically connected over a sufficiently small resistance @xmath52 , it offers a short cut path across the gapped bulk for reflected single electrons .
once having passed that bridge , each electron will by itself undergo the same process of triggering condensate currents and quasiparticle tunneling at the other edge .
while this model is able to account for our data , we can not definitively say whether this configuration really allows us to trigger such an excitonic current through the bulk of the @xmath6 qh state or not .
it is also possible that some still unknown ( tunneling ) process is taking place .
we have presented dc tunneling experiments on electron double layer systems at a total filling factor of one which clearly show the existence of critical tunneling currents @xmath0 .
when the total current @xmath10 exceeds the critical value , the 4pt interlayer resistance increases by many orders of magnitude .
the results can be explained in terms of quasiparticle tunneling which is possible due to the bose condensation .
these observations could have grave consequences for the interpretation of the @xmath6 qh state and the transport experiment performed within this regime .
this could be of particular relevance if the currents that are imposed in regular transport are smaller than @xmath0 .
we thank j. g. s. lok for the design of the corbino geometry and j. h. smet for giving us access to some of his equipment .
also , we would like to acknowledge the german ministry of research and education ( bmbf ) for its financial support and gratefully thank both allan h. macdonald and ady stern for discussions .
10 fertig h a 1989 _ phys .
b _ * 40 * 1087 macdonald a h and rezayi e h 1990 _ phys . rev .
b _ * 42 * 3224 tutuc e and shayegan m and huse d a 2004 _ phys . rev
. lett . _ * 93 * 036802 kellogg m and eisenstein j p and pfeiffer
l n and west k w 2004 _ phys .
lett . _ * 93 * 036801 champagne a r and eisenstein j p and pfeiffer l n and west k w 2008 _ phys .
lett . _ * 100 * 096801 spielman i b and kellogg m and eisenstein j p and pfeiffer l n and west k w 2004 _ phys .
b _ * 70 * 081303 spielman i b and eisenstein j p and pfeiffer l n and west k w 2001 _ phys . rev
. lett . _ * 87 * 036803 spielman i b and eisenstein j p and pfeiffer l n and west k w 2000 _ phys .
lett . _ * 84 * 5808 rossi e and nunez a s and macdonald a h 2005 _ phys .
_ * 95 * 266804 park k and darma s d 2006 _ phys . rev .
b _ * 74 * 035338 murphy s q and eisenstein j p and boebinger g s and pfeiffer
l n and west k w 1994 _ phys .
lett . _ * 72 * 728 tiemann l and lok j g s and dietsche w and von klitzing k and muraki k and schuh d and wegscheider w 2008 _ phys .
b _ * 77 * 033306 eisenstein j p and pfeiffer
l n and west k w 1990 _ appl .
lett . _ * 57 * 2324 rubel h and fischer a and dietsche w and von klitzing k and eberl k 1997 _ phys .
* 78 * 1763 eisenstein j p and pfeiffer l n and west k w 1992 _ phys .
lett . _ * 69 * 3804 fertig h a and murthy g 2005 _ phys . rev
. lett . _ * 95 * 156802 su j j and macdonald a h 2008 _ arxiv:0801.3694 _ , to be published macdonald a h , private communication .
halperin b i 1983 _ helv | we have investigated the tunneling properties of an electron double quantum well system where the lowest landau level of each quantum well is half filled .
this system is expected to be a bose condensate of excitons .
our four - terminal dc measurements reveal a nearly vanishing interlayer voltage and the existence of critical tunneling currents @xmath0 which depend on the strength of the condensate state . |
in recent years , renewable energy has gained much popularity and attention because of it s potential in economic and environmental advantages . some of the benefits include- high stainability , low carbon emission , reduction of environmental impact , saving fuel cost and so on .
other advantages include economical benefits to remote communities and supporting the microgrids during the operation in islanded mode .
although renewable energy , e.g. , wind and solar , offers huge benefits @xcite , their practical use is limited due to their intermittent nature which makes it very challenging to ensure a steady power supply in the grid @xcite . because of the variable nature of the renewable energy based power generation sources , transmission and distribution system operators need advanced monitoring and control .
wind power generation relies on wind speed which varies depending on location and time . for economic and stable operation of the wind power plant ,
accurate forecasting of wind power is critical .
there are two main wind power forecasting approaches , physical method and statistical method . in the first approach
, the physical system and power translation processes are modelled in detail . therefore , physical approaches not only need the information of historical wind speed data but also other information , i.e. , meteorological output , hub height of the turbine and physical modelling of power conversion process from wind speed are essential @xcite . on the other hand , in a statistical approach ,
wind power output is modelled as a time - series where the power output at any time instant depends on its previous observation values .
the physical approach provides good accuracy for long term forecasting but not so good for short term forecasting as it is computationally very demanding . on the contrary ,
statistical approaches are well suited for short therm forecasting . for short term wind power forecasting , different approaches are well studied @xcite . in a conventional statistical approach
, wind power output behaviour is modelled as a time - series .
autoregressive ( ar ) model has been used for wind energy forecasting in @xcite and autoregressive moving average ( arma ) model has been used in @xcite . the artificial neural network ( ann )
is also widely used @xcite . however , the ann based approaches has very slow convergence during the training phase @xcite . on the other hand ,
statistical regressive models are computationally very efficient and widely used for short term forecasting @xcite . in the statistical approaches ,
the forecasting accuracy is highly dependent on the estimated model of the wind power output behaviour .
therefore , it is important to identify the estimated model parameters accurately .
different methods are widely used to estimate the ar model parameters , such as , ordinary least squares ( ls ) approach , forward backward ( fb ) approach , geometric lattice ( gl ) approach and yule - walker ( yw ) approach , etc @xcite .
as the wind power output has variable characteristics , the error function obtained from the estimated model may have many local minima .
for short - term load forecasting , it has been shown that the particle swarm optimization ( pso ) , one of the major paradigms of the computational swarm intelligence , converges to the global optimal solution of a complex error surface and finds better solution compared with gradient search based stochastic time - series techniques @xcite .
previously , pso has been widely used in different applications of power system @xcite . in this work ,
a modified variant of pso based on constriction factor ( cf ) is employed to identify the ar parameters more accurately .
the proposed cf - pso based identified ar parameters have better error minimization profiles compared to the well - established ls , fb , gl and yw based approaches .
the organization of this paper is as follows- the formulation of basic pso and cf - pso is discussed in section [ psos ] .
autoregressive model order selection and parameter estimation methodology is described in section [ armodel ] .
the proposed ar parameter estimation method based on cf - pso is illustrated in section [ psomodel ] . in section [ rnd ] , results obtained from this experiment are given and compared with four standard techniques . finally , the paper concludes with some brief remarks in section [ secend ] .
pso is a multi - objective optimization technique which finds the global optimum solution by searching iteratively in a large space of candidate solutions .
the description of basic pso and cf - pso formulation is discussed in the following subsections : this meta - heuristic is initialized by generating random population which is referred as a swarm .
the dimension of the swarm depends on the problem size . in a swarm ,
each individual possible solution is represented as a ` particle ' . at each iteration
, positions and velocities of particles are updated depending on their individual and collective behavior .
generally , objective functions are formulated for solving minimization problems ; however , the duality principle can be used to search the maximum value of the objective function @xcite . at the first step of the optimization process , an _
n_-dimensional initial population ( swarm ) and control parameters are initialized .
each particle of a swarm is associated with the position vector and the velocity vector , which can be written as + velocity vector , @xmath0 $ ] and position vector , @xmath1 $ ] + where n represents the search space dimension . before going to the basic pso loop ,
the position and velocity of each particle is initialized .
generally , the initial position of the @xmath2 particle @xmath3 can be obtained from uniformly distributed random vector u ( @xmath4 ) , where @xmath5 and @xmath6 represents the lower and upper limits of the solution space respectively . during the optimization procedure ,
position of each particle is updated using ( [ peq ] ) @xmath7 where @xmath8 and @xmath9 .
+ at each iteration , new velocity for each particle is updated which drives the optimization process .
the new velocity of any particle is calculated based on its previous velocity , the particle s best known position and the swarm s best known position .
particle s best known position is it s location at which the best fitness value so far has been achieved by itself and swarm s best known position is the location at which the best fitness value so far has been achieved by any particle of the entire swarm @xcite .
the velocity equation drives the optimization process which is updated using ( [ veq ] ) @xmath10 in this equation , _ w _ is the inertia weight .
@xmath11 represents the ` self influence ' of each particle which quantifies the performance of each particle with it s previous performances .
the component @xmath12 represents the ` social cognition ' among different particles within a swarm and quantify the performance relative to other neighboring particles .
the learning co - efficients @xmath13 and @xmath14 represent the trade - off between the self influence part and the social cognition part of the particles @xcite .
the values of @xmath13 and @xmath14 are adopted from previous research and is typically set to 2 @xcite . in eqn ( [ veq ] ) , @xmath15 is particle s best known position and @xmath16 is swarm s best known position . in the solution loop of pso , the algorithm continues to run iteratively , until one of the following stopping conditions is satisfied @xcite . 1 .
number of iterations reach the maximum limit , e.g. , 100 iterations .
no improvement is observed over a number of iterations , e.g. , error less than @xmath17 = 0.001 to achieve better stability and convergent behavior of pso , a constriction factor has been introduced by clerc and kennedy in @xcite . the superiority of cf - pso over inertia - weight pso is discussed in @xcite .
basically , the search procedure of cf - pso is improved using the eigenvalue analysis and the system behavior can be controlled which ensures a convergent and efficient search procedure @xcite . to formulate cf - pso , ( [ veq ] )
is replaced by ( [ veqcons])-([kcons2])@xcite .
@xmath18 \label{veqcons}\ ] ] where @xmath19 and @xmath20 here the value of @xmath21 must be greater than 4 to ensure a stable and convergent behavior @xcite .
usually , the value of @xmath21 is set to 4.1 ( @xmath22 ) ; therefore , the value of _ k _ becomes 0.7298 @xcite .
boundary condition @xcite , which helps to keep the particles within allowable solution space , is also applied in this research as shown below : @xmath23 +
ar is a univariate time - series analysis model that is widely used for model estimation and forecasting . in an ar model
, the output variable has linear association with its own previous observations . for a sample period of @xmath24^t$ ] , a @xmath25-order ar model can be written following the expression below @xcite : @xmath26 where , @xmath27 are the lag parameters of the model , @xmath28 is the constant term , and @xmath29 is the white gaussian noise with zero mean . to select the minimal appropriate lag order @xmath25
, akaike information criteria is used following ( [ aiceq ] ) , where @xmath30 is the number of parameters in the ar model , @xmath31 is the effective number of observations , @xmath32 is the maximum likelihood of the estimate of the error covariance @xcite .
the best fitted model has the minimum aic value .
@xmath33 +
firstly , the structure of the ar model is selected based on ( [ areq ] ) for a predetermined order @xmath25 . after that
the model parameters are estimated using cf - pso . during the optimization loop
, the algorithm determines the optimal parameters by minimizing the residual sum of squares ( rss ) of the estimated model as shown in ( [ rsseq ] ) , where @xmath34 is the actual data that need to be predicted and @xmath35 is the estimated data .
@xmath36 the steps of cf - pso based ar parameter estimation are discussed below .
1 . initialize particle s position @xmath37 and velocity @xmath38 in an _
n_-dimensional search space . here ,
the dimension _
n _ represents the order @xmath25 of the ar model and each vector of the particle position indicates a potential solution .
2 . calculate the rss for each ` initial ' particle positions and determine the particle s best known position @xmath39 and swarm s best known position @xmath40 .
3 . update particle s position @xmath37 and velocity @xmath38 following ( [ peq ] ) and ( [ veq ] ) if necessary .
4 . calculate the rss with the updated velocity @xmath38 and position @xmath37 .
repeat ( 3 ) and ( 4 ) until the stopping criteria is satisfied , i.e. , there is not significant change in rss over a good number of iterations or the algorithm reaches it s maximum iteration limit .
here maximum iteration is considered 100 .
the proposed cf - pso based ar model parameter estimation algorithm is implemented on the practical wind power output data of the _ capital wind farm _ , obtained from the australian energy market operator @xcite .
the algorithm is implemented using matlab and standard ls , fb , gl and yw based approaches are evaluated using ` system identification toolbox ' @xcite . to compare the performance of the proposed method and four aforementioned well - established methods , following evaluation indices
are used : 1 . mean square error ( mse ) : @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the actual data and @xmath43 is the data from the estimated model .
2 . akaike s final prediction error ( fpe )
@xcite : @xmath44 where , @xmath45 is the number of parameters in the estimated model , @xmath46 is the number of values of the model and @xmath47 is the loss function . 3 .
normalized mean square error ( nmse ) @xcite : @xmath48 ^ 2\\ { \delta^2}=\frac{1}{n-1 } \sum_{i=1}^n[{y_i } - mean({y_i})]^2\\ \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath42 is the actual data and @xmath43 is the data from the estimated model .
the value of nmse varies between ` -inf ' to ` 1 ' .
while ` -inf ' indicates a bad fit , 1 represents the perfect fit of the data .
firstly , the appropriate lag order is determined . in order to do that the value of @xmath49 is varied from @xmath50 to @xmath51 and for each value of @xmath49
, the aic is calculated following the information criterion in ( [ aiceq ] ) .
once all aic value is known , @xmath49 is selected for that fitted ar(@xmath49 ) model which leads to the minimum aic value .
considering @xmath52 , in this analysis aic value is observed when @xmath53 for all four standard methods as shown in fig .
[ aiclbl ] .
now , the wind power output data ( first week of march 2012 with 5 minute interval ) of the ` capital wind farm ' is used to evaluate the performance of the five approaches including the cf - pso based ar model . for the proposed method ,
the results are documented considering the mean value of 30 individual runs .
the obtained results are summarized in the table .
[ case1results ] and the best results among all approaches are highlighted .
results presented in table . [ case1results ] shows that the proposed method outperforms the other approaches for this test case .
considering the error value ( mse and fpe ) of the ls approach as a base scenario , the error minimization performance ( emp ) of other approaches are evaluated following ( [ myindex ] ) , where @xmath54 is the mse or fpe of the ls method and @xmath55 is the corresponding mse or fpe of other approaches .
the positive value of emp indicates an improvement of error minimization performance over ls approach while negative value represents that the performance is worse than the ls approach .
@xmath56 in order to justify the performance , the proposed method is employed considering another data set , second week 5s interval data of the month march 2012 for capital wind farm .
results from this method is shown in table [ case1results2 ] . in this test case ,
the proposed cf - pso based ar model reduces the error indices most .
compared with ls , almost 40% reduction of error is achieved for this test data . moreover , the nmse for the standard ls , fb , gl and yw based approaches are around 96.7% while proposed method experiences 98.9% , as shown in table .
[ case1results2 ] .
as the value of nmse close to unity indicates the best performance , proposed method also shows it superiority for this test case .
.performance of ar parameter estimation considering the first week data of march 2012 [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] fig .
[ actest ] shows the actual wind output data and the estimated model data using the proposed method .
the convergence characteristics of the cf - pso based proposed algorithm is shown in fig .
[ cfpsolbl ] . from the figure , the algorithm convergence within 40 iterations . according to the results shown in table .
[ case1results ] and table .
[ case1results2 ] , the best improvement is observed considering the cf - pso based ar modelling among these five approaches for both of the test data sets .
the cf - pso based ar parameter estimation method finds a better solution compared to the gradient based methods due to its global search capabilities .
it is important to mention that these well - established gradient based methods may trap in local minima as referred by huang et al @xcite . on the other hand ,
cf - pso finds a global optimal solution . in our analysis
, we found that the performance of the cf - pso varied based on the wind data characteristics .
if wind data has a global minima that is very close to the local minima , the performance of the cf - pso is slightly improved compared with other algorithms ( as observed in table .
i ) . on the other hand ,
if the local minimum is far from the global minima value , significant improvement is observed using the cf - pso algorithm ( as observed in table .
in this paper , constriction factor based pso is employed to enhance the performance of the time - series autoregressive model .
the proposed algorithm is implemented to estimate the wind power output considering practical wind data . using the global search capable cf - pso based proposed ar model ,
the results obtained in this experiment show that the algorithm finds the solution very accurately and efficiently ( within 40 iterations ) . to justify the results obtained from the proposed method ,
four algorithms including the widely used least - square method and yule - walker method are employed for comparison .
experimental results conducted in this experiments show that the proposed method enhances the ar estimation model with better accuracy compared to other four well - established method . in this experiment ,
the exogenous input variables are not considered during the model estimation , which will be included in the future work .
since the proposed model enhances the performance of the autoregressive model by minimizing model estimation errors more effectively , in the future work the forecasting performance will also be explored in detail .
a. anwar and h. pota , `` optimum allocation and sizing of dg unit for efficiency enhancement of distribution system , '' in _ ieee international power engineering and optimization conference ( peoco ) _ , jun .
p. eriksen , t. ackermann , h. abildgaard , p. smith , w. winter , and j. rodriguez garcia , `` system operation with high wind penetration , '' _ ieee power and energy magazine _
, vol . 3 , no . 6 ,
6574 , 2005 . a. anwar and h. pota , `` loss reduction of power distribution network using optimum size and location of distributed generation , '' in _
21st australasian universities power engineering conference ( aupec ) _ , sept .
2011 , pp . 16 . c. lei and l. ran , `` short - term wind speed forecasting model for wind farm based on wavelet decomposition , '' in _ third international conference on electric utility deregulation and restructuring and power technologies _ , 2008 .
m. lei , l. shiyan , j. chuanwen , l. hongling , and z. yan , `` a review on the forecasting of wind speed and generated power , '' _ renewable and sustainable energy reviews _ , vol . 13 , no . 4 , pp . 915
920 , 2009 .
d. hill , d. mcmillan , k. r. w. bell , and d. infield , `` application of auto - regressive models to u.k .
wind speed data for power system impact studies , '' _ ieee transactions on sustainable energy _ , vol . 3 , no . 1 , pp .
134141 , 2012 .
p. poggi , m. muselli , g. notton , c. cristofari , and a. louche , `` forecasting and simulating wind speed in corsica by using an autoregressive model , '' _ energy conversion and management _ , vol .
44 , no . 20 , pp .
3177 3196 , 2003 .
g. venayagamoorthy , k. rohrig , and i. erlich , `` one step ahead : short - term wind power forecasting and intelligent predictive control based on data analytics , '' _ ieee power and energy magazine _ , vol . 10 , no . 5 , pp .
7078 , 2012 .
k. methaprayoon , c. yingvivatanapong , w .- j .
lee , and j. liao , `` an integration of ann wind power estimation into unit commitment considering the forecasting uncertainty , '' _ ieee transactions on industry applications _ , vol .
43 , no . 6 , pp .
14411448 , 2007 .
huang , c .- j .
huang , and m .- l .
wang , `` a particle swarm optimization to identifying the armax model for short - term load forecasting , '' _ ieee transactions on power systems _ , vol .
20 , no . 2 ,
pp . 11261133 , 2005 .
m. karen , v. ramos , and t. razafindralambo , `` using efficiently autoregressive estimation in wireless sensor networks , '' in _ international conference on computer , information , and telecommunication systems ( cits ) _ , 2013 . y. del valle , g. venayagamoorthy , s. mohagheghi , j .- c .
hernandez , and r. harley , `` particle swarm optimization : basic concepts , variants and applications in power systems , '' _ ieee transactions on evolutionary computation _
12 , no . 2 ,
pp . 171195 , 2008 .
r. eberhart and y. shi , `` comparing inertia weights and constriction factors in particle swarm optimization , '' in _ proceedings of the 2000 congress on evolutionary computation _ , vol . 1 , 2000 , pp . 8488
. h. zeineldin , e. el - saadany , m. salama , a. alaboudy , and w. woon , `` optimal sizing of thyristor - controlled impedance for smart grids with multiple configurations , '' _ ieee transactions on smart grid _ , vol . 2 , no . 3 , pp . 528537 ,
2011 .
m. clerc and j. kennedy , `` the particle swarm - explosion , stability , and convergence in a multidimensional complex space , '' _ ieee transactions on evolutionary computation _ , vol .
6 , no . 1 ,
5873 , feb 2002 .
j. vlachogiannis and k. lee , `` a comparative study on particle swarm optimization for optimal steady - state performance of power systems , '' _ ieee transactions on power systems _ , vol .
21 , no . 4 ,
17181728 , nov .
r. a. krohling and l. dos santos coelho , `` coevolutionary particle swarm optimization using gaussian distribution for solving constrained optimization problems , '' _ ieee transactions on systems , man , and cybernetics , part b : cybernetics _ , vol . 36 , no . 6 , pp .
14071416 , dec . 2006 .
j. heo , k. lee , and r. garduno - ramirez , `` multiobjective control of power plants using particle swarm optimization techniques , '' _ ieee transactions on energy conversion _
21 , no . 2 ,
pp . 552561 , june 2006 . | accurate forecasting is important for cost - effective and efficient monitoring and control of the renewable energy based power generation .
wind based power is one of the most difficult energy to predict accurately , due to the widely varying and unpredictable nature of wind energy .
although autoregressive ( ar ) techniques have been widely used to create wind power models , they have shown limited accuracy in forecasting , as well as difficulty in determining the correct parameters for an optimized ar model . in this paper , constriction factor particle swarm optimization ( cf - pso ) is employed to optimally determine the parameters of an autoregressive ( ar ) model for accurate prediction of the wind power output behaviour .
appropriate lag order of the proposed model is selected based on akaike information criterion .
the performance of the proposed pso based ar model is compared with four well - established approaches ; forward - backward approach , geometric lattice approach , least - squares approach and yule - walker approach , that are widely used for error minimization of the ar model . to validate the proposed approach , real - life wind power data of _
capital wind farm _ was obtained from australian energy market operator . experimental evaluation based on a number of different datasets
demonstrate that the performance of the ar model is significantly improved compared with benchmark methods
. constriction factor particle swarm optimization ( cf - pso ) , ar model , wind power prediction |
in this paper we present a novel algorithm to parallelize the direct summation method for astrophysical @xmath1-body problems , either with and without the individual timestep algorithm .
the proposed algorithm works also with the ahmad - cohen neighbor scheme @xcite , or with grape special - purpose computers for @xmath1-body problems @xcite .
our algorithm is designed to offer better scaling of the communication - computation ratio on distributed - memory multicomputers such as beowulf pc clusters @xcite compared to traditional algorithms .
this paper will be organized as follows . in section 2
we describe the traditional algorithms to parallelize direct summation method on distributed - memory parallel computers , and the scaling of communication time and computational time as functions of the number of particles @xmath1 and number of processor @xmath2 . it will be shown that for previously known algorithms the calculation time scales as @xmath10 , while communication time is @xmath11 .
thus , even with infinite number of processors the total time per timestep is still @xmath12 , and we can not use more than @xmath12 processors without losing efficiency .
@xmath12 sounds large , but the coefficient is rather small .
thus , it was not practical to use more than 10 processors for systems with a few thousand particles , on typical beowulf clusters . in section 3
we describe the basic idea of our new algorithm .
it will be shown that in this algorithm the communication time is @xmath13 .
thus , we can use @xmath0 processors without losing efficiency .
this implies a large gain in speed for relatively small number of particles such as a few thousands . we also briefly discuss the relation between our new algorithm and the hyper - systolic algorithm @xcite . in short , though the ideas behind the two algorithms are very different , the actual communication patterns are quite similar , and therefore the performance is also similar for the two algorithms .
our algorithm shows a better scaling and also is much easier to extend to individual timestep and ahmad - cohen schemes . in section 4
we discuss the combination of our proposed algorithm and individual timestep algorithm and the ahmad - cohen scheme . in section 5
, we present examples of estimated performance . in section 6 we discuss the combination of our algorithm with grape hardwares . in section 7
we sum up .
the parallelization of the direct method has been regarded simple and straightforward [ see , for example , @xcite ] . however , it is only so if @xmath14 and if we use simple shared - timestep method . in this section ,
we first discuss the communication - calculation ratio of previously known algorithms for the shared timestep method , and then those for individual timestep algorithm with and without the ahmad - cohen scheme .
most of the textbooks and papers discuss the ring algorithm .
suppose we calculate the force on @xmath1 particles using @xmath2 processors .
we connect the processors in a one dimensional ring , and distribute @xmath1 particles so that each processor has @xmath15 particles(figure [ fig : ring ] ) . here and hereafter
, we assume that @xmath1 is integer multiple of @xmath2 , to simplify the discussion .
the ring algorithm calculates the forces on @xmath1 particles in the following steps . 1 .
each processor calculates the interactions between @xmath15 particles within it .
calculation cost of this step is @xmath16 , where @xmath17 is the time to calculate interaction between one pair of particles .
each processor sends all of its particles to the same direction .
here we call that direction `` right '' .
thus all processors sends its particles to their right neighbors .
the communication cost is @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the time to send one particle to the neighboring processor and @xmath20 is the startup time for communication .
each processor accumulates the force from particles they received to its own particles .
calculation cost is @xmath21 .
if force from all particles is accumulated , go to step 5 .
each processor then sends the particles it received in the previous step to its right neighbor , and goes back to previous step .
force calculation completed .
= 8 cm the time for actual calculation is given by @xmath22 and the communication time @xmath23 the total time per one timestep of this algorithm is @xmath24 here , we neglect small correction factors of order @xmath25
. for fixed number of particles , the calculation cost ( first term in equation [ eq : tring ] ) scales as @xmath26 while communication cost _ increases_. therefore , for large @xmath2 we see the decrease in the efficiency .
here we define efficiency as @xmath27 which reduces to @xmath28 thus , to achieve the efficiency better than 50% , the number of processor @xmath2 must be smaller than @xmath29 equation ( [ eq : phalfring ] ) can be simplified in the two limiting cases @xmath30 in most of distributed - memory multicomputers , @xmath31 .
for example , with a 1 gflops processor , we have @xmath32 . if this processor is connected to other processor with the communication link of the effective speed of 10mb / s , @xmath33 .
the value of @xmath20 varies depending on both networking hardware and software .
table 1 gives the order - of - magnitude values for these coefficients for several platforms .
.time coefficients in seconds [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] even so , the number of processors we can use with this 2d algorithm is significantly larger than that for 1d ring , for any value of @xmath1 .
if @xmath34 , we can use @xmath0 processors .
even if @xmath35 , we can still use @xmath36 processors . in this 2d ring algorithm , the @xmath37 term in the communication cost limits the total performance .
we can reduce this term by using the extension of the copy algorithm to 2d .
= 8 cm instead of using the ring algorithm in the first stage , processors @xmath38 broadcast their data to all other processors in the same row . after this broadcast processor @xmath39
has both group @xmath40 and group @xmath41 .
then each processor calculates the force on particles they received ( group @xmath40 ) from particles they originally have ( group @xmath41 ) . in this scheme ,
the communication cost is reduced to @xmath42 if the network switch supports the broadcast .
if the network does not support the broadcast , the cost varies between @xmath43 for the case of a ring network and @xmath44 for a full crossbar . in the second stage ,
summation is now taken over the processors in the same row . here ,
result for row @xmath40 must be obtained on processor @xmath38 , which then broadcasts the forces to all processors in the same column .
after this broadcast , all processors have the forces on all particles in them .
they can then use this forces to integrate the orbits of particles . in this algorithm , the time integration calculation
is duplicated over @xmath45 processors in the same column , but in most cases this does not matter .
one alternative is that processor @xmath38 performs the time integration and broadcasts the updated data of particles to other processor in the same column .
yet another possibility is to let each of @xmath45 processor to integrate @xmath46 particles , which each of them then broadcasts within the column .
which approach is the best depends on the ratio between calculation speed , communication speed and communication startup overhead .
the total time per one timestep of this algorithm is @xmath47 for the number of processors @xmath48 for which the efficiency is 50% , we have a cubic equation .
for the two limiting cases , the solution is given as @xmath49 & ( $ n > n_{\rm c,2dbcast}$ ) , } \label{eq : p2dbcast}\ ] ] where @xmath50 is defined as @xmath51 the critical value of @xmath1 , @xmath50 , is larger than that for the 2d ring version of the algorithm .
this is because we reduced the @xmath52 term in the communication cost to @xmath53 . more importantly , even for @xmath54
, @xmath55 is only logarithmically smaller than @xmath0 .
thus , with this broadcast version of the algorithm we can really use @xmath0 processors and still achieve high efficiency . now the relation between our algorithm and the hyper - systolic algorithm @xcite must be obvious .
the `` regular bases '' version of the hyper - systolic algorithm applied to @xmath56 processors works in the essentially the same way as the ring version of our algorithm works , though in order to derive our algorithm we do not need to use any complex concepts like @xmath57-range problem or additive number theory . to put things in a slightly different way ,
the hyper - systolic algorithm is a complex way to reconstruct combination of rowwize ring and columwize summation on a 2d network by a sequence of shift operations in 1-d ring network .
thus , as far as the @xmath58 term is small , our algorithm and the hyper - systolic algorithm show the same scaling .
however , since @xmath58 term would almost always limit the scaling , the broadcast version of our algorithm is almost always better than the hyper - systolic algorithm .
in addition , our algorithm is by far easier to understand and implement .
this simplicity of our algorithm makes it possible to extend our algorithm to the individual timestep scheme and even to the ahmad - cohen scheme , which will be discussed in the following sections .
if we use the broadcast version as the base , the extension to the individual timestep method is trivial . instead of broadcasting all particles in the first stage
, we broadcast only the particles in the current block . in the following steps
, we always send only data related with the particles in the current block .
everything else is the same as in the case of the shared timestep algorithm . using the same assumption of @xmath59 , we have @xmath60 and @xmath61 where @xmath62 is now given by the following implicit equation @xmath63 for the example values in table 1 , the value of @xmath62 is fairly small .
so we can use only @xmath64 processors .
however , this is still much larger than the number of processors that can be used with 1d implementation of the individual timestep algorithm .
the same load - balance problem as we have discussed in the case of the copy algorithm occurs with this method .
we need some load - balancing strategy to actually use this method .
the difference from the individual timestep scheme is that the neighbor list is created / used to calculate the forces .
the neighbor list for forces from particles in group @xmath41 to particles in group @xmath40 is created , stored and used only by processor @xmath39 .
therefore , there is no increase in the communication cost , except for the summation of the number of neighbors . the total calculation time and the 50% efficiency processor count
are given by : @xmath65 and @xmath66 where @xmath67 is now given by the following implicit equation @xmath68 note that , in this case , whether or not @xmath69 makes very small difference for the number of processors , since the difference is only of the order of @xmath70 .
thus , practically we can say that we can use @xmath71 processors with the 2d version of the ahmad - cohen scheme .
in this section , we present the theoretical comparison of the proposed algorithm and the traditional one - dimensional algorithm .
first we show the result for the case of myrinet - like fast network .
figures [ fig : n3 ] to [ fig : n5 ] show the efficiencies for three different values of @xmath1 as the function of the number of processors @xmath2 .
it is clear that 2d algorithms allow us to use much larger number of processors compared to their 1d counterparts .
the gain is larger for larger @xmath1 , but becomes smaller as we use more advanced algorithms .
the gain for individual timestep is smaller than that for shared timestep , and that for the ahmad - cohen scheme is even smaller .
even so , the gain in the processor count is more than a factor of 5 , for the case of the ahmad - cohen scheme and @xmath72 .
we believe this is quite a large gain in the parallel efficiency .
= 8 cm = 8 cm = 8 cm figure [ fig : n5fe ] shows the efficiencies for the case of the fast ethernet . with the 2d algorithm we can use more than 500 processors even with ahmad cohen scheme , for @xmath73 .
pc clusters with inexpensive networks seem to be very attractive platforms to implement parallel version of the ahmad - cohen scheme .
the only thing grape does is to greatly reduce the value of @xmath17 .
thus , the same 2d network of processors each with one grape processor works fine , if the cost of the frontend is less than that of a grape processor .
grape-6 achieves essentially the same effect as this 2d processor grid , but using only @xmath45 hosts and @xmath56 grape processors connected with a rather elaborate multistage networks . in hindsight , such an elaborate network is unnecessary , if the fast network is available for a low cost . from the point of view of the scaling relations , what a grape hardware changes is simply @xmath17 .
if we attach a 1tflops grape hardware to a 1 gflops host , we reduce @xmath17 by a factor of @xmath74 .
this means that the limiting factor for the number of processors is almost always @xmath19 and not @xmath20 .
thus , for a parallel grape system , high - throughput , high - latency network such as gigabit ethernet is a practical choice .
figures [ fig : n5g6 ] and [ fig : n6g6 ] shows the efficiencies for grape-6 system .
since @xmath17 is much smaller , the number of processors we can use becomes much smaller .
of course , in the case of 1d algorithms , the actual speed we can achieve does not depend on @xmath17 , since the total speed is @xmath75 and @xmath55 is proportional to @xmath17 .
figure [ fig : n6g6 ] indicates that we can achieve the speed of multiple petaflops with currently available technology , by configuring several thousand grape-6 boards into a 2d network .
= 8 cm = 8 cm
we described a new two - dimensional algorithm to implement the direct summation method on distributed - memory parallel computers .
the basic idea of the new algorithm is to organize processors to @xmath76 2d network , and let the data be shared both rowwize and columnwize . in this way , we can reduce the communication cost from @xmath12 of the previously know algorithms to @xmath77 . for the case of the shared timestep algorithm
, the new algorithm behaves in essentially the same as the `` regular bases '' version of the hyper - systolic algorithm does .
however , with the broadcast version of our algorithm the communication overhead is reduced , which resulted in the better scaling . also , our algorithm is much simpler , which helped us to extend our algorithm to individual timestep and the ahmad - cohen scheme , as well as combination with grape hardwares . for all cases , compared to the previously known algorithm
, the number of processors we can use without losing efficiency is almost _
squared_. this is a quite large improvement in the efficiency of a parallel algorithm .
usually , a paper which proposes a new parallel algorithm should offer the verification of the concept , by means of the timing measurement of actual implementation . in this paper
we omit this verification , because we believe it s important to let those who working on hyper - systolic algorithms be aware of simpler alternatives . in this paper
, we assumed a network with full connectivity .
this assumption is okay with small pc clusters , but not true on large mpps . in this case ,
parallel efficiency of 1d algorithm is significantly reduced , and relative gain of 2d algorithm would become much larger .
i thank rainer spurzem and yoko funato for valuable discussions .
this work is supported in part by the research for the future program of japan society for the promotion of science ( jsps - rftp97p01102 ) . | we present a novel , highly efficient algorithm to parallelize @xmath0direct summation method for @xmath1-body problems with individual timesteps on distributed - memory parallel machines such as beowulf clusters .
previously known algorithms , in which all processors have complete copies of the @xmath1-body system , has the serious problem that the communication - computation ratio increases as we increase the number of processors , since the communication cost is independent of the number of processors . in the new algorithm ,
@xmath2 processors are organized as a @xmath3 two - dimensional array .
each processor has @xmath4 particles , but the data are distributed in such a way that complete system is presented if we look at any row or column consisting of @xmath5 processors . in this algorithm ,
the communication cost scales as @xmath6 , while the calculation cost scales as @xmath7 .
thus , we can use a much larger number of processors without losing efficiency compared to what was practical with previously known algorithms . _
pacs : 02.60.cb;95.10.ce ; 98.10.+z _ celestial mechanics , stellar dynamics;methods : numerical # 1@xmath8 # 1@xmath9 # 1*[#1 piet ] * # 1*[#1 jun ] * = cmbx10 scaled 2 |
the purpose of this paper is to outline the fundamental role the mittag - leffler function in renewal processes that are relevant in the theories of anomalous diffusion . as a matter of fact the interest in this function in statistical physics and probability theory
has recently increased as is shown by the large number of papers published since 1990 of which a brief ( incomplete ) bibliography includes . in this paper
we develop a theory for long - time behaviour of a renewal process with a generic power law waiting distribution of order @xmath1 , @xmath2 ( thereby for easy readability dispensing with decoration by a slowly varying function ) . to bring the distant future into near sight we change the unit of time from @xmath3 to @xmath4 , @xmath5 . for the random waiting times
@xmath6 this means replacing @xmath6 by @xmath7 .
then , having very many events in a moderate span of time we compensate this compression by respeeding the whole process , actually slowing it down so that again we have a moderate number of events in a moderate span of time .
we will relate the rescaling factor @xmath8 and the respeeding factor @xmath9 in such a way that in the limit @xmath10 we have a reasonable process , namely one whose waiting time distribution is the mittag - leffler waiting time distribution whose density is @xmath11 with the mittag - leffler function @xmath12 we will call the renewal process with waiting time density @xmath13 the _ mittag - leffler ( renewal ) process_. this process can be seen as a fractional generalization of the poisson process , see @xcite .
our method is , in some sense , analogous to the one applied in the sixties of the past century by gnedenko and kovalenko @xcite in their analysis of _ thinning _ ( or _ rarefaction _ ) of a renewal process .
they found , under certain power law assumptions , in the infinite thinning limit , for the waiting time density the laplace transform @xmath14 but did not identify it as a mittag - leffler type function . in section 2 ,
we provide , in our notation , an outline of the thinning theory for renewal processes essentially following gnedenko and kovalenko .
their method has inspired us for the reatment of our problems . as we consider our renewal process formally as a _ continuous time random
walk _ ( ctrw ) with constant non - random jumps 1 in space ( for the counting function @xmath15 , in section 3 we embed ab initio our theory into that of the ctrw , thus being in the position to treat the theory of a time fractional ctrw as limiting case of a ctrw with power law waiting time distribution . in this context
the pioneering paper by balakrishnan @xcite of 1985 deserves to be mentioned .
balakrishnan already found the importance of the laplace transform @xmath16 in the time fractional ctrw and time fractional diffusion , but also did not identify it as the laplace transform of @xmath13 .
then , in 1995 hilfer and anton @xcite , see also @xcite , showed that this waiting time density is characteristic for the time fractional ctrw and can be expressed in terms of the mittag - leffler function in two parameters , that is @xmath17 with the generalized mittag - leffler function @xmath18 the form ( 1.3 ) is equivalent to the form ( 1.1 ) that we prefer as it exhibits visibly also the cumulative probability function , the _ survival function _
, @xmath19 .
we explain in section 4 two manipulations , _ rescaling _ and _ respeeding _ and use these in section 5 to deduce the asymptotic universality of the mittag - leffler waiting time density under a power law assumption for the original waiting time .
then , in section 6 , assuming a suitable power law also for the spatial jumps we show that by a rescaling of the jump widths by a positive factor @xmath20 ( that means a change of the unit of space from 1 to @xmath21 to bring into near sight the far - away space ) another respeeding is effected , now an acceleration , that in the limit @xmath22 ( under a proper relation between @xmath20 and @xmath8 ) leads to space - time fractional diffusion . in section 7
, we pass to a properly scaled limit for the counting function @xmath15 of a renewal process ( again under power law assumption ) and obtain the time fractional drift process ( viewing @xmath15 as a spatial variable ) .
we will extensively work with the transforms of laplace and fourier , so easing calculations and proofs of _ convergence in distribution _ ( also called weak convergence " ) for our passages to the limit .
essentially , we treat in this paper three topics .
first , in section 2 , the thinning of a pure renewal process .
second , in sections 3 - 6 , under power law assumption for the waiting time , the asymptotic relevance of the mittag - leffler law , and then the general ctrw with special attention to space and time transition limits to fractional diffusion . as a third topic , in section 7
, we investigate the long time behaviour of the mittag - leffler renewal process .
essential properties of the derivative of fractional order in time and in space are given in appendix a and appendix b , respectively .
finally , in appendix c we give details on the two special functions of the mittag - leffler type that play a fundamental role in this paper , the mittag - leffler survival probability and the mittag - leffler waiting time density .
the _ thinning _ theory for a renewal process has been considered in detail by gnedenko and kovalenko @xcite .
we must note that other authors , like szntai @xcite speak of _ rarefaction _ in place of thinning .
let us sketch here the essentials of this theory : in the interest of transparency and easy readability we avoid the possible decoration of the relevant power law by multiplying it with a _ slowly varying function_. as usual we call a ( measurable ) positive function @xmath23 _ slowly varying at zero _ if @xmath24 with @xmath25 for every @xmath26 , _ slowly varying at infinity _ if @xmath24 with @xmath27 for every @xmath26 .
a standard example of a slowly varying function at zero and at infinity is @xmath28 , with @xmath29 .
denoting by @xmath30 , @xmath31 the time instants of events of a renewal process , assuming @xmath32 , with @xmath33 waiting times @xmath34 for @xmath35 , ( generically denoted by t ) , _ thinning _ ( or _ rarefaction _ ) means that for each positive index @xmath36 a decision is made : the event happening in the instant @xmath37 is deleted with probability @xmath38 or it is maintained with probability @xmath39 , @xmath40 .
this procedure produces a _ thinned _ or _ rarefied _ renewal process with fewer events ( very few events if @xmath41 is near zero , the case of particular interest ) in a moderate span of time . to compensate for this loss we change the unit of time so that we still have not very few but still a moderate number of events in a moderate span of time
such change of the unit of time is equivalent to rescaling the waiting time , multiplying it with a positive factor @xmath8 so that we have waiting times @xmath42 , and instants @xmath43 , in the rescaled process .
our intention is , vaguely speaking , to dispose on @xmath8 in relation to the rarefaction parameter @xmath41 in such a way that for @xmath41 near zero in some sense the average " number of events per unit of time remains unchanged . in an asymptotic sense
we will make these considerations precise . denoting by @xmath44 the probability distribution function of the ( original ) waiting time @xmath6 , by @xmath45 its density ( @xmath45 is a generalized function generating a probability measure ) so that @xmath46 , and analogously by @xmath47 and @xmath48(t ) the distribution and density , respectively , of the sum of @xmath36 waiting times , we have recursively @xmath49 observing that after a maintained event the next one of the original process is kept with probability @xmath41 but dropped in favour of the second - next with probability @xmath50 and , generally , @xmath51 events are dropped in favour of the @xmath52-th - next with probability @xmath53 , we get for the waiting time density of the thinned process the formula @xmath54 with the modified waiting time @xmath55 we have @xmath56 hence the density @xmath57 , and analogously for the density of the sum of @xmath52 waiting times @xmath58 .
the density of the waiting time of the rescaled ( and thinned ) process now turns out as @xmath59 in the laplace domain we have @xmath60 hence ( using @xmath61 ) @xmath62 from which by laplace inversion we can , in principle , construct the waiting time density of the thinned process . by rescaling we get @xmath63 being interested in stronger and stronger thinning ( _ infinite thinning _ )
let us now consider a scale of processes with the parameters @xmath64 ( of _ rescaling _ ) and @xmath41 ( of _ thinning _ ) , with @xmath41 tending to zero _ under a scaling relation @xmath65 yet to be specified_. we have essentially two cases for the waiting time distribution : its expectation value is finite or infinite . in the first case we put @xmath66 in the second case
we assume a queue of power law type ( dispensing with a possible decoration by a function slowly varying at infinity ) @xmath67 then , by the karamata theory ( see @xcite ) the above conditions mean in the laplace domain @xmath68 with a positive coefficient @xmath69 and @xmath2 .
the case @xmath70 obviously corresponds to the situation with finite first moment ( 2.6a ) , whereas the case @xmath71 is related to a power law queue with @xmath72 now , passing to the limit of @xmath73 of infinite thinning under the scaling relation @xmath74 between the positive parameters @xmath41 and @xmath8 , the laplace transform of the rescaled density @xmath75 in ( 2.5 ) of the thinned process tends for fixed @xmath76 to @xmath77 which corresponds to the mittag - leffler density @xmath78 let us remark that gnedenko and kovalenko obtained ( 2.9 ) as the laplace transform of the limiting density but did not identify it as the laplace transform of a mittag - leffler type function . observe that in the special case @xmath79 we have @xmath80 , hence as the limiting process the poisson process , as formerly shown in 1956 by rnyi @xcite .
the name _ continuous time random walk _ ( ctrw ) became popular in physics after montroll , weiss and scher ( just to cite the pioneers ) in the 1960 s and 1970 s published a celebrated series of papers on random walks for modelling diffusion processes on lattices , see @xcite , and the book by weiss @xcite with references therein .
ctrws are rather good and general phenomenological models for diffusion , including processes of anomalous transport , that can be understood in the framework of the classical renewal theory , as stated in the booklet by cox @xcite .
in fact a ctrw can be considered as a compound renewal process ( a simple renewal process with reward ) or a random walk _ subordinated _ to a simple renewal process .
a spatially one - dimensional ctrw is generated by a sequence of independent identically distributed ( @xmath81 ) positive random waiting times @xmath82 each having the same probability density function @xmath83 @xmath84 and a sequence of @xmath81 random jumps @xmath85 in @xmath86 each having the same probability density @xmath87 @xmath88 let us remark that , for ease of language , we use the word density also for generalized functions in the sense of gelfand & shilov @xcite , that can be interpreted as probability measures .
usually the _ probability density functions _ are abbreviated by @xmath89 .
we recall that @xmath90 with @xmath91 and @xmath92 with @xmath93 . setting @xmath94 @xmath95 for @xmath96
the wandering particle makes a jump of length @xmath97 in instant @xmath30 , so that its position is @xmath98 for @xmath99 and @xmath100 for @xmath101 we require the distribution of the waiting times and that of the jumps to be independent of each other .
so , we have a compound renewal process ( a renewal process with reward ) , compare @xcite . by natural probabilistic arguments we arrive at the _ integral equation _ for
the probability density @xmath102 ( a density with respect to the variable @xmath103 ) of the particle being in point @xmath103 at instant @xmath104 see @xcite , @xmath105\,dt'\ , , \eqno(3.1)\ ] ] in which the _ survival function _
@xmath106 denotes the probability that at instant @xmath107 the particle is still sitting in its starting position @xmath108 clearly , ( 3.1 ) satisfies the initial condition @xmath109 .
note that the _ special choice _ @xmath110 gives the _ pure renewal process _
, with position @xmath111 , denoting the _ counting function _ , and with jumps all of length 1 in positive direction happening at the renewal instants . for many purposes the integral equation ( 3.1 ) of ctrw can be easily treated by using the laplace and fourier transforms .
writing these as @xmath112 @xmath113 then in the laplace - fourier domain eq .
( 3.1 ) reads @xmath114 introducing formally in the laplace domain the auxiliary function @xmath115 and assuming that its laplace inverse @xmath116 exists , we get , following @xcite , in the laplace - fourier domain the equation @xmath117 = \left [ \widehat w(\kappa ) -1\right]\ , \widehat{\widetilde p}(\kappa , s ) \
, , \eqno(3.6)\ ] ] and in the space - time domain the generalized kolmogorov - feller equation @xmath118 with @xmath119 .
if the laplace inverse @xmath116 of the formally introduced function @xmath120 does not exist , we can formally set @xmath121 and multiply ( 3.6 ) with @xmath122 . then
, if @xmath123 exists , we get in place of ( 3.7 ) the alternative form of the generalized kolmogorov - feller equation @xmath124\ , dt'\ , , \eqno(3.7')\ ] ] with @xmath119
. special choices of the memory function @xmath116 are @xmath125 and @xmath126 , see eqs ( 3.8 ) and ( 3.12 ) : @xmath127 giving the _ exponential waiting time _ with @xmath128 in this case we obtain in the fourier- laplace domain @xmath129\ , \widehat{\widetilde p}(\kappa , s ) \ , , \eqno(3.10)\ ] ] and in the space - time domain the _ classical kolmogorov - feller equation _ @xmath130 @xmath131 giving the _ mittag - leffler waiting time _ with @xmath132 in this case we obtain in the fourier - laplace domain @xmath133 = \lt [ \widehat w(\kappa ) -1\right]\ , \widehat{\widetilde p}(\kappa , s ) \ , , \eqno(3.14)\ ] ] and in the space - time domain the _ time fractional kolmogorov - feller equation _
@xmath134 where @xmath135 denotes the fractional derivative of of order @xmath136 in the caputo sense , see appendix a. the time fractional kolmogorov - feller equation can be also expressed via the riemann - liouville fractional derivative @xmath137 , see again appendix a , that is @xmath138 , \eqno(3.16)\ ] ] with @xmath109 .
the equivalence of the two forms ( 3.15 ) and ( 3.16 ) is easily proved in the fourier - laplace domain by multiplying both sides of eq .
( 3.14 ) with the factor @xmath139 .
we note that the choice @xmath140 may be considered as a limit of the choice @xmath126 as @xmath70 .
in fact , in this limit we find @xmath141 so @xmath142 ( according to a formal representation of the dirac generalized function @xcite ) , so that eqs .
( 3.6)-(3.7 ) reduce to ( 3.10)-(3.11 ) , respectively . in this case
the order of the caputo derivative reduces to 1 and that of the r - l derivative to 0 , whereas the mittag - leffler waiting time law reduces to the exponential . in the sequel
we will formally unite the choices ( * i * ) and ( * ii * ) by defining what we call the mittag - leffler memory function @xmath143 whose laplace transform is @xmath144 thus we will consider the whole range @xmath2 by extending the mittag - leffler waiting time law in ( 3.13 ) to include the exponential law ( 3.9 ) . equation ( 3.7 ) clearly may be supplemented by an arbitrary initial probability density @xmath145 .
the corresponding replacement of @xmath146 by @xmath147 in ( 3.1 ) then requires in ( 3.4 ) multiplication of the term @xmath148 by @xmath149 and in ( 3.6 ) replacement of the lhs by @xmath150 $ ] . with @xmath151
we obtain in @xmath102 the fundamental solution of ( 3.7 )
we now consider two types of manipulations on the ctrw by acting on its governing equation ( 3.7 ) in its laplace - fourier representation ( 3.6 ) . + * ( a ) : rescaling the waiting time * , hence the whole time axis ; + * ( b ) : respeeding the process*. means change of the unit of time ( measurement ) . we replace the random waiting time @xmath6 by a waiting time @xmath7 , with the positive _ rescaling factor _ @xmath152 .
our idea is to take @xmath153 in order to bring into near sight the distant future . in a moderate span of time
we will so have a large number of jump events .
for @xmath154 we get the rescaled waiting time density @xmath155 by decorating also the density @xmath38 with an index @xmath8 we obtain the rescaled integral equation of the ctrw in the laplace - fourier domain as @xmath156 = \lt [ \widehat w(\kappa ) -1\rt]\ , \widehat{\widetilde { p}}_\tau ( \kappa , s)\ , , \eqno(4.2)\ ] ] where , in analogy to ( 3.5 ) , @xmath157 means multiplying the quantity representing @xmath158 by a factor @xmath159 , where @xmath160 is the _ respeeding factor _ : @xmath161 means _ acceleration _ , @xmath162 means _
deceleration_. in the laplace - fourier representation this means multiplying the rhs of eq . ( 3.6 ) by the factor @xmath9 since the expression @xmath163 $ ] corresponds to @xmath164 .
we now chose to consider the procedures of rescaling and respeeding in their combination so that the equation in the transformed domain of the rescaled and respeeded process has the form @xmath165 = a\ , \lt [ \widehat w(\kappa ) -1\rt]\ , \widehat{\widetilde { p}}_{\tau , a } ( \kappa , s)\ , , \eqno(4.4)\ ] ] clearly , the two manipulations can be discussed separately : the choice @xmath166 means _ pure rescaling _ , the choice @xmath167 means _ pure respeeding _ of the original process . in the special case @xmath168 we only respeed the original system
; if @xmath169 we can counteract the compression effected by rescaling to again obtain a moderate number of events in a moderate span of time by respeeding ( decelerating ) with @xmath170 . these vague notions will become clear as soon as we consider power law waiting times .
defining now @xmath171 we finally get , in analogy to ( 3.6 ) , the equation @xmath172 = \lt [ \widehat w(\kappa ) -1\rt]\ , \widehat{\widetilde { p}}_{\tau , a}(\kappa , s)\ , .
\eqno(4.6)\ ] ] what is the combined effect of rescaling and respeeding on the waiting time density ?
in analogy to ( 3.5 ) and taking account of ( 4.5 ) we find @xmath173 and so , for the deformation of the waiting time density , the _ essential formula _
@xmath174 : the formula ( 4.8 ) has the same structure as the thinning formula ( 2.5 ) by identification of @xmath9 with @xmath41 . in both problems we have a rescaled process defined by a time scale @xmath152 , and we send the relevant factors @xmath152 , @xmath9 and @xmath41 to zero under a proper relationship .
however in the thinning theory the relevant independent parameter going to 0 is that of thinning ( actually respeeding ) whereas in the present problem it is the rescaling parameter @xmath152 .
we have essentially two different situations for the waiting time distribution according to its first moment ( the expectation value ) being finite or infinite . in other words
we assume for the waiting time @xmath89 @xmath175 either @xmath176 or @xmath177 for convenience we have dispensed in ( 5.2 ) with decorating by a slowly varying function at infinity the asymptotic power law .
then , by the standard tauberian theory ( see @xcite ) the above conditions ( 5.1)-(5.2 ) mean in the laplace domain the ( comprehensive ) asymptotic form @xmath178 where we have @xmath179 then , _ fixing @xmath76 _ as required by the continuity theorem of probability theory for laplace transforms , taking @xmath180 and _ sending @xmath8 to zero _ , we obtain in the limit the mittag - leffler waiting time law .
in fact , eqs .
( 4.8 ) and ( 5.3 ) imply as @xmath10 with @xmath2 , @xmath181 } { 1 - ( 1-\lambda \tau^\beta)\ , \left[1-\lambda \tau^\beta s^\beta + o(\tau^\beta s^\beta)\right ] } \to \frac{1}{1 + s^\beta } \ , , \eqno(5.6)\ ] ] the laplace transform of @xmath182 , see ( 1.1 ) and appendix c. this formula expresses * the asymptotic universality of the mittag - leffler waiting time law * that includes the exponential law for @xmath80 .
it can easily be generalized to the case of power laws decorated with slowly varying functions , thereby using the tauberian theory by karamata ( see again @xcite ) . the formula ( 5.6 )
says that our general power law waiting time density is gradually deformed into the mittag - leffler waiting time density as @xmath8 tends to zero .
let us stress here the distinguished character of the mittag - leffler waiting time density @xmath183 defined in ( 1.1 ) .
considering its laplace transform @xmath184 we can easily prove the identity @xmath185 ^ml_,a ( s ) = ^ml ( s / a^1/ ) > 0 , a>0 .
( 5.8)@xmath185 note that eq .
( 5.8 ) states the _ self - similarity _ of the combined operation _
rescaling - respeeding _ for the mittag - leffler waiting time density .
in fact , ( 5.8 ) implies @xmath186 with @xmath187 which means replacing the random waiting time @xmath188 by @xmath189 . as a consequences ,
choosing @xmath190 we have @xmath185 ^ml_,^ ( s ) = ^ml ( s ) > 0 .
( 5.9)@xmath185 hence _ the mittag - leffler waiting time density is invariant against combined rescaling with @xmath152 and respeeding with @xmath191_. observing ( 5.6 ) we can say that @xmath192 is a @xmath10 attractor for any power law waiting time ( 5.2 ) under simultaneous rescaling with @xmath152 and respeeding with @xmath193 . in other words , this attraction property of the mittag - leffler probability distribution with respect to power law waiting times ( with @xmath194 ) is a kind of analogy to the attraction of sums of power law jump distributions by stable distributions .
we have again two different situations for the jump - width distribution but according to its second moment being finite or infinite .
in other words we assume for the jump - width probability density @xmath195 ( assumed for simplicity to be symmetric : @xmath196 ) either @xmath197 or @xmath198 then we have the asymptotic relation , compare with @xcite , @xmath199 where @xmath200 the above asymptotic relations are known in the framework of the attraction properties of the stable densities .
we note that the classical book by gnedenko and kolmogorov @xcite has unfortunately the wrong constant @xmath201 for @xmath202 .
as before we dispense with the possible decoration of the relevant power law by a slowly varying function . by another respeeding , in fact an acceleration
, we can pass over to space - time fractional diffusion processes .
for this we have * three choices * : + * ( a ) : diffusion limit in space only , for general waiting time * , + * ( b ) : diffusion limit in space only , for ml waiting time * , + * ( c ) : joint limit in time and space ( with power laws in both ) with scaling relation*. note hat ( b ) is just a special case of ( a ) but of particular relevance ( as we shall see ) .
in all three cases we rescale the jump density by a factor @xmath203 , replacing the random jumps @xmath204 by @xmath205 .
this means changing the unit of measurement in space from @xmath3 to @xmath21 , with @xmath206 , so bringing into near sight the far - away space . we get the rescaled jump density as @xmath207 , corresponding to @xmath208 . .
+ starting from the eq . ( 3.6 ) , the laplace - fourier representation of the ctrw equation , without special assumption on the waiting time density , we fix the fourier variable @xmath209 and accelerate the spatially rescaled process by the respeeding factor @xmath210 , arriving at the equation ( using @xmath211 as new dependent variable ) @xmath212 = \frac { \widehat w(h \kappa ) -1}{\mu h^\alpha } \ , \widehat{\widetilde q}_h(\kappa , s)\ , .
\eqno(6.5)\ ] ] then , _ fixing @xmath213 _ as required by the continuity theorem of probability theory for fourier transforms , and _ sending @xmath20 to zero _ we get , noting that @xmath214/(\mu h^\alpha ) \to -|\kappa|^\alpha$ ] , and writing @xmath215 in place of @xmath216 , @xmath217 = - |\kappa |^\alpha \,\widehat{\widetilde u}(\kappa , s)\ , , \eqno(6.6)\ ] ] where we still have , consistently with ( 3.5 ) , @xmath218 being @xmath219 the original waiting time density . in physical space - time we have the integro - pseudo - differential equation @xmath220 with @xmath221 as the symbol of the riesz pseudo - differential operator @xmath222 usually referred to as the riesz fractional derivative of order @xmath223 , see appendix b. : by this rescaling and acceleration the jumps become smaller and smaller , their number in a given span of time larger and larger , the waiting times between jumps smaller and smaller . in the limit
there are no waiting times anymore , the original waiting time density @xmath219 is now only spiritual , but still determines via @xmath116 the memory of the process .
( 6.7 ) offers a great variety of diffusion processes with memory depending on the choice of the function @xmath116 . .
+ we now choose in eq .
( 6.7 ) the mittag - leffler memory function ( 3.17 ) , namely @xmath224 corresponding to the mittag - leffler waiting time law @xmath225 consistently with the time fractional kolmogorov - feller equation ( 3.15 ) , that includes for @xmath80 the classical kolmogorov - feller equation ( 3.11 ) . as a consequence of our spatial diffusion limit , compare with @xcite , we so arrive immediately at the _ space - time fractional diffusion equation _ @xmath226 .
+ assuming the behaviour for the waiting time density as in eqs .
( 5.1)-(5.2 ) , and for the jump - width density as in eqs .
( 6.1)-(6.2 ) , rescaling as described the waiting times and the jumps by factors @xmath8 and @xmath20 , starting from ( 4.4 ) , decelerating by a factor @xmath227 in time , then accelerating for space by a factor @xmath228 , we obtain ( compare to section 4 , case ( b ) ) , fixing @xmath76 and @xmath209 and setting , for convenience @xmath229 @xmath230 = a(\tau , h)\ , \left [ \widehat w_h(\kappa ) - 1\right]\ , \widehat{\widetilde { p}}_{\tau , a(\tau , h ) } ( \kappa , s)\,,\eqno(6.10)\ ] ] with @xmath231 and @xmath232 fixing @xmath233 to the constant value 1 , which means introducing the relationship of _ well - scaledness _ @xmath234 between the rescaling of time and space , we get @xmath235 because of @xmath236 we finally get the limiting equation @xmath237 = - |\kappa |^\alpha \ , \widehat{\widetilde u}(\kappa , s)\,,\eqno(6.15)\ ] ] corresponding to eq . ( 6.8 ) , the space - time fractional diffusion equation .
* ( @xmath223 ) * the mittag - leffler waiting time ( choice ( b ) ) , obeying the power law asymptotics ( 5.2 ) with @xmath238 leads from ( 6.7 ) directly to the space - time fractional diffusion equation ( 6.8 ) , without requirement of rescaling and deceleration in time , and with these procedures we arrive likewise at ( 6.8 ) .
this strange fact is caused by the invariance of the mittag - leffler density to the combined effects of rescaling by @xmath8 and deceleration by @xmath239 , expressed in eq .
( 5.9 ) . * ( @xmath136 ) * going again through our preceding deductions , we observe that the combined ( well - scaled ) passage of @xmath152 and @xmath20 , under the relation ( 6.12 ) , towards zero can be split in two distinct ways into two separate passages . :
keep @xmath20 fixed letting @xmath152 tend to zero , then in the resulting model send also @xmath20 to zero . :
interchange the order played by @xmath20 and @xmath152 in the first way . under our power law assumptions
we can transform ( 3.7 ) , the basic integral equation of ctrw , into eq .
( 3.15 ) ( time fractional ctrw ) by rescaling - respeeding manipulation only in the time variable , and then by rescaling in space followed by an acceleration into ( 6.8 ) , the space - time fractional diffusion equation . or we can transform ( 3.7 ) by rescaling in space followed by an acceleration into eq . ( 6.7 ) ( general space fractional diffusion with memory ) , and then by by rescaling - respeeding in the time variable arrive at ( 6.8 ) . *
( @xmath240 ) * where have the waiting times gone in the space - time fractional diffusion equation ( 6.8 ) ?
we can answer this question by interpreting eq .
( 6.10 ) under the scaling relation ( 6.12 ) as the laplace - fourier representation @xmath241 = \left [ \widehat w_h(\kappa ) - 1\right]\ , \widehat{\widetilde { p}}_{\tau , 1 } ( \kappa , s)\,,\eqno(6.16)\ ] ] of our original ctrw ( 3.1 ) , whose laplace - fourier representation ( 3.6 ) coincides with ( 6.16 ) if there we delete all decorations with indices .
( 6.16 ) represents the same physical process as ( 3.1 ) but expressed in terms of new units @xmath242 and @xmath21 of time and space , respectively .
however , the respeeding factor @xmath233 being fixed to 1 , there is no change of physical speed .
when these new units are made smaller and smaller , moderate spans of time and space become numerically smaller and smaller , shrinking towards zero as @xmath152and @xmath20 tend to zero , and likewise the waiting times and the jump widths shrink to zero . the distant future and
the far - away space come numerically into near sight . as long as @xmath152 and @xmath20 are positive
, we always have the same physical process , only measured in other units . the finally resulting space - time fractional diffusion process ( 6.8 )
remembers the power laws for waiting times and jumps in form of the orders @xmath136 and @xmath223 of fractional differentiation .
* ( @xmath243 ) * an objection could be raised against the somewhat mystical actions of respeeding .
namely , if the respeeding factor @xmath9 in eq .
( 4.4 ) differs from 1 , the underlying renewal process and consequently the whole ctrw are distorted .
however , for the ctrw we carry out the actions of deceleration and acceleration in either order in succession or simultaneously in combination , and by our special choice of these factors they cancel each other in effect , so that there remains no physical distortion .
this is particularly obvious in our choice ( c ) , see the above comment ( @xmath240 ) . * ( @xmath244 ) * let us finally point out an advantage of splitting the passages @xmath10 and @xmath22 .
whereas by the combined passage as in choice ( c ) , if done in the well - scaled way ( 6.12 ) , the mystical concept of respeeding can be avoided , there arises the question of correct use of the continuity theorems of probability .
there is one continuity theorem for the laplace transform , one for the fourier transform , see @xcite .
possible doubts whether their simultaneous use is legitimate vanish by applying them in succession , as in our two splitting methods . in our investigations
we have met four types of spatially one - dimensional stochastic processes for the sojourn probability density @xmath102 or @xmath245 .
for the reader s convenience let us give a list of these processes in physical coordinates , referring to the preceding text for details , and remind briefly how they can be connected by appropriate scaling and passages to the limit .
let us note that in all these processes the initial condition @xmath246 for @xmath247 or @xmath248 can be replaced by a more general probability density function @xmath147 .
the integral equation for the ctrw is , see ( 3.1 ) with ( 3.2 ) , @xmath249\,dt'\ ] ] is equivalent , by the introduction of the memory function @xmath116 , see ( 3.5 ) , to the generalized kolmogorov - feller equation , see ( 3.7 ) , @xmath250 the time fractional kolmogorov - feller equation , see ( 3.15 ) , @xmath251 the integro - pseudo - differential equation of space fractional diffusion with general memory , see ( 6.7 ) , @xmath252 the space - time fractional diffusion equation , see ( 6.8 ) , @xmath253 we now sketch shortly how these four evolution equations are connected in our theory .
( i ) goes over in eq .
( ii ) , likewise eq .
( iii ) in eq .
( iv ) by the special choice @xmath254 for the memory function , see ( 3.17 ) . under our power law assumption for the waiting time ,
see ( 5.1 ) and ( 5.2 ) , these transitions can be achieved asymptotically by manipulation via rescaling and respeeding of the underlying renewal process . under our power law assumption for the jumps ,
see ( 6.1)and ( 6.2 ) , the transition from eq .
( i ) to eq .
( iii ) and from ( ii ) to ( iv ) can be achieved asymptotically by passage to the diffusion limit only in space . under our power law assumption for time space there is a direct way from eq .
( i ) to eq .
( iv ) , namely _ the well - scaled passage to the diffusion limit _ ,
for which the condition ( 6.12 ) is relevant .
it is instructive to study the spatial transition to the diffusion limit for the _ mittag - leffler renewal process_. as said in section 3 this renewal process , viewed as a ctrw by treating its counting number @xmath255 as a spatial variable @xmath103 , is obtained by choosing @xmath256 as the jump width density , see eq .
its waiting time density is , see ( 1.1 ) , ( 3.13 ) , @xmath257 we have @xmath258 , @xmath259 , hence
@xmath260 = \lt ( \e^{i\kappa}-1\rt)\ , \widehat{\widetilde { p } } ( \kappa , s ) \ , .
\eqno(7.1)\ ] ] rescaling in space by a factor @xmath20 and accelerating ( because of @xmath261 for @xmath262 ) this pure renewal process by the factor @xmath21 we get a process @xmath263 = \rec{h } \lt ( \e^{i h \kappa}-1\rt)\ , \widehat{\widetilde { q}_h } ( \kappa , s ) \,,\ ] ] which as @xmath264 and @xmath209 fixed gives @xmath265 = i\kappa \ , \widehat{\widetilde { u } } ( \kappa , s ) \ , , \eqno(7.2)\ ] ] which implies @xmath266 we note that eq .
( 7.2 ) corresponds to the time fractional drift equation @xmath267 by using the known scaling rules for the fourier and laplace transforms , @xmath268 we infer directly from ( 7 .
3 ) ( thus without inverting the two transforms ) the following _ scaling property _ of the ( fundamental ) solution @xmath269 consequently , introducing the _ similarity variable _ @xmath270
we can write @xmath271 where @xmath272 to determine the solution in the space - time domain we can follow two alternative strategies related to the different order in carrying out the inversion of the fourier - laplace transforms in ( 7 . 3 ) . indeed we can + ( s1 ) : invert the fourier transform getting @xmath273 and then invert this laplace transform , + ( s2 ) : invert the laplace transform getting @xmath274 and then invert this fourier transform . recalling the fourier
transform pair , @xmath275 where @xmath276 denotes the unit step heaviside function , we get @xmath277 in view of the fact that @xmath278 is the laplace transform of the extremal unilateral stable density of order @xmath136 , @xmath279 ( see for notation appendix b ) , we recognize that the solution in the space - time domain can be expressed in terms of a fractional integral ( see appendix a ) of such density , namely @xmath280\ , .
\eqno(7.7)\ ] ] working in the laplace domain we can note that the fundamental solution of our fractional drift equation ( 7.4 ) is simply related to that of the time fractional diffusion - wave equation @xmath281 equipped with the initial conditions @xmath282 if @xmath283 and @xmath284 if @xmath285 .
in fact , the solution of ( 7.8 ) turns out the half of the solution ( 7.7 ) of our time fractional drift equation ( 7.4 ) , extended in a symmetric way to all of @xmath286 , as can be seen by factorizing eq .
( 7.8 ) as @xmath287 indeed eq . ( 7.8 ) was solved by using the laplace transform strategy by mainardi in the 1990 s , see e.g. @xcite where the reader can find mathematical details of the proof and instructive plots of the fundamental solution .
then , based on mainardi s analysis , we can state that the required solution of eq .
( 7.4 ) reads @xmath288 where @xmath289 denotes the function of wright type defined in the complex plane @xmath290 } \!=\ !
\rec{\pi}\ , \sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\,{(-z)^{n-1 } \over ( n-1)!}\ , \gamma(\beta n ) \,\sin ( \pi \beta n ) .
\eqno(7.10)\ ] ] the @xmath289 function is a special case of the wright function defined by the series representation , valid in the whole complex plane , @xmath291 indeed , we recognize @xmath292 originally , wright introduced and investigated this function with the restriction @xmath293 in a series of notes starting from 1933 in the framework of the asymptotic theory of partitions . only later , in 1940 , he considered the case @xmath294 .
we note that in the handbook of the bateman project @xcite ( see vol .
18 ) , presumably for a misprint , @xmath69 is restricted to be non negative .
for further mathematical details on the @xmath289-wright function we recommend @xcite . for our time
fractional drift equation ( 7.4 ) we note the particular case @xmath295 for which we obtain @xmath296\ , , \q x\ge 0 \,,\q t\ge 0\ , .
\eqno(7.13)\ ] ] in the limiting case @xmath80 we recover the rightward pure drift , @xmath297 in view of the fact that that @xmath289-wright function of order @xmath136 is related to the extremal unilateral stable density of order @xmath136 , see @xcite , we conclude by displaying the alternative form of the solution of the time fractional drift equation : @xmath298 which , compared with ( 7.7 ) , shows the effect of the fractional integral on the stable density function @xmath299 . recalling the laplace transform pair , see e.g. @xcite , @xmath300 we get @xmath301 from which @xmath302 where @xmath303 denotes the cauchy principal value . because , see @xcite , vol .
3 , chapter xviii on miscellaneous functions , section 18.1 eq .
( 7 ) , @xmath304 we see that @xmath305 does not tend to zero fast enough for the integral ( 7.17 ) to exist as a regular improper riemann integral .
but there should be no problem for existence as a cauchy principal value integral .
it can be shown that the present strategy based on fourier integral ( 7.17 ) provides the result ( 7.9 ) . : not wanting to overload our paper we have deliberately avoided the concept of _ subordination _ in fractional diffusion .
but , referring to @xcite , let us say that if in ( 7.15 ) we replace @xmath103 by @xmath306 we get the _ subordinator _ ,
i.e. the probability law for generating the operational time @xmath306 from the physical time @xmath107 , see eq .
( 5.20 ) in @xcite , and , in other notation , @xcite .
because of its relation ( 7.16 ) via fourier transform to the mittag - leffler function with imaginary argument , the probability law governing the process ( 7.15 ) sometimes is called the _ mittag - leffler distribution _ , see e.g. @xcite .
although so named it must not be confused with our _ mittag - leffler waiting time distribution _ whose density is given by ( 1.1 ) .
the basic role of the mittag - leffler waiting time probability density in time fractional continuous time random walk ( ctrw ) has become well known by the fundamental paper of 1995 by hilfer and anton @xcite .
earlier in the theory of thinning ( rarefaction ) of a renewal process under power law assumptions , see the 1968 book by gnedenko and kovalenko @xcite , this density had been found as limit density by a combination of thinning followed by rescaling of time and imposing a proper relation between the rescaling factor and the thinning parameter .
likewise one arrives at this law when wanting to construct a certain special class of anomalous random walks , see the 1985 paper by balakrishnan @xcite , the anomaly defined by growth of the second moment of the sojourn probability density like a power of time with exponent between 0 and 1 .
balakrishnan s paper , having appeared a few years before the fundamental paper of 1989 by schneider and wyss @xcite , is difficult to read as it is written in a style different from the present one , so we will here not go into details . but
let it be said that by well - scaled passage to the limit from ctrw ( again under suitable power law assumptions in space and time ) he obtained the space - time fractional diffusion equation in form of an equivalent integro - differential equation .
unfortunately , balakrishnan s paper did not find the attention it would have deserved .
however , due to the sad fact that the mittag - leffler function too long played a rather neglected role in treatises on special functions balakrishnan as well as gnedenko and kovalenko contented themselves with presenting their results only in the laplace transform domain ; they did not identify their limit density as a mittag - leffler type function .
having worked ourselves for some time on questions of well - scaled passage to the diffusion limit from continuous time random walks to fractional diffusion , see @xcite , we got from the theory of thinning the idea that it should be possible to carry out the passages to the limit separately in space and in time . in time
this can be done by a combination of re - scaling time and respeeding the underlying renewal process ( formally treating it as a ctrw with unit steps in space ) .
in fact , _ thinning _ in the sense of gnedenko and kovalenko transforms the original renewal process into one that is running more slowly and this effect can be balanced by proper choice of the rescaling factor .
the result of our combination of rescaling and respeeding for a ctrw governed by a given renewal process with a generic power law waiting time law is a time fractional ctrw . by another rescaling in space ( now under power law assumption for the jumps ) which can be interpreted as a second respeeding we arrive at the already classical space - time fractional diffusion equation . in this way we shed new light on the long time and wide space behaviour of continuous time
random walks . in a series of comments at the end of section 6 ,
we have explained how , by what we call _ well - scaled _ passage to the diffusion limit , the transition from the ctrw to the space - time fractional diffusion process actually can be obtained by merely rescaling time and space without any respeeding at all . however ,
the separate passages to the limit are more satisfying with respect to mathematical rigour . finally , in section 7
, we have treated the time fractional drift process as a properly scaled limit of the counting function of a pure renewal process governed by a waiting time law of mittag - leffler type .
our trick in finding the limiting waiting time law of this renewal process consists in treating it as a ctrw with positive jumps of size @xmath3 so that its counting number acts as a spatial variable
. then , by suitably rescaling this spatial variable , we obtain as an interesting side result the long time behaviour of the mittag - leffler renewal process .
for a sufficiently well - behaved function @xmath45 ( @xmath307 ) we define the _ caputo time fractional derivative _ of order @xmath308 with @xmath71 through @xmath309 so that @xmath310 such operator has been referred to as the _ caputo _
fractional derivative since it was introduced by caputo in the late 1960 s for modelling the energy dissipation in the rheology of the earth , see @xcite .
soon later this derivative was adopted by caputo and mainardi in the framework of the linear theory of viscoelasticity , see @xcite .
the reader should observe that the _ caputo _ fractional derivative differs from the usual _ riemann - liouville _
( r - l ) fractional derivative @xmath311 \ , , \q 0<\beta<1 \ , .
\eqno(a.3)\ ] ] both derivatives are related to the riemann liouville ( r - l ) fractional integral that is defined for any order @xmath312 as @xmath313 so that @xmath314
. incidentally @xmath315 for @xmath316 .
then , in virtue of eqs ( a.2)-(a.4 ) , the two fractional derivatives read : @xmath317 @xmath318 in particular , the r - l derivative of order @xmath136 is the left inverse of the corresponding r - l fractional integral in that @xmath319 .
we note the relationships between the two fractional derivatives ( when both of them exist ) , for @xmath320 , @xmath321 \ , = \ , _
td^\beta \ , f(t ) - \frac{t^{-\beta } } { \gamma(1-\beta)}\,f(0^+ ) \ , . % % \q 0<\beta<1\ , .
\eqno(a.7)\ ] ] as a consequence we can interpret the caputo derivative as a sort of regularization of the r - l derivative as soon as @xmath322 is finite ; in this sense such fractional derivative was independently introduced in 1968 by dzherbashyan and nersesian @xcite , as pointed out by kochubei , see @xcite . in this respect
the regularized fractional derivative is sometimes referred to as the _ caputo - dzherbashyan derivative_. we observe the different behaviour of the two fractional derivatives ( a.2 ) , ( a.3 ) at the end points of the parameter interval @xmath323 , as it can be noted from their definitions in operational terms ( a.5 ) , ( a.6 ) .
in fact , whereas for @xmath324 both derivatives reduce to @xmath325 , due to the fact that the operator @xmath326 commutes with @xmath325 , for @xmath327 we have @xmath328 the above behaviours have induced us to keep for the riemann - liouville derivative the same symbolic notation as for the standard derivative of integer order , while for the caputo derivative to decorate the corresponding symbol with subscript @xmath329 . for the r - l derivative
the laplace transform reads for @xmath320 @xmath330 thus the rule ( a.9 ) is more cumbersome to be used than ( a.1 ) since it requires the initial value of an extra function @xmath331 related to the given @xmath45 through a fractional integral .
however , when @xmath332 is finite we recognize @xmath333 . in the limit @xmath324 both derivatives reduce to the derivative of the first order
so we recover the corresponding standard formula for the laplace transform : @xmath334 we conclude this appendix noting that in a proper way both derivatives can be generalized for any order @xmath335 , see @xcite .
let us first recall that a generic linear pseudo - differential operator @xmath336 , acting with respect to the variable @xmath337 is defined through its fourier representation , namely @xmath338 where @xmath339 is referred to as the symbol of @xmath336 , formally given as @xmath340 the fractional _ riesz _ derivative @xmath341 is defined as the pseudo - differential operator with symbol @xmath342 this means that for a sufficiently well - behaved ( generalized ) function @xmath147 ( @xmath343 ) we have @xmath344 the symbol of the riesz fractional derivative is nothing but the logarithm of the characteristic function of the generic symmetric _
( in the lvy sense ) probability density , see @xcite . noting @xmath345 we recognize that @xmath346 in other words , the riesz derivative is a symmetric fractional generalization of the second derivative to orders less than 2 . in an explicit way the riesz
derivative reads , for @xmath202 , @xmath347 where in the l.h.s we have also adopted the alternative and illuminating notation introduced by zaslavsky , see @xcite .
this operator is referred to as the _ riesz fractional derivative _ since it is obtained from the inversion of the fractional integral originally introduced by marcel riesz in the late 1940 s , known as the _ riesz potential _ , see @xcite .
it is based on a suitable regularization of a hyper - singular integral , according to a method formerly introduced by marchaud in 1927 .
: straightforward generalization to the _ riesz - feller derivative _ of order @xmath223 and skewness @xmath348 is possible . such pseudo - differential operator is denoted by us as @xmath349 in this case we have @xmath350 in an explicit way the riesz - feller derivative reads , for @xmath202 , @xmath351 \ , \int_0^\infty { f(x+\xi)- f(x ) \over { \xi}^{1+\alpha}}\ , d \xi \right.}\\ & + \,{\ds \left . \sin
\,[(\alpha-\theta ) \pi/2 ] \ , \int_0^\infty { f(x-\xi)- f(x ) \over { \xi}^{1+\alpha}}\ , d \xi \right\}}\ , . \end{array } \eqno ( b.8)\ ] ] notice in ( b.7 ) that @xmath352 $ ] .
thus the symbol of the riesz - feller fractional derivative is the logarithm of the characteristic function of the more general ( strictly ) _ stable _ probability density , closely following the feller parameterization , see @xcite revisited by the present authors in @xcite . according to our notation , the strictly stable density of order @xmath223 and skewness @xmath348
is denoted by @xmath353 .
we note that the allowed region for the parameters @xmath354 and @xmath348 turns out to be a diamond in the plane @xmath355 with vertices in the points @xmath356 , @xmath357 , @xmath358 , @xmath359 , that we call the _ feller - takayasu diamond _ , see fig .
1 . for more details
we refer the reader to @xcite , where series representations and numerical plots of the stable densities @xmath353 are found .
in particular , we recall that the extremal stable densities obtained for @xmath360 with @xmath361 are unilateral , with support in @xmath362 , respectively . -0.1truecm
the mittag - leffler function with parameter @xmath136 is defined as @xmath363 it is an entire function of order @xmath1 and reduces for @xmath80 to @xmath364 for detailed information on the functions of mittag - leffler type the reader may consult and references therein .
hereafter , we find it convenient to summarize the most relevant features of the functions @xmath365 @xmath366 that turn out to be the most relevant functions of mittag - leffler type for our purposes .
both of them reduce to the exponential function @xmath367 in the limit as @xmath368 .
we begin to quote their expansions in power series of @xmath369 ( convergent for @xmath307 ) and their asymptotic representations for @xmath370 , @xmath185 ( t ) = _ n=0^ ( -1)^n ~ , ( c.4 ) @xmath371 ( t ) = _ n=0^ ( -1)^n ~ .
( c.5 ) @xmath185 the laplace transforms of @xmath372 and @xmath175 can easily be obtained by transforming the series ( c.4 ) , ( c.5 ) term by term , respectively : they read @xmath373 for @xmath71 both functions @xmath372 , @xmath175 keep the complete monotonicity of the limiting exponential function of @xmath374 complete monotonicity of a function @xmath45 means , for @xmath375 , and @xmath307 , @xmath376 , or equivalently , its representability as ( real ) laplace transform of a non - negative function or measure , see @xcite .
recalling the theory of the mittag - leffler functions of order less than 1 , we obtain for @xmath71 the following representations , see @xcite , @xmath377 @xmath378 in figs 2 and 3 we exhibit plots of the functions @xmath372 and @xmath175 , respectively in logarithmic and linear scales .
e. barkai and r.j .
silbey , fractional kramers equation , _ j. phys
b _ * 104 * ( 2000 ) , 3866 - 3874 . e. barkai and i.m .
sokolov on hilfer s objection to the fractional time diffusion equation , _ physica a _ * 373 * ( 2007 ) , 231 - 236 . , _ renewal theory _
, 2-nd edn . , methuen , london ( 1967 ) .
, _ integral transforms and representations of functions in the complex plane_. moscow , nauka ( 1966 ) . in russian .
[ note that there is also the transliteration as djrbashyan ] m.m .
dzherbashyan and a.d .
nersesian , fractional derivatives and the cauchy problem for differential equations of fractional order .
nauk armjanskvy ssr , matematika _ * 3 * ( 1968 ) , 329 . in russian .
w. feller , on a generalization of marcel riesz potentials and the semi - groups generated by them , _ meddelanden lunds universitets matematiska seminarium _ ( _ comm .
universit de lund _ ) .
tome suppl .
ddi a m. riesz , lund , 1952 , pp .
, _ an introduction to probability theory and its applications _ , vol .
2 , 2-nd edn . wiley , new york ( 1971 ) .
[ 1-st edn .
1966 ] i.m .
gel`fand and g.e .
shilov , _ generalized functions _ , volume i. academic press , new york and london ( 1964 ) .
b.v . gnedenko and a.n .
kolmogorov , _ limit distributions for sums of independent random variables _ , addison - wesley , cambridge , mass.(1954 ) .
[ translated from the russian edition , moscow 1949 , with notes by k.l .
chung , revised 1968 ] , analytical properties and applications of the wright function , _ fractional calculus and applied analysis _ * 2 * ( 1999 ) , 383 - 414 .
[ e - print arxiv : math - ph/0701069 ] , wright functions as scale - invariant solutions of the diffusion - wave equation , _ j. comput .
_ * 118 * ( 2000 ) , 175 - 191 .
, fractional calculus : integral and differential equations of fractional order . in a. carpinteri and f. mainardi ( editors ) , _ fractals and fractional calculus in continuum mechanics _ , springer verlag , wien and new york ( 1997 ) , pp .
223 - 276 .
[ http://www.fracalmo.org ] r. gorenflo and f. mainardi , fractional diffusion processes : probability distributions and continuous time random walk , in : g. rangarajan and m. ding ( editors ) , _ processes with long range correlations _ , springer - verlag , berlin ( 2003 ) , pp .
148 - 166 .
[ lecture notes in physics , no .
621 ] r gorenflo and f. mainardi , simply and multiply scaled diffusion limits for continuous time random walks , in : s. benkadda , x. leoncini and g. zaslavsky ( editors ) , proceedings of the international workshop on chaotic transport and complexity in fluids and plasmas carry le rouet ( france ) 20 - 25 june 2004 , _ iop ( institute of physics ) journal of physics : conference series _ * 7 * ( 2005 ) , 1 - 16 . r. gorenflo , f. mainardi , e. scalas and m. raberto fractional calculus and continuous - time finance iii : the diffusion limit , in : m. kohlmann and s. tang ( editors ) , _ mathematical finance _ , birkhuser verlag , basel ( 2001 ) , pp .
171 - 180 .
r. gorenflo , f. mainardi , h.m .
srivastava , special functions in fractional relaxation - oscillation and fractional diffusion - wave phenomena , in : d. bainov ( ed . ) , _ proceedings viii international colloquium on differential equations , plovdiv 1997 _ vsp , utrecht , 1998 , pp .
195 - 202 .
r. gorenflo , f. mainardi and a. vivoli , continuous time random walk and parametric subordination in fractional diffusion , _ chaos , solitons and fractals _ * 34 * ( 2007 ) , 87 - 103 . [ e - print arxiv : cond - mat/0701126 ] r. hilfer , exact solutions for a class of fractal time random walks , _ fractals _ * 3 * ( 1995 ) , 211 - 216 .
r. hilfer , on fractional diffusion and continuous time random walks , _ physica a _ * 329 * ( 2003 ) , 35 - 39 .
t. huillet , on the waiting time paradox and related topics , _ fractals _ * 10 * ( 2002 ) , 1 - 20 . ,
_ generalized fractional calculus and applications_. harlow , longman ( 1994 ) .
[ pitman research notes in mathematics , vol .
301 ] a.n .
kochubei , a cauchy problem for evolution equations of fractional order , _ differential equations _ * 25 * ( 1989 ) , 967974 .
[ english translation from the russian journal _
differentsialnye uravneniya _ ] a.n .
kochubei , fractional order diffusion , _ differential equations _ * 26 * ( 1990 ) , 485492 . [ english translation from the russian journal _ differentsialnye uravneniya _ ]
m. kotulski , asymptotic distributions of continuous - time random walks : a probabilistic approach , _
_ * 81 * ( 1995 ) , 777792 .
f. mainardi , fractional calculus : some basic problems in continuum and statistical mechanics , in a. carpinteri and f. mainardi ( editors ) , _ fractals and fractional calculus in continuum mechanics_. wien and new york , springer verlag , 1997 , pp .
291 - 348 .
f. mainardi , r. gorenflo and a. vivoli , renewal processes of mittag - leffler and wright type , _ fractional calculus and applied analysis _ , * 8 * ( 2005 ) , 7 - 38 .
[ e - print arxiv : math - pr/0701455 ] f. mainardi , yu .
luchko and g. pagnini , the fundamental solution of the space - time fractional diffusion equation , _ fractional calculus and applied analysis _ * 4 * ( 2001 ) , 153 - 192 .
[ e - print arxiv : cond - mat/0702419 ] f. mainardi and g. pagnini , the wright functions as solutions of the time fractional diffusion equations , _ applied mathematics and computation _ * 141 * ( 2003 ) , 51 - 62 .
f. mainardi , m. raberto , r. gorenflo and e. scalas , fractional calculus and continuous - time finance ii : the waiting time distribution , _ physica a _ * 287 * ( 2000 ) , 468481 .
f. mainardi , a. vivoli and r. gorenflo , continuous time random walk and time fractional diffusion : a numerical comparison between the fundamental solutions , _ fluctuation and noise letters _ * 5 * ( 2005 ) , l291-l297 .
r. metzler , e. barkai and j. klafter , anomalous diffusion and relaxation close to thermal equilibrium : a fractional fokker - planck equation approach , _ phys .
* 82 * ( 1999 ) , 35633567 .
montroll and h. scher , random walks on lattices , iv : continuous - time walks and influence of absorbing boundaries , _ j. stat .
_ * 9 * ( 1973 ) , 101 - 135 .
montroll and g.h .
weiss , random walks on lattices , ii , _ j. math .
phys . _ * 6 * ( 1965 ) , 167181 . e.w .
montroll and d.j .
west , on an enriched collection of stochastic processes , in e.w .
montroll and j. leibowitz ( editors ) , _ fluctuation phenomena _ , north - holland , amsterdam , 1979 , pp .
[ studies in statistical mechanics , vol .
vii ] r.n .
pillai , on mittag - leffler functions and related distributions , _ ann .
_ * 42 * ( 1990 ) , 157161 .
a. piryatinska , a.i .
saichev and w.a .
woyczynski , models of anomalous diffusion : the subdiffusive case , _ physica a _ * 349 * , 375 - 420 ( 2005 ) .
, _ fractional differential equations_. san diego , academic press ( 1999 ) .
saichev and g.m .
zaslavsky , fractional kinetic equations : solutions and applications , _ chaos _ * 7 * ( 1997 ) , 753764 .
samko , a.a .
kilbas and o.i .
marichev , _ fractional integrals and derivatives : theory and applications _ , gordon and breach , new york ( 1993 ) . translation from the russian edition , nauka i tekhnika , minsk ( 1987 ) .
e. scalas , the application of continuous - time random walks in finance and economics , _ physica a _ * 362 * ( 2006 ) , 225 - 239 .
e. scalas , r. gorenflo and f. mainardi , fractional calculus and continuous - time finance , _ physica a _ * 284 * ( 2000 ) , 376 - 384 .
e. scalas , r. gorenflo and f. mainardi , uncoupled continuous - time random walks : solution and limiting behavior of the master equation , _ phys .
* 69 * ( 2004 ) , 011107 - 1/8 . , fractional diffusion and wave equations , _ j. math
. phys . _ * 30 * ( 1989 ) 134 - 144 .
sokolov , j. klafter and a. blumen , do strange kinetics imply unusual thermodynamics ? _ phys .
e. _ * 64 * ( 2001 ) , 021107/1 - 4 .
t. szntai , limiting distribution for the sums of random number of random variables concerning the rarefaction of recurrent events .
_ studia scientiarum mathematicarum hungarica _ * 6 * ( 1971 ) , 443 - 452 .
t. szntai , on an invariance problem related to different rarefactions of recurrent events .
_ studia scientiarum mathematicarum hungarica _ * 6 * ( 1971 ) , 453 - 456 . v.v .
uchaikin and v.v .
saenko , stochastic solution of partial differential equations of fractional orders , _ siberian journal of numerical mathematics _ * 6 * ( 2003 ) , 197 - 203 . | we show the asymptotic long - time equivalence of a generic power law waiting time distribution to the mittag - leffler waiting time distribution , characteristic for a time fractional continuous time random walk .
this asymptotic equivalence is effected by a combination of rescaling " time and respeeding " the relevant renewal process followed by a passage to a limit for which we need a suitable relation between the parameters of rescaling and respeeding .
as far as we know such procedure has been first applied in the 1960s by gnedenko and kovalenko in their theory of thinning " a renewal process . turning our attention to spatially one - dimensional continuous time random walks with a generic power law jump distribution , rescaling
" space can be interpreted as a second kind of respeeding " which then , again under a proper relation between the relevant parameters leads in the limit to the space - time fractional diffusion equation .
finally , we treat the time fractional drift " process as a properly scaled limit of the counting number of a mittag - leffler renewal process .
= 10000 -1.5truecm
-0.5truecm = cmr10 = cmr10 at 10 truept -0.75 truecm invited lecture by r. gorenflo at the 373 we - heraeus - seminar on anomalous transport : experimental results and theoretical challenges , physikzentrum bad - honnef ( germany ) , 12 - 16 july 2006 .
it will appear in the book _ anomalous transport : foundations and applications _ edited by r. klages , g. radons and i.m sokolov , as chapter 4 , pp .
93 - 127 , wiley - vch , weinheim , germany ( 2008 ) . @xmath0
-2.0truecm = 10000 = 2000 # 11 l = cmbx12 scaled1 |
a gamma - ray burst ( grb ) event comprises two phases , prompt emission and afterglow .
the prompt @xmath1-ray emission is usually highly variable , with many pulses overlapping within a short duration ( fishman & meegan 1995 ) .
the power density spectra ( pdss ) of the light curves are typically a power law with a possible turnover at high frequencies ( beloborodov et al . 2000 ) .
the light curves may be decomposed as the superposition of an underlying slow component and a more rapid fast component ( gao et al .
the fast component tends to be more significant in high energies , and becomes less significant at lower frequencies ( vetere et al .
2006 ) .
it has been shown that the external shock model has difficulty producing grb variability while maintaining a high radiative efficiency ( sari & piran 1997 ; cf .
dermer & mitman 1999 ) .
the detection of the steep decay phase following grb prompt emission ( tagliaferri et al . 2005 ) suggests that the prompt emission region is detached from the afterglow emission region ( zhang et al .
this nails down the internal origin of grb prompt emission for the majority of grbs . for an internal origin of grb
prompt emission , the variability is usually attributed to the erratic activity of the central engine ( e.g. , rees & mszros 1994 ; kobayashi et al . 1997 ) .
it is envisaged that the ejecta launched from the central engine is composed of multiple shells with variable bulk lorentz factors .
faster late shells catch up and collide with slower early shells .
part of the kinetic energy of the ejecta is converted to energy of non - thermal particles in these internal shocks , a fraction of which is released as the observed non - thermal radiation . in this model ,
different variability timescales are related to the angular spreading time of colliding shells at different internal shock radii . in order to account for superposed slow and fast variability components ,
one has to assume that the central engine itself carries these two variability components in the time history of jet launching ( hascot et al .
2012 ) , whose physical origin is unclear . the internal shock model also suffers a list of criticisms ( e.g. , zhang & yan 2011 for a review ) , including low radiation efficiency ( e.g. , kumar 1999 ; panaitescu et al .
1999 ) , fast cooling ( ghisellini et al . 2000 ; kumar & mcmahon 2008 ) , spectrum . however , a requirement is that the emission region has to be large where the magnetic field is weak .
this corresponds to an unconventional internal shock radius , but is consistent with the icmart model .
] , particle number excess ( daigne & mochkovitch 1998 ; shen & zhang 2009 ) , inconsistency with some empirical relations ( amati et al .
2002 ; zhang & mszros 2002 ; liang et al .
2010 ) , and overpredicting the brightness of the photosphere emission component ( daigne & mochkovitch 2002 ; zhang & peer 2009 ) .
alternatively , the grb variability can be interpreted as locally doppler - boosted emission in a relativistic bulk flow , such as relativistic mini - jets ( lyutikov & blandford 2003 ; yamazaki et al .
2004 ) or relativistic turbulence ( narayan & kumar 2009 ; kumar & narayan 2009 ; lazar et al . 2009 ) in a bulk relativistic ejecta .
some criticisms have been raised to these models .
for example , relativistic turbulence damps quickly so that the emission from the turbulence can not be sustained ( zrake & macfadyen 2012 ) .
the simulated light curves are composed of well - separated sharp pulses without an underlying slow component ( narayan & kumar 2009 ; lazar et al .
2009 ) . also the pulse was calculated to have a symmetric shape for the turbulence model ( lazar et al .
2009 ) , which is in contradiction with the data .
recently , zhang & yan ( 2011 , hereafter zy11 ) proposed an internal - collision - induced magnetic reconnection and turbulence ( icmart ) model to explain prompt emission of grbs . like the traditional internal shock scheme ,
the icmart model envisages internal interactions of shells within the ejecta wind .
the main difference is that the ejecta is poynting flux dominated , with the magnetization parameter @xmath2 in the collision region , where @xmath3 and @xmath4 are poynting flux and matter flux , respectively .
this was motivated by the non - detection of a bright photosphere thermal component in grb 080916c ( zhang & peer 2009 ) and most other large area telescope grbs ( zhang et al .
2011 ) . for a helical magnetic field structure ,
the initial collisions only serve to distort the magnetic field configurations . as multiple collisions proceed ,
the field configurations would be distorted to a critical point when a cascade of reconnection and turbulence occurs .
charged particles can be accelerated in these reconnection regions , leading to intense gamma - ray radiation . within this model ,
a grb light curve is supposed to have two variability components : a broad ( slow ) component that tracks central engine activity , and an erratic ( fast ) component with multiple sharp pulses superposed on the slow component , which is related to numerous reconnection sites during the icmart event . in this paper
, we simulate grb light curves and their corresponding pdss within the framework of the icmart model . in section 2
we describe the basic model and the simulation method .
the simulation results are presented in section 3 .
section 4 summarizes the findings with some discussion .
we first summarize the basic ideas of the icmart model ( zy11 ) .
magnetized shells with initial @xmath5 are envisaged to collide , leading to distortion of magnetic field lines until a threshold is reached and a runaway magnetic dissipation is triggered . during such an `` avalanche''-like reconnection / turbulence cascade
, it is envisaged that fast reconnection seeds in the moderately high @xmath0 regime would inject moderately relativistic outflows in the emission regions ( zy11 ; lyubarsky 2005 ) , which would excite relativistic turbulence .
the turbulence would facilitate more reconnection events , which trigger further turbulence .
the magnetic energy is converted to particle energy and efficient radiation . during the growth of the reconnection / turbulence cascade ,
the number of reconnection sites as observed at any instant increases rapidly with time , so that multiple mini - emitters contribute simultaneously to the observed gamma - ray emission .
rapid evolution of individual reconnection sites leads to rapid variability of the observed grb light curves .
the cascade stops as @xmath0 drops around or below unity when most magnetic energy is converted into radiation or kinetic energy . during the growth of an icmart event ,
turbulence is not quickly damped due to the continuous injection of particle energy from the reconnection events , which continuously drives turbulence . with these preparations , we can model the light curve of a grb within the framework of the icmart model .
lacking full numerical simulations of magnetic turbulence and reconnection , in this paper we perform a monte carlo simulation based on some simplest assumptions .
we define each reconnection event as a fundamental mini - emitter , which carries a local lorentz boost with respect to the bulk of the emission outflow .
each reconnection event can be modeled as a pulse , which can be bright and spiky if the mini - emitter beams toward the observer , but dim and broad if the mini - emitter beams away from the observer s direction .
the observed light curve is the superposition of the emission from all these mini - emitters . for simplicity , we assume that the characteristic brightness ( peak luminosity ) of each reconnection event in the rest frame of the reconnection outflow is the same .
we also take the shape of each pulse as a gaussian form for simplicity ( e.g. , narayan & kumar 2009 ; lazar et al .
our goal is to try to simulate the superposed slow and fast components , and the precise shape of each pulse does not matter too much . in any case
, we note that the shape of a spike within the icmart model is mainly defined by the time history of each reconnecting mini - jet rather than the time history of an ideal eddy , so the pulse profile may not necessarily be symmetric with peak time .
this is different from the previous models ( narayan & kumar 2009 ; lazar et al .
2009 ) that invoke relativistic turbulence .
more importantly , the shape of a broad pulse in the model is asymmetric : the rising portion is defined by the timescale of the reconnection - turbulence cascade process , while the decay portion is controlled by high - latitude emission after the icmart cascade ceases .
there are three rest frames in this model : the first is the rest frame of the mini - jet , i.e. the outflow of the individual reconnection event .
these mini - jets are moving with a relative lorentz factor @xmath1 with respect to the jet bulk .
we denote parameters in this frame as ( @xmath6 ) .
the second frame is the rest frame of the jet bulk , which moves with a lorentz factor @xmath7 with respect to the central engine .
we denote parameters in this frame as ( @xmath8 ) .
the third one is the rest frame of the observer ( with the cosmological expansion effect ignored ) .
the quantities within these three frames are connected through two doppler factors , i.e. , @xmath9^{-1}\ ] ] and @xmath10^{-1},\ ] ] where @xmath11 and @xmath12 are the corresponding dimensionless velocities with respect to @xmath7 and @xmath1 , respectively , @xmath13 is the latitude of the mini - jet with respect to the line of sight ( i.e. the angle between the line of sight and the radial direction of the bulk ejecta at the location of the mini - jet ) , and @xmath14 is the angle between the mini - jet direction and radial direction of the ejecta bulk within the comoving frame of the ejecta bulk .
each reconnection event is supposed to give rise to a single pulse in the grb light curve . since several reconnection events may occur simultaneously
, some pulses can superpose with each other . for
a naive sweet - parker reconnection , one has ( e.g. , see zweibel & yamada 2009 and references therein ) @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the inflow velocity of the reconnection layers , @xmath17 is the outflow velocity , and @xmath18 and @xmath19 are the width and length of the reconnection layer , respectively . reconnection physics demands @xmath20 , so that @xmath21 . on the other hand , what defines the duration of the reconnection event is the thickness of the bunch of magnetic field lines that continuously approach each other , and we assume that it is also of the order of @xmath19 . as a result , in the bulk comoving frame ( the @xmath8 frame ) , the duration of each pulse can be approximated as @xmath22 . in the observer frame , this is translated to @xmath23 , which corresponds to the duration of a certain pulse in the observer frame . for simplicity , we assume that the radiation intensity arising from each reconnection event has the same spectral form , i.e. , the band function ( see band et al .
1993 ) , in the comoving frame of the mini - jet ( the @xmath6 frame ) , @xmath24 the observed flux can be calculated as @xmath25 where @xmath26 is the distance of the grb to the observer . in a high-@xmath0 flow
, @xmath17 can eventually reach a relativistic speed ( with lorentz factor @xmath1 ) , and @xmath27 can reach a maximum value of @xmath28 ( e.g. lyubarsky 2005 and references herein ) .
therefore , @xmath29 .
the lorentz factor of the mini - jet is related to @xmath0 and would drop to unity when @xmath0 drops below unity .
the detailed dependence is related to the complicated physics of relativistic reconnection . in this paper
, we adopt @xmath30 ( i.e. , @xmath1 is proportional to the relativistic alfvn lorentz factor ) .
we also investigated other dependences between @xmath1 and @xmath31 .
the general conclusions regarding how the simulated light - curve properties depend on various parameters are essentially similar . in the rest of the paper , we only focus on the @xmath30 assumption . in the simulations , we fix the band function parameters as the following : @xmath32 , @xmath33 , and the peak frequency @xmath34
is chosen such that @xmath35 kev is satisfied , where 300 kev is the typical observed value of grb spectral peak , and @xmath36 is the average value of the product of the two doppler factors . based on these assumptions ,
we calculate the received flux in the detector band of _ swift _ burst alert telescope ( bat ; i.e. , 15 - 150 kev ) . in our monte carlo simulation ,
four random parameters have been introduced .
they are : ( 1 ) comoving length of the reconnection region @xmath37 , which is assumed to either have a typical value or have a power - law distribution with index @xmath38 below a typical value ; ( 2 ) the mini - jet direction ( angle @xmath14 with respect to the bulk motion direction ) in the bulk comoving frame , which is taken as isotropic or a gaussian distribution with respect to @xmath39 ( see more discussion below ) ; ( 3 ) the latitude of a mini - jet @xmath13 with respect to the viewing direction , which is random within the cone of the jet opening angle ; and ( 4 ) the epoch when a mini - jet occurs , which is taken to satisfy a distribution of exponential growth with time , i.e. @xmath40 .
the total number @xmath41 of the mini - jets is a free parameter , which is defined by the requirement that they dissipate most magnetic energy in the local emission regions , so that the local @xmath0 is brought to below unity after each icmart event . of the ejecta
can be still above unity , if the filling factor @xmath42 , since the majority of magnetic energy is still not dissipated .
a small @xmath43 seems to be required by the central engine study of lei et al .
( 2013 ) , who obtained @xmath0 values greater than the measured typical lorentz factors of grbs ( liang et al .
assuming that the magnetic energy density is roughly uniform within the emission region , this number can be simply written as the ratio between the total dissipated volume ( i.e. , total volume multiplied by the filling factor @xmath43 ) and the volume of the region affected by each reconnection event that powers a mini - jet . within the @xmath44 cone , this number is @xmath45 where @xmath46 is the radius of the emission region from the central engine .
other input parameters include the radius of the emission region @xmath46 , the jet opening angle @xmath47 , the initial values of @xmath7 , and @xmath0 ( which defines the initial @xmath1 ) . for each reconnection event
, we assume that half of the dissipated magnetic energy is released in the form of photons , while the other half is deposited to the jet bulk and used to boost the kinetic energy of the bulk . therefore , @xmath7 , @xmath0 , and @xmath1 are all functions of time during each icmart event .
the exponential growth of magnetic dissipation eventually ends when the local @xmath0 drops around or below unity . without numerical simulations , it is unclear how abrupt the ending process is . in this paper
we just assume an abrupt cessation of the cascade process , so that the number of new mini - jets drops to 0 after a particular time . the observed `` tail '' emission after this epoch is therefore contributed by the high - latitude emission from other mini - jets not along the line of sight due to the `` curvature effect '' delay .
this delay timescale is calculated as @xmath48 with respect to the last emission along the line of sight , where @xmath49 .
we calculate the contribution of all the mini - jets within @xmath50 .
although most of the received emission comes from the mini - jets within the @xmath44 cone , those mini - jets outside the @xmath44 cone make some contribution to the high - latitude emission .
we calculate the delay timescale of each mini - jet , apply its doppler factor to calculate the amplitude and shape of the pulse , and superpose these mini - jets to get the curvature tail of each icmart event .
we run a series of monte carlo simulations to generate sample light curves .
we first focus on the light curves for only one icmart episode .
the light curve of one grb could be then modeled by superposing multiple icmart events .
we first take the following nominal parameters : @xmath51 cm , @xmath52 cm , @xmath53 , @xmath54 , and @xmath55 . considering an exponential growth , i.e. , that each reconnection seed would eject a bipolar outflow and would stir up the ambient medium to trigger two reconnection events , one may estimate the generation number of successive reconnection events , @xmath56 , through the requirement @xmath57 .
the timescale for each generation in the bulk comoving frame may be estimated as @xmath58 s , which corresponds to an observer frame timescale @xmath59 s. this is the typical `` @xmath60-folding '' timescale .
the total duration ( rising timescale ) of an icmart event is therefore @xmath61 times larger , i.e.m @xmath62 s , which we adopt in the simulations .
we also assume that the observer s line of sight is along the jet axis , and we take a redshift @xmath63 for simplicity . for a power - law distribution of @xmath19 , in principle , @xmath19 can extend to much smaller values . in our simulations , reconnection regions with @xmath64 cm
are not considered , since the observed durations of these events already meet the detector s variability limit . in
the following we test various factors that may affect the shape of the light curves .
we first test how the simulated light curve depends on the unknown distribution of @xmath14 in the bulk comoving frame .
we first assume an isotropic distribution and calculate the light curve .
the result is shown in figure [ fig : direction](a ) .
one can immediately see that the light curve has a broad component , with some spiky small pulses superposed on top .
the broad component is due to the contributions of all the mini - jets beaming toward random directions in the bulk motion rest frame .
the rising of the broad pulse corresponds to the exponential growth of the number of mini - jets , while the decay is controlled by the high - latitude effect .
+ + since an icmart event corresponds to an event of destroying the initial ordered magnetic field , the magnetic configurations in the icmart region , even near the end of the cascade , should not be completely random .
the initial magnetic field configuration should be parallel to the ejecta plane ( e.g. , spruit et al .
2001 ; zhang & kobayashi 2005 ) .
this is because the toroidal component falls with radius much slower than the poloidal component .
such a configuration should still leave an imprint on the @xmath14 distribution .
we consider a distribution of @xmath14 that has a gaussian distribution with respect to the original field line direction , i.e. , @xmath39 . in figures [ fig : direction](b ) and [ fig : direction](c ) we show the gaussian angle to be @xmath65 and @xmath66 , respectively .
one can see that the simulated light curves have progressively less flux as the distribution angle becomes smaller .
this is because with a smaller distribution angle , only rare mini - jets could beam toward the observer , which have a relatively lower flux ( than the larger gaussian angle distribution ) with respect to the majority of mini - jets that beam away from the observer and only contribute to the background .
the overall shape of the light curves does not differ significantly .
we next compare the effect of lorentz factor contrast in the icmart region .
we keep the initial value of the bulk lorentz factor @xmath7 constant , i.e. , @xmath53 , and vary @xmath67 .
this corresponds to different values of the initial magnetization @xmath68 . in figure
[ fig : gamma - ratio ] , we compare three sets of simulations , with ( a ) @xmath69 ; ( b ) @xmath70 and ( c ) @xmath71 .
other parameters are the same as those adopted to calculate figure [ fig : direction ] , and the gaussian @xmath14-distribution model with typical angle @xmath65 has been adopted .
we show that the light curves become progressively more erratic and spikier when the @xmath67 becomes larger .
this is because a larger @xmath67 would give rise to larger @xmath72 , and thus a larger value of the total doppler factor @xmath73 .
a larger @xmath67 also tends to give a more significant evolution of the parameters ( figure [ fig : evolution ] ) .
initially , a constant @xmath74 corresponds to a constant @xmath75 cone , so that observed numbers of mini - jets are the same in all these cases .
however a larger @xmath67 can give rise to a larger @xmath7 near the end of evolution , thus a smaller @xmath44 cone .
the slow component is not as significant , so that the light curves become spikier .
+ + in order to show the evolution of the physical parameters during the icmart cascade event , in figure [ fig : evolution ] we display the evolution of the bulk lorentz factor @xmath7 , the mini - jet lorentz factor @xmath1 , and the emission region magnetization @xmath0 as a function of time .
it can be seen that evolution is more significant for a larger @xmath67 ( and equivalently a larger @xmath68 ) .
+ + next , we test how the total number of mini - jets @xmath41 within the @xmath44 cone affects the light curves .
according to equation [ eq : n ] , varying @xmath41 is effectively varying the filling factor @xmath43 . by varying @xmath41 , the total number of e - folding steps @xmath61
is slightly modified , as is the rising time @xmath76 . in figure 4 , we compare the simulated light curves for different @xmath41 values , i.e. , @xmath77 , and @xmath78 , respectively .
it can be seen that in general the light curves appear smoother with increasing @xmath41 .
this can be readily understood : the larger the @xmath41 , the more reconnection events happen simultaneously , so that more mini - jets beaming to different directions tend to enhance the slow component .
the short - timescale structures are smeared out , and the light curves become smoother . + next , we explore the effect of the emission region radius @xmath46
. figures [ fig : r](a ) , [ fig : r](b ) , and [ fig : r](c ) show the results for @xmath79 cm , @xmath80 cm , and @xmath81 , respectively .
one can see that the larger the @xmath46 , the longer and stronger the high - latitude emission tail .
this is because the length of the high - latitude tail is defined by @xmath82 .
we notice again that the rising time is the growth time of the cascade , which is the @xmath60-folding time of consuming most of the magnetic energy in the emission region , which is defined by the total number @xmath41 of the mini - jets and the characteristic scale @xmath19 of each mini - jet .
since the rising and falling times are related to different parameters , the pulse is usually asymmetric ( e.g. , figure [ fig : r ] ) .
the simulated light curve is more consistent with data if the emission radius @xmath46 is large .
zy11 suggested that icmart events should happen at larger radii , say , @xmath83 cm , in order to reach the critical condition of triggering a reconnection / turbulence cascade .
it is intriguing to see that such large - radius icmart events make light curves more resemble the observed ones .
+ + we also discuss the effect of different sizes of reconnection regions .
we make two sets of simulations . in the first set , we vary @xmath19 while keeping @xmath46 constant .
we also keep @xmath84 , so effectively , we are varying the filling factor @xmath43 .
since @xmath85 , the rising time @xmath86 is modified correspondingly .
the results are presented in figure [ fig : size1 ] , which shows the simulated light curves for @xmath87 , @xmath88 , and @xmath89 cm , respectively .
it can be seen that the smaller the @xmath19 , the spikier the light curve .
this is because a smaller @xmath19 corresponds to a shorter duration of each reconnection event . for the @xmath90 cm case
, short - timescale structures are missing , and the light curve is very smooth .
+ + next , we keep both @xmath41 and @xmath43 constant . by varying @xmath19 , we are effectively varying @xmath46 as well , so that the ratio @xmath91 is a constant .
the results are shown in figure [ fig : size2 ] , in which light curves for @xmath87 , @xmath88 , and @xmath89 cm are simulated .
the general trend as discussed above is still there , but since @xmath46 is changed accordingly , the contrasts are less significant , namely , the smaller @xmath19 cases are less spiky and larger @xmath19 cases are less smooth with respect to the case where @xmath46 is fixed ( figure [ fig : size1 ] . since the decay phase is defined by @xmath46 ( section [ sec : r ] above ) , varying @xmath46 with @xmath19 also affects the length of the decaying phase .
+ + we next test the effect of size distribution of the reconnection regions .
we try two possibilities : the power - law distribution with an index @xmath38 ( the kolmogorov type ) ( figure [ fig : size - distribution](a ) ) and a uniform distribution ( figure [ fig : size - distribution](b ) ) .
one can see that the uniform distribution has a smoother shape . in this case , the observed small pulse width distribution is solely determined by the distribution of the doppler factors . for the power - law distribution case , an extra factor ( the intrinsic distribution ) plays a role to make small pulses , so that the light curves are spikier .
+ finally we calculate the light curves for different energy bands .
we consider three cases here , below the peak of the band spectrum ( figure [ fig : bands](a ) ) , i.e. , 15 - 150 kev ( also the observation band for _ swift _ bat ) , above the peak ( 500 - 650 kev , figure [ fig : bands](b ) ) , and across the entire energy band ( 15 - 650 kev , figure [ fig : bands](c ) ) . the high - energy light curve is slightly narrower and spikier , as observed in real grbs .
in general , the overall shape of the light curves does not differ significantly .
+ + as suggested by zy11 , a real grb light curve may consist of multiple icmart events . in figure [ fig : grb ] ,
we simulate three emission episodes and superpose them together to make a mock grb light curve .
we have varied @xmath74 and @xmath67 around the values @xmath92 and @xmath93 , respectively , with small fluctuations in different episodes .
other parameters are the same as those adopted in figure [ fig : direction ] with a @xmath65 gaussian @xmath14-distribution .
the simulated light curve shows reasonable features as observed in some grbs .
we note that in reality the parameters of different icmart events could be more different , so that a variety of light curves could be made , which may account for the diverse prompt emission light curves as observed . in order to test whether our simulated light curves mimic the observed ones
, we also perform a pds analysis of our results . in order to get robust pds slopes ,
for each set of parameters , we perform 10 different monte carlo simulations to get 10 different light curves , derive the pds slope of each light curve , and calculate the average slope to stand for this particular set of parameters . some examples of pdss are presented in figure [ fig : pds ] . generally , the pdss can be fit with a power law , with indices generally steeper than @xmath94 .
the averaged pds indices for all the cases corresponding to figures 1 , 2 , and 4 - 9 are collected in table 1 .
observationally the pds slopes are steeper in softer bands ( e.g. _ swift _ ; guidorzi et al .
2012 ) than harder bands ( e.g. batse ; beloborodov et al .
our simulations recover this trend .
the presented pds values are taken from the _ swift _ band .
it is encouraging to see that the simulated values are generally consistent with the _ swift _ data ( guidorzi et al .
our simulations also show a turnover of pdss in the high - frequency regime with a steeper index .
such a feature is seen in some grbs .
+ .pds slopes of simulated light curves [ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] from table 1 , one can see that various parameters can affect the slope of a pds
. generally speaking , spikier light curves have more power in high frequencies and therefore have a shallower pds slope .
most pds indices listed in table 1 can be understood this way . for figure
[ fig : direction ] , it is seen that more isotropic distributions give steeper slopes . this is because the more isotropic cases give more mini - jets contributing to the broad component , and thus enhance the low - frequency power .
similarly , as shown in figure [ fig : n ] , a smaller number @xmath41 gives richer spiky features , and therefore gives a shallower pds slope .
the @xmath46-dependence ( figure [ fig : r ] ) can be understood as the following : a larger @xmath46 corresponds to a longer curvature decay tail , on top of which rapid variability can be observed , so that the pds slope is shallower . for the size effect ( figure [ fig : size1 ] ) ,
a smaller @xmath19 can give rise to pulses with shorter duration and hence , a more dominant high - frequency power and shallower pds ( figure [ fig : size1 ] ) .
when both @xmath46 and @xmath19 co - vary , this effect is still relevant , but somewhat compensated by the @xmath46 effect ( figure [ fig : size2 ] ) .
next , without a size distribution , the pds is steep ( figure [ fig : size - distribution](b ) ) . by introducing a size distribution ,
one has more contributions to short - time variability from smaller sizes , so the pds becomes shallower .
finally , the light curves in a higher energy band are somewhat spikier ( figure [ fig : bands ] ) and hence have a shallower pds .
this is consistent with the finding of guidorzi et al .
( 2012 ) and beloborodov et al .
( 2000 ) : using the _ swift _ bat data , guidorzi et al .
( 2012 ) obtained a steeper pds slope than beloborodov et al .
( 2000 ) , who used the batse data ( higher energy band ) to perform the analysis .
it is interesting to investigate the change of pds slope due to the change of the initial lorentz factor contrast .
as shown in figure [ fig : evolution ] , in principle one can have strong parameter evolution during one icmart event , which causes complicated evolution of the pds behavior . to avoid such strong evolution , we first fix @xmath53 , and vary @xmath67 so that the ratio @xmath95 evolves in the range of @xmath96 . in figure
[ fig : pds1 ] , we present the pds slope as a function of @xmath95 . the triangles ( and dotted line )
are calculated by turning off parameter evolution ( i.e. , keeping @xmath1 and @xmath7 unchanged throughout ) , and the squares ( and solid line ) are calculated by turning on the parameter evolution ( figure [ fig : evolution ] ) .
one can see that the pds slope becomes progressively shallower as @xmath97 increases .
this is understandable , since a larger @xmath67 corresponds to a stronger fast emission component , and therefore the light curves are spikier ( see figure [ fig : gamma - ratio ] ) .
one can tentatively draw the conclusion that a more magnetized outflow tends to make spikier light curves . since the final lorentz factor of the ejecta at the deceleration time is proportional to @xmath98 , and since observationally the lorentz factor at the onset of afterglow does not have a wide distribution ( e.g. , liang et al . 2010 ) , it is interesting to investigate how the pds slope depends on the lorentz factor contrast when @xmath98 is set to constant . in figure
[ fig : pds2 ] , we present the case of @xmath99 for cases both without and with parameter evolution . the range of the contrast is set to @xmath100 ( i.e. @xmath101 , @xmath102 ) to @xmath103 ( i.e. , @xmath104 ) .
the convention is the same as figure 10 .
the dependence shows more complicated patterns . for the case without evolution ( triangles and
dotted line ) , in general one can see decrease of pds slope when @xmath95 increases ( except the slight tilt at very large @xmath95 ) . this can be understood in the following way .
as @xmath95 increases , one has two competing effects .
the increase of @xmath67 tends to enhance the small timescale variability . on the other hand ,
the decrease of @xmath7 tends to enlarge the @xmath44 cone , so that many more mini - jets not beaming toward the observer could contribute to the slow component .
the net result after competition is that the latter effect wins , so that the long - time variability is more enhanced , and hence , a steeper pds is obtained .
this trend is overturned when @xmath67 exceeds @xmath74 near the end of the curve . when evolution is taken into account ( squares and solid line ) , the situation is even more complicated .
when @xmath67 is small enough , the above - mentioned trend is retained .
however , when @xmath67 becomes large enough , evolution of @xmath1 and @xmath7 becomes significant ( figure [ fig : evolution ] ) , so that quickly one can reach a regime with small @xmath1 and large @xmath7 .
the average pds would be dominated by this late phase , so that the general trend is reversed from the no - evolution case . in reality , since a real grb light curve would usually be the superposition of multiple icmart events , the clean evolution expected in a single icmart event would be smeared out .
in this paper we have simulated a sample of grb prompt emission light curves and pdss within the framework of the icmart model ( zy11 ) .
this model was developed to model grbs whose jet composition is still somewhat poynting flux dominated in the emission region .
this was motivated by the non - detection of the photosphere component in some grbs ( zhang & peer 2009 ; zhang et al .
since the emission region has a moderately high @xmath0 , in order to generate a reconnection / turbulence cascade envisaged by zy11 , the energy dissipation region must have many locally lorentz - boosted emission regions , or mini - jets .
the detected emission would be the superposition of emissions from all these mini - jets , which beam to random directions in the bulk comoving frame .
other global magnetic dissipation models for grb prompt emission have been proposed in the literature ( e.g. , lyutikov & blandford 2003 ; giannios & spruit 2006 ) .
if these models invoke runaway generation of mini - jets at a relatively large emission radius , then the simulations in this paper also apply to those scenarios . lacking detailed numerical simulations for a reconnection / turbulence cascade
, we carried out a monte carlo simulation by inputting many mini - jets with certain directional and temporal distributions within the icmart scenario .
we investigated the roles of the directional distribution , lorentz factor contrast , number of reconnection regions , emission radius , size of the mini - jet , mini - jet size distribution , energy dependence , etc .
, in defining the light curves and their pdss .
we adopt our simulation parameters according to observations ( e.g. , typical length of reconnection region @xmath52 cm corresponding to observed variability timescale @xmath59 s , 15 - 150 kev band for simulated light curves corresponding to _ swift _ bat band , and so on ) , as well as the requirements of the icmart model itseft ( e.g. , emission region radius @xmath51 cm in order to make sure that runaway reconnection can happen , and exponential growth of the number of reconnection events with time ) . within the icmart framework ,
most of our parameters are physically related to each other self - consistently .
even though some simplified assumptions are introduced so that the light curves may not fully represent the complex physics in an icmart event , our simulated light curves nonetheless show some encouraging features that are consistent with the grb prompt emission data .
the most noticeable feature is the superposition of an underlying slow component and more erratic fast component , which seems to be consistent with the data ( gao et al .
2012 ; vetere et al .
the slow component is caused by the superposition of emission from all the mini - jets in the emission region , while the fast component is related to those mini - jets that happen to beam toward the observer .
we follow the physics of an icmart event , including the exponential growth of the reconnection region , dissipation of the magnetic field energy ( so that @xmath0 drops with time ) , and acceleration of the bulk ejecta during the energy dissipation process and find that the erratic grb light curves as observed can be generally reproduced within the model . among all the model parameters , the lorentz factor contrast and the number of mini - jets play an important role in defining the `` spikiness '' of the light curve . we also derived the pds slopes of the simulated light curves , and found that they are generally consistent with the data . generally speaking , the larger the contrast @xmath95 ( keeping @xmath74 constant ) , the shallower the pds slope .
besides grbs , the `` jet - in - the - jet '' scenario has been discussed in other astrophysical contexts .
giannios et al .
( 2010 ) interpreted the fast tev variability of active galactic nuleus jets using the mini - jet scenario .
yuan et al .
( 2011 ) applied the scenario to account for the gamma - ray flares of the crab nebula .
compared with earlier work of narayan & kumar ( 2009 ) , kumar & narayan ( 2009 ) , and lazar et al .
( 2009 ) , the new ingredient introduced in our paper is the exponential growth of the number of mini - jets as a function of time , as envisaged in the icmart model ( zy11 ; see also stern & svensson 1996 ) . as a result
, our model allows many mini - jets emitting simultaneously at any instant .
this is the key ingredient to define the broad component of each icmart event .
a grb light curve is composed of multiple icmart events ( figure 8) , which are controlled by the erratic central engine activity . in order to set up the monte carlo simulations , we had to introduce a number of assumptions .
these include power - law distribution of the size of reconnection regions , gaussian shape of each pulse , same intrinsic radiation spectrum for all emitters , exponential growth of numbers of pulses with time , isotropic or gaussian distribution of the mini - jet directions , and so on .
some factors are still missing .
for example , in the comoving frame of the jet bulk but outside the mini - jets , there would also be particles that give rise to radiation .
the effects of this inter - mini - jet emission should be investigated ( e.g. , lin et al . 2013 ) .
the physical conditions of real grbs must be more complex than what is modeled here , so that one may not reproduce the full observational features of grbs with the simulations presented in this paper .
nonetheless , our simulations show the encouraging results that the simulated light curves based on these simplified assumptions can indeed reproduce some key features of the observations , e.g. the slow and fast variability components and a variety of degree of spikiness of the light curves . by changing parameters ( e.g. , @xmath14-distribution , lorentz factor contrast , jet opening angle ) ,
diverse light curves can be generated , ranging from relatively smooth to relatively spiky ones .
the pdss of the simulated light curves are also generally consistent with the data .
all these suggest that the icmart model may be a good candidate to interpret grb prompt emission . within the icmart theoretical framework
, the following constraints can be made to the model parameters .
( 1 ) to reproduce the general fast - rising slower decay shape of broad pulses , the emission radius should be relatively large ( @xmath105 cm and beyond ) .
( 2 ) since many grbs show high - amplitude rapid variability , the grb initial magnetization parameter @xmath68 in the emission region could be high ( e.g. , from several to hundreds ) .
( 3 ) the observed minimum variability timescale constrains that @xmath19 can not be too large and has to be @xmath106 cm .
( 4 ) in order not to smear these peaks by overgenerating mini - jets , one also requires a filling factor @xmath42 , suggesting that in these cases the global @xmath0 of the outflow after the icmart event may not drop to unity .
( 5 ) erratic light curves with multiple episodes suggest that the grb central engine acts multiple times to eject highly magnetized shells so that multiple icmart events can be generated within one burst .
( 6 ) the existence of smooth - pulse grbs suggests that in some cases the @xmath68 is not much larger than unity ( so that @xmath67 is not much larger than unity ) , or there are so many mini - jets operating simultaneously .
other information ( e.g. polarization properties and prompt emission efficiency ) is needed to break the degeneracy .
we thank kohta murase , pawan kumar , zi - gao dai , he gao , da - bin lin , and chun li for useful discussion , and an anonymous referee for very helpful suggestions .
this work is partially supported by nsf through grant ast-0908362 .
bo zhang acknowledges a scholarship from china scholarship council for support .
amati , l. , frontera , f. , tavani , m. , et al .
2002 , , 390 , 81 band , d. , matteson , j. , ford , l. , et al .
1993 , , 413 , 281 beloborodov , a. m. , stern , b. e. , & svensson , r. 2000 , , 535 , 158 cho , j. , lazarian , a. , & vishniac , e. t. 2003 , turbulence and magnetic fields in astrophysics , 614 , 56 daigne , f. , & mochkovitch , r. 1998 , , 296 , 275 daigne , f. , & mochkovitch , r. 2002 , , 336 , 1271 dermer , c. d. , & mitman , k. e. 1999 , , 513 , l5 drenkhahn , g. & spruit , h. c. 2002 , , 391 , 1141 fishman , g. j. , & meegan , c. a. 1995 , , 33 , 415 gao , h. , zhang , b .- b .
, & zhang , b. 2012 , , 748 , 134 giannios , d. , & spruit , h. c. 2006 , , 450 , 887 giannios , d. , uzdensky , d. a. , & begelman , m. c. 2010 , , 402 , 1649 ghisellini , g. , celotti , a. , & lazzati , d. 2000 , , 313 , l1 goldreich , p. , & sridhar , s. 1995 , , 438 , 763 guidorzi , c. , margutti , r. , amati , l. , et al . 2012 , , 422 , 1785 hascot , r. , daigne , f. , & mochkovitch , r. 2012 , , 542 , l29 kobayashi , s. , piran , t. , & sari , r. 1997 , , 490 , 92 kumar , p. 1999
, , 523 , l113 kumar , p. , & mcmahon , e. 2008 , , 384 , 33 kumar , p. , & narayan , r. 2009 , , 395 , 472 lazar , a. , nakar , e. , & piran , t. 2009 , , 695 , l10 lazarian , a. , & vishniac , e. t. 1999 , , 517 , 700 lei , w .- h . , zhang , b. , & liang , e .- w .
2013 , , 765 , 125 liang , e .- w . , yi , s .- x . , zhang , j. , et al .
2010 , , 725 , 2209 lin , d .- b .
, gu , w .- m .
, hou , s .- j . ,
liu , t. sun , m .- y . ,
lu , j .- f .
2013 , , 776 , 41 lyubarsky , y. e. 2005 , , 358 , 113 lyutikov , m. , & blandford , r. 2003 , arxiv : astro - ph/0312347 narayan , r. , & kumar , p. 2009
, , 394 , l117 panaitescu , a. , spada , m. , & mszros , p. 1999
, , 522 , l105 rees , m. j. , & meszaros , p. 1994
, , 430 , l93 sari , r. , & piran , t. 1997 , , 485 , 270 shen , r .- f .
, & zhang , b. 2009 , , 398 , 1936 spruit , h. c. , daigne , f. , & drenkhahn , g. 2001 , , 369 , 694 stern , b. e. , & svensson , r. 1996 , , 469 , l109 tagliaferri , g. , goad , m. , chincarini , g. , et al . 2005 , , 436 , 985 uhm , z. l. , & zhang , b. 2013 , arxiv:1303.2704 vetere , l. , massaro , e. , costa , e. , soffitta , p. , & ventura , g. 2006 , , 447 , 499 yamazaki , r. , ioka , k. , & nakamura , t. 2004 , , 607 , l103 yuan , q. , yin , p .- f .
, wu , x .- f .
, et al .
2011 , , 730 , l15 zhang , b. , & mszros , p. 2002
, , 581 , 1236 zhang , b. , & kobayashi , s. 2005 , , 628 , 315 zhang , b. , fan , y. z. , dyks , j. , et al .
2006 , , 642 , 354 zhang , b. , & peer , a. 2009 , , 700 , l65 zhang , b. , & yan , h. 2011 , , 726 , 90 ( zy11 ) zhang , b .- b . , zhang , b. , liang , e .- w . , et al .
2011 , , 730 , 141 zrake , j. , & macfadyen , a. i. 2012 , , 744 , 32 zweibel , e. g. , & yamada , m. 2009 , , 47 , 291 | in this paper , we simulate the prompt emission light curves of gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) within the framework of the internal - collision - induced magnetic reconnection and turbulence ( icmart ) model .
this model applies to grbs with a moderately high magnetization parameter @xmath0 in the emission region .
we show that this model can produce highly variable light curves with both fast and slow components .
the rapid variability is caused by many locally doppler - boosted mini - emitters due to turbulent magnetic reconnection in a moderately high @xmath0 flow .
the runaway growth and subsequent depletion of these mini - emitters as a function of time define a broad slow component for each icmart event .
a grb light curve is usually composed of multiple icmart events that are fundamentally driven by the erratic grb central engine activity . allowing variations of the model parameters , one is able to reproduce a variety of light curves and the power density spectra as observed . |
markov s principle has a special status in constructive mathematics . one way to formulate this principle
is that if it is impossible that a given algorithm does not terminate , then it does terminate .
it is equivalent to the fact that if a set of natural number and its complement are both computably enumerable , then this set is decidable .
this form is often used in recursivity theory .
this principle was first formulated by markov , who called it `` leningrad s principle '' , and founded a branch of constructive mathematics around this principle @xcite .
this principle is also equivalent to the fact that if a given real number is _ not _ equal to @xmath0 then this number is _ apart _ from @xmath0 ( that is this number is @xmath1 or @xmath2 for some rational number @xmath3 ) . on this form ,
it was explicitly _ refuted _ by brouwer in intuitionistic mathematics , who gave an example of a real number ( well defined intuitionistically ) which is not equal to @xmath0 , but also not apart from @xmath0 .
( the motivation of brouwer for this example was to show the necessity of using _ negation _ in intuitionistic mathematics @xcite . )
the idea of brouwer can be represented formally using topological models @xcite . in a neutral approach to mathematics , such as bishop s @xcite ,
markov s principle is simply left undecided .
we also expect to be able to prove that markov s principle is _ not _ provable in formal system in which we can express bishop s mathematics .
for instance , kreisel @xcite introduced _
modified realizability _ to show that markov s principle is not derivable in the formal system @xmath4 .
similarly , one would expect that markov s principle is _ not _ derivable in martin - lf type theory @xcite , but , as far as we know , such a result has not been established yet .
we say that a statement @xmath5 is _ independent _ of some formal system if @xmath5 can not be derived in that system .
a statement in the formal system of martin - lf type theory ( @xmath6 ) is represented by a closed type .
a statement / type @xmath5 is derivable if it is inhabited by some term @xmath7 ( written @xmath8 ) .
this is the so - called propositions - as - types principle .
correspondingly we say that a statement @xmath5 ( represented as a type ) is independent of @xmath6 if there is no term @xmath7 such that @xmath8 . the main result of this paper is to show that markov s principle is independent of martin - lf type theory .
the main idea for proving this independence is to follow brouwer s argument .
we want to extend type theory with a `` generic '' infinite sequence of @xmath0 and @xmath9 and establish that it is both absurd that this generic sequence is never @xmath0 , but also that we can not show that it _ has to _ take the value @xmath0 . to add such a generic sequence is exactly like adding a _ cohen real _
@xcite in forcing extension of set theory .
a natural attempt for doing this will be to consider a _
topological model _ of type theory ( sheaf model over cantor space ) , extending the work @xcite to type theory .
however , while it is well understood how to represent universes in _ presheaf _ model @xcite , it has turned out to be surprisingly difficult to represent universes in _ sheaf _ models , see @xcite and @xcite .
our approach is here instead a purely _ syntactical _ description of a forcing extension of type theory ( refining previous work of @xcite ) , which contains a formal symbol for the generic sequence and a proof that it is absurd that this generic sequence is never @xmath0 , together with a _ normalization _
theorem , from which we can deduce that we _ can not _ prove that this generic sequence has to take the value @xmath0 . since this formal system is an extension of type theory , the independence of markov s principle follows . as stated in @xcite , which describes an elegant generalization of this principle in type theory , markov s principle is an important technical tool for proving termination of computations , and thus can play a crucial role if type theory is extended with general recursion as in @xcite .
this paper is organized as follows .
we first describe the rules of the version of type theory we are considering .
this version can be seen as a simplified version of type theory as represented in the system agda @xcite , and in particular , contrary to the work @xcite , we allow @xmath10-conversion , and we express conversion as _
judgment_. markov s principle can be formulated in a natural way in this formal system .
we describe then the forcing extension of type theory , where we add a cohen real . for proving normalization ,
we follow tait s computability method @xcite , but we have to consider an extension of this with a computability _ relation _ in order to interpret the conversion judgment .
this can be seen as a forcing extension of the technique used in @xcite .
using this computability argument , it is then possible to show that we can not show that the generic sequence has to take the value @xmath0 .
we end by a refinement of this method , giving a consistent extension of type theory where the _ negation _ of markov s principle is provable
the syntax of our type theory is given by the grammar : @xmath11 we use the notation @xmath12 as a short hand for the term @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is the successor constructor .
we describe a type theory with one universe la russell , natural numbers , functional extensionality and surjective pairing , hereafter referred to as @xmath6.-conversion and surjective pairing . ] * natural numbers : * * booleans : * * unit type : * * empty type : * * dependent functions : * * dependent pairs : * * universe : * * congruence : * the following four rules are admissible in the this type system @xcite , we consider them as rules of our type system : markov s principle can be represented in type theory by the type @xmath15\ ] ] where @xmath16 is defined by @xmath17 .
note that @xmath18 is inhabited when @xmath19 and empty when @xmath20 .
thus @xmath21 is inhabited if there is @xmath22 such that @xmath19 .
the main result of this paper is the following : thmmainresult [ thm : mainresult ] there is no term @xmath7 such that @xmath23 .
an _ extension _ of @xmath6 is given by introducing new objects , judgment forms and derivation rules .
this means in particular that any judgment valid in @xmath6 is valid in the extension .
consistent _ extension is one in which the type @xmath24 is uninhabited . to show theorem [ thm : mainresult ] we will form a consistent extension of @xmath6 with a new constant @xmath25 where @xmath26 .
we will then show that @xmath27 is derivable while @xmath28 is not derivable . thus showing that @xmath29 is not derivable in this extension and consequently not derivable in @xmath6 . while this is sufficient to establish independence in the sense of non - derivability of @xmath30 . to establish the independence of @xmath30 in the stronger sense one also needs to show that @xmath31 is not derivable in @xmath6 .
this can achieved by reference to the work of aczel @xcite where it is shown that @xmath6 extended with @xmath32 is consistent .
since @xmath33 we have @xmath34 .
if we let @xmath35 we get that @xmath36 . by @xmath37 abstraction
we have @xmath38 .
we can then conclude that there is no term @xmath7 such that @xmath39 .
finally , we will refine the result of theorem [ thm : mainresult ] by building a consistent extension of @xmath6 where @xmath31 is derivable . a _ condition _
@xmath40 is a graph of a partial finite function from @xmath41 to @xmath42 .
we denote by @xmath43 the empty condition .
we write @xmath44 when @xmath45 .
we say @xmath46 _ extends _ @xmath40 ( written @xmath47 ) if @xmath40 is a subset of @xmath46 .
a condition can be thought of as a basic compact open in cantor space @xmath48 .
two conditions @xmath40 and @xmath46 are _ compatible _ if @xmath49 is a condition and we write @xmath50 for @xmath49 . if @xmath51 we write @xmath52 for @xmath53 and @xmath54 for @xmath55 .
we define the notion of _ partition _ corresponding to the notion of finite covering of a compact open in cantor space .
we write @xmath56 to say that @xmath57 is a partition of @xmath40 and we define it as follows : 1 .
2 . if @xmath51 and @xmath59 and @xmath60 then @xmath61 . note that if @xmath56 then any @xmath62 and @xmath63 are incompatible unless @xmath64 .
if moreover @xmath65 then @xmath66 .
we extend the given type theory by annotating the judgments with conditions , i.e. replacing each judgment @xmath67 in the given type system with a judgment @xmath68 .
in addition we add the locality rule : we add a term @xmath25 for the generic point along with the introduction and conversion rules : we add a term @xmath69 and the rule : since @xmath69 inhabits the type @xmath70 , our goal is then to show that no term inhabits the type @xmath71 .
it follows directly from the description of the forcing extension that : [ lem : extension ] @xmath72 in standard type theory then @xmath73 . note that if @xmath74 and @xmath68 then @xmath75 ( monotonicity ) .
a statement @xmath5 ( represented as a closed type ) is derivable in this extension if @xmath76 for some @xmath7 , which implies @xmath77 for all @xmath40 . similarly to @xcite we can state a conservativity result for this extension .
let @xmath78 and @xmath79 be two terms of standard type theory .
we say that @xmath80 is compatible with a condition @xmath40
if @xmath80 is such that @xmath81 whenever @xmath45 and @xmath82 otherwise .
we say that @xmath83 is compatible with a condition @xmath40 if @xmath80 is compatible with @xmath40 and @xmath83 is given by @xmath84 where @xmath85 is the smallest natural number such that @xmath86 . to see that @xmath83 is well typed , note that by design @xmath87 thus @xmath88 and @xmath89 .
we have then @xmath90 , thus @xmath91 .
let @xmath92 and @xmath79 be compatible with some condition @xmath40 . if @xmath93 then @xmath94 \vdash j[g/{\mathsf{f}},v/{\mathsf{w}}]$ ] , i.e. replacing @xmath25 with @xmath80 then @xmath69 with @xmath83 we obtain a valid judgment in standard type theory .
in particular , if @xmath95 where neither @xmath25 nor @xmath69 occur in @xmath96 or @xmath97 then @xmath72 is a valid judgment in standard type theory .
the proof is by induction on the type system and it is straightforward for all the standard rules . for ( @xmath25-eval )
we have @xmath98 \coloneqq g\ , { \sbox{\myboxa}{$\m@thn$ } \setbox\myboxb\null \ht\myboxb=\ht\myboxa \dp\myboxb=\dp\myboxa \wd\myboxb=0.75\wd\myboxa \sbox\myboxb{$\m@th\overline{\copy\myboxb}$ } \setlength\mylena{\the\wd\myboxa } \addtolength\mylena{-\the\wd\myboxb } \ifdim\wd\myboxb<\wd\myboxa \rlap{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb}{\usebox\myboxa } \else \hskip -0.5\mylena\rlap{\usebox\myboxa}{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb } \fi}$ ] and since @xmath80 is compatible with @xmath40 we have @xmath99\vdash g\ , { \sbox{\myboxa}{$\m@thn$ } \setbox\myboxb\null \ht\myboxb=\ht\myboxa \dp\myboxb=\dp\myboxa \wd\myboxb=0.75\wd\myboxa \sbox\myboxb{$\m@th\overline{\copy\myboxb}$ } \setlength\mylena{\the\wd\myboxa } \addtolength\mylena{-\the\wd\myboxb } \ifdim\wd\myboxb<\wd\myboxa \rlap{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb}{\usebox\myboxa } \else \hskip -0.5\mylena\rlap{\usebox\myboxa}{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb } \fi}= p(n){\!:\!}{{\mathsf{n}_2}}$ ] whenever @xmath100 . for ( @xmath69-term )
we have @xmath101 & \coloneqq ( { \mathsf{w}}{\!:\!}\neg\neg ( \sigma(x{\!:\!}{\mathsf{n}})\ , { \mathsf{iszero}}\,(g\,x)))[v/{\mathsf{w}}]\\ & \coloneqq v{\!:\!}\neg\neg ( \sigma(x{\!:\!}{\mathsf{n}})\,{\mathsf{iszero}}\,(g\,x ) ) .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] for ( loc ) the statement follows from the observation that when @xmath80 is compatible with @xmath40 and @xmath56 then @xmath80 is compatible with exactly one @xmath102
in this section we outline a semantics for the forcing extension given in the previous section .
we will interpret the judgments of type theory by computability predicates and relations defined by reducibility to computable weak head normal forms .
we extend the @xmath103 conversion with @xmath104 whenever @xmath45 . to ease the presentation of the proofs and definitions we introduce _ evaluation contexts _ following @xcite .
@xmath105 \mid \mathbb{e}\ , u \mid \mathbb{e}{.1}\mid \mathbb{e}{.2}\mid { \mathsf{s}}\,\mathbb{e } \mid { \mathsf{f}}\ , \mathbb{e}\\ & { { \mathsf{rec}_{{\mathsf{n}_0}}}}(\lambda x. c)\,\mathbb{e } \mid { { \mathsf{rec}_{{\mathsf{n}_1}}}}(\lambda x. c)\,a\,\mathbb{e } \mid { { \mathsf{rec}_{{\mathsf{n}_2}}}}(\lambda x. c)\ , a_0\,a_1\,\mathbb{e}\mid { { \mathsf{rec}_{\mathsf{n}}}}(\lambda x. c)\ , c_z\,g\,\mathbb{e}\end{aligned}\ ] ] an expression @xmath106 $ ] is then the expression resulting from replacing the hole @xmath107 $ ] by @xmath108 .
we have the following reduction rules : note that we reduce under @xmath14 . also note that the relation @xmath109 is monotone , that is if @xmath47 and @xmath110 then @xmath111 . in the following
we will show that @xmath109 is also local , i.e. if @xmath56 and @xmath112 for all @xmath62 then @xmath113 .
[ untypedredislocal ] if @xmath114 and @xmath115 and @xmath116 then @xmath113 .
by induction on the derivation of @xmath115 . if @xmath115 is derived by ( @xmath25-red ) then @xmath117 and @xmath118 for some @xmath119 .
but since we also have a reduction @xmath120 , we have @xmath121 which could only be the case if @xmath122 .
thus we have a reduction @xmath123 .
if on the other hand we have a derivation @xmath124 , then we have @xmath113 directly .
if the derivation @xmath115 has the form @xmath106{\rightarrowtriangle}_{p(m\mapsto { \mathsf{0 } } ) } \mathbb{e}[e']$ ] then we have @xmath125 and the statement follows by induction .
[ reductionislevelbehaved ] let @xmath74 .
if @xmath112 then @xmath113 or @xmath7 has the form @xmath126 $ ] for some @xmath127 . by induction on the derivation of @xmath112 .
if the reduction @xmath112 has the form @xmath128 then either @xmath129 and the statement follows or @xmath122 and we have @xmath113 . if on the other hand we have @xmath124 then @xmath113 immediately . if @xmath112 has the form @xmath106 { \rightarrowtriangle}_q \mathbb{e}[e']$ ] then @xmath130 and the statement follows by induction .
[ eitherreduceorstuck ] let @xmath115 and @xmath131 for some @xmath132 .
if @xmath133 then @xmath113 ; otherwise , @xmath7 has the form @xmath126 $ ] .
define @xmath134 to mean @xmath113 and @xmath135 and write @xmath136 for @xmath137 .
note that it holds that if @xmath138 and @xmath139 then @xmath140 $ ] and if @xmath141 then @xmath142 and @xmath143 $ ] .
we define a closure for this relation as follows : we will write @xmath144 as a short hand for @xmath145 .
a term @xmath7 is _ in _
@xmath40-whnf if whenever @xmath146 then @xmath147 .
a whnf is _ canonical _ if it has one of the forms : @xmath148 a @xmath40-whnf is _ proper _ if it is canonical or it is of the form @xmath149 $ ] for @xmath129 .
a canonical @xmath40-whnf has no further reduction at any @xmath74 .
a non - canonical proper @xmath40-whnf , i.e. of the form @xmath149 $ ] for @xmath129 , have further reduction at some @xmath74 , namely when @xmath150 .
we have the following corollaries to lemma [ untypedredislocal ] and corollary [ eitherreduceorstuck ] .
[ typedreduceorstuck ] let @xmath114 .
let @xmath151 and @xmath152 .
if @xmath133 then @xmath134 ; otherwise @xmath7 has the form @xmath126 $ ] .
[ onestepredmonolocal ] let @xmath56 and @xmath153 for all @xmath62 .
we have @xmath134 . by induction on @xmath57 . if @xmath154 the the statement follows .
assume the statement holds for @xmath155 and @xmath156 and let @xmath157 .
by ih , @xmath158 and @xmath159 .
from lemma [ untypedredislocal ] , @xmath113 . since @xmath160 and @xmath161 , then @xmath162 . thus @xmath163 . note that if @xmath74 and @xmath164 then @xmath165 .
however if @xmath166 and @xmath167 it is not necessarily the case that @xmath168 .
e.g. we have that @xmath169 and @xmath170 but it is _ not _ true that @xmath171 for a closed term @xmath77 , we say that @xmath7 _ has _ a @xmath40-whnf if @xmath164 and @xmath172 is in @xmath40-whnf .
if @xmath172 is canonical , respectively proper , we say that @xmath7 has a canonical , respectively proper , @xmath40-whnf .
since the reduction relation is deterministic we have : [ lem : uniquenessofwhnf ] a term @xmath77 has at most one @xmath40-whnf
. [ properwhnflocal ] let @xmath77 and @xmath114 .
if @xmath7 has proper @xmath173-whnf and a proper @xmath174-whnf then @xmath7 has a proper @xmath40-whnf .
let @xmath166 and @xmath175 with @xmath172 in proper @xmath173-whnf and @xmath83 in proper @xmath174-whnf . if @xmath147 or @xmath176 then @xmath7 is already in proper @xmath40-whnf .
alternatively we have reductions @xmath177 and @xmath178 . by corollary [ typedreduceorstuck ] either @xmath7 is in proper @xmath40-whnf or @xmath179 and @xmath180 .
it then follows by induction that @xmath181 , and thus @xmath7 , has a proper @xmath40-whnf .
we define inductively a forcing relation @xmath182 to express that a type @xmath5 is computable at @xmath40 . mutually by recursion
we define relations @xmath183 ( @xmath184 computable of type @xmath5 at @xmath40 ) , @xmath185 ( @xmath5 and @xmath186 are computably equal at @xmath40 ) , and @xmath187 ( @xmath184 is computably equal to @xmath188 of type @xmath5 at @xmath40 ) .
we write @xmath189 for @xmath190 and @xmath191 .
the definition fits the generalized mutual induction - recursion schema @xcite .
the following rules have an implicit ( hidden ) premise @xmath192 1 .
assuming @xmath182 by @xmath193 1 . assuming @xmath194 then
@xmath185 if 1 .
2 . @xmath196 $ ] , @xmath197 and @xmath198 .
@xmath199 for all @xmath7 .
@xmath200 for all @xmath7 and @xmath172 .
2 . assuming @xmath182 by @xmath201 1 . assuming @xmath194 then
@xmath185 if 1 .
2 . @xmath196 $ ] , @xmath197 and @xmath198 .
2 . @xmath203 if 1 .
@xmath204 2 .
@xmath205{\!:\!}a$ ] , @xmath129 and @xmath206 .
3 . assuming @xmath207 and @xmath208 then @xmath209 if 1 .
@xmath204 and @xmath210 .
2 . @xmath204 and @xmath211 { \!:\!}a , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath212 .
@xmath205{\!:\!}a , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath212 .
3 . assuming @xmath182 by @xmath213 1 . assuming @xmath194 then
@xmath185 if 1 . @xmath214
2 . @xmath196 $ ] , @xmath197 and @xmath198 .
2 . @xmath203 if 1 .
@xmath215 , @xmath216 .
2 . @xmath205 $ ] , @xmath129 and @xmath206 .
3 . assuming @xmath207 and @xmath208 then @xmath209 if 1 .
@xmath215 and @xmath217 , @xmath216 .
@xmath215 , @xmath216 and @xmath211{\!:\!}a , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath212 .
@xmath205{\!:\!}a , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath212 .
4 . assuming @xmath182 by @xmath218 1 . assuming @xmath194 then
@xmath185 if 1 .
2 . @xmath196 $ ] , @xmath197 and @xmath198 .
2 . @xmath203 if 1 . @xmath220 .
2 . @xmath205 $ ] , @xmath129 and @xmath206 .
3 . assuming @xmath207 and @xmath208 then @xmath209 if 1 .
@xmath220 and @xmath221 .
2 . @xmath220 and @xmath211{\!:\!}a , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath212 .
@xmath205{\!:\!}a , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath212 .
5 . assuming @xmath182 by @xmath222 ( let @xmath223 ) .
1 . assuming @xmath194 and @xmath224 then @xmath185 if 1 .
@xmath225 and @xmath226 and @xmath227=e[a])$ ] .
2 . @xmath196 $ ] , @xmath197 and @xmath198 .
2 . assuming @xmath77 then @xmath203 if 1 .
@xmath228 $ ] and @xmath229)$ ] .
3 . assuming @xmath207 and @xmath208 and @xmath162 then @xmath209 if 1 .
@xmath230)$ ] 6 .
assuming @xmath182 by @xmath231 ( let @xmath232 ) .
1 . assuming @xmath194 and @xmath224 then @xmath185 if 1 .
@xmath233 and @xmath226 and @xmath227=e[a])$ ] .
2 . @xmath196 $ ] , @xmath197 and @xmath198 .
2 . assuming @xmath77 then @xmath203 if 1 .
@xmath234 and @xmath235 $ ] 3 . assuming @xmath207 and @xmath208 and @xmath162 then @xmath209 if 1 .
@xmath236 and @xmath237 $ ] 7 .
assuming @xmath182 by @xmath238 ( i.e. @xmath239 ) .
1 . assuming @xmath194 then @xmath185 if @xmath240 2 .
assuming @xmath241 then @xmath242 if 1 .
@xmath243 with @xmath244 2 .
@xmath245 and @xmath246 and + @xmath247 { \!:\!}a)$ ] and @xmath248=g[b ] { \!:\!}a)$ ] .
3 . @xmath249 $ ] , @xmath129 and @xmath250 .
3 . assuming @xmath251 and @xmath252 and @xmath253 then @xmath254 if 1 .
@xmath243 and @xmath255 for @xmath256 .
2 . @xmath257 and @xmath258 and + @xmath259 and @xmath247 = e[a ] { \!:\!}a)$ ] 3 .
@xmath260 and @xmath261 and + @xmath259 and @xmath247 = e[a ] { \!:\!}a)$ ] 4 .
@xmath262 and @xmath263 , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath264 . 5 .
@xmath265 , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath264
assuming @xmath182 by @xmath266 ( i.e. @xmath267 , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath268 ) .
1 . assuming @xmath194 and @xmath269 then @xmath185 if @xmath198 2 . assuming @xmath77 then
@xmath203 if @xmath206 .
3 . assuming @xmath207 and @xmath208 and @xmath162 then @xmath209 if @xmath270 .
note from the definition that when @xmath185 then @xmath182 and @xmath194 , when @xmath183 then @xmath182 and when @xmath187 then @xmath183 and @xmath271 .
it follows also from the definition that @xmath272 whenever @xmath190 .
the clause ( @xmath273 ) gives semantics to _
variable types_. for example , if @xmath274 and @xmath275 the type @xmath276 has reductions @xmath277 and @xmath278 .
thus @xmath279 and @xmath280 and since @xmath281 we have @xmath282 . [ forcedtypeslocallyreducetocanonical ]
if @xmath182 then there is a partition @xmath56 where @xmath5 has a canonical @xmath46-whnf for all @xmath62 . if @xmath185 then there is a partition @xmath56 where @xmath5 and @xmath186 have similar canonical @xmath46-whnf for all @xmath62 , i.e. @xmath283 and @xmath284 where @xmath285 is of the form @xmath286 , @xmath287 , @xmath288 , @xmath289 , @xmath290 , @xmath291 , or @xmath292 . the statement follows from the definition by induction on the derivation of @xmath182 [ existenceofpwhnfislocal ] let @xmath56 . if @xmath293 for all @xmath62 then @xmath5 has a proper @xmath40-whnf
. follows from lemma [ forcedtypeslocallyreducetocanonical ] and corollary [ properwhnflocal ] by induction .
we will now proceed to prove properties of the forcing relation , monotonicity , locality , reflexivity , symmetry and transitivity . in the premise of any forcing @xmath190
there are a number of typing judgments .
since the type system satisfy these properties we will largely ignore these typing judgment in the proofs .
[ lem : typeintromonotone ] if @xmath182 and @xmath74 then @xmath293 .
let @xmath182 and @xmath74 .
by induction on the derivation of @xmath182 1 .
( derivation by @xmath193 , @xmath201 , @xmath213 , @xmath218 or @xmath238 . )
let @xmath294 for @xmath295 .
since the reduction is monotone we have @xmath296 , thus @xmath293 .
( derivation by @xmath222 or @xmath231 . )
let @xmath297 . from the premise @xmath298 , by ih
, it follows that @xmath299 . from @xmath300)$ ] and @xmath301=g[b])$ ] it follows directly that @xmath302)$ ] and @xmath303=g[b])$ ] . hence @xmath293 .
( derivation by @xmath266 . )
let @xmath304 , m\notin { \textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] .
if @xmath305 then @xmath306 .
since @xmath307 with a derivation strictly smaller than the derivation of @xmath182 then by ih @xmath293
. alternatively , @xmath308 $ ] but then @xmath309 . by ih we have @xmath310 and thus @xmath293 .
[ lem : typeeqmonotone ] if @xmath185 and @xmath74 then @xmath311 .
let @xmath185 and @xmath74 .
we have then that @xmath182 and @xmath194 . by lemma [ lem : typeintromonotone ] we have that @xmath293 and @xmath312 . by induction on the derivation of @xmath182 1 .
[ floctypeq ] let @xmath182 by @xmath266 , i.e. @xmath267 , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath313 .
by induction on the derivation of @xmath185 .
if @xmath314 then @xmath315 . since the derivation of @xmath316 is strictly smaller than that of @xmath317 , by ih @xmath311
otherwise , @xmath318 and @xmath319 $ ] and since @xmath320 , by ih , @xmath321 . by the definition @xmath311 .
2 . let @xmath182 by @xmath218 ( i.e. @xmath322 ) .
by induction on the derivation of @xmath185 1 .
let @xmath219 .
we have directly that @xmath311 by monotonicity of the reduction .
2 . let @xmath196 , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath313 .
the statement then follows similarly to ( [ floctypeq ] ) .
+ the statement follows similarly when @xmath182 holds by @xmath323 .
3 . let @xmath223 .
by induction on the derivation of @xmath185 1 .
let @xmath324 and @xmath226 and @xmath325=e[a])$ ] . by ih @xmath326 .
directly we have @xmath327=e[a])$ ] .
thus @xmath311 .
2 . let @xmath196 , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath313 .
the statement then follows similarly to ( [ floctypeq ] ) .
+ the statement follows similarly when @xmath182 holds by @xmath231 .
( derivation by @xmath238 ) we have then that @xmath240 and thus @xmath311 .
[ lem : termintromonotone ] if @xmath207 and @xmath74 then @xmath328 .
let @xmath207 and @xmath74 . from the definition we have that @xmath182 .
from lemma [ lem : typeintromonotone ] we have that @xmath293 . by induction on the derivation of @xmath182 . 1 .
let @xmath182 by @xmath218 .
by induction on the derivation of @xmath207
let @xmath329 .
then @xmath330 and @xmath328 .
2 . let @xmath205{\!:\!}a , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath331 . if @xmath150 then @xmath332 , since the derivation of @xmath333 is strictly smaller than the derivation @xmath207 , by ih , @xmath328 . otherwise , @xmath334 and @xmath335 { \!:\!}a$ ] .
but @xmath336 and by ih @xmath337 . by the definition @xmath328 .
+ the statement follows similarly when @xmath182 is derived by @xmath201 or @xmath213 .
2 . let @xmath182 by @xmath238 .
the statement follows similarly to lemma [ lem : typeintromonotone ] .
3 . let @xmath182 by @xmath222 and let @xmath223 . from @xmath338)$ ] and
@xmath339)$ ] we have directly that @xmath340)$ ] and @xmath341)$ ] . thus @xmath328 .
4 . let @xmath182 by @xmath231 and let @xmath232 .
by induction on the derivation of @xmath207 . from @xmath234 and
@xmath235 $ ] , by ih , @xmath342 and @xmath343 $ ] , thus @xmath328 .
let @xmath182 by @xmath266 and let @xmath267 , k\notin { \textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath268 .
by induction on the derivation of @xmath207 .
if @xmath314 then @xmath315 from the premise @xmath331 , by ih , @xmath328
. otherwise , @xmath334 and @xmath319 $ ] ( i.e. @xmath293 by @xmath266 ) . since @xmath344 , by the ih , @xmath337 . by the definition @xmath328 .
[ lem : termeqmonotone ] if @xmath345 and @xmath74 then @xmath346 .
let @xmath209 and @xmath74 .
we have then that @xmath182 , @xmath207 , and @xmath208 . by lemma [ lem : typeintromonotone ] @xmath293 . by lemma [ lem : termintromonotone ] @xmath347 and @xmath348 . by induction on the derivation @xmath182 . 1 .
let @xmath182 by @xmath218 .
by induction on the derivation of @xmath345
let @xmath329 and @xmath349 .
by monotonicity of reduction @xmath346 .
[ localtermeqforcingismonotone ] let @xmath329 and @xmath205{\!:\!}a , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath350 .
if @xmath150 then @xmath332 , by ih , @xmath346 . otherwise , @xmath335{\!:\!}a$ ] . but @xmath336 and by ih @xmath351 . by the definition @xmath346 .
3 . let @xmath205{\!:\!}a , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] .
the statement follows similarly to ( [ localtermeqforcingismonotone ] ) .
+ the statement follows similarly for when @xmath182 holds by @xmath201 or @xmath213 .
2 . let @xmath182 by @xmath238 .
the statement follows by a proof similar to that of lemma [ lem : typeeqmonotone ] .
3 . let @xmath182 by @xmath222 and let @xmath223 . from @xmath352)$
] we have directly that @xmath353)$ ] .
hence @xmath346 .
4 . let @xmath182 by @xmath231 and let @xmath232 .
by induction on the derivation of @xmath345 . from @xmath354 and
@xmath355 $ ] , by ih we have @xmath356 and @xmath357 $ ] , thus @xmath346 . 5 .
let @xmath182 by @xmath266 and let @xmath267 , k \notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] .
by induction on the derivation of @xmath209 . if @xmath150 then the statement follows by ih . if @xmath334 then @xmath319 $ ] ( i.e. @xmath293 by @xmath266 ) and since @xmath358 , by ih , @xmath359 .
hence @xmath346 .
we collect the results of lemmas [ lem : typeintromonotone ] , [ lem : termintromonotone ] , [ lem : termeqmonotone ] , and [ lem : typeeqmonotone ] in the following corollary .
[ cor : monotonicity ] if @xmath190 and @xmath74 then @xmath191 .
we write @xmath360 when @xmath361 . by monotonicity
@xmath360 iff @xmath190 for all @xmath40 .
[ lem : localitysublemma1 ] let @xmath182 and @xmath194 . if @xmath362 and @xmath363 then @xmath185 . by induction on the derivation of @xmath182 . 1 .
let @xmath182 by @xmath218 .
by induction on the derivation of @xmath194 1 . if @xmath194 by @xmath218 then @xmath185 immediately .
[ typeqrightloc ] if @xmath194 by @xmath266 .
the statement follows similarly to ( [ loctypeqloc ] ) below .
+ the statement follows similarly when @xmath182 is derived by @xmath364 and @xmath213 .
2 . let @xmath182 by @xmath222 and let @xmath223 .
by induction on the derivation of @xmath194 1 .
let @xmath194 by @xmath222 and let @xmath225 . since @xmath182 and @xmath194 we have @xmath298 and @xmath365 .
from the premise @xmath366 and by ih @xmath226 .
+ let @xmath74 and @xmath367 . if @xmath368 then @xmath369=e[a]$ ] and @xmath185 .
otherwise , since @xmath309 , by monotonicity @xmath370=e[a]$ ] .
from @xmath182 we have that @xmath369 $ ] and from @xmath194 we have that @xmath371 $ ] . by ih @xmath369 = e[a]$ ] .
we thus have @xmath185 .
2 . let @xmath194 by @xmath266 .
the statement then follows similarly to ( [ loctypeqloc ] ) below .
+ the statement follows similarly when @xmath182 is derived by @xmath231 .
3 . if @xmath182 by @xmath238 then @xmath372 and @xmath185 .
[ loctypeqloc ] if @xmath182 by @xmath266 .
let @xmath267 , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath268
if @xmath373 then we have @xmath185 by the definition .
2 . if @xmath374 . by monotonicity @xmath268 and @xmath375 and @xmath376 and @xmath377 .
the derivation of @xmath378 is strictly smaller than the derivation of @xmath182 . by ih
we have @xmath379 . by the definition @xmath185 .
[ lem : typeintrolocal ] if @xmath380 for some @xmath114 then @xmath182 .
the proof is by by induction on the derivations @xmath381 .
note that from @xmath380 we have that @xmath5 has proper @xmath173-whnf and @xmath174-whnf and by corollary [ existenceofpwhnfislocal ] @xmath5 has a proper @xmath40-whnf . 1 .
let @xmath381 by @xmath218 1 . if @xmath5 has a canonical @xmath40-whnf then @xmath322 and @xmath182 .
2 . otherwise ,
@xmath382 , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] . since @xmath5 has a canonical @xmath173-whnf we have that @xmath373 and by the definition we have @xmath182 by @xmath266 + the statement follows similarly when @xmath383 holds by @xmath193 , @xmath201 or @xmath213 .
2 . let @xmath381 by @xmath222 1 . if @xmath5 has a canonical @xmath40-whnf then @xmath223 .
from @xmath384 we have @xmath385 . by ih @xmath298 .
let @xmath74 1 . if @xmath305 then @xmath306 . assume , w.l.o.g , @xmath386 , then @xmath387)$ ] and @xmath388=g[b])$ ] .
2 . if @xmath389 then @xmath390 . let @xmath367 , by monotonicity @xmath391 . since @xmath309 , by the definition
@xmath370 $ ] and by ih @xmath369 $ ] .
let @xmath392 , by monotonicity @xmath393 . but
then @xmath394 $ ] and @xmath395 $ ] and @xmath394=g[b]$ ] . by lemma [ lem : localitysublemma1 ] we have @xmath369=g[b]$ ] .
+ the statement follows similarly when @xmath383 holds by @xmath231 .
3 . let @xmath381 by @xmath238 then @xmath396 and @xmath182 .
4 . let @xmath381 by @xmath266 .
since @xmath5 does nt have a canonical @xmath173-whnf @xmath5 does nt have a canonical @xmath40-whnf .
since @xmath5 has a proper @xmath40-whnf we have @xmath267 , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] .
1 . if @xmath373 then by the definition we have @xmath182 by @xmath266 2 . if @xmath374 then @xmath397 , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] .
hence @xmath398 by @xmath266 .
we have then @xmath399 and @xmath400 . by ih @xmath401 and @xmath402 . by the definition @xmath182 .
[ lem : typeeqlocal ] if @xmath362 and @xmath363 for @xmath132 then @xmath185 . by the definition @xmath380 and @xmath403 . by lemma [ lem : typeintrolocal ] @xmath182 and @xmath194 . by lemma [ lem : localitysublemma1 ] @xmath185 .
[ lem : termintroeqlocal ] 1 . if @xmath404 and @xmath405 for some @xmath114 then @xmath207 .
2 . if @xmath406 and @xmath407 for some @xmath114 then @xmath345 .
we prove the two statements mutually by induction . 1 .
[ termintromontone ] from @xmath408 we have @xmath380 and by lemma [ lem : typeintrolocal ] @xmath182 . by induction on the derivation of @xmath182
[ natlocaltermforced ] let @xmath182 by @xmath218 .
since @xmath7 has proper @xmath173-whnf and @xmath174-whnf . by lemma [ properwhnflocal ] @xmath7 has a proper @xmath40-whnf . by induction on the derivation of @xmath409 . 1 .
let @xmath410 1 .
if @xmath7 has a canonical @xmath40-whnf then @xmath329 and @xmath207 directly .
2 . otherwise , @xmath205{\!:\!}a , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] .
but then we have that @xmath373 and by the definition @xmath207 .
2 . let @xmath411,k\notin{\textup{dom(}p(m\mapsto { \mathsf{0}})\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath412 .
by monotonicity @xmath413 . by ih @xmath331 and by the definition @xmath207 .
+ the statement follows similarly when @xmath182 by @xmath201 and @xmath213 .
[ pilocaltermforced ] let @xmath182 by @xmath222 and @xmath223 .
let @xmath74 .
if @xmath368 then we have directly @xmath414 $ ] and @xmath415 $ ] . otherwise , we have @xmath309 .
let @xmath367 .
by monotonicity @xmath416 and we have @xmath417 $ ] . by ih
we have @xmath418 $ ] .
let @xmath392 .
by monotonicity @xmath393 and we have @xmath419 $ ] . by ih ( [ termeqlocal ] )
@xmath420 $ ] .
thus we have @xmath207 .
[ sigmalocaltermforced ] let @xmath182 by @xmath231 and let @xmath232 .
we have @xmath421 and @xmath422 $ ] . by ih @xmath234 and
@xmath235 $ ] .
thus @xmath207 .
4 . let @xmath182 by @xmath238 .
the statement then follows similarly to lemma [ lem : typeintrolocal ] .
[ locallocaltermforced ] let @xmath182 by @xmath266 and let @xmath267 , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] .
if @xmath373 then by the definition @xmath207 . if @xmath374 then by monotonicity @xmath423 and @xmath424 . by ih @xmath331 . by the definition @xmath207 .
[ termeqlocal ] from @xmath425 we have @xmath408 and @xmath426 and @xmath380 . by lemma [ lem : typeintrolocal ] @xmath182 . by induction on the derivation of @xmath182
let @xmath182 by @xmath218 .
by ( [ natlocaltermforced ] ) we have @xmath207 . by induction on the derivation of @xmath207
. 1 . if @xmath329
by induction on the derivation of @xmath208 1 .
if @xmath172 has a canonical @xmath40-whnf then @xmath349 and @xmath345 .
[ natermeqlocalright ] otherwise , @xmath427{\!:\!}a , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] .
if @xmath373 then by the definition @xmath209 . if @xmath374 then by monotonicity @xmath428 and @xmath429 . by ih , @xmath350 . by the definition @xmath345 .
2 . if @xmath205{\!:\!}a , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath331 .
the statement follows similarly to ( [ natermeqlocalright ] ) .
+ the statement follows similarly when @xmath182 holds by @xmath201 and @xmath213 .
2 . let @xmath182 by @xmath222 and @xmath223 .
by ( [ pilocaltermforced ] ) we have @xmath207 and @xmath208 .
let @xmath74 .
if @xmath368 then we have @xmath430 $ ] . otherwise , we have @xmath309 .
let @xmath367 .
by monotonicity @xmath416 and we have @xmath431 $ ] . by ih
we have @xmath432 $ ]
. thus @xmath345 .
[ sigmalocaltermforced ] let @xmath182 by @xmath231 and let @xmath232 . by ( [ sigmalocaltermforced ] ) @xmath207 and @xmath208 .
we have @xmath433 and @xmath434 $ ] . by ih @xmath354 . since we have @xmath435 $ ] then by ih([termintromontone ] ) @xmath436 $ ] . by ih
we have @xmath237 $ ] .
thus we have @xmath345 .
4 . let @xmath182 by @xmath238 .
the statement then follows similarly to lemma [ lem : typeeqlocal ] .
let @xmath182 by @xmath266 and let @xmath267 , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] . by ( [ locallocaltermforced ] ) @xmath207 and @xmath208 .
if @xmath373 then by the definition @xmath345 . if @xmath374 then by monotonicity @xmath437 and @xmath438 . by ih @xmath350 . by the definition @xmath345 .
[ lem : localcharacter ] if @xmath439 and @xmath440 for all @xmath62 then @xmath190
. follows from lemma [ lem : typeintrolocal ] , lemma [ lem : termintroeqlocal ] , and lemma [ lem : typeeqlocal ] by induction .
[ lem : basetypecanonicity ] let @xmath441 . if @xmath207 then there is a partition @xmath56 where @xmath7 has a canonical @xmath46-whnf for all @xmath62 . if @xmath345 then there is a partition @xmath56 where @xmath7 and @xmath172 have the same canonical @xmath46-whnf for each @xmath62
. follows from the definition .
[ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] let @xmath185 . 1 . if @xmath442 then @xmath443 and if @xmath444 then @xmath208 .
2 . if @xmath445 then @xmath446 and if @xmath447 then @xmath448 . by induction on the derivations of @xmath182 , @xmath194 and @xmath185 1 . let @xmath322 and @xmath219 1 .
let @xmath207 .
by lemma [ lem : basetypecanonicity ] there is a partition @xmath56 where for each @xmath62 @xmath330 for some @xmath449 .
but then @xmath450 and @xmath451 . by local character @xmath452 . similarly if @xmath444 then @xmath208 .
2 . let @xmath345 then there is a partition @xmath56 where for each @xmath62 @xmath330 and @xmath453 for some @xmath449 .
but then @xmath450 and @xmath454 and @xmath455 . by local character @xmath456 .
similarly @xmath457 whenever @xmath458 2 .
let @xmath223 and @xmath225
let @xmath207 and @xmath74 .
let @xmath459 .
from @xmath185 we get @xmath226 and by monotonicity @xmath326 . by ih @xmath367 .
thus we have @xmath418 $ ] and since @xmath369=e[a]$ ] we get @xmath460 $ ] . similarly if @xmath461 by monotonicity @xmath461 and by ih @xmath392 .
thus @xmath462 $ ] and since @xmath369=e[a]$ ] we get @xmath463 $ ] .
similarly @xmath208 when @xmath444 .
2 . let @xmath345 and @xmath74 .
let @xmath459 . similarly to the above we get @xmath464 $ ] .
thus showing @xmath455 .
similarly we have @xmath465 when @xmath466 3 .
let @xmath232 and @xmath233
let @xmath207 .
we have @xmath234 and @xmath235 $ ] . from @xmath185
we get @xmath226 and by ih @xmath467 . from @xmath185
we get @xmath468=e[t{.1}]$ ] and by ih @xmath469 $ ] .
thus @xmath452 .
similarly we have @xmath208 when @xmath444 .
2 . let @xmath345 .
we have @xmath354 and @xmath355 $ ] . from @xmath185
we get @xmath226 and by ih @xmath470 . from @xmath185
we get @xmath468=e[t{.1}]$ ] and by ih @xmath471 $ ] .
thus @xmath456 .
similarly we have @xmath457 when @xmath458 .
if either @xmath5 or @xmath186 does not reduce to a canonical @xmath40-whnf then by lemma [ forcedtypeslocallyreducetocanonical ] we have a partition @xmath56 where for each @xmath102 both @xmath5 and @xmath186 have canonical whnf and we can show the statement for each @xmath62 by the above . by local character the statement follows for @xmath40 . immediately from the definition we have if @xmath472 then @xmath473 .
if @xmath185 then @xmath474 .
if both @xmath5 and @xmath186 have canonical @xmath40-whnf then the statement follows by induction from the definition and lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] .
otherwise , by lemma [ forcedtypeslocallyreducetocanonical ] we have a partition @xmath56 where both @xmath5 and @xmath186 have canonical @xmath46-whnf for all @xmath62 . by monotonicity @xmath311 and it follows by the above that @xmath475 . by local character @xmath474 .
[ lem : typeequiv_refl , symm , trans ] if @xmath185 and @xmath476 then @xmath477 .
let @xmath185 and @xmath476 .
we then have that @xmath182 , @xmath194 and @xmath478 .
thus @xmath5 , @xmath186 and @xmath479 have proper @xmath40-whnf .
if any of these proper @xmath40-wnf is not canonical then by lemma [ forcedtypeslocallyreducetocanonical ] we can find a partition @xmath56 where all three have canonical @xmath46-whnf for all @xmath62 . by monotonicity @xmath311 and @xmath480 for all @xmath62 . if we can then show that @xmath481 for all @xmath62 then by local character we will have @xmath482 .
thus we can assume w.l.o.g that @xmath5 , @xmath186 and @xmath479 have canonical @xmath40-whnf .
by induction on the derivations of @xmath182 , 1 .
let @xmath182 by @xmath218 .
since by assumption @xmath186 has a canonical @xmath40-wnf and @xmath185 then @xmath219 . similarly @xmath483 and we have @xmath482 + the statement follows similarly when @xmath182 holds by @xmath193 , @xmath201 and @xmath213 .
2 . let @xmath182 by @xmath222 and @xmath223 . from @xmath185 and since by assumption
@xmath186 has a canonical @xmath40-whnf we have @xmath225 and @xmath226 and @xmath484=e[a])$ ] . since @xmath476 and by assumption @xmath186 has a canonical @xmath40-whnf we have @xmath485 and @xmath486 and @xmath487=r[b])$ ] . + by ih @xmath488 .
let @xmath74 and @xmath367 .
by monotonicity @xmath326 and by lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] @xmath459 .
thus @xmath371=r[a]$ ] . but @xmath369=e[a]$ ] . by ih
@xmath369=r[a]$ ] .
thus we have @xmath482 .
+ the statement follows similarly when @xmath182 holds by @xmath231 .
3 . since @xmath185 and @xmath476 ,
we have @xmath240 and @xmath489 and the statements follows . immediately from the definition we have the following if @xmath207 then @xmath490 . if @xmath345 and then @xmath491 .
let @xmath345 .
we have @xmath207 , @xmath208 and @xmath182 . by induction on the derivation of @xmath182 . 1 .
let @xmath182 by @xmath218 .
since @xmath345 we have a partition ( lemma [ lem : basetypecanonicity ] ) @xmath56 where for each @xmath62 we have @xmath330 and @xmath453 for some @xmath449 .
hence @xmath492 for all @xmath62 . by local character @xmath345 .
+ the statement follows similarly when @xmath182 is derived by @xmath201 and @xmath213 .
2 . let @xmath182 by @xmath222 and let @xmath223 .
let @xmath74 and @xmath367 we then have @xmath493 $ ] .
we have @xmath369 $ ] and by ih @xmath494 $ ] .
thus @xmath495 .
3 . let @xmath182 by @xmath231 and let @xmath232 .
we have @xmath354 and @xmath237 $ ] .
since @xmath299 , by ih @xmath496 .
since @xmath182 we have @xmath468=g[u{.1}]$ ] . by lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ]
@xmath497 $ ] .
since @xmath498 $ ] , by ih @xmath499 $ ] .
thus @xmath495 .
4 . let @xmath182 by @xmath238 .
the statement then follows similarly to lemma [ lem : typeequiv_refl , symm , trans ] 5 .
let @xmath182 by @xmath266 and let @xmath267 , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath268 .
since @xmath345 we have that @xmath500 . by ih @xmath501 . by the definition @xmath495 . if @xmath345 and @xmath502 then @xmath503 .
let @xmath345 and @xmath502 .
we have @xmath182 , @xmath207 , @xmath208 and @xmath504 . by induction on the derivation of @xmath182 . 1 .
let @xmath182 by @xmath218 .
by lemma [ lem : basetypecanonicity ] there is a partition @xmath56 where for each @xmath62 we have @xmath330 , @xmath453 , and @xmath505 .
thus @xmath506 for all @xmath62 . by local character @xmath506 .
+ the statement follows similarly when @xmath182 by @xmath201 and @xmath213 2 .
let @xmath182 by @xmath222 and let @xmath223 .
let @xmath74 and @xmath367 .
we have then @xmath493 $ ] and @xmath507 $ ] . by ih @xmath508
$ ] . thus @xmath503 .
3 . let @xmath182 by @xmath231 and let @xmath232 .
since @xmath345 we have that @xmath236 and @xmath237 $ ] .
similarly we have that @xmath509 and @xmath510 $ ] .
since @xmath182 we have that @xmath468=g[u{.1}]$ ] and by lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] @xmath511 $ ] . by ih we have @xmath512 and @xmath513 $ ] .
we have then that @xmath514 .
4 . let @xmath182 by @xmath238 .
the statement then follows similarly to lemma [ lem : typeequiv_refl , symm , trans ] .
let @xmath182 by @xmath266 and let @xmath267 , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath268 .
we have that @xmath500 and @xmath515 . by ih @xmath516 . by the definition @xmath503 .
in this section we show that the type theory described in section [ sec : forcingextensionoftypetheory ] is sound with respect to the semantics described in section [ sec : semantics ] .
i.e. we aim to show that @xmath190 whenever @xmath272 .
[ lem : types_reductionimplyequiv ] if @xmath517 and @xmath194 then @xmath182 and @xmath185
. follows from the definition .
[ lem : terms_onestepreductionimplyequiv ] let @xmath182 . if @xmath518 and @xmath208 then @xmath207 and @xmath345 .
let @xmath518 and @xmath208 .
by induction on the derivation of @xmath182 . 1 .
let @xmath182 by @xmath238 .
the statement follows similarly to lemma [ lem : types_reductionimplyequiv ] .
2 . let @xmath182 by @xmath218 .
by induction on the derivation of @xmath208 . if @xmath519 then @xmath520 and the statement follows by the definition . if @xmath211{\!:\!}a , k\notin { \textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath521 then since @xmath522 , by ih @xmath331 and @xmath212 . by the definition @xmath207 and @xmath209 .
+ the statement follows similarly for @xmath201 and @xmath213 .
3 . let @xmath182 by @xmath222 and let @xmath523 .
let @xmath74 and @xmath367 .
we have @xmath524 $ ] . by ih @xmath525 $ ] and
@xmath493 $ ] .
if @xmath526 we similarly get @xmath527 $ ] and @xmath528 $ ] . since @xmath369=g[b]$ ] , by lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] @xmath529 $ ] . but @xmath530 $ ] . by symmetry and transitivity
@xmath462 $ ] . thus @xmath207 and @xmath345 .
4 . let @xmath182 by @xmath222 and let @xmath531 .
from @xmath163 we have @xmath77 and we have @xmath142 and @xmath532 $ ] . by the induction @xmath234 and @xmath236 . by the induction
@xmath533 $ ] and @xmath497 $ ] .
but since @xmath182 and we have shown @xmath236 we get @xmath468=g[u{.1}]$ ] . by lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ]
@xmath235 $ ] and @xmath355 $ ] .
thus @xmath203 and @xmath534 5 .
let @xmath182 by @xmath266 .
let @xmath267 , k\notin{\textup{dom(}p\textup{)}}$ ] and @xmath268 .
since @xmath208 we have @xmath521 .
but we have @xmath522 . by ih @xmath331 and @xmath535 . by the definition @xmath207 and @xmath209 .
[ cor : terms_reductionimplyequiv ] let @xmath146 and @xmath182 .
if @xmath208 then @xmath207 and @xmath345 .
[ cor : genericwelltyped ] @xmath536 .
it s direct to see that @xmath537 . for
an arbitrary condition @xmath40 let @xmath538 .
by lemma [ lem : basetypecanonicity ] we have a partition @xmath56 where for each @xmath62 , @xmath539 for some @xmath540 .
we have thus a reduction @xmath541 . if @xmath305 then @xmath542 and by definition @xmath543 . if @xmath544 then @xmath545 and @xmath546 .
thus @xmath547 .
by the definition @xmath543 .
we thus have that @xmath543 for all @xmath62 and by local character @xmath548 .
let @xmath549 .
by lemma [ lem : basetypecanonicity ] there is a partition @xmath56 where for each @xmath62 , @xmath550 and @xmath551 for some @xmath552 .
we then have @xmath553 and @xmath554 . if @xmath305 then @xmath555 and @xmath556 . by corollary [ cor : terms_reductionimplyequiv ] ,
symmetry and transitivity @xmath557 . if on the other hand @xmath558 then @xmath559 and @xmath560 . by the definition @xmath561 .
thus @xmath561 for all @xmath62 .
by local character @xmath562 .
hence @xmath536 .
[ lem : forcingtermnegation ] if @xmath563 and @xmath182 then @xmath564 iff for all @xmath74 there is no term @xmath172 such that @xmath565 .
let @xmath182 and @xmath563 .
we have directly that @xmath566 .
assume @xmath564 . if @xmath567 for some @xmath74 , then @xmath568 which is impossible .
conversely , assume it is the case that for all @xmath47 there is no @xmath172 for which @xmath565 . since @xmath569 and @xmath570 never hold for any @xmath571 , the statements `` @xmath572 '' and `` @xmath573 '' hold trivially .
[ lem : markovpremisewitnesswelltyped ] @xmath574 . by lemma [ lem : forcingtermnegation ]
it is enough to show that for all @xmath46 there is no term @xmath172 for which @xmath575 .
assume @xmath575 for some @xmath172 .
let @xmath576 we have then @xmath577 thus @xmath578 which is impossible .
let @xmath579 and @xmath580 .
let @xmath581 $ ] .
we write @xmath582 if @xmath583 for all @xmath584 . letting @xmath585
, we write @xmath586 if @xmath587 for all @xmath584 .
we write @xmath588 if @xmath589 for all @xmath584 and @xmath590 if @xmath591 for all @xmath584 .
[ lem : evalissub ] if @xmath592 then @xmath593 . if @xmath594 then @xmath595
. follows from the definition . 1 .
we write @xmath596 if @xmath597 and
for all @xmath74 whenever @xmath598 then @xmath599 and whenever @xmath600 then @xmath601 .
we write @xmath602 if @xmath603 , @xmath596 and for all @xmath74 whenever @xmath598 then @xmath604 and whenever @xmath605 then @xmath606 .
we write @xmath607 if @xmath608 , @xmath596 , @xmath609 and for all @xmath74 whenever @xmath598 then @xmath610 .
we write @xmath611 if @xmath612 , @xmath602 , @xmath613 and for all @xmath74 whenever @xmath598 then @xmath614 . in the following
we will show that whenever we have a rule in the type system then it holds that . which is sufficient to show soundness
. follows from corollary [ lem : localcharacter ] .
[ soundpiintro ] let @xmath74 and @xmath598 .
let @xmath615 and @xmath616 .
we have @xmath617 . since @xmath618 we have @xmath619 and by lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] @xmath620 .
thus @xmath621 .
we have @xmath622 $ ] and @xmath622=g\sigma[a]$ ] . if moreover @xmath623 then @xmath624 .
thus @xmath622=g\rho[b]$ ] . by the definition @xmath625 and @xmath626 .
[ soundpieq ] let @xmath74 and @xmath598 .
similarly to lemma [ soundpiintro ] , we can show @xmath627 , @xmath628 , @xmath629 , and @xmath630 . from the premise
let @xmath615 and @xmath616 .
we have then @xmath617
. thus @xmath622=e\rho[a]$ ] . by the definition @xmath632 and @xmath633 .
[ soundlambdaintro ] let @xmath74 and @xmath598 .
by lemma [ lem : evalissub ] @xmath634 .
let @xmath615 and @xmath635 .
since @xmath636 we have that @xmath637 . since @xmath638 we have @xmath639{\!:\!}g\rho[d]$ ] . by the reduction rules @xmath640 $ ] .
thus @xmath641{\!:\!}g\rho[d]$ ] . but @xmath642 , hence , @xmath643{\!:\!}g\rho[d]$ ] .
by lemma [ lem : terms_onestepreductionimplyequiv ] we have that @xmath644 $ ] and @xmath645{\!:\!}g\rho[d]$ ] .
let @xmath646 we have similarly that @xmath647{\!:\!}g\rho[e]$ ] .
we have also that @xmath648 $ ] , thus @xmath643=t\rho[e]{\!:\!}g\rho[d]$ ] and @xmath649=g\rho[e]$ ] . by lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] we have @xmath647{\!:\!}g\rho[d]$ ] . by symmetry and transitivity
we have @xmath650 $ ] .
thus @xmath651 .
let @xmath600 .
we get @xmath652 . similarly to the above we can show @xmath653 .
let @xmath615 and @xmath616 .
by lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] @xmath620 . we then have @xmath621 .
thus we have @xmath622=g\sigma[a]$ ] .
thus @xmath654 and by lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] @xmath655 .
we have @xmath656=t\sigma[a]{\!:\!}g\rho[a]$ ] . but @xmath657{\!:\!}g\rho[a]$ ] and @xmath658 { \!:\!}g\sigma[a]$ ] . by lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] @xmath658 { \!:\!}g\rho[a]$ ] . by symmetry and transitivity
@xmath659 $ ] . thus @xmath660 .
[ soundbeta ] let @xmath74 and @xmath598 .
we have @xmath661 . as in lemma [ soundlambdaintro ] @xmath662\rho { \!:\!}g[a]\rho$ ] which by lemma [ lem : terms_onestepreductionimplyequiv ]
imply that @xmath663\rho { \!:\!}g\rho[a]$ ] .
[ soundapptyp ] let @xmath74 and @xmath598 .
we have @xmath664 and @xmath661 . by the definition @xmath665\rho$ ] .
let @xmath666 .
we have then @xmath667 and @xmath668 . from the definition @xmath669\rho$ ] . from the definition @xmath670\rho$ ] . by transitivity @xmath671\rho$ ] . [ soundappeq ] ( 1 )
( 2 ) let @xmath74 and @xmath598 . 1
. we have @xmath664 and @xmath672 . from the definition get @xmath673\rho$ ] .
we have @xmath674 and @xmath675 . from the definition we get @xmath676\rho$ ] . [ soundfunext ]
let @xmath74 and @xmath598 .
we have @xmath677 and @xmath678 .
let @xmath615 and @xmath616 .
we have then that @xmath679 .
thus @xmath680 $ ] . by the definition @xmath674 .
[ soundpairing ] let @xmath74 and @xmath598 .
by the typing rules @xmath681 and @xmath682 $ ] .
but @xmath634 .
by substitution we have @xmath683 and @xmath684\rho$ ] . but @xmath685 and @xmath686 . thus @xmath687 and @xmath688\rho$ ] . from the premise @xmath661 and @xmath689\rho$ ] . by lemma [ lem : terms_onestepreductionimplyequiv ] @xmath690 and @xmath691\rho$ ] . by lemma [ lem : terms_onestepreductionimplyequiv ] @xmath692 , thus @xmath693 . hence @xmath369\rho
= g[(a , b){.1}]\rho$ ] . by lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] @xmath694\rho$ ] . by the definition we have then that @xmath695 .
let @xmath605 .
similarly we can show @xmath696 .
we have that @xmath668 and @xmath697\rho$ ] .
we have also @xmath698 we thus have @xmath369\rho = g[a]\sigma$ ] . by lemma [ lem : terms_onestepreductionimplyequiv ] @xmath699\sigma$ ] . by lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] @xmath699\rho$ ] .
but we also have by lemma [ lem : terms_onestepreductionimplyequiv ] that @xmath700 . hence , by lemma
[ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] , we have @xmath701 . by symmetry and transitivity
we then have that @xmath702 and @xmath703\rho$ ] .
thus we have that @xmath704 .
[ soundproj ] \(1 ) ( 2 ) let @xmath74 and @xmath598 . 1 .
we have @xmath705 and @xmath706\rho$ ] . by substitution
we get @xmath707 .
but @xmath708 , thus @xmath709 . we have that @xmath710 .
thus by lemma [ lem : terms_onestepreductionimplyequiv ] @xmath711 and @xmath712 .
similarly we have @xmath713 $ ] .
since @xmath714\rho$ ] , by lemma [ lem : terms_onestepreductionimplyequiv ] , we have that @xmath715\rho$ ] and @xmath716 $ ] .
[ soundprojtypeq ] \(1 ) ( 2 ) let @xmath74 and @xmath598 . 1
. we have @xmath717 . by the definition we have @xmath718 and @xmath719\rho$ ] .
let @xmath605 .
we have that @xmath720 . by the definition @xmath721 and @xmath722\rho$ ] .
we have @xmath723 . by the definition @xmath724 and @xmath725\rho$ ] . [ soundpairext ]
let @xmath74 and @xmath598 .
we have @xmath717 and @xmath726 .
we also have @xmath727 and @xmath728\rho$ ] . by the definition @xmath729 .
[ soundnat ] \(1 ) ( 2 ) ( 3 ) \(1 ) and ( 2 ) follow directly from the definition while ( 3 ) follows from lemma [ lem : basetypecanonicity ] .
[ soundnessnatrec ] let @xmath74 and @xmath598 .
we have then that @xmath730 , hence , @xmath731 . let @xmath615 .
let @xmath732 , @xmath733 and @xmath734 .
by lemma [ lem : basetypecanonicity ] there is a partition @xmath735 such that for each @xmath736 , @xmath737 and @xmath738 . in order to show that @xmath739 we need to show that @xmath740 $ ] , @xmath741 $ ] , and @xmath742 $ ] . by local character
it will be sufficient to show that for each @xmath736 we have @xmath743 $ ] , @xmath744 $ ] , and @xmath745 $ ] .
we have that @xmath746\\ & s\vdash ( { { \mathsf{rec}_{\mathsf{n}}}}(\lambda x. f)\,a_0\ , g)\rho\,b { { \rightarrowtriangle}^\ast}({{\mathsf{rec}_{\mathsf{n}}}}(\lambda x. f)\,a_0\ , g)\rho\ , { \sbox{\myboxa}{$\m@thn$ } \setbox\myboxb\null \ht\myboxb=\ht\myboxa \dp\myboxb=\dp\myboxa \wd\myboxb=0.75\wd\myboxa \sbox\myboxb{$\m@th\overline{\copy\myboxb}$ } \setlength\mylena{\the\wd\myboxa } \addtolength\mylena{-\the\wd\myboxb } \ifdim\wd\myboxb<\wd\myboxa \rlap{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb}{\usebox\myboxa } \else \hskip -0.5\mylena\rlap{\usebox\myboxa}{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb } \fi } { \!:\!}f\rho[b]\end{aligned}\ ] ] let @xmath747 . by induction on @xmath748 . if @xmath749 then @xmath750\\ & s\vdash ( { { \mathsf{rec}_{\mathsf{n}}}}(\lambda x. f)\,a_0\ , g)\rho\,b { { \rightarrowtriangle}^\ast}({{\mathsf{rec}_{\mathsf{n}}}}(\lambda x. f)\,a_0\ , g)\rho\,{\mathsf{0}}{\rightarrowtriangle}a_0\rho { \!:\!}f\rho[b]\end{aligned}\ ] ] by lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] we have then that @xmath751 & \hphantom{space } s{\vdash}({{\mathsf{rec}_{\mathsf{n}}}}(\lambda x. f)\,a_0\ , g)\rho\,b = a_0\rho { \!:\!}f\rho[b]\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath752 we have @xmath753 and thus @xmath754=f\rho[b]$ ] . by lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] ,
symmetry and transitivity @xmath755 $ ] .
assume the statement holds for @xmath756 .
let @xmath757 .
we have then @xmath758\\ & s\vdash ( { { \mathsf{rec}_{\mathsf{n}}}}(\lambda x. f)\,a_0\ , g)\rho\,b { { \rightarrowtriangle}^\ast}g\rho \ , { \sbox{\myboxa}{$\m@th\ell$ } \setbox\myboxb\null \ht\myboxb=\ht\myboxa \dp\myboxb=\dp\myboxa \wd\myboxb=0.75\wd\myboxa \sbox\myboxb{$\m@th\overline{\copy\myboxb}$ } \setlength\mylena{\the\wd\myboxa } \addtolength\mylena{-\the\wd\myboxb } \ifdim\wd\myboxb<\wd\myboxa \rlap{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb}{\usebox\myboxa } \else \hskip -0.5\mylena\rlap{\usebox\myboxa}{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb } \fi}\ , ( ( { { \mathsf{rec}_{\mathsf{n}}}}(\lambda x. f)\,a_0\ , g)\rho\ , { \sbox{\myboxa}{$\m@th\ell$ } \setbox\myboxb\null \ht\myboxb=\ht\myboxa \dp\myboxb=\dp\myboxa \wd\myboxb=0.75\wd\myboxa \sbox\myboxb{$\m@th\overline{\copy\myboxb}$ } \setlength\mylena{\the\wd\myboxa } \addtolength\mylena{-\the\wd\myboxb } \ifdim\wd\myboxb<\wd\myboxa \rlap{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb}{\usebox\myboxa } \else \hskip -0.5\mylena\rlap{\usebox\myboxa}{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb } \fi } ) { \!:\!}f\rho[{\mathsf{s}}\ , { \sbox{\myboxa}{$\m@th\ell$ } \setbox\myboxb\null \ht\myboxb=\ht\myboxa \dp\myboxb=\dp\myboxa \wd\myboxb=0.75\wd\myboxa \sbox\myboxb{$\m@th\overline{\copy\myboxb}$ } \setlength\mylena{\the\wd\myboxa } \addtolength\mylena{-\the\wd\myboxb } \ifdim\wd\myboxb<\wd\myboxa \rlap{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb}{\usebox\myboxa } \else \hskip -0.5\mylena\rlap{\usebox\myboxa}{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb } \fi}]\end{aligned}\ ] ] by ih @xmath759 $ ] .
but we have @xmath760\rightarrow f[{\mathsf{s}}\,x])$ ] and thus @xmath761 $ ] . by corollary [ cor : terms_reductionimplyequiv ] , symmetry and transitivity we get that @xmath762 $ ] , @xmath763 $ ] , and @xmath764 $ ] .
but @xmath765 , thus , @xmath754=f\rho[{\mathsf{s}}\ , { \sbox{\myboxa}{$\m@th\ell$ } \setbox\myboxb\null \ht\myboxb=\ht\myboxa \dp\myboxb=\dp\myboxa \wd\myboxb=0.75\wd\myboxa \sbox\myboxb{$\m@th\overline{\copy\myboxb}$ } \setlength\mylena{\the\wd\myboxa } \addtolength\mylena{-\the\wd\myboxb } \ifdim\wd\myboxb<\wd\myboxa \rlap{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb}{\usebox\myboxa } \else \hskip -0.5\mylena\rlap{\usebox\myboxa}{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb } \fi}]$ ] . by lemma [
lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] we get then that @xmath766 $ ] .
as indicated above , this is sufficient to show @xmath767 .
similarly we can show @xmath768 . to show that @xmath769 we need to show that whenever @xmath616 for some @xmath615 we have @xmath770 $ ] .
let @xmath771 for @xmath615 .
by lemma [ lem : basetypecanonicity ] we have a partition @xmath735 where for each @xmath736 we have @xmath737 . as above it
is sufficient to show @xmath772 $ ] for all @xmath736 .
let @xmath773 .
by induction on @xmath748 .
if @xmath749 then as above @xmath751 & \hphantom{space } s{\vdash}({{\mathsf{rec}_{\mathsf{n}}}}(\lambda x. f)\,a_0\ , g)\sigma\,a = a_0\sigma { \!:\!}f\sigma[b]\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath774 we have @xmath775 .
we have then that @xmath754=f\sigma[a]$ ] .
but we also have that @xmath776 $ ] . by lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] , symmetry and transitivity
it then follows that @xmath777 $ ] .
assume the statement holds for @xmath756 .
let @xmath757 . as before we have that @xmath758\\ & s\vdash ( { { \mathsf{rec}_{\mathsf{n}}}}(\lambda x. f)\,a_0\ , g)\sigma\,a { { \rightarrowtriangle}^\ast}g\sigma \ , { \sbox{\myboxa}{$\m@th\ell$ } \setbox\myboxb\null \ht\myboxb=\ht\myboxa \dp\myboxb=\dp\myboxa \wd\myboxb=0.75\wd\myboxa \sbox\myboxb{$\m@th\overline{\copy\myboxb}$ } \setlength\mylena{\the\wd\myboxa } \addtolength\mylena{-\the\wd\myboxb } \ifdim\wd\myboxb<\wd\myboxa \rlap{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb}{\usebox\myboxa } \else \hskip -0.5\mylena\rlap{\usebox\myboxa}{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb } \fi}\ , ( ( { { \mathsf{rec}_{\mathsf{n}}}}(\lambda x. f)\,a_0\ , g)\sigma\ , { \sbox{\myboxa}{$\m@th\ell$ } \setbox\myboxb\null \ht\myboxb=\ht\myboxa \dp\myboxb=\dp\myboxa \wd\myboxb=0.75\wd\myboxa \sbox\myboxb{$\m@th\overline{\copy\myboxb}$ } \setlength\mylena{\the\wd\myboxa } \addtolength\mylena{-\the\wd\myboxb } \ifdim\wd\myboxb<\wd\myboxa \rlap{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb}{\usebox\myboxa } \else \hskip -0.5\mylena\rlap{\usebox\myboxa}{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb } \fi } ) { \!:\!}f\sigma[{\mathsf{s}}\ , { \sbox{\myboxa}{$\m@th\ell$ } \setbox\myboxb\null \ht\myboxb=\ht\myboxa \dp\myboxb=\dp\myboxa \wd\myboxb=0.75\wd\myboxa \sbox\myboxb{$\m@th\overline{\copy\myboxb}$ } \setlength\mylena{\the\wd\myboxa } \addtolength\mylena{-\the\wd\myboxb } \ifdim\wd\myboxb<\wd\myboxa \rlap{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb}{\usebox\myboxa } \else \hskip -0.5\mylena\rlap{\usebox\myboxa}{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb } \fi}]\end{aligned}\ ] ] by ih @xmath778 $ ] . but @xmath779\rightarrow f[{\mathsf{s}}\,x]))\rho$ ] , thus @xmath780 $ ] but @xmath781=f\sigma[{\mathsf{s}}\ , { \sbox{\myboxa}{$\m@th\ell$ } \setbox\myboxb\null \ht\myboxb=\ht\myboxa \dp\myboxb=\dp\myboxa \wd\myboxb=0.75\wd\myboxa \sbox\myboxb{$\m@th\overline{\copy\myboxb}$ } \setlength\mylena{\the\wd\myboxa } \addtolength\mylena{-\the\wd\myboxb } \ifdim\wd\myboxb<\wd\myboxa \rlap{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb}{\usebox\myboxa } \else \hskip -0.5\mylena\rlap{\usebox\myboxa}{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb } \fi}]$ ] and @xmath782=f\rho[{\mathsf{s}}\ , { \sbox{\myboxa}{$\m@th\ell$ } \setbox\myboxb\null \ht\myboxb=\ht\myboxa \dp\myboxb=\dp\myboxa \wd\myboxb=0.75\wd\myboxa \sbox\myboxb{$\m@th\overline{\copy\myboxb}$ } \setlength\mylena{\the\wd\myboxa } \addtolength\mylena{-\the\wd\myboxb } \ifdim\wd\myboxb<\wd\myboxa \rlap{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb}{\usebox\myboxa } \else \hskip -0.5\mylena\rlap{\usebox\myboxa}{\hskip 0.5\mylena\usebox\myboxb } \fi}]$ ] . by lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] ,
symmetry and transitivity we have then that @xmath783 $ ] which is sufficient to show @xmath784 [ soundnatrec0 ] let @xmath74 and @xmath598 .
we have @xmath634 and thus we get that @xmath785 $ ] . but @xmath786 .
thus @xmath787 $ ] .
but @xmath788 $ ] . by lemma [ lem : terms_onestepreductionimplyequiv ] we have @xmath789 $ ] .
[ soundnatrecsuc ] let @xmath74 and @xmath598 .
we have @xmath790 . by lemma [ lem : basetypecanonicity ]
there is a partition @xmath791 such that for each @xmath736 there is @xmath552 and @xmath792 .
thus @xmath793 .
we have then that @xmath794\end{aligned}\ ] ] but @xmath795 $ ] . by corollary [ cor : terms_reductionimplyequiv ] ,
symmetry and transitivity @xmath796 $ ] . since @xmath797
we have that @xmath798 = f\rho[{\mathsf{s}}\ , n\rho]$ ] . by lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] we thus have that @xmath799\rho$ ] . by local character @xmath800\rho$ ] [ soundnatreccong ] the proof follows by an argument similar to that used to prove lemma [ soundnessnatrec ] . for the congruence rules , soundness follows by reflexivity , symmetry and transitivity of the forcing relation .
soundness for rules of @xmath24 , @xmath801 and @xmath802 follow similarly to those of @xmath803 .
soundness for the rules of @xmath804 follows similarly to soundness of typing rules .
we have then the following corollary : [ lem : soundness ] if @xmath93 then @xmath805 [ thm : fundamentalthm ] if @xmath272 then @xmath190 .
follows from corollary [ lem : soundness ] .
now we have enough machinery to show the independence of @xmath30 from type theory .
the idea is that if a judgment @xmath97 is derivable in type theory ( i.e. @xmath806 ) then it is derivable in the forcing extension ( i.e. @xmath807 ) and by theorem [ thm : fundamentalthm ] it holds in the interpretation ( i.e. @xmath360 ) .
it thus suffices to show that there no @xmath7 such that @xmath808 to establish the independence of @xmath30 from type theory .
first we recall the formulation of @xmath30 .
@xmath809\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath16 is given by @xmath810 .
[ lem : markovconclusionnowitness ] there is no term @xmath7 such that @xmath811 .
assume @xmath811 for some @xmath7 .
we then have @xmath812 and @xmath813 . by lemma [ lem : basetypecanonicity ]
one has a partition @xmath814 where for each @xmath62 , @xmath815 .
hence @xmath816 and by lemma [ lem : types_reductionimplyequiv ] @xmath817 .
but , by definition , the partition @xmath57 must contain a condition , say @xmath818 , such that @xmath819 whenever @xmath820 ( this holds vacuously for @xmath821 ) .
let @xmath822 .
assume @xmath823 , then @xmath824 .
by monotonicity , from @xmath813 we get @xmath825 . but
@xmath826 thus @xmath827 .
hence , by lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] , @xmath828 which is impossible , thus contradicting our assumption .
if on the other hand @xmath829 then , since @xmath830 , we can apply the above argument with @xmath831 instead of @xmath818 .
[ lem : markovnotforcible ] there is no term @xmath7 such that @xmath808 .
assume @xmath808 for some @xmath7 .
from the definition , whenever @xmath832 we have @xmath833 . since by corollary
[ cor : genericwelltyped ] , @xmath536 we have @xmath834 . since by lemma [ lem : markovpremisewitnesswelltyped ] @xmath835 we have @xmath836 which is impossible by lemma [ lem : markovconclusionnowitness ] . from theorem [ thm : fundamentalthm ] ,
lemma [ lem : markovnotforcible ] , and lemma [ lem : extension ] we can then conclude : we extend the type system in section [ sec : forcingextensionoftypetheory ] further by adding a generic point @xmath837 for each condition @xmath46 .
the introduction and conversion rules for @xmath837 are given by : with the reduction rules : we observe that with these added rules the reduction relation is still monotone . for each @xmath837
we add a term : finally we add a term @xmath838 witnessing the negation of @xmath30 by analogy to corollary [ cor : genericwelltyped ] we have [ lem : qgenericpointforced ] @xmath839 for all @xmath46 .
[ lem : qmarkovpermisewitnessforced ] @xmath840 for all @xmath46 .
assume @xmath841 for some @xmath40 and @xmath7 .
let @xmath842 , we have @xmath843 .
thus @xmath844 and @xmath845 which is impossible .
[ lem : qmarkovconclusionnowitness ] there is no term @xmath7 for which @xmath846 .
assume @xmath846 for some @xmath7 .
we then have @xmath847 and @xmath848 . by lemma [ lem : basetypecanonicity ]
one has a partition @xmath849 where for each @xmath584 , @xmath850 for some @xmath851 .
hence @xmath852 . but
any partition of @xmath46 contain a condition , say @xmath853 , where @xmath854 whenever @xmath855 and @xmath856 .
assume @xmath857 .
if @xmath858 then @xmath859 and if @xmath860 then @xmath861 . thus @xmath862 and by lemma [ lem : types_reductionimplyequiv ] @xmath863 . from @xmath813 by monotonicity and lemma [ lem : equivalenttypeshaveequalpers ] we have @xmath864 which is impossible . if on the other hand @xmath865 then since @xmath866 we can apply the above argument with @xmath867 instead of @xmath853 .
@xmath868 assume @xmath869 for some @xmath40 and @xmath7 .
thus whenever @xmath74 and @xmath870 then @xmath871 .
but we have @xmath872 by lemma [ lem : qgenericpointforced ] .
hence @xmath873 . but @xmath874 by lemma [ lem : qmarkovpermisewitnessforced ] .
thus @xmath875 which is impossible by lemma [ lem : qmarkovconclusionnowitness ] .
we have then that this extension is sound with respect to the interpretation .
hence we have shown the following statement .
there is a consistent extension of @xmath6 where @xmath31 is derivable .
recall that @xmath876 .
we have then a term @xmath877 .
thus in this extension we have a term @xmath878 .
we would like to thank simon huber , thomas streicher , martn escard and chuangjie xu . | in this paper , we show that markov s principle is not derivable in dependent type theory with natural numbers and one universe . one tentative way to prove this would be to remark that markov s principle does not hold in a sheaf model of type theory over cantor space , since markov s principle does not hold for the generic point of this model .
it is however not clear how to interpret the universe in a sheaf model @xcite .
instead we design an extension of type theory , which intuitively extends type theory by the addition of a generic point of cantor space .
we then show the consistency of this extension by a normalization argument .
markov s principle does not hold in this extension , and it follows that it can not be proved in type theory . |
quintessence ( caldwell et al . 1998 ) or dark energy is a new component of the cosmic medium that has been introduced in order to explain the dimming of distant snia ( riess et al .
1998 ; perlmutter et al . 1999 ) through an accelerated expansion while at the same time saving the inflationary prediction of a flat universe .
the recent measures of the cmb at high resolution ( lange et al .
2000 , de bernardis et al .
2000 , balbi et al .
2000 ) have added to the motivations for a conspicuous fraction of unclustered dark energy with negative pressure . in its simplest formulation ( see e.g. silveira & waga 1997 ) , the quintessence component can be modeled as a perfect fluid with equation of state @xmath4 with @xmath5 in the range @xmath6 ( @xmath7 for acceleration ) . when @xmath8 we have pure cosmological constant , while for @xmath9 we reduce to the ordinary pressureless matter .
the case @xmath10 mimicks a universe filled with cosmic strings ( see e.g. vilenkin 1984 ) .
more realistic models possess an effective equation of state that changes with time , and can be modeled by scalar fields ( ratra & peebles 1988 , wetterich 1995 , frieman et al .
1995 , ferreira and joyce 1998 ) , possibly with coupling to gravity or matter ( baccigalupi , perrotta & matarrese 2000 , amendola 2000 ) .
the introduction of the new component modifies the universe expansion and introduces at least a new parameter , @xmath5 , in cosmology .
most deep cosmological tests , from large scale structure to cmb , from lensing to deep counting , are affected in some way by the presence of the new field . here
we study how a perfect fluid quintessence affects the dyer - roeder ( dr ) distance , a necessary tool for all lensing studies ( dyer & roeder 1972 , 1974 ) .
the assumption of constant equation of state is at least partially justified by the relatively narrow range of redshift we are considering , @xmath11 .
we rederive the dr equation in quintessence cosmology , we solve it analytically whenever possible , and give a very accurate analytical fit to its numerical solution . finally , we apply the dr solutions to a likelihood determination of @xmath0 through the observations of time - delays in multiple images .
the dataset we use is composed of only six time - delays , and does not allow to test directly for quintessence ; however , we will show that inclusion of such cosmologies may have an important impact on the determination of @xmath0 with this method .
for instance , we find that @xmath0 is smaller that for a pure cosmological constant . in this work we confine ourselves to flat space and extremal values of the beam parameter @xmath12 ; in a paper in preparation we extend to curved spaces and general @xmath12 .
in this section we derive the dr distance in quintessence cosmology , find its analytical solutions , when possible , and its asymptotic solutions .
finally , we give a very accurate analytical fit to the general numerical solutions as a function of @xmath1 and @xmath5 .
first of all , let us notice that when quintessence is present , the friedmann equation ( the @xmath13 component of the einstein equations in a flat frw metric ) becomes ( in units @xmath14 ) @xmath15 .\ ] ] where @xmath0 is the present value of the hubble constant , @xmath1 the present value of the matter density parameter , and where the scale factor is normalized to unity today . in terms of the redshift @xmath16 we can write @xmath17 where @xmath18 the ricci focalization equation in a conformally flat metric ( such as the frw metric ) with curvature tensor @xmath19 is ( see e.g. schneider , falco & ehlers 1992 ) @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the beam area and @xmath22 is the tangent vector to the surface of propagation of the light ray , and the dot means derivation with respect to the affine parameter @xmath23 .
multiplying the einstein s gravitational field equation @xmath24 by @xmath25 and imposing the condition @xmath26 for the null geodesic we obtain @xmath27 ; from ( [ focricci ] ) we obtain @xmath28 considering only ordinary pressureless matter and quintessence the energy - momentum tensor writes @xmath29 multiplying by @xmath25 , putting @xmath30 and inserting in ( [ focricci2 ] ) we have @xmath31 \sqrt{a}=0 .
\label{focricci3}\ ] ] now , the angular diameter distance @xmath32 is defined as the ratio between the diameter of an object and its angular diameter .
we have then @xmath33 . since @xmath34 , and defining the dimensionless distance @xmath35 , eq .
( [ focricci3 ] ) writes @xmath36 r=0 \label{focricciaffine}\ ] ] where we introduced the affine parameter @xmath37 defined implicitely by the relation @xmath38 where @xmath39 is defined in eq .
( [ h(z ) ] ) .
finally we get the dr equation with the redshift as independent variable @xmath40 \frac{d^{2}r}{dz^{2}}+ \\
\\ + \left ( 1+z\right ) \left [ \frac{7}{2}\omega _ { m}\left ( 1+z\right ) ^{3}+\frac{% m+4}{2}\left ( 1-\omega _ { m}\right ) \left ( 1+z\right ) ^{m}\right ] \frac{dr}{dz% } + \\ \\ + \left [ \frac{3}{2}\alpha \omega _ { m}\left ( 1+z\right ) ^{3}+\frac{m}{2}% \left ( 1-\omega _ { m}\right ) \left ( 1+z\right ) ^{m}\right ] r=0 \end{array } \label{drg}\ ] ] the constant @xmath12 in eq .
( [ drg ] ) is the fraction of matter homogeneously distributed inside the beam : when @xmath41 all the matter is clustered ( empty beam ) , while for @xmath42 the matter is spread homogeneously and we recover the usual angular diameter distance ( filled beam ) .
notice that in our case the empty beam is actually filled uniformly with quintessence .
since the actual value of @xmath12 is unknown ( see however barber et al . 2000 , who argue in favor of @xmath12 near unity ) , we will adopt in the following the two extremal values @xmath41 and @xmath42 .
the appropriate boundary conditions are ( see e.g. schneider , falco & ehlers 1992 ) @xmath43 ^{-1/2 } \end{array } \right .
\label{condizioni al contorno z}\ ] ] defining @xmath44 these become @xmath45 * analytical solutions*. eq .
( [ drg ] ) has an analytical solution only for some values of @xmath12 and @xmath5 .
here we list all the known analytical solutions .
all the cases for @xmath41 and @xmath46 or @xmath47 are new solutions . for the case
@xmath8 see also demiansky et al .
( 2000 ) .
case when @xmath8 the quintessence fluid is the cosmological constant ; the dr equation becomes @xmath48 \frac{d^{2}r}{dz^{2}}+
\\ + \left [ \frac{7}{2}\omega _ { m}\left ( 1+z\right ) ^{3}+2\left ( 1-\omega _ { m}\right ) \right ] \frac{dr}{dz}=0 \end{array}\ ] ] whose solution in integral form is @xmath49 that is @xmath50 -\frac{1}{% 1+z}f\left [ -\frac{1}{3},\frac{1}{2};\frac{2}{3},\frac{\omega _ { m}}{\omega _ { m}-1}(1+z)^{3}\right ] \right ) $ % \end{tabular}\ ] ] where @xmath51 $ ] is the gauss hypergeometric function .
case the solution is @xmath52 -\sqrt{1+z}f\left [ -\frac{1}{4},1;\frac{5}{4},\frac{\omega _ { m}}{\omega _ { m}-1}\left ( 1+z\right ) ^{2}\right ] } { \left ( 2\omega _ { m}-1\right ) f\left [ -\frac{1}{4},1;\frac{5}{4},\frac{\omega _ { m}}{\omega _ { m}-1}\right ] + \frac{4}{5}\frac{\omega _ { m}}{\omega _ { m}-1}f\left [ \frac{3}{% 4},2;\frac{9}{4},\frac{\omega _ { m}}{\omega _ { m}-1}\right ] } $ % \end{tabular}\ ] ] the solution can be written in terms of the meijer @xmath53 function , but the expression is so complicated that it is not worth reporting it here .
case now quintessence coincides with ordinary matter ; however , the choice @xmath54 implies that the ordinary matter is completely clustered , while quintessence remains homogeneous .
the solution is @xmath55 \label{soluzione alfa0 m3}\ ] ] where @xmath56 cases for @xmath57 the dr equation is @xmath58 and its solution is @xmath59 $ & $ m\neq 2 $ \\ & \\ $ \frac{1}{1+z}\ln \left ( 1+z\right ) $ & $ m=2$% \end{tabular } \right.\ ] ] while for @xmath60 we get @xmath61 and @xmath62 the case @xmath42 is actually the standard angular diameter distance in a homogeneous universe .
we list some particular solution here for completeness ( see also bloomfield - torres & waga 1996 , waga & miceli 1999 ) .
case the general solution is @xmath63 which gives for any @xmath5 @xmath64 \right .
+ $ \\ $ \left .
-\frac{1}{\sqrt{\left ( 1+z\right ) ^{m}}}f\left [ \frac{m-2}{2\left ( m-3\right ) } , \frac{1}{2};\frac{3m-8}{2\left ( m-3\right ) } , \frac{\omega _ { m}}{% \omega _ { m}-1}\left ( 1+z\right ) ^{3}\right ] \right ) $ % \end{tabular}\ ] ] case the solution reduces to @xmath65 case for @xmath57 we get @xmath66 ( identical to the case @xmath41 * , * @xmath57 ) . for @xmath67
we reduce to the case @xmath42 * , * @xmath9 . * asymptotic limits . * the dr equation can be solved analytically in the limit of small or large @xmath16 . here
we give these limits ; they will be used to produce accurate analytical fits to the numerical solutions . for small @xmath16 and
@xmath41 we have @xmath68 \frac{dr_{s}}{dz}+\frac{m}{2}\left ( 1-\omega _ { m}\right ) r_{s}=0 \label{drgpiccoli}\ ] ] whose solution is @xmath69 } { a\left ( \omega _ { m},m\right ) } \exp \left\ { -\left [ 3\omega _ { m}+m\left ( 1-\omega _ { m}\right ) + 4\right ] \frac{z}{4}\right\}\ ] ] where @xmath70 ^{2}+24\omega _ { m}}}{4}\ ] ] or , to second order in @xmath16 @xmath71 z^{2}+o\left ( z^{3}\right ) \label{second}\ ] ] for completeness , we quote also the result in the case @xmath72 : @xmath73 } { a^{\alpha } \left ( \omega _ { m},m,\alpha \right ) } \exp \left\ { -\left [ 3\omega _ { m}+m\left ( 1-\omega _ { m}\right ) + 4% \right ] \frac{z}{4}\right\}\ ] ] where @xmath74 ^{2}+24\left ( 1-\alpha \right ) \omega _ { m}}}{4}.\ ] ] the limit to second order is identical to eq . ( [ second ] ) , which shows that for small redshift the degree of emptiness is not relevant . for large @xmath16 ( and @xmath75 )
the dr equation for @xmath76 reduces to @xmath77 if we define @xmath78 we obtain the equation @xmath79 g=0\ ] ] whose solution can be written in terms of bessel functions of first kind : @xmath80 $ & $ m\neq 0 $ \\ & \\
$ c_{2}-\frac{2}{5\left ( 1+z\right ) ^{5/2}}c_{1}$ & $ m=0$% \end{tabular } \right .
\label{rlarge}\ ] ] where @xmath81 notice that the large-@xmath16 limit is always a constant : @xmath82 since in the limit of large @xmath16 the @xmath83 term in ( [ rlarge ] ) is negligible , we will consider in the following only the @xmath84 term .
again for completeness we quote the analogous result for any @xmath72 : @xmath85\ ] ] * numerical fits . *
the rest of this section focuses on the @xmath41 case , for which we do not have a closed solution .
although in the application of the next section we employ the exact numerical solutions , it may prove practical to produce analytical fits .
we use the asymptotic limits above to build an analytical fit to the full numerical solution , valid for all @xmath1 and all @xmath5 .
we search a fit in the form @xmath86 where the function @xmath87 is a step - like curve chosen so as to interpolate from @xmath88 to @xmath89 as @xmath16 goes from @xmath89 to infinity , and @xmath90 interpolates similarly from @xmath89 to @xmath91 we chose @xmath92 $ \\ \\ $ t_{l}\left ( z\right ) = \frac{1}{2}\left [ 1+\tanh \left ( \frac{1}{\delta } \ln \left ( \frac{z}{z_{0}}\right ) \right ) \right ] $ % \end{tabular}\ ] ] so that the transition occurs at @xmath93 and @xmath94 sets its steepness .
we have then three parameters @xmath95 to fit as functions of @xmath1 and @xmath5 .
the result for @xmath84 in terms of a simple polynomial fit is @xmath96 for @xmath93 and @xmath94 we find convenient to use the following functional form : @xmath97 the values of the fit parameters for @xmath93 and @xmath94 are listed in table i. @xmath98 such fits are accurate to better than 5% over the range @xmath99 and @xmath100 as can be seen from fig .
2 , where we compare our fits to a sample of exact numerical solutions . as a cautionary remark ,
let us notice that the assumption of a constant @xmath101 over a very large range in redshift is certainly problematic .
the results of the next section , however , are obtained in a relatively narrow range of redshifts , so that the approximation should be acceptable .
now that we are in possess of the general angular diameter distance in quintessence cosmology we can apply it to real data . as a first application , in this section we use six observed time - delays to measure @xmath0 taking into account the presence of quintessence fields .
let us first present the data .
there are only seven lens systems with measured time - delays : b0218 + 357 ( biggs et al . 1999 ; lehr et al . 1999 ; patnaik porcas & browne 1995 ) , q0957 + 561 ( bar - kana et al .
1999 ; kundi et al .
1997 ) , he1104 - 1805 ( courbin , lidman & magain 1998 ; wisotzki , wucknitz , lopez & srensen 1998 ) , pg1115 + 080 ( bar - kana 1997 ; impey et al .
1998 ; schechter et al . 1996 ) , b1600 + 434 ( burud et al .
2000 ; koopmans , de bruyn , xanthopoulos & fassnacht 2000 ) , b1608 + 656 ( fassnacht c. d. et al . 1999 ; koopmans & fassnacht 1999 ) and pks1830 - 211 ( lehr et al .
1999 ; lovell et al . 1998 ; wiklind & combes 1999 ) . due to the image multiplicity
, we have in total ten time - delays .
the lens model we use , the isothermal lens of mao , witt and keeton ( mao , witt & keeton 2000 ) can not be adapted to q0957 + 561 and b1608 + 656 so we are left with five lens systems and six time - delays , as detailed in table ii .
@xmath103 adopting the isothermal model , the relation between the distances of the deflector ( subscript @xmath104 ) and of the source ( @xmath105 ) and the time - delay between two images labelled 1 and 2 in terms of observable quantities is @xmath106 where @xmath107,\ ] ] @xmath108 is the angular distance between one of the two images and the center of the deflector and where @xmath109 to estimate @xmath0 we build the likelihood function @xmath110 , \ ] ] where we separated between quantities that contain theoretical parameters and purely observational quantities by definining the variables @xmath111 and where @xmath112 is the total error on @xmath113 , obtained by standard error propagation ( this error is dominated by the uncertainty on the angular positions @xmath108 ) .
then we marginalize over @xmath114 ( defined in the range @xmath115 and @xmath116 respectively ) and produce the marginalized and normalized likelihood @xmath117 that represents the likelihood of @xmath0 ( normalized to unity by the constant @xmath118 ) given any possible perfect fluid quintessence model .
we also evaluated @xmath119 and @xmath120 , marginalizing over the other variables , but the likelihoods we obtain are too flat to derive any interesting conclusion on the quintessence parameters .
we also estimated the effect of imposing a gaussian prior on @xmath121 with mean 0.3 and standard deviation 0.1@xmath122 we compared the marginalized likelihood with the likelihood in the `` standard '' cases @xmath123 and @xmath8 ( pure cosmological constant ) , and @xmath60 and @xmath9 ( no quintessence ) .
table iii summarizes the likelihood results : here 1,2,3@xmath37 stand for a probability of 68,95,99% , respectively ; the first four cases are marginalized over @xmath1 and @xmath5 , and the prior is the above mentioned gaussian on @xmath1 .
the strongest effects are obtained in the empty beam case , @xmath41 , because in this case the quintessence term is dominating in the last term of the dr equation .
the likelihood is shifted to lower values , in comparison to the two `` standard '' cases ( see fig .
5 ) , with an increase in the variance . for @xmath42
the shift is less evident and there is a degeneracy between marginalized likelihood and no quintessence likelihood .
thus the dependency of @xmath0 for @xmath1 and @xmath5 is strongest in the empty beam case . with no prior
we obtain @xmath124 @xmath125 already with six time - delays , the effect of a quintessence cosmology on the estimation of @xmath0 is therefore not negligible .
a qualitative idea of how the method can perform in the future can be gained assuming that the same six time delays can be estimated with only a 10% error on the variable @xmath126 . in this case
, we would get not only a better estimation of @xmath0 but also a substantial removal of the degeneracy with respect to @xmath1 and @xmath5 .
this exercise illustrates the potentiality of the method towards a detection of quintessence and a distinction from a pure cosmological constant .
the results of the simulation for @xmath41 are summarized in table iv and in figure 6 .
if 70% or so of the total matter content is filled by a new component with negative pressure and weak clustering , all the classical deep cosmological probes are affected in some way .
here we addressed the question of how the dyer - roeder distance changes when this new component , quintessence , is taken into account .
we have shown that , particularly in the case of empty beam , the effect of the quintessence is to move the estimate of @xmath0 to lower values with respect to two standard models , and to increase the spread of the likelihood distribution .
this is the first time , to our knowledge , that a full likelihood analysis of the almost entire set of time - delays available is performed . as a byproduct of our analysis
, we produced fits for a large range of values of @xmath1 and @xmath5 accurate to within 5%@xmath122 the future prospects seem interesting for the time - delay method : with a not unrealistic increase in accuracy ( or in the number of time delays ) , the quintessence could be detected and distinguished from a pure cosmological constant , thanks to the deepness to which lensing effects are observable .
an obvious improvement of our analysis , currently underway , is to investigate the dependence on @xmath128 and on curvature , producing a fully marginalized likelihood for @xmath0 .
amendola l. , 2000 , phys . rev .
d62 , 043511 , preprint astro - ph/9908440baccigalupi c. , perrotta f. & matarrese s. , 2000 , phys . rev .
d61 , 023507 , preprint astro - ph/9906066balbi a. , et al . , 2000 , astro - ph/0005124barber a. , et al . ,
2000 , astro - ph/0002437bar - kana r. , 1997 , apj , 489 , 21 , preprint astro - ph/9701068bar - kana r. , et al . , 1999 ,
apj , 523 , 54biggs a. d. , et al . , 1999 , mnras , 304 349 , preprint astro - ph/9811282bloomfield torres l. f. & waga i. , 1996 , mnras , 279 , 712burud i. , et al .
, 2000 , preprint astro - ph/0007136caldwell r. r. , dave r. , & steinhardt p. j.,1998 , phys .
80 , 1582courbin f. , lidman p. & magain p. , 1998 ,
a&a , 330 , 57de bernardis p. , et al . , 2000 , nature , 404 , 995demianski m. , de ritis r. , marino a. a. , piedipalumbo e. , 2000 , preprint astro - ph/0004376dyer c. c. & roeder r. c. , 1972 , apj , 174 , l115dyer c. c. & roeder r. c. , 1974 , apj , 189 , 167fassnacht c. d. , et al . , 1999 , apj , 527 , 513 , preprint astro - ph/9907257ferreira p. g. & joyce m. , 1988 , phys .
d58 , 2350frieman j. , hill c. t. , stebbins a. & waga i. , 1995 , phys .
75 , 2077impey c. d. , et al . , 1998 ,
apj , 509 , 551.koopmans l. v. e. & fassnacht c. d. , 1999 , apj , 527 , 513 , preprint astro - ph/9907258koopmans l. v. e. , de bruyn a. g. , xanthopoulos e. & fassnacht c. d. , 2000 , a&a , 356 , 391 , preprint astro - ph/0001533kundi t. , et al . , 1997,apj , 482 , 75lange a. e. , et al.,2000 , astro - ph/0005004 , phys .
rev . d submittedlehr j. , et al . , 1999 , preprint astro - ph/9909072lovell j. e. j. , et al . , 1998 ,
apj , 508 , 51 , preprint astro - ph/9809301patnaik a. r. , porcas r. w. & browne i. w. a. , 1995 , mnras , 274 , l5perlmutter s. , et al . , 1999 , ap.j . , 517 , 565ratra b. & peebles p. j. e. , 1988 , phys . rev . ,
d37 , 3406.riess a. g. , et al . , 1998 , ap.j . ,
116 , 1009schechter p. l. , et al .
, 1996 preprint astro - ph/9611051schneider p. , ehlers j. & falco e. e. , 1992 , gravitational lenses
springer - verlag new yorksilveira v. , & waga i. , 1997 , phys .
d56 , 4625vilenkin a. , 1984 , phys .
53 , 1016waga i. & miceli a. pam .
r. , 1999 , phys .
d 59 , 1035 , preprint astro - ph/9811460wetterich c. , 1995 , a & a , 301 , 321wiklind t. & combes f. , 1999 , preprint astro - ph/9909314wisotzki l. , wucknitz o. , lopez s. & srensen a. n. , 1998 astro - ph/9810181 preprintwitt h. j. , mao s. & keeton c. , r. , 2000 , preprint astro - ph/0004069 | we calculate analytically and numerically the dyer - roeder distance in perfect fluid quintessence models and give an accurate fit to the numerical solutions for all the values of the density parameter and the quintessence equation of state .
then we apply our solutions to the estimation of @xmath0 from multiple image time delays and find that the inclusion of quintessence modifies sensibly the likelihood distribution of @xmath0 , generally reducing the best estimate with respect to a pure cosmological constant .
marginalizing over the other parameters ( @xmath1 and the quintessence equation of state ) , we obtain @xmath2 km / sec / mpc for an empty beam and @xmath3 km / sec / mpc for a filled beam .
we also discuss the future prospects for distinguishing quintessence from a cosmological constant with time delays .
epsf.tex -.5 in |
the production of heavy quarkonium offers a unique perspective into the process of hadronization , because the creation of the relevant valence partons , the heavy quarks , is essentially perturbative .
quarkonium production and decay have been the subject of a vast theoretical literature and of intensive experimental study , in which the effective field theory nonrelativistic qcd ( nrqcd ) @xcite has played a guiding role .
nrqcd offers a systematic formalism to separate dynamics at the perturbative mass scale of the heavy quarks from nonperturbative dynamics , through an expansion in relative velocity within the pair forming the bound state . in nrqcd
, the description of the relevant nonperturbative dynamics is reduced to the determination of a limited number of qcd matrix elements , accessible from experiment and , in principle , lattice computation .
a characteristic feature of the application of nrqcd to production processes is the indispensible role of color octet matrix elements , which describe the nonperturbative transition of quark pairs in adjoint representation into quarkonia through soft gluon emission .
an early success of nrqcd was to provide a framework for the striking tevatron run i data on high-@xmath2 heavy quarkonium production @xcite , and it has been extensively applied to heavy quarkonia in both collider and fixed target experiments . a wide - ranging review of theory and experiment for quarkonium production and decay has been given recently in ref .
much of the analysis has been based on a factorization formalism proposed in @xcite , which offers a systematic procedure for the application of nrqcd to quarkonium production .
it is fair to say , however , that , in contrast to quarkonium decay , fully convincing arguments have not yet been given for nrqcd factorization as applied to high-@xmath2 production processes @xcite .
this omission may or may not be related to the current lack of confirmation for its predictions on quarkonium polarization at high @xmath2 @xcite . in this paper , we summarize progress toward the derivation of an appropriate factorization formalism for high-@xmath2 quarkonia , illustrating our considerations with results on infrared emission at next - to - next - to - leading order ( nnlo ) . at nnlo
we find infrared divergences that do not fall precisely into the pattern suggested in ref .
these divergences may , however , be incorporated into color octet matrix elements by a technical redefinition that makes the latter gauge invariant .
it is not clear whether this pattern extends beyond nnlo , and we conclude that nrqcd factorization must be examined further for production processes . in any case ,
all our results are consistent with the factorization of evolution logarithms in the ratio of momentum transfer to quark mass from nonperturbative matrix elements @xcite . in the results presented below
, the relevant infrared divergence is proportional to @xmath3 , where @xmath4 is the relative velocity of the heavy pair in the quarkonium rest frame .
the rotational invariance of this result ( in the quarkonium rest frame ) makes it possible to match the long - distance behavior of an arbitrary cross section to an octet matrix element in a manner that does not depend on the directions of energetic final - state gluons . in other words
, we may factorize the perturbative long - distance contributions from the short - distance cross section , and replace them with a universal nonperturbative matrix element that has the same perturbative long - distance behavior , just as proposed in @xcite and extended in @xcite .
we begin our discussion with a brief review of nrqcd factorization at high transverse momentum .
we discuss for definiteness the production of the @xmath5 and related heavy quarkonium states @xmath6 in leptonic or hadronic collisions , @xmath7 . to leading power in @xmath8 , which we assume to be a small parameter , production proceeds through gluon fragmentation . according to conventional factorization theorems @xcite
, we have ( keeping only the gluon ) @xmath9 where generally we pick the factorization scale @xmath10 to be of the order of @xmath2 . in this expression , the convolution in the momentum fraction @xmath11
is denoted by @xmath12 , and we have absorbed all information on the initial state into @xmath13 .
if we also assume nrqcd factorization , we have in addition to ( [ cofact ] ) , @xmath14+x}(p_t)\ , \langle { \mathcal o}^h_n\rangle\ , , \label{nrfact}\ ] ] where the @xmath15 are nrqcd operators , classified by powers of relative velocity and characterized by the various rotational and color transformation properties of the @xmath16 state @xmath17 $ ] . assuming both ( [ cofact ] ) and ( [ nrfact ] ) to hold , we conclude that the gluon fragmentation function is related to the nrqcd matrix element by @xcite @xmath18}(z,\mu , m_c ) \ , \langle { \mathcal o}^h_n\rangle\ , , \label{combofact}\ ] ] where @xmath19}(z,\mu , m_c)$ ] describes the evolution of an off - shell gluon into a quark pair in state @xmath17 $ ] , including logarithms of @xmath20 . in the following
, we will study the fragmentation function itself , concentrating on infrared divergences at nnlo .
first , however , we make some observations concerning the gauge transformation properties of nrqcd color octet matrix elements .
production operators for state @xmath6 were introduced in ref .
@xcite in the form ^h_n(0 ) = ^_n(0 ) ( a^_ha_h ) ^_n(0 ) , [ ondef1 ] where @xmath21 is the creation operator for state @xmath6 , and where @xmath22 and @xmath23 involve products of color and spin matrices , and at higher dimensions of covaraint derivatives .
although the heavy ( anti)quark fields ( @xmath24 ) @xmath25 are all at the same space - time point ( here @xmath26 ) , the operator @xmath27 is not truly local , because the operator @xmath28 creates particle @xmath6 for out states , in the far future . in particular , operator - valued gauge transformations do not commute with the product @xmath29 in general .
a consequence of nonlocality is that the right - hand side of eq .
( [ ondef1 ] ) is not gauge invariant in perturbation theory unless the individual product @xmath30 and @xmath31 are separately invariant .
this is the case when the @xmath22 s specify color singlets , but not when they specify color octets .
a related issue arises in the field - theoretic definitions of fragmentation functions @xcite , such as @xmath32 in eq .
( [ cofact ] ) above .
it is resolved by supplementing the bi - local products of fields by nonabelian phase operators , or wilson lines : @xmath33 = \exp \left[-ig\int_0^\infty d\lambda\ , l \cdot a(x+\lambda l ) \right]$ ] .
in contrast to parton distributions , moments of fragmentation functions do not result in expectation values of local operators @xcite , and the corresponding wilson lines are not guaranteed to cancel identically . for a color octet combination ,
the gauge field @xmath34 is given in adjoint representation , just as for a gluon fragmentation function , for which the operator @xmath35 multiplies the gauge covariant field strength @xmath36 . to be definite , and for convenience in relating nrqcd operators to the gluon fragmentation function , we will choose @xmath37 as a lightlike vector in the minus directon : @xmath38 .
our gauge invariant redefinition of production operators in octet representation is now found by the replacement ( which we refer to as a gauge completion ) , ^h_n(0 ) ^_n , c(0 ) _ l^ [ 0,a]_cb(a^_ha_h ) _ l [ 0,a]_ba ^_n , a(0 ) , [ replace ] where we have exhibited the color indices of the octets . in perturbation theory ,
the wilson lines generate propagators of the form @xmath39 when they carry gluon momentum @xmath40 , and the gluons couple to the wilson line at vertices @xmath41 , with @xmath42 structure constants .
these are precisely the same as the propagators and vertices of the eikonal approximation for the emission and absorption of soft gluons by an energetic gluon of momentum @xmath43 .
we will use this correspondence below .
it is worth noting that the replacement ( [ replace ] ) is nt really necessary if gauge dependence in the matrix elements and coefficient functions is infrared safe .
this appears to be an implicit assumption in the discussion of ref .
@xcite . as we shall see , however , although gauge dependence is certainly free of infrared singularities at next - to - leading order , at nnlo this is no longer the case .
for this discussion , we study the perturbative expansion of the fragmentation function for @xmath45+x$ ] with @xmath46= c(p/2+q)\bar c(p/2-q)$ ] , a pair with total momentum @xmath47 and relative momentum @xmath48 , always projected onto a color singlet state .
we can , of course , further project various spin and orbital angular momentum states @xmath17 $ ] as in eq .
( [ combofact ] ) . beyond lowest order , the computation of these diagrams tests nrqcd factorization , eq .
( [ combofact ] ) , which is verified to the extent that we can absorb , that is match , any infrared divergences into the perturbative expansion of nrqcd matrix elements @xmath49 @xcite .
we will be interested in gluons whose energies are much below @xmath50 .
for nrqcd factorization to hold these soft gluons must factorize from the higher energy radiation that generates logarithms of @xmath51 . because we need only the infrared structure of the diagrams from gluons of very low momentum , we may suppress overall color and combinatorial factors , as well as momentum factors that depend only on the scale of @xmath50 , including the lo fragmentation of the parent gluon , which is off - shell by @xmath52 , into the quark pair .
= 5.5 cm [ fig1 ] .
figure 1a shows the lowest order diagram @xmath53 , and figs .
1b , c show typical contributions with single soft gluon emission in the fragmentation function , all in cut diagram notation . both fig .
1b and 1c represent a class of four diagrams , in which gluons are attached to one of the two lines of the quark pair in the amplitude and its complex conjugate . in each diagram
we may treat the quarks in eikonal approximation , in effect replacing them with time - like wilson lines , whose propagators and vertices are given by @xmath54 and @xmath55 , respectively , for quarks , with @xmath56 a color generator in fundamental representation and @xmath57 the time - like quark four - velocity .
the corresponding approximation for antiquarks simply changes the sign at the vertex . the vertical lines in fig .
1b and 1c represent the quark pair final state , including a projection onto a color singlet configuration .
the full fragmentation function is found by cutting the remaining lines in all possible ways . when the gluon is cut in fig . 1b ,
in particular , the resulting diagrams have an uncancelled infrared pole in dimensional regularization , beginning at order @xmath58 when the gluon momentum @xmath59 .
this gluonic contribution , however , which involves only interactions between the pair , may be matched straightforwardly to a color octet matrix element , with which it shares an identical topology @xcite . the divergent part of fig
. 1b may be isolated by evaluating the four relevant diagrams in eikonal approximation and then expanding them in @xmath60 .
alternately , we may expand the momentum - space integrand , isolating the @xmath3 term before the integration . in @xmath61 dimensions , and in the quark pair
rest frame , the latter approach leads readily to an expression in terms of the total and relative momenta @xmath47 ( @xmath62 ) and @xmath48 , respectively , @xmath63 \nonumber\\ & & \hspace{30 mm } \times \ [ q^\nu ( p\cdot k ) - ( q\cdot k ) p^\nu ] \frac{1}{[(p\cdot k)^2]^2 } \nonumber\\ & = & { 16\over 3}\ , { \alpha_s\over \pi}\ , { \vec{q}\ , { } ^2\over p^2}\ , { 1\over -\varepsilon } + \dots\ , , \label{nlopt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have exhibited the infrared pole , regularized for @xmath64 .
this infrared pole , along with an appropriate color trace , appears at nlo as a multiplicative factor times the lowest - order fragmentation function , as found , for example , in refs.@xcite . in the integral
, the terms in square brackets correspond to the lowest - order vertices for the operator @xmath65 , with @xmath66 the field strength . in the quarkonium rest frame
, this corresponds to an electric dipole transition from octet to singlet color states @xcite .
an advantage of this expansion is that , because the field strength decouples from scalar polarized lines , all singularities associated with gluon momenta collinear to @xmath67 vanish on a diagram - by - diagram basis , and double poles in @xmath68 are entirely absent in the calculation . by the same token ,
the integral in ( [ nlopt ] ) is gauge invariant in the polarization sum for the final - state gluon of fig .
finally , in fig , 1c , the soft gluon connects the pair to the wilson line .
in covariant gauges , this diagram has double and single infrared / collinear poles in dimensional regularization .
these poles , however , cancel against analogous contributions from the corresponding virtual diagram .
imaginary parts of the virtual diagrams , of course , cancel in the fragmentation function , which is real . in practical terms , the contribution of fig .
1c plus its virtual counterpart contributes solely to the perturbative factor @xmath19}(z,\mu , m_c)$ ] in eq .
( [ combofact ] ) .
we note that the infrared behavior of all of the diagrams of fig .
1 is common between the fragmentation function and a generic cross section in which a high-@xmath2 gluon of momentum @xmath37 recoils against the heavy quark pair .
indeed , the same cancellation mechanism for the infrared divergences of fig .
1c is referred to specifically in ref .
@xcite as an essential step in the justification of nrqcd factorization for production cross sections .
to the extent that all the infrared poles of diagrams that do not share the topology of nrqcd matrix elements cancel , the matching of perturbative infrared poles with those of the effective theory is ensured .
the result of this cancellation is referred to as topological factorization @xcite .
the same considerations that lead to the inclusion of nonabelian phases to the fragmentation function , however , suggest that the cancellation of non - factored soft gluons may be nontrivial , and should be checked beyond nlo .
of course , a full nnlo calculation of either cross sections or fragmentation functions would be daunting .
fortunately , the analysis of the relevant infrared behavior at nnlo requires only the eikonal approximation , and is therefore a much more manageable , although still extensive , task , to which we now turn .
we can readily generalize our nlo discussion to nnlo . once again , because we are interested in gluons whose energies are much less that @xmath50 , we can adopt the eikonal approximation , and neglect all dynamics at the scale of the quark masses . in nrqcd , these approximations are relevant to gluons of order @xmath69 , with @xmath70 the relative velocity , but of course in the perturbative calculation the gluon momentum goes to zero .
we note that for octet - singlet transitions at nnlo , we need not include virtual gluon exchange between the quark and antiquark , except for diagrams that are already topologically factorized . as a result , we will not need not consider violations of the eikonal approximation from momentum regions at or below the scale @xmath71 , or the resulting @xmath72 singular behavior .
representative diagrams for the fragmentation function are shown in fig . 2 .
the full infrared fragmentation function is again generated by taking all allowed cuts of the remaining lines of each such diagram .
we are concerned only with diagrams that connect octet to singlet quark states , and which are not topologically factorized , since these are the potential sources of nonfactoring behavior in both the fragmentation function and related cross sections .
we recall once more that the familiar argument for nrqcd factorization is based on the conjecture that all infrared regions in these diagrams cancel after this limited sum over cuts @xcite . in fact , we shall see that this is the case at nnlo only if we employ the gauge - completed definitions for nrqcd matrix elements , as in eq .
( [ replace ] ) above .
[ fig2 ] as at nlo , we will concern ourselves here with infrared behavior at order @xmath3 , which may be computed by evaluating each diagram in eikonal approximation and then expanding their sum in @xmath73 , or by expanding the diagrams first , as in eq .
( [ nlopt ] ) . noting that the two approaches give the same answer , we summarize the results here , and provide details of the calculations elsewhere @xcite .
the individual classes of diagrams in fig . 2a and 2b , for which two gluons are exchanged between the quarks and the wilson line , satisfy the infrared cancellation conjecture of ref .
@xcite , by summing over the possible cuts and connections to quark and antiquark lines , as do diagrams that have three gluon - eikonal vertices on the quark pair and one on the wilson line . for the class of diagrams related to fig .
2c , however , with a three - gluon interaction , this cancellation fails .
expanding again to second order in the relative momentum @xmath48 , the full contribution from fig .
2c , found by cutting the gluon line @xmath74 and the wilson line can be written by analogy to eq .
( [ nlopt ] ) as @xmath75 \nonumber\\ & & \hspace{40 mm } \times \ [ q^\mu ( p\cdot k_1 ) - ( q\cdot k_1 ) p^\mu ] \ , ~ [ q^\nu ( p\cdot k_1)-(q\cdot k_2 ) p^\nu]~ \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{40 mm } \times \frac{1}{[p\cdot k_1 + i\epsilon]^2~ [ p\cdot k_2 - i\epsilon ] ^2 } \nonumber\\ & & \hspace{40 mm } \times \frac{1}{[k_2 ^ 2 - i \epsilon]~[(k_2- k_1)^2 - i\epsilon]~ [ l\cdot ( k_1 - k_2 ) - i\epsilon ] } \ , , \label{nnlopt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath76 $ ] represents the momentum part of the three - gluon coupling . as in eq .
( [ nlopt ] ) , we have suppressed color factors and momentum dependence at the scale @xmath50 . as observed above , the field - strength vertices eliminate collinear singularities on a diagram - by - diagram basis .
the leading singularities in ( [ nnlopt ] ) and related diagrams are therefore never worse than @xmath77 .
summing over all such contributions , however , we find a noncancelling real infrared pole in the fragmentation function , which may be written in invariant form as @xmath78\ , .
\label{gn}\ ] ] in the rest frame of heavy - quarkonium ( @xmath79 ) , this becomes simply @xmath80 where @xmath4 is the relative velocity of the heavy quark pair
. we will give the extension of this result to all powers in @xmath70 elsewhere @xcite .
( [ gn1 ] ) shows explicitly the breakdown of the simplest topological factorization of infrared dependence at nnlo .
its presence implies that infrared poles would appear in coefficient functions at nnlo and beyond when the factorization is carried out with octet nrqcd matrix elements defined in the conventional manner , eq .
( [ ondef1 ] ) . on the other hand , when defined according to its gauge - completed form ( [ replace ] ) , each octet nrqcd matrix element itself generates precisely the same pole terms given in ( [ gn1 ] ) above .
thus , at least at nnlo and to order @xmath3 , nrqcd factorization can accomodate these corrections .
we note , however , that at this order the nnlo correction is independent of the direction @xmath81 of the wilson line , while lorentz invariance alone would seem to allow a correction of the form @xmath82 .
the presence of poles with this coefficient could indicate problems with factorization , that is , with matching the poles of the fragmentation function to those of the perturbative cross section .
these could arise when the integration over @xmath48 is not rotationally invariant , as might happen for polarized final states , and/or final states with gluons of energies of order @xmath50 in the rest frame of @xmath6 , since their directions are arbitrary .
we are unable at this stage to rule out the occurance of such terms at higher orders in the strong coupling , or in higher powers of @xmath3 .
we have discussed the gauge invariance properties of color octet matrix elements in nrqcd as they appear in fragmentation functions .
gauge invariance and factorization require that they include nonabelian phase operators to match otherwise nonfactoring infrared divergences beginning at nnlo .
we have shown that at nnlo there are infrared ( not collinear ) poles from fragmentation diagrams that are not topologically equivalent to conventional nrqcd operators .
we have observed that rotational invariance in the quarkonium rest frame is an important consistency condition for the possibility of nrqcd factorization in terms of the gauge - completion of nrqcd operators
. should rotational invariance fail at higher orders , we anticipate that it will be necessary to complement the nrqcd classification of nonperturbative parameters for quarkonium production with matrix elements of additional operators , involving nonlocal products of the field strengths encountered above . finally ,
although our explicit calculations are carried out in the eikonal approximation for gluons of energies far below @xmath50 , it is not difficult to verify that these gluons do not interfere with the generation of standard evolution for the @xmath44 fragmentation functions .
the arguments for this result will be given elsewhere , along with details of the calculations described above .
this work was supported in part by the national science foundation , grants phy-0071027 , phy-0098527 and phy-0354776 , and by the department of energy , grant de - fg02 - 87er40371 .
we thank geoff bodwin for emphasizing the importance of this topic , and for many useful discussions .
collins and g. sterman , nucl .
b185 , 172 ( 1981 ) ; + j.c .
collins , d.e .
soper and g. sterman , nucl .
b261 , 104 ( 1985 ) ; b308 , 833 ( 1988 ) ; + g.t .
bodwin , phys .
d31 , 2616 ( 1985 ) erratum ibid .
d34 , 3932 ( 1986 ) . | we explore the role of soft gluon exchange in heavy quarkonium production at large transverse momentum .
we find uncanceled infrared poles at nnlo that are not matched by conventional nrqcd matrix elements .
we show , however , that gauge invariance and factorization require that conventional nrqcd production operators be modified to include nonabelian phases or wilson lines . with appropriately modified operators
, factorization is restored at nnlo .
we also argue that , in the absence of special cancellations , infrared poles at yet higher orders may require the inclusion of additional nonlocal operators , not present in the nrqcd expansion in relative veloctiy .
yitp - sb-05 - 01 + * fragmentation , factorization and infrared poles + * in heavy quarkonium production gouranga c. nayak@xmath0 , jian - wei qiu@xmath1 and george sterman@xmath0 _ @xmath0c.n .
yang institute for theoretical physics , stony brook university , suny + stony brook , new york 11794 - 3840 , u.s.a .
_ _ @xmath1department of physics and astronomy , iowa state university + ames , ia 50011 , u.s.a .
_ pacs numbers : 12.38.bx , 12.39.st , 13.87.fh,14.40gx |
there are a few facts about the universe we live in that we have now become certain of .
one such fact is that our universe is expanding . in 1929
edwin hubble discovered that distant galaxies appear to be receding from us with velocity proportional to their distance ( see fig .
[ hubble ] ) : @xmath0 where @xmath1 is the famous hubble constant , whose value is @xcite .
this observation marks the discovery that we live in an expanding universe .
because the above relation is linear it can be deduced that there is no centre for this expansion ( called hubble expansion ) ; distant galaxies are receding away from any observer , wherever placed , according to the above relation . the universe expansion , as it is perceived today , does not correspond to galaxies travelling through space away from each - other but it is due to an expansion of space itself , between the galaxies , which is responsible for galaxies being pulled away from each - other .
hence , according to hubble law above , the expansion of the universe is self - similar ; the three - dimensional equivalent of a photograph magnification .
such a uniform expansion suggests that the content of the universe is also uniformly distributed .
indeed , galaxy survey observations show that the distribution of galactic clusters and superclusters becomes uniform on scales above 100 mpc , which is about a few percent of the size of the observable universe ( e.g. see fig .
[ 2df ] ) . that is to say that structure in the universe is not of fractal form ; one does not find bigger structures the larger the distance scale considered .
instead , the largest structures correspond to bubble and filament like matter distributions comprised by galactic superclusters ( see fig . [ 2df ] ) whose characteristic size ( @xmath2 100 mpc ) is much less than the cosmological horizon scale which marks the limit of our observational capability .
the above correspond to observational support for the so - called _ cosmological principle _
, which simply states that , on large scales , `` the universe is homogeneous and isotropic '' , i.e. invariant under translations and rotations .
this means that there are no special points or directions in the universe , no centre , no edges and no axis of rotation . using the cosmological principle it has been possible to study the global dynamics of the universe as dictated by einstein s general relativity theory .
according to general relativity there is no stable spacetime solution which contains uniformly distributed matter and radiation and remains static .
hence , general relativity demands that the universe is either expanding or collapsing .
this agrees well with the observed hubble expansion .
now , going backwards in time , we would expect the universe to be contracting and its energy density increasing .
this means that matter in the early universe is predominantly relativistic , with a planckian spectrum of high black - body temperature .
furthermore , the universe content is fully ionised with matter being strongly coupled to radiation through thomson scattering . as the universe expands , its density is diluted and its temperature decreases . at some moment , the plasma filling the universe cools down enough to allow neutral atoms to form .
when this occurs , the scattering of radiation from matter is drastically reduced , which means that the universe content becomes transparent , allowing radiation to travel free , similarly to what happens at the photosphere ; the visible surface of the sun . at that time radiation
is said to `` decouple '' from matter .
this released radiation fills all space and survives until the present time .
indeed , in 1978 penzias and wilson won the nobel prize because they discovered this so - called cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) radiation .
as shown in fig , [ cmb ] , the cmb has an almost perfect blackbody spectrum peaked at microwave wavelengths corresponding to temperature of @xmath3 k. the distribution of the cmb is extremely uniform with minute variations in its temperature at the level .
such uniformity is another piece of supporting evidence for the cosmological principle .
the existence of the cmb shows that the early universe was hot and dense and a lot different from the universe at present .
this fact , along with the observation that the universe is expanding , agrees well with general relativity which suggests that our expanding universe has finite age .
this means that , when travelling backwards in time , the reversed expansion is such that all distances shrink in a self - similar manner to zero in finite time . that initial moment of infinite density has been dubbed the big bang ; the onset of time itself .
the latest dynamical estimate for the age of the universe is @xmath4 gyrs @xcite , which is in good agreement with estimates of the ages of the oldest astrophysical objects such as , for example , globular star clusters @xcite .
hence , cosmologists today operate in the framework of a standard model , which considers that the universe began its existence 14 billion years ago , passed through a hot period of ultra - high density , and has continued to cool down until the present because of the expansion of space .
this back - bone history of the universe is called the hot big bang and has been observationally confirmed as far back as the time when the universe was no more than a few seconds old . despite the observational support for the hot big bang
the fact is that , fundamentally , the cosmological principle is incompatible with a finite age for the universe .
this paradox is the so - called _ horizon problem _ and has to do with the apparent uniformity of the universe over distances which are causally unconnected .
for example , the cmb appears to be correlated at regions beyond the causal correlation scale ( the so - called particle horizon ) ; it appears to be in thermal equilibrium and at a preferred reference frame .
general relativity does not single out a preferred reference frame , which would imply that doppler shifts in the frequency of the cmb over causally unconnected regions ( with different centre of mass frames ) would result in @xmath5 .
in contrast , observations suggest that matter at these regions does lie at the same reference frame when the cmb is emitted and the fractional perturbation of the cmb temperature is much smaller
. one can understand the problem schematically by considering the spacetime diagram in fig .
[ horizon ] .
the slanted lines depict signals which travel with the speed of light , which is the fastest possible propagation through space . along the time axis
the present time @xmath6yrs is depicted at the tip of our past light - cone , that is the region of spacetime from which we can receive signals and lies below the large slanted lines in the diagram .
the horizontal line corresponds to the time of the decoupling of radiation from matter , when the cmb was emitted at @xmath7yrs .
the small triangles correspond to the light - cones at the time of decoupling and designate the regions which are in causal contact when the cmb was emitted ; at @xmath8 an observer can not be affected by events occurring beyond his / her light - cone . because @xmath9 our field of vision today includes a large number of regions which were beyond causal contact at the time of the cmb emission and yet these uncorrelated regions appear to be in thermal equilibrium at the same temperature
. + the most compelling mechanism to date which overcomes the horizon problem is the theory of _ cosmic inflation _ originally suggested by guth @xcite and independently by starobinsky @xcite . in a nutshell
, cosmic inflation can be defined as a brief period of superluminal expansion of space in the early universe .
general relativity allows inflation because the latter does not correspond to displacement of matter or energy through space with velocity faster than lightspeed .
instead , it is space itself which is expanding faster than light can travel .
indeed , inflationary expansion is readily obtained by general relativity if certain conditions are satisfied . how does inflation overcome the horizon problem ?
well , inflation produces correlations beyond the causal horizon by expanding an initially causally connected region to a size large enough to encompass the observable universe .
the region which corresponds to the observable universe is supposed to lie within the light - cone before the onset of inflation .
being initially causally self - correlated it can become uniform by interacting with itself . after it is inflated to super - horizon distances this original uniformity sets up uniform initial conditions after inflation , even if the original region corresponds to many causally - disconnected regions .
this is depicted schematically in fig .
[ horizon ] , where during inflation the growth of an initially causally correlated region is shown to be faster than lightspeed so as to engulf the entire field of vision today .
hence , we see that , provided it lasts long enough , cosmic inflation can impose the cosmological principle as an initial condition for the hot big bang
. however , if the cosmological principle was exact then there would be no structure in the universe ; no galaxies , no stars with planets harbouring intelligent life .
all these structures require the uniformity of the universe to be violated . if not , the universe today would be filled only with the cmb radiation and a thinned out gas at temperature @xmath10 , evenly distributed through space .
our existence demands that the cosmological principle is only approximately respected .
it so happens that cosmic inflation can provide also a small violation of the cosmological principle .
this is due to quantum effects during inflation , which , as explained below , can introduce a tiny variation in the density @xmath11 of the universe , called the _ primordial density perturbation _ @xmath12 .
+ this density perturbation reflects itself onto the cmb through the so - called sachs - wolfe effect @xcite , which describes how the cmb photons become redshifted when crossing regions of density higher than average ( so - called overdensities ) because they lose energy while struggling to exit from the gravitational potential wells of these growing overdensities .
hence , variations in the density of the universe cause perturbations in the apparent temperature of the cmb radiation : @xmath13 indeed the observations ( e.g. see fig . [ wmap ] ) suggest that @xmath14 @xcite , which , albeit tiny , turns out to be enough to explain the formation of structures in the universe , such as galaxies and galactic clusters . starting from an initial density perturbation , structure formation proceeds through the process of _ gravitational instability_. the latter amounts to intensifying , in a runaway manner , the contrast between overdense and underdense regions and is based on the fact that overdensities grow more massive by attracting matter from surrounding underdensities , depleting them even further .
indeed , numerical simulations have shown that density perturbations of magnitude @xmath15 at @xmath8 suffice to generate the observed structures given 14 billion years of growth .
therefore , it seems that inflation can successfully impose both the cosmological principle onto the universe and the deviations from it , which are necessary for structure formation .
inflation produces the primordial density perturbation through a process called _ particle production _ that arises from considering the superluminal expansion of space in conjunction with the notion of the quantum vacuum .
we are all familiar with the concept of the classical vacuum .
a box filled with vacuum is a box which is totally empty of matter and energy , i.e. the energy in the box is .
however , in quantum theory , this can not be true and the box has to have .
this is due to _ heisenberg s uncertainty principle _ , which , for energy , can be expressed mathematically as @xmath16 the meaning of the above expression is that the energy of a closed system ( such as our box ) can not be precisely determined but it has to fluctuate by an amount @xmath17 , which , in a given time period @xmath18 , has to satisfy the above constraint .
the crucial point is that the reduced planck s constant is planck s constant . ]
@xmath19 featured above , is small but positive , which means that , for any finite time interval , @xmath17 has to be non - zero .
in fact , the smaller the period of time considered the larger the fluctuation of the energy has to be .
hence , the uncertainty principle amounts to a controlled violation of energy conservation .
this violation manifests itself as the brief appearance of pairs of particles and anti - particles , the reason being that other quantities such as the electric charge or other quantum numbers , are indeed conserved .
consequently , the quantum vacuum is not empty but , instead , it is filled with constantly appearing and disappearing pairs of so - called virtual particles and anti - particles ( see fig . [ qv ] ) .
the energy of these virtual particles is the so - called vacuum ( or zero - point ) energy .
the above may sound like a bunch of flowery ideas , but it so happens that there is experimental proof of the existence of virtual particles .
this is the famous casimir experiment , first realised by casimir and polder in 1948 @xcite .
consider a pair of parallel conducting plates , not electrically charged and not connected through an electrical circuit .
the plates are just standing in empty space ( i.e. in vacuum ) , close to each - other as shown in fig .
[ casimir ] .
classically there is no force on the plates except from their mutual gravitational attraction , which is extremely weak and can be ignored .
now , let us consider the existence of virtual particles in the space between the plates and in particular , the appearance of virtual photons .
photons are the quanta of the electromagnetic field .
they can be thought of as wave packets of electromagnetic radiation whose energy @xmath20 is related to their wavelength @xmath21 as @xmath22 where @xmath23 is the speed of light in vacuum .
the existence of photons has been confirmed by the photo - electric phenomenon , whose particle interpretation awarded einstein his nobel prize in 1921 .
now , since the plates are conducting they can not allow a non - zero electric field inside them .
hence , virtual photons appearing between the plates can only have a discrete spectrum of energies , corresponding to wavelengths that satisfy the constraint @xmath24 where @xmath25 is a positive integer and @xmath26 is the distance between the plates .
the above constraint ensures that the amplitude of the electric field remains zero at the surface of the conducting plates , as depicted in fig .
[ casimir ] .
however , the virtual photons appearing outside the plates are not constrained by the above relation and can have any wavelength .
this means that many more energies of virtual photons are allowed outside the plates compared to the discrete spectrum allowed between the plates .
thus , the vacuum energy density in the space between the plates is different from the one outside the plates .
this difference ( gradient ) of vacuum energy gives rise to a force @xmath27 , which has been measured and found to be in precise agreement with the predictions of quantum electrodynamics , confirming thereby the existence of virtual photons @xcite . before combining the notion of the quantum vacuum with cosmic inflation
we need to briefly discuss black holes .
black holes are predicted by general relativity and are thought to exist astrophysically , for example in the centres of galaxies .
a black hole is an extremely compact object with a gravitational field which is locally so intense that anything approaching close enough can never escape .
indeed , a black hole is surrounded by an _ event horizon _ , which is the surface on which the escape velocity from the black hole is equal to the speed of light .
this means that one would need to travel with the speed of light away from the black hole simply to remain on the event horizon . within the horizon
the gravitational attraction is so strong that , even when travelling with lightspeed , one can not avoid being pulled inwards . since no matter or energy can travel faster than the speed of light the event horizon forms a boundary on the causal structure of spacetime in the sense that events within the event horizon can not affect events outside it .
one can think of the event horizon as a surface which is permeable from one direction only ( from the outside ) . a classical black hole , being enclosed within an event horizon , can only absorb matter and energy which is captured by its pull from its environment .
in - falling matter increases the gravitational field of the black hole , which in turn increases the radius of its event horizon as the gravitational pull further extends its effect in the surrounding space .
hence , a classical black hole can only increase in mass and size .
such was the understanding of black holes until hawking studied them in conjunction with the quantum vacuum . hawking considered the appearance of virtual particle pairs in the vicinity of the event horizon .
suppose that one of the particles of the pair falls within the event horizon as shown in fig .
the other part of the pair may follow it , but since it is still outside the event horizon , it has a non - zero ( albeit tiny ) probability of escaping from the black hole , whereas , by definition of the event horizon , the particle within it has no chance of escaping .
thus , since pairs of virtual particles are constantly appearing from nothing ( through the controlled violation of energy conservation by the uncertainty principle ) in the vicinity of the event horizon , the net effect of the above possibility is that a tiny fraction of virtual particles does escape from the black hole .
such particles can not meet their counterparts of the original pair because the latter have fallen within the event horizon and can never escape .
therefore , these particles can not annihilate with their partners ; their conserved quantum numbers can not disappear .
consequently , the virtual particles which avoided falling within the event horizon ( while their partners did not ) survive and become real particles , which can be detected by distant observers @xcite .
stable real particles can survive indefinitely . for stable particles which used to be virtual particles that escaped from the event horizon of a black hole
, this means that @xmath18 in the uncertainty relation ( that allowed their existence ) can become very large .
thus , we find @xmath28 , i.e. over large time periods , energy conservation has to be restored
. since the particles which escaped from the black hole , can be detected by an observer to have a positive energy @xmath29 , with respect to this distant observer , the pair partners of these particles ( the ones which did fall into the black hole ) must have energy @xmath30 , where @xmath31 .
hence , from the viewpoint of the distant observer , the black hole appears to be absorbing particles of negative energy which equals in magnitude the positive energy of the particles radiated away having escaped from the event horizon .
receiving negative energy the black hole reduces in mass and its event horizon reduces in size , while emitting energy ( equivalent to its mass reduction ) in the form of so - called _ hawking radiation_. hawking found that the emitted radiation has a black - body spectrum corresponding to a characteristic temperature , called the _ hawking temperature _ @xmath32 @xcite .
surprisingly , @xmath32 was found to increase the smaller the black hole becomes , i.e. the emission of hawking radiation intensifies as the black hole shrinks .
this runaway behaviour ends up in the evaporation of the black hole @xcite .
turning this around , the emission of hawking radiation from supermassive astrophysical black holes , such as the ones in the centres of galaxies , is negligible and is overwhelmed by absorption of positive energy from their environment , such as surrounding matter or even the cmb radiation . what does black hole evaporation have to do with cosmic inflation ?
well , it so happens that the cosmological horizon ( the range of causal correlations ) during inflation corresponds to an event horizon of an `` inverted '' black hole ; a black hole `` inside - out '' , centred at the observer .
this can be understood by considering that , during inflation , matter inside the horizon is being `` sucked out '' by the superluminal expansion of space , in analogy with the fact that nearby matter is being `` sucked in '' by a black hole . in this manner the virtual particle pairs of the quantum vacuum can be pulled outside the horizon before they have a chance to annihilate as shown in fig .
[ superlum ] . in this case , being over superhorizon distance apart , they are beyond causal contact and can never find each - other to annihilate .
thus , they cease being virtual particles and become real particles instead .
this is why this process is called _ particle production _
@xcite .
it is important to state here that the existence of an event horizon suffices to have particle production .
it is the division of the causal structure of spacetime , enforced by the event horizon , which gives rise to the particle production process ; the separation of the virtual particle pairs .
thus , the event horizon , once it exists , can be seen to emit hawking radiation without the need of a black hole or any concentration of mass . during inflation ,
the event horizon is filled with hawking radiation ( since it corresponds to the outside of the `` inverted '' black hole ) . since , the horizon is centred at the observer and we can put an observer anywhere in space , this means that all space is filled with hawking radiation , i.e. particle production occurs everywhere once we have superluminal expansion .
now , in quantum theory , particles correspond to waves with an associated de broglie wavelength .
for example , a massive particle of mass @xmath33 is characterised by a wavelength @xmath34 .
this dual nature of particles is hard to visualise , although we are all familiar with many `` particle - like '' properties of waves , such as the reflection of an incident sea wave on a concrete wall .
it is also easy to accept that waves , like particles , carry energy and momentum , e.g. radio - waves , laser beams or tsunami waves .
particles correspond to waves travelling on an otherwise smooth sea , which we call a field ( the particle is part of the field as the sea wave is part of the sea ) , for example photons travel through the sea of the electromagnetic field .
virtual particles of the quantum vacuum , therefore , correspond to spontaneously arising ripples on the calm sea of their corresponding fields .
this is why they are also referred to as quantum fluctuations of these fields .
based on the above , the particle production process during inflation can be also understood as the stretching of quantum fluctuations by the superluminal expansion of space , to superhorizon distances .
this stretching transforms the quantum fluctuations into classical perturbations of the fields .
one can imagine them as mountains and valleys , corresponding to classical variations of the field in question over superhorizon distances .
a variation of the values of fields gives rise to a variation of their energy density .
this , therefore , is the way that particle production during inflation produces variations of the density of the universe which generate the primordial density perturbation , that sources the formation of structures in the universe @xcite .
schematically , we can write @xmath35+{\sf inflation } \;\rightarrow\ ; \frac{\delta\phi}{\phi}\;\rightarrow\ ; \frac{\delta\rho}{\rho } \;\rightarrow\;{\sf galaxies}\ ] ] where @xmath36 is one of the fields in question , whose typical variation during inflation is given by the hawking temperature @xmath37 .
thus , according to this scenario , all structures in the universe , such as galaxies , stars , planets and ultimately ourselves , originated as quantum fluctuations ( like the ones we observe in the lab through the casimir experiment ) during a period of superluminal expansion of space .
do we have any observational support for this amazing scenario ?
indeed we do .
high precision observations of the cmb temperature perturbations , which are due to the primordial density perturbation , have revealed a stunning agreement with the predictions of inflation .
[ peaks ] depicts an analysis of these temperature perturbations in spherical harmonics , which follows the theoretical prediction of inflation ( shown by the solid lines ) with remarkable consistency @xcite .
it was this kind of analysis that led to the collapse of a rival theory for the generation of the density perturbations ( that of cosmic strings ) , which did not predict a sequence of peaks in the angular spectrum @xcite ( they are clearly observed in fig . [ peaks ] ) .
the simplest and most natural realisations of inflation suggest that the hawking temperature @xmath32 remains roughly constant during the inflationary phase of the universe .
this means that the variations of the fields , produced by the particle production process , are of the same amplitude even though they may correspond to much different length - scales , because the quantum fluctuations which exit the horizon early are stretched to much larger distances than those which exit the horizon later on . as a result
we expect that the spectrum of the density perturbations is almost scale - invariant , i.e. their amplitude is independent of the length - scale considered .
indeed , parameterising the scale dependence of the perturbation spectrum on the wavenumber @xmath38 as @xmath39 , we expect that the spectral index would be @xmath40 , where @xmath41 with @xmath42 being the corresponding length - scale .
the latest observations suggest that @xmath43 @xcite , which is very close to scale - invariance exactly as inflation predicts .
the deviation from exact scale invariance was also expected , and has to do with the fact that the inflationary expansion has to end well before the first second of the universe history .
another feature of the observed cmb temperature perturbations which agrees well with inflation is the fact that they appear to be predominantly gaussian .
the nature of quantum fluctuations is stochastic ( that is to say random ) which suggests that @xmath44 has a gaussian bell - shaped distribution centred at @xmath32 .
thus , inflation naturally predicts gaussian perturbations , as is indeed observed . the most important feature of the observations which supports the inflationary scenario for the generation of the primordial density perturbation is the following .
the main peak in the angular power spectrum in fig . [ peaks ] corresponds to the scale of the cosmological horizon at the time @xmath8 of the emission of the cmb . as shown in fig .
[ peaks ] , this peak corresponds to the multipole moment with @xmath45 . in the bottom half ( the te part ) of fig .
[ peaks ] , we see that there is an anti - correlation feature at multipole moments significantly lower than the one of the main peak , which correspond to superhorizon scales at the time of the emission of the cmb .
this means that the density perturbations show correlations beyond the causal horizon , a feature that only the superluminal expansion of an inflationary phase can explain .
looking into the particle production process in more depth one has to wonder which kind of fields are the ones whose quantum fluctuations are responsible for the generation of the primordial density perturbation . until recently , all mechanisms considered the use of scalar fields for the density perturbations .
scalar fields are hypothetical spin - zero fields , which are characterised by one degree of freedom , that is a single value at a given point in space .
scalar fields are ubiquitous in theories beyond the standard model of particle physics , such as supersymmetry ( the scalar partners of the observed fermion fields ) or string theory ( the so - called moduli fields , which parametrise the size and shape of the hypothesised extra dimensions ) .
however , it has to be stressed that no scalar field has ever been observed .
this means that designing models using unobserved scalar fields undermines their predictability and falsifiability , despite the high precision of the recent cosmological observations .
the standard model of particle physics does contain one scalar field , which is the only piece of it that has not been experimentally confirmed .
this is the famous higgs field , thought to be responsible for the masses of standard model particles ( which are all the known particles such as electrons , quarks and so on ) .
observing the quanta of this field , the higgs bosons , is one of the primary objectives of the large hadron collider ( lhc ) , which is about to become operational in the coming months in cern , geneva .
observation of the higgs particles , among other things , will substantiate the claim that scalar fields do exist and are not merely mathematical constructions .
however , what if the higgs bosons are not found by the lhc ?
do we have an alternative proposal for the generation of the density perturbations from inflation ?
can we form the galaxies without scalar fields ? recently , a proposal alternative to scalar fields has been put forward , which uses vector boson fields instead @xcite .
these are spin - one fields , characterised by three degrees of freedom corresponding to their magnitude , direction and orientation at every point in space .
in contrast to scalar fields , vector bosons are indeed observed .
the standard model of particle physics contains four vector boson fields : one is the familiar photon , i.e. the quantum of the electromagnetic field , and then we have the three massive vector bosons of the weak nuclear force - decay , which transforms neutrons to protons by emission of electrons , otherwise known as @xmath46-radiation . ]
, which are the so - called z - boson and the w@xmath47-bosons , that have been observed in cern in the 80s .
vector bosons were not originally considered as candidates for the particle production process in inflation because of two generic obstacles , which were thought to inhibit their suitability for this role .
the major obstacle has to do with the inherent anisotropic nature of vector fields .
inflation would homogenise a vector field as it does with everything else in the universe when it solves the horizon problem .
now , if a vector field is to generate or even affect the primordial density perturbation it needs to dominate ( or nearly dominate ) the content of the universe at some time so that it can affect the universe expansion rate .
however , a uniform vector field ( homogenised by inflation ) is , in general , anisotropic because it picks up a preferred direction in space .
if such an anisotropic contribution to the density of the universe became dominant it would result in anisotropic expansion which would , ultimately , be in conflict with the predominant isotropy of the uniform cmb radiation .
however , it can be shown that this problem can be overcome if the vector field is undergoing rapid coherent oscillations when it dominates the universe @xcite .
the equation of motion for a homogeneous massive ( and abelian ) vector field in the expanding universe is @xmath48 where the dot denotes time derivative , @xmath33 is the mass of the field and @xmath49 is the fractional rate of the universe expansion ; the so - called hubble parameter , whose value today is the hubble constant @xmath1 featured in the hubble law .
originally the vector field is taken to be subdominant , i.e. its contribution to the density budget of the universe is negligible .
after inflation the universe expansion rate is gradually decreasing so that the value of the hubble parameter @xmath49 diminishes .
eventually , we have @xmath50 , which means that one can ignore the second term in the above equation of motion ( the so - called friction term ) rendering the equation similar to the one of a harmonic oscillator .
hence , the homogeneous massive vector field eventually undergoes harmonic oscillations , with frequency @xmath33 , much larger than the inverse of the characteristic timescale of the universe expansion , given by @xmath49 .
these harmonic oscillations rapidly alternate the orientation of the vector field . as a result ,
the oscillating massive homogeneous vector field features no net direction and behaves like an isotropic fluid .
therefore , it can dominate the universe content without generating an excessive large - scale anisotropy @xcite , which would otherwise be in conflict with the cmb .
the second obstacle to the use of vector bosons for the particle production process is more subtle . in the case of scalar fields , particle production during inflation requires the mass of the virtual particles to be small @xmath51 , otherwise they annihilate before being pulled over superhorizon distances by the superluminal expansion .
hence , scalar fields need to be light to undergo particle production during inflation .
if the same argument is applied to vector fields then a problem arises : light vector boson fields are approximately conformally invariant , which inhibits their particle production .
this can be understood as follows .
a massless vector field ( e.g. the photon ) is conformally invariant .
this suggests that it is unaffected by the expansion of the universe , because it perceives this expansion as a conformal transformation to which it is insensitive . in terms of its virtual particles
, this means that they are not pulled outside the horizon during inflation by the superluminal expansion .
hence , the quantum fluctuations of a massless vector field are not stretched by the expansion to become classical perturbations .
consequently , a light vector field is approximately conformally invariant , so one would expect the particle production process to be suppressed . to overcome this obstacle an explicit breakdown of the vector field conformality
is required .
fortunately , there are numerous mechanisms in the literature which achieve this , but the disadvantage is that particle production is model - dependent ; it depends on the mechanism considered . on the positive side
though , this very fact may allow us to discriminate between mechanisms , through comparison with observations .
there are a number of observational characteristics which may signify the contribution of a vector field to the primordial density perturbation .
for example , in the above described mechanism which employed an oscillating massive vector field , there is a chance to produce a weak large - scale anisotropy in the universe .
the reason is that the coherent oscillations of the massive vector field are not exactly harmonic because their amplitude is gradually decreasing as their energy density is depleted by the universe expansion .
because of this , the oscillating vector field is not exactly isotropic , which means that , if it dominates the universe , it may give rise to a weak large - scale anisotropy .
it so happens that there is recent tantalising evidence that such a weak large - scale anisotropy does exist in the cmb .
indeed , there is a highly improbable correlation found between the quadrupole and octupole moments in the cmb angular spectrum , which reveals the existence or a preferred direction , called the `` axis of evil '' @xcite .
plotted along this direction ( instead of the usual galactic coordinates ) low multipoles in the cmb produce a clear pattern , as shown in fig .
an oscillating vector field may well explain this feature , which is impossible to account for under the traditional scalar field mechanisms .
a potentially clearer signal for the contribution of vector fields to the primordial density perturbation is the appearance of statistical anisotropy in the cmb temperature perturbations .
statistical anisotropy amounts to anisotropic patterns arising in the cmb designating special orientation .
an example of how such patterns might look like is shown in fig .
. one can think of them as similar to patterns in city planning produced by rows of identical houses .
statistical anisotropy in the cmb can arise due to anisotropic particle production during inflation @xcite .
as mentioned , vector fields have three degrees of freedom and can be analysed in three independent components .
each of these components undergoes particle production during inflation if the conformality of the vector field is suitably broken .
however , the efficiency of the particle production process may be different for each of these components and depends on the mechanism which breaks the conformal invariance of the vector field .
statistical anisotropy is a new observable , which is inherently connected with a vector field contribution to the density perturbations .
so far there is no observational detection of statistical anisotropic patterns in the cmb or in the distribution of structures in the universe ( e.g. rows of galaxies ) .
however , the observational bounds are rather weak and allow the existence of statistical anisotropy at a level as high as 30% @xcite .
the planck satellite , which was launched in may of 2009 by the european space agency , is expected to increase the cmb precision measurements by an order of magnitude and it is highly likely to observe statistical anisotropy .
the main mission of the planck satellite is to observe non - gaussian features in the predominantly gaussian cmb temperature perturbations .
if a vector field contributes to the primordial density perturbation the non - gaussianity in the cmb can also be anisotropic , in a direction which is correlated to the statistical anisotropy of the perturbation spectrum @xcite .
this is a smoking gun for the contribution of vector fields in the formation of structures in the universe . before concluding let us discuss an interesting possible spin - off of the above ideas , which might connect the formation of structures in the universe with cosmic magnetism .
observations suggest that the majority of galaxies carry magnetic fields of equipartition strength : @xmath52 g @xcite , meaning that their energy density is comparable to the kinetic energy density of the galaxy . in spirals
the magnetic field follows the spiral arms @xcite ( see for example fig .
[ pmf ] ) .
this means that it is not frozen into the plasma of the galactic disk , which strongly suggests that it is instead rearranged by a magnetic dynamo mechanism , similar to the one that operates in our sun .
the magnetic dynamo can also amplify an initial magnetic field up to equipartition value ( when dynamic backreaction stops further amplification ) but it needs a non - zero seed field to feed on . for the sun the seed field is presumed to be the magnetic field of the milky way . for galaxies at the time of formation the seed field needs to be at least as strong as @xmath53 g @xcite with a coherency scale @xmath54pc , corresponding to the largest turbulent eddy .
the origin of this seed field remains elusive .
suppose that the hypercharge vector boson field of the electroweak theory ( i.e. the unification of electromagnetism with the weak nuclear force ) has , through some mechanism , its conformality broken during inflation , so that it obtains a flat superhorizon spectrum of perturbations . after inflation ,
the universe cools down due to its expansion . at some moment ,
electroweak unification breaks down when the temperature of the hot big bang reduces below @xmath55gev , where @xmath56 is the boltzmann constant . at the electroweak phase transition
, the hypercharge field is projected onto the photon and the z - boson directions , through the weinberg angle as shown in fig .
[ ysplit ] . the z - boson condensate , being massive , rapidly oscillates a few tens of times before decaying to other lighter standard model particles .
during these oscillations its superhorizon perturbation spectrum ( which is due to the projection of the original hypercharge spectrum ) might affect the density perturbation in the universe if the density of the oscillating field is comparable to the density of the universe at the time .
the photon superhorizon perturbations ( also due to the hypercharge spectrum ) give rise to a magnetic field with scale dependence @xmath57 . due to the high conductivity of the primordial plasma
the magnetic field flux is conserved and the magnetic field survives until the epoch of galaxy formation .
it is a simple calculation to show that , provided the z - boson has enough density to nearly dominate the universe before its decay , the primordial magnetic field is strong and coherent enough to trigger the galactic dynamo and explain the magnetic fields of the galaxies @xcite .
this scenario , if realised , may connect directly cmb observations of statistical anisotropy with galactic magnetism .
according to state of the art cosmology , all structures in the universe , including galaxies , stars , planets and ourselves , originated as quantum fluctuations of suitable fields similar to the ones which we observe in the lab with the casimir experiment .
these quantum fluctuations were transformed into classical perturbations ( giving rise to the primordial density perturbation ) when stretched to sizes larger than the cosmological horizon ( the range of causal correlations ) during a brief period of superluminal expansion of space , called cosmic inflation .
inflation had to take place in the very early stages of the universe history in order to solve one of the fundamental paradoxes of modern cosmology , the so - called horizon problem , i.e. the apparent uniformity of the universe over distances which appear to be beyond causal contact .
inflation forces this uniformity onto the universe by expanding an originally causally connected region of space to size large enough to encompass the observable universe at present .
inflation also creates the deviations from uniformity which are necessary for the formation of structures , by generating the primordial density perturbation , which leads to structure formation through the process of gravitational instability .
recent precise observations of the perturbations of the temperature of cmb radiation , which reflect the primordial density perturbation , confirm both the particle production process through which these perturbations were generated , and also cosmic inflation itself .
these observations are the earliest data at hand , since inflation has to take place when the universe is only a tiny fraction of a second old .
the precision of cosmological observations has reached the level which demands theoretical model - building to become detailed and rigorous . because of this and also in light of the forthcoming lhc findings it may be necessary to explore alternatives beyond the traditional scalar field hypothesis for the realisation of the particle production process during inflation .
one such possibility is considering vector boson fields .
massive vector fields can indeed generate the primordial density perturbation without excessive large - scale anisotropy if they undergo coherent oscillations before they dominate the universe .
the scenario is characterised by a number of distinct observational signatures .
for example it may explain the observed weak large - scale anisotropy already found in the cmb ( `` axis of evil '' ) and it can give rise to statistical anisotropy in the cmb temperature perturbations , which amounts to direction dependent patterns that , at present , are allowed at a level up to 30% and may well be detected by the forthcoming observations of the planck satellite mission .
non - gaussian features in the cmb perturbations may also be anisotropic in a manner correlated with the statistical anisotropy in the cmb spectrum .
this would be a smoking gun for the contribution of a vector field in the density perturbation of the universe .
the author would like to thank the audiences of the 2008 christmas conference of the faculty of science and technology of lancaster university and also the physics department of the university of ioannina , for their feedback .
the author also wants to thank his collaborators mindaugas kariauskas , david . h. lyth and yeinzon rodriguez - garcia .
this work is based on research funded ( in part ) by the marie curie research and training network `` universenet '' ( mrtn - ct-2006 - 035863 ) and by stfc grant st / g000549/1 .
s. cole _ et al .
_ [ the 2dfgrs collaboration ] , `` the 2df galaxy redshift survey : power - spectrum analysis of the final dataset and cosmological implications , '' mon . not .
* 362 * ( 2005 ) 505 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0501174 ] .
b. chaboyer , p. demarque , p. j. kernan and l.m .
krauss , astrophys .
j. * 494 * ( 1998 ) 96 [ arxiv : astro - ph/9706128 ] ; r.g .
gratton , f. fusi pecci , e. carretta , g. clementini , c.e .
corsi and m. lattanzi , astrophys .
j. * 491 * ( 1997 ) 749 [ arxiv : astro - ph/9704150 ] .
casimir and d. polder , phys .
* 73 * ( 1948 ) 360 ; h.b.g .
casimir , indag .
* 10 * ( 1948 ) 261 [ kon
. ned .
wetensch .
* 51 * ( 1948 frpha,65,342 - 344.1987 knawa,100n3 - 4,61 - 63.1997 ) 793 ] .
k. dimopoulos , phys .
d * 74 * ( 2006 ) 083502 .
d. grasso and h.r .
rubinstein , phys .
* 348 * ( 2001 ) 163 ; m. giovannini , int .
j. mod .
d * 13 * ( 2004 ) 391 .
k. land and j. magueijo , phys .
* 95 * ( 2005 ) 071301 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0502237 ] .
k. dimopoulos , m. karciauskas , d.h .
lyth and y. rodriguez , jcap * 0905 * ( 2009 ) 013 [ arxiv:0809.1055 [ astro - ph ] ] .
groeneboom and h.k .
eriksen , astrophys .
j. * 690 * ( 2009 ) 1807 [ arxiv:0807.2242 [ astro - ph ] ] .
m. karciauskas , k. dimopoulos and d.h .
lyth , arxiv:0812.0264 [ astro - ph ] .
kronberg , rept .
* 57 * ( 1994 ) 325 .
r. beck , a. brandenburg , d. moss , a. shukurov and d. sokoloff , ann .
astrophys .
* 34 * ( 1996 ) 155 .
a. c. davis , m. lilley and o. tornkvist , phys .
d * 60 * ( 1999 ) 021301 .
k. dimopoulos , arxiv:0806.4680 [ hep - ph ] . | the fundamental paradox of the incompatibility of the observed large - scale uniformity of the universe with the fact that the age of the universe is finite is overcome by the introduction of an initial a period of superluminal expansion of space , called cosmic inflation .
inflation can also produce the small deviations from uniformity needed for the formation of structures in the universe such as galaxies .
this is achieved by the conjunction of inflation with the quantum vacuum , through the so - called particle production process .
this mechanism is explained and linked with hawking radiation of black holes .
the nature of the particles involved is discussed and the case of using massive vector boson fields instead of scalar fields is presented , with emphasis on its distinct observational signatures .
finally , a particular implementation of these ideas is included , which can link the formation of galaxies , the standard model vector bosons and the observed galactic magnetic fields .
inflation , particle production , primordial density perturbation , cmb radiation , structure formation |
to compile the sample , image fields from the vla - first survey ( becker et al .
1995 ) containing components bright and extended enough to judge the source morphologies were inspected by - eye .
this gave an initial 100 candidates with extended winged emission ( fig . 1 ; cheung 2006 ) .
compared to previously known examples ( e.g. , lal & rao 2006 ) , the new candidates are systematically fainter ( @xmath010@xmath1 ) and more distant ( @[email protected] ) .
new optical spectroscopic observations are identifying many of the fainter , more distant optical hosts .
most candidates have clear winged emission and higher resolution vla observations of initially @xmath040 sources have been obtained to confirm the morphological identifications . of the candidates , enough are legitimate x - shaped sources ( conventionally , those with wing to lobe extents of @xmath40.8:1 ) to more than double the number known .
lower frequency gmrt observations of selected objects are being pursued to map any spectral structure to estimate the particle ages in the wings to test formation scenarios ( e.g. , dennett - thorpe et al . 2002 ) .
we examined the host galaxies of about a dozen new and previously known examples with available sdss images ( 54 sec exposures ) to quantify any asymmetry in the surrounding medium as required by hydrodynamic wing formation models ( e.g. , capetti et al .
most of the galaxies are highly elliptical with the minor axes roughly aligned with the wings , consistent with the findings of capetti et al . for a similarly sized sample .
however , we found smaller ellipticities ( @[email protected] ) in at least two examples , 3c192 and b2 0828 + 32 , confirming previous studies of these hosts ( smith & heckman 1989 ; ulrich & r " onnback 1996 ) . round " hosts are not necessarily incompatible with the hydrodynamic picture as observed @xmath5 values can be lowered by projection .
this should be investigated more thoroughly with a dedicated host galaxy imaging program .
becker , r.h . , white , r.l .
, & helfand , d.j .
1995 , apj , 450 , 559 capetti , a. , et al .
2002 , a&a , 394 , 39 cheung , c.c .
2006 , aj , submitted dennett - thorpe , j. et al .
2002 , mnras , 330 , 609 lal , d.v . , &
rao , a.p .
2006 , mnras , in press ( astro - ph/0610678 ) merritt , d. , & ekers , r.d .
2002 , science , 297 , 1310 smith , e.p . , &
heckman , t.m .
1989 , apjs , 69 , 365 ulrich , m .- h . , & r " onnback , j. 1996 , a&a , 313 , 750 | a small number of double - lobed radio galaxies are found with an additional pair of extended low surface brightness ` wings ' of emission giving them a distinctive ` x'-shaped appearance .
one popular explanation for the unusual morphologies posits that the central supermassive black hole ( smbh)/accretion disk system underwent a recent realignment ; in a merger scenario , the active lobes mark the post - merger axis of the resultant system ( e.g. , merritt & ekers 2002 ) .
however , this and other interpretations are not well tested on the few ( about one dozen ) known examples . in part to remedy this deficiency , a large sample of winged and x - shaped radio sources is being compiled for a systematic study .
an initial sample of 100 new candidates is described as well as some of the follow - up work being pursued to test the different scenarios . |
nonlocal conserved charges play the central role in quantum integrability @xcite . for the superstring in @xmath0
their existence was proven in the classical sigma - model in @xcite using the green - schwarz - metsaev - tseytlin formalism , and in @xcite using the pure spinor formalism .
the existence of the nonlocal conserved charges at the quantum level was proven in @xcite .
the most important feature of the string worldsheet @xmath2-model ( besides the conformal invariance ) is the existence of the brst structure .
the physically meaningful constructions should respect the action of the brst operator @xmath3 .
the nonlocal conserved charges of @xcite are only brst invariant up to the boundary terms . to be more precise , we need to introduce the transfer matrix which is the generating function of the nonlocal conserved charges . for an open contour @xmath4 connecting points @xmath5 and @xmath6 on the string worldsheet
: we define the transfer matrix : @xmath7 = p\exp \left ( -\int^b_a j[z ] \right)\ ] ] where @xmath4 is a contour connecting points @xmath5 and @xmath6 on the string worldsheet , and @xmath8 is a representation of @xmath9 .
the currents @xmath10 $ ] depend on the spectral parameter @xmath11 and the representation @xmath8 .
the transfer matrix is a function of the _ spectral parameter _
it is the generating function of the conserved charges
. it can be also though of as the wilson line operator corresponding to the flat connection @xmath10 $ ] on the string worldsheet . in this paper
we will use both expressions : `` transfer matrix '' and `` wilson line '' , and understand them as synonyms .
the brst variation of the wilson line @xmath12 $ ] results in the boundary terms . using the notations of @xcite : @xmath13(z ) & = & \left ( { 1\over z } \varepsilon\lambda_3(b ) + z \varepsilon\lambda_1(b ) \right ) t[c_a^b](z ) - \nonumber \\ & & - t[c_a^b](z ) \left ( { 1\over z } \varepsilon\lambda_3(a ) +
z \varepsilon\lambda_1(a ) \right ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] this equation is very interesting .
nontrivial boundary terms in ( [ boundarytermsinbrst ] ) allow to `` bootstrap '' at least at the classical level the structure of @xmath14@xmath15 matrices , see section 7 of @xcite . on the other hand , these boundary terms present a problem : the nonlocal conserved charges are not physical quantities , at least not in an obvious sense .
( because they are not in the kernel of @xmath3 . )
what should we do with them ? a natural thing to try is to find an operator which when inserted at the endpoint of the wilson line would make it @xmath3-closed .
this is somewhat analogous to the open wilson line in qcd .
the expression @xmath16 is unphysical , because it is not gauge invariant .
the physical quantity is : @xmath17 we may call @xmath18 and @xmath19 `` the plugs '' because they fix `` leaking boundary terms '' in gauge tranformations , or in brst transformations .
can we find similar plugs for the wilson line on the string worldsheet in @xmath0 ?
in this paper we will report a progress in this direction .
remember that the wilson line depends on a choice of representation ; we have to choose a representation @xmath8 of @xmath20 .
consider the space of states of the linearized supergravity multiplet in @xmath0 .
it splits into the direct sum of infinitely many infinite - dimensional irreducible representations of @xmath20 , each corresponding to a bps state .
we will argue that when @xmath8 is one of those infinite - dimensional bps representations , then there is a suitable plug of the ghost number 2 .
this is closely related to the vertex operators for the massless states in @xmath0 .
in fact we will relate the brst cohomology complex corresponding to the endpoint of the wilson line to the brst complex corresponding to the vertex operators .
this is essentially an example of the frobenius reciprocity .
the main nontrivial point is the construction of the vertex operators transforming _ strictly covariantly _ under the global supersymmetries of @xmath0 .
this is different from flat space where massless vertices transform covariantly only up to brst exact terms .
wilson lines in infinite - dimensional representations played an important role in the integrable context in @xcite in the construction of the q - operator .
they also played an important role in the ads / cft context in @xcite for the interpretation of the ym feynman diagramms in the string worldsheet theory .
consider an infinite - dimensional irreducible representation @xmath21 of @xmath20 .
it is natural to ask the question : @xmath22 the results of our paper imply that this answer can be answered directly in terms of the structure of @xmath21 , as a representation of @xmath20 .
namely , given @xmath21 , we consider the following complex : @xmath23 defined entirely in terms of @xmath21 see section [ sec : definitionofalgebraiccomplex ] .
then , we claim that the multiplicity of @xmath21 in the space of linearized sugra solutions is equal to the dimension of the second cohomology @xmath24 of this complex .
( we only claim this when @xmath21 has `` high enough '' spin on @xmath25 ; see the end of section [ sec : covariantuniversal ] . )
most of the paper is about massless vertex operators in @xmath0 . in section [ sec : verticesingrouptheorylanguage ]
we give a geometrical definition of vertex operators using the representation of @xmath0 as the coset space @xmath26 . in section [ sec : definitionofcovariantvertex ] we explain what it means for the vertex to be strictly covariant , and then in sections [ sec : taylorseries ] and [ sec : cohomologicalargument ] prove the existence of such covariant vertices . in section [ sec : flatspacelimit ]
we discuss the flat space limit of our construction .
( although it is impossible to construct the strictly covariant vertex in the flat space , but nevertheless the construction in @xmath0 has a well - defined flat space limit , which does transforms strictly covariantly , but only under a subgroup @xmath27 . ) in section
[ sec : relationtoendpoint ] we explain how the covariant vertex plugs the endpoint of the wilson line . in section [ sec : applications ] we present some consequences of our construction ; we explain how to prepare the vertex operator depending on the spectral parameter .
the algebra of supersymmetries of @xmath0 has a @xmath28 grading : @xmath29 we denote @xmath30 the universal enveloping algebra of @xmath31 .
let @xmath32 denote the group element of @xmath30 , _
i.e. _ an element of the group @xmath33 : @xmath34 where @xmath35 , @xmath36 , @xmath37 and @xmath38 .
so defined @xmath39 and @xmath40 are coordinates of the super-@xmath0 .
the generators of @xmath9 are the same as in @xcite : @xmath41 } \in { \bf g}_{\bar{0}}\ ] ] for a vector space @xmath42 we will denote @xmath43 the dual vector space . in particular , the space of states is denoted @xmath21 and the space of linear functionals on the states is denoted @xmath44 .
we will mostly consider the linear functionals which are the values of some supergravity fields ( such as the ramond - ramond field strength ) at a fixed point in @xmath0 .
these could be also thought of as non - normalizable elements of @xmath21 , `` delta - functions type of states '' in @xmath21 . for an even vector space @xmath42
we denote @xmath45 the space of antisymmetric tensors . for an odd vector space @xmath45 will stand for symmetric tensors .
example : @xmath46 is an odd vector space , and @xmath47 is the dual space . therefore @xmath48 is identified with the fifth order polynomials of some bosonic spinor variable @xmath49 .
massless vertex operators in @xmath0 were introduced in @xcite . using the group theory language , we can define the vertex operator as a collection of functions @xmath50 , @xmath51 and @xmath52 of @xmath53 subject to the condition of @xmath54-covariance , which says that for any @xmath55 we should get : @xmath56 here @xmath57 and @xmath58 are the matrix elements of @xmath59 acting on @xmath60 and @xmath61 respectively . for a tensor field @xmath62
we introduce the covariant derivatives : @xmath63 } \varphi_{\alpha_1\ldots\alpha_m\;\dot{\beta}_1\ldots\dot{\beta}_n}(g ) & = & \left.{d\over ds}\right|_{s=0 } \varphi_{\alpha_1\ldots\alpha_m\;\dot{\beta}_1\ldots\dot{\beta}_n}(e^{-s t^0_{[mn]}}g ) \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] collectively : @xmath64 note that the covariant derivatives @xmath65 for @xmath66 satisfy the condition of @xmath54-covariance , for example : @xmath67 also , the @xmath54-covariance condition ( [ vertexcovariance1 ] ) ( [ vertexcovariance3 ] ) can be formulated as the following explicit expression for the covariant derivative @xmath68}$ ] along @xmath54 : @xmath69 } v_{\beta\gamma}(g ) = \left.{d\over ds}\right|_{s=0 } v_{\beta\gamma}(e^{-s t^0_{[\mu\nu ] } } g ) = { f_{[\mu\nu]\beta}}^{\beta ' } v_{\beta'\gamma}(g ) + { f_{[\mu\nu]\gamma}}^{\gamma ' } v_{\beta\gamma'}(g)\ ] ] the condition that the vertex operator is @xmath70-closed can be written as follows : @xmath71 where @xmath5 and @xmath72 are defined by these equations .
the gauge transformations are : @xmath73 where @xmath74 and @xmath75 are the parameters of the gauge transformations .
the brst operator is : @xmath76 our definition of the vertex is slightly weaker than the definition of @xcite .
the definition of @xcite requires that : @xmath77 the only nonzero component of the vertex remains @xmath78 .
in fact @xmath79 and @xmath80 are always @xmath81-exact .
therefore the condition ( [ ghostnumbergauge ] ) can always be satisfied by adding to the vertex something @xmath82-exact . in this sense
the components @xmath79 and @xmath80 can always be `` gauged away '' .
but we want the _ covariant _ vertex operator .
we suspect that it might be impossible to gauge away @xmath79 and @xmath80 in a covariant way .
this is the reason why we prefer to allow these components in the definition of the vertex operator .
in string theory vertex operators represent states .
vertex operators are functions @xmath83 .
the global symmetries act on @xmath40 and @xmath84 , and therefore act on vertex operators . on the other hand , the global symmetries act on the space of states .
therefore the action of the global symmetry group on states should agree with the action on vertex operators .
naively , this would imply that if @xmath85 is a vertex operator corresponding to the state @xmath86 then @xmath87 but in fact this formula , generally speaking , holds only up to brst - trivial corrections ( terms which are @xmath3 of something ) .
note that @xmath85 is not defined unambiguously , because we could add to it brst - exact terms and get physically equivalent vertex .
we will prove that in @xmath0 it is possible to use this freedom in the definition of @xmath88 and choose @xmath88 so that it transforms covariantly , as in ( [ transformscovariantly ] ) . in our proof
we will use the fact that vertices corresponding to supergravity states _ exist_.
this was proven in @xcite . given the existence of the vertex
, we will prove that it is always possible to correct it by a brst - exact expression , if necessary , to get a _
covariant _ vertex .
the first example of the covariant vertex was given in @xcite .
it was shown that the _ zero mode _
dilaton vertex is given by the expression ] which is independent of @xmath40 and @xmath84 : @xmath90 this operator plays the central role in @xcite .
the corresponding marginal deformation of the action changes the radius of @xmath0 .
the radius is invariant under the global symmetries , therefore in this case covariance means invariance ; the vertex ( [ zeromodevertex ] ) is invariant under the global symmetries .
this is related to the fact that the action of the pure spinor superstring in @xmath0 is exactly invariant under the global symmetries ( while the action in flat space is invariant only up to adding a total derivative ) .
our construction can be considered a generalization of ( [ zeromodevertex ] ) for fields with nontrivial dependence on @xmath40 and @xmath84 .
the second example will be presented in the forthcoming paper with o. bedoya , l. bevilqua , and v.o .
rivelles ] is : @xmath91 here the indices @xmath92 and @xmath93 enumerate the adjoint representation of @xmath20 .
notice that ( [ vbeta ] ) is antisymmetric under the exchange of @xmath92 and @xmath93 .
therefore this vertex transforms in the antisymmetric product of two adjoint representations of @xmath20 .
this antisymmetric product splits into two irreducible components .
the first component is the adjoint representation .
but the part of ( [ vbeta ] ) belonging to the adjoint representation is actually @xmath3-exact : @xmath94_c = \nonumber \\ = \varepsilon q_{brst } ( g^{-1 }
\varepsilon'(\lambda_3 + \lambda_1 ) g)_c\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( notice that this formula played an important role in section 6 of @xcite . )
the deformation of the action corresponding to ( [ vbeta ] ) follows from the standard descent procedure .
let us denote : @xmath95 this is the ghost number 1 cocycle corresponding to the local conserved currents , see also appendix [ sec : ghostnumberone ] .
it corresponds to the local conserved currents in the following sense : @xmath96 where @xmath97 is the density of the local conserved charge corresponding to the global symmetries .
therefore : @xmath98}(\varepsilon ' ) ) = 2\varepsilon q j_{[a } \lambda_{b]}(\varepsilon')\ ] ] and : @xmath99}(\varepsilon ) ) = -{1\over 2 } \varepsilon q ( j_{[a}\wedge j_{b]})\ ] ] we conclude that for any constant antisymmetric matrix @xmath100 we can infinitesimally deform the worldsheet action as follows : @xmath101}\ ] ] consider for example @xmath102 in the directions of @xmath25 .
we get : @xmath103[mn ] } \left ( \int x_{[k } dx_{l ] } \wedge x_{[m } dx_{n ] } + \ldots \right)\ ] ] where @xmath104 describes the embedding of @xmath25 into @xmath105 and dots denote @xmath84-dependent terms .
these @xmath84-dependent terms appear because @xmath106 includes @xmath84 .
( [ binsdirections ] ) corresponds to the marginal deformations of the @xmath107 yang - mills known as @xmath89_-deformations _
@xcite , as follows from their quantum numbers .
the subspace @xmath108 corresponds to @xmath6 of the following form : @xmath109[mn ] } = \delta^{km } a^{ln } - \delta^{lm } a^{kn } + \delta^{ln } a^{km } - \delta^{kn } a^{lm}\ ] ] where @xmath110 is antisymmetric matrix ; then the corresponding deformation of the lagrangian is a total derivative @xmath111 .
the complementary space has real dimension 90 , it corresponds to the representation @xmath112 of @xmath113 .
this is the expected quantum numbers of the linearized @xmath89-deformation , cp .
section 3.1 of @xcite and references therein .
it was observed in @xcite that some of these deformations are obstructed when we pass from the linearized supergravity equations to the nonlinear equations .
not all of the deformations ( [ linearizedbeta ] ) can be extended to the solutions of the nonlinear supergravity equations _ as solutions constant in @xmath114 directions _ , but only those which satisfy some nonlinear equations on @xmath100 . if these nonlinear equations are not satisfied , then the nonlinear solutions will have `` resonant terms '' and because of these resonant terms will not be periodic in the global time of @xmath114 .
suppose that we are looking at the _ massless _ states transforming in some representation @xmath21 of the global symmetry group @xmath33 .
for every state @xmath115 we have the corresponding vertex operator @xmath116 .
as we discussed , @xmath116 consists of the components : @xmath117 , @xmath118 and @xmath119 .
we write @xmath120 instead of @xmath121 to stress that @xmath120 is a function of @xmath86
. mathematically it would be more appropriate to call it `` a linear operator from the space of states to the space of vertex operators '' .
we will call @xmath120 the `` universal vertex '' for the representation @xmath21 because it is a uniform definition of vertex operators for all states in @xmath21 : @xmath122 the global symmetry group @xmath123 acts on both space of states and space of vertex operators .
it acts on the space of states by definition , because it is the global symmetry group of the theory .
it also acts on the space of vertex operators .
the action on the space of vertex operators may seem obvious , but we would like to spell it out explicitly because we feel that some confusion is possible .
a vertex operator has components @xmath79 , @xmath78 and @xmath80 which are all functions of the group element @xmath32 , _
i.e. _ @xmath50 , @xmath51 and @xmath52 satisfying the conditions of @xmath54-covariance ( [ vertexcovariance1 ] ) ( [ vertexcovariance3 ] ) .
then , the action of the global symmetry transformation @xmath124 is defined as follows : @xmath125 because @xmath126 hits @xmath32 on the right , this action of the global symmetries is manifestly consistent with the conditions of @xmath54-covariance ( [ vertexcovariance1 ] ) ( [ vertexcovariance3 ] ) and also commutes with the covariant derivatives ( [ defcovariantderivatives ] ) .
this defines the action of @xmath127 on @xmath116 for any fixed @xmath86 ; the expression : @xmath128 is defined by ( [ globalactiononv ] ) : @xmath129 it is natural to ask , if it is true that ( [ globalactiononuniversalvertex ] ) is equal to this : @xmath130 in other words , if it is true or not that : @xmath131 this is not automatically true .
what _ is _ automatically true is this statement : @xmath132 remember that vertex operators are defined modulo brst - exact expressions .
the question is , can we choose a representative for @xmath116 in the equivalence class of @xmath133 , `` uniformly in @xmath86 '' , so that ( [ exactcovariance ] ) is true ?
the answer to this question is `` no '' in flat space , but `` yes '' in ads .
it turns out that in @xmath0 it is possible to choose the vertex operator to be covariant .
let us introduce the notation for the action of the global symmetries ( compare to ( [ collectively ] ) ) : @xmath134 the covariant vertex is a superfield _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ @xmath135 depending linearly on the state @xmath86 , and such that : 1 .
it is annihilated by @xmath70 : @xmath136 and is not @xmath137-exact , and 2 . the action of the global symmetry on @xmath120 as a function of @xmath32 agrees with the action of the global symmetry on the space of states : @xmath138 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
let us study vertex operators for states which are not necessarily normalizable .
in other words , let us forget about the boundary conditions near the boundary of ads , and study the supergravity states which are not necessarily normalizable .
moreover , let us pick a point in @xmath0 and consider the taylor expansion of the supergravity fields around this point .
let us not worry about the convergence of the taylor series .
just study the supergravity equations , brst cohomology _ etc . _ on formal taylor series .
the question of convergence , and the question of the behaviour at spacial infinity , can be studied later . for the study of the taylor series the mathematical notion of the _ coinduced representation _
is useful .
let us study the supergravity fields around a point in @xmath0 corresponding to the unit @xmath139 .
if we do not insist on convergence , then the space of supergravity fields around a point can be replaced by a more algebraic notion , the so - called _ coinduced representation _ @xcite . for a representation @xmath121 of @xmath140
, we define the _ coinduced representation _
@xmath141 , in the following way : : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the space of linear functions @xmath142 from the universal enveloping algebra @xmath30 to @xmath121 , which satisfy the condition of @xmath54-invariance : @xmath143 is called the _ coinduced representation _ and denoted @xmath141 . _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the mathematical notation for such functions is : @xmath144 here `` @xmath145 '' means the space of linear maps from @xmath5 to @xmath6 , and the subindex @xmath54 means @xmath54-invariant functions : @xmath146 .
the action of @xmath31 on this space is defined by the formula : @xmath147 to summarize : we will now explain that @xmath141 encodes the taylor series of various tensor fields on @xmath0 , where @xmath121 is the representation of @xmath54 corresponding to the type of the tensor .
let us start with the trivial representation @xmath148 of @xmath149
. in this case we should get scalar fields on ads .
the correspondence between the elements of @xmath150 and the scalar fields on ads goes as follows .
given a scalar field @xmath151 , the corresponding element @xmath152 is given by the formula : @xmath153 in this case the @xmath54-invariance condition says that @xmath154 for any @xmath155 , and this is indeed satisfied for @xmath142 defined in ( [ inducedfromscalars ] ) because @xmath156 for any @xmath155 because @xmath157 is well defined on @xmath158 .
there is also a map going in the opposite direction .
namely , given @xmath142 a linear function from @xmath30 to @xmath159 we define the corresponding scalar field @xmath151 as follows : @xmath160 note that on the right hand side we treat @xmath32 as a _ group element _ is called _ group element _ if it is of the form @xmath161 for some @xmath162 of @xmath30 . we have just explained why for @xmath148 the space @xmath163 encodes the taylor coefficients of the scalar function on ads ; for general @xmath121 a similar construction shows that @xmath163 encodes the taylor coefficients of the tensor field with indices transforming in the representation @xmath121 of @xmath54 . to describe the linearized sugra in @xmath0 we need two pure spinor variables @xmath164 and @xmath165 satisfying the constraints : @xmath166 we will consider various types of vertex operators , which are homogeneous polynomials in @xmath167 and @xmath168 . note that ( [ purespinorconstraints ] ) are invariant under the action of @xmath54 .
therefore the polynomials of @xmath167 and @xmath168 form a representation of @xmath54 .
we will introduce the notation for such polynomials : 0= 1= 2= 3=to 1 2 we will define the polynomials of @xmath169 by specifying their coefficients , which are elements of @xmath170 ( see section [ sec : notations ] for notations ) .
we have to `` discard '' those polynomials which are identically zero because of the pure spinor constraints ( [ purespinorconstraints ] ) . as a trivial example
, let us consider the quadratic polynomials of @xmath167 .
the coefficients belong to @xmath171 .
let us denote @xmath172 the basis vectors of @xmath173 , such that : @xmath174 the space @xmath171 consists of expressions of the form @xmath175 where @xmath176 .
as an example of the polynomial which is identically zero , take @xmath177 where @xmath178 is the structure constants defined by @xmath179 .
such a polynomial is identically zero because of the pure spinor constraint ( [ purespinorconstraints ] ) : @xmath180 to summarize : @xmath181 where @xmath182 denotes a subspace of @xmath183 corresponding to those polynomials on @xmath60 which vanish identically on @xmath167 because of the pure spinor constraint .
we will also introduce : @xmath184 note that @xmath185 and @xmath186 are representations of @xmath54 , but not of @xmath31 .
the construction of coinduced representation is used to build the representations of @xmath31 from these spaces . in this section
we consider the taylor series of the vertex operator and do not bother about the convergence and the behaviour near the boundary .
then the vertex operator can be considered an element of the coinduced representation : @xmath188 we would like to discuss vertex operators `` uniformly '' for all vectors @xmath115 .
we will therefore introduce the `` universal '' vertex operator : @xmath189 in other words , we have a linear function on the hilbert space @xmath190 which to every vector @xmath191 associates the corresponding vertex operator : @xmath192 given a state @xmath115 we get @xmath116 an element of @xmath187 .
this means , by definition , that for every @xmath86 , the object @xmath116 is a linear map from @xmath30 to @xmath193 satisfying the @xmath54-invariance condition : @xmath194 given such @xmath116 , how do we construct the `` usual '' vertex operator ? as an element of @xmath195 our @xmath116 is a function of @xmath196 with values in @xmath193 . let us evaluate this function on a group element @xmath197 , where @xmath198 .
we get @xmath199 an element from @xmath193 , _
i.e. _ a quadratic polynomial in @xmath167 and @xmath168 .
the `` usual '' vertex opearator is just the evaluation of this polynomial : @xmath200 the brst complex is : @xmath201 the brst operator acts on the universal vertex @xmath116 in the following way : @xmath202 note that @xmath203 is an element of @xmath204 . in terms of the `` usual '' vertex @xmath205 defined by ( [ usualvertexoperator ] )
we get : @xmath206 [ [ statement - of - covariance ] ] statement of covariance + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + note that in eq .
( [ noncovariantvertex ] ) we use the notation @xmath207 rather than @xmath208 .
there is no apriori reason why @xmath120 would respect the action of @xmath31 .
but in the next section we will see that under some conditions on @xmath21 , it is possible to choose the universal vertex operator which does respect the global symmetry .
we will call it the _ covariant _ universal vertex : @xmath209 given eq .
( [ actionofg ] ) this implies : @xmath210 [ [ condition - on - cal - h - sufficiently - high - spin ] ] condition on @xmath21 : sufficiently high spin + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the conditions on @xmath21 are the following . consider @xmath21 as a representation of @xmath211 the symmetry algebra of @xmath25 . as a representation of @xmath113 , @xmath21 is the direct sum of infinitely many finite - dimensional representations of @xmath113 .
we request that the minimal value of the quadratic casimir of @xmath113 on @xmath21 be sufficiently high .
in this section we will use some facts about the lie algebra cohomology which we learned mostly from @xcite . see chapter 3 6 of @xcite for a very brief summary .
the physical states correspond to the cohomology of @xmath3 at the ghost number 2 , therefore : @xmath212 where @xmath213 is the multiplicity of @xmath21 ( how many times @xmath21 enters in the sugra spectrum on @xmath0 ) .
we will argue that the second cohomology of the brst operator can be calculated using the covariant subcomplex .
in other words , @xmath214 ( notice that @xmath215 is the covariant subcomplex . ) to prove eq .
( [ equalstocovarianth ] ) we rewrite it in the following form : @xmath216 here we have used the fact that for any representation @xmath42 of the lie algebra @xmath31 the zeroth cohomology group @xmath217 equals the space of invariants @xmath218 . in particular , for two representations @xmath219 and @xmath220 , @xmath221 .
the idea of the proof of ( [ hpermuted ] ) is to note that the left and the right hand side of ( [ hpermuted ] ) are two different second approximations to calculating the cohomology of the `` total '' differential @xmath222 .
therefore the equality of the left hand side and the right hand side follows if we prove that the second approximation is actually exact .
let us start by fixing some universal vertex ( not necessarily covariant ) : @xmath223 at this point we do not require that this vertex is covariant ; it is apriori an element of @xmath224 rather than @xmath225 . we will introduce the lie algebra brst operator of @xmath31 . for each generator @xmath226 of @xmath31
we introduce the corresponding ghost @xmath227 , and define : @xmath228 we will consider the action of @xmath229 on expressions polynomial in @xmath227 .
the polynomials of @xmath227 are specified by their coefficients ; in degree @xmath230 the coefficients live in @xmath231 .
therefore @xmath229 acts on the vertex operator as follows : @xmath232 we will consider the bicomplex with the differential @xmath233 : @xmath234 to prove the existence of the covariant vertex we will consider the spectral sequence computing the cohomology of this bicomplex . there are two ways to construct the spectral sequence .
one can first calculate the cohomology of @xmath3 and then consider @xmath229 as a perturbation .
the other way is to first calculate the cohomology of @xmath229 and then consider @xmath3 as a perturbation .
these two ways of calculating the cohomology of @xmath233 should give the same result .
we will see that this implies the existence of the covariant vertex .
we will now consider the two methods in turn .
[ [ first - q_brst - then - q_lie ] ] first @xmath3 then @xmath229 + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the first term of the spectral sequence has : @xmath235 where @xmath236 stands for the @xmath237-ghosts ; an element of @xmath238 is schematically @xmath239 .
the differential in the first term is @xmath240 .
the second term is : @xmath241 the higher differentials are of the type @xmath242 .
[ [ first - q_lie - then - q_brst ] ] first @xmath229 then @xmath3 + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the first term is : @xmath243 where @xmath244 .
the higher differentials are of the type @xmath245 .
[ [ existence - of - the - covariant - vertex ] ] existence of the covariant vertex + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the first page of @xmath246 and @xmath247 ; arrows denote @xmath248 and @xmath249 . the lie algebra ghost number ( the number of @xmath237 s ) increases in the horizonthal direction , while the brst ghost number ( the number of @xmath167 plus the number of @xmath168 ) in the vertical direction .
, title="fig:",width=192 ] the first page of @xmath246 and @xmath247 ; arrows denote @xmath248 and @xmath249 .
the lie algebra ghost number ( the number of @xmath237 s ) increases in the horizonthal direction , while the brst ghost number ( the number of @xmath167 plus the number of @xmath168 ) in the vertical direction .
, title="fig:",width=192 ] the second page of @xmath246 and @xmath247 ; arrows denote @xmath250 and @xmath251 .
, title="fig:",width=192 ] the second page of @xmath246 and @xmath247 ; arrows denote @xmath250 and @xmath251 .
, title="fig:",width=192 ] the differential @xmath252 of @xmath253 .
, width=192 ] first of all , we want to show that @xmath254 .
the first observation is that by definition @xmath255 is zero .
this is because the vertex is _ covariant up to brst - exact correction _ ( see eq .
( [ uptobrstexact ] ) ) .
therefore @xmath256 .
also , we will show ( for @xmath21 with large enough spin ) that @xmath257 .
this implies that @xmath254
. then we remember the relation between @xmath258 and @xmath259 , which is the following .
the space @xmath260 has a filtration , corresponding to the number of the @xmath237-ghosts .
namely , @xmath261 consists of expressions containing at least @xmath262 @xmath237-ghosts
. then @xmath263 . to summarize : @xmath264 \\[3pt ] e_1^{0,2 } & = & h^2(q_{tot } ) / f^1h^2(q_{tot } ) \label{e1isfactorspace}\end{aligned}\ ] ] on the other hand we will show that @xmath265 ( see eqs .
( [ shapiroforh2 ] ) , ( [ shapiroforh1 ] ) ) and also that @xmath266 ( similar to ( [ shapiroforh1 ] ) ) .
this implies that : @xmath267 we are now ready to prove the existence of the covariant vertex .
notice that @xmath268 is the space of functions @xmath269 , parametrized by @xmath115 , transforming covariantly under @xmath31 .
this means that @xmath270 is the _ covariant subcomplex _ of the brst complex .
( the subspace consisting of the covariant expressions . ) and eq .
( [ h2qtotfrometilde ] ) shows that : @xmath271 now the comparison of ( [ h2qtotfrome ] ) , ( [ e1isfactorspace ] ) and ( [ h2qtotiscovariant ] ) shows that the cohomology of @xmath3 can be calculated using the covariant subcomplex .
in fact , if the representation @xmath21 has large enough momentum in @xmath25 , then @xmath272 is zero ( because already @xmath273 and @xmath274 are zero ) .
this means that the factor space on the right hand side of ( [ e1isfactorspace ] ) is just @xmath259 .
this means that there is a covariant choice of the vertex . in the rest of this section
we will prove the required vanishing theorems and explain explicitly how the non - covariant vertex can be modified into the covariant one .
since the vertex transforms covariantly up to brst - exact terms , we must have : @xmath275 where @xmath276 note that @xmath277 is @xmath3-closed and has ghost number 1 : @xmath278 we want to argue that there exists @xmath279 such that @xmath280 .
more precisely : note that we are free to add to @xmath281 something in the kernel of @xmath3 ; we want to prove that it is possible to use this freedom and choose @xmath281 so that there exists @xmath279 such that @xmath280 .
an obstacle to this would be a nonzero @xmath282 where @xmath283 we want to argue that the space @xmath284 on the right hand side is zero .
note that the brst cohomology in ghost number 1 corresponds to local conserved charges .
but the only conserved charges are the global symmetries @xmath20 , and those transform in the adjoint representation of @xmath31 .
this means that on the right hand side of ( [ checkermove ] ) we have : @xmath285 adjustment of the vertex operator .
, width=470 ] this cohomology group is zero .
indeed , we can compute it using the serre - hochschild spectral sequence of @xmath286 .
already the first term of this spectral sequence consists of the following spaces , which are all zero : @xmath287 note that @xmath288 where @xmath289 and @xmath290 .
consider the corresponding casimir operators @xmath291 and @xmath292 .
for the cohomology to be nonzero , we need both of them zero , but @xmath292 is positive definite at least for @xmath21 with large enough momenta .
( note also that @xmath21 is an infinite dimensional irreducible representation of @xmath31 , so there are no invariants in its tensor product with powers of @xmath31 . )
therefore @xmath280 for some @xmath279 . in other words
@xmath293 is zero , and we can proceed with computing @xmath252 .
consider @xmath294 .
note that @xmath295 has zero pure spinor ghost number , and @xmath296 .
since @xmath295 is of ghost number 0 , this implies that @xmath295 is a constant ; it does not contain any @xmath40 or @xmath84 .
also , we could have added a constant to @xmath279 without affecting @xmath297 ; therefore @xmath295 by itself is not very well defined by our construction .
what is well defined is @xmath295 modulo the image of @xmath229 : @xmath298 \in h^3_{q_{lie}}({\cal h}'\otimes \lambda^{\bullet}{\bf g } ) = h^3({\bf g},{\cal h}')\ ] ] but the lie algebra cohomology group @xmath299 is zero : @xmath300 one can see that it is zero from the serre - hochschild spectral sequence corresponding to @xmath286 .
already the first term of this spectral sequence consists of the following spaces , which are all zero : @xmath301 the vanishing of these cohomologies can be proven as follows .
note that @xmath302 splits into @xmath289 and @xmath290 . for the cohomology to be nontrivial , both @xmath303 and @xmath304 should be zero .
but @xmath305 is positive definite .
therefore we can remove @xmath295 by modifying @xmath279 , adding to @xmath279 a constant term @xmath306 so that the modified @xmath307 has @xmath308 .
( note that adding the constant term does not change the image of @xmath309 under @xmath3 . )
is it possible to find such @xmath310 that @xmath311 ?
the answer is `` yes '' , because @xmath312 this can be proven using the shapiro s lemma ( proposition 6.8 and theorem 6.9 from @xcite ) : @xmath313 note that @xmath314 .
we want to prove that @xmath315 . the space @xmath44 consists of functionals on the space of states .
since we work in the vicinity of the fixed point @xmath316 our @xmath44 is generated by the values of various supergravity fields at the point @xmath317 .
for example the ramond - ramond field strength @xmath318 and its derivatives . under the action of @xmath319
this space splits into infinitely many finite - dimensional representations . for example
@xmath320 lives in @xmath321 where vect is is the vector representation of @xmath319 and index @xmath322 means that the contraction @xmath323 is zero , for the contraction to be zero ; the ramond - ramond 5-form @xmath324 is nonzero in the ads background . ] .
it follows from the general theory of lie algebra cohomology that @xmath325 of @xmath319 with coefficients in any finite - dimensional representation is zero .
these arguments imply that @xmath310 is in the image of @xmath229 .
we can modify @xmath281 by adding to it : @xmath326 then we have : @xmath327 now we use : @xmath328 therefore @xmath329 is in the image of @xmath229 . now the _
modified vertex : _
@xmath330 is covariant .
our procedure could perhaps be summarized as follows : @xmath331
in flat space it is impossible to choose a covariant vertex , because of the nontrivial cohomology @xmath332 which represents the nsns 3-form field strength . but one can satisfy a weaker covariance condition .
note that in flat space the generators of the lorentz subalgebra @xmath333 of the poincare algebra can not be obtained as commutators of other generators .
therefore it is consistent to require the covariance under all translations and supersymmetries , but only some rotations .
in particular , it turns out that we can choose a vertex covariant under : @xmath334 this is a subalgebra of the super - poincare algebra : @xmath335 corresponding to the split of the space - time : @xmath336 we will say that the ten spacetime directions split into @xmath337 a - directions and @xmath338 s - directions ( the letters a and s stand for the ads and the sphere ) . let us now explain how the diagramm of fig .
[ fig : adjustment ] works in flat space . instead of considering fig .
[ fig : adjustment ] literally let us study the similar diagramm for the supersymmetric maxwell field ( rather than supergravity ) .
this is a toy model ; the supersymmetric maxwell field in flat space is `` one half of the supergravity field '' .
the `` usual '' ( non - covariant ) vertex operator is of the form : @xmath339 } + \ldots\ ] ] where @xmath340 and @xmath341 are the vector potential and the photino .
let us first try to understand if it is possible to choose the vertex covariant under the even poincare algebra .
the vertex operator ( [ vertexoperator ] ) involves the gauge field @xmath342 . because of the gauge invariance the gauge field is not in one to one correspondence with the physical states .
the physical states are described by @xmath343 , not by @xmath342 .
to describe @xmath342 in terms of @xmath344 , let us break the translational symmetries by choosing a point @xmath322 in space - time .
then we can write , in the vicinity of the chosen point : @xmath345 where @xmath346 and @xmath347 and @xmath348 are the corresponding @xmath349 and lie derivative .
for example , @xmath350 and @xmath351 . note that eq .
( [ vicinitygauge ] ) is one particular way to choose a vector potential with the field strength @xmath142 .
let us therefore replace @xmath92 with @xmath352 .
this breaks the translation symmetry , since the gauge ( [ vicinitygauge ] ) depended on a choice of point @xmath353 .
can we restore the translational symmetry ?
let us introduce the operator @xmath229 acting on the physical vertex operators in the following way : @xmath354 here the index @xmath355 runs over an infinite set enumerating the basis vectors of @xmath21 , and @xmath356 are the generators of translations @xmath357 .
fermionic parameters @xmath358 are the lie - algebraic ghosts of the translation algebra .
this operator @xmath229 measures the deviation of the vertex operator from transforming covariantly under the action of the global shift .
we observe that @xmath359 is @xmath360 of something : @xmath361 f = \left ( \iota_c { 1\over { \cal l}_e } - \iota_e { 1\over { \cal l}_e } { \cal l}_c { 1\over { \cal l}_e}\right )
f = \nonumber \\ & = & d\left ( { 1\over { \cal l}_e({\cal l}_e+1 ) } \iota_e\iota_c f\right ) \label{descentderham}\end{aligned}\ ] ] let us calculate @xmath229 of this `` something '' : @xmath362 expanding @xmath142 in taylor series around @xmath353 and taking into account that @xmath363 we can see that ( [ equalsconstant ] ) is equal to : @xmath364 we should stress that ( [ equalsconstant ] ) is equal to the _ constant _ ( independent of @xmath40 ) expression ( [ descent ] ) .
in other words , the only term in the taylor expansion of ( [ equalsconstant ] ) around the point @xmath353 is the constant term .
one can see it , for example , because the lie derivative @xmath348 of ( [ equalsconstant ] ) vanishes .
this can be seen from the identity @xmath365 which follows from @xmath363 .
notice that if we started with some other point @xmath317 ( not the origin ) , then ( [ descent ] ) would change by @xmath229 of something .
for example , an infinitesimal shift by @xmath366 would change ( [ descent ] ) by the @xmath229-exact expression : @xmath367 ( this is a manifestation of the general fact , that a lie algebra acts trivially in its cohomology . )
the @xmath229-cohomology class of : @xmath368 is the obstacle for defining @xmath92 such that @xmath369 in a covariant way .
we have so far discussed only the action of shifts . the expression ( [ obstacle ] )
as we defined it represents the cohomology class of the algebra of translations @xmath370 .
but we can also think of it as a cocycle of the poincare algebra .
indeed , @xmath344 transforms covariantly under rotations and boosts and therefore ( [ obstacle ] ) is closed under the @xmath229 of the full poincare algebra .
the @xmath229 of the full poincare algebra is the sum of @xmath371 of translations @xmath370 and @xmath372 of rotations and boosts .
expression ( [ obstacle ] ) is in the kernel of @xmath371 by our construction , and more explicitly because @xmath142 is a closed form .
but it is also in the kernel of @xmath372 because @xmath142 transforms covariantly under rotations and boosts .
another question is whether or not ( [ obstacle ] ) is exact .
one can see that this is not exact as a cocycle of the full poincare algebra , in the following way .
let @xmath373 stand for the poincare algebra .
we have : @xmath374 notice that the space of states of the gauge field contains a proper subspace closed under the action of the poincare algebra .
( in other words , it is not an irreducible representation . )
this subspace consists of those gauge fields which have a constant field strenght : @xmath375 .
let us call this subspace @xmath376 : @xmath377 therefore there is a projection @xmath378 this projection naturally acts on the cocycles of @xmath379 with values in @xmath44 , and therefore on the cohomology groups : @xmath380 it is straightforward to see that the projection of ( [ obstacle ] ) to @xmath381 is automatically a nonzero cohomology class .
this implies that ( [ obstacle ] ) represents a nontrivial cohomology class in @xmath382 .
this is what prevents us from choosing the vertex covariant with respect to the poincare algebra .
let us start with introducing some notations .
for any vector @xmath384 we denote @xmath385 the vector with the components : @xmath386 also introduce : @xmath387 what happens if we do not require the invariance under the full poincare algebra @xmath373 , but only under the @xmath383 of ( [ psmall ] ) ?
then we can restrict ourselves to the subspace of @xmath21 where @xmath305 is a fixed positive number . on this subspace , it is possible to express @xmath342 in terms of @xmath344 in a @xmath388-covariant way .
let us choose the covariant gauge : @xmath389 and fix the residual gauge transformations with the additional `` axial '' gauge gauge condition : @xmath390 where @xmath391 is introduced as in ( [ barnotation ] ) .
in the gauge ( [ axialgauge ] ) we can express the gauge field @xmath342 in terms of the gauge field strength @xmath343 : @xmath392 now we have two different expressions for the vector potential , eq .
( [ vicinitygauge ] ) and eq .
( [ covariantgauge ] ) .
the difference between these two expressions is a gauge transformation .
let us use a `` diacritical '' mark to distinguish ( [ covariantgauge ] ) from ( [ vicinitygauge ] ) : @xmath393 note that @xmath394 is @xmath383-covariant : @xmath395 while @xmath92 is not see eq .
( [ descentderham ] ) .
also , for every gauge field we can calculate @xmath396 .
this is a functional of the gauge field , _ i.e. _ an element of @xmath44 .
if we calculate its @xmath229 as a cochain with values in @xmath44 we get : @xmath397 now let us return to eqs .
( [ descentderham ] ) , ( [ equalsconstant ] ) and ( [ descent ] ) . on the subspace @xmath398 the cohomology class of ( [ descent ] )
trivializes : @xmath399 this is analogous to eq .
( [ h3zero ] ) of section [ sec : descent ] .
therefore the same arguments as we presented in section [ sec : descent ] should imply that @xmath400 indeed we have : @xmath401 also notice that : @xmath402 this means that the correction of the vector potential : @xmath403 is completely analogous to the correction of the vertex operator described in section [ sec : descent ] . it turns the non - covariant expression @xmath404 into the covariant expression @xmath405 . let us now study the action of the supersymmetry generators . let us consider the part of the @xmath229 involving the supersymmetry generators .
we have : @xmath406 q_{brst } & = & \lambda^{\alpha}{\partial\over \partial\theta^{\alpha } } + \lambda^{\alpha}\gamma^{\mu}_{\alpha\beta}\theta^{\beta } { \partial\over \partial x^{\mu}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath407 is the supersymmetry transformation acting on the space of states @xmath21 and therefore ( after fixing the gauge ! ) on @xmath342 and @xmath408 .
we write only the part of @xmath229 corresponding to the super - translations ; @xmath409 are the bosonic ghosts corresponding to the super - translations . to make @xmath407 act on @xmath92 and @xmath408 we have to choose the gauge . with this notation ,
let us first of all present @xmath410 acting on the vertex operator ( [ vertexoperator ] ) in the following form : @xmath411 } -{1\over 4 } ( \theta\gamma^{\mu\nu\rho}\theta)(\varepsilon\lambda\gamma_{\rho } \varepsilon'\xi ) \partial_{[\mu}a_{\nu ] } + \nonumber \\ & & + ( \varepsilon\lambda\gamma^{\mu}\varepsilon'\xi)(\psi\gamma_{\mu}\theta ) + ( \varepsilon\lambda\gamma^{\mu}\theta)(\psi\gamma_{\mu}\varepsilon'\xi ) + \ldots = \nonumber \\[10pt ] & = & - { 3\over 2}(\varepsilon\lambda\gamma^{\mu}\theta ) \left ( ( \varepsilon'\xi\gamma_{\mu}\psi ) + { 1\over 2\delta_s}\partial_{\mu } ( \varepsilon'\xi\overline{\gamma}^{\rho}\partial_{\rho}\psi)\right ) - \nonumber \\ & & -{2\over 3 } ( \varepsilon\lambda\gamma^{\rho}\theta)(\varepsilon'\xi\gamma^{\mu\nu}\gamma_{\rho}\theta ) \partial_{[\mu}a_{\nu ] } + \ldots \\ & & + \varepsilon q_{brst } \left ( { 1\over 2 } ( \theta\gamma^{\mu}\varepsilon'\xi)(\psi\gamma_{\mu}\theta ) + { 3\over
2}{1\over 2\delta_s } ( \varepsilon'\xi\overline{\gamma}^{\mu}\partial_{\mu}\psi ) + \right .
\nonumber \\ & & \phantom{+ q_{brst}\;\ ; } \left .
+ ( \theta\gamma^{\mu}\varepsilon'\xi ) a_{\mu } -{1\over 12 } ( \theta\gamma^{\mu\nu\rho}\theta ) ( \theta\gamma_{\rho}\varepsilon'\xi ) \partial_{[\mu}a_{\nu ] } + \ldots \right ) \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] this implies that @xmath412}\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore we have indeed : @xmath413 on the right hand side @xmath3 is taken of the expression which is @xmath229-exact : @xmath414 then we have : @xmath415 this means that the following vertex operator : @xmath416 transforms covariantly under the odd shifts .
this can be also understood as follows : @xmath417 } + \ldots\ ] ] now we recognize what it is : @xmath418 where @xmath419 is the superfield ] related to the maxwell superfield @xmath420 by the chain of transformations : @xmath421 see @xcite for a recent discussion of @xmath422 . in flat space
the supergravity fields split into the product of the left and the right component ; the left and right components are essentially free maxwell fields .
the bispinor field is defined as follows : @xmath423 where @xmath424 is the field strength superfield of the free maxwell theory ; the @xmath425 component of @xmath422 is the gaugino @xmath426 .
this bispinor field is a linear combination of the rr field strengths contracted with the gamma - matrices @xcite : @xmath427 where @xmath428 and @xmath429 are some numeric coefficients which we do not need .
the supersymmetry variations of @xmath430 is given by this equation : @xmath431 where @xmath432 is a combination of the left dilatino @xmath433 , and the left gravitino field strength @xmath434}$ ] , and @xmath435 is a combination of the corresponding right fields @xmath436 and @xmath437}$ ] .
the @xmath438-covariant vertex in flat space is the product of two expressions of the form ( [ maxwellvertexviaw ] ) : @xmath439 this is brst equivalent to : @xmath440 the construction of section [ sec : cohomologicalargument ] implies that the @xmath33-covariant vertex operator exists in @xmath0 .
this construction gives ( [ vertexwithderivatives ] ) when applied in the flat space limit .
( we have demonstrated this for the maxwell field , but the free supergravity vertex in flat space is just the product of `` left '' and `` right '' maxwell vertices . ) therefore both ( [ vertexwithderivatives ] ) and the brst - equivalent ( [ vertexwithoutderivatives ] ) should be the flat space limits of some covariant vertices in @xmath0 . notice that ( [ vertexwithoutderivatives ] ) reduces to ( [ zeromodevertex ] ) in the zero momentum limit , except for the overall normalization factor @xmath441 which becomes singular on the zero mode .
however we were not able to write explicit expressions in terms of the supergravity fields in ads space which would explicitly generalize the flat space formulas ( [ vertexwithderivatives ] ) or ( [ vertexwithoutderivatives ] ) .
consider the wilson line operator corresponding to a semi - infinite contour going from infinity to some point @xmath6 on the string worldsheet : in some representation @xmath8 of @xmath442 .
consider the action of @xmath3 on this operator .
if we neglect the contribution of the boundary terms at infinity , then the brst variation is@xcite : @xmath443(z ) = \left ( { 1\over z } \varepsilon\lambda^{\alpha}_3(b)\rho(t^3_{\alpha } ) + z \varepsilon\lambda_1^{\dot{\alpha}}(b)\rho(t^1_{\dot{\alpha } } ) \right ) t[c_{\infty}^b](z)\ ] ] ( see section 2.2 of @xcite and section 7 of @xcite for a discussion of this formula . ) let us fix some vector @xmath408 in the representation @xmath8 `` at infinity '' ; then this expression : @xmath444(z)\psi\ ] ] is a vector in the representation space of @xmath8 . pick a vector @xmath445 in the dual space , and evaluate it on ( [ vectorfrominfinity ] ) : @xmath446(z)\psi\right ) \;\in\ ; { \bf c}\ ] ] this gives a number .
consider vectors @xmath445 depending on the pure spinors @xmath447 and the spectral parameter @xmath11 . then eq .
( [ boundarytermssemiinfinite ] ) can be regarded as defining the action of @xmath3 on @xmath445 : @xmath448 this defines the brst complex of the endpoint .
the @xmath449-cochains of this complex are elements @xmath450 \ ; , \ ; { \cal p}^n \right)\ ] ] where @xmath451 is defined in section [ sec : purespinors ] , and the differential is ( [ brstcomplexendpoint ] ) .
the `` plugs '' which we introduced in section [ sec : theplugs ] are the cohomologies of this complex . unfortunately we do not know a general classification of the cohomologies of this complex for a general representation @xmath8
. we will now consider the special case where @xmath8 is the representation of @xmath20 on the space of states @xmath21 of the bps multiplet . in this case
we will relate the brst complex of the endpoint ( [ brstcomplexendpoint ] ) to the brst complex of covariant supergravity vertices .
let us remember the general structure of the covariant vertex from section [ sec : covariantuniversal ] : @xmath452 here @xmath453 for the supergravity vertex , but we want to consider the whole brst complex so we keep @xmath449 .
let us evaluate @xmath120 on the unit of the group : @xmath454 this defines a correspondence between covariant vertices @xmath120 and vectors in @xmath455 : @xmath456 notice that @xmath120 is a function of @xmath457 while @xmath445 is essentially its value at @xmath458 . nevertheless , the correspondence ( [ evaluationatzero ] ) is a one - to - one correspondence between the elements of @xmath459 and the elements of @xmath455 .
indeed , the symmetry under @xmath460 : @xmath461 allows to relate @xmath199 to @xmath462 , see eq .
( [ actionofgoncovariant ] ) . in other words , if we know the value of the covariant vertex at the point @xmath458 _ for all states _
@xmath86 , then because of the global symmetry we know the covariant vertex everywhere ( for arbitrary @xmath40 and @xmath84 ) .
this construction is an example of the _ frobenius reciprocity _ : which is true for any representation @xmath42 of @xmath149 ; in our case @xmath463 . to summarize , given the covariant vertex @xmath120 , we define @xmath464 by saying that the value of @xmath445 on @xmath115 is : @xmath465 note that both the left hand side and the right hand side of ( [ vectorfromcovariantvertex ] ) are elements of @xmath451 _ i.e. _ polynomials of @xmath167 and @xmath168 .
we can evaluate them on @xmath169 : @xmath466 this is a quadratic polynomial in @xmath167 and @xmath168 .
( [ actionofgoncovariant ] ) and ( [ qonuniversal ] ) imply that the action of @xmath3 on the covariant vertex corresponds to the following action on @xmath445 : @xmath467 this formula for @xmath3 can be interpreted in the following way .
the space @xmath468 is obviously a representation of @xmath9 , just because @xmath21 is by definition a representation of @xmath31 .
( the @xmath193 part just `` goes along for the ride '' . )
let us denote this representation @xmath8 ( the action of @xmath469 on @xmath445 is @xmath470 ) .
then ( [ brstoncovariantvertex ] ) implies that the action of @xmath82 on @xmath471 corresponds to the action of the nilpotent operator @xmath472 on @xmath445 defined by this formula : @xmath473 this is identical to @xmath472 of ( [ brstcomplexendpoint ] ) at @xmath474 .
we conclude that : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ @xmath445 represents a cohomology class @xmath475 of the following complex : + @xmath23 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ in other words , the brst complex on covariant massless vertices ( independent of derivatives ) is equivalent to the endpoint complex @xmath476 . we have demonstrated that the complex ( [ zequalsone ] ) is equivalent to ( [ brstcomplexendpoint ] ) at @xmath474 .
but in fact ( [ brstcomplexendpoint ] ) at @xmath474 is equivalent to ( [ brstcomplexendpoint ] ) at @xmath477 by rescaling of @xmath167 and @xmath168 . in other words ,
the map @xmath478 is the equivalence of the complex ( [ brstcomplexendpoint ] ) at @xmath474 and the same complex at @xmath477 .
there is a relation between the endpoint cohomology and the cohomology of the positive - frequency part of the loop algebra of @xmath479 .
consider the algebra formed by the positive frequency @xmath28-twisted loops with values in @xmath479 .
we will denote is @xmath480 .
the cohomology complex is generated by the ghosts @xmath481 , where @xmath482 and @xmath92 the enumerates the adjoint representation of @xmath479 .
we have @xmath483 , @xmath484 , @xmath485 , @xmath486}$ ] , @xmath487 , _ etc . _
the `` energy '' operator @xmath488 counts the lower indices , for example : @xmath489 } = -5 c_{-1}^{\alpha } c_{-4}^{[mn]}\ ] ] notice that @xmath488 is a symmetry of the cohomology complex .
another symmetry is the @xmath237-ghost number ( the number of letters @xmath237 ) .
let @xmath490 denote the cohomology group with @xmath491 and ghost number @xmath262 .
the first cohomology group @xmath492 is generated by @xmath493 ( and therefore has @xmath494 ) .
some of other nontrivial cohomology groups are : @xmath495 generally speaking , @xmath496 is generated by the expressions of the form : @xmath497 but @xmath496 is not all of the cohomology , for example there is nontrivial with the character of @xcite ] @xmath498 .
the pure spinor cohomology should be identified with the part of the @xmath480 cohomology with `` energy '' equal to minus the ghost number , _ i.e. _ @xmath496 .
in flat infinite space massless vertex operators have the form : @xmath499 where @xmath262 is some polynomial of @xmath169 and @xmath84 . we can write @xmath500 where @xmath501 therefore there is a generalization of ( [ vertexinflatspace ] ) : @xmath502 this generalization is only well defined in flat space on those worldsheets which do not have handles , or in toroidal compactifications with appropriate integrality conditions on @xmath503 and @xmath504 .
we can formally consider ( [ flatspacegeneralizedvertex ] ) , for example on an infinite worldsheet without handles , if we neglect boundary effects .
we will now argue that there is a partial analogue of ( [ flatspacegeneralizedvertex ] ) in @xmath0 .
given a state @xmath115 we can prepare a nonlocal @xmath11-dependent covariant vertex operator , in the following way .
consider the transfer matrix @xmath505 from infinity to the point @xmath506 on the worldsheet .
let us fix a vector @xmath507 , and consider : @xmath508 so defined @xmath509 is analogous to : @xmath510 in particular for @xmath474 we get @xmath511 and therefore : @xmath512 this formula gives us back the covariant vertex for the state @xmath86 if we identify : @xmath513 for any @xmath514 we define @xmath515 as a non - normalizable vector in the space of states , characterized by the formula : @xmath516 where @xmath517 is the hermitean scalar product in @xmath21 .
note that @xmath515 strictly speaking does not belong to @xmath21 because it is not normalizable .
for example , one dimensional quantum mechanics has @xmath518 the space of square integrable functions of one variable , with the norm @xmath519 .
the dual space @xmath44 is the space of generalized functions ; if @xmath514 is defined by the formula @xmath520 then @xmath515 is a delta - function @xmath521 . using these notations
we can define the two - point vertex operator : @xmath522 however , we conjecture that this 2-point vertex operator is in fact brst exact . indeed ,
although we have not checked it explicitly , it should be true that the derivative of @xmath523 with respect to @xmath524 is @xmath3-exact .
therefore , up to brst - exact terms this vertex is independent of @xmath524 and @xmath525 . on the other hand , when @xmath526 we get a local vertex operator of the ghost number 4 .
there is no @xmath20-invariant cohomology at the ghost number 4 .
this implies that ( [ twopointvertex ] ) is brst exact .
in this paper we introduced a family of @xmath11-dependent vertex operators ( [ zdependentvertex ] ) parametrized by a choice of the bps representation of @xmath20 .
schematically , these vertex operators have a form : @xmath527 \right ) \right|\psi^{\infty}\right\rangle\ ] ] this expression is strictly speaking not brst invariant , because of the boundary term at infinity .
indeed we have put @xmath528 an arbitrary vector from @xmath21 , and this is generally speaking not a valid plug .
we assume that we can neglect this boundary term because it is at infinity ] .
we can consider @xmath509 locally near the point @xmath506 .
notice that @xmath529 is a @xmath169-dependent vector in the dual space to @xmath21 .
( in fact @xmath529 depends on @xmath530 and @xmath531 through @xmath532 . ) we can also think of @xmath529 as an element of @xmath21 , but then we have to remember that it is not normalizable ; it is a @xmath533-function type of state , rather than a proper wave packet .
note that for a fixed @xmath169 , our @xmath534 is a _
fixed _ vector in @xmath44 . in other words , for every bps representation @xmath21 we have a map , which takes a pair of pure spinors and transforms them into a vector in the space of bps states : 0= @xmath535 it would be interesting to describe this map explicitly .
the non - normalizable vector in @xmath21 on the right hand side of ( [ frompstovectorinh ] ) is obviously not invariant under @xmath20 ( it belongs to an irreducible representation ) .
but it transforms covariantly under @xmath536 , in the sense that the action of @xmath319 on the right hand side of ( [ frompstovectorinh ] ) agrees with the action of @xmath319 on the left hand side of ( [ frompstovectorinh ] ) .
another way of thinking about @xmath537 is in terms of the cohomology of the operator : @xmath538 acting on the bps representation @xmath21 ( more precisely , the @xmath149-invariant tensor product of @xmath44 with the space of polynomials of @xmath447 ) .
our results imply that the second cohomology of this operator is nontrivial , represented by the cocycle ( [ frompstovectorinh ] ) .
notice that this provides a purely representation - theoretic characterization of the linearized sugra spectrum on @xmath0 .
indeed , the question of the existence of the excitation transforming in the representation @xmath21 is reduced to the calculation of the cohomology of the operator ( [ lambdatinconclusions ] ) , which is defined in terms of the generators @xmath539 of the representation @xmath21 .
there is also another example of a plug , a plug of the ghost number 1 .
consider the wilson line in the adjoint representation .
the cohomology of ( [ lambdatinconclusions ] ) in the adjoint representation is nontrivial and is represented by : @xmath540 this is obviously a @xmath169-dependent vector in the adjoint representation , of the ghost number @xmath541 .
one can verify that this is annihilated by ( [ lambdatinconclusions ] ) ; note the relative minus sign of the second term in ( [ adjointrepresentative ] ) .
therefore we can take ( [ adjointrepresentative ] ) as a plug , and consider : @xmath542 \right ) \psi^{(\infty ) } \right)\ ] ] at @xmath474 the corresponding integrated vertex operator is the density of the local conserved charge @xmath543 .
we will prove in appendix [ sec : ghostnumberone ] that ( [ adjointrepresentative ] ) is the only example of the endpoint cohomology at ghost number 1 .
in particular , there is no nontrivial cohomology for representations other than the adjoint . with these notations
the 2-point vertex ( [ twopointvertex ] ) reads : @xmath544 \right ) \right| \mbox{plug}(\tau_1^+,\tau_1 ^ - ) \right\rangle \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( but as we discussed at the end of section [ sec : twopoint ] this must be brst exact . )
i want to thank y. aisaka , n.j .
berkovits , v. serganova and b.c .
vallilo for many useful discussions .
this research was supported by the sherman fairchild fellowship and in part by the rfbr grant no .
06 - 02 - 17383 and in part by the russian grant for the support of the scientific schools nsh-8065.2006.2 .
part of this work was done during the workshop `` non - perturbative methods in strongly - coupled gauge theories '' , at the galileo galilei institute for theoretical physics in florence .
i would like to thank the organizers of this workshop for their hospitality .
another part of this work was done during the monsoon workshop in tifr , mumbai .
i want to thank the organizers and the staff members at tifr for their hospitality .
another part of this work was done during my stay at the ift so paulo ; i want to thank n.j .
berkovits for his hospitality .
another part of this work was done during the workshop `` fundamental aspects of superstring theory '' at kitp santa barbara ; i want to thank the organizers of the workshop for their hospitality .
in this section we will prove that the only cohomology at ghost number 1 are the global @xmath20 conserved charges .
the conserved charges are the descendants of the cohomology classes of the ghost number 1 .
the `` standard '' local conserved charges correspond to the global symmetries @xmath33 .
they descend from the following operator : @xmath545 in other words , we have the following cohomology class of the ghost number one in the adjoint representation of @xmath31 : @xmath546 in this section we will prove that there are no nontrivial cohomology classes of the ghost number 1 in representations other than the adjoint .
we will write a representative of the cohomology class in the following way : @xmath549 the condition of @xmath54-invariance says that @xmath550 and @xmath551 should define intertwining operators of @xmath54 : @xmath552 in other words : @xmath553 } v_{\alpha } = { f_{[\rho\sigma]\alpha}}^{\beta}v_{\beta } \label{firstcovariancecondition}\\ & & t^0_{[\rho\sigma ] } v_{\dot{\alpha } } = { f_{[\rho\sigma]\dot{\alpha}}}^{\dot{\beta } } v_{\dot{\beta } } \label{secondcovariancecondition}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the conditions of @xmath54-covariance .
the conditions for being annihilated by @xmath81 are : @xmath554 for example , the class ( [ adjointclass ] ) is represented by : @xmath555 we consider the solutions of ( [ conditionthatqannihilates ] ) trivial if they are of the form : @xmath556 where @xmath557}\phi=0 $ ] . _
theorem : _ nontrivial solutions to eqs .
( [ firstidentity ] [ thirdidentity ] ) exist only when @xmath547 is the adjoint representation of @xmath31 , and are given by ( [ onlysolution ] ) up to adding a trivial solution .
there are no other nontrivial solutions .
[ [ cohomology - classes - at - ghost - number-1-consequences - of - the - defining - equations ] ] cohomology classes at ghost number 1 : consequences of the defining equations ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ acting on ( [ firstidentity ] ) by @xmath558 we get : @xmath559 } t^0_{[\rho\sigma ] } v_{\beta } - t^3_{\alpha}t^1_{\dot{\beta}}v_{\beta } \right ) + ( \alpha\leftrightarrow\beta ) = { f_{\alpha\beta}}^{\mu } t^1_{\dot{\beta } } a_{\mu}\ ] ] this with eqs . ( [ firstcovariancecondition ] ) and ( [ thirdidentity ] ) implies : @xmath559 } { f_{[\rho\sigma]\beta}}^{\gamma } v_{\gamma } + ( \alpha\leftrightarrow\beta)\right ) + { f_{\alpha\beta}}^{\mu}t^2_{\mu } \tilde{v}_{\dot{\beta } } = { f_{\alpha\beta}}^{\mu}t^1_{\dot{\beta } } a_{\mu}\ ] ] this with the jacobi identity for @xmath560 implies : @xmath561 similarly we have : @xmath562 let us act on ( [ fv ] ) by @xmath563 : @xmath564 this and ( [ thirdidentity ] ) implies : @xmath565 let us denote : @xmath566 .
we have : @xmath567 } = 0\ ] ] note that the gauge transformation @xmath568 where @xmath74 is @xmath149-invariant leads to : @xmath569 therefore we should think of @xmath570 as an element of @xmath571 . but this cohomology group is zero because @xmath572 ( notice that the serre - hochschild spectral sequence for @xmath286 has @xmath573 and @xmath250 acts from @xmath574 to @xmath575 ) .
therefore we should be able to gauge away @xmath570 .
let us therefore assume : @xmath576 note that this equation and ( [ firstrelationofas ] ) implies : @xmath577 therefore we can rewrite ( [ fv ] ) and ( [ ftv ] ) as follows : @xmath578 let us define @xmath579 by the following equation : @xmath580 eq .
( [ antisymmetryoff ] ) implies that @xmath581 is antisymmetric : @xmath582 .
we get : @xmath583 } t^0_{[\rho\sigma ] } a_{\nu } + t^2_{\mu } t^2_{\lambda }
a_{\nu } = \nonumber \\ & = & { f_{\lambda [ \mu |}}^{[\rho\sigma ] } { f_{[\rho\sigma]|\nu]}}^{\kappa } a_{\kappa } - t^2_{[\mu } t^2_{\nu ] } a_{\lambda } = \nonumber \\ & = & -{1\over 2 } { f_{\mu\nu}}^{[\rho\sigma ] } { f_{[\rho\sigma]\lambda}}^{\kappa } a_{\kappa } - { 1\over 2 } { f_{\mu\nu}}^{[\rho\sigma ] } { f_{[\rho\sigma]\lambda}}^{\kappa } a_{\kappa } = \nonumber \\ & = & - { f_{\mu\nu}}^{[\rho\sigma ] } { f_{[\rho\sigma]\lambda}}^{\kappa } a_{\kappa } \label{t2onf}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this implies , first of all , that @xmath579 is zero when @xmath584 is tangent to @xmath25 and @xmath585 is tangent to @xmath114 .
therefore @xmath579 is completely encoded in terms of @xmath586}$ ] which is defined by this equation : @xmath587 } g_{[\rho\sigma]}\ ] ] eq .
( [ t2onf ] ) implies for @xmath588}$ ] : @xmath589 } = { f_{\lambda[\mu\nu]}}^{\kappa } a_{\kappa}\ ] ] this means that the linear space formed by @xmath590 and @xmath586}$ ] is closed under the action of @xmath302 , and is in fact the adjoint representation of @xmath302 ( where @xmath590 corresponds to @xmath591 and @xmath586}$ ] corresponds to @xmath592}$ ] ) .
this is already close to what we wanted to prove .
but we have to also tame the expressions of this form : @xmath593 } \;\ ; , \;\;\ ; etc.\ ] ] for this purpose , let us use ( [ firstfv ] ) and ( [ secondfv ] ) in this expression : @xmath594 on the other hand , the combination @xmath595 can be calculated using the @xmath54-invariance .
this implies : @xmath596 we will also use this : @xmath597 } t^0_{[\rho\sigma ] } t_{\delta}^3 a_{\nu } - { 1\over c } { f_{\mu}}^{\gamma\delta } t^3_{\gamma } t^1_{\dot{\alpha } } t^3_{\delta } a_{\nu } = \nonumber \\ & & = { 1\over c}(fff)(t^3 a ) \label{threestructureconstants}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here we used the schematic notation @xmath598 for a product of three structure constants with some indices contracted , and @xmath237 is determined from @xmath599 .
the subspace of @xmath547 generated by acting on @xmath5 and @xmath127 by finitely many @xmath600 and @xmath601 is finite - dimensional .
indeed , using ( [ reducea ] ) and ( [ threestructureconstants ] ) we can prove that it is generated as a linear space by expressions of the form : @xmath602 } a_{\mu}\;,\;\ ; t^3_{[\alpha_1 } \cdots t^3_{\alpha_k ] } a_{\mu } \;\;\ ; ( k\geq 0 ) \label{subspacegeneratorsa } \\ & \mbox{and } & g_{[\mu\nu ] } \label{subspacegeneratorsg}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the square brackets stand for the antisymmetrization of the indices ( for example @xmath603 } a_{\mu}$ ] stands for @xmath604 ) .
( [ reducea ] ) and ( [ threestructureconstants ] ) imply that this subspace is closed under the action of @xmath31 .
because @xmath547 is assumed to be irreducible , we conclude that @xmath547 is generated by ( [ subspacegeneratorsa]),([subspacegeneratorsg ] ) . because of the antisymmetrization of the indices of @xmath600 and @xmath601 there are only finitely many linearly independent expressions of the form ( [ subspacegeneratorsa ] ) .
this proves that @xmath547 is a finite - dimensional space .
_ one can see that for any element @xmath445 of @xmath190 ( _ i.e. _ a finite linear combination of expressions of the form ( [ subspacegeneratorsa ] ) ) there is a number @xmath262 such that for any @xmath609 and any @xmath610 elements @xmath611 of @xmath302 we get : @xmath612 indeed , let us consider for example acting by @xmath613 on expressions of the form @xmath614 } a_{\mu}$ ] .
let us define the degree of such an expression by the following formula : @xmath615 } a_{\mu } = \mbox{deg } t^1_{[\dot{\alpha}_1 } \cdots t^1_{\dot{\alpha}_k ] } a_{\mu } = k\ ] ] more precisely , we introduce a filtration of @xmath190 saying that @xmath616 consists of all the elements of @xmath21 which can be written as linear combinations of the expressions of the form ( [ subspacegeneratorsa ] ) of the degree less or equal @xmath617 .
using eqs .
( [ reducea ] ) and ( [ threestructureconstants ] ) we derive that for @xmath618 : @xmath619 this implies ( [ eventuallyreachl ] ) . because of the assumption that @xmath547 is completely reducible as a representation of @xmath302 , eq .
( [ eventuallyreachl ] ) implies that @xmath608 .
we conclude that @xmath547 is in fact generated by expressions ( [ smallsetofgenerators ] ) .
note that the linear space generated by ( [ smallsetofgenerators ] ) consists of the even subspace generated by @xmath590 and @xmath586}$ ] , and odd subspace generated by @xmath620 .
the even subspace is the same as in the adjoint representation .
therefore the odd space should be also the same .
we have argued that the subspace generated by ( [ subspacegeneratorsa ] ) in fact coincides with @xmath547 , based on @xmath547 being an irreducible representation of @xmath31 .
this requirement can be replaced with the requirement that @xmath621 .
suppose that ( [ subspacegeneratorsa ] ) generate a smaller subspace @xmath622 .
let us denote @xmath445 the projection of @xmath121 on @xmath623 : @xmath624 then ( [ secondidentity ] ) implies : @xmath625 these equations imply that @xmath626 actually form the spinor representation of @xmath302 : @xmath627 we will now explain , using ( [ geveninvariance1 ] ) and ( [ geveninvariance2 ] ) , that @xmath445 can be gauged away if @xmath628 . and this cohomology group vanishes if @xmath629 vanishes .
more generally , let us consider the subcomplex of the brst complex covariant under @xmath302 .
this means consider the chains which satisfy : @xmath630 on this complex the brst operator coincides with the lie cohomology @xmath81-operator in the relative complex @xmath631 .
the relative cohomology is related to @xmath632 by the serre - hochschild spectral sequence .
namely @xmath633 the differential @xmath634 acts from @xmath635 to @xmath636 . in particular : @xmath637 is related to @xmath638 .
@xmath639 this means that @xmath640 can not cancel with anything and therefore @xmath641 implies that @xmath642 .
therefore , if @xmath629 vanishes , then @xmath643 should also vanish .
a. mikhailov and s. schafer - nameki , _ algebra of transfer - matrices and yang - baxter equations on the string worldsheet in ads(5 ) x s(5 ) _ , _ nucl .
phys . _ * b802 * ( 2008 ) 139 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/0712.4278[0712.4278 ] ] .
v. v. bazhanov , s. l. lukyanov , and a. b. zamolodchikov , _ integrable structure of conformal field theory ii .
q- operator and ddv equation _ , _ commun .
_ * 190 * ( 1997 ) 247278 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/hep-th/9604044[hep-th/9604044 ] ] .
r. g. leigh and m. j. strassler , _ exactly marginal operators and duality in four - dimensional n=1 supersymmetric gauge theory _ , _ nucl .
* b447 * ( 1995 ) 95136 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/hep-th/9503121[hep-th/9503121 ] ] .
o. aharony , b. kol , and s. yankielowicz , _ on exactly marginal deformations of n = 4 sym and type iib supergravity on ads(5 ) x s**5 _ , _ jhep _ * 06 * ( 2002 ) 039 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/hep-th/0205090 [ hep - th/0205090 ] ] .
n. berkovits and p. s. howe , _ ten - dimensional supergravity constraints from the pure spinor formalism for the superstring _ , _ nucl .
_ * b635 * ( 2002 ) 75105 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/hep-th/0112160 [ hep - th/0112160 ] ] .
j. kinney , j. m. maldacena , s. minwalla , and s. raju , _ an index for 4 dimensional super conformal theories _ ,
* 275 * ( 2007 ) 209254 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/hep-th/0510251 [ hep - th/0510251 ] ] .
j. bhattacharya , s. bhattacharyya , s. minwalla , and s. raju , _
indices for superconformal field theories in 3,5 and 6 dimensions _ , _ jhep _ * 02 * ( 2008 ) 064 , [ http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/0801.1435[0801.1435 ] ] . | the worldsheet sigma - model of the superstring in @xmath0 has a one - parameter family of flat connections parametrized by the spectral parameter .
the corresponding wilson line is not brst invariant for an open contour , because the brst transformation leads to boundary terms .
these boundary terms define a cohomological complex associated to the endpoint of the contour .
we study the cohomology of this complex for wilson lines in some infinite - dimensional representations .
we find that for these representations the cohomology is nontrivial at the ghost number 2 .
this implies that it is possible to define a brst invariant open wilson line . the central point in the construction
is the existence of massless vertex operators transforming exactly covariantly under the action of the global symmetry group . in flat space massless vertices
transform covariantly up to adding brst exact terms , but in ads it is possible to define vertices so that they transform exactly covariantly .
calt-68 2722 * @xmath1 + @xmath1 + symmetries of massless vertex operators in @xmath0 * + + + |
owing to recent progress in nanotechnology and materials science , nano- and micro - mechanics @xcite have emerged as subjects of great interest due to their potential use in demonstrating macroscopic quantum phenomena , and possible applications in precision measurements , detecting gravitational waves , building filters , signal amplification , as well as switches and logic gates . in particular , on - chip single- or few - phonon devices are ideal candidates for hybrid quantum information processing , due to the ability of phonons to interact and rapidly switch between optical fields and microwave fields @xcite .
fabrication of high - frequency mechanical resonators @xcite , demonstration of coherent phonon coupling between nanomechanical resonators @xcite , ground - state cooling @xcite , optomechanics ( in microtoroids @xcite , microspheres @xcite , microdisks @xcite , microring @xcite , photonic crystals @xcite , doubly- or singly - clamped cantilevers @xcite , and membranes @xcite ) have opened new directions @xcite and provided new tools to control and manipulate phonons in on - chip devices .
one possible obstacle to further develop this field is the ability to control the flow of phonons , allowing transport in one direction but not the opposite direction @xcite , i.e. , nonreciprocal phonon transport .
there have been several attempts to fabricate nonreciprocal devices for phonons @xcite , but these are almost exclusively based on asymmetric linear structures which indeed can not break lorentz reciprocity : a static linear structure can not break reciprocity @xcite .
these proposed linear structures do obey the reflection - transmission reciprocity and thus can not be considered as phonon diodes " .
diode - like behavior was observed in these linear acoustic structures because the input - output channels were not properly switched @xcite .
nonreciprocal phonon transmission inevitably requires magneto - acoustic materials , strong nonlinearity , or a time - dependent modulation of the parameters of a structure .
although already demonstrated in optics @xcite , the time - dependent modulation of acoustic parameters of a phononic structure has not been probed yet .
magneto - acoustic materials require high magnetic fields to operate and have been studied @xcite ; however , a magnetic - free nonreciprocal device is critical for building on - chip and small - scale phononic processors and circuits .
nonlinearity - based nonreciprocity seems to be the most viable approach for creating micro- or nano - scale nonreciprocal devices for controlling and manipulating phonons .
recently , there have been several reports on nonlinear mechanical structures and materials @xcite
. however , the weak nonlinearity of those acoustic / phononic materials hinders progress in this direction due to the high input powers required to observe the nonlinear effects @xcite . in order to circumvent this problem , coupling a weakly nonlinear structure to an auxiliary system , such as a quantum bit @xcite , has been proposed to engineer effective giant mechanical nonlinearities . in order to achieve the required nonlinearity for nonreciprocal phonon transport and to study nonlinear phononics , here
we introduce a new method based on parity - time ( @xmath0 ) symmetry @xcite , which has attracted much attention recently due to their interesting and generally counter - intuitive physics @xcite . parity - time symmetry and its breaking ( broken @xmath0-phase ) have been demonstrated in various physical systems @xcite , such as optical waveguides @xcite , microcavities @xcite , and electrical circuits @xcite .
however , mechanical @xmath0-symmetric systems have only been considered quite recently @xcite . in our proposed mechanical @xmath0 symmetric system , a lossy mechanical resonator ( passive resonator ) which has a weak mechanical nonlinearity is coupled to a mechanical resonator with mechanical gain ( active resonator ) that balances the loss of the passive resonator .
the active resonator here works as a dynamical amplifier . in the vicinity of the @xmath0-phase transition
, the weak nonlinearity is first distributed between the mechanically - coupled resonators and then significantly enhanced due to the localization of the mechanical supermodes in the active resonator . in this way , the effective nonlinear kerr coefficient is increased by over three orders of magnitude .
this strong nonlinearity , localized in the active resonator , blocks the phonon transport from the active resonator to the lossy resonator but permits the transport in the opposite direction . for the experimental realization of the proposed nonlinearity - based phonon diode
, we provide a system in which a mechanical beam with weak mechanical nonlinearity is coupled to another mechanical beam with gain .
we show that this micro - scale system can be switched from a bidirectional transport regime to a unidirectional transport regime , and vice versa , by properly adjusting the detuning between the mechanical frequency of the resonators and the frequency of the driving phononic field , or by varying the amplitude of the input phononic field .
the system we consider here consists of two mechanical resonators , one of which has mechanical loss ( passive resonator ) and weak nonlinearity , and the other has mechanical gain ( active resonator ) but no nonlinearity ( see fig . [ fig of mechanical pt ] ) .
the mechanical coupling between the resonators is linear and it gives rise to the mechanical supermodes @xmath1 with complex eigenfrequencies @xmath2 given by @xmath3 here @xmath4 is the mechanical frequency of the solitary mechanical resonators ( i.e. , both resonators are degenerate ) , @xmath5 where @xmath6 and @xmath7 denote , respectively , the damping rate of the lossy mechanical resonator and the gain rate of the active mechanical resonator , and @xmath8 is the coupling strength between the mechanical modes . when @xmath9 , the system is in the @xmath0-symmetric regime , and the supermodes are non - degenerate with @xmath10 and have the same damping rate @xmath11 ( see figs . [ fig of amplifying mechanical nonlinearity]a and [ fig of amplifying mechanical nonlinearity]b ) . however , when @xmath12 , the system is in the broken-@xmath0-symmetric regime , the supermodes are frequency - degenerate with @xmath13 ( see figs .
[ fig of amplifying mechanical nonlinearity]a and [ fig of amplifying mechanical nonlinearity]b ) and have different damping rates @xmath14 at @xmath15 , the two supermodes are degenerate with the same damping rate , indicating a transition between the pt - symmetric regime and the broken - pt - symmetry regime .
this point is generally referred to as the @xmath0-transition point .
it is seen that the two supermodes will be lossless in the @xmath0-symmetric regime if the gain and loss are well - balanced , such that @xmath16 .
let us assume that the passive resonator is made from a nonlinear acoustic material @xcite with a small nonlinear kerr coefficient @xmath17 .
this nonlinearity mediates a cross - kerr interaction between the two mechanical supermodes , which leads to the effective nonlinear coefficients @xmath18 and @xmath19 , in the broken- and unbroken-@xmath0 regimes @xcite : @xmath20 clearly , the effective nonlinear coefficients are significantly enhanced in the vicinity of the phase transition point @xmath15 . moreover ,
if the gain and loss are well - balanced , i.e. , @xmath16 , the supermodes become almost lossless .
this observation is one of the key contributions of this paper .
namely , operating the system of two coupled mechanical resonators in the vicinity of the phase transition point will significantly enhance the existing very weak nonlinearity with an extremely small loss rate . using the parameter values of @xmath21 , @xmath22 , and @xmath23
, we show in fig .
[ fig of amplifying mechanical nonlinearity ] the evolution of the eigenfrequencies of the system and of the nonlinear coefficient as a function of @xmath24 .
the transition from the broken- to the unbroken-@xmath0 symmetric regime and vice versa , as the mechanical coupling strength is varied , is seen in fig .
[ fig of amplifying mechanical nonlinearity]a and [ fig of amplifying mechanical nonlinearity]b and it is reflected in the bifurcations of the supermode frequencies and damping rates .
moreover , the enhancement of the nonlinearity in the vicinity of the @xmath0-phase transition point is seen in fig .
[ fig of amplifying mechanical nonlinearity]c .
we find that the nonlinear coefficient is enhanced by more than three orders of magnitude in the vicinity of the transition point .
more interestingly , in the broken-@xmath0 regime , the mechanical energy of the coupled system is localized in the active resonator , which leads to a nonlinear mechanical mode with strong self - kerr nonlinearity localized in the active mechanical resonator .
this can be interpreted intuitively as follows .
the initial weak mechanical nonlinearity is transferred from the passive resonator to the active resonator and it is enhanced by field localization in the broken-@xmath0 regime . owing to the presence of the mechanical gain , the active resonator then enjoys an almost lossless mechanical mode with a giant nonlinearity ( see fig .
[ fig of nonlinearity transfer ] ) .
finally , we would like to consider how the mechanical nonlinearity will affect the @xmath0-symmetric structure of the system . generally speaking
, a strong nonlinearity will shift the transition point of a @xmath0-symmetric system or even destroy the @xmath0 symmetry of such a system @xcite .
however , in our case , we start from a system in which a gain resonator is coupled to a lossy resonator with very weak kerr nonlinearity , and thus we can omit the shift of the @xmath0-transition point induced by such a weak nonlinearity .
although we generate a strong nonlinearity in the vicinity of the @xmath0-transition point , this is an effective nonlinearity induced in the supermode picture and thus will not affect the supermodes and the @xmath0-transition point of the system .
here we investigate the effect of the enhanced mechanical nonlinearity on the phonon transport in the coupled system .
we find that the localized strong mechanical nonlinearity leads to unidirectional phonon transport from the passive resonator to the active resonator and blocks phonon transport in the opposite direction ( i.e. , phonon transport from the active to the passive resonator is prevented ) .
the transport is almost lossless due to the gain - loss balance of the system .
when this system is operated in the vicinity of the @xmath0-phase transition point , the unidirectional phonon transport is possible within a region given by @xcite @xmath25,\ ] ] where @xmath26 is the detuning between the input ( driving ) field frequency @xmath27 and the resonance frequency @xmath4 of the mechanical resonators .
additionally , in order to observe the unidirectional phonon transport , the amplitude of the input field should satisfy @xmath28,\ ] ] implying that the intensity of the input field required for unidirectional transport is inversely proportional to the strength of the mechanical nonlinearity @xmath18 .
since the strength of the mechanical nonlinearity can be enhanced by more than three orders of magnitude by breaking the @xmath0 symmetry , the threshold of the input - field intensity for observing unidirectional phonon transport can be decreased by at least three orders of magnitude , allowing a low - threshold phonon diode operation . to show unidirectional phonon transport in the broken-@xmath0 regime ,
let us first fix the amplitude of the input field and vary the detuning @xmath29 .
we compare the amplitude transmittance @xmath30 and @xmath31 the former , @xmath32 , denotes the transmission from the passive to the active resonator , that is , the system is driven by a phononic input field @xmath33 of frequency @xmath27 at the passive resonator side and the output @xmath34 is measured at the active resonator side .
however , the latter , @xmath35 , denotes the amplitude transmittance from the active resonator to the passive resonator when the system is driven by the field @xmath36 of frequency @xmath27 at the active resonator side and the output @xmath37 is measured at the passive side .
the nonlinearity in the system manifests as a bistability and hysteresis in the power transmittance , @xmath38 and @xmath39 obtained as the detuning @xmath29 is up - scanned from smaller to larger detuning and down - scanned from larger to smaller detuning ( see fig .
[ fig of unidirectional phonon transport]a ) .
we find that during the down - scan , both of the transmittances @xmath40 and @xmath41 stay at the lower branch with values close to zero until @xmath42 , after which they bifurcate from each other only slightly and then jump to the stable points at the upper branch of their respective trajectories ( see fig .
[ fig of unidirectional phonon transport]a ) .
further decreasing the detuning leads to an increase in @xmath40 , but a decrease in @xmath41 .
this implies that there is no unidirectional phonon transport with the parameter values used in the numerical simulations .
instead , when the detuning is below a critical value , the phonon transport is bidirectional ; whereas when it is above that critical value there is no phonon transport . during the up - scan , however , after a short stay on the stable state , i.e. , a regime in which there is no bistability and hysteresis in the transmittance , ( during which @xmath43 decreases and @xmath41 increases with growing detuning ) , both of the transmittances follow the upper branches of their trajectories , during which a linear increase in @xmath41 and a slow - rate decrease in @xmath43 are observed ( see fig .
[ fig of unidirectional phonon transport]a ) .
this behavior continues until @xmath44 for @xmath41 , where it jumps to the lower branch of its trajectory , and becomes zero as the detuning is increased ( see fig .
[ fig of unidirectional phonon transport]a ) .
this implies that phonon transport from the active mechanical resonator to the passive one is prevented if the detuning is set to @xmath45 .
the transmittance @xmath40 stays at its upper branch with a value close to one until @xmath46 , where it jumps to its lower branch and becomes zero .
thus , for @xmath47 , phonon transport from the passive to the active resonator is prevented .
clearly , in the detuning region @xmath48 , the transmittance @xmath40 is close to one whereas @xmath41 is close to zero in this detuning region phonon transport from the active mechanical resonator to the passive one is forbidden , whereas phonon transport from the passive mechanical resonator to active one is allowed with almost no loss .
thus , we conclude that phonon transmission is non - reciprocal in this detuning region , and the rectification is @xmath49 db within the nonreciprocal transport region ( see fig .
[ fig of unidirectional phonon transport]a ) . for detuning values smaller than the lower bound of this region
, phonon transport is bidirectional . for detuning values larger than the upper bound of the region ,
phonon transport is not possible .
note that our phonon diode should work only when the disturbance and perturbation of the system parameters are not too strong .
in fact , within the unidirectional phonon transport window shown in fig .
[ fig of unidirectional phonon transport]a , the transmittance @xmath40 has two different branches of metastable values .
when we increase the detuning @xmath29 within this unidirectional phonon transport window , @xmath40 will stay in the upper stable branch if we do not severely disturb the system and the phonon diode should operate properly .
however , if the disturbance is too strong , @xmath40 will jump from the upper branch to the lower branch and stay in this stable lower branch , without rectification .
alternatively , we can fix the detuning and vary the amplitude of the input field to show the nonlinearity - induced bistability and hysteresis .
a nonreciprocal phonon transport region is seen when the amplitude of the input field is up - scanned ( see fig .
[ fig of unidirectional phonon transport]b ) .
the nonreciprocal transport region disappears when the amplitude of the input field is down - scanned . within the nonreciprocal transport region , when the input is varied at fixed detuning ( see fig .
[ fig of unidirectional phonon transport]b ) , the rectification is @xmath49 db . similarly , in this case , due to the metastability of the transmittance @xmath40 , the disturbance - induced perturbation of the system parameters may not be too strong otherwise our design of phonon diode will be invalid .
the unidirectional phonon transport enabled by the @xmath0-breaking - induced strong mechanical nonlinearity can be used to fabricate lossless phonon diodes in on - chip systems .
this may have many applications , such as single - phonon transistors and routers , on - chip quantum switches , and information - processing components .
one possible way to realize the proposed phonon diode is to use coupled beams and cantilevers ( see fig .
[ fig of experimental setup]a ) .
phonon lasing , and hence an active mechanical resonator , has been experimentally realized in an electromechanical beam @xcite .
elastically - coupled nano beams and cantilevers , by which the mechanical supermodes can be generated , have also been shown in various experiments @xcite , in which the two mechanical resonators can be independently driven @xcite .
thus our proposal is within the reach of current experimental techniques of nano - micro - electromechanical systems .
let us now consider the design of the phonon diode system shown in fig .
[ fig of experimental setup ] in which a lossy vibrating beam with damping rate @xmath6 and a weak kerr nonlinearity @xcite of strength @xmath17 is elastically coupled to another vibrating beam with gain @xmath7 @xcite .
the frequencies of the two beams are both @xmath4 and the mechanical coupling strength is @xmath8 . in fig .
[ fig of the power spectrum ] , we present the numerical results performed with the system parameters : @xmath50 khz , @xmath51 khz , @xmath52 khz , @xmath53 khz , @xmath54 khz , and @xmath55 khz . here
, we fix the detuning @xmath29 and change the amplitude of the input field .
there is a @xmath56 db background noise which includes the combined effect of the thermal noise on the mechanical resonators , the electrical noises induced by the measurement apparatus and other possible sources of noise .
the results shown in fig . [ fig of the power spectrum ] for the phonon diode agree well with the general model discussed in the previous section .
when the amplitude of the input field is increased , it is clearly seen that there is a nonreciprocal region in which phonon transport from the active beam to the passive beam is almost completely suppressed ( see fig .
[ fig of the power spectrum]b(ii ) ) , but phonon transport from the passive beam to the active beam is allowed ( see fig . [ fig of the power spectrum]a(ii ) ) . a rectification ratio of about @xmath57 db is obtained . when the amplitude of the phonon excitation is larger than the upper bound of the unidirectional phonon transport region , the transport is bidirectional . in this case
, the phonons can freely move from the active beam to the passive beam and vice versa ( see figs .
[ fig of the power spectrum]a(i ) and [ fig of the power spectrum]b(i ) ) . finally , for amplitudes of the phonon excitation smaller than the lower bound of the region , no phonon transport can take place between the resonators ( see figs .
[ fig of the power spectrum]a(iii ) and [ fig of the power spectrum]b(iii ) ) .
these are the result of hysteresis ( see fig .
[ fig of unidirectional phonon transport]b ) caused by the strong mechanical nonlinearity .
we have proposed a method to generate ultra - strong mechanical nonlinearity with a very low - loss rate using a @xmath0-symmetric mechanical structure in which a mechanical resonator with gain but no nonlinearity is coupled to a lossy ( i.e. , passive mechanical loss and no gain ) mechanical resonator with very weak nonlinearity .
we have showed that the weak mechanical nonlinearity is redistributed in the supermodes of the coupled mechanical system and is enhanced ( by more than three orders of magnitude ) when the mechanical @xmath0 system enters the broken-@xmath0 regime . moreover , owing to the presence of the mechanical gain in one of the resonators to compensate the mechanical loss of the other resonator , the effective mechanical damping rate is decreased in the @xmath0-symmetric system .
using experimentally accessible parameter values , we identified the regimes where unidirectional phonon transport is possible from the passive to active resonator but not in the opposite direction .
we then proposed an experimentally - realizable system where a mechanical beam with passive loss and weak nonlinearity is coupled to another beam which acts like an active mechanical resonator .
a possible bottleneck for this design to achieve a phonon diode operated in ambient condition is whether the mechanical gain observed with the mechanical beams in a controlled environment and at low temperatures @xcite could also be obtained in ambient - temperature conditions .
a possible way to overcome this problem , and to realize phonon diodes in ambient conditions , is to use a hybrid system composed of a gain optomechanical resonator and an nonlinear electrically - driven mechanical beam @xcite , where the coupling between them is achieved via the evanescent optical field of the optomechanical resonator @xcite .
the mechanical gain of the optomechanical resonators can be provided at ambient conditions by , e.g. , the optomechanical dynamical instability in the blue detuning regime @xcite , which has been demonstrated in optomechanical resonators in various experiments @xcite . since creating strongly - nonlinear mechanical or acoustic materials remains challenging , we believe that the proposed system and the developed approach provide a suitable platform for investigating nonlinear phononics and can be used as a building block to design more complex hybrid optomechanical or electromechanical information processors .
we envision that @xmath0 mechanical systems will open a new route for designing functional phononic systems with nonreciprocal phonon responses .
+ * acknowledgments * jz is supported by the nsfc under grant nos .
61174084 , 61134008 .
yxl is supported by the nsfc under grant nos .
10975080 , 61025022 , 91321208 .
yxl and jz are supported by the national basic research program of china ( 973 program ) under grant no .
2014cb921401 , the tsinghua university initiative scientific research program , and the tsinghua national laboratory for information science and technology ( tnlist ) cross - discipline foundation . ly and sko
are supported by aro grant no .
w911nf-12 - 1 - 0026 and the nsfc under grant no . 61328502 .
is supported by the riken ithes project , muri center for dynamic magneto - optics via the afosr award number fa9550 - 14 - 1 - 0040 , and grant - in - aid for scientific research ( a ) . * author contributions * jz , bp , sko contributed equally to this work .
ly , fn , sko , yxl supervised the project .
in order to prove the enhancement of mechanical nonlinearity in the broken-@xmath0-symmetric regime , let us consider a system of two coupled mechanical resonators , in which one of the resonators has mechanical gain ( active resonator ) and thus a positive damping rate @xmath7 and the second mechanical resonator has a passive mechanical loss ( passive resonator ) with loss rate @xmath6 .
the resonators have the same mechanical frequency @xmath4 , and the annihilation operators for their mechanical modes are denoted as @xmath58 and @xmath59 , respectively , for the active and passive resonators .
moreover , the passive mechanical resonator has a weak mechanical kerr - nonlinearity denoted by @xmath17 .
the hamiltonian describing these coupled mechanical resonators can be written as @xmath60 where @xmath8 is the coupling strength between the mechanical modes of the resonators . generally , the nonlinear kerr term in eq .
( [ two coupled mechanical resonators ] ) will shift the boundary between the @xmath0 symmetric regime and the broken-@xmath0 regime . however , in our model , the kerr nonlinearity denoted by @xmath17 is very weak , and we can omit the nonlinearity - induced shift of this boundary . to find the boundary of @xmath0 transition , we consider the first three terms in eq .
( [ two coupled mechanical resonators ] ) @xmath61 which can be written as @xmath62 this hamiltonian can be diagonalized as @xmath63 where the transformation matrix @xmath64 is defined by @xmath65 \\
g_{mm } & \left[\left(\omega_--\omega_0\right)-i\left(\gamma_--\gamma_l\right)\right ] \\
\end{array}\right)}{\sqrt{\left(\omega_{\pm}-\omega_0\right)^2+\left(\gamma_{\pm}-\gamma_l\right)^2+g_{mm}^2}}.\ ] ] consequently , we have @xmath66 as the mechanical supermodes formed by the coupling of the resonators .
these supermodes @xmath1 are characterized by the eigenfrequencies @xmath67 and damping rates @xmath68 . for this mechanical @xmath0 symmetric system , there are two different regimes ( see fig .
[ fig of eigenfrequencies of the pt system ] ) : \(i ) @xmath0 symmetric regime where @xmath69 and the two supermodes @xmath70 and @xmath71 are nondegenerate in their resonance frequencies ( i.e. , real part of their complex eigenfrequencies ) given by @xmath72 the damping rates of the supermodes ( i.e. , linewidths of the resonances ; imaginary part of their complex eigenfrequencies ) are the same and equal to @xmath73 \(ii ) broken @xmath0-symmetry regime where @xmath74 the two supermodes @xmath70 and @xmath71 are degenerate in their resonance frequencies @xmath75 and their damping rates are different : @xmath76 now let us consider the nonlinear kerr term in eq .
( [ two coupled mechanical resonators ] ) . using eq .
( [ supermodes ] ) , we find @xmath77 by substituting the above equation into the last term on the right hand side of eq .
( [ two coupled mechanical resonators ] ) and dropping the non - resonant terms , we can rewrite the nonlinear kerr term of eq .
( [ two coupled mechanical resonators ] ) as @xmath78 the self - kerr terms @xmath79 and @xmath80 only lead to a frequency - shift of the two supermodes and thus are less important . the cross - kerr term @xmath81 is more important and leads to the redistribution of the nonlinear effect among the two supermodes . from eqs .
( [ condition for pt symmetry])-([damping rate in the pt symmetric regime ] ) , the nonlinear coefficient @xmath82 can be represented in the broken-@xmath0 regime as @xmath18 , and in the @xmath0 symmetric regime as @xmath19 @xmath83 as was observed in photonic experiments @xcite , in the broken-@xmath0 regime the two supermodes @xmath1 are degenerate and the field is localized in the gain resonator , and thus the field @xmath59 is much smaller than @xmath58 .
therefore , we can omit the terms related to @xmath59 in the expressions of the supermodes @xmath1 and we have @xmath84 subsequently , we find that the cross - kerr term given in eq .
( [ the cross - kerr term ] ) can induce a self - kerr effect in the gain resonator @xmath85 clearly , when @xmath86 ( in the vicinity of the spontaneous @xmath0-symmetry breaking point : the @xmath0-phase transition point ) , this self - kerr nonlinearity is greatly enhanced .
let us now present a detailed analysis for finding the unidirectional phonon transport region near the @xmath0-transition point . in this case , the gain - loss balance between the active resonator , with annihilation operator @xmath58 , and the passive resonator , with annihilation operator @xmath59 , decreases the effective damping rates of the two modes . in the vicinity of the @xmath0-phase transition point ( i.e. , @xmath87 ) , the effective damping rates of the two modes is given by @xmath88 .
the coupling between the two mechanical resonators also leads to the transfer of mechanical kerr nonlinearity from the passive resonator to the active resonator , and this mechanical nonlinearity is strongly enhanced near the @xmath0-transition point ( i.e. , @xmath87 ) .
hereafter , we will denote this enhanced mechanical kerr nonlinearity coefficient as @xmath18 .
let us first consider the phonon transport from the passive resonator to the active resonator . here
the phononic field in the passive resonator is generated via an phononic input field with strength @xmath89 and frequency @xmath27 . using the standard input - output formalism @xcite ,
the output field of the active mechanical resonator is found as @xmath90 , which shows that the output field is proportional to the intracavity field @xmath58 , if we omit the vacuum fluctuations in the input field .
thus the transmission from passive to active resonator is given by @xmath91 where @xmath92 represents the steady - state value of the intracavity phonon number in the active resonator .
from the steady - state solution of the equations of motion for the coupled mechanical resonator system , we find that @xmath92 satisfies @xmath93 where @xmath94 the algebraic equation ( [ stationary equation of ng ] ) has three or one root depending on the system parameters , and one of the roots is unstable if the algebraic equation ( [ stationary equation of ng ] ) has three roots . when we increase the detuning @xmath95 , such that @xmath96 or equivalently , @xmath97 the system enters the bistable regime .
in fact , when @xmath98 , the algebraic equation has three branches of solutions .
however , two branches of solutions disappear when @xmath99 ( see ref .
@xcite and the supplementary materials of ref .
@xcite ) . in this case , the transmittance of the photon transport @xmath100 changes suddenly from a high value to a low value . noting that @xmath101 near the @xmath0 breaking point , the critical detuning @xmath102 can be approximately estimated to be @xmath103 let us now consider the phonon transport from the active mechanical resonator to the passive one .
the driving field with strength @xmath89 and frequency @xmath27 is fed into the gain resonator in this case .
following the same discussion and approach as for the previous case , it can be shown that a bistability - induced phase transition occurs when the detuning @xmath95 satisfies @xmath104 or equivalently , @xmath105 near the @xmath0-breaking point , @xmath106 , and thus @xmath107 can be approximately estimated to be @xmath108 combing eqs .
( [ upper bound of the unidirectional phonon transport window ] ) and ( [ lower bound of the unidirectional phonon transport window ] ) , we find that when the detuning @xmath29 is within the following region @xmath109=\left[\frac{g_{mm}^2\omega_0}{\omega_0 ^ 2+\chi^2},\frac{g_{mm}^2}{\omega_0-\sqrt{3}\chi}\right],\ ] ] it is possible to observe the unidirectional phonon transport , i.e. , the phonon transport from the passive resonator to the active resonator is allowed , whereas the phonon transport from the active resonator to the passive resonator is blocked
. figure .
[ fig of unidirectional phonon transport window]a shows the transmittance functions @xmath110 and @xmath111 as a function of the detuning @xmath29 .
it is ( as explained in the main text ) clear that there is a unidirectional phonon transport region when the detuning is up - scanned from smaller to larger detuning .
we also show in fig .
[ fig of unidirectional phonon transport window]b the rectification ratios for up - scanning and down - scanning the detuning @xmath29 .
similar to our previous discussions , a non - reciprocal region can be observed for the up - scanning process , while it disappears for the down - scanning process , and a high rectification - ratio , larger than @xmath57 db , can be obtained within the nonreciprocal region . up to this point , we do not consider the amplitude of the input field .
let us assume that the detuning @xmath29 is fixed and is within the detuning region given by eq .
( [ unidirectional phonon transport window ] ) .
we then vary the amplitude of the input field to show the bistability and the hysteresis in the transmittance functions .
let us first assume that @xmath112 .
if we consider the phonon transport from the passive resonator to the active resonator , we can obtain an algebraic equation similar to that given in eq .
( [ stationary equation of ng ] ) .
the bistable transition point corresponds to the stationary points of the function @xmath113 by setting @xmath114 , the stationary point of @xmath115 can be found as @xmath116\left(3\tilde{\mu}^2\right)^{-1}.\ ] ] the upper bound of the unidirectional phonon transport region is given by @xmath117.\end{aligned}\ ] ] near the @xmath0-transition point , we have @xmath118 , and thus it can be approximately estimated that @xmath119 let us now consider the case of phonon transport from the active resonator to the passive resonator when the amplitude of the input field is varied and the detuning is kept fixed . in this case , we obtain @xmath120 where @xmath121 similar to eq .
( [ function for the upper bound of the input intensity window ] ) , the bistable transition point can be found by calculating the stationary points of the function @xmath122 which leads to @xmath123\left(3\tilde{\tilde{\mu}}^2\right)^{-1}.\ ] ] the lower bound of the unidirectional phonon transport region is then given by @xmath124.\end{aligned}\ ] ] near the @xmath0-transition point , we have @xmath118 , and it can be approximately estimated that @xmath125 we thus conclude that nonreciprocal phonon transport takes place if the amplitude of the input is within the region @xmath126.\ ] ] similarly , when @xmath127 , the nonreciprocal region for the amplitude of the input field can be written as @xmath128.\ ] ] in fig .
[ fig of unidirectional phonon transport window]c , we present the transmittances as a function of the amplitude of the input field when the detuning is kept fixed within the unidirectional transport region given in eq . ( [ unidirectional phonon transport window ] ) .
we see that the lower stable branches of the bistable curves shown in fig .
[ fig of unidirectional phonon transport window]c ( the parts of the bistable curves before the bistable transitions occur ) increase when we increase the intensity of the input field .
this decreases the rectification , as shown in fig .
[ fig of unidirectional phonon transport window]d .
in order to check the performance of the proposed system as an isolator for phonons , we study the system considering that phonons are injected in the system in both directions , that is simultaneously at the passive and active resonator sides .
if the system exhibits unidirectional phonon transport under this condition , then the proposed system can be used as an isolator .
the equations of motion of the system for this case can be written as @xmath129 where the last terms on the right - hand - sides of eq .
( [ dynamical equation for phonon isolator ] ) denote the input fields .
the steady - state solution of eq .
( [ dynamical equation for phonon isolator ] ) leads to @xmath130 where @xmath131 let us first fix @xmath132 , and vary the detuning @xmath133 . in this case
, the bistable transitions for both directions occur when the detuning @xmath29 satisfies @xmath134 when the detuning is up - scanned from smaller to larger detuning values , the bistable transition occurs for @xmath135 when the detuning @xmath29 is down - scanned from larger to smaller detuning values , the bistable transition occur at @xmath136 the transmittances presented in fig .
[ fig of bistable curves for phonon isolator]a clearly show the bistable operation . a close look at fig .
[ fig of bistable curves for phonon isolator]a reveals that the transition from the bistable region to the stable trajectories takes place at the same points for both directions .
we can not find a detuning region within which transport in one direction is allowed and the transport in the other direction is prevented .
thus , we conclude that when phonons are injected simultaneously at both input ports , we can not see a unidirectional operation .
consequently , it is impossible to use this system as an isolator for phonons .
let us now fix @xmath137 , @xmath138 , @xmath139 , and vary @xmath140 , to check the possibility of providing a phonon isolator .
the bistable transition point is just the stationary points of the function @xmath141 by setting @xmath142 , we find @xmath143\left(3\bar{\mu}^2\right)^{-1},\\ \bar{n}_{g2}^*&=&\left[2\bar{\mu}\bar{\omega}-\sqrt{4\bar{\mu}^2\bar{\omega}^2 - 3\bar{\mu}^2\left(\bar{\gamma}^2+\bar{\omega}^2\right)}\right]\left(3\bar{\mu}^2\right)^{-1},\end{aligned}\ ] ] the bistable transition occurs at latexmath:[\[\label{input intensity for up - scan } when the amplitude of the input field @xmath89 is up - scanned and for @xmath145 ) .
for this case too , we do not see a unidirectional phonon transport region if we feed the inputs at the active and passive resonators sides simultaneously .
thus we conclude that although the proposed system can be used as phonon diode allowing nonreciprocal phonon transport , it can not function as an isolator for phonons .
r. w. andrews , r. w. peterson , t. p. purdy , k. cicak , r. w. simmonds , c. a. regal , and k. w. lehnert , _ bidirectidonal and efficient conversion between microwave and optical light _ , nature phys . * 10 * , 321 - 326 ( 2014 ) .
a. d. oconnell , m. hofheinz , m. ansmann , r. c. bialczak , m. lenander , e. lucero , m. neeley , d. sank , h. wang , m. weides , and j. wenner , j. m. martinis , and a. n. cleland , _ quantum ground state and single - phonon control of a mechanical resonator _ , nature * 464 * , 697 - 703 ( 2010 ) .
q. lin , j. rosenberg , d. chang , r. camacho , m. eichenfield , k. j. vahala , and o. painter , _ coherent mixing of mechanical excitations in nano - optomechanical structures _ , nat .
photon . * 4 * , 236 - 242 ( 2010 ) .
j. chan , t. p. mayer alegre , a. h. safavi - naeini , j. t. hill , a. krause , s. grblacher , m. aspelmeyer , and o. painter , _ laser cooling of a nanomechanical oscillator into its quantum ground state _
, nature * 478 * , 89 - 92 ( 2011 ) . j. d. teufel , t. donner , d. li , j. w. harlow , m. s. allman , k. cicak , a. j. sirois , j. d. whittaker , k. w. lehnert , and r. w. simmonds , _ sideband cooling of micromechanical motion to the quantum ground state _ ,
nature * 475 * , 359 - 363 ( 2011 ) .
t. carmon , h. rokhsari , l. yang , t. j. kippenberg , and k. j. vahala , _ temporal behavior of radiation - pressure - induced vibrations of an optical microcavity phonon mode _
lett . * 94 * , 223902 ( 2005 ) .
j. d. thompson , b. m. zwickl , a. m. jayich , f. marquardt , s. m. girvin , and j.g.e .
harris , _ strong dispersive coupling of a high - finesse cavity to a micromechanical membrane _ , nature * 452 * , 72 - 75 ( 2008 ) .
z. lin , h. ramezani , t. eichelkraut , t. kottos , h. cao , and d. n. christodoulides , _ unidirectional invisibility induced by @xmath0-symmetric periodic structures _ , phys .
lett . * 106 * , 213901 ( 2011 ) .
a. guo , g. j. salamo , d. duchesne , r. morandotti , m. volatier - ravat , v. aimez , g. a. siviloglou , and d n. christodoulides , _ observation of @xmath0-symmetry breaking in complex optical potentials _ , phys .
lett . * 103 * , 093902 ( 2009 ) .
l. feng , y .- l .
xu , w. s. fegadolli , m .- h .
lu , j.e.b .
oliveira , v. r. almeida , y .- f .
chen , and a. scherer , _ experimental demonstration of a unidirectional reflectionless parity - time metamaterial at optical frequencies _
, nature mater .
* 12 * , 108 - 113 ( 2012 ) .
s. bittner , b. dietz , u. gnther , h. l. harney , m. miski - oglu , a. richter , and f. schfer , _ @xmath0 symmetry and spontaneous symmetry breaking in a microwave billiard _ , phys .
lett . * 108 * , 024101 ( 2012 ) .
n. bender , s. factor , j. d. bodyfelt , h. ramezani , d. n. christodoulides , f. m. ellis , and t. kottos , _ observation of asymmetric transport in structures with active nonlinearities _ , phys .
* 10 * , 234101 ( 2013 ) .
b. peng , s. k. ozdemir , f. c. lei , f. monifi , m. gianfreda , g. l. long , s. h. fan , f. nori , c. m. bender , and l. yang , _ parity - time - symmetric whispering - gallery microcavities _ , nature phys . * 10 * , 394 - 398 ( 2014 ) .
l. chang , x. jiang , s. hua , c. yang , j. wen , l. jiang , g. li , g. wang , and m. xiao , _ parity - time symmetry and variable optical isolation in active - passive - coupled microresonators _ , nature photon . * 8 * , 524 - 529 ( 2014 ) .
e. gil - santos , d. ramos , a. jana , m. calleja , a. raman , and j. tamayo , _ mass sensing based on deterministic and stochastic responses of elastically coupled nanocantilevers _ , nano lett .
* 9 * , 4122 - 4127 ( 2009 ) .
g. anetsberger , o. arcizet , q. p. unterreithmeier , r. riviere , a. schliesser , e. m. weig , j. p. kotthaus , and t. j. kippenberg , _ near - field cavity optomechanics with nanomechanical oscillators _ , nature phys .
* 5 * , 909 - 914 ( 2009 ) . | nonreciprocal devices that permit wave transmission in only one direction are indispensible in many fields of science including , e.g. , electronics , optics , acoustics , and thermodynamics .
manipulating phonons using such nonreciprocal devices may have a range of applications such as phonon diodes , transistors , switches , etc .
one way of achieving nonreciprocal phononic devices is to use materials with strong nonlinear response to phonons .
however , it is not easy to obtain the required strong mechanical nonlinearity , especially for few - phonon situations . here , we present a general mechanism to amplify nonlinearity using @xmath0-symmetric structures , and show that an on - chip micro - scale phonon diode can be fabricated using a @xmath0-symmetric mechanical system , in which a lossy mechanical - resonator with very weak mechanical nonlinearity is coupled to a mechanical resonator with mechanical gain but no mechanical nonlinearity .
when this coupled system transits from the @xmath0-symmetric regime to the broken-@xmath0-symmetric regime , the mechanical nonlinearity is transferred from the lossy resonator to the one with gain , and the effective nonlinearity of the system is significantly enhanced .
this enhanced mechanical nonlinearity is almost lossless because of the gain - loss balance induced by the @xmath0-symmetric structure .
such an enhanced lossless mechanical nonlinearity is then used to control the direction of phonon propagation , and can greatly decrease ( by over three orders of magnitude ) the threshold of the input - field intensity necessary to observe the unidirectional phonon transport .
we propose an experimentally realizable lossless low - threshold phonon diode of this type .
our study opens up new perspectives for constructing on - chip few - phonon devices and hybrid phonon - photon components . |
Subsets and Splits